Luminescence in Crystals D. CURIE Professor ill the Faculty of Sciences, Paris Translated by
G. F. J. GARLICK University of Hull
Professor of Physics,
LONDON: NEW YORK:
METHUEN & CO LTD JOHN WILEY
& SONS INC
LUMINESCENCE CRISTALLINE This
in 1960 by Dunod of Paris
translation,
©
1960 by Dunod
incorporating
was
first published
later revisions by the
and translator, first published in 1963
1963 by Methuen and Co Ltd Printed in Great Britain by Butler and Tanner Ltd Frame and Lon don
©
Catalogue No (Methuen) 2/2578/11
author
Contents
PREFA CE
I
2 3 4
page xi
INTR O D U CTI O N
Luminescence Fluorescence and phosphorescence Relation between life time and fluorescence efficiency Centres and traps in the different classes of phosphorescent solids CHA P T ER I
DIPOLE A N D QUADRUPOLE R ADIATION: TIES OF EMISSION AND ABSORPTION I. Dipole and Quadrupole Moments
1 3 5
PROBABILI-
Electrostatic potential due to a charge distribution 2 Potentials due to dipoles and quadrupoles 3 Developmen t of potential due to a multipole in spherical harmonics
1
10
II 11
12
14
Maxwell's equations Solution of Maxwell's equations by the retarded potential method 3 Systems in harmonic vibration 4 Potential distribution among successive multipole orders
21
1
21
1
II. Dipole and Quadrupole Radiation in Electromagnetism
2
The Hamiltonian of the particle The transition probability 3 Magnetic dipole and electric quadrupole radiation 4 Selection rules
ID. Probabilities of Radiative Absorption and Emission
2
V
14 14 15
16 17
22
25
25
vi
Contents
CHAPTER
II
SPECT RA AND THE CON ( EXAMPLE OF ALKALI HALIDES ) page 31
EMISSION AND ABSORPTION
FIGURATIONAL COORDINATE MODEL
THALLIUM
ACTIVATED
I. Structure of a 'Non-photoconducting' Luminescent
Solid: KCl(Tl)
2 3
Energy leve l s in
t he matrix lattice of KC! Energy levels of the fre e thallium ion L oca t i o n of t h e g rou n d state 1S0 of TJ+ in the energyband schem e of KC! II. Absorption and Emission Phenomena in KCl(Tl),
the
2 3
Configurational Coordinate Diagram
Introduction to the m odel The inte racti o n between T!+ and ClPositi o n of the absorption and emission band maxima HI. Calculation of Emission and Absorption Spectra from the Configurational Coordinate Model
I 2 3 4
Stat e ment of
the problem Ca l culati o n of energy distribution in the sp ectrum Calculation usin g a semi-classical app ro xi matio n Quantum-mechanical calcul at i o n fo r the case w h e re th e ion vibr a t ion s v, a nd 1'u are e qua l
32 32
33 35
36 36
37
41
44 44 45 47 53
CHAPTER Ill EXPERIMENTAL
DETERMINATI O N AN D
USE Of CON-
59 59
FIGURATIONAL COORDINATE DIAGRAMS
2 3
Tun gs ta tes , will e m ites , halophosphates, &c. Rel ation between F centre a bsorpti on bands and luminescence emission ascribed to F centres
the
The Smakula formula
CHAPTER
2
I. The 'Momentum' Selection Rule and its Consequences Conservation of m om en tum in optical transitions from band to band Discussion
68
IV
OPTICAL TRANSITIONS I N A PHOTOCONDUCTING
CRYSTAL
63
76 77 77
78
Contents
11. Luminescence Emission near to the Absorption Edge {'Edge Emission') page
S pectra for electron-positive hole recombination in
2 I
2 3
4 5
germanium Spectra of the Ewles-Kroger type
Ill. Absorption Spectra and Exciton Emission
The experimental evidence Theoretical aspects Model for the electron in orbit around a hole; hyd rogenlike spectra Deviations from the hydrogenlike formula Stark and Zeeman effects for the exciton CHAPTER
1 2 3
V
LUMINES CENCE CENTRES IN P HOS P HORESCENT SULP HIDES I. Constitution of Phosphorescent Sulphides Preparation Numerical values of the energy-band gap for phosphors of the ZnS type Observations on the nature of binding in ZnS 11. Luminescence Centres and Emission Spectra for ZnS and CdS
1
2 3 4
Copper as an activator Silver and gold as activators Rad iative recombination due to vacancies Manganese as an activator
Ill. Optical Transitions involving Localized Levels
Luminescence centres and electron traps in a photoconducting crystal phosphor 2 Various types of centres in photoconducting phosphors CHAPTER
VI
E LECTRON TR A PS, P H OSP H O RESCEN C E , THER MOLUMINESCENCE
vii
84 84 86 90 90 91
92 95 96
107 107 107 108 1I 1 113 114 119
120 121 125 125
127
142
I. Definition of Traps. Mean Life Times, Effective I
2
Cross-sections
Definitions Thermal activation of trapped electrons
142 142 143
Vlll
3
4
2
3
Contents
of Williams and Eyrin g page 146 escape probability and the effective capture cross-section of the trap 146 II. Decay of Luminescence 147 Monomolecular and bimolecular mechanisms 147 Kinetics of p h o s p h o rescen ce i n photoconducting
Therm o d yna mic expression Relation between t he
Investig at ion s of trap distri butions by analysis of
ex peri m en tal d ecay cu rve s Ill. The Method of Thermoluminescence Curves
2
Description of the method Simpl e theory of the thermolumincscence
3
Thermoluminescence curve measurements
4
150
phosphors
Randall a n d Wilkins
curve due
156 160
to
using two
different war mi ng rate s
Observations on thermoluminescence e qu a ti o n s IV. Data on Electron Traps in Various Phosphors 1 ZnS(Cu) p ho s pho rs 2 CdS phosph o r s 3 CaS(Bi) ph o spho rs 4 KCI(Tl) phosphors 5 Thermoluminescence of alkali halides with col ou r centres
160 161
163
163
165 165
170 171 171 173
CHAPTER V I I THERMAL AND OPTICAL ACT! VATION OF ELECTRONS: QUENCHING EFFECTS
TRAPPED
I. Traps, Thermal Activation and Optical Stimulation in the Configurational Coordinate Model D esc ripti o n of the escape from t ra p s 2 O p t i cal activation energies 3 Description of e ffec t s shown by the highly s timulable alkaline earth sul ph id es 4 S timulat i on and q uenching spectra of zinc a n d c a d m i um sulphides
190 190 190
192 195
198
IX
Contents
II. Non-radiative Capture by Impurity-states, Thermal and Optical Quenching of Luminescence
1 2
Non-radiative captu re by traps Thermal quenching of luminescence Ill. The Theory of Multiphonon Transitions CHA P TER V I I I ENERGY TRANSFER, SENSITIZATION CENTRATION QUENCHING
page 202
AND CON-
I. Resonance Transfer between Atoms with Overlapping
Electric Fields
202 203 208
220 221
11. Other types of energy transfer without charge displacement
1
2 1
2
Reabsorption of emitted light Transfer by electronic exchange between neighbouring atoms m. Energy Transfer by Hole Migration
Riehl's excitation mechanism The Schon- Klasens theory of energy transfer between two centres IV. Energy Transfer by Exciton Migration
224
224 225 226
226 227 229
C H A P T E R IX ELECTROL UMINESCENCE AND ELECTROPHOTOL UMINESCENCE I. 'Pure' or 'Intrinsic' Electroluminescence 1 Introduction: Historical. The electroluminescent cell 2 Discussion of the electroluminescence mechanism 11. Electroluminescence due to Charge Carrier Injection Electroluminescence in single crystals or thin films of zinc sulphide 2 Electroluminescence of cadmium sulphide 3 Electroluminescence of silicon carbide 4 Luminescence in electrolysis 5 Infra-red electrolu minescence in germanium 6 Other investigation s
2 37 237 237 248 256
258 259 259 26 I 262 265
X
Contents
2
1
3
4
5
Ill. Electrophotoluminescence page Pohl effect Permanent quenchin g of luminescence in Zn S ( Cu) by electric fields Permanent enhancement of l u m inescence by electric fi elds Photoelectroluminescence Application of electroluminescence in the development of The Gudden and
image amplifiers
CHAPTER
2 3
I. Cathodoluminescence
Introduction
274
288
295 298
301
Characteristics of the main crystalline scintilla tors of res p onse Size of the excitation channel, density of ionization and refilling of electron traps IV. Radiation Damage in Phosphorescent Solids Appendix I. Phosphors for monochrome and colour Linearity
television
Appendix II. Rel at io n between photometric
288
291
Historical
4
269
272
the excita-
tion process
3
267
288
The general laws of cathodoluminescence Penetration of fast electrons into matter and 11. X-ray Excitation of Phosphors Ill. Radioluminescence - Scintillations
2
265
X
C A T H O D OLUMI NES CEN C E , RA DIOLUMINES C E N C E , S C INTIL L A TIONS. EFFE CTS OF HIGH-ENE R GY R A DIATION ON PHOSPHORESCENT SOLIDS
1
265
units of
301
302
304 307 308
314
luminescence
319
GENERA L BIBLIOGRAPHY
325
SUBJECT INDEX
329
Preface This book contains the main topics developed by the author in his lectures given in the Faculty of Science of the University of Paris.
The treatment is mainly theoretical, though attention is given to the more important applications of luminescent processes, for instance, phosphors for fluorescent lamps, X-ray screens and television tubes. This English edition is for the main part a translation of a book entitled Luminescence Cristalline, published by Dunod. Many ad ditions have been incorporated, the most important being the extra chapters on electroluminescence and cathodoluminescence processes. Unfortunately the manuscript was written just before the advent of Lasers and so it has only been possible to include a few preliminary references on this item. However, a short discussion on the lumin escence of ruby is included . Professor G. F. J. Garlick has undertaken the translation and no one could be better qualified. My thanks are due to him for the trans lation and for many interesting discussions on the topics of the book. Professor Garlick, who acted as an impartial translator, is not responsible for my errors.
MARCH
D. CURIE
1962
xi
Introduction
Under the general term luminescence we include luminous em iss i o n not purely thermal in origin. Accord i ng to the mode of excitation we d istinguish : - photoluminescence pro duced by absorption of light (or usually ultra-violet radiation). -luminescence excited by accelerated partic l es (cathodolumines cence if electrons are used) or more generally by high energy radia tion- X-rays or y-rays as well as particles such as (f. and fJ particles, protons, fission fragments, &c. (radioluminescence). In effect, all these emissions are due to excitation by the secondary electrons produced. If the i ndivi dual emissions due to single particles are consid ered these are known as scintillations and are used in the detection of the s pecific particles or quanta. - electroluminescence produced by the application of an electric field. - the phenomeno n of triboluminescence, radiation being emitted by a substance subject to mechanical forces, e.g. grinding of sugar in a mortar; frictio n produces electrical charges and either d i scharges occur in the body of the material or s omething like electrolumines cence occurs. - chemiluminescence and bioluminescence in which emission accom panies a chemical reaction (oxidation of phosphorus in a humid atmosphere); or a bi o logi cal pr o cess (glo w worm: oxidatio n of luciferin). The foll o wi n g text is confined to lum i nescence in crys ta l s exclud in g the last group of phenomena above as well as luminescence in gases, vapours, and organic l iquids or solution s 1. Luminescence
which is
.
Fig. l shows a typical energy-level scheme used i n luminescence: the emitting system is raised by excitation from the ground state f to the excited state e; return to the ground state occurs with emission of 2. Fluorescence and phosphorescence
1
2
Luminescence in Crystals
light. The emission occurs at a time t a ft er excitation, t b ei n g the life time of t h e excited st ate and being of the ord e r of I o-s sec for atomic d ipole emission; it is of t he order of IO-.; sec in phosphorescent sulp h i d es of the ZnS(C u) typ e . In practice, the main concern is with visible emission, but for some years studies have been made of luminescence A bsorplian Emrssron in the ultra violet and in the infra red . Such an energy scheme applies equally well toX-rays and y-rays; hence we speak of X-ray or y-ray fluorescence. However, Fig. I some phenomena of radiation emission (e.g. brehmsstrahlung, Cerenkov r adiatio n ) cannot be described by a diagram of the type in Fig. 1. For fluorescence the system m us t remain in the excited state fo r a time t, large compared with the frequency of the emitted radiation 01avi !ov), and this is not so for suc h emissions. The question of their inclusion amongst lu minescen ce phenomena has been d i sc us se d , but it i s more usual to group them in another category with such phenomena as Rayleigh sca tte ring and the Raman effect. Fig. 1 is descriptive o ffluorescence, the return to the ground state occu rri ng by spontaneous emission. Fig. 2, which includes a meta stable level m (trap or t rapp ing state), represents the case for phos phorescence. The system on excitation to the state e c an make a transition to the state m, which being by definition metastable d oes not allow of further transition m __, f e Thus the system will not change from E 1 the s tate m unless it receives an energy E lifting it again to the excited state e. Emission Then phosphorescence occurs (if there Absorption is no re tur n to the state m, i.e. recap-
ture into the trap) usually identical in emission with fluorescence (although Fig. 2 the relative intensities of the various emission bands may be different), but d e lay ed in time by an a mo u n t r equal to the time spent i n the s tate m. If the energy E (us ual l y called the trap de pth) is provided by a thermal activation, then in gen eral :
�
=
sexp
(ii)
Introduction
3
where r � t, s is a constant, k is Boltzmann's constant, and T is the absolute temperature. Definition due t o J. and F.
Perrin
'The phenomenon is fluorescence if the emission takes place by one or more spontaneous transitions. 'If, on the contrary, the emission occurs with the intervention of a metastable state followed by return to the excited state due to addi tion of energy, then this is phosphorescence.' A luminescence emission with a life time of about 10-s sec is indis putably fluorescence. In contrast, an effect where emission persists for the order of a second, or a longer duration, after excitation ends is almost always phosphorescence. However, in the intermediate time range, say I0-1 to I0-5 sec, it is difficult to decide between a long fluorescence (forbidden transition) and a short phosphorescence (due to very shallow traps). A study of the variation of the luminescence decay with tempera ture enables the distinction to be made. The decay of fluorescence is little dependent on the temperature, but the duration of phosphores cence is strongly temperature-dependent (determined by a Boltzmann function). The emission during excitation is often defined as fluorescence, but this is wrong in the case of a phosphorescent solid since at least a part of the emission is phosphorescence. In the case of zinc sulphides it is not certain that all electrons spend a short time in shallow traps. The activation energy E for escape from the traps is usually pro vided by the thermal agitation of the environment ; hence the occur rence of the Boltzmann function. However, it can also be provided by absorption of an incident photon of sufficient energy, this being known as optical stimulation. A burst of light is obtained when a previously excited phosphorescent solid is irradiated by light of longer wavelength than that of the excitation (usually infra-red irradiation). Relation between life time� and fluorescence efficiency 1} (F. Perrin)
Under certain conditions the life time 7: for the fluorescence shows an appreciable dependence on temperature, the decrease in life time being accompanied by an associated fall in the fluorescence efficiency rJ (see Fig. 3).
3.
4
Luminescence in Crystals
The fluorescence of uranyl salts (002)2+ is due to a transition in the life time being of the order of I0-3 sec for the non-perturbed free ion. In these brilliantly t fluorescent salts, e.g. uranyl nitrate, the life time i � I0-3 sec is usually found to depend very little on temperature and the quantum yield of fluorescence is of the order of 100 per cent. In contrast in other salts such as RbU02(CH3C02)3, i is much smaller and I j, temperature-dependent. i At 4°K i � 1780 f.£Sec, at 293°K i � 57 ,asec and the efficiency is very small (Hall and Dieke). This effect is, however, never of I .. ; the same order as those observed in phos 0 T phorescence for the trapping life times. For Fig. 3 the traps giving the visible phosphorescence of zinc sulphide (ZnS-Cu) wi t h E = 0·65 eV and s � 109 sec-I, the trapping occurs for 3 min at ordinary temperatures and for 1,600 days at -l00°C and i � 10800 sec at 4°K, if it is sensible to extra polate a formula to such proportions. The explanation lies in a competition between radiative transitions with a probability Pr depending little on temperature and non-radia tive transitions ('de-excitation' of the material by thennal a gitatio n ) having a probablity Pnr increasing with temperature. The normal life time of the fluorescence will be 1/pr, but the ob served life time is given by the uranyl group,
i-:�1 I I
I
-�-
�
---·
__ ···--·
- -·
":t 1
=
Pr+Pnr
If there are no non-radiative transitions at zero temperature the life time is 1
-=pr 'i(O)
and so
Pr 'i('l') 1J(T) = - = -'i(ol
Pr+P,r In general, radiative and non-radiative transitions compete even at absolute zero, and so we have the characteristic fluorescence relation 'i(T) -
=
1)(T) -
Introduction
5
In phosphorescence the introduction of non-radiative transitions usually shortens the decay time, but a simple relation such as the above is not found. The phenomenon was first studied by Perrin i n organic fluorescent solutions and later by Kroger and Hoogenstraaten for willemite (Zn 2 Si04- Mn), &c.
The crystals of phosphorescent solids known as 'conventional' are not photoluminescent in the pure state : the luminescence is due to the addition of a luminogen or activator in the form of a trace im purity. For example, in phosphorescent sulphides, copper, man ganese, bismuth , &c. - ZnS(Cu), CaS(Bi) or ZnS: Cu, CaS: Bi, &c. In some cases crystal lattice defects provide localized levels, like those of impurities, which play the part of the activator. The exceptions, that is, crystals which sh ow photoluminescence in the pure state, are materials containing groups which function like foreign molecules in the matrix crystal from which they are separated by screening (J. T. Randall). For example, in uranyl salts such as (N03)2U02, nH20, the U02 2 + group responsible for luminescence behaves as a separate molecule surrounded by a shield due to the water molecules of hydration. The luminescence disappears on heat ing but reappears when water is reintroduced. Certain rare earth salts are luminescent (Eu, Gd, Sm, Tb, Dy), due to transitions of the in ternal 4f electrons. In these cases the crystalline state is not necessary for luminescence and it is observed when the ions are in solution or 4.
Centres and traps in the different classes of phosphorescent solids
Leaving aside these exceptions, we have introduced two kinds of states involved in luminescence : - luminescence centres which contain levels responsible for the luminescence emission spectrum. - electron traps responsible for the phosphorescence or persistence of emission after cessation of excitation. We follow Mott in distinguishing two main groups of l uminescent solids : in vitreo.
A. The cases where the emitting system is quasi-atomic (crystals often known as non-photoconductors). This does not mean that photo
conductivity cannot be excited by absorption of radiation of suitable
Luminescence
6
in
Crystals
wavelength, but that under the usual conditions of l u minesce nc e ex
�
7
lp
, ==3p0
ev
is
j4 '
13
{� Fig. 4
2 t
O
citation the photoconductivity is n egligible and it is not necessary to raise electrons i nto the co nduction band in orde r to pro-
duce luminescence.
The typical solid of this class is
a first ap pro ximatio n the TJ+ ion. and e of Fig. 2 are ap p licable to this ion (Fig. 4). The scheme used in this case is thus identical with that of Jablon ski for organic mole
being to
The
levels denoted by J, m
cules and dyes.
have the
The heavy atoms Hg, TJ+, Pb2+, Bi3+
belong to this class and are iso-electronic with Tl-1-, i.e. they
The homogeneous series of ions :
same set of electronic energy levels. Ga+Ge2+ . .
may also be added to this class (Tech.
B.
KCI(TI),
the system responsible for luminescence
. In+Sn21-
B. Louchtchik and e o -worke rs) .
Cd S (Ag) , &c. Exci t ati on
Photoconducting, phosphorescent crystals typical
of which
the valence band or from the luminescence centres i n to
are
the conduc also a semicond uctor) . There thus arises a marked photoconductivity s ho w in g strong correlation with t h e luminescence. Conduction band Between t h e valence and conduction bands we have to i nt r o ZnS(Cu), ZnS(Ag),
tion band of the crystal (wh ich is thus
raises electrons from
Trap Donor
duce and consider the recombina
tion centres, donor levels, a nd
electron traps. The distinction be tween luminescence centres and
traps is less easy than in the case
an
of quasi-atomic practice
systems,
b u t in
energy level can be
put in one or other of these classes.
Hole
Valence band Fig. 5
electrons and holes are charac an effective c ro ss-s ecti on a, fo r electron c ap ture and a1 for
(a) The recombination centres for terized by
Forbidden
Centre
Introduction
7
hole �apture, which if not of the same order of magnitude are at least both of the same importance. A centre is a luminescence centre if the probability of radiative emission Pr is much greater than that for non-radiative emission Pnr: i.e.
Pr � Pnr
which is the case for Cu centres in ZnS. A centre is a 'killer' centre if, on the contrary,
Pr �Pnr
which is the case for Fe, Ni and Co in ZnS. Their introduction in large quantities results in a 'poisoning' of the luminescence . (b) Elect ro n traps and electron donors show a large capture prob ability for conduction electrons, but transitions from them to the valence band are almost forbidden : i.e.
a. � at
i.e.
at � a.
If the l e ve l is normally empty (available for electron cap t u re) it con stitutes an electron trap, if normally occupied it is a donor level. (c) Hole traps and acceptor levels can be defined in the inverse sense to the cases of electron traps and donor levels :
If a level is normally unoccupied by holes it is a hole trap, and if it is empty of electrons and ready to capture a valence ban d electron it is an acceptor level. O F T H E P A P E R S QUO T ED IN T H E I NT R ODU C T I ONt
BIBLIOGRAPHY
PERRIN, F . (1929) Flu orescence des solutions. Induction molecu Iaire. Polarisation et duree d'emission. Photochimie.' Ann de Phys., 12, 169. These, Faculte des Sciences, Paris. Definition offluorescence and phosphorescence '
-r A general bibliography on books and comprehensive revi ews on lumin escence is g iven at the end of the book (page 325). We have not attemp ted to give an exhaustive list of references: this woul d be beyond the scope of this book. We have quoted some of the most important papers relative to each problem treated in the text; we hope that it will be suf ficient as a first step in es tabl ishing the relevant bibliography.
8
Luminescence in
Crystals
VAVILOV, S. I. (1934) 'U ber die Abklingungsgesetzc der umkehr baren Lumineszenzerscheinungen', Phys. Z. Sov.;jet Union, 5, 369.
Definition o( luminescent ph enom ena
E. I. ( 1 9 5 1 ) 'Theoretical questions on the luminescence of crystals', L State editions of technical and theoretical literature, Le ning rad . (1953) 'Ei nige Fragen zur Theorie der Lumineszen der Kristalle', L Ak ad e mi e - V e r l ag, Berlin.
See also
ADIROVITCH,
Life time and efficiency offluorescen ce D E LOR M E, R. a nd PERRIN, F . (1 929) 'Dun!es de fluorescence des sels d ' u ranyle solides et de leurs solutions', J. Phys. Rad., 10, 177. HALL , L. and DIEKE, G. H. (1957) 'Fluorescent life times of uranyl salts at different temperatures', J. Opt. Soc. Am., 47, 1092. KROG ER, F. A. and HOOGENSTRAATEN, W. (1948) 'The decay and quenching of fluorescence in willemite', Physica, 14, 425. PERRIN, F. ( 192 9 ) These Paris (loc. cit.), 1 2- 1 4, 101-3. RANDALL, J. T. (1 938) 'Luminescence of s olid s at low temperatures', Nature, 142, 1 13. RANDALL, J. T. ( 1 9 3 9) 'Some recent experiments in luminescence', Trans. Faraday Soc . , 35, 2.
Solids photoluminescent in t h e pure sta t e
'Photoconducting' and 'non-photoconducting' phosph ors MoTT, N. F. and GURNEY, R. W. (1948) 'Electronic
ionic crystals', 202-26. Clarendon Press, Oxford . Thallium as an activator : see Chapter II.
p r oce ss es
in
Other activators, isoelectronic with Tf+ LOUCHTCHIK, N . E. and L O U C H TCH IK , Tech. B. ( 1 960) 'Spectro
scopy of the luminescence centers and alkali halide crystals acti vated by ho mol o go u s series of ions', Optics and Spectr., 8, 441. PRENER, J. S., HANSON, R. E . and WILLIA M S, F. E. ( 1 953) 'Atomic mercury as a luminescent activator', J. Chem. Phys. , 21, 759.
Energy-level scheme of Jablonski J ABLONSKI, A. ( 1935) 'Ober der Mechanismus der Photolumineszenz von Farbstoffphosphoren', Z. fur Phys., 97, 38.
Introduction
9
Classification of the diferent localized levels in the forbidden gap, traps,
centres etc .... AIGRAIN, P., Lectures given at the Faculte des Sciences de Paris, ,
1956-7.
Thermodynamics of luminescence phenomena KENNARD, H. E. (1 918) 'On the thermody n am i c s of fluorescence',
Phys. Rev., 11, 29. LANDAU, D. L. (1 946) 'On the thermodynamics of photolumines cence', Z. Phys. U. S.S.R., 10, 499, 503. VAVILOV, S . I. (1 948) 'Photoluminescence and thermodynamics', J. Phys. U.S.S.R., 10, 499. WEINSTEIN, A. ( 1 960) The rmo d ynam i c limitation on the co nversion of heat i nto l igh t' J. Opt. Soc. Amer , 50, 597. WEINSTEIN, A. ( 1 960) The r modyna mi cs of radiative emission pro cesses', Phys. Rev., 119, 499. WILLIAMS, F. E. (1 960) 'Irreversible thermodynamics of solid state lumi n e sce n ce', Spring Meeting, El ectrochemical Society, Chicago, '
,
.
'
May 1-5.
Angular distribution offluorescent brightness PRINGSHEIM, P. (1 949) 'Fluorescence and phosphorescence', 389, Inte rsci en ce Pub., New York.
CHAPT E R
I
Dipole and Quadrupole Radiation: Probabilities of Emission and Absorption
We
shall not give here the general theory for the ph en omena of
emission and absorption of radiation. The reader may refer to more
E.
H. S hortley The Theory of Atomic Spectra
specific writings for this, for example: U. Condon and G.
H ei tler The Quantum Theory of Radiation ,
(Cambridge University Press);
W.
,
(Oxford, C larend o n
Press).
We have made considerable use of the follow i n g :
F. Perrin, Emission
A.
de rayonnement par les atomes et les noyaux
(Cours du College de France, 1950-I-2); Berthelot,
Les champs multipolaires en electromagnetisme;
Only the elementary results fo r dipol e and quad rupol e radiations are necessary in considering luminescence. E ffective ly the e m is s io n p robabi lity for the various m ultipo l e orders falls by a factor� (a/A)2 unfortunately the last two have not been pu blished.
}. the
each time the ord er and
emitted radiation.
I changes
w avelength of the
by unity, a bei n g the source dimension
A)
For visible luminescence (}. � 5,000 factor
aj}.
is
from atoms (a �
thus 1/5000, and so quad r u po l e
feeble compa red
with
radiations
I A) the
are very
dipole radiat i ons and higher o rde r emissions
d ipole transition I 0-3 to 10-1 sec, and a qu adrupole transition an even longer life time.
are almost negligible.
An electric
-
dip ol e transition will have, for ex
ample, a life time of I0-8 to I0-7 s ec a magnetic ,
(In luminescent materials the interaction of the emitting atom with
the crystal lattice can usually cause
an appreciable redu cti on in these
In cont ra st for hard X-rays (A � I0-1 A and a� IQ-Io cm, the size of the inner shells of heavy atom) the same factor a/A can reach values.)
10
.
11
Dipole and quadrupole radiation
1/10; similarly for y-ray conditions multipole radiations are no longer n e gligible
I . D I P O L E AND Q UA D R U P O LE M O M ENT S
1. Electrostatic p otential due to a charge distribution An atom, molecule or luminescence centre is composed of one or more nuclei surrounded by a certain number of negatively charged electrons. These form an assembly of charges e; at points y;, z; . We no w find the potential due to this system at a poin t P(X, Y,Z) at a distanc e R from the orig i n of coordinates:
o;(x;,
)
the ch ar ge e;. Assuming R to be large compared with the distances of the charges from the origin, a Taylor series can be developed:
r1 being the distance from P to V= ��e;+
This indicates the total charge of the distribution dipole moment fJ. whi ch by defini t i o n has components
�e;, the vector
(=
fJ.x =
and the
...
�e;X;
•
•
•
tensor quadrupole moment
B<2>
Bxx
Bxv
Bxz
Bvx Bzx
Bv11
B11z
)
Bzz
a symmetric tensor of the second order (six separate components) Bzv
given by
I n genera l we have a series of polar moments 21 and each one charac terized by a tensor
and contributing to the total potential of the system the co n t racted product
denoting the tensor of the p arti al derivatives of order l of 1/ R calculated at the origin. The s imilari ty will be noted between the definition of dipole moment and that of the centre of gravity of a collection of masses grad0<1>
12
Luminescence i n Crystals
and also between the quadrupole moments and moments of inertia. By a suitable ch o ice of axes of reference it is p o ssibl e to diagonalize the tensor BC2l in the same way as the te ns or formed by the moments and products of i nertia. 2. Potentials due to dipoles and quadrupoles
A d ipol e formed by ch arge s A and B equal to +e and -e has a
mo m en t
!l. = eBA and gives rise to a potential which at large distances away, say ten times the length of the dipole, reduces to a term invo lvin g I IR2: cos 0 (n.!l.) _
n
being a uni t vector in
V1
-
11 --
th e direction
8 0
Fig.
I. I
A
_
R2
R.
:r
Electrostatic dipole
The p o ten ti al is zero along the axis for 8 = n/2, but not so the fiel d which is thus t ransv erse ; the field is radial about the axis of the d ip o le (0 = 0). A qu ad rupole is fo rmed by two e qual and opposed d ip o les dis placed from each other, say four charges ABCD of +e, --e, +e, -e arranged at the corners of a parallelogram. This gives rise to a p o t en ti al : V2 = 1 grad0<2>(1jR) .BC2l Using the two invariants attached to the tensor BC2l, we knowi its trace: B = Bxx+ B,"+ Bzz and the quadratic form: B(X,Y,Z) = BxxX2+ ... --i-2BvzYZ f ... ,
,
t In th e analogy between the tensor of the moments and products of inertia the invariant B corresponds to the moment of inertia with respect to the origin such t h at B(X, Y,Z) is the quadratic form appearing in the definition of the ellipsoid
of inertia.
Dipole and quadrupole radiation
13
We can then obtain explicitly the derivatives which occur in grad0C2>:
V2
=
� 3�(!kr2:)- J B
The anisotropy of a quadrupole is more complex than that of a
dipole and depend s on the type of quadrupole involved . .'ll
8
e
c 't
A:·e
0
8-//
"'
·
Fig. J.2
0
C
'. f: j
'
·•
21:.
A
'•
R
J
/
fJ
(�;
:('
Two types of quadrupoles
Consider first the case where the four charges
A, B, C, and Dare
arranged at the corners of a square. The only non-zero component
of the tensor
8<�> is
then
Vz
B,.v e(A 8)2, from which 3e(1 #)2 cos g �il! P
-
=
R3
The potential and the field are both zero along the axis
45°
Oz normal
to
the plane of the quadrupole. To diagonalize 8<2l it is sufficient here
to take the axes at
to the previous ones.
When the four charges
A, B, C, Dare aligned along the same axis The only non ze ro component is then
they form an axial quadrupole.
B:rx = 2e(A8)2•
V2
=
R3
2
cos 2
o-!) 2
0). In a 21 formed by charges
We see the appearance of the Legendre polynomial Plcos more general way, for an axial multiple of order
of alternate sign with equal distances between them, the number of charges a t each poi nt being equal to the successive coefficients in the
,
binomial ex p an sio n the potential is given by
Vz =
l!e(AB)1 Rl+
1
Pz(cos
{})
Luminescence in Crystals
14
3. Development of potential due to a multipole in spherical harmonics s am e order a rr anged along the ray vectors of th e poles . This
Any '21-pole' is eq u iva lent to the
us to
sum
of 21 axial multipoles of the
enables
expand the potential V1 of the 2 1-po le in the following form:
Vz =
We use for this
ll'-1
)
L of
a/" Yz"'(O,
t he
?n=-l
exp a nsi on
the
P1(cos
R
�m=l
m=l
=
.2:
o/)
Legendre polynomial
for the
Yt'(O, cj>) Yz"'(O', 4/)
where 0 and
I
nr = -r
the polar coordinates for the direction of the e,th ch a rge , a being the angle between these two directions. By i n tegr at ion over a volum e element dv of the charge system we obtain th e value of the coe fficie nt
'
am ! •
where
az
m_
4:n;
Qm
p(o) is the charge density. Qz"' is termed the multipole electric of order I, m. 21+ 1 coefficients are necessary to define the 21+ 1
1
'
moment
21 -poles in place of the 1-(l+ 1)(/-f-2) c oe fficien t s of the tensor B<1>. This is because the coefficients are not ind ependent , t he res ultant p oten ti al V h a v ing to satisfy Laplace's equation as well as its de riv a tives. In particular the moment
where
Q2o
Q
I.
=
about the axis ()
and defines the
rotation
=
v 156:n:. Q
J 02(3
cos2
0-!)p dv
q u adru pol e moment of = 0.
a
di stri buti on formed by
I I . D I P O L E A N D Q U A D RUP O L E R A D I A T I O N I N E L E C T R O MAG N E T I SM
Con sid e r an
elec t r om agne tic
Maxwell's
tion
equations
of density
p and a cu r ren t
field in vacuo due
to a
charge distribu
distribution of density j. This field is
Dipole and quadrupole radiation defi ned by the electric field
equation s
_!
curl E = div
E and
D = 4np
�C
div B
0
=
m agneti c field H related
by the
(law of ind u ction)
C
curl H =
the
15
theorem)
(Gauss's
+ 4nj (Ampere's theo rem) (i.e. no free magnetic poles)
The system of units is defi ned by
eo = flo =
1
vacuu m is
Unless otherwise indicated, magnetic quantities and also j are given
assumed : in
e.m.u
and electrostatic quantities in
D
E
=
B
and
e. s u . .
Since a
H
From these re l a t i on s o n e obtains the law of charge con servation :
d
The fields
E
and H can
and a vector pote n ti al E
lv 1 .
.
+ 1 ap
c at = o
be exp ress ed in te r m s of a scalar by the relations
A
I
oA
= - g rad
-c at
a nd H = curl
potential
A
When the poten t i a l s are c h o s en so that they s a tisfy t h e Lorentz
condition
and
A are solutions
Where 0 is the
of
o
=
d'Alembertian
D =
DA
4np
(}2
(}2
(}2
=
4nj
1 (}2
ox2 + iJy 2 + iJz2 - C2 o t2
2. Solution of Maxwell's equations by the retarded potential method Co n sid er a distribution of
occu p yin g a reg io n
sider the potential
moving charges p(x,y,z) and j(x,y,z) around the origin of coordinates. We now con
at P(X, Y, Z) at a
r from the charge (x,y,z).
d istan ce
R from the origin and
16
Luminescence in Crystals
When
P is ou ts i d e the ch a rge distribu t i o n we obta i n the
th e i n te g ra l ex ten d i n g
ch arge s .
The r e ta rd a tio n of velocity
<
r/c
p
-
-
r
fo l l o w i ng :
dx dy dz
J J J j(x,y,z,:. - r/c)d x dy d z
over the whole vol u m e o cc u pi e d by the
r e p re s e nts the time for electrom agnetic
to reach t h e po i n t P a ft e r
waves
emission by the cha rge at
p
Fig. l . 3 Poten tial produced by a moving charge
(x,y,z). These e xpres si o ns satisfy t h e equations for and A (involving the d'Aiembertian) as well as t h e Lorentz c on d i t io n resulting from t h e conservation of charge. 3.
If
Systems in harmonic vibration
r
is
the
vibrational
fr e q ue n cy then we can
write
i mpl yi n g of c our se the real parts of these expressions. We a l s o intro
duce the wav e l e n gth A. = cjv, the reduced wave number
Then we h ave
the
reduced wavelength j{ = A./2:n: and I
2m•
k = -- = -; J. c p
=
P o e i kcl ;
and charge conservation requires
that :
div kt- ikp0
j
=
=
0
j o e i kr t
Dipole and quadrupole radiation
17
U si ng these notations, the reta rded potential form ulae beco m e
=
=
A0 = 4.
o e ikrr
JJ J J. J J
,
Jo
A= e ikr
A o eikct
e - ikr · dv --
Potential distribution among successive multipole orders
The potential formu la
for <1> 0 d i ffers from that for the el ectrostat ic potential V for t h e charge d i stribution p 0 by the replacement of I /r by e - ikr f(r) r =
--
-
The exponential takes account of the different retardations between the different point charges of the system. Analogous to the d evelop ment of i n para. I . l , <1>0 can be given as follows :
V
o = f(R)
JJJ
Po dv -j-
6: ft
(grado<1) f(R) . B0<0)
the derivatives off(R) being taken at the origin . Each component of A 0 can be obtained in a s imi l ar way. Charge conservation during vibration requires that
We then obtain the results for successive multipole orders (1), taking together the (I+ l )th term of <1>0 and the /th term of A0•
Electric dipole radiation
We take the fi r st non-zero term of each series and obtain
grad 0/(R·) . (J. 0
<1> 0 A0
f(R)
JJJ
j 0 dv
(.1.0 is the vecto r d i po le m o m en t =
(.1.0 5 bei ng the
- gradpf(R) . (J.o
=
JJf
PoS d v
rad ial vector for a point charge (x,y,z) of the source.
18
Luminescence in Crystals
C hargc conservation gives :
so
that
the potentials
We now
I I I j0 dv
j( R)
=
i k!L o
finally d ep e nd only on the q u an t ity !Lo · and its d e rivative .f'(R)
introd uce .f(R)
=
f'(R) =
so t h a t we ca n n ow w ri t e
<}) o = - (D . (L0).f'(R) A 0 = ikELof( R) For small d i s t a n c e s , i.e. small compared with J.(k R � l ) but large c o m p ared with the size of the source, we can put .f(R) R: 1 /R : th us we obtain t h e electric field due to a stationary d ip o l e of moment !Lo and the magnetic field due to the curre nt j0• At l a rge distances (kR � 1 ) f'(R) red uces to - i f( R) , which gives terms in 1/R in the poten tia l s as well as in the fields, i.e. we have the ra d i atio n fiel d s . We find
k
H =
e2nio·t k 2 (n A !L o) -R e - iku
where n is t h e unit ve c t o r
e ikU
(n A !Lo)] -- e2nivt
in the direction R. These solutions are for divergent waves and this arises use of the retardation p o ten tial s . E
-k2[n
"
R
from the
We see that
(E and H hav e the s a m e magni tud e and are both t r an s v e r s e .) The ra d i a t i o n energy is equal to the flux of the Poynting vector : c S 4n(E " H)
a nd i nt eg ra t i n g over all space
=
where W i s the energy
W
1 6n·l y� 12 3 c 3 I tJ. o
radiated per second. The d ipo l e !Lo can be realized by assuming a p o i n t ch arge in har monic o sci l l a ti o n . Knowing the o sci l l a t o r energy and comparing this to W, we can d e d uc e the mean life time =
3m c 3
T = 8n2e2v2
For 1\
19
Dipole and quadrupole radiation
R:
6,000 A we obtain
r R:
1 ·6 x I0-8 sec
Anisotropy of the emission If the moment !J.o is real this corresponds to the case of a point charge axis Oz.
0 is the angle between the direction OP and this axis, the emission per unit solid a n g le is dependent on sin2 0 (t hi s is seen straight away oscillating along a direction which we take as the polar
0
If
fl- o
Un ear 05Cllla tor
Cwcutar oscillator
i.C
Fig. 1 . 4 Anisotropy of emission for in the expression for square of the field).
dipole oscillators
H, knowing that the radiant energy varies as the
The emission is zero along the dipole axis. However, the electro static field is a maximum (but radial for reasons of symmetry : there could not be a radiation field because
this must be transverse).
The angular d istribution of the radiation field is identical with that of the transverse component of the electrostatic field but differs from
In general !J. o = a + ib and i s complex. This corresponds to the case of the elliptical oscillator. In particular, if a = b the oscillator is cir that of the total electrostatic field.
cular and the anisotropy of the emission depends on 1 + cos2 e.
Case of a zero dipole
moment
The same approximation
as above the first
the potentials, i.e. we take
can be used in the derivation o f n on-zero term .
Consider first of all the scalar potential
o
=
-!(grad 0<2> f(R) . B0<2>)
20
Luminescence in Crystals
BCl.i being the tensor quad r up ole moment. Thus to describe Cl>0 it is any new quantities ; as in the electrostatic case it i s sufficient to replace 1 /R by f(R) e - ikRjR. However, it is necessary for the vector p ote nti al to introduce new pa ram eters related to the ch a rge distribution. If 5 is the radius vector of a p o i n t (x,y,z) of the source
not necessary to introduce
=
f'(R)
A0 =
We c an establish that
JJJ J JJ
xj0, d u yjoz d v
=
=
� ik Jik
J JJ J JJ
J J J (n . S)j0
p0xz
dv
'=
dv
iik 80
HJ J J
PoJ'Z d l'
.• .•.
(J}oz - zjo v) d r:
±ikBo uz + Mox We are thus led to introduce in addition to B0(2 l the magnetic dipole moment M0 M0
=
J
J J J (S
When only the magnetic mo men t
di pole wave
A
j0) du
is i nvolved we have a magn et i c
emi ss i o n for which
A0 f'(R)(M0 A n) Cl> 0 = 0 , Alth ough these potentials are very diferent from those o btained for the electric dipole radiation, the fields can be obtained by a simple perm utati o n of E and H (and of course repl ace me nt of !J.o by M0). The radiation energy is thus =
W
=
Mo
3c 3
j2
The magnetic d ipole moment is of the order of a Bo h r magneton
Mo � 4nm c eh
--
while
fl o � ea0,
where a0 is the Bohr
atom ic radius ft2 ao = 4.n Zmez
We can d ed uce that M0/!J.o is of the o rder of the fine structure constant
21
Dipole and quadrupole radiation
w h ich gives
a m uch smaller probability of magnetic dipole emission
than of electric dipole emission in the ratio 1 : 1 05 (and still 1 00 times weaker if the radiation comes from an intercombination transition). When M0 is zero bu t B0 <2> is not, we have the case of electric quadru pole e m i s si o n for which we h a ve already n oted t h e expression for
w h i le
Aox =
-f '(R)}ik(n . B0<2>),
From these form u l a e th e fields can be ded uced . We shaH not derive these b u t sim ply remark that at large distances they are agai n trans verse and s at i s fy the relation E = HAn
applying to a l l m u l t i p o l e orders . The emitted ra d i a t i o n has the va l u e
t h is
W =
�1�{2 I
Bvu
-
B,"
1 2 - !- 6
2I
Buz
1 2}
If a is the s o u rce dimension, the q uad r up o l e moment is of the order of ea2 whil e the e lec tri c dipole mo ment is R> ea, the coefficient is o n t h e other hand m u l t ip l i e d b y v 2 jc 2 and the emission p ro b ab il i t y is t h u s multipl ied by R> ( a/Jc) 2, which is of the o rder of 10 - 7 o r J Q - 8 • W e c a n a l so w r i t e W a s follows : 8 G 6
W= � 5c5 l
Q lz
J Q j 2 representing t h e expression J B,, - }B 1 2 + 1 Bv v - -}B 1 2 + 1 B•• - tB I 2 + 2(J Bxy J 2 + J B11z j 2+ j B,, \ 2)
or in the most condensed form
Q
=
B<2> -BI
B being the trace of the tensor B<2> and I the unit diagonal tensor. Reference may be made to J. Blatt a n d V. F. W ei ss kop f, Theoretical Nuclear Physics (Wiley, New York, 1 9 52), p. 586, for a study of the emission anisotropy for different multipole orders We only note here that the angul ar distribution of the radiation energy for the real axial quadrupole, osci l l a t i n g linearly along the OZ axis, depend s on cos2 e s i n 2 e.
Q tm·
I l l . P R O B A B I Ll T I E S O F R A D I ATIVE A B S O RPTI O N AND EMISSION
1 . The Hamiltonian of the particle (electron of mass m and charge - e, e b e i n g taken positive) in an electromagn etic field <1>, A is given in B
22
Luminescence in Crystals
non-relativistic
classical mechanics by I p z - e H _ 2m =
P = mv
p -i- �A c
P is t h e kinetic momentum, p t h e total momentum (that of particle and field ) . N eg l ect in g the terms i n (eA jc) Z, these e qu a ti o ns w h e re
gtve
H=
1
A 2mp2- e + mc(p . ) e
The term (eAjc)2 is a relativistic term and we H a mil to n i a n i s s e p a ra b le i n to I ., Hparticle = e
giving the el e ct r o n potential
In
and
motion
2nip - -
shall n e g l e c t
i n the field derived fro m
e
it. The
the electrostatic
- (p . A)
H; nter:ICtion
me
quantum mechanics p mu s t be rep l ace d by the operator p = �V !
where V is the operator g r a dien t . However, p and A are n o n - c o m
m utative and we have
V . A = A . V+ div A
is also convenient to choose a potential scale so that the scalar potential is zero for the radiation field (in contrast to previous condition imposed by using retarded potentials). We know that the physical results should be independent of the scale chosen for the potentials. The Lorentz condition implies that div A 0 and the difficulty of the non-commutative operators disappears. We then It
=
have Hinteraction ( radiat iou·elcctron)
2. The transition probability
e li = - -:(A · grad) me z
This interaction introduces simultaneous transitions between electron states and the photons of the radiation fiel d . The transition probability per unit time is ., ., P "' 't'�natHintemction\Fini tial d r
f
�-p(£)
Dipole and quadrupole radiation
where p(E) i s the density o f osci l l ator states aro u nd t h e ene rgy for the photons
p(E) dE =
c
E
23 =
hv
dv
(normalized to the volume V). The '¥ functions can be resolved into a 1p(r) function of the electron
coordinates multiplied by a product of the eigen functions of the oscillator for the photon field. The matrix elements for the latter are classical. We give here only the results of these calculations. When
the
vector potential
A is assumed constant at all points i n
the charge source, matrix elements appear o f the form
�f
1p1 * grad 1p dr
(a formula which when ?p;
of the centre of gravity).
=
f 1p1*r1p; d-r
m
= 1p1 red uces to p
=
mv for the movement
We also obtain the matrix elements for the electric dipole momen t :
We
!-'-it = erif,
r;1 =
f
1p1*r1p; dr
then have for the probability per second of emission :
N being
Pcmis•.
=
64n"v3
(N+ l) 3h c3 I fJ.it l 2
the mean number of photons in the energy hv (if N = 0 we
have spontaneous emission) and for the probability of absorption per second
Pal». _
64n"v3 N . 3h c 3 I !-'-it
I2
The luminous emission intensity per second from an atomic emitter (photon energy E
=
hv multiplied by the transition probability) is
64n4v4 I I(hv) = 3"CS IJ.if 1 2
The effective absorption cross-section is by definition
a(v)
=
Et!£ ���
No. of incident photons per cm 2 per sec
The numerator is Pats. and the denominator is the photon second
8 v2
n dv = cNc3
flux
per
24
Luminescence in Crystals
From which
a(v)
N
64;r-I J,3
[.Lit
I . c N Snv :i d ; c3
thus obtain the effective cross-section i ntegrated over an assembly matrix element [.L;r) in p ractice over all the possible n e i ghbouring energies t o hv fo r the abso rbed p h o t on s : =c
I
•
We
of 'physically identical' states (that is, with t h e same
One often c o n s i d e rs :
J J
8n31•
a(1·) cl J '
I
--3hc
[.Lit
8n3J'
a(E) dE = - - - I 3c
The absorption coefficient k(E)
[.Lit
I2
12
cm - 1 i s given by the product o f the e ffective cr o ss sect i o n a(E) and the concen tration o f absorbing a toms These classical fo rm ul a e are for atoms in vacuo. We shall see later -
.
crystalline m ed i u m of refractive index n . H o weve r the the study of e mi tted a n d absorbed rad i a
how they may be transformed fo r the case of absorbin g or emitting
atoms i n a
,
formulae above suffice for
tion as a function of the factor
sidering the
[ !L 1 2 ,
when
and we o nly need to introduce
absolute intensity of the radiation ( S m a k u l a formula) .
a coefficient w hich takes account of the refractive i ndex Compare the quantum
expression giving J(/w)
n
con
above and the pre
ceding formula from classical electrom agnetis m for the rad iated energy
(correspondence prin c iple) W
12
We see that the quantum formula differs fr o m the classical o n e in that =
!-L o
3 ca
we replace the dipole m o m e n t !-Lo by the matrix element of the dipole
do
have
of 2 in the matrix el e m e n t and of 4 i n the transition probability.
moment for the transitio n . I f we
this we
facto r 2 can be explai ned as fol lows :
The
to include a factor
tion between the i nt e ns ity at the harmonic of frequency v i n the fre The co rrespondence principle establishes in a general way a rela
quency spectrum and the rad iated energy in the quantum t h e ory d u e
to photons of en ergy h v . However, classically we d o n o t distinguish between v and - v, that i s , between photons emitted a n d ph oto ns absorbed . In applying t h e correspon dence principle to !-Lo
c �
e
spr
dr
Dipole and quadrupole radiation
t h e density p must b e replaced n o t b y tpt'lp; ; which gi v e s (.Lit
=
e
ftp1*np,
25
dr
but by the symmetrical expression 1J!f'IJ!; + 1fJ;1f!f> and we must take the real part R e (tp1*tp; + tp;*1f!t) 2 R e ( y•/ '1f•,) =
w h ich expl a i n s t h e correspondence
(.Lo -- 2(.Lit
3. Ma gnetic dipole and electric quadrupole radiation
The same correspondence occurs in the expressions for emission and absorption of magnetic dipole and electric quad rupole character. In the magnetic dipole case the luminous intensity emitted at fre quency v is
Jl(h 'jJ) - 64n4v4 � 1 Mif I •-
dE = 3c I Mi! ! 2
and the integrated absorption cross-section is
f a(E)
8:n:3v
In the case of electric quadrupole radiation (which is obtained when we introduce the first derivative of A (the first derivative of the re tardation c - l kr between different points of the c h a rge sou rce in t h e classical case) we obtai n
f
a(E) dE
=
4:n:5v 4
Sc3
I Q i! 1 2
Q
We refer back to the expression developed for at the end of paragraph II i n which each component Bxx , B x v . . . of the tensor B(2l can be replaced by the matrix element of the same quan tity for the transition i -- f 4. Selection rules
The selection rules are m ost easily appreciated by resolution of the dipole and quadrupole potentials, &c. , into spherical harmonics dependent on Q ';' (para. 1.3) with m = !, -l -!- 1 . . . !- 1 -!- 1, We can show that rad iation of multipole order /, m has a total angular
Luminescence in Crystals
26
momentum I for which the Oz component is m (m units of h/2n). Thus fo r the emitting atoms the angular momentum a n d for the D z component
J; = Jt + l
M; = M1 f - m
Since there is no multiple radiation for l 0 , all radiative tran sitions ]; 0 -+ 11 = 0 are forbidden in all multipole orders. For I 1 (dipole case) w e have =
=
6.1 = 0, ± 1 ,
!: M = 0, ± 1
givi ng an electr ic dipole wave if there is a change of parity fo r the w ave fu nct io n 1p (Lapo rte ' s rule) and a magnetic d i pole wave if the parity does not change (given the par i t i e s of the operators !J. a n d M). For I = 2 !:M = 0, ± 1 , ± 2 0.1 = 0, ± 1 , ± 2 ;
a n electric quad r u pol e wave i f there i s n o c h an ge i n parity. = ± 2, only quadrupole or higher o r d er radiation is allowed . For !:J 0 (0 �>- 0 excluded) or ± 1 , w e have an electric d ipol e wave if the parity changes and a mixture of electric quad rupo le and magnetic dipole waves if there is no change in parity. The m ag netic dipole radiation will usu ally predominate since its p rob ability is only I 0-5 times less than that for electric dipole radiation, while that for electric quadrupole radiation is about I0-8 times less. giving
For !:1
=
Forbiddenness of intercombination radiation. The operators !J., M and are symmetric al to the exchange of two electrons. If, for example, we consider a system of two electrons, the transition from a triplet state (spatial wave function antisymmetric with respect to the ex change) to a singlet state (spatial wave function symmetrical) is for bidden . The spin-orbit interaction partially lifts the for b id d e n ness . In an average atom, an intercombination transition will be 1 00 times weaker than an allowed transition of the same multipole order. In heavy atoms such as Hg, Tl+, &c. , this factor is reduced to about 1 0. B<2l
'Spin-flip' transitions. Chromium as an activator. In an allowed tran sition the electronic configuration changes by means of an electron transition from one 'orbit' to another. There are some transitions for which the configuration does not change, being the same in the ground and excited states . These states d i ffer only by the 'turning
Dipo le an d quadrupo le radiation over' o f o n e electron spin. I n luminescence the q uestion case of ruby (alu m in ium oxide containing
Cr203) :
27
arises in the
The emission spectra of chromium-activated phosphors are quite different from the spectra of other phosph ors, and to some extent
they can be co m p are d to the spectra of rare earth s . They consist of
m ay be resolved into a large n umber of narrow lines ; among them there is a characteristic intense doublet (Deutschbei n). In ruby, the position of this d ou blet is, at 20°C, at
a red fluorescence which
R1 : 6,942·3 A, (14,404 cm-1) R2 : 6,927·4 A, (14,435 cm-1)
These lines are sli ghtl y d i splace d when the temperature is varied , but 2 2
� 0·38
-1 I! '• r
G 912
G 7/ 2
} 4 F3 / 2
cm
Fig. 1.5 Energy-levels scheme for the emission spectrum of the main lines R1, R2 in ruby
the main effect is an exponential dependence of the relative inten sities :
I(R ,.) I( RJ
= ( - W) exp
kT
W � 29·2 cm- 1
Chromium i s incorporated a s Cr3 +. I n t h e fundamental level 4 F3;2,
the s pin s of the three outer 3d electrons are parallel ; in the excited 2G1;2 and 2Go;2 levels, one of the valence electrons is anti parallel to the other. In addition, when the
Cr3+ ion is incorporated into the crystal, the
,
fundamental level is s pli t into 2 tw ofold orbitally dege n erate states,
I and II,
3 single states (not shown on the Fig. !.5). The value of the splitting between I and II is accurately k nown from micro wave ab s orption measurements : it c o rres p on d s to a frequency of 1 1 ,593 Mc/s. It may be noted that this splitting is small compared with the and
28
Luminescence in Crystals
energy difference between states o f different J val ues : t h u s the de generacy of the levels of the free Cr3 + ion is raised by the crystal field, but the mixing of these levels is probably q u i te negligible fo r the mo st i mpo rta nt low energy levels, occurring in the red R-emission of ruby. A discussion, using as a starting-point the terms derived for t he free ion, as it was attempted by Deutschbein , Thosar and Pringsheim, is thus not too inaccurate.t A s p i n-fl ip transition is also assumed for the case of the activator manganese. Sometimes, this a ctivato r is embedded as M n 4+, wh ich is isoelectronic with Cr3 +, and an emission results which contains several lines, also situated in the red part of the sp e c t r u m . This is the case for mag n esiu m germanate, M g 2 G c 0 4 (M n ) , a n d magne s i um oxide, MgO(Mn), phosphors, but more often one has to deal with Mn2+ ions, with five outer 3d electrons : such is the case for ZnS(M n ), Zn2SiOiMn), &c . . . . We shall discuss these phosphors in Chapter V (page 1 22). Such transitions are naturally fo r b i d d e n for an electric d i po le approximation . They comprise v a r i o u s rad iations, some of elec t r ic quadrupole and others principally of m a gn e tic d ipole character. Their mean life time is rather l o n g (5 msec in r u b y) and very sensitive to cry s t al lattice interactions.
BI BLI OGRAPHY
References to some c o m p rehensive treatises o n the th e o ry of em issi o n absorption phenomena have already been gi ve n in t h e text.
and
On the anisotropy and polarization of luminescence in crystals F E OFIL OV , P . P . ( 1 9 5 6) 'Anisotropic optique des centres l u mi n oge n es dans Jes cristaux cubiques' , J. Phys. Rad., 1 7, 6 5 6 . F E OFI L OV, P . P . ( 1 9 60) The physical basis of polarized emission (Polarized luminescence of A toms, Molecules and Crystals), English t ranslation . Consultant B u re a u Books, New York. t The level scheme which is proposed here differs s l i g h t l y from the generally accepted scheme due to Suga n o and Tan a be ( 1 9 58). The fundamental level and t h e ex c i ted level i n v o lve d in the R-emission of ruby derive respectively from 4F and 2G sta tes ; the difference is in p a rt a matter of notation .
Dipole and quadrupo!e radiation
On
H . (1 929) 'Termaufspaltung in Kristallen',
the split t ing of terms in crys ta ls
1 33.
BETHE,
T . (1 960) Theorie Paris.
tique, D u n o d ,
K AH A N ,
29
Ann . der Phys. , 3 ,
des groupes e n physique classique et quan
0 . ( 1 932) 'Die D e u tu n g der linienhaften Emissions und Absorption sspektren der Ch romphosphore', Z. fir Phys. , 17, 489 ; Phys. Z. , 33 , 874 ; A nn. der Phys. , 14, 7 1 2, 729. GEUSI C , J . E . ( 1 956) 'Paramagnetic fine structure spectru m of Cr H· + in a single ruby crystal', Phys. Rev. , 102, 1 252. P R I N G S H E I M , P. (1 949) Fluorescence and Phosphorescen ce, 637-45 . Intersc. Pub . , New York. S uGANO , S. and T ANA B E , Y. (1 958) 'Absorption spectra of Cr++ + in A l 203', J. Phys. Soc. Japan, 13, 880. T A N A B E , Y . and S U G ANO , S. (1 954) 'On t h e a b s o rpt i o n spect ra of compl ex ions', J. Phys. Soc. Japan, 9, 769. T HO S A R , B. V. (1 938) 'On the fluorescent i o n s o f chromium i n corundum', Phi!. Mag. , 26, 380, 878. Structure and luminescence of ruby
D EUTS C H B E I N ,
( 1 956) 'Proposal for a maser', Phys . Rev . , 104, 324.
Some references on m icrowave and optical masers
B LOEMBERGEN, N .
new
type of solid state us
ing ruby
'Microwave modulation of light in paramagnetic cr y s t als
BLOEMBERGEN, N . , P ERSHAN, P. S. and W I L CO X , L. R . Rev. ,
120, 20 14.
teristics of a maser at 1 420
B i:i LGER , B . , R O B J N S O N , B . J . and U B B I N K , J .
( 1 960)
',
(1 960) Phys.
' S o m e charac
A . L. , B O N D , w . , (1 960) 'Coherence, narrowing, directionability and relaxation oscillations in the l i ght e m i s s i o n from ru b y , Phys. R e u . Letters, 5, 303. F O N E R , S . , M O M O L. R. and M A Y E R , A . (1959) ' M ultilevel pulsed field maser for generation of high frequencies', Phys. Rev. Letters, 3, 36. M A I M A N , T. H. (1 960) 'Optical and microwave optical experi m ents in ruby', Phys. R e v . Letters, 4 , 564. COLL I N S ,
R.
MHz' , Physica, 26, l .
J . , N ELS O N , D . F . , S CHA WL OW,
G A RRET, C . G . B . a n d K A I S E R , W . '
,
30 On
Luminescence in Crystals
/'.1n 1 ' as an activator
and V A N D E N B o o M G A R D , J. ( 1 9 50) 'The fluor of magnesi u m germanate activated by m a n ganese' , .!. Electrochem . Soc., 97, 3 7 7 . PATTEN , S . H . a n d W I L L I A M S , F . E . ( 1 949) ' Fluorescent M g 2GeO c M n ' , J. Opt. Soc. Am., 39, 702. PRENER, J . S . ( 1 953) 'Magnesiu m oxide ph osphor activated by M n + + + + ' , J. Chem. Phys., 21 , 1 6 1 . P R I N G S H E I M , P . ( 1 949) Fluorescence and Phosphorescence, 632. Intersc. P u b . New York. THORINGTON, L. ( 1 950) E m i s s i o n o f a n improved manganese activated m ag n esi u m germanate phosphor', J. Opt. Soc. Am., 40, 579.
KROGER ,
F. A.
escence
,
'
C H A PTER 1 1
Emission
the
and
Absorption
Spectra and
Configurational Coordinate Model
(Ex a m p le of Thallium Activa ted Alkali
Halides)
Luminescence spectra differ from atomic spectra in two basic aspects : (a) Bands (of the order of hund reds of angstroms wide) rather than lines are generally observed . Exceptions are the Ewles-Kroger lumin escence and exciton emission.
(b) The emitted radiation is displaced to longer wavelengths com pared to the absorbed radiation (Stokes's Law). More specifically, the band maxima for emission and absorption are displaced but it is possible to have an overlap of the long wavelength side of the absorp tion band and the short wavelength side of the emission band . The above phenomena are due to the interaction between the emission centre and the crystal lattice which can be treated by means
of the configurational coordinate model. This model is particularly appropriate for the case of a quasi-atomic emission system ; the inter· action can be represented i n a most satisfactory way by using a single configurational coordinate to give the distance between the lumin escent ion and its nearest neighbours in the surrounding lattice. As an example we take the case of thallium activated potassium chloride
F. Seitz F. E. Williams. The model can also be applied to cases where
KCl(Tl) which has been extensively studied, in particular by and by
the centres are less localized, in particular to luminescent semi conductors although the configurational coordinate can n ot be given such a specific interpretation as in the above case. 31
Lumin('sccncc in Cr_J •srals
1 . S T R U CT U R E O F A ' N O N - P H O T O C O N D U CT I N G '
In
L U M I N E S C E N T S O L I D : K CI(TI )
general, KCI(TI)
is p rep are d by i n c o rp ora ti o n
pa r t per
KCI. Two intense absorption b an d s of 1
due to we a ke r 1 0,000
TJ + i o n s are fo u nd at 1 ,960 and 2, 500 A respectively, wi th a b a n d at about 2, 1 00 A . Ex cita ti on is u s u al l y effected in the 2,500 A h a n d (merc u ry rad iation is at 2 , 5 3 7 A). A n i nte n s e ultra-violet emis s i o n occurs at 3 .050 A a n d a l s o a bl u e emission at 4,750 A to 4,900 A . to 1 part per 1 00 TIC!
in
L a t t iCI.� tJbsorpt. 1on
l
1 50 0
1800
Fig. I T . !
I . Energy levels in
'P,
2 0 0 0 2 2 0 0 2400 2 6 0 0 2 B O O A. I A )
.. ---�-- - -· -·-- ·-
-
_ _
_ _
_
Absorption spectra of KCI(Tl) (After Seit::) of KCl
The valence band (or filled ba n d ) is a s s u m e d to be d ue to
the Cl- i o n s . e m p ty) is a scri be d to l eve l s of the neutral K a to m s . The transitio n of an e l ectr o n from valence band to condu ction b a nd corre spo n d s to its mi gra t i on from the valence sh ell o f th e Cl - ion to the outer shell of a K + ion which thus becomes a
the matrix lattice
The co nd u c t i o n band (normally
p o s iti o ns of t h e bands relative t o th e zero of poten taken to i nfini ty ou t s id e th e crys tal) are d escribed by t h e v al u e s x a n d 'If' respectively (see Fig. I I . 2) : x is the electronic affi n i ty of the solid : it is the work obtained in taking an electron fro m i nfinity to th e bottom of the cond ucti on band o f the crystal . VJ is the separati on or extraction energy : it is the work done in re m ov i ng an electron fro m t h e top of the valence b an d to an i n fi nite d i s t a nce outside t h e crystal .
neutral ato m .
T h e energetic
t i al (electron
hv
1p --x
Emission and absorption spectra
33
i s the width o f the forbidden energy gap. a method o f ca lc u lat ing 1p and x by c o n si d eri n g the energy balance in a cycle w hich for 1p c on si sts of removing the C l - i o n from the crys ta l in o rd e r to rem ove its electron =
Mott and Gur ney h a ve d evel o pe d
K - - - r' j
__ _
i
-
--- - �
C L- -- -- -
I
7t:?rt') of p otwr tial
.
Fig. 11.2 Energy levels in KCI(T{). The filled band due to the K+ ions is situated below the valence band
a nd th e n p ut tin g it back into th e c ry s tal For x a K + ion is removed i n o rd e r to add an electron to it and th e n it is also put b a c k into the crystal. This ena b l es 1J! a n d x t o be determined fro m the electro n affinity of chlorine and the i on iza ti o n p o te n ti al of free K atoms which a re known from exp e ri m ent The res u l t is .
.
and
so
1f!
R:J
9 · 5 eV
hv
=
and
1p - x,
=
x R:J 0· 1
eV
9·4 eV
which c o rresp o n d s to a long wavelength absorption limit of 1 , 3 1 0 A . 2 . Energy levels o f the free thallium ion
The g roun d state of the Tl + i on is an 1S state (a central core outside which are two 6s electrons (6s 2 ). The first excited state is a P state (6s 6p). From Hund's r u l e we ass ume that the lowest state of t h e 6s 6p con fi gu ra t i on is a trip l et state 3P at a lower energetic position than the singlet 1P becau s e of the sign of the exchange integ ral (th e inverse is true fo r nuclear spectra using the model of M . Mayer) . The effect of spin-orbit inte racti on is to lift the dege n e racy of t h e triplet state, the state with the lowest J value b ei n g the least altered , i.e. the electron spin being a n ti para l l el to the orbital moment. The e n e rgy level scheme of Fig. U.3 is o b ta i n e d the energy val ues given -
there being fro m experiment.
,
34
Seitz a n d
Luminescence in Crystals
Williams associate the observed absorption bands for
Tl + ions in the crystal with the following transitions :
1S0 -- 1P1 (f ;: 1 ) 1 S0 -- 3P2 (very weak) (f ;: 0· 1 ) 1S0 -- 3P1 T h e transition 1S0 -- 3P1 being a singlet t o triplet state transition will be forbidden if the cou pling is purely of Russell-Saunders type : spin o rbital interaction is considered as a very weak perturbation. t 1 ,960 A 2, 100 A 2,500 A
eV
: 10
'P.I ·· - ····--- - -- - - -- -- - � 9 Jp
i
I
S1ngle electron s: a t fl s
Wi�h !!.tchange
Fig. I I . 3 Energy levels
�o 1
3
i 2
With spm orbitai coupling
_ __ __ _ _
1 1
j0
of the free Ti+ ion
Actually, in heavy atoms it is allowed t with an oscillator strength (f) less than that for the transition 1S0 -- 1 P1 which indicates partial jj coupling. The ratio of oscillator strengths will be about 30 for the free Tl+ ion : (the intercombination transition is relatively enhanced in the crystal). The mercury line at 2,537 A used for excitation in this band (1S0-- 3P1) is due to a transition between the same spectroscopic states 3P1 -- 1 S0 (Hg and Tl + have the same electronic structure).
t It wil be remembered t h a t in Russel i Saunders coupling or L . S coupling the orb ital moments I couple to give a resultant L and the spins s to give a resul tant S and only then is spin orbital coupling introduced to give J = L + S. This is o n l y valid for weak s p in - o rb i tal coupling : if the coupling is strong, then I and s for each electron are coupled (j = 1 -1- s) and the va r iou s j's are then added, this being known as jj coupling. t The trans i t ion life time is of the o r de r of J O ' sec and so the use of thall ium activated alkali halides as scintillators gives a shorter life time than that of photo conducting phosphors of the ZnS type ( J o • to w • sec).
35
Emission and absorption :,pectra
The transition 1S0 -+ 3P0 is forbidden for all o rd e rs (J 0 to 0) t h e 3P0 l evel constituting a typical electron trap. The transition 1S0 -+ 3P2 is also forbidden but only for a d i po l e approximation : the level 3P2 also forms an electron trap. These tran sitions cease to be forbidden when the Tl + ion is perturbed by a neighbouring Tl+ ion which occurs at higher concentrations. ='
J
3.
=
Location of the ground state 1S0 of TI + in the energy band scheme of KCI
F. E. Williams has calculated the io ni zat io n energy of Tl+ in the c ry s tal :
TI + -+ TI 2 + + conduction electron Outside the crystal this ionization : Tl+ -+ TP+ + free electron requires an energy I equ al to the second ionization potential of thallium, i.e. I = 20· 3 eV. However, i n sid e the crystal the re p l ace m e nt of TJ + by Tl 2 + y i e l d s the energy ae 2 /d and is 8 eV (a is the M ad e lu n g constant, d t h e inter atomic distance). This value is only a first app ro xi m atio n and must be modified to take account of the different polarizabilities of the lattice ions. We obtain the energy x i n taking an electron from i n fi ni ty into the conduction band. From this calculation the ground state for thallium is found to be ae 2
I-(1--x
1 2 eV
below the conduction band : polarization terms reduce this to 9 · 5 eV. The ground state of t h e Tl + ion is thus 0 · 1 eV below the top of the valence band . Since 2, 500 A corresponds to a quantum of about 5 eV, the 3P1 excited state in KCI(Tl) is situated at 9 · 5 - 5 4· 5 eV below the cond uction band. It is this which determines the q ua s i ato m i c nature of the emission transitions in t he phosphor. Excitation with 2, 500 A radiation can excite the Tl + centre without ionizing it : in addition, the energy of 4·5 eV cannot be provided by thermal ionization. However, at high intensities the 2, 500 A can ionize certain Tl + ions already excited by a first quantum : this is stepwise excitation of an electron from valence to conduction band . Besides, KCl can have other levels than those of the Tl + ions (due to F ce n t res pairs of T!+ ions, &c.), some of =
-
,
36
w h ich
Luminescence in Crystals
be i o n ized givi n g a very s m all p r o b a b i l ity of a weak p h o t o the ter m non-photocond ucting was placed in in ve rte d commas in th e t it le) . However, this photoconductivity is not necessary in the p rod u c t i o n of em i ss i o n ; in fact, it perturbs the lumin escence k i ne t i c s, t he freed e l ect r on s b ei n g able to recombine with can
c o nd uct i vity ( t h u s
e m ission centres for intense excitation and for high thall ium concen
recomb i n at i o n results in the same emission ban d s as fo r d i rect excitation of the activator ion ( T e ch . B. Louch tchik and e o -wo r k ers ) ; but the filling o f traps will be tration (Antonov-Romanovsky) . Suc h a
d i fferent . Traps n o t connected with the t ha l l iu m centres will now con tribute to t h e
p h o s ph o r e s ce n ce
decay . The same kind of
n o mena appear u nder X-ray or vacu u m u l t r a -v i o l e t
p h e
e xc ita ti o n .
I I . ABSO RPTION AND EMISSION PHEN O M ENA IN
KCI(TI), T H E C O N F I G U R A T I O N A L C O O R D I N A T E D I A G R A M (Mott a n d Seitz) 1 . Introduction to the model To acco unt fo r the d i fference
lengths :
as
1 S0 -+
111
emiSSion a n d absorption wave
3P1 (ab so rp t i o n)
3P1 -+ 1S0 (emission)
},
}.
=
2, 500
=
3,050
well as the w i dth o f the e mi ss i on a n d a b s orpti o n E at
(values
.
h alf height
at o rdin a ry
_
A A
band s :
0 · 3 eV for absorption 0 · 6 eV for emission
temperatures : the values are
re d u c ed by o ne-half
at 80°K) we must introduce the interaction between th e th all i u m ion
Tl + and the remainder of the c rystal . To a first a pp r o xi matio n we consider the Tl + ion substituted fo r a K + i o n , the six neighbouring Cl - i o n s vibrating about the Tl + ion. We c o n s i d er only the v i b r atio n al mode in whi ch the same d i s t an ce r between the CJ - and TJ + io ns occurs for all Cl- ions. The s ta t e o f t h e system fo rmed by t h e C I - i o n s i nte ra c ti n g with t h e Tl + i o n can be characterized by the d i s t a n ce r cal le d the configurational coordinate. To a sec on d degree o f approximation we must also in t r od u ce the interaction of the six CI - ions with the six n e a r e st K + ions of the lat tice situated o n the same r a d i u s vector at a distance r' from the CI- i o n s . T h i s l ea d s clea rly to a re-definition o f the c o n fi g u ra ti o n a l c o o rd i n ate .
Emission and absorption spectra
The
37
configu rational c u rve o r d i agram is that w h ich defi nes the
potential energy
U(r)
the coordinate
Two curves must be considered : that for the ground
state
r.
of the system Tl+ plus lattice as a function of
oztu (T l + in 1S0 state) and that for the excited state of the Tl +
ions (3P1). It is rarely possible to give such a precise physical meaning to the coordi nate
r
and moreover to be able to calculate the configura
F. E.
tional cu rves.
Williams was able to obtai n both fo r KCl(Tl)
3
4
5
6
7
eV
Fig. 1 I .4 Absorption and emission �pectra of KCI( Tl). Experimental results at room temperature
and this is why it was chosen as an example. G eneral l y, the
can do is
to
b es t
one
s h o w that a system o f configurational curves can b e
drawn to represent t h e experimental results . In several cases, h ow ever, these curves, o nce derived experimentally, can be used to pre dict new phenomena, e.g.
F centre luminescence. We shall examine
the latter later.
In the case of KCI(Tl) Williams uses the Hartree functions for er
and
K+
and calculates those for Tl+. The value of these functions
has since been criticized , in particular by Knox and Dexter, but nevertheless the results obtained are still i n good agreement with the facts. 2. The interaction between TI + and
Cl-
This includes - a Madelung electrostatic term - an exchange repulsion term
EM,
ER,
- a Van der Waals attraction term
Evw,
- a correctio n to the preceding term for the attraction between the
d ipoles induced on the Cl- ions by the perturbation of the lattice
resulting from introd uction of the thallium E1,
- for the excited s t ate a corre cti on Ec to the electrostatic e nergy
due to overlap of th e charge distributions arou nd the different ions.
38
Luminescence in Crystals
We
thus have for the g ro und state :
o/tU
=
ER + Evw+ EM + Er
an d for the excited state : OU•
= E'R + E'vw+ E', - E'r+- Ec +- 6 · 5 eV
6· 5 e V b e i n g the difference in the el ect ronic e n e rgies of the two states t he free thallium ion. It is the correction Ec to the Madelung electrostatic energy due to overlap of the c h arge distributions of t h e Tl + and Cl - ions (overlap w h ich is m u c h l a rge r in t h e excited state) which is r esp o nsi ble for the greater part of the cha nge in the equilibrium position of the ions acco rding to the p a rt icu l a r electro nic state of t he thalliu m i o n and t h u s for the Stokes separation between the abso rption and e miss ion in
band s .
I n t h e p e r fe ct KCl lattice the distance o f t h e K + ion from its near est C l - ion neighbour i s r0 = 3 · 1 4 A in e q ui li b riu m . At this distance fro m the nucleus the n o rmal charge density of the 6s electron of Tl + is o n l y 0· 0 1 , while that of t h e 6p electron is about 0·05 according to Williams's calculations. The overlap of the chlorine and thallium ions is t h u s effectively more important when the latter is in the ex c i t e d P sta te than when it is in the ground state S. Ec added only to the excited state energy is actually the difference in the overlap coulomb energies of the two states. The electrostatic attraction between the Tl + a nd Cl- ions is the resultant of the mutual coulomb repulsion of the nuclei, of the sur rounding electrons and of the attraction of the surrounding electrons of one nucleus for the other nucleus. The correction Ec is the sum of several terms of opposite sign but finally it res ults from the diminu tion in the repulsion of the two electron cl ouds. We consider an e x ternal l ay er of the thallium ion . The part of t h e chlorine electron cloud it includes is not repulsed but is subject to a null effect. There fore the attracti o n between c hl o ri n e and thallium i o n s with partia l e l ec t r o n ic o verl ap is greater t ha n that fo r the net c h a rge e of each co n ce n t rated at the centre of each respective ion. A s a c o n s e q ue nce the distance r between the chlorine and thallium ions in equilibrium is about 0·3 A smaller in the excited state than in the ground state. After Ec the most important terms are ER the exchange repuls ion a n d E,.w the Van der Waals a t t r a ct i o n Ec v a r ie s m o re rapidly with r .
Emission and absorption spectra
39
than Evw but le ss rapidly than ER. It follows that the curve 0k'•(r) is less sharp than '1/"(r), corresponding to a smaller vibrational quan tum for the ions when the thallium is in the excited state. The calculation of the e n er gie s 0U"(r) and crt•(r) is first made for the second n eig hbour K+ ions held in their equilibriu m po s itio n s in the perfect KC! la tt i ce while the different displacements of the CI- ions occur (.6.r r -- r0) . The energies '1 are thus sensibly quad ratic fu nc tions of .6.r : 0?/•· Y(.6.r) ae· u (.6.r-.6.r0)2 + constant 6. r0 is the displacement of Cl- ion s from equilibrium positions in the perfect lattice when a K+ ion is replaced by a TJ + l uminescence centre. The same calculation is t hen made for the d i s pl ace ment .6.r' o f the s econ d ne ighbo u r K + i on s from their normal position i n the per fect KCl latti ce . The energies '1 can then be represented by quad ratic functions of .6.r and 6.r' w i th coefficients assigned to them by the method of least squares : '1f•. u(6. r, .6.r') = Ae· Y(.6.r -6.r0) 2 + B(.6.r' -.6.r0')2 + constant These six K + ions are displaced .6. r' from their equilibrium position .6.r0' by the introduction of the Tl+ ion into the lattice. The coeffi cients A are obviously different fro m the a's. It would be most to use the two coordinates .6.r and .6.r'. However, in order to have only one configurational coordinate, Williams now assumes that for each .6.r value the remainder of the lattice has the equilibrium value .6.r' = .6. r0'. The energies '1 are then only functions of .6.r : '1f•. u(.6. r ) A•· q(6.r -.6.r0) 2 + constant as show n in Fig. II.5. It is clear that such a si m p le approach is only justified if the influ ence of the displacements .6.r' of the second neighbours is small. The pe rturbation resulting from .6.r'�O is no more than a tenth of an electro n volt. If the correction due to second n e i ghbo u r s had been large , then account would have had to be taken of the third neigh bour effects, and so on. Each ti m e a new definition of the configura tional c oo rd i na te 6.r would have had to be made . We thus see that this model is particularly appropriate to calcula tio ns for very localized centres suc h as Tl+ in KCl. For extensive centres such as boron acceptors in silicont it is better to use a mod el =
t Corresponding to absorption bands
at
about 0·04 cV.
Luminescence in Crystals
40
developed by various authors (Huang and Rhys, Pekar, Meyer, &c.) i n which a direct treatment o f the i nteractio n between the centre an d phonons of the perfect crystal is made, w i t hout giving special significance to the coordinates of specific atoms in the crystal. The results obtained by these two approaches arc o ften very si milar. u ev; 6
5
4 2
u9
2
( 1s0)
ar
F i g . 1 1 . 5 Configurational coordinate diagram /or KCI(Tl)
(After Williams, 1951)
D.r is the displacement of the neighbouring Cl- ionsjimn their mean positions in the pe1ject KC/ lattice
For luminescence where the centres are quite localized, more or less as in KCl(Tl), the configurational coordinate model is generally preferable, but with Lax we believe it is not always necessary to attri bute to the oscillators with energies cp;u and Olf• the nature of vibrating ions. Sometimes as a first approximation it may be possible to intro d uce only one configurational coordinate r, which can be described by a complicated function of the coordin ates r, of several io ns in the crystal : r = f(ri> r 2 , r") •
•
•
However, even if r exists, it will not be a linear fu nctio n of the co ordinates r11• From a theoretical aspect (see page 52) the general situation is that a configurational coordinate scheme is a convenient representation of the abso rption and emission characteristics over not too large a temperature range, but for large ranges the parameters such as ionic mass and oscillator frequencies must be modified . Experimental accu racy h as not yet revealed such variations.
Emission and absorption spectra
41
In the diagram of Fig. 11.5 we obtain the mean frequencies of absorp tion and emission v0 by using the vertical transitions hv0 (Franck Condon principle) from the minimum of the curve Cf/Y(r) of the ground state for absorption and from the minimum of the excited state curve 0/t• for the emission. Thus for absorption 1 S0 � 3P1 ; hv0 = 5 · 48 eV calculated (Fig. T I . 5) compared wi th 5 · 0 eV i n experim ent (Fig. li.4) and for emission 3P1 � 1S0 ; /zy0 = 3·9 eV calculated and 4·06 eV experimenta l . The vibrational quantum of the ground state is hYu = 0·0 1 6 eV and that of the excited state h1'• = 0·0 1 eV. The mean number of vibra tional qu anta thermally emitted after absorption in order for the system to fall into the minimum o f Cf/• is Sa = 41 , whil e after lumin escence emission the number emitted t o return to the minimum of 0/t" is s. = 67. The calculation described above is that made initially by F. E. Williams ( 1 9 5 1 ) . Since this time , many improvements in the theory have been suggested by different workers, ch i efl y the re-normaliza tion of the wave function for the thallous ions in the excited p- state , when these ions are introduced into the crystal, and the modification of the spin - orbit coupling affecting the U (eV l separation between the 1P and 3P states. These corrections are extremely sensitive to crystalline interactions. Configura Tnplet state tional curves much more intricate than the curves of Fig. II.5 have thus been proposed , including a pronounced mixing of singlet and triplet states. However, it is worthy of note that the last paper by Johnson and Williams ( 1 960) comes back again towards the simplicity of the initial 0 - o t. - 0 2 0 • 0 2 6r ( $. ) model. The configuration cu rve for the Fig. II.6 New, simplifed ground state 1S0 remains u nchanged , configuration model for 180, but the 3P1 curve suffers slight changes, 3P1 and 1P1 states inKC/(Tl) and the agreement with experiment is (Johnson and Williams, 1960) better. 3. Position of the absorption and emission band maxima
Luminescence in Crystals
42
An o t h e r fu n d am e n t a l c al cu lat i o n , i . e . using also the wave fu nc
tions of
Tl + i o n s
as starti ng-point, has been m ade by Kristoffe l
grou nd state 1 S0 and emitting l evel 3P1 a r e con sidered , a n d in the s a m e w a y as i n J o h n s o n a n d W i l l i a m s ' s c a lc u l a t i o n s , but o n ly t h e total l y symmet ric vi brati o n s of the e r - i o n s are considered . However, t h e ch oice o f the wave fu nct i o n s for the p-state i s s l i g h t l y different and takes into acc o u n t their angular depe n den c e . This ca l c ul a ti o n leads to a smaller d isp l ac e m e n t o f th e ions than i n th e J o h n s o n and Williams th e o ry . The ag re e m e n t with e xp e ri m e n t is a li tt l e better t h a n in the W i l liam s calcu latio n of 1 9 5 1 but not so good as in the Johnson and W i ll i a m s model of 1 960. H owever, for ( 1 9 59). The s a m e
t h e s e three calculations this agreement is as good as it may reasonably
be h o p e d to be from theories u s i n g only one configu rational co o r d i n at e .
TABLE
II. 1
the numerical values of the ionic vibrational quanta hJ't and hve, and the displacemen ts of t h e ions r0, for the three theories described in the text above Comparison between
hve
hvt
Williams, 1 9 5 1 J ohnson and Williams, 1 960 Kristoffe1, 1 9 59
0·0 1 6 eV 0·0 1 6 eV 0·0 1 9 eV
ro
0 · 0 1 0 eV 0·0 1 2 eV 0 ·0 1 5 eV
0·30 0·26 0· 1 6
A
A A
Other absorption and em ission bands in KC/(Tl)
While the 2,500- A a b s or p ti o n band
is
d e sc ri bed as d u e to the
1 S0 -+ 3P1 intercombination t r a ns iti o n , the intense ab s orp t i o n band at 1 ,960
A i s connected with the
a l l o w e d 1S0 -+ 1P1 transition
34) . In a d d i t i o n to the 3 , 050 A - em i ss i o n (3P1 -+ 1S0),
i s observed
i n the region 4,750-4,900
(pa ge a blue emission
A.
In the initial Williams th eo r y , this blue emission was ascribed to the 1P1 -+ 1S0 t r a n s iti on . Thus the long-wave emission band was
associated wi t h t h e sho r t- w ave a bs orpti o n ban d . This huge Stokes
(r0 � 0·5 A) fun dam e n tal calculation had then been
shift might be explained by assuming a much larger change in the
equil i b rium configuration of the ions for the 1P1 state than for the 3P1 state, but no
m a d e on t h is p o i n t . The state of a ffa irs is now more satisfactory s i nce the recent dis covery, by Eby and Teegard en and by J o h n s o n a n d Will iams, of a
Emission and absorption spectra
43
new emission band centred at 2,470 A ; this band is excited by i rradia tion in the 1 ,960-A absorption band . Thus the postulated sch e m e i s n o w t h e fol l owing :
2, 500 A absorpt i o n 3 ,050 A e mi ssi o n 1 ,960 A absorption 2,470 A emission
I So -+ 3p1 -+ rso -+ l p l -+
3p1 ISO rpl
ISO
In con t ras t to the earlier model, the configu rati onal coord inate cu rves for the triplet and si n gle t emitting states are very similar. This 2,470-A em i ssio n was not previously observed , because it fal l s within the 2,500-A absorption band, and thus the emitted light is strongly reabsorbed . The visible blue emission remains for t he presen t unexplained. Johnson and Williams suggest that it originates also from isolated Tl + i on s , but in a different excited or vibrational state. Other emission bands appear at high thallium concentrations, arising from TJ + pairs and other imperfections, such as molecular complexes of the form Tl(Cln) (P. Pringsheim, Ewles and J os hi). K C ! and TIC! may be mix ed in all proportions. Sunit Chandra Sen has shown that in such mixtures two phases exist :
(a) KC! activated by a large amount of thallium, in which one recognizes the emission bands described by the above autho rs ; (b) TIC! contaminated by potassium. TIC! seems to be luminescent in the pure state, the luminescence being due to structural defects (Sokolov and T olstoi) . Potassium acts here as a que nche r of this luminescence. The 3,050-A luminescence emission from isolated TJ+ centres in KC! is not polarized, except at temperatures near that of liquid helium (Klick and Dale Compton). This polarization is obtained when the exciting radiation is itself polarized. Theoretically, the spatial degeneracy of the centre may be removed when it is placed in the crystal lattice (Jahn-Teller effect), but the energy difference be tween these sub-levels is surely extremely small. However, at liquid helium temperature a preferential orientation of the centre may ap pear. The observed polarization is for centres distorted along the (100) d irections . On the other hand, the blue emiss i on is n ot polarized, even at liq uid helium temperature.
44
Luminescence in Crystals
a s T l+- pai r s , p robably shows much m o re pronounced
The emission from centres whose structure is fundamentally asym metric, s u c h
polarization effects.
I.
I l l . C A L C U LATI O N O F T H E E M I S S I O N A ND A B S O RPT I O N SPECTRA F R O M T H E CONFI G U RATIONAL COORDINATE M O D E L Statement of the problem
We have
seen how we can ob ta i n from the configurational co ordin ate
curves using the F r an ck- C o n don p ri nciple. We now c o nside r the form and magnitude of these bands. model the positions of the maxima of the absorption and emission
For the osci llators
-1fu
and o/• we have equi-distant vi brational
which we den ote by the symbol m i n the ground state and n i n the excited s t a te . In KCl(fl) and with t h e p r ese n t atio n d u e to Wi llia m s these arise fro m vibrational l eve l s of the Cl - i ons (co u pled to the rest of the lattice) surrounding the Tl + activator ion . For the tran sition from the vibrational level n of the excited state to the l e v el m of the gr ou nd state there is an emission o f a l i n e of fr e q u e n cy ln•nm levels
·
for all possible values of n and m forms the emission band . The same ideas a pp l y to the absorption. In practice, the ban d s cannot be resolved into l ines since the li ne s . 1 ' n m a re broadened by other vibrational modes of the lattice which are not taken account of i n the d iag ra m h aving a single configura t iona l coordinate. However, in one sa mp l e of Zn2Si01(Mn), C. Vlam has found a re s o l u t i o n of the emission spectrum into 1 9 lines wh e n the tem pe ra tu re is lowered to l 5°K. There is a non-zero band width at absolute zero : t h e emission transition begins from n 0, but because of t h e zero poi n t energy o f vibration can be to variou s o f the m level s . The explanation of the residual large wid t h (one or m o r e tenth s o f an electron volt) of t h e se bands at abso lute zero is one of the s u cce s s e s o f this model . The idea of i n tr o d u c i n g the ze r o - p o i n t energy in c onsi d e ratio n of l u m i nescence character is ti c s was due to M. Sch o n . If the temperat u re is suffi ciently high, then the band width increases because the emission transition can occu r fro m l evel s with n � 0. Experiment i n d i cate s that the form of The assembly of these 'lines'
=
Enu:uion and absorption spectra
45
the absorption and e m i s s i o n bands, a(hv) an d J(/w) respectively, general s en s ibly gau ssia n W e first define t h e notation used : .
The parameters of a gaussian distribution : If l !hv)
0
__
I(hv)
I I I
I _L_L _
�
is in
is a ga u ss i an dis-
�
Fig. I J . 7 Tire Gaussian distribution rr
rr
tribution about a mean value hv0 , the normalized distribution i s given b y
I(h 1')
=
� ex p
aV2n
[- (hv l�'o)2]
J J(hv)d(lw)
wi th
hv
and
hl'o
=
T h e mean square d ev i a ti on is
=
2a
=
J
I
I(hv)/IJI(/(hv)
1:1(hv) JJ(hv-l�v0)2l(hv)�(�l0 =
=� a
The cu rve J(h1') is s ymme t r ic a l abo ut the mean energy and h as points of inflexion for hv = hv0 ±a. T h e width at half m ax i mu m is 2L where [2 2a2 log. 2
h v0
=
2. Calculation of energy distribution in the spectrum
This can be made as for diatomic molecules. We set out the expres
s
i o n fo r the l i gh t i n tensity for t h e d i pole case which is
f(hl'nm)
_ ·-
64n411nm 4
-� I P.nm I 2
a n d we assume that f/nm is proportional (Condon ap p roximation).
to t h e
overl ap i n tegral
Luminescence in Crystals
46
th e ions, then we separate the e l ec t ron ic wave function tf>(x) and the vibrational wave fu ncti on 'lfJ(r) a n d thus postulate If
of
x
are the electron coordinates,
The factor
Pnm =
f
r
th e configurational coordin ate
t/>.* (x)v•n*'(r - r0)extf>a(X)1p,.,/'(r) dx dr ,f l ea =
f f,*(x)ex
depends only on the electronic states e a n d
dx g,
and s o
we
h a ve
To simplify m atte rs we change the no tat io n by reference to para graph 11 above ; the origin of the configurational coordinate cu rve u
I
h V0
u9
Fig.
·
0
r
Calculation of e m iss ion spectra: v0 is the frequency at the band maximum; >'n m is one of the possible emission frequencies
II.8
corresponds to the minimum in ct/q an d
excited state m i n i m u m of crt• rel ative to ct/9 :
is the displacement of t he the g ro u n d state minimum
r0
Emission and a bsorption spectra
47
The functions 'lflm0(r) and 'lfl,/(r - r0) are thus the eigenfuncti ons of
t he harmonic oscillator V'm"(r)
Nm e xp
[ -1(�Hm(�J - n
where H111 is the Hermitian polynomial, Nm a normalization fa cto r and au is the classical a m plitude of the ze r o p oi t vibration : ==
•
--
v'
au - = -
h
h M(J)u
,
= --
=
J�
liw0 is the vibrational quantum of the i o n s in the ground state : analo gous notations are used for the excited state. M is the mass of those ions which are vibratin g i.e. the mass of the six Cl - ions in KCI(TI) to a first approximatio n To a second de gree of approximation W i lliams gives 1'a
hvu
Wu
=
=-=
.,
Mc1* = Mc1 + a 2MK a being a couplin g constant equal to 0·4 3 . M = 6Mc1*
where
The quantum number m reached after e m i ssion is high (and i n the same way the number n reached after absorption) ; we h ave seen that it is about 67 for KC l (Tl) Thus J 'lflm0(r) J 2 tends towards th e classical density d i strib uti on which possesses a very sharp maxim u m aroun d the classical ampl i tud e rm given by 3. Calculation using a semi-classical approximation
.
0/IU(rm)
=
tkurm2
=
(m +!)hvu
In contrast, the initial state of the transition must be treated quantum mech ani cal ly Case for low temperatures. A t low temperatures the emission wil l begin from th e state n = 0, the only one occupied i n thermal equi
librium : Now
'lflo
.
is a gauss i an function and thus so also is p,,
j 'lflo" ( r - ro) f 2 , 1
f lom
=
No 2 exp
[
., 1 - = co n s t exp
.
I
L
-
( -0.--. )2] rm - r0
48
Luminescence in Crystals
is the vibrational amplitude at t he zero-po int ene rgy :
a.
"
By
qiP(rm) · - 1'19(r0)
T h u s we obtain The
li
=
li
VkeM Mwe differentiation of qig(r) in the regi o n of r = Oe"
"
llom"
moment
while the
a,
of
m o m en t
the
=-'
----
=
=
--
- h(l'om 1'0)
co n s t .
e xp
=
r0 :
k0r0(rm ·- r0)
[ (h1'0 m-h110)2] f.:.
2 " " 'a ro"a, ·
emission band is given by the expression 2a,2 kaz,.oza.z =
aa of the a b s o rpti o n band 2a"2 k.2ro2auz
is
g ive n by
=
We can alter these formulae to indicate the mean number s. [ = 67 in KCJ(TI)] of thermal vibrational quanta emitted after the photon
h 1 •0 = qf 0 SJn•0 -l- kar02 Sehl'a and so a.2 s.(h1·a) 3/lw, for the e m i ssi o n ban d . I n a s i m i l a r way, if we i n trod uce S,. [ '"' 4 1 for KCI(Tl)] , the n umber =
=
u
Sa h ve l - - - - - - - I
of
thermal
and
so
Fig. I I . 9
-
- - - ----
r
Introduction of the parameters Se and S,_,
vibrational quanta emitted after absorption of a p ho t on
ln•0 1k,r0 2 "
Gu ..
= =
@'o+ Sah1'e Sa111'e
(h1•,) 3 = Sa-- hl'u
Emission
In
the case w here
the vibrational frequencit:s a,
aa
The
and absorption !!pectra a;
Sa = S,
a 2 = S(h vphonons)2
a nd
v0
=
S
v,
a rc
49
equal
wid ths of the a b s o rpt i o n and emission bands are t h u s the same. KCI(TI) 1'• a n d 1 'v are q u ite d iffere n t : we h ave a l read y
H owever, fo r
se e n that
and s o �
h1•0
3
=
(Johnson, Wil l iams, O'n
:=:
to
4
0·0 1 6 eV
near
and
hl'e = 0·0 1 0 eV
This rat i o
to absol u te zero, which
S t u d er) .
is
is so e x p e r i me n ta l l y
only about 2
at o rdinary
Casefor any temperatures. The fr ac t i o n of excited centres to be found in the vibrational state n if t h e r m a l eq u i l i b r i u m is attained b et w een
temperatures .
absorption
and
so I
and e m i s s i o n t
,nnm
fi n
1 2 wi l l
is
�'-'
exp ( - - n/11',/kT) •o
_'2: exp (-- nh11e/kT)
" " ()
be affected
l(hvnm)
by t h e factor Pn
Pn
i 1Pn"(rm r0) 1 2
and wc then have
The e m i s s i o n i n tensity at freq u ency v can b e gi ven as a d ou b l e sum m ati o n over n and m , remembering that En" - Emu hJI. T h i s means that
n
m
s h o w t h a t the
OC
distribution remains ga u s s i a n . We use the
Franck-Condon principle, that is, we assume that emission occurs the position of the i o n s t and this position co rreWe now
with o ut change in
t Evi dence for this rapid ' ther:nostating' of the excited centres by the crystal lattice is given by the fact that the l uminescence quantum yiel d for KCl(Tl) is independent of the wavelength of the exciting light, as long as i t falls i n t o the 1 S0 -+3P abs o rpt ion band of the TI+ ions (Louchtchik, Tech. , Louchtchik, N. E. 1 and Shvarts). Th is is t r u e even if the exciting radi a ti on is s i tuated on the long wave side of the absorption band, for wh ich (as a result of the overlap between emission and absorption bands) part of the emission results from an anti-Stokes p roces s . � Actually Franck and Condon did not give this p ri n cipl e in such a restricted form. It is the mo s t intense lines which are emitted without change in the position of the ions. We are limited to a consideration of the latter.
50
Luminescence in Crystals
sponds to the cl assical vibrational a mp l i t u e
d
We can then replace
r"'
as defined above.
by Furthermore, we c a n replace the s u mmation over t h e fi nal vibrational states (m) by an i ntegral :
l(h v)
cc
f [LP" /
tp,."(r,. - r0)
"
/2]o[Oll'(rm)-"71°(rm)-111J dr,.
makes use o f the Mehler formula for the Slater summations of the harmonic oscillator :
The s umm a t i on
'\
11 = 0
n2"n !
H,,z(x) e -x'
where We h a ve thus
'�p,.
and
l(hv)
=
IX =
1 . ) 1 1 2 exp sm h IX
hl'e/k T
1 tp,/(rm r0) 1 � =
ex p
f [ -1k.(rm exp
cc
r0) 2 .
tanh
[- x2 (�2)]
[
�
ta n h
(;�)J
X
t an h
o (Ul/•(rm)
(�)]
O/t11(rm) - hv)
d r,.
We now take a new variable x = Ol! •(r,.,.) -
integration and obtain
I(h v)
cc
h ave
ex p
f f(x)o(x - hv) finally { exp [
a n d since we
f [
I(hv)
- -}k. (r -- r0) 2 •
cc
f(hv)
dx
••
ta n h
;�·�J ��}., =h•
r being related to the emission fr e q u e ncy by t h e linear relation
-h(v--Y0) = kur0(r- r0)
The exponential factor gives an esse n tially gaussian form to J(hv). A t high temperatures l(hv)
cc
e xp
[
J ��
Emission and absorption spectra
51
which is a classical formula, the exponential being that of the Boltz mann distribution , and gives the probability that the emitting system will be in the configuration r allowing by means of the Franck Condon principle the emission of a photon hv. This classical approximation w a s used by Williams for KCl(Tl) to which it applies wel l at liquid air temperature (90°K) which is suffi cie nt l y large. For KCl(Tl) the quantum hv. i s very small (0·0 1 0 eV). In contrast for CaWOlPb) it reaches 0·05 eV and Vlam has found that the classical approximation is onl y valid at temperatures w ell a b o v e ro o m te m pe ra ture
.
At T = 0 the hyperbolic term tanh
( ;�)
is eq u al to u ni ty and we
obtai n the expression first derived for low temperatures. Finally the band width L varies with temperature according to the relation
L.(T)
[
L.(o) tanh
A ty pical example of this variation is gi v e n in Fig. I I . l O. The theoretical curve has a point of inflexion and the width L(T) finally =
-
11 2
:: � Fig.
0
1 0 0 2 0 0 3 0 0 400 5 0 0
of luminescence emission band width (at lwl}: b and height) with temperature for a Ca WOlPb) phosphor
II. I 0
Variation
varies as vT (classical approximation). However, in the fi g ure this temperature re gi o n is not reached . For the width of the ab s o rption band lrv. is replaced by hva in the a b ove form u l ae : (After Vlam)
La( T)
==
La(O) [tan h
-l/2
The introduction of the factor 'tanh' may be understood in the fol l o wing manner : in the expression for the moment of the emission
52
Luminescence in Crystals
band, fo r i nsta nce, established above for the case of emission at O " K : 2a.2 = ku 2ro 2a. z
amplitude o f vibration o f the ions a t the zero-point energy a . must now be replaced by the mean square value a.(n) of all the ampli tudes in t h e d i fferen t vi brational s tates n. T h ese a m p l itu des a re d e fined by J.k.a.2 (0 -H)Izl'e the
Jk.a.(n) 2
This
sum mation
=
(n + J.)hv. a. � a, (n) = v"i:,p"a-;(n)2 =
( ) [ ;;�J The case \\'here the configurational is
straightfo rward a, n
=
a• .
and
tanh
space
leads to -112
is many-dimensional. I n the
c a s e , we have seen ( page 39) that several coordinates must be used i n order to describe the configuration of the ions interacting with the luminescence centre. W e shal l assume th at the p ote ntial energies have been put in t o the d i ag o na l form : general
qlu(r1, r2
ql•(r1, r2
•
•
•
)
)
=
U0u + 2: J.ku;(r; - r;0u) 2 i
U0• + 2: -!ke;(r; - r;0•) 2
T h i s is i n d e e d the case in Williams's calculation, with 2 coordinates, r 1 describing the position of t h e Cl - i o ns neighbouring the Tl + a c ti vator ion, and r2 describing the position of the next n e a res t ne i gh •
•
•
=
i
bours, i . e . K + ions. The
position of the maximum of the emission band is then given by
hvo
and the
=
qto• - Olfou - 2:-!-ku;(r;o• - r;ou) Z
corresponding m oment by la . o
2
ta rili (h;;•j2kT) l t is seen that, th e o r e t i ca l l y , this result cannot be o b tained by means of a one-dimensional c o n fi gu rat i o n d iagram , except w h e n all the fre quencies v,C are equal. However, for KCl(Tl) t h e difference between the results obtained in this way and the results obtained by Williams and eo-workers in el iminati n g the se c o n d c o n fi g u ra t i o n al coordinate r2 is almost i ns ignifica n t (about 0 · 1 5 e V in the position of the ba nd) . The general case, wh e re Ol/• and q1u are in a non-diagonal tensor fo rm , h as been treated by Kubo a n d Toyozawa, and by K. Maeda
(1 959).
=
Emission and absorption spectra 4 . Quantum-mechanical calculation for
tions u. and u, are equal
the
case
53
where the
ion vibra-
We put hve hvu = fwJ as t h e vibrational quantum for th e ions and the frequ e n cy of the e mi tte d photon. We c a n now gi ve a rigorous calculation o f the o v e r l a p i nt e gra l =
v
J(hvnm) =
f'f/ln*'(r-r0)'rp,/'(r) dr
o cc u r s in t h e matrix el em e n t /lnm (J. Ruamps).t We have seen t h a t t h i s as s ump tio n is not val id for KCI(TI) (hv. 0·0 1 eV ; hvu 0·0 1 6 eV), bu t it is al l righ t fo r F ce n t res i n the same KC! crystal where from Klick we have hv. R: hva R: 0·0 1 1 eV We have thus a si ngle pa ra m e ter S which is th e mean number o f th e rmal vibrational quanta emitted after the op tic al transition resu l t i n g in ab so r pt io n or emission of a photo n . S is given by w h ich
=
=
f n e m is s i o n the line iS Of about a frequency
1-kr0 2
and in ab s o rpti on
hv0
=
=
Sliw
U0- Siiw
Vo
given
by
The Stokes s h i ft between absorpti on and e mi ss ion is thus 2Sho> . U0 is a l w ay s the electron ic energy difference between the g r o u n d and ex cited states . Consider the emission, for e x a m pl e . An e m i ssion of fre q u ency Ynm occu rs by tra n s i ti o n from a vibrational s tate n to a vibra tional s ta te m, th e tra n s i ti o n b ei n g followed by e mi s s i o n of p m n vibrational quanta (mean value o f p S) : =
overlap integral J(hv,m) is given hvnm
The
ii ,/'( S)
=
=
a
U0 + (n + -})liw - (m + -})liw
=
An11(S); (p fu nction : -S. S! P] LnP(S) [n!etn +p) AnP (S)
J(hv,m,)
=
bei n g a n orm al Laguerre
by
U0 - pnw
formula d u e to Erdelyi =
m - n)
=
t In a recent p u b li cat i on (1 960), J. Ruamps has described an extension of t h i s metho d for the case hve =F hvg. The form o f the emision band /(h•) c a nno t be e x plic i tly derived, but the ex p ress i o n s of the first and second m ome n ts are given as developments in series. In ad d i t i on let us remark that the anharmonicity effects arc probably les im portant for t he case of luminescence centres i n a soli d than for the spectra of diatomic molecules. However preci se computations must take these effects into account. See the paper by Rebane and Sild, quoted i n the bibl iography .
,
c
,
54
Luminescence
w h ere
Ln P (S) level :
can be emitted by transition fro m
v
only depends on p.
1'
!(hv)
,
Crystals
=
However, the mean frequency any n
in
T hu s we h av e
n = oo
o:
[An11(S)F
1l = O p = const.
e -no:
e
ncx
"
(/. is , as pre v i o u s ly given by !iwjkT. This sum mation is ma d e by u s i n g the Myller-Lebedefr fo rm ula :
J(hv)
0:
e Pa./ 2e S coth (a./2)]
P
(
.
S
.
smh (a/2)
)
If n = 1 /(ea.- 1), the m e an number of vibrational quanta excited at temperature T, we can then w ri te
!(hv)
where
i.e.
lv(x) is
the
0:
e - S(•H llJP [2SVfz(n + I )]
Bessel fu nction with complex argument
lp[2Sv'n (n T 1)]
=
oo [svrz(n + I ) 281., L s !(s+p) ! J -
, ,� o
-
------
-
,
i-7'J11(ix),
-
This formula is due to Huang and Rh y s Pekar, Lax, Meye r, O'Rourke, &c. We have obtained it by using the co nfi gu ra ti o n al co ordinate model, but it is u s u ally derived by using the model where the interaction between centre and lattice is obtained by rep re s e nti ng the la tt e r by its as sembly of ph onons (c f. para . II.3) ; !iw is then the pho ton energy in the perfect lattice i nstead of the vibrational q ua nt u m for the ionic neighbours of t h e centre. Apart from this detail the formulae obtained are identical . According
to Klick the configu rational coo rdinate model is the ce n t res : we h av e seen that the common value of liw. and liwa wh ich gives the best i n terpretatio n of the observed spectra is 0·01 1 eV , which for the opti ca l branch of the perfect lattice vibrations of KC! (optical phonons) is 0·028 eV. We shall not give the calculati ons for the model of Huang and Rhys and Pek ar, but simply indicate that each term in the summation for JP appears as a c o n t ri bution to I(hv) from the transitions in which better one for F
Emission and absorption spectra
55
quantum a n d s+p ga i n a quantum a n d the total effected by a n emission of p ph o n o n s. We can verify that the mean value of p is i nd eed equal to S ; the mean value of p 2 is, according to Lax s oscillators lose a transition is
-
p2
such
S(2n + 1 )
that the moment a 2 a2
=
=
of I(kv)
f (hv-hl'o)2/(lrv)
=
S coth
2k T
has the value
d(hv)
=
[ (J;T)J -I
S(/iw)2 tanh
which agrees with the expressions obtained b y the semi-classical approach for this moment at absolute zero and for its v a ri at i o n with temperature. When x 2SVn(rz + 1) is large compared w i th unit (n or S l a rge) we have the asymptotic form =
lp(x) -+
e"'
e -P'/2:1:
V2nx I(hv) is thus a gaussian functio n centred on p S. Not only the m omen t a2 but the form of the emission band are identical to those obtai ned in the semi-classical approximation. This expression for I'P is al re ad y accurate t o 5 per cent i f x 4. =
=
BIBLIOG RAPHY
I. Structure of KCI(Tl) Energy levels in KC! HOWLAND , L . P . ( 1 958) 'Band structure and cohesive energy of KCl', Phys. Rev., 109, 1 927. MoTT, N. F. and GURNEY, R. W . ( 1 948) Electronic Processes in Ionic Crystals, 7 1 , 80. Clarendon Press, Oxford. (1 939) 'An i nte rp re t a tio n
Energy levels in
SEITZ, F .
Faraday
KCI(Tl)
Soc., 35, 79.
of c rys tal luminescence', Trall.S·.
11. Absorption and emission phenomena in KCI(Tl). Experimental V. V. (1 942) 'Th e mechanism of l u m in e s cence of phosphors', J. of Phys. U.S.S. R., 6, 1 20 ; 7, 1 53 . B UTLER, K . H . ( 1 9 59) ' Fl uo re s cence of thal l i u m -act i vated h a l ide phosph o rs', J. Electrochem. Soc. , 103, 508.
A NTONOV- ROMA NOVSKY,
Lumin escence in
56
EBY,
J.
( 1 9 59)
Crystals
E . a n d T E E G A R D E N , K . J . ( 1 9 59). Q u o t e d by (see below) .
EwLE s , J .
Knox, R. S.
a n d Jos H I , R . W . ( 1 960) 'The l u m i n e s ce nce o f thallium
activa ted potassium ch l o ri d e p h o s p h o r s ' , ?ro e . Ror. Soc . ,
358.
A
254,
HUTTEN, E . and P R I N G S H E I M , P. ( 1 948) 'A new method preparing st r o ngl y lumin esce n t t h a l l i u m a c tivated a l k a l i h a l i d es a n d some properti es of t h ese p h o s p h o r s ' , J. Chem. Phys. , 1 6, 24 1 . .T O H N S O N , P . D . and W t LL ! A M S , F . E. ( 1 9 54) ' E flect of p re s s u re o n the optical a b s o rp t i o n o f t h e activa t o r sys t e m i n K CI(T l ) ' , f'!Jys. H I RSH LOFF of
Rev. , 95,
69.
K u c K , C. C. a n d D A LE C O M P T O N , W. ( 1 958) ' P o l a rized l u m i nes cen t e m i ss i o n fro m KCI(Tl) a t low t e m p e ra t u res', J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 7, 1 70.
L O U C H T C H I K , N . E . and L O U C IH C H I K , T e c h .
scopy of the luminescence centres in by h om ologous series of ions' ,
B . ( 1 9 6 0) ' S p e c t r o
alkali halide crystals activated
Opt ics and Spectr., 8,
44 1 .
Lou cHTCHIK, Tech. B . , LIIDY A , G . G . , Y A E K , I . V . and T I I S LER ,
( 1 9 60) 'The mechanism of the recombination luminescence Optika i Spektr. , 9, 70 ; Optics and Sp ectr. , 9, 35. P A T T E R S O N , D. A. a n d K LI C K , C . C . ( 1 9 57) 'Emission a n d excita tion spectra of KCl(Tl) at low temperatures', Phys. Rev., 105, 40 1 . P R I N G S H E I M , P . (1 942) ' Fluorescence and phosph orescence o f thal lium-activated potassium halide phosphors', Rev. Mod. Phys., 1 4 , 1 32. S C H U L M A N , J. H . , CLAFFY, E . W . and P O TT E R , R. J. ( 1 957) 'Con E. S .
of a cti v at e d alkali halide crystals',
centrati o n dependence o f quantum efficiency of l u m i n esce n ce in KCl(Tl)', Phys. Re v . ,
108, 1 398. A. and T O L S T O I , N . A. ( 1 960) ' T h e luminescence o f thallous chloride', Optika i Spek tr. , 9, 42 1 ; Op tics and Spectr., 9 ,
S O KOLOV , V . 2 1 9.
CH A N D R A S E N , S . ( 1 959) 'Some aspects of the luminescence CaF2(Ce, Mn) and KCI + TI C I phosphors'. Thesis, I n d i a n
S UNIT
of
I n st i tute o f Tech n o l o gy, Kharagpu r .
Computation of the configurational coordinate diagram for KCI(TI) J O H N S O N , P . D . and WILLT A M S , F . E . ( 1 960) 'Simplified con figura t i o n a l coordin ate m o d el fo r KCI (Tl)', Phys. Re v . , 1 17, 964.
Emission and absorption spectra
57
K A M I M U R A , H . a n d S u G A N O , S . ( 1 959) 'Luminescence processes in the KCI(TI) phosp h o r i n
s p ace ' , J. Phys .
a multid i m e n s i o n al co n fi gu rati o n a l
So c . Japan , 14, 1 6 1 2.
i n te raction in alkali h a l i d e phospho rs ' , Phys . Rev . , 1 1 5, 1 095. KNOX, R. S. a n d D EX T E R , D. L . ( 1 956) ' So l i d State luminescence theory a n d oscillator strengths in KCI(Tl)', Phys. Rev. , 104, 1 24 5 . K R I STOFFE L , N . N . ( 1 9 59) 'A quantum m ec h a n i ca l calculation of the K N O X , R . S . ( 1 959) 'Co nfigurational
l uminescent centre in KCl(Tl)', Optika i Spektr. , 7, 78 ; Optics and Spectr. ,
7, 45.
W I L LI A M S , F . E . ( 1 9 5 1 ) 'An
cence', J.
ab s o l u t e th eo ry o f solid-state l u mines
Ch em . Phys. , 19, 457.
E. ( 1 9 5 3) 'Th eory o f the l u minesce n ce o f i m p u rity J. Phys. Chemistry, 57, 780. W I L L I A M S , F. E. and J O H N S O N , P . D. ( 1 9 59) ' Confi gurati o n a l co o rd in a te model fo r KC J (Tl ) incl uding spin-orbit i nteracti o n ' , Phys.
WILLIAMS, F.
activated ionic c ry s ta l s ' ,
Rev. , 1 13, 9 7 .
Computation of emission and absorption spe c tr a
in th e configurational
coordinate model (with par t icular reference to KCI(Tl)-type phos phors)
Tech . B . , LOUCHTCH I K , N. E . a n d S H V A RTS, K . K . 'Electronic-vibrational processes in the luminescence centres of ionic crystals', Op tika i Spek tr . , 9, 2 1 5 ; Op t ics and Sp e c tr . , 9,
LoucHT CH I K ,
( 1 960) 1 1 3.
WILLI A M S , F . E . ( 1 950) 'Calculation
of the absorptio n a n d emission spectra of the thallium-activated p o tassi u m chloride phospho r ' ,
Phys. Rev. , 80 , 3 0 6 .
W r LL I A M S , F . E . ( 1 9 5 1 ) 'Theo retical low temperature spectra o f the thallium-activated potassium chloride phosph or', Phys. Rev . , 82 , 28 1 .
W I LL I A M S ,
F . E . and HEB B , M . H . ( 1 9 5 1 ) 'Theoretical spectra o f solids', Phys. R ev . , 84, 1 1 8 1 .
lu m in es ce n t
Ill. Calculation of emission and absorption spectra (general papers)
A comprehensive review
D E XTER, D . L. ( 1 958) ' T h e o ry
of the o p ti c al properties of imperfec
t i o ns in n o n-m etal s ' , Solid State Physics, 6, 353. A cad e m i c Pre ss ,
New Y o rk .
Luminescence
58
in
Crystals
Other papers D . ( 1 958) 'Sur le calcul des s p ec t res d'emission dans le modele des cou rbes de con fi gu ration' , Comptes-Rendus A cad. Se. Paris, 246, 404. CuRIE, D . ( 1 9 59) ' Calcul des spectres d'emission par l'emploi de d iag r amm e s a p lusieurs coordonnees de configuration', Comp t es Rendus A cad. Se. Paris , 249, 1 884. CURIE, D. ( 1 9 60) 'Calcul des spectres d'emission da ns le modele des
C U RI E ,
de c onfigu ra tion : sur une interpretation p hy s i que simple resultats', Comptes-Rendus A cad. Se. Paris, 250, 834. H U A N G , K . and RHYS, A. ( 1 950) 'Theory of light absorp ti on and n on - radiati v e transitions in F- cen t res ' , Proc. Roy. Soc., A 204, 406. K R I V O G LA Z , M . A . ( 1 956) 'Comparison of the theory of the lumines cence of solid bodies with expe rimen t', Opt ika i Spektr., 1, 54. Kuso, B. and T O Y O Z A W A , Y. ( 1 9 55) 'A pplicatio n of the method of ge ne rat in g functions to radiat iv e and non radiative transitions of a t r ap p ed electron in a crys t al ', Frog. Theor. Phys. lap . , 13, 1 60. LAX, M. ( 1 9 52) 'The Franck-Condon p ri nci p le and its ap p l ication to c rys tal s' , J. Chem. Phys. , 20, 1 752. LAX, M . and B uRSTEIN, E. ( 1 9 55 ) ' B ro a de n i n g of i mpu ri ty levels in silicon', Phys. Rev., 100, 592. M A E D A , K . ( 1 9 59) 'One-dimensional configurational c o - o rdin ate curves for luminescence centers', J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 9, 335. M EYER, H. G . J . ( 1 955) 'Some aspects of e l ect r on - la tti ce interaction in p ola r crystals', Physica, 2 1 , 253. Thesis, A m sterd am , 1 9 5 5 . O ' RoUR K E , P . R . (1 953) 'Absorp tion of light by tra pp ed electrons' , courbes des
Phys. Rev., 91, 265. S . I. ( 1 9 54) Untersuchungen uber die Elektronen theorie der Kristalle, 1 29-1 54. Akademie-Verlag, Berlin. R E B A N E , K. and S I L O , 0. (1960) 'The calculation of the prob abilities of electronic vibrational transitions for a n an harmonic o s cil lato r' , Issledovania po luminesc., Tartou, 12, 3 . R u A M P S , J . ( 1 95 6 ) 'Sur le c al c u l des intensites dans les spectres de ban de s des molecules diatom i qu es (cas de l'oscillateur harmo nique)', Comptes-Rendus A cad. Se. Paris, 243, 2034. RUAMP S , J. (1 960) 'Calcul de la position et de la largeu r de l'enveloppe des bandes d'une transition electronique', J. Phys. Rad. , 21, 52S. VLAM, C . C. ( 1 953) 'The structure of t h e emission bands of l u m in
PEKAR,
escent solids'.
Thesis,
G ro n i n ge n .
C H A PTER 1 1 1
Experi mental Determination and Use of Configurational Coordinate Diagrams
1. Tungstates, willemites, halophosphates, &c.
A s d i sc u sse d in the
previo u s chapter, F. E. Wi l l i am s was able for the of the t ran s i tion 1S0 ++ 3P1 in KCl(Tl) to obtai n th e en e r gy v ersus c o nfi g urational coordinate curves for g round and e xcite d states and from them to o b ta i n ab so rp tion and e mi s s i on spectra which coul d be compared with e x pe ri me nt . This is a rath er excep tional case. However, it is possible to obtain fro m e xperime n ta l results a confi g urational coord i nat e diagra m and to confirm this with other results. Such diagrams have been used for the alkali halides, wille mites , tun gstates , h alophosphates (Fonda), calcium oxide (Janin and Crozet), all being cases of phosphors in which lumines cence is not very clos e l y associated with photoconductivity. They have also been a p pl i ed to doubly activated phosphors such as Ca3(P04MCe-Mn), &c., to e xpl a i n the process of sen s it iza tio n (B ot de n ). In the case of ph otoco n du c ti ng phosphors of the ZnS(Cu) type the use of configurational coo rd in at e di ag rams has been somewhat criticized , especi al ly by F. Seitz. They certainl y cannot be applied to the kinetic processes which occur after absorptions and before final emission. However, they can be applied to processes which are c on fi n ed to the emission ce ntres. Th e opti ca l and thermal activation of electrons from traps may also be described with a confi gurat i o n diagram (see Chapter VII), but, as a general rule in these p h osphors , not on th e same diagram as for the luminescence centres . We shall co ns i d er some examples bri efly : (A) Tungstates. These are s o m et i m es used in X-ray fluorescent screens. The configurational coordinate diagram was derived by V l am. The typical ex peri m ent al d ata are as follows : for a CaWOlPb) phospho r containing I per cent by weight of lead . case
59
60
Luminescence in Crystals TA B LE II I . l
Emission spectra of Ca W04(Pb)t
Temp.
20 90 288 410
°K
hv0 (e V) 2·68 (4,630 2·69 (4,620 2·73 (4,540 2 ·77 (4,480
A) A) A) A)
2Le
(e V) 0·71
0·725 0·82 0·87
We see that the width of the emission d oes n o t ch a nge s ign i fi ca n t l y with temperature ( l 1 5 i n creas e between 90°K and 1 40°C) . From the rel ation
L.(T)
=
L,(O)[tanh
ln·,j2kT] - 11 2
t h ere fo r e, we find a h igh value fo r the v i brati onal quantu m e nergy
in the excited state of
a n d in the grou nd state
ln ·c
0·050 eV
=
ln·u
=
0 · 1 0 eV
t he distance between the e q u i l i b rium position excited and ground states
r0
is esti mated t o be
r0
=
of the
ions m the
0 · 20 A
the atomic grou p responsible for the e m iss i o n is the t u n gstat e i o n W04 2 -. V l a m i d en ti fi e s t h e configu rational coord i n at e r with the d istance of t h e tungsten fro m the fou r s u rrounding oxygen
We as s u m e that ions .
(B) Wil!emite : Zn 2 Si04(Mn).
numb er Zn 2S i04(M n) have
a
by
Klick and Schulman .
large
Manganese functions
as an activator
of fluorescent solids. The emission spectra o f
in
been studied by Kroger, Szigeti a n d Nagy and by Vlam , &c. The configu rational co o r d i na t e d i agram was derived
TABLE Ill.2
Emission spectra of Zn2SiO�(Mn) T. °K
20 90
28S
The
410
h"o (e V) 2-40 2·39 (5,200
2 38
2·37
A)
(5.220 A)
b a n d width dou bles betwee n
about
2Le
(e V)
0· 1 1 0· 1 3 0· 1 9 0·23
I 80°C and 1 40"C and t h e
t T h e n o t a t i o n o f t he p rev i o u s chapter is used.
Configurational coordinate diagrams
vibrational quantum is m uch smaller than for
phors . Klick an d Schulman give
hv. hvg
r0
=
0·025 eV
=
0·04 eV
= 0·06
61
Ca W04(Pb) p h o s
A
The value of r0 is p a rti cularly small, and as a result the a p p r o x i ma r r0 t o obtain
tion made in differentiating U0(r) in the region of
=
a linear relation between the emission hv and r is not s atis fa ctory . The form of the emission s p ectral curve is cl e a rly different from
Fig. J I ! . I Low temperature (20°K) emission sp ectrum
Zn2Si04(Mn)
oJ
Continuous curve: observed spectrum (C. V!am) Cross points: computed spectrum (Klick and Schulman)
gau ss i a n (in the q u a n tu m t h e ory of II.4 this -co rre s p o n d s with the case where the p a rame te r S is small and the asym p totical app ro x i ma tion to t h e ga u ss i a n form of J"P can no l o n ge r be used). The observed spectrum is asymmetric, show i n g a 't a i l ' on the longer wavelength side e x ten d i n g i nto the red . Before the work of Klick and S chu l m a n , attempts were made to resolve the spectrum into a nu m b er of gaus sian com p one nts with out trying to attri b u te them to different wel l defined centres .
The emission transition is att r i b u ted to a s p i n reversal of o n e of the 3d shell electron s of the M n 2 + ion. The mode of vibration is a radial one for the four oxygen ions surrou nding the m a n ga n ese. (C) If we apply the configurational coordinate m odel to Z n S (Cu) p hos p h o rs the b a n d wid th i ncreases with temperature i n a n inter medi at e m a n ner re l at i ve to CaWOlPb) and Zn 2Si04(Mn) ph osph o rs
62
Luminescence in Crystals
vibrational q uantum b e i n g between 0·03 and 0 · 04 eV."! lt migh t be ass oc i a te d with vibrations of the s u l p h u r i o n s urro u di n g the copper i o ns . the
s
n
A m o n g phosphors used in fl uorescent lamps the h al o ho p h ate s have first l ace as they enable a wide ra n ge of colours to be achieved by variations in their compositions. From a theoretical aspect they demonstrate the effect of activator environ ment on emission spectrum. The formula of the halophosphates is
( D) Halophosphates.
p s
p
3Ca (PO ) Ca i
!
F 2 (Mn 2+ Sb3+) Cl2
They can be excited by 2,537-A radiation o r by cathode rays. An timony g iv e two emission bands as follows ( h e most i nt e n e one is
3 4 2•
s underscored)
a nd
t
s
gh t on the behaviour of this a ct i v a o r has rece n tly been thrown by F. E. Williams ( 1 960) . o cc u rs in the form Sb3+ (Butler and Jerome), which is i s o e l ect r on i c with In+ and so its scheme 4,870 A
Some theoretical l
i
3,960 A
t
It
of energy levels is very similar to Tl+, except for a smaller spin-orbit (near to the p u re chlorophosphate) where structural changes are ex p ecte d , the osi tio n of the antimony peak shows a negligible dependence o n t h e ratio CI 2/F2 since the nearest neighbours of t he Sb3+ in the l a ti ce are six 02- ions. How ever, the i n ten s i ty of the peak suffers a noticeable ha n ge with this ratio. The manganese is present in the divalent state Mn 2 +. Its emission spectrum is conveniently described by two gaussian bands, t which are progressively displaced as the chlorine is replaced by fluorine from 5,950 A and 6,550 A coupl i ng. Except at
compositions
p
t
to
and
c
vibrational quantum hv. for the main emission band of Mn2+ 5, 700 A
6,250 A
is about 0·03 5 eV (Vlam). Comparison with the value of 0·025 eV for The
willemite shows that the value depends on both the activator and i t s s ur roundin gs.
with the method of preparation of the specimen : see H. PAYEN GARANDERJE and D. CURJE, Comptes Rendus, 248 (1 959), p. 3 1 5 1 . t The quantum
� This
energy
and also
the band width
of the emission vary markedly
is really only an empi rical way of describing a
DE
single asymmetric
LA
band.
Configurational coordinate diagrams
63
The l i fe time of the tran sition giving e m i s s i o n from the S b H i o n s i s about I I 1 500 sec, whi l e that for t h e M n 2 1- emission i s about I /75 sec. The anti mony is necessary as a sensitizer for e xcitation of the man ganese emission (see Fonda, Brit. J. Applied Physics, suppl. 4, 1 955). As sole activator it gives a light-blue emission . With similar concen trations of antimony and manganese c� 2 per cent) daylight simula tion can be obtained . Increasing the manganese content gives warmer tones, but truly red phosphors are not obtained ; the efficiency of the 'warm white' lamps made using these phosphors can reach 60-70 lumens per watt (Vanmaker and Ouweltjes).
2.
Relation between F centre absorption bands and the luminescence emission ascribed to F centres
The colour centres of
F type form the most investigated lattice in the alkali halides. They are defined as halogen ion vacancies which have cap t u red an electron. For other types of defects or imper fections in these crystals reference may be made, for example, to C. Kittel (Introduction to Solid State Physics, J. Wiley (1956), pp. 49 1 -
d e fects
502). F centres can be prod u ced by a stoichiometric excess of the cations.
For example, a sodium or potassium chloride crystal can be heated in sodium or potassium vapour at a temperature of about l 00°C below the melting-point and then cooled quickly so that colloidal aggregation of the excess ions (or v a cancies) does not occur. The observed crystal colours due to the presence of F centres are as follows : Yellow NaCI M agenta KC! Blue KBr KI Blue-green
Since the whole crystal must be electrostatically neutral the excess of positive ions must be co m pensated by an eq uivalen t number of elec trons captured in the negative ion vacancies forming F centres. The coloration can be produced by electrolysis in an electric field of a few hundreds of volts per centimetre at a temperature of 10°C or so below the melting-point and also by bombard m ent with X-rays or high energy particles which remove electrons from lattice ions which are then captured in the negative ion vacancies ; at present such i rrad i a t i o n i s the method most o ft e n used to colour these -
64
Luminescence
in
Crystals
crystals. H o wever , it gi v e s rise to other k i n d s of cen tres, e.g.
centres, a n d
V
th e observed effects are m u ch m o re co m p l e x than th ose
p r o d u ced by add itive c ol o r at i o n
.
The F ce n t re ab s o rp tio n is assumed to be d u e to t he transition -
fro m the gro u n d s tate uu to an excited state u•, the gr o u nd state, being of
Is
c h a r acter and the excited state l i ke a 2p state
(a ll o wed
t ra n
sit i o n) . The work of Gudden and Pohl s h o w e d that such absorption
p r o d u ce s p h o toconduction a t t em pe r a t u re s above 90°K, but thi s Ccrh1uc : ; :. ,, b a .i d
d ec rease s rap i d l y at
lower temperaexplained by activati o n energy
tu res . T hi s behaviour is
a ssu mi n g that an ::;,; O· I eV i s necessary t o ra ise an elec tron fro m the e xci te d state uu into t h e
I P cV
co nduction band (Fig.
At 90°K
Is
III.2) .
t e m p e ra t u re s not much above
a
l u m i n e sc e nce emission is ob
I s transition. For F cen tre luminescence Fig. I I I . 2 Energy-level scheme has b ee n l o oked fo r, and it now s e e ms for F centres in KBr to have b e e n o bse rv e d d u ri n g recent yea rs ( B o t d e n , v a n Doorn and Haven), fi r s t o f all with a very low quantum efficiency I to 3 per cent, but m o re recently with an e ffi ci e n cy of 91 per cent. This is due to the fewer ' killer' cen t res in served for the 2p -a long ti m e this
-
,.
the crystals n ow u sed . Measu rements were made at 77°K, 20°K and
we re fou n d t o ch ang e very little in position with a considerable Stokes shift is ob se rved be and emission which makes it d i ffic u l t to be certai n
4°K, and the b a n d s
temperatu re . However,
t ween
ab s or ption
that i t i s F-centre e m iss i on
.
A blue-green emis si o n is observed fro m many al kali-halide cry s ta l s
w h e n excited b y ultra-violet light, b u t it can c ry s tal s
are
mostly contaminated with
be shown that ' p u re
oxygen ( M ae nh ou t and van
and L ewis) : these oxygen ions accompanied by are o fte n respo nsib le for t h i s visible emission . Klick has shown th a t a detectable green luminescence is produced i n NaCI b y i ncorp o r a ti o n o f 4 · 1 0 -6 of copper. In add i ti o n , i n coloured crystals, a visible and u l tra vi o le t em ission may occu r when electrons c o mi n g from F centres recombine with V-type ce n t r es or with the '
der Dorst ; H al peri n
anion v acan cie s
-
above
oxygen impurity centres : such an e missi o n is pro duced by th e F ban d , o r d u ri n g the gl ow-cu rve experiment when
i rrad i ati o n in
coordinate diagrams
65
t h e F cen t res are thermally emptied , b u t it i s n ot thought t o be
F c e n tre l u m i n escence
(Bonfiglioli, B ro vetto and Cortese ; H a l p eri n kind had been earlier d e
scribed by G. Perny. Pekar and K l ick have p re d ic ted t h e w a vel e n gth regi o n where the -
a n d K ristianpoller) . Phenomena of th i s
emission of F cen tres would be expected .
The co nfigurational c o ordi n at e curves can be d rawn w i t h o u t r e fe r
n atu re of the coord i n ate ; it is though t to be the d is t a n ce from the centre of the vacancy to each of th e six surrou nding K+ ions. Th e re are fou r parameters to b e determ i ned : th e coordi nates o/1 0 and r 0 of the m in i mum of the excited state curve, the m i n i m u m o f the curve fo r "1111 be i n g taken as the o ri g i n and also the coeffi c i e n ts k,. a nd k0 : "lu = Jkur 2 e nce to the
,
"1.
=
-!k.(r - r0)2+ o/10
c a n be repl aced by e xpre s s i o n s for hvc a n d hv11• As shown by Klick's ex pe ri m en t , a good fit i s obtai ned by assuming hv. � hv11•
The coefficients ke a n d ku
We take now
(i) the
p o si t i o n of th e F abso rpt i o n b a n d ; K l ick u s e d that fo r
extrapolation to absolute zero.
(ii) the relatio n givi n g the variation of the band wi d t h w i t h tem
[
p e ra t ure
L,.(T)
hvo
La(O) tanh
=
J
- J /2
2kT
Since this is for t he absorption, it gi ve s the vibrational quan t u m fo r
th e
ground state h1•"
hl'u
and from t h e band w i d th at
La(O)
aa
=
0 · 0 1 1 eV
0°K
l o g. 2,
aa
2
-
Sa
(hv.) a h Va
and finally t h e approximate n u m b e r of phonons Sa e mitted after the t ran s i t ion. Klick a s s u m e d for KBr the value Sa 22 as gi ve n by H u a n g and Rhys . These data for the absorptio n e n a b l e the co n fi gu ra t ional co o rd i n ate curve to be drawn (see Fig. I I I . 3) . From t h i s d i a gram the positi o n of the em i ss i o n ban d s can be deduced . All these bands are in the near infra-red r egi o n Klick used th is model bu t Pekar u s e d that wh e re t he crystal is considered in terms of i ts optica I phonons. However, thei r c o n cl usio ns are very s i m ilar =
.
.
Luminescence in Crystals
66
T A B L E I II . 3
Data on absorption and luminescence of F c ent r es in alkali ha!ides Absorption maximum 290°K
Crystal
0 56 I' 0 63 I' 0·46 ,,
KCI KBr NaCI
78°K
0·54 ,, 0 · 60 I' 0·45 I'
Emission maximum (78°K) cafe. obs.
1 · 1 I' (Meyer) 1 ·2 I' (Klick) 1 · 25 I' (Pekar)
1 ·00
1 ·32 I' 1 ·20 I' I"
The agreement between t h e o re t i ca l and experimental v a l u es seems is th at fro m F c e n t res . The vibra tional qu a n tu m hv. R:! hv. = 0·0 1 1 eVt U(eV) is c l e a rl y smaller than the optical 2p p h o n on energy liw 0·028 eV, but ! Is 2·0 � the K + ions around the vacancy have I l es s b i n d i n g energy than those i n the
to s h o w that the observed em i ss i o n
=
i 0 ·4 0 2 0
I 0·2
0 4 r (A )
perfect lattice. The sign of the shift r0 between the ground and excited equilibrium posi tions of the ions. The absorption and emission spectra d epe nd o n r0 but
not on its sign. We have seen that for Fig. III.3 Configurational co ordinate curves obtained by KCl(Tl) r0 appears to be negative, the Klick for F centres in KBr i nt er i o n i c d is t a n ce b ei n g smaller in the excited state. T he reverse seems to be true of F cen tres . The F-centre electro n has a stronger attraction for the K + or Na+ ions in the ground state when its presence in the vacancy is much more localized. This conclusion rests on some work by I. J aco bs , who showed that at high p ressu re s (several thousand atmospheres) the absorption band is moved to higher energies. The effect is a tt ri b ute d to a decrease in the size of t h e vacancy as the
pressure is raised.
luminescence. M-centre em i s s i on peak s h a ve the infra-red re gi o n . In c o n t ra st to F-centre emission, the luminescence from M centres is observed at room te m perature as well as at liquid-air temperature. The excited state of the M c e n t r e is situated deep below th e c o n d uc ti on b a n d . M-centre and R-cen tre
al s o b e e n re p o rt e d in
t These va"lues are for NaCI (N . B . d i fferent
or
KC! : almost identical values a re obt ained for KBr, b u t cation) /we "'' h1•y "" O· O I R eV ( K l ick and R ussel l), ·
Configurational coordinate diagrams
67
TABLE 111.4
Absorption and luminescence of M centres (van Doorn and Haven)
Absorption peak
KC! NaCI
0 · 8 1 1-' 0·71 1-'
(78°K)
Emission peak
1 ·06
1 ·03
(78° K)
1-'
1-'
The M-centre l u minescence may be excited either by an irradiati o n i n the
M absorptio n band itself or i n the F absorption ban d .
N o polarizati on h a s be e n found for the F-band emission , even
when excited by polarized light. This is in agreement with
the cubic
sym metry of F centres . On the other hand , polarization effects are observed for the M-centre emission. Let p be the d egree of polariza tion defi ned by
(111
Iu - h
P = Iu +I.t
intensity of t h e emitted l ight with polarization parallel t o the
polarizer , and
f.t i ntensity
of the emitted light with polarization per
pendicular to the polarizer.) For exciting radiation absorb e d in the
M band : p
p
=
2/3 fo r exciting light polarized along the tO l l ) direction
=
1 /3
for exciting light polarized al ong the (00 1 ) direction
(Lambe and Dale Compton). These results indicate that the
M
centre can be represented as a
d ipole oriented along the face diagonal. Two models h ave so far been suggested for these centres. Both are i n agreement with the above representation : (a) Seitz's m odel : an electron trapped at a site consisting of two negative-io n vacancies with an adj ac ent positive-ion vacancy ; (b) van Doorn and Raven's model, consisti n g of an associated pair of F centres . Experiments made by the above authors are i n progress which m ay decide between these models. t When the exciting light is abso rbed in the F
band and then re
emitted as M luminescence, the degree of polarization is smaller and of the opposite sign.
't The model of van Doom and Haven seems to be the correct one since no (sec OHKURA and.
electron spin resonance has been detected for M centres MURASE, J. Phys. Soc. Japan, 16, pp. 2076 7, Oct . 1 9 6 1 ) .
Luminescence in Crystals
68
due t o high-energy irradiati on over a lon g p rod u c ed i nto the crystal i n add ition to F a n d M ce ntres. They a l s o give an i n fra-red e m issi o n (between 1 · 2 fl a n d 1 · 5 y), but the res u l t s re p o r ted by d i ffe re n t a u t h ors are not in go o d agreement with each o t h e r When the coloration is
t i m e,
R
cen tres are
.
3. The Smakula fonnula is often used to determine the concentration of a given impuri ty by measu ri n g the a b s orp t ion i n tensity due to the i m p u rity or d e fect If we have N a bsorb i ng ato ms per cubic centi metre in vacuo the absorption section for the ph oto n s i n tegrated over as ass e m b l y of i d e n tical phy s i ca l states, i . e . with the same matrix ele ment, is given by 8;z:v:; a(E) d E = 3c \ f/it \ The Smakula formula .
"
I n ex pe ri m e n t s we m easure t he a b s orptio n coefficient
w hi c h
i s given by
J
k(E) dE
=
N
We introduce t h e o sci ll a tor strength .fit 8n 2mv
(2:-f
=
I for a hannonic
f.r
_
k(E)
\ flit 1 2
3h I r,, I 2
oscillator)
J
k(E) cm - 1
and obt ain
dE =
me
For atoms i n a medium of refractive i nd e x n , c m u s t be replaced by cjn . We must also introduce the ratio effective field Eetr to the applied field (due to the electromagnetic ra dia t i o n) : this ratio occurs as a s q u are d term since the dipole moment Jl is proportional to the field, but ,u 2 app e a rs i n the expression for th e absorp ti o n coefficient. We can thus wri te z f, t dE = Kmc E
Finally we
m
Jk(E)
u s t divide b y the d iel ec t ric co nstant K. We then return absorption : No. of t ra n s i t io n s per atom a = ·-----· ---- -- - -· ·-- -
to the defini tion of the effective cross-section for ·
. .·
·-- . ..
.
No . of incident photons per cm 2
The e l ectrom agn etic
energy density being K£2j4;z:, the number
of
Co nfigurational coordinate diagrams
69
p h ot ons in the field is K t im e s greater in a m e d i u m of d ielect ric co n stant K. A l l these correct ions are u ni m po rta nt a s fa r a s t h e s p e ct r a l d i s t ributi o n o f the radiati o n i s co ncerned , but t h e y affect i ts i n t e n s i t y . S i nce t h e a p p l ied field freq u ency i s l a rge we m a y assu m e
K = n2 I + 4na: w h ere et. is the electronic polarizability of the a to m s , a n d so Ecrr = I + _!et. = n2+2 3 E 3 and we obtain k (E) d E = N . ! =
I
Numerically
N(cm - •)
n
ne zh (n z t- 2) );, me
3
=
k(E) d E
where k is i n cm - 1 a n d E is in electron volts. T h i s is t h e S m a k u l a formula as generalized by Dexter. D e x te r observes t h a t t h e L o re n tz Lorenz expression used for the e ffe ct i v e field is val i d fo r a h i g h l y localized centre, but for an extensive ce n t r e the effective fi el d is close to the value E.t The numerical S mak u l a fo rmu l a applies to t h e c a s e of a line of natural width :
I
k(E)
y 2 j4
=
k(E) dE = !nkroaxY
N(cm-•l
=
)/<max(cm ')Y
I · 29 .
( e V)
However, if t h e band is of gaussian shape, a s i s m o r e often t h e case (Dex ter), then k(E ) = kmax e xp
the half-width bei ng y
I
[- (h� ;d�vo)]
= 2L = 211 V2 log, 2
k(E) dE = a V2nkmax
=
-tJ
n
I og. 2
km�xY
a n d we obtain the Smakula formula as co r re c te d by Dexter :
N(cm-•)
=
0·87
kmax(cm •JY (e V)
t K . R. Silbsee proposed the use of the Onsager formu la E,n/ E
2n 2 + 1
3n2
=
·
Th is is perhaps not much better than t h e Loren tz Lorenz fo r m u l a , b u t s h ows the deg ree of prec i s i o n wh ich can he o b t a ined i n the t heory.
70
In p r a cti ce it
Luminescence in Crystals
is necessary, in o rd er to use this formula, to know the b y using a specimen with a known im purity con centration. Under these conditions it is not of a n y interest to use a formula with an exact numerical co e ffici en t H owever, it is n o w becoming p o ss ib l e to c a l c ul ate oscillator strength s on a theoretical basis. For comparison with exp eri m ent the corrected formula must be u s e d . Experimental values obtained by use of the D e xte r formula are listed below : For the two absorption b a n d s at 1 ,960 and 2, 500 A in KCl(TI) : o s ci l l a t o r strength
.
fi .oGo
/1.o6o
::
h,5oo f2.5oo
I;
::
= 2 x 1 0-4 TI + N = 1 o-z Tl +
0· 1
for N
0·07
for
The oscillator strength d ec reas e s with increase i n TI + concentration while new bands appear in both ab s o rption and emission sp e ctra (P. Pringsheim and Joshi). For the F-centre absorption b a nds : ::
0· 3 ;
::
KC!, KBr, NaCl / :: 0 · 5 t o 0 · 6 K I and
Csl f :: 0·3
BIBLIOGRAPHY 1.
G eneral discussion on the configurational coordinate model and experimental work on emission spectra FoND A , G. R . ( 1 9 50) 'Dependence of emis s i o n spectra of p hos p hors upon activator c on ce n t r ati o n and t e m pe r a t ure J. Op t. Soc. A m . ,
R. ( 1 9 5 7) 'Influence of a ctiv ato r environment on the emission of p h o s p ho r s J. Op t . Soc. Am., 47, 877. KucK, C . C . ( 1 952) 'Experimentally derived configurational coordi nate curves for p hosphors', Phys. Rev . , 85, 1 54. S E I T Z , F. ( 1 939) 'An i n t erp r etat i on of crystal l u m i n e sc e n ce , Trans. ',
40, 347.
FOND A , G .
spectral
',
'
Faraday Soc. , 35, 74.
C. (1 949) 'The influence of temperature on the sp e ctra l energy distribution of some luminescent solids', Physica, 15, 609 . V L A M , C . ( 1 953) 'The structure of the emission bands of some lumin escent sol ids'. Thesis, G roningen. W I L L I A M S , F . E . ( 1 9 4 9) 'Review of the interpretatio ns of l u mi nes ce n ce p hen o m e n a J. Opt. Soc. A m . , 39, 648. VLAM,
',
Configurational coordinate diagrams
Tungstate phosphors H E N D E RSON, S . T.
71
(1 939) 'Band spectra of cathodoluminescence',
(1 947) 'The temp e ratu re dependence of the fluores cence of tu ng s tat es and molybdates i n relati on to the perfection of the lattice', Phi/. Res. Rep., 2, 340. K ROGER, F. A. ( 1 948) Some Aspects of the Luminescence of Solid�, 1 07-50. El s evi e r, Amsterdam. V L A M , C . , as ab ove . Proc. Roy. Soc., A 173, 323.
KROGER, F . A .
Wi/lemite phosphors K . H. (1 948)
'Emission s p ec t r a of silicate phosphors wi th manganese a ctivati o n ' , J. Electrochem. Soc., 93, 1 43. BUTLER, K . H. (1 949) 'The fluorescence cu rves of silicate p hos p ho r s · Appli cation of potential energy curves', J. Electrochem. Soc., 95,
B UTLE R ,
C. C. and S C H U LMAN , J. H. (1952) 'On t he luminescence of divalent manganese in so lid s ' , J. Opt. Soc. Am., 42, 9 1 0. K R O G E R , F . A . ( 1 940) ' Lum i n e sc e n ce i n solids c o n ta i n i n g m a n g a n es e ' . Th e si s , A m ste r da m . K RO G E R , F . A . (1 948) Some Aspects of the Luminescence of Solid�, 1 02, 1 87. El s ev i er, Am ste rdam . K RO G E R , F . A. and HOOGENSTRAATEN, W. ( 1 948) 'The decay and the qu en chin g of fl uo resce nce in wi l lem ite ' , Physica, 14, 425. K R O G E R , F. A . and ZALM, P . ( 1 9 5 1 ) 'The origin of mul tip l e bands in Iuminopho rs activated by d ivalent m an gan e se ' , J. Electrochem . Soc., 98, 1 77. N A G Y , E . ( 1 9 5 1 ) 'Luminescence p h e n om e na in willemite pho s phors ' , A cta Phys. Hung. , 1, 1 1 5. N A G Y , E . (1 952) 'The temperature dep enden ce of the lu m i ne s ce n c e of wi llemite ' , A cta Phys. Hung., 2, 89. S z ! GETI, G . and NAGY, E . (1 947) 'The relation between dielectric losses and temperature quenchi ng ofluminescence in Zn2Si0 iM n)', Publ. Univ. Techn. S e . B u d apest , DC 535. Nature, 160, 64 1 . VLAM, C . , as above. 267.
KLICK,
A . A . ( 1 9 5 1 ) ' The preparation of haloph o s p hate p h o s p h o rs activated by anti m ony and m an gan e s e ' , lz. Akad. Nauk S. S. S. R. , ser, Fiz. , 15, 8 1 5,
Halophosphates BUNDEL,
72
B UTLE R ,
K.
Luminescence in Crystals
H . and J E RO M E ,
p h o s p h o rs :
ana
C . W . ( 1 9 50) 'Calcium h a l o p h o s ph a t e
l y s i s of e m i ss i o n spectra', J. Efectrochem. Soc., 97,
265. D O H ERTY , M . and H A R R I S O N , W. ( 1 955) ' P re p a ra ti o n and ch a ra c teristics of calciu m-halophosphate phospho rs activated by a n t i m o n y a n d m a n g a n e se ' , Brit. J. App!. Phys. , 6 , suppl. 4, S 1 1 . F o N D A , G . R . ( 1 9 5 5 ) 'Energy tra n s fe r i n calcium h a l o p h o s p h a te p h o s p h o rs ' , Brit . J. Appf. Plzys. , 6, suppl.
N A G Y , R . , W O L L E N TI N ,
4, S 69.
R. W. an d L U I , C. K . ( 1 949) 'Calci u m
h a l o p h o s p h ate p h o s p h o r s ' , J. Electrochem. Soc., 95, 1 8 7. O U WE LTJ E S , J . L . ( 1 956) ' Q u e l qu e s c o n s i d e rati o n s s u r l a tran s m is sion d ' e n e rg i e d a n s les halophosphates ' , J. Phys. Rad. , 1 7, 64 1 . V A N M A K E R , W . L . ( 1 9 56) ' Co n t r i b u t i o n a l a ch i m i e des h al ophos phates d e calci u m ' , J. Phys. Rad. , 17, 6 3 6 .
W I LLI A M S , F .
an t i m o ny center i n
h a l o p h osphates', S p ri n g Meeti ng, the Electroch e m . Soc. , C h i c a g o ,
E . ( 1 960)
' T h e e n e rgy l evel s o f the
1 -5 M ay, 1 960.
C R O Z E T , A . a n d C L E R , P . ( 1 9 5 1 ) 'Stimulation d a n s a base d ' oxyde d e ca l ci u m ' , Comp tes-Rendus A cad. Se. Paris, 233,
CaO phosphors
JANIN, J.,
! ' i n fra-rouge de la p h o s p h o re s ce n ce de s u b s t a n ce s l u m i nescentes
934.
J A N I N , J . and CROZET, A. ( 1 952) 'Contribution a !'etude des pro ganese' , J. Phys . Rad. , 1 3, 9 1 .
p rietes optiques de la chaux activee au
plomb
LEVERE N Z , H . W . (1 950) An Introduction 232. Wi ley, New York.
to
et au plomb + man
Luminescence of Solids,
2.
On colour centres in alkali halides B O E R , J . H . ( 1 9 3 7) ' O ber d i e Natu r d e r Farbzentren in A l kali halogenid-Kristallen', R e c . trau. de Chimie Pays-Bas, 5 6 , 301 . PoH L , R . W . ( 1 9 3 8) 'Zusam m en fa s s e n d e r Bericht i.i ber Elektronen leitu n g u n d p h o t oc h e mi s c h e V o rga ng e i n A l kal ihal ogenidkris talle n ' , Phys. Z. , 39, 3 6 . S E I T Z , F . ( 1 9 54) ' C o l o u r centres i n a l k a l i h a l i d e c rys tals', R e v . Mod. DE
Phys . , 26, 7 .
S A I N T - J A M E S , D . ( 1 957) ' Les ce n t res alcal i n s' . f Phys. Rad. , 1 8, 260.
co l o n�s d a n s l e s h a l ogc n u re s
73 Configurational coordinate diagrams On co lo ur cen tres and their lumin esc ence in alkali ha/ides, jfuorite, quartz and o ther minerals
P R Z I B R A M , K . ( 1 9 5 6) Irradiation,
gamon Press, L o nd o n .
Colours
and
Luminescence. Per
I . S . ( 1 9 54) 'Effect of pressure o n F ce n t re a b s o rp ti o n i n a1 ka l i h a l i de s ' , Phys. Rev . , 93, 993 . KLI C K , C . C . ( 1 9 54) ' Search for F-centre luminescence', Phys. Rev . , F centres
Configurational coordinate diagram for
J A CO B S ,
-
-
94,
1 54 1 .
KLICK, C .
C . and R u s s ELL, G .
n a t e cu rves fo r 1 47 3 .
See also : M EY E R , H .
A . ( 1 9 5 6) 'Configu rati o n a l coordi F-centres in al kal i h a l i de c ryst a l s Phys. Reu . , 1 0 1 , '
',
J . G . ( 1 9 5 6) ' S o m e aspects of electron-l attice i n teract i o n
in polar crystals', 32. Thesis, Amsterdam . and luminescence o f F-cen t rcs i n t h e alkali halides', J. eks. Teor. Fiz. S. S.S. R . , 22, 64 1 . P E K A R , S . I . ( 1 9 54) Untersuch ungen ilber die Elek tronen theorie der Kristalle, 1 09-7 6 . Akademie-Verlag, Berl i n .
P E K A R , S . I . ( 1 9 5 2) A b so rpt i o n '
F-,
M-
and R-cen tre
luminescence
P. J . , VAN D O O R N , C. Z. and H A V E N , Y. ( 1 954) ' Lu m i n es ce n ce of F-centres in al kali-halide c rys t a l s' , Phi!. Res. Rep., 9,
BOTDEN, T.
469.
VAN D O O R N , C. Z . and H A Y E N , Y. ( 1 956) 'Absorption a n d l umines ce n ce of col our centres in KC! and NaCI', Phi/. Res. Rep 1 1 , 479. VAN D O ORN, C . Z . ( 1 9 5 8) 'Quantum efficiency of F ce ntre fl u o res ce n ce in KCI' , Phi/. Res. Rep . , 1 3, 296 . K L I C K , C . C . ( 1 9 60) 'Polarization of F a n d M centres', Meeting o n C o l o u r Centres a n d Crystal Lum i nescence, T u r i n , S e p t ember 8- l l , .,
-
1 960.
and D A L E C O M P TO N , W. ( 1 957) 'Lu minescen ce and metry properties of colour centres' , Phys. Rev . , 1 0 6 , 6 8 4 .
L A M D E , J.
sym
V A N D O O R N , C . Z. and H A V E N , Y . ( 1 9 5 5) 'Dich roism of the F an d M absorpti on bands', Phys. Rev., 1 00, 7 5 3 . V A N D O O R N , C . Z . ( 1 9 6 0) 'Th e r m a l eq u i l i b ri u m between F a n d M
S e e also :
Luminescence in
74
Crystals
centres in pot as s i um chloride', Meeti ng o n Colour Centres and Crystal Luminescence, Turin, September 8 - 1 1 , 1 960. F E O FI L O V , P. P. (1956) 'Anisotropic optique des centres l um in o genes dans les cristaux cubiques', J. Phys. Rad. , 17, 656.
L . , KLICK, C . C . an d R U S S E L , D . A . ( 1 955) 'Criterion for the occurrence of luminescence', Phys. Rev., 1 00, 603 . K o V A R S K Y , V. A . ( 1 958) 'The theory of radiationless transitions in
Estimates of the quantum yield for
F fluorescence
DEXTE R , D .
an F centre', Optika i Spektr., 5, 222. PERLI N , Y. E. (1 957) 'On the problem of quantum yie l d of F fl uores ce nce , Optika i Spektr., 3, 328. '
On the
general problem of luminescence in 'pure' or coloured alkali
P . and CORTESE, C . ( 1 959) 'F and V centres thermoluminescent rec o m bi nati o n , Phys. Rev., 1 14, 95 1 , 956. H A L P E R I N , A . and KRISTI ANPOLLE R , N . ( 1 958) 'Thermolumines cence spectra of X-ray colored KC! crystals', J. Opt. Soc. Am. , 48, 996. H ALPERIN, A . and LEW I S , N . ( 1 960) 'Symmetry of the green phos phorescence of heat pretreated coloured KCI crystals', Phys. Rev., 1 19, 5 10. M A E N H O U T , F . W. and VAN DER DORST (1 958) 'Luminescence of pure and silver-activated alkali-halides', Physica, 24, 996. PERNY, G. ( 1 954) 'Contribution a l'etude des centres F dans les h a l o ge n u re s alcalins ' J. Phys. Rad. , 15, 356. ha/ides
B O N F I G L I O L I , G . , BROVETTO,
'
,
SMAKUL A , A . (1 929) 'Ober Erregung und Entfarbung Iichtelektrisch leitender Alkali-halogenide', Z. fur Phys. , 59, 603. S M A K U L A , A. (1 930) 'Ober die Ve r farbu n g der Alkalihalogenid kristalle durch U.V. Licht', Z. fiir Phys. , 63, 762.
3.
Smakula's formula
D EXTER, D . L . (1 956) 'Absorption of ligh t by atoms in solids', Phys.
Further developments Rev., 101, 48.
S I LBSEE, R. H . ( 1 956) 'F-band oscillator s t re ngt h determination in NaCI and KC!', Phys. Rev., 103, 1 675.
Configurational coordinate diagrams
75
R . S . and D E X T E R , D . L . (1956) 'Luminescence th e o ry and oscillator strengths i n KCI(Tl)', Phys. Rev . , 104, 1 245. RAUCH, C. J . and HEER, C . V . (1 957) 'Some F-band optical oscil lator strengths in add i t i ve l y coloured alkali-halides', Phys. Rev. , Oscillator strengths in alkali ha/ides
KNOX,
9 1 4.
F . E . , S E G A L L , B . and JOHNSON, P . D . (1957) 'Oscillator strengths for luminescent t ra nsiti o ns in KCI(Tl) and KCI(In)', Phys. Rev. , 108, 46. 105,
W I L L I A MS ,
CHA PTER
I V
Op tical Transitio ns in
a
Photoconducting Crys tal
Principal characteristics of photoconducting
luminescent
solids. Cop
per activated zinc sulphide, ZnS(Cu), has been the most extensively studied : ZnS(Ag) and ZnS(Au) bel o n g to the same group and CdS has been s u bs ti t u t e d for ZnS in part or c o mp le t el y All t h e se materials are k n o w n as 'conventional' c rys ta l phosphors. I n these c ry sta l s e x citation raises electrons i n to the conductio n ban d . The g re a t e r t h e concentration of electrons i n this band the greater the luminescence and the photoconductivity. A m a rked photo .
c o n d uct i v i t y occurs showing parallel behaviour to the e m i s s i o n both
t h e c o n ducti o n e l ec tr o n d e n s i ty is n o t the only factor which the two phenomena : photocond ucti o n also de p e n ds on the electron mobility and charge distributi o n , &c. , while lumines cence depends on the number of empty recombinati o n centres and the rad i ative transition probab i l i ty , &c. The c o m p a r at iv e study of t h e two effects does, however, give m o s t u seful information. Another ch aracteristic of c o nv e n t i o n a l sulphide p h o sp h o r s th e d u ring e x c i t a t i o n and decay. This pa ra l l el behaviour is q u ali tative si n c e
i n fl uences
,
luminescence e m i ss io n occu rs only when c o n d u c t i o n electrons re
combine with s p e c ifi c i m p u ri t i es o r d e fects k nown as l u m i n e s ce nce
centres. It is only when such n o rm a l a c t i v a t o r impurities are absent that other l u minescence effects a re o bserved and o nly for s pe c ial c o nd i t i o n s s u c h as very low t e m p e r a t u r e s e.g. t h e Ewles-Kroger ,
t yp e of emission
and e x c i t o n luminescence.
Radiative transitions with visible light emission
due to conduction
e l ect ro n s re c omb i ni n g with p o si ti ve holes i n th e valence band a re not c o m p l e te l y fo rb i d d e n H o we ve r t he y obey momentum conserva tion rules which make the transition probability so s m a l l that emis sion is u n observable. .
,
76
I.
1.
Optical transitions
77
T H E ' M O M E N T U M ' S E LE CT I O N R U L E A N D I T S C O N S EQ U E N C E S
Conservation o f momentum in optical transitions from band t o band
Consider th e o p ti cal transition of an el ect r on between two stationary states i n the crystal la tt ice described by Bloch functions : 'ljJk Yk exp (ik . r) fo r the initial sta t e and Y�.;· exp (ik' . r) V'k' fo r t h e fi n al state. k is the red uced wave v e c to r i.e. k 2n �(k) = fi Zk z mv =
=
,
li
=
2m
A. '
=
where �(k) is the kinetic energy of the electron. For approximati on to free electron conditions, Y k and '�'k' will modulate the exponen tial fac to r with the 'periodicity' of the lattice. The m at ri x element corresponding to absorption or emiss i o n o f a photon o f wave number q is
=
Hkk' A
a
2 e �A. grad)1fk J1f"·*me 1
i s a vector po te n tia l of the fo rm
A=
a
exp
d-r
( ± iq . r)
being a vec t o r orientated in the direction of polarization.
Hw c a n be writte n Hw
J exp
[i (k -k'±q) . r](vk'* Xvk) d -r
where (Yk XYk) rep res en ts a q u a n ti ty
*
=
which need not be explai n ed but has the periodicity of the c ry s ta l lattice. It follows t h a t
H�.:�.:·
=
L exp [i(k - k ' ± q) . Rm] n ..
X
J�
xp [i(k - k ' ± q) . (r - Rm)](Yk·* X1•k) d r
the is extended to the mth cell f vector fro m the a represents t All the integrals J d n a and w h e re t h e in te gr a l
m
Rm is a
m
origin to
are i e ti c l
lh,.·
=
of
point which
equal to A a n d so
AL exp [i(k -k' ± q) . Rm] /{,,.
lattice and hi s
cel l .
Luminescence
78
in
Crystals
On the averagct the sum is zero u nless the fo llo w i ng condition is fulfilled : k-k'±q K where K is a p ri n ci p a l vector of the reciprocal lattice exp (iK . Rm) = 1 This is a ge ne ral iz a ti o n for a cry sta l lattice of the law of con se r vat i o n of momentu m . For a bs o rp t i on we have + q a n d for e mi ss i o n -q. I n general, the ph ot o n wavelength is large c o m p a red with the wavelengths of electrons involved in such tr an s i ti ons (for 1 eV elec tron }. 1 ·22 x 1 0 -• cm) and s o for these conditions we have =
=
k-k'
=
K
which shows that there is conservation of the r ed uced wave vecto r in d irect , radiative band-to-band transitions (often calle d the momen tum s e l ec tio n ru l e) . In t h e energy band model su c h transitions are
t'ertical.
2. Discussion
We now consider excitation in the fundamental ab so rpti o n band
of
lattice, i.e. pr o d uc in g a conduction band electro n . T h e electron and h o l e so pro d uced must obey this selection rule and can i m m e d i
the
ately recombine. However, the electron will d i ffu s e towards the bot t o m of the co n d u c ti o n band and the hole to the t op of the valence band . The diffusion is due (a) to i n t eracti o n s between electrons and (b) to interaction of electrons and holes with the c ry s tal lattice. The second effect (b) is us u all y assumed to p re d om in ate . The mean free path of the 'slow' electrons in ZnS is a b o u t I 0-7 cm and the mean velocity a b o u t 1 0 7 c m /s e c . Ph o n o n di ffu s i on o r s catte ri ng of the electrons occu rs every I0-14 sec. Th erm al equ ili bri u m between the electron s a n d the lattice can be attained in I Q - 1 2 to I0 10 s ec , a time wh i ch is m u ch smaller than the life ti m e for radiative dipole t rans i ti o ns (lo-s s ec) . It is the rapidity of this diffusion which in s e m i conductors allows us to i n t rod uce the idea of 'qu a si-Fermi levels'. The effect (a) above only occurs if th e re is a large concentration of conduction e lec tr on s (IQ-H ejc.c) alre a dy . t This c a n be the case for -r We often say - a little too hastily that the matrix element is zero in order that the above conservation law is justified. Actually the summation included in the expression for Hu· is rarely zero. It oscillates about zero while remaining fi n ite. When we n ormalize by dividing by the crystal volume we obtain a quantity tending to zero for an infinitely large volume and then the conservation rule is j ust ified . :� Cf. J. Bok, Thesis, Paris, 1 959.
Optical transitions
i ntense u l t ra-violet e x citati o n s or e x cita t i o n by partic l e s . A d is tinct difference in temperature between the electrons and the crystal lat tice is therefore not impos s ible due to the continued arrival of ener getic electrons in the band. This pos sib il ity was considered in 1 938 by Birus and SchOn. Whatever t h e cause of electron diffusion, once it has o cc u r red the electron and po s itive hole do not show identity of momenta and so cannot recombine with photon emission. They can, however, re combine with simultaneous emission of a photon and a phonon , the latter carrying away the excess momentum but with small energy. This effect is well known for germanium, where it is assumed to be responsible for the infra-red emission at about 0·68 eV (). � 1 ·8 t,t) obtained for high carrier densities. An analogous process is not im possible in zinc sulphide. However, this recombination process has a long life time of ab o ut a second, and in sulphides with activat o rs i s masked b y r eco mbinati o n and emission of the luminescence centres, apart from non-radiative transitions in defects. Even in germanium it only appears for carrier concentrations of � 1 0 1 9jc.c due t o injec tion of a dense flux of electrons and holes. At lower concentrations recombinations occur in defects which are in general non-radiative (deathnium). We now return to the case of direct band-to-band transitions solely with p h oton emission, which is highly likely if after diffusion the electron and hole have t h e same reduced wave vector. This is so i f the conduction and valence bands have their minima and maxima respectively at a wave vector value k 0 (see Fig. IV. I).
79
=
<. (1<) I
.j
I I
Emission 1
0
.
Absorp/J(m; 1<
--
Fig. IV. l
(a) Band structure allowing direct vertical band-to-band transitions with light emission (photon emission only) (b) Band structure with such transitions forbidden
80
H owever, e ne rgy
Lum inescence in Crystals
band structures a rc more complex than that in Fig. IV.2 shows the schematic energy band diagrams (k) for ge r m a n i u m (H e r m an) and i n d i u m antimonide (Kane and Dressel h au s ) respectivel y .
Fig.
IV. l .
0 1 8 oV .\£ 0 0 1 5 cV
0
,,
k
0 /, ·.
111
Fig. I Y . 2
k 111
(a) Energy band structure for germanium (after Herman)
(h) Energy band structure for
indium antimonide
(after Kane and Dresselhaus)
In german i u m the co n d u ctio n band has a mi n i m u m at k = 0 but also eight equi v al e nt minima situated at the band extremities al o n g t h e ( I 1 1 ) d ir ec t i o n s (and thus only four differe n t minima are ob served) a n d lower by !:E :: 0· 1 6 eV than the first m i n im um . The va le n c e b a n d maximum is at k 0 but is complex. In indium anti monide the conduction b a nd has a minimum at k = 0 but the vall nce band i n add i ti o n to a maximum at k = 0 has eigh t equivalent m a x i m a a l o n g t h e ( I l l ) directions close to the o rigi n and higher than the first m a x i mum by !:lE :: 0·0 1 5 eV. In s uch systems there are no vertical, rad iative transitions (wi t h o u t =
a t l o w temperatu res . O nly t h e lowest conduction band mi n i m u m and the h i ghest valence b a n d m a x i m u m a re pop u l a te d with
p h o n o n s)
el ectro ns a n d holes respectively, and t he se do n o t
have the same wave at higher temperatures (such that the value k 0 become appreciable
v ec to rs (see Fig. IV. l 6) . However,
kT :: and
6.£) the populati ons at
t here
i s a probability
with tem perature thus :
=
of d i rec t rad iative t ransitions
which
grows
Optical transitions Value
i\ 1
TABLE I V . !
of the energy gap for some semi-conduct o rs at ddrerent temperatures 4 °K (e V) 0·74 1 ·14 0·23 3 77 3 ·8 3 2·55 2·92
German i u m Silicon lnSb ZnS blende ZnS wurtzi lc
CdS wurtz i t c S i C hex .
7rK (e V) 0·72 1·13 0·22 3 75 HI 2·52 2 91
291 °K (c V) 0 65 1 ·08 0· 1 8 J 6! 3 · 70 2·43 2 86
such as was ob t a i n e d from th e c y c l o t r o n res o n a n ce ' , magneto- resist
T n t h e case of z i n c a n d cad m i um s u l p h i d es we d o n o t
h a ve
evidence,
m ag ne to-o pti cal e xpe r i ment s which lead to the above schemes in the case of ge r m a n i u m a n d J n S b . However, t h e s t u d y of the o p ti cal a b s o r p t io n al l ows us t o m a k e s o m e reaso n a b l e ass u m p t i o n s . It seems t h a t both valence and co n d u c t i on ban ds possess e x trem a at the o r i g i n k 0 o r very close to i t , b u t probably not t h e mi n im u m minimorum' of the co n d u cti o n band o r t h e ' m a x i m u m m a x i m o ru m o f the valence ban d . Thus the l ong wavel ength l i m i t o f t h e fundamental abs o rpti o n band is prob a b l y d u e t o p h on o n - a s s i sted t r a n s i t i o ns as for G e an d 'l n S b The energy o f d i rect vert ical t ra n s i t i o n s i s higher b y a few te nt h s o f a n electron-vol t . The cond uction ba n d i s d u e t o s-states o f t h e Zn o r Cd i o n s , a n d t h e valence band t o s- and p-orbitals of th e sulphur i o n s , m o re or less h yb ri d i ze d acco rdi ng to t h e covalent c h a rac te r of the c o m p ou nd (si1 o rbitals in a pu re l y covalent Pauling model). A s m al l degree of ad mixture of Zn or Cd levels inside the valence b a n d is q u i t e p o s s i b l e but it may probably be n eglected in the s em i -q u a n ti tati ve considera tions at present possible. '
ance an d
=
'
'
,
,
,
For CdS m o re elaborate computatio n s have been made than fo r
ZnS. Accord ing to Balkan ski and d es Cl oizeau x the valence band h a s As a fi rst approx imati o n , t h e band is d ivided i n to th ree parts . T h e
t h e fol l owin g structure :
other two from p-states. The (p,) orbitals exten d i n g a l o n g t h e he xago n al axis are more strongly b o u n d than t h e (p:r.) a n d (p") orbi tals. Thi s a s su mp ti o n (Dress elh a u s) comes fro m the fact that t h e c/a rati o in the Cd S l a t t i c e is s o m ewhat smal ler t h a n i ts va l u e i n t h e i d e a l l owest sub-ban d d e rives mai n ly from s-states of t h e sul p h u r i o n s , a n d
the
82
hex agon al structure :
Luminescence
in
� (hexagonal compact) � (CdS)
Crystals
=
a
J�
1 ·623
=
1 ·633
For ZnS, this ratio is very near to the ideal value ; the s ep a rat ion be and (p.,, Pv) is probabl y smaller. The value
t ween (pz)
� (ZnS)
=
has been give n , but the difference from the ideal value is of the order the ex perim en ta l errors and thus not s ig n i fica n t To a second-order app ro xi m atio n , the spin-orbit coup l in g lifts the degeneracy of the upper valence band . The states for which th e spi n i s parallel to the o rbital momentum (TD symmetry) h av e a higher =
a
1 · 637
of
.
Con duction ban d
T
EIIZ
s
metry).
energy
1I 1
r7
£1 l
Valen ce b a n d Without sp1n With spin
r1
Fig. IV.3 Structure suggested/or the valence and conduction bands of CdS according to Balkan ski and des Cloizeaux
t h a n the s t at es for wh ich the sp i n is antiparallel er, sym
This structure of the valence band results in a structure in t h e long wave l imi t of the fundam e n tal absorpti o n spectrum. With p ol a ri zed light the absorp ti o n transition between the r9 l evel s and t h e conduc tion band is observed with light po la rized perpendicularly to the opti c axis, and the transition arising from the r, levels with light polarized
83
Optical transitions
parallel t o the o p t i c axis. The energy d iffe re nce between the two transitions is 0·0 1 6 eV in CdS (B alkan s ki and Waldron). The same s tructu re is ob s e rv ed in studies of the maximum of the photoconductivity excitation spectrum. Bube has shown t h at this A bsorption coe ffJ c ienc /cm 1) ' 10
10'
·· -
21,000
20, 000
1 9,000
Wa ve n umber (cm 1!
Fig. lV.4 Absorption spectrum of monocrystals mium sulphide (Ba/kanski and Waldron)
of cad
E is the electric field of the radiation and z the optic axis of the crystal (Measurements at room temperature)
maximum is divided into two components whose separation is eV in CdS and 0 ·0 1 5 eV in CdSe respectively. A n a bs o rpt i o n band has been observed in the i n fr a- r ed , at I 7 fl
0·0 1 7
(0·074 eV) i n CdS, and ascribed by Balkanski a nd eo-workers to t h e transition between the (p.) and (p,., p11) sub-bands. T h e s p a rt of the valence band is much lower, p o ssib l y 1 eV lower. It has been s uggested (G. Cu rie) that infra-red stimulation and quenching bands, which appear in all sulphides at 1·3 fl for ZnS and 1 ·4 ,u for CdS, be asc ri be d t o a transition in s i d e the valence ban d ,
Luminescence in Crystals
84
le ad in g fro m the s-s t at es to one of the p-s tates. T h e p o s s i b i l i ty o f s u c h d i fferent l e v e l s , which m ay be s e n s i ti v e t o t h e i n c o rpo r at ion of the a c tiv at o r , b u t this p o i n t i s not yet resolved . a tra nsi t i o n depend s o n t h e o cc u p a t i o n of these
J T . LU M I NESCENCE E M I S S I O N N E A R TO T H E A B S O RPTI ON ED G E ( ' E D G E E M I S S I O N ' )
1 . Spectra for electron-positive hole recombination i n germanium
Near a P-N j un c ti on i t is possible to obta i n cons iderable elect r o n and
hole concentrations ( R: 1019/c.c). R a d i a t iv e recombi natio n of th e
el ectro ns and h oles is observed . A s seen above, there must arise non vertical transiti ons i n the b a n d d i a gr a m except a t sufficiently elevated
temperatu res. The width o f the forbidden band b e i n g about 0·72 eV
at 77°K (see Fig. IV.2) , an e mi ss io n band is observed in the i n fra-red
r e g i o n at 1 · 8 fl .
At liqui d air t e m p e r a t u r e we find o n ly this p h o n o n - a ss i s t e d tran
experiments are carried out at ro o m t e m pe r a t u re or it is possible to detect in a d d i t i o n a pe a k at 0 · 8 1 eV ( 1 · 5 11) (Haynes) wh ich is ascribed to vertical t r an s i t i o n s w i th o u t p h o n o n c o o p e r a t i o n at k = 0. The energy of t h i s seco n d peak is equal to t h e s u m Egnp -", - 6.£, where Egap 0 · 65 eV at r o o m temperature and 1:1£ 0· I 6 eV ( see Fig. I V . 2) . Its i n te n sity i ncreases w i th te mp e ra tu re, the a cti v ati o n energy b e in g 6.£. Ho we ve r , this ra d i a t i o n i s s t r o n gly reabsorbed . a n d i s observed o n l y when ve ry th i n s pe c i m e n s a re used . Using the law of d etailed bal a n c i ng, S h o ck l e y a n d v a n Roosb roek o b t a i ned the recombination emiss i o n p robability . If p(1•) is the rad ia s i t i o n . When the
a b o ve
=
=
tion intensity for a bl ack body
p(v)
87lhv3 1 = � h•·/kl' - 1 e
T h e i n t ensi ty o f e m issio n per seco n d a n d pe r el ect ron h ol e pa i r i n t h e frequency b a n d
v
to v + dv i s
J(v) d v
= const.
k(1•)p(v)n2(v) d1·
wh ere k(1·) is the measured absorption c o e ffi c i e n t a n d t i ve i n d e x at frequency 1' . Th i s ca l c u l at i o n gives t h e l i fe
n(v) the refrac
time fo r the recombination emission . 0-75 s ec a t or d i n a ry temperatures. The o bs e rv e d life t i m e d u e to recombi nation via defects rarely ex ceeds 1 / 1 00 sec,
T h i s i s about
Optical transitions
85
s h o w i n g t h a t direct reco mbination i s a relatively rare event. This i s
w h y it
is o n l y observed i n cases of high carrier concentrations. J lvl \ I \ I I 90°K I
' "'
l
05
I I I I I \
_____
---
\
A
7
08
hv [ e V l
I lvl Corre cted for absorp tion
6 -
) .
" -
3
2
Wa velength (p. ) Fig. A B
IV .5
Emission spec trum due to band-to-band recom bination in germanium
Experiments by Aigrain and Benoit a la Guillaume Experiments by Haynes performed on a very thin sample (/ - 1 · 3 . 1 0-3 cm)
The form of t he emission spectrum is a l s o determined by the re absorption of the emitted radiation : if l is the d i m ens i o n of the emitter, the rad i a ted energy is gi ve n by
J(v)
oc
J: I(v)e-i:(v)z
dx
This in teg ra l depends on the geometry of the specimen. If the emis sion origi nates at a p o i n t t h en J(v) l(v)e - k<•>. If the re c o m b i n a t i o n =
D
Luminescence in Crystals
86
takes pl ace u nifo r ml y t h r o u gh o u t the s a m p l e th ickness l (e x p er i m ent s of Haynes and Newman), then Germanium /
J(l')
=
I(v)
1 - e- k(•·)Z
The maxi m u m co r re s po n d s a l e xa ct ly with the width of t h e forbidden band, s ince at l o nge r p type wave l e ngt h s it falls off ra p i d ly ac contact cording to Kirchhoff's l aw and since at shorter wavelengths than t ha t of Fig. IV.6 Weierstrass sph ere t h e absorption edge the p h o t o n s are made of germanium (P. Aigrain strongly reabsorbed. and C. Benoit a la Guil/aume) : injection is made at the Weier In s i l ico n the energy band gap strass point which m in im izes the is 1 ·08 eV and a recombination light losses emission is observed at 1 ·2 fl . Haynes found a str u c t u re in th i s emission consisting of fou r peaks d ue t o the radiative transition e m i s s i o n coupled with longitud i nal o r t ra ns v e r s e phonons of the acoustic and optical b r a n ch e s re spe ct i vel y . m os t
2. Spectra
of the
Ewles-Kroger type
These emission spectra are observed at low t e m p e r a t ures in ZnS, Cd S and ZnO containing n o deliberate i m p u r i ty a c t i v a t o rs (F ig . (na r row IV.7). The l uminescence s h ow s a characteristic fine which o cc u r s equidistant bands, better resolved at low near the fundamental absorption edge. The effect is most noticeable in CdS, which has an edge i n the visible region, a very brilliant gree n luminescence being seen. In an activated phosphor the Ewles-Kroger emission is sup pressed and that usually d ue to the activator occurs. The line spacing i n CdS is 296 cm-1• I n some cases a substructure occurs of feeble lines with t h e sam e se pa rati on as the main set, but compared with it, sh ift e d towards the hi gh energy side, by 200 cm 1 in CdS. This is the first known case of edge emission, but it seems certain that it is not due to b a n d - t o - b and t ransitions. The e m issi on always has a smaller photon energy than the band gap energy ( � 0· 1 5 eV as in Fig. IV. 7). It is thought that it is d u e to the recombination of a hole
87
Optical transitions
with an electron captured in a level of 0· 1 5 eV depth , a theory first proposed by Schon. This 'shallow' level is not very localized and has an associated vibra tional frequency near to but not exactly that of the phonons of the 1 0 0 :�>
(a)
Fig. IV.7 Ewles-Kroger spectra of a single crystal of cadmiu m sulphide (after Klick), (a) at 77° K (b) at 4° K
the emission, brok en absorption spectra)
( The full curves g ive
curves
the
perfect lattice. Kroger and M ey e r have taken the line spacing of t h e principal e m i s s i on lines to correspond to Con duc tion b a n d the frequency of the longitudinal optical \ p ho n ons and that of the substructure to Loca lised level correspond to the frequency v, of the transverse optical phonons. For the case of ZnS (blende), the best measurements of these frequencies vz and Vt are given by studies on infra-red absorp tion and Raman Spectra (Mme L. Couture, Va len c e b a n d M. C. Haas and J. P . Mathieu). For CdS Fig. IV.8 Ewfes-Kroger and ZnO we have the measurements on emission 'Reststrahlen' by R . J. Collins. I n every (After Schon) case, the interval !J.v between the main lines of the emission spectrum is slightly different from v�, but the d is crepancy seems real. t Hopfield (1 959) has shown that the heights of the different peaks
t Quite recently, Choyke, Hamilton and Patrick ( 1 960) have described edge em ission phenomena in SiC which seem to i n dicate electron-hole recombina tion occurring i n donor-acceptor pairs . The separation (0·03 eV) of the l ines is here quite different from the energy of the optical phonons (0 09 eV for transverse phonons and 0· 1 2 eV for longitudinal phonons) . For a description of other luminescence emission shown by SiC, see Chap ter IX, §II . 3 .
ss
Luminescence in Crystals TABLE IV.2
,; , . Vj
l't
Blendc
ZnS Wurtzitc
3 64
3 68
274
?
349
Hex.
CdS Wurf::ifc
Zn O
305 24 1
591 414
550
296
cm 1 cm 1 cm - 1
P o i s s o n d i s tribu t i o n . T h e fi rs t em is i s a s cr i b e d to el ectron-hole recombination l ea d i n g to the emission o f one p h o t o n a n d n o p h o n o n , t h e seco nd l i ne /1 to a pho t o n a cc om pa n i e d by o n e p h o n o n , the (n + l ) th line In t o the simultaneous emission of the photon a n d n p h o n o n s . The r e s p e ct i ve i n tensities are a re
conve n i e n t l y descri bed by a
s i o n line /0
where
N is
Nn In = /0n .1
the m e a n n u mber o f e m i t ted p h o t o n s .
t a i n ed wi t h N
=
0·87.
I n CdS a
fi t is ob
TABLE I V . 3
Number
of phonons
n = O 1 2 3 4
Re/alive peak
height
1 ·00
0· 87 0·38 0· 1 1 0· 03
Polarization of t h e edge emission. The emission is mainly polarized wi th E.lz (E the electric field of the ra d i a ti o n , z the op ti ca l axis o f t h e CdS c ry s t a l ) . At 7 7 ° K (Dutton, Hopfield a n d Collins)
li = h
6·3
I n ZnO the polari za ti o n i s almost total .
These results are in a g reement with the st ructure of the abso rption
l i mit as d escri bed in Fi g . IV.4 i f we admit that the s h a l l ow level re spons i bl e for the ed ge emission po s s e s s es the same symmetry as the c o n d u ction b a n d . If 6.£ (0 ·0 1 6 eV in C d S) is the s epara t ion between the r9 and r, l evel s in the valence band , the polarization ra t io is
h
7;1
- exp -
(6.kT£)
I n Cd S the app r o x i m a te theoretical va l u e i s
7.
Other e x peri m e n t s a r e necessary i n o rder to identify t h i s shallow
l evel . F. E. Williams has su gge s t e d that it be c o nsi d e r e d as a level o f an electron t ra pped in the field o f an electric d i p o l e constituted by
Optical transitions
tw o a ss o c iat e d
89
va c a n ci e s ac ti n g like s u bsti t u ti o n a l c h a r g e s of o p p o
site sign s . Some p r o o f of t h i s h y p oth esi s h a s b een g i v e n b y L .
P a t r i ck fo r
th e case o f
SiC. I ndeed, i t s e e m s m o s t
probable t h a t t h e
e d g e emission m u s t b e ascribed to p h y s ic a l d e fects i n t h e l attice (vaca ncies o r i n tersti tial a t o m s ) rath e r t h a n to c h e m ical i m p u ri t i e s . Th i s i d ea is su p p o rt ed by the fact that s o m a n y peo p l e h ave m ad e
experi m e n t s o n t h e i n c orp o r at i o n of
chemical i m purities
i n zinc
or
c a d m i u m s u l p h i d es that, i f one of these i mp u ri t i e s h ad b e e n r e s p o n s i b l e fo r the Ewles-Kroger spectru m , s o m e o n e wo u l d ce rta i n l y h a v e
X (page
fou n d it. The ex p eriments of K u l p and K el l e y, d escribed i n C h a p
ter
309) indicate quite d efinitely t h e occurrence o f v a c a n c i e s
or interstitial s . E dge emission appears on bombard ment by acc e l e r
a ted electrons, wh e n the energy of these electro n s is h i gh e r t h a n t h e th reshold for S-v ac a n cy p r od u c tio n . As a general rule, the emission that o cc ur s at t h e b a n d ed ge s ee m s
to b e d epe n den t o n th e su rface conditi on o f t h e crystal ( D . C .
Reynold s) . I t is des t ro y ed b y s c rap i ng the su rface ( b u t i t i s r es t o re d
by etching). This re s u lt does n o t prove that the edge e m i s s i o n o cc u rs
at the surface, but more pro b ably that s c r ap i n g produces d e fe c t s acting like 'killer' ce n t r e s .
We notice al so in Fig. IV.7 the appearan ce at 4 ° K of a s p e ct ru m
i n the blue re g i on which also "shows structure . This spect r u m (n o n h yd rogenlike) has been obse
�ed b y various w o rker s ( K roger, K li c k ,
A r kh an gu el s kai a and Feo:fi lov, Furlong and Rav il i o u s ) . I t i s fo u n d
a t t h e fu nd a m e n tal a bs o rpt i o n edge b u t d i ffe rs
which had been i n q ues t i o n . It a ri ses from
i mpu ri t i e s .
fro m e x c i to n spectra superficially abso rbed
The Ewles-Kroger s p e ct rum is u s ua l l y obtained by ph oto-ex cita
ti o n . H owever, i t
w a s obtained b y R. W. S mi th by i nj ec t i o n o f e l e c
t r o n s and h oles into unactivated cad m i u m sulp h i de u s i n g i n d i u m
electrodes. I n t h e Ew les - Kr o g er spectrum observed o n l y a t l o w t e m pe r at u r e s a
s eco nd emission band was superimposed nearer
to
t h e absorption edge which appeared t o b e d u e t o d ir e c t electro n-hole recombination : this band persisted at room temperatu re and above (see Fig. IX. l 5) . I n a remarkable ex p e r i m e n t , t h e excitati on o f t h e Ewles-Kroger spectrum has been produced by in fr a- r ed excitation (Halste d , Apple
and Prener, 1 959). Th i s result is a m a r k ed violati o n of rule. I t
is ex p l a i n e d
b y a two-stage
e xc i t a t i o n p rocess .
the Stokes
Luminescence in Crystals
90
A CdS sam p l e con t ai n i n g coppe r is used .
The concentratio n of a n d the edge emission is n o t suppressed ; how ever, the copper levels play a fu n d a m e n tal part in the excitation procopper is r a t h er low
Conduction band
Electron 1 st . I. R. photon
Edge
e m i S S I On
Valence band
Fig. I V . 9 Two stage excitation of the edge emission (Halsted, Apple
and Prener)
cess. The fi rst i n fr a red p ho to n
ionizes the Cu-level into the cond uc one raises an electron of the v a l e nce band i nto the copper level. Then this level i s filled a ga i n while a free electro n -
t i o n band ; the s ec o nd
,
hole p air has been prod uced. Their recombination produces the
green emission (and a ls o , of cou rse, the i nfra-red emission
associated
with copper).
I l l . A B S O RPTI O N S PECTRA AND EXCITON EMISSION
1.
The experimental evidence
In recent years Gross, Nikitine and their eo-workers have found in C u 20 , CdS, Hgl2, Agl, Pbl2, &c. , series o f a b s o rp t i o n
lines a ppea rin g near the ab s orpt i o n e d ge and which can be rep rese nte d by a hydro genlike formula. The lines can be i n terp re t e d as the o p t i c al spect ra associated with the creati o n of e x c i ton s Since 1 956 h om o l o gou s line series have been fo und in emission fro m the same materials. They were first observed i n CdS but w it h l aye r s p rep ared in a special way. These crystals, deposited by sublimation at rel a t i vely low tempera t u res (700°C), are assumed to contain few defects . They show a ve ry weak Ewles - K roger l u m i n e s cen c e i n the green reg i o n , but the exten.
91
sion into the blue appears t o b e absent and i s replaced by a series of quasi-hydrogenlike lines (E. and M. Grillot, Pesteil and Zmerli). Lines of the same kind were observed for Hgl 2 , Pbl 2 , Agl and CdS by Arkhanguelskaia and Feofilov, Nikitine, Perny, Reiss and Sies kind. They obtained a detailed spectrum for Agl and numerous l i nes i n the other cases i nvestigated . Whether i n absorption or emission these spectra are observed at low temperatures ; at higher temperatures the lines broaden and merge into the absorption tail. Thin layers are needed for the ex p e r i ments (one to a few tens of microns, depending on the l i ne i n t e n s i ties) and they must be free from defects. Optical transitions
From a theoretical point of view the exciton was first thought of as a neutral excitation wave capable of movement through a crystal (Frenkel, 1 930) : in recent years this idea has received new interest, correlated with studies of exciton transfer (see later). Then in 1 9 3 8 Wannier established the quasi-hydrogenlike character of the levels prod uced while M ott, Slater and Shockley described the exciton as an electron in orbit around a hole bound to it by the coulombic attraction. In the excitation-wave model the formation of an exciton in KC! corresponds to the movement of an electron from a Cl - ion to one of the neighbouring K + ions while excitation of an electron from the valence band (Cl -) to the conduction band K (see Fig. Il.2) corre sponds to a complete freeing of the electron in the body of the crystal. The calculation of the energy cycle analogous to those made to find the forbidden energy gap enabled von Hippel, J. de Boer et alia to find the energy for exciton formation . Thus the width of the fo r bidden band in KC! is 9-42 eV, giving an optical absorption edge at 1 ,3 1 0 A, wh i le exciton formation requires o nl y 7 · 6 eV, giving a first absorption peak at 1 ,620 A . We thus obtain the first exciton state. In a similar way for CdS the first exciton state corresponds to the transit of an electron from a sulphur ion (i) to one of the neighbour ing cadmium ions (M) (M. Balkanski and P. Andre). However, the wave function obtained from that of the matrix crystal by replacing that for the sulphur ion by the Hartree function for this ion contain ing a positive hole and replacing that of the cad mium ion M by the Hartree function for this ion with an excess electro n , say rf>(i, M), 2. Theoretical aspects
92
Luminescence in Crystals
4>(i, M)
is not an eigen fu ncti o n of t h e crystal . For th e eige n function a wave
packet
It
of
t he
fu nct i ons must be taken :
1p (fo r c r ys t al co n tai n i n g exciton)
"J.Ai.Mf(i, M ) i,.l[
is p o s s i b l e t o take A c o effici e n ts of the fo rm A
ex
exp
(ik . R)
R l oca t e s the exc i to n and k pl ays the pa rt o f a propagati o n Near to the limit k0 w e can obtai n the energy C(k)
k'
where
=
=
t'(k0) +
li22 �k'2-j- . . .
k - k0, this co rrespond i ng to the m o tion of M.
vector.
a n exciton
with effective mass
This m od e l is p referable for calculating th e ground state
an d
t r a nsition s i n v o lving this s t ate and m o re ge ne r all y for the case where
the el ectron 'orbit' around the hole is of s m al l
th e
alkali halides
radius. This is so for con
because of their re lat ivel y small die lec tric
s tants (Slater and Shockley, T.
Muto
and
Okuno).
3. Model for the electron in orbit around a hole ; hydrogenlike spectra In contrast to the above the mod el fo r an electron orbiting
about
a
hole, called the 'quasi-positro n i um' model , gives a d i rect e x pl an a t i o n
of
the h y d r o gen l i k e spectra fo r the excited state.
Let
m.
and
mh
be the effective masses for c o n d u cti o n electrons and
h oles i n the valence band respectively, the bands being is o tr o pic and
for non-d egen erate conditions. The Wannier equa t i on
is then
H
=
Ji 2
2m.
- -b.,-
1i 2
2mh
-
for the exciton
e2
b.h - -Kr
K being the d i e l ectric co nstant of the materi al . Let r, be the electron co-ord i n a t e ,
rh
t ha t o f the hole and
R
R that of the centre of gravity :
m.r. + mhrh
The eq u a t i o n has solutions of the form
7p(R, r)
=
exp
(i kR)tp(r)
corresponding to a motion of the centre of gravity with wave vec tor k. It is easily shown that 1p(r) is a solution of the h y d rogen l i ke
Optical transitions
eq u a ti o n
fi 2
E
=
fi 2
2
e -f(,!P(r)
=
93
M = m. + mh
k 2 + I! ;
2M
M is the effective m a s s of the m oving exci t o n a n d ,a the red uced mass The e n e rg i es I!
R'
l
f-l
=
_!_+__!_
m. mh form a h yd r ogenlike s eri e s : lfn
=
R'
n2
'
R'
- - ·
bei n g a p s e u d o- R yd berg
=
R J!:. -
K2 · m
constan t ; R i s the Ryd berg c o n s t a n t fo r
h yd ro gen (1 3 · 5 eV) and m the free electron
separation in the orbit nS of the exciton i s
mas s . The e l ectro n - h o l e
is the Bohr r a d i u s 0· 5 3 A). For a given I! there is a corresp o ndi ng energy band, the total energy of the exciton being I! plus the translational energy !z2k2/2M. In general, we can only expect to obtain weak absorption tails, only the limits o(which form a series. However, in contrast we get a series of hyd rogenlike lines when m., m and K are isotropic and for vertical transitions at k = 0, or more generally for a k value which is the same for a m a x i m u m or minimum for the valence and conductio n bands respectively. This requires a c o rre sp o n d e n c e as shown in Fig. IV. l a. For such a band structure we have in either absorption o r e missio n t h e l i nes (a0
=
hvn
=
hvoo
R'
2 n
hYoo corresponding to the forbidden band-gap energy ( F i g . I V . l O) . W e can very likely observe the l i n e spectra for more complex band structures such as those pr o p o sed for CdS in which the extrem a of t h e bands lie at k 0, but th e minimum k 0 o f the conducti o n band i s not the lowest minimum. After absorption a t k 0 a nd formation of a free electron hole pair, the electron and the h o l e wi l l d i ffuse away from each other and will not normal l y recombine by a vertical ra di a ti ve transition. In contrast, after an a b s o rp t i o n at kJ 0 giving a bound electron h o l e pair, t h e el e c tr o n a n d h o l e w i l l =
=
=
=
94
problem
Luminescence
d i ffuse together and the Th e
in
Crystals
p oss i bi l i ty o f radiative recombinati o n e x is ts .
of de t e rm i n i ng the band structures which wil t give rise
to exciton line spectra and those which will n o t is s t ill far fro m clarification.
When the valence band is divided into several sub-bands, a simil a r n umber of exciton line series m ust appear ; each series limit coincides
1
Conduction band
n=3
t I
Valence band
Fig. J V . l 0
Energy
le vels
Continuous spectrum L in e spectrum
of exciton spectra
with the transition leading t o the i o n ization of the co r r e s p on d in g
N ik i tin e and eo-workers) : o n e is s i t u a te d in the yel low pa rt
sub-level . Two
m ai n
hydrogenlike s e ri es have been o b s e rv ed i n Cu20
o f the a b so rpt i o n spect r u m and i s observed with relatively thick
(G ross,
s peci m en s
( 10 to 1 00 p) ; the second series is i n the green and is ob
served with t hi n ne r speci mens ( '"'-' stronger in this
re gi o n .
'
�t) because th e abso rpti o n is
abso rp t i o n
(B alkan ski
s e ri e s
t he valence band
expe c t three exciton line
Since for CdS the upper part of
(p-band) is
and des Cloizeaux) . In emission, t h es e t h ree
d i vid ed into three sub-levels, we
series in
mig h t perhaps be observed at a s u ffici e n t ly high temperature, p o l ari zatio n ratio . At 4°K, t he holes are concentrated in the up per T9 level (Fig. IV. 3) and the e mi s s i o n is c o m p le te l y p olariz e d (El.z) . This has b e e n effe cti v e l y shown i n experiments (E. and M . Grillot, Gross a n d Razb i rine ; Thomas, H o pfi el d and Power) . Elliott has shown t h at theo ry c a n d is ti n g ui s h t w o kinds of exciton e a ch of them with a different
l i ne s pe ct r a :
95
Optical transitions
I. Spectra o f t h e first kind i n wh ich transitions fo r k
We observe thus the spectral series for
n
= I, 2
.
.
.
=
0 occur.
The osci l lator
strengths are proportional to the squares of the a m pl itudes of t h e hydrogenlike wave functions
Is, 2s,
&c. , a n d
I
a re
fn oc � na0 n
They are weaker than the lines for isolated atoms in the rat i o (a0' ja0) 3, t h e i r i n tensity decreases rapidly w i t h tor
I /n3
and very few lines are observed .
2. Spectra o f the
n
because of the fac
second kind in which the transition at k
forbidden b u t vertical transitions at a constant
1 n2 - l
k
val ue
and leading to p-states are allowed. We obtain i n th i s ca s e
fn
ex
=
near to
0 is
zero
3n ao'5n5
These li nes are weaker than the lines for isolated ato m s
in
the ratio
(a0' Ia0)", but the line intensity falls less rapidly than that for spectra of the first kind and more lines are observed . In all cases the l ine fo r n =
I
is absent since there is no p-state for
n
=
I.
These ded uctions are ma rked ly in agreement with experimen t
(Nikitine e t
al.).
Thus C u i shows absorption s pe ct ra
of
the fi rs t
kind, Cu 2 0 those of t h e second kindt a n d t h e oscil lator strengths show the expected theoretical ratios. The same d i fference occurs for
emission spectra. When the transition is not vertical and involves a sim ultane o u s
germanium), line spectra absorption curve. been fo u n d that are thought to
emission o r absorption of a ph onon (as i n
are not observed, but s uccessive k nees occur i n the At the p resent time, those knees have
be due to the formatio n of the ground state of the exciton (Macfar Iane et
al.).
4. Deviations from the hydrogenlike formula
To begin with, the treatment of the exciton in the Wannier equation (called the 'effective mass approximation') makes the crystal a con
1
tinuous medium of dielectric constant K: this is not valid except fo r
2 m ay
large orbital radii . Also the state state
n =
n
=
and to a lesser degree the
be normally perturbed.
Kittel and Mitchell h ave used the Wannier equation with a non isotropic effective m ass : Barriol, Nikitine and Sieski n d have studied
t T h e line
for
n
=
1 i s observed b u t is
very weak.
96
Luminescence in Crystals
t h e a n i s o tr o py of the d ielec t ri c constan t : in cease to
be h yd ro ge nl ike .
b o t h ca ses the s pect ra
In an ionic c rys tal d efined by i t s two dielectric c on s tan ts Kstntic
a nd K0 (at high frequencies) i t is necessary for
a l o ca lized level t o
i n troduce a n 'effective d iel ec tr ic constant' . However, in the case o f
established in the crystal and it is s u ffi c i en t t o use K0 in the above
t h e ex ci to n , in a bs orpt i o n i oni c p o l arizat i o n has no time to become c a l cu l a ti o n s .
Fo r e m i s s i o n t h e pr o b lem is m o re complex . I f the electron a n d h ol e are very mobile the polariza ti o n t h ey p r o d u ce wi l l be self-destructive a n d we have a non-polarizing exciton (Dyk m a n and P e ka r) and again K0 is u sed i n the calcu lati o n s . In an i o n ic crys tal o nly a non-polarizing exci t o n ca n give a hyd rogenlike emiss i o n spectrum c o r re sp o nding to the absorption s p ec tru m . The observation o f such agreement between a b s o rp ti o n spectra of CdS obta i n e d by G r oss and emi ss io n s pect ra obtained by G ri l l o t i s a strong argu m e n t fo r att ri bu ti n g them to excito n s si nce it d o es not occur for a hydro genlike impurity (electron in o r b it about a fixed p osi tive charge in the l a tti ce , the effective d i
electric constant d epe ndi ng on the p a r t icul a r l e v el co n sid ere d ) .
Tf the e l ec t r o n and hole are not very m ob i le t h e y p o la rize the sur rou n d i n g l attice : each o f t h em can be treated as a p o laro n , i.e. su r rounded by an as sem bly of phonons. In the s i m p lest case we can t a k e acco u n t o n l y of t he mean val u e o f such p o l a riz a ti o n (p o l a riz i ng e x c i t o n of D y k m a n and Pekar) , but in general the el ectro n-hole int e r action will be modified by their res p ec t ive su rr ou n d i n gs of phonons.
F o r this c a se we m a y refer to the work o f Haken a n d o f Meyer. M eyer cal ls s u ch a c o m p l e x e x ci t o n
5. Stark
an ' ex c i t a r o n'.
and Zeeman effects for the exciton
i n Cu20 by G ro ss et al. and in CdS by E. a n d M. G r i l l o t in collaboration with
Th ese t w o effects h ave been st u d ie d more recen tly
G ro s s . The Stark effect i s observed i n relatively weak el e ct r i c field s becau se of the large size of the ex c i t o n o r b i t . For the h y d r o gen atom
the Stark effect fo r a field F is
t:.E
=
- �-neFa0'
(all
fo r levels of p ri n cip a l quantum n u mber
fi rst Bohr
o rbi t , approximately
fo r hydroge n .
For Cu20 a n d
n =
5 the
n va l ues )
n. a0 ' i s
K0 t i m e s greater
t h e rad i u s of the
for the ex ci t o n
e ffect i s observed fo r fi e l d s o f
than
5 kV /cm .
Optical transitions
97
Furthermore, w e find the p he n o m e no n of ionization of t h e e x c ito n the sh i fti n g of th e levels n 6, 5, 4, &c., into the ioniza tion c o ntinue s as the field increases. The ab s o rp ti o n limit is shifted and affects successively each of the ter m s in the series. For Cu20 and for F = 25 kV/cm o n ly the levels n = I an d n = 2 su rvi v e . Such an e ffect for a hyd ro ge n atom requires 600,000 to 700,00 V/cm . The Zeeman effect for the line n = I (ye ll o w series of C u 20) s h o ws a normal t ripl et s tru ctu re . Us i n g the q uasi-positronium m o d e l , the separation of neighbouring lines is /:£ = m11 - m. �H p ro d u ced by
=
m.m"
We find
/: £ =
--
4nc
eh
4nmc
H
i f m" eo, while if m11 = m., t h e l i near Zeem an effect is ze r o . T h i s i s we l l k n own for p o si t r o n i um : the Larmor p r o cess i o n w efl/2mc produces an e n h a nce me n t of the electron velocity and a d i m i nution of the p o si t r o n velocity so that the energy of the system i s u n a l tered to a first approximation. P o sitro n i u m only shows the quad ratic Zeeman e ffe c t . A splitting of terms with n > I h a s been observed , b u t the d i ffer e n t components have not b e e n res o l v ed . The emission l i nes of CdS a ls o show a Zeeman effect. S o m e t i m es , e . g . that a t 4,870 A, t h ey give t h e normal t riplet. However, t h e n a n d a c om p on e n t s are inverted. This s u gge st s a ma g n et i c d i po le n ature for the emission (E. Gri llo t) (see Fig. IV. l l ). =
=
()
Normal trip/et Jt.
(J'
4 8 70 �
Jt.
line from ()
Cd 5
J1.
Fig. IV . l l Normal Zeeman triplet and the inverted triplet obtained by Grillot and Gross for CdS
reference to t h e li nes, a displacement of th e cen tre of the li n e s occ urs o n appli cati o n of a field H which i s q uad ra ti c in H. It is explained as a change i n m a g n e ti c energy d u e With
of
fu rt h e r
gra vi ty
Luminescence in
98
Crystals
t o the d iamagnetism o f the exciton. The effect fo r the n'th level is !:,£
__£_n
Go
' 2Hz
Th is effect, which only occurs for atoms with higher membe r s of the series, is observed for n 3 (H 25 to 30,000 oersted). The radius n 2a0' is of the order of 200 A for n 5 in the yellow series of c u pro u s =
_
- 8mc2
4
=
oxide. I n conclusio n , experimental evidence re v e a l s the existence of quasi a tomic systems in certai n crystals w h i c h show hydrogenlike absorp tion and emission spectra gi v en to a first a pproxima t i o n by the q uasi positronium level system of excitons. The large orbital radii indi cated by t h e Stark and Zeeman effects and the a greeme n t between the experimental and theoretical oscillator s t re n gt h s str o ngly sup port this model , a lt h o u gh the t h e o r ie s are often over-simpl ified and althou gh numerous points still need to be clarified. The identification of the system responsible for these o p t ica l transi tions with t h e Frenkel exciton rests on the evide n ce of its m o bility and its role in energy transfer, wh i c h re q u i res other experiments wh i ch we shal l refer to later (e x pe ri m e n ts of Broser and of B a l kanski on CdS). Light emission due to e xcito n recombination would s e em to be more li kely once the e xci t o n has been i mmob i l ized in the n e i g h b o u rhood of a l at t i ce defect. =
B I B LI O G R A P H Y
M . ( 1 938) ' D ber die Form der Emissions banden von Krystallphosphoren, un s be s o n d ere deren Temperatu r
1 . 1 . The 'momentum' selection rule and its consequences
B I RU S , K . a n d S c H 6 N ,
abhangigkeit', Verhandl. der deutsche Physikal. Gesellschaft, 19, 8 3 . F . a n d R o M P E , R . ( 1 9_AOJ ' O ber En e rgie u m w and lu ng in
M 6 G LI C H ,
Krystallphosphoren', Physikal. Z. , SEITZ, F. 2.
41,
2 36.
( 1 940) Modern Theory of Solids. McG raw-Hill Co., New
York.
H E R M A N , F. ( 1 955) 'The electronic e n e rgy band structure of s i l ic o n and germanium', Proc. I. R.E. , 43, 1 703. M A C FARLANE, G . G . and R O B ERTS , V . (1 955) 'Infra-red ab s orp ti o n of germanium near the lattice edge', Phys. Rev., 97, 1 7 1 4.
Band structure
of
germanium and silicon
99
G . G . and ROBERTS , V . ( 1 955) 'Infra-red absorp tion of silicon near the lattice edge', Phys. Rev., 98, 1 865. L A X , B . , R OT H , L . M. and ZWERDLING, S. (1 959) 'Quantum mag neto-absorption phenomena in semi-conductors', J. Phys. Chem . So lids, 8, 3 1 1 . Opt ical transitions
M AC FA R L A N E ,
HERMAN, F . (1 957) 'Report on the second symposium on the phy s i cs of semi-conductors', J. Phys. Chem . Solids, 2, 72.
Indium antimonide
B A L K A N S K I , M . and W A L D R O N , R . ( 1 958) 'Internal photoeffect and exciton diffusion in cadmium and zinc sulphides', Phys . Rev., 1 12,
Band structure and optical transitions in zinc or cadmium sulph ides!
1 23 .
B A LK A N S K I , M . ( 1 959) Proprietes optiques des semi-conducteurs, 2 ,
32. Faculte des Sciences, Paris.
B A L K A N S K I , M . and D E S CLOIZEAUX, J. ( 1 960) 'Transitions op tiques au voisinage de la limite d'absorption dans le CdS', J. Phys.
Rad. ,
825 ; 22, 41 .
H . (1955) 'Photoconductivity of the sulphide, selenide and
21,
telluride of zinc or cadmium',
B UBE, R .
J.R.E. , 43, 1 836.
B uB E , R . H . ( 1 955) 'Temperature dependence of the width of the Proc.
band gap in several photocond uctors',
Rev., 98, 43 1 .
B U B E , R . H . ( 1 957) 'Analysis of photoconductivity applied to CdS type photoconductors', J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 1 , 234. Cox, J. T . , WAYLONIS, J. E. and HUNTER, W. ( 1 9 59) 'Optical Pro perties of ZnS in the vacuum U.V.', J. Opt. Soc. Am., 49, 807. VAN D ooRN, C. Z. (1954) 'Temperature dependence of the energy
gap in ZnS',
1 1 55.
G . ( 1 957) 'Optical absorption band edge in aniso
Physica, 20,
tropic crystals',
D R ESSE L H A U S ,
Phys.
1 35.
D u M KE , W . P . ( 1 9 57) 'Spontaneous radiative recombination in semi conductors', Phys. R ev . , 1 05, 1 39. K E L L E R , S. P . and P E TT I T , G. D. (1 959) 'Optical properties of acti Phys. Rev . , 105,
vated and unactivated ZnS single crystals',
526.
PIPER, W. W . (1 953) 'Some electrical and optical properties of syn thetic crystals of zinc sulphide', Phys . Rev . , 92, 23 . Phys.
Rev.,
1 15,
t The problem of band structure connected with binding in ZnS and CdS is described in Chapter V .
I 00
P I P ER ,
W.
Luminescence
in Crystals
W . , M A R P LE , D . T . F . and J O H N S O N , P . D .
( 1 9 5 8)
'O p ti
c a l properties o f hexagonal ZnS crystals', Phys. Rev . , 1 1 0, 3 2 3 .
P I P ER , W .
W . , J O I-I N S O N , P . D . a n d M A R P L E , D. T . F . ( 1 9 5 9) 'Tem
perature depen d ence o f the optical band gap in ZnS', J. Phys.
Solids, 8, 4 5 7 . N . A . ( 1 9 59) 'A study o f t h e intrinsic ab sorp t i o n spec tru m of zinc sulphide', Op tics and Spec troscopy, 7, 320. Ch em .
V L A S EN K O ,
1 1 . 1 . Elec tron-hole
recombination in germanium
Th eory of band- t o -band recombination S H O C K L E Y , W. a n d V A N ROOS B R OE K , W. ( 1 954) ' Ph o to n radiative reco m b i n a t i o n s of ele c tr on s and holes in germanium', Phys. Rev. ,
94, 1 5 58 .
Two-steps recombination o n a crystal defect
S H O C K LEY, W .
and R E A D , W. T . ( 1 9 52) ' Stati s ti cs of the recombina
t i o n of holes and
electrons',
For experi mental wo rk,
2. Ewles-Kri:iger
Phys . Rev . , 87, 8 3 5 .
see Ch apt e r
IX
(Electroluminescence).
emission spectrum
EW L E S , J . ( 1 9 3 8) ' Resolution and i nterpretation of the l um i n e sce nt spectra of some s o l i ds at low t e m p e ra t u r e s ' , Proc. Roy. Soc. , A
Early references
167,
34.
K R O G E R , F. A. ( 1 9 4 0) 'Lumi nescence
and ab s o r p ti o n in zinc sul phi de, cad m i u m s u l p hi d e and their solid solutions', Physica , 7, I . P R I N G S H E I M , P . ( 1 9 49 ) Fluorescence and Phosphorescence, 608 . Intersc. Pub . , New York.
R A N D A L L , J.
T. ( 1 9 3 9) ' S o me recent experiments on l u m i n escence ' ,
Trans. Faraday Soc . , 3 5 , 2 .
S c HON ,
M . ( 1 9 42)
'Zum Leuchtmechanismus d e r K ristallphosphore',
Zeits. fur Phys., 1 19,
463.
G R O SS , E . F . , G R I L L O T , E . and RAZBIRINE, deux series de spectre de l a fluorescence v e rt e a basse te mp e rature du cadmium pur', Comptes-Rendus A cad. Se. Paris, 250,
More recent work, mainly on cadmium sulphide
B A N C I E - G R I LLOT, M . ,
B. S. ( 1 960) ' Infl u en ce d e la te m p e ratu re sur I e s
bandes d u
sulfu re 2868 .
de
C O L LT NS , R . 1 .
Optical transitions
101
( 1 959) ' Mechanism and defect res p o n s i b l e fo r ed ge
em ission in C d S ' , J. Appl. Phys. , 30, I 1 3 5 .
COLLINS ,
R . 1 . a n d HOPFTELD ,
e m i ssio n in C d S
1 . 1 . ( 1 960) 'Polari zati o n o f edge
Phys. Rev . , 1 20,
840.
H. G. J. ( 1 9 5 7) 'The a tu r e of edge emission in Cd S', Physica, 23, 9 8 7 . D U TTON, D. ( 1 9 5 8 ) 'A niso t r o py of e dg e l u m i n escence in cad m i u m sulphide', J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 6 , 1 0 1 . H A L S TE D , R . E . , A P P LE , E . F . and P R E N E R , 1 . S . ( 1 9 5 9 ) ' T w o - s tage op ti cal exci tat i o n in s u l p h i d e phosphors ' , Phys. Rev. Letters, 2, 420. H O P F I E L D , 1. 1. ( 1 959) ' A theory o f e d g e e m i ss i o n phe n o m e n a i n CdS , ZnS a n d ZnO', J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 1 0 , 1 1 0. KLICK, C . C . ( 1 95 1 ) 'Low temperature l u m i n e s c enc e o f i n o rganic solids', J. Opt. Soc. Am., 41, 8 1 6. K L I C K , C . C . (1 953) 'Luminescence and absorpti o n in C d S at the absorption edge', Phys . Rev., 89, 274. K RO G E R , F. A . and M E Y E R , H. G. 1. ( 1 954) 'The edge emission of ZnS, Cd S and ZnO and its relation to the lattice vibrati o n s of these solids', Physica, 20, 1 1 49. L AMB E , J . , KLI C K , C . C . and D EXTER , D. L . ( 1 956) Nat u re of edge emission in cadmium sulphide', Phys. Rev. , 103, 1 7 1 5. REYNOLD S , D . C . ( 1 960) 'Temperature dependence of edge emission in cad mium sulphide', Phys. Rev., 1 18, 478 . SMITH, R . W . ( 1 957) 'Low-field electroluminescence in i n s u l ati n g crystals of cadmium sulphide', Phys. Rev . , 1 05, 900. ',
D I E M E R , G . , V A N G U R P , G.
1. and M EYER ,
n
'
J . and KLEINMAN, D . A . (1 959) 'Infrared reflectivity of zinc oxide', J. Phys . Chem. Solids, 11, 1 90. CO UTURE, L. and M ATHIEU, 1. P. (1 953) 'Spectre de diffu s i o n d es cristaux piezoelectriques. Blende', Comptes-Rendus A cad. Se. Vibrational energies in ZnS and Zn O
COLLINS , R .
Paris, 236, 37 1 .
H A A S , C . and M A T H I EU,
l o ngitudin a les et Rad., 15, 492.
J.
P.
t ransversales
C H O Y K E , W. J . , H A MILTON,
( 1 954) 'Spectre i n fra-ro uge et o n d e s dans les cristaux cubiques', J. Phys.
Edge emission in SiC
ized e d ge e m i ssion of
D. R.
and PATR I C K , L. ( 1 960) 'Pol a r 1 4 30.
S i C ' , Phys . Rev . , 1 17,
I 02
Luminescence in Crystals
L . (1 960) 'Polarization of the luminescence of d onor acceptor pairs', Phys. Rev., 1 17, 1 439. See also, in connection with the donor-acceptor theory for edge
PATRI C K ,
P RENER, J . S . an d WILLIAMS, F. E . ( 1 9 56) 'Associated donor acceptor luminescent cen t res , Phys. Rev., 101 , 1 427. PRENER, J. S . and WILLIAMS, F. E. ( 1 9 5 6) 'Theorie des centres luminogenes du type donneur-accepteur associes', J. Phys. Rad. , emission :
'
17, 669. WALLIS, R . F . , H ERMAN,
Spectr., 4, 5 1 .
R.
and M I LNES,
H.
W . ( 1 960) Ene rgy J. Molecular '
l evel s of an electron in the field of an i n fi nite d ipole',
Ill. Emission and absorption spectra o f the excitont
Ea rly references FRENKEL, J. ( 1 93 1) ' O n the t ransformation of light i n t o heat i n solids', Phys. Rev., 37, 1 7, 1 276. FRENKEL, J. ( 1 936) ' O n the absorption o f l ight a n d the trapping of electrons a n d holes in crystalline dielectrics' , Phys. Z. So wje t Union, 9, 1 58. Mon, N . F . (1938) 'Energy levels in real a n d ideal crystals' , Trans. Faraday Soc. , 34, 500. Mon, N. F. ( 1 938) 'On the absorption of light by crystals', Proc. Roy. Soc., A 167, 384. PEIERLS, R. (1 932) 'Zur T h�eo ri e der Absorptionspektren fester Korper', Ann. Phys. , 13, 955. WANNIER, G . H . ( 1 937) 'The structure of electronic excitation levels in insulating crystals', Phys. Rev., 52, 1 9 1 . Comprehensive papers on the exciton problem BA LKANSKI, M . ( 1 958) Etude sur le probleme de l'exciton, Ecole d ' Ete
I'Etat
Normale
Paris.
BALKAN S K I , M . ( 1 958) 'Etat actuel du probleme d e l'exciton', J. Phys. Rad., 19, 1 70 ; 22, 1 1 3 . G Ross, E . F . ( 1 956) 'O p t i ca l spectrum of exci tons i n t h e crystal lattice', Nuovo Cimento, 3, Suppl. no. 4, 672 (48 references). sur
Solide. Ecole
Superieure,
t The papers working chiefly about exciton diffusion and transfers by excitons are described in Chapter VIII.
Optical transitions
1 03
H A K E N , H . ( 1 9 58) Der heutige Stand der Exzitonenforschung in Halb
/eitern. Vieweg, Braunschweig.
Phys. A cta, 28, 307.
N I KITIN E , S. ( 1 955) 'Spectres de l'exciton dans les cristaux', Helvetica NI KITINE, S . (1 955) 'Spectres d'absorption de l'etat solide', J. Phys.
Rad. , 16, 40S.
NIKITINE, S. (1 959) 'Spectroscopie du corps solide et spectres de l'exciton', J. Phys. Chem. So li ds, 8, 1 90.
Some experimental work on the emission and absorption spect ra of the exciton in ionic semi-conductors; Cu20, CdS, Hgl2, Agl, &c . . . . A RK H A N G U E LS K A I A , V . A . and FEOFILOV, P . P . ( 1 9 56) 'Sur les bandes etroites dans le spectre de luminescence de quelques cristaux aux basses temperatures', J. Phys . Rad. 17, 824. B A N C I E - G R I LLOT, M . , G Ross, E . F . , GRI LLOT, E . and RAZ BIRIN E , B . S . ( 1 959) 'Investigation of linear fluorescence and absorption o f pure cadmium sulphide crystals a t a temperature of 4 ·2°K', Optika i Spekt., 6, 707. Op t ics and Spectros. , 6, 46 1 . G RILLOT, E . , G R I LLOT, M . , PEST E I L , P . and ZMER L I , A . ( 1 956) ' Spectre de fluorescence quasi-hydrogenoide (exciton) de sulfure de cadmium pur a 20°K', Compt es-Rendus Acad. Se. Paris, 242, 1 794. G RILLOT, E. ( 1 956) 'Fluorescence de I'exciton dans CdS pur', J. Phys. Rad. , 17, 822. G RI LLOT, E. (1 958) 'Sur le transfert d'energie par Ies excitons dans le sulfure de cadmium pur', J. Chimie Phys., 55, 642. G ROSS, E . F . and KARRIEV, N . A . ( 1 9 52) 'Optical spectrum of the exciton', Dokl. Akad. Nauk S.S.S.R., 86, 47 1 . G ROSS, E . F . and JACOBSON, M . A . ( 1 955) 'Absorption line spec trum in the cadmium sulphide crystal at liquid air temperature', J. Techn. Fiz. , 25, 364. G Ross, E . F. and JACOBSON, M . A. (1956) 'Emission spectrum of the exciton', Z. Tekhn. Fiz. S.S.S. R., 26, 1 369. G Ross, E. F. ( 1 956) 'Le spectre optique d u a la formation des ex citons dans les reseaux cristallins', J. Phys . Rad. , 17, 8 1 5. G ROSS, E . F . and ZAKHARTCHENIA, B . P . ( 1 9 5 7) 'Les effets lineaire et quadratique Zeeman et le d iamagnetisme de l'exciton du crista! de protoxyde de cuivre', J. Phys. Rad., 18, 68. G ROSS, E . F . , G R I LLOT, E . , ZAKHARTCHENIA , B. P. and BANCIE G R I LLOT, M . ( 1 959) 'Influence of a magnetic field on the blue ,
1 04
Luminescence in
Crystals
fl u o rescence l i nes and of the abso rption lines of ce r ta i n pure cad mium s u l p h i d e crystals at a te m p e ra ture of 4·2°K', Optika i Spekt., 6, 7 1 0. Opt ics a n d Spectros. , 6, 462. N I K I T I N E , S . , PERNY, G. an d S I ES K I N D , M . ( 1 954) 'Etude des s p e c t re s de l'exciton dans Cu 20 ' , J. Phys . Rad. , 15, 1 8 S . N I K I T I N E , S . ( 1 956) ' Etu d e des spectres de l'exciton aux tres basses temperatures', J. Phys. Rad. , 17, 8 1 7. ' S p ect res d ' exci t o n d es cristaux ioniques', J. Phys. Rad. , 19, 2 1 S. N I K IT I N E , S . ( 1 9 5 8) ' E tu d e experimentale et tentative d 'i n te rp reta tion d es spec t re s d'absorption fondamentalc des c r i s tau x purs' , J. Chimie Phys. , 55, 62 1 . N I K I T I N E , S . , R E I S S , R . and S I ES K I N D , M . ( 1 958) ' Classification des s pect r e s des co rps solides et leur o ri g in e cxcitonique', Comptes Rendus A cad. Se. Paris, 246 , 3 4 3 9 . N I K IT I N E , S . and S ! ES K I N D , M . ( 1 9 5 8 ) 'Etude c o m p a r a t iv e des spectres d'absorption, d'emission et de refiexio n de Hgl 2 rouge aux basses temperatures', J . Chimie Phys. , 55, 837. N I K I T I N E , S . , GRUN, J. B. a n d S ! ES K I N D , M. ( 1 96 1 ) 'Etude spectro
N ! K I T I N E , S . ( 1 958)
photometrique de la serie j aune de Cu 20 aux basses temperatures', J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 17, 292. P E R N Y , G . ( 1 9 56) 'Remarques concernant le spectre de l'exciton', J. Phys. Rad. , 1 7, 820. P ER N Y , G. ( 1 9 5 8 ) 'Spectres de l'exciton et polymorphisme de l ' i o d ure d ' a r gen t' , J. Chimie Phys. , 55, 650.
Theoretical work on the exciton A N DRE, P. (1 958) 'Etude theorique sur l'exciton dans le sulfure de cadmium' . Thesis, Faculte des Sciences, P a ri s . B A L K A N S K I , M . ( 1 9 59) Proprietes op tiques des semi-conducteurs, 2, 79. Faculte des Sciences, Paris. B A R R I O L , J . , N I K I T I N E , S. and S ! ES K I N D , M. ( 1 9 56) ' Ca l cu l des n iveaux d'energie de liaison d'un e x ci t o n dans un crista! u n ia x e' , Comptes-Rendus A cad. Se. Par is , 242, 790. D RESSELH A U S , G. (1 956) 'Effective mass ap p r o x i m at i o n for exci tons', J. Phys. Chem . Solids, 1 , 1 5 . D R ES S E L H A U S , G . (1 957) ' A b s o r p tio n coefficients for exciton ab s o rp t i o n lines', Phys. Rev . , 106, 76.
D Y K M A N , I . and
1 05
P E K A R , S . I . ( 1 9 52) ' E x c i t o n s i n i o n i c c rysta l s ' ,
I . ( 1 9 57) 'Theory of excitons i n
Dokl. Akad.
DYKMAN,
Optical transitions
Nauk S. S.S. R . , 83, 8 2 5 .
Akad. Na uk S.S. S. R., Ser Fiz. , 2 1 , 65.
i o n i c crystals', Jzvest.
'Intensity of optical a bso rp t i o n by excitons', 1 384. E LLIOTT, R. J. and LouooN, R . ( 1 9 59) ' Th eor y of fine structure on t h e absorp tion edge in sem i-cond uctors', J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 8, 382. H A K EN , H. ( 1 9 56) 'Theorie des excitons dans les cristaux pola i res ' , J. Phys. Rad. , 1 7, 826. H A K E N , H. ( 1 9 57) 'Berech nung der Energie des Exzito n e n g r u n d zustandes i m p ol aren Kristall n ach einem neuen Variation sver fah ren von Feynman', Z. Phys. , 147, 323. H A K E N , H . ( 1 958) ' D i e Thcorie des Exzi t o n s i m festen Ko rper', Forts. der Phys. , 6, 2 7 1 . H A K E N , H . and S C H OTTKY, W . ( 1 958) 'Die Behandlung des Exzitons nach der Vielelektronentheorie', Z. Phys. Chem. Frankfurt, 16, 2 1 8 . HELLER , W . R . and MARCUS, A . ( 1 9 5 1 ) 'A note on the pro p aga t i o n of excitation in an ideal ized crystal', Phys. R ev . , 84, 809. HOPFIELD , J. J . ( 1 960) 'Fine structure in the op t ical a b s o rpt i o n e d g e of an i sot r op i c c r y s t a l s ', J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 15, 97. M EY E R , H . G . J . ( 1 9 56) ' S o m e aspects of electron-lattice i n teraction in polar crystals', Thesis, Amsterdam, Physica, 22, 1 09. N I K ITI N E , S . ( 1 95 5) 'Theorie approchee du spectre de l 'exciton d ' u n crista! u n i axc', Comptes-Rendus A cad. Se. Paris, 240 , 1 4 1 5 . P E K A R , S . I . ( 1 958) 'Theory of electromagnetic waves in a crystal with exci t o n s ', J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 5, 1 1 . T H O M A S , D . G . , HoPFI ELD , J. J . and P OW E R , M . ( 1 960) 'Excitons and the ab so r p tio n edge of cadmium sulphide', Phys. Rev . , 1 19, 570. E L L IOTT, R. J. ( 1 957) Phys.
Rev.,
108,
Excitons in germanium and silicon
P . , QUARRI NGTON, J . E. a n d ' Fine structure i n the absorpti on e d ge spec trum of ger m a n i u m ' , Phys. Rev . , 108, 1 377. M A C FA R L A N E , G. G . , M c LEAN, T. P . , Q UA R R I N G T O N , J. E. a n d RoB E R TS , V . ( I 958) ' Fine structure i n the abs o r p t i o n e d ge spec t r u m o f s i l i c o n ' , Phys. Rev., 1 1 1 , 1 245. M A CFA R L A N E , G . G . , M c L E A N , T . R o B E R T S , V . ( 1 9 57)
106
Luminescence in Crystal.�
M c LE A N , T. P.
and Lo u o o N , R . ( 1 960) 'Exciton energy levels i n germanium a n d silicon', J. Phys. Chem . Solids, 1 3 , I . Z W E R D L I N G , S . , ROT H , L . M . and L A X , B . ( 1 958) 'Direct transition exciton and fine structure of the magneto-absorption spectrum in germanium', Phys. Reu . , 1 09, 2207. Excitons in aflvali ha/ides
and T A FT , E . ( 1 9 5 2) Jmpelfections in Nearly Pe1ject Crystals. Chapman and H a l l Ltd . , London. E B Y , J. E . , T E EG A R D E N , K . and D U TT O N , D . B . ( 1 959) ' U l tra violet absorption of alkali halides', Phys. Reu . , 1 1 6, 1 099. v o N H I P P E L ( 1 936) 'Einige prinzipielle Gesichtpunkte zur Spektro scopie der Ionenkristalle und ihre Anwendung auf d ie A l kalihalo genide', Z. fur Phys., 101, 680. KNOX, R. S. and l N C H A U S P E , N. ( 1 959) 'Exciton states i n ionic crystals', Phys. Rev . , 1 1 6, 1 09 3 . M o T T , N . F . a n d G U R N E Y , R . W . ( 1 948) Electronic Processes in Ionic Crystals, 88-1 00. Clarendon Press, Oxford . M uT o , T . ( 1 956) 'Structure de l'exciton de KCI', J. Phys. Rad., 17, 829. M U T O , T . , 0YAMA , S. and 0 K U N O , H. ( 1 958) 'Electronic structure of the exciton in ionic crystal', Prog. Theor. Phys., 20, 804. M uT o , T. ( 1 9 59) 'Exciton problem and a new approach to its elec tronic structure', Prog. Theor. Phys . , Suppl. 1 1 , 1 . S L A T E R , J . C . and S H O C K L E Y , W . ( 1 936) 'Optical absorption by the alkali halides', f._hy_s. R ev . , 50, 705. APKER, L.
Some references on the a and {3 bands B A S S A N I , F . a n d l N C H A U S P E , N . ( 1 957) 'Position of the "greek" bands in alkali halides crystals', Phys. Rev., 105, 8 1 9. D E L B E C Q , C . J . , P R I N GS H E I M , P . and Y U S T E R , P . ( 1 9 5 1 ) 'A new type of short wavelength absorption band in alkali h alides contain ing colour centres', J. Chem. Phys., 19, 574. D ELB E C Q , C. J . , P R I N G S H E I M , P . and Y U S T E R , P . ( 1 952) 'a and {3 bands in potassium iodide crystals', J. Chem. Phys. , 20, 746. D E L B E C Q , C. J. and P R I N G S H E I M , P. ( 1 9 5 3) 'Absorptio n bands and lines in irradiated L i F', J. Chem. Phys., 21, 794.
C HAPT E R V
Luminescence Centres in Phosphorescent Sulphides
I . CONSTIT UT I O N OF PHOSP H O R ESCENT S ULPHIDES
To obtain luminescent zinc sulphide the base material must first be obtained as pure as possible. To do this several methods are available : (a) Hydrogen sulphide is passed through a solution of zinc salt, the zinc sulphide precipitated, washed and dried in an oven. (b) Guntz and Grillot used as the sulphuretting agent sodium thio sulphate Na2S20 3 instead of H 2S which forms a disulphide ZnS2 which is unstable and decomposes to give ZnS at high temperatures. (c) Coustal used a direct reaction of the elements zinc and sulphur, an explosive process but one appropriate for the production of so called 'self-activated' sulphides. As necessary a salt of the activator impurity is added in a suitable quantity and often also a flux (e. g. 1 per cent NaCl) and the whole is usually fired at 900°- 1 ,200°C. If the firing takes place at a temperature below 1 020° C the zinc sulphide crystallizes in the cubic form (blende), above 1 ,020°C the hexagonal form (wurtzite) is produced . Cooling must be sufficiently rapid to have the wurtzite form persisting at room temperature. Lewchin has found wurtzite to be present in ZnS made at much lower temperatures f'>:! 650°C. The small difference between the properties of the two forms of zinc sulphide is remarkable. The emission bands are very similar ; for ZnS(Cu) the green-band maximum is a little displaced towards the yellow-green in the case of blende crystals, in agreement with the slightly smaller energy-band gap for this form. Both forms show phosphorescence (they appear to have the same groups of electron traps with additional groups in the case of wurtzite). The difference 1 07 1 . Preparation
,
1 08
Luminescence
between the
in
Crystals
funda mental o r lattice absorp t i o n edge positi o n s is a l s o structures the n eares t neighbour configurati o n i . e . a t e t rah e d ro n of s u l p h u r i o n s a round a zinc i o n (o r
very s m a l l . I n b o t h is the same,
)
v i ce versa .
The p rep a ra t o ry methods fo r cad m i u m s u l phide a re anal ogous, but only the hexagonal form (wurtzite) usually o ccu r s. The blend e form has been observed , but only i n excepti onal cases . The st u d y of crystal l i n e t ra n s fo r ma t io n s in ZnS is ge n e ral ly made by o ptic a l m i c ro scop y using polarized light : hexagonal crystals are bi refringen t , w h i l e cubic crystals are not. T h i s method is a n excellent one and was used by A . G u ntz as early as 1 923. Diffr a c t i on e x peri ments by means of X-rays have al so been p e rfo r m ed . More recently, an inter e s t i n g meth od has been proposed by van Wierin gen ( 1 953) and used by A ven a n d Parodi ( 1 960) i n o rder to study the influence o f activator i m puri t ie s (Cu, A g) on crys t a l st r u c ture . A fraction of a bou t I 0 4 M n 2 + w a s added to the s am ple and electron spin reson ance studies were carried out. It is w e ll known (page 1 24) that the r es onan c e spectrum of Mn 2 + embedd e d in a n h exa g on a l su l phid e possesses 30 l i n es but only 6 in the b l e n d e cas e. The energy d iffere n ce between t h e blende and wurtzite forms is cer tainly e x t re mely s mal l ; p e r haps the transition temperature, and m o re over the rate of t h e transition, i s affected by low co n cent ra t io n s of cop p e r . A ccord ing to A ven and Paro d i , heati n g for one hour at 1 , ro o c a c h iev e s the transformation blende-wurtzite for a concentra tion of c o p p e r c < 2 · 5 . 1 0 - 4 , while the blende s t r u ctu re p e r s i s t s if c > 7 · 5 . J 0 4 • M an g an ese p ro d u c es an anal ogous effect (K ro g er) but at l a rger concentrations. Addamiano a n d A v e n sugges t that the transition te m p e rat u re fo r very pure c rys t a l s is hi ghe r than the accepted val u e of 1 ,020°C. The occurrence of t he phase ch a n ge wurtzite-blende nee d s nuclea tion effects whose opt i m u m temperature lies between 700°C ( Aven and P aro di) and 900°C ( Kremheller) . These results seem in a gree m ent with Lewch i n ' s exper i m en t s .
2. Numerical values of the energy-band gap for phosphors of the ZnS type The fol l o w i n g t a b l e is t a k e n fro m t h e review by B u b e (Proc. J. R.E.) and gi ves t h e v a l u es fo r the fu n d a m e n t a l o p t ical absorption limit .A.11m as well as t h o se for t h e e q u i v a len t q u a n t u m e n e rgy hl'llm· This quan-
Luminescence centres
1 09
t u rn is near to the v a l u e E for the fo r b id d e n b a n d w i d t h b u t m o re
precisely we h ave
/n·um h1•um
=
=
Egap if the
ve r t i ca l ( n o ph o n o n s i n vo l ved) if th e transi t i o n is effected with s i m u l ta n e o u s
tra n siti o n is
Egap - Ephonon
p h o n o n abso rptio n .
The table also gives the value for the agai n s t tem peratu re
s l o pe f3 of t h e
cu rve Ega 1,( T)
T between l i q u i d a i r tempera t u re a n d l 30°C.
E�;a,,(T)
=
Egap(O) -(JT
TA BLE V. !
Fundamental absorption limits h •um (e V) at 293°K
""'" (1)
at 293°K
ZnS blende ZnS wurtzite CdS wurtzite ZnSe blende CdSe wurtzite ZnTe blende CdTe blende
3,410 3,350
{J (e VjO C)
? 5·5 X J O -• 5 x IO - ' 7 X JO-' 5 x Jo-•
3 · 64 3 - 70 2-43 2-60 1 · 74 2 15 1 ·42
5 , 1 00 4,770 7,1 1 5 5,780 8,7 1 0
? 4 x IO-'
The values
give n are those which occur most o fte n i n the li tera t u re . e d ge i s not so sh arply defi ned a n d h1 ·1 1 m c a n est i m a ted to 0· 1 e V . W e often fi x t h e a b s or p t i o n l i m i t as t h e
However, the absorption o nly be
w a ve l e n g t h for whic h the absorption coefficient is 1 00 m m 1 ( Fi g . V . I ) . The l i m i t is most probably a ss o ci a t e d with a n o n - vertica l (o r Num ber of e l e c trons per photo n
K (m m1 ) '
1
Fig.
A(A)
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 :> 2
'--'-
3300
V. I
(a )
3400
3500
(b)
Op t ical properties of an unactivated ZnS (wurt
zite) crystal at room temperature (after Piper) (a) absorp tion spectrum (h) photoconduction response spectrum
1 10
Luminescence in Crystals
indi rect) transition (involving phonon absorption) between the valence and conduction bands, the lowest levels of the latter being due to the s-states of zinc or cadmium (Dresselhaus) while the valence band has a more complex structure due to the mixing of the p- and s-states of the sul phu r ions. In a purely ionic model for zinc sulphide Zn2+S 2 - the v al e nce band will be due to the S2- ions while t h e con duction levels will be those for Zn2+ to which an electron has been added, i.e. those for Zn + (cf. Fig. 1!. 2 for the monovalent ionic c ry st a l KC!). The l ong-w a v e limit for mixed crystals of ZnS and Cd S shifts con tinuously in the di rec t i o n of greater wavelengths with i ncreasi n g cadmium concentration (H e nde rs on , Kroger, P r i n gs h e i m). A similar di sp l ac e m ent occurs fo r the l u m i n esce n ce emission bands (A. Guntz, Rothschild, &c.).
This shift is al most linear when the the percentage of Cd S
functions of
hv11m are pl o t t e d as w e i g h t relative to ZnS
e n e rgies by
(Fig. V.2).
This behaviour suggests a s m a l l o r i n si g n i fi c an t difference i n t h e nature of the absorpti o n t r an s i t i o n hvlim for ZnS and CdS (K roger) . It contrasts with the behav i o u r of germ a n i u m-s i l icon al loys.
Fig.
Zn S
Q O '!.
V . 2 Band gap
1. 0 '1.
6