This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
(a)! (ssr+1 ... Sn) is in aRs , whieh proves the converse inclusion. Thus we see that aRs = q1R s n qrRs. Now we assume that \11 ;R i ;"2 qi and that r ~ 1. Take an element a of ni ;"2 qi which is not in al . Then since qlRs n R = ql, <1>( a) is not in qlR s , which shows that aIRs ;f2 i ;"2 qlRs . 101
COROLLARY:
~Rs
is a maxi-
If an ideal a of R does not meet S then, aRs "s Rs .
(6.9) THE~REM: Let ql, ... , q" be primary ideals of R. Then n ... n qn)Rs = qlRs n ... n q"R s . If ql ~ i ;"2 qi and if aiRs "s R s , then qlRs ~ i ;"2 qiRs . Proof: Set a = ql n '" n qn. We renumber qi so that qi n Sis empty if and only if i ~ 1'. Since qiR s contains aRs , aRs is contained ill alR 8 n ... n qnRs (= qlR.~ n .. , n q,.R.~). Let <1>(a)/<1>(s) (a E R, .~ ,:: S) be an element of qlRs n ... n q,.R.~ . Since qiR s n R - qi for i ~ r, a is in ql n '" n qr. Take elements S"+I , . . . , Sn of S so that 8"_j is in qr+j' Then a' = as"+I'" snisina.Therefore<1>(a)!
n
n
n ...
n
n
17
CHAPTER I
(G.lO) COROLLARY: Assume that the zero ideal of R can be e.rpressed as the intersection of primary ideals ql , ... , qn of R, where qi n S is empty if and only if i :::; r. Then the idwl n( =cp-I(O)) coincides with ql qr. Proof: n = cp-I(O) and therefore n = (O)Rs n R. By our assumption, (O)Rs = q1R s n ... n qrRs and therefore n = ql n ... n qr. (6.11) Let R be a ring and let S be a multiplicatively closed subset of R which does not contain zero. Let S' be a multiplicatively closed subset of Rs which does not contain zero. Let S" be the multiplicatively closed subset of R generated by S and all elements s" of R such that with a suitable element s of s, cp ( s") !cf> ( s) is in S', where cp is the natural homomorphism from R into Rs . Then R s" = (Rs)s' . Proof: Let e and 1r be the natural homomorphisms from R into R s" and from Rs into (Rs)S' , respectively. Then every clement of 1rCP(S") has inverse in (Rs)8' and (Rs)s' is generated by 1r¢(R) and inverses of clements of 1r¢( S"). Therefore there exists a homomorphism from R~" onto (Rs)s, . Let n" be the keruel of 1r¢. Then for every element a of n", there exists an element cp (s" ) / cp (s ) (s E S, s" E 8") of S' slH~h that cp( a )cp( s")!cf>( s) = O. Then as" is in the kernel of cp, whence there exists an element s' of S such that as"s' = o. Since s" s' is in S", a is in the kerncl of e. Therefore e = 1rCP, whence R,s" = (Rs)s'. (6.12) Let R be a ring and let S be a multiplicatively closed subset of R which contains no zero divisor. If a ring R' contains R and is contained in Rs , then Rs = R~. The proof is straightforward, and we omit it. We introduce the following notation: Let R be a ring and let:r be a transcendental element over R. Let S be the set of polynomials f E R[x] whose coefficients generate the unit ideal R in R. Then S is a multiplicatively closed subset of ReS contains no zero divisor because of the following lemma: (6.13) An element L~ aixi(ai E R) is a zero divisor in R[x], if and only if there is an element b ~ 0 of R such that bai = 0 for every i. Proof: The if part is obvious. Assume that L aix i is a zero divisor. j There is a non-zero element L~ bjx such that
n ... n
( L aixi) ( L bjx
j )
=
o.
We prove the existence of b as in the assertion by induction on the j degree s of bjx • If s = 0, it is obvious and we assume that s > o.
L
18
GENERAL COMMUTATIYEJ RINGS
If (L aixi)b s 0, then there is nothing to prove, and we assume i that aib s ~ 0 for some i, which means that aj( bix ) ~ 0 for some j; let t be the largest j such that the non-equality holds. Then
L
,( L~ aixi) ( L
j bjx )
0
=
L
j
and therefore atb. = o. Therefore f = ate bjx ) is different from zero and deg f < s. Furthermore, obviously (L aixi)f = 0, and we prove the assertion by induction. Now since S does not contain any zero divisor, the ring R[x]s contains R. This R[x]s is denoted by R(x). When Xl , ... , Xn are algebraically independent, we can define R(Xl)(X2) ... (Xn). This last ring is denoted by R(Xl' ... ,xn ), or simply by R(x). The following lemma is easily seen (cf. (6.17) below): (6.14) With R and the Xi as above, if R is quasi-local, or local, or quasi-semi-local, or semi-local or Noetherian then so is R (Xl , . . . , x n ), respectively.
As an immediate consequence of (6.13), we have: ( 6.15) If q is a primary ideal belonging to a prime ideal p in R, then in the polynomial ring R[x] = R[Xl, ... , x n], pR[x] is a prime ideal and qR[x] is primary to pR[x]; obviously qR[x] R = q.
n
We note by the way that the following is obvious from the uniqueness of the expression of polynomials. (6.16) For ideals ai, ... , an in R, we have, in the polynomial ring R[x], (a l an)R[x] = aiR [x] anR[x]. As for R(x), we have the following results: (6.17) (1) If a is an ideal of R, then R(x)/aR(x) = (R/a)(x); (2) "if q is a primary ideal with prime divisor p, then pR(x) is prime, qR(x) is primary to pR(x), qR(x) R = q, pR(x) R = p; (3) if ai, ... , an are ideals in R, then (al an)R(x) = aIR(x) anR(x); (4) an ideal m' of R(x) is a maximal ideal of R(x), if and only if there exists a maximal ideal m of R such that m' = mR (x) ; and (5) R < R (x) . Proof: (1), (2), and (3) are obvious by the case of R[x] ((6.16)). The if part of (4) is obvious. Let m' be a maximal ideal of R(x). The set m of coefficients of elements of m' R[x] forms an ideal of R. m ~ R by the construction of R (x). Since m' C mR (x) and since m' is maximal, we see that m' = mR(x) and that m is a maximal ideal of R, which completes the proof of (4). (5) follows from (4).
n ... n
n ... n n
... n
n ... n
n
We add here a remark on tensor product:
n
n
CHAPTER I
19
(6.18) Let S be a mu/tiplicatil1ely closed subset of a ring R such that
o~
S. Then ®R Rs is exact. Proof: Let M be an arbitrary R-module. In the set
P
=
{(m, s) 1m E M, s E S}
we introduce an equivalence relation such that (m, s) is equivalent to (m', s') if and only if there is an s" E S such that s"sm' = s"s'm. The set P' of equivalence classes of P becomes an Rs module by the operations (m, s) (m', s') == (s'm sm', ss'), cf>(a)/cP(s)(m, s') == (am, ss') (cf> and == being the natural homomorphism from R into Rs and the equivalence relation respectively). Then, as in the proof of (6.2), we see that there is a natural homomorphism from P' onto Jl![ ® R~ , and by the universal mapping property of the tensor product, we see that P' is naturally isomorphic to M ® Rs. Thus we may identify P' with IV[ ® R~ . If the same is applied to a submodule N of 11[, then we see that N ® Rs ~ 111 ® R~ , and the assertion is proved.
+
+
EXERCISES: 1. With R and the Xi as in (6.14), prove that R(x" ... ,x") = R[x, , ... ,x,,]s with the set S of polynomials whose coefficients generate R.
2. Let a, , '" ,a" be ideals in a ring R and let S be a multiplicatively closed subset of R such that 0 ~ S. Prove that IllRs
n '" n
Il n Rs
=
(Ill
n ... n Il n )Rs .
7. Prime divisors For a given ideal a of a ring R, let U be the set of elements of R which are not zero divisors modulo a. Then U is multiplicatively closed and does not meet a. A prime ideal ~ is called a maximal prime divisor of a if ~ is a maximal ideal with respect to U and if ~ contains a. A prime ideal q of R is called a prime divisor of a if there is a multiplicatively closed subset S of R which does not meet a such that qRs is a maximal prime divisor of aRs . (7.1) A prime divisor q of a contains a, and all elements of q are zero divisors modulo a. Proof: S being as above, qRs contains aRs by definition. (6.6) shows that q = qRs R, which proves that a c q. Applying (6.1) to Ria, we see that all elements of q are zero divisors modulo a. (7.2) A prime ideal ~ is a maximal prime divisor of a if and only if ~ is a maximal member of the set of prime divisors. Proof: By the definition, a maximal prime divisor is a prime di-
n
20
GENERAL COMMUTATIVE RINGS
visor. Let q be a prime divisor of a. Then q consists of zero divisors modulo a by (7.1), hence q is contained in a maximal prime divisor of a, which proves the assertion. (7.3) Let P be a minimal prime divisor of a. Then aRp n R is primary to p. This aR~ n R is called the primary component of a belonging to p. Proof: Since p is minimal among prime ideals containing a, the same is true for pRp and aR p . Therefore aR p is primary to pRp , ,vhich proves our assertion by (2.12). As an immediate consequence, we have: (7.4) A prime ideal p is a minimal prime divisor of a if and only if it is minimal among prime divisors of a. (7.5) Assume that an ideal a of R is the intersection of primary ideals ql , ... , qn and if the intersection nqi is irredundant, then the set of prime divisors of a coincides with the set of the prime divisors Pi oj the qi . Proof: (6.9) applied to Rp with \l = Pi shows that each Pi is a prime divisor of a. Conversely, assume that p is a prime divisor of a. Then for a mUltiplicatively closed set S which does not meet a, pRs is a maximal prime divisor of aRs = nqiRs . An element a of Rs is a zero divisor modulo aRs if and only if a is in some piRs such that piRs ~ Rs. It follows from this and (2.7) that the maximal prime divisors of aRs are some of piRs. Hfmee (6.6) shows that p = Pi for some i, which completes the proof. (7.6) An ideal is primary 4 and only if it has only one prime divisor. Proof: The only if part is a consequence of (7.5). Conversely, assume that an ideal a has only one prime divisor p. (7.4) shows that p is the unique minimal prime divisor of a, hence p is the radical of a. Assume that b is a zero divisor modulo a. Then a + bR consists of zero divisors modulo a, hence there is a maximal prime divisor of a containing b by (2.2). Hence b E p and b is nilpotent modulo a, which proves that a is primary to p. A prime divisor of a which is not minimal is called an imbedded prime divisor of a. For a prime ideal p, p is the unique minimal prime divisor of pr (for any natural number r). Hence the primary component qr of p" belonging to p is well defined. This qr is called the rth symbolic power of lJ and is denoted by p(,) . (7.7) If Rp is a local ring which may not be Noetherian, then the in-
21
CHAPTER I
tersection n of all the symbolic powers \JCr) of \J is the set of elements x of R such that xs = 0 for some s of R which is not in \J. Namely, n is the kernel of the natural homomorphism from R into Rp . Proof: Since Rp is a local ring which may not be 2'\ oetherian, the intersection of \JrR p is zero. Since pcr) = \JrR p R, the assertion follows. As a corollary, we have: (7.8) If R is a Noetherian integral domain, then the intersection of symbolic powers of a prime ideal is zero.
n
8. Primary decomposition of ideals vVe prove here a theorem on the primary decomposition of graded ideals in a graded Noetherian ring, which includes the usual decomposition theorem as a special case (because any ring is a graded ring with the trivial gradation, which will be defined below). We say that a ring R is a graded ring if R is the direct sum of additive subgroups R o , R r , .,. , R n , '" such that RiRj C Ri+j (then it follows that 1 E Ro). An R-module M is called a graded module if M is the direct sum of Ro-submodules lifo, ... , Jl;I n , • •• such that RiNI j ~ lIf i+j . Elements of Rn or M n are called homogeneous elements of degree n. When we say that R = L Rn is a graded ring or that M = L M n is a graded module, we mean that Rn or M n are as above. A submodule N of a graded module M = L: Mn is called graded if N = L (N M n). This definition can be applied to ideals. A gradation is called trivial if all homogeneous elements of positive degrees are zero. (8.1) A submodule N of a graded module M = L Mn over a graded ring R = L Rn is a graded sub module if and only if N is generated by homogeneous elements. Proof: The only if part is obvious. Assume that N is generated by homogeneous elements fniUni E kIn). Lfn E NUn E Mn) implies that Lfn = Lfij( Lk gkij) for some gkij E Rio, hence
n
which is in N. (8.2) If Ni are graded submodules of M and if Ui are graded ideals of R, then nN i , nUi, L:N i , L:Ui, Ur:U2, Nr:N2' Nr:ur, urNr are all graded. The proof is straightforward and we omit it.
22
GENERAL COMMUTATIVE RI""GS
L:
(S.3) THEOREM: A graded ideal q ( ;;t: R) of a graded ring R = Ri is a primary ideal with prime divisor ~ if and only if the following conditions are satisfied: ~ is the ideal generated by all the homogeneous elements which are nilpotent modulo q and, for homogeneous elements a and b, ab E q, a ~ ~ imply b E q. Proof: The only if part is trivial. We prove the if part. Since, by our assumption, every element of ~ is nilpotent modulo q, it is sufficient to show that (L:! ai) ('[~ bj ) E q, L: ai ~ ~ imply L: bj E q, where ai E R i , bj E R j • 'Ve prove it by double induction on m = t - sand n = v - u. If m = 0, we have 2: asb j E q, as ~ ~. Since q is graded, we have asb j E q, hence b j E q and L b j E q. The case where n = 0 is proved similarly. Now we consider the general case. Since asb" is the (s + u) th degree part of (2: ai) (2: b j) and since q is graded, we have asb" E q. We have (2: ai) (2: asb j ) E q. SInce a,b u == 0 modulo q, 2: asb j == L:+1 a,b j mod. q. Hence by our second induction, applied to ("L! ai) (2::+1 asb j ) E q (which has the same m and one less n), we have 2: asb j E q. If as ~ ~,then we apply the case where t - s = 0 and we have L b j E q. If as E ~,then
2:!+1 ai and
2: b
~ ~
(2:!H ai) ( 2: b j
E q. Hence by our first induction, we have j ) E q. Thus the proof is complete.
(S.4) COROLLARY: If q is a graded primary ideal of a graded ring, then the prime divisor of q is also graded. (8.5) If a graded ideal u of a graded ring R is not primary and if R is ~V oetherian, then there are graded ideals 0 and c such that u = 0 n c, u C 0, and such that u C c. Proof: There are homogeneous elements band c such that bc E u, b ,::: u and such that c n ~ u for any natural number n by virtue of 18.:3). Set bi = u:ciR. Since R is Noetherian, there is an n such that 1)'0-,-1 = bn • Set 0 = u bR and c = u cUR; they are graded because U and c are homogeneous. It is obvious that u c 0, u c c. Therefore it i" sufficient to show that 0 n c c u. Let x be an element of 0 n c. Then.r = a+ by = a' cnz(a, a' E u;y,z E R).cx = ac bcy E u, henee c.r = a'c c n+1z E u, which implies that cnHz E u and
+
+
+
+
z E u:c
Tiereiore cnz E u and x
+
nH
= a'
= bn+1 = bn = u:c n •
+ cnz is in u, which completes the proof.
CHAPTER I
23
(8.6) A graded ideal of a graded Noetherian ring R is the intersection of a finite number of graded primary ideals. Proof: Assume the contrary and let F be the set of graded ideals of R which are not the intersections of any finite nnmber of graded primary ideals. Since R is X oetherian, there is a maximal member a of F. a E F implies that a is not primary, hence there are graded ideals lJ and c such that a c lJ, l1 C c and such that a = lJ n c by (8.5). lJ and c are the intersections of graded primary ideals ql , ... , qm and qm+l , .. , , q" respectively by the maximality of a. Then a = nqi, which is a contradiction. Thus F is empty and the proof is complete. Now we have: (8.7) THEOREM: If a is a graded ideal of a graded Noetherian ring R, then (1) there are only a finite number of prime divisors, say PI , ... , . . . , pr, of a, (2) the Pi are necessarily graded, (3) there are graded primary ideals qi belonging to the Pi such that a = nqi and (4) if Pi is a minimal prime divisor of a, then the qj in (3) is necessarily the primary component of a belonging to Pj . Furthermore (5) a cannot be the intersection of primary ideals of number less than r. The primary decomposition given in this theorem is called a shortest primary decomposition of a.
Proof: (1), (2) and (5) follow from (8.6), (7.5) and (8.4). follows from (8.6) and (2.11). (4) follows from (6.6) and (6.9).
un
(8.8) COROLLARY: A prime ideal P of a Noetherian graded ring R is a prime divisor of a graded ideal a of R zj and only if there is a homogeneous element a of R such that a: aR = p. Proof: Let qi be as in (8.7) for a. Since a:a = n(qi:a), we prove the if part easily by virtue of (2.13). If P = Pi for some i, say 1, theri let b be a homogeneous element of q2 qr which is not in a. Then a:b = ql:b, which is primary to p by (2.13). Let c be a homogeneous element in (ql: b) : P which is not in ql: b. Then (ql: b) : c contains p. Hence (ql:b):c = P by (2.13). Thus, with a = bc, we have a:a = P by (l.2).
n .. , n
(8.9) THEOREM: Two graded ideals a and lJ in a graded ring R coincide with each other if and only if aRm = lJRm for every graded maximal ideal m of R. Proof; The only if part is obvious. Assume the validity of aRm = lJRm . Set c = a: lJ. cRm = aRm: lJRm = Rm , hence c is not contained
24
GENERAL COMMUTATIVE RICi'GS
in any graded maximal ideal of R. Since c is graded by (8.2), we have c = R, and 0 c a. Similarly a C 0, and a = b. (8.9) can be generalized to the case of graded modules by the principle of idealization, hence in particular we have: (8.10) COROLLARY: Let 1lI be a morhde over a ring R. If J11 ® Rm for every maximal ideal m of R, then 111 = o.
=
0
EXERCISES: 1. Generalize the above (8.7) to )Toetherian graded modules in the following way: Let lvl be a module over a ring R. A submodule P r" M of M is called primary if any zero divisor with respect to M/P is nilpotent with respect to M/P. In this case 0: (M/P) (= P:M) is a primary ideal. (Prove it.) The prime divisor of 0: (M /P) is called the associated prime ideal of P. If a submodule N of M is an irredundant intersection of primary submodules P, , ... , P n then the associated prime ideals of the Pi are called associated prime ideals of N. Assume that M = L: Mn is a graded module over a graded ring R = L: Rn . (a) Prove that the ring R EB M given in the principle of idealization is a graded ring with the structure L: (Rn EB Mn) and a submodule N of M is graded if and only if it is a graded ideal of the ring R EB M. (b) Prove that a submodule N of M is a primary submodule with associated prime ideallJ if M r" N and if there is a primary ideal q* of R EB M with prime divisor lJ EB M such that N = q* n M. (c) Then apply (8.7). 2. Prove the converse of (b) above in the following form: If N is a primary submodule of M with associated prime ideal lJ, then with the primary ideal q = N:,'vl, q* = q EB N is a primary ideal belonging to lJ EB ill, and, with this q*, N = q* n M. 3. Show that an irredundant primary decomposition (or the associated prime ideals) of the submodule N of M does not necessarily correspond to an irredundant 'primary decomposition (or the prime divisors) of the ideal (N: M). (Hint: Let q, , q2 be primary ideals of R, sct ill = R/q, EB R/q2 , and consider the decomposition of (0) in M.)
9. The notions oj height and altitude We say that a ring R is of altitude r if there is a chain of prime ideals Pi such that po :J P, :J ... :J pr but there is no such chain with more terms. If there is no such r, we say that R is of infinite altitude. For a prime ideal P of R, the altitude of Rp is called the height of p. Xamely, height p is the maximum of lengths of descending chains of prime ideals which begin with p (length of a chain is defined to be one less than the number of terms of the chain). For an ideal a of R, the minimum of heights of minimal prime diyisors of a is called the height of a; the maximum (or supremum) of
25
CHAPTER I
these heights is called the altitude of a. altitude R/a is called the depth of a. 'iVe shall prove a fundamental theorem of Krull on altitudes of ideals in a :x oetherian ring (( 9 .:3), below). In order to prove it, we need the if part of the following theorem on rings with minimum condition: (9.1) THEOREM: A ring R satisfies the minimum condition for ideals if and only if (a) R is Noetherian and (b) altitude R = 0 (namely, every prime ideal is maximal). (THEOREM OFAxIZUKI) Proof: Assume first that R satisfies the conditions (a) and (b). It follows that any maximal ideal is a minimal prime divisor of the zero ideal, hence we see by (8.7) that there are only a finite number of maximal ideals, say ~I , ••• , ~n, and that the intersection m of the Pi is the radical of O. Hence (:3.15) shows that m is nilpotent. Let l' be such r that m = O. Then R = R/ m", which implies by virtue of (1.4) that R is the direct sum of R/~: . Each ~;-I/~{ for j = 1, '" , l' is a finite module over the field R/~i , hence it has a composition series. Therefore R/~; , and hence also R, have composition series. Thus R satisfies the minimum condition. Conversely, assume that R satisfies the minimum condition. Let ~ be an arbitrary prime ideal of R. R/'p satisfies the minimum condition because R does. If R/p has a non-unit x ~ 0, then {xn(R/~)1 has no minimal member because R/p is an integral domain. Thus R/~ must be a field, which proves that ~ is maximal. Thus altitude R = O. We see also that R has only a finite number of prime ideals; for if lh, '" , ~n, ~n+l, .. , were different maximal ideals, then \\'e should have a descending chain ~I ::::J (PI n ~2) ::::J .•• ~ (~1 ~n) ::::J (~I ~n+1) ::::J ••.. Let the maximal ideals be ~I, ••. , ~n , and let m be the intersection of them. Among the powers of m, there is a minimal member; let it be n = m T • Assume for a moment that n ~ O. We have n 2 = n ~ O. Let b be a minimal ideal among those which are contained in n and whose product with n is different from 0 and set p = 0: bn. Since bn ~ 0, we have ~ ~ R. cd E ~,c tf ~ imply cdbn = 0 and con ~ 0, hence cO = b by the minimality of 0 and therefore don = 0, which implies that d E 'po Thus ~ is a prime ideal and therefore n ~ 'p, which implies that on = on2 ~ fmp = 0, which is a contradiction. Thus n = 0, i.e., m = O. Therefore (1.4) shows that R is the direct sum of R/~~ , each of which satisfies the minimum condition. Hence each ~{-I/~~ satisfies the minimum condition as an R/~i module, hence over the field R/~i. Therefore
n .. , n
n ... n
T
26 \.1~-I/\.1~ has a compo~ition ~E'riE's, and therefore R/\.1: , and R, too, have composition serie:". Henc·e R satisfies the maximum condition, too. We prO\~e ne:;;:t the following lemma of Krull: (9.2) LEt Cl bE a !lon-unit of a Noetherian integral domain R such that a ~ 0. If p is a minimal prime divisor of aR, then height \.1 = l. Proof: Considering Rp , we may assume that \.1 is the unique maximal ideal of R. Let q be a prime ideal of R such that q C \.1. Set ai = q(i: + aR. Since RlaR satisfies the minimum condition by (9.1), we see that there is an n such that ai = an for any i ::::: n. Then we have q,n) C q(i) + aR. By the minimality of \.1, a is not in q. Therefore q(n):aR = q(n). Hence (4.3) implies that q(n) = q(i). Thus i q(i) = q(n). On the other hand, (7.8) implies that i q(i) = 0, hence we have q(n) = 0, and q = 0. Thus height p = 1. Now we come to an important theorem of Krull:
n
n
(9.:3) THEOREM: If an ideal a of a Noetherian ring R is generated by r elements, then, for any minimal prime divisor p of a, height P is not greater than r, i.e., altitude a ::::; r. (ALTITUDE THEOREM OF KRULL) Proof: Let P = Po :::J \.1I:::J .. , :::J ps be a chain of prime ideals Pi . I t is sufficient to show that s ::::; r. If there are prime ideals between P and PI, then adding a maximal member of prime ideals between P and \.11 , we may assume that there is no such prime ideal. Considering Rp instead of R, we may assume that p is the unique maximal ideal of R. Let aI, ... , aT be a basis for a; we may assume that al ~ \.11 ifor, a Q; PI)' Then there is no prime ideal except \.1 which contains DI aIR, which shows that \.11 aIR is primary to p. Therefore there i;; a natural number t such that a; E PI aIR (for all i). We write 0: = alb i Ci with bi E Rand Ci E PI- Set a' = ciR. Let p' be a
+
+
+
+
E;
minimal prime divisor of a' contained in Pl. Since the radical of c' + aIR contains the ai, a' + aiR is primary to p, hence p' + aIR ~:" primary to p, which means that, in the ring RIp', pip' is a minimal prime divisor of a principal ideal, which shows that height pip' = 1 by (9.2). Since p' C Pi, we have p' = \.11' Since a' is generated by . - 1 elements, we have height p' ::::; r - 1, hence s ::::; r. Thus the ,. heorem is proved. [1..1) COROLLARY: The altitude of an ideal of a Noetherian ring is ~\.5
THEOREM: If a is an ideal of a Noetherian ring R and if
CH.-\..PTER I
27
height a = r, then there are elements ai, ... , ar of a such that I::~ aiR is of height s for any s ::; r. Proof: We construct ai inductively. Assume that there are elements ai, ... , a -1 of a such that height (I::i aiR) = t for any t ::; s - 1. Let ~l, • • . , ~n be all of the prime divisors of I::f- l aiR (= 0 if s = 1) such that heights of them are s - 1. If s - 1 < r, then a is not contained in any of the ~i , whence there is an element a. of a which is not contained in any of the ~i by (2.7). Then height I::~ aiR is at least s, whence it is s by (9.3). As a consequence of (9.5), we see that: (9.6) If (R, m) is a local ring of altitude r, then there are r elements ai, ... , ar of m which generate a primary ideal belonging to m but there is no primary ideal belonging to m which is generated by r - 1 elements. The set of such elements Oi as above is called a system of parameters of R. A system of parameters Xl, . . • , Xr of a local ring R is called a regular system of parameters if it generates the maximal ideal of R. A local ring which has regular system of parameters is called a regular local ring. The following are consequences of (9.6). (9.7) Let (R, m) be a local ring. For a given element X of m, there is a system of parameters of R containing X if and only if altitude R/xR = altitude R - 1; each of the follOWing conditions is sufficient: (a) altitude R/xR < altitude R, (b) there is no prime ideal of altitude o which contains x, (c) there is no prime ideal of depth equal to altitude R which contains x. Proof: Let Xl , ••• , Xs be elements of m. Then their residue classes modulo xR generate a primary ideal belonging to m/xR if and only if x, Xl , ••• , Xs generate a primary ideal belonging to m. From this fact, the assertion follows immediately. The same idea proves: (9.8 ) With the same (R, m) as above, if Xl , ... , Xs are elements of m such that height L xiR = s, then 8
altitude
R/I:: xiR
=
altitude R - s.
(9.9) If (R, m) is a local ring, then length R1l11 m/m2 ;:::: altitude R; the equality holds if and only if R is regular. The proof is straightforward by virtue of (5.1). (9.lO) If R is a Noetherian ring and if Xl, . . • , Xn are indeter-
28
GE"ERAL COMMUTATIVE RINGS
minates, then altitude R[XI , ... , xnl = n + altitude R, and altitude R(Xl, ... ,x n ) = altitude R. Proof; It is sufficient to consider the case where n = 1. 'Ve see that altitude R[xll 2: altitude R + 1 by (6.15). Let )TI' be a maximal ideal of R[xd and set m = m' n R. It is sufficient to show that height m' :s: height m + 1. In order to prove it, we may assume that R = Rm. R[xll/mR[:td = (R/m) [xll, which is a principal ideal ring, whence there is an element f of m' such that m' is generated by m and f. Let Yl , . . . , Yr be a system of parameters of R. Then we see that the Y i and f generate a primary ideal to m', whence height m' :s: height m + 1, and the first assertion is proved. Considering the case where 111' = 111R[xl + xR[x], we see that height 111 = height mR[x], whieh proves the second assertion. vVe make a remark, whieh is obvious from the definition of regularity. (9.11) Let R be a local ring. If there are r elements aI, ... , a r of R such that height, LaiR = r and such that R/ L aiR is regular, then R is regular. We note that (9.10) is not true in general if we do not aRSlimc that R is K oetherian. (ef. Seidenberg [1]) We note that though (9.4) implies that the altitude of a semi-local ring is finite, it is not true in general that altitndcR of Noetherian rings are finite; see Example 1 in the Appendix. Let 11'£ be a module over a ring R. Then altitude R/(O:M) iR called the operator altitude of M and is denoted by op. alt if/I. M is called a faithful R-module if O:M = O. Note that the structure of M as an R-module is substantially the same as the structure of 111 as an R/(O:M)-module.
10. Integral dependence Let R be a subring of a ring R'. An element a of R' is said to be integral over R if there are elements Cl , ••. , Cn of R such that an + n 1 Cla + '" + Cn = 0, i.e., a is a root of a monic polynomial over R. We say that R' is integral over R if every clement of R' is integral over R. (10.1) An element a E R' is integral over R if and only if there is a subring R" of R' such that R" is a finite R-module and such that
a E R". Proof: If a is integral over R, then R[al is a finite R-module. Conversely, assume the existence of R" = L~ RUi. aUi = L j aijUj
29
CHAPTER I
with aij E R, hence, denoting by d the determinant I Oija - aij I (Oij being Kronecker 0), we have dUi = 0, hence dR" = and d = 0. Since d is expressed as a monic polynomial in a with coefficients in R, we see that a is integral over R.
°
(10.2) COROLLARY: The set R" of elements of R' which are integral over R forms a ring. Proof: If a, b E R", then R[a, b] is finite over R, hence every element of R[a, b] is integral over R. The ring R" given above (10.2) is called the integral closure of R in R'. If R" = R, we say that R is integrally closed in R'. A ring is said to be integrally closed if it is integrally closed in its total quotient ring. (10.3) COROLLARY. If a E R' is integral over a subring R* and if R* is integral over R, then a is integral over R. Consequently the integral closure R" of R in R' is integrally closed in R'. Proof; Assume that a E R' is integral over R*:a n + clan-I + ... + Cn = with Ci E R*. Then R[cI , ... , Cn , a] is finite over R, whence a is integral over R. When R is a subring of a ring R', R' is an R-module. R:R' is called the conductor of R in R'. (10.4) A ssume that R is a Noetherian ring and that b is an element of a ring containing R'. (1) The conductor of R in R[b] contains elements a and ideals a of R such that ab n E R for any natural number n; ab C a. (2) If the conductor of R in R' contains an element a which is not a zero d~visor in R', then R' is a finite R-module, is integral over R and is contained in the total quotient ring of R. Proof: (1) is obvious, while (2) follows immediately from the fact that R is Koetherian and that R' eRa-I. (10.5) Let a be a non-zero-divisor of a ring R. If a- I is integral over R, then a-I E R. Consequently, if a field is integral over an integral domain I, then I is a field. Proof: There are elements CI , . . . , Cn of R such that (a-I) n n I CI(a-l)n-1 + .,. + Cn = 0, hence a-I = - (CI + C2a + ... + cna - ),
°
+
which is in R. On the other hand, the definition of integral dependence implies immediately the following lemma: (10.6) If a ring R' is integral over its subring R, then (1) for any homomorphism cf> defined on R', cf>(R') is integral over cf>(R) and (2)
30
GENERAL COMMUTATIVE RINGS
for any mUltiplicatively closed subset S of R which does not contain zero, R~ is integral over Rs . Now we have the following important result. THEOREM: Assume that a ring R' is integral over its subring be a prime ideal of R and let S be the complement of P in R. Then a prime ideal p' of R' lies over p if and only if p' is maximal with respect to S. Proof: Assume at first that a prime ideal p' of R' lies over p. Then p' does not meet S, therefore p'R~ is different from R~. Hence pRs C p'R~ Rs c Rs ,which proves that p'R~ Rs = pRs . Hence R~/p'R~ is integral over the field Rs/pR s , which shows that R~/p'Rs is a field, hence p'Rs is maximal, which means that p' is maximal with respect to S. Conversely, assume that p' is maximal with respect to S. Then p'R~ is a maximal ideal and the field R~/p'R.g is integral over RS/(plR~ Rs). (10.5) implies that this last integral domain is a field, which means that p'R~ Rs = pR s , which implies that p' R = p.
(10.7)
R. Let
~
n
n
n
n
n
(10.8) COROLLARY: With the same R, R ' , and p as above, there are prime ideals of R' which lie over p; there is no inclusion relation between any of these prime ideals of R'. (LYING-OVER THEOREM) (10.9) COROLLARY: With the same R, R' as above, if Po c '" c Pc is an ascending chain of prime ideals in R and if a prime ideal p~ of R' lying over Po is given, then there is an ascending chain of prime ideals lchich begins with p~ such thal p~ R = Pi for each i. If, in this case, there is no prime ideal between Pi and Pi+! , then there is no prime ideal between p; and Pi+l . (GOING-UP THEOREM). Proof: The existence is easy by induction on n, while the last assertion follows from (10.8) (the lying-over theorem).
n
p;
(10.10) COROLLARY: If a ring R' is integral over a ring R, then altitude R' = altitude R. This follows from (10.9). _~nother immediate consequence of (10.8) i,,:
'10.11) i.~
COROLLARY:
If a ring R' is integral over a ring R and if a
an ideal of R different from R, then aR' j1 1.
Let R be an integral domain. A ring R' containing R is called an ,"'d'gral extension of R if R' is an integral domain and if R' is integral ,~,l,-er R. If the field of quotients of R' is finite over that of R, we say :kt R' is almost finite over R.
31
CHAPTER I
An integrally closed integral domain is called a normal ring. The integral closure of an integral domain R in its field of quotients is called the derived normal ring of R. When R is a normal ring, an integral extension R' of R is called a Galois extension of R if R' is the integral closure of R in a Galois extension (not necessarily separable) of the field of quotients of R, in the sense of Galois theory: the Galois group of the field extension is called the Galois group of the integral extension. ( 10 .12) THEOREM: Let R be a normal ring and let R' be a Galois extension of R. Then for any prime ideal p of R, the prime ideals of R' which lie over p are conjugate to each other; that is, if prime ideals p~ and p~ lie over p, then there exists an automorphism 0" of R' over R such that p~u = p~. Proof: We consider at first the case where R' is almost finite over
R. Assuming the contrary, let p~, ... , p~ be all of the prime ideals of R' which are conjugate to p~ . Since there is no inclusion relation among the p; by the lying-over theorem «(10.8)), there is an element a of p~ which is not in any of the p~, ... , p~. Then no conjugate of a is in any of the p~, ... , p~ , whence the norm a* of a with respect to R is not in p = p~ R. This is a contradiction because a E p~ implies that a* E p~ R = p. Thus we have proved this case. Let us turn to the general case ..Consider the set F of pairs (S, 0") of Galois extensions S of R contained in R' and an automorphism 0" of S over R such that (p~ Sr = p~ s, for all possible Sand 0". Then we introduce an order in F as follows: (S, 0") ::; (S', 0"') if and only if S C S' and the restriction of 0"' to S coincides with 0". With this order, we see that F is an inductive set, hence there is a maximal member, say (S*, 0"*) of F. It is sufficient to show that S* = R'. Let S" be a Galois extension of R such that S* C S" C R' and such that S" is almost finite over S*. There is an automorphism of S" over R such that its restriction to S* is 0"*; we denote such an automorphism by the same letter 0"*. Then (p~ S"r* and (p~ S") lie S*), hence there is an automorphism over the same prime ideal (p~ 0"" of S" over S* such that (p~ S" = p~ S". By the maximality of S*, we have S" = S*, which implies that S* = R', and the proof is complete.
n
n
n
n
n
n
n r*u"
n
n
(10.13) THEOREM: Let R be a normal ring and let R' be a ring such that (1) R C R', (2) R' is integral over R and (3) no non-zero ele-
32
GENERAL COMMUTATIVE RINGS
ment of R is a zero divisor in R'. If a prime ideal ~~ of R' and a descending chain PI :J P2 :J .. , :J Pr of prime ideals in R are given such that PI = P; n R, then there is a descending chain of prime ideals P; in R' which begins with P; and such that p~ R = Pi; here if pr = 0 alld zj a prime ideal P' of R' which lies over 0 and such that p' C P; is pre-assigned, then there is such a chain with p~ = p'. (GOING-DOW~
n
THEOREM)
Proof: Since
P;
contains zero,
p;
contains a minimal prime divisor
q' of zero by (2.5). Since non-zero elements of R are not zero divisors
in R', q' lies over zero by (7.1). Thus it is sufficient to prove the last assertion. R'/p' is an integral extension of R; if we see the existence of such a chain in R'/p', then, considering the inverse image of the chain, we prove the assertion. Thus we may assume that R' is an integral extension of R. Let R" be a Galois extension of R containing R' and let p~ be a prime ideal of R" which lies over P; . Let q~ C ... C a; be a chain of prime ideals in R" such that q~ R = Pi by the going-up theorem (( 10.9)). Since p~ and q~ lie over the same prime ideal PI of R, there is an automorphism 0" of R" over R such that q~" = p~ . Then, obviously the chain of (q~U R:) is the required one.
n
n
dO.14) THEOREM: With the same Rand R' as in (10.13), let a' an ideal of R' and set a = a' R. Then height a = height a'. Proof : We first consider the case where a' is a prime ideal. For a c-hain a' = p~ :J p; :J ... :J p; of prime ideals in R', we have a chain II = lJ~ R :J p; R :J '" :J p; R by the lying-over theorem 10.8)), whence height a' ::; height a; similarly the converse int"'iuality follows from (10.13), and height a' = height a in this ":i"e. ~ ow we consider the general case. Let p' be a prime divisor of J' ",ueh that height a' = height p'. Since P' R contains a, we have height a ::; height p' n R = height P' = height a'. Conversely, let P ["E' a prime divisor of a such that height a = height p. Let p' be a prillle ideal of R' such that a' C p' and such that p' n R = p; the exi",tenee follows from the lying-over theorem applied to R'I a' and R II with the prime ideal pia. Then we have height a' ::; height p' = height b' n R = height a. Thus~eight a' = height a.
n
i)r,
n
n
n
n
10.15 I THEOREM: Let R be a normal ring and let f(x) be a monic .:'<;:/i'Jmial in an indeterminate x with coefficients in ./1. Set R' = R::: f z R[xl and let d be the discriminant of f(x). If R* {s the integral ~::'!'~ •.:. (~i R' in its total quotient ring Q, then dR* is contained in R'.
33
CHAPTER I
Proof: If d = 0, the assertion is obvious, and we assume that d ;;t' O. Let a be the residue class of x in R'. Let K be the field of quotients of R and let L be a field containing all roots of f( x). We note first that any element a ;;t' 0 of R is not a zero divisor in R', whence K is contained in Q and Q = K[a]. For each root ai of f( x ), there exists an R-homomorphism 1>i from R* into L such that 1>i(a) = ai. Kow let j b be an arbitrary element of R*. Then b = uja (Ui E K, n = degree of f( x ) ). Then 1>,( b) = U ja~ and we regard that these equalities as linear equations in the unknown Uj . The determinant D of the coefficients is IIi<j (ai - aj), hence D2 = d. Since 1>i(b) and ai are integral over R, the dUi are integral over R. Since dUi are in K and since R is a normal ring, we see that dUi are in R, hence db is in R', whence dR* is contained in R'.
L
2:;-1
(10.16) COROLL,\.RY: If R' is an almost finite separable integral extension of a Noetherian normal ring R, then R' is a finite R-module. Proof: Since R' is separable, there is an element a of R' such that R' and R[a] have same field of quotients. Let f be the irreducible monic: polynomial over R which has a as a root and let d be the discriminant of J(x). Because of the separability, d ;;t' O. (10.15) implies that dR' C R[a], whenee R' is a submodule of the finite Rmodnle L:;-I (aijd)R (n = deg f(x)). Since R is Noetherian, it follows that R' is a finite R-modnle. ( 10 .17) A ssume that f (x) is a monic polynomial over an integral domain R. Let the roots of f( x) be Ui (i = 1, ... , r) and let l' (x) be the derivative of f(x). Then the discriminant d of f(x) coincides with (_1)(1+2+'" +r-1) IId'(ui). Proof: f(x) = (x - Ul) .,. (x - u r ). Therefore, setting gi(X) = f(x)j(x - Ui), we have1'(x) = Lgi(X), hencef'(ui) = 9i(Ui) for each i. Therefore 1I1'(ui) = IIgi(Ui) = (_I)(I+2+···+r-1) IIi<j (Ui - Uj)2 = (_1)1+2+'" +r-Id.
By virtue of the above result, the following is a generalization of (10.15) in the case where R' is an integral domain. (10.18) ThEOREM: Let R be a normal ring and let f(x) be a monic polynomial over R. Let a be a root of f(x) (in an integral extension of R). Let l' (x) be the derivative of f (x) and let R* be the derived normal ring of R[a]. Thenf'(a)R* C R[a]. Proof: Let the roots of f(x) be a = 1&1 , U2 , . . . ,Ur and set gi(X) = f(:r) / (x - Ui). Then l' (a) = gl (a). Therefore it is sufficient to prove
34
GENERAL COMMUTATIVE RINGS
the assertion in the case where f(x) is irreducible. If a is inseparable, thenf'(a) = 0 and the assertion is obvious. Therefore we assume that a is separable over R. Let R" be an almost finite separable Galois extension of R containing a and with Galois group G. Let H be the subgroup of G which corresponds to R* and let 0"1 = 1, 0"2, ••• , O"r be elements of G such that a~i = Ui . Then it holds that G = L HO"i . Furthermore gi(X) = f(x)/(x - a Ui ) = g~i(X). Let Ci E R[a] be such that gl(x) = cr-d- I co. Then, for an arbitrary element b of R*, we have bf'(a) = bgl(a) = L bUigi(a) = Li,j b~ic?aj. Since G = L HO"i, Li bUicf' is invariant under any 0" E G, hence is in R. Thus we have bf'(a) E R[a], and the proof is complete.
+ .,. +
EXERCISES: Let R' be a ring and let R be a subring of R'. Let a be an ideal of R. An clement b E R' is said to be integral over a if there are elements a, , '" , an such that ai E ai for each i and such that bn a1b n - 1 an = O. 1. Prove that b E R' is integral over a if and only if there are elements 1/, , .•. , Un of R' such that bUi E L: aUi for any i and such that annihilators of L:R'Ui annihilate some powers of b. 2. Let b be another ideal of R. Prove that if a E R' is integral over a and if b c:: R' is integral over fl, then ab is integral over ab. 3. Define the integral closure a* of a in R' to be the set of all elements of R' which are integral over a. Prove that a* is an ideal of the integral closure R* of R in R'. Prove also that a* is integrally closed in R', namely, that the integral closure of a* in R' is a*. 4. Prove that when R is aN oetherian ring, an ideal b contained in a has the oame integral closure in R (or E') if and only if there is a natural number r ouch that bar = ar+l. 5. Assume that a ring R' is integral over its subring R and that x is an indeterminate. Prove that R' (x) is integral over R (x). (Hint: Let R" be the integral clo~ure of R(x) in R'(x). Use the fact that every maximal ideal of R" lies over il maximal ideal of R (x).)
+
+ .,. +
11. Valuation rings IVe say that a ring R is a valuation ring if R is an integral domain :,uch that for any two elements a, b of R, it holds that either aR C bR or bR CaR. When K is the field of quotients of a valuation ring R, we say that R is a valuation ring of K. ( 11.1) THEOREM: A ring R with a field of quotients K is a valuation ring of K if and only if one of the following conditions is satisfied: I I I Ifa E K,tlvneitheraora-1isinR. ,:2) Every finitely generated ideal of R is principal and R is quasi-
',xol.
CHAPTER I
Proof: (1) is nothing but a restatement of the definition. Assume that R is a valuation ring and let m be the set of non-units of R. Let ai, ... , aT be arbitrary elements of m. Then there is an element as (s ~ r) such that aj E a,R for any j. Hence the ideal generated by these elements is the principal ideal asR which is contained in m, which implies (2). Conversely, if (2) is true, then for any two elements b, c of R, the ideal bR + cR is principal, hence by (5.3), either bR + cR = bR or bR cR = cR, which shows that R is a valuation ring. Thus the theorem is proved. (11.2) Let R be a valuation ring. (1) If a is an ideal of R and if b E R is not in a, then a c bR. If \J is a prime ideal of R, then (2) R/p is a valuation ring and (3) p is set-theoretically equal to pRp . Proof: If a E a, then aR c bR (because bR Q; aR), which implies (1). (2) is therefore immediate from the definition. Let q be any element of pR p • Then there is an element a of R which is not in p and such that p = aq is in p. Since a ~ p, pR c aR by (1), and we have q E R. Since aq E p, we have q E p, which proves (3). (] 1.3) If R is a valuation ring of a field K, then an arbitrary ring R' such that R c R' c K is a valuation ring, and there is a prime ideal p of R such that R' = R~. Proof: The condition (1) in (11.1) is satisfied by R, hence by R', too. Therefore R' is a valuation ring, which implies R' is quasi-local by (11.1). Let p' be the maximal ideal of R' and set p = p' n R. Then R~ ~ R'. Since any element of R' which is not in R is the inverse of a non-unit of R, by (11.1), we see that R' c R~ . Thus R' = R~ . (11.4) Let R be a valuation ring of a field K, let p be the maximal ideal of R and let R* be a valuation ring of the field R/p. Then the set R' = {x I x E R, x modulo p E R*} is a valuation ring of K. R' p = R and R'/p = R* This R' is called the composite of R with R*. Proof: Let a be an arbitrary element of K. If a ~ R, then a-I E p and a-I E R'. Assume that a E R. Since R* is a valuation ring, either a modulo p E R* or a-I modulo p E R*, which shows that either a E R' or a-I E R'. Thus R' is a valuation ring. That R' /p = R* is obvious by the construction. That R'p = R follows from (11.3). (1l.5) Let R be a valuation ring of a field K and let k be a subfield of K. Then R k is a valuation ring of k. The proof is straightforward by (11.1). (1l.6) A valuation ring R is a normal ring.
+
n
36
GENERAL COMMUTATIVE RINGS
Proof: Let a be an element of the derived normal ring of R. If a ~ R, then a-l E R, hence we see that a-I has its inverse in R by (10.5), which is a contradiction to the assumption that a ~ R. Thus a E R, and R is normal. A mapping v from a field K onto a set G* is called an additive valuation, or merely a valuation, if the following conditions are satisfied: (1) G* is the union of a linearly ordered addithTe group G and an element CQ which is defined to be greater than any element of G, (2) v(a) = CQ if and only if a = 0, (:3) v(ab) = v(a) + v(b) (hence, v is a homomorphism from the multiplicative group of non-zero elements of K onto G), (4) v(a + b) ;::: min (v(a), v(b». G is called the value group of v. Two valuations v and v' of a field K are called equiva:lent to each other if there is an isomorphism (J" from the value group G onto G' such that (J"(v(a» = v'(a) for any a (>'" 0) E K. (11.7) Ifvisavaluation,thenv(l) = O,v(a- I ) = -v(a),v(-a) = v(a), and when v(a) < v(b) it follows that v(a b) = v(a). Proof: vel) = v(l·l) = vel) vel), whence v(l) = 0. Hence = v(1) = v(a) v(a- I ), and v(a- I ) = -v(a). = vel) = 2v(-1),andv(-1) = O,hencev(-a) = v(a). v(a) < v(b) implies v(a b) ;::: v(a) = v(a b - b) ;::: min (v(a b), v(b», which b) = v(a). shows that v(a If v is an additive valuation of a field K, then by the definition,
°
+
+
+
+
+
+
°
+
it is obvious that the set R = {x I x E K, vex) ;::: O} forms a ring. The formula v(a- I ) = -v(a) implies that either a or a-I is in R, hence R is a valuation ring. v( a) ;::: v (b) if and only if aR C bR. Thus it is easy to see that the value group is isomorphic to the multiplicative group {aR I a >'" O} with opposite order. This R is called the valuation ring of v. Conversely, assume that R is a valuation ring of a field K. Then the mapping v* such that v*(a) = aR is a homomorphism from the multiplicative group of non-zero elements a of K onto that of the aR. For two elements a, b E K, let c, a', b' be elements of R such that a = a'/c, b = b'/c. Then a'R + b'R = max (a'R, b'R), which shows that aR C bR or aR => bR and that aR + bR = max (aR, bR). Thus we see that {aRI is linearly ordered and that a + b E max (aR, bR). Therefore we see that v* can be modified to be a valuation v (by the opposite order and changing multiplication to addition), and the valuation ring of v is R. v is unique up to equivalence. Thus we have (1l.8) There is a one-one correspondence between valuation rings R
37
CHAPTER I
of a given field K and equivalence classes of additive valuations v of K in such a way that R corresponds to the class of v if and only if R is the valuation ring of v. We prove next the following existence theorem of valuation rings: (11.9) Let R be a subring of a field K and let 0 C \h C \.12 C .. , C \ls be an ascending chain of prime ideals in R. Then there exists a valuation ring V of K· such that V has prime ideals nl, . .. , n. which lie over \l1, . . . , P8 respectively. Proof : We prove the assertion by induction on s. When s = 1: Considering Rp with \l = \ll, we may assume that \ll is the unique maximal ideal of R. Let F be the set of sub rings S of K such that \lIS ;;z:: S and such that R c S. F is an inductive set, and therefore there is a maximal member S* of F. Then S* is quasi-local, for, otherwise, if m is a maximal ideal of S* containing \lIS*, then S: E F, which contradicts to the maximality of S*. Let x be an element of K which is not in S*. x ~ S* implies that \lIS*[X] contains 1, namely, PIX there are elements po, ... ,pn of \lIS* such that 1 Po Pnxn = O. Since S* is quasi-local, 1 + Po is a unit in S*, which means that X-I is integral over S*. Hence lhS*[X-I] does not contain 1 by (10.11). The maximality of S* implies that X - I E S*. Thus S* is a valuation ring, and is obviously the required one, because we assumed that \ll is the unique maximal ideal of R. Now, we assume that such a V, say V' with prime ideals nl , ... , nS-1 , exists for the chain \l1 C \l2 C ... C \l'-I. Considering V~'_l , we may assume that n,_1 is maximal. R* = R/\ls-I is a subring of the field V' /nH and has a prime ideal \ls/ps-I . Hence, by the case where s = 1, there is a valuation ring V* of V' /ns-I such that V* has a prime ideal which lies over \l,/\l8-1 . Then, as is easily seen, the composite of V' with V* is the required valuation ring. (11.10) Let RI , . . , , Rn be valuation rings of the same field K. For a given element a of K, there exists a natural number s such that both a/(l a as-I) and 1/(1 a as-I) are in the intersection D of the rings Ri . Proof: Let \li be the maximal ideal of Ri . We consider an arbitrarily given i (::;; n). If a ~ R i , then by a valuation Vi with the valuation ring R i , 0 = Vi(l) > vi(a) ;:::: vi(a 1 ) = vi(1 a as-I) for any s ;:::: 2, whence is;:::: 2, these elements are in the R, . Consider the case where a E Ri . Since 1 a as-I = (1 a')/(l - a), when a modulo \li is a primitive (ei)th root of 1 with
+ +
+ + ... +
+ ... +
+ + ... + S
-
+ + ... +
+ + .,. +
38
GENERAL COMMUTATIVE RINGS
ei ~ 2, then for s which are prime to ei , these two elements are in the Hi . When a - 1 E ~i, for s which are not multiple of the characteristic of R/~i , these two elements are in the Ri . In the other case, these two elements are in the Ri for any s. By the finiteness of the munber n of the Ri , there is surely an s which satisfies the above requirement for any i, and the assertion is proved.
(11.11) ThEOREM: Let RI , . . . , Rn be valuation rings of the same field K and assume that Ri R j for any (i ~ j). Let ~i be the maximal ideal of Ri , let D be the intersection of the Ri and set qi = ~i D. Then we have (1) an ideal m of D is maximal if and only if m = qi for some i and (2) Ri = D iq • (THEOREM OF INDEPEXDEXCE OF VALUATIOXS) Proof: We prove (2) at first. Let a be an arbitrary element of Ri . Let s be such that both 1/(1 a as-I) and a/(l a as-!) are in D, by virtue of (11.10). Since a E R i , we have 1 a as-I E R i , whence it is a unit in R i . Therefore 1/(1 a as-I) Et qi and therefore a is in D qi • Thus Ri ~ D qi • Since the converse inclusion is obvious, we have (2). (2) implies that q, qj for any (i ~ j). Therefore there is an element ei of nj,ei qj which is not in qi for each i. Let a be an ideal of D which is not contained in any of the qi . Then a contains an element ai which is not in qi , hence a contains aiei. aiei is not in any qi . It follows that aiei is a unit in any Ri , and therefore it is a unit in D, too. Therefore a = D. This implies that any maximal ideal m of D is one of the qi . Since qi Q; qj for any (i ~ j), we see the converse, and the proof is complete. 'iVe add here some remarks on normal rings.
%
n
+ + ... +
.. . +
+ + ...
+ + .. , +
+ + ... +
%
L
L
L
(11.12) THEOREM: An integral domain R is a normal ring if and ollly if R is an intersection of valuation rings of the field of quotients K of R. Proof: If R is the intersection of valuation rings VA , then, since each VA is normal, R is normal. Conversely, assume that R is normal and let b be an element of K which is not in R. Set R' = R[l/b]. If there is a relation (l/b)(L ai(l/b)i) = 1 (ai E R), then we 5ee that b is integral over R, which is not the case. Therefore l/b is not a unit in R', whence there is a valuation ring V of K such that 1b is a non-unit in V and such that R c R' c V by (11.9). Thus we 5ee that b is not in V, whence b is not in the intersection of valuation
CHAPTER I
39
rings of K which contain R. Therefore we see that R is the intersection of all valuation rings V of K such that R C V. (11.13) Assume that R is a normal ring and that b is an element of the field of quotients K of R. Then the kernel n of the R-homomorphism cf>, from R[x] (x being a transcendental element over R) onto R[b] such that cf>(x) = b, is generated by polynomials ex - d such that b = die (c, d E R). i Proof: Assume H:at L:~ a;x E n (ai E R) and let V be an arbii trary valuation ring of K such that R C V. Since L aib = 0, we n 1 have anbnV = (an_1b - + ... + ao) V C bn-1V, which implies that anbV C V, i.e., anb E V. Since V is arbitrary, we have anb E R by (11.12), whence (1;nX - dEn with d = a"b. Therefore we complete the proof by induction on n. EXERCISES: 1.
Willi the same notation as in (11.11), prove that if
0.1 , '"
... , an are ideals of R1 , . " , Rn respectively such that there is no inclusion
relations among the minimal prime divisors of them, then D / n (ai) is the direct sum of the Ri/ai . 2. Prove that a quasi-local integral domain with the field of quotients K is a valuation ring of K if and only if any ring R' such that R c R' k: K contains the inverse of some non-unit of R. 3. Assume that a ring R' dominates a valuation ring R of a field K. Prove that R' n K = R. 4. Let R be a valuation ring of a field K and let K' be an algebraic extension of K. Let R' be the integral closure of R in K'. Prove that valuation rings of K' which dominate R are just rings of quotients of R' with respect to maximal ideals, in the following way: (1) When K' is a finite Galois extension of K; let V be a valuation ring of K' dominating R and let D be the intersection of all the conjugates of V. Prove that D = R'. Then apply (11.11). (2) When K' is finite over K; apply the result in (1) to the smallest Galois extension of K containing K'. (3) Prove the general case, applying (2) to finite subextensions. 5. Let R be a valuation ring of a field K and let K' be an over-field of K. Prove that there is a valuation ring R' of K' such that R < R' and such that the residue class field of R' is algebraic over that of R, in the following way: Let {u~l be a transcendance base of K' over K and set K" = K({u~l). Prove the existence of such a valuation ring of K". Then apply 4 above.
12. Noetherian normal rings Let us begin with the following remark: (12.1) A local ring (R, m) which is not a field is a valuation ring if and only if height m ;:::: 1 and m is principal. In this case, height m = 1. Proof: The only if part is obvious. We prove the if part. height
40
GENERAL COMMUTATIVE RINGS
m = 1 by the altitude theorem of Krull. Let q be a minimal prime divisor of zero and let p be a basis for m. Since p ~ q, we have q:p = q. On the other hand, q cpR, hence q = 0 by (4.3). Thus R is an integral domain. Let a ~ 0 be an ideal of R, and let n be such that a C pnR, a Q; pn+lR. Then a = (a:pn)pn. If a:pn ~ R, then a:pn C pR and a C pn+lR which is not the case. Thus a = pnR. Therefore we see that every non-zero ideal of R is a power of pR, hence R is a ,~aluation ring. Next we have the following lemma: (12.2) Let a, b, c, d be elements of a ring R such that ad = bc. If a is not a zero divisor, then aR: cR C bR: dR. Consequently if both a and b are non-zero divisors, then we have aR:cR = bR:dR. Proof: x E aR: cR implies cx = ay with y E R, hence ayb = bcx = adx. Therefore by = dx, and x E bR: dR. (12.3) Let ~ be a prime ideal of a Noetherian ring R. Assume that Rp is not a valuation ring. Then for any non-zero divisor a E p and for any element b of aR: p, bI a is integral over R and the conductor of R in R[bla] contains ~. Proof: Let p be any arbitrary element of ~. Then bp = ar with an r E R. If r ~ p, then p C aR:bR C pR:rR C ~ (by virtue of (12.2)), which implies that ~ = pR:rR and we see that pRp is generated by p, hence Rp is a valuation ring by (12.1), which is a contradiction. Thus (bla)p C ~, and the assertion is proved by (10.4). ~~s an immediate consequence of (12.3), we have (12.4)
THEOREM:
e12.5)
THEOREM:
A normal local ring of altitude 1 is a valuation ring. Let p be a prime ideal of a Noetherian ring Rand assume that p contains an element a which is not a zero divisor. Then ~ is a prime diviso: of aR if and only if either height ~ = 1 and Rp is a 1'01 nation ring or there exist a, b E R such that bI a is integral over R and such that the conductor of R in R[bla] coincides with p. Proof: Assume at first that ~ is a prime divisor of aR and that Rp i" not a valuation ring. Let b be an element of R such that ~ = aR: bR Iby (8.8)). Then b E aR:p, hence, by (12.3), bla is integral over R and the conductor c of R in R[bla] contains p. If c E c, then cbla E R, i.e., cb EaR, hence c E aR: b = p. Thus the conductor c coincides ,yith p. Conversely assume at first that height p = 1. Then obviously :J is a minimal prime divisor of aR. Assume next that ~ is the conductor of R in R[bla]. Then pRp is the conductor of Rp in Rp[bla].
CHAPTER I
41
Since (bjd)'p C R, we have bp CaR, and 'p C aR:bR, and therefore 'pRp CaRp: bRp ~ R p , which implies that 'pRp = aRp: bRp ; hence 'pR p is a maximal prime divisor of aRp , and the assertion is proved. (12.6) THEOREM: If R is a Noetherian ring and if a prime ideal 'p is a prime divisor of aR with a non-zero-divisor a of R, then for any non-.zero-divisor b contained in 'p, 'p is a prime divisor of bR. Proof: By (8.8), there is an element c of R such that aR: cR = 'po Then, since b E 'p, there is an element d E R such that bc = ad. It follows from (12.2) that aR:cR = bR:dR, hence 'p = bR:dR, which implies that 'p is a prime divisor of bR by virtue of (8.8). (12.7) COROLLARY: Let R be a Noetherian ring and let a, b be elements of R such that a is not a zero divisor, b/a ~ R and such that b/a is integral over R. Then either there is a minimal prime divisor p of aR such that Rp is not a normal ring or there exists an imbedded prime divisor of aR. Proof: Assume that the prime divisors 'pi of aR are all minimal and that Rp are normal for any 'p = 'pi. Let qi be the primary component of aR belonging to 'pi . Since b/a is integral over R, it is integral over R Pi whieh is a normal ring, hence b/a E R Pi , and b E aRpi R = qi. Thus bEn qi = aR, and b/a E R. Thus we have proved the assertioll. (12.8) If R is a normal ring, then any ring of quotients of R is also a normal ring. Proof: If a is integral over R s , then there is an element s E S such that as is integral over R, which proves the assertion.
n
(12.9) THEOREM: A Noetherian integral domain R is a normal ring if and only if the following two conditions are satisfied: (1) If 'p is a prime ideal of height 1 in R, then Rp is a normal ring and (2) if 'p is a prime divisor of a principal ideal ~ 0, then height p = l. Proof: Assume that R is normal. Then (1) holds good by (12.8), while the validity of (2) follows from (12.5). The converse is an immediate eonsequence of (12.7). A Koetherian normal ring of altitude 1 is called a Dedekind domain. (12.4) and (1.4) imply that: (12.10) Any ideal a ~ of a Dedekind domain R is the product of maximal ideals of R, and such an expression is uniquely determined
°
bya. EXERCISES:
1. Let \l be a prime ideal of aN oetherian ring R and assume that
42
GENERAL COMMUTATIVE RINGS
height p;::: 1. Prove that Rp is a valuation ring if and only if there is no primary ideal q such that p(2) C q C p. 2. Prove that a Noetherian ring R is integrally closed if and only if R is the direct sum of finite number of Noetherian rings Ri such that either Ri is a normal ring or every maximal ideal of Ri is a prime divisor of zero (namely, every non-unit of Ri is a zerO divisor). 3. Let R be a Noetherian normal ring. Prove that every principal ideal aR of R is an intersection of symbolic powers of prime divisors of aR. 4. Let R be a Noetherian integral domain. Assume that every ideal of R is a product of prime ideals. Prove that R is either a Dedekind domain or a field. 5. Let R be a Dedekind domain with field of quotients K. Prove that the set of non-zero finite R-submodules of K forms a multiplicative group by the natural multiplication. 6. Assume that M is a finite module over a Noetherian ring R, that a E R is not a zero divisor with respect to M and that p is an associated prime ideal of aM (in M). Prove that if b E p is not a zero divisor with respect to M, then p is an associated prime ideal of bM.
13. Unique factorization rings ~~n element a of a ring R is called irreducible (in R) if a is not a product of any two non-units of R. We say that an integral domain R is a unique factorization ring if (1) every element a ~ 0 of R is the product of a finite number of irreducible elements and (2) if a = al . . . am = bl . . . bn with irreducible elements ai and b j , then Tn = n and there is a permutation 7r of the i such that a"(i)R = b,R. _~n element a ~ 0 of an integral domain R is called a prime element ii aR is a prime ideal of R. It is obvious that a prime element is an irreducible element, but not conversely. :\"ote that the condition (1) above is satisfied by any Noetherian integral domain.
(1:3.1) THEOREM: A Noetherian integral domain R is a unique factorization ring if and only if every prime ideal ~ of height 1 in R is principal. Proof: Assume that R is a unique factorization ring. For any prime ideal P of height 1, let a be an irreducible element of R contained in ~. Let b be an element of aR: p which is not in aR. Assume for a moment that aR ~ ~. Then let c E p such that c ~ aR. Then be EaR, and Thpreiore there is an element d E R such that be = ad. But a is not an irreducible factor of b or c, which is a contradiction. Thus ~ = aR and -hE' '1I!1y if part is proved. Assume conversely that every prime ideal 01 height 1 is principal and let a1 ••• am = bl • . . bn be factoriza-
CHAPTER I
43
tions of an element c as products of irreducible elements ai and bj • We prove the uniqueness by induction on n. \Vhen n = 1, c is irreducible and the assertion is obvious. By assumption, irreducible clements wh;ch are non-units are prime elements. Since al ... am E blR, which is prime, some ai E blR; we may assume that a l E blR. Since aiR is prime, we have aIR = blR, and therefore there is a unit u such that a2 ... am = (u~) ba • . • bn , whence, by induction, we have the proof of the uniqueness. (13.2) If R is a unique factorization ring, then for any multiplicatively closed set S which does not contain 0, Rs is a unique factorization ring. Proof; A prime element of R is either a unit or a prime element of Rs . Furthermore, ideals of Rs are generated by ideals of R, hence the assertion follows from the definition. (13.3) A unique factorization ring R is a normal ring. Proof: Assume that alb (a, b E R) is integral over R: (alb)n + cI(alb)n-1 + ... + Cn = (Ci E R). We may assume that a and b have no common prime factor. Assume that p is a prime factor of b. Then, since an + Clan-Ib + ... + cnb n = 0, we have an E pR and a E pR, which is a contradiction, and alb E R.
°
(1:3.4) COROLLARY; The polynomial ring in a finite n'tlmber of algebraically independent elements over a field is a normal ring. EXERCISES: 1 . Let R be aN oetherian normal ring and let S be a multiplicatively closed subset of R which does not contain O. Assume that (1) there is a natural number e such that q(') is principal, for any prime ideal q of height 1 in R such that q meets S and that (2) there is a natural number f such that p'(f) is principal for any prime ideal p' of height 1 in Rs . Prove that for any prime ideal p of height 1 in R, p(,j) is principal. 2. Assume that p, , ... , pr are prime elements of an integral domain R. Prove that an ideal a of R has prime divisors only among the piR if and only if a is a principal ideal generated by the product of some powers of Pi . 3. Prove that an integral domain R is a unique factorization ring if and only if (1) R satisfies the maximum condition for principal ideals and (2) every prime ideal of R different from zero contains a principal prime ideal different from zero. . 4. Give an example of a normal ring R, which is not a unique factorization ring, in which every prime ideal of height 1 is principal.
14. A normalization theorem When I is a subring of an integral domain R and when K and L are the fields of quotients of I and R respectively, then we know
GENERAL COMMUTATIVE RINGS
the transcendence degree of Lover K, which is defined to be t,he transcendence degree of R over I. (14.1) Let K be a field and let Xl , ... , Xn be algebraically independent elements over K. If YI is an element of K[x] = K[XI, ... , X"] Ichich is not in K, then there are elements Y2 , ... , Yn of K[x] such that (1) Yi = Xi x7 i for some natural numbers mi (i = 2, ... , n) and (2) K[x] is integral over K,[YI , ... , Yn] (and therefore YI , ... , Yn are algebraz'cally independent over K). Furthermore, (3) if a natural number s > 1 is given, all the mi can be chosen to be powers of s. Proof: We write YI as ai111i, where ai E K, ai ~ 0 and the kI; are monomials in the Xi . "\111 e define weights ml = 1, m2 , ... , mn of XI, X2 , ••• , Xn such that one Mi , say MI , has greater weight than
+
1:
the others; let t be a power of s such that t is greater than the degree i d of YI and set mi = t - l for each i. Then, since weight x~ < weight Xi+l for any i = 1, 2, ... , n - 1, we see that the mi satisfies the requirement on the weights (considering a lexicographical order of the monomials Mi)' Set Yi = Xi x7 i for i = 2, .. , , n. Then YI w l ran be written ±alxr + flx + fw where w = weight MI and thefi are polynomials in 1)2, ... ,Yn with coefficients in K. Therefore XI is integral over K[YI , ... , Yn], whence the Xi , which are in K[.Ih , ... , y" , xd, arc integral over K[YI , ... , Yn]. Thus the Yi are the required elements.
+ + ...
(14.2) ThEOREM: Let K be a field and let XI , . . . , Xn be algebraically independent elements over K. If a is an ideal of height r in the polynomial ring K[x] = K[xI, ... , Xn}, then there are elements YI , ... , Yn of K[.r] such that (1) K[x] is integral over K[y] = K[YI, ... , Yn], (2) L1 K[y] is generated by YI , ... , Yr and (3) Yr+j = Xr+j fj with polynomials fj in XI , . . . , Xr with coefficients in the prime integral domain 7r of K for each j = 1, 2, ... , n - r. If K is of characteristic p ~ 0, then the fj can be chos6n such that fj E 7r [xl, ... , x;'J. (1\ OR-
n
+
~L\..LIZATlON THEOREM FOR POLYNOMIAL RINGS)
Proof: We prove the assertion by induction on r. If r = 0, the asis obvious. Assume that I' 2:: 1 and let a' be an ideal of K[x] :ou('h that height a' = r - 1 and such that a' c a. Then, by induction, chere are elements YI, ... , Yr-I, Y~ , ... , y~ of K[x] which satisfy the o::onditions in our assertion with a' instead of a. Since height a = r, we han' by (10.14) that height (a K[YI, ... , Yr-I , y;,J) = ~. (In the other hand, we have Yi E a' k a(1 ~ i ~ r - 1) by con~-:n(·tion. Therefore there is an element Yr of a n K[y;. , ... , y~] ~ertion
n
y;., ... ,
45
CHAPTER I
'which is not zero. Then, applying (14.1) to Yr and K[y~ , . " ,Y~], we see the existence of Yr+l, ... , Yn of K[y~, ... , y~] such that (a) Yr+j = y;.+j + y~mi (if the characteristic p ~ 0, mj can be powers of p) and such that (b) K[y~, ... , y~] is integral over K[Yr, ... ,Yn]. The first condition (a) implies the validity of (3) (and the statement in parentheses implies the validity of the last statement in the theorem), while the condition (b) implies the integral dependence of K[x] over K[y]. Since YI , ... , v,. are in a, (t K[y] contains them. Since Lr yiK[y] is a prime ideal of height r and since height a n K[y] = r, the inclusion implies the equality. Thus the theorem is proved.
n
(14.3) COROLLARY: Let I be an integral domain and let XI, '" , Xn be algebraically independent elements over I. Let K be the field of quotients of I. If a is an ideal of I[x] = I[xI, .,. , Xn] such that a n I = 0, then there are elements YI, ... , Yn of I[x] and an element a( ~O) of I such that (1) I[a-I][x] is integral over I[a-I][y], (2) aI[a-I][x] I[a-I][y] is generated by YI, ... ,Yr with r = height aK[x] and (3) Yr+j = xr+j + fj with polynomials Ii in XI, ... , x,. with coefficients in the prime integral domain for each i = 1, '" , n - r. Proof: Set a' = aK[x], and let YI, ... , Yn be as in (14.2) applied to a' and K[x]. Then (3) is valid for them. Since YI, .,. , Yr are in a', there is an element ai ~ of I such that aiY E a for each i. Since K is a field, aIYI, ... , ary,. are as good as YI, ... , Yr . Therefore we may assume that YI, '" , V,. are in a. Since Xi is integral over K[y], there is an element CiC ~o) of I such that CiXi is integral over I[y] for each i. Let a be the product of all the Ci . Then we see easily that this a and the above Yi are the required elements.
n
°
(14.4) THEOREM: Assume that a ring R is generated by elements JI , . . , , bn over an integral domain I. Assume furthermore that no elenent a( ~o) of I is a zerO divisor in R. Then there are elements ZI , .. , • . • • , Z t of 1r[b l , ... , bn] (where 1r is the prime integral domain of 1) which are algebraically independent over I and an element a( ~o) of I such that R[a- I] is integral over I[a-\ ZI, ... , Zt]. (NORMALIZATION THEOREM FOR FINITELY GENERATED RINGS)
Proof: Let XI, ... , Xn be indeterminates. Then there is a uniquely determined homomorphism c/> from I[x] = I[xI, '" , Xn] onto I[b] such that c/>(Xi) = bi for each i. Let a be the kernel of C/>, and let YI, '" , Yn , and a be elements as in (14.3) applied to a and I[x]. Set Zi = c/>(Yr+i). Since Yi E a for i ~ r, I[a-I][b] is integral over
46
GENERAL COMMUTATIVE RINGS
n
I[a -I][zl. Since a I[Yr+l, ... , Ynl = 0, the Zi are algebraically independent over I. Since Yr+j E 1r[XI' ... , xn], we have Zi E 1r[b l , '" , bn ], and the assertion is proved. (14.5) THEOREM: Let R be an integral domain which is generated by a finite number of elements bl , ' " , bn over a field K. If po, '" , Pt are prime ideals such that Po = 0, PI is maximal, Po C PI C .. , C Pt and such that there is no prime ideal q such that Pi-I C q C Pi for any i, then t must be the transcendence degree of Rover K. Proof : We prove the assertion by induction on t. There are algebraically independent elements ZI, ... , Zu over K (Zi E R) such that R is integral over K[z], by (14.4). If t = 0, then K[z], is a field by (10.5) and the assertion is true. Assume that t > 0. Then apwhence u = plying (14.1) to PI K[z] and K[z], we may assume that ZI E PI. Then PI K[z] = zIK[z] by (10.14). Then, applying the induction assumption to R/rl1 , which is integral over K[zl/zIK[z], and to the prime ideals pi/PI, we see that t - 1 = u - 1, whence t = u, which proves the assertion.
°
n
n
(14.6) COROLLARY: If an integral domain R is finitely generated over a field K, then for any prime ideal P of R, height p depth p is equal to the transcendence degree of Rover K and depth P is equal to the t,.anscendence degree of R/p over K.
+
(14.7) THEOREM: If an integral domain R is generated by n elements a field K, and if m is a maximal ideal of R, then m is generated by n elements and R/m is algebraic over K. Proof: That R/m is algebraic over K follows from (14.6). Let bl , ' " , bn be such that R = K[b l , • . • , br.l. Let Ci be (b i modulo m) for each i and let f;(xi) be the irreducible monic polynomial over K[ci , ... , ci-d which has Ci as a root. Let fi be the monic polynomial in b; with coefficients in K[b l , ' " , bi-l] which is obtained from f: replacing CI, '" , Ci-I , Xi with bl , . . ' , bi- I , bi , respectively. Then we see that R/ ( L fiR) = K[CI' '" , cn ], and therefore m = L fiR, which proves the assertion. Ol'e!'
(14.8)
COROLLARY:
Let
Xl, ... ,
Xn be algebraically independent ele-
mJ?llts over an integral domain I. Let p be a prime ideal of I[x] I~Il'
=
'" , xnl. If IcpnI) is a regular local ring, then I[x]P is a regular local
,:,illg. Proof: We may assume that I = IcpnI) . Let h,
...
,fs be a regular
47
CHAPTER I
n
system of parameters of I. We set q = l-1 I, K = I/q, and Zi = Xi modulo qI[xl. Then, obviously the Zi are algebraically independent over K and I[xl/qI[xl = K[zl. We set ~' = ~/qI[xl, and apply (14.2) to ~' and K[zl; let Yl , ... , Yn be as in (14.2) applied to our case. Then K[zl = K[ZI' ... , Zr , YrH, ... , Ynl. Let L be the field of quotients of K[Yr+l, ... , Ynl. Then ~'L[ZI' ... , zrl is a maximal ideal of L[ZI, ... , zrl, and therefore it is generated by r elements, whence ~'K[z]P, is generated by r elements, which implies that pI[x]P is generated by r + s elements. Since height p' = r, we see that height ~ ~ r + s by (6.15), whence I[xlp is a regular local ring. (14.9) THEOREM: If a ring R is finitely generated over a field K, then the Jacobson radical of R is the radical of R. (HILBERT ZEROPOINTS THEOREM)
Proof: We first assume that R is an integral domain. Let f be an element of R which is not zero and consider R[l/fl. (14.6) implies that maximal ideals of R[l/fllie over maximal ideals of R, which implies that there are maximal ideals which do not contain f. Since f is arbitrary, it follows that the Jacobson radical of R is zero. Now we consider the general case. The above result shows that if ~ is a prime ideal of R, then the intersection of maximal ideals of R which contain ~ coincides with ~, and therefore we get the result. (14.10) Let Xl, ... , Xn be algebraically independent elements over an integral domain I. Then there is a maximal ideal m of I[xl such that m I = 0 if and only if there is an element a( ~O) of I such that I[ a-11 is the field of q11/Jtients of I. Proof: If there is such an element a, then a maximal ideal m of I[x], such that aXl - 1 E m, lies over zero of I. Assume conversely that there is a maximal ideal m of I[xl which lies over zero of I. Then, applying (14.4) to I[xl/m, which is a field, we see that the t in (14.4) must be zero in this case, and I[a -11 is a field by (10.5). Thus the proof is complete.
n
EXERCISE: With the same K, Xi and 11 as in (14.2), aswme that K contains infinitely many elements. Prove that there are elements Yl , ... , Yn of K[xj satisfying (1) and (2) in (14.2) and such that the Yr+i (j = 1,2, ... , n - r) are linear combinations of the Xi with coefficients in K.
CHAPTER II
Completions 15. Formal power series ring Let R be a ring and let Xl, '" , Xr be indeterminates. Let Fd be Lilli module of homogeneous forms of degree d in the Xi with coeffiI',inll('s in R for every d = 0, 1, ... ,n, .. , . The set F of infinite sums L: ai with ai E Fi forms a ring by the obvious operations ( L ai) + (Lb i) = (ai + bi ), (Lai)(Lb i ) = Ln (Li+j~naibj). This /1' is called the formal power series ring or merely the power series ring ill 1,ho Xi with coefficients R, and is denoted by R[[XI, ... , xrll or I'illlply by R[[xll. Elements of R[[x]] are called (formal) power series ill Lhexiwith coefficients in R.For an element at of R[[x]](ai E F i ), Llw Ilumber n, such that an ~ 0 and such that ai = 0 for i < n, is (lnllcd the leading degree of the element, and the an is called the leadin(J form of the element. The leading form of 0 is defined to be O. ao il' (:alled the constant term of the element. Note that R[x] is a sub ring of R[[x]] by the obvious identification "hut a finite sum L~ ai is identified with infinite sum L~ ai with !/'i = 0 for i > r. The above notation will be fixed throughout this section.
L
L
(15.1) THEOREM: There is a one-one correspondence between all ma.Timal ideals m of R and all maximal ideals m* of R[[xll in such a way that m* corresponds to m if and only if m* is generated by m and the Xi . Proof : We see obviously that, when m is a maximal ideal of R, (,he ideal mR[[xll + L xiR[[xll is a maximal ideal of R[[x]]. Let m* be a maximal ideal of R[[xll and let 111 be tho set of constant terms of elements of 111*. Then m is obviously an ideal of R. If we know that lit ~ R, then 111* is contained in mR + xiR[[x]], and we seo that m* = mR[[xll + xiR[[xll and that 111 is maximal. Therefore it is I'ufficient to show that 111 ~ R. Assume the contrary. Then there is ILIl eloment ai of 111* with ao = 1. Set b = - (L~ ai). Then we
L
L
L
[49]
J
~'I;'
()'
L (.,
10 ",IiI'I'I' ('11.1'11 ('" iH til' ~::' h' 1'111' Hii iii . II, 1It'III'(' 1'01' allY . eJ' ,., '~I/,{' I ('\",,(1 I (,,11 'i/l, 2:. n. ,-'IIH'n (~III)( ~II I) ( ))( L.,.II I) I , wn K(~(: Lhal, /:1) O~ 1+ (~.: (LI:I'IIIK 01' dl:gn:<: 1/,»), whil:lt ll?-eans that the nth degree pml, of (~L ai) ( C,.) it:: I or )\1:1'0 uI:I:ol'd(:11.11 ('OIlHidf'I'
lilu:d Lo Ill'
1.\It' II
wllil·1i iCI 1'111111.1
I. Ii tI(·J.!:I·('I· pal'l.
(L/1,i)(LZ
or
L
>
ing as n is zero or not. Thus we see that the element L a,. it:: unit, which contradicts to the assumption that [: ai E m*, and the proof is completed.
(15.2) COROLLARY: An element f E R[[x]] is a unit if and only if the constant term of f is a unit in R. (15.3) THEOREM: If R is Noetherian, then R[[x]] is also Noetherian· Proof: Let a be an arbitrary ideal of R[[x]]. It is sufficient to show that a has a finite basis. Let a* be the set of leading forms of elements of a. Then a* generates an ideal of the polynomial ring R[x], which has a finite basis (over R[x]) , say ii, ... ,ii, consisting of elements of a*. Let fi be an element of a which has f.i as its leading form and let a' be the ideal of R[[xll generated by the f1, '" ,ft. Let g be an arbitrary element of a. By the choice of a', there is an element [!ihi,o of a' which has the same leading form as g, and the same is applied to g - L fih i .O and so on. Thus we see that there is a sequonce of elements Lfih.,.,n(h.i,n E R[[x]]; n = 0, 1,2, ... ) such that (1) Lfihi,n has leading degree greater than that of Lfihi,n-l and (2) Lfihi,n and g - Lj
... ,xrll =
R[[xJll ... [[xrl].
16. An ideal-adic topology Let a be an ideal of a ring R and let M be an R-module. Let F be the family of anM. We introduce a topology on M, which may not be a To-topology, taking F to be a hase of neighborhoods of zero of R, which means that open sets of M me unions of an arbitrary number
1.1
1'11.\ 1"1'11111, II
I'dI' 01' II\(' 1'01'111 /J I 0"111 (I, I 11/). 'I 'Ii i,.., l.0pI,loJ.!:'v iH I~nllt'd 1.111' II IIdi,' lOjlulofJII III' /11. 'I'hnllll.ddil.ioll iH (',oltl,illlloIiK (i.".,.J'(.f, II) .f I· '!f iH a eOllLilillOllH 1'l\\I(',l.ioll 1'1'0111 M X M iliLo M) alld L1\1~ 1l1ldl.iplil~aLioll 01' elenwlIl.K o\' Nil' alKo mllLilillollS (i.e., f(;c, V) = :cy if,; a (:ontinuoliK 01'
fuuetion from R X Minto M, where the topology of R is assumed to be the a-adic topology of R). We retain the above meanings of R, M, and a throughout this section. (16.1) The a-adic topology of M is To if and only if anM = O. If the a-adic topology of M is To , then the following distance function r makes M a metric space: rex, x) = 0; r(x, y) = Tn if and only if x - y E anM and x - y ~ an+1M. The proof is straightforward and we omit it. (16.2) A submodule N of the R-module M is an open set of M in the a-adic topology, if and only if N: lJ;f contains some power (({ a. In that case, N is also a closed set. Proof: If N is an open set, then 0 E N implies anM eN for some n. Conversely, if anM ~ N, then since N is a submodule, b + anM eN for any bEN, and N is the union of the open sets b + lln]j,i, whi(:h proves that N is open. If N i.s open, then the complement M - N of N is the union of :c + N with x E M - N, and each x + N is open, hence jJJI - N is open. Thus N is closed.
n
(16.:3) TUEOHEM: The closure N* of a submodule N of Min M with the a-adic topology coincides with (N + anM). Proof: Since each N + anM is an open set, it is a closed set by (16.2). Hence N* eN + anM for any n, and N* c n(N + anM). Conversely, let x be an arbitrary element of n(N + anM). Then x = bn an with bn E N, an E anM for each n, which shows that, for any n, x + anM meets N. Since the x + anM form a basi.s for the neighborhoods of x, it follows that x is in the closure N* of N. Thus the assertion is proved.
nn
+
(16.4) COROLLARY: For a submodule N of M, the a-adic topology of MIN is To if and only if N is a closed subset in the a-adic topology ofM. Proof: The a-adic topology of MIN is To if and only if n(anM + N)IN = 0
by (16.1), or equivalently, n(anM sertion.
+ N)
=
N, which proves the as-
l'I'~II'ldl:'I'II'NI\
WI! 1\111", Lllltl, IVIII'II N iH n Hlillillodlll(' oi' III, 1111' IHtdi(! I,opology oj' N IlIaY hi! iliITI'I'I'IIi, 1'1'0111 Lhn Lopology or N :1.1' lI. HliI,Hjl:W.I' or III. III'IICI~ Lhn \'ollowill!l: thl!()I'cllI iH I'pally IloLnwol'Lhy:
(lG.5) THEOHEM: If M is a Noetherian module, then for any sul!module N of M, the a-adic topology of N coincides with the topology of N as a subspace of M with the a-adic topology. Proof: By virtue of (3.17), we may assume that R is Noetherian. It is obvious that anN C anM N. The lemma of Artin-Rees (3.7) implies that anM N = an-rearM N) C an-rN, thus we prove the assertion. On the other hand, it should be remarked that: (16.6) Let R* be the ring R EEl M in the principle of idealization. Then the a-adic topology of M coincides with the topology of M as a subspace of R* with (a EEl M) -adic topology (which is equivalent to aR* -adic topology) . The proof is straightforward and we omit it. Now we consider semi-local rings. On a semi-local ring which may not hc Noetherian, we define the Jaeobson-radic:al-adin topology to Iw UII! natuml topology. When lYI is a finite module over a semi-local I'illg N with Jacobson radical m, then the m-adic topology of M iR tll'iilll!d (,0 be the natural topology of M. ThiH definition iH jllHtified by ( IIUi).
n
n
n
THEOREM: Assume that M is a finite module over a semiring R with Jacobson radical nt. Then an arbitrary submodule N (~r M is a closed subspace of M and N = (N + mnM). i'mol': Since MIN is Noetherian, it is a To-space by (4.2), and we pl'Ovn the assertion by (16.3), (16.4) and (16.,5).
(10.7)
{lIl'ILl
nn
( I G.8) THEOREM: Assume that a semi-local ring R' is a finite module mwr a semi-local ring R. Then the topology of R' as a semi-local ring eoincides with that of R' as a finite R-module. If, furthermore, R' conLaing R (whence R' dominates R), then R is a closed subspace of R'. Proof: Let m and m' be the Jacobson radicals of Rand R' respecLivciy. R'/mR' is a finite R-modulc, hence is a finite Rim-module. Tb(~rcforc, there exists a natural number n such that m,n C mR', whieh shows that m,n, C m'R' em", and the firi:3t assertion is proved. The last assertion follows from the first one by virtue of (16.7). BXIJJHClSES:
1. We say that (R, a) is a Zariski ring if R is Noetherian ring
(1111\1"1'1'111, II
1IrIIIOl'illi,,,tI wH11 LI,,, 1\ lI.tlio I,lIpol0Il:Y (I h,.illll: 11,11 itil'lI.l or 10 Hilldl t.l1I1.I, (lVOI'Y id"n.l or U ill II. ... loH"d ,wI., 1','oVIl 1."".1. 11,11 n II.di,\ No"i,""rilt.ll rillll: H iH n /';ll.I'iHki rillll: if nllcl oilly if e'Ve\I''y ,,1,,111(,111, It or "~HII,\" (J, 1 ( a i8 a uuit in U, :1. I'rov" 1."11,1. il' (N, el) iH IL /';miHki I'ill!!: ILllel il' U i8 an iucal of R contained ill n, I,"nll (N, II) iH ILtHO II /';nriHki ring. :'1. (:"lInl'lLli7.(l (10.7) to the case of a Zariski ring R. 1. Adll.pl. (HUl) 1.0 j.he case of a Zariski ring and prove it. Ii. (,,,1, (U, a) be 11 /';ariski ring and let x, , ... , Xr be indeterminates. Prove 11111(, (NII~;II, allUxll + L xiR[[x]]) is a Zariski ring. II. (,uI, M be a module over a ring R with an ideal a. Assume that the a-adic I,,,polo!!:y of M is To. Set b = (a + (O:M))/(O:M). Prove that (1) the a-adic 1,lIpolo!!:y of M coincides with the b-adic topology of M and (2) the b-adic I,opolo!!:y of R/(O:M) is To. 7. Let M be a module over a ring R with an ideal a. Let N be a submodule "I' WI which is closed in the a-adic topology of M. Prove that N:M is closed in Lito (\-adic topology of R.
""II,I.
17. Completions This section is concerned with completions of semi-local rings and wit.h completions of finite modules over semi-local rings. But we begill with a case a bit more general so that the readers can see some g(~lIeral facts in the case of semi-local rings which may not be NoethnI'ian. Let R be a ring and let M be an R-module. Assume that M is a lIIotric space with a distance function rex, y) such that (1) rex, y) = '/'(:c - y, 0) for any x, y E M, (2) for any positive real number E, Lho set U, of x such that rex, 0) < E forms an R-submodule of M. We note the following fact which follows immediately from the above condition. (17.1) If rCa, b) > rCc, d), then rea, b) = rea c, b d). With this metric, we can discuss completions as usual. Namely: A ~equence (c n ) of elements cn(n = 1,2, ... ) of]}f is called a Cauchy ,WXjuence if for any given positive number E, there is a natural number N such that, for any m and n which are greater than N, r(c m ,cn ) < E. An element a i~ said to bo a limit of a Cauchy sequence {Cit} if
+
+
if such an a exists for a given (en), then a i~ unique and is denoted by lim Cn • M is said to be complete if every Cauchy sequence in M has a limit in M. An R-module M*, having the following properties, is naIled a completion of M: (1) M* is a metric space with a distance
(II 1M 1'1.1.\'1'(( INK
fllllnl.iolll'+ 1'1111,11 Lim!' I"~(fl', 1/+) 'f'+(,I'~' I/'~, 0) 1'01' "'lIy ,I"f, 1/>1< ( M>I< (:.l) 11/* iH I'.olllplnl.!', (:l) III iN II, tlnllHn HI I hHPH("l'. of 111*, HIHI Cl) if ,r* nlld HI'(, lillliLH of (:nlll'.hy H('
,,*
(:a\l(,hy sequence {Cn} is called a regular sequence if r(cj ,cn ) < !n for allY n and for any j > n. Then as a general fact in metric spaces, we have (17.2) For any Cauchy sequence {Cn} in M, there is a regular sequence {dn} such that lim r(c n , d n ) = O. N ow we prove the existence of completions:
(17.3) THEOREM: M has a completion M* which is unique 11,p to isomorphisms (with regards to topologies). The set of elements x* of M* such that r*(x*, 0) < f fonns an R-submodule of M* and is the closure of U, in M*, M* /U; is naturally isomorphic to M /U, . If M is a ring and if the U, are ideals, then M* is naturally a ring whose multiplication is such that (lim c:) (lim d:) = lim(c!d:) for anJ! Cauchy sequences {c!} and {d!} in M*, and the are ideals of M*. Proof: Let C and C* be the set of Cauchy sequences and regular sequences in M respectively. In C, we introduce the following operations: {en} {c~l = {Cn c~}, a{cn} = {acn}(a E R), and when M is a ring (as above), {cnl{ c~} = {CnC~}, Thus C becomes an R-module; when M is a ring, C becomes a ring. Let n be the set of Cauchy sequences which have zero as limits. Then n is a submodule of C; when M is a ring, n is an ideal. We shall show that C/n is a completion of M, identifying an element a of M with the class of Cauchy sequences which have a as the limit. We define a function r*(x*, y*) (x*, y* E C In) to be limn~oor(:rn, y,,) with representatives {x,,}, {Yn} of x*, y*. By virtue of (17.1), we see that r*(x*, y*) = r(xn, Yn) for suffieiently large n except for the case where x* = y*. With this r*, C /n becomes a metric space as is easily seen. Furthermore, if :c* is a class in C/n containing {c n }, then x* = lim Cn in this topology. Thus M is dense in C/n. Let {x:} be a Cauehy seqnence in C/n. Let {x n ;} be regular sequences in M such that = lim Xn; • Then by the regularity of the {Xni}, the sequence {Xnn} becomes a Cauchy sequence, hence has a limit x* in C In. Then we see that x* is a limit of the sequence {x!}. Thus C/n is a completion of M. The uniqueness of M* is rather obvious, because elements of M* must be in one-one correspondence
U:
U:
+
+
x:
I II I ;11"1'11111, II
wiLli
!,II'III(1l1irl
1>1'1'01111' I''''H.\'
oj'
"'lid
('/11.
Till' oLlII'" "'H,'iI'i·iioll.'I 1.111' d!~LaiIN.
ill 0111'
LI 1l'1I !'! 'II I
Ilav!' III1IY
\1'1' ollli!.
'l'III':OIII'IM: ,,1 88 If, II 1.1: thal (1":8 11.1/, '£deaf OJ' H and that the metric III /8 /1£1 1('11 b!f thl' n-ruJ-£c topology (by ( I G.1)). If a has a finite basis, Ihl'lI Ihl' tnl!11fnu.IJ I~r tlw (;nml!felion M* is the a-adic topology. l'l'oo\': II. i:-; HufficiPllt, by virtue of (17.:3), to show that the closure N~ oj' n"M ill M* is a"M*. Let x* be an arbitrary element of N!. 'I'bnll :1:* = lim :r;i with (Xi) such that Xl E a"M and such that Xi n .1"; II ( (1'11 i'iJYI = a ( aiM). Let ai, ... , at be a basis for an. Then ,I'j .- :1:j'H = Lj ajb ji with b ji E aiM. For each j, the series Li bji iH I:()II vergent (i.e., { L~~l bj;} is a Cauchy sequence) and express an l'lnnwnt of M*. Then we see that x* = L ajb;, which is in a"M*. 'l'huH N! C anM*. Since the converse inclusion is obvious, the proof
(,,'.,1)
I~r
b;
iH (\omplete. (17.5) THEOREM: Assume that the a-adic topology oj' R is To and that a has a finite basis ai, ... , aT . Let Xl, .. . , Xr be indeterminates and consider the formal power series ring R[[x]]. Then the completion U* of R is (isomorphic to) the ring R[[xll/n*, where 11* is the closure oj' tlu! ideal n = L (x,; - ai)R[[x]] in R[[xll with the (n aR[[x]])-adic topology (= the (aR[[x]] LXi R[[x]])-adic topology). Proof: We consider the map cf> from R[[x]] into R* such that if J = Lfi(x) E R[[x]] (fieX) being homogeneous form of degree i) I.Illm cf>(f) = Lfi(a). Then we see that cf> is a homomorphism from UI[x]l onto R* and that the kernel n' of cf> contains x - a, hence n. f = L!i(X) is in 11' if and only if Lf;(a) = O. Let f,,(x) be the Imding form of f. Then Lf;(a) = 0 implies that fuCa) E a"H, and Lh ere is a homogeneous form hUH (x) of degree u 1 such that .fAa) = hUH(a). f - f,,(x) huH(x) has leading degree greater Lhan u and f == f - fu(x) hU+JCx) modulo 11. Thus, repeating the Hame, we see that if fEn', then fEn (L xiR[[x]]) " for any n. Conversely, if f E n( n L xiR[[x]]) "), then we see that L fie a) E an = O. Thus we have n' = nn (n + (L xiR[[x]])n) = nn (n + n"R[[x]]) = n*.
+
+
+
n"
+(
+
+
+
(17.6) COROLLARY: Assume that R is a semi-local ring with J acobNon radical m and assume that elements ai, ... , aT generate an ideal which has 111 as its radical. Then the completion R* of R is a semi-local ring and is (isomorphic to) the ring
1111~11'1.lli'I'III~n\
NII.I'I, .. , , .1',11/( ~
(.1',
where the Xi are indetc'I'm'inllJi:8. '/'/11' IO/lo{o(1!I ol /tl. 118 1/1.1' t:IIllIllll'lio/l. IJ' /?, coincides with that of /t* as a semi-fo('(d 1'/11(1. I'roof: Set a = L aiR. Then since tlw rail il'al or n iK Ill, Lhe n-adie Lopology is equivalent to the m-adic topology. TIII,rdo\'(, WI) eall apply (17.4) and (17 ..5). Since R[[x]] is a semi-local ring by (L5.4), every idnal of R[[x]] is closed, whence we have R* = R[[x]l/(L (Xi lI,i)R[[xlJ) by (17.5). The coincidence of topology follows from (17.4).
Another important fact concerning the completions of semi-local dngs is: (17.7) THEOREM: Let (R, ~1, ••• , ~r) be a semi-local ring. Then the completion R* of R is the direct sum of completions Ri of local rings Ri = Rpi. Proof: Let m be the Jacobson radical of R, i.e., m = i ~i • Then, for each natural number n, Rim" is the direct sum of R/~~ and there n are ei.n E R such that 1 - Li ei,n E m , ei,n E ~j if i ~ j, hence 1 - ei,n E ~~ . Then for each i, ei,n - ei,n+! E ~~ ll~ = mn and therefore the sequence {ei,,,l has a limit ei in R*. Since
n
n .,. n
.n,
we have Lei = 1. Since ei,nej,n E mn (i ~ we have eiej = 0 if i ~ j. Hence we have e~ = ei. Thus R* is the direct sum of ideals R*ei, which are rings with identities ei. We shall prove now that R*ei is (isomorphic to) the completion of Ri . Let {c n} be a Cauchy sequence in Ri such that Cn - Cn+l E ll~ Ri . Since R/~~ = Ri/~~ Ri for any n, there is a sequence {c~} of elements c~ of R such that (c n modulo ~~Ri) = (c~ modulo ~n for every n. Then the sequence ' } 'IS a C auc h y sequence In . R and l'1m Cnei,n I l'1m Cnei,n I 2 {cnei,n = = ei(lim C~ei,n)' Hence the limit of {c~ei,nl is in R*ei . It is easy to see that the map lim Cn --'> lim C~ei,n gives a one-one correspondence between the completion Ri and R*ei. Then we see easily that is isomorphic to R*ei . Now we go back to the completions of modules:
R.;
( 17.8) THEOREM: A ssume that R is a semi-local ring and that M is a finite R-module. Let R* be the completion of R. Then M ® R R* is the completion of M, whose topology as a finite R*-module coincides with its topology as the completion of M.
('II;\I"I"'iI(, II l'I'IIl,I': 1,1,1.1111,1' UII'.JHI·(tI,~iI)lll'lI,dil'lI.llIr N, '1'111'11 IIIN'" is UII!.l:I.(~lIh fl I'ntiil'allll' HI' I,y (17,(j). 1"IIl'LiI('I'IIIIlI'n N*/III"N* ~~ N/llt l{ Now, 11 (III (,"'! N*)/IIII/(M C9 U*) = (M /1II J111) ® (/l*/m"R*) = M/mnM. Hill(:I~ III" III = 0, WI) s(~() that M ® R* contains M (by the identifica!.illil 'In 'fn ® I for any m EM), and furthermore that mn(M ® Hilil
n
N*) n M = mnM. This shows that M is a subspace of,M ® R*. An 1I.1'i>iLra,I'y clement c* of M ® R* can be expressed as L mi ® wiLh mi E M and r; = limn n,n with ri,n E R. Then c* is the limit of I L miri,n} as is easily seen. Thus M is dense in M ® R*. Let {c!} be II. mgular sequence in M ® R*. Let Ul, . , . , Ut be a basis for M. Since (M ® R*)/mn(M ® R*) = M/mnM, there is a sequence {c n} in M Hlldl that c! - Cn E mn(M ® R*). cn+! - Cn is in mnM, hence is expnlHHed as L Uimin(min E mn). For each i, L min has limit r; in U*. Furthermore, we see that ~ Ui ® is the limit of the sequence I (:';}. Thus M ® R* is complete.
r;
r;
(17.9)
COROLLARY:
Let a be an ideal of a semi-local ring R. Let R*
III: the completion of R. Then the completion of a is aR* and aR* is iso-
n
'/lwrphic to a ® R*. Furthermore aR* R = a, and R* / aR* is the completion of R/a. Proof: The first assertion follows from (16.5), hence the second HHHertion follows from (17.8), Since a is a closed set by (16.7) and :-;ince aR* is its closure in R*, we see that aR* R = a. The completion of Ria is (Ria) ® R*, which is obviously R*laR*. Similarly, we have for modules:
n
(17.10) COROLLARY: Let N be a submodule of a finite module M IIvcr a semi-local ring R. Then the closure N* of N in the completion M* (~r M is the completion of N and we have N* M = N. Furthermore, M* I N* is the completion of MIN. If we identify M* with M ® R*, then N* is surely identified with N ® R* in M ® R* as is easily seen. That N* is the completion of N implies that the usual tensor product N ® R* is isomorphic to the Hubmodule N ® R* in M ® R*. Hence we have
n
(17.11) COROLLARY: If R is a semi-local ring, then ®n R* is exact. (17.12) Let (R, lh, ... , prj be a semi-local ring and let R* be the completions of R. Then we have altitude R* = altit.ude R. Proof: altitude R = max {altitude R~J. On the other hand, R* is Lhe dircet sum of completions of R~i . Therefore it is sufficient to prove the assertion in the case where R is a local ring with maximal
.'I'MI'I,I'I'I'I.INII l ill. '11,1 III ).11. Wn PI'O\'I' Ih .. IIHlll'l'Lillll II,\' illdlH'lioll Oil II.ll,il.lldn It '. l II' nll,il,ll
a
such that R* jxlR* has altitude less than altitude R*, whence altitude R*/X1R* = altitude R* - 1 by (9.7). Since R*/x 1R* is the eompletion of R/x!R, we see that altitude R*/x!R* = altitude R/xJR by our induction assumption. Thus we have altitude R* = altitude R*/XlR* + 1 = altitude R/XlR + 1 2:: altitude R, whence we have altitude R* = altitude R. :1:1,
(17.13) COROLLARY: Let R be a local ring and let R* be the completion of R. Then any system of parameters of R is a system of parameters of R*. EXERCISES: 1. Prove that the completion of a Zariski ring is a Zal'iski ring. 2. Confirm that (17.9), (17.10) and (17.11) can be generalized to the case of Zariski rings without any substantial change of proofs. 3. Let R be a ring with an ideal a and let M be an R-module. Assume that the Il-adic topologies of M and R are To , hence metric. Prove that the completion M* is naturally a module over the completion R* of R. Prove furthermore that if a hasa finite basis, then the topology of M* is the aR*-adic topology.
18. Exact tensor products We saw in Section 17 that if R* is the completion of a semi-local ring R, then ® R R* is exact. Therefore, we prove here some general properties of exact tensor products, which can be applied to the case of semi-local rings immediately. (IS.1) THEOREM: Let R be a ring and let R* be a ring which is an R-module, and such that ® R R* is exact. Let M be an R-module. Then we have the following, where Ni are sub modules of M and a is an ideal of R: (1) (N! N r ) ® R* = (N l ® R*) (Nr ® R*). (2) (N!:N 2) ® R* = ((Nl ® R*): (N2 ® R*)), provided that N2 has a finite basis. (3) (N!:a) ® R* = (N! ® R*) :aR*, provided that a has a finite basis. (4) If an element a of R is not a zero divisor with respect to Nl , then a is not a zero divisor with respect to N! ® R*.
n ... n
n ... n
('11.11"1'11;11 II
([,) II 1111'11
I'!I'IIII'IIIN
I, ., . ,
M
11/'1'
I ill AI c¢ N>l<
W'II
III , '"
, II"
Id'
/il/.I'lf.r/!I illr/I'/!I'Ilr/('I//
Ii/lnl'
H,
lill('(ll'll! inr/IIJllllu/(lnl II/WI' N*. 1"'1101': III 111'£1('" 1,11 provn ( I ), wn haVil oilly 1,0 pt'()v(~ the ease where I' ~. 1,"'0111 (N I 1- NJ/N, =~ N 2/(N l N 2 ), we have (N 2 ® R*)/ (N, n N,,) ® N* , ((NI + N 2 ) ® R*)/(N l ® R*) = (N2 ® R*)/ ((N I ® W) (N 2 ® R*)), which proves (1). Since N2 has a finite hHNiN, ill 0 nkr to prove (2), we may assume that N 2 = bR with an (l!nIlWIlL (, C N 2 , by virtue of (1) above and (1.2). The map cf> delillnd by cf>(:c modulo Nl:bR) = (bx modulo Nl bR) is an isomor"biellil from R/(Nl:bR) onto bR/(N l bR) by (1.5). Therefore h~*/(Nl:{)R)R*
/1" (x)
n
n
n
n
n
((N I ® R*)
n (b-®
R*))
(/1* is defined similarly ascf>. Hence we have (2). (3) is proved similarly /l,N (:2), using M instead of R in the above proof. That a is not a zero divisor with respect to NI implies [0:aR]N 1 = 0, hence by(3) applied Lo Nl = M we have [0:aR*]N1 ® R* = 0, which proves (4). As for (fi), Ui ® 1 in (L uiR) ® R* are linearly independent, he nee the n:mdness implies (5). (18.2) COROLLARY: Let M be a finite module over a semi-local ring N and let M * and R* be the completions of M and R respectively. Then 'lOr: have op. altitude M* = op. altitude M. Proof: O:M* = (O:M)R* by (2) in (18.1), and R*/(O:M*) is the eompletion of R/ (0 :M) by (17.9). Therefore we have the assertion hy (17.12).
(18.3) THEOREM: With the same Rand R* as in (18.1), assume furthermore that there is no ideal a of R such that a ~ Rand aR* = R*. Then R C R* and, for any ideal a of R, it holds that aR* R = a.
n
Proof: Let a and IJ be ideals of R. Assume that IJ has a finite basis. If IJR* C aR* then R* = aR*:IJR* = (a:IJ)R*, whence IJ Ca. Applying this to a = 0 and IJ = bR with b EO: R* (as an R-module), we have IJ = 0 and R C R*. Applying the same to IJ C aR* R, we have aR* R C a, whence aR* R = a.
n
n
n
(18.4) With the same Rand R* as in (18.1), assume furthermore that ((, C R* and that aR* R = a for any ideal a of R. Then (1) the total quotient ring K of R is naturally a subring of the total quotient ring [(* (If R*, and (2) for any ideal a of R, K aR* = a, hence in particular J( R* = R.
n
n
n
110
('( 11111'1,1,;'1'11 INII
1'1'001': (I) 1'011011':,1'1'11111 (I) ill
v ic;
a 111l11-iWI'O-divic;ol') illlplinN
R = va, and we have (2).
we hav(~
njh ( n,
(IK,I), (1Ii, I 1\ n oU+ 1.1111.1. 1/ I {,IIN+, II!'III'I' 1/
ThiN PI'OVI'N LiIIl,1.
1\
(II,
n n/{~
i,
I
billtl'
I
C
a,
n
n, Hlld
(lS.5) With the same R, R* and M as in (VU), a.wu'ffW .r1J,/'lI/'(~I'IIWI'(! the same assumptions as in (lS.4) above. Then the mal) ¢ 8'11t:h that ¢(m) = m ® 1 (m E M) givesanisomorphismfromM into M ® U*. Proof: For a fixed mE M, mr _mr ® 1 (r E R) gives an isomorphism from mR into mR ® R*, hence the exactness proves the assertion. N ext we give some sufficient conditions for a tensor product to be exact. (lS.G) Let R be a ring and let R* be a ring which is an R-module. If, for any ideal a of R, the natural map from II ® R' onto aR* is an isomorphism, then ® R R* is exact. Proof: Let M be a finite R-module and let N be a finite R-module contained in M. We shall prove that N ® R* c M ® R*. Let u l , . . . , U r be a basis for M, and we set Ni = (L~--I ujR) + N. If N i - I ® R* C Ni ® R* for any i, then tho assertion is proved. Thus we may assume that UI, . , . , Ur-I E N. Let F be a free Rmodule with free base U 1 , •• , , U r , and let ¢ be the homomorphism from F onto M such that ¢( U i ) = Ui. Set G = L~-l RUi , H = cp-l(N) , K = cp--l(O). Then, with a = N:M = N:urR, H = G EEl aUr • Therefore H ® R* = (G ® R*) EEl (aU r ® R*), F ® R* = (G ® R*) EEl (UrR ® R*). Since, by our assumption, aUr ® R* C UrR ® R*, we have H ® R* C F ® R*. Hence K ® R* in H ® R* coincides with K ® R* in F ® R*, which proves that N ® R* = (H ® R*)j (K ® R*) C (F ® R*)j(K ® R*) = M ® R*. Thus we complete the proof. (IS.7) THEOREM: Assume that R and R* are Noetherian rings such that R* is an R-module. Let ¢ be the homomorphism from R into R* such that ¢ ( a) = a· 1 (in R*). Let ill?:* be the set of maximal ideals of R* and let ill?: be the set of prime ideals m of R such that m = ¢-I( m*) with m* E ill?:*. Then ® R R* is exact if and only if the following is true: If q is a primary ideal with prime divisor m E ill?: and if b is an element of R such that q: bR = m, then qR*: bR* = mR*. Proof: The only if part is obvious by (IS.I). We assume that the condition holds good. We remark first that the condition is carried
01
1111.\1"1'1'111 II
(Nil" h';,~.)(111 (U/n, U" /nN+) 1'111' Hlly idl'II,1 I(d, N 1111/1. ,'lIIi)1I10dllil' III' M. !,Ollll.\' pail'll
1'1'0111
N
('0
N* illLo M
Co)
f/. I (III,I'), 111'1' I II.lt"f) Itiid Id~11I 10 II III' N. 1.1'1, III 111'11, lilliLl' N IlIlIdllll' /1.1111 Lf'1, /\ IIf' i.l1f' 1.1'1'111,1111' 1.111' 11\11,1' I (OJ /(1'
It". I I,
iH Hlillinil'lli, 1.11 PI'O"I'
I\pplyill/!: (S.IO) 1,0/\, WI, Imvli ollly 1.0 PI'OVI'
pain.;
(N
llt
,
H,;'.). ThllH
WII IlIll.y
I.ltl'
l.Iud, 1\
O.
II.HHI'l'l.iow-! 1'01' HIII'h
aHHllllH, I.haL /{, a,lIi1 U* al'fI IIII'HI I'illp;~j '/' I( 111*). (I) I\HHIIIIII'
wiUI Il\axill\al i(lioai:--! H\ alld 1\\* alit! Lhn,j, 1l\
llilpoCnllL. I II ol'(kl' to prOY(, ChaC II. 0, WII IlIa.v tJmt NiH an iiI"al and Lhal; 111 =cc N by (Is.n). WI' lIKfI 1.111' iii Ihlfll.ioll olllenp.;Lh R. J[' blgth U '''' I, UWIi U iH a lildd, allli 1.\111 aHcH'I' Lioll iA obvious. AHHurnillp.; that lobp.;Llt R > I, IPI, b hI' all 1111'1111'111. or N Hileh that length bR = J, i.e., O:bR = 111. \{y Olll' illd\l(',Lioli a,H:-;\i1I1P /.iOIl, ®RlbR (R*/bR*) is exaet, which mCl1IlH that i,hl, naLul'al III:1p I'l'f)tn (N/bR) ® (R*/bR) into R*/bR* is an iflomorpbiHIII. '1'111'1'1'1'01'1' I{ iH contained in b ® R*. Since 0 :bR* = mIt*, we }mvil LhaL l)ol.Ii II ® R* and bR* are faithful R*/mR*-modules, hcw,!) J( = O. 'I'I\II.'-i lVI, hnve settled this case. (2) Now we prove the genoml (:aH(I. By (I) I\,l>0ve, we see that ®R/mn R*/mnR* is exact for any n, whidl iIIlPlil'~{ Chat (N/(mnM N)) ® (R*/mnR*) is naturally cOlltaill(\d ill 11,(' !irHL that 111 iN tl.HHillIl
n
(M/mnM) ® (R*/mnR*). n
n
Therefore we see that K is contained in (m M N) ® /(,* ill N (~ HI. Hince mnM N c mn~rN for an r and for any n ::::: r by the 1101111)\:1, oj' Artin-Rees, we see that K c nn mn(N ® R*), which mw.;/; lin :1,1'1'11 because R* is a local ring. Thus K = 0, which completes the PI·I)O/'.
n
(18.8) COROLLARY: Assume that a Noetherian ring R is dorn:ina/('d liy a Noetherian ring R* and that for any maximal ideal m (~r N till' 'ideal mR* is a maximal ideal of R*. Then ® R R* is exact if and oniil If qR* R = q Jor any primary ideal q of R such that the radical III q is a maximal ideal. In particular, ~r a semi-local ring R is a dense subspace oJ a ,w:llli local r'ing R', then ® Tl R' is exact. We notc that thi:-; (18.8) gives another proof of (17.11). }I'lli'Ll II 'I' more, as an immediate eonsequence of (18.8), we have tho f()lI()w~
n
ing corollary hy virtue of (G.l7).
(18.9)
COROLI,AHY:
Let
Xl,
..• , Xn
lie algebraically independ,I'IIJ
I !()MI'I,III'I'II INII
clc'f/wnts liI'I"/' 1/ N (}I 'Ihl ,/,11/11 /'111(/ H. "'!tl'll (.)),' N( ,I'I iN 1',1'1/1'1. ( 'f. II:,~I'I' cise 2 below). (18.10) Let Rand U* 1)(: 'l'inus slU:h thllJ h~" 'i,~ lUi '1~-I/I(}111/11' I/lid slt('h that ® R R* is exact. Let cf> be the nat'uTal !J,o'/l/'(l'llIo'l'jlh£sln Jl'lrill NI:/lto R* (cf>(r) = '1'·1 with 1 E R*). Let a be an ideal I({ U and lel 8 and 8* be multiplicatively closed subsets of Rand R* respectively 8uch that cf>(S) C S* and such that S a = S* aR* = empty. Set R' = U"/llU 8 and R" = R~* I aR~* . Then ® R' R" is exact. Proof: If M is an Ria-module, then M is an R-module and
n
M
®Rln
(R*laR*)
n
=
M
®R
R*.
Therefore we see easily that ® Rln R* I aR* is exact. Hence, we may assume that a = O. Since ®R* R" is exact by (6.18), we see that ®R R" is exact. If M is an R'-module, then M is an R-module and M ® R' R" = M ® R R", and therefore the assert.ion is proved easily. (18.11) THEOREM: Let Rand R* be Noetherian rings such that R* is an R-module and such that ® R R* is exact. Let a be an ideal of Rand let p* be a prime ideal of R*. Then p* is a p'l'ime diviso'l' of aR* if and only if there is a p'l'ime divisor p of a such that p* i8 a p'l'ime divisor oj pR*. p* is a minimal prime divisor of aR* if and only if there i8 a minimal prime divisor p of a such that p* is a minimal prime divisor of pR*. Proof: Assume that. p* is a prime divisor of 'pR* wit.h a prime divisor p of a. Then t.here are element.s b E Rand c* E R* such t.hat. p = a:bR, p* = pR*:c*R* by (8.8). Since pR* = aR*:bR* by (18.1), we have p* = (aR*:bR*) :c*R* = aR*:bc*R*, and p* is a prime divisor of aR*. Conversely, assume t.hat. p* is a prime divisor of aR*.
Let. ql n ... n qr be a short.est primary decomposition of a. Then aR* = nqiR*, whence p* is a prime divisor of some qiR*, say, qIR*. Let p be the prime divisor of q = ql. We shall prove that p* is a prime divisor of pR* by induction on length Rpl qRp . We may a88ume that q = 0 by (18.10). If the length is 1, then the aS8ertion is obvioutl beeause p = q. Let a be an element. of p such t.hat p = 0: aR, and let q' = aR)) n R. Then there is an element d of R which is not in p 8ueh that dq' CaR. Let qi n ... n q; be a shorte8t primary decomposition of zero in R* such that the prime divisor pi of q; i8 a prime divisor of pR* if and only if i ::::; t. Since p = 0: aR, pR* = n (q;: aR*) by (18.1), whence by our assumption on t.he prime divisors pR* qi : aR*) n ... n (qi: aR*). Let b* be an arbitrary element of
1'11.\1"1'1'111 "
qt ,
IIi (l '"
()
p'i' , ", ,
)l:' ,
tlil'l'('
II,\' 11111'
\\'1\('III~(\
1'.~iH','i /111 1'1.'1I11'lIt
r:'
I
illllill'lillll, III .. q'h~+' HIIII
(1+ I ('*
or
pl'i II II , dil'iHOI'rl
LiIl'!'I'!'OI'I'
N~' 1'1111,11 /.IlII,t iI'I'd
h*dU*:uH* ~ (qi
{/d I
1'1' q'U+
III'"
11/(1', 1V1i1'111'1'
(/{,'I',
n '" n q;) :IIN*
~"I~>I>.
0, WIIl'III'n b>l>d . O,III'III:n b* ( O:dN*' (O:dfnu+ 0, alld s .. I, whinb PI'OVI'H the HKKm(,ioll, Now we l'OIlHidl'l' t.lH~ InHt IIHYl'rtioli. AHHllrne thaL ~* il'l a lI\illimall)l'iml~ divil'lo]'o!' IlN*. 'l'III'1l p* il'l a pl'imc diviHot' of ~/(,* with a prime tiivitlo]' ).I of 11. 'I'lw llIillillIItiity or p* impliel'l Chat p* i.'l a miJlimal prime divisor of ).IU* alld that ~l iH /I. minimal prime diviso], of a. Conversely, assume that ~ iH H, minilll:d primo divisor of a and that ).1* is a minimal prime divisor of ).1n*, L.. t. ).1** be a minimal prime divisor of aRt such that p** C ).1*. Let, q) II11 Lbo natural homomorphism fromR into R* (cf>(a) = a·l with 1 ( U*), and let p' be cf>-l(p**). Then ).1' is a prime ideal by (2,12) and p' iN ('.011,' I.nined in p because p = cf>-l(p*) (for, non-zero elements of H/~l :IXI' 1I0!; zero divisors with respect to R*/pR* by (18,1), By the millillIality of ).1, we have ).1' = p, whence p** is a prime divisor of ).IN*, whieh implies that p** = p* by the minimality of p* and by (,haL p** C pt. Thus p* is a minimal prime divisor of aRt. We say that a module M over a ring R is torsion-free if every 11011;!,pro-divisor in R is not a zero divisor with respect to M, '1'111'1'101'01'1' Ilt*
(18.12)
THEOREM:
Let Rand R' be Noetherian rings such that H'
is an R-module and such that ® R R' is exact, If M is a torsion-free Hmodule and if every prime divisor of zero in R is of height at most I I then M ® R R' is a torsion-free R' -module. Proof: Let R* and R'* be the rings R EB M and R' EB (M ® R') I'nspectively in the principle of idealization. If N is an R*-module , Llten N is an R-module, and N ® R R' is naturally identified with N 0 R* (R' ®R R*) = N ®R' R'*. Therefore we see that ®R* R'* is exact. In order to prove (18.12), we may assume that M is a finite module. Assume that a E R' is a zero divisor with respect to M ® R'. Then a is a zero divisor in R'*, and there is a prime divisor p'* of ;!'ero in R'* such that a E p'*. (18.11) implies that there is a prime divisor p* of zero in R* such that p'* is a prime divisor of p*R'*, rlince M2 = 0, we have M C ).1*, and therefore p* = p EB M with a prime ideal p of R. Similarly, ).1'* = p' EB (M ® R') with a prime ideal ~' of R'. Since M is torsion-free, we see that ).1 consists merely of zero
til tlil'iHIII'H, 111'111'1' i:1 II. prillll' tlil'illlll' IIi' '/,111'11 II,\' 0111' 1I:1rllllllpLiIIIl oil
N,
fJ" HIHI :lilll'I' U+ III ,~, 11', Lill' 1'1101'1. 1.1111,1. ~I'''' iH :I. pl'illll' dil'i,'1ol' 01' \l+N'+ ililplil'r1 l,illl,L 11' iel II, WillII' tliviHol' or tIlt,', Hillel' ¢Il", N' iH I'xni'!, HIHI Hilll'(' P iN H pl'illll' diviHlIl' oi' iWI'o ill N, WI~ H('(', Lila!. ).1' iN a WillI(' diviHOl' 01' :t,l'I'o ill H' Ily (IK,II), WIIl'III'!' I/,
Hilll'l' ,,",1,/( II'
(il
,,"
I '"
1
iH a l',('I'O diviNOl' ill N', wllil'll 1',OIlIPld(~H (.1)(' pi'ool'. 1';XI,JIWlf;JC:-:: I. AHHll1nc l.lmL U, U*, U** are riJl~H KJleh thaI. ®u U* and ® u* fl*" are exact" Prove that ® II H.** iH exact, 2, Let x, , .,. , x" be algebntically independent elements over a ring R. PI'ove that ® R R[x] and ® R R (x) are exact. (Hint: Prove first the exactness of ®R R[x] using the fact that R[x] has a free base over R.) 3. Let R* be a ring which is a module over a Noetherian ring R. Prove that ®R R* is exact if (a:bR)R* = aR*:bR* for any ideal a and any element b of R, 4. Let (R, a) be a Zariski ring and let M be a finite R-module. Let S be the set of non-zero-divisors with respect to M and let N* be the completion of a submodule N of M. Prove that (M ® Rs) n N* = N, where, M ® Rs and N* are naturally imbedded in M ® R~ (R* being the completion of R). 5. Let (R, a) be a Zariski ring and let R* be the completion of R. J~et b be an ideal of R. Prove that if bR* is principal then b is principal. (Hint: b/ba = b/ba ® Ria = b/ba ® R* /aR* = bR* IbaR*.) 6. Prove that if the completion R* of a Zariski ring (R, a) is a unique factorization ring, then R is also a unique factorization ring. (Hint: Let lJ be an arbitrary prime ideal of height 1 in R lind let S be the complement of lJ in R. Then, show that lJR~ is principal and that every maximal prime divisor of \JR* does not meet S, Then conclude that \JR* has only prime divisors of height] and then that \JR* is principal.) 7. Let R* be a ring containing a ring R such that (a) ®R R* is exact and (b) aR* n R = 11 holds for any ideal a of R. Let M be an R-module. Prove that if M ® R* is a finite R*-module then M is a finite R-module.
19. The theorem oj transition We say that the theorem of transition holds for rings Rand R' if R is dominated by il' and (2) if q is a primary ideal in R such that the prime divisor of q is a maximal ideal, say m, then ~ 1)
lengthR' R' / qR' is finite and it holds that lengthR' R' / qR' (19.1)
THEOREM:
=
(lengthR' R' / mR') (length R R / q) .
Let Rand R' be Noetherian rings such that
R :s; R'. Assume that, for any maximal ideal m of R, the length of R' / mR' is finite (i.e., the prime divisors of mR' are all maximal). Then
(II L\ 1"1'11111
II
(\:)
,~j' l/i" follol/lill(/i{ i8 " II"",'IIS"I'!/ 1/1/(1 iill.lli,.;,.1I1 ,.o/It/ifio// Jor III,. I'Irlitlilli ,(/' Iii,' Ih"o/'t'1II qj' 1/'IIIINil;oIIIo/' l/i,' /'i//flN It allrl N': (a) II q /S 1/ /lrilll((I'!1 itll'lll hdo//I/illf/ 10 (('1/11/,,/,/11111'/ ir/I'II./ 111 in It I(.I/.({ 1/ q: hh~· 111 Iol' an d,:II/,'II'/' h ,~r H, the//. qU': hl{" = III /{,'. ( I») M I,: N' /:8 (',!>ad. ((~) 11'111' IJ://'!I '/II.(u'£'ma.1 ideal 111' (if Il', the theorem of transition holds JOI' Hlm'n,,: and N,~" . (d) If Il and 0 arc idcals of R, then (a:o)R' = aR':oR', ('(/I'll
1'1'001': We show first that the validity of the theorem of transition illiplins (a). Set q' = q + bR. Then length R/q = length R/q' + 1, !Il'III:n length R'/qR' = length R'/q'R' + length R'/mR', which impline; that length R'/mR' = length q'R'/qR' = length bR'/(bR' q/(,') = length R'/(qR':bR'), which implies that mR' = qR':bR'. Thie; proof being reversible by induction on length R/q, we see the eqllivalence with (a). (a) implies (b) by (lS.7). (b) implies (d) by (IR.l), while (d) implies (a) obviously. Thus (a), (b) and Cd) HI'P equivalent. It is obvious that (c) implies the validity of the theorem of transition; the converse is also obvious except for the i'lwt that R* = R(lIlnR) C R** = Rill" which is proved as follows: Q<),,:*R** is exact by (b) and (lS.1O), whence (1S.3) implies the indllsion relation.
n
(19.2) COROLLARY: Assume that the theorem of transition holds for Noetherian rings Rand R'. (1) For any ideal a of R, the theorem of transition holds for the rings /f,/a and R'/aR'. (2) A ssume that 8 and 8' are multiplicatively closed subsets of R nnd R' respectively such that every maximal ideal p' with respect to 8' '£n R' is a minimal prime divisor of pR' for some maximal ideal p 'with respect to 8 in R and conversely that if p is maximal ideal with reNPt;ct to 8 in R, then pR' does not meet 8'. Then the theorem of transition holds for the rings Rs and R~, . (3) If Rs and R~, in (2) are semi-local rings, then Rs is a subspace of R~,. Proof: We note first that ® R R' is exact by (19.1). Since aR' R = a by (1S.3), the validity of (1) is obvious. ® RS R~, is exact by (IS.1O). Therefore, by our assumption and hy (lS.:3), Rs is a suhI'ing of R~, , hence Rs is dominated by R~, . Therefore (2) is proved
n
00
, '( 1M 1'1 dl)'I'IIIN I \
I!I.IIIY (). (:\) iH l'HHY III"'HIIHI'
N,Y,
i1I'III'!!
ill
n"h',~j'
n Ii','j
p:t,l'l.it:IlIaI' 1'01' 1.I\1~ .I:1.I'01i:-1011
n"
1'01' Hlly ili":!i
n
III'
I'adi,'al n,
II;X,,]/\l:I;\I';: LoL N alld H' ho Nodh,:l"ia,/I l"i/lgH HIII:h l.lIal. /t,' iH all N /I\odll!". ASHlImc OwL Lhe following Ht.aComonj,H a,',) CnlO: (a) 1.1)(,"0 iH 110 IrInxilll:d id,:nl of R which generaieH il' in if,', (b) the natural imagc U* or It, ill a' (N" = R/(O:R ' )) is dominated by R' and (c) the condition (2) in the uoiiniLioll of the theorem of transition holds for Rand R'. Prove that R r;;;;, R'.
C II A PT II~ I{, 11 [
Multiplicities 20. Homogeneous rings i\ ring R is called a homogeneous ring over a ring A if R is a graded "illgL Ri such that A = Ro and such that R is generated by RI over A. II' furthermore Rl is generated by algebraically independent elements over A, then R is called a homogeneous polynomial ring. A graded ideal or a homogeneous ring is called a homogeneous ideal. The above definition 8how8 that homogeneous rings arc nothing hut homomorphic image8 of homogeneous polynomial ring8 who He IW['Jwls are homogeneous ideal8. (20.1) A homogeneous rIng R = L RII is Noetherian ~f and only z{ Nil and RI are Noetherian (i.e., Ro is a Noetherian ring and RI has a .finite bas'is over Ro). Proof: The if part is obvious. Convertlely, assume that R itl NonCherian. If a and b are ideals of R o , then that a r" b implies that nR r" bR (because a = aR R o , b = bR R o), and we see that Ro iN Noetherian. If a and bare sub modules of R I , then that a r" b implies that aR r" bR, and we sec that Rl is K oetherian. Let R = L It" he a graded ring and let M = L Mit itl a graded module over R. We retain these deiinitiolltl of Rand M throughout Chis seetion. The length of M" (as an Ro-module) is a function of n ['or n = 0, 1, 2, .... This function is called the K-function of M (over Ro) and is denoted by KRo (M; n) or simply by K( M; n). If there is a polynomial f( x) in one indeterminate x whose coefficients are rational numbers such thatf(n) = K(M; i) for sufficiently large n, then the polynomial f(x) is called the O"-polynomial of M and is denoted by O"R(M; n) or by O"(M; n). It is obvious that M has a O"-polynomial if and only if each K( M; n) is finite and furthermore K( M; n) is a polynomial in n for sufficiently large n. When a is a graded ideal of R, K (R / a; n) is called the IIilbert characteristic function of a and is denoted by X(ll; n). (20.2) If Nand N' are graded s'ubmodules of 1.11, then
n
n
L;
[67]
os
M, 11/I'II'ld( '1'1'1 WI
KeN IN';
11.)
I /dN
n N';
1,(
II)
N;
1/)
I (;( N';
11.).
Similarly if a and U 0/1"(: {fradol id('als (~( N, 1/11'1/, X(il I b; 1/.) -In 0; n) = xCa; n) + xCo; n). Proof: CNn + N~)/Nn = N~/CNn N:,), whidl implicH Lho assertion. C20.3) Let N = L N n be a graded submodule of M and let f be a homogeneous element of degree d in M. Then KCN + fR; n) = KCN ; n) + x(N:fR; n - d). Similarly, if M = R, then
xCa
n
xCN
+ fR; n)
xCN; n) - xCN:fR; n - d).
=
Proof: By C1.5), CN + fR)/N is isomorphic to R/CN:fR). By the nature of the isomorphism, we see that CN + fR) n/N n is isomorphic to Rn-d/CN:fR)n-d, which implies the assertion. C20.4) Assume that R is a homogeneous polynomial ring in indeterminates Xl, ... , Xs over a ring A which satisfies the minimum conditionfor ideals. Then KCR; n)
=
(n;-
~~
I)-length A.
Proof: The number of monomials of degree n is equal to (
n
+s
-
s -
1
1)
and the assertion is proved. C20.5) THEOREM: Assume that R is a Noetherian homogeneous ring over a ring of altitude zero. If a graded R-module M has a finite basis, then M has a O"-polynomial. Proof: At first, we consider tho case where M = R/a with a graded ideal a. Assuming the contrary, let F be the set of graded ideals a such that R/a has no O"-polynomial. Since R is Noetherian, F has a maximal member, say a*. If depth a* = 0, then R/a* has a finite length, say l, and R/a* has the constant l as its O"-polynomial, which is a contradiction. Thus depth a* ~ 1, thorefore there is a homogeneous element f of degree 1 which is not in a*. C20.3) implies that xC a* + fR; n) = xCa*; n) - xCa*:fR; n - 1). By the maximality of a*, xC a* + fR; n) is a polynomial in n for large n, say, for n ~ m. If a* :fR 7"" a*, then xC a* :fR; n - 1) is a polynomial in n for large nand we see that xC a*; n) is a polynomial for such n, which is a contradiction. If a*:fR = a*, then summing up the equalities xCa* + fR; r) = xCa*; r) - xCa*; r - 1) for r = m, m + 1, ... , n, we see that
1'11111"1'1'111, III
1111
L:,',
I\ln+; 1/) x(n" I .IN; i) 1 (I~OIIHLJI,IIL), HIIlI x(n*; 11.) iHn poly, lIolliial 1'111' 1n1'J.!:I· II, whil~h iH HINO II. 1~III1Ll'll.!lil',Lioli. "'hUN '" iH (~lIlpLy "'1111 LhiN ('HNn iH HI'LLind. Now wn pl'ovn Lh(~ gnllcml (~aN(~ hy ilidudiOl; 1111 ('111' 1111 II Ii 11'1' III' hOlliognlll'ollN gCllcmLol'N of M, Let Ul, . , . ,us be 11 IIHNiH i'ol' AI NiI(',1i LhaL ('adl 'lti iN homogeneous, If s = 1, then M is iHOIIIOI'pliil' Lo Il/(O:M), and therefore the assertion is true in this 1'11.141'. Hd N = I uR. Then, by our induction, we assume that N 1""14 n IT-polYliomial f(x). M/N = usR/(usR N), and therefore M/N IinH a IT-polynomial g(x), Since length Mn = length N n 11'11J.!:Lh (M.,jN n ), we see that f(x) g(x) is a IT-polynomial of M, II,lId tlw atlsertion is proved. (~(l.(i) If Ro/ (0: M) is the direct sum of local rings A i( i = 1, , .. ,r), Ihen denoting by ei the identity of Ai, M is the direct sum of Mei and /(/.,,(M; n) = KAi(Mei ; n). I 'l'Oof: IT i( m) = mei defines a homomorphism from M onto M ei , h"II(',e into M. Obviously ITi is the identity map, hence M is gen('I'aLnd by the M ei. mi = 0 (mi E M ei) means that, since miei = IIli, 0 = ej( mj) = mj. Thus we see that M is the direct sum of I.hn Mei , and the assertion is proved. (:20.7) Assume that Ro is a local ring with maximal ideal 111. If ( II, 11) is a local ring which is dominated by Ro and if K = R o/111 is a ,finite algebraic extension of K' = A/n, then
L';
n
+
+
Li
L
L
L
KAM, n)
=
[K:K'J'KRo(M; n),
I 'I'oof: Let M n = a(O) :::J a(l) :::J ... :::J aCr) = 0 be a composition /'Im'ies of M n as an Ro-moduk Then each aCi) /a(i+1) is isomorphic to /{, whence it has length [K:K'] as an A-module. Thus we prove the II. H.'-IPl'tion. A polynomial f(x) in one indeterminate x, whose coefficients are l'II.Lional numbers, is called a numerical polynomial if there exists an lIlL(~ger N such that fen) is an integer for any integer n such that /I ~ N. IT-polynomials are numericaL (20.8) If f(x) is a numerical polynomial of degree d, then there are
integers co, ... ,
,,. +
Cd-J
(x
Cd
such that f( x)
i 1) +
Cd,
=
Co (x
1
d)
+
Cl
(x
1~ ~ 1) +
where the (:) are binomial coefficients. Con-
Iwqnently, f( n) is an integer for any integer n and if a is a coefficient of
I(:c) then a· (d!) is an integer.
70
1\1111 il'll'l ,1('1'1'11<111 PI'!)D!':
W(\
pl'lIV!! CIi!! /I,HH(II'CiOIl
aKK(~I'LiDIi iK ol,vioIiK. AHKIIII\(\
hy
illilll!'l.ioll (III
I.hll.l. d I) ~·c I:d.r"
>
O. 1,('1. ('
d, II' d "II
0, 1.11('11 I,hll I,hll IIOl'lJinil'll1. or
xd • Thon I(x) - I(:I: 1-+ (1.1'1'1111' or lowI'!' dllJ,!;I·('('H). Since f(x) - I(:c - 1) it:: aiHo II\UXWl'i(lal, ('0 c'c (:(d!) iN :1.11 illl.l'g(,I·.
Therefore f(
x) - (x ! d) is a numeriwl polYliomial or dngn'(' 1(,1'1' Co
than d, and we prove the assertion hy our indtwtion.
21. A-Polynomials Let a he an ideal of a ring R and let M he an R-module. Set F n an/an+! and Gn = anM/an+!M, for n = 0,1,2, ., .. When a E F m , b E F n , we define ab as follows: let a' and b' be elements of am and an respectively such that a = (a' modulo am+1 ), b = (b'modulo an+!) and then we define ab = (a'b' modulo am+ n+1 ) ( E Fn+m). This multiplication defines a ring structure in the direct sum F of all the F n , and F becomes a graded ring. Furthermore, since Fn = an/a n +\ it follows that Fn = (F1)n, which implies that F is a homogeneous ring. This homogeneous ring F is called the form ring of R with respect to a. When a E an and a ~ an+!, n is called the degree of a with respect to a and (a mod an+!) is called the a-form of a. The direct sum G of all the Gi becomes similarly a graded module over F. This G is called the form module of M with respect to a. It is obvious that length M/a n +1M = length ai M/ai+ 1l\1 1:~ K(G; i). Therefore we see by virtue of (20.5) that (21.1) A ssume that Rand Mare Noetherian and that depth a = O. Then there is a numerical polynomialf(x) such that length M/an+1M = f( n) for all n that are greater than a fixed integer; f( x) is nothing but the O"-polynomial of the form module G. Now, applying (20.6) and (20.7) to the above result, we see that:
1:;
(21.2) THEOREM: Let M be ajinite module over a Noetherian ring R and le,t a be an ideal of R such that depth a = O. Furthermore let R' be a Noetherian ring such that (1) R is an R' -module, (2) with a'
=
(a I a E R', aR
c al,
R' / a' is dominated by R / a and (3) [R / mi: R' / m: 1 are finite, where mi (i = 1, ... , s) are the prime divisors of a and m; are the maximal ideals of R' such that m;/a' = (mi/a) (R'/a'). Then: (a) there is a numerical polynomial f(x) such that fen) = lengthR' M/anN\.for
n
71
('11111"1'1')11, III
if (/ iN thl! fOI'/11 I//lIdlll,' I~j' IlIu'illil'l'.Y/u'('I/IIIl,I/t"II./'(n I I) 1111'1",((,';//) • ./'(1/ I I) /(1/) h/,"III'( 0; 1/.) JII/' iiI/JII('':I'/lII!! 11/('(/1' //IIIIII'//.( //11I1I.{/('/,8 n I/l/.tI (('.) J( 1/) LIN/III i: N' /111; I· (1'lIlIlh J,'i • III (>0 10' Njn" AI C>() II Ni , I/Ihl '/'1 , Hi Nil, ( , Wn dnlloCn LlIl'/(.r) J.!:iVI~II.iIll-d, ahovn hy IIIIJI NII:f!ir'/I'ltllllirll'{/I' //1111/./'111 /llllI/hr'I' II. (I,)
AIo:'(O; Ai; .r), whidl i:-; ('alled a A-]!II(.l/II,(lfIl:ia( or M. A/,:(n; AI; .r) Illay "I~ dn1ioj,I'd Hilllply by A(11; M; .r) HIHj 111 may 1)(: omiCCI~d ir 111 = H. By our defillition, we Nne iIIlln<~diaLely Chai.:
(:2I.:n When R iii a l!erni-loC(J,t ring with cornlJtclilin I~*, tlu:1/
Aw(a; 111; ;;;)
=
Aw(all*; 111 ® R*; x).
We see also the following by virtue of (lS.!)), (19.1). (21.4) With the same R, R', a and M as in (21.2), if X
·i.~
((.
11'11.11.8
eendental element over R, then Aw(x)(aR(X); M ® R(X); .r) All' ( a; M; x).
(21.5) THEOREM: With the same R, R', a and lJ!l as in (21.:2), 11'1 N be a subrnodule of M. Set g(x) = AR,(a; N; x) + Aw(n; M/N; :1:) - Aw(a; M; x). Then g(n) = lengthR'(anM N)/ll"N :S length R'. an-rN /anN with a fixed natural number r and JOT a 8UJ/i-
n
eiently large natural number n, and therefore g( x) is of lower degree thaI/, Aw(a; N; x), except for the case where Aw(a; N; n) is of degree 0 and g(x) = O.
Proof: Since (M/N)/an(M/N) = M/(anM + N) and Hilll'l~ (anM + N)/anM = N /(anM N), we have the first equality. 8ilJ(~n anZVJ n N = an-rearM n N) by the lemma of Artin-Rees, we havli anN C anM N C an-rN, which shows the inequality. If Aw(a; N; :r:) is a constant, then amN = 0 for sufficiently large m and we see thaI, g(x) = 0 by the inequality just proved. Assume that AR,(a; N; :1:) is not COIlHtant. Then g(x) .::;: Aw(a; N; x) - Aw(a; N; x - 'r), which is of lower degree than AR(a; N; x), and thus we complete thn proof.
n
n
22. Superficial elements Let It = L Rn be a Noetherian homogeneous ring. An element .f of R is called a superficial element of R if f E Rl and if there is an m such that (O:fR) n Rn = 0 for any n ;:::: m. (22.1) Assume that Ro is a semi-local ring with maximal ideal.'!
7'2
M111/1'11'1,11 lI'I'llI\rl
1111 , " . , III", Ilia.!. ('1'1'1'11 U/illi l'OIlIf/InN il/jillilt'I!1 Illf/II!! l'it'IIII'II.IN f/,//(!
Ihl/,I "~I
iii
I,d III , ... , II j III' tWO/II'"/' 8Ii.1l/1wdli.lI'N oI 8upcljir:'/af I'f(!'II/,(!nl f lif U whit:!l, '£8 'not '£11, any of lit.(:
/8 a FII:I:II' Nw·l/I.odnit'.
. 'l'lum, t/wn; '£8
(J,
II, .
Proof: Consider all of the prime diviHors of )1;01'0 wh ieh do not eontain R 1 ; let them be ~l, .•• , \Ju. Set nt+i = \Ji n R 1 • Then, by the lemma of Krull-Azumaya, we see that nj 5tR I ~ RI for any j = 1, ... , t u,5t being the Jacobson radical of Ro (5t = ni mi). Hence N j = (nj 5tR 1 ) /.£R I is a proper submodule of M = R1/.£R I . We shall show that there is an element g of M which is not in any of the N j • M is the direct sum of Mi = RdmiRl ,which have free bases mi,l, ... , mi,n(i) over the fields RO/mi . We prove the existence of g by induction on Ln(i). SetN; = ml,lR N j • We may assume that N; = M if and only if j > v. Applying the induction assumption to /ml,lR in M/ml,lR, we see that there is an element g* of M/ml,lR which is not in any of the /ml,lR for j = 1, ... , v. Let g' and g" be two different elements of M whose residue classes modulo ml,lR are the same g*. If both g' and gil are in the same N j , then N j contains ml,l , which cannot happen for j > v. Therefore, if we take different gW, ... , l') of M whose residue classes are all the same g* and if r > t u v, then at least one of l i ) is not in any of the N j for j > v. By the choice of g*, we see that the element is not in any of the N j for j = 1, ... , t u. Thus the existence of g is proved. Now letfbe an element of R such thatfmodulo5tR = g. Sincef ~ \Ji for any i by our choice, 0 :fR coincides with 0 up to primary components whose prime divisors contain Rl ; namely, there is an ideal b which contains a power R7 of RI such that b n (O:fR) = 0, whence (O:fR) n Rn C (O:fR) n b = 0 for n ~ m, and f is superficial. When a is an ideal of a Noetherian ring R, an element a of a is called a superficial element of a if there exists a natural number c such that (an: aR) n aC = a,,-l for any natural number n > c. (22.2 ) With the notation as above, a E a is a superficial element of a 2 if a modulo a is a superficial element of the form ring F = L F" of R with respect to a. Proof: Set a' = a modulo a2 • Let a natural number c be tlllchLhat (O:a'F) n Fn = 0 for n ~ c. Let n be an arbitrary natural number such that n > c. It is obvious that a n - 1 C (an:aR) n aC • Let b be an arbitrary element of (an:aR) n aC • Then ab E an. Let m be such that m l b E a - and that b ~ am. Set b' = b modulo am. Then b' E F m-l .
+
+
+
+
N;
N;
+
+
7:1
.'11,11"1'1111(, III
n
Hilll'.' II I 1\", \1'1\ 1111,1'.' III . 1', ",lil'lll'(\ (.0:0'/,') I,'", I O. II' III • II, Ihl'll oh ( n" illl"lil'~j Lhnl. 1//1/ 0, whidl iN n I·OIlI.J'wlidioli. 'l'hnl'l'foJ'l'/II, . 1/., HIIII h ( nil I. ,I'hll:-l I.hn pmol' iH I~OII1J1ltd,n. (:.l:.l.:\) '1'''Wllt,I')M: 1"ll (\ Iw ((,/1. 'I:t!(/(/,l I~r Illljill!. z(/ro 1:'1/. a Nor;lIW1"£an '/''://(/ N, and lel I./u: 7!1'irrw d£/r£,w)'/'S I!/, (1 he 1111, ... , 1\l". Let 8 he lhe inler.wlci'ion I~r til.!: co'fnpl(mwnls I~r 11\.[. I,et 01, ... , 0 t be ideals oj R wlf.ch lho,l aa" is nol contained in any oiRs . If R/mi contains infinitely IWIny elements Jor every i, then there is a superficial element a of a which .,:.~ not in any oj the OJ . I)roof: Let F = F n be the form ring of R with respect to a. Set 2 2 2 Iii = FI ((OJ )/a ). If nj = F I , then a C OJ a , hence a = 2 (Uj a) a , whence aRs = (Uj a)R8 by the lemma of KrullJ\,mmaya, and it is a contradiction. Thus nj ~ FI for any j. Therefore there is a superficial element a' of F which is not in any of the IIj by (22.1). An element a of a such that a' = a modulo a is a superfieial element of a by (22.2). It is ohvious that a ~ OJ, and the [I$sor-
n n +
L +(
+
n
!,ion is proved. (22.4) With the same R and a as ahove, if (t = aR, then a is a .mper.ficial element of a. Proof: It itl sufficient to show that, in the form ring F = Fn of
S
Il with respect to a, a' = a modulo a2 is a superficial element of F. fi' is generated by a' over Fo = R/aR. Therefore, if \.1 is a prime divisor 0[' zero in F which does not contain F I , then a' Et \.1, hence 0: a' F (:oincides with 0 up to primary components whose prime divisors nontain Fl' Therefore, a' is a superficial element of F, and a IS a Kuperficial element of a. (22.5') With the same notation as in (21.2), iJ b E R, then length w R/(a n
+ bR)
= length w
R/a n - length1/' R/(an:bR).
This follows from (1.5). (22.6) THEOREM: With the same notation as above, assume that a E a. Set a' = a/aR. Then A1/'(a'; n) ~ Aw(a; n) - A1/'(a; n - 1) for large n. If a is a superficial element of a, then, with the intersection S of the complements of the prime divisors of a, kngthR' (O:aRs) is finite and AR,(a'; x) = Aw(a; x) - Aw(a; x - 1) length1/' (O:aRs). Proof: The firtlt assertion is immediate from (22.5). Let c be a
+
sufficiently large natural number which is fixed and let n be,greater Lhan c. Then (an:aR) n a = an-I. By (22.5), we have C
7,1
MIII!I'll'ld('I'I'II'ill
'\"" (n;
/I )
'\10" (n;
I)
1/
ill Hill", I.hi:-; length i:-; a eOlli:iLan(" flay C:, for large n. We have only to prove that C = length w c (O:aRs). Since Rla = RslacRs we may assume that R = Rs. Then an:aR is contained in (O:aR) + a by (3.12) for large n, whence C = length w (O:aR)/(O:aR) a Since this C is independent of c C (when c is large), (O:aR) a must be zero, and the assertion is proved.
Situ:<: !.Iw minimum <'.ollditioll lLold:-;
C
n
n
C
•
(22.7) THEOREM: With the same notation as in (21.2), the degree OJ AR' (a; M; x) is equal to altitude (a + (O:M))/(O:M) (in the ring RI(O:M)). Proof: By virtue of (21.2), we may assume that R = R' and furthermore that R is a local ring, with maximal ideal m = Jnl . We may assume obviously that 0: M = O. Let Ul , . . . , Ut be a basis for lVI, We prove the assertion by indnc:tion on t. If t = 1, then M is isomorphic to R, and A(a; M; n) = A(a; n). We prove thi:-; ease by indudion on altitude R. If altitude R = 0, then the assertion iN ohvious. Assume that alt.itude R > O. Conflidering R(X) if neceRsary (with a t.ranscendental element X over R), we may assume that R/1I1 eontains infinitely many elements by virtue of (21.4) and (9.10). (22.:3) and (22.5) imply that there is a superficial element. a of a such that. alt.it.ude RlaR = alt.itude R - ] (by virtue of (9.7)). Then 1..( al aR; x) is of degree (altitude R - 1) by our induction assumption. Therefore, we see that A(a; x) is of degree (altitude R) by (22.6), which proves t.he assertion in this case. We consider now the general case. Since 0 = 0: J\!J = ni (0: uiR), there is an Ui , say Ul, such that depth (0:u1R) = altitude R. Then, applying (21.5) with N = u1R, deg (A(a; M; x)) = max {deg A(a; N; x), deg A(a; MIN; x)}. deg A(a; N; x) = alt.itude R by the case where t = 1 and deg A(a; MIN; x) :::; altitude R by induction, and thus we prove the assertion. (22,8)
COROLLARY.
With the same a and R as above, if altitude
a 2:: 1
and if a is a superficial clement of a, then altitude alaR
=
altitude a - 1.
• '11.\1"1'1'111 III
(:'.:'..11) 'l'III':"lll':~'I: .'I.~NIIIII(' Ihai II/(' 11t('OI'r'11I
N (wllt('l'illll 'l'iIlIlN U ((lIrI Itl'. If 111/111:111111 WillI(! dill/NO'I'
((f'
pN*,
).1
((I'
is (( pl'illl(' irll'rli
I/I,('n hniJ.!:hL
/I'IIIINilili/l IwldN fol'
rd' Nand '1/
p '" heighL
~)Jf<
iN (/,
~l*. (,'on..<;equcn,Uy,
nlLiLlitin U HII,il,".h~ U*. VII,'I'!'/w'/'m,(m~, 1/ a i8 an ideal of il, then hniglll, 4l Iwii!:ld, nJ?,* and altitude II = altitude aR*. 1'1'001': 'I'he L!ICorem of transition holds for Rp and by (19.2), WII(HI(~(lA(pR:* ;:c) and A(pRp ;x) have the same degree, and we have height p = height p'. Therefore, it is obvious that altitude R = nlLitude R~ because R* dominates R. The last assertion follows from ( 18.11) and the above result (by virtue of (19.1)).
R:.
II~XERCISES: 1. Prove the converse of (22.2). 2. Let M be a finite module over a semi-local ring R and let u be an ideal of N Hllch that the radical of u is the Jacobson radical of R. Prove that altitude R iH equal to the altitude of the form ring F of R with respect to u and that op. alt M is equal to the operator altitude of the form module of M with respect to a (as an F-module). 3. With R, M and u as above, let b be an element of R. Prove that
}.(u; 1'01'
M/bM; n)
=
}'(u;
M; n) - length (M/(anM:bR»
sufficiently large n.
23. Multiplicities Let R, R ' , a, M, etc. be as in (21.2) throughout this section. Set altitude a. Then the degree of Aw(a; M; x) is at most equal to r by (22.7). Let a be the coefficient of xr in this A-polynomial. Then (r!) a is an integer by (20.8). This integer is called the multiplicity of a with respect to Mover R' and is denoted by fLR'(a; M). R' may be dropped if R' = R. M may be dropped if M = R. Note that J.!R'(a; M) = 0 if and only if altitude (a + (O:M) )/(O:M) < altitude (l. Note also that if M is a ring, then J.!R' (a; M) is either J.!R' (aM) or lIero according as altitude aM is equal to altitude a or not. (21.2) implies that (23.1) J.!R'(a; M) = 2::::> J.!(aR i ; M ® R i ) [R/mi:RI/m'], where i runs over those indices such that height mi = altitude a. 'I' =
(23.2) COROLLARY: Let S be the intersection of the complements of the mi such that height lni = altitude a. Then J.!w(a; M) = J.l-R'(aRs ; M ® Rs). Note that cine can reduce multiplicities to those of the case where R = R' and where R is a local ring by (2:3.1). As an immediate consequence of (21.5), we have an important
711
MIII.'I'II'I,II I I'I'IIoirI
(~l:l.:t) "'IIWllt.i'IM:
(/.IIIi, ,in llll,I'i'il'll/tI.!',
If N
it op.
iN 1/ NI//lll/otill/I'
ali. AI /N
<
Id 11/, 1/1t'11
nll.il.udn U,
t//./'I/. '1/1(: halN:
i-!1I'(ll; N) = i-!w(n; IY/). (2:3.4) COnOI,],A I~Y: If N has a free base al , ... , af and if op. alt 111 /N is less than altitude R, then we have i-!w(a; M) = r}tw(a). In particular, if the finite module M is a ring contained in the total quotient ring of R, then i-!w(aM) = }tw(a). N ext we prove
(23.5) THEOREM: Letting p run over all prime divisors of zero in R such that depth p = altitude R and such that a + p ~ R, we have }tn-(a; M)
=
Lpi-!w((a
+
p)/p).lengthRp(M ® Rp).
Proof: We note first that the vanishing of the right hand side implies that op. aIt M ® Ri < altitude R, and therefore that }tw(a; M) = O. Now we prove the assertion by induction on t = length (M ® Rp). Since the case where t = 0 is proved already, we assume that t > O. Let m be an element of M such that 0: mRp = pRp for one p, say q. Then there is an element c of It which is not in q such that O:cmR = q. Set N = cmR. Then N is isomorphic to R/q, and }tll'(aj N) = }tR'(a; R/q) = }tw((a + q)/q). This equality and our induction applied to M/N proves the assertion by virtue of (2:3.:3). The following lemma is immediate from the definition: (2:1.()) If 0 is an ideal of R such that 0 c a and if a and 0 have the same radical (or, moregeneralty, if altitude 0 = altitude a), then}t",(a; M) :::; }tR'(o; M).
L.
(2:1.7) THEOREM: With 0 as above, assume that J.!(a) }tR'(aj M) = }tR'(o; M). Proof: By the pin (23.5), we have }tea)
=
Lp
}tea
=
}teo). Then
+ p/p) . length R p , }teo) =
Lp }t(o + p/p) . length Rp.
SinceJ.!(o + p/p);:::: }tea + p/p) by (23.6),}t(a) = }teo) implies that J.!(o + p/p) = }tea p/p) for every p. By (23.1) we see, in the same way, that J.!/?'(o + p/p) = i-!w(a + p/p). Therefore, again by (23.5), we h:we the equality J.!R'(aj "~f) = }tR'(o; M).
+
77
1'11,11"1'1111[ III
WI' ndd 111'1'1' Llil' !'oll:;wili/o!: l'I'IIIIU'I,: If '" ~ /I'" 1I11t/ (: 111'1' lit ( fU1'11I '1'111(/ I~r N /1111/1/11 flll'lll //Ilit/llit' 4 II! ,1'1'81/1'l'Iil'I'/,I/, '11)illt '1'1'8/11'1'1 III n, I/II'//. 1l1",(Il; AI) Il""( /1'1"'; (il, op. all, III op. all, (/, 1I,lId ,ill. 'l)((,l'ti(IIi./U/I', aiLiLIIII<' n
L (/"
( ~:\.H)
nlLiLlldn FIV "'lin PI'OO!' iH illlllll'dia(.1' I'; x HllI:h
(lJ
n
l'1'01n
(21.2) and (22.7).
I. LnC !J nllli e h() ideals of R such that depth b > depth e and R. Prove Lh,tC MR,((a &)/0; M/oM) = MW((a (& e)/ e); M/\b elM) = MR,CCa bel/be; M/beM). 1m!)! 1-11-;;;:
LhnL a
+ u 'i"n
+
+
2. ASHume that Mi are finite R-modules and that 0 - t M, M" - t 0 is exact (with suitable homomorphisms). Prove that
+
-t
M2
n
-t ... -t
8. Let R* be the ring REEl M in the principle of idealization. PrOve that MI,:,(a; M) = MwCaR*) - MwCa).
24. System oj parameters We first generalize the notion of system of parameters: Let a be nil ideal of a Noetherian ring R such that depth a = O. Set r = altiLude a. If there are r elements al , ... , ar of a such that a and LaiR Imve the same radical, then we call the set of the ai a system of paramdeI'S of a. The set of r elements bl , ., . , br is called a system of param(~lers of R if depth L biR = 0 and if altitude L biR = r. (9.6) shows that if R is a semi-local ring then the Jacobson radical of R has a H'y8tem of parameters. On the other hand, (9.3) implies that if Lf biR (hi E R) has the same radical with a, then s ::::: r. Therefore, by virtue of the case of system of parameters of a local ring, if Xl , '" , Xr is a H,Ystem of parameters of a, then altitude al(xlR + .,. + xtR) = '/' - t. In this section, we mainly treat the case where a is generated by a system of parameters of a. One should note that the general I,use may be reduced to such a case by virtue of (21.4), (23.2), (23.7) II,nd the following: (24.1) THEOREM: If (R, ml, ... , ms) is a semi-local ring of altitude r, if every Rlmi contains infinitely many elements and if the radical (!f a is the Jacobson radical '5t = mi of R, then there is a system of 7)arameters al , '" , aT of a such that Il (a) = Il ( LaiR). Before proving (24.1), we prove a lemma. (24.2) With the same R, R', S, and a as in (22.6), we have the following:
n
7H
Mill ,'1'11'1,1/ '1'I'IIIH1
11.ll.i(.IIlI(l n/oN (~)
If (( 'is a
11.1 i,i 1.111 In 11- I 811'f/1'/:/ir/o,{ ('1t·11/1·11.!, (~!'
II'lIgL"!!, N/II.U
(:l) II a
n alld U /l.1(.iCll!h~ n
I, 111,'/1,
J.!w(n) -I- InllgLh/I,(O:oH,,).
·i8 a. 8I1.J1I·I:/ic·ia.l demcnt 01 n (f,nd J.!w(a/aR)
·tJ
all.i Clitin n
>
I, lIwn
= J.!/",(ll).
Proof: If a E a\ then an:aR contains an- t for n > t, and "w(a/aR; n) ;::: "R'(a; n) - AR' (a; n - t) for sufficiently large n by (22.6), and we prove (1). (2) and (3) follow from the last assertion in (22.6). We note, by the way, that if altitude alaR = altitude a, then J.!w (a/ aR) :::; J.!R' (a) by the definition of multiplicities (or by (23.3». Now we prove (24.1). We prove the assertion by induction on r. If r = 0, then the empty set is the required system of parameters. Assume that r ~ 1. Let al be a superficial element of a; the existence follows from (22.3). Assume at first that r = 1. Applying (2) ill (24.2), we have lengthR'R/aIR = J.!w(a/aIR) = J.!w(a) + lengthw(O: aIR). Since al is a superficial element of aIR by (22.4), we have by (22.6) that lengthR'R/aIR = J.!w(aIR) + lengthR'(O:aIR), and we have J.!w(a) = J.!w(a;R). Assume now thatr > 1. 'rhenJ.!/t,(a/aIR) = J.!w(a) hy (24.2). By induction, there is a system of parameters I '" ' a2, ' .. , arI of a/aiR such that J.!R,(a/aIR) = MR'( "L.. ai(R/adl». Let ai be elements of a such that a; = ai modulo aIR. We are to prove that al , ... , ar are the required elements. Since a; E a, we have MR'( LaiR) ;::: J.!w(a). On the other hand, by (1) in (24.2) we have J.!1l'( (L aiR)/aIR) ;::: J.!R'( L aiR), whence J.!w(a) = J.!R,(a/aIR) = J.!w(La~(R/aIR» = J.!wC(LaiR)/alR) ;::: J.!R,(LaiR), which implies that J.!w( L a;R) = J.!w(a), and the proof is complete. (24.3) We use the same notation as in (21.2). If a E at and if altitude a/aR = altitude a-I, then Mw(a/aR; M/aM) ;::: t·,uu,(a; M). If al , ... , ar form a system of parameters of a and if ai E ani, then lengthwM/( L aiM) ;::: nl ... n r • J.!R,(a; M). Proof: (22.5) can be generalized to the case of modules by virtue of (1.6), and we have lengthwM/(an + aR)M = lengthR'M/anM lengthwM/(anM:aR). Since a E at, we have length M/(anM:aR) :::; length M/an-tM, and Aw(a/aR; M/aM; n) 2:: AR,(a; M; n) Aw(a; M; n - t), and we have the first result. By a repeated application of the first result, we see that lengthR'M/( aiM) = Mw(O; M/C L aiM» ~ nl ... nr·Mw(a; M), which proves the last assertion.
L
71l
( 'II" I "1'11111, III
(:JI.,I) lI'ill! Ih" N!I,~/I'III
of
Nil 1111'
UN O,bOl'(', ,1/ n 'iN Ihl'!/' J,!",,(Il; AI)
N, U' , 11, (/,nd M
/)(//,(/,1111'/1"1'1-/ 01, '"
/I:
,
(/'",
I/I'/I.("/'(/'[I'd
bl/ (/'
lilllll';I1(",:) .,"
a;'iil! )/(111'" '/I.,,). (LIOMMA 01" LW:II) 1'!"Ool': 'l'hnC 1011I1:CII/,.,/I1 a;'iM ;:::: 'ILl'" nr'J,!W(!l; M) follow/,; 1'1'01\1 (:J,I.:n, alld wn hav~ lim inl" (lengthwM/L aiM)/nl ... nr ;:::: It"" (11; M ). Therefore, we have only to show that (IClII/l:UI1,,,M
/L
lim Nllp (IengthwM/( L afM) )/nl ... nr ::; J,!w(a; M).
L
IJd /I' = /1'" be the form ring of R with respect to a and let G = 0" be the form module of M with respect to a. Set Xi = 2 ((,l modulo a • Then the form module of M/( L a;iM) is a homolIIorphic: image of G/(L xtiG), whence longthwG/(L x;iG) ;:::: 1(~lIgt.hIl'M/( L a;iM), whence it is sufficient to show that
L
lim sup (lengthwG/( L x;iG) )/nl ... nr ::; Itw(F I ·/?; G), I)(~(:ause Itw(a; M) = ItR,(FI·F; G) by (23.8). Thus we may HNsume that F = R, M = G, and ai = Xi. R is then a homomorphic image of the polynomial ring in r indeterminates Xl , . " , XI' over Fo. We prove the ease where M = mR (m E Go) by induction on Inngth Fo. M is isomorphic to R/(O:M). If r = 0, then the assertion il'l obvious, and we assume that r > 0. Assume that length Fo = 1, 'i.e., a is maximal. Since Fo is a field in this case, the Xi must be algebraically independent over Fo because altitude a = r. If O:M = 0, Chen obviously M is isomorphic to the polynomial ring, Itw(a; M) length w Fo , and
longth w M/( =
L
x;iM)
=
lengthRI R/( L xfiR)
length w (Fo[xd/x?lFo[x])
(9 Po ••• (9 Po
=
(Fo[xrl/xrnrFo[xrD nl ... n r • length R, F o ,
und we have the required equality in thiN case. Assume that 0: M ~ 0, and let .r be a homogeneous form of degree, say 8, which is ill O:M (f T" 0). Thell M is a homomorphic image of R/JR. Then Icngthll' M / (L x;'iM) ::; length w R/(Lxi'iR) - lengthw(.fR + L xtiR)/( L Xl'iR). lcngth w R/ ( L Xfi R) = n l . . . nr length R, Fo as was shown above, and length w (fR
+L
x;'iR)/(L x;iR)
=
length w R/((
L xi'iR) :JR)
by (1.5). Since Fo is a field, (L xtiR) :!R C L X;'i- R and therefore length R, R/ ( ( LXi" R) :!R) is not smaller than 8
HO
MIII,'I'll'ldlll'I'lllili
N) • ,. (II, TItIIH
Iilll
HlIll
(1(~llgLh M / (
L
a<;'i M ) ) /UI
' ..
1/",
:::; lim sup (n! ... nr - (n! - s) .. ' (n.r - 8))' ]ollgLh u , FO/'fh ... nr =
and thus we prove this case. Now assume that length Fo let a E Fo be such that length aFo = 1. By induction,
+
lim (lengthIl'M/(aM
L xfiM»/nl ... nr
>
0,
1, and
J.!R,(a; M/aM) ,
=
and
J.!R,(a; aM). Now lim sup (lengthIl' M/( L xfiM) )/nl " . nr =
lim sup [(lengthIl' M/(aM
+
L Xi'iM)
+ lengthIl' aM/CaM n L xfiM)]/n! ... nr :::; J.!Il'(a; M/aM) + lim sup (lengthR,aM/a( L =
x~iM)/n! '"
J.!Il'(a; M/aM)
+ J.!Il'(a;
nr
aM),
this last sum is equal to J.!Il' (a; M) by (23.3). Thus the case where M = mR is proved. Now we prove the general case. Let m!, .. . , ms be a basis for M which are homogeneous. We prove the assertion by induction on s. Sot N = L ~-! mR. lim sup (lengthw M/( L xfiM) )/nl ... nr lim sup (length w M/(N
+
longth w (N
+
:::; J.!w(a; M/N)
L XfiM)
L x~iM)/( L xi'iM»/n! .. , nr
+ lim =
+
sup (lengthR'N/(Lx~'N»ln!'"
J.!R,(a; MIN)
+
J.!R,(a; N)
and we have proved the assertion completely. (24.5)
=
J.!w(a; M), ~
With the same notation as above, we havd nl ... nr·J.!R,(a; M).
COROLLARY:
J.!R,(L ai'R;M)
nr
HI
I'll 11"1' IIilt III
;\lIoi,lll'I' l'OI'OIlIl,I',Y 11'1'
Hllliliid
1'1'11111,1'1\ iN Cill' roilowillJ.(
(:J.I.(\) (!IIItIlI,J,A Ill': lI'ilh llil' I/lila/illll ((8 ((.1111/'1',1)' '/1'1' dn /III/' ((,881(.11/('
llirtl !l /8 {11'IIITUlt'd (1/1 1/ 8!Jslnll I~r 11((./,(/:/l1('/1'/,8 1m!' 1I.8S/WU: lIwl n I'm./I'd bll III , ••• , ((." 'W';II!. S > 'I' al(.iLllIln n. 'I'lwn
lilll (11~1\p;j,h"" M/(La;"M))/nl'" Proof: Hilll~n
n8
'';8 {/('I/,.-
= O.
have only (,0 "how that lim sup (length M / ... nr ~ 0, in tho same way as in the proof of (24.4), WI' lIl:1y tLHHUme that R is the form ring F = L Fn of R with respect Co (1. Tlwll lJ;f is a modulo over the polynomial ring Fo[X! , ... , X,] ill illdeterminates Xi with operation such that Xim = aim for allY /II. ( 111, and in this sense, the multiplicity of M is zero, and thm; we PI'OVO tho assertion. N ow we prove an important result.
(L at';M) )/nl
Wp
(24.7) THEOREM: With the same R, R', M, and u as above (which are Ihe same as in (21.2)), assume that u is generated hV a system oj param('tors a!, .. , , a r • For an arbitrarily fixed integer s such that 0 ~ s ~ '1', ,w:/, 0 = L~ aB. Then, letting ~ run over all min1:mat prime divisurs of b ::;uch that height ~ = s and such that depth ~ = r - s, we have the following formula: J.!II'(U; M) = J.!R'(u + ~/~) ·J.!(oRp ; M ® Rp).
Lp
(ASSOCIATIVITY FORMULA)
Proof: For all arbitrary natural numher t, set Ot = L~ a:R, ai,t = Ot and ci = Liai,t(R/ot). Then we see by (n.5) that f..!1l'(ci; M/otM) = L: J.!ll'(ci + ~*/p*) . length (lVi/o t) ® (R/ot)p*, where p* nms over all prime divisors of zero in R/o t sueh that depth ~* = r - s. Therefore, letting ~' run over all minimal prime divisors of Ot of depth r - s, we have ni modulo
J.!wCc*t ; M/otM)
=
Lp'J.!w(U+ p'/p') . length M ® (Rp.jotRp')'
On the other hand by the lemma of Lech (24.4), we have limn~"" (length w M/Cot + L;+IafR)M)/nr-s = J.!w(c*; M/11 t M). Therefore, we have that J.!w(u; M)
=
limt,n~oo length w (M/Cot
+
L;+! afR)M)/t"'n
rs
lim t~oo (limn~oo (length w M/ ( 0 t + L; +I afR) M) / t n s = limt~oo Lp'J.!w(U p'/p') (length JJ;[ ® Rp,/otRp,)/t . S
=
r
S )
+
By (24.4) and (24.6), we see that lim (length
1~1
® Rpoj 0 tR p' ) / t
S
MIII,'I'II'I,II'1'I'1111I1
i~ 1'1/11/1,1
1.0 ('iLlH'I' p(
~I' iN ('(l'tHl 1.11
[,Ull' ; II/ C·) H\I'I
N III' 1I0!., 1I,lId i.lH'I,,,j'1I1'1' WI'
III'
~,I'I'II 1I,1'1',oI'tiillll:
"l'lIvn
II.I·j IIl,jll:lil.
(.ill' nHr-lI'I'j,illll.
25. Macaulay rings We Nay thaI. all ideal (1 oj' a l'illg iN 1:,~(}l!alh!! if nVl'l'y pi'ill\(~ diviNoI' P of a hm.; d(~pth equal to d(~pth a. It iN obviouN I.hal. all i:'iOlmL!ty ideal cannot have any imbedded prime divisor. We Nay thuL a Nemi-I()(~al ring R is unmixed if the zero ideal in the completion of R i" iNobathy .. It is known that there are local integral domains which arc not unmixed; an example is given in the Appendix, Example 2. (25.1) Let R be a semi-local ring with Jacobson radical m. If thcre is an ideal a of R such that the radical of a is m and such that the zero ideal in the form ring F = L Fn of R with respect to a is isobathu, then R is unmixed. Proof: Let R* be the completion of R. Then F is the form ring of R* with respect to aR*. Assume that there is a prime divisor p* of zero in R* such that depth p* < altitude R = altitude R* (by (17.12)). Set p' = L (p* an)/(p* an+I). Then p' is an ideal of F and F/p' is the form ring of R*/p* with respect to (ItR* + p*)/p*. Therefore depth p* = altitude (aR* + p*)/p* = altitude (FIF + p')/p' by (2:1.8), and this altitude is equal t.o depth p' by (14.5). Since p* is a prime divisor of zero, there iN an element a ~ 0 of R* Nllch that. ap* = 0. Let at be the a-form of a. Then we have p'a' = 0, whence p' consists only of zero divisors, whence p' is contained in a prime divisor q' of zero in F, whence depth q' :::::. depth p' = depth p* < altitude R, and the zero ideal of F is not isobathy. Therefore we complete the proof. A system of parameters al , ., . , aT of a Noetherian ring R is called a distinct system of parameters of R if Jl- ( LaiR) = length R / ( LaiR). (Note the inequality }t(L aiR) ::::; length R/L aiR, which was proved in (24.3).) A Macaulay local ring is a local ring which has a distinct system of parameters. A Noetherian ring R is called a locally Macaulay ring if Rm is a Macaulay local ring for every maximal ideal m of R. A N oethorian ring R is called a Macaulay ring if it is a locally Macaulay ring and if height m = altitude R for every maximal ideal m of R.
n
n
(25.2) THEOREM: A system of parameters al , ... ,aT of a Noetherian ring R is distinct if and only if, in the form ring F = L F,. of R with
('11,11"1'11)1(, III
I'/'NIH'I'I 10
L
n
fI,li',
.1'/
hl'll/('rr/ill /1Ir!r'fI/'IIr/r'lIl Ol'r'/, 1"11
1'1'001': 1,1'1. I'
L
(II,' 1IIIiIlilio 0")
(i
I, ... ,
I') //1'/' 111(/1'
"~/(1.
I'" lin I.lin liOIlIOJ,!;I'III'III1H polYllolllial I'illg ill X" OV!"I' N/n. Tlinll p.(I',/') C~ 11'lIg1.II N/Il hy (:JO.·ll. 1,1'1. (i' 1)(' 1.I1I' hOlllolllol'pli iH11I 1'1'0111 I) Oil 1.0 F Hlleh I.hal. ril( .\';) .1'; , :l.Ild lid, II I.n I.III~ k(,I'llId or e/>. W(~ lIav(~ 11'llgth /(/11 = /I({',/') C~ p.(l',/'; II) p.(I',/'; F) by (:~:~.:)). Obviow-;Iy, P.(J'IJ>; F) iH 1'1111:1,1 to M( .r/P), whidl iH eqlml to 101(0.) by (2:3.8). Therefore It'IIJ,!;1.11 N/n 101(11) if and ollly if p.(J\J>; n) = O. Assume that n 7"" o tl.lld Id J be a homogeneous element of n. Multiplying a suitable llil'lnclI!; or Po if necessary, we may assume that fm = 0 with a IIIlI,ximaJ ideal l1l of Po. Then O:fP = mP, and fP is isomorphic to 1'/1111>, whenceM(PIP; 11) 2: M(PIP; fP) = 101 (PIP; (Po/m) [XI, ... , X,.I) = 1. Therefore, M(PIP; n) = 0 if and only if n = 0, and the tl.H,~I~l'tion is proved. We have by (25.1) and (25.2) the following: illti!"j,I'I·llIillal.l'K .\', , .,. ,
L
+
7=
(:25.3) COROLLARY: If a semi-local ring R has a distinct system of 7111:mmeters al , ... , aT of the Jacobson radical of R, then R is unmixed.
(21).4) THEOREM: A system of parameters al , ... , aT of the J acoblion r'adical of a semi-local ring R is distinct if and only if ai is not a
~I'I'O divisor modulo L~-I ajR for each i = 1, 2, ... , r. Proof: Set 0. = L~ aiR. We prove the assertion by induction on r.
II' r = 0, then the assertion is obvious because the empty set is a diHLinct system of parameters of a ring of altitude zero. Assume that 'I' ::::: 1. Assume at first that the ai form a distinct system of parameters. Thon, length R/a 2: M(a/aIR) 2: p.(a) by (24.3), whence the equaliCieH hold, and the ai modulo aIR (i = 2, ... , r) form a distinct H'yHtem of parameters of R/aIR. Therefore, by induction, ai is not a v,nl'O divisor modulo L~-I ajR for each i = 2, ... , r. Thus it is suffiI'ient to show that al is not a zero divisor, which is obvious by virtue of (25.2). Conve~sely, assume that each ai is not a zero divisor modulo I ajR. Then al is not a zero divisor and, by induction, the ai modulo aIR (i 2: 2) form a distinct system of parameters of R/aIR. L(~t F = L F n be the form ring of R with respect to 0., let XI, ... ,Xr 1)(\ indeterminates and lete/> bethe homomorphism from P = (R/a) [Xl 2 Ollto F such that e/>(X i ) = ai modulo 0. • Since the ai modulo aIR U 2: 2) form a distinct system of parameters of R/ aIR, the form ring /1'* of R/aIR with respect to a/aIR may be identified with P/XIP,
Li-
HI
~1111
11'11'1 ,\1 '1'1'1 WI
wllil'lI HiIlIWH 1,1111.1. 1.11(' 111'1'11(,1 II III' (I' in 1'!llIin.illl,d ill .\' 1/' /1,11(1 Llia!. /1"1' idl'lliili('d wilit /I'/,(.\' 1/'). WI' 11/1,1'(' IIIII,\' 10 1'1'11\'(' liI/I,1 /I 0. ;\C:C:lllllilll!; Liw ('old,l':u'Y, 11'1, f 111\ H h(/IIII1I!:I'III'OIiH nll'lIlI'lIll1l' 1\ : .\'1/' wit i!'.! I ic: 11111. ill It; HI\('h all I nxic:I:-;, I'('(·II.IIHI', ollu'l'wiH(' II X,II hy (H.lI), wh('III'(, II ~, () by (:{. I ()). LI'L rI h(\ Lit(' d('I!;I'I\I' IIi' f :I.lld It·L (I 1,1' an dnmenL of a'l :-;llI:h thnt ¢U) = (, modllio n"II. XI.!' ( II illiplil:H I.ha l, d 2 alU E a -I- • Starting with b = VI, we I:Olll'ltrlli:C a Call1·hy H('l]ltnll('(' t (un) such that b t - b l +1 E ad-l- and such that alb t E ItI 1\-1 at; foliowH: iH
When bi is defined, let g E P be a homogeneous form of degree d + i i + 1 such that ¢(g) = alb i modulo ad + +2. Since the kernel of tho natural map from F onto F* is¢(XIP), we see that g E XIP, whence there is a homogeneous form g' of degree d + i such that g = Xlg'. Let c be an element of ad +i such that ¢(g') = c modulo ad+i+l. Then d i 2 alb i == alC modulo a + + • Set bi+l = bi - c. Then bi - bi +1 = c E d d a +\ alb i +l = alb i - alc E a +i+2, and bi +l is defined. Now, let b* be the limit of the sequence (b i ) in the completion R* of R. Then we have alb* = O. Since al is not a zero divisor in R hence in R* by (lS.1), d we have b* = 0, which is a contradiction to bi ~ a +\ and the assertion that n = 0 is proved, whence the ai form a distinct system of parameters.
(25.5) THEOREM: If ai, ... , arform a distinct system of parameters of a N oethcrian ring R and if a system of parameters b] , . . . , br of R generate an ideal 0 which has the same radical as a = aiR, then the b i form a distinct system of parameters. Proof: By the nature of multiplicities, we may assume that R is a semi-local ring, and that the radical m of a is the .Jacobson radil:al of R. Note that every maximal ideal of R has height r by (253). We note also that the distinctness is not the property of the members of system of parameters but is the property of the ideals generated by them. We prove the assertion by induction on r. If r = 0, then a = 0 = 0 and the assertion is obvious; if r = 1, then, since R is unmixed, bl is not a zero divisor, which proves the assertion by (25.4). Assume that r > L By the above remark, we may assume that aiR blR has height 2. By (25.4), the ai modulo alR(i ::::: 2) form a distinct system of parameters, whence by induction, every system of parameters of m/alR is distinct, which means that every system of parameters of m which has al as.a member is distinct. Since height aiR blR = 2, there is a system of parameters of m having al and bl as members, and it is distinct by the above result. Hence, applying
L
+
+
1'11.\ 1"1' 1'1 It III
111(' IIIHII'I' 10 {" 1IIId 10 liliH IHHj, H,VHj,I'1I1
01'
or 1'11.1'11 II 1('1.1 '1'H,
WI' HI'I' I.hll,1, Hlly
iH diHj,illl'l., :l.lld 1.11(' h, 1'01'111 H di,..,l.illld, HYHLcll1 01' pal'alllni.('I'H. WI' HHy LIm!. Lill' I/.I/.III:I:./'(,r/I/.(!SS f/t,(!(}l'cm holdN ill a Nootherian ring R il' III(' I'ollowing iH L"np: II' all ideal n of R it:: generated by s elements and il' hl~ighL n ~~, S (N I:all bo ally non-negative integer) then every prime diviNol' 01' It iH oj' i\(light s. (intilw Lhit:: terminology, we can state the following characterization or 11)(:ally Macaulay rings.
H,YHII'1I1
PII.I'/l.IIIl'i.I'I'H
or
III whi('h IlnH
h,
HH II. 1111'1111>1'1'
ill 1'1I,l'l.il'IIII1,I'
(:,),:).0)
THIDOREM:
A Noetherian ring R is a locally Macaulay ring
U(lnd only if the unmixedness theorem holds in R. Pl'oof: Assume first that the unmixedness theorem holds in R, let 111 be an arbitrary maximal ideal of R. Let aI, ... , aT (r = lil'ight 111) be elements of 111 such that height I:~ aiR = s for any N ::; r; the existence follows from (D.5). The validity of the unmixodIII'HH theorem implies that each ai is not a zero divisor modulo ajR, ",hellee modulo ajRm , too. Therefore the ai form a distinct sysLI'IlI of parameters of Rm , and R is a locally l\1:aeaulay ring. Con1'1'I'Hdy, assume that R is a locally Macaulay ring, and assume that 11011 ideal a is generated by s elements aj, .. , , as and that height n = s. Let 111 be an arbitrary maximal ideal of R such that a C 111. 'l'lwn there is a system of parameters of Rm which contains the ai as a /'wiJt::et. By (25.5), we see that snch a system of parameters is necesHHl'ily distinct, whence Rill/aRm has a distinct system of parameters hy (25.4). It follows that R»,! aRIIl is unmixed by (25.3), whenco nN,,, has no imbedded prime divisors. Sinee this is true for any 111 I:ontaining a, we see that every prime divisor of a is of height s by virtue of (9.3), and the unmixedness theorem holds in R; and the pl'oof is eomplete. N ext we prove a eharacterization of Macaulay rings. IIolld
I:{
I:;
(25.7) THEOREM: A Noetherian ring R is a Macaulay ring if and only if one of the following conditions is satisfied: (1) Every system of parameters a1 , ••• , ar of R is distinct. (2) If maximal ideals 111, 111' (111 may be equal to 111' if R is a local 'I"/ng) of R are given, then there is a distinct system of parameters al , ... , ... , ar of R such that clIcry ai is in 111 n m'. Proof: Assume at first that R is a Macaulay ring. Let aI, ..• , a r be a system of parameters of R and let 1111, •. , 1118 be all of the prime
HO
M111i/'II'I.lI'I'I'llllIl
L
diviHOI'H III' n t.lld!'
U,
H,li! ,
WIII'III'n
1I,h',
Hilll'I'
\VIII'III'!' !.Ill' II, 1'111'111
hy
(~:1.1
h'
I\,
iH II.
1\1 11,1'/1,1 Ii 11..1'
diHt.illl'l. ~I,YHklll
I'ill/l:, IH'i/l:ill. III,
or
lI.il.i
,,11,1'1I,/lI('I.I'I'H ill l'il.I'1i
)
and (I) iH provnd. II, iK oi>viollK thuJ, (I) implinK (:2). AKHlllllP (,haL (~)
holds good. H iN i'Hlff1(:inllt (,0 show that R is a Mal:au'lay ring. Ln(, rat, ... , ar \ be a distinet system of parameters and set It = a,;R. Theil !-l(a) = length R/a = L length Rn/aR n , where 11 rum, through all prime divisors of a. On the other hand, by (23.1), )L( a) = L !-l( aR n,), where 11' runs through all prime divisors of a such that height 11' = r. Rince length Rn./aR n, 2: !-l(aR n,) by (24.3), we see that height 11 = r for any 11 and that the ai form a distinct system of parameters of R" . Hence (2) implies that height 111 = height 111' and that Rm , R"" are Macaulay local rings for any two maximal ideals m and m', whence R is a Macaulay ring. Thus the proof is completed. The following remark is immediate from the definition: (25.8) A semi-local ring R is a Macaulay ring or a locally Macaulay ring if and only if so is the completion of R. On the other hand: (25.9) If R is a locally Macaulay ring, then every ring of quotients of R is also a locally Macaulay ring. Proof: By the definition, it is sufficient to prove that Rp is a Macaulay ring for any prime ideal p of R. Let r be the height of ).l and let al , ... , a,. be elements of ).l such that Lf ajR is of height s for any s :::;; r (by (9.5». Since the unmixedness theorem holds in R, ai is not a zero divisor modulo L~-l ajR for each i, and therefore the ai form a distinct system of parameters of Rp by virtue of (25.4), which proves the assertion. The following is a generalization of the classical unmixedness theorem, because a field is obviously a Macaulay ring:
L
(25.10) THEOREM: Let Xl, '" , Xn be algebraically independent elements over a Noetherian ring R. If R is a locally Macaulay ring then so is the polynomial ring R[x). Proof: The general case follows easily from the case where n = ], and we assume that n = 1. Xl is denoted by x. It is sufficient to prove that if m is a maximal ideal of R[x), then R[xl m is a Macaulay loeal ring. Set \l = m R. Then Rp is a Macaulay loeal ring. In order to
n
'/J,7
I'll ;\1"1' 1<111 '"
P"OI'I' 1,IiI'IIHH('I'j,ioll 1'01' 141'111' , wn IIllly IIHI~I"lll! Lilli!, N· Nv , Ill/pNI,r! If'( /I. IIl/I.~jlll/l.l idl'lloi of (N/p)I,/'/' WIWIII'1! 11I/~J/4rj iH I!;nlH1l':tLnn 11011 1~11~lllnlll. of 111 HIWh Chat f' = J modulo 1.lNI,I'I, I,('/, 1/( , '" , (1", he a diHLiliet HYHtmn of parameters of R = R~, By ((i.!:l) alii! (2GA), we H()I~ that aI, ", , a r , f form a distinct sys1.('111 of PHI':t.IlWCOl'H of Il[:t:]", , and the assertion is proved, (2r), II) (JOItOJ,LAHY: Let Xl, , ' , , Xn be algebraically independent ('/I"lIw'nls over a Macaulay ring R, Then R[Xl, "" Xn] is again a Maennla,Jj nng if and only if there is no prime ideal 13 of R such that (I) P is not maximal and (2) there is an element a EE 13 such that
(Rlp)[l/(a modulo 13)]
'ill lhe .field of quotients of Rip, I 'I'oof: The non-existence of 13 as above is equivalent to the statement 1.11/1,(; every maximal ideal m of the polynomial ring R[x] lies over a maxi11111.1 ideal n of R, by virtue of (14.10). The proof of the if part: Since height n = n lieil!;ht min = n by (14.5), we see that height m 2: n ",ll.iLude R. Since altitude R[x] = n altitude R by (9.10), we see 1,linL height m = altitude R[x] for every maximal ideal m of R[x], ",,,d the assertion is proved by (25.10). The proof of the only if part:
+
+
+
AHHume the existence of such a p. Hence if follows that there is a Illltximal ideal m of R[x] such that n = m R is not maximal. Applyilll!; the above observation to m(Rn)[x], we see that height m = linight n + n. Therefore height m < altitude R + n = altitude R(x], whence R[x] is not a Macaulay ring. The following two remarks are obvious by (25.4) and (12.9). (25.12) A Notherian ring R of altitude 1 is a Macaulay ring if and only if no maximal ideal is a prime divisor of zero. Any Noetherian ring of altitude zero is a Macaulay ring. (25.13) A normal Noetherian ring R is a Macaulay ring if every 'maximal ideal of R is of height 2, We prove furthermore that;
n
(25.14) THEOREM: A regular local ring is a normal Macaulay ring. Proof: Let (R, m) be a regular local ring and let Xl, .. , , Xr be a I'ogular system of parameters of R. Then the form ring F = L:: Fn is lI:onerated by r elements over the field Fo = Rim, and altitude F = r by (23.8). Therefore the r generators must be algebraically independent, whence R is a Macaulay ring. That R is a normal ring follows from the following lemma:
~IIII,'I'II'I'/'
(:.l{,.1 r,) /'1'1 ( h~. III I II(' f/ /I/f'ft! I'IIIf!,
mil/!.
'/'f'S/JI'I'i
/1/ III
1:8 III/,
il/lf'r/I'II.!
'1'1'11':11
/f
Ihf' /01'11/ I'il/f! '"
dl/I/Illill, I//('I/
II'
~ /1'" f~r Ii.
IN fl/I il/lf'(/I'I/.( dl/I/llt'://..
If /I' '1;8 (J, 'fI,o'I"rnnl
)',:",U, I,hf'''' Ii. i8 n 1/,11/,1/1/1.1 1'11/(/, Proof: ab = 0 (a, II ( U) illlpiiPH 11,'1>' () il' ft' nlld // aI'(' /11·1'01'1111' of a and b. Therefore we have pl'OV(~U !.Iw find, :LHH('I'Lioli. NnxL wn HKsume that F is normal. Assume that a/h (a, !J ( N) iN illkgmi ,)V(\J' R and let c 'F 0 be an element of the conductor c of R ill Ula/hl, Wn are to prove that a E bR + mn for any n, by inductioIl on n. W(~ may assume that a, b are in m, Then the above is true for n = 1, Assume that a E bR + mn, i.e" a = bq + I' withq E R, I' E 111n. ItiH n sufficient to show that a E bR + 111n+1. If I' E m +\ then there iH n 1 nothing to prove, and we assume t.hat I' EE m + , Since alb = q + (r/b), we have c(r/b)m E R for any m, i.e., cr = b"'d m wit.hd m E R, m Let c', 1", b' and d~ be m-forms of c, 1', b, dm rei:lpeetively. Then cr = bmd m implies t.hat c'r,rn = b,md~ or c'r,m = 0 or b,md~ = O. Since II' is an integral domain, we see that c'r,m = b,md~ , whence c'(r'/b')'" E F. Since this is true for any natural number m and since F it.; tt normal Noetherian ring, we have 1" /b' E F. Then theI'e ii:l all element e of R such that the Til-form of e it.; 1" /b', which means that eb modulo m n+1 = 1", whence I' - eb E 111n+1, and, siIlf'e a = b(q + e) + (I' eb), we get a E bR + llln+l. Thus a E bR + mn for any n, and a C nn (bR + 1Il") = bR (by lG.7)), whence alb E R. ThuH the normality ifl proved. Another interest.ing re:mlt on regular loeal ring is the following rtl
(25.16) THEOREM: Assume that (R, lll) is a regular local ring and that a ring R' is a finite R-module and furthermore that R is a subring of R'. Then R' is a free module over R if and only if R' is a Macaulay ring. Proof: Let Yl, ... , Ys be clements of R' whose residue classes modulo mR' form a linearly independent base of R' /lllR' over R/m. Then R' = RYi by the lemma of Krull-Azumaya. Let Xl , ... , Xr be a regular system of parameters of R. R' is a Macaulay ring if and only if t.he Xi form a distinct system of parameters of R', or equivalently J.l( mR') = length R' /mR' namely
L:
J.lR(mR')
=
length n R'/mR' = s.
Let F be a free R-module with free base Y 1 , ••• , Y s and let 11 be the kernel of the homomorphism ¢ such that ¢( Y i ) = Yi. If n 'F 0, n contains a free module. Therefore
(I"
,11"1' 1111/, III
/1.1111 11)(· (''Illldily IilildH if /I,IIIIIIIIi.l' il' II 0, i.f'., h~' iH 1'1'('(\. 'I'IIIIH I.lill Pl'olll' i~4 "Olllpll'l,('. ()II !.Ii(' 1I1,1i('1' 111L11d, (.JI(' rollowill/!; iH oilvio\lH I' 1'0 III I.hn dd;llil.;oll: (~;).17) ;1.~SIlIl/(· llinl, Ihl' 111.1'/1/,11111 ItJ' 1/'(/'/I..~ill;/in holds/orllu! N/ll'/hl'r /11/1 /'':n(f,~ N n/l.d U'. '1'//./'/1. U is /l, Jl/llmu/nll riJ/,1/ ,,;r nnd (In/lI,;r .~/)':.~' h~'. Wn :t,dd 1\t'1'(~ I.ltn following; LI\(~()I'nllJ, wltidt iH a (!ol.'oll:t,I''y 1.0 (~!i.I;)): (~!i.I~) 'l'III<:
Xl, .,. , Xs
Ea
nlld :-meh that the residue dasses of Xs+I , ••• I'(~glliar system of parameters of Ria. Since
1).1' (:25.14) or (25.15), we see that
II =
, Xr
modulo
a form
;1,
I:i xiR is a prim(~ ili('n.l I:f x.Jl, which eomplnLPH
I."(~ proof. /I;XERCISE: Assume that an ideal a of a Macaulay ring R is generated by (lluments and that height a = '1'. Prove that Ria is a Macaulay ring.
l'
26. Definition of syzygies Lnt R be a NooLlwriall rillg, lIHlmlly a 10enl ring, thl'OlIgholll; LlliH ~(i(:Li()n.
Ld Ul , •.. ,Un be elements of an R-module M and let U1 , ... , fJ" I>n indeterminates. The set N of elements L aiU i (ai E R) of (,\W free module generated by the U i such that L aiUi = 0 is an R-modulp, whence it is a finite R-module. This last R-module N is ealled t1w 1'(dation module of the elements Ui. Note that (L RUi)/N iH nal;lIl'HlIy isomorphic to RUi' When the Ui form a minimal baHiH fol' M, the relation module N of the Ui is called a relation module of M. Nol;e that, in this last case, if R is a local ring with maximal ideal Ill, I,hull N C L mU i as is easily seen by virtue of (5.3).
L
(26.1) THEOREM: If R is a local ring, then a relation module of (~ II£'/Jcn finite R-modtde M is unique up to isomorphism. If VI, '" , 71" ,,;,~ ~ basis for M, then the relation module N of the Vi is the direct sum oJ IIIl! relation module of M and a free module. Proof: The uniqueness of the relation module of M is an immediate consequence of (5.3). As for the last assertion, we may assume by virtue of (5.3) that VI , " . , Vm is a minimal basis for M. Let VI, . . . , ... , Vn be indeterminates. For each i > m, there is a relation II.j = Lf=1 aijVj , whence the relation module N of the Vi contains ILII element fi = Vi aij V j . Since the V,: are free, we see that )'11/+1, '" ,fn generate a free submodule N* of N. On the other hand, N contains the relation module N** of VI, •.. , Vm , and N** is the I'olation module of lYI. We are to prove that N is the direct sum of N** and N*. It is obvious that N* N** = O. Therefore it is sufficient 1,0 show that N is generated by N* and N**. Let g = L biV i be 1111 arbitrary element of N. Then 9 - L;':+1 b,ji is in RV1 RVm , whence the element is in N**. Thus N = N* + N** and the /tssertion is proved.
L:7'
n
+ ... +
[91]
'1'111'1 '1'1111111111' 1)/1'
By Vil'Llln of (~(;'I), WIII'Ii ,,~ iH
/I,
1\,,~,\'IIIil:r\
IOI'/I,II'ill/l: lVI' 1~/l.1I "1'lilll' 1.111' lIoLioli
of lJyzygie8 of fini(.c modl/II~ Hi"! I'ollowi"!: Let R be a local ring and let M hl~ a filliLn N-IIIOd"II'. Tlan mil i"!Y:'.yJ.!;Y of M is M itself; when the ith syzygy Zi of M iH ddillnd, Lito (i + I) Lia syzygy of M is the relation module of Z i. The iLh Hy:'.ygy of 111 i,.., denoted by syzi M; if we want to express that M is an R-moduIC', WI' write syz~ M. Even if R is not a local ring, we can give the following notion of a weak syzygy sequence of a finite R-module JJ![: A sequence of finitl~ R-modules Zi (i = 0, 1, 2, '" ) is a weak syzygy sequence of M if Zo = M and if each Zi( i 2:: 1) is the relation module of a finite basis for Zi-l . Zi is called a weak ith syzygy of M. (26.2) If M = Zo, ZI, ... , Zn, .. is a weak syzygy sequence of a finite module M, then, with an arbitrary, multiplicatively closed subset S of R such that ~ S, Zo ® Rs , ZI ® R s , .. , , Zn ® Rs, ... is a weak syzygy sequence of M ® Rs over Rs . Proof: Let 11,1, •• , , Un be a basis for Zm such that the relation module of the Uj is Zm+l . Let N be the relation module of the
°
Ui
® 1
(1 E R,s).
It is obvious that Zm+l ® Rs is contained in N. In order to prove the converse inclusion, let La~ Ui be an el(ement of N, i.e.,
Since the elements of S are mapped to units, we may assume that a; are images of elements ai of R. Then L a:(u ® 1) = implies that L aiUi is in the kernel K of the natural map from Minto M ® Rs , whence there is an element s of S such that L a;sui = 0, and L Ui E Zm+l ® Rs . Thus N = Z",+1 ® Rs , and the assertion is proved. (26.3) When R is a local ring, any weak itk syzygy Z of a finite module M is the direct sum of the ith syzygy of M and a free module, hence the relation module of Z coincides with syzi+l M. The proof is immediate from (26.1). From now on, let R be a local ring. A finite module M is said to be of homological dimension n (over R) if n + 1 is the smallest i such that syzi M = 0. In symbols, we write hd M. = n; when we want to express "over R" explicitly, we write hd R • The definition implies that: (26.4) Let M be a finite module over the local ring R. Then: (1)
°
a;
if fll/d (llIluif III
1111 III
0,
(~)
lid M
() '(/' (t'Iul only if M
(:l) if M ~ 0 and if F is a free //lOr/II/I', 1/11'11 II(I M = hd(M E9 F), (4) hd(syzi M) = max(-l, lid III - ',;) anti (Ii) ~f Z is a weak ith syzygy of M then hd Z is equal /(1 hd M - i for i ::; hd M; it is equal to either or -1 for other i. III
II ,1'1'1'1' 1I1I1//ltll' tll)il'/'('II/ fl'/I/II, Z(:/'II,
°
(:W.Ii) THEOHEM: If a submodule N of a finite module M is given, Ihl'//', for each n, there is a weak nth syzygy Zn of M and an isomorphism If from syzn N into Zn such that ZnlCT(syzn N) is isomorphic to
syzn (MIN). I'roof: By the definition of syzygies, we have only to prove the case wltnrc n = 1. Let nl , ... ,nr be a minimal base of N and let m~ , ... , , .. , m: be a minimal base of MIN. Let mi be an clement of M such l,hnL m: = mi modulo N. Let Zl be the relation module of the base nl, ... , n r , ml, .. , , m., of M. L aiMi E syzl (MIN) if and only II' L a,m: = 0, that is, L aim, E N, or equivalently, L aimi + bjnj = with some lij E ii, whence syzl (MIN) is the image of :11 by the map ¢ such that ¢( aiMi + L bjNj) = L a;lYf; . The Iwmel of ¢ is the set of clements of Zl of the form L bjNj , which is obviously the relation module of N, i.e., syzl N. Thus the proof is I'omplete.
2:
°
L:
(26.6) COHOLLAHY: Among the homological dimensions of N, M, and M IN, one of the following must hold: (1) hd N ::; hd M = hd( MIN), (~) hd 111 ::; hd N = hd(MIN) - 1, or (3) hd(MIN) < hd M lid N. Proof: Let Z" be a weak syzygy of lYI sueh that Zn/syz n N ~'yzn (MIN). Case I : ASimmethat hd N is minimal among homologieal dimensions of M, N, MIN, and let n be hd N. Then Zn+l is isomorphic to syzn+l (MIN). Therefore, either hd M = hd (MIN) 01' ~'yzn+1 AI = 0. In the latter ease Zn+l is a free module, and therefore we see that, in ease I, either (1) or (2) holds. Case II: Assume that hd M is minimal among the homological dimensions of M, N, MIN, nnd set m = hd M. Since syzm M is free, syzm N is the relation module oj' a base of syzm (M)N), henee either both syzm (MIN) and syzm N nrcfree and different from zero or hd (syzm N) = hd (syzm+l (MIN)), nnd therci'ore either (1) or (2) holds. Case III: The remaining case iH where hd (MIN) is smaller than both hd Nand hd M. Set n' = hd (MIN). Then Zn'+l/syzn'+l N = 0, i.e., Zn'+l = syzn"I'1 N. By
III
'1'11111 '1'1111111111' 1111' IIH,I'IIIIIIII
11111' II,HHI II II pl,ioll
wn ItIl.V(~
!.ImL hd (II/ IN)
iH 1111111,\\1'1'1,\11\.11\1111,,,
lid N /1.1111 ltd nI,
(:1). '/'ItII14 I,hl' prolll' iH 1·lIllIpll'I",.
11;~(II:ItI'INI':H: LI1L
U 111,11, N"dhnrill,lI l'illJl; II.lld 1'''"Hid,,1' Iillil.n 11i",IiIl"H OVIll' ,,~. modliin Ai iH II, '1II'IIjIW/'il'l: 'lllIIt/III" il' M Iiii N", iH 1'1'111, 1'01' IUlY maximal idlJILl 111 or u. Th" hOl//,o[o!/,£I:/J,1 tlhll{;II,,~io/(, of II IIIOdlll" M iH d"fillnd 1.0 lie Lhe maximum (or tho HII\lrmnllm) Ill' 1i0IllOlogil::d
W"
HHy LIla" 1J,
27. Change oj Rings (27.1) Tm]OREM: Let M be a finite module over a local ring (R, m) and let x be an element oj m. Assume that x is not a zero divisor with respect to both Rand M. Then for every natural number n, there is a natural isomorphism between (syz n M) I x (syz n M) and SYZ~/XR (MlxM).
Proof: Using the induction on n, we have only to prove the caSe where n = 1. Let Ul, ... , Ur be a minimal base of M. Then u' = Ui modulo xM form a minimal base of MlxM. L a:U i E syzl (MlxM) if and only if L a:u~ = 0, i.e., L aiUi E xM with ai such that a: = ai modulo xR, namely L aiUi = L xbiui. Thus the map ¢ such that ¢( a,U i ) = (ai modulo xR) U i is a homomorphism from syzl M onto SYZ1/XR MlxM. The kernel of ¢ is the set of elements xaiUi such that xaiUi = 0, whence aiUi = because x is not a zero divisor with respect to M. Th us the kernel of ¢ is x (syz 1 lrf), and the assertion is proved. We say that a sequence of elements Xl, ... ,X r of the maximal ideal m of a local ring R is an M -sequence, M being an R-module, if Xi is not a zero divisor with respect to M/L~-l xjM for each i = 1, '" , r. Then we have:
L
L
L
L
L
°
(27.2) COROLLAIty: Let M be aflnite module over a local ring (R, m). If Xl, '" , Xs is an I11-sequence and at the same time an R-sequence, then hd R }J![ = hdR/oM I aM with II = L xiR.
('III 1"1'1'111 I V
(~7,:11 'l'1111:IIIII':M:
/,rl ill III' (/ ./illill' IIlIIdll/I'
(/1/1//1'1,/'111' II//I'!I'IIII'III
Id
III /I'hil'" iN
/101 ill
III'/'I' /I /lIl'Itll'ill(/
(/t', 1111
III", ,lssllI/lI'.I'III'I!lI'l'lIllil'I'I!Jn{
/11111/ '::/'I'II dipislIl' ':/1. /i', Ihol. M -i8 l'onlrt.i/II'r!':1I I/, .1'/'1'/1 U/.oduk F ,,~{ Ii ( {I" ' , , , (I,. Iwi/l(/ I/, fl'(,(, 111/,81 1 I~( /1') IUUf, thai, ,rF ~ JI,l ~ 111/1'. '/'lil' II , fol' I'lli'll. I/I/./I/i/,(/./ 1/.1/./11111"1'1/., HYY." ill m'fl, hi: imlwddr:d in a Iter: II/Udllk /1'" '£1/. SI/.(lh (!, 'W(/,I! Uw,/. :r/I'n C HYII" A;j C lIl!?n and such that (HYY." JI/) /.d l '" '/:s nalu,raUy isomorphic to SYII{;lxR (M / xF). Pl'oof: lJHill1!; illdudion on n, we have only to prove the case where I/. "= I. Lei; a~, ... ,a; be a minimal basis for M/xF and let aI, ... ,as
,/' iN
L
1)(1 elements of M sueh that a~ = ai modulo xF. Then aI, .. , , as, .rl1, , .. , , xUr is a basis for M. They really form a minimal basis for M, since otherwise there would be a relation Clal + .,. + csa s + d,:tU l + ... + drxU r = 0 with some Ci EE m or some d j EE m. If some (:,: ~: )11, then this contradicts the fact that the a~ form a minimal basis for M/xF; if some d j EE m, then the coefficient of U j in L Ciai is not ill )112, whence some Ci EE m (because M emF) which is not the case. Thus the ai and the xU j form a minimal basis for M. syzl M is therefore the relation module of aI, .. , , a r , x UI , .. , , X Us. L ciA i + L bjVj E syzl M if and only if L Ciai + L bjxU j = O. Let (J be Lhe map from syzl Minto FI = L RA i such that (J( L CiAi + L bj V j) = L ciA i . This (J is obviously a homomorphism. Element of the kernel of (J is bjVj with bjxUj = O. Since x is not a zero divisor and since Uj are free, we have bj = 0 and therefore (J is an isomorphism. Since the ai and the xU j form a minimal basis, we have (J(syzl M) C mFl . Since xai E xF, we have xAi E (J(syzl M). Thus :lPI ~ (J(syzl M) C mF I . L c;A i E syzlAxR (M/xF) if and only if L cA i E xF with Ci such that c; = Ci modulo xR, or equivalently L ciAi E (J(syzl M). Thus we see that
L:
syzAlxR (M/xF)
L:
=
(J(syzl M)/xFl,
and the assertion is proved completely. (27.4) COROLLARY : With the same notation and assumptions as in (27.3) above, we have hd R M = 1 hd RlxR M/xF, except for the case
+
where F = O. Proof: If both hd M and hd M / xF are infinite, then the assertion is obvious. Therefore, we assume that one of them is finite and we prove Lhe corollary by induction on the finite homological dimension. hd RlxR 111 /xF = -1 if and only if M /xF = 0, i.e., M = :rF, or equivnlently hd M = 0 because, in the notation in the proof of (27.3) the
II(I (/, Hlld
'1'1111\ '1'111,1(111\'
.I'l'/
1'111'111 II. lllildlilid 11I1./liI1 1'111'
t1\"~,"llllqll
III.
Hilll'I'
1.I'1i
IIJ1HIIII'lpLioll
ill
(:!/.:I) 1111111:-: 1'111' ",V 1,1 11111.1\(1 Hillll~~4,VV,;"/d" (/11/'1'1") ,-.' ",VY, I (/1I/'1'/I'd,
WI'
" I1(\ a,~:-:I'I'1.111I1 . II,V .1111 I11('1.11111. . 11I'OVI'J
ca.;;) COI((lLLA H,\': lVillt. /.II.(: Nf/./l/l' U, III, (/./I{I .1' n.~ 1/.11111'1', Id III Iii' fI, .finite H-'Ynotin/f: ,~uch Olat .r!l1 = O. 'I'h('/I. lid/,' !11 I + Iid/,'/J'{': Ill) except for the case where M ,= O. Proof: Let UI , '" , U r be a minimal bake of J\1. L c J 1; ( HYII:I M if and only if L CiUi = O. Then with F = L R Ui , we have :tF ~ syz1 M emF, and SYZ1/XR M = (syz1 M)/xF. Therefore, we can prove the assertion, using (27.4). We give, by the way, some results on M-sequences .. Let (R, m) be a local ring and let M be a finite R-module. For an M-sequence Xl, . . . , Xr the number r is called the length of the Msequence. An M-sequence Xl, '" , Xr is called a maximal M-sequence if there is no element y E 111 such that Xl , .. , ,X r , y is an M-sequence. (27.6) With the notation as above, zf Xl, .. , , Xr is an M -sequence, then any permutation of the Xi is an M -sequence. Proof: If we show that Xl and X2 permute with each other, then the general case follows immediately, using the induction on r from the fact that X2, .. , , Xr is an (M/xd\1)-sequence. Thus we arc to prove the permutability of Xl and X2. Assume that X2m = 0 (m EM). Then, since X2m E x 11l1, we have m E x 1N1:x 2R = xllJ;[, and m = xlm' with m' E 111. Thus xlx2m' = O. Since Xl i" not a zero divisor with respect to M, X2m' = O. Thus we have O:x2R (in M) is contained in Xl(O:X2R), whence by the lemma of Krull-Azumaya, we have
i.e., X2 is not a zero divisor with respect to N1. ASHume that m E X2M:XlR. Then Xlm = X2m' with m' E M. Then m' E x 11l1:x2R = xlM, i.e., m' = xlm" (m" EM). Then Xlm = xlx2m". Since Xl is not a zero divisor with respect to M, we have m = X2m" , and x2111:xIR C x2M. Thus X2 , Xl , X3, . , . , Xr is an M-sequence. (27.7) With the same notation as above, if there is an M-sequence Xl , . . . ,X r , then there is an N1 -sequence YI , . . . , Yr such that their residue classes modulo m2 are linearly independent over the field Rim; if the Xi form a maximal1l1-seqllCnce, then so do the Yi . Proof: Assume that Xl, . , . , Xs (s may be zero) modulo m2 are linearly independent. In that case, let YI, •.. ,Ys be the Xl, . , . , Xs .
1'11.\ 1"1'11111 I V WI' PI'II\'I' 1111' 1I1111111'Cioll II.\' illlllll'Lilll1 Oil fllll'll /1,11 8,
I~i II0LIlillJ,l; III PI'III'I'. AHelllllll' LiII'I'I'I'III'I"~'
IS 1101, II. 1:1'\'11
Ii I vi:-llll'
8/',1111'11 1.\11'1'('
III In III , I.III'I'P n I· III" (III' J'nUII~J', (nM: 111)+ wi Lit 1'(':-IPI'I'1. 1,11 III IIlM, \lIW:LII:-II'
,I'" 1~4 11111. /I. 1,1'1'11 dIVIHIII' wIl.li I'I'HPI'I~L 1.11
III' 111 wllll'lI i:-l 11111. III
II'
I'. HI'L il
2.:'; iH
1,1',1.'. HIIII'n
nil I'lpllIl~IIL !I
111'1) ~11I'1i LI,aL
!J
III' Lh(~ I'ad tImL
LII(~ :-11'1, III' 1:('1'(1 dIVi~II/'~ wiLh I'('~PP('I, 1,0 1111111111'1' IIJ' p!'ill\(~ id('al~ (:-,,~o 1';x('I'(li:-le
M luM i~ Ul(~ union of a finite I ill §8), Then :£1, '" , Xr-l , Y
iH 11.1\ JI1-Hoq\WIt('(~, and w(~ arc reduced to the case of greater s (by (:,)7,(;)). ThlH it remains only to prove that if the Xi form a maximal III -Hcquence, then so do Xl, ,., , Xr-l, y. Considering M luM and U/(uM:M), we may assume that r = 1 and that M is faithful. That ,1'1 is a maximal M-sequence implies that every element of m is a zero divi80r with respect to MlxlM, whence there is an element m of M wll ich is not in xlM but is in xIM: m (cf. Exercise 1 in §8). Then 11m = xlm' for an m' E lJ!!. If m' = ym* for an m* E lt1, then m = xm* which is not the case. Therefore m' ~ yM, Let z be an arbitrary eleIllent of m. Then zm = xm" for an m" E M, whence xym" = yzm = ,I'zm', and ym" = zm'. Thus z E yM:m'R. Thus every element of 111 is a zero divisor with respect to AII yM, and the maximality of 1/ is proved. Thus (27.7) is proved completely. (27,8) CORtlLLARY: Maximal M -sequences have the same length. Proof: Assume that Xl, ,., , Xr and 1/1, ." , Ys are maximal MH(~quences. We prove that r = s by induction on r, If r = 0, then the HHsertion is obvious; if r = ], this has been proved in the last step of the proof of (27.7). Assume now that r > 1. Then the union of the sets (If zero divisors with respect to M I xlM and M I ylM does not cover 111, whence there is an element z such that both Xl, Z and Yl, z form MHnquences. Let Xl, Z, ZR, " . , Z t and Yl, Z, W3, ,." w" be maximal M-sequences. Considering M IxdYI, we have r = t by induction, ConHidering M/zM, we have t = u, and, considering Mly1M, we have 'I/, = 8. Thus r = s, which completes the proof. EXERCISES: Let M be a finite module over a Noetherian ring and let a be an illeal of R. Then the notion of M-sequence in a is defined simibrly using a inHtead of m in the previous definition. 1. Confirm that, under the assumption that M laM T" 0, (27.6) and (27.8) (Jan be genemlized to such a case. 2. Prove (27.2) when R is a semi-local ring and when the Xi are in the Jacob~on mdical. 3. Adapt (27.4) to the case of semi-local rings.
11K
'1'111'1 'I'll 1':01/ \
11/" i1 \ 'f,\ 1111'11 \
2M. U('lllllm' IO('t11 1'I1I1l.\' Wn Il('gili wiLli /I, 11'111111/1,: (::lKI) I,d. (N, 11/) 1)(: a {,I/(:(/,( 'rill!!. If 0: III / 0, /Ju:n hd M ,D fll/' eveTY finite mod'ute M which i8 'not II'I'(:. Proof: Assume that hd M = n < 00 amI Chat n ?:. I. 'I'lwll :..;yll /I III is free and different from zero. Since syz n M i::; j,he l'elaLiol\ modltin or syzn-l ].II, there is a free module F such that syzn M ~ lllf?, wh(~II(',n (O:m)(syzn M) = 0, which is a contradiction. Now we prove: (28.2) THEOREM: Let (R, m) be a local Ting. If hd m is finite, then R is TegulaT. ConveTsely, if R is a TegulaT local Ting, then faT eveTY finite R-module M diffeTent fTom zeTa, we have hd M =c altitude R - s, wheTe s is the length of a maximal M -sequence. Proof: Assume that hd m is finite. We prove the regularity of R by induction on r = altitude R. We begin with the following remark: If O:m ,L 0, then m must be free by (28.1), whence m = 0 because 0: m ,L O. Therefore, R is a field in this case. Now, if l' = 0, then 0: m ,L 0, and the assertion is proved already. Assume that l' > O. Then by the above remark, we have 0: m = O. Therefore, there is an element x of m which is not in m2 such that x is not a zero divisor. Then hd m = hd R / xR m/xR 1 by (27.4), whence RfxR is regular by induction. Therefore we see that R is also a regular local ring by (9.11). Conversely, assume that R is a regular local ring and let M be a finite R-module different from zero. Let Xl , ... , Xs be a maximal M-sequence. We may assume, by (27.7), that Xs ~ m2 if 8 ?:. 1. We prove the equality hd M = l' - S (1' = altitude R) by induction on 1'. If l' = 0, then R is a field, and M is free (8 is obviously zero). Thus this case is obvious. Assume that l' ?:. 1. If s ?:. 1, then hd M = hd R / xsR M/::c M by (27.2), whence by induction hd M = (1' - 1) (8 - 1) = l' - s. If s = 0, then M is not free, whence syzI M ,L 0 and hd M = 1 hd syzl M. Since syzl M is contained in a free module, y E m (y ,L 0) forms an (syzl M)-sequence; if it is maximal, then by the above proof, we have hd (syzl M) = l' - 1, and hd M = r. Thus, it is sufficient to prove that every element z of m is a zero divisor with respect to (syzl M)/y(syzl M). Let F be a free module such that F/(syzl M) "" M. Since z is a zero divisor with respect to M, there is an element a of F which is not in syzl M such that za E syzI M, whence yza E y(syzl M). But ya ~ y(syzl M) because y is
+
8
+
('11111"1'11111, IV 1111(, II, Y,PI'I)
divir4ol' II.lld
111'1'/1,111'1(11/
II HY If, , II!,
'l'IH'I'PI'OI'!', .:: iH
/I,
~,(II'O IIi
ViNOI' willi IW1(1('1'I, 1,0 (N.v~,1 III )/!I(H.v~,' /1/ l, 1I,lId LlHI limo\' iH "Olilpil·l,ll,
(:.lH,:I) (!O/l.Old,AI1I': IJ' p /8 (/,fII'/I/I/' il!('(/l /~r /I /'I'(/lIlu/, lul'/l.!, '/'/11(/ h', h\, ':8 //, 'I'I'l/n{(I./' lo/'/r!, '1"1:11(/, "I'OO\': lid p iH 1;lIil.(', wlH,tll:n 1111/"" ~>Iip iH lillil.n I,.v (~o,:.n, wllidl
IIM'/I.
PI'OV(!H LlI(: Il.HH(!I'I.iOlI.
Lnl. (/(" Ill) h(: a I'n~I\III,J' IO(Ial J'illp; :l,lullnL 71 h(: 1.11(: cilal':I.(,i,(!I·iHI.iI' oi' iH (:allnd an 'Il'f/,r'(un'!j,:/,r/ '/'c(J'I1.lllr local r"';n.(j if nil.l\(\l· f{, ('OI\(,II,iIIH II,
U/lli.
n
P q:
2
• Namely, H iH 1I1lmmilicd if H.l\d only if H/p!?' iH I'<'P;IINow we Imvn: (28.4) If P is a prime ideal oj an unrarrtified regular loca,l rinfJ H, Ihen Il~ is an unramified regular local ring. Proof: Let p be the characteristic of the residue class field or U. II' pll Q;; lJ, then R~/lJR~ is of characteristic zero, whence R~ contailiH I,ll<: rational number field, and R~ is unramified in this case. ASRlIlll(', I.hat pR C lJ. Since R/pR is regular, we see that (R/pR)~!l'''' oc Nu/pR~ is regular by (28,3), and the assertion is proved, (28,5) Let (R, m) be a local ring and let a be an ideal of R. Assunw that a = xR:yR (x E a, y E R) and that x ~ am. If hd a S 1, then 1\ = xR. Proof: Assume the contrary. Since x if am, there is a minimal basiH a" aI, ... ) an for a. Let b be such that xb = yal . By the assumption Hyzl a = {cX + L CiAi I CX + L Ciai = 01 is a free module, Let i" ... ,fm be a free basis for syzl a. syzl a contains elements a1X a:Al and bX - yAl' whence there are elements dij such that a1X :1:A 1 = Lj dlifj and bX - yAl = Lj d2ifj , y(a1X - xA 1) = xbX :1:yA = x(bX - yA), whence we have yd1j = xd2j for any j, which implies that d1j E xR: y = a, whence the coefficients of did; are in am, which implies that x is in am because a1X - XAI = L d1dj, whieh iR a contradietion and we prove the assertion. (28.6) Let:1: and !J be elements oj a ring R. If J: is not a zero divisor, awn either J:R + yR is principal or hd (xR + yR) = ] + hd (xR:yR). Proof: A:osume that .rR + yR is not. principal, t.hon, since hd xR = 0, we have by (26.6) that hd (xR +yR) = hd (xR + yR)/xR, whence it is equal to hd R/(xR:yR) by (1.5), and the a:o:oertion is proved by the fact that xR:yR = syzl R/(xR:yR).
fidd
OJ'
m
111,1'.
(28.7) THEOREM: An arbitrary regular local ring (R, factorization ring.
111)
is a unique
10(1
'1'111,) '1'1111)01'"
Oil' t\\'~,"llIll)t\
!'I'OOi': 1.1'1. " hI' III(' nILiI,lIdl' 01' N 11.11(11(11. II 1.(1 11,11 II.I'hiLI'/I,I'Y pl'illl(l id(,ld (II' 1\(~i/!;liI, I ill Ii, W(I 11,\,\1(' oilly 1,(1 P"(lV(' Lllld, ~I iH pl'ill('ipnl. II' I' •.~ I, LlI('11 L11(\ HHHI'ltioli iH ol,vioIlH, AHH(lIII(\ 1.1111.1, .,.. :!, II' ;~ ( III i:-: 1101. ill p, 1.11('11 Z rOI'IIIN all U/).I-HI\qll(\III~(\, wllil~1I illlplinN Lh:I,(, hd N/p <: 'I' I, 1\(,1\(,1, 1\(1 P ~ 'I' - ~ "nl:II.IIH
induction on r. Set. a = xR + yR. Since x is irreducible, if a is prineipal, t.hen yR = R, and p is principal. Therefore, we· assume t.hat. a is not principal. Let. t be so large that a' : m = a' with a' = a: m t. Let z be an element of m which is not in m2 such that a':zR = a' . R' = R/zR is regular, hence it is a unique factorization ring by induction. Therefore hd R , (a + zR)/zR ~ 1 by (28,6), whence hd R , (R/a + zR) ~ 2 < altitude R ' , which implies in particular that (a + zR)/zR:m/zR = (a + zR)/zR, t
by (28.2), whence (a + zR):m = a + zR. Therefore a' = a:m C (a + zR): mt = a + zR, Since a':zR = ai, a' C a + zR implies that a' = a by (4.3). Therefore, there is a maximal R / a-sequence Xo, ., • . . . , Xs such that Xo = z. Then Xl, '" , Xs is a maximal R/ (a + zR)sequence. Since hd R , R/(a zR) ::; 2, we have s :::: r - 1 - 2 = r - 3 ,whence hd R R/a ~ 2, and hd a ~ 1. Since we assumed that a is not principal, we have hd a = 1, whence hd p = 0 by (28.6) and p is principal. Thus the proof is complete. We say that a Noetherian ring R is a regular ring if R Itt is a regular local ring for every maximal ideal m of R. Under this definition, one can assert the following corollary:
+
(28,8) COROLLARY: A regular semi-local integral domain is a unique factorization ring. This follows immediately from the following lemma: (28,9) Let (R, 1111, ... , 111,.) be a semi-local integral domain. If every Ri = R Itti (1; = 1, '" , n) iii a unique factorization ring, then R is a unique factorization ring. Proof: Let p be an arbitrary prime ideal of height 1 in R. Then pR i is generated by an element Pi of p. Let ai be an element of nll mi-l mi+l mn which is not in mi. Then pRi is generated by Piai . Set P = L Piai . Then since pjaj E pmiRi for i 'F j,
... n
n
n ... n
n
1() I
I'll \ 1"1'1'111 I V
II
WII tll'I' 1,11111.
W'III'I'II,I,I'ii
)Iii,
1'(11' I'\'I'I'.\'
i,
11'11('111'1')
IIU
II.\,
is.OI,
11.11.1 /,Il(' II.H~41'1·l,illll it1 PI'IIVI'II. WI'
add,
111'1'1', HOIIII' l'I'lIlnl'l(H Oil IIOII··)'('glilll,t· 1(lI:al l'ill!2;H.
(:.lS.IOJ /,1'1. (It', III) IIf'
(I, /II(:(/'I, 'I"';"'r/. /1 881/./lU: that an .1: ( 111 ,is not a n.finiil' 1////(i'II.I(: 111 'F 0, it hold& that heL" M = 1 + Itd{";,'1 (HY1.' 1I1)/'r(HY1.' M). I '!'Ool': Itd ll M = 1 + hd", Hyzl M. Since x is not a zero divisor and Hi 11(,(: HY1.' 111 iN a Nubmodulc of a free module, we see that hd R syzl M = lid ",/,.", (Hyy,l M)/X(syzl M) by (27.2), and the assertion is proved.
:('/'/1
dill/mI'. '1'11.1'//./111'
(28.11) Tn.MORIDM: Let (R, nt) be a local ring and let M( 'FO) be n .Ii.nite R-module. Let s be the length of a maximal M-sequence. If hd M iH .finite, then hd M + s is equal to the length t of a maximal R-seq'uence. Proof: We prove the assertion by induction on t. If t = 0, then 0: III 'F 0, and the assertion is true by (28.1). Assqme that t > 0, /1,11<1 let Xl , ... , :0t be a maximal R-sequence. If s 'F Q, then we may /I,HHllme that Xl i" not a zero divi"or with respect to ],';[ by virtue of (:!7.8). Then hd" M = hd R / xlTl Mj.TlM. (X2 modulo xIR), ... , (Xt Illoclulo xlR) is a maximal R/xIR-sequence, and if Xl , Y2, ... , Ys is a lIIaximal M-sequenc:e, then (Y2 modulo xIR), ... , (Ys modulo xIR) is fI, maximal M/xIM-sequence by definition. Thus we have settled this (:11,He. Assume that s = 0. We can prove that Xl form::; a maximal (Hyzl M)-sequence, in the same way as in the last step of the proof oj' (28.2) (with y = Xl)' Therefore, by the case where s > 0, we see Chat hd syzl M + 1 = t, and hd M = t, which completes the proof. 1'~XERCISES:
1. Let a be an ideal of a regular local ring R. Prove that if
p, , .. , , lJn are all of the prime divisors of a, then hd a is not greater t.han the
IIItLximum of the depth lJi + 1. 2. Let R be a Noetherian ring. Prove the equivaJence of the following condiI,ions: (1) hd M :::; n for every finit.e module M, (2) R is a regular ring such that IIHitude R ;;; n. 3. Assume that M is a finite Ria-module (a being an ideal of a local ring Il). I't'Ove that hd Rla M + hd R Ria = hd R M, provided that each of them is tillite.
29. Syzygies of graded modules Since there i8 a very close relation between graded ring::; and semilocal rings or between graded rings over loc:al ring" and local rings, we Itdd some remarks on syzygies of graded aodule". Let R = L Rn he a graded Noetherian ring sueh that Ro is a 10c:a1
III',',
'11111\ '1'111 11(111\' 1111'
~\\1,\1111'1I\
L"
I'illg willi 11111.\illlll.l idl'/I,I 1111), HI'I III 1111) I I h'", III iN oill'iollNly 11, Ill/I,xil1\1d ilil'/I,\. 1.1'1 M 1)(' H lillill' /l;I'HIIi'd 11111111111', WI~ d('(illl' Ii, NIP/lllli ,~/'ql//'I//'/' or III /1,,'4 rollnw,'4: TII(~ lil'HL 1111'1111)('1', wllidl IIlay 1)/· d/'liol.l~d I,y HYY,I) M, iN 11/ il.NI'IL WIII'II Clip ",1,11 1111'111111'1' NYX" I 11/, whidl iN a gl'/Likd [illil.l~ m()dllll~, iH ddilll'd, WI' ddill(\ !.Iw
+
('II. I )NC Il\mnl>I~1' NYX" 11/ aN folioWN: Ldo 'UI , '" , U r IH~ a Illillimal IIaNiN for NyxlI I M (',onNi,,('ing only of homogeneollN nli~In<~III.N, of dl~
gl'ce, NUY, d1 , , . ' , dr. Let U1 , . , ' , Ur be ind()t()rminat(~N and <:011Nider the relation module N = (L aiU i I L aiUi = 01. If we regard U i as an element of degree d i , then N is a graded module, ThiN graded module N is defined to be syzn M. Then: (29,1) Every syzn M is unique up to isomorphism. Proof: If VI , ••• ,Vs is another similar basis for lYI and if d~ = deg Vi , then we see, first, that there is a linear transformation from the members of Ui with smallest d i to such ones of the Vi, hence the same can be generalized to be the case of the Ui with d i at most the second smallest and such ones of the Vi , and so on, and we see that r = sand there is a linear transformation which maps the Ui onto the Vi , whence syzn M is independent of the choice of bases. Thus "syzygy sequence" is well defined, and therefore the same treat.ment as in the case of local rings can be applied. But we need not repeat. the same again, because of the following theorem. (29.2) THEOREM: With the same notation as above, we set R* = Rm. 'Then syz;. (M ® R*) is naturally isomorphic to (syz; M) ® R*. Proof: Since we are considering graded modules, any element a of R which is not in m is not a zero divisor with respect to modules, whence M is naturally contained in M ® R*. One can see easily that a minimal basis for M consisting of homogeneous elements becomes a minimal basis for M ® R*, whence we see easily that syz~. (M ® R*) is naturally isomorphic to (syz~ M) ® R*. Applying the same to syz; M instead of M, we prove the assertion. By virtue of the above results, one can state a generalization of the classical syzygy theorem of Hilbert as follows: (29.3) THEOREM: Let R be the homogeneous polynomial ring in algebraically independent elements Xl, . , . , Xn over a regular local ring Ro . Then jor any finite graded module 11{ over R, hd M is at most n altitude Ro , and with t = hd M, we have syzt+l M = o.
+
l-'heory of Complete Local Rings and Its Application 30. Some properties of complete local rings (:30.1) THEOREM: Let R be a complete semi-local ring with Jacobson 'I'adical 111. If un ( n = 1, 2, 3, . ,. ) are ideals of R such that lln C Un+l for any n and such that nn.Un = 0, then for any given natural n1lmber n, llime exists a natural nnmber m(n) such that llm(n) C 111n. Proof: Assume the contrary, namely, assume that there is a natural r lIl/mber r sueh that U 'II 111 for any m. Then, for any n :2: r, U m mn. Hillce altitude Rlmn = 0, the minimum condition for ideals holds in N/m n , whence there is a natural number t(n) such that at(n) + mn = n,n + mn for any m :2: t(n). We may assume that t(n) < t(n + 1) n 1'01' any n = r, r + 1, '" . Then Ut(n) C Ut(n) + mn = Ut(n+l) + m , Hiid therefore for any given element Xn of Ut(n) there is an element n ;t~"+l of Ut(n+l) such that Xn - Xn+l E m , Starting with an Xr E Ut(r) r which is not in m , we have a sequence of Xn as above. Then the Xn rorm a Cauchy sequence, which has a limit x* in R. Since Xn , Xn+l, ••• 1I,I'e in Ut(n) and since x* is the limit of the sequence, we have x* E Ut(n) I)'y the closedness of ideals. I-Ience x* E nn Ut(n) = 0, and x* = 0. On Lite other hand, since Xn - Xr E mT for any n, we see that x* - Xr E mr , whence Xr E nt'", which is a contradiction.
%
It
%
(30.2) COROLLARY: If a complete semi-local ring R is dominated by semi-local ring R' which may not be Noetherian, then R is a subspace
of R'. Proof: Let m and m' be the Jacobson radicals of Rand R', respecLively. Then obviously m" C m,n n R. By (30.1), we have m,m(n) n Il ~ m n , and the assertion is proved, We say that a quasi-local ring (R, m) is a Henselian ring if the following i8 true: If a monic polynomialf(x) over R is such thatf(x) == (J1I(x)ho(x) modulo mR[x] with monic polynomials go and ho with the l103]
1(11
'1'111111111\
PI'IIPI'I'I.I'
III" I'IIMPI,I'I'I'N I,III'!\!, 11111;(/11
111111 (l1Ih'1,1'1 I hllh'I,1'1 I IIINI,I'I
m"t
POIYlllllllill,le1 (1(,1') 1i,lId Ii(,,') Hlll'il IIl1i.1,/(,I')
O( ,I')
(III ( ,"), h( ,")
"11(.1') 11.1'1' ill
(I( ,"
1111'11 111,'1',' 111'1' 1IIIIIIi"
III( ,")
I\.lId HIII'it
CIlIioL
IIIUI,I'I,
Ill\dl'l' CitiH LI'I'llIiIlOloll:.Y, WI' l'Ii,1I 11.14141'1'1. 1,1,11.1,:
(:m,:l) '1'lIlmll,I'IM: If (U, 1Il) is (J. mll/pit:!,(! IU(:fI'/' ri/l.!1 'whi(:h,l/.fI,l! II.O!, 11f: N Of' lIwT'/a:n, !'hen R ":,,, a 11 r:fi8!il inn r"inll, We prove thiH Uwol'cm in the following form, whieh iH JllO],(, l!;(,IH,ral ill appent'n1H:e: (:10.4) If (R, m) is a complete local rino which may not be Noetherian, f(x), ho(x) aTe polynomials in an indeterminate x over R and if Oo(x) is a monic polynomial in x over R such thatf(,y) - Oo(x)ho(x) E mR[x] (Lnd such that Oo(x)R[x] + ho(x)R[x] + mR[x] = R[x], then there are polynomials O(x) and h(x)( ER[xJ) as follows: f(::c) = o(x)h(x), o(x) - Oo(x) E tnR[x] , hex) - ho(x) E tnR[x] and O(x) is a monic polynomial, Proof: We may aSimme that deg ho + deg 00 :::; deg f. Starting with 00 and ho , we construct sequences of polynomials On (:r;) and h" (:1:) such that f - O"h" E m,,+1R[x], 0" - 0,,-1 E m"R[x], hn - h,,-l E mnR[x], deg hn + deg On :::; deg f, and sueh that On is a monic polynomial (for every n): Namely, when an and h n are already defined, then we define 0,,+1 and h,,+l as follows: Since 00 - On and 110 - hn are in mR[x], we sec that On , h" , and m generate R[:r], whence there are polynomials ai( x), bi ( x) and mi( x) such that Xi = Onai + hnb, + mi with mi E mR [x] , Since On is monic, we may assume that deg bi < deg 0" = deg 00 ' By the existence of the term mi , we may assume that the coefficients of ai and bi are units or zero, Then we sec that deg ai :::; deg.f - deg On if i :::; deg f. Now we write f - Onh" = L CiXi(Ci E 111n+1). This last sum is taken up to the term whose degree is equal to d = deg f· Therefore, f - O"hn = On( Cia'i) + hn ( Cibi) + L Cimi, and deg (L Ciai) :::; deg f - deg On , deg (L cib i ) < n 2 deg (/n, Cimi E m + R[x]. Set 0,,+1 = On + cib i , hn+1 = hn + Ln C,ai. Then f - On+1hn+1 = L Cimi - (L cib i ) ( L Ciai) E m +2R[x], and as is easily verified, On+1 and hn+1 satisfy the requirements. Thus the existence of the sequences is proved. Since R is complete, we can consider the limits of (On(X)) and (hn(x)); let them be g(x) and h(,y). Then we see that f - Oh E mnR[x] for any n, and f = gh, and \vt' prove easily that these 0 and h are the rrquired elcments. Since some general properties of Henselian rings will be observed ~r
L
L
L
L
('11.\1"1'1,111
lOll
I'
IIIL('/' ill ( 'lill,pll'l' VII, illl'IIIdillg IIII' 1'11.1'1. ClmL ('lil' 11t'IIKI,1 1('11111111, or UII' 1'01'111 ill (:10,11 i1, 1\, gl'III'I'II,1 propl'I'Ly or 111'111-I1,linll I'illgl-l, \VI' t41111.11 IIO\. I/l'l'i\'I' HII.\' of 11i1'111 HI. IH'I'~I'ltI" I'XI'I'Pi. 1'01' 1.111' followill/.!:: (:IO,r,) If Ii is I/, /l1'lIsl'tinnillle!lJ'nl dOl/III,,://. (/,//.110' It' 'I:,~ ITn ":/1[1'(11'111 1',I'II'II,~i/i1l 'I~r Ii, Ili/'/l N'/:8 If /I,/I,~'/:-I/lcal, 1'1'001': 1.1'1 III hi' III(' IlIa:-:illl:l.1 ideal of N, A:otlumc that H' hU8 maxi111/1.1 idl'al~ '"', '""(111' ~ 1/1"), alld let a be all element of m' which is 1101, ill 111", ~"kL N" = Hlaj and let
!Iii ILII irreducible monic polynomial over R which has a as a root, i"\illce a Em', we have Cn E m. Since a ~ m", an ~ mR[a], and there is /I, I:,: which is not in m. Let j be such that Cj ~ m, Cj+s E m (for Ii> 0). Then 1 ~ j ::::; n - I, andf(x) := (;7;j + CIX i - 1 + .. , + Cj)x n - j IllOdulo mR[xJ. Since R is Henselian, f(x) must be reducible over R, which is a contradiction, and the assertion is proved. (:~0.6) THlDoREM: Let R be a complete semi-local ring with Jacobson 'I'((li'ical m. Let M be an R-module. If MjmM is a finite R-module and ':I'the m-adic topology of M is To , then M is a finite module: Let Ul , ... , , , , Us be elements of lJ;[ such that lJ;[ j mM is generated by their residue l'Iasses, then lJf = L RUi. Proof: Set N = L~ RUi. Let a be all arbitrary element of M. We W/I,lIt to show that there is a sequence of elements al , .... ,an, .. , of N :ouch that an = L mniUi with mni E m n- 1 and such that
a -
L~ aj E l11nlJ1.
We use induction on n. The case "vhere n = 1 is immediate from the ILHI-Illmption. Assume that ai, ... , an are already defmed. Then n a. - L~ aj = mib i with mi E m , bi E M. Let Ci be elements of N 1'11(,h that b i - Ci E: mlJr, and set an+l = L miCi . Then an+l is the I'equired element, and the sequence is well defined. Set = mni /Ll\d a* = L m:ui' Then a - a* E mnM for any n, whence a = a*, which implies that M eN, and M = N.
L
m;
Ln
EXERCISES: 1. Assume that a local ring R, with principal maximal ideal Till, is dominated by It semi-local ring R' which may not be Noetherian. Prove I,/Int R is a subspace of R'.
2. Generalize (30.1) to the case of finite module Over a complete semi-local
ring.
100
1,(,1, N
'1'11111(11/\
III'
/I,
III" (1IIMI'ldl\'I'I': 1,(11',\1, IIIN(III
H(\lI\i .. lo('all'illl!; wil,it ,JH('OIIC~((1I l'II,lIil'lI,1 111 11,111111'1. ,1'1, ., . ,
... "I'" III' nlnlll('lli,H 01' III. 1,('1, I III' /I, HliI)I'illg 01' N. '1'11(\11 pownl' H(,I'inH ill I.Iw ,/'1 wiLli ('o('(Ji('inIII,H ill I hns 1ll('IIollilig ill ('\1(, (',olllpl(\l,iolJ U* 01' U alld I,h(, :·wl, 01' all SlId\ POW(,I' s(\ries 1)(\(~OIl\(\H a sllIll·jllg or U*. This sllbrill!!; is d(ll\o\.<-<1 by 111:1'1 , ... , :(;,,11. It'llI'1.1WI'IllO[,(', if X, , '" , X" :\1'(. illde1;(,rminai.(\,'i, I.h(\1\ tiwr() is a homomorphism ¢ from JIIX, , ... ,X" II onto Il[x1, .,. , x"Jj over I such that ¢( Xi) = Xi' If (,h(, homomorphism ¢ is an isomorphism, we say that :r1, ... , Xn are anal!Jtically independent over I. We note that if I is Noetherian then I[[X1, ... , ... , xnll is Noetherian. If I is a semi-local ring or a .local ring, then so is I[[X1, ... , x n ]]. (The proof is immediate from (15.3) and (15.4).) The main result in this section is the following:
(31.1) THEOREM: If (R, m) is a complete local ring which may not be Noetherian, then R contains a ring I which satisfies the following condition: Let p be the characteristic of Rim. Then m I is generated by p (i.e., p-fold of the identity), I is a complete local ring and Rim is naturally equal to I I (m n I). Consequently, if Ia A} form a basis for m, then every element of R is expressed as a power series in the a A with coefficients in I. (STRUCTURE THEOREM OF COMPLETE I,OCAI, RINGS) Such a ring I, as above, is called a coefficient ring of R; if I is a field, then I is called a coefficient field of R. It is obvious that I is a field if
n
and only if R contains some field. Proof: We begin with the case where p = O. Let I be a maximal subfield of R; the existence follows from Zorn's lemma. We want to show that this I is a coefficient field. Since m I = 0, I is regarded as a subfield of Rim. If x' E Rim is transcendental over I, then with an x such that x' = x modulo m, I (x) is a subfield of R, which contradicts the maximality of I. Hence Rim is algebraic over I. Assume that Rim contains an clement a' which is not in I and let f(x) be the irreducible monic polynomial over I which has a' as a root. The same f(x) is regarded as a polynomial over R. Since p = 0, a' is a simple root of f(x) modulo mR[x], whence f(x) = (x - a)g(x) with an a E R such that a' = a modulo m, by virtue of (30.3) or (30.4). This implies that I (a) is a subfield of R, which contradicts the maximality of I, and Rim = I. Thus this case is proved. We consider the case p -,:6. O. Before proceeding with the proof, we give some preliminaries. When K is a field of characteristic p -,:6. 0, a subset B of K is called a
n
107 I'
'InSI'
oi' /1 ii' /I Hllli,dil'H I.hl' i'ollowillg I.wo l'oll(liLiollH: ( I ) 1\
=~
1\ I' ( U) ,
(~)
ii' /'1, ... , {,,. u]'(\ IlIutually di"tinct clements of B, then /),,):1\".1 = p". 1IIIIkl' Lhis terminology, we have the following lemma:
111111
1/1 "(11
1 ,
(:{I.~) /U1'lI
."
,
An arbitrary field K of characteristic p -,L 0 has a p-base,
n. For any natural number n and for any mutually distinct elements
"I, .. , , b
r
of B, we have that K [Kpn(b 1
,
•••
=
Kpn(B) and that pn ,br ) : K ] = pnr.
I It'oof: The existence of B is easy by virtue of Zorn's lemma, considerillg subsets of K satisfying the second condition in the definition. We pi'ove the other assertions by induction on n. Since the map ¢ such that pn c/)(n) = aP is an isomorphism from K onto K P , we have K P = K (B P ) P hy induction and therefore K = [(1ln(B). pnr 2: [K \b 1 , ••• ,
pn ... ,br ) : Kpn] = [K (b 1 , . . . , br ) :Kpn(bi , ... , bn]· [KP\bi , ... , pn 1 P ) 'K]!n] > r • • . , br ' _ p "[Kpn--l(1 . II, . . . , b) r''K - ] -_ p' p (n-1)·,. . 1'1lllS'
WI~
prove (31.~). We note that (:n.2) implies that every element of K is expressed as pn II. polynomial in elements of B with coefficients in K in such a way Chat the degree of the expression is less than pn for each member of B /l,lId that such an expression is uniquely determined by the element or K. Next we prove another lemma: (31.3) Let p be a prime number and assume that an ideal m of a ring
pn - b Em, then a Il" E m n+1. Conseq1lently, if, furthermore, m t = 0 and if m is a maximal 'I:deal, then the map ¢ such that ¢( a) = a P' with s 1 2: t induces a one-one map from the field Rim into R. q q 1 Proof: Set c = b - a, q = pn. Then bq = a qa - c q (;) aq-"c r c . If r = ptr', (p, r') = 1, then a simple calcula/?, contains p (i.e., the p-fold of the identity).
If a
+
+
+ '" +
+ .. , +
Lion shows that (;) is a multiple of pn-t, whence (;) E m,,-t. Since
> t, c" E mt+\ and therefore the assertion is proved. Now we proeeed with the proof of (31.1). Let B* be a p-base of f( = Rim and fix a set B of representatives of B* in R (i.e., we take only one b E R for each b* E B* such that b* = b modulo In, and B 7)1
IOH
'1'1111:(11/1
1111'
I'II~II'I"'I'I'II:
1,111'\1, IIINIIII
iN 1.111' Hi'1. 01' 1-1111,1111),1 1'01'1'11.1'11 I 111,1.11 I'HI 1111111111'1' 1/ 11'1. 'i'" III' 1.111' IIlnp 1'1'11111 NIIII" illl.o il.HI,11' giVI'1i I,y 'i'" (0. 1 (/,I!''', '1'111'11 'i'" illillll'I'H I/. lilli' IllIn Il\ap 1'/'11111 NIIII illl.o h~/III" h.v (;\1.;\); I.Ili:-: lilli' olin Iliap iN ill'III1LI'iI hy ITn' Wn (kIlIlLI~ by II n 1.111' illlngl' III' H/llI by (/" ' 1.1'1, 8" III~ Lill' NI'I, 01' polynomialN ill einnll'nLN III' /) I.aknll \l\lIdulo III" wiLli codli('.i(,IIL:-: ill /1" such that the degree of 1,he polynomial ill n11<:11 dnllwlIl. 01' /) i:.; IeN:-:
than p2n. Since CPn induces on K = Rim an isomorphiNlll from 1\ ollLo IJ2n KP2n, there is a natural one-one map between elemenLt-: of K alld 2n An (such that (a modulo m)P corresponds to (a modulo mn)p2n). Therefore, we have a one-one map from K onto Sn, and Sn beeomeN a complete set of representatives of Rim in Rlmn. Set I n = Sn + pSn + ... + pn-1Sn (this notation means that I n is the set of elements of the form L~~~ aipi with ai E Sn. We want to show that .1n is a ring. If it is known that the sum of two elements of So. is in .1n , then we see that the sum of two element8 of .1n is in .1n , and furthermore, since the product, of two elements of Sn which are monomialR in the elements of B are in Sn , we see easily that the product of two elementR of Sn is in J n , whence the product of two elementH of .In iR in I n • Thus, in order to prove that .1 n is a ring, we have only to show that. the Rum of two element" L ak,1'VI and L liMM (aM, liM E An ; M = b;) '" Ii~r with Iii E B, 0 ::; Ci < p211) is in .1n . We prove it in the form that piC L aMM -I- L Ii Ml'Vl) iN in pi.1." by inullei,ion on i starting with i = n (until i = 0). ThiN last asseri.iolt i:-: obvious for i = n. Assume that 0 ::; i < n. Set q = p2n. For each M, aM and bM are in An and therefore they are qth powers of element" C M and d M of Rim". Since aM and b M are uniquely determined by the residlle elasses of CM and d M modulo m, we may assume that CM and riM arc
. S n. N ow, aM m
+
bM
=
( CM -I- d M) q -
(;) arc multiples of p, we see that piC
(Q) CM q-rdM.
1 ",aL."l r
r
o' "mce
I>.M (;}~rd~ )1\11 i8in pHlJn
by induction because CM, d M are in Sn. Therefore L pi(aM
+ h)M =
L pi(CM
+
dM)aJV[
+
piC Lr,M
(;)C~rri~)M
is in piJn. Thus, the above assertion ii:> proved, and we see that I n is a ring. Obviously J n ml 111 n = pJ" , whence pJn is a maximal ideal of I n • The one-one correspondence between Sn and Rim now induces the natural isomorphism between JnlpJ n and Rim. We want to show
n
I'IIA 1"1'1'111 V
lOll
II(\~L LlIII.I, LlII' 1l/I,i,III'n1110IIIOllllll'pltitHIl II" 1'1'0111 U/III" Olli,o "~/I"" I ill 11,1111,1.111'11,1 hOlllOlllOl'pliiHl1i 1'1'0111 .I" 0111.0.1" I, II, iH ohvioliH UmL 1r,,( III ) l'I'I'ol\ll'H /1.11 ('11'11\('111, 01' ,'-,'" I ,111'111"(' 7r,,( 8,,) C:.I" I, whieh implil'H LIm!. '71'" iH H h01\1011IOl'phiH1l1 1'1'0111 .1/1 illto .1/1-1. On the other hnlld, iL iH ol,violiH hy Lh" nOIlHLI'llId,ioli !.ImL (~adl element of 8 n - 1 is in 71",,(,'-1,,), whidl implinH Lh:1.L 71",,(.1,,) l,onLaintl '/n-I' Therefore 7I"n in"III'('M a lIaLlIl'al hOIllOIlIIlI'phiHIlI 1'1'0111./" onto '/n-l' Now, let {an} be a M(\II'II'III'(: of <:I(:III<:IILH Hildl Lfiai;(l" E I n and such that 7I"n(an ) = an-I' 1,'01' nHeh Hileh "eqll<:lIec {an}, let {b n } be a sequence of elements of R Hili'll Lhat bn modulo mil = an. Then it is obvious that Ibn} is a regular H(~qILCllec, hence there is lim bn • This last limit depends only on the Hnqllcnee {an} as is easily seen. Let I be the set of such limits. Since nHeh .Tn is a ring, I is a ring. Furthermore, each regular sequence in I with pI-adic topology comes from such a sequence {an} as above, whence I is complete in its pI-adic topology. Therefore we see easily lI.H in the proof of (15.1) that I is a quasi-local ring with maximal ideal 'liT. Hence, in order to prove (31.1), it is sufficient to prove that I is Noetherian, which follows from the following two lemmas: "II"PH
(31.4) If a quasi-local ring (R, m) is dominated by a local ring ( /l', m') which may not be Noetherian, then R is a local ring which may not be Noetherian. Proof: This is obvious because m em'. (31.5) If a local ring R which may not be Noetherian has principal maximal ideal pR, then R is Noetherian. Proof: Let II be an arbitrary ideal of R such that R 'F II 'F O. Then there is a natural number n such that II C pnR, a ~ pn+lR. Then n:pnR is not contained in pR, whence a:pnR = R, which implies that 11 =:J pnR and a = pnR.
(31.6) COlWLLARY: If R is a complete local integral domain, then R contains a complete regular ring 8 such that R is a finite 8-module and such that S = I[[:CI, , .. , x r ]] with a coefficient ring I (if R and analytically independent clements Xl, ••• , Xr over I. Proof: When I if) a field, let Xl, ••• , Xc be a Rystcm of parameters of R; when I is llot a field and if the maximal ideal of I is pI, let XI, .•. , Xr be such that p, XI, . . . ,Xr is a system of parameters of R. Set 8 = I[[xI, .,. , Xr]]. (30.6) implies that R is a finite 8-module, whence altitude R = altitude 8. Let Xl, ... , Xr be indeterminates, Then since Xl, ... , Xr or p, XI, ... , Xr form a regular system of parameters of I[[X I , . . . , Xr]], we have altitude I[[XI , ••• , Xrll =
110
1I,IUl,lIdn
h~. '1'111'1'1'/'01'(\
I)(! 11.11 iHOIIlOI'plliHIII,
!'lin "'lid
1111,1,\/1'/1,1 II III,ppi IIj,I; 1'1'0111 I,hl' Il.rlHIII'l.ioli
lei
III.\' 110111,0 11\.1'1\
AH II.IIOLII(!I· l:o/'OIIHI''y 1.0 (:11.1), WI' 1111.,,11 !.III' followillJ,!; "il'l,lII~ of
I II II HI,
pl·o"l.d. I'I'HIlII. I),V
(11i.:l):
(:lI.7) COI(()LI,AHY: If ,,~ is a CO'tI/,7)/dn /I/(;al 'I"I:'/I.!I w":ichmay 'not /)(: Noetherian and if the maximal ideal 1Il of R It,a8 a .finitc ba81:8, then H 'I;.~ N octherian. As an application of (31.7), we prove the following: (:-n.8) THEOREM: A semi-local ring R which may not be Noetherian is really Noetherian if and only if: (1) every finitely generated ideal of R is a closed subset of R, and (2) the maximal ideals of R have finite bases. Proof: The only if part is obvious by (16.7). Assume that R is not Noetherian and that the maximal ideals have finite bases. Then there is an ideal which has no finite basis, whence there exists an ascending sequence a] C U2 C ... C an C ... of ideals an of R such that each of the an has a finite basis. Let R* be the completion of R. Then R* is Noetherian by (31.7) and (17.7). Therefore there is an n such that umR* = unR* for any m ~ n, which implies that an is not a closed subset of R, because llnR* R, which contains Um , is contained in the closure of Un • Thus (31.8) is proved. Next we give some remarks on the choice of coefficient rings. When (R, m) is a complete local ring which may not be Noetherian, such that Rim is of characteristic p -F 0, let K be the maximal perfect subfield of Rim. For each element a' of K, let bn be a representative of a,p-n in R and set Cn = b~n. Then since b~+l - bn E m, we see by (31.3) that the Cn form a Cauchy sequence, whose limit a is uniquely determined by a' independently of the choice of the bn • This a is called the multipl1:cative representative of a'. Note that a is a representativc of a' and that if [) is the multiplicativc repreHentative of an elemcnt b' of K, then ab is the multiplicative roprmlentativc of a'b', as is obviously 8cen by our definitioll; these are the reason:-1 for (·.alling a the mult,iplicative reprcsentatives of a'. Now we have:
n
(31.9) THl
III
('11.11"1'1,111 V
('//'1111'111(/
I I~r h'
1/l11I1'1t I'I>IIIII/IIN
If Ill1til'III'I'/lI'III:{,/it'il'lI./
,.':11(/ 1(1'
U l'IIII./I/,;/1.,~
IIII' IIIlIlli"lil'lllil'I' l'I'JiI'I'NI'llllIlifll'8 I(/' HIII'I"IIII'n/'8 I~r 1\. 1'1'0111': ( I) iH (lhv iOIiH hy I.itn wool' (II' (:ll.I). 'l'hn nxinj,()II(:e of 1 ('(llll.nillillg I.it(' giv('11 U wan I'mlly IlI'ov()d in Ow proof of (31.1). We
Ibn Ia,;!, hall' or (2). lJc;ing the notation employed just !.lin /)" (:an h() dlOl:len from a given coefficient rillg l' (II' N, wll('lI('() {,/w 1ll11ll,iplieaLive representative a of a' E K is in I'. /I./'n 1.(1
P"OV('
1)('1'01'(' (:: I.D),
(::1.10): COltOLI,AHY: Let (R, TIl) be a complete local ring which may 'lllIt 1)(; Nodhcr-ian such that m -F 0. (1) If Rim is oj chamcter-ist'ic zer-o, !/Wf!, U has only one coefficient field when and only when Rim is algel/miG over- the pr-ime field. (2) If Rim is of chamcteristic p -F 0, then U has only one coefficient r-ing when and only when Rim is per-fect. Lastly, we prove a structure theorem of ramified regular local rings. We note, first, that the classical theorem of Eisenstein on the irredlteibility of polynomials can be stated as follows: (31.11) Let ~ be a pr-ime ideal in a r-ing R and let f(x) = xn n 1 (LIX + ... + an (ai E R) be a monic polynomial in an indeter-minate :c over- R. Assume that all the ai ar-e in ~ and that an \f ~2, then f(x) is 'irred'ucible over R. Hence, if furthermore R is a normal ring, then f(x) is irreducible over the field of quotients of R. Proof: If f(x) is reducible, say f(x) = g(x)h(x) with monic poly/lomials g(x) and h(x), then, since f(x) == xn modulo ~, we have {/(x) == x", h( x) == x n- r modulo ~ and an E ~2 which is a contradiction, which proves the first assertion, from which the last assertion follows. When (R, m) is a local ring, a polynomial f(x) as above with 1.1 = m is ealled an Eisenstein polynomial over Rand R[xlIJ(x)R[xl iH ealled an it'iscnstein extension of R. Now we can state:
+
(31.12) THEOREM: Every complete regular local ring (R, m) is an fCise1Lstein extension of a complete unr-amijied r-egular local r-ing (Ro , 1110)' which is necessar-ily the power series r-ing in a finite number- of analytically independent elements over a coefficient ring of Ro . Ever-y Eiscn.~tein extension of a regular local ring is again a regular local r-ing. Proof: As for the first assertion, we have only to prove the case where R does not contain any field. Let I be a coefficient ring of R and let p be the characteristic of Rim. Let Xl, ... , Xn be a regular 2 Hystem of parameters of R. If R is unramified, i.e., if p \f m , then we may assume that Xl = p, whence R = I[[x2, ... , xnlL which proves the last statement of the first assertion. Returning to the general
I I :J
'1'111':0111
III!'
l'I)~II'ld,:'I'I'1
!,I)I',II, IIINIIII
I'.II,HI', WI! IIll1.y ItH,YIIIIII' 1.111\.1, I', .1'.,: , " . "I'" ill II, H,VHI.I'III or PII.I'HIII(
L;
°
EXERCISES: 1. Give a direct proof of (31.7) using the fact that the form ring of R with respect to the maximal ideal is aN oetherian ring. 2. Let CR, m) and (R', m') be complete local rings which may not be Noetherian, such that R' is integral over R (R ::; R'). Prove that if R'/m' is separable over Rim, then, for any coefficient ring I of R, there is a coefficient ring I' of R' which contains I. Prove furthernlore that such an l' is uniquely determined by I. 3. Let CR, m) be a complete local ring which may not be Noetherian. Assume that R contains a field of characteristic p r" O. Assume that (R', m') is a local ring which may not be Noetherian such that R'P eRe R'. Prove that there are coefficient fields I and l' ofR and R', respectively, s~h that I r;;; 1'.
32. Finiteness oj derived normal rings vVe first prove the following:
(32.1) THEOREM: If R is a complete local integral domain, then an arbitrary almost finite integral extension of R is a finite module. As for the proof, since R is a finite integral extension of a complete regular local ring by (31.6), we have only to prove the following: Let R be a complete regular local ring and let K be the field of quotients
I~J'
N, /,t'l /, III' 1/ .Ii II ill' IIIW/I/'IIII' 1',I'll'lIllioll I~J' /\' (/Ild II'! HilII' IIII' illll'fll'lIl h' ill I" '1'111'/1. /a" in 1/ .Ii II ii,' Ii' 1110'/1111',
1'108111'1' ,~r
"!'ool': 1.('1./1 '11'1.111' 1:IIII,I'I1oI'I,I'I'i cil,i(' 01' /1, II' /1 n, 1.11('11" iH HI:pal'ahln OVI'I' f\ , /Iolld II~I iH fi II i1.1', 11'y ( In, I() ), '1'11('1'1,1'01'1' WI' :I,:-::-:IIIlW Lhal. p -F 0, WIiI'IH'.I' U i:-: I.lil' pOWI'I' HI'I'il'H !'illg ill lumlyLieally illdependent eleIIWIII.:-: ,I'I , , , ' , ,I',. !lVIH' a finld /, 'I'11('l'c is a finite purely inseparable I'XI.(:II,yioll !/ of 1\ HlII'II Lila I. /;( 1/) iH separable over D, If we know that Llle illtngml dOHul'n U" oj' It, ill (/ is finite over R, then we see that the ill(,(:gml dosul'e oj' It, ill L(f/) it> finite because L(V) is separable over 1/, and therci'ore R' it> finite over R, by (3,1), Thus we may assume Lhat L = L', Let q = [L:Kl (q is a power of p) and set I* = Ilia, q i/.,: = x~lq, R* = I*[[Yl, '" , Yrll, If a E R', then a E R, whence U' C R*, which implies that every element a of R' is uniquely expressed as a power series in the Yi with coefficients in I*, and in that Hense we define the leading form of an element of R', We want to show first that when aI, ". , as are elements of R' such that the leading forms /I, .,. , I" or these elements are linearly independent over R, then aI, ... , as are linearly independent over R. Indeed, if ~ aio.i (Ii i E R) is a non-trivial linear combination, then the leading form of L aib i it:: a non-trivial linear combination of the Ii which cannot be lIero because of their linear independency. Thus aI, ... ,as are linearly independent. Since L is finite over K, we see that there are elements aI, ". , as of R' with leading forms iI, .,. , is such that if a is an dement of R', then the leading form i of a is linearly dependent on II, .. , , is . Let Cl, . , ' , Ct be the set of coefficients of 11, .. , , Is . Then the eoefficients of 1 are in I(cl, ... , Ct). Therefore, if do = 1, dl , . , . , du is a linear base of I (Cl' . , . , C t) over I and if mo = 1, ml, .. , , mv is the set of monomials in the Yi of degree less than rq, then 1 is in the module L Rmid j , whence the module M generated by leading forms of elements of R' is a finite R-module; let gl , ... , gw be a base of M such that each gj is the leading form of an element bj of R' and let R" = R[b 1 , • , • , bwl. R" is a finite R-module, whence it is complete. Therefore, R" is a subspace of both R* and R' by (30.2). Let d be an element of R', We want to show by induction on n that there is a sequence I dn} of clements of R" such that d - dn has leading degree not less than n, We may start with do = O. If do, ... , dn are already defined, let f be the leading form of d - d71 . We can write I = L hjg j with hj E R, and we may assume that h j are homogeneous forms, whence d* = L h)}j has the same leading form f, and Lhe1'e-
III
'1'111'1111/\ 01" l'IIMI'",q'I'I'! 1,111' II, IIINIIi!
tI" I t/'" ill LI", l'I''IlIil'l'd ,,1, ' 111,'111, '1'111111, 1,111' 1'~ild"'III'I' IIi' 1.111' 111'11\'1'11. ~illl'(' It'" ill /I, IlltlllIPHI'(' IIi' 11"" 1.111' HI'IIiII'III'I' iH if, (!/I,I/('hy HI'ql/('III',y ill It'''. HilWI' U" ill ('111111'1('1.1', LlII' H('(II/I'III'I' 1111.:-1 lI. liJlli!. tI" ill /(,". tI 1/" IW('II.lIHI' U" iH II. HI IItHIIII.I',I' III' h~', Whi('11 illllllil'H !.Im!. U' ~ U", :1.111\ N' iH:I, lilli!.n 1(lIllIillIll'. Wn NlI.y LIm!. a HI'mi-lo(',al rill/!: R iN wnn{lIli(:u,Uy '11:n;/,(/;It/,'/jil'd ir (,\II~ ('.olllpll'Lioll N* IIi' N linK ])0 nilpoLcl\L e1mncl\i; (,xenpL )ICI'O; all i(i
1'111'1' 1/" ! I
~"'IJlII'III'I' i~1
(;{2.2) TH1Wm~M: If a semi-local integral domain R is analytically then the derived normal ring R' of R is a finite R-module. I lr()oj': Assuming the contrary, let R = Ro C Rl C R2 C ... C //'" C '" be an infinite ascending chain of subrings of R' such that m(:h Rn is a finite R-module. Let R* be the completion of R. Then the (.ompletion R: of Rn is generated by R* and Rn (and is identified with /(,1/ ® R*) by (17.8), which implies that R: is a finite module over R* and is contained in the integral closure Q* of R* in its total quotient ring. Let K be the field of quotients of R. Then R: K = Rn by (18.4), which implies that Q* is not finite over R*. On the other hand, let be all of the prime divisors of zero of R*. Then Q* is the direct sum of derived normal rings of R* In; , whence Q* must be finite over R* by (32.1). Thus R' must be finite over R nnram~!ied,
n
n;
33. Derived normal rings oj Noetherian integral domains (33.1) Let R be a Noetherian integral domain with field of quotients K and let R' be a ring such that R C R' c K. If R is integrally closed in R' and if, for any given prime ideal ~ of R, there is a prime ideal ~' of R' such that ~' n R = ~, then it holds that R = R'. Proof: Assume the contrary and let b' be an element of R' which is not in R. Let a be the set of elements a of R such that ab' E R. Let ~ be a prime divisor of a and set c = ll:~. Then a ~ c, whence there is an element c of c such that cb ~ R. Let ~' be a prime ideal of R' sueh that ~' R = ~. (cb')~ C R and furthermore (cb')~ C ~', whence (cb')~ C ~' R = ~, which implies that cb' is integral over R, by (10.4). Since R itl integrally dosed in R', we have cb' ( R, which is a contradiction, and we complete the proof.
n
n
1'11,\ 1"1'1,:11 V
(;l:I.:~
I
'1'111,1( IIII'I~I:
I,d Ii' /11'
II
I Ifl
N III,/III'/,"Ull i/l(I'(//'(/.I dlil/I,ain wl:!,h Jif'id
11',11'1 " /w II, jill ill' II.ludi'm":l: 1'.rtC/I,8'1:()1I, I(/, I\. and let H' be a '/'ill(/ 81/('/1. Ihlll U C N' C I,. II al Li Lwin H = 1, then Ior any ideal a' of Id 1///11("1'1118
/{' 811ch 11i1/,(
0'
/0, /t,'/n' i8 a module of finite length over RICa'
II R).
111,1)(1.1'/";('1/,10:1', /{,' iii a Noetherian ring of altitude at most one. (THEOREM Ill>'
(\InJI,lrAKlZUICl)
Proof; Taking a finite integral extension of R we may assume that " = K. Set II = a' R and let ~l, ... , ~8 be all of the prime divisors of (I. Since a' 'F 0, we have a 'F 0, and therefore the ~i are maximal. Ld S be the intersection of complements of the ~i in R. Then every nkment of S is a unit module a, whence R'la' = R~/ll'R~ and Ria = Us/aR s . Therefore we may assume that R is a semi-local ring, that II iH eontained in the Jacobson radical m of R and that R is dominated by R'. Let R" be the integral closure of R in Ii/. We first prove the :tHsertion for R" instead of R'. Let x be an clemcnt of a which is different from zero and let YI , ... , Y t be arbitrary elements of R". Then Nand R[YI, ... , Ytl are IVlaeaulay rings, and therefore length R "~/xR = f..l(xR), length R R[Yl/l:R[yj = f..lR(xR[y]). By (2:3.4), we have f..l(:cR) = f..lHCxR[y]), whence we have
n
length R/rR
=
length R R[yJ/:l:R[y].
Hince the Yi are arbitrary, we see that length R R" IxR" .:::; length RlxR, hence the assertion is proved for RI! instead of R'. Therefore, we may l'8place R with RI!. Thus, we assume that R = R". Then the assumptions in (33.1) are satisfied by Rand R ' , whence R = R', and the asHertion is proved in the general case. We note that the derived normal ring R' of a local integral domain of altitude 1 is not necessarily a finite module. See Example 3 in the Appendix; cf. Exercise 1 below. An integral domain R is called a Krull ring if the following two conditions are satisfied; (1) If ~ is a prime ideal of height 1 in R, then R~ is a Noetherian valuation ring. (2) An arbitrary principal ideal aR (a 'F 0) of R is the intersection of a finite number of primary ideals of height 1. (33.8) The condition (2) above is equivalent to the following two conditions: (2.a) Every principal ideal of R has only a finite number of prime divisors ~ such that height ~ = 1.
lin (~~,I,)
U
!'dllllll
\1 1'/1/1 111'1'1'
1111 1"'1//1/'
1f/('tI/ii
u,llll'iJ,';hl. I ill 11',
/1 ' (' /IIII'!'
nIl 11'11'
1'1'11111': AHHl/illI' Ihal. (:!) l,oldH, (:2,11.) IluldH II.\' (7':,), ~('I. /) nUll 1('1. ('Id ((', (I, ( It,) II(' 11.11 n.l'hiLI'HI'y ('11'111I'liI, III' n, 'I'lli'll ('Up ~ (lNI' 1'01' allY pl'illln idl'al p or III~igh L I, WIl(~III'(\ (: ( n((LU p n h~), alld (,/, iN 111.~t. illI,n(,~I~I'liOIl l'oillc:iilnN wiLh (IN by I:OlldiLiOlI (2) by virLllI: of ((Ui), WIWIlI:I~ (:lrI C n, and we RCO Chat R = f), whidl prOWH Lhl: validil.y of (2,1», Conversely, assume that (2.a) and (2,1» hold alld /1:1. (!, 1)(: :til clement of R which is not zero. Set II = n(aR p' n R) whl:rn pi rUll::; over all prime divisors of aR such that height pi = 1. Wn havI: only to prove that a = aR, hence that a C aU. Let b be all arbitrary clement of ll, If Pis a prime ideal of height 1 and if p -F pi for ally pi, then a ~ p, whence aRp = Rp. Therefore, we see that b E a/t,p for any p (height p = 1), whence bla E nR" = R, and beaR. ThuR, the proof is complete. We note that: (:~:3.4) A Krull ring is a normal ring. A Nocthcrian normal ring 1:8 a Kr'ull ring. Proof: The first assertion followA from I'olldition (1) and (2,h), while the last assertion follows from (12,9). (:~3.5) Let R be an integral domain with field oJ qu.otients K and assume that a set F of Noetherian valuati()n rings V of K 8ati.~fie8 the Jollowing two conditions: (1) R is the intersection of all V E F. (2) If a (E R) is not zero, then there are only a finite number oj V in F such that a is non-unit in V. Let S be a multiplicatively closed subset of R such that 0 ~ S and let F' be the subset of F consisting of those V in which every element of S is a unit. Then we have the equality Rs = v EF' V. Proof: Let D be the last intersection. Since Rs C D obviously, we have only to prove that D C Rs. Let cld (c, d E R) be an arbitrary element of D. Let VI, ... , Vr be the set of V E F in which d is a non-unit; we renumber them so that Vi E F' if and only if i :; s. For each i > s, there is an clement Si of S which is non-unit in Vi. If m is sufficiently large, we have sci d E V j for every j with s = (ss+l ... . . . 8r)'n. TheIl scld E V for any V E F, whence seld E R. Therefore eld E Rs. 11.111/
n
(33.6)
THEOREM:
Let R be an integral domain. Then there is an F
(1111\ 1"I'lill! V
117
fin ill (:I:\.f)) 1/ (/1/(1 II///ll if N in (/ /1/'1/1/ 1'///(/. /1/ IIII/i f'ltW, Nil is 1/, ///1'/// lu'l' 4 /1' IIII' /'/'/'/'ll Ill'i/l/(' itlm.! ).1 /d' IU'i(/hi li/l. U. hoof: If N iH /I, 1\/'1111 "illg, Lhnll I.II(~ Hd of U~ , P (willg JlI'illw id(~al" of \wigliL I, HII.Li"fil'H I.hn (',olldi(.ioIlH 1'01' ]I'. Co II v
(33,7) If V is a Noetherian valuation ring of a field L and if K is a K is also a Noetherian valuation ring. subfield of L, then V Proof: Let a be an element of K. Then either a E V or a-I E V,
n
IIH
r)
n
n
\' 1\ 01' II I , I' 11, IVllil'll HIIOWN 1,11/1.1. I' II ir~ /I, valllll,l.ioll I'illg, 1"01' (,I('III('liI,H 1/, I, of 1', (/1' c: Id' if nlld oilly if 1//11 iN ill thl! Ilinxilllll.l iil('II,1 111 of I', WIHIII('(' II/II ( Iii 1\'). 'l'hllH a.V C IN iH ('l{lIivnll!lIl. 10 Nayillg 1.11:1.1. fI.( \' 1\) C Ii( V 'l'll(m~ I'm!!, I.hl! lII:txillllllll nOll(liLioll ill V illlpli!!H I.ImL ill II 1\, wllinh pmV!!H i.he :LHHeI'Lioli.
WIH'III'I' 1/ (
n
n ('" n n /\). n
(3;).8) Let R be an integral domain and lot J!' be a family oJ prime ide(ll8 of R such that, for any element a of R, and fur any prim(: dVl!isor ~ oJ aR, there is a q E F such that ~ C q. Then R = n qE F Rq . Proof: The inclusion R C nRq is obvious. Let alb (a, b E R) be an arbitrary element of nRq and set c = bR:aR. alb E:: Rq implietl that bRq:aR q = R q, hence that cR q = Rq. Assume for a moment that C -F R and let ~ be a prime divisor of c. Let p be an arbitrary element of ~. Then, there is an element y ~ C such that py E c. ,Then pya E bR. But, since y ~ c, we have ya ~ bR, and we see that p itl a zero divisor modulo bR. Therefore, there is a prime divisor ~' of bR such that ~ C ~', hence there is a q E F such that ~ C q, whence cR q C ~Rq -F Rq , which is a contradiction. Therefore c = R, namely, alb E R. Thus, the assertion is proved.
(33.9) COROLLARY: If R is an integral domain, then R m runs over all maximal ideals of R.
=
nR
11t
if
(33.10) THEOREM: Let R be a Noetherian integral domain and let R' be the derived normal ring of R. Then: (1) R' is a Krull ring and (2) if ~ is a prime ideal of R, then there are only a finite number of prime ideals ~' of R' such that ~ = ~'n R, and, for any such ~', R' I~' is an almost finite integral extension of R/~. Proof : We consider, first, the case where R is a local ring and ~ is the maximal ideal of R. Let R* be the eompletion of R and let n* he the radical of R*. Set 8 = R* In*. Sinee n* n R = 0, R is regarded as a subring of S. Since any nOll-zero element a of R is not a zero divisor of R* by (18.1), a is not ill any minimal prime diviflor of zero of R*, whence a is not a zero divisor in S. Thus, the field of quotienttl K of R is a subring of the total quotient ring L of 8. Let 8' be the integral closure of Sin L. We want to show first that R' = S' K. The inclusion R' C S' K is obvious. Assume that alb (a, b E R) is in S' K. Then, since alb is integral over S, there are elements c~, '" ,c~ of S such that (alb)n + c~(alb)n-l + ... + c~ = O. Let E R* be such that c~ = c7 modulo n*. Then we have an +
n
ci
n
n
I I \I III 1 " . 1 I':~II" I 11'1', ~ill('(\ 11+ if! lIilpol'('IIi" 1-101110 I)I'IV/'I' of UdH III.HL HIIIII 1)I'I'OIlI('H 11('1'0, 1V1i('III'(' 1.11('1'(' 11.1'11 ('I(,IIII'IIi,H d'i , ... , tI:~, or Itl. HII('1i l,lill.L fI.'" 1 d'i'II'" III 1 . . , 1 d:~Ji'" O. WII('III:O n'" ( ( L't (/'" 't,'lt n U, 11.1111 IliiH III.,d, idnal iN 2:)" a'" ii/a by (17.\)), wliil'il ililply Lllal. 1,11('1'(' 111'1' (,I('III/'lti,H til, .• , , Ii,,, of R such that (/."'·1 diU'" III + .,. 11",/1''' 0, alld alb iH integral over R, hence II/II ( NI :l.lld 1.I1(~ <'qllality N' '" 8' K is proved. Let pi , ... , p; lin \.Iw pl'imn diviHOI'H or iI*. Theil L iH the direct sum of the fields of I(lIoLiclltH of U* /jJi lw,d 8' is the direct sum of the derived normal l'illl!;S of R* /jJi . Since R* /jJi is a complete local ring, S: is a finite (W/jJi)-module, by (32.1). Let ei be the identity of K i • For an 1I,l'hitrary prime ideal qi of height 1 in S:, (S:)q*i is a Noetherian vltluation ring, because is a Noetherian normal ring. Set o(q;) = /(1 + .. ' + K i - 1 + (S:)q*i + K i +1 + ... + K r • Then we see that ehe intersection of all possible o(qi) becomes SI. Therefore, we have It = n(K n o(q":)). It is obvious that a E K is in K n o(qi) if and only if aei E S;;, hence K n o( qi) is isomorphic to Kei n (S:) q: , which implies that K n 0 (q i) is a Noetherian valuation ring, by (33.7). Thus R' is the intersection of Noetherian valuation rings 'J( o(qi) of K. If a E RI (a -F 0) is a non-unit in o(qi), then it rollows that a E S~ + .. , + S~-l + q; + S~+l + ... + S;, and therefore there are only a finite number of such 0 (qi ). Thus R' is a Krull ring in this case. Let Y1 , ... , y t be arbitrary elements of R' and consider R[y] = R[Y1, ... , y t]. R[y] is a semi-local ring, whose completion is generated by R* and the Yi . Therefore SI is the integral closure in L of R*[y] modulo its radical. Since this is true for any y, and since the completion of a semi-local ring having u maximal ideals is the direct sum of u local rings, we see that the number of maximal ideals of R' is at most r, and furthermore, the maximal ideals of S' lie over those of R'. Whence the assertion is proved for the case of a local ring R and its maximal ideal jJ. Now we consider the general case. Let S be the c:omplement of jJ in R. Then we see that R: is the derived normal ring of Rs = R~. Therefore, by what was proved above, R~ is a Krull ring and furthermore R~ has only a finite number of maximal ideals p' and R:/jJl is finite over Rs/pR s , which implies the last assertion in our theorem. Furthermore, since jJ is arbitrary, for any given prime ideal ql of height 1 in R I , applying the above for p = ql R, we see that R~, is a Krull ring, which shows that R~, is a Noetherian valuation ring. Furthermore, we have R' = where 1';11"
l ')
+-
8;
n
Ie
S:
n
n
nR;, ,
I ~~( )
p' I'IIIIH (1\'('1' 11.11 11I1I."iIIiHI idl\/dll of It", 11,\' (:;;\.\) I, \VIII'III'I' "" rlU:I, \Vitl'I'I' q' I'IIIIH 0\'1'1' 11,11 Pl'illll' iill'/i.l1I of IlI'i/l;itl, I ill h~', !.y LlII' fwd, I.it:!'!' 1111' "';,,11,1'1' 1\1'It1ll'iIlI!;N. 'J'itl'I'dol'I', hy (:1:1.:1), il, l'I'lllniIiH oilly 1,0 PI'OVI' LI,,('/, /l,1I,V pl'illnipal iil('al flH' 01' H' linN 01l1,V II. lillil.l\ 111IIH!.I'1' 01' IlIillilll:l.l Pl'illll' i1iviHol'H. Nillnl~ N\n\ iN Nodhl\/'in,1I HIIiI Hilll',I~ h~' iH i,J1I~ i1(,l'ivl'd 1101'11111,1 I'illl!; 01' U\n\, WI~ limy aHNlIflW LiIa,1. a ( U. aN has only a lillil.(\ IIIIIII!.I'I' 01' prilll(: diviNOI'N, hellee by LIte lillil.eneHH of lyillg-ov(~1' I>l'illw iill'nli.; PI'OVI\i1 abov(~, the lillit(\]WNI'> of minimal prime diviNon; of aR' l'oliowH 1'1'(l1\l Lit() following lemma. (:1:1.11) With the same R, a, and R' as above, if ~' is a minimal I)/'il//,I: d£m:,w/, (d aR', then ~ = ~' R is a prime divisor of aR. 1'1'001': Lot /) be the eomplcment of ~ in R. Then ~'R~ is a minimal pt'illln diviHOI' of aR~ , and ~Rs = \)'R~ Rs . As is easily seen by the pI'illlnry (k(~omposition of aR, ~ is a prime divisor of aR if and only if ~IUp iH a prime divisor of aRp . Therefore, by the fact that R~ is the i1Pl'iv()d lIol'malring of Rs , we may assume that R is a local ring with IllH.ximal ideal ~. Therefore R' is a Krull ring, in this case, whence it('ighl. \)' = 1. Since ~ = lJ' R is maximal, we see that ~' is also a lIIaximal ideal by (10.7). Let x be an element of ~' which is not in lI,ny other maximal ideal of R'; x exists because R' has only a finite 1lllIlIhm' of maximal ideals by our assumption. Set R" = R[x] and p" = \)' R". Then ~' is a unique prime ideal of R' which lies over ~l". Therefore height ~" = height ~' = 1 and ~" is maximal by (10.8). COIlHidcr the completion R"* of R". R"* is the direct sum of compldn local rings Ri where RI is the completion of R;, . Let e be the id(~lltity of RI . Let R* be the completion of R. Then R"* = R*[xJ. There is an elcment b 7"" 0 of R such that bR" ~ R, whence bR"* C /t,*[xJ. Since height ~" = 1, there is an n such that (~RI)n C bRI' Therefore \)ne C bR I C R*, whence ~tne C btRI C bt-IR*. Assume for a moment that ~ is not a prime divisor of bR. Then ~ is not a prime divisor of btR for any t, by (12.6), hence \J.- contains an element p which is not a zero divisor modulo btR (in R), whence modulo btR* in R*. Therefore, the fact that ~tn(~ne) = ~(t+l)ne C btR* implies that ~ne C btR* for any t, which is impossible because nt btR* = O. Thus ~ is a prime divisor of bR, hence of aR by (12.6). Thus the lemma is proved, and the proof of (33.10) is complete.
n
n
n
n
(33.12) THEOREM: The derived normal ring R' of a Noetherian integral domain R of altitude 2 is again Noetherian. Proof: We have only to prove that if ~' is a prime ideal of R ' , then
1'11,\ l"I'I'il!
I~ll
V
pi lilili IIlillill' lill.IIiH, II.\' \il'lll(I III' (:\.1) (1./11'111'1'111 III' (~oll('II). WI! Iin-iL 1'1'(1\'1' 11)(' I'II,H(' \VIiI'I'I' )\' IH lilli, IIIn.xilllll,l, II.HHlllllillf!: I.hal. I~V(~I'y maximal iill'II,1 IIar1 /I. lillill' 1,11,,"1', WI' Iliay aHHIIIIII~ I.hal. pi -F O. Set P = pi R. '1'1i1'11 ~) iH 11111. III/I,xillial by (10,7), wlwlI<:e height p = 1. Let a be an 1,llHlIl'lti, oi' pi which iH 1I0t ill any other prime ideal of R' which lies IIVI~I' p, Nillcn Hlal is Noetherian, we may replace R with R[aJ. Thus w(~ may aHHlime that pi is the unique prime ideal lying over p, Since N~, iN a Noetherian valuation ring, there is an element b of pi such I.hat bit;, = p'R;,. Considering R[b], we may assume that b E R, whence that p'R;, = pR;,. Set q' = pRI:p', q' contains bRI:p'. Since H' is a Krull ring, bR ' = pi n q~ n . , . n q~ with primary ideals q~ (~ pi) of height 1. Since p' is the unique prime ideal lying over p, q; n R is not contained in p, whence q' n R, which contains (q~ n R) ... (q~ R), is not contained in p. Since q' R contains p, we R) = 0, Let q'* be the radical see that q' R ::J P and depth (q' of q'. Since depth (q' R) = 0, we see that q'* is the product of a finite number of maximal ideals, say m~ , '" , m~ . Since each m~ has a finite basis, we sec that q,*n has a finite basis and that R/q,*n ii:< Noetherian by the theorem of Cohen, and furthermore that q' contains some q,*n. It follows that q' has a finite basis. q'/p'q' is an R'/p'module, Since q' has a finite basis, q' / p' q' is a finite module, whence its 8ubmodule (p' q')/p'q' is a finite module because R' /p' is Noetherian by the theorem of Cohen. Since p' q' cpR' c p' q', we can consider (p' q')/pR', and it is a finite R'/p'-module. Since p has a finite basis, we see that p' q' has a finite basis. Since R' / p' and R' / q' are Noetherian, we see that R'/(p' n q') is Noetherian by (3.16), and we see that p' / (p' n q') has a finite basis, and therefore p' has a finite basis because p' n q' has a finite basis. Thus, it remains only to prove that every maximal ideal of R' has a finite basis. Let m' be an arbitrary maximal ideal of R'. By the same reason as stated above for p', we may assume that,m' is a, unique prime ideal lying over m = m' R. Then R'/mR' = Rm,/mRm" Therefore we may assume that Rand R' are local rings. If height m = 1, then the assertion is true by the theorem of Krull-Akizuki (33,2), and we assume that height m = 2. Let a, b be a system of parameters of R and let x be a transcendental element over R, If we know that m'R' (x) has a finite basis, say II, , .. , ., , ,Is (F I{[.rD, then we see that 1l1' is generated by the coefficients of I, , and therefore 111' has a finite basis. Therefore it is sufficient to show that m'R' (x) has a finite basis. Since aR and bR have no common
n
n n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
'l'III'HIII\ III" I'IIMI'I.!!)'I'I>! 1,111'\1, 1111\1111\ Illillilllni 111'illll' dil'illlll'H, 11'1' HI'I' LilaL
I/Ii"
/1.1111
1,1i"
1111,\'1' 110 ('0111111011
"'y IIII'
l',wl,H Cilll,j, It" ill I/. 1\1'111' rill/!; I\.l\d illIl,\. III' iH Lill' IllIiqlll' 1I111,xil\\H1 illl'HI or U'. WI' \1'/1.1\1, 10 :dlll\V 1,11/1,1. II,/' I I, gl'III'I'li,I,('cl a primp i
Ii'[xJlp* = R'[li/al (:J: IIlOdlllo p* . , ,- II/It). 'l'hl'll l.l* i~4 gl'llnl·l\.LI'" by elements cx + d with c(b/a) = d by (11.1:l). Nilll:n aN' alld 'IU'lta'/n no common prime divisors, we see that c EaR', wlteIl(:(: p* i:-: g(:Il(:ml.(·1 I by ax b. Therefore, we see that ax b generates a primo idett! ill Ii'ex). Consider R* = R(x)/( (ax + b )Ii'(x) R(x)). This ring i:-: Noetherian and of altitude 1. Therefore R' (x) / (ax + b )Ii' (x) i:-: Noetherian by the theorem of Krull-Akizuki, which implies th"L m'R'(x)/(ax + b )R'(x), hence m'R'(x), hence m', too, have finite bases, which completes the proof. We note that there is a local integral domain Ii of altitude 2 such that it has non-Noetherian integral extensions contained in its derived normal ring and that there is a local ring of altitude 3 whose derived normal ring is not Noetherian; see Examples 4 and 5 in the Appendix.
+
+
n
EXERCISES: 1. Let R be a semi-local integral domain of altitude 1, and let R* be the completion of R. Prove that R is analytically unramified if and only if the derived normal ring R' of R is a finite R-module. Prove also that the number of the prime divisors of zero in R* coincides with that of maximal ideals in R'. (N ote that the above assertions are not true in general if we do not assume that altitude R = 1; see Examples 6 and 7 in the Appendix.) 2. Let R be aN oetherian integral domain of altitude 1 and with field of quotients K. Prove that if L is a finite algebraic extension of K and if R' is a ring such that R k: R' k: L, then there is an integral extension R" of R such that R' is a ring of quotients of R".
34. Chains oj prime ideals Let R be a ring and let p and q be prime ideals of R such that p C q. A chain of prime ideals po C Pl C . " C pr in R is called a maximal chain of prime ideals between p and q if po = p, Pr = q and if there is no prime ideal p' of R such that Pi-l C p' C Pi for any i = 1, ... , r. A maximal chain of prime ideals bet'('1een a minimal prime divisor of zero and a maximal ideal is called a maximal chain of prime ideals in R. We say that Ii satisfies the chain condition for prime ideals if, for any prime ideals p C q, and for any integral extension R' of Rq/pR q , every maximal chain of prime ideals in R' has length equal to altitude R'. Note that this is equivalent to saying that if R* is integral over
I'll·' 1"1'11111
V
Ii' IIIHI il' \1', q' 111'1' ,,1'ill'l' illl'nitl OJ' 11"1. IllIdl I.IlIi.I. p' ( q' Hlld HIh'Ii 1.1111.1, \1 Ii', II q' n Ii, IIII' 11'11/1:111 (II' 1111.1' III/I.,illll'" dlll,ill 01' prillI('
»' ()
illl'al:-1 Ill'tlVl'l'll p' Hlld q' iN 1'!j11/l,1 1.0 III'ighl. q/\). II. iH oll\'ioll,y 11.1' 0111' 1I1'lillil,illll Llml.: (:\.1.1) If (/. 1'/1/.(/ U 8(/J,.,~/il'8 IIII' dUI/n I'II/I·di/.illl/. fli/' 1J1"I:nu: 1:d('(!,l.~ ll!.I'//. 111.1' I·III/.d//.-ill!/, i" 8/1,1";.~/i/'(1 hI 1111/1 U,~/n' N.~ , 'Wh.ere U' £s (zn Ol)(;r-r1:nu I~r h~ 8/1.th. aU/,/, N' ·i8 '/;nl('!lm,{, (J/lI"I' N, II' £8 (/'1/. 'irie(zt of R', and S £s a mulli-
pl-iw,/,';,)(:l!/ dosed 811.1)8(:/ (~r h~', III O"del' Co diHt:IlHH Lhe condition, we introduce the following i,()!'IllillOlogy for II. ring it. We say that R satisfies the first chain condition for prime ideals if nvery maximal chain of prime ideals in R has length equal to altitude I( We say that R satisfies the second chain condition for prime ideals iI', for every minir.:ml prime divisor ~ of zero in R, and for any integral ()x(,ension R' of R/~, the length of any maximal chain of prime ideals in R/ is equal to altit.ude R . .1'\01.8 that the validity of the second chain condition for prime ideals in II. ring R whose altit.ude is finite is equivalent to (a) every maximal ideal m of R has height equal to altitude f(, and (b) R satisfies the chain condition for prime ideals. We note that, though the validity of the second chain condition for prime ideals implies the validity of the first one, the converse is not true. See Example 2 in the Appendix. We note furthermore that a ring R whose altitude is finite satisfies the chain condition for prime ideals if and only if for every minimal prime divisor ~ of zero in R and for every maximal ideal m of R eontaining ~, the ring R nt/~R '" satisfies the second chain condition for prime ideals. Therefore, it is of great importance to discuss the second chain condition for prime ideals in local integral domains. (34.2) Assume that R is a subring of a ring R' and that R' is integral over R. If R' satisfies the chain condition, or the first or the seccmd chain condition, for prime ideals, then R does, too. The proof is immediate from (10.9). (34.3) A Noetherian integral domain R satisfies the second chain ccmdition for prime ideals if and cmly if the first chain condition is satisfied by every finite integral e:ctension R" of R. Proof: The only if part is obvious by definition. Assume the validity of the first, ehain condition in any R" as above and let R' be an arbitrary integral extension of R. Let 0 = ~~ C ~~ C ... C ~~ be a maximal ehain of prime ideals in R'. Set ~i = \.1: R. Then there are only
n
1:.'.1
'1'111111
III I'
I iii' I '(
1~11'I.I'I'I'I'1
1,( 11'1 I, III NIIII
a lillil(~ 1IIIIIdll'I' or Pl'illl(' iill'!!.lrl ill It" ",itil'it Iii' 01'('1' )I, , II,V (:1:1.10), whencn UWI'(~ iN a lillil.p ('.\I,(~IINioll h'" or Ii' (/i" c: Ii') Nlll'it Llilii. ('VI'I'V ~~ is the unique prillw ilkal or h~' l,Villl!: OVI'I' -~I;: ~: nu", Nilll:(' ~~' c ~~ c '" c ~; i:s a maximal (·ltaill or pl'illIP idnalN ill h~" II,Y LlII' going-up theorem, we see that r = all.il.ll
n
n
l'II,II"I'IIiI/ V pl'illl(' di\'illlll' III' ~,I'I'II ill 11,1' "lIlllpll'Lilili IIi' Ir' I,nrl dl'pl" 1'11111'" III Hili 1.111\1' U. (:\,U,) If It' i8 II I//II/si IIII/lIi,/'I'tI 81'II/i III/'Irl ,.ill(/ /lilt! (f' )l iN /I 1/1'/11/( itll'lIl I~r H, Iltl'/I. Nip i,~ III/It.~i IIIIII/i,/'I't! 1111/1 11"igltl, )1 I I\I'pll, )l ",ll.il.lldn N. 1'1'001': 1,1,1, It~* III' 1.11(' 1'lIlIlpll'Lillli III' U nlld 11'1. )1" III' HII tl,d,iLI'II,I',I' Inillilllni pl'illll' diviHol' or pN*. ~ill(,(' LI'I' 1.111'11/'/'111 or 1.1·:/,II.'iil.ioll 1IIIIdii 1'01' II~ alld /{I', WI! H('(: 1.":1.(, II('ig"(' P III'ig"l. p'I' by (:J:J.!I). ~illi'" It'+ HII.LiHlil:H t}1(: lil'HI. dlaill l'olidiLioll I,y (;;,1.,1), WI' HI'I: 1.11:1.1. d.,pl.l, polII.ILitudo R - Iwight p* = :dLil.lltin U - II(:ighl. p. ~ill':I' i.I,iH iH 1.1'111' 1'01' any minimal primo diviHorH p* of pU* and Hill(:(: u'I,/~"rl' iii I./rl' I:ompletion of R/~, by (17.D), wo H(:(: (,haL tlnp!.h p* 11,ILiLlldl' N*/~R* = altitude R/~ = depth ~ and thai. LlH: :tHHW'i,ioli iN 1.1'111"
(34.6) THEOREM: Every quasi-unmixed semi-local .,.ill!! U {he second chain condition for prime ideals.
.~lIlii';.fil'N
Proof: We see easily the validity of the first ehaill I',olldi!.ioll ill "'. by (34.5) and by induction on altitude R. Let. p be all nl'hil.l'HI'.\' minimal prime divisor of zero in R. Then, sinec height p = 0, ii, 111I1d:1 that depth ~ = altitude R. Therefore, by the remark givoll abovI' HII" by (34.3), we have only to prove that every finito int(:gl':l.l I'X/.l'III-lioll R' of R/~ is quasi-unmixed, which is easy because Hlp iH IIIIH.Hi 1111 mixed by (34.5).
(34.7) COROLLARY: Assume that R is an unmixed semi-lu('(f} illll'lIl'IIl domain and that R' is an integral extension of R. A chw:n I({ 111'11111' ideals ~~ C ~~ C .,. C ~; in R' is maximal if and only if (~l:' n N) I (~~ n R) c ... c (~; n R) is a maximal chain of prime id(,(),f,,~ ill N. Furthermore, if a' is an ideal of R', then height a' = heigh!. (il' n h'), Proof: The first is an easy consequence of the validity of (,11/: Hl't'IIll(l chain condition for prime ideals. Consequently, the last aHi-\(:I'i.ilili i," true if u' is a prime ideal, whence the proof of (10.14) can hi: applil'd, which proves the last assertion.
(34.8) COROLLARY: If R is a homomoTphic image of a locally J\1 (/,{'/II/ lay ring, then R satisfies the chain condition fOT prime ideals. If II/I'ilil'/' more R is an integral domain and if R' is a finite z'ntegral exlen,~':/I11 I~r R, then for an ideal a' of R', it holds that height a' = height (n' n fa'). We add here the following result on unmixedness of 10call'illgN:
(34.9) THEOREM: A local z'ntegral domaz'n z's unmz'xed homomorphic image of a Macaulay local ring.
~r
£l i8
II
I~(I
'1'111'111111
IIII' 1'()MI'I,I'i'I'H 1,1)('11, IIINIIII
1'1'001': AHHllinn LliaL p iN /I. WillI(' idllll.1 or II, I\III,I'II.IIIII..Y 101'/1.1 I'illg 11'. LeI, l' 1><: til(: I,('iglll, or ~I Hlld 11:1, .1'1, .. , ,.1', III' 1,11'IiII'IIiH or )l HilI'" LilaL a = xj( is or hnighL r (b'y (lUi)). Ld N* 1)(1 Lhll 1·.OlllpII'LiOI\ or u. Then R* is a Macaulay ring, hCII('(1 (.Iw IUllnixl'dlll'"" (.1i<:w·(lIl\ hold" in R* by (25.6), whieh implic:,; HUt(, (lV('I'.; Pl'illll' divi"o\' or nN* i" a minimal prime divisor, and R* I aR* is lUunix(ld (d. 1';x(ln:i,,(1 ill *21)). Since ~ is a minimal prime divisor of a, every prime divisor of pH* is a prime divisor of aR*, by (18.11), and therefore it follow:,; 1.Ila(, R* I~R* if) unmixed. Thus the assertion is proved.
L
(34.10) COROLLARY: Assume that R is a Macaulay semi-local ring. For an ideal a of R, Ria is an unmixed semi-local ring if and only if every prime divisor of a is of height which is equal to height a.
35. Localities We say thai, a rilll!; It iH or fin'dely (J(!/I'{!'ml(!d l//'l)(; OWl' It rill/!: h' if is a ring of qIlOti(:lItH of a filliLniy l!;ellcmLnd I'illl!; N* OV(,I' N; N' iH said to be of ,ft:r~itc type over H, if fUI'L1Wl'ffiOI'C U* (',all III: <"iIOe'('11 III be integral over R. A ring R is called an affine ring over It rilll!; I il' H iH :1.11 illli'/!~I'al domain and if Ii is finitely generated over J, w\I(HI(:n I IIIIIHI, 11(' 1111 integral domain in this case, A quasi-local illi.q!;I'al dOIl\Hili which ill of finitely generated type over a ring 1 is ealbl a {/lm.!il/! OV('I" I, Such an I as above is called a grrnmd ring of (.it(: :dlilln rill/!: ot 1"1' locality, Note that local rings which are UH(:d ill IIHII:I.I : t.i/!:('\I l"iI,i(: /!:I' ometry are localities over fields, which we (::1.11 (l,/'ye/n'w';(:-IJI'/lIII('/I'i('(r/ local rings, In ring-theoretic formulations of all!;rlil'ai(: /!:(\OIli('I.I''y, i L iH sometimes convenient not to restrict oneself to I(H:aliLinH hilL Co ('Oil sider local rings which are of finitely generated (.ypn ovnl' fi(.JdH (II' some kinds of rings, But, most of the import.ant rCHtilLH Oil 1.11<'111 11.1'(' conveniently formulated in the case of integral domaillH 0/' HI'(: (1('I'i V('( I easily from that case, and this is the reason we defined n HIH'(',ial 1.('1'111 "locality," Of course, we do not have any good results wiLllollL allY restriction on the ring I, Since the case where I is a field iH I'aLil<'l' 1.011 specialfrom the ring-theoretic point of view, we shall Pl'OV(: i/II/1Ol'I all I reslllts coneerniIlg algebrltie-geomei,rieal loeal rings for (lIMn /!:('II<'I'nl CaRt'S in thiN ehapter, vVe say that an integral domain I satisfies the finitcn(',~8 ('/III/iii ill II for integral e:ctensions if every almost finite integral exkllHiol1 or Ii!: a finite extension, We note that: (35,1) If an integral domain I satisfies the finiteness c/il/,d,:li/i1/. f/ll' integral extensions, then so does every ring of quotients of I, The proof is straightforward and we omit it, A field L is called a function field over a ground ring 1 if 1.1 iN Lllo
a'
[127]
llliII'~"IJ'I'/lII'
I,IH',\/' IIINdll
(inl" or 'il/nLi('IILH or nil 11,1Ii11(1 rill!!; 0\'1'/' /, II' /, iH Lhll 1il'Id or '1l/oLjI'III.H II. I'illg It: wllil'h iH 11,11 11,llilll' I'illg 01' /I, IIII'II,liLy 0\'1'1' I, Lhl'll WI' Hay Lilal. I.; iH I.h(~Jl/,lId'';/iI/..lidd 4 N Hlld thaI. h~ iH /1,11 (/./Iill/' ,.illi/ 01' a 1/lI'IIIil!1 of L. We begin with the following lillil.clIPHH I.hnol'm'" 1'01' polYllollli:d l'illgH:
or
(35.2) THEOREM. Let Xl , ... , X" be algebraically indepenti/:nt cl/:ments over a Noetherian integral domain I. If I sati.'!jies the .linitenr:N'~ condition Jor integral extensions, then so does I[x] = /[;1::1, ... , XII]' Proof. Let L be an arbitrary finite extension of the field of quotient.H K of I[xl. We have only to prove that an arbitrary integral extension R of I[xl contained in L is a finite I[xl-module. By our assumption for I, we may assume that I is normal. If L is separable over K, then the assertion is obvious by (10.16). When L is inseparable over K, take elements al , ... , a r of I and a power q of the characteristic p of I such that L' = L( ai/q, ... , a~/q, xi/q, ... , x;;q) is separable over K' = K(ai/ a, .,. , a~/q, xi/q, .,. ,x~/q). Let l' be the derived normal ring of I[ai, q , ••• , a~/ql. Then l' is finite over I by our assumption, q and 1'[xi, , ... , x~/ql is finite over I[xl. Since L' is separable over K', q q the integral closure of 1'[xi/ , ... ,x~/a] in L' is finite over I'[xi, , ... , ... , x~/ql, whence it is finite over I[x]. Therefore R is finite over I[xl by (3.1). (35.3) ThEOREM. Let A be an affine ring over a Noetherian integral domain I. Assume that I satisfies the finiteness condition for integral extensions and that the derived normal ring of Ap is a finite A~-module for every prime ideal ~ of A. Then the derived normal ring A' of A is a finite A-module. Proof. There are elements ZI , ••• , Zr of A which are algebraically independent over I and an element a (~O) of I such that A[l/a] is integral over I[l/a, zj = I[l/a, ZI, ... , zrl by (14.4). Let L be the field of quotients of A. Then the int.egral closure of 1[1/ a, z] in L iF; A'[l/a] and is a finite I[l/a, z]-modulc by O~5.2). Thus we see that A'[l/al is a finite A [l/a)-module, wh(m(:e Lhere are a finite number of elementH b1 , •• ' , bs of A' fiuch that A'[l/a] = A[1/a, bl , '" , u.,j. Set Al = 11 [b 1 , ••• , b.,). If a iH a unit in 11, then the assertion is obvious and we assume that a is a non-unit in A. Let the prime divisors of aAI be ~1 , ••• , ~t. Then there are a finite number of clements Cl, ... , Cn of A' such that (Al)~JCl , ... , cu ] is normal for every ~i. We set A2 = A [b 1 , ••• , Us, Cl , ••• , cu]. A2 is a finite A-module. We prove here the following:
I ~.,) 1,1'1,
/I I II'
II. NOI'IIII'I'ilill I'illl!; 11111,1, 11,111, ,I~,
c:
/I
c:
,I'. '1'111'11 (
I
I
ii'
P il-l 110 I'1'illll' illl'lI.l or l'I'il1)lI, I ill II, 1.1\('11 11,\ i:1 H 1101'1111'" 1'11if/: 11,1111 ('J) if 1.111' illtl,,'lIdl'" prilll(' di\'i,YOI'~1 or (//1 /1.1'1' lj, , ,., , q" /l.llt! ii' til , " . , , .. , dot, 1101"1' 1'11'11\('111,1-1 or .1' HIll'h Lhll,L tl",ltI, , .. , , tI",1 iM Il0fllm\ fol' I'VI'I'Y q,', U\('II for /1.\1 IIoI·biLI'II.I'.\' illll)('d,kd prillII' dil'iNol' q' or flt1ltt, , ... , II",\, q' n H 1'011 Laille; NOIIII~ q i properly (q i C q' n H). IlId(',(~d, if a (I p, Ullm H~ 1'(IIIL:l.ill,Y I/It, alld fill ii':I. I'ill/!: or qlloLil'IILH oi' A'll/al, which implin,., LhaL HlJ il' 1I01'JIII'" ill Lhi,Y mSI'; ir I/. I p, ,'11'1, t)' = P n A, , pI! ='" P n /I~ . HiJ\(:': Iwi/!:h!' p = I, we Hnl~ LilaL p' iN H. prime divisol' of aA, by (:::l.ll) (by vit'LlI(~ of Lite goillg-Ilp LItI'OI'I'1I1 applied to 13 and A' with () c p). Tlwl'doJ'(', (A 2 )P" ie: lIonnal, !1,lld (A2)~" contain::; A', whence 13~ i::; a rillg of quotiClli,H or II' alld iN /I, lIormal ring, and (1) is proved. A::; for (2), sct q = q' H. Hilll:I' q' ii' an imbedded prime divisor of a13[d 1 , ••• , dwl, R[d[, .. , , tI'II!.,' ie: not a normal ring, by (12.9). By the same reaNOIl aN roJ' /I" above, we see that 13 q is not a normal ring, whence, hy vil'tt In 1'1' ( 1 ), we see that a13q has an imbedded prime divisor q" B q , wltil,1t must be some qi13q . Since 13q;[dl , ' " , tis] is a normal rillg, q 1',:\,\11101, be the qi , whence qi C q, and (2) is proved. Now we proceed with the proof of (35.3). Starting with Eo = .I,! , we eonstruct a sequence 13 i of rings as follows: \Vhen Bi ie: ddi I wd, let dl , ••• ,dw be as in (2) above, applied for 13 = 13 i , and Ret 8; II ~, Bi[dI , • , • ,dw]. Then, by the finiteneAs of the ascending ehain of prillll' ideals in A2 , we see that. there is a 13n such that a13n has no imbnddl'd prime divisor. Then the assertion is proved, beeause En iR nOJ'Ill:d, whence 13n = A', by the following lemma: (35.4) Let R be a Noetherian integral domain and let a (7""0) be an element oj R. Assume that R[l/a] is a normal ring and that Rp is a nor-
n
mal ring for every prime divisor p of aR. Then R is a normal ring. Proof. Let q be a prime ideal of height 1 in R. If a ~ q, then Rq ie: a ring of quotients of R[I/a] and is a normal ring. If a E q, then q is a minimal prime divisor of aR and R q is a normal ring. Let b ( 7""0) be an element of R and assume that bR has an imbedded prime divisor q. Since R[I/a] is a normal ring, bR[l/a] has no imbedded prime divisor, whence qR[l/a] = R[I/a], that is, a E q, which implies that q is an embedded prime divisor of aR by (12.6), which is a contradiction, and (35.4) is proved by virtue of (12.9). If I is a subring of an integral domain R, the trHnscendence degree of R over I is denoted by trans. degr R. We say that the altitude formula holds for an integral domain I if,
(It', III) 0\'('1' I, nll.jLlld(. Ii' I LI'HIIH, 11,"1111 I LI'/I,IIH. II('KI N.
1'111' lUI,\' illI'n1iL.v /l,ILil"ld(,
dl'glll,"I1/) U/III
(:lii.ii) "'III,;OIU':M. II (/1/. i",It'(/1'fI1 fili//llli", 1 is fl. hli///Ii//IIIJ'jihi/: ',:/1/(/.(//' III('ally M IU'/wlll.l/ '/"':n(/ III, 1.//1'1/, 1;'/: IIllill/d/' IIII'IIi'III(/, hllld,~ fill' I. jJ"urtlwrrnOTc, any !o(:(J,(,:ly N ()JWJ' 1 ',:,0.; a /i.O'I/I,/!II/III'II/ii/: iI/WI/(' /~r (/, )14 am,'//.lay ring, and c()ns(JqU/~ntly, the chain condition Jo'/' prinu: ,,:dnu.ls and t/U' altitude formula hold in R. /~r II.
Proof. There are algebraically independent elcmcntH ;/:1 , .• , , XII over M and prime ideals q C ~ of M[x] = M [Xl, ... , Xn] such that R = M[xh/qM[xh . Since M[x] is a locally Macaulay ring by (25.10), M[xh is a Macaulay ring, and R is a homomorphic image of a Macaulay ring, whence the last assertion follows from (34.8) and the first assertion. In order to prove the first assertion, we have only to prove the formula stated above for I and R, because R is arbitrary. We prove it by induction on n as follows: If n = 1, then the assertion is straightforward by the validity of the chain condition for prime ideals in any affine ring over I and, in particular, in M[x]. Assume that n > 1, and set B = I[xd/(q I[Xl]) , ~' = 111 B. Then altitude B~, + trans. degI/wnI) B/~' = altitude I(~'nI) + trans. deg[ B by the case n = 1, and altitude R + trans. degB/p' R/m = altitude B p' + trans. degB R. Since m 1 = ~' I, we prove the formula. Thus (35.5) is proved completely. As an application of (35.5) to general Noetherian integral domains, we can prove the following theorem:
n
n
n
n
(35.6) THEOREM. Let A be an affine ring over a Noetherian integral domain I and set r = trans. degI A. If ~ is a prime ideal of I and if ~' is a minimal prime divisor of ~A such that ~ = ~' n I, then trans. degI/~ A/~'
2:
r.
Proof. Let S be the complement of ~ in 1. Then considering Is and As, we may assume that (I, ~) is a local ring. We prove the assertion by double induction on height ~ and the number of generators of A over I. If height ~ :::; 1, then by our assumption, I is a Macaulay ring, whence by the altitude formula we prove the assertion in this case. Therefore, we assume that height ~ ~ 2. If height ~' T'" 1, then let q' be a prime ideal of A sueh that q' c ~', q' I -F 0 and such that height q' = 1. Sinc:e ~' is a minimal prime divisor of ~A, we see that q' n I -F ~. Sinec height q' = 1, q' ii:l a minimal prime divisor of (q I)A, whence by our induction on height ~, applied to q' I,
n
n
n
1'1111"1'1111/ 1'1
It'/q'
by 0111' illlilll',l.illll H,c,HI'I'l,illll iH 1.1'111' ill 1,liiN l'nNI', 11'1' 1I~lclllllll' LlmL IlI'iglil, ~l' I, LI'C ,1'1, , , , , ,I'", !In a H(~L of gl'III'l'al.ol'~ oi' ,I OVI'I' /, Ii' ,Ihl' iH 1101. algl'l>l'ai(~ OV(H' /Ip, Hay if ,(;, IIloilltio p' iH IIO!, algidH'ail" OVI~I' I Ip, U)(~II we eonHider A" = I[xI) Hlld ~I" ~I' n /1", Hilwe :1:1 modulo p" is transcendental over lip, W(~ HI~n I.haL ~l" ~c, pll" and Chat height p" :::;: height p by the altitude Lllnol'(~rn of Krllll :llld by the fact that a system of parameters of I~ gnncml.cH an ideal which is primary to p"A"~" in A"~", whence by our indudion on n applied to A over A" with the prime ideal p", we Hne i1wt trans, degA"w Alp' 2: trans, degA" A, Since trans, degrr~ II" Ip" = 1 and since trans, degr A" :::;: 1, we prove the assertion in Clii::; case. Therefore, we assume that Alp' is algebraic over lip. It Huffices to prove now that A is algebraic over I. Let A * be the derived Ilormal ring of A and let p* be a prime ideal of A * which lies over p', Then height p* = 1 by the going-up theorem, Since A * is a Krull I'ing by (;33,10), A:, i:,; a Noetherian valuation ring. Let K be the field of quotients of I and set B = A:, K, B is a Noetherian valuation ring by (33.7), Set C = B[A); this last ring is an affine ring over B, Set furthermore p** = p*A;. n Band p" = p*A;. n C, and let C* be the derived normal ring of C. Then obviously A * c C* C A;. , whence is a ring of quotients of C*, that is, = C: with r = p* A;, C*. It follows that r is a minimal prime divisor of p**C* and height r = 1. Since B contains I, Blp** contains lip, whence A;,/p*A;, is algebraic over Blp**. Therefore C*/r is algebraic over Blp**, whence C* is algebraic over B by (35,5) and by the fact that B is a Macaulay ring, which proves that A is algebraic over I. Thus the proof is complete, 1\'1' 111'(' 11111,1, 11'11.1111. dI'IJ:'il'l'III)
npplil'd III 'l'III'I'I'i'III'I',
P,'(
q' () /),
11'1' ~II'I' /1111.1
I'. '1'111'1'1·1'111'1',
/111'
n
A:.
n
A:.
36. Pseudo-geometric rings We say that a ring R is a pseudo-geometric ring if R is Noetherian and if, for every prime ideal p of R, Rip satisfies the finiteness condition for integral extensions. We note first that: (36,1) If R is a pseudo-gcometric ring, then every homomorphic image of R, every ring of quotients of R, and every ring which is a finite module over R arc pscwio-geometric rings, The proof i:,; :,;tmightfol'ward. (::)6.2) Let R be a semi-local integral domain and assume that p is a
I :I:~ Will/I' i"I'II/ I!!, /iI'i(/h/ I ill II' NIII'1i 111111 /i'p ill /I /11/11/1/1/111/ I'illfl· If P /N al/.oJy/.im.lly 1/1/.1'/('lIlIjil'" 1/.1/." if pl' i.~ II IIli/li/l/1l1 11,.//1/1' dillisor I!f' pH'f, R* being tlw (;mnJltl'l'ill/l, I!!, N, thl'//' h~I;' /8 1/ /111///(/,/.//11/. rin!/. Proof. Let w be an dement or \J whidl iH IIO!, iii p~N~\ . 'I'h(~11 pNp
wR~ , whence p*R;. = wR:• . Since w i" not a J1pr() diviHOt' ill N* hy (18.1), we see that is a valuation ring by (12.1). (36.3) Let R be a semi-local integral domain and let x (~O) be an element oj the Jacobson radical of R. Assume that xR has no imbedded prime divisor and that, for every prime divisor P of xR, P is analytically unramified and R~ is a valuation ring. Then R is analytically unramified. Proof. Let R* be the completion of R and let the prime divisors of xR be PI , ... , pr . By our assumption, and by (36.2), if the prime divisors of p;1l* are p7j (j = 1, ... ,n(i)), then eachp7j contains a prime divisor lj3;j of zero which is the kernel of the natural homomorphism from R* into the valuation ring R:. i i . Let n be the intersection of all the l.l3;j . Sinee the Pi are all the prime divisors of xli, we sec that the p7j are all the prime divisors of xR* by (18.11). Since 1j37j is contained in any primary ideal belonging to p7j , we see that n is contained in xR*. Since x is in the .Jacobson radical of R* and since n:xR*= n, we sec that 11 = by (4.3), which proves that the zero ideal of R* is semi-prime, i.e., R is analytically unramified.
R:.
°
(36.4) THEOREM. A pseudo-geometric semi-local integral domain R is analytically unramified. Proof. We prove the assertion by induction on I' = altitude R. Let R' be the derived normal ring of R. Then R' is a finite R-module by our assumption, whence R is a subspace of R' by (16.8). Therefore, it is sufficient to show that R' is analytically unramified. Since R' is pseudo-geometric, we may assume that R is normaL If r = 0, then the assertion is obvious, and we assume that r ;::: 1. Let x (~o) be an element of the .Jacobson radical of R. Then, by (36.3) applied to this x, we see that R is analytically unramified, which proves the assertion. (36.5) THEOREM. If R is a pseudo-geometric ring, then every ring which is of finitely generated type over R is a p8e1ldo-geometric ring. Proof. By the definition, and by (:36. J ), we have only to prove that if R is a pseudo-geometric integral domain, then every affine ring A over R is a pseudo-geometric ring. Using induction on the
1'11.11"1'1':11 1'1 111I/lillI'l' of J!;I'IIPI'II,i,ol'f: of ,I, WI' 1111.\'1' 11111,1' 1,0 /11'(11'1' 1.111' l'II.fIl' ",111'1'1' ,I /"1,1'1 IVilll 1111 1'11'1111'111 ,/, of ,I, II Ilidlil'I'H III "I,ow Lila!. if q iH :f, /l1'illl(' iill'I'" or ,I, 1.111'11 ,I /q ,~/I,Li:4Iil',cl 1111' liIIiLI'III'HH l'olliliLillll fill' illll' j.t;1'1I.1 I'XI.I'IIt-!ioIlH, ~illl'I' /,'1 ( q n N) it-! /lH(,lIlIo gI'IlIIII'LI'il', WI' Ilal'I' Olily (,(1 /11'111'(' Lllal. ,I II.H 11.11111'1' HII.liHlil',Y 1.111' lilliLI'III','iH I'ollilil.illil 1'111' ilil,I'gl'al I'XI.I'IiHioIlH, If ,I' iH 1,l'aIlNI'I'IIIII'IIL:I,1 01'1'1' N, 1,111'11 I.II(~ aHHI'I'l.ioll follolV,e; fl'lllli (;i!'i,~), 11,1111 WI' aNHtlllw Ihat. ,I' iH aigillll'ail: ov('l' U. 'I'hl'lI, 1'11/1Hiilcrill!!: a HltiLablc filii\'(' illl.q.!;I'nl l.xLl'lif'doll of fl, whidt iH PHI'tlilo gl:ome',l'ie by (:1(LI ), WI' may aHHllme that x is in the field of lIl/olil'l 11,'; J( of R. Let L be an arbitrary finite algebraic extensioll (If /\', III order to prove the finiteness of the integral closure A' of A ill I), Hilll'I' the integral closure of R in L is a finite R-module, we may :I,,'iHIIIIII' that L = K and that R is a normal ring. Thus it is sufficient to PI'II"I' the finiteness of the derived normal ring of A (assuming that U iH normal, and that x E K). By virtue of (35.3), it suffices to show t.hal. if lJ is a prime ideal of A, then the derived normall'ing of A~ is a finite module over A~. Obviously, we have only to prove it in the case where ~ is maximal. Since Rlpn R) is a pseudo-geometric local ring, we may assume furthermore that R is a local ring with maximal ideal R. Since ~ is maximal, x modulo ~ is integral over Rim, m = ~ If x E R, then there is nothing to prove. Assume that x EE R. Let f(X) be an irreducible monic polynomial over R which is irreducible modulo m and such that f( x) E ~. Considering a suitable, finite integral extension of R, we may assume furthermore that f(x) is of degree 1, hence that x E ~. Let F be the set of pairs (a, b) of elements of R Ruch that ax = b. Then the set of aX - b generates a prime ideal q of the polynomial ring R[X] such that R[X]/q is naturally isomorphic to R[x] by (11.13). Then the set b of the b has no imbedded prime divisor by (11.13), and by its proof, and AI xA is isomorphic to Rib, which implies that xA, hence xAp , both have no imbedded prime divisors. If ~' is a prime divisor of xA~ , then ~' n R is a prime divisor of b, hence we see that RWnR) is a valuation ring and x is in the valuation ring. Thus we see that A~ is analytically unramified by virtue of (36.3), whence the derived normal ring of Ap is a finite A~-modtlle by (32.2), which completes the proof of (36.5).
n
(36,6) COROLLARY. If A is an affine ring over a pseudo-geometric integral domain, then the derived normal ring of A is a finite A -module.
I: II
(;1(1.',') .1 1II'IIIi 111('(1/ 1'/1/(/ h' /.4 /11111/11111'/1111/ /I/lI'/I//lljil'tI If 1 III /S (1111111/1/('(11//1 IW I'll IIIlji/'(1 fill' ('1 ('1'/1 111(1.1'/111111 /(1('(/1 III (~r 'l'lin PI"OO!' is illllll('dill.l.n hy (17.7).
i/ U
/11111 11111.1/
u.
(;W.H) '/'I1I':()I{,II:M. I,d .1'1, ..• , :1'1/ II(' 111(/1'111'11/('(11//1 JIlt/(·II(·lliI('III. I'!(' ments O'I!(~r (t sem:i-iow/ 'I"inl/ N. 11881/,/11(' /,//,(/,1, N -/8 (Ulldlli/mlll! 11I/1'(/'llIlji('d. If a semi-local rino H' is a rino (~r (Jlwl'il'n/'8 I(/' 11,(, jllltY/WIII/ill.! I'ill!! R[x] = R[XI , ... , Xn], then Il' is analytically unmll/:~/it:d. In PW'I'I:('It.iIll', 1j p is a prime ideal of R, then R~ is analytically unram'~/i('d. Proof. By virtue of (36.7), we may assume that R' is a loeal rillg. Let q be the prime ideal of R[xj such that R[x]q = R' and set p = q R. Let R* be the completion of R and let p* be a minimal priffi(~ divisor of pR*. Then the theorem of transition holds for R~ and R:. and R~ is a subspace of R:•. Since R* is a pseudo-geometric ring by (32.1), we see that is a pseudo-geometric ring by (36.1), which implies that the completion of has no nilpotent elements except zero, whence the same is true for its subspace R~ . Thus Rp is analytically unramified and we may assume that R is a local ring with maximal ideal p. Since R*[x]/pnR*[x] is isomorphic to R[x]/p"R[x], qR*[x] is a prime ideal of R*[x] (because R*[xJlqR*[x] = (R*[xJl pR*[x]) / (qR*[xJlpR*[;r])), and furthermore the theorem of transition holds for the local rings R' and R*[X]qR'[x] by virtue of (IS.S) and (19.1), whence R' is a subspace of R*[X]qR*[X] . Therefore we may assume that R = R*, whence R' is pseudo-geometric by (32.1) and (36.5), and the assertion is proved by (36.4). We add, here, a result on the normality of pseudo-geometrir: semilocal integral domains. We first prove it in a more geneml case:
n
R:.
R:.
(36.9) THEOREM. Let R be a Noetherian integral domain and assume that a ( ~ 0) is an element of the Jacobson radical of R. A 8sume f urthermore that: (1) aR has only one minimal prime divisor p, (2) aR~ = pR~ , and (3) R/p is a normal ring. Let R' be the derived normal ring of R. If R' is a finite R-module and if every (minimal) prime divisor p' of aR' lies over p, then R itself is normal and p = aR. Proof. R' /p' is integral over R/p. Since R~ is a valuation ring by our assumption (2) and by (12.1), we see that R' is contained in R~. Therefore R'/p' C R~/pR~, which implies that R'/p' and R/p have a common field of quotients. Therefore that R/p is normal implies that R'/p' = R/p. On the other hand, R' C R~ implies that p' R' pR~, whence p' is unique, and that R;, = Rp , whence aR;, =
n
I!II A l"I'llllt V I
,
p'h~""
fL roliowH LlmL flH' )1'. 'l'IH'I'I'/'OI'(I WlaN' Nip, whidl illlpli"H LlI/I.L h~1 (/'I~' I N. Nilll~n H' j~ /I. IilliLn 1~-lI\odlll(~ alld !:lineo ((. iH ill LlII' .1n""ilHoll 1'11."i':/l.1 or u, w(~ H('(l LllaL U = "~' by LIw lemma, of 1\I'ldl,AY-IIIIIII.yll., wialllH:n (J."~' "" pi implieH that all = p. Thus the pl'ool' iH I:oll\plnl,n. Now Wp apply j,}w above result to the case of pseudo-geometric illLegml domaiuH. (36.10) TllIWRlDM. Assume that a psewlo-geometric integral domain U is a homomorphic image of a locally Macaulay ring, and that aI, ... , ... , ar are elements of R such that height (L aiR) = r and such that they are in the Jacobson radical of R. If L aiR has only one minimal 71rime divisor p, if the ai form a regular system of parameters of Rp and 'zf Rip is a. normal ring, then R is norma.l and p = LaiR, and furthermore every RIL{ aiR is a normal ring. (LEMMA OF HmONAKA) Proof. We prove the assertion by induction on r. If r = 1, then (36.9) a,nd (34.9) imply the validity of the assertion, and we assume Chat r > 1. Let q be a minimal prime divisor of arR. If r is a minimal L aiR, then height r/q :::;: r - I, whence, by prime divisor of q the validity of the chain condition for prime ideals, height r ::; r, and p = r. Therefore q c p. Since the ai form a regular system of parameters of Rp we see that q is unique and that arR q = qRq. Consider R" = Rlq. Then, applying the induction to R" with elements ai modulo q, we see that p/q = (q L aiR)/q and that RI(q L{ aiR) is normal for each j = 0, I, ... , r - 1. In particular, Rlq is normal. This, the uniqueness of q and the equality arR q = qRq imply that R is normal and that q = arR by the case where r = 1. Therefore the proof is complete.
+
+
+
EXERCISE. Prove that a pseudo-geometric semi-local integral domain R is unmixod if and only if R satisfies the second chain condition for prime ideals. GenernJi7.o (36.10) to the case whor~ R it! a pseudo-geometric unmixed local illtOgl'al dOIll~dn.
37. Analytical normality We I:la,y that ul:lemi-local integral domain R is analytically irreducible if the completion of R is an integral domain. R is called analytically normal if the completion of R is a normal ring; in this case, R itself must be a normal ring by (18.4). We say that a prime ideal p of a semi-local ring R is analytically irreducible if Rip is analytically irreducible.
1:\11
(lIiiIlMII)'I'I/.1(1 I.(II'ill. IIINIlII
"1'1
(;i7.I) U III' 1/ 'I'il/(/ (I//d (/IlIlI//I1f' Iho! I, ." ( fa: (//'(' I. ·,:s '/I./I! It Z(·'/'o···dilli8U'1' ,:'" N /UU{ (:!) '''~:I/U IH.!J /' /8
N/II'II
IIII/l ( I )
(/./1. 1'//'/1/('//1 /(/
the total quotient r-i'/l.(f 4 H 8U,(:/i. UUI.l ll! ((.nd ·W) nrc -i", N, !hl'''' ·0 '/N ":/1. fa'. Proof. Since tuv E tU, we have tv C tH:'uN = lU, wl\l~I\(:c LlII'I'I~ i.'j an element v' of R such that tv = tv'. Since t is noL a ;!'(:I'O divi:-iOl', W(' have v = v' E R. (37.2) Let R be a normal semi-local-ring and let R* be its compl/:/i/ll/.. A SSUme that t is an element of R which is neither zero nor unit in N such that every prime divisor of tR is analytically unramified. If v ·is an element of the total quotient -ring of R* such that v is integral over HI and such that tv E R*, then v is in R*, Proof. Let the prime divisor of tR be ~1 , • • • , ~r • They are of heigh (, 1 by (12.9). Let S be the intersection of the complements of ~i in U. Then Us is a semi-local Dedekind domain with maximal ideals ~iR,~ , whence ~iRs is a principal ideal for every i by (28.9). Let Xi be an element of ~i such that ~iRs = xiRs for each i, and let ei be natural numbers such that IRs = X~l ... x;r Rs . Since tR*: sR* = tR* for any s of S by (18.1), it is sufficient by virtue of (37.1) to show that there is an s of S such that tvs E x?··· x;rR* (observing that X~l ... x~r ( tR). Let ~jj (j = 1, .. ' ,n(i)) be all the prime divisors of ~iR* and let Wij be the valuation of the field of quotients of R:' ii with R~ij as valuation ring and such that Wij(Xi) = l. Let q,ij be the natural homomorphism from R* into R:. i i . Let fl , ... ,fr be non-negative integers satisfying the following condition: tvs is in X{l .. . X;rR* for some s of S but for any s of S and for any i, tvs is not in X{l .. ·x~r. xiR*. Then it is sufficient to show that fi 2: ei. Assume the contrary, for instance that fl < el. We take an element s of S such that tvs is in x{l .. . X;rR* and let z be an element of R* such that tvs = x{l ... x{rz. We may regard q,ij as a homomorphism from the total quotient ring R** of R* into the field of quotients of R:. i j • Then, :,lince v is integral over R*, q,ij( v) is in R:. i; , whence Wi/( q,ij( v )) 2: 0, Since WJj(q,lj(t)) = el > 11 = Wlj(q,lj(X{l .. 'x~r)), we have Wlj(q,lj(Z)) 2: 1. This shows that q,lj(Z) iH in q,lj( ~~j). Since the kernel of q,l; is contained in ~~j, it follows that Z is in ~ij . Since x 1U; = j ~ij R,~ , Z is in x1R; and therefore there is an element s' of S such that ZS' E xlR*. Thus, with s" = ss' which is in S, tvs" E Xl·x{l .. 'x~rR*, which is a contradiction and we have ei :::; fi for every i, Thus the proof is complete. (37.3) A ssume that a normal local -ring R is analytically normal. Let
n
I'll
11"1' 1'111 1'1
1',rll'll,ql"l/ I~( 1/11' ,1il'ld I~r 1IIIIIIil'lIl,q II I~r Ii' 111111 11'1 //1/1'(/1'111 I'lmilll'l' 1(1' Ii' ill /" ,\ ,%'/11111' l/il/I 1'1'1'1'/1 111'ill/I' itll'lll )I 1(1' /it'il/hi I ill I iN 111I1I1,l/lil'llll,ll 1I11I'1//llIjil,tI, '1'/11'11 1/11' 1'11111/1/1'110 /1 I" I~I' I IN illll'tll'lIlI!! 1'11I,o.;I'd, IItIII 1,0.;, fill' 1'/'1'1'11 11I1I,rllllll! itll'l/I III IIf I, I", is 111111 1/11//'((,11/1 /l.III'IIIIIJ,
" III'
1/
I /11'
l/il'
./il/III' 81'llltl'l/llll'
(,11'1\\('111, or I cHlI'h LhaL I, 1\(1/.) alld 1('(, dill' il'l'('dlll'ibll~ IlIOlli(, (loIYllollli:t.i OV('I' N \Vliil,li bn,.; /1, HH a root.. Ld Ii"' lin Lhl~ (lolllpidioll of It nlld ltd. 1** I )I~ (,he ill" Lnp;m[ e/OHlll'l, of /* ill i(.,y Lotal quotillld, rillp;, Hi II I'.i\ / iH a {illiLlr u~ I\lOdlde hy (10, J(;), t.he ill (,egral I'lmmre of n*[aJ in itH LoL:d (jlloLi('11 L I'illg I'oineide::; wiLh 1** by (J7,8), Therefore we see that dJ** C 1(,*1111
P('OO\'. L(,(,
II, 1)(' :1.\1
(.1\1' di:-;('l'illlill:l.IIL or Lill'
hy (10,15), whieh implies that 1** = J* by (37,2), and therdOl'(I 1* iH illtegrally closed, If b is a nilpotent element of J* and if x iH lIoi, :\, y.W'O divisor, then bj:r; is integral over 1* and is in J**, and b E :r1** ~,~ :r/*, which implies that b E mnJ* with Jacobson radieal 111 of R alld with an arbitrary natural number n, Therefore we have b = 0 by (4,2), whieh proves that 1* has no nilpotent elements except J1(1J'(), i,I)" the zero ideal of J* ilS tlw intersection of a finite number of prim(r ideals, say pi , ' , , , The idempotents of t.he total quot.ient rillg of J* are integral over J*, and t.herefore they are in J*, and we HCO that J* is the direct. sum of 1*/p; . Sinee 1* is integrally closed, c[l,(Ih /* / p; mURt, be normal, and the proof if; (~omplcte,
P: '
(:i7,4) THEom;J\L Assume that a normal local ring (R, nt) is analytically irreducible, Let K be the field of quotients oj R, Assume that a local ring (R', m') satisfies the following three conditions: (1) R ::s; H' c K, (2) RI/mR' is a finite R/111~mod1lle, and (:~) altit.ude R' = altitude R. Then R' coincides with R, Proof. Let R* and R ' * be the completions of Rand R ' , reRpectively. R = m, we see t.hat 111' C m,i R for every i, Therefore Since m' there exists a natural homomorphism ¢ from R* into R ' * and ¢(R*) becomes the elosure of R in R ' *, By assumption (2), we see that R '* is a finite ¢(R*)~module by (30,6), whenc:c altitude R ' * = altitude ¢(R*) by (10,10), Since altitude R ' * = altitude R' = alt.itude R = altitude R* by (17,12), we have :t11.iLllilc R* = altitude ¢(R*), Since R* is an integral domain, it. follow:-: that ¢ is an isomorphism, Thus we sec that. R is a subspace of W :,,"1 !t,'* is integral over R*, Let alb (a, b E R) be an arbitrary nl(rlll('I\1, or R ' , Since alb is iutegral over R*, there are elements ci , ", , c~ of Hoi' such that (a/b)n + ci(a/b)n-l c! = 0 :tlld Lhnl'dol'c an ban-lei
n
n
+ '" +
+
+ ,., +
(1I1\()~IIII'I'111i
I 1,( I( ',I 1. 11/ N
II" ('~: 11ft," I, ' " ,II". Nil\(·n (L;' 1)'1/" 'Itl') we "n(~ LhaC UWl'n a/'(~ nl('III('IIL" ('I , ..
+ ... + {),'c"
= 0, wh(~I\(~(1 (a/II)"
nH I
L.:'i
1/(('''
U Slicli ('du/I))" I
, , ('" 01'
'u hy
LIiIl,L II"
I
(17.\1),
I 1)(/" I ('"