Living the Body
Living the Body Embodiment, Womanhood and Identity in Contemporary India
MEENAKSHI THAPAN
Copyrigh...
124 downloads
2675 Views
800KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Living the Body
Living the Body Embodiment, Womanhood and Identity in Contemporary India
MEENAKSHI THAPAN
Copyright © Meenakshi Thapan, 2009 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. First published in 2009 by SAGE Publications India Pvt Ltd B1/ I-1 Mohan Cooperative Industrial Area Mathura Road, New Delhi 110 044, India www.sagepub.in SAGE Publications Inc 2455 Teller Road Thousand Oaks, California 91320, USA SAGE Publications Ltd 1 Oliver’s Yard, 55 City Road London EC1Y 1SP, United Kingdom SAGE Publications Asia-Pacific Pte Ltd 33 Pekin Street #02-01 Far East Square Singapore 048763 Published by Vivek Mehra for SAGE Publications India Pvt Ltd, typeset in 10/12 pt Galliard BT by Excellent Laser Typesetters, Delhi and printed at Chaman Enterprises, New Delhi. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Thapan, Meenakshi. Living the body: embodiment, womanhood and identity in contemporary India/Meenakshi Thapan. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. 1. Gender identity—India. 2. Body, Human—Social aspects—India. 3. Sex role—India. 4. Women—India—History. I. Title. HQ1075.5.I4T43
306.4—dc22
2008
2008039698
ISBN: 978-81-7829-901-3 (HB) The SAGE Team: Rekha Natarajan, Sushmita Banerjee, Anju Saxena and Trinankur Banerjee
To the memory of Professor Ravinder Kumar
Contents
Acknowledgements Introduction: An Engagement with the Sociology of Embodiment 1. Embodiment, Identity and Womanhood
ix xiii 1
2. Cultures of Adolescence
26
3. Embodiment and Womanhood in Femina
64
4. The Body in the Mirror: Embodiment, Violence and Identity
93
5. The Body as a Weapon: Embodiment, Work and Identity
131
6. Aporiai of Resistance
164
References and Select Bibliography Index About the Author
173 185 191
Acknowledgements
A
ll books invariably have personal histories and this is no exception. This book’s journey has taken an incredibly long time in its making and in its final completion. It began several years ago, in 1993, when I was a Fellow at the Centre for Contemporary Studies at the Nehru Memorial Museum and Library (NMML), New Delhi. Professor Ravinder Kumar, then Director at the NMML, gave me the opportunity to begin work on this project and I remain indebted to him for this. He asked me, one afternoon in late 1991, as I entered the library and was putting away my bag at the reception, ‘And when will you write your next book?’ I confidently replied. ‘I will write my next book here’ and, thinking I had overstepped politeness, apologised. He smiled and asked me to apply for a fellowship. A year and a half later, I was beginning work on this project. I was at the NMML as Fellow at the Centre for Contemporary Studies from 1993–1995. It was a lively group of Fellows and we participated in several exciting dialogues and seminars chaired by Professor Ravinder Kumar at the Centre. Professor Ravinder Kumar was dedicated not just to the library and its environs, but also to the band of Fellows at the Centre whom he encouraged and nurtured with infinite support, friendship and affection. This book is dedicated to his memory in gratitude for his support for all things of the mind and the scholarly zeal he inspired in young minds. I was teaching at the Department of Education, University of Delhi, from September 1989 until July 2002. Although my area of research was the sociology of education and schooling practices, in particular, I sought to begin new work in a completely different area. I was inevitably drawn to women’s studies, partly as a consequence of my personal trajectory. With complete independence as a young woman, supportive parents and a generous spouse, I found motherhood fulfilling but also extremely constraining. My personal
x
LIVING THE BODY
experience led to a search for understanding womanhood in its complexity and diversity. I was interested in questions about how women’s embodiment could be the site of not only domestic conviviality but also of violence, of community honour, and the practices of the State. State policy appeared to exacerbate women’s traumatic and embodied experiences of divisions of home, families and property at different historical junctures, and fundamentalisms sought to assert national and religious honour in the bodies of women. I was particularly interested in women’s lived experience of embodiment, and its representation in the media, in the visual arts, in dance and in the annals, in constructions and practices of the State. In an effort to understand some of these issues, I organised a conference in late 1994 at the NMML on ‘Femininity, the Female body and Sexuality in Contemporary India’. Some of the papers presented at this conference were later edited and published (see Thapan 1997b). Subsequently, I returned to teaching and worked on this project, along with the other commitments and responsibilities in the university and in the family. Although I began by working with, and trying to understand, the lives of middle-class women, who were educated, professionals and working, I also interviewed well-educated, but less successful women, who were struggling in the workplace as much as in their domesticity. I was struck by the eagerness with which women wanted to talk and often, I was approached by women who volunteered to be interviewed. My understanding of this aspect of women’s lives would however have been incomplete if I had neglected the world of underprivileged and poor working-class women. I selected Jahangirpuri in north-western Delhi as my ethnographic site primarily because the Department of Education, University of Delhi, was already engaged in several projects in the area. This undoubtedly helped me to gain access to the homes of women, who welcomed me and often sought me out, to tell me their stories. Earlier versions of some chapters in this book have been presented at a number of fora: the Centre for Contemporary Studies (NMML), at a seminar on Pierre Bourdieu: Sociologist and Sociologies, Department of Sociology, Delhi School of Economics; the seminar on Gender in South Asia at Queen Elizabeth House, University of Oxford; the South Asia Workshop, University of Chicago; the Department of Sociology Seminar at Hofstra University, New York; the annual conference of the Society for the Interdisciplinary Study of Social Imagery at the University of Southern Colorado; the Townsville International Women’s
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
xi
Conference at James Cook University, Townsville; the Sixth Women in Asia Conference at the Australian National University, Canberra; the weekly seminar at the Centre for Asia Pacific Social Transformations Studies (CAPSTRANS), University of Wollongong; the conference on Development Paradigm: Social Transformation and Gender Performance in Asia at the Department of Sociology, University of Madras; the weekly seminar at the Centre for Research in Gender Relations and Women’s Studies at the University of British Columbia, Vancouver; the seminar at York Centre for Asian Research, University of York, Canada; the Conference on Values in Education organized by the Konrad Adenauer Foundation at Neemrana Fort, Rajasthan and at the University of Bordeaux, France. This work has benefited from research at the NMML, the Ratan Tata Library at the Delhi School of Economics, Delhi University, the Koerner library at the University of British Columbia, Vancouver, the Regenstein library at the University of Chicago, the Social Sciences Library at the University of Oxford, the University of Wollongong and the Maison des Sciences de l’Homme, Paris. Earlier versions of some of the chapters in this book have been published in Economic and Political Weekly (Women’s Studies Special issue 28 October 1995, Vol. XXX, No. 43) Gender and Nation (ed. NMML, New Delhi 2001), Women’s Studies International Forum, (2001, Vol. 24, No. 3/4), Gender and Development (July 2003) Educational Regimes in Contemporary India (eds Radhika Chopra and Patricia Jeffery, Sage, 2005) Contributions to Indian Sociology (2004, Vol. 38, No. 3), Women’s Struggle for Existence (2006, UNDPTAHA), Reading Pierre Bourdieu in a Dual Context. Essays from India and France (eds Roland Lardinois and Meenakshi Thapan, 2006, Routledge, Taylor and Francis). I am grateful to several people for their help in very different ways and at varying times in the preparation and writing of this book and I thank them all: the anonymous reviewer at Sage, Margaret Abraham, Neera Chandhoke, Radhika Chopra, Barbara Harriss-White, Ruchira Ganguly-Scrase, Sneja Gunew, Shubhra Gururani, Loraine Kennedy, Roland Lardinois, Francine Muel-Dreyfuss, Namita Ranganathan, Valerie Raoul, T.N. Madan, Monique de Saint Martin, Timothy Scrase and Patricia Uberoi. I especially thank Niraja Gopal Jayal for her detailed and meticulous comments on Chapter 5. I am indebted to Professor Najma Siddiqi, then at the Institute of Advanced Studies in Education at the Department of Education, University of Delhi,
xii
LIVING THE BODY
who provided me with the funds and facilities to conduct fieldwork in Jahangirpuri over 2001–2002. I am very grateful to Rachna Singh and to Malini Mittal who helped me conduct the fieldwork. My parents have supported me in innumerable ways through the years I was struggling to complete this and other work—thank you for being there at all times. I am always grateful to George who is my greatest support, worst critic and best friend and forever beholden to Jyotsna and Ayushya for their unconditional love. I was privileged to spend two and a half months at the Rishi Valley School, in rural Andhra Pradesh, in mid 2007 where I was able to finish this work in an atmosphere of complete silence, pristine natural beauty and intellectual companionship. I thank Radhika and Hans Herzberger, A. Kumaraswamy, Geetha Varadan, M.S. Sailenderan, and other friends, for all this, and more. Above all, I remain indebted to all the women who agreed to be interviewed and spent several hours of their time talking to us in their homes and at work.
Introduction AN ENGAGEMENT WITH THE SOCIOLOGY OF EMBODIMENT
To work on a “paradigm of embodiment”… is not to study anything new or different, but to address familiar topics—healing, emotion, gender or power—from a different standpoint. (Thomas J. Csordas 1999a: 147) …it is in the everyday life of women, articulating the poisons that enter social relationships, that the act of hearing and recognition gets done, and through which I propose that culture acquires a soul—that it is born. (Veena Das 1995: 178)
T
his work is concerned with the development of a sociology of embodiment, rather than a sociology of the body, in the context of women’s lives in contemporary, urban India. My understanding of this focus on embodiment is mediated by gender and class, two critical elements, that constitute identity in relation to embodiment. My earlier works on women (Thapan 1997a, 2000, 2001a, 2004, 2005a, 2005b and 2005c) as well as an edited volume (Thapan 1997b) emphasise my effort to understand the complex relationship between embodiment, gender and identity. At a symposium held at the Nehru Memorial Museum and Library in 1997, on the release of the book Embodiment: Essays on Gender and Identity (Thapan 1997b), Rajeshwari Sunder Rajan, one of the key discussants, commented that the book explores ‘trendy’ concepts such as ‘embodiment’ and ‘identity’ and she wondered whether this would lead to meaningful research in women’s studies. To understand women, their position and their struggle in Indian society, the perspective of embodiment is imperative, as a woman is undoubtedly located in a physical and psychological space as much as she is in the cultural and social domain.
xiv
LIVING THE BODY
It is not surprising that there has been a growing interest in this area in feminist scholarship in India: John and Nair (1998) and Niranjana (1999, 2001), among others. Unravelling the complexities inherent in a multi-layered and fluid construct such as ‘identity’ has been a continued preoccupation in my work, whether it is in the area of transnational migration (Thapan 2004, 2005c), education (Thapan 2006b), or religion (Thapan 2007) and engages my attention in the present work. Undoubtedly, a sociology of the body has been around for some time, as is evident in the work of Pierre Bourdieu (1977, 1984), Bryan Turner (1984, 1996, second edition), Featherstone, Hepworth and Turner (1991), Shilling (1993), and others. Feminist scholarship in the west has also addressed embodiment in specific areas, such as, Elizabeth Grosz (1994, 1995), Conboy, Medina and Stanbury (1997), Price and Shildrick (1999), Emily Martin (2001), and others. However, it is also the case, as pointed out by Helen Fielding that ‘the more the body comes into focus,’ as it has in recent times, ‘the more our understanding of embodiment recedes’ (Fielding 2000:124). An interest in locating women firmly within their embodied experience of everyday life runs the risk of ‘essentialising’ women, that is, seeing them only in terms of the biological bases of existence, resulting in a feminist fear of working with the conceptual category of embodiment. An alternative perspective is that of phenomenology that views embodiment, not merely in corporeal terms, but always in a social and ‘relational’ context. This work therefore addresses embodiment very much as ‘the existential richness of being-in-the-world’, through the ‘vividness and urgency of experience’ (Csordas 2002: 3). No doubt, the historical influences and social and cultural backgrounds and spaces which encapsulate women are significant to this experience. As pointed out by Shildrick and Price, the notion of ‘being-in-the-world—or more appropriately, becoming-in-the-world—is an expression of indivisible corporeal subjectivity in which the temporal and the spatial are fully operative’ (Shildrick and Price 1998: 8). Moreover, the embodied subject is not an isolated, experiential self in relation to the world, out there, perceived as a separate entity. Contrarily, ‘it is the nature of the embodied subject to move into and be taken up by the world around her. Essences emerge through this intertwining, in the space between. They are enacted but always and only in relation to the world and to others’ (Fielding 2000: 132). In this process of playing out, enacting
INTRODUCTION
xv
performing selves in relational terms, it is significant that we are collapsing the dualities of subject-object (as did Merleau-Ponty 1962) as well as that of structure-practice (Bourdieu 1977, 1984) through the conceptual category of embodiment. I do not discuss the work of Merleau-Ponty at length but certainly elaborate on Bourdieu’s focus on ‘practice’ as the cardinal anthropological principle for understanding embodiment through the concept of habitus. If the paradigm of embodiment is essential to understand women in everyday life, it is no less important to emphasise identity, in its fluid, incomplete sense, as the sum of this experiential embodiment. An essential component of both the experience of embodiment and the playing out of an identity, always on the make, as it were, is that of resistance. In both experiential terms, as well as in terms of an awareness and knowledge of their condition and the possibilities for struggle open to them, women in telling their stories, pay acute attention to this aspect of their embodied lives. Resistance in fact is a double edged sword in women’s lives, one with which they constantly articulate and exhibit their struggle but one which does not always enable complete success. Resistance, nonetheless, remains central to their lives whether or not it achieves social transformation. In being crucial to their telling of their lives, their stories that reflect their dilemmas and their conscious choices, it certainly transforms women’s experiential living out of an embodied identity. This undeniable reality gives them a strength and dignity that is of their making, driven by their awareness and understanding, and therefore lies outside the domain of what is socially approved or normative behaviour.
WOMEN AND THEIR WORLDS My work focuses on two sets of adolescent and adult women, those who are educationally advantaged—in school or working, professional, career women and those who are educationally disadvantaged—located in slums and engaged primarily in unskilled labour or domestic work. The professional and educated women are articulate and conscious of their dilemmas and rights and view the world from their position in particular sections of society. I seek to understand their lived experience from their location, listening to
xvi
LIVING THE BODY
their constructions of their everyday world, as an experienced and contested social reality. Undoubtedly, poverty is central to women’s experience in the slum. This includes not only the objective criteria that define the parameters of poverty such as life expectancy, female mortality, assets, economic deprivation, access to education, consumption, nutrition, health, and so on, but also the ‘subjective experience’ of poverty as an everyday reality. I consciously take their subjective experience of poverty as central to their recognition of themselves as gendered subjects and assert that subjective experience is crucial to our understanding of the complexities characteristic of everyday life. My analysis of women’s experience is based on their accounts during my interviews with two sets of women: a) Forty adolescent young women from educationally advantaged socio-economic backgrounds and 25 middle- and uppermiddle class adult women in New Delhi. These women were selected on the basis of a snowball sample and particularly represent the category of urban Indian women, who because of their educationally advantaged and privileged status and position in urban society, are exposed to an array of visual images and textual discourse on embodied representation in the media and elsewhere. b) Fifteen adolescent, married and unmarried, educationally disadvantaged young women and 25 adult migrant women from a Gujarati community and from the northern state of Uttar Pradesh who live in a slum in north-western Delhi. The methodology employed for engaging in fieldwork among adolescent young women varied: on the one hand, I was able, with the help of a research assistant, to conduct interviews and have fairly elaborate discussions with students who also answered a long questionnaire. This interaction took place in the location of their schools. On the other hand, we had long discussions, group meetings and interviews with groups of young women in their homes in the slum. Undoubtedly, this resulted in vastly different sets of data based on written and interview material in the one case and oral testimonies in the other. This did not cause any serious problems except that the interviews with the educationally disadvantaged young women
INTRODUCTION
xvii
required us to draw them out in greater depth to ensure that we had sufficient material on which to base our analyses. Data were collected therefore through a written questionnaire distributed randomly to 50 women students from different co-educational, public (that is, fee paying) and government schools in New Delhi and also a boarding school in southern India spread over 2002–2005. The students were all aged around 16–18 years. Our meetings took place in the location of the school where we met students without the presence of teachers; students experienced a certain sense of freedom in responding to questions away from their families and in the absence of teachers. Interviews were also conducted with young women in the age group of 16–20 years in their homes in the slum. A larger age span was used for this group in order to understand the experience of adolescence at different stages. Interviews were conducted in groups, largely in the absence of older women and other family members. These young women are members of the Gujarati community and are the daughters of migrants who work as labourers in the vegetable and fruit wholesale market and do other odd jobs to earn a livelihood. The young women have either never been to school or have been there for a very short period (three to five years) only. In the first part of my fieldwork among these women, I conducted intensive, in-depth interviews with 30 adolescent and adult women of varied castes, belonging to different regional and linguistic backgrounds and living in different blocks in the slum. These were followed up by focused group discussions and meetings with the same women over an extended period of a few months. By focusing largely on interviews in which we recorded oral testimonies and women’s voices, and were dependent on their construction of their experience, it would appear that my understanding of embodiment is limited, as it is based primarily on the intersubjectivity of the interview. This may also suggest that the temporal dimension is removed and there is therefore a lack of engagement with women’s social and personal histories. My focus in Chapter 1 on the processes of social inclusion and exclusion, the drawing of boundaries, and the development of the habitus based on class, capital and culture points to the social and historical bases of the personal trajectories I seek to establish through the interviews. Time and space are crucial elements to how lives are shaped, as well as told. The life course is one way of experiencing time in different spatial settings.
xviii
LIVING THE BODY
Moreover, no individual lives in a particular social or cultural vacuum and clearly, marriage and the family are not the exclusive markers of women’s embodiment and identity. The educational and professional background of women, in one case, ensures an embodiment that is expressive of a particular habitus, developed over more than one generation, that bestows the women with certain capital. In the other case, marriage and the family may be significant markers in the experience of embodiment but women’s engagement with work of various kinds is of no less importance. The habitus is developed over generations of socialisation into bodily gestures, movements and practices that both reflect and reproduce the women’s relationship to both domestic work and unskilled labour. The two sets of women in this study are very diverse not only across categories of the slum or middle-class/professionals but also within each category. This is suggestive of a heterogeneity that is part of the everyday in terms of both location and experience. The book does not seek to explain the similarities or differences between or among the women. Nor does it set out to focus on those aspects that are common to both sets of women. The purpose is precisely to give voice to multiple voices and diverse locations to enable a nuanced understanding of the interplay between embodiment, culture, social relations and agency. In the writing of the book, the voices of women are present, as they are, without any embellishments, keeping always to the spoken or written word, as it was said or written. Apart from Chapter 1 that lays out the conceptual framework for the work, there is one chapter that examines textual and visual material from a women’s magazine, and the remaining chapters are based on material from women’s voices. Although my attempts at explanation within the overarching theoretical frameworks underlying embodiment, identity and resistance are no doubt present in different forms throughout the text, I have refrained from interfering with the stories of women, both in their telling and in their presentation. The varying manner in which the women spoke, with a quiet, morose sense of finality, or more excitedly and sharply, with tenderness, or with an acute consciousness of wanting to say only the ‘right’ thing, in a conspiratorial whisper, in minute detail, with gestures, smiles, silences and tears, sharply brought out the urgency and vividness of their heterogeneous experience. I have attempted to bring this out in the text. Simultaneously, I was always conscious of my presence as an ethnographer and
INTRODUCTION
xix
was asked questions about my life, my family, my work, by all categories of women. I replied to their questions with honesty but I was always consciously present as an ethnographer in the field and did not try to achieve professional or personal erasure amidst women who gave of themselves to me with complete sincerity and openness. I explained my role as an ethnographer to the women and was accepted by them as such. This work does not seek to make generalisations about ‘women in contemporary India’, their travails or their successes, and consciously speaks from the standpoint of women’s voices alone. It is no longer possible, however, to imagine that the text, truthful to the voices of subjects, reflects reality ‘as it is’ to even the participants in the process. Undoubtedly, all representation of the lives of others is always an incomplete reality, a ‘partial truth’ (Clifford 1986) and this work is, in that sense, no different. In the telling of their stories, women play out the tensions between self and society through the ‘presentation of a unique self which can also be recognised by society’ (Chanfrault-Duchet 2000: 61). Women in this manner seek to define their identities in relation to the distinctive character of their experiential self as well as to their living out of the social in everyday life. The ‘good’ woman, whether she is selfless worker, wife, daughter, mother is a significant trope in the stories, so that women work for the survival of the family, those who are in ‘bad’ marriages stay on for the benefit of the family, or are obedient daughters, or seek to establish their place as ‘good’ women in their aspirations to be recognised as such by the family and community. Similarly, among one category of women, it is quite evident that they seek to be identified as ‘radical’ women, consciously defining and aware of their lived experience, in its telling and in the articulation of their departure from social norms, whether it is as rebellious daughters, or as those who seek to assert their identities as reflective, thinking beings who challenge the social order. The significance of ‘work’ in relation to identity in the lives of another category of women points to a negotiated self and brings out their effort to establish an identity that is socially coherent as well as unique to their perception of their everyday existence. The social self, so to speak, confronts, contains and liberates the distinctive, personal self and the evolving relationship between the two, perhaps unexpressed, unconscious, and yet deeply present, results in the construction of both, as a gendered subject.
xx
LIVING THE BODY
THE CHAPTERS IN THE BOOK Within the larger problematic of embodiment, identity and resistance, this book seeks to cover ground in different dimensions pertaining to visual and textual representation and womanhood, the experience by young women of adolescence in the context of schooling, marriage and peer group cultures, women’s lived experience among poor, educationally disadvantaged women and among middle and upper class educationally advantaged women. Chapter 1 lays out the conceptual framework within which this work is located. The paradigm of embodiment, through lived experience, is viewed as being central to an understanding of women’s lives as well as of Indian womanhood in a changing society like India. I consider the linkages between embodiment, gender and identity and how these point to the socially, emotionally and individually constructed human body. To understand these linkages, I examine Bourdieu’s widely influential conceptual category of habitus in the context of ‘recolonisation’, an ideology that induces global flows, among other colonising practices. I also discuss the politics of the ambivalence in constructions of Indian womanhood in contemporary India. In Chapter 2, there is a foregrounding of young women’s lived experience in order to understand cultures of adolescence as they prevail in two different groups of young women. Clearly, there is no well-defined age period within which adolescence is experienced as a marked lifecycle event and in fact there are a series of transitions in the lives of young women that mark the lived experience of adolescence in particular and varied ways. The influence of family, peer group and schooling, or its absence, and marriage and domesticity emerge as significant components of the adolescent young woman’s life shaping their recognition and articulation of the experience of embodiment, sexuality and embodied self and other ‘images’ in diverse ways. Chapter 3 seeks to address the question of how representations of woman’s embodiment and definitions of identity are embedded in textual and visual displays of a popular women’s magazine Femina. While one set of women do not read this magazine and are not subject, therefore, to its specific influence, this in no way undermines the importance of women’s magazines in urban India. This particular magazine, in this genre, provides a legitimate space for developing normative definitions of woman’s embodiment within a trope of
INTRODUCTION
xxi
what is considered ‘authentic’ embodiment and appearance perfected through body regimes and displays. Women’s lived experience and the multiplicity of voice, class and location form the focus of the next two chapters in the book. Chapter 4 examines women’s voices from middle class and upper class social spaces, who have had some access to education, are privileged in different ways, through education, employment, wealth or a combination of these. Marriage is crucial to these women’s self-definitions much as they seek to break away from normative definitions of their identities as respectable, married women. Women do however simultaneously indicate a movement away from these external definitions to the extent that they articulate and express their dissatisfaction with what they are expected to be. They attempt to alter these normative definitions with their own construction, through expression and performance in front of the male gaze or to their own gaze in the mirror, of what they would like to be or how they would like themselves to be seen, creating, in the process, an intimate and personal portrayal of their embodiment. In Chapter 5, the perspectives and experiences of women in the slum point to the significance of work and marriage in the context of their location in the slum and their experience of grinding poverty. Work is crucial to women’s self-definitions, as indeed is marriage; paid work as well as work in the home, gives women a basis for living, for survival, and for strategising their lives in the context of complex networks of marriage and extended kin. Their embodiment is experienced within a largely utilitarian perspective for the crucial role of childbearing, work and inevitable sexual relations rather than only for adornment or pleasure. Within this world of the everyday, woman recognises her ability to negotiate, strategise and intervene, as she wants to, and in the very recognition and articulation of both her position and her desires, aspirations and hopes, she achieves her sense of identity as a woman. In the last chapter, I discuss the emancipatory possibilities of resistance in the everyday lives of women. In recognising that resistance is not conclusively linked to transformation, especially at larger social and cultural levels, I discuss resistance as an ‘impasse’, indicating an inevitability as well as an openness to possibilities. This view allows us to consider women as charters of their destinies as much as they experience them through the struggles and dilemmas that characterise their everyday lives.
1 EMBODIMENT, IDENTITY AND WOMANHOOD
T
his work is specifically concerned with the lives of women and seeks to provide an understanding of women’s experience of embodiment in everyday life.1 The focus on women arises from an explicit effort to speak about the social, from the perspective and experience of women. It is only then that we can speak about ‘a sociology’ for women: when the experience of women forms the basis of understanding the social. The social then is not only about women, but from their perspective, provides the basis for a sociology that serves to help us discover and understand the larger social and political reality. Such a sociology, that takes women’s experience as its starting point, does not objectify the subjects under study but seeks ‘to investigate how that society organises and shapes that everyday world of experience. Its project is to explicate the actual social relations in which people’s lives are embedded and to make these visible to them/ourselves’ (Smith 1999: 74). Ethnographies of communities and social processes in India that have taken the experience of women as central to their analyses include the works of sociologists and social anthropologists such as Das (1988), 1 Embodiment, ‘a lived matter of gender’ (Hughes and Witz 1997), is crucial to the experience and perception of gender identity. As Lois McNay puts it: ‘At the point of overlap between the physical, the symbolic and the sociological, the body is a dynamic, mutable frontier. The body is the threshold through which the subject’s lived experience of the world is incorporated and realized and as such, is neither pure object nor pure subject’ (McNay 1999: 98). As object, it is argued that the body and its image is part of ‘formally identical objects interacting in the infinity of space and time’ but as subject, the same body and body-image is ‘immeasurably enriched with the inner content of lived experience’ (Ferguson 1997: 6).
2
LIVING THE BODY
Dube (1986, 1988), Ganesh (1993), Jeffery (1979), Raheja and Gold (1996), Kapadia (1995) and Uberoi (1996), among others. These studies have sought to foreground women’s voices as being critical to their everyday experience in a network of social relations that are embedded in socio-economic and political domains. Such work has focused on issues that emphasise, among others, kinship relations, the status of women in the family and household, women’s work and agrarian relations, embodiment and sexuality, women and caste, the law and women and the state and social reform. My own interest in a sociology of women is firmly grounded in an exploration of embodiment and women’s lived experience through voice and agency.2 I seek to understand women’s embodiment and identity in their everyday lives, and local knowledge(s) and practice(s) as sites of power and resistance. I suggest that woman speaks with a complexity located in the multiplicities of economic deprivation, caste, familial and gender relations.3 This multiplicity is importantly located in the physical and social conditions of everyday life that women experience.
EMBODIMENT AND IDENTITY My purpose here is to consider the linkages between embodiment, gender and identity and how these point to the socially, emotionally and individually constructed human body. We exist through our bodies and the materiality of our existence is a certainty. We are embodied socially through our location in a socio-cultural and political space. In this sense, we are located in time and space, race, ethnicity and 2
In this work, I do not focus on embodiment as experienced through disability, disease, violence, religion or age, among other such categories. These are important considerations in any work on embodiment, as they frame the paradigm of embodiment in vastly different ways, but lie outside the scope of this book. 3 I assert that woman ‘speaks’ and therefore has voice, will and agency. We need to engage with women’s voices, ‘to learn to speak to (rather than listen to or speak for) the historically muted subject of the subaltern woman’ (Spivak 1988: 295). Spivak later clarifies that she is arguing for agency as ‘institutionally validated action’ (Spivak 2000: xx). She argues that this is crucial: ‘The politics of demanding and building infrastructure so that when subalterns speak they can be heard’ (ibid.). This is not however the point of this work where women’s voices construct an understanding of everyday life practices through an articulation of the twin processes of compliance and resistance.
EMBODIMENT, IDENTITY AND WOMANHOOD
3
gender, and history and culture which shape and limit us in different ways (Bordo 1997: 181). Our embodiment is therefore experienced in our everyday lives as lived and communicative bodies. To the extent that we can articulate our embodied experience through language, emotions, memory and speech, we use our bodily senses to both perceive and give voice to our experience. Embodiment in this sense is ‘an existential condition in which the body is the subjective source or intersubjective ground of experience’ (Csordas 1999a: 143) and therefore I am essentially concerned with culture and experience as they can be understood ‘from the standpoint of bodily being-in-the world’ (ibid.).4 Individuals clearly do not constitute singular, isolated and fixed identities but are multiply constituted with contradictory and often conflicting subjectivities. In an attempt to bring in these multiple voices, representing multiple subjectivities, my focus is on the lived and communicative body and on lived experience as constitutive of the embodied self. By lived experience, I mean that experience which is premised on the articulation by women of their subjectivity based in the everyday and simultaneously in particular historical and social locations.5 In foregrounding this subjectivity, it is important to refrain from providing anecdotal accounts or personal narratives that do not in some way reflect subjectivity in the social so that it is an engagement with the social that is the bedrock of lived experience.6 4 The work of Erving Goffman has been particularly significant in emphasizing the place of the body in identifying the links between people’s self-identity and social identity. Goffman was concerned with the techniques of the body in social relationships, such as ‘face-work’, gestures, and other nuanced forms of behaviour in the ‘presentation of the self ’ and maintenance of appearances as a form of public display in everyday life (Goffman 1956 ). The significance of Goffman’s work lies in his emphasis on the body ‘as integral to human agency’ (Shilling 1993: 82). His work shows us how people can, and do, intervene in the flow of everyday life through different aspects and modes of self-presentation, whether physical or sartorial. However, Goffman’s work also suggests that there is an extent to which individuals can express themselves through and with their bodies. This social constraint is exercised through ‘shared vocabularies of body idiom’ (as quoted by Shilling, ibid.) which implies that while bodies belong to individuals, their significance is socially derived. 5 ‘Lived experience’, it is suggested, ‘designates the whole of a person’s subjectivity. More particularly, the term describes the way an individual makes sense of her situation and actions’ (Moi 1999: 63). 6 Sara Suleri however warns us of the dangers of ‘lived experience’ or ‘radical subjectivity’ translating into a ‘low-grade romanticism’ that maybe unable to recognize its discursive status as a ‘pre- rather than post- colonialism’ (Suleri 1992: 761).
4
LIVING THE BODY
As Henrietta Moore has pointed out, persons and selves are bounded and therefore ‘embodiment is the essence of identity’ (Moore 1994a: 31). However, embodiment does not impart a fixity to identity as identities are always in the process of becoming, being made and re-made, constructed and re-defined, shaped and transformed. My interest in human embodiment is also in relation to the expression of inner feelings, self hood and identity, viewing none of these as isolated single issues but rather as multiple constituents of human embodiment. Phenomenology has been foremost in imbuing matter (the body) with life (agency) through the lived experience of human beings. The mind, imagination, emotions and memory play as much a role in the construction and experience of the human body as do the social expectations and the male and female gaze. The phenomenological perspective views all human perception as embodied. And embodiment thereby becomes both experience and body, agency and physical corporeality, life and matter. The psychological element is not insignificant in the formation of gender identity and as Nancy Chodorow has emphasised, I too contend that ‘each person’s sense of gender…is an inextricable fusion or melding of personally created (emotionally and through unconscious fantasy) and cultural meaning’ (Chodorow 1995: 517). The important point however is that much of the personal creation is grounded in social, cultural and ethnic factors so that it is not clear to what extent an individual’s own sense of gender subjectivity is not informed by the society in which she lives. For example, Ahmed points out how bodily encounters with strangers ‘in which something that cannot be named is passed between subjects’ serves to embody the social agent and such encounters in fact are ‘played out on the body, and is played out with the emotions’ (Ahmed 2000: 85–6).7 The psychological element remains an important component 7 In a moving quote from Audre Lorde’s encounter, as a child on a subway train with her mother, with a white woman who shirks from bodily contact and stands up to avoid sitting next to her, Ahmed concludes that ‘through such strange encounters, bodies are both deformed and reformed; they take form through and against other bodily forms’ (Ahmed 2000: 86). Such strange encounters also serve to mark out boundary lines between bodies, through the assumption of a bodily image, and also involve ‘social practices and techniques of differentiation’. In other words, bodies may be differentiated ‘not only from each other or from the other, but also through differentiating between others, who have a different function in establishing the permeability of bodily space’ (ibid.: 90).
EMBODIMENT, IDENTITY AND WOMANHOOD
5
in the formation of gendered selves to the extent that the body must be ‘psychically constituted in order for the subject to acquire a sense of its place in the world and in connection with others’ (Grosz 1994: xii) (emphasis added). It is in relation to others, especially significant others, that the embodied self is constituted and understood. Rather than split the person into the mutually exclusive categories of mind and body, and view gender identity in terms of a series of binary oppositions based on this essential opposition, it becomes important to emphasise the psychological and cultural nature of the embodied self. To this end, Elizabeth Grosz suggests we develop an understanding of what she calls ‘embodied subjectivity’ or ‘psychical corporeality’ which avoids dualism and the alternatives to it and thereby the criticisms of it (ibid.: 22). The psychological construction of gender identity, and thereby of womanhood, is therefore acknowledged. My attention in this work is focused on how woman, as embodied self, is defined both by her interiority as well as the public and social domain and what strategies and modes she uses to define, articulate, manipulate and transform both the inner and the outer in terms of her experiential reality. My concern with the experience of embodiment focuses my investigation into how young and adult women articulate this experience in their everyday lives. The act of hearing women’s voices is essential to understand woman’s recognition of herself as a feminine subject and the act of ‘recognition is a significant moment in the construction of subjectivity’ (Skeggs 1998: 98). Giving voice to agency therefore forms a significant component of the questions this work seeks to address. Woman’s personal and social worlds are defined very clearly in terms of the home, the family, their childhood, the workplace and their life experiences through various periods of their lives. In the process of articulating their life worlds, women traverse untrodden paths of revelation, strength and surprise as well as the more frequented ones of abuse, dishonour, shame and rejection. In traversing these paths, women revert to memory, narrative and voice as tools for reconstructing their emotions, thoughts and experiences in making sense of their own constitution as embodied, gendered beings. It is through her embodiment that woman both experiences and articulates herself: The woman knower for whom we will write the systematic feminist consciousness of psyche and social relations stands outside textually mediated discourse, in the actualities of her local and particular
6
LIVING THE BODY
world…She is always where her body is; if she makes the Cartesian leap into doubting its existence, the ontological irony is that she makes it as a body, with the disciplining of the body that subdues it in the presence of the text, an active being of the body in a particular actual local historical setting. (Smith 1991: 159)
The attempt is not only to provide descriptions of their everyday embodied experiences but also to understand whether written and oral responses and testimonies to my questions about their lives bring out important ways of remembering and forgetting, living, dying and being re-born, and political consciousness in spirit and in will. I argue that the experience of an embodied and gendered self lies at the intersection not only of multiple subjectivities but also at multiple points of political consciousness and location. Embodiment is therefore not merely about being-in-the-body or behaviour but about experience, subjectivity, political consciousness, agency and will. In my emphasis on the everyday as both the focus of study and site for explanation, I have undoubtedly been influenced by the work of Pierre Bourdieu who focuses on social power in the everyday. The great advantage of this approach is that everyday life practices become crucial to understanding how both power and agency operate in the most mundane situations, contexts and practices. Simple and everyday tasks such as the embodied engagement with work of different kinds, with domestic tasks and social networks, acquire a renewed significance when viewed from this perspective. In addition, a woman’s physical stance, the gestures she uses, the facial expressions she communicates, her articulation of her life experience in a particular tone of voice as well as the silences, the absence of speech, the hushed voice, are critical markers of both the exercise of power and of woman’s agential response. I examine Bourdieu’s widely influential conceptual category of habitus in terms of its emphasis on the collective, the social, so well articulated in his statement that, ‘Habitus is a socialized subjectivity’ (Bourdieu and Wacquant 1992: 126); and the implications of this when we seek to emphasise a sociology for women on the basis of subjectively constructed knowledge. I do not however preclude the possibilities of resistance or transformation as these are embedded in the nature of habitus itself to the extent that Bourdieu was concerned with the notion, following Chomsky, of ‘generative grammar’ and thereby of the ‘creative, active, and inventive capacities of habitus and of agent’. In fact, Bourdieu and Wacquant clearly emphasise that
EMBODIMENT, IDENTITY AND WOMANHOOD
7
‘Habitus is not the fate that some people read into it. …It is an open system of dispositions that is constantly subjected to experiences, and therefore constantly affected by them in a way that either reinforces or modifies its structures. It is durable but not eternal’ (Bourdieu and Wacquant 1992: 133). Moreover, the habitus is embodied in the human subject and is an experience, and in that sense, a capital, made explicit through bodily hexis—the bearing of the body, comportment, and deeply ingrained habits of behaviour, feeling and thought. Thus, embodiment is critical to Bourdieu’s sociology of lived practice and of what he calls ‘the practical sense’. The habitus, in this work, is an important concept as it focuses attention on the body. While we may know that the body ‘is a medium’ for expressions of moods and feelings, Bourdieu emphasises that the body, ‘as a repository for social experience, constitutes an essential part of the habitus’ (Krais 2006: 127). All human action is embodied, gendered and social. This does not however imply that the human is passive in ‘being-in-the-world’ but is ‘actively participating and grappling with the world’ (ibid.: 129). It is this element of struggle, and contestation, in habitus that, to my mind, is critical to understand the space between mere reiteration of social acts and of the open-ended and fluid nature of action.8 In this work, I seek to understand habitus, its constancy and simultaneously its malleability in the context of woman’s experience and my point of intervention in this debate takes place on two registers. First, I seek to define and understand the constancy of habitus in women’s experience wherein agency is contained in every attempt at breaking out so that the challenge to oppression or domination takes place on well recognised and trodden paths of resistance and rebellion that often do not reveal more than they appear to. They thus emerge from, and rest within, the social fields inhabited by 8 The major feminist critique against Bourdieu, however, expresses a dissatisfaction with the concept of habitus which, in spite of Bourdieu’s emphasis on the possibilities of change, is viewed as embodying an unchanging, obstinate set of dispositions that inhere in the body, emotions and psyche and endure over time. Contrarily, contemporary feminist discourse emphasises ‘agency, fluidity, the instability of subject positionings and identities’ which, as Terry Lovell tells us, ‘contrasts at times very starkly with the durability of Bourdieu’s dispositional subject’ (Lovell 2000:12). See also Lovell (2003), Adkins and Skeggs (2004) and Krais (2006) for new approaches in feminism towards Bourdieu’s work since his death in 2002.
8
LIVING THE BODY
subjects. They do however articulate individual aspirations, desires and goals and reflect the struggle for being-in-the-world in everyday life. Following Derrida (1993), I use the term ‘aporia’ (or ‘aporiai, pace Aristotle) suggestive of impasse without closure, to signify the quality of ambiguity, in resistance as a tool and as a method. Second, I address the problem of woman’s enactment or performance of identity in terms of what they seek to present about themselves through a variety of expressions that are embodied in their vision and construction of themselves as gendered beings. In a sense, as Judith Butler argues, ‘gender is performatively produced’ thereby ‘constituting the identity it is purported to be’. Further, ‘there is no gender identity behind the expressions of gender; that identity is performatively constituted by the very “expressions” that are said to be its results’ (Butler 1990: 24–25).9 I therefore pursue the notion of performativity as being central to woman’s self-construction and pose the question of whether this performativity and the creativity that is imbricated in performance in fact constitutes a break down in habitus. Or is it the case that the habitus is structured to some extent by ‘a kind of performativity’, as suggested by Butler (Butler 1997: 153)? If habitus operates according to a performativity, then the ‘social life of the body’, Butler argues, ‘is produced through an interpellation that is at once linguistic and productive.’ The manner in which this interpellative call takes ‘form in a bodily stylistics’, it is suggested, ‘in turn, performs its own social magic [and] constitutes the tacit and corporeal operation of performativity.’ Such a formulation understands habitus as the bodily enactment of certain dispositions that are already given and reaffirmed by society. I propose that performativity in a woman’s enactment and presentation of her embodied self, however, steps out of the constraining nature of habitus and reflects the more liberatory elements of play, movement, and unfettered expressions of the self. The constancy of the social is undeniable. In the playing out of an embodied identity through performance, in the assertion of an 9
‘Performatives’, we are told, ‘(utterances which enact or instatiate or bring about social statuses, as in the authorized declaration of marriage) are also always performances, but they have the force of social institutionalization behind them which mere performances lack. They are embedded in the social structures and norms that authorize them. For Butler, socially embedded performatives may be dislodged, their meanings transformed, by inspired performances that transgress with authority’ (Lovell 2000:15).
EMBODIMENT, IDENTITY AND WOMANHOOD
9
independence of spirit through the body, I do not suggest that the body has an independent existence. As Helen Fielding points out, ‘It is the nature of the embodied subject to move into and be taken up by the world around her. Essences emerge through this intertwining, in the space between. They are enacted but always and only in relation to the world and to others’ (Fielding 2000: 132). There is both a fluidity and closure therefore in expression and enactment. This should put to rest any attempt to consider such a perspective as essentialising woman as a biologically driven entity. In emphasising the agential aspects of embodiment, I do not suggest an ‘emancipatory model of agency’ (Mahmood 2005) but argue that agency emerges from within the structures of power and (like Butler) emphasise that ‘the reiterative structure of norms serves not only to consolidate a particular regime of discourse/power but also serves as the means of its destabilisation’ (as quoted in Mahmood 2005: 20). Moreover, ‘norms are not only consolidates and/or subverted but performed, inhabited and experienced in a variety of ways’ (ibid.: 22). In this understanding of the simultaneous constancy and malleability of habitus, the view is that the habitus is not only embodied, unthought and instinctual but also reflective through understanding and articulation, as well as through embodied work and play, made and unmade in the experience of everyday life. We are empowered through our bodies and the practical, material conditions of our everyday lives serve as markers of our embodiment as much as they do for the ground on which resistance, change and transformation are articulated and become possible. Class, caste and nation are therefore not only inscribed on our bodies but also, through our everyday lives, become the very agencies through which we negotiate our lives and the strategies we engage in to ensure our place, position and status in society or our struggle to attain class position and status as the case may be. Location is therefore critical to our understanding of embodiment in both its experiential and empowering contexts. It is not out of place to emphasise woman’s use of the body, including her sexuality, as a weapon—for survival, whether to combat the harsh conditions imposed by poverty, to attack the oppressor physically, or to strategically manipulate, coerce or extract the maximum to her advantage. Women seek to maximise their gains through embodied strategies of negotiation and manipulation, contestation and submission, creating desire and suggesting fulfilment. Such sexual strategies are not unknown in the
10
LIVING THE BODY
literature about women’s sexuality but I contend these embodied acts are as much political acts as they are sexual ploys, seeking to exploit and dominate as much as to sometimes submit to prevailing definitions about Indian womanhood. Location is also significant in the symbolism of the mirror in the narratives of women. What does the mirror symbolise in the lives of the women, in the family, in relationships and in self-imagery? The mirror, in one sense, constructs the ‘looking-glass self ’ (Cooley 1902)10 through engagement with the image reflected in the mirror whether this is one that emphasises ‘beauty’, desirable sexuality, or thebody-as-it-is, through display, adornment and self-appreciation. The mirror is also used as a metaphorical device to indicate the reflection of an embodied self in relationship, in play and in performance. Class is central to the use of the mirror as a strategic device, real or metaphorical, and it is upper-class women, with access to education, linguistic skills and the western media, who articulate this aspect of their lived experience of embodiment. My focus on women’s embodiment is clearly an effort to understand woman’s experience of her body, rather than emphasise the body as an object, image or construction. This formulation of embodiment as lived experience derives undoubtedly from the work of Merleau-Ponty who emphasises the body as ‘the vehicle of being in the world’ (Merleau-Ponty 1962: 82). Embodiment, a ‘lived matter of gender’ (Hughes and Witz 1997), articulated through our bodily senses, is crucial to the experience and perception of gender identity. In this sense, embodiment is ‘an existential condition in which the body is the subjective source or intersubjective ground of experience’ (Csordas 1999a: 143). I am therefore essentially concerned with culture and experience as they can be understood ‘from the standpoint of bodily being-in-the-world’ (ibid.). Bourdieu’s concept of habitus is critical for understanding the influence of structures in shaping our decisions as well as our response to them; similarly, the lived experience of embodiment is crucial for understanding the manner 10
Charles Cooley argues that the ‘looking glass self ’ or the ‘reflected’ self is a ‘social self ’. In this context, he says, ‘as we see our face, figure and dress in the glass, and are interested in them because they are ours and are pleased and otherwise with them according as they do or do not answer to what we should like them to be; so in imagination we perceive in another’s mind some thought of our appearance, manners, aims, deeds, character, friends, and so on, and are variously affected by it’ (see Cooley 1902: 179–185).
EMBODIMENT, IDENTITY AND WOMANHOOD
11
in which the body is perceived, constructed, performed, displayed and adorned. In the feminist discourse in contemporary India, woman’s embodiment is closely associated with the signifiers of identity emerging from the tropes of nation, community and religious fundamentalism whether it is in the context of the fractured nation-state of the partition period, the interests and forces of the nationalist movement, Hindu or Muslim communities, caste and ethnic communities and contemporary caste and class contexts.11 Woman’s embodiment is the true repository of purity, sacredness and honour thereby suggesting that in one way or another ‘the female body needs to be appropriated for a sense of national, racial or community identity to persist’ (Gedalof 1999: 203). The intersection of class and embodiment in the construction of identity is somewhat more complex. This emerges not only from women’s experience of their embodied and gendered selves in the context of their class positions but also from the ability of subjects to capture and convert different forms of capital to ensure upward mobility, status, position and privilege in society. Class is crucial to my analysis of women’s embodiment and identity as it shapes women’s experience of their everyday lives in very different ways. This is reflected in their diverse ways of knowing, remembering and experiencing their material conditions, their relationships with others and their consciousness of their condition in relation to caste, gender and community. The need for economic, cultural and social capital of different kinds signifying varied indicators of status and position is expressed very differently by women belonging to different social and economic backgrounds.12 Femininity, as that ‘way of being’ which bestows status, respectability and recognition, through embodied modes of appearance and selfpresentation is dependent on the social class position of women in differing contexts. For a middle-class woman, it is important to be viewed, both socially and culturally, as one who has clearly articulated self-definitions about her femininity as an embodied state that 11 See, for example, Sangari and Vaid (1993), Tanika Sarkar (1995, 1997), Butalia (1997), Chowdhry (1994, 2007), Chakravarti (2003). 12 I am here referring to the uses of capital as elucidated by Pierre Bourdieu (1986). In his understanding and analysis of the forms of capital, namely, economic, cultural and social capital and their transformation into symbolic capital, Bourdieu has made an important contribution to our understanding of how the conversion of capital results in changes in social class, status, privilege and domination.
12
LIVING THE BODY
gives off self-negotiated and constructed expressions about herself. A working class woman articulates her construction of femininity from within her economic and political space. It is therefore a very different construction of femininity, based on utilitarian and practical considerations, grounded in her everyday life experiences at work, in the family, community and poverty. Class is significant but I would like to emphasise that culture is equally important to our understanding of embodiment and identity as we are located in a space wherein culture in various forms impacts our physical senses and fleshly bodies in very specific and concrete ways and is simultaneously reflected in the practices we engage in. These include not only cultural practices that serve as markers of women’s status and roles in Indian society, but increasingly the domain of popular culture, the media and its manifestations and the practices emanating from them. The influence of culture is present in ways in which we use our bodies, look at our bodies, seek to change them in bits and pieces and above all, experience our embodiment in relation to others. In this sense, the space of everyday life, namely, ‘culture and social relations’, and I would assert our experience of these relations, are ‘essentially political spaces and practices’ (Bannerji 2001a: 8). Culture, and our experience of culture, is mediated by class relations and the discursive practices emanating from them. In contemporary social settings, therefore, changing modes of domination through the media, the ‘vendors of slimming aids’ and other agents of the increasingly dominant middle classes impose new uses of the body and create a new bodily ‘hexis’ which ‘substituting seduction for repression, public relations for policing, advertising for authority, the velvet glove for the iron fist, pursues the symbolic integration of the dominated classes by imposing needs rather than inculcating norms’ (Bourdieu 1984: 153–4). In this manner, both material conditions and social, cultural and symbolic transformations effect new modes of domination that in subtle ways are the tools par excellence of reproducing gender politics through embodied experience. It is in this sense that ‘class, as an ensemble of social relations and significational practices, is then not only an economic but a social form. It indicates how social spaces of lived relations, valorised practices and experiences are implicated in relations and moralities of property and labour relations’ (Bannerji 2001a: 10). This complex interplay of culture, social and class relations informs my analysis in different ways in the context of the experience of young
EMBODIMENT, IDENTITY AND WOMANHOOD
13
and adult women in the urban context of a changing postcolonial society like India. In my view, therefore, the body has both a physical location as much as a social construction. We experience our bodies not only in their socio-cultural located-ness but also through our emotions and our senses. We engage not only with the world but we also engage with our inner dilemmas, fears and anxieties through our embodied selves. The continuous dialogue between the inner and the outer, the self and the body, enables us to realise our goals through the experience of struggle, contestation and contradiction that is critical to everyday life.
SITES AND PRACTICES: RECOLONISATION AND ITS CONSEQUENCES The social, cultural and political consequences of location are significant indicators for embodied experience. The larger sociopolitical sites within which embodiment is experienced is at one level, the particular postcolonial context, that constructs a particular framework for the embodiment of subjects in contemporary society. Secondly, the specific socio-economic context in which subjects are both located and embedded is intrinsic not only to their class position but also to their particular experience of embodiment and gendered identity. There are thus variations at both the national and global levels and in the social locations of subjects. ‘Difference’ in a sense is critical to this approach. However, it is also significant that such difference does not imply or indicate a specificity of experience outside a universal experience but in fact includes the specific, and the multiplicities of experience implied, within the national and global.13 The ‘post-colonial’, as in postcolonial societies such as India, implies not only a historical condition but has also become a metaphor for an extraordinary situation in which a nation finds itself. This is the legacy of a mixed heritage characterised by the quality of 13 I would like to emphasise, pace Mohanty, that differences however are not mere ‘differences’ but that how ‘specifying difference allows us to theorise universal concerns more fully’(Mohanty 2002: 505).
14
LIVING THE BODY
the dominant postcolonial habitus that it embodies in its subjects. This habitus is produced and reproduced through the family, the educational code and its attendant discourse, such as language, and over a period of time becomes a significant marker of status and distinction.14 Simultaneously this habitus generates the recolonisation of society whether or not it has experienced political and economic colonialism. As opposed to the current preoccupation with postcolonial-ism, as both a social and political condition, as well as a conceptual category for the understanding of relations of power, I use the conceptual category of recolonisation which I see as a far more significant fallout of colonialism. The term ‘recolonization’ was brought to my attention through the astute comments made by Jacqui Alexander and Chandra Mohanty who refer to ‘processes of recolonization’ as those processes which are a result of ‘global alignments and fluidity of capital [which] have simply led to further consolidation and exacerbation of capitalist relations of domination and exploitation’ (1997: xvii). Recolonisation is not merely a process, as some would say, akin to globalisation or westernisation. Far more dangerously, it refers to relations of power that manifest themselves and function through different social processes at different historical moments in time and point to the continuities, discontinuities and transformations in colonial and imperial power. The term ‘colonisation’ implies several different relations at different historical and cultural moments. Apart from the obvious political and economic inequalities it addresses, it also significantly refers to ‘the production of a particular cultural discourse about what is called the “third world”’ (Mohanty 1991a: 52). In particular, this has included a feminist, white preoccupation by western scholars about women of colour, women in the ‘Third World’, ‘native’ women, and as Mohanty succinctly concludes, ‘almost invariably implies a relation of structural domination, and a suppression—often violent—of the heterogeneity of the subject(s) in question’ (ibid.). This hierarchical relation ends up therefore ‘producing/re-presenting a composite, singular “third-world woman”—an image…arbitrarily 14 I use the conceptual category of ‘postcolonial habitus’ to specify the context in which habitus is created and reproduced. I therefore take recourse to ‘postcolonial’ as a historical and social condition that shapes habitus in diverse and particular ways through familial relations, schooling practices and other modalities of the social and public domain.
EMBODIMENT, IDENTITY AND WOMANHOOD
15
constructed, but nevertheless carries with it the authorizing signature of Western humanist discourse’ (ibid.: 53). This hegemonic relation of power where western, feminist, predominantly white women appropriate for themselves the privileged position of commentators and theorisers of the condition and position of universal woman is, I contend, another example of recolonisation. All societies are characterised however by not only a dominant culture but also by those who have been excluded from both the culture as well as from the social and cultural reproductive process (to the extent that they remain outside the formal education system) and its gains. By remaining outside a fixed system that provides gains to those who simultaneously understand and imbibe it, they are in a sense outsiders to the dominant postcolonial habitus of that society. In other words, they have not imbibed the habits and manners of the colonisers, nor are they educated in elite, English-medium schools, nor do they have the cultural and social class that would signify their position in the dominant sections of a postcolonial space, and nor are they privileged to fathom the depths of recolonisation that takes them and their position in society as given but a nonetheless insignificant presence. Their educationally disadvantaged position and location in social space therefore generates a habitus that reproduces difference and lived experience as gendered, subaltern subjects. The social divisions that inhere in society may easily be grouped according to class, caste, age, ethnicity and gender differences but the divisions that exist on the ground go deeper than these well-defined and analysed social categories. Caste divisions therefore are not the only defining characteristics of social exclusion; the dominant culture ensures the reproduction of a habitus that automatically ensures exclusion along varied dividing lines.15 This habitus however is such that it seeks to rise above the very postcoloniality that it embodies and therefore seeks to consolidate and establish new relations of power that are both rooted in the contemporary as well as take on shades of a distant past that is both culturally and socially located in a modern, 15 Power relations, I would therefore argue, following Bernstein, ‘create boundaries, legitimise boundaries, reproduce boundaries, between different categories of groups, gender, class, race, different categories of discourse, different categories of agents’ (Bernstein 1996:19). The most significant and pervasive boundaries in rural and urban India are those of caste, gender and religion. See, among others, Chowdhry (2007), for the practices that serve to maintain and reproduce these boundaries in different contexts and the efforts towards resistance.
16
LIVING THE BODY
changing India as well as in its essential corollary, an emotionally, culturally and socially rooted tradition. In this process of exclusion, it is important to also establish the defining characteristics of those who have been included. These are primarily based on their class and caste affiliations, their social status and position in society in relation to their gender, education and occupation. These are perhaps the visible markers of being included in the pre-eminent habitus that is part of the dominant culture. There are however certain invisible markers of inclusion and these are visible only to others who seek to differentiate between those who are in and who are out, the included and the excluded, the privileged and the under-privileged, and the dominant and the subaltern. The invisible markers are defined by that which they purport to hide, the lack of an appropriate habitus, as it were, that forms the ground of the social and cultural exclusion. These may include aspects of their existence that do not fulfil the criteria of inclusion such as the appropriate caste or class status, educational or professional qualifications, linguistic abilities, age and gender. Although the postcolonial subject has herself been a subject of hegemonic forces, she still does not hesitate to knowingly exclude the subaltern other. The politics of recolonisation is therefore all about both reproducing the colonial moment as well as extending the hegemony of the past in the present. The dominant postcolonial habitus in India has been embodied primarily in those who had access to the colonisers and were privileged in the sense of being able to relate to them in terms of their language and socio-political relations. It was primarily in Bengal that the colonial literary and cultural encounter took root and shape and was to influence the nature and quality of the postcolonial character. This class imbibed western (English) education, culture, literature and the arts while simultaneously seeking freedom from the yoke of foreign rule. At the same time, as Aijaz Ahmad has argued, the ‘sense of the superiority of Western knowledges’ was established not in the literary or cultural but in the ‘cognitive and technical fields’ (Ahmad 1992: 269). He suggests that the ‘petty bourgeoisie, of both the traditional (propertied) and the new (professional) kinds’ were pushed towards English and Western knowledges because of the nature of their school education and their own ambitions. However, there was a contradiction to the extent that ‘their own lives kept them rooted on their own linguistic communities’ (ibid.: 272). It was this class
EMBODIMENT, IDENTITY AND WOMANHOOD
17
that existed in a contradictory realm of both loyalty and rebellion, western in its mind and indigenous in its life, that constituted the heart, as it were, of postcolonial habitus and influenced the direction in which further social inclusion and exclusion could and eventually would take place. It is also the case that this postcolonial habitus is now germane to the middle classes who are at the forefront of Indian socio-political and cultural life today. It has been suggested that it is the middle classes in Indian society who have taken on the mantle of building India in the postcolonial period, of playing a leading role in the development and growth of the nation. Satish Deshpande identifies the main function of the middle classes in this period as hegemonising: ‘to build hegemony’ (Deshpande 1998: 153). This ‘moral privileging’ of the middle-class task of modernising the nation through a model of ‘development’ which imitated the west and yet maintained a pristine inner sphere ‘protected from western contamination’ (ibid.) is an illustration of recolonisation through social agents whose postcolonial habitus created in them the general dispositions to perform a hegemonising role. This pure, untouched, inner sphere did not remain unpolluted for very long. The advent and spread of global culture has ensured its recolonisation with the help of the very same middle classes that perhaps sought to protect it in earlier times. In contemporary urban India beset by globalisation, recolonisation is in fact a complex process giving rise to complex and changing identities in everyday life. Alexander and Mohanty add, ‘Understanding the various constructions of self and identity during late capitalism—when transnationalisation confounds the postcolonial and women’s relationship to it, and when fluid borders permit the mobility of ‘free’ market capital—is a complicated enterprise that cannot be simply invoked by claiming fluid or fractured identities’ (Alexander and Mohanty 1997: xvii-xviii). My work makes an effort to comprehend these cultural, socio-economic and political processes of transnational crossings and understand their impact on identity in relation to gender and embodiment. In doing this, I aim to present a more nuanced understanding of the relations of power allowing for multiplicity in subjectivities, in perspectives, in the public and social domain and in agency and resistance. The possibilities for transformation are present in lived experience and find expression in multiple ways through voice, action and often
18
LIVING THE BODY
through a recognition and articulation of the acts of oppression and violence that are tied to the relations that bind women. Agency is therefore crucial, although the possibilities for transformation are always bounded by the restricting nature of the dominant constructions of caste, class, age, ethnicity, religious and regional locations. Does such agency, including struggle against oppression of different kinds, engender resistance to particular issues, experiences, actions and values and does it have any intent to transform? Sunder Rajan contends that ‘It [resistance] is not (yet) a revolutionary term since, as we notice, it is a praxis that is reactive to domination rather than one that initiates a transformation’ (Sunder Rajan 2000: 154). It is imperative to consider however that ‘transformation’, as the complete change of existing social and political conditions, can be attempted successfully only through a concerted effort at change at different levels of social existence. Transformation in itself is therefore not a condition that will necessarily result from individual acts of resistance although contrarily, individual actions do indeed often contribute to social transformation. The processes of resistance in the lives of women in urban India need to be understood in the context of their construction as ‘Indian’ women in the problematic scenario, that has accompanied the processes of globalisation, and that is still being played out in the arena of the socio-economic life of the country.
WOMANHOOD IN CONTEMPORARY INDIA Womanhood in contemporary India is a complex construct, and ambivalent experience, located as it is in the contradictions, cleavages and dilemmas that beset the social and public domains as well as in the complexities of everyday life. Uma Chakravarti’s seminal work on a colonial and nationalist construction of an Aryan Hindu identity for women in the second half of the nineteenth century documents the ‘invention’ of a tradition (Chakravarti 1993: 73). The construction of a particular past was coterminous with the construction of a particular kind of womanhood. Nationalism, like religion, became a legitimate area for women’s participation and the nationalists focused only on upper caste Aryan women. Chakravarti concludes
EMBODIMENT, IDENTITY AND WOMANHOOD
19
that the twentieth century has ‘continued to reproduce, in all essentials, what the nineteenth century has so carefully and so successfully constructed as an enduring legacy for us’ (ibid.: 79). This points to the recolonisation of women as gendered, subaltern subjects in contemporary India where discourses of tradition and modernity in fact exist simultaneously, and often contradictorily, creating an ambivalent space both for the construction of womanhood in the social and public domain and for women’s lived experience in everyday life.16 Modernity is a troublesome construct in postcolonial societies, particularly because it has to contend with a legacy of both a tradition that must be changed even as it must also be valued (Ram 1998: 270).17 This contradictory experience indicates a constant movement between defining and redefining old and new social and political constructions of womanhood in the changing and markedly fluid social and public discourses of ‘modern’ India.18 I contend that the new woman in the rapidly altering cultural and social imaginary of this nation need not necessarily always be constructed in the context of a charged and transformed modernity, as it were. Rather, she should be viewed in the fluid and marked nature of her identity as a woman, 16 Nita Kumar provides a cogent discussion of ‘women as subjects’ and rejecting the Cartesian subject as well as the subject as constituted by the Subaltern Studies group. She constitutes the subject through what she calls, ‘a modified Foucauldian approach’ wherein ‘the subject is constituted, as formed by discourse, but also, the subject that resists, that can inevitably fashion other discourses’ (Kumar 1994: 8). This perspective is similar to my own conclusions as elaborated in this work. 17 Modernity is also viewed as having been ‘misrecognised’ in India because it is understood as ‘technology and contemporary artefacts’ (Gupta 2000: 2). Gupta defines modernity in terms of ‘attitudes, especially those that come into play in social relations’ such as an individual’s dignity, adherence to universalistic norms, individual achievement and accountability in public life (ibid.). Undoubtedly, modernity includes not only attitudes that prevail in social relations but also the resultant practices that may emanate from these attitudes as well as from what may be considered ‘tradition’. 18 I do not consider ‘Indian woman’ as representative of a larger, homogeneous monolith whole but one constituted by and through the multiplicity, diversity and complexity of caste, class, linguistic and other social and economic indicators. My discussion of this ‘new’ or ‘modern’ woman is therefore very much related to her class and social position (she is educated), her ability to consume (she has income of some sort), to make choices (ability to discriminate and exercise choice), and so on. She is therefore unlike the category of the ‘Asian modern woman’ who, argues Munshi, ‘may be no more than a discursive ideological space for identification created by the global/local media’ (Munshi 2001: 7).
20
LIVING THE BODY
shaped and redefined in the everyday experiences of women as they both contest and submit to the images and constructs that impinge on their senses, their emotions and their material and social conditions. In this sense, as Sangari and Vaid argue, the constructs of tradition and modernity are the products of a colonial enterprise and should be rejected in favour of understanding ‘cultural processes in their actual complexity’ (Sangari and Vaid 1993: 17). This complexity is undoubtedly characterised by the heterogeneity and multiplicity of experiences, events and disjunctures of everyday life. Social class, status, and education, among other factors, are significant markers in the construction of the embodied identity of the ‘modern’ Indian woman. Squarely located in the facts of her material existence in terms of both her embodiment and her class position, ‘her image interacts with so many social forces that compete for space in female imagination, that historically and cross-culturally she continues to be a powerful dream or female fantasy’ (Munshi 2001: 7). It is this image and the fantasising about the image, linked as it is to feminine desire and consumption, that makes it imperative to understand the ‘modern’, new and somewhat fluid components of Indian womanhood. In contemporary times, the liberalisation of the Indian economy has added a new impetus to the discourse of modernity, particularly in relation to women. It is precisely in this period of transition that the possibilities for both recolonisation, and also for resistance, open up. Recolonisation is characterised by a mix of global elements translated into socially and culturally acceptable, and thereby legitimate, ideas, values and practices in everyday life. The phenomenon of globalisation, and its implications for urban India over the last decade, offers one example of the recolonisation of women (Bhattacharya 1994, Chaudhuri 1999, John 1998). The production of a global culture has consequences for everyday life in contemporary urban India. Education processes and media culture play a significant role in this production. A new global media provides the symbols, myths, resources, ideas, and images for the construction of a common culture as well as of individual identities. Thus the upper-class, English-speaking, educationally advantaged urban elite in India emphasises the non-traditional (contemporary), liberated (westernised) and trendy (modern) aspects of everyday life. The cosmopolitan, urbane, civilised Indian social agent, who is part of a globalised network of relations, constitutes the elite section of the new middle class, which has now become the crucial component of
EMBODIMENT, IDENTITY AND WOMANHOOD
21
a modern India.19 This new middle-class Indian emphasises all that is modern in the world today, including a view of the Indian woman that transcends her earlier location in the domestic world. Sangari and Vaid point to the ‘formation of a predominantly middle class public sphere’ in nineteenth century Bengal that repositioned ‘cultural forms…in a desired version of Indian culture and in desired versions of ideal women.’ This reformulation also implied the repositioning of the home ‘as the insulated private sphere which is to be free from even temporary challenges to male authority’. This paved the way for women to access the middle class sphere as both reformers and indeed as reformed women (Sangari and Vaid 1993: 12). There is however a complexity in this entry of women into the public sphere wherein although they had access to the English literary tradition and acquired a linguistic sophistication appropriate to their class and social status, they remained embedded in a patriarchal discourse that seeks to shape their engagement in public life in both enabling and restricting ways. The new and emergent view of Indian womanhood defines women, amongst other things, as ‘of substance’ and includes a more visible and public view of women in the workplace, both within new spheres of work, such as design and fashion, journalism and social activism, and through an entry into the traditionally male preserves of the military, police, banking, and other allied occupations. This emphasis on women’s public roles is largely at variance with the middle and upper class nationalist construction of the cultural domain in terms of an inner and an outer sphere. In everyday life these refer both to the home and the world, with the home representing our spiritual self and our true identity. Women are constructed at the centre of the inner world, whereas the exterior domain of ‘material interests’, treachery and intrigue is the domain of men (Chatterjee 1993: 238ff.). The inner world is also the ‘moral’ world, as it were, and it is the symbolic control of the moral, through education and 19 Contemporary work has addressed the significance of the middle class in postcolonial India. Deshpande (2003) provides an analysis of the centrality and social significance of the middle class in building hegemony in the post-independence period; Gupta’s (2000) analysis of modernity in India includes a scathing critique of the role of the middle class; Joshi (2001) examines the public-sphere politics of the middle class in late nineteenth and early twentieth century north India and links it to a ‘fractured modernity’ that included elements of both ‘authoritarianism and liberalism, emancipation and hierarchy.’
22
LIVING THE BODY
other civilising processes, that is emphasised in that period. Commenting on the same historical juncture, Bannerji emphasises, ‘…The hegemonic agenda, is invariably an agenda of morality, of values expressed through both ideas and practices…It is through the creation, recreation and a diffusion of a set of norms and forms that the necessary “consent” can be built which is essential for hegemony’s fullest expression’ (Bannerji 2001a: 139). The middle classes, who at the time hold ‘a subordinate and/or collaborative position within classes which are ruled…and ruling’ (ibid.), play a significant role in the control of the moral domain that contains the home with woman at its centre. This does not however deny the agency of women or restrain their voice during this period. It has been powerfully argued that women’s approach to nation-building at the time includes ‘demands for property or economic self-sufficiency (and) entitlement of political agency and citizenship’ (Bannerji 2001b: 70). It is therefore not only the home but most definitely, ‘the public sphere, resonating with a discourse of reason, which attracted women inexorably’ (ibid.). At the same time, however, women were limited by their own middle-class lifestyles that prevented them from breaking free of patriarchal structures and relations that had been created, legitimised and reproduced by a ‘fractured modernity’(Joshi 2001: 21). In contemporary, middle class, urban India, global culture rearticulates woman’s identity and interests through a set of discursive practices that privilege her position in the outer world. This world is largely defined by norms and forms emanating from the west, indigenized, adopted for consumption by the Indian middle classes and presented and represented through the countless tropes of modernity present in everyday life. This ‘entrapment’ of women in the conflict between ‘tradition’ and ‘modernity’ in postcolonial contexts (Sunder Rajan and Park 2000: 61) can be viewed as a process of recolonisation that seeks to position women in particular ways that are not dissimilar to their positioning in colonial contexts. It is apparent in contemporary India that the so-called old modes of contact (including religious practices, cultural tradition and social custom) and apparently new ones (most significantly, educational processes and the visual and print media) shape, influence, structure, and construct womanhood in particular and varied ways. Both modes of contact, I suggest, are forms of recolonisation of social agents in postcolonial societies. The reiteration of the old characteristics of colonialism include, for example, an emphasis on the education of women, not necessarily for their individual empowerment but for the
EMBODIMENT, IDENTITY AND WOMANHOOD
23
purposes of having educated and aware mothers and wives who are harbingers of social and cultural development that will contribute to national progress. The process of recolonisation is significant because it reproduces the characteristics of colonialism in a redefined mode, asserting the essential value of such characteristics, in postcolonial societies thereby ensuring continuous hegemony over cultural, social and economic domains. In urban India, the visual and print media has taken upon itself the mantle of spreading, supporting and thereby legitimising a particular image of a changing, ‘modernising’ India. The dominant postcolonial habitus asserts itself in different ways through the modalities of reproduction and change offered by the multiple channels of the visual and print mass media available in a rapidly growing and increasingly media-savvy urban society like India. For example, television today is dominated by a mix of indigenous television serials caricaturing contemporary urban and rural life. They are largely set in the familiar spaces of the family which is sacred to the constitution of personhood within the cultural dynamics of what it means to be an ‘Indian’. Reproduction of family norms, values, traditions and practices is therefore crucial to maintaining and conserving the image of the middle-class family in everyday life. There is a simultaneous celebration of the spending power of the middle-class elite through advertisements for all kinds of products in different channels of the media. Chakravarty and Gooptu aptly conclude that their analysis of the construction of the nation in the media in contemporary India, ‘has shown the emergence of a certain vision of the nation in the mainstream media, in which the middle class family forms the core of a community and a nation-space of plenty, and consumption provides the primary mode of enfranchisement’ (Chakravarty and Gooptu 2000: 104).20 The reproduction of the family as the core of a developing and changing society in turn reproduces values pertaining to its protection and well-being. This ensures an instrumental view of women who are 20 In the same way as the middle classes took on the mantle of modernising and developing the nation in the postcolonial period, the middle class plays a similar role in shaping the future vision of the media, including television policy in India. The middle classes embody the ‘target audience’ of official television networks and policy makers. In fact, it is suggested that through ‘its portrayal of “modern” middle-class lifestyles and its encouragement of consumerist desires, television seems to have played a crucial role in the cultural constitution of these middles classes as a powerful historic bloc’ (Mankekar 1999: 9).
24
LIVING THE BODY
now required to play a new role as educated mothers and wives, as well as, enlightened consumers of goods and services that will secure the family as a consuming, healthy unit. This perspective on women, engendered by globalisation, is one that merely views her in terms of her contribution to the national economy and, by not shaking off the clutch of patriarchy in any way, results in the recolonisation of women through a regurgitation of the old dressed up as new. Identities are not radically redefined, only recast in the language and mores of the contemporary moment. It is not surprising then, as Guha Thakurta concludes, that the new Indian woman in advertising in the media, for example, is trapped in ‘a twofold commodification of femininity’: on the one hand, through the ‘controlled and passive sexuality of the (Indian) woman that is inscribed in the bodies of “good” women with some sort of relation to the family’ and who end up propagating the ‘valorised ideals of sacrifice and self-effacement for the ‘cause’ of the family’(Guha Thakurta 2004: 138). On the other hand, not only does advertising encourage women to consume but it also ‘induces women to perceive themselves as commodities’. Through lending their bodies for endorsement of various products in the visual and print media, women do contribute to the commodification of their fragmented bodies, as lips, hair, eyebrows, legs, and so on. In this manner, a fragmented experience of embodiment may result and contribute to further commodification in an endless cycle of reproducing the very structures that serve to construct us in various ways.21 I would not like to conclude however that women are mere spectators and passive participants in this process of commodification and in their reproduction of an ideology that supports and values such commodification. There is a complexity underpinning women’s participation in work of all kinds and this needs to be further understood before we arrive at any hasty conclusions that emphasise the collusion of women in their own commodification. Perhaps, we need to understand that the new urban middle classes are not only the consumers of commodities but also of the ‘new India 21 It is significant that the resistance to such marketing ploys to boost the global/ local economies, has come from a Rightist perspective (more specifically, the Hindu right) that now seeks to reinvent Indian womanhood through an emphasis on values of the ‘virtuous’ and ‘good’ Hindu wife and mother (see Guha Thakurta 2004: 143ff), who in fact concludes that the ‘global economy/consumer capitalism goes hand-inhand with Indian (Hindu) nationalism’ (ibid.: 144).
EMBODIMENT, IDENTITY AND WOMANHOOD
25
produced through the meanings attached to these commodities’ (Fernandes 2000: 622). These include new and reworked meanings and identities of gender roles and gender relations within a re-imagined national identity. In this construction, the ‘new Indian woman’ is an ambivalent entity shaped by the social and public domain which simultaneously portrays her as glamorous, independent, conscious of her embodiment and of the many forms of adornment and selfpresentation available to her, and yet enshrined in the world of tradition through her adherence to family and national values. The overarching trope therefore remains that of middle-class respectability within which woman is ‘free’ to pursue her career and look after the interests of her family and her body repair and maintenance. This portrayal is perhaps one attempt to ‘manage the destabilizing contradictions’ produced by globalisation in the new India (Fernandes 2000: 623). Lest the trendy and socially elite lifestyles associated with contemporary consumerism suggest the emergence of amoral or decadent choices, it becomes essential to project the Indian woman as the symbol of all that is ‘good’ and yet ‘modern’ in the national imaginary. This active management of women as bearers of tradition and symbols of a ‘good’ (respectable) modernity may indicate at one level the victory of the agents of recolonisation, but it simultaneously gives rise to new and emergent forms of contestation and negotiation that engage women in pursuit of their goals in everyday life.
CONCLUDING COMMENTS This chapter has examined sociological and anthropological constructions of embodiment, gender and identity and asserted the significance of these for the study of the social construction of womanhood in contemporary India as well as women’s lived experience in everyday life. Such a perspective emphasises the embodied and thereby material existence of everyday life but, equally, underscores the fluidity in the socially lived experience of identity as a gendered subject. The methodological pitch of such an approach undoubtedly points to the politics of the construction, and living out of womanhood, based on historical and social events and perspectives, in contemporary India. The paradoxical elements in this process result in an ambiguity in an understanding of womanhood which remains a contested category, presented, represented, negotiated and experienced in vastly contradictory terms.
2 CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE
T
o understand the construction and experience of womanhood among young women in contemporary India, I turn to the everyday world of adolescent young women, in, and out of, school. Adolescence in India is a contested category as there is no fixed age span when young women may experience adolescence; it remains a more ambiguous and fluid category than it is perceived in the west. The term adolescence is Latin in origin and derives from adolescere, which means ‘to grow into adulthood’ and clearly there is ‘no single event or boundary line that denotes the end of childhood or the beginning of adolescence’ (Steinberg 2003). It has been suggested that adolescence comprises a ‘set of transitions’ that unfold gradually in the context of an individual’s behaviour, development and relationships (ibid.). There are gender differences in this process that remained unnoticed in the early works on the subject. It was only in the early 1980s that psychologists such as Carol Gilligan highlighted the psychological development of young women as part of a theory of adolescence. Psychologists like Erikson (1968, 1979) had earlier focused on male adolescents in formulating their theories and did not seek to differentiate between women and men. The term ‘adolescence’ itself was a masculine construct based on masculine images. Crucial defining concepts such as ‘self, identity, relationship, sexuality, morality, creativity, achievement and even development itself were drawn for the most part from a man’s perspective or reflected the viewpoint of a male child’ (Gilligan 1995: 196). While the sociologist James Coleman (1961) did include young women as a distinct category in his work, his primary focus was on the ‘value climate’ of each of the ten US schools he studied rather than women per se. Carol Gilligan’s work (1982, 1988) was a major landmark
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 27
in adolescent studies, highlighting the neglect of young women and focusing on the different dimensions of female adolescence. She has in fact suggested that by not studying women, what has been missed is an understanding about ‘relationships’ and their significance in young women’s lives.1 Cultures of adolescence are somewhat complex in a heterogeneous, pluralist and changing society like India where they are not only shaped by class, gender and educational status but are also mediated by the peer group, marriage and childbearing. There is clearly no well-defined age-period within which adolescence is experienced as a marked transition period between childhood and adulthood by young women in Indian urban and rural society.2 T.S. Saraswathi (1999) has argued that although there is a period of transition between childhood and adulthood marked by the onset of puberty, adolescence itself is ‘a matter of cultural construction’. She writes, ‘the greater the continuity between childhood and adulthood, and greater the similarity in life course and continuity in expectations from childhood to adulthood, the greater the possibility of the absence of a distinct phase or life stage called adolescence’ (Saraswathi 1999: 214). Referring to a large number of cross-sectional and longitudinal studies of Indian children, Saraswathi concludes that child-adult continuity is clearly marked among young women cutting across social class except in the highest socio-economic groups.3 Women in all social classes are groomed, in one way or another, for marriage and motherhood. It is only in the elite and the highest income groups that young women have the opportunity to pursue their interests and self-defined career goals. The influence of peer group culture and the mass media are significant in this group. Even here, however, young women experience a conflict in their articulation of their 1 Gilligan’s work has also addressed the importance of ‘moral questions’ in adolescence, which she suggests is a crucial time for a ‘moral education’ (Gilligan 1988). See also Gilligan et al. (1990) and Gilligan (1995). 2 There are differences between urban and rural experiences of adolescence further differentiated according to social class and educational backgrounds. Kumar (2002) divides the period of adolescence in a Rajasthani community into three phases: early adolescence characterising residence with parents with some physiological changes, mid-adolescence with the onset of menstruation and residence with the husband, and late adolescence when young women become mothers. 3 See also Verma and Saraswathi (2002) who examine the influence of ‘tradition and modernity in sociopolitical and cultural factors’ in shaping adolescence in India.
28
LIVING THE BODY
career aspirations and their commitment to the family. In very poor and working-class families, there does indeed appear to be an absence of adolescence as a distinct stage in the life cycle of educationally disadvantaged women especially among those who are betrothed in childhood and married before the onset of puberty. It is therefore difficult to fix any age at which young women may, therefore, be perceived as experiencing adolescence: is it when they attain puberty, or when they have sexual intercourse for the first time, or when they bear children? It is therefore a more fluid period of transition between childhood and adulthood that stretches out longer in this category of young women. In this chapter, I seek to understand the complexities in the articulation and constitution of gender identity as part of the cultures of adolescence among elite, educationally advantaged as well as poor, educationally disadvantaged adolescent women in urban India. The term ‘educationally advantaged’ refers to that category of individuals who not only have access to education (in a range of private and government schools) but also have the privilege of pursuing their educational goals to fruition. This is not common across India but is a distinct part of the lives of girls who belong to the middle and uppermiddle class in urban Indian society. The educationally advantaged young woman is simultaneously a part of tradition, ritual and customary practices and also experiences the contemporary world through both the education she may receive, the diverse images and texts presented by the visual and print media and the peer group culture she is part of. This dilemma gives rise to conflicting sets of expectations about her identity as a young woman in relation to familial and socio-cultural factors and in relation to her peers at school. The educationally disadvantaged young woman, on the other hand, due to the absence of schooling, except in her very early years, appears to lack a similar kind of obvious exposure to the contemporary modern world, with its imagery and the public sphere within which it is located. Early marriage, child bearing, her marital home and its attendant tasks and her relationship with her husband and his family, are her major preoccupations and her experience of adolescence is grounded in the dominant defining features of her life in the family and community. Although adolescent and adult women in this category are unable to read, it would be somewhat problematic to therefore assume that they do not have access to the visual media, Bollywood films, and an entire range of popular cinema in a variety of linguistic
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 29
and cultural genres. Satellite television is a part of the social life of families in urban slums and this opens up a visual world in the form of films, soaps, news and music channels.4 Although they do not have the experience of schooled education, this no doubt influences their perceptions of relationships between and among members of the family, the peer group and larger social and community networks. Moreover, the lure and driving force of the visually creative world of advertisements undoubtedly influences their sense of physical beauty in relation to their embodiment but, as we will see later, this too is largely influenced by cultural custom and tradition as complete choice, dependent on resources, lies outside their realm of experience. While their everyday life worlds may seem to be disparate and completely alien to each other, the presence or absence of schooling, is significant in the lives of both sets of young women. For the educationally advantaged group, schooling practices and the experience of schooling leads to certain career choices and decisions that are a result of schooling. Marriage is not perceived as inevitable although there is a consideration of family life in their career choices. In the second set of young women, schooling is more or less absent. This group therefore experiences the transition between childhood and adulthood through the institution of marriage which is the most significant post-pubertal event in their lives. The agential voice is present in both sets of young women although its articulation takes different forms. Educationally advantaged young women give voice to the disadvantages they experience in relation to young men and schooling practices in particular. Educationally disadvantaged young women are also critically engaged with the world: they give voice to their powerlessness through a recognition of the acts of powerlessness they experience. Their cognition of their powerlessness enables them to confront realities in ways that enable them to manoeuvre, strategise and survive often in very difficult and disempowering situations and contexts. The experience of ‘adolescence’ is based on young women’s perceptions and lived experience in relation to their families, peer group 4 Not only are all categories of women watching television, McMillin’s study on consumers of television and their choice of television programming in India suggests that women’s choices are certainly influenced by their class and income levels and, more importantly, their ‘selection of non-native language programmes was an important rite of signification of their citizenship within the multi-lingual, multi-ethnic and multicultural Indian nation’ (McMillin 2002: 128).
30
LIVING THE BODY
cultures, and schooling or lack of it. To understand how identities are both constructed and lived, I am interested in ‘the generation and circulation of meanings…relating to gender, and how these meanings are implicated in the construction of femininity in girls and young women’ (Taylor 1995: 5). These meanings do not however exist merely at a personal, experiential level but are also imbricated in social structures and indeed constitute such structures as much as they influence them. Taylor suggests that certain institutional settings such as schools, families and the workplace are sites where ‘social practices are gender structured’ (ibid: 6). To these may also be added sites outside formal institutional settings such as community centres, playgrounds, streets, and friendship groups, clusters or gangs, which may or may not be located within school settings. It is also essential to emphasise that meanings may certainly be shaped in institutional and non-institutional settings but are also simultaneously produced and engendered through talk, conversation, and gossip between young women, in the presence or absence of young men or older women, in friendship pairs or larger peer group settings. I will first examine the role of the family in providing, constructing and reproducing normatively defined and experienced gender identities among educationally advantaged young women. I will then consider the space of the school and peer group cultures in further articulating and legitimising the experiences of young women into well-defined feminine roles and identities. The second part of the chapter will examine the experiences of the educationally disadvantaged young women highlighting the significant absence of schooling and the centrality of the family, marriage and childbearing in their lives.
EDUCATIONALLY ADVANTAGED YOUNG WOMEN Cultures of adolescence in this category are characterised largely by the dominant influence of the family in constituting identities in terms of a patriarchal norm of the perfect but somewhat distant father and the communicative though sometimes strict mother, both of whom inhabit the emotional spaces and physical worlds of the young women differently. Together however they serve to reproduce habitus in its generative state wherein familial norms are affirmed
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 31
and strengthened within the larger context of schooling and peer group cultures.
The Reproduction of Patriarchy The family is a crucial site for the development of gender identities in relation to both familial perceptions as well as to those emerging from the social and public domain. The experience of young women may be articulated at one level in the register of the directly stated as experiential and at another level, through the register of the subtext of voices and texts, of the underlying nature of their relations with other members of their families. The emergence of multiple selves is clearly evident in their construction of self in relation to the family and peer group, in their diverse and varying images of self and others in the construction of identities. The characteristics of modern Indian family life appear to have changed, from the traditional extended family living together to the more commonly visible nuclear family.5 This may have resulted in greater bonding between members of the nuclear family, due to the absence of a large and overbearing network of kin relations, but in no way does this suggest a marked transformation in the articulation of the roles and functions of various members of the nuclear family. The work of Indian feminists and scholars such as Leela Dube (1988), Zarina Bhatty (1988), Sudhir Kakar (1988), Kamala Ganesh (1989), Shahida Lateef (1990), and Jasodhara Bagchi (1995), among others has shown the contribution of cultural and social values, in differing religious and social contexts, to the development of gender identities. These values include an emphasis on female submissiveness and passivity and particular role-specific identities and they tend to reproduce gender asymmetry and a classical femininity that is continuously looking to the external, social world for its own 5 A.M. Shah has used census data to show that the preponderance of joint households has increased and that a larger number of people live in joint households than nuclear households (1999: 1180). However, among the educationally advantaged, urban elite in India, there appears to be a greater preponderance of nuclear households, although more research is needed in this area. Not a single respondent in my sample indicated joint household residence. Among educationally disadvantaged young women, however, respondents were members of joint family households whether in their natal or in their marital homes.
32
LIVING THE BODY
nurturance and sustenance. In a sense, these processes also ensure that the gendered self does not seek to consciously develop an interior world of social and political awareness that may challenge social constructions of identity. Thus, contemporary middle class, urban India finds itself in a safe, patriarchal haven as far as the politics of the family is concerned. The family remains the cradle of nurturance, comfort and security that it has always constituted.6 Simultaneously, however, the family is also the site for the multiple oppression of young women, depending on their social class and background. This oppression is perceived for what it is by young women from poor or low middle-class backgrounds who can clearly predict their life trajectories and seek to negotiate their everyday life practices from within that experience. The cohesive and all-encompassing nature of the Indian family and the reproduction of existing patriarchal norms and values appear to be central to the experience of young women. That is, young women seek to acknowledge and affirm this experiential component of their relations with the family. Simultaneously, we may ascertain certain complexities in their articulation of their familial relationships. Fathers are idealised and revered for their abilities to look after the family, earn a livelihood against all odds, and be ‘perfect’ in more ways than one. A young woman’s relationship with her father, it has been suggested, is ‘only one strand in the great complexity of interfamilial relations that contribute to the construction of social and sexual identity in contemporary times’ (Mann 1996: 80). It is from these relationships and from young women’s relationships with other men in the family that the basis for relationships with men in different contexts is formed. It is a somewhat problematic relationship with the father wherein he is respected and admired but is not always around for a close relationship. One young woman says: My father: somebody who I always look up to for care, love, helping me make my decisions. His perfection in whatever he may 6 This is somewhat at variance with the status of the family in contemporary Western society, where it is acquiring a new historical form, the post-familial family (Beck-Gernsheim 1998: 54). However, this may not be embraced by North American and British Indians. Patricia Uberoi’s paper (1998) on contemporary commercial Hindi cinema points to the felt need among such diasporic communities for the rearticulation and regeneration of patriarchal and patrilineal family values among its possibly wayward, westernised youth. Clearly, the significance of place as location is important in understanding the Indian family.
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 33
do, compels me to make him my role model. … Since I have always seen my dad work very hard in his jobs; and he mostly came back home late, I certainly did spend more time with my mother. She is from where I belong, my shelter, my friend. She is a very patient and understanding listener; I can talk my heart out when with her. Of course we share an undestructible bond.
Young women, in the educationally advantaged category identify closely with their mother who is a close friend, partner and also their role model: ‘My father is one person I have always looked up to. My mother is my ideal. Her values, outlook of life, character is out of the world. She is most understanding and we have a perfect daughtermother relationship.’ The father has an image of ‘being there’, providing a sense of unshaken faith in the stability they provide for daughters even though they are not always available for the kind of close bonding the young women experience with their mothers: My father is my moral support…the faith he has in me…lets me talk to him about everything even boys and stuff. Where plans for the future are concerned, he is so excited about them as if he is going to choose a career for himself.
The father is also admired and valorised for his capacities to fulfil fatherly qualities such as ‘dedication’ to work and to the family. I think of my father as a man who does not influence me much as I have never had a very close or personal relationship with him. I however admire him a great deal because he’s dedicated to his work and in some ways his family, is absolutely fit even at this age (46) and is incredibly fun to be with. I would love to be like him.
Young women are nonetheless conscious of themselves as separate entities, as individuals, who experience themselves as not needing to communicate at any depth with anyone. My communication with my mom is fine. Affection: fine. I don’t share many of my ideas with anyone. Same goes for my thoughts. Plans for the future are shared however. My communication with dad: rare. Affection: fine. No sharing of ideas or thoughts or plans for future.
There are variations among young woman with similar backgrounds and there is also a strong awareness of how different parents
34
LIVING THE BODY
might relate to their children at different stages in their life cycles. For example, this young woman, in a government school, says, ‘My father is my bestest friend in this whole world. He treats us as a friend, not a very strict man with a hard hold on children. He behaves like a teenager when sitting with me.’ Her mother however is not so friendly and the channels of communication are somewhat closed. She is a very strict, principled woman. She loves me a lot but her way of loving is very different. I mean she keeps a hold on me because she wants me to become successful in my life…I communicate with my mother but can’t express [myself] clearly because she takes things very seriously and thinks always in regard to future, not present. That’s why I am more close to my father.
Fathers are valued for performing feminine tasks, for example, a young woman shares her memory of a father when he looked after her sister and herself while her mother had gone to another city to take her undergraduate degree exams. This young woman writes, ‘Our father used to get up at five since our bus got there at six a.m. and made us breakfast (which wouldn’t be too good) and made our plaits which would open but still the effort he made was commendable.’ While the father is an ideal support, it is, nonetheless, with their mother that these young women find friendship and from whom they draw strength and courage. This aspect of the relationship is repeated in almost all the responses, that is, a close friendship based on the ability to talk to the mother and confide in her: I love her very much. She supports and guides me in the steps I take for my future. Clear however that she’s a separate person whose opinions and advice I’m free to take or leave. My mother talks to me about her day and various issues on her mind. I love listening. I talk about almost anything under the sun, I love her listening. My mum leans on me for emotional support. I love to be strong. I love the relationship I have with my mama. My relationship with my father is less intense. I love him very much but I don’t know him as a person. Discipline was mostly handled by my mother…
The responses of young women from a government school, with a low middle-class social background, are vastly different from those in public schools (private schools in India). Family relationships are quite complex for them due to the fact that their mothers have had very little education or that their fathers may be rather strict in their
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 35
attitudes towards their daughters, and often do not relate to them at all, ‘My mother is an uneducated lady. She can’t understand my feelings. I can’t talk with her frankly…I share all my ideas, thoughts or plans for the future with [best friend]. But my mother loves me…’ The same young woman writes about her father’s overwhelming presence in the household that imposes an atmosphere of complete authority and control, ‘My father is a calm person…In fact, we can’t laugh in front of him. When he comes to the home there is a quiet atmosphere. It seems that there is no one in the house.’ There are certain influencing factors that shape their relationships with their mothers. These centre around the fears and concerns that mothers might have about their daughters’ future and especially her relationships with known or strange young men. Young women, on their part, whether in government, elite, or middle-class public schools, resent this kind of an attitude that often leads to poor communication between mothers and daughters, ‘I can share some things which are personal with my mom, but not all. I think she suspects a lot…’ Another young woman turns to her father for support and friendship as her mother disapproves of her relations with young men, ‘My father is a very friendly person…He doesn’t poke his nose in my matters. I am very much close to him…My relationship with my mother is very open. However, in matters like boyfriends, I can never talk to my mother.’ She then turns to her sibling for the support and understanding she craves from her mother, ‘I am closest to my sister. She is the only person I have seen from day one I was born. She takes me seriously. She is like a second mother to me.’ In the government school group as well, some young women experience an excellent communication with their mothers indicative of very strong bonding between mothers and daughters: My mother is a perfect mom, everything is good about her. I don’t know what good qualities to point out. She is just perfect and tries to make me so and in the process sometimes I feel hurt, as she always points out my mistakes. But I guess that’s for my best.
Among the middle class, English speaking girls, fathers remain central to young women’s experience of an ideal and perfect person and mothers for their strong ability to communicate with their daughters. Girls idolise their fathers: [‘He is] 5’11" with the most striking eyes ever. Straight-forward and frank. Humorous. Very caring about his parents and his in-laws.
36
LIVING THE BODY
Very punctual, hardworking and a bit short-tempered. Handles the accounts, etc. …I am not as close to my father as I am to my mother, however, it’s a very friendly relationship. I would regard him as my advisor. We have discussions often and I enjoy them... There are several qualities I admire about him and it is enjoyable to be in his company… [Mother] We agree on several aspects so it’s a very loving relationship that exists. I love and respect her very much.
Sometimes, there is an indication of regret regarding the emotional bonding with fathers, ‘My dad has a big ambition for me. He is the only one who can see right through me. He wants me to always be independent and responsible. He never gives up on me. He is very encouraging […]. He is very affectionate but never often kisses me.’ Perhaps earlier in the relationship her father had been more demonstrative in his affections. Apart from the obvious emphasis on the patriarchal norm of a masculine role model, the young women’s desire for deeper emotive relationships with their fathers is also an indication of the significance of relationships in their lives. The fathers’ opinions, appreciation of their efforts and encouragement does count a great deal in their lives, shaping their life experiences and relations with others. Bonding with their mother does not rule out their desire for a similar relationship with their father, which they consider necessary but cannot have due to his preoccupation with work as well as a social and cultural socialisation that does not encourage a close or intimate relationship between fathers and daughters. The complexity characteristic of recolonisation as a hegemonic tool is apparent in the dual-edged manner in which it manifests itself within the urban Indian family. On the one hand, the young women’s responses indicate a yearning for a closer relationship with their father, and on the other hand, they view their father as an ideal role model worthy of emulation. Longing for proximity with their father is based on the images derived from global culture and contemporary perspectives on intra-familial relations; it is generally not valued or encouraged by indigenous cultural norms and values which, in fact, exhort young women not to speak before their fathers. Simultaneously, there is an idealisation of the masculine figure, ‘physically fit’, ‘striking’ (in appearance), who ‘does the accounts’, a workaholic, a personification of great strength and determination, a provider for the family, one who holds authority in the family, all of which indicate a clear reproduction of the patriarchal norm and ideal.
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 37
There is also sympathy for fathers who are successful even though they did not have access to education or other privileges. Several young women consider their fathers their role model from among family members, ‘Because I think he is a perfect man’. They may consider their father ‘unsuccessful in life’, but he is valorised for other admirable characteristics. This girl, in a government school, writes about her father who works in a government job: ‘He is an honest person, truthful and he hates bribes. However, he’s unsuccessful in life…But he is an intellectual. He has knowledge about everything. I want to be like him.’ The multiplicity of voices of these young women reflect their construction of fathers in different registers that are simultaneously present. Fathers are responsible, efficient, strong and honourable, ‘Coz he’s a responsible person. Handles the family well. Takes us out for entertainment. Has fun with us.’ Or ‘…He knows the tricks to handle any situation.’ The fact that their fathers ‘made it good’ despite their underprivileged background holds a special place in their consideration of his virtues, ‘Because in his lifetime he had to struggle and he never gave up. In his family he was a good for nothing and he was mistreated by his parents…Luckily it made him strong to show them something and that’s what I admire.’ Also, ‘Because he never gets angry. He started earning from a very young age even though he was not very well educated. I am very proud of him because he has earned so much respect and goodwill.’ Very few young women actually view their mothers as their desired role models. Mothers are often valued because of her abilities to ‘play’ different roles successfully. It is in her competencies as a mother and a wife that mothers gain recognition from their daughters as models worth affection and emulation, ‘Because she plays her role very well. She is an ideal wife and an ideal mother. She is really a very lovable person.’ Sometimes, young women appreciate qualities in both their parents that they would like to emulate, ‘My mom and dad both because mom has the greatest patience and works day and night for us and my dad, who just for us is working in Calcutta all alone without his family’ and ‘Both my parents are my inspiration and role models. I want to be understanding and confident and strong like my parents. I want to be someone who loves others and is liked in return. I want to handle things like they do.’ Within the larger familial network, grandmothers are rarely seen as contributing to family harmony but more as perpetrators of
38
LIVING THE BODY
violence against the young women’s mothers. One young woman revealed, in the course of a focused group discussion at a middle-class private school, that her parents were separated for a while because of her paternal grandmother. ‘My grandmother,’ she stated, ‘was perpetually unhappy with my mother. Earlier she would lock her in the bathroom and unlock her only when it was time to clean and cook. She also poisoned my father against my mother.’ In the same group, two other young women agreed that their mothers ‘were simply great. Despite having nagging mothers-in-law they managed to be very good daughters-in-law’. Another young woman asserted, ‘I am simply amazed to see my mother’s strength and the way she pulled herself through despite my grandmother’s torture. My mother still managed to be nice.’ This experience was repeated in the experience of another young woman, ‘My grandmother,’ she stated, ‘had been the most cruel one. She had always been upset with my father and later also with my mother. The fact that my father had two daughters and no son was also a major factor aggravating the discontent. I am in fact surprised that my mother took everything in her stride and is still surviving.’ While the young women are loyal to their mothers and appreciate their role as daughters-in-law, there is a clear understanding that the relationship between paternal grandmothers and their mothers is fraught with conflict and violence. This results in an internalisation of an image that may affect their own familial and gender roles in adulthood as well as their relations with young men during adolescence. The previous respondent added that the experiences with her family had made her a different person. She did not have ‘crushes on boys’ like other girls and was not really interested in young men from the point of view of an exclusive relationship. Familial bonds and ties also tend to keep young women focused on goals and aspirations that are compatible with nurturing such bonds in their own adult lives. In a sense, then, the defining characteristics of middle-class families are those that also firmly establish young women’s place in the world of occupations and careers.
Careers and the Family The language of the young women’s constructions of masculinity and femininity reflects the power relations embedded in the playing
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 39
out of identities. The generative habitus develops sex role stereotypes and limits the subject’s own aspirations, although there is indeed a struggle among them between a desire to be independent and a desire to be like their mothers and like other women. Multiplicity, that creates a complex and perplexing situation for them, is present in the simultaneous presence and assertion of both maternal and familial interests as well as of career aspirations and interests. Gender identity is firmly entrenched as a social and cultural construction through the process of socialisation in the family and community. Although a young woman may not subscribe to the view that some professions are more appropriate for women than for men, she may be well aware of the division which is created by the internalisation of a heterosexual norm focusing on marriage and children. For example, ‘I guess the husband should be a little dominating as well as caring, for women often like being dependent on their husbands. The wife on the other hand should take care of the family for a mother’s love has no substitute.’ These young women in the elite schools have clearly internalised what they are expected to ‘know’ about themselves. ‘Girls sometimes just have a knack for doing some stuff like making jewellery or designing clothes although boys too do these things. Girls are mostly more gentle in nature too so maybe they excel in social work or baby sitting, etc.’ Or, being even more precisely focused on sex-specific career choices, ‘Careers involving less of hard labour or physical activities are more appropriate for girls keeping in mind their physical composition unlike men who are endowed with strong bodies and physical structure. Careers like teaching, designing, etc., are more appropriate for girls.’ It appears then that gender identity is firmly entrenched as a social and cultural construction through the process of socialisation in the family and in the community. In other words, the ‘constancy of habitus’ reproduces the structures and values of the patriarchal society in which it is embedded thereby reproducing the ‘relative constancy of the structure of the sexual division of labour’ (Bourdieu 2001: 95). Bourdieu explains this process: …Through the experience of a ‘sexually’ ordered social order and the explicit reminders addressed to them by their parents, teachers and peers themselves endowed with principles of vision acquired in similar experiences of the world, girls internalise, in the form of
40
LIVING THE BODY
schemes of perception and appreciation not readily accessible to consciousness, the principles of the dominant vision which lead them to find the social order, such as it is, normal or even natural and in a sense to anticipate their destiny, refusing the courses or careers from which they are excluded and rushing towards those for which they are in any case destined. (Bourdieu 2001: 95)
Young women may therefore argue about the significance of careers for ‘personality development’ and ‘my growth as an individual’, as my material in fact does indicate. They are, however, constrained in the pursuit of their goals by social and familial norms that point to socially approved career trajectories. At one point, one young woman says, ‘My career is very important for me because in my relations [relatives] I have to show them that even if I was not good at studies, I chose the right stream and I am successful. The main thing is I want my parents to be proud of me.’ She is not yet clear about her choice of profession at this point as her commitment to a career and to be good at whatever she does is the driving force of her life, ‘I am very confused about which profession to take up. But whatever I choose, I want to be the best at it. Things will be much clearer for me later. The main aim is a creative line like a designer (there are so many kinds of designers), advertisement agency job, an artist, etc.’ Later, she adds, ‘I think no profession has or should have a set image for girls or boys. Any person has the right to work in the field he/she wishes to.’ In so far as the habitus is a lived category, we can argue, however, that there is an element of creativity, struggle and perhaps surprise even in the most routine reproduction of gender identity. Young women no doubt struggle with social and familial definitions and expectations and experience conflict and dilemmas as they struggle to redefine and shape their identities in different contexts and situations. In accordance with her aspirations and desires, one young woman ranks her three career preferences as: ‘1) Neuroscientist; 2) Neurosurgeon; 3) Neurologist.’ She explains, ‘I love Maths and Sciences. I wasn’t influenced by anyone instead it was the topic that got me going.’ The family however is as important as her career, in fact more so, ‘Well, I suppose it is important to handle a career as well as take care of the family. In my opinion the family should come before one’s career. Therefore, before dedicating one’s self to the career it would be wiser to think about the family first.’
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 41
Similarly, another young woman lists her career choices as: 1) Engineer; 2) C.A. [Chartered Accountant]; 3) Hotel Management; and explains, ‘My sister is doing engineering. I love science and would like to pursue it. I would love to do Bio-Medical Engineering.’ However, she also expresses a struggle between her career aspirations and her commitment to her family: ‘A career is very important for me, I don’t want to depend on anyone else. […] I think it is very important to have a career that is compatible with family life. If your work makes you very busy, you tend to neglect your family which leads to separation and lack of closeness.’ These young women have selected a career in no uncertain terms, but at the same time they are at pains to emphasise their commitment to their families and the need for their career to be compatible with their family responsibilities. This refrain can be heard in the responses of others as well, who indicate a wide variety in their choice of professions from journalism, teaching, writing, the legal profession, to business, chartered accountancy, fashion designing, and architecture, but who do not want to be seen to be giving up their families. Thus, ‘It is very important to have a career that is very compatible with family life as families are very important in everyone’s lives,’ or ‘If I ever have kids they will come first—other than that I don’t really wish to be tied down with a family or such. I wish to travel, etc.’ This indicates the all-encompassing nature of the Indian family that somehow keeps young girls trapped within its complacent world of warmth and contentment. At the same time, young women in a less elite, and more middle-class school assert their intent to be more independent and argue that every age has its own freedom and independence and that they do not want to sit at home, cooking and washing dishes. The young women’s voices also include the voice of the creative subject who wants and seeks a close relationship with her father and is extremely happy when she has it. There is also the voice of the educationally advantaged and socially aware subject, who clearly understands and knows her choice of career but keeps a check on her aspirations so as to enable a ‘balanced’ life. The transitory space created by modernity opens up her career options and perhaps provides her with a host of opportunities to which she did not earlier have access, but her rootedness in a tradition that glorifies the family and relationships within the family inhibits her complete immersion in
42
LIVING THE BODY
the external world.7 In this manner, adolescence is characterised by a troubled and contested conformity to familial and social expectations about self and others in the experience of gender identity.
Peer Group Cultures at School Schooling is a site where gender ideologies are transmitted through peer group cultures, and through teachers, via the hidden curriculum of school practice. The heterosexual norm promoted by the young women’s ideal family types, with father as provider and advisor, a pillar of strength, and mother as nurturer, carer and communicator, is reinforced by peer group approval/disapproval of particular ways of behaving, acting and being in school. Adolescence is also the period when young men and women become acutely aware of the changes taking place in their bodies. This can, and as borne out by the material on educationally advantaged young women, often does result in apprehensions and anxieties about physical appearance linked to their acceptability in the peer group. It has been suggested that for boys, ‘body awareness is expressed as concern for physical strength and prowess…and popularity is associated with strength and athletic skills’ (Currie 1990: 31). For girls, it is argued, the focus is on physical beauty which is considered crucial for popularity with boys. Physical beauty is, however, also considered critical for acceptability in the peer group which during the time spent at school is the most significant group within which gender identity is validated and legitimised. At the same time, academic success is often considered unfeminine and therefore academically successful girls may particularly experience body anxiety (ibid.). Young women and men have pre-constructed images of one another that are based to a large extent on family stereotypes, social It has been reiterated by Kalpagam that ‘the ties that bind women in their lives provide both securities that impact positively on their personhood, as well as liabilities that are often very oppressive’ (Kalpagam 2000: 177). The family is undoubtedly the single most important of such ties and others include those of the sphere of intimacy and sexuality, of practical kinship relations, of friendship, and other social ties (ibid.). Both within and outside the family, women engage in the twin process of compliance and resistance, submission and rebellion, silence and speech, to assert their identities as women in what they clearly and assertively recognise as oppressive contexts and situations. 7
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 43
expectations and the visual and print media. By and large, young women acknowledge that having a ‘good figure’ is a passport to popularity at school among both boys and other girls. One young woman adds, ‘Most boys are like that’, suggesting that little else could be expected from young men than a focus on women’s bodily qualities. However, those girls, whose self-image extends beyond their physical embodiment, resent this, ‘There are boys countable on your fingers who appreciate loyalty, good nature and sensibility. Majority go for a good figure, short skirts and physical appearance.’ This way of looking at girls appears to be common across schools, as observed by the young women themselves: In all the schools I’ve been to, boys seem to give the most importance to the way a girl looks, not just a pretty face but also what she wears. They also give importance to the femininity of a girl. Studies or a sense of humour doesn’t seem too important. It’s more the physical outlook.
At the same time, young women showed an equal interest in young men’s physical characteristics, appreciating men who are ‘good-looking’, have ‘good height and stuff ’, a ‘good physique’, a ‘macho personality’, are ‘chivalrous’, have ‘charming ways of talking, movement’. However, they also mentioned appreciating men’s social skills, such as their ability to be friendly, have an ‘easy and open manner of speaking’, a ‘sense of humour’, and not being ‘anti-girls’. As one girl enumerated, ‘1. In school, guys have to be humorous. 2. Boys have to be “nice” and not rude.’ Nonetheless, the young women often found it difficult to reject conventional imagery completely. Indeed, there was a tension between the idealisation of men’s physical attributes (a form of conventional masculinity) and the idealisation of their social skills (that of contemporary masculinity), as the following voices reveal: ‘They gotta be good at football. Good-looking guys are appreciated. They have to talk nicely and not be shy. Friendly, outgoing, not mean guys are always welcome too’. Another girl says, ‘1. Should be a good friend. 2. Never to bitch behind back. No male chauvanism (sic). 3. Gives you another chance. 4. Good height and stuff.’ Young women’s self-images are essentially grounded in their embodiment, wherein the body as object and the body as subject are simultaneously present. There are some variations dependent on social class and cultural backgrounds. However, the experience of
44
LIVING THE BODY
being fat and therefore ugly is almost universal. The young women’s assessment of their image contains many aspects of their identity. As one girl says: I’m a confident girl. Not worried about looks at all. I love being tom-boyish—I am (though my mum doesn’t like it too much). I have a medium ego. Except with boys I don’t allow male chauvinism to take over me. I’m fat—Yuck. Need to reduce...I’m fat. But that’s it. I like my height. I’d be very happy if I could reduce. I don’t exactly crave for a ‘figure’ but I’d like to look healthy and strong (more guyish I suppose).
Some girls define their experience of embodied identity in terms of body parts, a fragmented but nonetheless, very experiential view, ‘Chubby, breasts on the small size, sexy legs, smooth delicate collar bones, very woman. Over all if I was slimmer I’d be pretty nice figured. Hips good for childbearing and shoulders strong for working and fighting.’ Others are a little more reflective: I haven’t given much thought to my appearance although people find me good-looking. However my image in the mirror is of a young, mature, no-nonsense human being who knows her goals and are [sic] all set to achieve it. I look at me and know myselfwell. The image has a touch of arrogance and poor communication skills.
These young women are certainly aware of their womanly characteristics, grounded in their embodiment, yet at the same time they assert their independence from the more feminine aspects of their embodiment. They also know how to express these multiple characteristics, whether it is in terms of different body parts or in terms of confidence, strength or even looking more boyish. These characteristics are asserted unselfconsciously and often together, so that a heightened femininity does not necessarily imply a lack of confidence or strength. However, there is a troubling concern with weight, the adolescent preoccupation across cultures, and for some women this overrides everything else: [I am] fat, ugly and stupid. (I’m a neurotic–just kidding!!). No, sometimes I develop a Fat-O-Phobia (a word I have made up myself ) although I’m underweight at the minute. I like my hair (‘coz I bleached it)...That’s about it!!!...Sometimes I exercise a lot also I’m no way overweight but I would like to be thinner…
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 45
Or, as another girl says, ‘I am obsessed about my weight...because the first thing a person is judged by is his/her physical appearance (Matter of First Impression).’ The obsession with weight here is overwhelming, both in terms of the emphasis on being thin as well as in terms of the desire for the perfect body image. There is a frightening contradiction in the first response, where a girl asserts simultaneously that she is already underweight and yet would like to be thinner. The second response makes clear the context within which bodily perfection is desired, namely, the assessment of one’s embodied self by the other. There is also the experience of a young woman who tries to convince herself that her expectations of her embodied self are not rational but eventually she is overwhelmed by her concern for her weight: I am not very particular about my looks. Yes! Before going out or before school, I dress up and do my hair neatly. Even if sometimes I feel that I am not very fair, tall, etc., I try to make myself understand to be happy and confident in whatever I look like because I think your personality matters more than looks. One thing I am always guilty about is I eat much sometimes and it seems to me I’m becoming fatter. I’ve become conscious about my weight after the time when I lost a lot of kilos (from 72 kg to 54 kg). But my weight still doesn’t match my height.
Physical body weight, is, in the young women’s minds, related to creating the right ‘impression’ and thereby ensuring a place in the social networks of friendship and inclusion. A sense of failure is experienced if the body does not match up to the perceived expectations of others. The wrong impression may perhaps result in exclusion and is not desirable at all—a clear link is manifest between embodiment, self-image and relationships. There is also an anxiety about being completely out-of-shape among girls in all kinds of schools, ‘I’m short, not too dark, high cheek bones, pinocchio nose, weird walk, knock kneed, bowlegged, busty...I’m not like I’m really happy. But I’m not bitter about it. I’m bitter about my walk, bust. The rest is fine and I can get along with it.’ Or, ‘I am fat, ugly, short height, immature, hair are not long, and eyes are not beautiful.’ More poignantly, a girl expresses an unhappiness regarding her sense of self, ‘I am incomplete!’ There is also a desire to portray an image of an older woman, perhaps more self-possessed, mature, ‘Not satisfied because I don’t know, all I see is a teenage girl whereas I want to see more.’
46
LIVING THE BODY
Thus looks and appearance are central to peer group cultures, whether in terms of young women’s self-image, their perceptions of young men, or their understanding of how young men perceive them. Teachers’ definitions of peer group cultures confirm this overriding concern with modes of self-presentation and appearance, citing peer group pressures and family cultures as the two most important factors. As a teacher in an elite English-medium school puts it, ‘Peer group pressure is very strong. [It] Influences the way you dress, your ideas on issues, sexual preference.’ According to this teacher, the criteria dictating the popularity of young women were: having the right male idol; being allowed out late; going to parties; wearing the right length of skirt (short); waxing (legs); and plucking eyebrows. Another teacher in the same school confirmed that peer pressure centres on women’s ‘looking good’, which requires waxing their legs, plucking their eyebrows, wearing their shirts outside their skirts or jeans and anything else which is ‘anti-establishment’, such as chewing gum and adopting an attitude of ‘defiance towards the school’. The peer group, therefore, provides the strength for collective resistance and rebellion which is exhibited in very specific ways through gestures, bodily display or plain disobedience. However, this resistance is not directed at breaking stereotypes or reproduction of gender identities but only in joining the gang, as it were, in a collective voice against the authority associated with the school establishment. The approval of friendship groups and other peers counts a lot for this age-group of young women and men, primarily because they want to blend in with their peers rather than stand out. As one teacher explained, ‘In the same way as the like-minded stick together, the like-bodied stick together’. The image young women and men strive for is to ‘look cool, act cool’ but, as a teacher explained, what this means is differentiated by gender. For young men it implies ‘not listening to teachers, not giving in home-work, not wearing regulation uniform’, whereas for young women it includes wearing short skirts listening to western music, waxing the hair off their legs and making friends with the opposite sex. Both young men and women are clearly adhering to the dominant characteristics associated with a stereotypical masculine and feminine image: the young men being riotous, rebellious and defiant while the young women are more concerned with self-presentation. Contemporary media culture shapes identity in many conflicting, competing, and formative ways. Ella Shohat has argued that, ‘In a
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 47
transnational world typified by the global circulation of images and sounds, goods and peoples, media spectatorship impacts complexly on national identity, communal belonging and political affiliations’ (Shohat 1997: 209). Clearly it also impacts on gender identity but not without class resonances. Contemporary popular Hindi film heroes like Shah Rukh Khan are also idolised, especially among government school girls, more for his having ‘made it’ in Hindi films, rather than for his popular appeal. The fact that he was able to rise above his low middle-class background and become a super star makes him an idol in their eyes. At the same time, the ideal male body espoused by elite young women in this study is not a classically Indian body, clothed in Indian clothes, but very much a body grounded in western culture. This body is appropriated from popular cinema, television serials and novels: Leonardo di Caprio from the film Titanic; Howard Roark from Ayn Rand’s novel The Fountainhead. These young women make a romantic association with western images of hegemonic masculinity through popular culture, and the perfectly formed, physically fit, healthy, preferably white, glamorous, and wealthy male becomes the ideal through which the gendered body is recolonised. The young women’s understanding of their embodied selves is also shaped by contemporary global media culture. The plump and even voluptuous female body associated with physical well-being and a deeply sensual sexuality and fertility in classical Indian thought, and reflected in popular art and cinema until the 1960s and 1970s, does not find any place in the idealisation of embodiment by young women in contemporary India. This earlier imagery has been replaced by a recolonised version that, although grounded in western cultures, is adapted to acceptable norms and representations in Indian culture. In school, this characterisation of young women and men changes when they indicate a high or positive self-image through their assessment of their image as they see themselves in the mirror. It is striking that amongst the middle classes and in the government schools, young women assert their positive image amid complaints of being fat and overweight, ‘I am fat, OK looking, a good friend, a person who wants to help, has a big fat ego and gets angry very fast.’ These girls appear to be brimming with confidence, have high self-esteem, and are very secure in their embodied self-assessment, ‘…I am very confident and I will earn name and fame in my life.’ Or,
48
LIVING THE BODY
‘I am very pretty and if my sister says that someone likes me, then she is probably right. I can be liked by anybody.’ This girl’s assessment is exceptionally self-determined, ‘I am pretty and I find myself very cute and beautiful.’ Looks are not the only criterion for judgement, as this girl asserts, ‘I am an independent, friendly, responsible and sensitive girl’ and even when they are, the positive self-assessment is undeniable, ‘No doubt I feel I’m beautiful with good features, figure and beautiful thick hair. I can speak well in front of the mirror and I love to talk with myself when I’m in front of the mirror.’ These young women are overwhelmingly focussed on projecting themselves as strong and confident, even though they may be unable to provide reasons for such an assessment, ‘I find myself very confident and strong, why, I myself don’t know.’ Although their positive self-image stems from normative definitions of femininity—cute, pretty and beautiful—there is a confidence in some of these responses that indicates the impact of positive reinforcement from family and perhaps peers and friends as well. The significance of class at this juncture cannot be overemphasised. These are the responses of girls from the lower end of the social class spectrum who study in the less upmarket private and government schools. Their exposure to English fiction, cinema and media is perhaps less than that of girls from the private, more privileged, educational backgrounds. Their positive self-image is a result of a combination of factors including their socio-economic backgrounds where the emphasis is perhaps on developing a culture of obedience, submission and marriage rather than on looks and appearance as an individual goal in itself. It is remarkable that the culture of submission promoted at home is not however reflected in the young women’s understanding of their embodied identities as passive subjects, but in fact serves to highlight their experience based on very high self-esteem, confidence and assertive expressions of themselves as independent young women. Some young women in the elite schools view their body size and shape in terms of its benefits in their chosen tasks or fields of specialisation. For example, one such woman says, ‘Yes, I am happy with the kind of body I have. Though it is huge but it is perfect for my field as I am into sports.’ Or, ‘Yes, because I have never bothered about having a figure, etc. I am fat but I can live with it. Among my class girls, in spite of my physical appearance I am the most flexible.’ There are other factors influencing their confidence and self-esteem
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 49
such as an acceptance of, and satisfaction with, what they have. For example, one young woman comments, ‘I am happy with my body shape because it is a gift of god.’ Another is content with her embodied self because she sees herself as being perfect, ‘Yeah, I’m happy. I have a good figure, beautifully charming face. Everything is shaped and sized.’ At other times, there is a deep guilt attached to having a particular skin colour or body shape that may not be considered socially desirable, ‘I feel O.K. Sometimes, I feel guilty because of my dark complexion.’ The guilt is an expression of the shame and inadequacy experienced among young women in a culture that glorifies fair coloured skin and either dismisses dark skin colour with contempt or exoticises it for purposes of marketing particular clothes or accessories.8 The significance of the peer group in adolescence cultures is critical to definitions of the self that are measured in relation to the other. Comparisons are drawn with their peers who are viewed as better looking than themselves and this gives them feelings of inadequacy and shame. For example, ‘I feel I am not as beautiful as my friends when I look at myself in the mirror. My face also has some scars which I don’t like. I am fat, ugly, short, and immature. My hair are not long and I am not beautiful.’ The emphasis on the experiential lack of an embodiment, that is common to others, is commonly expressed. For example, ‘There are things [in relation to her embodiment] which I don’t have and others have in plenty.’ It has been suggested that ‘comparison, and by extension, envy’, among adolescent young women is ‘a characteristic supported by the popular media’ (Nichter and Nichter 1997: 129). Young women are goaded into aspiring to be like the images they see in the magazines they read and the films they watch. This includes enhancing the idea that they too can be better than the girl in the picture, in the story or in the most popular film of the moment. In women’s magazines, body imagery is strikingly conveyed primarily through adverts and fashion photography. The female gaze is preoccupied with the visual imagery of one’s self and of others and there is a continuous assessment of whether these images match up to others’ expectations or to the 8 Writing about poor adolescent women in Bangladesh, Rozario (2002) draws linkages between poverty, skin colour and ‘purity’ wherein the stigma of being ‘dark’ also has implications for woman’s character resulting in the jeopardizing of marriage prospects.
50
LIVING THE BODY
socially prescribed ideal. In this manner, the body is seen outside the self. This is the most dangerous outcome of the objectification of women’s bodies: women now begin to ‘live in a world where they confront their bodies as things outside themselves’ (Currie 1990: 34).9 However, young women, especially from the lower middleclasses who study in the less upmarket schools, also contest these images and are strongly embedded in positive and assertive selfimages that affirm and celebrate their embodiment.
EDUCATIONALLY DISADVANTAGED YOUNG WOMEN Cultures of adolescence are constructed largely outside school in the domain of the family in this group of young women. Moreover, the experience of adolescence in this category is not fixed but moves across a larger age span that includes a range of bodily changes and psychological adjustments: when they experience menstruation for the first time, they are married but are waiting for the gauna (when they are sent to their husbands’ homes for the first time), are living with their husbands, bearing children, and coping with work and survival in their husbands’ homes. All (except one) are married and are in the liminal stage between marriage and gauna or are visiting their parents’ homes. In general, their experience of adolescence focuses on their embodiment, the family and relationships, primarily with the marriage partner and his affines. Relationships with the family are vastly different from the earlier set of young women. There are no heroic fathers or perfect mothers. In fact, young women in this category have no visible communication with their fathers who tend to be somewhat authoritarian and their relationships with mothers are also restrained. The natal family, however, is an important source of comfort and well-being and also the site for the reproduction of patriarchy and values ensuring compliance and submission on their part. 9 In this context, Frost refers to adolescence as the period when there is the ‘enforced location of self or identity within the confines of a gendered body’ which further results in ‘the lived contradiction of the body as somehow self and not-self ’ (Frost 2000:71).
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 51
Schooling practices and peer group cultures in the context of the school are absent. The same-sex peer group in the community is however crucial for this group’s shared articulation of their sexual experience and marital relations. In this sense, the peer group represents that collectivity of young women in whose presence they all find a common and legitimate space for the articulation and expression of their experience. The peer group is the critical space within which identities are expressed, constituted and affirmed. A significant component of this group’s experience of adolescent gender identity is, therefore, their experience of marriage and the relationships it entails as well as their definition of work and its impact on their self-esteem and identity especially in relation to their location in their husbands’ homes.
Staying Out of School Adolescent young women’s experience of any kind of formal education and of the institutional setting of the school is very limited. Instead, their childhood experience is based on a lack of engagement with schooling for a variety of reasons, including that of violence at home and with the tutor, lack of awareness about the benefits of education, preoccupation with work for livelihood purposes, and a total lack of interest. For example, one young woman, married, and visiting her natal home, nonchalantly tells me: I used to study in a small school. I used to study at a tutor’s house. His son and daughter-in-law always fought. He too used to hit us, pull our hair, etc. He was very physical in his hitting and I couldn’t study with him. Then I went to a government school, there they used to inoculate us and I hated injections. So, I used to avoid [going to school] and later my name was struck off. I used to be unwell a lot and I stopped going to school. Then I stopped studying altogether. My grandmother used to hit me a lot, I was scared of her. I was very naughty, I used to wander around. I used to often break things.
Another young woman tells me: I have studied till Grade 5. I can read slowly but cannot write. I can keep accounts till about Rs 2000. I studied only Hindi in a Government School. Education is important only for the purpose
52
LIVING THE BODY
of taking care of the expenses at home or to be able to get fair wages for the work done.
Sometimes, parents and their poor socio-economic condition is responsible for staying out of school: My parents did not enroll me in school. My mother used to go to the vegetable market, do dishes, sweeping etc. My father died when I was very small. I have one older and one younger brother. Earlier my mother used to cook; I started cooking from the age of 10–12 years. For the past three years I have been peeling ‘Green Gram’ for which I get paid Rs 5/- per pack.
Or, simply put, one young woman states, ‘I can only write my name. I have not studied at all.’ Sometimes, there is an expression of regret for a lack of formal education but they are also quick to assert that there is no point in being educated as, ultimately, a woman has to wash dishes whether or not she works outside the home. There is the recognition that education does liberate women, for example, ‘It is good to study these days. If one is educated then at least one can be independent.’ Or, the recognition that a lack of education results in the inability to communicate with others, such as: I could not study further because the elders in my family did not let me after the death of my father. When we were children, we would spend a lot of time at the guava orchard. But I never attended school sincerely at that time. At 10–12 years of age, I really wanted to go to school, but there was no chance. Now I really regret it, as I cannot even write a letter to my parents. I can recognise the alphabets separately but cannot connect them and read.
The most significant understanding is that education provides employment, work, independence and dignity, ‘If I were educated I would have taken tuitions at home. Now I have to work at other people’s houses. If someone scolds me, it feels very bad. Nobody in my family has done this work; relatives would ridicule the work I’m doing.’10 10
The work mostly entails cleaning dishes at other people’s houses.
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 53
One young woman had been asking her father to send her to school but he always refused. He asked her to find out whether other girls were studying in the school, as he could not have possibly send her to school where only boys were present. She can read and write due to her own efforts. She reads the Hindi newspaper very well and can write a little bit. She says: Nobody has taught me, I try myself. I am very fond of studying. There was no one to work at home so I could not study. I always desired to study whenever I saw girls going to school. I think it is important to go to school to have a better understanding about issues like health, hygiene, etc.
She tells us that in their community, they are not sent to school because it is understood that they have to only cook and clean all through their life. When probed further, she indicated that while some girls did study, it was by and large a norm to discontinue studies after marriage. A young woman tells us that she was taught at home, initially by a Gujarati maharaj and later by a woman tutor. She knows to write names and house numbers. She says, ‘With difficulty, I can count up to 100.’ She studied in the Gujarati medium, but has now learnt Hindi from her brother, so she can read the newspaper in Hindi and can generally read a little. She says that she can only do housework; she cannot even sign a form. Her brother has studied till Grade 7, so he signs various forms on her behalf. She does not even sign her name but nonetheless feels happy that she knows something. She says that she would like to study but is unable to do so as she has grown older and she wonders who would teach her now that she is past the school-going age. She adds that her parents did not send her to school and that whatever she has learnt, has been learnt at home. As a young girl, she says that girls were not allowed to go out. Boys can go out and she added that girls do not like to be caged up. ‘If we were boys we could have roamed about. Why weren’t we born boys?’ she laments and adds that their parents scolded them, but not their brothers, if they spent too much time in front of the mirror. The agential voice yearns for some kind of education, as education and gender in this case appear to be linked to notions of independence and freedom. By and large, there is a devaluation of formal education, primarily because of social expectations that focus on domestic tasks
54
LIVING THE BODY
such as ‘cooking, cleaning, washing dishes’ as well as compelling circumstances that force them to drop out of school.11
Domesticity and Marriage Adolescence also includes the period when women are trained in domestic tasks to ensure their adaptation to married life. A young woman tells us she was married at the age of 13. Her gauna took place when she was 15 years old. She had her first child at the age of 16. She said that she had never worked at her mother’s place. Her grandmother never allowed her to work. It was only when she was 13 years old, was married and her gauna was due that she started learning some household chores. She learnt to knead the dough, make vegetables, and so on, and thus entered the preparatory stage for marriage. In the same way as educationally advantaged young women identified ideal images of young men, these young women also have images of the other which they valorise and yearn for. These are based largely on boys’ physical attributes and social skills. The emphasis on skin colour is unmistakable, ‘A boy who is fair and has blue eyes is good looking.’ Apart from looks, ‘goodness’ as an attribute is also valued, ‘A fair, slim, nice build and a good heart. He should be good both from inside and outside. He should speak nicely and not think evil for anyone.’ Expectations of the marriage partner are clearly entrenched and influence young women’s perceptions of young men: He should be good looking, should be of my age, should be doing good work and earning well. He should leave the house on time and return on time. He should have good behaviour with everyone. Whenever I see a drunken man I wish to have one who is not. It is better if he is educated, only if he understands, will he be able to explain things to me.
The value of education is undoubtedly recognised by girls who have themselves had no, or very little, access to schooling. In her study of uneducated herd girls in rural Rajasthan, Gold provides their ‘practical’ perspective on school education as one that values grazing the family’s sheep, that gives them an income through the sale of lambs and dung, above schooling which will give them nothing (Gold 2002: 91). 11
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 55
Some young women view men only as a marriage partner: My husband is five years older to me, otherwise he is fine. I have a habit of laughing. But I cannot share everything with him. He can hit me if I make a mistake. He might explain to me once or twice but later may also hit.
The support for the partner is very strong, even allowing them to be beaten, or bear several children, as the case may be. Don’t ask about my husband, I like my husband very much. I like him when he works. He is older to me, but I like him. I like the way he speaks. He did not allow me to consume Mala-D. Nobody tells us anything in our community. He says that once we have six to seven children quickly then I can have an operation.
The experience of bodily changes overshadows other events so that the experience of menstruation constitutes a critical event in their lives. In their minds, it is associated with a coming of age, ‘growing up’, as they put it. However, bodily changes are not experienced through work, which is important to their lives but are inevitably linked to social practices, such as the ‘engagement’ and the glorified ‘first night’ after marriage. These events shape their experience of bodily changes and their understanding of their embodiment. They also assert that their mothers did not adequately prepare them for the experience: My older friend used to talk about periods; I never used to listen to her. I thought it happened only to her. Only when it happened to me did I realise that it happens to all. Even when my periods started, I did not feel that I had grown up. Before my grandmother died, I had to start working at home since my mother was busy nursing her. When I started working I didn’t realise when I grew up. But, at 17, when I got engaged, I realised that I had grown up. On the day of suhaag raat (first night after marriage) also, I did not allow him to touch me much.
Young women’s experience of adolescence includes early sexual encounters which may not be consensual or pleasurable. The first night and the strangeness associated with it are freely expressed by the young women. There is however an unquestioning acceptance of how things are meant to be, of a denial of their own sexual desires and pleasures. The larger kin network ensures submission and
56
LIVING THE BODY
compliance. One young woman narrated the events of her first night and stated that she was told that if one’s first night went well, then one’s entire life was destined to be happy. Her elder sister-in-law had explained that she should agree to whatever her husband asked for during that night. She said that her husband asked her to take out her clothes so she started to pull out a suitcase from under the bed till she realised what he had asked for. She started shaking vigorously and was scared. She clarified that she was very innocent, only 15 years’ old and did not realise the intimacy of sex on the first night. Another young woman did not like her first night; she sleeps alone and is troubled if someone sleeps with her, even her sister. So, if a stranger sleeps with her, whom she has not seen before, she definitely does not like it. She has not slept with him after that. One young woman used to enjoy sexual intercourse with her husband soon after they were married. She did not however understand or feel anything in the beginning. When she got up in the morning, she felt as if something had happened to her. When she asked her sistersin-law, they told her that this was the way that it happened and she was supposed to not speak or think about it. This was the way men were. In this manner, she was advised by other women in the family not to acknowledge or in a sense, even erase her sexuality and view it merely as another aspect of marriage. Her husband used to have sex with her everyday and, if she refused, he used to force himself on her. She did not want it everyday, she stated, ‘I used to feel repulsed and used to ask everyone if their men did the same.’ The importance of the peer group at this stage is immeasurable. It is the peer group that provides information about the sexual intimacy they are to encounter with their husbands. One girl says, ‘My mother’s brother’s daughter told me regarding the happenings after marriage but my husband does not force me for sex.’ Another clearly articulates the significant place of the peer group for such enlightening conversations, ‘One comes to know by sitting with and listening to older girls. I was informed a little bit by my cousin sister, a lot of it was told to me by my elder sister-in-law and some by my husband.’ Although the husband sometimes becomes a friend and partner in this learning experience, the mother is clearly taboo for such discussion, ‘My cousin told me that these things don’t have to be discussed with one’s mother. One refrains from it for a couple of days as a custom. It usually happens at the in-laws place, but it did not happen with me because I refused, he started arguing and a fight ensued.’
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 57
In the peer group it is considered more appropriate to indicate an aversion to sex rather than emphasise its pleasures. With great hesitation, a young woman stated that she did like sexual intercourse but only once in the day, while her husband wanted it at least four times in the day. She felt dirty doing it all the time. She tried talking to him during the night, so that time went by and she could avoid sex. Only one young woman courageously wants to express her pleasure through sexual experience with her husband but is unable to. She would like to be sent to her husband’s place sooner than later so that she can enjoy sex without tensions. She does not like the idea of these interim sexual encounters. She added that her husband’s happiness was more important to her than her own and that she enjoyed sex with her husband soon after marriage. The loss of childhood, a yearning for childhood friendships and games, is part of the experience of adolescence. A 19-year-old young woman says, ‘Sex happens only when a man wants it. Ever since the birth of my children, I don’t even enjoy it. I also feel very tired.’ She adds that sex is a man’s interest, not a woman’s and that she is totally involved with her children, ‘I did not even realise when my teenage years came and went. I’ve been staying with my husband since the age of fifteen. I therefore did not perhaps feel the urges that most of the girls of my age do. When it was the age to gossip among friends I was already married.’ Childbearing is the next significant experience in the adolescent stage of these young women. Some women have difficult childbirth and the trauma of miscarriage often takes place during adolescence. One such young woman, after her second miscarriage, always looks very pale and tired and is very quiet. On one occasion, she was eating khichdi (boiled rice and lentils) when her husband entered the room. She immediately covered her head and stopped eating. She tried to push away the food, but her mother reprimanded her and asked her to continue eating. She was completely indifferent to herself and relaxed only after her husband left the room. Clearly, she has not only accepted all that she has been socialised into but also appears to concur with behaviour that reproduces social norms of submission and acceptance. She also has a physical condition that causes her discomfort and pain and which she stoically bears with not only forbearance but also a sense of complete surrender, as it were, to the certainties and vicissitudes of adulthood that has so quickly arrived.
58
LIVING THE BODY
Identities are constructed around the event of marriage and the abilities to bear children. There is simultaneously an understanding of the powerlessness and therefore this entails an awareness about doing better for their children: I consider myself smart but I was not even clever enough to control the birth of four girls. When my first daughter was four years old, my mother-in-law started cribbing. Three-four months after delivery I did not realise that I was pregnant again. I got my periods a year after my marriage. My parents did not speak to me about anything and got me married. My marriage was negotiated at a public function when I was seven. I grew tall and people thought that I was old enough to be married. My gauna happened when I was only 14 years old. When my husband used to approach me, I used to fear him and shout that he was beating me. My desires were not fulfilled after marriage. Work was the major determinant in my life. I would like to do better for my children. My eldest daughter studied till Grade 5, the younger one is studying in Grade 5. The eldest one works as a domestic help. I will support my children. My parents were very simple and married us too soon. They did not have a mind of their own and were easily influenced by other people’s viewpoints.
‘Doing better’ for their children, however, does not enable them to educate their children beyond a particular grade due to prevailing social norms and restrictions. This is characteristic of the constraint that is present in every experiential context where women consciously understand the situation and are yet somehow unable to break the pattern of conformity. Another young woman was married early and has two daughters. She does not really want a third child but respects the viewpoint of her elders when they say that she should try for a son. She plans to have a tubectomy as soon as she has a third child even if it is a girl. The old women in her village tell her, ‘You feel exhausted after having only two children; there is no need to have an operation yet.’ She has not only accepted the voice and views of her elders but the habitus also communicates normative definitions of acceptable and authentic manhood and marriage partners. She tells us that ‘when looking for a boy for us, our parents see his income, (that he should at least have five-six bighas of land) house, and looks.’ By ‘looks’ she means that the boy should be presentable among people in society.
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 59
Adolescence, among these young women, is being engaged to be married, marriage itself, house work, keeping fasts on various days of the week for different reasons—for getting a good husband, for having one and keeping him, ‘for our parents’ peace and happiness’ and for other reasons. The body, as we have seen, remains enmeshed in the practices of conjugal life whether these entail unenjoyable sexual intercourse, childbearing and working for survival. Young women say their mother’s generation did not use make-up, no bindi or lipstick, but now they wear everything. Jewellery is worn during auspicious occasions. They enjoy using make-up and feel their face looks good. One young woman is glad that she is not short but just right in terms of her height, weight, and so on. There is therefore a greater acceptance of body size and shape among young women in the slum. The body is accepted as it is and only make-up can be used to add to what already is given. Jewellery and make-up is also used as an embellishment of marriage and not so much for purposes of changing or perfecting the body. They are allowed to wear both only after reaching 12–13 years of age and after a certain ceremony associated with marriage: goud bharai or gauna. Among married young adolescent women, the body acquires a symbolic status of auspiciousness and fulfilment that must also be visible and in a sense flaunted in the community. Using lipstick and filling vermilion in the central parting of the hair (lipstick lagana aur maang bharna) are the two most important activities of daily adornment symbolising the coalescing of tradition and modernity in the lives of these women. As one girl says: My mother says that I keep looking in the mirror the whole day. I like to do make-up while looking in the mirror. I like putting lipstick and ‘sindoor’ (vermilion). I get a lot of pimples on my face, they don’t let me live. My husband likes me with make-up. Rest of my body is O.K., nothing good, but I like the fact that I’m not short. I’m tall enough. I feel I’m very fat.
To the extent that ‘breasts look nice’ and that ‘flat chested women look like eunuchs’, there is a celebration of not only their femininity which is accentuated by their use of make-up, their acknowledgement of their husbands’ appreciation of such make-up, and also an awareness of their sexuality in their reference to eunuchs who are socially considered sexless. More importantly, it was the observation of these
60
LIVING THE BODY
young women that it was ultimately not just looks that mattered but one’s ability to work, ‘My lips are very fat, I don’t like them. I like hanging earrings and using bindiya and sindoor. It is very difficult to work with one’s face covered (with a veil or sari) and then in-laws complain that I do not know the work.’ Early marriage however results in the experience of loss of freedom and curtailment of desires and there is simultaneously a desire for independence and to be self-sufficient and free. One young woman acknowledges her multiple experiences of bodily changes, ‘growingup’ with her engagement and the necessity of ‘practical knowledge’ (not education) for survival: We have five fields. I would like to work there with my husband. I feel like standing on my own feet. But I don’t get the chance. If tomorrow my in-laws are no more and my husband does not work, if I have practical knowledge, I will be able to feed my children. I did not think like this before marriage. I used to feel free, now I feel caged. I don’t know why I feel like that. Even when my periods started, I did not feel grown up. Only when my mother had me engaged that I felt that perhaps I have grown up. …When my chest was just developing, it used to ache. My mother explained: that’s the way it happens. My engagement was broken off once, my mother liked the boy, but many people had broken the engagement with that boy and so we did too. We decided then that I would not be married to a boy from Delhi and that I should only marry a villager.
Although young women emphasise their abilities to work and also to endure bad marriages with great strength, their agency is clearly restricted by the family, social norms and practices. One young woman wants to take over vegetable vendoring from her motherin-law, ‘I can join her only after I’ve had children. People would talk about it if I go before that. Even my elder sister-in-law does not work yet; I can do it only when she starts.’ On the other hand, marriage and the long hours of tiring, domestic work it entails, is resented especially if young women feel they are being unfairly treated by their husband’s families. I find marriage destructive; I cannot stay without buffalo milk. At least food should be good, family members should behave well, even if they do not give food. It is more troublesome to keep shifting between my in-laws’ place and my house. I am woken up
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 61
at 3.00 A.M, and expected to sweep six houses and by then it is 5.00 A.M. I warm the water then, and cook chapattis for each cow. I then warm milk and make tea. I wash dishes thereafter and have to keep the food ready by 10.00 A.M. All women from the house work in the field, then again food has to be prepared in the evening. It was only after the wedding was completed that my brother’s wife told me that I was supposed to conduct myself according to the affinal family’s expectations. It is painful…how can they throw me out? I’ll throw them out instead.
Finally, however, it is through work that they acquire an identity and hold their own in their marital homes. A young woman who has been married for three years, emphasises the importance of work in a woman’s life: In my in-laws’ home, everyone respects me a great deal. I do all the work. I never give them a chance to say anything. I like living in the village very much: plenty of milk, clarified butter, buttermilk, and the greenery. But the most important thing that I like in my life is work and earning my livelihood.
More than any physical features of beauty or adornment, it is work alone that defines her embodied identity. Their refrain, ‘Woman must be not only beautiful to look at but also excellent in the work she is able to do’, emphasises the significance of work in the lives of these young women especially in their husbands’ homes. Identity is experienced in the context of the self in relation to the other through ‘doing something’ and doing it well: We do not have an identity, had we done something, we would have had one. I only wish that I don’t make any mistake at my inlaw’s place so that my elders at home may feel ashamed. Whatever I have got is fine. At home mummy used to stop me from roaming even with my friends. I used to feel bad then, but not anymore. Now, I can justify that. My mother used to prompt me for work, she used to scold me, I used to feel bad then but now I understand. My father used to help me understand that actually my mother loves me. Now if I am able to do anything new I am reminded of her strictness which has enabled me to do things in my life now.
Adolescence is also a process of growing up too fast to the extent that young women emphasise the traumatic aspects of marriage, of having sexual intercourse at a very young age, the fear of sexual
62
LIVING THE BODY
intercourse and of a demanding husband, of domestic violence and their conclusion that marriage is inevitable and therefore has to be endured. Their voices reflect their conclusion that marriage is inevitable: Marriage can make or break someone but mostly it is bad’ or ‘If we don’t marry, we would have to depend on our sisters-in-law (brothers’ wives) after our parents’ death. The sister-in-law of today would never keep us, rather we would have to work for her and keep her children. At our husband’s place everything would be ours. We would have a right there. If we tolerate some pain, we might also get some happiness.
There is simultaneously an affirmation of faith in their strength and self-determination as they are quite sure they can make their marriages work, sometimes with a little bit of help from the partner. There is also a clear assertion of their understanding of their position in the marriage as being the one in control. The voices of women reflect the multiplicity and complexity of their responses, ‘I feel my life is good, if I can run it well’; ‘If my husband supports me, it’ll be good, otherwise not’;. ‘If my husband listens to me, then I would do the same, otherwise not. If I leave my throne, then it will be shaken’; ‘My heart says something and conscience something else’;. ‘My heart says something, mind something else and conscience says nothing’. The reflective, agential voice is present in these ruminations about self, in their clear distinctions between emotion (heart), rationality (mind), and the moral, ethical self, that Carol Gilligan (1982) tells us is so critical to young women’s development. Marriage is not only sometimes bad but also gives them status and standing in the social and public domain. It is through their embodiment that they assert themselves whether it is in terms of its utilitarian considerations, as a worker or as bearer of progeny. Abstinence from food in the innumerable fasts kept by young women again reflects the use of the body for personal gain (a good husband) and familial or social good (parents’ peace of mind and happiness). Although the generative habitus reproduces the forms of engagement with the marital space and sexual encounters, it simultaneously provides the consciousness of will and agency that lies in their strategic manoeuvring to not wanting to, for example, give up ‘the throne’ on which they have been installed through the act of marriage.
CULTURES OF ADOLESCENCE 63
CONCLUDING COMMENTS One part of this chapter has sought to understand the processes in families and schools which contribute to the reproduction and creation of a class and gender specific habitus, as well as the factors that lead to the formation of gender identities located in the transitory moment of both reproduction and change in contemporary Indian society. It has been argued that the family is the ground on which the heterosexual patriarchal ideal is nurtured and sustained, but it is essential to understand that peer group cultures informed by global media are also important to adolescent young women’s perceptions of their embodied selves and gender identity. Grounded in global media images, family preferences and social expectations, young women consciously create, devise and formulate their own rules for conduct, appearance and self-presentation and seek to comprehend and assert their gender identities. Among educationally disadvantaged young women in the slum, the defining moments of gender identity occur in the very early years when they are compelled to view marriage as the only viable option or trajectory available to them through which they may be able to seek fulfilment of their desires and aspirations. The generative habitus, with enduring dispositions of conformity and success, also allows space for struggle and contradiction, compliance and resistance occurring simultaneously. Adolescence, as a marked, well-defined stage, may appear to be missing but the critical presence of the peer group in the school and in the community, in very different ways for the two sets of young women, ensures the experience of adolescence, as a lived reality and not a mere construct, in the lives of young women. In the next chapter, keeping in mind the role of the media in processes of recolonisation, I move towards an understanding of womanhood through the pages of a popular woman’s magazine.
3 EMBODIMENT AND WOMANHOOD IN FEMINA
I
am concerned, in this chapter, with the question of how body images serve to construct womanhood through the medium of visual imagery and textual discourse in women’s magazines.1 Images of women however do not only construct womanhood or femininity but are also seen in a social, political and economic context. In other words, ‘they always have a specific use value in the particular time and place of their consumption… [and] they also have exchange value: they circulate as commodities in a social/economic system. This further conditions, or overdetermines, the meanings available from representations’ (Kuhn 1996: 53). Through visual and textual images, then, women not only receive messages about themselves as embodied, feminine beings but also as consumers of both products and of themselves as objects for consumption. ‘Meanings do not reside in images, then: they are circulated between representation, spectator and social formation’ (ibid.). The image therefore does not reside in a vacuum but in the cultural context of spectatorship as well as in the ‘institutional and social/historical contexts of production and consumption’ (ibid.). The structural and the symbolic therefore coalesce in the construction of gendered imagery within an 1 My analysis of the magazine under review is based on a random reading of Femina from 1994–2007. I am aware that one category of women in this study are excluded from the readership of this magazine. This does not however lower the significance of the magazine for the other category for whom this is their favourite magazine. Moreover, I am focusing on Femina to the exclusion of other magazines such as Cosmopolitan or Women’s Era that address women consumers from two ends of the social spectrum of the urban middle class. Femina falls somewhere in-between and is therefore most suitable for analysis.
EMBODIMENT AND WOMANHOOD IN FEMINA 65
overarching trope of recolonised modernity represented in English women’s magazines popular in urban India. The field of exploring and understanding the construction of womanhood in Indian women’s magazines has been a relatively unexplored field with some notable exceptions (for example, Bannerji 1991, Wolf 1991, Singh and Uberoi 1994, Srilata 1997, 1999, Uberoi 2001, Oza 2006). It is necessary to state at the outset that my concern is not with the body images of women themselves as they are presented in the discourse of women’s magazines. The images serve to only highlight and reveal the ideas and practices underlying the use of particular images. The culture of body imagery in itself is therefore not my central concern. My focus is more centrally on the refashioned construction of Indian womanhood, ambivalent, contested and also contained, through a variety of images that address women’s embodiment, and the beauty culture associated with it, produced through the medium of visual imagery and textual discourse in women’s magazines. There are many aspects to the magazine that in a sense provide a grand narrative of an authoritative reality for women but I have focused on two major aspects, namely, the emphasis on beauty as an ideal and as a goal and on the ambivalent construction of Indian womanhood. 2 Other aspects of identity such as sexuality would perhaps need a more elaborate consideration as would the emerging interest in such magazines in masculinity and men as partners, friends, lovers, and fashion models. These are however not the focus of this chapter. One of the most commonly read magazines by middle- and upperclass women in urban India is Femina, edited by Sathya Saran and under the proprietorship of Bennett, Coleman and Company Ltd.3 It was first published in 1959 and had, by the 1990s, a readership of over 850,000 which made it the largest circulating women’s magazine (Srilata 1999). Among the professional, more educated, upper-class women I interviewed, all did not claim to be readers on a regular basis but some did confess to glancing at it (carefully enough to remember specific articles and fashion displays) at neutral, infrequently visited 2 The ideal of beauty, is based on a particular definition of femininity and, as V. Geetha says, ‘is both contemporary and historical’ (Geetha 2002: 109). In women’s magazines, this ideal, located in a multiplicity of images that reflect varying perspectives, is presented through visual imagery and textual representation of different kinds. 3 Sathya Saran is no longer the editor of Femina.
66
LIVING THE BODY
spaces, as it were, such as the beauty parlour or the doctor’s waiting room, outside the home and work place. Women clearly did not see their rational and intellectual lives being directly influenced by such a magazine which they never seemed to buy. However, middle-class women, both homemakers and working women, were more direct in their appreciation and appropriation of the magazine and said that they always made it a point to buy the magazine whenever it came out. They considered it as the one treat for themselves every month, that is, buying the magazine and going through the articles. Many of the issues discussed seemed very real to them, and they also developed ideas about clothes and fashion. Femina itself claims to cater to those it considers ‘women of substance’ in modern India. More recently, it has removed the ‘women of substance’ label and added on ‘Generation W ’ instead, the W obviously referring to all Women as a Generation and not simply to perhaps a few women of substance. This is yet another marketing tool to widen its readership by appealing to all women including homemakers, beauticians, fashion models and other professional women. Femina has advertised itself as a magazine that reflects ‘what women want’ (Times of India 10 March 2002, Sunday Review, New Delhi: 3). Its advertising slant now addresses the liberated Indian woman and man through this blurb: What’s experienced by women but explored by men? So have you ever felt, there is more to a marriage than just romancing each other or being each other’s spouses? How about being each other’s best buddies? Possible? Can you tell your husband that you have a crush on his best friend? You can tell your best friend. So is there any room for friendship between husband and wife? Ah, a delicate subject. Needless to say, a man would love to know more about it. Besides a woman who’s living the dilemma. Thanks to Femina, enlightenment is just a copy away. For both… (ibid.)
The rhetoric of equality and friendship between spouses serves to make the magazine more accessible to a wider audience that is now claimed to include men as well. This has resulted in the introduction of columns that target men such as Locker Room, Malespeak, Style and Pin Up. This advert assumes that men and women talk to each other as equals to begin with and that the feature in the magazine will enable friendlier and better communication between two equals. However, the advert also ensures that the Indian woman
EMBODIMENT AND WOMANHOOD IN FEMINA 67
remains contained within the respectable relationship of matrimony as the proposed ‘friendship’ is between spouses and therefore ‘being respectable’ includes the containment of sexuality and perhaps a wayward modernity. This in fact has been the hallmark of Femina’s marketing strategy over the years. Cosmopolitan has provided serious competition to Femina in recent years as it is a more glossy production and has provocative articles on beauty, sexuality and the lives of apparently more liberated women in its overt celebration of women’s sexuality. However, it has perhaps been unable to dislodge the middle-class reader in small towns all over India who turn to Femina precisely because it stays within prescribed moral codes, along with other women’s magazines such as Women’s Era.4 The marketing strategy adopted by Femina, under Sathya Saran’s editorship, could not be more direct, as she reveals the kind of women the magazine targets: The professional Indian woman, who is between the ages 20–40, also a homemaker, probably has young children in school. That’s the obvious target…but beyond that is the target that I think is more relevant…the woman who wherever she is and whatever she is doing is interested in improving her life…it’s a very aspirational kind of target. (Oza 2006: 36–7)
In stating that the magazine targets women who seek to improve their lives, Saran is clearly indicating the ideology of consumption that the magazine seeks to promote. It is through the consumption of a variety of goods, home products, recipes, cosmetics, fashion, appliances of various kinds, beauty regimes, physical exercises, and advice for good grooming, food preservation, kids, and pets among other things, that improvement is suggested, and is likely to take place. Through the range of issues that the magazine addresses and the products it seeks to sell, women aspiring improvement in their lives may turn to Femina for inspiration and the satisfaction of their desires whether it is through consumption through the gaze or 4 Women’s Era is a vastly successful magazine in terms of its circulation and acceptance amongst large numbers of middle-class women all over India. Srilata suggests that the popularity of Woman’s Era lies in ‘its successful rendering of a commonsensical understanding of what constitutes a middle-class woman’s problems, the ‘reality’ of their lives’ (Srilata 1997: 51). Marriage, for example, is naturalized as part of a ‘good “Indian” tradition’ and is constructed as central to a middle-class Indian woman’s existence (ibid.).
68
LIVING THE BODY
through the purchase of products and services suggested by Femina precisely for an improved status. Over time, Femina has also projected itself as the women’s magazine that promotes fashion and beauty culture through its unstinting support for beauty contests that are hosted in its name, the grooming and training of the young women who prepare for the events, and the celebration of the event once it is over especially if an Indian wins an international beauty title. Femina explicitly promotes the fashion industry through the beauty contests or pageants it hosts for women and the magazine in recent years has acquired the characteristics of a grooming ground for prospective models. There is a focus on the beauty contest itself, on young and upcoming models, on preparation for the event and on celebration of the event. There is clearly a commercial angle to Femina’s support of such events in terms of the corporate sponsorship of the different events and the huge money now involved in international beauty contests and their associated activities. Although Femina has always celebrated the beauty culture, it is the more recent impact of globalisation and liberalisation of the Indian economy that has resulted in this upswing in the magazine’s celebration and extolment of international beauty contests. Oza in fact suggests that the beauty pageant has become an ‘icon of globalization’ in contemporary India (Oza 2001: 1071). The focus on beauty as both an ideal and a goal, undoubtedly sets a certain kind of agenda for the woman the magazine addresses. I examine some samples of adverts and fashion photography, and selected textual material, available in Femina. It is quite clear of course that adverts have a strong commercial aspect to their production and it is apparent that a similar commercial angle dominates the production of fashion photography. Both use woman’s embodiment to promote a product which is obvious in the manner in which the body is packaged, displayed and eventually consumed through both the male and the female gaze and this points to yet another recasting or refashioning of Indian womanhood in the social imaginary of contemporary India. Women’s magazines in addressing different kinds of woman take various aspects of her embodiment such as clothing, beauty culture and adornment, as salient features of the magazine’s production and articulate these in conjunction with market forces that also push for consumption of products associated with woman’s embodiment in very different ways. The focus therefore, in Femina, is on the desirability of woman’s body not only as a glamorous,
EMBODIMENT AND WOMANHOOD IN FEMINA 69
well groomed product but also as a commercialised product for consumption in an international marketplace, that emphasises that India has arrived in the world of beauty and glamour, thereby legitimising the recolonisation of the Indian woman’s embodiment in the global economy.
BEAUTY AND GLAMOUR AS FEMININE IDEALS Femina which, apart from promoting beauty enhancing products, seeks to both fuel and fulfill woman’s desire to engage with beauty as an ideal and a goal. The magazine, over the years, has had regular features on Model Watch, Images, Faces, Haute Stuff (about the latest in designers, clothes and accessories), Events, Beauty News and Beauty Beat, and so on, all of which address beauty through the contemporary icons of beauty, that is, those who are winners of various beauty related international events such as Miss Universe and Miss World, and local events such as Miss India-Universe, Miss India-World, and so on, fashion models, and their creators, fashion designers, beauty experts, make-up artists, and others. Another section, Salon de Beaute, emphasises body care and has details on body maintenance and perfecting the body. This results in an undue emphasis on youth and an exoticisation of beauty. Youth and physical perfection are crucial to definitions of beauty and the ageing or disabled body is significantly absent in the magazine’s engagement with Beauty. Beauty, in Femina, takes on a sensual tone, emphasising the alluring and sexual aspects of embodiment. This sensuality is not perceived as a negative component but an aspect, that in its maturity, or indeed fulfillment, will ensure a sense of contentment and pleasure. An article in the Salon de Beaute column is curiously entitled, ‘The Zen of Beauty’ and tells readers, that it is ‘A sensual guide to achieving real beauty that brings with it a definite sense of well-being’ (Femina 1 June 2001). It further coaxes woman to strive for the ‘Buddhahood of Beauty’ through a mastery of the ‘Zen of Beauty’. It is assumed by the magazine that the rhetoric of a trendy attitude towards an age-old problem would help the more discerning or educated readers to relate to the propositions presented in the article and accept them more easily. The ‘Zen of Beauty’ is defined ‘as a way of handling all the bad things that happen to your mind, your body, your skin, your
70
LIVING THE BODY
very looks, of turning the negative into the positive’ and as a prime solution, the reader is asked to ‘tap into your senses…(that) hold the key to attaining the Buddhahood of Beauty.’ A step-by-step assessment of bodily needs, according to the senses, is provided and solutions are recommended in terms of products such as moisturisers and creams of different kinds, massages, yoga, acupuncture, ‘reflexotherapy’, eating habits, ‘colour therapy’ and the use of fragrances (ibid.). This particular approach to the enhancement of Beauty emphasises that it is ‘from within’ but uses external resources to attain an ideal perfection, harmony and well-being. This dependence on products and techniques of different kinds suggests that although Beauty may lie within, its outward manifestation certainly needs to be cultivated, developed and perfected and that there are tried and tested ways of doing this. At the same time, the ‘creativity’ or individuality of readers is not denied. Clearly, women ‘can selectively choose “options” to express their unique sense of self by transforming commodities from their mass-produced forms into expressions of individuality and originality’ (Lury 1996: 134). Consumption practices may therefore be seen as playing a vital role in the ‘creation of the feminine self ’ (ibid.). The use of products results in an attainment of Beauty with different meanings. Beauty is not only sensual but is primarily ‘modern’ and woman can look ‘modern and chic’ by highlighting ‘natural beauty’, ‘lighter make-up’ and by simply using ‘five tricks’ advocated by Femina (Salon de Beaute, Femina 15 January 2004). The modern chic look, Femina advises, is all about ‘shapely brows, a touch of pink on the cheekbones, glossy lips, soft face and softer feet’ and the tricks include details on how to get these done ‘right’ by using the appropriate products that Femina promotes. Apart from promoting products and styles for the authentic contemporary woman, who is both modern and chic, Femina emphasises aspects of this modernity: ‘looking feminine’, emphasising eyebrows that are ‘super defined but slightly natural’, having ‘full’ lips that are ‘kissably glossy’, having or creating ‘super curly lashes’, keeping feet ‘looking smooth and sexy’ (ibid.: 62–64). Through the consumption of beauty aids and commercial products, the sensual and the feminine coalesce in Femina’s modern and chic look. The feminine self is created not only by the personal whims and fancies of women readers but also by an evaluation of products in terms of their usefulness and validity as appropriate products. There
EMBODIMENT AND WOMANHOOD IN FEMINA 71
is a definite effort in Femina to portray beauty care as a growing international trend that takes care of the scientific bases of such care to attain greater acceptability among the educated readership that may place greater value on such information. A recent feature in the Makeover column asks readers to ‘Glow your way this season with a combo of smoky eyes and luminous skin. Here’s a quick tutorial with international make-up artist Paul Williams’ (Femina 15 April 2003). Paul Williams’ status as a make-up specialist is first confirmed by stating that he is consultant to the well-known international brand of Clarins and, to add to his qualifications, he is also a trendy jazz dancer. He declares with certainty that the ‘beauty forecast for the summer is: Dramatic and Natural.’ The ‘dramatic image’ is highlighted by women ‘doing up their eyes smoky and seductive; heavy mascara and flashy lipsticks…’ whereas the ‘natural look gets a post-modern, hippie-meets-spa-trekker take. The idea is based on well-being—radiant and healthy skin and hair that reflects light. And to do this fashionably so, match the looks with soft and light fabrics that are cut to enhance breasts and hips.’ In this statement, there is an attempt to target the ‘modern’ young woman who may be partly into an alternative lifestyle that is encased in a framework of the natural as opposed to the overtly consumerist as well as is concerned about being fashionable in a contemporary manner. So while her hair and skin may reflect a natural radiance, she none the less needs to wear mascara, lipstick and close fitting clothes to enhance her modernity. Beauty here acquires the tones of a complex modernity, located in multiple lifestyles, that moves away from conventional ideas about classical beauty that emphasised well established notions of physical perfection in different ways. The change in definitions of beauty is reflected in the terminology used in Femina. For example, adverts for body care of different kinds increasingly reflect more rational bases for the use of certain products that will not only enhance body image and style but more importantly take good physiological care of the particular body part or surface. This care is grounded in an ‘all-natural’ product base that relies on ingredients such as retinal, salicylic acid, kinetin, aloe vera, and so on, that are all derived from natural sources whether these are the bark of the willow tree (salicylic acid) or wild plants of the lily family (aloe vera). The emphasis on the natural and therefore healthy, however, in no way detracts from the normative definitions of beauty that are based on purely physical characteristics such as
72
LIVING THE BODY
height, weight, skin colour and texture, age and other related characteristics. Clearly, the multiplicity of definitions is to ensure an attraction for different kinds or readers who may be influenced by one or the other definitions and also thereby pushed towards the consumption of a variety of products advertised in the magazine. The Faces is a model watch column that recommends very young and largely unknown models, for example, 16-year-old Kavya Peerbhoy is highly recommended because of her age, her height (5 feet, 8 inches), her weight (44 kg), her vital statistics which Femina says, ‘Imagine the curve it could take if 32–23–34 were to shape up.’ In the accompanying photos and comments, the emphasis is on her youth, her innocence, her charming awkwardness, and her incredible figure. She is admired by a photographer for her ‘awkwardness and gawky manner…her mouth and curly hair’ and by a former model for her ‘fantastic height…, fantastic face…, a very good figure and she’s extremely photogenic.’ A senior model, Mehr Jesia comments on Kavya that she has a good attitude (‘very important in a model’) as she is ‘willing to try anything and everything at least once’ (Femina 1994). Being awkward and gawky is celebrated precisely because these characteristics are an indicator of adolescence and reflect the immature body as an ideal. Femina adds, ‘This large doe-eyed waifwoman is Kavya Peerbhoy, headed to prefix “model” to her name and the suffix “success” to her surname.’ In promoting the model, the magazine targets other aspiring 16-year-old models and also emphasises the essential quality of youth and a flexible attitude for a potential career in modelling. Another young model, Judi, is recommended for her dark-skinned look. Entitled Dark Devastation, the feature suggests an exotic element that is presented as being very different, thereby distinctive, and completely disarming. She is introduced through an emphasis on aspects of her overt and subtle sexuality, ‘She’s got drop-dead skin, naughty eyes, a wicked smile and a seductive pout.’ ‘Drop-dead skin’ is not explained but there is Femina’s conclusive recommendation, ‘Femina knows the impact of the difference.’ The photographer recommends her for her ‘nice body which she uses really well’ and concludes that ‘with that face, body and attitude, ...she’ll go a long way modelling high fashion stuff .’ Her ‘attitude’ perhaps reflects professionalism in her approach to modelling, which is deeply valued in models. A caption beside a particularly expressive photo says, ‘The song about her goes: Judi’s got the lips I wanna kiss...’ Judi’s voice
EMBODIMENT AND WOMANHOOD IN FEMINA 73
tells us that her experience of ‘being this exotic got me a lot of work (in London)’ where clearly being dark-skinned in London turned out to be an advantage (Femina 8 November 1995). Grewal has examined English ideas of beauty on the basis of Edmund Burke’s work at the time (1764) which was meant to reproduce an ‘aesthetic status quo’ that ‘could teach taste and judgement to the upper classes’ (Grewal 1996: 28). Burke’s idea of beauty was racialised and imbricated in class to the extent that the qualities that symbolised beauty such as ‘small bodies, weak bodies, a smooth bed, fragile flowers, a dove’ could only be found in a single ‘object: a white woman’ (ibid.: 30). Similarly, Mitter finds that nineteenth century Europeans resorted to the use of ‘scientific objectivity’ to highlight ‘European beauty’ as opposed to ‘African ugliness’. He adds, ‘By the 1850s, black had come to symbolize evil and degraded, the very opposite of chaste white’ (Mitter 2000: 45). He significantly concludes, referring to the contemporary supermodel Naomi Campbell in whose embodiment ‘the Western canon has not been dislodged in the least,’ that not only did Western ideas ‘construct a knowledge system to control the other but that the scientific discourse of the nineteenth century enabled the West to rationalize its cultural preconceptions, which, in our postcolonial age, we have not been able to shake off ’ (ibid.: 49). This preoccupation of eighteenth and nineteenth century European intellectuals with aesthetic preferences was squarely located not only in maintaining the order and hierarchy of European society but also has had an added effect of establishing a perspective that has become part of the postcolonial habitus and, in contemporary India, acts as a trope of idealised beauty in the recolonisation of women. One indication of the manifestation of the dominant postcolonial habitus is the internalisation of the coloniser’s inferiorisation of dark skin as native and Other. There has always been an attempt, among the middle and upper class sections of Indian society, to privilege white or lighter skin over dark skin and this is nowhere more clearly evident than in adverts in newspapers, seeking marriage partners, that reflect a woman’s skin characteristics as ‘fair’ or the more ubiquitous ‘wheatish complexion’. To achieve the goal of fair skin there are innumerable beauty products, such as ‘Fair and Lovely’ face cream, that serve to help achieve the goal of fairness or whiteness in skin colour. This preoccupation with skin colour in fact serves to highlight the intangible ways in which the postcolonial habitus endures in the
74
LIVING THE BODY
cultural trope for self-presentation as white (as opposed to dark), pure and virginal (as opposed to wild and untamable), chaste (as opposed to carnal), and familiar (as opposed to other). Quoting Fanon, Patel (2001) writes that there is a desire among the colonised to overcome the “state of ‘blackness’ or inferiority” (p. xv). This is done therefore ‘not by imitating the mannerisms of “whiteness” but by adopting the language of dominance as well.’ Patel in fact argues that ‘the black man’s confrontation with whiteness is automatically pathological and takes the form of mimicry’ (ibid.). While this in a sense may explain the innate and obsessive desire for fair or white skin among women in middle-class urban India, it is also representative of the consumer’s desire to perfect her self-presentation in the image of the perfect and dominant other. Although the virtues of fair skin are lauded and celebrated, dark skin is also exoticised in the beauty culture prevalent in women’s magazines. On the basis of her analysis of nineteenth century travel narratives, Grewal argues that colonised woman is viewed as ‘exotic’ as she is ‘believed to be sensual with a sexuality that was seldom represented as being connected with motherhood’ as opposed to the ‘bourgeois Englishwoman’s leisure’ which was a combination of ‘a nonsexual morality of wifehood and motherhood’ (Grewal 1996: 45). The reproduction of colonial stereotypes is germane to contemporary Indian society but recolonisation has introduced a concurrent trope of the native as exotic, and the exotic as distinctive, and, in market terms, extremely saleable. In a feature on Haute Stuff, a model, Cajol Sarup, is presented under a sub-title ‘Exotic Species’. The selling of what might appear an exotic element in a model’s sex appeal is part of Femina’s marketing strategy. There is an exoticisation of ‘dark looks’, ‘luminous skin’, ‘wild mane’ and so on, which are in fact the norm in an Indian or South Asian body. Similarly, an obviously dark-skinned model with dark, thick hair, large and luminous black eyes, displays a ‘short matka cotton kurta’ in two photographs (Femina 1 March 2001). The first photograph enhances an untamed sexuality in the pose of the model who is kneeling on the ground with her legs spread apart. With her thick, uncombed, dark hair, and full lips, her bodily display enhances her sexuality and serves as an invitation to consume the product and the look for achieving the total effect which is both sartorial and intensely sexual. The second photo display has the same model in a subdued pose, her hands interlinked in the front, her eyes shut. Not only is there an obvious erasure of identity in the closed
EMBODIMENT AND WOMANHOOD IN FEMINA 75
eyes but also, more importantly, a suppression of a blatant display of sexuality. The blurb adds that the use of ‘sequins and beads’ gives an ‘Indo-Western look’. This image will perhaps be more acceptable to those who desire good fashion without being overtly adventurous. In another fashion display image, a model is situated in an exotic desert locale, with a camel and local folk in the background, wearing a fur jacket with leather boots with fur trimmings (Femina 1 June 2001). The clothes are completely inappropriate for the terrain so clearly it is the exotic and unusual locale that serves as a foil to emphasise the exclusive fashion statement. In the photo at the bottom right hand corner, the ‘stoned’ (as suggested by the blurb) model is wearing denim capris but the focus is the belt of stones and her beaded shirt. More significantly, the photo is striking because of the boys/men framed in the car window who are looking into the camera. They form the audience, within the frame, from a different social class background than the model but by gazing at the camera, and not the model, they are almost not there. In other words, their socio-economic background can help provide the visual locale but results in their exclusion from the main frame of making eye contact with the model or simply gazing at her. Fashion photo imagery has a class and a gender dimension both of which provide stereotypes as well as unconventional portrayals and both serve to enhance the difference and exclusion. The poor remain excluded outside the frames of reference of culture as it is constructed by the urban elite in the pages of a women’s magazine that often uses the underprivileged, poor and marginalized to offset fashion and a beauty culture that is built on the edifice of a recolonised modernity.
THE AMBIVALENCE OF INDIAN WOMANHOOD Recolonisation serves to retain conventional images that will feed the postcolonial habitus as well as provide more challenging images that, through unconventional imagery, tease the viewer into surprise, submission or rejection. Market forces are the most critical determinants influencing the imagery of women in visuals and text. An advert for Bata footwear highlights the ‘wild’ aspects of woman’s nature in contrast to its own image as a tried and trusted producer of very middle-class, conventional shoes for men and women. This advert
76
LIVING THE BODY
(Femina 1 June 2001) has the film star Rani Mukherjee modelling Bata sandals with labels such as ‘Monica’, ‘Linda’, ‘Sera’ emphasising the ‘Untamed’ aspects of femininity by exhorting women to ‘Unmask your wild side. Unleash your natural instinct. In stripes, spots and hissing patterns.’ The use of unconventional names that have clear western connotations is to emphasise Bata’s departure from its past image of a family store providing traditional family shoes. It now appears to address the ‘modern’ woman epitomised in the model whose attire of striped top and leather trousers indicates another departure from tradition. The emphasis on ‘hissing’ patterns suggests the image of a snake with sexual undertones. Nonetheless using the non-controversial Rani Mukherjee as the model underscores the company’s adherence to the glamorous and ‘good’ woman. The soft approach to definitions of womanhood emphasise woman’s femininity and aspects of her identity that view her largely in her domestic roles as a devoted mother, wife, sister, and so on. The ‘good’ woman then is one who is married, is secure in her status as wife and mother and reflects an aura of contentment and success. An advert for the Life Insurance Corporation tells woman readers, ‘Only you can give life. That’s why we protect yours.’ There is a photograph of a ‘homely’ young woman, wearing a bindi, mangalsutra and sari, her hair tied back neatly in a bun, smiling gently and almost passively into the camera. The Company pledges complete support to this image of a married woman by saying, ‘Our tribute to the Indian woman is an insurance scheme that understands her need and covers her accordingly. Jeevan Bharti. Today’s woman deserves something special’ (Femina 15 May 2003). The emphasis on marriage as a suitable project that would appeal to readers has encouraged the magazine to initiate a column in its pages that offers matrimonial alliances. Entitled Meeting Ground, this column provides photographs and brief biographical details of eligible young men who are usually below 30 years of age, are apparently successful in their professional careers and looking for young women partners with clear indications of friendship and matrimony. The magazine simultaneously has stories about women who are leaders in their professional careers and portrays them as successful role models. The ‘Women’s Day Special’ cover story is entitled, ‘Faster, Higher, Further… The New Frontiers Women have set for the World.’ (Femina 1 March 2003). There is an effort to provide a space to highly motivated career women, who may or may not be in
EMBODIMENT AND WOMANHOOD IN FEMINA 77
a state of matrimony, but in the fine print, the magazine ultimately fails to break the pattern of feminine dependence on male partners. The same article therefore has four sections that read, ‘Storming the Male Bastion, Against all Odds, The Woman’s Touch and Male Support.’ The opening sentence of the last section reads, ‘Yet, women wouldn’t be where they are without the support of men. And they are gracious enough to admit it.’ Through this dual construction of Indian womanhood by both justifying, pursuing and celebrating the state of matrimony and a dependence on men as well as a portrayal of women as world class pioneers and professionals, Femina is only reflecting the ambivalence about women that reigns in society. The ambivalence in the construction of Indian womanhood in the public and social domain is nowhere more apparent than in multiple representations of woman’s embodiment in often a single photo frame. Fashion designers, make-up artists, and all those who contribute to the creation of the image play a significant role in this representation. Moreover, there is a simultaneous effort to contain woman, to impose boundaries and limits to her freedom, that is captured in an advert of the Seasons store that somewhat contradictorily asks woman to ‘Be Yourself ’. The model is draped in a long skirt and blouse but with the traditional veil and a jacket, contemporary yet demure, wearing a bindi on her forehead and bangles on her wrists, symbols of auspicious Indian womanhood. It is striking however that the model is pictured at Knightsbridge, London in front of Harrods department store. At the bottom, the advert adds that the store is located only at an address in Mumbai. The image therefore asserts a modernity that, in its location, is found in its best and most exclusive form in the western world. This location of the Indian model in a western context emphasises a recolonised modernity that finds expression and fulfillment only in a western public and social space. To be herself, however, Indian woman has to find the best of both worlds of tradition and a westernised modernity, being glamorous and beautiful in attire and presentation without breaking the boundaries of a normatively prescribed femininity. The ideal Indian woman contradictorily embodies the dichotomous, and yet congruent, identity of innocence and sophistication, purity and maturity, together in a single frame. The repeated focus on the contemporary woman is shifting and ambivalent in its representation: such a woman embodies the contemporary Indian woman. An advert for woollen shawls, available at Ahujasons in Karol Bagh, New Delhi,
78
LIVING THE BODY
shows a woman wearing a string of pearls, gold earrings, hair tied back in a neat bun, all wrapped up in a shawl, and reads, ‘Never screams for attention, never fails to get noticed. Always contemporary, always distinct.’ The advert adds at the bottom, ‘Rare Shawls for Rare People’ suggesting that distinctive people, with discerning taste, are rare and thereby exclusive. Such rarity then becomes symbolic of a style that is related to social class and status moorings and becomes a sought-after quality to be achieved. The idea that contemporary need not necessarily signify outrageous but someone who is discreet and yet stylish is a clear reminder of the concept of Indian womanhood as being within limits, boundaries or margins and emphasises the boundedness or a containment of gender identity. Similarly, visuals for adverts of saris, the traditional Indian female costume, tend to retreat from an exotic or westernised look and the emphasis is on Tradition. Deepam silks available at Chennai are promoted through an advert featuring a woman wearing classical jewellery and a wedding sari and the text reads, ‘essentially woman’. Her nails are devoid of polish, and her face, hair style and jewellery all emphasise her identity as a young woman entering the auspicious state of a married woman (Femina 1 June 2001). Other adverts for saris (for example, Femina 15 May 2003) reflect the current preoccupation with designer wear and certain designer labels are not only popular but also considered appropriate in terms of respectability thereby, once again, reflecting a need to stay within limits. In an advert for Ravi Bajaj Womenswear where a sari-clad model is featured wearing an off one shoulder blouse and is devoid of the conventional bindi, mangalsutra, or indeed any form of excess. The focus is on simplicity and style. The unconventional blouse and lack of jewellery gives the model an extremely contemporary look although she is clearly modelling traditional wear. Fashion celebrities offer a more glamorous image than other models and are commonly used in fashion photography. Aishwarya Rai, for example, has been presented both as a sophisticated woman of the world as well as a modern, young woman, ‘very much the woman in vogue,’ and with Sushmita Sen, as one ‘chosen to lead... young, smart, upbeat and winners all the way.’ The blurb in the corner of the photo says, ‘We aaj ki naris (women of today) are here! Right on top of the world’ (Femina 23 May 1995). Femina often invites its readers to participate in various beauty contests and there is a clear emphasis on post-contest privileges: ‘Hollywood parties,
EMBODIMENT AND WOMANHOOD IN FEMINA 79
press conferences, motorcades, meetings with Heads of State’ (Femina 8 November 1995). Another advert for a beauty contest emphasises ‘The Exultation, The Exhilaration. One small step for you’ (Femina, 1995). While the emphasis is on the glamour and excitement of success, a woman’s vital statistics, height, weight, and age are essential accompaniments in striving for this success. Interviews in the magazine with two of the current leading beauty icons in fact reflect the strict demands made on them to maintain their physical proportions and style. Sara Corner, the Femina Miss IndiaWorld 2001, tells the interviewer that ‘the diet was the hardest part to follow’ and ‘it took a lot of getting used to’ (Femina 1 March 2001). She is described as the ‘quintessential doll’ with the ‘grace, quietude and beauty of a giraffe’. Apart from this somewhat derogatory description of her physical characteristics that project all the qualities of colonial ideals of beauty on her embodiment, as also in ‘her delicate beauty’, she is identified simultaneously as a woman with ‘determination and maturity’ thus indicating that beauty so defined goes with strength, ‘self-confidence’ and an ambition to win further contests that will bring even greater rewards (ibid.). Similarly, an interview with Celina Jaitley, the Femina Miss India-Universe 2001 winner, describes her as a ‘cool cookie’ well-versed in the art of repartee and as one who has ‘elegance and mental agility’. It also reveals that while she is excited about future events, she is also ‘nervous’ because she is now preparing for another beauty pageant and ‘that means more diet food’ (Femina 1 March 2001). The interviewer adds, ‘And like Sara, Celina too found the diet and workout regime tough going. “It was very difficult to concentrate on both intellectual and physical growth at the same time,” she says, recalling the training sessions’ (ibid.). The emphasis on a strict diet regime that is adhered to by contestants in beauty pageants contributes to the reproduction of the ideology of ‘weightlessness’ associated with beauty practices. This is further enhanced by descriptions of the body statistics of various beauty models and through fashion photography a highlighting of various body parts excessively. In this definition of Indian womanhood, Femina is projecting beauty and glamour alongside hard work and success and in so doing reflecting a redefined image of woman who uses her embodiment as a tool towards greater and greater success, wealth and recognition. There is an emphasis on beauty regimens, diet rules, physical workouts and other such focused activities requiring hard work and present woman in a professional cast. This is not a
80
LIVING THE BODY
new perspective of Indian womanhood but acquires a recast image in the contemporary globalised world that provides new occupational choices for women such as the beauty contest industry. This is another example of the recolonisation of woman’s embodiment in a different temporal, spatial and socio-cultural frame. The glamour angle is projected by Femina precisely for its appeal to ordinary middle-class women who, it is assumed, lack glamour in their everyday lives.5 The two most well-known glamorous Indian beauty icons, Sushmita Sen and Aishwarya Rai, were ordinary young women, with images of the girl-next-door, who made it to the big world of fashion and beauty. This element gives their life stories an element of replicability so that it is fairly simple for women to relate to them and to imagine that such a life could indeed be theirs as well. Femina’s editor applauds Sushmita Sen’s victory as Miss Universe, 1994 and argues that the one area in which India has been ‘lagging behind’ the West is that of ‘glamour’, a gap which Sen amply filled with her victory. (Femina 23 June 1994). Femina also glorifies the ‘Sushmita Sen look’ which is defined as one of ‘naturalness’, a ‘smile that reaches out from the heart, into the eyes, and across the face to light it like a Diwali day’ (Femina 8 June 1994). The link between the familiar, the ordinary, that is, being natural and traditional, as in the metaphor, ‘Diwali day’, cannot be denied. Sen is also suggested as a ‘role model’ for ‘hundreds of young, pretty hopefuls who have their sights set on the invisible pot of gold at the end of their rainbows’ (ibid.). In order to be successful however the processes of recolonisation cannot cross the line of middle-class modernity. Glamour is therefore not an unattainable ideal for the middle-class reader and the trope of the ordinariness of Indian fashion models is continuously revoked in the magazine.
THE FRAGMENTED BODY AND AN AMBIVALENT IDENTITY The magazine offers advice for beauty care and watching body weight which it addresses through its own columns and features as well as through adverts. An obvious fragmentation of woman’s 5 This implies that a lack of glamour in the daily life of the reader encourages her to dream about glamour and a glamourous lifestyle offering her visual pleasure and some form of fulfillment. A desire for consumption is none the less also created.
EMBODIMENT AND WOMANHOOD IN FEMINA 81
body is apparent in the advice offered. Women are advised on skin care, hair styles and maintenance and caring for feet and hands, using appropriate nail varnishes, focusing specially on eyes, eyebrows, nose, mouth and, most significantly, lips and breasts, which are seen as a clear sexual symbol. This fragmentation by the beauty industry is linked to the marketing of their specific products which may focus on one or another feature of woman’s embodiment. More dangerously, this market-driven intervention in beauty care results in the fragmentation of woman’s embodiment as types of bodily parts that need constant care, repair and maintenance. There is, in this fragmentation, also an erasure of subjectivity and an objectification of woman’s body. The fragmented body may also signify a fragmented identity to the extent that particular bodily parts may be perceived as being especially important and as constituting the whole. Embodied gender identity may then be produced through particular aspects of woman’s embodiment highlighting what are considered ‘best features’, whether these are legs, hair, height, waist or lips. A fragmentation of facial features takes place in the marketing of goods that address the new Indian woman’s character and identity. An advert for Lakme Deep Pore Cleansing (Femina 1 June 2001) defines different parts of the model’s face in terms of certain positive qualities, highlights her strengths rather than weaknesses and, in this manner, emphasises that the use of the product will enable her to ensure that these strengths are not affected by dirt, pollution and stress. The advert asserts that the forehead symbolises ‘intelligence’, the eyebrows ‘pride’, the eyes ‘honesty’, the nose ‘character’, the lips ‘happiness’, the chin ‘determination’, and the punch line is ‘There’s a lot that shows on your face. Dirt, pollution and stress shouldn’t be part of it.’ In addition, ‘Now, one and half minutes is all it takes to uncover the real you. Presenting the complete Deep Pore Cleansing Regimen from Lakme. Simply because your face says it all.’ The true characteristics of Indian womanhood, constructed as essential by the magazine, are seen as lying in the fragmented features of this western model’s face which can have public and social visibility if adequate cleansing care is taken primarily of the skin. Similarly, woman’s breasts are particularly prone to a separate treatment as they embody a sexual character of their own and women are exhorted to have tighter, firmer and more uplifted breasts through the right kind of exercise and also through adverts for ‘ultimate push-up’ bras that promise the dream cleavage. So readers are told, ‘Give your figure
82
LIVING THE BODY
a boost and get the cleavage of your dream. Get Maximiser now!’ in an advert for ‘Maximizer. The ultimate push-up bra’ (Femina 1 March 2003). Adverts also engage in the fragmentation of woman’s embodiment for selling products for the adornment of the body. Adornment is central to self-presentation and indeed, as Wilson points out, ‘there has never been a culture without adornment, without some modification of the raw material of the body’ (Wilson 1990: 68). This includes the body’s relationship with objects of all kinds, such as, jewellery, accessories, and above all, clothing. Jewellery has always been central to woman’s adornment from the period of the Indus Valley Civilization, as Harappa and Mohenjodaro relics show us, until contemporary times where more gold is bought for jewellery in India than in any other country. Jewellery, among diverse religious communities in modern India, is an indicator of auspiciousness, associated with marriage and fulfilment. Different occasions in a woman’s life cycle are associated with different kinds of sartorial and other modes of adornment. This is particularly evident in the context of certain life cycle rituals in a woman’s life such as puberty, marriage, child-birth, marriages of children and other kin, and so on. The auspicious nature of adornment which includes not just jewellery, but also the use of kohl in the eyes, vermilion in the central parting in the hair, flowers in the hair, glass bangles on the wrist, and so on, is nowhere more strikingly apparent than in its absence among widows. An advert for the Tribhovandas Bhimji Zaveri jewellery store in New Delhi shows one eye of obviously white woman on the left hand page of an open book while the opposite page reads, ‘Her eyes were like limpid pools of dark emerald you could drown in. Funny how no one even seemed to notice them’ (Femina 1 June 2001). The word ‘notice’ is the only word in an otherwise black background lit up by a golden light and pink glow. Thus beautiful eyes by themselves cannot attract sufficient attention, and that in order to be noticed, there is a need for jewellery, preferably gold jewellery. Earlier jewellery adverts show women traditionally attired in conventional saris, in the midst of an auspicious event, surrounded by family and friends, wearing different kinds of jewellery. The emphasis was on auspicious events such as weddings and birthdays as occasions for the exchange of gifts of jewellery. This advert emphasises the necessity of adornment for the recognition of beauty as, without adornment, the suggestion is that
EMBODIMENT AND WOMANHOOD IN FEMINA 83
beauty remains incomplete. However, in doing this, it focuses only on the eyes of a woman, and that too only on one eye. By focusing on a single aspect of woman’s embodiment, and commenting on the lack of recognition without jewelled adornment, this advert is emphasising its inclusion as necessary to woman’s complete feminine presentation and identity. Similarly, another advert for Carbon jewellery promotes itself as a part of fashion accessories and emphasises the heightening of the sensuality of woman through the use of the product (Femina 1 September 2001). A woman in a western dress, with long slits along her legs, is leaning against a fence and gazing longingly into the distance. It is dark and she is alone, in an unusual dress. The advert reads, ‘If you don’t hear the whistles, they’re still catching their breath.’ There is longing and desire in the model’s gaze and the jewellery promises to be ‘very provocative’ which will not only heighten the wearer’s sensuality but also have a ‘heart-stopping effect’ on others. The combination of the global and the local in each frame, repeated in the magazine, will serve to heighten the experience of being part of an international trend setting scene if the spectator and the consumer are ready to be adventurous, untamed and wild without losing their traditional or normatively constructed femininity in any way. Similarly, woman’s sexuality is never directly addressed in adverts or fashion photography but a subtle or covert link is present in the text or in the model’s appearance in most adverts. In an advert for the ‘Beauty Secrets’ range of cosmetics, there is an image of a partially clad woman looking provocatively into the camera. The text reads, ‘A gorgeous well kept body takes a lot of care and a few Beauty Secrets.’ The advert highlights three points: that a ‘gorgeous well kept body’ is an ideal; that it takes a ‘lot of care’; and that the use of the advertised product would be helpful in this venture. The advert also emphasises the sexual dimension of beauty in the model’s caressing of her naked shoulder and the suggestion of her removing her bra. An overt display of an obvious sexuality is very carefully represented. In an advert for Vanity Fair underwear, a young woman is shown lounging in her underwear in front of a window where the curtains are not drawn. Although credits are displayed in small print at the bottom of the page, the model’s face is hidden from the viewer although she is perhaps clearly visible from the other side of the window. Her face is not revealed so that a woman who chooses to be daring in terms of body display and her body stance, which
84
LIVING THE BODY
appears to be sexually uninhibited and defiant, has to be somehow controlled possibly by being partially hidden from view (Femina 1994). Similarly, in an advert for Jockey stretch sport top, the model is behind a screen but is now shown with a full frontal image and not obscured or partially withheld from view as earlier lingerie adverts indicated (Femina 1 September 2001). This image appears almost prepubertal and very young and child-like in its representation and therefore becomes acceptable to the viewer. An international brand, Lovable, (Femina 1 June 2001) has an international model featured in a full frontal display in a visual expressing exuberance and joy. The text reads ‘Cotton Essensuals’ and the viewer is exhorted to ‘show it off ’, presumably a reference to her embodied self. An Indian model was clearly unacceptable in this advert so as not to offend social and public sensibilities in such an obvious overt bodily display of sexual freedom and what the advert considers a liberated and perhaps outrageous and therefore unacceptable sensuality. Wearing the advertised bra might be a ‘safe’ choice however as it is not visible to the naked eye and lies underneath a sartorial choice that may exude the aura of desirable respectability. These are shifting, contradictory and often ambivalent representations of a feminine gender identity. Adverts and fashion displays hover between tradition and modernity and there are no clear-cut or sharply defined body images which construct femininity in an idealtypical way. There are many different versions of femininity, as it were, and therefore many masks and persona available to women to acquire and use to fulfill their desires and aspirations. An advert for an Elizabeth Arden ‘arden beauty eau de perfum’ (Femina 15 April 2003) perhaps sums up what all adverts and fashion photography have been constructing about women: ‘Partreality. Partillusion. Allwoman’. The message clearly is that woman is made up of both an embodied material reality but also contains certain illusory characteristics and that taken together, she may be constructed as a complete woman. The partly illusory and partly real characteristics of womanhood however ensure that an ephemeral characteristic gets attached to womanhood that remains out of the grasp of ordinary acts of cognition and recognition. There is both erasure and incompleteness in this construction of womanhood, leaving an open door for the constructive role that women may play in the performance of their identity. It is also true that notions of the authentic Indian woman are constantly changing and the role of the media in this process in
EMBODIMENT AND WOMANHOOD IN FEMINA 85
undeniable. Television reaches out to millions of homes and the serials (daily soaps) that are watched by women range from those that extol traditional values of womanhood to those that celebrate contemporary womanhood by emphasising their commitment to work and the family. In one issue, Femina has a Cover Story (Femina 15 January 2004) on a television show (Jassi Jaissi Koi Nahin literally ‘There’s no one like Jassi’) that is about an ordinary young woman, who is not glamorous or stunning to look at (she wears spectacles, dresses in a dowdy style) but is hard working, caring and affectionate. This serial is appreciated by Femina for projecting ‘a kick-ass professional, confident, ambitious, caring and progressive’ woman who describes the ‘millions of women emerging from a new India-anchored by values but fired up with the hope to excel in life’ (ibid.: 34). The significance of work in women’s lives is emphasised as is her capacity to become ‘invaluable at the workplace and outside’ and Femina suggests that this reflects a ‘trend’ rather than just a passing fad. Femina also emphasises that such a change indicates that there is a break with tradition, ‘a sense of continuity slips away’ and that ‘we occupy a time of no enduring ideas, no over arching values or questions’ (ibid.: 37). The possibilities for dreaming about a different life, for nurturing hope and challenging stereotypes is therefore left open. The same issue of the magazine (Femina 15 January 2004) contains two adverts that emphasise woman’s assertion of her independence and fearlessness. One advert is for Asmi diamond jewellery and shows a very contemporary face of Indian womanhood, with very little make-up, straight hair, wearing a shirt, and modeling a small diamond pendant. The text reads: When did fear go away… And passion replace it? When did the boundaries disappear… And horizons look near? When did the world matter less… And your inner voice more? When exactly did you begin to believe There is no one You would rather be than you. Asmi Diamond Jewellery. Reflects your inner fire’. (Femina 15 January 2004)
86
LIVING THE BODY
An advert for Sahil Emporium foregrounds a woman, arms outstretched, glowing face, draped in a heavily embroidered sari, wearing traditional jewellery, against a backdrop of overpowering mountains and a cloudy sky, and another woman standing in the shadows at the back. The text reads, ‘Woman, its time you came out of the shadows’ (Femina 15 January 2004). Contemporary adverts therefore focus on contemporary womanhood and emphasise woman’s independence, fearlessness and courage while advertising products that would nonetheless aid in highlighting woman’s femininity. The message clearly indicates that although women today are independent and free, and need to be encouraged in their efforts, there is no need to give up traditional or trendy wear, beauty aids, expensive jewellery, and remain modern and chic at the same time. The emphasis is also on an assertion of what woman desires for herself and pushes woman to be more self-centred and selfish: An advert for Natalia designerwear shows a model in trousers and a lightweight jacket, wearing closed shoes, looking directly at the camera, a true professional who is urged to think only about herself as the label reads, ‘Natalia. I. Me. Myself ’ (Femina 1 November 2003). It may appear that there is a break with what are considered tradtional definitions of the female body which lead scholars to conclude that the ‘individual corporate woman is the icon’ of the upmarket magazines that project ‘a post-liberalised post-feminism’ (Chaudhuri 2000: 264). I contend, however that, Femina or even other magazines such as Elle or Cosmopolitan, clearly do not point to this construction of contemporary Indian womanhood. It is woman as an icon of beauty and glamour that dominates the magazine’s construction of Indian womanhood within the trope of an authentic woman who is both modern and yet epitomizes the best of tradition. While adverts and fashion photography may apparently depict Indian woman as modern, successful career and even corporate woman, and her embodiment as constitutive of self-identity to the extent that there is an excessive concern with shaping, moulding and fashioning the body, or indeed as a career woman who may outwardly appear not excessively concerned with her embodiment or engaged in power dressing, the link with traditional definitions of femininity has not been broken. A woman may therefore be shown as a professional or as a career woman, or as a modern, liberated woman, but she is simultaneously depicted as seductive and sensually appealing. An advert for Samsonite baggage has a promising one-liner
EMBODIMENT AND WOMANHOOD IN FEMINA 87
for the aspiring career woman ‘Take a Different Route’. While one frame (Femina 15 May 2003) depicts the western model in western clothes striding down an endless road with vast possibilities and open endings indicative of endless vistas embodying the opportunities and success that might await her, another frame (Femina 15 April 2003) seeks to restrict woman to the board room table on which she walks as a model might walk the ramp under the watchful eyes of her male colleagues, partners or simply, male predators.
FEMINA TODAY More recently, Femina has adopted a very different marketing strategy and I would argue, its management is perhaps no longer clear about its readership, and is searching for an elusive reader, having lost some ground to the plethora of magazines that have invaded the market. It is a much more upmarket magazine than it was only a few years ago, going primarily by the kinds of products being promoted by the magazine addressing the reader directly with its aggressive promotional call, ‘Femina says so’ (Femina 29 August 2007). To begin with, it has changed its opening statement about whom the magazine is intended for: moving from ‘Woman of substance’ to ‘Generation W’ to now simply ‘Femina Believe’. The connotations of this statement are ambiguous, open to many different kinds of interpretations, such as, inviting the reader to ‘believe’ in the magazine and all that it stands for, or perhaps suggesting that Femina believes in the potential of its clientele, or even that ‘belief ’ as a value, in oneself, in others, in life, is perhaps integral to being a woman today. This particular issue of the magazine is devoted to the movies, and in her editorial, Up Front, the editor sells the idea of using the movies as a theme for the magazine: ‘This issue is ‘All About Eve’. It’s telling you ‘What Lies Beneath’, it shows you ‘How (Not) To Lose a Guy in 10 Days’. It’s got 31 Things To Do Before You’re 30’, it talks about ‘A Mighty Heart’. Got it? We’re taking you to the movies’. (Femina 29 August 2007)
This racy style is reflected in the magazine as whole. The entire layout appears to have changed, with more colour, glossy full page or double
88
LIVING THE BODY
page adverts, professional fashion advice from an in-house fashion director and food advice from a consulting editor. Professionalism and opulence together now appear as the hallmark of a magazine set on recasting its image and that of the Indian woman as well. We now find, for example, that ‘perfecting the body’ has acquired a new meaning in the magazine, moving beyond body regimes such as physical exercise, the proverbial ‘best’ diet, to advice about cosmetic surgery. A leading cosmetic surgeon advises readers on such matters as arm lifts, breast reduction, sunken nipples, nose repair, pinning back the ears and removing facial moles (Femina 29 August 2007: 95). Similarly, an international aestheticienne answers queries about skin and hair and there is advice on puffy eyes, an uneven complexion and hard palms (Femina 29 August 2007: 100). In an apparently professional tone, there is an enhancement of the fragmentation of women’s embodiment in textual representation and this can only produce a similar experience in the reader. ‘Femina inner circle’ inviting the reader: ‘Its all about you’, is a whole new section on ‘relationships’ (‘how not to lose a guy in 10 days’), ‘evesdropping’ (a short piece on an airport encounter) ‘intimacy’ (about the ‘long goodnight kiss’ through visuals of American movie scenes), ‘me-time’ (‘31 things to do before you’re 30’), ‘parenting’, ‘family matters’, ‘fly on the wall’ (about male strippers), ‘therapy’ (about self-help books) and ‘your right to know’ (legal advice regarding divorce and other laws) (Femina 29 August 2007). Apart from the last column which provides sensible legal advice to readers, the rest are mere trivia, addressing young women through pieces, both texts and visuals, that seek to emphasise youth, adventurism, and simultaneously projecting itself as a trendy magazine for both the young and older woman. Perhaps this is the change that the new editor has brought about: appealing to the younger, slightly more fashionable woman, with higher disposable income, who may be lost otherwise to Cosmopolitan, Elle Hair, Fashion, and many other magazines. Femina has not forsaken its interest in Beauty and Fashion. That still remains its main focus and has acquired a cutting edge, because now ‘Femina says so’. The opening pages of the magazine begin with ‘Whats Buzzing? From the hottest to the coolest…’ with sections such as ‘beautiful women’, ‘all men’, ‘classic’, ‘watches’, and so on. The highlight of the section, ‘beautiful women’ is a quiz with a visual display of a hundred chosen women presented as ‘India’s most
EMBODIMENT AND WOMANHOOD IN FEMINA 89
beautiful women’, that have to be narrowed down to fifty. Names are provided and readers are invited to ‘grab your phone and help us to choose’. While this may suggest the involvement of the reader in expressing her selection of the ‘most beautiful’ women through a vote, the reader is in fact already provided with a visual display of what the magazine considers legitimate or authentic Indian beauty. This is done through names and photographs of mainly film actors and fashion models, which is then sought to be confirmed by readers through a voting and narrowing down process. In this manner, the magazine seeks to rest Indian womanhood on the shoulders of the fashion and film industry. The irony could not be more significant. ‘Femina Believe’ asks its women readers to believe in these icons which must be the most far removed from their individual lives as ordinary women in small towns and big cities. Beauty is still being promoted very much as something to strive for, to seek through various ways and means, and success may meet women who seek, follow the rules, and appropriately perfect their bodies, whether it is through professional advice, fashion displays, adverts and other features that exclusively address their embodiment, their emotions and their lives.
CONCLUDING COMMENTS As even casual readers of Femina, women undoubtedly experience their embodiment through a collage of visual and textual representation of which women’s magazines is only one arena. The presentation of woman’s embodiment through fashion photography, for example, is aimed at projecting both a glamourous body and a lifestyle which can apparently be achieved by any woman. The middle- or upper-class urban Indian woman to whom visual representation in women’s magazines is addressed is educated, upwardly mobile, class or status conscious, economically independent, capable of taking decisions for the family, modern, urban and consciously middle-class. Most importantly, she has the economic capacity to consume the products advertised in the magazine where beauty and body are equally emphasised, along with household/home care, through the use of appliances, gadgets, wall paint, and so forth. She also has the ability to develop her culinary skills displayed in the colourful and appetising
90
LIVING THE BODY
centrespread of the magazine, take appropriate care of her children, animal pets and garden plants, and simultaneously work hard to ‘keep her man’ and the marriage. She may find answers to her sexual and psychological problems in the Home Truths columns, the Doctor’s page, or the various other reader advice columns. Otherwise, she has to essentially rely on her wits and her imagination to survive in the world. Such a woman is perhaps Femina’s ‘woman of substance’ or ‘Generation W ’. Beauty pageants are crucial to the magazine’s glamour image and, in economic terms, to its circulation. Beauty pageants we all know are market grounds for not only the bodies on display but also for the promotion of the cosmetics and the fashion industry. It has also been suggested that the beauty pageant is a significant site of ‘political intervention’ precisely because it opens up the possibilities of new ways of considering ‘women’s engagement with desire and pleasure’ (Oza 2001: 1089). There is no pure space within which women are constructed as non-objectified subjects and therefore their expression of agency in participating in such events indicates a complex network of agency, negotiation and self-definition. There is however a factual reality which indicates that women participants in such beauty contests end up being the primary icons of the fashion and cosmetics industry and therefore remain trapped in the domain of objectified display and recognition. The ageing, disabled, obese or out-of-shape body, which are seen as being deviant from the perfect embodied state, find no place in this space and there is therefore an inability to break the dangerously limited and structuring nature of such embodied construction. More importantly, magazines like Femina, and even Cosmopolitan, and Elle, ensure that postcolonial constructions of gendered modernity are based very squarely on economic factors relating to advertisements and a policy that is meant to enhance the magazine’s circulation. The resultant new ‘consuming’ woman is a result of the new economic order and is a beneficiary of globalisation as much as she is caught up in the larger processes of recolonisation. It is also the case that postcolonial habitus reproduces gender identity as well as engenders social practices for the performance of identity through agential negotiation, strategisation and self-definition. In this context, Bourdieu notes, ‘The social gaze is not a universal, abstract, objectifying power...but a social power, whose efficacy is always partly due to the fact that the receiver recognizes the categories of
EMBODIMENT AND WOMANHOOD IN FEMINA 91
perception and appreciation it applies to him or her’ (Bourdieu 1984: 207). It is through this recognition that compliance as well as agency and resistance come into play and women are simultaneously engaged in the construction and reproduction of embodied womanhood. The complexities underlying this engagement belong both to the world of cognizance as well as to an unconscious playing out of desire and emotion in the construction of identity. The media has played a role that, through its ability to ‘inflect desire, memory and fantasy’, serves to reproduce prevailing ‘relations of ruling’ (Smith 1999) in various modes that may appear different but largely remain unchanged.6 The challenge in the contemporary moment lies in organising and developing a ‘media practice by which subjectivities may be lived and analysed as part of a transformative, emancipatory practice’ (Shohat and Stam 1996: 166). As long as women’s magazines continue to pander to the hard sell of the beauty and fashion industry, and cater to their own economic ambitions, it is unlikely that such a challenge will ever be raised.7 Magazines like Femina may have co-opted the language of feminist discourse in their emphasis on the ‘professional’ woman reflected in articles about women professionals, or in providing information about the different career choices available to women. Their overwhelming emphasis on beauty and glamour, both in the fashion displays and in the advertisements they carry, however, indicates that they attempt to address a diversity of women and by carrying progressive articles and a variety of useful information, they may attract some discerning readers. Moreover, the overall slant of Femina certainly remains very much towards emphasizing a life style dedicated to Beauty and Glamour. The woman who Femina addresses is no doubt a ‘modern’ woman to the extent that she may have access, through her education and privileged socio-economic status, to a variety of occupations that are increasingly available in a rapidly globalising and modernising urban India. She is no doubt interested in beauty and body care and maintenance to the extent it helps in the embodied presentation of herself 6 Smith has examined in depth ‘the ruling relations’ which she identifies as that ‘complex of objectified social relations that organize and regulate our lives in contemporary society’ (Smith 1999: 74). 7 I therefore find it difficult to accept Chanda’s view urging the women’s movement to negotiate the popular media, including women’s magazines, and to ‘use’ them as a ‘vehicle for the conveyance of our aims and concerns’ (Chanda 2004: 132–3).
92
LIVING THE BODY
in everyday life. She is also traditional to the extent that she places a high premium on certain values relating to, for example, marriage, motherhood and family life. She is, as Sunder Rajan defines her, the ‘woman for all seasons’, ‘new’ in the sense of ‘having evolved and arrived’ (Sunder Rajan 1993: 130) in response to the times as well as being ‘modern’ and ‘liberated’. She is also representative of the ‘truly Indian’ woman, to the extent that she has not forsaken tradition and in fact her identity is tied to that. The recolonisation of womanhood in contemporary India projects the trope of modernity as the overarching privileged space that offers freedom and liberation. However, the relations of power embedded in this trope simultaneously reconstruct woman as keeper, preserver and nurturer of tradition well within its normative definitions of gender identity. Gender in this way becomes essential to preserving the honour and integrity of the nation state that is beset with the vicissitudes of globalisation and turns to Indian womanhood as the embodiment of respectability and national honour that must be preserved at all costs. To understand women as the bearers of respectable and honourable embodiment is to emphasise their primary responsibility towards the community and the nation. Is this however how women themselves perceive their experience of embodiment? I turn now to women’s voices to understand their lives in the everyday from the perspective of embodiment and identity, and their experience of violence in the troubled contexts of their existence as gendered subjects.
4 THE BODY IN THE MIRROR EMBODIMENT, VIOLENCE AND IDENTITY
T
his chapter is based on material from interviews with two categories of women: those who are educated, professionals, upper class and engaged in work or are homemakers. The second category includes women who are from a more middle class socio-economic background, working outside the homes and who speak their mother tongue as their first language.1 The women in the first category have all received education at fee-paying private schools and have studied with English as the medium of instruction throughout. Many of them have studied abroad at institutions of higher education and have travelled outside India. They are cosmopolitan in demeanour, sartorial styles, and lifestyles. There are variations in their presentations of self in everyday life. Depending on the extent of their education, they consider it important to express and communicate their feminist outlook, articulating and emphasising by often using sophisticated linguistic turns of phrase, their various relationships through a feminist lens. Simultaneously, however, the mirrorimage of their embodiment appears as a trope in some of their stories signifying the construction of a self based on what is revealed to them through the looking glass.2 This is however not the only Interviews with both categories of women were conducted between 1997 and 2001. 2 Among some educationally disadvantaged young women as well, a mention was made of the use of the mirror but this appeared to be for purely utilitarian considerations such as the putting on of the bindi, sindoor or lipstick. The mirror is used by them for the construction of the self as well, even though, it remains unspoken to the extent that they rely on their reflection for the performance of a particular identity—as a married woman. 1
94
LIVING THE BODY
image as women’s embodied experience in everyday life is also derived from their location in the class and the family with capital of varying kinds. The meta