Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture Edited by
Josianne G. Støttrup, PhD Danish Institute for Fisheries Research, Charlottenlund, Denmark
and Lesley A. McEvoy, PhD North Atlantic Fisheries College, Shetland Isles, UK
© 2003 by Blackwell Science Ltd, a Blackwell Publishing Company Editorial Offices: 9600 Garsington Road, Oxford OX4 2DQ, UK Tel: ⫹44 (0)1865 776868 Blackwell Publishing, Inc., 350 Main Street, Malden, MA 02148-5018, USA Tel: ⫹1 781 388 8250 Iowa State Press, a Blackwell Publishing Company, 2121 State Avenue, Ames, Iowa 50014-8300, USA Tel: ⫹1 515 292 0140 Blackwell Publishing Asia Pty Ltd, 550 Swanston Street, Carlton South, Victoria 3053, Australia Tel: ⫹61 (0)3 9347 0300 Blackwell Wissenschafts Verlag, Kurfürstendamm 57, 10707 Berlin, Germany Tel: ⫹49 (0)30 32 79 060 The right of the Author to be identified as the Author of this Work has been asserted in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, except as permitted by the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, without the prior permission of the publisher.
First published 2003 by Blackwell Science Ltd Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data is available
ISBN 0-632-05495-6 A catalogue record for this title is available from the British Library Produced and set in Times by Gray Publishing, Tunbridge Wells, Kent Printed and bound in Great Britain by MPG Books, Bodmin, Cornwall For further information on Blackwell Science, visit our website: www.blackwell-science.com
Contents
Foreword Preface Contributors Abbreviations 1 Status of Marine Aquaculture in Relation to Live Prey: Past, Present and Future David A. Bengtson 1.1 A Historical Perspective 1.2 Marine Aquaculture Today and in the Future 1.3 The Status of Larviculture and Live Feed Usage 1.3.1 Africa 1.3.2 Asia 1.3.3 Europe 1.3.4 North America 1.3.5 Oceania 1.3.6 South America, including Central America and the Caribbean 1.4 Why is Live Feed Necessary? 1.5 Problems and Prospects with Alternatives to Live Feed 1.6 Conclusions 1.7 References 2 Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers Esther Lubzens and Odi Zmora 2.1 Introduction 2.2 Biology and Morphological Characteristics of Rotifers 2.2.1 General biology 2.2.2 Taxonomy 2.2.2.1 The genus Brachionus 2.2.3 Morphology and physiology 2.2.3.1 Feeding 2.2.3.2 Digestion
xiii xv xvi xviii 1
1 5 7 7 8 9 10 10 11 11 12 13 13 17
17 19 19 21 21 23 23 25
vi
Contents
2.3
2.4
2.5
2.6
2.7 2.8
2.2.3.3 Body fluids and excretion 2.2.3.4 Movement 2.2.3.5 Nervous system and sensory organs 2.2.4 Reproduction 2.2.4.1 Asexual and sexual reproduction 2.2.4.2 Reproductive rates 2.2.4.3 Sexual reproduction and resting egg formation Culturing Rotifers 2.3.1 Selection of species and/or strain 2.3.2 Maintaining water quality in culture tanks 2.3.2.1 Organic particles 2.3.2.2 Bacteria and other organisms in the culture tanks 2.3.3 Choosing the most appropriate culture techniques 2.3.3.1 Small-scale laboratory cultures 2.3.3.2 Mass cultures Advanced Warning on State of Cultures 2.4.1 Egg ratio 2.4.2 Swimming velocity 2.4.3 Ingestion rate 2.4.4 Viscosity 2.4.5 Enzyme activity 2.4.6 Diseases Nutritional Quality of Rotifers 2.5.1 Number of rotifers consumed by larvae 2.5.2 Dry weight and caloric value 2.5.3 Biochemical composition 2.5.3.1 Protein and carbohydrate content 2.5.3.2 Lipid composition 2.5.3.3 Vitamin enrichments 2.5.4 Effects of starvation Preserved Rotifers 2.6.1 Preservation at low temperatures 2.6.2 Cryopreservation 2.6.3 Resting eggs Future Directions References
3 Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia Jean Dhont and Gilbert Van Stappen 3.1 Introduction 3.2 Biology of Artemia 3.2.1 Morphology and life cycle 3.2.2 Ecology and natural distribution 3.2.3 Taxonomy
26 26 26 27 27 29 31 31 31 32 33 33 34 35 36 43 43 44 44 44 44 44 45 45 46 46 46 47 48 48 49 49 50 50 52 52 65
65 67 67 73 75
Contents
3.2.4 Strain-specific characteristics 3.2.4.1 Size and energy content 3.2.4.2 Hatching quality 3.2.4.3 Diapause characteristics 3.2.4.4 Growth rate of nauplii 3.2.4.5 Temperature and salinity tolerance 3.2.4.6 Life-history traits and reproductive capacity 3.2.4.7 Nutritional value 3.2.5 Cyst biology and diapause 3.2.5.1 Cyst morphology and physiology 3.2.5.2 Cyst metabolism and hatching 3.2.5.3 Diapause 3.3 Production Methods: Tank Production of Artemia Biomass 3.3.1 Advantages of tank production and tank-produced biomass 3.3.2 Physicochemical conditions 3.3.3 Artemia strain selection and culture density 3.3.4 Feeding 3.3.5 Infrastructure 3.3.6 Culture techniques 3.3.7 Control of infections 3.3.8 Harvest and processing of cultured Artemia 3.3.9 Production figures of intensive Artemia cultures 3.4. Biochemical composition 3.4.1 Proximate composition 3.4.1.1 Cysts and decapsulated cysts 3.4.1.2 Nauplii 3.4.1.3 Juveniles and adults 3.4.2 Lipids 3.4.2.1 Cysts and nauplii 3.4.2.2 Ongrown Artemia 3.4.3 Proteins 3.4.4 Vitamins 3.5 Applications of Artemia 3.5.1 The future use of Artemia in aquaculture 3.5.2 Hatching 3.5.3 Harvesting hatched nauplii 3.5.4 Decapsulation 3.5.5 Enrichment 3.5.5.1 Lipid enrichment 3.5.5.2 Phospholipid enrichment 3.5.5.3 Protein enrichment 3.5.5.4 Vitamin enrichment 3.5.5.5 Enrichment with prophylactics 3.5.5.6 Enrichment with other products
vii
76 77 77 77 78 78 78 79 79 79 80 81 83 83 84 86 86 88 91 92 93 93 94 94 94 94 95 96 96 97 97 98 99 99 99 102 104 105 105 107 108 109 110 110
viii
Contents
3.5.6 Cold storage 3.5.6.1 Survival at low temperatures 3.5.6.2 Maintenance of nutritional value 3.5.6.3 Other advantages 3.5.7 Use of juvenile and adult Artemia 3.6 References
110 110 110 111 111 112
4 Production, Harvest and Processing of Artemia from Natural Lakes Gilbert Van Stappen
122
4.1 Introduction 4.2 Pond Production of Artemia Cysts and Biomass 4.2.1 Permanent solar salt operations 4.2.2 Seasonal units 4.2.3 Site selection 4.2.3.1 Climatology 4.2.3.2 Topography 4.2.3.3 Soil conditions 4.2.4 Pond adaptation 4.2.4.1 Deepening the ponds 4.2.4.2 Dike construction 4.2.4.3 Screening 4.2.5 Preparation of ponds for Artemia cultivation 4.2.5.1 Liming 4.2.5.2 Predator control 4.2.5.3 Fertilisation 4.2.5.4 Inorganic fertilisers 4.2.5.5 Organic fertilisers 4.2.5.6 Combination of organic and inorganic fertilisers 4.2.6 Artemia inoculation 4.2.6.1 Artemia strain selection 4.2.6.2 Inoculation procedures 4.2.7 Monitoring and managing the culture system 4.2.7.1 Monitoring the Artemia population 4.2.7.2 Abiotic parameters influencing Artemia populations 4.2.7.3 Biotic factors influencing Artemia populations 4.3 Artemia Harvesting and Processing Techniques 4.3.1 Harvesting techniques 4.3.2 Processing techniques 4.4 Artemia Cyst Harvesting and Processing Techniques 4.4.1 Harvesting techniques 4.4.2 Brine processing 4.4.2.1 Brine dehydration 4.4.2.2 Size separation in brine 4.4.2.3 Density separation in brine
122 123 123 124 125 126 126 126 126 127 127 128 128 128 128 129 130 130 130 131 131 131 132 132 133 133 134 134 135 137 137 137 137 139 139
Contents
ix
4.4.2.4 Initial (or ‘raw’) storage 4.4.2.5 Cold storage 4.4.3 Freshwater processing 4.4.4 Drying 4.4.4.1 Layer drying in open air 4.4.4.2 Layer drying in oven 4.4.4.3 Fluidised bed drying 4.4.5 Prepackaging, packaging and storage 4.5 References
139 140 140 140 141 141 141 143 143
5 Production and Nutritional Value of Copepods Josianne G. Støttrup
145
5.1 Introduction 5.2 Biology 5.2.1 General characteristics 5.2.1.1 Calanoida 5.2.1.2 Harpacticoida 5.2.1.3 Cyclopoida 5.2.2 Copepod morphology 5.2.2.1 Digestive system 5.2.2.2 Circulatory system 5.2.2.3 Nervous system 5.2.2.4 Reproductive system 5.2.3 Reproduction 5.2.4 Resting or diapause eggs 5.2.5 Development, size and growth 5.2.5.1 Life cycle 5.2.5.2 Mortality 5.2.5.3 Size 5.2.5.4 Generation time 5.2.6 Feeding, food quality and food availability 5.2.6.1 Calanoids 5.2.6.2 Harpacticoids 5.2.6.3 Cyclopoids 5.3 Production Methods 5.3.1 Extensive and outdoor cultures 5.3.1.1 Harvest of wild zooplankton 5.3.1.2 Production in enclosed fjords or sea areas 5.3.1.3 Production in outdoor ponds or large tanks 5.3.2 Intensive culture of copepods 5.3.2.1 Calanoids 5.3.2.2 Harpacticoids 5.3.2.3 Cyclopoids
145 145 145 146 149 149 149 152 153 153 153 155 156 156 156 157 158 158 159 159 161 163 168 168 168 168 171 175 175 181 187
x
Contents
5.4 Biochemical Composition 5.4.1 Carbon 5.4.2 Lipids 5.4.3 Protein 5.4.4 Free amino acids 5.4.5 Vitamin C 5.4.6 Carotenoids 5.4.7 Chitin 5.4.8 Enzymes 5.5 Nutritional Value for Fish Larvae 5.6 Application in Marine Aquaculture 5.7 References 6 The Microalgae of Aquaculture Arnaud Muller-Feuga, Jeanne Moal and Raymond Kaas 6.1 Introduction 6.2 Biology of Microalgae 6.2.1 General characteristics of microalgae 6.2.2 Growth 6.2.3 Substrates of photoautotrophy 6.2.3.1 Light 6.2.3.2 Mineral nutrients 6.2.4 Substrates of heterotrophy 6.2.5 Other factors affecting growth 6.2.5.1 Temperature 6.2.5.2 Salinity 6.2.5.3 Metabolites 6.2.5.4 pH 6.2.5.5 Mixing 6.3 Biochemical Composition of Microalgae 6.3.1 Gross biochemical composition 6.3.2 Vitamins 6.3.3 Sterols 6.3.3.1 Bacillariophyceae 6.3.3.2 Prymnesiophycaea 6.3.3.3 Prasinophyceae 6.3.3.4 Cryptophyceae 6.3.4 Fatty acids 6.3.4.1 Bacillariophyceae 6.3.4.2 Prymnesiophycaea 6.3.4.3 Prasinophyceae 6.3.4.4 Chlorophyceae 6.3.4.5 Cryptophyceae 6.3.4.6 Eustigmatophyceae
189 189 190 190 191 191 191 191 191 191 194 195 206
206 206 206 209 213 213 217 217 218 218 219 219 220 220 221 222 223 223 225 227 227 228 228 229 229 230 231 232 232
Contents
6.4 Production Methods for Aquacultural Microalgae 6.4.1 State of the art of microalgal production techniques in hatcheries 6.4.1.1 Asepsis and quality controls 6.4.1.2 Culture medium and temperature 6.4.1.3 Running the cultures 6.4.1.4 Efficiency 6.4.2 Methods of improvement 6.4.2.1 Continuous cultures 6.4.2.2 The increase in production yields 6.4.3 Heterotrophic production 6.4.4 Discussion 6.5 References 7 Uses of Microalgae in Aquaculture A. Muller-Feuga, R. Robert, C. Cahu, J. Robin and P. Divanach 7.1 Introduction 7.2 Microalgae as Food for Molluscs 7.2.1 Microalgae as a potential food source in mollusc hatcheries 7.2.1.1 Size 7.2.1.2 Digestibility 7.2.1.3 Nutritional value: biochemical composition of microalgae 7.2.1.4 Microalgae bulk production 7.2.2 Microalgal requirements in mollusc hatcheries 7.2.2.1 Feeding broodstock 7.2.2.2 Feeding larvae 7.2.2.3 Feeding spat 7.2.3 Microalgal substitutes for bivalve feeding 7.3 Microalgae as Food for Shrimp 7.3.1 Development of penaeid shrimp 7.3.2 Selection of algal species used for rearing shrimp larvae 7.3.3 Ingestion and filtration rates for shrimp larvae fed microalgae 7.3.4 Nutrient supply from algae in relation to larval shrimp requirements 7.3.5 Substitution of spray-dried algae or microparticulate compound diets for live algae 7.3.6 Other roles of algae in shrimp larval growth 7.3.7 Feeding microalgae to shrimp juveniles and adults 7.4 Microalgae as Food for Live Prey 7.4.1 Feeding live prey with live microalgae 7.4.2 Nutritional value of algae for live prey 7.4.2.1 Proteins and proximate composition 7.4.2.2 Fatty acids 7.4.2.3 Other lipid components
xi
233 233 234 236 236 236 237 238 238 240 242 243 253
253 254 255 255 256 257 257 257 258 259 261 261 263 263 263 265 266 268 269 269 270 270 271 271 272 274
xii
Contents
7.4.3 Vitamins 7.4.4 Minerals 7.4.5 Influence of algae on live feed and larval microbiology 7.4.6 Substitutes for live microalgae 7.5 Importance of Microalgae in Marine Finfish Larviculture 7.5.1 Range of microalgal action 7.5.2 Effects on endotrophic larval stages 7.5.3 Effects on the yolk-sac drinking stage 7.5.3.1 Drinking and ingestion of dissolved organics 7.5.3.2 Ingestion of microalgae 7.5.3.3 Digestion and assimilation of microalgae 7.5.4 Resistance to delay in first zooplanktonic feeding 7.5.5 Process and efficiency of first feeding 7.5.6 Effect on survival and growth efficiency at first feeding 7.5.7 Stimulation of digestive functions and gut flora 7.5.8 Effects on early exotrophic larvae 7.5.9 Indirect effects of microalgae on larvae 7.5.10 Future developments 7.6 References
275 275 275 276 279 279 279 280 280 281 282 283 283 284 285 286 286 288 288
Appendix I Appendix II Appendix III Appendix IV
300 304 306 307
Taxonomic Index
309
Common Names Index
312
Subject Index
313
Foreword
In the preface the editors point out that marine aquaculture has shown an important evolution from a relatively modest operation to a mature bio-industry, both in its research and development as well as for the industry. The maturation of the commercial ventures is seriously indebted to the huge progress in research and development in various disciplines relevant to aquaculture. Various indeed: if one feature can typify aquaculture research it is multidisciplinarity. Originally, the typical aquaculture researcher was a combination of a marine biologist, engineer, biochemist, physiologist, ecologist (at best), and a part-time plumber. Common knowledge on distinct topics was limited and progress was often achieved through sound, albeit empirical, experiments. Trial and error ruled, not necessarily in a one-to-one ratio. But as knowledge has broadened and deepened, aquaculture scientists became more specialized and fundamental research gradually came to underpin empirical findings. With the drive for specialization it became harder for the individual scientist to keep track of all pertinent information as well as new developments in research fields other than his or her own. This explains and justifies the multiple initiatives to provide publications, like this book, offering comprehensive updates on a selected topic. To initiate such an initiative may well turn out to be a tedious job, but fortunately strong bonds were forged between leading research groups back in the days when the aquaculture ‘who’s who’ could still be printed on a single sheet of paper. And although some degree of (mostly healthy) competition exists, it is still rather easy to find enthusiastic and dedicated authorities willing to contribute to essential reviews of the state-of-the-art of, for instance, live feed technology. As aquaculture developed, live feed has often been a bottleneck in the larviculture of many species of fish and shellfish, especially at times when upscaling from laboratory and pilot trials to large industrial units. It is therefore a pleasure and an honor to introduce Live Feed in Marine Aquaculture wherein all its relevant issues are covered by representatives of some of world’s finest aquaculture research groups. Prof. Dr Patrick Sorgeloos
Preface
The past two decades have witnessed a dramatic expansion in the culture of marine finfish and crustaceans. Marine larviculture without live feed, or crustacean cultures without microalgae, are rarities in commercial aquaculture. The development of commercial formulated feeds remains today’s upcoming challenge. In the meantime, the industry continues the struggle to produce stable quantities of high-quality live feeds. The different species used in marine aquaculture differ in their biology and culture requirements, providing ample challenges for the novice and requiring expertise in a commercial enterprise. This book includes information on the biology and culture of copepods as well as of the better-known traditional live feeds such as rotifers and Artemia. Enrichment techniques for rotifers and Artemia have greatly improved their nutritional value for marine fish species and have contributed to the expansion of the industry. Nutritional defects, however, are still evident in some species and in other cases subtle differences such as decreased tolerance to low temperatures observed during the juvenile stages in marine fish are attributed to poor nutritional diets during the larval stages. With the increasing emphasis on fish welfare and the need to produce high quality fish both for the aquaculture industry and for stocking purposes, larval nutrition will continue to be a main focus area for research within marine aquaculture. Filtering molluscs and penaeid shrimps require microalgal diets at least during some stage in their development. The development of mollusc culture is closely related to the quantity and quality of phytoplankton produced. In shrimp culture, despite the development of formulated diets, phytoplankton is still used in hatcheries to supplement the diet during the larval stages. Survival and growth in marine fish larvae can be improved by the addition of live cultures. Although their role is not fully understood, their positive effects are well documented. This book provides the reader with the compiled information on most of the live feeds used in modern marine aquaculture. Although it may not be exhaustive, it will supply the basic information needed on the biology of the species and an introduction to the relevant literature. It will also serve as a practical guide, intended to provide the reader with a good overview on culture techniques for the different species involved and with substantial reference to related literature. Three chapters deal with the hatchery production, use and nutritional value of respectively Artemia, rotifers and copepods. A further chapter deals with the production, harvest and processing of Artemia from natural lakes. Two chapters on microalgae deal with their use and production in aquaculture providing the reader with a broad insight on the importance of phytoplankton in marine aquaculture, their production and nutritional value. The book is intended for advanced undergraduates, postgraduates and researchers in the field of marine aquaculture. It may also be relevant to experimental researchers working on physiology, behaviour or energetics in these species, or to hatchery biologists who may wish to diversify or improve their culture methods.
Contributors
David A. Bengtson Professor and Graduate Program Director, Department of Fisheries, Animal and Veterinary Science, University of Rhode Island, Kingston, RI 02881, USA. Tel.: (1) 401 874 2668, fax: (1) 401 874 4017, e-mail:
[email protected] Chantal Cahu Senior research scientist, Laboratoire Nutrition, IFREMER, Centre de Brest, BP 70, 29280 Plouzané, France. Tel.: (33) 2 98 22 40 40, fax: (33) 2 98 22 45 45, e-mail:
[email protected] Pascal Divanach Head of Aquaculture Department, Institute of Marine Biology of Crete, PO Box 2214, Post of Poros, 71003 Iraklion, Crete, Greece. Tel.: (308) 81 24 15 43, e-mail:
[email protected] Jean Dhont Researcher, Laboratory of Aquaculture & Artemia Reference Center, Ghent University, Rozier 44, 9000 Gent, Belgium. Tel.: (32) 9 264 3754, Fax: (32) 9 264 4193, e-mail:
[email protected] Raymond Kaas Senior research scientist, Laboratoire Algae Biotechnology, IFREMER, Centre de Nantes, BP 21 105, 44 311 Nantes cedex 03, France. Tel.: (33) 2 40 37 41 09, fax: (33) 2 40 37 40 71, e-mail:
[email protected] Esther Lubzens Department of Marine Biology and Biotechnology, Israel Oceanographic and Limnological Research, National Institute of Oceanography, PO Box 8030, Haifa 31080, Israel. Tel.: (972) 4 8515202, fax: (972) 4 8511911, e-mail:
[email protected] Jeanne Moal Senior research scientist, Laboratoire Invertebrate Physiology, IFREMER, Centre de Brest, BP 70, 29280 Plouzané, France. Tel.: (33) 2 98 22 40 40, fax: (33) 2 98 22 45 45, e-mail:
[email protected] Arnaud Muller-Feuga Head, Laboratoire Algae Biotechnology, IFREMER, Centre de Nantes, BP 21 105, 44 311 Nantes cedex 03, France. Tel.: (33) 2 40 37 42 20, fax: (33) 2 40 37 40 71, e-mail:
[email protected]
René Robert Senior research scientist, Laboratoire Invertebrate Physiology, IFREMER, Centre de Brest, BP 70, 29280 Plouzané, France. Tel.: (33) 2 98 22 40 40, fax: (33) 2 98 22 45 45, e-mail:
[email protected] Jean Robin Senior research scientist, Laboratoire Nutrition, IFREMER, Centre de Brest, BP 70, 29280 Plouzané, France. Tel.: (33) 2 98 22 40 40, fax: (33) 2 98 22 45 45, email:
[email protected] Josianne G. Støttrup Senior research scientist, Danish Institute for Fisheries Research, Department for Marine Ecology and Aquaculture, Charlottenlund Castle, DK-2920 Charlottenlund, Denmark. Tel.: (45) 3396 3394, fax: (45) 3396 3333, e-mail:
[email protected] Gilbert Van Stappen Researcher, Laboratory of Aquaculture & Artemia Reference Center, Ghent University, Rozier 44, B-9000 Ghent, Belgium. Tel.: (32) 9 264 37 54, fax: (32) 9 264 41 93, e-mail:
[email protected] Oded Zmora National Center for Mariculture, Israel Oceanographic and Limnological Research Ltd, PO Box 1212, Eilat 88112, Israel. Tel.: (972) 7 6361442, fax: 972 7 6375761, e-mail:
[email protected]
Abbreviations
AA ARA AscA AscAS ATP AWL BOD DHA DPH DPF DPPC DW EEZ EFA EPA ESD FAO FCE FW GMO GSL HUFA ILL ISA LC50 LNA L-type PAR PL PLa PUFA SCP SFB SGR SL S-type TAG WW
Amino acids Arachidonic acid; 20:4n-6 Ascorbic acid Ascorbic acid-2-sulfate Adenosine triphosphate Air-water lift system Biochemical oxygen demand Docosahexaenoic acid; 22:6n-3 Days post-hatching Days post-(first) feeding Dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine Dry weight Exclusive economic zones Essential fatty acids Eicosapentaenoic acid; 20:5n-3 Equivalent spherical diameter United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation Food conversion efficiency Weight after preservation in buffered saline formaldehyde Genetically modified organisms Great Salt Lake Highly unsaturated fatty acids with 20–22 carbon atoms and more than three double bonds Incipient limiting level International Study on Artemia Lethal concentration for 50% of the sampled population Linolenic acid; 18:3n-3 Large type Photosynthetically active radiation Phospholipid Post-larvae Polyunsaturated fatty acids with more than one double bond Single cell proteins San Francisco Bay Specific growth rate Standard length Small type Triacylglycerols Wet weight
Chapter 1
Status of Marine Aquaculture in Relation to Live Prey: Past, Present and Future David A. Bengtson
1.1 A Historical Perspective It is difficult to determine exactly where and when marine aquaculture began. Milkfish culture has been conducted in Asia for centuries, based on the capture of fry from the wild (Pamplona & Mateo 1985; Liao 1991), so that modern rearing methods and live feed in the hatchery were not required. The efforts to repopulate the seas of Europe and North America in the late 1800s may provide a more useful starting point for a brief historical review of the modern methods. In response to the fishery crisis at that time, ‘hatcheries’ were constructed in several countries for the purpose of providing fertilised eggs, developing embryos and larvae for distribution back into the ocean. The hope was that these would thrive and be recruited into the commercial fisheries. Given the knowledge of freshwater fish culture in Europe and the Americas, especially of salmonid culture, which had been rapidly developing since the mid-1800s and the attendant propagation, transportation and introduction of salmonid populations (Stickney 1996), this was not an unreasonable hope for the times. By the 1890s, Britain, France, Canada and the USA all had fish hatcheries devoted to the propagation of commercially important species, such as cod (Gadas morhua), haddock (Melanogrammus aeglefinus), turbot (Scophthalmus maximus = Psetta maxima), winter flounder (Pleuronectes americanus) and lobster (Homarus sp.). The prevailing practice was to obtain gravid adults of a given species, strip them of their gametes for purposes of controlled fertilisation, sometimes on-board ship (some of the hatcheries were in fact ships), sometimes on shore, and maintain them no longer than the prolarva stage prior to release back to the ocean. The reason for the release at such an early stage of development was simple: there was no convenient live feed with which to provide them for their postlarval survival and growth. Cod larvae were raised in concrete ponds in Flødevigen, Norway, in the 1880s on a diet of natural zooplankton and in the absence of predators (Rognerud 1887), but apparently the results of this ‘experiment’ were interpreted to mean that the larvae should survive in nature, not that juveniles could be reared for release. It is only with the benefit of hindsight that we know that these ocean stocking efforts were doomed to fail, owing to the high mortality rates of fish early life-stages in the oceans. Nevertheless, many of these programmes were sustained for decades until the lack of evidence of any success from them became apparent. We will never know whether earlier discovery of easily culturable live
2
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
feeds would have allowed hatchery culture of these species to a later stage when they might have had better chances of oceanic survival. Indeed, the field of stock enhancement might have been advanced by several decades had convenient live feeds been available in the late 1800s. Just as many of the ocean stocking programmes of the late 1800s and early 1900s were being phased out, two developments occurred half a world apart that paved the way for much of the development of modern marine aquaculture. First, nauplii of the brine shrimp, Artemia, were found to be a good food for raising both freshwater and some marine larval fish (Seale 1933; Gross 1937; Rollefsen 1939). This allowed the culture of at least some fish species (those with mouths large enough to ingest Artemia nauplii as a first food). The use of Artemia nauplii as a convenient live feed, not only for fish, but also (and especially) for crustaceans, has perhaps done as much for the explosion of marine aquaculture in the late 1900s as any other development. Secondly, in the 1930s, Japanese researchers, beginning with Dr M. Fujinaga, began research on the culture of the kuruma prawn, Penaeus japonicus, which subsequently led to the development of the shrimp industry that we know today (Liao & Chien 1994). That research, interrupted unfortunately by World War II, continued through the 1960s, when commercial culture of P. japonicus was finally achieved. Meanwhile, techniques were developed in the 1920s and 1930s that led to the development of molluscan hatcheries. Oyster culture, which has been known since Roman times, expanded in Japan in the seventeenth century with the finding that oyster larvae would settle on bamboo stakes, and expanded further in Europe, North America and Australia in the nineteenth century based on bottom culture (Bardach et al. 1972). Similarly, clam culture has been known in Japan and mussel culture has been known in France for several hundred years (Bardach et al. 1972). However, molluscan culture always relied on the settling of larvae from the natural zooplankton (and still does in many areas). Wells (1920) used a milk clarifier to retain oyster larvae while their water was being changed. Although hatchery spawning of oysters had been demonstrated as early as 1879, no one had been able successfully to change oyster culture water, and therefore replenish the algal food, without losing the larvae (Wells 1920). Wells (1927) then went on to raise clam larvae as well. Spawning and successful larval culture of mussels was not achieved until the early 1950s (Loosanoff & Davis 1963). Investigations of algal feeds for the rearing of molluscan larvae took place in the 1930s at both the Conwy, Wales, Fisheries Experiment Station (Walne 1974) and the Milford, USA, Bureau of Commercial Fisheries Biological Laboratory (Loosanoff & Davis 1963). Fertilisation of large tanks of filtered seawater to induce mixed phytoplankton blooms as food for molluscan larvae was carried out continuously beginning in 1938 (Loosanoff & Davis 1963), despite the contention that ‘large-scale cultivation of microalgae … was probably first considered seriously in Germany during World War II’ (Becker 1994). Decades of work at the Conwy and Milford laboratories paved the way for hatchery production of molluscs for commercial aquaculture in which natural settling of larvae was either impossible or undesirable. The culture of algae seems to have its origins in the late 1800s and was enabled by the methods developed by bacteriologists (Bold 1950). Marine algal culture lagged behind its freshwater counterpart, which successfully used uncomplicated media (Pringsheim 1924; Schreiber 1927) in the early 1900s. A significant advance in marine algal culture was reported by Gross (1937), who tried to culture diatoms and dinoflagellates, but whose
Status of Marine Aquaculture in Relation to Live Prey: Past, Present and Future
3
attention was drawn to ‘nannoplankton flagellates, most of them probably unknown systematically’ of about 2–10 m in size. He was able to culture these and use them as feed for harpacticoid copepods over three copepod generations. He summarised his work by writing ‘All these experiments led me to the conclusion that the autotroph nannoplankton flagellates are of great importance in the food economy of the sea.’ Little did he know that they would also be of great importance in aquaculture. Methods for marine algal culture continued to advance during the middle of the twentieth century with the development of artificial media (Provasoli et al. 1957) and the development of ‘f’ medium for the enrichment of seawater (Guillard & Ryther 1962). Improved methods for monospecific algal cultures allowed expansion of hatcheries for molluscan aquaculture and enabled culture of live invertebrates as feed for larval fish and crustaceans. Another extraordinarily important advance was made in the 1960s, when Japanese researchers discovered that rotifers, Brachionus plicatilis, previously considered a pest in culture ponds, could be used as a first food for larvae of both freshwater and marine fish species (Hirata 1979). This advance clearly allowed the culture of many more species whose larvae hatched at such a small size that their mouth gapes were insufficient for the ingestion of the larger Artemia prey. In retrospect, considering the large number of commercially important marine fish species that have been brought into culture and that rely on rotifers as first food in culture facilities, the debt to those initial Japanese culturists is profound. The 1960s saw widespread interest in the culture of commercially important marine fish species, first from a research perspective. In Japan, efforts were made to culture larvae of red sea bream, flounder and puffer fish, among others. In Britain, the White Fish Authority engaged in activities particularly in the area of flatfish culture (Shelbourne 1964) that ultimately led to the first commercial production of turbot in 1976 (Person-Le Ruyet et al. 1991). In France, research conducted primarily in the 1970s led to the development of the French sea bass and turbot industries in the 1980s (Person-LeRuyet et al. 1991; Coves et al. 1991). In many countries, including the USA, interest in larval fish biology from a fisheries perspective caused many laboratories to begin rearing larval fish on fieldcollected zooplankton, sometimes supplemented with rotifers and Artemia nauplii (e.g. Houde 1972), in order to conduct fisheries research (e.g. Laurence et al. 1981). Norwegian scientists, using some pertinent results from the cod-spawning and restocking efforts 100 years earlier, began pond culture of cod larvae using natural zooplankton in the mid-1970s, and followed that with a major research programme on halibut culture beginning in the 1980s. Many of the above efforts documented the difficulty of rearing the extremely delicate marine larvae through the first-feeding stages and on to metamorphosis and subsequent grow-out (e.g. Jones 1972). Clearly, early efforts at rearing larval marine fish, whether using natural zooplankton, rotifers or Artemia, were fraught with difficulties, to the point that the famous Kyoto conference in 1976 declared larval rearing a major bottleneck in marine aquaculture (Pillay 1979). As the 1970s saw the beginning of commercial production of several marine finfish and penaeid shrimp species, this decade is also noteworthy for the discovery that live feeds vary significantly in quality. From early reports suspecting pollutants (Bookhout & Costlow 1970) to later, more definitive, studies (Watanabe et al. 1978; and several papers from the International Study on Artemia: see Persoone et al. 1980), it became very obvious that different geographical strains of brine shrimp differed in their ability to support good survival and growth of marine larvae. The finding that the differences were due primarily to
4
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
fatty acid profiles led to productive collaborations between aquaculturists and biochemists that have resulted in literally hundreds of publications on the subject, as well as commercial products that have played no small role in the development of marine aquaculture. The lessons learned from brine shrimp were also shown to apply to rotifers (Lubzens et al. 1984), to be intimately connected to algal food supply (Léger et al. 1986) and to explain much of the high quality of natural zooplankton as a food item. The necessity for aquaculturists to understand in detail the physiology and biochemistry of the organisms that they raise has contributed much to making marine aquaculture a sophisticated industry. One event of the 1970s played a major role in the development of marine aquaculture, especially stock enhancement: the establishment of exclusive economic zones (EEZs). This event convinced the Japanese that they needed to become self-sufficient in seafood production, because they could no longer fish at will in the coastal waters of many nations and because they saw that an interruption of supplies on an international scale was a real possibility (Sproul & Tominaga 1992). The Japanese government responded by embarking on a massive research and hatchery-building campaign (Davy 1990, 1991). National and prefectural hatcheries now produce millions of fish, prawns and crabs for release into Japanese waters each year through the efforts of the national and prefectural Sea Farming Associations. As part of this effort, Japanese researchers have often led the way in marine aquaculture research and the practical applications of that research can be seen around the world. Investigations into the improvement of live feed, especially rotifers and Artemia, have certainly been a major contribution of the Japanese research programme. The last quarter of the twentieth century saw the explosion of marine aquaculture, both shrimp and fish. The aforementioned Japanese work on kuruma prawn led ultimately to the culture of numerous penaeid species around the world. Although postlarval shrimp for stocking into grow-out ponds were for years collected from the wild, the recent trend has been toward hatchery production, which is heavily dependent on microalgae and Artemia nauplii as larval feeds. Japanese research on red sea bream (Pagrus major) similarly led to the development of that species for commercial aquaculture in Japan as well as for stock enhancement. Research on other fish species in various areas of the world has led to large-scale aquaculture production of gilthead sea bream (Sparus aurata) and sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax) in the Mediterranean region, Asian sea bass (Lates calcarifer) in the Indo-West Pacific region, turbot in western Europe and olive flounder (Paralichthys olivaceus) in east Asia, among other species, all dependent on live feed in the hatchery stage. Although commercial aquaculture of these species has become well established, a variety of species is still undergoing commercial growing pains, for example, Atlantic halibut (Hippoglossus hippoglossus), several groupers (Epinephelus spp.) and cod; again, all require live feed in the hatchery. Indeed, of all the marine fish species in production or in the research and development pipeline, it seems that only the wolfish species (Anarhichas spp.) can be routinely fed formulated diets directly upon hatching. It appears likely that live feed will be required well into the future, not only for the established and nearly established species, but also for the plethora of new bream, sciaenid, flounder and sole species currently poised to make their debut appearances on the world’s commercial aquaculture stage. One of the more interesting controversies in the live feed area is the view that natural or cultured copepods are necessary for at least some species, as opposed to the view that rotifers and Artemia nauplii are quite sufficient. The former view seems to come from the
Status of Marine Aquaculture in Relation to Live Prey: Past, Present and Future
5
Nordic countries, particularly Norway and Denmark. A valuable result of this controversy has been the extensive biochemical analyses of natural zooplankton to determine whether particular nutritional ingredients are present there, but lacking in rotifers and Artemia. Van der Meeren and Naas (1997) provide an excellent review of larval fish rearing in large, enclosed systems primarily through the use of natural zooplankton. Norwegian scientists have pioneered this field of larviculture in ponds and natural inlets that have been closed off from the sea. The procedure requires either the filtration of incoming water or the use of rotenone to kill any predators. The enclosures can be fertilised to increase the phytoplankton productivity within, so that large populations of copepods are available on which the larvae can feed. Alternatively, larvae can be reared in a bag enclosure and provided with additional zooplankton that has been collected from the adjacent waters by the use of a plankton wheel (see van der Meeren & Naas 1997, p. 373). Cod have been raised successfully in Norwegian lagoons using these methods and halibut have been raised there in bags. A company in Denmark produces turbot larvae in large concrete tanks in which zooplankton ‘blooms’ are induced. In addition, at least one of the tanks is devoted exclusively to extensive copepod culture and used to feed the larval fish tanks if live prey levels therein fall too low. While larvae of all these species grow extremely well on the natural zooplankton, the production at such facilities is, almost by definition in the temperate zone, seasonal and not amenable to more intensive production methods in which juveniles must be produced year-round. However, some species produce larvae with mouths that are too small to ingest even rotifers at first feeding and an alternative live prey, such as copepod nauplii, would be necessary to culture such species. Furthermore, it is well known that the nutritional value of copepods is better than that of the convenient live feeds such as rotifers and brine shrimp. Thus, abundant rationale exists for research on the mass production of copepods. Research efforts into rearing copepods in intensive indoor systems have shown some promise, but commercial-scale production has not been achieved (see review by Støttrup 2000). Oddly, the use of live prey in hatcheries may be strongly related to one of the banes of the marine larviculturist, disease. As beneficial, indeed critical, as rotifers have been to the development of marine fish larviculture, it has been known for some time that rotifer cultures fed to a tank of fish can also carry pathogenic bacteria, such as Vibrio spp., that can lead to subsequent disease problems (Gatesoupe 1982). In a similar way, bacteria from Artemia hatching water, if the Artemia cysts have not been decapsulated or otherwise disinfected, can introduce to the fish tanks xenobiotics from wherever in the world the Artemia cysts originated. Disease has become a major consideration in hatcheries and the microbial ecology of hatchery tanks has become an area of intense research which one hopes will lead to more predictable hatchery outputs (Vadstein et al. 1993; Vadstein 1997). Live feeds thus have both good and bad aspects, and one challenge of the future is to minimize the bad aspects.
1.2 Marine Aquaculture Today and in the Future At the time of writing, the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) had just released its preliminary estimates for fisheries and aquaculture statistics from 1999, which indicate that world aquaculture production was 32.9 million tonnes (19.8 million t from freshwater, 13.1 million t from marine) (FAO 2000). Thus, aquaculture makes up
6
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
more than 35% of the total 92.6 million tonnes of fisheries products consumed by humans. Marine aquaculture has been growing by about 0.9 million tonnes per year in recent years, while the growth of freshwater aquaculture has been closer to 1.1 million tonnes per year. In 1998, the last year for which full statistics are available, aquaculture production of purely marine fish was 781,000 t, thus lagging behind crustaceans, mostly shrimp (1,564,000 t), and diadromous fish, mostly salmonids (1,909,000 t), and far behind freshwater fish, mostly carp (17,355,000 t) (FAO 2000). The major research endeavours in marine hatchery aquaculture today can be divided into three broad categories: improving reliability of production for existing species, development of culture methods for new species, and maximising the survival probability in the wild for hatchery-reared fish in stock enhancement programmes. Production reliability is being improved by several strategies. Selective breeding programmes for both fast growth and disease resistance should result in improved hatchery production in future years and those for improved flesh quality should ultimately yield a better product going to market. Improved management of microbial ecology in hatchery tanks through better husbandry, use of probiotics, etc., should also help production reliability. Development of vaccines, delivered by injection to older juveniles and by immersion to younger juveniles, should likewise aid in the minimisation of disease problems. Finally, the search for replacements for live feed proceeds apace as the world-wide availability of Artemia remains a question (see below) and the culture of algae and rotifers continues to be a labour-intensive requirement for marine hatcheries. The development of culture methods for new species tends to demonstrate the similarity of the requirements for raising different marine fish species, rather than differences between them. The research in this area generally involves the fine-tuning of widely accepted principles and procedures for application to the new species in question; if the culture of a species requires more than fine-tuning, its commercial development can be slowed or impaired (as in the case of Atlantic halibut). For example, if live feed other than rotifers and Artemia are required, the development of a new species is immediately hindered. The maximisation of survival of hatchery fish in the wild has been primarily the province of Japanese researchers (e.g. Tsukamoto et al. 1989; Yamashita et al. 1994), but their methods have more recently been adapted by others (e.g. Leber et al. 1997; Otterå et al. 1999). The basis of this area of research is the production of very high-quality juveniles from hatcheries (using only first-generation broodstock to maintain genetic integrity with the natural population), the identification of optimal release strategies (fish size, season, release site) and the use of conditioning methods, both in the hatchery and in the wild, to allow the fish to make the transition from hatchery to natural environment with maximum likelihood of survival. The fish are generally released as juveniles and therefore well adapted to formulated diets, but clearly the use of high-quality live feed is necessary earlier in the hatchery to produce the high-quality juveniles needed for release. As we proceed into the future, a few big questions dominate the landscape. The overriding one is ‘How do we make aquaculture sustainable?’ The environmental consequences of the explosion of marine aquaculture in the last quarter of the twentieth century have become a major international concern within the past decade. From shrimp farming in mangrove areas to organic enrichment from salmon net-pen culture, the ecological insults brought about by marine aquaculture are trumpeted to the world’s consumers by environmental groups. The global aquaculture industry is responding (Boyd 1999; SSFA & NAFC 2000) and there is cause for optimism that improved practices will be the norm in the future.
Status of Marine Aquaculture in Relation to Live Prey: Past, Present and Future
7
A second major question is ‘What will we feed aquacultured organisms in the future?’ This question applies both to hatchery-reared fish and crustaceans and to those in grow-out operations. At the hatchery level, the industry is currently undergoing a kind of crisis in Artemia cyst availability. This is due in large part to recent poor harvests from the traditionally productive Great Salt Lake, Utah, USA, along with increased regulation of harvests from those waters. The identification of new sources of Artemia cysts for harvest, for example in Asian countries that once belonged to the Soviet Union, allow some hope that this crisis will soon fade. Recalling that the last Artemia crisis in the mid-1970s led to the discovery of new geographical strains and focused research on Artemia cyst quality, one wonders what the current crisis will yield. A renaissance in research on formulated diets to replace Artemia is already underway (Kolkovsky et al. 1997; Yúfera et al. 1999) and one hopes that the results will be more commercialisable than those from the flurry of research on microdiets that arose from the last Artemia crisis. In a manner similar to the Artemia crises, periodic shortages of fish meal world-wide (usually due to climatic conditions off western South America) bring about intensive research into fish meal replacements. Recently, however, the aquaculture industry, as well as environmental groups, have questioned whether the projected growth of the industry over the next 30 years is possible in the light of fish meal availability even in the best of times (Naylor et al. 2000). It appears that partial or complete replacement of fish meal in the formulation of diets for some species will be necessary or desirable if the industry hopes to grow to the degree necessary. While this is a question primarily for grow-out producers, the ramifications will certainly be felt all the way back to the hatchery phase of the industry (Will we no longer grow species that require fish meal? Should we select for individuals that have minimal fish meal requirements?). One final major question concerns the role that biotechnology will play in aquaculture. Clearly, the biotechnology industry is already playing a role in products for the prevention, diagnosis and treatment of disease. Genome mapping is beginning for some of the major aquaculture species (M. Gomez-Chiarri, personal communication), but the question of whether genetically modified organisms (GMO) will be allowed in the marketplace is still a question for regulators. An even greater question is whether consumers will accept such products. It is likely that the answers to those questions will become apparent with GM products from terrestrial agriculture before aquaculture will address them in a major way.
1.3 The Status of Larviculture and Live Feed Usage It may be useful in this introductory chapter to describe the status of marine finfish and crustacean larviculture and live prey usage in different regions of the world, so that the reader receives a broad overview on a global scale. The review will be presented continent by continent, in alphabetical order, based on production figures supplied by FAO for the calendar year 1997 (FAO 1999) and various articles as cited.
1.3.1 Africa Africa’s marine finfish and crustacean production comes largely from countries bordering the Mediterranean. Egypt is the leading producer, with over 16,000 t of mullet production, but
8
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
these are grown from wild-captured fry, so no live feed is used (Wassef 2000). Egypt also produces more than 2000 t each of sea bass and seabream; the fry are mostly collected from the wild, but hatchery production is expanding, therefore requiring the use of rotifers and Artemia (Wassef 2000). Morocco and Tunisia also produce hundreds of tonnes each of sea bass and sea bream, so also require hatchery production using rotifers and Artemia (Romdhane 1992). Madagascar and the Seychelles Islands produce significant quantities of shrimp, Penaeus monodon, and South Africa has a small production of Penaeus indicus and P. japonicus, all of which require algae and Artemia as live feeds in the hatchery.
1.3.2 Asia Moving out of Africa and proceeding through Asia from west to east, one finds that Israel and Turkey, like Egypt, produce significant quantities of sea bass and sea bream, all apparently from hatchery production and requiring rotifers and Artemia. Iran and Saudi Arabia both report production of hundreds of tonnes of penaeid shrimp, requiring the use of algae and Artemia in hatcheries. A small amount of marine finfish culture is reported from Kuwait and Qatar. Penaeid shrimp culture dominates the mariculture of Pakistan (ca. 50 t), India (⬎50,000 t), Sri Lanka (ca. 5000 t), Bangladesh (⬎50,000 t), Myanmar (ca. 8 t) and Vietnam (ca. 80,000 t). Although some extensive culture using wild-caught shrimp still exists in India and Vietnam (Binh & Lin 1995; Shetty & Satyanarayana Rao 1996), the majority of the above production appears to rely on hatchery production using the normal methods with algae and Artemia (Shetty & Satyanarayana Rao 1996; Nien & Lin 1996). Thailand is the world’s largest shrimp producer (FAO 2000), based primarily on P. monodon, with production of ⬎200,000 t in 1997 (FAO 1999). Since this production is almost exclusively hatchery based, use of algae and Artemia is extremely heavy. Thailand also has significant production of Asian sea bass, L. calcarifer (⬎4000 t), grouper, Epinephelus spp. (ca. 800 t), and threadfin, Eleutheronema tetradactylum (ca. 400 t), requiring hatchery usage of rotifers and Artemia. The Philippines, Indonesia and Malaysia are somewhat similar to Thailand, having predominantly shrimp culture with P. monodon as the major species (although with substantial culture of Penaeus merguiensis and Metapenaeus spp. as well), but also exhibiting increasing production levels of finfish, L. calcarifer in the case of Indonesia and a variety of species (e.g. snappers, basses, rabbitfish, groupers) in the case of the Philippines and Malaysia. Thus, these countries also have significant hatchery production of both shrimp (using algae and Artemia) and fish (using rotifers and Artemia). It should be pointed out that both Indonesia and the Philippines are predominated by milkfish culture, but that industry still depends largely on capture of fry from the wild and therefore does not require live feed for larviculture. Singapore, Hong Kong and Taiwan are similar to each other in having their fish and crustacean mariculture activities dominated by finfish culture, with relatively little, if any, penaeid shrimp culture. They all culture Asian sea bass, groupers and snappers to greater or lesser degrees, and Hong Kong produces significant quantities (ca. 800 t) of silver bream, Rhabdosargus sarba, but Taiwan produces a wide variety of marine finfish, including over 4000 t of black sea bream, Acanthopagrus schlegeli, and ca. 400 t of red sea bream, Pagrus major, among many others. Culture of these high-value species is quite industrialised, with significant hatchery production relying on the standard formula of rotifers and Artemia.
Status of Marine Aquaculture in Relation to Live Prey: Past, Present and Future
9
The People’s Republic of China is the world’s largest aquaculture producer, responsible for a remarkable two-thirds of all aquaculture production globally. Their marine finfish and crustacean production is a fairly minor component of their total production, but still dwarfs that of most other countries. Shrimp production, mostly Penaeus chinensis, still exceeds 100,000 t per year despite problems with disease epidemics in the 1990s. Cen and Zhang (1998) state that all shrimp seed for production now comes from ‘a controlled environment’, rather than being collected from the wild. It is impossible to determine from FAO statistics the production of individual marine fish species in China, but Cen and Zhang (1998) report 145,000 t of production in 1995 (which had apparently increased to ⬎250,000 t by 1997), including mullets, breams, groupers, tilapia, Asian sea bass, puffer fish and olive flounder. Japan produces far more marine finfish than shrimp. Only a little more than 2000 t of kuruma prawn, P. japonicus, the species that began the industry, is still produced commercially in Japan. Japanese hatcheries, however, produce prodigious amounts of both finfish and shrimp for stock enhancement and sea ranching efforts. Oddly, yellowtail, Seriola quinqueradiata, the fish with the largest production in commercial aquaculture (nearly 140,000 t) is still dependent on wild-caught fry. Other major finfish produced commercially include red sea bream (⬎80,000 t), olive flounder (⬎8500 t), Tetraodontidae (nearly 6000 t) and jack mackerels, Trachurus spp. (⬎5700 t). These require hatchery production using the rotifer and Artemia techniques that the Japanese largely developed. Hatchery rearing with rotifers and Artemia is also necessary for the production of fry for the stock enhancement programmes. Major species with numbers of finfish fry released in 1995 are: P. olivaceus (23 million), P. major (19 million) and A. schlegeli (6 million) (Fushimi 1998). These impressive numbers are, however, surpassed by those for kuruma prawn, 305 million, which requires algae and Artemia in the hatcheries. Overall, Japan produced seed for stock enhancement of 80 species in a total of 284 facilities (such as national, prefectural and local hatcheries), with 11 species receiving more than 10 million seed and 33 species receiving at least 1 million seed (Fushimi 1998). This production included molluscs and echinoderms as well as fish and crustaceans, but clearly Japan is a major user of live feeds such as algae, rotifers and Artemia for marine finfish and crustacean culture in both commercial aquaculture and governmental stock enhancement efforts. Finally, South Korea has been rapidly expanding its marine finfish culture, primarily P. olivaceus (⬎26,000 t), while maintaining production of a few hundred tonnes of red sea bream and yellowtail and ⬎12,000 t of various other species. The flounder culture, as in Japan, is totally dependent on hatchery production of fingerlings, with both rotifers and Artemia required as live feed.
1.3.3 Europe Although minimal production of penaeid shrimp species is reported in Albania, Cyprus, France, Greece, Italy and Spain (requiring use of algae and Artemia), the production of marine finfish far outweighs that of marine crustaceans in Europe. In the Mediterranean countries plus Portugal, the dominant species are sea bass, with over 24,000 t, and sea bream, with nearly 30,000 t, reported for 1997 (FAO 1999). Greece is by far the leader, with over 15,000 t of sea bass and over 18,000 t of sea bream. Cyprus, France, Greece,
10
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Italy, Portugal and Spain all produce minor to significant quantities of other finfish species as well, for an additional total of between 4500 and 5000 t. All of this production is based on hatchery-raised fry. Sea bass can feed on Artemia as a first feed, whereas sea bream also require rotifers prior to feeding on Artemia. In northern Europe, the major species are cod and halibut and there is much greater usage of natural zooplankton in addition to, or in place of, rotifers and Artemia. Although research on culture of both species has been going on since the early 1970s, the actual commercial production is still rather small, but growing. Norway is the leader in cod production, with slightly more than 300 t of commercial production in 1997, but Norwegian scientists have also been engaged for a number of years in production of cod fingerlings for stock enhancement projects. Cod larvae are produced in tanks, ponds or blocked-off sections of fjords, and are fed natural zooplankton obtained from the same or similar enclosed bodies of water which have been fertilised to bring about phytoplankton blooms (Huse 1991). Halibut are produced in a variety of enclosed systems and can eat Artemia as first food, but Norwegian producers argue that natural zooplankton is also necessary during the larval stages for production of good-quality fry. Production of halibut has more recently been effected in Iceland, which has now become the leading producer of halibut juveniles, despite the fact that the halibut larvae in Iceland are raised without natural zooplankton (K. Pittman, personal communication).
1.3.4 North America Relatively little culture of marine finfish and crustaceans is reported from North America. Culture of cold-water finfish in Canada, using rotifers and Artemia as live feed for larvae, is still in the trial phases. In the USA, commercial production is reported for red drum (Sciaenops ocellata) and summer flounder (Paralichthys dentatus), both of which require rotifers and Artemia as prey in the hatchery. Oddly, FAO includes hybrid striped bass (Morone saxatilis ⫻ Morone chrysops) as a marine fish species in its statistics, even though the fish are reared in fresh water. The larvae of those bass are mostly raised in earthen ponds, which are fertilised in spring to induce blooms of phytoplankton and zooplankton before the introduction of the fish larvae (Harrell 1997). Since the early 1980s, hatchery production of a few species has been necessary for enhancement, restoration of stocks or mitigation of environmental impacts; striped bass (M. saxatilis), red drum (S. ocellata) and spotted sea trout (Cynoscion nebulosus) are the most noteworthy of these. In addition, the USA reported production of 1200 t of Litopenaeus vannamei in 1997, originating from intensive hatcheries with heavy use of algae and Artemia. Mexico has become a large producer of shrimp (L. vannamei), with over 17,000 t of production reported in 1997.
1.3.5 Oceania The majority of production here is penaeid shrimp. Australia reported nearly 1600 t of P. monodon production in 1997 and New Caledonia over 1100 t of Penaeus spp. All are from hatchery origin, requiring algae and Artemia. Other island nations (Fiji Islands,
Status of Marine Aquaculture in Relation to Live Prey: Past, Present and Future
11
French Polynesia, Guam and the Solomon Islands) all report minor production (⬍50 t each) of various penaeids. Australia also reported over 500 t of Asian sea bass production.
1.3.6 South America, including Central America and the Caribbean With the exception of Chile, the culture of marine finfish and crustaceans in this region is overwhelmingly dominated by penaeid shrimp. Ecuador is the clear leader, with 1997 production of over 120,000 t. Other countries producing between 2000 and 10,000 t include Brazil, Colombia, Costa Rica, Guatemala, Honduras, Nicaragua, Panama, Peru and Venezuela. Although wild seed is still used in some places, the trend is for increased reliance on hatchery production of postlarvae. The hatchery techniques are by now quite standard throughout the region, with algae and Artemia as the live feeds of choice, just as they are elsewhere in the world. Chile has been rapidly increasing its finfish aquaculture industry and is poised to become the world leader in salmon production, but it also is producing turbot in significant quantities for export to Europe. Hatchery rearing of these turbot depends on both rotifers and Artemia in the same way that they are used by the European turbot industry. To summarise this geographical review, hatchery production of penaeid shrimp postlarvae around the world depends on the use of live algae for the early stages and Artemia for the later stages. Usage of formulated diets to supplement and eventually replace Artemia is apparently increasing (see below), but live feed is still dominant at this point. For marine finfish, hatchery production of juveniles globally is normally accomplished just with Artemia, if the mouth gape is large enough at first feeding, or with rotifers and Artemia, if a smaller initial feed is required. It should be pointed out that algae is routinely used in marine fish culture of the so-called ‘green-water’ method, but it is still not clear to what degree the algae may be contributing directly to the nutrition of the larvae (Reitan et al. 1997). The use of natural zooplankton, or the use of cultured foods other than algae, rotifers or Artemia, is limited to a few places in the world, but it can be very important in those particular places.
1.4 Why is Live Feed Necessary? Fish biologists categorise larvae of two types: precocial and altricial. Precocial larvae are those that, when the yolk sac is exhausted, appear as mini-adults, exhibiting fully developed fins and a mature digestive system including a functional stomach. Such fish can ingest and digest formulated diets as a first food and are best exemplified by the salmon and trout raised extensively in hatcheries around the world without the benefit of live food. Altricial larvae are those that, when the yolk sac is exhausted, remain in a relatively undeveloped state. The digestive system is still rudimentary, lacking a stomach, and much of the protein digestion takes place in hindgut epithelial cells (Govoni et al. 1986). Such a digestive system seems (at this point) to be incapable of processing formulated diets in a manner that allows survival and growth of the larvae comparable to those fed on live feed. Altricial larvae therefore appear to require live feed, but there may be other reasons besides the digestibility question. Live feeds are able to swim in the water column and are thus constantly available to the
12
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
larvae. Formulated diets tend to aggregate on the water surface or, more commonly, sink quickly to the bottom, and are thus normally less available to the larvae than are the live feeds. In addition, the movement of live feed in the water is likely to stimulate larval feeding responses, since evolutionary history has probably adapted them to attack moving prey in nature. Formulated diets are generally capable of moving only in a downward direction, towards the bottom. Finally, live prey, with a thin exoskeleton and high water content, may be more palatable to the larvae once taken into the mouth, compared with the hard, dry formulated diets. This last point is rather critical, especially when considered in light of the fish larva’s absence of feeding appendages; any foods must enter the mouth whole (i.e. the larva’s mouth gape must be of sufficient size for particle ingestion to occur) and they are quickly either accepted or rejected on the basis of palatability. Jones et al. (1997a,b) reviewed the digestive physiology and nutrition of larval crustaceans and remarked that larval penaeid shrimp and late larval Macrobrachium can successfully use artificial diets. Crustacean larvae such as shrimp are qualitatively different from fish larvae. They are filter feeders as early larvae and by the time they can feed on live zooplankton, they possess not only feeding appendages with which to manipulate the prey organisms captured, but also a gut morphology and physiology with which to digest formulated diets more effectively (Jones et al. 1997b). Larval shrimp tanks tend to have greater water movement than do larval fish tanks, so that the formulated feeds are better able to stay in the water column and the shrimp can capture the diets with their feeding appendages rather than having to ingest them in a single gulp as larval fish must do. As a result, shrimp larvae have been shown to survive and grow well on formulated feeds (Jones et al. 1997a), whereas fish larvae do not (Holt 2000).
1.5 Problems and Prospects with Alternatives to Live Feed Pelleted diets became common in the salmonid industry during the middle of the twentieth century. As marine larviculture developed in the 1960s and 1970s, aquaculturists perceived that, even though encysted crustaceans such as Artemia provided a convenient live feed, they were still not as convenient as a formulated diet would be. In addition, the aforementioned Artemia crisis of the 1970s suggested that, if marine aquaculture were to achieve its potential rate of expansion, it needed to be unimpeded by a shortage of live feed. The natural tendency was to enlist the aid of fish nutritionists who specialised in pelleted diets for grow-out and to convince them somehow to make those pelleted diets small enough for fish or crustacean larvae to eat. The results were not encouraging (Girin 1979). Formulated feeds (often referred to as artificial diets, inert diets or prepared diets) could not provide nearly as good survival and growth of marine larvae as could live prey, although some studies indicated that partial substitution of Artemia with formulated feeds did yield survival and growth of larvae equal to that of larvae fed Artemia alone (e.g. Beck & Bengtson 1979). With the advent of microencapsulation technology, primarily for the pharmaceutical industry, came the hope that this technology might be applied to the development of successful microdiets for larviculture as well. Commercial microencapsulated larval feeds were developed in the 1980s and showed much greater success with shrimp larvae than
Status of Marine Aquaculture in Relation to Live Prey: Past, Present and Future
13
with fish larvae (Jones et al. 1993; Person Le Ruyet et al. 1993). In recent years, there has been a tendency to use formulated feeds in shrimp hatcheries to minimise usage of Artemia, but the usage in fish hatcheries appears to be less (although the exact numbers are not known). As argued previously (Bengtson 1993), breakthroughs in the development of microdiets for marine fish larvae require the multidisciplinary efforts of biochemists, nutritionists, chemical engineers and others all working with aquaculturists. These multidisciplinary teams have been forming and conducting research, but so far the ‘magic bullet’ remains elusive.
1.6 Conclusions Marine finfish and crustacean aquaculture has greatly expanded since the early 1980s, enabled in large part by the development of fairly standard hatchery protocols for live feed usage around the world. When new species are developed or new geographical regions opened up to aquaculture, it is a great benefit to have a standard ‘menu’ with a minimal number of well-established ‘entrees’ to use as live feed in the hatchery. The fact that development of new feed(s) is not required for the development of each new species has greatly facilitated aquaculture expansion. The major questions that remain for the future involve the availability and costs of feed for larvae: To what degree will Artemia availability and cost limit the expansion of marine aquaculture? To what degree can formulated diets replace live feeds generally, and at what cost? How can the costs of live feed culture (primarily algae, rotifers and alternative prey such as copepods) be minimised so that hatcheries can produce fingerlings/postlarvae at lower cost? The Kyoto conference identified larviculture as a bottleneck in aquaculture primarily on technical grounds. As many of the technical problems have been overcome, thanks to the tireless efforts of researchers around the world, there is now a need to reduce the economic bottleneck that larviculture still exerts on the commercial culture of many species.
1.7 References Bardach, J.E., Ryther, J.H. & McLarney, W.O. (1972) Aquaculture: The Farming and Husbandry of Freshwater and Marine Organisms. Wiley-Interscience, New York. Beck, A.D. & Bengtson, D.A. (1979) Evaluating effects of live and artificial diets on survival and growth of the marine atherinid fish Atlantic silverside, Menidia menidia. In: Finfish Nutrition and Fishfeed Technology. Vol. I (Ed. by J.E. Halver & K. Tiews), pp. 479–489. Heenemann, Berlin. Becker, E.W. (ed.) (1994) Microalgae: Biotechnology and Microbiology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Bengtson, D.A. (1993) A comprehensive program for the evaluation of artificial diets. J. World Aquacult. Soc., 24, 285–293. Binh, C.T. & Lin, C.K. (1995) Shrimp culture in Vietnam. World Aquacult., 26, 27–33. Bold, H.C. (1950) Problems in the cultivation of algae. In: The Culturing of Algae (Ed. by J. Brunel, G.W. Prescott & L.H. Tiffany), pp. 11–17. Charles F. Kettering Foundation, New York. Bookhout, C.G. & Costlow, J.B., Jr (1970) Nutritional effects of Artemia from different locations on larval development of crabs. Helgoländ. Meeresunters., 20, 435–442.
14
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Boyd, C.E. (1999) Codes of Practice for Responsible Shrimp Farming. Global Aquaculture Alliance, St. Louis, MO. Cen, F. & Zhang, D. (1998) Development and status of the aquaculture industry in the People’s Republic of China. World Aquacult., 29, 52–56. Coves, D., Dewavrin, G., Breuil, G. & Devauchelle, N. (1991) Culture of sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax L.). In: Handbook of Mariculture, Vol. II, Finfish Aquaculture (Ed. by J.P. McVey), pp. 3–20. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL. Davy, F.B. (1990) Mariculture in Japan. 1. Development of an industry. World Aquacult., 21, 36–47. Davy, F.B. (1991) Mariculture in Japan: current practices. World Aquacult., 22, 30–35. FAO (1999) Aquaculture production statistics, 1988–1997. FAO Fisheries Circular No. 815, Revision 11. Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations, Rome. FAO (2000) The state of world fisheries and aquaculture, 2000. http://www.fao.org/DOCREP/003/ X8002E/X8002E00.HTM Fushimi, H. (1998) Developing a stock enhancement program based on artificial seedlings: activities of the Japanese Sea-Farming Association (JASFA) in the last decade. In: Nutrition and Technical Development of Aquaculture: Proceedings of the Twenty-Sixth US–Japan Aquaculture Symposium (Ed. by W.H. Howell, B.J. Keller, J.P. Park, et al.), pp. 95–104. UJNR Technical Report No. 26. University of New Hampshire Sea Grant Program, Durham, NH. Gatesoupe, F.J. (1982) Nutritional and antibacterial treatments of live food organisms: the influence on survival, growth rate and weaning success of turbot (Scophthalmus maximus). Ann. Zootechn., 31, 353–368. Girin, M. (1979) Feeding problems and the technology of rearing marine fish larvae. In: Finfish Nutrition and Fishfeed Technology, Vol. I (Ed. by J.E. Halver & K. Tiews), pp. 359–366. Heenemann, Berlin. Govoni, J.J., Boehlert, G.W. & Watanabe, Y. (1986) The physiology of digestion in fish larvae. Environ. Biol. Fish., 16, 59–77. Gross, F. (1937) Notes on the culture of some marine plankton organisms. J. Mar. Biol. Assoc. UK, 21, 753–768. Guillard, R.R.L. & Ryther, J.H. (1962) Studies on marine planktonic diatoms. I. Cyclotella nana Hustedt and Detonula confervacae (Cleve) Gran. Can. J. Microbiol., 8, 229–239. Harrell, R.M. (ed.) (1997) Striped Bass and other Morone Culture. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Hirata, H. (1979) Rotifer culture in Japan. In: Cultivation of Fish Fry and its Live Food (Ed. by E. Styczynska-Jurewicz, T. Backiel, E. Jaspers, et al.), pp. 361–375. European Mariculture Society, Special Publication No. 4, Bredene. Holt, G.J. (2000) Symposium on Recent Advances in Larval Fish Nutrition. Aquacult. Nutr., 6, 141. Houde, E.D. (1972) Some recent advances and unsolved problems in the culture of marine fish larvae. Proc. World Maricult. Soc., 3, 83–112. Huse, I. (1991) Culturing of cod (Gadus morhua). In: Handbook of Mariculture, Vol. II, Finfish Aquaculture (Ed. by J.P. McVey), pp. 43–51. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL. Jones, A. (1972) Studies on egg development and larval rearing of turbot, Scophthalmus maximus L., and brill, Scophthalmus rhombus L. in the laboratory. J. Mar. Biol. Assoc. UK, 52, 965–986. Jones, D.A., Kamarudin, M.S. & LeVay, L. (1993) The potential for replacement of live feeds in larval culture. J. World Aquacult. Soc., 24, 199–210. Jones, D.A., Kumlu, M., Le Vay, L. & Fletcher, D.J. (1997a) The digestive physiology of herbivorous, omnivorous and carnivorous crustacean larvae: a review. Aquaculture, 155, 285–295. Jones, D.A., Yule, A.B. & Holland, D.L. (1997b) Larval nutrition. In: Crustacean Nutrition (Ed. by L.R. D’Abramo, D.E. Conklin & D.M. Akiyama), pp. 353–389. World Aquaculture Society, Baton Rouge, LA.
Status of Marine Aquaculture in Relation to Live Prey: Past, Present and Future
15
Kolkovsky, S., Koven, W. & Tandler, A. (1997) The mode of action of Artemia in enhancing utilization of microdiet by gilthead seabream Sparus aurata larvae. Aquaculture, 155, 193–205. Laurence, G.C., Smigielski, A.S., Halavik, T.A., et al. (1981) Implications of direct competition between larval cod (Gadus morhua) and haddock (Melanogrammus aeglefinus) in laboratory growth and survival studies at different food densities. Rapp. Procès-verbaux Réunions Cons. Int. Expl. Mer, 178, 304–311. Leber, K.M., Blankenship, H.L., Arce, S.M., et al. (1997) Influence of release season on size-dependent survival of cultured striped mullet, Mugil cephalus, in a Hawaiian estuary. Fish. Bull., 95, 267–279. Léger, P., Bengtson, D.A., Simpson, K.L., et al. (1986) The use and nutritional value of Artemia as a food source. Oceanogr. Mar. Biol. Annu. Rev., 24, 521–623. Liao, I.-C. (1991) Milkfish culture in Taiwan. In: Handbook of Mariculture, Vol. II, Finfish Aquaculture (Ed. by J.P. McVey), pp. 91–115. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL. Liao, I.-C. & Chien, Y.-H. (1994) Culture of kuruma prawn in Asia. World Aquacult., 25, 18–33. Loosanoff, V.L. & Davis, H.C. (1963) Rearing of bivalve mollusks. Adv. Mar. Biol., 1, 1–136. Lubzens, E., Marko, A. & Tietz, A. (1984) Lipid synthesis in the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. European Mariculture Society, Special Publication, 8, 201–209. Naylor, R.L., Goldburg, R.J., Primavera, J.H., et al. (2000) Effect of aquaculture on world fish supplies. Nature, 405, 1017–1024. Nien, N.M. & Lin, C.K. (1996) Penaeus monodon seed production in central Vietnam. World Aquacult., 27, 6–18. Otterå, H., Kristiansen, T.S., Svåsand, T., et al. (1999) Enhancement studies of Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua L.) in an exposed coastal area in western Norway. In: Stock Enhancement and Sea Ranching (Ed. by B.R. Howell, E. Moksness & T. Svåsand), pp. 257–276. Fishing News Books, Oxford. Pamplona, S. & Mateo, R. (1985) Milkfish farming in the Philippines. In: Reproduction and Culture of Milkfish (Ed. by C.S. Lee & I.-C. Liao), pp. 141–163. Oceanic Institute, Waimanalo, HI; Tungkang Marine Laboratory, Pingtung, Rebublic of China. Person Le Ruyet, J., Alexandre, J.C., Thébaud, L., et al. (1993) Marine fish larvae feeding: formulated diets or live prey? J. World Aquacult. Soc., 24, 211–224. Person-Le Ruyet, J., Baudin-Laurencin, F., Devauchelle, N., et al. (1991) Culture of turbot (Scophthalmus maximus). In: Handbook of Mariculture, Vol. II, Finfish Aquaculture (Ed. by J.P. McVey), pp. 21–41. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL. Persoone, G., Sorgeloos, P., Roels, O., et al. (eds) (1980) The Brine Shrimp Artemia, Vol. 3, Ecology, Culturing, Use in Aquaculture. Universa Press, Wetteren. Pillay, T.V.R. (1979) The state of aquaculture 1976. In: Advances in Aquaculture (Ed. by T.V.R. Pillay & W.A. Dill), pp. 1–10. Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations, Rome. Pringsheim, E.G. (1924) Algenkultur. Abderhalden’s Handbuch der biologische Arbeitmethoden, Vol. XI, No. 2, pp. 377–406. Provasoli, L., McLaughlin, J.J.A. & Droop, M. (1957) The development of artificial media for marine algae. Arch. Mikrobiol., 25, 392–428. Reitan, K.I., Rainuzzo, J.R., Øie, G., et al. (1997) A review of the nutritional effects of algae in marine fish larvae. Aquaculture, 155, 207–221. Rognerud, C. (1887) Hatching of cod in Norway. Bull. US Fish Commission, 7, 113–119. Rollefsen, G. (1939) Artificial rearing of fry of seawater fish – preliminary communication. Rapp. Procès-verbaux Réunions Cons. Perm. Int. Explor. Mer, 109, 133. Romdhane, M.S. (1992) Aquaculture in Tunisia. World Aquacult., 23, 27–30. Schreiber, E. (1927) Die Reinkultur von marinen Phytoplankton und deren Bedeutung für die Erforschung der Produktionsfähigkeit des Meerwassers. Meeresunters. Helgoland., N.F., 10, 1–34.
16
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Seale, A. (1933) Brine shrimp (Artemia) as a satisfactory food for fishes. Trans. Am. Fish. Soc., 63, 129–130. Shelbourne, J.E. (1964) The artificial propagation of marine fish. Adv. Mar. Biol., 2, 1–83. Shetland Salmon Farmer’s Association & North Atlantic Fisheries College (2000) Code of Best Practice for Shetland Salmon Farming. SSFA Code of Best Practice and Appendices, March 2000, Version 1.0. North Atlantic Fisheries College Publication. Shetty, H.P.C. & Satyanarayana Rao, G.P. (1996) Aquaculture in India. World Aquacult., 27, 20–24. Sproul, J.T. & Tominaga, O. (1992) An economic review of the Japanese flounder stock enhancement project in Ishikari Bay, Hokkaido. Bull. Mar. Sci., 50, 75–88. Stickney, R.R. (1996) Aquaculture in the United States: A Historical Survey. John Wiley & Sons, New York. Støttrup, J. (2000) The elusive copepods: their production and suitability in marine aquaculture. Aquacult. Res., 31, 703–711. Tsukamoto, K., Kuwada, H., Hirokawa, J., et al. (1989) Size-dependent mortality of red sea bream, Pagrus major, juveniles released with fluorescent otolith tags in News Bay, Japan. J. Fish Biol., 35A, 59–69. Vadstein, O. (1997) The use of immunostimulation in marine larviculture: possibilities and challenges. Aquaculture, 155, 401–417. Vadstein, O., Øie, G., Olsen, Y., et al. (1993) A strategy to obtain microbial control during larval development of marine fish. In: Fish Farming Technology (Ed. by H. Reinertsen, L.A. Dahle, L. Jørgensen, et al.), pp. 69–75. A.A. Balkema, Rotterdam. Van der Meeren, T. and Naas, K.E. (1997) Development of rearing techniques using large enclosed ecosystems in the mass production of marine fish fry. Rev. Fish. Sci., 5, 367–390. Walne, P.R. (1974) Culture of Bivalve Mollusks: 50 Years Experience at Conwy. Fishing News Books, Farnham. Wassef, E.A. (2000) Status of aquaculture in Egypt. World Aquacult., 31, 29–32, 60–61. Watanabe, T., Arakawa, T., Kitajima, C., et al. (1978) Nutritional quality of living feed from the viewpoint of essential fatty acids for fish. Bull. Jpn. Soc. Scient. Fish., 44, 1223–1227. Wells, W.F. (1920) Artificial propagation of oysters. Trans. Am. Fish. Soc., 50, 301–306. Wells, W.F. (1927) Report of the experimental shellfish station. Report NY State Conserv. Dept, 16, 1–22. Yamashita, Y., Nagahora, S., Yamada, H., et al. (1994) Effects of release size on survival and growth of Japanese flounder Paralichthys olivaceus in coastal waters off Iwate Prefecture, northeastern Japan. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser., 105, 269–276. Yúfera, M., Pascual, E. & Fernández, C. (1999) A highly efficient microencapsulated food for the rearing of early larvae of marine fish. Aquaculture, 177, 249–256.
Chapter 2
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers Esther Lubzens and Odi Zmora
2.1 Introduction For almost four decades, rotifers have been used as food organisms for cultured marine fish larvae. A continuous, stable and reliable supply of nutritionally adequate rotifers is the key to the flourishing culture of marine finfish in various parts of the world. Major fish species produced today using rotifers during the early developmental stages include yellowtail (Seriola quinqueradiata), red sea bream (Pagrus major), Asian sea bass (Lates calcarifer), turbot (Scophthalmus maximus), mullet (Mugil cephalus), pufferfish (Fugo rubripes), gilthead sea bream (Sparus aurata) and the European sea bass (Dicentrarchus labrax) (FAO 1998). Rotifers are also used as food for culturing penaeid shrimp (Samocha et al. 1989) and crabs (Keenan & Blackshaw 1999). Rotifers serve as a ‘living capsule’, providing the nutrients required by the cultured marine fish larvae for proper development. The incidental choice of rotifers (Ito 1960; see reviews by Hirata 1980; Nagata & Hirata 1986; Hagiwara et al. 2001) as food for early developmental stages of small-mouthed larvae has, therefore, been proven a success. Rotifers are not, in most cases, the natural food of marine fish larvae, which have at their disposal a wide range of food organisms in their natural habitats. In culture, fish larvae are fed on two or three organisms during the initial 10–30 days of exogenous feeding. These include rotifers of the species Brachionus rotundiformis and/or Brachionus plicatilis and brine shrimp (Artemia) nauplii. Brachionus rotundiformis is also known as the S-type (small-type) rotifer and B. plicatilis as the L-type (large-type) rotifer (Fig. 2.1). Artemia cysts are obtained mostly from natural sources, while rotifers must be cultured in hatcheries, as there is no other large supply of them. Copepods are a major component of the natural diet of marine fish larvae. Attempts to culture copepods have met with some success in recent years (Støttrup & Norsker 1997; Støttrup 2000; Hagiwara et al. 2001; Payne & Rippingale 2001). However, given the relative ease and low cost of culturing rotifers in high densities, it is unlikely that copepod cultures will replace rotifers as an economically viable alternative in the near future. Copepods do have some advantages over rotifers, including the wide range of body sizes both within and between species. In particular, the early stage nauplii and copepodites can be extremely useful as initial prey for species that have very small larvae with small mouth gape at first feeding (e.g. the grouper, Epinephelus sp.). The specific
18
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Fig. 2.1 Rotifers used in raising marine fish larvae: Brachionus rotundiformis (left) and B. plicatilis (right). (Photograph: Irena Pekarsky.) Table 2.1 A comparison between cultured rotifers (Brachionus plicatilis and Brachionus rotundiformis) and natural zooplankton harvested in the wild as food for early developmental stages of marine fish larvae. Characteristic
Rotifers
Natural zooplankton
Size
⬇90–350 m, depending on species and developmental stage
Variable but includes organisms less than ⬃60 m in size
Body shape
Round and flat, without spines
Variable with many spiny species
Distribution in water column and swimming
Usually planktonic and relatively slow moving
Variable with some benthic species and fast-moving species
Density
Tolerance of high densities
Some species (e.g. copepods) with low tolerance to high densities
Salinity
Tolerance to a wide range of salinities
Species-specific and variable tolerance
Supply
Manipulated and regulated; reliable, depending on culture facilities
Unpredictable; varies daily between locations
Nutritional quality
Can be manipulated and regulated
High but unpredictable and variable
Digestibility
Lorica and eggs not digested
Variable
Transmission of parasites and predators of fish larvae
Minimal
Realistic
Transmission of therapeutic agents and probiotics
Feasible
Doubtful or unlikely
advantages of using rotifers as food for early stages of development of marine fish larvae, as opposed to zooplankton, are summarised in Table 2.1. Rotifers (B. plicatilis) were found important in raising early developmental stages of cultured crustaceans, such as the mud crab (Scylla serrata) up to zoea 5 stage (Baylon &
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
19
Failama 1999; Keenan & Blackshaw 1999; Li et al. 1999; Mann et al. 1999; Quinitio et al. 1999) or the marine shrimp (Penaeus semisulcatus) (Samocha et al. 1989). Raising freshwater Brachionus calyciflorus in culture systems has been examined for freshwater, edible and ornamental fish species (De Luca et al. 1990; Awïass 1991; Awaïss et al. 1992a,b; Rico-Martinez & Dodson 1992; Ludwig 1994; Awaïss & Kestemont 1997a,b; Lim & Wong 1997; Isik et al. 1999; Hagiwara et al. 2001). The culture of freshwater rotifer species has not yet had the same impact on aquaculture as that of the marine species, although B. plicatilis rotifers were found to be helpful in culturing freshwater ornamental carp larvae (Lubzens et al. 1987). Huge numbers of rotifers, easily reaching several billions, may be required each day for raising marine fish larvae in commercial hatcheries (Lubzens et al. 1997, 2001). The amount needed ranges from 20,000 to 100,000 rotifers per fish larva during the 20–30 days of culture (Kafuku & Ikenoue 1983; Lubzens et al. 2001). The nutritional quality of the rotifers must be assured and controlled by the use of well-established and tested culture and enrichment methods. Furthermore, the rotifer culturist must be aware of and able to deal with occasional unpredicted events that can lead to low production. These may result from inadequate seawater supply, pollution of the culture water with waste products, quality and quantity of food provided to the rotifers, disease or insufficient biological information. The methods developed for providing an adequate supply of rotifers to a variety of small-mouthed fish larvae rely on extensive studies into their biology, feeding, reproductive strategies, genetics, physiology and biochemistry. This basic information provides the culturists with the tools for adapting rotifers for mass culture techniques and in solving problems arising during their culture. Several reviews have been published on rotifer morphology, biology, taxonomy and culture, and some of them have focused on production of rotifers as live food in aquaculture (e.g. Ruttner-Kolisko 1974; Nagata & Hirata 1986; Lubzens 1987; Fukusho 1989a,b; Lubzens et al. 1989, 2001; Fulks & Main 1991; Clément & Wurdak 1991; Wallace & Snell 1991; Nogrady et al. 1993; Hagiwara et al. 1997, 2001). The present review attempts to provide information on euryhaline rotifers, with a specific emphasis on the genus Brachionus (Family Brachionidae; Order Monogononta) and equip the newcomer to this field with the basic concepts and tools for using rotifers as food for cultured fish larvae. Assistance in evaluating the state of cultures is provided in Appendix I.
2.2 Biology and Morphological Characteristics of Rotifers 2.2.1 General biology The phylum Rotifera (previously known as the Rotatoria; see Ricci 1983) consists of a relatively small group of minute, unsegmented, pseudocoelomate, aquatic invertebrates with bilateral symmetry. Most rotifers are free-crawling or swimming, but sedentary and colonial forms are also known (Ruttner-Kolisko 1974; Pontin 1978; Wallace & Snell 1991; Nogrady et al. 1993). About 2000 species populate freshwater lakes and ponds, but several species are known from brackish or marine waters and from mosses and lichens in moist terrestrial habitats. Although Rotifera is a small phylum, rotifers are extremely important in the freshwater environment, contributing up to 30% of the total plankton biomass. By
20
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
consuming bacteria and/or algae, they form the link between primary producers and secondary consumers or predators such as fish and insect larvae. Rotifers have several distinctive features (Fig. 2.2). They are characterised by an anterior, apical, ciliated corona (‘crown’), functional in swimming and feeding. The presence of the corona distinguishes rotifers from all other metazoans, and the metachronal movements of the cilia in the anterior rotating apparatus, giving the illusion of two turning wheels, is one of the distinctive characteristics of organisms belonging to this group. Their body shape ranges from saccate to cylindrical and typically four regions can be distinguished: a head bearing the corona, a neck of variable length, a body and a foot, typically possessing two toes (but the number may range from none to four) that usually retract during swimming. The pedal glands found in the foot secrete a sticky cement material for temporary attachment of rotifers to the substratum. The body of rotifers is covered by an extracellular cuticle that is a gelatinous secretion of the underlying integument and has no skeletal function (Clément & Wurdak 1991). A dense intracytoplasmic lamina located within the syncytial integument forms the peripheral skeleton that serves for muscle attachment. Species in which extensive regions of the integument are thickened are known as loricated forms (including Brachionidae) and others with a thin, more flexible integument are known as illoricated. The thickness of the body wall has little taxonomic significance, as loricated and illoricated forms may be found within one genus. Several regions with thinner intracytoplasmic lamina provide flexibility in loricated forms. These regions include the corona, foot and articulations between movable spines and the body.
Fig. 2.2 Morphology and inner organisation of a Brachionus sp. female (left) and male (right). a, dorsal antenna; b, bladder; bt, buccal tube; c, corona; e, eye; eg, egg; f, foot; fg, foot gland; g, central ganglion; la, lateral antenna; m, mastax; mu, muscle; o, oesophagous; ov, ovary; p, prostate; pe, penis; s, sensory cirri; sg, stomach gland; st, stomach; t, toe; te, testis; tr, trophy; v, vas deferens. (From Koste & Shiel 1987. Reproduced from Invertebrate Taxonomy, Volume 7 with permission of CSIRO Publishing.)
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
21
Rotifers possess an internal fluid-filled space known as a pseudocoelom that is bound externally by the integument and internally by the epithelial cells of the various organs (digestive, protonephridial and reproductive). There are no respiratory or circulatory systems in rotifers, and the pseudocoelom internal fluid, bathing the internal organs, is equivalent to the circulatory system. Its composition is regulated by the protonephridia and it is replenished by the digestive tract. Rotifers are also characterised by the syncytial structure of their body parts. Cell membranes in tissues disappear after embryonic development, forming multinucleated or syncytial tissues. All individuals of a species have a consistent number of nuclei in each organ. This situation, known as eutely, is also found in nematodes. The total number of nuclei, ranging from 900 to 1000, is fixed for life during embryonic development, indicating a limited capacity for repairing damage.
2.2.2 Taxonomy Taxonomic classification of rotifers is under constant review (Garey et al. 1998; Melone et al. 1998; Segers 1998). Traditionally, the phylum is divided into two superclasses: the Seisona and Eurotatoria, the latter consisting of two classes: the Bdelloidea with two gonads, and the Monogononta with one gonad (Melone et al. 1998). The Monogononta contain over 90% of all rotifer species, with more than 1600 species, in about 95 genera of benthic, free-swimming and sessile forms. All are assumed to be dioecious with one gonad. Females possess one ovary with a vitellarium and males, if they occur, are structurally reduced with a vestigial gut. Males are present for brief periods (a few days or weeks). The family of Brachionidae comprises six genera of common rotifers, including Brachionus with about 25 species of littoral and planktonic rotifers. 2.2.2.1 The genus Brachionus The distinctive morphological characteristics of the genus Brachionus are an oval body that is flattened dorsoventrally, and a lorica with six spines on the dorsal anterior margin (Fig. 2.2; see Section 2.2.3). The foot is very mobile, annulated, fully retractable into the lorica and relatively long. The corona has five distinct lobes with long, sensory bristles between them. A cerebral eye is always present. The mastax (see below) is large with malleate trophi. The oesophagous is thin-walled and the cellular stomach is clearly separate from the intestine. There are two gastric glands of varying shape and the anus is terminal. There are four flame cells along the protonephridial duct on each side of the body connecting with a large urinary bladder. The vitellarium carries several cells (see below) and eggs are carried at the foot opening. One female can carry one to three amictic eggs or several male eggs, and each egg is individually attached to the female body. Usually, a female carries only one or, rarely, two resting eggs and these resting eggs are easily distinguished from other eggs by their darker orange–brown colour and a space or vacuole between the two egg membranes (see below). The family Brachionidae comprises a large number of species, most of them inhabiting freshwater. A few species are known from the marine environment and several from euryhaline waters. Two of these (B. plicatilis and B. rotundiformis; Fig. 2.1) are being used extensively in mass cultures and serve as food for early developmental stages of marine fish larvae. In the early days of devising methods for mass culture of rotifers, the cultured species was identi-
22
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Fig. 2.3 The lorica of Brachionus plicatilis (left) and B. rotundiformis (right) showing the anterior spines. (Photograph: Irena Pekarsky.)
fied as B. plicatilis showing two morphotypes known as L-type (large type) and S-type (small type). Accumulating data showing that these morphotypes do not differ in size and shape alone led to taxonomic identification as two species, B. plicatilis and B. rotundiformis (Segers 1995). The lorica of female B. plicatilis is significantly larger than that of B. rotundiformis and the anterior spines on the lorica of B. plicatilis are obtuse, in contrast to the pointed spines of B. rotundiformis (Hagiwara et al. 1995b; Fig. 2.3). Chromosome number (Rumengan et al. 1991), allozyme profiles (Fu et al. 1991a,b), reproductive isolation (Fu et al. 1993; Hagiwara et al. 1995b; Rico-Martinez & Snell 1995; Gomez & Serra 1995) and microsatellites (Gomez et al. 1998; Gomez & Carvalho 2000; Boehm et al. 2000) suggest genetic differences between these two species. However, recent data indicate that B. rotundiformis is composed of two genotypes, B. rotundiformis SM and B. rotundiformis SS, with no evidence of gene flow between them (Serra et al. 1998; Fig. 2.4). These studies show that B. plicatilis is a euryhaline, low-temperature group, B. rotundiformis SM is adapted to high temperatures and low salinities and B. rotundiformis SS is adapted to high-temperature and highsalinity conditions. In addition, the groups show different mictic responses to density, salinity and temperature, and mating experiments showed that most copulations occurred within a group and no hybrids could be obtained in laboratory cross-mating experiments. There are also some differences in the way rotifers carry their resting eggs. In B. plicatilis and B. rotundiformis SS, resting eggs are carried outside the female lorica in the same way as amictic or male eggs, while in B. rotundiformis SM they are retained within the body of the female (Serra et al. 1998). Production of resting eggs, their preservation and hatching are further discussed in later sections in this chapter. Caution is advised when considering older publica-
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
23
Fig. 2.4 Differences between Brachionus plicatilis SS (SS), B. rotundiformis SM (SM) and B. plicatilis (L). Average body length (top number) and width (lower number) and their standard deviations (in parentheses) are shown below each rotifer. (From: M. Serra, A. Gomez & M.J. Carmona, 1998. Reproduced from Hydrobiologica 387/388, 373–384. With kind permission of Kluwer Academic Publishers.)
tions, as there is evidence of confusion of B. plicatilis and B. rotundiformis. It may be assumed that B. rotundiformis is the main cultured species in tropical areas.
2.2.3 Morphology and physiology The anterior end, or ‘head’, carries the corona, which is comprised in Brachionus females of two concentric ciliary crowns; the outer one is the cingulum, which is responsible for swimming and the inner one, the pseudotrochus, is composed of cilia organised into membranelles or cirri (Clément & Wurdak 1991). The pseudotrochus sweeps the food particles towards the mouth. The head also carries the ventral mouth opening and several sensory organs, including antennae, cirri and light-sensitive ocelli (Fig. 2.2). 2.2.3.1 Feeding Food is captured by the corona, enters the mouth opening and passes through the buccal tube to the pharynx. The buccal tube is equipped with a variety of sensory receptors and ends in the buccal velum, a supple myelin-like structure whose function is to prevent rejection of food that has reached the pharynx. The longitudinal and circular muscle sheaths surrounding the buccal tube can, however, evoke rejection of the ingested food at this level. The pharynx houses the muscular mastax, where the translucent hard trophi break down
24
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
the food, probably with the aid of enzymes produced by ‘salivary glands’. The trophi, composed of hard parts, are of extreme taxonomic importance for the characterisation of rotifer families, genera or even species. The food leaving the mastax enters the cuticular region of the oesophagus and passes through the ciliary region before entering the stomach. Large syncytial gastric glands empty into the alimentary tract at the junction between the ciliary oesophagous and the stomach and their secretion aids in the extracellular digestion occurring within the stomach lumen. The stomach leads into the intestine and then into a cloaca, which voids fluid from the bladder or paired protonephridia, and eggs from the oviduct. Sensory receptors are located all along the alimentary canal, with a prominent sensory organ between the trophi on the mastax floor and sensory receptors on the mastax ceiling. The sensory receptors that participate in feeding behaviour are connected either to the brain or to the mastax ganglion, and these centres regulate the movement of circular and longitudinal muscles surrounding the buccal cavity and mastax, respectively (Clément & Wurdak 1991). The most common method of feeding in planktonic brachionid rotifers is by filter feeding. This type of feeding, also described as ‘microphagus feeding’ (Pourroit 1977; Clément et al. 1983), is found in rotifers having a developed ciliary corona and a crushing type of mastax. The type of food consumed, particularly its size, is directly dependent on the size and form of the ciliary apparatus and of the mastax. The rotational movement of the cilia directs a water current containing food particles towards the mouth and those that are suitable are swallowed, indicating a sensory mechanism regulating food selection. Brachionus plicatilis seems to have few food preferences and can reproduce when fed with various species of algae, yeast or bacteria (Clément et al. 1983; Hansen et al. 1997). Three sites were suggested to regulate the intake of food in B. calyciflorus and these are probably also operating in B. plicatilis (Clément et al. 1983). First, the anterior ciliated apparatus composed of tactile and/or chemical receptors may regulate the muscles governing the position of the pseudotrochus cilia in such a way that they would form a screen to keep certain particles from entering the mouth. Secondly, chemoreceptors in the buccal tube may activate the longitudinal and circular muscles. The contraction of these muscles will result in rejection of food particles if they are deemed unsuitable. Finally, the ground particles come into contact with sensory receptors in the mastax, and the chemical or tactile recognition at this site will determine the continuation or cessation of mastax grinding movements. If the food is found to be unsuitable, the sensory receptors will evoke expulsion of the food from the buccal canal. Several studies indicate that food selectivity by suspension feeders such as rotifers is mainly based on prey size (Rothhaupt 1990a,b; Hansen et al. 1997). However, selectivity was reported in several species and depended on cell surface, physiological condition of algal cells and algal motility (summarised in Hansen et al. 1997). The prey size spectrum for B. plicatilis ranges from approximately 1.4 to 4838 m3, or 1.4 to 21 m of equivalent spherical diameter (ESD), with changes in efficiency with different particle size. Optimal grazing was reported on Tetraselmis suecica, with an ESD of 8.3 m. The range covers sizes from bacteria to dinoflagellates (Hansen et al. 1997) and the largest particle size caught by rotifers is dependent on its body size (Hino & Hirano 1980). Rotifers were described as mechanical grazers as they were found to graze non-selectively when offered two algal species with different cell size. Their ingestion rates reflected the exact proportion of the volume of each species of algae (Hansen et al. 1997).
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
25
Three models have been proposed to describe the effect of food particle concentration on feeding rate of filter-feeding zooplankton (Rothhaupt 1990b). In the rectilinear model, clearance rates increase up to a certain food concentration that is termed the incipient limiting level (ILL). This model represents a feeding mode where numerous small particles can be collected simultaneously, without the interference of the particles with the feeding process until the ILL is reached. Maximal ingestion rates are probably determined by the gut packing and the rate of gut evacuation and, therefore, will be reached at lower food concentration with larger food items. Above the ILL, ingestion rates remain constant. The curvilinear model proposes continuously decreasing clearance rates with increasing food concentration, and is expressed by Michaelis–Menten (Michaelis & Menten 1913) or Ivlev (1960) equations. This model indicates a typical increasing interference with the feeding process and is observed with larger than optimal food particle size. Interference could be indicated by mechanical interference caused by, for example, the increased handling time necessary for processing large prey items, during which there is an interruption in collection of new particles. In this model there is a gradual increase in ingestion rates until a plateau is reached. The filtration or clearance rate is high at low food particle concentrations and declines in a curvilinear manner with the increase in food concentration. Finally, in the sigmoid model, clearance or filtration rates increase sigmoidally with increasing food particle concentration until a maximal value is reached, and then they decrease with any further increase in food particle concentration. The ingestion rate remains constant after the peak value has been reached by the clearance rates. Thus, the filtration rate is adjusted to the food concentration and maintains a full gut at low energy expenditure. Studies have indicated curvilinear (Hansen et al. 1997) or sigmoid (Navarro 1999) feeding models for B. plicatilis and a curvilinear feeding model (but not significantly different from the sigmoid model) for B. rotundiformis (Navarro 1999). In experiments using Nannochloropsis oculata as food for B. plicatilis, the ILL was twice that of B. rotundiformis (approximately 2 ⫻ 106 and 1 ⫻ 106 cells ml⫺1, respectively). Additional ILL values for B. plicatilis were obtained for other food sources; 4–8 ⫻ 106 cells ml⫺1 for feeding with Monochrysis (now Pavlova) lutheri and Saccharomyces cerevisae (Lebedeva & Orlenko 1995), 2.1 ⫻ 106 cells ml⫺1 with Chlorella sp. (probably known today as Nannochloropsis sp.; Hirayama & Ogawa 1972), 1.5 ⫻ 106 cells ml⫺1 with Chlamydomonas and 0.1 ⫻ 106 cells ml⫺1 (Chotiyaputta & Hirayama 1978). A large range (0.64–10 l h⫺1 per individual) in filtration rates was found for B. plicatilis, depending on the species of algae used as food and on the food density (Hirayama 1990). When fed with N. oculata, B. plicatilis rotifers ingested between 60 and 90% of their dry weight per day, while B. rotundiformis consumed 160% of their dry weight per day (Navarro 1999), reflecting their different body size. There were no significant differences for values obtained for filtration and ingestion rates between live (N. oculata) and freeze-dried algae in these experiments (Navarro 1999). 2.2.3.2 Digestion The crushed food particles pass through the oesophagous into the stomach and intestine. The stomach is sometimes pigmented by recently ingested food and the colour depends on the type of consumed food. Gastric glands in the anterior part of the stomach may aid in extracellular digestion. Several digestive enzymes have been reported from B. plicatilis,
26
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
including proteases (Hara et al. 1984a,b; Kuhle & Kleinow 1985; Wethmar & Kleinow 1993), ␣-amylase, laminarinase, cellulase, cellobiohydrolase, lysozyme and -1,3-glucanase (Kuhle & Kleinow 1985, 1989, 1990; Hara et al. 1997). The membrane lining the stomach lumen shows invagination of vesicles that coalesce into vacuoles and large oil droplets towards the interior, probably indicating absorption of the digested food (Clément & Wurdak 1991). 2.2.3.3 Body fluids and excretion As mentioned before, rotifers do not have a respiratory system or a circulatory system and body fluids are located in the pseudocoelom. Like other pseudocoelomates, rotifers exchange gases and dispose of nitrogenous wastes by diffusion through their body surface. Muscular contraction of the body aids in circulating the body fluid. Osmoregulation, at least in freshwater species, is carried out by protonephridia. The protenephridial system comprises two lateral parallel tubules with several fan-shaped flame cells opening into them. The flame cells are equipped with cilia that pump the body fluids and pass them into the tubules, where they are drained into the urinary bladder. The bladder empties the accumulated fluids, by contraction, into the cloaca. Brachionus plicatilis was found to adjust the body fluid osmolarity to that of the external concentrations ranging from 32 to 957 mosmol l⫺1, indicating that they are essentially osmoconformers. However, at an external concentration of 32 mosmol l⫺1, the body fluid osmolarity was 59 mosmol l⫺1, demonstrating that these rotifers are unable to tolerate low external concentrations (Epp & Winston 1977). 2.2.3.4 Movement The body fluids function as a hydrostatic skeleton, interacting with the muscular system. The muscular system consists of striated and smooth muscles occurring in small longitudinal and circular bands. They are inserted onto the integument, or join the integument and internal organs. In loricate species such as the Brachionidea, the contraction of muscles inserted on the integument and the resistance of the body fluids facilitate the movement of the animal in the water, with longitudinal muscles shortening and circular bands elongating the shape of the body. Contraction of longitudinal muscles that are inserted on the corona or foot facilitate their retraction into the lorica under unfavourable conditions or during swimming. Muscles inserted in the viscera, or forming part of the viscera, facilitate the contraction of organs such as the digestive gland, vitellarium and urinary bladder. 2.2.3.5 Nervous system and sensory organs The co-ordination of all of these functions is under the regulation of a nervous system that consists of a single large cerebral ganglion (‘brain’) that is located in the anterior part of the body, dorsally below the corona. Paired, ventral neurons proceed from the brain along the length of the body into the foot, branching off to various organs. There are a few ganglia located on the mastax and foot and at the exit points for lateral nerves. The sensory organs can be divided into mechanoreceptors, chemoreceptors and photoreceptors. Mechanoreceptor bristles are located on the corona and on antennae distributed on various regions of the
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
27
integument, including the foot region. The corona also carries chemoreceptors that function in accepting or rejecting food particles. These also function in copulation in males, by detecting the female’s pheromone (see Section 2.2.4.1). Several species possess one or more pigmented photoreceptive eyespots. A red eyespot is very distinctive in the anterior part of Brachionus species that have been fed on algae.
2.2.4 Reproduction The reproductive organs of female Monogononts are, as the name implies, composed of a single gonad. The gonad consists of the syncytial ovary that contains the ovocytes, the yolkproducing syncytial vitellarium and the follicular layer that surrounds the ovary and vitellarium and forms an oviduct leading to the cloaca. The total number of ovocytes is present at birth. Rotifers are generally oviparous, with embryos developing outside the maternal body. 2.2.4.1 Asexual and sexual reproduction Nearly all rotifers seen in nature are females. Males occur only for short periods and in many species have never been observed. During favourable conditions, the population increases through diploid parthenogenesis, whereby diploid females produce diploid eggs known as amictic eggs. Monogonont species (e.g. B. plicatilis; Fig. 2.5) can reproduce either by parthenogenesis or through sexual reproduction. In general, rotifers of this group reproduce by cyclic parthenogenesis, meaning that asexual reproduction is prevalent, but under certain circumstances sexual reproduction may occur. Females are always diploid and males, when they appear, are haploid and very much reduced in size compared with females. Diploid females can either be amictic or mictic and morphologically they are indistinguishable. Amictic females produce parthenogenetically diploid eggs that develop mitotically into females, while mictic females produce, parthenogenetically, haploid eggs via meiosis. Thus, it is easy to obtain genetic clones from cultures originating from one amictic female. If a mictic female does not mate and is not fertilised, the haploid eggs form into males, but a mated mictic female that is fertilised will form diploid resting eggs (subitaneous eggs or cysts). Parthenogenically formed eggs (diploid or haploid eggs) will develop immediately into embryos and hatch. Resting eggs will hatch under appropriate conditions into amictic females, after a dormant period (Hagiwara 1996; Lubzens et al. 2001). Thus, amictic females produce parthenogenically diploid amictic eggs and mictic females produce parthenogenically haploid male eggs or sexually diploid resting eggs that hatch into diploid amictic females. In some rotifer genera (e.g. Asplanchna, Conchilus and Sinantherina), amphoteric females that produce diploid and haploid eggs have been observed (King & Snell 1977). Production of resting eggs or subitaneous eggs via parthenogenesis and the occurrence of diapausing amictic eggs have also been observed (see discussion in Nogrady et al. 1993; Gilbert & Schreiber 1995). In the Brachionidae, the eggs are attached to the body of the female by a thin thread, and the embryos of amictic eggs hatch and are released from the maternal body leaving the egg shells still attached to their mother. Resting eggs at the initial stages of formation cannot be distinguished from those of amictic eggs. In B. plicatilis, where the resting eggs are formed outside the female’s body (Fig. 2.5), they are also attached by a thin thread to their mother until the end of their formation and later
28
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Fig. 2.5 Schematic explanation of sexual and asexual cycles of reproduction in Brachionus plicatilis. (Photograph: Gidon Minkoff and Esther Lubzens.)
released and sink to the bottom of the culture vessel, pond or lake sediment. However, the resting eggs of B. rotundiformis (SM type rotifer strains) that develop within the maternal organism are not released from it. They will sink to the bottom of the culture vessel, pond or lake sediment with the death of their mother and are finally released only after the decomposition of her body. Resting eggs survive for long periods and have been hatched from sediment samples more than 60 years after their formation (Kotani et al. 2001). Males are known from a limited number of monogonont species, but it is generally assumed that all members of this group are capable of producing males, including the
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
29
brachionid species, B. plicatilis and B. rotundiformis. Males are much smaller than females and typically very fast moving. They have a rudimentary digestive gut and a sac-like testis containing free-swimming spermatozoa. A vas deferens leads from the testis to a penis and one or two prostate glands discharge into it. Males attempt copulation with amictic or mictic females and mating occurs at the region of the corona or cloaca. Successful fertilisation occurs in newly emerged females for a very limited period (Snell & Hawkins 1983). A pheromone produced by females was identified first in B. plicatilis. It is a 29 kDa glycoprotein and is found in amictic and mictic females (Snell et al. 1988, 1995; Snell & Nacionales 1990). Its molecular structure probably differs from that of B. rotundiformis and this may serve as a species-specific barrier limiting interbreeding between these species (Kotani et al. 1997). The mode of cyclical parthenogenesis combines the advantages of rapid clonal propagation via diploid, ameiotic parthenogenesis with the advantages of sexual recombination and is found in monogonont rotifers and cladocerans and in some other animal phyla such as aphids. These groups tend to inhabit time-varying environments that may become periodically unsuitable and therefore must be recolonised (Serra & King 1999). Parthenogenic reproduction is predominant in the initial stages of colonisation as it produces rapid population growth and during this phase the genotype is copied without genetic recombination. Genetic recombination occurs during sexual reproduction that leads to the formation of resting eggs. The resting egg is the life-cycle stage having the greatest capacity to disperse in both time and space. The cues initiating meiosis in diploid mictic females are not well understood, but from laboratory studies they include nutritional, population density, salinity and genetic factors (Pourriot & Snell 1983; Serra & King 1999; Ricci 2001). In response to a mictic cue, the amictic female will produce amictic and mictic daughters. The proportion of mictic daughters of B. plicatilis is variable (18–66%), and depends on food quality and salinity (Lubzens et al. 1985; Lubzens & Minkoff 1988). Snell (1987) reported an average mictic ratio of 21.2 ⫾ 3.84% (mean ⫾ SD) for B. plicatilis and suggested 50% as the highest optimal mictic ratio in nature. Using a demographic model, Serra and King (1999) showed that the frequency of mictic females that will maximise the population long-term fitness depends on population mortality and birth rates. This means that a population may adjust its relative rates of mictic and amictic production in response to environmentally induced changes, and different mixis patterns are expected in different types of habitats or culture conditions. They concluded that intermediate mictic ratios are optimal in density-dependent growth conditions and that optimal mictic ratios are higher when habitat conditions are better. This means that optimal culture conditions will result in higher production of resting eggs. 2.2.4.2 Reproductive rates The intrinsic reproductive rates of rotifer populations (r or G values; see below) increase exponentially with increasing food concentration, and the relationship can be described by a modified Monod model, with a threshold for zero population growth and a plateau for maximal population growth values (Rothhaupt 1990c). This means that the population growth will not increase beyond a specific concentration of food and may even decrease at relatively high food concentrations. The parameters of this model depend on the food
30
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Table 2.2 Life tables of amictic females (AM), non-fertilised mictic females producing male eggs (M) and fertilised mictic females producing resting eggs (FM). AM
M
FM
Average life span (Σlx/n) Days Hours Range (days)
7.07 ⫾ 0.06 169.71 ⫾ 23.93 4–9
7.45 ⫾ 0.70 178.8 ⫾ 16.8 4–11
11.96 ⫾ 0.44 287.0 ⫾ 10.56 4–20
Preoviposition period Hours % of total lifespan
36.8 ⫾ 12.39 22
41.45 ⫾ 11.21 23
82.0 ⫾ 11.97 25
Oviposition period Hours % of total lifespan
108.8 ⫾ 17.84 64
61.09 ⫾ 16.5 34
107.66 ⫾ 43.7 37
Postoviposition period Hours % of total lifespan
24.08 14
76.26 43
108.00 38
No. of eggs per female Range
21.5 ⫾ 0.43 17–24
15.18 ⫾ 0.8 9–19
3.31 ⫾ 0.19 1–5
Rate of egg production Hours Eggs produced day⫺1
4.75 5.05 ⫾ 1.59
3.63 6.61 ⫾ 0.35
42.11 0.57 ⫾ 0.2
No. of replicates
14
11
35
Brachionus plicatilis rotifers were individually incubated in 1 ml seawater (at a salinity of 9 ppt), fed on Chlorella stigmatophora (3 ⫻ 106 cells ml⫺1) and incubated at 25 ⫾ 1°C under constant illumination. New offspring were separated from their mothers every 8–10 h and placed individually in new wells. The parent females were also transferred every 8–10 h to new wells containing freshly prepared medium. Values are given as means ⫾ SD. The detailed experimental set-up is described in Lubzens and Minkoff (1988, Table 1).
particle size since this determines the relative rate of consumption (or clearance rate, as discussed above) and on the nutritional quality of the food provided to the rotifers. The fecundity of rotifers depends on whether asexual or sexual reproduction takes place. An example given in Table 2.2 shows that B. plicatilis amictic females produced 17–24 eggs during their lifetime, compared with 1–5 resting eggs produced by fertilised mictic females (Lubzens & Minkoff 1988; unpublished results of Experiment 1). In addition, the production of amictic eggs is, on average, 10 times faster (about 5 eggs/day) than that of the resting eggs during a similar oviposition period (approximately 108 h) (Table 2.2). The unfertilised mictic females produced 9–19 eggs, but these did not contribute to the increase in population as they form males. The number of eggs produced by a female (R0) is dependent on the food algal species, with Synechococcus elongates and Tetraselmis tetrathele supporting the highest rates of reproduction (Hirayama et al. 1979). The optimal temperature for culturing rotifers depends strongly on the species, as the optimal temperatures for B. plicatilis (10–30°C) are lower than those for B. rotundiformis (24–35°C) (see reviews by Hirano 1987; Lubzens et al. 1987, 1989; Rumengan & Hirayama 1990; Hirayama & Rumengan 1993). Within each species, differences have been found in the reproductive rates under the same culture conditions, indicating intraspecific variability (Hino & Hirano 1977; Lubzens 1989; Lubzens et al. 1989; Hagiwara 1994).
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
31
2.2.4.3 Sexual reproduction and resting egg formation It is widely accepted that the occurrence of sexual reproduction in B. plicatilis and B. rotundiformis is genetically determined (Hino & Hirano 1976; Snell & Hoff 1985; Hagiwara et al. 1988b; Lubzens 1989). This means that not all rotifer cultures will show sexual reproduction, even if the optimal environmental conditions are provided. The optimal conditions for encouraging the production of resting eggs also differ between B. plicatilis and B. rotundiformis. Moreover, within each species, there is a large variation between cultures in the number of resting eggs they will produce under identical culture conditions. Therefore, the selection of the appropriate strain or culture is imperative for successful production of resting eggs. As mentioned before, the stimulus for initiating sexual reproduction is still poorly understood, although several studies have been conducted to elucidate the environmental requirements for amictic and mictic production. Sexual production has more constraints than asexual reproduction. Sexual reproduction is restricted by population density (Snell & Boyer 1988) and its occurrence requires more optimal conditions of food availability, salinity and temperature than those supporting asexual reproduction (Lubzens et al. 1985, 1993; Snell 1986; Snell & Boyer 1988; Serra & King 1999). Differences have also been found between B. plicatilis and B. rotundiformis in the environmental conditions that encourage resting egg production. It has been shown that lower temperatures and lower salinities are required for B. plicatilis rotifers, while higher temperatures and relatively higher salinities will encourage higher resting egg production in B. rotundiformis (Hagiwara & Lee 1991). One of the dominating factors is the rotifer culture density. While a threshold density (approximately 10 rotifers/ml) is required to attain successful fertilisation, densities exceeding about 150 rotifers/ml result in a lower production of resting eggs (Hagiwara et al. 1997). A semicontinuous system that maintained rotifer density improved resting egg production of B. plicatilis rotifers but reduced resting egg production in B. rotundiformis cultures. Frequent renewal of culture media has been implicated in the reduced production of resting eggs, and the occurrence of a ‘density-dependent factor’ associated with resting egg production has been suggested (Hino & Hirano 1976). To date, this factor has not been identified. Fresh or preserved algae (frozen and/or concentrated) have been used in the production of resting eggs, as well as in mass production of rotifers (Hagiwara et al. 1997). Specific bacterial strains were reported to encourage resting egg production (Hagiwara et al. 1994). Preliminary experiments were reported on testing the effect of invertebrate and vertebrate hormones for encouraging mixis in B. plicatilis (Gallardo et al. 1997, 1999).
2.3 Culturing Rotifers The success of rotifer cultivation is dependent on selecting the most suitable rotifer species or strain for local culture conditions, maintaining water quality in culture tanks and choosing the most appropriate culture technique.
2.3.1 Selection of species and/or strain The selection of the strain is the most crucial step in initiating mass cultures. Size, type of reproduction (asexual versus sexual) and reproductive rates are species or strain specific.
32
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Culture temperatures, salinities, type of food and its quantity all modulate the type of reproduction and its rates. Mass production of rotifers is better achieved by encouraging rotifers to reproduce asexually, since sexual reproduction results in males and resting eggs. Male are nutritionally inferior to females owing to their fast swimming behaviour and lack of a digestive system, which means they cannot be enriched with essential nutrients required by fish larvae. The number of resting eggs produced by one female is significantly lower than the number of eggs produced parthenogenically, and resting eggs do not hatch immediately. Sexual reproduction can be avoided by using specific genetic strains (Hino & Hirano 1976; Lubzens 1989; Hagiwara et al. 1995b) that do not reproduce sexually or by culturing rotifers at relatively high salinities. In general, frozen or live algae support higher reproductive rates than yeast or dried algae (Lubzens et al. 2001). A careful calculation is required on the optimal trade-off between the higher cost of algae and increased rotifer production. The amount of food that has to be supplied daily to each culture tank depends on the reproductive rate of the rotifers. Usually, 1–4 g of baker’s yeast (or 30% of this weight as dry yeast) is supplied per million rotifers per day. The amount varies according to the temperature of the culture, salinity (more is needed at lower salinities and at higher culture temperatures), rotifer species and rotifer density. It has been calculated that 105–107 yeast cells need to be supplied daily for each cultured rotifer, and 1 g of yeast can produce about 80,000 B. plicatilis or 100,000 B. rotundiformis rotifers (Hirano 1987). The routine practice is to make a daily count of the number of rotifers and the number of eggs they carry in 1 ml samples, calculating the increased daily increment. The rate of reproduction of cultures is determined as r (sometimes referred to as G): r⫽
1 ln ( Nt ⫺ N0 ) T
(2.1)
where T ⫽ duration of culture in days, N0 ⫽ initial number of rotifers and their eggs, Nt ⫽ total number of rotifers and their eggs after T days of culture. The r-values for B. plicatilis strains usually range from 0.23 to 1.15, and for B. rotundiformis values from 0.54 to 1.37 have been recorded, depending on salinity and temperature (Hirayama et al. 1979; Lubzens et al. 1989, 1995a; Hagiwara et al. 1995b; Hansen et al. 1997). The type of food (wet yeast, dry yeast, live, frozen or dried algae; Lubzens et al. 2001) and its amount directly affects reproductive rates. For example, the r-values for B. plicatilis (Nagasaki strain) cultured in seawater at a salinity of 17 ppt and fed with N. oculata, were 0.90, 1.15 or 0.52 at culture temperatures of 25, 30 or 35°C, respectively. Under the same culture conditions, the r-values observed for B. rotundiformis rotifers were 0.54, 0.77 and 1.20 at 25, 30 or 35°C, respectively (Hagiwara et al. 1995b). The maximal r-values were 0.51, 0.55, 0.69, 0.74, 0.92 or 0.96 when rotifers were fed with Cyclotella cryptica, Nitzschia closterium, Monochrysis (now Pavlova) lutheri, Eutreptiella sp., Chlamydomonas sp. or Synechococcus elongates, respectively (Hirayama et al., 1979). As reproductive rates increase in a curvi-linear manner with the food concentration, comparisons between the efficacy of various food sources should be made at the Km or saturation values for each food type (Hansen et al. 1997).
2.3.2 Maintaining water quality in culture tanks The optimal range of pH for culturing rotifers is 7.5–8.5 (Hirano 1987; reviewed in Fulks & Main 1991) and the pH affects the percentage of un-ionised ammonia (NH3-N) in the
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
33
water. The pH of the cultures plays an important role since the toxicity of NH3-N released from ammonium (NH ⫹ 4 -N) is a function of the pH, temperature and salinity. Owing to the extreme importance of these parameters, it is highly advisable to consult the relevant tables in Bower and Bidwell (1978). The optimal level for ammonia is ⬍1 mg l⫺1 and the acceptable range for ammonia and nitrate levels is 6–10 mg l⫺1. Rotifer cultures require aeration and the dissolved oxygen level should be maintained above 4 ppm (Fulks & Main 1991). Adequate aeration should be provided using perforated polyvinyl chloride (PVC) tubes, air-stones or small-diameter open-ended tubes. Pure oxygen gas should be provided through perforated tubes in high-density rotifer cultures (see below). The use of ozone is extremely useful for high-density rotifer cultures in a recycled system (Suantika et al. 2001). Ammonia levels in this system were reduced by 67%, nitrite levels by 85% and nitrate levels by 67%. Ozone also reduced the number of particles and the number of bacteria in the culture water of B. plicatilis. In general, the water quality parameters are better in B. plicatilis cultures, because they are maintained at lower temperatures than B. rotundiformis. At lower temperatures (20–25°C), more oxygen can be dissolved in seawater (a higher saturation point), there is a lower rate of reproduction of bacteria, resulting in a lower bacterial load in the culture and several contaminant protozoans (e.g. Vorticella sp., Zoothanmium sp. or Euplotes sp.) do not proliferate as quickly as at higher temperatures (⬃25°C or even slightly higher). Moreover, as it takes longer for a culture to collapse, it is possible to take preventive measures to avoid the complete loss of B. plicatilis cultures. There is no need to illuminate rotifer cultures and in most facilities they are exposed to natural daylight. Direct illumination or exposure to sunlight may encourage uncontrolled growth in some filamentous algal species that are not consumed by rotifers, and this may lead to increased pollution of the culture media. 2.3.2.1 Organic particles Surplus food is one of the main contributors to the deterioration in water quality in culture tanks. In addition to its effect on lowering pH, thereby increasing ammonia and nitrates, it encourages bacterial growth. A careful balance must be maintained between the density and number of rotifers and the allotted food ration, to avoid the accumulation of excess organic matter in rotifer culture tanks. The limited capacity of rotifers to filter the culture medium means that this volume should contain all the nutrients required to meet metabolic needs and support reproduction. The problem is particularly acute in cultures with low rotifer density (less than approximately 50 ml⫺1) that are fed with baker’s yeast, as the volume filtered by all the rotifers is not sufficient to clear the water of the food particles. At low rotifer density, especially if the rotifers are only fed once daily, the food is not consumed quickly enough and significant amounts will either remain suspended, forming particles, or sink to the bottom. This can easily be avoided by dividing the daily food ration into four to six meals a day or by continuous feeding using a peristaltic pump. 2.3.2.2 Bacteria and other organisms in the culture tanks When considering the role of bacteria in rotifer culture tanks, two avenues have been explored: first, the success or failure of rotifer cultures in the presence of specific bacterial
34
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
species and, secondly, those species that may positively or negatively affect the culture of fish larvae when they are introduced to fish larvae tanks along with the rotifers. Opportunistic bacteria that are pathogenic to fish are common in seawater and may proliferate in the seawater used for live food cultures owing to the high loads of organic matter (reviewed in Skjermo & Vadstein 1999). The Vibrio spp. are among the main pathogenic bacteria infecting fish and they grow especially quickly under the low oxygen concentrations that may prevail in rotifer cultures. In these cultures, they may grow more rapidly than other bacteria and eventually dominate the bacterial assemblage. It is extremely difficult to obtain bacteria-free rotifer cultures, as sterilisation methods and the use of antibiotics are not very effective (Maeda et al. 1997; Rombaut et al. 1999a). One way of overcoming this problem is to regulate the bacterial species occurring in the rotifer cultures by introducing selected, non-pathogenic species. Several bacteria species are beneficial to rotifer culture since they produce important metabolites such as vitamin B12 (Scott 1981; Hirayama & Funamoto 1983; Yu et al. 1988, 1989), encourage sexual reproduction and resting egg formation (Hagiwara et al. 1994), and act as a direct source of food (Aoki & Hino 1996; Hino et al. 1997). However, bacteria that are toxic to rotifers have also been reported (Yu et al. 1990). It should also be noted that the culture temperature may have an important effect on both the type and rate of proliferation of bacteria, and this temperature will generally be lower for B. plicatilis rotifer cultures, possibly increasing their stability by reducing the reproductive rate of bacteria. Introducing selected, non-pathogenic bacteria may not only serve to curtail the proliferation of pathogenic bacteria attacking rotifers or fish larvae, but also be used to introduce beneficial microbial fauna (‘probiotics’) into the digestive system of the fish larvae via the rotifers. Probiotics are defined as ‘microbial cells that are administered in such a way as to enter the gastrointestinal tract and be kept alive, with the aim of improving health’ (Gatesoupe 1999). Lactic acid bacteria and Bacillus sp. spores that were introduced into the culture medium of rotifers increased rotifer production and growth of turbot larvae (Gatesoupe 1991, 1993). Alternatively, rotifers can serve as vectors for probionts that will colonise the larval gut (Fjelheim et al. 1999) and prevent disease outbreaks (Grisez et al. 1997). The bacterial microflora of rotifers from culture tanks can be artificially changed by incubation for 1 h in bacterial suspensions consisting of one or more probiotic strains. The probiont bacteria persist in the rotifers’ microflora for 4–24 h (Markridis et al. 2000) and the treated rotifers will transmit this bacterial gut flora to the fish larvae’s guts after ingestion. In addition to bacteria, the culture water may harbour many other organisms such as viruses, fungi or yeast that may be harmful to rotifers. Organisms that may compete with the rotifers for their food, such as ciliates, copepods or cladocerans, may also be present (Colorni et al. 1991; Comps et al. 1991a,b; Maeda & Hino 1991; Hagiwara et al. 1995a; Comps & Menu 1997; Jung et al. 1997).
2.3.3 Choosing the most appropriate culture techniques Rotifers can easily be maintained in all scales of culture. Two types of culture can be distinguished, the first of which are small-scale laboratory cultures for studying rotifer biology and physiology, or for maintaining species and genetic strains. These cultures are maintained as a ‘live library’ in small volumes and serve to initiate mass cultures with
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
35
specific important traits, such as size, adaptation to high or low culture temperatures, and salinity. The second type comprises mass cultures for supplying rotifers in the quantities required for intensive larval fish production. 2.3.3.1 Small-scale laboratory cultures The aim of these cultures is to maintain their specific genetic traits for long periods and facilitate their availability to mass culture facilities whenever they are needed. The following description demonstrates the culture procedure for rotifer species and strains in the authors’ laboratory using Mediterranean seawater (40 ppt). Rotifers in this type of culture can also be maintained in seawater prepared from dry sea salts or in artificial seawater. Seawater Natural seawater should be filtered through a 0.2 m membrane filter and heat sterilised at 100°C at atmospheric pressure for 30 min to avoid the formation of insoluble precipitates. The cooled, sterile seawater can be kept for several days at room temperature or several weeks in a refrigerator, if the bottles are kept sealed. Sterile distilled water is used for dilution of seawater whenever required. Culture procedure Ehrlenmeyer flasks (100 ml in volume) or 50 ml sterile disposable tubes can be used for culture. Each heat-sterilised flask or sterile tube is filled with 10–20 ml sterile seawater and 40–60 rotifers are added. Usually, a salinity of 30 ppt is suitable for most strains and also ensures that in most cultures asexual reproduction will prevail. A drop of concentrated algae (see below) is added to each culture and the flasks or tubes are incubated at one or more of the following temperatures: 20, 25 or 35°C, depending on the strain or species of the rotifer. Brachionus plicatilis cultures are best kept at 20 and 25°C, while B. rotundiformis cultures should be kept at 25, 30 or 35°C. The cultures are fed ad libitum every 2 days with concentrated algae and the amounts will vary with the reproductive rate of the cultured rotifers. This depends on the species, strain, temperature and salinity, and empirical experience is the best way to determine the appropriate amount. Caution is needed not to provide too much food as this may reduce reproductive rates and result in the collapse of the culture. Cultures are renewed every 7–10 days. To avoid loss of cultures, two or more copies of each culture are maintained at all times, by placing each one at a different culture temperature. The old cultures are kept (even without feeding) at room temperature, as a back-up, until the cultures are renewed. While these cultures do not reproduce at optimal rates, the rotifers remain alive and can be used for replacement in case of failure of the previous renewed cultures. Culture of algae Culture of Nannochloropsis sp. was found to be the most convenient source of food for rotifer cultures. Nannochloropsis sp. originated from Japan and is cultured in 2–3 litre batches at 25°C, under constant illumination. The culture medium is prepared from natural seawater enriched with a modification of Guillard f/2 medium (Lubzens 1981). Algae are
36
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
cultured for 4–6 days and harvested in the log phase period of growth by centrifugation at 4200 g, for 15 min at room temperature. The algal pellet is resuspended in a small volume of culture medium and kept in 1–2 ml aliquots (in Eppendorf tubes) at 4°C for 2–4 days or frozen at ⫺20°C for up to 12 months. 2.3.3.2 Mass cultures Three methods are used today for obtaining large numbers of rotifers: batch cultures, semicontinuous cultures and continuous cultures. Batch cultures This type of culture was initially developed in 1964 (Hirata 1964; for reviews, see Hirata 1979, 1980; Lubzens 1987) and has been greatly modified in recent years by many fish hatcheries (Lubzens et al. 1997, 2001). Four types can be described for this system (Table 2.3). In Type I cultures, rotifers are introduced at low density into ‘green water’ produced in fertilised tanks or ponds. Rotifers are collected (‘harvested’) after all the algae have been consumed, and are used as food for fish larvae. A small number is used to inoculate newly prepared ‘green Table 2.3 Types of batch culture method. Type I
Type II
Type III
Type IV
Place and volume of cultures
Outdoor; 20–100 t
Indoor; 1–5 t
Outdoor; 10–100 t
Indoor; 1 t
Step 1
Growth of phytoplankton (‘green water pond’)
Inoculate rotifers at high density (50–100 ml⫺1) in one-fifth volume of the culture tank
Inoculate rotifers into a large tank at a low density (10–20 ml⫺1)
Inoculate rotifers into 1000 l tank at high density (⬃5000– 10,000 ml⫺1)
Step 2
Inoculate rotifers at low density (1–5 ml⫺1)
Feed with yeast
Feed with yeast
Feed with concentrated Chlorella
Step 3
Culture rotifers until density reaches 20–50 ml⫺1
Increase the volume Culture until rotifer Culture rotifers of the culture density reaches for 2–3 days according to the 100–200 ml⫺1 reproductive rate of rotifers to maintain relative high density
Step 4
Sieve the whole culture to harvest rotifers
Sieve the whole culture to harvest rotifers
Sieve the whole culture to harvest rotifers
Sieve rotifers
Step 5
Reinoculate a new ‘green pond’ with part of the rotifers
Reinoculate a new tank and clean old tank and pipes with chlorine solution
Reinoculate a new culture tank and clean old tank and pipes with chlorine solution
Reinoculate a new culture tank and clean old tank and pipes with chlorine solution
Step 6
Enrich rotifers
Enrich rotifers
Enrich rotifers
Enrich rotifers
Duration of culture
Unpredictable
4–5 days
Depends on reproductive rate
2–3 days
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
37
water’ ponds. A recent adaptation (Lubzens et al. 1997) for batch culture (Type II) relies on a series of tanks. The culture system depends on short (1 week) production cycles with a cleaning interval of tanks and aeration tubing. The culture in each tank is started with one-fifth of its volume with rotifers at a density of approximately 200–300 ml⫺1. Rotifers are fed mainly with baker’s yeast and the daily ration is divided into three to five meals. The volume of culture medium is increased daily with seawater depending on the reproductive rate, thus maintaining a relatively high rotifer density in the culture. This may reach 300–500 rotifers ml⫺1 at the end of the culture period. The final volume of the tank is reached after 4–5 culture days. The rotifers are then sieved and concentrated, and the culture tank and its accessories (sieves, aeration tubes) are sterilised in hypochlorite solution (10 ppm of commercial grade bleach) for 24 h, followed by thorough rinsing with seawater before reuse. The concentrated rotifers are immersed briefly (5–15 min) in dechlorinated freshwater to remove ciliates and other undesired organisms. Practical experience has shown that rotifers are not affected by this brief immersion period in freshwater. Most of the concentrated rotifers are enriched (see below) with essential fatty acids and proteins before being fed to fish or crustacean larvae and a small fraction is used to inoculate the new culture tanks. This system is based on six tanks. Each day, one tank is harvested and another is inoculated. The volumes of the tanks range between 3 and 10 m3, depending on the number of rotifers needed in the hatchery, and their number should take into account an occasional, unpredictable collapse of at least one culture per week. This safeguard can be reduced as experience is gained in the hatchery. Preliminary experiments (Ressem et al. 2001), were reported recently on a 3 day cycle of B. plicatilis batch culture system in 600 litre cylindroconical fibreglass tanks, using 1 g (dry weight) of yeast and 0.1 g (dry weight) of Algamac 2000 (Bio-Marine, Aquafauna, USA) per 106 rotifers per day, at 22–23°C and 20–25 ppt salinity. Rotifers are inoculated at a density of ⬃250 ml⫺1 and harvested after 3 days at ⬃750 rotifers ml⫺1 and the cultures seem very stable, owing to the short culture cycle. One of the advantages of using the Algamac 2000 is that the rotifers are already enriched during their culture period. This is in addition to the low cost of food for this rotifer production system. Another approach to mass culture is based on inoculating rotifers into the culture tank that contains the final volume of culture medium (Type III), at an initial low rotifer density. The rotifers are fed with yeast, other dry food or concentrated algae, and harvesting is performed when high densities (⬎200 rotifers ml⫺1) are reached. This system is less stable than the one described previously since, at the early stages of the culture, the surplus of food remaining in the tanks will encourage bacterial growth and possible reduction in the pH. As the density of rotifers increases, the amount of surplus organic material from food is reduced and the system becomes more stable. The introduction of refrigerated and condensed freshwater Chlorella enriched with vitamin B12 (Chlorella Industry Co., Japan) has facilitated the maintenance of extremely highdensity rotifer mass cultures and changed dramatically the future potential for providing rotifers for fish and crustacean hatcheries (Yoshimura et al. 1996, 1997; Balompapueng et al. 1997a). These high-density culture systems consist of 1 m3 tank units in which rotifers (B. rotundiformis) are batch-cultured at 2–3 day intervals (Type IV). Cultures are initiated at a density of 10,000 rotifers ml⫺1, and after 2–3 days with concentrated algae the culture density reaches 20,000–30,000 rotifers ml⫺1. The large number of rotifers needed for starting the first round of these cultures can originate from scaling-up a small initial culture by
38
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
traditional mass culture methods or, alternatively, from hatched resting eggs if they are available (see below for further discussion of this issue). Oxygen gas has to be supplied to these cultures to overcome the shortage of dissolved oxygen that results from the high amounts of food and the subsequent increase in the rotifer population. In addition, at these high densities, ammonia excreted by the rotifers becomes a significant problem. The pH of the culture also increases, presumably owing to the liberation of carbon dioxide from the water, by the oxygen gas supplied to the culture. This, in turn, results in a higher proportion of toxic un-ionised ammonia of the total ammonia, which increases with increased pH, salinity and the culture temperature. Regulation of the pH at 7.0 by hydrochloric acid minimises these effects. A special nylon filtration mat is used for removal of large amounts of suspended organic material that may also include protozoans, fungi and bacterial flocculations, which may be harmful to the fish larvae. The small space and reduced labour required are the main advantages of this ultra-high-density culture system. In hatcheries, this relatively compact, closed system permits the maintenance of separate cultures of several genetic rotifer strains, or populations of different sizes. Thus, it assists in providing a variety of rotifers for larvae of different fish species, without enlarging the hatchery facilities. Fish larvae prefer smaller rotifers immediately after hatching and larger ones as they grow, and providing them with this size variation increases their survival (Lubzens et al. 1989). Most hatcheries aim to culture a variety of fish species that may differ in their nutritional requirements during early life stages, and these can be more easily provided by the compact, high-density cultures. The relatively high culture temperatures (⬎25°C) required by small rotifers can be easily maintained in these compact systems. At the same time, fish cultured at low temperatures can benefit from this system by using rotifers cultured at relatively low temperatures. The convenience and accessibility of concentrated algae encourage its use also in intensifying traditional culture systems. Semi-continuous cultures This culture system relies on periodic (usually daily) harvesting of rotifers by removal of part of the culture medium and replacing it with new seawater (see Hirata 1980). This method has been termed the ‘thinning method’ (Fukusho 1989b). The volume removed depends on the reproductive rate of the rotifers and harvesting removes only the number of rotifers gained by reproduction from the previous harvesting period. Hirano (1987) suggested that 6–7% of the biomass can be removed daily in rotifer cultures maintained on baker’s yeast. In general, these systems often rely on large volume tanks ranging from 3000 to 300,000 litres (Hirata 1980; Fukusho 1989b; Lubzens et al. 1997). These cultures are characterised by relatively lower rotifer density (100–300 rotifers ml⫺1) and baker’s yeast is used as food. Cultures continue for several days or even weeks but, eventually, excretory products (solid wastes and nitrogenous products) that accumulate in the tank lead to their collapse. Continuous removal of the solid waste enhances rotifer reproduction and results in densities reaching 400 individuals ml⫺1 and the cultures are stable for over 30 days with daily harvesting periods. In these ‘feedback’ cultures (Hirata 1980), the solid waste is transferred to decomposing tanks and, after its breakdown to nitrogen, carbon and phosphates, it is used as fertiliser for algal cultures. However, as mentioned previously, these large-volume tanks harbour many other organisms that either compete for food with the rotifers (e.g. ciliates, copepods, cladocerans) or harm them (e.g. viruses, bacteria, fungi or yeast). Since these
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
39
and other pathogens can be transferred to the fish tanks (Gatesoupe 1990; Blanch et al. 1991; Verdonck et al. 1997; Munro et al. 1999), the cultivation of rotifers with selected, non-pathogenic bacterial strains has been suggested (Gatesoupe 1999; Markridis et al. 1999, 2000; Rombaut et al. 1999a,b) to curtail the growth of undesired micro-organisms and contribute to the stabilisation of the rotifer cultures (for further details see Section 2.3.2.2). High-density semi-continuous culture, using a modified commercially available formulated rotifer diet with recirculation of the culture media, was described recently (Suantika et al. 2000). This system consists of a 100 litre rotifer (B. plicatilis) culture tank, a settlement tank for suspended particulate matter, a protein skimmer and a biofilter. The amount of food provided to the rotifers in this system is adjusted to the circulation flow rate and loss of feed by the protein skimmer. Rotifer cultures are initiated at a density of approximately 250 rotifers ml⫺1, with the density reaching 3000 ml⫺1 after 8 days of culture and being maintained at about this level for over 1 month. About 20% (3–6 ⫻ 107 rotifers) of the standing stock is harvested daily. Adequate water quality is maintained by a daily 500% recirculation rate. Although it is possible to obtain densities of 8000 rotifers ml⫺1 after 8 days of culture following inoculation, the authors recommend that rotifer production should be performed at a lower density, where the system is more stable. The total rotifer production in this system is 1.7 ⫻ 109 rotifers over 32 culture days. Introducing ozone into this system (Suantika et al. 2001) improved its performance significantly by supporting a higher rotifer biomass (16,000 rotifers ml⫺1) and prolonging by 4 days the duration of rotifer production. An experimental, semi-continuous culture system using dried Nannochloropsis powder was described recently (Navarro & Yufera 1998). In this system, rotifers were cultured in 1 litre flasks, with gentle aeration in a thermoregulated chamber at 25°C, at a salinity of 18 ppt and under 2500 lux of continuous illumination. They were provided daily with 25 mg of dried N. oculata powder and the effect of daily dilution rates of 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4, 0.5 and 0.6 was investigated to establish the best production (mg rotifers day⫺1) and food conversion efficiencies (mg rotifer developed mg⫺1 microalgae consumed) for B. plicatilis or B. rotundiformis. The results showed that the optimal dilution rates were 0.2 and 0.3 for B. rotundiformis and B. plicatilis, respectively. At these dilution rates, the rotifer production reached 16.75 ⫾ 0.37 mg l⫺1 day⫺1 for B. plicatilis and 6.12 ⫾ 0.08 mg l⫺1 day⫺1 for B. rotundiformis. The average conversion efficiency at these conditions was 0.76 and 0.30 mg rotifers mg⫺1 algae for B. plicatilis and B. rotundiformis, respectively. This means that under optimal conditions, 76 and 30% of the microalgae biomass was transformed into rotifer biomass of the respective species. The lower efficiency for B. rotundiformis may be attributed to the relatively low culture temperature (25°C) used for this thermophilic species. The application of this system on a large scale awaits additional experimental results. Continuous cultures These cultures are based on the chemostat or turbidostat models of micro-organisms and are fully controlled (temperature, pH, oxygen supply and density of cultured organisms) and highly dependable (Walz 1993; Walz et al. 1997). They offer easy manipulation of rotifer physiological and nutritional quality. Log-phase produced rotifers can be harvested continuously and their nutritional quality is maintained by providing adequate food organisms (James et al. 1983, 1987; James & Abu-Rezeq 1989a,b, 1990). A more recent adaptation of this method involves high-density cultures (excess of 10,000 rotifers ml⫺1) using the
40
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
concentrated freshwater Chlorella (Fu et al. 1997). Part of the efficiency of rotifer production in these intensive, chemostat-like systems may be attributed to bacterial growth and consumption by the cultured rotifers. Bacterial nitrogen corresponding to approximately 20% of the algal feeding was consumed by rotifers in systems operating with unlimited food supply (Aoki & Hino 1996; Hino et al. 1997). These systems are compact (1000 litres of culture provides 1.7–3.5 billion B. rotundiformis daily, and 500 litres provides 0.13–0.27 billion B. plicatilis daily). However, their initial cost exceeds that of more conventional installations and they depend on a constant supply of concentrated algae. While more work is needed to optimise the culture system for B. plicatilis, it should be noted that their biomass (depending on their size) is at least three times higher (expressed as dry weight; Yufera et al. 1997) than that of B. rotundiformis. This means that a similar biomass per culture volume will consist of a smaller number of individuals. Moreover, the lower number of B. plicatilis produced per day may also be attributed to their lower metabolism and rate of reproduction at the optimal culture temperatures (20–24°C). Culture tanks A very large array and configuration of culture tanks is used for semi-continuous and batchculture rotifer mass production systems, in terms of both volume and shape, and these have been summarised by Fulks and Main (1991, pp. 323–326). They are round, square, cylindrical, conical or rectangular, and mass cultures are performed in volumes ranging from 150 to 300,000 litres (or 300 m3). An example of an indoor 100 m3 rotifer culture tank is shown in Fig. 2.6 and an example of a 500 litre cylindrical tank with a conical outlet is shown in Fig. 2.7. These culture tanks are made from concrete, fibreglass, polycarbonate or plastic, or nylon disposable bags hanging on metal frames. The chemostat-type, continuous culture system described by James & Abu-Rezeq (1989a,b) relies on 1000 litre culture tanks. The high rotifer density cultures relying on
Fig. 2.6 Concrete rectangular culture tank with maximum capacity of 100 m3 seawater used in culturing rotifers in Japan. (Photograph: Esther Lubzens.)
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
41
concentrated Chlorella cells use 100 or 1000 litre cylindrical tanks (Fu et al. 1997), and the system designed by Suantika et al. (2000) consisted of 100 litre cylindroconical tanks. The large 6–300 m3 concrete tanks are usually used for outdoor, semi-continuous cultures, where rotifer density is relatively low. In some places, these tanks have a conical bottom with an outlet that permits the removal of accumulated debris at least once a day, or is used for harvesting of rotifers. These tanks are difficult to clean, and bacteria or other organisms may accumulate in crevices that are abundant on their rough surface. For this reason, the old system of rotifer culture tanks at the National Mariculture Center (Eilat, Israel), consisting of six, 20 m3, concrete, circular tanks (Fig. 2.8) has been abandoned and replaced with an adaptation of the system devised at the Israel Salt Co. (Lubzens et al. 1997). This
Fig. 2.7 Cylindrical 500 litre fibreglass culture tanks, with conical bottom outlets for culturing rotifers at the National Mariculture Center, Eilat, Israel. (Photograph: Esther Lubzens.)
Fig. 2.8 Round 20 m3 concrete tanks for culturing rotifers at the National Mariculture Center, Eilat, Israel. Note the small tank at the lower part of the picture, near the outlet of the concrete tank, used for rotifer collection (or ‘harvesting’). (Photograph: Esther Lubzens.)
42
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Fig. 2.9 Rectangular bathtub-shaped fibreglass tanks (3000 litres) for culturing rotifers (Salt. Co., Israel). Note the cylindrical tanks with conical outlets in the background used for nutrient enrichment of rotifers or Artemia. (Photograph: Esther Lubzens.)
alteration also involved changing from a semi-continuous culture system to batch culture production. Most batch culture or continuous systems are performed in relatively small volumes, ranging from 150 to 3000 or even 10,000 litres. The smaller volumes (150–2000 litres) can be cultured in nylon disposable plastic bags that are placed on a circular or rectangular metal frame and have the great advantage of being used only once for 2–6 days. The most reliable system in Israel consists of smooth-surface rectangular ‘bathtub’-shaped tanks made from fibreglass (Fig. 2.9), with volumes ranging from 3000 to 10,000 litres. The tanks are shaped with a slanting bottom, leading to an external outlet that facilitates removal of debris and rotifers. The tanks can be easily cleaned with bleach and freshwater every 5–7 days, at the end of each batch culture. One of the advantages of the smaller volume batch cultures is that they can be placed indoors (in contrast to the large-volume, concrete tanks that are usually placed outdoors), thus avoiding the colonisation of the rotifer cultures with other organisms. The decision on the choice of the type and shape of culture tanks depends greatly on the available facilities and budget. For example, the use of fibreglass rectangular or circular tanks has proved to be beneficial in the authors’ facilities. The volume of the culture tank depends on the expected production in the hatchery and the convenience of handling. Rotifers have to be counted and inspected daily from each culture tank, independent of the volume. This means that it is more cost-effective to maintain a small number of large-volume tanks than a large number of small-volume tanks. However, the accidental loss of a culture in a large-volume tank will obviously entail the loss of a larger number of rotifers. Taking into consideration the greater reliability of the batch culture system, the policy that can be adopted by a new facility is to plan on a tank containing a volume that will suffice for 1 day’s supply of rotifers in the hatchery. This will mean that the hatchery’s culture will consist of six or seven tanks, where every day one tank is harvested and one tank is inoculated with a new culture (see also Lubzens et al. 1997). New culture facilities should also maintain one extra tank, until the culture systems have become completely reliable and predictable.
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
43
Choosing the best system Cost of production, reliability and the practical experience of the staff are the main factors that dictate the choice of system. The cost of production of rotifers depends greatly on the total scale of production, with an estimated cost of US $0.04 per million rotifers in a system producing 4 billion per day, and US $0.15 in a 1 billion per day production system (Lubzens et al. 1997). The production rate can also be improved by using concentrated algae. Although these are more expensive than yeast, they offer several advantages: higher rotifer reproductive rates, improved stability of rotifer cultures, allowing them to be used in high-density culture systems, and higher resting egg production. The cost of concentrated 18 litre canisters containing concentrated Chlorella at a density of 20 billion cells ml⫺1 ranges from US $140 to 150 (Hagiwara et al. 2001). Recent reports (Hayashi et al. 2001) on successful incorporation of n-3 highly unsaturated fatty acids (HUFA) by Chlorella cells will eliminate the need to enrich rotifers mass cultured with this alga, prior to feeding them to the fish larvae. Several other companies have been involved in marketing concentrated algae with prices ranging from US $300 to 400 kg⫺1 of dried algae or US $50–65 for 1 litre of concentrated algae (16–20% dry matter), depending on the species, purchasing quantities and shipment destinations. In Europe, North America and Japan, the cost of labour is one of the main concerns in these calculations, whereas the cost of equipment is the main concern in developing countries. The reliability of each system dictates the number of replicate culture tanks that should be installed to meet the required production, with fewer replicate cultures needed in more reliable systems.
2.4 Advanced Warning on State of Cultures Evaluating the physiological state of the rotifer culture is extremely important in hatcheries since larval production depends on a predictable and reliable daily supply of rotifers. Six parameters have been used as early warning signals for the state of the culture and these may be strain specific.
2.4.1 Egg ratio The number of eggs predicts the state of the culture for the forthcoming 24 h. Therefore, the egg ratio (E/N), determined as the number of eggs (E) divided by the total number of females (N) in a sample, is an important indicator of the status of a culture. Usually, a sample of 30–40 ml or even larger is removed daily from each culture for determining the state of the culture (see Appendix I) and for evaluating the amount of food that should be provided to that specific culture. The total number of females and the total number of eggs in 1 ml subsamples (from the 30–40 ml sample) is counted and the ratio E/N is calculated for each sample. Three different 1 ml aliquots should be counted to obtain a more reliable estimate and more aliquots should be counted if the variation exceeds 10% between the counted rotifers in three aliquots. In general, the egg ratio depends on food quality and quantity and is affected by abiotic parameters such as oxygen level, culture temperature, salinity, pH and ammonia levels. Any deviation from optimal conditions of these parameters will be
44
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
reflected by low egg ratios in the rotifer cultures, except that a short duration at low temperatures will not reduce the egg number. The critical ratio is strain specific. For example, in one study an egg ratio of less than 0.13 for B. plicatilis cultures indicated their instability and possible future collapse (Snell et al. 1987). Therefore, a low or high egg ratio should be considered as one of the indicators, in addition to others, of the state of a rotifer culture.
2.4.2 Swimming velocity Swimming velocity is a quick indicator of the current state of the culture (Snell & Hoff 1988; Korstad et al. 1995). It is reduced at high un-ionised ammonia concentration and at starvation. Extremely low or high values of temperature and pH have the same effect.
2.4.3 Ingestion rate Ingestion of fluorescent labelled beads by neonates hatching from eggs was reported to be related to water quality parameters (Juchelka & Snell 1994). An adaptation of this test to testing water from rotifer mass cultures should be considered in the future.
2.4.4 Viscosity It has been demonstrated that the relative viscosity of the culture medium increases with the age of the culture, resulting in reduced swimming speed, ingestion rates, mean longevity and mean number of offspring of the rotifers. Therefore, direct measurements of viscosity could be an indicator of approaching problems in maintaining culture stability. This phenomenon is of great importance in the high-density continuous cultures, where the culture media contain high concentrations of concentrated algae and excretory products (Hagiwara et al. 1998).
2.4.5 Enzyme activity Changes in the activity of endogenous esterases, phospholipases and glucosidases, has been suggested as a monitoring tool for water quality in rotifer culture tanks (de Araujo et al. 2000, 2001; Hagiwara et al. 2001). The tests are based on reduced enzyme activity in rotifers exposed to toxins (Burbank & Snell 1994; Snell & Janssen 1995, 1998). In these tests, rotifers of similar age, size and physiological condition are provided from hatched resting eggs. It is not yet known whether rotifers removed from mass cultures are suitable candidates for these tests.
2.4.6 Diseases Occurrence of disease will eventually lead to the collapse of the culture and, therefore, early detection is important for taking appropriate measures. Rotifers in mass cultures have
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
45
been observed to be infected by fungal, viral and yeast-like organisms (Colorni et al. 1991; Comps et al. 1991a,b, 1993; Comps & Menu 1997; Zmora 1991). As mentioned before, the culture temperature may affect the type of bacteria or other opportunistic organisms and the rate of their proliferation. Therefore, the incidence of specific infections, their type and rate of infection may vary between B. plicatilis and B. rotundiformis, as they are cultured at relatively low or high temperatures, respectively. While there are no known remedies for rotifer diseases, it has been observed (Zmora 1991) that providing Nannochloropsis to infected yeast-fed rotifer cultures will reduce the infection rate. The algae do not cure the rotifers, but the accelerated reproduction of the cultured rotifers fed algae results in new generations that show a low incidence of the disease (O. Zmora, unpublished results). These cultures remain susceptible and the diseases may recur if the cultures are exposed to additional stress. Swimming speed, egg ratio and health conditions must be inspected daily on samples removed from each culture tank.
2.5 Nutritional Quality of Rotifers After establishing mass culture techniques, it is necessary to ensure that the rotifers are nutritionally adequate for the fish larvae. This is usually performed by a step known as ‘enrichment’, where the rotifers are collected or harvested from the culture tanks into containers where they are kept at very high densities (usually more than 100,000 ml⫺1), and incubated for 8–20 h with enrichment dietary components that are specifically required by the fish larvae. In addition to enrichment with protein, lipids or carbohydrates, the rotifers can be enriched with antibiotics (Verpraet et al. 1992) or with probiotic bacteria (Markridis et al. 1999, 2000).
2.5.1 Number of rotifers consumed by larvae The nutritional value of rotifers depends on their dry weight, caloric value and chemical composition (reviewed in Lubzens et al. 1989). Amictic rotifer eggs and the loricae of rotifers are not digested by larval fish in their early developmental stages (Lubzens et al. 1989). Dynamic, physiological processes such as satiation, starvation and reproduction also affect the chemical composition of rotifers (Yufera & Pascual 1989; Olsen et al. 1993; Øie & Olsen 1997; Yufera et al. 1997; Markridis & Olsen 1999). The number of rotifers consumed by the larvae determines the quantity of food reaching their gut. In red sea bream, the number of rotifers consumed daily increases with the size or age of the larva, from 55–72 rotifers per 3.9 mm length larva to 4700 per 11.4 mm length larva (Fukusho 1989b; Fig. 2.10). There is a large variation in sizes between B. plicatilis and B. rotundiformis rotifers and between various populations within each species (Fu et al. 1990, 1991a,b; Hagiwara et al. 1995b), and this is reflected in their nutritional quality and consumption by fish larvae (Lubzens et al. 1989; Polo et al. 1992). Moreover, size changes occur during the life cycle of rotifers within each population or species, with rotifers growing in size from the time of hatching from the amictic egg until they reach sexual maturity. Size also depends on culture conditions such as salinity, temperature or diet (Snell & Carillo
46
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Fig. 2.10 Number of rotifers consumed daily by fish larvae: red sea bream, striped knifejaw and black sea bream. (Adapted from Fukusho 1989b.)
1984). All of these factors contribute to the difficulties in comparing results from different publications.
2.5.2 Dry weight and caloric value The dry weight of rotifers depends on their size and nutritional state (Lubzens et al. 1989). At approximately 600–800 ng, B. plicatilis rotifers are three to four times heavier than B. rotundiformis (approximately 200 ng) and this changes with their reproductive rate (Yufera et al. 1997). The caloric value was found to depend on the diet and ranged from 1.34 × 10⫺3 cal per rotifer fed on baker’s yeast to 2.00 × 10⫺3 cal per rotifer after 6 h enrichment with a formulated enrichment diet (Fernandez-Reiriz et al. 1993).
2.5.3 Biochemical composition 2.5.3.1 Protein and carbohydrate content Rotifer protein content ranges from 28 to 63% and lipid content from 9 to 28% of the dry weight (Lubzens et al. 1989; Frolov et al. 1991; Frolov & Pankov 1992; Nagata & Whyte 1992; Fernandez-Reiriz et al. 1993; Reitan et al. 1993; Rainuzzo et al. 1994; Øie & Olsen 1997; Markridis & Olsen 1999). The carbohydrate content ranges from 10.5 to 27% of the dry weight (Whyte & Nagata 1990; Frolov et al. 1991; Frolov & Pankov 1992; Nagata & Whyte 1992; Fernandez-Reiriz et al. 1993) and it is composed of 61–80% glucose (which is present mainly as glycogen), 9–18% ribose and 0.8–7.0% of galactose, mannose, deoxyglucose, fucose and xylose (Nagata & Whyte 1992). Food ration affects the reproductive rate of rotifers and their protein, lipid and carbohydrate content. The protein content of individual rotifers increases by 60–80% with increasing
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
47
food ration, but the amino acid profiles of rotifers are unaffected by either food ration or type of food provided to rotifers (Lubzens et al. 1989; Frolov et al. 1991; Tamaru et al. 1991, 1993; Frolov & Pankov 1992; Nagata & Whyte 1992; Fernandez-Reiriz et al. 1993; Øie & Olsen 1997). 2.5.3.2 Lipid composition The lipid content of rotifers varies generally between 9 and 28% of their dry weight and has been found, unequivocally, to have the greatest influence on growth and survival of marine fish larvae. About 34–43% of the lipids in rotifers are phospholipids and 20–55% are triacylglycerols, with small amounts of monoacylglycerols, diacylglycerols, sterols, sterol esters and free fatty acids (Teshima et al. 1987; Frolov et al. 1991; Nagata & Whyte 1992; Fernandez-Reiriz et al. 1993; Rainuzzo et al. 1997). Rotifer phospholipids and triacyglycerols display similar fatty acid profiles, but these are greatly affected by the lipids provided in their diet. Eicosapentaenoic (EPA) and docosahexaenoic (DHA) acids (20:5n-3 and 22:6n-3, respectively) have been known for several decades to be essential fatty acids for the survival of marine fish larvae (Owen et al. 1975; Fujita 1979; Watanabe et al. 1983). In general, marine fish contain large amounts of EPA and DHA in the phospholipids of their cellular membranes and, since they cannot synthesise them from linolenic acid (18:3n-3), these acids are essential dietary constituents. More specifically, DHA is present in high concentrations in neural and visual membranes, and insufficiency in the larval diet may result in serious consequences for a wide range of physiological and behavioural processes. These include impaired pigmentation and vision at low light intensities, leading to low hunting capabilities of the developing larvae and impaired development of the neuroendocrine system (Bell et al. 1995; Sargent et al. 1997, 1999; Estevez et al. 1999). Similarly, fish have a limited capacity to convert linoleic acid (18:2n-6) to n-6 HUFA, including arachidonic acid (ARA, 20:4n-6), which has gained increased attention in recent years (Sargent et al. 1997, 1999) and is now also considered an essential fatty acid. It has been shown to improve stress tolerance in fish larvae (Koven et al. 2001). ARA is the main precursor fatty acid of eicosanoids that are converted to biologically active compounds including prostaglandins, thromboxanes and leukotrienes, or can function in response to hormonal stimulation. Accumulating evidence points to the importance of supplying an optimal blend of EPA, DHA and ARA in the diet of marine fish larvae. Moreover, phospholipids rather than triacylglycerols are the preferred vehicle for delivery of these polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA). This probably relates to the limited ability of fish larvae to synthesise phospholipids de novo. It has been suggested that the optimal ratio for DHA:EPA:ARA is 1.8:1:0.12 for turbot (Sargent et al. 1999) and that excess ARA may have a deleterious affect (Bessonart et al. 1999; Estevez et al. 1999). While it is well known that rotifers can be easily cultured on yeast, rotifers reared in this way are nutritionally inadequate for marine fish larvae as they lack adequate amounts of DHA, EPA or ARA. Rotifers have to be enriched with these fatty acids and enrichment methods include feeding rotifers with algae, lipid emulsions, microparticulates or microcapsules containing lipids, or lipids with protein and carbohydrates (reviewed in Lubzens et al. 1989; Rainuzzo et al. 1997; Sargent et al. 1997). The quantitative and qualitative lipid content of rotifers can be manipulated by short or long enrichment periods on various diets containing lipid emulsion. Rotifer phospholipids were less influenced by these
48
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
diets than the triacylglycerol fraction (Rainuzzo et al. 1997). Commercial fish oils that consist mainly of triacylglycerols are the main source of DHA or EPA. Their content depends on the fish species, but they usually are poor in ARA, except for tuna orbital oil that may contain about 2% of ARA. These oils are usually incorporated into most artificial diets for rotifers. Lipids can also be provided by feeding algae to rotifers, e.g. EPA-rich Nannochloropsis and DHA-rich Isochrysis, both of which contain ARA. A mutant strain of Nannochloropsis that was found to be deficient in EPA (Schneider et al. 1995) contains abundant ARA (23.3 mol% in whole cell extracts of the mutant strain versus 4.2 mol% in the wild type) and can be used as an alternative source of this fatty acid. The algae can be supplied directly from cultures, as a live or frozen concentrated paste or after freeze-drying (Watanabe et al. 1983; discussed in Lubzens et al. 1989 and in Fulks & Main 1991; Frolov et al. 1991; Lubzens et al. 1995a; Takeyama et al. 1996; Navarro & Yufera 1998). More recently, bacteria isolated from Antarctica, containing high levels of EPA, were suggested as a potential alternative enrichment food for rotifers (Nichols et al. 1996). Another lipid enrichment source is the freshwater Chlorella (Hayashi et al. 2001). The lipid content of rotifers is usually lower than that of their food organism, indicating that lipids are utilised by the rotifers. Rotifers utilise more DHA in highly reproducing cultures (Øie & Olsen 1997) and lipid utilisation is temperature dependent (Olsen et al. 1993). They accumulate about three to five times more total lipids when they are kept at 10°C than at 25°C (Lubzens et al. 1995b) and these results suggest that higher enrichment levels will be obtained if this procedure is performed at relatively low temperatures (depending on the rotifer strain), where reproductive rates and utilisation rates are slowed down. 2.5.3.3 Vitamin enrichments The importance of enriching rotifers with vitamins has not been studied extensively. In addition to vitamin B12, which was mentioned previously, fat-soluble vitamins (A, D and E) were found to promote rotifer reproduction (Hirayama 1990). The content of water-soluble vitamins in rotifers increased after changing their diet from baker’s yeast and lipid emulsion to Isochrysis. The most significant increase was in the content of ascorbic acid and thiamin. Rotifers fed on algae contain sufficient amounts of these vitamins to meet the nutritional requirements of fish larvae (Lie et al. 1997). However, enhanced levels of lipid-soluble vitamins in rotifers, caused by feeding them fish oil emulsions, were quickly depleted when the rotifers were switched to a diet of Isochrysis. Nevertheless, their final content in rotifers exceeded the recommended levels needed for proper growth of fish larvae (Lie et al. 1997). Vitamin C (ascorbic acid) not only stimulates rotifer growth (Satuito & Hirayama 1991) but also contributes significantly to the survival of fish larvae (Dabrowski & Ciereszko 1993; Dabrowski & Blom 1994). Its content in rotifers was found to depend on the diet, as it is highly abundant in several species of algae. Maximal levels were achieved in rotifers enriched with ascorbyl palmitate (Merchie et al. 1997).
2.5.4 Effects of starvation One of the main problems in providing rotifers to larvae is the deterioration in their nutritional quality due to starvation that results from extended periods of residence in the fish
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
49
tanks. About 40–50% of the rotifer body mass is lost during 4–5 days of starvation at 18–20°C and the rate of decrease is positively related to temperature (Markridis & Olsen 1999). During starvation, preferential degradation of lipids, carbohydrates and amino acid takes place, leading to an increase in the proportion of proteins in the dry weight. The chemical composition of rotifers (e.g. protein content) can be presented in either mg g⫺1 dry weight or ng rotifer⫺1, and while large differences may occur in the content per rotifer (especially during starvation), these may not be reflected in the ratio of mg g⫺1 dry weight. During the first 8 h of starvation, free amino acids are used as the main energy source by rotifers, with lipids and carbohydrates being utilised later. Lipids serve as the main source of energy and different lipid classes are mobilised at different rates during starvation. An increase in the proportion of diacylglycerols, monoacylglycerols, sterols and free fatty acids results from mobilisation of triacylglycerols, and this also leads to an increase in the proportion of polar lipids. The mobilisation of sterols and wax esters follows the hydrolysis of triacylglycerols and carbohydrates, and coincides with increased mortality of rotifers (Frolov & Pankov 1992). The loss of lipids depends on temperature and can reach 19% of total lipids per day at 18°C, and the content of n-3 fatty acids is reduced more rapidly than other lipids (Olsen et al. 1993). The protein content of each rotifer is reduced during starvation, but the amino acid composition is rather stable (Frolov & Pankov 1992). The effect of starvation can be partially overcome by supplying algae to the fish tanks (Markridis & Olsen 1999). These results suggest that newly fed and enriched rotifers should be supplied daily to cultured larvae.
2.6 Preserved Rotifers Meeting the demands of fish larvae is a continuous effort from the day of first feeding up to the time that larvae are fed on other food sources (e.g. Artemia). While the usual practice is to depend on daily harvesting of rotifers from live cultures, various methods of storing rotifers have been explored.
2.6.1 Preservation at low temperatures Frozen rotifers are not usually adequate as food because of leaching of nutrients after thawing, their lack of buoyancy and motility, and they may also cause a deterioration in the water quality if introduced into the culture tanks. Live B. plicatilis can be stored at 4°C at relatively high densities, for at least 1 month (Lubzens et al. 1990), but this period is shorter for the thermophilic B. rotundiformis strains (Assavaaree et al. 2001a,b; see below). Storage at low temperature can help to reduce the daily tasks of harvesting and enriching rotifers, which may be performed every few days. It can also be helpful in storing surplus rotifers produced on one day for later use, providing a safeguard against unpredicted culture crashes, and facilitating transport of rotifers between sites of production and culture facilities. While storage at 4°C is feasible in most places, rotifers continue to reproduce at this temperature and require periodic feeding and exchange of culture media. Rotifers can be kept at ⫺1°C without feeding or water exchange for about 2 weeks (Lubzens et al. 1995b), but storage at this temperature requires more specific equipment.
50
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
As storage at low temperature was found to be relatively easy and successful for B. plicatilis rotifers, extending this method to B. rotundiformis has been examined recently (Assavaaree et al. 2001a,b). The results show that B. rotundiformis rotifer strains are less tolerant to 4°C than B. plicatilis rotifer strains, and the strains known as SS type were the most susceptible and showed the lowest survival. While the mean survival of B. plicatilis strains ranged from 26.9 to 63.7% after 30 days at 4°C, only one B. rotundiformis strain survived after 15 days at this temperature and only four strains survived after 7 days. A clear variation was found between S and SS type strains, with a lower survival of SS-type strains at low temperatures. At 12°C, more than 80% of B. rotundiformis rotifers (of an S-type strain and an SS-type strain) survived after 10 days. Survival of an S-type strain was higher at 35 ppt, while the SS-type strain survived best at 17 ppt. Feeding rotifers at intervals of 2 days improved their survival over those fed only at the beginning of the experiment or at intervals of 4 days, and changing the culture media every 4 days suppressed survival. An acclimation period of 24 h at 20°C, before transferring of rotifers from their usual culture temperature (28°C) to 12°C, resulted in higher survival of SS-type rotifers but had no effect on S-type rotifers. These results indicate the difficulties in attempting to keep small-type rotifers at low temperatures for extended periods, and the optimal conditions have to be empirically determined for each strain.
2.6.2 Cryopreservation Long-term preservation of genetically important strains can be achieved by cryopreservation. Amictic eggs (but not adults) are preserved in liquid nitrogen after they have been impregnated with cryoprotective agents such as dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) or propanediol (Toledo & Kurokura 1990; Toledo et al. 1991; Hadani et al. 1992). This method ensures full preservation of genetic traits of importance to aquaculture and is especially important for those strains that do not produce resting eggs. A small collection of cryopreserved B. plicatilis and B. rotundiformis strains is kept at the authors’ laboratory and serves as an alternative source for live cultures. Since this is a relatively expensive method, it is not suitable for preservation of large numbers of rotifers for direct use as food after thawing.
2.6.3 Resting eggs Artificially produced rotifer resting eggs have been offered as an alternative route for supplying rotifers without depending on the daily production cycle used in marine hatcheries. Resting egg production is genetically determined (Hino & Hirano 1976, 1977), with large variations between rotifers originating from eggs produced by one clone (Lubzens 1989). The production of these eggs can be manipulated by environmental factors, such as salinity, food quantity and quality, rotifer culture density, exchange of culture media and temperature, and varies between B. plicatilis and B. rotundiformis species. (Hino & Hirano 1976, 1977, 1984, 1985, 1988; Hagiwara et al. 1988a,b, 1989; Snell & Hoff 1985; Lubzens et al. 1985, 1993; Snell 1986; Lubzens 1987; Lubzens & Minkoff 1988; Hagiwara & Lee 1991; Hagiwara & Hirayama 1993; Hamada et al. 1993; Kogane et al. 1997).
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
51
Basically, it is relatively easy to obtain rotifer resting eggs, but the main problem is the relative number produced in relation to the invested effort. The first step is choosing an appropriate strain, as their production is genetically determined. For B. plicatilis, cultures should be maintained at salinities below 30 ppt and temperatures should preferably range from 12 to 25°C. Rotifer density should be kept low, not exceeding 150 rotifers ml⫺1, and food (preferably Nannochloropsis sp.) should be provided in adequate quantities. After introducing a rotifer inoculum of 5–10 individuals ml⫺1, the rotifers will start reproducing and, depending on the culture temperature, mictic females carrying male eggs will appear after 2–3 days. This will be followed by the appearance of males and of fertilised females carrying resting eggs, after 4–6 days. These resting eggs will be released from the females at the end of their development and will sink to the bottom of the culture container. With the appearance of resting eggs, the number of females carrying male eggs will start to decline and this will be followed by a decline in the relative abundance of males and reduced production of resting eggs. Most often, cultures at this stage collapse and production of resting eggs is stopped. The production cycle lasts for 10–24 days. The resting eggs can be collected from the debris found at the bottom of the culture container, by sieving the culture water with agitation, through 200 m mesh plankton net, through which the eggs will pass. The material collected on the sieve should be resuspended in clean seawater and the sieving process repeated several times, until most of the eggs have been freed from the debris. Removal of the remaining debris can be achieved by suspending the eggs in clean, diluted seawater (e.g. 10 ppt) in a separating funnel and introducing an aeration tube just above the bottom outlet. A very fine airstream will result in flotation of the debris and sinking of the eggs to the funnel outlet, where they can be collected. The collected eggs should be stored in the dark (in aluminium foil-covered glass tubes or any other container) at a low temperature. The simplest method is to suspend the eggs in capped tubes containing clean or sterile 10 ppt seawater and store them in a refrigerator (Minkoff et al. 1983). More recent results showed that eggs may also be stored in a dried form: desiccated, lyophilised or canned under pressure (Balompapueng et al. 1997b). Hatching of resting eggs is achieved by transferring them from the stored container into fresh seawater and incubation at 10–25°C, with illumination (Minkoff et al. 1983; Hagiwara & Hino 1990). Kogane et al. (1997) showed that a low-temperature treatment could improve the efficiency of resting egg production by culturing B. plicatilis for 20 days at 12°C before transferring them to 25°C. The optimal conditions for production of B. rotundiformis differ from those of B. plicatilis, with resting egg production encouraged at higher salinities in B. rotundiformis (Hagiwara et al. 1989). Mass production of rotifer (B. plicatilis) resting eggs has been reported in 50 m3 tanks (Hagiwara et al. 1993a) and improvements in culture techniques have been tested, including the use of a semi-continuous culture method to maintain relatively low rotifer density and the use of a nylon filter system for removing excess debris (Hagiwara et al. 1993a, 1997; Hagiwara & Hirayama 1993; Hagiwara 1994; Balompapueng et al. 1997a). Methods have been devised for optimal storage of large quantities of resting eggs, including removal of attached bacteria by rinsing eggs with hypochlorite (1.0 mg l⫺1) or sodium nifurstyrenate (5.0 g ml⫺1) for improving hatchability (Balompapueng et al. 1997a,b). Hatching conditions are well established, facilitating the use of resting eggs at the required time (Minkoff et al. 1983; Pourriot & Snell 1983; Hagiwara et al. 1985, 1995c; Hagiwara &
52
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Hino 1989, 1990; Hagiwara 1996; Balompapueng et al. 1997a). These eggs can be used directly for feeding fish larvae (Hagiwara & Hirayama 1993; Hagiwara et al. 1993b) or for initiating mass cultures, but asexual reproductive rates in rotifers hatched from resting eggs may show large fluctuations from those of the parent culture (Lubzens 1989). The cost of producing resting eggs exceeds several-fold that of producing mass-cultured rotifers (Lubzens 1989; Lubzens et al. 2001) and therefore has not yet been extensively adapted as a direct source of food for fish larvae. Moreover, rotifers hatched from artificially produced resting eggs may show a high occurrence of mixis, since the strain chosen for production of resting eggs has been selected for this purpose. Therefore, caution is required in using commercially available resting eggs for initiating mass cultures, as these cultures may show a high incidence of males under specific culture conditions (e.g. low salinity for B. plicatilis).
2.7 Future Directions The prospects of replacing live rotifers as food for early developmental stages of fish larvae are far from feasible, despite considerable efforts in this direction (Tandler 1984, 1985; Lubzens 1987; Kolkovsky & Tandler 1995). Generally speaking, current methodologies of producing and enriching rotifers have succeeded in meeting the demands of the industry. However, the current pressing need for very small live food is difficult to meet, although several ‘super small’ genetic strains have been found and cultured (Hagiwara et al. 2001). Improved methods for predicting the physiological state of rotifers in mass cultures could be helpful in avoiding the collapse of cultures. Using preserved rotifers may alleviate the immediate dependence of hatcheries on the daily production of rotifers. This includes keeping live rotifers at low temperatures or, alternatively, as resting eggs. Cheaper methods for resting egg production of inbred lines will be of great advantage in reaching this goal.
Acknowledgements The financial support for rotifer species and strain cultures (1991–2000) by the Kunin Lunenfeld Foundation is greatly acknowledged. The advice, support and patience of the editor, Dr J. Støttrup, made this review possible.
2.8 References Aoki, S. & Hino, A. (1996) Nitrogen flow in a chemostat culture of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Fish. Sci., 62, 8–14. Assavarree, M., Hagiwara, A., Ide, K., Maruyama, M. & Lubzens, E. (2001a) Low-temperature preservation (at 4°C) of marine rotifer Brachionus. Aquacult. Res., 32, 29–39. Assavaaree, M., Hagiwara, A. & Lubzens, E. (2001b) Factors affecting low temperature preservation of the marine rotifer Brachionus rotundiformis Tschugunoff. Hydrobiologia, 446/447, 355–361. Awaïss, A. (1991) Mass culture and nutritional quality of the freshwater rotifer (Brachionus calyciflorus P.) for grudgeon (Gobio gobio L.) and perch (Perca fluviatus L.) larvae. In: Larvi’91 – Fish
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
53
& Crustacean Larviculture Symposium (Ed. by P. Lavens, P. Sorgeloos, E. Jaspers & F. Ollevier), pp. 113–115. European Aquaculture Society, Special Publication 15, Ghent. Awaïss, A. & Kestemont, P. (1997a) Dynamique de production et qualité nutritive du rotifère d’eau douce Brachionus calyciflorus. Aquat. Living Resourc., 10, 111–120. Awaïss, A. & Kestemont, P. (1997b) An investigation into the mass production of the freshwater rotifer (Brachionus calyciflorus) Pallas. 2. Influence of temperature on the population dynamics. Aquaculture, 105, 337–344. Awaïss, A., Kestemont, P. & Micha, J.C. (1992a) An investigation into the mass production of the freshwater rotifer (Brachionus calyciflorus) Pallas. 1. An eco-physiological approach to nutrition. Aquaculture, 105, 325–336. Awaïss, A., Kestemont, P. & Micha, J.C. (1992b) Nutritional suitability of the rotifer (Brachionus calyciflorus) Pallas for rearing freshwater larvae. J. Appl. Ichthyol., 8, 263–270. Balompapueng, M.D., Hagiwara, A., Nishi, A., Imaizumi, K. & Hirayama, K. (1997a) Resting egg formation of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis using a semi-continuous culture method. Fish. Sci., 63, 236–241. Balompapueng, M.D., Hagiwara, A., Nozaki, Y. & Hirayama, K. (1997b) Preservation of resting eggs of the euryhaline rotifer Brachionus plicatilis O.F. Muller by canning. Hydrobiologia, 358, 163–166. Baylon, J.C. & Failama, N.A. (1999) Larval rearing of the mud crab Scylla serrata in the Philippines. In: Mud Crab Aquaculture and Biology. Proceedings of an international scientific forum held in Darwin, Australia, 21–24 April 1997 (Ed. by C.P. Keenan & A. Blackshaw), pp. 141–146. Australian Center for International Agricultural Research. ACIAR Proceeding No. 78. Bell, M.V., Batty, R.S., Dick, J.R., Fretwell, K., Navarro, J.C. & Sargent, J.R. (1995) Dietary deficiency of docosahexaenoic acid impairs vision at low light intensities in juvenile herring (Clupea harengus L.). Lipids, 30, 440–443. Bessonart, M., Izquierdo, M.S., Salhi, M., Hernandez-Cruz, C.M., Gonzalez, M.M. & FernandezPalacios, H. (1999) Effect of dietary arachidonic acid levels on growth and survival of gilthead seabream (Sparus aurata L.) larvae. Aquaculture, 179, 265–275. Blanch, A.R., Simo, M., Jofre, J.T. & Minkoff, G. (1991) Bacteria associated with hatchery cultivated turbot: are they implicated in rearing success? In: Larvi ’91 – Fish and Crustacean Larviculture Symposium (Ed. by P. Lavens, P. Sorgeloos, E. Jaspers & F. Ollevier), pp. 392–394. European Aquaculture Society, Special Publication No. 15, Ghent. Boehm, E.W., Gibson, O. & Lubzens, E. (2000) Characterization of satellite DNA sequences from commercially important marine rotifers Brachionus plicatilis and Brachionus rotundiformis. Mar. Biotechnol., 2, 38–48. Bower, C.E. & Bidwell, J.P. (1978) Ionization of ammonia in seawater: effect of temperature, pH and salinity. J. Fish. Res. Board Can., 35, 1012–1016. Burbank, S.E. & Snell, T.W. (1994) Rapid toxicity assessment using esterase biomarkers in Brachionus calyciflorus (Rotifera). Environ. Toxicol. Water Qual., 9, 171–178. Chotiyaputta, C. & Hirayama, K. (1978) Food selectivity of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis feeding on phytoplankton. Mar. Biol., 45, 105–111. Clément, P. & Wurdak, E. (1991) Rotifera. In: Microscopic Anatomy of Invertebrates, Vol. 4, Ascheleminthes (Ed. by F.W. Harrison & E.E. Ruppert) pp. 219–297. Wiley-Liss, New York. Clément, P., Wurdak, E. & Amsellem, J. (1983) Behavior and ultrastructure of sensory organs in rotifers. Hydrobiologia, 104, 89–130. Colorni, A., Zmora, O. & Kutin, E.S. (1991) Systematic infection in the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis by an invasive yeast. Bull. Eur. Assoc. Fish Pathol., 11, 116–117. Comps, M. & Menu, B. (1997) Infectious diseases affecting mass production of the marine rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Hydrobiologia, 358, 179–183.
54
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Comps, M., Mari, J., Poisson, F. & Bonami, J.R. (1991a) Biophysical and biochemical properties of an unusual birnavirus pathogenic for rotifers. J. Gen. Virol., 72, 1229–1236. Comps, M., Menu, B., Breuil, G. & Bonami, J.R. (1991b) Viral infection associated with rotifer mortalities in mass culture. Aquaculture, 93, 1–7. Comps, M., Menu, B. & Moreau, V. (1993) Massive infections with fungus of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Bull. Eur. Assoc. Fish Pathol., 13, 28–29. Dabrowski, K. & Blom, J.H. (1994) Ascorbic acid deposition in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) eggs and survival of embryos. Comp. Biochem. Physiol., A108, 129–135. Dabrowski, K. & Ciereszko, A. (1993) Influence of fish size, origin, and stress on ascorbate concentration in vital tissues of hatchery rainbow trout. Prog. Fish Cult., 55, 109–135. De Araujo, A.B., Snell, T.W. & Hagiwara, A. (2000) Effect of unionized ammonia, viscosity and protozoan contamination on the emzyme activity of rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Aquacult. Res., 31, 359–365. De Araujo, A.B., Hagiwara, A. & Snell, T.W. (2001) Effect of unionized ammonia, viscosity and protozoan contamination on reproduction and enzyme activity of the rotifer Brachionus rotundiformis. Hydrobiologia, 446/447, 363–368. De Luca, K., Sendacz, S. & Kubo, E. (1990) Experimentos de cultura do rotífero Brachionus calyciflorus visando sua utilizaça˘o na aqüicultura de água doce. B. Inst. Pesca, 17, 105–115. Epp, R.W. & Winston, P.W. (1977) Osmotic regulation in the brackish-water rotifer Brachionus plicatilis (Muller). J. Exp. Biol., 68, 151–156. Estevez, A., McEvoy, L.A., Bell, J.G. & Sargent, J.R. (1999) Growth, survival, lipid composition and pigmentation of turbot (Scophthalmus maximus) larvae fed live-prey enriched in arachidonic and eicosapentaenoic acids. Aquaculture, 180, 321–343. FAO (1998) The State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture. Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United Nations, Rome. Fernandez-Reiriz, U., Labarta, U. & Ferreiro, M.J. (1993) Effects of commercial enrichment diets on the nutritional value of the rotifer (Brachionus plicatilis). Aquaculture, 112, 195–206. Fjelheim, A.J., Markidis, P., Skjermo, J. & Vadstein, O. (1999) Rotifers (Brachionus plicatilis) as vector for probiotic to turbot larvae (Scophthalmus maximus). In: Towards Predictable Quality. Aquaculture Europe, European Aquaculture Society, Special Publication No. 27, 60. Frolov, A.V. & Pankov, S.L. (1992) The effect of starvation on the biochemical composition of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. J. Mar. Biol. Assoc. UK, 72, 343–356. Frolov, A.V., Pankov, S.L., Geradz, K.N., Pankova, S.A. & Spektrova, L.V. (1991) Influence of the biochemical composition of food on the biochemical composition of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Aquaculture, 97, 181–202. Fu, Y., Hirayama, K. & Natsukari, Y. (1990) Strains of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis having particular patterns of isozymes. In: The Second Asian Fisheries Forum (Ed. by R. Hirano & I. Hanyu), pp. 37–40. Asian Fisheries Society, Manila, The Philippines. Fu, Y., Hirayama, K. & Natsukari, Y. (1991a) Morphological differences between the two types of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis O.F. Muller. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol., 151, 29–41. Fu, Y., Hirayama, K. & Natsukari, Y. (1991b) Genetic divergence between S and L type stains of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis O.F. Muller. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol., 151, 43–56. Fu, Y., Hagiwara, A. & Hirayama, K. (1993) Crossing between seven strains of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, 59, 2009–2016. Fu, Y., Hada, A., Yamashita, T., Yoshida, Y. & Hino, A. (1997) Development of a continuous culture system for stable mass production of the marine rotifer Brachionus. Hydrobiologia, 358, 145–151. Fujita, S. (1979) Culture of red sea bream Pagrus major, and its food. In: Cultivation of Fish Fry and its Live Food (Ed. by E. Styczynska-Jurewicz, T. Backiel, E. Jaspers & J. Persoone), pp. 183–197. European Mariculture Society, Special Publication No. 4, Bredene.
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
55
Fukusho, K. (1989a) Biology and mass production of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis (1). Int. J. Aquacult. Fish. Technol., 1, 232–240. Fukusho, K. (1989b) Biology and mass production of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis (2). Int. J. Aquacult. Fish. Technol., 1, 292–299. Fulks, F. & Main, K.L. (1991) Rotifer and microalgae culture systems. Proc. US–Asia Workshop, Oceanic Insitute, Honolulu, HI, 364 pp. Gallardo, W.G., Hagiwara, A., Tomita, Y. & Snell, T.W. (1999) Effect of growth hormone and ␥-aminobutyric acid on Brachionus plicatilis (Rotifera) reproduction at low food or high ammonia levels. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol., 240, 179–191. Gallardo, W.G., Hagiwara, A., Tomita, Y., Soyano, K. & Snell, T.W. (1997) Effect of some vertebrate and invertebrate hormones on the population growth, mictic female production, and body size of the marine rotifer Brachionus plicatilis Muller. Hydrobiologia, 358, 113–120. Garey, J.R., Schmidt-Rhaesa, A., Near, T.J. & Nadler, S.A. (1998) The evolutionary relationship of rotifers and acanthocephalans. Hydrobiologia, 387/388, 83–91. Gatesoupe, F.J. (1990) The continuous feeding of turbot larvae, Scophthalmus maximus, and the control of the bacterial environment of rotifers. Aquaculture, 89, 139–148. Gatesoupe, F.J. (1991) The effect of three strains of lactic bacteria on the production rate of rotifers, Brachionus plicatilis, and their dietary value for larval turbot, Scophthalmus maximus. Aquaculture, 96, 335–342. Gatesoupe, F.J. (1993) Bacillus sp. spores as food additive for the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis: improvement of their bacterial environment and their dietary value for larval turbot Scophthalmus maximus L. In: Fish Nutrition in Practice (Ed. by S.J. Kaushik & P. Luquet), pp. 561–568. Institut National de la Recherche Agronomique, Paris, Les Colloques, 61. Gatesoupe, F.J. (1999) The use of probiotics in aquaculture. Aquaculture, 180, 147–165. Gilbert, J.J. & Schreiber, D.K. (1995) Induction of diapausing amictic eggs in Synchaeta pectinata. Hydrobiologia, 313/314, 345–350. Gomez, A. & Carvalho, G.R. (2000) Sex, parthogenesis and genetic structure of rotifers: microsatellite analysis of contemporary and resting egg bank populations. Mol. Ecol., 9, 203–214. Gomez, A. & Serra, M. (1995) Behavioral reproductive isolation among sympatric strains of Brachionus plicatilis Müller, 1786: insight into the status of this taxonomic species. Hydrobiologia, 313/314, 111–119. Gomez, A., Clabby, C. & Carvalho, G.R. (1998) Isolation and characterization of microsatellite loci in a cyclically parthenogenetic rotifer, Brachionus plicatilis. Mol. Ecol., 7, 1613–1621. Grisez, L., Reyniers, J., Verdonck, L., Swings, J. & Ollevier, F. (1997) Dominant intestinal microflora of sea bream and sea bass larvae, from two hatcheries, during larval development. Aquaculture, 155, 387–399. Hadani, A., Beddig, S. & Lubzens, E. (1992) Factors affecting survival of cryopreserved rotifers (Brachionus plicatilis O.F. Muller). In: Progress in Aquaculture Research (Ed. by B. Moav, V. Hilge & H. Rosenthal), pp. 253–267. European Aquaculture Society, Special Publication No. 17, Ostend. Hagiwara, A. (1994) Practical use of rotifer cysts. Isr. J. Aquacult.-Bamidgeh, 46, 13–21. Hagiwara, A. (1996) Appearance of floating resting eggs in the rotifers Brachionus plicatilis and B. rotundiformis. Bull. Fac. Fish. Nagasaki Univ., 77, 111–115. Hagiwara, A. & Hino, A. (1989) Effect of incubation and preservation on resting egg hatching and mixis in the derived clones of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Hydrobiologia, 186/187, 415–421. Hagiwara, A. & Hino, A. (1990) Feeding history and hatching of resting eggs in the marine rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, 56, 1965–1971. Hagiwara, A. & Hirayama, K. (1993) Preservation of rotifers and its application in the finfish hatchery. In: Proc. Finfish Hatchery in Asia ’91 (Ed. by C.-S. Lee, M.S. Su & I. Liao), pp. 61–71. TLM Conference Proceedings, Tungkang Marine Laboratory, Taiwan Fisheries Research Institute, Tungkang, Taiwan, 3.
56
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Hagiwara, A. & Lee, C.-S. (1991) Resting egg formation of the L- and S-type rotifer Brachionus plicatilis under different water temperature. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, 57, 1645–1650. Hagiwara, A., Hino, A. & Hirano, R. (1985) Combined effects of environmental conditions on the hatching of fertilized eggs of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis collected from an outdoor pond. Bull. Jpn. Soc. Scient. Fish., 51, 755–758. Hagiwara, A., Hino, A. & Hirano, R. (1988a) Effects of temperature and chlorinity on resting egg formation in the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, 54, 569–575. Hagiwara, A., Hino, A. & Hirano, R. (1988b) Comparison of resting egg formation among five Japanese stocks of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, 54, 577–580. Hagiwara, A., Lee, C.-S., Miyamoto, G. & Hino, H. (1989) Resting egg formation and hatching of the S-type rotifer Brachionus plicatilis at varying salinities. Mar. Biol., 103, 327–332. Hagiwara, A., Hamada, K., Nishi, A., Imaizumi, K. & Hirayama, K. (1993a) Mass production of rotifer Brachionus plicatilis resting eggs in 50 m3 tanks. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, 59, 93–98. Hagiwara, A., Hamada, K., Nishi, A., Imaizumi, K. & Hirayama, K. (1993b) Dietary value of neonates from rotifer Brachionus plicatilis resting eggs for red sea bream larvae. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, 59, 99–104. Hagiwara, A., Hamada, K., Hori, S. & Hirayama, K. (1994) Increased sexual reproduction in Brachionus plicatilis with the addition of bacteria and rotifer extracts. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol., 181, 1–8. Hagiwara, A., Jung, M.-M., Sato, T. & Hirayama, K. (1995a) Interspecific relations between marine rotifer Brachionus rotundiformis and zooplankton species contaminating in the rotifer mass culture tank. Fish. Sci., 61, 623–627. Hagiwara, A., Kotani, T., Snell, T.W., Assava-Aree, M. & Hirayama, K. (1995b) Morphology, reproduction, genetics, and mating behavior of small, tropical marine Brachionus strains (Rotifera). J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol., 194, 25–37. Hagiwara, A., Nishi, N., Kawahara, F., Tominaga, K. & Hirayama, K. (1995c) Resting eggs of the marine rotifer Brachionus plicatilis Muller: development and effect of irradiation on hatching. Hydrobiologia, 313/314, 223–229. Hagiwara, A., Balompapueng, M.D., Munuswamy, N. & Hirayama, K. (1997) Mass production and preservation of the resting eggs of the euryhaline rotifer Brachionus plicatilis and B. rotundiformis. Aquaculture, 155, 223–230. Hagiwara, A., Yamamiya, N. & De Araujo, A.B. (1998) Effect of water viscosity on the population growth of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis Muller. Hydrobiologia, 386/387, 489–494. Hagiwara, A., Gallardo, W.G., Assavaaree, M., Kotani, T. & De Araujo, A.B. (2001) Live food production in Japan: recent progress and future aspects. Aquaculture, 200, 111–127. Hamada, K., Hagiwara, A. & Hirayama, K. (1993) Use of preserved diets for rotifer Brachionus plicatilis resting egg formation. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, 59, 85–91. Hansen, B., Wernberg-Moller, T. & Wittrup, L. (1997) Particle grazing efficiency and specific growth of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis (Muller). J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol., 215, 217–233. Hara, K., Arano, H. & Ishihara, T. (1984a) Some enzymatic properties of alkaline proteases of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Bull. Jpn. Soc. Scient. Fish., 50, 1611–1616. Hara, K., Arano, H. & Ishihara, T. (1984b) Purification of alkaline proteases of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Bull. Jpn. Soc. Scient. Fish., 50, 1605–1609. Hara, K., Pangkey, H., Osatomi, K., Yatsuda, K. & Hagiwara, A. (1997) Some properties of -1,3-glucans hydrolyzing enzymes from the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Hydrobiologia, 358, 89–94. Hayashi, M., Yukino, T., Maruyama, I., Kido, S. & Kitaoka, S. (2001) Uptake and accumulation of exogenous docosahexaenoic acid by Chlorella. Biosci. Biotech. Biochem., 65, 202–204.
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
57
Hino, A. & Hirano, R. (1976) Ecological studies on the mechanism of bisexual reproduction in the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis – I. General aspects of bisexual reproduction inducing factors. Bull. Jpn. Soc. Scient. Fish., 42, 1093–1099. Hino, A. & Hirano, R. (1977) Ecological studies on the mechanism of bisexual reproduction in the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis – II. Effect of cumulative parthogenetic generation on the frequency of bisexual reproduction. Bull. Jpn. Soc. Scient. Fish., 43, 1147–1155. Hino, A. & Hirano, R. (1980) Relationship between body size of rotifer Brachionus plicatilis and the maximum size of particle ingested. Bull. Jpn. Soc. Scient. Fish., 46, 1217–1222. Hino, A. & Hirano, R. (1984) Relationship between water temperature and bisexual reproduction in the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, 50, 1481–1485. Hino, A. & Hirano, R. (1985) Relationship between the temperature given at the time of fertilized egg formation and bisexual reproduction pattern in the deriving strain of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, 51, 511–514. Hino, A. & Hirano, R. (1988) Relationship between water chlorinity and bisexual reproduction rate in the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, 54, 1139–1332. Hino, A., Aoki, S. & Ushiro, M. (1997) Nitrogen-flow in the rotifer Brachionus rotundiformis and its significance in mass cultures. Hydrobiologia, 358, 77–82. Hirano, K. (1987) Studies on the culture of the rotifer (Brachionus plicatilis O.F. Muller). Bull. Fac. Agric. Miyazaki Univ., 34, 57–122. Hirata, H. (1964) Cultivation of live food organisms at the Yashima Station. Saibai-Gyogyo, 2–4, 4. (In Japanese.) Hirata, H. (1979) Rotifer culture in Japan. In: Cultivation of Fish Fry and its Live Food. (Ed. by E. Styczynska-Jurewicz, T. Backiel, E. Jaspers & J. Persoone), pp. 361–375. European Mariculture Society, Special Publication No. 4, Bredene. Hirata, H. (1980) Culture methods of the marine rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Min. Rev. Data File Res., 1, 27–46. Hirayama, K. (1990) A physiological approach to problems of mass culture of the rotifer. NOAA Technical Report, No. NMFS 85, pp. 73–79. US Department of Commerce. Hirayama, K. & Funamoto, H. (1983) Supplementary effect of several nutrients on nutritive deficiency of baker’s yeast of population growth of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Bull. Jpn. Soc. Scient. Fish., 49, 505–510. Hirayama, K. & Ogawa, S. (1972) Fundamental studies on physiology of rotifer for its mass culture. I. Filter feeding of rotifer. Bull. Jap. Soc. Sci. Fish., 38, 1207–1214. Hirayama, K. & Rumengan, I.F.M. (1993) The fecundity patterns of S and L type rotifers of Brachionus plicatilis. Hydrobiologia, 255/256, 153–157. Hirayama, K., Takagi, K. & Kimura, H. (1979) Nutritional effect of eight species of marine phytoplankton on population growth of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Bull. Jpn. Soc. Scient. Fish., 45, 11–16. Isik, O., Sarihan, E., Kusvuran, E., Gul, O. & Erbatur, O. (1999) Comparison of the fatty acid composition of the freshwater fish larvae Tilapia zillii, the rotifer Brachionus calyciflorus, and the microalgae Scenedesmus abundans, Monoraphidium minitum and Chlorella vulgaris in the algae–rotifer–fish larvae food chains. Aquaculture, 174, 299–311. Ito, T. (1960) On the culture of the mixohaline rotifer Brachionus plicatilis O.F. Muller, in sea water. Rep. Fac. Fish. Prefect. Univ. Mie, 3, 708–740. Ivlev, V.S. (1960) On the utilization of food by planktophage fishes. Bull. Math. Biophys., 22, 371–389. James, C.M. & Abu-Rezeq, T. (1989a) Intensive rotifer cultures using chemostats. Hydrobiologia, 186/187, 423–430. James, C.M. & Abu-Rezeq, T. (1989b) An intensive chemostats culture system for the production of rotifers for aquaculture. Aquaculture, 81, 291–301.
58
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
James, C.M. & Abu-Rezq, T. (1990) Efficiency of rotifer chemostats in relation to salinity regimes for producing rotifers for aquaculture. J. Aqua. Trop., 5, 103–116. James, C.M., Bou-Abbas, M., Al-Khars, A.M., Al-Hinty, S. & Salman, A.E. (1983) Production of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis for aquaculture in Kuwait. Hydrobiologia, 104, 77–84. James, C.M., Dias, P.A. & Salman, A.E. (1987) The use of marine yeast (Candida sp.) and bakers yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) in combination with Chlorella sp. for mass culture of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Hydrobiologia, 147, 263–268. Juchelka, C.M. & Snell, T.W. (1994) Rapid toxicity assessment using rotifer ingestion rate. Arch. Environ. Contam. Toxicol., 26, 549–554. Jung, M.-M., Hagiwara, A. & Hirayama, K. (1997) Interspecific interactions in the marine rotifer microcosm. Hydrobiologia, 358, 121–126. Kafuku, T. & Ikenoue, H. (eds) (1983) Modern methods of aquaculture in Japan. Development in Aquaculture and Fisheries Science, 11. Kodansha, Tokyo; Elsevier, Amsterdam. Keenan, C.P. & Blackshaw, A. (1999) Mud Crab Aquaculture and Biology. Proceedings of an International Scientific Forum held in Darwin, Australia, 21–24 April 1997. ACIAR Proceedings No. 78. King, C.E. & Snell, T.W. (1977) Sexual recombination in rotifers. Heredity, 39, 357–360. Kogane, T., Hagiwara, A. & Imaizumi, K. (1997) Temperature conditions enhancing resting egg production of the euryhaline rotifer Brachionus plicatilis O.F. Muller (Kamiura strain). Hydrobiologia, 358, 167–171. Kolkovski, S. & Tandler, A. (1995) Why microdiets are still inadequate as available alternative to live zooplankters for developing marine fish larvae. Spec. Publ. Eur. Aquacult. Soc., 24, 265–266. Korstad, J., Neyt, A., Danielsen, T., Overrein I. & Olsen, Y. (1995) Use of swimming speed and egg ratio as predictors of the status of rotifer cultures in aquaculture. Hydrobiologia, 313/314, 395–398. Koste, W. & Shiel, R.J. (1987) Rotifers from Australian inland waters. II. Epiphanidae and Brachionidae (Rotifera: Monogononta). Invert. Taxon., 7, 949–1021. Kotani, T., Hagiwara, A. & Snell, T.W. (1997) Genetic variation among marine Brachionus strains and function of mate recognition pheromone (MRP). Hydrobiologia, 358, 105–112. Kotani, T., Ozaki, M., Matsuoka, K., Snell, T.W. & Hagiwara, H. (2001) Reproductive isolation among geographically and temporally isolated marine Brachionus strains. Hydrobiologia, 446/447, 283–290. Koven, W., Barr, Y., Lutzky, S., et al. (2001) The effect of dietary arachidonic acid (20:4n-6) on growth, survival and resistance to handling stress in gilthead seabream (Sparus aurata) larvae. Aquaculture, 193, 107–122. Kuhle, K. & Kleinow, W. (1985) Measurement of hydrolytic enzyme in homogenates from Brachionus plicatilis (Rotatoria). Comp. Biochem. Physiol., B81, 437–442. Kuhle, K. & Kleinow, W. (1989) Localization of hydrolytic enzyme activity within cellular fractions from Brachionus plicatilis (Rotatoria). Comp. Biochem. Physiol., B93, 565–574. Kuhle, K. & Kleinow, W. (1990) Glycosidases in Brachionus plicatilis (Rotatoria). Comp. Biochem. Physiol., B95, 393–402. Lebedeva, L.I. & Orlenko, O.N. (1995) Feeding rate of Brachionus plicatilis O.F. Müller on two types of food depending on ambient temperature and salinity. Int. Rev. Ges. Hydrobiol., 80, 77–87. Li, S., Zeng, C., Tang, H., Wang, G. & Lin, Q. (1999) Investigations into the reproductive and larval culture biology of mud crab, Scylla paramamosain: a research overview. In: Mud Crab Aquaculture and Biology. Proceedings of an International Scientific Forum held in Darwin, Australia, 21–24 April 1997 (Ed. by C.P. Keenan & A. Blackshaw), pp. 121–124. Australian Center for International Agricultural Research. ACIAR Proceedings No. 78.
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
59
Lie, O., Haaland, H., Hemre, G.-I., et al. (1997) Nutritional composition of rotifers following a change in diet from yeast emulsified oil to microalgae. Aquacult. Int., 5, 427–438. Lim, L.C. & Wong, C.C. (1997) Use of the rotifer, Brachionus calyciflorus Pallas, in freshwater ornamental fish larviculture. Hydrobiologia, 358, 269–273. Lubzens, E. (1981) Rotifer resting eggs and their application to marine aquaculture. Spec. Publ. Eur. Maricult. Soc., 6, 163–179. Lubzens, E. (1987) Raising rotifers for use in aquaculture. Hydrobiologia, 147, 245–255. Lubzens, E. (1989) Possible use of rotifer resting eggs and preserved live rotifers (Brachionus plicatilis) in aquaculture and mariculture. In: Aquaculture – A Biotechnology in Progress (Ed. by N. De Paw, E. Jaspers & H. Ackeford), pp. 741–750. European Aquaculture Society, Bredene. Lubzens, E. & Minkoff, G. (1988) Influence of the age of algae fed to rotifers (Brachionus plicatilis O.F. Muller) on the expression of mixis in their progenies. Oecologia, 76, 430–435. Lubzens, E., Minkoff, G. & Marom, S. (1985) Salinity dependence of sexual and asexual reproduction in the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Mar. Biol., 85, 123–126. Lubzens, E., Rothbard, S., Blumenthal, A., et al. (1987) Possible use of Brachionus plicatilis (O.F. Muller) as food for freshwater cyprinid larvae. Aquaculture, 60, 143–155. Lubzens, E., Tandler, A. & Minkoff, G. (1989) Rotifers as food in aquaculture. Hydrobiologia, 186/187, 387–400. Lubzens, E., Kolodny, G., Perry, B., Galai, N., Sheshinski, R. & Wax, Y. (1990) Factors affecting survival of rotifers (Brachionus plicatilis) culture. Aquaculture, 133, 295–309. Lubzens, E., Wax, Y., Minkoff, G. & Adler, F. (1993) A model evaluating the contribution of environmental factors to the production of resting eggs in the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Hydrobiologia, 255/256, 127–138. Lubzens, E., Gibson, O., Zmora, O. & Sukenik, A. (1995a) Potential advantages of frozen algae (Nannochloropsis sp.) for rotifer (Brachionus plicatilis) culture. Aquaculture, 133, 295–309. Lubzens, E., Rankevich, D., Kolodny, G., Gibson, O., Cohen, A. & Khayat, M. (1995b) Physiological adaptations in the survival of rotifers (Brachionus plicatilis O.F. Muller) at low temperatures. Hydrobiologia, 313/314, 175–183. Lubzens, E., Minkoff, G., Barr, Y. & Zmora, O. (1997) Mariculture in Israel – past achievements and future directions in raising rotifers as food for marine fish larvae. Hydrobiologia, 358, 13–20. Lubzens, E., Zmora, O. & Barr, Y. (2001) Biotechnology and aquaculture of rotifers. Hydrobiologia, 446/447, 337–353. Ludwig, G.M. (1994) Tank culture of the sunshine bass Morone chrysops ⫻ M. saxatilis fry with freshwater rotifers Brachionus calyciflorus and salmon starter meal as first food sources. J. World Aquacult. Soc., 25, 337–341. Maeda, M. & Hino, A. (1991) Environmental management for mass culture of rotifer, Brachionus plicatilis. In: Rotifer and Microalgae Culture Systems (Ed. by W. Fulks & K.L. Main), pp. 125–133. Proc. US–Asia Workshop. Oceanic Institute, Honolulu, HI. Maeda, M., Nogami, K., Kanematsu, M. & Hirayama. K. (1997) The concept of biological control method in aquaculture. Hydrobiologica, 358, 285–290. Mann, D., Asakawa, T. & Pizzutto, M. (1999) Development of a hatchery system for larvae of the mud crab Scylla serrata at Baribie Island Aquaculture Research Centre. In: Mud Crab Aquaculture and Biology. Proceedings of an International Scientific Forum held in Darwin, Australia, 21–24 April 1997 (Ed. by C.P. Keenan & A. Blackshaw), pp. 153–158. Australian Center for International Agricultural Research. ACIAR Proceeding No. 78. Markridis, P. & Olsen, Y. (1999) Protein depletion of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis during starvation. Aquaculture, 174, 343–353.
60
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Markridis, P., Bergh, O., Fiellheim, A.J., Skjermo, J. & Vadstein, O. (1999) Microbial control of live food cultures. In: Towards Predictable Quality. Aquaculture Europe 99 (Ed. by L. Laird & H. Reinertsen), pp. 155–157. European Aquaculture Society, Special Publication No. 27, Ostend. Markridis, O., Fjelheim, A.J., Skjermo, J. & Vadstein, O. (2000) Control of bacterial flora of Brachionus plicatilis and Artemia franciscana by incubation in bacterial suspensions. Aquaculture, 185, 207–218. Melone, G., Ricci, C., Segers, H. & Wallace, R.L. (1998) Phylogenetic relationship of phylum Rotifera with emphasis on the families of Bdelloidea. Hydrobiologia, 387/388, 101–107. Merchie, G., Lavens, P. & Sorgeloos, P. (1997) Optimization of dietary vitamin C in fish and crustacean larvae: a review. Aquaculture, 155, 165–181. Michaelis, L. & Menten, M.M. (1913) Die Kinetik der Invertinwirkung. Biochem. Z., 49, 333–369. Minkoff, G., Lubzens, E. & Kahan, D. (1983) Environmental factors affecting hatching of rotifer (Brachionus plicatilis) resting eggs. Hydrobiologia, 104, 61–69. Munro, P.D., Henderson, R.J., Barbour, A. & Birkbeck, T.H. (1999) Partial decontamination of rotifers with ultraviolet radiation: the effect of changes in the bacterial load and flora of rotifers on mortalities in start-feeding larval turbot. Aquaculture, 170, 229–244. Nagata, W.D. & Hirata, H. (1986) Mariculture in Japan: past, present and future perspectives. Min. Rev. Data File Fish. Res., 4, 1–38. Nagata, W.D. & Whyte, J.N.C. (1992) Effect of yeast and algal diets on the growth and biochemical composition of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis (Muller) in culture. Aquacult. Fish. Manage., 23, 13–21. Navarro, N. (1999) Feeding behaviour of the rotifers Brachionus plicatilis and Brachionus rotundiformis with two types of food: live and freeze-dried microalgae. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol., 237, 75–87. Navarro, N. & Yufera, M. (1998) Population dynamics of rotifers (Brachionus plicatilis and Brachionus rotundiformis) in semicontinuous culture fed freeze-dried microalgae: influence of dilution rate. Aquaculture, 166, 297–309. Nichols, D.S., Hart, P., Nichols, P.D. & McMeekin, T.A. (1996) Enrichment of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis fed an Antarctic bacterium containing polyunsaturated fatty acids. Aquaculture, 147, 115–125. Nogrady, T., Wallace, R.L. & Snell, T.W. (1993) Rotifera. Vol. 1. Biology, Ecology and Systematics. SPB Academic Publishing, The Hague. Øie, G. & Olsen, Y. (1997) Protein and lipid content of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis during variable growth and feeding conditions. Hydrobiologia, 358, 251–258. Olsen, Y., Reitan, K.I. & Vadstein, O. (1993) Dependence of temperature on loss rates of rotifers, lipids and 3 fatty acids in starved Brachionus plicatilis cultures. Hydrobiologia, 255/256, 13–20. Owen, J.M., Adron, J.W., Middleton, C. & Cowey, C.B. (1975) Elongation and desaturation of dietary fatty acids in turbot (Scophthalmus maximus L.) and rainbow trout (Salmo gaidneri Rich). Lipids, 10, 528–531. Payne, M.F. & Rippingale, R.J. (2001) Intensive cultivation of the calanoid copepod Gladioferens imparipes. Aquaculture, 201, 329–342. Polo, A., Yufera, M. & Pascual, E. (1992) Feeding and growth of gilthead seabream (Sparus aurata L.) larvae in relation to size of the rotifer strain used as food. Aquaculture, 103, 45–54. Pontin, R.M. (1978) A Key to the Freshwater Planktonic and Semi-planktonic Rotifera of the British Isles. Freshwater Biological Association, Scientific Publication No. 38, Cumbria. Pourriot, R. (1977) Food and feeding habit of rotifera. Arch. Hydrobiol. Beih., 8, 243–260. Pourriot, R. & Snell, T.W. (1983). Resting eggs in rotifers. Hydrobiologia, 104, 213–224. Quinitio, E.T., Parado-Estepa, F. & Alava, V. (1999) Development of hatchery techniques for mud crab Scylla serrata (Forskal): comparison of feeding schemes. In: Mud Crab Aquaculture and Biology. Proceedings of an International Scientific Forum held in Darwin, Australia, 21–24 April
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
61
1997. (Ed. by C.P. Keenan & A. Blackshaw), pp. 125–130. Australian Center for International Agricultural Research. ACIAR Proceedings No. 78. Rainuzzo, J.R., Reitan, K.I. & Olsen, Y. (1994) Effect of short- and long term enrichment on total lipids, lipid class and fatty acid composition. Aquacult. Int., 2, 19–32. Rainuzzo, J.R., Reitan, K.I. & Olsen, Y. (1997) The significance of lipids at early stages of marine fish: a review. Aquaculture, 155, 103–115. Reitan, K.I., Rainuzzo, J.R., Øie, G. & Olsen, Y. (1993) Nutritional effects of algal addition in first-feeding of turbot (Scophthalmus maximus L.) larvae. Aquaculture, 118, 257–275. Ressem, H., Zmora, O. & Barr, Y. (2001) Improvement of mass-culture of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis in hatchery of cold seawater fish. In: New Species: New technologies (Compiled by E. Kjorsvik & S. Stead; layout and proceeding by S. Vaneroose, H. Joncheere & L. Aspeslagh), pp. 229–230. Aquaculture Europe 2001. European Aquaculture Society, Special Publication No. 29. Ricci, C. (1983) Rotifera or Rotatoria? Hydrobiologia, 104, 1–2. Ricci, C. (2001) Dormancy patterns in rotifers. Hydrobiologia, 446/447, 1–11. Rico-Martinez, R. & Dodson, S.I. (1992) Culture of the rotifer Brachionus calyciflorus Pallas. Aquaculture, 105, 191–199. Rico-Martinez, R. & Snell, T.W. (1995) Mating behavior and mate recognition pheromone blocking of male receptors in Brachionus plicatilis Müller (Rotifera). Hydrobiologia, 313/314, 105–110. Rombaut, G., Dhert, Ph., Vandenberghe, J., Verschuere, L., Sorgeloos, P. & Verstraete, W. (1999a) Selection of bacteria enhancing the growth rate of axenically hatched rotifers (Brachionus plicatilis). Aquaculture, 176, 195–207. Rombaut, G., Vershuere, L., Dhert, Ph., Sorgeloos, P. & Verstraete, W. (1999b) Multi-component probiotic for live feed (Brachionus plicatilis) cultures. In: Towards Predictable Quality (Ed. by L. Laird & H. Reinertsen), pp. 201–202. Aquaculture Ostend. Rothhaupt, K.O. (1990a) Differences in particle size-dependent feeding efficiencies of closely related rotifer species. Limnol. Oceanogr., 35, 16–23. Rothhaupt, K.O. (1990b) Changes in the functional responses of the rotifer Brachionus calyciflorus with particle size. Limnol. Oceanogr., 35, 24–32. Rothhaupt, K.O. (1990c) Population growth rates of two closely related rotifer species: effects of food quantity, particle size, and nutritional quality. Freshwat. Biol., 23, 561–570. Rumengan, I.F.M. & Hirayama, K. (1990) Growth responses of genetically distinct S and L type rotifer (Brachionus plicatilis) strains to different temperatures. In: The Second Asian Fisheries Forum (Ed. by R. Hirano & I. Hanyu), pp. 33–35. Asian Fisheries Society, Manila, The Philippines. Rumengan, I.F.M., Kayano, H. & Hirayama, K. (1991) Karyotypes of S-type and L-type rotifers Brachionus plicatilis Muller, O.F. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol., 154, 171–176. Ruttner-Kolisko, A. (1974) Planktonic rotifers: biology and taxonomy. Die Binnengewässer (Suppl.), 26, 1–146. Samocha, T.M., Uziel, N. & Browdy, C.L. (1989) The effect of feeding two prey organisms, nauplii of Artemia and rotifers, Brachionus plicatilis (Muller), upon survival and growth of larval marine shrimp, Penaeus semisulcatus (de Haan). Aquaculture, 77, 11–19. Sargent, J.R., McEvoy, L.A. & Bell, J.G. (1997) Requirements, presentation and sources of unsaturated fatty acids in marine fish larval feeds. Aquaculture, 155, 117–127. Sargent, J., McEvoy, L., Estevez, A., et al. (1999) Lipid nutrition of marine fish during early development: current status and future directions. Aquaculture, 179, 217–229. Satuito, C.G. & Hirayama, K. (1991) Supplementary effect of vitamin C and squid oil on the nutritional value of baker’s yeast for the population growth of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Bull. Fac. Fish. Nagasaki Univ., 69, 7–11.
62
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Schneider, J.C., Livne, A., Sukenik, A. & Roussler, P. (1995) A mutant of Nannochloropsis deficient in eicosapentaenoic acid production. Phytochemistry, 40, 807–814. Scott, J.M. (1981) The vitamin B12 requirement of the marine rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. J. Mar. Biol. Assoc. UK, 61, 983–994. Segers, H. (1995) Nomenclatural consequences of some recent studies on Brachionus plicatilis (Rotifera, Brachionidae). Hydrobiologia, 313/314, 121–122. Segers, H. (1998) An analysis of taxonomic studies on Rotifera: a case study. Hydrobiologia, 387/388, 9–14. Serra, M. & King, C.E. (1999) Optimal rates of bisexual reproduction in cyclic parthenogens with density-dependent growth. J. Evol. Biol., 12, 263–271. Serra, M., Gomez, A. & Carmona, M.J. (1998) Ecological genetics of Brachionus. Hydrobiologia, 387/388, 373–384. Skjermo, J. & Vadstein, O. (1999) Techniques for microbial control in the intensive rearing of marine larvae. Aquaculture, 177, 333–343. Snell, T.W. (1986) Effect of temperature, salinity and food level on sexual and asexual reproduction in Brachionus plicatilis (Rotifera). Mar. Biol., 92, 157–162. Snell, T.W. (1987) Sex, population dynamics and resting egg production in rotifers. Hydrobiologia, 144, 105–111. Snell, T.W. & Boyer, E.M. (1988) Threshold for mictic female production in the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol., 124, 73–85. Snell, T.W. & Carrillo, K. (1984) Body size variation among strains of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Aquaculture, 37, 359–367. Snell, T.W. & Hawkins, C.A. (1983) Behavioral reproductive isolation among populations of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Evolution, 37, 1294–1305. Snell, T.W. & Hoff, F.H. (1985) The effect of environmental factors on resting egg production in the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. J. World Maricult. Soc., 16, 484–497. Snell, T.W. & Hoff, F.H. (1988) Recent advances in rotifer culture. Aquacult. Mag., 9/10, 41–45. Snell, T.W. & Janssen, C. (1995) Rotifers in ecotoxicology: a review. Hydrobiologia, 313/314, 231–247. Snell, T.W. & Janssen, C. (1998) Microscale toxicity testing with rotifers. In: Microscale Testing in Aquatic Toxicology (Ed. by G. Wells, K. Lee & C. Blaise), pp. 409–422. CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL. Snell, T.W. & Nacionales, M.A. (1990) Sex pheromone communication in Brachionus plicatilis (Rotifera). Comp. Biochem. Physiol., A97, 211–216. Snell, T.W., Childress, M.J., Boyer, E.M. & Hoff, F.H. (1987) Assessing the status of rotifer mass cultures. J. World Aquacult. Soc., 18, 270–277. Snell, T.W., Childress, M.J. & Winkler, B.C. (1988) Characteristics of the mate recognition factor in the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Comp. Biochem. Physiol., A89, 481–485. Snell, T.W., Rico-Martinez, R., Kelly, L.S. & Battle, T.E. (1995) Identification of a sex pheromone from a rotifer. Mar. Biol., 123, 347–353. Støttrup, J.G. (2000) The elusive copepods: their production and suitability in marine aquaculture. Aquacult. Res., 31, 703–711. Støttrup, J.G. & Norsker, N.H. (1997) Production and use of copepods in marine fish larviculture. Aquaculture, 155, 231–248. Suantika, G., Dhert, P., Nurhudah, N. & Sorgeloos, P. (2000) High-density production of rotifer Brachionus plicatilis in recirculated system: consideration of water quality, zootechnical and nutrient aspects. Aquacult. Eng., 21, 201–214. Suantika, G., Dhert, P., Rombaut, G., Vandenberghe, J., De Wolf, T. & Sorgeloos, P. (2001) The use of ozone in a high density recirculation system for rotifers. Aquaculture, 201, 35–49.
Production and Nutritional Value of Rotifers
63
Takeyama, H., Iwamoto, K., Hara, S., Takano, H. & Matsunaga, T. (1996) DHA enrichment of rotifers: a simple two-step culture using the unicellular algae Chlorella reularis and Isochrysis galbana. J. Mar. Biotechnol., 3, 244–247. Tamaru, C.S., Lee, C.-S. & Ako, H. (1991) Improving the larval rearing of striped mullet (Mugil cephalus) by manipulating quantity and quality of the rotifer, Brachionus plicatilis. Proc. US–Asia Workshop, pp. 89–103. Oceanic Institute, Honolulu, HI. Tamaru, C.S., Murashige, R., Lee, C.-S., Ako, H. & Sato, V. (1993) Rotifers fed various diets of baker’s yeast and/or Nannochloropsis oculata and their effect on the growth and survival of striped mullet (Mugil cephalus) and milkfish (Chanos chanos) larvae. Aquaculture, 110, 361–372. Tandler, A. (1984/1985) Overview: food for the larval stages of marine fish. Live or inert? Isr. J. Zool., 33, 161–166. Teshima, S.-I., Kanazawa, A., Horinouchi, K., Yamasaki S. & Hirata, H. (1987) Phospholipids of the rotifer, prawn, and larval fish. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, 53, 609–615. Toledo, J.D. & Kurokura, H. (1990) Cryopreservation of the euryhaline rotifer Brachionus plicatilis embryos. Aquaculture, 91, 385–394. Toledo, J.D., Kurokura, H. & Nakagawa, H. (1991) Cryopreservation of different strains of the euryhaline rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, 57, 1347–1350. Verdonck, L., Grisez, L., Sweetman, E., et al. (1997) Vibrio associated with routine production of Brachionus plicatilis. Aquaculture, 149, 203–214. Verpraet, R., Chair, M., Leger, P., Nelis, H., Sorgeloos, P. & De Leenheer, A. (1992) Live-food mediated drug delivery as a tool for disease treatment in larviculture. The enrichment of therapeutics in rotifers and Artemia nauplii. Aquacult. Eng., 11, 133–139. Wallace, R.L. & Snell, T.W. (1991) Rotifera. In: Ecology and Classification of North American Freshwater Invertebrates (Ed. by J.H. Thorpe & A.P. Covich), pp. 187–247. Academic Press, New York. Walz, N. (1993) Plankton regulation dynamics: experiments and models in rotifer continuous cultures. Ecol. Stud. 98, 308 pp. Springer, Berlin. Walz, N., Hintze, T. & Rusche, R. (1997) Algae and rotifer turbidostats: studies on stability of live food cultures. Hydrobiologia, 358, 127–132. Watanabe, T., Kitajima, C. & Fujita, S. (1983) Nutritional values of live organisms used in Japan for mass propagation of fish: a review. Aquaculture, 34, 115–143. Wethmar, C. & Kleinow, W. (1993) Characterization of a 27 kDa endopeptidase and detection of a proteinase-inhibitor in homogenates of Brachionus plicatilis (Rotifera). Comp. Biochem. Physiol., B106, 359–368. Whyte, J.N.C. & Nagata, W.D. (1990) Carbohydrate and fatty acid composition of the rotifer, Brachionus plicatilis, fed monospecific diets of yeast and phytoplankton. Aquaculture, 89, 263–368. Yoshimura, K., Hagiwara, A., Yoshimatsu T. & Kitajima, C. (1996) Culture technology of marine rotifers and implication for intensive culture of marine fish in Japan. Mar. Freshwat. Res., 47, 217–222. Yoshimura, K., Usuki, K., Yoshimatsu, T., Kitajima, C. & Hagiwara, A. (1997) Recent developments of a high density mass culture system for the rotifer Brachionus rotundiformis Tschugunoff. Hydrobiologia, 358, 139–144. Yu, J.-P., Hino, A., Hirano R. & Hirayama, K. (1988) Vitamin B12 producing bacteria as a nutritive complement for the culture of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, 54, 1873–1880. Yu, J.-P., Hino, A., Ushiro, M. & Maeda, M. (1989) Function of bacteria as vitamin B12 producers during mass culture of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, 55, 1799–1806. Yu, J.P., Hino, A., Noguchi, T. & Wakabayashi, H. (1990) Toxicity of Vibrio alginolyticus on the survival of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis. Nippon Suisan Gakkaishi, 56, 1455–1460.
64
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Yufera, M. & Pascual, E. (1989) Biomass and elemental composition (C.H.N.) of the rotifer Brachionus plicatilis cultured as larval food. Hydrobiologia, 186/187, 371–374. Yufera, M., Parra, G. & Pascual, E. (1997) Energy content of rotifers (Brachionus plicatilis and Brachionus rotundiformis) in relation to temperature. Hydrobiologia, 358, 83–87. Zmora, O. (1991) Management, production and disease interaction in rotifer culture. In: Larvi ’91 – Fish and Crustacean Larviculture Symposium (Ed. by P. Lavens, P. Sorgeloos, E. Jaspers & F. Ollevier), p. 104. European Aquaculture Society, Special Publication No. 15, Ghent.
Chapter 3
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia Jean Dhont and Gilbert Van Stappen
3.1 Introduction Artemia has probably been known and used within its natural distribution areas for centuries. However, its fame elsewhere only began to rise in the 1930s when some investigators adopted it as a convenient replacement for the natural diet of fish larvae, thus realising the first breakthrough in the culture of commercially important fish species (Sorgeloos 1980). In the 1950s, Artemia cysts were still predominantly marketed for the aquarium and pet trade at costs as low as US $10 kg⫺1. There were only two commercial sources: the coastal saltworks in the San Francisco Bay (SFB, California, USA) and the Great Salt Lake (GSL, Utah, USA). With fish and shrimp aquaculture developing from the early 1960s, new marketing opportunities were created for Artemia cysts. However, by the mid-1970s, increased demand, declining harvests from the GSL, high import taxes in some developing countries and, possibly, an artificial cyst shortage created by certain companies resulted in a severe price rise of up to US $50 or 100 kg⫺1 Artemia cysts by the end of the 1980s (Bengtson et al. 1991). The dramatic impact of the cyst shortage on the expanding aquaculture industry encouraged research on rationalising the use of Artemia and exploration of new cyst resources. During that period, the commercial exploitation of several other natural sources (Argentina, Australia, Canada, Colombia, France, PR China) and managed Artemia production sites (Brazil, Thailand) occurred. On the initiative of the Artemia Reference Center (Ghent University, Belgium) the International Study on Artemia (ISA) was established to co-ordinate a variety of different research initiatives (Sorgeloos 1979). The cyst shortage also simultaneously encouraged the search for alternatives for Artemia such as microencapsulated diets (Jones et al. 1993; Samocha et al. 1999) with the aim of eliminating live feed in fish larval nutrition, a process that continues today with slow but steady progress. With the development of improved techniques for cyst and nauplii applications (Léger et al. 1987a) and the exploitation of new natural resources, cyst prices returned to normal and annual market supply reached over 50 t by the 1980s. During the 1980s, improved techniques for harvesting from the open water and favourable hydrological and climatic conditions enabled a 10-fold increase in the yields from GSL (⬎200 t processed product; Fig. 3.1), while the hatching quality was also improved. This led to the precarious situation where, by the end of the 1980s, cyst supply was more than 90% dependent on one resource, namely
66
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
10,000
Harvested raw product (t)
9,000 8,000 7,000 6,000 5,000 4,000 3,000 2,000 1,000 0 ’84
’86
’88
’90
’92 Year
’94
’96
’98
2000
Fig. 3.1 Cyst harvest (in tonnes of raw product) from the Great Salt Lake (Utah, USA). (Data from USGS 2001.)
GSL. Despite its size, the GSL remains a natural ecosystem subject to climatic and other influences, and this has been illustrated by unpredictable and fluctuating cyst harvests. This situation urged producers in the 1990s to explore new sites such as Lake Urmia in Iran, Aibi Lake in China, Bolshoye Yarovoye in Siberia, Kara Bogaz Gol in Turkmenistan, and several lakes in Kazakhstan (Lavens & Sorgeloos 2000). In addition, numerous managed ponds and saltworks world-wide provided small quantities (1–20 t each). Although these sites did not necessarily contribute substantially to the world supply of cysts, they provide interesting opportunities for local commercial development. New insights into hatching characteristics and nutritional essentials gave rise to the segregation of different cyst qualities. Whereas in the early 1990s, cysts with good hatching quality could be purchased for as low as US $20 kg⫺1, prices of small sized cysts with high eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA; 20:5n-3) levels could reach over US $100 kg⫺1 at times of short supply owing to their critical role as starter food for marine fish larvae. With the severe cyst shortage in the mid-1990s and at the end of the twentieth century (Fig. 3.1), cyst prices inflated to levels around US $100 kg⫺1 for GSL product and nearly US $200 kg⫺1 for the EPA-rich product. Following the superharvest of over 9000 t of raw cysts from the GSL in 2000–2001, prices started to fall again. Since the early 1990s, cyst consumption has increased exponentially as a consequence of the booming shrimp and marine fish industries. In 1997, some 6000 hatcheries required over 1500 t of cysts annually. Some 80–85% of the total sales of Artemia went to shrimp hatcheries, mainly in China and south-east Asia, as well as Ecuador and a few other Latin American countries; the remainder went to marine fish larviculture in Europe, China and Japan, as well as to the pet fish producers. However, the rationalisation of the use of Artemia in hatcheries (Sorgeloos et al. 1998, 2001) has enabled a dramatic reduction in the required amount of cysts per unit of fish or shrimp produced. For instance, formerly, a typical Mediterranean sea bass and sea bream hatchery would have been using some 150 kg cysts to produce 1 million fry, whereas nowadays the required amount of cysts is only 90 kg for bass and 70 kg for bream. Likewise, in shrimp hatcheries, the consumption of cysts dropped from 10 kg per million
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia
67
postlarvae to less than 5 kg. Although there is no doubt that Artemia will gradually be replaced by formulated diets, it is obvious that the use of nauplii will continue to be market driven for at least a few more years and that record harvests at GSL and new locations may relieve the pressure or even reverse the current trends. Comprehensive literature reviews on the use of Artemia as live food in fish and shellfish larviculture have been published by Léger et al. (1986) and Sorgeloos et al. (1998, 2001). Today, Artemia is used in the mass culture of different sea bream species, sea bass species, wolf fish, cod, turbot, halibut, flounder species and other flatfish, milkfish, sturgeon, different carp and catfish species and whitefish species. The same is true for commercially important crustaceans such as several shrimp and prawn species, crawfish, several edible crab species and lobster. Nauplii in instar I and II stages are, undoubtedly, the most widely used forms of Artemia in aquaculture. They are also the easiest and earliest live food, being obtained directly from the cysts. However, it should be borne in mind that any farmer would switch to formulated feed as soon as this proves to be more cost-effective than Artemia. This switch will be triggered not only by the constantly improving quality of formulated feed, but also by price and quality of Artemia. In general, most fish and shrimp larvae accept formulated feed more easily as they grow bigger. This is not only a matter of size of mouthparts and particle size, but also a matter of the developmental stage and efficiency of the digestive system. As a consequence, Artemia is essential only for those species that require live food in their early life stages. Brine shrimp are mostly used as freshly hatched nauplii or as ‘enriched’ nauplii (see Section 3.5.5). Hatching procedures can be simplified and improved through prior ‘decapsulation’ of cysts (see Section 3.5.4), a process that also improves the quality of poor or nonhatching cysts. Juvenile and adult Artemia, often referred to as ‘biomass’, can be obtained through culturing (see Section 3.3.1) or can be harvested from salt ponds or lakes (Baert et al. 1996). In China, thousands of tonnes are collected on an annual basis from the Bohai Bay salt ponds and are used in the local culture of Chinese white shrimp, Penaeus chinensis (Tackaert & Sorgeloos 1991). Although live biomass has a higher nutritive value, most of the 3000 t that is harvested annually is marketed in frozen form. Part of it is also flaked, dried or incorporated in compound diets.
3.2 Biology of Artemia 3.2.1 Morphology and life cycle In its natural environment under certain conditions, Artemia produces cysts that float at the water surface and are driven ashore by wind and waves. These cysts are metabolically inactive and do not develop further as long as they are kept dry. Upon immersion in seawater, the biconcave cysts hydrate and become spherical and, within the shell, the embryo resumes its interrupted metabolism. After about 20 h the outer membrane of the cyst bursts (‘breaking’) and the embryo appears, surrounded by the hatching membrane (Fig. 3.2). While the embryo hangs underneath the empty shell (the ‘umbrella’ stage) the development of the nauplius is completed and within a short period the hatching membrane is ruptured (‘hatching’), giving rise to the free-swimming nauplius (Fig. 3.3).
68
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Fig. 3.2 Cyst in breaking stage. (1) Nauplius eye.
Fig. 3.3 Embryo in ‘umbrella’ stage (left) and instar I nauplius (right). (1) Nauplius eye; (2) antennula; (3) antenna; (4) mandible.
The first larval stage (instar I; 400–500 m in length) has a brownish-orange colour, a red nauplius eye in the head region and three pairs of appendages: the first antennae (sensorial function), the second antennae (locomotory plus filter-feeding function) and the mandibles (food uptake function). The ventral side is covered by a large labrum (food uptake: transfer of particles from the filtering setae into the mouth). The instar I larva does not take up food as its digestive system is not yet functional; it relies completely on its yolk reserves. After about 8 h, the animal moults into the second larval stage (instar II). Small food particles (e.g. algal cells, bacteria, detritus) ranging in size from 1 to 50 m are filtered out by the second antennae and ingested into the now functional digestive tract. The larva grows and differentiates through a number of moults; although there has been considerable disagreement about the exact number of larval stages, generally one naupliar, four metanaupliar, seven postmetanaupliar and five postlarval stages have been described (Hentschel 1968; Schrehardt 1987). Paired lobular appendages appear in the trunk region and differentiate into thoracopods (Fig. 3.4). On both sides of the nauplius eye lateral complex eyes begin to develop
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia
69
Fig. 3.4 Instar V larva. (1) Nauplius eye; (2) lateral complex eye; (3) antenna; (4) labrum; (5) budding of thoracopods; (6) digestive tract.
Fig. 3.5 Head and thoracic region of young male. (1) Antenna; (2) telopodite; (3) exopodite.
(Figs 3.4, 3.5). From the 10th instar stage onwards, important morphological and functional changes begin to take place, i.e. the antennae lose their locomotory function and undergo sexual differentiation. In males (Figs 3.6, 3.7) they develop into hooked graspers, while the female antennae degenerate into sensorial appendages (Fig. 3.8). The thoracopods are now differentiated into three functional parts (Fig. 3.9): the telopodites and endopodites (locomotory and filter-feeding), and the membranous exopodites (gills). Adult Artemia are typical primitive arthropods (8–12 mm in length) having an elongated segmented body with two stalked complex eyes, a linear digestive tract, sensorial antennulae, a pair of functional thoracopods on each of the 11 thoracal segments (Figs 3.7, 3.8) and a furca on the last abdominal segment. The entire body is covered with a thin, flexible exoskeleton of chitin to which muscles are attached internally. The male (Fig. 3.7) has a paired penis on the first of the eight abdominal segments (Fig. 3.10). Female Artemia can easily be recognised by the brood pouch or uterus situated in the same segment, just behind the 11th pair of thoracopods (Figs 3.8, 3.10). The female reproductive system consists of ovaries and oviducts leading into the single, median uterus, wherein several clusters of shell glands open. The ovaries are paired tubular structures extending into the abdomen
70
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Fig. 3.6 Head of an adult male. (1) Antenna; (2) antennula; (3) lateral complex eye; (4) mandible.
Fig. 3.7 Adult male.
Fig. 3.8 Adult female.
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia
71
Fig. 3.9 Detail of anterior thoracopods in adult Artemia. (1) Exopodite; (2) telopodite; (3) endopodite.
Fig. 3.10 Artemia couple in riding position. (1) Uterus; (2) penis.
Fig. 3.11 Uterus of ovoviviparous Artemia filled with nauplii (first larvae are being released). (1) Ovary with eggs.
72
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Fig. 3.12 Uterus of oviparous Artemia filled with cysts. (1) Brown shell glands.
(Fig. 3.11). Adult females ovulate approximately every 140 h, depending on rearing conditions and whether development of embryos occurs oviparously or ovoviviparously. In females, spawning is followed by a moult, after which ovulation takes place. The oviducts emerge from the ovaries near the anterior part of the third abdominal segment (Cassel 1937). Each oviduct empties into the anterolateral border of the uterus. The lateral pouches function as seminal receptacles during the time between copulation and fertilisation (within 1 h) (Benesch 1969; Criel 1980a,b). Once ripe, the eggs developing in the ovaries become spherical and migrate via two oviducts into the unpaired uterus. Fertilised eggs normally develop into free-swimming nauplii (ovoviviparous reproduction) (Fig. 3.11), which are released by the mother. In extreme conditions (e.g. high salinity, low oxygen levels) the embryos only develop up to the gastrula stage. At this point they are surrounded by a thick shell (secreted by the brown shell glands located in the uterus), enter a state of metabolic dormancy (diapause) and are then released by the female (oviparous reproduction) (Fig. 3.12). The shell glands consist of several cell clusters, and can vary from dark brown to white or even colourless, depending on reproductive strategy. In principle, both oviparity and ovoviviparity are found in all Artemia strains, and females can switch reproductive modes from one ovulation to the next. Although females may differ in their genetic tendency to reproduce either ovoviviparously or oviparously, no Artemia are known to lack completely the ability to produce ovoviviparous nauplii. The cysts usually float in the high-salinity waters and are blown ashore where they accumulate and dry. As a result of this dehydration process the diapause mechanism is generally inactivated; cysts are now in a state of quiescence and can resume their further embryonic development when hydrated in optimal hatching conditions. Under optimal conditions brine shrimp can live for several months, grow from nauplius to adult in only 8 days and reproduce at a rate of up to 300 nauplii or cysts every 4 days. However, not all encysted embryos produced by oviparous animals enter diapause, and nauplii emerge from some cysts without dehydration or other treatment (Jensen 1918; Mathias 1937; Lochhead & Lochhead 1940; Dutrieu 1960a,b; Morris & Afzelius 1967;
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia
73
alveolar layer
outer cuticular membrane embryonic cuticle
inner cuticular membrane embryo
Fig. 3.13 Schematic diagram of the ultrastructure of an Artemia cyst. (Modified from Morris & Afzelius 1967.)
Benesch 1969; Anderson et al. 1970). These cysts are surrounded by a much thinner shell than those that enter diapause (Lochhead & Lochhead 1940). Moreover, changes in cysts post release suggest that diapause is established gradually after release (Jardel 1986). The cryptobiotic cyst shell has two important layers in addition to the hypochlorite-soluble, double-layered outer chorion secreted by the shell glands, and the hypochlorite-resistant embryonic cuticle (Morris & Afzelius 1967) (see also Section 3.2.5.1). These are the outer cuticular membrane, separating chorion from embryonic cuticle, and the inner cuticular membrane, which delineates the embryo from the fibrous layer of the embryonic cuticle (Fig. 3.13).
3.2.2 Ecology and natural distribution Artemia populations are found in about 500 natural salt lakes and artificial salterns scattered throughout the tropical, subtropical and temperate climatic zones, along coastlines as well as inland. The distribution of these sites over the continents is very uneven, mainly reflecting sampling and exploration activities (Fig. 3.14). As such, it does not give a precise picture of the actual global occurrence of Artemia. The decline of Artemia cyst harvests from the GSL in Utah, USA, since 1977 (Lavens & Sorgeloos 2000) has intensified the search for alternative resources, especially in inland lakes that are sufficiently large and productive to justify commercial exploitation. As a result, several sites, especially in continental Asia, are exploited occasionally or on a regular basis (with some local investment), and these cysts are being used world-wide in aquaculture. The identity or location of these sites has still not reached scientific literature, and attempts are seldom made to perform a systematic
74
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Fig. 3.14 World distribution of Artemia.
characterisation of the respective strains. A continued survey will undoubtedly lead to the discovery of many more Artemia biotopes in different parts of the world. Two critical factors determine the population dynamics of Artemia and its biogeographical distribution: first, whether water body conditions allow the animals to survive throughout the year and, secondly, whether or not the seasonality of the environment is predictable (Lenz 1987; Amat et al. 1995). The common feature of all Artemia biotopes is their high salinity. Salinity is without doubt the predominant abiotic factor determining the presence of Artemia and consequently limiting its geographical distribution. Its physiological adaptations to high salinity provide a very efficient ecological defence against predation, as brine shrimp possess:
• • •
a very efficient osmoregulatory system the capacity to synthesise very efficient respiratory pigments to cope with the low oxygen levels at high salinities the ability to produce dormant cysts when environmental conditions endanger the survival of the species.
Other variables (temperature, light intensity, primary food production) may have an influence on the quantitative aspects of the Artemia population, or may cause only a temporary absence of brine shrimp. For physiological reasons the salinity optimum is situated towards the lower end of the salinity range, as higher ambient salinity requires higher energy costs for osmoregulation. Ambient salinity also plays a role in cyst metabolism, as Artemia cysts will only start to develop when the salinity of the medium drops below a certain threshold value. No Artemia are found in cold tundra or frost climates, as the year-round extremely low temperatures preclude Artemia development. Most strains do not seem to survive prolonged temperatures below 5°C unless in the form of cysts. The maximum temperature tolerated by
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia
75
Artemia populations has repeatedly been reported to be close to 35°C, a temperature often attained in the shallow tropical salterns that constitute a large part of the Artemia habitats. This tolerance threshold is, however, strain dependent. Moreover, physiological adaptation of SFB Artemia to high temperatures (40°C) after a number of generations in Vietnamese salt ponds has also been reported (Clegg et al. 2001). As for salinity, temperature optima are difficult to define and are strain dependent; in general, however, the optimum for Artemia is in the range 25–30°C. The ametabolic dehydrated cysts are resistant to a wider temperature range than would ever occur in nature. Artemia is a non-selective filter feeder of organic detritus, microscopic algae and bacteria. The Artemia biotopes typically show a very simple trophic structure and low species diversity: the absence of predators and food competitors allows brine shrimp to develop into monocultures. As Artemia is incapable of active dispersion, wind and waterfowl (especially flamingos) are the most important natural dispersion vectors. The floating cysts adhere to feet and feathers of birds and, when ingested, they remain intact for at least 2 days in the digestive tract of birds. Consequently, the absence of migrating birds is probably the reason why certain areas that are suitable for Artemia (e.g. salinas along the north-east coast of Brazil) are not naturally inhabited by brine shrimp.
3.2.3 Taxonomy The brine shrimp Artemia comprises a group of zygogenetic and parthenogenetic, morphologically similar species very likely to have diverged from an ancestral form living in the Mediterranean area some 5.5 million years ago (Abreu-Grobois & Beardmore 1982; Abreu-Grobois 1987; Badaracco et al. 1987). Speciation in the genus should be regarded as a complex, multidimensional process involving a variety of environmental and genomic factors. The identification of zygogenetic Artemia species has been established by a multidisciplinary approach, including cross-breeding tests, morphological differentiation, cytogenetics, allozyme studies, and nuclear and mitochondrial DNA sequencing. With the exception of cross-mating, all of these techniques have also contributed to identifying the parthenogenetic types described as A. parthenogenetica by Barigozzi (1974), as well as to gaining insight on population structure, origin and amount of clonal diversity. In 1755 Schlosser described the brine shrimp based on material collected from the solar saltworks near Lymington, England (no longer in existence) (Kuenen & Baas-Becking 1938). Linnaeus in 1758 classified it as Cancer salinus, and Leach in 1818 renamed the brine shrimp as Artemia salina (Artom 1931). Very often authors have named all brine shrimps A. salina. While for some time the name A. tunisiana was used, Artemia salina is now only recognised as a valid name for the zygogenetic species found in the Mediterranean area (Mura 1990; Triantaphyllidis et al. 1997b). The differentiation of seven zygogenetic species, defined primarily by the criterion of laboratory reproductive isolation, and many parthenogenetic strains is currently acknowledged. Endemic to the Old World are the parthenogenetic types designated by Barigozzi (1974) as A. parthenogenetica (with different levels of ploidy, found in Europe, Africa, Asia and Australia), the zygogenetic A. salina, Leach 1819 (Mediterranean area) (Triantaphyllidis
76
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
et al. 1997b), A. urmiana (Günther, 1890) (Iran), A. sinica (Cai 1989) (continental China), Artemia sp. (Pilla & Beardmore 1994) (Kazakhstan) and A. tibetiana (Abatzopoulos et al. 1998) (Tibet). Endemic to the New World are A. persimilis (Piccinelli & Prosdocimi 1968) (Argentina) and A. franciscana (Kellogg 1906) (North, Central and South America), with A. (franciscana) monica being a special case of a population described for an ecologically unique habitat (Mono Lake, USA). The genus Artemia is thus a complex of sibling species and superspecies, defined largely, but not completely, by the criterion of reproductive isolation. Very rarely, it has been shown that genetically extremely distinct and allopatric species can produce laboratory hybrids (Pilla & Beardmore 1994). Coexistence of two species in the same saline habitat is possible: mixtures of parthenogenetic and zygogenetic populations have been reported in Spain, Italy, and central and northern China. Parthenogenetic types tend to predominate in more disturbed, stressful, conditions of salinity, temperature and food availability (Browne & Bowen 1991; Lenz & Browne 1991). Laboratory competition experiments where Artemia adults, belonging to different species, were raised together and reproduced for a maximum of 3 months (25°C, ⫾80 g l⫺1, fed Dunaliella) resulted in the dominance of A. franciscana over parthenogenetic populations on the one hand, and parthenogenetic populations over A. salina on the other (Browne 1980; Browne & Halanych 1989).
3.2.4 Strain-specific characteristics The world-wide distribution of the brine shrimp Artemia in isolated habitats (about 500 natural salt lakes and artificial salterns) with specific ecological conditions has resulted in numerous geographical strains, or genetically different populations within the same sibling species. The parthenogenetic Artemia with their great clonal diversity, as evident from morphology (Hontoria & Amat 1992; Triantaphyllidis et al. 1997a), and cytological and allozyme studies (Abreu-Grobois & Beardmore 1982; Abreu-Grobois 1987; Abatzopoulos et al. 1993) and different ploidy levels (diploid, triploid, tetraploid, pentaploid), display a wide genotypic variation. While the nutritional value can be manipulated through enrichment, other qualities favourable for aquaculture can be obtained by selection of strains and/or their crossbreeds. In spite of the fluctuations in the harvest, over 90% of all marketed cysts originate from the GSL, but Artemia cysts are commercially available from various production sources in America, Asia, Australia and Europe. Knowledge of the characteristics (both genotypic and phenotypic) of a particular batch of cysts can greatly increase the effectiveness of its use in a fish or shrimp hatchery. Among these strains a high degree of genetic variability as well as a unique diversity in various quantitative characteristics have been observed (Browne et al. 1991). Some of this variability is phenotypical, such as the nutritional composition of the cysts (Léger et al. 1986), and changes from batch to batch. Other characteristics such as cyst diameter and resistance to high temperature are considered strain-specific and remain relatively constant (Vanhaecke & Sorgeloos 1980a), i.e. they have become genotypical as a result of long-term adaptations of the strain to the local conditions.
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia
77
Table 3.1 Size, individual dry weight and energy content of Artemia instar I nauplii from different cyst sources hatched in standard conditions (35 g l⫺1, 25°C).
Cyst source
Length (mm)
Dry weight (g)
Energy content (10⫺3 J)
San Francisco Bay, USA Macau, Brazil Great Salt Lake, USA Shark Bay, Australia Chaplin Lake, Canada Tanggu, Bohai Bay, PR China Aibi Lake, PR China Yuncheng, PR China Lake Urmiah, Iran
428 447 486 458 475 515 515 460 497
1.63 1.74 2.42 2.47 2.04 3.09 4.55 2.03 —
366 392 541 576 448 681 — — —
3.2.4.1 Size and energy content The nutritional effectiveness of a food organism is primarily determined by its ingestibility and, as a consequence, by its size and form. Data on biometrics of nauplii from various Artemia strains are given in Table 3.1. In spite of small variations between batches of the same strain, possibly caused by environmental and/or processing factors, generally the cyst diameter of different production batches of the same strain remains rather constant. Other biometrical characteristics, such as cyst volume, cyst dry weight, instar I naupliar length, individual naupliar weight and naupliar volume, and energy content, show a high correlation with the cyst diameter (Vanhaecke et al. 1983). As a consequence, biometrical parameters, in particular cyst diameter, are good tools to characterise Artemia strains, and to help define the origin of unknown or even mixed cyst samples (Vanhaecke & Sorgeloos 1980a). Some general correlations can also be made between sibling species and size: parthenogenetic Artemia produce large cysts; A. salina, large cysts with a thick chorion; A. franciscana and A. persimilis, small or intermediate cysts with a thin chorion. 3.2.4.2 Hatching quality Comparative studies of hatching behaviour of cysts of different origin show a considerable variation in hatching percentage, rate and efficiency (Vanhaecke & Sorgeloos 1982, 1983). However, none of these parameters is strain-specific as they are influenced by a wide array of factors such as harvesting, processing, storage and hatching techniques, as well as production conditions affecting the parental generation. For optimal use of Artemia in aquaculture the hatching characteristics of each batch of cysts being used should be known. 3.2.4.3 Diapause characteristics As diapause can be considered as a life-cycle strategy to overcome temporarily adverse conditions, and to synchronise population developments to the variations of their specific biotype, the process of diapause and its deactivation is likely to be adapted to the population’s habitat (Lavens & Sorgeloos 1987). Adaptations to local conditions may have contributed to strain-specific differences in diapause sensitivity. In response to simple dehydration by storage in a highly saline medium or by air-drying, SFB-type cysts are gradually released
78
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
from diapause (Versichele & Sorgeloos 1980; Vu Do Quynh & Nguyen Ngoc Lam 1987), while cysts from inland salt lakes (GSL, southern Siberia) need a period of cold storage or hibernation of several weeks to break diapause. In addition, differences in tolerance and responsiveness of different strains to hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) treatment during diapause deactivation (see Section 3.2.5.3) may be partially genetic and thus strain-specific. Although general recommendations can be formulated with regard to H2O2 concentration and exposure time, a limited screening of different combinations is therefore needed when the hatching of new batches is being optimised (Van Stappen et al. 1998). 3.2.4.4 Growth rate of nauplii Standard culture tests with brine shrimp from different geographical origins show important differences in growth rate even within the same sibling species, but not among batches of the same strain (Vanhaecke & Sorgeloos 1980b). Although the population growth of Artemia in the field (e.g. after inoculation) is determined by a variety of factors, selection of a strain with a high potential growth rate will have a positive impact on maximal production output. 3.2.4.5 Temperature and salinity tolerance Both temperature and salinity significantly affect survival and growth, the effect of temperature being more pronounced. A broad range of temperatures and salinities meets the requirements for ⬎90% survival (Vanhaecke et al. 1984). Strains from thalassohaline biotopes share a common preferred temperature range around 20–25°C, where mortalities are ⬍10%. Interaction between temperature and salinity is limited; substantial differences in tolerance have been recorded at low salinities (around 5 g l⫺1) and high temperatures (30–34°C). At elevated temperatures the survival of the GSL strain is significantly higher than for other strains. 3.2.4.6 Life-history traits and reproductive capacity Life history and reproductive characteristics of Artemia strains are important factors when an introduction of brine shrimp to a new habitat is considered, especially when competition with a local strain is to be expected. These competitive abilities are related to factors such as the length of reproductive, prereproductive and postreproductive periods, total lifespan, number of offspring per brood, broods per female, interval between broods, etc. In general, New World (zygogenetic) populations have a very large number of offspring per brood, a large number of offspring per female per day and a fast development time to sexual maturity. These are all favourable characteristics compared with those of Old World zygogenetic and parthenogenetic Artemia (Browne et al. 1984, 1991). Age at first reproduction is a key factor determining the population growth rate, and the rate of colonisation of new environments with limited nutrient resources. Consequently, if environmental preferences and nutritional factors do not interfere, New World zygogenetic species generally outcompete parthenogenetic strains, the latter in their turn predominating over Old World zygogenetic species. Inoculation experiments in natural habitats therefore require prior screening of candidate strains and of indigenous local populations, as well as the study of prevailing environmental conditions.
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia
79
3.2.4.7 Nutritional value In the late 1970s, when many fish and shrimp hatcheries started to commercialise, switching from one source of Artemia to another provoked unexpected problems. Aquaculturists even noticed highly significant differences when using different batches from the same geographical origin (Léger & Sorgeloos 1984). In particular, the lipid and fatty acid compositions, as well as the metabolisation of fatty acids in the Artemia, seemed to differ widely from strain to strain, and even from batch to batch, as a consequence of the fluctuations in biochemical composition of the primary producers (mainly unicellular algae) available to the adult population (Léger et al. 1987a). Cyst products from inland resources are more constant in fatty acid composition, albeit at suboptimal low levels. Appropriate enrichment techniques have thus been developed to improve the lipid profile of deficient Artemia strains, taking advantage of the indiscriminate filter-feeding behaviour of Artemia (Léger et al. 1987b). Applying simple methods, lipophilic compounds can easily be incorporated into Artemia before being offered as live feed (see Section 3.5.5). A number of other compounds also varies from strain to strain: nutritional components such as total amount of free amino acids, pigments (canthaxanthin), vitamin C, minerals and trace elements, as well as contamination with chemicals such as pesticides and heavy metals. In most cases these variations are not strain-specific, but correspond to different production conditions. Their effects on larviculture success are far less significant than nauplii fatty acid composition.
3.2.5 Cyst biology and diapause 3.2.5.1 Cyst morphology and physiology A schematic diagram of the ultrastructure of an Artemia cyst is given in Fig. 3.13. The cyst shell consists of three layers:
•
• •
Alveolar layer: This hard layer consists of lipoproteins impregnated with chitin and haematin. The haematin concentration determines the colour of the shell, i.e. from pale to dark brown. Its main function is to provide protection for the embryo against mechanical disruption and ultraviolet (UV) radiation. This layer can be completely removed (dissolved) by oxidation treatment with hypochlorite (cyst decapsulation, see Section 3.5.4; Bruggeman et al. 1980). Outer cuticular membrane: This protects the embryo from penetration by molecules larger than the carbon dioxide molecule (multilayer membrane with a very special filter function; acts as a permeability barrier). Embryonic cuticle: This transparent and highly elastic layer is separated from the embryo by the inner cuticular membrane (develops into the hatching membrane during hatching incubation). The embryonic cuticle is apparently impermeable to non-volatile solutes (De Chaffoy et al. 1978; Clegg & Conte 1980). The embryo is an undifferentiated gastrula, which is ametabolic when water content is below 10% and can be stored for long periods without losing its viability. The viability is affected when water levels are higher than 10% (start of metabolic activity) and when cysts are exposed to oxygen; i.e. in the presence of oxygen, cosmic radiation results in the formation of free radicals, which destroy specific enzymatic systems in the ametabolic Artemia cysts.
80
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
3.2.5.2 Cyst metabolism and hatching Given favourable environmental conditions the metabolism and development of encysted embryos are rapidly reinitiated. When incubated in seawater the biconcave cyst swells and becomes spherical within 1–2 h. Respiration, RNA and protein synthesis begin within minutes (Clegg & Conte 1980), supporting the conclusion that encysted embryos contain all the components needed for these activities. After a period of postdiapause development, in the order of 8–24 h depending on temperature and salinity, the cyst shell (including the outer cuticular membrane) bursts (breaking stage) and the embryo surrounded by the hatching membrane becomes visible. The embryo then leaves the shell completely and hangs underneath the empty shell (the hatching membrane may still be attached to the shell). Through the transparent hatching membrane one can follow the differentiation of the pre-nauplius into the instar I nauplius which starts to move its appendages. Shortly thereafter, the hatching membrane breaks open (hatching) and the free-swimming larva emerges head-first. Dry cysts (water content from 2 to 5%; Fig. 3.15) are very resistent to extreme temperatures; i.e. hatching viability is not affected in the temperature range ⫺273°C (Skoultchi & Morowitz 1964) to 60°C; above 60°C and up to 90°C only short exposures can be tolerated. Hydrated cysts have far more specific tolerances: mortalities occur below ⫺18°C and above 40°C; a reversible interruption of the metabolism (viability not affected) occurs between ⫺18 and 4°C and between 33 and 40°C, although the upper and lower temperature limits vary slightly from strain to strain. Active cyst metabolism occurs between 4 and 33°C. Within this range, the hatching percentage remains constant but the nauplii hatch earlier as the temperature increases.
Fig. 3.15 Cellular metabolism in Artemia cysts (as a function of hydration level).
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia
81
As for other environmental conditions, optimal hatching outputs are reached in the pH range 8–8.5. As a consequence, the addition of NaHCO3 (up to 2 g l⫺1), to artificial or diluted seawater or to dense suspensions of cysts, results in improved hatching. This may be related to the optimal pH activity range for the hatching enzyme. Increased hatching has been reported with increasing oxygen level in the range 0.6–2 ppm, and maximal hatching above this concentration. To avoid oxygen gradients during hatching a good homogeneous mixing of the cysts in the incubation medium is required. As stated above, hatching in a higher salinity medium will consume more of the energy reserves of the embryo. Above a threshold salinity (varying from strain to strain, but ⬎90 g l⫺1 for most strains), the amount of water that can be taken up is insufficient to support the embryo’s metabolism. Optimal salinity for hatching is equally strain specific, but generally situated in the range 15–70 g l⫺1. Although the physiological role of light during the hatching process is poorly understood, brine shrimp cysts, when hydrated and in aerobic conditions, need a minimal light triggering for the onset of the hatching process, related to light intensity and/or exposure time. Little is known about the exact light requirements, but generally strong illumination (about 2000 lux at the water surface) is recommended, at least during the first hours after complete hydration. Finally, hatchability of cysts is largely determined by the conditions and techniques applied for harvesting, cleaning, drying and storing of the cyst material (see Section 4.4). Hatching quality in stored cysts slowly decreases when cysts contain 10–35% water (Fig. 3.15). This process may, however, be retarded when the cysts are stored at freezing temperatures. The exact optimal water level within the cyst is not known, although there are indications that too severe dehydration (down to 1–2%) results in a drop in viability. Water content of about 5% is a reasonable value. Water levels in the range 30–65% initiate metabolic activity, eventually reducing the energy content to levels insufficient to reach the state of emergence under optimal hatching conditions (Fig. 3.15). Furthermore, a depletion of the energy reserves occurs when the cysts undergo subsequent dehydration/hydration cycles. Long-term storage of such material may result in a substantial decrease in hatching success. Cysts exposed for too long a period to water levels exceeding 65% will have completed their pre-emergence embryonic development. Subsequent dehydration of these cysts will, in the worst case, result in the killing of the now differentiated embryos. Sufficiently dehydrated cysts only keep their viability when stored under vacuum or in nitrogen. The presence of oxygen results in a substantial reduction in hatching success as a result of the formation of highly detrimental free radicals. Even correctly packaged cysts are preferentially stored at low temperatures. When frozen, the cysts should be acclimated for 1 week at room temperature before hatching. 3.2.5.3 Diapause As Artemia is an inhabitant of biotopes characterised by unstable environmental conditions, its survival during periods of extreme conditions (e.g. desiccation, extreme temperatures, high salinities) is ensured by the production of dormant embryos. Artemia females can indeed easily switch from the production of live nauplii (ovoviviparity) to cyst formation (oviparity) in response to fluctuating circumstances. The basic mechanisms involved in this switch are
82
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
not yet fully understood, but sudden fluctuations in, for example, oxygen levels and salinity seem to trigger oviparity. The phenomenon of diapause in Artemia cysts has been the subject of numerous studies and reviews (Clegg & Conte 1980; Drinkwater & Crowe 1987; Lavens & Sorgeloos 1987; Drinkwater & Clegg 1991). The study of the mechanisms of diapause induction and deactivation can help to maximise the hatching yield of the commercially important Artemia cysts. The termination of diapause is a complex process, influenced by multiple and mutually interfering genotypical and environmental factors. The triggering mechanism for the induction of the diapause state is not yet known. In principle, Artemia embryos released as cysts in the medium are, or soon become, diapausing (Clegg et al. 1996). Upon the deactivation of diapause by environmental factors (Drinkwater & Crowe 1987), cysts enter the stage of quiescence and metabolic activity can be resumed when they are exposed to favourable conditions in terms of temperature, oxygen and light, eventually resulting in hatching. In this phase the metabolic arrest is uniquely dependent on external factors. As a result, synchronous hatching occurs, resulting in a fast start and consequent development of the population shortly after the re-establishment of favourable environmental conditions. This allows effective colonisation in temporal biotopes. Moreover, diapause or a similar state can be reinduced by exposure to anoxia (Drinkwater & Clegg 1991; Clegg 1993; Clegg et al. 2000) or by a well-dosed heat shock (Abatzopoulos et al. 1994). For the user of Artemia cysts, several techniques have proven successful in terminating diapause. It is important to note here that the sensitivity of Artemia cysts to these techniques shows strain- or even batch-specificity (see Section 3.2.4), hence the difficulty in predicting the effect on hatching outcome. When working with new or relatively unknown strains, the relative success or failure of certain methods has to be found out empirically. In many cases, the removal of cyst water is an efficient way to terminate the state of diapause. This can be achieved by drying the cysts at temperatures not exceeding 35–40°C or by suspending the cysts in a saturated NaCl brine solution (300 g l⫺1). As some form of dehydration is part of most processing and/or storage procedures, diapause termination does not require any particular extra manipulation. Nevertheless, with some strains of Artemia cysts, the usual cyst processing techniques do not yield a sufficiently high hatching quality, indicating that a more specific diapause deactivation method is necessary. The following procedures have proven to be successful when applied with specific sources of Artemia cysts.
• •
Freezing: This ‘imitates’ the natural hibernation period of cysts originating from continental biotopes with low winter temperatures (GSL, Utah, USA; continental Asia). Incubation in H2O2 solution: In most cases, the sensitivity of the strain (or batch) to this product is difficult to predict, and preliminary tests are needed to provide information about the optimal dose and period to be applied, and about the maximal effect that can be obtained. Overdosing results in reduced hatching or even complete mortality as a result of toxicity of the chemical. In some cases no effect at all is observed. In general, other diapause termination techniques (cyclic dehydration/hydration, decapsulation, other chemicals) give rather erratic results and/or are not user friendly. However, one should keep in mind that the increase in hatching percentage after any procedure may (even partially) be the result of a shift in hatching rate (earlier hatching).
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia
83
3.3 Production Methods: Tank Production of Artemia Biomass 3.3.1 Advantages of tank production and tank-produced biomass Although tank-produced Artemia biomass is far more expensive than pond-produced brine shrimp its advantages may, depending on the local condition, justify its application:
• • •
year-round availability of ongrown Artemia, independent of climate or season; specific stages (juveniles, preadult, adults) or prey with uniform size can be harvested as a function of size preferences of the predator; quality of the Artemia can be better controlled (e.g. nutritional content, free from diseases).
High-density intensive culture techniques offer two main advantages compared with pond production techniques. First, there is no restriction with regard to production site or time, since the culture procedure does not require highly saline waters or specific climatological conditions. Secondly, controlled production can be performed with very high densities of brine shrimp, e.g. several thousand animals per litre versus a maximum of a few hundred animals per litre in outdoor culture ponds. As a consequence very high production yields per volume of culture medium can be obtained with tank rearing systems. Since the early 1990s, several superintensive Artemia farms have been established, e.g. in the USA, France, the UK and Australia, to supply local demand. Depending on the selected culture technology and implantation facilities, production costs are estimated at US $2.5–12 kg⫺1 live weight Artemia, with wholesale prices varying from US $25 to 100 kg⫺1. In practice, when setting up an Artemia culture one should start by listing the prevailing culture conditions and available infrastructure. The abiotic and biotic conditions relevant for Artemia culture are:
•
• • •
physicochemical conditions: – ionic composition of the culture media – temperature – salinity – pH – oxygen concentration – water quality (nitrogen metabolites, particles, etc.) Artemia: – strain selection – culture density feeding: – feeding strategy – selection of suitable diets infrastructure: – tank and aeration design – filter design – recirculation unit
84
•
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
– heating – feeding apparatus culture techniques: – stagnant culture – open flow-through system – recirculation type.
3.3.2 Physicochemical conditions Salinity and ionic composition of the culture media Although, in the wild, Artemia only occurs in highly saline waters (mostly above 100 g l⫺1), brine shrimp do thrive in natural seawater. The best physiological performance, in terms of growth rate and food conversion efficiency, is at salinities from 32 to 65 g l⫺1, depending on the cultured strain. For Artemia culture, the use of natural seawater of 35 g l⫺1 is the most practical. Small adjustments in salinity can be made by adding brine or diluting with tap water free from high levels of chlorine. Beside natural seawater or diluted brine, several artificial media with different ionic compositions are used with success in indoor installations for brine shrimp production. Since ionic composition is so important, concentrated brine (150 g l⫺1) from salinas can also be transported to the culture facilities and diluted with freshwater before use. Temperature, pH and oxygen concentration Temperature must be maintained between the specific optimal levels of the selected Artemia strain. For most strains a common range of preference is 19–25°C (Table 3.2). In the literature, it is generally accepted that the pH tolerance of Artemia ranges from 6.5 to 8. The pH tends to decrease during culture as a result of denitrification processes. When the pH drops below 7.5 small amounts of NaHCO3 (technical grade) should be added to increase the buffer capacity of the culture water. The pH is commonly measured using a calibrated electrode or with simple analytical test kits. In the latter case, the method must be suitable for seawater. With regard to oxygen, biomass production will decrease at concentrations below 2 mg l⫺1. For optimal production, oxygen concentrations higher than 2.5 mg l⫺1 are suggested. However, continuously maintaining oxygen levels higher than 5 mg l⫺1 will result in the production of pale animals (low in the respiratory pigment haemoglobin), possibly with a lower individual dry weight, which may therefore be less perceptible to and attractive for the predators. A dark red coloration (high haemoglobin content) is easily obtained by applying regular oxygen stresses (by switching off the aeration for a few minutes several times a day) a few days before harvesting. Oxygen levels should be checked regularly as they may drop significantly, especially after feeding. Oxygen is conveniently measured in the culture tank with a portable oxygen electrode. When oxygen occasionally drops below 30% saturation (i.e. 2.5 mg O2 l⫺1 in seawater of 32 g l⫺1 salinity), aeration intensity should be increased temporarily or air stones added. If oxygen levels remain low, the aeration capacity should be increased. It is important to remember that for a given air flow, the oxygen level is increased more effectively by small air bubbles than by large ones. However, very small air bubbles can become trapped between the thoracopods, causing the animals to float and congregate at the surface.
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia
85
Table 3.2 Effect of temperature on different production parameters for various geographical strains of Artemia. Temperature (°C) Geographical strain
20.0
22.5
25.0
27.5
30.0
32.5
San Francisco Bay, California, USA Survival (%) 97 Biomass production (%)a 75 Specific growth rateb 0.431g Food conversionc 3.89e
97 101 0.464d 3.35d
94 100 0.463d,e 3.64e
91 94 0.456e 3.87e
66 88 0.448f 4.15f
na na na na
Great Salt Lake, Utah, USA Survival (%) Biomass production (%)a Specific growth rateb Food conversionc
85 104 0.437f 2.90e
89 122 0.454e 2.65d,e
89 128 0.460d,e 2.62d
87 135 0.465d 2.40d
88 78 0.406g 4.14g
Chaplin Lake, Saskatchewan, Canada Survival (%) 72 Biomass production (%)a 78 0.422f Specific growth rateb c Food conversion 3.42e
75 102 0.452d,e 3.00d
77 108 0.459d 3.03d
65 106 0.456d 3.11d
50 90 0.437e,f 3.72d
na na na na
Tanggu, PR China Survival (%) Biomass production (%)a Specific growth rateb Food conversionc
94 61 0.343e 5.42e
91 80 0.371d 4.46d,e
93 92 0.387d 3.84d
84 85 0.378d 4.22d,e
54 16 0.208g 22.04g
77 69 0.392g 3.79h
95 41 0.299f 7.22f
Data compiled from Vanhaecke and Sorgeloos (1989). a Expressed as % recorded for the Artemia reference strain (San Francisco Bay, batch 288–2596) at 25°C after 9 days’ culturing on a diet of Dunalliella cells; bSpecific growth rate k ⫽ ln(Wt ⫺ W0) T⫺1, where T ⫽ duration of experiment in days (⫽9); cFood conversion ⫽ F(Wt ⫺ W0), where F ⫽ g dry weight Dunalliella offered as food, Wt ⫽ g dry weight Artemia biomass after 9 days’ culturing, and W0 ⫽ g dry weight Artemia biomass at start of experiment; d–gMeans with the same superscript letter are not significantly different at the p ⬍ 0.05 level. na, not analysed.
Water quality The quality of the culture medium is primarily affected by excess particles as well as by soluble waste products such as nitrogenous compounds. High levels of suspended solids will affect production characteristics, either by their interference with uptake of food particles and propulsion by the Artemia, or by enhancing bacterial growth that will compete for oxygen and eventually infest the culture tank. Soluble waste products give rise to toxic nitrogenous compounds. The tolerance levels in Artemia for ammonia, nitrite and nitrate in acute and chronic toxicity tests with, for instance, GSL brine shrimp larvae showed no significant effect on survival [median lethal concentration ⫺1 (LC50)] or growth for concentrations up to 1000 mg l⫺1 NH⫹ NO⫺2 (Chen et al. 4 , 320 mg l 1989). For nitrate, no effects were observed at 1000 mg l⫺1 and it is therefore considered non-toxic. It is therefore unlikely that N-components will interfere directly with Artemia cultures. Nevertheless, the presence of soluble substances should be restricted as much as possible since they are an ideal substrate for bacteria. Excess soluble waste products can only be eliminated by diluting the culture water with clean water, be it new or recycled.
86
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
3.3.3 Artemia strain selection and culture density Strain selection Based on laboratory results (Table 3.2), guidelines are provided for strain selection as a function of optimal temperature and culture performance. The optimal strain should be selected according to specific culture conditions. Culture density of Artemia Unlike other crustaceans, Artemia can be cultured at high to very high densities without affecting survival. Depending on the applied culture technique, inoculation densities up to 5000 larvae per litre for batch culture, 10,000 for closed flow-through culture and 18,000 for open flow-through culture can be maintained without influencing survival and growth. Above these densities, culture conditions become suboptimal (water quality deterioration, lower individual food availability), and growth and survival decrease (Table 3.3). Crowding seems to affect ingestion rate and thus growth. In stagnant systems, a clear decrease in growth rate with increasing animal density has been observed (Dhont et al. 1993). The costeffectiveness of a culture increases with increasing Artemia density. In an open flow-through system, maximal densities will be limited by feeding rate, while in recirculating and stagnant system the preservation of water quality will determine a safe feeding level, which in turn determines the animal density at which the individual feed amount still allows a satisfactory growth rate. After some culture trials with increasing animal densities, the maximal density can be identified as the highest possible density where no growth inhibition occurs.
3.3.4 Feeding Artemia is a continuous, non-selective, particle-filtering organism. Various factors may influence the feeding behaviour of Artemia by affecting the filtration rate, ingestion rate and/or assimilation: the quality and quantity of the food offered, the developmental stage of the larvae and the culture conditions. More detailed information about these processes is given in Coutteau and Sorgeloos (1989). Selection of a suitable diet Artemia can take up and digest exogenous microflora as part of the diet. Bacteria and protozoans, which develop easily in the Artemia cultures, are able to biosynthesise essential nutrients as they use the supplied brine shrimp food as a substrate. In this way they compensate for possible deficiencies in the diet composition. The interactions with bacteria make it a hard task to identify nutritionally adequate diets per se, and growth tests are difTable 3.3 Directive animal densities under different culture conditions. Culture system Open flow-through Closed flow-through Stagnant
Animals/litre 18,000 ⬎10,000 5000–10,000 5000 20,000
Culture period
Growth
Reference
To adult To adult To adult 7 days 7 days
High Moderate High High Low
Tobias et al. (1979) Lavens et al. (1986) Dhont et al. (1991)
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia
87
ficult to run under axenic conditions. As a consequence, nutritional composition of the diet does not play the most critical role in the selection of diets suitable for high-density culture of brine shrimp. The criteria used generally include:
• • • • • • •
availability and cost particle size composition (preferentially ⬍50 m) digestibility consistency in composition among different batches and storage capacity solubility (minimal) food conversion efficiency (FCE) buoyancy.
Commonly used food sources are listed below.
•
•
•
•
Microalgae: These undoubtedly yield best culture results but it is rare that sufficient algae are available at a reasonable cost. Mass culturing of suitable algae for Artemia is most often economically unrealistic, so their use can only be considered in locations where algal production is an additional feature of the main activity. Furthermore, not all species of unicellular algae are considered capable of sustaining Artemia growth (D’Agostino 1980); For example, Chlorella and Stichococcus have a thick cell wall that cannot be digested by Artemia, Cocochloris produces gelatinous substances that interfere with food uptake and some dinoflagellates produce toxic substances. Dried algae: In most cases algal meals give satisfactory growth performance, especially when water quality conditions are kept optimal. Drawbacks in the use of these feeds are their high cost (⬎US $12 kg⫺1), as well as their high fraction of water-soluble components, which cannot be ingested by the brine shrimp, but will interfere with the water quality of the culture medium. Bacteria and yeasts: Single-cell proteins (SCP) have several characteristics that make them an interesting alternative to microalgae: – the cell diameter is mostly smaller than 20 m – the nutritional composition is fairly complete – the rigid cell walls prevent the leakage of water-soluble nutrients in the culture medium – products are commercially available at acceptable cost (e.g. commonly used in cattle feeds). The highly variable production yields that often occur when feeding a yeast mono-diet are assigned to nutritional deficiencies of the yeast diet and should therefore be met by supplementation with other diets. For some SCP, digestibility by the Artemia can be a problem. Complete removal of the complex and thick yeast cell wall by enzymatic treatment and/or supplementation of the diet with live algae significantly improve the assimilation rate and growth rate of the brine shrimp (Coutteau et al. 1992). By-products from the food industry: Non-soluble by-products from agricultural crops or from the food-processing industry, such as rice bran, corn bran, soyabean pellets and lactoserum, appear to be a very suitable feed source for high-density culturing of Artemia (Dobbeleir et al. 1980). Their main advantages are their low cost and world-wide availability. Equally important in the evaluation of dry food is the consistency of the food quality and supply, and the possibility for storage without loss of quality. Bulk products must be stored in a dry and, preferentially, cool place.
88
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
1
3 2
T
Fig. 3.16 Feeding strategy with cultured Artemia. (1) Look through looking glass to turbidistick (or submerge stick in cylinder with appropriate mesh). (2) Submerge turbidistick until contrast between black and white disappears. (3) Read depth of submergence in cm ⫽ T. During first week: T ⬍ 15 cm: stop feeding and/or increase water renewal; 15 cm ⬍ T ⬍ 20 cm: maintain actual feeding ratio; T ⬎ 20 cm: increase feeding ratio and/or add food manually. During next week: T ⬍ 20 cm: stop feeding and/or increase water renewal; 20 cm ⬍ T ⬍ 25 cm: maintain actual feeding ratio; T ⬎ 25 cm: increase feeding ratio and/or add food manually.
Feeding strategy Since Artemia is a continuous filter-feeding organism, highest growth and minimal deposition of unconsumed food is achieved when food is distributed as frequently as possible. When feeding SCP, algae or yeast, concentrations should be maintained above the critical minimum uptake concentration, which is specific for the algal (or other) species and the developmental stage of Artemia (Abreu-Grobois et al. 1991). Levels of dry feeds, consisting of fragments and irregular particles, cannot be counted in the culture tank. Therefore, a correlation between optimal feed level and turbidity of the culture water has been developed, whereby the feed concentration in a culture tank is determined by measuring the turbidity of the water with a simplified Secchi-disc (Fig. 3.16).
3.3.5 Infrastructure Tank and aeration design Artemia can be reared in containers of any possible shape as long as the installed aeration ensures proper oxygenation and adequate mixing of feed and animals throughout the total culture volume. However, aeration should not be too strong. Thus, aeration and tank design must be considered together as the circulation pattern is determined by the combination of both. A wide variety of culture tanks has proven to be suitable (Dhont & Lavens 1996). For cultures up to 1 m3, rectangular tanks are most convenient. They can be aerated either with an air–water lift (AWL) system (Fig. 3.17), by an aeration collar mounted around a central standpipe or by perforated polyvinyl chloride (PVC) tubes fixed to the bottom of the tank.
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia
89
Fig. 3.17 Air–water lift.
For large volumes (⬎1 m3), it is advantageous to switch to cement tanks covered on the inside with impermeable plastic sheets or coated with special paint. These large tanks are traditionally operated as raceway systems. They are oblong, approximately 1.5 m wide and with a height:width ratio kept close to 1:2. The length is then chosen according to the desired volume. The corners of the tank may be curved to prevent dead zones where sedimentation can take place. A partition, to which AWLs are fixed, is installed in the middle of the tank and ensures a combined horizontal and vertical movement of the water, which results in a screw-like flow pattern (Bossuyt & Sorgeloos 1980). If axial blowers are used for aeration, the water depth should not exceed 1.2 m to ensure optimal water circulation. Filter design The most important and critical equipment in flow-through culturing is the filter used for efficient evacuation of excess culture water and metabolites without losing the brine shrimp from the culture tank. These filter units should be able to operate without clogging for at least 24 h, to reduce risks of overflowing. Traditionally, filters are constructed as a PVC frame around which an interchangeable nylon screen is fixed. The aeration is positioned at the bottom of the filter, ensuring a continuous friction of air bubbles against the sides of the filter screen and thus reducing filter-mesh clogging (Fig. 3.18). A more sophisticated type of cylindrical filter system consists of a welded-wedge screen cylinder, made of stainless steel. This welded-wedge system has several advantages with respect to the filter-screen types:
• •
Larger particles with an elongated shape can still be evacuated through the slit openings. The specially designed V-shape of the slit openings creates specific hydrodynamic suction effects, as a result of which filter particles that are only slightly smaller than the slit opening are sucked through.
90
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
65
filter bag
70
20
PVC frame
60
air
55
65
60
20
15
aeration collar 25 4
55
Fig. 3.18 Construction of filters used in Artemia culture (dimensions in cm).
•
Possible contact points between particles and filter are reduced to two instead of four mesh borders, which consequently reduces the chances of clogging.
This filter can be operated autonomously for much longer periods than traditional mesh filters. Therefore, proportionally smaller welded-wedge filters can be used, leaving more volume for the animals in the culture tank. As brine shrimp grow, the filter is regularly switched for one with a larger mesh or slit opening to achieve maximal evacuation of moults, faeces and other waste particles from the culture tanks. A set of filters covering a 14 day culture period should consist of approximately six different slit or mesh openings ranging from 120 to 350 m. Heating When ambient temperature is below the culture optimum range (25–28°C), heating is imperative. Small volumes (⬍1 m3) are most conveniently heated using electric thermoregulated resistors. Depending on the ambient temperature, a capacity up to 1000 W m⫺3 must be provided. For larger volumes, a heat exchanger consisting of a thermostatically controlled boiler with copper tubing under the bottom of the culture tank is recommended. Heat losses can be avoided by insulating the tanks with Styrofoam and covering the surface with plastic sheets. Feed distribution apparatus Dry feed cannot be distributed directly to the culture tank, but should be suspended by mixing it in tap water or seawater beforehand. The feed suspension is distributed to the culture tanks via a timer-controlled pump. The volume of the food tank should be big enough to hold the highest daily food ration at a concentration maximum of 200 g food l⫺1. Even at those concentrations, the food suspension is so thick that there is a high risk of blocking of the food lines.
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia
91
3.3.6 Culture techniques Depending on the objectives and the opportunities, different culture procedures for highdensity intensive Artemia production may be applied. The final selection of the type of culture installation will be subject to local conditions, production needs and investment possibilities. Decisions need to be made as to: (a) whether or not the water should be renewed (open flow-through); and (b) in the latter case, whether a particular water treatment should be applied (closed flow-through or stagnant or batch system). There are many kinds of transition types, ranging from open flow-through with 0% recirculation to closed flow-through with 100% recirculation. In reality, even at complete recirculation, a small part of the culture water must be regularly renewed. The culture system should be designed in such a way that the water quality can be maintained as close to optimal as possible. This means that the concentration of particles and soluble metabolites should remain minimal to prevent toxicity problems, proliferation of micro-organisms and interferences with the filter-feeding apparatus of the brine shrimp. Stagnant systems Stagnant systems are the simplest concept for intensive Artemia culture: no wastewater evacuation, filter systems or water treatment are involved. The culture is started in an aerated tank and biomass is harvested after a reduced culture period. The main disadvantage is that high animal densities do not allow for extended culture periods because of the degradation of the water quality. Successful trials with 10 animals l⫺1 on micronised soya pellets yielded Artemia juveniles of 3 mm in length and over 75% survival in 7 days (Dhont et al. 1993). Open flow-through A discontinuous or continuous renewal of culture water by clean seawater, with consequent dilution of particulate and dissolved metabolites, will result in the best possible culture conditions and highest production capacities. Application of an open flow-through culture technique, however, is limited to those situations where large volumes of sufficiently warm seawater (or brine) are available at relatively low cost, or where large quantities of algal food are available, such as from effluents from artificial upwelling projects, tertiary treatment systems or intensive grow-out ponds of shrimp. The water retention time is chosen so as to reach an optimal compromise between efficient evacuation of wastewater and minimal food losses. A very simple semi flow-through system has been developed by Dhert et al. (1992). The system does not require the use of feeding pumps and involves minimal care. The pilot system consists of six oval raceway tanks of 1 m3 and six reservoir tanks of the same capacity placed above each culture tank. These reservoir tanks hold seawater and food (squeezed rice bran suspension), and need manual refilling only once or twice a day. They are slowly drained to the culture tanks, and flow rate is easily adjusted by means of a siphon of a selected diameter. Retention time is at least 12 h. The culture effluent is drained using weldedwedge filters as described above. This technique involves minimal sophistication and appears to be very predictable in production yields, which are between those obtained in batch and flow-through systems (see Section 3.3.9 for production figures).
92
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
Closed flow-through (recirculation) systems When only limited quantities of warm seawater are available, open flow-through systems cannot be considered. High-density flow-through culturing of Artemia can only be sustained by recirculating the culture water via a water treatment unit. This unit should be designed to remove particles and decrease levels of harmful nitrogen components. Several suitable recirculation systems have been designed, proving that more than one solution exists to treat effluents from intensive Artemia cultures. However, at least one option will be most appropriate to a given situation when local conditions are taken into account. In general, a recirculation unit consists of a mechanical treatment that removes flocculations, particles, debris, etc., and a biological treatment that breaks down ammonia to nitrite and nitrate, and lowers the biological oxygen demand (BOD). A unit that removes the soluble fraction is also included. An overview of the most frequently used treatment components is presented in Table 3.4.
3.3.7 Control of infections Heavy losses of pre-adults may be due to infections with the filamentous bacterium Leucothrix, which particularly occur in nutrient-rich media (Solangi et al. 1979). The Leucothrix colonies fix on to the exoskeleton, by preference on the thoracopods, and become visible only from instar V/VI stage onwards. The brine shrimp suffer physically, as the movements of their thoracopods become affected and, consequently, filtration rates are reduced. Ultimately, growth and moulting are arrested, and overfeeding of the tanks occurs, eventually resulting in a collapse of the Artemia culture. One cure may be the application of tetramycin; however, antibiotics cannot be used in recirculation systems as they will affect the biological treatment unit. Raising salinity from 35 to 50–60 g l⫺1 appears to be the most practical solution, coupled with a higher water renewal rate of 25% instead of 10% on a weekly basis (Lavens et al. 1986). A second observed disease in Artemia cultures is the ‘black disease’. Black spots appear primarily on the extremities, such as on the thoracopods and antennae. This disease consists of the detachment of the epidermis from the cuticula, and is caused by a dietary deficiency, which interferes with lipid metabolism (Hernandorena 1987). In high-density cultures of Artemia using agricultural by-products as a food source, the black disease is observed when water quality deteriorates (probably interfering with the composition of the bacterial population and consequently the diet composition) and/or when feeding rates are not optimal. Improving these conditions does not save the affected animals, but appears to avoid further losses.
Table 3.4 Water treatment systems used in intensive Artemia culture. Treatment
Type
Reference
Mechanical treatment
Plate separator Cross flow sieve Foam fractioner or protein skimmer
Lavens et al. (1986) Brisset et al. (1982) Lim et al. (2001)
Biological treatment
Rotating disc contactor
Bossuyt & Sorgeloos (1980)
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia
93
3.3.8 Harvest and processing of cultured Artemia Harvesting of high-density cultures of Artemia can be facilitated by taking advantage of the surface respiration behaviour of the animals. When the aeration in the culture tank, together with the flow-through and the automatic feeding are interrupted, oxygen levels in the water drop very quickly and all waste particles sink to the bottom; after about 30 min the Artemia respond to the oxygen depletion by concentrating at the water surface, where they perform surface respiration. The concentrated population, free from suspended solids, can easily be scooped out with a net of an appropriate mesh size. When the culture water is not loaded with particles, brine shrimp can be harvested by draining the complete culture over a sieve, which should be partially submerged. The Artemia should be washed thoroughly in freshwater or seawater. The harvested Artemia can then be offered as live food for freshwater as well as marine predators. The salinity of the predator culture water is of no concern, as Artemia is a hypo-osmoregulator, and its body fluids have a constant and low salt content of about 9 g l⫺1. In seawater, they remain alive without feeding for several days. When transferred into freshwater, Artemia will continue to swim for another 5 h, after which time they eventually die as a result of osmoregulatory stress. Live brine shrimp can be transported in plastic bags containing cooled seawater under oxygen. Harvested Artemia that are not for immediate consumption can be frozen or dried in flakes. To ensure optimal product quality, brine shrimp biomass must be frozen immediately after thorough washing with freshwater when still alive. The biomass should be spread out in thin layers (1 cm) in plastic bags or on ice trays, and transferred to a quick freezer (at least ⫺15°C). The adult exoskeleton is not damaged when the biomass is frozen properly. Upon thawing, the Artemia cubes yield intact animals, which do not pollute the water by leaching of body fluids.
3.3.9 Production figures of intensive Artemia cultures Figure 3.19 provides a summary of average production data expressed as Artemia survival and length, obtained in the different culture systems described in this chapter. After 8
100
7 6 growth (mm)
survival (%)
80 60 40
5 4 3 2
20
1 0
0 0
2
4
6
8
10
time (days)
12
14
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
time (days)
Fig. 3.19 Production figures of various intensive Artemia cultures. (ⵧ) 1000 litre open flow-through culture on rice bran diet (Dhert et al. 1992); (䉫) 200 litre open flow-through culture on Chaetoceros diet (modified from Lavens 1989); (⌬) 300 litre closed flow-through culture on a mixture of soyabean waste and corn bran (modified from Lavens 1989); (䊊) 3 m3 closed flow-through raceway culture on rice bran diet (modified from Lavens 1989); (⫻) 500 litre batch culture on a mixture of pea and corn bran (Dhont, unpublished data).
94
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
2 weeks of culturing, pre-adult or adult Artemia with an average length of 5 mm or more can be harvested. In a flow-through culture there is a slight but continuous mortality during the whole of the culture period. No significant differences in survival are observed between open flow-through and recirculating cultures (Fig. 3.19). In stagnant cultures, there is a significantly higher mortality during the end of the first week of culture, which can be explained by the deterioration of the water quality, probably because the early naupliar stages are more sensitive than the juvenile or pre-adult stages. Average production yields harvested after 2 weeks (live wet weight Artemia biomass relative to tank volume) amount to 5, 15 and 25 kg m⫺3 for batch production, and flow-through systems using micronised feeds and live algae, respectively. These differences in production figures are mainly the result of differences in maximum stocking density at the start and survival at the end of the culture trial.
3.4 Biochemical Composition 3.4.1 Proximate composition Dealing with the biochemical composition of any living organisms usually involves a great deal of generalisation. Presented figures inevitably consist of average values that may conceal subtle changes or intriguing differences. In the case of Artemia, distinctions between species, sources and life-stage must be made, owing to its specific nature and the range of its applications. Unlike algae or rotifers, different life stages of Artemia are used as larval food: from the embryonic form (as decapsulated cysts), through non-feeding nauplii and enriched nauplii, to adult biomass. These life stages may show important biochemical differences. Different Artemia strains or even Artemia from the same strain but from another batch or a different seasonal harvest may show variation in their composition. However, the most important differences in composition can be observed with the exogenous feeding stages (instar II and later). Since Artemia is a non-selective filter-feeder with a relatively high ratio of gut content to body volume, its composition is highly dependent on its diet. This section aims to give a comprehensive picture of the composition of various Artemia forms (see Table 3.5). 3.4.1.1 Cysts and decapsulated cysts Since the chorion of Artemia cysts is completely indigestible by all known cultured species, the biochemical composition of intact cysts could be considered irrelevant, since they cannot be used as a food source. However, once this chorion has been removed by chemical decapsulation (see Section 3.5.4) the remaining embryo is digestible, and has been used successfully in the larviculture of carp, catfish, milkfish and some marine shrimp. 3.4.1.2 Nauplii There is a crucial distinction between the first larval stage or instar I, which is nonfeeding, and subsequent stages (instar II and further), which have a functional digestive
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia
95
Table 3.5 Proximate composition of different developmental stages of Artemia (% on a dry weight basis). Artemia stage Source (refs)
Protein (%)
Lipid (%)
Carbohydrate Ash (%) (%)
Fibre (%)
DW (g)
Cysts GSL, USA (a) SFB, USA (e) Mexico (e)
55.8 45.2 41.4–50.2
11.2 3.9 0.3–1.0
6.9 36.3 36.4
— — —
4.83 — —
Decapsulated cysts GSL, USA (a) SFB, USA (d)
50.6 67.4
14.7 15.7
6.6 —
10.6 —
— —
3.42 —
Nauplii GSL, USA (a) GSL, USA (b) GSL, USA (c) PR China (b) France (b) SFB, USA (b,d)
56.2 41.6–47.2 61.9 47.3 55.7 41.9–59.2
17.0 20.9–23.1 14.4 12.0 12.4 15.9–27.2
3.6 10.5 10.6 — — 11.2
7.6 9.5 7.1 21.4 15.4 8.17
— — 5.9 — — —
2.31 1.65–2.70 — 3.09 2.7–3.1 1.45–2.87
Adults: wild population San Diego, USA (b) SFB, USA (b) Italy (g)
64.0 50.2–58.0 41.9
12.0 2.4–19.3 3.5
— 17.2 —
20.6 29.2 —
— — —
— — —
Adults: cultured GSL, USA (b,c,f) France (b) SFB, USA (d) Italy (g)
50.8–67.4 53.7 39.4–64.0 55.4
10.8–30.6 9.4 4.5–12.1 4.0
4.0–12.3 — — 20.0
5.2–13.6 21.6 — 20.6
4.2 — — —
— — — —
5.9 5.2 5.8–12.6
References: a, García-Ortega et al. (1998); b, Léger et al. (1986); c, Lim et al. (2001); d, Dendrinos and Thorpe (1987); e, Correa Sandoval et al. (1993); f, Correa Sandoval et al. (1994); g, Trotta et al. (1987). DW, dry weight; GSL, Great Salt Lake; SFB, San Francisco Bay; —, not mentioned.
system. Instar I nauplii survive by depleting their yolk reserves, and gradually decrease in nutritional value and in energetic content. Their initial composition reflects the parental characteristics, both genetic and phenotypic, while from instar II nauplii onwards, the composition will also be influenced by the diet. Several publications offer data on naupliar composition, but few authors make a clear distinction between instar I and instar II stages. This is understandable given the fact that asynchronous hatching produces batches of nauplii consisting of different stages. 3.4.1.3 Juveniles and adults Ongrown Artemia are used much less frequently in aquaculture than nauplii, for the reason that, while nauplii can easily be obtained through simple hatching of widely available and storable cysts, culturing Artemia requires a considerable amount of labour and infrastructure. Even though various culture techniques have been developed to suit all kinds of local conditions (Section 3.3; Dhont & Lavens 1996), they often remain a significant extra investment. However, the nutritional value of ongrown Artemia compared with freshly hatched nauplii is superior, at least with respect to its protein quality and individual energetic content.
96
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture
3.4.2 Lipids The lipid fraction has undoubtedly received most attention in marine larviculture, yielding a wealth of published lipid analysis on all kind of Artemia strains and live stages. Published values seem to exhibit important differences (Table 3.6). Besides natural fluctuations, these differences may also arise from different analytical methodologies or inaccurate definitions of what exactly was analysed (e.g. exact strain or larval stage). 3.4.2.1 Cysts and nauplii The lipid content and profile of cysts and instar I nauplii are not affected by diet or environmental conditions. The differences in lipid profile that are observed between strains (Triantaphyllidis et al. 1995; Han et al. 2000b) can reflect either genetic characteristics or the lipid profile of the food of the parental population. However, the lipid profile is considered to be environmentally rather than genetically determined, as several authors have demonstrated that the fatty acid profile of Artemia adults and their offspring clearly reflects the composition of the parental diet, regardless of the strain (Vos et al. 1984; Millamena et al. 1988; Lavens et al. 1989; Navarro & Amat 1992). Many publications include values for 15 or more different fatty acids in Artemia nauplii, but according to Léger et al. (1986) only six fatty acids (16:0, 16:1n-7, 18:1n-9, 18:2n-6, 18:3n-3 and 20:5n-3) actually make up Table 3.6 Fatty acid composition of different developmental stages of Artemia (mg g⫺1 dry weight).
Artemia stage Source (refs)
Palmitic acid (16:0)
Cysts GSL, USA (a)
12.7
3.9
19.1
5.5
Decapsulated cysts GSL, USA (a,b) France (b)
16.1–25.7 16.5
5.0–8.1 9.8
24.2 20.9
13.2–19.4 3.6 12.6
4.1–7.4 0.1 6.7
15.7 18.6 14.4 23.6
Nauplii GSL, USA (a,c,d) SFB, USA (e) PR China (f,g,h) Urmia, Iran (g) A. parthenogenetica (g,h) Madagascar (i) A. persimilis, Arg (h) A. tibetiana, China (j) Adults GSL, USA (k) GSL, USA (l) SFB, USA (c)
3.9 9.1 4.5–14.5
Palmitoleic acid (16:1n-7)
Linolenic acid (18:3n-3)
EPA (20:5n-3)
DHA (22:6n-3)
27.2
3.2
0.1
6.9–11.1 34.2–49.4 7.3 22.7
3.9–4.7 6.2
0.1
20.3–34.8 6.1 17.8
5.7–10.1 28.6–40.0 1.8 8.2 11.0 3.6–39.3
tr
1.6
23.7
12.2
6.8
3.5–8.9 0.6 1.4–7.5 2.7 3.5–14.7
0.0–0.4 0.4 0.0–0.4
20.2 9.5 2.4
21.2 17.9 40.4
7.4 8.0 6.2
6.25 16.7 tr
24.5 0.0 44.7
0.0 0.3 0.2
1.7 0.0 3.5–13.5
1.7 2.8 2.5–3.9
0.8 0.0 0.1–0.4
1.7 4.3 0.2–1.0
Oleic acid (18:1n-9)
7.4 18.3 9.0–17.1
Linoleic acid (18:2n-6)
15.4 15.9 1.7–30.5
References: a, García-Ortega et al. (1998); b, Lavens et al. (1989); c, Estevez et al. (1998); d, Han et al. (2000a); e, Dendrinos and Thorpe (1987) (adults fed on yeast); f, Dhert et al. (1993); g, Triantaphyllidis et al. (1995); h, Han et al. (2000b); i, Triantaphyllidis et al. (1996); j, Han et al. (1999); k, Lim et al. (2001) (adults fed on rice bran); l, Lavens (1989) (adults fed on soya pellets). EPA, eicosapentaenoic acid; DHA, docosahexaenoic acid; GSL, Great Salt Lake; SFB, San Francisco Bay; tr, trace.
Biology, Tank Production and Nutritional Value of Artemia
97
about 80% of the total fatty acid pool in an Artemia sample. In later publications, some authors also detected significant levels of 18:1n-7, which was not reported earlier, probably reflecting increased chromatographic resolution (Estevez et al. 1998; Han et al. 2000b). Léger et al. (1986) compiled data on almost 150 fatty acid analyses of nauplii from about 20 different Artemia sources and came to the following conclusions. Oleic acid (18:1n-9) is often the most abundant fatty acid. It also has the most stable occurrence (lowest coefficient of variation). Together with palmitic (16:0) and palmitoleic acids (16:1n-7), it accounts for 40–60% of the total fatty acids in Artemia. The level of 16:0 is fairly constant over different strains, but levels of 16:1n-7 are more variable. Léger et al. (1986) concluded that Artemia nauplii contain between 0.4 and 33.6% linolenic acid (18:3n-3), but that the distribution of these levels is actually bimodal: 36% of the samples contain more than 20% of their total fatty acids as linolenic acid, while 43% of the samples contain less than 10% linolenic acid. The levels of EPA (20:5n-3) seem to be inversely related to linolenic acid levels. Most of these patterns can be recognised in the more recent compilation presented in Table 3.6. Only data expressed in mg g⫺1 dry weight have been listed here, as these not only reflect the relative proportions of the various fatty acids, but also indicate their quantities with reference to Artemia body weight. 3.4.2.2 Ongrown Artemia As soon as brine shrimp start feeding (at instar II), their lipid profile will quickly reflect the profile of their diet. This is the basis of the enrichment technique that is discussed in detail in Section 3.5.5. Just as for nauplii, the lipid composition of natural Artemia biomass will reflect the composition of its diet. The metabolic pathways and abilities of Artemia to convert one fatty acid to another are not yet entirely elucidated. Indications that Artemia converts docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) into EPA (McEvoy et al. 1995) were proven to be correct by Navarro et al. (1999). The conversion rate seems to vary according to the strain (Evjemo et al. 1997). Thus, it should be borne in mind that data on lipid composition of Artemia biomass reflects a variety of influences such as diet, season, geography, strain, life stage and physiological stage, and as such the figures presented only offer an indication of possible levels.
3.4.3 Proteins Some confusion appears when reviewing amino acid profiles of Artemia because of different methods of analysis or reporting the data. Nevertheless, it seems correct to state that protein levels and amino acid profiles show much less fluctuation between strains or life stages than, for example, the lipid fraction (Table 3.7). Adult Artemia have a slightly higher protein content than nauplii and contain slightly more essential amino acids than nauplii. The higher protein content of cysts compared with decapsulated cysts or nauplii is due to the presence of the chorion, which is composed of lipoprotein impregnated with chitin and haematin (García-Ortega et al. 1998). Nauplii contain markedly lower levels of free amino acids compared with wild copepods (Tonheim et al. 2000) but, generally, Artemia nauplii as well as adults contain sufficient levels of the 10 amino acids that are considered essential for fish larvae. Even so, methionine seems to be the first
98
Live Feeds in Marine Aquaculture Table 3.7 Amino acid composition of different developmental stages of Artemia (g 100 g⫺1 protein). Stage (refs) Cysts(b)
Decaps. cysts (a,c)
Nauplii (a,c)
Juveniles and adults (b,c,e)
Aspartic acid Threonine Serine Glutamic acid Proline Glycine Alanine Cystine Valine Methionine Isoleucine Leucine Tyrosine Phenylalanine Histidine Lysine Arginine Tryptophan
8.6 4.1 6.3 10.3 5.0 4.0 5.1 1.3 4.9 2.1 4.4 6.0 5.2 3.4 2.7 7.1 6.4 0.9
7.7–11.6 4.3–5.8 5.7–7.7 11.0–13.9 3.6 3.9–4.1 4.1–4.8 1.1–1.3 4.9–6.2 2.5–3.0 4.8–9.9 6.6 3.3–4.4 3.9–5.2 2.7–3.2 7.1–9.7 7.0–9.3 1.3
7.6–9.4 4.3–5.2 5.2–5.5 11.2–12.3 4.2 4.0–4.9 4.4–5.1 1.1–1.6 4.9–5.9 2.3–1.9 4.7–5.3 6.5–7.4 3.4–3.7 3.9–4.4 2.5–3.5 7.3–8.1 6.8–16.1 1.2
5.8–10.5 2.4–6.3 2.6–6.2 7.5–13.9 3.3–10.9 2.7–11.0 3.6–6.7 0.1–2.3 3.2–7.4 0.7–2.3 3.0–6.3 4.5–8.2 2.2–5.0 2.3–6.4 1.3–3.6 4.2–9.9 2.7–8.2 —
Total amino acid
87.8
85.5–111.6
85.5–105.7
52.1–125.1
References: a, García-Ortega et al. (1998); b, Lim et al. (2001) (adults fed on rice bran); c, Dendrinos and Thorpe (1987) (adults fed on yeast); e, Trotta et al. (1987). Decaps., decapsulated.
limiting amino acid when feeding nauplii to fish larvae (Fyhn et al. 1993; Conceição et al. 1997; Helland et al. 1999). Most protein in Artemia nauplii consists of small size proteins with a molecular weight between 7.4 and 49.2 kDa (García-Ortega 1999). The presence of these low molecular weight peptides and free amino acids in nauplii, together with their autolytic capacity and high solubility, accounts for the easy digestion of the proteins by fish larvae.
3.4.4 Vitamins Most data on vitamins relate to Artemia franciscana (Table 3.8). An account of differences between strains could only be found for ascorbic acid (AscA) forms in cysts in Merchie et al. (1995). They observed considerable differences in ascorbic acid 2 sulfate (AscAS) concentrations (296–517 g g⫺1 dry weight expressed as AscA) when comparing 10 different strains. Furthermore, they provided further evidence for the complete conversion of the