This page intentionally left blank
LIONEL ROBBINS
By the time of his death, the English economist Lionel Robbins (18...
68 downloads
3344 Views
7MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
This page intentionally left blank
LIONEL ROBBINS
By the time of his death, the English economist Lionel Robbins (1898–1984) was celebrated as a ‘Renaissance man.’ He made major contributions to his own academic discipline and applied his skills as an economist not only to practical problems of economic policy – with conspicuous success when he served as head of the economists advising the wartime coalition government of Winston Churchill in 1940–5 – and of higher education – the ‘Robbins Report’ of 1963 – but also to the administration of the visual and performing arts that he loved deeply. He was devoted to the London School of Economics, from his time as an undergraduate following active service as an artillery officer on the Western Front in 1917–18, through his years as professor of economics (1929– 62) and his stint as chairman of the governors during the ‘troubles’ of the late 1960s. This comprehensive biography, based on his personal and professional correspondence and other papers, covers all these many and varied activities. Susan Howson is Professor of Economics and Fellow of Trinity College, University of Toronto. She was educated at the London School of Economics (1964–9) and at the University of Cambridge, where she obtained her PhD in 1975. She has held visiting positions in the International Division of the Bank of England in 1979–81; Nuffield College Oxford in 1984–5; and Wolfson College Cambridge in 1991–3. Professor Howson is the author of Domestic Monetary Management in Britain 1919–38 (Cambridge University Press, 1975) and British Monetary Policy 1945–51 (1993) and coauthor with Donald Winch of The Economic Advisory Council (Cambridge University Press, 1977). She edited The Collected Papers of James Meade (3 volumes, 1988) and coedited with Donald Moggridge the wartime diaries of Lionel Robbins and Nobel Laureate James Meade and the Cabinet Office diary of James Meade (1990). Professor Howson began research on the life and work of Lionel Robbins in the early 1990s. She edited a selection of his major articles in economic theory and economic policy under the title Economic Science and Political Economy (1997). Her work on British economic policy has been published in The Economic Journal, Economic History Review, History of Political Economy, Journal of Economic History and Oxford Economic Papers, among other publications. She is also a contributor to the Cambridge Economic History of Modern Britain (Structural Change and Growth, Volume III, 2004). The recipient of two prizes for research in economic history, Professor Howson has also held two Connaught Senior Research Fellowships in the Social Sciences in 2004 and 2007 for her work on Lionel Robbins.
HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVES ON MODERN ECONOMICS
General Editor: Craufurd D. Goodwin, Duke University This series contains original works that challenge and enlighten historians of economics. For the profession as a whole, it promotes better understanding of the origin and content of modern economics. Other Books in the Series: Arie Arnon, Monetary Theory and Policy from Hume and Smith to Wicksell: Money, Credit, and the Economy William J. Barber, Designs within Disorder: Franklin D. Roosevelt, the Economists, and the Shaping of American Economic Policy, 1933–1945 William J. Barber, From New Era to New Deal: Herbert Hoover, the Economists, and American Economic Policy, 1921–1933 Fillipo Cesarano, Monetary Theory and Bretton Woods: The Construction of an International Monetary Order Timothy Davis, Ricardo’s Macroeconomics: Money, Trade Cycles, and Growth Jerry Evensky, Adam Smith’s Moral Philosophy: A Historical and Contemporary Perspective on Markets, Law, Ethics, and Culture M. June Flanders, International Monetary Economics, 1870–1960: Between the Classical and the New Classical J. Daniel Hammond, Theory and Measurement: Causality Issues in Milton Friedman’s Monetary Economics Samuel Hollander, The Economics of Karl Marx: Analysis and Application Lars Jonung (ed.), The Stockholm School of Economics Revisited Kyun Kim, Equilibrium Business Cycle Theory in Historical Perspective Gerald M. Koot, English Historical Economics, 1870–1926: The Rise of Economic History and Mercantilism David Laidler, Fabricating the Keynesian Revolution: Studies of the Inter-War Literature on Money, the Cycle, and Unemployment Odd Langholm, The Legacy of Scholasticism in Economic Thought: Antecedents of Choice and Power Robert Leonard, Von Neumann, Morgenstern, and the Creation of Game Theory Series list continues after the Index.
Lionel Robbins SUSAN HOWSON University of Toronto
cambridge university press Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, S˜ao Paulo, Delhi, Tokyo, Mexico City Cambridge University Press 32 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10013-2473, USA www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9781107002449 C Susan Howson 2011
This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published 2011 Printed in the United States of America A catalog record for this publication is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication data Howson, Susan, 1945– Lionel Robbins : a life in economics, government, and the arts / Susan Howson. p. cm. – (Historical perspectives on modern economics) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-107-00244-9 (hardback) 1. Robbins, Lionel Robbins, Baron, 1898–1984. 2. Economists – Great Britain – Biography. 3. Economics – Great Britain. 4. World War, 1939–1945 – Economic aspects. I. Title. II. Series. HB103.R6H69 2011 330.092–dc22 [B] 2011002213 ISBN 978-1-107-00244-9 Hardback Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of URLs for external or third-party Internet Web sites referred to in this publication and does not guarantee that any content on such Web sites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate.
Contents
List of Illustrations
page ix
Abbreviations
xi
Introduction
1
1
Father and son
11
2
The Great War
25
3
Postwar
51
4
The London School of Economics
68
5
Iris Gardiner
103
6
New College Oxford
126
7
The young professor
166
8
Fritz and Lionel
206
9
The School in the mid-1930s
242
10
The approach of war
294
11
The economics of war
342
12
Director of the Economic Section
387
13
Anglo-American conversations
424
14
The Law Mission and the Steering Committee
462
15
1944
495
vii
viii
Contents
16
The last months of the war
553
17
The postwar settlement
587
18
Return to the School
642
19
The end of the transition
681
20
LSE in the early 1950s
712
21
Chairman of the National Gallery
760
22
Lord Robbins
826
23
The Robbins Report
858
24
The sixties
897
25
The arts
941
26
The troubles at LSE
975
27
Retirement
1022
Conclusion
1079
Bibliography
1091
Index
1131
Illustrations
All the photographs come from the Robbins family with the exception of 14 (Illustrated London News Picture Library), 20 and 24 (the author) and 26 (Tarlok Singh). Illustration 14 is reproduced by permission of the Mary C Evans Picture Library; 23 with permission of the Financial Times Ltd; 29 Donald Southern Photograph Collection, courtesy of Royal Opera House Collections; and 30 the London School of Economics and Political Science. Illustration 8 is adapted from Basil Liddell Hart, A History of the Great War 1914–1918 (1934), 512; 13 is in the Robbins Papers; 16, now in the Derso and Kelen Collection, Public Policy Papers, Department of Rare Books and Special Collections, Princeton University Library, appears by permission of Princeton University Library. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16.
Sipson Farm, Lionel Robbins’s birthplace Hollycroft: lawn and west windows Hollycroft: the nursery Caroline, Lionel and Winifred Nethania The ‘three blind mice’ 2nd Lt Robbins The Battle of the Lys Lionel and Iris, 1923 or 1924 Lionel’s father, 1925 Lionel in Berlin, 3 May 1932 Lionel and Iris on holiday in Austria Sketch for a Christmas card, 1933 Lionel lecturing in Cambridge in 1940 Hot Springs, 21 May 1943 ‘This happy breed of men . . . ’ ix
page 330 331 331 332 333 334 335 336 337 338 339 339 340 341 629 630
x 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30.
Illustrations Lionel and Iris on holiday in Wales, July 1943 Delegate’s card, Bretton Woods, 1944 The family at Hollycroft, December 1945 10 Meadway Close Jacob Viner at Meadway Close Lionel Robbins and Friedrich Hayek Bracken House, 27 November 1962 4 Marine Parade, Lyme Regis Lionel at 4 Marine Parade Arriving at New Delhi, 16 December 1964 Concentration: Montauk Point, September 1967 Lecturing at Bologna, 1971 Lord Goodman and Lionel Robbins The naming of the Lionel Robbins Building, 27 July 1978
631 632 632 633 633 634 635 636 637 638 638 639 640 641
Abbreviations
AGG AUTE BCom BL BLPES BOC BOE BP BSC BSc(Econ) BSE BT CAB CEIS CO COD CSO CU CUL CUP DES DO Docs
ED
Alfred George Gardiner Association of University Teachers of Economics Bachelor of Commerce British Library British Library of Political and Economic Science Bank of Canada Archives Bank of England Archives British Petroleum Ballet Subcommittee Bachelor of Science in Economics Board of Studies in Economics Board of Trade Papers Cabinet Office Papers Central Economic Information Service Colonial Office Papers The Collected Papers of James Meade Volume IV: The Cabinet Office Diary 1944–46 Central Statistical Office Clearing Union Cambridge University Library Cambridge University Press Department of Education and Science Dominions Office Papers Documents on British Policy Overseas, Series I, Volume III Britain and America: Negotiation of the United States Loan 3 August–7 December 1945 Ministry of Education Papers xi
xii
EJ FAH FAO FO FRUS FSC FT GIIS GLC GPC HCDebs HLDebs HMG HMSO IBRD ICR IEA IEG/IER ILO IMF ITO JEM JMK LAC LCES LCR LNU LoN LPC LSE m MAF MAP MERL NACF NATO nd NFU NG NGA
Abbreviations
Economic Journal The Collected Works of F. A. Hayek Food and Agriculture Organization Foreign Office Papers Foreign Relations of the United States Finance Subcommittee Financial Times Graduate Institute of International Studies Greater London Council General Purposes Committee House of Commons Debates House of Lords Debates His/Her Majesty’s Government His/Her Majesty’s Stationery Office International Bank for Reconstruction and Development Ivy Caroline Robbins Institute of Economic Affairs Iris Elizabeth Gardiner/Robbins International Labour Organization International Monetary Fund International Trade Organization The Collected Papers of James Meade The Collected Writings of John Maynard Keynes Library and Archives Canada London and Cambridge Economic Service Lionel Charles Robbins League of Nations Union League of Nations Lord President’s Committee London School of Economics and Political Science million Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries Ministry of Aircraft Production Museum of English Rural Life National Art Collections Fund North Atlantic Treaty Organization not dated National Farmers’ Union National Gallery National Gallery Archives
Abbreviations
NIESR NPG ODNB OEEC OUP PPE Proceedings
RA RACS RBA RES RFA RIIA ROH RP RRR SF SPSL T TDRs TNA UCL UGC UNRRA WD WEA WO
xiii
National Institute of Economic and Social Research National Portrait Gallery Oxford Dictionary of National Biography Organization for European Economic Cooperation Oxford University Press Philosophy, Politics and Economics Proceedings and Documents of the United Nations Monetary and Financial Conference, Bretton Woods, New Hampshire, July 1–22, 1944 Royal Artillery Royal Artillery Cadet School Reserve Bank of Australia Archives Royal Economic Society Royal Field Artillery Royal Institute of International Affairs Royal Opera House Robbins Papers Rowland Richard Robbins Stabilization Fund Society for the Protection of Science and Learning Treasury Papers Treasury Deposit Receipts The National Archives University College London University Grants Committee United Nations Relief and Rehabilitation Administration The Wartime Diaries of Lionel Robbins and James Meade, 1943– 45 Workers Educational Association War Office Papers
Introduction
I have often been asked why I am writing a biography of Lionel Robbins. I usually reply, truthfully, ‘His family asked me to.’ But that is not the answer to the question I am being asked. The English economist Lionel Robbins (1898–1984) left his mark in several ways, in his own country and elsewhere. His legacy remains in at least three areas: the academic discipline of economics; UK domestic and international economic policy, especially in the Second World War; and the arts in Britain. He is most associated with the London School of Economics (‘LSE’ or ‘the School’ to its students and staff), whose Economics Department he headed for thirty years and built up to its preeminent position in British economics. To economists he is still known as the author of An Essay on the Nature and Significance of Economic Science (1932 and 1935), which is one of the three most important methodological statements on economics, and the source of its famous definition, ‘Economics is the science which studies human behaviour as a relationship between ends and scarce means which have alternative uses.’ But he was always as much interested in economic policy as in economic theory, in what he called political economy as distinct from economic science. During the Second World War, he entered government service in June 1940 and became (1941–5) the head of the group of economists advising the coalition government under Winston Churchill. As well as helping to create the British total war economy, he was decisively involved in the preparation of the white paper, Employment Policy (1944), and in the creation of the postwar international economy – a major figure in the process by which the visionary ideas of John Maynard Keynes in Britain and Harry Dexter White in the USA became the Bretton Woods institutions: the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank – and in the notoriously difficult Anglo-American loan negotiations at the end of the war, which allowed Britain to participate in the new postwar economic order. He was 1
2
Lionel Robbins
also a lover of the visual and performing arts, who took advantage of his skills and opportunities to serve the arts in the management of the Courtauld Institute of Art, the National Gallery and the Royal Opera House in London. Although he became famous in the 1960s for the ‘Robbins Report’ of the Committee on Higher Education (1961–3), his contribution to the wellbeing of the arts in Britain has been longer lasting. According to the recent historian of the National Gallery (Conlin 2006, 184), ‘The economist Lionel Robbins was probably the greatest of the Trustees to serve in the last century’ and ‘arguably the most effective Trustee the Gallery ever had.’ Lionel Robbins did not intend to become an economist. His first intellectual love was English literature and he first entered university to study it. As he put it in his autobiography (1971a, 29), ‘my chief, indeed my only, real ambition in life was to be an effective poet.’ His father, a very successful farmer and a local magistrate in Middlesex near London, would have preferred him to become a lawyer: indeed he later paid for his son to read for the Bar. The first five chapters of this biography tell the story of Lionel Robbins’s early life and how he came to be offered and to accept his first academic position as a temporary lecturer in economics at New College Oxford in 1924, the sixth how within five years he became a professor of economics at LSE at the age of thirty. Chapters 1 to 4 describe his family background, his school and university education and the development of the close friendships that were to remain important to him for the rest of his life. They also describe his gradual loss of religious faith, his evolving political views – from the Liberalism of his parents to socialism – out of which began his interest in economics, and his growing love of art and music which came to replace religion in his emotional and intellectual life. Like so many of his generation, the First World War interrupted Robbins’s education. After only one term reading Intermediate Arts at University College London (UCL) he entered the Royal Artillery as an officer cadet. He was commissioned in 1916, served on the Western Front in 1917–18 and was wounded and invalided home in April 1918. He returned from the war a socialist, and as a socialist he resumed his education, at LSE in 1920–3, after two years working in the labour movement. As an undergraduate he was a student of political science under Harold Laski. It was also during the Great War that he discovered the theatre, hitherto kept from him by his upbringing as a Strict Baptist, and ballet. At the same time it was from an artist friend, Clive Gardiner (whose younger sister he was to marry in 1924), that he learned to appreciate both Renaissance art and the Impressionists and Post-Impressionists, especially C´ezanne. It was his desire to marry Iris Gardiner that prompted him, in his first postgraduate year, to decide to
Introduction
3
become an economist, as Chapter 5 explains. By that time his study of economics had also completed his disillusionment with socialism. After teaching at New College Oxford (1924–5 and 1927–9) and LSE (1925–7) Lionel Robbins found himself with the responsibility of running the Economics Department at LSE. His accomplishments there and outside the School in the 1930s are the subject of four chapters (7–10). He gathered together an outstanding group of young economists, including John Hicks, Nicholas Kaldor and Friedrich von Hayek. Hayek and Robbins first met when Hayek came from Vienna to deliver four public lectures in January 1931. They became close friends, and close colleagues when Hayek accepted the Tooke Chair of Economics and Statistics at LSE in 1932. Lionel himself went to Vienna in April 1933, for the first time since he was an undergraduate. He came back to establish, with the director of the School, William Beveridge, the Academic Freedom Committee which helped Jewish and liberal academics and students to escape Nazi Germany. Meanwhile, his first opportunity to apply economic analysis to practical problems had been distinctly unsuccessful. When the Labour Prime Minister James Ramsay MacDonald asked J.M. Keynes in the summer of 1930 to chair a committee of economists to provide an ‘agreed diagnosis’ of and possible remedies for the unemployment problem in Britain, Keynes invited Robbins to serve. Keynes was incensed when the young professor refused to follow Keynes’s lead in contemplating protection and public works as means to reduce unemployment and insisted on a minority report of his own. Lionel came later to regret his negative attitude to public expenditure in depressed conditions and to reject the ‘Austrian’ theory he used to analyse the 1930s slump in his second book, The Great Depression (1934). As he noted in his autobiography (1971a, 153), ‘I realized that these constructions [of theory] led to conclusions which were highly unpalatable as regards practical action. But . . . [if they were valid] it was my duty to base recommendations as regards policy upon them. There was a touch of the Nonconformist conscience here.’ But he never regretted nor budged from his free-trade stance or lost his concern for real-world political and economic issues. While his younger colleagues engaged in vigorous theoretical debates, often in the famous graduate seminar he presided over at LSE, his own writing increasingly focussed on international economic problems and the economic causes of war (1937, 1939). The chapters of this biography devoted to Lionel Robbins’s wartime government service are written as a contribution to the political and economic history of the Second World War – reflecting the fact that he participated in so many episodes and the wealth of new material available in his papers and
4
Lionel Robbins
other archives. His active support of Keynes’s ideas on how to pay for the war began as soon as he entered government service and intensified when James Meade (to whom as a student he had lectured at Oxford) joined the economists in the War Cabinet Offices in order to compile the first national income and expenditure estimates. They worked closely together, and with Keynes, for the rest of the war. The first war chapter (11) covers the phoney war period that Robbins spent with LSE in Cambridge and the first year of active war when he and his economist colleagues in government devised the highly popular system of points rationing for food. Thereafter, the Economic Section, with Robbins as director and Meade his deputy, was actively committed to planning for a better postwar world. He was deeply involved in three aspects: domestic employment policy, international monetary policy, and trade and commercial policy. The planning began in the winter of 1941–2 even while Lionel and his colleagues had many more immediate wartime problems to attend to (Chapter 12). The three strands of planning and policymaking then ran in parallel but at different speeds, largely for political reasons: the intrinsic problems of a coalition government and the complicated relations with the US government after the passage of the Lend–Lease Act in March 1941. Robbins played a major role in the Anglo-American discussions on postwar international economic policy in Washington and in London and represented the UK at the United Nations conferences at Hot Springs in 1943 and Bretton Woods in 1944 (Chapters 13–15). Given his background and interests he was throughout the war often engaged in the less fruitful discussions of commodities and agriculture. He was still involved in these and in the still uncompleted discussions on postwar commercial policy as the war neared its end and the problems of the immediate postwar period became more pressing (Chapter 16). The climax of his wartime government service came in the autumn of 1945 with the bitter and protracted negotiations for a postwar loan from the US government (Chapter 17). On this and the earlier missions to Washington, Robbins became personally very close to Keynes in spite of their doctrinal differences in the 1930s. Although, as he admitted to Laski in 1949, there was ‘a side of my character which is very well pleased with administrative and diplomatic duties’, Lionel Robbins was determined not to remain in government service in peacetime. He returned to LSE and resumed his position as head of the Economics Department. As in the 1930s he enthusiastically encouraged the research and helped the careers of a long and distinguished line of students and younger colleagues. He participated vigorously in public policy debate from 1947 onwards. In spite of his desire to distance himself from government, he was
Introduction
5
consulted by two Chancellors of the Exchequer on monetary policy in the 1950s. He was consistently critical of the inadequate use of monetary policy as an instrument for the preservation of balance-of-payments equilibrium under the Bretton Woods system of fixed exchange rates. One of his specific recommendations for improved monetary control was adopted by the Bank of England in 1958. In his own work he followed the example of the Canadian economist Jacob Viner, a friend and mentor since their first meeting in Oxford in 1927, and became a scholarly and accomplished historian of economic thought, especially of English classical political economy from Adam Smith to John Stuart Mill in two major books (1952 and 1958). These and his other activities in the late 1940s and the 1950s are discussed in Chapters 18–21. The most important of the other activities concerned the arts. The crucial step was his appointment in 1950 to a committee on the export of works of art chaired by his former boss in Whitehall, Sir John Anderson, who became Lord Waverley. He helped to write the report recommending a standing reviewing committee on the export of works of art, which is still in existence. As he later commented (1971a, 249), ‘One thing leads to another’: two days after the last meeting of the Waverley Committee he was asked to serve as a trustee of the National Gallery. In his twenty-one years on its board he served two seven-year terms as chairman. As its liaison trustee on the board of the Tate Gallery he helped to resolve the ‘Tate Affair’ in 1954 (Spalding 1998, chapter 9), an ugly dispute involving the director and the trustees, of whom a friend from his Whitehall days had recently become chair. In 1954–5, at the request of the Treasury, he chaired a committee on the rebuilding of the bombed-out Queen’s Hall, an interesting case study in the economics of the performing arts. The achievements of his first term as chairman at the National Gallery included the restoration of its war-damaged building, the government’s acquisition of a site for its future extension, an eightfold increase of its annual grant from the Treasury, as well as special grants for particular paintings (most notably Paolo Uccello’s St George and the Dragon), and, last but not least, a settlement of the forty-year-old dispute between the British and Irish governments over the thirty-nine continental paintings bequeathed to the gallery by Sir Hugh Lane (Chapter 21). The highlight of his second term was the acquisition of C´ezanne’s Les Grandes Baigneuses in 1964. For nearly thirty years he was a director of the Royal Opera House Covent Garden. Originally invited to join the board by Waverley on the initiative of Garret Drogheda in 1956, he managed to persuade Waverley of the need for a finance committee, which he then chaired for twenty years, tackling from an economist’s standpoint the
6
Lionel Robbins
chronic funding problems of mounting opera and ballet. He also served on the ballet subcommittee and remained on the board until 1980, intimately involved at the end in the controversial redevelopment of the House. Lionel Robbins’s contributions to ballet and opera at Covent Garden, and his second term at the National Gallery, are the subject of Chapter 25 (continued in Chapter 27). In January 1959 he had accepted the offer of a life peerage. He had also agreed to join the board of the Financial Times newspaper and to become chairman after two years’ experience. As a result, but with great reluctance, he gave up his chair of economics at LSE (Chapter 22) – although he continued to lecture there for another twenty years. He was also reluctant to take on the chairmanship of the Committee on Higher Education, as it meant he could not write the treatise on economic theory he had been planning to write since the 1930s. The committee’s report, which he wrote two and a half years later after intensive study of universities at home and overseas and statistical work on the demand for higher education in Britain conducted by Claus Moser and Richard Layard, encouraged the expansion of British post-secondary education in the 1960s (Chapter 23). He had already assisted directly in the creation of the University of York in England and, as a result of the report, he was to serve as the first chancellor of another new university, Stirling, in Scotland. He was chairman of the Financial Times for ten years: according to its historian (Kynaston 1988, 279), ‘It was in almost every sense a fortunate appointment. Perhaps most importantly, it helped, through Robbins’s academic distinction, to give the paper a certain added intellectual authority – at a time when that was precisely the quality the FT was looking for in order to build on the foundations so painstakingly laid by [the editor Gordon] Newton in the 1950s. Robbins himself never sought to influence editorial policy, but the connection was there.’ Chapter 24 also discusses his academic work – teaching and writing – in the 1960s. Lord Robbins was chairman of the governors of LSE from 1968 to 1973, a turbulent period that included the ‘troubles’ of 1968–9. Although criticized at the time for usurping the role of the director, he can be seen now as having thus prevented further disruption and preserved the academic reputation of the School (Chapter 26). In his ‘retirement’ he further demonstrated his loyalty and devotion in his strenuous and unselfish leadership of the appeal to rehouse the library in what is now appropriately the Lionel Robbins Building. ‘The success of the Appeal was to be his last great gift to the School’ (Dahrendorf 1995, 479). In his seventies he also spoke frequently in the House of Lords on economic policy and on education, travelled extensively, usually to give lectures, and published six books (Chapter 27).
Introduction
7
Having worked closely with him for nearly twenty years, at Covent Garden and the Financial Times and as a governor of LSE, Lord Drogheda pointed out in 1974 that ‘in everyone who has worked alongside of him, Lionel Robbins inspires, in equal measure, affection and respect. The affection is due to his warmth of heart and breadth of understanding, to the knowledge that he is the staunchest of friends, whose sympathy and support is most readily available when it is most needed, whose loyalty, and willingness to help without regard to personal inconvenience, are legendary to all who know him. The respect is due to his massive intellect, his remarkable wideranging knowledge, his intense industry, his great sense of public duty, his utter selflessness; and, coupled with these things, his deep humility.’ These qualities have been repeatedly mentioned by those – younger colleagues, friends and fellow economists – with whom I have talked about Lionel Robbins. As Sir Karl Popper told me, ‘I loved and admired him, most of all for his moral and personal qualities – and as a teacher.’ I am very grateful for illuminating conversations about Lionel Robbins to: the late Iris Robbins, Caroline Robbins and Richard Robbins; Nancy Robbins, Rowland Robbins, Anne and Christopher Johnson and Philip Robbins; the late Anne Bohm, Bernard Corry, Aaron Director, Marjorie Durbin, Lionel Elvin, Milton Friedman, John Ginger, Lord Harris of High Cross, Clarisse Kaldor, Kurt Klappholz, James and Margaret Meade, Edith Penrose, Sir Henry Phelps Brown, Sir Karl Popper, Austin Robinson and John Watkins; and William Baumol, Mark Blaug, Partha Dasgupta, Alan and Shirley Day, Lord Desai, Dorothy and Frank Hahn, David Laidler, Richard Lipsey, Morris Miller, Lord Moser, Robert Orr, Ben Roberts, Lord Roll, Sir John Tooley, Ralph Turvey and Basil Yamey. They have all helped me make sense of the documentary evidence. I have tried to indicate the location of letters and other unpublished documents as economically as possible. Hence for family letters I provide only the recipient or writer and the date. Other material in the possession of the Robbins family that is destined for the archives at LSE is indicated by the name of the file or notebook and RP. The Robbins Papers already there appear with their collection name and file number, for example Robbins 1/1. Other archival material is similarly described, for instance Viner 22–14 for the file of correspondence with Robbins in the Viner Papers Box 22 Folder 14, Public Policy Papers, Department of Rare Books and Special Collections, Princeton University Library. Files in the UK National Archives at Kew are identified by their call numbers, for example T230/1. The archives consulted are listed before the published sources (which are referred to in the text by author and date of publication).
8
Lionel Robbins
I am very grateful to the archivists who have helped me locate invaluable material: Sue Donnelly and Angela Raspin of the British Library of Political and Economic Science, Colin Harris of the Bodleian Library, Caroline Dalton of New College Oxford, Alan Crookham, David Carter and Isobel Siddons of the National Gallery, Francesca Franchi Head of Collections Royal Opera House, Marianne Ehrhardt of the University of Queensland Library, Virginia MacDonald of the Reserve Bank of Australia and Caroline Gould of the Museum of English Rural Life. I am also very grateful to Stefania Martinotti Dorigo of the Fondazione Luigi Einaudi for sending me the correspondence between Einaudi and Robbins, to the Beinecke Library of Yale University for copies of the correspondence of Ezra Pound with Basil Bunting and Lionel Robbins, and to Alexander Swoboda, director of the Graduate Institute of International Studies in Geneva, for providing me with copies of Robbins’s correspondence in the Institute’s archives and from the William Rappard Papers in the Federal Archives in Bern. For permission to cite or quote from archival material I have to thank the British Library of Political and Economic Science, the Bodleian Library, the Warden and Scholars of New College Oxford, the Warden and Fellows of Nuffield College Oxford, the Provost and Scholars of King’s College Cambridge, Trinity College Cambridge, Churchill College Cambridge, Cambridge University Library, University College London, Senate House Library University of London, the British Library Board, the National Gallery, Tate Archive, the Courtauld Institute of Art, the Royal Opera House, the Royal Institute of International Affairs, the Bank of England, the Controller of Her Majesty’s Stationery Office, Library and Archives Canada, the Reserve Bank of Australia, the National Archives College Park, the Hoover Institution on War, Revolution, and Peace, the Rockefeller Archive Center, Princeton University Library, Stanford University, the Special Collections Research Center of the University of Chicago Library, the Rare Book, Manuscript and Special Collections Library of Duke University, the University Librarian and Director of the John Rylands University Library of the University of Manchester, the Museum of English Rural Life, the Mont Pelerin Society, the Director of the Universit¨atsbibliothek Basel, the University of Klagenfurt Karl Popper Library, the Estate of F.A. Hayek, Seymour J. Weissmann, John Freeman, Elizabeth Johnson, Anthony Thirlwall, John Halliday and the family of James Meade. Letters from Ezra Pound to Lionel Robbins C 2011 by Mary de Rachewiltz and The Estate of Omar S. Pound) are used ( by permission of New Directions Publishing Corporation. I am especially grateful to the director of the London School of Economics for allowing me to read and quote from Robbins’s Personal File and his Student’s Dossier.
Introduction
9
I am very grateful to the late John Ginger and to Peter Ginger for the opportunity to read and quote from John’s unpublished biography of Reginald Lawson and from his notes of discussions with Lawson and Robbins. I also wish to thank Wilma Johnson, Vicky Johnson and Lizzy Johnson for memories of their grandfather; Ellen Seiler for copies of the letters to her mother from her father Jacob Viner on his first visit to England in 1927; Richard Freeman for two letters in the Foxwell Collection; Philip Clarke and Robert M. Rauner for sending me their recollections of Lionel Robbins while they were students at LSE, Tarlok Singh for his memoir and photographs of Robbins, and Victor Urquidi for his recollections and for a copy of his notes of Robbins’s lectures in 1938–9. Several economists and historians have helped by sending me books, articles or papers: Riccardo Faucci, Harald Hagemann, J¨org Guido H¨ulsmann, Frederic Lee, Philip Schofield and Philip Sherwood. Selwyn Cornish was very helpful with his recollections of Leslie Melville and with his hospitality at the Australian National University in Canberra. I should like to thank Lord Coleraine for providing me with information from his father’s diary, Lord Crowther for correspondence between his father and Lionel Robbins, and Lord Kennet for permission to consult the Kennet Papers in Cambridge University Library. Richard Lambert and David Bell kindly allowed me to read the Financial Times Ltd Minute Book for the years that Lionel Robbins was on the board of Financial Times Ltd and Financial News Ltd. I am happy to acknowledge the support of the Institute for New Economic Thinking in the production of this book. I am very grateful for the generous financial assistance of the Wincott Foundation, of the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada, and of the Connaught Foundation, the School of Graduate Studies and the Faculty of Arts and Science at the University of Toronto, all of whom have provided me with time to research and to write. With their help I have also enjoyed the assistance of Megan McGarvie, Nathan Nunn and the late Shauna Saunders. Maggie Przywecki helped with translation from Polish. Many friends have acted as unofficial research assistants and in other ways. I should like especially to mention my best friend and colleague Donald Moggridge, who searched archives in the USA for Robbins’s letters when he was looking for Dennis Robertson’s; Patricia Wright in Cambridge; Kathy Rasmussen in Ottawa and London; Dorothy Wigmore in Sweden; Donald Winch in Sussex; and the late Virginia Clark in London. Several friends have read and commented on an earlier version of this manuscript: Anne Johnson, Christopher Johnson, Donald Moggridge, David Laidler, Richard Lipsey, Francine McKenzie, Richard Robbins, Donald Winch, Jeremy Wormell and Patricia Wright. I
10
Lionel Robbins
have tried to follow their advice, and that of two anonymous readers for Cambridge University Press, but all errors, infelicities and omissions are mine. I thank my family for moral support (and David Chester for introducing me to the history of the Baptists). I should most of all like to thank the members of the Robbins family who asked me to undertake the biography: the late Iris Robbins, Anne and Christopher Johnson and the late Richard Robbins. I am deeply grateful for their friendship. I am only sorry that Iris and Richard will not see the published book.
ONE
Father and Son
Lionel Charles Robbins was born on 22 November 1898, the first child of Rowland Richard Robbins and Rosa Marion Robbins (n´ee Harris), at Sipson Farm in the village of Sipson just west of London. He described his birthplace in his autobiography (1971a, 18): ‘Sipson itself was nothing memorable, little more than a conjunction of four roads lined with labourers’ cottages, three public houses and four farmsteads, of which that of Messrs Wild and Robbins, my father’s farm, was by the far the largest.’ It was one of four villages within the parish of Harmondsworth, the others being Harmondsworth, Longford and Heath Row. Longford was on the main road from London to Bath, Harmondsworth and Sipson to the north of it, Heath Row due south of Sipson on the opposite side of the Bath Road. North of Sipson lay the Grand Union Canal and West Drayton, with the nearest railway station. Today Sipson is bounded by the M4 motorway on the north and, immediately south of the Bath Road, London’s Heathrow Airport. The spur road between them runs across the land Lionel Robbins’s father used to farm. Rowland Richard Robbins (1872–1960) was the eighth of nine children of Rowland Robbins and Caroline Robbins (n´ee Ebbs), with two elder brothers Frank and Arthur. Their father was a prosperous London greengrocer, with two shops in Knightsbridge and Kensington, who was able to send his younger sons to public schools and to set Arthur up as a market gardener in Chiswick to provide fresh vegetables for the shops. After working with Arthur, Rowland, with no prospects in the family businesses, offered himself as a junior partner to Thomas Wild (1848–1932), whose family had lived and farmed in Sipson for several generations. Wild had been seriously ill and unable to run his farm, and his son, another Thomas, was too young to take over. Robbins was highly successful, becoming the senior partner of an enterprise which at its peak farmed more than 500 acres and 11
12
Lionel Robbins
employed 200 people. In the early 1930s, when agricultural prices were severely depressed, it was valued at nearly £45,000. The firm specialized in produce for the London market, sending fruit and vegetables up to Covent Garden every weekday evening. Robbins was, according to his eldest daughter, ‘an intellectual farmer [who] learnt farming out of books: he read up about everything he did.’1 He served as president of the National Farmers’ Union in 1921 and 1925. Rowland Richard Robbins (who was usually known as Richard or Dick) married Rosa Harris in March 1896. They lived first in the seventeenthcentury farmhouse of Sipson Farm, Thomas Wild having built a new house, The Vineries, for his family in the village in the 1880s. In the early 1900s the Robbinses moved to Hollycroft, a large early nineteenth-century house in the centre of the village, next to the general store and post office (which is still standing) (Sherwood ed 1996, 114–16). Its name survives in the housing development of Hollycroft Close built on its site after it was demolished in 1964. Lionel Robbins remembered (1971a, 18): ‘Externally it was architecturally undistinguished; but it was roomy and well laid out inside, and with the central heating which my father, always interested in technical innovation, installed almost at once, it was very pleasant and commodious for a family of our size.’ When the renovations were taking place Lionel is said (according to his stepbrother Rowland) to have met one of the workmen and told him proudly, ‘I’m the heir to this estate!’ There were now three children: Lionel, Ivy and Winifred. Twin boys had been born in September 1901 but one, Walter Rowland, had died aged two days; the other was stillborn. Ivy Caroline (who as an adult was always known as Caroline) was born in August 1903 at Sipson Farm, Annette Winifred in July 1905 at Hollycroft. A sixth child, Oliver Percy, was born in May 1907 and died after three weeks (information from Robbins family tree and tombstone in Harmondsworth churchyard). Lionel’s mother was the fourth of eleven children of Charles Centurier Harris and Annette Harris (n´ee Wilson). The size of the Harris clan – nine daughters and two sons – ensured that Lionel and his sisters had many uncles, aunts and cousins. Rosa’s oldest sister, Annette Grace, had married Lionel’s uncle Arthur in 1888; they had five children, including two boys near Lionel in age, and lived nearby in Hounslow. Another sister, Lily, and her husband Arthur Harris lived at Southall, also near Sipson. Rosa’s brothers 1
Information from Robbins family tree, Robbins (1971a, 12–13), Sherwood (1973, 7–10), Rowland Robbins (LCR’s stepbrother) and Caroline Robbins. The comments of LCR’s siblings come from conversations with Caroline Robbins (at Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania, 27 November 1991), Nancy Robbins (Heacham, Norfolk, 16 July 1997) and Rowland Robbins (Bedford, 5 August 1997).
Father and Son
13
Charles and Herbert married sisters, Lillie and Marie Lawson. The Harris grandparents had fifty grandchildren by their golden wedding anniversary in 1914 (Wilson 1965, 27). They lived in some style at 3 Cavendish Avenue, St John’s Wood, Charles Harris, an architect by profession, having been allowed to marry Annette on condition that he enter the family business of her father, a prosperous wholesale provision merchant. When Rosa was young, they lived at Nethania Lodge, Grove Gardens, just west of Regents Park, an area whose ‘respectability . . . was sadly disturbed in the 1890s, when the Great Central Railway destroyed the villas and broke into the terraces’ to reach Marylebone station (Cherry and Pevsner 1991, 662); by the time she married, the family had moved to Cavendish Avenue, just north of Lord’s cricket ground. St John’s Wood, with its ‘mixture of villas and terraces in generous gardens . . . had until the early C 20 a character decidedly of its own, a comfortable, verdant, early Victorian character, never showy and never mean’ (ibid., 664). They gave their new home the name of their old. ‘The house was called Nethania, a narrow, four-storied rectangle of grey brick with white pillars and cornices, neatly compressed by high walls between two similar structures, as impeccably genteel as the London suburb of St John’s Wood. . . . The name Nethania was taken from the book of Nehemiah, and it meant “Gift of God”’ (Wilson 1965, 27). There grandfather Harris lived in the bosom of his large family, collecting china – of which he was something of a connoisseur – and other objects, and painting in oils and watercolour. ‘Apart from missionaries and other ministers of religion,’ Lionel later wrote (1971a, 14), ‘in all our many visits to his home I do not recollect having ever met anyone except my aunts and uncles, their numerous progeny and other connections of his and my grandmother’s family.’ As with most large families, the generations overlapped. One of Lionel’s uncles by marriage, Reginald Lawson, was to become a close friend (see Chapter 2). He told his biographer: ‘On Sunday afternoons . . . we often went to tea at the Harris’s . . . an enormous tea was provided for about twenty, the [immediate] family numbered twelve, and usually half-a-dozen guests. On Sundays grace was sung. . . . The Harrises were half-Huguenot and talked local chapel gossip with a certain wit. After singing a second grace we went to the drawing room where hymn books were handed round and you might be asked to choose a hymn! Only two or three because it was necessary to walk half a mile to the chapel for the evening service which began at 6.30.’2 2
I am deeply indebted to John Ginger for long conversations about Lawson and for allowing me to read his unpublished biography, parts of Lawson’s autobiography and his notes of interviews with Lawson and LCR (including Lawson’s ‘Written answers to questions’, from which this quotation comes).
14
Lionel Robbins
The Huguenot in the family was Charles Centurier Harris’s mother, who had left Paris in 1830. The Harris clan were Strict Baptists and married into families also belonging to this rigidly Calvinist sect, including the Lawsons and the Robbinses. According to Robbins (1971a, 14–15), the ‘appalling doctrines’ of their belief included ‘predestination, original sin, eternal damnation for all but the [few] elect . . . , the literal inspiration of the Bible, the probable imminence of the Last Judgment, the Omnipotence of the Deity and His complete control of the course of history’. He had more sympathy for his maternal grandfather, who feared he might not be saved, than for his maternal grandmother, who was quite sure that she was. He and others have commented that she dominated the household, even as an invalid in her eighties. ‘Gentle though she was, her views were always positive for, like all the Harrises, she saw life never in shades of grey, always in blacks or whites’ (Wilson 1965, 30). The belief common to all Baptists is that Christian baptism should be administered only to believers, not to infants, for which there is no scriptural justification. (Modern Baptists also follow scripture in baptizing by immersion.) But in England from the 1630s there were also Particular as well as General Baptists, the Particular Baptists believing that the redemption offered by the death of Christ was limited to the elect only, whereas the General Baptists believed Christ had died for all men. There have also been differences among Baptists over whether participation in communion and church membership should be open to all professed believers or restricted to baptized believers. In the communion controversy of the nineteenth century many Particular Baptists took the closed-communion side and became known as Strict and Particular or just Strict Baptists (Underwood 1947, 58–60; Dix 2001, 1–3). Local Baptist churches, Particular or General, are autonomous and self-governing; in 1891, when many Particular Baptist churches joined the evangelical ‘New Connexion’ of General Baptists, which had been formed in 1770, the Strict Baptists stayed out (Underwood 1947, 153–64, 201–16; Briggs 1994, 96–157). As one Strict Baptist minister put it (Dix 2001, 266), ‘Strict Baptists were always averse to any kind of change, whether necessary or otherwise. . . . Even the smallest change was greeted with dismay: the introduction of the fourth hymn in the services was seen as “the thin end of the wedge”, opening the way for more serious departures from the old paths. This conservatism was itself a shelter from the winds of change which were blowing across the Victorian religious world.’ By 1900 Strict Baptist churches were about a quarter of the total number of Baptist churches and chapels in England and located mostly in the southeast.
Father and Son
15
The Harrises and the Lawsons attended the Mount Zion chapel in Dorset Square, London NW 8 (near Marylebone station), where Lionel’s parents were married. Its first pastor, John Foreman, was ‘a determined strict communionist’, recognized by the time of his death in 1872 as ‘one of the heads of the Strict Baptist denomination’ (ibid., 177–81). In Harmondsworth parish there were three Baptist chapels. There had been a Baptist Meeting House in neighbouring Colnbrook since 1708, attended by members of the Wild family; one of its congregation, related to the Wilds, built the Little Chapel in Longford in 1859. The chapel in Harmondsworth village, which replaced an earlier one burnt down in 1884, was owned by Thomas Wild of Sipson, who offered it for sale to the congregation in 1902. Thomas Wild was also responsible for the building of Sipson Chapel in 1891. First used by the Salvation Army, which had been holding services in a shed on Sipson Farm, the chapel became a Gospel Mission in 1897 and in 1905 the members of the Mission resolved to form themselves into a Baptist church (Wild 1993, 28–30). The building survives, converted into residential accommodation in the 1980s, unlike the chapel’s mission hall in Cain’s Lane, Heathrow, which was demolished to make way for the airport in 1944. The Wild and Robbins families also opened the Welcome coffee tavern to provide their workers with an alternative to the public houses. This too was converted into houses, in the 1930s, and demolished in 1989 (Sherwood ed 1996, 113, 115). According to his youngest daughter Nancy, Dick Robbins helped to build the Sipson Baptist Church when he first worked with Thomas Wild. Most of the farm workers in the village were members of the congregation. The Hollycroft gardener, James Mitchell (‘Mitchie’ to young Lionel), was a deacon, as was the man who looked after the stables. Robbins also taught in the Sunday school, of which he was the superintendent, and his oldest son graduated from pupil to teacher at an early age. The hours of the Sabbath not spent in chapel or Sunday school were to be kept quietly: because non-religious books could not be read on the Lord’s day, in his teens Lionel ‘ploughed through endless works on the history of Nonconformist sects, martyrology and missionary enterprise, not to mention a good deal of Calvinistic theology’ as he began to have doubts about his parents’ beliefs (Robbins 1971a, 28). Those beliefs were sorely tested by Rosa’s illness and death from cancer at the age of thirty-nine, when Lionel was eleven. Her faith was not shaken, and her husband’s recovered, in spite of the further tragedy of the death of Winifred eighteen months later. But Lionel and his sister Caroline, who was only six when their mother died, could not thereafter easily believe in
16
Lionel Robbins
a beneficent and omnipotent God (ibid., 26): ‘I had been taught sedulously that with God all things are possible. If this were true, therefore, and if it were true moreover, what I was also taught, that His knowledge and foresight were infinite, it followed inexorably that the evil and the suffering in the world were of His deliberate manufacture, that since He could do anything, He could have done without them. And while I perceived, in my immature way, that there was much cruelty and misery in the universe, I could not believe that it was as miserable and cruel as this.’ Rosa was buried on 30 July 1910 in the family plot in the burying ground beside the Harmondsworth parish church of St Mary, where the two dead sons were already interred. Thomas Wild and his family lay in the adjacent plot. On the stone are engraved a religious poem and the words of Revelation XXII.4: ‘They shall see his face.’ Her husband Dick was devastated. On the evening of her death he sat up all night playing Bach on the pianola at Hollycroft (Lawson, ‘Written answers to questions’). In October 1911, at the Mount Zion chapel, he married his deceased wife’s sister Estelle May (Stella), who had moved to Hollycroft to look after the three children. Their marriage would have been disapproved of in the established church (the Church of England) but not by nonconformists. As the Robbins tombstone records, ‘She lit many fires in cold rooms.’ She and her brother-in-law had been married only two months when Winifred died after an operation that was performed at home; they later had two children of their own, Nancy Estelle born in 1913, and Rowland Clive, born in 1918 (and hence twenty years younger than Lionel). Lionel and Caroline were both very fond of her. Although they called her Mother, they did not think of her as such: she was after all their aunt (and eleven years younger than their mother). Nancy was always amused that her stepbrother and stepsister were also her cousins. Their mother’s death meant that despite the five-year difference in age Lionel and Ivy Caroline were very close – as children and as intellectual companions from their undergraduate days on. As Caroline remembered it, she readily abandoned any belief in God. For Lionel it took longer to accept, and he continued to struggle with his loss of faith until his late teens. While they lived at home they continued to attend chapel, so as not to upset their father and, especially, their more pious stepmother. All the Robbins children remembered their father as a very tolerant man, while she, as a Harris, was much more evangelical, and her children became devout evangelical Christians. Lionel’s mother’s early death meant that his father was to be the most important influence on Lionel for most of his life. From his mother, who was a beautiful young woman, Lionel inherited his own good looks. He also acquired her love of poetry, which she read
Father and Son
17
to her children as well as writing it. Some of her poetry was published in The Earthen Vessel and Gospel Herald, a monthly magazine for Strict Baptists.3 Lionel’s love of music probably came more from his father. Both parents, especially his father, encouraged his voracious reading. Having left school early, at just under fifteen years of age, when his own father offered him the alternative of learning farming from brother Arthur, Dick Robbins had effectively completed his education by reading widely. His study at Hollycroft was full of the works of the major nineteenth-century English writers, such as Carlyle and Ruskin, which he obliged his son to begin reading when Lionel was about twelve (Robbins 1971a, 28–9). On an Easter holiday in April 1913 Lionel reported to his father that he had just finished ‘“Gladstone on Church and State” [1838] and also “Civil Disabilities of the Jews” [Blunt 1830].’ Caroline’s judgment was that ‘the brains were on the Harris side, administrative ability on the Robbins side’ of the family; as the Harrises were ‘passionately fond’ of art and literature, ‘Lionel probably got his taste from his mother’s side, his tolerance and efficiency from his father’s side’. The business of Wild and Robbins was thriving and expanding as Lionel and Caroline were growing up. Robbins owned half the share capital of the company, the two Wilds the other half of the total (£40,000 in 1920), and Robbins was the managing director (Memorandum of Association and Articles of Association of Wild & Robbins Limited, 28 March 1920, RRR, RP). It continued to be prosperous right up to 1939, thanks to technical innovation and to the concentration on crops for Covent Garden market, for which the fertile brickearth soil surrounding the villages of Sipson and Harmondsworth was particularly suitable. The valuation of the farm on Lady Day (31 March) 1931 listed the growing vegetables as ‘cabbage lettuce leeks kale spinach broccoli New Zealand spinach rhubarb chokes potatoes beet greens Brussels [sprouts] onions marrows parsnips’. Four huge glasshouses provided table grapes, peaches and tomatoes. As a history of agriculture in the parish notes (Sherwood 1973, 9), ‘The marketing of such a large variety of vegetables requires much enterprise and organisation and a constant adjustment of production to meet the needs of a changing market. To be successful therefore a market-gardener has to be in a position, not only to produce the crops, but to have them in a continual succession so that there is never a gap in supplies and never a glut . . . Market-gardening is thus 3
A notebook of her poems written in the early 1890s and a copy of ‘Flowers’ published in The Earthen Vessel and Gospel Herald in September 1894 survive in her son’s Papers. The Gospel Herald, or Poor Christian’s Magazine, first published in 1833, and The Earthen Vessel, first published in 1845, merged in 1887 (Dix 2001, 142–6 and 186–8).
18
Lionel Robbins
both more profitable than other forms of farming and also more risky.’ The 1931 valuation also records that while the farm still had seventeen horses (which would have been used in earlier days to transport the produce the fourteen miles to Covent Garden), its ‘rolling stock’ comprised ‘1 steam lorry 1 superheated lorry 1 petrol lorry 1 Ford truck 1 New Ford [motorcar] 4 tractors [and] 3 ploughs.’ The new Ford was driven by the chauffeur; neither Lionel nor his father learned to drive it. The farm generated its own electricity, which lit Hollycroft and The Vineries, the only houses in the village with electricity when Lionel and Caroline were young (Sherwood 1973, 8). Even in the 1920s, Nancy remembered, these were the only electric lights in the village: ‘when we turned them out, the village had to go to bed.’ Most of the workers lived in tied cottages built by Wild and Robbins. The solid bourgeois comfort of Hollycroft included, besides electricity and central heating, well-proportioned and well-furnished rooms, with a fine archway across the welcoming entrance hall on the east side of the house and French windows from the drawing room to the lawn and garden on the west side. Judging from faded photographs, the furnishings were in the fashion of the period: wallpaper by J.H. Dearle or another of Willam Morris’s associates, patterned rugs and heavy dark furniture which was not too large for the big rooms. In the nursery was a wooden rocking horse for young master Lionel. For all the children, however, the chief delight of Hollycroft was its garden. Its two and a half acres, ‘well timbered with a very beautiful cedar tree shading the lawn by the house, an extensive rock garden with a summer house, an abundance of rosebeds and herbaceous borders, and stables with a loft’, afforded ‘almost infinite scope for sophisticated games of hide and seek, [an] enormous mulberry tree where one could climb up and read for hours unobserved by one’s elders, . . . [and] sedate garden parties with croquet on the one lawn, tennis on the other, and the uncles and aunts listening deferentially to my father as he unveiled horticultural arts or expatiated on local politics’ (Robbins 1971a, 19). According to Lionel’s younger brother Rowland, the croquet games of his childhood went on for hours, often finished by torchlight after darkness had fallen, while tennis was made more exciting by the roots under the court of the black Italian poplar which stood beside it. On one side of the house was the village, on the other the fields and one of the orchards of the farm. In the early twentieth century there were many other orchards in the villages of Harmondsworth and adjacent parishes – the Cox of Cox’s Orange Pippin apples is buried in Harmondsworth churchyard – but these decreased afterwards with the expansion of market-gardening. There were also holidays for the children, usually with their mother or stepmother and some of their sisters, as their father was often too involved
Father and Son
19
with the farm or local politics to get away. These were frequently seaside holidays, and Lionel’s fondness for swimming began at a young age (postcards and notes to Papa dated July 1900, 15 July 1904 (from Felixstowe) and April 1913 (Shanklin, Isle of Wight)). Lionel and Caroline were at first educated at home by governesses. Lionel then went to a preparatory school, Hounslow College, as a weekly boarder. The first school report kept by his father, for the term ending at Easter 1908 when Lionel was nine years old, records his highest marks for Reading (98 per cent), Latin and French (90 and 91), and his lowest for Writing (59 per cent) and Homework (65). His conduct was ‘Good’. In later reports from this school, Writing was usually at the bottom of the grades, Reading always near the top but overtaken by Scripture in December 1908 and April 1909. Lionel later (1971a, 23) thought this school was ‘one of his father’s mistakes’: the headmaster was a mild sadist as far as corporal punishment was concerned; ‘the staff were mediocre; the food was poor; and the control of the few boarders almost non-existent.’ By Easter 1909 his father had decided to send Lionel elsewhere. He had also decided not to send him to a public school. Dick Robbins had been sent to Taunton School in Somerset. Although the school was favoured by nonconformists (later pupils included the economists Henry Phelps Brown and Evan Durbin, both from dissenting backgrounds), observation of juvenile homosexuality had apparently horrified Robbins, who declared to his son that ‘No boy of mine shall be exposed to what I was exposed to’ there (ibid., 24). So he sent his son to the local state secondary school, Southall County School. Lionel Robbins does not, therefore, truly belong to the young men of Noel Annan’s memoir, Our Age, for whom ‘more important than their family connections was the old school tie’ (Annan 1990, 8–9). He travelled to the school each day by bicycle, using the towpath of the Grand Union Canal for part of the way, in good weather, or by train from West Drayton in bad. At the end of his first term, in July 1909, he was reported to be ‘Very untidy, work needs care’ and placed twenty-seventh in a class of twenty-eight, but his conduct was ‘good’. In his first full year at the school (1909/10) he made considerable progress and was soon in the top third of the class. The following year he was in the top five. After gaining a prize for English, he slipped back in that first term of the 1911/12 school year, the time of his sister Winifred’s death: ‘Work has been irregular and often careless. More serious effort is needed. Conduct V. Fair.’ He made the effort the next term and by the end of the year was back near the top of his class. There he remained until he entered the sixth form, coming top at Easter 1913 and again in July 1914 (when, however,
20
Lionel Robbins
Geometry ‘require[d] particular attention’). Meanwhile his sister had been sent to Bournemouth Collegiate School, where she enjoyed a much happier experience. If his first three years at Southall School were shadowed by his mother’s and sister’s deaths, his last two or three years there were enlivened by one of his schoolmates, Edwin (Eddie, sometimes Teddy) Rose, who became the centre of a group of boys who were interested in music and literature. (The school was coeducational, but although Lionel had friendly acquaintance with the girls who travelled to school by train, his close friends were, in the manner of adolescents, all male.) Eddie and Lionel, and another of the group, George Davidge, were to be lifelong friends. As schoolboys Lionel’s father christened them ‘the three blind mice’ (Mrs H.L. Davidge [George’s mother] to RRR, 3 December 1917). Years later Lionel’s first recollection of Eddie was seeing him at the top of the school playing field ‘leaning with his back against one of the uprights in the wooden fence, his fine brow forward, plunged in deep meditation’; he had seen him before and had heard that he was very clever but this was ‘the first time I became aware of him as a presence’. (Eddie recalled in November 1923 [Personal letters from Iris & Clive etc, RP] seeing Lionel playing tennis: ‘I thought “How I should like to know that boy!” but I had no pretext for making your acquaintance.’) Once they became acquainted they spent many evenings at Eddie’s home in Southall near their school. Eddie was an exceptionally gifted musician, a performer and a composer, who could also explain music to his friends, who would sit listening to him play the piano and talk about the music he was playing. He could talk equally knowledgeably about literature. On those evenings ‘our little group sat entranced in his music room, littered with scores and secondhand editions of classical literature, listening, oblivious of time, as those powerful fingers passed from one example to another of the musical conceptions he was expounding; or debating with each other the new vistas which each day of reading was discovering – Shelley, Sir Thomas Browne, the first part of Goethe’s Faust.’ Lionel thought he was a genius, one of the only three he ever met, the others being G.H. Hardy the mathematician and John Maynard Keynes the economist, as he told those gathered at the unveiling of a memorial to Eddie in October 1960 at the parish church where he had been choirmaster (Eddie Rose, 1897–1958, 27 October 1960, Biographical Notices, RP): ‘An odd judgment, you may think, and biassed by youthful friendship, for the world has not heard of him thus and never will.’ Eddie studied at the Royal College of Music after obtaining a University of London degree in English, but, after converting to Catholicism in his early twenties, spent much of his career teaching,
Father and Son
21
‘underpaid and unappreciated’, in a Catholic school (Robbins 1971a, 32). Lionel was relieved to learn that by the time of his death in 1958, when he had been for some years a lecturer in music at a teachers training college, Eddie had reverted to the Church of England in which he had been brought up (LCR to ICR, 16 October 1960). Lionel’s friends also visited Hollycroft. His father kept in touch with some of them after they left school, writing regularly, for instance, to George Davidge when he was with the British Army in Salonika in 1917 and 1918. At Hollycroft Robbins Senior would talk about current events and politics. In these years before the First World War he was becoming involved in politics, at first local, as well as good works related to his church. He was a member of Middlesex County Council for fifteen years, from 1913 to 1928. He became a magistrate and sat on the Middlesex bench for over fifty years. As far as national politics was concerned, he was a lifelong Liberal and free trader. Lionel took over these beliefs, although he did not maintain the tradition of the Robbinses and the Harrises, and other nonconformist families, of consistently supporting the then great Liberal Party. The imperial preference crusade of the Conservative Joseph Chamberlain in 1903 had reunited the Liberals, divided over Home Rule for Ireland since 1886, in defence of free trade and cheap food. In December 1905, after ten years out of office, the Liberals came to power when the Conservative Prime Minister Arthur Balfour resigned. The subsequent general election of January 1906 returned them in a landslide victory. Lionel recalled the local Liberal candidate visiting Hollycroft during the campaign, but the local seat remained Conservative. In April 1908 Herbert Henry Asquith became Prime Minister, with David Lloyd George as his Chancellor of the Exchequer. It was Lloyd George who introduced the famous ‘people’s budget’ of 1909, which raised direct taxation and made it more progressive, taxed the drink trade and took preliminary steps towards land taxation in order to finance social reform measures, and which the House of Lords rejected. The resulting constitutional crisis was only resolved by the passing of the Parliament Act in 1911. British politics then bogged down in the question of Irish Home Rule, which the Unionists in Parliament were determined to prevent. Lionel shared his father’s disgust and contempt for Conservatives such as Sir Edward Carson, who led the resistance to Home Rule, and Lord Northcliffe, the owner of The Times and Daily Mail newspapers – and his low opinion of Lloyd George, ‘the Welsh rat’, but that came later, after Lloyd George had replaced Asquith as Prime Minister in 1916 (LCR to RRR, 15 December 1917 and 4 January 1918).
22
Lionel Robbins
The National Farmers’ Union (NFU) was formed in 1908, developed from the Lincolnshire Farmers’ Union founded by Colin Campbell, and by 1913 had 20,000 members, mainly tenant farmers. It excluded landowners (as distinct from owner-occupiers), who were more than sufficiently represented in Parliament in the House of Lords (Whetham 1978, 67–8). In 1918 it reorganized itself and acquired a London headquarters. Dick Robbins became a member of one of its new subcommittees, the Fruit and Market Garden Committee, and, a year later, a member of the Council as well as of the Finance and General Purposes Committee and chairman of the Costs and Labour subcommittee. When he was proposed as president-elect in February 1920, he was described by Campbell, alluding to his work on the government’s Agricultural Wages Board and to his membership of the Council, as ‘A man of great ability and untiring energy, who never spared himself any trouble or time to attend to Union affairs, even by neglecting his own’. When Robbins responded that he was merely a grower of vegetables, ‘not an ordinary farmer’, one member called out ‘No, you are an extraordinary one.’4 Robbins had been a member of the Agricultural Wages Board since its creation in 1917. The Lloyd George government, worried by the wartime shortage of imported food, had initiated a food production campaign to increase the output of grain and potatoes from British farms. The Corn Production Act of 1917 established guaranteed minimum prices for wheat and oats for the crop years of 1917–22, provided for a national minimum wage in agriculture of 25s a week and for a national Agricultural Wages Board supplemented by district wage committees in England and Wales which could impose higher minimum wages in their own areas, and restricted the raising of agricultural rents (Royal Commission on Agriculture 1919, para 10; Whetham 1974, 39–40). In 1919, with postwar inflation came demands for increases in agricultural wages, which were eventually granted, but under the Corn Production Act the guaranteed grain prices were to decline in the next three years and end in 1922. Robbins, as one of the employers’ representatives on the Agricultural Wages Board, argued for a policy of conciliation rather than confrontation, and with the president of the NFU and another employers’ representative on the Agricultural Wages Board had been to see the Minister of Agriculture in March 1919 to put the farmers’ case. The NFU position was, reasonably enough, that it ‘[did] not object to 4
Information from minutes of Annual General Meeting 27 February and Special Meeting of Executive Committee 2 July 1918, Council 26 March and 9 April 1919, and Annual General Meeting 25 February 1920, NFU AD1/2, MERL.
Father and Son
23
the proposed increased wages, subject to the prices of farm produce being raised in the same proportion.’5 Dick Robbins was also a member of a Royal Commission appointed in July 1919 to enquire into the economic prospects of British agriculure. The majority of the Commission, including Robbins, recommended that guaranteed minimum grain prices, with their extension to barley, should continue unless and until Parliament gave four years’ notice of their withdrawal. The government adopted these recommendations (except for barley) and introduced the Agriculture Act 1920, continuing the guarantees for wheat and oats (Whetham 1974, 42–6). The Minister of Agriculture appointed in August 1919, Arthur Lee – the recently ennobled Lord Lee of Fareham – had already as Director General of Food Production in 1917 antagonized many Tory landowners with the Corn Production bill. He had to fight hard to get his new bill through the Cabinet in the spring of 1920, and even harder to get it through the two Houses of Parliament at the end of the year. According to Lady Lee’s diary for 23 December (Clark ed 1974, 202), ‘The Commons sat all through the night and up till 7.0 p.m. the next day on the Peers’ Amendments to A’s bill. Then it went back to the Lords, and at 10.30 p.m. back to the Commons again. At this moment it looked like a fatal deadlock, and the Cabinet was hastily summoned at midnight. . . . [Some Cabinet members] were prepared to jettison it altogether. L.G. himself seemed weak and wavering – at times almost hostile – and A had to fight as for his very life. Eventually he won out. . . . ’ (But within a month Lloyd George shifted him from Agriculture to the Admiralty.) Robbins decided that Lee was a man who kept his word – an assessment which was to have unexpected personal consequences for his son many years later (see Chapter 18). Six months later the government, alarmed by the prospect of falling prices in the summer of 1921, repealed the crucial part of the Act. It also abolished the Agricultural Wages Board, although allowing county wage committees to continue on a voluntary basis. As president of the NFU Robbins was heavily involved in negotiations with the government (see Chapter 4). After he served a second term as president in 1925, the county branches of the NFU presented him and Mrs Robbins with a motorcar and a music cabinet 5
Joint Conference between the Employers’ Representatives on the Agricultural Wages Board and the Executive Committee of the National Farmers Union, 26 February 1919, Executive Committee 18 March 1919 and Council 9 April 1919, NFU AD1/2. By the spring of 1919 farmers were paying at least twice prewar wages: in the south of England the 1919 increase took minimum wages up to 40s a week compared with 15s a week before the war.
24
Lionel Robbins
‘as a small [sic] token of gratitude and esteem’ (Council 18 March 1926, NFU AD1/7). He also chaired the NFU’s Legal and Parliamentary Press and Publicity Committees for a decade, having demonstrated his skill in dealing with the complexities of legislation in preparing amendments, which Lee introduced, to the Agriculture bill in 1920.6 His skills as a negotiator and conciliator were often utilized again on the Agricultural Wages Board when it was re-created in 1924 – and in NFU meetings. As his son was to find himself doing in similar situations, he would ‘suggest the adoption of the following resolution with a view to uniting the Council’, other members would withdraw their resolutions in favour of his, which was carried, and by the end of a contentious meeting he would have drafted a document to be sent out on behalf of the NFU (Special Meeting of Council 15 January 1929, NFU AD1/11). At one point he contemplated standing for Parliament but thought better of it, not wishing to be beholden to a political party according to his youngest daughter. He refused the offer of a knighthood from a Conservative Prime Minister in 1923 (LCR to RRR, nd but November or December 1923). He finally declined to remain on the Council and its committees at the end of 1931, when another coalition government introduced agricultural protection. His example of commitment and integrity was one his son sought to follow. 6
Finance and General Purposes Committee 10 June, Council 28 July and 15 December 1920, NFU AD1/3; Council 18 January 1921, NFU AD1/4.
TWO
The Great War
To a later generation the events of the summer of 1914 that led to the Great War read as a chapter of bizarre and sinister accidents. On 28 June, Archduke Franz Ferdinand and his wife were assassinated in Sarajevo by a student revolutionary agitating for the separation of Bosnia-Herzegovina from the Austro-Hungarian Empire and union with its eastern neighbour Serbia. After obtaining a guarantee of support from Germany in case Russia actively supported the Serbs, Austria first threatened Serbia, as it had often done before, and then declared war on it on 28 July when the Serbian government had refused to allow Austro-Hungarian troops to enter Serbia in search of conspirators. Serbia had already mobilized its forces; in support of Serbia, Russia ordered general mobilization on 30 July. Germany responded by declaring war on Russia on 1 August, and on Russia’s ally France two days later. Belgium refused a German demand to allow its forces to cross Belgium to get to France; Germany invaded Belgium; and Britain, who had guaranteed Belgian neutrality, declared war on Germany on 4 August. No wonder the outbreak of war ‘came like a bolt from the blue to all [the Robbins] family circle’ (Robbins 1971a, 33). In August 1914 Lionel Robbins was a fifteen-year-old schoolboy. He was expecting to stay at school for two more years before going to university. As he recalled (ibid., 29 and 35), his only ambition in life was to be ‘an effective poet’ – his father naturally had other ideas – and his early reaction to the war was poetic: ‘I wrote a poetic drama, in the mode of Shelley’s Hellas, entitled Peace Exiled. . . . I remember getting up very early in the morning to get naturalistic detail for a chorus about sunrise which was to mark the turning-point of the allegoric entity who was the central figure of the action. . . .’ The earliest surviving poem in his papers is ‘Sunrise, Hymn to Dawn, August 1914’. 25
26
Lionel Robbins
In subsequent poems written in that first year of war, sunset and night were more in evidence. At the end of 1914 he ‘saw the dying year tonight’ as the sun set and then ‘I saw the full moon tonight / She wore a robe of dew and light / I saw the old year sad and hoary / Stealing away from his blighted glory / While the new year came into wrong and pain.’ In August 1915 he drew a contrast between the quietness of night at home and the noise of war in France, although it was hardly realistic: ‘But there the noise of cannon rends the night / And bugles for the combat loudly blown / The sky is lurid with reflected light’ (‘The Old Year, December 31st 1914’ and ‘Moonlight, August 1915’, RP). By the end of 1914 the war on the Western Front had already claimed nearly a million Allied casualties. After the British Expeditionary Force had retreated on 24 August from Mons to the Marne, they and the French forces won a tactical victory over the Germans on 6–9 September. Although the Allies held the line against the German offensive, the cost in men of the first battle of Ypres of late October and early November led Lord Kitchener to call for 300,000 volunteers. As well as this ‘psychological landmark’ – the recognition that it would be a long war – the first battle of Ypres is also a military landmark. The trenchline had been dug from the Swiss border to the Belgian coast, bulging out round the notorious Ypres salient in Belgium. To quote the most famous military historian of the Great War (Liddell Hart 1934, 65), ‘The power of modern defence had triumphed over attack, and stalemate ensued. The military history of the Franco-British Alliance during the next four years is a story of the attempts to upset this deadlock, either by forcing the barrier or by haphazardly finding a way round.’ By the end of the first year of the war these attempts had included the second battle of Ypres (April and May 1915), failed British offensives at Neuve Chapelle in March and Festubert in May and the disastrous ANZAC landing at Gallipoli on 25 April. After a holiday at Towyn on the North Wales coast with his cousins Kenneth and Ralph Robbins, enjoying the scenery, the swimming, reading Ruskin’s Two Paths and his cousins’ company (LCR to Mother and Papa, [August], LCR to Papa, 2 September), in September 1914 Lionel Robbins began his sixth form studies at Southall County School. He continued to excel in English and to have to work hard at mathematics. In the first term the headmaster noted that his ‘Arith[metic] must be improved’ and in the second his algebra needed particular attention, but he had done ‘commendable work’ in geometry, the previous year’s weakness. He slipped to the bottom of the form in the second term, as a result of many days absent, presumably through illness, but by the end of the year he had
The Great War
27
‘done well’ and could be commended for his work in algebra, geometry, arithmetic, English, history, chemistry and geography (School Reports, 18 December 1914, Easter 1915 and 29 July 1915, RP). He passed the London Matriculation Examination, which included papers in English, Elementary Mathematics, a language and two other subjects. His father then decided he should go immediately to university instead of spending another year at school. As Lionel explained it (1971a, 36), his father thought that as his son was bound to serve in the war sooner or later he should have a year or two of university study first. Dick Robbins had indeed thought from the outbreak of war that his son ought to prepare for active service and Lionel had assured him in his letter from Towyn on 2 September that he would join the school cadet corps as soon as it was formed. He also wanted his son to have the university education he had not. Having joined the cadet corps, Lionel and his friend George Davidge went to camp with them at Marlborough in August 1915. In his first letter home on 2 August he proudly reported that he was on guard duty and ‘I being Corporal have to keep awake all night to change guard every two hours. The others rest in “stints” of 4 hours.’ He asked his father to compare his letter with those written from Wales a year earlier (in one of which he had claimed that German atrocities showed ‘their help cometh not from the Lord but from the devil’) and to ‘remark the lack of hysteria’. Otherwise his letters were full of comments on the food (or lack of it). After an interview with the ‘incredibly formidable’ Provost, Dr T. Gregory Foster (ibid., 36), Lionel was admitted to University College London to read for an Arts degree in October 1915. The Intermediate Arts Course required four subjects, including two languages, one of which had to be Latin or Greek. Lionel chose English and English History, Latin and Roman History, and French. He later remembered lectures by the professor of English W.P. Ker, the mediaeval historian F.C. Montague and the Tudor historian A.F. Pollard. For the ‘junior class’ Ker offered lectures on the history of English literature from 1500 to 1800 ‘with exercises in composition and special study of the following books’: Shakespeare’s Merchant of Venice and Coriolanus, Milton’s Aeropagitica, and Book III (the eighteenth-century section) of Palgrave’s Golden Treasury of English Songs and Lyrics. Montague and Pollard lectured respectively on general English history up to and after 1485. There was also a class on the history of the English language with texts from Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales and an elementary course in Old English, which students intending to read for English Honours after their first year were required to take. In history there was also a class for discussion of essays and
28
Lionel Robbins
the study of prescribed texts. The Latin class involved grammar, composition and unseen translation, with Livy Book XXII and Ovid’s Metamorphoses I and II as set books; the lectures in Roman history covered the period BC 280 to the death of Augustus. The junior class in French met three times a week with a fourth meeting for ‘Conversation and practical exercises’.1 But, of course, Lionel Robbins wanted to be in the war. At UCL he found himself (ibid., 37) ‘tall [6’21/2”], well built at that time, and not obviously under military age, together with a few less martial types, in classes predominantly feminine.’ He joined the University Officer Training Corps, ‘attended all parades, slept at nights with the horses under the eaves of the Old Foundling Hospital in Guilford Street, then used as temporary stables’, and ‘plagued my poor parents to do something to get me into the Army without having to tell a definite lie about my age’.2 According to his autobiography, ‘Shortly after Christmas 1915, with the aid of some War Office friend of our family solicitor [Arthur Ellis of Ellis & Fairbairn], I was admitted as cadet at the Royal Artillery Barracks at St John’s Wood, and almost immediately posted to a training centre at Topsham, just outside Exeter’. According to letters and papers kept by his father, however, he left UCL on 3 January 1916, a little more than a month after his seventeenth birthday, while his father tried to pull strings in order to ensure he would obtain a commission, preferably in the artillery, and he moved to the Royal Field Artillery training school at Topsham two months later. In joining up in January it appears he had taken advantage of the scheme devised for Asquith, then still Prime Minister, by Lord Derby whereby men of military age ‘attested’ their willingness to serve in the armed forces. After Lionel entered the RA Barracks, Robbins senior contacted three barristers of his acquaintance: the chairman of the Middlesex Bench Montague Sharpe, a member of the Middlesex Territorial Force Association (who could not help as the Middlesex TFA had no artillery); the Liberal MP Hamar Greenwood, who wrote that he did not know any colonel to whom he could write; and W.L. Ainslie of Dowson Ainslie & Co, who knew two. Ainslie received an encouraging letter from Brigadier General C.H. Alexander, the commanding officer of the East Anglian Divisional Artillery, and passed it on to Lionel’s 1
2
Information from University College Calendar 1915–16 19, 27–48; Harte and North (1991, 122, 156); and LCR’s student record at UCL. According to the timetable in the Calendar, the French conversation classes and the Roman history lectures were given at the same time, so LCR cannot have attended both. The Foundling Hospital, demolished in 1928, was on the site of what is now known as Coram’s Fields, between Brunswick and Mecklenburgh Squares.
The Great War
29
father who wrote to Alexander at the beginning of March 1916.3 A couple of days earlier Lionel had been ordered, with some thirty other cadets at St John’s Wood, to ‘report with full kit in 1/4 hours time to proceed to Exeter’, as he told his father on 4 March. When he received a copy of his father’s letter to Alexander he told him on 7 March that it was ‘ideal[:] I do not think my case could have been better stated and his reply will be very useful at the end of 4 months [training].’ He was acutely aware he was well below the minimum age (eighteen and a half) for a commission and hoped that ‘Alexander’s letter will get me out of any tight corners I may run into.’ The crude conversation and behaviour of Lionel’s fellow cadets came as a rude shock. Apart from his shortlived experience of a preparatory school he had lived at home and attended a coeducational grammar school. As his father had hoped, his knowledge of ‘perverse sexuality was purely academic until I came across public school men in the army’ (LCR, ‘Property, I Autobiographical Preface’, nd but 1922, RP) and he was not used to the coarse ways of describing heterosexual activities either. He strongly and priggishly disapproved of the drunkenness he witnessed among his companions. The intellectual contrast between university lectures and army training courses was also stark. Resentful of boring methods of instruction and disliking his companions (1971a, 38–9), he later claimed to have enjoyed only the ‘strenuous hours in the riding school, which I loved, and . . . wonderful surcingle rides in the early morning over the Devonshire hills, exercising the horses on Saturdays against their lack of work on the Sabbath.’ Other cadets, who arrived at Topsham from public schools, ‘had no difficulty in adjusting to . . . army life’ but found the riding school the most difficult and even dangerous part of the training (Paish 1998, 10, 13): Lewis (1937, 97) claimed that several were killed there while he was at RACS Topsham. At the time Lionel’s frequent letters home revealed only some of his difficulties. On first arriving at RACS Topsham, he thought it a great improvement over the barracks at St John’s Wood, which he now told his father (on 5 March) had been ‘H-ll’. He had had to sleep in a room of twenty-seven men, filled with smoke due to a blocked chimney. ‘Every morning we woke up coughing. . . . Our hours were 5.30 to 8.15. At ten to six every morning we paraded in stables and carried the d-ng in our arms. The Bedding was like 2 year old manure. It was succulent! We then stood on the square in the cold . . . and did an hour’s physical exercise – sitting down in the mud to get 3
RRR kept a copy of letters from Sharpe, 31 January 1916, Greenwood, 28 and 31 January, and Ainslie, 29 January and 7, 8 and 12 February, and his own letter to LCR, 6 March. His letters to and from Alexander do not survive in the file.
30
Lionel Robbins
warm! After knocking off in the evening we had nowhere to go except the smoky sleeping room – There we had to make our beds and clean buttons boots etc till bed time. There was one small table with a pot of ink and no pen.’ At Topsham living conditions were far better: smaller bedrooms, which were well ventilated and warm, a reading room with writing material, and excellent food. But after a week, in telling his father that he was free from 5.15, except for dinner at 7, he told him on 10 March that he was spending his evenings in the gun park: ‘There is nothing to do in the town [of Exeter] except galivate [gallivant] about the shops with barmaids etc – an occupation which several of the “British Public school boy type” seem to find amusing. Some of the men here are very nice, others especially these overfed fools are not worth troubling about.’ His father was sympathetic but warned his son not to be ‘too supercilious & contemptuous in your manner towards those whose education has not taught them to think’ (RRR to LCR, 12 March and 12 April 1916). By the end of his first month Lionel was miserable: he and the other occupants of Hut 17 were isolated there because of a case of measles and he himself had a bad cold. Later letters in April 1916 vented his complaints about the snobbish behaviour of the regular officers, especially the graduates of the Royal Military Academy at Woolwich, the boorishness of his companions in Hut 17 and his own persistent cough. When he was well again his letters were more cheerful, and slightly more tolerant of his fellow men, with a few of whom he began to have arguments about socialism or religion. When they were no longer confined to barracks he dined in town and went to the cinema with a friend from the OTC at UCL, but otherwise he let his fellow cadets go out without him. He began to do better in the coursework, having been held back as a result of falling sick (LCR to RRR, 5, 19 and 25 May 1916). He continued to worry about his age, even after he completed the course at Topsham and moved on to a more congenial finishing course at Shoeburyness in Essex. At Topsham he had been summoned before the major, who asked him his age. ‘I said,’ he told his father (nd but April 1916), “I have attested as 18–6 Sir” in a tone of voice that invited criticism. He said nothing but passed on! I have found out that there are other chaps of 17 here. As we are all attested they must have had recourse to the same expedient.’ Although he also told his father his conscience was clear, because he had not actually lied about his age, he was relieved a couple of weeks later to have to fill in a form of application for admission to an officer cadet unit with a view to a wartime commission and to give his correct age. He asked his father if he could get in touch with General Alexander again (LCR to RRR, 27 April and 10 May 1916).
The Great War
31
He enjoyed the work of the month’s course at Shoeburyness, worked hard and did well in the final examinations. He wrote himself to General Alexander, whose reply was friendly but did ‘not clear matters much’ and the sword of Damocles remained suspended (LCR to RRR, 7 June 1916). When he left Shoeburyness he sent his father a photograph of his group: he described a few as ‘decent fellows’, others as non-entities, and one as ‘The absolute consummation of the abominable public school boy . . . an absolutely loathsome specimen.’ At the time (26 June) he thought ‘it quite on the cards that the next few weeks may show developments in the situation – events that may shorten the war considerably’: he was referring to the coming offensive on the Somme. He completed his training that first week of July 1916 back in Devon, at the RA practice camp at Okehampton, from where he wrote his father on 3 July that he had at last been ‘under fire’. Yesterday I was at the guns. We fired something like 120 rounds and made ourselves all deaf and tired. . . . Today I was at the observation station. We could hear the shells shrieking all over our heads all the time. When one came particularly close someone exclaimed and our officer said you’ll get worse than that this morning. We were then led to a dugout and engaged a target 200 yds in front. The firing was very erratic one shell burst 12 yds away on percussion several burst just over head. It was quite an experience and quite enjoyable.
Then he went home on leave to await news of his commission. It was a wait of several weeks, which was, according to his autobiography (1971a, 19), ended only after ‘a further process of wire-pulling by our friend’s friend in the War Office’ (which may in fact have been the only piece of wire pulling). He was commissioned as a second lieutenant in the Royal Field Artillery in the Special Reserve of Officers on 19 August (The Times, 22 August 1916). In the intervening weeks he had written again to General Alexander for advice and had received only a moderately helpful reply, but when he wrote to his old headmaster to inform him he had been gazetted he also told him that ‘the W[ar] O[ffice] were a bit squeamish about my age and were going to leave me alone till I was eighteen. Happily through a friend of Mr Ellis (the solicitor . . . ) we were able to push things through.’ He also wrote to Ainslie who replied congratulating him on his commission and adding, ‘I have the greatest respect for your Father, and cannot wish you better than that you will prove yourself as good a man.’4 4
The letters kept by RRR include LCR’s draft letter to Alexander and Alexander to LCR, 2 August, draft letter to Mr Pollitt, 30 August, and Ainslie to LCR, 29 August 1916.
32
Lionel Robbins
Second Lieutenant Robbins was posted first to RA Woolwich, the huge Royal Artillery complex centred on the Royal Arsenal built in 1717. The scale of the barracks, commenced in 1775, ‘can only be compared to St Petersburg’ (Pevsner 1952, 455): with a facade over 1000 feet long looking over the parade ground, the buildings behind the facade could accommodate 4000 men. Because Robbins was well under the minimum age (nineteen) for service overseas, he spent a little over a year there, instructing recruits in handling the guns and going on advanced courses in gunnery, map-reading, gas warfare and so on. Some of his notes for these or his earlier courses survive in a notebook that also includes instructions for the two main guns used by the Royal Field Artillery in 1914–18. His year at Woolwich was ‘not . . . by any means one of the happiest in my life’ – he was not impressed by the regular officers and he was not comfortable with his contemporaries, especially the public school boys from RMA Woolwich – but it had its advantages. At eighteen, ‘a callow second lieutenant . . . rather shy [and] still very unworldly’, he was free of home, with an income of his own and an account with Cox & Co, the army bankers; he had ‘comfortable quarters in a Georgian building which was part of the main complex bordering the great parade ground . . . a man to look after me . . . [and] a horse at my disposal on which I could ride carefree on the neighbouring common or, better still, on nearby windy Blackheath’ (1971a, 40). He could also escape in the evenings by train to central London, to concerts and to the theatre, which had been denied him while he lived at home. The RFA was intended to provide the most immediate fire-support to the British army on the battlefield and to keep pace with the infantry. The tactical unit was the brigade, which was divided into four batteries, each subdivided into two (sometimes three) sections of two guns each, and an ammunition column. The two main field guns used by the RFA in 1914– 18 were the 18-pounder, quick-firing field gun and the 4.5-inch howitzer, which lobbed heavier shells, shorter in length and larger in diameter, with a higher trajectory than the field gun. There was usually one howitzer battery among the four in a brigade. Both guns had a range of about 7000 yards; in action they were therefore positioned about two miles behind the infantry in the front line, while the wagon lines, with the ammunition wagons, the limbers for moving the guns, and all the horses (each gun needed a team of six horses to move it), were two or three miles further back, out of the range of enemy guns. Each gun was manned by six men, with a senior non-commissioned officer in command, with a further four in reserve. The officers in a battery comprised the battery commander, usually a major, with a captain as second-in-command, and four or five subalterns, who
The Great War
33
took turns in the gun lines, the wagon lines and the observation post (OP) forward of the gun line. A brigade would thus number about thirty officers, a thousand other ranks and the same number of horses.5 The training for officers therefore included artillery tactics, gun drill, the various methods of ‘ranging’ the guns and getting them on target (a complicated business when the enemy’s guns cannot be seen), the practicalities of choosing locations for gun lines, wagon lines and billets, as well as riding. A horse was the normal method of getting about, behind the guns, for any officer, who also had to learn to supervise the moving of the guns, by taking turns at riding each of the three mounted horses of the six in a gun team (Paish 1998, 10–13). One result of Robbins’s long stay at Woolwich was that he was more confident of his abilities at the technical tasks of an artillery officer when he went to the front than many of his equally young contemporaries. As he noted (1971a, 40): ‘in the brief period in which I took part in open warfare in France, I was the only officer in the battery save the major, a regular soldier, who could lay guns on concealed targets by anything but the mechanical use of maps and a protractor.’ Artillery officers and men on the way to the front passed through RA Woolwich, where Robbins was posted for duty not for draft to the 19th Reserve Battery. As he told his father on 8 September, ‘We have the (supposed to be) fully trained men up from the various depots and put them through their paces for three weeks or so. Then we take them over to France and deliver them to the base camp at Harfleur’ and return after a day in Le Havre. He paid his first visit to France a week after his arrival at Woolwich, sailing from Southampton overnight on 11/12 September. It was not as enjoyable as he anticipated: the conditions on board ship were disgusting given the number of men and horses crammed together, he was detained three days at the base waiting for a ship for the return voyage, and in Le Havre what little he ‘saw (and smelt) was filthy.’ On the way back, however, he witnessed ‘a sunrise of such intense beauty’ that it compensated for the discomfort of the voyage. Reaching London, he called on his grandparents at Nethania: ‘they fed me clothed me and let me wash’ and he talked about art with his grandfather (LCR to RRR, 16 September 1916). Woolwich was a natural target for air raids, first by Zeppelins (airships), later conventional aircraft because the airships were so easy to shoot down. During his first raid Lionel happened to be the brigade orderly officer. When the order to ‘take airraid action’ was given, ‘the duties, I must say, were arduous. They consisted of sitting in the orderly room smoking innumerable 5
Information from Haythornwaite (1996, 821–3), and LCR’s artillery notebook.
34
Lionel Robbins
cigarettes and reading “The Experimental Psychology of Beauty” . . . [thus] remain[ing] true to my intellectual pursuits’, as he smugly reported to his father on 24 September. But he admitted to excitement when he sighted the Zeppelin and when it started dropping bombs and the anti-aircraft batteries got to work: ‘Charlie Chaplin wasn’t in it I can assure you for thrills. . . . [I] found I was trembling with excitement.’ When the airship burst into flame, ‘Every body went mad! We rush about shouting stop that – noise but made no impression. The whole barracks was cheering and all the subs in the world couldn’t stop them.’ He shared the feeling of elation and brooded about it only later. When he got used to the raids and when not on duty he slept through them (LCR to RRR, 3 October 1916). He was also at Woolwich when a fire in the TNT plant at Silvertown, on the opposite side of the river, caused a massive explosion in January 1917. Even at that distance the blast, which killed seventy-three people, blew out part of the glass dome over the officers’ mess at Woolwich (Paish 1998, 17–18; Cherry, O’Brien and Pevsner 2005, 315). Lionel and other young officers witnessed the devastation of Silvertown firsthand as they were put in charge of working parties sent over to help to clear the debris, ‘turning over the rubbish in one direction and then another, sometimes finding a body sometimes not’ (LCR to RRR, 20 January 1917). The RA mess at Woolwich was ‘nearly as stupendous as Solomons Temple. . . . The food is excellent but the accommodation is more so.’ Lionel also described his colleagues in the 19th Reserve Battery to his father on 8 October. Major Warren, brought back from retirement, was ‘a major of the old school – a dug out perhaps but devoted to his duty’; when he was posted elsewhere he was replaced by Major Knox from RACS Topsham who committed suicide in April 1917 (Robbins 1971a, 40–1). Robbins got on best with Captains Hatcher and Kinersley who had been promoted from the ranks; the fact that he drank with them in the mess did not endear him to the more snobbish of his contemporaries. The subalterns in the battery comprised two from the ‘shop’ (RMA Woolwich), whom he thought had ‘too much of Shop taints and morals and an easy going definition of duty’; one who had been in the Territorial Army in peacetime; another described to his father only as ‘another “sub” a very nice fellow’; and his roommate Dunkley, who at thirty-eight had worked in the City for many years and was ‘not very good as a “gunner”’. The hazards of being a junior wartime officer at Woolwich are exemplified by one of Kinersley’s stories about Dunkley, which Lionel retailed to his father in October 1916: ‘Kin’s best story of him is that one day when lecturing on the 18 pdr [field gun] to a squad of gunners after he had talked for 3/4 hr, one of the NCOs said “you don’t know
The Great War
35
anything about this gun sir.” He looked up and to his horror found he had been using a 4.5 Howitzer.’ Lionel enjoyed teaching the new recruits. On 11 November he told his father he was ‘working my hardest with a squad . . . I do everything with them Lectures marching gun drill etc and am very pleased with the work. They are mostly boys of 18 or so called up on coming of age so I find them malleable material. The others are fairly well educated men – elementary school masters etc and I find great pleasure in leading their feet into the military way of peace as the prayer book will have it.’ One of this squad was his schoolfriend George Davidge, who was admitted to the RA Barracks at Woolwich when he turned eighteen in October 1916. Although Lionel took care not to acknowledge him on parade, Dav would come to Lionel’s room in the evenings where they would ‘thrash out together the old problems of life art etc’ (LCR to RRR, 25 October, 6 and 11 November 1916). In his year at Woolwich Lionel saw Eddie Rose frequently: they went together to promenade and other concerts at the Queen’s Hall, and also met, sometimes with Davidge before he left for Salonika in February 1917, at Eddie’s sister’s house in Eltham. Eddie had started to read for a degree at East London College (now Queen Mary). According to his autobiography (1971a, 42–3) Lionel contrived to get Rose enlisted as a gunner in the 19th Battery when Eddie was called up. His two friends both hoped the ungainly and absentminded Eddie would not be sent overseas; fortunately he was not and he spent most of the war at a reserve depot at Arborfield near Reading (Davidge to RRR, 15 May 1917 and 12 January 1918; Rose to RRR, 18 April 1918). Robbins made several lifelong friends while he was at Woolwich. He met Frank Paish, who became an economist and a colleague at the London School of Economics in the 1930s. Paish had been admitted directly from Winchester College to RACS Topsham in July 1916 and arrived at Woolwich on his way to the front at the end of the year. In January 1917, working together or spending their spare time riding on Woolwich Common, the always optimistic Paish would try to cheer up a rather gloomy and often depressed Robbins (Paish 1998, 16–17). Lionel found this infuriating – for instance when they were picking over the debris at Silvertown and Paish remarked that this grisly task was ‘such a change from the dead monotony of the gun park you know . . .’: he made a deliberately sarcastic reply (LCR to RRR, 20 January 1917). When they met again in 1932, they ‘at once resumed the disputations about prospects and policy which began when we took six o’clock stables together . . . , he ebullient, I despondent’ (Robbins 1971a, 42). He met Nathan Isaacs, whose intellectual interests were in philosophy and
36
Lionel Robbins
psychology and who ‘loved argument’, one Saturday in the winter of 1916– 17 outside the synagogue at Woolwich (‘Remarks at the Commemoration Ceremony for Nathan Isaacs 13th June 1966’, Biographical Papers, RP): ‘I had been detailed to march the troops of the Jewish persuasion to their weekly service. I had done this and was just about to give the order to file in, when there stepped forward a serious-looking young gunner who said very solemnly, “I beg to be excused. I am an agnostic.” Needless to say, I excused him; and breaking all the regulations of the day, we walked back up the hill together and founded a life-long friendship.’ The two men did not meet much during the rest of the war but they were very close in the years afterwards. Reginald (Reggie or Reg) Lawson was the youngest brother of the two Lawson sisters who had married Harris uncles of Lionel’s. He had known the Harrises since childhood as his mother was an active member of the Mount Zion congregation. (His father, Harry Lawson, was a nonconformist though not a Baptist; he was also an unscrupulous, and initially very successful, company promoter who had been convicted of fraud.) Lionel met him soon after his posting to Woolwich at one of the parties given by one of the two Harrises in St John’s Wood (the two men’s recollections differ on which). Reggie was playing the piano. Lionel was fascinated by the piano player; Reggie was ‘immediately attracted by the younger man . . . [whose] underlying boyishness was accentuated by a slightly clumsy manner and a habit of shaking his head to throw back the lock of hair that fell across his eyes’ (Ginger 1991, 35). Reggie found that ‘His interest in and appreciation of my piano-playing were a new inspiration to me. The more I played the more pleased he seemed to be, and the more pleased he was the more I desired to play. This was an ideal arrangement, and he very soon knew all my friends’; Lionel told Reg’s biographer that he was ‘a most talented performer of modern music – Debussy, Ravel, other French composers, a good interpreter of Bach’ (information from John Ginger). As he told his father on 5 January 1917 Lionel took Eddie Rose to Uncle Charlie’s to meet Lawson: ‘They were all charmed with him and I see vistas of pleasant evenings opening up before us.’ Seven years older than Robbins, Lawson had already served in the war, enlisting in the Honourable Artillery Company in August 1914 and serving in France until April 1915. But during officer training he had suffered a breakdown; he was on compassionate leave and studying the piano with Monsieur du Mont, who had been a pupil of Busoni’s in Paris, when Lionel met him (Ginger 1991, 30–4). In spite of the difference in their ages, they had tastes and interests in common, as well as their Strict Baptist background
The Great War
37
from which each was in his own way rebelling. In 1916 Lionel was the same age Reggie had been when he first encountered contemporaries with wide cultural interests. He was also ‘sensitive, fastidious and with an intuitive understanding of others’ hopes and fears which was quite exceptional’; realizing the young man’s emotional and cultural needs he introduced him to his circle of friends, including Clive Gardiner, with whom Lionel was until Clive’s death in 1960 to maintain ‘the greatest male friendship of my life’ (Robbins 1971a, 44). Clive was also seven years older than Lionel. Although he and Reggie had attended the same school, University College School, they did not meet until Reggie began to attend services led by the gifted preacher Robert Horton at the Lyndhurst Road Congregational church in Hampstead. At Dr Horton’s house Reggie met Clive as well as Horton’s sister Constance and her friend Jessie Monk; they joined him in attending musical evenings at the du Monts’ (Ginger 1991, 23–6). Clive, the eldest son of the great Liberal journalist A.G. Gardiner, was then (1910) a student at the Slade School of Fine Art. When Lionel met him he was well on his way to becoming a professional painter. Unfit on medical grounds for military service, he was working in the Ministry of Munitions (Reade 1963). Lionel came to know Clive during 1917 when Robbins’s father, ‘hearing my enthusiastic talk of my new acquaintance and anxious to have some record, other than photographs, of my appearance, before, as he feared, my almost inevitable death on active service, gave Clive a commission’ for a portrait of his son (Robbins 1967b, 13). In the sittings Lionel learned (1971a, 45) that ‘Clive had vision and imagination . . . [and] beyond that . . . judgment, a sense of proportion and quality, coupled with a modest and disarming candour of a kind I had not encountered before. At this turbulent and rebellious period of my development, this was just what I needed.’ When the painting was finished Lionel told his father on 17 September 1917 that ‘It was a stroke of genius on your part to have the portrait painted. It enabled me to gain a far greater intimacy with Clive than I should have done and to form a friendship that I hope will not be severed easily.’ He suggested his father commission his own portrait from Clive, but Dick Robbins preferred to buy one of Clive’s paintings exhibited at the New English Arts Club in 1918. Clive was particularly pleased with the one he chose, because ‘we discussed it so much together when it was in its early stages, and his [Lionel’s] enthusiasm and spirit helped it along enormously’ (Gardiner to RRR, 25 February and 14 March 1918). In the next three years the three men were to go about together in London a good deal: with his two tall friends Reggie was ‘inevitably the small man
38
Lionel Robbins
in the middle’ (Ginger 1991, 36). Clive took his two friends to the galleries, especially the National Gallery: it was with Clive that Lionel acquired his love of Italian early Renaissance art and of the Impressionists and PostImpressionists. The three together discovered the ‘Lane Bequest’ – the thirtynine foreign paintings, including major works by Degas, Renoir and Manet, acquired by Sir Hugh Lane who had gone down with the Lusitania in 1915 – which was first exhibited in the National Gallery in January 1917. This was, recalled Lawson, ‘really intoxicating’ (‘Written answers to questions’). There was one aspect of Reggie’s life that Clive and Lionel did not then know about. He was already well aware of his homosexuality and of the moral dilemma it posed for him. He found the beginning of the solution in conversion to Roman Catholicism, but that was later, after the war. Before the war, when he was working as a clerk for Myers & Co, and in 1917–18 when he returned to Myers & Co, he found lovers in the City. But he refused to regard these ‘attachments of a sentimental and utilitarian kind’ as real friendships like those with Clive and Lionel. He kept his lovers and friends strictly separate (Ginger 1991, 27–8). Lionel also went to the musical evenings at the du Monts’. Reggie described the evenings to his biographer (‘Written answers to questions’). The garden flat in Swiss Cottage consisted mainly of a large room with two grand pianos. Sometimes du Mont’s pupils played the two pianos, sometimes the ‘Master’ with his best pupil. Monsieur . . . was a brilliant player of Chopin, Beethoven and Brahms, not so brilliant at Bach, and we influenced him to take a greater interest in modern stuff . . . Madame . . . always reclined on a long seat that was part of the wainscoting. Some coloured stuff over an electric lamp suffused a candle light over her corner and suited very well her sallow features and black hair, and velvet dress which she usually affected, with all kinds of Liberty coloured scarves and wraps. She had a mind which kept everything in place, and us too, as we all sat around on low stools and armchairs, while she dispensed evening tea and delicious cakes.
Lionel was less impressed with Madame, at least in retrospect, telling John Ginger in 1979: ‘a character out of Flaubert [she] imagined herself holding a salon. . . . Her culture was something superficial – something which she paraded. Her husband was genuine – but he felt that he wasn’t sufficiently appreciated. . . . [He also] put up with a lot – R’s and Clive’s adulation of Madame.’ In his first few months in the army Lionel still attended chapel occasionally: when he went to Topsham he asked his father in March 1916 for names of ‘old friends of yours if any in Exeter also of ministers (if faithful)’.
The Great War
39
His father (who knew only of friends of Mr Ellis in Exmouth) wondered on 12 March if he would ‘find a place [of worship] which in any way approaches your ideals. I hope so – but do not be too particular – & in any case do not neglect the house of God.’ But, as he commented on 15 April, ‘You are having plenty of opportunity of putting to the test your theory that it is just as easy to worship God without attending “a place of worship” – I wonder whether you really find it so.’ Lionel intensely disliked the compulsory church parades, ‘hear[ing] the [Anglican] clergyman spoil all the prayers in the prayer book by intoning them’, and the pomp and ceremony of services in Exeter Cathedral (LCR to RRR, 20 April and 8 May 1916). After Lionel had enjoyed a weekend’s leave at Hollycroft in May 1916 his father told him on 16 May that he was worried: ‘I cannot help feeling grieved & somewhat anxious on the account of the fact that you seem to have lost so much of the joy of salvation – I know how difficult your surroundings are – I know from past personal experience something of the deadening influence of those doubts which haunt me in moments of depression but I do beg of you not to resign yourself to your doubts – nor yet to cut yourself off from Christian fellowship.’ Perhaps acting on this advice Lionel went to the Wesleyan Methodist chapel on 21 May, where he had to listen to a poor sermon he had already heard before at Exmouth when his father had visited him one weekend. His father responded on 24 May that he might try the Presbyterian Church: ‘as a rule they have very good men.’ At RA Woolwich Lionel could attend the Woolwich Tabernacle of which Dr John Wilson was the well-known and popular minister (Clayton 1927). But he began to enjoy church parades, as he told his father on 6 October 1916: We have a lovely Garrison church here built by Gunner officers subscription. In architecture it is one of the best I have seen especially internally. The chaplains there preach very well and the whole affair is absolutely ‘chic’. Personally if it was not for Mr Wilson I should always attend there: the preaching is very good. Simple but philosophically deep and the lovely spiral window settings make one worshipful. Also a beautiful choral service.
(The church was gutted in the Second World War and left as a ruin; built in 1863 as ‘an Early Christian-Italian Romanesque basilica’ it was ‘an ambitious forceful building, with much structural polychromy and marble and mosaic decoration inside’ [Cherry and Pevsner 1983, 279].) By the time he left Woolwich Lionel was enquiring of his father on 17 September whether they could meet in London rather than at Hollycroft: ‘Weekends, in some ways, are not the best times to meet – I mean Mother gets so upset if I don’t go to
40
Lionel Robbins
Chapel twice that it quite reacts on me – almost as much as if I went and I hate causing unpleasantness even I don’t appear to.’ In these months before he was sent to the front Robbins read widely. The musician Harry Blech remembered him when he was visiting Clive’s father, ‘coming in with a mass of books under your arm . . . with either Eddie Rose or John Polimeni’ (another friend of Clive’s).6 When the mess library proved to be empty of books he took to borrowing from the local public library, which he found was ‘well stocked with the literature of religious and social rebellion’ (LCR to RRR, 6 October 1916; Robbins 1971a, 43). His reading reflected the literary interests he shared with Eddie, his discovery of the theatre and the visual arts, and growing disillusionment with politics and the conduct of the war – especially after the formation of the Lloyd George coalition government in December 1916. Lionel avidly read Nietzsche, Ibsen and Strindberg, Maeterlinck, Shaw and Wells. He was ‘greatly impressed’ by Ibsen’s Brand, he told his father on 8 October 1916, explaining that ‘It is a religious drama of present day life. . . . The tragedy arises from his too severe view of God.’ A few months later he sent him a copy of Shaw’s pamphlet, The Sanity of Art – in which Shaw defended modern developments in art (Impressionism, Wagnerism, Ibsenism) against charges of ‘degeneracy’ – telling him on 13 June 1917 that Shaw could enlighten him better than he could as to ‘the aim and creed of a modern artist’. In his letter he added some arguments of his own, criticizing the puritans in his own family for appreciating only works which tallied with their religious beliefs. His father responded sympathetically on 18 June, ‘admit[ting] the force of many of his [Shaw’s] arguments’ and some of Shaw’s claims for the worth of artistic endeavour, but he pointed out that he agreed with Ruskin’s claim that high ideals could only be attained ‘by daily hourly yea momentarily waiting upon God for grace’ and not by art alone. On 17 September the latest book Lionel had for his father was ‘an interesting book . . . by P. Kropotkin – no anarchism this time only a treatise on the possibility of agriculture and industry – called “Fields, Factories and Workshops” [1913].’ The Russian anarchist had written and published this book, first as a series of articles in 1888–90, while he was living in exile in England; in it he argued for decentralized manufacturing industry producing on a small scale for local markets, intensive agriculture 6
LCR remembered the meeting but he connected the recollection ‘much more than Eddie Rose than with John Polimeni, although both were close friends of mine’: Blech to LCR, 9 October, LCR to Blech, 23 October 1962, General Correspondence March 1962-January 1963, RP.
The Great War
41
(especially market gardening), and education which combined manual and intellectual work. 1917 was the year of the Russian revolutions: the February Revolution in March (by the Western calendar) and the October Revolution on 7 November. Against this background Robbins read the works of many socialist writers. According to his autobiography (1971a, 56) he was put off by the opacity of Marx’s Das Kapital and found the writings of the English ‘guild socialists’ such as G.D.H. Cole much more congenial. With roots in both French syndicalism and the writings of William Morris and his followers, guild (or gild) socialism envisaged a society in which the workers took control of their workplaces and of their output from the capitalists, and formed themselves into ‘national guilds’ in which they worked for themselves, in cooperation with each other and with the state which would own the means of production. The New Age, the lively ‘weekly review of politics, literature and art’ (as it described itself), was the main forum for discussion of guild socialist ideas. Reg had been acquainted with the magazine since he had read it regularly to Dr Horton before the war; in 1917 or (more probably) 1918 he and Lionel went together to guild socialist meetings (Ginger 1991, 25). When he left the army in 1919 Robbins regarded himself as a committed (guild) socialist (see Chapter 3). He continued to write poetry, experimenting with styles and subjects, but within traditional prewar modes. A few semi-religious poems survive with his letters to his father; one at least was written when he was on active service in France in December 1917 (tss The Shepherds (1917-if you will!), The Three Maries, A Madonna of the Pure Heart, and LCR to Lawson, 31 December 1917). Others he kept and revised after the war (Orpheus and Eurydice, A Peony: Imitation of Flecker, and an untitled one marked ‘Woolwich 1917’, Youthful Miscellanea, RP). The war in France and Belgium dragged on. When Lionel Robbins turned nineteen on 22 November 1917, he was sent to France, sailing from Southampton to Le Havre on the night of 5 December. On a very calm crossing – ‘“Fair stood the wind for France . . . etc”’ – he slept and dreamt of his parents and of the National Liberal Club where he often met his father (LCR to Papa & Mother, 5 and 6 December 1917). From the base camp at Harfleur he wrote also to Reg and to Eddie, mostly about music (Bach and Cesar Frank in particular) and painting, specifically the two pictures of which he had reproductions with him: Leonardo da Vinci’s Head of the Christ and Botticelli’s Madonnna of the Magnificat. The few books he had brought included a pocket Shakespeare: he read both parts of Henry IV and, as he told Reg, was ‘greatly cheered . . . by the delightful coarseness of
42
Lionel Robbins
Old Falstaff ’. He spent four days at Harfleur, before being sent up the line to join his unit, the 64th Army Brigade RFA, where he was posted to A Battery, a field gun battery.7 His brigade had been fighting in the Third Battle of Ypres – the campaign known for its culmination, the capture of the village of Passchendaele, ‘synonymous in British annals for mud and useless waste’ (Haythornthwaite 1996, 39). This extended the bulge in the front around the war-ruined mediaeval cloth town of Ypres by five miles at a cost of over 300,000 casualties. As Liddell Hart (1934, 330) explained, ‘the Ypres offensive was doomed before it began – by its own destruction of the intricate drainage system in this part of Flanders’ which was reclaimed marshland. With the dykes destroyed by bombardment the area predictably turned into a swamp. Robbins saw the result (1971a, 46): ‘a flat, desolate expanse of shell-holes filled with water, ruins, duckboards and mud. Mud, endless polluted mud’ – polluted with the corpses of men and horses. Robbins arrived to find the 64th Brigade moving back from the positions east of Ypres where they had lost in action several officers and men even after the main battles were over. After their relief on 12–14 December they were billeted for a few days in Oudezeele, in France, and then moved to Watou just inside Belgium. Robbins was sent ahead as battery officer for the Brigade Ammunition Column. At Watou the brigade spent Christmas 1917. ‘It was a grim winter, and nowhere worse than around Ypres’, according to the official history of the Royal Artillery (Farndale 1986, 259); the brigade’s war diary reports cold or snow or hard frost day after day (WO95/295, TNA). In his first letter from the front Lionel asked for ‘socks, socks, socks, I can’t have too many’, as well as for such things as a wristwatch, a torch and reading material.8 The men were kept busy with training, when the weather permitted, and football matches (between teams from the four batteries, HQ and the Brigade Ammunition Column, for the Brigade Football Shield which was won by D/64, the howitzer battery). Christmas Day was a ‘Whole holiday. Great day for the men, all units had good dinners. Several concerts were arranged. The C.O. [Lt Col P. Barton DSO] wished the men a happy Christmas’. On Boxing Day Lionel wrote home that he had just received a second package of socks plus cigarettes and chocolates and the third book of 7
8
LCR to Rose, Saturday [8 December], LCR to Lawson, Friday [7 December 1917]), LCR to RRR, 9 December 1917. LCR wrote frequently to both friends while he was in France and Belgium; they both kept in touch with his father and passed on some of his letters which RRR kept with LCR’s. LCR to RRR, 12 September 1917. The brigade’s war diary for November 1917–April 1918 is the main source of the factual information in the next few paragraphs. I have also found invaluable the memoirs (Campbell 1977 and 1979) of another young artillery officer who served with another RFA army brigade in the same sector of the front in those months.
The Great War
43
Georgian Poetry edited by Edward Marsh (1917) ‘at which I danced all round the room in ecstasy’ (but he was critical of its contents in later letters home). The day before he had been ‘about the only sober man in the Brigade’. While the brigade was at rest Lionel assured his parents that he was ‘twenty or thirty miles behind the lines on a lovely farm and beautiful country’ and described the agricultural landscape at length (LCR to RRR, 16 and 17 December 1917). On 6 January 1918, there was ‘Frost all day. Batteries prepared for move. The Grenades [the brigade concert party] gave a second performance of their concert in the evening.’ Over the next two days, in the snow, the brigade marched south through Hazebrouck en route to new positions in front of Armentieres. Robbins was again in the advance billeting party, as he could make himself quite well understood in French. This gave him ‘a good bed for the night in a decent old fashioned estaminet’ in a little village. The brigade was billeted in villages south of Hazebrouck for several days, while the guns were taken to the army range at St Hilaire for calibration in preparation for the next round of fighting. For 2nd Lieutenant Robbins this last task meant he was ‘in the saddle for nearly 18 hours of the 36’. On the 19th the brigade marched to the Steenwerck area and Lionel reported home that they had moved into huts, were making beds out of old chunks of timber and wire netting, and asked for some Medici Society reproductions of Old Masters to adorn the canvas walls (LCR to RRR, 6, 17 and 20 January 1918). A Battery moved into its new position in a brickfield just east of Armentieres on 21–22 January. The officers ‘messed and slept in a brick kiln which was said to be proof against medium artillery’ where they played poker in the evenings. The wagon lines and the brigade headquarters were on the other side of the evacuated and deserted town, through which it was an ‘eerie experience’ to ride at night, with ‘a full moon, a clear sky and the lonely hoofs of one’s horse striking sparks from the cobbled pavements’. The front was quiet, with only intermittent artillery activity, including some on the part of A/64, and Robbins ‘did a good deal of forward observation, watching at a distance enemy movements which were almost negligible’, otherwise whiling away the long hours in the OP by reading Shakespeare (1971a, 48). An artillery battery was inevitably a very close-knit community. Campbell (1979, 6) recalled that the half a dozen officers of his battery ‘were like brothers, sleeping side by side, within touching distance, sharing whatever possessions we had and the contents of any parcel that came for us’. At first Robbins was dubious about the major (W.J.F. Halliday DSO) of his own battery, ‘a regular who habitually spoke of the working classes as if they were dirt’, but he was a brave man whom Robbins came to respect.
44
Lionel Robbins
The captain (A.J. Gardiner) was a ‘thoughtful schoolmaster’ and his fellow lieutenants ‘agreeable and without side’ (Robbins 1971a, 47). His greatest friend was 2nd Lieutenant H. Beresford, who won an MC and was killed in May 1918: Halliday managed to get him to a dressing station but he died within a few hours (Halliday to LCR, 11 August [1918], Personal letters from Iris & Clive etc, RP). With Beresford Robbins would ride out of the lines, on one occasion, on a ‘bright shiny day in midwinter’ to Bailleul (1971a, 47–8): ‘the only reminder of the war was when, having lunched splendidly, we turned our horses’ heads back towards the line and the sensitive creatures, so co-operative going out in the morning, jibbed and shied and continually slowed their paces returning to the anxieties of the line.’ Bailleul was then relatively untouched by the war: a ‘still unshattered civic illusion, with its little market place behind the church always filled with waiting horses, its long Grande Place of cleanly shops, the packed Officers’ Club, with its air of Victorian tradition and much good company’ (Blunden 1982, 232). It was destroyed during the Allies’ retreat three months later. In early February 1918 the batteries of the brigade were active in support of a couple of infantry raids on the German trenches, before they were relieved on the nights of 16 and 17 February. In a new position in the Fleurbaix sector of the front ‘life became much less agreeable’ (and Robbins’s letters home scrappy and uninformative). ‘As a preliminary to the offensive which was being prepared down south, the German guns began systematic bombardment of the areas behind our lines; and there was singularly little pleasure or peace of mind sitting waiting, wondering what time of day it would be our turn. . . . We were moved about a little and had some nasty times, chiefly on the road.’ The first of the officers to be killed while Robbins was with A Battery, 2nd Lieutenant Millard, was badly wounded in the head on 24 February, died the next day and was buried on the 26th. Robbins described his ‘baptism of fear’ (1971a, 49–50): We had been moved down a little south; and while the gunners lived in a reinforced cottage, we officers billeted in a farm which was still inhabited. The war was hotting up again and there was some shelling of adjacent areas. But our guns were reasonably well concealed, and nothing to speak of had come our way. Then one night, just as I was about to put one of Debussy’s Arabesques on the portable gramophone, there were distant clicks from the German lines and the whine of the shells, which hitherto had passed well to the right or the left, deepened into a sickening shriek and culminated in a deafening explosion just overhead. . . . The blast threw me to the ground; and as I picked myself up in a daze, I heard the major say: ‘For Christ’s sake get him out of here!’ . . . The front door was blocked. So each seizing the body, the major the legs, I the shoulders, we dragged it out through the back window . . . As we dragged our heavy load round the building, . . . from time to time we would be
The Great War
45
blown over by blast so that, if there had much life left in poor Millard when we started, it would have been substantially diminished by the rough passage. As it was, when at last we got him into an open field in the sinister moonlight, myself almost vomiting at the sight of my breeches steeped in his blood and fragments of his brain, it was clear that from the outset there had been no hope.
The collapse of the Russian army on the Eastern Front in 1917 and the peace negotiations at Brest-Litovsk with the new Bolshevik government allowed the German high command to prepare for a major offensive on the Western Front to defeat the Allies before the Americans, who entered the war in April, arrived. General Ludendorff’s plans included an attack codenamed Michael on the Somme to be followed by attacks further north and south. The first began on 21 March, the second, the Battle of the Lys, on 9 April. The March offensive was expected by the Allied armies (although its success was not); in the 64th Army Brigade on 10 March ‘Reserve battery positions were inspected on the N. Bank of the R[iver] LYS just east of BAC ST. MAUR in case of a break through’ (see Illustration 8). Systematic German shelling forced a move of the brigade headquarters on 15 March, and on 22 March A Battery crossed the River Lys to the north bank, the other batteries following over the next seven days. On the 27th ‘Better news was received from the war down south’ as the German offensive was halted before Arras. Lionel told his parents on 26 March that his brigade had gone into action on 20 January and pulled out on 22 March and was now ‘nowhere near’ the battle zone. He also told them he had been promoted to Lieutenant. In the evening of 30 March the 64th Army Brigade RFA moved forward only to receive on arriving orders to return, as a ‘Special Operation’ had been cancelled. For a week the brigade’s diary has little to report except a change in its commanding officer; on the 7th ‘The Huns were expected to attack the Portuguese [whose 2nd Division was directly in front of the brigade] on the following morning’, but on the 8th there was ‘Nothing to report’. The battle began on 9 April just after 4 a.m. (Buffetaut 1988, 47). Robbins (1971a, 50) woke up to a drum-fire of artillery on the front different from anything I had ever heard before;. . . . Almost at once orders came through that we were to go into action on predetermined targets, which we did amid a good deal of shelling from the enemy. As the morning wore on, there began to drift through the guns forlorn little groups of Portuguese retreating discreetly from what was happening on the line. Thenceforward all was confusion. Groups of enemy infantry appeared in the fields . . . [on the other side of the river]; and in some way or other which I do not recollect – if I ever knew – we were authorized to pull out.
46
Lionel Robbins
In his only note home between 5 and 13 April Lionel admitted: ‘I hear the Portuguese have let us down. Met one still many miles behind the lines. If I had had a rifle I would have plugged him.’ The confusion and chaos are captured in the brigade’s record: 9th Very heavy Hun bombardment on front and back areas. H[igh] E[xplosive] and gas shell from 4 AM to 9 AM – 5 AM Brigade H.Q. hit – Capt Attkins wounded. Batteries opened [fire] . . . All wires cut. Visual impossible all morning owing to thick mist. . . . 11 AM Bde ordered to retire . . . 11.15 AM orders cancelled. Brigade remained in action at BAC-ST-MAUR. 2.30 PM Bde retired . . . A/64 withdrew under heavy rifle fire . . . Batteries in action 4 PM firing on the SAILLY-ESTAIRES road in support of 50th [Infantry] Division. All gun teams kept close to guns. . . . 6 PM Huns captured CROIX-de-BAC and BRIDGEHEAD E. OF ESTAIRES. . . . 10th During the night batteries fired on the SAILLY-ESTAIRES road. . . . Huns started advancing . . . 8 AM. . . . During the morning batteries withdrew 700x as they were in full view of SAILLY CHURCH. 12 noon 285th Bde RFA on our left retired precipitately stating Huns were within 500x . 1 PM having fired all ammunition away batteries commenced to retire . . . Orders cancelled . . . A/64 never moved. – Brigade contiued firing N of the River on the same front. . . . 6 PM Brigade ordered to retire . . . Brigade fired . . . [on] crossings over the LYS during the night. 11 . . . A counter attack was ordered at 10 AM but cancelled as infantry were in a very demoralised state. Huns captured STEENWERCK . . . 3 PM Huns broke through . . . infantry retire . . . – 64th Bde retired to BLEU.
On the 12th Robbins was wounded in the left arm by a sniper’s bullet. He had been detailed to go forward with a corporal and a telephonist to see what was happening to the infantry, ‘confusion regarding our position being even greater than ever’. Having found the line and seeing no enemy about, they pushed on and climbed to the loft of an abandoned farmhouse to see further. Spotting some Germans, ‘we descended fairly quickly with the intention of resuming contact with the infantry’; the infantry having disappeared, they started to walk back to their battery across a ploughed field. ‘Suddenly I felt a blow on my left arm as though I had been hit by a very fast (and heavy) cricket ball. . . . Blood was spurting up from my arm like a fountain . . .’ A tourniquet applied by Corporal Otto stopped the bleeding and Lionel was ‘fully resolved not to report it but to continue with the battery. As we walked, however, the effects . . . began to be felt. My arm swelled up. It became quite black . . . [and] almost intolerably painful . . . although I was still upright, I was just a mass of appalling agony and, I suppose, outwardly appearing about to collapse.’ When his companions spotted an ambulance they pushed him, ‘almost tearfully protesting’, into it (Robbins 1971a, 51–3). He wrote to his father the next day:
The Great War
47
. . . I have a tiny rifle bullet wound in the left forearm which doesn’t hurt at all and which will be well in no time. . . . If I get home – and there seems a chance amongst these streams of wounded – I shall need a total new kit as master Boche has every stitch except Shakespeare and the things I was wearing when we retired. As to the battle I have never had such a thrilling time in my life. I am fearfully annoyed to be out of it. It makes me sick to read in the papers the rot about the gallant stand of the Portuguese. They didn’t. They ran like hares and the filthy cowards they are and were shot by our own men in heaps for their base cowardice. We fought our guns till we were being sniped from 400 yds off and then got the teams and guns away under fire. There followed the most exciting of open action in which A/64 covered itself with glory.
He admitted in his autobiography that ‘war, moving war, can be exciting and even enjoyable – however disgusting in retrospect’. It was a blighty wound: after a night at the field station and a few days at the base hospital at Calais he was sent back to England. The brigade war diary recorded: 12th . . . 8 AM Huns started attacking. Shelled cross roads at BLEU. 10 AM Huns break through . . . 29th and 31st Div were in a very exhausted state. A/64 and D/64 retire . . . followed by B/64 and C/64. . . . Great difficulty in finding out where our Infantry were . . . lack of OPs and communications. . . . It was now [3 pm] very difficult to place the batteries, as the 31st Div had retired in disorder . . . The line was more or less restored by nightfall.
The brigade retreated further the next day but on the 14th when the Australians relieved the 29th and 31st infantry divisions, the brigade supported the Australians in holding the front. By the 16th ‘Situation [was] settling down. Orders to dig in.’ On the next quiet evening the tally of casualties since 9th April was recorded: Capt Attkins and Lt Robbins wounded, 2nd Lt Marriott gassed, Major Baker wounded but at duty; 3 men killed, 21 wounded and 10 missing, 1 wounded and at duty; 60 horses killed or wounded; and five field guns lost. The brigade suffered several more casualties before its relief by a New Zealand brigade on 26 April. The 11th of April was the day Field Marshall Haig issued his historic order: ‘Every position must be held to the last man. . . . With our backs to the wall and believing in the justice of our cause, each one of us must fight on to the end.’ But Operation Michael had been so swiftly successful that Ludendorff failed to capitalize on it (Liddell Hart 1934, 399–401). When he attacked further north, on the Lys, his troops again made initial rapid progress, but were held up before they could reach the railway junction
48
Lionel Robbins
at Hazebrouck. After two less successful attempts to resume the offensive on 25 and 29 April this German offensive was abandoned (Buffetaut 1988, 52–60). A month later the Germans broke through further south and reached the river Marne. In July, however, when Ludendorff launched another major attack the Allies, who had had time to build up their trained forces, launched a counteroffensive three days later. With German reserves depleted, Ludendorff was ‘forced (on 20th July) to postpone, if not yet to abandon, the offensive in Flanders, and the initiative definitely and finally passed to the Allies’ (Liddell Hart 1934, 372). The spectacularly successful battle of Amiens on 8–12 August led by seasoned Canadian and Australian troops was followed by further Allied gains in September. In October the Germans sought an armistice from US President Wilson, Ludendorff resigned on 26 October, and the Armistice was signed at 5 a.m. on 11 November. Robbins spent the summer of 1918 at home at Hollycroft. One of his younger sister Nancy’s early memories is the arrival of the telegram reporting him a casualty. Her mother fainted. Her older sister Caroline, however, ‘looked at the telegram, said he’s alright, seriously wounded officers don’t get sent to that hospital.’ Lionel’s father rushed up to town to see his son, who was in the Prince of Wales’ Hospital for Officers (the converted 700room Great Central Hotel) at Marylebone. He had received at least two communications on 16 April: a telegram from the War Office informing him his son had been admitted to the Red Cross Hospital Boulogne with a ‘Gunshot wound forearm slight’ and a card from the Prince of Wales’ Hospital that Lionel was there. Lionel also sent a telegram from the hospital to his father at the Agricultural Wages Board. On 3 July Dick Robbins received another War Office telegram stating his son had been wounded on 28 June, and in September a letter cancelling this, by which time Lionel was at Hollycroft on convalescent home leave. During his leave Lionel got to know his younger sister, then five years old. She already knew that he ‘was such a nice person to play with’; in 1918 she helped him work on the garden with his useless arm, the gardener Mitchie having been directed to war work. From Hollycroft he could go up to town for daily electrical massage treatment on his arm. He could also meet Clive and Reg and again attend concerts and visit the galleries with them. He kept in touch with Miss Horton and Miss Monk, but he did not return to the du Monts’. Madame had written passionate letters to him in France: she ‘evidently thought that
The Great War
49
I should marry her daughter’. In the last of them she had accused Clive of cultivating Lionel only for the sake of his sisters; he had told Clive and Reg and they and Madeleine (the daughter) had had a quarrel about him while he was away. As he also told John Ginger, ‘This probably led to the end of the evenings.’ When it became clear that Lionel would not quickly recover the use of his left arm (it was paralyzed for about a year), he sought to be passed fit for office work in London. His father called on Major Wigan at the War Office, ‘who knows something of Lt Robbins’ record as a Cadet’, and indicated that his son would be particularly interested in an instructorship (RRR to Military Secretary, War Office, 28 September 1918). In October Lionel was posted to the RA Barracks at St John’s Wood, where his army career had begun. On 11 November he ‘was making my way along the north side of Trafalgar Square by the National Gallery when the signals went off. . . . In a matter of minutes, the square and the neighbouring streets were filled with dense masses of people inspired by uninhibited joy. . . . Strangers embraced one another. Tears of happiness rolled down our cheeks. Traffic came, more or less, to a full stop; and even late that night it was not easy for the average civilian to get about quickly.’ He spent the evening with Clive and Reg, making their way through the crowds more easily thanks to his sling and uniform (Robbins 1971a, 54). Among those who observed the scene was Osbert Sitwell, in a taxi with Sergei Diaghilev the Russian ballet impressario and his choreographer Massine (1949, 1–4): ‘it was impossible to drive through Trafalgar Square: because the crowd danced under lights turned up for the first time for four years – danced so thickly that the heads, the faces, were like a field of golden corn moving in a dark wind. . . . there were many soldiers, sailors and airmen in the crowd which, sometimes joining up, linking hands, dashed like the waves of the sea against the sides of the Square, against the railings of the National Gallery, sweeping up so far even as beyond the shallow stone steps of St. Martin-in-the-Fields.’ Diaghilev ‘gazed with an air of melancholy exhaustion at the crowds. . . . The dancer [Massine] was watching intently the steps and gestures of the couples.’ Lawson recalled (information from John Ginger) that ‘We all danced . . . in front of the Mansion House at midday, and climbed lamp-posts in the Strand that evening. I finally got home after midnight, carrying a number 24 bus-direction-board.’ At home at Hollycroft that autumn Lionel was in a more sombre mood. ‘Roaming about/The empty garden/One October morning/It was cold and misty/There were no flowers but drenched roses/And damp yellow
50
Lionel Robbins
leaves/Strewing the paths/I thought of my friend/Who lay dying/Under a cart . . . I wondered/“Where is he now?”’ (Return from the war, RP). He found ‘The Flat Country (Home i.e.)’ (the title of another poem written at this time) grey, joyless and desolate. And he wrote a poem ‘H. Beresford’: Now all the stacks are made The work is done: The grain is harvested And the sythes [sic] are laid Back in the shed Yet sometimes there comes to one Thought like a sudden cry What of the dead who lie Under the mould? The dead? There is no word to say. There is no song to sing. There is nothing that one can do. Nothing.
He later added a note ‘Died May 1918 occupying a post I should have held had I not been wounded six weeks previously.’
THREE
Postwar
The immediate postwar period was a time of hope and of disillusionment for Lionel Robbins as for many others in Britain. In the heady atmosphere of postwar optimism hopes of reform and reconstruction flourished. The Lloyd George coalition reelected in December 1918 promised a land fit for heroes to live in, reflecting the aspirations of the few remaining Liberals in the Conservative-dominated government. Many of the measures planned in the wartime Ministry of Reconstruction were begun in 1919. But after the breathing space of the demobilization period and a shortlived frenetic postwar boom in 1919–20 there came a severe and prolonged slump. UK unemployment, which is estimated to have fallen as low as 2–3 per cent by the spring of 1920, was over 20 per cent a year later. As officially measured, it did not fall below 1 million or 10 per cent of those insured under the national insurance scheme, which commenced in 1920, for the rest of the decade. Social reform gave way to public expenditure cuts and to the restoration of the gold standard at the prewar parity. Guild socialism withered as dreams of revolution or at least radical change faded. In the ‘breathing space’, which lasted for about six months, the exodus of people from the armed forces (and from munitions factories) was greater than the absorption of workers into peacetime employment. The government tried to slow down demobilization, by giving priority to men with definite offers of employment, skilled workers in certain key trades, and men on leave producing written offers of employment. This looked particularly unfair to those who had served longest, to older men and to married men, seeing newer recruits and younger or unmarried men released before them, and had to be abandoned early in 1919. Out of a total of 3.7m other ranks demobilized between 11 November 1918 and 20 February 1920, 1.8m were released in January–March 1919; the peak periods for officers released were February and April 1919 (Pigou 1947, 22–7 and 216). On release servicemen 51
52
Lionel Robbins
received twenty-eight days’ paid leave and a war gratuity. Once the boom began, however, the demand for labour increased rapidly and by the end of the year there was something like full employment along with rapidly rising prices and wages. Lieutenant Robbins was demobilized on 28 February 1919 (LCR to RRR, 3 March 1919). This was sooner than he anticipated but his commanding officer suddenly decided to let him go. As he explained it later (1971a, 54–5), at the RA Barracks in St John’s Wood he and a senior lieutenant had been appointed demobilization officers: they decided that ‘since the orders we were getting did not make sense, the best thing to do was to get on with the job and demobilize all but the regulars as quickly as we could. This we did, without cavil from above, with such expedition that, by March [sic] 1919, there was nothing left for me to do but to get demobilized myself.’ He was twenty years old and had spent three of his twenty years in the Army. At first he was in an optimistic frame of mind. The general enthusiasm for reconstruction encouraged those who wished to reform the economic and social system, including Liberal reformers, Fabians and socialists of all kinds. Lionel ‘hoped to be able to participate in . . . the forthcoming transformation of society’ as a guild socialist (ibid., 56), telling his father on 3 March 1919 that he ‘felt very strongly the necessity of doing what seems to me right rather than adopting the line of least resistance.’ Guild socialism as an idea had many attractions, proposing as it did an economic system without the most disagreeable features of capitalism, especially as they had been seen during the war. And in ‘the somewhat unreal atmosphere’ of 1918–19, when ‘the individuals and groups with ideas of a new society thrived, and the workers seemed to go along with them’, it seemed almost practical politics (Carpenter 1973, 72). The revolutions in Russia were in the very recent past. The position of the workers was strong while the post-Armistice boom lasted. To the guild socialists (Reckitt and Bechhofer 1918, 3), The fundamental basis of the revolutionary case against Capitalism is not that it makes the few rich and the many poor – though this is true; not that it creates social conditions which are a disgrace and an amazement in a civilised community – though this also is true; not that it brutalises the rich by luxury, stifles beauty, and frustrates the hope of craftsmanship for the worker . . . but that it denies and degrades the character of man by the operation of a wage-system which makes the worker of no more account than a machine to be exploited or a tool to be bought and sold.
Before the war guild socialism had been expounded in The New Age by S.G. Hobson and by the editor, A.R. Orage, who published Hobson’s articles as
Postwar
53
a book in 1914. During the war the idea had been taken further, practically with the founding in April 1915 of the National Guilds League and theoretically in Self-Government in Industry (1917) by the Oxford intellectual G.D.H. Cole. Hobson (1914, part I) had despaired of the Labour movement as it had developed in Britain. The trade unions in seeking higher wages for their members had gained little real improvement in the standard or quality of life of the workers. Attempts at political action, either through ‘permeation’ of the Liberal Party or through the setting up of the Independent Labour Party, had achieved even less. Fabian proposals for nationalization and state ownership of major industries would only substitute one employer, the state, for another, the private capitalists. The only ray of hope he had seen was the strikes organized by more militant trade unionists in the wave of industrial unrest in 1911–12. The ‘emancipation’ of the worker could only come through a direct attack on capitalism and the wage system. ‘The way out is to smash wages.’ Capitalism where workers were ‘wage slaves’ forced to sell their labour as a commodity had to be replaced by an economic system in which workers controlled the product of their own labour, and profits, rent and wages did not exist. Associations of producers could determine their own remuneration and their working conditions, enabling them to cooperate in working for themselves and to enjoy their work, as was believed by William Morris and his followers to have been true of the mediaeval craftsmen’s guilds. The new guilds would be ‘national’ in that they would include all the workers in a particular industry in one country, but they would not be the owners of their industry, which would be owned by the state, with which the guilds would have to cooperate in order to look after the interests of the citizens as a whole. Guild socialism ‘differs from State Socialism or Collectivism . . . [because] the Guild manages its own affairs . . . [and] rejects State bureaucracy’; at the same time it ‘rejects Syndicalism, because it accepts co-management with the State, . . . subject to the principle of industrial democracy . . . for the simple reason that the policy of a Guild is a public matter, about which the public, as represented by the State, has an indefeasible right to be consulted and considered’ (ibid., 132). Hobson (1914, part II) moved on to discuss what he saw as the practical details of his guilds – which industries should constitute separate guilds, how the guilds would be managed internally – without stopping to explain on what matters the guilds would cooperate with the state. Cole was much clearer: the state would represent the citizens as consumers. His conception of society and state was pluralist: he attacked the notion of state sovereignty, which Hobson took for granted, and pointed out that ‘a State is nothing
54
Lionel Robbins
more or less than the political machinery of government in a community’; a society could contain many associations formed for different purposes, of which the ‘state’ or national government was only one (Wright 1979, 32–49). The starting point of Cole’s book (1917a) was the situation in which the trade unions found themselves as a result of the war. The major unions had volunteered an ‘industrial truce’ early in the war and agreed to allow departures from their restrictive practices – such as the replacement of skilled labour by unskilled – for the duration. It was essential, argued Cole, that the prewar rights and privileges of the unions should be restored after the war; the trade unions should then use the opportunity of the reconstruction period, when labour would be in great demand, to reorganize themselves into industrial rather than craft unions, as a first step towards the formation of national guilds. Guild socialism was nothing if not utopian. Cole and Hobson wrote all too easily. They were short on analysis of the economic problems, of the matching of supply and demand for particular goods and services, or of the maintenance of capital, that would have to be solved in a guild socialist society.1 Aware of the existence of some of the problems – guild socialists were idealistic but not naive – they assumed they could be avoided administratively or politically. Cole in particular tried to devise institutional arrangements to prevent exploitation by powerful guilds and to protect the interests of consumers. His suggestion (ibid., chapter IX) of a system of taxation of the guilds agreed between a Guild Congress representing the producers and the State representing the consumers clashed with Hobson’s conception of the state. This and their other differences were well argued in their rounds of entertaining debate in The New Age in 1917–18 (Hobson 1920; Cole 1917b, 1918). Cole was the more pragmatic. It might be sensible to accept nationalization as a halfway house to guild socialism: it would reduce the economic power of the capitalists and it would probably be easier for unions gradually to wrest control of their workplaces from management in nationalized industries. Cole, who had worked for the unions during the war, always envisaged ‘encroaching control’ by the trade unions as the way forward (Carpenter 1973, 88–90). Lionel Robbins joined the National Guilds League at the time that Cole was at the height of his influence. He listened ‘green with envy’ to lectures and speeches by Cole, ‘whose apparently effortless command of his subject 1
Hobson’s economic analysis of the wage system under capitalism was tacitly Marxist, with a subsistence theory of wages and a Marxian theory of value.
Postwar
55
and superiority of manner seemed to me, at that time quite unacquainted with this kind of university product, to be beyond the ambition of any ordinary mortal to achieve’ (Robbins 1971a, 58). (He was later to call Cole a ‘B[loody] F[ool] [who] needs to be sat upon on every possible occasion’ [LCR to Cannan, 17 October 1930, Cannan Papers 1030, BLPES], but by then he had been a colleague in economics at Oxford.) The London lectures organized by the National Guilds League included talks on political and industrial policy by trade unionists and Labour Party activists as well as by intellectuals such as Cole and Bertrand Russell.2 Lionel reasonably decided that the way forward for himself was to find a job in the labour movement. He aired his views and ambitions vigorously at home. This led to long and vociferous arguments with his father, who ‘felt that I was throwing away all the advantages which his hard work had procured for me, that I was repudiating the moral basis of our family life’ and who ‘did not conceal his feelings’. His son was equally determined and obstinate: in one quarrel ‘he asked me if I wanted any [of his money] and I told him he could keep it. He said he was going to alter his will but I suspect he did not do it.’3 It cannot have helped that his father was in the spring of 1919 involved in difficult negotiations with the workers on the Agricultural Wages Board. Lionel’s first idea was to find a job as a union organizer. He applied for such a position with the British and Allied Waiters’ and Chefs’ Union, who were seeking to unionize waitresses at Lyons teashops. When he was called for an interview, ‘it did not take long for them [the union executive] to decide that ex-Lieutenant Lionel Robbins was emphatically not suitable for their job. . . . Whatever had been my relationship with drivers and gunners in the R.F.A., my contact with women of any kind, outside the family and my educational institutions, had been non-existent’ (1971a, 60). More practically, he talked to J.J. Mallon, a friend of Clive Gardiner’s father, who had wide contacts in the labour movement. He ‘asked him advice as to my possible usefulness in the labour world either as a factory hand or a lickeron of stamps to some official. He was very kind and sympathetic’ and offered to take young Robbins to meet G.D.H. Cole and W.N. Ewer of the National Guilds League ‘to see what can be done’. ‘I imagine,’ Lionel told his father on 3 March 1919, ‘that the most they will be able to do will be to recommend 2
3
The lectures in Kingsway Hall on Thursdays evenings in the autumn, winter and spring of 1919–20 were advertized and sometimes summarized in The Guildsman in September, November and December 1919 and January 1920. LCR, ‘Property, I. Autobiographical Preface’, [nd but 1922], RP. If RRR altered his will, he changed it again. According to his last will and testament his estate was essentially divided equally between his four children.
56
Lionel Robbins
me work in some industrial centre where later on I could be of assistance with propaganda. Till I have fixed up something definite I shall stay on here.’ ‘Here’ was 44 Hamilton Gardens, St John’s Wood, where Lionel lived for about eighteen months as one of the lodgers of a Mrs Smith. He asked his father to send him some of his books and ‘seditious brochures’ from home to join his ‘Woolwich collection’; the resulting ‘nucleus of a very useful students reference library’ included ‘Marx the truculent obscurantist who exercises a policemanlike guard over the more frivolous members of my “ideology”, [Clive] Bell with his incisive wit and exhaustive aesthetic and my beloved Diabolonian Nietzche’ (LCR to RRR, 3/7/19). He stayed away from Hollycroft in order to avoid quarrels with his father which upset his stepmother. After he had not seen his father for about three months he sought to meet him in town instead, and he returned to Hollycroft to celebrate his twenty-first birthday in November at a small party which included Eddie Rose and George Davidge (LCR to RRR, nd but June, 30 July and 20 November 1919). While he was still in the army Lionel had resumed the life and friendships in London he had begun to enjoy when he was at Woolwich. In the autumn of 1918 he and Clive Gardiner and Reg Lawson began to go to the ballet: Diaghilev’s Ballets Russes opened its first London season since before the war at the Coliseum on 5 September. Lawson told John Ginger (‘Written answers to questions’), ‘We were fascinated and went as often as we could.’ The company gave one ballet each afternoon and evening as part of mixed music-hall acts: the first two presented were Cl´eopˆatre with Tchernicheva as Cleopatra and The Good-humoured Ladies, the first Massine ballet to be seen in London, with Lopokova (later known to economists as the wife of John Maynard Keynes) as the maid. The season was so successful that Diaghilev was able to arrange a proper season, with three ballets a night, at the Alhambra theatre in Leicester Square from 30 April; it was there in June and July that the Massine ballets La boutique fantasque – in which Lopokova and Massine appeared as can-can dancers – and The Three-Cornered Hat, with their designs by Derain and Picasso, were first performed. The season opened with Petrushka, the first performance in England since the war. A third London season in September–December 1919 included the English premiere of Parade, with music by Satie, designs by Picasso and plot by Cocteau, but without Lopokova who had vanished in July (Buckle 1979, 345–60). Lionel and his two friends watched the Massine ballets and the dancing of Lopokova, Tchernicheva, Massine and Woizikovsky with, according to Lawson, ‘a reverence and devotion that most people associate with their religion’.
Postwar
57
Their favourites were The Good-Humoured Ladies, The Three-Cornered Hat and Petrushka (Ginger 1991, 36). Lopokova, who danced the part of the doll many times, said (1983, 211) of Petrushka: ‘One of the best music-drama compositions ever invented is Stravinsky’s Petrushka. . . . Diaghilev, Benois [the designer], Fokine, Stravinsky . . . created out of . . . [a proposed] piano concerto this peculiar Russian folklore drama. . . . Reality and symbolism perfectly blended, half-obvious, half-hidden and unfathomable, to which every spectator can give his own meaning.’ Lionel particularly remembered Lopokova in La boutique fantasque at the Alhambra (June 1919): she was ‘enchanting’ (information from David Laidler). In 1918–20 Clive had a studio at 6 Bedford Gardens, Kensington, which became the centre of Lionel and Reg’s social life. Reg’s Bl¨uthner piano was there, Clive and Lionel having helped to buy it at the bankruptcy sale after Reg’s father was convicted of fraud for the second time. Clive’s younger sister Iris remembered evening parties at the studio with guests including Lionel, Reggie, Eddie Rose, John Polimeni and Lilian Lancaster. John (Giovanni) Polimeni, whose Sicilian father ran the English end of the family fruit importing business, had been a friend of Clive and Reg’s since before the war; he had a powerful tenor voice and a passion for Debussy.4 Lilian Lancaster, who married Clive in 1921, was a fellow artist, one of Walter Sickert’s first pupils; they met at the Brighton School of Art when Clive was teaching there in 1918 (Reade 1963, 9; Sutton 1976, 145–6). At Christmas 1918 the three friends produced a ‘morality play – like Everyman’ for which Lionel wrote a poetic prologue and Reg played the piano; other members of Clive’s and Reg’s families were roped in to act or to dance (Clive Gardiner to IEG, nd but November 1918; Ginger, ‘Interview with Lord Robbins 4/4/79’). In 1919 Lionel saw more of Clive than of Reg. At the end of 1918 Lawson, the stage manager of his friends’ parties, found himself a job in the new film industry, at the Barker Studios in Ealing, and in 1919 he went to Haarlem, Holland, as assistant to the producer Bernard Doxat-Pratt and worked there for two years (Ginger 1991, 40–8). Clive was painting portraits and teaching at the School of Art at Goldsmiths’ College. One of his early pupils remembers him ‘as a young, shy, faintly mocking and sarcastic figure . . . bespectacled [and] intellectual-looking’. It was from him that ‘One heard for the first time such names as C´ezanne and Matisse and we were shown reproductions of their work’ (Sutherland 1963, 4–5). C´ezanne, in contrast to Degas and Gaugin, was still controversial in London in the 4
Information from Clive Gardiner to AGG, 28 November 1919, Gardiner 2/8, BLPES, John Ginger and Iris Robbins.
58
Lionel Robbins
early 1920s – with the Tate Gallery, for instance, refusing the offer of a loan of two paintings in 1921 and declining to purchase others in 1922 (House 1994, 12–13). Lionel saw the major exhibition of Matisse’s work at the Leicester Galleries in London in November–December 1919 with Clive, as he did subsequent exhibitions of the work of Gaugin, Van Gogh and C´ezanne (Robbins 1967b, 13; Cachin et al 1996, 589; Robins 1997, 159– 61). He learned from Clive to look at works of art ‘for what they conveyed through their own media rather than what I felt could be projected into them, in my own medium, as it were, of words’. He had read Clive Bell’s Art (1914) with enthusiasm and swallowed its message of ‘significant form’ whole: he admitted later (1971a, 243) that for some years he ‘more or less refused to recognize or admit the essentially mixed content of any visual art which was not deliberately formal’ – a narrow view that his friend did not share. According to Robbins (1967b, 13–14), Clive always had a strong impulse to figurative art and after experimenting with new techniques in the 1920s, with C´ezanne the main inspiration, ‘the old impulse to figurative composition, never entirely dormant, . . . reasserted itself’ in the 1930s; nonetheless ‘through all the vicissitudes of his style, Clive retained a quite special reverence for this master’, C´ezanne. Clive was one of a fairly large, close-knit family. His father, A.G. Gardiner, was the editor of the Daily News, one of the leading Liberal newspapers, from 1902 until September 1919, when, after a long period of disagreement with the owners over his opposition to Lloyd George, he resigned. He and his wife Ada had six children: Stella, who married J.J. Mallon in 1921, Clive, Gwen, Iris, Phyllis and Gilbert. In the years immediately after the war Lionel came to know the family well, though not Iris who was living away from home. In London they lived until 1921 at 613 Finchley Road, at the Golders Green end of Hampstead, but they had a country home in the Chilterns, in ‘the lovely hamlet of Whiteleaf [Buckinghamshire], with its sixteenthcentury thatched cottages sheltering under the deep woods of Whitecross Hill and looking over Princes Risborough and the wide Wycombe valley to Bledlow Ridge’ (Gardiner quoted by Koss 1973, 165). There Gardiner had a house built, The Spinney, which backs onto the local golf course; this became the family’s main home from 1917. It was a hospitable home; for Lionel it was ‘a model of what English family life at its best can be’, and the days he spent there were ‘among the happiest days of my life’ (LCR to IEG, 20 February 1924). He remembered (1971a, 98) Mrs Gardiner, the ‘focus for the love and devotion of all’, as ‘a truly beautiful person’. He got on well with A.G. Gardiner, for they shared interests in history and public affairs and a love of English literature. He was a great admirer of Gardiner’s
Postwar
59
writings, especially of his regular columns in the Star under the pseudonym ‘Alpha of the Plough’: he had taken the first published collection (1916) of these with him to France in 1917 (LCR to RRR, 23 December 1917). Mallon’s friendship with Gardiner dated from about 1906 when he was working for the National Anti-Sweating League which Gardiner supported strongly in the Daily News (Koss 1973, 77–9). The League was formed to campaign for a minimum wage in industries which employed sweated labour; it succeeded with the passage of the Trade Boards Act 1909 which set a minimum wage in several industries. In November 1919 Mallon, who had worked for the University Settlement at Ancoats, Manchester, before moving to London, became Warden of Toynbee Hall, the universities’ settlement in Whitechapel, East London. In the spring of 1919, when Lionel met him, he was working in a variety of labour-related activities – for instance as a member of the National Industrial Conference and as treasurer of the WEA (Pimlott 1935, 207–8; Briggs and Macartney 1984, 91–5). When he and Arthur Greenwood were asked to organize the Labour Campaign for the Nationalization of the Drink Trade, he suggested Lionel come and work for them. The existence of this organization requires some explanation. Wartime concern over excessive drinking and absenteeism among munitions workers had led to restriction of the opening hours of public houses – including from 1916 the ‘afternoon gap’ which lasted until 1990 – and the reduction of the alcoholic strength of beer and spirits. In some areas the government Central Control Board provided industrial canteens; in others it took over the pubs: at Enfield Lock near the Royal Small Arms Factory, at Invergordon and Cromarty around the Cromarty Firth naval base and, on a larger scale, in the Carlisle area following the establishment of a large munitions factory at Gretna. There ‘The newly arrived workers had nowhere to spend their leisure time, except in the streets and the public-houses. . . . it is not surprising that the public-houses in the district became the haven of the Gretna workers out of working hours. By the middle of 1916 the situation was deplorable. . . . Carlisle became a city of degrading sights . . . and the Liquor Control Board decided to acquire, on payment of compensation, the whole of the liquor trade, both wholesale and retail, in the district, in order . . . [to be] able to take drastic action to improve the prevailing conditions.’ The drastic action included the closing of some pubs, the remodelling or rebuilding of others, the provision of food in pubs, and the payment of salaries to the managers, as well as the manufacture and distribution of alcoholic beverages in the whole area. The Carlisle experiment was very successful, not just in reducing drunkenness locally and in ‘making the
60
Lionel Robbins
public-house less of a mere drink shop and more of a real social centre’, but also improving the working conditions of the workers in the industry and making a profit (Greenwood 1920, 15–22). The Central Control Board suggested extending the experiment to the whole country, and the government did set up committees during the war to examine the financial implications of nationalization of the whole trade. At the end of the war the ‘trade’ and no doubt many members of the public hoped for relaxation of the wartime restrictions, while temperance reformers were urging further control, even prohibition as in the USA. There had always been a strong temperance movement within the Liberal Party, while the brewers (who owned or controlled most of the public houses) and distillers were traditionally strong and generous supporters of the Conservative and Unionist Party. In the Labour Party opinions on drink were mixed. The Labour campaign for public ownership and control of the liquor trade was inaugurated in order to ‘focus what the [management] committee [of the campaign] regard[ed] as the general opinion of the organised Labour movement on the drink question’ (ibid., 29). Insobriety might be an evil but abstinence would not solve social and economic problems, which were not caused by drink. Prohibition was anyway quite unrealistic. What was desirable and possible was a reduction in the consumption of alcohol, for, as Greenwood (85–6) put it, ‘If half the amount of money now expended on alcoholic liquors and half the energy sapped by the drink shops were devoted to education and political and industrial organisation, Labour would be able to realise some of its most cherished aspirations within the next few years.’ Regulation of a privately owned drink trade would not be sufficient because it would always be in the interests of the owners to encourage increased consumption. Nor would regulation remove the political influence of the owners. Under state ownership it would also be possible to improve the amenities of licensed premises as in Carlisle and the quality of the beer. Robbins worked for Greenwood and Mallon for just over a year, in the campaign’s office at 45 Mecklenburgh Square, where Mallon already had his office. ‘At first all went well. The job of organizing an office and arranging systematic propaganda for a cause was new to me. For a time it occupied most of my physical and mental energies. We arranged conferences. We addressed – or caused to be addressed – thousands of envelopes. We compiled lists for circularization. We prepared literature . . . Greenwood even wrote a book [1920] . . . We engaged a regular organizer, whose duty it was to go round the country imparting the gospel of drink nationalization to local Labour Parties and trades councils. On a few occasions when Greenwood or others
Postwar
61
were prevented from functioning, I myself went out speaking. It was all quite strenuous’ and interesting (Robbins 1971a, 63). Greenwood was by all accounts including Robbins’s ‘a very decent man’. He had been a lecturer in economics at the University of Leeds before he moved to London during the war to work for the Ministry of Reconstruction. After the war Gardiner on resigning from the Daily News approached him to see if he would be prepared to succeed him as editor; he had pointed out he was too far to the left as well as too anti-Lloyd George to be acceptable to the owners (Greenwood to AGG, 4 August 1919, Gardiner 1/14). He ran the research and information department of the Labour Party before he was elected to Parliament in 1922. Lionel worked as Greenwood’s personal assistant. He wrote letters for him and transcribed his drafts.5 As he told his father in June 1919, he helped to prepare the pamphlets published under Greenwood’s name, Publicans and Politics and The Brewers Repentant (Greenwood Ms Eng c 76, Bodleian Library Oxford). At an early stage he gathered data on brewery profits and carried out other research for Greenwood’s book; although he later described the book as ‘compiled entirely hearsay second hand information which I had cut from papers’ (‘Socialism’, Essays on Trade & the Depression, RP), it is readable and well argued. Full of factual information on the economics and organization of the drink trade in Great Britain, it made a serious case for public ownership of the trade moderately, dealing fairly with the critics of public ownership. An attractive feature of the book is that it does not claim too much for its proposals. In August 1919 Lionel took a holiday on the Sussex coast with his old schoolfriends Eddie Rose and George Davidge, which he commemorated in a short poem (‘Newhaven 1919 – to E.C.R.’, RP). George had returned from Salonika in the spring and with the encouragement of Lionel’s father had decided to become a schoolteacher. After passing his Intermediate Arts examination in the summer he went up to East London College, where Eddie had returned to complete his degree in English (Davidge to RRR, nd but September 1919; Rose to LCR, 4 November 1918, Personal letters from Iris & Clive etc, RP). In the autumn Lionel, along with Nathan Isaacs and his friends Joseph Pole and Phoebe Rickards, attended a London University extension course on psychology given by Susan Brierley. Her ‘very well 5
One consequence of Robbins’s working for Greenwood was that he altered his handwriting to imitate Greenwood’s way of writing e’s so as to be able to sign his letters for him (1971a, 79). The result is not easily legible but since Robbins returned to a more conventional hand at the end of 1921 (see Chapter 4), it is a boon to his biographer as it allows the dating of many otherwise undatable documents in his papers.
62
Lionel Robbins
composed’ lectures were followed by a hour of discussion. Nathan who had already read widely in psychology ‘very soon became the main questioner and “they were at it hammer and tongs” . . . Susan was very poised, rather prim, and very clear and lucid, with never an obscure sentence’ (LCR quoted by Gardner 1969, 50–1). Lionel followed the course for two terms, claiming later that he ‘always felt a bit of a psychologist . . . just after sitting through that one course’ and doing the associated reading. Nathan married Susan – but not until 1922, for she avoided him for a couple of years until she decided to leave her first husband. With Nathan’s active intellectual and moral support she became the famous and influential child psychologist Susan Isaacs. He continued to think and write on philosophy and psychology – and to argue with Lionel – while working in the City for a firm of metal merchants.6 In March 1920 Lionel suffered a bout of influenza from which he took time to recover. Away from work he took himself off to the White Horse Hotel at Rottingdean, five miles east of Brighton, which he had visited with Clive several times during his ‘“wounded” period’, occupying himself with walks on the downs and on the beach below them. Judging from his letters to his father he was still quite content with his employment. In the summer, however, when the annual Labour Party Conference failed to support the state purchase of breweries and pubs, he was contemplating resignation. He was also beginning to have his doubts about guild socialism. Like other ardent young socialists before and since, he was disappointed to learn that British trade unionists and Labour Party workers had little inclination for revolution. At the same time the naive attitudes of some of his fellow young revolutionaries irritated him – for example the plain young woman at a party who apparently believed the way to stop the army from putting down a revolution was ‘to give ourselves to the officers’ (1971a, 63–5). Guild socialism itself was also changing and losing its way. Late in 1918 Orage had met ‘an extraordinary man, a Cambridge graduate and engineer by profession, at present a Major’, C.H. Douglas, who had his own peculiar theory of money and credit. Orage was immediately converted; Hobson was not and ceased writing for The New Age (Hobson 1938, 193–4). Douglas’s first book (1920) appeared in serial form in The New Age in 1919, his second (1921) in 1920. Douglas gave lectures to the National Guilds League, some of which Robbins attended. 6
LCR, Remarks at the Commemoration Ceremony for Nathan Isaacs, 13th June 1966, Biographical Papers, RP; Smith (1985, 169–82); Isaacs (1949); Hardeman (1976); see Chapter 7.
Postwar
63
Douglas’s theory rests on a simple fallacy which is not, however, immediately obvious to non-economists. He made his essential point on a few pages of his first book (1920, 59–62), namely that of the cost of any manufactured item, for instance ‘a steel bolt and nut weighing ten pounds’ and costing 15s 11d only a small portion (6s 10d in his example) constitutes payments to employees. ‘Without proceeding to add selling charges and profit it must be clear that a charge of 15s. 11d. on the world’s purchasing power has been created, of which only 6s. 10d. is distributed . . . and that if the effective demand exists at all in a form suitable for the liquidation of this charge, it must reside in the banks.’ Thus to keep the capitalist economy going it is necessary for the banks continuously to create money by lending to manufacturers, but the resulting inflation further reduces the purchasing power of the workers. The fallacy of his ‘A + B theorem’, which he introduced in his second book, where A = the payments to individuals (wages, salaries and dividends) and B = the payments to cover all other costs of production, is that the B payments are not lost as he claimed to the flow of available purchasing power. Indeed they must be made in order to provide for capital investment and ensure the continuous flow of manufactured goods. The fallacious A + B theorem thus cannot explain the lack of effective demand at times of economic depression (Robbins 1932h, 414–18). To Douglas his interpretation of factory costing implied the need to take money-creation away from private financiers, and for some form of ‘social credit’ where loans are made to produce goods actually desired by consumers and prices are somehow fixed so as to provide adequate rewards to the producers. Orage took up this idea eagerly: neglect of finance had always been a weak point of guild socialist proposals. He and Douglas developed a scheme involving producers’ (ie trade union) banks and price control for the mining industry, which they put to the National Guilds League in the spring of 1920. Although the League agreed to conduct an enquiry into the proposals, it decisively rejected its report at a special conference in December 1920 (Carpenter 1922, 126–37). The Labour Party even more decisively rejected the scheme, and Douglas’s theories, two years later in the scathing report of a special committee in July 1922 (Dutton and King 1986, 259–79). Orage’s attempt to press Douglas’s ideas on the National Guilds League only served to exacerbate the divisions in the League, already badly split over its attitude to the Bolshevik Revolution. By the end of 1920 guild socialism was effectively dead. The young Robbins, impressed by Orage’s earlier writings on guild socialism, was inclined to follow his lead over the new social credit ideas. Although they did not fit well with most of the tenets of guild socialism – the
64
Lionel Robbins
establishment of producers’ banks was hardly the way to abolish interest, for instance – ‘If the propositions were correct, were they not the answer to the most pressing social and economic problems of the day and was it not the duty of all men of goodwill to give them immediate attention?’ (1971a, 66). His employers in the Labour Party, like most members of the National Guilds League, were, however, dismissive of them and Lionel found himself obliged to try reading orthodox economic writings in an attempt to understand what was going on. He told Ezra Pound (who, like Orage, had been converted to social credit on meeting Douglas in 1918) on 18 September 1934 (Pound Collection, Beinecke Library, Yale): ‘I went into Economics after the war because I was convinced that Douglas had found the orthodox economists out & I wanted to learn their jargon so as to put things right.’ The importance of The New Age in English cultural history does not lie only, or even mainly, in its advocacy of guild socialism or social credit. When Lionel tried to persuade his father to subscribe by making him a present of a quarter’s subscription in the summer of 1920, he pointed out, ‘It usually deals with quite non controversial matter (noncontroversial in the ordinary sense I mean) and should make very good discussion when we meet.’ It had established itself as an innovative literary journal, providing informed comment on new writing and the arts, and publishing contributions by such authors as George Bernard Shaw, G.K. Chesterton, Hilaire Belloc, H.G. Wells and Arnold Bennett. Walter Sickert regularly contributed art criticism and drawings in 1910–14 (Baron 1992, 43–5). It had a very good drama critic, A.E. Randall. Orage himself contributed a literary column ‘Readers and Writers’ (signed RHC). Pound was a frequent contributor, providing essays and art and music criticism (pseudonymously) as well as poems. It is probably in The New Age that Robbins first read Pound’s poetry of which he became a great admirer. Pound’s Homage to Sextus Propertius, with its ‘irreverent wit, . . . sardonic parodies of imperial rhetoric . . . [and] mercurial shifts of mood and tone’ (Moody 2007, 349–50), appeared there in six parts in June-August 1919. Robbins shared his enthusiasm for Pound with a new friend. Basil Bunting, who later became known as a ‘northern’ poet as well as a disciple of Pound, was the son of a Newcastle doctor. Educated at Quaker schools, he had refused military service in March 1918 and was imprisoned as a conscientious objector. He obtained his release by going on hunger strike and, with the encouragement of his father who knew several of the early Fabians, he moved to London, where he worked for a while for the (Liberal) MP for Newcastle East, Major Harry Barnes (who later joined the Labour
Postwar
65
Party). Bunting probably met Lionel at the Fabian Research Department. In 1920 he registered as a student at the London School of Economics; he also tried to visit Soviet Russia via Scandinavia, but he failed to obtain a visa in Copenhagen and was deported from Northern Norway (Bunting to LCR, 12/10/20, RP). When he abandoned his studies in 1923 he followed Ezra Pound to Paris.7 Bunting later told Pound (August or September 1934, Pound Collection, Beinecke Library) that Robbins [is] a bloke abt a year or two older than me, good war record, son of the chap who used to be president or secretary or something of the National Farmers Union – anyway a man of some importance. I met him just before I went to the L.S.E. . . . He was one of the first people I met to show any interest in Douglas. Subsequent hostility is at least not result of ignorance, as in many cases. Tastes more or less better class Bloomsbury – i.e., aware of a lot of things you might not expect a prof of economics to have heard of. First person, I think, to show me any of [T.S.] Eliot’s work, certainly first to show me bits of [James Joyce’s] Ulysses in The Egoist (or was it Portrait of J.J.?). . . . He used to like yr works and probably still does.8
When Lionel was contemplating resignation from the Labour Campaign for the Nationalization of the Drink Trade in August 1920, he decided to spend his annual holiday in Paris. In his autobiography (1971a, 68) he described a lonely and miserable experience: ‘I spoke to no one save waiters, hotel servants and a prostitute in one of the grands boulevards whose offers I politely declined. I trudged round to many famous public places and buildings, but, with one exception, without much comprehension or enthusiasm, my thoughts being pre-occupied with my own private problem. The exception, of course, was the Louvre where the works of art held me enthralled, especially the “Collection Camondo”’ of Impressionist and PostImpressionist paintings. ‘Here I would sit morning after morning, gazing in rapture at C´ezanne’s “Vase Bleu”’. He was also despairingly reading Dostoyevsky, as Clive had been doing in a more cheerful frame of mind a few months earlier (Clive Gardiner to AGG, 28 November 1919, Gardiner 2/8). When he wrote to his father on 29 August after his first few days in Paris, he reported that his hotel was ‘a nasty poky little hole behind the Boulevard Montmartre’ in which he remained only because he hoped George Davidge, who was touring France on a bicycle, might contact him there. Since he did 7
8
Bunting’s several biographers (Alldritt 1998; Caddel and Flowers 1997; Forde 1991; Makin 1992; Terrell 1980; Williams 1968) provide conflicting accounts of his activities in 1919–23: for instance, he worked for Harry Barnes either before (Makin) or after (Alldritt, Caddell and Flowers, and Forde) his time at LSE, which is usually dated 1920–2. In fact he left LSE in April 1923 (see Chapter 5). Some of the remaining puzzles could be solved by his LSE Student’s Dossier which has unfortunately gone missing. It was Ulysses to which Robbins introduced Bunting (Stock 1970, 211–13).
66
Lionel Robbins
not now expect to hear from George he was thinking of leaving Paris: ‘A fortnight is a long time to be alone and I am not sure that I should not prefer to spend some of it, at least, right away from the strange people, who only annoy one, right in the heart of the French country where there would be no interference with one’s thoughts.’ He went on to complain of the ‘flagrant unreality’ of the city and its classical buildings. When he sent his father on 6 September a postcard of Leonardo’s St. Anne in the Louvre, however, his ‘only complaint . . . about this place is that it doesn’t remain open all night’. In London he had met several students from the London School of Economics (Robbins 1971a, 69). ‘In the diggings [sic] which I then inhabited at St John’s Wood, there was also residing a student from the London School of Economics’, who introduced him to other students. Through Basil Bunting he met Jacques Kahane, then a student at LSE reading for the BSc(Econ) degree and later a close friend. From what he heard from Kahane and the others, ‘it was clear that this offered just the course of study and environment which would be most congenial to me’. When Bunting decided to study for the same degree at the School Robbins was tempted to follow suit. But how could he possibly finance this? He decided that the only thing he could do was to go into business and earn enough money to enable him to continue his studies later. ‘I was just about to accept an offer of a post at £500 p.a. in the City when I met my father who hearing what I had decided to do very generously offered to provide me with enough money to return to college immediately. I accepted this offer [and] he placed £750 to my account at Cox’s [bank]’ (LCR, ‘Property I. Autobiographical Preface’, RP). Dick Robbins later made a similar offer to his youngest daughter Nancy when she wanted to go to medical school; he also offered to, and did, pay for the medical education of one of his wife’s nephews, the missionary doctor and leprosy specialist Paul Brand (Wilson 1965, 50–3). In his autobiography (1971a, 70–1) Lionel elaborated on this incident which took place a fortnight after he returned from Paris. The post he had been offered was in the intelligence department of the stockbrokers Pember & Boyle, of which Reggie’s elder brother Jack was a partner. He met his father in a Lyons teashop at Tottenham Court Road when he was on his way from Mecklenburg Square to have dinner with Jack Lawson in Hampstead and realized he was going to arrive too early. As I entered the shop, whom should I see at a distant table but my father, who had presumably just dropped in after an afternoon . . . transacting business for the National Farmers’ Union . . . I decided that I might as well advise him of my
Postwar
67
change of plan and my intention that evening. So I strolled across and related my news. . . . the news that I intended to become a stockbroker can hardly have been very welcome to him; for although he believed profoundly in private property and free enterprise, as a puritan he always had a slight suspicion that there was something rather dubious about this way of making a living. But he rose magnificently to the occasion. He listened sympathetically and then said ‘If you will undertake not to accept this offer and tell me how much you need to keep yourself for a full university course, I will give you the money here and now and never question you how it is used.’
Lionel quickly reckoned he would need £250 a year, hence the £750. He kept his dinner engagement, declined the job offer and registered at LSE the following morning – informing his father by postcard later in the day (28 September 1920).
FOUR
The London School of Economics
When Lionel Robbins entered the London School of Economics in October 1920, this Fabian institution was twenty-five years old. On 3 August 1894 Sidney Webb learned that he was an executor and trustee of the estate of the late Henry Hunt Hutchinson whose will instructed him to spend most of the estate on ‘the propaganda and other purposes’ of the Fabian Society and ‘to advancing its objects in any way they [the executors] deem advisable’. Over breakfast the next day Webb persuaded his wife Beatrice and his friends Graham Wallas and George Bernard Shaw that they could spend some of the money on founding a school of economics. Within a few months he had a director, W.A.S. Hewins, who was not a socialist or a Fabian, Wallas having declined the position, and on 10 October 1895 classes and lectures began (Dahrendorf 1995, 1–24). A year later the School had a library, the British Library of Political and Economic Science. It became a college of the University of London in 1900, moving to its present location, Clare Market, just off Aldwych, in 1902 (Hayek 1946, 9–14). With that history it is inevitable that LSE should be regarded as a left-wing institution, even when most of its staff, like the first director, were not. In 1920 it was physically still very small – construction of the main building in Houghton Street, now long since known as the ‘Old Building’, had just begun – and many lectures had to be given in temporary buildings to cope with the postwar influx of students, many of them like Robbins ex-servicemen. The students were not in the mood to complain: ‘Ex-soldiers, as the majority of us were, we thought we were lucky to be alive and where we were’ (Robbins 1971a, 72). It was in 1919 and 1920 that ‘a number of those arrived at LSE who were to determine more than others the character and appearance of the School for decades to come’, including Robbins and Arnold Plant (Dahrendorf 1995, 144). Plant had served as a private in the Royal West Kent Regiment in 1918; 68
The London School of Economics
69
after demobilization in January 1919 he had been general manager of the engineering works at the Steam Fittings Co. The historian of the School also singles out Sydney Caine, who like Plant became a close friend of Robbins in their undergraduate years; Caine was younger than Robbins and Plant, too young to have served in the forces, but entered a year earlier, as did Frederic Benham (London School of Economics 1934). Robbins’s fellow students included his existing LSE acquaintances Jacques Kahane (a year ahead of him) and Basil Bunting. The BSc(Econ) degree for which Robbins registered had been established at LSE in 1901, two years before the Economics Tripos at Cambridge (Hayek 1946, 14). It was a broad degree in the social sciences, especially in the first year. At the end of this year students were required to take the Intermediate Examination, which comprised four papers in economics (industrial and commercial history; principles of economics; currency, banking, trade and finance; and ‘passages from French and German works on [these] subjects for translation and comment’), two papers on the British Constitution, one in geography ‘with specific reference to Industry, Commerce and Politics’ and two in either mathematics or logic and scientific method (LSE Calendar 1920–1). The last was the only choice allowed. Robbins chose logic and scientific method – which was probably a mistake, as he realized when he encountered ‘mathematical formulae . . . his old betes noirs’ in economics (LCR to RRR, nd but early 1921). In the second and third years students could work for a pass or an honours degree, in both of which they had to take economics, history (with accounting as an alternative in the pass degree) and public administration. The honours degree also allowed some specialization in one of a range of subjects in economics and political science. While Robbins was an undergraduate the first reform of the degree changed the requirements for the candidates for honours in the Final Examination. Robbins was involved in several future reforms of the BSc(Econ) and tended to look back on the degree he took as a model to be preserved or recreated. The first lecture Robbins probably heard at the School was a public lecture opening the session on the first day of the Michaelmas term, Monday 4 October 1920, by the director, Sir William Beveridge, who expatiated on the virtues of ‘Economics as a liberal education’. He defined the objects of a liberal education as twofold – ‘The training of the mind’ and ‘The understanding of one’s environment so as to be in harmony with it’ – both of which the study of economics and the other social sciences, especially in the form of a broad degree such as the BSc(Econ), could easily provide (Beveridge 1921, 15–17). Lectures for the Intermediate Course began the next day, with Geography from Mrs Ormsby at 10.45 and Foreign Trade from
70
Lionel Robbins
Mr Gregory at noon. On Wednesday Dr Knowles lectured on The Growth of English Industry at 10.45, Mr Drummond Smith on The Elements of Industrial Organisation at 12. Dr Wolf offered Logic and Scientific Method at 11 on Thursdays, with a class following each lecture. On Friday Mr Dalton gave his lectures on Elements of Economics at 10.45, and a class at 2.30, and Mr Lees-Smith lectured on the British Constitution at noon. Beveridge was beginning the first of his eighteen years as director of LSE after eleven years as a civil servant. In the Board of Trade before the war he had the opportunity to put into practice his preferred solutions to the unemployment problem – labour exchanges in 1909 and compulsory unemployment insurance in 1911. During the war he served in the Ministry of Munitions and the Ministry of Food and had been appointed permanent secretary of the latter when Sidney Webb suggested in April 1919 that he become director of the School (Harris 1997, 252–60). Hilda Ormsby (n´ee Rodwell Jones) had been a student at LSE before the war, on the staff since 1912, and in naval intelligence during the war (Harrison Church 1974, 15). Gregory was of the same vintage of LSE students as Mrs Ormsby: born Theodore Guggenheim in 1890 he had been a student and a junior member of the staff before the war; during the war although he changed his name he was not allowed to join the forces (or for a while to teach at LSE) because of his German parentage. Robbins found his lectures on British foreign trade more interesting than Ormsby’s: ‘He was not the easiest of lecturers. He wrestled with his subjects like Jacob with the angel and would not let them go until he was blessed with some clarification. But from the outset he treated his audience as adults and vividly conveyed to us not only his passionate interest in problems, but also his independence and objectivity in dealing with them’ (‘Sir T. Gregory’, 3 February 1971, Biographical Papers, RP). Lionel attended many more of Gregory’s lectures, by choice, in the next two and a half years. Lilian Knowles, Reader in Economic History, became the first woman professor of economic history in 1921. A student at Girton College Cambridge, she had been trained in the Historical School of economics, which her writing and teaching reflected. ‘A county tory, a patriot and an imperialist’, she wrote and lectured on commerce, trade, transport and especially the empire (Berg 1992, 316). Her students nicknamed her Britannia (Burns 1983, 8). Her Michaelmas term lectures began with ‘The physical conditions which helped to make England a great power in the Eighteenth Century’ and continued with the development of agriculture and industry from the later mediaeval period to the eighteenth century and the industrial revolution. Robbins’s notes of these lectures are much less full than his notes of
The London School of Economics
71
Gregory’s lectures – but it has to be said that Knowles provided extensive printed synopses for her lecture courses. Along with William Cunningham’s Growth of English Industry and Commerce (1890) and Outlines of English Industrial History (1895), her recommended books included W.H.R. Curtler, A Short History of English Agriculture (1909), which Robbins read early in his first term.1 James Drummond Smith, a graduate of the University of Aberdeen, where he had lectured on economics for three years before the war, was a lecturer in commerce at LSE for only four years, leaving in 1924 to go into business. While he was at the School he was president of the students’ Christian Union. He was notionally Lionel’s supervisor in 1920–1; Lionel went to see him only once when ‘on revealing that I had no interest in games, [I] was told that I must come to tea with him one day, an invitation which, to my great relief, never materialized’ (1971a, 76). Abraham Wolf’s Logic course had been a feature of the undergraduate curriculum at LSE since 1905. Reader of Logic and Ethics, he held his post jointly at University College and LSE and continued to give his course at the School until his retirement in 1941. His published work includes several textbooks growing out of his lecture course (Wolf 1919, 1925, 1926, 1930) as well as studies and translations of Spinoza and a history of science, technology and philosophy. Lees-Smith on the British Constitution was another long-running feature: H.B. (Hastings Bernard) Lees-Smith had been on the staff as a lecturer in public administration since 1906. A Liberal member of Parliament in 1910–18, he was later, having joined the Labour Party in 1919, a Labour MP and Postmaster-General in the second Labour government 1929–31. His British Constitution course began with the doctrinal aspects of the subject, with J.S. Mill’s Representative Government (1861) and A.V. Dicey’s Law of the Constitution (8th edition, 1915) as essential reading. In the later part of the term he moved on to the working of the British Cabinet system, party government and Parliament in Britain.2 Robbins received his first teaching in economic theory from Hugh Dalton, who was already active in the Labour Party. (He has long been better known as a Labour MP, a junior minister in the second Labour goverment 1929–31 and Chancellor of the Exchequer in the third Labour government 1945–7.) 1
2
Synopsis for Economic History First Year 1760–Present Day, ms notes ‘Dr Knowles Michaelmas Term Lectures’ and ‘Notes on Curtler’s “A Short History of English Agriculture” ’, RP. Ms notes on ‘The British Constitution – Mr. Lees Smith’ in Public Administration (British). CENTRAL GOVERNMENT. The Constitution (Principles) notebook, RP; ms notes on ‘British Constitution. Prof. Lees Smith’, Plant 152, BLPES.
72
Lionel Robbins
Dalton had read economics at King’s College Cambridge in 1906–10 and worked as a research student at LSE before the war. He returned to the School, and joined the staff, in 1919 after serving as an artillery officer on the Italian front. In 1920 he (along with Gregory) became Reader in Commerce following the large benefaction from Sir Ernest Cassel and published his first book on The Inequality of Incomes based on his prewar research. He was an outstanding teacher: With his infectious vitality and his big booming voice, capable of drowning the noise of the cranes and excavators which disturbed the peace of the Bush House [building] site which was then where L.S.E. lectures were held, he could hold the attention of any audience, however miscellaneous. He had a splendid capacity for lucid exposition, with no undue fuss about inessentials and a strong perspective of salient relevant points (‘Lord Dalton’, 19 February 1962, Biographical Papers, RP).
Even after nine decades his lectures – as recorded in the notes of his students – have an appealing freshness and clarity. He was also unstuffy, genuinely interested in his students and readily accessible to them. In the early postwar years he was ‘particularly good at communicating with young men who shared his experience of war and his urgent desire to see that war should not happen again’ (Pimlott 1985, 135). In that first lecture on 8 October 1920 Robbins was introduced to the difficulties of defining the boundaries of economics. According to Plant’s notes (‘Elements of Economics Prof. Dalton’, Plant 153), Dalton gave three definitions of economics: (1) (Cannan) The aim of economics is the explanatn of the general causes on wh. the material welfare of human beings depends. (2) (Marshall) Economics is the study of man’s actions in the ordinary business of life. It enquires how he gets his income & how he uses it. (3) (Clay) Economics is the study of business in its social aspect, the word ‘business’ being used in its broadest sense to cover all lawful ways of making a living.
Comparing them, Dalton criticized Cannan’s definition for equating material welfare and economic welfare. In his second lecture Dalton indicated his attitude to economics, an attitude Robbins found particularly congenial in the state of mind in which he entered the School. Dalton told his students to be open-minded: ‘Be critical of existing organisations: but be equally critical of all plans to alter existing institutions.’ As he explained (in the words of Plant’s notes), ‘The great uncertainty is, how far is the existing system of society adequate, & how can it be made more adequate. In 20 yrs. time it will be different, owing
The London School of Economics
73
to experiments. First we must know all about existing systems, before we can alter them.’ Lectures were the main means of instruction for first year undergraduates. The ‘classes’ were in fact meetings of the lecture audiences where the lecturer or his assistants were available to answer questions. The students were also required to write short essays which were marked by the assistants. In 1920/1 a BSc(Econ) Intermediate student was supposed to write ‘at least five essays in Economic Theory; three each in Geography, Economic History and Public Administration; and one each in Currency and Banking, and Foreign Trade. He should not, however, attempt more than 20 essays or papers altogether on these subjects’, although he (or she) had also to write essays in logic or answer problem papers in mathematics, according to the minutes of the Professorial Council on 28 September 1921.3 In the Michaelmas term 1920 Dalton’s essay topics included: ‘What is economic welfare? Are there any exceptions to the general rule that an increase in econ. welf. is socially desirable?’ and ‘Discuss the adv.s & disadv.s of the division of labour.’ Unfortunately Robbins’s answers to these questions have not survived.4 In his first year at LSE Robbins lived in lodgings at 66 Denbigh Street, Pimlico. Here in the evenings he struggled to write undergraduate essays for the first time since his brief stay at UCL, having lost his youthful selfconfidence and being out of practice. He was still writing poetry, short pieces reflecting unsettled moods. At the end of his first week at LSE he contemplated ‘The Arc Lamp Reflections in the clammy autumnal streets./ An Orange in the dark, flawless pool’. A fortnight later he noted ‘Those pigeons I saw on the pavement/ Stars in my dark mental night’ and commenced a longer poem which began: ‘Here as the lamplight flicks on the whitewashed wall/ An unstable mood is maintained.’5 Some of his poems survived in ‘a sort of diary in which I used to jot down vindictive remarks about the universe’ (LCR to IEG, 27 May 1924). The entries are often obscure, only 3
4
5
The minutes of the Professorial Council (later expanded and renamed the Academic Board), the Court of Governors, the Emergency Committee (later the Standing Committee) which consisted of the director and a few governors, and other School committees are all in LSE MINUTES, BLPES. A few only of Robbins’s undergraduate essays remain in his papers. Some of his notes of Dalton’s ‘Elements’ lectures are there, although he later reorganized his lecture notes, reading notes and early drafts of papers in economics together in notebooks for particular topics (eg wages, population, capital). The lecture courses he attended, and the marks he received for some of his essays, are recorded in his LSE Student’s Dossier. The pieces are dated ‘9.20’, ‘23.10.20’ and ‘24.10.20’; the third uncompleted poem is reproduced with changes of punctuation in Robbins (1971a, 90).
74
Lionel Robbins
occasionally dated, and some have been obliterated or torn out, but they do record meetings with friends – and present a somewhat different picture of Robbins’s undergraduate days from that he portrayed in his autobiography. In his first months at the School he concentrated on his work. He read avidly, and much more than he needed to pass the Intermediate examinations, as he realized later. At the time of his twenty-second birthday he was ‘finding it all I can do to keep up with the day to day work of the class. The four year break is not so easy to surmount as I had hoped.’ At the same time he decided not to take advantage of the exemption from two papers he had just discovered his war service would allow: he wanted to get as much as he could out of his three years and knew he needed the spur of examinations to do so (LCR to Mother, November 1920). He continued, however, to see a good deal of his closest friends – Gardiner, Lawson, Rose, Davidge and Isaacs – and once he had survived his first term he began to spend more time outside lectures with his fellow students. Lawson returned from the Netherlands at the end of 1920, with a retainer from his employers in Haarlem, to continue to work in the film industry in London. He had decided to become a Roman Catholic and, having learned from John Polimeni of the Dominicans’ priory on Haverstock Hill, he was received into the Catholic Church by Father John-Baptist Reeves in February 1921. He then decided he wanted to become a lay-brother in the Dominican Order. Father J-B vetoed this for the time being but found him some editorial work for a Dominican house journal; when Father J-B moved to Oxford Reggie moved there in the summer of 1921. A year later he arranged for Reggie to join Eric Gill’s community at Ditchling Common, Sussex (Ginger 1991, 56–62). Lionel, on the other hand, was now settling comfortably into agnosticism. As he commented in his diary early in his second year at LSE, ‘One vindication of Agnosticism – If a god be worth believing in, it were a sin against him as much as against ourselves to believe in him before we have adequate proofs of his existence.’ Before Reggie went to Oxford he and Lionel were frequent companions, going to the circus at Olympia in January 1921, visiting the Misses Horton and Monk, going to dances. And, as Lionel enjoyed ‘communicating to others my rather naive enthusiasm on discovering things . . . I always used to talk more “shop” with Reggie than anyone else’ (LCR to IEG, 24 June 1924). Lionel was still a socialist. He was no longer convinced of the virtues of guild socialism, but Nathan Isaacs was nonetheless surprised he did not attend the special National Guilds League conference in December 1920 (Isaacs to LCR, ‘Thursday evening’ [16 December 1920], Personal letters from Iris & Clive etc, RP). He had serious doubts about the British labour
The London School of Economics
75
movement but he still believed in the desirability of an alternative to the capitalist system. By his own account he ‘Read every book [he could] lay hands on. Went [to] every lecture [and] discussion’ (‘Socialism’, Essays on Trade and the Depression, RP). The LSE student magazine, Clare Market Review, reported that the Socialist Society was revived in the Lent term 1921 with David Goodfellow as secretary, after inactivity in the Michaelmas term. Cole came to speak in March 1921; Orage and Douglas both promised to speak and did so later in the year. Basil Bunting organized a London University Social Credit study circle (Finlay 1972, 231, 250). Of one Socialist Society meeting Lionel wrote, cryptically, in his diary, ‘A meeting. Bunting and “absolute dictatorship”. The reassuring effect of proper names. Mr Tcherniakoff and the moon. Mr Goodfellow and the decay of empire. Coffee afterwards. I become “almost human”.’ Goodfellow and David Tcherniakoff were both fellow students for the BSc(Econ) Intermediate of whom Lionel saw a good deal during his first year.6 Lionel and Nathan Isaacs spent many long evenings together, often also with Joe Pole and Phoebe Rickards (later Mrs Pole). Nathan would argue for hours on philosophy – especially epistemology and scientific methodology judging by the comments in Robbins’s ‘diary’. Other evenings were spent with George Davidge: of one (unknown) episode with George and Elsie May his girlfriend, Lionel wrote that he was ‘so shaken out of my skin that I was almost natural – at any rate I have the recollection of being extremely and quite genuinely affable’. Passing Denbigh Street eighteen months later George remembered, ‘What a variety of queer things happened there, like parts of the threads of a Dostoieffsky novel.’ By then Davidge had unfortunately failed his finals at East London College and taken up supply teaching for the London County Council until he found a more permanent position, first at a private school in Margate in 1922 and later at an elementary school in Dover (Davidge to LCR, nd but probably autumn 1922, and other letters written in 1921–3 in Personal letters from Iris & Clive etc, RP). In the Lent and Summer terms 1921 the main lectures for first year students reading for the Intermediate examination continued. By the end of the Michaelmas term Knowles had reached the industrial revolution, LeesSmith was still talking about the UK parliamentary system, and Dalton had just started on the theory of value. Dalton had devoted a good deal of 6
Tcherniakoff, who had ‘strong communist leanings’ as a student, later earned a (poor) living teaching languages to Foreign Office officials: LCR to Carr-Saunders, 23 June 1952, Director Correspondence April 1946–Dec 54, RP. Goodfellow became a lecturer in economic history at the University of Cape Town (Goodfellow 1931).
76
Lionel Robbins
his first term’s lectures to explaining what economists mean by wealth and income, production, labour and productivity before discussing one of his favourite topics – population – including the determinants of the size of a population and the question of an optimum size of population. The lectures had become more technical at the end of term when Dalton introduced price theory.7 On 14 January Dalton opened the new term’s lectures by setting an essay ‘Is taxation in proportion to income taxation according to ability to pay?’ and spent the rest of that and most of the next lecture discussing the concept of saving. Marshallian supply and demand curves appeared in the third lecture of the term, followed a week later by competition and monopoly (with diagrams to illustrate monopoly pricing). The determinations of wages, interest and rent were then treated as applications of the theory of value in five lectures in February and March 1921, before Dalton turned to another favourite, the distribution of income. He continued with income distribution and the causes of inequality for the first five weeks of the Summer term and ended the course with four lectures on ‘Money’ – mainly a Marshallian treatment of the quantity theory of money and the price level. The final lecture on 24 June was a rushed affair concluding the discussion on exchange-rate determination and international trade (‘Elements of Economics Prof. Dalton’, Plant 153; LCR notes in ‘Distribution Earnings – Wages’ and ‘Economic Theory. Distribution’ notebook, RP). Lionel’s notebooks indicate that of Dalton’s recommended textbooks he read the American economist F.W. Taussig’s Principles of Economics as well as the introductory books by Edwin Cannan, Wealth and Money. Lees-Smith meanwhile had been concentrating on the ‘imperial aspects’ of the British Constitution – discussing federalism and the government of India, Egypt, Canada, Australia and South Africa and setting essays on ‘What light does the British Empire throw upon the problems of Federalism?’ and ‘What are the chief differences between the Federal Constitution of Canada and that of Australia?’ – until he returned to the workings of British central government in the middle of the Summer term. In the Lent term he also gave a shorter course on local government, covering the duties and responsibilities of the English local authorities, especially in education, health and the poor law (‘British Constitution. Prof. Lees Smith’, Plant 152, ‘Local Government. Prof. Lees-Smith M.A.’, Plant 241). Knowles continued with the industrialization of Britain in the Lent term. In the Summer 7
‘Elements of Economics Prof. Dalton’, Plant 153. LCR’s notes for Dalton’s lectures on population are in a notebook labelled: ‘Economic Theory. Production: Mechanics History of the Term Labour Land and Population’.
The London School of Economics
77
term she dealt with nineteenth-century factory and health legislation, the history of trade unionism and poor law legislation, and Britain’s move to free trade (printed syllabuses, Economic History: The Growth of English Industry Lectures by Dr. Knowles Lent Term and Economic History: First Year Summer Term, RP). Lionel also attended Gregory’s lectures on foreign trade and the foreign exchanges in the Lent term and his lectures on The Elements of Currency and Banking in the Summer term. From these he learnt a good deal of recent monetary history as well as the organization of the UK financial system. The issues Gregory raised were certainly topical. The pound sterling had been defined as a weight of silver, then of gold. Since 1914 it had been merely a piece of paper, in the form of a currency note issued by the UK Treasury. In 1918 the Cunliffe Committee on Currency and Foreign Exchanges after the War had recommended the restoration of an effective gold standard, and the phasing out of the Treasury notes, but the timing of the return had not been settled in 1921. By the vacation Lionel was ‘in very high spirits’. The term had been ‘ever so much more successful than last, from the work point of view at any rate, and in every subject but one I am now more or less up to date. I have made a good many new acquaintances lately as well and no longer find the School unsociable – indeed my chief difficulty is to contrive to turn down half the invitations etc. I receive without being offensive’ (LCR to Mother, 18 March 1921). Reggie Lawson was best man when Clive Gardiner married Lilian Lancaster at Easter 1921. After their marriage they held regular Saturday evening parties at 67a Marloes Road, Kensington. Of the people whom Lionel met at these and other gatherings his diary mentions, besides his old friends, Helen Rowe and a formidable and eccentric Miss George. Helen Rowe was a friend of the painter Nina Hamnett; Bunting was in love with her and may have lived with her for a short time. But, as Lionel recorded in his diary, by 1921 she had a child by Dr Hans Egli, who was also at LSE in 1919–21 and whom she married. Lionel did not identify her husband, but Bunting did when he wrote to Ezra Pound in December 1926. She was a fine writer, Bunting told Pound, ‘who was about to do good work, when she got married, produced three infants and became so taken up with domestic duties that I doubt whether she will ever make time to do anything.’8 Miss George is described (in Robbins’s ‘diary’ in early 1921) as disliking poetry 8
Information from Hamnett (1932, 322); Alldritt (1998, 27, where she is mistakenly called ‘Helen Moore’); Obituaries, LSE Magazine, Winter 2000, 38; and Bunting to Pound, 2 December 1926, Pound Collection, Beinecke Library.
78
Lionel Robbins
and having a hard head; a couple of years later, when she was a frequent guest at Clive and Lilian’s on Saturday evenings but still referred to as Miss George, Lionel remarked that he ‘could listen to [her] for almost ever’. By that time she had been speculating in the German mark, was contemplating attending lectures at LSE to learn more about finance and ‘had just written a prose tragedy’ (LCR to IEG, 7 October, 3 and 10 November 1923). Of women of his own age there is no mention in the diary that survives. In the Summer term Robbins was more confident and more cheerful than he had been when he entered LSE six months earlier. Less often did he find himself with ‘a mind suddenly paralyzed like my arm’, enjoying in May ‘A day of ecstatic mental clarity – Oh life giving sun’, although he recorded ‘dejection’ on 1 June (entries in his ‘diary’). Before the exams he was ‘rather tired’ and took himself off for a long weekend at the White Horse in Rottingdean to finish his revision. He passed the Intermediate examination in July without difficulty: before the results came out he thought he had not done badly in any subject except geography (which had bored him) (LCR to RRR, 30 June and 15 July 1921). Of ninety-five candidates sixty passed, including Bunting by dint of borrowing Lionel’s lecture notes (Professorial Council 28 September 1921; Robbins 1971a, 76). Lionel now had to decide on the subjects he would specialize in for the BSc(Econ) Final Honours course. He told his father on 15 July that he was thinking of taking the History of Political Ideas: ‘not perhaps so practical as some of the others but it is certainly more fitted to whatever specialized capacity I may possess . . . I feel that it is a subject at which I can work wholeheartedly and I have come to think that it is foolish to be “disobedient to the Heavenly vision”.’ In the meantime he was going to take a short holiday with Eddie and George before settling down at Hollycroft to try to learn German and ‘the easier forms of elementary mathematics’ during the vacation. Until its first reform the Final examination consisted of three compulsory papers in economics, history and public administration, two essay papers and four papers on one of ten special subjects. For the examination which Robbins would take in October 1923, the scheme was three compulsory papers in economics, one of which was an essay paper, one required paper in each of history and political science (political theory and public administration) and three in the candidate’s special subject. There was a language requirement: one of the papers in the special subject consisted of passages from French and German works for translation and comment (LSE Calendars 1921–2 and 1922–3). Robbins’s friends Plant and Goodfellow both took Economic History as their special subject, as had Benham and Caine a year earlier; Kahane (also a year earlier), Bunting and Tcherniakoff chose
The London School of Economics
79
Banking and Currency (Professorial Council 28 September 1921). Lionel chose the History of Political Ideas in spite of his enthusiasm for Dalton’s lectures and his interest in finance as taught by Gregory. He would have to take plenty of economics and currency and banking anyway, and, as he put it in the 1930s, he was still searching for the holy grail of ‘a body of serious thinkers or at any rate literature justifying confidence [in the socialist] diagnosis & the absence of reservations [in the] remedies suggested to ignorant followers’ (‘Socialism’, Essays on Trade and the Depression, RP). Still later (1971a, 80) he explained his choice as ‘offer[ing] more scope for the wide reading of the great international literature in which the leading minds of the past had explored the possibilities of alternative patterns of political society’. It was also the case that his marks in essays for Knowles and Lees-Smith had been better than those in economics. As there were only five lectures a week (plus some classes) for the compulsory papers there were plenty of choices to be made of other lectures to attend. The possibilities were increased by the fact that most lecture courses were delivered twice, in the day and in the evening. Robbins’s choices meant that in each of the two years he read a good deal of economic theory, of history, economic and political, and of political philosophy; in his second year he took public administration from both Lees-Smith and Wallas; and in his third year he went to Gregory’s advanced courses in currency and banking. For his second year at LSE Lionel found himself ‘an exceedingly clean, convenient and inexpensive, unfurnished room’ at 94a Guilford Street, just south of Mecklenburg Square. He was to live there for three years. It was on the top floor of ‘a five storey basement lodging house’, which has since been demolished. (The building was on the site of what is now Goodenough College.) From his window he had a view of brick walls and water piping and above them the ‘gentle and gracious . . . foliage’ of the plane trees in Mecklenburg Square. He had a gas-fire (with a meter) but no bath; a housekeeper cleaned the rooms and provided breakfast for each of the lodgers. By January 1922 he was well ensconced and had bought fabric so that his sister Caroline could make curtains for him. He had also acquired a ticket to the Reading Room of the British Museum.9 He was quite comfortable living on the money his father had given him for his three years at LSE: he admitted to himself (‘Property I Autobiographical Preface’, RP) that ‘I like good clothes and enjoy motoring when I can get it but I do not 9
LCR to RRR, 28 September 1921, 14 and 31 January 1922. His LSE Student’s Dossier provides the address; a diary entry the view; and the description of the accommodation comes from ‘Property, I Autobiographical Preface’, RP, and LCR to IEG, 24 October 1923.
80
Lionel Robbins
crave for it’ and would have liked to buy more books but could manage quite well with the British Museum Library near at hand. Looking further ahead (from June 1922) he thought he would be ‘quite happy so far as material comfort goes if by teaching and writing articles and books now and then I can make up my income to about £500 p.a. I should like to keep a horse and a good cupboard of still wines but I shall not grieve unduly without them.’ At weekends he often went home to Hollycroft – and there, as his sister Nancy remembered, he enjoyed the central heating and the bath tub. In the summer of 1921 there occurred the socalled ‘great betrayal’ of the farmers by the Lloyd George government which, having promised the farmers guaranteed minimum prices for wheat and oats in the Agriculture Act 1920, walked away from its promise at the moment it was to take effect and introduced a bill to repeal the Act. The government hoped to buy off the farmers by offering deficiency payments for the current harvest of wheat and oats which would be somewhat lower than those which would have been paid under the Act, as well as by abolishing the Agricultural Wages Board with its power to set a national minimum agricultural wage (Whetham 1974, 45–9). As president of the NFU Lionel’s father was approached by the Minister of Agriculture, now Sir Arthur Griffith-Boscawen, as early as May 1921, to try to find a basis for an agreement. At a secret meeting in June, Robbins bluntly told him: ‘Although you have admitted that having regard to the changed circumstances in which the Government find themselves today, the Government find themselves in a hopelessly weak position, our position with the Government is pretty strong. . . . You remember I said I hoped I should find you in a very generous mood when we met. The whole thing depends on what you are prepared to offer. . . . We are hoping you will pay 19/- in the £.’10 A special NFU Council meeting on 22 June congratulated Robbins ‘for the most able way he had looked after their interests’ (NFU AD1/3). As Griffith-Boscawen (1925, 236) remarked, ‘The fact is that many farmers were more anxious to be free from control than they were to have the subsidy.’ The results – grants of £4 per acre for oats and £3 per acre for wheat plus £1 m for education and research – were announced at the 20 July Council meeting, when Robbins reported on the continuing difficult negotiations over the abolition of the Agricultural Wages Board, which the 10
Minutes of a Conference with the National Farmers’ Union held in the Minister’s Room at 10, Whitehall Place, S.W. on Tuesday, 7th June, 1921, at 3 p.m., MAF53/12, TNA. PenningRowsell (1997) pointed out that ‘if anyone, it was the farm worker who was betrayed by a secret deal between the government and the National Farmers Union which paid farmers a bounty in exchange for their acceptance of the policy reversal. Farm workers received nothing in compensation for the demise of the Wages Board.’
The London School of Economics
81
farmers wanted but the farmworkers did not. The strain told on him: at the Council meeting on 24 August it was reported that he was seriously ill (NFU AD1/3). It was some months before he was fully recovered. A short convalescence at Folkestone in September 1921 was not enough and he was eventually persuaded to take a holiday in the south of France in January and February 1922 (LCR to RRR, 27 and 28 September 1921; AGM 1 February 1922, NFU AD1/4). While his father and stepmother were away Lionel went down at weekends to Hollycroft where the younger children were being looked after by one of their aunts. He wrote his parents in January 1922 that he ‘spen[t] all day and a good part of the evening at the School nowadays . . . Apart from work which daily becomes more fascinating nothing much of any importance has happened [there].’ On 4 February he told them: ‘I have been working very hard at Economic theory lately: the amount of work to be done sometimes seems overwhelming but I suppose I make some progress. Laski’s classes provide the most entertaining diversion but for the most part I find myself in substantial agreement with him so that they are not so stimulating as they might be if I really detested his principles. Clive is away every weekend nowadays so I see nothing of him and Reggie’s work absorbs every moment between waking and sleeping – even on Sundays when he distributes Catholic literature.’ On 6 March he reported to his father that he was ‘extremely fit but very busy with a new essay on Ultramontanism which has to be finished by next Thursday’ and on the 14th that ‘After an Homeric struggle against time I finished my paper . . . and read it before the History class . . . It was quite well received and as a piece of writing I think it is probably the best thing I have done.’ The centrepiece of economics teaching for the Final of the BSc(Econ) in the early 1920s was the two-year course on the Principles of Economics given by the Professor of Political Economy, Edwin Cannan. Cannan had been teaching at the School since its foundation, although he lived in Oxford where he had been a student at Balliol, and had been professor since 1907. To Robbins in his first year ‘old Cannan’ was ‘a short, bearded man in exceedingly shabby clothes [seen] threading his way through the refectory to his seat at high table’. At the beginning of his second year, on 4 October 1921, he attended one of Cannan’s lectures for the first time (Robbins 1935f, 393–4). For some reason or other he was wearing his doctor’s cap: . . . The cap was perched at a jaunty angle on his head and his mood was in harmony with the cap. The lecture dealt with the Physiocratic theory of distribution. Cantillon, Mercier de la Rivi`ere, Dupont de Nemours, Quesnay, all pronounced in a highly anglicised
82
Lionel Robbins
manner . . . rapidly appeared on the stage without any preliminary comment. Passages were read aloud, much too rapidly for assimilation and annotation. . . . Followed a lengthy and not always audible discussion of the derivation and uses of the word distribution. All sorts of people had used it in different senses. It was not quite clear at the time which sense the lecturer favoured. And so on. I was in complete despair and so were the rest of us who were beginning. But the third-year people who had already had a year of it appeared to be highly edified. So . . . we kept on. It was not easy.
One problem was that Cannan mumbled into his beard – but this could be overcome by sitting in the front two rows with the third year students as Robbins soon learned to do. Another was that Cannan always ‘went straight to the point whether simple or difficult. There was no preliminary statement of what he proposed to do. No summary of what he had done. He expected you to find that out for yourself.’ And it was a two-year course, the first devoted to Production and Value, the second to Distribution: if you came in in a Distribution year, as Robbins did, you were implicitly assumed to be acquainted with the previous year’s lectures on Production and Value. Lionel got round this problem in the Easter vacation when he borrowed Frederic Benham’s notes, ‘collated them with my own, copied out the passages from the classics I had missed and wrote the whole thing out up to date in longhand. Then daylight began to appear.’ Robbins’s notebooks survive: they are indeed neatly written, in the handwriting he adopted near the end of 1921, and they are interspersed with notes on his reading of recommended books and articles.11 Cannan’s lectures were very different in their scope and intention from the standard textbooks of his day, such as Alfred Marshall’s Principles of Economics. He was concerned mainly with critical examination of the theories of the English classical economists, especially Adam Smith but also Ricardo, Malthus and J.S. Mill, and discussed the origins of the concepts of economic theory in their work at length before outlining modern theory in a nontechnical way (no diagrams or other mathematics). Hence the focus was ‘not an elaboration of the working of the price system as we would expect from a survey course in economic theory . . . [but] instead a re-examination of Adam Smith’s central theme – “the origin and causes of the wealth of nations”’ though with more concern than Smith had for the question of the distribution of wealth (Bernard Corry, ‘Introduction’, Cannan 1964, xvi). 11
The notes are almost never dated; but the change of handwriting, when he dropped the ε’s adopted while working for Greenwood, can be dated from his notes of another course of lectures he attended that year (Wolf on the History of Philosophy) which show the change in handwriting occurred between 17 November and 15 December 1921.
The London School of Economics
83
However, since his references to Marshall were almost as frequent as those to Smith and Mill his students had to come to terms with the Principles if only to understand Cannan’s criticisms. Lionel inherited Cannan’s interest in the history of economic thought but fortunately not his lecturing style. Offering his son Richard advice on lecturing many years later he told him to do everything Cannan had not done: to plan each lecture in advance, to be clear at the outset on the main points to be covered, to recapitulate the last lecture before beginning the next and so on (LCR to Richard Robbins, nd but 1946 or 1947). Harold Laski, who supervised the special subject in the History of Political Ideas, was born in Manchester in 1893. Educated at Manchester Grammar School and New College Oxford, he had been on the faculty at Harvard for six years before he came to LSE in 1920. He had made his name as a political theorist with three books (1917, 1919, 1920) and was about to publish his fourth (1921). He was a man of the left, although not as far to the left of the Labour Party as he became in the 1930s. A pluralist in political philosophy, he had been sympathetic to guild socialist ideas. When Robbins met him for supervision, in the autumn of 1921, Laski gave him a list of about a hundred standard works on political thought, a large number of which provided Robbins’s main reading in the next two years. The reading was more important than Laski’s lectures, judging from the contents of Robbins’s notebooks. Other, later students have remembered Laski’s lectures as ‘always memorable for starting with phrases such as “Well, I just saw the PM yesterday”’ (Nadine Marshall reported by Berg 1996, 155). Robbins attended the lectures on the History of Political Ideas required for all BSc(Econ) Final students, which in 1921/2 Laski offered in the Lent and Summer terms. In only fifteen lectures the course was to cover, according to the LSE Calendar, Greek and Roman political ideas, the political ideas of the early Church, mediaeval political ideas, the Reformation, Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau, the French Revolution and the nineteenth century. There was also a class in the subject in the same terms. A few of Robbins’s essays for Laski survive