Learning Communities In Practice
EXPLORATIONS OF EDUCATIONAL PURPOSE Volume 4 Series Editors Joe L. Kincheloe, Canada...
75 downloads
2200 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Learning Communities In Practice
EXPLORATIONS OF EDUCATIONAL PURPOSE Volume 4 Series Editors Joe L. Kincheloe, Canada Research Chair of Critical Pedagogy, McGill University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada Shirley R. Steinberg, Montreal, Canada Editorial Board Barrie Barrell, Memorial University of Newfoundland, Canada Rochelle Brock, University of Indiana, Gary, USA Stephen Petrina, University of British Columbia, Canada Christine Quail, State University of New York, Oneonta, USA Nelson Rodriguez, College of New Jersey, USA Leila Villaverde, University of North Carolina, Greensboro, USA John Willinsky, Stanford University, USA
Series Scope
In today’s dominant modes of pedagogy, questions about issues of race, class, gender, sexuality, colonialism, religion, and other social dynamics are rarely asked. Questions about the social spaces where pedagogy takes place - in schools, media, and corporate think tanks - are not raised. And they need to be. The Explorations of Educational Purpose book series can help establish a renewed interest in such questions and their centrality in the larger study of education and the preparation of teachers and other educational professionals. The editors of this series feel that education matters and that the world is in need of a rethinking of education and educational purpose. Coming from a critical pedagogical orientation, Explorations of Educational Purpose aims to have the study of education transcend the trivialization that often degrades it. Rather than be content with the frivolous, scholarly lax forms of teacher education and weak teaching prevailing in the world today, we should work towards education that truly takes the unattained potential of human beings as its starting point. The series will present studies of all dimensions of education and offer alternatives. The ultimate aim of the series is to create new possibilities for people around the world who suffer under the current design of socio-political and educational institutions.
For other titles published in this series, go to http://www.springer.com/series/7472
Anastasia P. Samaras • Anne R. Freese Clare Kosnik • Clive Beck Editors
Learning Communities In Practice
Editors Anastasia P. Samaras George Mason University Fairfax, VA USA
Clare Kosnik Ontario Institute for Studies in Education University of Toronto, ON Canada
Anne R. Freese University of Hawai’i Honolulu, HI USA
Clive Beck Ontario Institute for Studies in Education University of Toronto, ON Canada
ISBN: 978-1-4020-8787-5
e-ISBN: 978-1-4020-8788-2
Library of Congress Control Number: 2008932852 © 2008 Springer Science + Business Media B.V. No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording or otherwise, without written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work. Printed on acid-free paper 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 springer.com
To Costa, Gabriella, Lucas, Amelia, Athena, Rohan, and Lucia To Ralph, Jim, Julie, Jason, Amanda, and Alexis To Bertha and Tony To David, Neil, and Trixie
“This is an extraordinary collection of theoretically sound and practical ideas for teachers and teacher educators. The authors present fascinating accounts of down-to-earth practices tested in experience. Priceless!” Nel Noddings Lee Jacks Professor of Education Emerita, Stanford University “This book provides a wealth of information on how learning communities function in practice and, more importantly, how they are sustained over time. The chapter authors document a wide array of international programs located in different institutional settings, including cross-institutional and crossnational programs. I recommend this book for both university-based and school or district-based educators who are serious about improving instruction based on locally available data.” Renée T. Clift Professor University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign “As the title announces, this wide-ranging collection of chapters shows learning communities actually at work, as their members– in schools, universities, and professional networks – describe what got them started and what keeps them going, despite the wider educational community’s general lack of support. Common to all chapters is a strong awareness of the benefits of learning communities not only for the teachers and researchers who share, critique and improve their own professional activities, but also for the students they teach; indeed, in several cases, the authors’ classrooms also metamorphosed into powerful communities of student coresearchers. Thus, for those who have been involved in a learning community such as those described here, the answer to the question the editors pose, “Are learning communities essential in education?” the answer is an unequivocal “Yes.” Hopefully, this book will enable others to see why this is so; it will certainly provide guidance for those who decide to embark on the kinds of journey that are so eloquently and persuasively presented in all the different sections of this book.” Gordon Wells Professor of Education University of California, Santa Cruz
vii
Acknowledgments
Our many thanks to Joe L. Kincheloe, Series Editor, for his brilliant conception of the need for this book and his generous invitation to us to serve as editors. His professional leadership and advice, informed by his many years of innovative writing and publishing experience, along with his good sense of humor, are very much appreciated. A book of this magnitude and scope would not be possible without the contributions and support of many individuals working collaboratively. Marianna Pascale, Assistant to Senior Publishing Editor Education, and Harmen van Paradijs, Senior Publishing Editor Education, Springer, have kindly and patiently responded to our many questions as they guided us through the publishing process with excellent efficiency. Our gratitude is extended to each of the book authors for taking the time to write about and share their work so others might benefit from its application in their educational setting. We appreciate their cooperation and professionalism – from their early manuscripts to their final chapters. We would like to also acknowledge the participants in the schools, universities, and professional networks included in these chapters whose dedicated and innovative work in building learning communities made these stories possible.
ix
Contents
Acknowledgments .........................................................................................
ix
An Invitation To Learning Communities In Practice ................................ Anastasia P. Samaras, Anne R. Freese, Clare Kosnik, and Clive Beck
xv
Part I Learning Communities in School Settings Introduction .................................................................................................... Anne R. Freese 1
2
3
4
5
The Project for Enhancing Effective Learning (PEEL): 22 Years of Praxis .................................................................................... Ian Mitchell and Judie Mitchell DICEP: Promoting Collaborative Inquiry in Diverse Educational Settings ................................................................................ Barbara Bell-Angus, Greta Davis, Zoe Donoahue, Maria Kowal, and Monica McGlynn-Stewart Pre-Service Teachers and Sixth Graders Explore Social Justice as a Community of Inquiry ....................................................... Monica Taylor and Gennifer Otinsky Lights, Camera, Action! Using Slowmation as a Common Teaching Approach to Promote a School Learning Community .............................................................................................. Garry F. Hoban Growing Our Own: A Learning Community Partnership between a University and a Public Middle School ............................... Cristy Kessler and Caroline S. Wong
3
7
19
31
45
59
xi
xii
Contents
6 A Whole-School Approach to Urban Educational Renewal: Community, Collaboration, and Leadership ...................................... Clive Beck, Clare Kosnik, and Yiola Cleovoulou
73
Part II Learning Communities in University Settings Introduction .................................................................................................... Anastasia P. Samaras 7
8
9
10
Fellow Travelers: New Teachers and Their Graduate School Faculty Take a Journey to the Land of Peer Discussion Groups.................................................................................. Barbara Stern Establishing a Learning Community as a Site to Explore Our Multicultural Selves ....................................................................... Anne R. Freese and Amber P. Strong Dissertation Support Groups: Building a Community of Practice Using Noddings’ Ethic of Care ......................................... Emily J. Klein, Megan Riordan, Amanda Schwartz, and Stacey Sotirhos Collective Creativity: A Learning Community of Self-Study Scholars............................................................................ Anastasia P. Samaras, Mary Adams-Legge, Deanna Breslin, Kavita Mittapalli, Jennifer Magaha O’Looney, and Dawn Renee Wilcox
87
89
103
117
133
Part III Learning Communities in Professional Networks Introduction .................................................................................................... Clare Kosnik and Clive Beck
151
11 A Learning Community for Teacher Induction .................................. Ellen Moir and Susan Hanson
155
12
13
Creating an International Learning Community for Teacher Education Scholars ........................................................... Melissa L. Heston, Deborah L. Tidwell, and Linda M. Fitzgerald Role of Teacher Research Communities and Cross-Culture Collaboration in the Context of Curriculum Reform in China..................................................................................... Gaalen Erickson, Chanyung Kang, Ian Mitchell, and Janette Ryan
165
179
Contents
14
15
16
Creating Stages for Development: A Learning Community with Many Tasks and No Goal ............................................................. Lois Holzman Supervisors of Teacher Interns: Building a Learning Community Through Inquiry-Based Practices................................... Patricia S. Tate, Marian H. Jarrett, Ann C. Lawlor, Lois M. Page, and Anita S. Ramsey
xiii
193
205
Funny, This Does Not Look Like a Community: Working Collaboratively Across Borders and Institutions ............... Clare Kosnik
219
About the Authors..........................................................................................
231
Author Index ..................................................................................................
241
Subject Index ..................................................................................................
245
An Invitation To Learning Communities In Practice Anastasia P. Samaras, Anne R. Freese, Clare Kosnik, and Clive Beck
We invite you to explore the very questions we asked ourselves when we decided to write this book. “Are learning communities essential in education?” “How are learning communities designed and developed?” “What difference do learning communities make in learning?” Most would agree that a learning community of practice cultivates social and intellectual development, but what are the other benefits and what does a learning community actually look like in practice? In this book, we invite you to read the contributions of authors who describe how they designed and implemented learning communities in their professional settings. Although there have been multiple theories generated by educators about the importance of learning communities of practice, there is limited information about the impact they are making in various educational contexts and on national and international levels. More specifically, this book addresses some key questions we have ourselves regarding learning communities: • • • •
How can community support learning? What are attributes of effective learning communities? Must all communities have the same attributes? How does a learning community affect the teachers, students, and/or facilitator and its participants? • What is the place of community in schools, in teacher education, and in academia? • What are the barriers to forming communities? • How are successful learning communities developed and sustained? A range of writers have advocated community. Paley (1992), in her work with young children, stresses the need for structures and practices which make a class an inclusive, supportive community for all. What do those structures and practices look like in school and university settings? In their work in school settings, Meier (1995) and Wasley (1994) argue that we need to create a common school culture with smaller schools so teachers can work together and so teachers and students can get to know each other. How does one build and share a common school culture? Wells (1994, p. ix), in his work in university settings, advocates the creation of communities of inquiry in which “knowledge is co-constructed through action, reflection, and collaborative talk.” In studies of higher education, Lenning and xv
xvi
A.P. Samaras et al.
Ebbers (1999) note that both students and faculty benefit from their work in learning communities. Their research supports the view that learning communities can be effective for impacting students’ academic achievement and satisfaction with college life, improving cooperation and curricular integration among faculty colleagues, and renewing learning and teaching in university settings. And yet, a walk through many school and university hallways will verify that learning communities are still not commonplace in schooling. Graves (1992, p. 60) notes: “When I first sought to introduce the concept [of community], many teachers I worked with considered such efforts a diversion from the real purpose of the school, or assumed that community feelings would develop automatically as students studied together in small groups.” Most recently, a video appeared on youtube depicting complaints of how college students felt anonymous and disconnected to their learning and were not a part of a learning community (Wesch and Students, Kansas State University, 2007). This disparity between theory and practice was the very impetus for writing this book – to share with you the work of practitioners and scholars who have used theories to inform their practice in designing and implementing learning communities and have also generated theories from their practice. The authors openly share the challenges they faced and the lessons they learned along the way, on a conceptual and practical level. The notion of community is a conceptually appealing one because it suggests a comfortable, socially supportive context. Yet community can do much more than create a friendly environment. It can support learning. Community is not simply an add-on. Rather, it can be an integral and powerful force in learning. Educational trends come and go, however, one that continues to be discussed, questioned, supported, and examined is the notion of learning communities. In their book on a social constructivist approach to building learning communities in teacher education, Beck and Kosnik (2006, p. 74) state: “We wish to stress at the outset that, in a social constructivist view, community is not just a frill: it is fundamental to effective learning.” Dewey expressed this belief in the early 1900s when he said, “We never educate directly, but indirectly by means of the environment” (1916, p. 32); and when he stated “education is essentially a social process. This quality is realized in the degree in which individuals form a community group” (1938, p. 58). Perhaps the question of “What is community?” is one of the most difficult questions to answer. Defining learning communities, especially given the range of educational settings, can be challenging. In examining this complex question about community and learning, we considered the writing of Grossman et al. (2001, p. 942) who argued that “the word community has lost its meaning. From the prevalence of terms such as ‘communities of learners,’ ‘discourse communities,’ and ‘epistemic communities’ to ‘school community,’ ‘teacher community,’ or ‘communities of practice,’ it is clear that community has become an obligatory appendage to every educational innovation.” We believe there is truth to their position: the term is often used as a “buzzword” where, in fact, community may not actually exist. However, educators who strive to form genuine learning communities in their programs do so because they feel the
An Invitation To Learning Communities In Practice
xvii
community will support students’ often-difficult transitions in learning. These educators are not interested in a fad because building community is very labor-intensive requiring a real commitment of time and effort. We also believe that there is much promise for educational reform through incorporating learning with community. Regardless of the setting – in schools, universities, and professional networks – community has a place and is the place where learning occurs. In order to make the broad topic of learning community both accessible and applicable, we have structured the book into three sections: • Learning Communities in School Settings • Learning Communities in University Settings • Learning Communities in Professional Networks Our decades of collaborative scholarship have inspired us to share the work of our colleagues with you. Each of us has taught in various educational contexts and we have had the privilege of working in professional learning communities. During our decades of work, we have thought deeply about the complexity of learning communities. We have worked to co-construct learning communities in teacher education programs and have conducted action research and self-study to assess our impact (Kosnik & Beck, 2006; Freese, 1999; Samaras et al., 2006). We have experienced a learning community first hand as long-time participants in The Self-Study of Teacher Education Practices (S-STEP) Special Interest Group (SIG) of the American Education Research Association which you will read about in this book. In earlier work, we wrote: For self-study teacher educators, the self-study of teaching community might be characterized as a communitas or a professional community where there are strong feelings of social togetherness and belongingness, often with rituals of practice. The S-STEP SIG has fostered a sense of intellectual safety in a non-competitive and highly supportive culture; much like what we encourage teachers to do in their classrooms. It is a culture that professes that individuals can make a larger impact on advancing teacher education when they work together in a trusting, supportive, and inclusive environment. (Samaras & Freese, 2006, p. 18)
We have witnessed individuals working valiantly to build community in their specific contexts and now share their stories and insights with you. In the chapters that follow, the authors describe their very innovative approaches for establishing learning communities and provide specific examples of learning communities to show what they may look like in practice. The contributing authors have been instrumental in building a learning community and impacting learning. They share with you the “what,” “how,” and “why” of learning communities. You will find rich descriptions of their learning communities including their goals, design, implementation, and the impact of their efforts. The actual work in building a learning community in practice, and not just of practice, gives them lived experience and knowledge which they willingly share with you. We asked the authors to consider the following questions: • What was your learning community and what did it involve? Can you describe its context, goals, and design?
xviii
A.P. Samaras et al.
• How does your learning community actually work? What is the theory and the practice behind it? • What difference did it make? What has been its impact for students, programs, the university, and/or the community? • Discuss the challenges you faced and your suggestions for implementation. This book, which combines both scholarly research and practical information, will be useful to teachers, student teachers, school and university administrators, and teacher and community educators. Descriptions of how the communities were formed and the benefits of this work will assist others interested in both understanding and developing learning communities in their own settings. We wish you the best in your work in building learning communities and join with you in continuing that collective and very important endeavor of supporting learning through community.
References Beck, C. & Kosnik, C. (2006). Innovations in preservice teacher education: A social constructivist approach. Albany, NY: SUNY. Boyer, E. L. (1987). College. The undergraduate experience in America. New York: Harper & Row. Costa, A., Bellanca, J., & Fogarty, J. (Eds.). (1992). If minds matter: A forward to the future. Palatine, IL: Skylight Publishing. Dewey, J. (1916). Democracy and education: An introduction to the philosophy of education. New York: The Free Press. Dewey, J. (1938). Experience and education. New York: Collier-Macmillan. Freese, A. R. (1999). The role of reflection on preservice teachers’ development in the context of a professional development school. Teaching and Teacher Education, 15(8), 895–910. Graves, L. N. (1992). Cooperative learning communities: Context for a new vision of education and society. Journal of Education, 174(2), 57–78. Grossman, P., Wineburg, S., & Woolworth, S. (2001). Toward a theory of teacher community. Teachers College Record, 103(6), 942–1012. Kosnik, C. & Beck, C. (2006). The impact of a preservice teacher education program on language arts teaching practices: A study of second-year teachers. In C. Kosnik, C. Beck, A. R. Freese, & A. P. Samaras (Eds.), Making a difference in teacher education through self-study: Studies of personal, professional, and program renewal (pp. 243–259). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer. Lenning, O. T. & Ebbers, L. H. (Eds.). (1999). The powerful potential of learning communities. Washington, DC: ERIC Clearinghouse on Higher Education and The George Washington University. Meier, D. (1995). The power of their ideas. Boston, MA: Beacon Press. Paley, V. (1992). You can’t say you can’t play. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Samaras, A. P. & Freese, A. R. (2006). Self-study of teaching practices. NY: Peter Lang. Samaras, A. P., DeMulder, E. K., Kayler, M. A., Newton, L., Rigsby, L. C., Weller, K. L., & Wilcox, D. R. (2006). Spheres of learning in teacher collaboration. In C. Kosnik, C. Beck, A. R. Freese, & A. P., Samaras (Eds.), Making a difference in teacher education through selfstudy: Studies of personal, professional, and program renewal (pp. 147–163). The Netherlands: Springer.
An Invitation To Learning Communities In Practice
xix
Wasley, P. (1994). Stirring the chalkdust: Tales of teachers changing classroom practice. New York: Teachers College Press. Wells, G. (1994). Changing schools from within: Creating communities of inquiry. Toronto/ Portsmouth, NH: OISE Press/Heinemann. Wesch, M. and Students, Kansas State University. (2007, Spring). A vision of students today. Retrieved November 13, 2007, from http://youtube.com/watch?v=dGCJ46vyR9o
Part I
Learning Communities in School Settings
Introduction Anne R. Freese
Wenger (1998) offers the following three important elements of a “community of practice”: “1) mutual engagement, 2) a joint enterprise, and 3) a shared repertoire” (p. 73). Barth (1990) envisioned a school where the teachers talked with one another about their practice, observed one another, engaged in teaching and learning activities, and shared their teaching and instructional strategies with one another in order to become more skillful teachers. Wenger and Barth’s descriptions nicely frame the characteristics of the learning communities included in this section. The six chapters focus on learning communities in elementary and secondary schools in a wide variety of contexts, including schools in Australia, Canada, and the USA. In this section, the authors provide examples that compare and contrast different types of learning communities. They discuss learning communities that have been in existence for a long time, as contrasted with learning communities that are in their early stages of development. In spite of the great diversity of contexts and longevity, there are a number of common themes that are found across the chapters. We see teacher educators sharing their knowledge and skills, working with strong principals and teacher leaders, and developing and implementing learning communities within and across the schools. We see examples of learning communities in which teacher educators and teachers engage in research with a focus on how students are learning and thinking in the classroom. The chapters describe the essential elements that contribute to the various learning communities, such as a shared vision and goals, and a shared commitment to accomplish these goals. The chapters document how the learning communities were formed, how they were designed and implemented, and discuss the impact of the community on student learning. And finally, the chapters provide useful examples and practical suggestions for implementing learning communities in very diverse settings. Chapter 1, by Ian and Judie Mitchell, explains how a learning community that began as a “bottom up” initiative in an Australian high school in 1985 has developed into a network of over 600 teachers from nearly 200 schools. The chapter provides examples of how teachers in this learning community have become “interdependent innovators,” problematizing and reflecting on their practice, sharing concerns and new ideas, as well as successes and failures. The chapter highlights A.P. Samaras et al. (eds.) Learning Communities In Practice, © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2008
3
4
A.R. Freese
the importance of collaborative action research and the importance of establishing a sense of ownership among the teachers. Chapter 2, by Bell-Angus et al., describes the development and growth of a learning community comprised of teacher researchers who collaboratively promote inquiry as a key mode of learning among themselves, and with their students in a variety of educational contexts. The evolution of the group is examined through a self-study in which members discuss how the community has been transformative for both the teachers and their students. In the chapter, the authors include six key goals for establishing and sustaining a learning community of teacher researchers. The authors also share key findings regarding the development, and the challenges and benefits, of sustaining a learning community over an extended period of time. Chapter 3, by Taylor and Otinsky, documents a 6-year professional development partnership between a university and middle school. The authors share how a university professor and social studies teacher worked collaboratively to develop a community of inquiry in which pre-service teachers and sixth graders learned side by side about issues of social justice. The authors include suggestions for educators who hope to develop a community of inquiry involving pre-service teachers and middle school students. They provide insight into the importance of teacher/learner reciprocity whereby the participants share the role of teachers and learners as they negotiate activities and collaboratively engage in their community of inquiry. Chapter 4, by Hoban, describes how a school learning community was initiated and developed when the teachers at an elementary school in Australia were introduced to a novel teaching approach based on digital animation. The author shares how the teachers embarked on a 9-month professional learning program with the goal of interacting as a community and supporting each other in using the innovative teaching approach called “Slowmation.” The conditions for teacher learning and the process and outcomes of forming the community of teacher learners are documented. Chapter 5, by Kessler and Wong, documents the collaboration between a middle school and university and discusses how the partnership supports site-based teacher preparation and quality professional development. The authors discuss the importance of several key elements that contributed to the success of their learning community. The elements include: a shared vision, continuous dialogue between the principal and university professor, a sense of community among faculty, collaborative research, and an emphasis on research-based best practices. Chapter 6, by Beck et al., offers a case study of an educational reform effort that focused on a “whole school approach” in an urban elementary school in Toronto. The chapter provides a snapshot of how a principal and teachers in a multicultural school developed and implemented a shared vision of teaching and learning together to promote success for all. Working closely together, they shared strategies, resources, and engaged in joint teaching and projects. The approach emphasized building a professional community among the staff with a focus on a shared vision for the school and collaboration among the staff as a means of promoting school renewal.
Introduction
5
References Barth, R. (1990). Improving schools from within: Teachers, parents, and principals can make a difference. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Wenger, E. (1998). Communities of practice: learning, meaning, and identity. Cambridge: University Press.
Chapter 1
The Project for Enhancing Effective Learning (PEEL): 22 Years of Praxis Ian Mitchell and Judie Mitchell
Background and Description The learning community that constitutes PEEL was founded at one working-class high school in Melbourne, Australia, in 1985 by a group of teachers and academics who shared concerns about the prevalence of passive, unreflective, dependent student learning, even in apparently successful lessons. The project was not funded or driven by any system or institution-level initiative. In our first book (Baird & Mitchell, 1986, p. 12), we listed four goals for the project: 1. To foster effective, independent learning through training for enhanced metacognition 2. To change teacher attitudes and behaviours to ones that promote such learning 3. To investigate processes of teacher and student change as participants engage in action research 4. To identify factors that influence successful implementation of a programme that aims to improve the quality of students’ learning It was unusual at that time both for teachers to be engaged in research and to be focusing on how students were learning and thinking in the classroom. The ideas for PEEL had come from several sources. Ian’s research in conceptual change in science had strengthened his views on constructivism as an important construct for understanding learning. The concept of metacognition (Flavell, 1976) was becoming more widely recognised as a necessary skill for the learners of the future. Barnes’ (1976) work on student talk and classroom communication, and his frame of transmissive versus interpretive teaching, had also informed Ian’s thinking. Ian then attended a conference session in which John Baird reported on his doctoral research (Baird, 1984, 1986). He argued first that most learners exhibit what he called ‘poor learning tendencies’ that inhibit their learning. The list of teacher concerns in Table 1.1 reflects what Baird has identified as poor learning tendencies. His second argument was that it seemed likely that these could be countered by the I. Mitchell and J. Mitchell Monash University
A.P. Samaras et al. (eds.) Learning Communities In Practice, © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2008
7
8
I. Mitchell, J. Mitchell Table 1.1 A list of teacher concerns 1. Students rarely contribute ideas 2. Students do not think about the meaning of what they read or hear 3. Students do not link different lessons 4. Students do not think about why or how they are doing a task 5. Teachers find negotiations difficult 6. Students keep making the same mistakes 7. Students do not read instructions carefully 8. Students do not learn from mistakes in assessment tasks 9. Students will not take responsibility for their learning 10. Students dive into tasks without planning 11. Students have no strategies when stuck 12. Students do not link school work with outside life 13. Students have difficulty dealing with mixed ability classes 14. Students do not believe that their own beliefs are relevant 15. Students are reluctant to take risks in creative tasks 16. Students are reluctant to edit or check their work
learners becoming more metacognitive. John’s poor learning tendencies collectively describe different aspects of unreflective, dependent learning. He regarded these as habits, developed during a student’s school experience. John believed that, because these habits had been learned, they could be unlearned – students could learn how to learn better. In his doctoral work, he had tested this belief in a project where he worked with only one teacher for one year and he wanted to continue with a bigger group of teachers for two years. Ian realised that John’s ideas were an interesting extension of his work, volunteered to ask a group of teachers at his school to work with the two of them, and PEEL was born. Although the project came primarily from Baird’s research, it was established as a collaborative action research project where ownership of all aspects, including research design, was shared by all participants. The teachers were entirely in charge of what they did in their classrooms. In his initial presentation to teachers, Ian made no effort to argue that they should be concerned about passive, dependent learning. Rather he designed what he said to reach teachers who already held concerns such as those in Table 1.1. This has remained a recurring theme as PEEL has spread. During the first two years, the teachers and academics met on a weekly basis, in their own time (but during the school day), to share and analyse experiences, ideas and new practices. The project also obtained a little funding that allowed a few fullday meetings. These meetings were crucial to the initial survival of the project. Ian and John both understood that for the project to work the teachers would need to take ownership and that this would need a supportive and safe environment in which to share. Although the teachers accepted that they would be in charge of their teaching interventions, they did ask for an initial suggestion from John. This reflective journal task failed badly, but the trusting environment meant that the group was able to focus on what were critical insights into student change that were revealed by these failures (Baird & Mitchell, 1986). This learning meant that our initial failures were able to be turned into a positive; moreover, it encouraged the teachers
1 The Project for Enhancing Effective Learning (PEEL)
9
to take the initiative in designing new teaching approaches and to set off on their own journey. (We have since learned a great deal about how to use reflective journals more successfully.) After three months of painful failure, the teachers started to report successes and they became what Baird termed ‘interdependent innovators,’ problematising and reflecting on their practice, sharing concerns, creating new teaching ideas, and sharing failures and successes. The academic collaborators maintained a role of providing minimal, just-in-time input which the teachers were free to accept or reject. More importantly the academics mirrored back to the teachers what they were doing, affirming, prodding, and promoting reflection about progress in terms of the original goals. The initial PEEL community began in one working-class high school and was intended to run for two years at only this school. However, the teachers found the process of collaborative action research so rewarding and the outcomes so beneficial for both them and their students that they refused to let the project end after the two years. A year later it began to spread to other schools (both secondary and primary) in Australia and then to other countries. This spread occurred because teachers in those schools had similar concerns about learning, and realised the potential of collaborative reflection. We responded by building a network and structures for communication between different school groups: a newsletter (now a teacher journal PEEL SEEDS), an annual conference, collective meetings, short courses about different aspects of the project, and a database, currently containing over 1,400 articles by teachers (Mitchell, 2007; Mitchell et al., 2007). This means that we established a second, cross-school community with many teachers, some who have moved into other educational settings, having been members for over 10 years. The PEEL process has resonated in many countries – Denmark, Sweden, Great Britain, Canada, New Zealand, and, most recently, China and there are links between teachers in those countries.
Why Was It Important To Have a Community? One initial reason flowed from a desire to have students experience more than one of their teachers promoting metacognition. Other reasons related to the teachers’ needs. One was stimulation. In 1985, there was little knowledge amongst teachers of what constituted quality learning. Most teachers had never heard the word metacognition. Because this focus was so new, it was important to have a group who could navigate the journey together. John Baird had tried working with one teacher in one school and found that little progress was made in terms of student learning. Teachers had no opportunity to discuss their ideas or share their practice. It was important to John and Ian that the research involve teachers of different age groups and subject areas who could bounce ideas off each other. A second reason was support. Changing practice is hard work and the teachers needed the support of the group. This proved so effective that, after what had been ten weeks of failure, when Ian (privately) asked each teacher whether they were thinking of quitting, all said no. They were frustrated with the failure but they loved
10
I. Mitchell, J. Mitchell
the stimulation of the meetings and the sharing. It was the first time any of the teachers had ever sat down and talked about their classroom teaching in the light of ideas of learning. As teachers began to share successes, a different, important form of support flowed from the affirmation that they received from others who were to take up this idea themselves. Finally the depth and breadth of the insights that emerged, as well as the richness of the new practical wisdom, were immeasurably enhanced by having a collective mind and multiple classrooms to extend and refine ideas.
What Difference Did the Learning Community Make to the Participants? The PEEL teachers set out to make students more metacognitive. What we did not realise was the extent to which this would make the teachers more metacognitive about their teaching and their own learning. They became empowered as they began to see ways of intervening in their practice to address the poor learning tendencies. These were an initially powerful frame because they broke up the nebulous and somewhat daunting concept of ‘learning’ into bits that could be tackled in the classroom. The academics listened to the teachers. This should not be underestimated as it was the first time the teachers had ever felt that academics wanted to listen to them! Their practice was affirmed, their ideas valued, and they grew to feel much more like professionals who were in charge of their practice. One marker of impact is that over 600 teachers from nearly 200 schools have chosen to take the time to write an article describing changes to their practice for PEEL SEEDS. The students became co-researchers, in that the teachers began to talk to them about learning, share their (teacher) purposes, listen to their ideas, and eventually share intellectual control. Their learning and ideas were affirmed and placed at the centre of the classroom agenda. We include here two classroom vignettes to build meaning for the sorts of changes that occurred over time. The first comes from the first edition of PEEL SEEDS and captures a teacher and his students early in the process of change. In the past I would have conducted this class by first showing a series of slides with different types of coastlines. During the slides I would have given the students information about the different types of coastlines. For this lesson however I stood aside a little and simply wrote the heading ‘Coastlines’ on the board. I then asked students to describe different coastlines and put their ideas on the board. The students’ early response was fairly typical; ‘What do you want us to say, sir?’ After fifteen minutes waiting and thinking time however, I filled the board with their responses. When this was finished, I showed the slides and was pleased with the lively discussion during and after. In fact I was thrilled when, at the end of the lesson, I was talking to the class about estuaries and fjords and the students, not me, had taken the class there. The lesson ended where I would normally want but not necessarily be. (Rod Greer)
The teacher here took a considerable risk. He did not know if his students would have anything to say, what they might say, and whether or not he could make
1 The Project for Enhancing Effective Learning (PEEL)
11
use of what they said. The students also were taking risks in offering ideas with little idea of what the teacher wanted or would do with what they said. This vignette is typical of thousands that have been reported verbally and in print as PEEL has encouraged teachers to step out of their comfort zone. What is crucial is how this is discussed in PEEL meetings and how the teacher builds on this in what has turned out to be a multi-year journey of change. The second vignette was written (10 years later) by Ian after visiting the class of Jill Flack, a teacher with many years of experience in PEEL. The class was a grade 2/3 (composite classes are common on Victorian elementary schools). It reflects the effect on the teacher with several years of involvement in PEEL as well as a huge impact on students. I have just had my understandings shifted in terms of the level of metacognitive awareness and control that young students can display. Jill began by commenting – once – that the theme for the morning was ‘What’s important’ and that they would discuss this before they went out to lunch. She then described a sequence of teaching procedures based around a story, ‘The Tortoises’ Picnic’; as tortoises are slow this picnic went on for a very long time, and one task was to turn the story into a timeline. The students were given all the directions for the morning’s work, Jill made no further procedural comment and the students had to decide when it was appropriate to move to the next task. Part of this decision included, as I found out later, reflecting on what was important in each task in terms of the overall goals of the day. After they started working, I sat down with one girl and asked her what she was doing: ‘A semantic map,’ she replied. ‘Why are you doing this,’ I asked. ‘Well, a semantic map helps me bring up what I already know about tortoises [in this case], I learn better when I can make connections to what I already know,’ she replied. There had been no conversation between Jill and her students on this in the lesson. The girl was drawing on her understandings of the learning purposes of semantic maps. Ten minutes before lunch, Jill brought the students together on the mat, asked them to recall the morning’s theme, and then called for any comment on it – a very open question! One girl put up her hand: ‘Well I think that when we were turning the story into a timeline, what was important was to get the things that happened sorted out on the timeline. I don’t think it was important to carefully colour in the pictures we drew on the timeline and I think that some of us spent too long on this.’ I found both the fact that Jill could envisage asking Grade 2/3 students to engage in this kind of thinking, and the extent to which they could, to be revelatory. It shows how much we underestimate what students are capable of if the teacher has the confidence to persist with a coherent strategy for enhancing metacognition. (Ian Mitchell)
Findings from the Research and Practice The Value of Academic/Teacher Interactions The project brought together academics, teachers and students in an ongoing learning collaboration. Teachers and academics have traditionally been seen to have different kinds of knowledge and skills and often teachers are suspicious of academics. In this project, the academics regarded the teachers as the driving force of the
12
I. Mitchell, J. Mitchell
research. They regarded themselves as having an open-ended role, responsive to the teachers’ needs. The kinds of knowledge the academics brought, richly complemented the teachers’ knowledge and vice versa. One important role of the academics was to keep the group in touch with the goals. John would regularly ask the teachers to explore how what they were doing was linked with the goals of metacognition and quality learning. Another role of the academics, as mentioned, was to mirror back their practice to the teachers. Much of teacher knowledge is tacit – it becomes part of the routine of teaching and important insights get buried. With skillful probing the academics could elicit ideas the teachers did not initially present, helping them to clarify, articulate, and codify their knowledge. Teachers normally do not have the luxury of the time to reflect in this way, but over time they became skilled at this form of thinking and the academic role here lessened. As the project extended over many years, a new role for academics was to help identify new challenges that stimulated further teacher innovation.
The Value of Teacher/Teacher Interactions Collaborative action research helped the group develop synergy. They became innovators who fed off each other’s ideas and built up creative practice. PEEL began as a cross-faculty community, with teachers of five different subjects in the initial group. This meant that teachers could not share ideas in any subject or topicspecific way. We had to learn to identify the generic features of any particular activity and this led to the development of the construct of ‘generic teaching procedures.’ We did not anticipate the extent to which the teachers would transfer ideas from one subject context to another. The framing of teaching ideas in terms of teaching procedures and the development of new procedures has been an important aspect of the internal literature of the project. A major outcome of the project has been a pool of over 200 generic teaching procedures (Mitchell, 2007); some, such as concept maps, were not original to PEEL, but the majority were.
Understandings of Student Change Initially we imagined that helping students to become metacognitive would simply be a matter of changing their behaviours, according to the poor learning tendencies. What we did not expect was that students would have definite and strong attitudes towards what constitutes learning in school, and equally strong conceptions about learning in general. Their ideas about learning were not what we wanted them to be. We’re doing too much thinking and not enough learning. All this thinking is interfering with my learning. (Mitchell, 1997)
They were suspicious of discussion. They believed learning meant writing or copying notes, and they did not believe they could learn from each other. This last con-
1 The Project for Enhancing Effective Learning (PEEL)
13
cern led us to realise that we needed to develop a classroom climate in which the students trusted each other and the teacher. Among many other lessons relating to student change, we have realised the importance of a language for learning. Teachers need to articulate their own understandings of learning and talk with students about how and why they are learning. This means a shared vocabulary in which terms like ‘making a link’ and ‘what’s important’ are part of everyday classroom interactions with shared meanings. Students have repeatedly shown us that they can take ownership of their own learning, if only we let them. We gradually started to relinquish control, first by encouraging them to ask questions. Once we had their questions, they set the agenda. We had to allow them to pursue their own pathways. This is not to say that we sat back and reverted to the inquiry-based model of the 1970s. This was inquiry with a purpose, understanding of the big ideas, and lots of teacher participation. After this success, we moved on to find many other ways of allowing students to share control. Offering more choice and promoting a wider range of student decisions were just two ways.
Understandings of Teacher Change The original PEEL teachers and academics completely underestimated the extent to which the teachers would need to change their practice. As already discussed, the poor learning tendencies offered the teachers a way of tackling issues of learning they could easily recognise. They could devise or find teaching procedures to help students. During the first year of PEEL, the teachers took the poor learning tendencies list and turned it into a list of good learning behaviours, such as: plans a general strategy before starting; offers or seeks links between different activities and ideas; suggests new activities and alternative procedures; and offers ideas, new insights and alternative explanations. This gave another menu of options for tackling the big idea of quality learning. These lists gave teachers choices about how and when they could make changes to their practice, and gave them ownership over the extent and rate to which they wanted to change. One teacher could begin with quite small changes involving, for example, having students write questions, while another might instigate a major change in how they negotiated a unit of work with students, allowing them to share intellectual control.
Discussion and Suggestions What Is Different About PEEL? PEEL’s unexpected longevity has enabled us to learn a great deal about what works and what does not work in terms of a teacher community. PEEL began as a group of volunteer teachers and academics with a focus on learning. This was
14
I. Mitchell, J. Mitchell
radically different in 1985. It was more usual for teacher professional development to focus on teaching. Indeed, little about learning that was of practical use to teachers was known at that time. With hindsight, this focus on how students are learning has turned out to allow for a so far indefinite development of the project as each new finding or idea raises stimulating new challenges for teachers. Promoting ‘good’ questions, for example, raises issues of what is a good question, and when and why. This leads to issues of how to broaden students’ conceptions in this area and how to weave these questions into the coverage of the curriculum. The project began as, and remains, a ‘bottom up’ initiative. There was no direction from any system-level initiative. This enabled the teachers to feel true ownership and hence a greater sense of professionalism. Later, many came to see themselves as valued change agents. The involvement of the academics made the teachers feel special. While the academics brought different sorts of wisdom to the research, the ways in which they did this depended on what the teachers wanted – there was no sense of the teachers ‘doing a course.’ This resulted in a partnership that was seen as more equal than was common at the time. In recent years, systems in Australia have begun to focus much more on how students learn, and current government agendas in our state map quite closely onto the original goals of PEEL. This convergence of (some) goals caused Ian to review everything written about PEEL with the aim of generating a list of features that distinguished it from other worthy initiatives with similar goals. The resultant list, shared at a keynote address at the 2007 PEEL conference, summarises much of what has gone before as well as articulating how PEEL has developed from the early, much less-informed explorations. You are using a PEEL approach if you are, or are moving towards: 1. Having a strategic, long-term learning agenda focusing on multiple aspects of quality learning and metacognition 2. Making consistent, persistent and purposeful use of teaching procedures, appropriate teaching behaviours, and the principles of teaching for quality learning 3. Trusting students and sharing responsibilities and intellectual control with students 4. Problematising and purposefully interrogating and developing your practice; becoming more metacognitive about your teaching and developing new dimensions of sense-making 5. Being supportive of, and are supported by, others in a process of collaborative action research A school is adopting a PEEL approach if it: 6. Positions teachers as generators of new knowledge and in control of their professional learning and development The longevity of the project can be attributed to the new challenges that continue to arise as teachers identify new challenges and trial new and exciting agendas. There is no end for PEEL teachers – the journey is the destination.
1 The Project for Enhancing Effective Learning (PEEL)
15
Challenges 1. One challenge, common in many education systems, is what Australians call the ‘tall poppy syndrome.’ Tall poppies are those in the workplace who dare to try to be different (and so run the danger of being ‘lopped off’). The workplace in schools is characterised by egalitarianism and teachers are reluctant to promote themselves as being in some ways better (even if it is just better than they were). Some PEEL groups have experienced resentment – especially if members are seen to be getting ‘special treatment.’ The most successful way to deal with this phenomenon has been for the teachers, and especially the group’s convener(s), to be totally transparent and informative by publishing and sharing the group’s work. 2. Another problem is that, after several years, a PEEL group might consist of teachers with several years’ experience, who have changed their practice in sometimes radical ways, as well as teachers who are new to the project and just starting to trial new ideas. This latter group is obviously much more tentative, and often experience failures; moreover, the issues that are exciting challenges to them may be established practice for others. It is important that the ‘experienced’ PEEL members not dominate the meetings with success stories; but it is equally important that the meetings deal with challenges that cover the full range of interests in the group. The role of the convener is crucial in making sure all members who wish to contribute are able to do so, as well as being especially sensitive to the ‘shy’ members who might be reluctant to interrupt more confident speakers. We have found that such members often come in clutching student work or other papers, and this is a sign that they need to be drawn in! 3. PEEL teachers have always been volunteers. When it was odd to be focusing on learning, this was easy to do. Over recent years in Victoria, many schools have required teachers to work in teams, sometimes called professional learning teams. Some schools have made these teams compulsory, and tied participation to the performance and development reviews that each teacher must undertake. Weaving PEEL into this structure is not simple; PEEL always has been voluntary because it is impossible to force teachers to admit to concerns about their practice or their students’ learning. If they are not prepared to do this, then they are not going to ever benefit from a teacher group like a PEEL group. Principals in the past have been known to refer struggling (or simply underperforming) teachers to PEEL groups and the result has always been disastrous.
Lessons Learned 1. As various curriculum reforms have come and gone over the 22 years, we have learned to ‘go with the flow.’ We focus on what matters, which is the core business of helping students understand their learning and improve it. The lat-
16
I. Mitchell, J. Mitchell
est reform in Victoria has some important elements that align perfectly with what PEEL represents, such as incorporating thinking processes, including metacognition much more explicitly into the subject disciplines. PEEL has been doing this for 22 years, so we have a lot to offer. There are other parts of the reform that are less interesting to us. One outcome that we did not expect is that PEEL builds teachers’ confidence in what they are doing and makes them much less anxious about meeting the minutiae of system curriculum statements. The core business will remain the same, no matter what systems choose to place on top of it. 2. We have learned the value of teachers writing and sharing. Both the process and the product are valuable; the act of sitting down to write a short vignette of what worked in their class and why is a valuable reflection that often brings out hitherto tacit wisdom. The publication of the writing provides valuable affirmation all too rare in teaching. There is a different aspect to the value of sharing these contextually rich stories. Teachers write about 100 articles a year for our journal PEEL SEEDS and every year these articles are transferred to our electronic database. After 22 years, in hundreds of different classrooms, this database, which can be interrogated by any combination of over 300 search fields, contains an immense body of teaching knowledge. However, there is another benefit of pooling so many contextually specific stories: an examination of these reveals recurring and generalisable themes that can be used both to make sense of classroom events and to provide new challenges and directions for innovation. 3. One feature of this knowledge is an increased understanding of student and teacher change, together with an appreciation of the complex, multifaceted, interconnected nature of teaching. PEEL has deliberately not developed a fixed programme – ‘x steps to promoting quality learning.’ There are two reasons for this. First, we do not believe there could ever be anything resembling a single programme that could be applicable in all subjects, topics, and year levels with all students. The second is that advice such as, for example, how to teach Food and Nutrition in Year 9 would be disempowering for teachers and contrary to all of the process aspects of how PEEL operates. To illustrate how ideas are transmitted, we present below a generic description of one of the 215 procedures on the current edition of the PEEL database. Teaching procedures provide teachers with concrete tools for improving learning. Importantly, the descriptions of these procedures are not presented as ‘black line masters’ that can be copied and used intact. Rather they require teachers to develop their own specific applications. This is a very empowering process. B51 Taking notes from a jumbled summary This procedure requires students to actively follow and then reconstruct the points made in a discussion or a brainstorming activity. Like B4 (Summarising a discussion with diagrams), it is a way of drawing together and keeping a record of the thinking that went on 1 The labels B5 and B4 refer to the (eight) groups that we use to cluster the many teaching procedures, both the articles referred to are in Group B: procedures for retrieving, restructuring and extending students’ ideas.
1 The Project for Enhancing Effective Learning (PEEL)
17
in a vigorous discussion or brainstorm without the teacher just putting up a set of notes that she or he has constructed. It shows the students that their ideas were important and useful. As the discussion proceeds, the teacher (or a student) records the points made on the board. However, these are deliberately placed in a random arrangement. At the end of the discussion, the students have to construct a logically ordered set of notes from this jumbled summary of brief points. This procedure is particularly useful when a teacher wants to introduce a topic where she or he knows that the students already possesses a lot of relevant knowledge and experience. The procedure was invented by Sue Cannard, a Commerce teacher discussing the structure of Australian Government. Here there was a discussion about different levels of government and their roles, and she put appropriate words and phrases all over the board as records of what had been raised. Rosemary Dusting, teaching year 7 maths (Taking Notes From a Jumbled Summary in Year 7 Maths), began a unit on Measurement with a brainstorm of all the words the students could think of that related in any way to measurement. The students, while sorting them, came up with three groups: (1) things we measure (e.g., distance, time); (2) things we use to take measurements (e.g., rulers, clocks); and (3) units of measurement. Rosemary has since reported (see Why PEEL) an apparently opposite variation of this, but one that still leaves the intellectual activity in the minds of the students. In this variation, the students brainstorm words relevant to a new topic and the teacher records them on the board, but does group them; however she does not tell the students what her groupings are – the students have to work this out and insert appropriate sub-headings.
4. Teaching procedures can be described as tactical in that most take less than one lesson to implement. PEEL teachers, over time, weave more of these into their classroom practice in ways that are not random selections of another new idea, but are informed by considerations of promoting different aspects of learning. These are what we would call long-term strategies. After 13 years of PEEL, we were able to codify (Mitchell & Mitchell, 1997) 12 strategic features (see Table 1.2) of what the teachers report as successful in promoting quality learning. These statements are the sorts of generalisations that emerge as teachers make sense of a pile of superficially disparate experiences. Each of these principles can be enacted in many ways, but we describe them as strategic in that all of them can be applied in all subjects at all year levels at all (at least most) times. Both Rod Greer and Jill Flack were enacting principles 1 and 6, but in very different ways. 5. The sharing of this communally developed wisdom and knowledge, via faceto-face meetings and sessions as well as the internal literature of the project, has been crucial to PEEL sustaining growth over such a long period of time. A challenge for us was to work out how to represent and then re-present this knowledge to other teachers. What we have attempted is to share wisdom about how to improve learning in ways that, as far as possible, replicate the way ideas bounce around in PEEL groups, becoming richer in the process. As stated above, this means sharing ideas in ways that require users to (at least on most occasions) design original applications to their own practice and encourage extension and development. It has also meant keeping the teacher’s voice and providing a mix of a rich range of possible classroom tactics that are cohered by some general strategic principles that allow teachers to identify big picture issues.
18
I. Mitchell, J. Mitchell
Table 1.2 Principles of teaching for quality learning 1. Share intellectual control with students 2. Create occasions when students can work out part (or all) of the content or instructions 3. Provide opportunities for choice and independent decision-making 4. Provide a diverse range of ways of experiencing success 5. Promote talk that is exploratory, tentative, and hypothetical 6. Encourage students to learn from other students’ questions and comments 7. Build a classroom environment that supports risk-taking 8. Use a wide variety of intellectually challenging teaching procedures 9. Use teaching procedures that are designed to promote specific aspects of quality learning 10. Develop students’ awareness of the big picture: how the various activities fit together and link to the big ideas 11. Regularly raise students’ awareness of the nature of different aspects of quality learning 12. Promote assessment as part of the learning process
6. Perhaps the most important lesson we have learned is not to underestimate what both students and teachers are capable of when provided with sustained support and stimulation for developing their learning and their independence.
References Baird, J. R. (1984). Improving learning through enhanced metacognition: Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, Monash University, Melbourne. Baird, J. R. (1986). Improved learning through enhanced metacognition: A classroom study. European Journal of Science Education, 8, 263–282. Baird, J. R. & Mitchell, I. J. (1986). Improving the quality of teaching and learning. Melbourne, Australia: PEEL Publishing. Barnes, D. (1976). From communication to curriculum. Harmondsworth, UK: Penguin. Flavell, J. H. (ed.) (1976). Metacognitive aspects of problem solving: The nature of intelligence. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Mitchell, I. J. (1997). Theory into practice: Improving the quality of teaching and learning. In J. R. Baird & I. J. Mitchell (Eds.), Improving the quality of teaching and learning (2nd ed.). Melbourne, Australia: PEEL Publishing. Mitchell, I. J. (ed.) (2007). Teaching for effective learning: The complete book of PEEL teaching procedures (3rd ed.). Melbourne, Australia: PEEL Publishing. Mitchell, I. J. & Mitchell, J. A. (eds.) (1997). Stories of reflective teaching: A book of PEEL cases. Melbourne, Australia: PEEL Publishing. Mitchell, I. J., Mitchell, J. A., et al. (2007). PEEL in practice: 1400 ideas for quality teaching (8th ed.). Melbourne, Australia: PEEL Publishing.
Chapter 3
Pre-Service Teachers and Sixth Graders Explore Social Justice as a Community of Inquiry Monica Taylor and Gennifer Otinsky
Description of Our Learning Community We are educators working in two different learning contexts: a university and middle school. Our chapter describes how we worked together to bring those two learning communities together. We share our efforts in developing a community of inquiry which explored issues of social justice. Monica is a teacher educator at a large public university in New Jersey. Gennifer is a sixth grade language arts/social studies teacher at a suburban middle school. Through our work in schools we have observed that, like many pre-service teachers across the country, our pre-service teachers have little first-hand knowledge and experience with issues of social justice and social justice teaching. Similarly, we have observed that middle schoolers do not view the world through a critical lens. In this chapter, we discuss the ways in which we developed a community of inquiry made up of pre-service teachers and sixth graders. Our goal for the community of inquiry was to provide a scaffolded social justice exploration for our students. This chapter explains the background and structure of our community of inquiry. Additionally we share the insights of our pre-service teachers from learning alongside middle schoolers, as well as our own reflections about establishing a community of inquiry. Over the last six years, we have grown to know one another while our schools have established a professional development school (PDS) partnership. During the summer of our first year as a PDS, we participated in a two week Summer Leadership Associates program sponsored by the university’s agenda for Education in a Democracy, where we grappled with issues of democracy together. Engaging in difficult discussions around issues of social justice was scary, challenging, and at times gut-wrenching, and often having one another to talk to and reflect with made all of the difference. We realized how powerful our own small community
M. Taylor Montclair State University G. Otinsky Grover Cleveland Middle
A.P. Samaras et al. (eds.) Learning Communities In Practice, © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2008
31
32
M. Taylor, G. Otinsky
of inquiry of two was and we wondered how we could replicate this type of experience for our students. Building upon the tenets that have developed organically through the PDS partnership (NCATE, 2001) for the past six years, we have offered a series of pre-service teaching courses on-site at the middle school. The community built in these courses exemplifies three traits of a “community of practice” (Wenger, 1998, p. 73): “1) mutual engagement, 2) a joint enterprise, and 3) a shared repertoire.” The courses are designed to provide pre-service teachers the opportunity to learn from and alongside middle schoolers. Since our pre-service teachers, as well as sixth graders, are primarily white and from suburban communities, they have little to no experience with people who are different from them and take their positions of privilege for granted. They are unaccustomed to examining their world critically and view racism as isolated incidents rather than institutionalized or societal norms. We feel it is important that they develop a “social justice lens” because they have had mixed experiences with social justice and constructivist teaching in school, and view these paradigms as a significant leap of faith.
Rationale Community of Practice Working in a PDS provides a tangible learning community for pre-service teachers. A PDS is defined as “a learning-centered community that supports the integrated learning and development of P-12 students, candidates, and PDS partners through inquiry-based practice” (NCATE, 2001, p. 11). These partnerships, often striving to be a “community of practice” (Wenger, 1998), encourage site-based learning that centers on extensive observation, small group tutorials, and student teaching (Sutherland et al., 2005). They do not necessarily disrupt the pre-service teachers’ traditional notions of teaching, learning, and curriculum or help pre-service teachers understand the potential of constructivist principles of teaching and learning. In order to do this, they must first participate in a “community of practice” (Wenger, 1998) in which they share reciprocal authority with students (Taylor & Coia, 2006) and view themselves as facilitators rather than depositors of knowledge. Although our teacher education program emphasizes constructivist principles, the pre-service teachers have a difficult time incorporating these principles into practice. This challenge is augmented by their experiences both within their individualized content areas as well as in field experiences. Too often, feeling isolated and pressured, they fall back into the direct instruction model with which they feel comfortable. They are unsure of the ways to diverge from transmission teaching, and with little power and community, are fearful of veering from the norm. We understand how high the stakes are, but we strive to use
3 Pre-Service Teachers and Sixth Graders Explore Social Justice
33
practices that open up conversations about social justice and encourage support through a learning community. Our community of inquiry develops “knowledge of practice” (Cochran-Smith & Lytle, 1999) for our pre-service teachers. “The knowledge,” as Cochran-Smith and Lytle (1999, p. 274) write, “teachers need to teach well emanates from systematic inquiries about teaching, learners and learning, curriculum, schools, and schooling. This knowledge is constructed collectively within local and broader communities.” We believe that participation in our social justice community of inquiry guides preservice teachers to think about their knowledge of practice – the connections between the theories of learning, curriculum, and social justice teaching that they have studied in their teacher education courses, and the application of these theories into practice.
Social Justice Teaching For the purposes of our community of inquiry, social justice teaching involves critical, pro-justice, and democratic instruction (Lee et al., 1998). In a social justice classroom, “inquiry is not simply finding right answers to old and familiar questions,” but also entails interrogating the questions and resources investigated (Boran & Comber, 2001, pp. vii–ix). In our social justice classrooms, students ask the following essential questions: “Who makes decisions and who is left out? Who benefits and who suffers? Why is a given practice fair or unfair? What are its origins? What alternatives can we imagine? What is required to create change?” (Bigelow et al., 2001). We strive to uncover the ways in which some people are privileged and have access to wealth and power and others live as objects of discrimination and injustice. Inquiry promotes social justice because it “begins with voice, inviting all learners to name their world. It ends in reflexivity and action, inviting all learners to interrogate the very constructs they are using to make sense of their world” (Harste, 2001, p. 15).
Defining a Community of Inquiry Pre-service teachers and middle school students become inquirers when they are invited to authentically investigate questions or problems that arise during their interactions in the world. Our inquiry operates from the understanding that knowledge is dynamic, ever-changing, and multiple, and is not static, does not reside in textbooks or with experts, and cannot be simply transmitted to students. We do not encourage our students to simply accept information as truth or make unsubstantiated claims. We ask our students to question, investigate, and justify. Our students become researchers who are immersed in a topic, “wondering and wandering” (Short et al., 1996, p. 265), designing and redesigning a question, and then
34
M. Taylor, G. Otinsky
articulating “understandings” (p. 260). Questions are defined and explored in an environment of uncertainty, and they are invited to resist their human desire to confirm knowledge. Rather they look for shades of grey instead of viewing the world in black and white. We believe that our inquirers cannot be engaged in inquiry alone. Inquiry is a relational process: it relies on the give and take of questions, ideas, perspectives, and even explanations to draw conclusions about the world and raise new questions and ideas. So inquiry flourishes when the student/teacher relationship reflects the authority and expertise of both parties. Inquiry requires a dialogical community of students and teachers where ideas are shared, discussed, examined, and reformulated (Stock, 1995), and where learners construct new understandings and questions of the world. In our community of inquiry, both students and teachers share reciprocal authority and alternate roles as knowers and learners, depending upon the question, the expertise, the prior knowledge, and the mode of exploration (Taylor & Coia, 2006). Ultimately, “knowledge building takes place between people doing things together, and at least part of this doing involves dialogue” (Wells, 2001, p. 186). Below we discuss the mechanics of our social justice community of inquiry.
Our Social Justice Community of Inquiry The social justice community of inquiry takes place each day over the course of a three week intensive teaching and learning class for the pre-service teachers. This course involves the final preparation before student teaching. Their student teaching experience, which lasts 14 weeks, follows this three-week inquiry and is accompanied by a biweekly evening seminar. During the course, Monica encourages the pre-service teachers to move from theory into practice, building their knowledge of practice. They write lesson plans, plan ways to differentiate instruction, discuss classroom management and assessment strategies, develop a philosophy statement, and attempt to prepare for their student teaching experience. They are required to maintain a reflective journal throughout the inquiry experience, and as a final reflection they write a teaching for social justice philosophy statement. Several of the readings address issues of race, ethnicity, gender, and teaching for social justice. Monica and the pre-service teachers meet for two hours of the course and then work with the sixth graders for an hour. This course setup fosters knowledge of practice, giving them the opportunity to discuss strategies or concepts and then try them out alongside sixth graders. The community of inquiry is developed around the sixth graders’ social studies theme of civil rights. At the beginning of the community of inquiry, groups are formed with two pre-service teachers and four sixth graders. The community of inquiry incorporates a variety of strategies including brainstorming; poetry writing; reader response to texts, films, and visual images; role-playing; and
3 Pre-Service Teachers and Sixth Graders Explore Social Justice
35
inquiry projects. Specifically it covers the following topics: building community; identity sharing; explorations of race, class, and gender; examination of stereotypes in the media; introduction and discussion of the term social justice; models of young social justice activists; and social justice inquiry projects. After introducing the inquiry cycle and some large group brainstorming of possible social justice questions, individual groups develop a shared open-ended authentic question. Narrowing a group question involves negotiation and collaborative decision-making within the community of inquiry. Then, in the media center, students plan their methodology and carry out their research. They must use at least one periodical, book, Internet site, and interview for their investigation, and synthesize different perspectives and draw conclusions. After searching the literature, they create a poster board that presents their findings visually. The board shows the original open-ended question, their methodology and bibliographic information, their results and findings, a social action plan (something that they can do themselves to raise awareness or make change) and finally, any new questions that they have. The inquiry topics are very diverse. One sixth grader’s uncle ran for a seat in the US Senate and lost to a millionaire, who prompted her group to ask the question: If a person cannot run for office because he/she does not have money, then is it a democratic society? Another group, comprised of five females and only one male, asked the question: Why hasn’t a woman ever been elected president in the USA? Other groups wondered about the following: How does Title IX affect sports? Are athletes more important than teachers? How can we protect ourselves from stereotypes often portrayed by the media? Why are there more African-Americans than whites in jail? Why is there world hunger? Why do some school districts have more money to spend on education than others? The students share their findings along with their proposed action plans. For example, one team organized student-run after school events designed to raise awareness about homelessness, racism, or bullying. Another distributed collection boxes to raise money for the Sudan, and still another wrote letters to local papers to express their concerns. Their work often leads them to new questions and actions.
Who Are Our Pre-service Teachers and Sixth Graders? Our pre-service teachers are enrolled in either the undergraduate teacher education program or the Master’s of teaching program at our suburban state university. Each spring semester we usually have between 25 and 30 pre-service teachers. The data for this particular study primarily involve the pre-service teachers who were enrolled in the spring of 2004 and 2005. In that cohort, 95% of the pre-service teachers were white, 5% were African-American and Latino. Two thirds of the preservice teachers were female. Economically their backgrounds ranged from lower, middle to upper incomes and for many, they were the first in their families to be
36
M. Taylor, G. Otinsky
college educated. They were working to complete their teaching certifications in K-12 settings in a specific content area, e.g., English, social studies, sciences, mathematics, art, music, foreign language, physical education, or speech. Our sixth graders attend a small public middle school in a suburban community. Ninety-five percent of the students are white and come from middle- to upperincome families. Five percent of the students are Asian, African-American, and Latino. The classes are evenly divided in terms of gender. Approximately 15% of the students are classified with recommended modifications in an Individualized Educational Plan. Each semester we work with two sections of Genn’s social studies class. Each section has approximately 25 students.
Methods Throughout these projects, we collected multiple and various forms of data to understand the impact of participating in the social justice community of inquiry. (1) We gathered and photocopied reflections that were written after each session from all student participants. (2) We conducted a series of three 45-minute open-ended interviews (Seidman, 1991) with a small representational group of students. (3) We digitally videotaped and photographed the students during the inquiry cycle, while they presented their findings, and also after their presentations. (4) We photocopied the pre-service teachers’ philosophical statements on social justice teaching. (5) The pre-service teachers also discussed their reflections on Blackboard, the university’s digital discussion community. (6) Additionally, we recorded our own observations and reflections as field notes. Interviews were tape-recorded and then transcribed. Our data analysis was recursive and generative. We attempted to analyze data as they were collected as well as after. We met once a week to discuss the progress of the project and to read and reflect about the data. Using constant-comparative methods, we continually looked for emerging themes, categories, or patterns that spanned across the data (Glaser & Strauss, 1967). We attempted to triangulate data (Gordon, 1980) by seeking themes that were represented in multiple forms of data. We share what we discovered in the following section.
Impact We Are Doing What with the Sixth Graders? The pre-service teachers enter into this community of inquiry with great apprehension. They display disbelief at the sixth graders being interested and motivated to think about social justice issues. They state: “We are doing what with the sixth graders? A social justice project? Why would we ever do that? What do they know
3 Pre-Service Teachers and Sixth Graders Explore Social Justice
37
or care about stereotypes and social justice? Why should they know about these things? They are so young and immature.” They believe that sixth graders cannot think critically because of their age and lack of maturity. We wonder how there can be such a great disconnect between our courses and the pre-service teachers’ responses. We worry about how they will teach for social justice in their own classrooms. At what age or level will they deem their students old enough to critically examine texts or the world? Interestingly, this disbelief quickly vanishes once they begin working with the sixth graders. As Anna illustrates, the pre-service teachers begin to value the critical potential of children almost immediately. She writes: “I learned that we don’t give enough credit to students. Kids are never given a chance because they are seen as too young to learn about things like this.”
Sixth Graders Can Wrap Their Brains Around Complex Issues It is relatively easy for us to emphasize the potential of students as learners and thinkers, but it is much more powerful to provide pre-service teachers with opportunities to experience the seriousness of a sixth grade discussion or critique of a text through a community of inquiry. We believe that these principles of believing in your learners and understanding that they come to the classroom with prior knowledge and critical dispositions to examine texts and the world are essential. The theme of surprise and amazement at the level of sixth grade engagement pervaded the pre-service teachers’ reflections. Claudia admits that she did not know what to expect when she first heard about the community of inquiry: “Initially I underestimated the abilities of the students. I didn’t realize how knowledgeable, sensitive and perceptive they were to understanding social justice issues.” As the experience progressed, Marcie writes: “They continue to amaze me with their ability to wrap their brains around these complex issues.” Robert echoes: “So far I’ve been impressed and fascinated with how insightful the kids are. Their awareness of issues like stereotyping and identity is amazing.” After the inquiry presentations, Janice writes: “I was very surprised that they had so many questions for the groups and that their minds work much more critically than I expected.” Engaging in a social justice community of inquiry clearly helps the pre-service teachers think about their students differently. They realize that their students are equipped to discuss difficult and complex issues of social justice. They begin to recognize the legitimacy of a curriculum that moves beyond factual recall.
Ownership Opens Possibilities Through the community of inquiry, the pre-service teachers have hands-on experiences that strengthen their understanding of the need for learners to have ownership
38
M. Taylor, G. Otinsky
of the learning process. Susan demonstrates this trust: “Students will come up with a lot of ideas on their own. You don’t always have to push them towards a certain conclusion.” Julie writes: “This is a very important project to do because by these students discovering the information for themselves, they can see the proper information from some of the misconceptions that they have.” The pre-service teachers realize that the students become mutually engaged and committed to the joint enterprise of the community (Wenger, 1998) through their participation. Melanie reflects: “I learned that when students take ownership of what they learn, they will get more out of it.” Felicia also addresses the issue of ownership: “Students can direct their own learning. They took charge of what they wanted to do and how they wanted to go about it.” Wenger (1998, p. 77) explains that the enterprise that keeps a community of practice together “is defined by the participants in the very process of pursuing it. It is their negotiated response to their situation and thus belongs to them in a profound sense.” The pre-service teachers move from teacher as provider of information to the role of “facilitator and coach,” where they have to “step back” and let the students come to know. This is another example of the development of knowledge of practice (Cochran-Smith & Lytle, 1999).
Teacher/Learner Reciprocity We model our community of inquiry blending Freire’s (1994) notion that “[t]he teacher is no longer merely the one-who-teaches, but one who is himself taught in dialogue with the students, who in turn while being taught also teach” (p. 67) with the characteristics of mutual engagement, joint enterprise, and shared repertoire of a community of practice (Wenger, 1998). Sharing the roles of teachers and learners and negotiating purposes and means seems natural to the pre-service teachers as they learn collaboratively with the sixth graders. Jack discusses his surprise at learning research strategies from the sixth graders: “It was interesting seeing how students half my age do things. They were so savvy about the Internet. It showed me that my process is also a little one-sided and that I need to re-evaluate my research methods.” “Working with the students reinforced the idea that our students will teach us as much as we teach them,” reiterates Debbie. Laura concludes: “The children really teach you to see things from a different perspective.” Debbie continues: “Working alongside the students was a great experience because they helped me to think about the inquiry process and question things that I would never have thought of.” Luisa concludes, in her philosophy statement: “Contrary to traditional methods of education where the teacher provides the information and asks students to ‘get it,’ when students construct their own meaning based on what they may already know, they have potential to move beyond the conventional student role and become a teacher.” As they shift their perceptions of learners, the pre-service teachers begin to rethink the ways in which they will approach curriculum. As they move to value
3 Pre-Service Teachers and Sixth Graders Explore Social Justice
39
their learners in the teaching equation, they realize that curriculum is not fixed but rather evolves with the students. Lesley notes: “I will use my curriculum as a guide but it can and will be changed if I see that something else has intrigued my students but doesn’t follow exactly what I had planned. Textbooks should be a resource not a lesson plan or guideline.” The pre-service teachers demonstrate a move from understanding curriculum theory to envisioning curriculum through theory (CochranSmith & Lytle, 1999). Pre-service teachers also discuss the importance of teaching and learning in collaboration with other adults. John writes: “Besides learning from and about the kids and their thoughts and ideas, I also learned from my colleagues. For example, I thought it was quite insightful of Dave to realize early on we had to narrow our question’s focus.” Katie echoes: “Working with university students was interesting because it was nice to bounce ideas off of other soon to be teachers.” Recognizing their value, we hope that our pre-service teachers will attempt to develop communities of practice of their own in the future.
Social Justice Teaching: “Truth Tellers and Change Makers” Our pre-service teachers demonstrate that social justice teaching involves two interrelated dimensions: providing content knowledge that represents multiple perspectives through the filtering of curriculum and materials, and developing critical lenses through their content areas that expand students as thinkers and moral citizens. Dana believes that social justice teaching “includes helping students learn how to recognize injustices within society, not just those on the surface; how to think critically about how those injustices affect the subordinate groups, themselves, and society as a whole, and finally how to find their voice as part of society to help them become ‘truth tellers and change makers.’” Sam, a future social studies teacher, begins to think about valuing alternative historical perspectives. He gives the example of World War II and the Japanese American perspective: “Japanese Americans were put in prison camps because of the war with Japan. For Japanese Americans this may be the biggest event of the war. It is important to look at social studies from a variety of perspectives so that all people’s pasts are included as part of the vital issues of history.” Justin realizes that his students may have little exposure to oppressed people. He reflects: “It is important for students to understand social justice through the eyes of people who may not be represented in their student population. A different way to introduce students to other cultures is learning about the struggles that other groups of people had to face in order to obtain better equality.” Lily believes that studying art naturally lends itself to talking back to texts. Thinking about art as literacy, she reflects: “By decoding messages in our visual surroundings my students gain an understanding of contexts such as institutionalized, interpersonal, and internalized racism and sexism. This practice of visual literacy will enable my students to ‘talk back’ to their surroundings by critiquing and
40
M. Taylor, G. Otinsky
evaluating visual messages that constantly bombard them.” She hopes that in recognizing these messages, her students will be able to resist maintaining the status quo and perpetuating stereotypes. Jennifer, a future art teacher, moves beyond the curricular content and reflects on her moral responsibility to promote informed and engaged citizens. She hopes to push students to “value more than just the familiar.” She does not want to change their opinions, rather she hopes that they will come to know on their own. This idea of opening up spaces for her students to discover for themselves their moral voices is a more complicated teaching objective, but one that clearly values the authority of the learner. She eloquently explains: I believe that we are not just teaching our students facts and how to combine them but how to live. We live in a country where our laws are written so that we have the ability to change if it is needed and we need to teach our students to take advantage of this. If students are confident and capable of inquiry they will keep exploring the world around them. I see a student who comes to my classroom with negative stereotypes imprinted in their thinking as a challenge but not bad or someone I try to keep quiet. Allowing students to have their opinions but insisting they know why they think the way they do forces them to look beyond the “it’s right because my Dad said so” or “my friends said.”
Nurturing Activists Inquiry connects learners to the pressing problems of the world and leads to action both inside and outside of the classroom. In a community of inquiry we acknowledge that action is a fundamental part of thinking and learning, or as Dewey (1997, pp. 156–157) argues: “The material of thinking is not thoughts, but actions, facts, events, and the relations of things.” This expanded notion of learning is inherently democratic and reflects the principles of a “community of practice” (Wenger, 1998) in that it values the unique and infinite actions and experiences of all learners. Both Sam and Justin conclude that raising awareness about injustice is just the first step of a social justice community of inquiry. Students need avenues by which to take action once they understand about injustices, otherwise they become hopeless. Sam reflects: “We did not only raise a question, we were also required to create an action plan. This is important in regards to social justice because not only are we drawing on the past but we are creating ways to change injustices in the future.” We agree that action is a vital part of a social justice community of inquiry because participation in a “community of practice” is active and as Wenger (1998, pp. 56–57) writes: “Participation in social communities shapes our experience, and it also shapes those communities; the transformational potential goes both ways.” Diana, as she thinks about her future language arts classroom, identifies promoting social justice as a way to unearth “truths about the world.” She feels responsible to investigate the issue of power with her students and help them to devise ways to become agents of change. She hopes her students “ask questions about decision making and the repercussions of negative choices, fairness, and most importantly power dynamics.” She continues: “I want to make them understand how and why some dif-
3 Pre-Service Teachers and Sixth Graders Explore Social Justice
41
ferences will ‘translate into wealth and power and others will be a source of discrimination and injustice.’ By creating situations where students can think critically about ways to apply the tools to real life, there is still a chance that students will try to make change beyond the classroom.” In a community of inquiry, the participants develop a shared repertoire of tools and discourses that help them to critique and analyze the world.
Discussion Our Views on a Social Justice Community of Inquiry A community of inquiry is a risky and uncomfortable endeavor, for there is no predicting what twists and turns the process takes, nor can we be sure of the final product. Each time we invite learners into a community of inquiry, the ingredients of the process emerge with the investigation and more importantly the investigators. Allowing for the unpredictable in our communities of inquiry is a drastic change from the traditional ways that we view teaching and learning, but it is inherently democratic. Teachers do not construct democratic classrooms using a transmission model of teaching. If they hope to promote democratic principles then they know that inviting their learners to take ownership of their learning will promote a more in-depth and critical understanding of the world. Coming to understand the worth of an inquiry community does not occur overnight, nor is it easy. It is a process – in which we take one big leap and several small steps. It involves a type of letting go – letting go of the reigns of control. It involves trusting the students as learners and the learning process. It also involves providing structure to help students when they struggle or need some redirection.
Community of Inquiry Leads to Finding One’s Agency As our program continues to adjust to meet the pre-service teachers’ needs, we believe that our community of inquiry helps them to reexamine issues of power, develop a social justice disposition, raise their consciousness, and consider their roles as moral change agents. We believe that this is just the first step. We realize from our seminar discussions, as we send our pre-service teachers out to student teaching and later teaching, that there are many obstacles that can obstruct their actualization of these teaching principles.
Challenges Alan, a technology pre-service teacher, is unsure what social justice means to his teaching. By the end of his community of inquiry experiences, he begins to embrace constructivist and social justice understandings of teaching and learning but is
42
M. Taylor, G. Otinsky
frustrated when he realizes that his cooperating teacher does not have the same beliefs. He recognizes the political implications of his new framework: Now that I have started student teaching, I am not sure how to teach for social justice. The sixth graders were given projects that stimulated research, critical thinking, and fostered a sense of inquiry. The students that I am working with are asked to sit quietly, take notes, do well on assignments and not cause disruptions.
Alan’s experience represents the voices of many pre-service teachers. Felicia expresses concern about finding a job in a school where she can really “carry out” her social justice beliefs. She wonders if her constructivist practices will be appreciated in all schools. These reflections raise serious questions as we continue to examine what preparing social justice teachers involves. We believe that transparency is essential in terms of our own pedagogical decisions and political advocacy in the field of education. Throughout the community of inquiry experience, we must articulate why we have made the choice to foster a learning community that allows pre-service teachers and students to learn from one another. We must also model the ways in which we navigate bureaucracy, teaching our pre-service teachers both the appropriate language and strategies necessary to work within larger communities of practice. How do we currently do this? We strive to demonstrate the means to publicize our social justice inquiry work. We present our projects to the local school boards, we meet with parents within the school, and we contact local newspaper journalists to write articles about our social justice inquiry projects (Moore, 2005). We attend multiple local and national professional conferences and we attempt to publish about our inquiries in professional journals. We also share with our preservice teachers our own instances of struggle within the university and middle school settings so that they are aware of the methods that we use to make change. We highlight the positive implications of our own membership in multiple diverse learning communities and the ways in which these social networks support our struggles and achievements. We strive to help our pre-service teachers recognize the value of participation in a community of inquiry. We hope that they will, in the future, seek out other like-minded teachers to form their own “communities of practice.” We know that this may be difficult to fathom for new teachers under pressure to conform to the system or to gain tenure, but we believe it adds a dimension of hope for their future potential as change agents. This is an aspect of teacher education that we specifically need to further develop. How can we strengthen our pre-service teachers’ sense of advocacy once they are student teaching and teaching? How can we equip them to develop supportive inquiry communities of their own?
Suggestions The following are suggestions that we offer to educators who hope to develop a community of inquiry that involves pre-service teachers and middle school students:
3 Pre-Service Teachers and Sixth Graders Explore Social Justice ●
●
●
●
●
●
●
43
The relationship between the teacher and university professor must be authentic and built on trust. It is difficult to team teach and negotiate individual roles with a stranger. Building a community of inquiry takes planning time and an element of risk-taking. Inviting students to become inquirers involves letting go of the control of the curriculum and sharing authority with students. The teacher and the university professor will not know all of the answers. Communities of inquiry emerge organically. The inquiry questions emerge authentically. The students need to understand that there will never be a right or wrong answer. They must begin to feel comfortable with the ambiguity. A social justice learning community necessitates safe spaces where inquirers can honestly grapple with difficult topics and tensions can arise. Being transparent about the work of the community of inquiry within the school, at the university, among parents, and in the community is essential in order to receive support.
References Bigelow, B., Harvey, B., Karp, S., & Miller, L. (Eds.). (2001). Rethinking our classrooms: Teaching for equity and justice Volume Two. Milwaukee, WI: Rethinking Schools. Boran, S. & Comber, B. (2001). Introduction: The inquirers and their questions. In S. Boran & B. Comber (Eds.), Critiquing whole language and classroom inquiry (pp. vii–xvii). Urbana, IL: National Council for Teachers of English. Cochran-Smith, M. & Lytle, S. L. (1999). Relationships of knowledge and practice: Teacher learning in communities. In Review of research in education (Vol. 24, pp. 249–306). Washington, DC: American Educational Research Association. Dewey, J. (1997). Democracy and education. New York: Free Press. Freire, P. (1994). Pedagogy of the oppressed. New York: The Continuum Publishing. Glaser, B. G. & Strauss, A. S. (1967). The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research. New York: Aldine De Gruyter. Gordon, R. L. (1980). Interviewing: Strategies, techniques, and tactics. Homewood, IL: Dorsey Press. Harste, J. (2001). What education is and isn’t. In S. Boran & B. Comber (Eds.), Critiquing whole language and classroom inquiry (pp. 1–17). Urbana, IL: National Council for Teachers of English. Lee, E., Menkart, D., & Okazawa-Rey, M. (1998). Beyond heroes and holidays: A practical guide to K-12 anti-racist, multicultural education and staff development. Washington DC: Network of Educators on the Americas. Moore, E. (2005, February 17). Sixth graders target social injustice: College students work with Caldwell middle schoolers. Star Ledger, p. E1. National Council for Accreditation of Teacher Education (2001). Standards for professional development schools (Washington, NCATE). Seidman, I. E. (1991). Interviewing as qualitative research. New York: Teachers’ College Press. Short, K. G., Harste, J. C., & Burke, C. (Eds.). (1996). Creating classrooms for authors and inquirers. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
44
M. Taylor, G. Otinsky
Stock, P. L. (1995). The dialogic curriculum: Teaching and learning in a multicultural society. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann. Sutherland, L. M., Scanlon, L. A., & Sperring, A. (2005). New directions in preparing professionals: Examining issues in engaging students in communities of practice through a schooluniversity partnership. Teaching and Teacher Education, 21, 79–92. Taylor, M. & Coia, L. (2006). Revisiting feminist authority through a co/autoethnographic lens. In D. Tidwell & L. Fitzgerald (Eds.), Self-study research and issues of diversity (pp. 51–70). Rotterdam, The Netherlands: Sense Publishers. Wells, G. (2001). Action, talk, & text: Learning and teaching through inquiry. New York: Teachers College Press. Wenger, E. (1998). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Chapter 2
DICEP: Promoting Collaborative Inquiry in Diverse Educational Settings Barbara Bell-Angus, Greta Davis, Zoe Donoahue, Maria Kowal, and Monica McGlynn-Stewart
Description of the Learning Community Context for the Learning Community The Developing Inquiring Communities in Education Project (DICEP) was formed in 1991 under the leadership of Professor Gordon Wells, who at that time taught at the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education at the University of Toronto. Since then the group has undergone substantial change in its organization and membership. What began as a university–school-based partnership to explore learning through talk in the science classrooms of three elementary school teachers has evolved into a self-directed, collaborative group of six teacher-researchers committed to promoting inquiry as a key mode of learning and teaching at all levels in education. Our group is comprised of elementary, high school, and post-secondary teachers who believe in a common theoretical framework. Currently, our members are teachers of grade three, grade seven French Immersion, undergraduate Early Childhood Education, and pre-service teacher education courses. One member provides professional development opportunities for kindergarten to grade six teachers at the Board level and another is a psycho-educational consultant. We are interested in understanding, in both practice and theory, how to create and sustain communities of inquiry in which all concerned learn with, and from, each other about matters of
B. Bell-Angus and Z. Donoahue Ontario Institute for Studies in Education, University of Toronto G. Davis Durham District School Board M. Kowal Toronto District School Board M. McGlynn-Stewart Ryerson University
A.P. Samaras et al. (eds.) Learning Communities In Practice, © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2008
19
20
B. Bell-Angus et al.
individual and social significance through talk and the generative process of knowledge building. Our group meets on a monthly basis throughout the school year. At our meetings we present and discuss our current inquiries and talk about issues in education. We also collaborate on conference presentations and publications and co-write grant proposals. We hope that by documenting our journey as a group we can contribute to the growing knowledge about learning communities and, in the process, encourage and support others’ work in this area.
Goals of Our Learning Community The goal of our learning community is to provide a safe, supportive and intellectually stimulating place where group members can get feedback about, and ideas for, the inquiries they conduct in their particular settings. Our group is collaborative in nature, and we bring a focus on making meaning through talk to our meetings, as well as to our work with our students. A number of common beliefs have emerged as we have conducted our inquiries. Our ongoing study of theory and current research enables us to function as a cohesive group in spite of our diverse working environments. These beliefs influence how we organize our learning environments, conduct our research, and function as a learning community. Even though our individual research projects are all self-selected and might be very diverse, (e.g., science instruction, kindergarten play, reading growth, teacher professional development), our shared beliefs provide an anchor for our work and enable us to discuss our research with a common language. These beliefs, or theoretical underpinnings, were not simply adapted to our practice but discovered collectively and individually over the course of many inquiries and our work together. Following are the six shared beliefs that underpin our research work. The importance of collaborative knowledge building. Collaboration features strongly in our classrooms and is central to our professional learning community. In our learning environments students and teachers are encouraged to share ideas and to construct their own understanding of particular concepts or topics. In our monthly DICEP meetings, we share our work in progress as we listen to, and question each other. Everyone feels responsible for the success of the group. When one person is presenting his/her current work at a meeting, everyone is truly engaged in thinking about that person’s question. There have been many instances when one of us has come to a meeting thinking that we are not far enough in our current work to share with the group, only to leave with more questions and ideas for new directions, or just a sense that our thoughts and findings, no matter how preliminary, were interesting to someone else. Our group has managed to build a community in which each member’s knowledge and contribution is valued and where informal teacher leaders are not only accepted but encouraged. The importance of having an improvable object. During each inquiry our focus is on improving something about our teaching practice or our students’ learning.
2 DICEP: Promoting Collaborative Inquiry
21
We call this an improvable object. In our classrooms this improvable object might consist of constructing a vehicle powered by an elastic band, using the metaphor of connoisseurship to help our students understand themselves as readers, or investigating the elements that lead to successful classroom discussions. In our professional learning community our improvable object is our teaching practice. Whereas some learning communities are formed with the intention of looking at new ways to apply policy initiatives, our focus is determined by some element of our practice that is currently unsettling in some way. There have been years when several of us have had the same interest that has arisen from our practice, and this has become a focus for the whole group. For example, one year, students in group members’ grade two, grade five and high school classes all asked their teacher if he/she would put in place an incentive programme to reward good behaviour. We were intrigued that students in different schools and at different grade levels would have all made this request at about the same time, and this led us to a year-long focus where the improvable object was students’ motivation. At other times, one of us has brought a new research focus to a meeting, and others have then chosen to explore a similar focus in their settings. The latter is how we came to be interested in involving our students in our inquiries as co-researchers, a focus that spanned a couple of school years. Some years, group members’ topics have been quite varied but might relate to an area we have inquired about in previous years, thus allowing all of us to contribute our knowledge and experience to each other’s current work. This occurred one year when a member was interested in examining the interaction between oral discourse style and competence, and group dynamics in her high school Special Education class, a topic that one of us had pursued years before when she inquired into how to give grade four students greater agency during discussions about books read aloud to the class. In these cases the improvable object was the students’ oral discourse. Whether our inquiries have an individual or group focus, the importance of having an improvable object is central to our individual research in our diverse settings for the duration of the research cycle. The importance of talk as a tool for meaning-making/learning. Purposeful talk is actively promoted in all our classrooms as a means of supporting collaborative knowledge building. Opportunities are provided for students to share, listen to, and question ideas. This classroom talk is also an important form of data in our research. We are interested in hearing learning in action and in including our students’ voices in our research. How to create opportunities for collaborative talk in our classrooms has been an important part of our research agenda and of our monthly meetings. Transcripts of student talk have provided the opportunity for us to slow down and to analyze the learning taking place in our classrooms. This rich data is also a tremendous resource that stimulates discussion, prompts us to ask new questions, and most importantly, impacts future instructional decisions and new cycles of research. Similarly, talk is the tool for the construction of knowledge in our monthly meetings. As we listen to a member share his/her research, we ask questions, make suggestions, and reflect on the data presented. In doing so, each of us is making meaning for ourselves as well as contributing to a collective understanding. In our
22
B. Bell-Angus et al.
group, we have recorded, transcribed, and analyzed our own talk as we periodically “check in” to see if our learning community is meeting our needs and operating in a way that is consistent with our beliefs. The importance of teaching within the student’s zone of proximal development. Since new learning is constructed on the foundation of current knowledge, our role as educators is to ensure that we are teaching students within their zone of proximal development (Vygotsky, 1980). In designing learning activities, we use oral discourse and written assignments as vehicles for determining the level of background knowledge of our individual students and then use that information to inform our instruction. Our role is to scaffold (Wood et al., 1976) our students so that they are able to perform at a higher level than they would be able to perform independently. Initially we may not see the evidence ourselves, but we gain new perspectives at our monthly meetings when we share and/or analyze transcripts or written responses from our students. In our research we frequently make use of questionnaires and reflection sheets to find out about the learners’ perspective of being in our classrooms and then use that information to inform our future practice. For example, one year we were interested in how our students’ perceptions of learning activities matched our goals for them. In order to find out, we would stop students when they were in the middle of an activity and ask them to quickly fill out a sheet that might contain questions such as: “What are you doing right now?”, “What are you learning?”, and “Why do you think your teacher is having you do this?” The information that we gathered from these quick reflections provided excellent feedback for us. It also helped us to plan future activities that provided a better match between our goals and students’ understanding of our goals, and allowed us to better teach our students in their zone of proximal development. The learning/teaching process is of a dialogic nature. Knowledge building and the deep understanding associated with it are best promoted when the teacher acknowledges that a successful classroom is an open community of learners, in which all individuals, students and the teacher, learn from each other. The teacher has an authoritative role to play, but how one enacts this role is influenced by one’s understanding of one’s students, their prior knowledge of the object of study, interests, and learning characteristics. One’s teaching is responsive to the needs and actions of one’s students, whose learning is in turn influenced by these decisions. Our members bring a diversity of knowledge and experience to our group, and this is one of our strengths. We use this diversity to enrich our collaborative understanding of teaching and learning, just as we use our students’ diversity to enrich learning and teaching in the classroom. The importance of providing links with the classroom and the wider world. In organizing our classrooms we provide many opportunities for students to be involved in activities that reflect real-life experiences in various curriculum areas. In science, students are encouraged to develop hypotheses and test them; in geography, students conduct field studies and analyze their findings; in literacy, students are engaged in real conversations about books and they critically analyze their own
2 DICEP: Promoting Collaborative Inquiry
23
craft as writers. In this way, higher-level thinking skills are promoted, content relevance is better appreciated and students become more engaged in their learning. For our group, it is important that we stay connected to the wider world of teacher research and teacher education. We achieve this through publishing, presenting at conferences, and having members who are teacher educators.
Theories That Have Impacted Upon the Design and Implementation of Our Learning Community Many of the initial members of DICEP were graduate students who had taken courses with Gordon Wells and were engaged in classroom inquiry and action research. As a result of our coursework, many of us had read and discussed social constructivist theory and were exploring these principles in our classrooms prior to joining DICEP. Many of the shared beliefs or goals previously mentioned are grounded in the social constructivist framework that unites our group and is central to our work together (Vygotsky, 1980). The constant interplay between sociocultural theory and classroom practice has helped us to ground what we do each day in a consistent theory. So many of our questions over the years have arisen when something has not, in our opinion, been going well. Maintaining the link between theory and practice, and meeting regularly with critical friends who evaluate everything against this theory, has ensured that the courses of action that arise from our inquiries are in keeping with our core beliefs about how people learn best.
Rationale The Importance of a Community for This Work While teaching is an incredibly rewarding profession it can, at times, be exhausting and somewhat isolating. Being a part of DICEP provides the opportunity to talk with individuals who share common beliefs about learning in an inclusive, supportive, and equitable setting. Members bring questions, share classroom data, listen to others talk about their inquiries, and provide feedback. This process supports each of us in the next steps of our own classroom research, and enables us to see the commonalities among our work. As a result, we leave meetings feeling enthused and excited about our classroom inquiries and connected to others in the research community. An opportunity to discuss one’s classroom practice is not always available or welcomed in our work settings. Many school settings establish professional learning communities in response to board-initiated foci, or foci selected by school administrators. There is often little room in these communities to discuss issues that are specific to individual classrooms or to individual’s current questions. The
24
B. Bell-Angus et al.
DICEP community provides a forum for discussion of individual concerns and, as a result, has had a dramatic impact on each of us in our own development as learners and teachers. Many of us agree that without DICEP we would not have sustained our work as teacher researchers. Having monthly meetings, schedules for sharing our work, conference presentations to prepare for, and writing deadlines keeps us accountable and focused on our research in a way that would be difficult, if not impossible, if we were conducting research on our own.
Studying Our Community In 1997, one of our members prepared, distributed, and analyzed an anonymous survey (McGlynn-Stewart, 1998) that provided a forum for members to discuss issues regarding how we functioned as a group. In 1999, the same member facilitated an interactive e-mail conversation among our members for an update as to how we were doing with respect to issues that arose in the earlier survey. During the 2000–2001 school year, there were two reasons that led us to again engage in a process of group reflection. First, our research group had begun a new phase. We had obtained a Spencer Foundation Grant as teacher-researchers after our university-based member had moved and became a long-distance adviser. We wanted to explore whether we felt that this change affected the nature of our group and what we perceived as the advantages and disadvantages. Second, we wanted to investigate our practice in a way that was consistent with what we were asking our students to do, as our focus at the time was on co-researching with our students. We wanted our students to be involved in setting the direction for research about their learning, in investigating their learning as it was happening, and in analyzing the results of the research. In keeping with this focus, we collaboratively designed interview questions for our group members. One member interviewed the other members individually, and was in turn interviewed (McGlynn-Stewart, 2003). He/she then facilitated a group interview, and finally, we met to collaboratively analyze the transcripts of the interviews. Some of the questions we asked ourselves included: ● ● ● ●
What makes this phase of DICEP unique? What is the best part of DICEP for you? What could we improve? Where should we go next?
Within the framework of these simple questions, we discussed a host of issues such as leadership, communication, the relationship between theory and practice, professional development, and our treatment of new members. Many of the findings from this investigation are highlighted in the following sections. One of our most valuable activities was this process of self-reflection. The interviews allowed us to reflect on our current phase of development as a collaborative action research group, to learn new things about each other, and to confirm the value that we place on our learning and teaching relationships. In conjunction with
2 DICEP: Promoting Collaborative Inquiry
25
the earlier survey and e-mail conversation, we now have a written history of our development over a five-year period as seen through self-reflection, and we used this data to make plans for the future. As one member said after reading the transcripts of our interviews: “If you were writing an article with advice to people starting and maintaining a teacher research group, I would suggest that they do some surveying, as you have, on a regular basis. I think it’s really valuable.”
Impact of the Learning Community Member Impact Being members of DICEP has had a dramatic impact on our lives as educators. Over the years, the process of inquiring into our classroom practices has been transformative for both us and for our students. As members of DICEP we are pursuing our own professional development as learners and teachers, while at the same time seeking to provide meaningful and effective learning experiences for our students. Here’s how one member described the professional development she then derived from DICEP: I think that the professional development opportunities that it gives me is the best part of DICEP, the fact that it gives me somebody else to talk to about things that I get excited about in my work. It also makes me do the things I would be doing anyway, but more systematically. I think it keeps me current. I get a chance to talk to people who are on the same wavelength; there’s a common viewpoint there. So I feel quite happy if somebody wants feedback, giving them feedback, and I feel quite happy bringing my stuff in and saying, “There’s this, but I want some help with this.” I feel completely comfortable with that. I get energy for my work through going to a DICEP meeting. DICEP also gives me a chance to attend conferences and to present at conferences. I think it gives me a chance to take leadership in my profession in a way that the school board doesn’t prioritize.
Belonging to a group of like-minded educators who validate our questions and are interested in our findings is very empowering. So often teachers’ day-to-day concerns are trivialized, or we feel that others do not have the same problems or issues as we do. Knowing that we have a monthly opportunity to be heard and that others will value our inquiries has increased our efficacy as professionals. This member’s view appears to be shared by all. People will give their full attention to what you bring, that is the part that makes the group feel so good and so respectful. And the times when I’ve come and I’ve thought, “I don’t know where I’m going with this” and everybody is so interested and they give me the best ideas. I always come away feeling like what I had was valuable and now I know where to go or I have some new questions. You know, just the contribution of the group always refuels what I come with and I never feel worried about what people are going to think. I just want to know what people think.
Listening to another member share her research also enhances our individual inquiries. In thinking about another’s work we often make connections to our own questions or to our own practice. Many of us have left feeling more energized about our own work after engaging in a lively discussion about another member’s inquiry.
26
B. Bell-Angus et al.
As mentioned earlier, being a member of DICEP has benefited us professionally in terms of developing skills as conference presenters, proposal writers, and published authors. Many of these skills have enabled us to pursue a variety of teaching opportunities and to broaden our educational perspectives. One member joined the group as a classroom teacher after finishing her Master’s degree, then became a consultant, founded an independent school, and is now an instructor in an undergraduate education programme. Two of our members became instructors in preservice education after joining DICEP and one has since become a consultant. That our members come from different settings and levels of education has necessitated that we expand our perspectives beyond our own settings, and has allowed us to see the commonalities in our work with learners of different ages. As a result, our research is enriched by the combination of our experiences and perspectives.
Student Impact Membership in DICEP has had a positive impact on our students. Not only have they been the recipients of improved teaching and learning, but they also have had the opportunity to participate in, and in some cases direct, our inquiries. Co-researching with us has enabled our students to truly have a voice in the classroom and to explore questions about who we are, how we live together, and how we learn best. In at least one of the inquiries there was evidence that students not only developed their questioning skills and desire to have ownership of their classroom, but applied these skills in new classroom settings. Next grade teachers commented that our former students often questioned classroom routines and made suggestions that they felt would help to improve their learning environment. Throughout our work, there has also been confirmation that our students felt that they were a valued part of the research process. They were always excited to know that what they said and did in their classrooms was discussed with other educators, presented at conferences, and written about by each of us. Some of us have had the experience of children saying: “Don’t forget to turn on the video camera!” before a discussion, and many children have told us how much they appreciate being asked what they think about school and their learning. Two members describe the effect that their involvement with DICEP has had on their students. My [Special Education] students have benefited, absolutely. And I have some students with whom I have worked for three years and because of working and thinking [with DICEP], it’s allowed me to come up with yet again a slightly different perspective for how to attack the same goal – “How do I get these kids engaged, how do I get them to learn?” And I think now, I do have some kids engaged. And I think that’s movement. I think what I’m doing is giving more power to the kids. I think the kids get a real kick about being included in the research. And I also think that the emphasis that we have on talk, two-way discussion, and interpersonal relationships and the importance we put on talking things through, as opposed to doing everything in writing, has helped my kids tremendously in becoming thinkers for themselves.
2 DICEP: Promoting Collaborative Inquiry
27
Emerging Issues Leadership In our 1997 survey, leadership issues emerged and members indicated a preference for shared leadership within the group. As a result, we started to rotate the positions of chair and secretary during our monthly meetings. During the 1999 conversation, members reported that this increased the level of democracy in the group, but that power was not yet shared equally. By the 2001–2002 school year, we seemed to have evolved into a truly egalitarian and collaborative group. Here is what some of our members said: I just love the way we take turns so naturally in leadership, the way we support each other. No one is trying to prove anything … just people who sincerely are good teachers, they’re questioners, thinkers, and they want to be better. The way we work together is joint leadership, shared leadership, with specific targets and goals, and it’s self-directed, not because someone is having us do it. Well, I think the main difference [from earlier phases] is that the group truly is run as a democracy now, and there doesn’t appear to be anybody who is a leader of the group, we’re all sharing that responsibility equally.
A significant change to our group dynamics occurred when the founder of the group, Gordon Wells, moved to California. While we agreed that there was a sense of loss with his departure, we were very positive about the way our group subsequently functioned. As a result of Gordon leaving the group, we were challenged to write a grant proposal on our own for the first time and to assume all aspects of administration for the group. While this has resulted in more work for us, it has increased our sense of ownership in the group. We feel that we have made gains since being on our own, but we also miss Gordon and his knowledge and expertise. The trajectory of the group’s evolution, from Master’s/Doctoral students collaborating with their university professor to teachers taking control of all aspects of the group’s functioning, has been a very empowering process for us all. Over the years we gradually took over the jobs of writing grant and conference proposals, presenting at conferences and planning and conducting monthly meetings. Working alongside an expert in the early years of the group allowed us to envision how we could see ourselves as researchers, not “just teachers”. Another theme that arose is also connected to Gordon’s departure. Individually and collectively we have always striven to remain informed about current research and theory through reading and conference participation. One of our sources of current literature was Gordon, as he taught courses on action research and sociocultural theory, and was always up to date on the latest research. The interview process revealed that we all felt the loss of his contributions in this area, and that we needed to increase our efforts to find relevant resources about research and theory during this phase. We knew we needed to incorporate more reading and discussion of relevant articles into our monthly meetings.
28
B. Bell-Angus et al.
Meetings As we took on the task of running the group ourselves, we realized the importance of setting the agenda for our meetings ahead of time. At the beginning of the school year, we asked everyone to choose a meeting where they will share their current research in detail. This gives us all a goal to work towards, and we know we will have an audience, even if our work is at a very preliminary stage. Other parts of the agenda are put in place by way of an e-mail sent out about a week before the meeting by that month’s chair. We always leave room at the end of each meeting for other business. Setting meeting dates that work for everyone is a constant challenge. We try to set several months’ meeting dates at a time, but inevitably find that someone has a conflict as the date nears. Sometimes we have met without that person; when possible we have rescheduled the meeting to a time when everyone can be there.
Group Size Over the years the size of our group has fluctuated between five and about twelve members. We believe that group size is a critical factor in the investment that members make in the group. If the group is too large, people may not feel that it is important that they attend every meeting, and everyone may not have a chance to speak. A group that is too small will suffer if just one person needs to miss a meeting, as everyone’s presence and voice is so necessary. We have found it is optimal to have about six members. Everyone has a chance to speak and feels that his/her presence at meetings is essential. We know one another well and take time at the beginning and throughout our monthly meetings to catch up on each other’s personal and professional lives. We are able to engage deeply with the inquiry work of five other professionals and to make connections with our own work.
New Members A strong theme of both the 1997 group survey and the 1999 e-mail conversation was that the main attraction and strength of DICEP is the supportive and constructive atmosphere it provides for teaching and learning. The 2001–2002 interview findings were no different. We welcomed two new members during this phase, and through the interview process discovered that they had had very different initial experiences with DICEP than members who had been with the group since its inception. One member, a high school Special Education teacher, joined just as we were finalizing a grant proposal. This is how she described her initial experiences.
2 DICEP: Promoting Collaborative Inquiry
29
I did always feel welcome . . . and I found you incredibly welcoming, incredibly generous. You gave me enough [information about the group] for the minute, and when I needed more you gave it to me. And I always felt that if I wanted to ask for more, I’d get it.
The other new person, a university professor, also felt that we were friendly, but she did not feel she was given the information that she needed to fully contribute. She described her feelings. I loved everybody instantly, like I got the best, best, best feelings. But I was nervous being an outsider, being a university professor because I didn’t want people to think that I thought something different. And I wasn’t part of the original grant, the Spencer Grant that you have now. And I remember thinking well, I want to ask to see the Spencer Grant, but then I thought that might be too presumptuous. I was always trying to piece together who was who … and so I still couldn’t ask any of these questions because then I felt well, I’m going to sound too pushy.
During the course of the individual interviews and the later group interview and group analysis, we discovered why these two new members had had such different initial experiences with DICEP. With the first member, we assumed that she knew very little about us, so we made an effort to give her as much information about the grant and about us as we could. With the second member, we assumed that she already knew about us and our work because she was a colleague of Gordon Wells. The first member assumed that her questions would be perfectly acceptable, while the second member was worried that we might think her questions were “pushy”. The interview process gave us the opportunity to examine our assumptions. We hope to learn from this experience by asking more questions of new members to ensure that we are meeting their needs. As one member said: I was struck with the fact that we don’t have a protocol in place for welcoming newcomers. I think [the second new member’s] comments will help us to be more aware of what we need to do, beyond being kind, welcoming and inclusive, when someone new comes into the group.
Funding Our group was most productive when we were supported with funding from the Spencer Foundation, which ended in 2003. The funding allowed us to release members from teaching responsibilities and to have day-long meetings once a term. With this extra time, we found we were able to delve more deeply into our research and that we accomplished a great deal during those full-day sessions. The funding also enabled us to participate in, and present at, teacher-research conferences. We are not currently funded, but we make the time to meet together regularly outside our working hours and we look for local opportunities to share our work. E-mail has been an invaluable tool in keeping us connected and saving us time. We are able to be more productive with our meeting times because we have discussed, shared, and in some cases, such as this book chapter, written together via e-mail.
30
B. Bell-Angus et al.
Applicability of Our Learning Community to Other Settings While we share a common theoretical framework, our diverse educational roles bring rich perspectives to the inquiries we undertake. We believe this diversity deepens our subsequent understanding of the inquiries. Passing the buck, for instance, is never an option. For example, our middle-school teacher would never suggest that a problematic issue in her classroom would be solved if primary/junior teachers prepared the students better. On the contrary, she has been able to learn from her colleagues in other educational contexts about their relative perspectives and experiences and use this feedback to inform her understanding of her own classroom. We are a community of equals, each with expertise in our respective contexts and as such, we can have unique and valuable insights to contribute to our group’s understanding. In our opinion, non-hierarchical, inter-institutional diversity has rich potential in all settings of educational inquiry.
Findings from Developing Our Learning Community Through our work over the years, we have gained valuable insight about developing and maintaining a diverse learning community. Following are our key findings. We have found it beneficial to: ● ●
● ● ● ● ●
● ●
Have a common theoretical framework Have shared goals that provide a focus, such as writing for publication, applying for grants, presenting at conferences Generate questions from classroom practice (must be choice and job-embedded) Maintain a group size that is small enough to be accountable and is stable Designate time to present/share research at meetings Share roles within the group Share inquiries that focus on evidence of student learning (transcripts of classroom discussions, journal entries, etc.) Include members from diverse settings Enjoy each other’s company; both personal and professional relationships are important
References McGlynn-Stewart, M. (1998). Researching the researchers, Orbit, 29(3), 22–25. McGlynn-Stewart, M. (2003). Co-researching the researchers: DICEP’s ongoing self-reflection, Networks: An Online Journal of Teacher Research, 6(1). Available at: http://journals.library. wisc.edu/index.php/networks Vygotsky, L. (1980). Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Wood, D., Bruner, J., & Ross, G. (1976). The role of tutoring in problem solving, Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 17(2), 89–100.
Chapter 4
Lights, Camera, Action! Using Slowmation as a Common Teaching Approach to Promote a School Learning Community Garry F. Hoban
Introduction The Origins of “Community” Although the notion of a “community” is commonly used in current educational literature, the term is quite old. It was first mentioned by John Dewey over 110 years ago, when he envisaged that classrooms should be organised like a community rather than simply being places for the dissemination of knowledge. Dewey’s theory of “learning through experience” was based on the assumption that learning involves an interaction between psychological processes focused on the individual, and sociological processes focused on how an individual interacts with others. The example he often used in describing the interaction between psychological and sociological processes was children learning to talk in the ideal community environment of an educated family. I believe that this educational process has two sides – one psychological and one sociological; and that neither can be subordinated to the other or neglected without evil results following. Of these two sides, the psychological is the basis. The child’s own instincts and powers furnish the material and give the starting point for all education. … I believe that knowledge of social conditions, of the present state of civilization, is necessary in order properly to interpret the child’s powers. (Dewey, 1897, pp. 4–5)
The psychological processes were the personal experiences that an individual brings to the situation and so “education, therefore, must begin with a psychological insight into the child’s capacities, interests and habits” (Dewey, 1897, p. 6). He believed that organizing classroom activities based on the notion of a community generated motivation and a social spirit for children centred on “sharing in each other’s activities and each other’s experiences because they have common ends and purposes” (Dewey, 1916, p. 75). Hence, personal experiences are scaffolded or extended by social interactions with others. Moreover, Dewey criticised traditional educational classrooms because they were not organised in a way which encouraged students to share as a community.
G.F. Hoban University of Wollongong
A.P. Samaras et al. (eds.) Learning Communities In Practice, © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2008
45
46
G.F. Hoban I believe that much of present education fails because it neglects this fundamental principle of the school as a form of community life. It conceives the school as a place where certain information is to be given, where certain lessons are to be learned, or where certain habits are to be formed. The value of these is conceived as lying largely in the remote future; the child must do these things for the sake of something else he is to do; they are mere preparation. As a result they do not become part of the life experience of the child and so are not truly educative. (Dewey, 1897, p. 8; italics inserted by author)
In particular, the educative role of a community is to extend personal understanding by sharing ideas with others who may have different experiences and perspectives. Dewey (1938), therefore, believed that the role of a classroom teacher should be to scaffold the existing experiences of children by organising activities and by providing appropriate subject matter. I do not know what the greater maturity of the teacher and the teacher’s greater knowledge of the world, of subject-matters and of individuals, is for unless the teacher can arrange conditions that are conducive to community activity and to organization which exercises control over individual impulses by the mere fact that all are engaged in communal projects. … The planning must be flexible enough to permit free play for individuality of experience and firm enough to give direction towards continuous development of power. (Dewey, 1938, p. 58; italics inserted by author)
The Relevance of “Community” for Teacher Learning The importance of social interactions for children’s learning that Dewey highlighted is also applicable to professional learning for teachers. When schools are viewed as learning communities for teachers, the key feature is the social interaction with colleagues to share ideas embodied in phrases such as “shared decision making; information sharing and communication” (Darling-Hammond, 1994), “shared vision and team learning” (Senge, 1990), and “collective goals of understanding and judgment” (Bereiter & Scardamalia, 1993). A study of 22 English and history teachers conducted at one high school over 18 months (Grossman & Wineburg, 2000) showed that the formation of a community of teachers goes through several stages. Importantly, the researchers made the point that there is a difference between a community of teacher learners and a gathering of teachers who simply share ideas. The researchers noted four stages in the development of a community of teacher learners: (1) formation of group identity and norms of interaction; (2) understanding difference/navigating fault lines; (3) negotiating the essential tension; and (4) taking communal responsibility for individuals’ growth. Hence, a community of teachers grows and develops through sharing ideas, encouraging positive and negative feedback, and developing mutual understanding. In this chapter, the process and outcomes of forming a community of teacher learners will be described as it occurred in an elementary school in Australia. A particular feature of this initiative is that the teachers were all attempting to learn to use a new teaching approach, called “Slowmation,” which greatly simplifies the process of making digital animations so that school children become the animation
4 Lights, Camera, Action! Using Slowmation
47
creators. Hence, the purpose of the professional learning programme was to introduce a new teaching approach in the school with the intention that all the teachers might use this new teaching approach and share their experiences as a community. As clearly pointed out by Grossman and Wineburg (2000), the notion of community has been loosely used in the education literature, and a “gathering of teachers” is not necessarily a “community of teacher learners.” Moreover, a community of teachers has to share something. It may be resources, teaching ideas, technology, reflections and discussions about different children, or about other staff members. In this nine month study, the focus was on introducing a new teaching approach into the school with the goal being that the school might organise a whole-school “animation film night” to share the animations produced as an artefact of the learning from each classroom.
Description of the Learning Community Conditions for Teacher Learning A full-day professional development programme to introduce the new teaching approach was organised for the school at the beginning of the second school term in April, 2007. The author has had extensive experience in running professional development programmes (Hoban, 2002, 2003; Hoban et al., 2007). The new teaching approach, “Slowmation” (abbreviated from “Slow Animation”), incorporates a new form of stop-motion animation that greatly simplifies the normally complex process so that they can be created by learners (Hoban, 2005, 2007, in press). The process has been developed over the last three years by the author in science education classes at the University of Wollongong, Australia; slowmation is a simplified form of stop-motion animation involving the manual manipulation of materials with digital still photos taken at each step that are uploaded into a computer program to play them in a sequence to create an illusion of movement. Because the animation process is relatively simple, animations can be made about a variety of educational concepts in science, maths, English, and social studies. It was not an accident that this particular school was chosen to pilot this new approach to professional learning. The school in fact had various “conditions for teacher learning” (Hoban, 2002) already in place that made it likely that a community could be initiated: (i) The teachers had access to the necessary technology and resources because the principal had bought each teacher a laptop computer with the necessary program, i.e. QuickTime Pro (if using a PC then Windows Movie Maker can also be used). In addition the principal also bought eight digital still cameras and tripods for mounting the digital still cameras.
48
G.F. Hoban
(ii) The teachers had a need or purpose to try a new teaching approach in their classes. (iii) One of the teachers was very familiar with using the technology and the teaching approach as he had been employed as a tutor at the university and so became an in-school facilitator who was able to supply “just in time support” for the teachers in the school. (iv) The principal was very supportive of the teachers using this new teaching approach and hoped that the teachers would each make an animation in their class and be able to be involved as a “whole school project.” The goal of the programme was for each teacher to create slowmations with their class to present at an “animation film night” at the end of the year to parents and the local community. In addition, several other conditions identified in previous research that were conducive to school change (Hoban, 2002) were in place. They included: conceptual inputs in terms of new ideas (slowmation), a long-term time frame of nine months to initiate change, a willingness by teachers to instigate action and try out new ideas, and an established collegial atmosphere in the school to provide a likely environment for the sharing of ideas.
Introducing Slowmation Slowmation is a new form of stop-animation that is similar to clay animation involving students researching information, scripting, storyboarding, designing models, photographing digital still images of small manual movements of the models, and using a computer program such as Apple’s QuickTime Pro or Window’s Movie Maker to create the animation. Slowmation, however, is different from claymation in six key ways as shown in Table 4.1. Slowmations can be like “mini-movies” explaining science concepts averaging 3–5 minutes in length, or shorter one-minute assessment tasks. Over the last two years, over 400 animated movies have been made by preservice primary teachers about many science concepts including day and night, seasons, lunar cycles, life cycles of various animals, particle motion, magnets, fungi life cycle, plant reproduction, weather, movement of the planets, water cycle, simple machines, mitosis, meiosis, and phagocytosis. Because slowmations are played ten times slower (two frames/second) and are easier to make than traditional animations (played at 25 frames/second), learners can represent their own understandings of science concepts in very comprehensive ways (Hoban & Ferry, 2006). Slowmations can be created as comprehensive teaching resources and can take up to 20 hours to make, or shorter slowmations can be made by students in one hour as an assessment task to represent their understanding of a particular concept. On the professional development day, teachers were introduced to the slowmation teaching approach. After the facilitator (the author) demonstrated the approach,
4 Lights, Camera, Action! Using Slowmation
49
Table 4.1 Comparative features of slowmation and claymation Feature Claymation Slowmation Purpose To tell a narrative or story (i) create a resource to teach a major concept (ii) as an assessment task to explain a smaller concept. Content English Science and maths but can be used in other subjects Orientation Models are made to stand up Models are mostly made flat on the floor vertically and manually and manually manipulated in the horimanipulated as they are zontal plane as they are photographed photographed with a digital with a digital camera mounted on a tristill camera mounted on a pod looking down at the models (this is tripod looking across at the not always the case, however, as existmodels. ing plastic models can be photographed in the usual way). Materials Clay or plasticine A wide variety such as soft play dough, plasticine, 2D pictures, drawings, clip art, existing 3D models, leaves, rocks, paper, fruit, felt, cardboard cut-outs and many everyday classroom materials. Learning prompts The art of telling the story Prompts are included to help explain a explains the experience concept such as audio narration, music, authentic photos, humour, diagrams, models, labels, questions, static images, repetitions, and characters. Timing Shown quickly at 20–24 Shown slowly at 2–4 frames/second to frames/second to simulate demonstrate a concept in slow motion real movement and hence the name “Slowmation”
teachers were given opportunities to make a slowmation themselves in any subject area that they selected. The teachers were successful to different extents on the day and some had to finish their animations later. They were then encouraged to try to make one with their class about any topic. Because the 10 teachers involved had different levels of technological expertise, it was intended that the teachers would help each other.
The Pedagogy of Slowmation As previously explained, slowmation greatly simplifies the normally complex process of creating animations and it is supported by a four-phase teaching approach as explained below (Hoban, in press): Phase 1: Planning. The teacher and/or preservice teachers plan how to represent a topic or concept which involves change. This can be done in one of two ways. One way is to get students to research a particular topic, which they do not know
50
G.F. Hoban
much about, as a project that will extend for a long period of time such as several days. Alternatively, the approach can be used over several lessons for students to represent what they have learned about a topic as an assessment task. The size of the concept is related to how much time is available and how familiar the students are with the process. Phase 2: Storyboarding. There are two forms of storyboarding which support the content that was researched, selected, and refined in the first phase. First, the content is chunked or broken down into several sections or episodes. The chunks focus on the main parts of the concept. An explanation needs to be provided with each chunk. Second, each “chunk” is sequenced into 10–20 movements that can be sketched as a storyboard. This analysis can guide an individual or group in making a complete slowmation, or each chunk can be allocated to a group of students similar to a “jigsaw” pedagogical approach so that the animation becomes a class project. For example, a chunk could include one of the life stages of a frog, one of the four seasons, one of the stages of a rocket take-off, one stage of a volcano developing, one part of meiosis or mitosis, or one part of a chemical equation. A key activity in sequencing storyboarding and scripting is the planning of learning prompts such as authentic photographs, labels, static images, or titles. It could also have a narrated explanation and/or music. It is unwise to have too much text, narration and music as it presents too much information and can be confusing as explained in Sweller’s Cognitive Load Theory (Sweller, 2006). Phase 3: Construction. This phase involves making and photographing the models. It is best if the models are made on a sheet of project cardboard or butcher’s paper on the floor as a backdrop. Existing models that are readily available in a classroom can be used, or new models can be made with play dough or modelling clay. Specific responsibilities can be allocated to members of a group, if required. These could include: storyboarder, model maker, scriptwriter, sign maker (for title, ending, or descriptions for a particular photo), photographer, and background designer. A digital still camera needs to be mounted on a tripod and positioned over a sheet of cardboard so that pictures can be shot looking down at the models. As the students manually make the small movements in the model, a photograph is taken at each step. The photographer needs to take at least 20–30 still photographs of each chunk. It is simpler if the photographs are taken in order of the presentation of the chunks for the whole story. Another way is for each group to have their own camera and then have the different QuickTime movies collated together when editing. Phase 4: Reconstruction. Once all the digital still photographs are taken, they need to be downloaded on to a computer, copied on to the desktop, and imported into a computer program to put the photos in a sequence to create the animation. A program such as QuickTime Pro available on Apple computer software or Window’s Movie Maker available on a PC is needed to import the photographs. The playback speed selected is usually two frames/second to slow the process down and a QuickTime movie is produced that can be played on any computer, PC or Macintosh. Once the initial animation is created, refinements need to be made to
4 Lights, Camera, Action! Using Slowmation
51
enhance and edit the animation. These can be made in several ways and are called learning prompts such as adding music, factual text, labels, static images, transitions, other backgrounds, or a narration. Research has showed that it is important for students to add a narration as this is the final layer of reflection to explain a science concept. The slowmations can be uploaded to web sites such as YouTube or Teacher Tube for public display.
Implementation of the Professional Learning Programme To assess the extent to which the teachers were sharing ideas about using the teaching approach in their classrooms and sharing ideas as a “community,” the animations that they produced were monitored. As seen in Table 4.2, all of the classes created at least one slowmation after six weeks. The classes made slowmations in four different subject areas: science, mathematics, social studies, and English. To gain an understanding of how the teachers were using the approach, several teachers were interviewed. The class that made the most slowmations was kindergarten, and so two of the teachers and the in-school facilitator were interviewed five months after the professional development programme started to ascertain their views on how they used the teaching approach.
Slowmations Made by the Kindergarten Classes Figure 4.1 shows some of the images from the math slowmation that the kindergarten children made about the number 10 entitled “Ways to Make 10.” The intention for creating an animation about counting was to provide the children with a deeper
Table 4.2 Some animation topics made by each class Class Topic Subject Kindergarten Incy Wincy Spider, Jack English and mathand Jill, Hickory Dickory ematics Dock, counting, ordinal numbers, sounds of the alphabet and counting to ten Grade 1 Ivy growing on back fence English Grade 2 Tom Thumb Lagoon Social science (aboriginal perspective) Grade 3 Volcanic eruptions Science Grade 4 Division and multiplication Mathematics Grade 5 Water evaporation and Science global warming Grade 6 Heat absorption Science
Extent of project completion All seven completed
Completed Completed but needed editing Completed Completed Completed Completed
52
G.F. Hoban
Fig. 4.1 Still photos from kindergarten slowmation Chunk 1: Title of the slowmation Chunk 2: Representing 10 as “five groups of two” Chunk 3: A circle of the number 10 Photo of a kindergarten group making their slowmation
understanding of the concept of “number” which is important in kindergarten. Small dolls were used to represent the numbers, and in addition to counting, the slowmation demonstrates the children showing different representations of the number 10 such as “two groups of five”, “five groups of two”, and a “circle of ten.” Also, in Fig. 4.1, there is a photo of the children working in groups taking the digital still photos as they created their slowmation. Note that in the group, one of the kindergarten children was standing on a chair to use the digital camera, but did this quite easily and they rotated their role as “camera operator” in the group. Two of the kindergarten teachers said that after the professional day they practised the teaching approach with their own young children at home to learn the process before using it in their teaching. These two teachers often team taught their two classes so in all there were 38 children in the combined class. The teachers explained that when they first started using slowmation, they did it as a whole class and made a few small ones about nursery rhymes such as “Incy Wincy Spider” and “Jack and Jill.” The whole process was very teacher-directed with the teachers taking the photos and moving the play dough models. After the teachers had made the
4 Lights, Camera, Action! Using Slowmation
53
first animated movie, they progressively shared the responsibility by asking the children to take the photos and also make the model movements. As they used the new teaching approach, they began to introduce more group work. Teacher: We started as a whole group, the whole 38 of us, with Marina and I both involved doing nursery rhymes. That worked really well and we started off trying to get the kids to do the little steps … and we were controlling most of the process … yes we were taking photos to begin with, but that was only for the first one. And then in the second one we started getting the kids involved and getting the kids up to take the photographs. And already the kids had switched on to slow movements, making very small slow movements. We did several of those. We’ve done Hickory Dickory Dock, Jack and Jill, IncyWincy Spider.
The reason the class made seven slowmations in one school term was that it was very engaging for the children. Also after several tries, they then put the children into groups of five or six and gave them specific roles with each group having a camera and tripod like a mini production set. One teacher stated: Teacher: They were so engaged and so enthusiastic about it and the activity was very easy … it ran by itself almost. They’re just so interested in it, it’s exciting. They enjoy doing it. They like the camera, they like the roles that they’re given. And each member of a group had a specific role which kept them on task so we had a camera operator, a director who was in charge of the group and organised the group. And then that day, we had race assistants and when we did the car races each student had a number 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 for their specific car so it is important that the children have a role.
The teachers explained how they used the teaching approach and allocated roles to the students. Teacher: There’s a lot of preparation beforehand. Like organising all the roles and who needs to do what and we actually look at the kids and see who they’re going to work with in that group. And there is a lot of explaining. We explain the activity to them and then we pretty much do it in one go. The kids are getting familiar with those roles and we’ve used them more often. So we’ve explained the roles to them about what a director does and the camera operator. All the children agreed that the director was in charge of the group and made important decisions and ran the group. But all the other children had an important role too, so they all had something to do that kept them interested.
When asked why it was important for kindergarten children to have roles, a teacher responded: Teacher: It gave each child a focus, it kept them on task, on their specific task. Otherwise they’d be fighting over the camera. There is a lot of time preparing and organising the materials … there’s a few hours the night before making up the game boards. It just depends which one we’re talking about but the one that we … the race one we did was so organised that the kids sort of knew what they needed to do and just went off and did it.
One of the important insights from the teachers is that since the children have made seven slowmations in one school term, they now understand the process and have become more independent in making the animations. Teacher: And because we’d done lots before, they knew the process they needed to go through, they needed to start, they needed to make small steps and they actually did smaller steps than what I’d originally expected. And the children are now enjoying it that much and are getting into it so much that they’ve started to become aware of the process and tell each other what to do. … “There’s a shadow there so move out of the way, you know like I’m trying to take the
54
G.F. Hoban photo” and “you’re in my way, your hands in the way” so they’re really getting into it now. So they know what do to do by themselves. They know first that you need to set their scene and that they make a small movement, take a photo, make a movement, take a photo and so on.
One of the most interesting slowmations which was made over several weeks by the class was one demonstrating all the sounds of the alphabet with an image for each letter accompanied by the particular sound.
Interview with the Teacher Facilitator The teacher who was the in-school facilitator was very familiar with the process as he was a tutor in the university subject where the process was developed. He was a key person in the school as he was providing “just in time” support for the teachers. In an interview the facilitator stated what the plan was for implementing the professional development. Teacher: After that day each of the teachers were to go back and try and make one with their class, come up with a topic, and do it after they had made it. Each of the classes have made them, some of the teachers are obviously more into it than others. Like the kindergarten teachers have just picked it up and run with it. My class obviously did it. Some of the teachers, whilst they’d already made one themselves on the staff development day, still didn’t get the equipment. Like they didn’t open the tripod out, they sort of just carried the tripod around and so it’s jumping everywhere. So I know a couple of the teachers on the first ones they’ve done they weren’t happy with it because they could just see the final presentation and think “Oh no this is not good enough.”
He explained how important it was to have an in-school facilitator to help create change in a school. Teacher: For anything to work in the school, someone’s got to drive it, if you don’t have someone who’s passionate about it driving, it won’t work even if they do understand the computer program. Now if they’ve got the passion and the drive for it, two things might happen. First, they might not be able to use the program and they’ll just lose interest and it’ll drop out. Second, they’ll be passionate for it and they’ll find out how to use it. They’ll fiddle around with it themselves and therefore they can use it but you do need someone who will drive it, but I mean that’s the same with anything.
Interviewer: Alright, so what are the goals for the school then do you think? Teacher: By the end of this term we want to have that animation film night. After that it won’t necessarily be a school project, however, there’s going to be a big technology push within the school, you know with the new grants we’re getting and stuff like that. I know the kindergarten teachers have especially said they’ve got to continue using the digital cameras, whether that’s for slow animation or not it’s going to depend. I’d like to see more of them go and I can push for that. I don’t know how … I know the kindergarten teachers will still do it next year, I don’t have any doubt they’re going to do a slow animation. I think a couple of other teachers may try one or do one throughout the year, I don’t know how big it will get.
The teacher also commented on the importance of teachers sharing their ideas especially if it is to be a whole-school project. Although he did not use the word “com-
4 Lights, Camera, Action! Using Slowmation
55
munity,” he discussed the importance of having whole-school goals which give a purpose for teachers to share and discuss ideas. Teacher: The teachers still see it as a school project. So I think in some ways, yes, but I think it’s the time that’s actually hard because it can be time consuming. And I know especially this term we’ve had Southern Stars going on and camp going on and this day going on, there’s been so many interruptions that I know a lot of them haven’t had a chance to spend the time on it. But yeah people do talk about it and I showed some of them at the staff meeting. I said “Oh this is some of the stuff that the people have done.” We showed the kindergarten ones, so the other teachers were impressed by them. Interviewer: Alright, so it’s still seen as a school project, everyone’s made one? Teacher: Everyone’s made one. Interviewer: Okay. Now what’s special about the kindergarten teachers, because it is a bit of a special situation actually I think? Teacher: For them, they just get so excited … they’ve been able to practice at home and they understand the technology. I show it to them once, they go and do it and they now help others.
The Big Night On Wednesday, 5 December 2007, the Coniston Public School Animation Film Night was organised and presented in the school hall. The children and teachers dressed up in theatre-like costumes, music was playing and the children sold pop corn. It ran for one and a half hours from 6:00 p.m. to 7:30 p.m. Every class in the school, grades K-6, showed two animations from a range of subject areas – science, English, mathematics and social studies. Each animation was introduced by a child from the class who told the audience of 150 people about the title and how it was made. From all who attended, teachers, children, and parents, it was a big success. It was the first animation film night held by a primary school in the region and possibly in the country, displaying and explaining animations made by every class in the school. A media release was prepared and there was an article in the local newspaper as well as an article on the University of Wollongong web site. Figure 4.2 shows a photo taken of the audience on the night at an apparently funny moment during one of the animations. You can see one of the children, Faith, dressed up in the front row in a long maroon coloured dress with a purple “boa” around her neck. You can see that the audience was made up of school children and parents with the author in the front row next to the child from kindergarten. The animation film night was fun for all, but it signified another important event. It was a clear outcome demonstrating that the school had developed into a learning community. As every class in the school had made at least two animations, it was a concrete goal for all the teachers and children to work towards. It was decided at the end of the night by the principal and the teachers that every class would continue to make slowmations about different educational concepts next year, and that they would hold another animation film night in 2008. A compact disc containing all of this year’s animations is now on sale at the school for US$3.
56
G.F. Hoban
Fig. 4.2 The audience at the Coniston Public School’s animation film night
Discussion From the follow-up observations at the school, interviews with various teachers, and the animation film night, it was clear that a learning community had been initiated by the introduction of the slowmation teaching approach into the school. Not only had each of the teachers in the school made a slowmation with their children, but they had been sharing their expertise and experiences in staff meetings and informally. In particular, the teacher who had been using the approach for three years became the in-school facilitator and the two teachers who had made the most number of slowmations, the kindergarten teachers, were also being called upon by other teachers to share their newly acquired expertise. Also, because the animations were concrete artefacts, the teachers were able to share them with each other and show what their class had produced. So it was not just talking about teaching but sharing real products. It involved a “shared vision and team learning” (Senge, 1990). One consideration for discussing the initiation of a learning community in the school was that it was ripe to begin such a community. This was because several key conditions for teacher learning were already in place, such as teachers having access to the required technology (each teacher had a laptop and there were eight digital cameras in the school), the principal was very encouraging, and the teachers were keen to try something new. Most importantly, there was an expert user of slowmation in the school already who was very happy to share his knowledge. Further evidence that a community had formed in the school is that the level of shared expertise increased. For example, the number of “experts” in the school had
4 Lights, Camera, Action! Using Slowmation
57
expanded from one (the teacher facilitator) to three (with the two kindergarten teachers), which provided additional expertise to support the rest of the staff in using the approach and developing into a community. One other feature was critical for initiating this community. Although the slowmation teaching approach has mainly been used to develop science animations, the approach is simple enough to be used in other subject areas. For this reason, teachers were allowed to choose their own subject area, and from Table 4.2 it can be seen that the range included science, mathematics, English, and social science. Hence, the innovation is simple and versatile enough for each of the teachers to have a particular “buy in” and find a particular topic to explore, develop, and show to others. Initiating a community of teacher learners who can implement and share slowmations is possible in other schools, but careful planning needs to occur to ensure that the necessary conditions for teacher learning (Hoban, 2002) are present to increase the likelihood that this will occur. Hence, a principal needs to be confident that the teachers have a perceived need to try a new teaching approach, teachers have access to the required technology such as computers, tripods and digital cameras, and that there is back-up support within the school. Although this community of teacher learners has developed, I would suggest that it is only in stage 1 of Grossman and Wineburg’s (2000) framework, “formation of group identity and norms of interaction.” Perhaps before the new teaching approach was introduced, the teachers were more like a “gathering” sharing social interactions, not necessarily fostering each others’ professional learning. But certainly in the last nine months the teachers have found new ways to promote interaction about classroom practice, because they were introduced to a new teaching approach that could be used by all teachers and discussed across different grades and subjects. The “Animation Film Night” conducted on Wednesday, 5 December, was a significant whole-school achievement and was a demonstrated outcome that a learning community had formed. This chapter explains how a school learning community was initiated and developed when introduced to something as novel as a common teaching approach based on digital animation. Although the idea of an animation film night was mentioned as a possibility on the first day of the professional learning programme, the chance of it occurring was unknown. In terms of the future prospects for this emerging professional learning community, a longer study would be needed to ascertain if this community progresses through the other Grossman and Wineburg’s stages to engage in “taking communal responsibility for individual’s growth” whereby the teachers monitor and support each others’ professional learning. However, after the huge success of the animation film night that produced widespread public praise for the school, the teachers plan to do it again next year and make it “bigger and better.” This provides a goal and process for the teachers to build on the interactions this year and grow as a learning community. Furthermore, it is possible that other schools in the area may initiate the use of this new teaching approach, and so time will tell if this type of learning community will expand to include other schools. Hopefully, the animation film night will become an annual event in Wollongong involving multiple school-based learning communities.
58
G.F. Hoban
Acknowledgements The author would like to acknowledge the teachers at Coniston Public School in Wollongong for their involvement in this project. Particular thanks also goes to the teacher who tutors at the University of Wollongong, Trent Whittaker, who became the school facilitator and the three kindergarten teachers, Nicole Flynn, Marina Zayakovski, and Christine Yates for their specific contribution to this chapter.
References Bereiter, C. & Scardamalia, M. (1993). Surpassing ourselves: An inquiry into the nature and implications of expertise. Chicago, IL: Open Court. Darling-Hammond, L. (Ed.). (1994). Professional development schools: Schools for developing a profession. New York: Teachers College Press. Dewey, J. (1897). My pedagogic creed. New York: E. L. Kellogg. Dewey, J. (1916). Democracy and education. New York: Macmillan. Dewey, J. (1938). Experience and education. New York: Collier Books. Grossman, P. & Wineburg, S. (2000). What makes teacher community different from a gathering of teachers? Washington: Center for the Study of Teaching and Policy, University of Washington. Hoban, G. (2005). From claymation to slowmation: A teaching procedure to develop students’ science understandings. Teaching Science: Australian Science Teachers Journal, 51(2), 26–30. Hoban, G. (2007). Using slowmation to engage preservice elementary teachers in understanding science content knowledge. Contemporary Issues in Technology and Teacher Education, 7(2), 1–9. Hoban, G. (2009). Facilitating learner-generated animations with slowmation. In L. Lockyer, S. Bennett, S. Agostino, & B. Harper (Eds.), Handbook of research on learning designs and learning objects: Issues, applications and technologies (pp. 312–329). Hershey, PA: IGI Global. Hoban, G. F. (2002). Teacher learning for educational change: A systems thinking approach. Buckingham and Philadelphia, PA: Open University Press. Hoban, G. F. (2003). Changing the balance of a science teacher’s belief system. In J. Wallace & J. J. Loughran (Eds.), Leadership in science education. London: Routledge Falmer. Hoban, G., & Ferry, B. (2006). Teaching science concepts in higher education classes with slow motion animation (slowmation). In T. Reeves & S. Yamashita (Eds.), Proceedings of E-Learn, 2006 World conference on E-Learning in Corporate, Government, Healthcare & Higher Education (pp. 1461–1646). Assocation for Advancement in Computing in Education: Honolulu, Hawaii. Hoban, G. F., Butler, S., & Lesslie, L. (2007). Facilitating self-study of professional development: Researching the dynamics of teacher learning. Studying Teacher Education, 3(1), 35–51. Senge, P. (1990). The fifth discipline. New York: Doubleday. Sweller, J. (2006). Discussion of emerging topics in cognitive load research: Using learning information characteristics in the design of powerful learning environments. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 20, 353–357.
Chapter 5
Growing Our Own: A Learning Community Partnership between a University and a Public Middle School Cristy Kessler and Caroline S. Wong
More than 15 years ago Barth (1990) talked about the concept of a community of learners as the coat-rack which supported all of the components of his vision of a good school. Barth envisioned a school where all educators talked with one another about their practice, observed one another engaged in daily teaching and learning activities, shared knowledge of their craft with one another, and actively helped one another become more skillful teachers. It is this concept of a learning community that frames the partnership between a university professor, pre-service teachers, a principal, and teachers at Moanalua Middle School (MMS). The community of learners’ framework supports the University of Hawai’i Master of Education in Teaching Program (MEdT) in tandem with the professional development in a public school setting. Like teaching hospitals in medicine, the school aims to provide a site for state-of-the-art practice that is also organized to support the training of new professionals, extend the professional development of veteran teachers, and sponsor collaborative research and inquiry (Darling-Hammond, 2000). According to the American Educational Research Association (AERA), teacher education programs that incorporate collaborative partnerships between university programs and local schools have a positive effect on student achievement (NCATE, 2006). MEdT is a two-year program for students who already possess a baccalaureate degree in the arts or sciences. It is a field-based, learnercentered program focused on using inquiry, reflection, and collaboration to support the success of future classroom teachers. While fully immersed in the school setting for all four semesters, MEdT students teach, learn, and reflect on practice with veteran teachers and mentor teachers. The program was designed to develop a strong and collaborative relationship between the university and the partnership schools, and this relationship is essential to the success of the MEdT program.
C. Kessler University of Hawai’i at Manoa C.S. Wong Moanalua Middle School
A.P. Samaras et al. (eds.) Learning Communities In Practice, © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2008
59
60
C. Kessler, C.S. Wong
We believe that a purposefully designed professional learning community nurtures and sustains shared learning among pre-service and in-service teachers. In this chapter, we will describe the goals, essential characteristics, and processes of the learning community partnership between the university and a local public middle school.
Rationale As we reflect back on those early conversations in the partnership, we recall where each of us recognized that the other carried the same passion to improve teaching and learning by building the capacity of educators in a learning community. Cristy was a struggling college professor who missed the joy in teaching and the energy of a secondary school classroom. Caroline was a seasoned middle school principal seeking new ways to strengthen and reenergize shared professional learning for both classroom and pre-service teachers. At a MEdT Executive Council meeting in early 2005, an opportunity was provided for participants to share their hopes and expectations for the partnership through a round-robin process. Principals and teachers sat with university professors and student representatives discussing possibilities. Caroline bravely voiced that this partnership could powerfully support action research in the classroom and build an authentic research framework for teachers to utilize in their teaching and assessment. We discussed the potential for university graduate courses offered on the school campus as a way to give back to teachers who serve as mentors to MEdT students. Because Cristy had recently received National Board Certification (NBC), possibilities emerged for her to support reluctant teachers as they ventured forth into what many perceived as a daunting process. And so we glimpsed at an emerging vision and the endless possibilities of a genuine learning community built on the strengths, interests, and passions of educators in partnership.
A Shared Vision of a Learning Community Partnership In the beginning there was a great deal of dialogue about: (1) how we could develop and describe our learning community; (2) a shared commitment to the values of quality teaching and learning; and finally, (3) an inclusive learning community. We asked the same question posed by Schmoker (2006) in his work, what are the most practical, effective actions and arrangements for ensuring that instruction improves, meaningfully and steadily, in every discipline? There are two big ideas that have become clear and compelling as our learning community partnership has developed; these ideas are not linear and continue to overlap and integrate. Whether collaboratively planning an agenda, problem-solving a difficult personnel decision, or strategizing professional development for pre-service or in-service teachers, we discovered that no matter what the conversation topic was, our touchstone was always a shared commitment to two essential goals that were at the heart of it all.
5 A Learning Community Partnership between a University
61
Individually, and in partnership, our goals were: 1. To develop highly qualified teachers who would positively impact student learning 2. To employ research-based best practices so everyone in the learning community was simultaneously a teacher and a learner
Research-Based Best Practices: A Shared Commitment to Teaching Results Some of the key questions that we explored and discussed included the teaching and learning processes in our learning community partnership and how these processes were guided by research-based best practice findings. An example of the dialogue that took place between Cristy and Caroline went like this: Cristy: How do we most effectively teach pre-service teachers? Caroline: How do we best teach early adolescents in a middle school? Cristy: How do we organize the learning community in a middle school or a college of education class? Caroline: How do we purposefully create a culture in a classroom where it is safe to take risks, to ask essential questions, to dialogue about teaching and learning? Cristy: How do we overcome position and status to focus on shared learning?
Within all of this dialogue, our focus always came back to our desire for a shared vision for a learning community and for an approach that would include pre-service and in-service teachers working together to support best practice.
Description of the Learning Community: Nurturing Holonomy We wanted the learning community to reflect the concept of holonomy described by Costa and Garmston (2002) as a phenomenon with the dual characteristics of being both a part and a whole at the same time. Holonomy looks at both our independent and interdependent tendencies; i.e., being the best that I can be as an individual and reflective learner … and being the best that I can be as part of a team, partnership, or learning organization (Costa & Garmston, 2002, p. 19). A holonomous partnership continually seeks avenues of growth for every individual in the learning community, so that individuals become independent and self-actualizing while functioning and growing interdependently. Partnership members purposefully develop productive, collaborative relationships; respect individual differences and needs; and recognize their own personal contribution to the growth and development of the learning community regardless of role and position. This vision and sense of purpose is grounded in the shared belief that if educators have the training, skills, resources, and will, they can overcome barriers to student learning and make a compelling difference in achievement for all students.
62
C. Kessler, C.S. Wong
Since our challenge was to incorporate research-based best practice findings in our pre-service and in-service teaching, we turned to the extensive research identifying essential instructional strategies that make a significant difference in student learning. We drew upon the meta-analysis of Marzano et al. (2001), who analyzed studies on K–12 instructional strategies. The researchers identified nine instructional strategies that have a high probability of enhancing achievement for all students in all subject areas in all grade levels. As practicing teacher educators, we used these nine instructional strategies to frame our efforts to focus on research-based best practice in both university classes and professional development with pre-service and in-service teachers. We are all learners and our efforts must reflect a commitment to developing and refining instructional strategies that we know increase student achievement.
Aligning Structures When teachers recognize that knowledge for improvement is something they can generate, rather than something that must be handed to them by so-called experts, they are on a new professional trajectory. They are building a new culture of teaching. (Hiebert & Stigler, 2004)
As the vision for a shared learning community partnership began to take definition, it was essential that structures currently in place at the school and in the MEdT program were aligned. As we speak of structures, we are referring to school and MEdT program organizational and work groups; the commitment of specific personnel, time or other resources; and school or program expectations, requirements, practices and processes in place. What pre-service teachers did for required university course work needed to be directly linked to what they were observing and doing in the field. We worked to bridge the gap between theory and practice for the entire learning community, and use the structures at the school and in the MEdT program to support the goals of the partnership. It was essential to identify the independent structures of the MEdT program and the middle school to understand how we aligned them to support our learning community. I do not believe that we should have a one-size-fits-all teacher education program, but I do believe that we can be using best practices and draw on research to develop common goals and practices. We need to make explicit pedagogies of teacher education that help to guide both new teachers and experienced teacher educators. Developing such pedagogies is fraught with challenges, but that is what teacher education is all about. (Kosnik, 2007, p. 29)
MEdT program structures that support the learning community partnership Throughout the two-year program, the MEdT on-site classes and seminars integrate research and instructional practices which are the same as those that actively engage
5 A Learning Community Partnership between a University
63
the classroom teachers. For example, MEdT students are grounded in standards-based lesson planning as well as strategies to differentiate instruction, address multiple intelligences, and integrate metacognitive reflections to strengthen the learning. Assessments focus on critical thinking, problem-solving and application to real-life situations, and may involve service learning. Seminar topics are often co-facilitated by the professor and principal and provide time for dialogue, clarification, and scaffolding to the professional development conversations of the faculty. Based on this model, pre-service teachers are able to work collaboratively with in-service teachers and develop a shared knowledge and language that focuses on improved teaching and student learning. In addition to weekly seminars and electives, MEdT students must also complete five program requirements. These include: (1) a school portrait; (2) a lesson study; (3) a case study; (4) a Master’s thesis or alternative project; and (5) a teaching portfolio. We share examples of these assignments to demonstrate the common focus of the learning community partnership which emerged from these learning experiences.
The school portrait During the first semester, the school supports inquiry learning for MEdT students through an immersion process within the middle school learning community. The immersion time provides the MEdT students with a realistic view of the daily routines and responsibilities of teachers, and includes participation in team and staff meetings. Students spend 15 hours a week observing in partnership schools while engaged in required university course work. The focus is on the school community rather than the details of a single classroom. The MEdT students use the inquiry process to investigate the culture of the school, examine school functions and processes, learn about the social context for classroom instruction, and produce a school portrait. The following is an example of the school portrait which illustrates the collaborative nature of this research project. Working with the school principal and site coordinator, four MEdT students designed an intensive research agenda to examine middle school teaming as their portrait topic. The following research questions were addressed through the portrait process: What are the teachers’ perceptions of the effectiveness of teaming in student achievement? How does teaming at the middle school encourage or prohibit the development of integrated curriculum? What resources are needed to advance teaming practices? The MEdT students collected data through surveys and interviews, analyzed the data, created a narrative of the outcomes, and then presented their findings to the school faculty. Staff members provided feedback, new insights, and follow-up questions after the presentation. The school portrait presentation data was given to the school for future self-study and school renewal. These same four students surveyed the entire faculty and administration one year later to determine the impact of the portrait on the school. The following quotes from the faculty and administration illustrate the value of the portrait process:
64
C. Kessler, C.S. Wong The portrait process is an authentic way for the MEdT students to be immersed in relevant school issues that integrate best practice and the review of literature with the realities of teaching practices. As pre-service teachers prepare to be educators, the portrait provides a process for how change may take place in a learning community. The portrait provided an opportunity for the staff to reflect on the research base of teaming and why it is good for kids. Too often the middle school structures serve the needs of the teaching staff rather than the learners. By examining the data collected from the teachers, it was clear that much of their team planning time was spent talking about student behavior, planning field trips, and even ‘talking story.’ We used the slides from the portrait presentation and the excellent review of the literature to revisit the teaming structure at our school and how it could be strengthened.
Lesson study During the second semester the MEdT students participated in the process of lesson study. Lesson study, a process to improve classroom instruction based on careful observation of students and their work (Lewis, 2002), provided a valuable opportunity for the pre-service and mentor teacher to collaboratively generate goals and design a lesson plan. When Cristy initially facilitated the lesson study process, she was amazed at the enthusiasm of the mentor teachers. As evidence of the growing learning community partnership, the site coordinator, principal, and professor are currently working with eight in-service teachers in the lesson study process. For each step of the process, teachers are documenting their goals, lesson plans, observations, debriefings, and reteachings, and will create a portfolio reflecting their professional growth through a new kind of collaboration. Case study During the third semester, the MEdT students continued to use reflection and inquiry to conduct case studies on a particular student or incident, or problem related to their student-teaching classroom and experience. The students incorporated action research methods to explore theory and practice through “hands on” real-life issues. Through their research, the MEdT students worked collaboratively with their mentor teachers to gain greater insight into the issue. Using a single student case study, the following quotes illustrate how one MEdT student explored ways of creating a positive learning environment to encourage greater student responsibility and engagement. I wanted to focus on creating and maintaining a positive learning environment where responsibility to self, the teacher, and peers encourages a student to take an active role in his or her learning and the learning of others. In order to do this I assigned roles to various students to see if this would positively impact their participation and responsibility for their own learning. I focused on one student. Student T is very smart but lacks motivation and a positive attitude to learn. My question was whether or not the implementation of the Tsunami’s of the Week (roles and responsibilities assigned to students throughout the semester) will give this student a sense of responsibility to himself, to his peers, and to the learning community. At the conclusion of my case study, Student T was actively involved in our learning community within my classroom. The case study approach really allowed me to see the impact of my teaching on one student.
5 A Learning Community Partnership between a University
65
Middle school structures that support the learning community partnership MMS has innovative middle school structures in place to support quality professional development of its in-service teachers. These structures also make MMS an ideal place for the MEdT students to learn the profession of teaching and researchbased instructional practices to improve student achievement. Some of the unique structures implemented at MMS include: (1) interdisciplinary teaming and team planning time; (2) looping; (3) a flexible block schedule; (4) TRIBES; and (5) staff development through team planning. Interdisciplinary teaming and team planning time All students and teachers are organized in interdisciplinary teams, which are actually smaller learning communities within the school and grade level. The MEdT pre-service teachers meet regularly with their interdisciplinary teacher team and quickly become an integral part of the whole team process. They are mentored not only by a supervising teacher in their content major, but also by team members from other disciplines. While students attend elective fine arts courses, team teachers share common planning time which is used for planning units of study and team activities; discussing student learning progress and sharing student work and exemplars; and collaboratively deciding when and how they will utilize school-wide instructional strategies. Team teachers also regularly review student achievement data to identify the students who are meeting content area benchmarks, and those who are approaching and need additional time or support to make the necessary achievement gains. If the team is an integration team with either special education or English Language Learning (ELL) staff support, review of special needs student status is done on a regular basis to make sure these students are experiencing success in learning. Looping All teams loop up from seventh to eighth grade so that students and teachers stay together for two years. The advantages of looping are many as there is less time spent at the beginning of the year reviewing what was learned the year before; teachers are able to make connections between learning across grade levels; and teachers are more familiar with student learning styles and therefore better able to support their success. Some of the MEdT pre-service teachers experience the benefits of looping when they are able to stay with their same interdisciplinary teaching team, and loop up with teachers and students the second year to complete their student teaching semester. A flexible block schedule A flexible block schedule supports regrouping of students for extended learning time. Teachers, not ringing bells, determine the length of the class period while
66
C. Kessler, C.S. Wong
students are in the block. MEdT pre-service teachers truly became part of critical conversations as teachers plan strategies for differentiation and individualization of instruction; time for reteaching to support learning success for all students; and opportunities for enrichment of interested and gifted students in topics of their choice across the curriculum.
TRIBES Team teachers most often use the TRIBES (Gibbs, 2001) processes to identify common classroom practices and expectations, and to support the positive behavior of students. TRIBES processes are used to purposefully create a positive and supportive learning environment in the school and in every classroom. Through common agreements and inclusion practices, student voices are valued and no one is invisible. A four-day TRIBES training is provided each year for new staff members and MEdT pre-service teachers. What a powerful difference it makes for them to gain strategies and processes to purposefully create a culture in their classroom prior to actually becoming teachers! Additionally, they are able to make the connections as they observe TRIBES processes within various classrooms across teams.
Staff development through team planning Another structure that supports shared teacher learning time and professional development is the monthly staff development through team planning. The principal, teacher leaders, and, on occasion, the professor meet during planning time to provide focused support that is specific to their students and professional development needs. This time provides opportunities for small group shared learning and mentoring for in-service and MEdT pre-service teachers related to research-based best practice. Thinking Maps (Hyerle & Yeager, 2007) is one example of a school-wide research-based best practice implemented school wide over a two-year period which has had a statistically significant impact on reading comprehension.
Impact After identifying the unique structures that existed within the MEdT program and at MMS, we began to have conversations about how to integrate these separate entities into our shared vision. Together, a principal and a university professor created a culture to strengthen the holonomous culture and learning community for all the stakeholders. These shared structures include: (1) Executive Council meetings; (2) involvement of a site coordinator; (3) shared planning of MEdT seminars; (4) professional development at MMS; and (5) action research.
5 A Learning Community Partnership between a University
67
Executive Council This partnership has demonstrated a different and more effective way for schools and universities to work together, which truly benefits everyone in the learning community. Freese (2004) described the unique structure of governance of MEdT when she explained the Executive Council, which is composed of university faculty, mentor teachers, site coordinators, principals, and student representatives. The council meets monthly to provide an effective means of communication, collaborative decision-making, and formative assessment of progress to achieve the shared goals of the program. This governance structure includes all stakeholders working together and actively engaged in planning, teaching, inquiry, and decisionmaking to strengthen practice at all levels. It is this very structure that not only allows MEdT and MMS to communicate in a formal and regularly scheduled manner, but also supports the sharing of successes and best practice with other partnership schools who are working with the other MEdT cohorts.
Site Coordinator The role of the site coordinator is crucial to the partnership. We realized early on that due to the various roles the principal and professor would be playing, a site coordinator is necessary to serve as a liaison between MMS and the University of Hawai’i (UH). The site coordinator’s main functions are to communicate effectively with the staff at MMS who will serve as mentors to the MEdT pre-service teachers and coordinate partnership efforts at the school. We have found that teachers are more receptive to ideas when they are presented by one of their fellow staff members, as opposed to being given a directive from a principal or professor. Additionally, the site coordinator helps identify quality mentors, provide training (with us) for the mentors, follow up on a myriad of program details, and often participates in on-site seminars. The site coordinator at MMS also serves as the Middle School Coordinator. This site coordinator position provides the wonderful advantage that he is always at the school and is able to troubleshoot a potential problem situation with MEdT pre-service teachers before it becomes a crisis.
Seminars for MEdT Students Another unique structure for this partnership is the way that seminars are provided to the MEdT students. “Being able to articulate one’s own knowledge of practice is vital to enacting a pedagogy of teacher education in order to be able to answer questions such as: ‘Why does that teaching procedure work?’; ‘How does concept mapping enhance student learning?’; or ‘Why would I use a jigsaw method for group
68
C. Kessler, C.S. Wong
work?’ ” (Loughran, 2007, p. 4). In an attempt to connect theory to practice in the seminars, we often discuss current teaching and learning issues at MMS and try to find ways to infuse them into the seminars. We co-teach many seminars and ask the site coordinator, as well as mentor teachers, to participate in relevant topics related to research-based best practice. Since MMS is actively involved in the implementation of TRIBES, we embed TRIBES into seminars and model how it can be used to not only build a culture within the MEdT cohort, but also may be used when the MEdT pre-service teachers work in their own classrooms. We design each seminar together to not only provide key information and instructional strategies of how to teach, but through our teaching we model for the MEdT students what these instructional strategies look like in a classroom. Using the inquiry process to guide the MEdT students, we purposefully teach standardsbased lesson planning and unit design, differentiation, multiple intelligences, and Thinking Maps, so when the MEdT pre-service teachers enter their student teaching semester, they are speaking the same language and thinking the same way as the in-service teachers.
Professional Development at MMS Just as we both collaborate on teaching and selecting topics for the student seminars, we also work with the faculty at MMS. Professional development days and faculty meetings have been designed to focus on specific information on the latest research on classroom instruction that works (Marzano et al., 2001), including how to promote critical thinking and problem-solving; as well as the NBC process. Trying to find ways to give back and support the needs of the faculty at MMS is important because the compensation for being a mentor teacher is never enough in light of the hours required to effectively support a pre-service teacher. As part of the partnership we implement a reciprocal process as a way to provide support for the professional development of the school staff members. We offer a course for a cohort of in-service teachers who are interested in pursuing NBC. “In experiencing what was personally required to complete NBC, Kessler brought new meaning to the notion of ‘recent and relevant’ experience for teacher educators” (Loughran, 2007, p. 9). Drawing upon DuFour et al. (2006), we created another purposeful small learning community with this group of in-service teachers to encourage a shift from focus on teaching to focus on learning. This philosophy relates directly to the goals set forth by NBPTS (2005) as candidates must demonstrate, through their portfolio entries, how their teaching impacts students’ learning. In addition, DuFour (2004) believes that collaborative teams drive the school improvement process. By establishing a learning community among candidates going through NBC, these teachers develop the tools necessary to become leaders within their schools and propel overall school improvement. In return, these teachers become highly effective mentors for the MEdT students. While undertaking the NBC
5 A Learning Community Partnership between a University
69
process, some in-service teachers were also serving as mentors to MEdT preservice teachers. This provides some extremely valuable lessons for the MEdT students as they watch their mentors struggle with their own journey of reflection-on-practice to become highly qualified teachers. Reciprocal learning is happening among the participants.
Action Research in the Partnership The partnership between MMS and MEdT is also a source for significant action research focused on student learning. We have joined together to collect relevant data and analyze the impact of research-based best practice on student success. Additionally, we collaboratively try to provide useful data for classroom teachers and present our findings at various educational conferences as well as publish articles in the field.
Discussion and Suggestions Since implementing our partnership in 2005, we continue to have frequent conversations to examine how we can make our partnership stronger. An integral piece of this conversation is celebrating the things that have been successful. The key elements in developing our learning community are: ● ●
●
● ●
A shared commitment to our vision and developing holonomy Principal and teacher buy-in at MMS to support the development of pre-service teachers Commitment from the university professor to be on-site and to support the professional growth of in-service and pre-service teachers A common research agenda Continuous dialogue between the principal and university professor as well as feedback from the site coordinator, mentor teachers, and the MEdT students
Challenges and Barriers to Overcome Just as we recognize our successes, we have been able to identify barriers and challenges to our learning community. Keynes (1935) stated more than 70 years ago that the real difficulty in changing the course of any enterprise lies not in developing new ideas but in escaping old ones. Some of our barriers are: (1) stability of university staff; (2) commitment to research-based instructional practices; (3) shared and purposeful action research to impact student achievement; and (4) inservice teachers willing to be mentors to pre-service teachers.
70
C. Kessler, C.S. Wong
Stability of university staff One of the challenges is the mind-set of university professors who tend to buy into the ivory tower notion and find it difficult to leave their offices to walk in the lowly hallways of the K–12 setting. Hanna (2003, p. 26) identifies the ivory tower as “a time when knowledge was to be awarded in order to be preserved … and when the primary medium for storing knowledge was physically and geographically bound books.” In addition to the ivory tower mentality, a recurring and unresolved problem has been the high turnover of the university staff within the MEdT program. Although university educators are preparing teachers for our public schools, few choose to be involved in partnerships with local schools; fieldwork is often not very desirable. According to Freese et al. (1998) the major commitment of time, resources, and effort provide a source of tension for university faculty. Freese (2004, p. 14) states that “faculty are aware that there are no rewards from the university for extensive amounts of time devoted to working with partnership schools, and it is particularly difficult for untenured faculty because the demands of publishing and conducting research compete with the needs and expectations of the pre-service and mentor teachers at the partner schools.” Commitment to research-based instructional practices It is often assumed at both the university level and in most schools that there truly is a commitment to research-based best practices and a willingness to change practice. Few university faculty members focus on research-based best practice in the delivery of instruction, or model through lesson design and classroom practice those teaching and learning processes that reflect the needs of the adult learners. As Loughran (2007, p. 13) states: “[O]ne difficulty associated with framing professional identity through the lens of the ex-school teacher is that the teacher educator may be viewed as simply being a teacher teaching in teacher preparation rather than as a teacher educator with an expertise in teaching and learning about teaching.” These best-practice instructional strategies should also be modeled and included as an integral part of teaching and learning in College of Education courses. How often do university professors truly address the array of learners in their college classrooms or build a curriculum on the research-based needs of adult learners? Shared and purposeful action research to impact student achievement Many public schools today face what seems like insurmountable challenges as they attempt to address the needs of the array of learners in every classroom. Public schools desperately need teachers who can purposefully create a positive and caring culture in the classroom; utilize instructional strategies and an engaging curriculum relevant and important to students and their community; facilitate strategic reading and thinking skills; and use assessments to inform instruction. However, as recently noted on the front page of USA Today during the 2007 AERA conference: “[U]niversity professors often conduct studies on topics that do little to help schools solve problems such as how to train teachers, how to raise
5 A Learning Community Partnership between a University
71
skills, how to lower dropout rates and whether smaller classes really make a difference” (Toppo, 2007, p. 1). In-service teachers willing to be mentors to pre-service teachers In this demanding climate created by the No Child Left Behind (NCLB) Act, public school educators often feel that they have to function as be-all, know-all problemsolvers for everything that ails our society. Teachers are overwhelmed and are not always willing to take on the added responsibility and hours of commitment to mentor a pre-service teacher. The monetary payment for a mentor teacher is not even equal to a day’s pay, and many teachers feel that their role is not valued in the pre-service teacher preparation process. Therefore, one of the challenges that must be addressed systemically is to support the role of mentor teachers in preparing the pre-service teachers.
Next Steps The journey of this partnership continues to provide opportunities for reflection and refinement as we critically examine outcomes and what has worked and what has not been successful within our learning community. Part of this journey is acknowledging our barriers and committing ourselves to the process of overcoming them. Cristy remains a fundamental part of the faculty at MMS. She traveled with 10 educators from the Moanalua Complex to attend the Thinking Maps conference and then participated in a four-day training with MMS staff members to become a trainer for the Thinking Maps program. The next cohort of in-service teachers who will attempt NBC during the 2007–2008 school year is already in place, and has started its support sessions with Cristy. Cristy will also lead a small learning community of interested teachers in the lesson study process using Thinking Maps as the focus. It will be an additional effort to continue data collection on relevant research related to the learning success of students in the classroom. Caroline and Cristy will work with members of the learning community to develop a handbook for MEdT that is specific to our learning community and includes what we have learned during the past two years. We will also begin to restructure the seminars in the MEdT program to better reflect the research-based best practices that are currently implemented in the Moanalua Complex. Our goal is to strengthen the processes, methodology, pedagogy, and the culture of our partnership learning community. As we experience success in this collaborative effort, the outcome will not only be improved teaching and learning to support the success of every student, but also every teacher learner, whether university professor, instructional leader, in-service, or pre-service. As Marcel Proust has stated: “The real voyage of discovery consists not in seeking new landscapes, but in having new eyes.”
72
C. Kessler, C.S. Wong
References Barth, R. (1990). Improving schools from within: Teachers, parents, and principals can make a difference. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Costa, A. L. & Garmston, R. J. (2002). Cognitive coaching: A foundation for renaissance schools. MA: Christopher-Gordon. Darling-Hammond, L. (2000). How teacher education matters. Journal of Teacher Education, 51, 166–173. DuFour, R. (2004). What is a professional learning community? Educational Leadership, 61(8), 6–11. DuFour, R., Dufour, R., & Eaker, R. (2006). Professional learning at work. Bloomington, IN: Solution Tree. Freese, A. R. (2004). Evaluation as a way of knowing: assessing the impact of a PDS. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Association Research Association, San Diego, CA, April, 2004. Freese, A., McEwan, H., Bayer, A., Awaya, A., & Marble, S. (1998). Reinventing teacher preparation: The master of education in teaching program. National Forum of Teacher Education Journal, 8(1), 7–13. Gibbs, J. (2001). Discovering gifts in middle school learning in a caring culture called TRIBES TLC. Windsor CA: CenterSource Systems. Hanna, D. (2003). Building a leadership vision: Eleven strategic challenges for higher education. Educause Review, 38(4), 25–34. Hiebert, J. & Stigler, J. W. (2004). A world of difference: Classrooms abroad provide lesson teaching math and science. Journal of Staff Development, 25(4), 10–15. Hyerle, D. & Yeager, C. (2007). Thinking maps: A language for learning. NC: Thinking Maps. Keynes, M. (1935). Retrieved July 2007, from http://thinkexist.com/quotes/john_maynard_ keynes/ Kosnik, C. (2007). Still the same yet different. In T. Russell & J. Loughran (Eds.), Enacting a pedagogy of teacher education: values, relationships, and practice. New York: Routledge. Lewis, C. (2002). Lesson study: A handbook for teacher-led improvement of instruction. Philadelphia, PA: Research for Better Schools. Loughran, J. (2007). Enacting a pedagogy of teacher education. In T. Russell & J. Loughran (Eds.), Enacting a pedagogy of teacher education: values, relationships, and practice. New York: Routledge. Marzano, R., Pickering, D., & Pollock, J. (2001). Classroom instruction that works: Researchbased strategies for increasing student achievement. Alexandria, VA: ASCD. National Board for Professional Teaching Standards Guide to National Board Certification (NBPTS). (2005). Retrieved October 2005, from the National Board for Professional Teaching Standards (NBPTS) web site online: http://www.nbpts.org/pdf/nbpts_guide_2005.pdf National Council for Accreditation of Teacher Education (NCATE). (2006). What makes a teacher effective? Retrieved April 17, 2007, from (pamphlet). Proust, M. Retrieved July 2007, from http://www.quotesandpoem.com/quotes/ showquotes/ author/Marcel_Proust/79689 Schmoker, M. (2006). Results now. VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. Toppo, G. (2007). Usefulness of education research questioned. Retrieved April 2007, from http:// www.usatoday.com/news/education/2007-04-10-education-science_n.htm
Chapter 6
A Whole-School Approach to Urban Educational Renewal: Community, Collaboration, and Leadership Clive Beck, Clare Kosnik, and Yiola Cleovoulou
Many attempts at educational reform focus either on developing the knowledge and skills of individual teachers through courses, workshops, publications, and so on, or on mandating curriculum and pedagogy – with related professional development – across a whole-school system. The first approach is problematic because individual teachers need workplace support and encouragement in order to go in new directions, and furthermore the innovations of individual teachers must be reinforced by other teachers in their school if they are to have a substantial impact on students. The second approach also presents challenges. System-wide directives tend to be either so general that teachers have difficulty interpreting what they mean, or so specific that no room is left for essential adaptation at the school and classroom level. And even if appropriate “medium grain” standards (DarlingHammond, 1997, p. 229) can be found, implementing them across a whole system requires more resources, ingenuity, and coordination than are often available. In this paper, we report on an educational reform effort that pursued a third alternative, what we call a “whole-school approach.” The staff of a downtown Toronto elementary school worked together as a community to develop and implement a shared vision of teaching and learning. One of their central goals was to ensure that all students achieved success in this strongly urban setting. While aspects of the vision – and substantial support – came from government and school district sources, the staff showed a great deal of local initiative. This third approach to educational renewal also has its challenges. Just as individual teachers need support, so do schools: it is difficult for a school to rise above the general culture of a system. And even where one school is highly successful, there is no easy way to “spread” the success to other schools (Sarason, 1990). Fullan (1991) maintains that school renewal requires system-wide top-down initiatives as well as bottom-up ones. However, we believe the approach taken in our case study school is instructive and elements of it could be utilized in other school settings. Of particular interest for this book, of course, was the school’s emphasis on building professional community among the staff as a means of promoting school renewal.
C. Beck, C. Kosnik, and Y. Cleovoulou Ontario Institute for Studies in Education, University of Toronto
A.P. Samaras et al. (eds.) Learning Communities In Practice, © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2008
73
74
C. Beck et al.
Theoretical Framework In our research we were concerned to study ways of achieving “learning for all” in an urban school with a diverse student population. Recent theory on standards for the teaching profession has stressed the importance of ensuring that all students are successful (Beck et al., 2002; Darling-Hammond, 1997; National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, 1995). New York city’s Central Park East Schools in the 1980s and 1990s, under the leadership of Deborah Meier, took a student population in Harlem with traditionally low academic success and enabled them to achieve at a high level, both at school and subsequently at college and university (Meier, 1995). While classroom teachers are key to school renewal and learning for all, they need the support and encouragement of their principal and other teachers in their school (Barth, 1990; Sergiovanni, 1992; Zemelman et al., 1998). Cuban (1998) states that seeing the school as “the basic unit of reform” was emphasized in the USA by the Effective Schools movement from the mid-1970s (pp. 461–462). This movement was founded by a small group of researchers who questioned the view that schools could do little to increase academic success among poor and minority students (p. 461). Because of the prevalence of this view at the time, there was a danger that special funding for schools in poor and minority neighborhoods would be discontinued. The central tenet of the Effective Schools movement was that “[a]ll children, regardless of background, can learn and achieve results that mirror ability, not socioeconomic status” (p. 462). In addition to its school-based orientation, the movement advocated the following strategies for ensuring that all students are successful: ● ● ● ● ● ●
Clearly stated academic goals Principal’s instructional leadership Concentration on basic academic skills Strong emphasis on maintaining order in the school Frequent monitoring of academic achievement Connecting what is taught to what is tested (pp. 461–462)
At the same time there existed a less prominent but also influential school-based reform movement focused on middle schools. It appeared initially in the mid-1960s and reemerged in the early 1980s (and is still with us today, in several countries). The middle schools movement, according to Cuban (1998, p. 467), “has competed with Effective Schools ideology for a version of what constitutes a ‘good’ school.” Strategies advocated by the movement include: ● ● ● ●
Team teaching of core subjects Teachers acting as advisers A pedagogy grounded in active learning and small-group instruction Large time blocks set aside for classes (p. 467)
The “neoprogressive philosophy” of this movement was “at best, skeptical and, at worst, hostile to some of the Effective Schools factors and standardized achievement testing” (p. 467).
6 A Whole-School Approach to Urban Educational Renewal
75
While in Cuban’s (1998) view the Effective Schools movement had considerable impact, some of its key principles were quickly modified. From the early 1980s, “policy elites” in the USA focused increasingly on the economic benefits to the nation of student academic success, neglecting other purposes of schooling such as “building citizens, seeking social justice, and providing a psychologically and emotionally healthy experience for children” (p. 465). [B]y the end of the 1980s, policymakers spoke publicly less and less of “effective schools” and far more about “restructuring,” “site-based management,” “professional development of teachers,” and “systemic reform”…. [T]hey viewed the reform of schooling as a far larger project involving national goals, curriculum, and testing rather than a local schoolby-school venture. (pp. 462–463)
On this model (which is still prominent today) many bureaucratic decisions were “site-based.” However, curriculum and pedagogy were largely generated at a system level and simply implemented by the school (or by individual teachers – hence the need for professional development). Assessment programs, too, were developed beyond the school and served primarily to determine whether students were meeting system targets. This was significantly different from the approach the Effective Schools founders had in mind. At the K-6 school we studied – Bridge Street School (we use pseudonyms in this paper) – the principal and teachers were acutely aware of the Ontario government’s curriculum and standardized testing program. The detailed curriculum expectations impacted their planning and teaching and framed student reporting; and every year the Education Quality and Accountability Office (EQAO) released to the public its test results in literacy and mathematics for grade 3 and 6 students, grouped by school. However, in line with the Effective Schools and middle schools movements, the staff chose in addition to develop a set of objectives, principles, and strategies for their school, with an emphasis on success for all students. In accord with these movements, too, the principal had a major leadership role in curriculum and pedagogy and several teachers were given special responsibility as “instructional leaders.” Also in keeping with the middle schools movement (and progressive education generally), the Bridge Street staff emphasized building community among the staff and students, using active and collaborative learning methods, and pursuing goals that went beyond academic learning to personal and social growth and citizenship development.
Context and Methodology of the Study Bridge Street is a relatively small elementary school (about 350 students) in downtown Toronto. It is high on the school district’s scale of “inner-cityness,” and thus qualifies for special funding and other kinds of support. According to the principal, the school is very diverse, with “no main group.” “They’re from all over the world,” perhaps 20% from Chinese background, 15% East Indian, 15% from Africa and the Caribbean, some from South America, and so on. A
76
C. Beck et al.
very high proportion were born outside Canada. One teacher said: “We have many students who are very low academically: there’s nothing wrong with them intellectually or physically, but their background experiences are quite lacking.” Nearly all the students come from the local neighborhood and most from relatively poor households. At the time of our study, the school was a practicum site for our OISE/University of Toronto teacher education program, and this gave us opportunities to observe it beyond those normally available to outside researchers. The study was funded through a small-scale grant from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada, whose support we gratefully acknowledge. In the fall and early winter of 2004 we gained the ethical permission of the University of Toronto to conduct the study, the administrative consent of the Toronto District School Board, and the written agreement of the principal and teachers. Our observations at the school occurred from January 2005 to June 2006. In June 2005, we interviewed the principal and 13 teachers. In selecting teachers for interview we included all four “instructional leaders” and looked for a balance in grade level taught and years of experience at the school. Each interview was about an hour in length and was recorded and transcribed. In addition to the interviews, we conducted two focus groups in June 2006. Each group consisted of five teachers – a more junior and a more senior group – and again we recorded and transcribed the discussion. Our research approach was qualitative, as defined by Punch (2005). For example, we had a small sample (just one school, the principal, and 13 teachers) which we studied in depth, our interview and focus group sessions were somewhat openended, and the themes emerged as the study progressed. In analyzing the transcripts, we began by reading them several times to identify themes or “codes” related to the central issues of the study. We then developed a table of these themes, matched to interviewees and, going through the transcripts again, recorded the pages on which reference was made to each topic; this table was used in developing a structure for our report. As we wrote the report we continued to add, delete, and modify themes and kept going back to the transcripts to seek clarification and select further quotations and examples.
Findings In this main section of the chapter, we outline some of the key findings of our study of Bridge Street School. In line with the overall theme of the book, our focus is especially on the professional community, common vision, and collaboration established among the staff. While there were other important elements in the school’s renewal approach – for example, community among the students and links to the parents and surrounding neighborhood – limitations of space do not allow us to discuss them at length here.
6 A Whole-School Approach to Urban Educational Renewal
77
A Staff Community We found that there was indeed a strong community among the teachers and principal at Bridge Street School. We observed it during our visits to the school, and many of the teachers spoke about it in the focus groups and individual interviews. For example, Gina said: “We feel very safe as teachers here. … It’s a small school, so we get to see everyone. In my first school, I was down the hall, I never saw half the teachers and didn’t know what they were doing … [But here] it’s really close knit.” Jane recalled that “when I first started in the kindergarten, other teachers were amazing, giving me resources, advice, and so on.” Natalie commented: I find that our principal is very supportive, she’s always there for the kids and for the teachers as well. If I ever have anything I need to talk about or am concerned about, I know I can always go to her, whether it be a personal issue or a professional issue. And the teachers within the school are great. If you need a resource, you can pop into anyone’s room and say, “Can I borrow this,” and they will say, “Yeah, take it, go.” It’s just a sharing community.
While there was much sharing and considerable closeness, however, some teachers commented that the community was more professional than social in nature. For example, Natalie said: “There’s just that professionalism; like somebody you may not connect with outside of the school, socially, you feel comfortable going to professionally to ask them anything, and they’re very willing to help you out.” Similarly, Gina distinguished between the professional and the social. There are people you gravitate towards because of similarities or what not, and then people you can connect with in the professional role but not more than that; and I think that’s fine. That’s what I realized my first year: I had these big hopes, these big dreams, that everyone is going to get together and we’re all going to get along; but nope, it’s not like that. We’re human beings and everyone has their baggage, their differences and similarities. Just like the kids in our classrooms, not everyone will always get along on a personal level, but they can do it professionally.
The teachers believed that having a professional community was very important for the success of the school. It enabled them to pull together and gave a common direction to their teaching. It provided a means of learning from each other and inspired them to work harder. Speaking of the community and its expectations, Mark said: “I think it’s good, because without big expectations you get teachers who don’t seem to care.” Amy commented: It’s important that in general teachers take the initiative to share resources … sharing success stories, materials, and that sort of thing … whether it’s in-school workshops that are being offered, whatever it happens to be. This information has to be disseminated. Also it’s important for teachers to support each other so we become creative problem-solvers, because there are constraints and demands that can sometimes seem overwhelming. If you have a particularly challenging class or if you are an inexperienced teacher, teachers can help each other by opening their doors.
78
C. Beck et al.
A Common Vision The community, then, was largely professional in nature (a “team,” as Janet called it), but the staff enjoyed the camaraderie of a joint enterprise, working successfully together with like-minded people. However, much of the success of their efforts – and the enjoyment – depended on the fact that they were pulling in the same direction. Having a common vision was crucial to the model. Obviously they differed on some matters and had varied styles, but there was basic agreement on goals and pedagogical approach. Many of the teachers made reference to this shared vision. For example, Natalie said: “As a staff … we have common goals for our kids. … [W]e all have main goals we want to accomplish, things we want to implement, things we want the children to learn. So it’s a whole-school approach.” Key elements in the vision were: ● ● ● ●
● ● ● ● ● ●
All students being successful Student engagement Development of the whole child A stress on academic development (especially in literacy, but also math and science) Integration of subjects A collaborative and integrated program across the whole school Appropriate behavior both individually and in the school Community among faculty, in individual classrooms, and across the school Inclusion of students of different backgrounds and abilities And links with parents and the neighborhood community
Summarizing the vision, Janet (the principal) said that its “three pillars” were “behavior, curriculum, and community.” While there was a common vision, however, it was not imposed in an overly strict or top-down manner. Amy spoke of flexibility in implementing it: “Sometimes you think, Oh I can’t handle one more thing; there’s that odd moment. But as Andrea says, you pick and choose, and the things that really need to get done tend to get done.” Amy talked of the autonomy she felt as a teacher at the school: “All of us want to support the initiatives that have been put in place here. But it’s also important to have a feeling of autonomy, a sense that you have the freedom to use other programs too that you think the children could benefit from; and I certainly feel I have that freedom.” Natalie said there was an acceptance in the school of teachers – especially new teachers – pacing themselves, implementing one thing at a time. The existence of a common vision was seen by the staff as having a number of advantages. Janet noted that teachers liked to work at the school, despite the common agenda and its heavy demands: “Teachers want to come here to teach; which is different from how it used to be. I have lots of applications now, from people who are interested in working successfully and happily in the inner city.” Some of the teachers spoke of the role of the common vision in helping them grow as teachers and teach in the way they wanted to. Gina said: I started here as a new teacher, so this common agenda and structure were good for me personally, because I came in as a blank slate. I had my teacher education, had been in a
6 A Whole-School Approach to Urban Educational Renewal
79
couple of classrooms, and had taught ESL for a year; but it was nice to go into a primary classroom and have certain programs emphasized by the school, so I knew what the direction of the school was. … And I feel it has helped me create a well-balanced literacy program because of the school’s agenda and resources.
In particular, several of the teachers mentioned that buying into the school’s agenda resulted in their being far ahead of teachers in other schools in certain respects. Amy remarked in a focus group: “You know what I find – and I’ve heard some of you say this too – when we go to workshops, we are so ahead of the game. Like we’ll be sitting there and they’ll be going, Well, maybe you should try guided reading, and we’re like, Guided reading?! … And in my ESL course they said, Have you heard of ‘Erasing Prejudice for Good’?, and I thought, wow, we’ve been doing that for ten years.”
A Collaborative Enterprise The staff not only had a common vision, they also worked closely together. They shared strategies and resources and engaged in joint teaching and school-wide projects. Andrea said: “We do a lot of team teaching in our school and a lot of collaboration on how to make students work together and how to teach the Second Steps program (on behavior and conflict resolution). … That happens in every single grade: it is given to every class so they all know similar strategies.” Cindy reported: So when you see a child who has been in our school since grade 1, and let’s say they’ve reached grade 6, they will have a whole collection of experiences that they’ve shared as a whole group, but also individually in classrooms. And it’s also about sharing between the staff too, about what you’ve done as their grade 3 teacher, as their grade 4 teacher; and I can take that and build on it the next year … and not teach in isolation.
Among the school-wide projects was the Butterfly Project, coordinated by Naomi. All the classes from Kindergarten to grade 6 participated in some way in rearing, caring for, observing, writing about, and eventually releasing a colony of Monarch butterflies. A major aspect of the collaboration among the staff was teaching each other. Of course, much incidental sharing took place as they worked together, but often the instruction and coaching were more systematic. This was truly a learning community. For example, James said: Since I’ve started here I’ve had some excellent workshops and programs run by people at the school, such as the literacy coordinator (Cindy) and our old VP (the school no longer has a VP). In First Steps literacy, experienced teachers within the school prepared workshops for us to attend in the library after school and at lunch-time. … They showed us how they implemented First Steps in their classrooms. They brought student work and charts they had used and put things on overhead projectors. … And the librarian (Nina) will show us things that are on the computer.
Naomi, who later launched the Monarch project, described how she was introduced to integrated programming by other teachers at the school. One day the literacy coordinator (Cindy) and another teacher had a planning day and they involved me. They were teaching grades 3 and 4 and I had a grade 2/3 class, and we sat down to do some planning. They dragged me in and used the board, a chart, a map, and so
80
C. Beck et al. on, and I was like, How did you do that?! So I was blown away, but I guess they saw that I was willing to try and was capable of doing it. So … that’s how I got into cross-curricular planning, and they were really happy that I accomplished that.
The teachers believed that staff collaboration, within a shared vision, was important for the success of the school. Andrea described how, for literacy, students from Kindergarten onward have folders with work samples and other information that are passed on from one year to the next, so that “it’s not just individual classes, we’re pushing for a school-wide approach.” Similarly, Cindy commented: With our Butterfly Project … we’re now going into our third year of having the Monarchs in the school. So for example, the students who started with it in grade 1, and for whom all this learning about insects was new, those children now will be in grade 3. When their teacher starts to talk to them about life-cycle, migration, the changes, graphing, and keeping notes and records, that will remind them of what their teachers talked about in previous years.
Being part of a collaborative enterprise meant a lot of hard work, but several teachers maintained it was worth it. As we saw earlier, Natalie realized that implementing the vision involved extra work but said that all teachers have to work hard, and this is just a different way to do it. Naomi’s attitude was that “it’s stimulating, as a person, to be in a place where you can actually use your brain. Otherwise your job just becomes this thing that you go to and then you go home again, right? So for me, I feel I’m engaged.” Andrea commented: Teaching is not the only profession where the first couple of years you have to work a lot harder than you do later on. I mean, there are lots of other professions where people go in on a Saturday. It takes a while to build up a program and feel comfortable with what you’re doing. Even if I was in another school I think I would be working just as hard, but my job would probably be even more difficult because I wouldn’t have the resources to actually do what I want to do.
Teacher Leadership A key aspect of the model of school reform at Bridge Street was leadership by the teachers, especially the four “instructional leaders.” It is perhaps paradoxical to have strong leadership by a subgroup of teachers within a staff community, but in fact the teacher leaders helped to nurture a communal approach. Without teacher leaders who deliberately cross boundaries, teachers tend to work in isolation rather than as a community. For her part, the principal (Janet) said she found the teacher leaders invaluable and could not have developed and implemented the model without them. She gave them a lot of responsibility and room for initiative. The teachers designated as instructional leaders were Cindy the literacy coordinator, Mark the behavior resource person, Nina the librarian, and Linda the special education coordinator (or MART – methods and resource teacher). In addition, Gina helped with literacy, Natalie with behavior (especially through the Second Steps program), and Naomi with science (especially through the Butterfly Project). Other teachers mentored new teachers and assisted in a variety of ways.
6 A Whole-School Approach to Urban Educational Renewal
81
How did the position of instructional leader come into being? Janet explained that she invented the role at the school: I call them instructional leaders; it’s just me calling them that. … Cindy’s the only one who has an actual school board position, a 0.5 allocated for PD in literacy because we are an EYLP (early years literacy project) school. The term instructional leader is used elsewhere in the board, but I use it in a different sense: to acknowledge their special leadership role in this school. For example, the MART position comes from the board, but together Linda and I built the “struggling learner” piece, and I consider that a leadership thing. Similarly, Mark built the behavior piece, and I consider that leadership.
So although it was not official at a school board level, Janet was able to set up a whole structure of leadership in her school. But doing so required a strong vision and a lot of juggling of budgets, positions, and roles. How was it possible in budget terms to have such a leadership structure? We have noted that Cindy’s half-time literacy position was funded by the school board. Nina’s library resource position was possible because she was the librarian, although having a librarian in a small school in Toronto today takes considerable ingenuity and determination with respect to both program and budget. Regarding the other two positions, Janet explained: In my first year here as VP (1996–97) the behavior was really awful; so the staff, the principal, and I decided to put forward a proposal to have a 0.5 behavior resource teacher, which meant that the teachers agreed to accept higher class numbers in order to have somebody who would support behavior. And that was the beginning of the turn-around for this school, we never looked back. Then eventually – about two or three years ago – they changed the special education model in the board and sent it all to the home schools. And that gave us the MART (Linda) 1.0 and 0.5 for the home-school program. So with 1.5 for special education, including Mark’s piece devoted to behavior, we were able to lower class size again.
Role of the Principal As one might expect, the principal – Janet – was a key figure in the school renewal effort at Bridge Street. It is difficult to imagine a school-based approach being successful without a strong and supportive principal. Janet began at Bridge Street as vice principal in 1996 and became principal in 1999. The teachers spoke about her important leadership role. Linda observed: “A lot of the vision comes from Janet. She has her finger on the pulse out there, what the current things are. And she will show, at our meetings, that she reads herself.” According to Cindy, “the school culture comes from Janet” and “she is the driving force.” Although she had vision and passion, however, Janet did not control the school in an overly top-down manner. She was open and flexible and relied heavily on the talent and initiatives of her teachers. As she said: “I’m open to a lot of different things … and if I see a good idea I try to implement it; but if it doesn’t work I drop it. I don’t have a vested interest in stuff.” On the matter of teacher autonomy, she commented: I’ve never been a person who wanted to tell teachers what to teach. To me teaching was such a creative enterprise, and I always enjoyed that aspect of it. I would hate for the prin-
82
C. Beck et al. cipal to prevent that. My expectations are very clear, even around topics in the curriculum. But my teachers know I’ll leave them alone if they’re doing a good job. So as long as they’re meeting the broad objectives, they can pretty well do what they want; I’m not interested in that kind of micro-management.
In the interviews and focus groups, the teachers repeatedly confirmed that Janet gave them considerable leeway. But while she did not control the details, Janet participated in the school at a detailed level, and we see this as an important distinction. She did not just leave the teachers to their own devices but worked closely with them. According to James, “she is committed to everyone being successful. … She honestly knows the name of every single student in the school and can tell you what grade they’re in and how they’re doing.” Janet’s central concern was the children’s academic and personal development and their general well-being. However, she took very seriously her role of providing material and other resources needed in the school. Nina observed: “She is very supportive. Like you’ll say, I really think we could use more of such and such, and she’ll say, Oh okay, I’ll find the money for it.” Jane said: “This school has perhaps been the one where I’ve received the most support as a teacher. Our principal is very open to our suggestions, and when we mention a problem she make things work; and unfortunately in public education, things usually don’t turn out the way you want them to.” Apart from resources for teaching, Janet also took great care to establish a school office and building facility that supported the teachers and the program.
Impact The Bridge Street efforts at school renewal led to what we regard as strongly positive changes in school programming, processes, and culture. These changes in turn undoubtedly had a major impact on student academic and personal development, although we were not in a position to assess this systematically. We observed strong practice in the classrooms: the state-of-the-art approaches to literacy teaching, group work, and special education promoted by the principal and instructional leaders were being implemented. Cross-curricular teaching was widespread. Students were engaged. And the staff’s commitment to “never giving up on kids” could be seen in the relationship between the teachers and their students. An especially apparent area of success was student interest in reading. Janet commented that “Nina loves books and the kids adore her, and our rate of borrowing books from the library went up 25 per cent in the first year she took over.” James, Ann, and Mark all spoke of how interest in reading had risen significantly in the school among both boys and girls. Improvement in behavior throughout the school was perhaps the most dramatic change that occurred. According to Naomi, the school is “complimented all the time on how well the kids behave.” James observed that behavior used to be so bad that he refused to supply teach at the school (before he became a permanent teacher there), even though he lived just a couple of blocks away. “The teachers used to have to take attendance ten times a day because children would literally run
6 A Whole-School Approach to Urban Educational Renewal
83
away, or hide in the bathrooms. … But now it’s not really an issue any more, the school culture has changed so much.” In general, the respectful and caring approach of Mark and the rest of the staff toward the students helped build a positive culture throughout the school and in individual classrooms, a culture that was strongly conducive to ensuring that all students are successful. Many of the teachers spoke about how the community in their classroom had improved in recent years. At a school level, the atmosphere in the hallways and at assemblies was positive and friendly. Beyond the school, too, community links became stronger. Jane observed: “Community involvement has been progressing, at least since I’ve been here. In the past, parents were not that involved in the school. But over the last couple years … we have had some community events and everyone is surprised at the good turn out. … So the school is slowly becoming a part of the community, and people are starting to look at the school with a sense of pride.”
Conclusion and Recommendations From what we could see, the renewal effort at Bridge Street School was very successful. It resulted in enhanced programming, increased student engagement, substantial improvement in behavior, and a positive school culture and atmosphere. We think it highly likely that these changes in turn had a major impact on students’ academic and personal development, taking this strongly urban school some distance toward the goal of ensuring that all students are successful. The changes that took place appeared to be due in large measure to: developing a common vision; building community among the staff; working closely together; establishing a structure of teacher leadership; and having a strong principal at the helm. In many ways the renewal effort took place under favorable circumstances. The school was relatively small, a factor considered crucial by many school reformers (Meier, 1995; Wood, 1998). The principal was unusually able and knowledgeable and prepared to take a firm stand on the reforms. The teachers were also very talented and committed. And the school district had a policy of providing additional support to schools in poorer neighborhoods. However, there are ways of establishing a “school-within-a-school” to create the kind of context that was established at Bridge Street. Principals can be trained and encouraged to become more involved in substantive aspects of their school. And teachers can be selected and trained for a role similar to that followed at Bridge Street. We believe other schools could adopt many of the same strategies for ensuring that all students are successful. Based on our study, we would make the following recommendations for pursuing the success of all students in urban settings: ● ● ● ●
Keep the school small (or form a school-within-a-school). Select teachers carefully. Foster community and collaboration among the staff. Develop an explicit, shared vision for the school.
84 ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ●
C. Beck et al.
In the vision, emphasize curriculum, behavior, and community. Establish school-wide programs, projects, and approaches. Build a structure of teacher leadership, including in-house professional development. Involve the principal deeply in developing the program and culture of the school. Develop community across the school and in individual classrooms. Establish close links with parents and the neighborhood community. Seek help from the school district and other potential supporters. Link up with government and district-wide initiatives that support the school’s vision.
References Barth, R. (1990). Improving schools from within. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Beck, C., Hart, D., & Kosnik, C. (2002). The teaching standards movement and current teaching practices. Canadian Journal of Education, 27(2), 153–172. Cuban, L. (1998). How schools change reforms: Redefining reform success and failure. Teachers College Record, 99(3), 453–477. Darling-Hammond, L. (1997). The right to learn: A blueprint for creating schools that work. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Fullan, M. (1991). The new meaning of educational change (2nd ed.). New York: Teachers College Press. Meier, D. (1995). The power of their ideas. Boston, MA: Beacon Press. National Council of Teachers of Mathematics. (1995). Assessment standards for school mathematics. Reston, VA: Author. Punch, K. (2005). Introduction to social research: Quantitative and qualitative approaches (2nd ed.). London: Sage. Sarason, S. (1990). The predictable failure of educational reform. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Sergiovanni, T. (1992). Moral leadership: Getting to the heart of school improvement. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Wood, G. (1998). A time to learn. New York: Dutton. Zemelman, S., Daniels, H., & Hyde, A. (1998). Best practice. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
Part II
Learning Communities in University Settings
Introduction Anastasia P. Samaras
The chapters in this section demonstrate that although we often think of learning communities in elementary and secondary schools, learning communities also have an essential place in university settings. The chapter authors invite us to consider how programs and courses for teachers, education students, dissertation-bound students, and doctoral candidates might look if there was a sense of community in their learning. These very interesting chapters offer detailed descriptions of key attributes of university-based learning communities. They call our attention to common themes found across the chapters and the value the community placed on relationship and interrelationships; the need for members to feel safe to take risks and to share any individual concerns that might impact the group; and the importance of caring about each other’s ideas for the group’s sustainability. As a whole, the chapters also highlight the attributes of openness and trustfulness in developing and sustaining learning communities. Impressive in each of these studies are the participants’ ongoing commitment to a shared group goal or task. You will read about their research rich with data on how their communities offered members academic, professional, and personal support. Authors explain their work in building and maintaining a learning community, the challenges they faced, and the refinements they were willing to negotiate as a group. The chapters also shed light on the importance of multiple perspectives in helping each community member to learn from and with others. Especially noteworthy in each of the learning communities was the usefulness and practicality of the work to the participants’ everyday lives and the positive impact the communities made in education. This section opens with Chapter 7, where Stern describes a challenging and rewarding journey in the development of learning communities designed to provide ongoing support and professional development for teacher graduates. Teachers are often catapulted into their teaching worlds with little or no contact or support from faculty. This chapter offers an example of a college’s role in changing that situation. In peer discussion groups, new graduates and college alumni developed a collegial exchange with faculty serving as group facilitators. This chapter provides an honest appraisal of the challenges in sustaining learning communities and how members mutually struggled to define and redefine their roles. It includes a discussion of the support the community needed, the lessons they learned along the way, and the success that resulted from their collective efforts.
A.P. Samaras et al. (eds.) Learning Communities In Practice, © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2008
87
88
A.P. Samaras
In Chapter 8, Freese and Strong take us into their multicultural education classroom where a unique learning community was established in their co-taught university class. They provide detailed descriptions of the instructional activities that brought theory into practice for their students and themselves. They explain the ways they supported and encouraged all voices and allowed students to get to know one another beyond superficial connections. Their pedagogical approach cultivated a classroom culture where students and faculty could wrestle and unpack tensions related to openly discussing multicultural issues and arriving at new understandings. Honoring their students’ multiplicity of identities, respectfully listening to students’ personal histories, and creating a classroom anthology with their students, enabled the class to experience, and not just talk about, a classroom learning community. In Chapter 9, Klein et al. explain the process and structure of their dissertation support group and offer a model for other doctoral programs interested in supporting their students through the arduous dissertation journey. As with Stern’s Chapter 7, the authors emphasize that conceptual and personal support and the development and care of other’s ideas are mutually beneficial to members who are new to any position, whether they are doctoral students, teachers, or peer discussion facilitators. This selfformed support group recognized that it is the multiple perspectives and voices, a dedication to reciprocity, and a commitment to mutuality that benefits all participants. Their work speaks volumes of the potential and need for such learning communities for all doctoral students during and after the completion of their dissertations. This section concludes with Chapter 10, where Samaras et al. tell us about how their learning community evolved as they supported each other in learning and teaching about the self-study research methodology. The “Mason Group” invites us to consider what a doctoral research method would entail if the professor shared leadership, learning, and researching with her students. They describe the pedagogical activities that were catalysts to their learning community designed with an application of Vygotsky’s (1981) ideas of situated learning, the zone of proximal development, social cognition, and using the arts as a mediating tool. Individually and collectively, the research members grew as self-study scholars as they questioned and shifted their thinking within a supportive, trustful, and open classroom atmosphere. Collectively, the studies in this section advance our understanding about the design of learning communities in higher education and how they can, and do, thrive in university settings. The chapters provide useful exemplars of learning communities that serve both students and faculty and are both scholarly and practical. These studies shift the paradigm of thinking about how learning communities can be developed in university settings and how much they are needed.
Reference Vygotsky, L. S. (1981). The genesis of higher mental functions. In J. V. Wertsch (Ed.), The concept of activity in Soviet psychology, (pp. 144–188). Armonk, NY: Sharpe. (Original work published 1960)
Chapter 7
Fellow Travelers: New Teachers and Their Graduate School Faculty Take a Journey to the Land of Peer Discussion Groups Barbara Stern
Toward the end of the 2007 school year, I had dinner at a restaurant in Brooklyn with nine members of a peer discussion group called “Weaving Bank Street Principles into Your Every Day Math Practice,” organized and facilitated by Hal Melnick, a fellow faculty member at Bank Street College of Education. The group had graciously invited me to join their celebration culminating 10 weeks of visiting one another’s schools and classrooms, sharing teaching practices, and engaging in collective brainstorming about ways to integrate learnings from graduate school with the demands and realities of their school cultures. Throughout the meal, tales of summer plans and other bits of personal lives mixed easily with serious discussion of teaching issues. As the group prepared to say their goodbyes, David asked the person next to him for advice about the next morning’s math lesson, and soon the entire group was once more engaged in lively discussion. For me, this was a culminating experience of a different nature. Three years previously, I had started coordinating a new induction program at Bank Street College. The program was part of a larger project funded by Teachers for a New Era (TNE), an initiative whose goal is to strengthen K-12 teaching by researching and enhancing programs of teacher preparation. In a collaborative venture of the Graduate School faculty and other members of the college community, an induction committee and I had designed and implemented several types of support for new teachers. Now the TNE project was drawing to a close. Listening to the group members reflect on themselves as a community of learners, I thought about the many moments of collaborative planning and learning that had led up to the formation of this and other peer discussion groups. In fact, although it was not the conscious intention of the TNE project, other communities of learners had emerged through the process of creating professional support and growth opportunities for graduates. The peer discussion groups for new teachers were the “intentional communities” that we set out to establish. Much to my surprise, other “unintentional communi-
B. Stern Bank Street College
A.P. Samaras et al. (eds.) Learning Communities In Practice, © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2008
89
90
B. Stern
ties” of faculty members also developed over time. Reflecting back on the experience of designing, creating, and implementing the peer discussion groups, it seems that faculty may have the same yearnings for connection and social learning opportunities as their students. This chapter traces the evolution of Bank Street College’s peer discussion groups, from the perspectives of both faculty members and new teachers. It looks at new teachers and faculty members as “fellow travelers” on a journey. While I write primarily from the perspective of an organizer and observer of the peer discussion groups, I also write from my vantage point as a facilitator of one of the first peer discussion groups and a participant in the concomitant faculty communities of learners.
History and Context of the Peer Discussion Groups for New Teachers1 When Bank Street College of Education was selected to participate in the TNE initiative in 2002, one of the challenges and opportunities was the requirement to establish a program of induction support for recent graduates (Carnegie Corporation of New York, 2002). Like most other teacher education programs, we had not previously delineated a formal role in providing ongoing support and professional development to our graduates, though many faculties remained informally connected to former students. In designing this new program of support for graduates, we grappled simultaneously with redefining the roles of a teacher education program and individual faculty members in the professional lives of new educators. Relationships and collaboration are essential elements of all teaching and learning at Bank Street. All graduate students participate in a year-long, 12-credit experience of Supervised Fieldwork, which includes weekly “conference group” sessions with an adviser and four to six other students. Additionally, students meet at least twice a month with their advisers (Hirsch, 1991; Darling-Hammond & McDonald, 2000). In courses, students engage in Vygotskian social learning experiences such as small group discussions and collaborative projects (Samaras & Gismondi, 1998). Likewise, Graduate School faculty typically work together in a spirit of collaborative inquiry. In other words, graduate students and faculty are immersed in a number of learning communities (Beck & Kosnik, 2006). In designing the new induction program, it was important to maintain and build upon our core values of relationship and collaboration, and to create multiple kinds of learning communities to meet the varying needs of graduates. Though we did not frame it like this at the time, our experiments with various induction offerings represented an exploration of various types of learning communities. During the three-year lifetime of the induction program, we offered a web 1 While in this chapter I use “new teachers” to distinguish the participants from the faculty (teacher educator) facilitators, we usually prefer the term “new educators” to include graduates who worked in hospitals and other settings.
7 New Teachers and Their Graduate School Faculty
91
site with contributions from teachers, an online discussion group, a buddy system that matched new and experienced teachers, and a large-scale gathering. (For a more detailed description of these offerings, see Stern et al., 2006, 2007). With each of these offerings, we experimented with a different balance of support from fellow new teachers, more experienced teachers, and faculty members. In designing the peer discussion groups, we honed in on a particular desire and need frequently expressed by graduates: to reconnect with peers and faculty from the graduate program of study, in order to continue growing as a professional. The peer discussion groups were designed to provide opportunities for graduates to explore particular areas of interest and reconnect and expand their networks with colleagues from Bank Street, with facilitation from a faculty member.
The Challenges in Creating Peer Discussion Groups Prior to setting up peer discussion groups, we faced the challenges and limited success of attracting recent graduates to other induction offerings. We knew that new teachers were swamped and overwhelmed with the daily challenges of teaching, with little time or energy for anything else. Additionally, we recognized that dependency issues can be quite complex for new teachers. It is not always easy to admit that one feels insecure, overwhelmed, and/or less than fully competent. Some new teachers feel that asking for help is tantamount to admitting that they are not good teachers. Others, who view themselves as self-sufficient, are reluctant to admit that they need suggestions or encouragement from more experienced others. With the peer discussion groups, we hoped to focus on the strengths and interests of our graduates, rather than their needs or deficits. There were also challenges on the faculty side. For many faculty members, this was the first time that they were formally involved in the postgraduate learning of their former students. Recognizing that learning to find professional resources and establish professional relationships are key tasks of new teachers, and that building and growing a professional community of colleagues outside of the graduate school setting is an essential facet of success for our graduates, faculty grappled with the associated shifts in relationships with their former students. Some faculty members likened this process to the stage in parenting when the child leaves home. Like the parallel shift that occurs between parent and young adult child, the changing relationship between faculty members and graduates involves a transformation on both sides. Without the power differential that typically exists between teacher and student, the relationship has the potential to become more equal and collaborative. It is not always easy, however, to make this change. The peer discussion groups were an exciting way to address some of these challenges. Exit and alumni surveys indicated that graduates highly valued the weekly conference group component of their Supervised Fieldwork experience, and frequently wanted to maintain it after graduation. They also wanted to maintain connections with faculty members with whom they had close relationships. Peer
92
B. Stern
discussion groups could offer opportunities to connect with a small group of fellow graduates, as well as a faculty member. They seemed consistent with our growing understanding of an induction model that provided a transition from dependence on faculty to independent professional growth.
A Journey to the Land of Peer Discussion Groups The Beginning of the Journey: Conceptualizing the Peer Discussion Groups When the faculty facilitators2 of the peer discussion groups (or study groups, as they were originally called) started the journey of conceptualizing and creating the groups, we focused on the needs and interests of recent graduates. We walked the slippery slope of trying to design and shape something for others, while maintaining a philosophical stance that the groups would be whatever the participants wanted them to be. We rarely, if ever, talked about ourselves as fellow learners along with the new teacher participants. We did, however, quickly recognize that our planning group was itself turning into a sort of study group. Our first meeting took place in the apartment of one of the faculty facilitators. Linda Levine had prepared a beautiful spread of food, and as we helped set the table and chatted about our summers, it felt much like the beginning of a conference group meeting. Our conversation about the content and format of the groups also felt similar to a conference group conversation, with each member paying mindful attention and sharing thoughtful responses. Unknowingly, we were creating for ourselves a learning environment which we would later mirror in the peer discussion groups. Over the next few months, we exchanged a flurry of e-mails in which we ironed out details and built a mutual understanding of the groups. We had all planned courses collaboratively with colleagues, but this felt different. We were inventing something together. We wrestled with big and small questions, such as: Do participants need to engage in a predetermined course of study like reading a book or doing an assessment of student work? Should there be an “end product” such as a social action research plan? What are the pros and cons of meeting at the college versus a facilitator’s apartment? We struggled with how to convey the message that the group participants would shape the groups, even though we were presenting written descriptions for outreach purposes. We eventually crafted a publicity flyer that included a description of each of the groups and a summary statement which read: “Would you like to meet with other recent Bank Street graduates to address
2 The following current or former Bank Street College faculty members planned and/or facilitated peer discussion groups between 2005 and 2007: Nancy Balaban, Susan Goetz-Haver, Harriet Lenk, Linda Levine, Diana-Elena Matsoukas, Hal Melnick, Gil Schmerler, Jonathan Silin, Barbara Stern, and Patty Weiner.
7 New Teachers and Their Graduate School Faculty
93
issues of common concern to new educators?” We named the groups: (1) Looking Critically at Equity Issues within a School Culture: Using Social Action Research to Find Possibilities for Change; (2) Diversity in the Classroom: Family, Child, and Teacher; (3) Linking Observation and Assessment of Children Through Use of Descriptive Review Processes; and (4) Aesthetic Education.
First Stop on the Journey: Is This a Study Group or a Class? Response to outreach was so limited that, with great disappointment, we decided to postpone the start of three of the four groups. Only Linda had enough participants to start her Social Action Research Study Group. She sent the rest of us detailed descriptive notes from each of the group sessions, and together we identified issues that affected all of the groups. For instance, some non-Bank Street graduates who taught together wanted to join the group. Linda wrote in an e-mail: “Our aim is to help support grads by offering supportive, collegial community, opportunities for learning, etc. Helping grads build bridges to other like-minded colleagues in the field would be a useful thing.” We then raised the possibility of including experienced teachers, who had also expressed interest in the groups. Would this increase professional growth opportunities for new teachers, or would it betray the goals of providing induction support for recent graduates? After many rich discussions about the nature of social learning, we decided that, like mixed-age groupings for children, a mixture of new and experienced teachers would offer multiple learning opportunities for everyone. While Linda’s group continued (and dwindled in size due to the heavy teaching demands on some of the participants), the rest of us “went back to the drawing boards.” I wrote optimistically: “I see this as an opportunity to step back and creatively reconceptualize what we are doing.” A moment of epiphany occurred when we reread our group descriptions. They sounded like course descriptions, straight out of the Bank Street catalog! Much as we had wanted to invent something new, it was hard to escape our course instructor mentality. In fact, we were sometimes still talking about “teaching this course” rather than “facilitating this group.” In order to put aside our course-like way of describing the groups, we needed to deeply understand how the study groups differed from courses, and to alter our language accordingly. Summary notes from a facilitators’ meeting reflect our evolving understanding of the groups. “Some of the distinctions [between a course and a study group] that we noted were: a study group is driven by the interests and concerns of its members. It provides an opportunity to share individual and/or group interests, with many possibilities for working collaboratively. It is more open-ended and constructivist than a course, and doesn’t necessarily have an end product. The role of the study group leader isn’t exactly the same as the role of a course instructor.” The last line of the notes reads, “We ended by noting that we are like a study group ourselves!” Our collaborative process continued as we tweaked some of the groups, radically redesigned others, shortened or changed the names, and rewrote all of the descriptions. Recognizing the importance of language in conveying the intent of the “study
94
B. Stern
groups,” we also struggled with what to call them. Ira Lit, TNE Project Director, humorously but seriously advised, “Study Group – maybe this isn’t an appealing enough title for what we’re doing. A ‘Book Club’ sounds like a lot more fun. So does ‘Recess’ or ‘Tea & Cookies’ for that matter. While we’re not describing the endeavor like a course, perhaps having a faculty member invite one to ‘study’ invokes a similar reaction.” We ultimately changed the name to “peer discussion groups.” It is noteworthy that we did not include recent graduates, the “target audience” for the groups, in this process of reconceptualization. We were still trying to figure out what they wanted and needed, rather than giving them a true voice in reshaping the groups. One of the greatest challenges in shifting away from a course instructor mentality was giving up the monopoly on planning the learning process.
Second Stop on the Journey: This Is Harder than We Thought It Would Be! One of the groups that transformed significantly was “Diversity in the Classroom: Family, Child, and Teacher,” facilitated by Diana-Elena Matsoukas. The original description of this group read: “Are you seeking a forum to brainstorm, analyze, reflect, experiment, and craft a piece of thoughtful responsive work/project that focuses on diversity in your learning setting/classroom? Come and join a semesterlong alumni study group for Bank Street educators. … We will meet as a small group, and work at crafting/refining a piece of individual work/project, with the support of the group, that enables us to connect the diversity of children and families with the teaching and learning in our learning communities/classrooms. We will focus our study with a literature exploration of [an issue of a teaching journal].” Trying to be sensitive to the scheduling challenges faced by many teachers and the requests for online discussions that we had received, Diana-Elena decided to offer an online rather than in-person group. Her revised description read: “The On-Line Book Talk is a new study group being offered to Bank Street teachers, and soon-to-be graduates, who are interested in discussing a seminal piece of writing in the field of education. In this venue the group will engage in on-line discussion about a past or current book written by a provocative thinker and problem-solver. … The group process will serve to open pathways of thinking about elements and issues of social justice and how these can impact our teaching practice in independent or public schools communities.” Unfortunately, while many teachers expressed an interest in joining this online book talk group, there were never enough active participants to get it off the ground. I completely changed the focus of my group, and renamed it “Teacher Talk: Challenges and Opportunities in Under-Resourced Schools.” We met four times with three to five participants per session. Because there was a different configuration of participants at each session, a sense of community never developed. But the Art Matters group met regularly with nine to 14 participants at each of the four sessions. Reflecting on possible reasons for the sustained engagement of
7 New Teachers and Their Graduate School Faculty
95
participants, faculty facilitator Harriet Lenk spoke about the desire of new teachers to “nurture themselves.” She felt that framing the group as “not necessarily something to use in their classrooms, [but rather] for themselves” was a draw that motivated participants to come to each session. While the content of the group sessions clearly related to teaching, and the participants shared information and ideas that could be used with children, participants’ sense of deep satisfaction seemed to derive from the experience of joining with fellow teachers.
Third Stop on the Journey: Time To Adjust and Refine Upon completion of the peer discussion groups, the facilitators had a “debriefing” meeting to share reflections on the groups and to contemplate possible changes for the next round of groups. The debriefing meeting was noteworthy because it brought to our attention the faculty facilitator group’s nonjudgmental and noncompetitive nature. Rather, faculty members spoke honestly about the challenges in supporting new teachers, and about their own professional growth. Linda summed it up by saying “Be sure to let faculty and graduates know much we learned and grew in the peer discussion groups!” As Kosnik and Beck noted in their response to a description of Bank Street’s induction program and the evolution of the peer discussion groups (Stern et al., 2007), “The collaborative process was clearly at the heart of [the] work … the evidence-gathering element allow[ed] for the program to be continuously adjusted and refined” (Kosnik & Beck, 2007). The first-year facilitators completed their work together by rewriting their original description of peer discussion groups. The new statement, which was subsequently placed on all publicity materials, reflects an understanding of the spirit of the peer discussion groups that could only be gained from experience. It read: “Teaching Today – Imagining Tomorrow!” “Want more of the intellectual nourishment you found at Bank Street? Looking for a chance to reconnect with colleagues from Bank Street and expand your resources and professional community? Join one of our new peer discussion groups! Each group will have a mix of recent alums, experienced educators, and soon-to-be graduates, and will be facilitated by a Graduate School faculty member.” We also decided to widen the circle of faculty engaged in this conversation by holding a faculty seminar with presentations by recent graduates. After hearing several peer discussion group participants speak about how the group experience helped them get through difficult situations in their schools, faculty participated in a lengthy discussion about their role in supporting new educators. I believe that engagement in this dialogue inspired many faculty members to submit proposals to the TNE Leadership Team for new peer discussion groups. The team was stunned and delighted to receive 17 proposals, which gave us the opportunity to offer groups with a range of topics and formats. The five groups selected for 2006–2007 were entitled: (1) Child Life Chatter: Challenges and Opportunities; (2) Hot Topics in a Cold Climate: Talking Tough Topics in
96
B. Stern
Today’s Classrooms; (3) So Why Isn’t She/He Reading Yet?; (4) Teacher Leadership: Meeting the Challenge; and (5) Weaving Bank Street Principles into Your Daily Math Practice.
Fourth Stop on the Journey: We Are Really on a Roll Now! Again, faculty facilitators met to plan their groups collaboratively. This time I was more aware of the learning opportunities for the facilitators, and together we pondered how to use some of the insights gained from the experiences of the first-year facilitators. For example, we spoke explicitly about the complicated role of the faculty facilitator and ways to create a shared sense of ownership of the groups. We also talked seriously about the learning implications of involving teacher participants in nitty-gritty decisions like where and when the groups would meet. As each facilitator crafted her or his group, we became acutely aware that there is no perfect model to meet the needs of all new educators, and that “meeting the needs of new teachers” is often very complicated. Like the first year of the peer discussion groups, outreach and publicity required a tremendous amount of energy, but ultimately five of the six groups were up and running with approximately ten participants in each group. Faculty and participants were brimming with excitement, and many shared reflections with me as the groups progressed. After his first session, when Hal was so moved that he could not sleep, he wrote a reflection that included the following: “One participant (who teaches in a school in the Bronx) reluctantly but courageously admitted how difficult it felt for her to walk into this [affluent] school’s entranceway. In spite of the obvious painful contrasts and in the spirit of Lucy Sprague Mitchell, this dedicated teacher did not turn around and leave. She joined in. We all are here for one reason; to learn from and to help support one another.” For the teacher participants, the reflections tended to focus on the power of meeting with colleagues to talk about pressing issues. It was striking that the participants felt they were not only giving and receiving support, but were also engaged in active learning and professional growth. Megan Monteleone-Morrison, a new educator, summed it up by saying “I thoroughly enjoyed the peer discussion group, especially the connections – curricular and emotional-social – it enabled.”
Fifth Stop: One Journey Ends, Another Begins With the termination of TNE funding in 2007, Bank Street was no longer able to offer faculty-facilitated peer discussion groups. However, the legacy of the groups lives on, and the experience is infused in much of our work at Bank Street. When the groups ended, I conducted individual interviews with each of the faculty facilitators and several of the teacher participants, in order to gather information about their
7 New Teachers and Their Graduate School Faculty
97
experiences and to identify themes that could inform our ongoing work with students and graduates. Our learnings provide insights to others interested in traveling the road of developing peer discussion groups.
Impact and Insights Many comments in the interviews were similar to those of the first-year facilitators and participants. Interviewees spoke poignantly about the profound impact of the peer discussion groups on themselves as teachers and learners. The themes that emerged in the interviews have important implications for teachers and teacher educators.
Importance of Ongoing Nurturance and Support for Educators Across all of the groups, facilitators felt that the nurturance and support that participants gave to one another was at least as important as the content of the conversations. Patty Weiner reported that the participants in the Child Life group viewed the group meetings as “a time for themselves,” and an opportunity to talk about managing the stresses of their work. Many participants felt their school or hospital settings did not provide the kind of caring community that they had treasured at Bank Street. In Jonathan Silin’s group, teachers talked about needing support that was largely lacking within their schools. He said poignantly, “I thought people would come in with a ‘hot topics’ concern. However, a large part of the time was spent talking about the ‘cold climate’.” This group decided to attend a performance of an education-related play and go out to a restaurant afterwards, combining socializing with an exploration of teaching in the age of No Child Left Behind. With the peer discussion groups, participants were able to recreate elements of the conference group, while at the same time transforming the group into a new type of learning community that was appropriate to their stage of professional growth. Gil Schmerler reflected the sentiments of most of the facilitators when he said, “I see this as pretty close to a conference group. I think that’s what they want.”
Importance of Sharing Ideas and Concerns with Like-Minded Educators Many participants worked in settings where their teaching practices were not highly valued (or in some cases, were actively discouraged) by their colleagues. The groups offered opportunities for professional validation as well as exchange of ideas. In a farewell e-mail to Hal, Sharon Kramer wrote: “Although I didn’t take full advantage of our group because the logistics were sometimes nuts for me, I did
98
B. Stern
appreciate the opportunity to share ideas, questions, frustrations, and successes with a group of smart, caring educators. … I learned that no matter how diverse our educational settings, caring educators share a number of qualities including a strong spirit, passion, willingness to be self-reflective, and a sense of humor. … And mostly, I learned that it really helps me to have peers to share my work with.” Hal added that the visits to classrooms “allowed each member to show off in a very joyful way.”
Importance of Ongoing Professional Growth Opportunities and Renewal for Teacher Educators In the interviews, many faculty facilitators also spoke explicitly about their own professional growth. For instance, Nancy Balaban had long dreamed of creating a postgraduation group focused on the supervision issues of early childhood teachers. Funding from the TNE project gave her the opportunity to reach a long-awaited professional goal. Many of the facilitators also alluded to the transformative nature of their experience in planning and facilitating the groups. Hal identified two specific ways in which he had been transformed. Describing the impact of visiting the classrooms of recent graduates, he spoke of his intention to reorient his graduate school courses to include direct exposure to new teachers. He also spoke passionately about how the participants in his group “affirmed some of his beliefs” and inspired him. He reiterated what he wrote after the second meeting of the group: “It is so uplifting in the middle of my week! Everyone is committed to help one another learn. This is a delicious thing.” Recalling Virginia Richardson’s call for all teachers to be given opportunities for renewal (Richardson, 2007), I asked Hal if this group gave him a sense of renewal, and, as if recognizing that indeed this is what it was, he enthusiastically replied yes.
Importance of Clarifying the Role of Teacher Educators in Supporting New Teachers Throughout the process of facilitating the groups and into the final interviews, many of the facilitators grappled with understanding their role in relation to recent graduates. When I asked Jonathan what he would do differently if he were to do it over again, he immediately answered, “have a better conceptualization of our role as faculty.” Gil captured the depth of the challenge when he wrote after his first session “The people who came were really excited, but I mostly felt confused.” He honestly shared his ongoing confusion about the group and his role in it. He felt that it was much “messier” than being an adviser or course instructor, describing complicated decisions like introducing specific content versus allowing the group to take on its own shape, and “trying to bring together all the threads of the conversations.”
7 New Teachers and Their Graduate School Faculty
99
Other facilitators spoke explicitly about distinguishing their new role from that of a course instructor. Nancy explained the difference: “A class has a set agenda and I stick to it, with a goal in mind. I keep moving people forward … I’m in charge.” Her goal for the peer discussion group, on the other hand, was to “present opportunities to express deep concerns.” She introduced a focusing question at the beginning of the first session, and then let the discussion go in whatever direction the participants took it, recognizing that participants valued the shared experience more than any answers that she might try to provide. Harriet was mindful about the group process and used specific strategies “to get away from being the group leader.” Drawing upon a common model in Child Life3 and other therapeutic fields, Patty compared her role to that of a facilitator. While her overarching goal was to create a sense of “camaraderie” among the participants, she also helped structure learning experiences by bringing resources to the group and inviting a guest speaker to address common concerns. Patty was also available by phone or e-mail to the participants if they had a difficult case or situation at work.
Moving Forward at Bank Street and Implications for Other Teacher Education Programs Where do we go from here? One of the charges of the TNE grant was to use evidence to drive program renewal. How can we use evidence from the peer discussion group’s journey to transform our ways of working with students and graduates? Although facilitators and participants lamented the lack of funding to offer more faculty-facilitated groups, this has also pushed us to ask how we can best promote autonomy and mutual support among new educators. As we wended our way on the journey of creating peer discussion groups, we became increasingly aware of the developmental trajectory of new teachers, in which our graduates move away from dependence on faculty and towards support from, and collaboration with, professional colleagues (Stern et al., 2007) With this understanding, we shifted from a course-like, faculty-directed approach to a model that explicitly left lots of room for participant input. Faculty facilitators spent considerable time talking about this with one another, and made conscious efforts to make appropriate shifts in their own practice. Still, the faculty facilitators ultimately felt responsible for the success of the meetings. In the final interviews each faculty facilitator described ways in which she/he had “managed” the groups, trying to balance “leadership” with giving participants a sense of ownership of the groups. Jonathan captured this struggle when he described bringing in six videos and letting the participants describe which one to watch. With a chuckle, he said to me “I was following your instructions.” Ironically, somehow I had become the “expert” in how to facilitate a peer discussion group. It seems like it is really difficult for all of us to let go of the notion 3 Child Life prepares professionals to work as Child Life Specialists in hospital and community health-care environments.
100
B. Stern
that someone knows better, and we need to depend on that “expert” for knowledge and guidance. Even when we consciously reject the teacher-directed model of learning, it seems to shape our expectations of what is or is not possible. I believe that our experience with the peer discussion groups brought us closer to understanding how very difficult it is to promote true autonomy for teachers and teacher learning. Even when we hold a strong belief in self-directed learning and co-construction of knowledge, we live in a world where professional development for teachers is still largely expert-directed, with little or no input from the teacher participants. Math and literacy coaches frequently tell teachers what to do, rather than co-constructing instructional approaches. Unwittingly, we may have perpetuated this dependence on experts in offering peer discussion groups that were facilitated by faculty. What would it look like for teachers to participate in totally autonomous peer discussion groups (or other types of learning communities)? In the literature, there are many examples of facilitated study groups, but far fewer of groups run by teachers themselves (e.g., see Burbank & Kauchak, 2003). At Bank Street, we are considering a model in which more experienced teachers would take on leadership roles in organizing and facilitating peer discussion groups. We could draw upon the many “experienced alumni” who expressed interest in supporting recent graduates during the lifetime of the TNE induction program. A mixed peer discussion group of new and experienced teachers could offer valuable learning opportunities for all. There is also great potential for self-organized teacher groups within schools or geographic communities (Torres-Guzmán et al., 2006). At least one of the participants in our groups was inspired to create this kind of opportunity in her work setting. At the end of the “Weaving Bank Street Principles” group, Sharon Kramer wrote excitedly, “Yesterday I met with a group of Bronx math teachers from two schools to begin our collaborative journey.” This journey in peer discussion groups has underscored the importance of providing and promoting examples of learning communities not only after graduation, but also during the graduate school experience. For instance, collaborative learning experiences are built into Bank Street courses, and Supervised Fieldwork is shaped by the interests and needs of advisees. It would be helpful for faculty to explicitly identify these experiences as “learning communities” that can be replicated in future work settings. We have also infused some of our learnings from this journey into other aspects of the graduate school experience. For instance, as we look at ways of revamping our final integrative project, we are building peer support into a model that previously relied heavily on faculty support. We see this as a concrete way to move gradually from dependence on “experts” to professional autonomy and mutual support with colleagues. It is striking that faculty started this journey eager to provide learning opportunities for graduates, and ended the journey eager to reflect upon their own learning experiences. No matter where we are in our work as educators, we seem to be hungry for learning and community. When faculty met recently to talk about what they most want from faculty meetings, there was a powerful cry for “connections to our community.” The content of the conversations, it seems, is sometimes less important than the opportunities to simply be with one another in a shared learning experience. Perhaps the peer discussion group model will be adapted for faculty purposes.
7 New Teachers and Their Graduate School Faculty
101
Finally, we recognize the power of sharing the experience of participating in a learning community. Perhaps sometimes we sound like zealous converts to a new cause, but those of us who were part of the peer discussion group’s journey like to tell our stories often – to colleagues both within and beyond Bank Street – because we believe so strongly that the nurturance found within our peer discussion groups is exactly what educators need to stay vibrant and passionate about the work that we do. The peer discussion groups planted a seed that continues to grow and flourish at Bank Street and in the schools and other educational settings where participants work. We provided a model and an experience for faculty and new educators. In the spirit of learning communities, each faculty member and new educator will take the model and experience and incorporate them into their individual practices as well as their collaborative work with others.
References Beck, C. & Kosnik, C. (2006). Innovations in teacher education: A social constructivist approach. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press. Burbank, M. & Kauchak, D. (2003). An alternative model for professional development: Investigations into effective collaboration. Teaching and Teacher Education, 19(5), 499–514. Carnegie Corporation of New York. (2002). Grant prospectus, teachers for a new era. New York: Carnegie Corporation of New York. Darling-Hammond, L. & McDonald, M. (2000). Where there is learning there is hope: The preparation of teachers at Bank Street College of Education. In L. Darling- Hammond (Ed.), Studies of excellence in teacher education: Preparation at the graduate level. (pp. 1–95). Washington, DC: American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education. Hirsch, G. (1991). The social construction of teachers’ practical knowledge in the advisement conference group: Report of a case study. Thought and Practice: The Journal of the Graduate School of Bank Street College of Education, 3(1), 94–134. Kosnik, C. & Beck, C. (2007). From preservice to induction: A response to “Endings and beginnings: Experiences in building a new teacher induction and support model through a higher education program of teacher preparation.” In J. Kitchen (Ed.), Teacher induction, mentoring, and renewal: Proceedings of the academic symposium. (pp. 31–34). Toronto: Centre for Teacher Development, Ontario Institute for Studies Education, University of Toronto. Richardson, V. (2007). Teacher renewal: What is it? How is it engendered? In J. Kitchen (Ed.), Teacher induction, mentoring, and renewal: Proceedings of the academic symposium. (pp. 77–90). Toronto: Centre for Teacher Development, Ontario Institute for Studies in Education, University of Toronto. Samaras, A.P. & Gismondi, S. (1998). Scaffolds in the field: Vygotskian interpretation in a teacher education program. Teaching and Teacher Education, 14(7), 715–733. Stern, B., Lit, I., & Snyder, J. (2006). Bank Street College of Education Teachers for a New Era induction model. Paper presented at the 2006 Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco, CA. Stern, B., Lit, I., & Snyder, J. (2007). Endings and beginnings: Experiences in building a new teacher induction and support model through a higher education program of teacher preparation. In J. Kitchen (Ed.), Teacher induction, mentoring, renewal: Proceedings of the academic symposium. (pp. 7–21) Toronto: Centre for Teacher Development, Ontario Institute for Studies in Education, University of Toronto. Torres-Guzmán, M., Hunt, V., Torres, I.M., Madrigal, R., Flecha, I., Lukas, S., & Jaar, A. (2006). Teacher study groups: In search of teaching freedom. The New Educator, 2(3), 207–226.
Chapter 8
Establishing a Learning Community as a Site to Explore Our Multicultural Selves Anne R. Freese and Amber P. Strong
The self-reflexive journey inward can allow one’s multiple, contradictory identifications and locations-in terms of race, gender, sexuality and culture-to emerge, to “come out”. (Asher, 2007, p. 71)
Description of Our Learning Community Context The above quote has particular significance for our students in Hawai’i because of the blending of the many different ethnicities, cultures, languages, social classes, and religions. Given this diversity, teaching multicultural education in Hawai’i provides a unique opportunity to draw upon the rich multiplicity of cultures, ethnicities, religions, and languages. However, along with that opportunity there are unique challenges. Some students question why they have to take a multicultural education course in Hawai’i because they believe that people in Hawai’i are “color blind” (Okamura, 1998). They assume that racism happens somewhere else, not here. Despite the seemingly harmonious nature of our diverse society, underneath it all there are particular groups who have historically been, and continue to be, marginalized. We found that one of our challenges teaching multicultural education was to find ways to move beyond our notions of “color blindness” and to open up a critical dialogue about race, prejudice, identity, and other socially divisive issues in an effort to prepare our pre-service teachers to be effective multicultural educators. Related to this challenge was the need to examine our assumptions and find ways not to gloss over the sensitive issues, but rather to take risks and critically inquire into our assumptions, biases, and prejudices. In this chapter we present a pedagogical approach that describes the instructional practices that we incorporated in a required multicultural education course for education A.R. Freese and A.P. Strong University of Hawai’i
A.P. Samaras et al. (eds.) Learning Communities In Practice, © Springer Science + Business Media B.V. 2008
103
104
A.R. Freese, A.P. Strong
majors. Anne had taught this course three previous semesters and Amber, a graduate student and high school teacher, collaborated in the teaching and systematic study of the impact of the course on the students’ views of multicultural education. We examine how the learning community created conditions that encouraged students and faculty to wrestle with, and unpack, tensions related to openly discussing issues such as racism, discrimination, and stereotyping, and to arrive at new understandings. We discuss the theories that provide the framework for our pedagogical approach, and describe the learning community as a site for incorporating multicultural activities and practices in the classroom. In addition, we explore the ways in which the learning community allowed students to reframe and expand their thinking about multiculturalism.
Rationale Defining a Learning Community as a Site for Exploring Multicultural Education The term “learning community” can be defined in many ways and has been widely used as an approach for facilitating teaching and learning in classrooms. Learning communities are sometimes simply defined by structures or classroom configurations such as “group work,” “cooperative learning,” or “whole class discussions.” And although these classroom arrangements are practices with good intentions, they do not always foster the type of caring community of inquiry that we believe is necessary for meaningful and honest multicultural discussions. Therefore we would like to elaborate on our use of the term “learning community” by drawing upon the work of various philosophers and educational researchers. As multicultural educators, our goal was to encourage pre-service teachers to develop personal insights, multiple perspectives and empathy for those who are different from themselves. To do this we drew upon Lipman’s (1993, p. 15) description of “converting the classroom into a community of inquiry in which students listen to one another with respect, build upon one another’s ideas, challenge one another to supply reasons for otherwise unsupported opinions, assist each other in drawing inferences from what has been said, and to seek to identify one another’s assumptions.” We believe that learning is socially constructed (Vygotsky, 1981; Rogoff 1990, 2003) and that dialogue between members of communities is essential for creating the climate and dispositions that are necessary for establishing a community of inquiry. By opening up communication among our students within a multicultural learning community, we strove to free ourselves from being “ethnically encapsulated” and to “help individuals gain a greater self-understanding by viewing themselves from the perspectives of other cultures” (Banks, 2002, p. 1). Believing that effective learning communities must be authentic and cultivate rich relationships between both teachers and students, we drew upon Noddings’
8 Establishing a Learning Community as a Site to Explore
105
(2003) work regarding students’ “longing for community.” We focused on cultivating a classroom environment in which students felt connected and were given opportunities to make meaningful relationships with the instructors as well as with their peers.
Planning the Course So how could we create the conditions in the classroom for a “self-reflexive journey” that allows our “multiple, contradictory identifications to emerge and to come out”? (Asher, 2007, p. 71). We wanted our learning community to include a community of inquiry in which students felt connected and intellectually safe to actively participate in written and spoken dialogue. We wanted to create a space where they could explore their assumptions and understandings about their multicultural identities and multicultural education. We established the classroom as a site for discussion, inquiry, reflection, and evaluation where we could practice bridging the gap between our beliefs and biases, as well as our words and actions. All of our class assignments and activities were driven by the goal of having both the students and instructors reflect inward and discuss outward as participants in an intellectually safe community of their peers. We created conditions in the course that allowed the students to wrestle with, and unpack, tensions and stereotypes, and socially construct new understandings about multicultural education. With a sense of our shared commitment and shared philosophy, we co-planned, co-reflected, and co-taught the course geared towards helping pre-service teachers meet the needs of their future students. Considering the diverse demographics of our classroom, our goal was to raise our students’ awareness of the complexities of multiculturalism in Hawai’i and the issues that they might face as teachers. We did this by incorporating a number of structures and pedagogical approaches that support and encourage community. Students were required to read the writings of scholars (Banks, 2002; Gay, 2003) and other authors who reflected a variety of different multicultural perspectives. In addition, students wrote reflective papers, personal histories, and discussed case studies about controversial issues. Following is a description of the research and learning theories that guided our teaching. Dewey (1916) argued against seeing teaching as the transmission of readymade ideas, saying that “no thought, no idea, can possibly be conveyed as an idea from one person to another. … Only by wrestling with the conditions of the problem at first hand, seeking and finding [his or her] own way out, does [a person] think” (p. 188). Drawing on Dewey’s work, our goal was to problematize multicultural education and create an “intellectually safe” (Jackson, 2001) environment in which the students could openly discuss their assumptions and biases about race, class, culture, religion, as well as gender, sexuality and disability issues. We included aspects of self-study, described by Beck et al. (2004) as a “personal, constructivist, and collaborative approach,” to the study of multicultural education. This was in contrast to a technical transmission approach. We wanted to create a
106
A.R. Freese, A.P. Strong
learning environment that cultivated and supported the critical thinking that Dewey (1916) described. In the learning community our emphasis on a personal approach focused on our students’ prior experiences and personal histories. We emphasized a constructivist approach that included elements of inquiry, challenging prejudice and convention, as well as the personal construction of knowledge. While the term self-study suggests an individualistic approach, it emphasizes that the views of individuals must be constantly brought into dialogue with the views of others (Samaras & Freese, 2006). Knowledge construction became an interactive process that enabled the students to give expression to their unique experiences, insights, and interests (Fosnot, 1989, 1996; Richardson, 1997). The learning community and self-study concepts discussed above guided our course goals, assignments, and instructional activities. We believed that in order to operationalize a personal, constructivist, collaborative approach, we needed to create a learning community that fostered opportunities for social experiences and multiple perspectives. As we implemented various learning activities and assignments, we kept in mind Cochran-Smith and Zeichner’s (2005) caveat that the process of preparing culturally responsive teachers can create a sense of “stress and unrest” in both the students and instructor because it is “not simply a matter of grasping or understanding ideas – full blown and clear – that already existed” (p. 553). Rather it is a journey that involves “constructing uncertain knowledge about race and teaching” that may lead to “feeling doubtful, confused, angry and surprised by new realizations” (p. 553). Therefore, many of the course assignments caused students to “problematize their selves in their practice situations” with the objective being that the students would “reframe” their beliefs and/or practices (Feldman, 2002, p. 971). We realized that to be able to wrestle with sensitive issues in multicultural education, students would need to take risks, and be open and willing to share different perspectives. In order to accomplish this, it was essential that the learning community be a safe and trusting environment.
Studying Our Community of Inquiry Applying Theory to Practice We included a number of essential elements for approaching diversity and building community. In order to foster participation, we introduced learning community structures and designed activities for addressing sensitive issues and sharing personal stories. During the course of the semester, we regularly made the theories behind our pedagogical practices explicit so that the students would make the connections between theory and practice. We wanted the students to be fully aware of the pedagogical practices that foster a learning community in which all students’
8 Establishing a Learning Community as a Site to Explore
107
voices are honored and we included pedagogical strategies that supported the multiple voices and perspectives of all students. Community building and intellectual safety were introduced the first day of class. As students and faculty introduced themselves they engaged in making a “community ball” together as a class (Jackson, 2001). The use of the community ball was an important strategy for facilitating conversations and honoring multiple perspectives. The ball helped to focus the discussions, encourage participation, and manage conversations so that no one individual or individuals dominated the discussions. The ball functioned like a “talking stick” in that only the person with the ball could speak. Students had the choice of speaking or remaining silent (pass) when they received the ball. As the semester progressed the ball increased the participation of all members of the class. Following is one student’s reaction to the creation of the community ball. The first activity that we did in this class was unusual but it set the tone for the class throughout the semester. The twisting and turning of yarn to create a ball was child like, but if it weren’t for that activity our class wouldn’t be like what it was. The environment in our class is something that you wouldn’t expect in a college classroom. Everyone got along and respected each other’s opinions. I also made friends I will always remember. With the ethnic diversities and backgrounds, our class was an example of multicultural education.
Developing relationships and getting to know one another was a critical part of establishing trust and a feeling of safety. We did this in several ways. In the early weeks of the semester, a critical component of the class involved students engaging in dialogue with each other by sharing information about themselves initially through their personal artifacts, and later through their multicultural collages. The personal artifacts involved each student bringing five or six items or pictures related to their background, interests, talents or anything that provided information about who they were and what they valued. Through sharing our personal artifacts and creating multicultural collages, we identified aspects of ourselves that related to our multicultural identities using the characteristics identified by Banks (2002) of race, class, ethnicity, language, religion, exceptionality, gender, and sexuality. One student described her reactions to the activities in her “lessons learned” paper. We got to know one another beyond the superficial and found connections and similarities that drew us together with others in the class. The personal interactions and relationship building done in the first several weeks of class opened the way for developing a learning community.
Another way we established bonds between the students and the instructors was through a file folder system. The first day of class each student received a file folder that was used as a tool for reflection and a means of communicating with the instructors. Each day at the end of class, the students wrote several sentences describing their thoughts, reactions, or questions about the day’s class. The file folders were a safe place to share comments and not risk public embarrassment. The comments were also crucial to us, the instructors, as a way of gauging the climate of the class and as a guide as to what issues needed to be revisited or explored further. Prior to each class session, we each read their reflections and wrote
108
A.R. Freese, A.P. Strong
responses on each file folder. The back and forth dialogue in the file folders helped to build connections between the students and ourselves. Drawing upon the application of Vygotsky’s ideas that learning is socially constructed (Samaras & Gismondi, 1998), we created opportunities for students to talk, share information, negotiate meaning and socially construct their understanding about multiculturalism through dialogue. A critical component of the class involved students engaging in dialogue with each other by sharing and discussing insight papers on the readings in small groups (four students) during each class. The insight papers required students to analyze and explain material in the small groups, share their reactions and different points of view, and obtain feedback from one another. The small groups provided a safe space for each person to speak and give feedback. In addition to the small group interactions, the class came together as a large learning community to engage in discussions on controversial and sensitive topics. The group activities were designed to foster multiple perspectives, to raise our awareness of differences between our beliefs and actions, and to provide opportunities to reflect on, and reframe, one’s beliefs through interactions with others. We included a variety of readings, videos, and current events to raise multicultural education issues and problems. In order to provide relevance, we encouraged the students to use their own multicultural experiences as topics to make connections during those class discussions. They were also encouraged to draw on their thoughts that they had expressed during written assignments, other discussions, and their interpretations of the readings. Drawing upon the work of Clandinin & Connelly (2000), we used students’ personal histories as a way to “help readers question their own stories, raise their own questions about practice and see in the narrative accounts stories of their own … with the intent to foster reflection, storying and restorying” (p. 20). Using the multicultural characteristics of gender, race, language, ethnicity, sexuality, class, and ability/disability, the personal histories were a way for students to inquire into their assumptions, biases, and beliefs (Samaras & Freese, 2006; Zeichner & Noffke, 2001). The personal histories became an opportunity for the students to explore and better understand their prior multicultural experiences. The learning community provided a structure/foundation for students to share their personal histories about who they are as multicultural individuals and what experiences have shaped the way they think and act. The individual stories led to the creation of a class anthology, a sort of multicultural text that included each of the students’ personal histories. The students read the class anthology and conducted a content analysis of all the personal histories. The systematic analysis of the anthology allowed them to examine the multicultural characteristics of their peers and experience many different perspectives through each person’s unique and authentic multicultural history. This activity contributed to the collaborative nature of the course because the students were working together sharing their personal histories and analyzing the authentic, “real life” data that led to new ways of thinking about multicultural education. The analysis of the personal histories raised many questions such as how much of one’s identity is shaped by outside factors such as race, ethnicity, culture, family, environment, and religion. We questioned: “How much of our identity is a choice?” “What does it mean to be a
8 Establishing a Learning Community as a Site to Explore
109
minority in Hawai’i?” “Do we all struggle to define who we are?” “Who is marginalized in Hawai’i?” “Are there other factors besides race and ethnicity that marginalize individuals?” By systematically examining the diversity in our classroom, the students saw “through new eyes” the kinds of diversity and multicultural experiences and dimensions their future students will bring to their classrooms in Hawai’i. By layering these essential course elements we were able to provide multiple opportunities for our students to make connections, personally reflect and build our community of learners. This interplay between written and verbal dialogue allowed students to listen and learn from one another. It was only through these combined activities that we were able to construct a meaningful community of learners in this multicultural setting. (See Appendix for a description of the course activities.)
Impact of the Pedagogical Approach Methods In order to examine the impact of the learning community on our students’ views about multicultural education we focused on several questions: ●
●
●
How did the learning community and pedagogical approaches impact their participation and willingness to take risks and discuss sensitive issues? Was there evidence of transformation and changes in their thinking about multicultural education? To what extent were the students able to apply theory to practice in their classrooms?
Participants The participants consisted of 24 students ranging in age from 20 to 56 years. There were 17 females in the class and seven males. Their religious affiliations included: Christian, Buddhist, and Jewish. Five of the students spoke English as a second language. The students came from a variety of ethnic backgrounds including Asian (Filipino, Chinese, Japanese, Korean, or mixed Asian ethnicity), Hawaiian, part-Hawaiian, Caucasian, and “hapa” (mixed ethnicity). It is difficult to estimate what percentage of each ethnicity was represented in the class because many of the students were of mixed ethnicity, and did not identify strongly with just one ethnic group. The composition of the class is representative of the rich diversity that occurs in Hawai’i classrooms. This sample of students closely matches the demographic make up of the state of Hawai’i, which is very diverse in terms of socioeconomic status, ethnicity, religion, disabilities, and language.
110
A.R. Freese, A.P. Strong
Data Sources and Data Analysis Data came from students’ (1) personal history papers; (2) file folder comments; and (3) “lessons learned” papers. Using the method of constant comparison (Glaser & Strauss, 1967), we analyzed the students’ work by reading and rereading the personal history papers, the “lessons learned” papers, and the file folder comments. The student’s folder comments were directly linked to his or her personal history paper and the “lessons learned” paper. The intent was to compare and contrast the students’ formative comments with the summative knowledge. We coded the data from the data sources, identified themes, and made comparisons across the various da