Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Leading Smart Transformation
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd i
1/16/2011 5:24:00 PM
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The opinions offered in this book are the personal views of the individuals indentified and the authors, but not of any government of organization.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd ii
1/16/2011 5:24:00 PM
Leading Smart Transformation Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
A Roadmap for World Class Government
Andrew Kakabadse Professor of International Management Development, Doughty Centre, Cranfield School of Management, Cranfield University, UK
Mohamed Omar Abdulla Undersecretary, Department of Economic Development, Abu Dhabi, UAE
Rabih Abouchakra Managing Director, Office of Strategic Affairs, Abu Dhabi Crown Prince Court
and Ali Qassim Jawad Strategic Advisor, Government Visiting Scholar, Yale University, USA
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd iii
1/16/2011 5:24:00 PM
© Andrew Kakabadse, Mohamed Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra & Ali Qassim Jawad 2011 Foreword © Lord Andrew Adonis 2011 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No portion of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, Saffron House, 6-10 Kirby Street, London EC1N 8TS. Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Any person who does any unauthorized act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The authors have asserted their rights to be identified as the authors of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. First published 2011 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN Palgrave Macmillan in the UK is an imprint of Macmillan Publishers Limited, registered in England, company number 785998, of Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS. Palgrave Macmillan in the US is a division of St Martin’s Press LLC, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010. Palgrave Macmillan is the global academic imprint of the above companies and has companies and representatives throughout the world. Palgrave® and Macmillan® are registered trademarks in the United States, the United Kingdom, Europe and other countries. ISBN: 978–0–230–24372–9 This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. Logging, pulping and manufacturing processes are expected to conform to the environmental regulations of the country of origin. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 Printed and bound in Great Britain by CPI Antony Rowe, Chippenham and Eastbourne
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd iv
1/16/2011 5:24:00 PM
Andrew Kakabadse To those who guided me throughout the journey of my life. I dedicate this book with love, appreciation and recognition. Mohamed Omar Abdulla To my wife Nayla and children, Kinda, Nabil, and Ramzi for their inspiration and unconditional support Rabih Abouchakra To my family for their love and support Ali Qassim Jawad
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
To my wife Nada who tirelessly worked in the background to bring this project to reality and to Sophia and Reeves who are already leaders in their own right.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd v
1/16/2011 5:24:00 PM
Government: [noun] 1. The governing body of a state; 2. The system by which a state or community is governed; 3. The action or manner of governing a state, organization or people.1
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The important thing for government is not to do things which individuals are doing already, and to do them a little better or a little worse; but to do those things which at present are not done at all. John Maynard Keynes2
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd vi
1/16/2011 5:24:00 PM
CONTENTS
viii
About the authors Introduction Part I
3 21 42
The Transformational Cycle
4 Setting the strategy 5 Designing the operating model 6 Developing talent 7 Making it happen Part III
xii
The Context for Change
1 Leading through vision 2 Managing stakeholders 3 Driving the transformation Part II
x
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Foreword
63 91 110 132
The X-Factor
8 Distilling the X-factor 9 Navigating the roadmap
171 199
Notes
214
Further reading
220
Acknowledgments
221
Index
223
vii 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd vii
1/16/2011 5:24:00 PM
Can government change? The answer must be “yes” but not in the mold of previous reform efforts. Incremental, partial, shortterm, unconnected initiatives never add up to the coherent, fundamental reform now required of governments across the world. So where is the script on what to do and how to do it? Unfortunately, there isn’t one and my ministerial tenure taught me that no one problem is like the next; they all have unique characteristics that require an agile approach to finding ways forward. Governments are incredibly interconnected organizational structures. Policies and initiatives do not exist in isolation; many tentacles reach across organizational boundaries and country borders. The complexity in delivering change is immense. Add to this the reality that most political leaders have little experience of delivering change of this size and scope, and the task of transforming government can seem overwhelming. Leading Smart Transformation: A Roadmap for World Class Government, is an excellent guide to the challenge of creating a highly adaptive and efficient government. The central concept of “Smart Transformation” does not support “Big” government but more efficient government, where the state and corporations take responsibility for finding a balanced “commercial model that is sustainable over time and produces outcomes that are in the best interest of the country’s citizens.”
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
FOREWORD
Leading Smart Transformation reinforces tenets widely regarded as critical to managing change successfully; having a meaningful vision, setting strategy, managing stakeholders, and developing talent. What sets it apart is the authors’ emphasis on the “X-factor leadership.” Through their global case studies they have observed a “superset” of unique leadership characteristics, sensitive to the particular context and point in time. This reflects my own personal experiences, where analytical and viii 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd viii
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
Foreword
ix
intellectual skills can design the change route but the difference between success and failure is the distinct emotional and interpersonal skills that leaders intuitively demonstrate in bringing about change.
LORD ANDREW ADONIS Institute for Government London, UK
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
A roadmap for world class government is well overdue and this book is a valuable contribution to this ambition.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd ix
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
Andrew Kakabadse (
[email protected]) is Professor of International Management Development, Doughty Centre, Cranfield University’s School of Management, UK. Recognized as a world authority on leadership and governance, Andrew has held and also holds visiting appointments at the Copenhagen Business School, Denmark, Universite Pantheon Assas, Paris, France, Centre for Creative Leadership and Thunderbird, the Garvin School of International Management, United States, University of Ulster, The Windsor Leadership Trust, UK, Institute of Management Economics and Strategic Research, Kazakhstan, and Macquarie Graduate School of Management, Australia. He has consulted and lectured in every region of the world. His bestselling books include The Politics of Management, Working in Organizations, The Wealth Creators, Leading the Board and Rice Wine with the Minister. Mohamed Omar Abdulla joined the Department of Economic Development (DED) as Undersecretary in March 2007. Before joining DED, he assumed the position of Director General of the Abu Dhabi Chamber of Commerce and Industry from May 1997 to March 2007. His areas of specialization and expertise include law, banking, and economic development. In addition to his role at DED, Mr. Abdulla holds board positions in the following organizations: National Bank of Abu Dhabi, Abu Dhabi Media Company, Abu Dhabi Ports Company, Sheikh Khalifa Fund; National Drilling Company, and the Abu Dhabi Retirement Pensions & Benefits Fund.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Rabih Abouchakra (
[email protected]) is the Managing Director of the Office of Strategic Affairs, at the Abu Dhabi Crown Prince Court. Previously, he was a Vice President and Partner of Booz & Company heading the “Organization and Strategy” practice in the Middle East and focusing on public administration modernization, policy formulation, and largescale transformation. Prior to that Mr. Abouchakra worked x 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd x
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
About the authors
xi
Dr. Ali Qassim Jawad (
[email protected]) is a senior advisor to governments on strategy, organizational reform, and leadership. With a professional background that spans three regions—the United States, Europe, and the Middle East— Dr. Jawad has coached and mentored senior public sector officials on major capacity development and institutional change projects. Dr. Jawad is the Strategic Advisor to the Abu Dhabi Department of Economic Development. He has also been involved in a number of research projects, including developing an organizational effectiveness framework for the public sector with Oxford University, and exploring the role of leadership in enhancing employee motivation and productivity with Professor Victor Vroom of Yale University. Dr. Jawad is a Visiting Scholar at Yale University.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
for Bain & Company in Canada and the United Kingdom. Mr. Abouchakra holds an MBA from INSEAD in France, a Master of Telecommunication Engineering and a Bachelor of Electrical Engineering from McGill University, Canada. He was awarded the British Medal of Great Distinction. Mr. Abouchakra is an active member of several boards and has authored several publications addressing emerging public sector strategic challenges.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd xi
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
Today, transformation is on the agenda of governments throughout the world. Why? Simply and persuasively, it is increasingly clear that nations can no longer rest on their competitive laurels. In the 1990s corporations encountered what the American strategist Richard D’Aveni described as “hypercompetition.”3 Today, it is the turn of the world’s governments to encounter hypercompetition. The rapid growth and emergence of the new economic powerhouses of India, China, Brazil, and Russia demonstrate the shifting sands of competitive power. And while a national economy might once have relied on a gentle and gradual development of its place in the world, the new reality is likely to be far more brutal. The simple truth is that countries—and entire trading areas—can no longer take economic supremacy or even progression for granted. Nor can they assume that long-standing government practices—and inefficiencies—can be supported by a vibrant private sector. At the same time, there can be no doubt that governments will play an increasingly important role in creating, supporting, and nurturing the future competitive position of cities, regions, and nations. The size and scope of this role is the source of continuing debate. Recent events—especially governmental intervention to avoid an economic meltdown from the banking crisis—reinforce the point that governments have an important, sometimes vital, economic role. In an increasingly globalized and connected world, governments will have to move more quickly to safeguard the future stability and prosperity of their people.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
INTRODUCTION
In part, this will depend on adopting forward-looking policies and effective regulatory regimes to stimulate business while also ensuring that the excesses of recent years are not repeated. This is not a call for yet more government. We do not believe in big xii 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd xii
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
Introduction
xiii
To some extent, what is now happening with government mirrors what has already happened with the private sector in many countries. Amid the turbulence of recent times—technological, political, and economical—how corporations are run has been questioned and examined from every angle. As a result, many have transformed themselves from slow-moving behemoths to nimble global operators. Others have bitten the corporate dust. But a much bigger issue lies ahead. While corporations have proved adept at change, governments have largely continued to govern according to established rules. And while many in government exhort captains of industry to embrace innovation, they have not done so in their own sector. While business leaders are berated for their slow adoption of new ideas, most governments remain ponderous, conservative, and slow-moving beasts: carefully preserved dinosaurs. True, e-government has begun to bring greater efficiency to some parts of government, but compared to the business world in particular, progress is painfully slow. The banking crisis and global recession will continue to haunt regulators and policy-makers for many years to come. But it will no longer be sufficient for the drive for greater efficiencies to stop at the door of government. In future, competitive power will rest as never before upon the efficient and effective exercise of essential government activities. These include both services to citizens and to the business sector.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
government; we do believe in efficient government. (And we firmly disagree with Harry Truman’s quip that, “Wherever you have an efficient government you have a dictatorship.”)4
We are not talking about the privatization or hiving off of government services—although that will inevitably be an option in some cases. Nor are we talking about the need for more vigilant and effective policy-makers—although clearly this will help. Rather, we are talking about the urgent need to overhaul the machinery of government to make the public sector work more effectively and become a true enabler of economic and social progress.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd xiii
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
Introduction
xiv
The art of balance As recent experience has amply demonstrated, undirected, free market forces can lead to the sorts of excesses that nearly wrecked the global economy. Yet, capitalism and commerce have proved to be the most effective force for social progress. We believe that the coming debate will focus on how governments can curb the worst excesses of capitalism. The onus will be on government working in partnership with the wealth-creation sector, particularly the banks, to facilitate social investment in infrastructure projects. This will, hopefully, allow market forces to be an engine that is harnessed for the good of a government’s citizens. If governments fail to act in this way, the massive capital funds now waiting to be invested will go into exactly the same sorts of short-term financial instruments (albeit with different names perhaps) as before. If that happens, we will find ourselves back in crisis in a few years’ time. At the heart of this book—and smart transformation—is the idea that government as well as corporations must take responsibility for finding a balanced business model—one that meets the needs of shareholders as well as other stakeholders, such as employees, customers, and local communities. In short, governments must try to foster a commercial model that is sustainable over time and produces outcomes that are in the best interests of the country’s citizens.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The former Swedish Prime Minister, Ola Ullsten, put it this way when we talked to him: “One metaphor is the way our computers talk to us. They say do you want to save the changes. You may have only moved a comma from one place to another, but everything you do means a change in relation to what it was before. It is the same thing with politics. Whatever you do in politics it means change.”
To state that effective and efficient government is a prerequisite for economic prosperity is a truism—at least that is how it appears to us. But, truths need constant re-stating if their full potential is to be realized. Governmental effectiveness and economic prosperity are inextricably linked.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd xiv
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
Introduction
xv
We believe that the challenge facing governments everywhere is to put in place the systems and organization to provide services—everything from keeping the streets clean to providing licenses for foreign investors—and to do so in a way that resists the suffocating growth of bureaucracy. Exactly what those systems and organization look like will vary from place to place. However they are configured, we believe they will have to answer a number of fundamental questions: ●
●
●
How can governments be both high performing and highly responsive? How can you lead transformation in stakeholder organizations? How can you integrate stakeholder principles with shareholder disciplines to create effective and efficient governments?
To answer these questions it will be necessary to create highly adaptive and efficient government that is both fleet of foot but also resolute of vision; that requires leadership with the courage to take the necessary steps now to transform government and safeguard the interests of citizens in the long term. We call this smart government—government that not only can deliver on specific, measurable, achievable, realistic, and timely goals, but also combines efficiency with agility in order to deliver social and economic objectives. At a time of unparalleled change and uncertainty—from pandemics to financial crises—the need for smart government could not be starker.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
“The important thing for government is not to do things which individuals are doing already, and to do them a little better or a little worse; but to do those things which at present are not done at all,” the famous economist John Maynard Keynes observed.
Smart transformation If the challenge for leaders is to create smart government, creating it requires smart transformation in the ways by which we understand government and how it acts.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd xv
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
Introduction
xvi
This book provides a model for smart transformation—and explains how to overcome the leadership challenges required to make it a reality. It is based on a combination of global research into government and hands-on experience in governing. We also describe the unique journey that writing the book has taken us on—and the lessons we have learned. Transforming any major organization is never easy. And, we should say right at the outset, that transforming government is an even more sizeable and troubling challenge. “Even where big change is clearly needed, the history of reinventing government shows it is not easy,” observes the Economist with characteristic understatement.5 So how is smart transformation different to traditional change programs—or transformations? We believe the answer lies with leadership. Transforming government demands leadership. Smart transformation only occurs where the context for change is clearly articulated by leadership and the sequence of transformation has been understood, the conditions for its Smart Transformation vs. Traditional Transformation Characteristic
Smart Transformation
Traditional Transformation
Scope
Comprehensive Holistic Rapid Parallel Strategic, objectives with internal and external pressures Flexible and dynamic Leadership is critical and integral; Stakeholders are fully engaged: bottom up and top down interaction
Partial Ad hoc Regular Sequential External or short-term objective
Pace Change driver Target state Approach
Flow
Roadmap to link stages is well defined
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The challenge of achieving smart transformation is facing the governments of countries as diverse as Singapore, New Zealand, Qatar, and Saudi Arabia. At stake is the legacy for future generations. Until now, however, leaders in those countries have had no clear pattern or model to follow. Leading Smart Transformation is our attempt to answer that need.
Specific and static Leadership is important but peripheral; Stakeholders are driven in a top-down direction by leadership; Transformation program is ad hoc, as-you-go Phases not clearly linked
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd xvi
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
Introduction
xvii
success created, the strategy carefully prepared and executed efficiently.
Leading Smart Transformation describes a holistic, rapid, flexible, dynamic approach, where leadership is integral to the process; stakeholders are fully engaged; and last but not least, the transformation program is well planned with a clear roadmap linking the various components of the cycle.
Distinctive government Above all else, this is intended as a practical book to help government leaders of today tackle the challenges of tomorrow. It draws on a rich database of research—including best practice from more than a dozen countries—and is packed with real examples from the authors’ own experiences and those of leaders at the forefront of transforming governments throughout the world. As the importance of creating efficient, agile government becomes increasingly clear, we hope that Leading Smart Transformation may in some small way inspire the leaders of the world’s emerging nations, as well as those seeking to better understand the real dynamics of leading transformation. It is a roadmap for public sector transformation. There are a number of elements that we believe give the book a distinctive point of view:
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
In particular, the role of a competent leadership is central to a successful smart transformation—and is the primary building block of the smart transformation model.
Leadership required: First, it is more than just a book about redesigning government for the twenty-first century. Leading Smart Transformation examines the catalytic power of leadership in creating lasting change—and the monumental challenge of embedding leadership within institutions for generations to come. In many ways, it is a deliberate attempt to provide an antidote to powerful toxins that course through the blood of governments. These can best be observed by the failures they engender.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd xvii
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
Introduction
xviii
Global best practice: Second, although every situation is different, there are lessons that can be learned from the experience of other countries. Leading Smart Transformation distils lessons from the experiences of a host of countries including: Canada, Australia, Germany, Sweden, Switzerland, Singapore, France, the United Kingdom, the United States, the Netherlands, Belgium, Botswana, the United Arab Emirates (UAE), Bahrain, Ireland, and Monaco. X-factor leadership: Third, it advocates contextual sensitivity as the only viable strategy. In a world that some commentators claim is becoming ever flatter, we observe the opposite effect: globalization makes local context more rather than less important. Received wisdom suggests that there is a set of universal leadership capabilities required for successful transformation. We argue that this only gets you so far. The success of a smart transformation depends critically on a superset of unique leadership characteristics, which are relevant to the place and time. Together, these constitute the leadership X-factor. Being a successful leader of change in Singapore, for example, requires a different style to that which works even in a neighboring country. The discipline of change: Fourth, it is vital to complete the entire transformation cycle before embarking on the next phase according to a well-crafted roadmap. Transformation requires discipline and attention to detail as well as inspiration, passion, and belief.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
For example, many countries have tried to introduce change within the framework of existing government structures and have been derailed by bureaucracy and resistance. Leading Smart Transformation asserts the importance of redesigning government to achieve effective change. In one case, for example, 145 federal and local government entities were reduced to just 49.
Engaging stakeholders: Fifth, the traditional view is that a strong leadership mandate is sufficient to drive and sustain transformation. We argue that constant alignment of major stakeholders is required to prevent resistance that can otherwise ultimately derail the transformation effort. Here the concept of “soft power” is critical. Soft power is the ability to negotiate and gain through co-option and attraction. It is the opposite of hard power, that is, influence through cohesion, military intervention, and forcing payment 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd xviii
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
Introduction
xix
Created with a specific mandate to drive the transformation, the Smart Tools oversee the implementation of projects that deliver on the smart criteria—specific, measurable, achievable, realistic, and timely goals. It also monitors progress and provides necessary support, eventually making themselves redundant. Dynamic government: What unites these six strands is our firm conviction that governments can no longer adopt a business-asusual approach to their own organization. In a volatile world, they must transform themselves to keep pace with the relentless surge of change. Dynamism and government can no longer be mutually exclusive. Today, efficiency and agility must coexist. Smart examples: Throughout the book, too, we have included a number of case studies both at a national level and organizational (or departmental) level that involve a major governmental transformation. So, for example, we consider how countries as diverse as Ireland, New Zealand, and Singapore have used governmental leadership to transform (and damage) their economies—and societies. We also examine a number of government departments and agencies. Among them: how the US Internal Revenue Service—one of the largest organizations in the world—restructured itself for the twenty-first century; how the Reserve Bank of New Zealand transformed itself for its new role as an independent central bank; and how in the United Kingdom the Financial Services Authority was formed by integrating eight financial regulators into one.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Smart Tools: Sixth, an essential executing lever of smart transformation is the creation of Smart Tools. In effect, these provide a transformational SWAT (special weapons and tactics) team that acts as a catalyst to manage and maintain the momentum of transformation. The Smart Tools exist in parallel to the main government apparatus, and are free of the day-to-day sclerosis often characteristic of government.
How the book is organized The Smart Transformation model operates at two distinct levels. The first is at the policy-setting level of central government. It is at this level that the overarching national vision and strategy must be set. But that vision and strategy must then be cascaded 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd xix
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
down to the next level of government departments, agencies, and other entities. It is at the departmental level that the real day-to-day work of government is carried out—the provision of services to the general population. Without the active involvement of central government, no vision or strategic direction can be set; but without the active engagement of government departments, that central vision and strategy cannot become a reality. Throughout the book we have tried to describe how the model works at both these levels—and to distinguish between them. In effect, one can think of each and every department operating its own version of the model—all of which are aligned with and cascaded from the model at the center. The book is organized as follows. Part I explores how the context affects the transformational opportunity. Here the importance of creating a powerful vision of the future; managing the various stakeholders in the process; and translating leadership will and aspirations into executive action are examined. Chapter 1: Leading through vision. Without a meaningful vision for the future, no transformation is possible. It is the vision of the leadership that provides the mandate and momentum for change. This chapter describes the galvanizing power of a strong leadership vision and how, by aligning the aspirations of a nation or a department the will of individual leaders is embedded into institutional leadership. Chapter 2: Managing stakeholders. Transformation starts with a clear vision but that is not sufficient. Internal and external stakeholders have the power to resist or enable change. Successful transformation requires that leaders communicate strategic change with key stakeholders to ensure their buy-in. Sustaining their support requires ongoing, proactive engagement and dialog. Critical leadership capabilities here include: teamwork; the nurturing of networks; role modeling and other elements of soft power; the willingness to learn from best practice; negotiating transition; handling ambiguity; and personal resilience.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Introduction
xx
Chapter 3: Driving the transformation. With a leadership vision and the stakeholders aligned, the enablers are in place and transformation is possible. The next step is to develop a program
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd xx
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
Introduction
xxi
PMOs are essential at both central and departmental levels. At the level of central government, the PMO reports directly to the leadership. At the departmental level, the PMO provides guidance on entity management, priorities, and direction. It also monitors and regularly reports on progress, using objective performance measures, ensuring successful implementation. With the creation and activation of the PMO, the enablers are in place to pursue smart transformation.
The transformational cycle Part I is all about creating a context that is ripe for change. Part II is about the transformational cycle that will make the change a reality. This requires working through each of four transformational disciplines. It is vital that none are overlooked and that the proper linkage is preserved and the sequencing is well orchestrated. Chapter 4: Setting the strategy. The first discipline involves formulating a strategy that articulates the leadership vision by creating a plan to turn it into reality. This involves setting strategic objectives to drive the transformation. The leadership vision is translated into strategy by central government and is then cascaded to the relevant departments which each in turn create their own departmental strategies.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
of transformation that can be driven by the leadership. This requires the creation of a Smart Tool—the Project Management Office (PMO). The PMO is a catalyzing entity that executes the will of the leadership of the entity. Typically, it covers five key areas: project planning; project execution; content assurance; tracking and monitoring; and capacity building.
Part of the strategy is to build a self-sustainable business model aligned with the vision. The term business model has many interpretations. In this book, we use it to describe how shareholder value techniques can be leveraged for the purpose of promoting a stakeholder philosophy. In short, how business can be an economic engine that serves the long-term aspirations and best interests of a nation’s citizens. Indeed, the notion of building a sustainable and transformative business model is crucial to creating and delivering transformation. 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd xxi
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
In this context, “business” refers to the expertise and dynamism of the markets—which, in the right setting, may be used for government advantage, and to create benefits for all citizens. It is also worth making the point that in today’s world government has to be business-minded. Not only does a healthy economy require a healthy business sector, a government that is hostile to business—or incompetent—will drive global business away. The simple fact is that in a global economy, capital can migrate to different parts of the world in a matter of hours. That is why building a business model for government is now essential. We make no apology either for the fact that we draw on private sector experience as a key consideration. Indeed, how to best leverage market dynamics for the benefit of citizens will be a key challenge facing all governments in the coming years. This requires a pragmatic approach, with realistic expectations and a willingness to learn and leverage best practice from elsewhere. These are important leadership capabilities—but they also need to become core operational capabilities. Chapter 5: Designing the operating model. With the strategy and economic engine in place, the third part of the cycle is to improve organizational structure and governance to support the effective delivery of services. What is the operating model? How is the organization structured to ensure it is fit for purpose today and tomorrow? This includes redesigning the organization and reassigning roles to ensure the transformation achieves momentum. Chapter 6: Developing talent. Organizations are collections of people. To create and maintain momentum it is vital to build internal human capabilities. Transformation is built and delivered by the people in the organization. This chapter examines how to develop a strategic talent management plan to ensure the successful transformation and post-transformation.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Introduction
xxii
Chapter 7: Making it happen. Finally, it is necessary to roll out the transformation plan to execute on the strategic objectives within a well-defined time frame. Chapter 7 explains the reality of making change happen and the importance of validating by monitoring and measuring to ensure key performance indicators are met. It includes case studies at both the central (national) and departmental level.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd xxii
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
Introduction
xxiii
Parts I and II provide the mechanics of transformation. But there is more to achieving smart transformation than a simple model. One of our most striking findings is the importance that contextual leadership plays in the success or failure of organizational change. Initially, we identified a set of international (generic) leadership capabilities required for effective transformation. But these alone did not explain why what worked in one country or context sometimes did not work in another. We then discovered something truly fascinating—and new. Beyond the generic capabilities, we observed another level of leadership capabilities unique to that particular organization and environment. Chapter 8: Distilling the X-factor. It turns out that that every economic transformation project has its own secret recipe. We call it the leadership X-factor—a unique set of capabilities that determine whether a leader will be effective in that part of the world and in that particular context at that time. In Chapter 8, we describe how this extra level makes a difference to the success or failure of transformation efforts. Chapter 9: Navigating the roadmap. The final chapter has a twofold message. On the one hand, it denotes the final phase of the Smart Transformation Model—the opportunity to step back and learn from the current cycle of change and to apply those learnings to the next transformation cycle. It is also a chance to pull the threads of this book together to provide practical lessons and guiding principles for successful transformation. What are the leadership steps required to lead a smart transformation? Taken altogether, we believe the Smart Transformation Model offers a process for transforming government. As with all good models, the whole is greater than the sum of its parts. It is also a dynamic open-ended model. Viewed in this way, it is clear that the transformation cycle is just that—a virtuous circle of transformation. Once a cycle is complete, and each of the four transformational disciplines in Part II has been applied, it is time to go back to the start and begin again.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The X-factor
This includes revisiting the context for transformation—Part I—to ensure that stakeholders remain aligned with the vision and that
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd xxiii
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
Introduction
xxiv
The Smart Transformation Model allows government to translate the leadership vision into a workable and measurable strategic plan. Equally importantly, it ensures that the necessary human talent, organizational design, and execution focus is in place to make the vision a reality. Leading Smart Transformation is not the final word. Performance in government should always be in the process of being improved. But, we hope that it helps ignite a much needed debate about the purpose, shape, and leadership of governments in our global age. ANDREW KAKABADSE, MOHAMED OMAR ABDULLA, RABIH ABOUCHAKRA, AND ALI QASSIM JAWAD, Abu Dhabi, October 2010 VISION II
11 Strategy
22
TR N
Operating Model
RS DE
EH OL
IIII 33
AK
TIO
5
aEnR -SpTl MA
ST
Revise Revise New Cycle New Cycle Transformed Execution ExecutionTransformed Entity Entity 5
III
MA
OR SF
AN
Business Model
Talent
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
the leadership capabilities are in place to drive the next phase of the transformation. The vision itself and the leadership X-factors also require periodic reappraisal—although they should be fairly consistent. Once the context is refreshed, then the strategic goals can be reset—with key performance indicators recalibrated— and another cycle of transformation begun.
44
LA
-P N
The smart transformation model 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_01_prexxiv.indd xxiv
1/16/2011 5:24:01 PM
Part I
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The Context for Change
One never goes so far as when one doesn’t know where one is going. Johann Wolfgang von Goethe1 A vision goes beyond the numbers that are typically found in five-year plans ... It says something that helps clarify the direction in which an organization needs to move. John Kotter2 No man that does not see visions will ever realize any high hope or undertake any high enterprise. Woodrow Wilson3 I have a strong view. Like a good Minister, I think that if you have public service power, you want to use it for a purpose—and a purpose usually involves some sort of change. Dr. Peter Shergold, Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet, Sydney, Australia4
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 1
1/16/2011 5:24:04 PM
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 2
1/16/2011 5:24:04 PM
CHAPTER 1
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Leading through vision Yas Island, Abu Dhabi, November 1, 2009 The warm up lap had been completed and five red lights were illuminated. The distinctive starting sequence for a Formula 1 Grand Prix began. Four. Three. Two. One. A deafening roar as 24 state-of-the-art F1 racing cars screamed into action. The inaugural Abu Dhabi Grand Prix was underway. Years of anticipation and preparation had led to this moment. The world was watching—some 600 million pairs of eyeballs tuned in via their television sets. The authors were among those watching with bated breath. Let us clearly state that we can claim no credit for the success of the event. We were not involved in the project. But like everyone else we were fascinated by it. Quite apart from the adrenalin pumping, ear-splitting mechanical cacophony that is F1, the finale of the 2009 season was noteworthy for several reasons. It was the first grand prix hosted in the United Arab Emirates (Abu Dhabi is the capital of UAE) and the first ever day and night F1 race. It was also the first time a debut track hosted the final race of the season. In the hotels and streets of Abu Dhabi in the days leading up to the race, the buzz was audible—and infectious. The authors met several times in the week of the race to discuss the book. We visited the Emirates Palace Hotel, a seven-star showcase for Abu Dhabi’s tourism, which was temporarily transformed into an F1 museum—with racing cars through the ages on display on loan from F1 supremo, Bernie Ecclestone’s, own private collection. The F1 glitterati hosted events for days at the city’s swankiest hotels and night spots. Behind the scenes, the activity in the run up to the race was equally frenetic. When we visited the Yas Marina Circuit just 3 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 3
1/16/2011 5:24:04 PM
three days before the grand prix, the contractors were still adding the final touches. With 68 different contractors and 47,500 workers involved, the project required logistical organization of military precision. Even the sumptuous Yas Hotel was strewn with paint pots and ladders as every last detail was attended to. With security to think of and the sheer logistics of busing 50,000 spectators to the circuit, we wondered if everything would be ready in time. We needn’t have worried. The project leaders were not about to let anything spoil this particular coming out party. By the time the racing cars streamed into the distance, for the people of Abu Dhabi, the important race had already been won. The brand new Yas Island race circuit was built in just 30 months. A barren island was transformed into a world-class motor racing venue with more than 40 kilometers of roads and infrastructure ready to receive the F1 circus and 50,000 spectators.5 The people of Abu Dhabi were proud—and rightly so. Hosting the F1 race was a huge achievement. But beyond all the glitz and glamour; all the petrol fumes and the celebrity sideshow; something more significant was occurring. The Abu Dhabi Grand Prix announced the emirate’s arrival on the world stage. Make no mistake, the F1 party was not just a celebration of fast cars and painstaking project management, it was also a celebration of a nation’s aspiration—and a vindication of the vision of its leadership. Contemporary in its conception, large in scale, fast in execution, and global in its reach, Yas Island is a tangible example of what visionary leadership can achieve and how smart transformation can shape governmental, organizational, societal, and personal agendas and behavior.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Leading smart transformation
4
Begin with the future The starting point of change is the future. Any individual, organization, or government is only ready to change if it acknowledges that the current reality is not where it wants to be and then sets about creating a credible and persuasive future: a vision. “The best predictor of the success or failure of organizational change is something I call readiness for change,” says Michael
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 4
1/16/2011 5:24:04 PM
Leading through vision Jarrett of the international business school INSEAD and author of Changeability. “What do I mean by readiness for change? Readiness for change applies at the philosophical level—being open to and prepared to embrace change; but it also applies at the practical level. Readiness applies to those organizations that have developed a set of core dynamic and internal capabilities that allow them to adapt when faced by external demands. Basically, successful change is a function of how well an organization’s internal capabilities—its management capacity, its culture, its processes, its resources, its people—match the requirements of its external environment, the marketplace. When there is an internal capability and external match, you are more likely to gain successful change. My research consistently shows that readiness for change is the single most reliable predictor of successful change.”6 How can you express a readiness to change? There are many ways—dissatisfaction with the current status quo runs on a scale from silent discontent to fuming revolutionary—but the most powerful and compelling is to articulate a clear vision of the future. “Many of the great strategies are simply great visions. And great visions can be a lot more inspirational and effective than the most carefully constructed plan. Only when we recognize our fantasies can we begin to appreciate the wonders of reality,” argues Professor Henry Mintzberg of Canada’s McGill University.7 Visions have been around for centuries. In modern times, think of Martin Luther King Jr.’s “dream” of racial equality or President Kennedy’s ambition to put a man on the moon. In the business world, remember Henry Ford’s aspiration to produce cars for the masses or Microsoft’s hope of putting a computer on every desk and in every home. But, only in recent years have the dynamics of visions and their role in achieving transformation been examined.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
5
In the 1980s, the leadership researcher Warren Bennis embarked on a now famous study of 90 American leaders including former astronaut Neil Armstrong and a tightrope walker. Bennis sought to identify and codify effective leadership. He offered a view of leadership based on four factors: vision, meaning, trust, and the deployment of self. Vision comes first. Indeed Bennis
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 5
1/16/2011 5:24:04 PM
Leading smart transformation
6
defined leadership as “the capacity to create a compelling vision and translate it into action and sustain it.”8
The meaning of vision As a starting point for smart transformation, it is useful to explore the real meaning of what a vision is and how it should be constructed and used. In their influential book Built to Last, Jim Collins and Jerry Porras view the function of a leader as “to catalyze a clear and shared vision of the organization and to secure commitment to and vigorous pursuit of that vision.”10 Collins and Porras contend that vision has two main components: a guiding philosophy and a tangible image. The guiding philosophy is “a system of fundamental motivating assumptions, principles, values and tenets” that stems from the organization’s core beliefs, values, and purpose. Making up the tangible image involves a mission and a vivid description. The mission is “a clear and compelling goal that serves to unify an organization’s effort. An effective mission must stretch and challenge the organization, yet be achievable.” An alternative perspective comes from the American leadership researcher, Burt Nanus. He defines vision as “a realistic, credible, attractive future for an organization.” Nanus continues: “It is a carefully formulated statement of intentions that defines a destination or future state of affairs that an individual or group finds particularly desirable. The right vision is an idea so powerful that it jump-starts the future by calling forth the energies, talents, and resources to make things happen. A visionary leader is one who has the ability to formulate a compelling vision for the future of his or her organization, gain commitment to it, and translate that vision into reality by making the necessary organizational changes.”11
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Without a vision of what you would like to achieve, what you do achieve has no benchmark of success. Henry Kissinger claimed: “Leaders must invoke an alchemy of great vision. Those leaders who do not are ultimately judged failures, even though they may be popular at the moment.”9
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 6
1/16/2011 5:24:04 PM
Leading through vision
7
● ●
●
●
It attracts commitment and energizes people. It creates meaning in workers’ lives, by making them feel they are part of a greater whole. It establishes a standard of excellence and stimulates improvement. It bridges the present and the future by focusing the organization on its desired future state.
While Collins and Porras view mission as a component of vision, Nanus differentiates between the two. He comments: “A vision is not a mission. To state that an organization has a mission is to state its purpose, not its direction.” In his influential work on the learning organization, Peter Senge emphasizes that a shared vision is a vehicle for building shared meaning in an organization, particularly if it is built in a participative way.13 He sees a vision as representing the organization’s guiding aspirations. These are composed of: ● ● ● ●
Vision: an image of our desired future Values: how we expect to travel to where we want to go Purpose or mission: what the organization is here to do Goals: milestones we expect to reach before too long
So, what does a vision mean in the context of smart transformation in government? Borrowing from the definitions above, we believe that for transformational government, an effective vision—a smart vision, if you will—meets the following criteria: ●
●
●
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
According to Nanus, the right vision can lead to a number of benefits for an organization:12
It acts as a catalyst—offering an alternative future that disrupts the status quo and mobilizes commitment to change. It offers a tangible picture of a destination—a better place that will be achieved via the transformation. In this way it provides the bridge from the present into the future. It attracts commitment and energizes people—by creating meaning between workers’ lives and their work, by making them feel they are part of a greater whole.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 7
1/16/2011 5:24:04 PM
Leading smart transformation
8
●
It establishes a standard of excellence and stimulates improvement. It emerges from a considered process of thought, connection, and communication. Visioning is an inclusive process—witness the pages of interview at the end of Abu Dhabi’s vision.
It is these characteristics of the vision that make smart transformation possible. By its nature, then, a vision cannot emerge fully formed. It is by working out the fine details—both at the level of strategy and at the level of how each individual will relate to it— that people engage with the vision to bring it alive. In other words, how we follow the vision in one government department will be different to another—not least because they start from slightly different places. But both are moving toward a shared destination. In the context of smart transformation, visions operate at two levels: the national level (central government) and departmental level.
National visions Transforming performance is not something naturally associated with the mechanics of government. In most societies it is assumed that a change of ruling party is accompanied by changes to government behavior, processes, and performance. This is rarely the case. There is a premium on continuity in the mechanics of government rather than emphasizing the need for constant improvement. A political appetite for change cannot be assumed to be accompanied by a governmental appetite for change. Government tends to be focused on getting things done and, truth be told, on stopping other things from being done.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
●
Given this, it is no surprise that visions are usually notable by their absence in governmental processes of change. Instead of the big picture there tends to be a focus on local initiatives. Changes in government are regularly seen in isolation rather than as joined-up parts of a coherent vision for a government and a nation. Or worse, they are seen as policy diktats imposed from on high and usually resisted on the ground. As a result, most countries have been through a long list of such initiatives.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 8
1/16/2011 5:24:04 PM
Leading through vision
9
Initiatives only work if they are sewn into a broader transformational canvas. People are understandably questioning and cynical. In the face of a request to change their thinking or behavior they are likely to ask why? To this the leader—any leader—has to have an answer. The answer is the vision. For the moment at least, visions are more commonplace in the corporate world than at governmental or national levels. And yet any transformation, no matter what level, demands some sort of conceptualization of the desired destination. Visions are the vital starting point for any change in how an organization performs—whether it is a team, a division, a corporation, a government department, or an entire governmental apparatus.
Singapore 21: A vision for a new era As an example, think of how Singapore has used its vision to galvanize people and government departments to action. Thanks to its strategic location as a port, the tiny island of Singapore has developed into the world’s fourth most important financial center, playing a crucial role in international trade, and one of the richest states in East Asia. Singapore is the fourth-wealthiest country in the world in terms of GDP, and boasts the eleventhhighest quality of life. The country is a parliamentary republic, with a system of government originally derived from that of Britain, its former colonial ruler. Singapore’s material wealth and commercial acumen have never been in doubt. But in the late 1990s, its leaders felt that their country’s future should be about more than just prosperity. To thrive as a well-rounded nation, Singapore also needed “soft” strengths: social cohesion, shared values, political stability, and human capital—the kind of strengths, perhaps, that free markets would not deliver if left to their own devices.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Open up any newspaper anywhere in the world on any day of the political week and you will find a lengthy list of such governmental initiatives. Most disappear with little trace.
To give substance to their ideas, the Singapore government launched Singapore 21, tasked with creating a “vision for a new
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 9
1/16/2011 5:24:04 PM
Leading smart transformation
10
Singapore’s vision had its roots in five dilemmas that the country faced: ● ● ● ● ●
Less stressful life vs. retaining the drive Needs of senior citizens vs. aspirations of the young Attracting talent vs. looking after Singaporeans Internationalization/regionalization vs. Singapore as home Consultation and consensus vs. decisiveness and quick action
To find ways to resolve these dilemmas, the Singapore 21 Committee conducted consultations, forums, and online surveys, obtaining the views of over 6000 people. The content was distilled down to form five key ideas that lie at the heart of the Singapore 21 vision: ●
●
●
●
Every Singaporean matters. People are Singapore’s only resource, and they matter both collectively and individually. Every one has a contribution to make and a place in society. Our definition of success must include character, courage, commitment, creativity, and compassion as well as material wealth. Each Singaporean should set their own goals. Opportunities for all. As in the past, Singapore must be a place where people can find optimism, prospects, and fulfillment—a global center where people, ideas, and resources come together. Talented foreigners should be welcomed, and Singapore must develop the potential of every citizen. Strong families. Families are the foundation of society, but cannot be taken for granted. As families become smaller and work more demanding, children will need more help to grow and learn. Government and employers must play their part in reinforcing family bonds. The Singapore heartbeat. As globalization gathers pace, Singaporeans need a stronger sense of belonging to their
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
era” in 1997. Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong convened the Singapore 21 Committee, which comprised ten members of parliament chairing five subject committees. In total, Singapore 21 committees comprised 83 members drawn from a broad spectrum of society—business people, professionals, volunteers and many more.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 10
1/16/2011 5:24:05 PM
Leading through vision country and a common vision. Whatever their origins, citizens need to regard Singapore as their home. Active citizens. Singaporeans must be active participants in society—aware of what is happening and ready to express views and suggest solutions. The “people sector” should complement, and cooperate with, the public and private sectors. Consultation, mutual respect, and trust form the basis for this partnership.
These five themes were united in a single phrase: “Together, we make the difference.” In April 1999, the Singapore 21 vision was officially launched. “More than a house, Singapore must be a home,” commented Goh Chok Tong foreshadowing the vision in a speech to the Singapore Parliament. “In the end, it is people who give feeling, the human touch, the sense of pride and achievement, the warmth. So beyond developing physical infrastructure and hardware, we need to develop our social infrastructure and software ... We need to go beyond economic and material needs, and reorient society to meet the intellectual, emotional, spiritual, cultural and social needs of our people.”14 Taking a cue from the private sector, Goh Chok Tong alluded to what the Sony Corporation calls “heartware.” (Several decades before Western businesses began using concepts such as Lovemarks to create experiences that resonated with consumers’ emotions, Sony used the theme “Not hardware, but ‘heartware’ for everyday life” to unite the diverse strands of its business. Instead of just making products to be bought, Sony wanted to create experiences that would be loved. Singapore applied a similar principle to its vision.)
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
●
11
In the years that followed, a broad range of initiatives, activities, and events were carried out under the Singapore 21 banner, including exhibitions, community games, online forums, and many more. These took their cue from the themes identified in the Singapore 21 vision, focusing on community building, cultural development, family events, education, and celebrating Singaporean heritage.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 11
1/16/2011 5:24:05 PM
Leading smart transformation
12
Used in this way, visions are the banners around which committed people gather—sometimes in unlikely places. The vision can provide an overarching message or idea to guide a country’s economic, social, and political development. For example, after a difficult period after its independence in 1963, and following Singapore’s exit in 1965 and race riots in 1969, Malaysia embarked on its New Economic Policy—intended to increase proportionally the share of economic wealth of the Bumiputras—the indigenous people, which includes the majority of Malays. Malaysia is now on its tenth five-year economic plan: the first of these dates back to the National Economic Policy of 1970. Over the four decades, the ten economic plans have seen a movement—a shift in emphasis—from a focus on pure poverty reduction and promoting investment, toward more industrialization and building a knowledge economy in the past few years. Guiding this change in Malaysia’s economic plans is its 2020 Vision of an equal, competitive, and growing economy. So, the ninth economic plan—2006 to 2010—represents the first of three plans, which form the National Mission to achieve Vision 2020. In keeping with that Vision, the aims of the ninth economic plan are to: move the economy up the value chain; raise the capacity for knowledge and innovation; address persistent socioeconomic inequalities; improve the standard and sustainability of quality of life; and to strengthen the institutional and implementation capacity. All of these are important steps toward achieving the Vision. Or consider Botswana. A small, landlocked nation of nearly two million people in southern Africa, Botswana, Africa’s oldest democracy, was originally home to Bushmen, then Bantus. It became a British protectorate in 1886 and remained so until gaining independence in 1966. Its legacy from British rule includes English as an official language but, more importantly, a strong government that has acted wisely in almost every area over the years. In the latest Global Peace Index ranking, Botswana was the highest listed African nation.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Flagging the future
The government’s careful management of the economy has changed Botswana from one of the poorest countries in Africa,
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 12
1/16/2011 5:24:05 PM
Leading through vision
13
Today, the once-poor nation of Botswana has a Gross Domestic Product (GDP) of $27.1 million and a per capita GDP of $13,900, compared with $70 in 1966. Moreover, its GDP growth over the past decade has been in double digits (except recently, a reflection of the world economic crisis).15 Botswana’s economy has relied heavily on its major natural resource—diamonds—and the government invested its mineral revenues to improve social and economic conditions (e.g., building its infrastructure), avoiding the trap of corruption that has kept many nations impoverished while its rulers grew rich. In addition to diamonds, Botswana has copper and nickel mines and grazing land that supports a strong cattle-raising industry. There is also a tourism sector that provides approximately 16 percent of GDP. The major economic problem facing Botswana is that its diamond deposits will begin to run out over the next decade. Anticipating that event, however, the government developed its Vision 2016 plan, making diversification a strategic objective. Involving the creation of development hubs for such things as innovation, the plan has received praise and financial support from many international organizations and attracted private foreign support. Ericsson, one of the world’s biggest telecommunications equipment providers, was one of the first tenants of the Botswana Innovation Hub when it opened in December 2010.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
at its independence, to one of the more rapidly growing economies in the world. (As we write, two major investment services rank Botswana as the best credit risk in Africa.) Nobel Prizewinning economist Joseph E. Stiglitz says its economic strength is the result of “its ability to maintain a political consensus, based on a broader sense of national unity.”
Naturally blessed Or consider the vision of Abu Dhabi. Blessed with natural resources in the shape of abundant oil reserves, the challenge facing the emirate is to use its natural wealth to broaden and diversify its economic base and create a sustainable economy.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 13
1/16/2011 5:24:05 PM
Leading smart transformation
14
That vision is set out in a document entitled the Abu Dhabi Economic Vision 2030. Simply writing a nation’s vision down can be hugely powerful. It gives everyone involved in government and the citizens of the nation a clear idea of what the leadership is seeking to achieve. It also means the people can hold their government accountable. A written vision can also communicate beyond the country’s borders, sending a clear message to the rest of the world and especially trading partners and the global business community. One of the authors was recently on a fact-finding visit to Norway and, on meeting the head of a Norwegian government department, was impressed to discover on her desk next to the Norwegian flag a copy of the Abu Dhabi Economic Vision 2030 document. Clearly, the Norwegians had done their homework. National visions travel. They make a powerful statement about a country’s aspirations.
Departmental visions But visions do not just occur at the level of central government. Beneath the national vision are departmental visions. These are inspired by the vision of the central government, but define what the department’s role in that future will be. Think of the national vision as a Russian doll. Inside the big vision is another smaller vision. In this way the same picture is translated down to ever-smaller levels of granularity. Each doll is an image of the first, only smaller. They fit together to flesh out the national vision to make it a reality.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The Emirate’s Economic Vision for 2030 sees: “Abu Dhabi as a sustainable, diversified, high value-added economy that encourages enterprises and entrepreneurship and well integrated into the global economy leading to better opportunities for all.”
So, for example, Singapore’s Infocomm Development Authority is leading a national effort to formulate and develop iN2015 (pronounced “in twenty-fifteen”). Built on the theme of creating an Intelligent Nation, this is a ten-year master plan launched in 2006 to grow the information communications sector and to build a well-connected society. The year 2015 also marks the 50th anniversary of Singapore’s independence.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 14
1/16/2011 5:24:05 PM
Leading through vision
15
Powerful visions have been repeatedly used by Singapore to fuel its growth. The country first embarked on the National Computerization Plan to computerize the civil service in the 1980s. There have been various plans to grow an IT industry and build connectivity within Singapore. These include the National IT plan, which saw the development of TradeNet, LawNet, and MediNet; IT2000 when Singapore ONE (One Network for Everyone) was developed; and, Infocomm 21 and Connected Singapore, which focused on the further developing Information Communication Technology (ICT) in the private and public sector, and promoting ICT among the public. All of these initiatives are part of a connected effort—or vision—to create an Intelligent Nation, a thoroughly modern and technologically sophisticated and connected society.
Cascading visions As we have already seen, visions come in many shapes and sizes. They include grand designs for an entire nation but they can also be the level of an organization, department or even team. Indeed, a key element of any large-scale transformation is how the big vision is translated and cascaded down to the people on the ground. For a smart transformation, the leadership of each department or agency creates its own vision that supports the overall vision (see what happened at the Internal Revenue Service in the United States on page 160). So, as we saw with Singapore, the vision to become an Intelligent Nation is supported by a series of smaller visions that are steps toward that goal.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
“Singapore is in a competitive race with other countries. It is no longer a matter of moving first, but a matter of moving faster— ahead of others to stay relevant and competitive. It is all the more important that we take a look at the role that infocomm can play to help Singapore stay highly competitive to look ahead for the next ten years, and implement strategic initiatives that will keep Singapore to the fore,” says Lam Chuan Leong, chairman of the iN2015 steering committee.16
Enshrining the national vision in a widely available document also provides a point of reference for everyone in the government
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 15
1/16/2011 5:24:05 PM
and beyond. In Abu Dhabi, for example, it is now commonplace to hear people begin any proposal with the phrase “in line with the 2030 vision ...” In other words, people have come to explain every initiative and project with reference to the national vision. It follows, too, that if the connection cannot be made with the broad aims of the vision, then the project should not be undertaken. This gives all government departments a clear frame of reference for their initiatives. Clarity begets clarity. If the national vision is well articulated then departmental visions are likely to be as well. Among the most inspiring interviewees we encountered was Frank Ryan, CEO of Enterprise Ireland (for a case study of Ireland see page 138). He previously worked in the corporate world and with the country’s Industrial Development Agency (IDA Ireland) before leaving to lead Enterprise Ireland, the agency responsible for the development of industry and the internationalization of Irish business. “I came here with a very clear view that Enterprise Ireland would become the number one business development agency in the world. That Ireland would have, through Enterprise Ireland and IDA Ireland respectively, the No 1 indigenous and FDI development agencies in the world. So that was very clear in my mind. In order to move in that direction we would have to deliver transformational change in terms of the impact of our focused interventions on our client base and their performance.”17 The clarity of force of Ryan’s vision—“to be the number one business development agency”—shone through every word he said, his actions, and those of his colleagues. The need for vision all the way down through government was brought home in an interview with Lord Michael Bichard. Former director of the Institute for Government in the United Kingdom, Lord Bichard passionately advocates the need for a powerful trinity of clarity, values, and vision:
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Leading smart transformation
16
You need clarity about what the change is and you need people to own that vision, that change, because without that you can’t judge progress, you can’t set milestones. I have seen many change programmes where people are simply not clear where they are trying to get to, where they are, how
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 16
1/16/2011 5:24:05 PM
Leading through vision to measure the distance between the two points and how to track the milestones. I have always felt that as important as clarity around the vision is having clarity around the set of values—the things that drive this place, the way we do things around here. This has to be truly owned. These are not things that you can impose on people, so there has to be a considerable process of involvement and discussion. At the end there has got to be a clear, short, simple set of values. You have to be prepared to use the things that make the organization tick—the appraisal systems, the assessment systems, the promotion criteria, things like capability reviews. If those don’t reflect the way you want the organization to behave then the staff and outsiders will come to the view that you are not serious about that and clearly will give it less priority. In the early 1990s, Lord Bichard was put in charge of the UK’s Benefits Agency with 70,000 staff and a budget in the region of £2.5 billion. Here he was able to put his theories about how to achieve transformation to the test: The benefits agency was a very complex organization. It was important to have a clear vision of what we wanted to do—what we wanted to change. In the past, it had not truly focused on clients and customers and, therefore, we made customer service and our clients central to the vision. It was an organization that had to get things right; so accuracy and getting things right first time, and quality were also central. It was an organization, which traditionally received and dealt with people in the most disgusting surroundings and it was also an organization in which people had felt insufficient priority had been given to its staff. We provided staff with development opportunities. We were focused on clients and staff, on accuracy and quality. It was a team effort, but eventually I was able to walk into any benefit office in the country, and there were four or five hundred, and be confident that, if I started talking about the values, people would be able to quote them back at me. I would be able to see examples of how they had taken those values forward—things like caring for staff, quality,
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
17
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 17
1/16/2011 5:24:05 PM
Leading smart transformation
18
and competence. We enforced all of that by reviewing our appraisal process and making clear the kind of qualities and competencies we were looking for in the people we promoted. We deliberately pursued a process and it did have an impact.
As Michael Bichard makes persuasively clear, no transformation can occur without a clear vision from the top—be it the national leadership or the leadership of a single government department. In almost all cases, the initial vision comes from the overall leader—the president, prime minister, or monarch—or someone close to them. As we will emphasize throughout, in any smart transformation, leadership is vital. Once the vision is clear it may be amplified and articulated by the executive arm. In government terms this is typically the cabinet. To execute successfully on the vision requires leadership throughout the government. The role of minister (or its equivalent) is therefore vital and pivotal to successful transformation. Yet, somewhat strangely, this is a leadership role that has received very little attention from researchers. In part, this is because the role is frequently cloaked in secrecy and masked by mystique—both of which may be regarded as essential to the effective functioning of ministers. This attitude is outdated. It is only through a clear understanding of the leadership requirements of ministers that this critical role can be effective in supporting smart transformation. We were struck in our conversations with more enlightened ministers and senior civil servants throughout the world that the leadership style they embraced was decidedly—and somewhat surprisingly—contemporary. They were people who had thought long and hard about how they practiced leadership and the impact it had on themselves, their followers, and their organization. There was a reassuring frankness to many of their replies to our questions.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The role of leadership
“There are two challenges,” the head of a government department explained. “First, the pace of the change. Second, the
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 18
1/16/2011 5:24:05 PM
Leading through vision
19
One of the exemplary leaders we encountered was leading a wide-ranging governmental transformation. His leadership style was consensual. We arrived to talk to him with a junior official. Throughout the conversation he was at pains to bring the official into the conversation and to make him feel part of a team. He emphasized trust, transparency, and patience. First of all, however, he emphasized that change starts with the leader and the leader must set the example—constantly. “I lead by example. When I ask them to be punctual, I am punctual. When I ask them to be committed, I am committed. So they believe and trust. I want and need them to believe that I am a trustworthy person leading them to do something useful and important for their country. They are part of the success,” he explained. “First, you have to be very consistent. Second, when you promise you have to deliver. Third, you have to be clever in your objectives and results have to be very well defined—so people can see them. Fourth, when you bring them in they have to believe that you are there for them—all the way. You cannot start the journey and then leave.” We pressed him. How would he describe his leadership style? “As a facilitator who tries to facilitate to his team how they can see the challenges ahead and deal with these issues. Trying to make the challenge near to them and make them ready. In this way I will be able to make them engage, make the message consistent and make it clear that they need to lead. I hope in this way we can demonstrate that we are leading these changes. There is no time to waste. It is a big responsibility we have.”
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
people—human capital.” But what kept her awake at night we asked? “External factors: a change of government direction; the inability to have commitment of the team throughout the journey. The possibility that I push too hard—that I am too optimistic and discover later that there is a gap between my ideas and the resources available.”
“The most critical issue is to move quickly and move from one culture to another. The typical government culture moves slowly. I need to be an agent for change—and that needs a different style of leadership. People have to believe in what they are doing—to create the right environment—to be an active player.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 19
1/16/2011 5:24:05 PM
Leading smart transformation
20
They have to witness it. Initially, I saw some resistance but once they felt there was something for them, their families, the future of their children, they started to be very positive.”
Creating the vision is an essential first step, but it is not enough on its own. Mapping out a vision without action is an empty and pointless experience. Inspiring leadership requires powerful management to make the leap from theory to fact. The next challenge for the leadership is to translate the vision into meaningful measurable strategic objectives as well as tangible and symbolic actions. But first it is necessary to mobilize the support of the key stakeholders. Failure to do so will result in resistance that can derail the transformation process.
Smart questions ●
● ● ●
●
● ●
●
●
What is the vision for your nation, your department, your organization? How have you made your vision inclusive? Can you convey that vision in a single phrase? Does it convey an aspirational element that you and your staff can relate to? What will it mean for their children? Can you visualize it in a way that makes it real and meaningful? How much time do you spend articulating that vision? What do you and your leaders do to make that vision real? What would be the tangible proof of it? What leadership role model do you provide that will inspire the people who work with you? Which visions and leaders have inspired you?
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Beyond vision
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_02_cha01.indd 20
1/16/2011 5:24:05 PM
CHAPTER 2
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Managing stakeholders Leading the many Smart transformation starts with a clear vision, but that is not sufficient. Internal and external stakeholders have the power to resist or enable change. A stakeholder is any individual or group that will be impacted by or is interested in the change. Successful transformation requires that leaders communicate strategic change with key stakeholders to ensure their buy-in. Sustaining their support requires ongoing, proactive engagement and dialog. There is no easy formula for this. Even where executive power is greatest, it is impossible to mobilize resources unless the most influential stakeholders buy into the vision and are in agreement with the overall direction of the change agenda. Here again we see that there are two levels at which stakeholders must be engaged. The first is at the level of central government, and may include other governments; the second is at departmental level, and will certainly include other government departments. We will explore both. But first we consider the differences between the public and private sector, especially the importance of influencing skills. In the business world, even though hierarchical authority has been reduced in many companies, the CEO or chairman can often rely on willing executives to implement his or her strategy. In the long run the market will determine the success or failure of a given strategy. But in reality, of course, the market outcome depends on a number of powerful stakeholder groups—in particular, shareholders and customers. With government transformations, the stakeholders are often less obvious but no less influential. Indeed, they are often even 21 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 21
1/16/2011 5:24:07 PM
Leading smart transformation
22
more important. A vital task for leaders is to identify key stakeholder groups—and individuals within those groups—and ensure that they remain onside. This takes time, energy, and persuasive leadership.
It is worth remembering that leadership roles in government are highly demanding. The leader of a national government is a lot more than just a figurehead. Ultimately, they are responsible for everything from the state of the economy to the defense of the realm. The buck stops with them—even though they cannot possibly have a detailed working knowledge of all the minutia. Similarly, the head of a government department is the decisionmaker, setting the policy agenda. They must take decisions concerning operations, the organization, and staffing of their department. They must promote accountability; defend their department and its policies under scrutiny from the media and other political leaders. They must lead and champion legislation; take a lead on public relations, especially with increasingly hostile media; act as an advocate for plans, policies, and expenditure; and provide constructive critical commentary on the policies and plans of other departments and ministers. They are also likely to need to take a lead role in promoting the country’s interests in the wider political world. For the modern governmental leader, complexity comes with the job. The role of governmental leaders is becoming increasingly more difficult and challenging. They face growing pressure from a variety of stakeholders to meet performance expectations; increasing complexity as a result of globalization; demands to restructure and manage change; ever more demanding customers and clients; difficulties in finding good people; and relentless technological change, particularly in the use of information technology. In addition, there is increased scrutiny—and criticism—from a variety of audiences, and stakeholders.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Leadership challenges
“The job [of leader] is more complex,” says Warren Bennis of the University of Southern California. “There’s a more clogged cartography of stakeholders, unbelievable changes, disruptive
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 22
1/16/2011 5:24:07 PM
Managing stakeholders
23
When it comes to government, the picture—and the sheer number of dots that need to be connected—becomes ever more complex. “I think if you are leading complex organizations with so many different stakeholders, so many different pressures, so many different ways of judging success or failure, you need indepth experience. I have seen many people left very exposed by being promoted into those positions without having that experience and sometimes that is sad for the organization and the individual,” laments Lord Michael Bichard. As challenging as this is—and governmental leadership roles are undoubtedly highly challenging—managing stakeholders is rarely afforded the attention it deserves. Yet, one of the most important factors in leading smart transformation is the ability to win and retain the support of internal as well as external stakeholders. We asked one minister what was at stake in the transformation he was trying to bring about in his department and who would be the arbiters of his success or failure. He barely paused before replying: “The people—our stakeholders—will tell us if we have achieved this. There is no good simply wishing for transformation. Our biggest success must be our ability to look ahead and then to seize the opportunity. We must see the challenges and take the actions that are needed.” To do so, the leaders of the future will need to use soft power.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
technologies, globalization, inflection points no one would even think 10 years ago, and most of all, speed. It not only takes a strong stomach and a tough nervous system but a mind that can take nine points of view and connect the dots.”18
Soft power Soft power is the ability to negotiate and gain through co-option and attraction. It is the opposite of hard power, that is, influence through coercion, force, or material payment. Soft power is a phrase that is in vogue in international affairs, but it can also apply to individuals and government departments as well as entire states.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 23
1/16/2011 5:24:07 PM
The phrase was coined by Joseph S. Nye, a professor at the John F. Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University, in a 1990 book, Bound to Lead: The Changing Nature of American Power.19 Nye further developed the concept in his 2004 book, Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics. The term is now widely used. For example, the US Secretary of Defense, Robert Gates spoke of the need to enhance American soft power by “a dramatic increase in spending on the civilian instruments of national security—diplomacy, strategic communications, foreign assistance, civic action and economic reconstruction and development.” There have been calls, too, from China’s political leaders to make more use of soft power in their dealings with the rest of the world. Soft power is dependent on individuals, institutions and nations, values, cultures, citizen sensitive policies and outward looking institutions. Soft power depends also on the reputation of individuals and institutions. The concept of soft power is also gaining attention in the business world. The logic was summed up in a 2004 Harvard Business School Working Knowledge for Business Leaders.20 “Soft power rests on the ability to shape the preferences of others. In the business world, smart executives understand that leadership is not just a matter of issuing commands, but also involves leading by example and attracting others to do what you want. Similarly, contemporary practices of communitybased policing rely on making the police sufficiently friendly and attractive that a community wants to help them achieve shared objectives.” Political leaders have long understood the power that comes from attraction. If a leader can get people to want to do what he or she wants, then they do not have to use carrots or sticks to make them do it. Soft power is a staple of daily democratic politics. The ability to establish preferences tends to be associated with intangible assets such as an attractive personality, culture, political values and institutions, and policies that are seen as legitimate or having moral authority.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Leading smart transformation
24
Simply put: If a leader represents values that others want to follow, it will cost less to lead.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 24
1/16/2011 5:24:07 PM
Managing stakeholders
25
Soft power uses a different type of currency—not force, not money—to engender cooperation. It uses an attraction to shared values, and the justness and duty of contributing to the achievement of those values.
What makes soft power soft? Soft power can be wielded not just by states, but by all actors in international politics, such as NGOs or international institutions. The primary currencies of soft power are an actor’s values, culture, policies, and institutions—and the extent to which these “primary currencies,” as Nye calls them, are able to attract or repel other actors to “want what you want.” In 2008, Nye applied the concepts of hard and soft power to individual leadership in The Powers to Lead. In any discussion of power, he suggested, it is important to distinguish behavior (affecting others to obtain the preferred outcomes) from the resources that may (or may not) produce those outcomes. Sometimes people or countries with more power resources are not able to get the outcomes they wish. Power is a relationship between an agent and a subject of power, and that relationship will vary with different situations. The same principles apply whether talking about government department or an individual leader and his or her team.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Soft power should not be equated simply with influence. Influence comes in many forms; it can rest on the hard power of threats or payments. Soft power, too, is more than just persuasion or the ability to move people by argument, though that is an important part of it. It is also the ability to attract, and attraction often leads to acquiescence. In behavioral terms, soft power is attractive power.
Engaging with stakeholders Soft power is especially important in managing stakeholders. Our experience suggests that failure to address the concerns—and
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 25
1/16/2011 5:24:07 PM
Leading smart transformation
26
This means that a process of consultations with external and internal stakeholders is vital. Yet, this can all too easily be neglected by leaders who are anxious to make a start on the transformation. This is not surprising given the pressures placed on them. Consultations need to be wide ranging simply because leaders of government departments have to manage a whole constellation of stakeholders. As well as direct stakeholders, such as government employees, these include semi-government entities such as chambers of commerce and a wide variety of other groups with vested interests all seeking to influence government in their favor. For example, there are industry groups and professional bodies, which lobby the government in an attempt to influence new regulations and laws to help their members. There are also social activists and other non-government organizations (NGOs)—everything from environmental pressure groups such as Greenpeace, which aim to protect the environment, to Amnesty International, which petitions governments on their human rights records. Then there are other influential groups—the media, for example. In fact, one of the difficulties of governing is that media organizations—as well as a myriad other vested-interest groupings—are free to pursue their own, often conflicting, agendas. And while these legitimate stakeholders can and frequently do argue that they champion public opinion, there is no question that they also influence and shape public perceptions and public opinion. They may claim that they are just “the messenger” but often they are also the authors of the message.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
win the support—of stakeholders is a surefire way to derail a transformation. The arena of stakeholder opinion is where the transformation must win approval if it is to succeed. Soft power is often more effective in this arena than hard power.
At the same time, these external stakeholders exert varying degrees of influence over government policy. It would be naïve to suggest that all lobbyists are created equal or treated fairly. Governments respond to their stakeholders differently. The effectiveness of lobbying is linked not only to the strength of the
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 26
1/16/2011 5:24:07 PM
Managing stakeholders
27
case but also to the strength of the financial resources deployed. Lobbying is not a level playing field.
Stakeholders are enablers of transformation. They can also be blockers. The transformative cycle can be likened to a wheel or dynamo that drives the transformation process. In order to turn, the wheel must be unobstructed by the forces surrounding it. The external stakeholders can be compliant—and supportive—of the transformation. If so, they allow the wheel to turn freely. Alternatively, if there is friction and resistance from the external stakeholders, they will act as a brake, slowing down the momentum of the wheel or preventing it from turning at all. At best, this will result in a lot of wasted effort and energy to drive the wheel; at worst it will stop it dead. The metaphor makes it plain why managing stakeholders is so vital to smart transformation. The support of internal stakeholders—principally employees—is needed to set the wheel in motion and to drive it through the various phases of its cycle. But the support of external stakeholders is vital to allow the wheel to turn freely. The external stakeholders, then, can be viewed as the context or environment in which the government entity is seeking to transform itself. These external stakeholders can either act as an enabler or as a brake on the transformation. Similarly, neglect internal stakeholders and the brakes will be applied.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The leadership challenge this presents to government departments should not be underestimated. The challenge for government is to shape the agenda—through change—bearing in mind the conflicting agendas of stakeholders, and their power to pursue their own agendas. This requires considerable skill.
Auditing stakeholders The first step toward managing stakeholder engagement is to identify who the key stakeholders are. For example, an obvious stakeholder would be a government employee whose job is directly affected by the transformation, and whose role and responsibilities will change as a result. But other stakeholders are less obvious. For example, foreign companies may be affected by changes in business regulations introduced by the
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 27
1/16/2011 5:24:07 PM
government—either making it easier or harder to set up a business. Or existing businesses may be affected if changes in regulation make it easier for competitors to enter their markets. Alternatively, changes may require action. For example, efforts to remove discrimination in the workplace may require companies to send staff on training courses. Similarly, non-government organizations (NGOs) may be interested in changes to central government policy or how those changes are implemented at the departmental level. Stakeholders may actively (or passively) support and promote change; or they may oppose the change. For instance, they may be enthusiastic converts to new ways of working, sending their people for training or they may drag their feet or refuse to participate in the training initiative. In this way we can see that the vision of central government—for example, to boost national productivity or raise innovation—may be thwarted by disgruntled stakeholders at the grassroots. A stakeholder analysis helps the transformational leadership team identify key stakeholders—and their attitudes toward the change. The aim is to ensure all the key players are on your radar and to identify what their concerns are. This allows leaders to develop strategies to communicate with them effectively. The objective must be to involve those stakeholders who support the change, while helping to mitigate resistance from those who may oppose it. The key is to engage with stakeholders so that they feel part of the process—and can voice their point of view. Once internal and external stakeholders have been identified, the next step is to use data gathering techniques, such as interviews, surveys, and focus groups (we recommend these be with groups of eight to ten people), to learn more about stakeholders’ perceptions. This will generate useful information about their hopes and fears concerning the changes. Such data gathering is also an opportunity to explore with them how they stand to gain from the transformation. The high-priority stakeholders can then be identified—the ones whose behavior is likely to have the biggest impact on the success of the change program. Ultimately, the objective is to develop relationships with the key
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Leading smart transformation
28
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 28
1/16/2011 5:24:07 PM
Managing stakeholders
29
stakeholder groups so that they can provide support throughout the transformation. It is also helpful to identify potential allies among the stakeholder groups whose support can be used to create momentum for change. These individuals or groups can be powerful opinion formers among other stakeholders.
Roles and positions: Understanding the stakeholders’ roles and their positions on the key issues will help you understand how the changes might impact on them. Objectives: Identifying their objectives and what motivates them will help you anticipate whether they will support or resist the changes. Hopes and fears: Building a picture of their hopes and fears— what concerns them and how they might benefit from the changes will inform your tactics and the messages you communicate. Impact on success: Understanding how the stakeholder may impact on the success or failure of the change program enables you to prioritize initiatives and activities. For a government department, external stakeholders will typically include some or all of the following: foreign investors; business membership organizations and professional trade bodies; NGOs; educational institutions; the media; the general public (citizens); the private sector (business); as well as vendors and suppliers (trainers, consultants, IT providers and so on). Internal stakeholders include: departmental leaders; managers; and employees. Straddling the two are stakeholders who are outside the department but inside the government. These include: central government; leaders of other government departments; the cabinet or national leadership committee. Peer groups stakeholders are especially important here. If a government department can achieve credibility among its peer group as a role model for transformation, this is a powerful (soft power) lever for change and can act as a catalyst for transformation in other departments.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
It is useful to analyze a variety of information about each stakeholder group. We recommend the following:
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 29
1/16/2011 5:24:07 PM
Leading smart transformation
30
Communication is glue
Much is said about the importance of consistent messages and behavior from leaders. But trying to be consistent in terms of policy statements and policy delivery when trying to negotiate through such a minefield of diverse interests is not easy. For one thing, different stakeholders are won over by different messages—depending on their own agendas. A strong commitment to reducing CO2 emissions may win you friends among environmental pressure groups but is unlikely to automatically please heavy industry, for instance. Even when government tries hard to understand and consult with interested parties, things do not always run smoothly. Government bodies in several countries have been caught out by sending policies for public consultation, gaining acceptance from key interest groups and then finding when policies are made public those key interest groups go against their word and criticize the government. When government then responds to the requirements of these interest groups they are accused of being inconsistent by some; of double dealing by others who feel aggrieved that their interests have been let down; and criticized by still others who are naïve about the workings of government and interaction with stakeholders. Managing stakeholders requires a clear idea of what the public sector leader is there to do: who and what does he or she serve? One of the most useful answers to this question lies with the notion of public value.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The need to win and maintain the support of internal and external stakeholders means effective communication is vital. Yet communicating with a diverse group of stakeholders is problematic.
Creating public value Creating Public Value by Mark Moore, a professor at the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University, is the seminal work in its field—an innovative and thought-provoking look at the role of the public servant.21 It sheds useful light on the notion of who a government’s stakeholders are.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 30
1/16/2011 5:24:08 PM
Managing stakeholders
31
In a town library, the librarian is concerned about the volume of schoolchildren that have suddenly begun visiting the library’s reading rooms after school at about 3.00pm, then disappearing again between 5.00pm and 6.00pm. An informal survey reveals that the library is being used as a substitute day care center for working parents. What should the public sector manager—the librarian—do about this? There are a number of options. The librarian’s first instinct is to crack down on the situation, especially as the influx of children makes the library crowded, causes disruption, and leaves untidy piles of books all over the tables, creating extra work for the library staff. Given that caring for children out of school hours is the responsibility of the parents or day care providers and not the library, the librarian considers sending out a letter to the local newspaper reminding citizens of the appropriate use for the library, and if this fails, limiting access for children. Next, the librarian considers that the additional influx of children might be used to claim more funds for the library, especially as the library budget is tight. Alternatively, it might be possible to create a new program for the children and recoup the costs from the parents, although this would be problematical, especially apportioning direct and indirect costs, and balancing the interest of the working parents and general taxpayers. Equally, the local authorities may want a say in whether it was appropriate to use the library for this type of program.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Moore provides an example which highlights a dilemma facing public sector managers, a dilemma that Moore’s concept of public value goes some way to solving.
If obtaining funding was difficult, perhaps the service for the children could be provided through volunteering, with parents helping supervise and clean up afterwards. But, this is potentially complex and not obviously within a librarian’s remit. Finally, the librarian considers that the needs of the children of working parents could be met from the library’s existing organization. This would require some careful fine-tuning, staff rescheduling, special reading and the addition of enrichment
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 31
1/16/2011 5:24:08 PM
Leading smart transformation
32
This last approach helped the librarian see the library in a different light. Professional training encouraged a view of the library as a place where books were kept and made available for the public to borrow; but the library had evolved beyond that. It had extended its classification system, for example, to music CDs and film DVDs, there was an area designed for young children, societies met in the meeting rooms, and internet access was available.
Sense of purpose This example highlights the situation many governmental leaders find themselves in. Where the purposes of the governmental enterprise are set out and mandated for in legislation, regulations and doctrine, the leader is accountable accordingly. Yet, what should they do in the many situations, which do not fit neatly within existing frameworks? And should government leaders only perpetuate the status quo according to existing rules, or should they act as agents of change, driven by some other equally valid purpose—in Moore’s case the pursuit of public value? After all, if the actions of private sector leaders are driven by a need to maximize shareholder value, and this purpose guides their strategic decision-making, what drives the actions of their counterparts in government? Is there an equivalent overriding aim? Moore argues that public value is the loose equivalent of shareholder value for the public sector. When an organization uses public authority or money from taxes, the value of the enterprise must be judged against the expectations of citizens for justice and fairness and also efficiency and effectiveness. This means that the creation of public value can come from the governmental leader exercising authority and spending public monies to deliver products and services—providing healthcare to help improve people’s health—as well as helping to create a well-governed and productive public body.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
programs aimed at the children. This could even be said to fall legitimately within the central mission of the organization—encouraging reading and a love for books.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 32
1/16/2011 5:24:08 PM
Managing stakeholders
33
Moore considers different options for how we can calculate the value of public value in an enterprise. One way of reckoning public value is to look at how satisfied the people in charge of the enterprise are with the way that is run. Another would be to use some form of evaluation to assess how the enterprise is achieving its mandated aims. A third method might be to use financial analysis to map the value to those who benefit against the costs of providing those benefits. Finally, customer satisfaction might, potentially, be a means of assessing value.
Visions of value Each of the possible means of assessing public value has its merits, but also its disadvantages—the methods are, for example, not necessarily consistent with each other. Moore offers his own method of “envisioning value” by adapting corporate strategy for the purposes of the public sector. This new method of understanding public value involves an integration of several elements: substantive judgments of what would be valuable and effective; an analysis of political expectations and a tough assessment of what is practically possible. The three pillars of public value are presented as a strategic triangle of politics, substance, and administration, with governmental leaders focusing on three key questions when considering organizational purpose and their actions. First, is the purpose publicly valuable—are they producing something of substantive value to the stakeholders? Second, will it be supported, politically and legally—will it continue to attract money and support from political authority? And finally, is it administratively and operationally feasible—are the objectives achievable? These are the necessary conditions for producing public value, says Moore.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Moore explores ways that leaders can be more of an asset to the society that they serve by “searching out and exploiting opportunities to create public value.” His ideas are strongly rooted in the notion that context is critical. He seeks to provide a “general answer to the question of what public managers should think and do to exploit the particular circumstances they find themselves in to create public value.”
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 33
1/16/2011 5:24:08 PM
Leading smart transformation
34
What Mark Moore is suggesting is a radical departure from the concept of a governmental leader or civil servant as an administrator merely deploying resources to deliver a mandated product or service, in a way that ensures that they are properly accountable. Instead, within Moore’s framework, they have the scope to define the organization’s overall purpose and mission, and act in a strategic and entrepreneurial way, detecting opportunities to create public value that would normally lie outside their mandate. As Moore argues, the ability to mobilize support and resources for their organizations, while also obtaining the help of others in a position to assist them in furthering their aims, often beyond the scope of their direct authority, is an essential skill. Five approaches to political management include the management of policy development, public deliberation and leadership, public sector marketing, negotiation, and entrepreneurial advocacy. Managing downwards to motivate stakeholders lower down— primarily employees—is also essential.
Managing the media Among the growing number of stakeholders governments need to understand and work with, several stakeholder groups in particular bear closer examination: the media; the business community; lobbyists; and internal stakeholders. We will address these in turn.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Using the strategic triangle also focuses the mind of leaders on the core aspects of their task. Leaders in the public sector must judge the value of their intended purpose, and then manage their actions in a way that acquires legitimacy from above, while also managing downwards to improve the organization’s ability to deliver its purpose.
One of the most powerful stakeholders that impact on government transformation is what Thomas Carlyle called the “Fourth Estate,” the media. Let us first consider the evolution of this phrase and its significance. The idea of dividing the state into branches, or estates, with separate and independent powers and areas of responsibility has a long history. It was developed in Ancient Greece and
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 34
1/16/2011 5:24:08 PM
Managing stakeholders
35
The separation of powers was highly influential in the writing of the US Constitution. The US Federalists, whose leaders included James Madison, Alexander Hamilton, John Jay, George Washington, and Benjamin Franklin, embraced Montesquie’s governing philosophy of the threefold division—with the executive, legislature, and judiciary forming the three estates. As they saw it, the separation of powers was an effective guarantee of the rights of minority groups who might otherwise be oppressed by an overbearing majority. The Federalists argued that the benefits of national government, as formed by the Constitution, would flow to the people. But Thomas Jefferson, another of the founding fathers and the principal author of the Declaration of Independence, took a different view. He was concerned that a powerful central government could divert power away from the citizens. Jefferson believed in the concept of popular sovereignty, whereby the people themselves needed to “exercise control with wholesome discretion.” His main thesis was that “if people were truly informed, they would not be often misled.” The successful operation of government, he said, depended on the education of the populace. For Jefferson, it was vital that the people remained informed. To “inform their discretion,” as Jefferson put it, the people needed access to information that was not controlled by the state. Jefferson saw an informed and educated citizenry as the ultimate check on the abuse of power. It is from Jefferson that the notion of the importance of a free press can be traced. To the three estates was added Carlyle’s “fourth estate.” Together, these are meant to provide the vital checks and balances required to protect the rights of individual citizens.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
used by the Roman Empire. Building on this idea, the French political thinker Charles-Louis de Secondat, Baron de La Brède et de Montesquieu argued for a threefold separation of powers (trias politica).
Degrees of freedom In many countries today, privately and publicly owned newspapers, television networks, and new media (online) channels
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 35
1/16/2011 5:24:08 PM
Leading smart transformation
36
A major issue with the media is always its degree of independence and objectivity. In the West, the commercial nature of most media organizations means that their survival and success depends on their ability to sell newspapers or attract viewers and advertisers. Inevitably, the desire to sell newspapers or airtime can put pressure on decisions about which stories to bring to the public attention. The stories that interest the public most may not be those that are most in the public interest. But which are the newspapers most likely to print on the front page? The answer, often, is the stories that will sell more newspapers. None of this is especially new. Newspapers—and pamphleteers—have always been less than perfect. Indeed, our real conceit in recent years has been to elevate the notion of a free press and imagine that this means a neutral or objective press. The real question with a free press is always about the degree of freedom. Is there a sufficient spectrum of free and open opinion, or are there limitations caused by a concentration of ownership? The fact is that without the support of the press—or at least the absence of outright press hostility—governments will always find it difficult, if not impossible, to achieve smart transformation. And the press can be a very fickle beast. It may smile on you today only to bare its teeth and snarl at you next week. Leaders should not expect consistency from the media; it is rarely forthcoming. What is perfectly acceptable one day can be portrayed as a public outrage the next. But in this, the fourth estate is merely mirroring the rest of society.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
can—and frequently do—criticize their governments. In many countries, too, the power of new media via the internet is increasingly potent.
Digital Utopia? The evolution of the media is a powerful force and one that is being shaped by new technology. As we noted earlier, the internet makes it increasingly difficult for governments to censure information and news. And it is not just authoritarian governments that are affected by the growth of online activism.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 36
1/16/2011 5:24:08 PM
Managing stakeholders
37
In many ways, though, the creation of new ways of connecting people—with each other and with their governments—has opened a Pandora’s Box. New technology—primarily Information and Communication Technology (ICT)—can empower individual citizens. Scholars, entrepreneurs, and contemporary politicians alike have promoted ICT for its potential to engage the population—to create a “postindustrial” or “information society” that promotes a sense of community, educational opportunity, and more participative government. The spread of technology also has a darker side—raising new issues for governments and citizens alike. In the United Kingdom, for example, the wiring up of public space with closed camera (CC) surveillance systems has been rapid and relentless. In just a few years, CCTV systems have been installed in city centers, schools, hospitals, libraries, car parks and roads, as well as in residential and rural areas. Britons are now watched by more CCTV cameras than the people of any other country in the world. The average Briton is caught on camera 300 times a day. Some 10 percent of the world’s 30 million CCTV cameras are in Britain.22 Many find these developments alarming. They represent increasingly invisible, all-seeing, all-powerful, control mechanisms over citizens. For some commentators they are the embodiment of George Orwell’s Big Brother in his novel 1984 or the “Panopticon” envisaged by the British philosopher, Jeremy Bentham, in 1787, for social control in prisons, asylums, work places, and schools. Bentham’s notion of “Panopticon” has been used, both by novelists and scholars, as a metaphor to raise awareness of increased use and abuse of ICT in the collection of citizen’s information through overt and covert surveillance.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Some commentators have argued that the advent of new technology—especially the internet—would herald a new era of more transparent and participative government. The notion of e-government was one of the big ideas of the past decade. The experience has been somewhat different.
In the future, government leaders will need to find ways to balance the traditional and new media. We believe that, in the end, soft power rather than hard power will be more effective in managing these stakeholder groups. Similarly, soft power
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 37
1/16/2011 5:24:08 PM
Leading smart transformation
38
is the best way to engage with another increasingly powerful stakeholder—the business community.
The reality is that any government that is not business-friendly risks alienating the global business community. In a world where capital can migrate to different parts of the world in a matter of hours, this can be disastrous. Fundamental questions need to be asked about the relationship between the public and private sector. As we will see, how governments seek to harness market disciplines is arguably the most important issue facing governments today. It is not a simple issue. Current debate centers on the best way to use markets to improve the efficiency of public services—both in terms of improving quality and reducing costs. Such questions have profound implications for the future of capitalism as a system. They have become even more critical and pressing in the light of the recent financial crisis and are at the heart of the ongoing debate about public management.
Lobbies of power In our age the business world reigns. Corporations and their lobby groups exert unprecedented power. This can be seen in: ●
●
●
The focus on microeconomic rationality (profit-maximization, the pursuit of immediate economic self-interest) to the exclusion of macro-social realties. The retreat of the state (through privatization, outsourcing, hollowing out) and the increased delivery of public services by private parties which exercise authority in their own name, rather than in the name of the law that transcends their own power. A blurring of the lines between public and private sectors.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The business community
In the face of such trends and new realities, governments are not powerless. They must constantly seek to engage and understand the different agendas at work. Being on the front foot requires
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 38
1/16/2011 5:24:08 PM
Managing stakeholders
39
In terms of lobbying, governments and government departments need to sprint to catch up and understand the complex dynamics now at work. Increasingly, multinational corporations are adept at lobbying power brokers. David Bach of IE Business School talks about the need for companies to have “nonmarket strategies” as well as market-focused strategies. Faced with more sophisticated lobbying, governments and government departments need clear and unequivocal expressions of where they are and where they are going.
Internal stakeholders As well as the complex array of external stakeholders, smart transformation requires the willing—indeed enthusiastic—support of internal stakeholders. Most of these stakeholders work for the government. But other groups, such as consultants and contractors, who might otherwise be regarded as suppliers may be seen as internal stakeholders; as may certain clients who work closely with government. All of these internal stakeholders have a decision to make. They must decide whether to commit to the transformation. Inevitably, the reaction and level of engagement will vary across the stakeholder population depending on a variety of factors. But in order to make change happen, the organization must engage with its internal stakeholders. Without followers there can be no leadership—and no transformation. The work of James McGregor Burns in the late 1970s led to the most significant change in the way we understand leadership. Burns viewed leadership as a relationship between leader and led. Leadership was, Burns said, “leaders inducing followers to act for certain goals that represent the values and the motivations— the wants and needs, the aspirations and expectations—of both leaders and followers.”
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
that they establish relationships with as many stakeholders as possible.
Burns identified two contrasting leadership styles: transactional and transformational leadership. In transactional leadership the relationship between leader and followers is based on an
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 39
1/16/2011 5:24:08 PM
Leading smart transformation
40
The link here with government is through the vision. As we noted in Chapter 1, the vision acts as a catalyst—securing commitment to an end state that will be achieved via the transformation. The vision, then, provides a bridge from the present into the future. An effective vision attracts commitment and energizes people—by creating meaning in their work. When they are given good role models they aspire to a standard of excellence, which stimulates improvement.
It is not one way “I think the biggest thing that you can have is ambition, the second biggest thing is leadership and followership. The world is full of leaders that nobody wants to follow,” says Frank Ryan of Enterprise Ireland. “You have to have a logic attached to what you are trying to achieve and clearly show that if people are prepared to commit their time and intelligence to a certain path what the conclusion of this can be and that it is an important result worth achieving e.g. it is valuable in business terms and valuable in terms of the impact it can have on Irish society.” The vision must be clearly mapped out—as must the benefits for those who follow. Leaders have to continually think of their followers. But followers, too, have a more active role. They are not merely the recipients of leadership. Rather, they are active and responsible participants in leadership.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
exchange of value that is mutually beneficial. It might be psychological, political, or economic in nature. Transformational leadership, however, does more than exploit and meet existing needs or demands from followers. Transformational leaders try to understand the motivation that drives followers and meet that higher need. They seek to engage with the followers. Transformational leaders develop a binding and mutually stimulating relationship with followers.
In her book Bad Leadership, Barbara Kellerman, the James MacGregor Burns Lecturer in Public Leadership at Harvard University’s John F. Kennedy School of Government, examines bad leaders who she categorizes as: incompetent; rigid; intemperate; callous; corrupt; insular; and evil. As Kellerman points
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 40
1/16/2011 5:24:08 PM
Managing stakeholders
41
As this final point makes clear, managing stakeholders has to be a two-way process. All have to be connected with and listened to if transformation is to be achieved. And all have to be on board if transformation is to be driven and delivered—the subject of our next chapter.
Smart questions ●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
●
Who are the key external stakeholders you have to manage? Who are the key internal stakeholders? What roles do your stakeholders play in your organization or transformation program? What role would you like them to play? What are the most important aspects of the agendas of all your stakeholders? What are their objectives or personal goals (that’s what motivates them)? What are their hopes and fears? How do you keep up-to-date with the evolving needs of your stakeholders? To what extent do you need that support of your stakeholders for the changes to be successful? Which stakeholders in particular will impact on your success? Is it possible to win over critical stakeholders most of the time? If not, what can you do about it? How can you use soft power to attract stakeholders to your cause? What does the notion of public value mean to you and your stakeholders? Who do the stakeholder’s report to? Which leaders can influence them? Are you sufficiently resilient to withstand the criticism of stakeholders when you know that you have made the best possible decision under the circumstances?
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
out, bad leaders often retain a hard core of followers even when their inadequacies are exposed. How do we prevent bad leadership? The answer lies in strong moral followership. There is an obligation on followers to exert a positive influence on their leaders, and reject patently bad leaders.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_03_cha02.indd 41
1/16/2011 5:24:08 PM
CHAPTER 3
Enablers, institutions, and processes So far we have looked at the need for a vision to direct and inspire smart transformation, and the importance of engaging with stakeholders to enable it to occur. Now we turn our attention to what drives that transformation. The simple reality is that strategic change rarely happens of its own accord: it requires momentum and energy and a governance model to drive it. There are different models possible for the governance of a transformation process. In Singapore, for example, they favor a taskforce approach; while in other countries a steering committee structure may be preferred; in yet other places, such as Malta, the transformation is driven by the Prime Minister’s Office. In Sweden the transformation is driven by the civil society and the political system. “It is a rather pragmatic system,” says Ola Ullsten, the former Swedish prime minister. “One method often used is that the government invites a bipartisan commission with representatives from major political parties and interest groups like trade unions and industry to prepare a proposal. In other cases smaller and independent task force groups are being used. These arrangements can be looked upon as complimentary to the parliamentary process. It is more easy to implement reforms if you have an overall idea of what the tension points are, which are the crucial things to achieve and how can it be done.”
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Driving the transformation
Yet, whichever governance model is preferred, two main models exist based on whether the transformation is championed from within the government machinery or from outside. Neither model is right or wrong. Rather, they suit different situations, cultures, and sets of circumstances. 42 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 42
1/16/2011 5:23:35 PM
Driving the transformation The first model is driven from outside of the existing government machinery. This may involve a dedicated temporary steering committee. We call this a Smart Tool. This is what happened in Ireland and Abu Dhabi, where a senior leadership committee was established to make high-level decisions with a Program Management Office (PMO) overseeing the reforms. In these countries, the steering committee is the main decision-maker, with the PMO responsible for day-to-day implementation. In Ireland, for instance, the implementation of the change program is carried out by a dedicated program office working through sector centers and is overseen by the Cabinet Committee. The Cabinet Committee is chaired by the Taoiseach (Irish prime minister) and includes the ministers for finance; health and children; justice, equality and law reform; environment, heritage and local government; and education and science. To drive its transformation, Ireland underwent a 15-year program equipping government departments with strategic planning capabilities. A variation on this model is provided by the United Kingdom, where transformation was championed by the Cabinet Office, which is responsible for high-level centralized decision-making with the follow-up provided by the PMO or at unit level. The second transformation model is driven from within the existing government machinery. Again, there are two main variations of this model: through multiple or single entities. In Australia, Canada, and New Zealand, for example, key departments within the government took the lead in introducing reforms. These countries use a partially decentralized approach, with the Treasury handling fiscal reforms; the Public Service Commission handling communication; and the Prime Minister’s Office responsible for general policy. In the case of New Zealand and Canada, these three main entities were involved in driving the transformation; in Australia, there were ten main entities involved.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
43
Elsewhere, in Barbados, St. Lucia and St. Vincent and the Grenadines, for example, transformation was driven from within the government machinery but centralized through one government entity and usually mandated by the prime minister. The main owner of the reform in these places is the Ministry of Civil or Public Service.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 43
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
Leading smart transformation
44
The driving force Our experience suggests that, regardless of which model is applied, effective governmental transformation programs require a central driving entity. This entity—which we prefer to call the Smart Project Management Office—acts as a catalyst, seeding the success of the transformation. The PMO sits between the top management or leadership of an organization and the traditional organizational chart. In effect, it exists in parallel—and provides a shadow management structure. Being separate from the preexisting structure, the PMO is unencumbered by history or the agendas of existing fiefdoms. Its primary purpose is to drive the transformation—and to support and champion the new organizational structure and priorities. In effect, the Smart PMO provides a lever for the leadership to enact its will upon the organization. It balances two roles—process monitoring; and content delivery and assurance. The intelligent use of soft power is one of the most important levers available to the Smart PMO.
The master plan
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The choice of the model depends on the circumstances driving reform. If fiscal and economic crises are the catalyst, then the Treasury is likely to drive the model. In New Zealand a centralized unit drawn from the Treasury, the Prime Minister’s Office, and the civil service drove change but lost momentum due to tension between departments and the dominance of the Treasury. The shape of the centralized entity matters and will impact the outcome.
At central government level the PMO is responsible for administering the entity’s strategic plans across six key activities: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Initiative proposal Initiative planning Required management decisions Managing change requests Tracking progress and reporting Managing communication
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 44
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
Driving the transformation
45
1. Reviewing and approving newly proposed projects and initiatives aimed at achieving the targets. 2. Helping to prepare project plans—including deliverables, milestones, and costs. 3. Identifying the management decisions (enablers) required to ensure projects are delivered on time and to cost. 4. Setting and maintaining a standard process for managing projects—including changes to scheduling and budget planning. 5. Tracking outcomes (jointly with the implementation team) to ensure projects and initiatives stay on track. This includes preparing consolidated weekly, bi-weekly, monthly, quarterly, and annual reports that set out progress against plans—and identify problem areas and help remedy them. 6. Communicating relevant messages to stakeholders.
Departmental PMOs PMOs are also required at departmental or agency level. The roles and activities described above are repeated at the unit level. (Once again, the Russian Doll metaphor can be applied). The network of PMOs also provides an effective shadow organization, mirroring the structure of government at both central and departmental level and providing a clearly visible and accountable organizational framework. In this way, traditional challenges associated with cascading initiatives are mitigated, and an effective set of levers are available to senior leadership. The PMO network also ensures an effective flow of reliable information both from central government to departmental level and from departments back to central government. (For more on how the PMO works see Chapter 7: Making it happen.)
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
So, for example, high-level PMO activities include:
Measuring sticks With a leadership vision and the stakeholders aligned, the enablers are in place and transformation is possible. The next step is to develop a program of transformation that can be driven
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 45
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
Leading smart transformation
46
Creating appropriate measures and targets is only one part of the challenge. The other part is having the transparency and leadership will to hold people accountable for their performance. This should not be underestimated. Traditional civil services have been soft on targets, providing a safe sinecure for life. Smart transformation requires a degree of transparency and accountability that many civil servants are not used to. A culture of under performance is not compatible with smart transformation and often represents the biggest obstacle to change. Lord Michael Bichard, former director of the Institute for Government in the United Kingdom, has been at the forefront of change initiatives in government for the past 20 years. He knows from firsthand experience how difficult it is to take policy goals and translate them into targets—and a realistic assessment of the organizational capabilities required to achieve those targets. “People are quite reluctant, perhaps through a lack of courage, to translate the vision into hard-edged competencies and to assess people on the basis of those. It’s almost as if there is a vision we articulate and a traditional set of characteristics, qualities and competencies which we allow to run on, so we won’t allow people’s careers to be affected by the fact that we now have a different vision and a different way of doing things. There is a tendency to be concerned more with people’s experience, the posts they have held, rather than whether or not they subscribe to the skills required for the new challenges.”
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
by the leadership. Smart transformation requires a yardstick for measuring the progress of individual government departments, agencies, and teams. The nitty-gritty of smart transformation lies with setting and monitoring hard-edged targets.
Lord Bichard continued, “Take customer service, I got fed up with the number of times I had intellectual discussions about whether or not we should call someone a customer or a client. People were interested in having the intellectual debate, what they weren’t very keen about was saying, well we have now decided we are going to be an organization that’s focused on clients and therefore we are looking for people who have the skills and values to translate that into practical action. We are going to assess people on the contribution they make to improving client
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 46
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
Driving the transformation
47
As Lord Bichard observes, it is often easier to ignore the gap than to face up to the fact that an organization or government department is not fit for its new task. But being soft on people and failing to identify capabilities that are lacking is a recipe for mediocrity. And, of course, spelling out milestones with great clarity has implications for managers and leaders. Milestones and measurement go together.
What gets measured ... The act of measuring something focuses attention on its importance and that in turn focuses the minds and efforts of those charged with achieving it. “The success of our client companies is of paramount importance at Enterprise Ireland,” says Frank Ryan, CEO of Enterprise Ireland. “That’s how you know whether you are winning or losing. It can’t be success if you simply imagine you are moving in a positive direction; you have to have clear metrics and this is an agency which is now metric-driven. We have across the full agency about 85 metrics. No department or division has more than about five or six to focus on. Given the mandate and scope of different departments, each requires different metrics to monitor progress.” Frank Ryan went on to say, “In 2003 we commenced the transformational change programme. Our indigenous exports had not grown for the previous 10 years. In the following five years total exports from Irish companies grew by 40 per cent, in other words by 4 billion euros. That was achieved by going back to basics by uncomplicated things, by saying look this is about markets; it’s about companies; it’s about international contacts at Government level and at business level; it’s about substantive R&D projects that are actually delivering new products and services to the market place; it’s about delivering what international
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
service, we are going to assess people on the contribution they make to innovation. It was almost as if people felt well that’s not very fair, that’s not what we joined the civil service for. Well it is fair because that’s what this organization is all about.”
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 47
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
Leading smart transformation
48
customers want; it’s about delivering what our customer’s customer wants.”
The willingness to identify and use hard, standardized measures and objective milestones is critical to all successful smart transformations. One of the most important tasks of leadership is to set stretching objective targets. Without these it is all too easy for the leadership to declare victory when in reality it is losing the transformational war. One common issue for governments and their agencies, especially in emerging markets, is that there simply isn’t the apparatus to measure any changes on performance and behavior. This is a significant problem as the truism that what gets measured gets done has never been truer. In Abu Dhabi this was identified as an important issue in transforming the government and economy. Historically, statistics had simply not been captured nor communicated. There was nothing to go on. The Department of Economic Development (DED) was charged with “providing for a dynamic, open and successful economy.” In what is an evolving and new role, the department is expected to become a policy-maker, facilitator, and monitor of economic development. In most countries the policy infrastructure is already established, but for an emerging economy—and especially for one attempting a smart transformation—there was no such luxury. While most economies look to compare the impact of policy with a base line for performance, in Abu Dhabi there were no reliable measures. Think about it. Without clear and reliable statistics, how could Abu Dhabi gauge its progress? An early task for the DED, therefore, was to create a government body capable of providing objective data.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Measuring the previously overlooked
In May 2008, in response to this issue, the creation of a statistics center was announced.23 The Statistics Centre—Abu Dhabi (SCAD) is an autonomous body, which enjoys financial and administrative independence and legal competence as the
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 48
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
Driving the transformation
49
Statistics are the dynamic pulse of transformation. Technology means that statistics can be instant and more accurate than ever before. In Abu Dhabi the latest wireless handheld devices are now used for compiling data.24 By the middle of 2009 SCAD was reporting on six major surveys for the year 2007–08 conducted in the emirate covering a wide range of economic activities including financial, industrial, services, construction, commercial, maintenance, in addition to transport, communication and storage activities.25 The surveys monitor the evolution of the different sectors of the economy, and provide data directly obtained from the field on the volume and origin (foreign, Arab, or local) of investment capitals, on the size and costs (wages and other cash and in kind advantages) of manpower in every economic activity, and on the production of both goods and services. The outcome of the surveys makes the basic information and data on different economic activities available so that the added value of these activities can be calculated, as well as the overall GDP of the emirate and the contribution of each activity. Measurement and milestones are important, but as we indicated earlier, there is a third leg to driving the transformation— accountability. It is one thing to set targets and measure progress toward them; it is quite another to hold civil servants accountable for their performance. How should performance be assessed?
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
sole agency for official statistics in the emirate. The center is based in Abu Dhabi and may open branches or affiliate offices. The center aims to develop and organize statistical work in the emirate and provide accurate and reliable information on the emirate’s social, economic, and environmental state to decisionand policy-makers, as well as to the public, media, businesses, research centers, and the international community.
Whose value? As we saw in Chapter 2, the idea of public value advanced by Mark H. Moore as the Hauser Professor of Nonprofit Organizations and director of the Hauser Centre for Nonprofit Organizations, at the John F. Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University, is an important one. Moore has pioneered
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 49
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
Leading smart transformation
50
“The critical question is: who gets to be the arbiter of the value that is produced by a particular organization? As we began talking about ‘customers’ in the public sector it began to sound as though the people who were in the position to arbiter the value of public sector operation were the same as those in the private sector—namely people who voluntarily chose to buy or not to buy a particular good or service,” said Moore in an interview. “An alternative way to think about it is that it isn’t an individual who is the arbiter of value, but a collective, acting through the instrumentality of representative government. You can use a lot of metaphors, society as a whole, society acting through the processes of representative government, but a crucial idea is that the individual who matters is not a person who thinks of themselves as a customer but as a citizen.”26 A citizen, Moore says, focuses on the degree to which an effort being undertaken with collectively owned assets, like the money or authority of the state, advances their conception of what is a just, fair, and good society. There are two ways of looking at this, he says. The first is the markets concept where things are good or bad according to how individuals value them. The second is that society gets together and constructs a social utility function that is not necessarily the same as the satisfaction of each individual in the society. So you have a social utility function, which is not the summation of individual satisfaction, but the degree to which the society is successful or unsuccessful in achieving a desired goal.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
research on the way leaders of public organizations can engage communities in supporting and legitimatizing their work.
Moore illustrates his point with an example. He began his career doing evaluations of publicly supported drug treatment programs. “If I had done the evaluations according to customer analysis, I would have asked the addicts if they liked the programme, and they would have said yes—so much so, they kept coming back for more. I could have filed a report that said it looked like we were doing a good job providing public goods and service because the customers liked it, and kept coming back for more—the market test in the private sector.” 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 50
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
Driving the transformation
51
Benchmarking for beginners One of the most effective tools for improving performance is benchmarking. Benchmarking became popular in the business world in the 1980s and 1990s, and then spread to government. The idea is literally to benchmark performance against other companies or other departments. It involves the detailed study of productivity, quality, and value in different departments and activities in relation to performance elsewhere. The principle behind benchmarking (or best practice benchmarking as it is also sometimes known) is very simple. If you want to improve a particular aspect of your organization or the service it provides, find someone else who is good at the activity you want to improve and use them as a benchmark to raise your own standards. In effect, it’s a way of pulling up performance by the bootstraps. Typically, a database of relevant performance measures is drawn up from looking at similar activities in other parts of the government and in other similar organizations. This information is then used to compare the performance of the unit or department being reviewed with the range of experience elsewhere.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
“But if I handed that report to a public accountability body, acting for society as a whole, they would have said that is not what ‘we’ had in mind. What ‘we’ had in mind when we taxed to produce money for this drug treatment programme, was that the addicts would stop using drugs, stop committing crime, get a job, and take care of their family. In that moment they would be specifying the social outcome that the collective had in mind, for the individuals that were the clients of the programme.”
Benchmarks can be set at the overall governmental level. So, for example, it might be helpful to benchmark against the Canadian states of Ontario and Alberta; Australia’s Queensland; the State of North Rhine-Westphalia in Germany; Zurich in Switzerland; or Singapore. Or it might make more sense to benchmark at a more functional level considering governance in municipalities. Even more specific baselines might look at specific governmental departments or agencies—the UK’s Cabinet Office; the Ministry of General Affairs in the Netherlands; Belgium’s Federal Public 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 51
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
Leading smart transformation
52
Service Chancellery; or Germany’s State Chancellery. In monarchies, further useful organizational lessons might be drawn from the UK’s Royal Household; the Queen Support Functions in the Netherlands; or Monaco’s Prince Palace Organization.
1. Best Demonstrated Practice (BDP) involves the comparison of performance by units within the same organization or government. For example, the staffing levels or service responsiveness in one location can be compared with the same statistic for an office in another, within the same government department, as can the unit cost of electricity, security, or any other cost for that matter. BDP usually throws up large variances, some of which can be explained by lack of comparability, but much of which is due to superior techniques or simply greater efficiency at one site. That site can then be used as a challenge to lever up the performance at other sites. 2. Relative Cost: This analysis looks at each element of the cost structure (e.g. administrative staff cost) per dollar of service in organization X compared with the same thing in organization Y. Good analysis of this kind is very hard to do but very valuable, as much for its insight into alternative approaches as for cost reduction. 3. Best Related Practice is like BDP, but takes the comparisons into related (usually not competing) organizations, where direct comparisons can often be made by cooperation between departments to collect and compare data. So, for example, the tax collecting department of one government might benchmark against the tax collecting organization in another country.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
There are three different techniques that can be used in benchmarking:
Organizations which take benchmarking seriously often have a web of benchmarking partners both within the organization and with outside partners across a wide spectrum of activities. So, for example, a national postal service might benchmark its transport and delivery performance internally across its different locations; against other government departments such as the tax office; and against a transportation specialist such as one of the international courier companies such as FedEx or DHL.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 52
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
Driving the transformation
53
Benchmarking is not about trying to clone other organizations, or industrial espionage. Nor should it be measurement for measurement’s sake. Rather it is based on the logic: why waste time and effort trying to reinvent the wheel, when you can have a look at someone else’s wheel and refine its applications to fit your own needs. Benchmarking typically involves: ●
●
●
● ●
●
Establishing what improvements would make an important contribution to competitiveness. Identifying other organizations, or units, with superior performance in the key area. Approaching those organizations to form benchmarking partnerships, enabling the study of internal processes. Determining meaningful measures of performance (metrics). Setting new targets in the key areas based on those observed in the benchmark organizations. Applying best practice from the benchmark organizations to meet and if possible exceed the new targets.
Benchmarking—along with other techniques such as business process re-engineering—are useful tools. But they are no more than tools. On their own they are simply yardsticks by which an organization can monitor its performance and look to make improvements. It is only when such tools are used to set meaningful targets that significant progress occurs. That is the hard edge of transformation—and that requires leadership.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The same postal service might also benchmark its accounting systems against a financial services company, and so on.
Global benchmarks It is worth noting that there are a growing number of global competitiveness rankings, which provide ready benchmarks for many aspects of governmental performance. For example, the World Economic Forum has published its annual Global Competitiveness Report since 1979. It has become a benchmark for policy-makers seeking to improve the economic conditions for growth and competitiveness.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 53
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
The IMD World Competitiveness Yearbook also ranks the competitiveness of entire nations. Published annually since 1989, the IMD study examines the relationship between a country’s national environment and the wealth creation process—ranking “the ability of nations to provide an environment that sustains the competitiveness of enterprises.” The 2010 ranking covered 58 economies, ranking them from the most to the least competitive. (The top five were: Singapore, Hong Kong, the United States, Switzerland, and Australia.) The interactions of four competitive factors are analyzed: economic performance; government efficiency; business efficiency; and infrastructure. Each category is broken down into five subcategories, which are evaluated using multiple measures. In all, data are collated across 300 competitiveness criteria. Wide ranging in scope, these cover a multitude of measures from GDP per capita to levels of tax evasion; from Nobel prizes per capita to how open a national culture is to foreign ideas. Useful as they are, macroeconomic indexes are just that—measures of the total performance of a national economy.
Exposed by measurement The thing about measurement is that it exposes hiding places. There is no escape. For many in government this is very difficult and uncomfortable. For others it is liberating. “I think most organizations and people find accountability quite difficult. A number of our professions in the UK have shied away from accountability in the last twenty years, so I don’t think the civil service is particularly unusual in that,” observes Lord Bichard. “But, having said that, there are some particular issues in the civil service which make people reluctant to expose themselves and maybe also in the political process and the way some ministers behave reinforces that. I have worked with some brilliant ministers, but there are others who are very quick to blame, when blame perhaps is not justified, and less quick to learn and support.”
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Leading smart transformation
54
Key to success is the robustness of the debate surrounding the measurements. There is an enormous difference between
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 54
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
Driving the transformation
55
When things go wrong, it is normal for people to feel let down— angry even. They may also feel that they—and the changes that they are trying to bring about—are threatened. The more passionately they feel about the matter, the more intense the emotions that are likely to be generated. It is clear, then, that when an element of a transformation goes awry, feelings can run high. With its reliance on a strong vision to mobilize emotions and energy, failure can easily tip over from a genuine desire to learn from errors into a witch-hunt. The critical difference is the maturity of government ministers and public officials to deal with such comments and show that what they have is not a blaming culture but a learning culture. In other words, the notion of a learning government is similar to that of a learning organization. The notion of the learning organization was popularized by MIT professor Peter Senge. In his seminal book on the subject, The Fifth Discipline, Senge claimed that successful organizations of the future would be learning organizations. What would distinguish these learning organizations from the traditional “controlling organizations” would be mastery of certain key disciplines. Senge identified five new “competent technologies,” which provide the vital dimensions in building organizations that can truly learn. These are: ●
●
Systems thinking—Senge champions systems thinking, recognizing that things are interconnected. He introduced the idea of systems archetypes, to help managers identify unhelpful repetitive patterns and problems. He also explicitly recognized that organizations are complex—and messy—systems. Governments are even more so. Personal mastery—Learning is not a passive process. Senge grounds this idea in the familiar competencies and skills associated with management, but also includes spiritual growth— opening oneself up to a progressively deeper reality—and living
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
blaming people when things go wrong and understanding what went wrong in order to learn from mistakes. The line between the two is often a very fine one and it is important to remain on the right side of that line—the learning side.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 55
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
●
●
●
life from a creative rather than a reactive viewpoint. It is only by exercising their will to learn that individuals can master the complex processes involved. This discipline involves two underlying movements—continually learning how to see current reality more clearly—and the ensuing gap between vision and reality produces the creative tension from which learning arises. Mental models —Noting that many of the best ideas never get put into practice, Senge asserts that this is not the result of weak intentions but because the new ideas are in conflict with deeply held internal images of how the world works. The organization’s current view of the world and assumptions about reality get in the way. These “mental models” limit organizations to familiar ways of working. Senge alerts managers to the power of patterns of thinking at the organizational level and the importance of nondefensive inquiry into the nature of these patterns. Shared vision —here Senge stresses the importance of cocreation and argues that shared vision can only be built on personal vision. At its simplest level, he says, shared vision is the answer to the question: “What do we want to create?” It may be inspired by an idea, but once it becomes compelling enough to acquire the support of more than one person, it moves beyond an abstraction. He claims that shared vision is present when the task that follows from the vision is no longer seen by the team members as separate from the self. “A shared vision is a vision that many people are truly committed to, because it reflects their own personal vision.” “Shared vision is vital for learning organizations because it provides the focus and energy for learning.” Team learning—this requires alignment of goals but also a clear understanding of two practices: dialog and discussion. The former is characterized by its exploratory nature, the latter by the opposite process of narrowing down the field to the best alternative for the decisions that need to be made. The two are mutually complimentary, but the benefits of combining them only come from having previously separated them. Most teams lack the ability to distinguish between the two and to move consciously between them.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Leading smart transformation
56
Senge’s points are equally valid for government departments. All this requires maturity to behave and reflect in vivo so that
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 56
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
Driving the transformation
57
the government learns as it acts. A good example of learning while driving transformation is Singapore.
Having a vision and managing stakeholders are important steps toward achieving smart transformation. Yet few countries have managed to harness them to effectively drive through change. One plus one often fails to equal two. And, as Lord Bichard points out, even when the addition works it demands constant support and repetition. One of the few that has successfully done its sums is Singapore. In the mid-nineteenth century, Singapore was one of the great fleshpots of the Orient. Opium dens, brothels, and bars lined its narrow, winding streets, attracting the sailors, adventurers and colonizers who used the bustling port as a jumping-off point for much of Southeast Asia. Today Singapore is still one of the great entryways to the region, but instead of ramshackle bordellos and open sewers, visitors are now greeted by gleaming towers of glass and steel. The former British crown colony boasts not only the world’s busiest port but also a strong free-market economy based strongly on exports of electronics and manufacturing and, increasingly, on finance. GDP is also high, with a per capita average of more than $25,000 for its population of approximately 4.6 million. The IMD World Competitiveness Index has ranked Singapore as the most competitive country on planet earth. Singapore has successfully transformed itself. While its progress has not been without bumps in the road—the Asian financial crisis, for example—the country has driven a national change program that has delivered on its original vision. The decision to industrialize—and to do so rapidly—was a deliberate policy.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The reinvention of Singapore
The Singapore approach can be distilled to two equations: Vision + leadership = transformation. Milestones + measurement = accountability.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 57
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
Leading smart transformation
58
The proof of the transformational pudding lies in the eating. Technological change and political considerations in the postSecond World War period—not least of all the nationalism that accompanied the quest for independence among the region’s European colonies—have combined to alter dramatically the economic self-perception and public policies of this diminutive island-state. By the late 1950s, it was obvious that prospects for economic growth would be severely limited if Singapore remained bound by its old economic role as entrepôt. Initial emphasis in the government’s economic development program was on employment. The increasing trend toward economic self-sufficiency in neighboring Indonesia and Malaysia—and the steady retreat of the United Kingdom from defense responsibilities in the region as a whole (centered on its large Singapore naval and air facilities)—prompted the government to focus completely on finding alternative employment for the island’s highly skilled and disciplined workforce. By the end of the 1960s this problem was effectively solved with Singapore boasting one of the lowest unemployment rates in all of Asia. The emphasis in the mid-1970s was on labor skills and technology, especially as these were identified with such modern industries as machine tools, petrochemicals, electronics, and other precision work. A high level of participation by private foreign capital provided an important cornerstone to this development. In 1979, the Singaporean government abandoned its earlier policy of stimulating low-wage industries and adopted a policy of encouraging capital-intensive and technologically sophisticated industries. Especially targeted for investment promotion in the 1980s were computers, computer peripherals, electronic medical instruments, automotive components, specialty chemicals and pharmaceuticals, and optical and photocopying equipment. Following the recession of 1985–86, the government concentrated on developing new markets and on turning Singapore into a manufacturing, financial, and communications center for multinational corporations. In the 1990s the economic
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Future proofing
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 58
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
Driving the transformation
59
The Economic Development Board (EDB), formed in 1961, has guided Singapore’s industrialization. Early emphasis was placed on promoting investment in manufacturing. The Strategic Economic Plan (SEP) announced in 1991 focused on education and human resources to enhance export competitiveness. Emphasis on developing the service sector has been supported and enhanced by the Operational Headquarters (OHQ) program, encouraging companies to use Singapore as regional headquarters or as a distribution center. The Creative Business Programme promotes investment in the film, media, and publishing, arts and entertainment, textile, fashion and design sectors. Currently the EDB works toward Singapore’s vision of its future as a developed country through the promotion of business. Singapore’s globalization strategy hinges on making a transformation from a production-driven economy to an innovation-driven one. Other key elements of this strategy are the reversal of downward trends in productivity, and sustaining foreign investment in Singapore’s capital investment. Singapore initiated the formation of a growth-triangle, linking Johor, Malaysia, Singapore and Indonesia’s Riau province focusing on Batam Island. Singapore benefits by tapping a supply of low-wage workers and offshore land to sustain its more labor-intensive industries. The Asian financial crisis was only a temporary setback for the healthy economy of Singapore. Roadblocks to further economic development include rising labor costs; which have threatened investment in Singapore’s industrial sector, causing the government to implement strategies to cut costs and increase productivity. The rise of Singapore’s currency has also prompted the dispersion of new industrial enterprises from the country, which the government has answered by promoting the development of high-capital industries.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
development strategy emphasized both the manufacturing and service sectors.
It is tempting to look at the success—albeit qualified success— of Singapore and think that economic transformation is both inevitable and achievable. But Singapore’s success is built on
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 59
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
Leading smart transformation
60
relentless effort—and a willingness to use objective measures to push through bold visions.
●
●
●
●
●
● ● ●
●
●
What is the governance model that applies to your transformation? Is it fit for purpose? Do you have a Smart PMO or equivalent to overcome barriers and drive the transformation? Do you have clear lines of accountability for core activities; project execution; content assurance; and capacity building? Do you have standardized processes and measuring sticks to measure progress? Have you benchmarked your organization against other parallel organizations throughout the world to establish a base line? What are the key metrics of your transformation? Do you have the resources to capture the vital metrics? How do you go about understanding the needs of your communities, citizens, and clients and do you service them accordingly? Are you consistent in the delivery of your services in terms of promises made and actions undertaken, and if not how do you then communicate that with your stakeholders? How do you hold people accountable? Who has ownership of an issue or challenge? What is the price of failure? Do you have processes in place to learn from mistakes?
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Smart questions
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_04_cha03.indd 60
1/16/2011 5:23:36 PM
Part II
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The Transformational Cycle
The strategist’s method is very simply to challenge the prevailing assumptions with a single question: Why? And to put the same question relentlessly to those responsible for the current way of doing things until they are sick of it. Kenichi Ohmae1 We do not need magic to change the world, we carry all the power we need inside ourselves already: we have the power to imagine better. JK Rowling2 You can’t out-Xerox Xerox. Don’t play the competitor’s game. Costas Markides3
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 61
1/16/2011 5:23:38 PM
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 62
1/16/2011 5:23:39 PM
CHAPTER 4
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Setting the strategy The art of translation Part I was all about understanding and creating a context that is ripe for change. This relies on having a vision, understanding the multiple stakeholders involved, and using measures and governance to enable transformation to be pushed through. Part II is about the transformational cycle that will make the change a reality. This requires working through each of four transformational disciplines. It is vital that none are overlooked and that the proper linkage is preserved and the sequencing is well orchestrated. The first discipline involves formulating and translating a strategy. At a national level, that includes a clear idea of the role of the private and public sectors. At the departmental level, it includes a clarity of purpose and service offerings. In both cases, strategy must be focused on turning vision into reality. In particular, it is essential to agree on strategic objectives and set key performance indicators. In the first instance, a government comes to power with a manifesto—which is its vision. But once it has a mandate to rule, it has to translate that vision into a strategy to make it a reality. At a national level, it has to translate its priorities into a high level budget, which sets the budgets and key objectives for all the government departments below it. That strategy is then cascaded down to each department or government entity, which then has to create its own departmental strategy. The importance of strategy was brought home to us when we encountered a colleague who is a senior official in the Bangladesh government. He came to London on a study tour and was shown 63 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 63
1/16/2011 5:23:39 PM
around the foreign office, the Treasury, the cabinet office, and so on. At the end of three grueling days of exposure to the way the British government operates he expressed his disappointment. He then went on to meet Scottish ministers and pubic servants in various departments at the new Scottish parliament and legislature. He was highly impressed by the Scottish parliament and the efficiency and effectiveness of its government. “What was the difference?” we asked. “Clear structures and clear strategy,” he replied, going onto observe that this contrasted with what he had found in London which he described as “out-dated thinking, unpleasant inward looking politics and no appetite for change.” That phrase “an appetite for change” goes to the heart of smart transformation. Our own experience suggests that there are pockets of appetite everywhere—including London. So how do you translate a vision into a strategy that can be executed by those with the required appetite for change?
Back to the beginning Let’s first rewind a little to consider what we mean by strategy. The word derives from the Greek for generalship, strategia, and entered the English vocabulary in 1688 as strategie. According to James’ 1810 Military Dictionary, it differs from tactics, which are immediate measures in face of an enemy. Strategy concerns something “done out of sight of an enemy.” Its origins can be traced back to Sun-Tzu’s The Art of War from 500 BC. Indeed, Sun-Tzu makes periodic returns to the bestseller lists. His book is full of neat aphorisms which seem to shed light on the mysterious world of strategy. They are reassuring, if not always appropriate. The traditional view is that strategy is concerned with making predictions based on analysis. Predictions, and the analysis which forms them, lead to security. The bottom-line is not transformation—it is survival. If, by using strategy, we can increase our chances of predicting successful methods, then our successful methods will lead us to survival and perhaps even improvement. So, strategy is to do with getting it right or, as the more competitive would say, winning. Of course it is possible to win battles and lose wars and so strategy has also grown up
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Leading smart transformation
64
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 64
1/16/2011 5:23:39 PM
Setting the strategy
65
This was all very well in the 1960s and for much of the 1970s. Predictions and strategies were formed with confidence and optimism (though they were not necessarily implemented with such sureness). Security could be found. The political and economic environment appeared to be reassuringly stable. Governmental objectives could be set and strategies developed to meet them in the knowledge that the overriding objective would not change. This approach became known as Management By Objectives (MBO). In practice, MBO demanded too much data. It became overly complex and also relied too heavily on the past to predict the future. The entire system was ineffective at handling, encouraging, or adapting to change. MBO simplified strategy to a question of reaching A from B using as direct a route as possible. Under MBO, the ends justified the means. The organizational equivalent of highways was developed in order to reach objectives quickly with the minimum hindrance from outside forces. “The confusion of means and ends characterizes our age,” the Canadian strategist, Henry Mintzberg observes and, today, the highways are liable to be gridlocked.4 When the highways are blocked people are left to negotiate minor country roads to reach their objectives. And then comes the final confusion: the destination is likely to have changed during the journey. Equally, while MBO sought to narrow objectives and ignore all other forces, success (the objective) is now less easy to identify. Today’s measurements of success can include everything from environmental performance to meeting equal opportunities targets. Success has expanded beyond simplistic measures of more of the same.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
in the context of linking together a series of actions with some longer-term goals or aims.
Another fatal flaw in the conventional view of strategy is that it tended to separate the skills required to develop strategy in the first place (analytical) from those needed to achieve its objectives in reality (practical). The divide between analysis and practice is patently artificial. For governments set on transformation, strategy does not stop and start, it is a continuous process of redefinition and implementation.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 65
1/16/2011 5:23:39 PM
Leading smart transformation
66
In strategic thinking, one first seeks a clear understanding of the particular character of each element of a situation and then makes the fullest possible use of human brain power to restructure the elements in the most advantageous way. Phenomena and events in the real world do not always fit a linear model. Hence the most reliable means of dissecting a situation into its constituent parts and reassembling them in the desired pattern is not a step-by-step methodology such as systems analysis. Rather, it is that ultimate non-linear thinking tool, the human brain. True strategic thinking thus contrasts sharply with the conventional mechanical systems approach based on linear thinking. But it also contrasts with the approach that stakes everything on intuition, reaching conclusions without any real breakdown or analysis.5 When the future could be expected to follow neat linear patterns, strategy had a clear place in the order of things. Now, the neatness is being upset, new perspectives are necessary. Even attitudes to time are being questioned. Western admiration of the BRIC economic miracle makes Eastern notions of time intriguing. The East tends to use a cyclical conception of time not driven by achievement or by short-term objectives. Instead, it is deterministic and fatalistic. Linear thinking has tended to make Western governments opportunistic rather than strategic. For example, governments are inclined to assume that the private sector is a given. Yet, as the recent financial crisis confirms, there are profound questions that governments need to ask themselves about the nature and relationship of the private and public sectors. We shall explore these later. But our main theme in this chapter is to examine how a central government sets a strategy, and how this strategy is translated from a country level to a government entity or departmental level.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
In his book, The Mind of the Strategist, the Japanese strategic thinker Kenichi Ohmae says:
As we have seen already, a country’s strategic plan should be set based on a long-term vision, which is then translated into a strategic plan which cascades all the way down to target and priority areas across government.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 66
1/16/2011 5:23:39 PM
Setting the strategy
67
COUNTRY VISION
Long-term (20 years)
GOALS
Country Policy Agenda
THEMES PRIORITY AREAS
Medium-term (5 years)
5-YEAR TARGETS
Government Strategic Plan
2-YEAR TARGETS
Short-term (2 years)
INITIATIVES
Government Business Plan
KPIs
The strategy cascade model At the departmental level, government entities then develop five-year and two-year strategic plans, along with related performance measures and financial plans. These should align with the overall government policy agenda. As we will see the vision shapes the strategic levers that may be used. The last part of this value chain is the business model itself. So, for example, when we consider attracting Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) or creating clusters (see later in this chapter) these are examples of strategies utilized in order to achieve the overall vision. These can be seen along a spectrum of possible policies utilized depending on the overall government strategy/ vision. For example, at one end of the spectrum are government visions with pure private sector orientation (business model) and at the other end are pure government (public sector models). In between are different options of policies of which clustering could be one, social capitalist policies another.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
STRATEGIES
Model building Viewed in this way, a key task in creating a strategy for transformation is to foster an economic model aligned with the vision. In other words, how do I economically organize my society or my department to achieve my objectives? What is my model? It sounds straightforward, yet it is anything but.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 67
1/16/2011 5:23:39 PM
Leading smart transformation
68
So, what sorts of market forces do we want to encourage and harness? What sort of private sector do we want to foster? How can and should you economically organize your society, government, and department? Answers differ. Many countries have tried to create an economic engine for change. But no two situations are identical. Abu Dhabi, for example, is blessed with natural resources in the shape of abundant oil reserves. The challenge facing the emirate is to use its natural wealth to broaden and diversify its economic base and create a sustainable economy. The emirate’s economic vision for 2030 sees: “Abu Dhabi as a sustainable, diversified, high value-added economy that encourages enterprises and entrepreneurship and well integrated into the global economy leading to better opportunities for all.” The strategy set out in the Abu Dhabi Economic Vision 2030 involves moving from a resource-based economy to a knowledge-based economy. To achieve this aim, the vision has been translated into two clear economic policy priorities: Policy one is to build a sustainable economy. Policy two is to ensure a balanced social and regional economic development approach that brings benefits to all the emirate’s population.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
For one thing, it raises the question of what we mean by our business or operating model. For governments worldwide, the answer is increasingly that we are concerned with leveraging shareholder value techniques for the purpose of promoting a stakeholder philosophy within government. This means using the expertise and dynamism of the markets for the benefit of public services—both to make government more efficient and also to drive transformation.
Beneath these policy priorities are five specific core objectives. So, under policy priority one, it is important to reduce GDP volatility through diversification away from its dependence on oil. The second strategic objective is to enlarge the enterprise base—encouraging entrepreneurship to support a dynamic private sector. The third objective is to enhance competitiveness and productivity—by bolstering the SME sector but also by raising the game of underperforming sections of the economy.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 68
1/16/2011 5:23:39 PM
Setting the strategy
69
To achieve the economic growth required to make its vision a reality, the government has identified a number of sectors as the “engines of future economic growth.” Among them are energy; petrochemicals; metals; transportation and logistics, including aviation and aerospace; pharmaceuticals, biotechnology and life sciences; tourism; healthcare; education; media; financial services; and telecommunications. Other countries, such as Ireland, have sought to kick-start economic growth in a number of ways as circumstances have changed (see case study on page 138). The simple fact is that there is no silver bullet for creating a sustainable business model for a country. “In the history of economic success, no two countries have ever followed identical paths,” R. Glenn Hubbard and William Duggan, two leading scholars in business finance, observe in an article in strategy+business.6 “Nations rise out of poverty when elements of a thriving business sector replace the previous economic system.” This may be true of Western countries. Yet many Asian economies grew in much more closed economic settings where governments were major drivers. This luxury may not be open to governments in the future. As globalization becomes an ever more powerful force, governments will face increasing pressure to open up their borders rapidly. They will find it hard to delay regulatory reform that attracts private sector companies. Making it simple and straightforward to do business is a fundamental requirement for many governments. At an operational level, since 2004, the World Bank has tracked the realities of doing business each year in countries around the world for its Doing Business report.7 The report specifies ten forms of
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Supporting policy priority two are four more strategic objectives. These are: to equip the emirate’s youth to enter the workforce by investing at all levels of the education system especially tertiary education and vocational education; to maximize the participation of national women in the workforce; to attract and retain skilled workers; and, finally, to stimulate faster economic growth in the regions by creating incentives for businesses to set up in the more remote areas of the emirate.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 69
1/16/2011 5:23:39 PM
Leading smart transformation
70
● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Starting a business Obtaining licenses Employing workers Registering property Getting credit Protecting investors Paying taxes Trading across borders Enforcing contracts Closing a business
The fewer obstacles that government places before entrepreneurs in any of these areas, the faster the process involved, and the less it costs (for fees or bribes), the more business-friendly the country is deemed to be—and the more prosperous. In 2009, Singapore ranked first out of 181 countries on the list. It was followed by New Zealand, Hong Kong (China), the United States, and the United Kingdom. The Central African Republic ranked last.
Strategy levers So far we have looked at how a national vision can be translated into strategy at a national level. But beyond this is the next step—translating the national strategy of central government into strategy for individual government entities or departments. As an example of how the central government strategy cascades down to the departmental strategy, consider the Abu Dhabi Chamber of Commerce and Industry. In response to the strategic objective to enlarge the enterprise base and encourage foreign investment, the Abu Dhabi Chamber of Commerce has transformed itself into a one-stop shop to serve its members and investors. The ground floor of the Chamber’s building is a hive of commercial activity. A wide variety of organizations now offer services to Chamber customers through its Members’ Services Center. They include the Ministry of Justice, the country’s health insurance provider, the Naturalization and Residence
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
government regulation that affect the various phases of a company’s life cycle:
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 70
1/16/2011 5:23:39 PM
Setting the strategy
71
But if the benefits of being business-friendly are so clear, ask Hubbard and Duggan, why hasn’t every country and every government jumped on the bandwagon? The answer, they say, provides a critical insight into the travails of poor economies. “Countries often have a competing system—either a powerful and arbitrary government or an entrenched oligarchy, or both— that resists the adoption of pro-business elements. And in countries that remain poor, that competing system is still winning.” Other factors also play a part. For one thing, it is not so clear-cut that adopting the pro-business regime advocated by the World Bank will bring greater prosperity. The reality is more subtle. Smart government is about fostering a business model—or private sector—that is in step with the long-term vision of the country. It would be naïve for the government of any emerging country to allow business to operate entirely unconstrained. The result is likely to be disastrous for the local population. As we have seen, no two situations—or countries—are identical. But there are some strategic issues that are common to all modern governments. Among them are macro issues such as a nation’s strategy on energy generation. In the light of the 2010 BP oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico, this is now moving up government agendas and was included in President Obama’s first Oval Office address, when he urged Americans to see the oil spill as a reason to move toward sustainable energy sources. Clearly, its stance or strategy on energy is linked to a country’s stance on its environmental footprint. Other macro issues include infrastructure policy—especially transportation.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Department, the National Bank of Abu Dhabi, the Ministry of Labor and Labor Affairs, the Businesswomen Council and others. Red tape is not eliminated, but a lot of it can be relatively simply untangled in one building.
Any one of these (and many other) macro strategy issues could fill a book on their own. So it is not our intention to describe the issues in great detail. Suffice it to say that they will be increasingly important in the coming years. But, there are a number of macro strategy levers that demand our attention. These include: cluster creation; New Public Management; and especially considerations of the form of capitalism or private sector
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 71
1/16/2011 5:23:39 PM
Leading smart transformation
72
governments should seek to foster—shareholder or stakeholder capitalism, or possibly a new paradigm of socialized capitalism. We will examine these in turn. First, cluster creation.
An example of a strategy lever to achieve an overall vision is the decision by some governments to encourage the formation of specialized clusters of economic activity. Cluster formation policy goes to the heart of the government/economy relationship and the need to create a sustainable business model and economic engine. Some governments also see it as a strategic lever to attract talent and build educational infrastructure. Visit the fast expanding development of Masdar City in Abu Dhabi and you will witness the reality of a business model at first hand. The rising city will be home to 40,000 people in ten years. It is part of the wider Masdar Initiative, an ambitious commitment to renewable energy. In oil rich Abu Dhabi, Masdar is a huge investment in repositioning. In 2008 the emirate’s government allocated US$15 billion to the project. Already, it has attracted the headquarters of the International Renewable Energy Agency. A new university is planned as Abu Dhabi seeks to create an environmental legacy.8 Masdar is probably alone in the sheer scale of its ambition, but not in its objectives. In their attempts to foster productivity and economic dynamism, governments have always looked toward the most successful economies. In doing so many policy-makers have tried to emulate the success of the US economy in driving technological progress. A recurring aspiration has been attempts to replicate the economic benefits of clusters, such as Silicon Valley, through governmental support.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Creating talent magnets
Clusters are dotted around the industrial world and occur in virtually all industries. The Hollywood film industry and the automotive industry around Detroit are famous examples. Clusters create a virtuous circle of investment and development. Above all, they act as talent magnets attracting the brightest and best
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 72
1/16/2011 5:23:39 PM
Setting the strategy
73
minds. But, for all the glittering successes there are many white elephant developments throughout the world where would-be clusters have failed to take off.
Making sense of clusters It is worth remembering that clusters of specialized companies are not new. Some clusters have existed for centuries. Long-established examples include the Italian leather fashion cluster, which includes Ferragmo and Gucci and a host of specialized suppliers around Milan; the flower-growing cluster in the Netherlands; and the financial district in London’s Square Mile. The phenomenon was first observed by the Cambridge economist Alfred Marshall in the nineteenth century. He noted a tendency for specialized companies to cluster together in a way that produces geographic concentrations of expertise and economic activity. (Economists refer to them as neo-Marshallian nodes.) Marshall’s analysis, however, overlooked the importance of the role of entrepreneurs. In the twentieth century, the Harvard economist Joseph Schumpeter identified the role of self-interested economic agents, who took risks in order to generate substantial profits. In Schumpeter’s model, entrepreneurs created new products, services, methods of production, and new ways of organizing economic activity to create new markets. This, he argued, created a technology push mode of innovation.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Whether and to what extent, public policy can be a catalyst for cluster formation remains a topic of debate. The most useful role for government is often to remove regulatory obstacles that hinder the free working of capital and talent markets.
More recently, Stanford’s Professor Paul Romer has developed a model, which suggests that technology progress is caused by the search for new ideas by researchers interested in profiting by their innovations. Although Romer doesn’t explicitly equate entrepreneurship with innovation, his theory interprets growth as a process through which the research sector and other interested parties produce new products for the market and obtain
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 73
1/16/2011 5:23:39 PM
Leading smart transformation
74
Harvard’s Michael Porter’s research confirms that clusters of specialized companies enjoy unusual competitive success. Porter suggests that clusters encompass an array of linked industries and other entities important to competition. They include suppliers of specialized inputs, and providers of specialized infrastructure. They also extend downstream to channels and customers and laterally to manufacturers of complementary products and to companies in industries related by skills, technologies, or common inputs. Clusters often include governmental and other institutions—such as universities, standard-setting agencies, and think tanks, and providers of specialized training, education, information, research and technical support. What is harder to explain is why geographic proximity should continue to confer a competitive advantage in the global economy. The success of Silicon Valley and other high-tech clusters highlights what Porter calls the “paradox of location.” Despite suggestions that in a connected world geographic location is no longer a significant competitive factor, for high-tech firms, the reverse appears to be true: proximity to other technology companies is more vital than ever. “Paradoxically, the enduring competitive advantages in a global economy lie increasingly in local things—knowledge, relationships, and motivation that distant rivals cannot match,” Porter has noted.9 In other words, in the global economy clusters are more important than ever.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
monopoly profits from new ideas. Romer did not consider entrepreneurship explicitly as a mechanism through which R&D is transformed into economic activity, but the model does provide a theoretical underpinning for high-tech clusters.
Although what happens inside firms is important, the cluster effect indicates that the immediate business environment outside companies plays a vital role as well. The proximity of organizations within clusters appears to affect competition in three broad ways. First, they increase the productivity of companies in the region. Second, they drive the direction and pace of innovation. Third, they stimulate and trigger the genesis of new businesses within the cluster. “Clusters are knowledge communities,” says Dr. Mark Jenkins, of Cranfield University in the UK, who has studied the 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 74
1/16/2011 5:23:39 PM
Setting the strategy
75
Jenkins argues that three levels of specialist knowledge exist in certain global industries. These are at the firm; the cluster; and the industry level. Although there are important firm-specific and industry-specific forms of knowledge, cluster level knowledge is the most significant source of competitive advantage. “The region as a whole is successful more than are the individual firms within it,” says Jenkins. “In many respects, then, it is the regional cluster rather than the individual firms that constitute the significant resource and unit of analysis. This fact raises important issues about how we view the nature of competitive success.”
Lessons in clustering What is particularly interesting is when clusters are used as a means of educating and training an indigenous workforce. Several education-focused hubs have been established in the Middle East, for example, and are attracting the attention of some of the world’s leading business schools. Dubai’s Knowledge Village is a learning community with state-of-the-art facilities. It includes the Dubai Knowledge Universities campus, allowing international universities to have a presence in Dubai. There is a similar move in Qatar, where the Qatar Foundation for Education, Science and Community Development has created Education City, a 2500-acre campus near Doha.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
phenomenon.10 “A cluster is a way of doing things that is a lot more durable than the know-how of a single company. It’s more than just co-location. I’d use the term knowledge architecture. It’s know-how, but it’s also know-who.”
The government of Abu Dhabi has also wooed leading educational providers, including INSEAD, which has established a permanent campus in the emirate, and is launching an Abu Dhabi section of its Global Executive MBA (GEMBA) program. The Abu Dhabi government also has an international agreement with the Paris-Sorbonne. “The government of Abu Dhabi considers advancement in education to be an integral part of its social and economic development 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 75
1/16/2011 5:23:39 PM
Leading smart transformation
76
India is also following the learning cluster model with its own Education City, located on a 60-acre site near Delhi International Airport. Lancaster University Management School is working in partnership with GD Goenka Educational Trust, which owns Education City, to deliver a range of programs, including a twoyear Global MBA. Education clusters are seen as a way to help transform emerging economies into knowledge-based economies. Of course, in education, Oxford and Cambridge universities have followed the cluster principle for centuries. Indeed, being part of an already established education cluster gives their much younger business schools an important advantage at home—and with the emergent educational hubs. The Said Business School at Oxford University, for example, has benefited from its strong brand recognition in the region, winning executive education projects with both Abu Dhabi and Saudi Arabia. The Abu Dhabi Oxford Leadership Development Programme was launched in January 2008 to deliver a development program for more than 200 of the emirate’s leading civil servants. Oxford also works with other countries in the Middle East. The Saudi Oxford Advanced Management and Leadership Programme, for example, is a joint initiative between Said Business School and the North Development Programme of Rakisa Education, in association with the Saudi Arabian General Investment Authority. The program provides a forum for developing senior leaders from Saudi public and private sector organizations.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
plans,” Director General of Abu Dhabi Education Council (ADEC), H.E. Dr. Mugheer Khamis Al Khaili, observed. “We are currently implementing a range of strategies to deliver education excellence and are particularly proud of our partnership with INSEAD. With this and other strategies in place, Abu Dhabi looks forward to becoming a hub for higher education.”
These various developments even though small are significant in their general impact. Such educational clusters can provide the rocket fuel for transformation: knowledge.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 76
1/16/2011 5:23:40 PM
Setting the strategy
77
Crisis? What crisis? At a micro level there appears to be general agreement on the role of government in developing a country’s economy. It should facilitate the easy practice of commerce. (Or as the Abu Dhabi Chamber of Commerce and Industry’s mission puts it: “We are the private sector representative working to advocate policies, connect businesses and expand member opportunities by providing world-class member services, with an aim to contribute to Abu Dhabi’s sustainable economic development.”) Now, take a step back and let us contemplate the bigger picture: what is the macro role of government in global commerce? This issue was brought to the forefront of ministerial minds when the world’s financial systems teetered on the brink in 2008. The IMF estimates that the total cost of the 2008 banking crisis was $10 trillion. It is a truly staggering bill. What went wrong and what can be done to prevent it happening again has been widely debated. To this we would add a couple of points. First, it is tempting to attribute the causes of the crisis to a misfiring of the engine of capitalism or worse to a confluence of unpredictable global events. This is dangerous. It is also to miss the opportunity that the crisis presents.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
If knowledge is one of the super fuels of change, then another is money. Recent events have shown just how exposed governments can be to financial volatility. The banking crisis of 2008 raises important and urgent questions about an increasingly potent strategic lever—the nature of global capitalism that governments seek to foster.
A 2009 survey of professional risk managers makes interesting reading.11 It concludes that the crisis was entirely avoidable. Only 3 respondents out of 563 agreed with the then UK Prime Minister Gordon Brown that the most important cause of the crisis was “global economic circumstances beyond anyone’s control.” The most remarkable finding of the survey was that most risk professionals—on the whole a highly analytical group—believed
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 77
1/16/2011 5:23:40 PM
Leading smart transformation
78
The picture that emerges from the survey is clear. Most risk professionals saw the technical factors, which might cause a crisis, well in advance. These included easy availability of global capital, excessive leverage and accounting standards, which permitted over-valuation of assets. The risks were reported but senior executives chose to ignore their warnings and to prioritize sales. The reason that they did so is put down to individual or collective greed, fuelled by remuneration practices that encouraged excessive risk-taking. That they were allowed to do so is explained by inadequate oversight by nonexecutives and regulators and organizational cultures, which prevented effective challenges to risk-taking. Equally clear views are found on what needs to change, both inside firms and in regulation. Internally, the most important area for improvement, say the risk managers, is the culture in which risk management takes place (including vision, values, management style, and operating principles), starting with the adoption of remuneration policies, which discourage shortterm risk-taking. The simple fact is that we cannot trust banking executives to govern themselves and that drastic action is still needed. While major regulatory renewal is taking place in the United States, the EU and elsewhere, so far little has changed. Nothing will really change without cultural change, because the effectiveness of risk management, governance and internal controls depends heavily on the climate in which they take place. Risk culture and ethics need to be at the top of the agenda, both of boards and governmental regulators.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
the banking crisis was caused not so much by technical failures as by failures in organizational culture and ethics.
Beyond shareholder value Beyond its immediate causes, the banking crisis cracks in the edifice of shareholder capitalism. it illustrated the limitations of free markets to investment. If it is allowed to, a pure capitalist
revealed deep In particular, deliver social system would
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 78
1/16/2011 5:23:40 PM
Setting the strategy
79
“The economic crisis has revived the old debate about whether firms should focus most on shareholders, their customers or their workers,” argued the Economist.12 But, strictly speaking, what was operating was not shareholder capitalism. The cult of shareholder value that began in the mid-1970s has been much maligned, when in fact what took place was a distortion of it. The obsession with shareholder value began in 1976, Roger Martin, dean of the Rotman School of Management at the University of Toronto, wrote in the Harvard Business Review.13 He traces its rise to an article by two economists, Michael Jensen and William Meckling, entitled “Theory of the Firm: Managerial Behaviour, Agency Costs and Ownership Structure.” In it, Jensen and Meckling argued that the owners of companies— shareholders—were often poorly served by professional managers running the businesses they owned. The article was widely cited and prompted a move to get managers to focus on creating value for shareholders. Advocates of shareholder value had little time for other people with a stake in the business such as employees, customers, suppliers and society at large. As the Economist noted: “American and British value-maximizers reserved particular disdain for the stakeholder capitalism practiced in Continental Europe in countries such as Germany.” Roger Martin argues that the failure of shareholder capitalism—as evidenced by the financial crisis—means that it should give way to “customer-driven capitalism.” Other commentators prefer to emphasize another stakeholder group. In his book, Employees First; Customers Second, for example, Vineet Nayar, CEO of HCL Technologies, a fast-growing Indian business process outsourcing company, suggests that the interests of employees should come before even customers.14
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
reward the owners of capital above all else. This in itself is probably not desirable for the best interests of a society. However, as many critics have pointed out, the recent excesses cannot even be accurately described as pure capitalism. In many cases, the markets rewarded professional managers and traders for taking huge risks with shareholder’s funds.
But, before we write off shareholder capitalism entirely, the Economist questions whether it has really failed. “The financial
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 79
1/16/2011 5:23:40 PM
meltdown has certainly undermined two of the big ideas inspired by Jensen and Meckling: that senior managers’ pay should be closely linked to their firm’s share price, and that private equity, backed by mountains of debt, would do a better job of getting managers to maximize value than the public equity markets,” it says. “The bubbles during the past decade in both stockmarkets, and, later, the market for corporate debt highlighted serious flaws with both of these ideas, or at least with the way they were implemented.” “A firm’s share price on any given day ... can be a very poor guide to long-term shareholder value. Yet bosses typically had their pay linked to short-term movements in share prices, which encouraged them to take measures to push the share price up quickly, rather than to maximize shareholder value in the long run (by when they would probably have departed). Similarly, private-equity firms took on too much debt during the credit bubble, when it was available on absurdly generous terms, and are now having to make value-destroying cuts at many of the companies in their portfolios as a result.”
Government forces or market forces? So why is the fervent interest in shareholder capitalism of consequence for those in government? Simply, government must set the tone and direction of what matters in a society and what it wishes to achieve and by what means. What we have seen in recent years is governments throughout the world broadly embracing markets without really fully articulating where the boundaries and limitations of markets lie and their bigger purpose.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Leading smart transformation
80
Much has been written in recent years about New Public Management (NPM). Basically, it describes the wave of public sector reforms around the world that started in the 1980s. The fundamental idea underpinning NPM is that market discipline and orientation in the public sector will make government more efficient. NPM was meant to use competition to reduce costs without reducing service provision. The logic was that by exposing public sector organizations to the rigor of market forces, unnecessary bureaucracy and duplication would be stripped
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 80
1/16/2011 5:23:40 PM
Setting the strategy
81
The struggle for balance bedevils governments around the globe. The pendulum continues to move—and in different directions in different parts of the world. Privatization of government remains prominent in Australia, Scandinavia, Eastern Europe, and various Asian and Middle Eastern countries, for example. But elsewhere there are those who believe that NPM has peaked and is now in decline. In the United Kingdom and the United States, for example, the so-called Third Way and ideas associated with Public Value Theory are coming to the fore. These focus on citizenship, networked governance, and the role of public agencies in working with citizens to cocreate public value, generate democratic authorization, legitimacy and trust, and stress the domains within which public managers are working as complex adaptive systems with different characteristics from simple market forms, or private sector business principles.
Next year’s model The current debate about the optimal model is timely. We believe that the business model is central to Smart Transformation for two related but separate reasons. The first is that without an economic engine to power it no transformation can succeed. Very simply, change requires money and resources and they have to come from somewhere. It is absolutely integral to the vision for any country to foster a vibrant and sustainable business model. Public and private sectors need to be in sync.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
out, leading to leaner and more streamlined government. In particular, NPM was supposed to remove the inefficiencies and high costs associated with monopolistic practices. It led to a spate of privatizations and outsourcing of public services across the globe.15
The second reason is a more subtle one. The characteristics of the desired business model will influence the transformation itself. In other words, if a pure shareholder value business model is the goal, then changes in government operations should aim to support the interests of shareholders—through increased tax incentives, for example. If, however, a pure shareholder model is not
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 81
1/16/2011 5:23:40 PM
Leading smart transformation
82
Some believe that the financial crisis was caused by poor implementation rather than a misguided model.16 But we believe there are more deep-rooted issues to address here. Smart transformation is about making a lasting improvement to the machinery of government in order to benefit the citizens of a country. Many of those citizens will be employees, customers, and suppliers. Some will also be shareholders, but not all. The danger with shareholder capitalism is that it elevates the best interests of shareholders above the rest of society. That is even when it is well implemented. When it is poorly implemented, as we have seen in recent years, it has a distorting effect not just on how wealth is distributed but also on how capital is invested. Much is made of how free markets are more efficient, but this is simply not the case when it comes to making the best investments for society. Investment in social infrastructure projects—including roads, hospitals, airports, and education—is often neglected by the operation of untrammeled markets. Such investments take time and often do not yield the best returns to investors. The most striking failure highlighted by the financial crisis is the tendency for the current system of capitalism to maximize short-term benefits for the individuals making investment decisions. Such a system is unlikely to be in the best interests of ordinary citizens. This raises serious questions about the sort of business model—or model of capitalism—governments should seek to foster and support. So, while it is clear that a robust and dynamic business sector is vital to smart transformation, there are very good reasons to consider carefully the nature of that business model. In particular, it is becoming increasingly clear that short-termism can do a great deal of harm. As the debate moves toward notions of more sustainable business—in terms of environmental impact and the impact on local communities—it is also time for governments to think hard about what a sustainable business model will actually mean going forward. The point to understand here is that the business model and the incentives it creates underpin society.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
the intended outcome then shareholder interests will be balanced with the interests of other stakeholders. This goes to the heart of what the leadership of the country is seeking to achieve.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 82
1/16/2011 5:23:40 PM
Setting the strategy
83
To understand this better, let’s step out of the current context and rewind 4500 years.
As we have observed earlier, a dynamic business model is essential to a progressive society. According to Columbia Business School’s Glenn Hubbard and William Duggan, it has been that way since the dawn of recorded history.17 Starting around 2500 BC in Mesopotamia (modern day Iraq), archaeologists have found evidence of a vibrant private sector— including records of loans between individuals; advances paid to citizens by governments for tax payments; and financing merchants for trade. These practices were later adopted by the Phoenicians, Greeks, Persians, and Romans—giving rise to the growth of thriving towns. These commercial centers were the engine of mass prosperity. They enabled large numbers of people to live in relative wealth even while most of the world’s population was struggling to eke out a living. Economic prosperity, stable government, and private business, then, have always gone hand in hand. Interestingly, too, the two most peaceful centuries of the Roman Empire coincide with a business-friendly attitude from Rome. As Hubbard and Duggan point out: “Starting a business was apparently easy. Anyone, including women, non-Romans, and slaves could open one without a restriction. In practice, of course, it was far easier for free Roman men to open a business than for anyone else; the mainstream leaders favored one another, just as they often do today.”
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Business models of the Ancients
“Licencing was also relatively business-friendly. Romans could make, buy, or sell anything without a licence. There was only one major exception: government monopolies. The empire operated its own mines for salt, metal, and marble; bought and distributed grain; and produced uniforms, weapons, and other supplies for its army.” Rome’s legal system also made it relatively easy to register property, and raise finance through credit. The Roman institore
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 83
1/16/2011 5:23:40 PM
Leading smart transformation
84
The Roman business model had its faults, of course. Chief among these, to modern eyes, were its dependence on slavery and its tendency toward judicial corruption. It also suffered from draconian bankruptcy rules, which could force failed entrepreneurs into slavery if they were unable to pay their debts. But, for its time, the Roman business model was extremely developed and enabled the empire to flourish. So what went wrong with the smart Roman government? In the end, arguably, it was the crippling effects of taxes raised to pay for wars that undermined the Roman business model—and ultimately brought the empire to its knees.
Global business model Fast forward to today and it is clear that having an effective business model remains a major factor in social progress. Empires have come and gone. The most enduring—including the British Empire and more recently, the American Empire—have been founded on commerce. The nature of commerce, however, continues to evolve. We have moved from imperial trade routes to global trade. International trade is as old as nations themselves, but in recent decades, advances in technology have changed the scope and method of international trade. Today, when a trader on the New York or one of the other international stock exchanges executes a billion-dollar currency transaction in Hong Kong, his or her actions can have a completely unintended and unconscious impact upon the people of New York, London, Hong Kong or the rest of the world. The increase in international trade and the ease with which it is conducted is one aspect of what we understand as globalization. It goes hand in hand with the liberalization of financial markets, which in turn is also increasing
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
was the equivalent of the modern business manager, running an enterprise for an absentee owner. Although Rome had no equivalent to the corporation that protected investors, it did have a form of business entity—a “society” that collected taxes for government and offered a predictable and stable investment. Romans were able to buy and sell shares in these societies.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 84
1/16/2011 5:23:40 PM
Setting the strategy
85
Globalization—often encouraged by the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund (IMF)—has given more power to transnational corporations. It has also weakened the sovereign power of governments. One consequence is that national economic policies can no longer be decided by government officials alone, but must take account of the interests of multinationals. Some believe that these developments have further exacerbated the shortcomings of shareholder capitalism as it has been practiced in recent years. We believe that there is a growing case for a shift to a new paradigm of socialized capitalism—where the role of capital is for the public good rather than for the enrichment of a selected few. How governments have so far responded to the financial crisis, by injecting huge amounts of public funds to reestablish the security of financial markets, is not addressing the fundamental issue of the role of capital. Rather, it reveals that profits are privatized, and if and when they are jeopardized, losses are socialized.
Toward social capitalism Research by one of the authors (Andrew) suggests that the current model of capitalism as practiced in Anglo-Saxon cultures such as the United States and the United Kingdom in particular, poses a threat to the ability of sovereign governments to drive social progress.18 Globalization encourages the good of capital against the rights of individual nation states to determine their destiny in a similar manner that human rights challenge the rights of the state in favor of the rights of the individual.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
the economic integration between countries, eroding trade barriers and increasing the mobility of goods and services to move between countries.
The “invisible hand” of the market so vividly depicted by Adam Smith cannot be trusted to bring about social justice.19 As Nobel Prize-winning economist Joseph Stiglitz observes: “The reason that the invisible hand often seems invisible is that it is often not there.”20
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 85
1/16/2011 5:23:40 PM
Leading smart transformation
86
The fact of the matter is that market forces are just that— forces created by the operating rules of the market. The question, then, is who makes the rules? The way that most markets operate reflects the best interests of their architects. As such they are imperfect. Most are created by the powerful and favor them. Indeed, the rhetoric of free markets is one way that power elites protect their advantage. Certainly, we should not expect markets to deliver social justice unless they were designed with that purpose in mind. That does not mean we should ignore the need for governance; in fact, the opposite is true. The imperfect nature of markets makes good governance all the more important. Traditionally, we have looked to shareholders and their representatives to provide that governance. Yet there is ample evidence that this is inadequate. Reform of institutional arrangements such as corporate control and governance arrangements often challenges the influence of those groups wielding power so they have an incentive to block change. This is one reason why markets might not adjust sufficiently to changes in economic conditions or the needs of the economy. The power of vested interests distorts the process of evolution—undermining the idea of economic Darwinism. The survival of the fittest is not the reality. Rather, what we see is the survival of the powerful—which is not quite the same thing.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Adam Smith himself was well aware of the limitations of “free” markets. He recognized that markets, by themselves, often destroy the possibility of a decent human existence “unless government takes pains to prevent” that from happening.21 Smith argued that moral will was required to direct market forces. He acknowledged that markets are never perfect, suggesting that an “optimal” range of government interventions can lead to superior, later to be termed Pareto, outcomes.
Capital flows and liberalization Clearly, when it comes to shareholder value, market forces, and responsible governance, governments have a role to play. What
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 86
1/16/2011 5:23:40 PM
Setting the strategy that role is, is open to debate, but governments need to have as transparent and clear a position as possible. Governments need to make it clear what they value and what their vision is. Rather than express a coherent and wide-ranging vision and strategy, governments often settle for initiatives and campaigns to attract foreign investment. This is seen as a good thing. The reality is that, as with other received economic wisdom we have discussed, it is also worth considering the disadvantages, as well as the advantages, of direct investment in determining the wealth of the nation. Foreign direct investment (FDI) refers to the flow of investment from one country to another. For example, when a foreign company buys a UK company investment is seen to flow into the UK. This usually involves participation in management, joint venture, transfer of technology, and expertise. On the other hand, if a UK company invests overseas the FDI effect is negative. Direct investment sounds attractive but in fact it may be unsustainable and unpredictable. As we have seen with Ireland, FDI is a double-edged sword. It can bring economic growth but it can also lead to increased financial volatility. The key issue is how easy it is for investors to exit—in other words how easily they can get their money out. The greatest advantage is gained from infrastructure investment—such as rails, roads, drainage, and so on, which allows that nation to keep the wealth that comes out of the investment. Generally, when a government removes barriers to inward investment, it pursues a business model luring foreign investment and the accompanying benefits. But this also leads to the disruptive impact of foreign-capital mobility during distress conditions, as experienced by Mexico between 1994 and 1995; East Asia (1997–98), Russia (1998), and Brazil (2000). All of these nations experienced the down side of rapid, capital mobility.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
87
As financial markets become more integrated so they become more vulnerable to systemic failure. At the same time, this integration creates global oligopolies, which control the basic decision-making of the world economy. There are clear signs that world markets are increasingly linked and are moving together. These oligopolies are not exclusive to the financial sector but are also involved in industrial production, services, transport and the like.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 87
1/16/2011 5:23:40 PM
Some commentators see the issue of sovereignty as a key roadblock to achieving complete market integration, or globalization, of the economy. There are signs too that some markets are moving in the opposite direction—seeking to decouple themselves from the global ebb and flow. These pockets of resistance may offer the most effective safety valve on a global financial crisis. Some critics of globalization even argue that the collapse of globalization has already begun and that the reinvention of the “world” is occurring. More regulation is not the answer. Rather, basic, common law principles need to be respected. Regulators do not need more power; they need the will to use the power they already have. Markets drive people in business to pursue market share and profits and, in turn, drive business people to respond to these pressures by focusing on ever-shorter time horizons as every business aspires to become a monopoly. Two critical components of effective markets—market vibrancy (competition) and market integrity—ensure the role of the regulator in preventing monopolistic behavior. Concentrated economic resources readily translate into political influence. This situation was one which even the eighteenth-century mercantile economy (see Table 1) recognized. Political power exercised by economic interest is dangerous. Table 1 Paradigm shifts
System
1. Mercantilism (eighteenth century)
2. Laissez-faire capitalism (Adam Smith’s design for the nineteenth century)
3. Neo-liberal capitalism (late, twentieth century)
Structures
Centralized
Decentralized
Decentralized
Political system Markets Role of capital
Authoritarianism Monopoly Autarky (economic self-sufficiency)
Producer– consumer relationship
Producer push (appropriation of the social surplus)
Representative Competitive International interdependence through spatial division of labor Demand pull (consumer sovereignty)
Representative Oligopoly International interdependency through movement of capital Intermediary (through leveraging of debt)
4. Social capitalism (proposed for the twentyfirst century) Regionalized/ decentralized Participative Social Public good (Socialized capital)
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Leading smart transformation
88
Poly-mediary (multiple interest sustainability negotiated)
Source: Knyght, P.R., Kakabadse, N. K., Kouzman, A., and Kakabadse, A., Chronic Failure in Globalized, Oligopolistic Markets: An Urgent case for Socialized Capital, Society and Business Review, to be published 2011.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 88
1/16/2011 5:23:40 PM
Setting the strategy In social capitalism the role of capital is socialized for the benefit of all stakeholders and investment horizons are long term—20 to 100 years and beyond. This model considers capital, as well as corporations, as social entities responsible and accountable to a broader set of actors than just owners—employees, suppliers, local communities and others affected by the behavior of the company. In this view of capitalism, the measure of a company’s usefulness is not whether it creates individual wealth but whether it helps society gain a greater sense of the meaning of community by honoring individual dignity and promotion of overall welfare. If a government aspires to this model, its vision and strategy must be in step with those aspirations.
Smart questions ● ●
●
● ● ●
●
●
●
● ●
●
●
●
What is your strategy? How is it related to your vision? Does everyone internally understand your strategy? Do they understand how it relates to the vision? Do external stakeholders understand your strategy? Have you made it clear how it relates to the vision? How able and willing are you to change strategy if necessary? How are your agencies organized? Are your political leaders sufficiently in touch with the reality of how strategy is put into action on the ground to make it effective? Can they change or adapt political direction because they listen to their senior civil servants and heads of agencies? How should the fragile space between market and nonmarkets be governed/navigated? How do you minimize “the abuse of entrusted power for private gain”? How do you go about business planning in government? What sort of culture have you created in government—is it entrepreneurial, professional, ad hoc, partnership, bureaucratic? How has government balanced the freedom for wealth creation with the meeting of citizen needs? What industry or sector does your region want to be a talent magnet? Has government entered into social partnership arrangements with the financial services sector guaranteeing major
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
89
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 89
1/16/2011 5:23:40 PM
Leading smart transformation
90
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
●
projects over longer-term duration for the benefit of all in the community? Is there the political will to integrate fast money and slow money or is government browbeaten by the large private capital funds to meeting only their needs?
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_05_cha04.indd 90
1/16/2011 5:23:40 PM
CHAPTER 5
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Designing the operating model Replumbing government With the strategy in place and a clear idea of the characteristics of the macro and micro strategic levers, the second part of the cycle is to improve organizational structure and governance to support the effective delivery of the operating model in line with the strategy. The key question the leadership needs to ask is: how should the government be structured and operated to ensure that it is truly fit for purpose today and tomorrow? This includes redesigning the organization and reassigning roles to ensure the transformation achieves momentum. The reality is that governments sprawl. Departments morph into other departments. Clear reporting lines become blurred by the processes of time, ambition, and bureaucracy. It is very hard to take a step back and to consider how an effective organization should be organized and against which benchmarks governments should be measured. In countries around the world a root-and-branch review of the apparatus and organization of government is now required. In one case, a government department was asked to carry out an overview of the existing government to design a blueprint for the future based on best practice models around the world. In designing the new organization structure, the designers derived lessons from more than ten countries. The result was that more than 140 existing federal and local government entities were reduced to less than 50. The new structure target was approved. It sought to address a number of key issues and to embed the policy imperatives. These were: 1. Local government should become more efficient and effective. 91 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 91
1/16/2011 5:23:42 PM
Leading smart transformation
92
The study also identified the blockers to turning these issues into reality. Our studies and experience suggest they are commonplace. They include: ●
●
●
●
●
●
Centralized decision-making: too many operational decisions were escalated to cabinet level, resulting in delays in the decision-making process. Lack of local representation: Limited or no representation of selected federal ministries and entities. Uncommon status (authority versus department): executive government consisted of two types of entities. Authorities had been created to circumvent financial/administrative constraints in the government. Ineffective grouping of functions: Government functions were not grouped in a way that aided their efficient functioning. The grouping of sector planning, regulation, and operational activities was highly ineffective. Fragmentation and duplication: activities across several government entities were highly fragmented, leading to duplication in some areas—and redundancy in support services across all government entities. Lack of interdepartmental coordination: lack of formal interdepartmental coordination and communication between departments.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
2. Local government should be empowered and held accountable for results. 3. Local government should focus on core activities and seek to outsource/privatize all noncore activities. 4. Clear roles and responsibilities should be put in place, duplications eliminated, and customer service levels improved. 5. Local government should seek to attract high-caliber employees.
Changing structure Once again, in considering the structure of government, it is useful to make a clear distinction between those parts of the civil service that are involved in policy development and those
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 92
1/16/2011 5:23:42 PM
Designing the operating model
93
For example, one can think of the traditional civil servant as a man in a dark suit who works in London’s Whitehall. But the reality is that most UK civil servants work in service delivery roles—for example, in job centers and benefits agencies dealing with the unemployed and those entitled to benefits, or tax offices dealing with tax payers. Smart transformation will more often involve the latter group of civil servants in any country. In the UK, recent reforms to the civil service were driven by a need to break it up into more manageable parts. The central civil service would continue to service ministers and manage departments, but other activity would be conducted by executive agencies that would be responsible for service delivery. Each agency would have a chief executive who would be answerable to the minister under the terms of a framework document, which would be published. By 2000 there were 137 executive agencies responsible for some 80 percent of the civil service. They vary enormously in size from the Employment Service with 45,000 civil servants to the National Weights and Measures Laboratory with just 45. This delegation and decentralization of function was designed to “bring a new, more customer-focused approach to individual executive (service delivery) functions within government,” leaving their parent departments to concentrate on policy development. Executive agencies do not usually have their own legal identity, but operate under powers that are delegated from ministers and departments. They have a chief executive who reports to the minister against specific targets. Most agencies receive their funding from their parent department and, although they are required to publish and lay before Parliament separate accounts, these accounts also form a constituent part of their parent department’s accounts.22
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
engaged in service delivery. In other words, we need to distinguish again between the two levels of central government and government departments, agencies, and other entities.
The creation of these agencies was part of an overall strategy that saw the introduction of “quasi-market structures into the public services,” to be achieved by privatization, market testing, and contracting-out.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 93
1/16/2011 5:23:42 PM
Leading smart transformation
94
Out, out This vision of a more market-oriented public service has been the dominant model for the past two decades in many parts of the world. Central to this has been the outsourcing of public services. There is nothing fundamentally new in public bodies outsourcing services. In the United States, the Massachusetts Bay Company incorporated the private Water Works Company to supply drinking water to Boston 350 years ago. According to the National Council for Public-Private Partnerships, the average US city now calls on private entities to help deliver 23 of 65 basic municipal services—everything from wastewater handling to urban development. In Europe, too, the concept of a working partnership between the private sector and public bodies is well established. Compagnie Générale des Eaux (CGE), launched in 1853 and the founders of Veolia Environnement, was contracted to supply water to the city of Lyons. The company was awarded a 50-year contract to supply water to Paris in 1860 and in 1867 won a contract with the municipality of Nantes to clear the streets of manure and refuse and to convert it into fertilizer.23
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
According to the political commentator and academic W.J.M. Mackenzie-Bogdanor, the basic logic for these developments was the simulation of a business situation. “The fundamental leitmotif of the reforms was that efficiency in the public services could be achieved by adapting the methods and practices of the private sector.”
Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) Combining public and private sector resources is often the most effective way—and sometimes the only way—to structure very large-scale infrastructure projects. For example, when London hosts the 2012 Olympic Games, it will be the culmination of a huge public-private sector initiative. The scale of the modern Olympic Games demands public-private partnership to a degree
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 94
1/16/2011 5:23:42 PM
Designing the operating model few other projects can match. The Games are simply too large in every dimension—technological, organizational, broadcasting, project management, merchandizing—for either public or private sectors to take full responsibility. Only the public sector has the financial means to fund substantial capital infrastructure projects; only the private sector has the organizational and entrepreneurial capabilities to make the Games happen against an unmovable deadline. Other large-scale initiatives also require a judicious blending of both sectors. Private-public partnerships (PPPs) are a special kind of outsourcing used by governments. A PPP is basically a transfer of responsibility for a public service project—such as the construction of a large bridge or road network—to a private agency where a government acts as contractor. PPP’s combine the resources of a public sector organization and a private company to provide improved efficiency, better access to capital, as well as compliance. Public-private partnerships are increasingly widespread. In the UK, for example, they have been extensively utilized in improving the performance and infrastructure of the country’s National Health Service. The past 25 years have seen a new phase in the development of PPPs. PPP toll tunnels were built in Hong Kong in the 1970s and American private prison companies were among the first in private provision of correctional facilities in the early 1980s. Today, PPPs are growing fast across the world. When it comes to their usage, the UK is ahead of all other nations. The UK’s use of PPPs has been at the heart of its public service reform agenda. PPPs are a contractual relationship between a government body and a private sector agent to complete a project according to clear criteria.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
95
There are three basic types of PPPs: Type 1: Design-build-finance-transfer. With this sort of PPP, the private sector finances and constructs the asset or project (for example, a large bridge or tunnel), incentivizing the firms involved to complete the project on time and within budget.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 95
1/16/2011 5:23:42 PM
Leading smart transformation
96
Along with their obvious advantages, PPPs also bring some challenges—in particular balancing the need for profit to incentivize the private sector contractors with the requirement to get value for money from government investment. This balance has not always been achieved. In particular, PPPs have been criticized for failing to deliver value, with a number of concerns directed at private sector operators. For example, contractors sometimes refinance their loans in order to increase their profit but without sharing this windfall with government. The terms of interest for the PPP may also be set too high. Government may be held to ransom by each PPP contract because the private contractor can threaten to walk away leaving the government having to spend much more to get in another contractor to repair the situation. Despite these very real challenges, PPPs will become more widespread in future. The critical concern for PPPs is whether there is sufficient political will to support this form of public/private sector financing or not. Without political will PPPs don’t work.
Best of both Combining the strengths of both sectors is essential to the workings of modern society. With technological change and a drive toward greater value for money, outsourcing (including the special case of PPPs) can be a powerful tool for improving effectiveness in public service. Progress, however, comes at a price. There will be failures along the way.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Type 2: Design-build-finance-maintain. With the second sort of PPP, the private sector is responsible for the design, building, and maintenance of the asset, thus taking a much longerterm strategy. Type 3: Design-build-finance-operate. In this case, the private sector designs, builds, and finances a new facility and then manages its operations.
From the mid-1980s the Australian Federal Government embarked on a policy of public service and industry reform. By 2000, the Australian government had outsourced most of its IT
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 96
1/16/2011 5:23:42 PM
Designing the operating model
97
The OECD reports that an array of services are now being outsourced—including international airport operations (outsourced by the city of Indianapolis); IT-based activities outsourced by the UK’s Inland Revenue and tax services elsewhere in the world; cleaning services in Copenhagen hospitals and so on. Research by Cranfield School of Management sought to get to the reality of whether outsourcing actually delivered.24 The research covers public service enterprises in the United States, the United Kingdom, and continental Europe. It found that public service managers are highly skilled in managing outsourcing contracts. But, they remain divided as to the benefits of outsourcing. Truth be told, outsourcing gets a great deal of negative coverage. Sometimes this is entirely justified. The Australian Federal Government’s Department of Immigration and Multi-Cultural Affairs, for example, found that the outsourcing vendor was costing the department more than the cost of maintaining services in-house. Various pieces of research, including the Cranfield study, report that public service managers feel that accountability to the public has been undermined by the disruption arising from what they regard as unnecessary outsourcing of noncritical processes and activities which nevertheless still have a significant effect on the functioning of the organization. Until public service managers think that the process works to the benefit of the community, as well as to the enhancement of public service enterprise, their disillusionment with outsourcing is likely to remain.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
services. Along the way, there were some notable failures. The Auditor General reported that three contracts, worth a total of AU$732 million failed to achieve the projected savings, being two years late in being implemented and three times the original budget.
What is increasingly clear, too, is that outsourcing is only part of the solution. An important element of the operating model is also looking at the reorganization of entities internally. For any organization to be formed—or reformed—a number of fundamental areas need to be addressed. Chief among them are as follows.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 97
1/16/2011 5:23:43 PM
Leading smart transformation
98
●
●
●
How should organizational structures be designed? What should be the guiding principles? (For example, should they be customer based; service/product based; geographical exposure based?) What is the best way to minimize reporting lines and establish synergies between the different divisions? Where does one entity end and another start? Are there opportunities to share capabilities? (There is evidence to suggest that greater efficiency occurs in government restructuring where governments deploy shared services to established cross government synergies.)
Processes ●
What processes should be codified? How much discretion should be allowed?
Infrastructure ●
●
What IT infrastructure should the entity develop—and to what extent is it desirable to outsource that infrastructure? What physical infrastructure is required?
Governance ●
●
What committees should exist to ensure effective governance of the entity? (mandatory and sector specific) What should be the board composition and responsibilities?
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The organizational structure design itself
Manpower planning ●
●
What capabilities and competencies are required for the future? How can we manage talent? (We consider these issues in the next chapter.)
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 98
1/16/2011 5:23:43 PM
Designing the operating model
99
Fast forward—2035 So what’s next? What is the vision for the organization of the public sector in the next two to three decades? Dr. Peter Shergold, the Australian academic and former Secretary to the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet, presented his view in a speech (entitled “The Australian Public Service in 2035: Back to The Future”) in which he made a number or predictions about the Australian Public Service (APS). These included the predictions that: ●
●
●
●
●
●
The size of public services would continue to decline—with the APS declining to a workforce of about 100,000 employees in 2035. Innovations in technology would enable more to be done with less. The development of “a blended, multi-dimensional workforce” in which full-time and part-time employees would work with contract providers and consultants “bound together by the work they do, not their working conditions.” Women would represent approximately 75 percent of the APS—and would be represented across all levels of the service. The problem of relativity of pay between the private and public sectors would remain. The Australian Public Service Commissioner, Lynelle Briggs, has also referred to “the generally lower level of remuneration of APS staff compared with equivalent staff in the private sector.” The career public service would remain. All APS employees would be graduates. In Shergold’s words: “Managing an all-graduate service will present new challenges.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
It is only by addressing these issues that government entities can be constantly reconfigured to ensure they are fit for purpose. But it is important to recognize that organizational redesign does not happen in a vacuum. Again, the notion of soft power is essential to achieve the required change—opening doors and avoiding opposition that could otherwise derail the transformation process.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 99
1/16/2011 5:23:43 PM
Leading smart transformation
100
Shergold also argued that the influence of technology will be uncertain and difficult to envisage, adding: “I do not think it will all be for the better. Dealing with the wicked complexity of public policy will be as slow and difficult as ever but the flow of information and responses to it will be ever more immediate ... Governments and their public services will find it increasingly difficult to meet the expectations of citizens as to what government action can achieve and how quickly ... The job of public servants to identify and promote a national interest may have become even more challenging.” Some things will remain largely unchanged, in his view. For example, the nature of the public service itself—he was of the view that the merit-based and apolitical public service would remain the best model well into the twenty-first century. The Australian Public Service Commissioner, however, noted that decisions would need to be made about the balance between inhouse and external work. In her words: As public servants, we need to identify where collaborations with external stakeholders will add the most value and where work should be done in house. We also need to think about how we can try to loosen some of our controls and guidelines to facilitate more flexibility, innovation and effectiveness on the ground, while retaining high standards of accountability. The more we reduce unnecessary red tape, the better our arrangements will be for everyone.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
The process of dismantling hierarchy as the basis of authority will have continued, driven by similarities in the education level of the workforce, workplace aspirations, flat job structures and communications technology. Employees will all, in a real sense, be managers—managing knowledge, contracts and projects to develop and deliver policy for the government of the day. They will all be expected to behave as leaders.”
Shergold’s prediction was for: “A professional administrative class, willing and able to serve successive governments in a nonpartisan manner, accountable through ministers for ensuring that decisions are taken and implemented in a lawful manner and responsive to the directions set by elected government—these, I
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 100
1/16/2011 5:23:43 PM
Designing the operating model
101
suggest, are values which will retain their virtue in the decades ahead.”
The idea that has largely informed the move to outsourcing and the restructuring of government is reengineering (or business process reengineering as it is also known). This was brought to the fore by James Champy, co-founder of the consultancy company CSC Index, and Michael Hammer, an electrical engineer and former computer science professor at MIT. The roots of the idea lay in the research carried out by MIT from 1984 to 1989 on “Management in the 1990s.” Champy and Hammer’s book, Reengineering the Corporation, was a bestseller which produced a plethora of reengineering programs; the creation of many consulting companies; and a deluge of books promoting alternative approaches to reengineering. (Thanks to the popularity of reengineering, CSC also became one of the largest consulting firms in the world.) More recently, the concept of Business Process Management (BPM) has gained major attention in the corporate world and can be considered as a successor to the BPR wave of the 1990s. BPM’s driving logic is the quest for process efficiency supported by information technology. Like BPR before it, BPM is now accused of focusing on technology and disregarding the people aspects of change. The basic idea behind both BPR and BPM is that organizations need to identify their key processes and make them as lean and efficient as possible. Peripheral processes (and, therefore, peripheral people) need to be discarded. BPR took a more brutal approach. “Don’t automate; obliterate,” Hammer proclaimed. Champy and Hammer defined reengineering as “the fundamental re-thinking and radical re-design of business processes to achieve dramatic improvements in critical measures of performance such as cost, quality, service and speed.”
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Redesigning government
BPR was the sword to cut the Gordian knot of bureaucracy that had become institutionalized in many companies. In particular,
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 101
1/16/2011 5:23:43 PM
Leading smart transformation
102
To start the revolution, it was suggested that organizations take a blank piece of paper and map out their processes. This is undoubtedly a useful exercise. It encourages organizations to consider exactly what are their core activities and what processes are in place, and need to be in place, to deliver them efficiently. It also encourages organizations to move beyond strict functional demarcations to more free-flowing organizational forms governed by key processes rather than fiefdoms. Inevitably, the optimum processes involved more effective utilization of resources. Functional organizations (as opposed to process-based ones) tend to contain elements of self-serving protectionism. Different functions do not necessarily share knowledge or work to the same objectives as other functions. Clearly this is, at best, inefficient. As a result, some stages in processes are eliminated completely. Others are streamlined or made more effective through the use of information technology. Having come up with a neatly engineered map of how their organizations should operate, government departments and other organizations can then attempt to translate the paper theory into concrete reality.
The blank piece of paper problem While its relative simplicity makes it alluring, actually turning reengineering or BPM for that matter into reality is more difficult than its proponents suggested. The first problem is that the blank piece of paper ignores the years, often decades, of cultural evolution which led to an organization doing something in a certain way. Such preconceptions, and often justifiable habits, are not easily discarded. Functional fiefdoms may be inefficient, but they are difficult to break down.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
it advocated that peripheral processes and by implication peripheral employees should be stripped away.
The second problem is that reengineering can appear inhumane. Reengineering, as the name suggests, owes more to visions of the organization as a machine than a human, or humane,
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 102
1/16/2011 5:23:43 PM
Designing the operating model
103
The third obstacle is that government organizations and the civil servants who populate them are not natural revolutionaries. Instead of casting the reengineering net widely they tend to reengineer the most readily accessible process and then leave it at that. Related to this, reengineering usually fails to impinge on management. Not surprisingly, managers are all too willing to impose the rigors of a process-based view of the organization on others, but often unwilling to inflict it upon themselves. In response, James Champy has suggested that reengineering management should tackle three key areas: managerial roles, managerial styles, and managerial systems.
Case study: Reinventing the Bank As an organizational example, let us consider the story of the UK’s Financial Services Authority (FSA). In the general election of May 1997, the new Labour government swept to power in the UK with an overwhelming majority. One of the new government’s first bold actions was to make the Bank of England independent to set monetary policy. In effect, the new government was restoring the Bank of England’s freedom from political interference that had been lost when the Bank was nationalized in 1946. Within three weeks of coming to power, the new government also announced that the eight existing financial regulators in the UK would be merged. In the process the Bank of England would lose responsibility for banking supervision, leaving it free to pursue its primary aim of setting monetary policy.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
system. The human side of reengineering has proved its greatest stumbling block. To reengineering purists, people are objects who handle processes. Depersonalization is seen as the route to efficiency. (Here, the echoes of Frederick Taylor’s management by dictatorship are most obvious.) Similarly, BPM with its emphasis on using technology has also been criticized for dehumanizing work.
At the time, the new regulator did not have a name—it started life under the title of Newco—and had only one employee—its first chairman and chief executive, Howard Davies. In June 2008,
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 103
1/16/2011 5:23:43 PM
Leading smart transformation
104
Prior to its creation, eight different “principal” regulators oversaw operations in the banking, securities, and insurance markets. For large financial services groups, with operations spanning several different financial markets, this meant separate relationships with multiple regulators. A conglomerate such as HSBC, for example, had relationships with four or five different regulators. One regulator acted as the “lead” regulator and coordinated with the other concerned or interested regulators. This process wasted resources for both the industry and regulators and often created conflicts between entities. By 1997, the Bank of England had a specialist bank supervision department staffed by about 450 people (the largest it had been in decades).
Context of change By the late 1990s there was a growing sense that the Bank of England should focus on monetary policy (and abandon bank supervision). It was also clear that having one regulatory entity accountable to Parliament would be easier than tracking the operations of eight different agencies. In 1997, empowered by its electoral triumph, the new Labour government announced the merger of the existing eight financial regulators. The vision was clear and simple: Carve a niche role for the FSA and define how things will work.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
the new regulator, now called the Financial Services Authority, opened for business. The FSA was intended to be a one-stopshop for banking supervision.
From the outset, Howard Davies, the leader of the newly created unified regulator, recognized the importance of the key stakeholders. These were: the Bank of England; the newly created FSA; the Treasury; and the financial institutions (effectively its clients). These clients were heavily engaged through advisory panels, consultation mechanisms, and partnerships in studies. But the FSA often failed to communicate to institutions the role of the EU in the regulatory framework.
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 104
1/16/2011 5:23:43 PM
Designing the operating model
105
“I am a great believer in public/private sector discussion and co-operation at every stage,” he noted. “The word may now be somewhat passé; but the quality and cost of financial regulation matter a great deal to the industry and its consumers—they are the key stakeholders. I have not had time to write about the array of advisory panels, consultation mechanisms, cost-benefit studies and all the rest that the FSA surrounded itself with. But in helping to find the manpower to create a new regulator while keeping the old system running and to build support from the industry and consumers (who eventually will end up paying for the new regulator), the time and effort spent on consultation pays for itself many times over.”
The role of leadership In 1997, when Howard Davies was appointed chairman of the newly formed regulator, it had no name, no employees, and no law governing its operations. Yet, despite this difficult start, Davies managed the long transition period as a member of the tripartite committee until the 2001 Act empowered the FSA. During that period, Davies had to absorb the eight entities and shape the creation of the FSA, while closely coordinating with the two powerful and established partners—the Bank of England and the Treasury. His leadership clearly defined what the FSA would become.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Michael Foot worked at the Bank of England from 1969 to 1998, and on the creation of the FSA from its announcement at end of May 1997 while still a director at the Bank of England to its formal creation in June 1998. He was then appointed as one of three managing directors of the FSA, an appointment renewed in 2001. In writing about his experiences at the FSA, Foot was keen to capture the lessons from the transformation for others embarking on a similar journey.25
“I was not a great believer in ‘leaders make history’ until I worked with Howard Davies in the creation of the FSA,” Michael Foot observed. “There I saw at first hand the value of his insistence in defining what the new body was to be (in the sense of its culture, ‘how we do things around here’) and how this helped us to carve out a new existence. From the first, the FSA was consciously set
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 105
1/16/2011 5:23:43 PM
Leading smart transformation
106
The transformation consisted of merging eight financial regulators—and integrating them into one entity. A year into the merger, the new entity was given the name the FSA but no legislation was enacted to empower the FSA which remained a body in transition for almost 3.5 years (the necessary law was not enacted until 2001). For most of that time, the transformation was governed by a memorandum of understanding (MoU) between the three main stakeholders—the FSA, the Bank, and the Treasury—signed in 1997. A tripartite committee was created and successfully oversaw the transition. The MoU between the three parties included four basic tenets: clear accountability; transparency; no duplication of effort; and regular information exchange. (These tenets are worthy of consideration as the basis of any organization.) The FSA created economies of scale during and after the transition, combining the resources from HR, IT, and support services, for example. As a result of this and other efficiencies, the FSA also managed to keep its fees at a competitive rate. As Michael Foot noted: “The new FSA managed to find some very significant economies of scale even in transition. The eight previous regulators had all had support services for IT and human resources that were just too small. It also proved much easier and far more effective for the FSA to represent UK interests in Brussels and at the huge range of international regulatory meetings than it had been for individual regulators to do so. As a result, and despite operating in a strong financial market where salaries were rising far faster than inflation, the FSA in its early years managed to keep the increase in its fees to no more than the rate of inflation.”
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
up not to be the ‘Bank of England in exile’, or an extension of the old Securities & Investment Board or any of the predecessor bodies.”
Ambidextrous organizations In any process of change—such as that at the FSA—trying to foster a culture that is supportive of innovation and change means wrestling with two diametrically opposed organizational
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 106
1/16/2011 5:23:43 PM
Designing the operating model
107
Organizations that successfully balance the two qualities have been called ambidextrous. The key to success is to empower individuals to make the choices in their day-to-day work that allow them to find the balance. Balance will be an increasingly important quality in government. Indeed, nowhere will balance be more vital than in navigating a particular type of challenge—multiagency collaboration. This is where a large number of agencies work together on a local, national, or global basis.
Tackling wicked issues Multiagency intervention and cooperation is an attempt to effectively combine resources, time, and skills that several organizations can bring to bear on a common problem. Originally, the concept came from particular community developed projects. Today, a multiagency approach is increasingly seen as the only way to address a special type of issue—so-called wicked issues. “The idea of the ‘wicked issue’ has become part of the contemporary currency of public administration and management,” notes an influential 1997 paper on the subject.26 “... they [wicked issues] suggest a special class of policy problem; one without an obvious or established (or even common sense) solution, defying normal understanding—and often not sitting conveniently within the responsibilities of one organization.”
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
qualities—adaptability and alignment. Adaptive organizations have the ability to respond to change, to be nimble, to progress. Alignment is about maximizing the present, leveraging existing ideas, and exploiting markets.
Wicked issues include such disparate challenges as addressing criminal activity, urban regeneration, health inequalities, substance misuse, climate change, and homelessness. Take crime, for example. It has become apparent that crime is a social problem that is best tackled by several organizations (or agencies) working together. Furthermore, collaborative working, where two or more organizations work on a problem simultaneously and in close cooperation, can result in a combined
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 107
1/16/2011 5:23:43 PM
Leading smart transformation
108
Examples of multiagency collaboration from the UK include the Wolverhampton Community Safety Partnership, which is supported by the Probation Service, the local authority, the voluntary sector, and the police. Its directors are drawn from these agencies and the Wolverhampton Chamber of Commerce; Wolverhampton University; the Race Equality Council; Victim Support; the Town Centre Association; City Challenge; the Federation of Tenants Associations; and other bodies. Another example of a multiagency approach is the Thames Valley Partnership. In 1992, the determination to initiate a major crime prevention program brought together senior members of the Thames Valley Police, the Probation Service, the Crown Prosecution Service, the Prison Service, the courts and the local government. These organizations were convinced that progress could best be achieved by partnership between their agencies, together with representatives of voluntary community groups and with the support of the business world. The value of this sort of collaborative approach lies in the combination of resources, time, and skills that several organizations can bring to bear on a common problem or target. After all, no one agency has the monopoly on resources, information, or expertise. There are definite advantages but serious difficulties to this way of working. Multiagency collaboration involves liaison, coordination, cooperation, partnership, and even consortium. Above all, though, it requires the will to tackle important but seemingly intractable challenges—and the leadership to balance multiple interests and stakeholders.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
outcome that is more effective than that of any one organization working in isolation.
Smart questions ●
●
Is your organization fit for its purpose? How would it have to change to meet the new expectations and demands placed upon it? Have you defined an operating model?
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 108
1/16/2011 5:23:43 PM
Designing the operating model
●
●
●
●
●
What would your organization look like if you started with a blank sheet of paper? How hierarchical is your organization? How many layers of management separate you from the customer/citizen? Could your organization be simpler and leaner? What would have to happen to achieve that? What is stopping you changing your organizational structure? Which services that you provide are core and which could be outsourced to deliver better value? Do you face “wicked issues” that require multiagency collaboration? Which other agencies would you need to collaborate with? How could you start that conversation?
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
●
109
10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_06_cha05.indd 109
1/16/2011 5:23:43 PM
CHAPTER 6
Talent scouts Organizational structure and design is critical for smart transformation. But the structure is merely the vehicle for human capital. Like a well-designed car, it is pleasing to the eye but will not take you anywhere without people to drive it. To create and maintain momentum it is vital to build internal human capabilities. Transformation is built and delivered by the people in the organization. The quality or talent of the people working in government departments and agencies is probably the single biggest factor in determining the success of the transformation. The talent challenge spans the entire organization—from the most senior leader down. Many a good leader sees their transformational ambitions thwarted by a lack of talent lower down the organization. It is not enough to simply hope for the best. Effective leaders manage the talent issue to ensure they have the right people and the right capabilities in place to drive change. Just as importantly, they put a strategy in place to ensure that the organization is building the talent and capabilities for the future to sustain the smart transformation. This includes having recruitment targeted at and training for the right skills, but, critically, it also means developing and deepening institutional capabilities especially leadership.
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to ETH Zuerich - PalgraveConnect - 2011-04-01
Developing talent
This chapter examines how to develop a strategic talent management plan to ensure the successful transformation and posttransformation. There are two important points to make right at the start. First, it is already clear that in the future the public sector will have to compete with the private sector for talent as never before. 110 10.1057/9780230306493 - Leading Smart Transformation, Andrew Kakabadse, Mohammad Omar Abdulla, Rabih Abouchakra and Ali Jawad 9780230_243729_07_cha06.indd 110
1/16/2011 5:24:10 PM
Developing talent The days when individuals chose to pursue a career solely in the public sector—typically in the civil service—are largely over. Today’s leading graduates are bombarded with opportunities. The question is no longer whether to join the civil service or, say, a leading management consulting firm. Rather the issue is when and for how long to work in the private sector before switching to a career in the public sector for a time and then perhaps moving back to the private sector again. Indeed, many talented individuals will spend their careers moving continuously between the private, public, and even the not-for-profit sector. The second point, which follows from the first, is that if public sector organizations are to compete for talent with private sector organizations then they cannot hope to win on financial compensation alone. The private sector is more flexible and often better resourced and therefore able to pay a premium for talent. This places special requirements on talent strategies with government entities. In particular, it is vital that they find ways to tap into the ethos of public service to attract, motivate, and retain talent. Soft power once again has an important part to play in attracting and retaining talented individuals. A third point to make at the outset is that a transformation by its very nature will change the capabilities and skills required of the people