^
SpringerWienNewYork
7n[bF[hd[Ypao HeX[hjH[_iY^
A[o^eb[7ffheWY^[i_d D[kheikh][ho Lebkc[? 9edY[fjWdZikh]_YW...
71 downloads
693 Views
16MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
^
SpringerWienNewYork
7n[bF[hd[Ypao HeX[hjH[_iY^
A[o^eb[7ffheWY^[i_d D[kheikh][ho Lebkc[? 9edY[fjWdZikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[
?dYebbWXehWj_edm_j^ CWd\h[ZJiY^WX_jiY^[h ?bbkijhWj[ZXoIj[\WdA_dZ[b M_j^W\eh[mehZXo J[jikeAWdde
Ifh_d][hM_[dD[mOeha
7n[bF[hd[Ypao"C$:$"F^$:$ HeX[hjH[_iY^"C$:$"F^$:$ Ij[\WdA_dZ[b :[fWhjc[dje\D[kheikh][ho" @e^Wdd[i=kj[dX[h]Kd_l[hi_jo CW_dp"=[hcWdo
CWd\h[ZJiY^WX_jiY^[h"C$:$"F^$:$ ?dij_jkj[e\7dWjeco C[Z_YWbKd_l[hi_joe\L_[ddW L_[ddW"7kijh_W
J^_imeha_iikX`[YjjeYefoh_]^j$ 7bbh_]^jiWh[h[i[hl[Z"m^[j^[h j^[m^eb[ehfWhje\ j^[cWj[h_Wb_iYedY[hd[Z" if[Y_ÓYWbbo j^ei[ e\ jhWdibWj_ed" h[fh_dj_d]" h[#ki[ e\ _bbkijhWj_edi" XheWZYWij_d]" h[fheZkYj_ed Xo f^ejeYefo_d] cWY^_d[i eh i_c_bWh c[Wdi" WdZ ijehW][ _d ZWjW XWdai$ FheZkYj B_WX_b_jo0 J^[ fkXb_i^[h YWd ]_l[ de ]kWhWdj[[ \eh Wbb j^[ _d\ehcWj_ed YedjW_d[Z_d j^_iXeea$J^_iWbieh[\[hi je j^WjedZhk]ZeiW][WdZWffb_YWj_ed j^[h[e\$?d[WY^_dZ_l_ZkWbYWi[ j^[h[if[Yj_l[ki[hckijY^[Ya j^[WYYkhWYoe\ j^[_d\ehcWj_edXoYedikbj_d]ej^[hf^WhcWY[kj_YWbb_j[hWjkh[$ J^[ki[e\h[]_ij[h[ZdWc[i"jhWZ[cWhai"[jY$_dj^_ifkXb_YWj_edZe[idej_cfbo" [l[d_dj^[WXi[dY[e\Wif[Y_ÓYijWj[c[dj"j^WjikY^dWc[iWh[[n[cfj\hec j^[h[b[lWdjfhej[Yj_l[bWmiWdZh[]kbWj_ediWdZj^[h[\eh[\h[[\eh][d[hWbki[$ (&&.Ifh_d][h#L[hbW]M_[d Fh_dj[Z_d7kijh_W Ifh_d][hM_[dD[mOeha_ifWhje\Ifh_d][hIY_[dY[!8ki_d[iiC[Z_W ifh_d][h$Wj Jof[i[jj_d]0Ij[\WdA_dZ[b"CW_aWcc[h"=[hcWdo 9efo[Z_j_d]07Zh_Wd9$I[m[bb""/*)'Ij$Ij[\Wd_cBWlWdjjWb"7kijh_W Fh_dj[ZedWY_Z#\h[[WdZY^beh_d[#\h[[Xb[WY^[ZfWf[h IF?D'&./+'-(
M_j^,**<_]kh[i**&_dYebehi
B_XhWhoe\9ed]h[ii9edjhebDkcX[h(&&./(('., ?I8D/-.#)#(''#.)..+#)
<eh[mehZ H[Y[dj WZlWdY[i _d d[kheikh][ho ^Wl[ X[[d Y^WhWYj[h_p[Z Xo W YedijWdj_cfhel[c[dj_dikh]_YWbfh[Y_i_ed$J^[Z[jW_b[ZijkZoe\ c_YheWdWjecoo_[bZ[Z_d\ehcWj_ed[ii[dj_Wb\ehj^[Z[l[befc[dj e\fh[Y_i_edj[Y^d_gk[i1^em[l[h"_jmWij^[WdWjecoijkZ_[Z\eh Y[djkh_[i j^Wj ^Wi X[[d h[#l_i_j[Z cWdo j_c[i m_j^ j^[ W_c e\ i[hl_d] j^[ _ddelWj_l[ _Z[Wi e\ d[kheikh][edi$ Ed[ e\ j^[i[ _d# delWj_l[XWi_YYedY[fji_ij^Wje\c_d_cWb_dlWi_l[d[iiÅWceij _cfehjWdj ^WbbcWha e\ Yedj[cfehWho d[kheikh][ho$ C_d_cWb _d# lWi_l[d[iiYed\ehciYecfb[j[bom_j^j^[Z[i_h[e\Xej^fWj_[dji WdZikh][edijeh[ZkY[ikh]_YWbbo_dZkY[ZjhWkcWjeWc_d_ckc$ 7hWf_Zh[jkhdjedehcWbb_\[_ij^[^_]^[ijW_ce\[l[hofWj_[djWdZ ^_i%^[hikh][ed$ Fhe\[iiehF[hd[YpaoÊimehaWiWm^eb[_ij^[f[h\[Yj_bbkijhWj_ede\ j^_iZ[Z_YWj[ZYh[Wj_l[d[kheikh]_YWbWffheWY^$7ced]^_icWdo WY^_[l[c[dji"j^[YedY[fje\Ça[o^eb[Èikh][ho_ie\[ii[dj_Wb_c# fehjWdY[WiWcW_djeebe\c_d_cWb_dlWi_l[d[ii$IkccWh_p_d]^_i lWij[nf[h_[dY[cWa[ij^_iXeealWbkWXb[\eh[l[hod[kheikh][ed WdZ i[hl[i Wi Wd _dZ_YWjeh e\ j^[ Z_h[Yj_ed e\ fhe]h[ii _d d[khe# ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[i$ J^[ Wkj^ehi ^Wl[ ij_ckbWj[Z WdZ Yedjh_Xkj[Z je j^[ jhW_d_d] e\ cWdod[kheikh][edi_dc_d_cWb_dlWi_l[d[ii$8oZ[cedijhWj_d] j^[X[d[ÓjiWdZjhW_d_d]"Fhe\[iiehF[hd[Ypao_ifheXWXbocWa_d] j^[]h[Wj[ijYedjh_Xkj_edWikh][edYWdfhel_Z[ÅZ_ijh_Xkj_d]^_i ademb[Z][ WdZ j[Y^d_gk[i je cWdo ikh][edi WhekdZ j^[ mehbZ \ehj^[X[d[Óje\]h[Wj[hdkcX[hie\fWj_[dji$?WZc_h[^_c\eh^_i Z[Z_YWj_edWdZ^_iWY^_[l[c[dji$
J[jikeAWdde Fhe\[iiehWdZ9^W_hcWd":[fWhjc[dje\D[kheikh][ho" [Wbj^Kd_l[hi_jo"@WfWd
L
9edj[dji 7XXh[l_Wj_edi
?N
'$& ?djheZkYj_ed
)
($& IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
)-
($'
BWj[hWblWh_Wj_ede\j^[ikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco
++
($(
C[Z_WbceZ_ÓYWj_ede\j^[ikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco
,/
($)
8WiWblWh_Wj_ede\j^[ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^0 j^[ikfhWehX_je#ehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco
.)
)$&
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
/-
)$'
Feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ede\j^[ikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejeco
''-
)$(
J^[YecX_d[Zfeij[h_ehikXj[cfehWb# fh[i_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
')'
)$)
;njhWZkhWbceZ_ÓYWj_ede\j^[ikXj[cfehWb YhWd_ejeco[nfei_d]j^[_dj[hdWbWkZ_jehoYWdWb
;nj[dZ[ZjhWdi#f[jheki#Wf[nceZ_ÓYWj_ed [nfei_d]j^[feij[h_eh\eiiW
'*+
*$&
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
'+/
+$&
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
'-/
+$'
9WkZWblWh_Wj_ede\j^[c[Z_WdikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^ '/+
,$&
F_d[WbWffheWY^
(&+
-$&
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
(('
-$'
J^[Wdj[h_eh\hedjWbikXYWbbeiWblWh_Wj_ed e\j^[_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
(*'
-$(
J^[feij[h_eheYY_f_jWbikXYWbbeiWbceZ_ÓYWj_ed e\j^[_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
(+)
.$&
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^ [nfei_d]j^[bWj[hWbWdZj^_hZl[djh_Yb[i
(,-
H[\[h[dY[i ?bbkijhWj_edYh[Z_ji IkX`[Yj_dZ[n
(.) (/, (//
L??
7XXh[l_Wj_edi 7977'"7("7)"7* Wdj[h_ehY[h[XhWbWhj[hoi[]c[dji 79^7 Wdj[h_ehY^ehe_ZWbWhj[ho 79e7 Wdj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d]Whj[ho 79F Wdj[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii 7FYB Wdj[h_ehf[jheYb_de_Zb_]Wc[dj 87 XWi_bWhWhj[ho 9D? eb\WYjehod[hl[ 9D?? efj_Yd[hl[ 9D??? eYkbecejehd[hl[ 9D?L jheY^b[Whd[hl[ 9DL jh_][c_dWbd[hl[ 9DL%'Å) XhWdY^[ie\j^[jh_][c_dWbd[hl[ 9DL? WXZkY[djd[hl[ 9DL?? \WY_Wbd[hl[ 9DL??? l[ij_XkbeYeY^b[Whd[hl[ 9D?N ]beiief^Whod][Wbd[hl[ 9DN lW]kid[hl[ 9DN? WYY[iiehod[hl[ 9DN?? ^ofe]beiiWbd[hl[ 9I YWl[hdekii_dki 9I< Y[h[Xheif_dWbÔk_Z ;79 [nj[hdWbWkZ_jehoYWdWb =IFD ]h[Wj[hikf[hÓY_Wbf[jheiWbd[hl[ ?79 _dj[hdWbWkZ_jehoYWdWb ?97 _dj[hdWbYWhej_ZWhj[ho ?9F _djhWYhWd_Wbfh[iikh[ ?DEF _djhWefj_Ym_dZem C97C'"C("C)"C*c_ZZb[Y[h[XhWbWhj[hoi[]c[dji CC7 c_ZZb[c[d_d][WbWhj[ho EF97 efje#YWhej_Zm_dZem Ef^j7 ef^j^Wbc_YWhj[ho F97F'"F( feij[h_ehY[h[X[bbWhWhj[hoi[]c[dji F9e7 feij[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d]Whj[ho F9F feij[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii F?97 feij[h_eh_d\[h_ehY[h[X[bbWhWhj[ho FFYB feij[h_ehf[jheYb_de_Zb_]Wc[dj FI9 feij[h_ehi[c_Y_hYkbWhYWdWb I97 ikf[h_ehY[h[X[bbWhWhj[ho II9 ikf[h_ehi[c_Y_hYkbWhYWdWb III ikf[h_ehiW]_jjWbi_dki L7 l[hj[XhWbWhj[ho
?N
A[o^eb[7ffheWY^[i_dD[kheikh][ho
?d ^_i Whj_Yb[ [dj_jb[Z ÇB_c_j[Z ;nfeikh[ _d 9[h[XhWb Ikh][hoÈ" fkX# b_i^[Z_d'/-'":edWbZ>$M_biedgkej[Zj^[\Wcekid[kheikh][ed M_bb_Wc >Wbij[Z" m^e" _d '/(*" [nfh[ii[Z ^_i X[b_[\ Çj^Wj j^[ j[dZ[dYo m_bb WbmWoi X[ _d j^[ Z_h[Yj_ed e\ [n[hY_i_d] ]h[Wj[h YWh[ WdZh[Ód[c[dj_def[hWj_d]ÈQM_bied'/-'S$JeZWo"edj^[j^h[i^ebZ e\j^[j^_hZc_bb[dd_kc"j^_i\kdZWc[djWbf^_beief^oe\c_d_cWbbo _dlWi_l[ j^[hWfo i^ekbZ X[ [cf^Wi_p[Z ceh[ j^Wd [l[d X[\eh[" ef[hWj_d] m_j^ W c_d_ckc e\ _Wjhe][d_Y jhWkcW WdZ WY^_[l_d] W cWn_ckce\[\ÓY_[dYo$ ?d j^_i Óhij lebkc[ e\ ekh fkXb_YWj_ed" m[ _dj[dZ je Z[cedijhWj[ Z_\\[h[dj a[o^eb[ WffheWY^[i \eh j^[ ikh]_YWb jh[Wjc[dj e\ _djhW# YhWd_Wb WdZ iakbb XWi[ b[i_edi$ ;WY^ Y^Wfj[h Z[iYh_X[i j^[ ^_ijeh_# YWb Z[l[befc[dj e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco" j^[ WdWjec_YWb YedijhkYj_ed e\j^[jWh][jh[]_edWdZ"ceij_cfehjWdjbo"j^[ikh]_YWbWffheWY^$ 9edY[djhWj_d]edikh]_YWbfhWYj_Y["fWj_[djfei_j_ed_d]WdZeh_[djW# j_edXWi[Zedikf[hÓY_WbWdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhai"j^[ijW][ie\j^[ YhWd_ejeco"_djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed"WdZmekdZYbeikh[Wh[Z[iYh_X[Z _d Z[jW_b$ :[Wb_d] m_j^ Z_\\[h[dj WffheWY^[i" W Yedi[gk[dj mWo" fWj_[djÊifei_j_ed_d]WdZj^[[njhWZkhWbijW][ie\j^[YhWd_ejeco Wh[_bbkijhWj[Zm_j^Whj_ij_YZhWm_d]iWdZj^[_djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed m_j^ \h[i^ ^kcWd YWZWl[hi$ Fej[dj_Wb [hhehi" j^[_h Yedi[gk[dY[i WdZ_cfehjWdjj_fiWdZjh_YaiWh[Wbie]_l[d"fhel_Z_d]_dijhkYj_edi \eh[l[hoZWoki[$ ?d j^[ i[YedZ lebkc[ e\ j^[ Xeea" iY^[Zkb[Z je Wff[Wh _d (&&." m[ m_bb fh[i[dj Z[cedijhWj_l[ ef[hWj_l[ YWi[i jh[Wj[Z l_W a[o# ^eb[WffheWY^[i$FWj_[dj^_ijeho"c[Z_YWbh[fehjiWdZd[khebe]_YWb Wff[WhWdY[m_bbX[Z[iYh_X[Z1if[Y_WbWjj[dj_edm_bbX[]_l[djefh[# ef[hWj_l[d[khehWZ_ebe]_YWbZ_W]deij_Yi"[$]$"Yecfkj[Zjece]hWf^o 9J"cW]d[j_Yh[iedWdY[CHjece]hWf^o_dYbkZ_d]CHWd]_e]hW# f^oWdZ\kdYj_edWb_cW]_d]"WdZ"_\f[h\ehc[Z"Z_]_jWbikXjhWYj_ed Wd]_e]hWf^o:I7$J^h[[#Z_c[di_edWbfh[ef[hWj_l[WffheWY^fbWd# d_d]m_bbX[Z_iYkii[Z"_dfWhj_YkbWhki_d]ij[h[eiYef_Y[lWbkWj_ede\ j^[hWZ_ebe]_YWbZWjW_dl_hjkWbh[Wb_jo$E\Yekhi["c_d_cWbbo_dlWi_l[ a[o^eb[ ikh][ho m_j^ m[bb ZeYkc[dj[Z _djhW# WdZ feijef[hWj_l[ Yekhi[e\[WY^fWj_[djm_bbX[fh[i[dj[Z_dZ[jW_b$
'
?djheZkYj_ed
'$& ?djheZkYj_ed
;lebkj_ede\d[kheikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[i0\heccWYhe# ikh][hojej^[c_d_cWbbo_dlWi_l[a[o^eb[ikh][ho
<_]$'$&$' :WdZoÊi \hedjej[cfehWb YhWd_ejeco [nfei_d] i[bbWh WdZ fWhWi[bbWh b[i_edi$ Dej[ j^[ [nj[di_l[ [nfbehW# j_edYWki_d]kdWle_ZWXb[_d`khojej^[Yehj_YWbikh\WY[$?d j^[ '/(&i WdZ '/)&i" YhWd_ejec_[i e\ j^_i i_p[ m[h[ d[Y# [iiWho je Xh_d] [dek]^ b_]^j _dje Z[[f#i[Wj[Z Wh[Wi \eh cWd_fkbWj_edm_j^cWYheikh]_YWb_dijhkc[dji$Dej[j^Wj WffheWY^_d] W f_jk_jWho jkceh" :WdZo i[l[h[Z j^[ b[\j 9D??jeeXjW_defj_YWbced_jeh_d]e\jkcehh[celWb$
7ffhen_cWj[bo ed[ ^kdZh[Z o[Whi W]e" d[kheikh]_YWb j^[hWfo e\ _djhWYhWd_Wb b[i_edi mWi f[h\ehc[Z m_j^ [nj[dZ[Z YhWd_ejec_[i <_]$'$&$'$7jj^Wjj_c["ikY^bWh][WffheWY^[im[h[d[Y[iiWho\eh i[l[hWb h[Wiedi$ <_hij" ed WYYekdj e\ ifWhi[ WdZ i_cfb[ Z_W]deij_Y j[Y^d_gk[i" j^[ i_p[ WdZ i_j[ e\ fWj^ebe]_YWb b[i_edi YekbZ dej X[ WYYkhWj[bo Z[j[hc_d[Z1 j^[h[\eh[" j^[ YhWd_ejeco ^WZ je X[ bWh][ [dek]^ je ÓdZ j^[ b[i_ed m_j^_d j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb ifWY[$ I[YedZ" X[YWki[ e\ j^[ kdZ[l[bef[Z Wjj_jkZ[ jemWhZ ^[Wbj^ fheXb[ci" _djhWYhWd_Wb b[i_edi m[h[ edbo Z_W]dei[Z m^[d j^[o ^WZ h[WY^[Z _cc[di[i_p[i1j^[h[\eh["j^[YhWd_ejeco^WZjeX[bWh][[dek]^je h[cel[j^[i[bWh]["ifWY[#eYYkfo_d]jkcehi$J^_hZ"_bbkc_dWj_ed_d ef[hWj_d]j^[Wj[himWifeeh1j^[h[\eh["j^[YhWd_Wbef[d_d]^WZje X[bWh][[dek]^jeXh_d]b_]^j_djej^[ikh]_YWbÓ[bZ$<ekhj^"_dijhk# c[djiWjj^Wjj_c[m[h[dejZ[i_]d[Z\ehd[kheikh][hoXkj\eh][d# [hWbikh][hoWdZj^[om[h[jeebWh][jeX[ki[Zm_j^_ddWhhemef[d# _d]i$ ?d WZZ_j_ed" d[kheikh]_YWb j[Wci Yedi_ij[Z e\ Wj b[Wij j^h[[ c[cX[hi"j^ki"i_n^WdZiWdZj^[_hbWh][_dijhkc[djieXiYkh[Zj^[ ikh]_YWbÓ[bZWdZj^[YhWd_ejeco^WZjeX[bWh][[dek]^jeWbbem ik\ÓY_[djeXi[hlWj_ede\j^[i_j[$ M_j^j^[[lebkj_ede\fh[ef[hWj_l[Z_W]deij_Yjeebi"_djhWef[hWj_l[ _bbkc_dWj_edZ[l_Y[iWdZd[kheikh]_YWb_dijhkc[dji"j^[Z_iYel[hoe\ \kdZWc[djWbWdWjec_YWbWdZf^oi_ebe]_YWbfh_dY_fb[i^Wl[Wbbem[Z W jh[c[dZeki Z[l[befc[dj _d d[kheikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[i cWa_d] ikY^_dj[hl[dj_edib[iiZWd][hekiWdZb[iijhWkcWj_p_d]<_]$'$&$($
<_]$'$&$( ?d '/)." :WdZo Z[iYh_X[Z j^[ ie#YWbb[Z ^ofe# f^oi[WbWffheWY^"[nfei_d]j^[ikfhWi[bbWhWh[W$Dej[j^[ i_]d_ÓYWdjb_c_jWj_ede\ia_d_dY_i_edWdZYhWd_Wbef[d_d]" ZeYkc[dj_d]:WdZoÊib[Whd_d]fheY[ii_dh[ZkY_d]ikh]_# YWbjhWkcW$J^[_bbkijhWj_edi^emij^[ÓhijYb_ff_d]e\Wd _djhWYhWd_Wb Wd[khoic" YWki_d] eYkbecejeh fWbio Zk[ je beYWbYecfh[ii_ede\j^[9D???$
J^[ Óhij _cfehjWdj \WYjeh _d j^[ Z[l[befc[dj e\ d[kheikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[i mWi j^[ [lebkj_ed e\ fh[ef[hWj_l[ Z_W]deij_Y _cW]_d]$ ?d'/'."hWZ_e]hWf^_Yj[Y^d_gk[im[h[_djheZkY[Z_djed[kheikh][ho XoMWbj[h;$:WdZoQ:WdZo'/')S$M_j^j^[^[bfe\W_h_d`[Yj_edWdZ ÔkeheiYefoe\j^[l[djh_Yb[ioij[cZkh_d]j^[ie#YWbb[Zl[djh_Ykbe# ]hWf^o" ^[ mWi WXb[ je Z[cedijhWj[ j^[ Z[\ehc[Z WdZ Z_bWj[Z l[djh_Yb[i WdZ l[h_\o j^[ Z_W]dei_i <_]$ '$&$)$ 7 \khj^[h c_b[ijed[ mWi WY^_[l[Z m^[d ;Z]Wh Ced_p Z[iYh_X[Z j^[ j[Y^d_gk[ e\ Y[h[XhWb Wd]_e]hWf^o m^_Y^ ^[ YWbb[Z ÇWhj[h_Wb [dY[f^Wbe]hWf^oÈ <_]$'$&$*$?d'/(-"W\j[h[nf[h_c[djiedWd_cWbceZ[biWdZYWZWl[hi"
)
?djheZkYj_ed
^[ mWi WXb[ je i^em _djhWYhWd_Wb l[ii[bi e\ W (o[Wh#ebZ fWj_[dj QCed_p'/(-S$ ?d'/)("DehcWdC$:ejjZ[cedijhWj[Zj^[Óhijf_Yjkh[e\Wd_djhW# YhWd_Wb Wd[khoic WdZ >[hX[hj Eb_l[YhedW fkXb_i^[Z ^_i [nf[h_# [dY[edj^[Wd]_e]hWf^_YWff[WhWdY[e\fWhWiW]_jjWbc[d_d][ecWi Q:ejj '/)(" Eb_l[YhedW '/*)S$ J^[ c[j^eZ e\ Z_h[Yj Whj[h_Wb fkdY# j_edmWi_cfhel[ZXoIl[d#?lWhI[bZ_d][hm_j^WYWj^[j[hh[fbWY[# c[djj[Y^d_gk[m^_Y^mWibWj[hh[Ód[ZXoH[d:`_dZ`_Wdh[ikbj# _d]_dj^[j[Y^d_gk[e\ikf[hi[b[Yj_l[Wd]_e]hWf^oQI[bZ_d][h'/+)" :`_dZ`_Wd '/-+S$ >em[l[h" :WdZoÊi l[djh_Ykbe]hWf^o WdZ Ced_pÊ Wd]_e]hWf^oWbbem[ZedboWd_dZ_h[YjeXi[hlWj_ede\j^[XhW_dm_j^ _ji l[djh_YkbWh Y^WcX[hi WdZ l[ii[bi$ J^[ Óhij Z_h[Yj l_ikWb_pWj_ed e\ XhW_d j_iik[ _dYh[Wi[Z j^[ \khj^[h Z[l[befc[dj e\ Z_W]deij_Y \WY_b_j_[i ki_d] ÇYecfkj[h_p[Z Wn_Wb jece]hWf^oÈ 9J" Z[iYh_X[Z Xo7bb[dC$9ehcWYa"=eZ\h[oD$>ekdi\_[bZWdZ@Wc[i7cXhei[ _d j^[ [Whbo '/-&i <_]$'$&$+$ 7\j[h ckY^ Z[l[befc[dj" cW]d[j_Y h[iedWdY[_cW]_d]CH?[dWXb[Zdejedboj^[fh[Y_i[Z_W]dei_iXkj Wbiej^[WYYkhWj[Z[j[hc_dWj_ede\jefe]hWf^_Yh[bWj_edie\if[Y_ÓY b[i_edije_dZ_l_ZkWbWdWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[iQ>ekdi\_[bZé7cXhei[ '/-)"BWkj[hXkh'/-)":WcWZ_Wd'/--"=ebZic_j^'/--S$
7
<_]$'$&$) L[djh_Ykbe]hWce\WY^_bZik\\[h_d]\heci[l[h[ ^oZheY[f^Wbki$J^_if^eje]hWf^mWifkXb_i^[ZXo:WdZo _d '/') _d ^_i ]hekdZ#Xh[Wa_d] fWf[h ÇL[djh_Ykbe]hWf^o \ebbem_d]j^[_d`[Yj_ede\W_h_djej^[Y[h[XhWbl[djh_Yb[iÈ$
8
<_]$'$&$+ Ed[ e\ j^[ Óhij 9J iYWdi fkXb_i^[Z Xo >ekdiÓ[bZ _d ^_i \kdZWc[djWb Whj_Yb[ Ç9ecfkj[h_p[Z jhWdil[hi[ Wn_Wb iYWdd_d] jece]hWf^oÈ _d '/-) 7$ Dej[ j^[Z_ifbWY[c[dje\j^[l[djh_Yb[iWYYehZ_d]jeWifWY[#eYYkfo_d]Xb[[Z_d]e\j^[ b[\j XWiWb ]Wd]b_W$ 7d [Whbo YehedWh CH? iYWd e\ W YhWd_ef^Whod][ecW \hec j^[ Dejj_d]^Wc\WY_b_jo_d'/.&8$
*
<_]$'$&$* ?d'/(-"Ced_pfkXb_i^[Z_d^_iWhj_Yb[Ç7hj[h_Wb [dY[f^Wbe]hWf^o" _ji _cfehjWdY[ _d j^[ beYWb_pWj_ed e\ Y[h[XhWb jkcehiÈ j^[ Whj[h_Wb d[jmeha e\ j^[ _dj[hdWb YWhej_Z Whj[ho _d (o[Wh#ebZ c[d$ >[ _d`[Yj[Z W )& iebkj_ede\ieZ_kc_eZ_Z[Z_h[Yjbo_djej^[YWhej_Z"m^_Y^ mWim[bbjeb[hWj[ZXoj^[fWj_[dji$
?djheZkYj_ed
<_]$'$&$, IY^be\\[hYWhh_[Zekjj^[ÓhijjhWdiif^[de_ZWb f_jk_jWhoef[hWj_eded',CWhY^'./-$J^[fWj_[djmWiW) o[Wh#ebZ cWd m^e ik\\[h[Z \hec ^ofef_jk_jWh_ic" l_ikWb Z_ijkhXWdY[WdZfhe]h[ii_l[i_]die\[b[lWj[Z_djhWYhWd_Wb fh[iikh[$:[if_j[Wd_dlWi_l[WffheWY^m_j^h[celWbe\j^[ i[fjkc" dWiWb jkhX_dWj[i" [j^ce_Z Y[bbi" WdZ j^[ c[Z_Wb mWbb e\ j^[ b[\j ehX_j" j^[ _djhWef[hWj_l[ eh_[djWj_ed mWi Yecfb_YWj[Z$ IY^be\\[h j^[h[\eh[ c[Wikh[Z j^[ Z_ijWdY[ \hecj^[]bWX[bbWjej^[Wdj[h_ehWif[Yje\j^[i[bbWedW fh[ef[hWj_l[ hWZ_e]hWf^ WdZ ki[Z j^[ c[Wikh[c[dj je ÇiekdZekjÈj^[ikh]_YWbYWl_jom_j^WÇZ_fij_YaÈ$
J^[i[YedZ_cfehjWdj\WYjeh_dj^[[lebkj_ede\d[kheikh]_YWbj[Y^# d_gk[imWij^[Z[l[befc[dje\_djhWef[hWj_l[_bbkc_dWj_edZ[l_Y[i$ JeZWo_j_iWbceij_cfeii_Xb[je_cW]_d[j^Wj>[hcWddIY^be\\[h" Z_h[Yjehe\j^[d[kheikh]_YWbZ[fWhjc[dj_d?ddiXhkYa"7kijh_W"f[h# \ehc[Z^_iÓhijjhWdiif^[de_ZWbikh][ho_d'/&-m_j^ekjWdo_bbkc_# dWj_edehcW]d_ÓYWj_edjeebi<_]$'$&$,$Iec[o[WhibWj[h">Whl[o 9ki^_d]ki[ZW^[WZ#cekdj[ZbWcf\eh^_ijhWdiif^[de_ZWbcWYhe# ikh]_YWbWffheWY^<_]$'$&$-$7jWXekjj^_ij_c["FWkb9$8kYomhej[ _d^_ifkXb_YWj_edÇD[kheikh][ho_dZWhad[iiÈ"Z[iYh_X_d]Wikh]_YWb fheY[Zkh[e\Ej\h_Z<e[hij[h0ÇJ^[iY[d[mWiWfh_c_j_l[ed[$J^[ edboiekhY[e\_bbkc_dWj_ede\j^[ef[hWj_d]Ó[bZmWiWijkZ[djbWcf m_j^ W XhWii h[Ô[Yjeh$ ?j mWi ^[bZ _d co ^WdZ" m^_Y^ ieed X[YWc[ kdij[WZo ckY^ je <e[hij[hÊi Z_i]kijÈ <_]$'$&$. QIY^be\\[h '/&-" 9ki^_d]'/'*"8kYo'/)&S$
<_]$'$&$. <e[hij[hÊief[hWj_d] j^[Wj[h\eh jhWdiYhWd_Wbikh][ho_d j^[Wkjkcde\ '/)&$FWkb9$8kYo_iedj^[b[\ji_Z[e\j^[f^eje]hWf^_dijh[[jYbej^[i^ebZ_d]W ijkZ[djbWcf$
<_]$'$&$- 9ki^_d]Êi ikXbWX_Wb jhWdii[fjWb WffheWY^ \eh f_jk_jWhojkcehi$Dej[j^[^[WZ#cekdj[ZbWcfWbbem_d] ik\ÓY_[dj_bbkc_dWj_ede\j^[Z[[f#i[Wj[Zikh]_YWbÓ[bZ$
+
?djheZkYj_ed
E\ Yekhi[" j^[ h[Wb h[lebkj_ed _d _bbkc_dWj_ed e\ j^[ ikh]_YWb Ó[bZ mWij^[ki[e\ef[hWj_d]c_YheiYef[im^_Y^[dWXb[Z_dWk]khWj_ed e\j^[c_Yheikh]_YWbWh[W_dj^['/,&iWdZ[Whbo'/-&i$ M^_b[ej^[hikh]_YWbÓ[bZiikY^Wi]od[Yebe]o"khebe]o"WdZ"[if[# Y_Wbboejebe]oWZefj[Zj^[c_YheiYef[\ehZW_bohekj_d[fheY[Zkh[i l[hogk_Yabo"ceijd[kheikh][edim[h[h[bkYjWdjjeki[_j$>em[l[h" :m_]^jFWha_died"ed[e\j^[h[Wbf_ed[[hie\c_Yhed[kheikh][ho fe_dj[Z l[ho Yb[Whbo j^[ WZlWdjW][i e\ j^_i d[m Z[l_Y[0 Ç;Whbo _d '/,& j^[ d[kheikh]_YWb i[Yj_ed Xehhem[Z Wd ef[hWj_l[ c_YheiYef[ \hec j^[ ejebWhod]ebe]o Z[fWhjc[dj$ J^[ c_YheiYef[ fhel_Z[Z ki m_j^ j^[ [dehceki WZlWdjW][i e\ YeWn_Wb _bbkc_dWj_ed" cW]d_# ÓYWj_ed" WdZ i_ckbjWd[eki l_[m_d] \eh j^[ ikh][ed WdZ h[i_Z[djÈ QFWha_died '//+S$ J^[ Óhij d[kheikh][ed m^e ki[Z W ikh]_YWb c_YheiYef[ mWi J^[eZeh[ Akhp[ \eh jh[Wj_d] Wd WYekij_Y d[kh_# decWed'7k]kij'/+-$Akhp[fkXb_i^[Z^_i[nf[h_[dY[i_di[l[hWb fkXb_YWj_ediWced]ijej^[hi_dWdWhj_Yb[[dj_jb[ZÇC_Yhej[Y^d_gk[i _dd[khebe]_YWbikh][hoÈQAkhp['/+-"'/,*S$?d'/,."HeX[hjM$HWdZ WdZ F[j[h @$ @Wdd[jjW cWZ[ Wd _cfehjWdj Yedjh_Xkj_ed je j^[ [lebl_d]Ó[bZe\d[kheikh][hom_j^j^[Whj_Yb[ÇC_Yhed[kheikh][ho0 Wffb_YWj_ed e\ j^[ X_deYkbWh ikh]_YWb c_YheiYef[ _d XhW_d jkcehi" _djhWYhWd_Wb Wd[khoici" if_dWb YehZ Z_i[Wi[" WdZ d[hl[ h[YedijhkY# j_edÈQHWdZé@Wdd[jjW'/,.S$7\j[h[nf[h_c[djWbijkZ_[i"C$=Wp_ OWiWh]_b Z[cedijhWj[Z j^[ kj_b_jo e\ j^[ ef[hWj_d] c_YheiYef[ \eh j^[ jh[Wjc[dj e\ XhW_d jkcehi WdZ lWiYkbWh cWb\ehcWj_edi <_]$'$&$/$@Wdd[jjWh[fehj[Zj^[WZlWdjW][e\j^[ikh]_YWbc_Yhe# iYef[\ehc_YhelWiYkbWhZ[Yecfh[ii_ede\YhWd_Wbd[hl[iQOWiWh]_b '/,,"'/,/"'/-&"@Wdd[jjW'/-&S$
<_]$'$&$/ 7d[WhboEFC??P[_iief[hWj_d]c_YheiYef[m_j^ YWc[hWkd_ji_dfbWY[ki[ZXoOWiWh]_b_dj^['/-&i$
<_]$'$&$'& Akhp[Êic_Yheikh]_YWb[gk_fc[djfkXb_i^[Z_d ^_i f_ed[[h_d] Whj_Yb[ ÇC_Yhej[Y^d_gk[i _d d[khebe]_YWb ikh][hoÈ_d'/,*$
J^[ _djheZkYj_ed e\ c_YheiYef_Y l_ikWb_pWj_ed e\ j^[ ikh]_YWb Ó[bZ mWi \ebbem[Z Xo j^[ _dl[dj_ed e\ WZ[gkWj[ ikh]_YWb _dijhkc[dji <_]i$'$&$'&"'$&$''$J^[j[Y^d_gk[e\X_febWhYeW]kbWj_edmWiikYY[ii# \kbbo WZefj[Z \eh c_Yhed[kheikh][ho Xo @Wc[i =h[[dmeeZ WdZ B[edWhZ CWb_i" WdZ Ód[ c_Yhe_dijhkc[dji m[h[ Z[l[bef[Z \eh _djhWYhWd_Wb WdZ if_dWb ki[ QAkhp[ '/,)"CWb_i '/,-"'/-/"OWiWh]_b '/,/S$ :[if_j[ j^[ WXel[ c[dj_ed[Z Z[l[befc[dj e\ fh[ef[hWj_l[ Z_W]# deij_Yi" _bbkc_dWj_ed Z[l_Y[i WdZ c_Yhed[kheikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[i" _djhWYhWd_Wbd[kheikh][homWiY^WhWYj[h_p[Z_dj^['/-&iWdZ'/.&i" WdZWbie_dj^['//&iXobWh]["[nj[dZ[ZYhWd_ejec_[i$
,
<_]$'$&$'' 7 CWb_i X_febWh YeW]kbWjeh \eh d[kheikh]_YWb ki[$ Dej[ j^[ WjjWY^[Z \ehY[fi Wbbem_d] YWh[\kb ikh]_YWb Z_ii[Yj_ed$
?djheZkYj_ed
7
8
9
<_]$'$&$'( IY^[cWj_Y ZhWm_d] Z[cedijhWj_d] j^[ ij[f# m_i[ Z[l[befc[dj e\ j^[ \hedjej[cfehWb ikX\hedjWb WffheWY^$ Dej[ j^[ h[ZkYj_ed _d i_p[ e\ j^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed WdZ YhWd_ejeco YecfWh[Z je :WdZoÊi cWYheikh]_YWb \hedjej[cfehWbWffheWY^7WdZjeOWiWh]_bÊifj[h_edWb YhWd_ejeco ki_d] c_Yheikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[i 8$ J^[ ikfhWehX_jWba[o^eb[YhWd_ejeco"h[fh[i[dj_d] j^[\hedje# XWiWb fWhj e\ OWiWh]_bÊi fj[h_edWb WffheWY^" Wbbemi W cWha[Zbo h[ZkY[Z [nj[di_ed e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco m_j^ ikXi[gk[djbob[iiikh]_YWbZWcW][jej^[[njhW#WdZ_djhW# YhWd_WbijhkYjkh[i9$
>em[l[h" i_dY[ j^[ l[ho edi[j e\ d[kheikh][ho j^[h[ ^Wi X[[d W m_Z[boWYY[fj[Z\WYjj^Wj[nfeikh[e\XhW_dj_iik[\ehi[l[hWb^ekhi Zkh_d] ikh][ho ki_d] j^[i[ [nj[dZ[Z WffheWY^[i WbmWoi c[Wdi _d`khojej^[XhW_dikh\WY[Xodedf^oi_ebe]_YWbikhhekdZ_d]iikY^ Wi heec W_h" _hh_]Wj_ed" Yel[h cWj[h_Wb" eh ifWjkbW fh[iikh[$ Dej[ j^Wj j^[i[ Yehj_YWb c_Yhe_d`kh_[i m[h[ feii_Xbo j^[ h[Wied \eh j^[ fh[l_eki d[Y[ii_jo e\ hekj_d[ feijef[hWj_l[ Wdj_Yedlkbi_l[ c[Z_# YWj_ed _d Wbb fWj_[dji kdZ[h]e_d] _djhWYhWd_Wb ikh][ho$ ?d ehZ[h je ]W_d Wd _cfh[ii_ed e\ Z_c[di_edi e\ Yehj_YWb [nfbehWj_ed WdZ ikh]_YWb jhWkcW" j^[ Wh[W e\ XhW_d ikh\WY[ [nfei[Z \eh W b_c_j[Z YhWd_ejeco e\ Wffhen_cWj[bo ( Yc i^ekbZ X[ YecfWh[Z m_j^ j^[ Wh[W [nfei[Z Zkh_d] W Yedl[dj_edWb YhWd_ejeco m_j^ W Xed[ ÔWf Z_Wc[j[he\Wffhen_cWj[bo.Yc$Ki_d]j^[[gkWj_edh9 \ehj^[ YWbYkbWj_ede\j^[Wh[We\WY_hYb[_dm^_Y^h_ij^[hWZ_kie\WY_hYkbWh Xed[ÔWf"j^[\ebbem_d]h[ikbjiYekbZX[eXjW_d[Z0Wh[We\XhW_dikh# \WY[[nfei[ZZkh_d]Yedl[dj_edWbYhWd_ejecom_j^.YcZ_Wc[j[h0 h9 3*Yc9 3+&$(-Yc91Wh[We\ikh\WY[WffheWY^[ZZkh_d] b_c_j[ZYhWd_ejecom_j^(YcZ_Wc[j[h0h9 3'Yc9 3)$'*Yc9$ M[YWdi[[j^Wj_dY^eei_d]Wb_c_j[ZWffheWY^jeif[Y_ÓYb[i_edi" _j X[Yec[i feii_Xb[ je ZhWcWj_YWbbo h[ZkY[ _d`kho je j^[ Yehj_YWb ikh\WY[$ 7jj^[iWc[j_c["b_c_j[ZYhWd_ejecoh[ZkY[ij^[d[Y[ii_joe\hek]^ XhW_dh[jhWYj_ed$I_dY[;k][d[C$BWdZ_i_d'/)*Z[iYh_X[Zj^[f^oi# _ebe]_YWbhWd][e\YWf_bbWhofh[iikh["_j^WiX[[di^emd_dWdkcX[h e\ [nf[h_c[djWb WdZ Yb_d_YWb ijkZ_[i WdZ ^Wi X[Yec[ W m_Z[bo WYY[fj[Z\WYjj^WjXhW_dh[jhWYj_ed[nY[[Z_d]Y[hjW_db_c_jiYWki[i i_]d_ÓYWdj_djhWef[hWj_l[jhWkcWjeXhW_dj_iik[WdZcWoYWki[f[h# cWd[djd[khebe]_YWbZ[ÓY_jiQBWdZ_i'/)*"7bX_d'/-+"'/--"C_bb[h '/-)" Oeae^ '/.)" '/.-" Hei[dehd '/.+" >ed]e '/.-" 7dZh[mi '//)"em# [l[h"j^[X[ijh[jhWYj_ed_ideh[jhWYj_ed$9Wh[\kbY^e_Y[e\WdWZ[# gkWj["b[ii_dlWi_l[ikh]_YWbWffheWY^m_j^c_d_cWbXhW_d[nfbehW# j_edWdZh[jhWYj_edh[ikbji_dWi_]d_ÓYWdjh[ZkYj_ede\ZWcW][je _djhWYhWd_WbijhkYjkh[i<_]$'$&$'($ ?d'/-'":edWbZ>$M_biedc[dj_ed[Zj^WjÇm[cWa[de\[j_i^e\ a[o^eb[ ikh][ho$ 7 bWh][ Whj[h_el[deki cWb\ehcWj_ed" ^[c_if^[h[Y# jeco"WdZiec[[f_b[fioikh][homekbZY[hjW_dboh[gk_h[bWh][ijWd# ZWhZ YhWd_ejec_[iÈ$ >[ mWi ed[ e\ j^[ Óhij d[kheikh][edi je ki[
-
?djheZkYj_ed
j^[j[hca[o^eb[ikh][hoZ[iYh_X_d]j^[[nj[di_ede\b_c_j[Zjh[f^_# dWj_ediQM_bied'/-'S$ >em[l[h"_j_i_cfehjWdjjedej[j^Wjm_j^j^[[nfh[ii_edÇa[o^eb[È dejedboj^[[nj[di_ede\j^[YhWd_ejecoi^ekbZX[Z[iYh_X[Z$J^[ j[hca[o^eb[i^ekbZ[nfbW_dceh[el[hWYedY[fjWffheWY^_d]fWj^# ebe]_YWb b[i_edi _d Z[Ód_j[ _djhWYhWd_Wb Wh[Wi$ J^[ W_c e\ a[o^eb[ d[kheikh][ho _i dej j^[ b_c_j[Z YhWd_ejeco" Xkj j^[ b_c_j[Z XhW_d [nfbehWj_ed WdZ c_d_cWb XhW_d h[jhWYj_ed$ ?d j^_i mWo" j^[ b_c_j[Z YhWd_ejeco_idejj^[]eWbXkjj^[h[ikbje\j^[f^_beief^oe\c_d_# cWb_dlWi_l[d[ii_dd[kheikh][ho$J^[YhWd_ejecoi^ekbZX[Wib_c# _j[ZWifeii_Xb[jee\\[hc_d_cWbXhW_djhWkcW"Wbj^ek]^WibWh][Wi d[Y[iiWhojeWY^_[l[WiW\[ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_ed$ >[h[ _j _i [ii[dj_Wb je dej_Y[ j^Wj Wbb bWh][ i_p[Z WffheWY^[i _d d[kheikh][ho YWd X[ _cW]_d[Z Wi W i_Z[#Xo#i_Z[ YecX_dWj_ed e\ i[l[hWb icWbb WffheWY^[i <_]$'$&$')$ J^[h[\eh[" _d j^[ fbWdd_d] WdZ f[h\ehcWdY[ ijW][i e\ Wdo c_Yheikh]_YWb WffheWY^" j^[ ikh][edÊiemdYh_j_YWbh[Ô[Yj_ededj^[d[Y[iiWhoWdZkdWle_ZWXb[ cWd_fkbWj_ediWdZ[nfeikh[iZkh_d]W]_l[dikh]_YWbWYY[iim_bbX[ ed[e\j^[ceij_cfehjWdjij[fi_dj^[Z[l[befc[dje\^_if[hiedWb Yecfh[^[di_ede\j^[a[o^eb[YedY[fj_dc_Yhed[kheikh][ho$J^[ ]eWb e\ a[o^eb[ ikh][ho _i je Y^eei[ WdZ f[h\ehc j^[ ceij _Z[Wb WffheWY^ WYYehZ_d] je j^_i Yh_j_YWb h[Ô[Yj_ed Z[f[dZ_d] ed j^[ _dZ_l_ZkWb fWj^eWdWjeco e\ j^[ fWj_[dj Wi m[bb Wi ed _dZ_l_ZkWb f[hiedWb[nf[h_[dY["Wjj_jkZ["WdZYWfWX_b_jo$ ?d Y^eei_d] j^[ Yehh[Yj a[o^eb[ WffheWY^ je W if[Y_ÓY b[i_ed" _j X[Yec[ifeii_Xb[jeZhWcWj_YWbboh[ZkY[j^[i_p[e\j^[YhWd_ejeco m_j^b[iid[[Z\ehZkhWef[d_d]WdZb[iiXhW_d[nfeikh[WdZh[jhWY# j_ed$J^[i[WZlWdjW][ie\c_d_cWbbo_dlWi_l[a[o^eb[c_Yheikh][ho cWoYedjh_Xkj[je_cfhel[Zfeijef[hWj_l[h[ikbji_dYbkZ_d]i^ehj[h ^eif_jWb_pWj_ed j_c[ X[YWki[ e\ h[ZkYj_ed _d j^[ h_ia e\ Yecfb_YW# j_edi ikY^ Wi Xb[[Z_d] eh h[#Xb[[Z_d] m_j^ d[khebe]_YWb Z[j[h_ehW# j_ed" b[WaW][ e\ 9I<" _d\[Yj_ed" iYWh_ÓYWj_ed" WdZ Yeic[j_Y Z_ijkh# XWdY[i$ >em[l[h"j^[ki[e\b_c_j[ZWffheWY^[iYWki[iZ_\\[h[dji^ehjYec# _d]iZkh_d]j^[fheY[Zkh[ikY^Wij^[fh[Z[Ód[Zikh]_YWbYehh_Zeh" Z[Yh[Wi[Z _djhWef[hWj_l[ eh_[djWj_ed" dWhhem l_[m_d] Wd]b[i m_j^ WdWbceijYeWn_WbYedjhebe\j^[c_Yhe_dijhkc[dji"WdZh[ZkYj_ed e\b_]^j_dj[di_jo_dj^[Z[[f#i[Wj[Zef[hWj_d]Ó[bZ$
.
7
8
9 <_]$'$&$') IY^[cWj_Y ZhWm_d] e\ W bWh][ i_p[Z ijWdZWhZ WffheWY^m_j^\kdd[b#b_a[dWhhem_d]e\j^[ikh]_YWbÓ[bZ [nfei_d] Z[[f#i[Wj[Z b[i_edi 7$ ;nj[dZ[Z YhWd_ejec_[i YWdX[Yedi_Z[h[ZWiWYecX_dWj_ede\i[l[hWbb_c_j[Za[o# ^eb[ WffheWY^[i 8$ ;dj[h_d] j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb Y^WcX[h j^hek]^WYehh[Yjbof[h\ehc[Zb_c_j[Zef[d_d]"j^[l_ikWb Ó[bZ i^emi W i[Yjeh#b_a[ m_Z[d_d] 9$ 7 i^ehj Z_ijWdY[ WbbemiWb_c_j[Zel[hl_[m1_dYedjhWij"Wbed]ikh]_YWbYeh# h_ZehjeWZ[[f#i[Wj[Zikh]_YWbÓ[bZe\j[dfhel_Z[iWX[jj[h ced_jeh_d]e\j^[ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_ed$?dcWdoYWi[i"j^_i Yedi_Z[hWj_ed cWo h[ikbj _d j^[ [cfbeoc[dj e\ YedjhW# bWj[hWbWffheWY^[i$
?djheZkYj_ed
FheXb[c? 8[YWki[ e\ j^[ fh[Z[Ód[Z ikh]_YWb fWj^mWo" j^[ Yeh# h_Zeh e\ Z_ii[Yj_ed YWddej X[ Y^Wd][Z Zkh_d] ikh][ho1 j^[h[# \eh[" j^[ YhWd_ejeco i^ekbZ X[ jW_beh[Z [nWYjbo WYYehZ_d] je j^[ fWj^eWdWjec_YWb i_jkWj_ed e\ j^[ _dZ_l_ZkWb fWj_[dj$ ?d j^_i mWo" j^[ a[o^eb[ YedY[fj _i XWi[Z ed W YWh[\kb fh[ef[hWj_l[ ijkZo e\ Z_W]deij_Y _cW][i$ Ki_d] ceZ[hd jeebi" j^[ [nWYj WdWjeco WdZ fWj^ebe]o e\ j^[ fWj_[dj YWd X[ fh[Y_i[bo Z[iYh_X[Z$ 7dWjec_# YWb fWj^mWoi WdZ Yehh_Zehi YWd X[ Z[j[hc_d[Z" fhel_Z_d] efj_cWb WYY[ii je j^[ fWj^ebe]_YWb fheY[ii[i$ 7YYehZ_d] je j^[ _dZ_l_ZkWb fWj^eWdWjec_YWbi_jkWj_edWdZjej^[_dZ_l_ZkWb[nf[h_[dY[e\j^[ ikh][ed"WjW_beh[Z"_dZ_l_ZkWbWffheWY^YWdX[YWhh_[Zekj$J^_i_dZ_# l_ZkWb b[Wij ZWcW]_d] WdZ j^[h[\eh[ c_d_cWbbo _dlWi_l[ WffheWY^ jej^[jWh][jh[]_ed^[bfijeWle_Zh[jhWYj_ede\i[di_j_l[ijhkYjkh[i WdZkdd[Y[iiWho[nfbehWj_ede\j^[Yehj_YWbikh\WY[$
<_]$'$&$'*
fh[Z[Ód[Zikh]_YWbYehh_Zeh
_dZ_l_ZkWbjW_beh[ZWffheWY^
<_]$'$&$'+
b_c_j[Zeh_[djWj_ed
i[b\#cWZ[[nfbehWj_ed _djhWef[hWj_l[_cW]_d] d[khedWl_]Wj_ed
J^[Yedi[gk[dY[e\j^[YedY[fje\j^[_dZ_l_ZkWbikh]_YWbj^[hWfo_i j^WjW\j[hc[j_Ykbekiel[hl_[me\j^[fh[ef[hWj_l[Z_W]deij_YiWdZ fbWdd_d]e\j^[fheY[Zkh["j^[ikh][edi^ekbZf[h\ehcj^[ikh]_YWb WffheWY^^_ci[b\$I[b\#cWZ[ikh][ho_dYbkZ[ii[b\#cWZ[fei_j_ed_d] e\ j^[ fWj_[dj" i[b\#cWZ[ ia_d _dY_i_ed" i[b\#cWZ[ YhWd_ejeco WdZ i[b\#cWZ[ ikh]_YWb [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ jWh][j h[]_ed$ J^[ _dZ_l_ZkWb" c_d_cWbbo _dlWi_l[ WdZ cWn_cWbbo [\\[Yj_l[ ikh]_YWb WffheWY^ je j^[_djhWYhWd_Wbb[i_ed_ij^[Y[djhWbgk[ij_ede\a[o^eb[d[kheikh# ][ho1 j^[h[\eh[ [nfbeh_d] j^[ fWj^ebe]o _i j^[ jWia e\ j^[ ef[hWj# _d]d[kheikh][ed^_ci[b\WdZdejWdWii_ijWdjJ^_ifh_dY_fb[e\j^[ jW_beh[Z c_d_cWbbo _dlWi_l[ a[o^eb[ d[kheikh][ho _i _d Z_h[Yj Yed# jhWijjeWijWdZWhZikh]_YWbj^[hWfol_W[nj[dZ[ZijWdZWhZikh]_YWb WffheWY^[i$ ?dj^_imWo"fh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZi[b\#cWZ[f[h\ehc_d]e\j^[ jW_beh[Z ikh]_YWb WffheWY^ _i j^[ ceij _cfehjWdj fWhj e\ a[o^eb[ d[kheikh][ho<_]$'$&$'*$ FheXb[c?? J^[ i[YedZ ZhWmXWYa e\ a[o^eb[ fheY[Zkh[i _i j^[ Z[Yh[Wi[Z _djhWef[hWj_l[ eh_[djWj_ed$ ?d ekh [nf[h_[dY[" j^[ _dZ_# l_ZkWbfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WYYehZ_d]jej^[_dZ_l_ZkWbfWj^eWdW# jec_YWbi_jkWj_edWdZj^[_dZ_l_ZkWbbof[h\ehc[Z[nfeikh[WYYehZ# _d]jej^[ikh][edi[nf[h_[dY[e\\[hiW\[Z_ii[Yj_edZ[if_j[b_c_j[Z WffheWY^[i$?dWZZ_j_ed"j^[ki[e\dWl_]Wj_edZ[l_Y[i"kbjhWiekdZ kd_ji"_djhWef[hWj_l[9JWdZCH?cWoX[^[bf\kb_\j^[b_c_j[ZYhW# d_Wbef[d_d]^WiYWki[ZWYed\ki[ZWdZfeehboel[hl_[m[Zi_jkWj_ed <_]$'$&$'+$D[l[hj^[b[ii"j^[i[j[Y^d_YWbjeebiYWdd[l[hh[fbWY[j^[ fh[Y_i[WdZfWhj_YkbWhWdWjec_YWbademb[Z][e\j^[jWh][jh[]_ed
/
?djheZkYj_ed
FheXb[c??? J^[dWhheml_[m_d]Wd]b[WdZWbceijYeWn_WbYedjheb e\Z_ii[Yj_edYWki[iWdWZZ_j_edWbfheXb[c$7YYehZ_d]jeekh[nf[# h_[dY["_\j^[YhWd_ejeco_iicWbb[hj^Wd'+cc"j^[_djhWef[hWj_l[ ki[ e\ Yedl[dj_edWb c_Yhe_dijhkc[dji X[Yec[i l[ho b_c_j[Z$ <eh j^_ih[Wied"j^[Z[l[befc[djWdZ_djhWef[hWj_l[ki[e\d[mjkX[# i^W\jc_Yhe_dijhkc[dji"[$]$"iY_iiehi"]hWif_d]WdZYeW]kbWj_d]\eh# Y[fi"Yb_fWffb_YWjehi"_icWdZWjeho\ehf[h\ehc_d]a[o^eb[ikh][ho <_]$'$&$',$ FheXb[c?L J^[ [o[i e\ j^[ d[kheikh][ed ckij X[ WXb[ je i[[ WdWjec_YWb ijhkYjkh[i je iWl[ j^[c WdZ je h[Ye]d_p[ fWj^ebe]_[i je WjjWYa j^[c$ J^[ \ekhj^ cW_d Z_\ÓYkbjo e\ a[o^eb[ WffheWY^[i _ij^[beiie\_djhWef[hWj_l[b_]^jWdZi_]^jj^hek]^j^[b_c_j[ZYhW# d_ejeco" YWki_d] i_]d_ÓYWdjbo h[ZkY[Z efj_YWb Yedjheb Zkh_d] ikh# ][ho$ <eh j^[ fkhfei[ e\ Xh_d]_d] b_]^j _dje j^[ ikh]_YWb Ó[bZ WdZ Yedjhebb_d]Z[[f#i[Wj[Zc_Yhe_dijhkc[djim_j^WdWZ[gkWj[cW]# d_ÓYWj_ed"ikh]_YWbc_YheiYef[iYWdX[[\\[Yj_l[boikffb[c[dj[ZXo j^[efj_YWbfhef[hj_[ie\ceZ[hd[dZeiYef[i<_]$'$&$'-$J^[j^h[[ WZlWdjW][ie\[dZeiYef[iWh[Wi\ebbemi0'_dYh[Wi[Zb_]^j_dj[di_jo" ([nj[dZ[Zl_[m_d]Wd]b["WdZ)Yb[WhZ[f_Yj_ede\Z[jW_bi_dYbei[# kffei_j_edi$J^[Óhijikh][edim^eh[Wb_p[Zj^[b_c_jWj_edie\ikh# ]_YWbc_YheiYef[im[h[M[hd[hFhejj_d'/-*m^[d^[f[h\ehc[Z Z_W]deij_Y[dZeiYef_YY_ij[hdeiYefoe\j^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[" C_Y^W[bB$@$7fkppe_d'/--m^[d^[_djheZkY[Zj^[ie#YWbb[Zi_Z[# l_[m_d] j[b[iYef[" WdZ <Wba Eff[b _d '/.' m^[d ^[ Wffb_[Z _djhW# ef[hWj_l[[dZeiYefoZkh_d]fheY[Zkh[ie\c_YhelWiYkbWhjh_][c_dWb Z[Yecfh[ii_edQFhejj'/-*"7fkppe'/--"Eff[b'/.'S$7bbe\j^[i[ Z[iYh_fj_ediYWdX[h[]WhZ[ZWij^[_d_j_Wj_ede\[dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[Z c_Yhed[kheikh][ho"m^_Y^"Wbed]m_j^ej^[hd[khe[dZeiYef_Yj[Y^# d_gk[i"[nf[h_[dY[ZWh[l_lWb_dj^['//&i$ CeZ[hdj^h[[#Y^_fc_YheYWc[hWim_j^i[fWhWj[jhWdic_ii_ede\j^[ h[Z"]h[[d"WdZXbk[l_Z[ei_]dWbifhel_Z[[nY[bb[dj_cW][gkWb_jo$ J^[ [dZeiYef_Y l_Z[e i_]dWb _i h[YehZ[Z WdZ Z_ifbWo[Z ed W l_Z[e ced_jeh m^_Y^ i^ekbZ X[ _Z[Wbbo fbWY[Z _d \hedj e\ j^[ ikh][ed$ H[Y[djbo"j^[[lebkj_ede\YWc[hWj[Y^debe]o^Wi[dWXb[Zh[fbWY[# c[dje\j^[ef[hWj_d]c_YheiYef[$J^[ie#YWbb[Z[neiYef[[dWXb[i d[kheikh][edi je f[h\ehc Yecfb_YWj[Z YhWd_Wb ikh][h_[i m_j^ekj ki_d]j^[c_YheiYef[0j^[[neiYef[e\\[hil_ikWb_pWj_ede\j^[ikh# ]_YWbÓ[bZÇ\hecekji_Z[È"j^[[dZeiYef[Ç\hec_di_Z[È<_]i$'$&$'/" '$&$(&$ 7 \kjkh_ij_Y effehjkd_jo _i Ykhh[djbo X[_d] Z[l[bef[Z m_j^ ^[WZ#cekdj[Z B9: iYh[[di m^_Y^ Wbbem j^[ ikh][ed je jWa[ ^_i [o[ie\\j^[c_YheiYef[eYkbWhi<_]i$'$&$'."'$&$'/$Ceh[el[h"j^_i
'&
<_]$'$&$',
dWhhemikh]_YWbYehh_Zeh
if[Y_Wb_dijhkc[djWj_ed
<_]$'$&$'-
b_c_j[Zl_ikWbYedjheb
[dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[Z c_Yhed[kheikh][ho
?djheZkYj_ed
Z_ifbWo ioij[c Wbbemi _cfehj_d] e\ Z_\\[h[dj Z_]_jWb _cW][i ikY^ Wi Z_W]deij_Y f_Yjkh[i WdZ _d\ehcWj_ed e\ dWl_]Wj_ed Z[l_Y[i" Z_h[Yjbo_djej^[^[WZ#cekdj[ZB9:iYh[[di$J^[ki[e\j^[f_Yjkh[# _d#f_Yjkh[ceZ[cWoh[ikbj_dWd[\ÓY_[djl_ikWb_pWj_edZkh_d]j^[ ikh]_YWbfheY[Zkh[$
<_]$'$&$'. F^eje]hWf^\hec j^[ef[hWj_d] j^[Wjh[i^em# _d] j^[ _djhWef[hWj_l[ ki[ e\ Wd [dZeiYef[" Z[i_]d[Z \eh _djhWl[djh_YkbWh fheY[Zkh[i7[iYkbWf7="Jkjjb_d][d" =[h# cWdo$ Dej[ j^[ _djhWef[hWj_l[ Wffb_YWj_ed e\ W ^[WZ# cekdj[Z B9: iYh[[d" cWdk\WYjkh[Z Xo L_ijW C[Z_YWb J[Y^debe]_[i" 9WhbiXWZ" 9Wb_\ehd_W" KI7$ J^[ f^eje]hWf^ Yb[Whbo i^emi j^Wj j^[ ikh][ed ^Wi W Yec\ehjWXb[ WdZ [h]edec_Ymeha_d]fei_j_edZkh_d]j^[m^eb[fheY[Zkh[$
<_]$'$&$'/ F^eje]hWf^_bbkijhWj_d]j^[_djhWef[hWj_l[ki[e\Wd[neiYef[Ebocfki 9ecfWdo"Jeaoe" @WfWd WdZ W ^[WZ#cekdj[Z B9: iYh[[d Zkh_d] W a[o^eb[ fheY[# Zkh[$ J^[ ikf[h_eh _cW][ gkWb_jo e\ j^[ [neiYef[ [dWXb[i je f[h\ehc c_d_cWbbo _dlWi_l[a[o^eb[ikh][hom_j^ekj_djhWef[hWj_l[ki[e\Wikh]_YWbc_YheiYef[$
<_]$'$&$(& Fhejejof[Z[cedijhWj_d]WX_deYkbWh[neiYef[m^_Y^m_bbX[Z[l[bef[Z _dj^[ÇC?DEF??IjkZoÈ_dYeef[hWj_edm_j^7[iYkbWf7="Jkjjb_d][d"=[hcWdo$
''
?djheZkYj_ed
=[d[hWbj[Y^d_gk[i\eha[o^eb[d[kheikh][ho F[hiedd[b"ef[hWj_d]j^[Wj[h[h]edec_Yi" WdZ_dijhkc[djWj_ed Ef[hWj_d]j^[Wj[hf[hiedd[b Ef[hWj_d] j^[Wj[h f[hiedd[b fbWo W l_jWb heb[ m^[d f[h\ehc_d] a[o^eb[fheY[Zkh[i$J^[fhef[h[ZkYWj_edWdZjhW_d_d]e\ikh]_YWb Wii_ijWdji"dkhi[iWdZj[Y^d_YWbWii_ijWdjiWh[cWdZWjeho\ehiW\[ _djhWef[hWj_l[YWh[$ J^[Wii_ijWdji^ekbZ^Wl[jhW_d_d]_dd[kheikh]_YWbWdWjecoWdZX[ \Wc_b_Wh m_j^ ][d[hWb c_Yheikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[i$ :k[ je j^[ b_c_jW# j_ede\WffheWY^[i"WdWii_ijWdjÊiZ_h[YjfWhj_Y_fWj_ed_df[h\ehc_d] ikh]_YWb cWd[klh[i X[Yec[i l[ho h[ijh_Yj[Z$ >em[l[h" _d i[l[hWb i_jkWj_edij^[Wii_ijWdjYWd^[bf_dlWh_ekimWoi"_dYbkZ_d]ikYj_ed# _d]"YeW]kbWj_d]"Ykjj_d]WdZ][djboh[jhWYj_d]$J^[d[m][d[hWj_ed e\c_YheiYef[i]_l[ij^[Wii_ijWdjX_deYkbWhl_i_edm^_Y^Wbbemij^[ WiieY_Wj[jemehaWdZWii_ijWj[Wi[$?dekhZ[fWhjc[dj"j^[Wii_i# jWdj_i_dY^Wh][e\X_febWhYeW]kbWj_edWYYehZ_d]jej^[ikh][edÊi WZl_Y[$7Z[l_Y[m_j^le_Y[Yedjhebm_bbX[Z[l[bef[Z_dj^[\kjkh[$ J^[ iYhkX dkhi[ i^ekbZ kdZ[hijWdZ j^[ XWi_Y ]eWb e\ j^[ ikh]_YWb [l[dj WdZ X[ WXb[ je \ebbem j^[ fheY[Zkh[ ed j^[ ced_jeh$ J^[ dkhi[ i^ekbZ X[ \Wc_b_Wh m_j^ j^[ d[kheikh]_YWb [gk_fc[dj WdZ Z[b_l[h _dijhkc[dji je j^[ ikh][edÊi ^WdZi h[WZo \eh ki[ m_j^ekj h[gk_h_d]j^[ikh][edjebeeaWmWo\hecj^[ikh]_YWbÓ[bZWdZj^[ c_YheiYef[$ J^[Y_hYkbWj_d]dkhi[eXjW_did[Y[iiWho_dijhkc[djiWdZiebkj_edi WdZmehaiYbei[bom_j^j^[iYhkXdkhi[$?dWZZ_j_ed"j^[Y_hYkbWj_d] dkhi[i^ekbZX[WXb[jei[jkfc_Yheikh]_YWb[gk_fc[dj"[$]$"c_Yhe# iYef[i"[dZeiYef[i"dWl_]Wj_edZ[l_Y[i"X_febWhkd_ji"9#WhcÔkehe# iYef[jeebi$7iWj[Y^d_YWbWii_ijWdj"j^[Y_hYkbWj_d]dkhi[i^ekbZX[ jhW_d[ZWdZWXb[jeZ[Wbm_j^WdocWb\kdYj_ed_d][gk_fc[dj$ Ef[hWj_d]j^[Wj[hbWoekj JeZWoÊi d[kheikh]_YWb ef[hWj_d] j^[Wj[hi ckij X[ bWh][ [dek]^ je WYYecceZWj[ j^[ fWj_[dj" j^[ ef[hWj_d] f[hiedd[b WdZ ^_]^bo ief^_ij_YWj[Zd[kheikh]_YWb[gk_fc[dj$ J^[XWi_Yeh]Wd_pWj_ede\j^[ef[hWj_d]j^[Wj[h_dekhZ[fWhjc[dj_i i^emd_d<_]$'$&$(&$J^[fWj_[dj_iXhek]^jedj^[ef[hWj_d]jWXb[_d
'(
?djheZkYj_ed
0ORTABLE #4
.URSE )NSTRU
3URGEON
S MENT
TOR
NI -O
PE
SCO
RO -IC
VIG
AT
IO
N
!SSISTANT
%NDO 5NIT
HE
SIA
!NE ST
.A
.EUROMONITORING
<_]$'$&$(' IY^[cWj_Y f_Yjkh[ i^em_d] ef[hWj_d] j^[Wj[h bWoekjm^[df[h\ehc_d]a[o^eb[ikh][ho$
j^[ikf_d[ehfhed[fei_j_edWYYehZ_d]jej^[ikh]_YWbjWh][jh[]_ed$ J^[ikh][edijWdZiZ_h[YjboWjj^[^[WZm_j^^_iWii_ijWdjedj^[ h_]^ji_Z[$J^[iYhkXdkhi[i_jiehijWdZiX[jm[[dj^[ikh][edWdZ j^[Wii_ijWdj"Wbbem_d]fh[Y_i[Wii_ijWdY[$J^[Wd[ij^[i_ebe]_ijm_j^ ^_i[gk_fc[dj_iedj^[b[\ji_Z[e\j^[fWj_[dj$J^_ieh]Wd_pWj_ed Wbbemi\h[gk[djY^Wd][i_dj^[ikh][edÊifei_j_edm^[df[h\ehc_d] a[o^eb[[nfeikh[i$ J^[ c_YheiYef[ _i ed j^[ b[\j i_Z[ e\ j^[ ikh][ed WdZ j^[ l_Z[e ced_jeh_i_dikY^Wfei_j_edj^Wjj^[dkhi[WdZj^[Wd[ij^[i_ebe# ]_ijYWdXej^\ebbemj^[fheY[Zkh[$?\ki[Z"j^[ced_jeh\eh[dZe# iYef_Y l_ikWb_pWj_ed _i fbWY[Z Z_h[Yjbo _d \hedj e\ j^[ ikh][ed$ em[l[h" j^[ h[bWj_ed X[jm[[d j^[ d[khe# ikh][edÊifei_j_edWdZj^Wje\j^[fWj_[dj_iWi[di_j_l[ed[j^Wj_i e\j[d_cfW_h[ZZkh_d]ikh][ho$J^[bWh][dkcX[he\^_]^boief^_ij_# YWj[Zjeebii^ekbZdej^Wcf[h[\ÓY_[dYo_dj^[ef[hWj_d]j^[Wj[h$
')
?djheZkYj_ed
IjWdZ_d]li$i_jj_d]5 8Wi_YWbbo" ef[hWj_d] j^[Wj[h bWoekj WdZ fWj_[dj fei_j_ed_d] i^ekbZ e\\[hWf^oi_ebe]_YWbboWYY[fjWXb[[h]edeco\ehj^[ikh][ed"ef[h# Wj_d] j^hek]^ W b_c_j[Z WffheWY^$ >em[l[h" ikh]_YWb Z_ii[Yj_ed j^hek]^ j^[i[ b_c_j[Z a[o^eb[ YhWd_ejec_[i \h[gk[djbo h[gk_h[i Y^Wd][i _d j^[ ikh][edÊi fei_j_ed m^[d l_ikWb_p_d] Wd [nj[dZ[Z _djhWYhWd_Wb Wh[W WYYehZ_d] je W i[Yjeh#b_a[ m_Z[d_d] e\ j^[ ikh]_# YWb Ó[bZ <_]$'$&$(($ ?d ekh [nf[h_[dY[" j^_i ÇZWdY_d] WhekdZ j^[ jWXb[È_iceh[h[bWn_d]\ehj^[ikh][edm^_b[ijWdZ_d]"[l[dm^[d f[h\ehc_d]bed]WdZj_c[#Yedikc_d]fheY[Zkh[i$<ehj^_ih[Wied" m[ fh[\[h je f[h\ehc j^[ [dj_h[ ikh]_YWb fheY[Zkh[ _d W ijWdZ_d] fei_j_edm_j^ekjj^[d[[Z\ehYecfb_YWj[Z"if[Y_WbboZ[i_]d[ZWdZ j^[h[\eh[[nf[di_l[ef[hWj_d]Y^W_hi<_]$'$&$()$ E\Yekhi["j^[^[_]^je\j^[ef[hWj_d]jWXb[i^ekbZX[WZ`kij[Zje Wle_Z [nY[ii_l[ X[dZ_d] e\ ikh][edÊi XeZo WdZ d[Ya1 j^[ efj_cWb jWXb[^[_]^j_ikikWbboWjj^[b[l[be\ikh][edi[bXem$>em[l[h"_j YWdX[lWh_WXb[WYYehZ_d]jej^[\eYkiZ_ijWdY[e\j^[c_YheiYef[ WdZjej^[if[Y_ÓYYWi[$
7
<_]$'$&$((
8
<_]$'$&$() em[l[h"_dekh[nf[h_[dY["j^_iÇZWdY_d]WhekdZj^[ jWXb[Èm^_b[ijWdZ_d]Wbbemic_d_cWbbo_dlWi_l[fheY[Zkh[i jeX[f[h\ehc[Z_dW ceh[h[bWn[ZcWdd[h$
'*
?djheZkYj_ed
7
8
<_]$'$&$(* F^eje]hWf^i \hec j^[ ef[hWj_d] j^[Wj[h _bbki# jhWj_d]j^[_djhWef[hWj_l[ki[e\Wikh]_YWbc_YheiYef[7 WdZ[dZeiYef[8$Dej[j^[Wffb_YWj_ede\WP[_iiF[dj[he c_YheiYef[ 9Whb P[_ii Ikh]_YWb =cX>" EX[haeY^[d" =[h# cWdo WdZ ^_]^bo ief^_ij_YWj[Z [dZeiYef_Y [gk_fc[dj 7[iYkbWf7="Jkjjb_d][d"=[hcWdo$
7
J^[ef[hWj_d]jWXb[ Fh[i[dj#][d[hWj_edef[hWj_d]jWXb[iWbbemWZ[gkWj[WdZiW\[fei_# j_ed_d]e\j^[fWj_[dje\\[h_d]efj_cWbikh]_YWbWYY[iie\j^[jWh][j h[]_edm_j^ekjfei_j_ed_d]#h[bWj[Zh_iai$?dWZZ_j_ed"ceZ[hd[b[Yjh_Y ef[hWj_d]jWXb[iWbbemW]h[WjWcekdje\lWh_Wj_ed_dfWj_[djfei_# j_ed Zkh_d] j^[ fheY[Zkh[$ Ef[hWj_d] j^hek]^ b_c_j[Z WffheWY^[i m_j^ \h[gk[dj Y^Wd][i _d j^[ Z_h[Yj_ed e\ ikh]_YWb Z_ii[Yj_ed" j^_i feii_X_b_joe\_djhWef[hWj_l[h[ceZ[bb_d]_i[if[Y_Wbboi_]d_ÓYWdj$ J^[ef[hWj_d]c_YheiYef["_djhWef[hWj_l[ki[e\[dZeiYef[i J^[ _djhWef[hWj_l[ ki[ e\ c_YheiYef[i _i cWdZWjeho _d a[o^eb[ d[kheikh][ho$ ?d ekh Z[fWhjc[dj" m[ fh[\[h j^[ P[_ii D9* WdZ P[_iiF[dj[hec_YheiYef[i9WhbP[_iiIkh]_YWb=cX>"EX[haeY^[d" =[hcWdo" m^_Y^ Wbbem f[h\[Yj efj_YWb l_ikWb_pWj_ed m_j^ W ^_]^# gkWb_joZ_]_jWbf^ejeWdZl_Z[eZeYkc[djWj_ed$ J^[ ef[hWj_d] c_YheiYef[ e\\[hi WZ[gkWj[ cW]d_ÓYWj_ed e\ j^[ ef[hWj_l[Ó[bZ_dWij[h[eiYef_YcWdd[hWdZWbbemi_bbkc_dWj_ede\ j^[ ikh]_YWb Ó[bZ$ >em[l[h" Wi WXel[ c[dj_ed[Z" j^[ beii e\ b_]^j _dj[di_jo _d j^[ Z[[f#i[Wj[Z ikh]_YWb Ó[bZ _i W \kdZWc[djWb fheX# b[c$<ehj^[fkhfei[e\Xh_d]_d]b_]^j_djej^[i_j["ef[hWj_d]c_Yhe# iYef[i YWd [\\[Yj_l[bo X[ ikffb[c[dj[Z m_j^ j^[ _djhWef[hWj_l[ ki[e\ceZ[hd[dZeiYef[i<_]$'$&$(*$ J^[ WZlWdjW][i e\ j^[ [dZeiYef_Y _cW][ Wh[ j^[ _dYh[Wi[Z b_]^j YedY[djhWj_ed"[nj[dZ[Zl_[m_d]Wd]b[WdZYb[Whh[fh[i[djWj_ede\ WdWjec_YWbZ[jW_bi_dWYbei[#kffei_j_ed<_]$'$&$(+$
8
9
<_]$'$&$(+ ?djhWef[hWj_l[f^eje]hWf^ii^em_d][nfeikh[e\j^[ikfhWi[bbWhWh[Wm_j^j^[9D??"?97WdZ9D???j^hek]^Wh_]^j#i_Z[ZikfhWehX_jWb WffheWY^$Dej[j^[_dYh[Wi[Zb_]^j_dj[di_joWdZ[nj[dZ[Zl_[m_d]Wd]b[ki_d]Wh_]_Z[dZeiYef[8YecfWh[Zm_j^j^[l_ikWb_pWj_ede\j^[ikh]_YWb c_YheiYef[7$?dYbei[#kffei_j_ed"j^[[dZeiYef[]_l[iWYb[Whl_[me\j^[WdWjec_YWbZ[jW_bi9$
'+
?djheZkYj_ed
J^[ [dZeiYef[ _i [if[Y_Wbbo _Z[Wb \eh eXjW_d_d] W Z[jW_b[Z l_[m e\ ijhkYjkh[i _d j^[ i^WZem e\ j^[ c_YheiYef[ X[Wc$ J^ki" _d i_jkW# j_edi Zkh_d] c_Yheikh]_YWb Z_ii[Yj_ed m^[d WZZ_j_edWb l_ikWb _d\eh# cWj_ede\j^[jWh][jWh[W_iZ[i_h[Zehm^[dWle_ZWdY[e\h[jhWYj_ed e\ ikf[hÓY_Wb ijhkYjkh[i _i h[Yecc[dZ[Z" Wd [dZeiYef[ _i _djhe# ZkY[Z _dje j^[ ikh]_YWb i_j[$ 8ej^ Z[l_Y[i" c_YheiYef[ WdZ [dZe# iYef["ikffb[c[dj[WY^ej^[hZk[jej^[_hZ_\\[h[djefj_YWbfhef[h# j_[i$ H_]_Zb[diiYef[iWh[h[Yecc[dZ[Z\eh;dZeiYef[#7ii_ij[ZC_Yhe# ikh][ho;7CX[YWki[edboj^[fei_j_ede\_dijhkc[djim_j^h_]_Z i^W\jiYWdX[Yedjhebb[Zfh[Y_i[boWdZX[YWki["Wjfh[i[dj"edbob[di iYef[i e\\[h WYY[fjWXb[ _cW][ gkWb_jo$ ;dZeiYef[i m_j^ Wd]b[Z i^W\ji Wh[ fh[\[hh[Z \eh [dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[Z d[kheikh][ho Wi j^[ YWc[hWWjjWY^[Zjej^[[o[f_[Y[Ze[idej_dj[h\[h[m_j^j^[l_ikWb Ó[bZe\j^[c_YheiYef[WdZZe[idejZ_ijkhXikh]_YWbcWd_fkbWj_ed <_]i$'$&$(,Å)&$:_\\[h[djZ[]h[[ie\_dYb_dWj_ede\j^[\hedjb[di e\\[h Z_\\[h[dj l_[m_d] Wd]b[i e\ &" )&" *+ WdZ -&$ ?d WZZ_j_ed" ceZ[hdZ_]_jWbl_Z[ej[Y^debe]o_id[Y[iiWhojeWY^_[l[\kbbki[e\ [dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[Zc_Yheikh][ho$ >[h[ _j _i _cfehjWdj je dej_Y[ j^Wj j^[h[ Wh[ jme Z_\\[h[dj mWoi e\ f[h\ehc_d] [dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[Z j[Y^d_gk[i _d a[o^eb[ d[kheikh][ho$;dZeiYef[#9edjhebb[ZC_Yhed[kheikh][ho;9C e\\[hi[dZeiYef_Yl_ikWb_pWj_ede\j^[ikh]_YWbÓ[bZWYYehZ_d]jeW \h[[#^WdZj[Y^d_gk[$?dj^[YWi[e\b_c_j[Zl_ikWb_pWj_edj^hek]^ j^[ ikh]_YWb c_YheiYef[" j^[ ikh][ed _djheZkY[i j^[ [dZeiYef[ _djej^[ikh]_YWbi_j[$<eh_cc[Z_Wj[efj_YWbYedjhebe\j^[fWj^e# WdWjec_YWb i_jkWj_ed" [$]$" \eh Wbbem_d] fh[Y_i[ jkceh h[celWb eh Yb_f Wffb_YWj_ed" j^[ [dZeiYef[ _i kikWbbo ki[Z edbo \eh W \[m c_dkj[i$J^[[dZeiYef[_i]hWif[Z_ded[^WdZ1_dj^[ej^[h^WdZ _iWikYa[h\ehYedj_dkekiYb[Wd_d]e\j^[iYef[<_]$'$&$(,7$Ki_d] fkh[;dZeiYef_YC_Yhed[kheikh][o;C"j^[[dZeiYef[_iÓn[Z m_j^Wif[Y_Wb^ebZ_d]Z[l_Y["e\\[h_d]X_#cWdkWbZ_ii[Yj_edkdZ[h Wd[dZeiYef_Y_cW][$?dj^_imWo"j^[Çjme#^WdZ[ZÈikh][ed_iWXb[ jeZ_ii[Yjm_j^ekjb_c_jWj_ed_dikh]_YWbcWd_fkbWj_ed$M_j^ekjW c_YheiYef["j^[Ón[Z[dZeiYef[_if[hcWd[djboki[Z\ehWbed][h j_c[Zkh_d]a[o^eb[ikh][ho<_]$'$&$(,8$ J^[ ki[ e\ [dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[Z j[Y^debe]o _d j^[ Yekhi[ e\ c_Yhe# ikh]_YWbfheY[Zkh[im_j^i_]d_ÓYWdjbo_cfhel[Zl_ikWbYedjhebcWo Yedjh_Xkj[jej^[Yh_j[h_We\j^[a[o^eb[YedY[fjm_j^c_d_ckc_Wj# he][d_YjhWkcWWdZcWn_ckc[\ÓY_[dYo$
',
7
8
<_]$'$&$(, ?djhWef[hWj_l[ f[h\ehcWdY[ e\ [dZeiYef[# Wii_ij[Z c_Yheikh][ho ;7C$ Dej[ j^[Çed[#^WdZ[ZÈ ikh# ][ed ki_d] Wd [dZeiYef[#Yedjhebb[Z c_Yhed[kheikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[ ;9C$J^[ [dZeiYef[ _i ]hWif[Z _d ed[ ^WdZ" m_j^j^[ej^[h^WdZWikYa[h_i_djheZkY[Z\ehYedj_dkeki Yb[Wd_d]e\j^[j_fe\j^[[dZeiYef[7$Ki_d]fkh[[dZe# iYef_Yc_Yhed[kheikh][ho;C"j^[[dZeiYef[_iÓn[Z_dW if[Y_Wb ^ebZ_d] Whc" Wbbem_d] X_#cWdkWb Z_ii[Yj_ed$ J^[ Çjme#^WdZ[ZÈikh][ed_iWXb[jemeham_j^ekjb_c_jWj_ed_d ikh]_YWbcWd_fkbWj_ed8$
?djheZkYj_ed
<_]$'$&$(- Fkh[[dZeiYef_Yc_Yheikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_edki_d] W^ebZ_d]Whc"^ebZ_d]Z[l_Y[WdZWd]b[Z[dZeiYef[$J^[ ikh][ed YedY[djhWj[i ed j^[ l_Z[e#ced_jeh1 j^[ ^_]^bo ief^_ij_YWj[Z ioij[c Wbbemi \h[[ X_#cWdkWb ikh]_YWb Z_i# i[Yj_edm_j^ekjki_d]Wikh]_YWbc_YheiYef[$
<_]$'$&$(. >ebZ_d] Whc ki[Z \eh ijWXb[ _djhWef[hWj_l[ ÓnWj_ed e\ j^[ [dZeiYef[ KD?JH79 Whc" 7[iYkbWf 7=" Jkjjb_d][d"=[hcWdo$
<_]$'$&$(/ H_]_Zb[di[dZeief[im_j^&")&WdZ-&l_[m_d]Wd]b[i"[if[Y_WbboYed# i_Z[h[Z \eh [dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[Z c_Yhed[kheikh][ho 7[iYkbWf 7=" Jkjjb_d][d" =[h# cWdo$ Dej[ j^[ Wd]b[Z i^W\j e\ j^[ jeebi" Wbbem_d] \h[[ ikh]_YWb cWd_fkbWj_ed WhekdZWdZWbed]j^[[dZeiYef[$
<_]$'$&$)& If[Y_WbboZ[i_]d[Z[dZeiYef[^ebZ_d]Z[l_Y[D[khe#F_bej"7[iYkbWf7=" Jkjjb_d][d"=[hcWdo$J^[ioij[ce\\[hiWZ[gkWj[ÓnWj_ed"WdZj^[fei_j_ede\j^[ [dZeiYef[YWdX[c[Y^Wd_YWbboh[ceZ[bb[Zm_j^fh[Y_i[Zh_l_d]m^[[bidej[Xbk[" h[ZWdZo[bbemWhhemi$
'-
?djheZkYj_ed
C_Yheikh]_YWb_dijhkc[dji J^[ki[e\c_Yhed[kheikh]_YWb_dijhkc[dji_ieXb_]Wjeho_djh[Wj_d] _djhWYhWd_Wbb[i_edi$>_]^boief^_ij_YWj[Z_dijhkc[djWj_ed_dYbkZ_d] i[b\#h[jW_d_d]h[jhWYjehi"c_YheZh_bbi"A[hh_iedc_YhefkdY^[i"ikYj_ed jkX[i"Ód[X_febWh\ehY[fi"c_YheiY_iiehi"Z_WcedZad_l[i"Z_WcedZ ^eeai"c_Yhe\ehY[fi"c_YheZ_ii[Yjehi"c_YheYkh[jj[i"WdZYb_fWffb_# [hiWbbemiWZ[gkWj[c_Yheikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_edkdZ[hc_YheiYef_Yeh [dZeiYef_YYedjheb$ D[l[hj^[b[ii"m^[dWffheWY^_d]Z[[f#i[Wj[ZWh[Wij^hek]^Wb_c# _j[Z YhWd_ejeco m_j^ W Z_Wc[j[h e\ YW$ '+ je (& cc" j^[ _djhWef# [hWj_l[ ki[ e\ Yedl[dj_edWb c_Yhe_dijhkc[dji cWo X[ W fheXb[c X[YWki[e\j^[dWhhemikh]_YWbYehh_Zeh$<eh[nWcfb["WX_febWh\eh# Y[fi eh W c_YheiY_iieh m_bb X[ Ybei[Z Wj _ji j_f m^[d j^[ jWh][j _i h[WY^[ZX[YWki[_j^WiWbh[WZoX[[dfki^[Zje][j^[hXoj^[[Z][i e\ j^[ icWbb YhWd_ejeco ef[d_d]$ <eh j^_i h[Wied Wi fh[l_ekibo Z[iYh_X[Z" j^[ _dl[dj_ed WdZ _djhWef[hWj_l[ ki[ e\ h[Y[djbo Z[l[b# ef[Zc_Yhe_dijkc[dji_icWdZWjeho\eha[o^eb[ikh][ho$
7
8
A[o^eb[c_Yhe_dijhkc[djiWh[if[Y_WbboZ[i_]d[Zm_j^WjkX[i^W\j Wbbem_d] kd^_dZ[h[Z _djheZkYj_ed e\ j^[ jeeb j^hek]^ j^[ b_c_j[Z YhWd_ejeco <_]$'$&$)'$ JkX[#i^W\j _dijhkc[dji YWd X[ ki[Z _d W ckY^h[ZkY[Zef[hWj_d]Yehh_Zehe\\[h_d]iW\[cWd_fkbWj_edm_j^_d j^[dWhhemikh]_YWbYehh_ZehWdZeXl_ekil_ikWb_pWj_ede\j^[ikh]_# YWbÓ[bZ$8odej_Y_d]j^WjkikWbboedboj^[bWij(Å)c_bb_c[j[hie\W iY_iiehXbWZ[Wh[WYjkWbboki[Z"j^[_hXbWZ[i_p[mWi^[dY[h[ZkY[Z fheZkY_d]_cfhel[Zl_i_ed"hWd][e\cej_edWdZWYY[ii$?di[l[hWb YWi[i"j^[Wffb_YWj_ede\jkX[#i^W\jc_Yhe_dijhkc[dji_ieXb_]Wjeho m^[def[hWj_d]j^hek]^a[o^eb[WffheWY^[i<_]i$'$&$)("'$&$))$ A[o^eb[_dijhkc[djii^ekbZX[YWh[\kbboYb[Wd[ZWjj^[[dZe\j^[ ef[hWj_ed"fhej[Yj_d]i^Whfj_fi"WdZa[fj_dif[Y_WbjhWoij^Wji[f# WhWj[ j^[ Z_\\[h[dj jof[i e\ _dijhkc[dji$ 9Wh[\kb ^WdZb_d] Xo j^[ ef[hWj_d]j^[Wj[hijW\\YWd[b_c_dWj[j^[m[WhWdZj[Whe\i[di_j_l[ c_YheZ[l_Y[i$
'.
<_]$'$&$)' ?djhWef[hWj_l[ ki[ e\ W Yedl[dj_edWb XWoed[j# i^Wf[ZYb_fWffb_[h7YecfWh[Zm_j^WjkX[#i^W\jZ[l_Y[ 8$Dej[j^Wjj^[Yedl[dj_edWbc_Yhe_dijhkc[djih[gk_h[ i_]d_ÓYWdjboceh[ifWY[m_j^_dj^[dWhhemikh]_YWbYehh_# Zeh$ JkX[#i^W\j a[o^eb[ _dijhkc[dji Wh[ Z[i_]d[Z [if[# Y_Wbbo\ehkd^_dZ[h[Z_djheZkYj_ede\j^[jeebj^hek]^j^[ b_c_j[ZYhWd_ejeco$
?djheZkYj_ed
<_]$'$&$)( F^eje]hWf^ i^em_d] W Yedl[dj_edWb XWoed[j# i^Wf[Z Yb_f Wffb_[h 7 WdZ W jkX[#i^W\j _dijhkc[dj 8 [if[Y_Wbbo Yedi_Z[h[Z \eh c_d_cWbbo _dlWi_l[ a[o^eb[ d[k# heikh][ho$Ki_d]b_c_j[ZYhWd_ejec_[im_j^WZ_Wc[j[he\ YW$ '+Å(& cc" jkX[#i^W\j _dijhkc[dji Wbbem kd^_dZ[h[Z l_ikWb_pWj_ed e\ j^[ Z[[f#i[Wj[Z i_j[ WdZ iW\[ cWd_fkbW# j_edm_j^_dj^[dWhhemikh]_YWbYehh_Zeh$
7
8
<_]$'$&$)) 9ecfWh_iede\WYedl[dj_edWb7WdZW jkX[# i^W\j 8 Yb_f Wffb_[h i^em_d] _cfh[ii_l[bo j^[ Z_\\[h[dY[ _d _dijhkc[dj Z[i_]d$ M^[d ef[hWj_d] j^hek]^ a[o^eb[ YhWd_ejec_[i" j^[ ki[ e\ jkX[#i^W\j _dijhkc[dji _i e\j[d eXb_]Wjeho\ehiW\[_djhWef[hWj_l[Z_ii[Yj_ed$
7
8
'/
?djheZkYj_ed
F[h\ehcWdY[WdZj[Y^d_gk[e\a[o^eb[d[kheikh][ho Fh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d] J^[ ]eWb e\ fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d] _i je Y^eei[ j^[ Yehh[Yj WdZ WYYkhWj[mWo"ef[hWj_d]m_j^Wc_d_ckce\_Wjhe][d_YjhWkcWWdZ WY^_[l_d] W cWn_ckc e\ ikh]_YWb [\ÓY_[dYo m_j^ekj c_ii_d] j^[ jWh][jehYWki_d]_d`khojei[di_j_l[_djhWYhWd_WbijhkYjkh[i$ J^[ fbWdd_d] WdZ [n[Ykj_ed e\j^[ WffheWY^fbWo W Yh_j_YWb heb[ _d f[h\ehc_d]c_d_cWbbo_dlWi_l[a[o^eb[WffheWY^[i$J^[icWbb[hj^[ YhWd_ejecoj^[]h[Wj[hj^[d[[Z\ehfh[Y_i[fbWdd_d]WdZi[b\#cWZ[ Yecfb[j_ede\j^[WffheWY^X[YWki[j^[Yehh_Zehe\ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Y# j_edYWddejX[Y^Wd][ZZkh_d]j^[fheY[Zkh[$ J^[ fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d] _i XWi[Z ed j^[ fh[Y_i[ WdZ fWhj_YkbWh WdWjec_YWb ademb[Z][ e\ j^[ jWh][j h[]_ed WdZ ed W YWh[\kb fh[# ef[hWj_l[ijkZoe\Z_W]deij_Y_cW][i$Dejedboj^[Z_W]dei_i]W_di Wfh_dY_fWb_dj[h[ij"j^[jWiae\ceZ[hdd[khehWZ_ebe]oi^ekbZdej [dZm_j^j^[Z[Ód_j_ede\j^[ikif[Yj[ZfWj^ebe]o$J^[]eWb_ije Z[iYh_X[WZZ_j_edWb_d\ehcWj_edYedY[hd_d]WdWjec_YWbZ[jW_bi"dej edboe\j^[b[i_ed_ji[b\Xkje\_jil_Y_d_joWdZe\d[_]^Xeh_d]Xedo" ZkhWb"d[hlekiWdZlWiYkbWhijhkYjkh[i$Ki_d]j^[[nY[bb[djZ_W]dei# j_Y \WY_b_j_[i e\ 9J" CH? WdZ Z_]_jWb ikXjhWYj_ed Wd]_e]hWf^o :I7" ed[^WijeZWoj^[feii_X_b_jojeZ[cedijhWj[j^[if[Y_WbWdWjec_# YWb i_jkWj_ed e\ j^[ fWj_[dj _dYbkZ_d] icWbb Z[jW_bi WdZ [bkY_ZWj[ fh[ef[hWj_l[bo j^[ fh[Y_i[ _dZ_l_ZkWb WdWjeco WdZ fWj^ebe]o$ ?j _i [if[Y_Wbbo _cfehjWdj je Z[j[hc_d[ WdWjec_YWb m_dZemi e\ j^[ ikXWhWY^de_ZWbifWY[ij^Wjfhel_Z[WYY[iijej^[fWj^ebe]_YWbfhe# Y[ii[i$ J^[i[ WdWjec_YWb fWj^i \eh ikh]_YWb Z_ii[Yj_ed i^ekbZ X[ Z[iYh_X[Z fh[ef[hWj_l[bo WdZ X[ _dYbkZ[Z _d j^[ fbWdd_d] e\ j^[ ikh]_YWbfheY[Zkh[$7YYehZ_d]jej^[i[m_dZemiWdZikh]_YWbfWj^i" j^[ b[Wij jhWkcWj_p_d] WffheWY^ je j^[ jWh][j h[]_ed i^ekbZ X[ Z[Ód[Z" m^_Y^ ^[bfi je Wle_Z h[jhWYj_ed WdZ kdd[Y[iiWho ikh\WY[ [nfbehWj_ed$ 9ecfkj[hi^Wl[X[[dki[Z_dYh[Wi_d]boje^[bfikh][edijeWdW# bop[fh[ef[hWj_l[_cW]_d]ZWjW$LWh_ekiYecfkj[hfhe]hWci^Wl[ X[[d Z[l[bef[Z je ][d[hWj[ j^h[[#Z_c[di_edWb h[fh[i[djWj_edi e\ jece]hWf^_Y _cW]_d] ZWjW _d ehZ[h je fbWd d[kheikh]_YWb WffheWY^[i WdZ ceij demWZWoi WlW_bWXb[ _cW][ ]k_ZWdY[ ioi# j[ci e\\[h ikh]_YWb fbWdd_d] jeebi$ 9edY[fjkWbbo" j^[ fbWdd_d] e\ Wikh]_YWbfheY[Zkh[m_j^j^h[[#Z_c[di_edWbYecfkj[h#][d[hWj[Z
(&
?djheZkYj_ed
7
8
ZWjWi^ekbZh[Ô[Yjj^[j^h[[#Z_c[di_edWb_joe\j^[h[WbfheY[Zkh[$ ?dekhZ[fWhjc[dj"m[ki[j^[:[njheiYef[ioij[cLebkc[?dj[h# WYj_edi Fj[$ BjZ$" I_d]Wfeh[" m^_Y^ Wbbemi W ij[h[eiYef_Y Z_ifbWo e\ j^[ fh[ef[hWj_l[ ZWjW WdZ l_hjkWb cWd_fkbWj_ed m_j^ j^h[[# Z_c[di_edWbjeebi_dij[WZe\ceki[WdZa[oXeWhZ<_]$'$&$)*$ ?dj^[:[njheiYef["j^[ki[hmehaim_j^Xej^^WdZi_di_Z[Wij[h[e# iYef_Yl_hjkWbmehaifWY[$J^_i_iWY^_[l[ZXoh[Ô[Yj_d]WYecfkj[h# ][d[hWj[Z )#: iY[dWh_e l_W W c_hheh _dje j^[ ki[hÊi [o[i$ M[Wh_d] b_gk_Z Z_ifbWo i^kjj[h ]bWii[i iodY^hed_p[Z m_j^ j^[ j_c[ ifb_j Z_i# fbWo"j^[ki[hh[WY^[im_j^Xej^^WdZiX[^_dZj^[c_hheh_djej^[ ÇÔeWj_d]È)#:ZWjW$;b[YjhecW]d[j_Yi[diehi_dXej^^WdZiYedl[o j^[_dj[hWYj_edWdZWbbemcWd_fkbWj_ede\j^[)#:ZWjW_dh[Wbj_c[$ Ed[^WdZ^ebZiWd[h]edec_YWbboi^Wf[Z^WdZb[jecel[j^[)#: ZWjW\h[[boWi_\_jm[h[WdeX`[Yj^[bZ_dh[WbifWY[$J^[ej^[h^WdZ ^ebZi W f[d#i^Wf[Z _dijhkc[dj m^_Y^ Wff[Whi _di_Z[ j^[ l_hjkWb h[Wb_jomehaifWY[WiWYecfkj[h#][d[hWj[Z_dijhkc[djWdZm^_Y^ YWdX[ki[Zjef[h\ehcZ[jW_b[ZZWjWcWd_fkbWj_edi<_]$'$&$)*8$ M_j^j^[j^h[[#Z_c[di_edWb_dZ_l_ZkWbWdWjec_YWbZ[jW_bie\Wif[# Y_ÓYfWj_[dj"_j_ifeii_Xb[jef[h\ehcWif[Y_ÓYWdZjW_beh[Zikh]_# YWbfheY[Zkh[h[ZkY_d]j^[ikh]_YWbjhWkcWj_pWj_edjeWd[Y[iiWho c_d_ckcb_c_j$ ?dj^_imWo"fh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]_ij^[ceij_cfehjWdjfWhje\j^[ c_d_cWbbo_dlWi_l[WdZcWn_cWbbo[\\[Yj_l[a[o^eb[d[kheikh][ho$
<_]$'$&$)* 9ecfkj[h WdWboi_i e\ j^[ fh[ef[hWj_l[ _cW]# _d] ZWjW m_j^ j^h[[#Z_c[di_edWb h[fh[i[djWj_ed e\ j^[ fWj^eWdWjec_YWb i_jkWj_ed e\\[hi W ki[\kb jeeb \eh fbWd# d_d] e\ j^[ ikh]_YWb WffheWY^$ F^eje]hWf^ i^emi j^[ Wffb_YWj_ed e\ j^[ :[njheiYef[ Lebkc[ ?dj[hWYj_edi Fj[$ BjZ$" I_d]Wfeh[" \eh m^_Y^ b_gk_Z Z_ifbWo i^kjj[h ]bWii[i Wh[mehd7$J^[ki[hmehaim_j^Xej^^WdZi_di_Z[ j^[ ij[h[eiYef_Y l_hjkWb mehaifWY[1 ed[ ^WdZ ^ebZi Wd [h]e# dec_YWbboZ[i_]d[Z^WdZb[jecel[j^[j^h[[#Z_c[di_edWb ZWjW" j^[ ej^[h ^WdZ ^ebZi W f[d#i^Wf[Z _dijhkc[dj m^_Y^ YWd X[ ki[Z je f[h\ehc Z[jW_b[Z ZWjW cWd_fkbW# j_edi8$
('
?djheZkYj_ed
7
8
<_]$'$&$)+W"X ?bbkijhWj_l[YWi[e\WfWj_[djm_j^Wdkdhkfjkh[ZWd[khoice\j^[ 79e7$9edl[dj_edWb:I7e\j^[h_]^j7WdZb[\j8YWhej_ZWhj[h_[i_dWdj[he#feij[# h_ehl_[mZ[cedijhWj[ij^[Wd[khoic"m_j^j^[Zec[Z_h[Yj[Zjeb[\j$Dej[j^Wjj^[ 7' i[]c[dj e\ j^[ b[\j 797 Wff[Whi ^ofefbWij_Y" cWa_d] _dj[hl[dj_edWb j^[hWfo m_j^h[YedijhkYj_ede\j^[79e7ceh[Z_\ÓYkbj$
7
9 <_]$'$&$)+Y )#:Wd]_e]hWf^oe\j^[h_]^j?97i^em_d]j^[ d[Yah[]_edWdZj^[Zec[e\j^[Wd[khoic"Z_h[Yj[Zjej^[ b[\ji_Z[$
8
<_]$'$&$), J^h[[#Z_c[di_edWbZ[njheiYef[h[YedijhkYj_ed e\ j^[ fh[ef[hWj_l[ 9J WdZ CH? ZWjW i^em_d] j^[ iakbb XWi[ijhkYjkh[i"l[ii[bie\j^[Wdj[h_ehY_hYkbWj_edm_j^j^[ 79e7Wd[khoic"WdZ_cfehjWdjWdWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[ie\ j^[d[_]^Xeh^eeZi$Dej[j^[h[bWj_edi^_fe\j^[l[ii[bije j^[ Wff[WhWdY[ e\ j^[ ia_d ikh\WY[ 7 WdZ je j^[ jh_fbWdWhCH_cW]_d]8$
((
?djheZkYj_ed
7
:
8
<_]$'$&$)- :[njheiYef[ l_ikWb_pWj_ed e\ j^[ h[]_ed e\ _dj[h[ij WffheWY^_d] j^[ Wd[khoic_dj^[j^h[[#Z_c[di_edWbl_hjkWbh[Wb_joj^hek]^Wh_]^jikfhWehX_jWb7" _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y8ehb[\jikfhWehX_jWb9WffheWY^$Dej[j^Wj\hecj^[h_]^ji_Z[ j^[fhec_d[dj7'i[]c[djYWdX[m[bbYedjhebb[Z$>em[l[h"ki_d]Wh_]^jikfhWeh# X_jWbeh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^"j^[d[Yah[]_ed_iYedY[Wb[ZcWa_d]ZWd][heki WdZ jhWkcWj_Y cWd_fkbWj_ed m_j^ Wd[khoic d[Y[iiWho$ Ki_d] W b[\j ikfhWehX_jWb WffheWY^" j^[ ikh]_YWb WYY[ii je j^[ d[Ya Wff[Whi kd^_ZZ[d" Wbbem_d] i[Ykh[ Yb_f# f_d]$ Dej[ j^[ Wff[WhWdY[ e\ j^[ Wd[khoic _d j^[ l_hjkWb h[Wb_jo j^hek]^ W b[\j# i_Z[Zb_c_j[ZikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco:$
9
()
?djheZkYj_ed
FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] J^[ d[kheikh][ed ckij fbWd WdZ f[h\ehc j^[ fhef[h fei_j_ed_d] e\ j^[ fWj_[djÊi XeZo WdZ ^[WZ ^_ci[b\ X[\eh[ ijWhj_d] j^[ ikh]_# YWb fheY[Zkh[$ J^_i i[b\#cWZ[ fh[fWhWj_ed _dYbkZ_d] fbWdd_d] WdZ fei_j_ed_d]_i[ii[dj_Wb\ehYh[Wj_d]a[o^eb[YhWd_ejec_[i$J^[]eWb e\ fWj_[dj fei_j_ed_d] _i je WY^_[l[ efj_cWb ikh]_YWb WYY[ii je j^[ jWh][j h[]_ed m_j^ekj fei_j_ed_d]#h[bWj[Z ZWd][hi \eh j^[ fWj_[dj$ ?dWZZ_j_ed"fei_j_edi^ekbZe\\[h[h]edec_YYedZ_j_edi\ehj^[ikh# ][edWdZcWa[j^[ef[hWj_edf^oi_ebe]_YWbboWYY[fjWXb[Zkh_d]j^[ e\j[dbed]"j_c[#Yedikc_d]fheY[Zkh[i$J^[ki[e\WceZ[hdef[h# Wj_d] jWXb[" m^_Y^ YWd X[ cWd_fkbWj[Z [b[Yjh_YWbbo" Wbie \WY_b_jWj[i efj_cWbfWj_[djfei_j_ed_d]Zkh_d]ikh][ho<_]$'$&$).$ 7 7bceij [l[ho _djhWYhWd_Wb jWh][j h[]_ed YWd X[ ikYY[ii\kbbo WffheWY^[Z ki_d] j^[ ikf_d[ eh fhed[ fei_j_ed$ ?d ekh ef_d_ed" cWa_d]ki[e\Yecfb[nfei_j_ed_d]j[Y^d_gk[i"[$]$"j^[bWj[hWbfWha X[dY^fei_j_ed"i[c_fhed[fei_j_ed"i_jj_d]ehi[c_i_jj_d]fei_j_ed" Ze[i dej e\\[h WZZ_j_edWb WZlWdjW][i _d _djhWYhWd_Wb l_ikWb_pWj_ed$ Ikh]_YWbWffheWY^[if[h\ehc[Zki_d]j^[i[Yecfb_YWj[Z"j_c[#Yed# ikc_d]fei_j_ed_d]cWd[klh[iYWdX[Zed[[gkWbbom[bbm_j^j^[ fWj_[dj_dj^[i_cfb[ikf_d[ehfhed[fei_j_ed$?dWZZ_j_ed"fWhj_Yk# bWhboj^[i_jj_d]WdZi[c_i_jj_d]fei_j_ediYWki[i[l[hWbikh]_YWbWdZ Wd[ij^[i_ebe]_YWb Z_iWZlWdjW][i WdZ cWa[ j^[ ef[hWj_ed f^oi_# ebe]_YWbbol[hoZ_\ÓYkbj\ehj^[ikh][ed$ J^[ikf_d[fei_j_ed J^[cW`eh_joe\d[kheikh]_YWbef[hWj_edijWa[fbWY[m_j^j^[fWj_[dj _dj^[ikf_d[fei_j_ed<_]i$'$&$)."'$&$)/$J^_ifei_j_ed[dWXb[ij^[ ikh][edjeWYY[iij^[Wdj[h_ehWdZc_ZZb[YhWd_Wb\eiiW"j^[\hedjWb WdZj[cfehWbiakbbXWi[WdZj^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[h[]_ed$ 7ffheWY^_d]j^[i[jWh][jh[]_edi"ej^[hd[kheikh][edi\h[gk[djbo ki[j^[bWj[hWbfWhaX[dY^fei_j_ed$>em[l[h"j^[bWj[hWbfei_j_ed_i j_c[#Yedikc_d]WdZZ_\ÓYkbjjeki[\ehWd_d[nf[h_[dY[Zikh]_YWb j[Wcm_j^ekjWZl[hi[boW\\[Yj_d]fh[iikh[fe_dji$Ki_d]j^[i_cfb[ ikf_d[fei_j_ed"j^[fWj_[dj_ifbWY[Zedj^[jWXb["m[bbfWZZ[ZXkj m_j^j^[i^ekbZ[hiec[Y[dj_c[j[hiWXel[j^[[Z][e\j^[jWXb[1 j^[ _fi_bWj[hWb i^ekbZ[h YWd X[ [b[lWj[Z m_j^ W Yki^_ed je \WY_b_# jWj[j^[^[WZhejWj_ed$?di[l[hWbYWi[i"j^[ki[e\iakbbYbWcfi_i dejd[Y[iiWho"e\\[h_d]i_cfb[WdZXh_[\fh[fWhWj_ede\j^[fWj_[dj <_]$'$&$).8$ ?\ ki[Z" j^[ i_d]b[ f_d e\ j^[ ^[WZ ÓnWjeh i^ekbZ X[ fbWY[Z_dj^[effei_j[\hedjWbWh[WX[^_dZj^[^W_hb_d[jeWbbem\h[[ cWd_fkbWj_ed e\ j^[ _fi_bWj[hWb i_Z[ Zkh_d] j^[ fheY[Zkh[$ J^[ f_d
(*
8 <_]$'$&$). Ikf_d[ fei_j_ed_d] e\ j^[ fWj_[dj fh[fWh[Z \ehikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ecoki_d]WceZ[hdef[hWj_d]jWXb[$ J^[ ^[WZ _i i[Ykh[Z _d W j^h[[#f_d YbWcf 7$ ?d i[l[hWb YWi[i" j^[ ki[ e\ iakbb YbWcfi _i dej d[Y[iiWho" e\\[h_d] W i_cfb[ WdZ Xh_[\ fh[fWhWj_ed e\ j^[ fWj_[dj$J^[ ^[WZ _i fei_j_ed[Z _d W ie\j Yki^_ed WdZ Ón[Z m_j^ W i_cfb[ jWf[8$
?djheZkYj_ed
Ij[f'
<_]$'$&$)/ 7ffheWY^_d] j^[ \hedjWb iakbb XWi[" WdZ j^[ Wdj[h_eh eh c_ZZb[ YhWd_Wb\eiiWj^hek]^WikX\hedjWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^"j^[d[njij[fie\fei_j_ed# _d]i^ekbZX[\ebbem[Z0 Ij[f'$ ?d_j_Wbbo"j^[^[WZ_i[b[lWj[ZWXel[j^[b[l[be\j^[j^ehWnje\WY_b_jWj[l[deki ZhW_dW][e\j^[_djhWYhWd_WbifWY[$?dWZZ_j_ed"[b[lWj_ede\\[hi[\\[Yj_l[Z[Yecfh[i# i_ede\j^[cW_dY[hl_YWbl[ii[bi"bWhodnWdZj^[l[dj_bWj_edjkX[$ Ij[f($ 7i W i[YedZ ij[f" j^[ ^[WZ i^ekbZ X[ h[jheÔ[Yj[Z YW$ '+$ J^_i ][djb[ h[jheÔ[n_ed ikffehji dej edbo ]hWl_jo#h[bWj[Z i[b\#h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWb eh j[cfehWb beX[" Xkj Wbie Z[f[dZi kfed j^[ fh[Y_i[ WdWjec_YWb WdZ fWj^ebe]_YWb i_jkWj_ed$ =[d[hWbbo" b[i_edi m_j^ Ybei[ fhen_c_jo je j^[ iakbb XWi[ h[gk_h[ b[ii h[jheÔ[n_ed1ijhkYjkh[ii_jkWj[Zceh[YhWd_WbboYWdX[efj_cWbboWffheWY^[Zm_j^ ceh[^[WZh[jheÔ[n_ed$
Ij[f(
Ij[f)$ J^[h[W\j[h" j^[ ^[WZ _i hejWj[Z WYYehZ_d] je j^[ jWh][j h[]_ed$ F[h\ehc# _d]WikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^j^hek]^Wd[o[Xhemia_d_dY_i_ed"j^[_fi_bWj[hWbj[c# fehec[i_Wb Wh[W WdZ Iobl_Wd Óiikh[ YWd X[ X[ij WffheWY^[Z m_j^ W hejWj_ed e\ YW$ '+$ 7ffheWY^_d] j^[ bWj[hWb ikfhWi[bbWh WdZ h[jhei[bbWh Wh[W" W hejWj_ed e\ YW$ (& _i d[Y[iiWho$ <eh j^[ Wdj[h_eh ikfhWi[bbWh h[]_ed" W hejWj_ed e\ )& WdZ \eh j^[ eb\WYjeho ]heel[" W *+ je ,& hejWj_ed _i h[gk_h[Z$ 8o Y^eei_d] j^[ Yehh[Yj Wd]b[ X[jm[[d )& WdZ ,&" ed[ YWd Wbie cWa[ YedjhWbWj[hWb b[i_edi l_i_Xb[$ Dej[ j^Wj h_]^j#^WdZ[Zikh][ediki_d]Wb[\j#i_Z[ZYhWd_ejecod[[Zceh[hejWj_edjefhel_Z[ Wd[\ÓY_[djmeha_d]fei_j_ed$ Ij[f*$ J^[bWijfei_j_ed_d]ij[fki_d]j^[ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^_ibWj[heÔ[n_ede\ YW$'&"fhel_Z_d]Wd[h]edec_Ymeha_d]fei_j_edZkh_d]ikh][ho$
i^ekbZdejX[fbWY[Z_djej^[j[cfehWb_ickiYb[Wij^_iZ_c_d_i^[i j^[ijWX_b_joe\j^[ioij[c<_]i$'$&$).7"'$&$)/$
Ij[f) J^[fhed[fei_j_ed J^[fhed[fei_j_ed_iX[ij\ehj^[jehYkbWhh[]_ed"f_d[Wbh[]_ed"c_Z# b_d[feij[h_eh\eiiWWdZj^[YhWd_eY[hl_YWb`kdYj_ed$
Ij[f*
Iec[ekjijWdZ_d]d[kheikh][ediij_bbki[j^[i_jj_d]ehi[c_i_jj_d] fei_j_ed je WffheWY^ j^[ iWc[ jWh][j h[]_edi$ 7i W cW_d WZlWd# jW]["j^[i_jj_d]fei_j_ed_cfhel[il[dekiZhW_dW][e\j^[feij[h_eh \eiiW$8beeZ"9I<WdZ_hh_]Wj_d]Ôk_ZiZhW_dWmWo\hecef[hWj_l[i_j[ cWa_d]l_[m_d]e\j^[WdWjeco[Wi_[h$>em[l[h"j^[i_jj_d]fei_j_ed h[gk_h[i [dehceki Wd[ij^[i_ebe]_YWb ced_jeh_d] X[YWki[ e\ j^[ ZWd][he\W_h[cXeb_icWdZYWhZ_efkbcedWho_dijWX_b_jo$?dWZZ_j_ed" i[l[h[fd[kceY[f^Wbkiehl[djh_YkbWhYebbWfi[X[YWki[e\j^[bWh][ beiie\9I<YWdWff[WhWifeijef[hWj_l[ikh]_YWbYecfb_YWj_edi$ ?d ekh Z[fWhjc[dj" m[ kj_b_p[ j^[ fhed[ fei_j_ed \eh j^[ WXel[ c[dj_ed[Z jWh][j h[]_edi$ 7ZlWdjW][i e\ j^_i fei_j_ed_d] Wh[ j^[ i_cfb_Y_jo e\ j^[ j[Y^d_gk[ WdZ Yec\ehj \eh j^[ fWj_[dj kdZ[h]e# _d]bed]"j_c[#Yedikc_d]fheY[Zkh[i$?dWZZ_j_ed"j^[f[hf[dZ_Yk# bWhZ_h[Yj_ede\ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_edfhel_Z[iWd[h]edec_Ymeha_d] fei_j_ed\ehj^[ikh][edm_j^efj_cWbl_ikWb_pWj_ede\j^[ef[hWj_d]
(+
?djheZkYj_ed
Ó[bZ$ J^[ fWj_[djÊi i^ekbZ[h WdZ ^_fi ckij X[ m[bb ikffehj[Z Xo ^[Wlohebbi$J^[^[WZ_ifbWY[Z_df_diWbbem_d]efj_ckcfei_j_ed# _d]$ M[ Ze dej h[gk_h[ j^[ ki[ e\ W ^ehi[i^e[ ^[WZh[ij je Wle_Z i[l[h[Yecfh[ii_ede\j^[ia_dZkh_d]bed]ikh]_YWbfheY[Zkh[i$ *
Eh_[djWj_edWYYehZ_d]jeWdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhai 7\j[hfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]e\j^[WffheWY^WYYehZ_d]jej^[_dZ_# l_ZkWb fWj^eWdWjec_YWb i_jkWj_ed WdZ W\j[h fWj_[dj fei_j_ed_d] WYYehZ_d]jej^[jWh][jh[]_ed"j^[fbWY[c[djWdZi_p[e\j^[YhWd_# ejecoi^ekbZX[_dZ_l_ZkWbbojW_beh[Z<_]$'$&$*&$ <ehj^_ih[Wied"fWbfWXb[ijhkYjkh[ie\j^[fWj_[djÊiWdWjec_YWbikh# \WY[i^ekbZX[Z[j[hc_d[ZWdZZhWmdedj^[ia_dm_j^ij[h_b[cWha# [hi7$<eh[nWcfb["m^[dki_d]j^[ikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco"j^[ _cfehjWdj WdWjec_YWb bWdZcWhai e\ j^[ \hedjej[cfehWb eii[eki iakbb" ikY^ Wi j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb \ehWc[d '" j[cfehWb b_d[ (" \hed# jeXWi_im_j^_cfh[ii_ede\j^[Iobl_WdÓiikh[)WdZj^[po]ecWj_Y WhY^*Wh[fWbfWj[Zfh[Y_i[bo$If[Y_WbWjj[dj_edckijX[]_l[dje j^[Yekhi[e\j^[ikf[hÓY_Wbd[khelWiYkbWhijhkYjkh[ie\j^[\hedje# j[cfehWbh[]_edikY^Wij^[ikfhWehX_jWbd[hl[iWdZWhj[ho+WdZ j^[ \hedjWb XhWdY^ e\ j^[ \WY_Wb d[hl[ ,$ Edbo j^[h[W\j[h i^ekbZ j^[XehZ[hie\j^[YhWd_ejecoX[cWha[Z"jWa_d]_djeYedi_Z[hWj_ed j^[fei_j_ede\j^[b[i_edWdZj^[bWdZcWhaiZhWmdedj^[ia_d8$ 7\j[h Z[Ód_d] j^[ YhWd_ejeco" j^[ _dZ_l_ZkWb efj_ckc b_d[ e\ j^[ ia_d_dY_i_ed_icWha[Zm_j^j^[f[d9$
)
'
( ,
+
7
8
H[Y[djbo" j^[ efj_cWb fbWY[c[dj e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco YWd X[ [\\[Y# j_l[boYedjhebb[Zm_j^j^[ki[e\ceZ[hddWl_]Wj_edjeebi$>em[l[h" j^[WffheWY^ckijX[Z[j[hc_d[ZW\j[hikh]_YWbeh_[djWj_edWYYehZ# _d]jej^[WYYkhWj[WdWjec_YWbademb[Z][WdZj^[dWl_]Wj_edZ[l_Y[ i^ekbZfbWoedboj^[heb[e\Wfh[Y_i[Yedjheb 9
Ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ia_d_dY_i_edWdZie\jj_iik[Z_ii[Yj_ed J^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed _i cWZ[ WYYehZ_d] je j^[ fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d] WdZWdWjec_YWbeh_[djWj_ed$J^[Z_ii[Yj_edi^ekbZe\\[hWZ[gkWj[ _dif[Yj_ed e\ j^[ eii[eki ikh\WY[ m^_bij c_d_c_p_d] ie\j j_iik[ jhWkcW$ 7d WZZ_j_edWb _cfehjWdj \WYjeh _i je WY^_[l[ Yeic[j_# YWbbo\WlehWXb[feijef[hWj_l[h[ikbjim_j^ikXi[gk[djiWj_i\WYj_ed Wced]fWj_[djiIj[fi'Å)"<_]i$'$&$*'Å*)$
(,
<_]$'$&$*& ?bbkijhWj_l[YWi[f[h\ehc_d]ikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_# ejeco$ <eh j^[ Wffhefh_Wj[ ia_d _dY_i_ed" j^[ _cfehjWdj WdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhai7e\j^[eii[ekiiakbbWh[fWbfWj# [Z fh[Y_i[bo WdZ cWha[Z m_j^ W ij[h_b[ f[d Xbk[ b_d[i$ If[Y_WbWjj[dj_edckijX[]_l[djej^[Yekhi[e\j^[ikf[h# ÓY_Wb d[khelWiYkbWh ijhkYjkh[i e\ j^[ \hedjej[cfehWb h[]_ed o[bbem WdZ h[Z b_d[i$ Edbo j^[h[W\j[h i^ekbZ j^[ XehZ[hie\j^[YhWd_ejecoX[cWha[Z]h[[db_d["jWa_d] _djeYedi_Z[hWj_edj^[fei_j_ede\j^[b[i_edWdZj^[bWdZ# cWhaiZhWmdedj^[ia_d8$7\j[hZ[Ód_d]j^[YhWd_ejeco" j^[_dZ_l_ZkWb"efj_ckcb_d[e\j^[ia_d_dY_i_ed_icWha[Z m_j^WXbWYaf[d9$
?djheZkYj_ed
F[h\ehc_d] W ikfhWehX_jWb YhWd_ejeco j^hek]^ Wd [o[Xhem ia_d _dY_i_ed" i^Wl_d] e\ j^[ [o[Xhem _i dej d[Y[iiWho1 \eh W fb[Wi_d] Yeic[j_YekjYec["j^[_dY_i_edb_d[ckijX[fbWY[Z[nWYjbo_dj^[ ^W_h[ZWh[W$F[h\ehc_d]WdWffheWY^m_j^_dj^[^W_h[ZWh[W"m[kik# Wbboki[Wc_d_cWb'&cci^Wl_d]WYYehZ_d]jej^[[nWYjb_d[e\j^[ ia_d_dY_i_ed$ 9hWd_ejeco"ZkhWbef[d_d] J^[W_ce\a[o^eb[d[kheikh][ho_idejj^[b_c_j[ZYhWd_ejeco"Xkj j^[b_c_j[ZXhW_d[nfbehWj_edWdZc_d_cWbXhW_dh[jhWYj_ed$?dj^_i mWo" j^[ b_c_j[Z YhWd_ejeco _i dej j^[ ]eWb Xkj j^[ h[ikbj e\ j^[ f^_beief^oe\c_d_cWb_dlWi_l[d[ii_dd[kheikh][ho$ 7\j[h f[h\ehc_d] W b_c_j[Z a[o^eb[ YhWd_ejeco" h[celWb e\ j^[ _dd[h[Z][e\j^[YhWd_ejecokdZ[hfhej[Yj_ede\j^[ZkhWYWdX[ l[ho ^[bf\kb$ 9Wh[\kb Zh_bb_d] e\ j^_i _dd[h Xed[ [Z][ i_]d_ÓYWdjbo _dYh[Wi[ij^[Wd]b[\ehl_ikWb_pWj_edWdZcWd_fkbWj_ed1icWbbeii[# eki[nj[di_edie\j^[iakbbXWi[i^ekbZWbieX[YWh[\kbboh[cel[Z je fhel_Z[ Wd [nY[bb[dj el[hl_[m WdZ je Wbbem \h[[ c_Yheikh]_YWb WYY[iijeZ[[f#i[Wj[Zi_j[i$J^[i[cWd[klh[i]h[Wjbo\WY_b_jWj[j^[ ki[e\j^[ef[hWj_d]c_YheiYef[WdZc_Yheikh]_YWb_dijhkc[dji_d j^[\khj^[hYekhi[e\j^[ef[hWj_edIj[fi*Å-"<_]i$'$&$**Å*-$ J^[ ZkhWb ef[d_d] i^ekbZ e\\[h efj_cWb _djhWYhWd_Wb [nfeikh[ WdZ \WY_b_jWj[j^[ZkhWbYbeikh[j^[h[W\j[h$J^[ZkhWi^ekbZX[ef[d[Z _dWYkhl[ZehÇOÈi^Wf[Z\Wi^_edm_j^_jiXWi[jemWhZjej^[iakbb XWi[ehjej^[c_Zb_d[$J^[\h[[ZkhWbÔWf_iÓn[Zm_j^ikjkh[i1ej^[h ZkhWb[b[lWj_edikjkh[iWh[dejh[gk_h[ZIj[f."<_]$'$&$*.$ ?djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed J^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb Z_ii[Yj_ed i^ekbZ X[ f[h\ehc[Z W\j[h [nWYj fbWd# d_d]e\[l[hoij[fe\j^[fheY[Zkh[$J^[ikh][edi^ekbZX[WXb[je Çhkdj^hek]^È[WY^ij[fe\j^[ef[hWj_ed_d^_ieh^[hc_dZWYYehZ# _d] je cWdZWjeho WdWjec_YWb WdZ ikh]_YWb [nf[h_[dY[$ J^_i e\\[hi iW\[cWd_fkbWj_edm_j^_dj^[ikh]_YWbÓ[bZWdZm_bb^[bfjefh[l[dj _djhWef[hWj_l[Yecfb_YWj_edi$ <_hij ij[f e\ j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[ i^ekbZ X[ j^[ ik\ÓY_[dj ZhW_dW][ e\ 9I<$ :k[ je j^[ cWha[Z _djhWYhWd_Wb h[bWnWj_ed" Yehj_# YWbh[jhWYj_edYWdX[[\\[Yj_l[boc_d_c_p[Z$M_j^\kbb[cfbeoc[dj e\ j[Y^d_gk[i ikY^ Wi [dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[Z a[o^eb[ c_Yhed[khe# ikh][ho j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[ YWd X[ ikYY[ii\kbbo Yecfb[j[Z Ij[fi/Å'+"<_]i$'$&$*/Å++$
(-
?djheZkYj_ed
Ij[f' J^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed X[]_di bWj[hWbbo \hec j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb _dY_ikhW WdZ _i cWZ[ m_j^_d j^[ [o[Xhem$<ehWYeic[j_YWbboefj_cWbh[ikbj"j^[ _dY_i_ed i^ekbZ \ebbem j^[ ehX_jWb h_c$ Dej[ YWh[\kb Z_ii[Yj_ed e\ j^[ ia_d ÔWf ki_d] ded# ZWcW]_d] \ehY[fi$ J^[ ikXYkjWd[eki j_iik[ _i Z_ii[Yj[Z kfmWhZi _d W \hedjWb Z_h[Yj_ed je WY^_[l[ efj_cWb [nfeikh[1 ^em[l[h" j^[ ia_d ÔWf i^ekbZ X[ ][djbo ceX_b_p[Z ZemdmWhZi _d Wd ehX_jWb Z_h[Yj_ed je Wle_Z f[h_ehX_jWb ^[cWjecW<_]$'$&$*'$ <_]$'$&$*'
Ij[f( 7\j[h ia_d _dY_i_ed" j^[ ia_d ÔWf _i j[cfehWh_bo h[jhWYj[Z m_j^ ij_jY^[i [nfei_d] j^[ \hedjWb X[bboe\j^[eYY_f_je\hedjWbckiYb["j^[ehX_YkbWh WdZj^[j[cfehWbckiYb[i$J^[\hedjWbckiYb[i Wh[ Ykj m_j^ W cedefebWh [b[YjheZ[ ad_\[ fWhWbb[bjej^[]bWX[bbWWdZj^[j[cfehWbckiYb[ _i ijh_ff[Z \hec _ji Xedo _di[hj_ed$ Dej[ j^Wj j^[ia_dÔWfiWh[jekY^[Zedbom_j^WjhWkcWj_Y \ehY[fi<_]$'$&$*($
ehX_YkbWh_ieYkb_ ckiYb[ j[cfehWbckiYb[ \hedjWbckiYb[
<_]$'$&$*(
Ij[f) J^[ j[cfehWb ckiYb[ _i ceX_b_p[Z bWj[hWbbo ki_d]WXbkdjZ_ii[Yjeh$Dej[j^Wj[nfeikh[WdZ ceX_b_pWj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbckiYb[i^ekbZX[ h[ijh_Yj[Zjej^[d[Y[iiWhoc_d_ckcjefh[l[dj feijef[hWj_l[fheXb[cim_j^Y^[m_d]WdZbWj[h j[cfehWbWjhef^o$Dej[j^[j[cfehWbb_d[1j^[ Z_ii[Yjehfe_djijej^[b[l[be\j^[Wdj[h_ehiakbb XWi[<_]$'$&$*)$
j[cfehWbb_d[
<_]$'$&$*)
(.
?djheZkYj_ed
Ij[f* J^[ j[cfehWb ckiYb[ _i h[jhWYj[Z m_j^ icWbb mekdZ^eeaiWdZj^[\hedjWbckiYb[kfmWhZi WdZ ZemdmWhZi m_j^ ijhed] ikjkh[i Wbbem_d] b_c_j[Z [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb Xedo ikh\WY[$ Dej[ j^Wj j^[ \hedjWb WdZ ehX_YkbWh ckiYb[i i^ekbZ X[ ][djbo fki^[Z ZemdmWhZi je j^[ ehX_j$ 9Wh[\kb Z_ii[Yj_ed WdZ c_d_cWb h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^_i ckiYkbWh bWo[h _i [ii[dj_Wb je Wle_Z feijef[hWj_l[ f[h_ehX_jWb ^[cWjecW$ Ki_d] W ^_]^#if[[Z Zh_bb" W i_d]b[ \hedjeXWiWb Xkhh^eb[_iZh_bb[Zfeij[h_ehjej^[j[cfehWbb_d[ Wjj^[b[l[be\j^[\hedjWbiakbbXWi[<_]$'$&$**$
<_]$'$&$**
Ij[f+ 7\j[hc_d_cWb[dbWh][c[dje\j^[^eb[m_j^Ód[ fkdY^[iWdZceX_b_pWj_ede\j^[ZkhW"WijhW_]^j b_d[_iYkjm_j^W^_]^#if[[ZYhWd_ejec[fWhWbb[b je j^[ ]bWX[bbW _d W bWj[hWb je c[Z_Wb Z_h[Yj_ed" jWa_d] _dje WYYekdj j^[ bWj[hWb XehZ[h e\ j^[ \hedjWbfWhWdWiWbi_dki<_]$'$&$*+$
<_]$'$&$*+
Ij[f, J^[h[W\j[hWÇ9Èi^Wf[Zb_d[_iYkj\hecj^[Xkhh ^eb[jej^[c[Z_WbXehZ[he\j^[fh[l_ekiboYkj \hedjeXWiWbb_d["j^kiYh[Wj_d]WXed[ÔWfm_j^ Wm_Zj^e\YW$'+Å(&ccWdZW\hedjWb[nj[di_ed e\YW$'&Å'+cc<_]$'$&$*,$
<_]$'$&$*,
(/
?djheZkYj_ed
`k]WY[h[XhWb_W
<_]$'$&$*-
Ij[f- 7l[ho_cfehjWdjijW][e\j^[YhWd_ejecoW\j[h h[celWb e\ j^[ Xed[ ÔWf _i j^[ ^_]^#if[[Z Zh_bb_d] e\ j^[ _dd[h [Z][ e\ j^[ Xed[ WXel[ j^[ ehX_jWb h_c kdZ[h fhej[Yj_ed e\ j^[ ZkhW$ 9Wh[\kb h[celWb e\ j^_i _dd[h Xed[ [Z][ YWd i_]d_ÓYWdjbo_dYh[Wi[j^[Wd]b[\ehl_ikWb_pWj_ed WdZcWd_fkbWj_ed$IcWbbeii[eki[nj[di_edie\ j^[ ikf[hÓY_Wb ehX_jWb hee\" j^[ ie#YWbb[Z `k]W Y[h[XhWb_W" i^ekbZ Wbie X[ Zh_bb[Z [njhWZkhWbbo je eXjW_d efj_cWb _djhWZkhWb l_ikWb_pWj_ed$ 7 icWbbZ_WcedZZh_bb_ih[Yecc[dZ[Z$Dej[j^[ Wffb_YWj_ed e\ W ifWjkbW \eh fhej[Yj_ed e\ j^[ ZkhWbikh\WY[<_]$'$&$*-$
Ij[f. J^[ZkhWi^ekbZX[ef[d[Z_dWYkhl[Z\Wi^_ed m_j^ _ji XWi[ jemWhZ je j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb h_c$ J^[ \h[[ ZkhWb ÔWf _i Ón[Z ZemdmWhZi m_j^ ikjkh[i1 ej^[h ZkhWb [b[lWj_ed ikjkh[i Wh[ dej h[gk_h[Z<_]$'$&$*.$
<_]$'$&$*.
Ij[f/ 7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ ZkhW cWj[h" j^[ Óhij ij[f i^ekbZ X[ j^[ ik\ÓY_[dj ZhW_dW][ e\ 9I< Xo ef[d_d] j^[ Y^_WicWj_Y WdZ YWhej_Z Y_ij[hdi$ 7\j[h Z_ii[Yj_ed e\ j^[ WhWY^de_Z c[cXhWd[i" j^[ Wdj[hebWj[hWb ijhkYjkh[i e\ j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh h[]_edWh[[nfei[Z0j^[b[\j9D?"9D??WdZj^[ ikfhWYb_de_Z i[]c[dj e\ j^[ ?97$ J^[ \hedjWb beX[ _i c_d_cWbbo h[jhWYj[Z WdZ j^[ EF97 m_dZem_ief[d[Z<_]$'$&$*/$
9D?? 9D? ?97
<_]$'$&$*/
)&
?djheZkYj_ed
Ij[f'& 7&[dZeiYef[_i_djheZkY[Z_djej^[ikh]_YWb Ó[bZ$Dej[j^[_dYh[Wi[Zb_]^j_dj[di_joWdZj^[ ^_]^bo XheWZ[d[Z eXi[hlWj_edWb Ó[bZ 7$ ?d W Ybei[#kf fei_j_ed 8" j^[ WdWjec_YWb Z[jW_bi YWd X[ l_ikWb_p[Z WdZ j^[ Z[[f#i[Wj[Z XWi_bWh X_\khYWj_edWff[Whij^hek]^j^[EF97m_dZem <_]$'$&$+&$
7
?97 9D??
XWi_bWhj_f
8 <_]$'$&$+&
Ij[f'' :_ii[Yj_d] je j^[ c_Zb_d[" j^[ Wd[khoic _i WffheWY^[Z$Dej[j^[bWc_dWj[hc_dWb_iWdZW \hedjeXWiWbXhWdY^e\j^[797"WZ^[h[djm_j^ j^[Wd[khoiciWYa<_]$'$&$+'$ bWc_dWj[hc_dWb_i Wd[khoic
<_]$'$&$+'
Ij[f'( 7\j[h \khj^[h Z_ii[Yj_ed" j^[ [dj_h[ Wd[khoic YWd X[ i[[d$ Dej[ j^[ ^ofefbWij_Y b[\j 7' i[]c[djWdZj^[79e7<_]$'$&$+($ b[\j7' 79e7
<_]$'$&$+(
)'
?djheZkYj_ed
Ij[f') Kfed _djheZkYj_ed e\ j^[ [dZeiYef[" j^[ h[bWj_edi^_f X[jm[[d j^[ Wd[khoic WdZ j^[ bWc_dW j[hc_dWb_i X[Yec[i [l_Z[dj$ Dej[ j^[ Y^_Wic WdZ Xej^ efj_Y d[hl[i 7$ ?d W Ybei[# kf fei_j_ed e\ j^[ [dZeiYef[ 8" j^[ d[Ya e\ j^[Wd[khoic_iZ_ii[Yj[Zm_j^Ód[Z_ii[Yjehi$ Dej[j^[iWYae\j^[Wd[khoic"j^[b[\j7(WdZ 79e7<_]$'$&$+)$
7 b[\j9D?? h_]^j9D?? bWc_dWj[hc_dWb_i 7Ye7 b[\j7(
8 <_]$'$&$+)
Ij[f'* M^[dj^[fWj^eWdWjecoe\j^[Wd[khoic^Wi X[[d WiY[hjW_d[Z WdZ j^[ d[Ya Z_ii[Yj[Z" W ijhW_]^jWd[khoicYb_f7[iYkbWf7="Jkjjb_d][d" =[hcWdo_ifbWY[Z$J^[iWYa_iYebbWfi[ZW\j[h YWh[\kbef[d_d]WdZWif_hWj_ede\j^[Wd[khoic <_]$'$&$+*$
<_]$'$&$+*
Ij[f'+ J^[ [dZeiYef[ e\\[hi WZ[gkWj[ l_ikWb Yedjheb e\ j^[ Yb_ff_d] fheY[Zkh[ 7$ J^[ Yecfb[j[ Ybeikh[ YWd X[ [\\[Yj_l[bo ced_jeh[Z _d Ybei[# kf8<_]$'$&$++$
7
8 <_]$'$&$++
)(
?djheZkYj_ed
Ij[f', 7j j^[ [dZ e\ j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[" j^[ ikXWhWY^de_Z ifWY[ _i Óbb[Z m_j^ Whj_ÓY_Wb 9I< iebkj_edWjXeZoj[cf[hWjkh[$J^[ZkhWb_dY_i_ed _i Ybei[Z m_j^ mWj[hj_]^j Yedj_dkeki ikjkh[i$ Dej[ j^[ [nj[di_ed e\ j^[ b_c_j[Z YhWd_ejeco WdZc_d_cWbZkhWbef[d_d]<_]$'$&$+,$
<_]$'$&$+,
Ij[f'- 7 fbWj[ e\ ][b\eWc _i fbWY[Z [njhWZkhWbbo WdZ j^[Xed[ÔWf_iÓn[Zm_j^Wj_jWd_kc9hWd_e\_n c_d_fbWj[ 7[iYkbWf 7=" Jkjjb_d][d" =[hcWdo$ Dej[j^Wjj^[Xkhh^eb[i^ekbZX[Ybei[Zm_j^ j^[fbWj[WdZj^[Xed[ÔWfj_]^jboÓn[ZXej^ c[Z_Wbbo WdZ \hedjWbbo je WY^_[l[ efj_cWb Yeic[j_Yh[ikbji<_]$'$&$+-$
<_]$'$&$+-
Ij[f'. 7\j[h ÓdWb l[h_ÓYWj_ed e\ ^[ceijWi_i" j^[ ckiYkbWh WdZ ikXYkjWd[eki bWo[hi Wh[ Ybei[Z m_j^ _dj[hhkfj[Z ikjkh[i WdZ j^[ ia_d m_j^ _djhWYkjWd[eki ikjkh[i$ Ed WYYekdj e\ j^[ b_c_j[Zia_d_dY_i_edWdZdedjhWkcWj_Yikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[" j^[ ki[ e\ W ikYj_ed ZhW_d _i dej d[Y[iiWho WdZ j^[h[\eh[ dej h[Yecc[dZ[Z <_]$'$&$+.$
<_]$'$&$+.
))
?djheZkYj_ed
MekdZYbeikh[ 7\j[h Ód_i^_d] j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[" j^[ ikXWhWY^de_Z ifWY[ _iÓbb[Zm_j^Whj_ÓY_Wb9I<iebkj_edWjXeZoj[cf[hWjkh[$J^[ZkhWb _dY_i_ed_icWZ[mWj[hj_]^jki_d][_j^[h_dj[hhkfj[ZehYedj_dkeki ikjkh[i Ij[f '," <_]$'$&$+,$ ?\ j[di_ed ^Wi Z[l[bef[Z _d j^[ ZkhWb fbWd["Wf_[Y[e\ckiYb[YWdX[i[md_djej^[ZkhWbYbeikh[$7fbWj[ e\][b\eWc_ij^[dfbWY[Z[njhWZkhWbbo$M[Zedejh[Yecc[dZj^[ ki[e\ÓXh_dehfhej[_d#YedjW_d_d]ÓnWj_l[jeWii_ijm_j^ZkhWbYbe# ikh[edWYYekdje\j^[ÓXh_deboj_Y[\\[Yje\j^[9I<$J^[Xed[ÔWf _iÓn[Zm_j^Wj_jWd_kcc_d_fbWj[$KikWbboed[fbWj[_i[dek]^je Wbbemik\ÓY_[djÓnWj_ed1_\feii_Xb["j^[j_jWd_kcfbWj[i^ekbZYbei[ j^[Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_edIj[f'-"<_]$'$&$+-$Dej[j^Wjj^[Xed[ ÔWf i^ekbZ X[ Ón[Z j_]^jbo je WY^_[l[ efj_cWb Yeic[j_Y h[ikbji$ 7\j[hÓdWbl[h_ÓYWj_ede\^[ceijWi_i"j^[ckiYb[WdZikXYkjWd[eki bWo[hi Wh[ Ybei[Z m_j^ _dj[hhkfj[Z ikjkh[i$ <eh Ybeikh[ e\ j^[ ia_d" Z_\\[h[djj[Y^d_gk[iYWdX[ki[Z$7d[o[Xhemia_d_dY_i_edYWdX[ Ybei[Zm_j^_djhWYkjWd[ekihkdd_d]ikjkh[iehm_j^ij[h_b[WZ^[i_l[ jWf[iIj[f'."<_]$'$&$+.$7ia_d_dY_i_edm_j^_dj^[^W_h[ZWh[WYWd X[ Ybei[Z m_j^ _dj[hhkfj[Z eh hkdd_d] ikjkh[i eh W\j[h WZ[gkWj[ ikXYkjWd[ekiikjkh[im_j^^_ijeWYhob]bk[$EdWYYekdje\j^[b_c# _j[Z ia_d _dY_i_ed WdZ dedjhWkcWj_Y ikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[ _d a[o^eb[ d[kheikh][ho"WikYj_edZhW_d_idejh[gk_h[Z$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i ?dWZ[gkWj[ fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d] m_j^ ikXi[gk[dj _dWZ[gkWj[ [nfeikh[e\j^[jWh][jh[]_edWdZi_]d_ÓYWdjZ[j[h_ehWj_ed_d[\Ó# Y_[dYoe\ikh]_YWbbo[nY_i_d]j^[b[i_ed$FbWdd_d]_ij^[jWiae\j^[ ikh][ed ?dWZ[gkWj[ fei_j_ed_d] e\ j^[ fWj_[dj m_j^ _dik\ÓY_[dj _djhW# YhWd_Wb [nfeikh[$ Je Wle_Z W f^oi_ebe]_YWbbo kdYec\ehjWXb[ `eX Zkh_d]j_c[#Yedikc_d]fheY[Zkh[i"j^[ikh][edi^ekbZf[h\ehc j^[fWj_[djfei_j_ed_d]^_ci[b\$ ?dWZ[gkWj[fbWY[c[dje\j^[YhWd_ejeco$J^[WffheWY^ckijX[ Z[j[hc_d[ZW\j[hWYYkhWj[ikh]_YWbeh_[djWj_edWYYehZ_d]jeWdW# jec_YWb ademb[Z][ WdZ fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d]$ >em[l[h" m_j^ j^[ki[e\ceZ[hddWl_]Wj_edjeebi"Yehh[Yjfei_j_ed_d]e\j^[YhW# d_ejecoYWd[\\[Yj_l[boX[ced_jeh[Z$ El[hbeea[Z"Xkje\j[dkdWle_ZWXb[_d`khojej^[ZkhWZkh_d]YhW# d_ejeco$:khWbh[YedijhkYj_edcWoX[d[Y[iiWho$ ?dWZ[gkWj[h[celWbe\9I<m_j^_d`khojej^[Yehj_YWbikh\WY[Zk[ jeifWjkbWfh[iikh[$
)*
<_]$'$&$+/ FWj_[djÊi Wff[WhWdY[ j^[ (dZ WdZ ('ij feij# ef[hWj_l[ZWo$J^[b_c_j[Zia_d_dY_i_ed"c_d_cWbckiYkbWh Z_ii[Yj_edWdZb[Wijfeii_Xb[Xed[ZWcW][eXjW_d[Zm_j^ j^_i c_d_cWb _dlWi_l[ j[Y^d_gk[ h[ikbj _d Wd efj_cWb Yeic[j_YekjYec[fkXb_i^[Zm_j^fWj_[djÊif[hc_ii_ed$
?djheZkYj_ed
?d`kh_[i je d[hl[i WdZ l[ii[bi _d j^[ ikh]_YWb Ó[bZ Zkh_d] c_Yhe# ikh]_YWb cWd_fkbWj_ed h[ikbj_d] _d feijef[hWj_l[ d[khebe]_YWb Z[j[h_ehWj_ed$ ?dWZ[gkWj[_djhWYhWd_Wb^[ceijWi_iYWki_d]i[l[h[feijef[hWj_l[ h[Xb[[Z_d]m_j^_dj^[ikh]_YWbÓ[bZ$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ZkhWbYbeikh[m_j^feijef[hWj_l[9I<b[Wa$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ fei_j_ed_d] WdZ ÓnWj_ed e\ j^[ Xed[ ÔWf m_j^ ikX# efj_cWbYeic[j_Yh[ikbji$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ [njhWYhWd_Wb ^[ceijWi_i YWki_d] feijef[hWj_l[ ie\j j_iik[^[cWjecW$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ Ybeikh[ e\ j^[ ia_d YWki_d] feijef[hWj_l[ mekdZ ^[Wb_d]Z_ijkhXWdY[ehikXefj_cWbYeic[j_YekjYec[$
J_fiWdZjh_Yai JWa[ j_c[ \eh fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d] WdZ fei_j_ed_d] e\ fWj_[dji$ J^[h[mWhZ_iWd[nY[bb[djel[hl_[me\j^[jWh][jWh[WWdZWd[\Ó# Y_[djmeha_d]fei_j_ed$ CWa[WYWh[\kbWdWjec_YWbeh_[djWj_edWdZki[j^[j^h[[ij[fie\ cWha_d]m_j^Wij[h_b[f[d0'$eii[ekiijhkYjkh[iWdZikf[hÓY_Wb d[khelWiYkbWhijhkYjkh[i1($fbWY[c[dje\YhWd_ejeco1)$ia_d_dY_# i_ed$ J^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed i^ekbZ X[ cWZ[ _d W Yeic[j_YWbbo WYY[fjWXb[ mWo$ 8oh[jhWYj_d]j^[ie\jj_iik["j^[eii[ekiikh\WY[i^ekbZX[efj_# cWbbo[nfei[Z$>em[l[h"h[jhWYj_edWdZceX_b_pWj_ede\j^[ia_d ÔWf i^ekbZ X[ h[ijh_Yj[Z je j^[ d[Y[iiWho c_d_ckc je fh[l[dj feijef[hWj_l[d[Yhei_i$ 8[YWh[\kbZkh_d]j^[Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_ed0WZ[gkWj[fbWY[c[dj Xkj_dWZ[gkWj[Z_h[Yj_ede\j^[Xkhh_d]fheY[Zkh[cWoWbief[d# [jhWj[ijhkYjkh[ie\j^[iakbbXWi[ehcWo_d`kh[j^[ZkhWbWdZYeh# j_YWbikh\WY[ IjW][ie\YhWd_ejeco0'$Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_ed1($Ykjj_d]m_j^j^[ YhWd_ejec[WYYehZ_d]jej^[fbWdd[ZWffheWY^$ :h_bb_d]e\j^[_dd[h[Z][e\j^[YhWd_ejecoW\j[hh[celWbe\j^[ Xed[ÔWf_i_cfehjWdj\ehb_c_j[ZWffheWY^[ijeWY^_[l[kd^_d# Z[h[Z_djhWYhWd_Wbl_ikWb_pWj_ed$IcWbbeii[eki[nj[di_edie\j^[ iakbbXWi[i^ekbZWbieX[YWh[\kbboh[cel[Zjefhel_Z[Wd[nY[b# b[djel[hl_[mWdZjeWbbemc_Yheikh]_YWbWYY[iijeZ[[f#i[Wj[Z i_j[i$ Ef[dj^[ZkhW_dWÇ9ÈehÇOÈi^Wf[Z\Wi^_edWdZ^ebZj^[ZkhWb ÔWfm_j^ikjkh[i$
)+
?djheZkYj_ed
CWdo d[kheikh][edi X[b_[l[ j^Wj _djhWYhWd_Wb ikh][ho i^ekbZ X[ Zed[ m_j^ j^[ ikh][ed i_jj_d]$ >em[l[h" f[h\ehc_d] W a[o^eb[ WffheWY^" _djhWef[hWj_l[ Y^Wd]_d] e\ j^[ ikh][edÊi fei_j_ed _i l[ho\h[gk[dj$?dekh[nf[h_[dY["j^_iÇZWdY_d]WhekdZj^[jWXb[È _iceh[Yec\ehjWXb[\ehj^[ikh][edm^_bijijWdZ_d]"[l[dm^[d f[h\ehc_d]bed]WdZj_c[#Yedikc_d]fheY[Zkh[i$ 7\j[h Yecfb[j_ed e\ j^[ _djhWZkhWb Z_ii[Yj_ed" ZkhWb Ybeikh[ i^ekbZ X[ cWZ[ mWj[hj_]^j ki_d] [_j^[h _dj[hhkfj[Z eh Yedj_dk# ekiikjkh[i$?\j[di_ed^WiZ[l[bef[Z_dj^[ZkhWbfbWd["Wf_[Y[e\ ckiYb[YWdX[i[md_djej^[ZkhWbYbeikh[$ 7\j[hZkhWbYbeikh["j^[Xed[ÔWfi^ekbZX[j_]^jboÓn[ZjeWY^_[l[ efj_cWbYeic[j_Yh[ikbji$ 7j_jWd_kcfbWj[YWdX[ikYY[ii\kbboki[Z\ehYbeikh[e\j^[Xkhh ^eb[jh[f^_dWj_ed$ 8[YWki[ e\ j^[ b_c_j[Z ie\j j_iik[ Z_ii[Yj_ed" j^[ ki[ e\ ikYj_ed ZhW_d_idejh[gk_h[Z$ J^[ia_di^ekbZX[Ybei[Zm_j^_dj^[^W_h[ZWh[Wm_j^ikjkh[ieh W\j[hikXYkjWd[ekiikjkh[im_j^^_ijeWYhob]bk[$ 7d [o[Xhem _dY_i_ed YWd X[ ik\ÓY_[djbo Ybei[Z m_j^ _djhWYkjWd[# ekihkdd_d]ikjkh[iehm_j^ij[h_b[WZ^[i_l[jWf[i$
),
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
($& IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ >_ijehoe\j^[Wdj[h_ehikX\hedjWbWdZ \hedjebWj[hWbWffheWY^[i
<_]$($&$' 7f_Yjkh[jWa[d\hecj^[Óhij[Z_j_ede\ <[Zeh AhWki[Êi f_ed[[h_d] mehaÇIkh][ho e\ j^[ 8hW_dWdZIf_d[È$?dj^_iYWi["AhWki[WffheWY^[Z Wd[nj[dZ[ZiakbbXWi[c[d_d][ecW_djmeij[fi$ 7\j[h f[h\ehc_d] j^[ ikX\hedjWb YhWd_ejeco" j^[ jkcehmWifWhj_Wbboh[cel[Z_dWi[YedZi[ii_ed ki_d] Wd [njhWZkhWb [nfeikh[" j^ki c_d_c_p_d] _d`kho je j^[ Yehj_YWb ikh\WY[$ :k[ je j^[ hek]^ h[jhWYj_ede\j^[\hedjWbbeX[m^_Y^mWid[Y[iiWho X[YWki[e\Wi[l[h[XhW_dim[bb_d]"j^[fWj_[djZ_Z dejikhl_l[$
7ikX#WdZjhWdi\hedjWbWffheWY^mWiÓhijZ[iYh_X[ZXo$
<_]$($&$( J^[[njhWZkhWbikX\hedjWbWffheWY^e\
Ej^[h jhWdiYhWd_Wb \hedjWb WffheWY^[i ^Wl[ h[gk_h[Z j^[ fWhj_Wb [nfeikh[e\j^[Wdj[h_eh^Wb\e\j^[Y[h[XhWb^[c_if^[h[WiZ[ced# ijhWj[Z_d9ki^_d]Êi">[k[hÊiWdZ:WdZoÊi^_ijeh_YWbZ[iYh_fj_edi e\ ikh][ho e\ j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh h[]_ed$ >Whl[o 9ki^_d] f[h\ehc[Z j^[ Óhij Yecfb[j[ h[celWb e\ W jkX[hYkbkc i[bbW[ c[d_d][ecW l_W ikX\hedjWb [nfeikh[ _d '/', WdZ h[fehj[Z ^_i [nf[h_[dY[ e\ j^[h[i[Yj_ede\(.jkcehi_d^_iYbWii_YWbfkXb_YWj_ed"Ye#Wkj^eh[Z Xo Bek_i[ ;_i[d^WhZj Q9ki^_d] é ;_i[d^WhZj '/).S$ =[eh][ @$ >[k[h Z[iYh_X[Z ^_i ikX\hedjWb#\hedjej[cfehWb WffheWY^ je Y^_WicWb b[i_edi" W fhejejof[ e\ j^[ bWj[h \hedjebWj[hWb#fj[h_edWb
)-
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
YhWd_ejecoQ>[k[h'/(&S$MWbj[h;$:WdZofkXb_i^[Zj^[h[ikbji e\^_iÓhij[_]^jYWi[ie\\hedjeXWiWbc[d_d][ecW_d'/(("ki_d] >[k[hÊi \hedjej[cfehWb WffheWY^ Q:WdZo'/((S$ J^[ Wkj^ehi [nfei[ZWbWh][Yehj_YWbikh\WY[m^_Y^mWif[hcWd[djboYedjWc_# dWj[Zm_j^W_hZkh_d]ikh][hoYWki_d]Yehj_YWbc_Yhe_d`kh_[im_j^ j^[ ikXi[gk[dj feii_X_b_jo e\ feijef[hWj_l[ [f_b[fj_Y i[_pkh[i <_]i$'$&$'"($&$)$7ifh[l_ekiboZ[iYh_X[Z"j^[i[[nj[dZ[Zef[d_d]i m[h[d[Y[iiWho\ehi[l[hWbh[Wiedi1^em[l[h"j^[Z[l[befc[dje\ Z_W]deij_Y _cW]_d] WdZ ikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[i Wbbem[Z W ij[fm_i[ h[ZkYj_ed_dj^[i_p[e\j^[ia_d_dY_i_edWdZYhWd_ejeco$:WdZoÊi f[hiedWb b[Whd_d] fheY[ii _d h[ZkY_d] ef[hWj_l[ jhWkcWj_pWj_ed mWi m[bb Z[cedijhWj[Z _d ^_i fkXb_YWj_ed e\ ^_i ie#YWbb[Z ^ofe# f^oi[Wb WffheWY^ [nfei_d] Wd ?97 Wd[khoic Q:WdZo'/).S <_]$'$&$($ 7d kdkikWb _dZ_YWj_ed \eh j^[ \hedjej[cfehWb#^ofef^oi[Wb WffheWY^ mWi j^[ eYYbki_l[ ^oZheY[f^Wbki Q:WdZo '/((S$ 7\j[h ikX\hedjWb[nfeikh[e\j^[ikfhWi[bbWhh[]_ed":WdZoef[d[Zj^[ bWc_dW j[hc_dWb_i WY^_[l_d] Wd Wdj[h_eh l[djh_YkbeY_ij[hdeijeco e\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[$Dej[j^Wjj^_i_d_j_Wbj[Y^d_gk[jej^_hZl[d# jh_Ykbeijeco_dlebl[Zj^[i[Yj_ed_d]e\ed[efj_Yd[hl[je[nfei[ j^[ jkX[h Y_d[h[kc$J^_i c[j^eZ mWi h[Ód[Z Xo 8ohed Ijeea[o WdZ J[Z IYWh\\ Xo fkdYjkh_d] j^[ bWc_dW j[hc_dWb_i WdZ j^[d j^[ Ôeeh e\ j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ <_]$($&$*$ ?d '/,)" IYWh\\ fkX# b_i^[Zj^[h[ikbjie\+(-^oZheY[f^Wb_YfWj_[dji_dm^ecj^[feij# ef[hWj_l[ cehjWb_jo mWi '+ m_j^ Wd _d_j_Wb ikYY[ii hWj[ e\ -& QIjeea[o'/),"IYWh\\'/+'"'/,)S$
<_]$($&$) >[k[hÊi \hedjej[cfehWb YhWd_ejeco [nfei# _d] j^[ ikfhW# WdZ fWhWi[bbWh h[]_ed$ Dej[ j^Wj edbo j^[ Wdj[h_ehfWhje\j^[[nfbehWj_edmWiki[ZWffheWY^_d]j^[ h_]^jefj_Yd[hl[$J^[h[\eh["j^[[nj[di_l[YhWd_ejecoWdZ ZkhWbef[d_d]YWki[Z_dj^_iYWi[Wdkdd[Y[iiWhojhWkcW jej^[Yehj_YWbikh\WY[$
9edY[hd_d] fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d]" cWdo ikh][edi ef[hWj[Z ed j^[dedZec_dWdji_Z[1^em[l[h"@Wc[iB$Feff[dik]][ij[Z j^Wj h_]^j#^WdZ[Zikh][edii^ekbZki[j^[h_]^j\hedjWbWffheWY^WdZ b[\j#^WdZ[Z ikh][edi j^[ b[\j \hedjWb WffheWY^ QFeff[d '/,&S$ Dej[ j^Wj (( o[Whi W\j[h :WdZoÊi Z[iYh_fj_ed" Feff[dÊi [nfeikh[ Z_Zdejh[if[Yjj^[^W_hb_d[<_]$($&$+$ ?d j^[ [Whbo '/-&i" Wd [dehceki Z[l[befc[dj _d j[Y^d_YWb ijWd# ZWhZiWbbem[Zd[kheikh][edijeki[h[Ód[ZWffheWY^[i$>[k[hÊi WdZ:WdZoÊi\hedje#j[cfehWbWffheWY^mWih[Ód[ZXoC$=Wp_OWi# Wh]_bQOWiWh]_b'/-+S<_]$($&$,$7b_c_j[Z\hedjebWj[hWbWffheWY^ jeWd[khoicie\j^[Wdj[h_ehY_hYkbWj_edmWif[h\ehc[ZXoCWh_e 8heYaWdZ:_[jpQ8heYaé:_[jp'/-.S$J^[Wkj^ehiikccWh_p[Z j^[WZlWdjW][ie\j^[icWbbYhWd_ejecoWi'j^[j[cfehWbckiYb[ h[cW_di_djWYjX[YWki[e\c_d_cWbceX_b_pWj_ed1(j^[YhWd_ejeco
).
<_]$($&$* J^_hZ l[djh_Ykbeijeco Xo j^[ ikX\hedjWb hekj[" Z[iYh_X[ZXoIYWh\\_d'/+'$Dej[j^[fkdYjkh[e\Xej^j^[ bWc_dW j[hc_dWb_i WdZ j^[ Ôeeh e\ j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[" Wbbem_d]\h[[9I<Y_hYkbWj_ed$
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
_i [nYbki_l[bo eij[efbWij_Y1 )ef[d_d] j^[ Iobl_Wd Óiikh[ _i kd# d[Y[iiWho"Wle_Z_d]_d`khoe\j^[Iobl_Wdl[ii[bi$If[Y_WbWjj[dj_ed i^ekbZ X[ ]_l[d je j^_i f_ed[[h_d] Z[iYh_fj_ed e\ W b[ii _dlWi_l[ ikX\hedjWb WffheWY^ m^_Y^ ^Wi fhel_Z[Z Çj^[ WZlWdjW][ e\ f[h# c_jj_d]Wd[Wio"Z_h[YjWdZfhej[Yj_l[WjjWYajeikY^Wd[khoici j^hek]^WicWbbWdZc[h[boeij[efbWij_YYhWd_ejecoÈ<_]$($&$-$
<_]$($&$+ 7d kd_bWj[hWb ikX\hedjWb WffheWY^ je Wd[k# hoicie\j^[Wdj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d]Whj[hofkXb_i^[ZXo Feff[d_d'/,&$Dej[j^Wj((o[WhiW\j[h:WdZoÊiZ[iYh_f# j_ed"Feff[dÊiia_d_dY_i_edmWidejYedY[Wb[ZX[^_dZj^[ ^W_hb_d[]_l_d]WdkdWYY[fjWXb[Yeic[j_Yh[ikbj$
<_]$($&$, 7h[Ód[c[dje\:WdZoÊi^ofef^oi[WbWffheWY^ ki_d]c_Yheikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[imWifkXb_i^[ZXoOWiWh]_b _d '/-+$ J^_i \hedjej[cfehWb fj[h_edWb WffheWY^ _i Ykh# h[djboj^[ceij\h[gk[djboki[Z\ehikh]_YWbWYY[iijei[bbWh WdZfWhWi[bbWhb[i_edi$
<_]$($&$- J^[ b_c_j[Z \hedjebWj[hWb WffheWY^ je Wd[k# hoicie\j^[Wdj[h_ehY_hYkbWj_edmWifkXb_i^[ZXo8heYa WdZ:_[jp_d'/-.$
?d'/.("@Wc[i7$@Wd[h[fehj[ZWZ_\\[h[djikX\hedjWb#ikfhWehX_jWb [nfeikh[jeWd[khoiciWdZej^[hb[i_edie\j^[ikfhWi[bbWhWh[WWi m[bbWijeehX_jWbb[i_ediQ@Wd['/.(S$J^_iWffheWY^mWiceZ_Ó[Z Xo @e^ddo :[bWi^Wm Xo \hWYjkh_d] j^[ ehX_jWb hee\ eh _dYbkZ_d] W j[cfehWb [nj[di_ed e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco Q:[bWi^Wm '//(S$ J^[ _d\[h_eh [nj[di_ed e\ j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb YhWd_ejeco Xo h[celWb e\ j^[ ehX_jWb h_c mWi Wbie Z[iYh_X[Z Xo HeX[hje :[b\_d_ ki_d] Wd Wbj[hdWj_l[j[Y^d_gk[m_j^jmeXed[ÔWfiQ:[b\_d_'//(S$EiiWcW 7b#C[\jo fkXb_i^[Z ^_i [nf[h_[dY[ YedY[hd_d] W ikfhWehX_jWb# fj[h_edWb WffheWY^ je iakbb XWi[ b[i_edi Xo _dYehfehWj_d] j^[ ikf[h_ehWdZbWj[hWbehX_jWbmWbbi1@ei[f^C$PWXhWciaoZ[iYh_X[Z [nj[dZ[Zj[cfehWbWdZehX_jepo]ecWj_YXed[h[celWbfhel_Z_d] m_Z[ WYY[ii je j^[ Wdj[h_eh WdZ c_ZZb[ YhWd_Wb \eiiW Q7b#C[\jo '//&"PWXhWciao'//.S$ CeijlWh_Wj_edie\ j^[i[ikfhWehX_jWbWdZikX\hedjWbWffheWY^[i h[ikbj[Z_d[nj[di_l[ie\jj_iik[WdZXedo[nfeikh["[nj[dZ[ZZkhWb ef[d_d] WdZ ikXi[gk[djbo d[Y[iiWho XhW_d h[jhWYj_ed" YWki_d] W feii_Xb[_dYh[Wi[_dikh]_YWbcehX_Z_jokdh[bWj[Zjej^[b[i_ed_ji[b\$ >em[l[h"i_c_bWhjej^[icWbb\hedjebWj[hWbWffheWY^e\8heYaWdZ :_[jp"h[Y[djfkXb_YWj_ediedikX\hedjWb[nfeikh[i^Wl[Z[iYh_X[Z b_c_j[Z jhWkcWj_pWj_ed e\ j^[ [njhW# WdZ _djhWYhWd_Wb ijhkYjkh[i$ ?d '//." ;h_YlWd B_dZ[hj h[fehj[Z j^[ ikh]_YWb [nf[h_[dY[ ki_d] ikfhWehX_jWbikX\hedjWbYhWd_ejeco\ehj^[jh[Wjc[dje\'/-_djhW# YhWd_Wb Wd[khoici1 I|dZeh9p_h`|a fkXb_i^[Z ^_i [nf[h_[dY[ _d (&&' WdZ (&&( WdZ HWcei#Pd_]W fh[i[dj[Z j^[ jhWdi#ikfhW# ehX_jWb WffheWY^ _d (&&( QlWd B_dZ[hj '//." 9p_h`|a (&&'" (&&(" HWcei#Pd_]W (&&(S$ >Wdi @WaeX Ij[_][h Z[iYh_X[Z W icWbb ehX_jeYhWd_Wb WffheWY^ j^hek]^ W \hedjej[cfehWb ^W_hb_d[ _dY_i_ed je WYY[ii Wd[khoici e\ j^[ Wdj[h_eh Yecckd_YWj_d] Whj[ho QIj[_][h (&&'S$ ?d (&&( WdZ (&&+" j^[ CW_dp j[Y^d_gk[ e\ f[h\ehc_d] ikfhWehX_jWb YhWd_ejeco j^hek]^ Wd [o[Xhem ia_d _dY_i_edmWiZ[iYh_X[ZQH[_iY^(&&("(&&+S$ :kh_d] j^[ bWij Z[YWZ[i" cWdo Z_\\[h[dj ikX\hedjWb WdZ \hedje# bWj[hWb WffheWY^[i je j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh Wh[W ^Wl[ X[[d Z[iYh_X[Z"
)/
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
[l[d_\iec[e\j^[i[[nfeikh[im[h[_d\WYjgk_j[i_c_bWh$>em[l[h" _d^_if_ed[[h_d]Z[iYh_fj_ed"<[ZehAhWki[^WZWbh[WZo]hWif[Z j^[ [ii[dY[ e\ j^[ ikX\hedjWb ikfhWehX_jWb [nfeikh[0 j^[ ikfhW# i[bbWh WdWjec_YWb ijhkYjkh[i Wh[ \h[[ \eh ikh]_YWb Z_ii[Yj_ed \hec WdWdj[h_ehZ_h[Yj_ed"m^_b[j^[Wdj[h_ehfWhje\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[ Ze[idejeXiYkh[WYY[iijej^[Z[[f#i[Wj[ZWh[Wi$ ?dj^[\ebbem_d]"j^_i_cfehjWdjWdWjec_YWb\WYjm_bbX[Z_iYkii[Z _dZ[jW_b$
7
=[d[hWbWdWjec_YWbYedijhkYj_ede\j^[Wdj[h_ehYhWd_Wb \eiiWWdZj^[ikfhWi[bbWhh[]_ed 7YYehZ_d] je AhWki[Êi YedY[fj" je X[jj[h kdZ[hijWdZ j^[ ][e# c[jh_YWb WdZ jefe]hWf^_YWb WhY^_j[Yjkh[ e\ j^[ Wdj[h_eh YhWd_Wb \eiiW"j^[][d[hWbWdWjec_YWbYedijhkYj_edWdZj^[[ii[dj_WbWdW# jec_YWb Y^WhWYj[h_ij_Yi e\ j^_i Wh[W ckij Óhij X[ Z_iYkii[Z$ J^[ XWi[ e\ j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh Wh[W m_j^ j^[ gkWZhWd]b[ e\ j^[ Yb_de_Z fheY[ii[i _i ed j^[ iWc[ b[l[b Wi j^[ Wdj[h_eh iakbb XWi[$ >em# [l[h" bWj[hWb je j^[ i[bbWh ijhkYjkh[i" j^[ XWi[ e\ j^[ c_ZZb[ YhW# d_Wb\eiiW_ii_jkWj[ZZ[[f[hj^Wdj^[fbWd[e\j^[Wdj[h_ehYhWd_Wb \eiiW$7YYehZ_d] je@e^Wdd[iBWd]" j^_iZ_\\[h[dY[_iedWl[hW][ '.ccedj^[b[\jWdZ(&ccedj^[h_]^ji_Z[QBWd]'/.'S$J^_i c[Wdi j^[ j[cfehWb beX[ el[hbWfi j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh h[]_ed \hec W bWj[hWbZ_h[Yj_edj^kid[Y[ii_jWj_d][nj[di_l[h[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[c# fehWbbeX[m^[dWffheWY^_d]\hecWbWj[hWbj[cfehWbZ_h[Yj_ed<_]$ ($&$.7$?dWZZ_j_ed"j^[j[cfehWbfeb[^WiWd[nj[di_edWdj[h_ehje j^[ \hedjWb fWhj e\ j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh Wh[W$J^ki" m^[d WffheWY^_d] j^_i Wh[W \hec W \hedjej[cfehWb fj[h_edWb Z_h[Yj_ed" j^[ Wdj[h_eh fWhje\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[eXiYkh[ij^[ikh]_YWbWYY[ii0ifb_jj_d]e\ j^[Iobl_WdÓiikh[m_j^cWd_fkbWj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbl[_dickij WbieX[f[h\ehc[Z <_]$($&$.8$>em[l[h"ki_d] j^[ Wdj[h_eh ikX# \hedjWbWffheWY^"WYY[iijej^[ikfhWi[bbWhWh[W_i\h[[\ehikh]_YWb Z_ii[Yj_edWdZh[jhWYj_ede\ j^[ j[cfehWbbeX[_ikdd[Y[iiWho$?d WZZ_j_ed"j^[ikX\hedjWbWffheWY^Wbbemi[WhboWYY[iijej^[ikfhW# i[bbWhWh[Wm_j^ekjef[d_d]j^[Iobl_WdÓiikh[<_]$($&$.9$ J^[cW_djWh][jh[]_edki_d]WikX\hedjWbWffheWY^_ij^[ikfhW# i[bbWhWh[Wm_j^Wbb_jiikhhekdZ_d]ijhkYjkh[i$Jemeham_j^_dj^_i h[]_ed_dWj^h[[#Z_c[di_edWbcWdd[h"_j_iX[ij[nfbW_d[Z_dW][e# c[jh_YmWoWiWl_hjkWbfohWc_Z<_]$($&$/$J^[XWi[e\ j^[fohW# c_Z_i\ehc[ZXoj^[Z_Wf^hW]cWi[bbW[Wjj^[b[l[be\j^[\hedjWb
*&
8
9
<_]$($&$. IY^[cWj_Y f_Yjkh[i Z[cedijhWj_d] j^[ i[bbWh WdZ fWhWi[bbWh h[]_ed _d j^[ YehedWh" Wn_Wb WdZ iW]_jjWb fbWd[i$ Dej[ j^Wj m^[d eXi[hl_d] j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh Wh[W \hecj^[bWj[hWbikXj[cfehWbeh\hedjej[cfehWbfj[h_edWb Z_h[Yj_ed" j^[ j[cfehWb beX[ eXiYkh[i j^[ ikh]_YWb WYY[ii h[Z Whhemi$ Ki_d] j^[ Wdj[h_eh ikX\hedjWb WffheWY^" WYY[ii je j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh Wh[W _i \h[[ \eh ikh]_YWb [nfbehW# j_ed]h[[dWhhem$
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
7
iakbbXWi[$;WY^e\j^[jh_Wd]kbWhfbWd[ie\j^[fohWc_Z_iZ[Ód[Z XoY[hjW_dijhkYjkh[i$J^[Wdj[h_ehfbWd[e\j^[fohWc_Z_i\ehc[Z WbceijYecfb[j[boXoj^[efj_Yd[hl[i"Y^_WicWdZj^[bWc_dWj[h# c_dWb_i$J^[Óhiji[]c[djie\Xej^797WdZj^[79e7Wh[Wbie_d Z_h[Yjh[bWj_edi^_fjej^_ifbWd[$J^[i_Z[e\j^[fohWc_Z_dYbkZ[i j^[9D??WdZefj_YjhWYj"j^[9D???"j^[?97WdZ_jijmeikfhWYb_de_Z XhWdY^[i" j^[ feij[h_eh Yecckd_YWj_d] WdZ Wdj[h_eh Y^ehe_ZWb Whj[h_[i$J^[ feij[h_eh fohWc_ZWb fbWd[ _i Z[Ód[Z Xo j^[ l[djhWb ikh\WY[e\j^[XhW_dij[cWdZ87m_j^j^[feij[h_ehY[h[XhWbWdZ ikf[h_ehY[h[X[bbWhWhj[h_[i$J^[Wn_ie\j^[fohWc_Z_i\ehc[ZXo j^[ _d\kdZ_Xkbkc WdZ f_jk_jWho ijWba$ J^_i l_hjkWb YedijhkYj_ed [dWXb[if[hY[fj_ede\j^[lWh_ekil_[m_d]Wd]b[i_djej^_iifWY[1 j^[fohWc_ZWdZj^[Z_\\[h[djm_dZemiX[jm[[d_jiijhkYjkh[iYWd X[m[bbWffheWY^[Zki_d]Z_\\[h[djefj_cWbWd]b[i$?dWZZ_j_ed"_j Wbie^[bfijekdZ[hijWdZ^emWdWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[iWh[Z_ifbWY[Z _dj^[YWi[e\WifWY[#eYYkfo_d]b[i_edm_j^_dj^[ikfhWi[bbWhWh[W <_]$($&$/$
8
9
:
<_]$($&$/ 7hj_ijÉi ZhWm_d] Z[cedijhWj_d] j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh Wh[W Wi W l_hjkWb fohW# c_Z \hec Z_\\[h[dj l_[m_d] Wd]b[i$ Dej[ j^Wj j^[ iWc[ WdWjec_YWb ijhkYjkh[i Wh[ l_ikWb_p[Z l[ho Z_\\[h[djbo WYYehZ_d] je Z_l[hi[ ikh]_YWb [nfeikh[i0 7 c[Z_Wd ikX\hedjWb [nfeikh[1 8 \hedjebWj[hWb ikfhWehX_jWb [nfeikh[1 9 \hedjej[cfehWb fj[h_edWb[nfeikh[1:ikXj[cfehWb[nfeikh[$J^_il_hjkWbYedijhkYj_edWbie^[bfi je kdZ[hijWdZ ^em WdWjec_YWb ijhkYjkh[i Wh[ Z_ifbWY[Z _d j^[ YWi[ e\ ifWY[# eYYkfo_d]b[i_edim_j^_dj^[ikfhWi[bbWhh[]_ed$
*'
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
?fi_bWj[hWb
C_Zb_d[
9edjhWbWj[hWb
EhX_jWbhee\ 7dj[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii"7FYB Feij[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii Hee\WdZbWj[hWbmWbbe\j^[9I 8WiWb\hedjWbbeX[ =ohkih[Yjki Iobl_WdÓiikh[ 7dj[hec[Z_Wbj[cfehWbbeX[ KdYki^_ffeYWcf_ 9D?"9D??"9D???"9D?L ?97"Ef^j7"F9e7"79^7" _dYb$f[h\ehWjehi 7'"7("C'"C("_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi F'"F("I97"_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi Ikf[hÓY_Wbj[cfehWbl[_d
9h_ijW=Wbb_ Eb\WYjeho]heel[ FbWdkcif^[de_ZWb[ JkX[hYkbkci[bbW[ BWc_dWj[hc_dWb_i 7dj[h_ehj^_hZl[djh_Yb[ F_jk_jWhoijWba ?dj[hf[ZkdYkbWh\eiiW 79e7 :_ijWb87m_j^f[h\ehWjehi
EhX_jWbhee\ 7dj[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii 8WiWb\hedjWbbeX[ =ohkih[Yjki Iobl_WdÓiikh[ J[cfehWbfeb[ 9hkiY[h[Xh_ 9D?"9D??"9D??? ?97"Ef^j7"F9e7"79^7" _dYb$f[h\ehWjehi 7'"7("C'"C("_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi F'"F("I97"_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi
JWXb[($&$' 7dWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[iWffheWY^[Zj^hek]^j^[ikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_jeco$
Ki_d] j^[ikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejecoi[l[hWbWdWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[i e\j^[ikfhW#WdZfWhWi[bbWhWh[WYWdX[[nfei[ZJWXb[($&$'$?dj^[ \ebbem_d]" j^[ ikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[ e\ j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb ikX\hedjWb WffheWY^_iZ[iYh_X[ZWiWij[f#Xo#ij[fZ_ii[Yj_ed$
*(
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[
<_]$($&$'&
'$ FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] J^[ fWj_[dj _i fbWY[Z ikf_d[ ed j^[ ef[hWj_d] jWXb[$ ?\ ki[Z" j^[ i_d]b[ f_d e\ j^[ ^[WZ ÓnWjeh i^ekbZ X[ fbWY[Z _d j^[ effei_j[ \hedjWb Wh[W je Wbbem \h[[ cWd_fkbWj_ed e\ j^[ _fi_bWj[hWb i_Z[ Zkh_d]j^[fheY[Zkh[$J^[f_di^ekbZdejX[fbWY[Z_djej^[j[c# fehWb_ickiYb[Wij^_iZ_c_d_i^[ij^[ijWX_b_joe\j^[ioij[cWdZ YWdYWki[feijef[hWj_l[j[cfehWb^[cWjecW$ Ij[f' ?d_j_Wbbo" j^[ ^[WZ _i [b[lWj[Z YW$ '+ WdZ j^[ ^[WZ e\ j^[ ef[hWj# _d]jWXb[_i[b[lWj[ZWXel[j^[j^ehWnje\WY_b_jWj[l[dekiZhW_dW][$ ;b[lWj_ed fhel_Z[i Z[Yecfh[ii_ed e\ j^[ Y[hl_YWb l[ii[bi" bWhodn WdZl[dj_bWj_edjkX[<_]$($&$'&$
<_]$($&$''
<_]$($&$'(
<_]$($&$')
Ij[f( H[jheÔ[n_ed dej edbo ikffehji ]hWl_jo#h[bWj[Z i[b\#h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[\hedjWbbeX[XkjWbieZ[f[dZikfedj^[jWh][jh[]_edWdZj^[ fh[Y_i[WdWjec_YWbWdZfWj^ebe]_YWbi_jkWj_ed$B[i_edim_j^Ybei[ fhen_c_jojej^[\hedjWbiakbbXWi[h[gk_h[Wh[jheÔ[n_ede\'&Å'+$ IjhkYjkh[ii_jkWj[Zceh[YhWd_Wbbo"ikY^Wib[i_edie\j^[Wdj[h_eh j^_hZl[djh_Yb[YWdX[efj_cWbboWffheWY^[Zm_j^ceh[^[WZh[jhe# Ô[n_ede\YW$)&<_]$($&$''$ Ij[f) J^[h[W\j[h"j^[^[WZ_ihejWj[Zjej^[YedjhWbWj[hWbi_Z["j^[Z[]h[[ e\ hejWj_ed Z[f[dZ_d] ed j^[ jWh][j h[]_ed0 \eh j^[ _fi_bWj[hWb j[cfehec[i_Wb Wh[W" Iobl_Wd Óiikh[ WdZ j^[ C97" W hejWj_ed e\ YW$'&je'+_iik\ÓY_[dj$7ffheWY^_d]j^[bWj[hWbikfhWi[bbWhWdZ h[jhei[bbWhWh[Wm_j^j^[9D??"?97"WdZ87"WhejWj_ede\YW$)&_i d[Y[iiWho$ <eh j^[ Wdj[h_eh ikfhWi[bbWh h[]_ed m_j^ ijhkYjkh[i e\ j^[ bWc_dW j[hc_dWb_i WdZ 79e7" W hejWj_ed e\ )& je *+ WdZ \eh j^[ eb\WYjeho ]heel[" *+ je ,& hejWj_ed _i h[gk_h[Z$ 8o Y^eei_d] j^[Yehh[YjWd]b[X[jm[[d)&WdZ,&"ed[YWdWbiecWa[YedjhW# bWj[hWb b[i_edi l_i_Xb[$ Dej[ j^Wj h_]^j#^WdZ[Z ikh][edi ki_d] W b[\j#i_Z[Z YhWd_ejeco d[[Z ceh[ hejWj_ed je fhel_Z[ Wd [\ÓY_[dj meha_d]fei_j_ed<_]$($&$'($ Ij[f* 7ij^[bWijfei_j_ed_d]ij[f"j^[^[WZ_ibWj[heÔ[Yj[ZYW$'&jej^[ YedjhWbWj[hWbi_Z["Wbbem_d]Wd[h]edec_Ymeha_d]fei_j_edZkh_d] ikh][ho<_]$($&$')$
*)
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
($7dWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZeh_[djWj_ed <eh j^[Wffhefh_Wj[ia_d_dY_i_ed"j^[_cfehjWdjWdWjec_YWbbWdZ# cWhaie\j^[eii[ekiiakbb"ikY^Wij^[]bWX[bbW"\hedjWbfWhWdWiWb i_dki"ehX_jWbh_c"ikfhWehX_jWb\ehWc[d"j[cfehWbb_d["\hedjeXWi_i" _cfh[ii_ede\ j^[Iobl_WdÓiikh[WdZ j^[po]ecWj_YWhY^Wh[fWb# fWj[Z fh[Y_i[bo WdZ cWha[Z m_j^ W ij[h_b[ f[d$ If[Y_Wb Wjj[dj_ed ckijX[]_l[djej^[Yekhi[e\j^[ikf[hÓY_Wbd[khelWiYkbWhijhkY# jkh[ie\j^[\hedjej[cfehWbh[]_edikY^Wij^[ikfhWehX_jWbd[hl[i WdZWhj[ho"WdZj^[\hedjWbXhWdY^e\j^[\WY_Wbd[hl[<_]$($&$'*$ Edboj^[h[W\j[hi^ekbZj^[XehZ[hie\j^[YhWd_ejecoX[cWha[Z" jWa_d]_djeYedi_Z[hWj_edj^[fei_j_ede\j^[b[i_edWdZj^[bWdZ# cWhaiZhWmdedj^[ia_d$7\j[hZ[Ód_d]j^[YhWd_ejeco"j^[_dZ_# l_ZkWb efj_ckc b_d[ e\ j^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed _i cWha[Z m_j^ j^[ f[d$ KikWbbo j^_i ia_d _dY_i_ed _i fbWY[Z bWj[hWbbo je j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb d[hl[hkdd_d]m_j^_dj^[[o[Xhem<_]$($&$'*$I^Wl_d]e\j^[[o[# Xhem_idejd[Y[iiWho1\ehWfb[Wi_d]Yeic[j_YekjYec[" j^[_dY_# i_edb_d[ckijX[fbWY[Z[nWYjbo_dj^[^W_h[ZWh[W$?\j^[[o[Xhem _idejZec_dWdj" j^[ia_d_dY_i_edi^ekbZX[cWZ[_dWYh[Wi[eh iYWhe\j^[ikfhWehX_jWbWh[W$7bj[hdWj_l[bo"Wd_dY_i_edX[^_dZj^[ ^W_hb_d[ _i Wbie feii_Xb[$J^[ [o[b_Zi Wh[ fhej[Yj[Z m_j^ i[di_j_l[ jWf[WdZj^[ia_dWdZ[o[XhemZ_i_d\[Yj[Zm_j^WbYe^ebiebkj_ed$
<_]$($&$'* :[Ód_j_ed e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco WYYehZ# _d] je j^[ WdWjec_YWb bWdZcWhai e\ j^[ \hedje# j[cfehWbh[]_ed$J^[ia_d_dY_i_edi^ekbZX[cWZ[ m_j^_d j^[ [o[Xhem" ]_l_d] W fb[Wi_d] feijef[hW# j_l[Yeic[j_Yh[ikbj$
**
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
)$9hWd_ejeco Ij[f' H_]^j i_Z[$ J^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed X[]_di bWj[hWbbo \hec j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb _dY_ikhW" WdZ _i cWZ[ m_j^_d j^[ [o[Xhem" _d iec[ YWi[i [nj[dZ# _d] W \[m c_bb_c[j[hi el[h j^[ bWj[hWb fhe`[Y# j_ed e\ j^[ Xhem _dje j^[ \hedjepo]ecWj_Y Wh[W$JeWY^_[l[WYeic[j_YWbboefj_cWbh[ikbj" j^[_dY_i_edckij\ebbemj^[ehX_jWbh_c$Dej[ j^Wjj^[ia_d_dY_i_edi^ekbZdej[nj[dZc[Z_# Wbbo je j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb d[hl[ ie Wi je Wle_Z \hedjWb dkcXd[ii$ J^[ \hedjWb XhWdY^ e\ j^[ \WY_Wbd[hl[WdZj^[ikf[hÓY_Wbj[cfehWbWhj[ho d[l[hYheiij^_ijof[e\ia_d_dY_i_ed1^em[l[h" j^[\hedjWbXhWdY^cWoX[j[cfehWh_boW\\[Yj[Z feijef[hWj_l[bo X[YWki[ e\ Yecfh[ii_ed Zk[ jeia_dh[jhWYj_ed$7\j[hia_d_dY_i_ed" j^[ikX# YkjWd[ekij_iik[i^ekbZX[Z_ii[Yj[ZYWh[\kbbo _dW\hedjWbZ_h[Yj_ed<_]$($&$'+$
<_]$($&$'+
<_]$($&$',
Ij[f( J^[ ia_d ÔWf _i j[cfehWh_bo h[jhWYj[Z m_j^ ij_jY^[i[nfei_d]j^[\hedjWbX[bboe\j^[eYY_# f_je\hedjWb ckiYb[" j^[ ehX_YkbWh_i eYkb_ WdZ j^[j[cfehWbckiYb[i$Dej[j^Wjj^[ia_dÔWf i^ekbZX[][djbofki^[ZkfmWhZ_dWdehX_jWb Z_h[Yj_edjeWle_Zf[h_ehX_jWb^[cWjecW1^em# [l[h" j^[ ÔWf i^ekbZ X[ h[jhWYj[Z \ehY[\kbbo ZemdmWhZi _d W \hedjWb Z_h[Yj_ed je WY^_[l[ efj_cWb[nfeikh[<_]$($&$',$
<_]$($&$'-
Ij[f) J^[\hedjWbckiYb[iWh[Ykjm_j^WcedefebWh [b[YjheZ[ad_\[fWhWbb[bjej^[ehX_jWbh_cWdZ j^[j[cfehWbckiYb[_iijh_ff[Z\hec_jiXedo _di[hj_ed$J^[j[cfehWbckiYb[_ih[jhWYj[ZbWj# [hWbbo"j^[\hedjWbckiYb[kfmWhZim_j^ijhed] ikjkh[i<_]$($&$'-$;nfeikh[WdZceX_b_pWj_ed e\ j^[ j[cfehWb ckiYb[ i^ekbZ X[ h[ijh_Yj[Z jej^[d[Y[iiWhoc_d_ckcjefh[l[djfeijef# [hWj_l[fheXb[cim_j^Y^[m_d]$Dej[j^Wjj^[ \hedjWbWdZehX_YkbWhckiYb[ii^ekbZX[][djbo fki^[Z kfmWhZi je j^[ ehX_j$ 9Wh[\kb Z_ii[Y#
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
j_ed WdZ c_d_cWb h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^_i ckiYkbWh bWo[h_i[ii[dj_WbjeWle_Zfeijef[hWj_l[f[h_eh# X_jWb^[cWjecW$BeYWb^[ceijWi_id[[ZijeX[ f[h\ehc[ZhWf_ZboWdZm_j^fh[Y_i_ed$
<_]$($&$'.
Ij[f* ?dWbbYWi[i"Wdeij[efbWij_YYhWd_ejeco_if[h# \ehc[Z$Ki_d]W^_]^#if[[ZZh_bb"Wi_d]b[\hed# jeXWiWb Xkhh ^eb[ _i Zh_bb[Z feij[h_eh je j^[ j[cfehWbb_d[$If[Y_WbWjj[dj_edckijX[]_l[d jej^_iXkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_ed"[if[Y_Wbboje_ji h[bWj_edi^_f je j^[ \hedjWb iakbb XWi[ WdZ je j^[ ehX_j$ Dej[ j^Wj W\j[h Wd efj_ckc fbWY[# c[dje\j^[Xkhh^eb["j^[Zh_bbckijX[fki^[Z ZemdmWhZije[nfei[j^[Wdj[h_eh\eiiWm_j^# ekjf[d[jhWj_d]j^[ehX_j<_]$($&$'.$
<_]$($&$'/
Ij[f+ 7\j[h c_d_cWb [dbWh][c[dj e\ j^[ ^eb[ m_j^ Ód[ fkdY^[i WdZ ceX_b_pWj_ed e\ j^[ ZkhW" W ijhW_]^j b_d[ _i Ykj m_j^ W ^_]^#if[[Z YhWd_e# jec[ fWhWbb[b je j^[ ehX_jWb h_c _d W bWj[hWb je c[Z_Wb Z_h[Yj_ed" jWa_d] _dje WYYekdj j^[ bWj[hWb XehZ[h e\ j^[ \hedjWb fWhWdWiWb i_dki <_]$($&$'/$ <_]$($&$(&
Ij[f, J^[h[W\j[hWÇ9Èi^Wf[Zb_d[_iYkj\hecj^[Xkhh ^eb[ je j^[ c[Z_Wb XehZ[h e\ j^[ fh[l_ekibo f[h\ehc[Z \hedjeXWiWb b_d[" j^ki Yh[Wj_d] W Xed[ÔWfm_j^Wm_Zj^e\YW$'+Å(&ccWdZW \hedjWb[nj[di_ede\YW$'&Å'+cc<_]$($&$(&$ >[cehh^W][i eYYkhh_d] Zkh_d] j^[ YhWd_e# jecoYWdX[ij[cc[ZXoX_febWhYeW]kbWj_ed WdZmWn$
*,
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
Ij[f- 7 l[ho _cfehjWdj ijW][ e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco W\j[h h[celWb e\ j^[ Xed[ ÔWf _i j^[ ^_]^# if[[Z Zh_bb_d] e\ j^[ _dd[h [Z][ e\ j^[ Xed[ WXel[j^[ehX_jWbh_ckdZ[hfhej[Yj_ede\j^[ ZkhW$9Wh[\kbh[celWbe\j^_i_dd[hXed[[Z][ YWd i_]d_ÓYWdjbo _dYh[Wi[ j^[ Wd]b[ \eh l_ikWb_pWj_edWdZcWd_fkbWj_ed$J^[i[cWd[k# l[hi ]h[Wjbo \WY_b_jWj[ j^[ ki[ e\ j^[ ef[hWj# _d] c_YheiYef[ WdZ c_Yheikh]_YWb _dijhk# c[dji _d j^[ \khj^[h Yekhi[ e\ j^[ ef[hWj_ed$ IcWbb eii[eki [nj[di_edi e\ j^[ ikf[hÓY_Wb ehX_jWb hee\ i^ekbZ Wbie X[ Zh_bb[Z [njhWZk# hWbbojeeXjW_defj_cWb_djhWZkhWbl_ikWb_pWj_ed <_]$($&$('$
<_]$($&$('
<_]$($&$((
Ij[f. J^[ZkhWi^ekbZX[ef[d[Z_dWYkhl[Z\Wi^_ed m_j^ _ji XWi[ jemWhZ je j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb h_c <_]$($&$(($
Ij[f/ J^[\h[[ZkhWbÔWf_iÓn[ZkfmWhZim_j^jme ikjkh[i$Ej^[hZkhWb[b[lWj_edikjkh[iWh[dej h[gk_h[Z<_]$($&$()$
<_]$($&$()
*-
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
9D?? 79F ?97
<_]$($&$(*
9D?? ?97 Y^_Wic 7'i[]c[dj
<_]$($&$(+
j[cfehWbbeX[ ?97 C97X_\khYWj_ed C'i[]c[dj
<_]$($&$(,
*.
*$?djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ij[f' H_]^ji_Z[$:_ii[Yj_eded\h[i^^kcWdYWZWl[h$ 7hj[h_Wbl[ii[biWh[fh[fWh[Zm_j^h[ZYebeh[Z bWj[n iebkj_ed$ 7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ ZkhW cWj[h" j^[Óhijij[fi^ekbZX[j^[ik\ÓY_[djZhW_dW][ e\9I<Xoef[d_d]j^[Y^_WicWj_YWdZYWhej_Z Y_ij[hdi$ ?d j^[ YWi[ e\ ^_]^ ?9F" \eh [nWcfb[" W\j[h cWii_l[ ikXWhWY^de_Z ^[cehh^W][" j^[ bWj[hWb l[djh_Yb[ i^ekbZ X[ fkdYjkh[Z m_j^ W l[djh_YkbWh YWddkbW$ 7\j[h h[celWb e\ j^[ ikXWhWY^de_ZWbehl[djh_YkbWh9I<" j^[\hedjWb beX[ Z[ÔWj[i ifedjWd[ekibo" h[dZ[h_d] i_]d_# ÓYWdj h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWb beX[ kdd[Y[i# iWho$ =[d[hWbbo" j^[ i[b\#h[jW_d_d] ifWjkbW _i b[\j_dfbWY[WiWÇXhW_dfhej[YjehÈhWj^[hj^Wd j^[ XhW_d h[jhWYjeh$ J^hek]^ j^[ ikX\hedjWb mWo j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh h[]_ed YWd X[ _cc[Z_# Wj[bo WffheWY^[Z" m_j^ekj j_c[#Yedikc_d] WdZ jhWkcWj_Y ef[d_d] e\ j^[ Iobl_Wd Óiikh[ <_]$($&$(*$ Ij[f( 7\j[hZ_ii[Yj_ede\j^[WhWY^de_Zc[cXhWd[i" j^[ Wdj[hebWj[hWb ijhkYjkh[i e\ j^[ ikfhWi[b# bWh fohWc_Z Wh[ [nfei[Z0 j^[ _fi_bWj[hWb 9D ??" Y^_Wic" WdZ j^[ ikfhWYb_de_Z i[]c[dj e\ j^[ ?97 WdZ j^[ 7' i[]c[dj$ J^[ \hedjWb beX[ _i c_d_cWbbo h[jhWYj[Z WdZ j^[ ?DEF WdZ EF97 m_dZemiWh[ef[d[Z<_]$($&$(+$ Ij[f) 7\j[hef[d_d]j^[_fi_bWj[hWbIobl_WdÓiikh[_dW c[Z_WbjebWj[hWbZ_h[Yj_ed"j^[ÓhijfWhje\j^[ C97YWdX[i[[d$Dej[j^Wj\hecj^[ikX\hed# jWbZ_h[Yj_ed"j^[C'i[]c[djYWdX[efj_cWbbo l_ikWb_p[Zm_j^ekjh[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWb beX[$Ifb_jj_d]e\j^[Iobl_WdÓiikh[_dWc[Z_Wb jebWj[hWbZ_h[Yj_ed_ij_c[#Yedikc_d]WdZb[ii jhWkcWj_Yj^Wdj^[bWj[hWbjec[Z_WbZ_h[Yj_ed" ki_d] W \hedjej[cfehWb fj[h_edWb YhWd_ejeco <_]$($&$(,$
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
Ij[f* :_ii[Yj_d]W]W_djej^[c_Zb_d["j^[[dj_h[7' i[]c[dj YWd X[ WffheWY^[Z$ Dej[ j^[ 79e7 WdZ j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWb 7'$ J^[ bWc_dW j[hc_# dWb_i _i Wbie l_i_Xb[$ 7d[khoici e\ j^[ 79e7 YWd X[ m[bb WffheWY^[Z l_W j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb YhWd_ejeco"[l[dm_j^ekjh[celWbe\j^[]ohki h[Yjki$ Dej[ j^[ >[kXd[h Whj[ho ed j^[ h_]^j i_Z[<_]$($&$(-$
b[\j7'i[]c[dj bWc_dW j[hc_dWb_i 79e7Yecfb[n h_]^j7'i[]c[dj >[kXd[hWhj[ho
<_]$($&$(-
Ij[f+ J^[Z_ii[Yj_ed_iYedj_dk[Z_dj^[YedjhWbWj[hWb Z_h[Yj_ed eXi[hl_d] j^[ effei_d] 9D ?? WdZ ?97$Dej[j^[if[Y_Wbh[bWj_edi^_fX[jm[[dj^[ efj_Y d[hl[ WdZ YWhej_Z Whj[ho WdZ j^[ eh_]_d e\ j^[ Ef^j7$ C[Z_Wb beYWj[Z Wd[khoici e\ j^[ Ef^j7 YWd X[ efj_cWbbo WffheWY^[Z j^hek]^WYedjhWbWj[hWbikX\hedjWbYhWd_ejeco <_]$($&$(.$
fbWdkc if^[de_ZWb[ Ef^j7 b[\j9D?? b[\j?97 h_]^j9D??
<_]$($&$(.
Ij[f, 7YYehZ_d] je j^[ a[o^eb[ YedY[fj" j^[ YedjhW# bWj[hWb?97X_\khYWj_edYWdX[WbieWffheWY^[Z j^hek]^ j^[ b_c_j[Z ikfhWehX_jWb YhWd_ejeco$ J^[YWhej_ZY_ij[hdWdZj^[Iobl_WdÓiikh[Wh[ ef[d[Z1dej[j^[j[cfehWbbeX[WdZj^[7'WdZ C'i[]c[djie\j^[effei_j[i_Z[<_]$($&$(/$
j[cfehWbbeX[ 9D?? b[\jC'i[]c[dj ?97 b[\j7'i[]c[dj
<_]$($&$(/
*/
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
Ij[f- Ki_d] ^_]^[h cW]d_ÓYWj_ed" j^[ _fi_bWj[hWb ikfhWi[bbWh ijhkYjkh[i Wh[ W]W_d l_ikWb_p[Z$ Dej[j^[WdWjec_YWbm_dZemiX[jm[[dijhkY# jkh[ie\j^[9D??"?97"9D???WdZj^[Wdj[h_eh f[jheYb_de_Zb_]Wc[dj$J^hek]^j^[i[m_dZemi j^[ Z[[f#i[Wj[Z fh[fedj_d[ WdZ _dj[hf[Zkd# YkbWhY_ij[hdiYWdX[WffheWY^[Z<_]$($&$)&$
7FYB 9D??? 9D?? ?97
<_]$($&$)&
Ij[f. 7\j[h\khj^[hZ_ii[Yj_ed"j^[Z[[f#i[Wj[Z_dj[h# f[ZkdYkbWh ijhkYjkh[i YWd X[ WffheWY^[Z j^hek]^ j^[ WdWjec_YWb m_dZemi$ ?d j^_i YWi[" j^[ _fi_bWj[hWb I97 WdZ j^[ XWi_bWh jhkda Wh[ i[[d j^hek]^ j^[ EF97 m_dZem <_]$($&$)'$
9D?? ?97 87 I97
<_]$($&$)'
+&
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
+$:khW"Xed[WdZmekdZYbeikh[ 7\j[hYecfb[j_ede\ j^[_djhWYhWd_WbfheY[Zkh[" j^[ikXWhWY^de_Z ifWY[_iÓbb[Zm_j^Whj_ÓY_Wb9I<iebkj_edWjXeZoj[cf[hWjkh[$J^[ ZkhWb_dY_i_ed_iYbei[ZmWj[hj_]^jki_d][_j^[h_dj[hhkfj[ZehYed# j_dkekiikjkh[i$?\Z[^_iY[dY[^WiZ[l[bef[Z_dj^[ZkhWbef[d_d]" Wf_[Y[e\ckiYb[YWdX[i[md_djej^[ZkhWbYbeikh[$7fbWj[e\][b# \eWc_ifbWY[Z[njhWZkhWbbo$J^[Xed[ÔWf_iÓn[Zm_j^Wj_jWd_kc c_d_fbWj["Ybei_d]j^[fh[l_ekibof[h\ehc[ZXkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_ed$ Dej[j^Wjj^[Xed[ÔWfi^ekbZX[j_]^jboÓn[ZXej^c[Z_WbboWdZ \hedjWbbojeWY^_[l[efj_cWbYeic[j_Yh[ikbji$7\j[hÓdWbl[h_ÓYWj_ed e\^[ceijWi_i" j^[ckiYkbWhWdZikXYkjWd[ekibWo[hiWh[Ybei[Z m_j^ _dj[hhkfj[Z ikjkh[i WdZ j^[ ia_d m_j^ W hkdd_d] ikjkh[ eh ij[h_b[WZ^[i_l[jWf[i$EdWYYekdje\j^[b_c_j[Zia_d_dY_i_edWdZ dedjhWkcWj_Yikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk["WikYj_edZhW_d_idejd[Y[iiWho$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i ?dWZ[gkWj[fh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]e\j^[fWj_[dj m_j^ikXi[gk[dj_dWZ[gkWj[[nfeikh[e\j^[jWh][jh[]_edWdZ i_]d_ÓYWdj Z[j[h_ehWj_ed _d [\ÓY_[dYo e\ ikh]_YWbbo [nY_i_d] j^[ b[i_ed$FbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]_ij^[jWiae\j^[ikh][ed J^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed _i f[h\ehc[Z jee c[Z_Wbbo m_j^ Yedi[gk[dj _d`khojej^[ikfhWehX_jWbd[hl[WdZfeijef[hWj_l[\hedjWbdkcX# d[ii$ F[d[jhWj_ede\j^[ehX_jZkh_d]Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_edm_j^feij# ef[hWj_l[ehX_jWb^[cWjecWWdZim[bb_d]$ El[hbeea[Z"XkjhWh[bokdWle_ZWXb[_d`khojej^[ZkhWZkh_d]YhW# d_ejeco$:khWbh[YedijhkY_edcWoX[d[Y[iiWho$ F[d[jhWj_ede\ j^[\hedjWbfWhWdWiWbi_dki$J^[ef[d_d]i^ekbZ X[Ybei[Zm_j^mWn"f[h_eij[WbckiYb[ÔWfehWXZec_dWb\Wj je Wle_Zfeijef[hWj_l[9I<b[Wa$ F[d[jhWj_ed e\ j^[ ehX_j Zkh_d] [njhWZkhWb h[celWb e\ eii[eki [nj[di_edie\j^[ehX_jWbhee\m_j^feijef[hWj_l[ehX_jWb^[cW# jecWWdZim[bb_d]$ ?dWZ[gkWj[h[celWbe\9I<m_j^_d`khojej^[\hedjWbbeX[Zk[je ifWjkbWfh[iikh[$ ?d`kh_[ijedkc[hekid[hl[iWdZl[ii[bi_dj^[fWhWi[bbWhh[]_ed Zkh_d] c_Yheikh]_YWb cWd_fkbWj_ed h[ikbj_d] _d feijef[hWj_l[ d[khebe]_YWbZ[j[h_ehWj_ed$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ _djhWYhWd_Wb ^[ceijWi_i m_j^ ikXi[gk[dj h[Xb[[Z# _d]$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ZkhWbYbeikh[m_j^feijef[hWj_l[9I<b[Wa$
+'
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
?dWZ[gkWj[fei_j_ed_d]WdZÓnWj_ede\j^[Xed[ÔWf$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ ^[ceijWi_i _d j^[ f[h_ehX_jWb h[]_ed YWki_d] feij# ef[hWj_l[ie\jj_iik[^[cWjecW$
<_]$($&$)(
J_fiWdZjh_Yai JWa[j_c[\ehfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]e\fWj_[dji$ J^[ h[mWhZ _i Wd [nY[bb[dj el[hl_[m e\ j^[ jWh][j Wh[W WdZ Wd [\ÓY_[djmeha_d]fei_j_ed$
<_]$($&$))
<eh i_cfb[ Yedjheb e\ Yehh[Yj fei_j_ed_d] e\ j^[ fWj_[djÊi ^[WZ" [nfei_d] j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh h[]_ed" dej[ j^[ \ebbem_d] jh_Ya0 j^[ dWieehX_jWb [djhWdY[ jekY^[Z Xo j^[ ÔWj ^WdZ i^ekbZ i^em W ^eh_pedjWbfbWd[<_]$($&$)($ CWa[WYWh[\kbWdWjec_YWbeh_[djWj_edWdZki[ j^[ j^h[[ij[fi e\cWha_d]m_j^Wij[h_b[f[d0'$eii[ekiijhkYjkh[iWdZd[hl[i1 ($fbWY[c[dje\YhWd_ejeco1)$ia_d_dY_i_ed$
<_]$($&$)*
?\j^[[o[Xhem_idejZec_dWdj"j^[ia_d_dY_i_edi^ekbZX[cWZ[ _dWYh[Wi[ehiYWhe\j^[ikfhWehX_jWbWh[W$7bj[hdWj_l[bo"Wd_dY_# i_edX[^_dZj^[^W_hb_d[_iWbiefeii_Xb[<_]$($&$))$ 8o h[jhWYj_d] j^[ ie\j j_iik[" j^[ \hedjWb ckiYb[ i^ekbZ X[ h[jhWYj[ZZemdmWhZim_j^jmeehj^h[[ijhed]ikjkh[ijeWY^_[l[ ik\ÓY_[djel[hl_[me\j^[\hedjWbXed[$;nfeikh[WdZceX_b_pW# j_ede\j^[\hedjWbWdZehX_jWbckiYb[kfmWhZjej^[ikfhWehX_jWb h_ci^ekbZX[h[ijh_Yj[Z je j^[d[Y[iiWhoc_d_ckc jefh[l[dj feijef[hWj_l[f[h_ehX_jWb^[cWjecW$Ie\jj_iik[i^ekbZX[YWh[# \kbboh[jhWYj[Zjefh[l[djfeijef[hWj_l[d[Yhei_i<_]$($&$)*$
<_]$($&$)+
8[ YWh[\kb Zkh_d] j^[ Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_ed0 WZ[gkWj[ fbWY[# c[dj Xkj _dWZ[gkWj[ Z_h[Yj_ed e\ j^[ Xkhh_d] fheY[Zkh[ cWo Wbief[d[jhWj[j^[ehX_j<_]$($&$)+$ <_]$($&$),
IjW][i e\ YhWd_ejeco <_]$ ($&$),0 '$ Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_ed1 ($\hedjeXWiWbYkjj_d]m_j^j^[YhWd_ejec[fWhWbb[bjej^[ehX_jWb h_c _d W bWj[hWb je c[Z_Wb Z_h[Yj_ed1 )$ iWm_d] _d W i[c_bkdWh \Wi^_ed \hec j^[ Xkhh ^eb[ je j^[ c[Z_Wb [Z][ e\ j^[ \ehc[h YhWd_ejecob_d[$
+(
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^
<_]$($&$)-
<_]$($&$).
:h_bb_d]e\j^[_dd[h[Z][e\j^[YhWd_ejecoW\j[hh[celWbe\j^[ Xed[ ÔWf _i _cfehjWdj \eh b_c_j[Z WffheWY^[i$ IcWbb eii[eki [nj[di_edie\j^[ehX_jWbhee\i^ekbZWbieX[YWh[\kbboh[cel[Zje fhel_Z[Wd[nY[bb[djel[hl_[mWdZjeWbbemc_Yheikh]_YWbWYY[ii jeZ[[f#i[Wj[Zi_j[i<_]$($&$)-$ Ef[d j^[ ZkhW _d W Ç9È i^Wf[Z" i[c_bkdWh \Wi^_ed WdZ ^ebZ j^[ ZkhWb ÔWf jemWhZi j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb h_c m_j^ jme ikjkh[i <_]$($&$).$ 7\j[h Yecfb[j_ed e\ j^[ _djhWZkhWb Z_ii[Yj_ed" ZkhWb Ybeikh[ i^ekbZX[cWZ[mWj[hj_]^jki_d][_j^[h_dj[hhkfj[ZehYedj_dk# ekiikjkh[$?\Z[^_iY[dY[^WiZ[l[bef[Z_dj^[ZkhWbef[d_d]"W f_[Y[e\ckiYb[YWdX[i[md_djej^[ZkhWbYbeikh[<_]$($&$)/$
<_]$($&$)/
?\ j^[ \hedjWb fWhWdWiWb i_dki _i f[d[jhWj[Z" YWh[\kb Ybeikh[ _i h[gk_h[Z$8ed[mWn"WÔWfe\]Wb[WehWXZec_dWb\Wjj_iik[YWdX[ ki[Z\ehj^_ifkhfei[<_]$($&$*&$ 7\j[hZkhWbYbeikh[" j^[Xed[ÔWfi^ekbZX[ j_]^jboÓn[Zc[Z_# Wbbo WdZ \hedjWbbo je WY^_[l[ efj_cWb Yeic[j_Y h[ikbji$ 7 j_jW# d_kcfbWj[YWdX[ki[Z\ehYbeikh[e\j^[Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_ed <_]$($&$*'$ J^[[o[Xhemia_d_dY_i_edi^ekbZX[Ybei[Zm_j^_djhWYkjWd[eki hkdd_d]ikjkh[iehm_j^ij[h_b[WZ^[i_l[jWf[i$
<_]$($&$*&
EdWYYekdje\j^[b_c_j[Zia_d_dY_i_edWdZdedjhWkcWj_Yikh]_# YWbj[Y^d_gk["WikYj_edZhW_d_idejh[gk_h[Z$
<_]$($&$*'
+)
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^rbWj[hWblWh_Wj_ed
($' BWj[hWblWh_Wj_ed e\j^[ikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco J^[[ii[dY[e\j^[bWj[hWblWh_Wj_ede\j^[ikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco _idejedboj^[ceh[bWj[hWbfbWY[c[dje\j^[a[o^eb[YhWd_ejeco XkjWbieWfWhj_Wbh[celWbe\j^[b[ii[hif^[de_Zm_d]"Wbie[nfei# _d] j^[\hedjWbWdZ j[cfehWbZkhWcWj[h<_]$($'$'$J^[fj[h_edWb ikh]_YWbYehh_Zeh[nfei[ij^[Wdj[hec[Z_Wbj[cfehWbbeX["\hedjWb bWj[he#XWiWbYehj[n"j^[Iobl_WdÓiikh[WdZj^[ikfhWi[bbWhfohWc_Z ceh[\hecj^[i_Z[$J^_iWbbemiiW\[Z_ii[Yj_ede\j^[Wdj[h_ehfWhj e\ j^[ YWl[hdeki i_dki WdZ j^[ fWhWYb_de_Z h[]_ed$ Ceh[el[h" Xo h[cel_d]j^[Wdj[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii"j^[fWhWYb_de_Zi[]c[dje\ j^[ _dj[hdWb YWhej_Z Whj[ho YWd Wbie X[ [nfei[Z m_j^ekj ef[d_d] j^[l[dekiY^WcX[he\j^[YWl[hdekii_dki$ <_]$($'$' IY^[cWj_Yf_Yjkh[Z[cedijhWj_d]j^[W_ce\j^[ bWj[hWblWh_Wj_ede\j^[ikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco$H[celWb e\ j^[b[ii[hif^[de_Zm_d]fhel_Z[iWfj[h_edWbikh]_YWb Yehh_Zeh\ehXheWZ\hedjej[cfehWb[nfbehWj_ed$
?dj^[\ebbem_d]"j^[ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[e\j^[bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWb WffheWY^_iZ[iYh_X[Z$
?fi_bWj[hWb
C_Zb_d[
9edjhWbWj[hWb
Hee\WdZbWj[hWbmWbbe\j^[ehX_j 7dj[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii Feij[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii 9^WcX[he\j^[9I BWj[he#XWiWb\hedjWbbeX[ Iobl_WdÓiikh[ 7dj[hec[Z_Wbj[cfehWbbeX[ 9hkiY[h[Xh_ 9D?"9D??"9D???"9D?L 9DL"9DL? ?97"Ef^j7"F9e7"79^7" _dYb$f[h\ehWjehi 7'"7("C'"C("F'"F("I97
9h_ijW=Wbb_ Eb\WYjeho]heel[ FbWdkcif^[de_ZWb[ JkX[hYkbkci[bbW[ 9^_Wic BWc_dWj[hc_dWb_i F_jk_jWhoijWba 79e7 :_ijWb87"_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi
EhX_jWbhee\ 7dj[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii 8WiWb\hedjWbbeX[ Iobl_WdÓiikh[ J[cfehWbfeb[ 9D?"9D??"9D??? ?97"Ef^j7"F9e7"79^7 7'"7("C'"C("F'"I97" _dYb$f[h\ehWjehi
JWXb[($'$' 7dWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[iWffheWY^[Zj^hek]^j^[bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco$
++
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^rbWj[hWblWh_Wj_ed
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[ '$FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] J^[fWj_[dj_ifei_j_ed[Zikf_d[$?\ki[Z"j^[i_d]b[f_de\j^[CWo# Ó[bZ YbWcf i^ekbZ X[ fbWY[Z ed j^[ effei_j[ i_Z[" Wbbem_d] \h[[ cWd_fkbWj_ed Zkh_d] ikh][ho$ J^[ f_di i^ekbZ dej X[ fbWY[Z _d j^[j[cfehWb_ickiYb[jeWle_Z_dijWX_b_joe\j^[ioij[cWdZfeij# ef[hWj_l[j[cfehWb^[cWjecW$ <_]$($'$(
Ij[f' M_j^j^[fWj_[dj_dWikf_d[fei_j_ed"j^[^[WZ_i[b[lWj[ZWffhen_# cWj[bo'+WXel[j^[b[l[be\j^[j^ehWn$J^_icWd[klh[\WY_b_jWj[i j^[ Y[h[XhWb l[deki ZhW_dW][ WdZ fhel_Z[i [\\[Yj_l[ Z[Yecfh[i# i_ed e\ j^[ cW_d Y[hl_YWb l[ii[bi" bWhodn WdZ l[dj_bWj_ed jkX[ <_]$($'$($
Ij[f( 9W$ (& h[jheÔ[n_ed ikffehji j^[ ]hWl_jo#h[bWj[Z i[b\#h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[\hedjWbbeX[$7ij^[bWj[hWblWh_Wj_ed_iki[Z\ehWffheWY^_d]j^[ bWj[hWbikfhWi[bbWhh[]_edWdZj^[9I"j^[Z[]h[[e\h[jheÔ[Yj_ed_i kikWbbob[iij^Wdj^Wj\ehikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco<_]$($'$)$
Ij[f) J^[h[W\j[h" j^[ ^[WZ _i hejWj[Z )& je -+ je j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWb i_Z[ WYYehZ_d] je j^[ fh[Y_i[ beYWj_ed e\ j^[ b[i_ed$ 9ecfWh[Z je ikfhWehX_jWb YhWd_ejeco" j^[ ceh[ fj[h_edWbbo i_jkWj[Z bWj[hWb lWh_Wj_ed h[gk_h[i ceh[ hejWj_ed0 \eh j^[ bWj[hWb 9I" W hejWj_ed e\ YW$ *& WdZ \eh j^[ eb\WYjeho ]heel[ j^Wj e\ .& _i ik\ÓY_[dj$ Dej[ j^Wj h_]^j#^WdZ[Z ikh][edi ki_d] W b[\j#i_Z[Z YhWd_ejeco d[[Z ceh[ hejWj_ed je fhel_Z[ Wd [\ÓY_[dj meha_d] fei_j_ed <_]$($'$*$
<_]$($'$)
<_]$($'$*
Ij[f* I_c_bWh je j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb YhWd_ejeco" j^[ ^[WZ cWo X[ bWj[he# Ô[Yj[ZYW$'&jej^[YedjhWbWj[hWbi_Z["Wbbem_d]Wd[\ÓY_[djmeha# _d]fei_j_ed\ehj^[ikh][ed<_]$($'$+$ <_]$($'$+
+,
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^rbWj[hWblWh_Wj_ed
($7dWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZeh_[djWj_ed <ehWdefj_cWbia_d_dY_i_ed"j^[_cfehjWdjWdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhai e\ j^[eii[ekiiakbbikY^Wi j^[]bWX[bbW"\hedjWbfWhWdWiWbi_dki" ikfhWehX_jWb\ehWc[d"j[cfehWbb_d["\hedjeXWi_i"_cfh[ii_ede\j^[ b[ii[hif^[de_Zm_d]WdZj^[po]ecWj_YWhY^Wh[fh[Y_i[boZ[Ód[Z WdZcWha[Z$Dej[j^[Yekhi[e\j^[ikfhWehX_jWbd[hl[iWdZWhj[ho" WdZj^[\hedjWbXhWdY^e\j^[\WY_Wbd[hl[<_]$($'$,$ 7\j[hfei_j_ed_d]"j^[_dZ_l_ZkWbefj_ckcb_d[e\j^[ia_d_dY_i_ed _icWha[Zm_j^j^[f[d"fbWY[Z+Å'&ccbWj[hWbbojej^[ikfhWeh# X_jWb \ehWc[d hkdd_d] m_j^_d WdZ [nj[dZ_d] iec[ c_bb_c[j[hi el[h j^[ bWj[hWb [Z][ e\ j^[ [o[Xhem$ J^[ c_Zfe_dj e\ j^_i ia_d _dY_i_edkikWbboYehh[ifedZijej^[j[cfehWbb_d[<_]$($'$,$?\j^[ [o[XhemWff[Whij^_d"j^[bWj[hWbbofbWY[Zia_d_dY_i_edcWo]_l[W ikXefj_cWbYeic[j_Yh[ikbj$?dj^_iYWi[j^[ia_d_dY_i_edi^ekbZX[ f[h\ehc[ZX[^_dZ j^[\hedjej[cfehWb^W_hb_d[eh_dWfhec_d[dj mh_dab[$J^[ [o[b_Zi Wh[ fhej[Yj[Z YWh[\kbbo WdZ j^[ ia_d _i Z_i_d# \[Yj[Zm_j^WbYe^ebiebkj_ed$
<_]$($'$, :[Ód_j_ede\j^[YhWd_ejecoWYYehZ_d]jej^[WdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaie\ j^[ \hedjej[cfehWb h[]_ed$J^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed i^ekbZ X[ cWZ[ m_j^_d j^[ [o[Xhem" [nj[dZ_d] iec[ c_bb_c[j[hi el[h _ji bWj[hWb [Z][$ ?d j^[ YWi[ e\ W j^_d WdZ ded# Zec_dWdj[o[Xhem"j^[_dY_i_edYWdX[WbieYedY[Wb[ZX[^_dZj^[^W_hb_d[$
+-
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^rbWj[hWblWh_Wj_ed
)$9hWd_ejeco Ij[f' H_]^j i_Z[$ J^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed X[]_di WXekj +Å'&cc bWj[hWbbo \hec j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb _dY_ikhWWdZ_if[h\ehc[Zm_j^_dj^[[o[Xhem" [nj[dZ_d] W \[m c_bb_c[j[hi el[h j^[ bWj[hWb fhe`[Yj_ed e\ j^[ Xhem _dje j^[ \hedjepo]e# cWj_Y Wh[W$ 7\j[h ia_d _dY_i_ed j^[ ikXYkjW# d[eki j_iik[ _i Z_ii[Yj[Z _d W \hedjWb" \hedje# bWj[hWbZ_h[Yj_ed<_]$($'$-$
<_]$($'$-
<_]$($'$.
Ij[f( J^[h[W\j[h" j^[ ÔWfi Wh[ h[jhWYj[Z" fki^[Z ][djbo kf jemWhZi j^[ ehX_j WdZ h[jhWYj[Z ijhed]bo ZemdmWhZi _d W \hedjWb Z_h[Yj_ed je WY^_[l[ efj_cWb [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ eYY_f_je# \hedjWb" ehX_YkbWh WdZ j[cfehWb ckiYb[i$ 9ecfWh[Z m_j^ j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb YhWd_ejeco" j^[ bWj[hWb lWh_Wdj e\\[hi ceh[ [nfbehWj_ed e\ j^[j[cfehWb_ickiYb[<_]$($'$.$
<_]$($'$/
Ij[f) J^[\hedjWbX[bboe\j^[eYY_f_je\hedjWbckiYb[ _i Ykj fWhWbb[b je j^[ ehX_jWb h_c _d W c[Z_Wb je bWj[hWb Z_h[Yj_ed WdZ j^[ j[cfehWb ckiYb[ _i ijh_ff[Z \hec _ji Xedo _di[hj_ed m_j^ W cedefebWh [b[YjheZ[ ad_\[$ 9ecfWh[Z m_j^ j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb YhWd_ejeco" j^[ j[cfehWb ckiYb[i^ekbZX[ceh[ceX_b["Wbbem_d][nfe# ikh[e\j^[fj[h_ed$>[ceijWi_ii^ekbZX[f[h# \ehc[ZhWf_ZboWdZm_j^fh[Y_i_ed<_]$($'$/$
+.
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^rbWj[hWblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f* J^[j[cfehWbckiYb[_ij^[d\ehY_Xboh[jhWYj[Z bWj[hWbbo"[nfei_d]j^[_cfh[ii_ede\j^[b[ii[h if^[de_Z m_d] X[jm[[d j^[ \hedjWb WdZ j[c# fehWb iakbb XWi[$ J^[ \hedjWb ckiYkbWh bWo[h _i h[jhWYj[Z \ehY[\kbbo ZemdmWhZi m_j^ ijhed]" YWh[\kb ij_jY^[i$ 7\j[h ie\j j_iik[ Z_ii[Yj_ed" W i_d]b[\hedjeXWiWbXkhh^eb[_iZh_bb[Z`kijfeij[# h_ehjej^[j[cfehWbb_d[m_j^W^_]^#if[[ZZh_bb <_]$($'$'&$
<_]$($'$'&
Ij[f+ J^[^eb[_i[dbWh][ZWb_jjb[m_j^Ód[fkdY^[i$ 7\j[h ceX_b_pWj_ed e\ j^[ ZkhW cWj[h" W YW$ '&cc bed] ijhW_]^j b_d[ _i Ykj m_j^ W ^_]^# if[[Z YhWd_ejec[ fWhWbb[b je j^[ ehX_jWb h_c _dWbWj[hWbjec[Z_WbZ_h[Yj_ed<_]$($'$''$
<_]$($'$''
Ij[f, 7\j[h j^[ \hedjeXWiWb Ykjj_d]" W i[c_Y_hYkbWh b_d[_iYkjWjÓhijbWj[hWbbo\hecj^[Xkhh^eb[" j^[d je j^[ c[Z_Wb XehZ[h e\ j^[ fh[l_ekibo Ykj\hedjeXWiWbb_d["Yh[Wj_d]WXed[ÔWfm_j^ W m_Zj^ e\ YW$ '+Å(+ cc WdZ W b[d]j^ e\ YW$ (&Å)&cc<_]$($'$'($
<_]$($'$'(
+/
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^rbWj[hWblWh_Wj_ed
<_]$($'$')
Ij[f- 7\j[hh[celWbe\j^[Xed[ÔWf"j^[_dd[h[Z][e\ j^[Xed[WXel[j^[ehX_jWbh_cWdZj^[bWj[hWb fWhje\j^[b[ii[hif^[de_Zm_d]Wh[h[cel[Z m_j^W^_]^#if[[ZZh_bb[nfei_d]j^[jhWdi_j_ed X[jm[[dj^[\hedjWbWdZj[cfehWbZkhWcWj[h$ IcWbb Xedo fhejhki_edi e\ j^[ ehX_jWb hee\ i^ekbZ Wbie X[ Zh_bb[Z [njhWZkhWbbo je eXjW_d efj_cWb_djhWZkhWb[nfeikh[<_]$($'$')$
<_]$($'$'*
Ij[f. 7\j[h [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ \hedjej[cfehWb ZkhW cWj[h" j^[ Zkhejeco i^ekbZ X[ f[h\ehc[Z _d W Ykhl[Z \Wi^_ed m_j^ _ji XWi[ jemWhZi j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb h_c [nfei_d] j^[ Iobl_Wd Ói# ikh[X[jm[[d j^[\hedjWbWdZ j[cfehWbbeX[i <_]$($'$'*$
<_]$($'$'+
Ij[f/ J^[ \hedjWb WdZ j[cfehWb beX[i Wh[ [nfei[Z W\j[hef[d_d]j^[ZkhWcWj[h$J^[ZkhWbÔWf_i Ón[ZXWiWbbom_j^^ebZ_d]ikjkh[i<_]$($'$'+$
,&
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^rbWj[hWblWh_Wj_ed
*$?djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ij[f' H_]^ji_Z[$:_ii[Yj_eded\h[i^^kcWdYWZWl[h1 Whj[h_Wbl[ii[biWh[Óbb[Zm_j^h[ZYebeh[ZbWj[n iebkj_ed$7\j[hm_j^ZhWm_d]j^[Xed[ÔWf"j^[ b[ii[hif^[de_Zm_d]_iYWh[\kbboh[cel[Zm_j^ WÓd[^_]^#if[[ZZ_WcedZZh_bb$7\j[hYecfb[j[ h[celWbe\j^[Wdj[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii"j^[9D?? WdZj^[fWhWYb_de_Zi[]c[dje\j^[?97YWdX[ fh[Y_i[bo eXi[hl[Z$ J^[ Yel[h_d] ZkhW cWj[h e\ j^[ Wdj[h_eh Yb_de_Z" m^_Y^ i^ekbZ X[ a[fj _djWYj"\ehcij^[ie#YWbb[Zfhen_cWbWdZZ_ijWb h_d]ie\j^[YWhej_ZWhj[ho$J^[fhen_cWbZkhWb h_d]i[fWhWj[ij^[l[dekiYecfWhjc[djie\j^[ 9I\hecj^[fWhWYb_de_ZWh[WYel[h_d]j^[9D???$ J^[ZkhWbi^[[je\j^[Z_ijWbh_d][dY_hYb[ij^[ ?97WdZj^[9D??WdZWbie\ehcij^[\WbY_\ehc b_]Wc[dje\j^[efj_Yd[hl[<_]$($'$',$ Ij[f( 7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ ZkhW cWj[h" j^[ YWhej_Z Y_i# j[hdWdZj^[c[Z_WbfWhje\j^[Iobl_WdÓiikh[ Wh[ Z_ii[Yj[Z$ 7\j[h h[celWb e\ 9I<" j^[ \hed# jWb WdZ j[cfehWb beX[i Z[ÔWj[" Wbbem_d] _djhW# ZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_edm_j^c_d_cWbXhW_dh[jhWYj_ed$ Dej[ j^[ ef[d_d] e\ j^[ EF97 m_dZem m_j^ Ód[ c_YheiY_iiehi$ J^[ \hedjWb beX[ _i ][djbo h[jhWYj[Zm_j^WifWjkbW<_]$($'$'-$
j[cfehWb ZkhWcWj[h 9D?? 9D??? fWhWYb_de_Z?97
<_]$($'$',
j[cfehWbbeX[ ?97 9D??
<_]$($'$'-
Ij[f) EXi[hlWj_ede\j^[bWj[hWbikfhWi[bbWhfohWc_Z$ 9ecfWh[Zjej^[ikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco"j^[ ikfhWi[bbWhijhkYjkh[iWh[l_ikWb_p[Zceh[\hec j^[bWj[hWbi_Z[1dej[j^[9D??"efj_YjhWYj"?97 WdZ9D???$Ki_d]j^_ibWj[hWb#fj[h_edWbikh]_YWb Yehh_Zeh"h[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[m_j^W Z_ii[Yjeh_id[Y[iiWho\ehefj_cWb[nfeikh[e\ j^[ikfhWi[bbWhh[]_ed<_]$($'$'.$
9D??? F9F 9D?? ?97 efj_YjhWYj
<_]$($'$'.
,'
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^rbWj[hWblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f* :_ii[Yj_d]_dj^[c[Z_WbZ_h[Yj_ed"j^[Y^_Wic WdZXej^efj_Yd[hl[iWh[eXi[hl[Z$Dej[j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWb 9D ??1 j^[ Z_ii[Yjeh _i fe_dj_d] jej^[79e7Yecfb[nWdZj^[effei_j[7'i[]# c[dje\j^[797<_]$($'$'/$
b[\j9D?? h_]^j9D?? Y^_Wic
<_]$($'$'/
Ij[f+ EXi[hlWj_ed e\ j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWb ?97 X_\khYW# j_ed$ J^hek]^ j^[ bWj[hWb#fj[h_edWb WffheWY^" j^[ Y^_Wic WdZ j^[ effei_j[ 9D ?? ckij X[ h[jhWYj[Z je h[l[Wb j^[ ?971 W Yb[Wh Z_iWZlWd# jW][YecfWh[Zjej^[ikX\hedjWbikfhWehX_jWb WffheWY^$ Dej[ j^[ effei_d] j[cfehWb beX[ X[^_dZ j^[ ?971 j^[ C97 Z_iWff[Whi m_j^_d j^[ effei_j[ Iobl_Wd Óiikh[$ Dej[ j^[ bWc_dW j[hc_dWb_i<_]$($'$(&$
b[\j9D?? j[cfehWbbeX[ C97 ?97X_\khYWj_ed bWc_dWj[hc_dWb_i
<_]$($'$(&
Ij[f, 7ffheWY^_d] W]W_d \hec j^[ _fi_bWj[hWb i_Z[" j^[ Yel[h_d] ZkhW cWj[h e\ j^[ fh[l_ekibo h[cel[ZWdj[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii_i_dY_i[ZWdZ h[jhWYj[Z m_j^ c_Yhe\ehY[fi" Wbbem_d] W Yb[Wh Z[f_Yj_ede\j^[Z_ijWbZkhWbh_d][dY_hYb_d]j^[ ?97$Dej[j^[ikfhW#WdZfWhWYb_de_Zi[]c[dji e\j^[?97WdZj^[9D???<_]$($'$('$
fWhWYb_de_Z?97 Z_ijWbZkhWbh_d] h_]^j9D??? ikfhWYb_de_Z?97
<_]$($'$('
,(
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^rbWj[hWblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f- J^[hee\e\j^[YWl[hdekii_dki_ief[d[ZWdZ h[jhWYj[Z c[Z_Wbbo m_j^ c_Yhe\ehY[fi$ J^[ fhen_cWbh_d]ehie#YWbb[ZYWhej_Ye#Yb_de_Zb_]W# c[djWff[Whic[Z_Wbjej^[9D???"Ybei_d]j^[ l[dekiY^WcX[he\j^[YWl[hdekii_dki$Dej[ j^[ fWhWYb_de_Z ?97 WdZ j^[ ?97 X_\khYWj_ed m_j^_dj^[ikXWhWY^de_ZifWY[<_]$($'$(($
fWhWYb_de_Z?97 Z_ijWbh_d] fhen_cWbh_d] 9D??? ?97X_\khYWj_ed
<_]$($'$((
Ij[f. 7\j[h h[i[Yj_ed e\ j^[ fhen_cWb h_d] WdZ j^[ [dj_h[ hee\ e\ j^[ YWl[hdeki i_dki" j^[ Y^Wc# X[he\j^[YWl[hdekii_dki_ief[d[Z$Dej[j^[ ikfhWYb_de_Z" fWhWYb_de_Z WdZ _djhWYWl[hdeki i[]c[djie\j^[?97$J^[9D???WdZ9D?LZ_iWf# f[Wh_djej^[ikf[h_ehehX_jWbÓiikh[$J^[87YWd X[eXi[hl[Zm_j^_dj^[feij[h_eh\eiiWc[Z_Wb \hecj^[ikXWhWY^de_ZWbfehj_ede\j^[9D??? <_]$($'$()$
9D?L fWhWYb_de_Z?97 _djhWYWl[hdeki?97 9D??? ikfhWYb_de_Z?97 87
<_]$($'$()
Ij[f/ 7\j[h fWhj_Wb h[celWb e\ j^[ bWj[hWb ZkhWb mWbb e\ j^[ YWl[hdeki i_dki" j^[ feij[h_eh ad[[ e\ j^[ ?97 _i eXi[hl[Z$ 7\j[h ][djb[ h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ i[di_j_l[ 9D ?L" j^[ l[deki Y^WcX[h e\ j^[ feij[h_eh YWl[hdeki i_dki YWd X[ i[[d$ Dej[j^[9D???Wff[Wh_d]X[^_dZj^[F97WdZ Z_iWff[Wh_d] _dje j^[ ikf[h_eh ehX_jWb Óiikh[ <_]$($'$(*$
j[djeh_kc 9D?L 9D??? ?97 87 F97
<_]$($'$(*
,)
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^rbWj[hWblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f'& EXi[hlWj_ede\ j^[ikXWhWY^de_ZWbWdZ_djhW# YWl[hdekii[]c[djie\ j^[9D???W\j[hef[d# _d]j^[YWl[hdekii_dki$Dej[j^[I97"j^[F' WdZ F( i[]c[dji e\ j^[ F97$ J^[ F9e7 Yed# d[Yjij^[?97jej^[F971_dj^_iYWi[j^[F'i[]# c[dj_iceh[fhec_d[djj^Wdj^[F9e7$Dej[ j^[bWj[hWbboZ_ifbWY[Z87m_j^_dj^[feij[h_eh \eiiW$J^[ikfhWYb_de_Z?97_i][djboh[jhWYj[Z m_j^Wc_YheikYa[h<_]$($'$(+$
9D??? 87 F9e7 I97 F97
<_]$($'$(+
Ij[f'' EXi[hlWj_ed e\ j^[ feij[h_eh Y^WcX[h e\ j^[ YWl[hdeki i_dki$ Dej[ j^[ 9DL? hkdd_d] m_j^_d j^[ :eh[bbe YWdWb" X[jm[[d j^[ Yb_lki WdZ=hkX[hÊif[jheYb_lWbb_]Wc[dj$8[^_dZj^[ Yb_lki"j^[Wdj[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[fediYWdWbie X[i[[d<_]$($'$(,$
9DL? =hkX[hÊi b_]Wc[dj _djhWYWl[hdeki?97 9D?L fedi
<_]$($'$(,
Ij[f'( 7\j[h WZZ_j_edWb h[celWb e\ j^[ bWj[hWb i_dki mWbb" j^[ [dj_h[ YWl[hdeki i_dki YWd X[ WffheWY^[Z l_W j^[ bWj[hWb ikfhWehX_jWb YhW# d_ejeco$ Dej[ j^[ _djhWYWl[hdeki ?97" 9D ???" 9D?L"9DLWdZj^[9DL?$J^[l[djhWbikh\WY[ e\ j^[ fedi m_j^ j^[ ikf[h_eh Y[h[X[bbWh WdZ feij[h_ehY[h[XhWbWhj[h_[iWff[Wh_dWif[Y_Wb jhWdiYWl[hdeki Wif[Yj$ Dej[ j^[ Z_l_i_ed e\ j^[I97d[Whjej^[9D?L<_]$($'$(-$
9DL 9DL? 9D?L 9D??? fedi I97
<_]$($'$(-
,*
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^rbWj[hWblWh_Wj_ed
+$:khW"Xed[WdZmekdZYbeikh[ 7\j[h Yecfb[j_ed e\ j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[" j^[ _djhWZkhWb ifWY[_iÓbb[Zm_j^Whj_ÓY_Wb9I<WdZj^[ZkhWYbei[Zm_j^ikjkh[i$ J^[Ybeikh[i^ekbZX[cWZ[mWj[hj_]^jjeWle_Zfeijef[hWj_l[9I< ÓijkbW$?\j[di_edehZ[^_iY[dY[^WiZ[l[bef[Z_dj^[ZkhWbfbWd["W f_[Y[e\ckiYb[YWdX[i[md_djej^[ZkhWbYbeikh[$7fbWj[e\][b# \eWc_ifbWY[Z[njhWZkhWbboWdZj^[Xed[ÔWfÓn[Zm_j^Wj_jWd_kc fbWj[$Dej[j^Wjj^[Xed[ÔWfi^ekbZX[j_]^jboÓn[ZXej^c[Z_# WbboWdZ\hedjWbbojeWY^_[l[efj_cWbYeic[j_Yh[ikbji$?dj^[YWi[e\ bWh][XedoZ[\[YjWh[WiW\j[hh[celWbe\j^[b[ii[hif^[de_Zm_d]" m[e\j[dki[WbWh][#i_p[Zj_jWd_kcfbWj[Wle_Z_d]WYeic[j_YWbbo Z_ijkhX_d]]heel[W\j[hmekdZ^[Wb_d]m_j^_dj^[j[cfehWbWh[W$ 7bj[hdWj_l[bo"Xed[Y[c[djYWdX[ki[ZYel[h_d]j^[XedoZ[\[Yj$ 7\j[h ÓdWb l[h_ÓYWj_ed e\ ^[ceijWi_i" j^[ ckiYkbWh WdZ ikXYkjW# d[eki bWo[hi Wh[ Ybei[Z m_j^ _dj[hhkfj[Z ikjkh[i WdZ j^[ ia_d m_j^Whkdd_d]_djhWYkjWd[ekiikjkh[ehij[h_b[WZ^[i_l[jWf[$De ikYj_edZhW_d_id[Y[iiWho$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i ?dik\ÓY_[djfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]e\j^[fWj_[dj m_j^ikXi[gk[dj_dik\ÓY_[dj[nfeikh[e\j^[ikh]_YWbÓ[bZWdZ i_]d_ÓYWdjZ[j[h_ehWj_ed_d[\ÓY_[dYoe\[nY_i_d]j^[b[i_ed$FbWd# d_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]_ij^[jWiae\j^[ikh][ed J^[ia_d_dY_i_edZe[idej\ebbemj^[ehX_jWbh_cYWki_d]WikX# efj_cWbYeic[j_Yh[ikbj$ F[d[jhWj_ed e\ j^[ ehX_j Zkh_d] Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_ed m_j^ feijef[hWj_l[ehX_jWb^[cWjecWWdZim[bb_d]$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ h[celWb e\ j^[ b[ii[h if^[de_Z m_d] m_j^ b_c_j[Z j[cfehWb[nj[di_ede\ j^[YhWd_ejecoWdZb_c_j[Z[nfeikh[e\ j^[Iobl_WdÓiikh[$ El[hbeea[Z" Xkj e\j[d kdWle_ZWXb[" _d`kho je j^[ ZkhW Zkh_d] YhWd_ejeco$?diec[YWi[i"_cfbWdjWj_ede\fbWij_YcWj[h_WbcWo X[d[Y[iiWho$ F[d[jhWj_ed e\ j^[ ehX_j Zkh_d] [njhWZkhWb h[celWb e\ eii[eki [nj[di_edie\j^[ehX_jWbhee\WdZj^[b[ii[hif^[de_Zm_d]m_j^ ikXi[gk[djfeijef[hWj_l[ehX_jWb^[cWjecWWdZim[bb_d]$ ?dWZ[gkWj[h[celWbe\9I<W\j[hZkhejecom_j^Yedjki_ede\j^[ \hedjWbehj[cfehWbbeX[Zk[jeifWjkbWfh[iikh[$ ?d`kh_[i je dkc[heki d[hl[i WdZ l[ii[bi m_j^_d j^[ fWhWi[bbWh h[]_ed Zkh_d] c_Yheikh]_YWb cWd_fkbWj_ed m_j^ feijef[hWj_l[ d[khebe]_YWbZ[j[h_ehWj_ed$
,+
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^rbWj[hWblWh_Wj_ed
?dWZ[gkWj[_djhWYhWd_Wb^[ceijWi_im_j^feijef[hWj_l[h[Xb[[Z# _d]_djej^[ikh]_YWbÓ[bZ$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ZkhWbYbeikh[m_j^Wfeijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW$ ?dWZ[gkWj[fei_j_ed_d]WdZÓnWj_ede\j^[Xed[ÔWfh[ikbj_d]_d feehYeic[j_Yh[ikbji$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ ^[ceijWi_i Zkh_d] mekdZ Ybeikh[ m_j^ feijef[hW# j_l[ie\jj_iik[^[cWjecW$
<_]$($'$(.
<_]$($'$(/
J_fiWdZjh_Yai JWa[j_c[\ehfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]e\fWj_[dji$ J^[ h[mWhZ _i Wd [nY[bb[dj el[hl_[m e\ j^[ jWh][j Wh[W WdZ Wd [\ÓY_[djmeha_d]fei_j_ed$ CWa[WYWh[\kbWdWjec_YWbeh_[djWj_edWdZki[ j^[ j^h[[ij[fi e\cWha_d]m_j^Wij[h_b[f[d0'$eii[ekiijhkYjkh[iWdZd[hl[i1 ($fbWY[c[dje\YhWd_ejeco1)$ia_d_dY_i_ed$
<_]$($'$)&
9ecfWh[Z je j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb YhWd_ejeco" j^[ bWj[hWb ikfhWeh# X_jWb WffheWY^ h[gk_h[i ceh[ ^[WZ hejWj_ed Zkh_d] fei_j_ed_d] <_]$($'$(.$ ?\ j^[ [o[Xhem _i dej Zec_dWdj" j^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed cWo X[ f[h# \ehc[ZX[^_dZj^[\hedjej[cfehWb^W_hb_d[eh_dWia_dYh[Wi[je WY^_[l[efj_cWbYeic[j_Yh[ikbji<_]$($'$(/$ :kh_d]ie\j j_iik[Z_ii[Yj_ed" j^[\hedjWbckiYb[i^ekbZX[\eh# Y_Xbo h[jhWYj[Z ZemdmWhZi _d W \hedjWb Z_h[Yj_ed m_j^ jme eh j^h[[ikjkh[ifhel_Z_d]ik\ÓY_[djel[hl_[me\j^[\hedjWbXed[$ ;nfeikh[ WdZ ceX_b_iWj_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWb WdZ ehX_jWb ckiYb[i kfmWhZii^ekbZX[h[ijh_Yj[Zjej^[d[Y[iiWhoc_d_ckcjefh[# l[dj feijef[hWj_l[ f[h_ehX_jWb ^[cWjecW$ 9ecfWh[Z m_j^ j^[ ikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco"j^[j[cfehWbckiYb[ckijX[h[jhWYj[Z ceh[\ehY_Xbojej^[bWj[hWbi_Z["Wbbem_d][nfeikh[e\j^[b[ii[h if^[de_Zm_d]$>em[l[h"dej[YWh[\kbh[jhWYj_edjefh[l[djfeij# ef[hWj_l[d[Yhei_i<_]$($'$)&$
<_]$($'$)'
<_]$($'$)(
JeWle_Zf[d[jhWj_ede\j^[ehX_j"jWa[YWh[e\j^[fbWY[c[dje\ j^[Xkhh^eb[WdZZ_h[Yj_ede\j^[Xkhh_d]fheY[Zkh[<_]$($'$)'$ IjW][ie\YhWd_ejeco<_]$($'$)(0'$Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_ed1($\hed# jeXWiWb Ykjj_d] fWhWbb[b je j^[ ehX_jWb h_c1 )$ iWm_d] _d W i[c_#
,,
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^rbWj[hWblWh_Wj_ed
Y_hYkbWh\Wi^_ed\hecj^[Xkhh^eb["WjÓhij_dWbWj[hWbZ_h[Yj_ed j^[djej^[c[Z_Wb[Z][e\j^[ÓhijYhWd_ejecob_d[$
<_]$($'$))
:h_bb_d]j^[b[ii[hif^[de_Zm_d]WbbemiWj[cfehWb[nj[di_ede\ j^[ikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco<_]$($'$))$ ;njhWZkhWbZh_bb_d]e\j^[_dd[h[Z][e\j^[YhWd_ejecoh_cWdZ h[celWb e\ j^[ eii[eki [nj[di_edi e\ j^[ ehX_jWb hee\ e\\[h Wd _dYh[Wi[Z _djhWYhWd_Wb l_[m Zkh_d] j^[ bWj[h ikh]_YWb fheY[Zkh[ <_]$($'$)*$
<_]$($'$)*
Ef[d_d]j^[\hedjej[cfehWbZkhW_dWi[c_bkdWh\Wi^_ed_ij_c[# Yedikc_d] Xkj Wle_Zi kdd[Y[iiWho [nfbehWj_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWb WdZj[cfehWbbeX[<_]$($'$)+$ 7\j[hYecfb[j_ede\j^[_djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed"ZkhWbYbeikh[i^ekbZ X[cWZ[mWj[hj_]^jjeWle_Zfeijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW$?\j[di_ed ehZ[^_iY[dY[^WiZ[l[bef[Z_dj^[ZkhWbfbWd["Wf_[Y[e\ckiYb[ YWdX[i[md_djej^[ZkhWbYbeikh[<_]$($'$),$
<_]$($'$)+
<_]$($'$),
7YYehZ_d] je j^[ bWj[hWbbo fbWY[Z WffheWY^" f[d[jhWj_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWbfWhWdWiWbi_dki_ikdYecced$?\_j^Wff[di"YWh[\kbYbe# ikh[ _i h[Yecc[dZ[Z m_j^ Xed[ mWn" W ÔWf e\ ]Wb[W eh m_j^ WXZec_dWb\Wjj_iik[<_]$($'$)-$
<_]$($'$)-
:kh_d] mekdZ Ybeikh[" j^[ Xed[ ÔWf i^ekbZ X[ j_]^jbo Ón[Z c[Z_Wbbo WdZ \hedjWbbo je WY^_[l[ efj_cWb Yeic[j_Y h[ikbji <_]$($'$).$?dj^[YWi[e\bWh][XedoZ[\[YjWh[WiW\j[hh[celWb e\ j^[ b[ii[h if^[de_Z m_d]" ed[ i^ekbZ ki[ W bWh][ j_jWd_kc fbWj[jeYel[hj^[Z[\[Yj7$7bj[hdWj_l[bo"Xed[Y[c[djYWdX[ ki[Z8$ J^[[o[Xhemia_d_dY_i_edi^ekbZX[Ybei[Zm_j^_djhWYkjWd[eki hkdd_d]ikjkh[iehm_j^ij[h_b[WZ^[i_l[jWf[i$ EdWYYekdje\j^[b_c_j[Zia_d_dY_i_edWdZdedjhWkcWj_Yikh]_# YWbj[Y^d_gk["WikYj_edZhW_d_idejh[gk_h[Z$
<_]$($'$).
7
8
,-
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r c[Z_WblWh_Wj_ed
($( C[Z_WbceZ_ÓYWj_ede\j^[ ikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco
<_]$($($' IY^[cWj_Y f_Yjkh[ _bbkijhWj_d] j^[ ]eWb e\ j^[ c[Z_Wb ceZ_ÓYWj_ed e\ j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb YhWd_ejeco" dWc[bo j^[ feii_X_b_jo e\ j^[ i_ckbjWd[eki _dj[h^[c_# if^[h_YWdZikX\hedjWbZ_ii[Yj_ed$
J^[]eWbe\j^[c[Z_WbceZ_ÓYWj_ede\j^[ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ _ij^[WbceijfWhWc[Z_WdfbWY[c[dje\j^[YhWd_ejecoWbbem_d] dej edbo W ikX\hedjWb ikh]_YWb l_[m Xkj Wbie Wd _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y Z_ii[Yj_ed fhel_Z_d] i_ckbjWd[eki [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh WdZ_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YijhkYjkh[i<_]$($($'$7Z_iWZlWdjW][e\j^_i j[Y^d_gk[_ij^WjZ[f[dZ_d]edj^[fWj_[djÉi_dZ_l_ZkWbWdWjeco" _diec[YWi[i_d`khojej^[ikfhWehX_jWbd[khelWiYkbWhijhkYjkh[i WdZef[d_d]e\j^[\hedjWbfWhWdWiWbi_dkiWh[kdWle_ZWXb[$Jof_# YWb_dZ_YWj_edi\ehj^_iceZ_ÓYWj_edWh[YWi[im_j^ckbj_fb[Wd[k# hoicie\j^[Wdj[h_ehY_hYkbWj_edYecX_d[Zm_j^Z_ijWbWd[khoici e\j^[Wdj[h_ehY[h[XhWbWhj[ho$ ?dj^[\ebbem_d]"j^[XWi_Yikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[e\j^[c[Z_WbikfhW# ehX_jWbWffheWY^_iZ[iYh_X[Z$
?fi_bWj[hWb
C_Zb_d[
9edjhWbWj[hWb
EhX_jWbhee\ 7dj[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii 8WiWb\hedjWbbeX[ Iobl_WdÓiikh[ 7dj[hec[Z_Wbj[cfehWbbeX[ 7dj[h_ehfedjec[i[dY[f^Wb `kdYj_ed"YhkiY[h[Xh_ 9D?"9D??"9D??? ?97"Ef^j7"F9e7"79^7 7'"7("7)"7*"C'"C(" _dYb$f[h\ehWjehi F'"F("I97
9h_ijW]Wbb_ 7dj[h_eh\WbnY[h[Xh_ Eb\WYjeho]heel[ FbWdkcif^[de_ZWb[ JkX[hYkbkci[bbW[ F_jk_jWhoijWba BWc_dWj[hc_dWb_i 7dj[h_ehj^_hZl[djh_Yb[ HeijhkcYehfeh_iYWbbei_ =[dkYehfeh_iYWbbei_ ?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YÓiikh[ ?dj[hf[ZkdYkbWh\eiiW 79e7 J_fe\j^[87
EhX_jWbhee\ 7dj[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii 8WiWb\hedjWbbeX[ Iobl_WdÓiikh[ J[cfehWbfeb[ 9hkiY[h[Xh_ 9D?"9D??"9D??? ?97"Ef^j7"F9e7"79^7 7'"7("7)"7*"C'"C(" _dYb$f[h\ehWjehi F'"I97
JWXb[($($' 7dWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[iWffheWY^[Zj^hek]^j^[c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco$
,/
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r c[Z_WblWh_Wj_ed
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[ '$FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] J^[fWj_[dj_ifei_j_ed[Zikf_d[edj^[ef[hWj_d]jWXb[$?\ki[Z"j^[ i_d]b[f_de\j^[CWoÓ[bZYbWcfi^ekbZX[fbWY[Zedj^[effei_j[ i_Z[" Wbbem_d] \h[[ cWd_fkbWj_ed Zkh_d] ikh][ho$J^[ f_di i^ekbZ dejX[fbWY[Z_dj^[j[cfehWb_ickiYb[jeWle_Z_dijWX_b_joe\j^[ ioij[cWdZfeijef[hWj_l[j[cfehWb^[cWjecW$ <_]$($($(
Ij[f' 7ij^[Óhijij[f"j^[^[WZ_ihW_i[ZjeYW$'+WXel[j^[b[l[be\j^[ j^ehWn" \WY_b_jWj_d] l[deki ZhW_dW][ Zkh_d] ikh][ho$ ?d WZZ_j_ed" j^_i cWd[kl[h fhel_Z[i Z[Yecfh[ii_ed e\ j^[ cW_d Y[hl_YWb l[i# i[bi"bWhodnWdZj^[_djhWjhWY^[WbjkX[<_]$($($($ Ij[f( J^[h[W\j[h"j^[^[WZ_ih[jheÔ[Yj[ZXo'+je*+$9ecfWh[Zjej^[ ikfhWehX_jWb YhWd_ejeco" j^[ c[Z_Wb ceZ_ÓYWj_ed h[gk_h[i ceh[ h[jheÔ[Yj_ed WYYehZ_d] je j^[ fh[Y_i[ beYWj_ed e\ j^[ _dj[h^[c_# if^[h_Y jWh][j fe_dj$ B[i_edi Ybei[ je j^[ \hedjWb iakbb XWi[" ikY^ Wifhen_cWbWd[khoicie\j^[7("h[gk_h[Wh[jheÔ[n_ede\YW$'+$ IjhkYjkh[ii_jkWj[Zceh[YhWd_Wbbo"ikY^WiZ_ijWbboi_jkWj[ZWd[k# hoicie\797"d[[ZWh[jheÔ[n_edkfje*+<_]$($($)$ Ij[f) 7ib_]^jhejWj_edjej^[YedjhWbWj[hWbi_Z[_id[Y[iiWhoe\\[h_d]Wd [\ÓY_[djmeha_d]fei_j_edZkh_d]ikh][ho1^em[l[h"ceh[j^WdYW$ '&hejWj_edi^ekbZX[Wle_Z[ZjeWbbemWdedjhWkcWj_Yh[jhWYj_ed e\j^[_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YÓiikh[$Dej[j^Wjh_]^j#^WdZ[Zikh][edi ki_d] W b[\j#i_Z[Z YhWd_ejeco d[[Z ceh[ hejWj_ed je fhel_Z[ Wd [\ÓY_[djmeha_d]fei_j_ed<_]$($($*$
<_]$($($)
<_]$($($*
Ij[f* 7YYehZ_d]jej^[_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YZ_ii[Yj_ed"bWj[heÔ[n_ede\j^[ ^[WZ_idejh[gk_h[Z<_]$($($+$
<_]$($($+
-&
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r c[Z_WblWh_Wj_ed
($7dWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZeh_[djWj_ed 7\j[h fei_j_ed_d]" j^[ _cfehjWdj WdWjec_YWb bWdZcWhai e\ j^[ eii[ekiiakbb"ikY^Wij^[c_Zb_d["]bWX[bbW"\hedjWbfWhWdWiWbi_dki" ikfhWehX_jWb\ehWc[d"ehX_jWbh_c"j[cfehWbb_d[WdZj^[\hedjeXW# i_iWh[fh[Y_i[boZ[Ód[ZWdZcWha[Zm_j^Wij[h_b[f[d$Dej[j^[ ikf[hÓY_Wb d[khelWiYkbWh ijhkYjkh[i" [if[Y_Wbbo j^[ Yekhi[ e\ j^[ ikfhWehX_jWbd[hl[iWdZWhj[ho<_]$($($,$9hWd_ejeco_ij^[dZ[j[h# c_d[ZXWi[Zkfed j^[i[WdWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[iWdZ j^[ikh]_YWb jWh][j$J^[Yehh[Yjb_d[e\j^[ia_d_dY_i_edZ[f[dZidejedboedj^[ [nWYji_j[kdZi_p[e\j^[YhWd_ejecoXkjWbieedj^[f^oi_e]deco e\j^[fWj_[dj0j^[_dZ_l_ZkWb\ehce\j^[[o[Xhem"mh_dab[ie\j^[ \eh[^[WZehj^[\hedjWb^W_hb_d[$?dj^_imWo"j^[ia_d_dY_i_edYWd X[cWZ[m_j^_dj^[[o[Xhem"Wmh_dab[ehiYWhedj^[\WY["eh[l[d X_\hedjWbboX[^_dZj^[^W_hb_d[fhel_Z_d]Wfb[Wi_d]Yeic[j_Yfeij# ef[hWj_l[ekjYec[$J^[[o[b_ZiWh[fhej[Yj[Zm_j^i[di_j_l[jWf[i WdZj^[ia_d_iYWh[\kbboZ_i_d\[Yj[Z$
<_]$($($, :[if_j[ W fWhWc[Z_Wbbo fbWY[Z YhWd_ejeco" ef[d_d]e\j^[\hedjWbfWhWdWiWbi_dkiYWdX[fh_dY_fWbbo Wle_Z[Z$?dYWi[im_j^Wd[nj[dZ[Z\hedjWbi_dki"j^[YhWd_# ejeco i^ekbZ X[ fbWY[Z ceh[ Wf_YWbbo eh [l[d W jhWdi# \hedjWb#i_dki WffheWY^ YWd X[ f[h\ehc[Z$ 7YYehZ_d] je fWj_[djÊi _dZ_l_ZkWb Wff[WhWdY[" j^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed YWd X[ f[h\ehc[Z m_j^_d j^[ [o[Xhem eh X_\hedjWbbo X[^_dZ j^[ ^W_hb_d[$
-'
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r c[Z_WblWh_Wj_ed
)$9hWd_ejeco Ij[f' 7ic[dj_ed[ZWXel[" j^[ia_d_dY_i_edi^ekbZ X[ cWZ[ WYYehZ_d] je j^[ _dZ_l_ZkWb f^oi_e]# decoe\j^[\hedje#ehX_jWb\WY[$?dceijYWi[i" Wd [o[Xhem _dY_i_ed _i cWZ[ m_j^ Wd [nj[d# i_ed _d W mh_dab[ e\ j^[ ]bWX[bbWh h[]_ed$J^[ ikXYkjWd[eki j_iik[ _i Z_ii[Yj[Z ZemdmWhZi _d W \hedjWb Z_h[Yj_ed" [nfei_d] j^[ ehX_YkbWh eYkb_WdZ\hedjWbckiYb[i$?dj^[YWi[e\Wj^_d WdZ dedZec_dWdj [o[Xhem" j^[ _dY_i_ed YWd X[ f[h\ehc[Z m_j^_d W mh_dab[ eh YedY[Wb[Z X[^_dZ j^[ ^W_hb_d[ f[h\ehc_d] W X_YehedWh ia_d_dY_i_ed$H_]^ji_Z[<_]$($($-$
<_]$($($-
<_]$($($.
Ij[f( 7\j[h f[h\ehc_d] W Yeic[j_YWbbo ik_jWXb[ _dY_# i_ed" j^[ ia_d ÔWfi Wh[ j[cfehWh_bo h[jhWYj[Z m_j^^ebZ_d]ikjkh[i$J^[\hedjWbX[bboe\ j^[ eYY_f_je\hedjWbckiYb[_i_dY_i[ZfWhWbb[bjej^[ ehX_jWb h_c" j^[d h[jhWYj[Z \hedjWbbo [nfei_d] j^[\hedjWbXed[<_]$($($.$
Ij[f) M^[d [nfei_d] j^[ Xedo ikh\WY[" dej[ j^Wj h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWb ckiYkbWh bWo[h _d Xej^ j^[ c[Z_Wb WdZ \hedjWb Z_h[Yj_ed i^ekbZ X[ Zed[ Óhcbo" Wbbem_d] efj_cWb [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ Xedo ikh\WY[" Xkj ][djbo _d j^[ ehX_jWb Z_h[Yj_edjeWle_Zi[l[h[feijef[hWj_l[f[h_eh# X_jWb^[cWjecW$7\j[hie\jj_iik[h[jhWYj_ed"W i_d]b[\hedjeXWiWbXkhh^eb[_iZh_bb[Z\hedjWbbo _dj^[c[Z_Wd#fWhWc[Z_WdfbWd[<_]$($($/$
<_]$($($/
-(
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r c[Z_WblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f* 7\j[h c_d_cWb [dbWh][c[dj e\ j^[ ^eb[ m_j^ Ód[ fkdY^[i WdZ cel[c[dj e\ j^[ ZkhW" W ^_]^#if[[Z YhWd_ejec[ _i ki[Z je iWm _d Wd ehX_jWb Z_h[Yj_ed$ 7YYehZ_d] je j^[ [nj[di_ed e\j^[\hedjWbfWhWdWiWbi_dkiWdZjej^[\ehc e\ j^[ ehX_jWb h_c" j^[ iWm b_d[ _i Yedj_dk[Z _d W c[Z_Wb je bWj[hWb Z_h[Yj_ed" jWa_d] _dje WYYekdjj^[kff[hXehZ[he\j^[\hedjWbi_dki <_]$($($'&$
<_]$($($'&
Ij[f+ J^[h[W\j[hWYkhl[Zb_d[_iiWm[Z\hecj^[Xkhh ^eb[ je j^[ bWj[hWb XehZ[h e\ j^[ fh[l_ekibo f[h\ehc[Z \hedjeXWiWb Ykjj_d]" j^ki Yh[Wj_d] WXed[ÔWfm_j^Wm_Zj^e\WXekj(&Å(+cc WdZW^[_]^je\WXekj'+Å(&cc$?\j^[\hedjWb fWhWdWiWbi_dkimWief[d[Z"fbWij_YYbeikh[_i d[Y[iiWhoW\j[hYecfb[j_ede\j^[_djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[<_]$($($''$
<_]$($($''
Ij[f, 7d _cfehjWdj ij[f e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco W\j[h h[celWb e\ j^[ Xed[ ÔWf _i j^[ ^_]^#if[[Z Zh_bb_d]e\j^[_dd[hXWiWbcWh]_de\j^[Xed[ WXel[ j^[ ehX_jWb h_c m_j^ekj ef[d_d] j^[ \hedjWbfWhWdWiWbi_dki$?diec[YWi[i"fhec_# d[dj[nj[di_edie\j^[ehX_jWbhee\i^ekbZX[ Wbieh[cel[Zm_j^W^_]^#if[[ZZ_WcedZZh_bb$ M_j^YWh[\kbh[celWbe\j^_i_dd[hXed[[Z][" j^[ Wd]b[ \eh l_ikWb_pWj_ed WdZ cWd_fkbWj_ed YWdX[i_]d_ÓYWdjbo_dYh[Wi[Z<_]$($($'($
<_]$($($'(
-)
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r c[Z_WblWh_Wj_ed
<_]$($($')
Ij[f- J^[ ZkhW i^ekbZ X[ ef[d[Z _d W ÇJÈ i^Wf[Z \Wi^_ed Wbbem_d] Xej^ ikfhWehX_jWb WdZ _dj[h# ^[c_if^[h_YZ_ii[Yj_ed<_]$($($')$
<_]$($($'*
Ij[f. J^[\h[[ZkhWbÔWfiWh[Ón[ZkfmWhZiWdZ_d Wc[Z_WbZ_h[Yj_edm_j^ikjkh[i$M_j^j^[b_c# _j[ZYhWd_ejeco"ej^[hZkhWbb_\j_d]ikjkh[iWh[ dejh[gk_h[Z<_]$($($'*$
-*
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r c[Z_WblWh_Wj_ed
*$?djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ij[f' H_]^ji_Z[$:_ii[Yj_eded\h[i^^kcWdYWZWl[h1 Whj[h_[i Wh[ Óbb[Z m_j^ Yebeh[Z iebkj_ed$ 7\j[h ef[d_d]j^[ZkhWcWj[h"j^[Wdj[h_ehikfhWi[b# bWhh[]_ed_i[nfei[Z$J^[Óhijij[f_ij^[[\Ó# Y_[djZhW_dW][e\9I<Xoef[d_d]j^[WhWY^de_Z c[cXhWd[i m_j^ c_Yheikh]_YWb _dijhkc[dji$ Dej[j^[9D??WdZj^[WhWY^de_Zc[cXhWd[i e\j^[YWhej_ZY_ij[hd<_]$($($'+$
YWhej_ZY_ij[hd 9D??
<_]$($($'+
Ij[f( 7\j[hh[celWbe\9I<"j^[\hedjWbbeX[_i][djbo h[jhWYj[Z$ :k[ je j^[ i_]d_ÓYWdj h[jheÔ[n_ed WdZh[celWbe\9I<" j^[\hedjWbbeX[ikXi_Z[i" ^[h[Xo a[[f_d] h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWb beX[ jej^[d[Y[iiWhoc_d_ckc$7\j[hef[d_d]j^[ Y^_WicWj_YWdZYWhej_ZY_ij[hdi"j^[h_]^j9D??" ?97 WdZ 7' i[]c[dj e\ j^[ 797 Wh[ [nfei[Z$ J^[ Iobl_Wd Óiikh[ _i dej o[j ef[d[Z1 dej[ j^Wjj^[\hedjWbWdZj[cfehWbbeX[iYel[hj^[ C97$Dej[j^[bWj[hWbWif[Yje\j^[efj_YjhWYj <_]$($($',$
79F 9D?? kdYki ?97 efj_YjhWYj 7'i[]c[dj
<_]$($($',
Ij[f) 7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ c[Z_Wb fWhj e\ j^[ Iobl_Wd Óiikh[WdZceX_b_pWj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[" j^[ bWj[hWb fWhj e\ j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh h[]_ed _i eXi[hl[Z$BWj[hWb\hecj^[9D???"j^[feij[h_eh \eiiWYWdX[i[[dm_j^j^[Wdj[h_ehikh\WY[e\ j^[fedi$Dej[j^[F97WdZI97"j^[feij[h_eh Yb_de_Z fheY[ii WdZ j^[ hee\ e\ j^[ YWl[hd# ekii_dkic[Z_Wbbo\hecj^[9D???$J^[?97_i h[jhWYj[Z c[Z_Wbbo m_j^ W Ód[ c_YheZ_ii[Yjeh <_]$($($'-$
9D?? I97 9D??? F9F F97 ?97
<_]$($($'-
-+
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r c[Z_WblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f* :_ii[Yj_d] \hec W c[Z_Wb je bWj[hWb Z_h[Yj_ed" j^[ _fi_bWj[hWb Iobl_Wd Óiikh[ _i ef[d[Z$ Dej[ j^[ C' i[]c[dj WdZ X_\khYWj_ed e\ j^[ h_]^j C97$ ?d j^_i ikX\hedjWb j[Y^d_gk[" h[jhWY# j_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[_idejd[Y[iiWho\eh WffheWY^_d]j^[C97<_]$($($'.$
C97X_\khYWj_ed C97 ?97X_\khYWj_ed
<_]$($($'.
Ij[f+ :_ii[Yj_d] W]W_d _d W c[Z_Wb Z_h[Yj_ed" j^[ Wdj[h_ehikfhWi[bbWhh[]_ed_ii[[dl_Wj^[ikX# \hedjWbhekj[$8[^_dZj^[efj_Yd[hl[i"Xej^?97 Wh[ m[bb i[[d WdZ j^[ c[Z_Wb ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWb ?97 YWd X[ WffheWY^[Z j^hek]^ j^[?DEFm_dZem$Dej[j^[\hedjWbiakbbXWi[ WdZj^[efj_YY^_Wic<_]$($($'/$
YedjhWbWj[hWb?97 YedjhWbWj[hWb9D?? _fi_bWj[hWb?97 Y^_Wic
<_]$($($'/
Ij[f, 7\j[h \khj^[h h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWb beX[" j^[ effei_j[ 9D ?? _i i[[d$ Dej[ j^[ b[\j ?97 WdZ ef^j^Wbc_Y Whj[ho" WffheWY^[Z j^hek]^ Wh_]^j#i_Z[ZYhWd_ejeco$?dj^_iYWi[Wbeefe\ j^[Ef^j7YWki[ii[l[h[lWiYkbWhYecfh[ii_ed e\j^[b[\j9D??<_]$($($(&$
Ef^j7 ?97
<_]$($($(&
-,
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r c[Z_WblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f- 7\j[h Ód_i^_d] j^[ ikX\hedjWb Z_ii[Yj_ed" j^[ \hedjWbbeX[_i][djbocel[Z\hecj^[c[Z_Wb je bWj[hWb WdZ j^[ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y Óiikh[ _i YWh[\kbbo ef[d[Z l_W j^[ fWhWc[Z_Wd Yh[Wj[Z YhWd_ejeco<_]$($($('$
\hedjWbbeX[
<_]$($($('
Ij[f. M_j^\khj^[hef[d_d]e\j^[_dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y Óiikh[" j^[ Z_ijWb Yekhi[ e\ j^[ 797 YWd X[ WjjW_d[Z$ Dej[ j^[ 7(#7) i[]c[dji hkdd_d] WhekdZ j^[ ][dk e\ j^[ Yehfki YWbbeikc <_]$ ($($(($
7(i[]c[dji
<_]$($($((
Ij[f/ J^[Wdj[h_ehikfhWi[bbWhh[]_ed_ii[[dj^hek]^ j^[ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y Óiikh[$ Dej[ j^Wj j^[ 79e7 WdZ j^[ 7( i[]c[dji e\ j^[ X_bWj[hWb 797 YWd X[ WffheWY^[Z _d W dedjhWkcWj_Y cWdd[hm_j^ekjh[i[Yj_ede\j^[]ohkih[Yjki$ ?dj^[XWYa]hekdZ"j^[YedjhWbWj[hWb?97YWdX[ eXi[hl[Z j^hek]^ j^[_djhWefj_Ym_dZem<_]$ ($($()$
b[\j?97 Y^_Wic 79e7 7(i[]c[dji
<_]$($($()
--
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r c[Z_WblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f'& J^[ \hedjWb beX[ WdZ j^[ 79e7 Yecfb[n Wh[ ][djboh[jhWYj[Z"Wbbem_d]l_ikWb_pWj_ede\j^[ efj_Y Y^_Wic WdZ j^[ bWc_dW j[hc_dWb_i <_]$ ($($(*$ Y^_Wic bWc_dWj[hc_dWb_i
<_]$($($(*
Ij[f'' J^[bWc_dWj[hc_dWb_iWdZj^[Ôeehe\j^[j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ Wh[ ef[d[Z$ Dej[ j^[ j_f e\ j^[ 87 m_j^_d j^[ _dj[hf[ZkdYkbWh Y_ij[hd" eXi[hl[Z j^hek]^j^[Wdj[h_ehY^WcX[he\j^[j^_hZl[d# jh_Yb[<_]$($($(+$
Y^_Wic XWi_bWhj_f 79e7
<_]$($($(+
-.
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r c[Z_WblWh_Wj_ed
+$:khW"Xed[WdZmekdZYbeikh[ 7\j[hYecfb[j_ede\ j^[_djhWYhWd_WbfheY[Zkh[" j^[ikXWhWY^de_Z ifWY[ _i Óbb[Z m_j^ Whj[ÓY_Wb 9I<$ :khWb Ybeikh[ i^ekbZ X[ cWZ[ mWj[hj_]^j Wle_Z_d] feijef[hWj_l[ 9I< ÓijkbW1 _\ Z[^_iY[dY[ ^Wi Z[l[bef[Z_dj^[ZkhWbef[d_d]"Wf_[Y[e\ckiYb[YWdX[i[md_dje j^[ZkhWbYbeikh[$7fbWj[e\][b\eWc_ifbWY[Z[njhWZkhWbbo"WdZ"_\ d[Y[iiWho"j^[\hedjWbfWhWdWiWbi_dki_iYbei[Z$8ed[mWn"WÔWfe\ j^[]Wb[WehehX_YkbWhckiYb[j_iik[YWdX[ki[Z\ehj^_ifkhfei[$ ?dYWi[im_j^Wd[nj[dZ[Z\hedjWbi_dki"WXZec_dWb\WjYWdWbieX[ l[hoki[\kb$J^[Xed[ÔWf_iÓn[Zm_j^Wj_jWd_kcfbWj[$Dej[j^Wj j^_ifbWj[i^ekbZYbei[j^[\hedjWbXkhh^eb[$J^[Xed[ÔWfi^ekbZ X[j_]^jboÓn[ZXej^c[Z_WbboWdZ\hedjWbbojeWY^_[l[Wfb[WiWdj Yeic[j_Yh[ikbj$7\j[hÓdWbced_jeh_d]e\^[ceijWi_i"j^[ckiYkbWh WdZikXYkjWd[ekibWo[hiWh[Ybei[Zm_j^_dj[hhkfj[Zikjkh[iWdZ j^[ia_dm_j^Wd_djhWYkjWd[ekiikjkh[ehij[h_b[WZ^[i_l[jWf[$De ikYj_edZhW_d_id[Y[iiWho$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i ?dWZ[gkWj[ fbWdd_d] m_j^ ikXi[gk[dj _dWZ[gkWj[ [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ jWh][j h[]_ed WdZ i_]d_ÓYWdj Z[j[h_ehWj_ed _d [\ÓY_[dYo e\ ikh]_YWbbo[nY_i_d]j^[b[i_ed$ J^[ fWj_[dj _i _dWZ[gkWj[bo fei_j_ed[Z m_j^ _dik\ÓY_[dj _djhW# YhWd_Wb[nfeikh[$FbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]i^ekbZX[f[h\ehc[Z Xoj^[ikh][ed^_ci[b\$ J^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed _i cWZ[ m_j^_d j^[ c[Z_Wd [o[Xhem m_j^ _d`kho je j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb d[hl[$ ?d iec[ YWi[i" W fhec_d[dj \hedjWbmh_dab[ehiYWhYWdX[ki[Z\ehia_d_dY_i_ed$?\mh_dab[i eh iYWhi Wh[ dej fh[i[dj WdZ j^[ [o[Xhem ia_d _dY_i_ed mekbZ h[ikbj_dWikXefj_cWbYeic[j_Yh[ikbjm_j^feijef[hWj_l[\hed# jWbdkcXd[ii"Wd[nj[dZ[Z\hedjWb#X_YehedWhia_d_dY_i_edYWdX[ fhefei[Z$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ fbWY[c[dj e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco m_j^ f[d[jhWj_ed e\ j^[\hedjWbfWhWdWiWbi_dki$J^[WffheWY^ckijX[Z[j[hc_d[Z W\j[h WYYkhWj[ fbWdd_d] WdZ ikh]_YWb eh_[djWj_ed$ J^[ ef[d_d] i^ekbZ X[ Ybei[Z YWh[\kbbo W\j[h Yecfb[j_ed e\ j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[jeWle_Zfeijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbWWdZc[d_d]_j_i$ ?d`khojej^[ZkhWcWj[hZkh_d]YhWd_ejeco$ F[d[jhWj_ed e\ j^[ ehX_j Zkh_d] [njhWZkhWb h[celWb e\ eii[eki [nj[di_edie\j^[ehX_jWbhee\m_j^feijef[hWj_l[ehX_jWb^[cW# jecWWdZim[bb_d]$
-/
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r c[Z_WblWh_Wj_ed
?dWZ[gkWj[ h[celWb e\ 9I< m_j^ _d`kh_[i WdZ Yedjki_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWbbeX[Zk[jeifWjkbWfh[iikh[$ ?d`kh_[ijedkc[hekid[hl[iWdZl[ii[bi_dj^[fWhWi[bbWhh[]_ed Zkh_d] c_Yheikh]_YWb cWd_fkbWj_ed m_j^ feijef[hWj_l[ d[khe# be]_YWbZ[j[h_ehWj_ed$ ?dWZ[gkWj[_djhWYhWd_Wb^[ceijWi_iYWki_d]i[l[h[h[Xb[[Z_d]$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ZkhWbYbeikh[h[ikbj_d]_dWfeijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW$ ?\j^[\hedjWbi_dkimWief[d[Z"dWieb_gkehh^[WYWdeYYkhfeij# ef[hWj_l[bo$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ fei_j_ed_d] WdZ ÓnWj_ed e\ j^[ Xed[ ÔWf m_j^ j^[ j_jWd_kcfbWj[h[ikbj_d]_dfeehYeic[j_Yh[ikbji$ ?dWZ[gkWj[^[ceijWi_iZkh_d]mekdZYbeikh[m_j^ikXi[gk[dj ie\jj_iik[^[cWjecW$
<_]$($($(,
<_]$($($(-
J_fiWdZjh_Yai JWa[j_c[\ehfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]e\fWj_[dji$ 9ecfWh[Z je j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb YhWd_ejeco" j^[ c[Z_Wb ikfhWeh# X_jWbWffheWY^h[gk_h[ib[ii^[WZhejWj_edWdZceh[h[jheÔ[n_ed Zkh_d]fei_j_ed_d]<_]$($($(,$
<_]$($($(.
CWa[WYWh[\kbWdWjec_YWbeh_[djWj_edWdZki[ j^[ j^h[[ij[fi e\ cWha_d] m_j^ W ij[h_b[ f[d0 '$ eii[eki ijhkYjkh[i WdZ ikf[h# ÓY_Wb d[khelWiYkbWh ijhkYjkh[i1 ($ fbWY[c[dj e\ YhWd_ejeco1 )$ia_d_dY_i_ed$ J^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed i^ekbZ X[ cWZ[ _d W Yeic[j_YWbbo WYY[fjWXb[ mWo$ ?\ j^[ [o[Xhem _i dej Zec_dWdj" j^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed YWd X[ cWZ[ m_j^_d W mh_dab[ eh iYWh ed j^[ \WY[" eh [l[d X_\hedjWbbo X[^_dZj^[^W_hb_d[<_]$($($(-$ :kh_d]ie\j j_iik[Z_ii[Yj_ed" j^[\hedjWbckiYb[i^ekbZX[\eh# Y_Xboh[jhWYj[ZkfmWhZiWdZc[Z_Wbbo_dW\hedjec[Z_WbZ_h[Yj_ed m_j^^ebZ_d]ikjkh[ifhel_Z_d]ik\ÓY_[djel[hl_[me\j^[c[Z_Wb ikfhWehX_jWb h[]_ed$ >em[l[h" h[jhWYj_ed WdZ ceX_b_pWj_ed e\ j^[ia_dÔWfi^ekbZX[h[ijh_Yj[Zjej^[d[Y[iiWhoc_d_ckcje fh[l[djfeijef[hWj_l[d[Yhei_i$CWd_fkbWj_ede\j^[\hedjWbWdZ ehX_jWb ckiYb[i kfmWhZi el[h j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb h_c i^ekbZ X[ c_d_c_p[Z" Wle_Z_d] feijef[hWj_l[ f[h_ehX_jWb ^[cWjecW <_]$ ($($(.$ Fh[ef[hWj_l[ Yecfkj[Z jece]hWf^o WdZ YhWd_Wb N#hWo _d j^[ Wdj[hefeij[h_ehWdZbWj[hWbl_[mYWdZ[j[hc_d[j^[[nj[di_ede\
.&
<_]$($($(/
<_]$($($)&
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r c[Z_WblWh_Wj_ed
<_]$($($)'
j^[\hedjWbfWhWdWiWbi_dki$?dceijYWi[i"j^[\hedjWbfWhWdWiWb i_dki_ibeYWj[Zceh[XWiWbboj^Wdj^[fbWdd[ZYhWd_ejeco"j^ki f[d[jhWj_ede\j^[i_dkiYWdX[Wle_Z[Z<_]$($($(/$ IjW][i e\ YhWd_ejeco <_]$ ($($)&0 '$ fWhWc[Z_Wd \hedjWb Xkhh ^eb[jh[f^_dWj_ed1($\hedjeXWiWbYkjj_d]m_j^j^[YhWd_ejec[1)$ iWm_d]_dWYkhl[Z\Wi^_ed\hecj^[Xkhh^eb[jej^[bWj[hWb[Z][ e\j^[ÓhijYhWd_ejecob_d[$
<_]$($($)(
<_]$($($))
H[celWbe\j^[_dd[h[Z][e\j^[YhWd_ejecom_j^W^_]^#if[[Z Zh_bb\WY_b_jWj[ij^[_djhWYhWd_Wbl_ikWb_pWj_ed$?\d[Y[iiWho"eii[eki [nj[di_edie\j^[ehX_jWbhee\i^ekbZWbieX[YWh[\kbboh[cel[Z <_]$($($)'$ Ef[d_d]j^[\hedjWbZkhW_dWi_cfb[ÇJÈ#i^Wf[Z\Wi^_edWle_Zi kdd[Y[iiWho[nfbehWj_ede\j^[\hedjWbbeX[WdZefj_cWbYecX_# dWj_ed e\ j^[ ikX\hedjWb WdZ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y Z_ii[Yj_ed <_]$ ($($)($ J^[fWhWc[Z_WdfbWY[c[dje\j^[YhWd_ejecoWbbemiikX\hedjWb Wim[bbWi_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YZ_ii[Yj_ed<_]$($($))$
<_]$($($)*
<_]$($($)+
7\j[h Yecfb[j_ed e\ j^[ _djhWZkhWb Z_ii[Yj_ed" ZkhWb Ybeikh[ i^ekbZ X[ cWZ[ mWj[hj_]^j je Wle_Z feijef[hWj_l[ dWiWb 9I< ÓijkbW$?\j[di_edehZ[^_iY[dY[^WiZ[l[bef[Z_dj^[ZkhWbfbWd[" Wf_[Y[e\ckiYb[YWdX[i[md_djej^[ZkhWbYbeikh[<_]$($($)*$ ?\f[d[jhWj_ede\j^[\hedjWbfWhWdWiWbi_dkiYekbZdejX[Wle_Z[Z" c[j_YkbekiYbeikh[_ih[gk_h[Z$J^[f[d[jhWj_edi^ekbZX[Ybei[Z m_j^Xed[mWn"m_j^W\hedjWb]Wb[WbehckiYkbWhbWo[h"ehm_j^ WXZec_dWb\Wjj_iik[<_]$($($)+$ J^[ Xed[ ÔWf i^ekbZ X[ Ybei[Z j_]^jbo je WY^_[l[ efj_cWb Yei# c[j_Yh[ikbji$7j_jWd_kcfbWj[YWdX[ikYY[ii\kbboki[Z\ehYbe# ikh[e\j^[Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_ed<_]$($($),$
<_]$($($),
J^[[o[Xhemia_d_dY_i_edi^ekbZX[Ybei[Zm_j^_djhWYkjWd[eki hkdd_d]ikjkh[iehm_j^ij[h_b[WZ^[i_l[jWf[i$ EdWYYekdje\j^[b_c_j[Zia_d_dY_i_edWdZdedjhWkcWj_Yikh]_# YWbj[Y^d_gk["WikYj_edZhW_d_idejh[gk_h[Z$
.'
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r XWiWblWh_Wj_ed
($) 8WiWblWh_Wj_ede\j^[ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^0 j^[ikfhWehX_je#ehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco IkfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejecoWbbemiWXheWZ[nfeikh[e\j^[ikfhWi[bbWh d[khelWiYkbWh ijhkYjkh[i1 ^em[l[h" _d if[Y_Wb i_jkWj_edi dWhhem WdWjec_YWbm_dZemicWo^_dZ[hj^[Z_ii[Yj_edj^hek]^j^[_cfeh# jWdjikfhWi[bbWhikh]_YWbfWj^mWoi$?dfWhj_YkbWh"WffheWY^_d]^_]^ i_jkWj[ZXWi_bWhj_fWd[khoiciWdZikfhW#h[jhei[bbWhifWY[#eYYkfo# _d]b[i_edicWoh[gk_h[Wl[hoeXb_gk[l_[mje]kWhWdj[[iW\[_dj[h# f[ZkdYkbWhcWd_fkbWj_edm_j^ekjh[jhWYj_ede\j^[i[di_j_l[efj_Y ijhkYjkh[i"m^_Y^YWdX[^_]^boYecfb_YWj[ZXoj^[YecX_dWj_ede\ Wi^ehj_dj[hdWbYWhej_ZWhj[hoWdZfh[Ón[Zbemefj_YY^_Wic$ <_]$($)$' IY^[cWj_Y f_Yjkh[ Z[f_Yj_d] j^[ W_c e\ j^[ XWiWblWh_Wj_ede\j^[ikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco$8ofWhj_Wb h[cel_d] j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb h_c WdZ ehX_jWb hee\" W ceh[ eXb_gk[ l_[m e\ j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh h[]_ed YWd X[ WY^_[l[Z [nfei_d] b[i_edi e\ j^[ _dj[hf[ZkdYkbWh h[]_ed WdZ j^[ kff[hfWhje\j^[Y_ij[hdWbWc_dW[j[hc_dWb_i$
J^[[ii[dY[e\j^[ikfhWehX_je#ehX_jWbWffheWY^_ije]W_dWceh[ eXb_gk[l_[me\j^[Z[[f#i[Wj[Zfh[fedj_d[WdZ_dj[hf[ZkdYkbWh h[]_edl_Wj^[ikX\hedjWb[nfeikh["W\j[hh[cel_d]j^[ehX_jWbh_c WdZ fWhj_Wbbo h[cel_d] j^[ ehX_jWb hee\ <_]$ ($)$'$ ?d j^_i Wd]b[Z l_[m" j^[ hee\ e\ j^[ _dj[hf[ZkdYkbWh Y_ij[hd m_j^ j^[ cWc_bbWho XeZ_[i"_d\kdZ_Xkbkc"WdZj^[j_fe\j^[87YWdX[m[bbl_ikWb_p[Z m_j^ekjh[celWbe\j^[Wdj[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[iiWdZceX_b_pWj_ed e\j^[fWhWYb_de_Z?97WdZ9D??$ ?d j^[\ebbem_d]" j^[ikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[e\ j^[XWiWbikfhWehX_je# ehX_jWbWffheWY^_iZ[iYh_X[Z$
?fi_bWj[hWb
C_Zb_d[
9edjhWbWj[hWb
EhX_jWbhee\ 7dj[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii 8WiWb\hedjWbbeX[ =ohkih[Yjki Iobl_WdÓiikh[ 7dj[hec[Z_Wbj[cfehWbbeX[ 7dj[h_ehfedi 9hkiY[h[Xh_ 9D?"9D??"9D??? ?97"Ef^j7"F9e7"79^7 7'"7("C'"C("_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi F'"F("I97
Eb\WYjeho]heel[ FbWdkcif^[de_ZWb[ JkX[hYkbkci[bbW[ BWc_dWj[hc_dWb_i 7dj[h_ehj^_hZl[djh_Yb[ HeijhkcYehfeh_iYWbbei_ =[dkYehfeh_iYWbbei_ F_jk_jWhoijWba ?d\kdZ_Xkbkc CWc_bbWhoXeZ_[i ?dj[hf[ZkdYkbWh\eiiW 79e7"J_fe\j^[87" _dYb$f[h\ehWjehi
EhX_jWbhee\ 7dj[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii 8WiWb\hedjWbbeX[ Iobl_WdÓiikh[ J[cfehWbfeb[ 9hkiY[h[Xh_ 9D?"9D??"9D??? ?97"Ef^j7"F9e7"79^7 7'"7("C'"C("_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi F'"I97
JWXb[($)$' 7dWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[iWffheWY^[Zj^hek]^j^[XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco$
.)
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r XWiWblWh_Wj_ed
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[ '$FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] J^[fWj_[dj_ifei_j_ed[Zikf_d[m_j^j^[^[WZi[Ykh[Z_dW^[WZ ^ebZ[h$ ?\ ki[Z" j^[ i_d]b[ f_d e\ j^[ CWoÓ[bZ YbWcf i^ekbZ X[ fbWY[Z ed j^[ effei_j[ i_Z[" Wbbem_d] \h[[ cWd_fkbWj_ed Zkh_d] ikh][ho$J^[f_dii^ekbZdejX[fbWY[Z_dj^[j[cfehWb_ickiYb[je Wle_Z_dijWX_b_joe\j^[ioij[cWdZfeijef[hWj_l[j[cfehWb^[cW# jecW$
<_]$($)$(
Ij[f' J^[^[WZ_i[b[lWj[ZjeYW$'+WXel[j^[b[l[be\j^[j^ehWnjeWbbem \h[[l[dekiZhW_dW][WdZ[\\[Yj_l[Z[Yecfh[ii_ede\j^[Y[hl_YWb l[ii[bi"bWhodnWdZj^[_djhWjhWY^[WbjkX[<_]$($)$($ Ij[f( 8[YWki[e\j^[Wd]b[ZWffheWY^jej^[_dj[hf[ZkdYkbWhh[]_ed"j^[ XWiWbikfhWehX_je#ehX_jWblWh_Wj_edh[gk_h[iceh[h[jheÔ[n_edj^Wd j^[ikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco$J^_icWd[klh[e\YW$)&h[jheÔ[n_ed Wbieikffehjij^[]hWl_jo#h[bWj[Zi[b\#h[jhWYj_ede\j^[\hedjWbbeX[ <_]$($)$)$
<_]$($)$)
Ij[f) J^[h[W\j[h"j^[^[WZ_ihejWj[Zjej^[YedjhWbWj[hWbi_Z[$7ij^[cW_d Z_h[Yj_ede\j^[_djhWYhWd_WbZ_ii[Yj_ed_ij^hek]^j^[ikfhWi[bbWh EF97m_dZem"WYW$)&hejWj_ede\j^[^[WZ_ih[gk_h[Z$Dej[j^Wj h_]^j#^WdZ[Z ikh][edi ki_d] W b[\j#i_Z[Z YhWd_ejeco d[[Z ceh[ hejWj_edjefhel_Z[Wd[\ÓY_[djmeha_d]fei_j_ed<_]$($)$*$ Ij[f* J^[ ^[WZ cWo Wbie X[ bWj[heÔ[Yj[Z je WXekj '& ed j^[ YedjhW# bWj[hWbi_Z["jefhel_Z[Wik_jWXb[meha_d]fei_j_ed\ehj^[ikh][ed <_]$($)$+$
<_]$($)$*
<_]$($)$+
.*
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r XWiWblWh_Wj_ed
($7dWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZeh_[djWj_ed <_hijbo"j^[WdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaie\j^[\hedjWbiakbb"ikY^Wij^[ ]bWX[bbW"\hedjWbfWhWdWiWbi_dki"ikfhWehX_jWb\ehWc[d"ehX_jWbh_c" \hedjeXWi_i"j[cfehWbb_d["_cfh[ii_ede\j^[b[ii[hif^[de_Zm_d] WdZj^[po]ecWj_YWhY^Wh[fWbfWj[Z$Dej[j^[ikfhWehX_jWbd[khe# lWiYkbWhijhkYjkh[iWdZj^[Yekhi[e\j^[\WY_Wbd[hl[<_]$($)$,$ 7\j[hj^_i[ii[dj_Wbeh_[djWj_ed"j^[i_p[WdZi_j[e\j^[YhWd_ejeco i^ekbZ X[ Z[Ód[Z$ 7YYehZ_d] je j^[ YhWd_ejeco m^_Y^ _dYehfe# hWj[ih[celWbe\j^[ehX_jWbh_cWdZfWhj_Wbh[celWbe\j^[ehX_jWb hee\" j^[ _dZ_l_ZkWb b_d[ e\ j^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed _i cWha[Z" fbWY[Z bWj# [hWbbo je j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb \ehWc[d hkdd_d] m_j^_d j^[ [o[Xhem <_]$($)$,$J^[[o[b_ZiWh[YWh[\kbbojWf[ZWdZj^[ia_d_iZ_i_d\[Yj[Z c[j_Ykbekibo$
<_]$($)$, :[Ód_j_ed e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco WYYehZ_d] je j^[ WdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaie\j^[\hedjej[cfehWbh[]_ed$Dej[ j^[fbWY[c[dje\j^[ia_d_dY_i_edm^_Y^i^ekbZX[cWZ[ m_j^_dj^[[o[Xhem$
.+
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r XWiWblWh_Wj_ed
)$9hWd_ejeco Ij[f' J^[ [o[Xhem ia_d _dY_i_ed _i fbWY[Z bWj[hWb \hecj^[ikfhWehX_jWb\ehWc[d"_diec[YWi[i [nj[dZ_d] W \[m c_bb_c[j[hi el[h j^[ bWj[hWb fhe`[Yj_ed e\ j^[ Xhem _dje j^[ \hedjepo]e# cWj_YWh[W$<ehWYeic[j_YWbbofb[Wi_d]feijef# [hWj_l[h[ikbj"j^[ia_d_dY_i_edcWo\ebbemj^[ ehX_jWbh_c$H_]^ji_Z[<_]$($)$-$
<_]$($)$-
Ij[f( 7\j[h ia_d _dY_i_ed" j^[ ia_d ÔWfi Wh[ j[cfe# hWh_boh[jhWYj[Zm_j^^ebZ_d]ikjkh[i"[nfei_d] j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb Wh[W m_j^ j^[ \hedjWb X[bbo e\ j^[ eYY_f_je\hedjWb ckiYb[" j^[ ehX_YkbWh_i eYkb_ WdZ j[cfehWb ckiYb[i$J^[ \hedjWb cki# Yb[i Wh[ Ykj fWhWbb[b je j^[ ehX_jWb h_c" j^[ j[cfehWb ckiYb[ _i ijh_ff[Z \hec _ji Xedo _di[hj_edWjj^[j[cfehWbb_d[<_]$($)$.$
<_]$($)$.
Ij[f) J^[j[cfehWbckiYb[_ih[jhWYj[ZbWj[hWbbom_j^ ijhed] ikjkh[i dej_d] j^[ _cfh[ii_ed e\ j^[ b[ii[hif^[de_Zm_d]"j^kii^em_d]j^[b[l[be\ j^[\hedjWbiakbbXWi[$9ecfWh[Zjej^[ikfhW# ehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco"j^[XWiWblWh_Wj_edh[gk_h[i ceh[ cel[c[dj e\ j^[ j[cfehWb_i ckiYb[$ J^[ \hedjWb WdZ ehX_YkbWh_i eYkb_ ckiYb[i Wh[ Z_ii[Yj[Z kfmWhZi je][j^[h m_j^ j^[ \hedjWb f[h_eij [nfei_d] j^[ ehX_jWb h_c$ J^[ ehX_jWb h_c _i YWh[\kbbo Z_ii[Yj[Z \hec j^[ f[h_ehX_jW ki_d]WXbkdjYkhl[ZZ_ii[Yjeh$J^[ehX_YkbWh_i eYkb_ckiYb[WdZj^[f[h_ehX_jWbi^[[jWh[j^[d \ehY_Xbo h[jhWYj[Z kfmWhZi ki_d] ijhed] ^ebZ# _d]ikjkh[i$J^[\hedjWbckiYb[WdZj^[\hedjWb f[h_eijWh[h[jhWYj[ZZemdmWhZi_dW\ehmWhZ Z_h[Yj_ed" [nfei_d] j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb h[]_ed <_]$($)$/$
<_]$($)$/
.,
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r XWiWblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f* M_j^ W ^_]^#if[[Z Zh_bb" W i_d]b[ Xkhh ^eb[ _i f[h\ehc[Z feij[h_eh je j^[ j[cfehWb b_d[ WYYehZ_d]jej^[b[l[be\j^[\hedjWbiakbbXWi[$ J^[h[W\j[h" j^[ Xkhh_d] Z_h[Yj_ed i^ekbZ X[ Y^Wd][Z" j^ki ef[d_d] j^[ bWj[hWb Wif[Yj e\ j^[ehX_j$J^[]eWbe\j^_i[dbWh][Zi_d]b[Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_ed _i je f[d[jhWj[ Xej^ j^[ Wdj[h_eh \eiiW WdZ j^[ ehX_j Xo Z_\\[h[dj X_Z_# h[Yj_edWbZh_bb_d]<_]$($)$'&$
<_]$($)$'&
Ij[f+ 7\j[h _dif[Yj_d] j^[ f[h_ehX_jW WdZ j^[ \hed# jWb ZkhW cWj[h" W Ykhl[Z i[c_Y_hYkbWh b_d[ _i iWm[Z \hec j^[ \hedjWb fWhj e\ j^[ Xkhh ^eb[ _dWbWj[hWb jec[Z_WbZ_h[Yj_ed je j^[b[l[be\ j^[ \hedjWb iakbb XWi[$ J^[h[W\j[h" j^[ bWj[hWb ehX_jWbmWbbWdZj^[po]ecWj_YfheY[iie\j^[ \hedjWbXed[_iZ_l_Z[Z\hecj^[ehX_jWbfWhje\ j^[Xkhh^eb[<_]$($)$''$
<_]$($)$''
Ij[f, J^[ ehX_jWb h_c _i j^[d iWm[Z Xej^ c[Z_Wbbo WdZ bWj[hWbbo ki_d] j^[ YhWd_ejec[$ If[Y_Wb Wjj[dj_ed i^ekbZ X[ ]_l[d je Wle_Z _d`kho je j^[Z[b_YWj[f[h_ehX_jW<_]$($)$'($
<_]$($)$'(
.-
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r XWiWblWh_Wj_ed
<_]$($)$')
Ij[f- J^[ bWj[hWb Wif[Yj e\ j^[ ehX_jWb hee\ _i j^[d Z_l_Z[Z m_j^ W Z_WcedZ Zh_bb Wbbem_d] i[Ykh[ b_\j_d] e\ j^[ Xed[ ÔWf WdZ \hWYjkh_d] e\ j^[ ehX_jWb hee\$ 9Wh[ i^ekbZ X[ jWa[d je fbWY[ j^[ \hWYjkh[ b_d[ Wi \Wh XWYa Wi feii_Xb[ m_j^# ekj ZWcW]_d] j^[ efj_Y YWdWb WdZ d[hl[ <_]$($)$')$
<_]$($)$'*
Ij[f. 7\j[hj^[Xed[ÔWf_ih[cel[Z"j^[\hedjWbZkhW cWj[hWdZj^[j^_df[h_ehX_jWYWdX[i[[d$7d [nj[dZ[Zh[celWbe\ j^[h[i_ZkWbehX_jWbhee\ _dWdeij[eYbWij_YcWdd[h_idejWZl_i[Z"j^ki Wle_Z_d] feijef[hWj_l[ [def^j^Wbcei eh fkb# iWj_d][nef^j^Wbcei<_]$($)$'*$
<_]$($)$'+
Ij[f/ J^[ZkhWi^ekbZX[ef[d[Z_dWYkhl[Z\Wi^_ed m_j^_jiXWi[jemWhZij^[ehX_j$J^[\h[[ZkhWb ÔWf _i Ón[Z \ehY_Xbo kfmWhZi m_j^ ijhed] [b[# lWj_d]ikjkh[i"Wbbem_d]WibWdj[Zl_[mZkh_d] _djhWYhWd_WbZ_ii[Yj_ed<_]$($)$'+$
..
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r XWiWblWh_Wj_ed
*$?djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ij[f' H_]^ji_Z[$:_ii[Yj_edi^emdedW\h[i^^kcWd YWZWl[h1 j^[ Whj[h_Wb l[ii[bi Wh[ fh[fWh[Z m_j^Yebeh[ZbWj[niebkj_ed$7\j[hWÇ9Èi^Wf[Z _dY_i_ed" j^[ ZkhW cWj[h _i \ehY_Xbo h[jhWYj[Z kfmWhZi"Wbbem_d]WibWdj[Zl_[mZkh_d]_djhW# YhWd_Wb eXi[hlWj_ed$ Dej[ j^Wj WYYehZ_d] je j^_ieXb_gk[l_[m"j^[\hedjeXWiWbYehj_YWbikh# \WY[YWdX[efj_cWbbo[nfei[Zm_j^ekjh[jhWY# j_ede\j^[\hedjWbbeX[$<_]$($)$',$
ZkhWcWj[h \hedjeXWiWbYehj[n
<_]$($)$',
Ij[f( 7\j[hef[d_d]j^[ZkhW"j^[Óhijij[fi^ekbZX[ Wd WZ[gkWj[ ZhW_dW][ e\ 9I< Xo ef[d_d] j^[ ikfhWi[bbWhY_ij[hdi$?dj^[YWi[e\[b[lWj[Z?9F W\j[h Wd[khoicWb ikXWhWY^de_Z ^[cehh^W][" j^[ bWj[hWb l[djh_Yb[ i^ekbZ X[ fkdYjkh[Z$ 7\j[hh[celWbe\ikXWhWY^de_ZWbehl[djh_YkbWh 9I<" j^[ \hedjWb beX[ ikXi_Z[i ifedjWd[ekibo Wbbem_d] YWh[\kb Z_ii[Yj_ed m_j^ c_d_cWb XhW_d h[jhWYj_ed$ Dej[ j^[ 9D ?? WdZ j^[ ?97 W\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ EF97 m_dZem m_j^ W Ód[ c_Yhead_\[$J^[ikYa[hfWhj_WbboYel[hij^[9D? <_]$($)$'-$
9D?? ?97 9D?
<_]$($)$'-
Ij[f) :_ii[Yj_d]jej^[c_Zb_d["j^[WhWY^de_Zc[c# XhWd[i e\ j^[ Y^_WicWj_Y Y_ij[hd Wh[ ef[d[Z ki_d]Ód[c_YheiY_iiehi$Dej[j^[Y^_WicWdZ Xej^efj_Yd[hl[i<_]$($)$'.$ Y^_Wic
<_]$($)$'.
./
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r XWiWblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f* 7\j[h \khj^[h Z_ii[Yj_ed WdZ h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWb beX[" j^[ bWc_dW j[hc_dWb_i WdZ j^[ 79e7 YWd X[ WffheWY^[Z$ :k[ je j^[ eXb_gk[ l_[m WdZ ikh]_YWb Z_ii[Yj_ed" h[celWb e\ j^[ ]ohki h[Yjki _i dej d[Y[iiWho m^[d d[Wh_d] j^[79e7Yecfb[n<_]$($)$'/$
Y^_Wic bWc_dWj[hc_dWb_i 79e7 h_]^j7'
<_]$($)$'/
Ij[f+ :_ii[Yj_d] jemWhZi je j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWb Z_h[Y# j_ed"j^[effei_j[YWhej_ZWhj[ho_iWffheWY^[Z$ Dej[ j^[ YWhej_Z X_\khYWj_ed" j^[ C97 Z_iWf# f[Whi_djej^[Iobl_WdÓiikh[<_]$($)$(&$
effei_j[b[\j?97 b[\j7'
<_]$($)$(&
Ij[f, 7\j[hef[d_d]j^[c[Z_WbWif[Yje\j^[effei_j[ Iobl_Wd Óiikh[" j^[ b[\j C97 YWd X[ eXi[hl[Z$ Dej[ j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWb \hedjWb WdZ j[cfehWb beX[iWdZj^[eh_]_de\j^[797<_]$($)$('$
j[cfehWbbeX[ effei_j[C97 \hedjWbbeX[ ?97X_\khYWj_ed 797
<_]$($)$('
/&
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r XWiWblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f- :_ii[Yj_d] W]W_d ed j^[ _fi_bWj[hWb i_Z[ WdZ ef[d_d] j^[ Wdj[hebWj[hWb ikfhWi[bbWh ikX# WhWY^de_Z ifWY[i" j^[ [dj_h[ ikfhWYb_de_Z i[]c[dj e\ j^[ ?97 YWd X[ i[[d$J^[ Iobl_Wd Óiikh[ _i dej o[j ef[d[Z1 ^[h[ j^[ j[cfehWb beX[Yel[hij^[C97"j^[\hedjWbbeX[fh[l[dji eXi[hlWj_ed e\ j^[ 797$ Dej[ j^[ Zehikc i[bbW[WdZj^[9D???"m^_Y^_iZ_ii[Yj[ZWmWo \hec WhWY^de_ZWb WZ^[i_edi m_j^ Ód[ c_Yhe# iY_iiehi<_]$($)$(($
9D?? 9D??? Zehikci[bbW[ ?97
<_]$($)$((
Ij[f. J^[_fi_bWj[hWbIobl_WdÓiikh[_ief[d[ZWbbem# _d]_dl[ij_]Wj_ede\j^[h_]^jC97$7YYehZ_d] jej^[ikX\hedjWbl_[m"j^[C'i[]c[djYWdX[ WffheWY^[Z m_j^ekj h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ j[cfe# hWbbeX[$Dej[j^[YWhej_ZX_\khYWj_edm_j^j^[ eh_]_de\j^[h_]^j797<_]$($)$()$
Ij[f/ 7\j[h \khj^[h Z_ii[Yj_ed" j^[ bWj[hWb Wif[Yj e\ j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh Wh[W _i l_ikWb_p[Z1 j^[ WdW# jec_YWb m_dZemi c[Z_Wb WdZ bWj[hWb je j^[ 9D??? Wh[ ef[d[Z$ J^hek]^ j^[ EF97 WdZ bWj[hWbikfhWi[bbWhm_dZemi"j^[Z[[fh[jhei[b# bWh h[]_ed Wff[Whi m_j^ekj h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ d[khelWiYkbWhijhkYjkh[i$Dej[j^[Wd]b[Zikh# ]_YWbl_[mWYYehZ_d]jej^[ibWdj[ZWif[YjW\j[h h[celWbe\j^[ehX_jWbh_c$M_j^_dj^[feij[h_eh \eiiW"j^[Wdj[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[fediWff[Whi1 dej[ j^[ bWj[hWb fh[fedj_d[" c[Z_Wb WcX_[dj WdZYhkhWbY_ij[hdim_j^j^[I97WdZF(i[]c[dj e\j^[F971j^[9D???Wff[WhiX[jm[[dj^[fei# j[h_ehY[h[XhWbWdZikf[h_ehY[h[X[bbWhWhj[h_[i <_]$($)$(*$
j[cfehWbbeX[ C97X_\khYWj_ed YWhej_ZX_\khYWj_ed C'i[]c[dj 7'i[]c[dj
<_]$($)$()
9D??? fedi I97 ?97 F97
<_]$($)$(*
/'
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r XWiWblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f'& <eYki_d]j^hek]^j^[EF97m_dZem"j^[_dj[h# f[ZkdYkbWh Y_ij[hd YWd X[ i[[d$ J^[ Z_ijWb 87 Wff[Whi X[^_dZ j^[ Zehikc i[bbW[" j^[ B_bb`[gk_ijc[cXhWd[_idejo[jef[d[Z$Dej[ j^[7'"j^[efj_YY^_WicWdZj^[h_]^jefj_YjhWYj <_]$($)$(+$
Y^_Wic ?97 efj_YjhWYj 7'i[]c[dj
<_]$($)$(+
Ij[f'' 7\j[h ][djb[ h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ Y^_Wic m_j^ W c_YheZ_ii[Yjeh" j^[ f_jk_jWho ijWba YWd X[ eXi[hl[Z$ 7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ B_bb`[gk_ij c[c# XhWd[" j^[ 87 Wff[Whi X[^_dZ j^[ Zehikc i[bbW[<_]$($)$(,$
f_jk_jWhoijWba ?97 87
<_]$($)$(,
Ij[f'( J^[ XWiWb ikfhWehX_je#ehX_jWb lWh_Wj_ed e\ j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb YhWd_ejeco fhel_Z[i W iW\[ ikh# ]_YWb [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ kff[h _dj[hf[ZkdYkbWh Y_ij[hdim_j^j^[j_fe\j^[87WdZj^[cWc_b# bWhoXeZ_[i$JhWkcWj_Yh[jhWYj_edWdZ[nj[dZ[Z cel[c[dj e\ j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh d[khelWiYkbWh ijhkYjkh[i Wh[ dej d[Y[iiWho m^[d [nfei_d] j^[XWi_bWhj_f<_]$($)$(-$
I97 XWi_bWhj_f F97 cWc_bbWhoXeZ_[i
<_]$($)$(-
/(
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r XWiWblWh_Wj_ed
+$:khW"Xed[WdZmekdZYbeikh[ 7\j[hYecfb[j_ede\ j^[_djhWYhWd_WbfheY[Zkh[" j^[ikXWhWY^de_Z ifWY[ _i Óbb[Z m_j^ Whj[ÓY_Wb 9I<$ :khWb Ybeikh[ i^ekbZ X[ cWZ[ mWj[hj_]^j Wle_Z_d] feijef[hWj_l[ 9I< ÓijkbW$ ?\ Z[^_iY[dY[ ^Wi Z[l[bef[Z _d j^[ ZkhWb ef[d_d]" W f_[Y[ e\ ckiYb[ YWd X[ i[md _djej^[ZkhWbYbeikh[$?\j^[f[h_ehX_jW_i_d`kh[Z"f[h_ehX_jWbj[Whi i^ekbZX[h[fW_h[ZWle_Z_d]fhejhki_ede\ j^[ehX_jWb\Wj$7fbWj[ e\ ][b\eWc _i fbWY[Z [njhWZkhWbbo" j^[ Xed[ ÔWf _i h[fei_j_ed[Z WdZ WjjWY^[Z ki_d] ed[ eh jme j_jWd_kc fbWj[i$ Dej[ j^Wj j^[ Xed[ÔWfi^ekbZX[Ón[Z_dWdWdWjec_YWbboYehh[YjcWdd[h"dej edbo WY^_[l_d] efj_cWb Yeic[j_Y h[ikbji Xkj Wle_Z_d] feijef[hW# j_l[ [d# eh [nef^j^Wbcei m_j^ W ikXi[gk[dj Z_ijkhXWdY[ e\ [o[# XWbb cej_ed$ 7\j[h YWh[\kbbo eXjW_d_d] Yecfb[j[ ^[ceijWi_i" j^[ ckiYkbWh WdZ ikXYkjWd[eki bWo[hi Wh[ Ybei[Z m_j^ _dj[hhkfj[Z ikjkh[i" j^[ ia_d m_j^ _djhWYkjWd[eki hkdd_d] ikjkh[i eh ij[h_b[ WZ^[i_l[ jWf[i$ 8[YWki[ e\ j^[ b_c_j[Z ia_d _dY_i_ed WdZ ded# jhWkcWj_Yikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk["WikYj_edZhW_d_idejd[Y[iiWho$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i ?dYehh[Yj fbWdd_d] WdZ fWj_[dj fei_j_ed_d] m_j^ _dik\ÓY_[dj _djhWYhWd_Wb[nfeikh[e\j^[b[i_ed$FbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]Wh[ jWiaie\j^[ef[hWj_d]d[kheikh][ed^_ci[b\$ J^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed _i f[h\ehc[Z jee c[Z_Wbbo m_j^ _d`kho je j^[ ikfhWehX_jWbd[hl[WdZikXi[gk[djfeijef[hWj_l[\hedjWbdkcX# d[ii$ F[d[jhWj_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWb fWhWdWiWb i_dki Zkh_d] YhWd_ejeco$ J^[ef[d_d]i^ekbZX[Ybei[Z jeWle_ZWfeijef[hWj_l[9I<Ói# jkbWWdZc[d_d]_j_i$<eh j^_ih[Wied"Xed[mWn"W]Wb[WbÔWfeh WXZec_dWb\Wjj_iik[YWdX[ki[Z$ El[hbeea[ZXkjiec[j_c[ikdWle_ZWXb[_d`khojej^[ZkhWcWj[h Zkh_d] YhWd_ejeco$ <eh mWj[hj_]^j Ybeikh[" icWbb f_[Y[i e\ j^[ j[cfehWb ckiYb[ YWd X[ ki[Z$ ?d iec[ YWi[i" ZkhWb h[YedijhkY# j_edcWoX[d[Y[iiWhoki_d]fbWij_YcWj[h_Wb$ F[d[jhWj_ed e\ j^[ f[h_ehX_jW m_j^ eYYWi_edWb ZWcW][ je _djhW# ehX_jWb ijhkYjkh[i$ Feijef[hWj_l[ ef^j^Wbcebe]_Y Z_ijkhXWdY[i cWoeYYkh$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ h[celWb e\ 9I< Wi j^[ Óhij ij[f e\ j^[ _djhWZkhWb fheY[Zkh[m_j^ikXi[gk[djYedjki_ede\j^[\hedjWbbeX[Zk[je ifWjkbWfh[iikh[$ ?d`kh_[ijedkc[hekid[hl[iWdZl[ii[bi_dj^[fWhWi[bbWhh[]_ed Zkh_d] c_Yheikh]_YWb cWd_fkbWj_ed YWki_d] feijef[hWj_l[ d[k# hebe]_YWbZ[j[h_ehWj_ed_diec[fWj_[dji$
/)
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r XWiWblWh_Wj_ed
?dWZ[gkWj[^[ceijWi_iWdZikXi[gk[dj_djhWYhWd_Wbh[Xb[[Z_d]$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ZkhWbYbeikh[YWki_d]Wfeijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW$ ?dWZ[gkWj[fei_j_ed_d]WdZÓnWj_ede\j^[Xed[ÔWfm_j^feij# ef[hWj_l[[d#eh[nef^j^Wbcei"ikXi[gk[dj[o[cel[c[djZ_i# ehZ[hiWdZfeehYeic[j_Yh[ikbji$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ ^[ceijWi_i Zkh_d] mekdZ Ybeikh[ YWki_d] feijef# [hWj_l[ie\jj_iik[^[cWjecW$
<_]$($)$(.
<_]$($)$(/
J_fiWdZjh_Yai JWa[j_c[\ehfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]$ 9ecfWh[Z je j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb YhWd_ejeco" j^[ ikfhWehX_je# ikfhWehX_jWb WffheWY^ h[gk_h[i ceh[ h[jheÔ[n_ed Zkh_d] ^[WZ fei_j_ed_d]<_]$($)$(.$ <_]$($)$)&
CWa[WYWh[\kbWdWjec_YWbeh_[djWj_edWdZki[j^[j^h[[ij[fie\ cWha_d]m_j^Wij[h_b[f[d0'$eii[ekiijhkYjkh[iWdZikf[hÓY_Wb d[khelWiYkbWhijhkYjkh[i1($fbWY[c[dje\YhWd_ejeco1)$ia_d_dY_# i_ed$ ?\ j^[ [o[Xhem _i dej Zec_dWdj" j^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed cWo X[ f[h# \ehc[Z _d W mh_dab[ eh iYWh _d j^[ ikfhWehX_jWb \hedjej[cfehWb Wh[W$?\ j^[oWh[Wbiedejfh[i[dj"WYkhl[Z\hedjej[cfehWbia_d _dY_i_ed YWd X[ cWZ[ X[^_dZ j^[ ^W_hb_d[$ >em[l[h" ie\j j_iik[ h[jhWYj_ed i^ekbZ X[ h[ijh_Yj[Z je j^[ d[Y[iiWho c_d_ckc je Wle_Zfeijef[hWj_l[d[Yhei_i<_]$($)$(/$
<_]$($)$)'
J^[ \hedjWb WdZ ehX_YkbWh ckiYb[i i^ekbZ X[ \ehY_Xbo h[jhWYj[Z Xej^ZemdmWhZi_dW\hedjWbWdZkfmWhZi_dWdehX_jWbZ_h[Yj_ed m_j^ ijhed] ^ebZ_d] ikjkh[i" [nfei_d] j^[ ehX_jWb h_c WdZ j^[ \hedjebWj[hWbh[]_ed<_]$($)$)&$ <_]$($)$)(
M_j^Wik_jWXbofbWY[ZXkhh^eb["Xej^j^[Wdj[h_eh\eiiWWdZj^[ ehX_jYWdX[ef[d[Zm_j^ekjZWcW]_d]j^[ZkhWcWj[hWdZj^[ f[h_ehX_jW<_]$($)$)'$ IjW][ie\YhWd_ejeco<_]$($)$)(0'$Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_edm_j^ ef[d_d]e\Xej^j^[Wdj[h_eh\eiiWWdZj^[ehX_j1($\hedjWbYkj# j_d]_dWYkhl[Z\Wi^_ed\hecj^[Xkhh^eb[_dWbWj[hWbjec[Z_Wb Z_h[Yj_ed1 )$ Ykjj_d] e\ j^[ po]ecWj_Y fheY[ii e\ j^[ \hedjWb
/*
) '
* + (
IkfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^ r XWiWblWh_Wj_ed
<_]$($)$))
Xed[1*$Z_l_Z_d]j^[ehX_jWbh_c1+$Zh_bb_d]e\j^[bWj[hWbWif[Yj e\j^[ehX_jWbhee\WdZ\hWYjkh_d]j^[ehX_jWbhee\$ :khWb ef[d_d] _d WÇ9È i^Wf[Z \Wi^_ed _i j_c[#Yedikc_d] Xkj Wle_Zikdd[Y[iiWho[nfbehWj_ede\j^[\hedjWbbeX[<_]$($)$))$
<_]$($)$)*
Ki_d] ijhed] ZkhWb ^ebZ_d] ikjkh[i WdZ c_d_cWb Z[fh[ii_ed e\ j^[ehX_jWbijhkYjkh[i"Wceh[Wd]b[Z_djhWYhWd_Wb[nfbehWj_edYWd X[WY^_[l[Z<_]$($)$)*$ Je WY^_[l[ mWj[hj_]^j ZkhWb Ybeikh[" W f_[Y[ e\ ckiYb[ YWd X[ i[md_djej^[ZkhWbYbeikh[<_]$($)$)+$ ?\ j^[ \hedjWb fWhWdWiWb i_dki _i f[d[jhWj[Z" YWh[\kb Ybeikh[ _i h[gk_h[Z$8ed[mWn"WÔWfe\]Wb[WehWXZec_dWb\Wjj_iik[YWdX[ ki[Z\ehj^_ifkhfei[<_]$($)$),$
<_]$($)$)+
7\j[h Yecfb[j_ed e\ j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[" j^[ Xed[ ÔWf i^ekbZ X[ Ón[Z WdWjec_YWbbo je WY^_[l[ efj_cWb Yeic[j_Y ekj# Yec[ WdZ je Wle_Z feijef[hWj_l[ [o[ cel[c[dj Z_iehZ[hi <_]$($)$)-$ ?\fh[i[dj"XedoZ[^_iY[dY[i^ekbZX[Ybei[Zm_j^Wc_Z#ehbWh][# i_p[Zj_jWd_kcfbWj[<_]$($)$).$ <_]$($&$),
J^[[o[Xhem_dY_i_edi^ekbZX[YWh[\kbboYbei[Zm_j^_djhWYkjW# d[ekiikjkh[iehm_j^ij[h_b[WZ^[i_l[jWf[i$ Ki_d]b_c_j[Zia_d_dY_i_edWdZc_d_cWbie\j#j_iik[Z_ii[Yj_ed"de ikYj_edZhW_d_id[Y[iiWho$
<_]$($)$)-
<_]$($)$).
/+
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
)$& IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ >_ijehoe\ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^[i ?d j^[ Yekhi[ e\ d[kheikh]_YWb ^_ijeho" j[Y^d_gk[i ki_d] j[cfe# hWb YhWd_ejec_[i \eh j^[ jh[Wjc[dj e\ jh_][c_dWb d[khWb]_W" ifWY[# eYYkfo_d] b[i_edi e\ j^[ c_ZZb[ WdZ feij[h_eh YhWd_Wb \eiiW WdZ Wd[khoici e\ j^[ _dj[hdWb YWhej_Z WdZ XWi_bWh Whj[h_[i ^Wl[ X[[d \h[gk[djboZ[iYh_X[Z$
<_]$)$&$' IkXj[cfehWb [njhWZkhWb [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ =Wii[# h_Wd]Wd]b_ed_dWYWi[e\i[l[h[j_YZekbekh[kn"fkXb_i^[Z Xo <[Zeh AhWki[ _d '/''$ :_\\[h_d] \hec ceZ[hd j[cfe# hWbehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^[im_j^YWh[\kbZ_ii[Yj_ede\ WdWjec_YWbbWo[hi"j^[Wkj^ehYh[Wj[ZW^ehi[i^e[#i^Wf[Z YecX_d[Zia_d#\WiY_W#ckiYb[#Xed[ÔWfh[jhWYj[Z_d\[h_ehbo el[h j^[ po]ecWj_Y WhY^$ M_j^ j^_i [njhWZkhWb [nfeikh[" _djhWef[hWj_l[ ZWcW][ je j^[ j[cfehWb beX[ YekbZ X[ [\\[Yj_l[boc_d_c_p[Z$
<_]$)$&$( 7 i_c_bWh ikXj[cfehWb [njhWZkhWb WffheWY^ je j^[jh_][c_dWb]Wd]b_edZ[iYh_X[ZXoJWdZb[hWdZHWdp_ _d '/(& _d j^[_h _bbkijhWj[Z j[njXeea ÇIkh]_YWb 7dWjeco WdZEf[hWj_l[J[Y^d_gk[ie\j^[9[djhWbD[hlekiIoij[cÈ
7 \ehc e\ ikXj[cfehWb WffheWY^ je j^[ jh_][c_dWb ]Wd]b_ed mWi Z[iYh_X[ZXo<[ZehAhWki[_d'/''_dj^[i[YedZlebkc[e\^_if_e# d[[h_d]mehaÇIkh][hoe\j^[8hW_dWdZIf_d[ÈfkXb_i^[Z_d8[hb_d" =[hcWdoQAhWki['/''S$J^[Óhijef[hWj_ed\ehjh[Wjc[dje\i[l[h[ jh_][c_dWbd[khWb]_WmWiYWhh_[Zekj_d'./([dYekhW][ZXoj^[d[k# hebe]_ij >[hcWdd Eff[d^[_c$ 7 fh[#Wkh_YkbWh ikXj[cfehWb [njhW# ZkhWb WffheWY^ mWi Z[l[bef[Z \eh [nj_hfWj_ed e\ j^[ =Wii[h_Wd ]Wd]b_ed m^[h[W\j[h j^[ i[l[h[ j_Y Zekbekh[kn e\ j^[ ;d]b_i^ YWf# jW_dC_bjed>emWhZi^em[ZcWha[Zfeijef[hWj_l[_cfhel[c[dj$ ?d'/&'"j^[d[khebe]_ijM_bb_WcIf_bb[hWdZj^[ikh][ed9^Whb[i Whl[o9ki^_d] Wbieef[hWj[ZedfWj_[djiik\\[h_d]\hecj_YZekbekh[knQ9ki^_d] '/'(S$?d'/(&"@kb_kiJWdZb[hWdZ;$HWdp_Z[iYh_X[ZWikXj[cfehWb [nfeikh[ _d j^[_h lebkc[ ÇIkh]_YWb 7dWjeco WdZ Ef[hWj_l[ J[Y^# d_gk[i e\ j^[ 9[djhWb D[hleki Ioij[cÈ QJWdZb[h é HWdp_ '/(&S$ CWdo o[Whi bWj[h" W l[ho i_c_bWh c[j^eZ mWi ki[Z Xo BkZm_] =$ A[cf["m^eZ[iYh_X[ZWdeij[eYbWij_Y[njhWZkhWbWffheWY^\ehj^[ i[b[Yj_l[h[jhe]Wii[h_Wdh^_pejecoe\j^[cWn_bbWhoWdZcWdZ_Xk# bWhheejie\j^[jh_][c_dWbd[hl[<_]$)$&$)QA[cf['/,.S$ 7 if[Y_Wb _dZ_YWj_ed \eh W ikXj[cfehWb WffheWY^ mWi eYYbki_l[ ^oZheY[f^Wbki$?d'/)("MWbj[h:WdZoZ[iYh_X[ZWbWj[hWbikXj[c# fehWb WffheWY^ \eh W j^_hZ l[djh_Ykbeijeco Q:WdZo '/)(S$ 9ec# fWh[Zm_j^^_i_d_j_WbikX\hedjWb[nfeikh["j^[ikXj[cfehWbj^_hZ l[djh_Ykbeijeco Z_Z dej h[gk_h[ Z_l_i_ed e\ j^[ efj_Y d[hl[ \eh ef[d_d]j^[Ôeehe\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[<_]$)$&$*$?d'/*+":WdZo fkXb_i^[ZWi[h_[ie\/(fWj_[djijh[Wj[Z_dj^_i\Wi^_edm_j^W'( cehjWb_johWj[WdZm_j^Whh[ije\j^[^oZheY[f^Wbki_d+&e\j^[ fWj_[djiQ:WdZo'/*+S$
/-
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
J^[j[cfehWbWffheWY^jeWd_djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoicmWiÓhijfkX# b_i^[Z Xo 7$I$Jh[lWd_ Wi ^[ mWi [nfbeh_d] W fWj_[dj \eh W jkceh m_j^_dj^[c_ZZb[YhWd_Wb\eiiWQJh[lWd_'/)(S$7\j[hf[h\ehc_d]W bWh][j[cfehWbÔWf[nj[dZ_d]_djej^[\hedjWbWdZfWh_[jWbh[]_ed" ^[\ekdZW]_WdjWd[khoice\j^[_dj[hdWbYWhej_ZWhj[ho$M_bb_Wc @$=WhZd[hZ[iYh_X[ZWYWi[_dm^_Y^Wj[cfehWbYhWd_ejecomWi ki[Z \eh W ^ofef^oi[Wb jkceh m^_Y^ mWi Wbie Wd Wd[khoic e\ j^[ _dj[hdWb YWhej_Z Q=WhZd[h '/),S$ 7\j[h _djhWef[hWj_l[ hkfjkh[" j^[ef[hWj_d]Ó[bZmWiÓbb[Zm_j^]Wkp[m^_Y^X[YWc[_d\[Yj[Z WdZmWih[cel[Z jmeo[WhibWj[h$Ej^[hiikXi[gk[djboki[Z j^[ j[cfehWbhekj[\ehfbWdd[Zef[hWj_edi\ehWd[khoicie\j^[_dj[h# dWb YWhej_Z Whj[ho WdZ _ji XhWdY^[i$ F[j[h >Whh_i WdZ =[eh][ 8$ KZlWh^[bo_h[Yecc[dZ[ZWikXj[cfehWbYhWd_[Yjeco_dij[WZe\ YhWd_ejecoQ>Whh_iWdZKZlWh^[bo_'/+-S$@Wc[iB$Feff[d_d'/,& <_]$)$&$+"@_heIkpka__d'/,+"WdZ;$Ij[f^[di=khZ`_Wd_d'/-& [WY^h[fehj[Zedj^[ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^\ehWd[khoicie\j^[ F9e7QFeff[d'/,&"Ikpka_'/,+"=khZ`_Wd'/-&S$ J^[Óhijikh][edjeki[j^[j[cfehWb#ikXj[cfehWbhekj[\eh[nfe# ikh[ e\ XWi_bWh Wd[khoici mWi <$ @e^d =_bb_d]^Wc$ ?d '/+." ^[ h[fehj[Z\ekhYWi[i_dm^_Y^jmeWd[khoicim[h[Yb_ff[ZWdZjme m[h[mhWff[Zm_j^\WiY_WQ=_bb_d]^Wc'/+.S$J^[h[Wbf_ed[[h_d j^[Z[l[befc[dje\ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^[i\ehWd[khoicie\j^[ XWi_bWhWhj[ho"^em[l[h"mWi9^Whb[i:hWa["m^eh[fehj[Z^_iÓhij [nf[h_[dY[i_d'/,&e\Wd[khoicie\j^[XWi_bWhj_fQ:hWa['/,&S$ ?d'/,."^[mWiWXb[jeZ[iYh_X[Z_\\[h[djlWh_Wj_edie\j^[ikXj[c# fehWbWdZj[cfeheXWiWbWffheWY^[i[nfei_d]j^[XWi_bWhX_\khYW# j_ed"j^[kff[hWdZbem[hXWi_bWhjhkda"WdZj^[j[hc_dWbl[hj[XhWb Whj[h_[i<_]$)$&$,$?dj^[Zk[Yekhi[e\j_c[":hWa[ÊiÔWfX[YWc[ icWbb[hWdZceh[Wdj[h_eh"Z[cedijhWj_d]:hWa[Êif[hiedWbb[Whd# _d]fheY[ii_dh[ZkY_d]ikh]_YWbjhWkcWj_pWj_ed$J^[bWh][feij[h_eh YhWd_ejec_[im[h[edboki[Zjeh[WY^bem[hi_jkWj[ZWd[khoici_d j^[ feij[h_eh \eiiW W\j[h i[Yj_ed_d] e\ j^[ f[jheYb_de_Z b_]Wc[dj WdZ j[djeh_kc Q:hWa[ '/,." '/-.S$ BkZm_] @$ A[cf[" ;$ Ij[f^[di =khZ`_Wd" A[_`_ IWde WdZ :edWbZ >$ M_bied ikXi[gk[djbo kj_# b_p[Zj^[ikXj[cfehWbhekj["WbX[_jm_j^Z_\\[h[djceZ_ÓYWj_edie\ ia_d_dY_i_edWdZYhWd_ejeco<_]$)$&$-$JWa[i^_AWmWi[h[fehj[Z edj^[ikXj[cfehWbjhWdif[jheiWbWffheWY^\ehWd[khoicie\j^[ bem[hXWi_bWhWhj[hoW\j[hh[celWbe\j^[f[jhekiWf[nQA[cf['/,." =khZ`_Wd'/-&"IWde'/-'"M_bied'/-'"AWmWi['/.+S$ ;nfeikh[e\ j^[feij[h_eh\eiiWWdZ_dj[hdWbWkZ_jehoYWdWbl_WW ikXj[cfehWb c_ZZb[ YhWd_Wb \eiiW WffheWY^ mWi Óhij Z[iYh_X[Z
/.
<_]$)$&$) 7 b_c_j[Z ikXj[cfehWb eij[eYbWij_Y [njhWZkhWb [nfeikh[ \eh h[jhe]Wii[h_Wd h^_pejeco e\ j^[ cWn_bbWho WdZcWdZ_XkbWhheejie\j^[jh_][c_dWbd[hl[_dfWj_[dji ik\\[h_d] \hec i[l[h[ jh_][c_dWb d[khWb]_W fkXb_i^[Z Xo A[cf[_d'/,.$Dej[j^[i[b[Yj_l[Z_ii[Yj_ede\j^[i[dieho d[hl[heejiWdZfhej[Yj_ede\j^[hWZ_ncejeh_W$
<_]$)$&$* :WdZoÊij[cfehWb[nfeikh[\ehWj^_hZl[djh_Yk# beijecofkXb_i^[Z_d'/)($Dej[j^[icWbbia_d_dY_i_edWdZ c_d_cWbh[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[$J^[Ôeehe\j^[ [dbWh][Zj^_hZl[djh_Yb[mWiWffheWY^[ZX[jm[[dj^[?97 WdZ9D???$
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
7
<_]$)$&$+ J[cfehWb [nfeikh[ \eh Wd[khoici e\ j^[ _dj[h# dWbYWhej_ZWhj[hoWdZj^[_hXhWdY^[iWYYehZ_d]jeFeff[d fkXb_i^[Z_d'/,&$
8
<_]$)$&$- A[cf[Êi j[cfehWb ÔWf \eh XWi_bWh Whj[ho Wd[k# hoici" fkXb_i^[Z _d '/,.$ Dej[ j^[ [nj[dZ[Z \hedjWb WdZ j[cfehWbXed[h[celWb$
<_]$)$&$, :_\\[h[djikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^[i\ehjh[Wj_d] XWi_bWhWhj[hoWd[khoicifkXb_i^[ZXo9^Whb[i:hWa[_d '/,&" '/,. WdZ '/-.$ Dej[ j^[ \hedjefWh_[jWb [nj[di_ed e\ j^[ [nj[dZ[Z '/,& YhWd_ejeco h[Z Whhemi je ]W_d [nfeikh[jej^[l[djhWbboi_jkWj[ZWd[khoicZ_W]dei[ZXo fh[ef[hWj_l[ Wd]_e]hWf^o 7$ :hWa[Éi ikXj[cfehWb YhW# d_ejeco\ehXWi_bWhj_fWd[khoici"fkXb_i^[Z_d'/,.8$?d '/-."^[jh[Wj[ZWl[hoi_c_bWhWd[khoicl_WWb_c_j[ZikX# j[cfehWb[nfeikh[Z[cedijhWj_d]^_if[hiedWb[nf[h_[dY[ _dh[ZkY_d]ef[hWj_l[jhWkcW9$
9
//
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
XoH$>$FWhho_d'/&*$>[Z[iYh_X[ZWYWi[e\j_dd_jkiWdZl[hj_]e jh[Wj[Z Xo Z_l_i_ed e\ j^[ WkZ_jeho d[hl[ QFWhho '/&*S$J^[ i[dj_# d[bmehae\M_bb_Wc<$>eki[_d'/,'b[Zjej^[h[Ód[c[dje\j^_i WffheWY^ \eh j^[ _dj[hdWb WkZ_jeho YWdWb WdZ Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[ Wd]b[$J^[ WffheWY^ mWi ki[Z _d_j_Wbbo \eh Z[Yecfh[ii_ed e\ j^[ _dj[hdWb WkZ_jeho YWdWb _d YWi[i e\ [nj[di_l[ ejeiYb[hei_i _dlebl# _d] j^[ bWXoh_dj^_d[ Xed[$ J^Wj _dZ_YWj_ed ^Wi X[[d WXWdZed[Z" Xkjj^[c_ZZb[\eiiWWffheWY^^WiX[Yec[Wmeha^ehi[_d[nfei# _d] icWbb l[ij_XkbWh iY^mWddecWi m^[d fh[ef[hWj_l[ ^[Wh_d] h[cW_di_djWYjQ>eki['/,'"<_iY^'/,.S<_]$)$&$.$ J^[ ikXj[cfehWb f[jheiWb WffheWY^ \eh c[d_d][ecWi e\ j^[ feij[h_eh \eiiW WdZ f[jheYb_lWb h[]_ed mWi Z[iYh_X[Z Xo C$ =Wp_ OWiWh]_b_d'/.&"BWb_]WcD$I[a^Wh_d'/.*"EiiWcW7b#C[\jo_d '/.."CWZ`_ZIWc___d'/./WdZJWa[i^_AWmWi[_d'//'<_]$)$&$/$
<_]$)$&$. ?Z[dj_ÓYWj_ed e\ j^[ _dj[hdWb WkZ_jeo YWdWb Xo j^[ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ki_d]j^[ikf[h_ehi[c_Y_hYkbWh YWdWbWikd_gk[bWdZcWha"fkXb_i^[ZXoK]e<_iY^_d'/,.$ J^[h[bWj_edi^_fe\j^[[nj[hdWbWkZ_jehoYWdWb'"j^[heej e\j^[po]ecWj_YWhY^("j^[ikf[h_ehi[c_Y_hYkbWhYWdWb )"j^[l[ij_XkbWhd[hl[*"j^[\WY_Wbd[hl[+"j^[][d_Yk# bWj[]Wd]b_ed,WdZj^[XWiWbj[hce\j^[YeY^b[W-_i m[bbZ[cedijhWj[Z$
Jkceheki WdZ lWiYkbWh b[i_edi e\ j^[ YWl[hdeki i_dki m[h[ Yed# i_Z[h[Z je X[ _def[hWXb[ X[\eh[ j^[ f_ed[[h_d] meha e\ :m_]^j FWha_died$7ffheWY^[ij^hek]^j^[bWj[hWbmWbbe\j^[YWl[hdeki i_dkiki_d]ikXj[cfehWb[nfeikh[m[h[fkXb_i^[ZXoi[l[hWb[nf[# h_[dY[Zikh][ediQFWha_died'/,+"'/-)"@e^dijed'/-/"KcWdiao '/.(" :eb[dY '/.)" F[hd[Ypao '/.-S$ ;nj[dZ[Z \hedje#j[cfehWb WdZ j[cfehe#XWiWb [nfeikh[i \eh b[i_edi e\ j^[ YWl[hdeki i_dki Wh[WWdZj[cfehWbiakbbXWi[m[h[h[fehj[ZXoBWb_]WcD$I[a^Wh" L_dae:eb[dYWdZEiiWcW7b#C[\joQI[a^Wh'/.,":eb[dY'/.-" 7b#C[\jo '/..S1 ^em[l[h" j^[ ZWcW]_d] WffheWY^[i ikY^ Wi j^[ fh[#Wkh_YkbWh _d\hWj[cfehWb eh ehX_jepo]ecWj_Y [nfeikh[i kik# Wbbo Z_Z dej _dÔk[dY[ j^[ [nj[dj e\ h[i[Yj_ed Xkj h[ikbj[Z _d ^_]^[h feijef[hWj_l[ cehX_Z_jo$ 9ecfWh[Z m_j^ j^[i[ [nj[dZ[Z WffheWY^[i" ej^[h Wkj^ehi h[fehj[Z ed ikXj[cfehWb a[o^eb[ YhWd_ejec_[i"Wbbem_d]efj_cWbl_ikWb_pWj_ede\j^[feij[h_ehWdZ bWj[hWbWif[Yje\j^[YWl[hdekii_dkiWdZj^[j[cfehWbiakbbXWi[ QF[hd[Ypao'/.."Adeif'//,"JWd_]kY^_'//-S$
=[d[hWbWdWjec_YWbYedijhkYj_ede\j^[ c_ZZb[YhWd_Wb\eiiW"j^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[WdZ j^[ikfhWi[bbWhh[]_ed Fh_ehjef[h\ehc_d]WikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^"j^[WdWjec_YWbY^W# hWYj[h_ij_Yi e\ j^[ c_ZZb[ WdZ Wdj[h_eh YhWd_Wb \eiiW i^ekbZ Óhij X[ Yedi_Z[h[Z$ J^[ XWi[ e\ j^[ Wdj[h_eh fWhj e\ j^[ c_ZZb[ YhW# d_Wb\eiiW_ii_jkWj[ZZ[[f[hj^Wdj^[XWi[e\j^[ikfhWi[bbWhWh[W"
'&&
<_]$)$&$/ AWmWi[ÊiikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^eXi[hl_d]b[i_# edie\j^[Y[djhWbiakbbXWi[$Dej[j^[m_Z[[nfeikh[e\j^[ feij[h_eh\eiiWW\j[hh[celWbe\j^[f[jhekiWf[n$
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
7
h[fh[i[dj[Z Xo j^[ Wdj[h_eh WdZ feij[h_eh Yb_de_Z fheY[ii[i WdZ j^[Z_Wf^hW]cWi[bbW[QBWd]'/.'S$J^_ic[Wdij^WjWffheWY^_d] j^_iWh[W\hecWbWj[hWb"j[cfehWbZ_h[Yj_ed"j^[Wdj[h_ehfWhje\j^[ j[cfehWbbeX[eXiYkh[iWYY[iijej^[_cfehjWdjikfhWi[bbWhijhkY# jkh[i$J^[h[\eh["ki_d]j^[Wdj[h_ehj[cfehWb[nfeikh["cWd_fkbW# j_edWdZh[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[ckijWbmWoiX[_dYbkZ[Z m_j^ikXi[gk[dj_d`khoWdZYedjki_ede\j^[XWiWbfWhje\j^[j[c# fehWbbeX[$?dehZ[hjec_d_c_p[j^[h[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[" j^[Wdj[h_ehikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejecoi^ekbZX[fbWY[ZWiYbei[je j^[XWi[Wifeii_Xb[<_]$)$&$'&7"8$?dWZZ_j_ed"Wfeij[h_ehfbWY[# c[dje\j^[YhWd_ejecoYWd[\\[Yj_l[boc_d_c_p[j[cfehWbh[jhWY# j_ed<_]$)$&$'&9$;WhboZhW_dW][e\9I<"WZ[gkWj[fei_j_ed_d]e\ j^[fWj_[dj"c_d_cWbZkhWbef[d_d]WdZYWh[\kbikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Wh[Wbie[ii[dj_Wb\WYjehijeWle_ZYedjki_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[$ Ki_d] ikXj[cfehWb YhWd_ejec_[i" W \h[gk[djbo Z[iYh_X[Z ikh]_YWb fheXb[c _i Z[Wb_d] m_j^ j^[ _d\[h_eh WdWijecej_Y l[_d e\ BWXX$ >em[l[h" ki_d] W b_c_j[Z Wdj[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb WffheWY^" Z_ii[Y# j_ede\j^[feij[h_ehboi_jkWj[Zl[_dckijX[d[l[h_dYbkZ[Z$
8
J^[cW_djWh][jh[]_ediki_d]j^[Wdj[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ Wh[j^[bWj[hWbWif[Yje\j^[ikfhWi[bbWhh[]_ed"j^[YWl[hdekii_dki WdZj^[Wdj[hebWj[hWbfeij[h_eh\eiiW$ 7ifh[l_ekiboZ[iYh_X[Z"j^[ikfhWi[bbWhh[]_edYWdX[h[fh[i[dj[Z Wi W l_hjkWb fohWc_Z Wbbem_d] W X[jj[h YedijhkYj_edWb _cW][ e\ j^_iWh[W<_]$)$&$''$J^[XWi[e\j^[fohWc_Z_i\ehc[ZXoj^[Z_W# f^hW]cWi[bbW[WdZj^[bWj[hWbfbWd[Yedi_ijie\j^[?97"9D??"efj_Y jhWYj" F9e7" 79^7" WdZ j^[ 9D ???$J^[ feij[h_eh jh_Wd]b[ fbWd[ _i Z[Ód[ZXoj^[l[djhWbikh\WY[e\j^[c[i[dY[f^WbedWdZj^[87" F97WdZj^[I97$J^[fohWc_Zi^emiWib_]^jj_bjXWYamWhZim_j^ _jiWn_i\ehc[ZXoj^[_d\kdZ_XkbkcWdZf_jk_jWhoijWba$
9
<_]$)$&$'& ;nfei_d] j^[ ikfhW# WdZ fWhWi[bbWh h[]_ed j^hek]^ Wd Wdj[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb YhWd_ejeco" h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ j[cfehWb beX[ ckij WbmWoi X[ _dYbkZ[Z 7$ >em[l[h" Zk[ je W XWiWb 8 eh feij[h_eh 9 fbWY[c[dj e\ j^[ WffheWY^" j[cfehWb Yedjki_ed YWd X[ [\\[Yj_l[bo c_d_c_p[Z$
J^[XWi[e\j^[fohWc_ZYehh[ifedZijej^[Z_Wf^hW]cWi[bbW[Wi hee\e\j^[X_bWj[hWbYWl[hdekii_dki$
'&'
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
8
7
9 7
<_]$)$&$'( 7hj_ijÊiZhWm_d]Z[cedijhWj_d]j^[b[\jYWl[hd# ekii_dki$J^[l[dekiY^WcX[hYWdX[Z_l_Z[Z_djej^h[[ cW`eh fWhji$J^[ Wdj[h_eh fWhj h[fh[i[dji j^[ fWhW#_d\hW# Yb_de_ZWbi[]c[djie\j^[?977$J^[c_ZZb[fWhj_dlebl[i j^[bWj[hWbmWbbe\j^[9IWdZj^[^eh_pedjWbi[]c[dje\ j^[ ?97 8$J^[ feij[h_eh fWhj _dlebl[i j^[ f[jheki Wf[n WdZj^[feij[h_ehad[[e\j^[?979$
8
9
<_]$)$&$'' 7l_hjkWbfohWc_ZYedijhkYj_ede\j^[ikfhWi[bbWhh[]_ed"Z[cedijhWj_d] lWh_ekil_[m_d]Wd]b[ij^hek]^j^[7Wdj[h_eh"8c_ZZb["WdZ9feij[h_ehikXj[c# fehWb[nfeikh[i$Dej[j^Wjj^[iWc[WdWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[iWh[[nfei[ZZ_\\[h[djbo WYYehZ_d]jeZ_l[hi[ikh]_YWbl_ikWb_pWj_edi$
'&(
<_]$)$&$') J^[ Wdj[hebWj[hWb feij[h_eh \eiiW YWd X[ [nfei[Zki_d]WjhWdij[djeh_Wb[nj[di_ede\j^[ikXj[cfe# hWbWffheWY^$Dej[j^Wjj^[kff[hY[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[ YWd Wbie X[ Z[Ód[Z Wi W l_hjkWb fohWc_Z" m_j^ _ji Wf[n h[fh[i[dj[ZXoj^[feij[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[iiWdZj^[XWi[ \ehc[ZXoj^[Wdj[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[XhW_dij[c$
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
Ki_d]WdWdj[h_ehikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejeco"j^[ikfhWi[bbWhfohWc_Z WdZj^[YWl[hdekii_dkiWh[WffheWY^[Z\hecWbWj[heXWiWbWif[Yj1 ^em[l[h"m_j^_dY_i_ede\j^[j[djeh_kcWdZfWhj_Wbh[celWbe\j^[ f[jhekiWf[n" j^[feij[h_ehYhWd_Wb\eiiWYWdWbieX[WffheWY^[Z$ J^[ Wdj[hebWj[hWb feij[h_eh \eiiW WdZ j^[ Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[ Wd]b[ h[]_edYWdWbieX[Z[Ód[ZWiWfohWc_ZXkj_dYb_d[Zl[djhWbbom_j^ _ji Wf[n fe_dj_d] je j^[ feij[h_eh Yb_de_Z fheY[ii WdZ j^[ XWi[ \WY_d] j^[ _dd[h bWj[hWb ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ eYY_f_jWb Xed[ <_]$ )$&$')$ J^[ ikf[h_eh i_Z[ Yehh[ifedZi je j^[ _d\[h_eh ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ j[d# jeh_kcm_j^j^[9D?Lhkdd_d]j^hek]^_j$J^[_d\[hec[Z_Wbi_Z[ _dYbkZ[i j^[L7 WdZ j^[ 9D N??$J^[ Wdj[h_eh WdZ feij[h_eh i_Z[i Wh[h[fh[i[dj[ZXoj^[feij[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[f[jhekiXed[WdZ j^[Wdj[hebWj[hWbikh\WY[e\j^[XhW_dij[cWdZY[h[X[bbkc"h[if[Y# j_l[bo$ Ki_d] j^[ Wdj[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb WffheWY^" j^[ kff[h fWhj e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[fohWc_ZYWdX[[dj[h[Z$7\j[hf[h\ehc_d]Wj[d# jeh_Wb_dY_i_edWdZfWhj_Wbh[i[Yj_ede\j^[f[jhekiWf[n"j^[l_[m _djej^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[fohWc_Z_iZ_l_Z[ZXoj^[9DL_djejme cW`ehm_dZemi$J^[YhWd_Wbm_dZeme\\[hiWYY[iijej^[f[jheYb_lWb h[]_edm_j^m_Z[[nfeikh[WhekdZj^[Wdj[hebWj[hWbfedjec[i[d# Y[f^Wb`kdYj_edWdZijhkYjkh[ie\j^[9D???"9D?L"87"WdZfhen_# cWbfehj_edie\j^[F97WdZj^[I97$J^hek]^j^[YWkZWbm_dZem" j^[c_ZZb[fWhje\j^[Yb_lkiYWdX[WffheWY^[Z_dYbkZ_d]j^[7?97 WdZj^[9DL?$ ?dj^[\ebbem_d]"j^[XWi_Yikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[e\j^[Wdj[h_ehikX# j[cfehWbWffheWY^_iZ[iYh_X[ZWiWij[f#Xo#ij[fZ_ii[Yj_ed$
IkfhW#"fWhWi[bbWh
9Wl[hdekii_dki
Feij[h_eh\eiiW
J[cfeheXWiWbiakbbXWi[ 7dj[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii Feij[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii :ehikci[bbW[ 7FYB"J[djeh_kc :_Wf^hW]cWi[bbW[ ?d\kdZ_Xkbkc"F_jk_jWhoijWba 9D??"efj_YjhWYj"9D???"9D?L ?97"7'"F9e7"79^7"_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi
9D???"9D?L =Wii[h_Wd]Wd]b_ed 9DL%'"9DL%("9DL%) 9DL? ?97_dYb$_djhWYWl[hdeki XhWdY^[i
Kff[hYb_lki 7dj[hebWj[hWbc[i[dY[f^Wbed 7dj[hebWj[hWbfedi J[djeh_kc 9DL"9DL?"9DL??"9DL??? 87"F97"I97"7?97" _dYb$f[h\ehWjehi 8WiWbl[_de\Hei[dj^Wb F[jhekil[_de\:WdZo
JWXb[)$&$' 7dWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[iWffheWY^[Zj^hek]^j^[ikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejeco$
'&)
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[ '$FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] J^[fWj_[dj_ifbWY[Zikf_d[WdZj^[_fi_bWj[hWbi^ekbZ[h_ihW_i[Z m_j^ W Yki^_ed je \WY_b_jWj[ ^[WZ hejWj_ed$ 7d [b[Yjh_YWbbo cejeh# _p[Zef[hWj_d]jWXb[e\\[hiWdWZZ_j_edWbj_bj_d]WdZ_djhWef[hWj_l[ h[ceZ[bb_d]e\fWj_[djfei_j_ed_d]$8ojWa_d]j^[i[fh[YWkj_edi"W i_]d_ÓYWdj^[WZWdZd[YahejWj_edm_j^ikXi[gk[djYecfh[ii_ed e\ j^[bWhodn"YWhej_ZWhj[hoWdZ j^[_dj[hdWb`k]kbWhl[_dYWdX[ Wle_Z[Z$J^[^[WZ_iÓn[Z_dWj^h[[#f_dCWoÓ[bZ^ebZ[hm_j^j^[ i_d]b[ f_d fbWY[Z _d j^[ \hedjWb Wh[W je Wbbem \h[[ cWd_fkbWj_ed Zkh_d]j^[fheY[Zkh[$
<_]$)$&$'*
Ij[f' ?d_j_Wbbo"j^[^[WZ_i[b[lWj[ZWXel[j^[b[l[be\j^[j^ehWnje\WY_b_# jWj[ l[deki ZhW_dW][ WdZ je Wbbem WZZ_j_edWb Z[Yecfh[ii_ed e\ j^[Y[hl_YWbijhkYjkh[iWdZj^[l[dj_bWj_edjkX[<_]$)$&$'*$ Ij[f( ?dj^[d[njijW][j^[^[WZ_ihejWj[Z,&Å'&&jej^[YedjhWbWj[hWb i_Z[$J^[Z[]h[[e\hejWj_edZ[f[dZiedj^[fh[Y_i[beYWj_ede\j^[ b[i_ed$JWa[dWiWhek]^_dZ_YWjeh"\ehb[i_edie\j^[bWj[hWbikfhW# i[bbWhWh[WWdZkff[hfh[fedj_d[h[]_ed"j^[po]ecWj_YWhY^i^ekbZ X[_dWdWbceij^eh_pedjWbfei_j_edm_j^WhejWj_ede\YW$/&$<eh j^[f[jhekiWf[n"feij[h_eh\eiiWWdZj^[kff[hY[h[X[bbefedj_d[ Wd]b["W^[WZhejWj_ede\YW$-+_ih[gk_h[Z$7hejWj_ede\YW$'&&_i d[Y[iiWho\eh[nfei_d]j^[j[cfehefebWhiakbbXWi[<_]$)$&$'+$ Ij[f) J^[h[W\j[h j^[ ^[WZ i^ekbZ X[ bWj[heÔ[Yj[Z Xo YW$ '+Å(&$ J^_i _cfehjWdj cWd[klh[ fhel_Z[i Wd [\ÓY_[dj meha_d] fei_j_ed \eh j^[ikh][edWij^[ij[[fkfmWhZWd]b[e\j^[c[Z_WbfWhje\j^[ c_ZZb[YhWd_Wb\eiiW_iYecf[diWj[Z$?dWZZ_j_ed"bWj[heÔ[n_edikf# fehjij^[]hWl_jo#h[bWj[Zi[b\#h[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[m^_Y^ _id[Y[iiWhojeWle_Z\ehY[Zh[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[m_j^ ikXi[gk[djj[cfeheXWiWbYedjki_ed<_]$)$&$',$
<_]$)$&$'+
<_]$)$&$',
Ij[f* 7iWbWijij[f"j^[^[WZcWoX[h[jheÔ[Yj[ZXoYW$'&_dehZ[hdejje Yecfh[iij^[l[dj_bWj_edjkX["bWhodnWdZj^[cW_dY[hl_YWbl[ii[bi <_]$)$&$'-$ <_]$)$&$'-
'&*
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
($7dWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZeh_[djWj_ed <ehfh[ef[hWj_l[eh_[djWj_ed"j^[_cfehjWdjWdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhai e\j^[j[cfehWbeii[ekiiakbbikY^Wij^[bWj[hWbehX_jWbh_c"\hedje# XWi_i" _cfh[ii_ed e\ j^[ Iobl_Wd Óiikh[" po]ecWj_Y WhY^" Whj_YkbWh jkX[hYkb[" [nj[hdWb WkZ_jeho c[Wjki WdZ j^[ ikfhWcWije_Z Yh[ij Wh[fh[Y_i[boZ[Ód[Z$If[Y_WbWjj[dj_edckijX[]_l[djej^[Yekhi[ e\ j^[ ikf[hÓY_Wb d[khelWiYkbWh ijhkYjkh[i e\ j^[ fh[#Wkh_YkbWh j[cfehWbh[]_edikY^Wij^[ikf[hÓY_Wbj[cfehWbWhj[ho"j^[Wkh_# Ykbej[cfehWbd[hl["WdZ j^[ j[cfehWbXhWdY^e\ j^[\WY_Wbd[hl[ <_]$)$&$'.$ 7\j[hfh[Y_i[eh_[djWj_ed"j^[XehZ[hie\j^[YhWd_ejecoWh[cWha[Z m_j^Wij[h_b[f[d"jWa_d]_djeYedi_Z[hWj_edj^[jWh][jh[]_edWdZ j^[ ikf[hÓY_Wb WdWjec_YWb bWdZcWhai$J^[ _d\[h_eh XehZ[h e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco"m^_Y^kikWbbo^WiWZ_Wc[j[he\YW$'+je(+cc"Yeh# h[ifedZijej^[b[l[be\j^[po]ecWj_YWhY^1j^[feij[h_ehXehZ[h Yehh[ifedZijej^[fbWd[e\j^[[nj[hdWbWkZ_jehoYWdWb<_]$)$&$'.$ 7\j[hZ[Ód_j_ede\j^[YhWd_ejeco"j^[i_Z[^W_hiWh[i^Wl[ZWYYehZ# _d]jej^[b_d[e\WijhW_]^jia_d_dY_i_ede\YW$*&Å+&cc_db[d]j^$ J^[ia_d_iZ_i_d\[Yj[Zc[j_YkbekiboWdZj^[[o[b_ZiWh[fhej[Yj[Z m_j^i[di_j_l[jWf[$
<_]$)$&$'. :[Ód_j_ede\j^[YhWd_ejecoWYYehZ_d]jej^[WdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaie\ j^[ j[cfehWbh[]_ed$J^[ia_d_dY_i_edi^ekbZX[cWZ[Wdj[h_eh je j^[ikf[hÓY_Wb j[cfehWbWhj[ho"Wffhen_cWj[boWjj^[b[l[be\j^[Whj_YkbWhjkX[hYkb[$
'&+
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
)$9hWd_ejeco Ij[f' B[\j i_Z[$ 7\j[h fei_j_ed_d] WdZ WdWjec_YWb eh_[djWj_ed" W l[hj_YWb ijhW_]^j [f_\WiY_Wb ia_d _dY_i_ed _i cWZ[ \hec j^[ _d\[h_eh h_c e\ j^[ po]ecWj_Y WhY^ Wj j^[ b[l[b e\ j^[ Whj_YkbWh jkX[hYkb[ Wffhen_cWj[bo '& cc Wdj[h_eh je j^[ [nj[hdWb WkZ_jeho c[Wjki$ 7\j[h f[h\ehc# _d] j^_i fh[Wkh_YkbWh ia_d _dY_i_ed" j^[ ikXYk# jWd[eki j_iik[ _i YWh[\kbbo Z_ii[Yj[Z m^_bij fh[i[hl_d]j^[ikf[hÓY_Wbj[cfehWbWhj[hoWdZ Wkh_Ykbej[cfehWbd[hl[$M_j^j^_iia_d_dY_i_ed" _d`kho je j^[ j[cfehWb XhWdY^ e\ j^[ \WY_Wb d[hl[YWdX[Wle_Z[Z<_]$)$&$'/$
<_]$)$&$'/
<_]$)$&$(&
Ij[f( 7\j[hX_bWj[hWbh[jhWYj_ede\j^[ia_d"j^[\WiY_W e\ j^[ j[cfehWb ckiYb[ _i Ykj _d W O#i^Wf[Z \Wi^_ed$J^[XWiWbÔWfe\j^[\WiY_W_ih[Ô[Yj[Z kfmWhZiel[hj^[po]ecWj_YWhY^$J^[h[cW_d# _d] jme ÔWfi e\ j^[ j[cfehWb \WiY_W Wh[ Z_i# i[Yj[Z X_bWj[hWbbo [nfei_d] j^[ j[cfehWb ckiYb[<_]$)$&$(&$
<_]$)$&$('
Ij[f) J^[XWiWbÔWfe\j^[\WiY_W_iÓn[Zm_j^^ebZ_d] ikjkh[i kfmWhZi$ KdZ[h j^[ po]ecWj_Y WhY^" j^[_d\[h_ehcWh]_de\j^[j[cfehWbckiYb[_i Z_ii[Yj[Z Xbkdjbo WdZ h[jhWYj[Z ZemdmWhZi m_j^WZ_ii[Yjeh[nfei_d]j^[igkWcekiXed[$ BeYWb ^[ceijWi_i d[[Zi je X[ f[h\ehc[Z hWf# _ZboWdZfh[Y_i[bo<_]$)$&$('$
'&,
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
Ij[f* ?dfWj_[djim_j^Wj^_Yaj[cfehWbckiYb["Yec# fb[j[ ceX_b_pWj_ed e\ j^[ ckiYb[ _i dej fei# i_Xb[" WdZ W i^ehj l[hj_YWb _dY_i_ed Wj j^[ fei# j[h_ehcWh]_d_id[Y[iiWho$>em[l[h"[nfeikh[ WdZceX_b_pWj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbckiYb[YWd X[ h[ijh_Yj[Z je j^[ d[Y[iiWho c_d_ckc je fh[l[djfeijef[hWj_l[fheXb[cim_j^cWij_YW# j_edWdZi[l[h[j[cfehWbWjhef^o<_]$)$&$(($
<_]$)$&$((
Ij[f+ J^[j[cfehWbckiYb[_ij^[dh[jhWYj[ZX_bWj[h# Wbboki_d]WmekdZh[jhWYjehWdZj^[igkWceki Xed[_i[nfei[Z$?diec[YWi[i"Wj_do]heel[ _i l_i_Xb[ X[jm[[d j^[ fhejkX[hWdY[i e\ j^[ c[Z_Wb WdZ _d\[h_eh j[cfehWb ]ohki$ J^[ YhW# d_ejeco _i ijWhj[Z m_j^ W Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dW# j_ed`kijWXel[j^[po]ecWj_Yf[Z_Yb[Wdj[h_eh je j^[ b[l[b e\ j^[ [nj[hdWb WkZ_jeho c[Wjki <_]$)$&$()$
<_]$)$&$()
Ij[f, 7\j[h c_d_cWb [dbWh][c[dj e\ j^[ ^eb[ m_j^ Ód[ fkdY^[i WdZ ceX_b_pWj_ed e\ j^[ ZkhW" W ijhW_]^j b_d[ _i iWm[Z m_j^ j^[ YhWd_ejec[ fWhWbb[b je j^[ po]ecWj_Y WhY^$ J^[h[W\j[h W Ç9Èi^Wf[Z"Ykhl[Zb_d[_iiWm[Z\hecj^[Xkhh ^eb[ je j^[ Wdj[h_eh XehZ[h e\ j^[ fh[l_ekibo cWZ[j[cfeheXWiWbb_d["Yh[Wj_d]WXed[ÔWf m_j^Wm_Zj^e\YW$'+Å(+ccWdZW^[_]^je\ YW$'+Å(&cc<_]$)$&$(*$
<_]$)$&$(*
'&-
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
<_]$)$&$(+
Ij[f- 7d eij[efbWij_Y YhWd_ejeco _i YWhh_[Z ekj _d WbbYWi[i$7d_cfehjWdjij[fe\j^[YhWd_ejeco" W\j[hh[celWbe\j^[Xed[ÔWf"_ij^[Zh_bb_d]e\ j^[_dd[h[Z][e\j^[j[cfeheXWiWbb_d[kdZ[h fhej[Yj_ede\j^[ZkhWm_j^W^_]^#if[[ZZh_bb$ >[cehh^W][i eYYkhh_d] Zkh_d] j^[ YhWd_ej# eco YWd X[ ij[cc[Z ki_d] X_febWh YeW]kbW# j_edWdZmWn<_]$)$&$(+$
<_]$)$&$(,
Ij[f. J^[ZkhWcWj[hi^ekbZX[ef[d[Z_dWi_cfb[ i[c_Y_hYkbWh mWo m_j^ _ji XWi[ jemWhZi j^[ j[cfehWbiakbbXWi[<_]$)$&$(,$
<_]$)$&$(-
Ij[f/ J^[\h[[ZkhWbÔWf_iÓn[ZkfmWhZim_j^jme ikjkh[i$Ej^[hZkhWb[b[lWj_edikjkh[iWh[dej d[Y[iiWho m_j^ j^_i b_c_j[Z YhWd_ejeco <_]$ )$&$(-$
'&.
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
*$?djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ij[f' B[\j i_Z[$ :_ii[Yj_ed ki_d] \h[i^ ^kcWd YWZWl[h1Whj[h_[iÓbb[Zm_j^Yebeh[ZbWj[niebk# j_ed$ 7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ ZkhW cWj[h" j^[ Óhij ij[fi^ekbZX[fhel_i_ede\9I<ZhW_dW][$J^[ j[cfehWb beX[ _i ][djbo h[jhWYj[Z WdZ j^[ WhWY^de_Zc[cXhWd[ie\j^[WcX_[djY_ij[hd Wh[ef[d[Z$M_j^efj_cWbfWj_[djfei_j_ed_d]" j^[Z[Yh[Wi_d]?9Fikffehjij^[]hWl_jo#h[bWj[Z i[b\#h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ j[cfehWb beX[$ ?d j^[ YWi[ e\ dWhhem l[djh_Yb[i WdZ ikXWhWY^de_Z ifWY[i" W bkcXWh ZhW_d YWd X[ _di[hj[Z fh[# ef[hWj_l[bo" Wle_Z_d] Yedjki_ed e\ j^[ j[cfe# hWb beX[ Zkh_d] Óhij ij[fi e\ j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[$ Dej[ j^[ j[djeh_Wb _dY_ikhW WdZ j[cfehWbbeX[$J^[WhWY^de_Z_ief[d[Zm_j^W c_YheZ_ii[Yjeh<_]$)$&$(.$
j[djeh_kc j[cfehWbbeX[
<_]$)$&$(.
Ij[f( 7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ ikXWhWY^de_Z ifWY[i WdZ WZZ_j_edWb h[celWb e\ 9I<" j^[ j[cfehWb beX[ _iik\ÓY_[djboh[jhWYj[Z\ehl_ikWb_pWj_ede\j^[ F97WdZ9D???$Dej[j^[h[bWj_edi^_fX[jm[[d j^[ Wdj[h_eh f[jheYb_de_Z b_]Wc[dj WdZ 9D ??? <_]$)$&$(/$
7FYB 9D??? F97
<_]$)$&$(/
Ij[f) J^[Wdj[h_ehf[jheYb_de_Zb_]Wc[dj_ih[jhWYj[Z m_j^ W c_YheZ_ii[Yjeh" [nfei_d] j^[ feij[h_eh f[jheYb_de_Zb_]Wc[djWdZj^[ikXWhWY^de_ZWb i[]c[dje\j^[9D???m^_Y^[dj[hij^[fedje# c[i[dY[f^WbikbYkiX[jm[[dj^[I97WdZF97$ J^[ ikf[h_eh Y[h[X[bbWh Whj[ho j^Wj Whei[ _d j^_iYWi[WiWZekXb[l[ii[bZ_iWff[WhiX[^_dZ j^[j[djeh_kc$Dej[j^[XWi_bWhj_fm_j^_dj^[ _dj[hf[ZkdYkbWhY_ij[hd<_]$)$&$)&$
7FYB FFYB 9D??? I97 87 F97
<_]$)$&$)&
'&/
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
Ij[f* J^[ 9D ??? _i ][djbo h[jhWYj[Z eXi[hl_d] j^[ Z_ijWb 87$ Dej[ j^[ F97$ J^[ I97 _i ^_ZZ[d X[^_dZj^[j[djeh_kc<_]$)$&$)'$ 7FYB 87 9D??? F97
<_]$)$&$)'
Ij[f+ ?dWdWdj[h_ehl_[m"j^[?97YWdX[WffheWY^[Z l_W j^[ ikXj[cfehWb hekj[$ J^[ ikfhWYb_de_Z i[]c[djX[]_dim^[h[j^[?97fWii[ij^hek]^ j^[ Z_ijWb ZkhWb h_d] e\ j^[ YWl[hdeki i_dki" c[Z_Wb \hec j^[ Wdj[h_eh f[jheYb_de_Z b_]W# c[dj$ Dej[ j^[ h[bWj_edi^_f X[jm[[d j^[ 9D???WdZ?97"l_ikWb_p[Zj^hek]^j^[ikXj[c# fehWbYhWd_ejeco$Dej[j^[79^7<_]$)$&$)($
7FYB 9D??? ?97 79^7
<_]$)$&$)(
Ij[f, ?dWdWdj[h_ehWif[YjW\j[h\khj^[hh[jhWYj_ede\ j^[j[cfehWbbeX["f[h\ehWjehie\j^[?97"79^7 WdZF9e7YWdX[i[[dikffbo_d] j^[Wdj[h_eh j^WbWckiWdZ^ofej^WbWcki$Dej[ j^[9D??? WdZefj_YjhWYj<_]$)$&$))$
9D??? 79^7 F9e7 ?97 efj_YjhWYj
<_]$)$&$))
''&
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
Ij[f- ?d W feij[h_eh Wif[Yj" j^[ jheY^b[Wh d[hl[ YWd X[i[[d$J^[Z[Ód_j_ede\_ji[djhofe_dj_dje j^[ j[djeh_Wb dejY^ Xo ifb_jj_d] e\ j^[ j[dje# h_kc_iWXiebkj[bo[ii[dj_Wb$7\j[hYWh[\kbZ_l_# i_ede\j^[j[djeh_kc"j^[bWj[hWbikh\WY[e\j^[ fedjec[i[dY[f^Wb`kdYj_edWdZj^[WcX_[dj i[]c[dje\j^[I97YWdX[eXi[l[Z$Dej[j^[ F97<_]$)$&$)*$
I97 9D?L F97
<_]$)$&$)*
Ij[f. J^[ j[djeh_kc Y[h[X[bb_ _i Z_l_Z[Z feij[h_eh \hec j^[ 9D ?L WdZ hW_i[Z je [nfei[ j^[ 9D L$ Dej[ j^[ WcX_[dj i[]c[dj e\ j^[ I97 Wj j^[ Wdj[hebWj[hWb cWh]_d e\ j^[ XhW_d ij[c hkdd_d]Wbed]j^[bWj[hWbikh\WY[e\j^[kff[h fedi$J^[YWkZWbjhkdae\j^[I97\ehciWbeef fhe`[Yj[Z jemWhZi j^[ heej [djho ped[ e\ j^[ 9DL<_]$)$&$)+$
9DL I97 fedi 9D?L
<_]$)$&$)+
Ij[f/ 7\j[h fWhj_Wb h[celWb e\ j^[ j[djeh_kc" j^[ h[jhei[bbWh Wh[W m_j^ ijhkYjkh[i e\ j^[ fh[# fedj_d[ WdZ _dj[hf[ZkdYkbWh Y_ij[hdi _i WffheWY^[Z$ Dej[ j^[ 87" I97" F97 WdZ j^[ 9D???<_]$)$&$),$
fhen_cWb87 9D?L I97 9D??? F97
<_]$)$&$),
'''
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
Ij[f'& <eYki_d]edj^[j[cfeheXWiWbiakbbXWi["j^[ ZkhWbYel[h_d]e\j^[f[jhekiWf[n_ih[cel[Z$ J^[9DL_i][djboceX_b_p[Zm_j^WXbkdjZ_i# i[Yjeh<_]$)$&$)-$
f[jhekiWf[n 9DL 87 fedi
<_]$)$&$)-
Ij[f'' J^[f[jhekiWf[n_ih[cel[Zm_j^WZ_WcedZ Zh_bbkdZ[h][djb[fhej[Yj_ede\j^[9DL$Dej[ j^[ jh_][c_dWb _cfh[ii_ed" W i^Wbbem Z[fh[i# i_ed ed j^[ Wdj[h_eh ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ f[jheki Wf[n<_]$)$&$).$
jh_][c_dWb _cfh[ii_ed 9DL
<_]$)$&$).
9DL? fhen_cWb87 fedi 9DL Z_ijWb87
<_]$)$&$)/
''(
Ij[f'( 7\j[hh[i[Yj_ede\j^[f[jhekiWf[n"j^[fh[fed# j_d[#h[jheYb_lWb h[]_ed WdZ j^[ feij[h_eh fWhj e\ j^[ 9I YWd X[ [nfei[Z$J^_i l_[m _dje j^[ Z[[f feij[h_eh YhWd_Wb \eiiW _i Z_l_Z[Z Xo j^[ 9DL_djejmecW`ehfWhji$J^[YhWd_Wbm_dZem e\\[hi \h[[ WYY[ii je j^[ Wdj[hebWj[hWb fedje# c[i[dY[f^Wb `kdYj_ed$ J^hek]^ j^[ YWkZWb m_dZem"j^[c_ZZb[Yb_lkiWdZj^[fh[fedj_d[ h[]_ed YWd X[ WffheWY^[Z$ Dej[ j^[ 87" 9D L WdZ jh_][c_dWb ]Wd]b_ed$J^[ 9DL? fWii[i X[bem j^[ 9D L hkdd_d] m_j^_d j^[ :eh[bbe YWdWb_djej^[feij[h_eh9I<_]$)$&$)/$
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
+$:khW"Xed[WdZmekdZYbeikh[ 7\j[h Yecfb[j_ed e\ j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[" j^[ _djhWZkhWb ifWY[_iÓbb[Zm_j^H_d][hiebkj_edWjXeZoj[cf[hWjkh[$J^[ZkhWb _dY_i_ed_iYbei[ZWikikWbm_j^mWj[hj_]^jhkdd_d]eh_dj[hhkfj[Z ikjkh[i$?\j[di_ed^WiZ[l[bef[Z_dj^[ZkhWbfbWd["_cfbWdjWj_ed e\ icWbb f_[Y[i e\ j[cfehWb ckiYb[ eh fbWij_Y cWj[h_Wb cWo X[ d[Y[iiWho$7fbWj[e\][b\eWc_ifbWY[Z[njhWZkhWbboWdZj^[Xed[ ÔWf_iÓn[Zm_j^Wj_jWd_kcfbWj[$7\j[hÓdWbl[h_ÓYWj_ede\^[ce# ijWi_i" j^[ ckiYkbWh WdZ ikXYkjWd[eki bWo[hi Wh[ Ybei[Z m_j^ _dj[hhkfj[Zikjkh[iWdZj^[ia_dm_j^_djhWYkjWd[ekiikjkh[i$J^[ b_c_j[Zia_d_dY_i_edWdZdedjhWkcWj_Yikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[Zedej h[gk_h[j^[ki[e\WikYj_edZhW_d$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i ?dYehh[Yjfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]e\ j^[fWj_[dj$ FbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]Wh[jWiaie\j^[ef[hWj_d]ikh][ed$ ?d`kho je j^[ ikf[hÓY_Wb j[cfehWb Whj[ho" Wkh_Ykbej[cfehWb eh \WY_Wbd[hl[Zkh_d]ia_d_dY_i_ed$ JhWkcWj_YZ_ii[Yj_edWdZh[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbckiYb[YWki# _d]feijef[hWj_l[fheXb[cim_j^cWij_YWj_edWdZbWj[hj[cfehWb Wjhef^o$ El[hbeea[Z" Xkj e\j[d kdWle_ZWXb[ _d`kho je j^[ ZkhW cWj[h Zkh_d]YhWd_ejeco$J^[[ii[dj_WbmWj[hj_]^jZkhWbYbeikh[YWdX[ WY^_[l[Zki_d]f_[Y[ie\j^[j[cfehWbckiYb[eh_cfbWdjWj_ede\ fbWij_YcWj[h_Wb$ :WcW][jej^[j[cfehWbbeX[Zk[jeifWjkbWfh[iikh[W\j[h_dWZ# [gkWj[h[celWbe\9I<$ ?d`kh_[ijedkc[hekid[hl[iWdZl[ii[bi_dj^[bWj[hWbikfhWi[bbWh Wh[WZkh_d]ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_edm_j^feijef[hWj_l[d[khebe]_YWb Z[j[h_ehWj_ed$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ZkhWbYbeikh[m_j^feijef[hWj_l[9I<b[Wa$?\cWije_Z Y[bbim[h[ef[d[ZZkh_d]YhWd_ejeco"dWieb_gkehh^[WYWdeYYkh$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ ^[ceijWi_i m_j^ feijef[hWj_l[ _djhWYhWd_Wb eh ie\j j_iik[^[cWjecW$ ?dYehh[Yjfei_j_ed_d]WdZÓnWj_ede\j^[Xed[ÔWf$
'')
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
J_fiWdZjh_Yai
<_]$)$&$*&
JWa[ j_c[ \eh fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d] WdZ Yehh[Yj fei_j_ed_d]$ If[Y_WbWjj[dj_edi^ekbZX[]_l[djej^[fbWd[e\j^[j[djeh_kc Z[cedijhWj[Z_dj^[fh[ef[hWj_l[_cW]_d]$ CWa[ W YWh[\kb WdWjec_YWb eh_[djWj_ed m_j^ Z[Ód_j_ed e\ j^[ eii[eki ijhkYjkh[i WdZ d[khelWiYkbWh ijhkYjkh[i" fbWY[c[dj e\ j^[YhWd_ejecoWdZia_d_dY_i_ed$ J^[j[cfehWb\WiY_Wi^ekbZX[Ykj_dWO#i^Wf[Z\Wi^_edm_j^j^[ XWiWbb[WÔ[jh[Ô[Yj[ZjemWhZj^[po]ecWj_YWhY^$J^[h[cW_d_d] jmeÔWfiWh[h[jhWYj[ZX_bWj[hWbbob[WZ_d]jeWZ[gkWj[[nfeikh[ e\j^[j[cfehWbXed[<_]$)$&$*&$ IjW][i e\ YhWd_ejeco <_]$ )$&$*'0 '$ Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_ed1 ($j[cfeheXWiWbYkjj_d]fWhWbb[bjej^[po]ecWj_YWhY^1)$iWm_d] _dWi[c_bkdWhYkhl[Z\Wi^_ed\hecj^[Xkhh^eb[jej^[Wdj[h_eh [Z][e\j^[j[cfeheXWiWbYhWd_ejecob_d[$ :h_bb_d] e\ j^[ _dd[h [Z][ e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco W\j[h h[celWb e\ j^[ Xed[ ÔWf _i _cfehjWdj je [Wi[ _djhWZkhWb l_ikWb_pWj_ed WdZ cWd_fkbWj_ed<_]$)$&$*($
<_]$)$&$*'
<_]$)$&$*(
<_]$)$&$*)
J^[ZkhW_ief[d[Z_dWi_cfb[Ç9Èi^Wf[Z"i[c_bkdWh\Wi^_edWdZ h[jhWYj[Z jemWhZi j^[ po]ecWj_Y WhY^ m_j^ jme ikjkh[i$ Ej^[h ZkhWb[b[lWj_edikjkh[iWh[dejh[gk_h[Z<_]$)$&$*)$ 7Z[gkWj[fei_j_ed_d]e\j^[fWj_[dj"[Whboh[celWbe\9I<\hecj^[ WcX_[djY_ij[hdehfkdYjkh[e\j^[bWj[hWbl[djh_Yb[Wh[h[gk_h[Z je Wle_Z j[cfeheXWiWb Yedjki_ed$ 7bj[hdWj_l[bo" W bkcXWh ZhW_d YWdX[fbWY[Zfh[ef[hWj_l[bo$ 7\j[h Ód_i^_d] j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[" j^[ ZkhWb ef[d_d] i^ekbZX[Ybei[Zm_j^mWj[hj_]^jikjkh[i$?\ j[di_ed^WiZ[l[b# ef[Z_dj^[j[cfehWbZkhW"WicWbbf_[Y[e\ckiYb[YWdX[i[md _djej^[ZkhWbYbeikh[$?dej^[h_dijWdY[i"fbWij_YcWj[h_WbcWoX[ ki[Z<_]$)$&$**$
''*
<_]$)$&$**
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^
<_]$)$&$*+
?\ f[d[jhWj_ed e\ j^[ cWije_Z Y[bbi YekbZ dej X[ Wle_Z[Z" c[# j_Ykbeki Ybeikh[ _i d[Y[iiWho$ 8ed[ mWn eh W ÔWf e\ j^[ j[c# fehWbckiYb[YWdX[ki[Z\ehj^_ifkhfei[<_]$)$&$*+$ <_n_d]j^[Xed[ÔWf"j^[Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_edi^ekbZX[Ybei[Z m_j^Wj_jWd_kcfbWj[<_]$)$&$*,$
<_]$)$&$*,
J^[ia_d_dY_i_edi^ekbZX[Ybei[Zm_j^_djhW#ehjhWdiYkjWd[eki hkdd_d]ikjkh[i$ 8[YWki[e\j^[b_c_j[Zia_d_dY_i_edWdZdedjhWkcWj_YZ_ii[Yj_ed WikYj_edZhW_d_idejd[Y[iiWho$
''+
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
)$' Feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed e\j^[ikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejeco 7
J^[ WZlWdjW][ e\ j^[ feij[h_eh YhWd_ejeco fbWY[c[dj _i j^[ i_]# d_ÓYWdjboh[ZkY[Zh[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[YecfWh[Zjej^[ Wdj[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb WffheWY^$ 7i fh[l_ekibo Z[ih_X[Z" j^[ Wdj[# h_ehikXj[cfehWbikh]_YWbWYY[iih[gk_h[icW`ehh[jhWYj_ede\ j^[ j[cfehWbbeX[X[YWki[j^[XWi[e\j^[Wdj[h_ehfWhje\j^[c_ZZb[ YhWd_Wb\eiiW_iceh[Z[[fboi_jkWj[Z j^Wd j^[b[l[be\ j^[ikfhW# i[bbWh Wh[W$ Ki_d] j^[ feij[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb WffheWY^ Wbed] j^[ ikf[h_ehXehZ[he\j^[f[jhekiXed[WdZj^[j[djeh_kc"j^[l_[m e\j^[ijhkYjkh[iWhekdZj^[j[djeh_Wb_dY_ikhW_ib[iieXiYkh[ZXo j^[j[cfehWbbeX[<_]$)$'$'$
8
7Y^Wbb[d]_d]fheXb[cki_d]feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^[i_i jeZ[Wbm_j^j^[_d\[h_ehWdWijecej_Yl[_de\BWXX$?dceijYWi[i" j[cfehWbXh_Z]_d]l[_diYWdX[YWh[\kbboZ_ii[Yj[ZWmWo\hecj^[ Yehj_YWbikh\WY[WdZ\hecj^[ZkhWb[djhWdY["Y_hYkcl[dj_d]eYYbk# i_ed$>em[l[h"_\iYWh_ÓYWj_edYWddejX[Wle_Z[Z"h[jhWYj_ede\j^[ j[cfehWbbeX[ckijX[cWn_cWbboh[ZkY[ZWbbem_d]ef[dÔem_d j^[WdWijecej_Yl[_die\j^[j[cfehWbikh\WY[$J^ki"fei_j_edWdZ fh[iikh[e\j^[XhW_difWjkbWfbWoWY[djhWbheb[$
<_]$)$'$' IY^[cWj_Yf_Yjkh[_bbkijhWj_d] j^[WZlWdjW][e\ W feij[h_ehbo fbWY[Z ikXj[cfehWb YhWd_ejeco$ 9ecfWh[Z m_j^ j^[ Wdj[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb hekj[ 7" j^[ feij[h_eh ceZ_ÓYWj_ed h[gk_h[i i_]d_ÓYWdjbo b[ii h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ j[cfehWbbeX["Wbbem_d]Wb[iijhWkcWj_Y[nfeikh[e\j^[ feij[h_ehikfhWi[bbWhWh[WWdZj[djeh_Wb^_Wjki8$
M_j^j^[feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejeco"j^[h[]_ede\j^[j[dje# h_Wb_dY_ikhWYWdX[m[bbWffheWY^[ZWbbem_d]iW\[Z_ii[Yj_edm_j^_d j^[feij[hebWj[hWbfh[fedj_d["WcX_[dj"WdZgkWZh_][c_dWbY_ij[hdi$ J^[ [bWij_Y_jo e\ j^[ j[djeh_kc e\\[hi m_Z[ _djhWYhWd_Wb [nfeikh[$ 7dWZZ_j_edWbifb_jj_d]e\j^[j[djeh_kcfhel_Z[iWYY[iijej^[fei# j[h_ehYhWd_Wb\eiiWWdZl_ikWb_pWj_ede\j^[j[djeh_Wbikh\WY[e\j^[ Y[h[X[bbkcWdZijhkYjkh[ie\j^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[$ 7YYehZ_d] je j^[ jWh][j ijhkYjkh[i WdZ j^[ fbWdd[Z ikh]_YWb Yeh# h_Zeh"j^[[nWYjfbWY[c[djWdZ[nj[di_ede\j^[YhWd_ejecoYWdX[ lWh_[Z$J^[Y[dj[he\j^[i[lWh_Wj_edie\j^[feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWb YhWd_ejeco Yehh[ifedZi Wffhen_cWj[bo je j^[ `kdYj_ed X[jm[[d j^[jhWdil[hiWbWdZi_]ce_Zi_dki[i<_]$)$'$($J^[Wdj[h_eh[nj[d# i_ed e\ j^[ feij[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb YhWd_ejeco ef[di W ikh]_YWb Yehh_ZehWbed]j^[kff[hh_ce\j^[f[jhekiXed[<_]$)$'$(7$J^[ feij[h_eh[nj[di_edfhel_Z[ij^[effehjkd_jojeWffheWY^j^[fei# j[h_eh fWhj e\ j^[ j[djeh_Wb ^_Wjki <_]$)$'$(8$J^[ feij[he_d\[h_eh [nj[di_ede\j^[feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejeco_iWYecX_dW#
''-
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
7
8
9
:
<_]$ )$'$( IY^[cWj_Y _bbkijhWj_ed Z[cedijhWj_d] j^[ lWh_# Wdjie\j^[feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejeco$J^[Wdj[h_eh lWh_Wdj7ef[diWikh]_YWbYehh_ZehWbed]j^[kff[hh_ce\ j^[ f[jheki Xed[$ 7\j[h j[djeh_Wb ifb_jj_d]" j^[ ijhkYjkh[i e\j^[feij[hebWj[hWbfh[fedj_d["bWj[hWbfh[c[i[dY[f^Wb_Y" WcX_[dj" kff[h Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[ WdZ gkWZh_][c_dWb Y_ij[hdi YWd X[ m[bb [nfei[Z$J^[ feij[h_eh [nj[di_ed 8 e\\[hi[nfeikh[e\j^[feij[h_ehj[djeh_Wb^_Wjkim_j^j^[ WcX_[djWdZgkWZh_][c_dWbY_ij[hdi$7\j[hifb_jj_d]e\j^[ j[djeh_kc"j^[j[djeh_Wbikh\WY[e\j^[Y[h[X[bbkcYWdX[ [nfei[Z$J^[Ykbc[dWdZgkWZhWd]kbWhbeXkb[Yehh[ifedZ je j^[Wdj[h_ehfWhjWdZ j^[Z[Yb_l["i_cfb[beXkb[WdZW fWhj e\ j^[ ikf[h_eh i[c_bkdWh beXkb[ Yehh[ifedZ je j^[ feij[h_ehfWhje\j^_ij[djeh_Wbikh\WY[$J^[feij[he_d\[h_eh [nj[di_ed 9 h[fh[i[dji W YecX_dWj_ed e\ j^[ feij[h_eh ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^m_j^ j^[h[jhei_]ce_ZWb[nfeikh[$ J^[Wdj[he_d\[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed:_iWfh[i_]ce_ZWb[nj[di_ed j^hek]^j^[JhWkjcWddjh_Wd]b[Wbbem_d]m_Z[[nfeikh[ e\ j^[ feij[h_eh \eiiW$ E\ Yekhi[" j^[i[ \ekh lWh_Wdji YWd WbieX[YecX_d[Zm_j^[WY^ej^[hWdZi^ekbZX[jW_beh[Z WYYehZ_d]jej^[_dZ_l_ZkWbfWj^eWdWjec_YWbi_jkWj_ed$
j_ede\j^[ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^m_j^Wh[jhei_]ce_ZWb[nfeikh[ e\j^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[<_]$)$'$(9$J^[Wdj[he_d\[h_ehlWh_W# j_ede\j^[feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejecoh[fh[i[djiWfh[i_]# ce_ZWb[nj[di_ede\j^[WffheWY^<_]$)$'$(:$ ?dj^[\ebbem_d]"Z[jW_bie\j^[XWi_Yikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[e\j^[Wdj[# h_ehceZ_ÓYWj_ede\j^[feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^Wh[]_l[d$
IkfhWj[djeh_Wb
?d\hWj[djeh_Wb
Feij[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii 7dj[h_ehWdZfeij[h_ehf[jheYb_de_Zb_]Wc[dji J[djeh_Wb_dY_ikhW"ikf[h_ehf[jheiWbi_dki BWj[hWbWif[Yje\j^[fedjec[i[dY[f^Wb`kdYj_ed BWj[hWbf_d[Wbh[]_ed Efj_YjhWYj"9D???"9D?L ?97"F9e7"79^7"F97"I97"_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi 8WiWbl[_de\Hei[dj^Wb"l[_de\BWXX
J[djeh_Wb_dY_ikhW Ikf[h_ehf[jheiWbi_dki Kff[hfWhje\j^[Yb_lki 9[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[ 7dj[hebWj[hWbWif[Yje\j^[c[i[dY[f^WbedWdZfedi J[djeh_Wbikh\WY[e\j^[Y[h[X[bbkc 9D?L"9DL"9DL?"9DL??"9DL??? Kff[h87"I97"7?97"_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi 8WiWbl[_de\Hei[dj^Wb"l[_de\=Wb[d
JWXb[)$'$' 7dWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[iWffheWY^[Zj^hek]^j^[feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejeco$
''.
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[
<_]$)$'$)
'$FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] M_j^ j^[ fWj_[dj _d j^[ ikf_d[ fei_j_ed" j^[ ^[WZ _i Ón[Z _d W CWoÓ[bZ ^ebZ[h m_j^ j^[ i_d]b[ f_d fbWY[Z _d j^[ \hedjWb h[]_ed Wbbem_d] \h[[ Z_ii[Yj_ed Zkh_d] ikh][ho$ J^[ ^[WZ e\ j^[ ef[hWj# _d]jWXb[_i[b[lWj[ZWXel[j^[j^ehWn"\WY_b_jWj_d]YhWd_Wbl[deki ZhW_dW]["WdZj_bj[Zjej^[effei_j[i_Z[ikffehj_d]j^[i_]d_ÓYWdj ^[WZhejWj_ed$?dWZZ_j_ed"j^[_fi_bWj[hWbi^ekbZ[h_ihW_i[Zm_j^W Yki^_edWle_Z_d]Yecfh[ii_ede\j^[cW_dY[hl_YWbl[ii[biWdZj^[ bWhodn$ Ij[f' J^[^[WZ_i[b[lWj[ZWXel[j^[b[l[be\j^[j^ehWn$J^_icWd[klh[ \WY_b_jWj[i WZZ_j_edWbbo j^[ YhWd_Wb l[deki ZhW_dW][ WdZ Z[Yec# fh[ii[ij^[bWhodn"j^[l[dj_bWj_edjkX[WdZj^[cW_dY[hl_YWb l[i# i[bi<_]$)$'$)$
<_]$)$'$*
<_]$)$'$+
Ij[f( J^[h[W\j[h" j^[ ^[WZ _i hejWj[Z YW$ .& je '&& je j^[ i_Z[ effe# i_j[ je j^[ fbWdd[Z YhWd_ejeco$J^[ [nWYj Z[]h[[ e\ hejWj_ed Yeh# h[ifedZijej^[jWh][jh[]_edWdZjej^[Z_h[Yj_ede\j^[ikh]_YWb Yehh_Zeh$7ffheWY^_d]j^[j[djeh_Wb_dY_ikhWWdZj^[gkWZh_][c_dWb Y_ij[hd"WhejWj_ede\YW$.&_ih[gk_h[Z1[nfei_d]j^[Wdj[hebWj[hWb fedjec[i[dY[f^Wb`kdYj_ed"j^[^[WZi^ekbZX[jkhd[ZYW$/&je j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWb i_Z[1 WffheWY^_d] j^[ Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[ Wd]b[ j^hek]^jhWdij[djeh_WbfWj^"WhejWj_ede\YW$'&&_id[Y[iiWho$7i c[dj_ed[ZWXel["j^_ii_]d_ÓYWdjhejWj_edi^ekbZX[Zed[m_j^W i_Z[mWoij_bj_d]e\j^[ef[hWj_d]jWXb[WdZm_j^WYki^_edfbWY[Z X[d[Wj^j^[_fi_bWj[hWbi^ekbZ[h<_]$)$'$*$ Ij[f) ?dj^[d[njij[f"j^[^[WZ_ibWj[heÔ[Yj[ZYW$'+je(&ZemdmWhZi" ikffehj_d]j^[]hWl_jo#h[bWj[Zi[b\#h[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[$ ?dj^_imWo"W\ehY[Zh[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[YWdX[ikYY[ii# \kbboWle_Z[Z<_]$)$'$+$
<_]$)$'$,
Ij[f* <_dWbbo"j^[^[WZi^ekbZX[h[jheÔ[Yj[Z$J^_iib_]^jh[jheÔ[Yj_ede\ YW$'&cWoe\\[hWdWZZ_j_edWbZ[Yecfh[ii_ede\j^[Y[hl_YWbijhkY# jkh[i<_]$)$'$,$
''/
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
($7dWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZeh_[djWj_ed <ehfh[ef[hWj_l[eh_[djWj_ed"j^[_cfehjWdjWdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhai e\ j^[ j[cfehefWh_[jWb h[]_ed" [$]$" j^[ po]ecWj_Y WhY^" Whj_YkbWh jkX[hYkb[" [nj[hdWb WkZ_jeho YWdWb" ikfhWcWije_Z Yh[ij" cWije_Z fheY[ii"cWije_Z_dY_ikhW"eYY_f_jecWije_ZWdZbWcXZe_Zikjkh[i" Wij[h_ed"fWh_[jecWije_Zikjkh["WdZj^[igkWcekiikjkh[i^ekbZ X[fh[Y_i[boZ[Ód[Z$If[Y_WbYWh[i^ekbZX[jWa[djeZ[Ód[j^[b[l[b e\j^[j[cfehWbXWi[WYYehZ_d]jej^[ikfhWcWije_ZYh[ijWdZje j^[Yekhi[e\j^[jhWdil[hiWbWdZi_]ce_Zi_dki[i<_]$)$'$-W$ 7\j[hWdWjec_YWbeh_[djWj_ed"j^[XehZ[hie\j^[YhWd_ejecoWdZj^[ efj_ckcb_d[e\j^[ia_d_dY_i_edi^ekbZX[Z[Ód[Z$J^[XWiWbb_d[ e\j^[YhWd_ejecoYehh[ifedZijej^[j[cfehWbiakbbXWi["cWha[Z Xoj^[ikfhWcWije_ZYh[ij$J^[feij[h_ehXehZ[he\j^[YhWd_ejeco Yehh[ifedZijej^[`kdYj_edX[jm[[dj^[jhWdil[hiWbWdZi_]ce_Z i_dki[i$J^[Y[dj[he\j^[YhWd_ejeco_iWffhen_cWj[boWjj^[b[l[b e\j^[cWije_ZfheY[ii$J^[ijhW_]^jehib_]^jboYkhl[Zia_d_dY_i_ed i^ekbZ X[ cWZ[ W\j[h c_d_cWb i^Wl_d] WdZ YWh[\kb Z_i_d\[Yj_ed `kij X[^_dZ j^[ [Wh" Wbbem_d] [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ j[cfehecWije_ZWb Xedoikh\WY[<_]$)$'$-X$
:
9
8
7
<_]$)$'$-W :[Ód_j_ede\j^[jhWdil[hiWbWdZi_]ce_Zi_dki" WYYehZ_d]jej^[WdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaie\j^[h[jheWkh_Y# kbWh#h[jhecWije_ZWb h[]_ed$ Dej[ j^[ ikfhWcWije_Z Yh[ij 7" Wij[h_ed 8" [nj[hdWb eYY_f_jWb fhejkX[hWdY[ 9 WdZ j^[cWije_ZfheY[ii:$
<_]$)$'$-X :[Ód_j_ede\j^[YhWd_ejeco"WYYehZ_d]jej^[ WdWjec_YWb bWdZcWhai e\ j^[ feij[h_eh j[cfehWb h[]_ed$ If[Y_WbWjj[dj_edckijX[]_l[djej^[Yekhi[e\j^[jhWdi# l[hiWbWdZi_]ce_Zi_dki[iWdZjej^[b[l[be\j^[j[cfehWb iakbbXWi[$Dej[j^[eYY_f_jecWije_ZWb"bWcXZe_Z"fWh_[je# cWije_ZWbWdZigkWceiWbikjkh[iWbbem_d][nWYjZ[j[hc_# dWj_ede\j^[jh[f^_dWj_ed$
'(&
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
)$9hWd_ejeco Ij[f' B[\ji_Z[$7\j[hfWj_[djfei_j_ed_d]"WdWjec_YWb eh_[djWj_ed"WdZc_d_cWb^W_hi^Wl_d]"j^[ia_d _ifh[fWh[Zm_j^WdWbYe^ebiebkj_ed$7ijhW_]^j eh ib_]^jbo Ykhl[Z [f_\WiY_Wb ia_d _dY_i_ed e\ Wffhen_cWj[bo+&cc_ij^[dcWZ[`kijX[^_dZ j^[ [Wh Wj j^[ b[l[b e\ j^[ cWije_Z fheY[ii <_]$)$'$.$
<_]$)$'$.
Ij[f( 7\j[h X_bWj[hWb h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ ia_d" j^[ j[c# fehWbckiYb[_icel[Z\hecj^[ikfhWcWije_Z Yh[ij ki_d] W Xbkdj Z_ii[Yjeh1 j^[ ikX]Wb[Wb \WiY_WWdZf[h_eij[kc_i_dY_i[Z_dj^[Z_h[Yj_ed e\j^[cWije_ZfheY[ii<_]$)$'$/$
<_]$)$'$/
Ij[f) J^[XWiWbb[WÔ[je\j^[\WiY_W_i^[bZkfmWhZi m_j^ W ijhed] ^ebZ_d] ikjkh[$ Ki_d] W mekdZ h[jhWYjeh" j^[ feij[h_eh ÔWf e\ j^[ \WiY_W _i h[jhWYj[Z_dWfeij[h_ehZ_h[Yj_edWdZj^[j[c# fehWb ckiYb[ _d Wd Wdj[h_eh Z_h[Yj_ed" ]W_d_d] [nfeikh[jej^[`kdYj_edX[jm[[dj^[cWije_Z fheY[ii" j[cfehWb WdZ fWh_[jWb Xed[i$ EXi[hl# _d] j^[ Xedo ikh\WY[" jme WdWjec_YWb ijhkY# jkh[i"j^[ikfhWcWije_ZYh[ijWdZj^[`kdYj_ed X[jm[[dj^[fWh_[jecWije_ZWbWdZigkWceiWb ikjkh[i" i^ekbZ X[ beYWj[Z fh[Y_i[bo je Wle_Z _d`khojej^[i_]ce_Zi_dkiWdZje[dj[h[nWYjbo j^[ c_ZZb[ YhWd_Wb \eiiW$ J^[ [Wi_bo fWbfWXb[ ikfhWcWije_ZYh[ijcWhaij^[b[l[be\j^[j[c# fehWbiakbbXWi[$J^[/&`kdYj_edX[jm[[dj^[ fWh_[jecWije_ZWb WdZ igkWceiWb ikjkh[i Yeh# h[ifedZijej^[efj_cWbfbWY[c[dje\j^[Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_ed `kij _d \hedj e\ j^[ `kdYj_ed X[jm[[d j^[ jhWdil[hiWb WdZ i_]ce_Z i_dki[i <_]$)$'$'&$
<_]$)$'$'&
'('
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f* 7\j[h c_d_cWb [dbWh][c[dj e\ j^[ ^eb[ m_j^ Ód[fkdY^[iWdZceX_b_pWj_ede\j^[ZkhW"j^[ Wdj[h_eh XehZ[h e\ j^[ i_]ce_Z i_dki WdZ j^[ b[l[be\j^[j[cfehWbiakbbXWi[Wh[i[[d$J^[h[# W\j[h" W ijhW_]^j b_d[ _i iWm[Z m_j^ j^[ YhWd_e# jec[_dWdWdj[h_ehZ_h[Yj_edWYYehZ_d]jej^[ b[l[b e\ j^[ j[cfehWb iakbb XWi[$ D[nj" W Ç9È i^Wf[Z"Ykhl[Zb_d[_iiWm[Z\hecj^[Xkhh^eb[ jej^[Wdj[h_ehXehZ[he\j^[fh[l_ekibo\ehc[Z j[cfeheXWiWb b_d[" j^ki Yh[Wj_d] W Xed[ ÔWf m_j^Wm_Zj^e\YW$'+je(+ccWdZW^[_]^je\ YW$(&cc<_]$)$'$''$
<_]$)$'$''
<_]$)$'$'(
Ij[f+ 7\j[hh[celWbe\j^[Xed[ÔWf"j^[_dd[h[Z][e\ j^[ j[cfeheXWiWb YhWd_ejeco b_d[ _i h[cel[Z ki_d]W^_]^#if[[ZZh_bbfhel_Z_d]Wi_]d_ÓYWdjbo _dYh[Wi[Z _djhWYhWd_Wb l_[m$ ?d j^[ feij[h_eh fWhj e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco" _d`kho je j^[ jhWdil[h# iWbWdZi_]ce_Zi_dki[ii^ekbZX[c[j_Ykbekibo Wle_Z[Z<_]$)$'$'($
<_]$)$'$')
Ij[f, J^[ZkhWi^ekbZX[ef[d[Z_dWYkhl[Z\Wi^_ed m_j^_jiXWi[jemWhZij^[j[cfehWbiakbbXWi[$ J^[ \h[[ ZkhWb ÔWf _i Ón[Z ZemdmWhZi m_j^ jme ikjkh[i$ M_j^ j^_i b_c_j[Z ZkhWb ef[d_d]" ej^[h[b[lWj_edikjkh[iWh[dejh[Yecc[dZ[Z <_]$)$'$')$
'((
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
*$?djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ij[f' B[\j i_Z[$ :_ii[Yj_ed ki_d] W \h[i^ ^kcWd YWZWl[h1Whj[h_Wbl[ii[biWh[fh[fWh[Zm_j^h[Z" l[_difWhj_Wbbom_j^Xbk[Yebeh[ZbWj[niebkj_ed$ 7\j[hef[d_d]j^[ZkhWcWj[h"j^[ikh\WY[e\j^[ feij[h_ehj[cfehWbbeX[m_j^j^[_d\[h_ehWdWi# jecej_Yl[_de\BWXXWh[eXi[hl[Z$?\eYYbki_ed e\j^[Xh_Z]_d]l[_dYWddejX[Wle_Z[Z"h[jhWY# j_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[ckijX[Wic_d_cWb Wi feii_Xb[ Wbbem_d] ef[d Ôem m_j^_d j^[ WdWijecej_Y l[ii[bi e\ j^[ j[cfehWb ikh\WY[ <_]$)$'$'*$
l[_de\BWXX j[cfehWbbeX[
<_]$)$'$'*
Ij[f( J^[ j[cfehWb beX[ _i YWh[\kbbo hW_i[Z$ J^[ Óhij ij[f e\ j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb Z_ii[Yj_ed i^ekbZ X[ j^[ ef[d_d] e\ j^[ ikXWhWY^de_Z ifWY[i m_j^ ik\ÓY_[dj9I<ZhW_dW][$J^_iikffehjij^[]hWl# _jo#h[bWj[Zi[b\#h[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[ Wle_Z_d] Yedjki_ed e\ j^[ j[cfeheXWiWb Yehj_# YWb ikh\WY[$ 7\j[h ][djb[ h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ j[d# jeh_kc m_j^ W c_YheikYa[h" j^[ ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbkc WdZ j^[ feij[hebWj[hWb XhW_d ij[c Wh[[nfei[Z$J^[9D?LWff[Whim_j^_dj^[fei# j[h_ehfWhje\j^[WcX_[djY_ij[hd<_]$)$'$'+$
j[djeh_kc Y[h[X[bbkc XhW_dij[c 9D?L j[cfehWbbeX[
<_]$)$'$'+
Ij[f) Beea_d] _d j^[ Wdj[h_eh Z_h[Yj_ed" j^[ 9D ??? YWdX[i[[dZ_iWff[Wh_d]_djej^[hee\e\j^[ YWl[hdeki i_dki$ Dej[ j^[ I97" F97 WdZ j^[ Wdj[hebWj[hWb ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ fedjec[i[dY[# f^Wb_Y `kdYj_ed$ ?d j^[ feij[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb l_[m"j^[XWi_bWhj_f_i^_ZZ[dX[^_dZj^[XhW_d ij[c WdZ YWddej X[ [nfei[Z m_j^ekj h[jhWY# j_ed e\ i[di_j_l[ ijhkYjkh[i$ Dej[ j^[ Wdj[h_eh f[jheYb_de_Z\ebZWdZX[^_dZj^[9D???j^[fei# j[h_eh Yb_de_Z fheY[ii$ Dej[ j^[ F9e7 Yedd[Yj# _d]j^[?97WdZF97<_]$)$'$',$
7FYB I97"9D?L 9D??? F9F F9e7 F97
<_]$)$'$',
'()
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f* 9edj_dk_d]j^[Wdj[h_eheXi[hlWj_ed"j^[ikfhW# i[bbWhh[]_edYWdX[WffheWY^[Z\hecj^[fei# j[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb ikh]_YWb Yehh_Zeh$ Dej[ j^[ XhWdY^[ie\j^[?97"[$]$"j^[feij[h_ehYecck# d_YWj_d]WdZj^[Wdj[h_ehY^ehe_ZWbWhj[h_[i$J^[ efj_Yd[hl[YWdWbieX[m[bbi[[d<_]$)$'$'-$
9D??? F9e7 9D?? ?97 79^7
<_]$)$'$'-
Ij[f+ EXi[hl_d]W]W_dj^[j[djeh_WbdejY^"j^[feij[# h_ehfWhje\j^[WcX_[djY_ij[hd_iWffheWY^[Z$ 7\j[h ][djb[ h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ j[cfehWb beX[" j^[c_YheiYef_Yl_[m_i\eYki[Zedj^[j[cfe# hWbikh\WY[e\j^[j[djeh_kc$?dj^[XWYa]hekdZ" Yekdjb[ii XhWdY^[i e\ j^[ ikf[h_eh Y[h[X[bbWh WdZfeij[h_ehY[h[XhWbWhj[h_[iYWdX[eXi[hl[Z$ Dej[j^[9D?LZ_iWff[Wh_d]X[^_dZj^[j[dje# h_WbdejY^<_]$)$'$'.$
j[djeh_kc 9D?L
<_]$)$'$'.
Ij[f, ;nfeikh[ e\ j^[ j[djeh_Wb ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ Y[h# [X[bbkc W\j[h ifb_jj_d] j^[ j[djeh_kc$ ?d j^[ XWYa]hekdZ" m[ YWd i[[ j^[ ijhkYjkh[i e\ j^[ WcX_[dj WdZ gkWZh_][c_dWb Y_ij[hdi1 dej[ j^[ _djhWY_ij[hdWbYekhi[e\j^[9D?LYbei[jej^[ I97<_]$)$'$'/$
Y[h[X[bbkc I97 9D?L
<_]$)$'$'/
'(*
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f- 7\j[h h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ Z_l_Z[Z j[djeh_kc" j^[ Z_ii[Yj_ed _i eh_[djWj[Z _d W ceh[ feij[h_eh Z_h[Yj_ed WffheWY^_d] j^[ gkWZh_][c_dWb Y_i# j[hd$Dej[j^[XWiWbl[_de\Hei[dj^WbWdZj^[ f_d[Wb]bWdZ<_]$)$'$(&$
XhW_dij[c f_d[Wb]bWdZ XWiWbl[_d l[_de\=Wb[d
<_]$)$'$(&
Ij[f/ J^[feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ede\j^[ikXj[cfehWbYhW# d_ejecofhel_Z[ij^[effehjkd_jojeWffheWY^ j^[kff[hY[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[WdZj^[h[jhe# Yb_lWbfWhje\j^[feij[h_eh\eiiW$7\j[hh[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ j[djeh_kc m_j^ ijhed] ^ebZ_d] ikjkh[i" j^[ikh]_YWbYehh_ZehWbed]j^[kff[hh_ce\j^[ f[jhekiXed[_ief[d[Z$Dej[j^[9D???"9D?L" WdZ j^[ 9DL$ 7YYehZ_d] je j^[ feij[h_ehbo fbWY[ZYhWd_ejeco"j^[87_i^_ZZ[dX[^_dZj^[ XhW_dij[c<_]$)($'$('$
9DL 9D?L F97 9D???
<_]$)$'$('
Ij[f'& J^[ Wdj[h_eh Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[ WdZ fh[fedj_d[ Y_ij[hdi Wh[ WffheWY^[Z l_W j^[ ikXj[cfehWb jhWdij[djeh_Wb fWj^mWo eXi[hl_d] j^[ \WY_Wb WdZ l[ij_XkbeYeY^b[Wh d[hl[i$ Dej[ j^[ feij[# h_ehZkhWbikh\WY[e\j^[f[jhekiXed[WdZj^[ Yb_lki$7beefe\j^[7?97Wff[WhiYbei[jej^[ 9DL??WdZ9DL???<_]$)$'$(($
7?97 9DL??"9DL???
<_]$)$'$((
'(+
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f'' 7\j[h \khj^[h ceX_b_pWj_ed e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbkc" j^[9DL?_iWffheWY^[ZX[jm[[dj^[jh_][c_# dWbWdZl[ij_XkbeYeY^b[Whd[hl[i$Dej[j^Wjj^[ 9DL?[dj[hij^[ZkhWe\j^[Yb_lki"hkdd_d]_dje j^[:eh[bbeYWdWb<_]$)$'$()$
9DL??"9DL??? 9DL? 9DL
<_]$)$'$()
Ij[f'( El[hl_[m e\ j^[ c_ZZb[ WdZ feij[h_eh \eiiW j^hek]^j^[feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbjhWdij[dje# h_WbWffheWY^$Dej[j^[9D???"9D?L"9DL"9DL?" 9DL??WdZj^[9DL???<_]$)$'$(*$
9DL??"9DL??? 9DL? 9DL 9D?L 9D???
<_]$)$'$(*
'(,
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
+$:khW"Xed[WdZmekdZYbeikh[ 7\j[h Yecfb[j_ed e\ j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[" j^[ _djhWZkhWb ifWY[_iÓbb[Zm_j^H_d][hiebkj_edWdZj^[ZkhWb_dY_i_ed_iYbei[Z WikikWbm_j^hkdd_d]eh_dj[hhkfj[Zikjkh[i$?\d[Y[iiWho"f_[Y[ie\ j^[j[cfehWbckiYb[ehfbWij_YcWj[h_WbYWdX[ki[Z\ehmWj[hj_]^j Ybeikh[$7fbWj[e\][b\eWc_ifbWY[Z[njhWZkhWbboWdZj^[Xed[ÔWf _iÓn[Zm_j^Wj_jWd_kcfbWj[$?\feii_Xb["j^_ifbWj[i^ekbZYbei[j^[ Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_ed$ 7\j[h ÓdWb l[h_ÓYWj_ed e\ ^[ceijWi_i" j^[ ikX]Wb[WbWdZckiYkbWhbWo[hiWh[Ybei[Zm_j^_dj[hhkfj[Zikjkh[i WdZj^[ia_dm_j^_djhWYkjWd[ekiikjkh[i$:k[jej^[icWbbYkjW# d[eki_dY_i_edWdZdedjhWkcWj_Yikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_ed"j^[ki[e\W ikYj_edZhW_d_ikdd[Y[iiWho$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i ?dWZ[gkWj[fh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]e\j^[fWj_[dj m_j^ikXi[gk[djZ[j[h_ehWj_ed_dikh]_YWbWYY[ii$ E\j[d kdWle_ZWXb[ ef[d_d] e\ j^[ cWije_Z Y[bbi Zkh_d] YhWd_e# jeco$J^[ef[d_d]i^ekbZX[Ybei[Zc[j_YkbekibojeWle_ZWfeij# ef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW$ ?d`khojej^[jhWdil[hiWbehi_]ce_Zi_dkiZkh_d]Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_# dWj_ed$M_j^fh[Y_i[WdWjec_YWbeh_[djWj_ed"j^_ii[l[h[Yecfb_# YWj_edYWdX[ikYY[ii\kbboWle_Z[Z$ ?d`kho je j^[ ZkhW cWj[h Zkh_d] YhWd_ejeco$ ?d ceij YWi[i" j^[ ZkhWbZ[^_iY[dY[YWdX[Ybei[Zm_j^W]Wb[WbÔWfehicWbbf_[Y[i e\j^[j[cfehWb_ickiYb[$?dej^[hYWi[i"_cfbWdjWj_ede\fbWij_Y cWj[h_Wb_id[Y[iiWho$ ?d`kho je j^[l[_de\BWXX$C_d_cWbZkhWbef[d_d]WdZb_c_j[Z XhW_dh[jhWYj_edYWdc_d_c_p[j^_ie\j[dfheXb[cWj_YYecfb_YW# j_ed$ :WcW][ je j^[ j[cfehWbbeX[Zk[ jeifWjkbWfh[iikh[$B_c_j[Z ZkhWb ef[d_d]" WZ[gkWj[ fei_j_ed_d] e\ j^[ fWj_[dj WdZ [Whbo h[celWbe\9I<\hec j^[WcX_[djY_ij[hdYWdWZ[gkWj[boc_d_# c_p[j[cfehWbYecfh[ii_ed$ ?d`kh_[ijedkc[hekid[hl[iWdZl[ii[bi_dj^[bWj[hWbj[djeh_Wb WdZ ikfhWi[bbWh Wh[W Zkh_d] ikh]_YWb Z_ii[Yj_ed YWki_d] feij# ef[hWj_l[d[khebe]_YWbZ[ÓY_ji$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ZkhWbYbeikh[m_j^feijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW$?dYWi[i e\ef[d[ZcWije_ZY[bbi"dWieb_gkehh^[WcWoeYYkhm_j^Wfej[d# j_Wbh_iae\feijef[hWj_l[c[d_d]_j_i$ ?dWZ[gkWj[^[ceijWi_iZkh_d]mekdZYbeikh[m_j^_djhWYhWd_Wb eh[njhWYhWd_Wbie\jj_iik[^[cWjecW$
'(-
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
J_fiWdZjh_Yai
<_]$)$'$(+
JWa[j_c[\ehfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZYehh[Yjfei_j_ed_d]$ IjkZoj^[fbWd[e\j^[j[djeh_kcm^[df[h\ehc_d]ikh]_YWbfbWd# d_d]"_j_i_cfehjWdj\ehfei_j_ed_d]e\j^[fWj_[dj<_]$)$'$(+$ 9ecfWh[Zm_j^j^[ikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejeco"j^[feij[h_ehikX# j[cfehWbWffheWY^h[gk_h[iceh[^[WZhejWj_ed$J^_ii_]d_ÓYWdj hejWj_ed YWd X[ ikffehj[Z m_j^ W Yki^_ed X[d[Wj^ j^[ _fi_bWj# [hWb i^ekbZ[h WdZ m_j^ j_bj_d] e\ W cejeh_p[Z ef[hWj_d] jWXb[ <_]$)$'$(,$
<_]$)$'$(,
Feii_Xb[ lWh_Wj_edi e\ j^[ feij[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb YhWd_ejeco0 Wdj[h_eh [nj[di_ed 71 feij[h_eh [nj[di_ed 81 feij[he_d\[h_eh [nj[di_ed91Wdj[he_d\[h_eh[nj[di_ed:<_]$)$'$(-$
<_]$)$'$(-
7
8
9
:
J^[ j[cfehWb ckiYb[ i^ekbZ X[ cel[Z m_j^ W Xbkdj _dijhk# c[dj1 j^[\WiY_Wi^ekbZX[_dY_i[Z_d j^[Z_h[Yj_ede\ j^[cWi# je_ZfheY[iiWbbem_d]WZ[gkWj[[nfeikh[e\j^[igkWcekiXed[ <_]$)$'$(.$ Dej[ j^[ ikfhWcWije_Z Yh[ij" cWha_d] j^[ b[l[b e\ j^[ j[cfe# hWbiakbbXWi["WdZj^[/&`kdYj_ede\j^[fWh_[jecWije_ZWbWdZ igkWceiWbikjkh[iZ[Ód_d]j^[efj_cWbfbWY[c[dje\j^[Xkhh ^eb[jh[f^_dWj_edWdZj^[YhWd_ejeco<_]$)$'$(/$
<_]$)$'$(.
<_]$)$'$(/
'(.
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
<_]$)$'$)&
<_]$)$'$)'
IjW][ie\YhWd_ejeco<_]$)$'$)&0'$Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_edWjj^[ `kdYj_ede\j^[fWh_[jecWije_ZWbWdZigkWceiWbikjkh[i1($j[c# feheXWiWbYkjj_d]WYYehZ_d]jej^[j[cfehWbiakbbXWi[1)$iWm_d] _dWi[c_bkdWh\Wi^_ed\hecj^[Xkhh^eb[jej^[Wdj[h_eh[Z][e\ j^[ÓhijYhWd_ejecob_d[$ :h_bb_d]e\ j^[_dd[h[Z][e\ j^[ j[cfeheXWiWbYhWd_ejecob_d[ W\j[hh[celWbe\j^[Xed[ÔWf_i_cfehjWdjje\WY_b_jWj[_djhWZk# hWbl_ikWb_pWj_edWdZcWd_fkbWj_ed<_]$)$'$)'$ ?\f[d[jhWj_ede\j^[cWije_ZY[bbiYekbZdejX[Wle_Z[Z"c[j_Yk# bekiYbeikh[_ih[gk_h[Z<_]$)$'$)($
<_]$)$'$)(
<_]$)$'$))
J^[ZkhWbef[d_d]i^ekbZX[f[h\ehc[Z_dWi_cfb[Ç9Èi^Wf[Z" i[c_bkdWh\Wi^_ed$J^[ZkhWbÔWf_i^[bZ jemWhZi j^[ j[cfehWb iakbbXWi[m_j^jmeikjkh[i1ej^[hZkhWb[b[lWj_edikjkh[iWh[dej h[gk_h[Z<_]$)$'$))$ 7\j[h[dZ_d]j^[_djhWYhWd_WbfheY[Zkh["j^[ZkhWbef[d_d]i^ekbZ X[ Ybei[Z _d W mWj[hj_]^j \Wi^_ed$ ?\ j[di_ed ^Wi Z[l[bef[Z _d j^[ j[cfehWb ZkhW" W icWbb f_[Y[ e\ ckiYb[ YWd X[ i[md _dje j^[ZkhWbYbeikh[1_dej^[hYWi[ifbWij_YcWj[h_Wbi^ekbZX[ki[Z <_]$)$'$)*$ J^[Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_edcWoX[Ybei[Zm_j^Wj_jWd_kcfbWj[ fhel_Z_d]Wdefj_cWbÓnWj_ede\j^[Xed[ÔWf<_]$)$'$)+$ DeikYj_edZhW_d_id[Y[iiWho$
<_]$)$'$)*
<_]$)$'$)+
'(/
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehfh[i_]ce_ZWblWh_Wj_ed
)$( J^[YecX_d[Zfeij[h_ehikXj[cfehWb# fh[i_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^ J^[feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejecoYWdX[[\\[Yj_l[bo[nj[dZ[Z _d Wd Wdj[he_d\[h_eh Z_h[Yj_ed$J^[ [ii[dY[ e\ j^[ YecX_d[Z fei# j[h_ehikXj[cfehWb#fh[i_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^_ij^[XheWZikfhW#WdZ _d\hWj[djeh_Wb [nfeikh[ W\j[h f[h\ehc_d] W b_c_j[Z Wdj[h_eh cWi# je_Z[YjecoWdZef[d_d]j^[ikXj[cfehWbWdZfh[i_]ce_ZWbZkhW cWj[h$ 7 Y^Wbb[d]_d] fheXb[c ki_d] YecX_d[Z feij[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb# fh[i_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^[i_ijeZ[Wbm_j^j^[_d\[h_ehWdWijecej_Y l[_de\BWXX$?dceijYWi[i"j[cfehWbXh_Z]_d]l[_diYWdX[YWh[# \kbboZ_ii[Yj[ZWmWo\hecj^[Yehj_YWbikh\WY[WdZ\hecj^[ZkhWb [djhWdY[" Y_hYkcl[dj_d] eYYbki_ed$ >em[l[h" _\ iYWh_ÓYWj_ed YWd dejX[Wle_Z[Z"h[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[ckijX[cWn_cWbbo h[ZkY[ZWbbem_d]ef[dÔem_dj^[WdWijecej_Yl[_die\j^[j[c# fehWbikh\WY[$J^ki"fei_j_edWdZfh[iikh[e\j^[XhW_difWjkbWfbWo WY[djhWbheb[$ <_]$)$($' IY^[cWj_Y_bbkijhWj_edZ[cedijhWj_d]j^[eX`[Y# j_l[ e\ j^[ fh[i_]ce_ZWb [nj[di_ed e\ j^[ ikXj[cfehWb YhWd_ejeco0W\j[hWfWhj_WbcWije_Z[YjecoWdZ j[djeh_Wb _dY_i_ed" j^[ Wdj[h_eh fWhj e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[ Wd]b[ YWd X[ [\\[Yj_l[bo WffheWY^[Z WYYehZ_d] je W YecX_d[Z ikfhW#WdZ_d\hWj[djeh_WbZ_ii[Yj_ed$
J^_i YecX_d[Z ikXj[cfehWb#fh[i_]ce_ZWb WffheWY^ Wbbemi m_Z[ ikfhW#WdZ_d\hWj[djeh_Wbl_ikWb_pWj_edWhekdZj^[feij[he#ikf[h_eh ikh\WY[e\j^[f[jhekiXed[$J^[ikfhWj[djeh_WbikXj[cfehWbfWhj e\ j^[ WffheWY^ Yehh[ifedZi je W lWh_Wj_ed e\ j^[ feij[h_eh ikX# j[cfehWbYhWd_ejeco"Wbbem_d][nfeikh[e\j^[feij[hebWj[hWbj[d# jeh_Wb_dY_ikhW$J^[_d\hWj[djeh_Wbfh[i_]ce_ZfWhje\j^[WffheWY^ _i Y[dj[h[Z ed j^[ cWije_Z fheY[ii" f[h\ehc_d] lWho_d] Z[]h[[i e\ cWije_Z WdZ bWXoh_dj^_d[ h[i[Yj_ed$ J^hek]^ j^[ fh[i_]ce_Z ZkhWb ef[d_d]" WYYehZ_d] je j^[JhWkjcWdd jh_Wd]b[" j^[ Y[h[X[b# befedj_d[ Wd]b[ WdZ j^[ bWj[hWb Y[h[X[bbec[ZkbbWh h[]_ed YWd X[ eXi[hl[Z \hec j^[ j[djeh_Wb _dY_ikhW _dje j^[ YhWd_eY[hl_YWb `kdY# j_ed$ M[ Z[iYh_X[ ^[h[ W b_c_j[Z fh[i_]ce_Z Z_ii[Yj_ed m_j^ekj Z[ijhkYj_ed e\ j^[ bWXoh_dj^ WdZ m_j^ekj Z_ifbWY[c[dj e\ j^[ \WY_Wb d[hl[$ 7i W h[Wb h[jhebWXoh_dj^_d[ ceZ_ÓYWj_ed" _d YWi[i e\ dWhhemWdWjec_YWbifWY[i"j^[WffheWY^cWo_dYehfehWj[_Z[dj_Ó# YWj_ede\j^[XedoYWfikb[ie\j^[bWj[hWbWdZfeij[h_ehi[c_Y_hYk# bWhYWdWbiWdZia[b[jed_p_d]j^[<Wbbef_WdYWdWb$7ceh[[nj[di_l[ Z[]h[[e\cWije_ZZ_ii[Yj_edm_j^fWhj_Wbeh[dj_h[h[i[Yj_ede\j^[ i[c_Y_hYkbWhYWdWbiWdZj^[l[ij_Xkb[Ze[idejWbbemi_]d_ÓYWdjbo _dYh[Wi[Z _djhWYhWd_Wb l_ikWb_pWj_ed e\ j^[ Z[[f#i[Wj[Z Y[h[X[bbe# fedj_d[ijhkYjkh[iWdZ"_dekhef_d_ed"i^ekbZX[Wle_Z[Z$
')'
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehfh[i_]ce_ZWblWh_Wj_ed
IkfhWj[djeh_Wb
F[jhekiXed[
?d\hWj[djeh_Wb
Ikf[h_ehf[jheiWbi_dki J[djeh_Wb_dY_ikhW 7dj[h_ehWdZfeij[h_ehf[jheYb_de_Zb_]Wc[dj Feij[h_ehYb_deZfheY[ii Feij[h_ehfWhje\j^[YWl[hdekii_dki BWj[hWbWif[Yje\j^[ fedjec[i[dY[f^Wb`kdYj_ed BWj[hWbf_d[Wbh[]_ed Efj_YjhWYj"9D???"9D?L ?97"F9e7"79^7"F97"I97"_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi 8WiWbl[_de\Hei[dj^Wb"l[_de\BWXX
<Wbbef_WdYWdWb BWj[hWbi[c_Y_hYkbWhYWdWb Feij[h_ehi[c_Y_hYkbWhYWdWb
JhWkjcWddjh_Wd]b[ Ikf[h_ehf[jheiWbi_dki J[djeh_Wb_dY_ikhW Kff[hfWhje\j^[Yb_lki 9[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[ BWj[hWbWif[Yje\j^[c[i[dY[f^Wbed BWj[hWbWif[Yje\j^[fedi J[djeh_Wbikh\WY[e\j^[Y[h[X[bbkc 9D?L"9DL"9DL?"9DL??"9DL??? 9D?N"9DN"9DN?"9DN?? 7?97"F?97"L7"87"I97" _dYb$f[h\ehWjehi 8WiWbl[_de\Hei[dj^Wb"l[_de\=Wb[d
JWXb[)$($' 7dWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[iWffheWY^[Zl_Wj^[YecX_d[Zfeij[h_ehikXj[cfehWb#fh[i_]ce_ZWbYhWd_ejeco$
?d j^[ \ebbem_d]" j^[ ikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[ e\ j^[ ikXj[cfehWb fh[# i_]ce_ZWffheWY^_iZ[iYh_X[Z$
')(
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehfh[i_]ce_ZWblWh_Wj_ed
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[
<_]$)$($(
'$FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] M_j^j^[fWj_[dj_dWikf_d[fei_j_ed"j^[^[WZ_iÓn[Z_dWCWo# Ó[bZ ^ebZ[h m_j^ j^[ i_d]b[ f_d fbWY[Z _d j^[ \eh[^[WZ X[^_dZ j^[^W_hb_d["Wbbem_d]W\h[[WdZYec\ehjWXb[fei_j_ed\ehikh][ho$ 7YYehZ_d]jej^[i_]d_ÓYWdj^[WZhejWj_ed"j^[_fi_bWj[hWbi^ekbZ[h _i [b[lWj[Z m_j^ W Yki^_ed" WdZ" _\ d[Y[iiWho" j^[ ef[hWj_d] jWXb[ YWdX[j_bj[Zi_Z[mWoi$ Ij[f' J^[[b[lWj_ede\j^[^[WZWXel[j^[b[l[be\j^[j^ehWn\WY_b_jWj[i YhWd_Wbl[dekiZhW_dW][WdZe\\[hi[\\[Yj_l[Z[Yecfh[ii_ede\j^[ Y[hl_YWb ijhkYjkh[i$ 9ecfWh[Z je j^[ Wdj[h_eh WdZ feij[h_eh ikX# j[cfehWbYhWd_ejec_[i"ceh[[b[lWj_ede\j^[^[WZe\\[hiefj_cWb WdZ[h]edec_YWYY[iijej^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[<_]$)$($($
<_]$)$($)
<_]$)$($*
Ij[f( J^[h[W\j[h" j^[ ^[WZ _i YWh[\kbbo hejWj[Z WXekj /&Å'&& je j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWbi_Z[$7ic[dj_ed[ZWXel["j^_i[njh[c[hejWj_edYWd X[ ikYY[ii\kbbo ikffehj[Z m_j^ W Yki^_ed X[d[Wj^ j^[ _fi_bWj# [hWbi^ekbZ[hWdZXoj_bj_d]j^[ef[hWj_d]jWXb[$If[Y_WbWjj[dj_ed i^ekbZX[]_l[djej^[l[dj_bWj_edjkX["bWhodnWdZjej^[cW_dY[h# l_YWbl[ii[bi$9ecfWh[Zjej^[Wdj[h_ehWdZfeij[h_ehikXj[cfehWb WffheWY^[i" j^[ fh[i_]ce_Z ceZ_ÓYWj_ed h[gk_h[i ceh[ hejWj_ed jeWbbemefj_cWbWYY[iijej^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[<_]$)$($)$ Ij[f) J^[^[WZi^ekbZX[bWj[heÔ[Yj[ZWXekj'&"ikffehj_d]j^[]hWl_jo# h[bWj[Zi[b\#h[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[$9ecfWh[Zjej^[Wdj[# h_ehWdZfeij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^[i"j^[fh[i_]ce_ZlWh_W# j_edd[[Zib[iibWj[heÔ[n_ed"fhel_Z_d]efj_cWbWYY[ii je j^[Y[h# [X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[<_]$)$($*$ Ij[f* I_c_bWh je j^[ feij[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb WffheWY^" j^[ ^[WZ i^ekbZ X[ h[jheÔ[Yj[Z WXekj '&" fhel_Z_d] W Yec\ehjWXb[ meha_d] fei_# j_ed\ehj^[ikh][ed$J^[h[jheÔ[n_edWbiee\\[hiWZZ_j_edWbZ[Yec# fh[ii_ed e\ j^[ l[dj_bWj_ed jkX[" bWhodn WdZ j^[ Y[hl_YWb l[ii[bi <_]$)$($+$
<_]$)$($+
'))
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehfh[i_]ce_ZWblWh_Wj_ed
($7dWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZeh_[djWj_ed 8[\eh[f[h\ehc_d]j^[ia_d_dY_i_ed"j^[WdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaie\ j^[ bWj[hWb eii[eki iakbb ikY^ Wi j^[ bWj[hWb ehX_jWb Yehd[h" po]e# cWj_YWhY^"Whj_YkbWhjkX[hYkb["[nj[hdWbWkZ_jehoYWdWb"ikfhWcWi# je_ZYh[ij"cWije_ZfheY[iiWdZj^[cWije_Z_dY_ikhWWh[fh[Y_i[bo fWbfWj[Z$Dej[j^[eYY_f_jecWije_Z"bWcXZe_Z"fWh_[jecWije_ZWdZ igkWceiWb ikjkh[i WdZ Z[Ód_j_ed e\ j^[ Wij[h_ed$ If[Y_Wb Wjj[d# j_edi^ekbZX[]_l[djej^[Yekhi[e\j^[jhWdil[hiWbWdZi_]ce_Z i_dki[iWdZjej^[b[l[be\j^[j[cfehWbiakbbXWi[<_]$)$($,W$
:
9
8
7
7\j[h Z[Ód_j_ed e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco" j^[ _dZ_l_ZkWb efj_ckc b_d[ e\j^[ia_d_dY_i_ed_icWha[ZWdZfbWY[ZWXekj'&cc_dWh[jhe# Wkh_YkbWhfei_j_edWjj^[b[l[be\j^[cWije_ZfheY[ii<_]$)$($,X$ 7\j[h c_d_cWb i^Wl_d]" j^[ ia_d i^ekbZ X[ YWh[\kbbo Z_i_d\[Yj[Z m_j^WbYe^ebiebkj_ed$ <_]$ )$($, W :[Ód_j_ed e\ j^[ jhWdil[hiWb WdZ i_]ce_Z i_dki"WYYehZ_d]jej^[WdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaie\j^[h[jhe# Wkh_YkbWh#h[jhecWije_ZWb h[]_ed$ Dej[ j^[ ikfhWcWije_Z Yh[ij 7" Wij[h_ed 8" [nj[hdWb eYY_f_jWb fhejkX[hWdY[ 9 WdZj^[cWije_ZfheY[ii:$
<_]$ )$($, X :[Ód_j_ed e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco WdZ ia_d _dY_# i_ed WYYehZ_d] je j^[ WdWjec_YWb bWdZcWhai e\ j^[ j[c# fehe#eYY_f_jWb WdZ cWije_Z h[]_edi$ Dej[ j^[ feij[h_eh fbWY[c[dje\j^[ikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejeco0j^[Xkhh^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_edi^ekbZX[f[h\ehc[ZWj j^[`kdYj_ede\ j^[ fWh_[jecWije_Z WdZ igkWceki ikjkh[i" `kij Wdj[h_eh je j^[i_]ce_Zi_dki$J^[XWi[e\j^[YhWd_ejecoYehh[ifedZi je j^[ ikfhWcWije_Z Yh[ij$ J^[ fh[i_]ce_Z [nj[di_ed e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco Yehh[ifedZi je W fWhj_Wb cWije_Z[Yjeco" [nfei_d]j^[JhWkjcWddjh_Wd]b[$J^[ijhW_]^jehib_]^jbo Ykhl[Z ia_d _dY_i_ed i^ekbZ X[ cWZ[ Wj j^[ b[l[b e\ j^[ cWije_ZfheY[ii$
')*
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehfh[i_]ce_ZWblWh_Wj_ed
)$9hWd_ejeco Ij[f' B[\j i_Z[$ J^[ ib_]^jbo Ykhl[Z ia_d _dY_i_ed _i cWZ[ YW$ '& cc X[^_dZ j^[ [nj[hdWb WkZ_# jehoYWdWb$J^[_dY_i_edX[]_diWjj^[j_fe\j^[ cWije_ZfheY[iiWdZ[nj[dZim_j^Wb[d]j^e\ WXekj ,& cc _dje j^[ j[cfehefWh_[jWb Wh[W$ J^[ikXYkjWd[ekibWo[h_iZ_ii[Yj[Zi_Z[mWoi [nfei_d] j^[ feij[h_eh fWhj e\ j^[ j[cfehWb ckiYb[WdZj^[ikh\WY[e\j^[cWije_ZfheY[ii$ Dej[ iY^[cWj_Y _bbkijhWj_ed e\ j^[ i_]ce_Z i_dkiWYYehZ_d] je j^[WdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhai <_]$)$($-$
<_]$)$($-
Ij[f( J^[ f[h_eij[Wb bWo[h" je][j^[h m_j^ j^[ \WiY_W e\ j^[ ij[hdeYb[_ZecWije_Z ckiYb[" _i _dY_i[Z _dWijhW_]^j\Wi^_edWdZj^[j[cfehWbckiYb[ _i \h[[Z Xbkdjbo \hec j^[ ikfhWcWije_Z Yh[ij <_]$)$($.$
<_]$)$($.
Ij[f) Ki_d]WmekdZh[jhWYjeh"j^[\WiY_We\j^[cWi# je_ZfheY[iiWdZj^[j[cfehWbckiYb[Wh[\ehY# _Xboh[jhWYj[Z$Dej[j^[_cfehjWdjWdWjec_YWb bWdZcWhai e\ j^[ j[cfehecWije_ZWb h[]_ed0 j^[ ikfhWcWije_Z Yh[ij" WdZ j^[ jhWdi_j_ed X[jm[[dj^[igkWceiWbWdZfWh_[jecWije_ZWb ikjkh[i$ J^[ ikfhWcWije_Z Yh[ij Yehh[ifedZi jej^[feij[h_ehfWhje\j^[j[cfehWbb_d[WdZ cWhaij^[b[l[be\j^[j[cfehWbiakbbXWi[1j^[ `kdYj_edX[jm[[dj^[igkWceiWbWdZfWh_[je# cWije_ZWbikjkh[iYehh[ifedZijej^[efj_cWb fbWY[c[dje\j^[Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_edWle_Z# _d]_d`khojej^[i_]ce_ZWbi_dki<_]$)$($/$
<_]$)$($/
')+
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehfh[i_]ce_ZWblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f* J^[ YecX_d[Z feij[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb#fh[i_]# ce_ZWb WffheWY^ Yehh[ifedZi je W fWhj_Wbbo eij[efbWij_Y WdZ fWhj_Wbbo eij[eYbWij_Y YhWd_# ejeco$ 7\j[h Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_ed" j^[ j[c# feheXWiWbZkhW_ii[[d`kijWdj[h_ehjej^[i_]# ce_Z i_dki$M_j^ j^[ ^_]^#if[[Z YhWd_ejec[" WijhW_]^jb_d[_ij^[diWm[Z_dWfeij[h_ehje Wdj[h_ehZ_h[Yj_edWjj^[b[l[be\j^[ikfhWcWi# je_ZYh[ij"WYYehZ_d]jej^[j[cfehWbiakbbXWi[ <_]$)$($'&$
<_]$)$($'&
<_]$)$($''
Ij[f+ J^[h[W\j[h" WÇ9È i^Wf[Z" Ykhl[Z b_d[ _i iWm[Z je j^[ Wdj[h_eh XehZ[h e\ j^[ fh[l_ekibo f[h# \ehc[Zj[cfeheXWiWbb_d["ki_d]W^_]^#if[[Z Zh_bb$J^ki"Wb_c_j[Zfeij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbYhW# d_ejeco_iYh[Wj[Zm_j^Wm_Zj^e\YW$(+cc WdZW^[_]^je\YW$'+cc<_]$)$($''$
<_]$)$($'(
Ij[f, 7\j[hYecfb[j_d]j^[ikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejeco" j^[Wdj[h_ehfWhje\ j^[i_]ce_Zi_dki_iia[b# [jed_p[Z"WdZWb_c_j[ZcWije_Z[Yjeco_if[h# \ehc[Z" ki_d] W ^_]^#if[[Z Zh_bb$ ?d j^[ YWi[ e\ W dWhhem fh[i_]ce_Z ifWY[" j^[ i_]ce_Z i_dkiYWdX[\h[[ZWdZ][djboh[jhWYj[Z"Wbbem# _d]efj_cWb[nfeikh[e\ j^[fh[i_]ce_ZZkhW cWj[h$ If[Y_Wb Wjj[dj_ed i^ekbZ X[ ]_l[d je j^[ <Wbbef_Wd YWdWb m_j^ j^[ \WY_Wb d[hl[ WdZ jej^[feij[h_ehWdZbWj[hWbi[c_Y_hYkbWhYWdWbi <_]$)$($'($
'),
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehfh[i_]ce_ZWblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f- J^[ feij[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb YhWd_ejeco WdZ W b_c_j[Z cWije_Z[Yjeco Wh[ f[h\ehc[Z$ J^[ \WY_Wb YWdWb WdZ j^[ c_ZZb[ WdZ _dd[h [Wh ijhkYjkh[i Wh[ a[fj _djWYj$J^[ ZkhW cWj[h e\ j^[ feij[h_eh YhWd_Wb \eiiW" Wdj[h_eh je j^[ i_]ce_Zi_dki"Yehh[ifedZi je j^[JhWkjcWdd jh_Wd]b[$7\j[hYhWd_ejecoWdZfWhj_WbcWije_Z# [Yjeco"j^[ikXj[cfehWbZkhWcWj[h_i_dY_i[Z _dWi[c_bkdWh"Ykhl[Z\Wi^_edWbed]j^[XWi[ e\j^[j[cfehWbYhWd_ejeco$Dej[j^[ikf[h_eh f[jheiWbi_dkiWdZj^[eXi[hl[ZWdj[h_eh[Z][ e\j^[i_]ce_Zi_dki<_]$)$($')$
<_]$)$($')
Ij[f. 7d _cfehjWdj ij[f e\ j^[ ZkhWb ef[d_d] _i je Z_l_Z[j^[ikf[h_ehf[jheiWbi_dki$J^[Ybeikh[ WdZZ_l_i_ede\j^[i_dkii^ekbZX[f[h\ehc[Z Wj_jiYedd[Yj_edjej^[i_]ce_ZWdZjhWdil[h# iWb i_dki[i Yehh[ifedZ_d] je j^[ Wf[n e\ j^[ 9_j[bb_Wd]b[$<ehj^_ih[Wied"j^[ki[e\^[ce# Yb_fiYWdX[h[Yecc[dZ[Z<_]$)$($'*$
<_]$)$($'*
Ij[f/ 7\j[h Z_l_i_ed e\ j^[ ikf[h_eh f[jheiWb i_dki" j^[ZkhWcWj[he\j^[feij[h_ehYhWd_Wb\eiiW_i ef[d[ZWdj[h_ehjej^[i_]ce_Zi_dkiWYYehZ_d] jej^[feij[h_ehcWh]_de\j^[JhWkjcWddjh_Wd# ]b[$7YYehZ_d]jej^[ikh]_YWbYehh_Zeh"j^[j[d# jeh_kc _i _dY_i[Z m_j^ekj ZWcW]_d] j^[ ijhkY# jkh[i e\ j^[ feij[h_eh j[djeh_Wb _dY_ikhW$ J^[ j[djeh_kc"j^[ZkhWe\j^[feij[h_eh\eiiWWdZ j^[ ZkhW e\ j^[ j[cfehWb Yedl[n_jo Wh[ j^[d h[jhWYj[Z Wdj[h_ehbo ki_d] [b[lWj_d] ikjkh[i <_]$)$($'+$
<_]$)$($'+
')-
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehfh[i_]ce_ZWblWh_Wj_ed
<Wbbef_WdYWdWb feij[h_ehi[c_# Y_hYkbWhYWdWb j[cfehWbZkhW cWj[h ikf[h_ehf[jheiWb i_dki i_]ce_Zi_dki jhWdil[hiWbi_dki
<_]$)$($',
*$:khWbef[d_d]"_djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ij[f' B[\ji_Z[$
j[djeh_kc Y[h[X[bbkc j[cfehWbbeX[
<_]$)$($'-
Ij[f) 7\j[h _Z[dj_\o_d] j^[ feij[h_eh fWhj e\ j^[ WcX_[dj Y_ij[hd" j^[ WhWY^de_Z c[cXhWd[i Wh[ ef[d[Z \eh ik\ÓY_[dj 9I< ZhW_dW][$ 7\j[h h[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehe#eYY_f_jWbh[]_ed"j^[ jhWdi_j_ed X[jm[[d j^[ WcX_[dj WdZ gkWZh_# ][c_dWb Y_ij[hdi m_j^ XhWdY^[i e\ j^[ feij[# h_eh Y[h[XhWb WdZ ikf[h_eh Y[h[X[bbWh Whj[h_[i YWdX[i[[d$9bei[jej^[I97"j^[9D?LYWdX[ eXi[hl[ZWdZ_dj^[XWYa]hekdZ"j^[feij[he# bWj[hWbikh\WY[e\j^[c[i[dY[f^WbedWff[Whi <_]$)$($'.$
j[cfehWbbeX[ I97"9D?L c[i[dY[f^Wbed Y[h[X[bbkc
<_]$)$($'.
').
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehfh[i_]ce_ZWblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f* J^[ fWhW^_ffeYWcfWb ]ohki _i h[jhWYj[Z WdZ j^[WcX_[djY_ij[hd_iZ_ii[Yj[Zm_j^Wc_Yhe# iY_iieh$J^[Y_ij[hdWbYekhi[e\j^[9D?L_i\eb# bem[Z _d Wd Wdj[h_eh Z_h[Yj_ed WdZ i[fWhWj[Z \hec WhWY^de_ZWb WZ^[i_edi$ Dej[ j^[ bWj[hWb c[i[dY[f^Wb_Y i[]c[dj e\ j^[ I97$ ?d j^[ XWYa]hekdZ j^[ bWj[hWb ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ c[i[d# Y[f^WbedYWdX[i[[d <_]$)$($'/$
9D?L I97 c[i[dY[f^Wbed
<_]$)$($'/
Ij[f+ ?dWceh[Wdj[h_ehl_[m"j^[9D?LZ_iWff[Whi m_j^_d j^[ ZkhWb \ebZ e\ j^[ j[djeh_kc$ Dej[ j^[ fh[c[i[dY[f^Wb_Y i[]c[dj e\ j^[ I97$ M_j^ j^[feij[h_ehboi_jkWj[ZYhWd_ejeco" j^[ 87_i^_ZZ[dX[^_dZj^[XhW_dij[c$Dej[j^[ 9D???<_]$)$($(&$
9D??? 9D?L I97
<_]$)$($(&
Ij[f, J^[h[jhe#WdZikfhWi[bbWhWh[W"eXi[hl_d]\hec j^[feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbZ_h[Yj_ed$Dej[j^[ efj_Y jhWYj WdZ j^[ ikfhWYb_de_Z i[]c[dj e\ j^[ ?97 m_j^ _ji XhWdY^[i$
?97 9D??? efj_YjhWYj 9D?L F97 I97
<_]$)$($('
')/
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehfh[i_]ce_ZWblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f- :_ii[Yj_d]_dYWkZWbZ_h[Yj_ed\hec j^[9D?L" j^[9DLWff[WhiYbei[jeWXhWdY^e\j^[I97$ M_j^ j^[ YecX_d[Z ikfhW# WdZ _d\hWj[djeh_Wb WffheWY^" ijhkYjkh[i e\ j^[ c_ZZb[ WdZ fei# j[h_eh \eiiW YWd Wbie X[ eXi[hl[Z$ Dej[ j^[ f[jheki l[_d e\ :WdZo" b[WZ_d] _dje j^[ ikf[# h_ehf[jheiWbi_dki$J^[j[djeh_kc_ih[jhWYj[Z \ehY_Xbo_dWdWdj[h_ehZ_h[Yj_ed<_]$)$($(($
9D?L 9DL I97 f[jhekil[_d
<_]$)$($((
Ij[f. J^[Y[h[X[bbkc_i\h[[Z\hecj^[f[jhekiXed[" Wbbem_d] eXi[hlWj_ed e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[ Wd]b[ j^hek]^ j^[ fh[i_]ce_Z ikh]_YWb Yehh_# Zeh$ J^[ Yecfb[n e\ j^[ \WY_Wb WdZ l[ij_Xkbe# YeY^b[Whd[hl[iWff[WhiYWkZWb\hec:WdZoÊi f[jheiWb l[_d$ J^[ ÔeYYkbki _i h[jhWYj[Z m_j^ W Z_ii[Yjeh Wbbem_d] eXi[hlWj_ed e\ j^[ [djho ped[e\j^[9DL???$Dej[j^[beefe\j^[7?97 Ybei[jej^[9DL??<_]$)$($()$
7?97 9DL??"9DL??? f[jhekil[_d
<_]$)$($()
Ij[f/ :_ii[Yj_d]ceh[ZemdmWhZ"j^[9D?NWdZ9DN YWdX[eXi[hl[Z$Dej[j^[l[djhebWj[hWbikh\WY[ e\j^[fedjec[ZkbbWh`kdYj_ed<_]$)$($(*$ 9D?N"9DN 9DL??"9DL???
<_]$)$($(*
'*&
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehfh[i_]ce_ZWblWh_Wj_ed
+$:khW"Xed[WdZmekdZYbeikh[ 7\j[hYecfb[j_ede\j^[_djhWYhWd_WbfheY[Zkh["j^[ZkhW_iYbei[Z m_j^ _dj[hhkfj[Z eh Yedj_dkeki ikjkh[i$ ?d i[l[hWb YWi[i" mWj[h# j_]^jYbeikh[e\j^[fh[i_]ce_ZZkhW_iZ_\ÓYkbj$J^[cWije_ZY[bbi Wh[Ybei[Zm_j^WXZec_dWb\Wjj_iik[ehm_j^WÔWfe\j^[j[cfe# hWb_ickiYb[$J^[ikXj[cfehWbXed[ÔWf_iÓn[Zm_j^ed[ehjme j_jWd_kcfbWj[i$7\j[hÓdWbl[h_ÓYWj_ede\^[ceijWi_i"j^[ckiYk# bWh WdZ ikXYkjWd[eki bWo[hi Wh[ Ybei[Z m_j^ _dj[hhkfj[Z ikjkh[i WdZj^[ia_dm_j^_dj[hhkfj[Zehhkdd_d]_djhWYkjWd[ekiikjkh[i$ JeWle_ZWfeijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW"ki[e\WikYj_edZhW_d_idej h[Yecc[dZ[Z$?\dWiWbb_gkehh^[WeYYkhi"bkcXWhZhW_dW][_id[Y# [iiWhojeWle_Zfeijef[hWj_l[c[d_d]_j_i$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i 7YYehZ_d] je j^[ j[Y^d_YWbbo ief^_ij_YWj[ZWffheWY^" i[b\#cWZ[ fbWd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]_i[if[Y_Wbbo_cfehjWdj$ M_j^ j^[ fh[i_]ce_ZWb eij[eYbWij_Y YhWd_ejeco" cWije_Z Y[bbi m_bbX[ef[d[Zm^_b[f[h\ehc_d]j^[fWhj_WbcWije_Z[Yjeco$J^[ ef[d_d]i^ekbZX[Ybei[Zc[j_YkbekibojeWle_ZWfeijef[hWj_l[ 9I<ÓijkbWWdZc[d_d]_j_i$ ?d`khojej^[ZkhWcWj[hZkh_d]YhWd_ejeco$:khWbYbeikh[_iZ_\# ÓYkbj"[if[Y_Wbbo_dj^[fh[i_]ce_ZWh[W$ ?d`kho je j^[ i_]ce_Z i_dki Zkh_d] fh[i_]ce_Z cWije_Z[Yjeco$ J^_iYecfb_YWj_edm_j^ikXi[gk[dji[l[h[Xb[[Z_d]i^ekbZZ[Ó# d_j[boX[Wle_Z[Z$ :WcW][ je j^[ j[cfehWb beX[ WdZ Y[h[X[bbkc Zk[ je ifWjkbW fh[iikh[$ B_c_j[Z ZkhWb ef[d_d]" WZ[gkWj[ fei_j_ed_d] e\ j^[ fWj_[djWdZ[Whboh[celWbe\9I<\hecj^[WcX_[djWdZY[h[X[b# befedj_d[Y_ij[hdiWh[_cfehjWdj$ ?d`kho je j^[ l[_d e\ BWXX m_j^ ikXi[gk[dj j[cfehWb l[deki _d\WhYj_edWdZ_djhWY[h[XhWbXb[[Z_d]$ ?d`kh_[ijedkc[hekid[hl[iWdZl[ii[bim_j^_dj^[bWj[hWbj[dje# h_Wb"Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[WdZY[h[X[bbec[ZkbbWhh[]_ediZkh_d]ikh# ]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_ed"YWki_d]feijef[hWj_l[d[khebe]_YWbZ[ÓY_ji$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ ^[ceijWi_i _d j^[ ikh]_YWb i_j[ m_j^ ikXi[gk[dj _djhWYhWd_Wbh[Xb[[Z_d]$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ZkhWbYbeikh[m_j^feijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ ^[ceijWi_i Zkh_d] mekdZ Ybeikh[ m_j^ ie\j j_iik[ ^[cWjecW$JeWle_ZW9I<ÓijkbW"j^[ki[e\WikYj_edZhW_d_idej h[gk_h[Z$
'*'
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehfh[i_]ce_ZWblWh_Wj_ed
J_fiWdZjh_Yai
<_]$)$($(+
JWa[ j_c[ \eh fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d] WdZ Yehh[Yj fei_j_ed_d] e\ j^[fWj_[dj$Dej[j^[\ehcWdZfbWd[e\j^[j[djeh_kc_dfh[ef# [hWj_l[_cW]_d]$I[b\#cWZ[eh_[djWj_ededWdWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[i _icWdZWjehojeWle_ZZWcW][e\j^[i[di_j_l[d[khe#ejebe]_YWb ijhkYjkh[iWdZjeWbbemik\ÓY_[dj_djhWYhWd_Wbl_ikWb_pWj_ed$
7
8 9ecfWh[Zjej^[Wdj[h_ehWdZfeij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^[i" j^[ ikXj[cfehWb#fh[i_]ce_ZWb WffheWY^ h[gk_h[i ceh[ ^[WZ hejWj_ed7"ceh[[b[lWj_ed8WdZb[iibWj[heÔ[n_ed9"Wbbem# _d]efj_cWb[nfeikh[e\j^[feij[h_ehYhWd_Wb\eiiW<_]$)$($(+$ J^[ j[cfehWb ckiYb[ i^ekbZ X[ \h[[Z Xbkdjbo WdZ j^[ \WiY_W YkjijhW_]^jWbbem_d][nfeikh[e\j^[feij[h_ehigkWcekiXed[ <_]$)$($(,$ Dej[ j^[ _cfehjWdj WdWjec_YWb bWdZcWhai0 j^[ ikfhWcWije_Z Yh[ij"cWha_d]j^[b[l[be\j^[j[cfehWbiakbbXWi["WdZj^[`kdY# j_ed X[jm[[d j^[ fWh_[jecWije_ZWb WdZ igkWceiWb ikjkh[i" i^em_d] j^[ efj_cWb fbWY[c[dj e\ j^[ Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_ed <_]$)$($(-$ Ij[fi e\ j^[ feij[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb#fh[i_]ce_ZWb YhWd_ejeco <_]$ )$($(.0 '$ feij[h_eh j[cfeheXWiWb Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_ed1 ($ j[cfeheXWiWb Ykjj_d] WYYehZ_d] je j^[ ikfhWcWije_Z Yh[ij1 )$ iWm_d] _d W i[c_bkdWh" Ykhl[Z \Wi^_ed \hec j^[ Xkhh ^eb[ je j^[Wdj[h_eh[Z][e\j^[ÓhijYhWd_ejecob_d[1*$fWhj_WbcWije_Z# [Yjeco$
9
<_]$)$($(,
<_]$)$($(-
<_]$)$($(.
'*(
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehfh[i_]ce_ZWblWh_Wj_ed
<_]$)$($(/
Ia[b[jed_pWj_edWdZ"_diec[YWi[i"][djb[\h[[_d]e\j^[i_]ce_Z i_dki _i d[Y[iiWho je ]W_d WYY[ii je j^[JhWkjcWdd jh_Wd]b[ e\ j^[feij[h_eh\eiiWZkhW<_]$)$($(/$
<_]$)$($)&
J^[ZkhWe\j^[JhWkjcWddjh_Wd]b[i^ekbZX[ef[d[ZWbed]j^[ i_]ce_Zi_dkiWdZj^[ikXj[cfehWbZkhW_dWi[c_Y_hYkbWh\Wi^# _ed$J^[ikf[h_ehf[jheiWbi_dkii^ekbZX[Ybei[Zki_d]^[ceYb_fi WdZZ_l_Z[Zm_j^Wc_YheiY_iieh<_]$)$($)&$ JeWle_Z_d`kho je j^[l[_de\BWXX"b_c_j[ZZkhWbef[d_d]WdZ YWh[\kbZ_ii[Yj_ede\j^[l[_d\hecj^[ZkhWWdZ\hecWhWY^de_ZWb c[cXhWd[_i_cfehjWdj$?\Ybeikh[e\j^[BWXXl[_d_ikdWle_Z# WXb["h[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[ckijX[h[ijh_Yj[ZjeWc_d_# ckc _d ehZ[h dej je Yecfh[ii _cfehjWdj WdWijecej_Y l[deki fWj^mWoi$
<_]$)$($)'
7\j[h ZkhWb Ybeikh[" j^[ ef[d[Z cWije_Z Y[bbi i^ekbZ X[ Ybei[Z m_j^WXZec_dWb\Wjj_iik[ehm_j^WÔWfe\j^[j[cfehWbckiYb[ <_]$)$($)'$ JeWle_Zfeijef[hWj_l[dWieb_gkehh^[W"c[j_YkbekiZkhWbYbeikh[ _icWdZWjeho$MWj[hj_]^jYbeikh[e\j^[fh[i_]ce_ZZkhW_iZ_\Ó# Ykbj1_dj^[i[YWi[iWf_[Y[e\j[cfehWbckiYb[YWdX[i[md_dje j^[ZkhWbZ[^_iY[dY[<_]$)$($)($
<_]$)$($)(
Je Wle_Z feijef[hWj_l[ 9I< ÓijkbW" ki[ e\ ikYj_ed ZhW_d _i dej h[Yecc[dZ[Z$ ?\feijef[hWj_l[dWieb_gkehh^[WeYYkhi"j^[ki[e\bkcXWhZhW_d# W][_ih[Yecc[dZ[Z$
'*)
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r ?79lWh_Wj_ed
)$) ;njhWZkhWbceZ_ÓYWj_ede\j^[ ikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejeco[nfei_d]j^[ _dj[hdWbWkZ_jehoYWdWb ;nj[dZ[ZjhWdi#f[jheki#Wf[nceZ_ÓYWj_ed [nfei_d]j^[feij[h_eh\eiiW
<_]$ )$)$' IY^[cWj_Y ZhWm_d] _bbkijhWj_d] j^[ [nfbehWj_ed e\ j^[ _dj[hdWb WkZ_jeho YWdWb l_W W ikXj[cfehWb YhWd_e# jeco$M_j^YWh[\kbZh_bb_d]e\j^[hee\e\j^[_dj[hdWbWkZ_# jehoYWdWb"j^[\WY_Wb"ikf[h_ehl[ij_XkbWh"YeY^b[Wh"WdZj^[ _d\[h_ehl[ij_XkbWhd[hl[iYWdX[[\ÓY_[djboWffheWY^[Z$
<_]$)$)$( 7\j[h_Z[dj_ÓYWj_ede\ j^[=IFDWdZZ[Ód_j_ed e\j^[ikf[h_ehi[c_Y_hYkbWhYWdWbm_j^j^[ÇXbk[b_d[Èj[Y^# d_gk[" j^[ Yekhi[ e\ j^[ ?79 YWd X[ fh[Y_i[bo Z[j[hc_d[Z b[\ji_Z[$
J^_ij[Y^d_gk[Yehh[ifedZijeWd[njhWZkhWbWffheWY^jej^[ikf[# h_eh ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ j[cfehWb Xed[ j^hek]^ W b_c_j[Z ikXj[cfe# hWb YhWd_ejeco$J^[ W_c e\ j^_i ceZ_ÓYWj_ed e\ j^[ ikXj[cfehWb WffheWY^ _i j^[ ef[d_d] e\ j^[ ?79" [nfei_d] j^[ \WY_Wb" ikf[h_eh l[ij_XkbWh"YeY^b[Wh"WdZ_d\[h_ehl[ij_XkbWhd[hl[i<_]$)$)$'$7\j[h YWh[\kb_Z[dj_ÓYWj_ede\j^[]h[Wj[hikf[hÓY_Wbf[jheiWbd[hl[WdZ j^[ikf[h_ehi[c_Y_hYkbWhYWdWbWjj^[WhYkWj[[c_d[dY["j^[Yekhi[ e\j^[_dj[hdWbWkZ_jehoYWdWbYWdX[[nWYjboZ[j[hc_d[Z"Wle_Z_d] ZWcW][jej^[i[di_j_l[l[ij_XkbeYeY^b[WhijhkYjkh[i$CWdoj[Y^# d_gk[i^Wl[X[[dZ[iYh_X[Z\ehj^_ifkhfei[1m[fh[\[hj^[ÇXbk[ b_d[Èc[j^eZZ[iYh_X[ZXoM_bb_Wc<$>eki[WdZK]e<_iY^Q>eki[ '/,'"<_iY^'/,/S$Ki_d]WZ_WcedZZh_bbm_j^Yedj_dkeki_hh_]Wj_ed" j^[ ikf[hÓY_Wb Xedo bWo[h Wj j^[ WhYkWj[ [c_d[dY[ Yel[h_d] j^[ ikf[h_ehi[c_Y_hYkbWhYWdWbi^ekbZX[fWhj_Wbboh[cel[Z$J^[Xbk[ b_d[e\ j^[YWdWb" je][j^[hm_j^ j^[]h[Wj[hf[jheiWbd[hl["Z[j[h# c_d[ij^[Yekhi[e\j^[_dj[hdWbWkZ_jehoYWdWb<_]$)$)$($ J^_iWffheWY^_i_dZ_YWj[Z\ehh[celWbe\icWbb_djhWc[WjWbWYeki# j_Yd[kh_decWim_j^b[iij^Wd+cc[nj[di_ed_djej^[Y[h[X[bbe# fedj_d[ Wd]b[1 _d fWhj_YkbWh" jkcehi m^_Y^ Óbb j^[ _dj[hdWb WkZ_# jehoYWdWb$J^[]eWb_ijeWY^_[l[jejWbh[celWbe\j^[jkcehm_j^ fh[i[hlWj_ede\^[Wh_d]Wjj^[fh[ef[hWj_l[b[l[bWdZdehcWb\WY_Wb \kdYj_ed$?dY[hjW_dYWi[i"mehj^m^_b[l[ij_XkbWh\kdYj_edYWdWbie X[fh[i[hl[Z$ 7ic[dj_ed[ZWXel["j^[WZlWdjW][e\j^[ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ _i j^Wj _j fhel_Z[i WYY[ii je j^[ _dj[hdWb WkZ_jeho YWdWb m^_Y^ _i ej^[hm_i[Z_\ÓYkbjjeh[WY^$>em[l[h"j^_ib_c_j[ZiakbbXWi[[nfe# ikh[YWdX[[nj[dZ[Z_dWdWdj[h_ehZ_h[Yj_ed"W\j[hef[d_d]e\j^[ j[cfeheXWiWb ZkhW cWj[h" [nfei_d] j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh WdZ Y[h[X[b# befedj_d[ijhkYjkh[i$ ?dj^[\ebbem_d]"j^[ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[e\j^[[njhWZkhWbikXj[c# fehWb WffheWY^ _i Z[iYh_X[Z$ ?d WZZ_j_ed" j^[ Wdj[h_eh iakbb XWi[ [nj[di_ede\j^[WffheWY^_i]_l[d_dZ[jW_b$
'*+
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r ?79lWh_Wj_ed
;njhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed
7dj[h_eh[njhW#WdZ_djhWZkhWb[nj[di_ed
J[cfeheXWiWbiakbbXWi[ <ehWc[dif_deikcm_j^j^[CC7 =IFD 7hYkWj[[c_d[dY[ Ikf[h_ehi[c_Y_hYkbWhYWdWb ?79 9DL?? Ikf[h_ehl[ij_XkbWhd[hl[ 9eY^b[Whd[hl[ ?d\[h_ehl[ij_XkbWhd[hl[ BWXoh_dj^_d[Whj[ho 7?97
F[jhekiWf[n BWj[hWbWif[Yje\j^[Yb_lki Feij[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii J[djeh_Wb_dY_ikhW Ikf[h_ehf[jheiWbi_dki C[Ya[bYWl[ :eh[bbeYWdWb Feij[h_ehfWhje\j^[YWl[hdekii_dki BWj[hWbWif[Yje\j^[fedjec[i[dY[f^Wb`kdYj_ed Efj_YjhWYj 9D???"9D?L"9DL"9DL?"9DL??"9DL??? ?97"F9e7"79^7"87"F97"I97"7?97"_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi F[jheiWbl[_de\:WdZo
JWXb[)$)$' 7dWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[iWffheWY^[Zl_Wj^[ceZ_Ó[ZikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejeco$
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[ '$FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d]WdZ_djhWef[hWj_l[ced_jeh_d] 7\j[h Wd[ij^[j_Y WZc_d_ijhWj_ed" W bkcXWh ZhW_dW][ i^ekbZ X[ fbWY[Z$?dj^[_d_j_Wbf^Wi[e\j^[[njhWZkhWbWffheWY^"h[celWbe\ 9I<c_d_c_p[iYecfh[ii_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[$7Z_\\[h[djfhWY# j_YWbiebkj_ed_ijef[h\ehcWc_d_cWbZkhWbef[d_d]X[\eh[[njhW# ZkhWb[b[lWj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[$Ki_d]Wb_c_j[ZWhWY^de_ZWb _dY_i_ed"Yedj_dkeki9I<h[celWbYWdWbieX[WY^_[l[Zj^kic_d_# c_p_d]Yecfh[ii_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[$ 9edj_dkeki \WY_Wb d[hl[ ;C= ced_jeh_d] _i [ii[dj_Wb WdZ \WY_b_# jWj[i iW\[ [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ ZkhW e\ j^[ _dj[hdWb WkZ_jeho YWdWb$ <WY_Wb d[hl[ _Z[dj_ÓYWj_ed _i kikWbbo [Wio WdWjec_YWbbo1 ^em[l[h" ced_jeh_d] \khj^[h _dikh[i dedjhWkcWj_Y \WY_Wb d[hl[ Z_ii[Yj_ed Zkh_d]jkcehh[celWb$
'*,
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r ?79lWh_Wj_ed
J^[ fWj_[dj i^ekbZ X[ fei_j_ed[Z ikf_d[ m_j^ j^[ ^[WZ e\ j^[ ef[hWj_d] jWXb[ [b[lWj[Z WXel[ j^[ b[l[b e\ j^[ j^ehWn WdZ j^[ _fi_bWj[hWb i^ekbZ[h hW_i[Z m_j^ W Yki^_ed$J^[ ^[WZ _i Ón[Z _d W CWoÓ[bZ^ebZ[h1j^[i_d]b[f_d_ifbWY[Z_dj^[\eh[^[WZjeWbbem kdZ_ijkhX[Zikh][ho$
<_]$)$)$)
<_]$)$)$*
Ij[f' 7ij^[Óhijij[f"j^[^[WZ_i[b[lWj[ZWXel[j^[b[l[be\j^[j^ehWn je \WY_b_jWj[ YhWd_Wb l[deki ZhW_dW][ WdZ je fhel_Z[ Wd [\\[Yj_l[ Z[Yecfh[ii_ed e\ j^[ Y[hl_YWb ijhkYjkh[i$ 9ecfWh[Z je j^[ Wdj[# h_ehWdZfeij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejec_[i"ceh[[b[lWj_ede\j^[ ^[WZe\\[hiefj_cWbWdZ[h]edec_YWYY[iijej^[?79<_]$)$)$)$ Ij[f( J^[h[W\j[h"j^[^[WZ_ihejWj[Z.&jej^[effei_j[i_Z[e\j^[YhW# d_ejeco$?d j^_ifei_j_ed" j^[Z_h[Yj_ede\ j^[?79Yehh[ifedZi je Wl[hj_YWbb_d["Wbbem_d]iW\[WdWjec_YWbeh_[djWj_edWdZYec\ehj# WXb[ikh]_YWbWYY[ii<_]$)$)$*$ Ij[f) J^[ ^[WZ i^ekbZ X[ bWj[heÔ[Yj[Z Xo YW$ '& je '+" ikffehj_d] j^[]hWl_jo#h[bWj[Zi[b\#h[jhWYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbbeX[$9ecfWh[Z jej^[Wdj[h_ehWdZfeij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbYhWd_ejec_[i"j^[[njhW# ZkhWblWh_Wj_edh[gk_h[ib[iibWj[heÔ[n_ed"Wbbem_d]efj_cWb[nfe# ikh[e\j^[?79<_]$)$)$+$
<_]$)$)$+
Ij[f* I_c_bWhjej^[Wdj[h_ehWdZfeij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^[i"j^[ ^[WZ i^ekbZ X[ h[jheÔ[Yj[Z WXekj '&" Wbbem_d] W Yec\ehjWXb[ meha_d]fei_j_ed\ehj^[ikh][ed$?dWZZ_j_ed"Zk[jej^[ib_]^jh[j# heÔ[n_ed" i[l[h[ Yecfh[ii_ed e\ j^[ l[dj_bWj_ed jkX[" bWhodn WdZ j^[Y[hl_YWbl[ii[bicWoX[Wle_Z[Z<_]$)$)$,$
<_]$)$)$,
'*-
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r ?79lWh_Wj_ed
($7dWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZeh_[djWj_ed <eh fh[Y_i[ fbWdd_d] e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco" j^[ _cfehjWdj WdWjec_# YWbbWdZcWhaie\j^[j[cfehWbWdZpo]ecWj_Yh[]_edikY^Wij^[ bWj[hWb ehX_jWb h_c" po]ecWj_Y WhY^" Whj_YkbWh jkX[hYkb[" [nj[hdWb WkZ_jeho YWdWb" cWije_Z fheY[ii WdZ j^[ ikfhWcWije_Z Yh[ij Wh[ WYYkhWj[boZ[Ód[Z$Dej[j^[Yekhi[e\j^[Wkh_Ykbej[cfehWbd[hl[ WdZj^[ikf[hÓY_Wbj[cfehWbWhj[ho<_]$)$)-$ 7\j[h WdWjec_YWb eh_[djWj_ed" j^[ XehZ[hi e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco WdZ j^[efj_ckcb_d[e\j^[ia_d_dY_i_edi^ekbZX[Z[Ód[Z$J^[XWiWb b_d[e\j^[YhWd_ejecoYehh[ifedZijej^[ikfhWcWije_ZYh[ij"j^[ Y[dj[he\j^[YhWd_ejecoYehh[ifedZijej^[;79$J^[[nj[di_ede\ j^[YhWd_ejeco_iYW$(+n(+cc"Wbbem_d][nfeikh[e\j^[?79$J^[ ijhW_]^jia_d_dY_i_edm_j^Wb[d]j^e\YW$+&cci^ekbZX[cWZ[ `kij Wdj[h_eh je j^[ [Wh Wle_Z_d] Z[ijhkYj_ed e\ j^[ Wkh_Ykbej[c# fehWb d[hl[ WdZ j^[ ikf[hÓY_Wb Whj[ho <_]$ )$)$-$ Dej[ W c_d_cWb i^Wl_d]e\j^[^W_hWdZYWh[\kbZ_i_d\[Yj_ede\j^[ia_d$
<_]$)$)$- :[Ód_j_ede\j^[YhWd_ejecoWYYehZ_d]jej^[WdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaie\ j^[j[cfehWbWdZpo]ecWj_Yh[]_ed$J^[Y[dj[he\j^[YhWd_ejecoi^ekbZX[fbWY[Z [nWYjboWjj^[b[l[be\j^[;79WdZj^[ia_d_dY_i_ed_icWZ[`kijWdj[h_ehjej^[[Wh" feij[h_ehjej^[ikf[hÓY_Wbj[cfehWbWhj[ho$
'*.
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r ?79lWh_Wj_ed
)$9hWd_ejeco Ij[f' B[\j i_Z[$ 7\j[h fWj_[dj fei_j_ed_d]" WdWjec_# YWbeh_[djWj_ed"WdZc_d_cWb^W_hi^Wl_d]"j^[ ia_d _i fh[fWh[Z m_j^ Wd WbYe^eb iebkj_ed$ 7 ijhW_]^j [f_\WiY_Wb ia_d _dY_i_ed _i j^[d cWZ[ `kijWdj[h_ehjej^[jhW]ki$J^[ikf[hÓY_Wbj[c# fehWb Whj[ho WdZ j^[ Wkh_Ykbej[cfehWb d[hl[ Wh[ Z_ii[Yj[Z WdZ cel[Z _d Wd Wdj[h_eh Z_h[Y# j_ed fh[i[hl_d] j^[ d[khelWiYkbWh ijhkYjkh[i <_]$)$)$.$
<_]$)$)$.
Ij[f( 7\j[hX_bWj[hWbia_dh[jhWYj_ed"j^[\WiY_We\j^[ j[cfehWbckiYb[_iYkj_dWO#i^Wf[Z\Wi^_ed efj_cWbbo[nfei_d]j^[j[cfehWbckiYb[$Dej[ j^[ ikf[hÓY_Wb j[cfehWb Whj[ho cel[Z WdZ h[jhWYj[Z_dWdWdj[h_ehZ_h[Yj_ed<_]$)$)$/$
<_]$)$)$/
Ij[f) J^[XWiWbb[WÔ[j_i\ehY_Xboh[jhWYj[Zel[h j^[ po]ecWj_Y f[Z_Yb[ m_j^ W ijhed] ikjkh[ WdZ j^[h[cW_d_d]jmeÔWfie\j^[j[cfehWb\WiY_W Wh[h[jhWYj[ZX_bWj[hWbbo[nfei_d]j^[j[cfehWb ckiYb[<_]$)$)$'&$
<_]$)$)$'&
'*/
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r ?79lWh_Wj_ed
<_]$)$)$''
Ij[f* M_j^ W Z_ii[Yjeh" j^[ _d\[h_eh cWh]_d e\ j^[ j[cfehWb ckiYb[ _i cel[Z Xbkdjbo \hec j^[ ikfhWcWije_Z Yh[ij WdZ \hec j^[ feij[h_eh po]ecWj_YWhY^h[l[Wb_d]j^[igkWcekiXed[$ J^_ifeij[h_ehWif[Yje\j^[j[cfehWb_ickiYb[ _ij^_dWdZ_dY_i_ede\j^[ckiYb[_ikikWbbodej d[Y[iiWho je ]W_d WZ[gkWj[ [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ Xedoikh\WY[<_]$)$)$''$
<_]$)$)$'(
Ij[f+ 7\j[h [nfei_d] j^[ igkWceki Xed[" W i_d]b[ Xkhh ^eb[ _i fbWY[Z feij[h_ehbo Wj j^[ b[l[b e\ j^[ ikfhWcWije_Z Yh[ij" ef[d_d] j^[ c_ZZb[ YhWd_Wb\eiiW<_]$)$)$'($
<_]$)$)$')
Ij[f, 7\j[h c_d_cWb [dbWh][c[dj e\ j^[ ^eb[ m_j^ Ód[ fkdY^[i WdZ ceX_b_pWj_ed e\ j^[ ZkhW" W ijhW_]^j b_d[ _i iWm[Z m_j^ j^[ YhWd_ejec[ fWhWbb[bjej^[po]ecWj_YWhY^_dWfeij[h_ehje Wdj[h_ehZ_h[Yj_ed<_]$)$)$')$
'+&
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r ?79lWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f- J^[h[W\j[hWÇ9Èi^Wf[Zb_d[_iiWm[Z\hecj^[ Xkhh ^eb[ je j^[ Wdj[h_eh XehZ[h e\ j^[ fh[l_# ekibof[h\ehc[Zj[cfeheXWiWbYhWd_ejecob_d[" j^ki Yh[Wj_d] W Xed[ ÔWf m_j^ W m_Zj^ e\ YW$ (+ccWdZW^[_]^je\YW$(+cc$J^[^[_]^je\ ($+Yc_id[Y[iiWhoje]W_dWYY[iijej^[_dj[hdWb WkZ_jehoYWdWb$?dWbbYWi[i"Wdeij[efbWij_YYhW# d_ejeco_iYWhh_[Zekj$9Wh[ckijX[jWa[ddej jebWY[hWj[j^[ZkhW[_j^[hm_j^j^[YhWd_ejec[ ehm^[db_\j_d]j^[Xed[ÔWf<_]$)$)$'*$
<_]$)$)$'*
Ij[f. ?\WbkcXWhZhW_dW][mWidejfbWY[Zfh[ef[hW# j_l[bo" Wd _cfehjWdj ij[f _i je f[h\ehc W b_c# _j[ZZkhWb_dY_i_edm_j^ef[d_d]e\j^[Yehj_YWb ikXWhWY^de_Z ifWY[$ Ki_d] j^_i i_cfb[ j[Y^# d_gk[" Yecfh[ii_ed e\ j^[ j[cfehWb beX[ YWd X[[\\[Yj_l[boc_d_c_p[Z$7\j[hh[celWbe\j^[ Xed[ÔWf"j^[j[cfeheXWiWb_dd[h[Z][e\j^[ YhWd_ejeco _i Zh_bb[Z kdZ[h fhej[Yj_ed e\ j^[ ZkhWm_j^^_]^#if[[ZZh_bb"j^ki_dYh[Wi_d]j^[ Wd]b[ \eh _djhWYhWd_Wb _dif[Yj_ed WdZ cWd_fk# bWj_ed$?\cWije_ZY[bbiWh[ef[d[Z"j^[oi^ekbZ X[eYYbkZ[Z<_]$)$)$'+$
<_]$)$)$'+
Ij[f/ J^[ ZkhW _i i[fWhWj[Z \hec Xej^ j^[ _d\[h_eh WdZ bWj[hWb XehZ[hi e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco WdZ hW_i[Z YWh[\kbbo \hec j^[ XWi[ e\ j^[ c_ZZb[ \eiiW<_]$)$)$',$
<_]$)$)$',
'+'
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r ?79lWh_Wj_ed
*$;njhW#WdZ_djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ij[f' B[\j i_Z[$ :_ii[Yj_ed Xo ki_d] W \h[i^ ^kcWd YWZWl[h$ J^[ Whj[h_[i Wh[ fh[fWh[Z m_j^ h[Z" l[_di m_j^ Xbk[ Yebeh[Z iebkj_ed$ J^[ ZkhW cWj[h _i hW_i[Z [nfei_d] j^[ ]h[Wj[h ikf[h# ÓY_Wb f[jheiWb d[hl[$ J^[ =IFD _i YWh[\kbbo Z_ii[Yj[Z\hecZkhWbWZ^[i_edi$J^[\ehWc[d if_deikc m_j^ j^[ CC7 YWd X[ i[[d _d j^[ Wdj[h_ehWif[Yj<_]$)$)$'-$
CC7 =IFD
<_]$)$)$'-
Ij[f( M_j^ \khj^[h [b[lWj_ed e\ j^[ j[cfehWb ZkhW" j^[ f[jheki h_Z][ WdZ j^[ WhYkWj[ [c_d[dY[ Wh[i[[d$Ki_d]WZ_WcedZZh_bb"j^[j^_dXedo bWo[h WXel[ j^[ ikf[h_eh i[c_Y_hYkbWh YWdWb i^ekbZ X[ fWhj_Wbbo h[cel[Z" Wbbem_d] [nWYj eh_[djWj_ed$J^[Xbk[b_d[e\j^[YWdWb"je][j^[h m_j^ j^[ ]h[Wj[h f[jheiWb d[hl[" Z[j[hc_d[i l[hoWYYkhWj[boj^[Yekhi[e\j^[_dj[hdWbWkZ_# jehoYWdWb<_]$)$)$'.$
WhYkWj[[c_d[dY[ =IFD
<_]$)$)$'.
Ij[f) 7YYehZ_d] je j^[ WXel[#c[dj_ed[Z WdWjec_# YWbeh_[djWj_ed"j^[?79_ief[d[Zm_j^W^_]^# if[[Z Z_WcedZ Zh_bb$ Dej[ j^[ h[bWj_edi^_f e\ j^[ Xbk[ b_d[" j^[ =IFD WdZ j^[ Z_h[Yj_ed e\ Zh_bb_d]<_]$)$)$'/$
Xbk[b_d[e\II9 =IFD
<_]$)$)$'/
'+(
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r ?79lWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f* J^[ ZkhW cWj[h e\ j^[ ?79 WdZ j^[ feij[h_eh \eiiW _i [nfei[Z WdZ j^[ Z[[f[ij bWo[h e\ j^[ Xed[ _i h[cel[Z m_j^ W Ód[ A[hh_ied fkdY^ <_]$)$)$(&$
=IFD Xbk[b_d[e\II9 ZkhWcWj[he\ j^[?79
<_]$)$)$(&
Ij[f+ 7\j[hZkhWbef[d_d]"j^[\WY_WbWdZikf[h_ehl[i# j_XkbWhd[hl[iYWdX[eXi[hl[Z$Dej[j^[beef e\j^[7?971j^[ikh\WY[e\j^[XhW_dij[cYWd X[ i[[d _d j^[ XWYa]hekdZ$J^[ ikXj[cfehWb WffheWY^ Wbbemi W ceij WZlWdjW][eki [nfe# ikh[e\j^[?79WdZ_jiYedj[dji<_]$)$)$('$
=IFD ikf[h_eh l[ij_XkbWhd[hl[ 7?97 9DL?? XhW_dij[c
<_]$)$)$('
Ij[f, M_j^ \khj^[h h[celWb e\ j^[ f[jheki Wf[n _d Wd Wdj[h_eh Z_h[Yj_ed" j^[ bWj[hWb ikh\WY[ e\ j^[XhW_dij[cYWdX[eXi[hl[Z$Dej[j^[9D L?hkdd_d]_djej^[:eh[bbeYWdWb$If[Y_WbYWh[ i^ekbZ X[ jWa[d dej je ZWcW][ j^[ YeY^b[W <_]$)$)$(($
=IFD YeY^b[W 9DL? fedi
<_]$)$)$((
'+)
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r ?79lWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f- 7\j[hikXj[cfehWbZkhWbef[d_d]WdZ_dY_i_ed e\j^[j[djeh_kc"j^[ijhkYjkh[ie\j^[WcX_[dj Y_ij[hd YWd X[ [nj[di_l[bo WffheWY^[Z$ Dej[ j^[ f[jheki l[_d e\ :WdZo" h[jhWYj[Z m_j^ W c_YheikYa[h$ 7hWY^de_Z c[cXhWd[i WhekdZ j^[ 9D ?L Wh[ ef[d[Z m_j^ c_YheiY_iiehi <_]$)$)$()$
f[jhekil[_d j[djeh_kc 9D?L
<_]$)$)$()
Ij[f. :_ii[Yj_d] ceh[ Wdj[h_ehbo" j^[ l[djhebWj[hWb ikh\WY[e\ j^[fediYWdX[WffheWY^[Z$Dej[ 9D ?L" 9D L" WdZ _d j^[ XWYa]hekdZ j^[ 87 <_]$)$)$(*$
9DL 87 I97"9D?L
<_]$)$)$(*
Ij[f/ J^[ f[jheki l[_d _i h[cel[Z Wbbem_d] \h[[ WdWjec_YWb l_ikWb_pWj_ed e\ j^[ 9D ???" 9D ?L WdZ j^[9DL$Dej[ j^[XWi_bWh jhkdaWdZ j^[ ZekXb[ikf[h_ehY[h[X[bbWhWhj[h_[i<_]$)$)$(+$
9DL 9D?L 9D??? I97
<_]$)$)$(+
'+*
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r ?79lWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f'& F_dfe_dj j^[ h[]_ed e\ j^[ XWi_bWh Wf[n m_j^ j^[ Óhij i[]c[dji e\ j^[ F97 WdZ I97$ Dej[ j^[9D???WdZ9D?L"Z_iWff[Wh_d]m_j^_dj^[ ZkhWcWj[h<_]$)$)$(,$
9DL 87 I97 9D??? 9D?L F97
<_]$)$)$(,
Ij[f'' ;nj[dZ[Z ikXj[cfehWb WffheWY^ je j^[ Wdj[# hebWj[hWb fedi W\j[h h[celWb e\ j^[ f[jheki Wf[nWdZZ_l_i_ede\ j^[ j[djeh_kc$Dej[ j^[ [nY[bb[dj l_[m e\ j^[ XWi_bWh jhkda \hec j^[ 7?97jej^[I97"j^[9D???"9D?L"9DLWdZj^[ Y_ij[hdWbYekhi[e\j^[9DL?<_]$)$)$(-$
9DL?"7?97 fhen_cWb87 9DL 9D?L"I97 Z_ijWb87 9D???
<_]$)$)$(-
Ij[f'( ;nfei_d]W]W_d_dj^[feij[h_ehZ_h[Yj_ed"j^[ h[bWj_ede\j^[9DL"9DL?WdZ9DL??YWdX[ m[bbl_ikWb_p[Z<_]$)$)$(.$ 9DL? 9DL?? 9DL
<_]$)$)$(.
'++
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r ?79lWh_Wj_ed
+$:khW"Xed[WdZmekdZYbeikh[ 7\j[h Yecfb[j_ed e\ j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[" j^[ _djhWZkhWb ifWY[ _i Óbb[Z m_j^ H_d][h iebkj_ed$ ?d ceij YWi[i" W mWj[hj_]^j ZkhWbYbeikh[_i_cfeii_Xb[1^em[l[h"Ód[ikjkh[iYWdX[ki[Z je h[#Wffhen_cWj[ j^[ feij[h_eh \eiiW ZkhW$ 7 feijef[hWj_l[ 9I< Ói# jkbWYWd[\\[Yj_l[boX[Wle_Z[Zm_j^WÔWfe\j[cfehWbckiYb[eh \WiY_W"eYYbkZ_d]j^[XedoZ[\[Yje\j^[_dj[hdWbWkZ_jehoYWdWb$?d ej^[h YWi[i" WXZec_dWb \Wj j_iik[ i^ekbZ X[ fbWY[Z [njhWZkhWbbo$ J^[Xed[ÔWf_iÓn[Zm_j^Wj_jWd_kcfbWj[$7\j[hÓdWbl[h_ÓYWj_ed e\^[ceijWi_i"j^[ckiYkbWhWdZikXYkjWd[ekibWo[hiWh[Ybei[Z m_j^ _dj[hhkfj[Z ikjkh[i WdZ j^[ ia_d m_j^ hkdd_d] eh _dj[h# hkfj[Z ikjkh[i$ :k[ je j^[ icWbb ia_d _dY_i_ed WdZ dedjhWkcWj_Y ie\jj_iik[Z_ii[Yj_ed"WikYj_edZhW_d_idejd[Y[iiWhoWdZWbiedej h[Yecc[dZ[ZjeWle_ZWfeijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i ?dYehh[Yj fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d] WdZ fei_j_ed_d] e\ j^[ fWj_[dj m_j^_dWZ[gkWj[[nfeikh[e\j^[b[i_ed$ ?d`khojej^[fh[Wkh_YkbWhd[khelWiYkbWhijhkYjkh[i$ ?d iec[ YWi[i" ef[d_d] e\ cWije_Z Y[bbi _i kdWle_ZWXb[ Zkh_d] YhWd_ejeco$J^[ef[d_d]i^ekbZX[Ybei[Zc[j_YkbekibojeWle_Z feijef[hWj_l[dWieb_gkehh^[WWdZc[d_d]_j_i$ ?d`khojej^[ZkhWcWj[hZkh_d]YhWd_ejeco"[if[Y_Wbbo_d[bZ[hbo fWj_[dji$Dei[l[h[i[gk[bW[1^em[l[h"[njhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_edYWd X[Yecfb_YWj[Z$7\j[hYecfb[j_ede\ j^[_djhWYhWd_WbfheY[Zkh[" j^[ZkhWckijX[Ybei[Zm_j^_dj[hhkfj[Zehhkdd_d]ikjkh[i$ :WcW][ je j^[ j[cfehWb beX[ Zk[ je ifWjkbW fh[iikh[$ M_j^ WZ[gkWj[ fei_j_ed_d] e\ j^[ fWj_[dj WdZ [Whbo h[celWb e\ 9I< j^hek]^ j^[ Yehj_YWb ikXWhWY^de_Z ifWY[ eh j^hek]^ j^[ fh[l_# ekibo _di[hj[Z bkcXWh ZhW_dW][" j[cfehWb Yecfh[ii_ed YWd X[ c_d_c_p[Z$ ?d`khojej^[b[ii[heh]h[Wj[hikf[hÓY_Wbf[jheiWbd[hl[iZkh_d] ZkhWb [b[lWj_ed Wbj^ek]^ m_j^ekj i[l[h[ d[khebe]_YWb Yedi[# gk[dY[$ ?d`khojej^[ikf[h_ehi[c_Y_hYkbWhYWdWbYWki_d]l[ij_XkbWhZ_i# jkhXWdY[m_j^j[cfehWhodWki[WWdZlec_j_d]$9eY^b[Wh_d`kho YWki[ifeijef[hWj_l[_fi_bWj[hWbWdWYki_i$ ?d`khojej^[\WY_Wbd[hl[m_j^_dj^[?79m_j^ikXi[gk[djfeijef# [hWj_l[\WY_WbfWbio$ ?d`kh_[ijedkc[hekid[hl[iWdZl[ii[bi_dj^[c_ZZb[WdZfei# j[h_ehYhWd_Wb\eiiWZkh_d]ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_edYWki_d]feijef[hW# j_l[d[khebe]_YWbZ[ÓY_ji$
'+,
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r ?79lWh_Wj_ed
?dWZ[gkWj[ _djhWYhWd_Wb ^[ceijWi_i m_j^ feijef[hWj_l[ h[# Xb[[Z_d]$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ ZkhWb Ybeikh[ m_j^ feijef[hWj_l[ 9I< ÓijkbW$ ?d j^[ YWi[e\ef[d[ZcWije_ZY[bbi"feijef[hWj_l[dWieb_gkehh^[WYWd eYYkh$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ ^[ceijWi_i Zkh_d] mekdZ Ybeikh[ m_j^ ie\j j_iik[ ^[cWjecW$
<_]$)$)$(/
<_]$)$)$)&
J_fiWdZjh_Yai JWa[j_c[\ehfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]$ J^[^[WZi^ekbZX[hejWj[ZYW$.&\ehWZ[gkWj[l_ikWb_pWj_ede\ j^[ ?79 <_]$ )$)$(/$ 9ecfWh[Z m_j^ j^[ Wdj[h_eh WdZ feij[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb WffheWY^[i" j^[ [njhWZkhWb ceZ_ÓYWj_ed h[gk_h[i b[iibWj[heÔ[n_edWdZceh[[b[lWj_edZkh_d]fWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] <_]$)$)$)&$
<_]$)$)$)'
CWa[ YWh[\kb eh_[djWj_ed Xo WffheWY^#fbWdd_d]0 eii[eki WdZ d[khelWiYkbWh ijhkYjkh[i1 fbWY[c[dj e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco1 ia_d _dY_i_ed$ 7ijhW_]^jia_d_dY_i_edi^ekbZX[f[h\ehc[Z`kijWdj[h_ehjej^[ [Wh"fh[i[hl_d]j^[ikf[hÓY_Wbj[cfehWbWhj[hoWdZj^[Wkh_Ykbe# j[cfehWbd[hl[$ <_]$)$)$)(
J^[ j[cfehWb \WiY_W i^ekbZ X[ _dY_i[Z _d W O#i^Wf[Z \Wi^_ed m_j^ j^[ XWiWb b[WÔ[j Z[Ô[Yj[Z el[h j^[ po]ecWj_Y WhY^$ 7\j[h Yecfb[j_d]j^[_djhWYhWd_WbfheY[Zkh["j^_iÔWfYWdWbieX[ki[Z \eh ZkhWb Ybeikh[$ J^[ h[cW_d_d] jme ÔWfi Wh[ h[jhWYj[Z X_bWj# [hWbbo fhel_Z_d] WZ[gkWj[ [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ j[cfehWb ckiYb[ <_]$)$)$)'$
<_]$)$)$))
?dceijYWi[i"Xbkdjcel[c[dje\j^[j[cfehWbckiYb[_ifeii_# Xb[m_j^ekj_dY_i_ede\j^[ckiYb[[nfei_d]j^[igkWcekiXed[ <_]$)$)$)($ IjW][ie\YhWd_ejeco<_]$)$)$))0'$Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_ed1($j[c# feheXWiWbYkjj_d]fWhWbb[b je j^[ikfhWcWije_ZYh[ijWdZpo]e# cWj_Y WhY^1 )$ iWm_d] _d W Ykhl[Z" i[c_bkdWh \Wi^_ed \hec j^[ Xkhh^eb[jej^[Wdj[h_eh[Z][e\j^[fh[l_ekiYhWd_ejecob_d[$
'+-
IkXj[cfehWbWffheWY^ r ?79lWh_Wj_ed
9h[Wj_d]j^[YhWd_ejeco"W^[_]^je\($+Ycc[Wikh[Z\hecj^[ po]ecWj_Y WhY^ _i d[Y[iiWho je ]W_d kd^_dZ[h[Z WYY[ii je j^[ _dj[hdWbWkZ_jehoYWdWb<_]$)$)$)*$
<_]$)$)$)*
:h_bb_d]e\j^[_dd[h[Z][e\j^[j[cfeheXWiWbYhWd_ejecoXehZ[h W\j[hh[celWbe\j^[Xed[ÔWf_i_cfehjWdjje\WY_b_jWj[_djhWZk# hWbl_ikWb_pWj_edWdZcWd_fkbWj_ed<_]$)$)$)+$ ?\_dlWi_ede\j^[cWije_ZY[bbiYekbZdejX[Wle_Z[Z"c[j_Ykbeki Ybeikh[_ih[gk_h[Z$J^[ef[d[ZY[bbii^ekbZX[Ybei[Zm_j^Xed[ mWn1WÔWfe\j^[\WiY_Wehj^[j[cfehWbckiYb[YWdWbieX[ki[Z \ehj^_ifkhfei[<_]$)$)$),$
<_]$)$)$)+
<eh c_d_c_p_d] Yecfh[ii_ed e\ j^[ j[cfehWb beX[" j^[ Yehj_YWb ikXWhWY^de_ZifWY[i^ekbZX[ef[d[ZW\j[hb_c_j[ZZkhWbef[d# _d]$ 7bj[hdWj_l[bo" fh[ef[hWj_l[ bkcXWh ZhW_dW][ YWd X[ ki[Z <_]$)$)$)-$
<_]$)$)$),
J^[ Yekhi[ e\ j^[ _dj[hdWb WkZ_jeho YWdWb YWd X[ WYYkhWj[bo Z[Ód[Zki_d]j^[ÇXbk[b_d[Èj[Y^d_gk[<_]$)$)$).$ J^[[njhWZkhWbWffheWY^jej^[?79YWdX[ikYY[ii\kbbo[nj[dZ[Z W\j[hikXj[cfehWbZkhWbef[d_d]WdZZ_l_i_ede\j^[j[djeh_kc$ 7dWZZ_j_edWbh[celWbe\j^[f[jhekiWf[ne\\[him_Z[[nfeikh[ e\j^[c_ZZb[WdZfeij[h_ehYhWd_Wb\eiiW[$
<_]$)$)$)-
?\feii_Xb["j^[ZkhWbef[d_d]i^ekbZX[Ybei[Zm_j^mWj[hj_]^j ikjkh[i$ J^[ ZkhWb Ybeikh[ m_j^_d j^[ feij[h_eh \eiiW YWd X[ WY^_[l[Zm_j^WckiYb[ÔWfehm_j^WXZec_dWb\Wjj_iik[$ ?d j^[ YWi[ e\ feijef[hWj_l[ dWieb_gkehh^W[" W bkcXWh ZhW_d i^ekbZX[ki[Z$ J^[Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_edYWdX[Ybei[Zm_j^Wj_jWd_kcfbWj[ <_]$)$)$)/$
<_]$)$)$).
=IFD II9 ?79
JeWle_ZWfeijef[hWj_l[9I<b[Wa"j^[ki[e\WikYj_edZhW_d_idej h[Yecc[dZ[Z$ <_]$)$)$)/
'+.
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
*$& H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^ >_ijehoe\j^[bWj[hWbikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^[i J^[ikXeYY_f_jWbc[j^eZe\]W_d_d]WYY[iijej^[bWj[hWbfeij[h_eh \eiiW WdZ Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[ Wd]b[ mWi Óhij ki[Z ikYY[ii\kbbo Xo I_h 9^Whb[i 8WbbWdY[ _d './*" m^e ef[hWj[Z ed W ÇÓXheiWhYecW e\ j^[ c[d_d][iÈ WjjWY^[Z je j^[ ZkhWb Yel[h_d] e\ j^[ feij[h_eh ikh\WY[e\j^[f[jhekiXed[$J^[ef[hWj_edmWiYWhh_[Zekj_djme ijW][iWdZj^[jkcehmWi[njhWYj[ZXoÓd][hZ_ii[Yj_edX[jm[[d j^[ i[di_j_l[ d[khelWiYkbWh ijhkYjkh[i$ J^[ fWj_[dj ikhl_l[Z m_j^ h[i_ZkWbjh_][c_dWbWdZ\WY_Wbd[hl[_d`khoQ8WbbWdY['./*S$ <_]$*$&$' ?d '/&)" AhWki[ Z[iYh_X[Z W kd_bWj[hWb [nfeikh[\ehiakbbXWi[jkcehiWdZ^_idWc[^Wi X[[d _Z[dj_Ó[Z m_j^ j^[ kd_bWj[hWb ikXeYY_f_jWb WffheWY^" h[]WhZb[ii e\ j^[ cWdo ceZ_ÓYWj_edi j^Wj \ebbem[Z$ Dej[ j^[ fbWY[c[dj e\ j^[ YhWd_# ejeco [nfei_d] j^[ jhWdil[hiWb WdZ i_]ce_ZWb i_dki$
D[l[hj^[b[ii"j^[ikh]_YWbjh[Wjc[dje\Y[h[X[bbWhWdZ[njhWY[h[X[bbWh jkcehi mWi Y^WhWYj[h_p[Z Xo W l[ho ^_]^ cehjWb_jo hWj[ Zk[ je j^[ hek]^ WdZ YhkZ[ fheY[Zkh[i ki[Z$ :kh_d] j^[ [Whbo f[h_eZ e\ d[kheikh][ho" ej^[h Wjj[cfji Wj h[celWb e\ ifWY[#eYYkfo_d] b[i_edim_j^_dj^[bWj[hWbfeij[h_eh\eiiWm[h[iekdikYY[ii\kbj^Wj ikh][edi m[h[ h[bkYjWdj je kdZ[hjWa[ j^[i[ ef[hWj_edi$ ?d './)" 7bb[dIjWhhfkXb_i^[Z'+YWi[ie\Y[h[X[bbWhjkcehim_j^edboed[ _dijWdY[ e\ Yecfb[j[ jkceh h[celWb WdZ d[khebe]_YWb h[Yel[ho e\ j^[ fWj_[dj$ Ed WYYekdj e\ j^[i[ \hkijhWj_d] h[ikbji" >[hcWdd Eff[d^[_cYbWii_Ó[ZY[h[X[bbWhb[i_ediWi_def[hWXb[WdZh[fehj[ZW ceh[j^Wd-&cehjWb_johWj[QIjWhh'./)"Eff[d^[_c'/&(S$ 9edY[hd_d] [njhWY[h[X[bbWh b[i_edi e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[ Wd]b[ ikY^ Wi WYekij_Y d[kh_decWi WdZ c[d_d][ecWi" j^[ fh[lW_b_d] cehjWb_jo \eh Wd ef[hWj_ed _d j^[ ^WdZi e\ ceij ia_bb[Z ikh][edi hWd][Z \hec +. Xo L_Yjeh >ehib[o je .)$. Xo <[Zeh AhWki[ Wi fh[i[dj[Z Wj j^[ ?dj[hdWj_edWb D[khebe]_YWb 9ed]h[ii _d '/')$ IkY^\W_bkh[i^Wl[X[[dWjjh_Xkj[Zjei[l[hWb\WYjehi_dYbkZ_d]j^[ kdZ[l[bef[Zfh[ef[hWj_l[Z_W]deij_Yjeebi"b_c_j[Zefj_YWbYedjheb" WdZ j^[ ki[ e\ Ód][hi _d [dkYb[Wj_d] j^[ d[efbWic$ AhWki[ Wbie WZleYWj[Z W Xbkdj Ód][h Z_ii[Yj_ed YWki_d] WiieY_Wj[Z _d`kho je i[l[hWbi[di_j_l[d[khelWiYkbWhijhkYjkh[i<_]$*$&$'$>_iYhkZ[ikh# ]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[ h[ikbj[Z _d W cehjWb_jo hWj[ hWd]_d] \hec ,- je ..QAhWki['/')S$
<_]$*$&$( 9ki^_d]Êief[hWj_ed\ehWffheWY^_d] Wd WYekij_Y d[kh_decW$ >_i X_bWj[hWb [nfeikh[ j^hek]^ W YheiiXem _dY_i_ed Wbbem[Z [\\[Yj_l[ Z[Yecfh[ii_ed e\ j^[ feij[h_eh \eiiW$ Dej[ j^[ fkdYjkh[ e\ j^[ b[\j bWj[hWb l[djh_Yb[ Wle_Z_d] _dYh[Wi[Z_djhWYhWd_Wbfh[iikh[Zkh_d]ikh][ho$
7jj^[X[]_dd_d]e\j^[(&j^Y[djkho"ikh][ediiek]^jWiW\[WdZ b[ii_dlWi_l[WffheWY^jej^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b["[if[Y_Wbbo\eh h[celWbe\X[d_]dWYekij_Yd[kh_decWi<_]$*$&$($>Whl[o9ki^_d]" _d'/&+"Z[iYh_X[ZWX_bWj[hWb[nfeikh[e\j^[Y[h[X[bbWh^[c_if^[h[i
'+/
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
j^hek]^WÇYheiiXem_dY_i_edÈh[ikbj_d]_dWle_ZWdY[e\XhW_dij[c Yecfh[ii_ed Zkh_d] ikh][ho$ Ed j^[ XWi_i e\ ^_i [nf[h_[dY[ ed YWZWl[hZ_ii[Yj_ed"9^Whb[i>$_i Óhij [dYekdj[h m_j^ Wd WYekij_Y d[kh_decW mWi _d '/&,$ BWj[h ^[ Z[iYh_X[Z j^_i \hkijhWj_d][nf[h_[dY[Wij^[Ç]beecoYehd[h_dd[khebe]_Yikh][hoÈ$ >em[l[h"ki_d]^_iZ[l[bef[Zj[Y^d_gk[i_d'.-fWj_[djiik\\[h_d] \hec WYekij_Y d[kh_decWi" ^[ mWi WXb[ je bem[h j^[ fh[l_ekibo kdWYY[fjWXb[ cehjWb_jo hWj[ je W ceh[ h[WiedWXb[ b[l[b e\ ')$ >em[l[h" Wd WZZ_j_edWb *& e\ fWj_[dji [l[djkWbbo Z_[Z m_j^_d + je'&o[WhiX[YWki[e\ikXi[gk[djjkcehh[Ykhh[dY[W\j[hikXjejWb h[i[Yj_edQ9ki^_d]'/)(S$ ?d '/'-" j^[ iWc[ o[Wh _d m^_Y^ 9ki^_d] fh[i[dj[Z ^_i YbWii_YWb cede]hWf^edØJkcehie\j^[D[hlki7Ykij_YkiÈ"MWbj[h;$:WdZo" _cfh[ii[ZXoj^[fej[dj_WbYkhWX_b_joe\X[d_]djkcehi"Z[iYh_X[ZW ceh[W]]h[ii_l[ikh]_YWbWffheWY^\ehjejWbh[celWb<_]$*$&$)$>_i WffheWY^Yedi_ij[Ze\Wkd_bWj[hWbikXeYY_f_jWbYhWd_[Yjeco"_dj[hdWb jkcehZ[Yecfh[ii_edWdZYecfb[j[h[celWbe\j^[[dYWfikbWj[Z d[kh_decWQ:WdZo'/(+S$?d'/*'":WdZofkXb_i^[Z^_ii[h_[ie\*, fWj_[dji m_j^ W cehjWb_jo hWj[ e\ ''1 ^em[l[h" Wbb fWj_[dji beij j^[_h^[Wh_d]edj^[ef[hWj[Zi_Z[WdZ/+^WZWdWZZ_j_edWb\WY_Wb fWhWboi_iQ:WdZo'/*'S$?d'/)/"=_bX[hj>ehhWn"Wdej^[he\9ki^_d]Éi Wii_ijWdji"WdZ@Wc[iB$Feff[dh[fehj[Zj^[_hh[ikbjim_j^W+#o[Wh cehjWb_jo hWj[ e\ '.1 ^em[l[h" ,+ e\ j^[ ikhl_l_d] _dZ_l_ZkWbi m[h[d[khebe]_YWbbo_djWYjW\j[hYecfb[j[h[celWbe\j^[WYekij_Y d[kh_decWi Q>ehhWn é Feff[d '/)/S$ ?d >[hX[hj Eb_l[YhedWÊi i[h_[i" m^_Y^ jejWbb[Z *'+ YWi[i" Yecfb[j[ h[Yel[ho e\ j^[ \WY_Wb d[hl[mWieXi[hl[Z_d(/m_j^icWbbjkcehiYecfWh[Zm_j^edbo -m_j^bWh][d[kh_decWiQEb_l[YhedW'/*/S$;$Ij[f^[di=khZ`_Wd WdZBkZm_]@$A[cf[h[fehj[Zl[hoi_c_bWhh[ikbji"WffheWY^_d]j^[ Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[j^hek]^Wkd_bWj[hWbikXeYY_f_jWb[nfeikh[ <_]$*$&$*"*$&$+Q=khZ`_Wd'/,*"A[cf['/-&S$ 7 jh[c[dZeki Z[l[befc[dj _d fh[ef[hWj_l[ Wii[iic[dj WdZ j^[ h[lebkj_edWho ki[ e\ c_Yhed[kheikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[i W\j[h _djhe# ZkYj_ed e\ j^[ ikh]_YWb c_YheiYef[ h[ikbj[Z _d W cWha[Z _cfhel[#
',&
<_]$*$&$) Kd_bWj[hWbWYY[iijeWdWYekij_YjkcehZ[iYh_X[Z Xo:WdZo_d^_iWhj_Yb[Ç7def[hWj_ed\ehj^[jejWbh[celWb e\ Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[ WYekij_Y jkcehiÈ" fkXb_i^[Z _d '/(+$ >_iWffheWY^_bbkijhWj[ZÇj^[c[j^eZXom^_Y^jhWYj_eded j^[[nYWlWj[ZYWfikb[e\j^[bem[hfeb[ijh_fij^[h[cW_d# _d] jkceh\hec j^[XhW_dij[cWdZXh_d]i_djel_[m j^[ l[ii[bim^_Y^Yheii\hecj^[XhW_dij[cÈ$
<_]$*$&$* =khZ`_WdÊikd_bWj[hWbikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^je WY[h[X[bbefedj_d[jkcehW\j[hfWhj_Wbh[i[Yj_ede\j^[Y[h# [X[bbWh^[c_if^[h[$Dej[j^[ki[e\Wd_bbkc_dWj[Zh[jhWY# jehe\Wjof[ik]][ij[ZXo
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
c[dj_dfeijef[hWj_l[h[ikbji$Ki_d]WjhWdic[WjWbh[jhei_]ce_ZWb WffheWY^" HeX[hj M$ HWdZ WdZ J^[eZeh[ Akhp[ h[fehj[Z _d j^[_h i[h_[i e\ '*& fWj_[dji ef[hWj[Z X[jm[[d '/,* WdZ '/.&" '&& fh[i[hlWj_ed e\ j^[ \WY_Wb d[hl[ _d YWi[i m_j^ icWbb WYekij_Y jkcehi QHWdZ é Akhp[ '/.&S$ 7bie ej^[h f_ed[[hi e\ ceZ[hd c_Yhed[kheikh][ho fkXb_i^[Z j^[_h Óhij h[ikbji e\ WYekij_Y d[kh_decWief[hWj[Zm_j^WbWj[hWbikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^QOWiWh]_b '/-,"Aeei'/-,"IWc__'/.'S$
<_]$*$&$+ CWYheikh]_YWbh[celWbe\WdWYekij_Yd[kh_# decW"WiZ[cedijhWj[ZXoA[cf[_d'/-&$Dej[j^[YWh[# \kbZ_ii[Yj_ede\j^[\WY_Wbd[hl[$
7jj^Wjj_c["dejedbod[kheikh][ediXkjWbieejebe]_YWbikh][edi m[h[ \Wc_b_Wh m_j^ ef[hWj_l[ h[celWb e\ WYekij_Y d[kh_decWi$ ?d '/,." M_bb_Wc >eki[ h[fehj[Z ')) YWi[i _d m^_Y^ W bWj[hWb ikXeYY_f_jWbjhWdibWXoh_dj^_d[WffheWY^mWiki[Z\ehceZ[hWj[WdZ bWh][ jkcehi$ K]e <_iY^" Wdej^[h fhefed[dj e\ j^[ c_Yheejebe]_Y j[Y^d_gk[" fkXb_i^[Z ^_i h[ikbji ki_d] fh[# WdZ h[jhei_]ce_ZWb WffheWY^[i_dj^[[Whbo'/-&iQ>eki['/,."<_iY^'/-&S$ J^[ bWj[hWb ikXeYY_f_jWb WffheWY^ mWi Wbie ki[Z Xo j^[ WXel[# c[dj_ed[ZWkj^ehi\ehej^[hifWY[#eYYkfo_d]b[i_edie\j^[bWj[hWb feij[h_eh \eiiW ikY^ Wi c[d_d][ecWi" [f_Z[hce_Zi" Y^ehZecWi" Y^edZhecWi$ 8o Z_\\[h[dj lWh_Wj_edi" b[i_edi e\ j^[ j[djeh_kc QIWc__ '/.'S" f[jheki Xed[ QOWiWh]_b '/.&S" Yb_lki Q>WakXW '/--S" WdZ\ehWc[dcW]dkcQF[hd[Ypao'/.,Sm[h[ikYY[ii\kbbojh[Wj[Z$
<_]$*$&$, :WdZoÊikd_bWj[hWb[nfeikh[e\ j^[Ó\j^d[hl[$ ?dj^_iYWi["WYWkZWbbeefe\j^[I97YWki[Zi[l[h[j_YZek# bekh[kn$
7
8
?d '/)*" MWbj[h ;$ :WdZo feijkbWj[Z j^Wj Whj[h_Wb Yecfh[ii_ed WdZ Z_ijehj_ed e\ j^[ jh_][c_dWb d[hl[ c_]^j X[ j^[ YWki[ e\ j^[ jh_][c_dWb d[khWb]_W Q:WdZo '/)*S$ ;cfbeo_d] W kd_bWj[hWb ikXeY# Y_f_jWbYhWd_[Yjeco"^[[nfei[Zj^[i[diehoheeje\j^[jh_][c_dWb d[hl[Wjj^[heej[djhoped[_djej^[fedi<_]$*$&$,$>[Z[iYh_X[Z
9
<_]$*$&$- @Wdd[jjWÊic_Yheikh]_YWbZ[Yecfh[ii_ede\j^[i[l[dj^d[hl[YWki_d]^[c_\WY_WbifWic$Dej[j^[bWj[hWbZ[YkX_jkiehie#YWbb[ZfWhaX[dY^ fei_j_ed[nfei_d]j^[b[\jh[jheWkh_YkbWhWh[W7$7\j[hf[h\ehc_d]Wb_c_j[Zh[jhei_]ce_ZWbYhWd_ejeco8"j^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[mWiWffheWY^[Z ki_d]c_Yheikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[i$?djhWef[hWj_l[c_Yhef^eje]hWf^9i^em_d]j^[bem[hYhWd_Wbd[hl[i$Dej[j^[fheij^[i_i\X[jm[[dj^[\WY_Wbd[hl[ [WdZl[hj[XhWbWhj[hoYWY^_[l_d][\\[Yj_l[lWiYkbWhZ[Yecfh[ii_ed$
','
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
,,e\^_i('+fWj_[djiWi^Wl_d]lWiYkbWhWXdehcWb_j_[i_dh[bWj_edje j^[i[diehoheejWdZZ[cedijhWj[Zj^[ikf[h_ehY[h[X[bbWhWhj[hoWi W\\[Yj_d]j^[d[hl[_dceh[j^Wd)&e\^_ifWj_[djim^eik\\[h[Z \hecjh_][c_dWbd[khWb]_W$J^[lWiYkbWhYecfh[ii_edj^[eho\W_b[Z je ]W_d WYY[fjWdY[ Wj j^Wj j_c[1 ^em[l[h" M$ @Wc[i =WhZd[h _d '/+/ Y_j[Z :WdZoÊi fh_eh eXi[hlWj_edi WdZ ik]][ij[Z j^Wj j^[ c[Y^Wd_YWb\WYjehYekbZX[_cfehjWdj_dYWki_d]i[l[h[d[khWb]_W Q=WhZd[h '/+/S$ 7i W h[ikbj" ^[ Z[l[bef[Z j^[ d[khelWiYkbWh Z[Yecfh[ii_ed ef[hWj_ed \eh j_Y Zekbekh[kn$ J^_i ef[hWj_ed mWi \khj^[hh[Ód[ZXoF[j[h@$@Wdd[jjWWdZHeX[hjM$HWdZ_d'/,, <_]$*$&$- Q@Wdd[jjW é HWdZ '/,-S$ ?d '/,(" =WhZd[h Z[iYh_X[Z W d[khelWiYkbWh Yecfh[ii_ed c[Y^Wd_ic Wj j^[ XhW_d ij[c [n_j ped[e\j^[\WY_Wbd[hl[Wij^[ceij\h[gk[djYWki[e\^[c_\WY_Wb ifWic$?d^_ieh_]_dWbef[hWj_ed"=WhZd[hfbWY[ZWicWbbigkWh[e\ ][b\eWcX[jm[[dj^[Yecfh[ii_d]l[ii[bWdZj^[\WY_Wbd[hl["l_WW h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^Q=WhZd[h'/,(S$;j_ebe]oWdZc_Yheikh]_YWb jh[Wjc[dje\j^[^[c_\WiY_WbifWicmWiWbieZ[iYh_X[ZXo@Wdd[jjW WdZYemeha[hiQ@Wdd[jjW'/-&"'/--S$ J^[ Óhij ikYY[ii\kb ef[hWj_ed ed Wd Wd[khoic e\ j^[ l[hj[XhWb Whj[hoeh_jiXhWdY^[il_WikXeYY_f_jWbYhWd_ejecomWif[h\ehc[Z Xo>[dhoIY^mWhjp_d'/*,WdZh[fehj[Z_d'/*.QIY^mWhjp'/*.S$ J^[cW`eh_joe\YWi[im[h[jh[Wj[ZXokd_bWj[hWbYhWd_[Yjecoki_d] Wi_jj_d]ehi[c_fhed[fWhaX[dY^fei_j_edWiZ[iY_X[ZXo9^Whb[i :hWa[WdZMWbbWY[>WcXo<_]$*$&$.Q:hWa['/,+">WcXo'/,/S$ ?d '/.*" OWiWh]_b Z[iYh_X[Z W fWhWc[Z_Wd _d\hWY[h[X[bbWh a[o^eb[ WffheWY^ \eh Wd[khoici e\ j^[ feij[h_eh _d\[h_eh Y[h[X[bbWh Whj[ho _d j^[ Óhij lebkc[ e\ ^_i f_ed[[h_d] meha ØC_Yhed[kheikh][hoÈ <_]$*$&$/QOWiWh]_b'/.*S$
<_]$*$&$. FWhaX[dY^fei_j_ed_d]e\WfWj_[djjh[Wj[Z\eh Wd Wd[khoic e\ j^[ l[hj[XhWb Whj[ho$ Dej[ j^[ ie#YWbb[Z ^eYa[oij_Yaia_d_dY_i_ed"fkXb_i^[ZXo:hWa[_d'/-/$
7
8
<_]$*$&$/ OWiWh]_bÊi fWhWc[Z_Wd _d\hWY[h[X[bbWh WYY[ii \eh W icWbb Wd[khoic e\ j^[ F?97" Z[iYh_X[Z _d ^_i Xeea ÇC_Yhed[kheikh][hoÈ fkXb_i^[Z _d '/.*$ Dej[ j^[ i_jj_d] fei_j_ed e\ j^[ fWj_[dj 7$ J^hek]^ j^[ h[jhei_]ce_ZWb YhWd_ejeco"OWiWh]_bWffheWY^[Zj^[Wd[khoic_dWc_d_# cWbbo _dlWi_l[ cWdd[h Wle_Z_d] YhkZ[ h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbWh^[c_if^[h[8$
',(
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
Ki[e\j^[a[o^eb[YedY[fj_dj^[bWj[hWbikXeYY_f_jWb" h[jhecWije_ZWbWffheWY^[iWdZ][d[hWbWdWjec_YWb YedijhkYj_ede\j^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[ 7iZ[iYh_X[ZWXel["j^[ikh]_YWbekjYec[W\j[hbWj[hWbikXeYY_f_jWb WffheWY^[i _cfhel[Z cWha[Zbo m_j^ j^[ ki[ e\ ceZ[hd c_Yhe# d[kheikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[i$ >em[l[h" j^[ Óhij h[fehji Wbh[WZo h[Wb# _p[Z j^[ lWbk[ e\ h[jhecWije_ZWb [nfeikh[i ki_d] j^[ YedY[fj e\ a[o^eb[ikh][ho$:k[jej^[icWbbikh\WY[e\j^[ikXeYY_f_jWbWh[W" Wd [nj[dZ[Z YhWd_ejeco WdZ ZkhWb ef[d_d] YekbZ dej X[ ki[Z1 d[l[hj^[b[ii" ikh][edi m[h[ WXb[ je el[hl_[m Wbceij j^[ [dj_h[ feij[h_eh\eiiW$ ?d Yh[Wj_d] j^[i[ b_c_j[Z bWj[hWb ikXeYY_f_jWb" h[jhei_]ce_ZWb WffheWY^[i"iec[WdWjec_YWbY^WhWYj[h_ij_Yii^ekbZX[Z[iYh_X[Z _dZ[jW_b$
<_]$*$&$'& 7hj_ijÉi ZhWm_d] Z[cedijhWj_d] j^[ Y[h[X[bbe# fedj_d[ Wd]b[ Wi W l_hjkWb fohWc_Z$J^_i l_hjkWb YedijhkY# j_edWbie^[bfijekdZ[hijWdZ^emWdWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[i Wh[Z_ifbWY[Z_dj^[YWi[e\ifWY[#eYYkfo_d]b[i_edim_j^_d j^[feij[h_eh\eiiW$
J^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[_ii_jkWj[ZX[jm[[dj^[feij[h_ehikh# \WY[e\j^[f[jhekij[cfehWbWdZj^[f[jheiWbikh\WY[e\j^[Y[h[# X[bbWh^[c_if^[h[$J^[j^_hZj^hek]^j^[jm[b\j^YhWd_Wbd[hl[iWh[ beYWj[Zd[Whehm_j^_dj^[Wd]kbWhifWY[X[jm[[dj^[jmeb_cXi e\ j^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Óiikh[\ehc[ZXo j^[f[jheiWbY[h[X[bbWh ikh\WY[\ebZ_d]WhekdZj^[fediWdZc_ZZb[Y[h[X[bbWhf[ZkdYb[$ 9ecfWh[Z m_j^ j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh Wh[W" j^[ Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[ Wd]b[ YWdWbieX[Z[Ód[ZWiWfohWc_Z#i^Wf[ZifWY["Xkj_dYb_d[ZWdj[he# c[Z_Wbbom_j^_jiWf[n[nj[dZ_d]jej^[feij[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii WdZj^[XWi[\WY_d]j^[_dd[hikh\WY[e\j^[igkWceiWbfWhje\j^[ j[cfehWbWdZeYY_f_jWbXed[i$J^[ikf[h_ehi_Z[Yehh[ifedZijej^[ h[jhei[bbWhWh[W_dYbkZ_d]j^[9D???WdZj^[_d\[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[ j[djeh_kc" m_j^ j^[ 9D ?L hkdd_d] j^hek]^ _j$J^[ _d\[hec[Z_Wb i_Z[_iYbei[jej^[\ehWc[dcW]dkc"_dYbkZ_d]j^[l[hj[XhWbWhj[ho WdZj^[9DN??$J^[Wdj[h_ehWdZfeij[h_ehi_Z[iWh[h[fh[i[dj[ZXo j^[feij[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[f[jhekiXed[WdZj^[f[jheiWbikh\WY[ e\j^[XhW_dij[cWdZY[h[X[bbkc"h[if[Yj_l[bo$J^[cW`eh_joe\l_jWb ijhkYjkh[i"ikY^Wij^[ikf[h_ehY[h[X[bbWh"Wdj[h_eh_d\[h_eh"feij[h_eh _d\[h_ehY[h[X[bbWhWhj[h_[i"WdZj^[j^_hZjejm[b\j^YhWd_Wbd[hl[i" Wh[YedÓd[Z_dj^[c[Z_Wbj^_hZe\j^[fohWc_Z<_]$*$&$'&$ 7ffheWY^_d] j^[ WdWjec_YWb ijhkYjkh[i e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbefed# j_d[Wd]b["Z_\\[h[dj jWh][jh[]_edih[gk_h[Z_\\[h[djlWh_Wj_edi_d j^[ i^Wf[" fbWY[c[dj WdZ i_p[ e\ j^[ h[jhei_]ce_ZWb YhWd_ejeco <_]$*$&$''$
',)
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
<_]$*$&$'' Ikf[h_eh"Y[djhWbWdZYWkZWblWh_Wdjie\j^[h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^$J^[Z_\\[h[djlWh_Wj_edi[WY^h[gk_h[WZ_\\[h[djf[h\ehcWdY[e\j^[ YhWd_ejeco"ZkhWbef[d_d]WdZWZ_\\[h[djfbWY[c[dje\j^[Y[h[X[bbWhh[jhWYjeh$
Ikf[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
9[djhWblWh_Wj_ed
9WkZWblWh_Wj_ed
JhWdil[hiWbi_dki I_]ce_Zi_dki Ikf[h_ehf[jheiWbi_dki 7d]b[X[jm[[dj^[feij[h_eh ikh\WY[e\j^[f[jhekiXed[WdZj^[ j[djeh_kc J[djeh_Wb_dY_ikhW Kff[hf[jheiWbWdZbWj[hWb j[djeh_Wbikh\WY[e\j^[Y[h[X[bbkc Feij[hebWj[hWbikh\WY[e\j^[ c[i[dY[f^Wbed 9D???"9D?L"9DL"9DL? 9DL??"9DL??? 8Wi_bWhWf[n"_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi F97"I97 F[jheiWbl[_de\:WdZo
JhWdil[hiWbi_dki Feij[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[ f[jhekiXed[ ?79 F[jheiWbikh\WY[e\j^[Y[h[X[bbkc
JhWdil[hiWbi_dki Feij[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[f[jhekiXed[ WdZYhWd_eY[hl_YWb`kdYj_ed <ehWc[dcW]dkc @k]kbWh\ehWc[d F[jheiWbWdZikXeYY_f_jWbikh\WY[ e\j^[Y[h[X[bbkc Feij[hebWj[hWbikh\WY[e\j^[ c[ZkbbWeXbed]WjW 9DL??"9DL???"9D?N"9DN 9DN?"9DN?? 87"l[hj[XheXWi_bWh`kdYj_ed"L7 F?97"_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi 8eY^ZWb[aÉiY^ehe_Zfb[nkie\j^[ \ekhj^l[djh_Yb[
JWXb[*$&$' 7dWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[i[nfei[ZXoZ_\\[h[djlWh_Wj_edie\j^[bWj[hWbikXeYY_f_jWb"h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^$
',*
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
<eheXi[hlWj_ede\j^[kff[hd[khelWiYkbWhYecfb[n"j^[ikf[h_eh lWh_Wj_ed i^ekbZ X[ f[h\ehc[Z$ J^[ YhWd_ejeco _i fbWY[Z Wj j^[ jhWdi_j_ede\j^[jhWdil[hi[i_dki_djej^[i_]ce_Zi_dkiWdZj^[ i_p[e\j^[jh_Wd]kbWhYhWd_ejecoi^ekbZX[YW$'&je(&cc$J^[ ZkhWbef[d_d]i^ekbZWbbemiW\[Z_ii[Yj_ed_dj^[Wd]b[X[jm[[d j[djeh_kcWdZj^[feij[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[f[jhekiXed[$;nfei_d] j^[jh_][c_dWbd[hl["j^[ifWjkbW_ifbWY[ZfWhWbb[bjej^[ikf[h_eh f[jheiWbi_dki$ <eh [nfeikh[ e\ b[i_edi e\ j^[ c_Zfehj_ed e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbefed# j_d[ Wd]b[ ikY^ Wi WYekij_Y d[kh_decWi" j^[ YhWd_ejeco i^ekbZ X[fbWY[ZX[bem j^[ jhWdil[hi[i_dki`kijc[Z_Wb je j^[i_]ce_Z i_dki$J^[i_p[e\j^[YhWd_ejecoWYYehZ_d]jej^_iY[djhWblWh_Wj_ed e\j^[h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^hWd][i\hec'+je(&ccWdZj^[ i^Wf[i^ekbZX[gkWZhWd]kbWh$J^[ZkhWbef[d_d]i^ekbZX[Zed[ _dWYkhl[Z\Wi^_edm_j^_jiXWi[jemWhZjej^[i_]ce_Zi_dki$J^[ XhW_difWjkbW_ifbWY[ZfWhWbb[bjej^[i_]ce_Zi_dkih[jhWYj_d]WdZ fhej[Yj_d]j^[bWj[hWbikh\WY[e\j^[Y[h[X[bbkc$ ;nfei_d] j^[ bem[h d[khelWiYkbWh Yecfb[n WdZ j^[ \ehWc[d cW]dkc" j^[ YhWd_ejeco i^ekbZ X[ f[h\ehc[Z ceh[ YWkZWbbo Wbed] j^[ i_]ce_Z i_dki$J^[ i_p[ e\ j^[ YWkZWb lWh_Wj_ed e\ j^[ YhWd_ejecoi^ekbZX[YW$(&cc"m_j^Wjh_Wd]kbWh\ehcWbbem_d] WdedjhWkcWj_YfbWY[c[dje\j^[XhW_dh[jhWYjeh$
',+
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[ '$FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] FWj_[dj fei_j_ed_d] \eh bWj[hWb ikXeYY_f_jWb" h[jhecWije_ZWb Wf# fheWY^[i_i^_]^boYedjhel[hi_Wb$J^[i_jj_d]"fhed["ikf_d[ehfWha X[dY^ fei_j_edi \eh [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ bWj[hWb feij[h_eh \eiiW e\\[h Z_\\[h[dj WZlWdjW][i WdZ ZhWmXWYai1 ^em[l[h" fei_j_ed_d] e\ j^[ fWj_[djZe[idejfWhj_YkbWhboW\\[Yjj^[ikh]_YWbefj_edie\\[h[ZXo j^[bWj[hWbikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^$ 7YYehZ_d]jeekh[nf[h_[dY["m[ki[j^[i_cfb[ikf_d[fei_j_ed\eh j^[cW`eh_joe\ekhfWj_[dji$:kh_d]ikh][ho"j^[ikh][edh[cW_di Wj j^[ _fi_bWj[hWb i^ekbZ[h e\ j^[ fWj_[dj" fhel_Z_d] Wd [\ÓY_[dj meha_d] fei_j_ed$ 7ZlWdjW][i e\ j^_i fei_j_ed_d] Wh[ j^[ i_c# fb_Y_jo e\ j^[ j[Y^d_gk[ \eh Xej^ ikh][edi WdZ dkhi[i" WdZ Yec# \ehj \eh j^[ fWj_[dj$L[deki WdZ 9I< Yed][ij_ed _i c_d_cWb Yec# fWh[Zm_j^j^[fhed[ehi[c_fhed[fWhaX[dY^fei_j_ediWdZj^[ fei_j_edikffehjij^[]hWl_jo#h[bWj[Zi[b\#h[jhWYj_ede\j^[Y[h[X[b# bWh^[c_if^[h[$7\j[hh[celWbe\9I<"j^[Y[h[X[bbkckikWbboi_dai ifedjWd[ekibo WdZ ikXi[gk[djbo" i_]d_ÓYWdj h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbWh ^[c_if^[h[ _i dej d[Y[iiWho$ >em[l[h" j^_i fei_j_ed# _d] ^Wi Wbie Yedi_Z[hWXb[ b_c_jWj_edi [if[Y_Wbbo _d fWj_[dji m_j^ l[ho i^ehj d[Yai WdZ fhec_d[dj i^ekbZ[hi$ ?d ikY^ YWi[i" j^[ [nY[ii_l[Y[hl_YWbjm_ij_d]h[gk_h[Zm_j^j^_iWffheWY^cWoYWki[ a_da_d] e\ j^[ cW_d Y[hl_YWb l[ii[bi" cWa_d] W fhed[ fei_j_ed d[Y[iiWho$
<_]$*$&$'(
<_]$*$&$')
Ij[f' J^[^[WZ_i[b[lWj[ZWXel[j^[b[l[be\j^[j^ehWn$J^_icWd[klh[ \WY_b_jWj[i WZZ_j_edWbbo j^[ YhWd_Wb l[deki ZhW_dW][ WdZ Z[Yec# fh[ii[ij^[bWhodn"j^[l[dj_bWj_edjkX[WdZj^[cW_dY[hl_YWbl[i# i[bi<_]$*$&$'($ <_]$*$&$'*
Ij[f( J^[^[WZ_iYWh[\kbbohejWj[Z-+Å'&&jej^[YedjhWbWj[hWbi_Z[WdZ j^[_fi_bWj[hWbi^ekbZ[h_i[b[lWj[Zm_j^WYki^_ed<_]$*$&$')$J^[ Z[]h[[ e\ [nWYj hejWj_ed Z[f[dZi ed j^[ fh[Y_i[ beYWj_ed e\ j^[ b[i_ed$:_ii[Yj_d]jemWhZj^[XhW_dij[c"WhejWj_ede\YW$-+_iik\# ÓY_[dj$Edj^[ej^[h^WdZ"_\j^[ikh][ed^Wijeel[hl_[mj^[bWj# [hWbWif[Yje\ j^[feij[h_eh\eiiW_dYbkZ_d] j^[_dj[hdWbWkZ_jeho YWdWbWdZC[Ya[bYWl["j^[^[WZh[gk_h[iWhejWj_ede\ceh[j^Wd /&$Jeiec[Z[]h[["j^[WlW_bWX_b_joe\d[m#][d[hWj_ed"[b[Yjh_YWbbo cejeh_p[Z ef[hWj_d] jWXb[i [dWXb[i h[WZ`kij_d] e\ fWj_[dj fei_#
',,
<_]$*$&$'+
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
j_ed_d]Zkh_d]ikh][hoWdZm_j^WdWZZ_j_edWbj_bj_d]e\j^[ef[h# Wj_d]jWXb["Wd[\\[Yj_l[hejWj_ede\kfje'(&YWdX[WY^_[l[Z$ Ij[f) ?dWj^_hZij[f"j^[^[WZcWoX[Wdj[heÔ[Yj[ZWXekj'&_dehZ[hje WY^_[l[Wd[\ÓY_[djmeha_d]fei_j_ed\ehj^[ikh][edm_j^ekjZ_i# jkhXWdY[e\j^[_fi_bWj[hWbi^ekbZ[h$>em[l[h"if[Y_WbYWh[i^ekbZ X[ jWa[d dej je Yecfh[ii j^[ l[dj_bWj_ed jkX[ WdZ j^[ bWhodn <_]$*$&$'*$ Ij[f* J^[Z[]h[[e\bWj[heÔ[n_edZ[f[dZied j^[[nWYjikh]_YWb jWh][j$ M^[d[nfei_d]j^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[m_j^ijhkYjkh[iWhekdZ j^[ ?79 WYYehZ_d] je j^[ Y[djhWb lWh_Wj_ed e\ j^[ h[jhei_]ce_ZWb WffheWY^" j^[^[WZi^ekbZX[fei_j_ed[Z_d j^[^eh_pedjWbfbWd[ m_j^ekjbWj[heÔ[n_ed$7ffheWY^_d]j^[\ehWc[dcW]dkch[]_ed j^hek]^ j^[ YWkZWb lWh_Wj_ed" j^[ ^[WZ i^ekbZ X[ [b[lWj[Z je YW$ '&Å'+$M^[d[nfei_d]j^[_d\[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[j[djeh_kcWdZ j^[kff[hd[khelWiYkbWhijhkYjkh[ie\j^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[ l_W j^[ ikf[h_eh lWh_Wj_ed e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco" j^[ ^[WZ i^ekbZ X[ c_d_cWbbo Z[fh[ii[Z" Wbbem_d] efj_cWb l_ikWb_pWj_ed Zkh_d] ikh# ][ho<_]$*$&$'+$
7
8
9
:
<_]$*$&$', :[Ód_j_ede\j^[jhWdil[hiWbWdZi_]ce_Zi_dki" WYYehZ_d]jej^[WdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaie\j^[h[jheWkh_Y# kbWh#h[jhecWije_ZWb h[]_ed$ Dej[ j^[ ikfhWcWije_Z Yh[ij 7" Wij[h_ed 8" [nj[hdWb eYY_f_jWb fhejkX[hWdY[ 9 WdZ j^[cWije_ZfheY[ii:$
($7dWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZeh_[djWj_ed <ehfh[ef[hWj_l[eh_[djWj_ed"j^[_cfehjWdjWdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhai e\ j^[ bWj[hWb j[cfeheeYY_f_jWb eii[eki iakbb ikY^ Wi j^[ po]e# cWj_YWhY^"[nj[hdWbWkZ_jehoc[Wjki"ikfhWc[WjWbYh[ij"cWije_Z fheY[iiWdZ_dY_ikhW"Wij[h_edWdZj^[[nj[hdWbeYY_f_jWbfhejkX[h# WdY[Wh[fh[Y_i[boZ[Ód[Z$If[Y_WbWjj[dj_edckijX[]_l[djej^[ Yekhi[e\j^[jhWdil[hi[WdZi_]ce_Zi_dki$J^[h[Wh[i[l[hWbjh_Yai \ehWYYkhWj[beYWb_pWj_ede\j^[jhWdi_j_ede\j^[jhWdil[hiWbjej^[ i_]ce_ZWbi_dkiWiWa[ojej^[[nWYjYhWd_ejeco$M[[cf^Wi_p[W Z[Ód_j_edWYYehZ_d]jej^[bWdZcWhaie\j^[po]ecWj_YWhY^"ikfhW# cWije_ZYh[ij"cWije_ZfheY[ii"Wij[h_ed"WdZj^[[nj[hdWbeYY_f_jWb fhejkX[hWdY[<_]$*$&$',$?dWZZ_j_ed"j^[Wff[WhWdY[e\[c_iiWho l[_diWdZWbj[hWj_edi_dj^[b[l[bWdZcWj[h_Wbe\j^[ZkhWcWo^[bf jefhel_Z[WYYkhWj[i_dkiZ[Ód_j_ed$>em[l[h"Z[if_j[YWh[\kbeh_# [djWj_ed" lWh_Wj_edi e\ j^[ i_dkie_Z l[ii[bi YWd Yh[Wj[ ikhfh_i_d] Z_\ÓYkbj_[iZkh_d]j^[Óhijij[fie\j^[ef[hWj_ed$ 7\j[hj^[[ii[dj_Wbeh_[djWj_ed"j^[XehZ[hie\j^[YhWd_ejecoWh[ cWha[Zm_j^Wij[h_b[f[d$7iZ[iYh_X[ZWXel["jWa_d]_djeYedi_Z#
',-
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
[hWj_edj^[jWh][jh[]_ed"m[YWdZ_ij_d]k_i^j^h[[cW_dlWh_Wj_edi _dj^[fbWY[c[dje\j^[YhWd_ejeco<_]$*$&$'-$<ehj^[Y[djhWbfWhj e\ j^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[WiW jWh][jh[]_ed" j^[YhWd_ejeco i^ekbZ X[ fbWY[Z X[bem j^[ jhWdil[hi[ i_dki `kij c[Z_Wb je j^[ i_]ce_Zi_dki8$<ehj^[kff[hWdZbem[hd[khelWiYkbWhYecfb[n Wi jWh][j fe_dj" j^[ YhWd_ejeco i^ekbZ X[ fbWY[Z ikf[h_ehbo 7 ehYWkZWbbo9m_j^_jiWdj[h_ehXehZ[hYbei_d]j^[i_]ce_Zi_dki" h[if[Yj_l[bo$J^[ Z_Wc[j[h e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco cWo hWd][ \hec '& je(&cc$ 7\j[hZ[Ód_j_ede\j^[YhWd_ejeco"j^[^W_h_ii^Wl[Zh[jheWkh_Ykb# bWhoWYYehZ_d]jej^[b_d[e\j^[ia_d_dY_i_edm^_Y^_iYW$)&je+& cc_db[d]j^1j^[ia_d_iZ_i_d\[Yj[ZYWh[\kbbo$
7
<_]$*$&$'- :[Ód_j_ede\j^[YhWd_ejecoWYYehZ_d]jej^[WdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaie\ j^[h[jheWkh_YkbWh#h[jhecWije_ZWbWh[WWdZWYYehZ_d]jej^[jWh][jh[]_ed$ 70 ikf[h_ehbofbWY[ZWffheWY^\ehj^[kff[hd[khelWiYkbWhYecfb[n_dYbkZ_d]j^[ 9DLWdZI97$ 80 Y[djhWbbo fbWY[Z YhWd_ejeco \eh j^[ 7?97 WdZ j^[ \WY_Wb#l[ij_XkbeYeY^b[Wh Yecfb[n$ 90 YWkZWbbofbWY[ZWffheWY^\ehj^[bem[hd[khelWiYkbWhijhkYjkh[im_j^j^[9D?N" 9DN"9DN?"9DN??WdZj^[F?97$ Dej[j^[eYY_f_jecWije_Z"fWh_[jecWije_ZWdZbWcXZe_Zikjkh[im_j^j^[Wij[h_ed WdZj^[fh[Y_i[Z[Ód_j_ede\j^[jhWdil[hiWbWdZi_]ce_Zi_dki$
8
9
',.
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
)$9hWd_ejecoWdZZkhWbef[d_d] Ij[f' H_]^j i_Z[$ 7 ijhW_]^j eh ib_]^jbo Ykhl[Z ia_d _dY_i_edm_j^_dj^[h[jheWkh_YkbWhWh[W_icWZ[$ J^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed i^ekbZ X[ Yh[Wj[Z el[h j^[ feij[h_ehj^_hZfWhje\j^[fbWdd[ZYhWd_ejeco" ej^[hm_i[ j^[ h[jhWYj[Z ckiYkbWh bWo[h cWo ^_dZ[h _djhWZkhWb l_ikWb_pWj_ed$ ?d j^[ \khj^[h Yekhi[ e\ j^[ ef[hWj_ed" j^_i cWd[klh[ fhe# l_Z[i[WioWffb_YWj_ede\j^[ef[hWj_d]c_Yhe# iYef[ WdZ ikh]_YWb Z_ii[Yj_ed m_j^ c_Yhe_d# ijhkc[dji<_]$*$&$'.$
<_]$*$&$'.
Ij[f( 7\j[h X_bWj[hWb h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ ia_d WdZ j^[ ikXYkjWd[ekij_iik["j^[ij[hdeYb[_ZecWije_Z \WiY_W_i_dY_i[Z_dWbed]_jkZ_dWbijhW_]^j\Wi^# _ed$J^[_di[hj_ede\ j^[ij[hdeYb[_ZecWije_Z ckiYb[ _i j^[d \h[[Z" [nfei_d] j^[ eYY_f_je# cWije_ZWb Wh[W$ ?d YWi[i m_j^ j^_Ya ckiYkbWh bWo[hiehWYWkZWb[nj[di_ede\j^[YhWd_ejeco" j^[ ifb[d_ki YWf_j_i" bed]ki YWf_j_i WdZ ikf[# h_eheXb_gk[ckiYb[iWh[i[fWhWj[Z\hecj^[_h WjjWY^c[djijej^[Xed[$Dej[j^Wjj^[cki# YkbWh j_iik[ i^ekbZ X[ \h[[Z YWh[\kbbo je j^[ Wdj[h_eh cWije_Z h[]_ed" Xkj \ehY_Xbo _d j^[ feij[h_eheYY_f_jWbZ_h[Yj_ed"Wbbem_d]efj_cWb [nfeikh[ W\j[h YhWd_ejeco$ If[Y_Wb YWh[ _i jWa[d je eXi[hl[ j^[ eYY_f_jWb Whj[ho m^[d _j Wff[Whi\hecj^[Whj[h_WbikbYkie\j^[eYY_f_# jWb Xed[$ ;c_iiWho l[_di Wh[ Wbie kikWbbo [nfei[Z _d j^[ cWije_Z Wh[W" _dZ_YWj_d] j^[ Ybei[ Yekhi[ e\ j^[ i_]ce_Z WdZ jhWdil[hi[ i_dki[i$BeYWb^[ceijWi_ii^ekbZX[f[h\ehc[Z hWf_ZboWdZfh[Y_i[bo<_]$*$&$'/$
<_]$*$&$'/
<_]$*$&$(&
Ij[f) 7\j[h Xed[ [nfeikh[" W j_do ]heel[ _i kik# Wbbo l_i_Xb[ WYYehZ_d] je j^[ Wij[h_ed" m^_Y^ _i kikWbbo beYWj[Z Wj j^[ _d\[h_eh cWh]_d e\ j^[ jhWdil[hi[ i_dki `kij feij[h_eh \hec j^[ jhWdi_j_ed_djej^[i_]ce_Zi_dki$Ej^[hXedo ijhkYjkh[i ikY^ Wi j^[ eYY_f_jecWije_Z" igkW#
',/
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
ceiWbWdZbWcXZe_Zikjkh[iWdZj^[cWije_Z _dY_ikhW cWo Wbie ^[bf je _Z[dj_\o j^[ Yekhi[ e\ j^[ i_]ce_Z i_dki$ 7\j[h _Z[dj_ÓYWj_ed e\ j^[ _cfehjWdj Xedo bWdZcWhai" W Xkhh ^eb[ _i fbWY[Z WYYehZ_d] je j^[ eYY_f_jecWije_Z ikjkh[" `kij YWkZWbbo \hec j^[ Wij[h_ed$ M[ fh[\[h Wd eij[eYbWij_Y YhWd_ejeco ki_d] ^_]^# if[[Z Zh_bb Wle_Z_d] W ^WpWhZeki eij[efbWij_Y fheY[Zkh[d[Whjej^[fhec_d[dji_dkie_Zl[i# i[bi<_]$*$&$(&$
<_]$*$&$('
Ij[f*
Ij[f+ 7d _cfehjWdj ij[f e\ j^[ WffheWY^ _i j^[ h[celWb e\ j^[ _dd[h [Z][ e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco ki_d]Ód[fkdY^[im^_bijfhej[Yj_d]j^[ZkhW$ M_j^YWh[\kbh[celWbe\j^_i_dd[hXed[[Z][" j^[ Wd]b[ \eh l_ikWb_pWj_ed WdZ cWd_fkbWj_ed YWd i_]d_ÓYWdjbo _dYh[Wi[" Wbbem_d] W Z_h[Yj b_d[e\i_]^jZemdj^[feij[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[ f[jheki Xed[$ <eh [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbe# fedj_d[Wd]b["WigkWh[#i^Wf[ZYhWd_[Yjeco_i ik\ÓY_[djWYYehZ_d]jefbWY[c[dje\j^[XhW_d ifWjkbWWdZ je j^[cW_dZ_h[Yj_ede\ikh]_YWb Z_ii[Yj_ed<_]$*$&$(($ <_]$*$&$()
Ij[f, J^[ ZkhW i^ekbZ X[ ef[d[Z _d W Ykhl[Z \Wi^# _ed m_j^ _ji XWi[ jemWhZ j^[ i_]ce_Z i_dki$ J^[ \h[[ ZkhWb ÔWf _i Ón[Z bWj[hWbbo m_j^ jme ikjkh[i1ej^[hZkhWb[b[lWj_edikjkh[iWh[dej h[gk_h[Z$?diec[YWi[i"WYYehZ_d]jej^[_dZ_# l_ZkWbi_jkWj_ed"c_d_cWb[dbWh][c[dje\ j^[ ZkhWbef[d_d]cWoX[d[Y[iiWho_dWO#i^Wf[Z \ehc<_]$*$&$()$
'-&
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
*$?djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ij[f' H_]^ji_Z[$:_ii[Yj_edi^emded\h[i^^kcWd YWZWl[hi$ 7hj[h_Wb l[ii[bi Wh[ fh[fWh[Z m_j^ h[Z" l[_di m_j^ Xbk[ Yebeh[Z iebkj_ed$ 7\j[h ef[d_d]j^[ZkhWcWj[h"j^[Y[h[X[bbWhikh\WY[ YWdX[eXi[hl[Z$Dej[Wfhec_d[djikf[hÓY_Wb l[_dhkdd_d]\hecj^[ikXeYY_f_jWbjej^[j[d# jeh_Wb ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbkc$ ?d j^_i YWi[" j^[ YhWd_ejeco mWi f[h\ehc[Z Ybei[ je j^[ `kdYj_edX[jm[[dj^[jhWdil[hiWbWdZi_]ce_Z i_dki<_]$*$&$(*$ <_]$*$&$(*
Ij[f( 7\j[h ][djb[ ceX_b_pWj_ed e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbkc" j^[ Wd]b[ X[jm[[d j^[ j[djeh_kc WdZ j^[ feij[h_eh ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ f[jheki Xed[ YWd X[ WffheWY^[Z WYYehZ_d] je j^[ Yekhi[ e\ j^[ ikf[h_eh f[jheiWb i_dki$ 7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ WhWY^de_Z c[cXhWd[i" WZ[gkWj[ Wcekdji e\ 9I< i^ekbZ X[ Wif_hWj[Z ikffehj_d] ]hWl_jo# h[bWj[Z i[b\#h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbWh ^[c_# if^[h[$ J^[ ifWjkbW _i fbWY[Z fWhWbb[b je j^[ ikf[h_eh f[jheiWb i_dki fhej[Yj_d] j^[ kff[h bWj[hWbikh\WY[e\j^[Y[h[X[bbkc<_]$*$&$(+$
f[jhekiXed[ j[djeh_kc
<_]$*$&$(+
Ij[f) 7\j[h Wif_hWj_ed e\ 9I<" j^[ f[jheki l[_d e\ :WdZo WdZ j^[ 9DL Wh[ [nfei[Z$J^[ kff[h d[khelWiYkbWh Yecfb[n YWd X[ efj_cWbbo [nfei[Zm_j^j^[ikf[h_ehlWh_Wj_ede\j^[h[j# hei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^<_]$*$&$(,$
:WdZoÊif[jheiWb l[_d 9DL
<_]$*$&$(,
'-'
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
Ij[f* 7\j[h \khj^[h Z_ii[Yj_ed e\ WhWY^de_ZWb c[c# XhWd[i m_j^_d j^[ kff[h Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[ Wd]b[" j^[ h[bWj_edi^_f X[jm[[d j^[ f[jheki l[_d" 9DL" 9DL?? WdZ 9DL??? X[Yec[i [l_# Z[dj$Dej[Wfhec_d[djI97Ybei[jej^[9DL <_]$*$&$(-$
f[jhekil[_d 9DL I97 9DL??"9DL???
<_]$*$&$(-
Ij[f+ 8[jm[[d j^[ f[jheki l[_d WdZ 9DL" W Z[[f# i[Wj[ZWh[Wm_j^j^[9D???_iWffheWY^[Z$Dej[ j^[ZekXb[I97WdZj^[F9e7<_]$*$&$(.$
f[jhekil[_d 9D??? 9DL F9e7 I97
<_]$*$&$(.
Ij[f, >_]^[hcW]d_ÓYWj_ede\j^[9D???$?dj^[XWYa# ]hekdZ"j^[F9e7Wff[Whi<_]$*$&$(/$
9D??? F9e7
<_]$*$&$(/
'-(
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
Ij[f- :_ii[Yj_d]_dWYWkZWbZ_h[Yj_ed\hecj^[9DL" j^[ \WY_Wb WdZ l[ij_XkbeYeY^b[Wh d[hl[i Wh[ [nfei[Z$Dej[j^[ÔeYYkbki<_]$*$&$)&$ 9DL??? 9DL 9DL?? ÔeYYkbki
<_]$*$&$)&
Ij[f. <eYki_d]_djej^[Z[[f#i[Wj[Zfh[fedj_d[Wh[W" j^[87WdZj^[9DL?Wh[l_ikWb_p[Z$Dej[j^[ l[dekil[ii[bie\j^[Wdj[hebWj[hWbikh\WY[e\ j^[fedi<_]$*$&$)'$
87 9DL?
<_]$*$&$)'
Ij[f/ ?d W ceh[ YWkZWb Yekhi[ e\ Z_ii[Yj_ed" j^[ h[]_ed e\ j^[ `k]kbWh \ehWc[d _i WffheWY^[Z$ Dej[j^[beefe\j^[7?97X[jm[[dj^[\WY_Wb WdZ ]beiief^Whod][Wb d[hl[i$ 8eY^ZWb[aÊi Y^ehe_Zfb[nkie\j^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[Wff[Whi Ybei[jej^[9DN<_]$*$&$)(
9D?N 9DL?? 9DN 7?97 Y^ehe_Zfb[nki
<_]$*$&$)(
'-)
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
Ij[f'& ;nfeikh[e\j^[bem[hY[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[ m_j^j^[9D?N"9DNWdZ9DN?$Dej[j^[eh_]_d e\j^[F?97\hecj^[L7<_]$*$&$))
L7 9DN? F?97 9DN 9D?N
<_]$*$&$))
Ij[f'' 9[dj[h e\ Wjj[dj_ed _i j^[ ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ L7 m_j^ÓX[hie\j^[^ofe]beiiWbd[hl[$Dej[j^[ Wdj[hebWj[hWb ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ c[ZkbbW eXbed# ]WjW<_]$*$&$)*
9DN? 9DN?? 9DN L7 c[ZkbbW eXbed]WjW
<_]$*$&$)*
Ij[f'( :_ii[Yj_d] Wbed] j^[ Wdj[h_eh \ehWc[d cW]dkc"j^[`kdYj_ede\Xej^l[hj[XhWbWhj[h# _[iYWdX[m[bbl_ikWb_p[Z<_]$*$&$)+ 87 h_]^jL7 b[\jL7
<_]$*$&$)+
'-*
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
+$:khW"Xed[WdZmekdZYbeikh[ 7\j[h Yecfb[j_ed e\ j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[" j^[ _djhWZkhWb ifWY[_iÓbb[Zm_j^H_d][hiebkj_edWjXeZoj[cf[hWjkh[$J^[ZkhWb _dY_i_ed _i Ybei[Z m_j^ _dj[hhkfj[Z eh Yedj_dkeki ikjkh[i$ ?\ j[d# i_ed^WiZ[l[bef[Z_dj^[ZkhWbfbWd["WicWbbf_[Y[e\ckiYb[YWd X[ ki[Z \eh W mWj[hj_]^j Ybeikh[1 _d ej^[h YWi[i" fbWij_Y cWj[h_Wb cWo X[ h[gk_h[Z$ 7 fbWj[ e\ ][b\eWc _i fbWY[Z [njhWZkhWbbo WdZ j^[ YhWd_[Yjeco _i Ybei[Z m_j^ Xed[ Y[c[dj$ 7\j[h ÓdWb l[h_ÓYW# j_ede\^[ceijWi_i"j^[ckiYb[WdZikXYkjWd[ekibWo[hiWh[Ybei[Z m_j^_dj[hhkfj[Zikjkh[iWdZj^[ia_dm_j^hkdd_d]eh_dj[hhkfj[Z ikjkh[i$7ikYj_edZhW_d_idejd[Y[iiWho$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i ?dWZ[gkWj[ fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d] m_j^ j^[ Yedi[gk[dY[ e\ _dWZ[gkWj[[nfeikh[e\j^[jWh][jh[]_edWdZi_]d_ÓYWdjZ[j[# h_ehWj_ed_d[\ÓY_[dYoe\ikh]_YWb[nfeikh[e\j^[jWh][jh[]_ed$ 7ij^[ceij_cfehjWdjfWhje\fheY[Zkh["fbWdd_d]_ij^[jWiae\ j^[ikh][ed If[Y_Wb Wjj[dj_ed i^ekbZ X[ fW_Z je fWj_[dj fei_j_ed_d]$ ?dWZ[# gkWj[fei_j_ed_d]cWoYWki[Yecfh[ii_ede\ j^[cW_dY[hl_YWb l[ii[bih[ikbj_d]_d^ofef[h\ki_edehi[l[h[l[dekiYed][ij_ed _dj^[feij[h_eh\eiiW$ ?dWZ[gkWj[fbWY[c[dje\j^[ikh]_YWbWffheWY^YWki_d]_d`khoje j^[jhWdil[hi[ehi_]ce_Zi_dkim_j^i[l[h[l[dekiXb[[Z_d]$J^[ WffheWY^ckijX[Z[j[hc_d[ZW\j[hWYYkhWj[ikh]_YWbeh_[djWj_ed WYYehZ_d]jeWdWjec_YWbademb[Z][WdZfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ h[celWb e\ 9I< m_j^ i[l[h[ Yedjki_ed e\ WZ`WY[dj fehj_edi e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbWh ^[c_if^[h[ Zk[ je ifWjkbW fh[iikh[$ ?dYh[Wi_d]fh[iikh[m_j^_dj^[feij[h_eh\eiiWcWoYWki[i[l[h[ d[khebe]_YWbZ[j[h_ehWj_ed$ ?d`kh_[i je i[di_j_l[ d[hl[i WdZ l[ii[bi _d j^[ bWj[hWb feij[h_eh \eiiWZkh_d]c_Yheikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_ed$ ?dWZ[gkWj[^[ceijWi_im_j^_dj^[ikh]_YWbi_j[m_j^ikXi[gk[dj feijef[hWj_l[h[Xb[[Z_d]$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ZkhWbYbeikh[m_j^feijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW$?dceij YWi[i" dWieb_gkehh^[W eYYkhi X[YWki[ e\ \h[gk[djbo ef[d[Z cWije_ZY[bbi$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ [njhWYhWd_Wb ^[ceijWi_i YWki_d] feijef[hWj_l[ ie\j j_iik[^[cWjecW$
'-+
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
J_fiWdZjh_Yai
<_]$*$&$),
If[Y_WbYWh[i^ekbZX[]_l[djefh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfWj_[dj fei_j_ed_d] WYYehZ_d] je j^[ fh[Y_i[ beYWb_pWj_ed e\ j^[ b[i_ed$ Dej[j^WjbWj[hWbbobeYWj[Zb[i_edid[[Zb[iihejWj_edXkjc[Z_# WbbobeYWj[Zb[i_edih[gk_h[ceh[^[WZhejWj_ed$ CWa[WYWh[\kbWdWjec_YWbeh_[djWj_edWdZki[ j^[ j^h[[ij[fi e\ cWha_d] m_j^ W ij[h_b[ f[d0 '$ eii[eki ijhkYjkh[i WdZ ikf[h# ÓY_Wb d[khelWiYkbWh ijhkYjkh[i1 ($ fbWY[c[dj e\ YhWd_ejeco1 )$ia_d_dY_i_ed$ Jefhel_Z[j^[_djhWZkhWbcWd_fkbWj_edWbbem_d]WZ_h[Yjb_d[e\ i_]^jZemdj^[feij[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[f[jhekiXed["j^[d[nj j^h[[Z[jW_biWh[_cfehjWdj0 '$J^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed i^ekbZ X[ Yh[Wj[Z el[h j^[ feij[h_eh j^_hZ fWhj e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco" ej^[hm_i[ j^[ h[jhWYj[Z ikXeY# Y_f_jWb ckiYb[i cWo ^_Z[ j^[ _djhWZkhWb ikh]_YWb Z_ii[Yj_ed <_]$*$&$),$ ($ J^[ WjjWY^c[dj e\ j^[ ij[hdeYb[_ZecWije_Z WdZ ifb[d_ki YWf_j_i ckiYb[i i^ekbZ X[ ceX_b_p[Z \ehY_Xbo _d j^[ feij[h_eh WdZ][djbo_dj^[Wdj[h_ehcWije_ZWbZ_h[Yj_ed"fhej[Yj_d]j^[ _djhWZkhWbl_ikWb_pWj_ed<_]$*$&$)-$ )$ H[celWbe\j^[Wdj[h_eh_dd[h[Z][e\j^[YhWd_[Yjecoel[hj^[ i_]ce_Zi_dkikdZ[hfhej[Yj_ede\j^[ZkhWki_d]Ód[fkdY^[i$ J^[Wd]b[\ehl_ikWb_pWj_edYWdWbiei_]d_ÓYWdjbo_dYh[Wi[m_j^ YWh[\kbh[celWbe\j^_i_dd[hXed[[Z][<_]$*$&$).$ J^[ ZkhW i^ekbZ X[ ef[d[Z _d WÇ9È i^Wf[Z" i[c_bkdWh \Wi^_ed WdZ^[bZjemWhZj^[i_]ce_Zi_dkim_j^jmeikjkh[i$?j_i[Wio je ]W_d X[jj[h l_ikWb_pWj_ed e\ j^[ \ehWc[d cW]dkc eh j[dje# h_kcm_j^WYWkZWbehYhWd_Wb[dbWh][c[dje\j^[ZkhWbef[d_d] <_]$*$&$)/$ J^[Óhijij[fe\j^[_djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_edi^ekbZX[j^[ef[d_d] e\j^[Y[h[X[bbec[ZkbbWhY_ij[hdWdZik\ÓY_[djZhW_dW][e\9I<$
'-,
<_]$*$&$)-
<_]$*$&$).
<_]$*$&$)/
H[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^
<_]$*$&$*&
<_]$*$&$*'
7\j[h Ód_i^_d] j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[" j^[ ZkhWb ef[d_d] i^ekbZX[Ybei[ZmWj[hj_]^jki_d]_dj[hhkfj[Zehhkdd_d]ikjkh[i$ ?\j[di_ed^WiZ[l[bef[Z"m^_Y^_il[ho\h[gk[dj"WicWbbf_[Y[e\ ckiYb[YWdX[i[md_djej^[ZkhWbYbeikh[$?dej^[hYWi[i"fbWij_Y ]hW\jcWj[h_Wbi^ekbZX[ki[Z<_]$*$&$*&$
J^[Xedoef[d_d]e\j^[YhWd_[Yjecoi^ekbZX[Ybei[Zm_j^Xed[ Y[c[djWle_Z_d]ckiYb[_d]hemj^WdZWjjWY^c[djjej^[ZkhW cWj[hm_j^ikXi[gk[djfeijef[hWj_l[Y[hl_YWbfW_d<_]$*$&$*'$ 8[YWki[ e\ j^[ b_c_j[Z WffheWY^" W ikYj_ed ZhW_d _i dej h[Yec# c[dZ[Z$
'--
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
+$& IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^ >_ijehoe\j^[c[Z_WdikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^[i
7
:kh_d] j^[ [Whbo f[h_eZ e\ d[kheikh][ho" ef[hWj_l[ jh[Wjc[dj e\ ifWY[#eYYkfo_d]b[i_edim_j^_dj^[feij[h_eh\eiiWmWiY^WhWYj[h_p[Z XoWd[njh[c[bo^_]^cehjWb_johWj[$:k[je_dWYYkhWj[fh[ef[hWj_l[ Wii[iic[djWdZYhkZ[ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[i\ehjkcehh[celWb"j^[ jh[Wjc[dj \W_b[Z ie \h[gk[djbo j^Wj ikh][edi m[h[ h[bkYjWdj je kdZ[hjWa[ j^[i[ ef[hWj_edi <_]$+$&$'W$ ?d './)" 7bb[dIjWhh fkXb_i^[Z '+ YWi[i e\ Y[h[X[bbWh jkcehi m_j^ edbo ed[ fWj_[dj ikhl_l_d] m_j^ d[khebe]_YWb h[Yel[ho QIjWhh './)S$ Ed WYYekdj e\ j^[i[\hkijhWj_d]h[ikbji">[hcWddEff[d^[_cYbWii_Ó[ZY[h[X[bbWh b[i_edi Wi _def[hWXb[" h[fehj_d] W ]h[Wj[h j^Wd -& cehjWb_jo QEff[d^[_c'/&(S$ <[ZehAhWki[_d'/')fkXb_i^[ZZ_\\[h[djWffheWY^[ijeY[h[X[bbWh jkcehiZ[iYh_X_d]WXheWZX_bWj[hWb[nfeikh[e\j^[feij[h_eh\eiiW <_]$+$&$'X$ >em[l[h" edbo W c_deh_jo e\ fWj_[dji ikhl_l[Z j^_i jh[Wjc[dj"h[ikbj_d]_dWcehjWb_johWj[hWd]_d]\hec,-je.. QAhWki['/')S$
8 <_]$+$&$'
M_Z[[nfeikh[e\j^[[dj_h[ikXeYY_f_jWbWh[WmWiYeccedboki[Z jeWffheWY^j^[feij[h_eh\eiiW$L_Yjeh>ehib[o_d'/&*WdZ>Whl[o 9ki^_d] _d '/&+ h[fehj[Z j^[ ÇX_bWj[hWb [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbWh ^[c_if^[h[ij^hek]^WYheiiXem_dY_i_edÈQ>ehib[o'/&*"9ki^_d] '/&+S$J^[i[[nj[dZ[ZWffheWY^[iWle_Z[ZXhW_dij[cYecfh[ii_ed Zkh_d] ikh][ho WdZ Wbbem[Z feij[h_eh \eiiW Z[Yecfh[ii_ed W\j[h _dYecfb[j[jkcehh[celWbWdZXhW_dim[bb_d]<_]$+$&$($ <_]$+$&$' ?d j^[[WhboZWoie\d[kheikh][ho"ifWY[#eYYkfo_d]b[i_edim[h[kikWbbo h[cel[ZXoXbkdjÓd][hZ_ii[Yj_edX[jm[[dj^[i[di_j_l[d[khelWiYkbWhijhkYjkh[i$ Jh[Wjc[dje\Y[h[X[bbWhb[i_edimWie\j[dkdikYY[ii\kbX[YWki[e\j^[YhkZ[ikh]_# YWbj[Y^d_gk[i$JeWY^_[l[WdedjhWkcWj_YZ_ii[Yj_ed"[if[Y_Wbbom_j^_dj^[feij[h_eh \eiiW"AhWki[_d'/&/fkXb_i^[ZWd[mc[j^eZki_d]lWYkkcikYj_ede\j^[jkceh cWii7$Dej[AhWki[Êic[Z_WdikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^[nfei_d]j^[feij[h_eh\eiiW$ >[ YWhh_[Z ekj W XheWZ bWc_d[Yjeco e\ j^[ WjbWi Wbbem_d] Z[Yecfh[ii_ed e\ j^[ YhWd_eY[hl_YWbh[]_edWdZj^[ZkhWmWief[d[Z_dWÇOÈ\ehc8$ <_]$+$&$( 9ki^_d]Êifeij[h_eh\eiiWikh][hoki_d]WX_bWj[hWbikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^$ 9ki^_d] Z[iYh_X[Z WdÇ[njh[c[ \ehWc_dWb ^[hd_Wj_ed _d W YWi[ _d m^_Y^ j[di_ed mWiie]h[WjWijed[Y[ii_jWj[h[celWbe\j^[bWc_dW[e\j^[WjbWiWdZYWhho_d]j^[ ZkhWb_dY_i_edjej^[WjbWiX[\eh[h[if_hWjeho[cXWhhWiic[djmWih[b_[l[ZÈ$Dej[j^[ fkdYjkh[e\j^[b[\jbWj[hWbl[djh_Yb[$
<_]$+$&$(
'-/
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
Ed j^[ XWi_i e\ ^_i [nf[h_[dY[" >ehib[o fe_dj[Z ekj j^Wj W bWh][ Wcekdj e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbWh j_iik[ YekbZ X[ iWYh_ÓY[Z WdZ h[cel[Z m_j^Wc_dehehdeZ[cedijhWXb[beiie\d[khebe]_YWb\kdYj_ed$J^[ YeccedWffheWY^jeb[i_edie\j^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[mWieXjW_d[Z Xo ifb_jj_d] j^[ l[hc_i ed j^[ ikXeYY_f_jWb ikh\WY[" WdZ _d iec[ YWi[i" h[cel_d] j^[ c[Z_Wb fWhj e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbWh ^[c_if^[h[ Wi h[Yecc[dZ[Z Xo MWbj[h ;$ :WdZo WdZ BkZm_] =$ A[cf[ Q:WdZo'/)."A[cf['/-&S<_]i$+$&$)"+$&$*$ J^[ _djheZkYj_ed e\ c_Yheikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[i fhel_Z[Z W cWha[Z _cfhel[c[dj_dikh]_YWb[\ÓY_[dYo$M_j^b[ii_dlWi_l[WffheWY^[iWi h[fehj[ZXoHeX[hjM$HWdZWdZC$=Wp_OWiWh]_b"ikh]_YWbcehjWb_jo WdZcehX_Z_joYekbZX[ikYY[ii\kbboc_d_c_p[ZQHWdZ'/,."OWiWh]_b '/-&S$?dfWhj_YkbWh"j^[fh[Y_i[Z_ii[Yj_edm_j^_dj^[ikXWhWY^de_Z ifWY[ie\j^[feij[h_eh\eiiWWdZWffheWY^_d]j^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[ j^hek]^WdWjec_YWbfWj^mWoie\\[h[ZWi_]d_ÓYWdjZ[l[befc[dj_d ikh]_YWbh[ikbji<_]$+$&$+$ ?dj^[\ebbem_d]j^[_cfehjWdY[e\j^[i[WdWjec_YWbYedi_Z[hWj_edi _iZ_iYkii[Z_d\kbb$
<_]$+$&$) ;nfbehWj_ed e\ W fWhj_Wb Yoij_Y jkceh e\ j^[ feij[h_eh \eiiW j^hek]^ W c[Z_Wd ikXeYY_f_jWb WffheWY^ Wi Z[iYh_X[Z Xo :WdZo$J^[ fWj_[dj ik\\[h[Z \hec i[l[h[ ^[WZWY^[i YWki[Z Xo W Yedi[Ykj_l[ eXijhkYj_l[ ^oZhe# Y[f^Wbki$Dej[j^[_djhWef[hWj_l[ki[e\cedefebWhYeW]# kbWj_edWbbem_d]WiW\[ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_ed$
<_]$+$&$* A[cf[Êi cWYheikh]_YWb feij[h_eh \eiiW [nfbehW# j_edfkXb_i^[Z_d'/,._d^_iYecfh[^[di_l[d[kheikh]_YWb j[njXeea$ Dej[ j^[ XheWZ X_bWj[hWb [nfbehWj_ed WdZ i[Y# j_ed_d]e\j^[_d\[h_ehl[hc_i\ehWffheWY^_d]j^[jkceh m_j^_dj^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[$
<_]$+$&$+ J^[c[Z_WdikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^ki_d]c_Yhe# ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[iZ[iYh_X[ZXoOWiWh]_b\ehZ_ijWbboi_jk# Wj[ZWd[khoicie\j^[F?97$
'.&
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
=[d[hWbWdWjec_YWbYedijhkYj_ede\j^[ikh]_YWb Yehh_Zehjej^[\ekhj^l[djh_YkbWhh[]_ed J^[feij[h_ehYhWd_Wb\eiiW_ij^[Z[[f[ije\j^[j^h[[YhWd_Wb\eiiW[ YedjW_d_d]j^[ceijYecfb[n_djhWYhWd_WbWdWjecom_j^ijhkYjkh[i e\j^[Y[h[X[bbkc"XhW_dij[c"j[dfW_hie\YhWd_Wbd[hl[i"WdZYec# fb[nWhj[h_WbWdZl[dekih[bWj_edi^_fi$J^[feij[h_eh\eiiW[nj[dZi \hecj^[j[djeh_Wb_dY_ikhWjej^[\ehWc[dcW]dkcX[jm[[dj^[ ikfhWj[djeh_WbWdZ_djhWif_dWbifWY[i$?j_iikhhekdZ[ZXoj^[eYY_f# _jWb" j[cfehWb" fWh_[jWb" WdZ if^[de_Z Xed[i$ ?d _ji dWhhem ifWY[" m^_Y^ Yedi_iji e\ edbo Wffhen_cWj[bo ed[#[_]^j^ e\ j^[ _djhWYhW# d_Wb lebkc[" Wh[ j^[ ceij _cfehjWdj l_jWb fWj^mWoi h[]kbWj_d] YediY_ekid[ii" YWhZ_eh[if_hWjeho WdZ ej^[h Wkjedec_Y \kdYj_edi" cejehWYj_l_j_[iWdZi[diehoh[Y[fj_ed"WdZY[dj[hi\ehYedjhebb_d] XWbWdY[WdZ]W_j$
<_]$+$&$, 7hj_ij_Y _bbkijhWj_ed e\ j^[ \ekhj^ l[djh_Yb[" h^ecXe_Z \eiiW WdZ j^[ ikhhekdZ_d] WdWjec_YWb ijhkY# jkh[i$
Ef[hWj_l[WffheWY^[ijej^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[WdZceijY[h[X[bbWh jkcehi Wh[ Yeccedbo Z_h[Yj[Z WhekdZ WdZ j^hek]^ j^[ ikXeY# Y_f_jWbWh[We\ j^[feij[h_eh\eiiW$7YYehZ_d] je j^[\WbnY[h[X[bb_" j^[ ikXeYY_f_jWb ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbkc _i Z_l_Z[Z Xo j^[ fei# j[h_eh Y[h[X[bbWh _dY_ikhW _dje h_]^j# WdZ b[\j#i_Z[Z ^[c_if^[h[i$ J^[l[hc_iY[h[X[bb__i\ebZ[Z_dje j^_i_dY_ikhWWdZ\ehciW jof[ e\ Yehj_YWb ikh\WY[ m_j^_d j^[ _dY_ikhW$ J^[ ikXeYY_f_jWb Y[h[X[b# bWhikh\WY[_iZ_l_Z[Z^eh_pedjWbboXo j^[ikXeYY_f_jWbÓiikh[_dje ikf[h_eh WdZ _d\[h_eh fWhji$ J^_i ikXeYY_f_jWb Óiikh[ ^Wi W l[hc# _WdWdZW^[c_if^[h_YfWhj$J^[l[hc_WdfWhji[fWhWj[ij^[jkX[h WdZ j^[ fohWc_Z WdZ _i j[hc[Z j^[ fh[fohWc_ZWb Óiikh[$ ?d j^[ ^[c_if^[h_YfWhj"j^[fh[X_l[djhWbÓiikh[i[fWhWj[ij^[X_l[djhWb WdZ_d\[h_ehi[c_bkdWhbeXkb[ie\j^[Y[h[X[bbWh^[c_if^[h[i$J^[ jedi_biWdZj^[klkbWWh[i_jkWj[Z_d\[hec[Z_Wb\hecj^[beXkbki X_l[djhWbWdZfohWc_ZYel[h_d]j^[WYY[iijej^[YWkZWbfWhje\j^[ \ekhj^l[djh_Yb[$ L_Wj^[ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^"WYY[ii_i]W_d[Zjej^[\ekhj^l[d# jh_YkbWh Y^WcX[h j^hek]^ W jh_Wd]b[#\ehc[Z ifWY[ X[jm[[d j^[ jme jedi_bi" j^[ ie#YWbb[Z lWbb[YkbW" WdZ j^hek]^ j^[ Y[h[X[bbe# c[ZkbbWhoÓiikh["j^[dWhhemifWY[X[jm[[dj^[jedi_biWdZj^[ c[ZkbbW eXbed]WjW$ J^[ lWbb[YkbW Yecckd_YWj[i j^hek]^ j^[ \ehWc[d e\ CW][dZ_[ m_j^ j^[ Y^WcX[h e\ j^[ \ekhj^ l[djh_Yb[ <_]$+$&$,$ Ikh]_YWb [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ l[djh_Yb[ h[gk_h[i Z_ii[Y# j_ede\j^[\ehWc[de\CW][dZ_[WdZef[d_d]e\j^[YWkZWbfWhj e\ j^[ l[djh_YkbWh hee\$J^_i YWkZWb hee\ e\ j^[ \ekhj^ l[djh_Yb[ _i \ehc[ZXoj^[_d\[heYWkZWbfWhje\j^[l[hc_im_j^j^[klkbWWdZ
'.'
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
deZkbkiWdZj^[_d\[h_ehc[ZkbbWhol[bkcYel[h_d]j^[jedi_bie\ Xej^Y[h[X[bbWh^[c_if^[h[i$J^[j[bWY^ehe_Z[Wijh[jY^[iX[jm[[d j^[_d\[h_ehc[ZkbbWhol[bkcWdZj^[jW[d_We\j^[c[ZkbbWeXbed# ]WjW \ehc_d] j^[ Y^ehe_Z fb[nki e\ j^[ \ekhj^ l[djh_Yb[ m_j^ XhWdY^[ie\j^[feij[h_eh_d\[h_ehY[h[X[bbWhWhj[ho$ ?dj^[fWij"ef[hWj_l[WYY[iijej^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[mWieXjW_d[Z Xoifb_jj_d]j^[Y[h[X[bbWhl[hc_iWdZ"_diec[YWi[i"Xoh[cel_d] j^[ c[Z_Wb fWhj e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbWh ^[c_if^[h[$ >em[l[h" YWh[\kb c_Yheikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_ede\j^[lWbb[YkbWWdZj^[Y[h[X[bbec[Zkb# bWhoÓiikh[fhel_Z[iWXheWZ[nfeikh[e\j^[YWkZWb[djhWdY[_dje j^[l[djh_Yb[$Ef[d_d]j^[\ehWc[de\CW][dZ_[WdZ j[bWY^ehe_# Z[Wm_bbfhel_Z[WZ[gkWj[[nfeikh[e\j^[\kbbb[d]j^e\j^[Ôeeh e\j^[l[djh_Yb[m_j^ekjifb_jj_d]e\j^[l[hc_iehh[cel_d]d[khWb j_iik[<_]$+$&$-$J^_icWd[klh[YWdX[YecfWh[Zm_j^j^[jhWdi# Y^ehe_ZWb [dbWh][c[dj e\ j^[ \ehWc[d e\ Cedhe$ ?d WZZ_j_ed" Xo ef[d_d]j^[_d\[h_ehc[ZkbbWhol[bkc"ed[YWdWffheWY^j^[[dj_h[ l[djh_YkbWhY^WcX[h_dYbkZ_d] j^[\Wij_]_kc" j^[bWj[hWbh[Y[ii[i jemWhZj^[\ehWc[de\BkiY^aWWdZj^[Wgk[ZkYje\Iobl_ki$?j_i _cfehjWdj jedej[ j^Wj j^[h[Wh[deh[fehjie\Z[ÓY_ji\ebbem_d] i[fWhWj[ef[d_d]e\ j^[l[bkcWdZ j[bWYecfWh[Zm_j^feii_Xb[ i[l[h[]W_jZ_ijkhXWdY[iWdZWjWn_WW\j[hifb_jj_d]e\j^[l[hc_i$
<_]$+$&$- Ef[hWj_l[[nfeikh[e\j^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[ki_d] j^[ c[Z_Wd ikXeYY_f_jWb WffheWY^$ Dej[ j^Wj YWh[\kb h[jhWYj_ede\j^[deZkbkiWdZklkbWW\j[hZ_ii[Yj_ede\j^[ Y[h[X[bbec[ZkbbWho Óiikh[ fhel_Z[i W XheWZ WffheWY^ je j^[ l[djh_YkbWh Y^WcX[h m_j^ekj ifb_jj_d] j^[ _d\[h_eh l[hc_i$
?dj^[\ebbem_d]"j^[XWi_Yikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[e\j^[c[Z_WdikXeY# Y_f_jWb_d\hWY[h[X[bbWhWffheWY^_iZ[iYh_X[Z$
9hWd_eY[hl_YWb`kdYj_ed
<ekhj^l[djh_Yb[
Feij[h_ehY_hYkc\[h[dY[e\j^[\ehWc[dcW]dkc CWh]_dWbi_dki"eYY_f_jWbi_dki IkXeYY_f_jWbikh\WY[e\j^[Y[h[X[bbWh^[c_if^[h[i 9[h[X[bbWhjedi_bi"bem[hl[hc_i"lWbb[YkbW ?d\[h_ehc[ZkbbWhol[bkc 9^ehe_Zfb[nkie\j^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[ <ehWc[de\CW][dZ_[ 9[hl_Yec[ZkbbWho`kdYj_ed Feij[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[c[ZkbbWeXbed]WjW <_hijZ[dj_YkbWj[b_]Wc[dji 9DN??"9DN?"9DN"9D?N"ÓhijY[hl_YWbheej L7"F?97"_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi
9^ehe_Zfb[nkie\j^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[ H^ecXe_Z\eiiW <ehWc[de\BkiY^aW <Wij_]_kc Ikf[h_ehc[ZkbbWhol[bkc 7gk[ZkYj Feij[h_ehj^_hZl[djh_Yb[
JWXb[+$&$' 7dWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[im^_Y^YWdX[h[WY^[Zj^hek]^j^[c[Z_WdikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^$
'.(
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[
<_]$+$&$.
'$FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] Ikh][ho e\ j^[ feij[h_eh \eiiW _dYbkZ_d] j^[ \ekhj^ l[djh_Yb[ YWd X[f[h\ehc[Zm_j^j^[fWj_[dj_dj^[i_jj_d]ehj^[fhed[fei_j_ed$ 7i W cW_d WZlWdjW][" j^[ i_jj_d] fei_j_ed _cfhel[i j^[ l[deki ZhW_dW][e\j^[feij[h_eh\eiiWWdZWbbemiXbeeZ"9I<"WdZ_hh_]Wj# _d]iebkj_edijeZhW_d\hecj^[ef[hWj_l[Ó[bZ$>em[l[h"j^[i_jj_d] fei_j_edYWhh_[iWl[hoi[l[h[Wd[ij^[i_ebe]_YWbh_iam_j^ZWd][he\ YWhZ_efkbcedWho_dijWX_b_jo"W_h[cXeb_ic"i[l[h[fd[kceY[f^Wbki ehl[djh_YkbWhYebbWfi[YWki[ZXoWd[dehcekibeiie\9I<$?dWZZ_# j_ed"[nfei_d]j^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[_dj^[i_jj_d]fei_j_edh[gk_h[i h[jhWYj_ede\j^[Y[h[X[bbWh^[c_if^[h[iW]W_dij]hWl_jo"h[ikbj_d] _d Yedjki_ed e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbWh j_iik[$ ?d ekh Z[fWhjc[dj" m[ ki[ j^[fhed[fei_j_ed\eh[nfei_d]j^[feij[h_eh\eiiWl_Wj^[c[Z_Wd ikXeYY_f_jWb WffheWY^$ 7ZlWdjW][i e\ j^_i fei_j_ed_d] Wh[ j^[ i_cfb_Y_joe\ j^[ j[Y^d_gk[WdZYec\ehj\eh j^[fWj_[dj$M_j^Wd WZ[gkWj[fei_j_ed_d]e\j^[^[WZ"j^[Y[h[X[bbkc\WbbiWmWo\hec j^[XhW_dij[cikh\WY[ef[d_d]j^[ikXl[hc_Wbikh]_YWbYehh_Zeh$7j j^[iWc[j_c["j^[f[hf[dZ_YkbWhZ_h[Yj_ede\ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_ed fhel_Z[iWd[\ÓY_[djmeha_d]fei_j_edm_j^efj_cWbl_ikWb_pWj_ed e\j^[ef[hWj_d]Ó[bZ$
<_]$+$&$/
Ij[f' 7iWÓhijij[fe\fei_j_ed_d]"j^[XeZoWdZj^[^[WZWh[[b[lWj[Z YW$(&je)&Wi_dWdWdj_#Jh[dZ[b[dXkh]fei_j_ed$J^_i[b[lWj_ed_i d[Y[iiWhojeXh_d]j^[^[WZWXel[j^[b[l[be\j^[j^ehWne\\[h_d] efj_cWbl[dekiZhW_dW][<_]$+$&$.$
<_]$+$&$'&
Ij[f( ?dWi[YedZij[f"j^[^[WZcWoX[Wdj[heÔ[Yj[ZWXekj*+_dehZ[h je Xh_d] j^[ j[djeh_kc _d W f[hf[dZ_YkbWh fbWd[$ J^_i ie#YWbb[Z 9edYehZ[ fei_j_ed fhel_Z[i Wd [\ÓY_[dj meha_d] fei_j_ed \eh j^[ ikh][ed Z_ii[Yj_d] jemWhZ j^[ _d\[h_eh Y[h[X[bbWh ikh\WY[ WdZ m_j^_dj^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[$>em[l[h"if[Y_WbYWh[i^ekbZX[jWa[d dej je Yecfh[ii j^[ l[dj_bWj_ed jkX[ WdZ j^[ bWhodn$ ;nY[ii_l[ Wdj[Ô[Yj_edYWdWbieYWki[l[dekiYed][ij_edZk[jeYecfh[ii_ed e\j^[`k]kbWhl[_di<_]$+$&$/$ Ij[f) <ehb[i_edibeYWj[ZcW_dbo_d j^[c_Zb_d["hejWj_ede\ j^[^[WZ_i dejd[Y[iiWho$>em[l[h"c[Z_ebWj[hWbboi_jkWj[Zb[i_edih[gk_h[W ib_]^jhejWj_ede\+Å'+<_]$+$&$'&$
'.)
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
($7dWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZeh_[djWj_ed <ehfh[ef[hWj_l[eh_[djWj_ed"j^[_cfehjWdjWdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhai e\ j^[ feij[hebWj[hWb eii[eki iakbb WdZ if_d[" ikY^ Wi j^[ [nj[h# dWbWkZ_jehoc[Wjki"cWije_ZfheY[ii"j^[^_]^[ijdkY^Wbb_d["j^[ [nj[hdWb eYY_f_jWb fhejkX[hWdY[" j^[ \ehWc[d cW]dkc WdZ j^[ if_dekifheY[iie\9(Wh[fh[Y_i[boZ[j[hc_d[Z<_]$+$&$''$If[Y_Wb Wjj[dj_ed i^ekbZ X[ ]_l[d je j^[ Yekhi[ e\ j^[ jhWdil[hi[ i_dki Wij^[XehZ[he\j^[feij[h_eh\eiiW"WdZZ[Ód_j_ede\j^[c_Zb_d[ ijhkYjkh[i$ 7\j[h[nWYjeh_[djWj_ed"j^[XehZ[hie\j^[YhWd_ejecoWh[cWha[Z m_j^ W ij[h_b[ f[d$ KikWbbo" j^[ YhWd_ejeco _i fbWY[Z c[Z_Wd eh ib_]^jbofWhWc[Z_Wd[nj[dZ_d]\hecj^[\ehWc[dcW]dkcjej^[ _d\[h_ehdkY^Wbb_d[m_j^WZ_Wc[j[he\WXekj)Yc$?diec[YWi[i" j^[ ikf[h_eh h_c e\ j^[ feij[h_eh WhY^ e\ 9' YWd WZZ_j_edWbbo X[ h[cel[Z"Wbbem_d]efj_cWb[nfeikh[e\j^[Y[hl_Yec[ZkbbWho`kdY# j_ed$ 7\j[h Z[Ód_d] j^[ YhWd_ejeco" j^[ ^W_h _i i^Wl[Z WdZ YWh[\kbbo Z_i_d\[Yj[ZWYYehZ_d]jej^[c_Zb_d[ia_d_dY_i_ede\,je.Yc_d b[d]j^<_]$+$&$''$
<_]$+$&$'' :[Ód_j_ede\ j^[YhWd_ejecoWYYehZ_d] je j^[ WdWjec_YWb bWdZcWhai e\ j^[ feij[h_eh YhWd_eY[hl_YWb h[]_ed$J^[ c_Zb_d[ ia_d _dY_i_ed i^ekbZ h[WY^ j^[ [Wi_bo fWbfWXb[9(if_dekifheY[ii$
'.*
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
)$9hWd_ejecoWdZZkhWbef[d_d] Ij[f' 7\j[h fWj_[dj fei_j_ed_d] WdZ WdWjec_YWb eh_# [djWj_ed" j^[ ia_d _i fh[fWh[Z m_j^ WbYe^eb iebkj_ed$ Je X[]_d j^[ ikXeYY_f_jWb [nfeikh[" WijhW_]^jc_Zb_d[_dY_i_ed_icWZ[[nj[dZ_d] \hec j^[ _d_ed je j^[ m[bb fWbfWXb[ if_deki fheY[iie\9(<_]$+$&$'($
<_]$+$&$'(
Ij[f( 7\j[h h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ ia_d" j^[ b_]Wc[djkc dkY^W[_ifh[Y_i[boZ[Ód[ZWdZifb_jWYYehZ_d] jej^[c_Zb_d[$Ie\jj_iik[Z_ii[Yj_edWdZi[fW# hWj_ed e\ j^[ ikXeYY_f_jWb ckiYb[i i^ekbZ X[ cWZ[ijh_Yjbo_dj^[c_Zb_d[j^hek]^j^[b_]W# c[djkc dkY^W[" j^ki Wle_Z_d] c_i]k_Z_d] _dje j^[ ^_]^bo lWiYkbWh fWhWc[Z_Wd ckiYb[i <_]$+$&$')$
<_]$+$&$')
Ij[f) 7 bem fheÓb[" i[b\#h[jW_d_d] h[jhWYjeh _i j^[d ki[Z je ^ebZ XWYa j^[ j^_Ya ikXeYY_f_j_Wb ckiYb[bWo[hi"[$]$"j^[jhWf[p_ki"ifb[d_kiWdZ i[c_if_dWb_iYWf_j_ickiYb[i$J^[h[YjkiYWf_j_i feij[h_ehc_deh_iZ_ii[Yj[Z\hecj^[jkX[hYb[ edj^[feij[h_ehWhY^e\j^[WjbWi[nfei_d]j^[ ikXeYY_f_jWbWh[Wm_j^ j^[\ehWc[dcW]dkc WdZj^[feij[h_ehWhY^e\9'$BeYWb^[ceijWi_i d[[Zi je X[ f[h\ehc[Z hWf_Zbo WdZ fh[Y_i[bo$ 7\j[h h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ ckiYb[i" jme fWhWc[# Z_Wd Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_edi Wh[ f[h\ehc[Z [nfei_d] j^[ ZkhW cWj[h e\ Xej^ Y[h[X[bbWh ^[c_if^[h[i<_]$+$&$'*$
<_]$+$&$'*
'.+
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
<_]$+$&$'+
Ij[f* D[nj" j^[ fWhWc[Z_Wd Xkhh ^eb[i Wh[ Yed# d[Yj[Z ki_d] Ód[ fkdY^[i m_j^ h[celWb e\ j^[ _dj[hdWb eYY_f_jWb Yh[ij" Wle_Z_d] ZWcW][ jej^[eYY_f_jWbi_dki<_]$+$&$'+$
<_]$+$&$',
Ij[f+ 7\j[hYWh[\kb[nfeikh[e\ j^[ZkhWcWj[hWdZ j^[eYY_f_jWbi_dki"Wdeij[efbWij_YYhWd_ejeco _i f[h\ehc[Z ki_d] W ^_]^#if[[Z YhWd_ejec[$
<_]$+$&$'-
Ij[f, 7YYehZ_d] je j^[ YhWd_ejeco b_d[i" j^[ j^_Ya feij[h_eh cWh]_d e\ j^[ \ehWc[d cW]dkc _i j^[d h[cel[Z ki_d] W ^_]^#if[[Z Zh_bb" Wle_Z# _d]_d`khojej^[ZkhWcWj[he\j^[bWj[hWbYhW# d_eY[hl_YWb `kdYj_ed$ Dej[ Wle_Z_d] ikh]_YWb _d`khojej^[l[hj[XhWbWhj[ho<_]$+$&$'-$
'.,
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
Ij[f-7 EXi[hl_d] j^[ lWbb[YkbW WdZ j^[ \ekhj^ l[d# jh_Yb["j^[Xed[ÔWfi^ekbZX[[b[lWj[Zm_j^W Xbkdj Z_ii[Yjeh$ Ki_d] j^_i Çef[d#ZeehÈ j[Y^# d_gk[" j^[ ÔWf _i h[jhWYj[Z YWkZWbbo m_j^ekj Z[jWY^_d]\hec j^[WjbWdjeeYY_f_jWbb_]Wc[dj WdZÓn[Zj[cfehWh_boedj^[dkY^Wbb_]Wc[dj$ D[l[hj^[b[ii" j^_i ikXeYY_f_jWb a[o^eb[ Ze[i dej e\\[h WZ[gkWj[ [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ Y[hl_Ye# c[ZkbbWho`kdYj_ed<_]$+$&$'.7$
<_]$+$&$'.7
Ij[f-8 ?\ l_ikWb_pWj_ed e\ j^[ kff[h Y[hl_YWb if_d[ _i h[gk_h[Z" Wd [nj[dZ[Z ikXeYY_f_jWb YhWd_e# jecockijX[f[h\ehc[Z$7\j[hh[celWbe\j^[ Xed[ÔWf"j^[ikf[h_ehXehZ[he\j^[feij[h_eh WhY^ e\ j^[ WjbWi i^ekbZ Wbie X[ WZZ_j_edWbbo h[cel[Z$J^_ifWhj_Wbh[celWbe\j^[feij[h_eh WhY^ m_j^ekj 9' bWc_d[Yjeco Wbbemi WZZ_# j_edWb [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ YhWd_eY[hl_YWb h[]_ed" WdZW\j[hZkhWbef[d_d]"ef[dl_ikWb_pWj_ede\ j^[Y[hl_Yec[ZkbbWho`kdYj_ed<_]$+$&$'.8$
<_]$+$&$'.8
Ij[f. J^[ZkhW_ief[d[Z_dWh[l[hi[O#i^Wf[Z\Wi^# _ed [nj[dZ_d] jemWhZ j^[ \ehWc[d cW]dkc WdZj^[\h[[ZkhWbÔWfiWh[Ón[Zm_j^^ebZ_d] ikjkh[i$ ?d oekd] Y^_bZh[d" j^[ ZkhW cWo X[ \kbbe\l[dekiY^Wdd[biWdZWfhec_d[djcWh# ]_dWbi_dkicWoX[fh[i[dj_dj^[h[]_ede\j^[ \ehWc[dcW]dkc$J^_icWoXb[[Z[nY[ii_l[bo kfedZkhWbef[d_d]WdZ^[ceYb_fiehikjkh[i i^ekbZX[ki[Z\eh^[ceijWi_i<_]$+$&$'/$
<_]$+$&$'/
'.-
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
*$?djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ij[f' :_ii[Yj_ed f[h\ehc[Z ed W \h[i^ ^kcWd YWZWl[h$J^[l[ii[biWh[fh[fWh[Zm_j^Yebeh[Z bWj[n iebkj_ed$ 7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ ZkhW cWj[h" j^[_djWYjWhWY^de_Zc[cXhWd[ie\j^[]h[Wj Y[h[X[bbec[ZkbbWho Y_ij[hd YWd X[ i[[d$ J^[ Óhij ij[f _i j^[ ik\ÓY_[dj ZhW_dW][ e\ 9I< Xo ef[d_d] j^[ WhWY^de_Z i^[[j$ J^_i ^[bfi \kh# j^[h h[bWnWj_ed e\ j^[ XhW_d Xo h[b[Wi_d] 9I< WdZ m_bb _d_j_Wj[ Z_ii[Yj_ed e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbWh jedi_bi" j^[l[hc_Wdf[]"WdZ j^[Ôeehe\ j^[ \ekhj^l[djh_Yb[<_]$+$&$(&$
c[ZkbbWeXbed]WjW Y[h[X[bbkc
<_]$+$&$(&
Ij[f( 7\j[hef[d_d]WdZh[jhWYj_ede\j^[WhWY^de_Z" j^[ Y[hl_Yec[ZkbbWho `kdYj_ed _i i[[d WdZ" _d fWhj"j^[ikXeYY_f_jWbikh\WY[e\j^[Y[h[X[bbkc$ Dej[ j^[ beXkbki X_l[dj[h WdZ j^[ Y[h[X[bbWh jedi_bi^_Z_d] j^[l_[m_dje j^[\ekhj^l[djh_# Yb[$J^[l[hj[XhWbWhj[h_[iYWdX[eXi[hl[Zed Xej^i_Z[ie\j^[c[ZkbbW1j^[F?97Z_iWff[Whi _djej^[Y[h[X[bbec[ZkbbWhoÓiikh[<_]$+$&$('$
L7 Y[hl_Yec[ZkbbWho `kdYj_ed YWkZWbbeefe\F?97 Y[h[X[bbWhjedi_b beXkbkiX_l[dj[h
<_]$+$&$('
Ij[f) :_ii[Yj_d]ceh[bWj[hWbbo" j^[[djhWdY[e\ j^[ h_]^j L7 _dje j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb ifWY[ YWd X[ eXi[hl[Z$ Dej[ j^[ Y[hl_YWb heej e\ j^[ 9D N? WdZ j^[ Óhij Z[dj_YkbWj[ b_]Wc[dj$ Dej[ j^[ WhWY^de_Z c[cXhWd[ e\ j^[ ]h[Wj Y[h[X[bbe# c[ZkbbWhoY_ij[hd<_]$+$&$(($
ÓhijZ[dj_YkbWj[ b_]Wc[dj"h_]^jL7 9DN? WhWY^de_ZXehZ[h e\j^[Y[h[X[bbe# c[ZkbbWhoY_ij[hd
<_]$+$&$((
'..
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
Ij[f* 7\j[hYWh[\kbh[jhWYj_ede\j^[XhW_dij[c"j^[ [djhWdY[ e\ j^[ 9D N?? _dje j^[ ^ofe]beiiWb YWdWbYWdX[i[[d$Dej[ j^[h_]^jL7WdZ j^[ 9DN?<_]$+$&$()$
L7 DN? DN??
<_]$+$&$()
Ij[f+ 7\j[hceX_b_pWj_ede\j^[Y[h[X[bbkc"j^[9DN WdZ 8eY^ZWb[aÊi Y^ehe_Z fb[nki e\ j^[ \ekhj^ l[djh_Yb[YWdX[eXi[hl[Z$Dej[ j^[Óhijbeef e\j^[F?97Ybei[jej^[YWkZWbYhWd_Wbd[hl[i <_]$+$&$(*$
9DN h_]^jF?97 Y^ehe_Zfb[nki e\8eY^ZWb[a
<_]$+$&$(*
Ij[f, <eYki_d] ceh[ c[Z_Wbbo" j^[ h_]^j jedi_b _i h[jhWYj[Z$ 8ej^ feij[h_eh Y[h[X[bbWh Whj[h_[i Z_iWff[Wh _dje W jh_Wd]b[#\ehc[Z Y^WcX[h X[jm[[d j^[ jme jedi_bi" j^[ ie#YWbb[Z lWb# b[YkbW$ Dej[ j^[ Y[h[X[bbec[ZkbbWho Óiikh[" j^[dWhhemifWY[X[jm[[dj^[jedi_biWdZj^[ c[ZkbbWeXbed]WjW<_]$+$&$(+$
b[\jF?97 h_]^jF?97 b[\jjedi_b h[jhWYj[Zh_]^j jedi_b
<_]$+$&$(+
'./
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
Ij[f- Je[nfei[j^[Y^WcX[he\j^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[" j^[ jedi_bi i^ekbZ X[ cel[Z WmWo \hec j^[ c[ZkbbW" jWa_d] YWh[ dej je ZWcW][ j^[ fei# j[h_eh_d\[h_ehY[h[X[bbWhWhj[h_[i$J^[j[bWY^e# he_Z[W _i YWh[\kbbo Z_ii[Yj[Z \hec j^[ jW[d_W e\ j^[c[ZkbbWeXbed]WjW"[dbWh]_d] j^[\ehW# c[de\CW][dZ_[$Dej[j^[YWkZWbfWhje\j^[ \ekhj^l[djh_Yb[<_]$+$&$(,$
j[bWY^ehe_Z[W YWkZWb\ekhj^ l[djh_Yb[
<_]$+$&$(,
h_]^jWh[W feijh[cW ^ofe]beiiWb WdZlW]Wbjh_]ed[ c[ZkbbWhoijh_W[
Ij[f. 7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ \ehWc[d e\ CW][dZ_[ WdZ Z_ii[Yj_ede\j^[j[bWY^ehe_Z[WWmWo\hecj^[ jW[d_W e\ j^[ c[ZkbbW eXbed]WjW" j^[ _d\[h_eh c[ZkbbWho l[bkc WdZ j^[ l[hc_i Wh[ ][djbo h[jhWYj[Z"fhel_Z_d]WXheWZl_[me\j^[\ekhj^ l[djh_Yb[$ J^[ YWkZWb fWhj e\ j^[ h^ecXe_Z \eiiW Wff[Whi m_j^ j^[ jh_]ed[ e\ j^[ ^ofe# ]beiiWb WdZ lW]ki d[hl[$ J^[ Wh[W feijh[cW" Wjh_Wd]kbWhÓ[bZYWkZWbjej^[jh_]ed[e\j^[ lW]ki d[hl[ m_j^ ijhed]bo lWiYkbWh_p[Z h[Z# Z_i^]b_W#h_Y^j_iik["YWdWbieX[m[bbeXi[hl[Z$ Dej[j^[m^_j[j_iik[e\j^[c[ZkbbWhoijh_W[ <_]$+$&$(-$
<_]$+$&$(-
Ij[f/ Ki_d] WZ[gkWj[ ^[WZ fei_j_ed_d] WdZ YWh[# \kbikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_ed"[nfeikh[e\j^[YhWd_Wb fWhje\j^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[_ifeii_Xb[m_j^ekj _dY_i_edWdZifb_jj_d]e\j^[l[hc_i"j^kiWle_Z# _d]i[l[h[feijef[hWj_l[WjWn_W$J^[\WY_WbYeb# b_Ykbki Wff[Whi YhWd_Wb \hec j^[ c[ZkbbWho ijh_W[WYYehZ_d]jej^[][dke\j^[\WY_Wbd[hl[$ Dej[ j^[ c[Z_Wd [c_d[dY[ X[jm[[d j^[ c[Z_WdWdZb_c_j_d]ikbYki$Dej[j^[Y[h[XhWb Wgk[ZkYj WdZ j^[ ikf[h_eh c[ZkbbWho l[bkc <_]$+$&$(.
\WY_WbYebb_Ykbki c[Z_WdikbYki c[Z_Wd[c_d[dY[ b_c_j_d]ikbYki Wgk[ZkYj ikf[h_eh c[ZkbbWhol[bkc
<_]$+$&$(.
'/&
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
Ij[f'& :_ii[Yj_d] ceh[ bWj[hWbbo m_j^_d j^[ l[djh_Yk# bWhY^WcX[h"j^[l[ij_XkbWhWh[WWdZj^[bWj[hWb h[Y[iie\j^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[YWdX[eXi[hl[Z$ Dej[j^[c[ZkbbWhoijh_W["\WY_WbYebb_YkbkiWdZ j^[b_c_j_d]ikbYkie\j^[h^ecXe_Z\eiiW<_]$ +$&$(/
c[ZkbbWhoijh_W[ \WY_WbYebb_Ykbki b_c_j_d]ikbYki bWj[hWbh[Y[ii
<_]$+$&$(/
Ij[f'' EXi[hl_d] W]W_d j^[ YhWd_eY[hl_YWb `kdYj_ed" j^[ZkhWb[djhWdY[e\j^[b[\jl[hj[XhWbWhj[ho YWd X[ i[[d$ Dej[ j^[ Óhij Z[dj_YkbWj[ b_]W# c[dj$J^[if_dWbheeje\j^[9DN?Yheii[ij^[ _djhWYhWd_WbL7WdZj^[9DN??Z_iWff[Whi_dje j^[^ofe]beiiWbYWdWb<_]$+$&$)&
[njhWZkhWbL7 Z[dj_YkbWj[ b_]Wc[dj _djhWZkhWbL7 9DN? 9DN??
<_]$+$&$)&
Ij[f'( :_ii[Yj_ed i^emi j^[ _djhW# WdZ [njhWZkhWb Yekhi[e\j^[L7"j^[XbkdjZ_ii[Yjehfe_djije j^[ÓhijY[hl_YWbheejW\j[hh[celWbe\j^[fei# j[hebWj[hWbZkhWe\j^[YhWd_eY[hl_YWb`kdYj_ed$ Dej[j^[if_dWbfWhje\j^[9DN?<_]$+$&$)'
ÓhijY[hl_YWbheej L7 9DN?
<_]$+$&$)'
'/'
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
+$:khW"Xed[WdZmekdZYbeikh[ 9beikh[e\c_Zb_d[feij[h_eh\eiiW[nfeikh[ickijX[f[h\ehc[Z c[j_Ykbekibo$ 7\j[h Yecfb[j_ed e\ j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[" j^[ _djhWZkhWbifWY[_iÓbb[Zm_j^H_d][hiebkj_edWjXeZoj[cf[hWjkh[$ J^[ZkhWb_dY_i_ed_iYbei[Zm_j^_dj[hhkfj[Zikjkh[i$?\i^h_daW][ ^WiZ[l[bef[Z_dj^[ZkhWbfbWd["m^_Y^_iW\h[gk[djfheXb[c"W icWbbf_[Y[e\ckiYb[YWdX[i[md_djej^[ZkhWbYbeikh[$?dej^[h YWi[i"WdWhj_ÓY_WbZkhWb]hW\jYWdX[ki[Z$7\j[hmWj[hj_]^jZkhWb Ybeikh["WfbWj[e\][b\eWc_ifbWY[Z[njhWZkhWbbo$J^[Xed[i^ekbZ X[ h[WjjWY^[Z ki_d] j_jWd_kc fbWj[i$ 7\j[h ÓdWb l[h_ÓYWj_ed e\ ^[ceijWi_i" j^[ ckiYb[i i^ekbZ X[ Ybei[Z _d WdWjec_YWb bWo[hi$ J^[ikXYkjWd[ekibWo[h_iYbei[Zm_j^_dj[hhkfj[Zikjkh[iWdZj^[ ia_dm_j^hkdd_d]eh_dj[hhkfj[Zikjkh[i$IkYj_edZhW_dW][_idej h[gk_h[Z$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i Feeh fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d] m_j^ feeh [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ jWh][j h[]_ed WdZ i_]d_ÓYWdj Z[j[h_ehWj_ed _d [\ÓY_[dYo e\ ikh]_YWbbo [nY_i_d]j^[b[i_ed$FbWdd_d]_ij^[ceij_cfehjWdjfWhje\ikh# ][hoWdZj^[jWiae\j^[ikh][ed ?dWZ[gkWj[fei_j_ed_d]e\j^[fWj_[djm_j^_dik\ÓY_[dj[nfeikh[ e\j^[jWh][j$ Beii e\ j^[ c_Zb_d[" Z_ii[Yj_d] j^[ Z[[f ikXeYY_f_jWb ckiYb[i$ J^_i YWd YWki[ kdmWhhWdj[Z Xb[[Z_d]" _dWZ[gkWj[ [nfeikh[ e\ j^[Xedoikh\WY[WdZfeijef[hWj_l[Z_iYec\ehj$ ?d`khojej^[eYY_f_jWbi_dkiW\j[hXkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_edeh_d`kho je j^[ cWh]_dWb i_dki W\j[h YhWd_ejeco m_j^ [nY[ii_l[ l[deki Xb[[Z_d]$ ?dWZ[gkWj[h[celWbe\9I<Wjj^[ÓhijijW][e\j^[_djhWYhWd_Wb Z_ii[Yj_edm_j^ikXi[gk[dj_d`khojej^[Y[h[X[bbWhikh\WY[$ D[[Z je ifb_j j^[ _d\[h_eh l[hc_i W\j[h _dWZ[gkWj[ fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d]"feehfWj_[djfei_j_ed_d]eh_dWZ[gkWj[YhWd_ejeco$ ?d`kho je i[di_j_l[ d[khelWiYkbWh ijhkYjkh[i e\ j^[ Y[hl_Ye# c[ZkbbWhh[]_edWdZY[h[X[bbec[ZkbbWhoÓiikh[m_j^feijef[hW# j_l[d[khebe]_YWbi[gk[bW[$ ?d`khojej^[h^ecXe_Z\eiiWZkh_d]jkcehh[celWbm_j^ikXi[# gk[dji[l[h[YhWd_Wbd[hl[Z_iehZ[hi$ Feijef[hWj_l[^oZheY[f^WbkiZk[je_dYecfb[j[jkcehh[celWb eh_djhWl[djh_YkbWhXbeeZYbej$?dikY^YWi[i"[dZeiYef_Yj^_hZl[d# jh_Ykbeijecoi^ekbZX[f[h\ehc[Zm_j^j[cfehWho_cfbWdjWj_ed e\Wl[djh_YkbWhZhW_d$
'/(
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
?dWZ[gkWj[ZkhWbYbeikh[m_j^feijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW$ ?dWZ[gkWj[fei_j_ed_d]WdZÓnWj_ede\j^[Xed[ÔWf$ ?dWZ[gkWj[^[ceijWi_iYWki_d]feijef[hWj_l[ie\jj_iik[^[cW# jecW$
<_]$+$&$)(
J_fiWdZjh_Yai JWa[j_c[\ehfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]e\fWj_[dji$ J^[h[ikbj_iWd[nY[bb[djel[hl_[me\j^[jWh][jWh[WWdZWd[\Ó# Y_[djmeha_d]fei_j_edZkh_d]ikh][ho$ <_]$+$&$)) 7
8
CWa[WYWh[\kbWdWjec_YWbeh_[djWj_edWdZki[ j^[ j^h[[ij[fi e\ cWha_d] m_j^ W ij[h_b[ f[d0 '$ eii[eki ijhkYjkh[i WdZ ikf[h# ÓY_Wb d[khelWiYkbWh ijhkYjkh[i1 ($ fbWY[c[dj e\ YhWd_ejeco1 )$ia_d_dY_i_ed$ Ki_d]W9edYehZ[fhed[fei_j_ed"Y[h[X[bbWhh[jhWYj_edWdZifb_j# j_d]e\j^[_d\[h_ehl[hc_iYWdX[[\\[Yj_l[boWle_Z[Z<_]$+$&$)($
<_]$+$&$)* 7
8
IjW][i e\ j^[ ikXeYY_f_jWb Çef[d#ZeehÈ a[o^eb[ YhWd_ejeco <_]$+$&$))7"80 '$ jme fWhWc[Z_Wd Xkhh ^eb[i WdZ h[celWb e\ j^[ _dj[hdWb eYY_f_jWb Yh[ij1 ($ YhWd_ejeco ki_d] W ^_]^#if[[Z YhWd_ejec[1)$[b[lWj_ede\j^[Xed[ÔWfWdZ*$j[cfehWhoÓnW# j_ededj^[dkY^Wbb_]Wc[dj IjW][i e\ YhWd_ejeco <_]$+$&$)*7"80 '$ jme fWhWc[Z_Wd Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_edi1($c[Z_WdikXeYY_f_jWbYhWd_ejeco1)$Zk[ je fWhj_Wbh[celWbe\j^[feij[h_ehWhY^e\j^[WjbWim_j^ekjbWc_# d[Yjeco j^[[nfbehWj_ede\ j^[Y[hl_Ye#c[ZkbbWho`kdYj_edYWd X[[nj[dZ[Z$
<_]$+$&$)+
J^[ZkhWi^ekbZX[ef[d[Z_dWh[l[hi[ÇOÈ#i^Wf[Z\Wi^_edWle_Z# _d]_d`khojej^[eYY_f_jWbi_dki$?doekd]fWj_[djiWdZY^_bZh[d" [nj[di_l[ i_dkie_Z l[ii[bi WhekdZ j^[ \ehWc[d cW]dkc cWo X[fh[i[djm^_Y^i^ekbZX[eYYbkZ[Zm_j^^[ceYb_fiehikjkh[i <_]$+$&$)+$ J^[Óhijij[fe\j^[_djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_edi^ekbZX[j^[ef[d_d] e\j^[Y[h[X[bbec[ZkbbWhY_ij[hdWdZik\ÓY_[dj9I<ZhW_dW][$ 7\j[h Ód_i^_d] j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[" j^[ ZkhWb ef[d_d] i^ekbZX[Ybei[ZmWj[hj_]^jki_d]_dj[hhkfj[Zehhkdd_d]ikjkh[i$
'/)
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^
?\j[di_ed^WiZ[l[bef[Z"m^_Y^_idejkdYecced"WicWbbf_[Y[ e\ckiYb[YWdX[i[md_djej^[ZkhWbYbeikh[$?dej^[hYWi[iWd Whj_ÓY_WbZkhWb]hW\ji^ekbZX[ki[Z<_]$+$&$),$ 7\j[hZkhWbYbeikh["j^[Xed[ÔWfi^ekbZX[j_]^jboÓn[Zm_j^W j_jWd_kcfbWj[$ J^[ Z[[f ikXeYY_f_jWb ckiYb[i i^ekbZ X[ c[j_Ykbekibo Ybei[Z _dWdWjec_YWbbWo[hi$J^_iWbie^[bfijeWle_Zfeijef[hWj_l[9I< b[WaW][$ IkYj_ed ZhW_d i^ekbZ dej X[ ki[Z je Wle_Z feijef[hWj_l[ 9I< b[Wa$
'/*
<_]$+$&$),
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^ r YWkZWblWh_Wj_ed
+$' 9WkZWblWh_Wj_ede\j^[ c[Z_WdikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^ J^[c[Z_WdikXeYY_f_jWb_d\hWY[h[X[bbWhWffheWY^Wbbemil_ikWb_pWj_ed e\j^[cW_dfWhje\j^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[$?diec[YWi[i"^em[l[h"j^[ YhWd_WbfWhje\j^[l[djh_YkbWhY^WcX[hYWdX[WffheWY^[ZedboW\j[h [nY[ii_l[h[jhWYj_edeh[l[dfWhj_Wbi[Yj_ed_d]e\j^[_d\[h_ehl[hc_i" h[ikbj_d]_dfeijef[hWj_l[YeehZ_dWj_edZ_ijkhXWdY[iWdZWjWn_W$Je Wle_ZZ[ijhkYj_ede\i[di_j_l[d[khWbj_iik["[nfeikh[e\j^[YhWd_Wb \ekhj^l[djh_Yb[WdZj^[Iobl_WdWgk[ZkYji^ekbZ\ebbemj^[fbWd[ e\ j^[ h^ecXe_Z \eiiW" fbWY_d] j^[ ZkhWb ef[d_d] Wi YWkZWbbo Wi feii_Xb[$ 7
J^[ [ii[dY[ e\ j^[ YWkZWb lWh_Wj_ed e\ j^[ c[Z_Wd ikXeYY_f_jWb WffheWY^ _i [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ kff[h fWhj e\ j^[ \ekhj^ l[djh_Yb[ j^hek]^ j^[ \ehWc[d cW]dkc \hec W YWkZWb Z_h[Yj_ed$ 7\j[h W YhWd_eY[hl_YWb c_Zb_d[ ia_d _dY_i_ed WdZ ie\j j_iik[ Z_ii[Yj_ed" j^[ feij[h_ehWhY^e\j^[WjbWiWdZj^[if_dekifheY[iie\j^[Wn_iWh[ fWhj_Wbboh[cel[Z"h[l[Wb_d]j^[feij[h_ehYhWd_eY[hl_YWbh[]_edWdZ \ehWc[d cW]dkc$ 7\j[h W b_c_j[Z ZkhWb ef[d_d]" j^[ h^ecXe_Z \eiiWe\j^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[_dYbkZ_d]j^[Iobl_WdWgk[ZkYjYWdX[ eXi[hl[Z<_]$+$'$'$
8
<_]$+$'$' 9WkZWb lWh_Wj_ed e\ j^[ c[Z_Wd ikXeYY_f_jWb WffheWY^W\j[hfWhj_Wbh[celWbe\j^[feij[h_ehWhY^e\9' WdZj^[if_dekifheY[iie\9(7$9ecfWh[Zm_j^j^[XWi_Y ikXeYY_f_jWb[nfeikh[8j^[YWkZWblWh_WdjWle_Zih[jhWY# j_ede\j^[Y[h[X[bbkc[nfei_d]j^[Iobl_WdWgk[ZkYj$
'/+
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^ r YWkZWblWh_Wj_ed
9hWd_eY[hl_YWb`kdYj_ed
<ekhj^l[djh_Yb[
J^_hZl[djh_Yb[
Feij[h_ehWdZfeij[hebWj[hWbY_hYkc\[h[dY[ e\j^[\ehWc[dcW]dkc Feij[h_ehWhY^e\j^[WjbWi If_dekifheY[iie\j^[Wn_i CWh]_dWbi_dki 9[hl_Yec[ZkbbWho`kdYj_ed Feij[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[c[ZkbbWeXbed]WjW 9[h[X[bbWhjedi_bi Bem[hl[hc_i LWbb[YkbW ?d\[h_ehc[ZkbbWhol[bkc 9^ehe_Zfb[nkie\j^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[ <ehWc[de\CW][dZ_[ F?97
9^ehe_Zfb[nkie\j^[\ekhj^ l[djh_Yb[ H^ecXe_Z\eiiW <Wij_]_kc Ikf[h_ehc[ZkbbWhol[bkc 9[h[XhWbWgk[ZkYj
Feij[h_ehY^WcX[he\j^[j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[
JWXb[+$'$' 7dWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[ih[WY^[ZXoj^[YWkZWblWh_Wj_ede\j^[c[Z_WdikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^$
'/,
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^ r YWkZWblWh_Wj_ed
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[ '$FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] I_c_bWhjej^[c[Z_WdikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^"j^[fWj_[dj_iXhek]^j _dje j^[ fhed[ fei_j_ed$ =eWb e\ j^[ fei_j_ed_d] _i j^[ cWn_cWb _dYb_dWj_ede\j^[^[WZ"Wbbem_d]ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_edfWhWbb[bjej^[ fbWd[e\j^[h^ecXe_Z\eiiW$
<_]$+$'$(
Ij[f' 7\j[h Ón_d] _d j^[ j^h[[#f_d ^[WZ ^ebZ[h" j^[ XeZo WdZ j^[ ^[WZ Wh[[b[lWj[ZYW$(&je)&edj^[ef[hWj_d]jWXb[$J^_i[b[lWj_ed_i d[Y[iiWhojeXh_d]j^[^[WZWXel[j^[b[l[be\j^[j^ehWnWbbem_d] efj_cWbl[dekiZhW_dW][<_]$+$'$($ Ij[f( ?dWi[YedZij[f" j^[^[WZcWoX[cWn_cWbboWdj[heÔ[Yj[Z$J^_i [njh[c[ 9edYehZ[ fei_j_ed Wbbemi Wd [\ÓY_[dj meha_d] Z_h[Yj_ed WYYehZ_d] je j^[ fbWd[ e\ j^[ h^ecXe_Z \eiiW$ If[Y_Wb Wjj[dj_ed i^ekbZX[]_l[djeWle_Zi[l[h[Yecfh[ii_ede\j^[bWhodnm_j^j^[ l[dj_bWj_edjkX[WdZj^[cW_dY[hl_YWbl[ii[bi<_]$+$'$)$
<_]$+$'$)
Ij[f) 7ij^[jWh][je\j^[WffheWY^_ij^[c_Z#beYWj[Z\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[ WdZ Wgk[ZkYj" hejWj_ed eh bWj[heÔ[n_ed e\ j^[ ^[WZ _i dej d[Y[i# iWho<_]$+$'$*$
<_]$+$'$*
'/-
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^ r YWkZWblWh_Wj_ed
($7dWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZeh_[djWj_ed <eh fh[ef[hWj_l[ eh_[djWj_ed" j^[ _cfehjWdj WdWjec_YWb bWdZ# cWhaie\j^[feij[hebWj[hWbeii[ekiiakbbWdZif_d["[$]$"j^[[nj[h# dWb eYY_f_jWb fhejkX[hWdY[" \ehWc[d cW]dkc" cWije_Z fheY[ii" WdZ j^[ if_deki fheY[ii[i e\ 9( je 9* Wh[ fh[Y_i[bo Z[j[hc_d[Z <_]$+$'$+$ 7\j[h[nWYjeh_[djWj_ed"j^[^W_he\j^[ikXeYY_f_jWbWh[Wi^ekbZX[ YecX[Zehi^Wl[ZWYYehZ_d]jej^[ikXeYY_f_jWbc_Zb_d[ia_d_dY_# i_ed<_]$+$'$+$J^[ia_d_iZ_i_d\[Yj[Zc[j_Ykbekibo$
<_]$+$'$+ :[Ód_j_ed e\ j^[ ikh]_YWb WffheWY^ WYYehZ_d] je j^[ WdWjec_YWb bWdZcWhai e\ j^[ feij[h_eh YhWd_eY[h# l_YWbh[]_ed$J^[c_Zb_d[ia_d_dY_i_edi^ekbZ[nj[dZ\hec j^[[Wi_bofWbfWXb[9)if_dekifheY[iikfjej^[\ehWc[d cW]dkc$
'/.
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^ r YWkZWblWh_Wj_ed
)$9hWd_ejecoWdZZkhWbef[d_d] Ij[f' 7\j[h fWj_[dj fei_j_ed_d] WdZ WdWjec_YWb eh_# [djWj_ed" j^[ ia_d _i fh[fWh[Z m_j^ WbYe^eb iebkj_ed$ 7 ijhW_]^j c_Zb_d[ _dY_i_ed _i j^[d cWZ[ [nj[dZ_d] \hec j^[ \ehWc[d cW]dkc jej^[if_dekifheY[iie\9)$7\j[hh[jhWYj_ede\ j^[ ia_d" j^[ b_]Wc[djkc dkY^W[ _i fh[Y_i[bo Z[Ód[Z WYYehZ_d] je j^[ c_Zb_d[$ I_c_bWh je j^[c[Z_WdikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^"ie\jj_iik[ Z_ii[Yj_ed WdZ i[fWhWj_ed e\ j^[ ikXeYY_f_jWb ckiYb[ii^ekbZX[Zed[ijh_Yjbo_dj^[c_Zb_d[ Wle_Z_d]Ykjj_d]_dje^_]^bolWiYkbWhckiYkbWh j_iik[<_]$+$'$,$
<_]$+$'$,
<_]$+$'$-
Ij[f( 7i[b\#h[jW_d_d]h[jhWYjeh_iki[Zje^ebZXWYa j^[ j^_Ya ckiYkbWh bWo[h" [$]$" j^[ jhWf[p_ki" ifb[d_ki WdZ i[c_if_dWb_i YWf_j_i ckiYb[i" [nfei_d]j^[feij[h_ehYhWd_eY[hl_YWb`kdYj_ed$ J^[h[YjkiYWf_j_ifeij[h_ehcW`ehWh_i[im_j^W fe_dj[Z j[dZed \hec j^[ if_deki fheY[ii e\ j^[Wn_i"j^[h[YjkiYWf_j_ifeij[h_ehc_dehed j^[feij[h_ehjkX[hYb[e\j^[WjbWi$8ej^cki# Yb[i Wh[ Z_ii[Yj[Z \hec j^[_h _di[hj_ed WdZ h[jhWYj[Z bWj[hWbbo" eXi[hl_d] j^[ \ehWc[d cW]dkc"feij[h_ehWhY^e\9'WdZj^[if_deki fheY[ii e\ 9($ 7le_Z_d] W Yecfb[j[ bWc_d[Y# jeco" j^[ jef e\ j^[ if_deki fheY[ii e\ j^[ Wn_i _i h[cel[Z ki_d] W ^_]^#if[[Z Zh_bb <_]$+$'$-$
<_]$+$'$.
Ij[f) J^[h[W\j[h" j^[ ikf[h_eh fWhj e\ j^[ feij[h_eh WhY^e\j^[WjbWi_ih[cel[Z[dbWh]_d]j^[\ehW# c[dcW]dkc<_]$+$'$.$
'//
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^ r YWkZWblWh_Wj_ed
<_]$+$'$/
Ij[f* J^[h[W\j[h"j^[feij[h_ehcWh]_de\j^[\ehWc[d cW]dkc _i h[cel[Z [nfei_d] j^[ feij[h_eh WjbWdje#eYY_f_jWbc[cXhWd[$HWf_ZWdZfh[Y_i[ beYWb^[ceijWi_i_id[Y[iiWho<_]$+$'$/$
<_]$+$'$'&
Ij[f+ 7\j[h Xed[ h[celWb" j^[ Z_h[Yj_ed e\ l_[m _i Y^Wd][Z dej[ iY^[cWj_Y f_Yjkh[ ed j^[ b[\j" eXi[hl_d] j^[ feij[h_eh cWh]_d e\ j^[ \ehW# c[dcW]dkc\hecWYWkZWbWif[Yj$J^[fei# j[h_eh WjbWdje#eYY_f_jWb c[cXhWd[ _i fWhj_Wbbo h[cel[Z eh _dY_i[Z WYYehZ_d] je j^[ ZkhWb ef[d_d]<_]$+$'$'&$
<_]$+$'$''
Ij[f, J^[ ZkhW _i ef[d[Z _d W ijhW_]^j eh h[l[hi[O# i^Wf[Z \Wi^_ed WdZ j^[ \h[[ ZkhWb ÔWfi Wh[ h[jhWYj[Z m_j^ ^ebZ_d] ikjkh[i$ M^[d fhec_# d[dji_dkie_Zl[ii[biWh[fh[i[dj"fWhj_YkbWhbo _doekd]Y^_bZh[d"^[ceYb_fiehikjkh[ii^ekbZ X[ki[Z\ehik\ÓY_[dj^[ceijWi_i<_]$+$'$''$
(&&
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^ r YWkZWblWh_Wj_ed
*$?djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ij[f' :_ii[Yj_ed f[h\ehc[Z ed W \h[i^ ^kcWd YWZWl[h$Dej[j^[h[ZWhj[h_WbWdZXbk[l[deki l[ii[bi$ 7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ ZkhW cWj[h" j^[ _djWYjWhWY^de_Zc[cXhWd[ie\j^[]h[WjY[h# [X[bbec[ZkbbWhoY_ij[hdYWdX[i[[d$Ik\ÓY_[dj ZhW_dW][ e\ 9I< Xo ef[d_d] j^[ WhWY^de_Z c[cXhWd[ie\\[hi_cc[Z_Wj[Z[Yecfh[ii_ed e\j^[feij[h_eh\eiiW$Dej[j^[Y[h[X[bbWhjed# i_biWdZj^[YWkZWbbeefe\j^[F?97Wff[Wh_d] j^hek]^j^[WhWY^de_ZWbbWo[hi<_]$+$'$'($
F?97 Y[h[X[bbec[ZkbbWhoY_ij[hd b[\jY[h[X[bbWhjedi_b
<_]$+$'$'(
Ij[f( 7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ WhWY^de_Z e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbe# c[ZkbbWho Y_ij[hd" j^[ h[]_ed e\ j^[ lWbb[YkbW _i eXi[hl[Z$ Dej[ j^[ c[Z_Wb Wif[Yj e\ Xej^ jedi_bi WYYehZ_d] je j^[ b_c_j[Z ZkhWb ef[d# _d]$ J^[ F?97 Z_iWff[Whi _dje j^[ lWbb[YkbW <_]$+$'$')$
F?97 h_]^jjedi_b b[\jjedi_b
<_]$+$'$')
Ij[f) 7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ \ehWc[d e\ CW][dZ_[" j^[ jedi_bi WdZ j^[ _d\[h_eh l[hc_i m_j^ j^[ Y^e# he_Zfb[nkiWh[][djboh[jhWYj[Z[nfei_d] j^[ Y^WcX[h e\ j^[ \ekhj^ l[djh_Yb[$ J^[ if[Y_Wb ikh]_YWbl_[mWbbemil_ikWb_pWj_ede\j^[ikf[# h_ehc[ZkbbWhol[bkc$Dej[j^[h^ecXe_Z\eiiW WdZj^[Y[h[XhWbWgk[ZkYj<_]$+$'$'*$
h^ecXe_Z\eiiW Wgk[ZkYj ikf[h_ehc[ZkbbWhol[bkc
<_]$+$'$'*
(&'
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^ r YWkZWblWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f* M^[deXi[hl_d]j^[YhWd_WbfWhje\j^[\ekhj^ l[djh_Yb[" dej[ j^[ ikf[h_eh c[ZkbbWho l[bkc WdZj^[YWkZWbfWhje\j^[Y[h[XhWbWgk[ZkYj <_]$+$'$'+$
Wgk[ZkYj ikf[h_ehc[ZkbbWhol[bkc
<_]$+$'$'+
Ij[f+ J^[ [djhWdY[ e\ j^[ Y[h[XhWb Wgk[ZkYj l_ikWb# _p[Z\hecj^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[$Dej[j^[h^ec# Xe_Z \eiiW m_j^ j^[ c[ZkbbWho ijh_W[ WdZ j^[ ikf[h_ehc[ZkbbWhol[bkc<_]$+$'$',$
c[ZkbbWhoijh_W[ F?97 ikf[h_ehc[ZkbbWhol[bkc
<_]$+$'$',
Ij[f, M_j^ W ][djb[ Z_ii[Yj_ed" j^[ Wgk[ZkYj _i [dbWh][ZWbbem_d]Wb_c_j[Zl_[m_djej^[fei# j[h_ehj^_hZl[djh_Yb[<_]$+$'$'-$ j^_hZl[djh_Yb[
<_]$+$'$'-
(&(
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^ r YWkZWblWh_Wj_ed
+$:khW"Xed[WdZmekdZYbeikh[ 7\j[hYecfb[j_ede\j^[_djhWYhWd_WbfheY[Zkh["j^[_djhWZkhWbifWY[ _iÓbb[Zm_j^H_d][hiebkj_edWjXeZo j[cf[hWjkh[$J^[ZkhWb_dY_# i_ed_iYbei[Zc[j_Ykbekibom_j^_dj[hhkfj[Zikjkh[i$?\j[di_ed^Wi Z[l[bef[Z_dj^[ZkhWbfbWd["WicWbbf_[Y[e\ckiYb[YWdX[i[md _djej^[ZkhWbYbeikh[1_dej^[hYWi[i"WdWhj_ÓY_WbZkhWb]hW\ji^ekbZ X[ki[Z$7\j[hmWj[hj_]^jZkhWbYbeikh["WfbWj[e\][b\eWc_ifbWY[Z [njhWZkhWbboWdZj^[ikXeYY_f_jWbckiYb[iWh[Ybei[Z_dWdWjec_YWb bWo[hi$J^[ikXYkjWd[ekibWo[h_iYbei[Zm_j^_dj[hhkfj[Zikjkh[i WdZj^[ia_dm_j^hkdd_d]eh_dj[hhkfj[Zikjkh[i$IkYj_edZhW_dW][ _idejh[gk_h[Z$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i ?dWZ[gkWj[fh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]m_j^Yedi[gk[dj_dWZ[gkWj[ [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ jWh][j h[]_ed WdZ i_]d_ÓYWdj Z[j[h_ehWj_ed _d ikh]_YWb[nfeikh[$FbWdd_d]e\j^[fheY[Zkh[ckijX[f[h\ehc[Z Xoj^[ikh][ed :_ii[Yj_ede\j^[Z[[fikXeYY_f_jWbckiYb[ii^ekbZX[f[h\ehc[Z _dj^[c_Zb_d[WYYehZ_d]jej^[dkY^Wbb_]Wc[dj$C_i]k_Z_d]cWo YWki[[nj[di_l[Xb[[Z_d]\hecj^[^_]^bolWiYkbWhj_iik["_dWZ[# gkWj[[nfeikh[e\j^[Xedoikh\WY[WdZfeijef[hWj_l[d[YafW_d m_j^^[WZWY^[$ Feehfei_j_ed_d]e\j^[fWj_[djcWoYWki[_dWZ[gkWj[[nfeikh[ e\j^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[h[gk_h_d]h[jhWYj_edeh[l[difb_jj_d]e\j^[ _d\[h_ehl[hc_i$J^[ikh][edi^ekbZf[h\ehcfWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] ^_ci[b\$ ?d`khojej^[ZkhWZkh_d]YhWd_ejeco$:khWbh[YedijhkYj_edm_j^ ZkhWbcWj[h_WbcWoX[d[Y[iiWho$ ?dWZ[gkWj[h[celWbe\9I<\hecj^[Y[h[X[bbec[ZkbbWhoY_ij[hd m_j^ikXi[gk[dj_d`khojej^[Y[h[X[bbWhikh\WY[Zk[jeifWjkbW fh[iikh[$ ?d`khojei[di_j_l[d[khelWiYkbWhijhkYjkh[ie\j^[Y[hl_Yec[Zkb# bWh h[]_ed" Y[h[X[bbec[ZkbbWho Óiikh[ WdZ \ekhj^ l[djh_Yb[ m_j^ feijef[hWj_l[d[khebe]_YWbi[gk[bW[$ Feijef[hWj_l[ eYYbki_l[ ^oZheY[f^Wbki Zk[ je Ybeikh[ e\ j^[ Y[h[XhWbWgk[ZkYjXojkcehj_iik[eh_djhWl[djh_YkbWhXbeeZYbej$ ?d j^_i [c[h][dYo i_jkWj_ed" [dZeiYef_Y j^_hZ l[djh_Ykbeijeco i^ekbZX[f[h\ehc[Z_cc[Z_Wj[bom_j^j[cfehWho_cfbWdjWj_ed e\Wl[djh_YkbWhZhW_dW][$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ZkhWbYbeikh[m_j^feijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ ^[ceijWi_i YWki_d] feijef[hWj_l[ _djhWYhWd_Wb eh [njhWYhWd_Wbie\jj_iik[^[cWjecW$
(&)
IkXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^ r YWkZWblWh_Wj_ed
J_fiWdZjh_Yai
<_]$+$'$'.W
JWa[j_c[\ehfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]e\fWj_[dji$ J^[h[ikbj_iWd[nY[bb[djel[hl_[me\j^[jWh][jWh[WWdZWd[\Ó# Y_[djmeha_d]fei_j_edZkh_d]ikh][ho$ CWa[WYWh[\kbWdWjec_YWbeh_[djWj_edWdZki[j^[j^h[[ij[fie\ cWha_d]m_j^Wij[h_b[f[d0'$eii[ekiijhkYjkh[i1($Z[Ód_j_ede\ j^[WffheWY^1)$ia_d_dY_i_ed$
<_]$+$'$'.X
Ki_d]W9edYehZ[fhed[fei_j_ed"Y[h[X[bbWhh[jhWYj_edWdZifb_j# j_d]e\j^[_d\[h_ehl[hc_iYWdX[[\\[Yj_l[boWle_Z[Z<_]$+$'$'.W$ Dej[j^[[njh[c[_dYb_dWj_ede\j^[^[WZ<_]$+$'$'.X$ <ehefj_cWb[nfeikh[e\j^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb["j^[if_dekifheY[ii e\9(WdZfeij[h_ehWhY^e\9'i^ekbZX[fWhj_Wbboh[cel[Z1j^[h[# W\j[h j^[ \ehWc[d cW]dkc _i [dbWh][Z WffheWY^_d] j^[ ZkhW cWj[he\j^[feij[h_ehYhWd_eY[hl_YWb`kdYj_ed<_]$+$'$'/$
<_]$+$'$'/
J^[ ZkhW i^ekbZ X[ ef[d[Z _d W ijhW_]^j eh h[l[hi[ÇOÈ#i^Wf[Z \Wi^_edWle_Z_d]_d`khojej^[eYY_f_jWbi_dki$?doekd]fWj_[dji WdZ Y^_bZh[d" [nj[di_l[ i_dkie_Z l[ii[bi WhekdZ j^[ \ehWc[d cW]dkccWoX[fh[i[djm^_Y^i^ekbZX[eYYbkZ[Zm_j^^[ce# Yb_fiehikjkh[i<_]$+$'$(&$ J^[Óhijij[fe\j^[_djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_edi^ekbZX[j^[ef[d_d] e\j^[Y[h[X[bbec[ZkbbWhY_ij[hdWdZik\ÓY_[dj9I<ZhW_dW][$
<_]$+$'$(&
7\j[h Ód_i^_d] j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[" j^[ ZkhWb ef[d_d] i^ekbZX[Ybei[ZmWj[hj_]^jki_d]_dj[hhkfj[Zehhkdd_d]ikjkh[i$ ?\j[di_ed^WiZ[l[bef[Z"m^_Y^_idejkdYecced"WicWbbf_[Y[ e\ckiYb[YWdX[i[md_djej^[ZkhWbYbeikh[$?dej^[hYWi[i"Wd Whj_ÓY_WbZkhWb]hW\ji^ekbZX[ki[Z<_]$+$'$('$ J^[Z[[fikXeYY_f_jWbckiYb[ii^ekbZX[c[j_YkbekiboYbei[Z_d WdWjec_YWbbWo[him_j^ekjki_d]WikYj_edZhW_d$J^_iWbie^[bfi jeWle_Zfeijef[hWj_l[9I<b[WaW][$
(&*
<_]$+$'$('
F_d[WbWffheWY^
,$& F_d[WbWffheWY^ >_ijehoe\ikh]_YWbWffheWY^[ijej^[f_d[Wbh[]_ed 7dWjec_YWbbo" j^[ beYWj_ed e\ f_d[Wb jkcehi _d j^[ Y[dj[h e\ j^[ _djhWYhWd_WbifWY[WXel[j^[XhW_dij[c^Wl[fh[i[dj[ZWikh]_YWb Y^Wbb[d][jeiW\[[nfeikh[WdZh[celWb$ <_]$,$&$' C[Z_Wd ikXeYY_f_jWb YhWd_[Yjeco \eh WYoij_Yjkcehe\j^[f_d[Wbh[]_ed"fkXb_i^[ZXo Fkii[f_d'/'&$7\j[hZ_l_i_ede\j^[eYY_f_jWbWdZ h_]^jjhWdil[hiWbi_dki"j^[jkcehmWiWffheWY^[Z l_W W jhWdij[djeh_Wb hekj[$ Fkii[f mWi WXb[ je WY^_[l[ W fWhj_Wb jkceh h[i[Yj_ed1 ^em[l[h" j^[ 'o[Wh#ebZfWj_[djZ_[Zedj^[)hZfeijef[hWj_l[ ZWo$
J^[ Óhij Wjj[cfji m[h[ fWbb_Wj_l[ _dj[hl[dj_edi _d ^ef[b[ii YWi[i$ ?d'/&+">Whl[o9ki^_d]h[fehj[ZedWoekd]fWj_[djm_j^Yb_d_YWb [l_Z[dY[e\Wf_d[WbjkcehWdZf[h\ehc[ZX_j[cfehWbZ[Yecfh[i# i_ed Q9ki^_d] '/&+S$ J^[ fWj_[dj Z_[Z iec[ m[[ai bWj[h WdZ ik\# \[h[Z\hecWgkWZh_][c_dWb]b_ecW$J^[Z_\ÓYkbjoe\j^[i[YWi[i_i [cf^Wi_p[Z Xo 9ki^_d]Êi Yedj[cfehWho ijWj[c[dj Çf[hiedWbbo ? ^Wl[d[l[hikYY[[Z[Z_d[nfei_d]Wf_d[Wbjkcehik\ÓY_[djbom[bbje `kij_\oWdWjj[cfjjeh[cel[_jÈ$Ej^[hef[hWj_edim[h[YWhh_[Zekj Xo7hj^khFWff[d^[_cWdZF[hY[_lWb8W_boki_d]eYY_f_jWbZ[Yec# fh[ii_ed m_j^ feeh fWj_[dj ikhl_lWb$ 7hd[ Jeha_bZi[d fkXb_i^[Z W fWbb_Wj_l[ef[hWj_ed_dYWi[im_j^_def[hWXb[eYYbki_ede\j^[Iobl_Wd Wgk[ZkYjQFWff[d^[_c'/&,"8W_bo'/''"'/))"Jeha_bZi[d'/))S$
<_]$,$&$( J^[ Óhij ikYY[ii\kb _d\hWj[djeh_Wb ikfhWY[h[X[bbWh WffheWY^ \eh W f_d[Wb b[i_ed" Z[iYh_X[Z Xo AhWki[ _d '/')$ AhWki[ h[cel[Z W *Ycjkcehm_j^j^[fWj_[dj_dWi_jj_d]fei_j_ed m^eikhl_l[Zm_j^ekjd[khebe]_YWbZ[j[h_ehWj_ed$
:_h[Yj[nfeikh[e\ifWY[#eYYkfo_d]b[i_edie\j^[f_d[Wbh[]_edmWi Óhij h[fehj[Z Xo BkZel_Yki Fkii[f _d '/'& WffheWY^_d] W f_d[Wb Yoij l_W ikXeYY_f_jWb jhWdij[djeh_Wb [nfeikh[ <_]$ ,$&$'$ 7\j[h fWh# j_Wbh[celWb"j^['o[Wh#ebZXeoZ_[Zedj^[j^_hZfeijef[hWj_l[ZWo QFkii[f'/'&S$
<_]$,$&$) JWdZb[hWdZHWdp_Êiik]][ij_edki_d] WdWjec_YWb Yedi_Z[hWj_edi je [nfei[ j^[ f_d[Wb h[]_ed$ Dej[ j^[ _d\hWj[djeh_Wb ikfhWY[h[X[bbWh fWj^mWojej^[]h[Wjl[_de\=Wb[d$
?d'/''<[ZehAhWki["_d^_if_ed[[h_d]mehaÇIkh][hoe\j^[8hW_d WdZ If_d[È" h[Yecc[dZ[Z je WffheWY^ j^[ f_d[Wb h[]_ed l_W j^[ ikfhWY[h[X[bbWh _d\hWj[djeh_Wb hekj[ QAhWki[ '/''S$ Jme o[Whi bWj[h" AhWki[ h[cel[Z W bWh][ jkceh _d j^[ h[]_ed e\ j^[ gkWZh_][c_# dWb fbWj[ \hec W oekd] Xeo Xo j^_i _d\hWj[djeh_Wb hekj[ m^_Y^ ^[ h[fehj[Zje][j^[hm_j^>[hcWddEff[d^[_c"m^eZ_W]dei[Zj^[ fWj_[dj<_]$,$&$($J^_imWij^[fkXb_YWj_ede\j^[ÓhijikYY[ii\kb [nj_hfWj_ede\Wjkceh\hecj^[f_d[Wbh[]_edWdZj^[fWj_[djmWi h[fehj[Zje^Wl[X[[dm[bbWjb[Wijkdj_bj^[ÓhijMehbZMWh$?d'/(," AhWki[ WZZ[Z jme ceh[ fWj_[dji m^e m[h[ ef[hWj[Z ed Xo j^[ iWc[WffheWY^1^em[l[h"^[YekbZdejh[cel[j^[jkcehiQAhWki[ '/')"'/(,S$@kb_kiJWdZb[hWdZ;]edHWdp_WbieZ[iYh_X[ZWi_c_bWh _d\hWj[djeh_WbikfhWY[h[X[bbWhhekj["Wbj^ek]^m_j^ekjYb_d_YWb[nf[# h_[dY[ <_]$ ,$&$)$ Ed WYYekdj e\ j^[ dWhhem ef[hWj_l[ Ó[bZ" j^_i WffheWY^ mWi hWh[bo ki[Z Xo ej^[h ikh][edi" fkXb_i^_d] ifehWZ_Y
(&+
F_d[WbWffheWY^
YWi[ h[fehji QJWdZb[h é HWdp_ '/(&" 8W]][dijeii é Bel[ '/)/S$ 8e^kibWl PWfb[jWb _d '/+, Z[iYh_X[Z ^_i _d\hWj[djeh_Wb ikfhW# Y[h[X[bbWh WffheWY^ m^_Y^ ^[ Z[l[bef[Z _d '/+*$ >[ h[fehj[Z ed \ekh YWi[i0 W cWb_]dWdj WijheYojecW" W c[ZkbbeXbWijecW e\ j^[ kff[hl[hc_i"Wd[f_Z[hce_Z"WdZWf_d[Wbjkceh"j^[bWijX[_d]ikY# Y[ii\kbboh[cel[ZQPWfb[jWb'/+,S$ J^[ Óhij _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y jhWdiYWbbeiWb WffheWY^ je j^[ f_d[Wb h[]_ed mWi eh_]_dWbbo Z[iYh_X[Z Xo MWbj[h ;$ :WdZo _d '/'+ ki_d] W feij[h_eh [nfeikh[ _d Wd Wd_cWb ceZ[b <_]$-$&$'$ ?d '/(' ^[ fkXb_i^[Z j^[ Óhij Yb_d_YWb [nf[h_[dY[i Q:WdZo '/'+" '/('S$ Ej\h_Z <e[hij[h fkXb_i^[Z ^_i [nf[h_[dY[ m_j^ j^[ feij[h_eh _dj[h^[c_# if^[h_Y [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ gkWZh_][c_dWb h[]_ed _d j^h[[ fWj_[dji <_]$,$&$+$ >[ mWi j^[ i[YedZ ikh][ed je ikYY[ii\kbbo h[cel[ W f_d[Wb jkceh Q<e[hij[h '/(.S$ M^[d :WdZo h[fehj[Z j[d f_d[Wb b[i_ediWffheWY^[Zl_WWh_]^jfWh_[jWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YjhWdiYWbbe# iWb[nfeikh["j^_iX[YWc[j^[ceij\Wlekh[Zhekj[\ehWbed]f[h_eZ <_]i$,$&$,"-$&$(Q:WdZo'/('S$
<_]$,$&$* PWfb[jWbÊi _d\hWj[djeh_Wb ikfhWY[h[X[bbWh WffheWY^ je j^[ f_d[Wb h[]_ed" fkXb_i^[Z _d '/+, 7$ IY^[cWj_Y ZhWm_d] _d j^[ iW]_jjWb i[Yj_ed Z[cedijhWj[i j^[ ifedjWd[eki ef[d_d] e\ j^[ ikfhWY[h[X[bbWh hekj[ WY^_[l[ZXoW]hWl_jo#h[bWj[Zi_da_d]e\j^[Y[h[X[bbkc8$
<_]$,$&$+ <e[hij[hÊi _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^ je j^[ f_d[Wb h[]_ed Z[cedijhWj[Z _d W iY^[cWj_Y f_Yjkh[ \hec '/(.$Dej[j^[iYWh_Ó[ZXh_Z]_d]l[_die\j^[eYY_f_jWbbeX[ WdZjhWdij[djeh_Wb[nfeikh[e\j^[jkceh$
<_]$,$&$, :hWm_d]i_bbkijhWj_d]j^[c[j^eZe\fheZkY_d] ceh[ WZ[gkWj[ [nfeikh[ e\ Wd [nj[dZ[Z jkceh e\ j^[ f_d[Wbh[]_edXoh[i[Yj_d]j^[eYY_f_jWbbeX[fkXb_i^[ZXo :WdZo_d'/),$M^[dd[Y[iiWho":WdZoh[i[Yj[Zj^[bem[h fWhje\j^[\Wbn"j^[j[djeh_kc"j^[l[_de\=Wb[dWdZj^[ ijhW_]^ji_dki9$Dej[j^[h[bWj_edi^_fe\j^[jhW`[Yjehoe\ j^[ef[hWj_l[WffheWY^7jej^[ia_d_dY_i_ed8$
(&,
F_d[WbWffheWY^
7ceh[_dlWi_l[WffheWY^mWiZ[l[bef[ZXoM_bb_WclWdMW][d[d _d'/)'m^e[nfei[Zj^[f_d[Wbh[]_edl_WWjhWdiYehj_YWbjhWdil[d# jh_YkbWhhekj[<_]$,$&$-$ehhWnki[Zh[i[Yj_ede\j^[ [dj_h[eYY_f_jWbbeX[<_]$,$&$.QlWdMW][d[d'/)'">ehhWn'/)-S$
<_]$,$&$- J^[ jhWdiYehj_YWb#jhWdil[djh_YkbWh WffheWY^ je f_d[Wb jkcehi Z[iYh_X[Z Xo lWd MW][d[d_d'/)'$J^_i[nfeikh[mWiki[Zedbo_d j^[YWi[e\^oZheY[f^Wb_YZ_bWjWj_ede\j^[bWj[hWb l[djh_Yb[i$
<_]$,$&$. ;nfeikh[e\Wd[nj[dZ[Zf_d[Wbjkceh Xo>ehhWn_d'/)-"ki_d]h[i[Yj_ede\j^[eYY_f_jWb beX[$ J^[ jkceh YekbZ X[ ikYY[ii\kbbo h[cel[Z W\j[hjhWdii[Yj_ede\j^[\Wbn"j[djeh_kcWdZifb[# d_kce\j^[YehfkiYWbbeikc$
<_]$,$&$/ C_Yheikh]_YWb [nfbehWj_ed e\ W bWh][ jkcehj^hek]^j^[_d\hWj[djeh_WbikfhWY[h[X[bbWh hekj[fkXb_i^[ZXoIj[_d_d'/-'$
J^[i[bWh]["jhWkcWj_Y[nfeikh[im[h[d[Y[iiWhojeXh_d][dek]^ b_]^j_djej^[Z[[f#i[Wj[Zf_d[WbWh[W$7YYehZ_d]bo"j^[YhkZ[ef[hW# j_l[j[Y^d_gk[ib[ZjeZ_iWffe_dj_d]feijef[hWj_l[h[ikbji$?d'/+)" HeX[hj M$ HWdZ h[fehj[Z W cehjWb_jo hWj[ e\ -& _d j^[_h i[h_[i ki_d]cWYheikh]Y_Wbj[Y^d_gk[i$>WdiH_d][hjpfkXb_i^[ZW+.$. cehjWb_johWj[Wced]+'fWj_[djie\j^[Eb_l[YhedWYb_d_YQHWdZé B[cc[d'/+)"H_d][hjp'/+*S$ ?dj^[[Whbo'/-&i"m_j^_djheZkYj_ede\c_YheiYef_Yj[Y^d_gk[i_d d[kheikh][ho"if[Y_WbWjj[dj_edmWi]_l[dW]W_djej^_ilkbd[hWXb[ h[]_ed$7i8[d[jjIj[_d_d'/-'Z[iYh_X[Z<[ZehAhWki[Êi_d\hWj[d# jeh_Wb ikfhWY[h[X[bbWh WffheWY^ ki_d] c_Yheikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[i" W d[m [hW ijWhj[Z \eh ef[hWj_l[ [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ f_d[Wb h[]_ed <_]i$ ,$&$/" ,$&$'& QIj[_d '/-'" F[dZb '/.+S$ >em[l[h" _d ^_i f_ed[[h_d] Z[iYh_fj_ed"AhWki[Wbh[WZoh[Wb_p[Zj^[[ii[dY[e\j^[_d\hWj[djeh_Wb ikfhWY[h[X[bbWh [nfeikh[0 j^[ WdWjec_YWb ijhkYjkh[i e\ j^[ f_d[Wb h[]_edWh[\h[[\ehikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_edWdZj^[Yehh_ZehX[jm[[dj^[ j[djeh_kcWdZj^[Y[h[X[bbkcZe[idejl_ebWj[Wdoi[di_j_l[_djhW# YhWd_WbijhkYjkh[i$ ?dj^[\ebbem_d]"j^[_cfehjWdY[e\j^_iWdWjec_YWb\WYj_iZ_iYkii[Z _dZ[jW_b$
<_]$,$&$'& F[dZbÊic_Yheikh]_YWbWYY[iijef_d[WbjkcehiZ[cedijhWj[Z_d^_iYec# fh[^[di_l[j[njXeeaÇF_d[WbWdZC_ZXhW_dB[i_ediÈfkXb_i^[Z_d'/.+$
(&-
F_d[WbWffheWY^
=[d[hWbWdWjec_YWbYedijhkYj_ede\j^[ikfhWY[h[X[bbWh Yehh_ZehWdZj^[f_d[Wbh[]_ed B[i_edim_j^_dj^[f_d[Wbh[]_edYWdX[X[ij[nfei[Zl_Wj^[fei# j[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb" feij[h_eh _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y ikfhWj[djeh_Wb eh ikfhWY[h[X[bbWh _d\hWj[djeh_Wb WffheWY^[i$ J^[ feij[h_eh ikXj[c# fehWb Y^Wfj[h)$' WdZ feij[h_eh _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^[i Y^Wfj[h-$(i^ekbZX[fh[\[hh[Z\ehb[i_ediY[dj[h[ZWjj^[j[djeh_Wb [Z]["[if[Y_Wbbo_\j^[oWh[i_jkWj[ZWXel[j^[]h[WjY[h[XhWbl[_de\ =Wb[dWdZ^Wl[WbWj[hWb[nj[di_ed<_]$,$&$''W"X$>em[l[h"ceij jkcehiWh[beYWj[Zfh_cWh_boX[d[Wj^j^[Z[[fl[dekiioij[c$?d j^[i[YWi[i"j^[_d\hWj[djeh_Wb[nfeikh[h[ZkY[ij^[h_iae\l[deki _d`kho$?dj^_imWo"j^[_d\hWj[djeh_WbikfhWY[h[X[bbWhWffheWY^_iX[ij ik_j[Zjeb[i_edid[Whjej^[c_Zb_d[i_jkWj[ZWjj^[b[l[behYWkZWbbo \hecj^[l[_de\=Wb[d<_]$,$&$''Y$ J^[ikfhWY[h[X[bbWhYehh_Zeh_ibeYWj[ZX[bemj^[ZkhWbj[dje\j^[ j[djeh_kce\\[h_d]W\h[[ikh]_YWbhekj[jej^[f_d[Wbh[]_ed\hec j^[feij[h_ehZ_h[Yj_ed$7jj^[b[l[be\j^[j[djeh_Wb^_Wjki"j^_iYehh_# Zeh_iYbei[ZXoWc_bao"jh_Wd]kbWhWhWY^de_ZfbWj[$J^[f_d[Wbh[]_ed YWdX[[dj[h[ZedboW\j[hZ_ii[Yj_d]j^_ijek]^c[cXhWd[_dWbWj# [hWbjec[Z_WbZ_h[Yj_ed"fh[i[hl_d]j^[ikf[h_ehY[h[X[bbWhl[_d$J^[ jh_Wd]kbWh l_[m _dje j^[ f_d[Wb h[]_ed _i fWhj_Wbbo eYYkf_[Z Xo j^[ ]h[Wjl[_de\=Wb[dWdZj^[ifb[d_kce\j^[YehfkiYWbbeikc1^em# [l[h"m_j^][djb[ceX_b_pWj_ede\j^[kff[hl[hc_i"j^[ikXWhWY^de_Z ifWY[e\j^[gkWZh_][c_dWbY_ij[hdYWdX[l_ikWb_p[Z$J^[Ôeehe\j^[ gkWZh_][c_dWb Y_ij[hd _i \ehc[Z Xo j^[ kff[h ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ c[i# [dY[f^WbedWdZj^[l_hjkWbhee\Yehh[ifedZijej^[bem[hikh\WY[ e\j^[ifb[d_kcYehfeh_iYWbbei_"YhkhWe\j^[\ehd_Y[i"^_ffeYWcfWb Yecc_iikh[WdZj^[l[_de\=Wb[d$J^[XWiWbl[_de\Hei[dj^WbWdZ j^[9D?LZ_iWff[WhbWj[hWbbo_djej^[WcX_[djY_ij[hd$?dWdWdj[h_eh Z_h[Yj_ed" j^[ f_d[Wb XeZo" ^WX[dkbWh WdZ feij[h_eh Yecc_iikh[i WdZj^[[djhWdY[_djej^[l[bkc_dj[hfei_jkcYWdX[WffheWY^[Z$ J^[efj_cWbfbWY[c[dje\j^[YhWd_ejecoZ[f[dZiedj^[fh[Y_i[ beYWj_ede\j^[b[i_ed$7f_YWbboi_jkWj[Zb[i_edid[Whjej^[ifb[d_kc e\j^[YehfkiYWbbeikci^ekbZX[WffheWY^[Zl_WWXWiWbbofbWY[Z YhWd_ejeco$ Ed j^[ YedjhWho" b[i_edi e\ j^[ gkWZh_][c_dWb fbWj[ WdZ Y[h[X[bbec[i[dY[f^Wb_Y Óiikh[ Wh[ X[ij WffheWY^[Z \hec W ceh[Wf_YWbZ_h[Yj_ed<_]$,$&$'($ 7bj^ek]^j^[_d\hWj[djeh_WbWffheWY^_iefj_cWb\ehc[Z_Wdi_jkWj[Z jWh][j fe_dji" b[i_edi beYWj[Z ceh[ bWj[hWbbo YWd X[ Wbie [nfei[Z$
(&.
7
8
9
<_]$,$&$'' J^[ feij[h_eh ikXj[cfehWb WffheWY^ e\\[hi WZ[gkWj[ [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ feij[h_eh j[djeh_Wb ^_Wjki 7$ F_d[Wb b[i_edi i_jkWj[Z WXel[ j^[ ]h[Wj Y[h[XhWb l[_d e\ =Wb[d Wh[ X[ij h[WY^[Z j^hek]^ j^[ feij[h_eh _dj[h^[c_# if^[h_Y WffheWY^ 8$ J^[ _d\hWj[djeh_Wb ikfhWY[h[X[bbWh WffheWY^ YWd X[ h[Yecc[dZ[Z \eh b[i_edi X[d[Wj^ j^[ Z[[fl[dekiioij[cbeYWj[Zd[Whjej^[c_Zb_d[9$
F_d[WbWffheWY^
?d YWi[i e\ fWhWc[Z_Wd beYWj[Z b[i_edi" m[ fh[\[h W fWhWc[Z_Wbbo fbWY[Z YhWd_ejeco WdZ YedjhWbWj[hWb [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ jWh][j Wh[W WYYehZ_d]jej^[YedY[fje\a[o^eb[WffheWY^[i<_]$,$&$')$
<_]$,$&$'( J^[ efj_cWb fbWY[c[dj e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco Z[f[dZi ed j^[ [nWYj beYW# j_ede\j^[b[i_ed$7f_YWbboi_jkWj[Zb[i_edid[Whjej^[ifb[d_kce\j^[YehfkiYWb# beikci^ekbZX[WffheWY^[Zl_WWXWiWbbofbWY[ZYhWd_ejecoh[ZWhhem$Edj^[ YedjhWho"b[i_edie\j^[gkWZh_][c_dWbfbWj[WdZY[h[X[bbec[i[dY[f^Wb_YÓiikh[Wh[ X[ijWffheWY^[Z\hecWceh[Wf_YWbZ_h[Yj_ed"Yh[Wj_d]j^[YhWd_ejecod[Whjej^[ YedÔk[dY[e\i_dki[i]h[[dWhhem$
<_]$,$&$') 7bj^ek]^ j^[ _d\hWj[djeh_Wb WffheWY^ _i efj_cWb \eh c[Z_Wd i_jkWj[Z jWh][jfe_dji"b[i_edibeYWj[Zceh[bWj[hWbboYWdWbieX[[nfei[Z$?dYWi[ie\fWhWc[# Z_WdbeYWj[Zb[i_edi"m[h[Yecc[dZWfWhWc[Z_WbbofbWY[ZYhWd_ejecoWdZYedjhW# bWj[hWb[nfeikh[e\j^[jWh][jWh[W$
IkfhWY[h[X[bbWhYehh_Zeh
F_d[Wbh[]_edWdZj^_hZl[djh_Yb[
9edÔk[dY[e\i_dki[i ?d\[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[j[djeh_kc IjhW_]^ji_dki Kff[hl[hc_i J[djeh_WbY[h[X[bbWhikh\WY[ 9[djhWbY[h[X[bbWhl[_d =h[WjY[h[XhWbl[_de\=Wb[d
Ifb[d_kce\j^[YehfkiYWbbeikc F_d[Wb]bWdZ GkWZh_][c_dWbfbWj[ Feij[h_ehYecc_iikh[ Fkbl_dWhj^WbWc_ 9hki\ehd_Y_i >_ffeYWcfWbYecc_iikh["l[bkc_dj[hfei_jkc 9^WcX[he\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[ 7dj[h_ehYecc_iikh[ 9ebbkcdW\ehd_Y[i"jh_Wd]kbWhh[Y[ii D?L :_ijWbl[ii[bie\j^[F97WdZI97 =h[WjY[h[XhWbl[_de\=Wb[d"Y[djhWbY[h[X[bbWhl[_d 8WiWbl[_de\Hei[dj^Wb"_dj[hdWbY[h[XhWbl[_d
JWXb[,$&$' 7dWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[i[nfei[Zj^hek]^j^[ikfhWY[h[X[bbWh_djhWj[djeh_WbWffheWY^$
(&/
F_d[WbWffheWY^
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[ '$FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] Efj_cWb fWj_[dj fei_j_ed_d] \eh _d\hWj[djeh_Wb ikfhWY[h[X[b# bWh WffheWY^[i _i Yedjhel[hi_Wb$ ?d j^[ cW`eh_jo e\ d[kheikh]_YWb Z[fWhjc[dji" j^[ i_jj_d] fei_j_ed _i fh[\[hh[Z \eh _d\hWj[djeh_Wb [nfeikh[e\j^[f_d[Wbh[]_ed$J^[cW_dWZlWdjW][_ij^Wjj^[i_j# j_d]fei_j_edWbbemi]hWl_jojemeha_dj^[ikh][edi\WlehXoh[ZkY# _d]feeb_d]e\XbeeZ_d j^[ef[hWj_d]Ó[bZWdZXoWbbem_d]c_d_# cWbY[h[X[bbWhh[jhWYj_edZkh_d]ikh][ho$7ZlWdjW][ie\j^[fhed[ fei_j_ed Wh[ j^[ i_cfb_Y_jo e\ j^[ j[Y^d_gk[ Xej^ \eh ikh]_YWb Wi \ehWd[ij^[i_ebe]_YWbf[hiedd[bWdZYec\ehj\ehj^[fWj_[dj$9ec# fWh[Zm_j^ j^[Z_\ÓYkbji_jj_d]fei_j_ed" j^[h[_ideZWd][he\W_h [cXeb_ic"YWhZ_efkbcedWho_dijWX_b_jo"i[l[h[fd[kceY[f^Wbkieh l[djh_YkbWhYebbWfi[$J^[f[hf[dZ_YkbWhZ_h[Yj_ede\ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Y# j_edWbbemiWd[\ÓY_[djmeha_d]fei_j_edWdZ[nY[bb[djel[hl_[me\ j^[ef[hWj_d]Ó[bZ$ Ij[f' 7jÓhij"j^[XeZoWdZj^[^[WZWh[[b[lWj[ZYW$(&je)&Xocel_d] j^[ef[hWj_d]jWXb[$J^_i[b[lWj_ed_id[Y[iiWhojeXh_d]j^[^[WZ WXel[ j^[ b[l[b e\ j^[ j^ehWn \eh efj_cWb l[deki ZhW_dW][" \WY_b_# jWj_d] j^[ e\j[d Z_\ÓYkbj Z_ii[Yj_ed e\ j^[ jkceh \hec j^[ Z[[f l[dekiioij[c<_]$,$&$'*$
<_]$,$&$'*
<_]$,$&$'+
Ij[f( ?dWi[YedZij[fj^[^[WZcWoX[Wdj[heÔ[Yj[ZWXekj*+_dehZ[h je Xh_d] j^[ j[djeh_kc _d W f[hf[dZ_YkbWh fbWd[$ J^_i cWn_cWb Ô[n_ede\j^[d[Yam_j^YedYec_jWdjh[l[hi[Jh[dZ[b[dXkh]fei_# j_ed_d]e\ j^[XeZo" j^[ie#YWbb[Z9edYehZ[fei_j_ed"fhel_Z[iWd [\ÓY_[djmeha_d]fei_j_ed\eh j^[ikh][edZ_ii[Yj_d] jemWhZ j^[ _d\[h_eh j[djeh_Wb ikh\WY[$ >em[l[h" if[Y_Wb Wjj[dj_ed i^ekbZ X[ ]_l[ddejjeYecfh[iij^[l[dj_bWj_edjkX[WdZj^[bWhodn$;nY[i# i_l[Wdj[heÔ[Yj_edcWoWbieYWki[l[dekiYed][ij_edZk[jeYec# fh[ii_ede\j^[`k]kbWhl[_dicWa_d]ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_edceh[Z_\# ÓYkbjm_j^_dj^[f_d[Wbh[]_ed<_]$,$&$'+$ <_]$,$&$',
Ij[f) <ehb[i_edibeYWj[Z_dj^[c_Zb_d["hejWj_ede\j^[^[WZ_idejd[Y[i# iWho$>em[l[h"c[Z_ebWj[hWbboi_jkWj[Zb[i_edih[gk_h[Wib_]^jhejW# j_ede\+Å '+"WYYehZ_d]jej^[WYYkhWj[fWj^eWdWjec_YWbi_jkWj_ed$ ?dj^_iYWi[m[fh[\[hWfWhWc[Z_WdYhWd_ejecoWdZYedjhWbWj[hWb [nfeikh[e\j^[jWh][jWh[WWiZ_iYkii[ZWXel[<_]$,$&$',$
('&
F_d[WbWffheWY^
($7dWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZeh_[djWj_ed <ehfh[ef[hWj_l[eh_[djWj_ed"j^[_cfehjWdjWdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhai e\j^[feij[hebWj[hWbeii[ekiiakbbikY^Wij^[\ehWc[dcW]dkc" cWije_Z fheY[ii" bWcXZe_Z ikjkh[" ^_]^[ij dkY^Wb b_d[ WdZ j^[ [nj[hdWbeYY_f_jWbfhejkX[hWdY[Wh[fh[Y_i[boZ[j[hc_d[Z$If[Y_Wb Wjj[dj_edi^ekbZX[]_l[djej^[Yekhi[e\j^[jhWdil[hi[i_dkiWi Z[Ód_j_ed e\ j^[ feij[h_eh \eiiW b[l[b WdZ je j^[ WYYkhWj[ Z[j[h# c_dWj_ed e\ j^[ jehYkbWh h[]_ed Wi a[oi je j^[ [nWYj YhWd_ejeco <_]$,$&$'-$>em[l[h"Z[if_j[YWh[\kbeh_[djWj_ed"lWh_Wj_edi_dj^[ i_dkie_Z WdWjeco e\ j^[ feij[h_eh \eiiW YWd h[ikbj _d ikhfh_i_d] Z_\ÓYkbj_[i Zkh_d] j^[ Óhij ij[fi e\ j^[ ef[hWj_ed$J^[h[\eh[" fh[# ef[hWj_l[ [lWbkWj_ed m_j^ ^_]^#h[iebkj_ed 9J WdZ CH _cW]_d] WdZZ[Ód_j_ede\j^[_dZ_l_ZkWbWdWjec_YWbi_jkWj_edWh[[ii[dj_Wb X[\eh[ikh][ho$ 7\j[heh_[djWj_ed"j^[XehZ[hie\j^[YhWd_ejecoWh[cWha[Zm_j^ Wij[h_b[f[d$KikWbbo"j^[YhWd_ejeco_ifbWY[Zc[Z_Wdehib_]^jbo fWhWc[Z_Wdm_j^WZ_Wc[j[he\(je)Yc<_]$,$&$'-$ 7\j[h Z[Ód_d] j^[ YhWd_ejeco" j^[ ^W_h _i i^Wl[Z WYYehZ_d] je W c_Zb_d[ia_d_dY_i_ede\WXekj+Yc_db[d]j^WdZZ_i_d\[Yj[ZYWh[# \kbbo$
<_]$,$&$'- :[Ód_j_ede\j^[YhWd_ejecoWYYehZ_d]jej^[ WdWjec_YWb bWdZcWhai e\ j^[ eYY_f_jWb h[]_ed$ J^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed i^ekbZ X[ f[h\ehc[Z WYYehZ_d] je j^[ c_Zb_d[ W\j[h c_d_cWb eh [l[d m_j^ekj i^Wl_d] j^[ ^W_h$ If[Y_Wb Wjj[dj_ed ckij X[ ]_l[d je j^[ Yekhi[ e\ j^[ jhWdil[hi[ i_dkiWdZbeYWj_ede\j^[YedÔk[dii_dkkc$
(''
F_d[WbWffheWY^
)$9hWd_ejeco Ij[f' 7\j[h fWj_[dj fei_j_ed_d]" WdWjec_YWb eh_[djW# j_ed WdZ c_d_cWb eh [l[d WXi[dj i^Wl_d] e\ j^[^W_h"j^[ia_d_ifh[fWh[Zm_j^WbYe^ebiebk# j_ed$ Je X[]_d j^[ ikXeYY_f_jWb [nfeikh[" W ijhW_]^j c_Zb_d[ _dY_i_ed _i cWZ[ el[h j^[ jehYkbWhh[]_ed<_]$,$&$'.$
<_]$,$&$'.
<_]$,$&$'/
Ij[f( J^[ ia_dÔWfi Wh[ h[jhWYj[Z ijhed]bo$J^[ b[l[b e\j^[\ehWc[dcW]dkc_ji[b\Ze[idejd[[Z jeX[[nfei[Z<_]$,$&$'/$
<_]$,$&$(&
Ij[f) 7\j[hh[jhWYj_ede\j^[ikXYkjWd[ekibWo[h"j^[ dkY^Wbb_]Wc[dj_iZ[Ód[ZWdZZ_l_Z[Zh[bWj[Z ijh_Yjbo je j^[ c_Zb_d[" i[fWhWj_d] j^[ ikXeY# Y_f_jWbckiYb[i$J^[\WiY_We\j^[i[c_if_dWb_i YWf_j_ickiYb[iWdZj^[f[h_eij[Wbi^[[jWjj^[ [nj[hdWbeYY_f_jWbfhejkX[hWdY[Wh[_dY_i[Z_d W h[l[hi[ O#i^Wf[Z \Wi^_ed$ J^[ _di[hj_ed e\ j^[i[c_if_dWb_ickiYb[_ij^[dijh_ff[Z\hec j^[ f[h_eij[Wb Yel[h_d] e\ j^[ [nj[hdWb fhejk# X[hWdY[<_]$,$&$(&$
('(
F_d[WbWffheWY^
Ij[f* J^[b[WÔ[jYel[h_d]j^[[nj[hdWbfhejkX[hWdY[ _i ceX_b_p[Z m_j^ Wd [b[lWjeh WdZ h[Ô[Yj[Z m_j^ijhed]ikjkh[i$J^[i[c_if_dWb_ickiYb[i Wh[ h[jhWYj[Z X_bWj[hWbbo m_j^ W mekdZ h[jhWY# jeh<_]$,$&$('$
<_]$,$&$('
Ij[f+ 7\j[hXedo[nfeikh["j^[eYY_f_jWbXed[_ifWh# j_Wbboh[cel[ZWYYehZ_d]jej^[[nj[hdWbfhejk# X[hWdY[m_j^W^_]^#if[[ZZh_bb$M[fh[\[hWd eij[eYbWij_YYhWd_ejecoWdZki[Xed[Y[c[dj je h[fW_h j^[ Xedo Z[\[Yj W\j[h ZkhWb Ybeikh[$ ?d ekh ef_d_ed" W ^WpWhZeki eij[efbWij_Y fhe# Y[Zkh[d[Whjej^[fhec_d[dji_dkie_Zl[ii[bi fhel_Z[ideWZlWdjW][YecfWh[ZjeWYWh[\kb YhWd_[Yjeco<_]$,$&$(($
<_]$,$&$((
Ij[f, J^[ _dj[hdWb eYY_f_jWb fhejkX[hWdY[ _i j^[d h[cel[Z m_j^ Ód[ fkdY^[i" eXi[hl_d] j^[ [Z][ e\ j^[ jehYkbWh ^[hef^_b_$ J^[ _dj[hdWb eYY_f_jWb Yh[ij _i Wbie h[cel[Z WYYehZ_d] je c_Zb_d[" [nfei_d] j^[ eYY_f_jWb i_dki$ If[Y_Wb YWh[ i^ekbZ X[ jWa[d je Wle_Z _d`kho je j^[ eYY_f_jWbWdZjhWdil[hiWbi_dki[i<_]$,$&$()$
<_]$,$&$()
(')
F_d[WbWffheWY^
<_]$,$&$(*
Ij[f- J^[ ZkhW i^ekbZ X[ ef[d[Z _d W i[c_bkdWh \Wi^_ed m_j^ _ji XWi[ jemWhZ j^[ YedÔk[di i_dkkc"Ybei_d]j^[eYY_f_jWbi_dkim_j^^[ce# Yb_fi<_]$,$&$(*$
<_]$,$&$(+
Ij[f. J^[Y[h[X[bbWh\Wbn_iZ_l_Z[ZWdZj^[ZkhWbÔWf [b[lWj[Zm_j^^ebZ_d]ikjkh[i$7bj^ek]^cW`eh [b[lWj_ede\j^[ZkhW_id[Y[iiWhojeef[dj^[ Yehh_ZehX[bemj^[j[djeh_kc"[nY[ii_l[h[jhWY# j_edYWdXbeYaj^[i_dkiWdZb[WZje_dYh[Wi[Z l[deki fh[iikh[ m^_Y^ i^ekbZ X[ Wle_Z[Z <_]$,$&$(+$
('*
F_d[WbWffheWY^
*$?djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ij[f'
\WbnY[h[X[bb_
<_]$,$&$(,
Ij[f( J^[ kff[h l[hc_i e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbkc _i ][djbo h[jhWYj[Z [nfei_d] j^[ ikfhWY[h[X[bbWh _d\hWj[djeh_Wb hekj[$ EdY[ j^[ h[jhWYjeh _i _d fbWY[" j^[ j^_Ya[d[Z c_bao WhWY^de_Z c[c# XhWd[YWdX[i[[deXiYkh_d]j^[l_[m_djej^[ f_d[Wb h[]_ed$ Dej[ j^[ [Z][ e\ j^[ j[djeh_Wb _dY_ikhWWdZj^[ZkhWWYYehZ_d]jej^[ijhW_]^j i_dki<_]$,$&$(-$
j[djeh_Wb_dY_ikhW ijhW_]^ji_dki
<_]$,$&$(-
Ij[f) J^[ c[cXhWdeki fbWj[ _i ef[d[Z _d W bWj[hWb je c[Z_Wb Z_h[Yj_ed m_j^ Ód[ c_YheiY_iiehi$ J^[ ]h[Wj Y[h[XhWb l[_d e\ =Wb[d Wff[Whi _d j^[XWYa]hekdZb[WZ_d]_djej^[ijhW_]^ji_dki <_]$,$&$(.$
]h[WjY[h[XhWb l[_de\=Wb[d
<_]$,$&$(.
('+
F_d[WbWffheWY^
Ij[f* 7\j[h Yecfb[j[ ef[d_d] e\ j^[ WhWY^de_Z c[cXhWd[" j^[ ]h[Wj Y[h[XhWb l[_d e\ =Wb[d YWdX[\kbbo[nfei[Z$?dj^_iYWi["j^[eYY_f_jWb beX[ _i ^[hd_Wj[Z j^hek]^ j^[ j[djeh_Wb _dY_# ikhW _dje j^[ feij[h_eh \eiiW eXiYkh_d] j^[ [nfeikh[_djej^[f_d[Wbh[]_ed<_]$,$&$(/$
l[_de\=Wb[d eYY_f_jWbbeX[
<_]$,$&$(/
Ij[f+ 7\j[h\khj^[hceX_b_pWj_ede\j^[kff[hl[hc_i" j^[bWj[hWbfWhje\j^[gkWZh_][c_dWbY_ij[hd_i [nfei[Z$Dej[ j^[Y[djhWbY[h[X[bbWhl[_d"b[\j _dj[hdWbY[h[XhWbl[_d"WdZj^[b[\jXWiWbl[_de\ Hei[dj^Wb$J^[eYY_f_jWbbeX[_i][djboh[jhWYj[Z m_j^WZ_ii[YjehWffheWY^_d]j^[ifb[d_kce\ j^[YehfkiYWbbeikc<_]$,$&$)&$
Y[djhWb Y[h[X[bbWhl[_d _dj[hdWb Y[h[XhWbl[_d l[_de\Hei[dj^Wb YehfkiYWbbeikc eYY_f_jWbbeX[
<_]$,$&$)&
Ij[f, J^[ Y[djhWb Y[h[X[bbWh l[_d _i ][djbo h[jhWYj[Z je j^[ b[\j" [nfei_d] j^[ h_]^j _dj[hdWb Y[h[# XhWb l[_d$ Dej[ j^[ f_d[Wb ]bWdZ Wff[Wh_d] _d j^[Wd]b[X[jm[[dj^[Y[djhWbY[h[X[bbWhWdZ _dj[hdWbY[h[XhWbl[_di<_]$,$&$)'$
f_d[Wb]bWdZ _dj[hdWb Y[h[XhWbl[_d
<_]$,$&$)'
(',
F_d[WbWffheWY^
Ij[fJ^[_dj[hdWbY[h[XhWbl[_d_i\ebbem[ZWdj[h_ehbo Z_iWff[Wh_d] _dje j^[ l[bkc _dj[hfei_jkc$ Dej[ j^[ icWbb f[h\ehWj_d] l[ii[bi ikffbo_d] j^[ gkWZh_][c_dWb fbWj[ e\ j^[ c[i[dY[f^W# bed<_]$,$&$)($
_dj[hdWbY[h[XhWbl[_d h_]^jl[_de\ Hei[dj^Wb
<_]$,$&$)(
Ij[f. ;nfeikh[e\j^[[djhWdY[_djej^[l[bkc_dj[h# fei_jkcX[jm[[dj^[ifb[d_kce\j^[Yehfki YWbbeikc WdZ j^[ bWj[hWb_p[Z f_d[Wb ]bWdZ <_]$,$&$))$ f_d[Wb]bWdZ l[bkc_dj[hfei_jkc YehfkiYWbbeikc
<_]$,$&$))
Ij[f/ 7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ WhWY^de_Z c[cXhWd[i e\ j^[ l[bkc _dj[hfei_jkc" j^[ ^WX[dkbWh Yec# c_iikh[YWdX[i[[d$Dej[9I<Wff[Wh_d]\hec j^[feij[h_ehj^_hZl[djh_Yb[<_]$,$&$)*$
^WX[dkbWh Yecc_iikhW
<_]$,$&$)*
('-
F_d[WbWffheWY^
+$:khW"Xed[WdZmekdZYbeikh[ 7\j[hYecfb[j_ede\j^[_djhWYhWd_WbfheY[Zkh[" j^[ikXWhWY^de_Z ifWY[_iÓbb[Zm_j^H_d][hiebkj_edWjXeZoj[cf[hWjkh[$J^[ZkhWb _dY_i_ed_iYbei[Zm_j^_dj[hhkfj[Zikjkh[i$?\i^h_daW][^WiZ[l[b# ef[Z_dj^[ZkhWbfbWd["j^[jh_Wd]kbWh#i^Wf[Z\WiY_WbWdZf[h_ei# j[WbbWo[hYWdX[ki[ZWiWZkhWb]hW\jjeWY^_[l[mWj[hj_]^jYbeikh[$ 7 fbWj[ e\ ][b\eWc _i fbWY[Z [njhWZkhWbbo WdZ j^[ Xedo Z[\[Yj _i Ybei[Zm_j^Xed[Y[c[dj"Wle_Z_d]Ôk_ZYebb[Yj_edWdZfeijef[hW# j_l[Z_iYec\ehj$7\j[hÓdWbl[h_ÓYWj_ede\^[ceijWi_i"j^[ckiYkbWh WdZikXYkjWd[ekibWo[hiWh[Ybei[Zm_j^_dj[hhkfj[Zikjkh[iWdZ j^[ia_dm_j^hkdd_d]eh_dj[hhkfj[Zikjkh[i$IkYj_edZhW_dW][_i dejh[gk_h[Z$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i ?dWZ[gkWj[fh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]e\j^[fWj_[dj m_j^ikXi[gk[dj_dWZ[gkWj[[nfeikh[e\j^[jWh][jh[]_edWdZ i_]d_ÓYWdj Z[j[h_ehWj_ed _d [\ÓY_[dYo e\ ikh]_YWbbo [nY_i_d] j^[ b[i_ed$FbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]_ij^[jWiae\j^[ikh][ed ?d`kho je j^[ jehYkbWh ^[hef^_b_ eh ej^[h i_dkie_Z l[ii[bi ikY^ Wij^[eYY_f_jWbWdZjhWdil[hi[i_dki[iZkh_d]YhWd_ejecom_j^ [nY[ii_l[ Xb[[Z_d]$ ?\ d[Y[iiWho" j^[ ]Wb[W#f[h_eij ÔWf YWd X[ ki[Z\ehh[fW_h$ ;nj[di_l[h[jhWYj_ede\j^[kff[hl[hc_im_j^feijef[hWj_l[Y[h[# X[bbWhiocfjeci$7Z[gkWj[fei_j_ed_d]WdZ[Whboh[celWbe\9I< cWoYWki[h[bWnWj_ede\j^[Y[h[X[bbWhikh\WY[$ ?d`kho jelWiYkbWhijhkYjkh[ie\ j^[f_d[Wbh[]_edZkh_d]c_Yhe# ikh]_YWbcWd_fkbWj_edm_j^feijef[hWj_l[d[khebe]_YWbZ[ÓY_ji$ ?d`kho je j^[ ifb[d_kc Yehfeh_i YWbbei_ YWki_d] b[\j ^[c_Wb[n_W" j^[_dWX_b_jojeh[WZ_dj^[b[\jl_ikWb^[c_Ó[bZ"WdZWXheWZWhhWo e\X[^Wl_ehWbWXdehcWb_j_[i$ ?d`kho e\ j^[ gkWZh_][c_dWb fbWj[ cWo ]_l[ h_i[ je ikXi[gk[dj FWh_dekZi_]d$ ?dWZ[gkWj[_djhW#eh[njhWYhWd_Wb^[ceijWi_im_j^feijef[hWj_l[ h[Xb[[Z_d]$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ZkhWbYbeikh[cWob[WZjefeijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ Ybeikh[ e\ j^[ Xedo Z[^_iY[dY[ m_j^ ikXi[gk[dj feijef[hWj_l[Z_iYec\ehj$
('.
<_]$,$&$)+
7
8
<_]$,$&$),
<_]$,$&$)-
F_d[WbWffheWY^
<_]$,$&$).
J_fiWdZjh_Yai JWa[j_c[\ehfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]e\fWj_[dji$ J^[ h[mWhZ _i Wd [nY[bb[dj el[hl_[m e\ j^[ jWh][j Wh[W WdZ Wd [\ÓY_[djmeha_d]fei_j_ed$
<_]$,$&$)/
7f_YWbbo i_jkWj[Z b[i_edi d[Wh je j^[ ifb[d_kc e\ Yehfki YWbbe# ikc i^ekbZ X[ WffheWY^[Z l_W W YWkZWbbo fbWY[Z YhWd_ejeco <_]$,$&$)+7$Edj^[YedjhWho"b[i_edie\j^[gkWZh_][c_dWbfbWj[ WdZ Y[h[X[bbec[i[dY[f^Wb_Y Óiikh[ Wh[ X[ij WffheWY^[Z \hec W ceh[Wf_YWbZ_h[Yj_ed<_]$,$&$)+8"f[h\ehc_d]WYhWd_ejecod[Wh jej^[jehYkbWhh[]_ed$ ?dYWi[ie\bWj[hWbbobeYWj[Zf_d[Wbb[i_edi"j^[YhWd_ejecoi^ekbZ X[ fbWY[Z fWhWc[Z_Wd" Wbbem_d] YedjhWbWj[hWb [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ jWh][j Wh[W WYYehZ_d] je j^[ YedY[fj e\ a[o^eb[ WffheWY^[i <_]$,$&$),$
<_]$,$&$*&
Ij[fie\j^[eij[eYbWij_YYhWd_ejeco<_]$,$&$)-0'$h[celWbe\j^[ [nj[hdWbeYY_f_jWbfhejkX[hWdY[m_j^W^_]^#if[[ZZh_bb1($h[celWb e\j^[_dj[hdWbeYY_f_jWbfhejkX[hWdY[WdZ_dj[hdWbeYY_f_jWbYh[ij m_j^ Ód[ fkdY^[i" eXi[hl_d] j^[ jehYkbWh ^[hef^_b_ WdZ j^[ eYY_f_jWbi_dki$ J^[i[c_if_dWb_ickiYb[ii^ekbZX[h[jhWYj[ZX_bWj[hWbbom_j^W ijhed]mekdZh[jhWYjeh$J^[f[h_eij[Wbb[WÔ[jYel[h_d]j^[[nj[h# dWbfhejkX[hWdY[_ih[Ô[Yj[Zm_j^ikjkh[i<_]$,$&$).$ <_]$,$&$*'
J^[ ZkhW i^ekbZ X[ ef[d[Z _d WÇ9È i^Wf[Z \ehc W\j[h Z_l_i_ed e\j^[eYY_f_jWbi_dki$Ki[c_YheYb_fi"Z_l_Z_d]j^[eYY_f_jWbi_dki <_]$,$&$)/$ J^[c_baoWhWY^de_Zc[cXhWd[Ybei_d]j^[WYY[ii_djej^[f_d[Wb h[]_ed _i bWj[hWbbo j^_d WdZ [Wi_[h je ef[d j^Wd _d j^[ c_Zb_d[ <_]$,$&$*&$
<_]$,$&$*(
?\ j[di_ed^WiZ[l[bef[ZZkh_d]ZkhWbYbeikh[ehW\hW]c[dje\ j^[ZkhW^WiX[[dh[i[Yj[Z"j^[f[h_eij[Wbi^[[je\j^[[nj[hdWb fhejkX[hWdY[YWdX[ki[Z\ehmWj[hj_]^jYbeikh[<_]$,$&$*'$ 7\j[hZkhWbYbeikh["j^[XedoZ[\[Yji^ekbZX[h[fW_h[Zm_j^Xed[ Y[c[dj Wle_Z_d] Ôk_Z Xk_bZkf WdZ feijef[hWj_l[ Z_iYec\ehj$ IkYj_edZhW_d_idejh[gk_h[Z<_]$,$&$*($
('/
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
-$& ?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ >_ijehoe\j^[_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^[i
<_]$-$&$' :WdZoÊi_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^fkXb_i^[Z_d '/'+"ki_d]WZe]ceZ[b$?d^_ifWf[h[dj_jb[ZÇ;nj_hfWj_ed e\j^[F_d[Wb8eZoÈ"^[YedYbkZ[Zj^WjÇj^[f_d[Wb_iWffWh# [djbodej[ii[dj_Wbjeb_\[WdZi[[cije^Wl[de_dÔk[dY[ kfedj^[Wd_cWbÊim[bbX[_d]$È
<_]$-$&$( Ikh]_YWb h[celWb e\ W jkceh \hec j^[ f_d[Wb h[]_ed h[fehj[Z Xo :WdZo$ Dej[ j^[ fbWY[c[dj e\ j^[ Xed[ ÔWf WdZ j^[ feij[h_eh _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^ [nfei_d]j^[f_d[WbfheY[ii$
J^[ Óhij _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y jhWdiYWbbeiWb WffheWY^ je j^[ f_d[Wb h[]_ed mWi eh_]_dWbbo Z[iYh_X[Z Xo MWbj[h ;$ :WdZo _d '/'+ ki_d] Wfeij[h_eh[nfeikh[_dWdWd_cWbceZ[b<_]$-$&$'$>_i[nf[h_[dY[ b[Z^_cjeik]][ijj^[\[Wi_X_b_joe\ikY^WdWffheWY^_d^kcWdi" WdZ i_n o[Whi bWj[h" ^[ fkXb_i^[Z ^_i _d_j_Wb [nf[h_[dY[ ki_d] j^_i c[j^eZ_dj^h[[YWi[ie\f_d[Wbh[]_edjkcehiQ:WdZo'/'+"'/('S$ :WdZo h[jkhd[Z je j^_i ikX`[Yj _d '/)) WdZ '/), <_]$-$&$( Wi ^[ mWiWXb[jeh[fehjedikYY[ii\kbbh[celWbe\j[df_d[Wbb[i_edil_WW h_]^jfWh_[jWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YjhWdiYWbbeiWbWffheWY^Q:WdZo'/(/" '/),S$J^_iWffheWY^mWij^[ceij\Wleh[Z\ehcWdoo[Whi$;hd[ij IWY^i[nfei[ZWbWh][Yoij_Yjkceh_dj^[f_d[Wbh[]_edWdZCWn F[[jh[cel[ZWf_d[Wbb[i_edj^hek]^Wh_]^jfWh_[je#eYY_f_jWbjhWdi# YWbbeiWb WffheWY^ QIWY^i '/(," F[[j '/(-S$ Ed[ o[Wh bWj[h" Ej\h_Z <e[hij[h fkXb_i^[Z ^_i [nf[h_[dY[ m_j^ j^[ feij[h_eh _dj[h^[c_# if^[h_Y [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ gkWZh_][c_dWb fbWj[ <_]$,$&$+ >_i _dj[h# ^[c_if^[h_Y ikXeYY_f_jWb jhWdij[djeh_Wb WffheWY^" f[h\ehc[Z ikY# Y[ii\kbbo _d j^h[[ fWj_[dji" mWi ik]][ij[Z Xo @kb_ki JWdZb[h WdZ ;]edHWdp__dj^[_hikh]_YWbWdWjec_YWbj[njXeea<_]$-$&$)QJWdZb[h éHWdp_'/(&"<e[hij[h'/(.S$ :WdZo Wbie ki[Z j^[ feij[h_eh _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y jhWdiYWbbeiWb WffheWY^\eh[nfeikh[e\ifWY[#eYYkfo_d]b[i_edie\j^[feij[h_eh j^_hZl[djh_Yb[$?d^_icede]hWf^[dj_jb[ZÇ8[d_]dJkcehi_dj^[J^_hZ L[djh_Yb[e\j^[8hW_d0:_W]dei_iWdZJh[Wjc[djÈ"^[Z[iYh_X[Z^_i ikh]_YWb[nf[h_[dY[m_j^_djhWl[djh_YkbWhjkcehiWdZYoij_Yb[i_edi Q:WdZo '/)'" '/))S$ <eh Wdj[h_eh j^_hZ l[djh_YkbWh jkcehi" :WdZo fh[\[hh[Z j^[ \hedjWb jhWdiYehj_YWb hekj[ <_]$.$&$( WdZ \eh feij[# h_ehbo i_jkWj[Z b[i_edi j^[ feij[h_eh jhWdiYWbbeiWb _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^<_]i$-$&$(".$&$'$J^[c_Z#iW]_jjWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YjhWdi# YWbbeiWb[nfeikh["fkXb_i^[Z_d_j_Wbbo_d'/)'"mWiki[Zedbo\ehYoij_Y b[i_edie\j^[i[fjkcf[bbkY_ZkcWdZYWlkcl[h]W[<_]$-$&$*$?j _i_dj[h[ij_d]jedej[j^Wj:WdZoh[fehj[Zded[khebe]_YWbZ[ÓY_ji eYYkhh_d] Wi W h[ikbj e\ ifb_jj_d] j^[ feij[h_eh fWhj e\ j^[ Yehfki YWbbeikc$ >em[l[h" j^[h[ ^Wl[ X[[d ej^[h ik]][ij_edi i^em_d] j^WjWbj^ek]^i[Yj_ed_d]j^[ceh[Wdj[h_ehfWhje\j^[YehfkiYWbbe# ikc_idejWiieY_Wj[Zm_j^i[l[h[Z_ij_dYjiocfjeci"feij[h_ehWdZ Yecfb[j[YWbbeiWbi[Yj_ed^Wi_dfWhj_YkbWhX[[di^emdjefheZkY[ WXheWZWhhWoe\X[^Wl_ehWbWXdehcWb_j_[i$
(('
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
7YYehZ_d]bo"lWdMW][d[dh[fehj[Z^_i[nf[h_[dY[e\ikh]_YWb[nfe# ikh[ e\ j^[ ^ofej^WbWc_Y h[]_ed l_W j^[ Wdj[h_eh _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y hekj[QlWdMW][d[d'/)/S$7i_c_bWh"ijh_Yjboc_Zb_d[[nfeikh[mWi Wbie fkXb_i^[Z Xo 8kiY^ Z[iYh_X_d] j^[ Wdj[h_eh _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y jhWdiYWbbeiWb_dj[h\ehd_Y[WbWffheWY^\ehh[celWbe\j^_hZl[djh_YkbWh jkcehiQ8kiY^'/**S$Ki_d]c_Yheikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[i"j^[ikh]_YWb b_j[hWjkh[ ^Wi YedjW_d[Z Wd _dYh[Wi_d] dkcX[h e\ h[fehji [cf^W# i_p_d]j^[[\ÓYWYoe\j^[Wdj[h_ehjhWdiYWbbeiWbWffheWY^<_]$-$&$+$ If[Y_WbWjj[dj_edi^ekbZX[]_l[djeC_Y^W[bB$@$7fkppe"m^e^WZ W kd_gk[ _dj[h[ij WdZ [dehceki [nf[h_[dY[ _d j^[ ikh]_YWb jh[Wj# c[dj e\ j^_hZ l[djh_YkbWh jkcehi QC_b^ehWj '/,," A[cf[ '/-," I^kYWhj '/-." :[bWdZi^[[h '/-." Ij[_d '/.&" 7fkppe '/.(S$ AWhb Kd][hiXYa WdZ 7n[b F[hd[Ypao" C_Y^W[b BWmjed WdZ HeX[hj If[jpb[h Z[iYh_X[Z j^[ WZlWdjW][i e\ j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWb [nfeikh[ \eh WffheWY^_d] j^[ bWj[hWb WdZ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[i QKd][hiXYa é F[hd[Ypao'/.,"BWmjedéIf[jpb[h'//,S$ J^[ Óhij _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y jhWdiYWbbeiWb WffheWY^ \eh j^[ jh[Wj# c[dj e\ W hkfjkh[Z Wd[khoic e\ j^[ 79e7 mWi fkXb_i^[Z Xo M_b^[bc Jdd_i QJdd_i '/),S$ >_i j[Y^d_gk[ h[gk_h[Z ifb_jj_d] e\ j^[ Wdj[h_eh Yehfki YWbbeikc <_]$ -$&$,$ MWbbWY[ >WcXo WdZ >[hX[hj Eb_l[YhedW ki[Z W l[ho i_c_bWh Wdj[h_eh jhWdiYWbbeiWb [nfeikh[Q>WcXo'/+("Eb_l[YhedW'/+)S$?d'/+/"BWmh[dY[Feeb Z[iYh_X[ZWZ_\\[h[dj"ceh[\hedjeXWiWbbofbWY[ZX_\hedjWbWffheWY^ je Wd[khoici e\ j^[ 79e7$ J^[ h[]_ed mWi [nfei[Z j^hek]^ Wd Wdj[he_d\[h_eh _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y hekj[ WdZ j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh h[]_ed YekbZ X[ [\\[Yj_l[bo WffheWY^[Z m_j^ekj ifb_jj_d] e\ j^[ Yehfki YWbbeikc QFeeb '/+/S$ <eh Z_ijWb Wd[khoici e\ j^[ 797" W i_c_bWh WffheWY^ mWi Z[iYh_X[Z Xo >k]e AhWo[dX^b WdZ @_he Ikpka_ QAhWo[dX^b'/+("Ikpka_'/--S$?d'//'"JWaWdeh_Whl[o9ki^_d]Z[iYh_X[Zj^[Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWdZikX# \hedjWbWffheWY^\ehj^[jh[Wjc[dje\eb\WYjeho]heel[c[d_d][e# cWim_j^j^[W_Ze\[b[Yjheikh][hoQ:WdZo'/(("9ki^_d]'/(-S$I_dY[ j^[i[Óhijh[fehji"j^[Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^^WiX[[d ki[Z \eh cWdo Z_\\[h[dj fWj^ebe]_[i e\ j^[ Wdj[h_eh \eiiW$ Ki_d]
(((
<_]$-$&$) ;nfeikh[ e\ j^[ f_d[Wb h[]_ed l_W j^[ eYY_f_jWb _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^" Z[iYh_X[Z Xo JWdZb[h WdZ HWdp_ _d j^[_h j[njXeea fkXb_i^[Z _d '/(&$ Dej[ j^[ jhWkcWj_Y h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ eYY_f_jWb beX[" d[Y[iiWho je l_ikWb_p[j^[Z[[f#i[Wj[ZWh[W$
<_]$-$&$* :WdZoÊi c_Z#iW]_jjWb _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^ Ç[ijWXb_i^_d] Yecckd_YWj_ed X[jm[[d j^[ Yoij_Y L$ l[djh_Yb[ WdZ bWj[hWb l[djh_Yb[È" h[fehj[Z _d '/)'$ Dej[j^Wj\eh[nfeikh[e\WifWY[#eYYkfo_d]YWlkci[fj_ f[bbkY_Z_":WdZoki[ZXhW_dh[jhWYj_edW]W_dij]hWl_jo$
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
7
8
9
<_]$-$&$+ H[bWj_edi^_f e\ ia_d _dY_i_ed 7 je Xkhh ^eb[i WdZ YhWd_ejeco 8 ki_d] j^[ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y jhWdiYWb# beiWbWffheWY^h[fehj[ZXoM_bb_WcI^kYWhj_dC_Y^W[bB$ @$7fkppeÊiYecfh[^[di_l[j[njXeeaÇIkh][hoe\j^[J^_hZ L[djh_Yb[È"fkXb_i^[Z_d'/.-WdZ'//.$J^_iWffheWY^mWi ki[Z je l_ikWb_p[ [dj_h[ dehcWb#i_p[ Wdj[h_eh l[djh_YkbWh ioij[c9$
c_Yheikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[i" C$ =Wp_ OWiWh]_b" =Wbb_d]^Wc I[a^Wh" EiiWcW7b#C[\jo"CWZ`_ZIWc__WdZ@_heIkpka_WffheWY^[Ziakbb XWi[ c[d_d][ecWi" YhWd_ef^Whod]_ecWi" j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ jkcehi WdZWd[khoici\hecj^_iWdj[h_ehZ_h[Yj_edQOWiWh]_b'/.&"I[a^Wh é7b#C[\jo'/.+"IWc__'/.'"Ikpka_'/.'S$ ?j YWd X[ i[[d j^Wj Zkh_d] j^[ bWij Z[YWZ[i cWdo Z_\\[h[dj _dj[h# ^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^[ijej^[c_Zb_d[h[]_ed^Wl[X[[dZ[iYh_X[Z$ >em[l[h"_d^_iÓhij[nf[h_[dY[i"MWbj[h:WdZoWbh[WZoh[Wb_p[Zj^[ _cfehjWdY[e\j^[hekj[e\j^[c_Zb_d[Yehh_Zeh0j^[ki[e\j^[a[o# ^eb[YedY[fj_d_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^[i$
<_]$-$&$, Jdd_iÊ \hedjWb _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^ \eh WdWd[khoice\j^[Wdj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d]Whj[hoYWki# _d]ikXWhWY^de_Z^[cehh^W]["h[fehj[Z_d'/),$J^[Wdj[# h_eh fWhj e\ j^[ Yehfki YWbbeikc mWi Z_l_Z[Z je ]W_d [nfeikh[ki_d]Wkd_bWj[hWb\hedjWbYhWd_ejeco$
?d j^[ \ebbem_d]" j^[ [ii[dY[ e\ j^[ a[o^eb[ YedY[fj _d d[kheikh# ][ho _i Z_iYkii[Z _d Z[jW_b ki_d] j^[ Wdj[h_eh WdZ feij[h_eh _dj[h# ^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^[i$
(()
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
Ki[e\j^[a[o^eb[YedY[fj_dj^[_dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^[iWdZ][d[hWbWdWjec_YWbYedijhkYj_ede\j^[ c_ZZb[Yehh_Zeh ?d'/**":WdZoh[fehj[ZedWikYY[ii\kbikh]_YWb[nfeikh[e\Whkf# jkh[ZWd[khoice\j^[79e7"YWki_d]i[l[h[_djhWl[djh_YkbWhXb[[Z# _d]Q:WdZo'/**S$>[WffheWY^[Zj^[Wdj[h_ehj^_hZl[djh_Yb[l_WW feij[h_eh _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y [nfeikh[ WdZ Z_W]dei[Z j^[ hkfjkh[Z Wd[khoicm_j^ekjki_d]Wdef[hWj_d]c_YheiYef[$?jmWifeii_Xb[ X[YWki[ j^[ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y Óiikh[ Wbbem[Z Wd el[hl_[m e\ j^[ [dj_h[ Yehfki YWbbeikc WdZ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[1 W ikh]_YWb Z_ii[Yj_ed ki_d]j^[_Z[We\j^[a[o^eb[YedY[fj<_]$-$&$-$
<_]$-$&$- Ki[e\j^[a[o^eb[YedY[fj_d_dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^[i$=[d[hWbbo"b[i_edie\j^[YehfkiYWbbeikc"j^[ bWj[hWbWdZj^_hZl[djh_Yb[i"j^[f_d[Wbh[]_edWdZj^[c_Z# b_d[iakbbXWi[Wh[Z[[f#i[Wj[Z$J^[iY^[cWj_YZhWm_d]e\ j^[c_Zb_d[ijhkYjkh[iZ[cedijhWj[i j^WjWb_c_j[Z[nfe# ikh[ YWd X[ ik\ÓY_[dj je l_ikWb_p[ j^[ Z[[f#i[Wj[Z Wh[Wi ki_d] j^[ WdWjec_YWb Yehh_Zeh e\ j^[ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y Óiikh[$
?d_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^[i"j^[cW`ehjefe]hWf^_Y[b[c[dji e\ j^[ c_Zb_d[ Yehh_Zeh h[gk_h[ _Z[dj_ÓYWj_ed WdZ Yedi_Z[hWj_ed" _dYbkZ_d] j^[ ikf[h_eh WdZ _d\[h_eh iW]_jjWb i_dki" fWhWiW]_jjWb l[_di" Yehfki YWbbeikc" f[h_YWbbeiWb Whj[h_[i" \ehd_n" i[fjkc f[bbk# Y_Zkc"Y_ij[hdWl[b__dj[hfei_j__m_j^j^[_dj[hdWbY[h[XhWbl[_di"bWj# [hWbWdZj^_hZl[djh_Yb[i"WdZj^[Wdj[heikf[h_ehfWhje\j^[ikfhW# i[bbWhWh[W$ J^[h[_iW]h[[c[djWced]ikh][edij^Wjfh[i[hlWj_ede\j^[iW]# _jjWbi_dkiWdZj^[_hl[dekijh_XkjWh_[i_iWd_cfehjWdj]eWb"Yh[Wj# _d]Wd_dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y[nfeikh[$?dfWhj_YkbWh" j^[YecX_dWj_ed e\ XhW_dh[jhWYj_edWdZl[dekieYYbki_edcWo h[ikbj _d [nj[dZ[Z
((*
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
l[deki _d\WhYj_ed m_j^ feijef[hWj_l[ d[khebe]_YWb Z[j[h_ehWj_ed$ ?\ W Xh_Z]_d] l[_d _i _d`kh[Z WdZ ckij X[ iWYh_Ó[Z" j^[ \ebbem_d] fh_dY_fb[ i^ekbZ X[ Yedi_Z[h[Z0 Y[h[XhWb l[_di Wh[ XWi_YWbbo WdWi# jecej_Y l[ii[bi m_j^ekj lWbl[i" j^[h[\eh[ je fh[i[hl[ j^[ WdWije# cej_Yfe_dji"j^[l[_diYWdX[eYYbkZ[Z$>em[l[h"W\j[heYYbki_ed e\j^[Xh_Z]_d]l[_d"j^[ki[e\Wh[jhWYjehYWdYWki[i[l[h[Yec# fh[ii_ede\j^_il[dekiWdWijecei_im_j^ikXi[gk[dj_d\WhYj_ede\ j^[ikhhekdZ_d]Wh[W$<ehj^_ih[Wied"Y[h[XhWbh[jhWYj_edckijX[ h[ijh_Yj[Zjej^[d[Y[iiWhoc_d_ckc"WYYehZ_d]jeWb_c_j[ZWdZ m[bb#fbWdd[Z YhWd_ejeco$ Dej[ j^Wj edbo Wd Wffhefh_Wj[ fbWY[# c[dj e\ W b_c_j[Z Xed[ ÔWf WYYehZ_d] je fh[ef[hWj_l[ l_ikWb_pW# j_ede\j^[l[dekiWdWjeco"YecX_d[Zm_j^YWh[\kbZ_ii[Yj_edWdZ b_c_j[ZXhW_dh[jhWYj_edYWd[\\[Yj_l[boc_d_c_p[ikh]_YWbZWcW][$ 7
8
<_]$-$&$. ?fi_bWj[hWb _dl[ij_]Wj_ed e\ j^[ bWj[hWb l[djh_Yb[ \ehc[Z_WbbobeYWj[Zb[i_edi7$M_j^ j^[^[bfe\[b[]Wdj hejWj_ede\j^[^[WZZkh_d]fei_j_ed_d]e\j^[fWj_[dj"j^[ ]hWl_jo#h[bWj[Zi[b\#h[jhWYj_ede\j^[XhW_def[dij^[_dj[h# ^[c_if^[h_Y Óiikh[ Wbbem_d] WjhWkcWj_Y ikh]_YWb Z_ii[Y# j_edm_j^ekjki_d]WXhW_difWjkbW8$
7
8
<_]$-$&$/ IY^[cWj_Y ZhWm_d] e\ j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWb _dj[h# ^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^ \eh bWj[hWbbo i_jkWj[Z _djhWl[d# jh_YkbWh b[i_edi 7$ Ki_d] j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWb j[Y^d_gk[" _djhWef[hWj_l[jhWkcWj_pWj_ede\j^[i_Z[e\j^[b[i_edYWd X[ [\\[Yj_l[bo c_d_c_p[Z _d ehZ[h dej je `[efWhZ_p[ j^[ \hedjWb eh fWh_[jWb beX[$ J^_i _i _cfehjWdj [if[Y_Wbbo \eh Zec_dWdji_Z[Zb[i_edi$Dej[j^[fei_j_ede\j^[\WbnYel[h# _d] WdZ fhej[Yj_d] j^[ ^[c_if^[h[ \hec Z_h[Yj ifWjkbW fh[iikh[$ Ki_d] WZ[gkWj[ fei_j_ed_d]" hek]^ XhW_d h[jhWY# j_ed YWd X[ Wle_Z[Z ed Xej^ i_Z[i0 j^[ _fi_bWj[hWb ^[c_# if^[h[Z[ÔWj[im_j^ekjki_d]Wh[jhWYjehWYYehZ_d]jej^[ ]hWl_jo#h[bWj[Z i[b\#h[jhWYj_ed1 j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWb ^[c_# if^[h[ _i h[jhWYj[Z \ehY[\kbbo1 ^em[l[h" fhej[Yj[Z Xo j^[ \WbnY[h[Xh_8$
7\j[h YWh[\kb XhW_d h[jhWYj_ed WdZ Z_ii[Yj_ed e\ j^[ f[h_YWbbeiWb Whj[h_[i" m^_Y^ cWo iec[j_c[i X[ ^_ZZ[d _d j^[ ikbYki e\ j^[ YehfkiYWbbeikcehcWoYheiij^[c_Zb_d["lWh_ekiceZ[ie\[djho _djej^[l[djh_YkbWhioij[cWh[feii_Xb[$>em[l[h"_j_i_cfehjWdj je dej[ j^[ feii_Xb[ i[l[h[ d[khe#f^oi_ebe]_YWb Yedi[gk[dY[i e\ Wdef[hWj_l[Yecc_iikhWbi[Yj_edWiZ[iYh_X[Z_ddkc[hekifkX# b_YWj_ediQ7fkppe'/.,S$7dWYkj[iodZhec[\ebbem_d]i[Yj_ed_d] e\ j^[ Wdj[h_eh fehj_ed e\ j^[ Yehfki YWbbeikc YWd X[ Y^WhWYj[h# _p[Z Xo W Z[Yh[Wi[ _d j^[ ifedjWd[_jo e\ if[[Y^ hWd]_d] \hec W c_bZibemd[ii_d_d_j_Wj_d]if[[Y^je\hWdackj_ic$:_l_i_ede\j^[ feij[h_ehYehfkiYWbbeikcWdZifb[d_kccWoYWki[WXheWZhWd][ e\X[^Wl_ehWbWXdehcWb_j_[i$<ehj^_ih[Wied"Yecc_iikhWbi[Yj_ed i^ekbZX[h[ijh_Yj[Zjej^[d[Y[iiWhoc_d_ckc$ B[i_edi e\ j^[ bWj[hWb l[djh_Yb[ beYWj[Z c[Z_Wbbo m_j^_d j^[ l[d# jh_YkbWhY^WcX[hYWdX[efj_cWbbo[nfei[Zj^hek]^Wd_fi_bWj[hWb _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^$ Ki_d] j^[ _fi_bWj[hWb Z_ii[Yj_ed" j^[ ^[c_if^[h[ YWd X[ ][djbo ceX_b_p[Z WdZ h[jhWYj[Z WmWo \hec j^[ \Wbn$ Efj_cWb fei_j_ed_d] e\ j^[ ^[WZ [dWXb[i dedjhWkcWj_Y [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ bWj[hWb l[djh_Yb[ W\j[h b_c_j[Z YWbbeiejeco$ Dej[ j^Wj h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ XhW_d j_iik[ YWd X[ [\\[Yj_l[bo c_d_c_p[Z0 m_j^WZ[gkWj[fei_j_ed_d]e\ j^[fWj_[dj j^[]hWl_jo#h[bWj[Zi[b\# h[jhWYj_ede\j^[XhW_def[dij^[_dj[h^[c_if^[h_Yhekj[m_j^ekj hek]^h[jhWYj_ede\j^[Y[h[XhWbj_iik[<_]$-$&$.$B[i_edibeYWj[Z bWj[hWbbo_dehWZ`WY[djjej^[bWj[hWbl[djh_Yb["[if[Y_Wbbom_j^_dj^[ Zec_dWdj^[c_if^[h_Yi_Z["i^ekbZX[[nfei[Zl_WWYedjhWbWj[hWb jhWdiYWbbeiWb WffheWY^$ H[jhWYj_d] j^[ \Wbn WdZ j^[ effei_j[ Y_d# ]kbWj[]ohki"j^[YedjhWbWj[hWbboi_jkWj[Zb[i_edYWdX[[\\[Yj_l[bo WffheWY^[Z<_]$-$&$/$
((+
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
<_]$-$&$'& ?dj[h\ehd_YWb_dl[ij_]Wj_ed e\ j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ ki_d] j^[ _dj[h# ^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^$ 7\j[h Z_l_Z_d] j^[ \ehd_YWb Yecc_iikh[" j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[_i[dj[h[Zj^hek]^j^[l[bkc _dj[hfei_jkc WdZ _ji Y^ehe_ZWb hee\$ J^_i WffheWY^ Wbbemi m_Z[ [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_YkbWh Y^WcX[h1 ^em[l[h" Yedjki_edi e\ Xej^ \ehd_Y[i cWo h[ikbj _d i[l[h[ feijef[hWj_l[ c[cehobeii$
7
<_]$-$&$'' Ki_d] j^[ ikXY^ehe_ZWb eh jhWdiY^ehe_ZWb [nfeikh[" j^[ \ehd_n cWo X[ ][djbo ceX_b_p[Z kdZ[h fhe# j[Yj_ed e\ j^[ Yel[h_d] Y^ehe_ZWb j_iik[$J^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[YWdWbieX[ m_Z[bo[nfei[Zm_j^ekjjhWdi\ehd_YWb Z_ii[Yj_ed$
8
<_]$-$&$'( Ki_d]j^[jhWdiYWbbeiWbjhWdi\ehWc_dWb[nfeikh[e\j^[j^_hZl[djh_YkbWh Y^WcX[h" j^[ ikh][ed ]W_di Wd el[hl_[m _dje j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ j^hek]^ j^[ \ehWc[de\Cedhe1^em[l[h"edboW\j[h][djb[h[jhWYj_ede\j^[\ehd_n7$?dYec# fWh_ied"ki_d]j^[jhWdiYehj_YWbhekj["ed[_iWXb[je_dl[ij_]Wj[j^[j^_hZl[djh_YkbWh Y^WcX[hm_j^ekjjekY^_d]j^[\ehd_YWbijhkYjkh[i$J^[jhWdiYehj_YWbhekj[i^ekbZ X[ki[Z[if[Y_Wbbo_dj^[YWi[e\^oZheY[f^Wb_YYedÓ]khWj_ede\j^[l[djh_Yb[i8$
((,
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
7
8
<_]$-$&$') Ki_d] W jhWdi\ehWc_dWb WffheWY^" efj_ckc fbWY[c[dje\j^[YhWd_ejeco_i[ii[dj_WbjeWle_Z\ehd_YWb Yedjki_ed$M_j^ ]eeZ fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d]" j^[ _dZ_l_Z# kWb WdWjeco e\ j^[ \ehWc[d e\ Cedhe WdZ j^[ i_p[ WdZ i_j[e\ j^[_dj[hj^WbWc_YWZ^[i_edi^ekbZX[Z[j[hc_d[Z YecfWh[Zjej^[jWh][jfe_dj$B[i_edie\j^[Wdj[h_ehj^_hZ l[djh_Yb[WdZj^[XWi_bWhj_fi^ekbZX[WffheWY^[Zj^hek]^ Wfeij[h_ehbofbWY[ZYhWd_ejeco7$J^[feij[h_ehY^WcX[h e\ j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ YWd X[ efj_cWbbo [nfei[Z j^hek]^ WdWdj[h_ehbofbWY[ZWffheWY^8$
7ffheWY^_d] j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ ki_d] W jhWdiYWbbeiWb hekj[" j^[ j^_hZl[djh_YkbWhY^WcX[hYWdX[WffheWY^[Zl_WWd_dj[h\ehd_YWb" ikXY^ehe_ZWb" jhWdiY^ehe_ZWb eh jhWdi\ehWc_dWb fWj^$ Ki_d] j^[ _dj[h\ehd_YWb [nfeikh[" cWd_fkbWj_ed e\ j^[ \ehd_n ckij WbmWoi X[ _dYbkZ[Z1 Zk[ je _dY_i_ed e\ j^[ \ehd_YWb hWf^[ WdZ Yedjki_ed e\ Xej^ \ehd_Y[i" f[hi_ij[dj c[ceho beii cWo h[ikbj <_]$ -$&$'&$ ?d YedjhWij je X_bWj[hWb \ehd_YWb Z_ii[Yj_ed" kd_bWj[hWb ZWcW][ i[[cijeh[ikbj_dc_dehZ[ÓY_ji"[if[Y_Wbboedj^[dedZec_dWdj i_Z[$J^[h[\eh["_dehZ[hjec_d_c_p[j^[h_iae\Wcd[i_W"j^[ikX# Y^ehe_ZWb eh jhWdiY^ehe_ZWb WffheWY^ i^ekbZ X[ h[Yecc[dZ[Z \eh [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ <_]$ -$&$''$ J^[i[ [nfeikh[i e\j[dh[gk_h[edboc_dehceX_b_pWj_ede\j^[\ehd_YWb[b[c[dji_d WZZ_j_ed je j^[ Z_ifbWY[c[dj fheZkY[Z Xo j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_YkbWh cWiib[i_ed_ji[b\$J^[jhWdi\ehWc_dWbWffheWY^cWoX[X[jj[hYec# fWh[Z m_j^ j^[ ej^[h f[h_\ehd_YWb hekj[i _d j^[ YWi[ e\ [dbWh][Z l[djh_Yb[i Zk[ je Y^hed_Y ^oZheY[f^Wbki <_]$ -$&$'($ Dej[ j^Wj ki_d]j^_ijhWdi\ehWc_dWbWffheWY^"fh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]e\j^[ fbWY[c[dje\j^[YhWd_ejeco_i[ii[dj_WbjeWle_ZYedjki_ede\j^[ \ehd_n<_]$-$&$')$ >em[l[h"Wic[dj_ed[ZWXel[_dj^[^_ijeh_YWbel[hl_[m"ki_d]j^[ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Yhekj[dejedboj^[l[djh_YkbWhY^WcX[hXkjej^[h l[ho Z_\\[h[dj _djhWYhWd_Wb h[]_edi YWd X[ [\\[Yj_l[bo WffheWY^[Z JWXb[-$&$'$ 9ecfWh[Z m_j^ j^[ Wdj[h_eh ikf[h_eh jhWdiYWbbeiWb _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^\eh_djhWl[djh_YkbWh[nfeikh["j^[Wdj[# h_eh_d\[h_ehikXYWbbeiWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y[nfeikh[e\\[hiWZ[gkWj[ l_ikWb_pWj_ede\j^[Wdj[h_ehiakbbXWi[$?dWZZ_j_ed"j^[Wdj[h_ehfWhj e\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[YWdX[m[bbWffheWY^[Z"Z_ii[Yj_d]j^hek]^ j^[bWc_dWj[hc_dWb_i$8oj^[feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^" b[i_edie\j^[feij[h_ehj^_hZl[djh_Yb[WdZj^[f_d[Wbh[]_edYWdX[ m[bb[nfei[Z$ E\Yekhi["WYYehZ_d]jej^[_dZ_l_ZkWbfWj^eWdWjec_YWbi_jkWj_ed" j^[ WXel[#c[dj_ed[Z jWh][j h[]_edi YWd X[ Wbie [nfei[Z ki_d] Wbj[hdWj_l[ WffheWY^[i$ 7d Wbj[hdWj_l[ WffheWY^ je j^[ Wdj[h_eh ikf[h_eh jhWdiYWbbeiWb [nfeikh[ \eh _djhWl[djh_YkbWh b[i_edi YWd X[ j^[ \hedjWb jhWdiYehj_YWb WffheWY^" Wi Z[iYh_X[Z _d Y^Wfj[h .$ B[i_edie\j^[Wdj[h_ehiakbbXWi[WdZj^[Wdj[h_ehj^_hZl[djh_Yb[ YWd Wbie X[ [nfei[Z l_W j^[ ikX\hedjWb ikfhWehX_jWb WffheWY^" Z[iYh_X[Z _d Y^Wfj[h ($ ?dij[WZ e\ j^[ feij[h_eh ikXYWbbeiWb _dj[h# ^[c_if^[h_Y[nfeikh["j^[ikfhWY[h[X[bbWh_d\hWj[djeh_Wbhekj[YWd X[f[h\ehc[Z\ehWffheWY^_d]j^[f_d[Wbh[]_edWdZj^[feij[h_eh j^_hZl[djh_Yb["WiZ_iYkii[Z_dY^Wfj[h,$
((-
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
?d j^[ \ebbem_d]" j^[ XWi_Y ikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[ e\ j^[ _dj[h^[c_# if^[h_YWdZ jhWdiYWbbeiWbWffheWY^[iWh[Z_iYkii[Z[nfei_d] j^[ bWj[hWb WdZ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[i JWXb[-$&$($ J^[ Wdj[h_eh \hedjWb ikX# YWbbeiWbWdZj^[feij[h_eheYY_f_jWbikXYWbbeiWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^[iWh[Z[iYh_X[ZWilWh_Wj_edie\j^[cW_d[nfeikh[$
_dj[h\ehd_YWb jhWdi\ehWc_dWb ikXY^ehe_ZWb
j^_hZl[djh_Yb[ jhWdi#bWc_dW#j[hc_dWb_i
j^_hZl[djh_Yb[
iakbbXWi[
bWj[hWbl[djh_Yb[
Wdj[h_ehikXYWbbeiWb
Wdj[h_ehjhWdiYWbbeiWb
Wdj[h_eh _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y feij[h_eh
feij[h_ehikXYWbbeiWb
feij[h_ehjhWdiYWbbeiWb
f_d[Wbh[]_ed
bWj[hWbl[djh_Yb[
l[bkc_dj[hfei_jkc
j^_hZl[djh_Yb[ ikXY^ehe_ZWb
JWXb[-$&$' :_\\[h[djlWh_Wdjie\_dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y[nfeikh[i$
?fi_bWj[hWb
C_Zb_d[
9edjhWbWj[hWb
C[Z_WbfWhje\j^[\hedjWbbeX[ ?fi_bWj[hWbY_d]kbWj[]ohki
Ikf[h_ehiW]_jjWbi_dki 7dj[h_ehY[h[XhWb\Wbn :_ijWb7)"7*i[]c[djie\j^[797 7dj[h_ehYehfkiYWbbeikc L[bkc_dj[hfei_jkc J^_hZl[djh_Yb[ ?dj[hf[ZkdYkbWh\eiiW J_fe\j^[87"_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi
Effei_j[Y_d]kbWj[]ohki BWj[hWbWif[Yje\j^[YedjhWbWj[hWb l[djh_Yb[
JWXb[-$&$( 7dWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[im^_Y^YWdX[WffheWY^[Zj^hek]^j^[Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YjhWdiYWbbeiWbfheY[Zkh[$
((.
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[
<_]$-$&$'*
'$FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] M_j^ j^[ fWj_[dj _d W ikf_d[ fei_j_ed" j^[ feij_j_ed e\ j^[ ^[WZ i^ekbZWbbemWikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_edd[Whjej^[f[hf[dZ_YkbWhfbWd[$ J^_ifhel_Z[iWd[\ÓY_[djikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_edWdZWle_ZiWdkdYed# jhebb[Z beii e\ 9I<" m^_Y^ _i Wd _cfehjWdj Yecfb_YWj_d] \WYjeh _d Wbb_djhWl[djh_YkbWhfheY[Zkh[i$J^[^[WZ_iÓn[Zki_d]WCWoÓ[bZ ^ebZ[hm_j^j^[i_d]b[f_de\j^[^[WZÓnWjehfbWY[Zedj^[effe# i_j[i_Z[jeWbbem\h[[ikh]_YWbcWd_fkbWj_ed$ Ij[f' 7iWÓhijij[f"j^[^[WZe\j^[fWj_[djWdZj^[ef[hWj_d]jWXb[Wh[ [b[lWj[ZWffhen_cWj[bo'+"jefhel_Z[ik\ÓY_[djl[dekiZhW_dW][ <_]$-$&$'*$
<_]$-$&$'+
<_]$-$&$',
Ij[f( J^[h[W\j[h"j^[^[WZ_iYWh[\kboWdj[heÔ[Yj[Zm_j^ekjYecfh[ii_ed e\j^[bWhodnWdZj^[l[dj_bWj_edjkX[$M_j^WÔ[n_ede\YW$'+je *+"j^[YhWd_ejecoi_j[_iedj^[kff[hfWhje\j^[fei_j_ed[Z^[WZ" Wle_Z_d]WbWh][beiie\9I<<_]$-$&$'+$ Ij[fi)Å* <_dWbbo" j^[ ^[WZ _i hejWj[Z YW$ '& je )& <_]$ -$&$', WdZ bWj[he# Ô[Yj[Z je j^[ i_Z[ e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco <_]$ -$&$'-$J^_i cWd[klh[ e\bWj[heÔ[n_edWdZhejWj_edYWki[iWi_]d_ÓYWdjh[bWnWj_ede\j^[ \hedjWb beX[ WmWo \hec j^[ \Wbn Y[h[Xh_" Wbbem_d] W c_d_ckc eh [l[d WXi[dj h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ Y[h[XhWb ^[c_if^[h[ WdZ h[ikbj_d] _dWdefj_cWbWYY[iijej^[b[i_ed$7ffheWY^_d]j^[_fi_bWj[hWbi_Z[" WbWj[heÔ[n_ede\YW$)&WdZhejWj_ede\'&_id[Y[iiWho"m^[h[Wi [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ effei_j[ i_Z[ h[gk_h[i W bWj[heÔ[n_ed e\ YW$ '& WdZhejWj_ede\'&jefhel_Z[Wd[\ÓY_[djmeha_d]fei_j_ed\ehj^[ ikh][ed$
<_]$-$&$'-
((/
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
($7dWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZeh_[djWj_ed <ehWdefj_cWbia_d_dY_i_ed"j^[_cfehjWdjWdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhai e\j^[eii[ekiiakbbikY^Wij^[YehedWhoWdZiW]_jjWbikjkh[iWh[ fh[Y_i[boZ[Ód[Z<_]$-$&$'/$ 7\j[h j^_i XWi_Y eh_[djWj_ed" j^[ fbWY[c[dj e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco _i [nWYjbo Z[Ód[Z WYYehZ_d] je j^[ jWh][j Wh[W$ Dej[ j^Wj j^[ Xeh# Z[hie\j^[jh[f^_dWj_edi^ekbZYheiij^[c_Zb_d[je]W_dYedjheb e\j^[i_dkiiW]_jjWb_iikf[h_eh$7\j[hZ[Ód_j_ede\j^[YhWd_ejeco" j^[_dZ_l_ZkWbefj_ckcb_d[e\j^[ia_d_dY_i_ed_icWha[Zm_j^W f[d$J^[ijhW_]^jiW]_jjWbia_d_dY_i_ed_ifbWY[Z_dj^[fh[YehedWho h[]_ed"`kijX[^_dZ j^[\hedjWb^W_hb_d[<_]$-$&$'.$7\j[hc_d_cWb eh[l[dWXi[dji^Wl_d]e\j^[^W_h"j^[ia_d_iYWh[\kbboZ_i_d\[Yj[Z m_j^WbYe^ebiebkj_ed$?dXWbZfWj_[djieh_dif[Y_Wbi_jkWj_edi"j^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed WdZ j^[ YhWd_ejeco cWo X[ fbWY[Z Wdj[h_eh je j^[ _cW]_dWho^W_hb_d[$<ehj^_ifkhfei["mh_dab[i_dj^[ia_dcWoX[ Y^ei[d\ehj^[_dY_i_ed"j^[_dY_i_edWdj[h_ehj^[^W_hb_d[i^ekbZX[ jhWdil[hi["WYYehZ_d]jej^[fhec_d[djmh_dab[i$
<_]$-$&$'. :[Ód_j_ed e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco WYYehZ# _d] je j^[ WdWjec_YWb bWdZcWhai e\ j^[ \hedjWb h[]_ed$J^[fWhWc[Z_WdfbWY[ZYhWd_ejecoWbbemi iW\[ Yedjheb e\ j^[ c_Zb_d[ WdZ e\\[hi WZ[gkWj[ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YZ_ii[Yj_ed$
()&
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
)$9hWd_ejeco Ij[f' H_]^ji_Z[$7\j[hc_d_cWbeh[l[dWXi[dji^Wl# _d] e\ j^[ ^W_h" W YW$+Yc bed] ijhW_]^j ia_d _dY_i_ed _i f[h\ehc[Z YW$'$+Yc fWhWc[Z_Wd \hecj^[YWh[\kbboZ[Ód[Zc_Zb_d[<_]$-$&$'/$
<_]$-$&$'/
Ij[f( 7\j[hceX_b_pWj_ede\j^[ikXYkjWd[ekij_iik[" j^[ ]Wb[W Wfed[khej_YW WdZ j^[ f[h_eij[Wb bWo[h Wh[ _dY_i[Z _d W Ykhl[Z \Wi^_ed WdZ h[jhWYj[ZjemWhZj^[c_Zb_d[$?\d[Y[iiWho"j^_i j_iik[ YWd X[ ki[Z bWj[h \eh W mWj[hj_]^j Ybe# ikh[e\j^[ZkhWcWj[h<_]$-$&$(&$
<_]$-$&$(&
Ij[f) M_j^ W YhWd_ejec[" jme Xkhh ^eb[i Wh[ f[h# \ehc[Z WYYehZ_d] je j^[ c_Zb_d[" `kij WXel[ j^[ III$J^[ cW_d ZWd][h e\ Wdo c_Zb_d[ YhW# d_ejeco_ij^[j[Wh_d]e\j^[III1^em[l[h"Xo j^_ij[Y^d_gk[_d`khojej^[i_dkiYWdX[[\\[Y# j_l[bo Wle_Z[Z$ J^[ Óhij Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dW# j_edi^ekbZX[fbWY[Z\hedjWbboWjj^[Wdj[h_eh# c[Z_WbYehd[h"j^[i[YedZXkhh^eb[fWh_[jWbbo Wjj^[feij[h_eh#c[Z_WbYehd[he\j^[fbWdd[Z YhWd_ejeco$J^[Wh]kc[dj\ehj^_i\ehce\YhW# d_ejeco_ij^Wj_jWff[WhijeX[iW\[hjefbWY[ j^[ Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_ed [nWYjbo WXel[ j^[ III WdZ [nfei[ _j el[h _ji \kbb m_Zj^" j^Wd je Yheii _j m_j^ j^[ YhWd_ejec[" eh je iWm Xb_dZ fWhWbb[bjej^[i_dki<_]$-$&$('$
<_]$-$&$('
()'
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
<_]$-$&$((
Ij[f* 7\j[h ceX_b_pWj_ed e\ j^[ ZkhW cWj[h m_j^ W Xbkdj Z_ii[Yjeh" j^[ Xkhh ^eb[i i^ekbZ X[ [dbWh][Z ki_d] Ód[ A[hh_ied hed][khi$ 8o h[celWb e\ j^[ Xedo [Z][i e\ j^[ ]heel[ e\ j^[III"j^[bWj[hWbXehZ[hie\j^[i_dkiYWdX[ [\\[Yj_l[boY^[Ya[Z<_]$-$&$(($
<_]$-$&$()
Ij[f+ Ki_d] W YhWd_ejec[" ed[ d[l[h i^ekbZ Ykj _d j^[Z_h[Yj_ede\j^[III$7YYehZ_d]jej^_ifh_d# Y_fb[" W Ykhl[Z b_d[ _i iWm[Z \hec j^[ \hedjWb Xkhh^eb[edj^[_fi_bWj[hWbi_Z[$J^_i_fi_bWj[hWb Ykj _i j^[d Yecfb[j[Z \hec j^[ fWh_[jWb Xkhh ^eb[<_]$-$&$()$
<_]$-$&$(*
Ij[f, J^[h[W\j[h" j^[ YhWd_ejec[ _i ki[Z ed j^[ effei_j[i_Z[_dWi_c_bWhmWo"Yh[Wj_d]WfWhW# c[Z_Wd YhWd_ejeco m_j^ Wd [\\[Yj_l[ Yedjheb e\j^[III<_]$-$&$(*$
()(
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
Ij[f- 7\j[hh[celWbe\j^[Xed[ÔWfm_j^WZ_Wc[j[h e\YW$($&je)$&Yc"j^[_dd[h[Z][e\j^[Xed[ i^ekbZX[h[cel[Zki_d]Ód[fkdY^[i$:k[je YWh[\kb h[celWb e\ j^[ jWXkbW _dj[hdW Wdj[h_# ehboWdZfeij[h_ehbo"j^[Wd]b[\eh_djhWYhWd_Wb l_ikWb_pWj_edYWdi_]d_ÓYWdjbo_dYh[Wi[$?dj^[ \khj^[hYekhi[e\j^[ef[hWj_ed"j^_ijh_YaYWd ]h[Wjbo \WY_b_jWj[ j^[ Wffb_YWj_ed e\ Yedl[d# j_edWb c_Yhe_dijhkc[dji j^hek]^ j^[ b_c_j[Z YhWd_ejeco<_]$-$&$(+$
<_]$-$&$(+
Ij[f. J^[ ZkhW i^ekbZ X[ ef[d[Z _d W i[c_Y_hYkbWh \Wi^_edm_j^j^[XWi[e\j^[ZkhWbÔWfjemWhZ j^[ III$J^[ \h[[ ZkhWb ÔWf _i Ón[Z m_j^ jme ikjkh[i1ej^[hZkhWb[b[lWj_edikjkh[iWh[dej h[gk_h[Z$EYYWi_edWb_d`kh_[ijej^[IIIYWddej X[eYYbkZ[Zm_j^X_febWhYeW]kbWj_edX[YWki[ i^h_da_d]e\j^[ZkhWbj_iik[[dbWh][ij^[^eb[$ <ehj^_ih[Wied"^[ceYb_fiWdZYWh[\kbbofbWY[Z ikjkh[iYWdX[[\\[Yj_l[<_]$-$&$(,$
<_]$-$&$(,
())
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
*$?djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ij[f' H_]^j i_Z[$ :_ii[Yj_ed ki_d] W \ehcWbZ[^oZ[# Ón[Z ^kcWd if[Y_c[d$ 7hj[h_Wb l[ii[bi Wh[ fh[fWh[Zm_j^Wh[ZbWj[niebkj_ed$7\j[hZkhWb ef[d_d]"j^[ikf[h_eh\hedjWb]ohkii^ekbZX[ YWh[\kbboZ_ii[Yj[Z\hecj^[c_Zb_d[$?\fh[i[dj" Xh_Z]_d] l[_di hkd iec[ c_bb_c[j[hi m_j^_d j^[ Yedl[n_jo#ZkhW eh m_j^_d j^[ \Wbn X[\eh[ [dj[h_d]j^[III$Ki_d]c_Yhe_dijhkc[dji"j^_i fWhje\j^[l[_di^ekbZX[Z_ii[Yj[ZWmWo\hec j^[ZkhW"Wbbem_d][nfeikh[e\j^[_dj[h^[c_# if^[h_YÓiikh[<_]$-$&$(-$
Xh_Z]_d]l[_d \hedjWbbeX[
<_]$-$&$(-
<_]$-$&$(.
Ij[f( ?d WZZ_j_ed" j^[ ikf[hÓY_Wb Xh_Z]_d] l[_d i^ekbZX[YWh[\kbboZ_ii[Yj[Z\hecWhWY^de_ZWb WZ^[i_edi"]W_d_d]ki[\kbWZZ_j_edWbceX_b_pW# j_ede\j^[ikf[h_eh\hedjWb]ohki$?\j^[l[_d_i _d`kh[ZWdZckijX[eYYbkZ[Z"Y[h[XhWbh[jhWY# j_edi^ekbZX[h[ijh_Yj[Zjej^[WXiebkj[c_d_# ckc Wle_Z_d] Yecfh[ii_ed e\ j^[ ikhhekdZ# _d] l[deki WdWijecei[i$ CeX_b_pWj_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWbbeX[YWdX[ikYY[ii\kbboikffb[c[dj[Z m_j^WYehh[Yjfei_j_ed_d]e\j^[^[WZe\\[h_d] [\\[Yj_l[ h[bWnWj_ed e\ j^[ XhW_d" m^_Y^ j^[d" Zk[je]hWl_jo"i_daiifedjWd[ekiboWmWo\hec j^[\WbnY[h[Xh_<_]$-$&$(.$ Ij[f) 7\j[hceX_b_pWj_ede\j^[\hedjWbbeX[WdZj^[ \Wbn Y[h[Xh_" j^[ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y Óiikh[ _i YWh[\kbbo WffheWY^[Z$ Dej[ j^[ YWbbeiecWh# ]_dWbWhj[ho1j^[f[h_YWbbeiWbWhj[hoWff[Whi_d j^[XWYa]hekdZ<_]$-$&$(/$
YWbbeiecWh]_dWb Whj[ho f[h_YWbbeiWbWhj[ho
<_]$-$&$(/
()*
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
Ij[f* M_j^ \khj^[h Z_ii[Yj_ed m_j^_d j^[ _dj[h# ^[c_if^[h_Y Óiikh[" j^[ Yehfki YWbbeikc _i WffheWY^[Z$J^[ Y_d]kbWj[Z ]ohki _i YWh[\kbbo h[jhWYj[Z ed Xej^ i_Z[i$ Dej[ j^[ _dZki_kc ]h_i[kcedj^[ikh\WY[e\j^[YehfkiYWbbeikc WdZj^[ceX_b_p[ZWhj[h_[i<_]$-$&$)&$
b[\jf[h_YWbbeiWb Whj[ho YehfkiYWbbeikc h_]^jf[h_YWbbeiWb Whj[ho
<_]$-$&$)&
Ij[f+ 7\j[h b_c_j[Z YWbbeiejeco" j^[ Y^WcX[h e\ j^[ h_]^j bWj[hWb l[djh_Yb[ _i [dj[h[Z$J^[ Y^e# he_Zfb[nkiZ_iWff[Whim_j^_dj^[\ehWc[de\ Cedhe"j^[Wdj[h_ehfWhje\j^[l[djh_Yb[m_j^# ekjfb[nkiYehh[ifedZijej^[\hedjWb^ehde\ j^[bWj[hWbl[djh_Yb[$Dej[j^[\ehd_n"j^[^[WZ e\j^[YWkZWj[dkYb[kiWdZj^[bWc_dWW\ÓnW j^WbWc_$ 8[YWki[ e\ j^[ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^"j^[\ehWc[de\CedheWff[Whi_dWd eXb_gk[l_[m\hecWXel[<_]$-$&$)'$
\ehd_n Y^ehe_Zfb[nki \ehWc[de\ Cedhe j^WbWcki ^[WZe\j^[ YWkZWj[dkYb[ki
<_]$-$&$)'
Ij[f, <eYki_d]Wdj[h_ehbo"j^[\ehWc[de\CedheWdZ j^[\hedjWb^ehdWh[[nfei[Z$Dej[j^[\ehd_n1 j^[ Y^ehe_Z fb[nki Z_iWff[Whi _dje j^[ \ehW# c[de\Cedhe<_]$-$&$)($ \ehWc[de\ Cedhe \ehd_n \hedjWb^ehd
<_]$-$&$)(
()+
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
Ij[f;nfeikh[ e\ j^[ \ehWc[d e\ Cedhe WdZ j^[ Y[bbWc[Z_We\j^[bWj[hWbl[djh_Yb[$J^[Y^ehe_Z fb[nki _i ][djbo h[jhWYj[Z m_j^ W c_YheikYa[h Wbbem_d]l_ikWb_pWj_ede\j^[Y^ehe_ZWbÓiikh[ X[jm[[d\ehd_nWdZj^WbWcki<_]$-$&$))$
Y^ehe_ZWbÓiikh[ Y^ehe_Zfb[nki j^WbWcki \ehWc[de\Cedhe \ehd_n
<_]$-$&$))
Ij[f. J^[Y^ehe_Zfb[nki_iYWh[\kbboZ_ii[Yj[Z\hec j^[j[d_Wj^WbWc_Wbbem_d]ikXY^ehe_ZWb[nfe# ikh[ e\ j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[$ Dej[ icWbb f[h\e# hWjehie\ j^[Y^ehe_ZWbWhj[h_[iikffbo_d] j^[ j^WbWcki<_]$-$&$)*$
j^_hZl[djh_Yb[ Y^ehe_Zfb[nki j^WbWcki
<_]$-$&$)*
Ij[f/ J^[ Y^ehe_Z fb[nki WdZ j^[ _dj[hdWb Y[h[XhWb l[_dWh[h[jhWYj[Z\ehWffheWY^_d]j^[c_ZZb[ WdZfeij[h_ehfWhjie\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[$Dej[ j^[ _dj[hj^WbWc_Y WZ^[i_ed WdZ j^[ Ôeeh e\ j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[<_]$-$&$)+$
j^WbWcki _dj[hj^WbWc_Y WZ^[i_ed Ôeehe\j^[j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ Y^ehe_Zfb[nki _dj[hdWb Y[h[XhWbl[_d
<_]$-$&$)+
(),
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
+$:khW"Xed[WdZmekdZYbeikh[ 7\j[h Yecfb[j_ed e\ j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[" j^[ _djhWl[djh_Yk# bWh WdZ _djhWZkhWb ifWY[ _i Óbb[Z m_j^ Whj_ÓY_Wb 9I< iebkj_ed Wj XeZo j[cf[hWjkh[$<eh j^_ifkhfei[_j_iki[\kb_\ j^[YhWd_ejeco _ifbWY[ZWjj^[^_]^[ijfe_dje\j^[^[WZ"ej^[hm_i[i[l[h[feij# ef[hWj_l[ fd[kceY[f^Wbki YWd eYYkh$ J^[ ZkhWb _dY_i_ed i^ekbZ X[Ybei[Zm_j^mWj[hj_]^jikjkh[i$?\j[di_ed^WiZ[l[bef[Z_dj^[ ZkhWbfbWd["j_iik[e\j^[]Wb[WWfed[khej_YWYWdX[ki[Z\ehik\# ÓY_[djYbeikh[$7fbWj[e\][b\eWc_ij^[dfbWY[Z[njhWZkhWbbo1dej[ j^Wjj^_i][b\eWcfbWj[i^ekbZdejYecfh[iij^[ikf[h_ehiW]_jjWb i_dki$7\j[hÓnWj_ede\j^[Xed[ÔWfWdZW\j[hÓdWbl[h_ÓYWj_ede\ ^[ceijWi_i"j^[f[h_eij[kc"ikXYkjWd[ekibWo[hWdZj^[ia_dWh[ Ybei[Z[WY^m_j^_dj[hhkfj[Zikjkh[i$:k[jej^[b_c_j[ZWffheWY^" WikYj_edZhW_d_idejd[Y[iiWho$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i Ceije\j^[Yecfb_YWj_ediW\j[h_djhWl[djh_YkbWhikh][hoWh[h[bWj[Z jej^[beYWj_edWdZdWjkh[e\j^[fh_cWhob[i_ed_ji[b\hWj^[hj^Wd jej^[ikh]_YWbWffheWY^$>em[l[h"iec[jof_YWbikh]_YWb[hhehiWdZ j^[_hYedi[gk[dY[ii^ekbZX[Z_iYkii[Z_dZ[jW_b$ ?dYehh[Yj fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d] m_j^ _dik\ÓY_[dj _djhWYhWd_Wb [nfeikh[$ ?d`kho je j^[IIIZkh_d]YhWd_ejeco"_diec[YWi[im_j^i[l[h[ Yedi[gk[dY[i$9ecfh[ii_ede\j^[IIIXo^[ceYb_ficWoYWki[ i_dkij^hecXei_iWdZikXi[gk[djl[deki_d\WhYj_ede\j^[\hed# jWbbeX[$ L[deki_d\WhYj_edcWoWbieeYYkhZk[jeeYYbki_ede\bWh][Xh_Z]# _d]l[_dihkdd_d]_djej^[III$ ;nY[ii_l[\hedjWbbeX[h[jhWYj_edW]W_dij]hWl_joZk[jefeehfei_# j_ed_d] e\ j^[ ^[WZ$ 7a_d[j_Y ckj_ic YWd Z[l[bef W\j[h hek]^ h[jhWYj_edW]W_dijXej^Y_d]kbWj[]oh_$ :[Yh[Wi[_difedjWd[ekiif[[Y^hWd]_d]\hecWc_bZibemd[ii je\hWdackj_icZk[je[nj[dZ[Zi[Yj_ed_d]e\j^[Wdj[h_ehfeh# j_ede\j^[YehfkiYWbbeikc$ 9edjki_ed e\ j^[ \ehd_n WffheWY^_d] j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ cWo h[ikbj _d j[cfehWho eh _d iec[ YWi[i f[hi_ij[dj Wcd[ij_Y iod# Zhec[i$ ?dWZ[gkWj[_djhWYhWd_Wb^[ceijWi_im_j^feijef[hWj_l[_djhWl[d# jh_YkbWhh[Xb[[Z_d]$J[cfehWho_di[hj_ede\Wl[djh_YkbWhZhW_dYWd X[h[Yecc[dZ[Z$
()-
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
?dYehh[Yjfei_j_ed_d]e\j^[^[WZZkh_d]ZkhWbYbeikh[m_j^i[l[h[ fd[kceY[f^WbkiW\j[hikh][ho$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ZkhWbYbeikh[m_j^feijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW$ ?dWZ[gkWj[fei_j_ed_d]WdZÓnWj_ede\j^[Xed[ÔWfm_j^Yec# fh[ii_ede\j^[IIIWdZikXi[gk[djl[deki_d\WhYj_ed$ Feeh^[ceijWi_iZkh_d]mekdZYbeikh[m_j^feijef[hWj_l[ie\j j_iik[^[cWjecW$
<_]$-$&$),
<_]$-$&$)-
J_fiWdZjh_Yai JWa[ j_c[ \eh fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d]$ J^[ h[mWhZ _i [nY[bb[dj _djhWYhWd_Wbl_ikWb_pWj_ede\j^[jWh][jWh[W$ 7Z[gkWj[ fei_j_ed_d] e\ j^[ ^[WZ h[ikbji _d W ]hWl_jo#ikffb[# c[dj[Z i[b\#h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWb beX[" Wle_Z_d] [nY[ii_l[ XhW_dh[jhWYj_ed<_]$-$&$),$ CWa[YWh[\kbWdWjec_YWbeh_[djWj_edWdZki[j^[j^h[[ij[fie\ fbWdd_d]j^[WffheWY^0'$eii[ekiijhkYjkh[i1($fbWY[c[dje\j^[ YhWd_ejeco1)$ia_d_dY_i_ed$ 9h[Wj_d] j^[ Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_ed" j^[ bWj[hWb XehZ[hi e\ j^[ III i^ekbZ X[ Y^[Ya[Z" Wle_Z_d] _d`kho Zkh_d] YhWd_ejeco <_]$ -$&$)-$
<_]$-$&$).
IjW][i e\ YhWd_ejeco <_]$ -$&$).0 '$ \hedjWb WdZ ($ fWh_[jWb Xkhh ^eb[jh[f^_dWj_edim_j^[\\[Yj_l[Yedjhebe\j^[III1)$_fi_bWj[hWb WdZ *$ YedjhWbWj[hWb Ykjj_d] \hec j^[ Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_edi m_j^W^_]^#if[[ZYhWd_ejec[$ 7dej^[hlWh_Wj_edWbbem_d]iW\[[nfeikh[e\j^[IIIYehh[ifedZi je\ekhXkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_ediedXej^i_Z[ie\j^[i_dki$8oj^_i j[Y^d_gk[" j^[ ]heel[ e\ j^[ III _i [nfbeh[Z bWj[hWbbo m_j^ekj ZWd][he\i_dkie_ZWbXb[[Z_d]Zkh_d]j^[jh[f^_dWj_edi$ :k[ je h[celWb e\ j^[ _dd[h [Z][ e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco Wdj[h_ehbo WdZ feij[h_ehbo" j^[ Wd]b[ \eh _djhWYhWd_Wb l_ikWb_pWj_ed i_]d_Ó# YWdjbo_dYh[Wi[i<_]$-$&$)/$
().
<_]$-$&$)/
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
<_]$-$&$*&
<_]$-$&$*'
J^[ZkhWi^ekbZX[ef[d[Z_dWÇ9Èi^Wf[Z"i[c_Y_hYkbWh\Wi^_ed m_j^j^[XWi[e\j^[ZkhWbÔWfjemWhZj^[c_Zb_d[$Fh[i[hlWj_ed e\Xh_Z]_d]l[_di_i[ii[dj_WbjeWle_ZY[h[XhWbl[deki_d\WhYj_ed$ ?\WbWh][Xh_Z]_d]l[_d_ifh[i[dj" j^[l[_di^ekbZX[Z_ii[Yj[Z \hecj^[WhWY^de_Z[We\j^[Y[h[XhWbikh\WY[WdZ\hecj^[ZkhWb ikh\WY[e\j^[\WbnY[h[Xh_$?\feii_Xb["j^[l[_di^ekbZX[YWh[\kbbo fhej[Yj[Zm_j^Wif[Y_WbZkhWbef[d_d]<_]$-$&$*&$ L[djh_YkbWhb[i_edibeYWj[Zc[Z_Wbbom_j^_dj^[l[djh_YkbWhY^Wc# X[hi^ekbZX[[nfei[Zl_W_fi_bWj[hWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ <_]$-$&$*'$ B[i_edibeYWj[Z_dj^[bWj[hWbfWhje\j^[bWj[hWbl[djh_Yb[YWdX[ [\\[Yj_l[bo[nfei[Zl_WWYedjhWbWj[hWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ <_]$-$&$*($
<_]$-$&$*(
:kh_d] mekdZ Ybeikh[" j^[ ZkhW i^ekbZ X[ Ybei[Z m_j^ mWj[h# j_]^jikjkh[i$?\d[Y[iiWho"j_iik[e\j^[]Wb[WWfed[khej_YWYWd X[ki[Z\ehj^_ifkhfei[<_]$-$&$*)$ J^[Xed[ÔWfi^ekbZX[Ón[Zm_j^ekjYecfh[ii_ede\ j^[III Wle_Z_d]i_dkie_ZWbj^hecXei_i<_]$-$&$**$ J^[ia_d_dY_i_edm_j^_dj^[^W_h[ZWh[WYWdX[Ybei[Zm_j^_dj[h# hkfj[Zehhkdd_d]ikjkh[i$
<_]$-$&$*)
:k[jej^[b_c_j[Zia_d_dY_i_ed"WikYj_edZhW_d_idejh[gk_h[Z$
<_]$-$&$**
()/
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r Wdj[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
-$' J^[Wdj[h_eh\hedjWbikXYWbbeiWblWh_Wj_ed e\j^[_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ J^[Wdj[h_eh_d\[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^_ied[e\j^[ceij \h[gk[djboki[Zj[Y^d_gk[i\ehb[i_edie\j^[Wdj[h_ehYhWd_Wb\eiiW$ Ki_d]j^[_dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y[nfeikh["[nj[dZ[Zb[i_edie\j^[\hed# jWb iakbb XWi[ WdZ Wdj[h_eh fbWd[ e\ j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh h[]_ed YWd X[ [\\[Yj_l[boWffheWY^[Z<_]$-$'$'$
<_]$ -$'$' IY^[cWj_Y ZhWm_d] e\ j^[ ikfhWi[bbWh fohWc_Z WffheWY^_d]\hecWdWdj[h_ehZ_h[Yj_ed$J^[ijhkYjkh[ie\ j^[ Y^_Wic" j^[ efj_Y d[hl[i" j^[ f_jk_jWho ijWba WdZ j^[ bWc_dW j[hc_dWb_iYWdX[m[bb[nfei[Z$J^[YWhej_ZX_\kh# YWj_edi"j^[Wdj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d]Whj[hoWdZj^[fhen_# cWbi[]c[djie\j^[Wdj[h_ehY[h[XhWbWhj[h_[iWh[Wbie_d Z_h[Yjh[bWj_edi^_fjej^_iWdj[h_ehikfhWi[bbWhfbWd[$
<_]$-$'$( J^[_dZ_l_ZkWb\ehce\j^[YehfkiYWbbeikcWdZ j^[ beYWb_pWj_ed e\ j^[ jWh][j Wh[W Z[Y_Z[ j^[ fbWY[c[dj e\ j^[ c_Zb_d[ YhWd_ejeco$ 7\j[h fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d]" j^[ cWn_ckc ^[_]^j e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco i^ekbZ X[ c[W# ikh[Z\hecj^[dWi_edXoCH_dl[ij_]Wj_edi_dj^[iW]_jjWb fbWd[$
J^[ [nWYj fbWY[c[dj e\ j^[ c_Zb_d[ YhWd_ejeco Z[f[dZi ed j^[ fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d]" jWa_d] _dje Yedi_Z[hWj_ed j^[ _dZ_l_ZkWb fWj^e#WdWjeco"[if[Y_Wbboj^[h[bWj_edi^_fX[jm[[dj^[iakbbXWi[ WdZ j^[ Yehfki YWbbeikc" WdZ j^[ \ehc e\ j^[ ][dk WdZ heijhkc Yehfeh_i YWbbei_ <_]$-$'$($$ J^hek]^ W ikf[h_ehbo fbWY[Z Wdj[h_eh _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y YhWd_ejeco" j^[ \hedjWb iakbb XWi[ YWd X[ [\\[Y# j_l[boWffheWY^[Zh[ZWhhem"WdZj^hek]^Wc_Z#fei_j_ed[ZYhWd_e# jeco"j^[Wdj[h_ehfbWd[e\j^[ikfhWi[bbWhYWdX[[nfei[Zm_j^ekj i[l[h[h[jhWYj_ede\j^[\hedjWbbeX[]h[[dWhhem$7XWiWbbofbWY[Z WffheWY^Xbk[WhhemWbbemiefj_cWbWYY[iijej^[heijhkcYehfe# h_iYWbbei_WdZj^hek]^j^[bWc_dWj[hc_dWb_i_djej^[Wdj[h_ehj^_hZ l[djh_Yb[<_]$-$'$)$
<_]$ -$'$) J^hek]^ Z_\\[h[dj lWh_Wdji e\ j^[ Wdj[h_eh ikXYWbbeiWb _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^"j^[c[Z_WdiakbbXWi[ikf[h_ehlWh_Wdj"h[ZWhhem"j^[ikfhWi[bbWhWh[W c_Z#lWh_Wdj" ]h[[d Whhem WdZ j^[ Wdj[h_eh j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ _d\[h_eh lWh_Wdj" Xbk[ Whhem YWd X[ [\\[Yj_l[bo WffheWY^[Z m_j^ekj hek]^ h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWb eh j[cfehWbbeX[$
(*'
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r Wdj[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
Ikf[h_ehlWh_Wdj
C_Z#lWh_Wdj
?d\[h_ehlWh_Wdj
7dj[h_ehj^_hZe\j^[ ikf[h_ehiW]_jjWbi_dki 7dj[h_ehj^_hZe\j^[\WbnY[h[Xh_
7dj[h_ehikf[h_ehiW]_jjWbi_dki 7dj[h_ehj^_hZe\j^[\WbnY[h[Xh_
?d\[hec[Z_Wb\hedjWbbeX[ 7dj[h_ehj^_hZe\j^[\WbnY[h[Xh_ Heijhkce\j^[YehfkiYWbbeikc BWc_dWj[hc_dWb_i 7dj[h_ehj^_hZl[djh_Yb[ Efj_Yd[hl[iWdZY^_Wic ?97"7'"79e7"7("_dYb$f[h\ehWjehi
JWXb[-$'$' 7dWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[iWffheWY^[Zj^hek]^j^[Z_\\[h[djlWh_Wdjie\j^[Wdj[h_eh\hedjWb_d\[h_ehikXYWbbeiWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^$
J^[Z[Y_i_edWijem^[j^[hj^[YhWd_ejeco_ifbWY[Zb[\jfWhWc[Z_Wd ehh_]^jfWhWc[Z_Wd_icWZ[fh[ef[hWj_l[bom_j^WYWh[\kbWdWboi_i e\ j^[ Z_W]deij_Y _cW]_d] ZWjW$ 7YYehZ_d] je j^[ a[o^eb[ YedY[fj \ehYedjhWbWj[hWbWffheWY^[i<_]$-$'$*"Z[[f#i[Wj[Zb[i_edibeYWj[Z h_]^j e\ j^[ c_Zb_d[ Wh[ X[ij [nfei[Z j^hek]^ W b[\j fWhWc[Z_Wd _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^1_dYedjhWij"b[i_edi[nj[dZ_d]b[\je\j^[ c_Zb_d[Wh[X[ijWffheWY^[Zl_WWh_]^jfWhWc[Z_WdYhWd_ejeco$ ?dj^[\ebbem_d]"j^[ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[e\j^[Wdj[h_eh\hedjWbikX# YWbbeiWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^_iZ[iYh_X[Z_dZ[jW_b$
(*(
<_]$-$'$* 7YYehZ_d]jej^[YedY[fje\a[o^eb[WffheWY^[i" _di[b[Yj[ZYWi[iZ[[f#i[Wj[Zb[i_ediYWdX[X[ij[nfei[Z j^hek]^YedjhWbWj[hWbbof[h\ehc[ZYhWd_ejec_[i$
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r Wdj[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[ '$FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] M_j^j^[fWj_[dj_dj^[ikf_d[fei_j_ed"j^[^[WZ_iÓn[Z$?\ki[Z" j^[ i_d]b[ f_d e\ j^[ iakbb YbWcf i^ekbZ X[ fbWY[Z Wbbem_d] \h[[ Z_ii[Yj_edZkh_d]ikh][ho$ Ij[f' J^[^[WZe\j^[ef[hWj_d]jWXb[_i[b[lWj[ZWXel[j^[j^ehWn"\WY_b_# jWj_d] YhWd_Wb l[deki ZhW_dW][ WdZ Wle_Z_d] Yecfh[ii_ed e\ j^[ cW_dY[hl_YWbl[ii[biWdZj^[bWhodn<_]$-$'$+$
<_]$-$'$+
7
8 <_]$-$'$,
<_]$-$'$-
9 Ij[f( J^[h[W\j[h" j^[ ^[WZ _i h[jhe# eh Wdj[heÔ[Yj[Z <_]$-$'$,$ 8Wi_YWbbo" j^[ ceh[ _d\[h_ehbo j^[ YhWd_ejeco _i f[h\ehc[Z" j^[ ceh[ h[jhe# Ô[n_ed_id[[Z[ZjeWY^_[l[Wd[h]edec_Yikh]_YWbfei_j_ed$J^ki" b[i_edim_j^WYbei[fhen_c_jojej^[\hedjWbiakbbXWi["m^_Y^YWd X[[nfei[Zl_W j^[ikf[h_ehlWh_Wdje\ j^[ikXYWbbeiWb_dj[h^[c_# if^[h_YWffheWY^"h[gk_h[WceZ[hWj[Wdj[heÔ[n_ede\YW$'&7$<eh j^[c_Z#lWh_Wj_ede\j^[YhWd_ejeco[nfei_d]j^[i[bbWhWdZikfhW# i[bbWh Wh[W" W h[jheÔ[n_ed e\ YW$ '& je (& _i ik\ÓY_[dj 8$ IjhkY# jkh[i i_jkWj[Z ceh[ YhWd_Wbbo" \eh [nWcfb[" b[i_edi e\ j^[ bWc_dW j[hc_dWb_i"heijhkcYehfeh_iYWbbei_WdZWdj[h_ehj^_hZl[djh_Yb["YWd X[WffheWY^[Zj^hek]^j^[_d\[h_ehlWh_Wdje\j^[YhWd_ejeco9 m_j^Wh[jheÔ[n_ede\)&je*+$ Ij[f) J^[^[WZ_ihejWj[ZYW$'&jemWhZj^[i_Z[e\j^[YhWd_ejeco$J^_i cWd[klh[_dZkY[ij^[\hedjWbbeX[jeh[bWnWmWo\hecj^[\WbnY[h[# Xh_ Zk[ je ]hWl_jo$ J^ki" WYY[ii je Z[[f#i[Wj[Z ijhkYjkh[i YWd X[ \WY_b_jWj[Zm_j^c_d_ckch[jhWYj_ede\j^[XhW_d<_]$-$'$-$
<_]$-$'$.
Ij[f* <_dWbbo"j^[^[WZi^ekbZX[bWj[heÔ[Yj[ZYW$+jeWbbemWd[h]edec_Y WdZ[\ÓY_[djmeha_d]fei_j_ed\ehj^[ikh][ed<_]$-$'$.$
(*)
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r Wdj[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
($7dWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZeh_[djWj_ed <eh j^[Wffhefh_Wj[ia_d_dY_i_ed"j^[_cfehjWdjWdWjec_YWbbWdZ# cWhai e\ j^[ eii[eki iakbb" ikY^ Wi j^[ c_Zb_d[" YehedWho ikjkh[" ehX_jWb h_c" ikfhWehX_jWb \ehWc[d WdZ j^[ \hedjWb fWhWdWiWb i_dki i^ekbZ X[ fh[Y_i[bo Z[Ód[Z WdZ cWha[Z m_j^ W ij[h_b[ f[d <_]$-$'$/$ J^[XehZ[hie\j^[YhWd_ejecoWh[cWha[Z[nWYjbom_j^j^[YhWd_ej# ecokikWbboYheii_d]j^[c_Zb_d[WdZj^[Wdj[h_ehikf[h_ehiW]_jjWb i_dki$7ic[dj_ed[ZWXel["fbWY[c[dje\j^[YhWd_ejecoZ[f[dZi edj^[_dZ_l_ZkWbi^Wf[e\j^[YehfkiYWbbeikcWdZedj^[beYWb_pW# j_ede\j^[jWh][jWh[W$7\j[hZ[Ód_j_ede\j^[YhWd_ejeco"j^[efj_# ckcb_d[e\j^[ia_d_dY_i_ed_icWha[Z1j^_i^eh_pedjWbia_d_dY_i_ed _ikikWbbofbWY[ZWjj^[\hedjWb^W_hb_d[7$<ehXWbZ#^[WZ[ZfWj_[dji ehceh[XWiWbbofbWdd[ZYhWd_ejec_[i"Wmh_dab[e\j^[ia_dcWoX[ Y^ei[d\eh j^_ifkhfei["WY^_[l_d]Wfb[Wi_d]Yeic[j_Yh[ikbj8$ <ehj^[_d\[h_ehlWh_Wdje\j^[WffheWY^"\ehfWj_[djim_j^ekjWdo mh_dab[i_dj^[\hedjWbWh[W"Wd[nj[dZ[ZijWdZWhZX_YehedWhia_d _dY_i_ed YWd X[ f[h\ehc[Z 9$J^[ ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ ia_d i^ekbZ X[ Z_i_d\[Yj[ZYWh[\kbbo$
8
7
(**
<_]$ -$'$/ :[Ód_j_ed e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco WdZ ia_d _dY_i_ed WYYehZ_d]jej^[jWh][jh[]_ed"WdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZ _dZ_l_ZkWb f^oi_e]deco e\ j^[ fWj_[dj$ Ikf[h_eh lWh_Wdj m_j^b_c_j[Zia_d_dY_i_edX[^_dZj^[^W_hb_d[7$C_ZlWh_# Wdj ki_d] W mh_dab[ \eh j^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed 8$ ?d\[h_eh lWh_# Wdj1\ehfWj_[djim_j^ekjWdomh_dab[i_dj^[\eh[^[WZ"Wd [nj[dZ[ZX_YehedWhia_d_dY_i_edYWdX[f[h\ehc[Z9$
9
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r Wdj[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
)$9hWd_ejeco Ij[f' H_]^j i_Z[$ 7\j[h c_d_cWb eh [l[d WXi[dj ^W_h i^Wl_d]" j^[ ia_d _i Z_i_d\[Yj[Z ki_d] WbYe^eb iebkj_ed$J^[ia_dWdZj^[ikXYkjWd[ekij_iik[ Wh[ _dY_i[Z WdZ h[jhWYj[Z [nfei_d] j^[ ]Wb[W Wfed[khej_YWWdZj^[\hedjWbX[bboe\j^[eYY_f# _je\hedjWbckiYb[ <_]$-$'$'&$
<_]$-$'$'&
Ij[f( J^[]Wb[WWdZj^[f[h_eij[kcWh[_dY_i[Z_dW i[c_Y_hYkbWh \Wi^_ed WdZ Z_ii[Yj[Z Wi W Yec# cedÔWfm_j^j^[XWi[jemWhZdWiWb$J^_i]Wb[W ÔWf YWd X[ [\\[Yj_l[bo ki[Z \eh ZkhWb ]hW\j Wi m[bbWi\ehYbei_d]j^[\hedjWbfWhWdWiWbi_dki_\ d[Y[iiWho<_]$-$'$''$
<_]$-$'$''
Ij[f) 7\j[h X_bWj[hWb h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ ie\j j_iik[ bWo[hi"Wi_d]b[c_Zb_d[Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_ed_i Yh[Wj[ZfWh_[jWbboWjj^[feij[he#c[Z_WbYehd[h e\ j^[ fbWdd[Z YhWd_ejeco$ J^[ ZkhW cWj[h _i ceX_b_p[Zm_j^WXbkdjZ_ii[Yjeh1j^[Xkhh^eb[ _i [dbWh][Z ki_d] Ód[ A[hh_ied hed][khi ]k_Z# _d]j^[bWj[hWbXehZ[hie\j^[ikf[h_ehiW]_jjWb i_dki<_]$-$'$'($
<_]$-$'$'(
(*+
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r Wdj[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
<_]$-$'$')
Ij[f* 7 i[c_bkdWhbo i^Wf[Z b_d[ _i j^[d iWm[Z m_j^ j^[ ^_]^#if[[Z YhWd_ejec[ ed j^[ _fi_bWj[hWb i_Z[" \hec j^[ feij[h_ehbo fbWY[Z Xkhh ^eb[ je j^[Wdj[h_ehc_Z#b_d[$J^[h[W\j[h"Wi[YedZfWhW# c[Z_WdYhWd_ejecob_d[_iiWm[Zedj^[effe# i_j[i_Z["`kijbWj[hWbbo\hecj^[ikf[h_ehiW]_jjWb i_dki" j^ki Yh[Wj_d] W YhWd_ejeco m_j^ W Z_W# c[j[he\($&Å)$&Yc<_]$-$'$')$
<_]$-$'$'*
Ij[f+ 7\j[hh[celWbe\j^[Xed[ÔWf"j^[_dd[h[Z][ e\ j^[ jWXkbW _dj[hdW _i h[cel[Z ki_d] Ód[ fkdY^[i$ :k[ je YWh[\kb h[celWb e\ j^_i _dd[h Xed[ [Z][" j^[ Wd]b[ \eh _djhWYhWd_Wb l_ikWb_pW# j_edYWdX[i_]d_ÓYWdjbo_dYh[Wi[Z<_]$-$'$'*$
<_]$-$'$'+
Ij[f, J^[ ZkhW i^ekbZ X[ ef[d[Z _d W i[c_Y_hYkbWh \Wi^_edm_j^j^[XWi[e\j^[ZkhWbÔWfjemWhZi j^[ikf[h_ehiW]_jjWbi_dki$J^[\h[[ZkhWbÔWf _iÓn[Zm_j^jmeikjkh[i1ej^[hZkhWb[b[lWj_ed ikjkh[iWh[dejd[Y[iiWho<_]$-$'$'+$
(*,
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r Wdj[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
*$?djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ij[f' H_]^j i_Z[$ :_ii[Yj_ed f[h\ehc[Z ed W \h[i^ ^kcWd if[Y_c[d1 Whj[h_[i Wh[ fh[fWh[Z m_j^ h[Z"l[_dim_j^Xbk[Yebeh[ZbWj[niebkj_ed$7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ ZkhW cWj[h" j^[ ikf[h_eh \hedjWb ]ohki WdZ Xh_Z]_d] l[_di jemWhZ j^[ ikf[h_eh iW]_jjWbi_dkiWh[YWh[\kbbo[nfei[ZWdZ"m^[d# [l[hfeii_Xb["j^[Xh_Z]_d]l[_diWh[fh[i[hl[Z$ J^[d[njij[fi^ekbZX[j^[ik\ÓY_[djZhW_dW][ e\ 9I< Xo ef[d_d] j^[ ikXWhWY^de_Z Y_ij[hdi$ ?diec[YWi[i"jhWff_d]e\j^[bWj[hWbl[djh_Yb[ cWo X[ d[Y[iiWho$ J^[ \hedjWb beX[ _i ][djbo ceX_b_p[Z WdZ j^[ Wdj[h_eh _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y Óiikh[ WffheWY^[Z$ 9ehh[Yj fei_j_ed_d] e\ j^[ ^[WZe\\[hii_]d_ÓYWdjh[bWnWj_ede\j^[\hedjWb beX["m^_Y^j^[d"Zk[je]hWl_jo"m_bbi_daifed# jWd[ekiboWmWo\hecj^[\WbnY[h[Xh_$J^[h[\eh[ cW`eh h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWb beX[ _i kikWbbo dej h[gk_h[Z$ Dej[ j^[ c_Yhe\ehY[fi ][djbo h[jhWYj_d]j^[ikf[h_eh\hedjWb]ohki<_]$-$'$',$
Ij[f( J^[\hedjWbbeX[_ih[jhWYj[Zm_j^WXhW_difWj# kbW[nfei_d]j^[][dke\j^[YehfkiYWbbeikc$ Dej[j^[f[h_YWbbeiWbWdZYWbbeiecWh]_dWbWhj[h# _[i$ J^[ effei_j[ \hedjWb beX[ _i fhej[Yj[Z Xo j^[ \Wbn$ ?d j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWb _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y c_Zb_d[" j^[ Y_d]kbWj[Z ]ohki YWd X[ [nfei[Z <_]$-$'$'-$
\WbnY[h[Xh_ ikf[h_eh\hedjWb]ohki
<_]$-$'$',
b[\jY_d]kbWj[]ohki YehfkiYWbbeikc f[h_YWbbeiWbWhj[ho YWbbeiecWh]_dWbWhj[ho
<_]$-$'$'-
Ij[f) 7dj[h_eh je j^[ ][dk" j^[ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y Óiikh[ _i YWh[\kbbo ef[d[Z$ Dej[ j^[ 7) i[]# c[dji e\ Xej^ Wdj[h_eh Y[h[XhWb Whj[h_[i hkd# d_d]WhekdZj^[][dke\j^[YehfkiYWbbeikc <_]$-$'$'.$
7)i[]c[dj ][dkYehfeh_iYWbbei_
<_]$-$'$'.
(*-
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r Wdj[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f* J^[Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YÓiikh[_ief[d[Z m_j^XhW_difWjkbWi"eXi[hl_d]j^[XWi[e\j^[ Wdj[h_ehYhWd_Wb\eiiWj^hek]^j^[c_Zb_d[hekj[$ Dej[j^[7(i[]c[djie\j^[Wdj[h_ehY[h[XhWb Whj[h_[i$J^[efj_YY^_WicWdZj^[Z_Wf^hW]cW i[bbW[Wff[Wh_dj^[XWYa]hekdZ<_]$-$'$'/$
Z_Wf^hW]cWi[bbW[ Y^_Wic b[\j7( h_]^j7(
<_]$-$'$'/
Ij[f+ ;nfeikh[ e\ j^[ _fi_bWj[hWb ikfhWi[bbWh Wh[W j^hek]^ j^[ Wdj[h_eh _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y hekj[$ Dej[ j^[ h_]^j efj_Y d[hl[ WdZ jhWYj WdZ j^[ Z_l_i_ed e\ j^[ ?97 _dje j^[ 797 WdZ C97$ C[Z_Wb je j^[ Wdj[h_eh f[jheYb_de_Z \ebZ" j^[ 9D???Z_iWff[Whi_djej^[hee\e\j^[YWl[hdeki i_dki<_]$-$'$(&$
h_]^j9D?? 7FYB 9D??? ?97 C' 7'
<_]$-$'$(&
Ij[f, J^[ \Wbn Y[h[Xh_ WdZ j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWb \hedjWb beX[ Wh[ h[jhWYj[Z" WffheWY^_d] j^[ effei_j[ 9D ?? WdZ ?97$ Dej[ j^[ ef^j^Wbc_Y Whj[ho Z_iWff[Wh_d] kdZ[h j^[ \WbY_\ehc b_]Wc[dj <_]$-$'$('$
\WbY_\ehcb_]Wc[dj Ef^j7 b[\j9D??
<_]$-$'$('
(*.
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r Wdj[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f- EXi[hlWj_ed e\ j^[ efj_YWb Y^_Wic WdZ j^[ bWc_dW j[hc_dWb_i$ Dej[ j^[ ^ofefbWij_Y 79e7 WdZ j^[ beef e\ j^[ 7( i[]c[dji e\ j^[ 797 <_]$-$'$(($
Y^_Wic 79e7 bWc_dWj[hc_dWb_i
<_]$-$'$((
Ij[f. 7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ bWc_dW j[hc_dWb_i WdZ j^[ Ôeehe\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb["j^[h_]^jF'i[]c[dj WdZ j^[ XWi_bWh Wf[n Wh[ l_ikWb_p[Z m_j^_d j^[ _dj[hf[ZkdYkbWh\eiiW$Dej[j^[jmecWc_bbWho XeZ_[i<_]$-$'$()$ 87 cWc_bbWhoXeZ_[i
<_]$-$'$()
(*/
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r Wdj[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
+$:khW"Xed[WdZmekdZYbeikh[ 7\j[hYecfb[j_ede\j^[_djhWYhWd_WbfheY[Zkh["j^[_djhWZkhWbikX# WhWY^de_ZifWY[_iÓbb[Zm_j^Whj_ÓY_Wb9I<iebkj_edWjXeZo j[c# f[hWjkh[$J^[ZkhWb_dY_i_ed_iYbei[ZmWj[hj_]^jm_j^_dj[hhkfj[Z ehYedj_dkekiikjkh[i$:khWb[WaiYWdX[h[fW_h[ZXoki_d]W]Wb[W# f[h_eij[kc ]hW\j$ ?\ ef[d[Z" j^[ \hedjWb fWhWdWiWb i_dki i^ekbZ X[Ybei[Zm_j^j^[]Wb[WÔWfWic[dj_ed[Zfh[l_ekibo$7fbWj[e\ ][b\eWc_ifbWY[Z[njhWZkhWbboWdZj^[Xed[ÔWf_iÓn[Z$J^[Xkhh ^eb[i^ekbZX[Ybei[Zm_j^WbWh][#i_p[Zj_jWd_kcfbWj["Wbbem_d] Wfb[WiWdjYeic[j_YekjYec[W\j[h\hedjWbYhWd_ejeco$7\j[hÓdWb l[h_ÓYWj_ede\^[ceijWi_i"j^[f[h_eij[kcWdZj^[ikXYkjWd[eki bWo[hi"[WY^Wh[Ybei[Zm_j^ikjkh[iWdZj^[ia_dm_j^_djhWYkjWd[# ekiikjkh[iehWZ^[i_l[jWf[i$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i ?dik\ÓY_[djfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]e\j^[fWj_[dj m_j^ikXi[gk[dj_dik\ÓY_[dj[nfeikh[e\j^[ikh]_YWbÓ[bZWdZ i_]d_ÓYWdjZ[j[h_ehWj_ed_d[\ÓY_[dYoe\[nY_i_d]j^[b[i_ed$FbWd# d_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]_ij^[jWiae\j^[ikh][ed ?d`kho je j^[ ikf[h_eh iW]_jjWb i_dki eh \hedjWb Xh_Z]_d] l[_di Zkh_d]YhWd_ejeco$KikWbbo"eYYbki_ede\j^[Wdj[h_ehfWhje\j^[ ikf[h_eh iW]_jjWb i_dki Ze[i dej h[ikbj _d i[l[h[ d[khebe]_YWb ZWcW][1^em[l[h"_\feii_Xb["_ji^ekbZX[Wle_Z[Z$ ;nY[ii_l[\hedjWbbeX[h[jhWYj_edZk[jefeeh^[WZfei_j_ed_d]$ ?d`kh_[ijedkc[hekid[khelWiYkbWhijhkYjkh[ie\j^[_dj[h^[c_# if^[h_Y WdZ ikfhWi[bbWh h[]_ed Zkh_d] c_Yheikh]_YWb cWd_fkbW# j_edm_j^feijef[hWj_l[d[khebe]_YWbZ[ÓY_ji$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ZkhWbYbeikh[m_j^feijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW$ ?dWZ[gkWj[fei_j_ed_d]WdZÓnWj_ede\j^[Xed[ÔWfm_j^feeh Yeic[j_YekjYec[$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ _djhW# eh [njhWYhWd_Wb ^[ceijWi_i m_j^ ikXi[gk[dj h[Xb[[Z_d]$
(+&
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r Wdj[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
J_fiWdZjh_Yai
<_]$-$'$(*
JWa[j_c[\ehfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]e\fWj_[dji$ J^[ h[mWhZ _i Wd [nY[bb[dj el[hl_[m e\ j^[ jWh][j Wh[W WdZ Wd [\ÓY_[djmeha_d]fei_j_ed$ F[h\ehc_d] j^[ YhWd_ejeco" W i_d]b[ Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_ed i^ekbZX[f[h\ehc[Z_dj^[feij[hec[Z_WbYehd[he\j^[fbWdd[Z YhWd_ejeco$ 7\j[h ZkhWb Ybeikh[" j^[ Xkhh ^eb[ i^ekbZ X[ Ybei[Z m_j^WbWh][j_jWd_kcfbWj["fhel_Z_d]efj_cWbYeic[j_YekjYec[ _dj^[\hedjWbWh[W<_]$-$'$(*$
<_]$-$'$(+
9h[Wj_d] j^[ Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_ed" j^[ bWj[hWb XehZ[hi e\ j^[ ikf[h_ehiW]_jjWbi_dkii^ekbZX[Y^[Ya[Z"Wle_Z_d]_d`khoZkh_d] YhWd_ejeco<_]$-$'$(+$ IjW][ie\YhWd_ejeco<_]$-$'$(,0'$feij[h_ehXkhh^eb[jh[f^_dW# j_edm_j^ced_jeh_d]e\j^[ikf[h_ehiW]_jjWbi_dki1($_fi_bWj[hWb WdZ )$ YedjhWbWj[hWb Ykjj_d] \hec feij[h_eh je Wdj[h_eh ki_d] W ^_]^#if[[ZYhWd_ejec[$
<_]$-$'$(,
H[celWbe\j^[Wdj[h_ehWdZfeij[h_eh_dd[h[Z][ie\j^[YhWd_e# jecofhel_Z[i_dYh[Wi[Z_djhWYhWd_Wbl_ikWb_pWj_ed<_]$-$'$(-$ <_]$-$'$(-
7Z[gkWj[ fei_j_ed_d] e\ j^[ ^[WZ h[ikbji _d ]hWl_jo#ikffb[# c[dj[Z i[b\#h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWb beX[" Wle_Z_d] [nY[ii_l[ XhW_dh[jhWYj_ed<_]$-$'$(.$ :kh_d] mekdZ Ybeikh[" j^[ Xed[ ÔWf i^ekbZ X[ Ón[Z _d\[h_ehbo m_j^ekjXedoZ[^_iY[dY[\ehWX[jj[hYeic[j_YekjYec[$ IkYj_edZhW_d_idejh[gk_h[Z$
<_]$-$'$(.
(+'
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
-$( J^[feij[h_eheYY_f_jWbikXYWbbeiWb ceZ_ÓYWj_ede\j^[_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^
7
Ki_d]j^[feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^"j^[feij[h_ehfWhje\ j^[j[djeh_Wb_dY_ikhWYWdX[[nfei[Zl_WWikfhWj[djeh_Wbhekj[$J^_i feij[h_eh _dY_ikhWb ifWY[ _i beYWj[Z feij[h_eh je j^[ c_ZXhW_d WdZ Yehh[ifedZijej^[h[]_ede\j^[gkWZh_][c_dWbY_ij[hd$?dj^_imWo" j^[ifb[d_kce\j^[YehfkiYWbbeikc"f_d[Wb]bWdZ"c[i[dY[f^Wb_Y j[Yjkc" kff[h fWhj e\ j^[ l[hc_i WdZ j^[ Yecfb[n d[khelWiYkbWh h[bWj_edi^_fe\j^[gkWZh_][c_dWbY_ij[hdYWdX[m[bbeXi[hl[Z$If[# Y_WbWjj[dj_edi^ekbZX[]_l[djej^[l[dekiYedjh_Xkjehie\j^[l[_d e\=Wb[d"j^[l[ii[bie\j^[feij[h_ehY[h[XhWbWdZikf[h_ehY[h[X[b# bWhWhj[h_[i"WdZjej^[jheY^b[Whd[hl[$ B[i_edim_j^_dj^[feij[h_eh_dY_ikhWbifWY[YWdWbieX[WffheWY^[Z l_W j^[ _d\hWj[djeh_Wb ikfhWY[h[X[bbWh hekj[" Z[iYh_X[Z _d Y^Wfj[h ,$&$ J^[ ikfhWj[djeh_Wb ikXYWbbeiWb _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^ _i Z[iYh_X[Z^[h["fh[\[hh[Z\ehb[i_ediY[dj[h[ZWjj^[j[djeh_Wb[Z][" [if[Y_Wbbo_\j^[oWh[i_jkWj[ZWXel[j^[l[_de\=Wb[d<_]$-$($'$
8
<_]$-$($' J^[feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^YWdX[ h[Yecc[dZ[Z \eh b[i_edi i_jkWj[Z WXel[ j^[ ]h[Wj Y[h[# XhWbl[_de\=Wb[d7$B[i_edii_jkWj[ZX[d[Wj^j^[Z[[f l[dekiioij[cWh[h[WY^[ZX[ijj^hek]^j^[_d\hWj[djeh_Wb ikfhWY[h[X[bbWhWffheWY^8$
Ki_d] j^[ feij[h_eh ikXYWbbeiWb WffheWY^ m_j^ Wd WZZ_j_edWb ifb_j# j_d]e\j^[j[djeh_kc`kijfWhWbb[bjej^[ijhW_]^ji_dki"j^[ikfhW# j[djeh_WbWffheWY^cWoWbiefhel_Z[[nY[bb[djWYY[iijej^[feij[# h_eh \eiiW \eh b[i_edi _dlebl_d] j^[ Y[h[X[bbec[i[dY[f^Wb_Y Óiikh[ WdZj^[feij[h_ehfWhje\j^[WcX_[djY_ij[hd$ 7YYehZ_d] je j^[ a[o^eb[ YedY[fj" YedjhWbWj[hWb WffheWY^[i YWd X[ ki[Z _d i[l[hWb YWi[i Wbbem_d] c_d_cWb h[jhWYj_ed WdZ efj_cWb [nfeikh[<_]$-$($( ?dj^[\ebbem_d]"j^[ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[e\j^[feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_# if^[h_YWffheWY^_iZ[iYh_X[Z_dZ[jW_b$
<_]$-$($( 9edjhWbWj[hWb[nfeikh[e\Wc_Zb_d[b[i_edki_d]j^[YedY[fje\a[o^eb[ d[kheikh][ho$Dej[fbWY[c[dje\YhWd_ejecoWdZWffheWY^_d]W\j[h\[d[ijhWj_ede\ j^[feij[h_ehfWhje\j^[\WbnY[h[Xh_$
(+)
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
IkfhWj[djeh_Wb
?d\hWj[djeh_Wb
Feij[h_ehfWhje\j^[III Feij[h_ehfWhje\j^[\Wbn IjhW_]^ji_dki"j[djeh_kc C[Z_Wbikh\WY[e\j^[eYY_f_jWbbeX[ Ifb[d_kce\j^[YehfkiYWbbeikc Feij[h_ehfWhje\j^[?II Feij[h_ehf[h_YWbbeiWbWhj[ho :_ijWbi[]c[djie\j^[F97 L[_de\=Wb[d
Ifb[d_kce\j^[YehfkiYWbbeikc L[_de\=Wb[d 8WiWbl[_de\Hei[dj^Wb ?dj[hdWbY[h[XhWbl[_d 9[djhWbl[_de\j^[Y[h[X[bbkc F_d[Wb]bWdZ 9_ij[hdWl[b__dj[hfei_j__ GkWZh_][c_dWbfbWj[ Kff[hl[hc_i 9D?L :_ijWbi[]c[djie\j^[F97WdZI97
JWXb[-$($' 7dWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[i[nfei[ZXoj^[feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^$
(+*
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[
<_]$-$($)
'$FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] Ki_d] j^[ feij[h_eh _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^" jme Z_\\[h[dj fWj_[djfei_j_ediWh[feii_Xb[$J^[i[c_i_jj_d]fei_j_edm_j^\ehY[Z [b[lWj_edWdZWdj[heÔ[n_ede\j^[^[WZe\\[hiWdefj_cWbl[deki ZhW_dW][m_j^_dj^[gkWZh_][c_dWbh[]_ed1^em[l[h"j^_ifei_j_ed YWhh_[iWh_iae\W_h[cXeb_icWdZh[gk_h[iWdkdYec\ehjWXb[meha# _d]fei_j_ed\ehj^[ikh][ed$J^[i_cfb[fhed[fei_j_edWbbemiWd [\ÓY_[djmeha_d]fei_j_edZkh_d]ikh][hom_j^ekjj^[ZWd][he\W_h [cXeb_ic$J^[[b[lWj[Zfh[iikh[_dj^[Z[[fY[h[XhWbl[_di"WYYehZ# _d] je j^[ fhed[ fei_j_ed" YWd X[ [\\[Yj_l[bo _cfhel[Z Xo W ik\Ó# Y_[dj[b[lWj_edWdZh[jheÔ[n_ede\j^[^[WZ$J^[fWj_[dj_ifbWY[Z _dWd[kjhWbfhed[fei_j_ededj^[ef[hWj_d]jWXb[$J^[^[WZe\j^[ fWj_[dj_iÓn[Z_dWj^h[[#f_dCWoÓ[bZ^ebZ[hiej^Wjj^[iW]_jjWb ikjkh[_i_dWd[Whl[hj_YWbfei_j_ed$
<_]$-$($*W
Ij[f' J^[ XeZo WdZ j^[ ^[WZ Wh[ [b[lWj[Z je WXekj '+ Xo cel_d] j^[ ef[hWj_d]jWXb[$J^_i[b[lWj_ed_id[Y[iiWhojeXh_d]j^[^[WZWXel[ j^[b[l[be\j^[j^ehWn\ehX[jj[hl[dekiZhW_dW][<_]$-$($)$
<_]$-$($*X
<_]$-$($*Y
Ij[f( J^[h[W\j[h" j^[ ^[WZ cWo X[ Wdj[he# eh h[jheÔ[Yj[Z je YW$ *+ _d ehZ[h je Xh_d] j^[ j[djeh_kc _dje W ceh[ ^eh_pedjWb fbWd[$ J^[ [nWYjZ[]h[[e\Ô[n_edZ[f[dZiedj^[\ehce\j^[ijhW_]^ji_dki WdZj^[^[_]^je\j^[fbWdd[ZYhWd_ejeco<_]$-$($*W"X"Y$?\j^[ ijhW_]^j i_dki _i ceh[ f[hf[dZ_YkbWh" j^[ h[jheÔ[n_ed i^ekbZ dej X[fWhj_YkbWhbo[nY[ii_l[WdZj^[YhWd_ejecoYWdX[fbWY[Zd[Whje j^[[nj[hdWbeYY_f_jWbfhejkX[hWdY[$ Ij[f) Ki_d]Wib_]^jhejWj_ede\YW$'&"j^[eYY_f_jWbbeX[i_daiWmWo\hec j^[ \Wbn Y[h[Xh_ Zk[ je W ]hWl_jo#h[bWj[Z i[b\#h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ _fi_# bWj[hWbY[h[XhWb^[c_if^[h[$J^ki"WYY[iijeZ[[f#i[Wj[ZijhkYjkh[i YWdX[eXjW_d[Zm_j^Wc_d_ckce\XhW_dh[jhWYj_ed<_]$-$($+$
<_]$-$($+
(++
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
($7dWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZeh_[djWj_ed 8[\eh[f[h\ehc_d]j^[ia_d_dY_i_ed"j^[eii[ekiWdWjec_YWbbWdZ# cWhaie\j^[eYY_f_jWbh[]_edikY^Wij^[c_Zb_d["bWcXZe_Zikjkh[" WdZ[nj[hdWbeYY_f_jWbfhejkX[hWdY[i^ekbZX[beYWb_p[Z<_]$-$($,$ J^[[nWYji_j[e\j^[b_c_j[ZYhWd_ejecoZ[f[dZiedj^[_dZ_l_ZkWb \ehce\j^[j[djeh_kcWdZj^[ijhW_]^ji_dkiWdZedj^[_dZ_l_ZkWb fWj^eWdWjec_YWbi_jkWj_ed$7ic[dj_ed[ZWXel["j^[ceh[f[hf[d# Z_YkbWhj^[\ehce\j^[ijhW_]^ji_dki"j^[d[Wh[hj^[YhWd_ejeco_i fbWY[Zjej^[[nj[hdWbeYY_f_jWbfhejkX[hWdY[$ J^[i_Z[e\j^[YhWd_ejecocWoX[fh[\[hh[ZWYYehZ_d]jej^[Yed# Y[fje\a[o^eb[WffheWY^[i$:[[f#i[Wj[Zb[i_edibeYWj[Zh_]^je\ j^[ c_Zb_d[ YWd X[ m[bb [nfei[Z ki_d] W b[\j fWhWc[Z_Wd _dj[h# ^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^1 Yedl[hi[bo" b[i_edi [nj[dZ_d] b[\j e\ j^[ c_Zb_d[Wh[_diec[YWi[iX[jj[hWffheWY^[Zl_WWh_]^jfWhWc[# Z_WdYhWd_ejeco$>em[l[h"dej[j^WjWYedjhWbWj[hWb[nfeikh[YWd X[fWhj_YkbWhbom[bb^_ZZ[dXoj^[\WbnY[h[Xh_WdZXoj^[l[deki Yecfb[ne\j^[]h[WjY[h[XhWbl[_de\=Wb[d$ 7\j[h WdWjec_YWb eh_[djWj_ed WdZ fbWdd_d] e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco" j^[_dZ_l_ZkWbefj_ckcb_d[e\ j^[f[hf[dZ_YkbWhia_d_dY_i_ed_i cWha[Z$J^[_dY_i_ed_ifbWY[ZYW$'$+Yc\hecj^[c_Zb_d[m_j^W b[d]j^e\YW$+$&Yc<_]$-$($,$Dej[YWh[\kbbia_d_dY_i_ed$
<_]$ -$($, :[Ód_j_ed e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco WdZ ia_d _dY_i_ed WYYehZ_d]jej^[WdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhai$
(+,
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
)$9hWd_ejeco Ij[f' B[\j i_Z[" fhed[ fei_j_ed$ 7\j[h c_d_cWb i^Wl# _d]e\j^[^W_h"j^[ia_dWdZj^[ikXYkjWd[eki j_iik[ Wh[ _dY_i[Z _d W ijhW_]^j f[hf[dZ_YkbWh \Wi^_edWdZj^[ia_dÔWfiWh[h[jhWYj[Z[nfei# _d] j^[ eYY_f_jWb X[bbo e\ j^[ eYY_f_je\hedjWb ckiYb[ <_]$-$($-$
<_]$-$($-
Ij[f( J^[ eYY_f_jWb ckiYb[ WdZ j^[ ]Wb[W Wfed[khe# j_YW Wh[ _dY_i[Z _d W i[c_Y_hYkbWh \Wi^_ed WdZ Z_ii[Yj[Z je][j^[h m_j^ j^[ f[h_eij[kc \hec j^[Xedoikh\WY[$J^_ibWo[h_ij^[dh[jhWYj[ZWi WÔWfm_j^j^[XWi[jej^[c_Zb_d[<_]$-$($.$
<_]$-$($.
Ij[f) ?d Wbb YWi[i" Wd eij[efbWij_Y YhWd_ejeco _i YWh# h_[Z ekj YWh[\kbbo Y^[Ya_d] j^[ ikf[h_eh iW]_j# jWbi_dkiWdZjehYkbWh^[hef^_b_$I_c_bWhjeej^[h _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^[i"m[_di_ijedf[h# \ehc_d] jme c_Zb_d[ Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_edi" ced_jeh_d]j^[fhec_d[djfeij[h_ehfWhje\j^[ iW]_jjWbi_dki<_]$-$($/$
<_]$-$($/
(+-
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
<_]$-$($'&
Ij[f* 7\j[h l_ikWb_pWj_ed e\ j^[ ZkhWb ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ ikf[h_eh iW]_jjWb i_dki" j^[ ZkhW cWj[h i^ekbZ X[YWh[\kbbo\h[[Zki_d]XbkdjZ_ii[Yjehi$M_j^ Ód[ A[hh_ied hed][khi" j^[ bWj[hWb XehZ[hi e\ j^[ i_dki Wh[ [nfei[Z m_j^ekj ZWcW]_d] j^[ i_dki<_]$-$($'&$
<_]$-$($''
Ij[f+ M_j^ W ^_]^#if[[Z YhWd_ejec[" W Ykhl[Z b_d[ _i iWm[Z \hec j^[ eYY_f_jWb Xkhh ^eb[ ed j^[ _fi_bWj[hWbi_Z[$J^_i_fi_bWj[hWbYkj_ij^[dYec# fb[j[Z\hecj^[fWh_[jWbXkhh^eb[<_]$-$($''$
<_]$-$($'(
Ij[f, J^[h[W\j[h"j^[YhWd_ejec[_iki[Zedj^[effe# i_j[ i_Z[ _d W i_c_bWh mWo" Yh[Wj_d] W fWhWc[# Z_Wd YhWd_ejeco e\ ($& je )$& Yc _d Z_Wc[j[h <_]$-$($'($
(+.
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f- 7d _cfehjWdj ij[f e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco _i j^[ h[celWb e\ j^[ jWXkbW _dj[hdW ki_d] Ód[ fkdY^[i<_]$-$($')$
<_]$-$($')
Ij[f. 7\j[h f[h\ehc_d] j^[ YhWd_ejeco" j^[ ZkhW _i ef[d[Z_dWi[c_Y_hYkbWh\Wi^_edm_j^j^[XWi[ e\ j^[ ZkhWb ÔWf jemWhZ j^[ ikf[h_eh iW]_j# jWbi_dki$J^[\h[[ZkhWbÔWf_iÓn[Zm_j^jme ikjkh[i m_j^ekj j^[ d[[Z \eh ej^[h [b[lWj_ed ikjkh[i<_]$-$($'*$
<_]$-$($'*
Ij[f/ 8o YedjhWbWj[hWb WffheWY^[i" j^[ \Wbn Y[h[Xh_ YWd X[ ef[d[Z [nfei_d] j^[ effei_j[ fWh_[je# eYY_f_jWbWh[Wi<_]$-$($'+$
<_]$-$($'+
(+/
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
eYY_f_jWbbeX[
<_]$-$($',
*$?djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ij[f' B[\j i_Z[$ :_ii[Yj_ed ki_d] W \h[i^ ^kcWd YWZWl[h$ 7hj[h_Wb WdZ l[deki l[ii[bi Wh[ fh[# fWh[Zm_j^h[ZWdZXbk[Yebeh[ZbWj[niebkj_ed h[if[Yj_l[bo$7\j[hZkhejeco"j^[eYY_f_jWbbeX[ _i YWh[\kbbo cel[Z WmWo \hec j^[ \Wbn m_j^ c_Yhe\ehY[fi$ 9ecfWh[Z m_j^ j^[ \hedjWb WdZ fWh_[jWb Wh[W" eYYkhh[dY[ e\ fhec_d[dj Xh_Z]# _d]l[_di_dj^[eYY_f_jWbh[]_ed_ikdYecced" WdZ" _\ fh[i[dj" j^[o hkd i[l[hWb c_bb_c[j[hi Wbed] j^[ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y Óiikh[" cWa_d] Wd WhWY^de_ZWb Z_ii[Yj_ed WdZ cel[c[dj [Wi_[h$ M_j^WZ[gkWj[fei_j_ed_d]e\j^[fWj_[dj"j^[ ifWjkbWfh[iikh[YWdX[ik\ÓY_[djboc_d_c_p[Z" Z_YjWj[ZXoj^[]hWl_jo#[d^WdY[Zh[bWnWj_ede\ j^[eYY_f_jWbbeX[<_]$-$($',$
Ij[f( 7ikikWb"Wd_cfehjWdjij[fe\j^[_djhWYhWd_Wb Z_ii[Yj_ed _i j^[ ik\ÓY_[dj ZhW_dW][ e\ 9I< Xo ef[d_d]j^[ikXWhWY^de_ZY_ij[hdi$?dj^[YWi[ e\[b[lWj[Z_djhWYhWd_Wbfh[iikh["j^[feij[h_eh ^ehde\j^[bWj[hWbl[djh_Yb[YWdX[fkdYjkh[Z m_j^Wl[djh_YkbWhYWddkbW$Dej[j^[h[jhWYj[Z eYY_f_jWbbeX[<_]$-$($'-$
\Wbn
<_]$-$($'-
Ij[f) M_j^ WZZ_j_edWb h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ eYY_f_jWb beX[" j^[ jhWdi_j_ed X[jm[[d j^[ feij[h_eh WcX_[dj WdZ gkWZh_][c_dWb Y_ij[hdi YWd X[ WffheWY^[Z$ Dej[ j^[ l[_di hkdd_d] je j^[ ]h[Wj Y[h[XhWb l[_d e\ =Wb[d" m^_Y^ _i" Wj j^_i ijW][e\j^[ikh][ho"^_ZZ[dX[^_dZj^[][djbo h[jhWYj[Zj[djeh_kc$Dej[j^[ifb[d_kce\j^[ YehfkiYWbbeikc<_]$-$($'.$
ifb[d_kc
<_]$-$($'.
(,&
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f* J^[WhWY^de_Zi^[[jie\j^[gkWZh_][c_dWbY_i# j[hd Wh[ ef[d[Z [nfei_d] j^[ gkWZh_][c_dWb fbWj[ WdZ j^[ f_d[Wb ]bWdZ$ Dej[ j^[ ZekXb[Z XWiWbl[_de\Hei[dj^WbZ_iWff[Wh_d]m_j^_dj^[ WcX_[djY_ij[hd$J^[m^_j[j_iik[Yehh[ifedZi jej^[_d\[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[ifb[d_kcYehfeh_i YWbbei_<_]$-$($'/$
c[i[dY[f^Wbed f_d[Wb]bWdZ XWiWbl[_die\Hei[dj^Wb ifb[d_kc
<_]$-$($'/
Ij[f+ J^[jhWdi_j_edX[jm[[dj^[\WbnWdZj[djeh_kc _ih[jhWYj[Zm_j^WikYa[hWbbem_d]X[jj[h[nfe# ikh[e\j^[f_d[Wb]bWdZWdZj^[gkWZh_][c_dWb fbWj[<_]$-$($(&$
gkWZh_][c_dWbfbWj[ f_d[Wb]bWdZ
<_]$-$($(&
Ij[f, Ef[d j^[ j[djeh_kc fWhWbb[b je j^[ Yekhi[ e\ j^[ijhW_]^ji_dkiki_d]Wi^Whfc_Yhead_\[$J^[ j[djeh_Wb ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ Y[h[X[bbkc Wff[Whi j^hek]^j^[]Wf<_]$-$($('$
j[djeh_kc
<_]$-$($('
(,'
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f- 7\j[hifb_jj_d]j^[j[djeh_kc"j^[YedÔk[dY[e\ j^[]h[Wjl[_de\=Wb[d_djej^[ijhW_]^ji_dki YWdX[[nfei[Z$Dej[j^[l[dekiXhWdY^[ie\ j^[XWiWbl[_de\Hei[dj^Wb"j^[_dj[hdWbY[h[XhWb l[_dWdZj^[Y[djhWbY[h[X[bbWhl[_d<_]$-$($(($
_dj[hdWbY[h[XhWbl[_d Y[djhWbY[h[X[bbWhl[_d l[_de\Hei[dj^Wb ifb[d_kc
<_]$-$($((
Ij[f. J^[ j[djeh_kc _i hW_i[Z m_j^ ^ebZ_d] ikjkh[i WdZ j^[ Y[h[X[bbkc _i ][djbo h[jhWYj[Z m_j^ W ikYa[h WdZ W Z_ii[Yjeh$ Dej[ j^[ _dj[hdWb Y[h[# XhWbl[_dWdZj^[f_d[Wb]bWdZ<_]$-$($()$
gkWZh_][c_dWbfbWj[ _dj[hdWbY[h[XhWbl[_d f_d[Wb]bWdZ l[_de\=Wb[d
<_]$-$($()
Ij[f/ <ebbem_d]j^[_dj[hdWbY[h[XhWbl[_d"ijhkYjkh[i e\ j^[ l[bkc _dj[hfei_jkc YWd X[ [nfei[Z <_]$-$($(*$ l[bkc_dj[hfei_jkc _dj[hdWbY[h[XhWbl[_d
<_]$-$($(*
(,(
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
Ij[f'& :_ii[Yj_ed e\ j^[ l[bkc _dj[hfei_jkc WYYehZ# _d]jej^[feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^$ Dej[ j^[ c[Z_Wb ikh\WY[ e\ j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWb j^WbWckiWYYehZ_d]jej^[ef[d_d]e\j^[fei# j[h_ehj^_hZl[djh_Yb[<_]$-$($(+$
effei_j[j^WbWcki Y^ehe_Zfb[nkie\j^[j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ _dj[hdWbY[h[XhWbl[_d
<_]$-$($(+
Ij[f'' :_ii[Yj_d]_dWbWj[hWbZ_h[Yj_ed"j^[jhWdi_j_ed e\ j^[ gkWZh_][c_dWb WdZ WcX_[dj Y_ij[hdi _i WffheWY^[Z$ Dej[ j^[ Ód[ lWiYkbWjkh[ e\ j^[ feij[hebWj[hWb c[i[dY[f^Wbed" j^[ XhWY^_kc Yebb_Ykb_ _d\[h_eh_i WdZ j^[ jh_]edkc b[cd_iY_ <_]$-$($(,$
jh_]edkcb[cd_iY_
<_]$-$($(,
Ij[f'( J^[jh_]edkcb[cd_iY_e\j^[c_ZXhW_dm_j^j^[ I97WdZj^[9D?L<_]$-$($(-$ I97 9D?L
<_]$-$($(-
(,)
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
+$:khW"Xed[WdZmekdZYbeikh[ 7\j[hYecfb[j_ede\j^[_djhWYhWd_WbfheY[Zkh["j^[_djhWZkhWbifWY[ _i Óbb[Z m_j^ Whj[ÓY_Wb 9I< WdZ j^[ ZkhWb ef[d_d] _i Ybei[Z m_j^ _dj[hhkfj[ZehYedj_dkekiikjkh[i$:khWb[WaiYWdX[h[fW_h[ZXo ki_d]W]Wb[W#f[h_eij[kc]hW\j$7fbWj[e\][b\eWc_ifbWY[Z[njhW# ZkhWbboWdZj^[Xed[ÔWf_iÓn[Zm_j^j_jWd_kcfbWj[i$7\j[hÓdWb l[h_ÓYWj_ed e\ ^[ceijWi_i" j^[ f[h_eij[kc" ikXYkjWd[eki bWo[h WdZj^[ia_dWh[Ybei[Zm_j^_dj[hhkfj[Zikjkh[i$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i ?dYehh[Yj fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d] m_j^ _dik\ÓY_[dj _djhWYhWd_Wb [nfeikh[$ ?d`khojej^[ikf[h_ehiW]_jjWbi_dkiehjehYkbWh^[hef^_b_Zkh_d] YhWd_ejeco" _d iec[ YWi[i m_j^ i[l[h[ Xb[[Z_d] WdZ \WjWb Yed# i[gk[dY[i$Dej[j^[]Wb[W#f[h_eijÔWf\ehh[fW_h$ ;nY[ii_l[Yecfh[ii_ede\j^[ikf[h_ehiW]_jjWbi_dkiXoj^[i[b\# h[jW_d_d]h[jhWYjehm_j^j^hecXei_ie\j^[i_dkiWdZikXi[gk[dj XhW_d_d\WhYj_ed$ L[deki_d\WhYj_edZk[jeeYYbki_ede\WdeYY_f_jWbXh_Z]_d]l[_d hkdd_d]_djej^[ikf[h_ehiW]_jjWbi_dki$ ;nY[ii_l[ eYY_f_jWb beX[ h[jhWYj_ed W]W_dij ]hWl_jo Zk[ je feeh fWj_[djfei_j_ed_d]$9edjki_ede\j^[eYY_f_jWbbeX[cWoh[ikbj_d l_ikWbZ_ijkhXWdY[i$ ?d`khojej^[ifb[d_kcYehfeh_iYWbbei_cWoYWki[b[\j^[c_Wb[n_W" j^[_dWX_b_jojeh[WZ_dj^[b[\jl_ikWb^[c_Ó[bZ"WdZWXheWZWhhWo e\X[^Wl_ehWbWXdehcWb_j_[i$ ?d`kh_[i je dkc[heki l[ii[bi WdZ j^[ 9D ?L m_j^_d j^[ gkWZh_# ][c_dWb WdZ feij[h_eh WcX_[dj h[]_ed Zkh_d] c_Yheikh]_YWb cWd_fkbWj_edm_j^feijef[hWj_l[d[khebe]_YWbZ[j[h_ehWj_ed$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ZkhWbYbeikh[m_j^feijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ ^[ceijWi_i m_j^ ikXi[gk[dj _djhW# eh [njhWYhWd_Wb h[Xb[[Z_d]$
(,*
?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ r feij[h_ehlWh_Wj_ed
<_]$-$($(.
J_fiWdZjh_Yai
<_]$-$($(/
JWa[j_c[\ehfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZfei_j_ed_d]e\fWj_[dji$ J^[h[ikbj_iWd[nY[bb[djel[hl_[me\j^[jWh][jWh[WWdZWd[\Ó# Y_[dj meha_d] fei_j_ed Zkh_d] ikh][ho$ <eh fbWdd_d] j^[ [nWYj fbWY[c[dje\j^[YhWd_ejeco"fh[ef[hWj_l[_cW]_d]e\j^[Xh_Z]# _d]l[_diki_d]9JehCH7_ih[Yecc[dZ[Z$?dif[Y_WbYWi[i:I7 YWdX[f[h\ehc[Z$
CWa[WYWh[\kbWdWjec_YWbeh_[djWj_edWdZki[j^[j^h[[ij[fie\ cWha_d]m_j^Wij[h_b[f[d0'$eii[ekiijhkYjkh[i1($fbWY[c[dje\ YhWd_ejeco1)$ia_d_dY_i_ed$
<_]$-$($)&
9h[Wj_d] j^[ Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_ed" j^[ bWj[hWb XehZ[hi e\ j^[ ikf[h_eh iW]_jjWb i_dki i^ekbZ X[ YWh[\kbbo Y^[Ya[Z Wle_Z_d] _d`khoZkh_d]YhWd_ejeco<_]$-$($(.$ IjW][i e\ YhWd_ejeco <_]$-$($(/0 '$ fWh_[jWb WdZ ($ eYY_f_jWb Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_edi Y^[Ya_d] j^[ ikf[h_eh iW]_jjWb i_dki1 )$Å*$_fi_bWj[hWbWdZ+$Å,$YedjhWbWj[hWbYkjj_d]\hecj^[fWh_[jWb je j^[ eYY_f_jWb Xkhh ^eb[ m_j^ W ^_]^#if[[Z YhWd_ejec[$ J^[ YhWd_ejec[i^ekbZd[l[hYheiij^[i_dkiWh[W$
<_]$-$($)'
H[celWb e\ j^[ _dd[h [Z][ e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco e\\[hi _dYh[Wi[Z _djhWYhWd_Wbl_ikWb_pWj_edZk[jeWi[Yjeh#b_a[ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_ed <_]$-$($)&$ 7Z[gkWj[ fei_j_ed_d] e\ j^[ ^[WZ h[ikbji _d ]hWl_jo#[d^WdY[Z i[b\#h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ eYY_f_jWb beX[" Wle_Z_d] [nY[ii_l[ XhW_d h[jhWYj_ed<_]$-$($)'$ <_]$-$($)(
:kh_d] mekdZ Ybeikh[" j^[ ZkhW i^ekbZ X[ Ybei[Z m_j^ mWj[h# j_]^jikjkh[i$?\d[Y[iiWho"j_iik[e\j^[]Wb[WWfed[khej_YWYWd X[ki[Z\ehj^_ifkhfei[<_]$-$($)($ J^[Xed[ÔWfi^ekbZX[Ón[Zm_j^ekjYecfh[ii_ede\ j^[III Wle_Z_d]i_dkie_ZWbj^hecXei_i<_]$-$($))$ <_]$-$($))
J^[ia_d_dY_i_edm_j^_dj^[^W_h[ZWh[WYWdX[Ybei[Zm_j^_dj[h# hkfj[Zehhkdd_d]ikjkh[i$ Ki_d]Wb_c_j[Zia_d_dY_i_ed"WikYj_edZhW_d_idejh[gk_h[Z$
(,+
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^
.$& JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^[nfei_d]j^[bWj[hWbWdZ j^_hZl[djh_Yb[i >_ijehoe\j^[\hedjWbjhWdiYehj_YWb jhWdil[djh_YkbWhWffheWY^[i
<_]$.$&$' J^[ feij[h_eh jhWdiYWbbeiWb WffheWY^ \eh ikh]_# YWbWYY[iijej^_hZl[djh_YkbWhb[i_ediZ[iYh_X[ZXo:WdZo _d'/))$Dej[_dY_i_ede\j^[WiY[dZ_d]\ehd_nWdZef[d_d] j^[hee\e\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[Wbbem_d]WZ[gkWj[[nfbehW# j_ede\j^[Z[[f#i[Wj[Zi_j[$
M^[d Z_iYkii_d] WffheWY^[i je j^[ l[djh_YkbWh ioij[c" if[Y_Wb Wjj[dj_ed i^ekbZ X[ ]_l[d je MWbj[h ;$ :WdZo" m^e ^WZ kd_gk[ _dj[h[ij_dl[djh_YkbWhb[i_ediWdZWdkdfh[Y[Z[dj[Z[nf[h_[dY[_d Z[Wb_d]m_j^j^[c$?d'/(("^[Z[iYh_X[Zj^[ÓhijikYY[ii\kbh[celWb e\WX[d_]djkceh_dj^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb["eYYbkZ_d]j^[\ehWc[de\ Cedhe$ >_ijeh_YWbbo" jme WffheWY^[i m[h[ Z[iYh_X[Z Xo :WdZo je h[WY^j^[h[]_ede\j^[Wdj[h_ehbWj[hWbWdZj^_hZl[djh_Yb[i0j^[fei# j[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YjhWdiYWbbeiWbWdZj^[Wdj[h_ehjhWdiYehj_YWb jhWdil[djh_YkbWh[nfeikh[iQ:WdZo'/(("'/(-"'/))"'/),S$J^[Y^e_Y[ X[jm[[d[_j^[hj^[Wdj[h_ehehj^[feij[h_ehWffheWY^mWiZ[Y_Z[Z Xoj^[fei_j_ede\j^[jkceh"Z_W]dei[ZXol[djh_Ykbe]hWf^_Y_dl[i# j_]Wj_edi$?\j^[b[i_edeYYkf_[Zedboj^[feij[h_ehfWhje\j^[j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[" j^[ feij[h_eh jhWdiYWbbeiWb :WdZoÉi Çf_d[WbÈ [nfeikh[ WffheWY^mWiYWhh_[Zekj<_]$.$&$'$?\j^[jkceheYYkf_[Zj^[Wdj[# h_ehj^_hZl[djh_Yb[WdZ\ehWc[de\Cedhe"j^[Wdj[h_ehjhWdiYehj_YWb Ç^ofef^oi[WbÈ[nfeikh[WffheWY^mWiikf[h_eh<_]$.$&$($;nfei# _d]j^[l[djh_YkbWhY^WcX[hl_Wj^[\hedjWbWffheWY^" :WdZoki[Z WdelWbh[i[Yj_edehjhWdil[hi[i[Yj_ede\j^[\hedjWbbeX["kikWbbo edj^[h_]^j"dedZec_dWdji_Z[$>[Z_Zdejki[j^[Wdj[h_ehjhWdi# YWbbeiWb[nfeikh[X[YWki[e\j^[ikffei[Zboi[l[h[Yb_d_YWb[\\[Yji h[ikbj_d]\heci[Yj_ed_d]j^[Wdj[h_ehfWhje\j^[YehfkiYWbbeikc$ ?d^_icede]hWf^Ç8[d_]dJkcehi_dj^[J^_hZL[djh_Yb[e\j^[8hW_d0 :_W]dei_iWdZJh[Wjc[djÈ"fkXb_i^[Z_d'/))":WdZoh[fehj[ZWceh# jWb_johWj[e\))$)Wced]fWj_[dji\hecj^[[dj_h[i[h_[iYel[h_d]W f[h_eZe\''o[Whi$:[if_j[Wi_]d_ÓYWdj_cfhel[c[dj_dbWj[hfkXb_# YWj_edi"j^[i[h[ikbjifhecfj[Ziec[d[kheikh][edijeWle_ZikY^ ef[hWj_edi$ 7hd[ Jeha_bZi[d [cf^Wi_p[Z fWbb_Wj_l[ cWdW][c[dj _djh[Wj_d]fWj_[djim_j^_djhWl[djh_YkbWhjkcehi"ki_d]l[djh_Ykbe# Y_ij[hdeijeco _d ^oZheY[f^Wb_Y fWj_[dji X[\eh[ Wdo ej^[h ikh]_YWb fheY[Zkh[im[h[kdZ[hjWa[dQJeha_bZi[d'/)/S$
<_]$.$&$( :WdZoÊi \hedjWb jhWdiYehj_YWb WffheWY^ [n# fei_d]WYebbe_ZYoije\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[$Dej[j^[Ç^ehi[# i^e[ m[Z][È _dY_i_ed WdZ fWhj_Wb h[celWb e\ j^[ \hedjWb beX[je[nfei[j^[bWj[hWbl[djh_Yb[WdZ\ehWc[de\Cedhe$
J^[ ceij \h[gk[djbo Z_iYkii[Z Yecfb_YWj_ed e\ j^[ jhWdiYehj_YWb WffheWY^ mWi feijef[hWj_l[ i[_pkh[i X[YWki[ e\ j^[ [nj[dZ[Z Yehj_YWb_dY_i_ed<_]$.$&$)$J^[_dY_Z[dY[e\i[_pkh[imWih[fehj[Z je X[ Wi ^_]^ Wi (- WYYehZ_d] je >k]^ 9W_hdi" ki_d] cWYheikh#
(,-
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^
]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[i"fheXWXboh[ikbj_d]\hecj^[Yehj_YWb_dY_i_ed_ji[b\ QFWjj[hied'/)+"Feff[d'/+)"=khZ`_Wd'/,*"A[cf['/,."9W_hdi '/-'S$ J^[ _djheZkYj_ed e\ j^[ c_YheiYef[ _d d[kheikh]_YWb j[Y^# d_gk[iWbbem[ZZ[Yh[Wi[Zikh]_YWbjhWkcWj_pWj_edWdZX[jj[hl_ik# Wb_pWj_ede\j^[Z[[f#i[Wj[Zb[i_edi<_]$.$&$*$>em[l[h"_dWi[h_[i _dj^['/.&i"ej^[hfeijef[hWj_l[Yecfb_YWj_edim[h[WbieZ[iYh_X[Z0 ^[c_fWh[i_iW\j[hh[jhWYj_ede\j^[Y[djhkci[c_elWb[eYYkhh[Z_d kfje(&e\fWj_[djiQ>_hiY^'/-/"7djkd[i'/.&S$Ej^[hfWj_[dji ^WZ c[ceho Z[ÓY_ji Z[f[dZ_d] ed j^[ Z[]h[[ e\ h[jhWYj_ed WdZ _d\WhYj_ede\j^[dkYb[kiYWkZWjki$9ed\ki_edWdZckj_icm[h[Wbie h[fehj[Z$ J^[ Wkj^ehi c[dj_ed[Z j^Wj d[khebe]_YWb Z[j[h_ehWj_ed Wced]j^[i[fWj_[djih[ikbj[Z\hecj^[[nj[dZ[ZYehj_YWb_dY_i_ed WdZj^[h[jhWYj_edd[Y[iiWhojel_ikWb_p[j^[l[djh_YkbWhY^WcX[h$ J^[^_]^cehjWb_joWdZcehX_Z_johWj_e_dj^[b_j[hWjkh[YekbZm[bb _dZ_YWj[j^Wjj^[jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^jej^[bWj[hWbWdZj^_hZl[d# jh_Yb[ i^ekbZ X[ Z_ih[]WhZ[Z$ >em[l[h" W Yh_j_YWb WdWboi_i e\ j^[i[ WXel[c[dj_ed[ZWffheWY^[ii^emij^Wj_d[l[hoYWi["[nj[dZ[Z YhWd_ejec_[i WdZ Yehj_YWb [nfeikh[i m_j^ hek]^ h[jhWYj_ed e\ j^[ \hedjWbbeX[m[h[f[h\ehc[Z$?dYedjhWij"j^[j[Y^d_gk[e\b_c_j[Z a[o^eb[[nfeikh[iYWki[ic_d_cWbZWcW][jeXhW_dj_iik[m^_Y^_i WbceijYecfWhWXb[jej^[_d`khoYWki[ZXol[djh_Yb[fkdYjkh[$Ed j^[ej^[h^WdZ"Wb_c_j[ZYehj_YWb_dY_i_ed_iWbieik\ÓY_[djjel_ik# Wb_p[ Z_\\[h[dj fWhji e\ j^[ l[djh_YkbWh Y^WcX[h WdZ [nfei[ bWh][ _djhWl[djh_YkbWhb[i_ediZk[jeWi[Yjeh#b_a[ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_ed$ ?dj^[\ebbem_d]"j^[_cfehjWdY[e\j^[a[o^eb[YedY[fj_iZ_iYkii[Z ki_d]\hedjWbjhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^[ijej^[l[djh_YkbWhioij[c$
(,.
<_]$.$&$) A[cf[Êi\hedjWbjhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^[nfei_d] l[djh_YkbWh b[i_edi$ Dej[ j^[ [nj[dZ[Z cWYheikh]_YWb Yehj_YWb_dY_i_ed$
<_]$.$&$* J^[\hedjWbjhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^jej^[j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ Z[iYh_X[Z Xo M_bb_Wc I^kYWhj _d C_Y^W[b B$@$ 7fkppeÊi Yecfh[^[di_l[ Xeea [dj_jb[Z ÇIkh][ho e\ j^[ J^_hZL[djh_Yb[È"fkXb_i^[Z_d'/.-WdZ_dWi[YedZ[Z_j_ed _d'//.$Dej[j^[h[bWj_edi^_fe\j^[iYWbf_dY_i_edjej^[ Xkhh^eb[iWdZj^[YhWd_ejeco$J^[jhWdiYehj_YWb[nfeikh[ \eh_djhWl[djh_YkbWhb[i_edimWiki[Z_dj^[YWi[e\^oZhe# Y[f^Wb_Y[dbWh][Zl[djh_Yb[i$
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^
Ki[e\j^[a[o^eb[YedY[fj_d\hedjWbjhWdiYehj_YWb jhWdil[djh_YkbWhWffheWY^[i
7
J^[iY^[cWj_YYWhjeedie\j^[l[djh_YkbWhijhkYjkh[iZ[cedijhWj[ j^WjWb_c_j[Z[nfeikh[WffheWY^YWdX[ik\ÓY_[djjel_ikWb_p[bWh][ _djhWl[djh_YkbWh Wh[Wi" [if[Y_Wbbo _d ^oZheY[f^Wb_Y fWj_[dji$ 7YYehZ# _d]jej^_iYedY[fj"j^[ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_edi^ekbZX[i_c_bWhjej^[ eXi[hlWj_ed j^hek]^ W l_hjkWb a[o^eb[$ :_ii[Yj_d] _d W i[Yjeh#b_a[ Z_h[Yj_edj^hek]^WicWbb"fh[Y_i[bofbWdd[ZWdZWYYkhWj[bofbWY[Z Yehj_YWb _dY_i_ed" j^[ ikh][ed _i Wbie WXb[ je l_ikWb_p[ WdZ h[cel[ [nj[dZ[Z _djhWl[djh_YkbWh b[i_edi <_]$ .$&$+ W$ J^_i YedY[fj _i j^[ jhk[ effei_j[ e\ j^[ Yecced \kdd[b#b_a[ ikh]_YWb Z_ii[Yj_ed m_j^ Wd [nj[dZ[Z Yehj_YWb _dY_i_ed \eh W h[bWj_l[bo icWbb jWh][j b[i_ed <_]$.$&$+X$ Ki_d]WjhWdi\ehWc_dWbWffheWY^jej^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb["j^[efj_cWb fbWY[c[dje\j^[YhWd_ejeco_i[ii[dj_WbjeWle_Z\ehd_YWbYedjki_ed$ ?dj^[fh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]"j^[_dZ_l_ZkWbWdWjecoe\j^[\ehWc[d e\Cedhe"WdZj^[i_p[WdZi_j[e\j^[_dj[hj^WbWc_YWZ^[i_edi^ekbZ X[Z[j[hc_d[Z_dYecfWh_iedm_j^j^[jWh][jfe_dj<_]$.$&$,$
8 <_]$.$&$+ J^[ki[e\j^[a[o^eb[YedY[fj_djhWdiYehj_YWb WffheWY^[i$=[d[hWbbo"b[i_edie\j^[bWj[hWbWdZj^_hZl[d# jh_Yb[i Wh[ Z[[f#i[Wj[Z$ 9ecfWh[Z m_j^ W ijWdZWhZ ikh]_# YWb WffheWY^ 8" [dj[h_d] j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb Y^WcX[h j^hek]^ W b_c_j[Z YhWd_ejeco" j^[ l_ikWb Ó[bZ i^emi W i[Yjeh#b_a[m_Z[d_d]7$7i^ehjZ_ijWdY[WbbemiWb_c_j[Z el[hl_[m1 _d YedjhWij" W bed] ikh]_YWb Yehh_Zeh je W Z[[f# i[Wj[ZÓ[bZe\j[dfhel_Z[iWX[jj[hced_jeh_d]e\j^[Z_i# i[Yj_ed$
J^[b_c_j[Za[o^eb[[nfeikh[h[ikbj_d]_dh[ZkY[ZZWcW][je_cfeh# jWdjYehj_YWbijhkYjkh[icWoc_d_c_p[j^[feijef[hWj_l[d[khebe]_# YWbZ[j[h_ehWj_ed_dfWj_[dji$?dj^_ih[if[Yj"j^[\hedjWbjhWdiYehj_YWb jhWdil[djh_YkbWhWffheWY^_ifWh[nY[bb[dY[j^[\kbbh[Wb_iWj_ede\j^[ a[o^eb[ijhWj[]o_dd[kheikh][ho$ ?dj^[\ebbem_d]"j^[WdWjec_YWbXWi_ie\j^[\hedjWbjhWdiYehj_YWb WffheWY^_iZ_iYkii[Z_dZ[jW_b$
<_]$.$&$, Je [nfei[ j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ j^hek]^ j^[ _djhWl[djh_YkbWh \ehWc[d" j^[ efj_ckc fbWY[c[dj e\ j^[YhWd_ejecoi^ekbZX[Z[j[hc_d[Zfh[ef[hWj_l[bo$J^[ Wdj[h_ehj^_hZl[djh_Yb[YWdX[ijX[WffheWY^[Zj^hek]^W YehedWhbo fbWY[Z YhWd_ejeco ]h[[d Whhem$ <eh [nfei_d] j^[h[]_ede\j^[feij[h_ehYecc_iikh[WdZWgk[ZkYj"j^[ YhWd_ejecoi^ekbZX[fbWY[Zceh[\hedjWbboh[ZWhhem$
(,/
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^
=[d[hWbWdWjec_YWbYedijhkYj_ede\j^[l[djh_YkbWh Y^WcX[hWdZWdWjec_YWbXWi_ie\j^[\hedjWb jhWdiYehj_YWbjhWdil[djh_YkbWhWffheWY^ M^[dYedi_Z[h_d]ikh]_YWbWffheWY^[i\ehb[i_edie\j^[Wdj[h_eh fWhje\j^[bWj[hWbWdZj^_hZl[djh_Yb["ef_d_edilWhoX[YWki[e\j^[ m[bb#ademd_Wjhe][d_YYecfb_YWj_edie\j^[_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWdZ jhWdiYehj_YWb[nfeikh[i$J^[h[Wied\ehj^[^_]^hWj[e\Yecfb_YW# j_edi _i j^[ feii_Xb[ _d`kho je _cfehjWdj d[kheWdWjec_YWb ijhkY# jkh[i$ >em[l[h" _j _i _cfehjWdj je Yedi_Z[h Yecfb_YWj_edi WiieY_# Wj[Zm_j^j^[ikh][ho_dh[bWj_edjej^[Yehh_Zeh"cWd_fkbWj_edWj j^[jWh][jWh[W"WdZ_dh[bWj_edjej^[fWj^ebe]oe\j^[b[i_ed_ji[b\$ ?dZ[f[dZ[dje\j^[fWj^ebe]o"j^[XWi_ie\c_d_c_p_d]ZWcW][_i j^[Y^e_Y[e\WdWffheWY^m^_Y^WbbemiiW\[cWd_fkbWj_edZk[je efj_cWbl_ikWb_pWj_ede\j^[ef[hWj_l[Wh[Wj^hek]^WiW\[Yehh_Zeh m_j^ekj_d`khojed[_]^Xeh_d]ijhkYjkh[i$
7
9edY[hd_d]j^[ef[hWj_l[Yehh_Zeh"j^[jhWdiYehj_YWbhekj[_iX[jj[h YecfWh[Zm_j^j^[_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^l_W[dbWh][Zl[djh_# Yb[icWa_d]j^[jhWdiYehj_YWbZ_ii[Yj_edb[iijhWkcWj_Y<_]$.$&$-$ J^[ WffheWY^ _i X[ij f[h\ehc[Z \hec j^[ h_]^j" dedZec_dWdj i_Z["kdb[ii_j_iX[_d]ki[Z\ehb[i_edie\j^[b[\jbWj[hWbl[djh_Yb[ eh \eh j^_hZ l[djh_YkbWh b[i_edi m_j^ i_]d_ÓYWdj [nj[di_ed _dje j^[ b[\j bWj[hWb l[djh_Yb[$ 7YYehZ_d] je j^[ YedY[fj e\ YedjhWbWj# [hWba[o^eb[WffheWY^[i"Wb[\j#i_Z[ZYhWd_ejecoYWdX[Wbieki[Z \eh b[i_edi beYWj[Z m_j^_d j^[ h_]^j i_Z[ e\ j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_YkbWh Y^WcX[h$ If[Y_WbWjj[dj_edi^ekbZX[]_l[djej^[\WYjj^Wjj^[jhWdiYehj_YWb jhWdil[djh_YkbWhWffheWY^jej^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[cWa[ii[Yj_ed_d] e\ j^[ Wdj[h_eh Yehfki YWbbeikc WdZ cWd_fkbWj_ed e\ j^[ \ehd_n kdd[Y[iiWho$ J^[ c_Zb_d[ _dj[h\ehd_YWb WffheWY^" Z[iYh_X[Z Xo ;ZmWhZ8kiY^WdZh[Ód[ZXoC_Y^W[bB$@$7fkppe"h[gk_h[ii[fW# hWj_ede\j^[Ybei[WdZl[holkbd[hWXb[\ehd_YWbijhkYjkh[iQ8kiY^ '/**"7fkppe'/.(S$
(-&
8
<_]$.$&$- W" X IY^[cWj_Y ZhWm_d] YecfWh_d] j^[ jhWdi# Yehj_YWb 7 WdZ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^[i 8 je j^[ bWj[hWbl[djh_Yb[$J^[jhWdiYehj_YWbhekj[i^ekbZX[ki[Z_d j^[YWi[e\^oZheY[f^Wb_YWbbo[dbWh][Zl[djh_Yb[icWa_d] j^[jhWdiYehj_YWbZ_ii[Yj_edb[iijhWkcWj_Y$J^[_dj[h^[c_# if^[h_Y WffheWY^ _i X[jj[h \eh dehcWb i_p[Z eh dWhhem l[djh_Yb[i$
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^
7
8
<_]$.$&$. W"X JhWdi\ehWc_dWb _dl[ij_]Wj_ed e\ j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ki_d]j^[\hedjWbjhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^7$J^_i WffheWY^ Wbbemi m_Z[ [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_YkbWh Y^WcX[hm_j^ekji[Yj_ed_d]j^[Wdj[h_ehYehfkiYWbbeikc WdZh_iaoZ_ii[Yj_ede\j^[\ehd_n$Ki_d]j^[ikXY^ehe_ZWb hekj[" j^[ [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ YWd X[ ikYY[ii# \kbbo[dbWh][Z8$>[h[" j^[ j^_hZl[djh_Yb[_iWffheWY^[Z j^hek]^j^[l[bkc_dj[hfei_jkcW\j[h][djb[Z_ii[Yj_ede\ j^[_dj[hdWbY[h[XhWbl[_di$
;nj[dZ[Z b[i_edi cWo X[ [nfei[Z j^hek]^ Wd WZZ_j_edWb feij[# h_eh[nj[di_ede\j^[\ehWc[de\Cedhe"j^[]eWbe\j^_iWffheWY^ X[_d] j^[ ef[d_d] e\ j^[ Y^ehe_Z Óiikh[ WdZ [dj[h_d] j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ j^hek]^ j^[ Y_ij[hdW l[b_ _dj[hfei_j__ <_]$.$&$.X$ J^[ XWi_ie\j^[ikXY^ehe_ZWbWffheWY^_iWYWh[\kbeXi[hlWj_ede\j^[ Z[[f c[Z_Wb WdZ bWj[hWb ikX[f[dZocWb l[deki ioij[c" ZhW_d_d] j^[ Wdj[hebWj[hWb Wif[Yj e\ j^[ l[djh_YkbWh XekdZWho$ J^[ i[fjWb WdZ j^WbWceijh_Wj[ l[_di i^[Z j^[_h ikX[f[dZocWb YeWj d[Wh je j^[ \ehWc[d e\ Cedhe WdZ `e_d Z_h[Yjbo m_j^ j^[ _dj[hdWb Y[h[# XhWb l[_d$J^_i YedÔk[dY[ e\ j^[ i[fjWb WdZ j^WbWceijh_Wj[ l[_di je][j^[hm_j^j^[ikf[h_ehY^ehe_ZWbl[_d_ij^[ie#YWbb[ZWd]kbki l[deiki"i_jkWj[Zm_j^_dj^[b[Wl[ie\j^[WhWY^de_Zc[cXhWd[i e\j^[l[bkc_dj[hfei_jkc$7\j[hceX_b_pWj_ede\j^[Wd]kbkil[de# iki"j^[Y^ehe_Zfb[nkii^ekbZX[Z_ii[Yj[Z\hecj^[j[d_Wj^WbWc_$ J^[Y^ehe_Zfb[nkim_j^j^[\ehd_n_ij^[d][djboh[jhWYj[ZWdZj^[ l[bkc_dj[hfei_jkcWdZj^[Y^ehe_ZWbhee\e\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[Wh[ ceX_b_p[Z]W_d_d]WYY[iijej^[j^_hZl[djh_YkbWhY^WcX[h$J^[i[ ikXY^ehe_ZWbehjhWdiY^ehe_ZWbWffheWY^[i^Wl[X[[dZ[iYh_X[ZXo i[l[hWbWkj^ehiQ:[bWdZi^[[h'/-.">_hiY^'/-/"BWlod[éFWjj[h# ied'/.)"M[déH^ejed'//.S$ 9edY[hd_d]j^[cWd_fkbWj_edWjj^[jWh][jWh[W"m[i^ekbZ[cf^W# i_p[j^[ZWd][hie\[nfeikh[e\j^[Z[[fZ_[dY[f^Wb_YWh[W"_dfWh# j_YkbWhj^[b_cX_Yioij[c$J^_iioij[c"ÓhijZ[iYh_X[ZXoFWkb8heYW Wij^[Ç]hWdZbeX[b_cX_gk[È_d'.-."b_[if^obe][d[j_YWbboX[jm[[d j^[ ebZ[ij fWhji e\ j^[ XhW_d WdZ j^[ d[eYehj[n$ @Wc[i M$ FWf[p _d '/)- Z[cedijhWj[Z j^[ Yedd[Yj_edi X[jm[[d j^[ cW_d fWhji e\j^_iioij[c"j^[ie#YWbb[ZFWf[pY_hYk_j$>_iWdWjec_YWbj^[eho mWi ikffehj[Z Xo j^[ Yb_d_YWb _dl[ij_]Wj_edi e\ >[_dh_Y^ Abl[h WdZ FWkb 9$ 8kYo QFWf[p '/)-" Abl[h WdZ 8kYo '/)/S$J^[ b_cX_Y ioij[c _i YedY[hd[Z m_j^ cej_lWj_ed" [cej_ed" ceeZi h[bWj_d] je[Wj_d]WdZic[bb"i[nkWbX[^Wl_eh"WdZX[^Wl_ehWbh[ifedi[ije [nj[hdWbWdZ_dj[hdWbij_ckb_j^WjYedjh_Xkj[]h[Wjbojef[hiedWb_jo" c[ceho"WdZc[djWbYecf[j[dY[$?d`khoe\WdWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[i" ikY^Wij^[XeZoWdZYebkcdie\j^[\ehd_n"j^[cWc_bbWhoXeZ_[i" j^[ j[hc_dWj_ed e\ j^[ cWc_bbej^WbWc_Y jhWYj e\L_Yg ZÊ7poh WdZ j^[Wdj[h_ehdkYb[_e\j^[j^WbWckicWob[WZjei[l[h[d[khebe]_# YWbZ[j[h_ehWj_ed\eh j^[h[cW_dZ[he\ j^[fWj_[djÊib_\[$J^ki j^[ d[kheikh][edi^ekbZX[WmWh[e\ j^_iWdZW_c je_dÔ_YjWib_jjb[ ZWcW][Wifeii_Xb[$ Ki_d]j^[\hedjWbjhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^"i[l[hWbWdWjec_YWbijhkY# jkh[ie\j^[bWj[hWbWdZj^_hZl[djh_Yb[YWdX[WffheWY^[Z$?dWZZ_#
(-'
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^
BWj[hWbl[djh_Yb[
J^_hZl[djh_Yb[
9_ij[hde\j^[_dj[hf[ZkdYkbWh\eiiW
[WZWdZXeZoe\j^[YWkZWj[dkYb[ki 7dj[h_ehkff[hfWhje\j^[j^WbWcki <ehWc[de\Cedhe <ehd_n 9^ehe_Zfb[nkie\j^[bWj[hWbl[djh_Yb[ J^WbWceijh_Wj[l[_d I[fjWbl[_d 9WkZWj[l[_d
9^WcX[he\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[ ?dj[hj^WbWc_YWZ^[i_ed <ehd_n 7dj[h_ehYecc_iikhW Jh_Wd]kbWhh[Y[ii BWc_dWj[hc_dWb_i 9^_WicWj_Yh[Y[ii Efj_YY^_Wic ?d\kdZ_XkbWhh[Y[ii JkX[hY_d[h[kc CWc_bbWhoXeZ_[i >ofej^WbWcki >WX[dkbWhh[]_ed Feij[h_ehYecc_iikhW F_d[WbWdZikfhWf_d[Wbh[Y[ii[i 9hWd_WbfWhje\j^[Wgk[ZkYj
7dj[heikf[h_ehfWhj e\j^[c[i[dY[f^Wbed J_fWdZZ_ijWbfWhje\j^[87" _dYb$f[h\ehWjehi F'i[]c[djie\j^[F97" _dYb$f[h\ehWjehi Fhen_cWbi[]c[djie\j^[I97 F9e7 9D???"9DL?
JWXb[.$&$' 7dWjec_YWbijhkYjkh[i[nfei[Zj^hek]^j^[\hedjWbjhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^$
j_ed"W\j[hef[d_d]j^[Ôeehe\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb["j^[Y_ij[hde\j^[ _dj[hf[ZkdYkbWh\eiiWYWdX[[nfei[ZJWXb[.$&$'$ ?dj^[\ebbem_d]"j^[XWi_Yikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[e\j^[\hedjWbjhWdi# Yehj_YWb jhWdil[djh_YkbWh WffheWY^ _i Z[iYh_X[Z Wi W ij[f#Xo#ij[f Z_ii[Yj_ed$ J^[ jhWdi\ehWc_dWb WdZ ikXY^ehe_ZWb jhWdi#l[bkc _dj[hfei_jkc[nfeikh[ie\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[Wh[WbieZ_iYkii[Z$
(-(
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[
<_]$.$&$/
'$FWj_[djfei_j_ed_d] J^[fWj_[dj_i_dj^[ikf_d[fei_j_ed$?\ki[Z"j^[i_d]b[f_d e\j^[ CWoÓ[bZ^[WZ^ebZ[hi^ekbZX[fbWY[Z_dj^[effei_j[\hedjej[c# fehWb Wh[W je Wbbem \h[[ ikh]_YWb cWd_fkbWj_ed$ Dej[ j^Wj j^[ f_d i^ekbZdejX[fbWY[Z_dj^[j[cfehWb_ickiYb[jeWle_Z_dijWX_b_jo e\j^[ioij[c$
<_]$.$&$'&
Ij[f' J^[^[WZ_iWdj[heÔ[Yj[ZWffhen_cWj[bo)&WXel[j^[^eh_pedjWb b_d[ je Xh_d] j^[ fh[YehedWho Wh[W e\ j^[ \hedjWb Xed[" m^_Y^ m_bb X[ j^[ [djho fe_dj e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco" je j^[ ^_]^[ij fe_dj$ Ki_d] j^_icWd[klh["kdYedjhebb[Zbeiie\9I<Zkh_d]ikh][ho"m^_Y^YWd YWki[YebbWfi_d]e\j^[l[djh_Yb[iWdZj[Wh_d]e\Xh_Z]_d]l[_di"YWd X[[\\[Yj_l[boWle_Z[Z$J^[[nWYjZ[]h[[e\_dYb_dWj_edZ[f[dZied j^[\ehce\j^[bWj[hWbl[djh_Yb["edj^[i_j[WdZi_p[e\j^[\ehWc[d e\CedheWdZedj^[jWh][jh[]_ed<_]$.$&$/$ Ij[f( J^[^[WZ_i[b[lWj[Z_dj^_iWd]kbWj_edjeWXekj+Yc_djejWbWdZ c_d_cWbboh[jheÔ[Yj[Z_dehZ[hdejjeYecfhec_i[j^[jhWY^[WWdZ j^[bWhodnWdZje\WY_b_jWj[l[dekiZhW_dW][<_]$.$&$'&$
<_]$.$&$''
Ij[f) ?dWj^_hZij[f"j^[^[WZ_i]k_Z[Zm_j^Wib_]^jhejWj_ede\'&je '+jej^[YedjhWbWj[hWbi_Z[$M^_b[j^[fei_j_ed_d]e\j^[^[WZ_d Wijh_Yjbol[hj_YWbfei_j_edcWo\WY_b_jWj[_djhWef[hWj_l[eh_[djWj_ed" j^[ ^[WZ fei_j_ed m_j^ W ib_]^j hejWj_ed" WYYehZ_d] je j^[ ^WdZ# [Zd[ii e\ j^[ ikh][ed" cWo [dWXb[ W ceh[ [h]edec_Y fei_j_ed <_]$.$&$''$ Ij[f* <_dWbbo"j^[^[WZ_ibWj[heÔ[Yj[ZYW$'&jej^[YedjhWbWj[hWbi_Z["fhe# l_Z_d]Wd[\ÓY_[djmeha_d]fei_j_ed\ehj^[ikh][ed<_]$.$&$'($
<_]$.$&$'(
(-)
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^
($7dWjec_YWbbWdZcWhaiWdZeh_[djWj_ed <ehWdefj_cWbia_d_dY_i_ed"j^[_cfehjWdjWdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhai e\ j^[ eii[eki iakbb" ikY^ Wi j^[ dWi_ed" YehedWh ikjkh[" iW]_jjWb ikjkh[ WdZ j^[ c[Z_e#fkf_bbWh iW]_jjWb b_d[ Wh[ fh[Y_i[bo Z[Ód[Z WdZ ZhWmd ed j^[ ia_d m_j^ W ij[h_b[ f[d <_]$ .$&$')$ ?d iec[ fWj_[dji"j^[YehedWhikjkh[cWodejX[fWbfWXb[$?dj^_ii_jkWj_ed j^[ fh[ef[hWj_l[ CH _cW]_d] YWd ^[bf je Z[Ód[ j^[ fei_j_ed e\ j^[ ikjkh[$ ?d WZZ_j_ed" _d _dZ_l_ZkWbi m_j^ W dedfWj^ebe]_Y iakbb YedÓ]khWj_ed"j^[fei_j_ede\j^[YehedWhikjkh[YWdX[c[Wikh[Z WjYW$'($&Ycfeij[h_ehjej^[dWi_ed$ J^[YhWd_ejecoWh[We\WXekj(&cc_dZ_Wc[j[h_ikikWbbofbWY[Z Wjj^[b[l[be\j^[YehedWhikjkh[m_j^j^[Y[dj[he\j^[Wdj_Y_fWj[Z Xed[ÔWf_dj^[c[Z_e#fkf_bbWhiW]_jjWbb_d[<_]$.$&$')$>em[l[h" j^[[nWYjfbWY[c[dje\j^[YhWd_ejecoZ[f[dZiedj^[_dZ_l_ZkWb fWj^eWdWjec_YWbi_jkWj_ed$J^[iW]_jjWbWdZYehedWhfbWd[e\j^[ fh[ef[hWj_l[CHZWjWZ[Ód[j^[X[ijjh[f^_dWj_edWbbem_d]efj_# cWbZ_h[Yj_ed\ehikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_ed$ 7\j[h Z[Ód_j_ed e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco" j^[ ijhW_]^j iW]_jjWb ia_d _dY_# i_edi^ekbZX[fbWdd[Z"kikWbboX[^_dZj^[\hedjWb^W_hb_d["_dj^[ c[Z_efkf_bbWho fbWd[ <_]$ .$&$')$ <eh XWbZ#^[WZ[Z fWj_[dji" j^[ ia_d _dY_i_ed i^ekbZ X[ f[h\ehc[Z _d j^[ YehedWh fbWd[$ <eh j^_i fkhfei["Wmh_dab[e\j^[ia_dcWoX[Y^ei[djeWY^_[l[Wfb[Wi_d] Yeic[j_YekjYec[$J^[ia_di^ekbZX[Z_i_d\[Yj[ZYWh[\kbbo$
<_]$.$&$') :[Ód_j_ede\j^[YhWd_ejecoWdZia_d_dY_i_ed WYYehZ_d] je WdWjec_YWb bWdZcWhai$ Dej[ j^[ c[Z_e# fkf_bbWh iW]_jjWb b_d[" cWha_d] j^[ Y[dj[h e\ j^[ YhWd_e# jeco$
(-*
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^
)$9hWd_ejeco Ij[f' H_]^j i_Z[$ 7\j[h WdWjec_YWb eh_[djWj_ed WdZ c_d_cWbeh[l[dWXi[dj^W_hi^Wl_d]"j^[ia_d i^ekbZX[c[j_YkbekiboZ_i_d\[Yj[Zki_d]WbYe# ^ebiebkj_ed$J^[ia_d_i_dY_i[ZijhW_]^j_dj^[ c[Z_efkf_bbWh b_d[ _d W bed]_jkZ_dWb Z_h[Yj_ed _d ed[ bWo[h m_j^ j^[ ikXYkjWd[eki j_iik[ <_]$.$&$'*$
<_]$.$&$'*
Ij[f( J^[ ]Wb[W#f[h_eij bWo[h _i Z_ii[Yj[Z c[Z_# Wbbo Wi W ÔWf" j^[ ie\j j_iik[ bWo[hi Wh[ j^[d h[jhWYj[Z X_bWj[hWbbo" [nfei_d] j^[ Xedo ikh# \WY[<_]$.$&$'+$
<_]$.$&$'+
Ij[f) 7\j[h Zh_bb_d] W ^eb[ Wj j^[ c[Z_Wb cWh]_d e\ j^[ fbWdd[Z YhWd_ejeco" j^[ ZkhWb ikh\WY[ _i ceX_b_p[Zm_j^WXbkdjZ_ii[Yjeh<_]$.$&$',$
<_]$.$&$',
(-+
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^
<_]$.$&$'-
Ij[f* J^[h[W\j[hWXed[ÔWfm_j^WZ_Wc[j[he\WXekj ($& Yc _i Ykj ekj ki_d] W ^_]^#if[[Z YhWd_e# jec[$?dWbbYWi[i"Wdeij[efbWij_YYhWd_ejeco _iYWhh_[Zekj$>[cehh^W][ieYYkhh_d]Zkh_d] j^[ YhWd_ejeco YWd X[ Yedjhebb[Z Xo X_febWh YeW]kbWj_edWdZXed[mWn<_]$.$&$'-$
<_]$.$&$'.
Ij[f+ 7d _cfehjWdj ij[f e\ j^[ WffheWY^ W\j[h h[celWb e\ j^[ Xed[ ÔWf _i j^[ h[celWb e\ j^[ _dd[h [Z][ e\ j^[ YhWd_ejeco m_j^ Ód[ fkdY^[i$M_j^YWh[\kbh[celWbe\j^[_dj[hdWb jWXb["j^[Wd]b[\ehikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_edYWdi_]# d_ÓYWdjbo_dYh[Wi[<_]$.$&$'.$
<_]$.$&$'/
Ij[f, J^[ZkhW_i_dY_i[Z_dWi[c_Y_hYkbWh\Wi^_edm_j^ j^[XWi[e\j^[ZkhWbÔWfjemWhZij^[c_Zb_d[ eh_dWYhkY_Wj[\Wi^_edWbed]j^[Z_W]edWb$J^[ \h[[ ZkhWb ÔWfi Wh[ Ón[Z m_j^ ikjkh[i1 ej^[h [b[lWj_edikjkh[iWh[dejh[gk_h[Z<_]$.$&$'/$
(-,
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^
*$?djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_ed Ij[f' H_]^j i_Z[$ :_ii[Yj_ed f[h\ehc[Z ed W \h[i^ ^kcWd if[Y_c[d" m_j^ekj Whj[h_Wb eh l[deki _d`[Yj_ed$7\j[hZkhWbef[d_d]"j^[WhWY^de_Z _i YeW]kbWj[Z WdZ _dY_i[Z m_j^ W Z_WcedZ ad_\[\ebbem[ZXoWicWbbYehj_Yejecoe\WXekj '&je'+cc_db[d]j^$J^[Wdj[h_eh^ehde\j^[ bWj[hWb l[djh_Yb[ _i Óhij fkdYjkh[Z m_j^ W l[d# jh_YkbWh YWddkbW$ 7\j[h h[ZkY_d] j^[ _djhWl[d# jh_YkbWhfh[iikh["j^[YWddkbWcWoX[h[cel[Z$ :_ii[Yj_d] Wbed] j^[ fkdYj_ed YWdWb" j^[ bWj# [hWb l[djh_Yb[ _i [dj[h[Z$ Dej[ j^[ ef[d_d] e\ j^[ [f[dZocW e\ j^[ h_]^j bWj[hWb l[djh_Yb[ <_]$.$&$(&$
[f[dZocW
<_]$.$&$(&
Ij[f( J^[ Óhij WdWjec_YWb bWdZcWha je X[ [dYekd# j[h[Z _i j^[ Y^ehe_Z fb[nki$ 8o \ebbem_d] j^[ Y^ehe_Zfb[nkiWdj[h_ehbo"m[YWd_dZ[dj_\oj^[ \ehWc[de\Cedhe" j^[bWc_dWW\ÓnW j^WbWc_" WdZj^[\ehd_n<_]$.$&$('$
\ehd_n \ehWc[de\ Cedhe Y^ehe_Zfb[nki j^WbWcki
<_]$.$&$('
Ij[f) 7YYehZ_d]jej^[YedY[fje\a[o^eb[WffheWY^[i" m[YWd\ebbemj^[Y^ehe_Zfb[nki_dWfeij[h_eh Z_h[Yj_ed" WffheWY^_d] j^[ Y[bbW c[Z_W$ Dej[ j^[bWc_dWW\ÓnWj^WbWc_"Y^ehe_Zfb[nkiWdZ j^[\ehd_ne\j^[bWj[hWbl[djh_Yb[<_]$.$&$(($
\ehd_n Y^ehe_Zfb[nki j^WbWcki
<_]$.$&$((
(--
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^
Ij[f* :_ii[Yj_d]ceh[feij[h_ehbo"j^[eYY_f_jWb^ehd YWd X[ [nfei[Z$ Dej[ j^[ jof_YWb ikX[f[dZo# cWbl[_die\j^[_d\[h_ehikh\WY[e\j^[Yehfki YWbbeikc<_]$.$&$()$ YehfkiYWbbeikc Y^ehe_Zfb[nki eYY_f_jWb^ehd
<_]$.$&$()
Ij[f+ ?d YWi[i e\ W dehcWb#i_p[Z _dj[hl[djh_YkbWh \ehWc[d" j^[ \ehWc[d e\ Cedhe YWd X[ [dbWh][Z ikh]_YWbbo _d W feij[h_eh Z_h[Yj_ed$ Dej[ ][djb[ Z_ii[Yj_ed e\ j^[ Y^ehe_Z Óiikh[ <_]$.$&$(*$
\ehWc[de\Cedhe Y^ehe_ZÓiikh[ j^WbWcki
<_]$.$&$(*
Ij[f, 9Wh[\kbZ_ii[Yj_ede\j^[ikXY^ehe_ZfWj^mWo$ Dej[ j^[ _dj[hdWb Y[h[XhWb l[_d m_j^_d j^[ l[bkc_dj[hfei_jkc<_]$.$&$(+$
_dj[hdWbY[h[XhWbl[_d
<_]$.$&$(+
(-.
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^
Ij[f:_ii[Yj_d]feij[h_ehbo"m[YWd_dl[ij_]Wj[j^[ h[]_ed e\ j^[ feij[h_eh j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ m_j^ ijhkYjkh[i e\ j^[ feij[h_eh Yecc_iikh[ WdZ j^[ Wgk[ZkYj e\ Iobl_ki$ Dej[ j^[ ikf[h_eh eXi[hlWj_ed j^hek]^ j^[ ikXY^ehe_ZWb hekj[ <_]$.$&$(,$
Wgk[ZkYj feij[h_ehYecc_iikh[
<_]$.$&$(,
Ij[f.$ <eYki_d]W]W_d_dWdj[h_ehZ_h[Yj_ed" j^[Ôeeh e\ j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[ _i l_ikWb_p[Z _d \hedj e\ j^[ _dj[hj^WbWc_Y WZ^[i_ed$ Dej[ j^[ cWc_b# bWhoXeZ_[i<_]$.$&$(-$
\ehd_n cWc_bbWhoXeZ_[i
<_]$.$&$(-
Ij[f/ 7\j[h ef[d_d] j^[ fh[cWc_bbWh h[Y[ii" m[ YWd [dj[h j^[ _dj[hf[ZkdYkbWh Y_ij[hd WdZ eXi[hl[j^[XWi_bWhj_f$Dej[j^[9D???Wff[Wh# _d] X[jm[[d j^[ YedjhWbWj[hWb F97 WdZ I97 <_]$.$&$(.$
9D??? F97 I97 XWi_bWhWhj[ho
<_]$.$&$(.
(-/
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^
+$:khW"Xed[WdZmekdZYbeikh[ 7\j[h Yecfb[j_ed e\ j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[" j^[ _djhWZkhWb ifWY[_iÓbb[Zm_j^Whj_ÓY_Wb9I<iebkj_edWjXeZoj[cf[hWjkh[$<eh j^_ifkhfei[_j_iki[\kb_\j^[YhWd_ejeco_ifbWY[ZWjj^[^_]^[ij fe_dje\ j^[^[WZ"ej^[hm_i[bWh][W_hXkXXb[icWoX[YWk]^j_d j^[bWj[hWbl[djh_Yb[ieh_dj^[ikXZkhWbifWY[$IkY^_djhWYhWd_WbW_h XkXXb[iYWdX[Yec[ifWY[#eYYkfo_d]WdZcWo_cfW_hfeijef[hW# j_l[h[Yel[ho\ehW\[mZWoi$?dWZZ_j_ed"Wd[nj[di_l[beiie\9I< cWo h[ikbj \hec W l[djh_YkbWh YebbWfi[ m_j^ feii_Xb[ j[Wh_d] e\ Xh_Z]_d]l[_di$ J^[ZkhW_iYbei[ZmWj[hj_]^jm_j^_dj[hhkfj[Zehhkdd_d]ikjkh[i$ ?\Z[^_iY[dY[^WiZ[l[bef[Z"Wf_[Y[e\ckiYb[i^ekbZX[i[md_dje j^[ZkhWbef[d_d]$7d[f_ZkhWb][b\eWcfbWj[_ifbWY[ZX[\eh[ÓnW# j_ed e\ j^[ Xed[ ÔWf$J^[ Xed[ ÔWf i^ekbZ X[ j_]^jbo Ón[Z m_j^ W j_jWd_kc fbWj[" Yel[h_d] j^[ Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dWj_ed$J^[ f[h_ei# j[kc"ikXYkjWd[ekibWo[hWdZj^[ia_dWh[Ybei[Z[WY^m_j^_dj[h# hkfj[Zikjkh[i$
Fej[dj_Wb[hhehiWdZj^[_hYedi[gk[dY[i Ceije\j^[Yecfb_YWj_edie\_djhWl[djh_YkbWhef[hWj_ediWh[h[bWj[Z jej^[beYWj_edWdZdWjkh[e\j^[b[i_edhWj^[hj^Wdjej^[ikh]_YWb WffheWY^$>em[l[h"iec[ jof_YWbikh]_YWb[hhehiWdZ j^[_hYedi[# gk[dY[ii^ekbZX[Z_iYkii[Z_dZ[jW_b$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ fh[ef[hWj_l[ fbWdd_d] m_j^ _dWZ[gkWj[ [nfeikh[ e\j^[_djhWYhWd_WbjWh][jh[]_edWdZi_]d_ÓYWdjZ[j[h_ehWj_ed_d [\ÓY_[dYoe\ikh]_YWbbo[nY_i_d]j^[b[i_ed$FbWdd_d]_ij^[jWiae\ j^[ikh][ed ?dWZ[gkWj[fbWY[c[dje\j^[YhWd_ejecom_j^Z[Yh[Wi[Zl_ikWb_# iWj_ede\j^[l[djh_YkbWhY^WcX[hWdZWf^oi_ebe]_YWbbokdYec# \ehjWXb[ `eX Zkh_d] ikh][ho$ ;if[Y_Wbbo m^[d ki_d] W jhWdi\e# hWc_dWb WffheWY^ je j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[" Wd _dYehh[Yj Z_h[Yj_ed e\ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_edcWoYWki[i[l[h[_d`khojej^[\ehd_nm_j^ ikXi[gk[djfeijef[hWj_l[c[cehoZ[ÓY_ji$ F[d[jhWj_ed e\ j^[ ZkhW Zkh_d] YhWd_ejeco" kikWbbo m_j^ekj i[l[h[Yedi[gk[dY[i$ Feijef[hWj_l[i[_pkh[iZk[je[nj[dZ[ZYehj_YWb_dY_i_ed$ Feijef[hWj_l[ ^[c_fWh[i_i Zk[ je hek]^ Yehj_YWb h[jhWYj_ed eh feijef[hWj_l[^[cehh^W][m_j^_dj^[jhWdiYehj_YWbhekj[$
(.&
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^
?d`khojefWhjie\j^[b_cX_Yioij[ccWoh[ikbj_di[h_eki\kdY# j_edWb _cfW_hc[dj YWki_d] X[^Wl_ehWb WdZ [cej_edWb Z_ijkh# XWdY[WdZc[cehobeii$ :_WX[j[i _di_f_Zki WdZ Wa_d[j_Y ckj_ic W\j[h [nfeikh[ e\ j^[ Wdj[h_ehj^_hZl[djh_Yb[Zk[je_d`khoe\j^[^ofej^WbWcki$ Feijef[hWj_l[ Wi[fj_Y c[d_d]_j_i YWd Z[l[bef _d fWj_[dji m^e ^WZ jkcehi ikY^ Wi cWb_]dWdj WijheYojecWi eh Yebbe_Z Yoiji" m^_Y^if_bbXbeeZ"Yebbe_Zehd[Yhej_Yj_iik[_djej^[9I<$9Wh[\kb ikh]_YWbZ_ii[Yj_edcWoZ[Yh[Wi[j^[\h[gk[dYoe\j^_iYecfb_YW# j_ed$M[Zedejh[Yecc[dZj^[hekj_d[WZc_d_ijhWj_ede\Yehj_# Yeij[he_ZiehWdj_X_ej_Yi$ Feijef[hWj_l[ WYkj[ ^oZheY[f^Wbki Zk[ je Wgk[ZkYjWb eh j^_hZ l[djh_YkbWheYYbki_ed$7l[djh_YkbeijecoYh[Wj[ZXoef[d_d]j^[ j^_hZl[djh_YkbWhÔeehcWoWle_Z^oZheY[f^Wbki_dj^[kdi^kdj[Z fWj_[dj$>em[l[h"j^[Yehj_YWb_dY_i_edWiWYedd[Yj_edX[jm[[d _djhWl[djh_YkbWhWdZikXWhWY^de_ZWbifWY[icWo\kdYj_ed_dj^[ iWc[cWdd[h$?dWZZ_j_ed"m_j^\[d[ijhWj_ede\j^[i[fjkcf[bbk# Y_Zkcm[Wh[WXb[jeWle_Zj^[fheXb[ce\WjhWff[Zeh_iebWj[Z l[djh_Yb[i[YedZWhojekd_bWj[hWb\ehWc[de\CedheeYYbki_ed$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ZkhWbYbeikh[m_j^feijef[hWj_l[9I<ÓijkbW$ ?dWZ[gkWj[fei_j_ed_d]WdZÓnWj_ede\j^[Xed[ÔWfm_j^ikX# efj_cWbYeic[j_Yh[ikbji$ ?dWZ[gkWj[ ^[ceijWi_i YWki_d] feijef[hWj_l[ _djhWYhWd_Wb eh [njhWYhWd_Wb^[cWjecW$
J_fiWdZjh_Yai
<_]$.$&$(/
Ki_d]WjhWdi\ehWc_dWbWffheWY^"j^[_dZ_l_ZkWbWdWjecoe\j^[ \ehWc[d e\ Cedhe WdZ j^[ i_p[ WdZ i_j[ e\ j^[ _dj[hj^WbWc_Y WZ^[i_edi^ekbZX[Z[j[hc_d[Z_dYecfWh_iedm_j^ j^[ jWh][j fe_dj$:[Ód_d]j^[efj_ckcfbWY[c[dje\j^[YhWd_ejeco"j^[ iW]_jjWb WdZ YehedWh fbWd[i e\ j^[ fh[ef[hWj_l[ CH i^ekbZ X[ j^ehek]^bo_dl[ij_]Wj[Z$J^[h[mWhZe\j^[efj_cWbfbWdd_d]_i Wd[nY[bb[djel[hl_[me\j^[jWh][jWh[WWdZWd[\ÓY_[djmeha_d] fei_j_edZkh_d]ikh][ho<_]$.$&$(/$ CWa[WYWh[\kbWdWjec_YWbeh_[djWj_edWdZki[j^[j^h[[ij[fie\ cWha_d]m_j^Wij[h_b[f[d0'$eii[ekiijhkYjkh[i1($fbWY[c[dje\ YhWd_ejeco1)$ia_d_dY_i_ed$
<_]$.$&$)&
IjW][i e\ YhWd_ejeco <_]$.$&$)&0 '$ \hedjWb Xkhh ^eb[ jh[f^_dW# j_ed1($Y_hYkbWhYhWd_ejecom_j^W^_]^#if[[ZYhWd_ejec[$
(.'
JhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^
8oh[jhWYj_d]j^[ie\jj_iik["j^[eii[ekiikh\WY[i^ekbZX[efj_# cWbbo[nfei[Z$>em[l[h"h[jhWYj_edWdZceX_b_pWj_ede\j^[ia_d ÔWfi^ekbZX[h[ijh_Yj[Zjej^[d[Y[iiWhoc_d_ckcjefh[l[dj feijef[hWj_l[d[Yhei_i$
<_]$.$&$)'
<ebbem_d]YhWd_ejeco"h[celWbe\j^[_dd[h[Z][e\j^[YhWd_ej# ecofhel_Z[i_dYh[Wi[Z_djhWYhWd_Wbl_ikWb_pWj_ed<_]$.$&$)'$ Ef[d j^[ ZkhW _d WÇ9È i^Wf[Z \Wi^_ed WdZ ^ebZ j^[ ZkhWb ÔWf m_j^ikjkh[i<_]$.$&$)($
<_]$.$&$)(
7ffheWY^_d] j^[ l[djh_YkbWh Y^WcX[h jhWdiYehj_YWbbo" j^[ Yehj_# Yejecoi^ekbZX[f[h\ehc[Zedj^[Y[h[XhWbikh\WY[$:_ii[Yj_ed j^hek]^ W fhec_d[dj ikbYki YWki[i ceh[ Yehj_YWb _d`kho m_j^ feii_Xb[feijef[hWj_l[Z[ÓY_ji<_]$.$&$))$ ;nfei_d] j^[ j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[" j^[ \ehWc[d e\ Cedhe YWd X[ [dbWh][Z feij[h_ehbo m_j^ W ikXY^ehe_ZWb Z_ii[Yj_ed" Wbbem_d] m_Z[ikh]_YWb[nfeikh[$
<_]$.$&$))
7\j[h Yecfb[j_ed e\ j^[ _djhWYhWd_Wb fheY[Zkh[" j^[ _djhWZkhWb ifWY[ _i Óbb[Z m_j^ Whj_ÓY_Wb 9I< iebkj_ed Wj XeZo j[cf[hWjkh[$ <ehj^_ih[Wied"j^[YhWd_ejecoi^ekbZX[fbWY[ZWjj^[^_]^[ij fe_dj e\ j^[ ^[WZ" Wle_Z_d] feijef[hWj_l[ fd[kceY[f^Wbki eh ifWY[#eYYkfo_d]W_hXkXXb[im_j^_dj^[ikXZkhWbifWY[$ J^[ ZkhWb Ybeikh[ i^ekbZ X[ cWZ[ mWj[hj_]^j je Wle_Z feijef# [hWj_l[dWiWb9I<ÓijkbW$?\j[di_edehZ[^_iY[dY[^WiZ[l[bef[Z _dj^[ZkhWbfbWd["Wf_[Y[e\ckiYb[YWdX[i[md_djej^[ZkhWb Ybeikh[<_]$.$&$)*$
<_]$.$&$)*
7\j[hZkhWbYbeikh["j^[Xed[ÔWfi^ekbZX[j_]^jboÓn[ZjeWY^_[l[ efj_cWb Yeic[j_Y h[ikbji$ 7 j_jWd_kc fbWj[ YWd X[ ikYY[ii\kbbo ki[Z\ehYbeikh[e\j^[Xkhh^eb[jh[f^_dWj_ed<_]$.$&$)+$ <_]$.$&$)+
(.(
H[\[h[dY[i
H[\[h[dY[i
9ki^_d]>'/&. J[Y^d_YWbc[j^eZie\f[h\ehc_d]Y[hjW_d YhWd_Wbef[hWj_edi$ Ikh]=od[YebEXij[j,0((-Å(*,
>_ijeho 8W]][dijeii7>"Bel[@='/)/ F_d[WbecWi$ 7hY^D[khebFioY^_Wjho*'0''.-Å'(&, 8W_b[oF'/)) ?djhWYhWd_Wbjkcehi$ 99J^ecWi"Ifh_d]Ó[bZ"?bb 8W_b[oF"@[bb_\\[I;'/'' Jkcehie\j^[f_d[WbXeZo$ 7hY^?dj[hdC[Z.0.+'Å..& 8_d][b7'/(' :_[;dY[f^Wbe]hWf^_["[_d[C[j^eZ[pkh hdj][de]hWf^_iY^[d:Whij[bbkd]Z[i=[^_hdi$ <ehjiY^h=[XHdj][dijh(.0(&+Å('& 8heYaC":_[jp>'/-. J^[icWbb\hedjebWj[hWbWffheWY^\ehj^[c_Yheikh]_YWb jh[Wjc[dje\_djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoici$ D[kheY^_hkh]_W('0'.+Å'/' 8kYoF9'/-* Jme]_Wdji0>Whl[o9ki^_d]WdZMWbj[h:WdZo$ ?d0M_ba_diH>"H[d]WY^WhoII[ZiD[kheikh][ho$ CY=hWm#>_bb"D[mOeha"ff',Å(, 8kYoF9'/-. D[kheikh][ho_dZWhad[ii$ Ikh]D[kheb/0),& 8kdYa[>@@h"CYB[Wd:>'/-' J^[WZlWdjW][e\WijhW_]^jd[[Zb[ _dc_Yheikh][ho$ FbWijH[YedijhIkh]*-0,&(Å,&) 8khjed9L"Cepb[o@C"MWba[h7;"[jWb'/,, ?dZkYj_edj^[hceYeW]kbWj_ede\j^[XhW_d0 Wd[md[kheikh]_YWbjeeb$ JhWdi8_ec[Z;d]')0''*Å'(& 8kiY^;'/** 7d[mWffheWY^\ehj^[h[celWbe\jkcehi e\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[$ 7YjWFioY^_WjhD[kheb'/0+-Å,& 9bWha[H>">ehib[oL'/&, EdWc[j^eZe\_dl[ij_]Wj_d]j^[Z[[fY[djhWb]Wd]b_W WdZjhWYjie\j^[Y[djhWbd[hlekiioij[c$ 8hC[Z@(0'-//Å'.&& 9ki^_d]>'/&) Edhekj_d[Z[j[hc_dWj_edie\Whj[h_Wbj[di_ed _def[hWj_d]heecWdZYb_d_Y$ 8eijedC[ZIkh]@'*.0(+&Å(+, 9ki^_d]>'/&+ J^[[ijWXb_i^c[dje\Y[h[XhWb^[hd_W WiWZ[Yecfh[ii_l[c[Wikh[\eh_dWYY[ii_Xb[ XhW_djkcehi$ Ikh]=od[YebEXij[j'0(/-Å)'*
9ki^_d]>'/'& J^[f_jk_jWhoXeZoWdZ_jiZ_iehZ[hi$ @8B_ff_dYejj"F^_bWZ[bf^_W 9ki^_d]>'/'' J^[Yedjhebe\Xb[[Z_d]_def[hWj_edi\ehXhW_djkcehi$ M_j^j^[Z[iYh_fj_ede\i_bl[hÇYb_fiÈ\ehj^[eYYbki_ede\ l[ii[bi_dWYY[ii_Xb[jej^[b_]Wjkh[$ 7ddIkh]+*0'Å'/ 9ki^_d]>'/'-"h[fh_dj'/,) Jkcehie\j^[d[hlkiWYkij_YkiWdZj^[iodZhec[e\j^[ Y[h[X[bbefedj_b[Wd]b[$ >W\d[hFkXb_i^_d]"D[mOeha 9ki^_d]>'/(- J^[c[d_d][ecWiWh_i_d]\hecj^[eb\WYjeho]heel[WdZ j^[_hh[celWbXoj^[W_Ze\[b[Yjhe#ikh][ho$ @WYaied"Mob_[9e$"=bWi]em 9ki^_d]>'/(. ;b[Yjhe#ikh][hoWiWdW_Zjej^[h[celWb e\_djhWYhWd_Wbjkcehi$ Ikh]=od[YebEXij[j*-0-+'Å-.* 9ki^_d]>'/(/ J^[Y^_WicWbiodZhec[e\fh_cWhoefj_YWjhef^o WdZX_j[cfehWbÓ[bZZ[\[Yji_dWZkbjfWj_[dji m_j^dehcWbi[bbWjkhY_YW$ N???9edY_b_kcEf^j^Wbcebe]_Ykc')0/-Å'.* 9ki^_d]>'/)( ?djhWYhWd_Wbjkcehi$Dej[ikfedWi[h_[ie\jmej^ekiWdZ l[h_Ó[ZYWi[im_j^ikh]_YWbcehjWb_jof[hY[djW][i f[hjW_d_d]j^[h[je$ 99J^ecWi"Ifh_d]Ó[bZ"?bb 9ki^_d]>";_i[d^WhZjB'/). C[d_d][ecWi$J^[_hYbWii_ÓYWj_ed"h[]_edWbX[^Wl_ekh" b_\[^_ijeho"WdZikh]_YWb[dZh[ikbji$ 99J^ecWi"Ifh_d]Ó[bZ"?bb :WcWZ_WdH"=ebZic_j^C"C_dae\\B'/-- DCH_dYWdY[h0NL?$<ED7H_cW][e\ j^[b_l[^kcWdXeZo$ F^oi_eb9^[cF^oi/0/-Å'&& :WdZoM;'/'+ ;nj_hfWj_ede\j^[f_d[WbXeZo$ @;nfC[Z((0()-Å(*:WdZoM;'/'. L[djh_Ykbe]hWf^o\ebbem_d]j^[_d`[Yj_ede\W_h _djej^[Y[h[XhWbl[djh_Yb[i$ 7ddIkh],.0+Å'( :WdZoM;'/'/ Hdj][de]hWf^oe\j^[XhW_dW\j[hj^[_d`[Yj_ed e\W_h_djej^[if_dWbYWdWb$ 7ddIkh]-&0)/-Å*&) :WdZoM;'/'/ efa_di>eif)&0(/Å)*
:WdZoM;'/(' 7def[hWj_ed\ehh[celWbe\f_d[Wbjkcehi$ Ikh]=od[YebEXij[j))0'')Å''/ :WdZoM;'/(( :_W]dei_i"beYWb_pWj_edWdZh[celWbe\jkcehi e\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[$ 8kbb@e^di>efa_di>eif))0'..Å'./ :WdZoM;'/(( 7def[hWj_l[fheY[Zkh[\eh^oZheY[f^Wbki$ 8kbb@e^di>efa_di>eif))0'./Å'/& :WdZoM;'/)* 9edY[hd_d]j^[YWki[e\jh_][c_dWbd[khWb]_W$ 7c@Ikh](*0**:WdZoM;'/), Ef[hWj_l[[nf[h_[dY[i_dYWi[ie\f_d[Wbjkcehi$ 7hY^Ikh]))0'/Å*, :WdZoM;'/). ?djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoice\j^[_dj[hdWbYWhej_ZWhj[ho$ 9kh[ZXoef[hWj_ed$ 7ddIkh]'&-0,+*Å,+/ :WdZoM;'/*( 7d[khoicie\j^[Wdj[h_ehY[h[XhWbWhj[ho$ @7C7''/0'(+)Å'(+* :WdZoM;'/*( Ikh]_YWbjh[Wjc[dje\_djhWYhWd_Wb WdZWhj[h_WbWd[khoici$ JhWdi7cD[kheb7iieY,.0'*(Å'** :[bWdZi^[[h@"=koej@"@ec_dC'/-. 7YYiWkjhe_i_c[l[djh_Ykb[fWhle_[ _dj[h#j^WbWce#jh_]edWb[$ D[kheY^_hkh]_[(*0*'/Å*(( :edW]^oHCF'/,- FWjY^WdZXo#fWii_dc_YheWd]_edWbikh][ho$ ?d0:edW]^oHCF"OWiWh]_bC=[ZiC_Yhe#lWiYkbWh ikh][ho$J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj"ff-+Å., :edW]^oHCF'/-/ J^[^_ijehoe\c_Yheikh][ho_dd[kheikh][ho$ 9b_dD[kheikh](,0,'/Å,(+"'/-/ :ejjDC'/)( ?djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoic$ C[Z9^_hIeY;Z_dX'0('/Å(() :ejjDC'/)) ?djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoici0Y[h[XhWbWhj[h_e#hWZ_e]hWf^o0 ikh]_YWbjh[Wjc[dj$ ;Z_dXC[Z@*&0('/Å()* :hWa[9='/,' 8b[[Z_d]Wd[khoicie\j^[XWi_bWhWhj[ho$ :_h[Yjikh]_YWbcWdW][c[dj_d\ekhYWi[i$ @D[kheikh]'.0()&Å(). :hWa[9='/,+ Edj^[ikh]_YWbjh[Wjc[dje\hkfjkh[Z _djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoici$ 9b_dD[kheikh]')0'((Å'++
(.)
H[\[h[dY[i
:hWa[9='/,. J^[ikh]_YWbjh[Wjc[dje\Wd[khoici e\j^[XWi_bWhWhj[ho$ @D[kheikh](/0*),Å**, :hWa[9='/-. 9ecc[dj$ D[kheikh][ho)0'*&Å'*'
=ebZic_j^C":WcWZ_WdH"IjWd\ehZC"[jWb'/-- DCH_dYWdY[hNL???$7ikf[hYedZkYj_l[DCHcW]d[j\eh W^kcWdiWcfb[$ F^oi_eb9^[cF^oi/0'&+Å'&=em[hiMH">ehib[oL'... 7YWi[e\jkcehe\j^[if_dWbYehZ$ H[celWb0h[Yel[ho$ C[Z9^_hJhWdi-'0)--Å*)&
:hWa[9="F[[hb[[iI@">[hd[id_[c_@7'//, Ikh][hoe\l[hj[XheXWi_bWhWd[khoici$ Ifh_d][h"M_[dD[mOeha
=hWdj<9'/*. Ikh]_YWb[nf[h_[dY[m_j^jkcehie\f_jk_jWho]bWdZ$ @7C7'),0,,.Å,-(
:khWdj[<'..+ ;ij[hfWp_ed[Z_kdjkceh[[dZeYhWd_e \ehcWcehXeiWfh_cW[ZefebÊef[hWp_ed[$ 8ebb7YYWZC[ZHecW''0(*-Å(+(
=h[[dXbWjjI>":W]_J<";fij[_dC>'//- 7^_ijehoe\d[kheikh][ho_d_jiiY_[dj_ÓYWdZ fhe\[ii_edWbYedj[nji$ 7c[h_YWd7iieY_Wj_ede\D[khebe]_YWbIkh][edi"
;_i[d^WhZjB'/(/ J^[ef[hWj_l[cehjWb_jo_dWi[h_[ie\ _djhWYhWd_Wbjkcehi$ 7hY^Ikh]9^_YW]e'.0'/(-Å'/)+ <[hh_[h:">ehib[oL'../ :_iYkii_ededY[h[XhWbbeYWb_pWj_ed$ JhWdi9ed]h7cF^oiIkh]'0))-Å)+& <_iY^K'/,/ Eje#d[kheikh]_YWbef[hWj_edi$ ?d0OWiWh]_bC="C_Yheikh][ho07ffb_[Zjed[kheikh][ho$ J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj"ff'/+Å('& <e[hij[hE'/(. :Wief[hWj_l[Leh][^[dX[_Jkceh[d Z[hL_[h^][b][][dZ$ M_[dAb_dMeY^[diY^h*'0/.,Å//& <enMB'/-+ J^[9ki^_d]Å:WdZoYedjhel[hio$ Ikh]D[kheb)0,'Å,, <en@B'/-/ C_Yheikh]_YWb[nfeikh[e\_djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoici$ @C_Yheikh]'0(Å)'
=h[[dmeeZ@'/*& Jmefe_djYeW]kbWj_ed$7d[mfh_dY_fb[ WdZ_dijhkc[dj\ehWffbo_d]YeW]kbWj_ed 7c@Ikh]+&0(,-Å(-& =khZ`_Wd;I'/,* Ef[hWj_l[d[kheikh][ho"(dZ[Zd$
>Wbij[ZMI'/(* Ikh]_YWbfWf[hi"leb'$ @e^di>efa_diFh[ii"8Wbj_ceh[ >WcXoM8'/+( ?djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoici$ 99J^ecWi"Ifh_d]Ó[bZ"?bb >WhZo@'/,/ JhWdidWiWb#jhWdiif^[de_ZWbWffheWY^ jej^[f_jk_jWho]bWdZ$
@Wdd[jjWF@'/-& C_Yheikh]_YWb[nfbehWj_edWdZZ[Yecfh[ii_ed e\j^[\WY_Wbd[hl[_d^[c_\WY_WbifWic$ 9khhJefIkh]H[i(0('-Å((& @Wdd[jjWF@"HWdZHM'/,- 7hj[h_WbYecfh[ii_ede\j^[jh_][c_dWbd[hl[ _dfWj_[djim_j^jh_][c_dWbd[khWb]_W$ @D[kheikh](,0'+/Å',+ @Wdd[jjWF@"7XXWioC"CWheed@9"[jWb'/-- ;j_ebe]oWdZZ[Ód_j_l[c_Yheikh]_YWbjh[Wjc[dj e\^[c_\WY_WbifWic$ @D[kheikh]*-0)('Å)(. @WYeXW[ki>9'/'' Akhp[{X[hi_Y^jX[hc[_d[;h\W^hkd][d c_jZ[hBWfWhej^ehWaeiaef_[$ CdY^C[ZMeY^[diY^h+-0(&'-Å(&'/ AWba>'/(/ ;h\W^hkd][dc_jZ[hBWfWheiaef_[$ PAb_dC[Z'''0)&)Å)*.
?d0OWiWh]_bC="C_Yheikh][ho07ffb_[Zjed[kheikh][ho$ J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj"ff'.&Å'/*
>[k[h=@'/)'
AWjedW<'/,) 7pW]oi[Xip[jjhjd[j[$ C[Z_Y_dW"8kZWf[ij
Ikh]_YWb[nf[h_[dY[im_j^Wd_djhWYhWd_WbWffheWY^je Y^_WicWbb[i_edi$ 7hY^Ikh]'0),.Å).'
J^[ikh]_YWbWffheWY^WdZj^[jh[Wjc[dje\jkcehiWdZ ej^[hb[i_ediWXekjj^[efj_YY^_Wic$ Ikh]=od[YebEXij[j+)0*./Å+'. >ehib[oL'./( 7dj_i[fj_YmWn$ 8hC[Z@'0'',+
(.*
>ehhWn='/)- ;nj_hfWj_ede\WbWh][f_d[WbecW\hecWfWj_[djm_j^ fkX[hjWifhW[Yen0Wd[mef[hWj_edWffheWY^$ 7hY^D[khebFioY^_Wjho)-0).+Å)/-
M_bb_WciM_ba_di"8Wbj_ceh[
Whl[o9ki^_d]$78_e]hWf^o$ 99J^ecWi"Ifh_d]Ó[bZ"?bb
=_]b_B'./. PkhJ[Y^d_aZ[hj[cfehh[dIY^Z[bh[i[aj_ed c_jc[_d[h:hW^ji][$ P[djhWbXb9^_h(+0*(+Å*(.
>eki[M<'/,* JhWdij[cfehWbXed[h[celWbc_Yheikh][ho e\WYekij_Yd[kh_decWi$ 7hY^EjebWhod]eb.&0+/-Å,&)
Ykhh[dj_dd[kheikh][ho$
>[k[h=@'/(&
=WhZd[hM@'/,( 9edY[hd_d]j^[c[Y^Wd_ice\jh_][c_dWb d[khWb]_WWdZ^[c_\WY_WbifWic$ @D[kheikh]'/0/*-
>eki[M<'/,' Ikh]_YWb[nfeikh[e\j^[_dj[hdWbWkZ_jehoYWdWbWdZ_ji Yedj[djij^hek]^j^[c_ZZb[YhWd_Wb\eiiW$ BWhod]eiYef[-'0'),)
FWhaH_Z]["?bb
'/') 7dWffheWY^jej^[^ofef^oi_ij^hek]^ j^[Wdj[h_ehYhWd_Wb\eiiW$ 7ddIkh]'0'*+Å'+&
=WhZd[hM@'/), 9[h[XhWbWd]_ecWiWdZWd[khoici$ Ikh]9b_dDehj^7c',0'&'/Å'&)&
>ekdi\_[bZ=D'/-) 9ecfkj[h_p[ZjhWdil[hi[Wn_WbiYWdd_d]jece]hWf^o0 FWhj'$:[iYh_fj_ede\ioij[c$ 8h@HWZ_eb*,0'&',Å'&((
>ehib[oL'/'* Dej[ed^[ceijWi_iXoWffb_YWj_ede\b_l_d]j_iik[$ 8hC[Z@(0.
A[cf[B='/,. Ef[hWj_l[d[kheikh][ho$ Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha AhWki[<'/&. 9^_hkh]_[Z[i=[^_hdikdZHYa[dcWhai dWY^[_][d[d;h\W^hkd][d"leb'$ KhXWdIY^mWhp[dX[h]"8[hb_d AhWki[<'/'' 9^_hkh]_[Z[i=[^_hdikdZHYa[dcWhai dWY^[_][d[d;h\W^hkd][d"leb($ KhXWdIY^mWhp[dX[h]"8[hb_d AhWo[dX^b>'/-' C_Yheikh]_YWbWffheWY^jeY[h[Xheif_dWbb[i_edi$ @H9ebbIkh];Z_dX',0).Å+'
>ehib[oL"9bWha[H>'/&. J^[ijhkYjkh[WdZ\kdYj_ede\j^[Y[h[X[bbkc[nWc_d[Z XoWd[mc[j^eZ$ 8hW_d)'0*+Å'(*
AhWo[dX^b>"H_Y^j[h>H'/+( :_[p[h[XhWb[7d]_e]hWf^_[$'$7kÔW][$ J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj
H[\[h[dY[i
AhWo[dX^b>"OWiWh]_bC='/+. :WiiWYa\hc_][7d[khoicWZ[h>_hdWhj[h_[d$ ?d0AhWo[dX^b>":Wi>_hdWd[khoicW$ :eYkc[djW=[_]o"I[h_[i9^_hkh]_YW"dh$*"=[_]o"8Wi[b" ff'&Å,+ AhWo[dX^b>"OWiWh]_bC='/,+ :_[p[h[XhWb[7d]_e]hWf^_[$($7kÔW][$ J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj Akhp[J'/,* C_Yhej[Y^d_gk[i_dd[khebe]_YWbikh][ho$ 9b_dD[kheikh]''0'(.Å')BWdZ_i;C'/)* 9Wf_bbWhofh[iikh[WdZYWf_bbWhof[hc[WX_b_jo$ F^oi_ebH[l'*0*&*Å*.'
Ced_p;'/(-
FWd@'./'
BÊ[dY[f^Wbe]hWf^_[Whjh_[bb["ied_cfehjWdY[ZWdibW
xf_b[fi_[fWhj_[bb[ZÊkdWd]_ec[_djhWYh~d_[dZ[i
beYWb_iWj_edZ[ijkc[khiYhXhWb[i$
c[d_d][i$JhfWdWj_ed"eXbWj_edZ[bWjkc[kh$
H[lD[kheb(0-(Å./
=kh_ied8kbb7YWZC[ZFWh_i'0..'Å..)
DW\\p_][h>9'/(+
F[d\_[bZM'/)+
7c[j^eZ\ehj^[beYWb_pWj_ede\XhW_djkcehiÅ
<eYWb[f_b[fj_YZ_iY^Wh][_dWYWi[e\jkcekhe\
j^[f_d[Wbi^_\j$
j^[feij[h_ehj[cfehWbh[]_ed$
Ikh]=od[YebEXij[j*&0*.'Å*.*
9WdC[Z7iieY@))0)(Å)+
Dehbd='/,,
F[d\_[bZM'/*/
9^_hkh]_iY^[8[^WdZbkd]_djhWahWd_[bb[h
D[kheikh][ho0o[ij[hZWo"jeZWoWdZjecehhem$
=[\c_X_bZkd][d$
@D[kheikh],0-Å.
?d0Eb_l[YhedW>"Jdd_iM[Zi>WdZXkY^Z[h D[kheY^_hkh]_["leb?L%($Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]
F[dZb='/.+
D[mOeha"ff'*,Å(''
F_d[WbWdZc_ZXhW_db[i_edi$ Ifh_d][h"M_[dD[mOeha
BWkj[hXkhF9'/-) ?cW][_d\ehcWj_edXo_dYbkZ[ZbeYWb_dj[hWYj_edi0 [nWcfb[i[cfbeo_d]dkYb[WhcW]d[j_Yh[iedWdY[$ DWjkh[(*(0'/&Å'/'
Dehbd="Eb_l[YhedW>'/+) J^[jh[Wjc[dje\Wd[khoicie\j^[Y_hYb[e\M_bb_i$
F_W>M'/-(
@D[kheikh]'&0*&*Å*'+
J^[c_YheiYef[_dd[kheikh][hoÅ j[Y^d_YWb_cfhel[c[dji$
EXWb_dia_7'./- B[_iY^d[h>'/&/ PkhY^_hkh]_iY^[d8[^WdZbkd]Z[h>_hdjkceh[d$ 7hY^Ab_d9^_h./0+*(Å+/+
PkhJ[Y^d_aZ[hIY^Z[bjh[fWdWj_ed$ P[djhWbXb9^_h(*0.+-Å.+/ Eb_l[YhedW>'/)*
B_]^jHK'//( 9ki^_d]Êi^WdZmh_j_d]WdZh[c[cX[h_d] >Whl[o9ki^_d]0j^[Ybei_d]o[Whi$ Ikh]D[kheb)-0'*-Å'+B_b`[gk_ij8'/+/ J^[ikXWhWY^de_ZY_ij[hdi$7dWdWjec_Y WdZhe[dj][debe]_YijkZo$ 7YjWHWZ_ebIjeYa^Ikffb'.+0'Å'&. B_jjcWdd>'/+* ;_dd[k[iEf[hWj_edic_aheiaef$ Ab_dCedWjiXb7k][d^[_baZ'(*0*-)Å*-CWb_iB?'/,- 8_febWhYeW]kbWj_ed_dc_Yheikh][ho$ ?d0:edW]^oHCF"OWiWh]_bC=[Zi C_Yhe#lWiYkbWhikh][ho$ J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj"ff'(,Å')& CWb_iB?'/-/ ?dijhkc[djWj_edWdZj[Y^d_gk[i _dc_Yhed[kheikh][ho$ 9b_dD[kheikh](,0,(,Å,), CWb_iB?'//, ;b[Yjheikh][ho$J[Y^d_YWbdej[$ @D[kheikh].+0/-&Å/-+ CWjied::"=[hcWdM@[Zi'/,/ >Whl[o9ki^_d]0i[b[Yj[ZfWf[hiedd[kheikh][ho$ OWb[Kd_l[hi_joFh[ii"D[m>Wl[d CY7hj^khBB'/'( 7dWi[fj_Yikh]_YWbWYY[iijej^[f_jk_jWhoXeZoWdZ_ji d[_]^Xekh^eeZ$ @7C7+.0(&&/Å(&''
:_[fWhWiW]_jjWb[dC[d_d][ec[$ J^_[c["B[_fp_] Eb_l[YhedW>'/)+ 8[h_Y^jX[hWhj[h_e]hWf^_iY^[:Whij[bbkd] Z[h7$l[hj[XhWb_i$ P[djhWbXb9^_h)(0'/&*Å'/&+ Eb_l[YhedW>"Boi^ebc;'/(- :_[Y^_hkh]_iY^[8[^WdZbkd]Z[h=[^_hdjkceh[d$ ;_d[ab_d_iY^[IjkZ_[$ Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d"ff'..Å'/( Eff[d^[_c>'./* B[^hXkY^Z[hD[hl[dahWda^[_j[d$ AWh][h"8[hb_d Eff[d^[_c>"AhWki[<'/')
7YjWD[kheY^_h(,0(+'Å(++ Feeb@B'/,' 7d[khoicie\j^[Wdj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d]Whj[ho$ 8_\hedjWbYhWd_ejecoWdZhekj_d[ki[e\j[cfehWhoYb_fi$ @D[kheikh]'.0/.Å'&' Feeb@B'/-( 8_\hedjWbYhWd_ejeco\ehWdj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d] Whj[hoWd[khoici$ @D[kheikh]),0('(Å((& Feeb@B"9ebjedHF'/,, J^[Z_ii[Yj_d]c_YheiYef[\eh_djhWYhWd_Wb lWiYkbWhikh][ho$ @D[kheikh](+0)'+Å)'. Feff[d@B'/,& 7dWjbWie\d[kheikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[i$ IWkdZ[hi"F^_bWZ[bf^_W"ff'+,Å'.' Feff[d@B'/,*
Ef[hWj_l[;h\eb][X[_=[iY^mbij[dZ[hI[^^][b
Ef[hWj_l[jh[Wjc[dj\ehWd[khoicie\
kdZL_[h^][b][][dZ$
j^[Wdj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d]Whj[ho$
8[hb_dAb_dMeY^[diY^h+&0()',Å()((
9b_dD[kheikh]''0.Å')
FWff[d^[_c7C'/'&
FhejjM'/-*
{X[hZ_[=[iY^mbij[Z[h9ehfehWf_d[Wb[$
9_ij[hdeiYefo#[dZeiYefoe\j^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[$
7hY^FWj^eb7dWj(&&0'((Å'*'
7YjWD[kheY^_h)'0'&+Å'')
FWha_died:'//+
Fkii[fF'/'*
;Whbo^_ijehoe\d[kheikh][ho_dCWd_jeXW0
:_[ef[hWj_l[;dj\[hdkd][_d[hPoij[
j^h[WZi_dj^[jWf[ijhoe\mehbZd[kheikh][ho$
Z[h=bWdZkbWf_d[Wb_i$
@D[kheikh].(0/&&Å/&,
D[khebP[djhWbXb))0+,&Å+,)
FWha_died:"CWYF^[hiedH7"9^_bZ[7;'/,-
FkjdWcJ@'/)*
Hekj_d[i_ckbjWd[ekiX_#fbWd[ij[h[eiYef_Yi[h_Wb
Jh[Wjc[dje\^oZheY[f^WbkiXo[dZeiYef_YYeW]kbWj_ede\
Wd]_e]hWf^o$
j^[Y^ehe_Zfb[nki$:[iYh_fj_ede\Wd[m_dijhkc[djWdZ
@9Wd7iieYHWZ_eb'.0)-'Å)-,
fh[b_c_dWhoh[fehje\h[ikbji$ D[m;d]b@C[Z('&0')-)Å')-,
C_nj[hM@'/() L[djh_YkbeiYefoWdZfkdYjkh[e\j^[Ôeeh e\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[$ 8eijedC[ZIkh]@'..0(--Å(-.
F|ipjeh;'//* J^[j^ehdoheWZjec_d_cWbbo_dlWi_l[j[Y^d_gk[i
HWdZHM'/,/
_dd[kheikh][ho$
C_Yhed[kheikh][ho$
C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh])-0,*Å,/
CeiXo"Ij$Bek_i
(.+
H[\[h[dY[i
HWdZHM"@Wdd[jjWF@'/,.
I[bZ_d][hI?'/+)
M[hd_Ya[9'..'
C_Yhed[kheikh][ho0Wffb_YWj_ede\j^[X_deYkbWhikh]_YWb
9Wj^[j[hh[fbWY[c[dje\j^[d[[Zb[_df[hYkjWd[eki
B[^hXkY^Z[h=[^_hdahWda^[_j[d$
c_YheiYef[_dXhW_djkcehi"_djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoici"
Whj[h_e]hWf^o0Wd[mj[Y^d_gk[$
J<_iY^[h"AWii[b
if_dWbYehZZ_i[Wi["WdZd[hl[h[YedijhkYj_ed$
7YjWHWZ_ebIjeYa^)/0),.Å)-,
9b_dD[kheikh]'+0)'/Å)*(
M_bb_iJ',,* Ij[_d8C'/-'
9[h[Xh_WdWjec_Wd[hlehkcgk[Z[iYh_fj_e[jkiki$
HWdZHM"Akhp[J'/,.
J^[_d\hWj[djeh_WbikfhWY[h[X[bbWhWffheWY^
Fh[i[hlWj_ede\l[ij_XkbWh"YeY^b[WhWdZ\WY_Wbd[hl[i
jef_d[Wbb[i_edi$
Zkh_d]c_Yheikh]_YWbh[celWbe\WYekij_Yjkcehi$H[fehj
@D[kheikh])+0'/-Å(&(
e\jmeYWi[i$
M_bied:>'/-' B_c_j[Z[nfeikh[_dY[h[XhWbikh][ho$J[Y^d_YWbdej[$
Ijeea[o8"IYWh\\@'/),
@D[kheikh](.0'+.Å','
@D[kheikh])*0'&(Å'&,
EYYbki_ede\j^[Wgk[ZkYje\Iobl_kiXod[efbWij_Y HWdZHM"B[cc[dB@'/+)
WdZded#d[efbWij_YfheY[ii[im_j^WhWj_edWbikh]_YWb
OWiWh]_bC='/,-
Jkcehie\j^[feij[h_ehfehj_ede\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[$
jh[Wjc[dj\ehh[b_[\e\j^[h[ikbjWdjeXijhkYj_l[
;nf[h_c[djWbicWbbl[ii[bikh][ho_dj^[Ze]_dYbkZ_d]
@D[kheikh]'&0'Å'.
^oZheY[f^Wbki$
fWj^_d]WdZ]hW\j_d]e\Y[h[XhWbl[ii[biWdZj^[
8kbbD[kheb?dijDO+0)*.Å)--
\ehcWj_ede\\kdYj_edWb[njhW#_djhWYhWd_Wbi^kdji$
H_d][hjpD"DehZ[dijWc>"
?d0:edW]^oHCF"OWiWh]_bC=[ZiC_Yhe#lWiYkbWh
Jkcehie\j^[f_d[Wbh[]_ed$
JWcW_I'//)
@D[khefWj^eb;nfD[kheb')0+*&Å+,'
>_ijehoe\c_Yheikh][hoÅ\hecj^[X[]_dd_d] kdj_bjej^[[dZe\j^['/-&Êi$
HeX_died@B'/-'
C_Yheikh][ho'*0,Å')
D[kheikh][hocW]d_Ó[Zj^hek]^j^[[o[ie\ j^[c_YheiYef[$
JWdZb[h@"HWdp_;'/(&
7EHD@'*0*&Å**
9^_hkh]_iY^[7dWjec_[kdZEf[hWj_edij[Y^d_a Z[iP[djhWbd[hl[dioij[ci$
HeX_died@B":Wl_[iD@'/-)
Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d
7d[mX_#febWhYeW]kbWjeh$ 8_ec[Z;d].0+',Å+'/
J^ehmWbZ@'/., ?cp[hXh[Y^b_Y^[d>WkiZ[hI[[b[$
Hdj][dMA'./+
:he[c[h#AdWkh"CdY^[d
{X[h[_d[d[k[7hjledIjhW^b[d$ I_jpkd]iX[hF^oiC[Z=[iMhpXkh]'./+0')(Å'*'
Jdd_iM'/), ;h\eb]h[_Y^[8[^WdZbkd][_d[i7d[khoicW
IYWh\\@;'/),
Z[h7hj$Yecckd$Wdj$Y[h[Xh_$
;dZeiYef_Yjh[Wjc[dje\^oZheY[f^Wbki0Z[iYh_fj_ede\
P[djhWbXbD[kheY^_h'0)/Å*(
l[djh_YkbeiYef[WdZfh[b_c_dWhoh[fehje\YWi[i$ 7hY^D[khebFioY^_Wjho)+0.+)Å.,'
Jdd_iM"MWbj[hM'/,& ;_dd[k[hef[hWj_l[hPk]Wd]pkZ[diWYa\hc_][d
IYWh\\@;'/+'
7d[khoic[dZ[hXWiWb[d>_hd][\[$
Jh[Wjc[dje\eXijhkYj_l[^oZheY[f^WbkiXofkdYjkh[e\
M_[dC[ZMeY^[diY^h''&0'*+Å'*-
j^[bWc_dWj[hc_dWb_iWdZÔeehe\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[$
ikh][ho$J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whjff.-Å'(, OWiWh]_bC='/,/ C_Yheikh][ho$7ffb_[ZjeD[kheikh][ho$ J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj OWiWh]_bC="<en@B'/-+ J^[c_Yheikh]_YWbWffheWY^je_djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoici$ Ikh]D[kheb)0-Å'* OWiWh]_bC="<en@B"HWoCM'/-+ J^[ef[hWj_l[WffheWY^jeWd[khoicie\j^[Wdj[h_eh Yecckd_YWj_d]Whj[ho$ 7ZlJ[Y^IjWdZD[kheikh]( OWiWh]_bC="AhWo[dX^b>'/-& J^[ki[e\j^[X_deYkbWhc_YheiYef[_dd[kheikh][ho$ 8_XbEf^j^Wbceb.'0,(Å,+ PWfb[jWb8'/+, ;_dd[k[hef[hWj_l[hPk]Wd]pkc=[X_[j Z[h?dY_ikhWj[djeh__$ P[djhWbXbD[kheY^_h',0,*Å,/
Jdd_iM"MWbj[hM"8heYaC'/,,
@D[kheikh].0(&*Å(')
:_[JejWb[nij_hfWj_ed_djhWp[h[XhWb[hWhj[h_el[di[h
PbY^A@'/+'
IYWh\\@;'/,,
7d]_ec[X[_BeaWb_iWj_ed_d\kdaj_ed[bbm_Y^j_][d
:_[>_hd][iY^mbij[$
J^_hZl[djh_YkbeijecoXofkdYjkh[e\j^[bWc_dW
>_hdWh[Wb[d$
@78Whj^"B[_fp_]
j[hc_dWb_iWdZÔeehe\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[$
8[_jhD[kheY^_h''0+Å,'
@D[kheikh](*0/)+Å/*) Jeha_bZi[d7'/)/ IYWh\\@;'/-&
7d[mfWbb_Wj_l[ef[hWj_ed_dYWi[ie\_def[hWXb[
J^[jh[Wjc[dje\dedeXijhkYj_l[Yecckd_YWj_d]
eYYbki_ede\Iobl_WdWgk[ZkYj$
^oZheY[f^WbkiXo[dZeiYef_YYWkj[h_pWj_ede\
7YjW9^_hIYWdZ.(0''-Å'()
C_Yhed[kheikh]_YWbWdWjeco" ef[hWj_l[WffheWY^[i 7b#C[\joE'/.-
j^[Y^ehe_Zfb[nki[i$ @D[kheikh]))0'Å'.
Jh[lWd_;'/)(
J^[ikfhWehX_jWb#fj[h_edWbWffheWY^jeiakbbXWi[b[i_edi$
;_dWbifWhWi[bbh[hJkcehef[h_[hj[i7d[khoicW
D[kheikh][ho('0*-*Å*--
IY^_bb[h<'//,
Z[h7hj[h_WYWhej_i_dj[hdW$
;WhboWffheWY^[ijeXhW_djkcehi$
:jiY^P9^_h()-0+)*Å+)+
7b#C[\joE"7dWdZLA'//& Po]ecWj_YWffheWY^jeiakbb#XWi[b[i_edi$
D[kheikh][ho).0'&()Å'&)& LWdMW][d[dMF'/)'
@D[kheikh]-)0,,.Å,-)
IY^be\\[h>'/&-
7ikh]_YWbWffheWY^\ehj^[h[celWbe\
;h\eb]h[_Y^[Ef[hWj_ed[_d[i>ofef^oi[djkcehi
Y[hjW_df_d[Wbjkcehi$
7b#C[\joE"<en@B'/.+
Wk\dWiWb[cM[][$
Ikh]=od[YebEXij[j+)0(',Å((&
Ikf[hebWj[hWbehX_jWb[nfeikh[WdZh[YedijhkYj_ed$ Ikh]D[kheb()0,&/Å,')
M_[dAb_dMeY^[hiY^h(&0,('Å,(* MW]d[hM'../ IYel_bb[M8"Eh[=:'/,&
:_[j[cfehh[H[i[aj_edZ[iIY^Z[bZWY^[i
7b#C[\joE"<en@B"Ic_j^HH'/..
BWh][jh[f^_d[YhWd_ejec_[i$
WdIj[bb[Z[hJh[fWdWj_ed$
F[jheiWbWffheWY^\ehf[jheYb_lWbc[d_d]_ecWi$
7YjWD[khebBWj_deWc,0*&&Å*&(
P[djhWbXb9^_h',0.))Å.).
D[kheikh][ho((0+'&Å+'-
(.,
H[\[h[dY[i
7cc_hWj_C"IfWbbed[@"CW@"[jWb'//) 7dWdWjec_Yeikh]_YWbijkZoe\j^[j[cfehWbXhWdY^e\ j^[\WY_Wbd[hl[$ D[kheikh][ho))0'&).Å'&** 7fkppeCB@'/.( JhWdiYWbbeiWb_dj[h\ehd_YWb[nfeikh[e\b[i_edi e\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[$ ?d0IY^c_Z[a>>"Im[[jM>[ZiEf[hWj_l[ D[kheikh]_YWbJ[Y^d_gk[i$=hkd[WdZIjhWjjed"D[mOeha" ff+.+Å+/* 8WbZm_d>P"C_bb[h9="LWdBel[h[d>H"[jWb'//* J^[\WhbWj[hWb%YecX_d[ZikfhW#WdZ _d\hWj[djeh_WbWffheWY^$ @D[kheikh].'0,&Å,. 9^[hWp_88'//( 7j[cfehWbjhWdiiobl_WdWffheWY^je Wdj[h_ehY_hYkbWj_edWd[khoici$ D[kheikh][ho)&0/+-Å/,' 9^e9M"7b#C[\joE(&&( 9ecX_d[Zf[jheiWbWffheWY^jef[jheYb_lWb c[d_d][ecWi$ D[kheikh][ho+'0-&.Å-'. 9eiYWh[bbW;"L_i^j[^7="If[jpb[hH<"[jWb(&&& IkX\WiY_WbWdZikXckiYkbWhc[j^eZie\j[cfehWbckiYb[ Z_ii[Yj_edWdZj^[_hh[bWj_edi^_fjej^[\hedjWbXhWdY^e\ j^[\WY_Wbd[hl[$J[Y^d_YWbdej[$ @D[kheikh]/(0.--Å..& 9ekbZm[bbMJ"
:[bWi^Wm@8"J[Z[iY^_>"H^ejed7B'//( CeZ_Ó[ZikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco0j[Y^d_YWbdej[$ D[kheikh][ho)&0/+*Å/+,
=_Xe>"9Whl[h99"H^ejed7B'/.' C_Yheikh]_YWbWdWjecoe\j^[c_ZZb[Y[h[XhWbWhj[ho$ @D[kheikh]+*0'+'Å',/
:[bWi^Wm@8"@Wd[@7"AWii[bbD<'//) IkfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejecoXo\hWYjkh[e\ j^[Wdj[h_ehehX_jWbhee\$ @D[kheikh]-/0,'+Å,'.
=_biXWY^@";]][hj>H">Wiib[hM9'/.+ Feii_X_b_j_[iWdZb_c_jie\j^[c_Zb_d[ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^$ 7YjWD[kheY^_hIkffb)+0.*Å..
:[b\_d_H"HWYe7"7hj_YeC'//( 7jme#ij[fikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^jeb[i_edi e\j^[ehX_jWbWf[n$ @D[kheikh]--0/+/Å/,'
=e[b7'//+ ;nj[dZ[Zc_ZZb[\eiiWWffheWY^\ehf[jheYb_lWbb[i_edi$ 7YjWD[kheY^_h')+0-.Å.)
:[IekpW@C"HeZh_]k[i<<":WI_blWCH" [jWb'/+/ 9hWd_e#ehX_jWbWffheWY^\ehj^[fWhWYb_de_ZWbWdZ Wdj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d]Wd[khoici$ 7hgD[khefi_gk_Wjh+)0+/(Å+/:_Jkbb_eCL"CWbaWi_Wd:"HWdZHM'/-. 7Yh_j_YWbYecfWh_iede\d[kheikh]_YWbWdZ ejebWhod]ebe]_YWbWffheWY^[ijeWYekij_Yd[khecWi @D[kheikh]*.0'Å'(
=edpWb[pB<"9hWm\ehZDH">eh]WdC7"[jWb(&&( Meha_d]Wh[WWdZWd]b[e\WjjWYa_dj^h[[YhWd_WbXWi[ WffheWY^[i0fj[h_edWb"ehX_jepo]ecWj_Y"WdZcWn_bbWho [nj[di_ede\j^[ehX_jepo]ecWj_YWffheWY^$ D[kheikh][ho+&0++&Å++=kffoA>"Eh_]_jWdeJ9"H[_Y^cWdE>"[jWb'//- L[dekiZhW_dW][e\j^[_d\[hebWj[hWbj[cfehWbbeX[_d h[bWj_edi^_fe\jhWdij[cfehWb%jhWdij[djeh_WbWffheWY^[i jej^[YhWd_WbXWi[$ D[kheikh][ho*'0,'+Å,(&
:eb[dYLL'/./ 7dWjecoWdZikh][hoe\j^[YWl[hdekii_dki$ Ifh_d][h"M_[dD[mOehaff,.Å--
>WakXW7"D_i^_ckhWI"?dek[O'/.+ JhWdif[jheiWb#jhWdij[djeh_WbWffheWY^WdZ_jiWffb_YWj_ed _dj^[j^[hWfoe\h[jheY^_WicWj_YYhWd_ef^Whod][ecWi$ Ikh]D[kheb(*0*&+Å*'+
:eb[dYLL'//- JhWdiYhWd_Wb[f_ZkhWbWffheWY^jef_jk_jWhojkcehi [nj[dZ_d]X[oedZj^[i[bbW$ D[kheikh][ho*'0+*(Å++(
>WakXW7"Bk_II"D_i^_ckhWI'/., J^[ehX_jepo]ecWj_Y_d\hWj[cfehWbWffheWY^0 Wd[mikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[$ Ikh]D[kheb(,0(-'Å(-,
:eb[dYLL"IahWfC"Ikij[hi_Y@"[jWb'/.- 7jhWdiYWl[hdeki#jhWdii[bbWhWffheWY^je j^[XWi_bWhj_fWd[khoici$ 8h@D[kheikh]'0(+'Å(+/
>WhZo:="F[WY[:7"H^ejed7B'/.& C_Yheikh]_YWbWdWjecoe\j^[ikf[h_ehY[h[X[bbWhWhj[ho$ D[kheikh][ho,0'&Å(.
:Wo@:"A[bbe]]@N"JiY^WX_jiY^[hC"[jWb$'//, Ikh\WY[WdZikf[hÓY_Wbikh]_YWbWdWjecoe\j^[ feij[hebWj[hWbYhWd_WbXWi[0i_]d_ÓYWdY[\ehikh]_YWb fbWdd_d]WdZWffheWY^$ D[kheikh][ho).0'&-/Å'&.*
:Wo@:"
=_WdejjWIB"CWY[h_:H'/.. H[jhebWXoh_dj^_d[jhWdii_]ce_ZWffheWY^jeXWi_bWhjhkda WdZl[hj[XheXWi_bWhWhj[ho`kdYj_edWd[khoici$ @D[kheikh],/0*,'Å*,,
>WhbWdZIF">kii[_d7"=kbbWdHM'//, CeZ_ÓYWj_ede\j^[ijWdZWhZfj[h_edWbWffheWY^\eh Wd[khoicie\j^[Wdj[h_ehY_hYb[e\M_bb_i$ 8h@D[kheikh]'&0'*/Å'+) >Whh_iWhi^=H"I[a^WhBD'//( J^[ikXj[cfehWb"jhWdiYWl[hdeki"Wdj[h_eh jhWdif[jheiWbWffheWY^jej^[kff[hXhW_dij[c WdZYb_lki$ @D[kheikh]--0-&/Å-'>[heiH9"B[[I>'//) J^[YecX_d[Zfj[h_edWb%Wdj[h_ehj[cfehWbWffheWY^\eh Wd[khoicie\j^[kff[hXWi_bWhYecfb[n0j[Y^d_YWbh[fehj$ D[kheikh][ho))0(**Å(+' >eY^X[h]@"AWk\cWd>"7hZ[d]^oC'//+ IWl_d]j^[\hedjWbXhWdY^Zkh_d]Wbem\hedje#ehX_jWb WffheWY^$ 7[ij^[j_YFbWijIkh]'/0','Å',) ?jeP'/.( J^[c_Yheikh]_YWbWdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^ ik_jWXboWffb_[Zjehkfjkh[ZWd[khoicie\j^[Wdj[h_eh Yecckd_YWj_d]Whj[ho_dj^[WYkj[ijW][$ 7YjWD[kheY^_h,)0.+Å//
(.-
H[\[h[dY[i
@Wbbe=?"8[d`Wc_dL(&&(
Aef[hdWJ"JiY^WX_jiY^[hC"Adeif;'//(
JkX[hYkbkci[bbW[c[d_d]_ecWi0c_Yheikh]_YWbWdWjeco
J^[j[hc_dWj_ede\j^[l[_de\BWXXWdZ_jic_Yheikh]_YWb
WdZikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[$
i_]d_ÓYWdY[$
D[kheikh][ho+'0'*)(Å'*)/
7YjWD[kheY^_h''.0'-(Å'-+
@Wd[@7"FWhaJI"FeX[h[ia_dB>"[jWb'/.(
Ah_i^j7"8Whd[jj:M"8Whhem:B'//*
J^[ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^0j[Y^d_YWbdej[$
J^[XbeeZikffboe\j^[_djhWYWl[hdekiYhWd_Wbd[hl[i0
D[kheikh][ho''0+)-Å+*(
WdWdWjec_YWbijkZo$ D[kheikh][ho)*0(-+Å(-/
@^e>:'//- EhX_jWbhee\YhWd_ejecol_WWd[o[Xhem_dY_i_ed0
BWd]@'/.'
Wi_cfb_Ó[ZWdj[h_ehiakbbXWi[WffheWY^$
Ab_d_iY^[7dWjec_[Z[iAef\[i0D[kheahWd_kc"EhX_jW"
C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh]*&0/'Å/-
ahWd_ep[hl_aWb[h{X[h]Wd]$ Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha
AWhjki^@"J[b_WdI"=hW^WcC"[jWb'/., 7dWjec_YXWi_i\ehbWXoh_dj^_d[fh[i[hlWj_edZkh_d]
BWi`Wkd_WiF"8[h[dij[_d7'/.-
feij[h_eh\eiiWWYekij_Yjkcehikh][ho$
7hj[h_WbWdWjeco0_djheZkYj_ed$
BWhod]eiYef[/,0'&(*Å'&(.
?d0BWi`Wkd_WiF"8[h[dij[_d7[ZiIkh]_YWb d[kheWd]_e]hWf^o"leb'0
AWmWaWc_A"OWcWdekY^_O"AWmWckhWO'//'
YhWd_e\WY_WbWhj[h_[i$
Ef[hWj_l[WffheWY^jej^[\hedjWbiakbbXWi[0[nj[di_l[
Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha"ff'Å)(
jhWdiXWiWbWffheWY^$ D[kheikh][ho(.0-(&Å-(+
BWi`Wkd_WiF"8[h[dij[_d7'/.-
AWmWaWc_A"OWcWdekY^_O"AkXejW9'//' 7d[nj[di_l[jhWdiXWiWbWffheWY^je\hedjWbiakbb#XWi[ jkcehi$J[Y^d_YWbdej[$
J^[_dj[hdWbcWn_bbWhoioij[c$ ?d0BWi`Wkd_WiF"8[h[dij[_d7[ZiIkh]_YWb d[kheWd]_e]hWf^o"leb'0
@D[kheikh]-*0'&''Å'&')
Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha"ff))Å'((
AWmWi[J"I^_eXWhWH"JeoWI'//' 7dj[h_ehjhWdif[jheiWb#jhWdij[djeh_WbWffheWY^\eh if^[def[jheYb_lWbc[d_d]_ecWi0ikh]_YWbc[j^eZWdZ h[ikbji_d'&fWj_[dji$
BWi`Wkd_WiF"8[h[dij[_d7'//& J^[feij[h_ehZ_l_i_ede\j^[_dj[hdWbYWhej_ZWhj[ho?97$ ?d0BWi`Wkd_WiF"8[h[dij[_d7[ZiIkh]_YWb d[kheWd]_e]hWf^o"leb)0
D[kheikh][ho(.0.,/Å.-,
CW_hW="7d_b[9"9ebei_cW9"[jWb(&&& 9hWd_ef^Whod]_ecWie\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[0 jhWdi#bWc_dWj[hc_dWb_iWffheWY^$ D[kheikh][ho*-0.+-Å.,) CWo\hWdaB"=_biXWY^@C'//, ?dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^\ehc_Yheikh]_YWbh[celWbe\ eb\WYjeho]heel[c[d_d]_ecWi$ 8h@D[kheikh]'&0+*'Å+*+ CWo\hWdaB"H[kb@">k\\cWdd8"[jWb'//, C_Yheikh]_YWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^jeZkhWb Whj[h_el[dekiÓijkbWie\j^[Ôeehe\j^[ Wdj[h_ehYhWd_Wb\eiiW$ C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh])/0-*Å-C[deliaoJ"=hej[d^k_i7"Z[Lh_[i@"[jWb'/// ;dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[ZikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco\ehb[i_edie\ j^[_dj[hf[ZkdYkbWh\eiiW$ D[kheikh][ho**0'&,Å''( C_Ya[o8"9bei[B"IY^W[\[hI'/.. 7YecX_d[Z\hedjej[cfehWbWdZbWj[hWb_d\hWj[cfehWb \eiiWWffheWY^jej^[iakbbXWi[$ @D[kheikh],.0,-.Å,.) C_b[dael_YP"=ef_Y>"7djel_YF"[jWb'/.( 9edjhWbWj[hWbfj[h_edWbWffheWY^jeYWhej_Z#ef^j^Wbc_Y Wd[khoichkfjkh[ZWjikh][ho$9Wi[h[fehj$ @D[kheikh]+-0.()Å.(+ C_pe_A"Ikpka_@"A_d`eJ"[jWb'/.. 8_\hedjWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^\ehYWhej_Z# ef^j^Wbc_YWd[khoici$ 7YjWD[kheikh]/&0.*Å/&
e\j^[XhW_d"if_dWbYehZWdZif_d[$Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d
AWmWi[J"I^_eXWhWH"JeoWI'//* C_ZZb[\eiiWjhWdif[jheiWb#jhWdij[djeh_WbWffheWY^[i\eh f[jheYb_lWbc[d_d]_ecWi$I[b[Yj_l[fohWc_Zh[i[Yj_edWdZ hWZ_YWb_jo$
>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha"ff'+)Å'/( BWlod[C>"FWjj[hiedH>@h'/.) IkXY^ehe_ZWbjhWdi#l[bkc_dj[hfei_jkcWffheWY^jec_Z# j^_hZl[djh_YkbWhjkcehi$
7YjWD[kheY^_h'(/0'')Å'(&
D[kheikh][ho'(0.,Å/*
A_akY^_A"MWjWdWX[A'//) CeZ_Ó[ZX_\hedjWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^je Wd[khoicie\j^[Wdj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d]Whj[hom_j^ j^[ki[e\jh[f^_d[YhWd_ejeco0Wh[l_[me\f[hiedWb
BWmjedCJ":Wif_j9F"If[jpb[hH<'//- Fh[i_]ce_ZWffheWY^[ijeiakbbXWi[b[i_edi$ 7ZlJ[Y^IjWdZD[kheikh]()0'./Å(&*
[nf[h_[dY[m_j^(+YWi[i$ B_bb`[gk_ij8'/+/
7YjWD[kheY^_h'(+0'(-Å')'
J^[ikXWhWY^de_ZY_ij[hdi$7dWdWjec_YWdZ Ad_p[:C'//,
he[dj][debe]_YijkZo$
B_c_j[Z#_dY_i_ed\eh[^[WZb_\j\eh[o[Xhem[b[lWj_edje
7YjWHWZ_eb'.+0'Å'&.
[d^WdY[kff[hXb[f^WhefbWijo$ FbWijH[YedijhIkh]/-0'))*Å')*(
B_ij[h@H"H^ejed7B@h"CWjiki^_cWJ"[jWb'/.( C_Yheikh]_YWbWdWjecoe\j^[
Adeif;"Cbb[h="F[hd[Ypao7'/..
feij[h_eh_d\[h_ehY[h[X[bbWhWhj[ho$
J^[fWhWYb_de_ZYWhej_ZWhj[ho0WdWjec_YWbWif[Yjie\W
D[kheikh][ho'&0'-&Å'//
c_Yhed[kheikh]_YWbWffheWY^$ BodY^@9"7dZhWZ[H'//)
D[kheikh][ho((0./,Å/&'
Kd_bWj[hWbfj[h_edWbWffheWY^jeX_bWj[hWb Adeif;"F[hd[Ypao7"AeeiMJ"[jWb'//,
Y[h[XhWbWd[khoici$
C[d_d][ecWie\j^[ifWY[e\j^[YWl[hdekii_dki$
Ikh]D[kheb)/0'(&Å'(-
D[kheikh][ho).0*)*Å***
Ckiie79"H^ejed7B@h(&&& J[bel[bWhWffheWY^jej^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[0 c_Yheikh]_YWbWdWjeco$ @D[kheikh]/(0.'(Å.() DWaWeI"A_akY^_>"JWaW^i^_D'/.' IkYY[ii\kbYb_ff_d]e\YWhej_Z#ef^j^Wbc_YWd[khoici j^hek]^WYedjhWbWj[hWbfj[h_edWbWffheWY^$ H[fehje\jmeYWi[i$ @D[kheikh]+*0+)(Å+), D_[km[d^koiH"Lee]Z@"lWd>k_p[d9'//. :WiP[djhWbd[hl[dioij[cZ[iC[diY^[d$ Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha E]WjWD"Oed[aWmWO'//- FWhWc[Z_WdikfhWY[h[X[bbWhWffheWY^jej^[kff[hXhW_d ij[cWdZf[ZkdYkbWhb[i_edi$ D[kheikh][ho*&0'&'Å'&+ E_aWmWI"Aoei^_cWA"AeXWoWi^_I'//. Ikh]_YWbWdWjecoe\j^[`knjW#ZkhWbh_d]Wh[W$ @D[kheikh]./0(+&Å(+* EdeC"H^ejed7B'/.* C_Yheikh]_YWbWdWjecoe\j^[h[]_ede\j^[j[djeh_Wb _dY_ikhW$ @D[kheikh],&0),+Å)//
CWY:edWbZ@:"7djed[bb_F":Wo7B'//. AeZWcWD"IWiWa_J"IWakhW_O'//+
J^[Wdj[h_ehikXj[cfehWb"c[Z_WbjhWdif[jheiWbWffheWY^
JhWdij^_hZl[djh_YkbWhWffheWY^\ehW^_]^XWi_bWh
jej^[kff[hXWi_bWhWhj[hoWdZ
X_\khYWj_edWd[khoic$H[fehje\j^h[[YWi[i$
fedje#c[i[dY[f^Wb_Y`kdYj_ed$
@D[kheikh].(0,,*Å,,.
D[kheikh][ho*)0.*Å./
(..
Ei^_he;C"H_d_:7"JWcWh]eH@'//- 9edjhWbWj[hWbWffheWY^[ijeX_bWj[hWbY[h[XhWbWd[khoici0 7c_Yheikh]_YWbWdWjec_YWbijkZo$ @D[kheikh].-0',)Å',/
H[\[h[dY[i
FWbWZ_de@"F_ha[hD"Ij_cWY9"Ij[hd#FWZelWdH'//. ;o[Xhema[o#^eb[WffheWY^_dlWiYkbWhd[kheikh][ho$ C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh]*'0(&&Å(&) FWha_died:'/,+ 7ikh]_YWbWffheWY^jej^[YWl[hdekifehj_ede\j^[ YWhej_ZWhj[ho$7dWjec_YWbijkZ_[iWdZYWi[h[fehj$ @D[kheikh]()0*-*Å*.) F[hd[Ypao7"Adeif;"Pe^bk7'//' Ikh][hoe\lWiYkbWhb[i_edi_dj^[YWl[hdekii_dki$ ?d0IWc__C[ZIkh][hoe\j^[i[bbWhh[]_edWdZfWhWdWiWb i_dkii[i$Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha" ff*/*Å+&' F[hdaef\;'/,& Jefe]hWf^_iY^[7dWjec_[Z[iC[diY^[d$ KhXWdIY^mWhp[dX[h]"CdY^[d F[jhkYY_H@"8kY^^[_jM7"MeeZhk\\=9"[jWb'/.- JhWdiYWbbeiWbfWhW\ehd_Y_WbWffheWY^jej^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[ jkcehi0d[khefioY^ebe]_YWbYedi[gk[dY[i$ D[kheikh][ho(&0*+-Å*,* Feeb@B'/-( 8_\hedjWbYhWd_ejeco\ehWdj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d]Whj[ho Wd[khoici$ @D[kheikh]),0('(Å((& Fkpp_bb_<"Hk]][h_7"CWijhedWhZ_B"[jWb'/// 7dj[h_ehYb_de_ZWbc[d_d]_ecWi0h[fehje\Wi[h_[ie\)) fWj_[djief[hWj[Zedj^hek]^j^[fj[h_edWbWffheWY^$ D[khe#edYeb'0'..Å'/+ HWcei#Pkd_]WH'/// J^[jhWdi#ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^$ C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh]*(0'))Å'), HWcei#Pkd_]WH"L[b|pgk[p>"8WhW`WiC"[jWb(&&( JhWdi#ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^jeikfhWj[djeh_Wb Wd[khoici$ D[kheikh][ho+'0'(+Å')' HWl[^@"Lk_bb[c_dJ'//& J^[ikXYhWd_Wb#ikfhWehX_jWbj[cfehWbWffheWY^\ehjkceh h[i[Yj_ed$ @9hWd_e\WYIkh]'0+)Å+/ H[_iY^H"Lkjia_jiB"FWjedWoB"[jWb'//, J^[c[d_d]e^ofef^oi[WbjhkdaWdZ_jiXbeeZikffboje Z_\\[h[dj_djhWYhWd_WbijhkYjkh[i$7dWdWjec_YWbijkZo$ C_d_c?dlWiD[kheikh])/0-.Å.' H[_iY^H"Lkjia_jiB"<_b_ff_H"[jWb(&&( Jefe]hWf^_Yc_Yheikh]_YWbWdWjecoe\j^[fWhWYb_de_Z YWhej_ZWhj[ho$ D[kheikh]H[l(+0'--Å'.) H[_iY^H"F[hd[Yao7"<_b_ff_H(&&) Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[e\j^[ikfhWehX_jWba[o^eb[WffheWY^$ Ikh]D[kheb+/0(()Å((H[iY^A:C"F[hd[Ypao7"JiY^WX_jiY^[hC"[jWb'//* ;dZeiYef_YWdWjecoe\j^[l[djh_Yb[i$ 7YjWD[kheY^_hIkffb,'0+-Å,' H^ejed7B"IW[a_D"F[hbckjj[h:"[jWb$'/-/ C_Yheikh]_YWbWdWjecoe\YeccedWd[khoici_j[i$ 9b_dD[kheikh](,0(*.Å)&,
H^ejed7B'/.( C_Yhe#ef[hWj_l[j[Y^d_gk[i$ ?d0OekcWdi@H[ZD[khebe]_YWbikh][ho"leb'"(dZ[Zd$ IWkdZ[hi"F^_bWZ[bf^_W"ff'',&Å''/*
I^Wdde="CWkiC"8_boa@(&&' ?cW][#]k_Z[ZjhWdiehX_jWbhee\YhWd_ejecol_WW ikfhWXhemWffheWY^0Wikh]_YWbi[h_[ie\-(fWj_[dji$ D[kheikh][ho*.0++/Å+,-
H^ejed7B(&&) 9hWd_WbWdWjecoWdZikh]_YWbWffheWY^[i$ B_ff_dYejjM_bb_WciM_ba_di">W][hijemd
I^_XkoWC"Ikpka_C"Ik]_jWIA'//, 8_\hedjWbXWiWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^je YhWd_ef^Whod][ecWh[i[Yj_edm_j^ehm_j^ekjZ_l_i_ed e\j^[Wdj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d]Whj[ho$ @D[kheikh].*0/+'Å/+,
Heid[hII"H^ejed7B"EdeC"[jWb'/.* C_Yheikh]_YWbWdWjecoe\j^[Wdj[h_ehf[h\ehWj_d] Whj[h_[i$ @D[kheikh],'0*,.Å*.+ IWbWced=">kWd]OF'/-, HWZ_ebe]_YWdWjecoe\j^[XhW_d$ Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha IWbWi;"P_oWb?C"8[``Wd_=A"[jWb'//. 7dWjecoe\j^[\hedjej[cfehWbXhWdY^e\j^[\WY_Wbd[hl[ WdZ_dZ_YWj_edi\eh_dj[h\WiY_WbZ_ii[Yj_ed$ D[kheikh][ho*)0+,)Å+,/ IWbWi;"I[a^WhBD"P_oWb?C"[jWb'/// LWh_Wj_edie\j^[[njh[c[#bWj[hWbYhWd_eY[hl_YWbWffheWY^0 WdWjec_YWbijkZoWdZYb_d_YWbWdWboi_ie\,/fWj_[dji$ @D[kheikh]If_d[/&0(&,Å('/ IWc__C"7cc_hWj_C'//. J^[YecX_d[ZikfhW#_d\hWj[djeh_Wbfh[#i_]ce_Zi_dki Wl[dk[jej^[f[jhe#Yb_lWbh[]_ed$Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[WdZ Yb_d_YWbWffb_YWj_edi$ 7YjWD[kheY^_h/+0,Å'( I[[][hM'/.& C_Yheikh][hoe\j^[XhW_d0WdWjec_YWbWdZj[Y^d_YWb fh_dY_fb[i"(lebi$ Ifh_d][h"M_[dD[mOeha I[_\[hjL"Ijeba[:'//, Feij[h_ehjhWdif[jheiWbWffheWY^jeWd[khoicie\j^[ XWi_bWhjhkdaWdZl[hj[XheXWi_bWh`kdYj_ed$ @D[kheikh].+0)-)Å)-/ I[a^WhBD";ijed_bbeH'/., JhWdij[cfehWbWffheWY^jej^[iakbbXWi[$ 7dWdWjec_YWbijkZo$ D[kheikh][ho'/0-//Å.&. I[a^WhBD"IY^hWccLB"@ed[iD<'/.- IkXj[cfehWb#fh[Wkh_YkbWh_d\hWj[cfehWb\eiiWWffheWY^ jebWh][bWj[hWbWdZfeij[h_ehYhWd_WbXWi[d[efbWici$ @D[kheikh],-0*..Å*// I[a^WhBD"DWdZW7"I[d9D'//( J^[[nj[dZ[Z\hedjWbWffheWY^jejkcehie\j^[Wdj[h_eh" c_ZZb["WdZfeij[h_ehiakbbXWi[$ @D[kheikh]-,0'/.Å(&,
I^_hWd[H"9^_d]#9^WdI"AkiWaWO(&&( Ikh]_YWbekjYec[i_d)'fWj_[djim_j^ YhWd_ef^Whod]_ecWi[nj[dZ_d]ekji_Z[j^[ ikfhWi[bbWhY_ij[hd0Wd[lWbkWj_ede\\hedjeXWiWb _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^$ @D[kheikh]/,0-&*Å-'( If[jpb[hH<":Wif_j9F"FWffWi9J;'//( J^[YecX_d[ZikfhW#WdZ_d\hWj[djeh_WbWffheWY^ \ehb[i_edie\j^[f[jhekiWdZYb_lWbh[]_edi0 [nf[h_[dY[m_j^*,YWi[i$ @D[kheikh]-,0+..Å+// Ij[_][h>@"IY^c_Z#;biW[ii[hH"Ijkcc[hM"[jWb(&&' JhWdiehX_jWba[o#^eb[WffheWY^jeWdj[h_eh Yecckd_YWj_d]Whj[hoWd[khoici$ D[kheikh][ho*.0)*-Å)+( Ikpka_@"C_de_A"Oei^_cejeJ'/., 8_\hedjWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^jeWd[khoicie\j^[ Wdj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d]Whj[ho$ @D[kheikh],*0'.)Å'/& JW]kY^_O"JWdWaWA"CWjikpWmWC"[jWb'//, 7ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[jeWle_Zfeijef[hWj_l[ [def^j^Wbcei_dj^[YhWd_eehX_jWbWffheWY^$ J[Y^d_YWbdej[$ @D[kheikh].+0+'*Å+'JWd_]kY^_C"F[hd[Ypao7'//- IkXj[cfehWba[o^eb[WffheWY^jej^[ikfhWi[bbWhWdZ f[jheYb_lWbh[]_ed0c_YheWdWjec_YYedi_Z[hWj_ediWdZ Yb_d_YWbWffb_YWj_ed$ D[kheikh][ho*'0+/(Å,&' JWjW]_XWC"IWc__C"CWjj^[_i9"[jWb'//( J^[i_]d_ÓYWdY[\ehfeijef[hWj_l[^[Wh_d]e\fh[i[hl_d] j^[bWXoh_dj^_dWYekij_Yd[kh_decWikh][ho$ @D[kheikh]--0,--Å,.* Jh[K"OWiWh]_bC="7b#C[\joE'//- J^[jhWdiYWbbeiWb#jhWdi\ehWc_dWbWffheWY^je j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[m_j^h[]WhZjej^[l[dekilWh_Wj_edi _dj^_ih[]_ed$ @D[kheikh].-0-&,Å-'+
I[a^WhBD"AWb_WAA"OedWi>"[jWb'//* 9hWd_WbXWi[WffheWY^je_djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoici_dj^[ ikXWhWY^de_ZifWY[$ D[kheikh][ho)+0*-(Å*.)
Kd][hiXYaA"F[hd[Ypao7'/., ?djhWl[djh_YkbWhWd[khoice\j^[c[Z_Wbfeij[h_eh Y^ehe_ZWhj[hoYb_ff[Zl_Wj^[YedjhWbWj[hWbjhWdiYWbbeiWb WffheWY^$ 7YjWD[kheY^_h.(0(*Å(-
I[f[hd_W7"AdeffK'/// Fh[i[hlWj_ede\j^[eb\WYjehojhWYj_dX_\hedjWbYhWd_ejeco \ehlWh_ekib[i_edie\j^[Wdj[h_ehYhWd_Wb\eiiW$ D[kheikh][ho**0'')Å''-
LW`ZW@"@k^|ip@"F|ipjeh;"[jWb'/.. 9edjhWbWj[hWbWffheWY^jeX_bWj[hWbWdZef^j^Wbc_Y Wd[khoici$ D[kheikh][ho((0,,(Å,,.
(./
H[\[h[dY[i
LWdZ[h7ha=:"A[cf[B="Ic_j^:H'/-*
O[^>"J[m@C'/.+
7dj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d]Wd[khoici0
7dj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^jeWd[khoicie\
j^[]ohkih[YjkiWffheWY^$
j^[Wdj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d]Whj[ho$
9b_dD[kheikh]('0'(&Å'))
Ikh]D[kheb()0/.Å'&&
LWdB_dZ[hj;"F[hd[Ypao7"
PWXhWcia_@C"A_h_iJ"IWda^bWIA"[jWb'//.
J^[ikfhWehX_jWba[o^eb[WffheWY^jeikfhWj[djeh_Wb
EhX_jepo]ecWj_YYhWd_ejeco$J[Y^d_YWbdej[$
Wd[khoici$9edY[fjWdZj[Y^d_gk[$
@D[kheikh]./0)),Å)*'
Ikh]D[kheb*/0*.'Å*/& LWdBel[h[d>H"A[bb[h@J";b#AWbb_doC"[jWb'//' J^[:eb[dYj[Y^d_gk[\ehYWl[hdekii_dki[nfbehWj_ed$ 9WZWl[h_Yfhei[Yj_ed$ @D[kheikh]-*0.)-Å.**
?cW]_d]j[Y^d_gk[iWdZ ikh]_YWbfbWdd_d]
8hWdj#PWmWjpa_C"IebecedC"D[mjedJ>"[jWb'/.+ 8Wi_Yfh_dY_fb[ie\cW]d[j_Yh[iedWdY[_cW]_d]_d Y[h[XhWb_iY^[c_WWdZ_d_j_WbYb_d_YWb[nf[h_[dY[$ D[khehWZ_ebe]o(-0+'-Å+(& 8hWiY^H9'/.) Meha_dfhe]h[ii0c[j^eZie\YedjhWij[d^WdY[c[dj\eh DCH_cW]_d]WdZfej[dj_WbWffb_YWj_edi$ HWZ_ebe]o'*-0-.'Å-.. 8hWii_[h="CehWdZ_N"C[hY_[hF"[jWb'//* J^[feij[h_ehfWhje\j^[Whj[h_WbY_hYb[e\j^[iakbbXWi[$ 9WkZWbZ_l_i_ede\j^[[cXhoed_Y_dj[hdWbYWhej_ZWhj[ho$ H_lD[khehWZ_eb-0.+Å./
7bX[h_YeH7"FWj[bC"9Wi[oI"[jWb'//+
L_i^j[^7=":Wl_Z97"CWhY_Wde<<"[jWb(&&& ;njh[c[bWj[hWbikfhWY[h[X[bbWh_d\hWj[djeh_WbWffheWY^ jej^[feij[hebWj[hWbc[i[dY[f^Wbed0 j[Y^d_gk[WdZYb_d_YWb[nf[h_[dY[$ D[kheikh][ho*,0).*Å)./
;lWbkWj_ede\j^[Y_hYb[e\M_bb_im_j^j^h[[#Z_c[di_edWb 9JWd]_e]hWf^o_dfWj_[djim_j^ikif[Yj[Z_djhWYhWd_Wb Wd[khoici$ 7@DH',0'+-'Å'+-. 7dZ[hied=8"<_dZbWo@C"Ij[_da[:;"[jWb'//-
Lkjia_jiB"H[_iY^H"FWjedWoB"[jWb'//, J^[h[j[c_hWX_b[e\j^[Yb_lkiWdZZehikci[bbW[$ C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh])/0').Å'*& MWaW_I'//' IkX\hedjWb#XWiWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^\ehWdj[h_eh Yecckd_YWj_d]Whj[hoWd[khoici$J[Y^d_YWbdej[$ 7YjWD[kheY^_h'&.0-.Å.&
;nf[h_[dY[m_j^Yecfkj[Zjece]hWf^_YWd]_e]hWf^o\eh j^[Z[j[Yj_ede\_djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoici_dj^[i[jj_d]e\ WYkj[ikXWhWY^de_Z^[cehh^W][$ D[kheikh][ho*'0+((Å+(. 7fkppeCB@'//, D[mZ_c[di_edie\d[kheikh][ho_dj^[h[Wbce\^_]^
C_Yheikh]_YWbWdWjecoe\j^[jhWdiYedZobWh" ikfhWYedZobWh"WdZfWhWYedZobWh[nj[di_edie\ j^[\Wh#bWj[hWbWffheWY^$
7k[hBC"7k[h:F'//. L_hjkWb[dZeiYefo\ehfbWdd_d]WdZi_ckbWj_ede\
M[d>J"H^ejed7B"Z[Eb_l[_hW;'//.
7jbWiI[Z'//, CW]d[j_Yh[iedWdY[_cW]_d]e\j^[XhW_dWdZif_d["
JhWdiY^ehe_ZWbWffheWY^jej^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[0
(dZ[Zd$
WdWdWjec_YijkZoe\j^[Y^ehe_ZWbÓiikh[WdZ_ji
HWl[d"D[mOeha
Yb_d_YWbWffb_YWj_ed$ D[kheikh][ho*(0'(&+Å'('/
8Wjd_jpaoI"Fh_Y[>?"B[[AH"[jWb'/.( J^h[[#Z_c[di_edWbYecfkj[hh[YedijhkYj_edie\XhW_d
OWcWceje?"H^ejed7B"F[WY[:7"[jWb'/.'
b[i_edi\hecikh\WY[Yedjekhifhel_Z[ZXoYecfkj[Z
C_Yheikh][hoe\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[0
jece]hWf^o0Wfheif[Yjki$
FWhj'$C_Yheikh]_YWbWdWjeco$
D[kheikh][ho''0-)Å.*
D[kheikh][ho.0))*Å)+, 8[hdWhZe7"Fh[kbC9"PWXhWcia_@C"[jWb(&&) OWiWh]_bC="AWiZW]b_IA"@W_dAA"[jWb'/-,
7j^h[[#Z_c[di_edWb_dj[hWYj_l[l_hjkWbZ_ii[Yj_edceZ[b
7dWjec_YWbeXi[hlWj_ede\j^[ikXWhWY^de_ZWbY_ij[hdi
jei_ckbWj[jhWdif[jhekiikh]_YWbWl[dk[i$
e\j^[XhW_dZkh_d]ikh][ho$
D[kheikh][ho+(0*//Å+&+
@D[kheikh]**0(/.Å)&( 8edjepe]bekD"IfWdei>"BWi`Wkd_WiF"[jWb'//* OWiWh]_bC="7dj_Y@"BWY_]WH"[jWb'/-,
J^h[[#Z_c[di_edWbZ_ifbWoe\j^[eh_ÓY[e\_djhWYhWd_Wb
C_Yheikh]_YWbfj[h_edWbWffheWY^jeWd[khoici
Wd[khoici0Wd[mfej[dj_WbWffb_YWj_ed\ehcW]d[j_Y
e\j^[XWi_bWhX_\khYWj_ed$
h[iedWdY[Wd]_e]hWf^o$
Ikh]D[kheb,0.)Å/'
D[khehWZ_ebe]o),0)),Å)*/
OWiWh]_bC="Ic_j^H:"=Wii[h@9'/--
8eehI"H[iY^A:C"F[hd[Ypao7"[jWb'//.
C_Yheikh]_YWbWffheWY^jeWYekij_Yd[kh_decWi
L_hjkWb[dZeiYefoL;e\j^[XWiWbY_ij[hdi0
7ZlJ[Y^IjWdZD[kheikh]*0/*Å'(/
?jilWbk[_dfbWdd_d]j^[d[kheikh]_YWbWffheWY^$ C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh]*'0'--Å'.(
OWik_D"DWj^Wb;"'//( J^[XWiWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^\ehWYkj[Wdj[h_eh
8hWZb[oM="MWbkY^L'/.*
Yecckd_YWj_d]Wd[khoici$
CH[l[d[Y^eh[f^Wi_d]_dibembWc_dWhÔemm_j^CH?$
7YjWD[kheY^_h''.0/'Å/-
@9ecfkj7ii_ijJece]h.0+/*Å+/.
(/&
9Whh:>"8hemd@"B[kd]M#B"[jWb'/.* ?hedWdZ]WZeb_d_kcY^[bWj[iWiYedjhWijW][dji_dDCH _cW]_d]0fh[b_c_dWhoijkZ_[i$ @9ecfkj7ii_ijJece]h.0).+Å)./ 9^Wb_\:@":k\h[di[9H"HWdie^e\\@"[jWb'/.. J^h[[#Z_c[di_edWbYecfkj[Zjece]hWf^_Y h[YedijhkYj_edie\_djhWYhWd_Wbc[d_d]_ecWi$ D[kheikh][ho()0+-&Å+-+
c_d_cWbbo_dlWi_l[d[kheikh][ho$ D[kheikh][ho*)0+(/Å+*.
@D[kheikh].-0+++Å+.+
8hemdH7'/-/ 7Yecfkj[h_p[Zjece]hWf^oÅYecfkj[h]hWf^_Yi WffheWY^jeij[h[ejWYj_YbeYWb_pWj_ed$ @D[kheikh]+&0-'+Å-(&
j[Y^debe]o0feii_X_b_j_[i"fhWYj_YWb_j_[i"h[Wb_j_[i$ D[kheikh][ho).0,(+Å,)/
M[d>J"H^ejed7B"AWjikjWJ"[jWb'//-
8heeaiH7":_9^_heF"FWjhedWiD'/./ CH_cW]_d]e\Y[h[XhWb^[cWjecWiWjZ_\\[h[djÓ[bZ ijh[d]j^i0j^[ehoWdZWffb_YWj_edi$ @9ecfkj7ii_ijJece]h')0'/*Å(&,
:Wl_i9F"BWZZC;"=^Z[I9"[jWb'//, L_hjk[bb[_djhWlWiWb[;dZeiaef_[_dZ[dD_[h[dWhj[h_[d0 [_d[d[k[h[8[jhWY^jkd]i\ehcled):#CH7#:Wj[dijp[d$ He\e',+0(+-Å(,) :`_dZ`_WdH'/-+ Ikf[hi[b[Yj_l[_dj[hdWbYWhej_ZWhj[h_e]hWf^oWdZ [cXeb_pWj_ed$ D[khehWZ_ebe]o/0'*+Å'+, :eob[7'//& Efj_YY^_Wicfei_j_ededCH_cW][i$ 7@DH''0++)Å+++ ;X[b_d]K">WiZ[c_hC='//+ Ij[h[ejWYj_Y]k_Z[Zc_Yheikh][hoe\Y[h[XhWbb[i_edi$ C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh]).0'&Å'+ <_jp[a9"C[m[iJ"=Wm[^d@"[jWb'//. ;nWc_dWj_ede\Y^eb[ij[WjecWie\j^[f[jhekiXed[m_j^ Z_\\ki_edm[_]^j[Z[Y^efbWdWh_cW]_d]:M?$ D[khehWZ_ebe]o*&0,(Å,) _bb:B"IjkZ^ebc[9"[jWb'//* 9ecX_d[ZWdZj^h[[#Z_c[di_edWbh[dZ[h[Zckbj_ceZWb ZWjW\ehfbWdd_d]YhWd_WbXWi[ikh][ho0Wfheif[Yj_l[ [lWbkWj_ed$ D[kheikh][ho)+0*,)Å*-&
H[\[h[dY[i
=eceh_@C"=heiicWdH?"=ebZX[h]>?"[jWb'/.+ ?djhWYhWd_Wb^[cWjecWi0_cW]_d]Xo^_]^#Ó[bZCH$ HWZ_ebe]o'+-0.-Å/) =eeZcWdHH'//) CW]d[j_Yh[iedWdY[_cW]_d]#Z_h[Yj[Zij[h[ejWYj_Y [dZeiYef_Yj^_hZl[djh_Ykbeijeco$ D[kheikh][ho)(0'&*)Å'&*=ehcWdF@"C[_[h7>"Ahkcc[bJC'/// I_ckbWj_edWdZl_hjkWbh[Wb_jo_dikh]_YWb[ZkYWj_ed0 h[Wbehkdh[Wb5 7hY^Ikh]')*0'(&)Å'(&.
>Wma[iH9">ebbWdZ=D"Ceeh[MI'/.&
BWkX='//,
DkYb[WhcW]d[j_Yh[iedWdY[DCHjece]hWf^o
FeijfheY[ii_d]j[Y^d_gk[i$
e\j^[XhW_d0Wfh[b_c_dWhoYb_d_YWbWii[iic[djm_j^
?d07hbWhj?F"8ed]Whjp=C"CWhY^Wb=[ZiCW]d[j_Y
Z[cedijhWj_ede\j^[fWj^ebe]o$
h[iedWdY[Wd]_e]hWf^o$
@9ecfkj7ii_ijJece]h*0+--Å+.,
Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha"ff+-Å,'
>[bi[j^7'//+
B[hY^A:'//+
J^[_dY_Z[dY[e\fh_cWhoY[djhWbd[hlekiioij[c
Ij[h[ejWYj_YWbbo#]k_Z[Zc_Yheikh]_YWbh[i[Yj_ede\Z[[f#
d[efbWiciX[\eh[WdZW\j[hYecfkj[h_p[Zjece]hWf^o
i[Wj[ZXhW_db[i_edi0c_d_c_pWj_ede\[ijWXb_i^[ZWdZ
WlW_bWX_b_jo$
Z[l[befc[dje\d[mkdYedl[dj_edWbWffheWY^[i$
@D[kheikh].)0///Å'&&)
C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh]).0,&Å-.
>ef[@A7"M_bied@B"J^ecied<@'//, =k]b_[bc_="L_dk[bW<"I[f[jaW?"[jWb'//' ;b[Yjhej^hecXei_ie\iWYYkbWhWd[khoicl_W[dZelWiYkbWh WffheWY^$FWhj'0;b[Yjhec[Y^Wd_YWbXWi_i"j[Y^d_gk[WdZ [nf[h_c[djWbh[ikbji$ @D[kheikh]-+0'Å-
J^h[[#Z_c[di_edWb9JWd]_e]hWf^o_dj^[Z[j[Yj_edWdZ Y^WhWYj[h_pWj_ede\_djhWYhWd_WbX[hhoWd[khoici$ 7@DH'-0*)/Å**+ ?ZWC"Akh_ikO"OWcWi^_jWC'//- CHWd]_e]hWf^oe\hkfjkh[ZWd[khoici_dWYkj[
=k]b_[bc_="L_dk[bW<":_ed@"[jWb'//' ;b[Yjhej^hecXei_ie\iWYYkbWhWd[khoicl_W[dZelWiYkbWh WffheWY^$FWhj(0Fh[b_c_dWhoYb_d_YWb[nf[h_[dY[$ @D[kheikh]-+0.Å'* =k]b_[bc_="L_dk[bW<":kYam_b[h="[jWb'//( ;dZelWiYkbWhjh[Wjc[dje\feij[h_ehY_hYkbWj_ed Wd[khoiciXo[b[Yjhej^hecXei_iki_d][b[Yjh_YWbbo Z[jWY^WXb[Ye_bi$ @D[kheikh]--0+'+Å+(* =k_ejF=":[hec[F">[hjpe];"[jWb'/,. L[djh_Ykbe#Y_ij[hdeijec_[iekiYedjheb[hWZ_eiYef_gk[ fekh^oZheY[f^Wb_[eXijhkYj_l[$ Fh[ii[C[Z*&0'/()Å'/(,
ikXWhWY^de_Z^[cehh^W][$ 7@DH'.0'&(+Å'&)(
=kj^h_[8B"7Zb[h@H'//( 9ecfkj[h#Wii_ij[Zfh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]"_dj[hWYj_l[ ikh][ho"WdZ\hWc[b[iiij[h[ejWno$ 9b_dD[kheikh]).0''(Å')'
>WhZ[dWYaC"8kY^[hD"<Wba7"[jWb'//. Fh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZ_djhWef[hWj_l[dWl_]Wj_ed0 ijWjkigkeWdZf[hif[Yj_l[i$ 9ecfkj7_Z[ZIkh])0'+)Å'+. >WkicWddH'//, ?cW]_d]j[Y^d_gk[ie\cW]d[j_Yh[iedWdY[Wd]_e]hWf^o$ ?d07hbWhj?F"8ed]Whjp=C"CWhY^Wb=[ZiCW]d[j_Y h[iedWdY[Wd]_e]hWf^o$ Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha"ff)+Å*-
mehakfe\_djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoici$ @D[kheikh].+0'&+&Å'&++ CWd[b\[9"BWi`Wkd_WiF"HkiYWZ[bbW@'/., Fh[ef[hWj_l[[cXeb_iWj_ede\_djhWYhWd_Wbc[d_d][ecWi$ 7@DH-0/,)Å/-(
KbjhWiekdZ#]k_Z[ZYhWd_ejeco\ehc_d_cWb_dlWi_l[
If_hWb9JiYWdd_d]\eh\WijWdZYedj_dkekilebkc[ZWjW
[nfeikh[e\Y[h[XhWbYedl[n_job[i_edi$
WYgk_i_j_ed$
7YjWD[kheY^_h')'0(-&Å(-)
?d0[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha"ff++Å,*
CY:ek]Wbb9=">WbXWY^LL":emZ9<"[jWb'//, ;dZelWiYkbWhjh[Wjc[dje\XWi_bWhj_fWd[khoiciki_d]
AWjeO"IWde>"AWjWZWA"[jWb'//+
[b[Yjheboj_YWbboZ[jWY^WXb[Ye_bi$
Ki[\kbd[iie\i_ckbWj_ede\ikh]_YWbWffheWY^[i
@D[kheikh].*0)/)Å)//
jeY[h[XhWbWd[khoiciXo^[b_YWbiYWdd_d]9J>;I#9J$ C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh]).0//Å'&*
Cbb[hM"=heiiaef\I">_bZ[XhWdZ7"[jWb'//- L_hjkWbh[Wb_jo_dj^[ef[hWj_d]heece\j^[\kjkh[$ IjkZ>[Wbj^J[Y^deb?d\ehc)/0((*Å()'
9ecfkj[Zjece]hWf^oWdZcW]d[j_Yh[iedWdY[ jece]hWf^oe\_djhWYhWd_Wbjkcehi"(dZ[Zd$
Cbb[h#<eh[bbM"LWbWlWd_i7'//+
Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha
>emWd]_eWhY^_j[Yjkh[e\Y[h[XhWbWhj[h_el[deki cWb\ehcWj_edii^ekbZ_dÔk[dY[j^[j^[hWf[kj_Y
A_a_d_iH"=b[WiedFB"Ceh_WhjoJC"[jWb'//,
Yedi_Z[hWj_edi$
9ecfkj[h#Wii_ij[Z_dj[hWYj_l[j^h[[#Z_c[di_edWb
C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh]).0)(Å*&
fbWdd_d]\ehd[kheikh]_YWbfheY[Zkh[i$ D[kheikh][ho).0,*&Å,*/
DWhW]^_H"=WWXCH"MWbj[h=<"[jWb'//( 7hj[h_Wb^of[hj[di_edWdZd[khelWiYkbWhYecfh[ii_ed
J^h[[#Z_c[di_edWbif_hWb9J\ehd[kheikh]_YWbfbWdd_d]$ D[khehWZ_ebe]o),0*)+Å*)/ AeYaheH7"I[hhWB"Ji[d]#JiW_O"[jWb(&&& FbWdd_d]WdZi_ckbWj_ede\d[kheikh][ho_dWl_hjkWb
>WhXWk]^H;"IY^bkii[bX[h]:I"@[\\[hoH"[jWb'//+ J^h[[#Z_c[di_edWbYecfkj[h_p[Zjece]hWf^_Y Wd]_e]hWf^o_dj^[fh[ef[hWj_l[[lWbkWj_ede\ Y[h[XhelWiYkbWhZ_i[Wi[$ D[kheikh][ho),0)(&Å)(-
h[iedWdY[Wd]_e]hWf^o_dj^[iYh[[d_d]WdZfh[ef[hWj_l[
CWo\hWdaB"8[hjWbWd\\o>"If[jp][hK"[jWb'//*
Ab[_d>C"8[hjWbWd\\o>"CWo\hWdaB"[jWb'//* >WhXWk]^H;"IY^bkii[bX[h]:I"@[\\[hoH"[jWb'//( J^h[[#Z_c[di_edWbYecfkj[h_p[Zjece]hWf^o Wd]_e]hWf^o_dj^[Z_W]dei_ie\Y[h[XhelWiYkbWhZ_i[Wi[$ @D[kheikh]-,0*&.Å*'*
J^h[[#Z_c[di_edWblebkc[h[dZ[h_d]\ehcW]d[j_Y
AWb[dZ[hM"LeYaF"I[_iib[hM'//&
AWpd[h;"M[dZ[I"=hkcc[J"[jWb[Zi'/./ =kh_Wd@>"CWhj_dD7"A_d]M7"[jWb'//+ D[kheikh]_YWbcWdW][c[dje\Y[h[XhWbWd[khoici \ebbem_d]kdikYY[ii\kbeh_dYecfb[j[[dZelWiYkbWh [cXeb_iWj_ed$ @D[kheikh].)0.*)Å.+)
CW[Z[hFF"C[kb_H7"Z[Jh_Xeb[jD'//,
h[Wb_jo[dl_hedc[dj$ D[kheikh][ho*,0''.Å')+ Ae_lkaWd]Wi@"Bek^_iWbc_O"7bWak_`WbW@"[jWb'//)
Wjj^[l[djhebWj[hWbc[ZkbbW07YecfWhWj_l[ c_YheWdWjec_YWbWdZfWj^ebe]_YWbijkZo$ @D[kheikh]--0'&)Å''( DWhW]^_H"=[_][h>"9hdWY@"[jWb'//* Feij[h_eh\eiiWd[khelWiYkbWhWdecWb_[i_d[ii[dj_Wb ^of[hj[di_ed$ BWdY[j)**0'*,,Å'*-& E]WmWJ"EakZ[hWJ"De]kY^_A"[jWb'//, 9[h[XhWbWd[khoici0[lWbkWj_edm_j^j^h[[#Z_c[di_edWb
KbjhWiekdZ#Yedjhebb[Zd[khedWl_]Wjeh#]k_Z[Z
9J#Wd]_e]hWf^o$
XhW_dikh][ho$
7@DH'-0**-Å*+*
@D[kheikh]-/0),Å*( HedaW_d[d7"FkhWd[dC?">[hd[id_[c_@7"[jWb'//+ AhWo[dX^b>"OWiWh]_bC='/-/
?djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoici0CHWd]_e]hWf^oiYh[[d_d]_d*&&
P[h[XhWb[7d]_e]hWf^_[\hAb_d_akdZFhWn_i")hZ[Zd$
WiocfjecWj_Y_dZ_l_ZkWbim_j^_dYh[Wi[Z\Wc_b_Wbh_ia$
J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj"ff)-Å(+/
HWZ_ebe]o'/+0)+Å*&
AkcWh7"M[bj_:";hdijHH'/-+
HedaW_d[d7">[hd[id_[c_@7"FkhWd[dC"[jWb'//-
DCH<ekh_[hp[k]cWje]hWf^o$
<Wc_b_Wb_djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoici$
@CW]d[jH[ied'.0,/Å.)
BWdY[j)*/0).&Å).*
(/'
H[\[h[dY[i
HkX_dC:"IWjeO"9heiXo:B"[jWb'//, ?dl_leZ_ii[Yj_ede\Y[h[XhWbWd[khoiciki_d]Yecfkj[Z jece]hWf^_YWd]_e]hWf^o$ ?dj@D[khehWZ_eb(0+'&Å+('
K[cWjikI"MWba[h7;'/,- KbjhWied_YZ[j[hc_dWj_ede\j^[i_p[e\Y[h[XhWb l[djh_YkbWhioij[c$ D[khebe]o'-0.'Å.*
7fkppeCB@">[_\[jpC:"M[_iiC>"[jWb'/-- D[kheikh]_YWb[dZeiYefoki_d]j^[i_Z[#l_[m_d] j[b[iYef[$J[Y^d_YWbdej[$ @D[kheikh]*,0)/.Å*&&
HoWdC@";h_YaiedHA"B[l_d:D"[jWb'//,
L_ed#:kho@"L_dY[dj[bb_<"@_ZZWd[C"[jWb'/./ CH_cW][ie\[f_Z[hce_ZYoiji$ D[khehWZ_ebe]o(/0)))Å)).
7hX_j;":_H[ijW=H"8[Z\ehZH<"[jWb'/./ ?djhWef[hWj_l[c[Wikh[c[dje\Y[h[XhWbWdZjkcehWb XbeeZÔemm_j^bWi[h#Zeffb[hÔemc[jho$ D[kheikh][ho(*0',,Å'-&
IWhjehA'//( CH_cW]_d]e\j^[iakbbWdZXhW_d$ 7Yehh[bWj_l[j[njWjbWi$ Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha IWhjeh[jj_#IY^[\[hI"M_Y^cWddM"7]kpp_7" [jWb'//- CHZ_\\[h[dj_Wj_ede\WZWcWdj_dekiWdZ igkWceki#fWf_bbWhoYhWd_ef^Whod][ecWi$ 7@DH'.0--Å.IYejj@7">ehd[hJ="B[_fp_]J@'//' H[jhe]hWZ[ikYj_edZ[Yecfh[ii_ede\Wdef^j^Wbc_Y Whj[hoWd[khoicki_d]XWbbeedeYYbki_ed$ @D[kheikh]-+0'*,Å'*I_died="F^_b_fiC<"WbbC[Z_YWb"BedZed"ff*)-Å*.. Ij[_d^e\\>"BWd][I'/-, Fh_dY_fb[ie\YedjhWij[d^WdY[c[dj_dYecfkj[h_p[Z jece]hWf^o$ ?d0BWdaiY^M"AWpd[h;[Zi9hWd_WbYecfkj[h_p[Z jece]hWf^o$Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha" ff,&Å,. J^kbXehdAH"7jbWiIM'//, ?djhWYhWd_Wb^[cehh^W][$ ?d07jbWiIM[ZCW]d[j_Yh[iedWdY[_cW]_d]e\j^[ XhW_dWdZif_d["(dZ[Zd$ HWl[d"D[mOeha"ff(,+Å)'* Jhkm_j9B"8Whael_Y^7@'//, :_iehZ[hie\XhW_dZ[l[befc[dj$ ?d07jbWiIM[ZCW]d[j_Yh[iedWdY[_cW]_d]e\j^[ XhW_dWdZif_d["(dZ[Zd$HWl[d"D[mOeha"ff'-/Å(,* JikY^_oWA">WY^_oWO"C_pkjWd_O"[jWb'//, J^h[[#Z_c[di_edWb^[b_YWb9JWd]_e]hWf^oe\iakbbXWi[ c[d_d][ecWi$ 7@DH'-0/))Å/),
(/(
MWZb[o@":ehmWhZD"A_jY^[dD"[jWb'/// Fh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d]WdZ_djhWef[hWj_l[]k_ZWdY[_d ceZ[hdd[kheikh][ho0Wh[l_[me\)&&YWi[i$ 7ddH9ebbIkh];d]b.'0('-Å((+
7k[hBC"7k[h:F'//. L_hjkWb[dZeiYefo$7d[mjeeb\ehj[WY^_d]WdZjhW_d_d] d[khe_cW]_d]$ ?dj@D[khehWZ_eb*0)Å'*
MWj[hmehj^@7(&&( :[njhekiWdZi^Wh[Z_dj[hWYj_edm_j^c[Z_YWbZWjW0 ij[h[eiYef_Yl_i_ed_iceh[_cfehjWdjj^Wd^WdZ#_cW][ YebbeYWj_ed$ IjkZ>[Wbj^J[Y^deb?d\ehc.+0+,&Å+,,
7oZ_d?>"zdZ[h7"JWaY_;"[jWb'//( Feijef[hWj_l[Wdeic_WW\j[hh[celWbe\f_jk_jWho WZ[decWiki_d]j^[fj[h_edWbWffheWY^$ 7YjWD[kheY^_h''/0'&'Å'&)
Oekd]?H"8khbC"9bWha[=@"[jWb'/.' CW]d[j_Yh[iedWdY[fhef[hj_[ie\^oZhe][d0_cW]_d]j^[ feij[h_eh\eiiW$ 7@DH(0*.-Å*/)
7oZ_d?9>"AWZ_e]bk>>"JkpkdO'//, Feijef[hWj_l[Wdeic_WW\j[hWdj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d] Whj[hoWd[khoiciikh][hoXoj^[fj[h_edWbWffheWY^$ C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh])/0-'Å-)
Ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[i"d[khe[dZeiYefo WdZef[hWj_l[jhWkcWj_pWj_ed
8Wk[h8B">[bbm_]:'//* C_d_cWbbo_dlWi_l[[dZeiYef_Yd[kheikh][hoÅ Wikhl[o$ 7YjWD[kheY^_hIkffb,'0'Å'(
7XZ[[dA"AWjeO"A_oWD"[jWb(&&& D[khe[dZeiYefo_dc_YhelWiYkbWhZ[Yecfh[ii_ed\eh jh_][c_dWbd[khWb]_WWdZ^[c_\WY_WbifWic0 j[Y^d_YWbdej[$ D[khebH[i((0+((Å+(, 7X[>"JikhkC"?jeJ"[jWb'/.' J[cfehWbbeX[ZWcW][Wif_j\WbbiWjikXj[cfehWb jhWdij[djeh_WbWffheWY^$ DeI^_da[_=[aW/0.'/Å.(7bX_dCI"8kd[]_dB":k`eldoC"[jWb'/-+ 8hW_dh[jhWYj_edfh[iikh[Zkh_d]_djhWYhWd_WbfheY[Zkh[i$ Ikh]<ehkc(,0*//Å+&& 7bX_dCI"8kd[]_dB"8[dd[jjC>"[jWb'/-- 9b_d_YWbWdZ[nf[h_c[djWbXhW_dh[jhWYj_edfh[iikh[ ced_jeh_d]$ 7YjWD[khebIYWdZ,+Ikffb',*0+((Å+() 7cc_hWj_C"IfWbbed[7"CW@"[jWb'//* Fh[i[hlWj_ede\j^[j[cfehWbXhWdY^e\j^[\WY_Wbd[hl[_d fj[h_edWb#jhWdipo]ecWj_YYhWd_ejeco$ 7YjWD[kheY^_h'(.0',)Å',+ 7dZh[miH@"8h_d]Wi@H'//) 7h[l_[me\XhW_dh[jhWYj_edWdZh[Yecc[dZWj_edi\eh c_d_c_p_d]_djhWef[hWj_l[XhW_d_d`kho$ D[kheikh][ho))0'&+(Å'&,* 7fkppeCB@'/.( JhWdiYWbbeiWb_dj[h\ehd_YWb[nfeikh[e\b[i_edie\ j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[$ ?d0IY^c_Z[a>>"Im[[jM>[ZiEf[hWj_l[d[kheikh]_YWb j[Y^d_gk[i$=hkd[WdZIjhWjjed"D[mOeha"ff+.+Å+/* 7fkppeCB@'//) 8hW_dikh][ho$9ecfb_YWj_edWle_ZWdY[WdZcWdW][c[dj$ 9^khY^_bbB_l_d]ijed["D[mOeha
8Wk[h8B">[bbm_]:'//+ C_d_cWb_dlWi_l[[dZeiaef_iY^[D[kheY^_hkh]_[C?;D$ :jiY^uhpj[Xb/(80(&,(Å(&-8[[ciJ"=hej[d^k_i@7(&&* Bed]#j[hcYecfb_YWj_ediWdZZ[Ód_j_ede\\W_bkh[e\ d[khe[dZeiYef_YfheY[Zkh[i$ 9^_bZiD[hlIoij(&0.,.Å.-8[dWX_Z7B"BWlWbb[[I">e\\cWdd:"[jWb'//( Fej[dj_Wbki[e\heXeji_d[dZeiYef_Yd[kheikh][ho$ 7YjWD[kheY^_hIkffb+*0/)Å/9W[cW[hj@"7XZkbbW^@"9Wbb_WkmB"[jWb'//( ;dZeiYef_Yjh[Wjc[dje\ikfhWi[bbWhWhWY^de_ZYoiji$ 7YjWD[kheY^_h''/0,.Å-) 9W[cW[hj@"7XZkbbW^@'//, ;dZeiYef_YcWdW][c[dje\Yebbe_ZYoiji$ J[Y^D[kheikh]'0'.*Å(&& 9WffWX_WdYWF"8kedWcWiiWI"9WlWbbeBC"[jWb(&&* D[khe[dZeiYefo0fh[i[djWdZ\kjkh[Wffb_YWj_edi$ 9b_dD[kheikh]+'0'.,Å'/& 9Whj[hBF"M^_j[MB"7ja_died@H'/-. H[]_edWbYehj_YWbXbeeZÔemWjYhWd_ejeco$ D[kheikh][ho(0(()Å((/ 9^WhWbWcfWa_F"<_b_ff_H"M[biY^[^ebZI"[jWb(&&+ Jkcehie\j^[bWj[hWbWdZj^_hZl[djh_Yb[0h[celWbkdZ[h [dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[Za[o^eb[YedZ_j_edi$ D[kheikh][ho+-Ikffb)0)&(Å'' 9^WhWbWcfWa_F"<_b_ff_H"M[biY^[^ebZI"[jWb(&&, ;dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[Zh[celWbe\Yebbe_ZYoijie\j^[j^_hZ l[djh_Yb[$ D[kheikh]H[l/0-(Å-
H[\[h[dY[i
9^[dJ9"HWXX9"7fkppeCB@'//* 9ecfb[nj[Y^d_YWbc[j^eZebe]_[iWdZj^[_hWffb_YWj_edi _dj^[ikh][hoe\_djhWYhWd_Wbc[d_d][ecWi$ D[kheikh]9b_dD7c+0(,'Å(.'
;h_ai[dA:"HWickii[dJ8"BWhi[d9A'//& 7deic_W\ebbem_d]ef[hWj_ed\ehY[h[XhWbWd[khoici_d j^[Wdj[h_ehY_hYkbWj_ed$ @D[kheikh]-(0.,*Å.,+
9_dWbb_="If[ddWjeF"9_WdY_kbb_;"[jWb(&&, J^[heb[e\jhWdil[djh_YkbWhd[khe[dZeiYefo_dj^[ cWdW][c[dje\YhWd_ef^Whod]_ecWi0j^h[[fWj_[dj h[fehjiWdZh[l_[me\j^[b_j[hWjkh[$ @F[Z_Wjh;dZeYh_debC[jWX'/Ikffb'0)*'Å+*
<W^bXkiY^H"IY^ejjM(&&( Fj[h_edWbikh][hoe\c[d_d]_ecWie\j^[jkX[hYkbkc i[bbW[WdZfbWdkcif^[de_ZWb[0ikh]_YWbh[ikbji m_j^if[Y_WbYedi_Z[hWj_ede\ef^j^Wbcebe]_YWbWdZ [dZeYh_debe]_YWbh[ikbji$ @D[kheikh]/,0()+Å(*)
9e^[d7H'//) ;dZeiYef_Yl[djh_YkbWhikh][ho$ F[Z_WjhD[kheikh]'/0'(-Å')* 9e^[d7H"F[hd[Ypao7"HeZp_[m_Yp=I"[jWb'//+ ;dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[ZYhWd_ejeco0WffheWY^je j^[heijhWbXhW_dij[c$ D[kheikh][ho),0''(.Å''(/ :Wl_[i>J"D[_b#:mo[h=";lWdi8J"[jWb'//( J^[po]ecWj_Ye#j[cfehWbWffheWY^jej^[iakbbXWi[0 WYh_j_YWbh[l_[me\''fWj_[dji$ 8h@D[kheikh],0)&+Å)'( :Wo@:"AeeiMJ"CWjkbW9"[jWb'//- 9ebehWjbWie\c_Yhed[kheikh]_YWbWffheWY^[i0YhWd_Wb XWi[WdZ_djhWYhWd_Wbc_Zb_d[$ J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj :[YgF"8hk]_[h[iF"B[=k[h_d[b9"[jWb'//, F[hYkjWd[eki[dZeiYef_Yjh[Wjc[dje\ikfhWi[bbWh WhWY^de_ZYoiji0l[djh_YkbeYoijeijecoehl[djh_YkbeYoije Y_ij[hdeijeco5J[Y^d_YWbdej[$ @D[kheikh].*0,/,Å-&' :[_diX[h][hM"8a[h:A"IWc__C'//* '//. Ikh][hoe\j^[YhWd_eY[hl_YWb`kdYj_ed$ J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj
=h_\\_j^>8'/., ;dZed[kheikh][ho0[dZeiYef_Y_djhWYhWd_Wbikh][ho$ 7ZlJ[Y^IjWdZD[kheikh]'*0)Å(* =hej[d^k_i@7'//+ CWdkWbe\[dZeiYef_YfheY[Zkh[i_dd[kheikh][ho$ K_j][l[h_`CWY^Wed"D_`c[][d =hej[d^k_i@7'//, ;dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[ZYhWd_ejeco$ J[Y^D[kheikh]'0(&'Å('(
<[hh[h;"IWdjWcWhjW:"=WhY_W#
=hej[d^k_i@7'//. ;dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[Zc_Yhed[kheikh][ho$7YedY_i[ ]k_Z[Xeea$ K_j][l[h_`CWY^Wed"D_`c[][d =hkd[hjF"F[hd[Ypao7"H[iY^A'//* ;dZeiYef_YfheY[Zkh[ij^hek]^j^[\ehWc[d _dj[hl[djh_YkbWh[e\CedhekdZ[hij[h[ejWYj_YWb YedZ_j_edi$ C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh])-0(#.
WakXW7[ZIkh][hoe\j^[_djhWYhWd_Wbl[deki ioij[c$Ifh_d][h"Jeaoe"ff(//Å)&)
>W_d[iI"9WcWhWjWF"<_ddC"[jWb'//+ Fhejejof[_dijhkc[dji\eh[dZeiYef_Yc_Yheikh][ho0 j[Y^d_YWbdej[$ C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh]).0',-Å',/ >WhZWl[bbW="?Wdel_Y_D(&&+ 9khh[djjh[dZi_dc_d_cWbbo_dlWi_l[d[kheikh][ho0 d[khe#[dZeiYefo$ H[lC[Z9^_hIeYC[ZDWj?Wi_'&/0+(.Å+)'
>Whh_i7;">WZ`_fWdWo_i9="Bkdi\ehZB:"[jWb(&&+ C_Yheikh]_YWbh[celWbe\_djhWl[djh_YkbWhb[i_ediki_d] [dZeiYef_Yl_ikWb_pWj_edWdZij[h[ejWYj_Y]k_ZWdY[$ D[kheikh][ho+,Ikffb'0'(+Å')( >Wi[]WmWJ"OWcWdeA"C_oWceh_J"[jWb'//' 7c_YhecWd_fkbWjeh\ehfh[Y_i[Yedjhebe\WXhW_d
:eb[dYLL[Z'/.- J^[YWl[hdekii_dki0Wckbj_Z_iY_fb_dWhoWffheWY^je lWiYkbWhWdZjkcehekib[i_edi$ Ifh_d][h"M_[dD[mOeha
"OWik_D"DWj^Wb#L[hW;"[jWb'//, 7deic_WW\j[hWdj[h_ehYecckdY_Wj_d]Whj[ho Wd[khoicikh][ho0YecfWh_iedX[jm[[dj^[Wdj[h_eh _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWdZXWiWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^[i$ D[kheikh][ho).0)(+Å)(.
:eb[dYLL(&&) C_Yheikh]_YWbWdWjecoWdZikh][hoe\ j^[Y[djhWbiakbbXWi[$ Ifh_d][h"M_[dD[mOeha
h[jhWYjeh$J[Y^d_YWbdej[$ @D[kheikh]-*0'&&/Å'&'& >Wiib[hM"P[djd[h@'//' Ikh]_YWbjh[Wjc[dje\eb\WYjeho]heel[c[d_d]_ecWi ki_d]jefj[h_edWbWffheWY^$ 7YjWD[kheY^_hIkffb+)0'*Å'. >[bbm_]:"8Wk[h8B'//( C_d_cWbbo_dlWi_l[d[kheikh][hoXoc[Wdie\kbjhWj^_d
:edW]^oHCF"DkcejeC"MWbbcWdB@"[jWb'/-( Fh[iikh[c[Wikh[c[djX[d[Wj^h[jhWYjehi\eh fhej[Yj_ede\Z[b_YWj[j_iik[i$ 7c@Ikh]'()0*(/Å*)'
:hWa[9='/-) CWdW][c[dje\Wd[khoicie\feij[h_ehY_hYkbWj_ed$ ?d0OekcWdi@H[ZD[khebe]_YWbikh][ho"leb($ IWkdZ[hi"F^_bWZ[bf^_W"ff-.-Å.&,
=Wm_i^?"H[_iY^H"F[hd[Ypao7(&&+ ;dZeiYef_YWgk[ZkYjefbWijoj^hek]^WjW_beh[Z YhWd_eY[hl_YWbWffheWY^$ @D[kheikh]'&)0--.Å.(
:hWa[9="F[[hb[iiI@">[hd[id_[c_@7'//, Ikh][hoe\l[hj[XheXWi_bWhWd[khoici$ Ifh_d][h"M_[dD[mOeha
=[hp[doC"9e^[d7H'//. 7ZlWdY[i_d[dZeiYef_Yd[kheikh][ho$ 7EHD@,-0/+-Å/,'
[dZeiYef[i$ 7YjWD[kheY^_hIkffb+*0,)Å,. >ed]eA"AeXWoWi^_I"Oeae^7"[jWb'/.- Ced_jeh_d]h[jhWYj_edfh[iikh[edj^[XhW_d$ 7d[nf[h_c[djWbWdZYb_d_YWbijkZo$ @D[kheikh],,0(-&Å(-+ >eh_aei^_J"Dkak_>"C_jikaWI"[jWb'//( FWhj_Wbh[i[Yj_ede\j^[]ohkih[Yjki_dfj[h_edWbWffheWY^ jeWdj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d]Whj[hoWd[khoici$ D[khebC[Z9^_h)(0'),Å')/
(/)
H[\[h[dY[i
>ehl|j^P"L[j<"8Wb|pi?"[jWb(&&&
B[lo;?"9boZ[8"CYBWk]^b_dCH"[jWb'//.
9ecfb[j[h[celWbe\Yebbe_ZYoijl_W9J#]k_Z[Z
C_YhelWiYkbWhZ[Yecfh[ii_ede\j^[b[\jbWj[hWbc[ZkbbW
ij[h[ejWYj_YX_fehjWbd[khe[dZeiYefo$
eXbed]WjW\ehi[l[h[h[\hWYjehod[khe][d_Y^of[hj[di_ed$
7YjWD[kheY^_h'*(0+)/Å+*+1
D[kheikh][ho*)0'Å/
D_XkA"IWiWa_J"AWmW^WhWD"[jWb'//. 9ecfb_YWj_edie\YhWd_e\WY_Wbikh][ho\ehjkcehi _dlebl_d]j^[Wdj[h_ehYhWd_WbXWi[$ D[kheikh][ho*(0*++Å*,(
Z_iYkii_ed+*+Å+*, B[m_i7?"9hed[AH"JW^W@"[jWb'//* ?mWXkY^_J"IeXWjW;"Ikpka_C"[jWb'/.)
Ikh]_YWbh[i[Yj_ede\j^_hZl[djh_Yb[Yebbe_ZYoiji$
:khWbi_dkifh[iikh[Wih[bWj[Zjed[kheikh]_YWbfei_j_edi$
Fh[b_c_dWhoh[ikbjiYecfWh_d]jhWdiYWbbeiWbc_Yheikh][ho
D[kheikh][ho'(0(&)Å(&-
m_j^[dZeiYefo$ @D[kheikh].'0'-*Å'-.
@Wdd[jjW@F'/-- EXi[hlWj_ediedj^[[j_ebe]oe\jh_][c_dWbd[khWb]_W"
B_k9O"MWd]CO"7fkppeCB(&&*
^[c_\WY_WbifWic"WYekij_Yd[hl[Zoi\kdYj_ed"WdZ
J^[[lebkj_edWdZ\kjkh[e\c_d_cWb_ic_dd[khebe]_YWb
]beiief^Whod][Wbd[khWb]_W$
ikh][ho$
D[kheY^_hkh]_W(&0'*+Å'+*
9^_bZiD[hlIoij(&0-.)Å-./
@^e>#:"9WhhWkHB'//-
CWb_iB?'/.+
;dZeiYef_Y[dZedWiWbjhWdiif^[de_ZWbikh][ho0
Ikh]_YWbh[i[Yj_ede\jkcehie\j^[iakbbXWi[$
[nf[h_[dY[m_j^+&fWj_[dji$
?d0M_ba_diH"H[d]WY^WhoII[ZiD[kheikh][ho"leb'$
@D[kheikh].-0**Å+'
CY=hWm#>_bb"D[mOeha"ff'&''Å'&('
AWbWlWaedZW9"I[a^WhBD"HWcWY^WdZhWdF"
CWdmWh_d]A>'//(
[jWb(&&( ;dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[Zc_Yheikh][ho\eh_djhWYhWd_Wb Wd[khoici$
i^kdj$ CWho7ddB_[X[hj"D[mOeha"ff(/Å*&
AWo[7>"8bWYaFCYB[Zi(&&& Ef[hWj_l[d[kheikh][ho"(lebi
coe\WiY_WbXed[ÔWf\ehfj[h_edWbYhWd_ejeco$
A_l_iWWh_HF"IWbed[dE"E^cWd@(&&& 8WiWbXhW_d_d`kho_dWd[khoicikh][ho$ D[kheikh][ho*,0'&-&Å'&-*
J[Y^d_YWbdej[$ @D[kheikh]/*0,,-Å,-& CWjikoWcWJ"I^_ceckhWJ"EakckhWO"[jWb'//-
Adeif;"F[hd[Ypao7"AeeiM"[jWb'//, C[d_d]_ecWie\j^[ifWY[e\j^[YWl[hdekii_dki$ D[kheikh][ho).0*)*Å***
CeX_b_pWj_ede\j^[_dj[hdWbYWhej_ZWhj[ho\ehXWi_bWh Whj[hoWd[khoicikh][ho$J[Y^d_YWbdej[$ @D[kheikh].,0(/*Å(/, CWjkbW9"JiY^WX_jiY^[hC":Wo@:"[jWb'//+
AeXWoWi^_I[Z(&&+ D[kheikh][hoe\Yecfb[nlWiYkbWhb[i_ediWdZjkcehi$ J^_[c["D[mOeha Ae_lkaWd]Wi@"Beki^_Wbc_O"7bWak_`W`W@'//)
;dZeiYef_YWbboWii_ij[Zc_Yhed[kheikh][ho$ 7YjWD[kheY^_h')*0'/&Å'/+
KbjhWiekdZ#Yedjhebb[Zd[khedWl_]Wjeh#]k_Z[ZXhW_d ikh][ho$
Yedi[hlWj_edWYekij_Yjkcehikh][ho$
@D[kheikh]-/0),Å*(
7c@Ejeb'*0(+/Å(,(
AeeiMJ"If[jpb[hH<"F[dZb="[jWb'/.+
C[dpM"=kX[h7'//*
9ebehWjbWie\c_Yhed[kheik][ho$
C_YheijhkYjkh[j[Y^debe]_[iWdZj^[_hfej[dj_Wb_d
J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj
c[Z_YWbWffb_YWj_edi$ C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh])-0('Å(-
AeeiMJ"CWjkbW9"BWd]@(&&( 9ebehWjbWie\c_Yhed[kheikh][hoe\WYekij_Yd[kh_decWi$
C_bb[h@:"IjWd[a7;"BWd]\_jjJM'/-)
J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj
9[h[XhWbXbeeZÔemh[]kbWj_edZkh_d][nf[h_c[djWbXhW_d Yecfh[ii_ed$ @D[kheikh])/0'.,Å'/,
IkfhWjWhiWb\ebZ_dY_i_ed\ehWffheWY^jej^[ikf[h_eh bWj[hWbehX_j$
Ce^i[d_fekh?"=ebZ^W^dM;"<_iY^[h@"[jWb'//*
EhWbIkh]EhWbC[ZEhWbFWj^ebEhWbHWZ_eb;dZeZ
7ffheWY^[i_dd[kheikh][ho
.'0+((Å+(+
J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj
BWmjedCJ":Wif_j9F"If[jpb[hH<'//-
DWaWi[>"A[cfia_E">[_cWdd7"[jWb'//-
J[Y^d_YWbWif[YjiWdZh[Y[djjh[dZi_dj^[cWdW][c[dj
C_YheY_hYkbWj_edW\j[hY[h[XhWbl[dekieYYbki_edWii[ii[Z
e\bWh][WdZ]_Wdjc_ZXWi_bWhWhj[hoWd[khoici$
XobWi[h:effb[hiYWdd_d]$
D[kheikh][ho*'0+')Å+('
@D[kheikh].-0)&-Å)'*
(/*
E_aWmWI"C_pkdeC"CkhWeaWI"[jWb'//, H[jhe]hWZ[Z_ii[Yj_ede\j^[j[cfehWb_ickiYb[ fh[l[dj_d]ckiYb[Wjhef^o\ehfj[h_edWbYhWd_ejeco$ J[Y^d_YWbdej[$ @D[kheikh].*0(/-Å(// EaWA"A_dO"JecedW]WC'//) 7deXi[hlWj_ede\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[kdZ[hÔ[n_Xb[ ÓX[hefj_Yl[djh_YkbeiYef[0dehcWbijhkYjkh[$ Ikh]D[kheb*&0(-)Å(-EaWA"OWcWcejeC"?a[ZWA"[jWb'//) [_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha"ff*(/Å*)FWj[bHI"Oeki[c:C"CWbZ`_Wd@7"[jWb(&&& ?dY_Z[dY[WdZYb_d_YWbi_]d_ÓYWdY[e\\hedjWbehehX_jWb [djhoZkh_d]fj[h_edWb\hedjej[cfehWbYhWd_ejeco$ 7@DH('0')(-Å'))&
CYA[ddWdAN'//) ;dZeiYefoe\j^[_dj[hdWbWkZ_jehoYWdWbZkh_d]^[Wh_d]
Akd]:I"AWXWdB8'//,
E]WjWC"?i^_aWmWJ">eh_Z[H"[jWb'/,+ ;dY[f^WbeiYef[0XWi_YijkZo$ @D[kheikh]((0(..Å(/'
CWjikcejeA"7aW]_A"7X[akhWC"[jWb(&&' 9eic[j_YWdZ\kdYj_edWbh[YedijhkYj_edWY^_[l[Zki_d]W
9^khY^_bbB_l_d]ijed["BedZed
EÊ:ede]^k[=C"EÊ
;dZeiYef[#]k_Z[ZfbWY[c[dje\j^[l[djh_Ykbef[h_jed[Wb ?d0CWdmWh_d]A>"9hed[AH[ZiD[khe[dZeiYefo"leb'$
D[kheikh][ho+'0'''/Å''(-
EY^_W_9"Eak^WjWI"Oei^_cejeO"[jWb'//, 8h_Z][ZYhWd_ejeco\ehijWXb[ÓnWj_ede\WXed[ÔWf$ J[Y^d_YWbdej[$ @D[kheikh].+0+'.Å+'/
F[h[jjWF"HW]Wpp_F"=WbWhpWC"[jWb(&&, 9ecfb_YWj_ediWdZf_j\Wbbie\d[khe[dZeiYef_Yikh][ho _dY^_bZh[d$ @D[kheikh]'&+0'.-Å/)$ F[hd[Ypao7'//( FbWdd_d]ijhWj[]_[i\ehj^[ikfhWi[bbWhh[]_ed$ D[kheikh][edi''0)*)Å)*. F[hd[Ypao7"9e^[d7"=[eh][8"[jWb'//* ;Z_jeh_Wb$ C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh])-0' F[hd[Ypao7"
H[\[h[dY[i
F[hd[Ypao7"Adeif;"LehaWf_YF"[jWb'/.+ :_h[Yjikh]_YWbWffheWY^je_d\hWYb_de_ZWbWd[khoici$ 7YjWD[kheY^_h-,0),Å** F[hd[Ypao7"Cbb[h#<eh[bbM"lWdB_dZ[hj;" [jWb'/// A[o^eb[YedY[fj_dd[kheikh][ho$ J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj
H[d]WY^WhoII"M_ba_diH>[Zi'//*
IYel_bb[M8"Eh[=:'/,&
Fh_dY_fb[ie\d[kheikh][ho$
BWh][jh[f^_d[YhWd_ejec_[i$
Meb\["BedZed
7YjWD[khebBWj_deWc,0*&&Å*&(
HeX_diedI"9e^[d7H'//-
I[a^WhBD"IY^hWccLB@h"@ed[iD<'/.-
J^[heb[e\d[khe[dZeiYefo_dj^[jh[Wjc[dje\f_d[Wb h[]_edjkcehi$ Ikh]D[kheb*.0),&Å),+1Z_iYkii_ed),+Å),-
F[hd[Ypao7"JiY^WX_jiY^[hC"H[iY^A:C'//) ;dZeiYef_YWdWjeco\ehd[kheikh][ho$ J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj
Hei[dehd@":_[c[hD'/.+ J^[h_iae\Y[h[XhWbZWcW][Zkh_d]]hWZ[ZXhW_dh[jhWYjeh
IkXj[cfehWb#fh[Wkh_YkbWh_d\hWj[cfehWb\eiiWWffheWY^ jebWh][bWj[hWbWdZfeij[h_ehYhWd_WbXWi[d[efbWici$ @D[kheikh],-0*..Å*// I[a^WhBD"Z[Eb_l[hW;'/// 9hWd_Wbc_Yheikh][ho0WffheWY^[iWdZj[Y^d_gk[i$ J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj
fh[iikh[_dj^[hWj$ F_bbWoFA">Wii[dXkiY^I@"IWmWoWH'//) C_d_cWbbo_dlWi_l[XhW_dikh][ho$ 7dd7YWZC[ZI_d]Wfeh[((0*+/Å*,) FhejjM'/-* 9_ij[hdeiYefo#[dZeiYefoe\j^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[$ 7YjWD[kheY^_h)'0'&+Å'') HWaH"I[a^WhBD"Ij_cWY:"[jWb(&&* ;dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[Zc_Yheikh][ho\ehc_YhelWiYkbWh Yecfh[ii_ediodZhec[i$ D[kheikh][ho+*0.-,Å.'1Z_iYkii_ed..'Å..)
@D[kheikh],&0,&.Å,''
7d[nj[dZ[ZikX\hedjWbWffheWY^jej^[iakbbXWi[$ IWc__C"I[f[^hd_W7"8_d_M'/./
?d0H[d]WY^WhoII"M_ba_diH>[ZiD[kheikh]_YWb
Ikh][hoe\j^[`k]kbWh\ehWc[d$
ef[hWj_l[WjbWi"leb($M_bb_WciM_ba_di"8Wbj_ceh["
7ZlD[kheikh]'-0'*&Å'+(
ff/-Å'&,
IWc__C"CWjj^_[i9"JWjW]_XWC'//'
I^W^_d_Wd>A";Xo@8"EYedC(&&*
?djhWYWdWb_YkbWhWYekij_Yd[kh_decWi$
D[kheikh][ho)(0)(Å)IWc__C"JWjW]_XWC"F_gk[h@"[jWb'//, Ikh]_YWbjh[Wjc[dje\[f_Z[hce_ZYoijie\j^[
HWdZHM'/-. C_Yhed[kheikh][ho"(dZ[Zd$ CeiXo"Ij$Bek_i H[iY^A:C"F[hd[Ypao7'//- ;dZe#d[khe#iede]hWf^o0WdWjec_YWbWif[Yjie\ j^[XWiWbY_ij[hdi$ C_d_c?dlWi_l[J^[h7bb_[ZJ[Y^deb,0))(Å))/
I[d9"I[a^WhBD'//(
Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[$ @D[kheikh].*0'*Å'/
C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh]*-0)(/Å))( I^_XkoWC"JWaWoWikC"Ikpka_O"[jWb'//, 8_\hedjWbXWiWb_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^je YhWd_ef^Whod][ecWh[i[Yj_edm_j^ehm_j^ekjZ_l_i_ede\ j^[Wdj[h_ehYecckd_YWj_d]Whj[ho$ @D[kheikh].*0/+'Å/+,
IWddWC"IWb[^;"Hkiie7"[jWb'//+
Ic_j^A7"If[jpb[hH<'//+
7jbWie\j[cfehWbXed[WdZbWj[hWbiakbbXWi[ikh][ho$
IkfhWj[djeh_Wb#_d\hWeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^\ehfeij[hec[Z_Wb
J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj
j[cfehWbbeX[b[i_edi$ @D[kheikh].(0/*&Å/**
IY^Wbb[h9"P[djd[h@'//. H[iY^A:C(&&, JhWdi[dZeiYef_YkbjhWiekdZ\ehd[kheikh][ho$ Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha
LWieifWij_Yh[WYj_ed_dh[ifedi[jej^[jhWdiiobl_Wd
If[jpb[hH<"B[[AI'//,
WffheWY^$
H[YedijhkYj_ede\j^[j[cfehWb_ickiYb[\ehj^[fj[h_edWb
Ikh]D[kheb*/0'-&Å'-+
YhWd_ejeco$J[Y^d_YWbdej[$ @D[kheikh]-)0,),Å,)-
H[_iY^H"
IY^Wbb[h9"Ab[cc;">Wkd:"[jWb(&&( J^[jhWdiiobl_WdWffheWY^_iÇc_d_cWbbo_dlWi_l[È XkjdejÇWjhWkcWj_YÈ$
H[_iY^H"FWjedWoB"@kbem@'//- 7p[dZeipafeil[djh_akbeipjc_WWdWjc_W_WbWf`W_$ 7Ø\h[[^WdZÈj[Y^d_aWab_d_aW_WbaWbcWp|iW$ 9b_dD[kheiY_%?Z[]]oIpb[+&'Å(0'.,Å'/) H[_iY^H"F[hd[Ypao7(&&+ J^[ikfhWehX_jWbYhWd_ejeco\eh\hedjeXWiWb c[d_d][ecWi$ ?d0AeXWoWi^_[ZD[kheikh][hoe\Yecfb[njkcehiWdZ lWiYkbWhb[i_edi$J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj H[_iY^H"H[iY^A"F[hd[Ypao7(&&( 7aWchWh[dZip[h[dZeipede]h|Ó|iWdWjec_|`W$ 9b_dD[kheiY_%?Z[]]oIpb[++'Å(0'-Å(( H[_iY^H"F[hd[Ypao7(&&+ J[d#o[Wh[nf[h_[dY[m_j^j^[ikfhWehX_jWbikX\hedjWb WffheWY^j^hek]^Wd[o[Xhemia_d_dY_i_ed$ D[kheikh][ho+-Ikffb)0(*(Å(++ H[_iY^H"Lkjia_jiB"FWjedWoB'//+ 7ikfhWj[djeh_|b_iY_ij[hdWh[dZip[h[dZeipafei WdWjc_|`W$ 9b_dD[kheiY_%?Z[]]oIpb[*.''Å'(0*&(Å*&,
D[kheikh][ho+'0/-'Å/--
Ij[_d8C'/-' J^[_d\hWj[djeh_WbikfhWY[h[X[bbWhWffheWY^je f_d[Wbb[i_edi$ @D[kheikh]+0'/-Å(&(
IY^c_Z[a>>"Im[[jM>[Zi'//+
Ijed_[miaoF"P_[b_dia_F'//-
Ef[hWj_l[d[kheikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[i$
H[cej[[\\[Yje\XhW_dh[jhWY_ededh[]_edWbY[h[XhWb
M8IWkdZ[hi"F^_bWZ[bf^_W
XbeeZÔemWdZY[h[XhelWiYkbWhh[i[hl[edi_d]b[f^ejed [c_ii_edYecfkj[Zjece]hWf^o$
IY^he[Z[h>MI"=WWXCH'///
Ikh]D[kheb*.0+''Å+')
?djhWYhWd_Wb[dZeiYefo$ D[kheikh]<eYki,*0'+Å(*
Ik]_jWA">_hejWJ"Jik]Wd[H'/-+ 7ffb_YWj_ede\dWief^Whod][Wbc_hheh\ehWd[khoic
IY^he[Z[h>MI"=WWXCH"D_[dZeh\MH'//, D[khe[dZeiYef_YWffheWY^jeWhWY^de_ZYoiji$ @D[kheikh].+0(/)Å(/. IY^he[Z[h>MI"E[hj[b@"=WWXCH(&&* ;dZeiYef[#Wii_ij[Zc_Yheikh]_YWbh[i[Yj_ede\
ef[hWj_ed$J[Y^d_YWbdej[$ @D[kheikh]*)0(**Å(*, Ik]_jWA"AeXWoWi^_I"Oeae^7'/.( Fh[i[hlWj_ede\bWh][Xh_Z]_d]l[_diZkh_d]XhW_d h[jhWYj_ed$J[Y^d_YWbdej[$ @D[kheikh]+-0.+,Å.+.
[f_Z[hce_Zjkcehie\j^[Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[Wd]b[$ @D[kheikh]'&'0((-Å()(
Ikpka_@"Oei^_cejeJ"C_de_A'/.' Fh[i[hlWj_ede\j^[eb\WYjehojhWYj\ehWdj[h_eh
IY^he[Z[h>MI"E[hj[b@"=WWXCH(&&*
Yecckd_YWj_d]Whj[hoWd[khoici"WdZj^[\kdYj_edWb
?dY_Z[dY[e\Yecfb_YWj_edi_dd[khe[dZeiYef_Yikh][ho$
fhe]dei_i$
9^_bZiD[hlIoij(&0.-.Å..)
@D[kheikh]+*0)*(Å)*+
(/+
?bbkijhWj_edYh[Z_ji
JW]kY^_O"JWdWaWA"CWjikpWmWC"[jWb'//, 7ikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[jeWle_Zfeijef[hWj_l[ [def^j^Wbcei_dj^[YhWd_eehX_jWbWffheWY^$ J[Y^d_YWbdej[$ @D[kheikh].+0+'*Å+'JWjW]_XWC"CWjj^_[i9"IWc__C'//, C_Yhe[dZeiYefoe\j^[_dj[hdWbWkZ_jehoYWdWb_d l[ij_XkbWhiY^mWddecWikh][ho$ D[kheikh][ho).0-)-Å-*& J[e9'//- D[khe[dZeiYefo0Ykhh[djWffb_YWj_edi
OWiWh]_bC="H[_Y^cWdCL"AkX_aI'/.- Fh[i[hlWj_ede\j^[\hedjej[cfehWbXhWdY^e\j^[\WY_Wb d[hl[ki_d]j^[_dj[h\WiY_Wbj[cfehWb_iÔWf\ehfj[h_edWb YhWd_ejeco$J[Y^d_YWbWhj_Yb[$ @D[kheikh],-0*,)Å*,, OWiWh]_bC="9hWl[di=<"Hej^F'/.. Ikh]_YWbWffheWY^[ijeÇ_dWYY[ii_Xb[ÈXhW_djkcehi$ 9b_dD[kheikh])*0*(Å''& OWiWh]_bC="9kh_YC"A_iC"[jWb'//& JejWbh[celWbe\YhWd_ef^Whod][ecW$7ffheWY^[iWdZ bed]j[hch[ikbji_d'**fWj_[dji$ @D[kheikh]-)0)Å''
WdZ\kjkh[Z_h[Yj_edi$ Ikh]J[Y^deb?dj,0)(-Å))) J[e9"HW^cWdI"8eef<7"[jWb'//, 9ecfb_YWj_edie\[dZeiYef_Yd[kheikh][ho$ 9^_bZiD[hlIoij'(0(*.Å(+) Jikjikc_A"I^_eaWmWO"IWaW_J'/.' L[deki_d\WhYj_ed\ebbem_d]j^[_dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y WffheWY^_dfWj_[djim_j^WYkj[ikXWhWY^de_ZWb ^[cehh^W][$ @D[kheikh]+*0)*(Å)*+
OWiWh]_bC='/.*Å'//, C_Yhed[kheikh][ho"*lebi$ J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj Oeae^7"Ik]_jWA"AeXWoWi^_I'/.) ?dj[hc_jj[djl[hikiYedj_dkekiXhW_dh[jhWYj_ed$ 7d[nf[h_c[djWbijkZo$ @D[kheikh]+.0/'.Å/(. Oeae^7"Ik]_jWA"AeXWoWi^_I'/.- 9b_d_YWbijkZoe\XhW_dh[jhWYj_ed_dZ_\\[h[djWffheWY^[i WdZZ_i[Wi[i$ 7YjWD[kheY^_h.-0')*Å')/
JkhWpp_I"9h_ije\eh_B"=WcX_dH"[jWb'/// J^[fj[h_edWbWffheWY^\ehj^[c_Yheikh]_YWbh[celWbe\ eb\WYjeho]heel[c[d_d]_ecWi$ D[kheikh][ho*+0.('Å.(+ Kd][hiXYaA"F[hd[Ypao7'/., ?djhWl[djh_YkbWhWd[khoice\j^[c[Z_WbY^ehe_ZWhj[ho Yb_ff[Zl_Wj^[YedjhWbWj[hWbjhWdiYWbbeiWbWffheWY^$ 7YjWD[kheY^_h.(0(*Å(lWdB_dZ[hj;">ef\D"F[hd[Ypao7'//. ;dZeiYef_Yjh[Wjc[dje\c[i[dY[f^Wb_Y[f[dZocWb
OkdZjA:"=hkXXHB":_h_d][hCD"[jWb'//- 9[h[XhWb^[ceZodWc_YWdZc[jWXeb_YY^Wd][iYWki[Z XoXhW_dh[jhWYj_edW\j[hWd[khoicWbikXWhWY^de_Z ^[cehh^W][$ D[kheikh][ho*&0**(Å*+( P_cc[hcWddC"Ah_i^dWdH"HWWX[7"[jWb(&&( HeXej#Wii_ij[ZdWl_]Wj[Zd[khe[dZeiYefo$ D[kheikh][ho+'0'**,Å'*+'
?bbkijhWj_edYh[Z_ji <_]kh[idejb_ij[ZX[bemWh[_dfeii[ii_ede\j^[Wkj^ehi WdZIfh_d][hM_[dD[mOeha <_]$'$&$' :WdZoM;'/(( 7def[hWj_l[fheY[Zkh[\eh^oZheY[f^Wbki$ 8kbb@e^di>efa_di>eif))0'./Å'/&"BMM <_]$'$&$( :WdZoM;'/). ?djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoice\j^[_dj[hWdWbYWhej_ZWhj[ho$ 9kh[ZXoef[hWj_ed$ 7ddIkh]'&-0,+*Å,+/"BMM <_]$'$&$) :WdZoM;'/'. L[djh_Ykbe]hWf^o\ebbem_d]j^[_d`[Yj_ede\W_h_djej^[ Y[h[XhWbl[djh_Yb[i$ 7ddIkh],.0+Å'("BMM <_]$'$&$* Ced_p;'/(- BÊ[dYf^Wbe]hWf^_[Whj[h_bb["ied_cfehjWdY[ZWdibW beYWb_iWj_edZ[ijkc[khiYhXhWb[i$ H[lD[kheb(0-(Å./";bi[l_[h%CWiied <_]$'$&$+7 >ekdi\_[bZ=D'/-) 9ecfkj[h_p[ZjhWdil[hi[Wn_WbiYWdd_d]jece]hWf^o0 FWhj'$:[iYh_fj_ede\ioij[c$ 8h@HWZ_eb*,0'&',Å'&(("8h@HWZ_eb <_]$'$&$+8 :WcWZ_WdH"=ebZic_j^C"C_dae\\B'/-- DCH_dYWdY[h0NL?$<ED7H_cW][e\j^[b_l[^kcWdXeZo F^oi_eb9^[cF^oi/0/-Å'&&"BMM <_]$'$&$, IY^be\\[h>'/&- ;h\eb]h[_Y^[Ef[hWj_ed[_d[i>ofef^oi[djkcehiWk\ dWiWb[cM[][$ M_[dAb_dMeY^[diY^h(&0,('Å,(*"Ifh_d][h"M_[d <_]$'$&$- 9ki^_d]>'/'& J^[f_jk_jWhoXeZoWdZ_jiZ_iehZ[hi$ @8B_ff_dYejj"F^_bWZ[bf^_WBedZed"BMM
Yoiji0j[Y^d_YWbYWi[h[fehj$ D[kheikh][ho*)0'()*Å'(*' lWdB_dZ[hj;"F[hd[Ypao7"
<_]$'$&$. 8kYoF9'/-. D[kheikh][ho_dZWhad[ii$ Ikh]D[kheb/0),&";bi[l_[h
J^[ikfhWehX_jWba[o^eb[WffheWY^jeikfhWj[djeh_Wb Wd[khoici0YedY[fjWdZj[Y^d_gk[$ Ikh]D[kheb*/0*.'Å*./ lWdB_dZ[hj;@"=hej[d^k_i@7"8[[ciJ(&&* J^[ki[e\W^[WZ#cekdj[ZZ_ifbWo\ehl_ikWb_pWj_ed_d d[khe[dZeiYefo$
<_]$'$&$/ OWiWh]_bC="AhWo[dX^b>'/-& J^[ki[e\j^[X_deYkbWhc_YheiYef[_dd[kheikh][ho$ 8_XbEf^j^Wbceb.'0,(Å,+"BMM <_]$'$&$'& Akhp[J'/,* C_Yhej[Y^d_gk[i_dd[khebe]_YWbikh][ho$ 9b_dD[kheikh]''0'(.Å')-"BMM
9ecfkj7_Z[ZIkh]/0(+'Å(+, Lh_[i@A'/-. 7d[dZeiYef_Yj[Y^d_gk[\ehj^_hZl[djh_Ykbeijeco$ Ikh]D[kheb/0',+Å',. MWh_d]7@">ekimehj^9C"Leeh^_[iHC"[jWb'//& 7fhejejof[h[jhWYjehioij[cZ[i_]d[Zjec_d_c_p[ _iY^[c_YXhW_dh[jhWYjeh_d`kho0_d_j_WbeXi[hlWj_edi$ Ikh]D[kheb)*0')/Å'*) M[ij[hcWdd8"Jh_ff[bC"H[_d^WhZj>'//+ Efj_YWbbo#dWl_]WXb[ef[hWj_d]c_YheiYef[\eh _cW][#]k_Z[Zikh][ho$ C_d_c?dlWi_l[D[kheikh]).0''(Å'',
(/,
<_]$'$&$'' CWb_iB?'/,- 8_febWhYeW]kbWj_ed_dc_Yheikh][ho$ ?d0:edW]^oHCF"OWiWh]_bC=[ZiC_YhelWiYkbWhikh][ho$ J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj"ff'(,Å')&"J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj <_]i$'$&$(.Å'$&$)& XoYekhj[ioe\7[iYkbWf7="Jkjjb_d][d"=[hcWdo <_]i$'$&$)(Å'$&$)) XoYekhj[ioe\7[iYkbWf7="Jkjjb_d][d"=[hcWdo <_]$($&$' AhWki[<'/&. 9^_hkh]_[Z[i=[^_hdikdZHYa[dcWhaidWY^[_][d[d ;h\W^hkd][d"leb'$ KhXWdIY^mWhp[dX[h]"8[hb_d";bi[l_[h
?bbkijhWj_edYh[Z_ji
<_]$($&$( '/') 7dWffheWY^jej^[^ofef^oi_ij^hek]^j^[Wdj[h_eh YhWd_Wb\eiiW$ 7ddIkh]'0'*+Å'+&"BMM <_]$($&$) >[k[h=@'/(& Ikh]_YWb[nf[h_[dY[im_j^Wd_djhWYhWd_WbWffheWY^je Y^_WicWbb[i_edi$ 7hY^Ikh]'0),.Å).'"7C7 <_]$($&$* IYWh\\@;'/+' Jh[Wjc[dje\eXijhkYj_l[^oZheY[f^WbkiXofkdYjkh[e\ j^[bWc_dWj[hc_dWb_iWdZÔeehe\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[$ @D[kheikh].0(&*Å(')"77DI <_]$($&$+ Feff[d@B'/,* Ef[hWj_l[jh[Wjc[dj\ehWd[khoicie\j^[Wdj[h_eh Yecckd_YWj_d]Whj[ho$ 9b_dD[kheikh]''0.Å')"BMM <_]$($&$, OWiWh]_bC='/.* C_Yhed[kheikh][ho"leb' J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj <_]$($&$- 8heYaC":_[jp>'/-. J^[icWbb\hedjebWj[hWbWffheWY^\ehj^[c_Yheikh]_YWb jh[Wjc[dje\_djhWYhWd_WbWd[khoici$ D[kheY^_hkh]_W('0'.+Å'/'"J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj <_]$)$&$' AhWki[<'/'' 9^_hkh]_[Z[i=[^_hdikdZHYa[dcWhaidWY^[_][d[d ;h\W^hkd][d"leb($ KhXWdIY^mWhp[dX[h]"8[hb_d";bi[l_[h <_]$)$&$( JWdZb[h@"HWdp_;'/(& 9^_hkh]_iY^[7dWjec_[kdZEf[hWj_edij[Y^d_aZ[i P[djhWbd[hl[dioij[ci$ Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d
<_]$)$&$. <_iY^K'/,/ Eje#d[kheikh]_YWbef[hWj_edi$ ?d0OWiWh]_bC="C_Yhed[kheikh][ho07ffb_[Zje d[kheikh][ho$J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj"ff'/+Å('& J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj
<_]$+$&$+ OWiWh]_bC='/.* C_Yhed[kheikh][ho"leb'$ J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj <_]$,$&$' Fkii[fF'/'* :_[ef[hWj_l[;dj\[hdkd][_d[hPoij[Z[h
<_]$)$&$/ AWmWi[J"I^_eXWhWH"JeoWI'//* C_ZZb[\eiiWjhWdif[jheiWb#jhWdij[djeh_WbWffheWY^[i \ehf[jheYb_lWbc[d_d]_ecWi$I[b[Yj_l[fohWc_Z h[i[Yj_edWdZhWZ_YWb_jo$ 7YjWD[kheY^_h'(/0'')Å'(&"Ifh_d][h"M_[d <_]$*$&$' AhWki[<'/&. 9^_hkh]_[Z[i=[^_hdikdZHYa[dcWhaidWY^ [_][d[d;h\W^hkd][d"Leb$'$ KhXWdIY^mWhp[dX[h]"8[hb_d";bi[l_[h
=bWdZkbWf_d[Wb_i$ D[khebP[djhWbXb))0+,&Å+,)"Ifh_d][h">[_Z[bX[h] <_]$,$&$( AhWki[<'/'' 9^_hkh]_[Z[i=[^_hdikdZHYa[dcWhaidWY^ [_][d[d;h\W^hkd][d"leb($ KhXWdIY^mWhp[dX[h]"8[hb_d";bi[l_[h <_]$,$&$) JWdZb[h@"HWdp_;'/(& 9^_hkh]_iY^[7dWjec_[kdZEf[hWj_edij[Y^d_a
<_]$*$&$( 9ki^_d]>'/'-"h[fh_dj'/,) Jkcehie\j^[d[hlkiWYkij_Yki$ >W\d[hFkXb_i^_d]"D[mOeha
Z[iP[djhWbd[hl[dioij[ci$ Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d <_]$,$&$* PWfb[jWb8'/+,
<_]$*$&$) :WdZo'/(+ 7def[hWj_ed\ehj^[jejWbh[celWbe\Y[h[X[bbefedj_d[ WYekij_Yjkcehi$ Ikh]=od[YebEXij[j*'0'(/Å'*.";bi[l_[h
;_dd[k[hef[hWj_l[hPk]Wd]pkc=[X_[jZ[h ?dY_ikhWj[djeh__$ P[djhWbXbD[kheY^_h',0,*Å,/"J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj <_]$,$&$+ <e[hij[hE'/(.
<_]$*$&$* =khZ`_Wd;I'/,* Ef[hWj_l[d[kheikh][ho"(dZ[Zd$ M_bb_WciM_ba_di"8Wbj_ceh["BMM <_]$*$&$+ A[cf[B='/,. Ef[hWj_l[d[kheikh][ho$ Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha" <_]$*$&$, :WdZoM;'/)* 9edY[hd_d]j^[YWki[e\jh_][c_dWbd[khWb]_W$ 7c@Ikh](*0**-";bi[l_[h
<_]$)$&$) A[cf[B='/,. Ef[hWj_l[d[kheikh][ho$ Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha
<_]$*$&$- @Wdd[jjWF@"HWdZHM'/,- 7hj[h_WbYecfh[ii_ede\j^[jh_][c_dWbd[hl[_dfWj_[dji m_j^jh_][c_dWbd[khWb]_W$ @D[kheikh](,0'+/Å',+"77DI3J^[`di
<_]$)$&$* :WdZoM'/)( J^[XhW_d$?d0B[m_i:[ZFhWYj_Y[e\ikh][ho$ >W][hijemd"ff'Å,.("77DI3J^[`di
<_]$*$&$. :hWa[9='/-/ J^[jh[Wjc[dje\Wd[khoicie\j^[feij[h_ehY_hYkbWj_ed$ 9b_dD[kheikh](,0/,Å'**"BMM
<_]$)$&$+ Feff[d@B'/,& 7dWjbWie\d[kheikh]_YWbj[Y^d_gk[i$ IWkdZ[hi"F^_bWZ[bf^_W";bi[l_[h
<_]$*$&$/ OWiWh]_bC='/.* C_Yhed[kheikh][ho"leb'$ J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj
<_]$)$&$,7 :hWa[9='/,' 8b[[Z_d]Wd[khoicie\j^[XWi_bWhWhj[ho$:_h[Yjikh]_YWb cWdW][c[dj_d\ekhYWi[i$ @D[kheikh]'.0()&Å()."77DI3J^[`di
<_]$+$&$' AhWki[<'/'' 9^_hkh]_[Z[i=[^_hdikdZHYa[dcWhaidWY^ [_][d[d;h\W^hkd][d"leb($ KhXWdIY^mWhp[dX[h]"8[hb_d";bi[l_[h
<_]$)$&$,8 :hWa[9='/,. J^[ikh]_YWbjh[Wjc[dje\Wd[khoicie\j^[XWi_bWhWhj[ho$ @D[kheikh](/0*),Å**,"77DI3J^[`di
<_]$+$&$( 9ki^_d]>'/'-"h[fh_dj'/,) Jkcehie\j^[d[hlkiWYkij_Yki$ >W\d[hFkXb_i^_d]"D[mOeha
:Wief[hWj_l[Leh][^[dX[_Jkceh[dZ[h L_[h^][b][][dZ$ M_[dAb_dMeY^[diY^h*'0/.,Å//&"Ifh_d][h"M_[d <_]$,$&$, :WdZoM;'/), Ef[hWj_l[[nf[h_[dY[i_dYWi[ie\f_d[Wbjkcehi$ 7hY^Ikh]))0'/Å*,";bi[l_[h <_]$,$&$- LWdMW][d[dMF'/)' 7ikh]_YWbWffheWY^\ehj^[h[celWbe\ Y[hjW_df_d[Wbjkcehi$ Ikh]=od[YebEXij[j+)0(',Å((&";bi[l_[h <_]$,$&$. >ehhWn='/)- ;nj_hfWj_ede\WbWh][f_d[WbecW\hecWfWj_[djm_j^ fkX[hjWifhW[Yen0Wd[mef[hWj_edWffheWY^$ 7hY^D[khebFioY^_Wj)-0).+Å)/-"7C7 <_]$,$&$/ Ij[_d8C'/-' J^[_d\hWj[djeh_WbikfhWY[h[X[bbWhWffheWY^ jef_d[Wbb[i_edi$ @D[kheikh])+0'/-Å(&("77DI3J^[`di <_]$,$&$'& F[dZb='/.+
<_]$)$&$,9 :hWa[9='/-/ J^[jh[Wjc[dje\Wd[khoicie\j^[feij[h_ehY_hYkbWj_ed$ 9b_dD[kheikh](,0/,Å'**
<_]$+$&$) :WdZo'/). >_hdY^_hkh]_[$ @7cXhei_ki"B[_fp_]"Ifh_d][h">[_Z[bX[h]
<_]$)$&$- A[cf[B='/,. Ef[hWj_l[d[kheikh][ho$ Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha
<_]$+$&$* A[cf[B='/,. Ef[hWj_l[d[kheikh][ho$ Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha
F_d[WbWdZc_ZXhW_db[i_edi$ Ifh_d][h"M_[dD[mOeha <_]$-$&$' :WdZoM;'/'+ ;nj_hfWj_ede\j^[f_d[WbXeZo$ @;nfC[Z((0()-Å(*-"@;C <_]$-$&$( :WdZoM;'/), Ef[hWj_l[[nf[h_[dY[i_dYWi[ie\f_d[Wbjkcehi$ 7hY^Ikh]))0'/Å*,";bi[l_[h <_]$-$&$) JWdZb[h@"HWdp_;'/(& 9^_hkh]_iY^[7dWjec_[kdZEf[hWj_edij[Y^d_a Z[iP[djhWbd[hl[dioij[ci$ Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d
(/-
?bbkijhWj_edYh[Z_ji
<_]$-$&$* :WdZoM;'/)' 9ed][d_jWbY[h[XhWbYoijie\j^[YWlkci[fj_f[bbkY_Z_ Ó\j^l[djh_Yb[WdZYWlkcl[h]W[i_nj^l[djh_Yb[0 Z_W]dei_iWdZjh[Wjc[dj$ 7hY^D[khebFioY^_Wjho(+0**Å,,"7C7 <_]$-$&$+ I^kYWhjM'//. J^[Wdj[h_ehjhWdiYWbbeiWbWdZjhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^[i$ ?d07fkppeCB@[ZIkh][hoe\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[$ M_bb_WciM_ba_di"8Wbj_ceh["BMM <_]$-$&$, Jdd_iM'/), ;h\eb]h[_Y^[8[^WdZbkd][_d[i7d[khoicWZ[h 7hj$Yecckd$Wdj$Y[h[Xh_$ P[djhWbXbD[kheY^_h'0)/Å*("J^_[c["Ijkjj]Whj <_]$.$&$' :WdZoM;'/)) 8[d_]djkcehi_dj^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[e\j^[XhW_d0 Z_W]dei_iWdZjh[Wjc[dj$ 99J^ecWi"Ifh_d]Ó[bZ <_]$.$&$( :WdZoM;'/)) 8[d_]djkcehi_dj^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[e\j^[XhW_d0 Z_W]dei_iWdZjh[Wjc[dj$ 99J^ecWi"Ifh_d]Ó[bZ <_]$.$&$) A[cf[B='/,. Ef[hWj_l[d[kheikh][ho$ Ifh_d][h"8[hb_d>[_Z[bX[h]D[mOeha <_]$.$&$* I^kYWhjM'//. J^[Wdj[h_ehjhWdiYWbbeiWbWdZjhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^[i$ ?d07fkppeCB@[ZIkh][hoe\j^[j^_hZl[djh_Yb[$ M_bb_WciM_ba_di"8Wbj_ceh["BMM
(/.
IkX`[Yj_dZ[n
IkX`[Yj_dZ[n
7Yekij_Yd[kh_decW"^_ijeh_YWbZ[iYh_fj_ed'+/ WdWjec_YWbbWdZcWhai ][d[hWb(, Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(** XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^.+ YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^')* [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'*. _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^()& bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^+- c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-' f_d[WbWffheWY^('' feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(+, feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'(& h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^',- ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'.* ikXeYY_f_jWbWgk[ZkYjWffheWY^'/. ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'&+ ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^** jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(-* Wd[khoic [nfei[Z_dfhWYj_Y[)' ^_ijeh_YWbZ[iYh_fj_ed)/"//"',("'.& Wd[khoicYb_f ^_ijeh_YWbÓhijZ[iYh_fj_ed) _dfhWYj_Y[)( Wd]_e]hWf^o :I7\ehikh]_YWbfbWdd_d](&"(( ^_ijeh_YWbZ[iYh_fj_ed) Wdj[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii"[nfeikh[e\ bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,'Å,( c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-+ ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^*.
Wdj[h_ehf[jheYb_de_Zb_]Wc[dj"[nfeikh[e\ Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(*. bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,'Å,( c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-+ feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'() ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^''& ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^+& Wgk[ZkYje\Iobl_ki"[nfeikh[e\ ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'.. ikXeYY_f_jWbWgk[ZkYjWffheWY^(&( jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(-/ Whj[h_[i 7'"79e7eh7("[nfeikh[e\ Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(*/ XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^/& bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,' c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-+ ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^*/
bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,* c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-. ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'&/"''' ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^+& jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(-/
87"fhen_cWb"[nfeikh[e\ [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'++ h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-) ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'''
?97"79^7ehF9e7"[nfeikh[e\ Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(*. XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^/' YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^')/ bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,' c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-+ feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'(* ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^''& ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^*.
C97"[nfeikh[e\ Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(*. XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^/&"/' bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,( c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-, ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^*.
CC7"[nfeikh[e\ [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'+(
Efj^7"[nfeikh[e\ Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(*. c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-, ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^*/
F97"[nfeikh[e\ XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^/' YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^''/ [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'++ bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,)",* c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-+ feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'() ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'&/"'''
F?97"[nfeikh[e\ YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'*& h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-* ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'.. ikXeYY_f_jWbWgk[ZkYjWffheWY^(&'
I97"[nfeikh[e\ XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^/' YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^')/ [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'+* bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,* feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'() feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(,) h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-( ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'&/"''' ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^+&
L7"[nfeikh[e\ h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-* ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'.."'/'
7)#7*"[nfeikh[e\ Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(*- c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^--
7?97"[nfei[Zj^hek]^j^[ YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'*& [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'+) h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-)
87"Z_ijWb"[nfeikh[e\ Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(*/ XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^/( [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'++
8eY^ZWb[aÊiY^ehe_Zfb[nki'-)
8_febWhYeW]kbWj_ed ^_ijeh_YWbZ[iYh_fj_ed, _dfhWYj_Y['.
Xbk[b_d[j[Y^d_gk['*+
XhW_dh[jhWYj_ed ][d[hWb- Xof_d[WbWffheWY^(&.
XoikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'&'"''- XoikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'/+ XoikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^*&
9WkZWj[dkYb[ki"[nfeikh[e\ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^()+ jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(--
YWl[hdekii_dki"[nfeikh[e\ [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'++ bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,)",* feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'(, ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^''( Y^ehe_ZÓiikh["[nfeikh[e\ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(), jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(-. Y^ehe_Zfb[nkie\j^[\ekhj^l[djh_Yb[" [nfeikh[e\ ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'/& Y_hYkbWj_d]dkhi['( Yb_lki"[nfeikh[e\ feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'(, h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-) YeY^b[W'*+"'+) Yebbe_ZYoij(,Yecfkj[Zjece]hWf^o9J ^_ijeh_YWb* fh[ef[hWj_l[(& YedjhWbWj[hWbikh]_YWb[nfeikh[ ][d[hWb. XoWdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(*( Xo_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^((+ Xof_d[WbWffheWY^(&/ Xofeij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(+) XoikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^+& YehfkiYWbbeikc"[nfeikh[e\ Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(*- _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^()+ feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(,' jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(-. Yehj_YWb[nfbehWj_edYhWd_Wbd[hl[i 9D?"[nfeikh[e\ XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^./ ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^*.
9D??"Y^_WicWehefj_YjhWYj"[nfeikh[e\ Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(*. XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^./ YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^')/ bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,' c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-+ feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'(* ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^*.
9D???"[nfeikh[e\ Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(*. XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^/' YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^')/ [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'++ bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,' c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-+ feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'() h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-( ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'&/"''' ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^+&
(//
IkX`[Yj_dZ[n
9D?L"[nfeikh[e\ [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'+* YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^')/ bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,* feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'(*"'(+ feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(,) ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'''
9DL"[nfeikh[e\ YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'*& [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'++ bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,* feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'(+ h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-( ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^''(
9DL?"[nfeikh[e\ [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'++ bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,* feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'(, h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-) ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^''(
9DL??"9DL???"[nfeikh[e\ YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'*& [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'+) feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'(, h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-)
9D?N"9DN"9DN?"[nfeikh[e\ h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-)"'-* ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'./
9DN??"[nfeikh[e\ h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-* ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'./
[neiYef[ YedY[fj'& _dfhWYj_Y[''
[nj[dZ[ZYhWd_ejeco)").
A[o^eb[YedY[fj
[njhWZkhWb[nfeikh[ ^_ijeh_YWb)-"/- XobWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,' XoikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'*+"'+(
<ekhj^l[djh_Yb["^_ijeh_YWb[nfeikh['.&
\ekhj^l[djh_Yb["[nfeikh[e\ ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'/& ikXeYY_f_jWbWgk[ZkYjWffheWY^(&( \ehWc[de\CW][dZ_"[nfeikh[e\ ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'/& ikXeYY_f_jWbWgk[ZkYjWffheWY^(&( \ehWc[de\Cedhe"[nfeikh[e\ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^()+ jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(--
YhWd_ejecoWdZZkhWbef[d_d] Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(*+Å(*, XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^.-Å.. YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^')+Å')- [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'*/Å'+' ][d[hWb(- _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^()'Å()) bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^+.Å,& c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-(Å-* f_d[WbWffheWY^(')Å('* feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(+-Å(+/ feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'('Å'(( h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^',/Å'-& ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'.+Å'.- ikXeYY_f_jWbWgk[ZkYjWffheWY^'//Å(&& ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'&,Å'&. ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^*+Å*- jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(-+Å(-,
:[njheiYef[(' Z_WcedZad_\['. Zehikci[bbW["[nfeikh[e\ bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,'Å,( c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-+ ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^+&
=h[Wj[hikf[hÓY_Wbf[jheiWbd[hl['*+
^[c_\WY_WbifWic"^_ijeh_YWbZ[iYh_fj_ed','
b_c_j[ZYhWd_ejeco- b_c_j[Zefj_YWbYedjheb'& b_c_j[Zeh_[djWj_ed/
CW]d[j_Yh[iedWdY[_cW]_d]CH?
^_ijeh_YWbZ[iYh_fj_ed* fh[ef[hWj_l[(&
c[d_d][ecW"^_ijeh_YWbZ[iYh_fj_ed)-"'&&"(((
D[khedWl_]Wj_ed
YedY[fj/ _djhWef[hWj_l[ki[')
Ef[hWj_d]c_YheiYef[
^ebZ_d]Whc'- ^ebZ_d]Z[l_Y['-
^oZheY[f^Wbki"eYYbki_l[)."/-
ef[hWj_d]jWXb['+
?79"[nfeikh[e\
ef[hWj_d]j^[Wj[h bWoekj'( f[hiedd[b'(
h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-) ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'*+"'+)
_djhWZkhWbZ_ii[Yj_edWdZmekdZYbeikh[ Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(*-Å(+& XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^./Å/) YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^').Å'*' [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'+(Å'+, ][d[hWb(-")* _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^()*Å()- bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,'Å,+ c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-+Å-/ f_d[WbWffheWY^('+Å('. feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(,&Å(,* feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'()Å'(- h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-'Å'-+ ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'..Å'/( ikXeYY_f_jWbWgk[ZkYjWffheWY^(&'Å(&) ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'&/Å'') ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^*.Å+' jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(--Å(.&
_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YfWj^mWo ][d[hWb((* ^_ijeh_YWbZ[iYh_fj_ed(&,"((' _dj[hj^WbWc_YWZ^[i_ed"[nfeikh[e\ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(),
)&&
_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(), jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(-/
ced_jeh_d]"_djhWef[hWj_l[ ][d[hWb') \ehikXj[cfehWb[nfeikh['*,
_dZ_l_ZkWbWffheWY^/
[h]edeco\ehikh][ed'*
BWj[hWbl[djh_Yb["[nfeikh[e\
\ehd_n"[nfeikh[e\ _dj[h^[c_if^[_YWffheWY^()+ jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(--
[dZeiYef_Yd[kheikh][ho',
][d[hWb. \eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_Y[nfeikh[((* \ehjhWdiYehj_YWb[nfeikh[(,/
c_Yhe_dijhkc[dj ^_ijeh_YWbZ[iYh_fj_ed, _djhWef[hWj_l[ki['. jkX[i^W\j'/
;dZeiYef[ YedY[fj'& #Wii_ij[Zd[kheikh][ho', #Yedjhebb[Zd[kheikh][ho',
h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-)
\ehWc[dcW]dkc"[nfeikh[e\ h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-* ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'.. ikXeYY_f_jWbWgk[ZkYjWffheWY^(&'
>[WZ#cekdj[ZZ_ifbWo'&
YhWd_eÓnfbWj[))
@k]kbWh\ehWc[d"[nfeikh[e\
^_ijeh_YWbZ[iYh_fj_ed, _dfhWYj_Y['+
ehX_jWbhee\"[nfeikh[e\ XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^.) bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,' c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-+ ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^+& ehX_jejeco.) eh_[djWj_ed"_djhWef[hWj_l[/
F_d[Wb]bWdZ"[nfeikh[e\
f_d[WbWffheWY^('- feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(,' feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'(+
f_jk_jWhoWZ[decW"^_ijeh_YWbZ[iYh_fj_ed). fbWdkcif^[de_ZWb["[nfeikh[e\ ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^*/ fei_j_ed_d]e\fWj_[dj \ehWdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(*) \ehXWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^.* \ehYecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^')) \eh[nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'*- ][d[hWb(* \eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^((/ \ehbWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^+, \ehc[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-&
IkX`[Yj_dZ[n
\ehf_d[WbWffheWY^('& \ehfeij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(++ \ehfeij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^''/ \ehh[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^',, \ehikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'.) \ehikXeYY_f_jWbWgk[ZkYjWffheWY^'/- \ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'&* \ehikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^*) \ehjhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(-)
feij[h_ehYb_de_ZfheY[ii"[nfeikh[e\ bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,'Å,( c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-+ feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'() ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^+& feij[h_ehf[jheYb_de_Zb_]Wc[dj"[nfeikh[e\ bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,( feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'() ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^+&
_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^()' bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^+. c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-'Å-( f_d[WbWffheWY^('( feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(+- feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'(' h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^',/ ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'.+ ikXeYY_f_jWbWgk[ZkYjWffheWY^'// ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'&, ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^*+ jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(-+
iakbbYbWcf(* ikf[h_ehc[ZkbbWhol[bkc"[nfeikh[e\ ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'.("'.. ikXeYY_f_jWbWgk[ZkYjWffheWY^(&( ikf[h_ehi[c_Y_hYkbWhYWdWb'*+
fej[dj_Wbikh]_YWb[hhehi Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(+& XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^/) YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'*' [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'+, ][d[hWb)* _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^()- bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,+ c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-/ f_d[WbWffheWY^('. feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(,* feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'(- h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-+ ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'/( ikXeYY_f_jWbWgk[ZkYjWffheWY^(&) ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'') ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^+' jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(.&
ikf_d[fei_j_ed"][d[hWb(*
fh[ef[hWj_l[Z_W]deij_Y ^_ijeh_YWb) \ehikh]_YWbfbWdd_d](&
j^h[[#Z_c[di_edWbfbWdd_d]('
fh[ef[hWj_l[fbWdd_d](& fh[i_]ce_Zh[]_ed')' fhed[fei_j_ed"][d[hWb(+ fj[h_edWbYehh_Zeh++ fohWc_Z"l_hjkWb [nfei_d]j^[9F7',)"'.' \ehikXj[cfehWb[nfeikh['&( \ehikfhWehX_jWb[nfeikh[*'
GkWZh_][c_dWbfbWj["[nfeikh[e\
f_d[WbWffheWY^('- feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(,'
H^ecXe_Z\eiiW"[nfeikh[e\
ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'.("'.. ikXeYY_f_jWbWgk[ZkYjWffheWY^(&(
IYhkXdkhi['( i[b\#cWZ[ikh][ho"YedY[fj/ ia_d_dY_i_edWdZie\jj_iik[Z_ii[Yj_ed Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(*+ XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^., YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^')+ [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'*/Å'+& ][d[hWb(,
ikh]_YWbYehh_Zeh/
JW_beh[ZWffheWY^
YedY[fj/ _dfhWYj_Y[()"(.Å))
j[bWY^ehe_Z[W'.( j[djeh_kc"[nfeikh[e\ YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'). [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'+* bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,) f_d[WbWffheWY^('+ feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(,' feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'() h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-' ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'&/
Y[djhWbY[h[X[bbWhl[_d"[nfeikh[e\ f_d[WbWffheWY^(',
_dj[hdWbY[h[XhWbl[_d"[nfeikh[e\ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(), f_d[WbWffheWY^(', jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(-.
f[jhekil[_de\:WdZo"[nfeikh[e\ YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'*& [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'+* h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-'
i[fjWbl[_d"[nfeikh[e\ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(), jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(-.
j^WbWceijh_Wj[l[_d"[nfeikh[e\ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(), jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(-.
l[_de\=Wb[d"[nfeikh[e\ f_d[WbWffheWY^(',
l[_die\Iobl_WdÓiikh["[nfeikh[e\ XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^/' c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^-, ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^*.
l[djh_Ykbe]hWf^o) l[hc_i"[nfeikh[e\ ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'.("'.. ikXeYY_f_jWbWgk[ZkYjWffheWY^(&( l_hjkWbh[Wb_jo('
j_fiWdZjh_Yai Wdj[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(+' XWiWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^/* YecX_d[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'*( [nj[dZ[ZikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'+- ][d[hWb)+ _dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(). bWj[hWbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^,, c[Z_WbikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^.& f_d[WbWffheWY^('/ feij[h_eh_dj[h^[c_if^[h_YWffheWY^(,+ feij[h_ehikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^'(. h[jhei_]ce_ZWbWffheWY^'-, ikXeYY_f_jWbWffheWY^'/) ikXeYY_f_jWbWgk[ZkYjWffheWY^(&* ikXj[cfehWbWffheWY^''* ikfhWehX_jWbWffheWY^+( jhWdiYehj_YWbWffheWY^(.' JhWkjcWddjh_Wd]b[''."')'"'). jh_][c_dWbd[khWb]_W"^_ijeh_YWbZ[iYh_fj_ed/-"',' jh_]edkcb[cd_iY_(,) jkX[i^W\j_dijhkc[dj'/
LWbb[YkbW'.("'.. l[_di XWiWbl[_de\Hei[dj^Wb"[nfeikh[e\ f_d[WbWffheWY^(',
)&'