!,.,~
i
".'. 'i! 'i
KAISER ALUMINUM ELECTRICAL BUS CONDUCTORS TECHNICAL MANUAL
}
'.I
,::,,,';'
KAISER ALUMINUM ELECTRICAL BUS CONDUCTORS TECHNICAL MANUAL
FIRST EDITION
KAISER ALUMINUM & CHEMICAL SALES, INC. 919 North Michigan Avenue Chicago 11, Illinois
, y.
EDITORIAL ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Information presented in this book was compiled and written by Chester G. Sorflaten, Electrical Condnctor Sales, Kaiser Alnminum & Chemical Sales, Inc., as a company service to the Electrical Indnstry. Factual data have been obtained from numerous individuals and companies whose help and cooperation Kaiser Aluminuul gratefully recognize. In addition, acknowledgement is offered to the othel' personnel throughout this company and the complete staff of the Technical Publications Department whose combined efforts have made this book possible.
J. M.
AnLE,
Technical Editor
,.{
Copyright 1957
by Kaiser Aluminum & Chemical Sales, Inc.
TABLE OF CONTENTS Page
Page
SECTION I: General.
1-13
Dt . . 0 f~ R' e ermmation
.
27
dc
ALLOY CHARACTERISTICS AND PROPERTIES. .. Physical Properties : . . . . .. Electrical Properties . . , , .. Conductivity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Resistivity Thermal Properties of Aluminum Bus Conductors. . . .. Temperature Coefficient of Resistance. . . . . . . . . . .. , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Specific Heat ,............. Thermal Conductivity Effect of Heating on Tensile Strength. . . . . . . . . . . .. '" ,. '" . Creep Conosion Resistance General Classes of Bus Conductor Alloys. . . . . . . . . . .. Non-Heat-Treatable Bus Alloys .. ,. ... . .. . .... .. Temper Designation for Non-Heat-Treatable Bus Bar Alloys. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Heat-Treatable Bus Alloys. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Temper Designations for Heat-Treatable Bus Bar Alloys. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
1 1 2 2 2 2 2 3 3 4 5 5 6 6 6 6
Problem No.2. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 27 INDUCTIVE REACTANCE OF BUS CONDUCTORS. Solid Round and Round Tubular Bus Conductors. . . .. Inductive Reactance to a One-foot Radius. . . . . . . .. " Inductive Reactance Spacing Factor Geometric Mean Distance (GMD). . . . . . . . . . . . .. Inductive Reactance of Rectangular Bars. . . . . . . . . .. Graphical Solution Using Reactance Curves. . . . . .. Methods of Calculation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Widely Spaced Conductors. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Inductive Reactance of Square Tubular Conductors and Channels in Box Form. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Method of Calculation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Graphical Solution Using Reactance Curves ..... " Problem No.3. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
8 8 8 9 9 9 9 10 10 10 10 11 11 11 11 12 12 12 12
MANUFACTURING PROCESS AND TOLERANCES .. Extruded Bar and Shapes. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Tolerances . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Rolled Bar and Structural Shapes. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
12 13 13 13
35 35 35 38
BUS IMPEDANCE : Problem No.4 Voltage Drop-Vectorial Relationship. . . . . . . . . . . . .. '" , Problem No.5
39 39 39 40
CURRENT RATING OF BUS CONDUCTORS Current Rating of Round Conductors. . . . . . . . . . . . .. Heat Loss by Convection-Outdoor Rating Heat Loss by Convection-Indoor Rating. . . . . . . .. Heat Loss by Radiation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Method of Calculation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Limitations of Round Conductors-Solid and Tubular Cunent Rating of Rectangular Bar. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Effect of Width of Bar on its Cunent Rating. . . . . .. Effect of Bar Thickness on Current Rating. . . . . . . .. , Effect of Position on Cunent Rating Cunent Ratings of Multiple Bar Arrangements. . . . . .. Current Rating for Square Tubular Bus. . . . . . . . . . . .. Current Rating for Standard Channels and Angles. . .. Cunent Rating for Non-Standard Bus Shapes Conversion Factors .Effect of Bus Enclosures. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Effect of Painting Bus Bars. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
40 41 41 41 42 42 43 43 43 44 44 46 46 46 46 46 48 49
SECTION III: Mechanical Design SECTION II: Electrical Design
29 29 29 30 30 30 30 34 35
7
BUS CONDUCTOR SHAPES " Rectangular Bar . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Edge Contours Alumimun Rectangular Bar Alloys. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Alloy Selection . . . . . . .. Bending Properties . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Specifications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Round Tubular Conductor. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Electrical Characteristics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Alloys Bending Properties " Square Tubular Conductor. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Electrical Characteristics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Alloys : . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Channel and Angle Conductor. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Alloys Fabrication Other Conductor Shapes. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
15-49
D-C RESISTANCE OF BUS CONDUCTORS Calculation of D-C Resistance. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Problem No.!. " Temperature Conversion of D-C Resistance " Temperature Coefficient of Resistance (it)
15 16 16 16 17
A-C RESISTANCE OF BUS CONDUCTORS Skin Effect . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Effect of Bus Shape and Size on A-C Resistance. . . . .. Rectangular Bars Tubular Conductors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . .. Channels and Angles Arranged in Box Form. . . . . .. Calculation of A-C Resistance Independent Variable . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Shape Parameter . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
18 20 20 20 21 23 23 23 27
~'
,.r·
51-72
SHORT CIRCUIT FORCES oN BUS CONDUCTORS. Lateral Forces , Value of k Short Circuit Cunent. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Symmetrical Currents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Asymmetrical Currents . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. '. . . . . . . . .. Effective Current NEMA Standards . . . . . . . . .. Calculation of Fault Current. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Calculation of Lateral Short Circuit Forces , Force between Two Conductors. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Force on End Conductor of Three-Phase Bus Spaced Horizontally . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Force on Center Conductor of a Three-Phase , Bus with Flat Symmetrical Arrangement Forceon Each Conductor in a Multiple Bar Arrangement
51 51 52 52 52 52 54 54 55 56 56 56 56 58
\
Page
I
,!
, !.
Vibration and Resonance , Stress Factors Longitudinal Forces Torsional Forces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
59 59 60 61
BUS DESIGN . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Clearances " Deflections of Bus Conductors Bare and Loaded " Bus Loading-Ice and Wind Ice Loading . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Wind Loads . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. " Combined Ice and Wind Load Formulas for Deflection and Stress of Bus Conductors. Calculation of Deflection and Stress in a Typical Bus Installation " Expansion of Aluminum Bus Conductors " Calculation of Bus Expansion. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Types of Expansion Joints. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Application of Expansion Joints " Methods of Support for Buses. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Fixed Supports in Center Only " Fixed Supports at One End Only " Fixed Supports at Both Ends. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Fixed Supports at Intermediate Points " Fixed Supports at!Center and Both Ends. . . . . . . . ..
61 61 62 63 63 63 65 65
SECTION IV: Joining Bus Conductors
69 70 70 71 72 72 72 72 72 72 72
73-103
PREPARING ALUMINUM CONTACT SURFACES Aluminum to Copper Joints , , . .. Silver Plated Contact Surfaces Other Methods of Surface Preparations
73 74 74 74
JOINT RESISTANCE Total Joint Resistance. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Contact Resistance for a Uniformly Applied Pressure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Metal Resistance in a Lapped Joint with Uniformly Applied Pressure Joint Resistance of Bolted Bus Bars , Effect of Overlap on Bolted Bus Bars. . . . . . . . . . ..
75 75 75 76 77 77
77 77 , 78
JOINT BOLTING PRESSURE Distribution of Applied Force in a Bolted Joint Bolting Methods
JOINT DESIGN , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Heating in a Typical Bus Joint. Effect of Heating in a Bus Joint. Current Limitation per Bolt , '" , Design of a Lapped Joint" Multiple Bars per Phase , ,, Joint with Silver Plated Surfaces "
79 79 79 80 80 80 81
CLAMPING FORCES DEVELOPED BY BOLTS ..... Joint Stresses Developed by Bolted Clamping Forces.. Reducing Joint Stresses with Flat Washers ,. Strength Characteristics of Fasteners , . .. Aluminum Bolts Steel Bolts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
81 81 83 83 83 84
BELLEVILLE SPRING WASHERS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. Belleville Washer Design , , . . . .. Belleville Spring Materials and Finish Selection of a Belleville Washer , "
85 85 86 86
WELDING ALUMINUM BUS BAR Melting Point and Thermal Capacity .. ,
87 , .. 87
Page
Thermal Conductivity 87 Oxide Films , 88 Porosity 88 Thermal Expansion and Contraction. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 88 Effects of Welding Heat on Bus Bar Properties. . . . . .. 88 Preparing Aluminum Bus Bar for Welding ..... " ... 89 Joint Design and Edge Preparation. . . . . . . . . . . . .. 89 Cleaning of Welding Surfaces , '" ., .. " 89 Preheat ' , . .90 Choice of Welding Method 90 Welding Methods for Aluminum Bus Bar. . . . . . . . . .. 90 Gas Welding . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 90 Equipment for Gas Welding 90 90 Gas Flame Adjustment , Filler Rods , .. ,................. 91 Welding Flux , , .. , 91 Edge Preparation ahd Cleaning before Welding 91 Preheating . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 93 Welding Procedure 93 Cleaning after Gas We1ding. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 93 Physical Properties of Gas Welded Work Hardened Alloys (EC & 1100) . . . . . . . . .. . . . . .. 93 Properties of Gas Welded, Heat-Treatable Alloys (6101, 6061, & 6063) , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 93 Metallic Arc Welding , '" . " .. 94 Equipment 94 Electrodes 94 Edge Preparation and Cleaning Before Welding 94 Preheating and Welding Procedure 95 Cleaning after Metallic Arc Welding. . . . . . . . . . . .. 96 Properties of Metal Arc Welds , .. ; . . .. 96 Tungsten-Inert-Gas Welding (TIG) 96 Equipment 96 Filler Rods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 96 Gas Coverage 96 Edge Preparation and Cleaning before Welding , 96 Preheating and Welding Procedures. . . . . . . . . . . .. 98 Properties of TIG Welded Bus , '" 98 Metal-Inert-Gas Welding (MIG) 98 Equipment 98 Filler Wire , , 99 Gas Coverage 99 Edge Preparation and Cleaning before Welding. . .. 99 Preheating and Welding Procedures 100 Properties of MIG Welds 100 Carbon Arc Welding 100 Atomic Hydrogen Welding 101 Resistance Welding 101 Pressure Welding 101 Joining Aluminum to Copper by Welding 101 Joint Design 102 Silver Solder Coating the Copper Bar 102 Procedures ' ~ 102 Physical Properties of Aluminum to Copper MIG Welds " 102 Exothermic Welding 102
SECTION V: Accessories Welding Fittings Bolted Accessories Tee Connectors Expansion Connectors Stud Connectors Bus Supports' ' Couplers and Terminals
105-116 ,
, .105-107 107 108-109 110-111 , .. 112-113 114-115 116
SECTION VI: Tables and Specifications . . , .117-168
.
'I r. :1
FOREWORD
..
) ,~
The wide acceptance of aluminum and its alloys in the electrical industry rests basically upon its economy and abundance. Aluminum's physical characteristics, such as high conductivity and light weight, give it unique advantages in Plany electrical applications where other non-ferrous metals formerly served exclusively. While the use of EC grade aluminum as bus bar dates back to 1895, the application of alloy aluminum bus conductor has been more recent. The various alloys and tempers now available provide a full range of properties, both elech'ical and physical, to meet practically any requirement. Aluminum bus bar is readily employed in proposed designs of new electrical systems and equipment and, in most cases, with only minor changes it can also be designed into existing systems. The primmy purpose of this book is two-fold: (1) to illustrate, describe and classify the numerous aluminum bus bar shapes and alloys now available; and (2) to assist the reader in making the most advantageous utilization of aluminum for various electrical bus bar applications. The versatility of aluminum bus bar as a rigid conductor is evidenced in the countless small installations designed to carry a few hundred' amperes to the extremely large facilities distributing currents on the order of 60,000 amperes. The smaller installations include rectangular bar in bus duct which provides service to machinery and equipment in many industrial plants. The larger facilities, such as chemical and reduction plants, require massive sections of bus bars to cany the high process currents. Selection of the most suitable alloy to provide both conductance and strength for the proposed usage is covered in Section 1. All of the common shapes of bus conductor offered by producers are described in detail. Fabricating processes, such as extrusion and cold rolling, are outlined to compare surface finish, strength characteristics, and dimensional tolerances inJparted to the alloys processed by each fabricating method. Electrical bus condu:ctor design is discussed in detail in Section II, while Section III presents mechanical design infOlmation to prove the adequacy of the proposed installation when subjected to short circuit forces and vibrational stresses, with or without additional loads such as wind pressure and accumulations of ice in outdoor conductor installations. Section IV offers methods of joining aluminum bus . C:ollductor both mechanically and by fusion processes. Emphasis has been placed upon the proper surface preparation to give low resistance, stable electrical joints; recommended bolting techniques are indicated. Fusion welding by four principal methods, .i.e., gas, metal are, tungsten inert-gas, and metal ineli-gas is described for applications where permanent electrical joints are prefened. Each welding process is covered in detail, including such subjects as preheating, edge preparation, and a practical method of welding aluminum to copper. j" Accessories commonly used for joining, supporting, tapping, and terminating bus bar are illustrated in Section V. These illustrations show the wide variety of installation methods possible with such accessories. Line drawings in this section indicate recent developments in welding fittings for bus conductor. Special attention is directed to the numerous charts, graphs, line drawings, and other illustrations. All have been handled with care both to simplify and augment text material. Numerous tables on bus bar physical and electrical properties provide a ready reference for design and application studies. . A comprehensive table of contents is presented under each section heading. July 1, 1957
ALUMINUM BUS CONDUCTORS
ALLOY CHARACTERISTICS AND PROPERTIES
I
I
I
,
,.
ing characteristics. The 59 EC temper is intended for . The abundance of aluminum ores and the rapid severe forming operations such as edge bending. Its eXpansion of aluminum production capacity are two forming properties are thus comparable to EC-H12. iUlportant factors that assure the electrical industry of a continued reliable supply of aluminum bus bar ma- These replacement alloys have somewhat less conductivity than EC grade confluctors, but their physical terials.. The reduction facilities necessary to produce properties and lower cost offset this disadvantage for ll,luminum from aluminum oxide (alumina) depend ·.upon large quantities of electrical power. It requires many applications. :N>proximately 9 kw-hr of electrical energy to produce one pound of aluminum. Since the production costs of electrical power are inherently stable, the price of Physical Properties of Aluminum .aluminum should also be stable. This is reflected in Bus Conductors ,the historical price pattern of aluminum. The many applications for aluminum bus conduc. ' As a result of this stability, aluminum has become tor demand a number of alloys with varied physical . ',the most economical of all conductor materials, and properties in addition to good electrical characteristics. .. because of this, a more extensive use of aluminum bus To supply the designer with this flexibility, several conductor has developed. Such conductor is finding its aluminum bus bar alloys are available that will pro,,!, way into manufactured electrical equipment of all vide physical properties to meet the requirements of kinds where its use heretofore had been considered most applications. This range of properties provides , neither feasible nor economical. Accompanying this alloys with high tensile strength at only a slight sacri'gradual spread of aluminum bus conductor into many fice in ductility for applications requiring high strength electrical usages has been the demand for performance but limited bending or forming properties. More duccharacteristics other"than those available with EC tile alloys for extreme bending or forming require(electrical conductor) grade aluminum. This trend has led to the development of several tempers of. a new . ments are also available where moderate tensile strengths are satisfactory. The physical properties of high strength bus bar alloy. The chemical composition these commonly used aluminum bus conductor alloys of this alloy conforms to the Aluminum Association are shown in Table L designation of alloy 6101. Four tempers of this bus These aluminum alloys have common physical conductor alloy have been developed to providl'l miniproperties important in the mechanical design of a mum conductivities of 55, 56, .57, and 59 per cent bus bar installation. One imp0rtant property is unit . . . (lACS) and physical properties superior to the EC bus weight as measured by density in pounds per cubic bar tempers which the new alloy conductors are reinch. Although other metal additions are made to placing. Kaiser Aluminum has designated these alloys some of the bus bar alloys, theYi are so small that, for as follows: all practical purposes, density. can be considered as 55EC (6101-T6); identical in all of· these alloys. The specific gravity 56EC (6101-T62); will thereby be a constant also. These properties are 57EC (6101-T61); given as: 59EC (6101-HIll). Density-lbs. per cubic inch-0.09765; The high strength tempers-55 EC and 56 EC-are Specific Gravity -2.703. replacements for EC-H17 and are intended for applications where only limited forming properties are deThe modulus of elasticity for all bus bar alloys can sired. The lower strength EC-H12 and EC-H13 alloys also be considered to have the same value, can be replaced by 57 EC and 59 EC which are more E = 10 X 106 (psi). ductile than 55 EC and 56 EC to provide better form-
1
!
section I - general
TABLE .1 -
Alloy
PHYSICAL PROPERTIES OF ALUMINUM BUS CONDUCTOR ALLOYS
Minimum
Typical
Minimum
Typical
Typical Compressive Yield Strength (psi)
Yz
29,000
32,000
25,000
29,000
28,00.0
14
Vil- Yz
27,000
290 000
22,000
26,000
25,000
14
Thickness (Inches)
55 EC
Ys-
56EC 57 EC
Ys - 0.749 0.750 - 1.499 1.500 - 2.000
59EC
-
6061-T6
-
20,000 18,000 15,000 12,000 38,000
Vil- Yz
6063-T6
Ultimate Tensile Strength (psi)
30,000 33,000
Tensile Yield Strength (psi)
Elongation in 2 Inches (Per bent)
-
15,000 11,000 8,000
-
-
-
-
-
-
8,000
-
-
35
35,000
40,000
-
12
35,000
25,000
31,000
31,000
38,000
30,000
36,000'
36,000
10
12,000
10,000
35
-
45,000
-
12
6063-T83
0.050 - 0.150
EC-H12
Vil - 1
12,000
15,000
8,000
- % Ys- Yz
14,000
17,000
12,000
16,000
14,000
20
20,000
15,000
19,000
17,000
14
EC-H13
j~
EC-H17
-
EC-H111 EC-Hl12
Vil- Y2
lh - 1 1
- 1Yz
17,000 9,000
-
4,000
-
-
12,000 11,000 10,000
-
7,000 5,000 4,000
-
-
-
* * * *
-
*Elongation of these tempers will be equal to or greater than the elongation of EC-HI2.
Electrical Properties of Aluminum Bus Bar Alloys
TABLE 2 - PERCENTAGE VOLUME CONDUC· TIVITY (lACS) OF BUS CONDUCTOR ALLOYS AT 20 C
Conductivity-The selection of a bus conductor alloy for current carrying ability is based primarily on its electrical conductivity. In 1913, the International Annealed Copper Standard (lACS) was estabUshed based on annealed copper at 20 C and designating 100 per cent volume conductivity for a rod one meter in length and one square millimeter in cross section, having a resistance of 0.017241 ohm. This is the basis for establishing the percentage conductivity of other metals and their alloys. The percentage volume conductivity of these materials will be inversely proportional to the resistance of identical specimens at 20 C, e.g., the per cent conductivity of an EC (electrical conductor) grade aluminum wire one meter long and having the same one square millimeter cross section and a resistance of 0.028264 ohm at 20 C will have a per cent volume conductivity as follows: Per Cent Conductivity of EC 0.01724:1 100% - 0.028264 Per Cent Conductivity of EC = 61%. The per cent volume conductivity (lACS) for the common bus bar alloys is given in Table 2.
Thermal Properties of Bus Conductors
Resistivity-Resistivity is the reciprocal of conductivity and, like conductivity, is expressed on either a volume or a weight basis. Standard values for resistivity are also based on a temperature of 20 C. These values
Temperature Coefficient of Resistance-Standards for conductivity and resistivity are established for a tem.~ perature of 20 C, and d-c resistance calculations using these values will give resistance at 20 C. Conversi9n '
2
Bus Conductor Alloy
EC Grade (All Tempers) 55 EC 56 EC 57 EC 59 EC 6063-T6 6063-T83 6061-T6 1100 (Annealed) 1100 (Hard)
. . . . . . . . . .
Minimum
Typical
61 55 56 57 59 51
62 56 57 58 53 56 40 59 57
provide the basis for the calculation of. resistance of bus conductors according to formulas presented in the section on electrical characteristics. The resistivity of common bus conductor alloys is given in Table 3 in both units of volume and weight resistivity.
,i
general- section I
tABLE 3 -
RESISTIVITY (p) OF ALUMINUM BUS CONDUCTOR ALLOYS AT 20 C
. .
-
(Based on Minimum and Typical Conductivity Values)
'.
..
Maximum Values
~"'. : ,
EC Grade 610/0 Condue-
" :.
tivity
,,"
57 EC 570/0 Conductivity
56 EC 560/0 Conductivity
Typical Values
55 EC 55% Conductivity
6063-T6 51~ Con uctivity
EC Grade 62~ Con tlCtivity
1100 Annealed 59% Conductivity
55 EC, 56 EC 1100-Hard 57% Conductivity
Wef~~t Resistivity
6063-T6 53% Conductivity
6063-T83 56% Con duc·tivity
6061-T6 40% Conductivity
'.
,,'II ••
436.24 0.07640 ·¢!crohms-pound/feet' 15.65 ., ~Iuiis-pound/mile' .,. ¢~-gram fmeter' ..
466.85 0.08176 16.75
475.19 0.08322 17.05
483.83 0.08473 17.36
521.78 0.09138 18.72
429.20 0.07516 15.40
451.03 0.07899 16.18
466.85 0.08176 16.75
502.09 0.08793 18.01
475.19 0.08322 17.04
18.195 0.03025 1.191 14.29 3.025
18.520 0.03079 1.212 14.55 3.079
18.857 0.03135 1.234 14.81 3.135
20.336 0.03381 1.331 15.97 3.381
16.728 0.02781 1.095 13.14 2.781
17.578 0.02922 1.151 13.81 2.922
18.195 0.03025 1.191 14.29 3.025
19.568 0.03253 1.281 15.37 3.253
18.520 0.03079 1.212 14.55 3.079
665.27 0.1165 23.86
V:~~~e Resistivity ';ohms-cir mil/foot .... :Johms-sq rom/meter .. ·microhms-inch iIiicrohms--
17.002 0.02826 1.113 13.35 2.826
:tb other temperatures is often necessary, and the tem,iperature coefficient of resistance (a) is used for this, ,see Table 4. Generally, each metal has a unique doc ~esistance vs. temperature characteristic which is lin';ear in the range of temperatures usually encountered. .The temperature coefficient is derived from the slope · .bf the linear portion and indicates the amount of .' change in doc resistance per degree Centigrade of .temperature change. . A series of metals having like structure but different ·"chemical content exhibit a thermal coefficient of re· sistance which is proportional to their conductivity. .: Thus, alloying or work hardening effects on aluminum I and copper which alter conductivity, also change the ·; temperature coefficient of resistance correspondingly. · . This is expressed mathematically as follows: ~,
'~i"
'
'.
a20
= 66
X
10-6
A.20
(at 20 C).
\>1.; Where: a
is the temperature coefficient of resistance
25.928 0.04310 1.697 20.36 4.310
to raise its temperature a given amount. On an equal weight basis, aluminum has a higher specific heat than copper. EC aluminum is 0.214 cal/gmrC and copper 0.0921 cal/gmrC. On an equal doc resistance basis, the thermal capacities are approximately equal. This high thermal storage capacity enables aluminum bus to withstand high overloads and short circuit currents. Test results show that under short circuit conditions, the bum-off characteristics of equivalent sizes of aluminum and copper conductors are similar. Specific heat values for a number of aluminum bus conductor alloys are: Aluminum Alloys
EC Grade 6063 55 EC (6101) 56 EC (6101)
Specific Heat
0.214 cal/gmrC 0.23 callgmr C 0.23 cal/gmrC 0.23 cal/gmrC
A. is the per cent conductivity (lACS) at 20 C.
TABLE 4-THERMAL COEFFICIENT OF RESISTANCE (a) AT 20 C
Aluminum Alloy
EC 59EC · 57 EC 56EC 55 EC 6063-T6 '"
.. . . . . .
Per Cent Volume Conductivity (lACS)
Thermal Coefficient of Resistance at 20 C
61 minimum 59 minimum 57 minimum 56 minimum 55 minimum 53 typical
0.00403 .0.00389 0,00376 0.00370 0.00363 0.00350
A more complete table of thermal coefficients of resistance is given in the section on electrical charac-· teristics along with examples of resistance conversions to other temperatures, see page 17. Specific Heat-The specific heat of a bus conductor material is a measure of the thermal energy required
Thermal Conductivity-The thermal conductivity of a material is its ability to conduct or carry away heat from a high temperature area and distribute and dissipate it. On an equal weight basis, aluminum bus conductor has higher thermal conductance than both steel and copper. On an equivalent resistance basis, the thermal conductance is comparable for both aluminum and copper bus conductors.}'-·
THERMAL CONDUCTIVITY AT 20 C (WATTS/IN2 IIN/SECI °C) Material
ECAluminum 59 EC, 1100 Soft 57 EC, 1100 Hard 56 EC, 6063-T83 55EC 6063-T6 6061-T6
....
Watts/in' /in/sec/oC
5.9 5.7 5.5 5.4 5.3 5.1 3.9 3
r I
section I - general
I
I I
I ,!'
i
,
(,
, i'
1.1
"
i:
! Ii ji
:.;
'I "I
Effect of Heating on Tensile Strength-The generally accepted maximum continuous operating temperature limit for electrical bus conductor is 70 C. This maximum continuous operating temperature is established at an ambient temperature of 40 C with a conductor temperature rise above ambient of 30 C. These are the standard conditions used to e,stablish the continuous current ratings of bus conductors. These ratings are described in detail in the section on electrical characteristics, page 40. The effect of this 70 C temperature upon the physical properties of aluminum bus conductor is negligible. However, short time emergency conditions or high ambient conditions may cause conductor temperatures in excess of the normal 70 C operation, and the effects of heating' should be considered for such conditions. The effect of time at temperature on the hot and cold tensile' strengths of EC-Hl1 and 6063-T6 aluminum bus ,conductor is shown in Figs. 1 and 2. All alloys show a reduction in tensile strength at elevated tempera.wres. For EC-H17 alloy, tensile strength ranges from 20,000 psi at room temperature to approximately 10,000 psi at 200 C. Likewise, the tensile strength of alloy 6063-T6 falls upon heating, the extent depending upon the magnitude of the temperature as shown in Fig. 1. A similar behavior can be expected from 55 EC, 56 EC, 57 EC, and 59 EC.
These curves also show the effect of continued heating at elevated temperatures. The downward trend of the EC-H17 curves indicates progressive annealing. It is not significant until temperatures exceed 100 C where annealing just starts or proceeg.s very slowly. With rising temperature, the rate of an- . neal becomes progressively faster. At approximately 570 C, annealing is very rapid. Short time emergency overloads can be safely carried on EC aluminum bus conductor without seriously affecting its strength properties. At temperatures of approximately 150 C and below, the continued heating of 6063-T6 has the effect of artificially aging the alloy, and tensile strength.. may actually increase for a period of time before annealing is initiated. At temperatures exceeding 175 C, the continuous heating of 6063-T6 alloy produces an immediate reduction in tensile strength which is more pronounced than for EC-H17. The consequences of continued overheating of bus conductors must also be considered in bolted bus conductor joints where reduced clamping forces may result unless conservative methods of joining are used. These are described in the section on mechanical joining, see page 79. The cumulative effects of continued heating of aluminum bus conductors after they have cooled to
45000 , . . . . . - - - - , - - - - - - , - - - - - , - - - - - , . - - - - ,
45000 TENSILE STRENGTH AT ROOM TEMPERATURE AFTER HEATING
TENSILE STRENGTH AT ELEVATED TEMPERATURES
II
40oo01-----j----+----+----+----j
40000
35000 I - - - - - - - i - - - - / - - - - - t - - - - - + - - - - - j 65 C
35000
.1
6063 -T6
85 C
30000 r6:
,T6
3ססoo
v; <>.
150 C
~ 25000 ~--+--=1r::-i75~=t"'-'---=4---_l_-~~-l~ 25000
C>
Cl Z
z .... '" lU
lU
.... '"
II)
~
II)
20000
f----~----T~""'---+---,..,__---l
lU
v;
':=
w
lU
.... EC-+--~""-
15000
, I !
20000
E~
II)
z ....
Z
-H17
15000
-H17
10000 I---*-'-+~
10000
5000 1 - - - - 1 1 - - - - - + - - - - / - - - - - + - - - - 1
O'--_ _--' 0.1
1.0
--J.
--'--
10 100 HEATING PERIOD, HOURS
Fig. 1
--'-
1000
--'
10000
-+
5 0 0 0 1 - - - - 1 - - - - + - - - - + -_ _
1
O'-:-_ _-:'~--_:::_----'-----L--_:_:_:~ 0.1
1.0
10 100 HEATING PERIOD, HOURS
1000
10000
Fig. 2 Courtes!I Aluminum Co. of America
4 "i j
general - section I 6063-T6
EC-HI7
EC - H12
35000
32 C
30000
25000
10000
15000
32 C 10000
-
100 C
"-
ISO C
5000
200 C
200 C
o 10
100 TIME, HOURS
1000
10
100
1000
TIME, HOURS
Fig. 3 - Creep Characteristics of Bus Alloys
room temperature are shown in Fig. 2. These curves are similar to the curves showing tensile strength at elevated temperatures, Fig. 1, but at room temperatures, the cumulative effects of this heating show a more pronounced annealing. The curves also show a signi£cant gain in the tensile strength of- alloy 6063-T6 at room temperature due to arti£cial aging' at these elevated temperatures. Creep of Aluminum Bus Conductors-In some applications of aluminum bus conductor, high temperature and stress may be sufficient to cause a gradual plastic deformation of the metal. This is referred to as creep, and its rate is a function of both stress and temperature. Bolted bus conductor joints are particularly vulnerable to this phenomenon as bolting stresses may be high and current loadings produce a temperature rise that results in signi£cant rates of creep. The reliability of bolted joints can be affected by these higher rates of creep unless design measures are incorporated to prevent serious reduction in the pressure applied to the joint. This is discussed in the section on mechanical joining, see page 81. The curves shown in Fig. 3 indicate the creep characteristics for EC-HI2, EC-HI1, and 6063-T6 aluminum alloys. The EC aluminum alloys show less creep resistance than the heat-treatable alloys such as 6063-T6, 55 EC, 56 EC, and 57 EC. EC-HI2 bus conductor has less creep resistance than EC-H17 at low
10
100 1000 TIME, HOURS Cow'tesy Aluminum Co, of America,
temperatures, but this is reversed at the higher temperatures (at approximately 150 C and up) where the recrystallization of EC-HI7 is more rapid. Resistance to creep at room temperature of bus conductor alloys in order of increasing resistance is ECHIll, EC-HI2, EC-H1l2, EC-H13, EC-HI7, 57 EC, 56 EC, 55 EC, 6063-T6, and 6063-T83. The creep characteristics of 55 EC and 56 EC alloys are expected to be slightly lower tllan alloy 6063-T6.
Corrosion Resistance Aluminum owes its excellent resistance to corrosion to a thin, tightly adherent £lm of aluminum oxide that forms instantaneously when the metal is exposed to the atmosphere. This protective layer resists attack under many conditions of service. Under severe exposure, a heavier £lm may form. Thus, a corrosion process is likely to be self stopping before signi£cant attack has occurred. The service performance of aluminum bus bar will follow closely these general con./', cepts of the corrosion behavior of aluminum. The aluminum alloys EC, 6063, 55 EC, 56 Ee, 51 EC, and 59 EC are especially well suited for bus bar applications. Except for EC grade aluminum, these alloys are of tlle silicon-magnesium group with only small percentages of alloying elements added to increase their physical properties. These alloying elements make possible a group of aluminum alloys recognized 5
l.
C
section I - geneml
for superior corrosion resistance. Because of the higher aluminum content of EC, it will have a more uniform, naturally formed, protective oxide layer than other aluminum alloys. Consequently, EC may demonstrate slightly superior resistance to corrosion in more severe atmospheres. In view of the substantial metal sections used in bus bar applications, corrosion should present no problem under all normal conditions of service.
General Classes of Bus Conductor Alloys Aluminum bus conductor alloys fall into two general classes: 1. Non-heat-treatable alloys which achieve strength
through cold working; 2. Heat-treatable alloys that obtain their properties through heat treatment alone or in combination with cold working.
., , !
'1.,
I' i
Non-Beat-Treatable Bus Alloys-Where high conductivity is essential, EC aluminum is usually required. EC grade aluminum has a nominal purity in excess of 99.45 per cent aluminum. The many tempers of this alloy offer a range of physical properties with all tempers having a minimum conductivity of 61 per cent (lACS). The softer tempers of EC bus bar such as EC-H12 and EC-H13 are normally used where edge bending characteristics or other extreme forming propelties are desired. Often, the lower cost of these softer tempers determines the selection when strength is not an essential requirement. Commercially pure aluminum alloy-99 per cent aluminum-designated as alloy 1100 is sometimes used for bus conductors. Although its conductivity is somewhat less than that of EC grade aluminum, it may be more readily available in standard shapes where only small quantities are required. Alloy 1100 has 57 per cent conductivity in the full hard temper and 59 per cent in its softest temper. Other standard non-heat-treatable aluminum alloys may be used for bus conductor, but since conductivity is greatly affected by small amounts of alloying elements, they find only limited use for electrical purposes. Such alloys, however, may be more readily available in the standard shapes for small requirements. Or, if some other characteristic is desired, such as strength, ease of welding, brazing, or soldering, then their use may be preferable. Temper Designation for Non-Beat·Treatable Bus Bar Alloys-Several tempers, from soft to full hard, apply to the non-heat-treatable bus bar alloys. The temper designation follows the alloy designation, e.g., in the bus bar alloy EC-H17, the temper designation is H17 and is separated from the alloy designation by a hyphen.
6
The standard temper designations show two things: They identify the specific temper; They indicate how that temper is obtained. Tempering by cold rolling or cold drawing is indicated by the letter "H" followed by two digits, e.g., H12, H24, H36. The first digit indicates the manufacturing process used to obtain the temper, i.e.: I-indicates that the bus bar is hardened by cold working the material after annealing, such as by cold rolling or drawing; 2-indicates that the material is first cold worked to a higher temper than desired and then partially annealed to the desired temper; 3-indicates that the material is cold worked after annealing and then stabilized. Stabilizing is a low temperature treatment-IOO F-400 F-and is usually confined to alloys containing magnesium as the principal alloying agent. The second digit of the temper designation indicates the degree of hardness or temper, e.g., the following designations have tempers indicated by their second digit: HI2-~hard;
Hi4-~hard;
HI6-%ohard; HiS-full hard; Hi~-extra hard-usually reserved for EC drawn wire. EC bus bar tempers depart from the standard tempers in two instances where intermediate tempers have been found desirable for bus bar applications. These intermediate tempers are designated as: EC-HI3-properties between % and liz hard; EC-H17-usually designated as the hard temper for EC bus bar. Two other letter designations are used for indicating temper. These are designated "0" and "F." "0" indicates material that is fully annealed or dead
soft; "F" indicates the "as fabricated" condition where the process does not control the temper. Heat-Treatable Bus Alloys-A number of heat-treatable alloys are available for bus conductor. Those used most frequently are as follows: Alloy
6063-T6 6063-T83 55 EC (6101-T6) 56 EC (6101-T62) 57EC (6101-T61) 59 EC (6101-Hll1) 6061-T6
Principal Alloying Elements
magnesium and silicon; magnesium and silicon; magnesium and silicon; magnesium and silicon; magnesium and'silicon; magnesium and silicon; magnesium, silicon, chromium, and copper.
These alloys are all of the magnesium-silicon group with 6061 having small amounts of chromium and
geneml- section I I
~
65
I
I 111111
I IIIIII
I
I 111111
I
-- --. '~
I III III
cu.
"- ". TI.
60
~ 0.01
I
I 1I1III
0.1
I
I I I 1111
1.0
I
I I 11111
10.0
ADDED ElEMENT, PER CENT
Fig. 4
i ,,'
I 11111
I
I IIIII
NI.
-.......
51.
50
\
I 111111
I
55
\
I
1111111
'\
:'-ZN.
\
I
I J J '"I
M~
65
\MG.
0.001
I
copper added to impart greater strength. The addition . of alloying elements to aluminum adversely affects the conductivity of all aluminum alloys. However, the strength and superior creep performance imparted to them and the ease of fabricating these alloys into bus conductor gives them a decided economic advantage over the EC bus bar tempers. The addition of magnesium and silicon in the proper proportions, along with other impurities, depresses the conductivity. A close control of such additions, plus a similar control of the amounts of other impurities permits ~aintenance of conductivity at an adequately high level. Certain impurities have a greater effect on conductivity than others, and the chemical content of these undesirable elements must be established at low levels. The curves in Figs. 4 and 5 show comparatively the effect of adding small quantities of several elements on the conductivity of pure aluminum. Among those having the greatest effect on conductivity are vanadium, titanium, chromium, and manganese. Small traces of these elements in quantities of 0.01 to 0.1 per cent have a pronounced effect on conductivity. Elements such as copper, iron, silver, magnesium, and silicon have slightly less effect when present in this percentage, but have noticeable effect when percentages exceed 0.1. Even less effect on conductivity is produced by such impurities as zinc, nickel, gold, and gallium. Concentrations up to one per cent have only a small effect, while greater percentages depress conductivity appreciably. Some of the alloying elements added to aluminum form inter-metallic compounds. Of principal impor-
I
0.001
I 111111
0.01
I
I 111'11
I
I 111111
0.1 1.0 ADDED ELEMENT, PER CENT
I
I 111111
10.0
Fig. 5
tance in bus bar alloys is the combination of magnesium and silicon into tlle compound magnesium silicide (Mg2 Si). This inter-metallic compound has less effect on the conductivity of a bus conductor than the total effect these elements would produce individually. The proportions of magnesium and silicon added to bus conductor alloys is made in the proper ratio to produce Mg 2 Si. The addition of silicon is usually slightly in excess of these requirements so that the bus conductor will have a small free silicon content rather than. a free magnesium content, sihce the latter has a greater effect in depressing the conductivity of the , alloy. Boron is sometimes intentionally added to electrical conductor materials to improve their conductivity. This element does not directly increase conductivity but achieves this effect by its tendency to precipitate other elements from their solid solution state in these aluminum alloys. In particular,Jboron helps to precipitate titanium, since this element depresses conductivity when present in very small percentages. Temper Designations for Heat·Treatable Bus Bar Alloys-The stable tempers resulting from various heat treatments applied to heat-treatable aluminum alloys are designated by tlle letter "T"followed by a single digit oi· several digits which indicate the particular heat treating method or combination of methods, e.g.: T3-indicates the material has been solution heat treated and then cold worked;
7
section I - general
T4-indicates the material has been solution heat treated only; T5-indicates the material has been artillcially aged only-precipitation heat b'eatment; T6-indicates the material has been solution heat treated, then artillcially aged; T8-indicates the material has been solution heat treated, cold worked, and then artificially aged. Added numbers to designations denote a modification of these standards. Letter designations such as "W," "0," and "F" also apply to heat-treatable alloys.
·
W-indicates the unstable condition of the material following solution heat treatment; O-indicates material that is fully annealed or dead soft; F-indicates the "as fabricated" condition where no control of temper is made during the process.
I
,. 'I ,
;
" ii "
I
['/'
"',
.,
Solution heat 'freatment is a high temperature treatment ranging approximately from 900 to 975 F. At this temperature, certain alloying elements go into solution or dissolve in the solid metal. The materials are then quenched, usually in cold water, to retain
these alloying elements in solid solution. The material after quenching has relatively low physical properties.. This is not a stable condition, however, as these elements are not as soluble at room temperature. Immediately after quenching, these alloying elements begin . to precipitate from the solid solution. This precipitation produces extremely small grains of the alloying ,elements in the solid metal, and the strength at room temperature increases as this precipitation or aging continues. The rate of precipitation or natural aging varies with different alloys. In alloy 2024-T4, precipitation progresses rapidly and uniformly at room temperature and is virtually complete at the end of four days at which time maximum physical properties are attained. Precipitation heat treatment or artificial aging at relatively low temperatures is necessary in some alloys to develop their maximum physical properties. In these alloys, the natural aging process is not sufficient to"i develop maximum physical properties. A low tempera~ .1 ture treatment ·for a specified time accelerates the precipitation process. The extent of this precipitation is controlled by the length of time and the temperature. This will vary for the different alloys.
:'1
I'
BUS CONDUCTOR SHAPES
I
,
,i j
"
Rectangular Bar The most common form of aluminum bus conductor is rectangular bar. It presents large exposed surfaces for heat dissipation. Several bars can be paralleled with a small air space between each bar to build up a bus of high current capacity. The many flat exposed surfaces, both internal and external, readily provide for the dissipation of generated heat. The capacity of such a bus is theoretically unlimited when carrying direct current since the current is distributed uniformly in an isolated d-c conductor. However, when used to carry alternating current, special arrangements must be resorted to on high capacity installations to maintain a more uniforIn distribution of current. Rectangular bar can be more easily jollied than other shapes of bus conductor. The broad flat surfaces are bolted together without special fittings and also to standard equipment terminals. Welding, brazing, and soldering rectangular bar are easily accomplished where these methods of joining are preferred. Rectangular bar is more rigid in the direction of its larger dimension; supports must be closely spaced where loads or short circuit forces are perpendicular to the flat surfaces of the bar. , Electrical applications for rectangular bus conductor are extensive. It is used in many fabricated products such as bus duct, switchboards, panelboards, metal clad switch gear, equipment terminals, and other similar electrical products. It is also used extensively for
8
high capacity d-c buses, in generating stations, substations, and many industrial and commercial plants where it may be fabricated and installed on the job. Rectangular bar is the most versatile of all conductor shapes because it can be easily formed in 90 degree flat bends and readily joined and attached to wall supports and building structures. Edge Contours-Various standard edge contours are available with rectangular bar. These contours are specified by ASTM Specification B236* for EC rectangular bar. Sketches with a description of the standard tolerances applying to each are shown. Square Corners-Bar finished with commercially square corners will have a maximum permissible corner radius as follows: lh2 inch radius for . bar 78 to 1 inch inclusive in thickness, ~6 inch radius for bar over 1 inch in thickness. Rounded Corners-Bar finished with corners rounded to a quarter circle will have the following corner radius: %2 inch radius for bar 78 to %6 inch inclusive, l!J.6 inch radius for bar over ~16 to 1 inch inclusive in thickness, 78 inch radius for bar over 1 inch in thickness.
CJ
CJ
* Complete specification on page 149.
geneml- section I
Rounded Edge-Bar finished with rounded edges will have a radius of curvature approximately 1~ times the thickness of the bar for bar % inch and over in thickness. The tolerance on the radius shall be ~ the thickness of the bar. Fttll Rounded Edge-Bar finished with full rounded edge will have a uniform round edge with a radius of curvature approximately one half the thickness of the bar, but in no case will the radius exceed lh the thickness by more than 25 per cent. Sawed Edge-A rough surfaced edge showing saw marks and very slight or no deformation of the corners. The sawing operation leaves a slight burr on the corners which is generally not completely removed and which may necessitate care in handling.
Aluminum Rectangular Bar Alloys-Rectangular bar is produced in several bus conductor alloys and in many tempers of EC grade aluminum from annealed to full hard, depending upon the physical properties desired and the degree of fmming or bending necessary. The alloys most commonly used for rectangular bar are: ConductivityAlloy Per Cent (lACS) EC-H111 61-62 61-62 EC-H1l2 EC-H12 61-62 61-62 EC-H13 EC-H17 61-62 55-56 55EC 56-57 56EC 57-58 57EC 59EC 59-60 57-59 1100
and EC-H13 which it replaces. Its forming and bending characteristics approach these Ee tempers. 3. 59 EC is the most ductile of the alloy rectangular bars and is intended to be used for severe forming or bending operations such as edge bending. It is comparable to EC-HI2 for this use. The EC-HIll and EC-H1l2 rectangular bar alloys are designations for the "as fabricated" condition of EC grade aluminum. EC-H1ll is the designation for an "as extruded" bar, and EC-H112 is the designation for rectangular bar sawed to required widths from hot rolled EC plate.
Bending Properties-The bending properties of rectangular bar often detelmine the selection of a bus alloy and temper. Certain applications may require the bar to make both edge and flat bends. The physical properties and dimensional shape of the bar are factors which govern its bending properties. Bending properties are described as follows: 1. Edge bending requirements for EC-Hlll, ECH1l2, EC-HI2, and EC-HI3 rectangular bar 4 inches or less in width are established by ASTM Specification B236-"Aluminum Bars for Electrical Purposes." No edge bending requirements have been established for EC-HI7. Of the rectangular heat-h'eatable alloy bars, only the lower tensile sh'ength materials are recommended for edge bending. Alloy 59 EC is the most ductile in this class and is preferred for edge bending applications. Alloy 56 EC is not recommended for edge bending and alloy 57 EC for only very limited edge bending. 2. For flat bending, the following EC alloys can be bent 90 degrees aTOund a radius equal to its thickness without cracking or evidence of sliversEC-HIlI; EC-H1l2; EC-HI2; EC-HI3. See ASTM Specification B236. EC-HI7 requires a slightly larger flat bending radius. A 2t radius is suggested for this alloy. Flat bends for aluminum alloy bus conductor are governed by the following:
FLAT BEND RADIUS
Alloy Selection-Alloys for aluminum rectangular bar have a considerable range of electrical and physical properties. This versatility gives the designer wide latitude in adapting aluminum rectangular bus conductor to the requirements of a particular application. In many instances, several alloys may be used for the same application. Where conductivity can be saCl-ificed, lower cost alloys may be substituted. For example: 1. 55 EC and 56 EC are lower cost alloys, have lower
conductivity, but higher strength than, EC-H17 which they often replace; 2. 57 EC is a lower cost alloy, has lower conductivity, ' but higher strength characteristics than EC-H12
Alloy 55EC 56EC 57EC 59EC
TIlickness, t (Inches)
0-0.499 0-0.499 0-0.499 0.500-0.749 All Thicknesses
Bend Radius
2t It It
2t It
Specifications-A specification for EC aluminum rectangular bus bar has been tentatively issued by ASTM . (American Society for Testing Materials) and is designated as ASTM B236 "Aluminum Bars for Electrical Purposes," (Bus Bars). This specification covers only EC grade aluminum bars in all tempers. It is reprinted on page 149.
9
section I - general
ROlmd Tubular Conductor ROUild hlbular conductors are used primarily in outdoor sub-stations and switching structures where long spans between supports are required. They are also used for generator phase bus. The inherent rigidity of a tubular shape in all directions resists lateral forces such as wind loads; vertical loads that include its own dead weight and accumulated ice formations; and in addition to these loads, the forces due to short circuit currents. The light weight of an aluminum hlbular shape provides a minimum bare deflection, thus presenting visually a straight uniform appearance. Tubular conductors are generally manufactured in Iron Pipe Sizes (IPS). Physical and electrical characteristics for both the standard IPS and the extra heavy pipe sizes are given on pages 126 and 127. Fittings for these IPS conductors are standard and can be obtained from accessory manufacturers for coupling lengths together, for making connections and terminals, Fig. 6, and for expansion joints and supports. The practice of welding joints in hlbular conductor is gaining in acceptance and general use. A properly welded joint has the advantage of being a pelmanent connection and as reliable as the conductor itself, Fig. 7.
I i
I: •j
t
Electrical Characteristics-A round hlbular shape is the most efficient electrical shape for an a-c bus conductor. Alternating current is distributed more unifonnly in tubing than in other shapes, hence it has the lowest skin effect of commonly used bus conductors. Its current rating is limited, however, in comparison with rectangular bar conductor because of the smaller ratio of smface area to volume for the dissipation of heat. The internal cooling of tubular conductors by forced air or circulating liquid coolants finds very limited application. , Due to skin effect, optimum w'all thickness for all sizes of EC aluminum tubular conductors carrying 60 cycle alternating current is approximately 11!J.6 inch; for aluminum alloy 6063-T6, the optimum wall thickness is approximately 0.8 fuch for all diameters. Conductor wall thicknesses greater than these add nothing to the current carrying capacity. This means that only a limited range of wall thicknesses is available for tube of given diameter and conductivity which results in a limited range of available alternating current ratings for each diameter tubular conductor. Further details are given on page 22.
a
I'
, I
r
"
,
. ..
; ~
Alloys-Strength is usually the primary requirement of a hlbular conductor used for long span construction. Hence, the higher sb'ength alloys such as 6063T6, 56 EC, and 57 EC are generally used for this application although conductivity is somewhat lower than for the EC grade conductors. These alloy con10
ductors are heat treated to improve their physical properties, and hence, are lower in cost than the EC tempers which require cold drawing. Tubular con-
Fig. 6 - Bolted Construction
Fig. 7 - Welded Construction
ductors can be fabricated from many aluminum alloys. The required physical and elecb'ical properties, along with cost, will determine the most suitable alloy for the application. Bending Properties-Satisfactory 90 degree bends and offsets can be made with tubular conductors, thus eliminating many fittings. Bends are made without elaborate equipment except for short radius bends. The curve shown in Fig. 8 gives the conditions for satisfactory bends with tubular conductors of alloys 6063-T6, 6063-TS3, 56 EC, and 57 EC. The EC tempers can also be bent Field bending is shown in Fig, 9.
geneml- section I
Skin effect resistance ratios are slightly greater than for round tubular conductor of the same wall thickness and diameter. Electrically, it is a very efficient conductor shape. The optimum wall thickness of square tubing, due to skin effect, is approximately the same as for round tubular conductor ·of the same material. Wall thicknesses greater than this value are not practical because alternating current ratings are not increased. A small range of alternating current ratings can be obtained for a given size tube by varying the wall thickness below the optimum value.
16
~18
f--
II
AREA No.1
uJ 12 Z'" uJ::>
~
~
!
Z~
,
!
1/
uJO
4
6 ~
2
'"
/
/
V
/
V
/
/ I
V
'/
ffiV5
u
/
I
ZD
i
./V
./
AREA No.3
V
4:;;;: "'4:
-uJ 6 ~o
II·
/
"'...00 10 ::>uJ "'''' -...OuJ 8
I
VAREA No.2
-
o ~.
V
/1
14
./V
/
1/
r/ V
V
_~~o,
AREA No.4
/
\
V
tR . .- TK
~'-~
/
'£. V
AREA No, 5
o
20
40
60
RATIO,
80
lOa.
120
140
OUTSIDE DIAMETER OF TUBE THICKNESS OF TUBE WALL =
160
180
200
0.0.
TK
Fig. 8 Area No. I-No Mandrel or Wiper Die Area No.2-Plug Mandrel and Wiper Die Area No.3-One Ball Mandrel Area No. 4- Two Ball Mandrel and Wiper Die Area No..5-Nat'Practical
Alloys-The high short circuit strength requirements of a square tubular bus usually require a heat-treatable, high strength alloy. Alloys 6063-T6 and 57 EC are generally used for this purpose. The cost and difficulty of drawing EC grade aluminum and the limited strength after drawing usually preclude the use of EC grade aluminum for square tubular conductor.
Channel and Angle Conductor Channels and angles used for bus conductors can either be rolled, extruded, or formed. These shapes may conform to the standard structural channel or angle section used in the steel indusby or they may be of special design for electrical applications. Where they are used for a-c buses, they are usually arranged to form a hollow square to provide an efficient elecb'ical configuration having a low skin effect resistance ratio. This is illusb'ated in Fig. 10.
T
..
l[JIO Courtesy Tal Bending Equip., Inc.
Fig. 9 - Field Bending
Square Tubular Conductor Square tubular conductors are used for applications reqt.Jiring high current carrying capacity and greater rigidity to resist extremely high short circuit forces. They are .used primarily for generator phase bus and for high capacity station bus. Courtesy General Electric Co.
I.
Electrical Characteristics-The current carrying capacity of square tubular conductor, like round tubing, is limited because of the smaller amount of exposed surface area for the dissipation of generated heat. To ventilate the interior surfaces, large holes are sometimes provided in the top and bottom surfaces to supply additional internal cooling by convectiop. air currents.
Fig. 10
The channel alTangements shown approximate square tubular conductor in both electrical characteristics and rigidity with the added advantage of providing cooling for the interior surfaces by convection. Current carrying capacity is thereby increased over an equivalent section of conventional square tubular con11
( I
I
;P-'=
section I - general
ductor. Where space is limited, such as in isolated phase bus, the special channels shown can be used to advantage. This is shown diagrammatically in the two equivalent sections, Fig. 10. The 5 inch special channel shapes arranged in box form have the same rating as the 7 inch standard channels. * In most cases, the size of the housing for isolated phase bus need not be increased when special aluminum channel sections are used.
!
I, ~
I
I I
il II' f
11'
,!, ;1] 1-. Ii
, .1
,
'I I.
:i1'1. i i'{ "j. ~ ,
\: )t
Applications-Standard channel conductor is used primarily for long span construction where a high current rating is desired and structural rigidity is necessary to withstand high short circuit forces. These sections can be used to advantage in outdoor substations and switching stations where a greater current capacity is desired than can be obtained with round or square tubular conductors. Channel bus conductor is also used in many low voltage, high current industrial applications for both a-c and d-c service. Typical of these applications is service to large rotating equipment, induction furnaces, rectifiers, and other mill installations having unusual current needs. It is also employed as bus conductor in industrial sub-stations and for bus ties between sub-stations or large electrical installations. Alloys-High current ratings, high short circuit forces, and long spans usually require high strength, heattreatable alloys such as 6063-T6 and 57 EC. Where even higher strength is desired and some conductivity can be sacrificed, 6061-T6 alloy may be used. For maximum conductivity, EC grade aluminum is preferred; however, the lower physical properties of EC aluminum must be considered in the design of supports, span lengths, and distances between buses. Usually the harder tempers of EC aluminum or a heattreatable alloy are most suited for a high capacity bus because of strength requirements..
t
~~ I
I
Ii 1
I
:1
II I:!: I' ~
t'
Other Conductor Shapes Special designs requiring non-standard shapes of bus conductor are readily fabricated from a number of aluminum alloys. These shapes, Fig. 11, may be produced by the extrusion process where a relatively
Fig. 11
simple extrusion die is required and the conductor thus produced will have close dimensional tolerances. The alloy selected will be governed by the physical and electrical properties required for the application and by cost consideration.
MANUFACTURING PROCESS AND TOLERANCES
!J, )
Fabrication-The broad flat surfaces of ch~umel and angle sections are used to advantage in joining sections of bus together. Flat plates may be bolted to both the inside and outside surfaces in either a straight splice or for making 90 degree angle bends. Prefabricated bus such as isolated phase bus is usually joined in this manner by bolting the prefabricated sections together in the field. Where standard channels and angles are fabricated on the job such as in an outdoor sub-station, these conductors are sometimes joined by welding. This method of joining is economical, particularly for the larger installations. Both methods of joining, either bolting or welding, give reliable elecbical joints when properly made.
.1
The methods of producing aluminum bus conductor generally fall into two classes: 1. Extruded bar and shapes; 2. Rolled bar and structural sections. Other methods are used to a limited extent for producing bus conductor. Among these is the casting method for producing large sections for high capacity bus. Bus conductor is also formed into various bus shapes from rolled aluminum sheet or plate. Drawn bus conductor is usually produced by one of the two basic methods of production indicated above and is an
* "Application of
Alumi.num Charulel Conductors for Station Bus," AlEE TECHNICAL PAPER 52-295, by E. J. Casey and N. Swerdlow, September, 1952.
12
added operation to achieve either strength, contoured edges, or dimensional tolerance. Each of the two general methods of production listed has its advantages and limitations, and discussion will be confined to these methods. The process used by the manufacturer in producing bus conductor should be the one that can most economically produce the quantity and the quality desired in the finished product. All of these basic production methods produce high quality bus conductor. The electrical properties of the conductor are not affected by the process used. The surface finish will be slightly different-each process producing its own inherent surface characteristics. Dimensional tolerances can be held to close
geneml- section I
limits with extruded or rolled bus bar. Cast bus bar has relatively larger tolerances.
Extruded Bar and Shapes The extrusion process is one of the most versatile used in producing bus conductor. All bus conductor alloys, both non-heat-treatable and heat-treatable, can be extruded into practically any shape desired. The process is particularly economical for the heat-treatable alloys which achieve strength through a heat treatment following the extrusion process. The nonheat-treatable alloys on the other hand, such as EC aluminum, must be cold worked to refine the grain structure and thereby impart greater strength to the "as extruded" material. This is done by cold drawing operations following the extrusion process in which the conductor is pulled through a die or series of dies, each being slightly smaller than the preceding one. The number of drawing operations required will depend on the amount of cold reduction necessary to produce the temper desired. The drawing operation is also limited by the shape of the section. Usually only the simple shapes such as rectangular bar, round bar, and round or square tubular sections lend themselves to a drawing operation. Irregular shapes create die design problems, and it is usually advisable to either extrude these shapes in a heat-treatable alloy, or as in the caSe of a standard structural section, it may be produced by cold rolling in rolling mill equipment.
Tolerances-Standard tolerances for aluminum extruded shapes and extruded rod and bar have been established by the Aluminum Association and applicable ASTM specifications. Aluminum Association tolerances are shown on pages 141 and 143 and are applicable to the average section. Column two tolerances in
the table on page 141 apply to all solid metal dimensions such as the thickness and width dimensions of rectangular bars and to all dimensions where 75 per cent or more of the dimension is solid metal. Standard tolerances for solid round bar and aluminum pipe are given on pages 124 and 126, respectively. The ASTM tolerances for EC aluminum rectangular bar in all tempers are shown on page 149.
Rolled Bar and Structural Shapes The production of rolled sections requires large rolling mill equipment which is not as flexible as the extrusion process. This generally limits the hot rolled and cold rolled bus conductor sections to standard structural shapes and flat or round bars. Edge contours on rectangular bar, other than square corners, are usually applied in separate edge rolling or drawing operations. The rolling process does offer advantages in processing wrought conductor alloys such as EC grade aluminum in rectangular or round bars and the standard structural shapes because cold working increases the temper of the material, imparting improved physical properties. Several tempers can be produced depending upon the degree of l~eduction in the rolling process. Hot rolled bus conductor is generally limited to rectangular bar which is sawed or sheared to width from hot rolled plate. In this form, it is designated as EC-H1l2. Although EC grade aluminum plate is commonly employed to produce hot rolled rectangular bar, commercially ptu'e almninum, 99 per cent aluminum which is designated as alloy llOO, can also be used. While dimensional tolerances can be closely controlled by cold rolling, greater dimensional accuracy and contoured edges usually require a drawing operation following cold or hot rolling..
Xl
t:
('l
13
-
--.~
---
-.
..= , ...
-'-'~~.,_
v
ELECTRICAL DESIGN OF BUS CONDUCTORS D-C RESISTANCE OF BUS CONDUCTORS
a
In long homogeneous conductor carrying a continuous current, the current is distributed through its cross section equally. The resistance is given by the formula:
R dc =
p
volume resistivity and weight resistivity corresponding to the per cent conductivity (lACS) at 20 C of aluminum and the various aluminum alloys used for bus conductor. For the per cent conductivity, (lACS), at 20 C of the various bus conductor alloys, see the table below.
L A ohms (at temperature, t)
in which R dc is the direct current resistance and p isthe volume resistivity of the conductor material, L is the length, and A is the cross sectional area, all at temperature, t. . This may also be written in terms of the weight resistivity, in which case it becomes:
R dc
= P WL
CONDUCTIVITY OF BUS BAR MATERIALS (Per Cent Conductivity (lACS) at 20 C) Material
EC (All Tempers) 1100-0
Minimum
Typical
61
62 59 57
1100-HIB
ohms (at temperature, t).
59EC 57EC 56EC 55EC 6063-T6 6063-T83 6061-T6 HD Copper
Here, p is the weight resistivity of the conductor material at temperature, t, and W is the weight of the conductor material ill either pounds or grams per unit of length consistent with the units of p. R dc is the d-c resistance at temperature, t. With these two formulas, the d-c resistance of a conductor can be calculated when the value of p is in any standard units. This means, however, that where p is given in ohms-cir mil/foot, the unit of area should be in circular mils and the length, L, should be in feet, or where p. is given as the weight resistivity in microhms-poundjfeetz, the weight, W, should be indi; cated in pounds per foot and the length, L, should be given in feet. The 'various values for p are shown in Table 1. This table lists the common units for both
59 57
•• .j'
i·
58 57 56 53 56 40 98
56 55
51
.,
Minimum conductivity is established by ASTM or company standards' and represents a guaranteed minimum conductivity for the respective alloy when purchased according to the governing specification. Typical conductivity values are not guaranteed. They are the representative values obtained from daily
TABLE 1 - RESISTIVITY (p) AT 2.0 C FOR BUS CONDUCTOR MATERIALS J"
% Conductivjty (lACS) at 20 C Aluminum Alloys Units Weight Resistivity
40%
Copper
51%
53%
55%
56%
57%
59%
60%
521.78 0.09138 18.72
502.09 0.08793 18.01
483.83 0.08473 17.36
475.19 0.08322 17.05
466.85 0.08176 16.75
451.03 0.07899 16.18
443.51 0.07767 15.91
20.336 0.03381 15.97 3.381
19.568 0.03253 15.37 3.253
18.857 0.03135 14.81 3.135
18.520 0.03079 14.55 3.079
·18.195 0.03025 14.29 3.025
17.578. 0.02922 13.81 2.922
17.285 0.02874 13.58 '2.q74
I /
61%
62.%.
98%
436.24 0.07640 15.65 .
429.20 0.07516 15.40
893.06 0.1564 32.03
*
Ohms·pound/mile" ... Ohms-gram/meter' Microhms-pound/feet'
665.27 0.1165 23.86
\
Volume Resistivity Ohms-cjr. mil./ft..... Ohms-mm' /meter .... Microhms-sq. in,fft... Microhms~cm. .......
*A
,
25.928 0.04310 20.36 4.310
?
i
~
....
. 17.002 0.02826 13.35 ~. 2.1126 ,,'
16.728 0.02781 13.14 2.2!l1 .
10.583 0.01759 8.31? I 059'
density of 2.703 is tak~n for ,aluminum far can'ductivity values 40-62 per: cent. A density of 8.89 is takeJ' for 98 per cent conductivity copper.
~.' -, ~
r!~ .-
I .70
(?
~
...
/« f
(.~
':?
I:{ / •
/. 16J. '
l- / S
/. / 3
///
·/oe;;;.-
. . ;.IJ
section II - electrical design
D = 1250 mils; A = (1250) 2 = 1,562,500 circular mils; L = 1 foot (unit of length) ; P = 17.002 ohms-cir mil/foot at 20 C (for 61 per cent lACS); ,
production mllS. Typical values will exceed the guaranteed minimum conductivity by a margin which allows for a small variance in the composition or manufachlring process.
L
Calculation of D·C Resistance
Rae=PA;
To illustrate the application of the d-c tesistance fonnulas to the calculation of d-c resistance for common aluminum bus bars, refer to the following problem.
R de
Required: The d-c resistance at 20 C of the following bus bars in microhms per foot: A. Flat rectangular bus bar 4 inches X % inch of EC grade aluminum; B. A I1f4 inch solid round EC bus of 61 per cent conductivity (lACS); C. A 1 112 inch standard IPS extmded almninum tubular bus of alloy 6063-T6 with a typical conductivity of 53 per cent (lACS); D. Extruded aluminum alloy channel bus-4 inches-2.16 lb.-of alloy 6063-T6. Solution: I-A. The d-c resistance of a4 inch X lf4 inch flat rectangular bus bar of EC grade aluminum in microluns per foot at 20 C is calculated as follows: A = 4 inches X % inch = 1 square inch cross sectional area; L = 1 foot (unit of length) ; p = 13.35 microhms per square inch per foot at 20 C (for 61 per cent lACS);
" II'
k ,I I;
,j
,I
Rae
i
,!
, I
L
,j
1
I
= 13.35 microhms
per
foot at 20 C.
;i
I
I-B. The d-c resistance of a 11;4 inch solid round bus of EC grade aluminum of 61 per cent conductivity in microhms per foot at 20 C is calculated as follows:
!:
!I it
"
Laboratory Tests Being Made on Aluminum Bus Conductor
16
The d-c resistance of a 1% inch IPS extruded aluminum alloy tubular bus of 6063-T6 with a typical conductivity of 53 per cent (lACS) is calculated in microluns per foot as follows:
= 0.939
pounds per foot (table on page 126); L = 1 foot; P = 18.01 microhms-lb/feet 2 at 20 C (for' 53 per cent lACS) ; L Rae=PW; W
I ;
I
R de
=
1 18.01 X 0.939
= 19.2 microhms per
foot at 20 C. ' I-D. The d-c resistance of a 4 inch-2.16 lb. extruded channel section of aluminum alloy 6063-T6 in microhms per foot is calculated as follows: A
= 1.84 square inches
(cross sectional area), see page 132; L = 1 foot (unit of length); P 15.37 microluns per square inch per foot at 20 C (for 53 per cent lACS) ;
=
R de
= 15.37 X 1.~4 =8.35 microhms per foot at 20 C.
= P A:;
Rae = 13.35 X
6
ohms per foot at 20 C; = 10.88 microhms per foot at 20 C. l~C.
PROBLEM NO. 1
1 = 17.002 X 1,562500 = 10.88 X 10,
Temperature Conversion of D·C Resistance The heating or coolin b of an aluminum conductor produces a d-c resistance change which is linear
electrical design - section II
f· :
within the normal operating temperatures of the conductor. Graphically, this is shown in Fig. 1. The projection of the linear portion of the curve to the horizontal axis denoting zero doc resistance establishes a theoretical "temperature of inferred zero resistance." This "temperature of inferred ·zero resistance" will be a characteristic of each bus conductor material having a given percentage conductivity (lACS). To convert d-c resistance values from any temperature, such as the standard 20 C temperature, to another temperature within the normal operating limits where the above curve is linear, the following can be used: R tl = R t [1 + at (t, - t)]. Where: R tl is the doc resistance desired at a temperature, t , (in degrees C);
20 C as conductivity, resistivity, and basic resistance values are standardized at this temperature. In Table 2, the value of a is established for other operating temperatures. Care should be taken in the substihItion of a in the foregoing doc resistance conversion formula that its value and the known resistance are both for the same temperahlre. Due to skin effect and other inductive phenomena, a-c resistance does not follow the same linear relationship of temperature versus resistance that the doc resistance follows for the normal operating temperatures. To arrive at the a-c resistance at any value of temperahIre, the doc resistance should first be corrected to the temperatme desired, using the d-c resistance conversion formula. The a-c resistance can then be calculated for that temperature by methods shown in succeeding pages.
R t is the known d-c resistance at a temperature, t (in degrees C); at is the tempel~atme coefficient of resistance at temperature, t; (t , -.,. t) is the change in temperature in degrees C. ;,.
Temperature Coefficient of Resistance (a) The temperature coefficient of resistance represents the change in doc resistance per degree C. Its value will vary with the material, its percentage conductivity, and the temperature. The standard temperature coefficient of resistance is given for a temperature of
Temp. dcg. C. 0 10 20 25
o
·r
TEMPERATU RE
Fig. 1
TABLE 2 -.TEMPERATURE COEFFICIENTS OF RESISTANCE (a) FOR BUS CONDUCTORS 'MATERIALS' O( PERCENTAGE CONPUCTlVITY (lACS) 40% Condo
51% Cond.1 53% Cond.1 55% Condo
0.00279 ·0.00271 0.00264
0.00361 0.00349 0.00337
"il.6026i
ii:'Oo33I
0.00376 0.00363 0.00350 0.00344
I
0.00391 0.00377 0.00363
'D.Do'357
56% Condo
57% Condo
59% Condo
60% Condo
0.00400 0.00384 0.00370 0.00363
0.00407 0.00391 0.00376 0.00369
0.00422 0.00405 0.00389 0.00382
0.00430 0.00412 0.00396
0.00257 0.00251 0.00245 0.00239
0.00326 0.00316 0.00306 0.00297
0.00338 0.00327 0.00317 0.00307
0.00350 0.00338 0.00327 0.00317 __ _ _••:;0
0.00357 0.00345 0.00333 0.00322
0.00362 0.00350 0.00338 0.00327
0.00374 0.00361 0.00348 0.00337
0.00381 0.00367 0.00354 0.00342
70 80 90 100
0.00233 0.00228 0.00223 0.00218
0.00288 0.00280 0.00273 0.00265
0.00298 0.00289 0.00281 0.00273
- 0.00307 0.00298 0.00289 0.00281
0.00312 0.00303 0.00294 0.00285
0.00316 0.00307 0.00298 0.00289
0.00326 0.00315 0.00306 0.00297
0.00331 0.00320 0.00310 0.00301
Materials Aoolicable
6061-T6
Min. 6063-T6
1
Typical 6063-T6
Min.. 55 EC
atl
65ltTB~
Min. 57 EC
Typical 1100 Annealed
J
~
= desired thermal coefficient of resistance
62% Condo 98% Condo 0.00445 0.00426 0.00409 0.00401
0.00417 0.00400 0.00385
0.00387..... '0.00373 0.00360 0.00347
0.00393 0.00378 0.00364 0.00351
0.00371 0.00357 0.00345 0.00334
0.00335 0.00325 .0.00314 0J)!l30~
0.00340 0.00328 0.00318 0.00308
0.00323 0.00313 0.00303 0.00294
Typical EC-All Tempers
Represen.. tative Value for Commercial Copper Bus Bar
0.00438 0.00420 0.00403 0.00395
ii:'iiii38ii
30 40 50 60
Min. 56EC
61"fo Condo
M;" EC-All Tempers
Q.'6O'378
= known value of thermal coefficient of resistance = temperature in degrees C of known value of coefficient of resistance t, = temperature in degrees C at which desired coefficient is wanted.
at t
section IT - electTical design
A·C RESISTANCE OF BUS CONDUCTORS
When a conductor is used to carry alternating current, its resistance is apparently increased over its d-c value by several factors. This increase over the d-c resistance may be the result of one or more phenomena, each contributing an increment of resistance to the total a-c resistance of the conductor. The design of an a-c bus installation is influenced by such factors as skin effect and proximity which act independently of each other to increase d-c resistance. Losses due to induced circulating currents and hysteresis have a related effect on conductor a-c resistance in that both are incurred by the magnetic field of the bus conductor. In the over-all design of a bus conductor for a-c installations, thought should be given to all factors that contribute to a-c resistance. The major factors are: 'I. Skin effect This phenomenon is the tendency of current to concentrate more in the outer layers of the conductor thus apparently increasing the d-c resistance due to less efficient dist:ribution of the current in the conductor. The alternating current frequency, the conductor cross sectional shape, and its d-c resistance are factors that influence the magnitude of skin effect.
ij
2. Proximity effect This is the influence of nearby current carrying conductors on the current distribution in a conductor. When the current in two closely spaced conductors is opposite in direction at any instant, the current will be crowded toward the facing sides. When the current is in the same direction, it will be crowded toward the outer sides. This is shown diagrammatically.
II
:\ d 'j ,I I
,I:-
CURRENTS IN OPPOSITE DIRECTIONS
I I
00
jt
I: " i;'
Ii I~
Current Crowded Toward Facing Sides
I'
I;
Current Crowded Toward Outer Faces
The extent to which proximity increases d-c resistance depends upon the closeness of the spacing. The curves in Fig. 2 show the effect of proximity on the current rating of 55 EC rectangular conductors when spaced on 18 inch and 4 inch centers. Although a slight additional reduction in current rating at 4 inches is due to mutual heating, the majority is due to proximity. The 18 inch spacing may be considered as adequate for most
I: "
i!
,"
CURRENTS IN SAME DIRECTION
"
18
installations to reduce proximity to a negligible amount. 3. Mutual heating effects Mutual heating may be linked closely to proximity, but where proximity effect is the influence of the magnetic field of one conductor on a nearby conductor, mutual heating is due only to the interference of one conductor on the heat dissipation of the other. Close spacing, however, is not always indicative of mutual heating. On closely spaced, vertically arranged rectangular bars, the "chimney effect" created may actually aid in heat dissipation. Usually, however, closely spaced buses concentrate the heat produced by elements of the circuit and convection cannot dissipate this heat as effectively as it can when a greater separation is maintained. Less efficient cooling causes a more rapid temperature rise in the conductor and thereby reduces the current that can be carried for a given temperature rise. This phenomenon does not affect the RRac ratio of the bus. An equal degree of de
heating on either an a-c or d-c bus will produce like heating effects. 4. Induced circulating currents Induced circulating currents in nearby metallic parts require energy which must be supplied from the inducing circuit. This loss is accounted for by an additional component of resistance. The magnitude of this loss is a function of the distance to adjacent metal parts, the magnitude of the current flowing, and the resistivity of the metal part. Where such heating effects become excessive, e.g., in a common enclosure for a 3 phase bus installation, such as segregated phase or isolated phase bus, it may be necessary to make individual housings for each phase. 5. Hysteresis losses Hysteresis losses or magnetic heating is associated with the losses caused by induced circulating currents in that both are a result of the magnetic field of the conductor. This additional loss is also accounted for by an additional component of resistance. Where excessive heating is produced in nearby building steel, it may be necessary to band the steel sh'ucture with low resistance sh'aps or interpose an amortisseur grid between the bus and the steel to be protected. Losses in adjacent building steel will also be reduced by the presence of high circulating currents in metallic enclosures which separate the bus from building steel, as these circulating currents set up fields directly opposed to the conductor fields, thereby reducing the net effect. *
* "Temperature Rise
and Losses in Solid Structural Steel," O. R. Schurig and H. P. Kuehni, Journal AIEE, May 1926, pp. 446-453.
electrical design - section II
EFFECT OF CONDUCTOR SPACING ON CURRENT RATING 6101 Aluminum Bus at Spacings of 4" and 18"
6"xy"" RECTANGULAR BARS
V
V 3000
Current ratings are for bars arranged vertically and based on a 30 C temperature rise over 40 C
V
/
V
ambient in still but unconfined air.
/ V>
V
w
2000
...
:lj 2500
V
3"xlh" RECTANGULAR BARS
~'"
~ I-
u
()~:7 e;,~
...
V.I¥ <:;~tS-~'0
zw
'"'"
17
...... I.........
~
II
V 1000
/
VV
o
'0
V
...-
I
/
I I IV 1500 VI
~
~'/
/
...
~./'
;:,
u
rjA;t¢°
'";:,'"
.
S
e;
zw
V V
~
...
V
./' 1500
.~
S
1/ V> w
i?-0/
~
/ /
/V
V 500
1006 2
1
. 1
3
2
'"
NUMBER OF BARS PER PHASE
3000
2500
3
4
NUMBER OF BARS PER PHASE
5"x'4" RECTANGULAR BARS
4"x lh" RECTANGULAR BARS
V
V V
/
/
2000 V> w
0
o~
...'" ...zS w
w
'"'"
-"
"~ ...y . I~\~
~
/
1500
;:,
u
/
...
)
0 '0
II
V
/
/'
V v
2500
--
v
V> w
l - I--
....'"w ~ ...
e;,~!>"
.it
~'~
'"
V
'"
0
o~
e:;~~
b/
,'I>
2000
V
.
;:,
7
u
...
V
)
o
"v
'0
V
,.
'\~9-
....
,/
!.e;,~p
1/ / " 1/
17
1500
1000 r/
1/
VV jV
IlJ 1000
500 1
2 3 NUMBER OF BARS PER PHASE
2
1
4
3
NUMBER OF BARS PER PHASE
Fig. 2
'" •••. ;.
',. ~'"
t
e ••
-Ii'·
X
.. J
section II - electrical design
6. Losses due to corona Cowna discharge from a high voltage conductor or equipment is due to the gaseous discharges in the air in its immediate vicinity. This discharge represents an energy loss which also adds to the value of a-c resistance. The magnitude of corona loss is a function of a. Voltage of the bus; b. The diameter of the conductor; c. Irregular smfaces such as bolt heads, sharp projections, or rough spots and dirt on the conductor sUlface; d. The humidity of the atmosphere; e. The atmospheric density. Corona losses may be minimized by eliminating all sharp irregularities on the conductor installation such as bolt heads or other sharp projections and by keeping the conductor clean and free from rough abrasions. Where these factors unavoidably exist, electrostatic shields can be used as a cover to minimize cororiildischarge.
!
r i
i
JI
i
~
I[ (
Skin Effect
1,: ( ,
~i ,
II"',
,"
Ii
':111
': :,
.1
, •
," j I
*
Of the factors that contribute to the a-c resistance of a bus conductor, skin effect is generally the most important. At any particular a-c frequency, skin effect is an inherent characteristic of the cross sectional shape and resistivity of the bus itself and can be evaluated independent of the electrical design of the circuit. Skin effect is caused by the internal magnetic flux in the bus conductor. More of this internal flux links the center of the conductor than the surface, thereby inducing a greater reactive voltage drop, Ix, at the center of the conductor than near the surface. The total voltage drop for any given length of conductor will be the same, whether measured near the center, as V e, or near the sUlface, V., Fig. 3.
H, !
"
I
,',
r
"
I
,I
I
I
i/,
I I
,j
n
Ve =lcR+jlcX c
II :1
"
I I
=~=============~=========~=~
I
I
I
I
,j
Vs=lsR+j'sX s
:'
I:
I:
\
===========================?=~ \
:
\
I:
; ;: iI I
II II,Ii I:
\: "
l"
IiI . i.
I' : Ii
.,!
"
Effect of Bus Shape and Size on A·C Resistance Rectangular Bars-High current requirements often demand that a bus be built up in laminated form using several rectangular bars of smaller capacity. The arrangement of these rectangular conductors, when grouped to form a large a-c bus, i,s important to utilize the cross section of metal efficiently. Several methods are used to reduce skin effect, some of which can be enumerated as follows: 1. Ananging the conductors of a bus to produce a void at the center of the group to reduce the effect of internal flux; 2. Interlacing or paired-phase arrangements of parallel bars; 3. Installing iron magnetic loops or balancers to increase the reactance in bars carrying higher currents. (Not practical for most installations.) The necessity of incorporating one of the above methods to a bus composed of a number of rectangular bars will be apparent from Fig. 5 showing one phase of a typical bus bar system. This illustration shows the division of current between the 10 indi-
1020
225
350 513
249
342 257
677
480
9" TO 1ST BAR OF RETURN
=
of Electric Power Transmission," L. F. Woodruff, Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc,
I:
Bus conductors have a unUOlm resistivity throughout; hence, in order to maintain a lower resistance drop at the center of the conductor, the current density in this portion of the conductor must be lower than at the surface. This greater concentration of current at the surface is termed "skin effect," and in the large low resistance sections usually encountered in bus bar, its magnitude can be appreciable at 60 cps. Special arrangements and designs are necessary for large, low resistance a-c buses to effectively reduce skin effect.
728
Since the inductive reactance at the center, lexe, is greater than the surface reactance drop, I.x., the resistance drop at the center must be smaller than the resistance drop, lsr, at the surface in order to produce the same voltage drop at the center that appears across any other filament parallel to the conductor axis as shown in the diagram, i.e., /Yel /y.I. Vectorially, this is shown in Fig. 4.
I,X,
Fig. 4
Fig. 3
* "Principles ;1
V,
20
Fig. 5 '" '" "Current Carrying Capacity of Hollow Conductors," H, W. Pabst, The ELECTRIC JOURNAL, July, 1931.
.1;>0
elect1'ical deSign - section II
vidual rectangular bars comprising the bus. These bars are arranged vertically with each bar separated by a small air space. The internal flux greatly increases the reactance in the center bars, causing reduced currents and a slight shift in phase relationship between the currents in the individual bars. Vectorially, the addition of these individual currents gives a total current of 4380 amperes, although the algebraic sum of the currents is 4849 amperes. This is shown in Fig. 6.
728
513
480
677
what superior to the hollow square arrangement as all bus surfaces are adequately exposed to dissipate heat, and the internal flux, although producing greater current densities in the outer edges of the bars, gives high current ratings for multiple bar arrangements. The interlacing of bars, or paired-phase arrangements, offers an excellent solution to the unequal distribution of currents in low voltage systems. Low voltage bus duct of low reactance design makes use of these arrangements to almost completely nullify proximity and skin effects. The arrangements of bars, Figs. 8 and 9, illustrate these types of design.
C:==:::::JI A1 C:==:::::JI Bl
Fig. 6"
'--
Proximity effect causes the non-symmetrical division of current in the bars. The relatively small spacing to the return bus and the high current causes a pronounced concentration of current in the facing bars and much less current in the outside bars.
B
-II Cl
A
C:==:::JI A2 C:==:::JI B2 '--
....IIC2
'--
....IIA3
C:==:::JI B3 C==:::JIC3
Modified Hollow Square Arrangement
Hollow Square Arrangement Fig. 7
Various hollow square arrangements of multiple rectangular bars have been used to reduce skin effect. Two common arrangements are indicated in Fig. 7. Both arrangements essentially produce a void at the center of the group of conductors. The hollow square arrangement gives a low skin effect resistance ratio-the resulting shape being similar to a square tubular conductor. Current density will be slightly greater at the corners of this arrangement. The disadvantage of this arrangement is the necessity of spacing supports closer than for square tubing and box channel shapes. The reduced surface exposure for the dissipation of heat also limits the current carrying capacity, but it is obviously better than a closed square tubular conductor. The modified hollow square arrangement is some* "Current Carrying Capacity of Hollow Conductors," H. W. Pabst, The ELECTRIC JOURNAL, July, 1931.
Interlaced Bars
C Paired Phase Arrangement
Fig. 8
Fig. 9
The paired-phase arrangement, Fig. 9*, produces uniform current density because of the ahnost complete neutralization of the magnetic fields. Currents tend to divide evenly in all bars under conditions of unbalanced load apd even for single phase loads. In each pair of bars, the currents tend to be nearly equal in magnitude and opposite in phase, e.g., the currents in A1 and B2 , A 2 and C 1 , and B 1 and C 2 , as shown vectorially-are nearly opposite in phase relation and nearly equal in magnitude. The total phase current in each of the three phases-A, B, and Cdivide into two components-A 1 and A 2 , B1 and B2, C 1 and C 2-each pair tending to be nearly equal in magnitude and differing in pha,~e angle by nearly 60 degrees. It is important that ~terphase ties be made at all intermediate load connections; otherwise, the system impedance will be affected; currents will not divide equally between pairs of bars, and higher temperature rises will be encountered in the more heaVily loaded pair of bars. . Tubular Conductors-A tubular conductor provides the most efficient cross section for an electrical conductor when considering skin effect because the center of the conductor is hollow where current densities " "Current Distribution in Paired-Phase Bus Bars Under Unbalanced Load Conditions." J. B. Cataldo and N. Shaclanan, A.I.E.E. Transactions Paper 54-329, October. 1954.
21
·-------~··------.--·~·--~··-.·I'-~......,...
..
·__
" ,
.~
_r- •• ~ •••_•• _
~.
..
':;"; ~..::..' . '
section II - electrical design
EFFECT OF WALL THICKNESS ON ELECTRICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF A 3 INCH O.D. ROUND ALUMINUM TUBE OF ALLOY 6063·T6 2
o
2.0
jT 7!
~ Rae
C
Rdc
"./
--~
~
/' ,/ /"
/.
15 1.5
·1 !I
/
f!
!
I
'II ! . I
/
(
;
i
/
/
Ii
11
II;j
u
·1'
o o .... '"w a..
1 11 ,
I
~
o u '"
10 1.0
U
,
~ Vl
~
w
'
Z
if I
I'
i.
""
'.
t Il
t ." ",
"
"
II
~ f-"""
\,
,;
5
Z
:'\:
'""-
o
:
..........
.....
0
Rae AT
..........
~
...~
70 C
..........
0
z
i"""'-- ..........
1500
<{
"""- r- ~
Rdc AT
'"...
70 C
z
1400
w
'"::>'" Vl
1300
a..
U 0
'" .2
.3
.4
.5
.6 .7 WALL THICKNESS,
.8
Fig. 10
22
1600
;::
.9
1.0
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
1.5
t (INCHES) Current ratings are based on a 30 C temperature rise over a 40 C ambient temperature in still but unconfined air.
"j: l' ~I );
.1
1700
u u
1/
Ii
"~
1800
0
/
:i I~ L
;1
...w ...'"0u
u
,: '
I
1900
~
0.8"
/ 1/
I J:"
'I
<{
'"a..w
c
/ ","
2000
....'"
::>
J
. ~1"~
<{
w ::>
I
/
2100
~
I ~~
I Wi ",
I I I I I I
K
I
'"
w
'"a..w
lac
I
~; .'
r
r;;
I
/
';
,II
I
V-
V
I~ J
i' f'
I I
/'
I:
i
~'
.j
V
l/
/ ./
/'
\
Vl
W
~
-
\ \
~
"
/
~
,Vl
~/
,
\ \
;::-
i ~
I
V
~
i,
ti
r
/
R
,;
il
Rae Rdc
1200
electrical design - section II
normally would be smaller. A round tubular conductor is slightly more efficient than a square tubular conductor as currents will tend to be slightly greater at the corners of square tubing. The magnitude of skin effect increases with wall thickness in a round tubular conductor as shown
internal ventilation. As a result, standard shapes make an efficient bus conductor in the arrangements indicated and are used where high current ratings are desired.
by the RR ae curve in Fig. 10. For thin tubes, skin effect
Calculation of A-C Resistance
lie
conductor. The Rae curve, Fig. 10, shows this variation R rle for a 3 inch outside diameter tube of aluminum alloy 6063- T6 which has a typical conductivity of 53 per cent (lACS). The d-c resistance at 70 C as indicated in Fig. 10 is a function of wall thickness. When the d-c resistance values are multiplied by corresponding
The calculation of the a-c resistance of a conductor is based on the determination of the apparent increase in the d-c resistance of the conductor due to skin effect only, since this is the principal component that influences d-c resistance. For any given cross sectional shape, its d-c resistance, and the frequency of the circuit, skin effect can be evaluated independent of the conductor material and the parameters of the circuit. To find a-c resistance, the "skin effect resistance
. t ance ra t'10,"R va1ues a f t1le "k':ff s m e ect reS1S Ifae ,a curve
ratio," RR ae , is first determined. This ratio is a multiply-
is negligible and increases with wall thickness until it is a maximum where the tube becomes a solid round
(Ie
dc
giving a-c resistance is obtained. This a-c resistance curve, Rae, shows that a-c resistance becomes a minimum with a wall thickness of approximately 0.8 inch and increases slightly when the wall thickness is increased beyond this point. The current rating of this 3 inch diameter tube is also greatest at a wall thickness of 0.8 inch where a-c resistance is at a minimum as shown by the curve, lac. These curves are typical for all diameters of tubing having a conductivity of 53 per cent (lACS at 20 C). A-c resistance will be a minimum and the current rating a maximum at approximately 0.8 inch wall thickness for all diameters. Other materials will produce similar characteristics, but these optimum. characteristics will occur at a different wall thickness. Copper tubing (98 per cent conductivity lACS), has a minimum a-c resistance and maximum current rating when the wall thickness is approximately 0.5 inch and EC aluminum tubing (61 per cent conductivity lACS) at approximately 0.7 inch wall thickness. The effect of high conductivity of the material is to concentrate the current nearer the surface of the conductor. This means that a lower conductivity material fares better, with regard to skin effect; a given cross section is better utilized with current more uniformly distributed. It is sometimes possible to design a conductor of aluminum with the same outside diameter as one of copper, both with the same a-c resistance per foot. As a consequence, the same size fittings can be used. *
Channels and Angles Arranged in Box Form-These shapes arranged in box fonn, shown on page 11, approximate square tubular conductor in configuration. The web or leg thickness of standard sections is usually within the optimum limits where skin effect is at a low value. In addition, such shapes provide for
* "Aluminum in Heavy Current Conductors," 'VilJiam Paper 55-261, April 20, 1955.
Deans, AlEE Trans
ing factor that is used to modify the d-c resistance to obtain a-c resistance at the same temperature, e.g., Rac
=R
de
Rae R dc
X-.
The magnitude of the skin effect resistance ratio,
Rae' can b e determme : d convemen . tl y f rom curves:., R dc The following curves are used in this text as the basis for determining. skin effect for the common shapes of conductor, Fig. 11, page 24, skin effect in isolated rectangular bus conductors; Fig. 12, page 25, skin effect in isolated round wires and tubes; and Fig. 13, page 26, skin effect in isolated square tubular conductors. . Independent V ariable-The conductor shapes in Figs. 11, 12, and 13 have a common independent variable 'which is the abcissa on these graphs. The value of this independent variable is dependent upon the circuit frequency and the d-c resistance of the conductor at a given temperature, t. If the a-c resistance is desired at any other temperature, the d-c resistance must be converted to that temperature before the independent variable is calculated. The d-ch'esistance temperature conversion is shown on page 17. With the d-c resistance converted to the desired temperature, the calculation of tlle independent variable is then made by the following:
Where: Rde is the resistance in microhms per foot; is the frequency in cycles per second.
f
This establishes one coordinate for determining from
* "Electrical Coils and Conductors," H. B.
Dwight, McGraw-Hill Book Co.
23
lilillliililiililllll~
~
__..- ~._.~ . ~~=--.- ~
__.
section II - electrical design
CURVES FOR SKIN EFFECT OF ISOLATED FLAT RECTANGULAR CONDUCTORS I. 5
v
I
v
/ fl ~
1.4 I - - -
r---
/
t
~
~
I
I-
w.
/
I
II
/
J
)
If /
I I I 7 11 17
iJ ....
'.1
"-
~J
J /
./
J J
VhF! II
'0
J /f
I I 1 I /V II '/
1.3
II'
I
-$')
}
V
J
If
7
.../
7 J
/
/ VI /
If 'I iJlf
1.2
Ii / If V 'I
,j
J
J
j
'j
IJv
1.1
).
v
1/ /v 1.0
,.,.
ji ¥
\.
i ,;; !.
20
40
60
80
~ fx10 3
100
120
H. B. Dwight, "Elech'ical Coils and Conductors," McGraw-Hill Book Co.
.", l::
o
IN MICROHMS PER FOOT
j:
~
l----"V Rdc
L"
il:
/
Fig. 11
24
140
160
180
electrical design - section II
CURVES FOR SKIN EFFECT OF ISOLATED ROUND ROD AND TUBULAR CONDUCTORS 2. 1
2.0
t~
1.9
! - f--
1.8
ii;'
i'"
e
0
!:2
o· 0
'"
""'Ii "'t:I ~
-
-
'"""
0
1.7
t/ d' tid tid
O.~5
0
'"
0
::J
0.40
tid
1.6
I
o'
0.35
!:!
o'
0.30
!2 O' 0.
0
C::i
~
1.5
O'
&
O'
1.4
~
O'
~
O'
1.3
r;:,~ 1.2 Cl~
J;;P'
,1° 1.1
_0.0'1.
\/0.-
I,
tid-om 1.0
o
50
100
150
200
V
250
300
350
400
f•lO,
Rdc
Rdc
IN MICROHMS PER FOOT.
H. B. Dwight, "Electrical Coils and Conductors," McGraw-Hill Book Co.
Fig. 12
25
section II - electrical design
CURVES FOR SKIN EFFECT OF ISOLATED SQUARE ROD AND SQUARE TUBULAR CONDUCTORS
2.1
2.0
1.9
1
1.8
iI,
:11
,j:
"I: ~~ I,
1.7
'P
'i iii
J i,
1.6
Ii
~
I,
~
;,:
1.5 " J
t
.. I[
".
f
I
I
1.4 :
!
r " [
I
i
1.3
,;'I' ::
o
Ii
i;
I:: I..
1.2
i' I
II:
I:r, "
.1
I~ ,
1.1
I
I: t:
1.0
It;;
i~ ".
o
50
I {.i, .j
i:
150
200 r e 2 5 0 f,,103
Rdc
1
300
Rdc IN MICROHMS PER FOOT
Fig. 13
Ii
IIf: .
100
H. B. Dw;ghl, "Electrical Coils and Conductors," McGraw-Hill Book Co.
26
.J;
.
i:\
3.$0
400
450
electrical design - section II
curves the skin effect resistance ratio of the particular conductor section. The other parameter is a function of the conductor shape or physical dimensions, and its detelmination will be considered in the following paragraphs for the common bus conductor shapes.
curve representing the ratio ~
=
0.5 is the limitin
9
case for a solid square conductor. These curves may be used without appreciable error on channel bus conductors arranged in box form and also for angle conductors arranged in box form, Fig. 15.
Shape Parameter-The shape parameter is different for all of the foregoing conductor sections and is extremely variable because of the innumerable combinations of conductor dimensions. The graphical method provides for this variation by offering a family of curves to cover the practical range of bus conductors.
Rectangular Bar-The shape parameter for rectangular bar is the ratio of conductor width, W, to conductor thickness, t, in the same units of measure. The condition where Wit = 1 is the limiting case for a solid square conductor. Where several rectangular bar conductors are grouped together with a small separation between bars, a larger rectangular section is formed. The over-all dimensions of this section may be used with little error to establish the Wit ratio. For example, the Wit ratio for four rectangular conductors each G inches X Y4 inch spaced % inch apart will be as indicated in Fig. 14.
Fig. 15
The
dt ratio for the boxed channel arrangement
will be the ratio of the channel web thickness to the average outside dimension formed by the channels. For the boxed angle arrangement, the
~ ratio is the
ratio of the leg thickness to the average outside dimension formed by the two angles. These dimensions are listed on pages 133 and 135 for the standard clamps usually used as supports and spacers.
W
T=
6 1%
.. f Rac D elerlnluallOn 0 -R dc
= 3.425
With the independent variable calculated as described above and the shape parameter determined from the physical dimensions of the conductor, the Rae "k' . t ance ra t'10" can b e d etelmme . d '-R s m e ff ect reSlS de
Fig. 14
Solid Round and Tubular Conductors-The shape parameter for round tubular conductors is the ratio of the wall thickness of the tube to its outside diameter,
{Z, both in the same units of measure. The limit-
ing case
where~ = 0.5 is the curve for a solid round
conductor.
Square Tubula1' Conductors-The shape parameter for a square tubular conductor is the ratio of the wall thickness to its outside square dimension, _t. The
.
d
from the appropriate graph for the conductor shape. The shape parameter determines the proper curve from the family of shape curves and the independent variable establishes a point on this curve for which a ...:l ·(j)n t I1e or dinate sca Ie. · Rae correspon dmg - ra t"10 IS reaUj R dc To determine a-c resistance, the d-c resistance is multiplied by this ratio. This gives the a-c resistance at the same temperature, R ac = -Roc X Rde· Rdc To illustrate the calculation of the a-c resistance of aluminum bus bar, sample calculation is presented for several common conductor shapes.
a
PROBLEM NO. 2 Required: The 60 cps a-c resistance at 70 C in microhms per foot for the various bus conductor shapes illustrated in Problem No.1 on page 16.
27
section II - elect1'ical design
A. Rectangular EC aluminum bus bar 4 inches X % inch with a d-c resistance of 13.35 microhms per foot at 20 C; B. 1114 inch solid round EC aluminum bus bar with a d-c resistance of 10.88 microruns per foot at 20 C; C. Ph inch IPS tubular bus bar of alloy 6063-T6 with a doc resistance of 19.2 microhms per foot at 20 C; D. Two extruded channels 4 inches-2.16 lb. of 6063-T6 alloy arranged in box form with a d-c resistance of 8.35 microhms per foot at 20 C.
= 1.061
Rae
R de
and the a-c resistance is Rae
=r X
Rae
= 1.061
Rae
2-C.
,I
=
= =
t/fXT03 d and \/~mustbe calculated. These
[1 + a20 (70 - 20) J 13.35 [1 + (0.00403) (50)] 16.04 microhms perfoot at 70 C. R ae20
are given ~s follows for 11;2 inch standard IPS tubing:
t
~f
Rae
3
Rae
= 1.060
and the a-c resistance at 70 C is
R
Rae10
Rae = -R de
R ae10
= 1.060 X 16.04 = 17.00 microhms perfootat70 C.
de10
The a-c resistance at 60 cps of 1% inch solid round EC aluminum bus bar at 70 C is calculated as follows by determining first its d-c resistance at 70 C:
=
[1 + a20 (70 - 20) J [1 + (0.00403) (50)J 13.07 microhms per foot at 70 C. R
= 10.88
=
The skin effect resistance ratio for solid round conductor is obtained from Fig. 12 0.50 and by using the curve where tid calculating the parameter:
=
~f X
3
10 =
R de
From Fig. 12, the skin effect resistance ratio is:
28
_
-
= 22.57 microhms per foot at 70 C.
The skin effect resistance ratio from Fig. 12 for all practical purposes, is unity and the a-c resistance is equal to the d-c resistance for 11;2 inch IPS tubing. The approximate skin effect resistance ratios for the standard IPS conductors of 6063-T6 alloy at a temperature of 70 C are given in the table on page 127. This table shows that the skin effect resistance ratio at 60 cps for bus conductors operating at 70 C is approximately unity for all sizes up to 3 inches standard IPS and up to and including 1 inch IPS in the extra heavy sizes.
Then, the skin effect resistance ratio from Fig. 11 is approximately
R ae10
10 3
= 0.076
Rae R = 1.000 and Rae = R de de
10 =
X
X
Rae
-t = % -4 = 16
2-B.
0.145
d = 1.900
W
Rae Rae
= R de20 [1 + azo (70 - 20) J = 19.2 [1 + (0.00350) (50)J = 22.57 microruns per foot at 70 C.
To find the skin effect resistance ratio from Fig. 12 on page 25, values for the factors
The skin effect resistance ratio for rectangular bus bar is given in Fig. 11 on page 24. For a 4 inch X 14 inch bus bar, the coordinates that establish the skin effect resistance ratio are calculated as follows:
~f X
= 13.87 microhms
The a-c resistance at 60 cps of 1112 inch IPS tubular bus is calculated by determining first its d-c resistance at 70 C: R de70
The 60 cps a-c resistance of 4 inch X % inch rectangular EC bus bar at 70 C is calculated as follows by determining first the d-c resistance at 70 C: R aC10
X 13.07
per foot at 70 C. -
Solution:
2-A.
R de
2-D.
The 60 cps a-c resistance in microhms per foot at 70 C for two channels of aluminum alloy 6063-T6 arranged in box form, each channel 4 inches-2.16 lb. with a d-c resistance of 8.35 microhms per foot at 20 C, is obtained by converting the d-c resistance at 20 C to 70 C and then obtaining the skin effect resistance ratio from Fig. 13. The d-c resistance of a single channel at 70 C will be: R dc10
= R,!e2o [1 + a~o (t t)] = 8.35 [1 + (0.00350) (50)J 1 -
= 9.82 microhms per foot at 70 C or
= 4.91 microhms per foot at 70 C for two channels.
elect1'ical design - section II
and
The corresponding skin effect resistance ratio from Fig. 13 is:
-R-- must be obtained. These factors ~ are calculated as follows:
Rae 1.045. R de The a-c resistance'is calculated as follows:
To use Fig. 13, the coordinates
~
X103
=
de
£= 0.~47 =
0.0618
Rae
Rae = -R X
R
de
de
~f X 103 = Rile
60,000
= 1.045 X 4.91
= 111.
= 5.13 microhms per foot at 70 C.
4.91
INDUCTIVE REACTANCE OF BUS CONDUCTORS The total inductive reactance, then, is the algebraic sum of these two parts:
The inductive reactance for various bus conductor shapes is obtained by different means. For solid round and round tubular bus, established formulas for inductive reactance may be used or reactance values may be obtained from tables for the standard sizes. For rectangular bus bars and for channel bus arranged in box form, the most convenient method of determining 60 cps inductive reactance is from curves giving reactance in terms of conductor spacing or equivalent spacing. These 60 cps reactance values can be converted to any other frequency by multiplying the 60 cps value by a ratio of the two frequencies, e.g., where X 60 is the 60 cps reactance and the reactance, Xr, is wanted at another frequency, f, it is obtained by the relation:
X r = X so
xL.
60 The methods of determining reactance for various bus conductor shapes are illustrated in Problem No.3 on page 38.
XL
XLI
that due to the flux out to a radius of one foot from the center of the conductor; .
2.
tha! due to the remaining flux beyond the onefoot radius and extending to the retum conductor or neutral.
XLi'
XL2'
1 = 0.88191 f Log lo GMR (microhms perfoot).
Where: GMR is given in feet; f is given in cycles per second.
.
The GMR term is the geometric mean radius of the conductor. It is a mathematical relationship expressing the radius of an infinitely thin tube whose inductance, carrying the same current, is equal to that of the conductor. The GMR for non-magnetic solid round or tubular conductors can be determined from their physical din1ensions. For these conductors, the GMR is expressed by the following relations: 1. Solid Round Conductor GMR = 0.7788 l' (in feet when radius, r, is in feet) 2. Tubular Conductor j .• 1\4
LnGMR=Lnr 1 _ 4
=
1.
+ XL2'
Inductive Reactance to a One-Foot Radius-The
The inductive reactance for a round conductor is given by the fOlmula: GMD XL 0.88191 f Log io GMR For convenience in calculating and tabulating inductive reactance, this formula is usually written in two terms. These terms separate inductive reactance into two parts:
XLi
fOlmula applying to inductive reactance due to the flux within a radius of one foot of the center of the conductor is:
Solid. Round and Round Tubular Bus Conductors
(mierolmls per foot, eonduetor to neutral) .
=
-1'1 2 1'2 2 +1'2 4. (%+Ln:i.) l'
(1'1 2
-
1'22)2
2
Where: 1'1 is the outside radius of the tube; 1'2 is the inside radius of the tube; Ln is the natural logarithm.
Values of inductive reactance for a one-foot spacing have been established for each standard size of solid round and round tubular conductor by the above 1'elations. ThIs portion of the total inductive reactance is a function of the GMR of the conductor at any given frequency and is a constant for each standard size.
29
"
......
'
' ..t _.., . . .1.'.,,1 ..
I
'.
section II - electrical design
The GMR values for both the standard pipe sizes of tubular bus and the extra heavy IPS series are shown on page 127. The values of GMR for standard sizes of solid rOlU1d bus conductor are given on page 125. This table also lists the inductive reactance at 60 cps for a one-foot spacing using the standard values of GMR given in these tables.
can be calculated for various conductor arrangements, as illustrated in Fig. 16. The general formula for the GMD of a conductor in any three-phase configuration is given by the following expression: GMD
= \o/A X B X C
Where:
Inductive Reactance Spacing Factor-The portion of inductive reactance due to the remaining flux beyond the one-foot radius from the conductor and extending to the return circuit or neuh'al is: XL2
= 0:88191 f Log
10
GMD (microhms per foot).
A, B, and C are the distances between the three conductors.
The calculation of the GMD for various standard arrangements and spacings is given in the following examples:
Where:
1. Symmetrical Triangular Spacing of 10 Feet GMD = A B C = 10 feet;
= =
tis the frequency in cycles per second. The values obtained from this formula are usually called "spacing factqr( and are algebraically added to the values of inductive reactance for a one-foot spacing to get the total inductive reactance. These "spacing factors," as their name indicates, are a function of the total distance between conductors where only one return conductor is involved or, more generally, the GMD (geometric mean distance between conductors) or equivalent spacing where several con-' ductors comprise the circuit. The spacing factors for conductor spacings of 1 to 251 inches are given on page 137. These spacings are based on the total separation between conductors and not from one foot outward.
Geometric Mean Distance (GMD )-The GMD is dependent upon the conductor spacing and arrangement. For a single-phase installation, the GMD is merely the physical spacing between conductors in feet. For a three-phase configuration, the equivalent spacing
= =
2. Right Triangulal' Spacing where A C 10 Feet GMD 1. 123A = 1.123 X 10 11.23 feet;
=
=
3. Unequal Triangular Spacing where A = 10 Feet, B 12 Feet, C 15 Feet GMD = \0/ 10 X 12 X 15 = 12.16 feet;
=
=
4. Symmetrical Flat Spacing A
GMD = 1.26A
= 1.26 X
10
= B = 10 Feet = 12.6 feet;
5. Non-symmetrical Flat Spacing where A = 10 Feet, B = 12 Feet, C = 22 Feet GMD
= \0/ 10 X. 12 X 22 = 13.82 feet.
Once the GMD or equivalent spacing has been detennined, the inductive reactance due to this spacing may be determined from convenient tables of inductive reactance spacing factors which list values of inductive reactance corresponding to various spacings or equivalent spacings (GMD) as determined by the above formulas.
Inductive Reactance of Rectangular Bars
Af\.
L~ Symmetrical triangular spacing GMD=
Unequal triangular spacing GMD= iYAXBxC
Right triangular spacing A C GMD = 1.123 A
=
A=B=C
Ii ,.
Unsymmetrical Bat spacing GMD iY A X B X C
Symmetrical flat spacing
A=B GMD
= 1.26 A
=
Fig. 16
30
Graphical Solution Using Reactance Curves-The inductive reactance of rectangular bars usually cannot be calculated by the methods used for round conductors. The reactance of a circuit comprised of two rectangular bars can generally be determined more expediently by curves than by a rigid mathematical treahnent of the problem. The reactance curves * in Figs. 17 and 18, establish the 60 cps inductive reactance of a circuit comprised of two bars for a wide range of spacings and conductor dimensions. Inductive reactance obtained by these curves is based only upon the physical dimensions and arrangement of the conductors. Fig. 17 should be used for closely spaced conductors and Fig. 18 for widely spaced conductors. Where a conductor is composed of several bars grouped together with a small air space between bars, the over-all dimensions of the group can be used for
* H.
B. Dwight, "Reactance Values for Rectangular Conductors," ELECTRIC JOURNAL, June, 1919.
electrical design - section 11
INDUCTIVE REACTANCE AT 60 CPS OF CLOSELY SPACED RECTM~GULAR CONDUCTORS
55
50
~/
-"
./ ./
45
~~
/
40
~~ / ~~ V ~~
oo ....
~ 35 OJ>
/
~ J:
o
~
'"
u
~ 30
~ ~V
/. ~ ~
I
en
.,:
o
.'0
~V
V
A-
.......!. -0
~ =5
/J ~~
v
~ 7d A
.... 25
« w
/I; II
U
z
« ....
t=O",-
u ~ 20
~ ~I t
'"
w
> ;::
If/;/
u
::> Cl
I
~ 15
.
"
-lAr-
B- 2
T-
"A -1
10
W
l~l--s--;1~
A_v: 8- 2
/iJ ~
I
5
IC
R
I
t=115
~ =1/10
/ o
-
8
8 -
//; I"r-..
/
~V
./
I 0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1.0 S
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
A+B Fig. 17 H. B. Dwight, "Electric JOUl'llal," Vol. 16, June 1919, Pages 255~256
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.8
1.9
2.0
I. '
.,.
section II - electrical design
INDUCTIVE REACTANCE AT 60 CPS OF WIDELY SPACED RECTANGULAR CONDUCTORS 95
90
85
C 0 u.
""w
80
0..
II)
::E :r
,
0
e; 75
(
I.....
~
I
.,; .,; 70
0 a
'0
...< w
65
V
Z
<{ l-
V
<{
w
""w
60
> u ;:) c 55
;::
z
II
i ,.i: I'
ii ~
50
'i:
c:;:;
:1'
-
r-T
"!I
i~ . -~ ~i
"d
0
l
2
3
"
5
6 S
A+B
7
or
8
9
10
GMO
A+B
. s NOTE: Use Graph and Fonnula only when - - b is greater than 2.
a+
APPROXIMATE FORMULA: GMD X so 52.9 Log1o a + b + 34.5 (rnicrohms per foot of conductor)
=
Conventional Arrangement GMD
Flat Arrangement For symmetrical flat spacings shown above (see page 30 for GMD of other conductor configurations)
= 1.26 S.
Fig. 18 H. B. Dwight, "Electric Journal," Vol. 16, June 1919, Pages 255-256
32
11
12
electrical design - section II
a rough approximation of reactance by considering the group as a single bar. This is shown in Fig. 19. Where a greater separation exists between bars, this rough approximation should not be made. When the bars comprising a conductor are widely spaced as in a hollow square arrangement, these bars may be
:::;
::
~d---1
-S:---I
assumes an equal division of current between bars and neglects proximity and skin effect. The error due to this assumption is usually not large for a frequency of 60 cps as resistance is affected to a far greater degree than inductance by an unequal distribution of current in the conductor cross section.
Fig. 19
grouped as illustrated in Fig. 20, to give a close approximation for reactance calculations. The determination of reactance by these methods
-r--.
1.1 1 1.10
5',-,
I
.............r-.,Lo
-
1.09
~
---
-
1.08 1.07 5
I I I --1 ~S
j
1.12
1.06
GMD
~ ~
~
" --
~ 0.70
""" '" - '" """
-
0,65
1.04
.............
.............
~
-
~
r---...
~
1.02 0.40 0.30
L- 0.10
0.00
0.99
o
0.1
~~
" ""'" " I"'" ......
~
.........
,
i'......
r-- r--. I'-.. I'....... ~ ~ ........... ~ ~ r-I--.. r-- r---.... ~ ~~~ r-- r-.... r-- I -- r---- -......: r--. r=::: ~~ :'-.. r---...:::: :S:::: ~ r-:: t--- --.: ::-:::: t:S ~ ~ -.::::: ::-:::: r-- ~ ~ ~
?r
1.00
S
-- ---
0.55 0.50
1.01
.............
r--: ~
0.60 1.03
I~T
r--......
.............
0.75 1.05
,0
Fig. 20
II---..
1.13
c
8
A
:::::
It1"-
-
U
0.2
0.3
0.5
0.4
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
""
1.0
Fig. 21
0t.
"Engineering Calculations Inductance and Reactance f01' Rectangular Bar Conductors," O. R. Schurig, General Electric Reoiew, Vo . 36, No.5, May 1933. Curves plotted from tables calculated by F. W. Grover.
33
section II - electrical design I
Methods of Calculation-The calculation of inductive reactance and voltage drop is often necessary for conductor arrangements other than two rectangular bars. Such arrangements as the multiple bars per phase, 5.4
5.0 4.6
3.8
~
.~
1\ \
4.2
3.4
1\
GMD 3.0
LL-
II-
I-
~S-1
\
S
i=O 1\ ./
l-
II-
TO 0.1
~
2.6
'\..
'\
2.2
SEE CHART BELOW FOR VALUES IN DOTTED AREA
i'..
"
1.8
~=0.2
1.4
~
/'
-..::::::
....
-
I
I
-~-
I-
- -
I
1.0 0.05
I
0.08 0.10
0.15
0.2
0.3
0.4 0.5 0.6
0.8 1.0
S B
1.34
111111111 I I I I I III 1
I
1.32 1.30
A
.~
1.28 1.26
1.24
~ ~.S-1
1.22 A , -fB=O TO 0.1_
f-
1.20
I....
t- ~-02, • f- B -
l\
1.12
1\1
1.10 1.08
\1
1\1
1.06
"
1.02
0.8 1.0
1.5 S
2
3
4
5
6
8 10
B
Fig. 22*
* "Engineering
Calculation of Inductance and Reactance for Rectangular Bar Conductors," O. R. Schurig, GENERAL ELECTRIC REVIEW, Vol. 36. No.5, May, 1933. Curves plotted from tables calculated by F. W.
34
L
21 [Ln 2GMR 1 = 1000
1
GMRJ (Microhenries). + -1-
(2)
The term GMR is the self geometrical mean distance in cm of all points within the area of the conductor cross section and 1 is, the length of the bar in cm. The value of GMR for a rectangular section is given below, when a and b are the dimensions of the bar in cm.
GMR
= 0.2235 (a + b)
(Centimeters)
The mutual inductance between a pair of straight, parallel rectangular bars is indicated by the relation:
GMD] (Microhenries). (3) + ~l-
= LA + M AB -
MAO - M.w ( Microhenries for group A) .
(4)
Where:
......... ["'0.,
0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6
Grover.
L t = L - M. The calculation of the self inductance, L, of a straight rectangular bar, neglecting the return conductor is given by the relation:
L TA
1.00
(1)
The total inductance, L t , in the above expression, is the difference between the self-inductance, L, of the conductor and the mutual inductance, M, between two conductors of the circuit. The total inductance, L t , of each conductor of a circuit composed of two bars is expressed by the relation:
I""
1.04
(microhms per foot)
where the GMD is the geometrical mean distance in cm of the two conductor areas from each other and 1 is the length of the bars in em. The GMD can be determined from the curves in Fig. 21 for conductors in an edgewise position or from Fig. 22 for a facing position. The spacing between bars, s, is given in cm. The useful application of these formulas will be apparent from the reactance calculations of the circuit shown in Fig. 20. The two conductors per phase in this illustration result from the grouping of the eight bars per phase into two groups of four bars each, The inductance of group A, designated by L TA , is given by the relation:
1.18
1.14
= 27T f L t
21 [Ln 2 1 -1 M = 1000 GMD
GMD
S 1.16
X
f-
A
1\ \
Fig. 20, and three-phase configurations sometimes require the more fundamental calculations of self and mutual inductance. * The 60 cps inductive reactance values shown on the curves,in Figs. 17 and 18 express the total reactance, X, of the conductor,
LA is the self inductance of group A; MAB is the mutual inductance of the circuit comprising groups A and B; MAO is the mutual inductance of the circuit comprising groups A and C; M.w is the mutual inductance of the circuit comprising groups A and D.
electrical design - section II
By adding the quantity of LA - LA mula and grouping terms, it becomes:
L TA = (LA - MAO)
+ (LA -
( Microhenries for group A).
= 0 to
the for-
M4D ) - (LA - MAE)
The total inductance of group A is thus the algebraic sum of the inductance values for the three branches indicated and the total reactance of group A will be:
XTA = 27T f L TA = (X AO + X AD - X AS ) ( Microhenries for conductor group A).
The individual reactances can be determined from the curves in Figs. 17 and 18 or the self inductance and the mutual inductances may be calculated by formulas (2) and (3) and the values substituted in relation (4) to obtain the total inductance of group A. The inductance and inductive reactance of group B is calculated in a similar mamler. Widely Spaced Conductors-Where the value of s a + b is less than 2, the reactan~e should be deter-
mined either by the curves in Fig. 17 or by calculation. For widely spaced conductors where the value of s a + b is greater than 2, the 60 cps reactance can be
formulas and graphs advanced by these authors express reactance for widely spaced, thin, square tubes and assume a uniform distribution of current throughout the cross section. Commercial aluminum tubing having a wall thickness up to its optimum value, page 22, will have reactance values that closely approach the reactance of a thin hollow square tube. Method of Calculation-The reactance for widely spaced, thin, square tubes may be calculated approximately by the formula below: X
= 0.88216 f [ Log
+ 0.235 + 0.0108 ~
10 :
J.
Where: "s" is the spacing between centers in the same units as the square tube dimension "a," Fig. 23.
Approximate corrections to the reactance found by this formula have been advanced by the authors to correct for the thickness of the tubing and for round comers usually present on commercial tubing. These corrections are evaluated by the curves in Figs. 24 and 25 and are added as corrections to the calculated value.
determined graphically from Fig. 18 or by the approxi-
.
s
mate formula below. For ratios of --b greater than
a+
2, this will give 60 cps reactance within 1 per cent accuracy. X so
= 52.9 Log
10
GMD +b
a
+ 34.5
(Microhms per foot per conductor).
Graphical Solution Using Reactance Curves-A more expedient method of determining inductive reactance for a frequency of 60 cps is by means of the curve shown in Fig. 23. This curve expresses 60 cps s reactance for various ratios of - for two thin, square a . tubes. Corrections should be made to the 60 cps re-
Where:
a, b, and GMD are in the same units.
II
70
For two conductors widely spaced, the GMD is equal to the spacing, s. For three widely spaced conductors, the GMD can be determined from the relation GMD
= iY A X
B X C.
Where: A, B, and C are the spacings between conductors. See page 30 for the value of GMD for the more common conductor arrangements.
~,,v
III
w
U
~ 60 o >0
~
0 50
o"-
"""-w U'l40
/
~ J:
Inductive Reactance of Square Tubular Conductors and Channels in Box Form The inductive reactance of square tubular conductors can be determined approximately by the formulas an~graphs advanced by Dwight and Wang.* The
* "Reactance of Square Tubular Bus Bars," H. B. Dwight and T. K. Wang, AlEE Transactions. 1938. Vol. 57.
/
o u '"
~ 30
20 1
/
/
V
V
V
V
V
V
rCl
~,~
I I I III
2
3
4 RATIO
5
6
7
8
sic
Fig. 23 - Reactance of Thin Square Tubes
10 12 14
I
=
section II - electrical design
actance determined from this curve to correct for the wall thickness of the tube and for round comers usually present on commercial tubing. The curves in Figs. 24 and 25 provide the approximate corrections which are added to the reactance obtained from the curve in Fig. 23. 3.0
I
I
{OJ
2.5
~a==i
II)
w
U
>u 2.0 o-0
II
.... -<
....
o o u..
1.5
'"c..w II)
/
~
:z:
o
~ 1.0 ~
0.5
o
I
V o
/ V
V
/
V
0.05
0.10 RATIO
0.15
0.20
0.25
t/a H. B. Dwight and T. K. Wang
Fig. 24 - Correction for Wall Thiclmess 1.5
proximated by these methods using the average length of the sides of the double channel arrangement for the · . W +d d nnenSlOn, a, 0 f a thin square tub e, e.g., a = --2-' see Fig. 27. Reactance should be corrected for channel thickness. The 60 cps reactance of standard channel sections arranged in box form and separated by standard spacers and spacer supports is expressed by the curves in Fig. 27. These curves give the inductive reactance for standard channels with depths of 3 inches to 10 inches for conductor spacings up to 100 inches. For spacings over 100 inches, the reactance for a 12 inch spacing should be taken from the curves and a spacing factor from the table on page 137 added to this reactance to obtain the total inductive reactance per conductor. The reactance of double channel conductors arranged in box form can be determined by a more rigorous mathematical formula developed by Siegel and Higgins. * The mathematical solution presented by these authors, however, verifies the close approximation obtained with the Dwight and Wang formulas and the curves presented. Reactance determinations by these methods assumes a uniform distribution of current in the cross section of the two channels. However, measurements reported by O. R. Schurig * have shown that, for closely spaced buses in a three-phase flat arrangement, the outside channels may carry substantially less current than the inside channels, This is due essentially to the fact that the two channels have a di1Ierent phase spacing from other conductors in the circuit and the flux linking each of the two channels in box arrangement will be different. This unequal division of current in a typical three-phase closely spaced double channel bus arrangement is shown in Fig. 26,
,.-----.------.--------,---~--...,
lJ lJ r
II)
w
U >-
u
~ 1.0 .
.... -<
....
f--12"
o ou..
I·
12"
1570
I
6"-4.48# ALUMINUM CHANNELS
'"w
~ 0.5 f-----+------..~-I-----+----_\
Fig. 26 - Division of Current in 3 Phase Channel Bus
~
:z:
o u '" ~
0 1 - o ~
o
J.......
0.1
J_
0.2 RATIO
_'__
0.3
_l
'0.4
ria H. B. Dwight and T. K. Wang
·~ .
Fig. 25 - Correction for Round Comers
The calculation of inductive reactance for double channel conductors arranged in box form can be ap-
36
Equations have been advanced by Siegel and Higgins ** for determining the magnitude of this unequal distribution of current in the outside channels of a three-phase double channel bus, Where closely spaced, high current, double channel arrangements are used for 60 cps installations, the concentration of cur-
* ''Equations for the Inductance and Short-Circuit Forces of Buses Com-
prised of Double Channel Conductors," C. M. Siegel and T. J. Higgins, AlEE Traosactions, Vol. 71, January, 1952. **"Equations for Determioing Current Distribution Among the Conductors of Buses Comprised of Double Channel Conductors," C. M. Siegel and T, J. Higgins, AIEE Traosactions Paper 54-467, October, 1954.
electrical design - section II
REACTANCE CURVES AT 60 CPS FOR DOUBLE·CHANNEL CONDUCTORS ARRANGED IN BOX FORM 9(1
II
J
V V ~~
I I
I
V ~~
I I
~w-1
80
'-,T
,-J
----...
I-
0 0 .... 0-
60
I
, I
I
I
.50
II
0 -0
I
l-
«
J
u
U
40
> ;::
II
u
::::l 0
/
36
V I A
/ If
1/ tf
I
V kf
1/ A
20
VII / ~
Iwl.!ft.
STANDARD CHANNelS'
y~'"
V
3"_1.73#~ Lbs.
r;'
I
1/
V
~
l--:::::.;;::b::b::::~l/
5"-3.10~?:::....-::::~V
....... 1/
6"-4.48#::=:':::::% j
V
~
/ VVVV V V / 7 /: ~V; V / /
~~/
VVA I i
1/
A
A
II
/
V
....... 1.---"
8,,~.80~.%'
3
V
-
.
:
..... ~
I I I II
i
.
4
V
I
II
~c:V 0
~ ~ II
/j 'V0
/<7 r/?71f 1/
10"_10.05#
7
/~
J
~
:lfl /iIjil
1/ kr~ ~ l/ ~ ~~II II
4"_1.85#~:/-':l/-":~~V
7"-5.10#
II
k1 V 1I
4"-2.16#--:;VV-::;V ~
6"-3.63# 7"_5.96#
It"
~A/ 1/ /
II
~
d
IJ
I
'/
~
1/
y/ I/~~ ~ /
w
""w
tI
I
vi
z « I« w
I
I
I
~
1/
'I
/~ ~
/ V V I~ 'I~V / / # kf ~ IJV 1I 11 bI V LJ II l,I 1/ / V ~/ V V l! / ~1/ ~ IIV 1/ !J 1/
I
I
...:
II .J ~
1
~
0 u "" ~
U
/
d
70
""w l'"
IJ ~
5
6
7
8
9
10
12
15
20
30
40
50
60
70
8090100
CONDUCTOR SPACING (D) OR EQUIVALENT SPACING (GMD) (INCHES)
* SIZE
IS DESIGNATED BY THE. DEPTH OF THE CHANNEL AND THE WEIGHT PER FOOT
Fig. 27
37
.... _r.---
section II - electrical design
with an unsymmetrical h-iangular spacing of 10 feet, 12 feet, and 15 feet will be as follows. The inductive reactance for a onefoot spacing is obtained from the table on page 125; its value is;
rent in one channel of an outside pair may cause overheating on normal loads. This would be particularly true where the current rating of the double channel arrangement is closely approached. PROBLEM NO. 3 This problem will illush'ate methods of determining inductive reactance for various shapes of bus conductor.
XLI
The inductive reactance spacing factor is found by calculating the GMD or equivalent spacing. This value will be:
Required: The 60 cps inductive reactance in microhms per foot for a three-phase installation of the following shapes of conductors; A. Rectangular bus bar 4 inches X 1;4 inch arranged with flat surfaces vertical and spaced with a 10 inch flat symmetrical spacing; B. 11;4 inch solid round bus conductor with an unsymmetrical h"iangular spacing of 10, 12, and 15 feet; C. 1 % inch IPS tubular bus bar with a symmeh-ical flat spacing of 10 feet; D. A three-phase installation of channel bus conductor-each phase consisting of two 4 inch-2.16 lb. channels arranged in box form. These phases are arranged in an unsymmeh"ical flat spacing of 12, 15, and 27 feet. Solution: 3-A.
GMD
XL2 == 57.4 microhms per foot. The total inductive reactance, then, is equal to the algebraic sum, of the two above reactance values. XL
The 60 cps inductive reactance for' a three-phase symmetrical flat spacing of 10 feet for 1 Y2 inch IPS tubular bus bar is determined as follows. The inductive reactance, due to a one-foot spacing, is determined from the table on page 127. Its value is: XLI == 59.51 microhms per foot. The inductive reactance spacing factor for a 10 foot symmetrical flat spacing is found by calculating the GMD as follows: GMD
a+
inductive reactance is obtained from the curves in Fig. 18 or the formula for widely spaced conductors. The GMD for a flat symmeh-ical spacing of 10 inches is;
XL2
For the conventional arrangement of bars shown in Fig. 18, the inductive reactance in microhms per foot is a function of
XL
GMD==~==296 %+4 ..
a+b
~!
'"
For this value, the inductive reactance from Fig. 18 will be XL == 59.4 micmhms per foot to neutral. 3-B.
38
The inductive reactance for a 1 % inch solid round, three-phase 60 cps installation
== XLI + X L2 == 59.51 + 58.2 == 117.71 microhms per foot (or:e phase to neutral).
GMD
a+
== 58.2 microhms per foot.
The total inductive reactance will be the sum of these two reactance values:
(10)
of the bar as indicated for the conventional arrangement.
10 == 12.6
feet or 12 feet 7 inches.
The inductive reactance spacing factor corresponding to this value of GMD is obtained from the table on page 137. For a total spacing of 12 feet 7 inches, this value is:
Since the value of~b is greater than 2,
--b' where a and b are the dimensions
== 1.26A == 1.26 X ==
+ 74
== 1.26A == (1.26) == 12.6 inches.
~,
i'.
""'';
3-C.
s 10 - - b == - 4 11 == 2.35
GMD
== XLI + X L2 == 73.66 + 57.4 == 131.06 micmhms per foot (one phase to neutral) .
a+
+
== '{Y1O X 12 XIS == 12.16 or == 12 feet 2 inches.
From the table on page 137, the inductive reactance spacing factor corresponding to a total spacing of 12 feet 2 inches is:
The inductive reactance for a 60 cps, three-phase, symmetrical flat configuration with a 10 inch spacing for a vertical arrangement of one 4 inch X 1;4 inch rectangular bar per phase is determined as follows. The method of calculation will s depend on the value of --b
a
== 73.66 micmhms per foot.
3-D.
The inductive reactance per phase for two 4 inch-2.16 lb. channels arranged in box form is found as follows for a 60 cps threephase unsymmetrical flat spacing of 12, 15, and 27 feet. The inductive reactance for the two channels alTanged in box form is determined from Fig. 27 where reactance in microhms per foot at 60 cps is given as a function of conductor spacing or equivalent spacing in inches. The equivalent spacing or GMD for this installation is:
elect1'ical design - section Il
CUD
=
=
XLI = 39.0 micl'ohms per foot. The spacing factor corresponding to 16 feet 11 inches from the table on page 137 is: XL2 = 65.0 microhms per foot. The total inductive reactance, then, will be the algebraic sum of XLI and XL2 or
V'12 X 15 X 27 16.93 feet = 16 feet 11 inches (203 inches).
Referring to Fig. 27, the reactance corresponding to this value of spacing is -beyond the scale shown with these reactance curves, hence, the detelwination will necessarily involve the use of spacing factors given in the table on page 137 for this installation.
XL
=
XLI
+ XL2
= 39.0 + 65.0
= 104.0 microhms per foot
The reactance for a 12-inch spacing, according to Fig. 27, will be:
(one phase to neutral).
BUS IMPEDANCE The impedance of a bus conductor is obtained from the fundamental impedance formula and is expressed in the same units as the a-c resistance and reactance:
Z
= V R2 + X2
rnicrohms pel' foot.
I
I\
The impedance angle is given by the relation: ¢
= tan-
I
X R'
The application of the above impedance fOlIDulas to the rectangular bus conductors in Problems 2 and 3 is given in Problem No.4, using the a-c resistance and reactance values calculated in part A of these problems.
PROBLEM NO. 4 The impedance and impedance angle, ¢, is required for the following 60 cps three-phase bus bar installation for which the a-c resistance at 70 C was calculated in problem 2 and the inductive reactance in problem 3. The three 4 inch X V4 inch EC aluminum rectangular bars in the referenced problems have a 60 cps resistance of 17.00 microhms per foot at 70 C and an inductive reactance of 59.4 microhms per foot. The impedance and impedance angle will be: i
I I,
I
I
I
Z
= V (17.00)2 + (59.4)2
= 61.8 micl'Ohms pel' foot 59.4 ) = tan- 3 49 4 = tan- ( 17.00 'I' . ¢ = 74 degrees, 2 minutes. ,I.
I
--
I
Voltage Drop-Vectorial Relationship Contraly to a d-c bus bar installation, the resistance drop (IR) in an a-c bus installation is not usually a significant part of the total voltage drop. The reactance drop (IX) in an a-c installation is usually the larger factor, Vectorially, the relationship between these voltage drops, the phase current, and the sending-end and
Fig. 28 - Vector Diagram for Single Phase Circuit
receiving-end voltages is given in Fig. 28 for one phase of an a-c system. Where:
IR IX
= resistance voltage drop; = reactance voltage drop;
Es
= sending-end voltage;
E,-
:::>:
receiving-end voltage;
= a-c phase current; = impedance angle; e = power factor angle;
I ¢
IZ = impedance voltage drop. The magnitude of the sending-end voltage for a given load and load power factor angle, e, is obtained by the following formulas:
39
section II - electrical design
E s == \I (E,. cos ()
+ IR)2 +
(Ersin ()
+ IX)2
cos () = 0.9
() = 25.83 degrees
( Generated voltage to neutral)
,/3E. == (Generated voltage phase to phase).
= 0.4359 IR = (728) (17.00 X 10-
sin ()
PROBLEM NO. 5 The application of these formulas to a typical bus installation is offered in the following problem using the resistance, reactance, and impedance values calculated in previous problems.
IX
Required:
=
Solution: With 440 volts available at the load, the sending-end voltage is desired to determine if the installation is within the 2 per cent voltage drop required. watts 1- \13 X volts X pf 500,000 1== (\13) (440) (0.9)
== 728 amperes
(100)
= (728)
(59.4 X 10-6 ) (100) = 4.32 volts
IZ = (728) (61.8 X 10-6 ) (100) == 4.50 volts
It is required to supply rated power to a 440
volt, three-phase, 60 cps load of 500 kw at 0.9 power factor lagging without exceeding a 2 per cent voltage drop. The bus consists of one 1/4 inch X 4 inch EC aluminum bar per phase in a run 100 feet long. The elecb:ical characteristics of this installation have been illustrated in part A of Problems 2, 3, and 4, as follows: a-c resistance, R == 17.00 microhms per foot at 70 C; reactance, X = 59.4 microhms per foot; impedance, Z = 61.8 microhms per foot at 70 C; impedance angle, ep 74 deg., 2 min.
6)
== 1.24 volts
Er .
\13
+ 11)2 +(Ersin + 1x)2 11[(254.0) (0.9) + 1.24)2 + [(254.0)
E s == V (E r cos
=
= 44~ = 254.0 volts (line to neuhal)
(J
(J
(0.4359)
+ 4.32)"
= 257.0 volts to neutral at switchboard E8 Es
== (257.0) \13 = 445.1 volts (line to line) -
E r =445.1- 440
== 5.1 volts (actual voltage difference) A 2 per cent voltage drop required for this installation would be: (440) (0.02) ==8.8volts. The actual voltage difference of 5.1 volts is lower than the 8.8 volts that represents 2 per cent voltage drop so that the installation meets the requirements for voltage drop. The current carrying capacity of a 4 inch X 1/4 inch bar arranged vertically is listed as 1000 amps for a 30 C rise over ambient when installed in still, but unconRned air, so that this installation also meets the requirements for current rating.
CURRENT RATING OF BUS CONDUCTORS In the majority of bus conductor installations, temperature rise of the conductor is the limiting factor. Since bus conductor runs are usually short, voltage drop and energy loss are usually not important factors. This is particularly true on high voltage installations. However, at the a-c distribution voltage level and on low voltage d-c bus where very high currents are encountered, voltage drop and power loss may be important factors. Industrial a-c bus runs utilizing voltages less than 600 volts fall in this latter class. For any given surface condition, i.e., fixed emissivity, the temperature rise of a bus conductor is affected by the magnitude of the current flowing and the resistance of the bus bar. These two factors govern the amount of heat generated within the bus conductor 40
and are directly responsible for increasing the temperature above its surroundings. This generated heat within the conductor is dissipated by two means-the radiation of heat to other bodies located nearby and by air currents which become heated and carry away heat either through natural convection currents, as in a closed room, or by forced air circulation such as a light breeze or wind in an outdoor installation. The difference in the latter two quantities, i.e., the loss due to natural convection air currents or the heat loss by forced air circulation, determines the indoor and outdoor current ratings respectively of bus conductors. Temperature limits for a bus conductor must be established such that continuous operation is possible with a reasonable factor of safety for the bus itself
electl'ical design - section II
and for equipment connected to the terminals of the Where: bus. Where equipment ratings are based on a 30 or J2R represents the heat generated in the conductor 35 C rise, the bus rating is usually limited to the same in watts per unit of length; temperature rise. The bus and the connecting leads to W, and We represent, respectively, the heat loss by this equipment, then, will not operate at a higher temradiation and convection in watts per unit of perature and conduct heat into the equipment, thereby surface area; raising its normal operating temperature. A represents the surface area per unit of length of The physical properties of rolled or drawn prodthe conductor. .ucts, i.e., tensile strength and yield strength, may be The above formula solved for the current, I, gives: sacrificed by excessive heating, and temperature limits should be established with due regard to the thermal I(W, + We) A properties shown on page 4. Expansion lengthwise of 1= '\j Rae amperes. the bus conductors may also become a problem on long bus iuns. Expansion fittings and flexible connecWhen the a-c resistance, Rae, is given in microhms tions are used to compensate for elongation of the bus per foot, the heat losses W, and Weare given in watts members so that strains are not imposed on supporting per square inch of surface area, and the diameter of insulators and equipment terminals. The reliability of the conductor, in inches, replaces the surface area per electrical connections to bus conductors may also be foot, A, I then becomes: affected by high current densities and excessive heating. This is discussed in the section on the joining of 37.7 (W, + We) D X lOG 1= R amperes. bus conductors. ae . To determine the current rating of a bus conductor, it is necessary to establish an ambient air temperature and a maximum safe continuous conductor operating ""'Heat Loss by Convection-Outdoor Rating-The temperature. These temperatures determine the perheat loss due to convection air currents is based on a missible temperature rise over ambient. The continuminimum value of wind velocity which is generally ous current that is required to produce equilibrium at taken as 2 feet per second. This is from 5 to 10 times this established temperature rise is the nominal curthe estimated velocity of air currents due to ·free conrent rating of the conductor. Usual procedure is to use vection, but is a low value for usual outdoor wrnd velocities. Heat loss by outdQOf convection currents is: a 40 C ambient air temperature and a maximum safe continuous operating temperature of 70 C which 0.0128 V PV M . means that a 30 C temperature rise is the limiting We watts per square mch, T aO.123 IjD condition. Once the temperature limits have been established, Where: other variables that affect the current rating must also P absolute air pressure be taken into account. Such variables as wind velocity, (P = l.0 for atmospheric air pressure); emissivity of the conductor surface, atmospheric pressure, the effect .of sunlight, and bus enclosures should V = cross-wind velocity in feet per second; be considered. M = te~perature rise of the conductor above ambient in degrees C; . T a = T +2 To is the average ab soIute temperature 10 Current Rating of Round Conductors
~
=
=
The Schurig and Frick * method of calculating the degrees Kelvin betl'veen conductor and air current carrying capacity of round conductors is gentemperatures; erally accepted as the method which approximates D = the conductor diameter in inches. field conditions and gives proper weight to the above factors. The effect of sunlight in raising conductor v'Heat Loss by Convection-Indoor Rating-The intemperature has been found to be small on loaded door ratmg of a bus conductor is considerably lower conductors and is neglected in this method of calthan the outdoor rating because the heat loss due to culation. . natural convection air currents is lower. Thus, the This method essentially balances the heat generwatts dissipated from a cylindrical conductor indoors ated in the conductor by I2R losses against the heat -free convection-for any temperature rise and any loss by convection and radiation. The general formula ambient air temperature is: for the steady-state condition is: 17.5 X 10-G T aO.754 M VI>
We =
* "Heating and Current Carrying Capacities of Bare Conductors for Outdoor
Service," Schurig and Frick, GENERAL ELECTRIC REVIEW, VoL 33, No.3, March, 1930.
D Ln
[0.0031 T aO.941 Do.s1 f:"t O•27
+1
]
watts per square inch.
41
section II - electl"ical design
For the standard conditions of 30 C temperature rise over a 40 C ambient air temperature at atmospheric pressure, this becomes: 0.01805
We ==
D Log10
watts pe1' square inch.
[0.298] DO.81 + 1
When D is more than 3 inches, an approximate relation for the convection heat loss indoors is:
We
0.14 = DO.19 watts per square inch, approxima.tely.
W _ 0.0128 e -
yW t"t' y'D
Ta,0.123
.
Where: P = atmospheres (air pressure) usually taken as
1; V == cross-wind velocity-2 feet/second; == temperature rise-30 C above an ambient of 40 C; Ta, == average absolute temperature of conductor and ambient temperatures; t"t
== 70; 40 + 273 == 328 K; Heat Loss by Radiation-The radiation heat loss, W n for both indoor and outdoor installations can be calculated as:
W 7 == 36.8e
[C~O Y- (1~~0 y]
watts per square inch. Where: e is the surface emissivity constant-usually given as 0.35 for indoor installations and as 0.5 for outdoor bus with average tarnished metal surface, Black non-metallic surfaces have greater emissivity and 0.9 is generally used; T is the absolute temperature of the conductor in degrees Kelvin; To is the absolute temperature of the surroundings in degrees Kelvin-usually taken as absolute air temperature.
In the case of outdoor installations, bus conductors are subject to more corrosive conditions and the degree of surface tarnish will have an influence on its ability to radiate heat to surrounding objects. This factor is taken into consideration by the term e which represents the emissivity of the surface of the conductor. For outdoor installations, e is generally taken as 0.5; while for indoor bus conductors, the average emissivity has been found to be approximately 0.35, Bus conductors are sometimes painted with a flat nonmetallic paint to increase their emissivity. This is discussed on page 49.
.~
Method of Calculation-The indoor and outdoor current ratings for a 1 ~ inch IPS extruded bus conductor of alloy 6063-T6 are determined as follows for a 30 C temperature rise over 40 C ambient air temperature:
=
Diameter D 1.900 inches; A-C resistance at 70 C = 22.57 microhms per foot; Emissivity e 0.35 for indoor rating; 0.5 for outdoor rating.
,1,1
; I;· . IR':
=
Outdoor Rating The outdoor rating for this conductor is calculated as follows: 42
W- (0.0128) y(l) (2) (30) . (328)0.123'11.9
e-
'
= 0.1931 watts per square inch;
C~O)' - C~~O)']
W 7 = 36.8e [ watts per square inch. 'Where:
T == 70 + 273 = 343 K, conductor temperature in degrees K; To == 40 + 273 == 313 K, temperature of . surroundings usually taken as ambient air temperature in degrees K; e == 0.5 for outdoor installation; W,. == (36.8) (0.5) [(0.343)4 - (0.313)4]; == 0.0781 watts per square inch; We
+ W == 0.1931 +
0.2712 watts per
0,0781 square inch;
7
!( 37.7) 1= '\j
(0.2712) (1.9) lOG 22.57
= 927.8 amperes or 930 amperes. Indoor Rating W _ e-
0.01805 [0.298 D Log10 D 081
+1
0.01805 0.298 1.9 Log10 [ 1.90.81
]
+1
]
= 0.1341 watts per square inch W 7 = 36.8e
[(l~OY - C~~O)']
= (36.8) (0.35) (0.00424) = 0.0546 watts per square inch
electrical design - section II
We
+ W r = 0,1341 + 0.0546 = 0.1887 watts per square inch 1
=
/37.7 (We
+ Wr )
'\j
D
X
106
Rae
/(37.7) (0.1887) (1.9) 106 - '\j 22.57 _
=
770 amperes
Limitations of Round Conductors-Solid and Tubular-Round bus conductors do not have the disadvantage of requiring orientation with respect to convection air currents for dissipating l"R heat losses. This advantage is offset by the limited amount of exposed surface area on a round conductor. In tubular conductors, the internal surface does not contribute to the dissipation of heat unless methods are provided for circulating a cooling medium. This is not practical for most installations. A small variation in the cunent rating of a tubular conductor can be achieved by varying the wall thickness up to its optimum value, page 22. Wall thicknesses greater than optimum do not add to its current canying capacity. The efficiency of a tubular conductor with a given outside diameter can only be improved by changing the denominator of the efficiency formula, i.e., by lowering the a-c or d-c resistance by increasing the wall thickness up to its optimum value, as surface area remains constant. This is shown by the following relation:
that a rectangular bar of given dimensions and material will have one current rating when arranged with its width vertically and another rating when its width is arranged horizontally. Other intermediate ratings will depend upon the angle the flat sides of the bar make with the horizontal or vertical position. Rectangular bar lacks the symmetry of a round conductor; hence, the dimensions of a rectangular bar-its width and thickness-also affect CUlTent rating in addition to the orientation. Each is discussed in detail. Effect of Width of Bar on Its Current Rating-Since the exposed surface area is more a Mlction of the width of the bar than the tIlickness, changing the width of a bar increases surface area and enhances its ability to dissipate heat. The most efficient rectangular conductor is one that has the highest ratio of exposed surface area to a-c resistance or to d-c resistance for direct cun-ent applications. This is expressed simply as: . exposed surface area/unit of length E ffi Ctency = . /um ' t 0 f lengt}~ reStstance Changing the width of a rectangular bar increases efficiency by affecting favorably both the numerator and denominator in the efficiency formula. The exposed sUlface area is increased and a-c resistance is decreased, both of which increase the efficiency of the bar. Table 3 gives current ratings of various sizes of bar to show the effect of varying tile width of a bar rather than its thickness.
Current Rating of Rectangular Bar The alternating cunent rating and the direct current rating of an aluminum rectangular bar with its width arranged either vertically or horizontally is available from tables for standard design conditions, pages 118 and 119. It is apparent from these tables
I I
,j
~i
I
I/,~
( J
I
Effie' exposed surface area wncy = a-cor d-c resistance . It is impractical to design for maximum efficiency in most instances as this will require a large diameter tube to increase surface area, with a thin wall to give a maximum of surface area per unit of cross section. The design and selection of a tubular conductor is often dictated by the cost of the accessories used to support, tap, and join the lengths together. From filn accessory cost standpoint, good design will usually indicate that an aluminum tube with a wall thickness approaching optimum, see page 22, will allow the replacement of a standard copper IPS conductor with the same outside diameter aluminum tube. Solid round aluminum conductors are practical up to approximately 2 inches in diameter for a-c applications while any size is suitable for d-c operation, see page 125.
I j I
I'
TABLE 3-CURRENT RATINGS (Rectangular EC Aluminum Bar, Arranged Vertically)
Size
A-C Current Rating * (Amperes)
3X ~ 4 X 14 3X %
775 990 955
f
Cross Sec- Surface Area Current tional Area Per Foot Density (Square (Square (Amperes Per Inches) Inches) Square Inch)
%
1
IVa
78
1033
102
990 849
81
* 30 C temperature rise over 40 C ambient in still but unconfined air.
The 60 cps alternating current rating of a 3 X ~ inch rectangular bar arranged vertically is shown to be 775 amperes. The most desirable shape for a replacement bar in order to increase tile current rating to approximately 1,000 amperes would be to select a bar of increased width rather than thickness. The tabulation shows that a 4 X ~ inch bar has a current rating of 990 amperes and a cross sectional area of one square inch. An increase in the thickness of tile original bar to % inch, with the width remaining at 3 inches would provide a ba~. with greater cross sec43
section II - electrical design
tional area-tVa square inches, while sluface area is increased by only 3 square inches, thus giving a rating of 955 amperes. The use of a 4 X 14 inch bar for the required rating provides a significant increase in surface area-24 square inches per foot, and yet only increases cross sectional area from % to 1 square inch. It is not practical in most installations to pursue the ultimate in efficiency as space limitations often dictate conductor dimensions. A wide thin rectangular conductor, although quite efficient, is obviously not suitable in modem installations. Some degree of latitude in design, however, may be used to take advantage of a slight increase in the width of a rectangular bar. In multiple bar installations, somewhat greater efficiency may be obtained by using more bars of reduced thickness to provide more total surface area between laminations.
Effect of Bar Thickness on Current Rating-From an efficiency standpoint, a change in the thickness of a rectangular bar is not as effective as a change in width as only the resistance is changed without appreciably affecting the amount of exposed surface area. In the efficiency formula, this means that a change in thickness affects primarily the denominator. Since the thickness, t, of the bar is proportional to the cross sectional area, A, for a constant width, W; and the d-c resistance is inversely proportional to cross sectional area:
Wt 1 = A 1 Wt 2 A 2
=R
2
R1
and t 1 t2
=R
2
•
R1
Two bars of the same material, having identical widths, but slightly different thicknesses, possess nearly the same exposed surface area for heat dissipation. These two bars will necessarily generate and dissipate nearly equal amounts of heat to maintain like operating temperatures. This means the J2R losses will be approximately the same for each bar, i.e.:
11 12 =
/2'
\iT = 1.41.
A comparison of the actual current ratings of two bars of equal widtll but with a thickness ratio of 2 to 1, shows a close correlation of the above ratio to the actual ratio of their direct current ratings, e.g., EC aluminum bar, 8 inches 2720 amperes d-c; EC aluminum bar, 8 inches 1920 amperes d-c;
11 2720 12 = 1920
X ~~
inch-
X ~~
inch- .
= 1.417.
A comparison of their alternating cun-ent ratings will show a slightly different ratio due to the influence of skin effect. The actual ratio of the a-c ratings of these bars is 1.34.
Effect of Position on Current Rating-The effect of position on the current rating of a rectangular bar is very pronounced. Where the long flat sides of a bar are arranged vertically, the convection air currents pass upward along the sides of the bar and thereby efficiently canoy away the heat generated by the J2R losses. The horizontal anangement of a rectangular bar prevents the rising convection air currents from contacting the large flat surfaces of the bar which present the greatest exposed area for natural ventilation. The curves in Fig. 29 show the difference in the current rating of a single bar when arranged both vertically and horizontally. 2000 , - - - - - - - , . . - - - - - , . - - - - . . - - - - , - - - - ,
1600 I------il----+----+~,L:.._=..-l"'::::;;..-----l
11 2 R 1 = 12 2 R 2 • Where: 11 2 R 1 is the heat generated in one bar; 12 2 R 2 is the heat generated in the other. A ratio of the currents in the two bars will be:
." 1200. UJ
'" "" ~ UJ
800 ~~~~f=-----+----I----+-~----j
11 2 R 2 11 /R 2 12 2 =R 1 and 7;= VR 1 ' By substitution, the relation between bar thickness and current rating will be approximately,
400
1-----1I--'---+----t---+----j
OL_ _-L_ _-.L 3x!4
5xv..
--L-_ _--L_ _----'
6xv..
7xv..
SIZE OF BARS
The relation between two bars of equal width, where one bar is twice the thickness of the other, will be approximately 44
Fig. 29 - Effect of Position on Rating NOTE: Ratings are for 30 C rise over 40 C ambient temperature in still but unconfined air.
electrical design - section II
ALTERNATING CURRENT RATING AT 60 CPS*
OF MULTIPLE COPPER AND EC ALUMINUM RECTANGULAR BARS 7000
6000
1f.I "x6" BARS-..........
t---..
5000
o z
~ ~ 4000
"l
w
DVl7 ic
","-
w::E
:t «
o
3000
u
0
VB
2000
~
~
G&H
0
N___
0
5000
R
Q
p
o
o
.~
4000
4;
'"
(M
::E
3000 ~ ::>
"-
""z w -
1f.I"x4" BARS
c.. :::E :::E::>
J
2000
F
4; -' 4;
C---< ~
u
w
A
1000
o
V
V ~ "" /0 ~
;::'"
N
I,.--"
1000
s:
0 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
CD
n
16
:r
NUMBER OF BARS
III ~
n',
!!!.:
ARRANGEMENT OF BARS
I
A
II
B
I I I
c
"I I
E
III II
r
I II
I I
F
/II
I
G
"I
II
f--",,-j
H
II I
II
0
I
II
I
I II I
/I
J
1111
/I
I
II
/'
/I /I /I II
I
N
I:,;;~
II II
Il'!L
III' III /I
J
/I II
p
II II
II II II
II
II
I I
I M,
II II
I
"'II "'II III III III
II II /I
f--18"~
"
Q
"' "'
'"
""
1/11
""
"II
R
~.;
l' J iJ
""
/1/1
f--",,-i
I'J'~ "i
I
I"
1/1
*
inch. Large spacings between bars are 2% inches.
Fig. 30
fi
1
.
1
j' Ii•if ~
;f'
) r.
1/l u If i" " §nu j
l'r
'"
/III
i:,J
/III
;1
:/
'I'
t" (I
IJ
j: , I:: '
!
:'"
iiI' i~
* For a 30 C temperature rise over 40 C ambient in still but unconfined air. Ratings are for single phase in the multiple arrangements shown above. NOTE: Small spacings between bars are
~
,
1111 K
oti'
I
I
I /I"
0
0 CD ur
i
I'
1:1" : I: I! I' "
'
(IT
,45
'! ,f
,I
"
fl
;, :~
..__.__ ~_JUJ1: '
section II - electrical design
Current Ratings of Multiple Bar Arrangements A great deal of experimental work has been done in determining the current ratings of copper rectangular bus bars in the many' arrangements being used. These values can be used to determine the current rating of aluminum rectangular bars where the same number and size of aluminum bars are arranged as the copper installation. These copper ratings, however, must be reduced by the conversion factors shown in the table on page 47. These factors will be accurate for d-c conversions and conservative for alternating current ratings. Where a more exact alternating current rating is desired, the direct current rating should be modified to correct for the skin effect resistance ratios of the buses. For example, if the d-c rating of a copper rectangular bar is given as 2000 amperes and the d-c rating is desired for an identical bar in EC aluminum, the conversion factor from the table for the copper bar in terms of the EC aluminum bar at 70 C is 1.273, using EC aluminum as the base value of 1.000. The EC aluminum rating then at 70 C is as follows: 2000 1.273
= 1570 amperes for EC aluminum.
If the d-c rating is desired for the same construction in 55 EC aluminum bar, this is determined from the conversion factor of 0.958 in the same table which gives: 1570 X 0.958
= 1500 amperes for 55 EC aluminum.
To facilitate this conversion for the 60 cps ratings of 4 X lf4 inch and 6 X lf4 inch rectangular bars, the published curves * of copper ratings are reprinted as Fig. 30, with a scale added for the ampere rating of EC aluminum bars. The 60 cps ratings for EC aluminum bars can be converted approximately to other aluminum alloys by the d-c conversion factors in Table 4. Such values will be conservative for aluminum alloys of lower conductivity. Standard replacement sizes of aluminum bars have been designated by Underwriters Laboratories Inc. in their "Standard for Dead-Front Switchboards." These sizes are shown to the right.
Current Rating for Square Tubular Bus The current ratings for square tubular bus are indicated on page 136. Where a ventilated square tubular bus is used, these current ratings can be increased by 15 to 20 per cent. Ventilation is obtained by drilling holes in the top and bottom surface of the square tube to allow convection air currents to pass through the interior section of the bus. These holes are staggered
* "Current
Carrying Capacity of Bus Bars," H. W. Pabst, ELECTRICAL WORLD. September 21, 1929.
46
for maximum effect at intervals of approximately 4 inches. Holes normally are Ilf4 inch diameter for the 3 inch square hlbe and range in size to 1% inch for the 6 inch square tube.
Current Rating for Standard Channels and Angles The current ratings for standard channel shapes arranged in box form are shown on page 133; the current ratings for angles arranged in box -form are also indicated, page 135. The current ratings for standard channel shapes not listed are best determined experi~ mentally.
Current Rating for Non-Standard Bus Shapes The current rating of non-standard shapes should be determined experimentally where an accurate determination is required.
Conversion Factors Many tables give the resistance and current rating of a bus conductor in terms of a particular material or alloy with its conductivity based on the International Annealed Copper Standard (lACS) at 20 C. It is often desirable to know the characteristics of an identical conductor when fabricated of another metal or alloy when only its conductivity is specified. Conversion factors may be used to convert standard values such as the resistance and current rating of one metal to the other without starting from basic values. These values apply only to a given conductor size and shape, i.e., a conductor of equal dimensions and cross sectional area, see Table 4. This table of conversion factors applies essentially to the d-c constants of a given size and shape conductor. In many cases, the direct current rating is of sufficient accuracy that it can be substituted for the BUS BAR CURRENT RATINGS FOR DEAD-FRONT SWITCHBOARDS * Bus Bar Rating in Amperes
225
400 600 800 1000
Minimum Dimensions of Bus Bars in Inches Copper
~by
%
lf4 by IVz Y4 by2 Y4 by3 Y4 by4
Aluminum
Y4 by % Y4 by 2 Y4 by3 Y4 by4 lf4 by 6 or two Y4 by 3
A minimum tolerance of five per cent in the cross sectional area is allowed for rounding and shaping a bus bar. A bus bar having other dimensions may also be acceptable if it has not less than the cross sectional area specified in the table and has equivalent rigidity.
* Underwriters boards."
Laboratories "Standard for Dead-Front Switch-
electrical design - section II
TABLE 4 - CONVERSION FACTORS FOR IDENTICAL SHAPES BUT DIFFERENT CONDUCTOR MATERIALS (EC Aluminum -
55 EC Minimum
6063-T6 Mini- 6063-T6 Typical 6061-T6 mum
Bus Conductor Material
Per Cent Conductivity (lACS) ..... 40 Equivalent Conductance at 20 C ...... 0.656 Equivalent d-c Resistance at 20 C ...... 1.525 Equivalent d-c Resistance at 70 C* . .... 1.437 Equivalent d-c Rating 0.834 at 70 C. '" .. Equivalent d-c Voltage Drop at 70 C ...... 1. L98
* Resistance
61 Per Cent Conductivity -
51
55
53
as a Base)
56 EC 6063-T83 1100-H18 1100-0
56
57
59
EC
61
Hard Drawn Annealed Copper Copper MiniMinimum mum
98
99
lACS
100
0.836
0.869
0.902
0.918
0.934
0.967
1.000
1.607
1.623
1.639
1.196
1.151
1.109
1.089
1.070
1.034
1.000
0.622
0.616
0.610
1.170
1.126
1.089
1.074
1.060
1.028
1.000
0.618
0.613
0.607
0.925
0.943
0.958
0.965
0.971
0.986
1.000
1.273
1.278
1.283
1.082
1.062
1.043
1.036
1.029
1.014
1.000
0.787
0.783
0.779
oCD
III
aQ' :::I
values calculated for 70 C temperatures by using the following temperature coefficients of resistance:
6063-T6 ................... . 0.00350
..................... 1100-HI8 ..................
55 EC
1100-0 .................... 0.00389
606l-T6 ................... . 0.00264
••••••
0
••••••••••••••
0.00363
57 EC
..................... ........................
0.00376 0.00376
56 EC .................... . 0.00370
59 EC
0.00389
6063-T83
EC
0.00403
•••
0
•••••••••••••••
0.00370
alternating current rating. This is true where the skin effect resistance ratio of the two materials investigated is veIY low or nearly the same and where proximity can be ignored. Where a more accurate equivalent alternating current rating is desired, the d-c rating obtained by the conversion factors in the table must be corrected to allow for the difference in the skin effect resistance ratios of the two conductors. For the standard shapes, the a-c resistance can be determined easily by obtaining first the d-c resistance value at 70 C for each conductor and then multiplying this value by the respective skin effect resistance ratio for each conductor as obtained from the following curves: 1. Round conductors-solid or tubular, page 25; 2. Square conductors-solid or tubular, page 26; '·3. Rectangular conductors, page 24.
Copper- 98 per cent conductivity ......... 0.00385 Copper- 99 per cent conductivity ..... , ... 0.00389 Copper-lOO per cent conductivity
1 -
2
IR2~c
'\j R lac •
....... 0.00393
Where: I 1 is the altemating current rating desired for conductor 1; R lac is the a-c resistance of conductor 1; I 2 is the known altemating current rating of conductor 2; R 2ac is the a-c resistance of conductor 2. The following example illustrates the calculation of the altemating current rating of a 55 EC rectangular bar having a conductivity of 55 per cent using the current ratings of an EC aluminum rectangular bar of the same shape but with a conductivity of 61 per cent. The equivalent values in Table 4 are used to simplify this conversion. These charaCteristics apply to a 3 X ¥4 inch EC aluminum bar with current ratings given for a vertical arrangement.
With these data, the altemating current rating, I 1 , can be determined by the following ratio: I - I
.
Material
Size (Inches)
EC Aluminum 3 X
¥4
Current CarryD-C Resistance ing Capacity ( Microhms at 70 C Per Foot) (Amperes) 20 C 70 C D-C 60 cps
17.81
21.40
780 760 47
_==Uf'
section II - electrical design
The conversion of the a-c rating of the above EC aluminum bar to the rating of a 55 EC rectangular bar of the same shape is given as follows. The d-c resistance at 70 C for 55 EC aluminum alloy bar, using the conversion factor 1.089 from the table is: R de70 = 21.40 X 1.089 = 23.30 microhms per foot at 70 C. To determine precisely the equivalent a-c values, the skin effect resistance ratios should be calculated and used to correct the d-c resistance values. The skin R effect resistance ratio, Rae, for a 3 X Y4 inch EC de
aluminmn bar is determined from the following calculated values and the curves on page 24.
/f
'\I
X
Rc/e7o
W
Rae de
/60,000 V 21.40
The skin effect resistance ratio,
R Rae,
for a 3 X ~
inch bar of 55 EC is obtained from the curves on page 24 after calculating these values:
dC70
/60,000 = 50.8
'\j 23.30
.
.
-R = 1.036 (from page 24).
jl
The a-c resistance at 70 C for 55 EC aluminum alloy will be: RaC70 = 23.30 X 1.036 = 24.14 microhms per foot. The equivalent alternating current rating of the 55 EC bar may be found from the formula below where R lae and R 2ae are the a-c resistances of the two bars:
"
11 =12
I'"
f_
"I
,
"
:. 1. , i'L~' ,J"
.i
I ' .I": • "
i
"'
I I,
J: j (/I
1':1 I,
1 1'1: 1 ,
I
1
, I"
'
;,
I
" "1 . ;11;'
~l':d'n,
= 1.084.
This compares with a skin effect resistance ratio of 1.041 for an EC aluminum bar of the same shape and 1.036 for a bar of 55 EC aluminum alloy. The d-c resistance of the copper bar using the conversion factor in the table for d-c resistance at 70 Cis: R de - cu = (0.618) (21.40) = 13.22 microhms per foot. R The a-c resistance, using the Rae ratio, will be:
= (13.22) (1.084) = 14.33 mierohms per
~
=
/2228 760V24:14
= (760)
/14.33
155
(0.961)
= lei< '\j 24.14 =leu X 0.771 for a-c conversion.
This compares with the direct current conversion factor of 0.753 as calculated below from values in the table: leu
lEO
lae
= 730 amperes.
The conversion factor for the alternating current rating is 0.961. This compares with the tabulated value of 0.958 for the conversion of the d-c rating. These factors are so nearly equal that for many applications, 48
The conversion factor applying to the 60 cps current rating of 55 EC will be calculated from its a-c resistance at 70 C, calculated above as R ae55 = 24.14 microhms per foot:
R2ae
-R
The a-c rating, then, of the 55 EC bar is:
I
74 6.
foot.
de
1. " , 1 ;,;
de
Rae-au
Rae
I
,I.
Rae
-R
/4
I"
=
de
W 3 -t =v=12
L' "
3
/60,000
'\j 13.22
The skin effect resistance ratio for the copper bar corresponding to the above is:
rle
10
103
W T= 12.
= 1.041 (from page 24).
/f X V R
X
V Rde20
.
The a-c resistance at 70 C for the EC aluminum bar is: R aC70 = 21.40 X 1.041 = 22.28 microhms per foot.
,
/f
= 529
3 ~ =12
T= -R
3
10 =
the d-c values could be used with sufficient accuracy where an approximate value for the alternating current rating is desired. When the change in the conductivity of the two bars is small, the difference in the a-c and d-c conversion factors will also be small. When the materials have a considerable difference in conductivity, skin effect will have a greater influence on the a-c resistance of the higher conductivity material. For example, assume a conversion factor is desired for converting the a-c rating of a copper bar with 98 per cent conductivity to the rating for a 55 EC aluminum bar with 55 per cent conductivity. For the size just calculated, the skin effect resistance ratio for an iden- , tical size copper bar can be obtained by using the curves on page 24 with the following values:
155
155
= 1.273
155
and lEO = 0.958 0.958 leu 1.273 = leu X 0.753 for d-c conversion.
=
Effect of Bus Enclosures Current ratings for indoor bus bar installations are based on a given temperature rise over ambient in
elect1'ical design - section II
still but unconfined air. These ratings apply to installations in a large enclosed room without circulating air, in which the volume of air is sufficient to prevent the heat generated by the bus from having an appreciable effect on the room temperature. Cooling is affected by natural convection air currents and by radiation. Where the bus bars are installed in an enclosure, the heat generated is also dissipated by radiation directly to the inside walls of the housing and by convection air currents. The small volume of air in the enclosure rapidly increases in temperature as it recirculates in this confined space. The temperature rise of this trapped air will depend upon tlle amount of heat it can transfer to the housing before it is recirculated. There exists, therefore, a series of temperature gradients in a bus enclosure, i.e., from the bus bars to the enclosed air, from the enclosed air to the walls of the enclosure, and from the walls of the enclosure to the surrounding air. This process of heat transfer from a small bus enclosure slows up the cooling process, and a de-rating factor is necessary to prevent tlle bus from exceeding its upper temperature limits. The magnitude of the de-rating required when a bus is enclosed in a nonmagnetic housing such as aluminum is variable and will depend on several factors, such as the size of the housing, the quantity of heat generated by the bus, and the relation between the radiation and convection heat losses of the conductor. High current, laminated, rectangular bus bars with Hat sides vertical are cooled principally by convection air currents and depend to a high degree on "chimney effect" for cooling, i.e., the updraft between laminations. Such arrangements will require a more drastic de-rating when installed in a confined housing since convection cooling represents a greater than normal avenue for heat dissipation. The current carrying capacity of enclosed buses in non-magnetic housings can only be discussed in general terms because of the variable factors noted above. De-rating factors for three phase bus arrangements in a compartmented 24 K,V. enclosure each 30Y2 X 32~ inches-have been presented. * For these conditions, the following approximate ratio applies:
Rating in Non-Magnetic Housing do . In or Current Ratmg
= 75 per cent.
A ratio of only 60 to 65 per cent applies for high current, laminated bus bars that depend upon convection air currents as the principal cooling medium. '" "Carrying Capacities of Enclosed Buses" by A. P. Fugal, ELECTRICAL WORLD, March 19, 1932.
Non-magnetic housings are preferred over magnetic housings for a-c bus bar enclosures, particularly for high current installations and installations where the bus is in close proximity to the walls of the enclosure. Alternating current induces eddy currents in the enclosure walls and, in magnetic material, causes additional hysteresis losses, both of which raise the temperature of the housing. Non-magnetic housings eliminate the losses due to hysteresis. Oftentimes a further de-rating is necessary where magnetic enclosures are used. * The relationship between the current ratings in these two types of housing was found to be approximately as follows:
Rating in Magnetic Enclosure 5 R' . N on- Magnetzc . E nclosure = 8 per cent. atmg m This percentage will valY depending upon the proximity of the conductor to the walls of the enclosure and tlle magnitude of the current in the conductor. Common practice is to limit bus bars carrying alternating currents to 1200 amperes when they are instaUed in a magnetic housing. For higher current ratings, a non-magnetic enclosure is usually required. A common enclosure for a three-phase bus installation, such as generator phase bus, usually requires a non-magnetic aluminum housing to minimize heating. In these common enclosures, the heat generated by the combined three-phase circulating currents induced in the covers of the enclosure limit the rating of enclosed bus. When current ratings are 6000 amperes and over, it is common practice to isolate each phase in an individual non-magnetic aluminum enClosure.
Effect of Painting Bus Bars Painting the surface of an aluminum bus bar is done to increase the amount of heat loss by radiation. New aluminum surfaces have a relatively low emissivity which is improved in time upon exposure to the atmosphere. Outdoor weathered bus bar having average tarnished surfaces is usually considered to have an emissivity of 0.5 and indoor bus to have a slightly lower value, taken generally as 0.35 for average conditions. This compares with the value of 1.00 for the ideal black body. For indoor applications, the current rating of a bus bar can be increased appreciably by painting it with a Hat, non-metallic paint of any color. Increases in current rating up to 25 per cent have been attained by the use of some types of Bat paint. A particularly effective application for painted bus bar is isolated phase bus.
MECHANICAL DESIGN SHORT CIRCUIT FORCES ON BUS CONDUCTORS
The mechanical design of bus conductors and their supports must include provisions for resisting the electromagnetic forces due to short circuit currents. These forces, which are exerted on the conductors during short circuit conditions, are in tum transmitted.') to the insulator supports. Bo~h conductors and su?) ports must be designed to wIthstand these short Cll'cuit forces in addition to the natural loading of the bus conductor. The lateral forces of attraction or repulsion exerted on bus conductors during short circuit produce several force components acting on the insulator supports. These are: Lateral forces exerted on these supports at right angles to the axis of the bus conductors; Longitudinal forces which deflect the insulator supports in the direction of the axis of the bus due to the greater bus deflection tending to pull the supports toward the center of the span; Torsional forces exerted on the insulator at the end supports when the bus swings laterally due to short circuit lateral forces.
Where: The currents i 1 and iz are the maximum direct currents or either (1) the instantaneous peak values of the altematmg current or (2) the maximum RMS asymmetrical alternating current; D is the separation between conductors in inches; k is the shape factor of the bus conductor. It is sometimes desirable to state this force in terms of absolute units for convenience in deriving equations for certam shapes of conductor, as:
F
2 k i iz = -D-(Dynes per centimeter of bus length). 1
A r : : L E Of TORSIONAL ROTATION
)(
TORSIONAL fORCE LONGITUDINAL FORCE
LATERAL fORCE
Such forces, Fig. 1, are illustrated in a typical outdoor bus installation.
Lateral Forces
,
,.,'I ,"
:
~~
it.
The direction of the lateral short circuit forces acting on two bus conductors will be one of repulsion when the currents in the two conductors are in opposite direction. When the currents are in the same direction in the two conductors, the force will be one of attraction. Such a condition exists, for example, in a bus conductor composed of two channels arranged in box form. The proximity of the two channels requires the addition of spacer clamps at short intervals along the conductor to maintain a separation during short circuits. These spacer clamps also add rigidity to lateral movement of the bus conductor. Calculation of this lateral short circuit force between conductors utilizes the basic short circuit formula. This formula gives the force between conductors in pounds per foot length of bus conductor: F
=
5.4 k i 1 i z 10-7 D
(Pounds per foot length).
Fig. 1 - Short Circuit Forces
Mter the solution has been obtained from this fundamental relation, the units of measure can be converted to the standard units of pounds and inches by simple conversion factors. *
* prised "Equatio;'s for the Inductance and ShRrt Circui~ Forces of Buses. C,?mof Double Channel Conductors, C. M. SIegel and T. J. Hlggms, AlEE Trans, Vol. 71, January, 1952, pp. 522-531.
!\ "
51
=
section III - mechanical design
Value of k-The value of k in the foregoing equations is determined from the physical shape and arrangement of the bus conductor. It is commonly referred to as the shape factor. For the common shapes of bus conductor, the value of k will be as follows:
( 1.75 or 1.8)
X
I EMS
RMS current (lst half cycle ); i"
2. Round tubular conductors and symmetrical square
tubular conductors for all practical purposes will have a value of k equal to unity. The value of k for non-symmetrical rectangular tubular conductors can be calculated.** However, for the practical spacings used for rectangular tubular conductor, the value of k can usually be taken as unity. 3. The equations for short circuit forces for double
channel and sb'uctural shapes of bus bar have been advanced by Siegel and Higgins and by Higgins. *** In these equations, forces are determined from fundamental formulas. Short Circuit Current-The short circuit current that will produce the maximum electromagnetic force is the maximum d-c fault current or the maximum peak instantaneous value of alternating current. For most design applications, the maximum value of the short circuit force is desired. However, to determine this force, peak currents often must be' calculated in terms of other current values. For example, the ratings of some equipment are based on the root mean square (RMS) symmetrical short circuit current values. To differentiate between the various currents, the symbols below are used to designate current values described in the following paragraphs. i' = instantaneous peak symmetrical current; ( I
I RMS = 'I,
i
z'1 ,
y2 symmetrical RMS current;
= instantaneous peak asymmetrical current (i = 2i/ );
* Fonnulas for the Geometric Mean Distances of Rectangular Areas ** ***
52
and of Line Segments," T. J. Higgins, JOURNAL OF APPLIED PHYSICS, April, 1943, Vol. 14. "Fonnulas for Calculating Short Circuit Stresses for Bus Supports for Rectangular Tubular Conductors," T. J. Higgins, ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING, August, 1942, Vol. 61, pp. 578-580. "Formulas for Calculating Short Circuit Forces Between Conductors of Structural Shape," T. J. Higgins, ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING, October, 1943, Vol. 62, pp. 659-663. "Equations for the Inductance and Short Circuit Forces of Buses Comprised of Double Channel Conductors," C. M. Siegel and T. J. Higgins, ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING, Oct., 1943, Vol. 62, pp. 659-663.
= average peak asymmetrical current, see page 60;
=1.25i'.
1. For rectangular bars the value of k may be deter-
mined by equations advanced by Higgins * from the bus bar dimensions and spacing. However, graphical solutions are more practical for the usual rectangular bus conductor applications and offer, in addition, a visual comparison of the values of k for different shapes and arrangements of rectangular bar. The value of k in terms of the ratio of conductor dimensions and spacing is shown in Fig. 2. It will be noted that where the long sides of the rectangular bars are perpendicular to the plane of the axes, k will be less than unity. If the short sides are perpendicular to the plane of axes, k will be greater than unity.
= maximum asymmetrical
Symmetrical Currents-When it is desirable to use the RMS values of current in calculating short circuit forces, a multiplying factor is necessary to correct RMS values to instantaneous peak current values in the formula. Symmetrical RMS values are denoted by the value of T in Fig. 3. Th~peak instantaneous symmetrical current, i', in terms of the symmetrical RMS current is:
i' =
y2 I EMS
and I EMS = 0.707 i' .
A symmetrical a-c short circuit current results when the fault is initiated at the instant of peak voltage. The current is symmetrical about its axis and no d-c transient exists for this short circuit condition. Instantaneous peak current is represented in Fig. 3 on page 54 by the crest value, B, of the symmetrical CUlTent.
Asymmetrical Currents-The condition for a symmetrical fault current is seldom attained in actual practice; an asymmetrical fault is the general rule since the probability of the fault being initiated at the instant of peak voltage is very small. When the fault is initiated at zero voltage, a maxinrum asymmetrical condition exists and the alternating current wave is fully offset from its axis. This gives a momentary peak current, i, in the first half cycle which decays rapidly as shown in the sketch, Fig. 3. This peak current reaches a value designated by point A, and represents the maximum possible fault condition. This maximum short circuit disturbance usually governs the design and selection of electrical equipment such as bus conductor and bus conductor supports. Normally, the severity of the fault CUlTent will range in magnitude between a symmetrical fault current and a maximum asymmetrical fault current, depending upon the point on the voltage wave in which the fault is initiated. For this reason, the maximum asymmetrical RMS current is sometimes used in place of maximum peak current particularly where dampmg is present in the system. This maximum asymmetrical current is composed of two parts: 1. A d-c decaying component;
2. A sustained a-c componE;nt. The diagram, Fig. 3, shows these current components for an asymmetrical fault condition.
mechanical design - section III
SHAPE FACTOR, k, FOR RECTANGULAR CONDUCTORS 1..4
1. 3 ' .
~~
I A-
~-O A B
I\.
\.
1. 2
I'.. I'\.
"- "......
"
......
1. 1~ ~A""""
5
r-...
r-....
r-.
r-.
I - 1-8=2
1t-
l-
'-""r- +-
f-
1.O
_A B
1-....
--
l...l...-
l-I--
-- --
I-
V
v
~A - .5, / L..-
~
t-t- +-
1
0.9 I-
t-
-
1--1-
I~--
--
.... _I_f.--
I...-
L..-
L..l-
I/
A
~I..
V 1/
00.7 8·=·25 J w :>
/
II 1/
f7 I-~
A--j
....
~.
0.6
1. SINGLE BARS PER PHASE I ....
1/
~
~
1.7
1/
r7
V"
L..-
I.....
O. 8
i 1/
i
0.5
/
I1-'1--''-1--
~I -I
1-11-1~I-
r-A-J
/
~~~ ~~~I
1/
J
II 1/
I-
·0.3 1-1- l - " 8 =0
I I
~
2. MULTIPLE BARS PER PHASE
1/ 0.4
f--
~S r-Tl
J
!-.~ =.1
rJ~ l-
s
l-
IS
-j
~s-'I
J / II
I
IT 0.1
-,.
1
I I
II
o 0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I Tl I I I I I II I I I 1.4 1.2
1-11-11-11-11-11-11-1-'II-~
1-1I-~
1-1I-~ I-~
1-11-11-11-11-11-11-11-11-11-1-
I I I I I I I I I I I I I I II I I
1.6
1.8
2.0
S-A A+B H. B. Dwight, "Electrical Coils and Conductors," McGraw-Hill Book Co.
Fig. 2
53
section III - mechanical design A
n:--Tl"~~Ir""""r-i:----"--~~_B --T
Fig. 3 - Short Circuit Current* I)
Where: AB is a curve passing through maxima peak cur-
II
'Ii I
'j
,
-I
L ~ j'
_il i: )1 . :,1 T.- ;:',';,
rent values; EF is a curve passing through minima peak current values; DC is the d-c component midway between curves AB and EF and represents the offset of the a-c current due to the d-c component; ST is a curve of the RMS values of the alternating current component only; RT is a curve of the RMS values of the alternating and direct currents. The theoretical maximum asymmetrical peak current as shown by the value at A on curve AB will be a maximum in the first one-half cycle. For conservative bus design, this value will be used to determine the maximum electromagnetic force produced by an asymmetrical short circuit. This maximum instantaneous peak asymmetrical value of current, i, as represented by the conditions in the first one-half cycle will be twice the normal symmetrical peak current, i = 2i', and in terms of the symmetrical RMS current as represented by the value, T, on the curve, ST, it becomes:
,I, .'
i = 2i'
>11[,J_
= 2 (y2I
RMs )
= 2.828 [RbiS Maximum peak asymmetrical
, ,1
amperes.
Effective Current-It is sometimes desirable to use the effective value of current rather than maximum peak current in the calculation of electromagnetic forces. This effective value of current is represented by the curve, RT, and its value at any instant is the
* A.
G. Darling, "Short-Circuit Calculating Procedure for Low-Voltage A-C Systems," AlEE Transactions, 1941. Vol. 60.
54
square root of the sum of the squares of the RMS value of alternating current represented by the curve, ST, and the instantaneous direct current represented by curve, DC. The maximum asymmetrical RMS value of the total short circuit current is represented by the value, R, on the curve, RT, and is sometimes taken as 1.75 or 1.8 times the value of the RMS symmetrical current value. Where these values of current are used to determine short circuit forces, it is well to investigate the system for possible vibration resonance and determine the proper stress factor to apply to the ' system, page 59.
:,i
.,
.
'.i
NEMA Standards The National Electrical Manufacturers Association ( NEMA) standards for Power Switching Equipment, Publication No. SG6-1954, has established conservative standards for the calculation of electromagnetic forces between two current carrying conductors. The basis of this calculation is the fundamental formula for short circuit forces using instantaneous peak current values to establish the maximum force. This standard recognizes the fact that the forces thus calculated are, in most cases, higher than those that actually occur. This, however, tends to compensate for the possibility of increased force due to resonant vibration since this factor is not taken into consideration. The standard force formula shown gives the force in pounds per foot of conductor:
F=M
5.4 i 2 X 10-7
D
The value of i in this formula is taken as maximum asymmetrical peak current and is used in conjunction with a multiplier, M. When maximum peak current is substituted, M 1 for a d-c fault or a single-phase
=
~
;
.'.\
'1 'j
mechanical design - section III
fault on either a single-phase or a three-phase circuit. Often it is desirable to use RMS current values either symmetrical or asymmetrical. Where these current values are available, they can be used in the formula with a corresponding value of M from the following table. The multiplier, M, acts not only as a correction for peak current but also corrects for the maximum force in a' three-phase fault, taken as 0.866 the value of a single-phase fault. This maximum force occurs on the center conductor of a flat symmetrically spaced arrangement, page 57. MULTIPLYING FACTORS Current Used
Circuit
Multiplying Factor, M
Current
1.00
1.0
1 phase a-c or Maximum peak 1.00 1 phase of 3 phase
1.0
Maximum peak
d-c
1 phase a-c or 1 phase of RMS asymmetrical 3 phase
1.63
(1.63)2 or
2.66
1 phase a-c or 1 phase of RMS 3 phase' symmetrical
2.82
(2.82)2 or
8.0
0.866 X (l)2
0.866
** 3 phase a-c ** 3 phase a-c
3 phase a-c
**
Maximum peak 1.00
, RMS asymmetrical
I 1.63
0.866 X (1.63)2
2.3
2.82
0.866 X (2.82)2
6.9
RMS symmetrical
r.;.
Relation to Peak
*
* NEMA "Standard for Power Switching Equipment," 1954. ** For the center bus of a flat symmetrically spaced bus.
Publication SG6-
Calculation of Fault Current
,. '.,
The calculation of actual short circuit current usually involves the use of symmetrical components, except where the three-phase short circuit is considered. For high voltage installations where resistance is small compared to reactance, the circuit resistance can usually be neglected and calculations based on reactance values alone. On low voltage installations, this is not always true, but in cases where circuits are comprised of h'ansformers, generators, and reactors, the value of reactance may be sufficiently greater than the resistance so that the reactance alone may be used without introducing too great an error.t An investigation of the relative magnitudes of resistance and reactance in a circuit will reveal whether reactance values alone can be used or whether a more accurate det61mination is advisable, using impedance values. In determining the total impedance on low t "Calculation of Fault Currents
voltage circuits, all small impedances become important and such components of circuit impedance as bus bars and their connections, disconnects, switches, and current transformers should all be considered in the total. Since the severity of the short circuit force on a bus conductor and its supports is dependent upon the magnitude of the fault current, the mechanical design of a bus installation should be based on a maximum fault condition. For most conditions, a three-phase fault may be used as an indication of maximum fault current for design purposes. This will be conservative for line to line faults in which the current magnitude is approximately 86 per cent of the three-phase value. For line to ground faults, the current may be greater or may be less than the three-phase fault current, depending upon the fault location in the circuit or the magnitude of the ground resistance. The three-phase fault current is of such a magnitude that it can often be used to represent line to ground fault conditions. Many bus installations connected to transformer secondaries are designed to withstand the maximum fault current output of the three-phase transformer bank. The calculation of this fault current is based on sustained primary voltage and the amount of power on the primary side. The formula for the greatest symmetrical three-phase short circuit current on the secondary side is:
in Industrial Plants," Raymond C. R. Schulze, ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING, June, 1941,pp. 271-279.
Where: KVA
X 100 =KVAy3X X1000 amperes. E XZ
= rating of three-phase transformer or trans-
former bank; E = secondary voltage of h'ansfOlmer or transformer bank; Z = per cent impedance of transformer or transformer bank. For example, assume a three-phase transformer bank with a capacity of 45,000 KVA. The voltage of the bank is 66,000/13,200 volts and the per cent impedance of the transformer bank is 10 per cent. The maximum three-phase secondalY short circuit current is· desired assuming sustained primary voltage and capacity available on the primary side.
KVA = 45,000 Secondary Voltage, E = 13,200 volts Per cent impedance of bank, Z 10 per cent
=
I = KVA X 1000 X 100 \/3 X Ex Z 45,000 X 1000 X 100 - 1.732 X 13,200 X 10
= 19,700 RMS amperes (three-phase symmetrical short circuit current).
55
=
section III - mechanical design
The vector sum of the two forces will vary in magnitude depending upon the angular displacement of the short circuit currents from the reference axis. A plot of the cosine functions through 180 electrical degrees will give one complete cycle of the functions. This is shown in Fig. 5. The total force, F A, which is the vector sum of the individual forces on bar, A, is equal to their numerical sum in this case since the forces are in the same direction. This total force becomes:
Calculation of Lateral Short Circuit Forces Force Between Two Conductors-The calculation of the electromagnetic short circuit force between two conductors involves the substitution of the proper values for the shape factor, k; the separation, D, in inches; and the short circuit currents, i 1 and i z, in the formula on page 5l. Where more than two conductors are involved, the short circuit force on anyone of the conductors is the vector sum of the forces between this conductor and each of the other conductors comprising the circuit. Force on End Conductor of Three-Phase Bus Spaced Horizontally-The total three-phase short circuit force on the end bar of a three-phase bus arranged with a horizontal symmetrical spacing of D inches as shown in Fig. 4 would be as follows. Using the vector relationship indicated for the three-phase symmetrical short circuit currents, equations can be written for the forces between any two bars. The total force on the outside bar, A, will be the vector sum of the forces between bars A and Band between A and C. These forces are:
z
F.!
AS
= F. w
5.4 k iAiB X 10D 54 k X 10-7
= . 2D = 5.4 k iAie X D
(
~
( iA COS a i e COS
,,, ,• ••
o -% ::l c..
-Y2
'"
Q)
cos a cos f3
+ cos a2cos OJ
«
0 in
cos a COS fJ
[
z o
w
7
X
;:: u
z
54 k X 10-7 F,IB=' D (iAcosaiBcosp)
7
= F + F,1O = 5.4 ki DX 10-
-%
,.
"
"
'.
~
v·- "-._,
,'Aoo /o%~ "
#
",,
1500-~
120"
\
\\ ,,
"1--..., ~./
,
'.
" 1
V
1\
\\
, ,• . .. '
,,
MAX: AT 165' (.0;768)
(J )
-1
10-7 ( cos a cos (J ) 2'
.-~.-
•••.• cos.I. cos,9
- - _ y, COsrJ..
COS I)
- - - VECTOR SUM OF COSINE FUNCTIONS
o[ oB
oC
"!II, 1 I
:I
REFERENCE
'f
!
Fig. 5 - Value of Cosine Functions
The sum of the cosine functions in this formula is a maximmn at 165 degrees, with a value of 0.768 as graphically shown. For a symmetrical three-phase fault, where i A is ie, the maximum force on the outside conductor of a symmetrical flat arrangement with a spacing of D inches will be 0.768 times the value for a single-phase fault of the same magnitude. The formula, then, for the force on the outside conductor of three symmetrically spaced conductors in a flat arrangement for a three-phase fault is:
= =
FA
(0.768) (5.4) ki z X 10-7 D
=
(lbs. per foot of conductor).
Fig. 4
56
.'1 1
Force on Center Conductor of a Three-Phase Bus with Flat Symmetrical Arrangement-The force on the center conductor of the same three-phase symmetrical flat arrangement of bus conductors will be the vector sum of the forces F I3A and F 130 which are given by the equations:
::l
mechanical design - section III
54 k X 10-1 F BA = ' D ( iB 7
= 5.4 kiniD X 10A
F no
=
5.4 k
X
D
f3 iA
COS
10-1
(i B
(
X
COS
symmetrically spaced conductors in a flat arrangement for a three-phase symmetricalfault will be:
(l')
cos f3 cos (l'
)
FB
= (0.866) 5.4D ki
'1 (
cos f3 cos
8)
2
z o
;::
u
-< ......'"
Yz
/
-<
o
[cos f3
COS
(l' -
-'h
cos f3 cos 8] z
(lbs. per foot force on the center conductor) .
The variable cosine functions which determine the magnitude of the forces F BA and F BO with respect to angular displacement are shown in Fig. 6 along with their vector sum which determines the variation and magnitude of the total force F B on the center conductor. This force will be a maximum at 75 degrees to the reference axis as shown with a magnitude of 0.866 times the single phase value for a fault of like intensity. The maximum force on the center conductor of three
"",''\.
/
10-1
(lbs. perfoot).
Q
'"
~ :l;
-%
'"
,
/7
,,/j
/
~".
60·
AT 75·
(0.866)
\
-
II/~
1
X
.........
/'
+ (- FBO)
= 5.4 k i D X 10-
® MA~.
.
These forces will be applied from opposite sides of the center so that the forces of attraction to one outside conductor will be added to the forces of repulsion of the other outside conductor. The maximum force for a three-phase symmetrical fault on the center conductor will be the vector sum of F BA and F BO or F B = F BA
X
f3 i o COS 8)
COS
1 = 5.4 kinioD X 10- X
2
•• •
.. . ..
90·
'\\
\
\\
\
\
120·
/'/
~ 150:1
180·
.•. I' •• ...
A
\, ./' ..'.
,.\KS I
,I
"'
-1 ________ COS! cos "_._._ cos (J COS 9 _ _ _ VECTOR SUM OF COSINE FUNCTIONS
Fig. 6 - Value of Cosine Functions
Interlaced Bars Feeding Electric Furnaces
57
section III - mechanical design
Force on Each Conductor in a Multiple Bar Arrangement-The same vector addition of the individual forces may be applied to any multiple arrangement of conductors. The total short circuit force on each conductor for a symmetrical flat spacing of six bars is derived in the same manner. For an interlaced bus arrangement of two bars per phase, Fig. 7, the short circuit force for any single bar is calculated as the vector sum of all the individual forces exerted between it and each of the other bars.
F 01.41
FORCES ON C l 5.4 k 10-1 • = 2D (~Ol cos 0 iAl cos a)
F 01Bl
= 5.4 kD 10-
' F 01A2
= 5.4 Dk 10-
1
k 10= 5.4 2D
1
F 01B2
F 0102
k 10= 5.4 3D
1
•
(to l cos 0 iBl cos (3) (.
~Ol
1
cos
()
•
~A2
cos a
)
•
(~Ol cos () i B2 cos (3) .
(to l cos () i02 cos 0)
0,8
0.4
f----\---+----++---+----+-'~_+__t--___l
0.2 f - - + - t - - - f - + - - - t - - - - + - - + + - t - - - - - i
Fig. 7 - Interlaced Bars
O!---o\'-i,....+-+---....--..".--...p--...-j
Assuming the vector rotation in Fig. 7, the forces on bars AI, Bl , and Cl are calculated as follows.
-0.2
f---~--hl\---+---+----''r-I-I---__t-~---l
'j 'I :1
'_1
FORCES ON Al
F AlBl
=
5.4 k 10-1 (.
~Al
D
F AlGI = 5.4k1O-1(. 2D ~Al
F AIB2
=
F AlG2
k 10= 5.4 5D
1
- 0.4 I--+-t--\---+---t--JI-.---tlt---t-----i •
~Bl COS
(3
a
~Ol COS
.
0)
COS
•
~A2
cos a
"
'"
"!
F BIA1
=
= 5.4 Dk 10-
1
F BlOl
k 10= 5.4 2D
1
F BIA2
k 10= 54. 3D
7
F BlB2
F B102 =
58
D
- 0 . 8 1 - - - + - - - - + 81 M A X , ' - - - + - - 76°-0.78
COS
a iB!
COS
(tAl COS
a i02
COS ())
•
•
(3)
•
(~Bl cos
/3
~Al cos a)
(i Bl cos
/3
i Ol cos ())
(iBl
- 0.6 1->"'-------t----\-t---+-i'-------1--->t__t--___l
)
FORC,ES ON B 1 5.4 k 10-1
1i
)
cos a
k 10-1 ,(. F AIA2 = 5.4 3D ~Al cos a 5.4 k 10-1 • 4D (ZAI
'i
cos (3 i A2
COS
a)
(i BI cos (3 iB2 cos (3)
54 k 10-1 . 4D (iBl cos
/3
i 02 cos ()
0°
30°
60°
90°
120°150°
180°
Fig. 8 - Vector Sum of Cosine Functions
The total vector sum of the forces on bars AI, B l , and C1 will vary with the angular values of the cosine functions. This total will vary sinusoidally as shown in Fig. 8, which gives the vector summation of these cosine functions for 180 electrical degrees. A maximum value occurs for each bar as follows. On: Bar Al at 162 degrees-vector sum 0.72 (maximum value); Bar Bl at 76 degrees-vector sum 0.78 (maximum value); Bar Cl at 95 degrees-vector sum 0.63 (maximum value).
j :j
mechanical design - section III
The equations for the maximum total force on these bars for a three-phase symmetrical fault current with the bars arranged as in Fig. 7, assuming currents divide equally between the bars of each phase, will be: F Al =
(0.72) 5.4 ki 2 D
= (0.78) 5.4Dki
2
FBI
= (0.63) 5.4Dki
2
F 01
X
10-7
X
10-7
X
10-7
(1bs. perfoot on A,). (lbs. per foot on BI)' (1bs. per foot on CI)'
Vibration and Resonance Vibration in a system of bus bars subjected to a-c short circuit currents may be attributed to the frequency of the components of current resulting from the short circuit. The system frequency contributes the fundamental frequency to which the bus bars are subjected. The first harmonic of the fundamental frequency may also be present as a result of the combination of two sine waves of double fundamental frequency as was noted for a three-phase fault shown in the graphs on page 58. For asymmetrical faults, a doc uni-directional component of force is also present. This is a variable force with a rate of decay depending upon its decrement factor. A bus conductor ipstallation will have a natural period of vibration depending upon the span length, rigidity of supports, degree of damping, and elasticity of its members. The conductor supports will also have a natural period of vibration. The frequency or frequencies at which this assembly vibrates is a combi~ nation of the natural frequency of the conductors to which the force is applied and the supports which provide the reaction to such motion. The calculation
of this period of vibration has been advanced by several authors. * The conditions for vibration are increased by the proximity of the conductors, short span lengths between supports, the inflexibility of the supports, and the rigidity of bus bar members. Resonance may be established. when the conductors and their supports vibrate in harmony with the electromagnetic short circuit forces. The conditions for resonant vibration are most favorable when the natural period of vibration of the conductor and its supports is equal to, or nearly equal to, the fundamental frequency or double fundamental frequency. This resonance may produce a significant increase in the normal short circuit stresses in a bus bar. In some cases, stresses may be many times greater than normal and it is desirable to change the natural period of vibration of the system by varying design conditions. Such variations as the following are effective in changing the frequency of vibration: Increase span lengths between supports to reduce natural frequencies; Provide flexible SUPPOlts so that more of the initial energy will be absorbed in the movement of the conductor and supports. In installations where bus bars are designed to swing laterally with the short circuit forces, extremely large short circuit currents can be encountered with little or no damage; The flexibility of a conductor will affect its natural period of vibration. Greater flexibility will decrease its natural period of vibration.
Stress Factors (p)-Where a bus bar system vibrates at or near a resonant frequency, it is sometimes necessary to assess a stress factor which, when multiplied by the force as calculated from the standard short circuit formula, gives the approximate increased force, P, due to resonance. It is: P
= P X F (lbs. per support).
Where: p is the stress factor; F is the force as calculated from the electromagnetic force formula for the span adjacent to the support. For doc short circuits, the initial force is suddenly applied to the supports with an impact that gives a higher initial force than the sustained short circuit force. The stress factor for this condition would theoretically be two. Actual determinations of these impact forces may show this stress factor to be slightly in excess of two or somewhat less than two, depending upon how much inherent damping is present in the system.
* "Short-Cut Method of Calculating Stresses in Bus Conductors," W. Specht, Flexible Supports ReduceVibriiffon
GENERAL ELECTRIC REVJEW, Vol. 31, No.8, August, 1928. "Sb-esses in Bus Supports," R. Tanberg, THE ELECTRICAL JOURNAL, Vol. 24, No. 10, October, 1927, pp_ 517-525. "Mechanical Stresses in Bus Bar Supports During Short Circuits," O. R. Schurig and M. F. Sayre, ALEE Trans., Vol. 60, pp. 478-486, Apr., 1925.
59
section III - mechanical design
For the usual outdoor installations of bus bar, under 66 KV, flexibility is inherent due to the long spans. This usually provides enough damping so that the initial movement of the conductor and its supports absorbs a part of the initial energy, A stress factor of one can usually be taken for these installations. On higher voltages (66 KV and up), considerable damping is usually present due to the length and flexibility of the bus and the height of the insulator stack. Short circuit forces calculated by the accepted methods outlined may be more conservative than is required since the natural frequencies of the bus assembly may be so low that allowances for resonant vibration are unnecessary. Where such a condition exists, a more realistic substitution of average asymmetrical peak current rather than the maximum asymmetrical peak current may give forces which are closer to actual effective values. Tests on long span high voltage conductors show that short circuit force calculated by standard methods is very conservative. * The effective force that deflects the insulator and causes insulator failure is in close agreement with the force calculated by the accepted formula using the average asymmetrical peak current instead of the maximum asymmetrical peak value, It is assumed that the initial electromagnetic forces acting on a long tubular bus act as a series of successive forces which are used initially to bend and deflect the bus and to initiate movement of the insulators from rest. The initial peak current in the first half' cycle of an asymmetrical fault is, therefore, not fully effective in this case because of its short duration and the inherent damping in the system. Such force is approximated if the average peak current of an asymmetrical fault from inception to steady state is used in the fundamental force formula. This may be taken as 1.25 times the symmetrical peak current or in terms of symmetrical RMS current, it will be: iff = 1.25 X
y2 X I RMs
= 1.77IRMs • Where:
I RMs is the symmetrical RMS current.
I
i~,
This value substituted in the standard force formula will give the "effective force" on the insulators and bus in a high voltage long span tubular bus installation. The use of average peak asymmetrical current instead of maximum peak asymmetrical current gives a factor of 1.77 times symmetrical RMS current. This value is in close agreement with the factors applied to symmetrical RMS current values (1.75 to 1.8) to obtain the maximum asymmetrical RMS value of the total current, see page 54. " "Behavior of High Voltage Buses and Insulators During Short Circuits," R. M. Milton and Fred Chambers, AlEE Trans. 55-11, February 16, 1955.
60
Longitudinal Forces The lateral deflection of a bus conductor and its supports during short circuit conditions creates an accompanying longitudinal deflection of the bus supports. The greater the lateral deflection of the bus, the greater will be this force tending to pull the insulator supports together. This longitudinal force will vary from a minimum at the center of the bus system to a maximum at the end support. The design of the bus installation, then, should consider the magnitude of these longitudinal forces on the end support and the support next to the end where they are the grtlatest. The calculation of longitudinal forces is beyond the scope of this manual, but methods have been advanced by several authors to determine mathematically its value. * AXIS OF CONDUCTOR
_1_
2F
SUPPORTNEXT TO END
R2
= V (2F)2 + P22
Fig, 9
Although the longitudinal force, P, is less on the span next to the end, the lateral force, F, is approximately twice that of the end support for equal spans, The resultant force, then, will be greatest on the support next to the end unless there is considerable flexibility in the bus conductor. This is shown in Fig. 9. The maximum total cantilever force exerted on the insulator is the vector sum of the lateral and longitudinal forces and is calculated as R 1 and R 2 for the end span and the span next to the end, respectively. To reduce the longitudinal forces in a bus installation, several design factors may be considered. They are as follows: Increase the stiffness of the bus conductor in the direction of the lateral forces; Decrease the length of the span between supports; Decrease the number of continuous spans. The first two factors limit the lateral deflection of the bus and the third reduces the magnitude of the longitudinal force at the end support. For rectangular bar and structural shapes, the arrangement of conductors with their axis of greatest stiffness perpendicular to the direction of short circuit force will limit deflection
* "Stresses
in Bus Supports," R. Tanberg, THE ELECTRIC JOURNAL, Vol. 14, No. 10, pp. 517-525. "Short-Cut Methods of Calculating Stresses in Bus Structures," W. Specht, GENERAL ELECTRIC REVIEW, Vol. 31, No.8, August, 1928, pp. 413-418. "Practical Calculation of Short-Circuit Stresses in Supports for Straight, Parallel Bar Conductors," 0, R. Schurig and C. W. Frick, GENERAL ELECTRIC REVIEW, Vol. 29, No.8, August, 1926, pp. 534-544.
mechanical design - section III
and, thereby, reduce the longitudinal force. Increasing the stiffness of the bar and decreasing span lengths will also change the natural frequency of vibration of the bus conductor and its supports. Where these factors increase the possibility of resonant vibration, a condition more serious may result because resonant vibration may increase lateral force to a far greater degree than they reduce the longitudinal force.
Torsional Forces Torsional forces are encountered in the end supports of a bus conductor installation. These forces are due to the twisting of the insulator support by the lateral swing of the bus bar during short circuit and
may be of serious proportions where the conductors are extremely flexible, and the late)'al movement is great. Since torsional stresses are a function of the lateral movement of the bus, they may be reduced by increasing the bus rigidity to lateral movement or by making the end support relatively free to rotate within limits. A slip fit support may also aid by allowing the bus to rotate slightiy within the retaining clamp. Where it is necessary to weld the bus in tile span, it is wise to reinforce the weld so that bending does not accompany the lateral movement of tile bus and tilereby increase the torsional force. Welds should not be placed in the center section of the bus where bending moments are high and may result in greater lateral deflections and permanent set.
BUS DESIGN Bus supports are designed for a cantilever sh'ess which is measured in inch-pounds, one inch from the base of the support. The total force acting on tilis support is the combined effect of the lateral and longitudinal forces imposed by electromagnetic short circuit conditions. In systems where considerable damping is inherent or short circuit forces relatively light, a small safety factor may be included in the design for these supports. Increased safety factors should be included where tile magnitude of tillS total stress is high and conservative design is anticipated. In outdoor installations, provisions should be made for the complete drainage of water that may collect on or within tile bus conductor shape. On a tubular bus, a small drainage hole in mid-span on the bottom will drain tile conductor. Such shapes as channel and I-beam sections should be arranged so that they drain naturally and do not allow water to stand in any depression. This water not only causes an increase in the dead load of the conductor but may initiate corrosion of tile conductor. Wind induced vibration in long span tubular conductors has been experienced in isolated cases under certain conditions. In most cases resonant vibration can be eliminated by threading a length of aluminum or ACSR conductor into the tube where it lays loosely and acts as a damper. This simple, effective method of dealing with wind induced vibration has become standard practice in tubular installations because of its simplicity and ease of installation.
Clearances Minimum standard clearances have been established between live parts of bus conductors such as switchboard circuits and other applications of rigid bus conductors. Tables 1, 2, 3 and 4 indicate acceptable clearances for various applications. The spacing of out-
door buses is based on design experience and physical size of equipment, and will vary with the voltage and application.
TABLE I-STANDARD FOR
SWITCHBOARD SPACING * Minimum Spacing in Inches Between Live Parts of Opposite Polarity
Voltage Involved
Minimum Spacing in Inches Through Air and Over Surface Between Live Metal Parts and Grounded Metal Parts
Over Through Surface Air
~
125 or less 126 to 250 251 to 600
2
* Underwriters'
Laboratories "Standard for Dead Front Switch-
%
1~
~
~
::Sl /4
1
1
boards."
i
TABLE 2 - MINIMUM CLEARANCES FOR SWITCHBOARDS* ~~'~~~:~eo~js~~~es~~~~e
Striking Distances when
Ri~?~rrS~rS~~I~~e:nd
of Insulating Panels
Between
Part~
of 0EPosite Po arity
% ~
%
1 114 1% 2Y2 3
Between Live Parts and Ground
~~
% ~
%
1~
1% 2Y2 3
Between Parts
of 0r-posite Po arity
Voltage Class**
Up to 50 125 250 600 750 1,500 2,500 3,500
Between Live Parts and Ground
~
:yg
~
%
% % %
1112
2 2Y2
~ ~
%
1~
!:(
2
;. ·1,.'
2~
i ; ;:
*Westinghouse Switchboard Data Book. **For intermediate voltages, it is advisable to use the distances given for the next higher voltage class. Note: For switchboard circuits connected to systems above 150 kva capacity, the distances between parts of opposite polarity should be increased from lh to 1 inch.
I'III !
i .J
61 "
r ,
.1
iL \
j"
-
section III - mechanical design
TABLE 3 -MINIMUM CLEARANCE IN INCHES BETWEEN LIVE PARTS OR BARE CONDUCTORS IN AIR*
Deflection of Bus Conductors Bare and Loaded In designing, the deflection of a bus between its SUppOltS should be considered for both the bare or unloaded condition and for ice and wind loads added to its dead load. It should have a small unloaded or bare deflection so that it visually appears to be reasonably straight;
The bus, when subjected to ice and wind loads, should not be stressed above safe limits nor should it sag excessively.
The unloaded deflection is important from an appearance standpoint. A visible amount of sag in a bare conductor would present an unsightly appearance. The same bus, when loaded with ice, would not present an objectionable appearance because of a slightly greater deflection. It is often desirable in designing . long span buses to formulate a rule which will govern the maximum tolerable unloaded deflection of the bus. This rule, e,g., can be a constant ratio expressing the relation of deflection to span length or it can be a rule which establishes maximum deflection as a function of bus diameter or physical size. The maximum bare deflection of a long span tubular bus is limited by some designers to one diameter of the bus while others prefer to designate the maximum unloaded deflection as a certain fraction of the span length. Conservative design limits the dead load deflection to 1/150 or 1/200 of the span length, while less conservative design to 1/80 of the span length. To gain a straight or level appearance, bus con-
TABLE 4 -
Indoors Phase to Phase
Outdoors
To Ground
3Yz
2Yz
4 7
5Yz
3%
'1' ,I Of
J
I
I
d
!
;:
1
6 6 6 12
6 6 6 9
8Yz 12 16
25,000 37,000 50,000
17 24 32
13 18 23
30 36 45
23 28 34
73,000 88,000 110,000
44 52 64
,32
54 63
41 47
132,000 154,000
77 89
56 65
76 89
57 67
187,000 220,000
106 124
78 90
,
if It I",- . g.
n I.'
q
38 47
* Westinghouse Switchboard Data Book. ** For intermediate voltages, use distances
given for next higher voltage. Note: The above table is for rigid conductors only when supported clear of surface. For flexible conductors, increase clearances given by twice the maximum sag. Smaller spacings may be used for standard apparatus when all parts are shaped to minimize electrostatic stresses.
ductors are sometimes formed with a slight bow equal to the normal unloaded deflection. When this bus it>
STANDARD CLEARANCES AND PHASE SPACINGS* Centerline Spacing 2 Inch Rod Gap, 60-Cycle Dry (Inches)
Minimum Safe Clearance to Ground (Inches)
Hook and Gang Disk Switches and Bus Supports (Inches)
Nominal System Voltage
Apparatus Voltage Rating
Dry
Wet
6,900 13,200 22,000
7,200 14,400 23,000
60 85 110
40 55 75
4.2 7.6 10.7
6.0 8.0 11.0
18 24 30
36 36 48
33,000 44,000 66,000
34,500 46,000 69,000
145 170 235
100 125 180
14.1 16.9 23.7
14.0 17.5 24.0
36 48 60
60 84
110,000 132,000 154,000 220,000
115,000 138,000 161,000 230,000
385
285
39.5
84
120
485 660
380 560
50.1 68.6
39.0 45.0 51.0 71.0
108 156
168 216
* Standard
i .1
To Ground
11 16 21
E~uivalent
i
Phase to Phase
Up to 3,500 4,500 7,500 15,000
Insulator 60-Cycle Flashovers (Kilovolts)
:i
**
Voltage Class
Horn-Gap Switches (Inches)
72
clearances and phase spacings as adopted by the NEMA and based on the joint EEl - NEMA preferred system voltage and also using AlEE standards as a basis. Standard Handbook for Electrical Engineers.
62
mechanical design - section III
then installed with the bow upward, the bare deflection neutralizes the upward bow and the bus conductor is straight or level between supports. The unloaded deflection is not usually the governing factor in a bus installation, particularly where heavy ice formations are encountered and high wind velocities add to the load imposed on the bus. These loads, along with shOlt circuit forces, add to the stress in the outer fibres of the bus conductor and should be limited to values that provide an adequate factor of safety. For most applications, it is satisfactOly to base the maximum fibre stress on a certain percentage of the yield strength or by reducing the yield strength by a £Xed amount. For the bus materials commonly used, the following yield sh'engths and suggested working stresses may be used as a guide in bus design. DESIGN STRESSES
,
Bus Material
EC-H17 EC-H13 55EC 56EC 57EC 59EC' 6063-T6 6063-T83 6061-T6 Drawn Copper Iron Pipe
Yield Strength (psi)
Thickness (Inches)
Up to Vz Up to % Up to Vz Up to Vz Upto%
Suggested Working Stress ( psi)
15,000 12,000 25,000 22,000 15,000 8,000 25,000 30,000 35,000 28,000
Up to Vz 0.050-0.150
10,000 8,000 15,000 13,000· 10,000 6,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 18,000 24,000
Ice Loading-Ice loads are assumed to be of uniform radial thickness on tubular conductors and of uniform thickness on all exterior smfaces of bus conductors such as channel or angle arrangements in box form. A factor of 57 pounds per cubic foot is commonly used to determine ice weight. Typical examples of ice loading are shown for channel bus and tubular or solid round bus.
r1 F
Tf:::::::':':::':':::::::::::::::::'::::
I 1:;: ; N +
...;}
ll", 2
(A
[(A
F X t = cross sectional area of ice on two flanges of one channel;
+ 2t) t =
cross sectional area of ice on outside web of one channel;
+ 2t) t + 2 Pt] = cross sectional area of ice on one channel;
2 [(A
+ 2t) t + 2 Ft]
X
12
= cubic inches of ice on two channels per foot of length;
Bus Loading-Ice and Wind Bus loadings are usually calculated for a given set of conditions depending upon geographic location and experience with ice and wind conditions. These must mst be determined before bus loads are calculated. Tables, pages 128-131, give bus deflections and stresses for bare or unloaded tubular bus conductors and for loadings of Vz inch ice, liz inch ice with 8 pounds of wind, and for 1 inch of ice. t
weight of ice = 1.244 t (D
X
::.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.'.'.:.:.
+ t)
lbsJft.
0.792 t [A
+ 2t + 2F] = weight of ice in lbs/ft on two channels.
Wind Loads-Wind loads are calculated for an assumed crosswind velocity acting on the projected area of the bus conductor. The projected area of an iced conductor is the over-all velucal dimension which includes the height of the conductor plus the top and bottom thickness of ice. The relationship between wind pressure in pounds per square foot of projected area and the actual wind velocity in miles per hour is shown in Fig. 10. The wind pressure on a cylindrical surface such as a tubular conductor will vary slightly from that on a flat surface such as a channel bus. This difference is shown by the two curves in Fig. 10 representing both types of bus conductors. The mathematical relationship for wind pressure and actual wind velocity is given by the following formulas:
63
:j
.," "
section III - mechanical design
WIND PRESSURE VS. WIND VELOCITY I
I
60
I
I I II
55
I
IT J
I ,I
I II
50 I
I
I I
45
I I
I
J
I
I
t--=
I
I
'I
40
I
u..
II
V)
l:l::
w c..
I
J
d 35
II
J
II
vi a:l
I
-' W
l:l::
:::>
:
c..
~
ct. J 4.JI vJ
tJl
l:l::
Z
I 'I
ct.J
V) V)
W
0
II
,
30
~
~~I
~F
25
"',:SJ
"J S,
PI .::s,
ll.:
~/
I
20
1/
I J
I 15
,
/
/
J
/
./ )
/
10
1/
J
/ ~
1/
/
~ ~
~
5
/
~
/
,/
___17 1:;;0' 17
o
..... 20
1."
40
60
80
100
120
WIND VELOCITY (MILES PER HOUR) Fig. 10
64
140
160
180
mechanical design - section III
Cylindrical smfaces- P
= 0.0025 V a
Flat surfaces-
= 0.0042 V a2lbs. per square
pI
2
lbs. persquam foot of protected area; foot of protected area.
Where:
Va is the actual wind v~locity, in miles per hour. Combined Ice and Wind Load-The combined loading on a conductor is calculated by the vector addition of all conductor loads. Graphically this is represented below. RESULTANT LOAD, (w r ) 10,.= V (w b +wi)2+W1/
lbs. per foot
BARE WEIGHT, (w b ) lbs. per foot (from tables)
Formulas for Deflection and Stress of Bus Conductors The calculation of bus deflection and stress is often necessary where tables do not give the required data. Tables, pages 128-131, list deflections and stress for standard IPS and extra heavy IPS tubular bus conductors since these shapes are used considerably for both indoor and outdoor installations. The deflection and stre'~ses for other shapes of conductors can be calculated from the standard beam formulas on page 66. The formulas for uniformly distributed loads have identical variable parameters but the constant in each formula is different. Hence, a simple ratio exists between these relations which permits deflections calculated by one formula to be easily converted where another formula applies. The values given in Tables, pages 128-131, for uniform loading can thus be converted from deflections for simply supported beams to deflections for other methods of support by the following conversion ratios. These conversion ratios do not apply where concentrated loads are applied. CONVERSION RATIOS (Using a simply supported beam as the base)
ICE WEIGHT, (10.) Solid Round or Tubular 10. = 1.244t(D
+ t)lbs./ft.
Two Channels (box form ) Wi O.79Zt [A +Zt+Zf] lbs./ft.
=
WIND LOAD, (w p ) Solid Round or Tubular D+2t w p = P X 1 2 lbs./ft. Two Channels (box form) , A+2t 10 p P X-- lbs./ft. 1Z
=
Where: W
r
= Resultant load in pounds per foot
Wi
= Bare conductor wt. in pounds per foot = Ice Weight in pounds per foot
Wp
= Wind load in pounds per foot
D
= Outside diameter of a tubular conduc-
Wb
tor in inches A = Channel depth in inches t = Ice thickness in inches P = Wind pressure in pounds per square foot of projected area (round surface) pI = Wind pressure in pounds per square foot of projected area (flat surface)
Method of Support
Deflection Formula
5WV
Conversion Ratios
Simply supported beam
D
= 384EI
Beam £Xed at both ends
D
= 384EI
Beam £Xed at one end and simply supported at other end Cantilever beam
D
= l85EI
2/5
WV D=8EI
9.6
WV WV
1 1/5
r
By means ()f these ratios, the deflections for a simply supported bus can be used to determine the deflection for a bus uniformly loaded but supported differently by using the above ratios as multiplying factors. For example, the center spans of a continuous bus may be considered as a beam £Xed at both ends. Mid-span deflection for a beam thus supported is 1/5 of the value listed for the same span simply supported. The end span of a continuous bus can be treated like a beam £Xed at one end and simply supported at the other end. The deflection for this span will be 2/5 of the deflection for the same span simply supported. The formulas and diagrams that apply to the common loadings on bus conductor spans are given on the following pages. For moments of inertia of common bus sections, along with common relations applying to all sections, see page 68.
65
!
i
I
Ir
II :' 1 " . ".!
!:/,,:, 0,
iI ;/1
Y
I, ~
section III - mechanical design
FORMULAS AND DIAGRAMS FOR STATIC BUS CONDUCTOR LOADS SIMPLY SUPPORTED BEAMS
CONCENTRATED LOAD NEAR ONE END (One Span-Ends Not Fixed) WcA -L-
=
UNIFORMLY DISTRIBUTED LOAD (One Span-Ends Not Fixed)
J¥"1"1~,,,~-+ :-
(max.ifA>B)
) = -WeB L - (max.ifB>A
I SHEA: DIAGRAM RlmTrm
I
I
= WC: X
M
W AB - _e_
1u...u...u...L.IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIR2
-
IT
I
D
FS W
=2'
D
W.,(L-X) 2L
R 2
L
I -.L
l 2
WL
=8
M
~M
+ 2B)
V 3A (A 27 ElL
WeAB (A
"'a"
i
(if X
, I I I fSL ~-;-Wcma"=AB MOMENT DIAGRAM
I
SHEAR IDIAGRAM
M.,
,
W(L-2X)
I
+ 2B)
8fS
I,W"-=T
MOMENT DIAGRAM
, I
I
5WL3
D"la"
= 384 El .,
BEAM FIXED AT BOTH ENDS
UNIFORMLY DISTRIBUTED LOAD (Beam Continuous Over Both Supports)
CONCENTRATED LOAD NEAR ONE END (Beam Continuous Over Both Supports) J
1 - .-
-
-
I
I 1 M2 M
1
~ I W
~~
= WekL (1 - k)2, = W ek 2L (1 - k), M1>M or M2 ,
= R1X -M1,
rrmm rutlllllllllllllllR2
G
= 1+2k
1M
H
I
W ema..
_~gl
.
,
I I
~"
-I
D
V.,
=
=
K'l
SHEAR Rl DIAGRAM
R2 (L - X) - M 2,
.i [
W 2L (L-2X)
=
W
k<0.5~~g;g~g]~~
=2
if if k<0.5:: if k<0.5 if XkL
= ~ ( 6X _
L _
kL
M
=24'
M1
=12"
,-
=3-2;; if k<0.5 kL(l-k)2' 2 W ek 2 L3 (1 - k)3 if k<0.5 3 El (3 - 2k)2 '
_ 12fS W ma.,- L WL3
D ma.,
= 384El
g
=
0.211 L
I
,l:
.;~
CANTILEVER BEAM
'.;
UNIFORMLY DISTRIBUTED LOAD (Beam Continuous Over One Support)
CONCENTRATED LOAD NEAR ONE END (Beam Continuous Over One Support)
I
I
We
D~g~~ R\ W I
IIII111111
I
IDIIJJJ
I
r~ ..L~
MOMENT DIAGRAM
I i
:
J
L----1 l~lllll~ I
.
~2.r. ~ ~ !
R
=W e
M.,
=WeX =WeL
M
l
R
I
r -1'
fS
WL3
= 3El
=y
R
=W WX2
= 2L M
MOMENT DIAGRAM ~
I M I-i.
WX
V.,
X
Wemax=T, D ma.,
)
WL
! \ !
6~2
WL
L
D11IailJ
I
=
We (1 - 3k 2 + 2k 3 ) W ek 2 (3 - 2k) = 2W ek 2 L (1 - k)2, if k<0.5
M., M.,
.
M,
M
I
~;1
Rl
Rl R2
---------I.
\
WL
=-22fS
W",a"=T WL3
D"la".= 8El
mechanical design - section III BEAM FIXED AT BOTH ENDS
UNIFORMLY DISTRIBUTED LOAD (Beam Continuous Over One End and Supported at Other End)
R1
-
5W -S-
Rz
-
-B-
3W
W (3L - SX) SL
V" ~
I
M
= 0.07WL
M1
WL - S
M" E g
_WX(3L-4X)
8L 3L =s 3L =4
w
CONCENTRATED LOAD AT ANY POINT (Beam Continuous Over One End and Supported at Other End)
rx~
L
D
~ ! I I I
SHEAR DIAGRAM
Rl~
I
.
' --errrrrnI
6!1Tl1111
'IR
[[Jfui+
jf]--G~T
=
DIAGRAM
= total uniform loading of beam in pounds; = concentrated load in pounds;
= bare weight of beam in pounds per foot; Wi weight of ice load in pounds per foot; wp wind load on conductor in pounds per foot; Wr resultant load in pounds per foot; R reaction in pounds at the support; V = vertical shear in pounds; V" vertical shear at x in pounds; M bending moment in inch-pounds; M" bending moment at x in inch-pounds; f bending sh'ess on exh'eme fibre in pounds per square inch; I = moment of inertia of beam in inches 4 ; S = section modulus of beam in inches 3 ; E modulus of elasticity in pounds per square inch; D deflection in inches; L = length of span in inches; k distance from end to load or support divided by span in inches; g distance from end to nearest point of zero moment in inches; h distance from end to point of maximum deflection in inches; < less than; > greater than. Wb
= = = =
= = = =
= =
= = = =
=
I
~~~:~ I A1111IIII1JJbJ M ~~~g~
h
W We
I IIIIIIIIII! R
II
•
I
Description of Symbols
III I I II IIII I
'SHEAR DIAGRAM
R2
= 00422 L WV D",a" = ISS El 8fS W",a,,=y
.
M
Mx Mx G
H H
Wek (3 - k 2 )
2
We (2 - 3k + k 3 ) 2 WekL (2 - 3k + k 3 ) 2 Max. '(1.74 WeL) WekL (1- k Z ) 2 = R2 X, = RzX - We (X - kL),
if k = 0.366
if XkL
2L - (3 - k Z ) _ L (1 + k Z ) - (3 - k Z ) ,
if k
=L~2~k'
if k>Oo414
2fS W",a" = kL (2 - 3k + k 3 )' 2fS W",ax = kL (1 _ k Z ),
D
D D ma"
if kOo414
_ WekV (1-k 2 )3 3 (3 - k 2 ) Z El ' W kV (k -1)2 e . 6El 0.0098 WeV El
if k
~ 2 +k k
if k
ELEMENTS OF SECTIONS Material
Modulus of Elasticity, E (psi)
Aluminum
10 X lOG 16 X lOG
Copper Iron Pipe
27 X lOG 67
section III - meehamea . I d estgn . MOMENT OF INERTIA
RECTANGLE
CIRCLE
It
A =bd d
x III
1
Tn
"2
r----
_ bds
-1"2
-6 d V12
=
7T
----
f
= 0.288675 d
X I 11
S
I--b~
7T
-1-----11
d
d4 64
=4
ds
'TT 1,3
7T -
'TT
7T
rd
1~
2
1'
=2'
_
11
d2
=~ =
d
s _ bds 11
A
J
r4
1
.
-""3]2=4 d
l'
1'11=4'=2 TUBE
A =
'TT
(d 2
EQUAL ANGLE
dIS)
-
4
A =t(b+e)
d
x
"2
III :=
'TT
(d
4
X _ b 2 + et -2(b+c)
d/)
-
64
s
=
'TT
(d
d1
-
4
= Vd
2
+d
1
y
=X
III
= t (b -
)
32d
11
T11
4
x) 3 + bx s - a (x
t)3
3
2
. , .:-:I
I
4
.
.,
, .....
CHANNEL
I-BEAM
m n
.
.:'!
A = dt+2a (m+n)
A
= dt + a
X = d/2 Y = b/2
X
= d/2 bSn
y
(m + '11)
+ ct2 + a (m32
n) (b
+ 2t)
A
III
bd s
_
a
8 (m - n) (e 12
4
4
-
e
)
COMMON RELATIONS
I =Ar2
! I
'!
II
Where:
!
1
l'
= Radius of Gyration'mme , h es
:
n
= fibre Distance from eenter l'me 0 f gravity to extreme in inches.
f
The moment of inertia , I l' ab out an axis parallel to the
68
axis of th e sectlon ' and at a",- distance from it is given bneutral y t h e expression:
= 1+ AZ2
b earn The momentflexure of resistane resisting Mr e to th' e mtemal stresses of a forces producing bending ,must be equal to the external M1'-M I S ma,,= f n=f
mechanical design - section III
Calculation of Deflection and Stress in a . Typical Bus Installation The following typical bus installation will illustrate the application of beam formulas to determine maximum deflection and fibre stress in each span.
This deflection is smaller than one tube diameter 1
and is approximately 250 of the span length. This bare deflection can be considered conservative design. Maximum loaded deflection with Y2 inch radial ice:
WV D = 185EI Where: w,. Wb + Wi
=
= 1.262 + 1.788 = 3.05lbs. per foot
W SPAN 1
SPAN 2
SPAN 3
SPAN 4
Fig. 11 - Four Span Bus
=J:2 =
3.05
X
360
12 =
. 91.5lbs.-total umfonn load
(91.5) (360)3 (185) (10 X 10~) (0.6657)
D
The deflection and maximum fibre stress is desired for a 2 inch IPS extruded aluminum alloy tubular bus of 6063-T6 with span lengths as indicated in Fig. 11, with an assumed unifOlw ice loading of ~ inch in radial thickness. Short circuit forces and wind loads are not considered. Where these additional loads are applied to the bus, the resultant vector sum of all loads should be determined for the uniform conductor loading.
wrL
Maximum fibre sh'ess,
.
= 3.47 mches
f:
Mc
f =T Where: - WL M- 8 d
Beam Loading:
2.375
c = 2" = -2- = 1.188 inches
Ice weight: Wi
Where:
= 1.244 t (d + t) lbs. per foot.
WL
t = ~ inch ice d = 2.375 inches, (a.D. of 2 inch IPS pipe) Wi
= (1.244) ( lh ) (2.375 = 1.788 lbs. per foot.
(91.5) (360) (1.188) (8) (0.6657)
= 7,348 psi. The allowable working stress for this alloy is 15,000 psi so. that an adequate factor of safety is included in the design.
+ 0.5)
Bare weight: Wb
c
f = -8- x y=
= 1.262 lbs. per foot-bare conductor weight fronL tables.
Spans (2) and (3 )-fixed both ends. Bare deflection:
WV
Span (1), beam fixed one end, simply supported other end. Bare deflection:
WV D = 185EI
D
= ~84EI
Since the span length and loading are the same as span (1), the deflection can be calculated from a ratio of the constants in their respective deflection formulas. Hence, Maximum bare deflection:
Where:
185
L = 30
12 = 360 inches Wb = 1.2621bs. per foot, bare weight WbL 360 W = 12 = 1.262 X 12 = 37.86 lbs. E = 10 X lOG psi I = 0.6657 inches\ from table, page 126 X
(37.86) (360)3
.D
.
= 185 (10 X lOG) (0.6657) = 1.43 mches.
D = 384
X
1.43 = 0.69 inches, bare deflection.
Maximum loaded deflection: 185 D = 384 X 3.47 = 1.67 inches, loaded deflection. Maximum sh'ess, f:
f
-
-
Mc I
69
section III - mechanical design
Where:
Where:
lif (for R 2 and R4 )
M=
M
WL M=T+We L
WL
WL
=12 (for R
WLc
3)
WLc 10 I at supports R 2 and R 4
_ (36.60) (144) (1.188) (12) (144) (1.188) (2) (0.6657) + (0.6657)
=
(91.5) (360) (1.188) 10 (0.6657)
= 4703 + 3084
=
WLc 12 I at support R 3
f =
= 5878 psi at supports R and R 2
f
_ (91.5) (360) (1.188) 12 (0.6657)
4
4899 psi at SUpp01t
R3
Span (4), cantilever beam uniformly distributed load, W, and a concentrated load, We, at extreme end. Beam constants:
=
Wb 1.262lbs. per foot, bare weight L = 12 X 12 = 144 inches WbL 144 W 12 1.262 X 12 15.14lbs.,' total bare wetght W c = 12 pounds.
=
=
=
Bare deflection, with bare weight and concentrated load at free end: WV
D
WcLc
f =2T+-l-
WeV
=8El + 3El
= 7787 psi Expansion of Aluminum Bus Conductors Changes in conductor temperature due either to operating conditions or to seasonal temperatures affect the total length of a continuous bus. A temperature rise will increase the over-all length of the bus while a fall in temperahrre will decrease its length. On long conductor runs with rigid tap-offs to equipment, some provision is often necessary to prevent damage to the terminals of equipment connected to the bus and to prevent overstressing of bus supports. Flexible couplings between sections of the bus, sliding bus supports, and flexible tap connections are used to provide for the free expansion and contraction of the bus and, thereby, protect the bus, bus supports, and equipment terminals. Calculation of Bus Expansion-The amount of expansion or contraction of a bus is dependent upon its length, the temperature change, and its coefficient of thermal expansion. For the materials commonly used for bus conductor, the following coefficients of thermal expansion apply:
(15.14) (144)3 (12) (144)3 6 ( 8) (10 X 10 ) (0.6657) + (3) (10 X 106 ) (0.6657)
= 0.849 + 1.794 = 2.643 inches. Loaded deflection, uniformly distributed ice load plus £Xed load, We: WV D = 8El
W
WeV + 3El
L (Wb + Wi )12
= = 36.60 lbs.
=
+ 1.794
= 2.052 + 1.794 = 3.846 inches. Maximum fibre stress, f:
70
= Mc I
Material
Inch/Inch/ Degree F
Inch/Inch/ Degree C
Aluminum Copper Steel
12.8 X 10-6 9.4 X 10-6 6.4 X 10-6
23.0 X 10-6 16.9 X 10-6 U.5 X 10-6
The total expansion lengthwise of a continuous bus can be calculated, thus: t:>.l LC (t 2 - t 1 ) inches. Where: t:>.l change in length of the conductor in inches; L = length of continuous conductor run in inches; C = thermal coefficient of expansion in inch/inch/ degree F or inch/inchjdegree C; t1 starting temperature in degrees F or C; t 2 = final temperahlre in degrees F or C.
=
144 (1.262 + 1.788) 12
(36.60) (144)3 D = (8) (10 X 106 ) (0.6657)
f
Coefficient of Thermal Expansion
=
=
For a 30 C temperature rise, a 100 foot section of continuous aluminum bus will have an increase in length as follows:
mechanical design - section III
=
=
L 100 x 12 1200 inches C = 23 X 10-6 inch/inch/degree C (tz - t 1 ) = 30 C III = (1200) (23 X 10-6 ) (30) = 0.83 inch increase in length. Types of Expansion Joints-To compensate for this change in length with temperature, various types of expansion joints are used. A common form of expansion joint consists of thin sheets of aluminum laminations usually 0.010 to 0.016 inch thick. These sheets are soldered together at the ends where connections are made to the bus, or the ends can be welded to an aluminum plate, see Fig. 12. These expansion joints take up little room, are neat in appearance, and properly designed, give reliable performance. They can be bolted to both the inside and outside of square tubular conductors and the web surfaces of box channel arrangements. Also they may be inserted between laminations of a bus built up of several rectangular bars. Indoor applications are best suited for this type of expansion joint and for bus runs where a moderate amount of movement due to expansion and contraction is anticipated.
Flexible braid is often used for expansion joints and flexible connections. It is extensively applied where expansion produces considerable movement; hence, it can be used for long spans and in applications subject to considerable change in temperature. Braid is more bulky than the laminated sheet expansion joint and is commonly used for outdoor installations and in equipment where clearances are not critical. When flexible braid is installed on the inside surfaces of a box channel arrangement, the ends of the channels are sometimes staggered to provide more space for the flexible braided connections. These flexible braids may be applied in a number of ways such as bolting directly to the ends of the bus where flat surfaces present themselves or in expansion £ttings which incorporate flexible braid as the means of providing electrical continuity between the mechanical parts, and in bus expansion supports that serve the dual purpose of support and expansion joint with electrical continuity provided by flexible braids. Such joints are illustrated in the section on accessories, page 105, and below.
LAMIN'ATIONS SOLDERED TOGETHER' AT ENDS ONLY
Courtesy Velta
Sta~
Eleo. Vivo
I !
II
Courtesy I-T-E Circuit Breaker Co.
Fig. 12
Cou~tesy
Burndy Corp.
71
section III - mechanical design
Application of Expansion Joints-On short runs where the duty is not severe and only nonnal temperature variations are encountered, expansion joints are not ordinarily used. This applies to short straight runs of rectangular bar that are less than 75 feet in length. Small changes in the length of the bus are usually compensated for by a slight lateral movement of the bus between supports and a slight movement of the supports. Structural shapes of bus conductor are usually more rigid, and it may be desirable to incorporate an expansion joint in a short run of bus, particularly where it connected to rigid tenninals at both ends. Where possible, it is desirable to make a rigid support near the center of a short run and allow free expansion and contraction at the ends by the use of sliding support fittings. Typical methods of supporting bus conductors are illustrated below. These sketches show expansion joints combined with a support, but this combination may be a sliding or fixed support with an adjacent expansion joint.
Methods of Support for Buses TAP
-....H~TE SLIDE
SLIDE
2
FIXED
* H
E
SLIDE
SLIDE
Fixed Supports in Center Only-This method of support is applicable to a bus length up to approximately 75 feet and is a common method on short runs to eliminate expansion joints. Tap travel longitudinally will depend upon the tap distance from the center fixed support.
extreme end depending upon the length of bus; in most cases, a flexible tap will be required. This practice should be confined to a relatively short run where tap movement must be held to a minimum. TAP
~)---rtir-----:';t?----'R~-~ FIXED
SLIDE
EXPANSION SUPPORT
SLIDE
FIXED
F,ixed Supports at Both Ends-Where rigid connections are made to both ends of a bus run this method is applicable. One intennediate expansio~ joint is used where the bus run is of moderate length and taps are not located at too great a distance from the fixed ends. The center expansion joint also may be a support as shown in the sketch. TAP
H
SLIDE
rz!1---iZ? FIXED
EXPANSION SUPPORT
rz!1----,.-,He-FIXED
SLIDE
Fixed Supports at Intermediate Points-This method of support is similar to the bus with fixed supports at both ends but with additional slide supports on either end of the bus. Much longer runs are, therefore, possible. Without rigid end supports, torsional strains on these supports caused by lateral movement of a flexible bus on short circuit may be slightly less. Tap mov~ment will be slight near the fixed supports. Connections located near the expansion joint may require flexible taps.
TAP
7!-----;'H~---,..H..-------rH~T---H~ FIXED
SLIDE
SLIDE
SLIDE
SLIDE
Fixed Supports at One End Only-Where one end must be fixed, this method of support applies. Rigid connections to equipment are usually made at the fixed end. Taps will have considerable travel near the
* "Basic Principles
to Support Alunlinum and Copper Buses" M. Bl'enner ELECTRICAL WORLD, July 27, 1953, PP. 118-119.' ,
EXPANSION SUPPORT
FIXED
Fixed Supports at Center and Both Ends-This method applies to long bus nmS. With fixed supports at the ends, rigid connections to equipment may be mad~ at both ends of the bus. Intermediate slide supports can be used although not shown. The expansion joint may also be a point of support as illustrated.
JOINING BUS CONDUCTORS Aluminum bus conductor is commonly joined by several methods. The simplest and most widely used is overlapping the bus and bolting the sections together. The advantage of this method is its simplicity and flexibility, allowing field assembly and disassembly of component parts. Other joining practices such as welding, brazing, and soldering require skill and special equipment. Such joints, however, may be more stable for the materials are united in a bond that eliminates the variable contact resistance between bars. The variable nature of contact resistance affects joint efficiency, and standard practices must be followed to make reliable, efficient bolted bus bar joints.
The efficiency of a bolted joint is usually gaged in terms of its resistance. A joint is considered to have 100 per cent efficiency when the resistance of the joint is equal to an equivalent length of conductor used to make up the joint. The overlapped section is the length of the joint. The factors which determine high joint efficiency are those that initially produce the lowest possible joint resistance. The most important of these factors are the method of preparation of the contact surfaces and the application of sufficiently high clamping force to the joint.
PREPARING ALUMINUM CONTACT SURFACES The oxide film on an aluminum conductor is not a good conductor of electricity and must be removed from the contact surfaces before making an electrical joint. Since oxidation takes place almost immediately on a chemically clean surface of aluminum when exposed to the ahnosphere, a means should be provided to prevent the immediate re-oxidation of the mating surface after the oxide is removed. The following joining procedure provides for the removal of the oxide film and prevents re-oxidation while the joint is being made. The areas to be joined should first be cleaned of any dirt or foreign material and a grease-like sealing paste or compound applied to the smfaces to be joined. These surfaces are then abraded through this paste by using one of the following methods: Brushing with a suitable fiberglas brush; Abrading with emery cloth or emery paper; Wire brushing; Draw filing; Abrading with steel wool. Excellent smface preparation can be obtained with the first three methods of smface treatment, while the latter two give good results. A fiberglas brush produces a satin finish with the depth of scratches quite uniform, leaving numerous microscopic peaks and valleys. Wire brushes produce a slightly less uniform smface with deeper scratches.
After abrading through the sealing paste, the contact surfaces are joined together, either by clamps or with bolts. The excess paste will extrude from the joint where it can be wiped off. The sealing paste provides an important joint function. Electrical contact is made between coincident peaks on the two mating surfaces. The pressure applied to the bus bar joint causes these high points to Hatten or defOlTIl. This deformation is not complete, leaving a considerable amount of voids between the Hattened current carrying areas. The function of a sealing paste is to penetrate into these voids and make the joint gas tight and moisture proof. Deteriorating inHuences are thus kept from the joint surfaces, and oxidation is prevented. There are many excellent sealing pastes or compounds for making reliable electrical joints. These materials may be classed as electrical "contact aids" and ordinarily may be of two types: 1. Sealing pastes-These serve only to seal the pre-
pared joint surfaces from air and moisture. Examples are neuh'al greases, heavy bodied jells, extensible films, etc.; 2. Sealing paste and contact aid-This type incorpo-
rates a metallic particle suspended in a heavy bodied sealing paste, or it may contain a mild chemical in a sealing paste to remove the aluminum oxide film.
73
section IV - ioining
Many of these contact aids are available under brand names in various kinds of containers and dispensers. They are available in bulk form for paddle application and in collapsible tubes for direct application. Sealing pastes are also available in pressurized containers for spraying. The effectiveness of a joint contact aid can be gaged by its desirable properties. These may be listed as follows: High temperature stability-The joint compound should not drip or leach out when subjected to high temperatures. A measure of the high temperature stability is the drop point of the material; Low temperature stability-The material should be able to withstand low temperatures and vibration without cracking; Stable consistency-The paste should not evaporate or harden with service; Other properties-The material should be easily applied, non-inflammable, non-toxic, and non-staining.
Aluminum to Copper Joints Where aluminum bus bar is joined to copper bus bar, the same surface preparation should be made as indicated above. For indoor installations, protection against galvanic corrosion is generally not important, but for outdoor applications, it may be necessary to protect the joint with a covering or "cover-all" that will exclude air and moisture. Molded on plastic covers, self sealing hand applied mastic compounds, tape, and sprayed or brushed on paint and films are used. Generally, a liberal application of a suitable compound will give satisfactory protection.
Silver Plated Contact Surfaces A high degree of efficiency is attained in a bolted electrical joint where the aluminum contact surfaces are silver plated. This is achieved because of the high conductivity of silver and the fact that silver oxide and silver sulphide will conduct electricity. Both also tend to revert back to the metallic silver state upon heating; hence, silver plated contact surfaces need little or no preparation before joining, and the resistance of the joint will remain relatively stable over a long period of time for all normal conditions of loading. The contact resistance of a silver plated electrical joint is independent of the thickness of the silver plating but is dependent upon the bond to the parent material. A thin silver plating will produce as low a contact resistance as a heavier plating. It is advisable, however, to plate the contact surfaces with at least the commercial plating thickness as this will eliminate porosity of the deposit and thereby better protect the base metal and other preparatory platings applied to
74
the bars. A plating thickness of 0.0002 inch has been found satisfactory to withstand a great number of repeated contact operations such as plug-in bus duct. The silver plating process lends itself to production methods in which the quality of the plating and the uniformity of the deposits can be closely controlled. A recommended process for silver plating, which is easily adapted to production methods, is given on page 160. Small quantities of aluminum bus bar can be silver plated in many of the job shops experienced in silver plating aluminum. It is sometimes desirable to mask portions of the bar where silver plating is not necessary or where bending operations will be performed. Masking tapes or quick drying films can be applied to the areas where silver deposition is not wanted. By this procedure, silver deposits are made where required for electrical contact purposes. Where it is desirable to silver plate the electrical contact surfaces of small quantities of eus bar, a portable brush plating device can be used. This device produces high quality silver deposits for electrical contact purposes where plating thickness is not an important factor. It has the advantage that it may be used for emergencies, for small quantities of bar, and for field applications. A very selective silver deposit can be made on the aluminum contact surfaces without the necessity of masking the material. Any intermediate area can be silver plated on one or both sides and limited to portions of the conductor where actual .contact is to be made. The effectiveness of silver plated contacts in producing a permanent low resistance joint is recognized in the rating of electrical equipment. Where the terminals are silver plated, such equipment will have higher recognized operating temperatures than equipment with unplated terminals.
Other Methods of Surface Preparations Standards also recognize the use of other metallic contact materials besides silver for preparing the contact surfaces of aluminum. The Underwriter's Laboratories, Inc., in their "Standard for Busways and Associated Fittings," specify tin and cadmium as alternate metals. Cadmium is usually applied to aluminum by the electroplating process and may be advisable in some corrosive installations because its galvanic potential in certain environments is closer to aluminum than other metals. Where it is used in corrosive atmospheres, a plating thickness considerably greater than the commercial plating thickness should be used. * The application of tin to an aluminum contact surface can be done by electroplating or by hot flowing tin onto the aluminum contact surfaces. Hot tinning can be accomplished either by the use of suitable '" "Evaluation of Test pata in Determining Minimum Design Requirements for Aluminum to Copper Connectors," D. C. Hubbard and R. W. Kunkle, AlEE Tech. Paper 54-39, November, 1953.
ioining - section N
fluxes presently On the market or by the newly developed procedure of ultra-sonic tinning. In the latter process, the oxides are removed by ultra-sonic vibrations, and the tin is hot flowed onto the oxide free contact surface. Since it is necessary to heat the bars during tinning, the temper of cold worked or heat treated aluminum materials may be sacrificed and lower physical properties result. Hot tinning of bus bar contact surfaces, therefore, has some limitations in its application. Tinned contact sUlfaces are used in applications where assembly and disassembly of the joint will be encountered as no surface preparation is necessary for clean tinned contact surfaces.
Friction tinning of bus sUlfaces shows great promise for electrical applications. This method requires no flux. It is easily accomplished by abrading the surface of the aluminum bar through a molten globule of tin or a tin-zinc solder. Solders with a lead content are not recommended. The abrasion removes the oxide film, leaving a chemically clean aluminum surface for the solder bond. Fiberglas blUshes have proven to be excellent abrading devices and are available for preparing small quantities of bar by manual abrading methods. Development of automatic devices for friction tinning the ends and intermediate areas of bus bars on a production scale are now being investigated.
JOINT RESISTANCE Total Joint Resistance The total joint resistance of two lapped rectangular bus bars is composed of two parts-the contact resistance at the interface of the mated bars and the volumetric resistance of the metal in the overlapped section, Fig. 1, considering the j oint to be devoid of any contact resistance. The sum of these two components gives total joint resistance.
ship was uniformly applied to the external surfaces of the bars, giving a uniform pressure over the entire contact surface. This relation is expressed as follows and is applicable for the range of pressures used in bus conductor joints. RPll=C Where: R is the contact resistance in ohms or microhms; P is the total pressure in pounds; n is an exponent whose value will range from OAto 1.0; C is a constant.
iLl
Fig. 1
Where the pressure is uniformly applied, contact resistance is uniform across the- interface and contact area can be measured in terms of the total square inches of overlap area, such as multiplying the width of the bar by the length of overlap. This condition is produced, for example, by clamping the two lapped bars in a hydraulic press. Contact Resistance for a Uniformly Applied Pressure-The contact resistance between two lapped bars, Fig. 2, is the resistance at the contact interface. This resistance will be affected by the total applied force and the condition or preparation of the contact surface prior to joining. The contact resistance of such a joint has been established by a general formula as a function of pressure. * The pressure used to determine this relation-
* JOURNAL, "Electrical Contact of Bus Bar Joints," C. L. Denault, THE ELECTRIC July 1933.
I
_--.--_ _--1-1--------r~
iT
Fig. 2
Where a bus bar is prepared by abrading the contact sUlfaces with emery through a particular sealing paste such as NO-OX-ID, the above becomes approximately: RpO.724 = 1620. Where: R is given in microhms per square inch; P is the pressure in pounds per square inch. The formula applies only to surfaces prepared in this manner using this type of sealing paste. For silver plated contact surfaces mated with a uniformly applied pressure, the expression that approximates this surface preparation is: RpO.778 = 155. 75
section N - joining
Where: R is given in microhms per square inch; P is given in pounds per square inch. The contact resistance for these conditions of preparation is shown in the curves in Fig. 3. 8000
\.
600.0
\.
I'\. 1\
4000 3000
\.
I\.
'"
RP
~
II)
=155 "'" \.
0.0778
13 1000
'"c..
800
ti z
600
~
8
RP
tvt
=162b\
0.724
Resistance R L of the solid joint in Fig. 1:
\
Q) II Q)SILVER PLATED CONTACT ISURF~CES WITH NO COMPOUND
400
L R=p-.
\.
e::.
w
Resistance of equal length of a single bar:
\
1\
5i 2000
CD
RL
ABRAI~ED
300
©JoJJT ISUFHE .! THROUGH NO-OX·ID "A" SPECIAL
200
100 0.1
0.2
0.3 0.4
tact resistance, the effect of different lengths of overlap is shown in Fig. 4. The ratio of the resistance of this solid lapped joint to the resistance of an equal length of single bar is called the streamline or distortion factor. The value of this streamline factor is given in terms of the ratio Lit, where L is the length of overlap and t is the thickness of the bar. The resistance of the solid joint indicated in Fig. 1 in terms of the resistance of a single bar of length, L, and width, tv, is offered by the expressions below, which show the application of the streamline factor, e.
0.6 0.8 1.0
2.0
3.0 4.0
6.0 8.0
CONTACT RESISTANCE (MICROHMS PER SQ. INCH)
Fig. 3
Metal Resistance in a Lapped Joint with Uniformly Applied Pressure-Where the clamping force is uniformly applied to the external surfaces of two lapped bars, the effect of different lengths of overlap can also be determined. The effective overlap in this case will be the actual length of overlap, L, as shown in Fig. 2. Assuming the joint to be solid metal without con-
Generally, small amounts of overlap are not used and hence are not too important, except that they illustrate the value of the streamline factor. A length of overlap eqlial to or greater than eight to ten times the thickness of the bar is often considered adequate. For these commonly used lengths of overlap, the streamline factor approaches the value of 0.5 which means that the resistance of the solid joint approaches liz the resistance of a single bar of equal length. In many instances, the length of overlap is made equal to the width of the bar where the width is greater than eight to ten times the thickness: In bolting two' Hat rectangular bars together, the factor that generally determines the length of overlap is the spacing and arrangement of the bolts or the size of the clamp where one is used.
2.0
I--l
1.8 w
I
= e X R = e (p ~t ).
I
(OJ
,-
1.6
...'"o
t
~1.4
u..
w ~1.2
~ 1.0 ~
Fig. 5
,
1\
lJ)
.8
1"'-
""
.6 .4
o
2
l~_-=====CDJ~_-----==::(TI)===~
'-
3
---%1
4 5 6 VALUES OF L/ t
Fig. 4
7
8
9
10
76
------ % 1 - -
*
* ins. Copper W. Melsom and H. C. Booth, "The Efficiency of Overlappiog Joiots and Alumioum Bushar Conductors," JOURNAL IEE (G.B.), Vol. 60. No. 312. Aug. 1922.
Tt
Fig. 6
joining - section IV
Joint Resistance of Bolted Bus Bars Where bars are lapped and bolted as in Figs. 5 and 6, contact resistance and the metallic resistance due to different lengths of overlap are difficult to determine because current is not uniformly distributed across the contact interface. In a typical bolted joint, the current is concentrated more heavily around each bolt hole where pressure is high and contact resistance low. Current density is less in areas remote from the bolts, and these areas add little to the cun-ent canying capacity of the joint. This affects the volumetric resistance of the metal comprising the joint and also affects the contact resistance. Effect of Overlap on Bolted Bus Bars-The effectiveness of a length of overlap where only a single bolt is used is illustrated in Fig. 5. In this case, the effective overlap is not a great deal more than the diameter of the washer used. The effective overlapping area where two bolts are used, Fig. 6, indicates that the
effective length of overlap is approximately equal to the distance between the bolts plus the diameter of one washer. The latter arrangement is prefen-ed, for the bus bar in the region between bolts will divide the current How. Tests show that bolts placed near the ends of the overlapped section tend to decrease the streamline factor. Also, the heat generated in the length of bar between bolts will be considerably lower than in an equivalent length of single conductor. In a bolted joint, it is difficult to determine contact resistance in terms of pressure per square inch of contact area because the pressure is not uniformly distributed. The concentration of pressure around the bolt produces an area of low contact resistance in the immediate vicinity of the bolt hole. The area between bolt holes and the area near the edges of the bus bar have a much greater contact resistance. The magnitude of applied bolt force and more particularly the distribution of this applied force to the bus bars are important in determining the pattern of contact resistance and its effect on the life of the joint.
JOINT BOLTING PRESSURE One of the important factors in establishing a low resistance bus bar joint and maintaining this low resistance is the use of sufficient pressure well distributed. The initial contacts between coincident peaks on the mating surfaces can be considered as a number of small paralleled conductors. As pressure is applied, more of these peaks are brought into contact, and they Hatten into larg,er contact areas, thereby paralleling a multitude of electrical paths between the bars. To join two conductors efficiently, it is desirable to establish
Fig. 7 - Concentration of Pressme Around Bolt Holes
a maximum of these contact areas and to distribute them as uniformly as possible. This distribution will depend upon the surface preparation and the method of applying the clamping force.
Distribution of Applied Force in a Bolted Joint When force is applied by a bolt, Fig. 5, the contact area is concentrated more heavily around the bolt hole where pressure is highest. In such a joint, pressure can be considered as graduated in a series of concentric annular areas with the pressure decreasing in intensity as the distance from the edge of the bolt hole increases. The pattern of this pressure variation is shown in Fig. 7. Since pressure is highest around the bolt hole, the bus bar material in this area is forced into more intimate contact and all surface irregularities are flattened until the material is almost completely solid metal-tometal contact with little voids. From this high pressure and good metal-to-metal contact in the vicinity of the bolt hole, pressures are gradually reduced as tlle distance from the hole increases and the resulting metal-to-metal bond is less complete. At points remote from the bolt hole, little pressure may be exerted, and contact resistance in these areas will be higher. The pattern of pressure distribution around each individual bolt is important in a bus bar joint in order to maintain the low initial resistance indefinitely. This distribution of contact area in two typical. bolting de77
i !
section IV - joining MAXIMUM PRESSURE ELASTIC LIMIT OF CONDUCTOR MATERIAL
ELASTIC lIMI,.'\OF CONDUCTOR MATERIAL
MAXIMUM PRESSURE -----:::::::;;<>P Vi
in
0..
1£_11
w·
""
:;)
en en w
"" 0..
I
I
r ---;I----"l=;.:;z='!-.
0
0
~I~~~"'----~
~LAPPED BARS---+-HOlE+lAPPED BARS~
I
I
I I
I I
rvtxX"X''"V'"'''7V~h~-----l"TT7'~rv---;T"7.."...,..,~1
I I I I I
I
I
I
I
0..
W
""
:;)
en en w
"" 0..
0
I
I
I
I
LAPPED BARS-r- HOLE -I-lAPPED BARS-l
I
I
I i : I I
I I
I
I
I
I I
1
I
Fig. 8 - Poor Pressure Distribution Fig. 9 - Improved Pressure Distribution
signs is indicated in Figs. 8 and 9. The pressure distribution for an extreme condition is shown in Fig. 8. This would be typical where no washers are used under the head or nut of the bolt or where a very thin washer is used. The material in the immediate vicinity of the bolt hole may be stressed to the point where the bus material flows and the localized distortion at this point will tend, in time, to stabilize at a value near the elastic limit of the bus bar material. This high localized pressure near the bolt hole is subject to a high rate of creep when current loadings increase bus temperatures. A more desirable pressure distribution will result where thick, large diameter washers are used with each individual bolt. This is shown in Fig. 9. These washers, in effect, serve to distribute the applied bolt pressure more uniformly to the surface of the bus bar. The resulting pressure curves will be somewhat as indicated in the pressure diagram of Fig. 9. Such a joint will have more stable operating characteristics and longer life because localized portions of the bar near the bolt hole are not as highly stressed and are, therefore, not as subject to creep when the temperature of the joint increases. Where the pressure can be considered to be uniformly applied, design stresses on the total lapped area of 800 psi to 1,200 psi can be used for the EC aluminum tempers. Joints in the higher strength alloy bus bars such as 55 EC and 56 EC can be designed with pressures up to 2,000 psi.
78
Bolting Methods Two methods are generally accepted as producing reliable bolted bus bar joints. These methods are described as Method I and Method II. Method I makes use of an aluminum bolt and nut combined with thick washers. Method II uses a steel or bronze bolt and requires the use of a Belleville spring washer to maintain a uniform clamping force. This Belleville spring washer compensates for pressure variations due to the difference in the coefficients of expansion of the bolts and the aluminum bars. Both methods will produce reliable joints with proper surface preparation. Where
STEEL NUT METHOD I
METHOD II
Fig. 10
Fig. 11
Recommended Bolting Methods
it is desirable to use bolts % inch in diameter or smaller, Method II is generally used. Either method
joining - section IV
will produce excellent electrical joints where larger bolt sizes are used, that is, over % inch in diameter. These methods are shown in Figs. 10 and 11. Where two bars are joined as in Method I, the use of thick washers under the head and nut of the bolt produces a uniform pressure on the bars. By using an aluminum bolt, the thermal expansion of the bus bar and the bolt will be the same. Consequently, when current loadings increase the temperature of the joint assembly, the applied bolting force will remain constant. In fact, with steel washers, the pressure may slightly decrease because the washers will not expand as much as the aluminum bolt. This is a desirable characteristic since creep rates are increased considerably with a temperature rise, and a small reduction in pressure will tend to lower the creep rate slightly. When this joint is exposed to outdoor ahnospheric conditions, some provisions should be made to protect the steel washers from corrosion. In locations where ahnospheric corrosion is not severe, galvanizing or heavy platings of tin or cadmium may provide sufficient protection for the steel parts. In the more highly corrosive atmospheres, a stainless steel washer will be more reliable. Stainless steel type 316 is recommended. The use of steel bolts and flat washers is not generally recommended for bolting aluminum bus bars.
A satisfactory joint can be made with steel bolts, but this method of joining should only be applied to the higher strength bus bar materials, such as 55 EC and 56 EC, where current loading conditions are conservative and thicker than standard flat washers are used. Silver plating the contact surfaces will make such joints more reliable. Aluminum joints are also commonly made with Belleville spring washers and steel bolts. This is jofuing Method II. Since the steel bolts have a much lower coefficient of thermal expansion than the aluminum bars, provisions must be made to compensate for variations in joint pressure with temperature. Belleville spring washers provide this compensation. These spring washers are not usually required when aluminum bars are joined with aluminum bolts since both have the same thermal coefficient of expansion. On joints subjected to heavy loading or high temperatme operation, Belleville washers or a pressure plate may be used with aluminum bolts to effectively distribute the applied force and to reduce the possibility of excessive creep. Their use on the softer tempers of aluminum bus bar and buses composed of many laminations may give more reliability under these adverse operating conditions. Belleville washers should be used as shown in Fig. 11.
JOINT DESIGN The effect of multiple bolts in a bus bar joint is to provide a number of parallel paths for current f