John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre Katherine Newey and Jeffrey Richards
John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
Als...
121 downloads
2985 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre Katherine Newey and Jeffrey Richards
John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
Also by Katherine Newey: WOMEN’S THEATRE WRITING IN VICTORIAN BRITAIN MARY SHELLEY’S FRANKENSTEIN RUSKIN, THE THEATRE AND VICTORIAN VISUAL CULTURE (edited with Anselm Heinrich and Jeffrey Richards) Also by Jeffrey Richards: IMPERIALISM AND MUSIC SIR HENRY IRVING: A VICTORIAN ACTOR AND HIS WORLD HOLLYWOOD’S ANCIENT WORLDS THE ANCIENT WORLD ON THE VICTORIAN AND EDWARDIAN STAGE A NIGHT TO REMEMBER: THE DEFINITIVE TITANIC FILM DIANA: THE MAKING OF A MEDIA SAINT (edited with Scott Wilson and Linda Woodhead ) THE UNKNOWN 1930s: AN ALTERNATIVE HISTORY OF BRITISH CINEMA, 1929–1939 (editor ) UNEASY CHAIRS: LIFE AS A PROFESSOR (editor )
John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre Katherine Newey and
Jeffrey Richards
© Katherine Newey and Jeffrey Richards 2010 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No portion of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, Saffron House, 6–10 Kirby Street, London EC1N 8TS. Any person who does any unauthorized act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The authors have asserted their rights to be identified as the authors of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. First published 2010 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN Palgrave Macmillan in the UK is an imprint of Macmillan Publishers Limited, registered in England, company number 785998, of Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS. Palgrave Macmillan in the US is a division of St Martin’s Press LLC, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010. Palgrave Macmillan is the global academic imprint of the above companies and has companies and representatives throughout the world. Palgrave® and Macmillan® are registered trademarks in the United States, the United Kingdom, Europe and other countries. ISBN 978–0–230–52499–6
hardback
This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. Logging, pulping and manufacturing processes are expected to conform to the environmental regulations of the country of origin. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Newey, Katherine. John Ruskin and the Victorian theatre / Katherine Newey and Jeffrey Richards. p. cm. Summary: “This the first sustained study of the interest of John Ruskin in the theatre of his time. It examines Ruskin’s active engagement with and influence on the Victorian popular theatre. Ruskin was an enthusiastic and catholic theatre-goer, enjoying pantomime as much as Shakespeare. Through the lens of Ruskin’s discussions of pantomime, melodrama, Shakespearean tragedy, and painting and the stage, Newey and Richards offer a new view of the late Victorian stage focusing on London’s West End in its heyday”—Provided by publisher. ISBN 978–0–230–52499–6 (hardback) 1. Theater—Great Britain—History—19th century. 2. Ruskin, John, 1819–1900—Influence. 3. Ruskin, John, 1819–1900—Knowledge—Performing arts. I. Richards, Jeffrey. II. Title. PN2594.N49 2010 792.0942'09034—dc22 2010002707 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 Printed and bound in Great Britain by CPI Antony Rowe, Chippenham and Eastbourne
For David Mayer
This page intentionally left blank
Contents List of Illustrations
viii
Acknowledgements
ix
1. John Ruskin at the Theatre
1
2. Ruskinian Influences
19
3. E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
45
4. Toga Plays
83
5. Melodrama
114
6. Pantomime
140
7. Ruskinian Shakespeare
168
8. Stage Beauty
209
Endnotes
233
Index
253
vii
List of Illustrations Cover:
Mary Anderson as Galatea, in Pygmalion and Galatea. The Graphic, 22 December 1883. Author’s collection
Figure 1: Ellen Terry as Ophelia. Author’s collection
221
Figure 2: Mary Anderson as Hermione. Author’s collection
222
Figure 3: Engraving of W.S. Herrick, Othello and Desdemona. Illustrated London News, 21 February 1874. Author’s collection
224
Figure 4: Mary Anderson as Juliet. Author’s collection
230
viii
Acknowledgements The authors wish to thank the Arts and Humanities Research Council for their substantial support of ‘Ruskinian Theatre: The Aesthetics of the Late Nineteenth Century Popular London Stage, 1870–1901’, the research project of which this book and Ruskin, the Theatre and Victorian Visual Culture (also published by Palgrave Macmillan) are the products. Our postdoctoral research associates, Drs Anselm Heinrich and Peter Yeandle, contributed their considerable expertise, energy and imagination to the project, and extended and developed it through their invaluable work. Other support was offered by the Folger Shakespeare Library in Washington DC, that true haven for scholars, where Kate Newey was a Folger Fellow in 2006–7. The Ruskin Seminar provided a knowledgeable and interested scholarly community for testing our work in progress, and we would particularly like to thank Professors Keith Hanley and Stephen Wildman, and Dr Andrew Tate. Libraries and librarians as always make our work possible: thanks to our colleagues at the Ruskin Library (Lancaster) and the University Library, Lancaster, the Brotherton Library (Leeds), the University Library, Birmingham, the Folger Shakespeare Library, Washington, DC, the Pierpont Morgan Library and Museum, New York, the Harry Ransom Humanities Research Center, University of Texas (Austin), the British Library, the National Library of Scotland, and the Theatre Museum, Blythe House. We acknowledge the generosity of these libraries and archives in allowing us to quote from archives, scrapbooks and manuscripts in their holdings. Our colleagues in the Department of History, Lancaster University, and the Department of Drama and Theatre Arts, University of Birmingham, have been interested and supportive throughout. Substantial contributions were made to this project by the participants in three annual Ruskinian Theatre colloquia from 2005 to 2007, and we thank all speakers and other participants. Personal thanks from the authors go to members of the Historiography Working Group of the International Federation for Theatre Research (particularly Tom Postlewait), Ken Cerniglia, Claire Cochrane, Alison Collins, Jim Davis, James Dearden, Rachel Dickinson, Richard Foulkes, Cynthia Gamble, Howard Hull, Russell Jackson, Adrien Lanusse, Emma Loveridge, Gail Marshall, Gillian Mawby, Lauren Proctor, June Rye, Richard Schoch and Sharon Aronofsky Weltman. This book, and the project from which it comes, survived both authors’ broken wrists and, for Kate Newey, a job and house move, three years as Head of Department and the relocation of an entire Department. Our thanks to our Palgrave editors, Paula Kennedy and Steven Hall, for bearing ix
x
Acknowledgements
with us. And finally, our thanks to our dedicatee, David Mayer, whose work as a theatre historian is challenging and inspirational, and whose personal support is unstinting, however much he may wish to argue with us over the contents of this book. All references to Ruskin’s works are from E.T Cook and Alexander Wedderburn (eds) (1903–12) The Complete Works of John Ruskin (London: George Allen) and are indicated by CW, volume and page number parenthetically within the text. References to Ruskin’s diaries are from Joan Evans and John Howard Whitehouse (eds) (1956–9) The Diaries of John Ruskin (Oxford: Clarendon) and are indicated by EW, volume and page number parenthetically within the text.
1 John Ruskin at the Theatre
The name of John Ruskin, the sage of Brantwood, pre-eminent Victorian art critic and social commentator, is not one that has customarily been associated with the theatre. But he was a long-time theatregoer, had a circle of friends associated with the theatre and made regular pronouncements about the value of the theatre as an educational form. In this book, we trace the ways in which Ruskin’s direct and indirect engagements with the popular theatre of his time reveal theatre as a medium through which art can elevate and educate a mass audience. Through the lens of Ruskin’s social and aesthetic theories, we argue that the Victorian theatre develops the model of a ‘feeling individual’, in the service of traditional morality, seeking to stage a vision of the world which resists the reduction of character to mechanism through the forces of late Victorian industrial capitalism. In 1888 Ruskin was reported as saying: ‘I have always held the stage quite among the best and most necessary means of education – moral and intellectual’ (CW 34.549). This was only the latest of a succession of such pronouncements. In his 1880 essay on the functions and formation of a museum or picture gallery, he equated the museum and the theatre, saying: ‘both are means of noble education’ (CW 34.259). We can assume that he saw the function of the theatre as he saw the function of the museum and gallery being ‘primarily for simple persons. Children that is to say, and peasants’, and that it was to ‘manifest to these simple persons the beauty and life of all things and creatures in their perfectness. Not their modes of corruption, disease or death’. In the gallery, ‘every form of noble art would take harmonious and instructive place’. In 1874 he had compared the church and the pantomime as ‘these two theatrical entertainments – where the imaginative congregations still retain some true notions of the value of human and beautiful things’ and ‘they return some just notion of truth in moral things’ (CW 28.52). Truth, beauty and harmony: these emerge as recurrent themes in his pronouncements on art. He set out his priorities in 1
2 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
judging a work of art in The Stones of Venice and he applied the same criteria to plays as to paintings: It is well, when we have strong moral and poetical feeling manifested in painting to mark this as the best part of the work; but it is not well to consider as a thing of small account the painter’s language in which that feeling is conveyed; for if that language be not good and lovely, the man may indeed be a just moralist or a great poet, but he is not a painter and it was wrong of him to paint (CW 9.448). He gave a practical example of the educational value of theatre in a lecture in 1875 when he said: Remember that no mortal of you is able to write history at all, or understand a single event of it, unless he can understand the motives and the movements of the strongest minds of men, and has sympathy and passion scarcely less than theirs. I only know four bits of perfect history in the English language – Shakespeare’s Coriolanus, King John, Richard the Second, Henry the Fourth (CW 22.300). By 1884, when he was writing his notes for the continuation of St Mark’s Rest, he had included Scott along with Shakespeare as a teacher of history: There have been only two real historians (to my thinking) since Herodotus-Shakespeare and Walter Scott. Neither are entirely to be trusted as to dates, or even material facts. Even Thucydides is only a chronicler, a useful sort of person, but not an historian. But once understand Shakespeare’s Caesar, Henry the Fifth, and John of Gaunt; once understand Scott’s Marmion, King James, Coeur de Lion, Saladin, and Robin Hood, and after that you may read the chronicles of the great ages, and see your way into them for yourself (CW 24.432). This preference for drama as the teacher of history – and Scott’s novels were much dramatised in the nineteenth century and performed alongside Shakespeare – stemmed from Ruskin’s basic definition of history, which was that: the most important part of the history of man is that of his imagination. What he actually does, is always in great part accidental; it is at best a partial fulfilment of his purpose; and what we call history is often […] merely a record of the external accidents which befall men getting together in large crowds. The real history of mankind is that of the slow advance of resolved deed following laboriously just thought; and all the greatest men live in their purpose and effort more than it is
John Ruskin at the Theatre
3
possible for them to live in reality […] It is therefore a true historian’s work diligently to separate the deed from the imagination; and when these become inconsistent, to remember that the imagination, if precious at all, is indeed the most precious (CW 22.269). The novelist and the dramatist, then, by exploring the mind, the imagination and the motivation of the great men who shape history are truer guides to the deeper historical truth than mere chroniclers. However, institutions which set out to provide edification for the people did not always live up to Ruskin’s high expectations. When the Crystal Palace moved to Sydenham, Ruskin hoped it would be used as a vehicle for artistic and educational uplift, for a population ‘thirsting for knowledge, where contemplation may be consistent with rest, and instruction with enjoyment. It is impossible to estimate the influence of such an institution on the minds of the working classes’ (CW 12.418). Ruskin went regularly to the Crystal Palace to attend concerts and to play chess against a chessplaying automaton (CW 34.xlv). But he was appalled by the vulgarity of some of the displays, for example the gigantic head of a pantomime clown continually collapsed by machinery. He insisted that it was impossible to combine ‘a place of amusement and an art school’ and called for the Palace and similar institutions to improve their educational thrust – with plenty of flowers, ‘always carefully named, and with good popular and useful information about them given in a cheap alphabetical catalogue’; good prints and pictures and panoramas and dioramas ‘with an attention to truth and a splendour and care in the execution which should […] be very truly a school both in physical geography and art’. He added significantly: ‘I am prepared to use the theatre, and that largely, but a very different kind of theatre from any we frequent now’ (CW 19.217–18).1 To Evangelical Protestants, the theatre was anathema. Although not hostile to culture in general – they favoured reading the classics, singing and performing sacred music, studying pictures for the moral uplift, sightseeing and nature study – they were intensely suspicious of public amusements (theatregoing, dancing, card-playing, field sports). They were particularly suspicious of theatre, which they saw as a distraction from religion, as a vehicle for a bohemian life-style and value-system antithetical to their own and as a promoter of frivolity, vanity and female forwardness. These views were clearly shared by Ruskin’s mother Margaret, who disapproved of the theatre and never visited it. However, somewhat surprisingly, Ruskin’s father John James loved the theatre. John James Ruskin had been an enthusiastic boy actor at school, often reminisced in his letters about his theatrical experiences and continued to enjoy theatre.2 John Ruskin, who was introduced to the theatre by his father, came to share John James’ love of the theatre and to inherit his talent for the dramatic. Ruskin, though not an actor, was an inspiring and influential lecturer, and the good lecturer has
4 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
to have something of the actor in him. Many of Ruskin’s books began as lecture series, but he lectured from notes rather than fully written out texts, often utilising humour and sometimes deploying illustrations and diagrams. He undoubtedly saw his lectures as performances, describing himself – with reference to his beloved pantomimes – as ‘a legitimate pantaloon’. Contemporary comments from audience members include ‘his action as a lecturer was always significant and dramatic’; ‘striding back and forth behind his platform rail, he poured out a rhapsody of exalted thought in rhythmic phrases’ and his delivery was ‘marked by great vigour and verve’.3 He was not above startling his audiences, as on the occasion recalled by the Dean of Durham. Lecturing on the Psalms of David, he was reminded of a Mendelssohn setting, ‘in which the solemn dignity of the Psalms was lowered by the frivolous prettiness of the music. It was “oh, for the wings” etc that he had heard with disgust, and he suddenly began to dance and recite, with the strangest flappings of his MA gown, and the oddest look on his excited face’.4 In 1882 Ruskin jocularly listed among the pleasant things to do ‘going to all manner of wicked plays and pantomimes’ (CW 33.xxx). In Praeterita (1886–9) he recorded that he could not recall anything of his first trip to the theatre ‘though I was full twelve before I was taken’ (CW 35.175). His memory here was at fault. He was at the theatre in Birmingham nine months earlier than his twelfth year, as his diary entry for 2 June 1830 reveals.5 Ruskin went on: ‘afterwards, it was a matter of intense rapture of a common sort, to be taken to a pantomime’ (CW 35.175). As early as 1838, while he was an undergraduate at Oxford, Ruskin had proposed at the Oxford Union the motion ‘that theatrical representations are upon the whole highly beneficial to the character of the nation’ and spoke strongly in support of it (CW 1.xxxv). At the age of 17, pained by his unrequited love for Adele Domecq, Ruskin turned, like many another tormented adolescent, to poetry. He set himself, as he recalled in Praeterita: ‘in a state of imbecility, to write a tragedy on a Venetian subject in which the sorrows of my soul were to be enshrined in immortal verse’ (CW 35.182). He completed three acts of a proposed five-act poetic tragedy, Marcolini, with scenes set in the Rialto, St Mark’s Square and the princely palaces of Venice. It was full of echoes of Byron and Shakespeare (in particular Othello and Romeo and Juliet), replete with long soliloquies and featured classic romantic tropes (a wronged nobleman Friuli returning to Venice in disguise to avenge the death of his father at the hands of Count Orsini’s father; two friends Orsini and Marcolini in love with the same woman, Bianca; and Friuli seeking to set them against each other as part of his revenge plot). He eventually gave up on it because ‘when I had described a gondola, a bravo, the heroine Bianca, and moonlight on the Grand Canal, I found I had not much more to say’ (CW 35.222). Although she never stopped John James taking their son to the theatre, Margaret Ruskin’s ‘puritanical’ objection to the theatre increased as she got
John Ruskin at the Theatre
5
older, particularly after John James’ death, and she made her disapproval clear to her son.6 W.G. Collingwood reported: She objected strongly, in these later years, to the theatre; and when sometimes her son would wish to take a party into town to see the latest new piece; her permission had to be asked, and was not readily granted, unless to Miss Agnew, who was the ambassadress in such affairs of diplomacy.7 The painter Arthur Severn, who married Ruskin’s cousin Joan Agnew, confirms this: We were great play-goers, driving all the way from Herne Hill into London, and back at night. Ruskin had always been very fond of the theatre, but in older days at Denmark Hill had been a little shy of going, as old Mrs. Ruskin never quite liked it. When they did go, my wife, then Miss Agnew, was generally told off to break it gently to the old lady.8 Like many educated and cultivated persons of the time, Ruskin went to the opera and to French plays in the original language. He regularly went to operas on his continental tours and expressed his opinions of them with characteristic trenchancy. Writing from Amiens on 12 October 1880, he expressed how: indignant I was, a few days ago, to see the drop-scene(!) of the Folies at Paris composed of huge advertisements! The ghastly want of sense of beauty, and endurance of loathsomeness gaining hourly on the people! They were playing the Fille du Tambour Major superbly, for the most part; they gave the introductory convent scene without the least caricature, the Abbess being played by a very beautiful and gracefullymannered actress, and the whole thing would have been delightful had the mere decorations of the theatre been clean and pretty. To think that all the strength of the world combining in Paris to amuse itself can’t have clean box-curtains! or a pretty landscape sketch for a drop scene! – but sits in squalor and dismalness, with bills stuck all over its rideau! I saw Le Châlet here last night, in many respects well played and sung, and it is a quite charming little opera in its story, only it requires an actress of extreme refinement for the main part, and everybody last night sang too loud. There is no music of any high quality in it, but the piece is one which, played with such delicacy as almost any clever, wellbred girl could put into the heroine’s part (if the audiences would look for acting more than voice), ought to be extremely delightful to simple persons. On the other hand, I heard William Tell entirely massacred at the great opera house at Paris. My belief is they scarcely sang a piece of pure Rossini all night, but had fitted in modern skimble-skamble tunes, and quite
6 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
unspeakably clumsy and common ballet. I scarcely came away in better humour from the mouthed tediousness of Garin at the Française, but they took pains with it, and I suppose it pleased a certain class of audience. The William Tell could please nobody at heart. The libretto of Jean de Nivelle is very beautiful, and ought to have new music written for it. Anything so helplessly tuneless as its present music I never heard, except mosquitos and cicadas (CW 34.550). The visits of French theatrical companies to London to perform plays in the original language became a major feature not only of theatrical but of social life from the 1840s onwards. This development was essentially initiated by John Mitchell, a Bond Street ticket agent, who took over the St James’s Theatre in 1842 and ran annual French theatre seasons for 12 years. The great French actress Rachel appeared regularly to great acclaim. Queen Victoria was a frequent attendee. The St James’s was so closely associated with this aspect of the drama that it was popularly known as ‘The French Theatre’. After Mitchell retired, the tradition was taken up by John Hollingshead, who ran the Gaiety Theatre from 1868 to 1886, regularly imported French companies and achieved a coup in 1879 when he persuaded the complete Comédie Française company to appear. The result was a sell-out six week season and an electrifying London debut by Sarah Bernhardt. Matthew Arnold, who attended the season, tartly observed that the season had attracted an audience ‘of those acquainted with the French language perfectly, of those acquainted with it a little, and of those not acquainted with it at all’.9 Ruskin, who spent much of 1879 at Brantwood, seems to have missed this major cultural event. However, he recorded other visits to the French plays in his diaries. In November 1870 he paid two recorded visits to the French theatre – one to an unnamed play and another to the comedy Les premières armes de Richelieu (‘delicious acting’) (EW 2.707). In January 1872 he went to a comedy Voyage de M. Perrichon (‘Excellent in analysis of small vanity’) and the tragi-comedy Frou-Frou (‘dreadful’) (EW 2.719). In February 1873 he was at an unnamed French play (‘mad scenes with nice doctor, but stupid’) (EW 2.738). He also went to see French plays when in France (EW 2.592; 2.658). In a fascinating, ground-breaking recent essay, Andrew Tate has identified J.B.P. Molière as a significant influence on Ruskin. In a letter entitled ‘Books which have influenced me’, published in the British Weekly and written from Brantwood on 14 May 1887, Ruskin identified Molière along with Dante, Byron and Scott. He claims to have valued Molière ‘always’ (CW 34.605–6). Ruskin studied the texts of Molière’s plays and, where possible, attended productions of the plays when in France. We know of at least two visits to performances of Tartuffe in 1868 and 1880 (EW 2.658; 3.988). Ruskin made regular allusions in his writings to Molière’s plays, in particular
John Ruskin at the Theatre
7
Le Misanthrope and Tartuffe, and goes so far as to claim that Molière was the true precursor of Pre-Raphaelite aesthetics (EW 2.658; 3.988). Tate argues convincingly that Ruskin saw Molière as ‘a fearless moralist whose work contradicted the dissolute tendencies of his era, but [...] he also locates the dramatist as a precursor of the English Romantic tradition’.10 He associates him directly with Wordsworth (CW 5.374–5). Tate also intriguingly suggests that Ruskin identified strongly with Alceste, the disenchanted title character of Le Misanthrope, particularly in his withdrawal from the centre of civilisation to the periphery, a withdrawal paralleling Ruskin’s own retreat to Brantwood. Writing in Modern Painters III, he paid tribute to Molière in characteristic terms: Living in the blindest period of the world’s history, in the most luxurious city, and the most corrupted court of the time, he yet manifests through all his writings an exquisite natural wisdom; a capacity for the most simple enjoyment; a high sense of all nobleness, honour and purity, variously marked throughout his slighter work, but distinctly made the theme of his two perfect plays – the Tartuffe and Misanthrope; and in all that he says of art or science he has an unerring instinct for what is useful and sincere, and uses his whole power to defend it, with as keen a hatred of everything affected and vain (CW 5.375). Unlike his father, John Ruskin did not go to tragedies and dramas, apart from those of Shakespeare, in whom he had a lifelong interest. Ruskin had grown up with Shakespeare, his father regularly reading the plays aloud to the family. Ruskin read and re-read the plays throughout his life.11 He recorded in his diaries his reactions to the printed text. On 25 February 1843 he reported: ‘Read King John completely for the first time; I like the history plays better than the pet ones, A Midsummer Night’s Dream I like least of any in Shakespeare. I think the death scene in King John one of the very finest things in Shakespeare; but Constance talks too much Billingsgate’ (EW 1.245). On 29 December 1866 he was reading Henry IV, Part 1 (EW 2.606). On 27 June 1886 he wrote: ‘read with understanding for first time in my life the first scene of As You Like It ’ (EW 3.1131). In The Mystery of Life and its Arts he wrote: ‘It does not matter how little, or how much, any of us have read, either of Homer and Shakespeare, everything around us, in substance, or in thought, has been moulded by them [...] The intellectual measure of every man, since born, in the domains of creative thought, may be assigned to him, according to the degree to which he has been taught by Shakespeare’ (CW 18.139). Ruskin did see some of the finest contemporary interpreters of Shakespeare in action but was not always impressed by them. He saw Macready in Macbeth on 23 January 1843: ‘wretched beyond all I had conceived possible’
8 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
(EW 1.240). On 22 September 1870 he saw A Midsummer Night’s Dream at the Queen’s Theatre, Longacre, with Samuel Phelps as Bottom (EW 2.703). The production was generally praised for both the acting and the staging (with Mendelssohn’s music, picturesque scene painting of the woods, Theseus’ palace in the approved ‘archaeological’ manner and a troupe of 150 well-drilled children as fairies). Ruskin did not record his view of it. He had seen Henry Irving in his early success Two Roses (1870).12 He saw Irving and Ellen Terry in Much Ado About Nothing at the Lyceum and recorded in his diary on 16 December 1882: ‘Yesterday at Lyceum to Irving and Helen Terry’s Much Ado (he always called her Helen Terry), which taught me a good deal in Beatrice that I had not felt, but I am not sure how far truly. Irving’s Benedict of course offensive only, yet suggestive’ (EW 3.1044). But in 1879, having been taken by Oscar Wilde to see Irving’s revolutionary new production of The Merchant of Venice, Ruskin became embroiled in a public controversy about Irving’s interpretation of Shylock. Irving’s view was that Shylock was a victim: ‘I look on Shylock as the type of a persecuted race, almost the only gentleman in the play, and the most ill-used.’13 The artist W. Graham Robertson recalled the performance as one which ‘united the soul of Savonarola and the bearing of Charles the First, with just a touch of Lord Beaconsfield’.14 It was widely praised, not least by the Jewish press, but such notable figures as Henry James, Bernard Shaw and Lewis Carroll all strongly objected to Irving’s view of Shylock as a ‘martyred saint’. Taken backstage to meet Irving, Ruskin praised his acting as ‘noble, tender and true’. This was reported in The Theatre magazine, a journal run by a noted Irvingite, Clement Scott.15 Ruskin felt obliged to write to both Irving and the journal to say that his praise of Irving’s acting was not to be taken as approval of the interpretation of the play from which he ‘entirely and indignantly’ dissented. He thought the supporting cast inadequate, Ellen Terry’s Portia lacking in the humility which he saw as a vital element of her character and objected to the elimination of the Prince of Aragon and the diluting of Shakespeare’s message – an attack on usury.16 This was the root of his objection to Irving’s Shylock, an interpretation which became the dominant one to such an extent that Ruskin wrote in a postscript to St Mark’s Rest (1884) that the modern view of Shylock was erroneous: ‘the public […] now – consistently and naturally enough, but ominously – considers Shylock a victim to the support of the principles of legitimate trade and Antonio “a spectacular sentimentalist”’, thus reversing completely what Ruskin saw as the relative vice and virtue of their positions (CW 24.418).17 He saw the great Italian actor Tomasso Salvini in Othello (24 April 1875). Marvin Rosenberg in his study of the performers of the role, The Masks of Othello, records that he was: One of the theater’s greatest Othellos […] His terrible magnificence set a standard […] He came out of Italy like a tornado, and his first
John Ruskin at the Theatre
9
performances in England – spoken entirely in Italian – almost blasted the Victorians from their theatres […] But his Moor was recognized as a masterpiece of passion (except by those too fearful of passion), of a frank, erotic sensuality, then of a grief that transcended violence, finally of an utter despair of nobility, sunk in delusion, torment and disaster – and yet never ignoble.18 One of those evidently fearful of the passion was Ruskin, who wrote in his diary (24 April 1875) ‘Yesterday […] horrible Italian Othello, spoiling all’ (EW 3.842). He expanded on his feelings in Fors Clavigera 91 (September 1883) and it was precisely the animalistic passion that disturbed him. He wrote: Very few young people, brought up on modern principles, have ever felt love, or even know what it means, except under the conditions in which it is also possible to the lowest animals. I could easily prove this […] by the evidence given me in a single evening, during which I watched the enthusiastic acceptance by an English audience of Salvini’s frightful, and radically false, interpretation of Othello (CW 29.445). He evidently conceived love as something refined, noble and uplifting and not tempestuous and violent, as an aesthetic, perhaps, rather than an erotic experience. This in turn may help to explain his tormented private life. He went on 27 April 1867 to the Haymarket to see the London debut of Mrs Scott-Siddons as Rosalind in As You Like It (EW 2.617). Considerable interest was generated by the fact of her being a descendant of the great Sarah Siddons. The Era (14 April 1867) reported that her performance was natural, free of ‘staginess’ and that ‘expectations were more than realised by her personation of this exquisite heroine’. On 19 December 1870 Ruskin was at Drury Lane for the benefit night of Adelaide Neilson, a production of Romeo and Juliet under the patronage of the Prince and Princess of Wales (who were at the last moment prevented from attending) (EW 2.708). The Era (25 December 1870) noted: ‘It is no exaggeration to say that all through the long and difficult play Miss Neilson held the audience firmly in her grasp.’ After the play, she recited Tennyson’s Charge of the Light Brigade. Ruskin went to the Crystal Palace to see Tom Taylor’s production of Hamlet starring the American actor Steele Mackaye. Even before it was seen, it was denounced by The Era (22 April 1873), as Taylor had announced his intention of directing his own adapted text of the play, ‘Shakespeare at Sydenham, with little scenery, without much attention to costume, and above all with a scratch company of actors, seems to us to be a “fantastic trick” which ought to be condemned “for the sake of the dramatic art and the public”, at whose improvement Mr Taylor professes to be aiming. We
10 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
object to the whole of this scheme, in which we think Mr Taylor is illogical and inconsistent’. They thought the Crystal Palace, with its poor acoustics, entirely the wrong place for a Shakespeare production. After the production opened, The Era (11 May 1873) reviewed it: ‘We recently offered our readers some rather hostile criticism upon Mr Tom Taylor’s scheme for doing justice to Shakespeare at the Crystal Palace. Last Saturday that criticism, in the presence of a tolerable audience, which included many notabilities of art and literature was fully endorsed; and although the applause of undisguised partisans was not wanting, we do not hesitate to say that Hamlet, our “immortal bard’s” masterpiece, has never been more vilely massacred anywhere off the amateur stage.’ This opinion was not shared by other reviewers. The Illustrated London News (10 May 1873) pronounced it a success, praising the acting, Taylor’s judicious adaptation of the text, the costumes after designs from the works of Viollet le Duc and scenery, painted by F. Fenton. The Times (5 May 1873) agreed, drawing attention to Taylor’s desire to produce the play not as a star vehicle but for ‘artistic and aesthetic reasons’ as an ensemble piece, newly interpreted and dispensing with much traditional business, tastefully staged and intelligently acted. Ruskin went to Hamlet on 14 May 1873 and he wrote about it on 29 September 1873, saying ‘Hamlet. Drama dealing only with the heart; all “spectacle” contrary to it. Hamlet at Crystal Palace: ranting; snow on the ground, and the speech on election of Fortinbras omitted!’ (EW 2.746; 760). The Antony and Cleopatra he attended at the Haymarket on 7 December 1866 was not Shakespeare’s play but Frank Burnand’s burlesque version of the story (EW 2.604). The Era (25 November 1866) reported that ‘four scenes, carefully painted by Messrs. O’Connor and Morris, give a semi-spectacular grace to the extravaganza’. This may well have been one of the attractions for Ruskin. It was not thought to be particularly funny, with The Era observing: ‘The performers have a very arduous task assigned them in reducing their acknowledged talents to the level of burlesque, and that such a subject should have been chosen by the author, and have been so liberally embellished by the Management, indicates a curious opinion of the present condition of popular taste. There was a faint burst of applause at the end, but no further token of approval.’ Why did Ruskin so sedulously avoid drama and tragedy? One reason may be because he shared the conventional view of the day as he expressed it himself in Time and Tide that there was a ‘direct and constant’ connection between the many horrific crimes reported in the press and ‘the modern love of excitement in the sensational novel and drama […] all furious pursuit of pleasure ending in actual desire of horror and delight in death’ (CW 28.468). Another reason he avoided drama was the language. He wrote: ‘as regards the literature of modern plays, I think that in comedies the language is very often precious and piquant – more in French than in English pieces; but I know of no tragedy, French or English, whose language satisfies me’ (CW 34.669).
John Ruskin at the Theatre
11
But perhaps most influential in his decision-making was that he found drama too emotionally harrowing. In The Eagle’s Nest he wrote: It is death in ourselves which seeks the exaggerated external stimulus […] The most complete rest and refreshment I can get, when I am overworked, in London […] is in seeing a French play. But the French act so perfectly that I am obliged to make sure beforehand that all is to end well, or it is as bad as being helplessly present at some real misery. I was beguiled the other day, by seeing it announced as a ‘Comédie’, into going to see ‘Frou-Frou’. Most of you probably know that the three first of its five acts are comedy, or at least playful drama, and that it plunges down, in the last two, to the sorrowfullest catastrophe of all conceivable – though too frequent in daily life – in which irretrievable grief is brought about by the passion of the moment, and the ruin of all that she loves, caused by the heroic error of an entirely good and unselfish person. The sight of it made me thoroughly ill, and I was not myself again for a week (CW 22.173–4). He went regularly to comedies, pantomimes and to the Christy Minstrels. Ruskin recorded some of his theatre visits in his diaries, but he rarely commented on them in detail. W.G. Collingwood reported a story that he heard from Sir Edward Burne-Jones of a visit with Ruskin in the summer of 1877 to the St James’s Hall to see the Moore and Burgess company of Christy Minstrels: ‘the Professor dragged him there, to a front seat, and those burntcorked people anticked and shouted, and Burne-Jones wanted to go, and Ruskin wouldn’t, but sat laughing through the whole performance as if he loved it. An afternoon to him of oblivion in the cares of life.’19 Ruskin praised the Moore and Burgess Minstrels for their singing qualities (CW 29.85). He recorded visits to the Christy Minstrels in July 1866, January 1867, July and August 1870, October 1870 and November 1870 (EW 2.594; 608; 698; 705; 707). On 27 October 1887, Ruskin wrote to his niece Joan that he had been to see Sophia, a four-act comedy by Robert Buchanan, at the Vaudeville Theatre, but he had been deeply disappointed to find that it was actually an adaptation of ‘the old Tom Jones’. He also disliked ‘the quantities of time wasted in what an English audience always seems to like, imitations of drunkenness, and the “spinster aunt” business of middle-aged women’. However, there were some compensations: ‘The Tom was extremely good however – the Sophia beautiful – and the peasant girl Molly extremely pretty and clever.’20 Ruskin was also a devotee of the pantomime. In a letter to Dr George Parsons, physician of Hawkshead, dated 11 February 1884, from Herne Hill, Ruskin writes: ‘I hope to get my second lecture well over, and then after a pantomime or two I shall set my face North and be within your episcopate again by the 25th or so.’ Ruskin went regularly and the pantomimes inspired
12 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
strong feelings.21 It is clear that he saw pantomime as fulfilling that role of moral and intellectual education which he ascribed to the stage in general (see Chapter 6 for further discussion). There is some question over his idiosyncratic judgement of plays. For instance, he calls Dion Boucicault’s comedy London Assurance, which he saw on 5 July 1877 and which starred the Bancrofts and the Kendals, ‘the vilest rubbish’, yet it is one of the few mid-Victorian plays to have survived in the repertoire and is wholly delightful (EW 3.964). Then there is his comment on the performance of W.C. Macready, the greatest actor of his age, in Macbeth. His diary entry for 24 January 1843 reads: I am getting quite dissipated; out at Drury Lane last night. Macready in Macbeth – wretched beyond all I had conceived possible. Quite tired and bored, but Gordon liked it, and as it was for him that I went, I was well pleased. I was surprised to see him completely affected and upset by the scene where Macduff hears of the death of his children (EW 1.240). (The Gordon referred to was his close Oxford friend Rev. Osborne Gordon.) These somewhat odd judgements may have something to do with the reasons why Ruskin went to the theatre. One reason is that he was a fan. Ruskin was a particular fan of the actress Madge Robertson, later Mrs Madge Kendal, later still Dame Madge Kendal, who acted regularly with her husband W.H. Kendal. The Theatre magazine wrote of her: ‘No living actress has done more by means of her art to teach men to be true and women to be tender’, something likely to commend her to Ruskin.22 He often went back to see her productions several times, declaring himself ‘delighted’ with the play Lady Fiona which he saw on 15 April 1875, and going back to see it again on 21 April (EW 3.841). He thought Queen Mab ‘a really lovely play’ when he saw it on 28 March 1874, and with it My Uncle’s Wife ‘a quite inoffensive afterpiece’ (EW 3.781–2). The result was ‘an entirely satisfactory evening’. In Deucalion, Ruskin called Mrs Kendal ‘my much-regarded friend’, praising the play New Men and Old Acres by Tom Taylor and A.W. Dubourg, in which he saw her in 1869 and which incidentally contains the line: ‘In spite of her Ruskinism-run-mad, she isn’t half a bad sort’ (CW 26.378). Even Dame Madge, however, could not save some plays. He recorded on 24 October 1883: ‘At stupidest play last night I ever saw the Kendals in’ (EW 3.1049). This will have been Young Folks’ Ways by W.H. Gillette and Mrs Burnett, which ran for 50 nights but was described by The Theatre magazine as ‘a disappointing play. It begins well, dawdles in the middle and ends badly’, and by The Times as ‘a poor play well acted’.23 The actor Frank Archer, who later made the acquaintance of the Severns, recalled that the only time he saw Ruskin was when he attended his lecture at the Royal Institution on snakes on 17 March 1880, and saw the Kendals
John Ruskin at the Theatre
13
in the audience.24 The title of the lecture was ‘a caution to snakes’. It was taken from a line in the play New Men and Old Acres which had starred Mrs Kendal – ‘and his wife – well she’s a caution for snakes’ (CW 26.327–8). The friendship between Ruskin and Mrs Kendal is confirmed by a letter from Lily Severn to Ruskin, undated but evidently sent in 1898. Lily reports that she and her mother Joan went to the St James’s Theatre to see Mrs Kendal in The Elder Miss Blossom, which opened on 22 September 1898. They went backstage after the performance and ‘she at once enquired most affectionately after you and sends best love’.25 Another reason for Ruskin’s theatregoing is that it took him out of himself. It was a sort of therapy. He records in his diary for 22 March 1867, ‘Languid all day’ and that in the evening he went to see Lavater, J.R. Planché’s comedy-drama, and Samuel Foote’s Liar at the Olympic Theatre (EW 2.613). Cause and effect by the sound of it. Then on 30 November 1875, he records ‘utterly black all day. At Rip Van Winkle in the evening, and very much enjoyed it – but’, implying that he could not be lifted out of his depression even by a good play (EW 3.874). On 1 August 1862 in Milan, he recorded in his diary: ‘Went to see Linda again [presumed to be Donizetti’s opera Linda de Chamounix] – and got none the merrier’, suggesting that he specifically went to be cheered up (EW 2.566). In 1871 Ruskin, trying to cheer up a dyspeptic Thomas Carlyle, invited him to share his box for the pantomime The Dragon of Wantley at Drury Lane, saying ‘Nobody would see him and he would see … some fairly good fooling’.26 Sadly Carlyle declined to go. He recommended plays to others for rest and recuperation. On 17 April 1884, he wrote to Lizzie Weston: ‘Do you know French well enough to read French plays? They’re the prettiest and pleasantest things in the world for rest after Dante!’ (CW 37.482). But plays also caused Ruskin to think about his work. In 1871 he wrote to Squire Bancroft, the leading actor-manager, to thank him for the pleasure afforded by Bancroft’s production of Tom Robertson’s Ours starring Bancroft and his wife, Marie, and saying: ‘I get more help in my own work from a good play than from any other kind of thoughtful rest’ (CW 37.28–9). So it is more than just escapism, it is intellectual stimulation that theatre provides. In his diary for 26 January 1872 he recorded, ‘At French play last night. Saw the dreadful Frou-Frou – the best views of Venice I ever saw on the stage. Gives one much to think of’ (EW 2.719). Apart from Mrs Kendal, Ruskin did number other actors and actresses among his circle of friends and acquaintances. One of them was Helen Faucit, once Macready’s leading lady and the greatest actress of her age. She married essayist, critic and poet Sir Theodore Martin, the official biographer of Prince Albert, in 1851 and she retired from the stage in 1871. Following retirement and encouraged by friends, she began to write interpretative essays on Shakespeare’s heroines, an interest she shared with Ruskin (see Chapter 2 for further discussion). Ruskin also made the acquaintance of
14 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
the beautiful American actress Mary Anderson, who took on Mrs Kendal’s old role of Galatea in a revival of Pygmalion and Galatea. He discussed the play with her but he told art critic M.H. Spielmann in early 1884 that he was ‘a critical admirer […] with many reservations, of Miss Mary Anderson […] a sweet lady and an excellent person, but not, I think, a great actress’ – a view shared by many contemporary critics though not by her adoring audiences27 (see Chapter 4 for further discussion). Another close theatrical friend of Ruskin was Wilson Barrett. Barrett’s friendship with Ruskin was a form of discipleship: in one letter to Ruskin, Barrett addresses him as ‘Master’.28 Ruskin broke with his customary embargo on attending tragic plays to go to Wilson Barrett’s production of the historical melodrama Claudian. He saw it three times, wrote a letter of appreciation to Barrett and initiated an influential friendship. Ruskin later told the art critic M. H. Spielmann: ‘I like Wilson Barrett, he flatters me so deliciously and in such tactful taste.’29 Barrett assisted Ruskin directly, helping him with the visual illustrations and effects in the first of the two lectures to the Royal Institution which formed the basis of The Storm Cloud of the Nineteenth Century (1884). On 20 February 1884 Ruskin wrote accepting an invitation from Barrett for himself and the Severns to pay a Sunday visit. He said: ‘to me, it will be a new and long wished for privilege to speak of things close to my heart in the drama with an actor capable of sustaining its greatest parts and it will be a double privilege, since I find him also a personal friend.’30 The young poet Richard Le Gallienne, writing excitedly to his father in Liverpool on 5 January 1889 to inform him that he had been appointed literary secretary to Wilson Barrett, described him as ‘a gentleman and a man of honour […] his passion in his art as an earnest, conscientious, intelligent artist is second only to that of Henry Irving’, adding as a clinching argument, ‘Ruskin who thinks a great deal of him and has praised him very highly in print […] stays at his house’.31 Indeed, Ruskin and Barrett were on sufficiently intimate terms for Barrett to send Ruskin throat lozenges when he was suffering from a bad cold. Ruskin complained: ‘they’re rather nasty […] as if they had dropped overboard and been at sea some time.’32 Barrett would much later acknowledge the importance of Ruskin’s encouragement to him in his ambition to stage a series of artistically beautiful classical dramas (see Chapters 4 and 5). In 1883 George Alexander directed The Tale of Troy, a fashionable largely amateur production, based on The Iliad and The Odyssey. Ruskin was present at one of the performances and made a presentation to Alexander. In 1900, Alexander, by now a leading London actor-manager, wrote to Joan Severn on Ruskin’s death: You will be deluged with letters. I am loath to add mine to the number but I must just express my sympathy with you and yours, and my deep
John Ruskin at the Theatre
15
regret at the loss of so great a man. I had nothing but great kindness at his hands.33 This suggests that there developed a friendship between them at some point, perhaps initiated by this contact. In 1884 Alexander Wedderburn, who was looking after ‘Dave’, the collie belonging to George Alexander, then currently on tour in America with Irving, took the dog to stay at Brantwood. The dog would be run over in the street and killed the day after his master returned from America.34 Alexander and his wife attended the memorial service for Ruskin at Westminster Abbey. This would add another leading actor to Ruskin’s circle along with Mrs Kendal, Mary Anderson, Helen Faucit and Wilson Barrett. One step removed from acting and more widely deemed thoroughly respectable was public recitation, and Ruskin counted several well-known reciters among his acquaintances. The most notable were the Webling sisters. Robert James Webling, a jeweller and silversmith, and his wife Maria had six daughters: Ethel (born c. 1861), Josephine (born in 1862), Ruth (born in 1866), Rosalind (born in 1868), Peggy (born in 1871) and Lucy (born c. 1878). Rosalind and Peggy were infant prodigies and in 1879 their mother arranged for them at the ages of 10 and 8, together with Josephine (17), to give a programme of public recitations at the Steinway Hall, Lower Seymour Street. The programme included Shelley’s Ode to a Skylark, Longfellow’s Hiawatha and R.H. Barham’s The Jackdaw of Rheims, together with a 15 minute playlet Only a Dream specially written for them by the playwright Alfred C. Calmour. They were reviewed in the press, photographed by the London Stereoscopic Society and embarked on a career as reciters. Their regular programme included poetry, scenes from Shakespeare and extracts from Alice in Wonderland. Predictably Lewis Carroll sought them out and, as Peggy later recalled, ‘it later became fashionable to have “the little Weblings” for afternoon and evening parties’.35 Ruskin first met Ethel and Peggy Webling at the home of Marcus Huish, editor of the Art Journal, and was enchanted by them. He went to see them perform and wrote to their father on 16 February 1880: ‘I heard your daughters’ recitation in London last autumn, with quite unmixed pleasure and the sincerest admiration – not merely that, but with grave change in my opinion of the general value of recitations as means of public instruction [...] I have not seen any public entertainment – for many a long year – at once so sweet, so innocent and so helpful, as that which your children can give to all the gentle and simple in mind and heart’ (CW 34.545–6). Rosalind rapidly became his favourite and she and Peggy were invited to stay at Brantwood: ‘the most memorable month of my childhood’ recalled Peggy.36 Later Peggy, Josephine, Rosalind and their mother all went to stay. Peggy wrote that Ruskin’s affection was ‘perhaps the strongest influence of my youth’. Ruskin wrote to their father to say ‘there never were sweeter or more rightly behaved children [...] It is the best of results to me to have them to play with and to teach the little
16 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
things which will be useful to them hereafter’. These useful things included rowing, drawing and water-colour painting. He taught Rosalind the Greek alphabet, read to them from Scott and the Bible and acted little playlets with them. They nicknamed him ‘Fidelity’ and he nicknamed Rosalind ‘Gratia’ and Peggy ‘Fate’. The Weblings began touring the country with their recitations and Ruskin began and kept up a correspondence individually with Josephine, Rosalind and Peggy. Ruskin went to see them whenever he and they were in London. ‘The joy of our friendship with the Professor went on for a long time’, Peggy recalled. Eventually the youngest sister Lucy joined the act and during the 1890s they toured Canada and the United States. But as they grew up and the appeal of their recitations faded, Josephine and Rosalind both married Canadians, Lucy became a straight actress joining George Alexander’s company at the St James’s Theatre and Peggy turned to journalism and writing short stories, novels and plays, the most celebrated being her 1930 stage adaptation of Frankenstein. Rosalind continued to write to Ruskin until his death and visited him at Brantwood near the end of his life. She and Peggy visited his grave two years after his death and scattered fresh leaves on it. Ethel, who studied at the Slade School of Fine Art and became a miniaturist, painted a miniature of Ruskin which she exhibited at the Royal Academy in 1888, and Peggy wrote about her friendship with Ruskin in her memoirs, Peggy (1924) and a 29 page A Sketch of John Ruskin published in 1920. Writing about recitation in her memoirs, Peggy observed that the art of recitation died with Clifford Harrison. Harrison, a former actor, embarked on a career as reciter in 1877 and from then until ill-health curtailed his career in 1888 performed at private parties, schools, mechanics’ institutes and charitable functions as well as in public. He made the acquaintance of many celebrities, among them Tennyson, Browning, Matthew Arnold, George Eliot and Ruskin. The friendship with Ruskin was initiated in 1885 when Harrison wrote to Ruskin to thank him for inspiring and instructing him and later sending him some of his drawings of Alpine scenes. This led to several meetings, exchanges of letters and animated discussions of painting, drawing, acting and reciting. Harrison recalled in his memoirs that ‘Acting and dramatic speaking had always, it seemed, greatly interested him and he had seen and heard the best actors and speakers of the day. He had theories about them [...] In speaking of great actors, he nearly always brought against them the charge of artificiality. They were not “natural”, not “spontaneous” enough; they had thought about it all too much. This he said most emphatically about Macready whereby challenging a little good-natured argument with my mother’37 (Harrison’s mother, Ellen Clifford, had acted with Macready). Harrison recited privately for Ruskin and received a very Ruskinian reaction: After he had heard me recite, he told me that my reciting was ‘all too studied’, was not ‘natural’ enough; that he was sure I should recite much
John Ruskin at the Theatre
17
better if I did not learn my pieces, or think them out in every tone and gesture, but just took the book up and read them dramatically, as I felt at the moment. I pointed out to him that this was in effect the very denial of all his pet theories in another art; this was haphazard, slapdash, rough art with a vengeance. But he said the matter was essentially different. No such parallel could be drawn. And on further talk I discovered the real reason for all this, namely, that recitation, and in a sense acting, was but a voice of literature to him, not per se an art.38 It is clear that the theatre, in its search for artistic and social respectability, was anxious for the imprimatur of leading cultural authorities. So Ruskin’s presence in the audience of plays was reported in the press. His favourable comments on Wilson Barrett’s Claudian (1883) were repeated over and over again for the rest of the century. When Praeterita was published, the theatrical trade paper The Era (27 February 1886) took the opportunity to extract and summarise Ruskin’s references to his early theatregoing. However, this enlistment of Ruskinian approval spectacularly backfired in the dispute with Irving about the character of Shylock and Irving’s interpretation of The Merchant of Venice. By the 1890s, although Ruskin was now confined to Brantwood, he was kept up to date with the theatrical world by his cousin Joan Severn who sent him regular letters reporting on her theatre visits, which she obviously felt would be of interest to him and which relate to his known interests. It was Arthur Severn, her husband, who reported to Ruskin the visit to see Irving in King Lear (13 December 1892): ‘I do not think him very good – he wants dignity – but I dare say it is a very difficult part.’ It was Joan, however, who went to see Irving in King Arthur (‘it was wonderful’) (5 February 1895). Interestingly she went with friends to see Irving and Ellen Terry in The Merchant of Venice (18 March 1898) and, given the famous quarrel with Ruskin about the play, her comments are intriguing: ‘we all enjoyed it wildly – the scenery was so lovely – it made me think of ’oo at every turn! – and Irving was marvellous as the Jew – and Ellen Terry a triumph as Portia – and all the other characters were excellent – and well sustained, we even had a gondola now and then gliding along.’ An undated letter has her at a performance of Waterloo in Manchester with Irving and Terry (‘so charming – but most touching’) (this was probably the autumn tour of 1897 when Irving played Waterloo in a double bill with The Bells in Manchester). Joan went to see the Kendals in The Greatest of These (30 June 1896), The Silver Shell (undated) and most interestingly The Elder Miss Blossom. The letter about this, undated, from Lily Severn reports ‘Mother is resting after being late at the theatre last night. She sends her love. We so enjoyed seeing Mrs Kendal in a charming new play “The Elder Miss Blossom”’.39 The Elder Miss Blossom by Ernest Hendrie and Metcalfe Wood opened at the St James’s Theatre on 22 September 1898 and Mrs Kendal called it ‘one of my most successful and popular parts’.40
18 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
Joan went to see George Alexander at the St James’s Theatre in Lord Anerley (7 November 1891) and Henry Arthur Jones’ The Masqueraders (28 June 1894). On 14 March 1897 she reported a visit on the previous evening to Nelson’s Enchantress at the Avenue Theatre, with Johnston Forbes Robertson as Nelson and Mrs Patrick Campbell as Emma Hamilton: ‘We greatly enjoyed seeing Nelson yesterday tho’ Violet and I both sobbed bitterly at his parting with Lady Hamilton and his death.’ However, the theatregoing public did not share their enthusiasm and the play which opened on 11 February closed on 20 March. On 29 November 1897 she wrote to say they were going to see John Hare in A Pair of Spectacles (‘such a charming play’) at the Camberwell Theatre (‘How I wish you were here – and going with us!’). On 11 July 1896 she reported a visit to ‘Wilson Barrett’s great play’ The Sign of the Cross but expressed disappointment that Barrett and his leading lady were on holiday and replacement actors played the leads. She went several times to the ‘lovely new Camberwell Theatre’, presumably the Metropole, Camberwell, opened in 1894, to see not only Hare in A Pair of Spectacles but also in Caste. She also went to a revival of the popular mid-century hit Our Boys (undated letters) and to Charley’s Aunt (27 May 1893) (‘the success of the season’). Like Ruskin, she was a regular attender at the pantomime, seeing Robinson Crusoe at Drury Lane (17 February 1894), Cinderella at the new Camberwell Theatre (2 February 1895) and Bluebeard (undated).41 In his last published work, Praeterita (1886–9), Ruskin had recorded ‘And I greatly enjoy theatre to this day – it is one of the pleasures that have least worn out’ (CW 35.175). Joan evidently sought almost to the end to stimulate that still surviving appetite for the drama in the old man’s steadily dimming faculties.
2 Ruskinian Influences
Throughout his life, Ruskin had no doubt that the arts were a basic necessity for humankind. The role of painting and poetry as religious guides, moral educators, and guides to feeling, seeing and living, sing through all his work. However idealised, however inaccurate as historical discourse, his homage to the medieval craftsmen in Modern Painters for their work showing their individuality, their roughness, their savagery, was typical of Ruskin’s commitment to knowledge and education through art and craft. As we will see throughout this study, Ruskin’s evangelical zeal for ‘right seeing’ was catholic. He cared little for arbitrary boundaries between ‘high’ culture and the arts and crafts of the working classes. His central criterion for valuable art was that it moved the spectator to a closer understanding of the truth: the difference between a noble and ignoble painter is in nothing more sharply defined than in this, – that the first wishes to put into his work as much truth as possible, and yet to keep it looking un-real; the second wishes to get through his work lazily, with as little truth as possible, and yet to make it look real (CW 5.186). However, as Ruskin developed his aesthetic theories as social and political theory, he argued that the purposes of art were not merely individual; they were also national. In his extraordinary address to the unwitting burghers of Bradford in 1864, ‘Traffic’, Ruskin tells his audience that: you cannot have good architecture merely by asking people’s advice on occasion. All good architecture is the expression of national life and character; and it is produced by a prevalent and eager national taste, or desire for beauty (CW 18.434). He goes on to explain himself: Permit me, therefore, to fortify this old dogma of mine somewhat. Taste is not only a part and an index of morality; – it is the ONLY morality. 19
20 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
The first, and last, and closest trial question to any living creature is, ‘What do you like?’ Tell me what you like and I’ll tell you what you are. […] And the entire object of true education is to make people not merely do the right things, but enjoy the right things: – not merely industrious, but to love industry – not merely learned, but to love knowledge – not merely pure, but to love purity – not merely just, but to hunger and thirst after justice (CW 18.434). Although Ruskin does not articulate it here, he viewed the theatre – as we have seen in Chapter 1 – as a prime vehicle for national education of taste and morality. As Ruskin told his Bradford audience, ‘there is no national virtue, small or great, which is not manifestly expressed in all the art which circumstances enable the people possessing that virtue to produce’ (CW 18.437). Ruskin’s interest in the theatre was part of a broader interest in recreation and pleasure, as the corollary to work. Both were necessary, according to Ruskin, and both were threatened by the encroachments of industrial capitalism – by what Carlyle (Ruskin’s sometime intellectual uncle) called ‘the cash nexus’. The theatre could offer recreation which could both educate and amuse its audiences. And both aspects of the theatre were important for Ruskin. Ruskin’s direct engagement with the theatre comprised a life-long and catholic attendance at West End theatres, and friendships with actors and managers, which included advising and debating with them. But, apart from the comments cited in Chapter 1, Ruskin never wrote on the theatre in any sustained and systematic way. However, the influence of his aesthetic and social thinking is discernible in the theatre writing of those theatre practitioners he came to know, and in the work of several influential writers who made significant commentaries and critiques on the British theatre in the last third of the nineteenth century. From Helen Faucit and Madge Kendal, through Henry Arthur Jones and Stewart Headlam, to Lewis Carroll and Matthew Arnold, those who wished to make and change the theatre in the late nineteenth century were all Ruskinians, to a greater or lesser degree. Like Ruskin, Matthew Arnold wrote comparatively little about the theatre, but he always took it seriously. He was a regular theatregoer not only in Britain but also in France and Germany. He expressed his love of theatre in sonnets to Shakespeare, Sophocles and the French actress Rachel. As such, not only was he, like Ruskin, a fan, he also shared Ruskin’s taste for Shakespeare, comedy and French plays in the original language. But he also went to fashionable dramatic and melodramatic successes too, such as The Silver King, Forget-Me-Not and The Duke’s Motto. He set out his major ideas on the drama in an essay on ‘The French Play in London’, inspired by the visit of the Comédie Française to London in 1879. It had been a major cultural event. Inspired by the French company, he set out a blueprint for a subsidised British national theatre, which would not
Ruskinian Influences
21
be realised for 100 years.1 Others were also to argue for a national theatre, many of them inspired directly by Ruskinian ideals.2 At various times Arnold planned to write plays himself, one set at the end of the Roman Republic and another on the life of the Latin poet Lucretius. Neither materialised. But he did publish a drama on a Greek theme, Merope in 1858. He wrote on 6 March 1858 asking Helen Faucit to play Merope on the stage.3 She refused the play, ‘pointing out some of the difficulties which she saw would stand in the way of its success on the stage’.4 Merope never made it to the stage. Arnold offered his reflections on a lifetime of theatregoing in his five ‘letters from an old playgoer’ published in the Pall Mall Gazette between December 1882 and October 1884.5 He was moved by Irving’s Hamlet and wrote on 7 March 1878 inviting him to dine.6 He devoted one of his letters of an old playgoer to Irving’s production of Much Ado About Nothing (‘beautifully put upon the stage’) arguing that Irving and Ellen Terry had personalities which peculiarly fitted them for this kind of comedy. He was in the audience for Wilson Barrett’s Hamlet and also wrote on it for the Pall Mall Gazette. There is a striking parallel to Ruskin’s theatregoing and theatre interests in those of Lewis Carroll. Both had been strictly brought up – in Carroll’s case by a clergyman father and in Ruskin’s by evangelical parents. Carroll himself became a clergyman and was all too aware of the longstanding clerical prejudice against the stage. But, like Ruskin, Carroll became entranced by the stage. They shared similar tastes – Shakespeare, comedy, and in particular pantomime. They each went to three or four a year, though Carroll also patronised melodrama which Ruskin did not, and not the French plays in the original language that Ruskin favoured. Both were fans: Carroll of the Terry sisters, Ruskin of Mrs Kendal. Both wrote about the theatre. Carroll subscribed to the Theatre magazine and wrote two articles for it. Both wrote stories for children (Ruskin’s King of the Golden River and Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland were both much-reprinted classics of the genre). Both went to see Claudian three times, and Carroll’s comments directly echo those of Ruskin. Both were obsessed by young girls, an obsession which in these knowing times has led to accusations of paedophilia, a condition of which Catherine Robson seeks to acquit both of them.7 Ruskin and Carroll knew each other in Oxford and Carroll actually photographed Ruskin. They also had friends in common, particularly the Liddells and George MacDonald, another author of fairy stories, unlike Ruskin and Carroll a married man with children of his own, though described by those who knew him as a puer aeternus – a child man.8 W.E. Gladstone, who was Prime Minister during the years 1868–74, 1880–5, 1886 and 1892–4, had been brought up in a strict Scottish Presbyterian atmosphere and had inevitably imbibed the deep evangelical mistrust of the stage. He recorded in his diary on 19 December 1832 his belief that the
22 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
races and the theatre ‘involve the encouragement of sin’. But at Eton and Oxford he was required to study the repertoire of classical plays and the standard texts on rhetoric and gesture. When he took up politics, he turned these studies to good effect, as well as harnessing his natural gifts, and became a renowned orator. In the 1850s Gladstone underwent something of a conversion to theatrical performance. This may have been due to the regime of his fellow Etonian Charles Kean at the Princess’s Theatre. There is no doubt that Gladstone found Kean’s regime very much to his taste. He saw Kean’s productions of The Winter’s Tale (1856), Richard II (1857), The Tempest (1857), King Lear (1858), The Merchant of Venice (1858), Henry V (1859), The Corsican Brothers (1859) and A Midsummer Night’s Dream (1859). He arranged for Kean to give him a guided tour of his theatre in 1857 and he spoke at Kean’s retirement dinner in 1859, lamenting the fact that his parliamentary duties kept him from attending the theatre as often as he would have liked. Gladstone praised Kean for labouring ‘in the noble and holy cause of endeavouring to dissociate the element of the drama from all moral and social contamination’. His conversion extended to writing in 1878 an open letter advocating the creation of a National Theatre. Gladstone had read and seen all of Shakespeare’s major plays. Not surprisingly he became a regular attendee at the Lyceum under Irving’s management. He recorded his many visits in his diary between 1875 and 1893 when his increasing deafness made theatregoing impracticable. He saw Irving in Hamlet, Othello, Richard III, Romeo and Juliet, Much Ado About Nothing, Henry VIII and King Lear. But he also went to the Lyceum for Irving’s melodrama productions The Lady of Lyons, The Lyons Mail, Ravenswood, The Corsican Brothers, Faust and poetic dramas The Cup and Becket. Other visits to Shakespeare productions included Mary Anderson in Romeo and Juliet, Lillie Langtry in Antony and Cleopatra and Charles Fechter in Hamlet. But Gladstone’s theatregoing was nothing if not catholic. He went to the ballet at the Alhambra, the opera (Gounod, Wagner) at Covent Garden, the circus, the Metropolitan Music Hall, the pantomime at Drury Lane, comedies (Money, A Pair of Spectacles), popular melodrama (The Ticket of Leave Man, Peril), the French plays to see Sarah Bernhardt, and Tomasso Salvini in Il Gladiatore. On Salvini, Gladstone’s opinion (‘manifestly an actor of real greatness’) differed markedly from Ruskin’s.9 Ruskin became a friend and regular guest of Gladstone. Gladstone read 13 of Ruskin’s works, attended Ruskin’s lectures and enjoyed lively and interesting discussions with him on political (crime, education) and cultural (Scott, Homer) matters. Gladstone called him ‘In some respects an unrivalled guest’ (CW 33.xxxi). In 1892 Gladstone wanted Ruskin to succeed Tennyson as Poet Laureate, but his deteriorating health precluded such a development. Although Ruskin had fallen silent by the 1880s, the gospel according to Ruskin was effectively preached by leading playwright and polemicist
Ruskinian Influences
23
Henry Arthur Jones (1851–1929). He has been described as ‘the most popular dramatist of the 1890s’.10 In 1895 he published a collection of his essays and lectures from the previous 10 years under the title The Renascence of the English Drama. These pieces are suffused with direct and indirect references to Ruskin and are evidence of the role of Ruskinism in debates about theatre. George Bernard Shaw explicitly described him as ‘a disciple of Ruskin’.11 In the introduction, he outlines the recurrent themes of his writing: ‘I have fought for a recognition of the distinction between the art of the drama on the one hand and popular amusement on the other, and of the greater pleasure to be derived from the art of the drama’; ‘I have fought for the entire freedom of the modern dramatist, for his right to portray all aspects of human life, all passions, all opinions’; ‘I have fought for sanity and wholesomeness, for largeness and breadth of view. I have fought against the cramping and deadening influence of modern pessimistic realism, its littleness, its ugliness, its narrowness, its parochial aims’.12 The context in which he writes is his perception that over the previous decade society has moved from a prevailing spirit of materialism to a more spiritual interpretation of life. He argues that the four chief qualities that any work of art can possess, be it play, picture, poem or statue, are beauty, mystery, passion and imagination. The modern realistic drama, he believes, not only does not possess these qualities, it derides them. In his essay ‘The Theatre and the Mob’ (first published in The Nineteenth Century in 1883), he laments the influence of mass popular taste on the theatre, quoting Ruskin to the effect that the multitude ‘always awake to the lowest pleasures art can bestow and blunt to the highest’.13 The taste of the mob has dictated the prevalence in the theatre of burlesque, comedy and sensation drama. Managers pander to this taste when they should be seeking to raise taste. But he sees hope in ‘a general awakening of art-feeling and art-curiosity in the country’, a growing interest in the drama as an art among audiences and critics. He ends with a quote from ‘our great English seer’ (by which he means Ruskin): Must it be then only with our poets that we insist they shall either create for us the image of a noble morality, or among us create none? Or shall we not also keep guard over all other workers for the people (including our playwrights, and managers and actors), and forbid them to make what is ill-customed, and unrestrained, and ungentle, and without order or shape, either in likeness of living things or in buildings, or in any other thing whatsoever that is made for the people. And shall we not rather seek for workers who can track the inner nature of all that may be sweetly schemed; so that the young men as living in a wholesome place may be profited by everything that in work fairly wrought may touch them through hearing or sight, as if it were a breeze bringing health to them from places strong with life.14
24 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
In ‘Religion and the Stage’ (published in The Nineteenth Century in 1885) he complains about the elimination of serious subjects (religion, politics, business) from the stage: ‘The only restriction that should be placed upon (the playwright) is that he should not offend against the recognised code of social decency, and here we have a sufficient safeguard in the censorship and the “common-sense of most”.’15 In a short essay on truth and realism, published in the New York Dramatic Mirror (19 April 1890), in which he calls for art to be put at the service of the former rather than the latter, he approvingly quotes Ruskin on Turner.16 In an essay on ‘The Future of the English Drama’ (New Review, 1893) he identifies the positive changes in the theatre over the previous 20 years: the decline of adaptations from the French and the rise of original English dramas, the awakening of dramatic intelligence in the audience, the growing distinction between the theatre as ‘a funny entertainment and as a mirror of life’, the fact that more serious subjects are being dealt with on the stage and that there are now half a dozen theatres devoted to the drama as an art.17 In ‘A Playwright’s Grumble’ (To-Day, 1884) he gives as a creed for the modern playwright Ruskin’s statement in his Lectures on Art: ‘The highest thing that art can do is to set before you the true image of the presence of a noble human being. It has never done more than this, and it ought not to do less.’18 In ‘The Dramatic Outlook’ (English Illustrated Magazine, 1885), he points to ‘the enormous and ever-growing popularity of the theatre with all classes’ and ‘the comparative scarcity of major modern plays of high excellence and serious import’. He declares ‘our great need is, then, for a school of plays of serious intention, plays that implicitly assert the value and dignity of human life, that it has great passions and great aims, and is full of meaning and importance’.19 He identifies ‘truthful character drawing’ and ‘adequate language’ as the two cardinal tests of the merits of a play. He quotes as still relevant the rules of art laid down by Ruskin in Modern Painters and urges his readers ‘if you will but study him, you will find that much of what he has said there may be as usefully applied to the criticism of the drama as to the criticism of pictures. So true is that fine saying, which I think is Michael Angelo’s, “There is but one art” ’.20 In ‘On Playmaking’, a lecture delivered to the National Sunday League on 15 February 1891, he advocates as models for the aspiring playwright, in an evident echo of Ruskin, the technique of Turner and the structure and nature of the Gothic church, in other words a combination of truth, beauty, variety and harmony.21 He launches a fierce attack of the Realists: Lately a school has arisen amongst us which proclaims that the details of ugliness and disease are of the chief importance for us to study, and that curious and distorted forms of vice and selfishness and human degradation are the essential elements to be preserved and treasured
Ruskinian Influences
25
in our plays. I protest against it with all my might. I say that all great art is instinctively healthy, instinctively rejects and hates and tramples upon all mere disease, ugliness and vice, and uses them only by way of contrast, and to produce the impression of truthfulness. I think that in this respect art should strictly follow nature by preserving a balance, as nature always does – a balance of health, of beauty, and pleasure in life.22 The lecture provoked the ire of the critic A.B. Walkley who rejected his dismissal of the realists, characterising Jones as ‘one of the old apostles who preach that there are things not convenient for the stage. He has not yet cast out the devil […] of Ruskinism. Art must be “healthy”’.23 In ‘Our Modern Drama – is it an art or an amusement?’, a lecture delivered to The Playgoers Club on 5 November 1890, he quotes with approval the opinion of ‘the greatest art critic the world has ever seen, John Ruskin’: ‘The end of art is not to amuse. All art which proposes amusement as its end, or which is sought for that end, must be of an inferior, and is probably of a harmful, class.’24 In a lecture on ‘The Relations of the Drama to Education’, delivered to the City of London College (12 October 1893), he called for recognition of the drama as an educative force: ‘The drama should teach; if it does not it is meaningless, empty, puerile, trivial. It should never teach directly and with set purpose; if it does, it is meddlesome, one-sided, intolerant, irritating and tiresome. Briefly we may say, it should teach, but it should never preach.’25 ‘The stage is not merely the most vivid and forcible teacher of the truths and wisdom of life. It is also the most flexible, the most humane, the most tolerant teacher … beyond giving a deep and searching knowledge of the heart of man and the great truths of life, the stage has a lighter and pleasanter task in teaching good manners and the delicacies and amenities of social intercourse.’26 Jones wrote an introduction to the English translation of Augustin Filon’s history of the English stage, originally published in France. Augustin Filon invoked Ruskin in his defence of the archaeological accuracy and artistic harmony of Irving’s Lyceum productions of Shakespeare: Irving is to be looked on not merely as an interpreter of Shakespeare. Hardly less important has been his work in editing the plays for the modern theatre, and in staging them worthily: at the Lyceum he has given them a setting than which the great dramatist, had he lived in our days (and read Ruskin), could have wished for nothing better.27 Jones not only lectured on Ruskin’s ideas but sought to give them dramatic form in his plays. His 1889 play Wealth, which starred Herbert Beerbohm Tree, was his attempt to illustrate the Ruskinian maxim ‘There is no wealth but life’. The central character in Wealth is the millionaire Sheffield
26 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
ironmaster Matthew Ruddock, who, having no son, wants his daughter Edith to marry her cousin John who will inherit the business and carry on the family name. She refuses, being in love with Paul Davoren, who is both a socialist and a rival ironmaster. He enrages Ruddock when he decides to take his workmen into partnership in his business. Ruddock refuses his consent to her marriage to Paul and banishes her. She denounces him because ‘money has been your god’ and she believes ‘all the riches in the world are nothing weighed against love’. Ruddock embarks on a wild spree of reckless speculation and comes to believe that he is bankrupt. His mind gives way under the strain and Edith returns to look after him. In a distinctly Ruskinian manner Ruddock rhapsodises about the beauty of flowers he has picked, never having noticed them before in his money-obsessed heyday. He soliloquises: ‘Oh for money, money, money, not for myself, but to give, give, give, to pour it all away like water, to scatter plenty like God, to rain happiness everywhere round me.’28 On discovering that he is not bankrupt after all but dying, he agrees to the marriage of Edith and Paul and makes a final declaration of his belief: ‘I had millions and was poor! I had nothing and was rich! Rich! Rich! Rich! […] Not money – not that sort of riches – heavenly riches – Love, love, love.’29 The play was a critical and box office failure. But Jones achieved greater success later in the same year with his play The Middleman which starred E.S. Willard. Jones described the theme of the play as ‘a fight between grasping commercialism and inventive genius’.30 It dramatises the very Ruskinian idea of the superiority of skilled craftsmanship to moneymaking. The central figure is Cyrus Blenkarn, a potter who devotes his life to seeking to rediscover the lost ancient method of glazing. He is contrasted with his employer, Chandler, the rich and smug owner of the porcelain factory. Cyrus is reduced to poverty by his search for the perfect pot but eventually he succeeds in producing it. This makes his fortune while the Chandlers are reduced to poverty. The play was ‘a great and immediate success’.31 It ran for 182 nights at the Shaftesbury Theatre and was later successfully produced in New York. In the first systematic critical analysis of Jones’ work, Richard A. Cordell declared in 1932 that Jones was ‘a liberal Victorian and drew his intellectual and spiritual nutrition largely from his contemporaries. There is hardly an “idea” in any of his plays that cannot be found expressed somewhere in Ruskin or Arnold or one of their fellowliberals’.32 Jones’ increasingly emphatic critique of popular entertainment is underscored by a general critical assumption that the drama and the theatre had become separated in the English theatre industry in the nineteenth century. Critics’ and practitioners’ contemplation of this division recurs throughout the period. But they had different answers to the problem. The gap between literature and the theatre, between drama and theatre, was felt by critics and theorists to be an almost insuperable barrier to arresting what his fellow theatre reformer, William Archer, called in 1897 the ‘blight on the drama’.
Ruskinian Influences
27
Acknowledging himself as an ‘outsider’ and, as such, not privy to the actual financial arrangements of managers, he still regrets that the economics of the London theatre are such that managers tend towards fads and crazes, as well as the Christmas pantomime, to cover their costs, and the ‘theatrical public’ has one simple desire: ‘it demands to be amused and interested, and does not in the least care how.’33 In the light of this, he calls for an endowed theatre to free the drama from the commercial demands of the theatre. An endowed, non-commercial theatre would stage plays: that appeal to the thousands, not to the tens of thousands; plays that interest intelligent people without being sufficiently sensational, or amusing, or sentimental, or vulgar to run for two hundred and fifty nights; plays that have no star-part to tempt an actor-manager; plays in which the female interest is weak; plays that end, must end, unhappily; plays, in fine, that do not fulfil the thousand and one trivial conditions on which popular success is supposed to depend.34 While Jones’ and Archer’s views on the theatre diverged from those of actors and managers, such as Wilson Barrett and the Kendals (for further discussion of these divergences, see Chapter 5), their differences were largely about the ways in which the theatre might be renovated. The basic principles which should guide that renovation were never in dispute: critics and practitioners were united in the Ruskinian vision of art that is beautiful, useful and playful. Such art would contribute to the education of a morally-aware and feeling individual, equipped to resist the mechanisation of industrial capitalism. The controversial Anglican cleric Reverend Stewart Duckworth Headlam (1847–1924) was another public figure to promote Ruskinian ideas about the stage. Educated at Eton and Trinity College, Cambridge, Headlam had been ordained as a deacon in the Church of England in 1870 and as a priest in 1872. From 1870 to 1873 he was curate of St John’s, Drury Lane, where he encountered the dancers and theatricals who he was to champion for the rest of his life. At a time when women on the stage were considered little better than prostitutes, Headlam earned disapproval from his superiors for defending dancers in particular against disparagement and arguing that dance was essentially sacramental and godly. But throughout his life he courted controversy and provoked outrage by his actions. In 1895 he stood bail for Oscar Wilde and in 1897 took him into his house after his release from prison. He defended the atheist M.P. Charles Bradlaugh, barred from taking his seat in Parliament for refusing to swear the oath of allegiance. He established a Sunday School for the children of ballerinas. An AngloCatholic and a Christian Socialist, he was so far at odds with the mainstream views of his Church that the Bishop of London removed his licence to preach in 1878; he did not regain it until 1898.
28 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
Headlam was not only inspired by Ruskin’s views on the stage but also by his doctrine of political economy. He wrote in 1907: It is especially worth noting that the teaching which has revolutionised Political Economy in England was founded on Christ’s saying, ‘I will give unto this last even as unto thee’. It is to be hoped that, now that Mr Ruskin’s epoch-making little book can be obtained for a few pence, it will be read far and wide as a text-book of Political Economy which is essentially Christian.35 As a member of the London School Board, Headlam pressed to have Unto This Last made compulsory reading. Embracing and expounding Ruskin’s views both on art and on society, Headlam became a thoroughgoing Ruskinian. The last straw for his bishop may well have been the enthusiastic lecture that Headlam, by now Curate of St Matthew’s, Bethnal Green, delivered to the Commonwealth Club on 7 October 1877 on the subject of theatre and music hall. A summary was published in the theatrical journal The Era (18 November 1877) under the heading ‘startling defence by clergyman’ and it was subsequently issued as a pamphlet. It contained the arguments that were to be the basis of Headlam’s lectures, addresses and articles for the rest of his life. He acknowledged that many clergymen considered theatres to be evil but declared firmly ‘at the outset what a deep respect I have for all those whose work it is to minister to our amusements; how disastrous it is to give such people a bad name. I regard the profession of an actor or singer or dancer as an entirely honourable profession’. He applauded the profession’s ‘extreme usefulness in our present state of society […] most of us work and live such worried, complicated lives, that we can ill afford to depreciate those who make it their duty to amuse us’. He urged his audience to attend serious drama like Irving’s productions of Macbeth and Hamlet for the moral lessons they teach: ‘I defy anyone to see one of Shakespeare’s great tragedies fairly well acted without having most tremendous moral lessons brought home to him.’ He declared it a duty for people to see ‘really great drama’ in the interests of self-culture. Theatregoing, he thought, had a ‘brightening, educating effect on those who go’. On the lighter side of theatre, he praised Lydia Thompson’s production of Bluebeard, Nellie Farren and Kate Vaughan at the Gaiety, and pantomime stars the Vokes family ‘who have delighted us Christmas after Christmas at Drury Lane’. But he valued in particular the art of dance, though confessing ‘with real shame’ that he had not mastered it himself: ‘I do seriously put it before you as an art which you should get all your children taught. I am sure it would do the children in the elementary schools more good than the military drill which they are now taught.’ He clinched the argument in favour of dance by citing Ruskin: Mr Ruskin who is you know one of the greatest art critics, who probably knows more about the arts of drawing, painting and sculpture than any
Ruskinian Influences
29
man in England, puts dancing above them all, as the highest of all the arts; and constantly to see a beautiful dance on the stage – ballet as we will call it – is an exhilarating sight. Some dances and dancers are bad but: don’t let us be blind to the essential beauty of the ballet, or to the fact that the majority of the dances to be seen in London music halls and theatres are pure and beautiful; above all don’t let us speak with scorn of the ladies who dance on the stage.36 This address expounded the essential elements of Headlam’s justification of the stage – the educational value of the drama, the invaluable role of the theatre in spreading joy, uplift and wholesome diversion and the divine exaltation produced by participating in and witnessing dance. Headlam’s next step was to set up the Church and Stage Guild, which he did on 30 May 1879 with himself as its honorary secretary. Its objects were ‘to break down the prejudice against theatres, actors, music-hall artists, stage-singers, and dancers, in those days all too common among Churchmen; to promote social and religious sympathy between Church and Stage; to vindicate the worthiness of acting and dancing as arts, no less capable of being dedicated to God’s service than any other work of man conscientiously pursued; and to claim for religious persons the right to take part in theatrical amusements, whether as performers or spectators. There was one thing we always repudiated as a Guild and that was having any idea of undertaking a mission to the dramatic profession. Such a notion would have seemed to us an impertinence’.37 Within a year, the Guild had 470 members, of whom 172 were theatricals and 91 clergy. There were monthly meetings, papers were read and there were ‘at homes’ and conversaziones. Senior members of the acting profession such as Irving and the Kendals kept aloof from the Guild, because it treated music hall performers as the equal of actors, though Irving was later to say that it was Headlam, not he, who should be credited with raising the esteem in which the stage was held. But Headlam enjoyed the enthusiastic support of others in the acting profession such as Ben Greet and Johnston Forbes Robertson, both future theatrical knights, and lectures were given by such luminaries as Bernard Shaw and William Poel. Bishop James Fraser of Manchester, Canon Henry Liddon and Lewis Carroll all refused to join the Guild, Liddon declaring his belief that it was impossible to enlist the stage ‘in the cause of Religion and Morality’.38 But the Guild survived until 1900, its role being taken up by the Actors’ Church Union which emerged in 1898 under the leadership of Rev. Donald Hole. Headlam enlisted the support of Ruskin for the Guild and Ruskin wrote to him on 18 July 1879 to say that he did not know ‘when I have been more pleased, amused, or amazed by your letter and the papers of
30 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
the Guild’, adding ‘quite seriously, you have my entire sympathy and good wishes’ (CW 37.292–3). Headlam had another outlet for his view, the journal The Church Reformer, which he took over in 1884 and ran until 1895, subsidising it out of his own pocket. The journal included theatrical reviews, reports on the Church and Stage Guild and essays on the moral ministry of the stage alongside articles on theology and economy. Headlam sent the first issue of The Church Reformer under his editorship to Ruskin, who wrote to him: ‘I never yet looked through a paper I thought so right or likely to be so useful.’39 Ruskin was quoted regularly in Headlam’s articles and lectures and in the contributions of his regular writers, notably Selwyn Image, another convinced Ruskinian. Headlam printed a large extract from Fors Clavigera 39 in The Church Reformer 7 (December 1888), in which Ruskin described the church and the pantomime as ‘these two theatrical entertainments’ whose ‘imaginative congregations still retain true notions of the value of human and beautiful things’. In ‘Applause’, a paper read to the Church and Stage Guild and reprinted in The Church Reformer 5 (May 1886), Headlam quoted Ruskin as saying ‘all the arts of mankind and womankind are only rightly learned and practised when they are so with the definite purpose of pleasing others’. In The Function of the Stage (1889), a pamphlet which expanded and developed his lecture on ‘The Moral Ministry of the Stage’, Headlam quoted Ruskin saying ‘just as life without industry is guilt, so industry without art is brutality’.40 In ‘The Moral Ministry of the Stage’ summarised in The Church Reformer 8 (1889), Headlam reiterated his message: ‘The moral ministry of the stage depends upon the fact that we can be made better people by being made brighter and happier people.’ He saw the role of tragedy as serving humanity ‘by purifying our passions, by correcting and refining our pity and terror, making us pity what we ought to pity, dread what we ought to dread; but it does this education for us in a pleasurable way’. Comedy was equally important: ‘Caricaturing and ridiculing our faults, foibles and follies, but at the same time arousing human sympathy with, and interest in, the affairs and events of everyday life; and, at any rate, in the last resource, making us laugh and forget ourselves altogether.’ He said the ballet had a ‘consoling, healing, exhilarating influence’ on the masses ‘overworked and worried, living too often in gloomy streets, surrounded by mud, dirt, grime, meagreness’. So it was a message of uplift and instruction. Richard Foulkes has traced the often troubled relations between church and stage in the nineteenth century and has identified something of a rapprochement between the two by the end of the century. This was brought about partly by the eminently respectable lives lived by key figures in the profession such as William Charles Macready, Samuel Phelps, Henry Irving (the first actor to be knighted), Helen Faucit (later Lady Martin), Marie Wilton and Madge Kendal (ultimately Dame Madge Kendal). Not only the
Ruskinian Influences
31
careers of such key figures but the religious, social and intellectual transformations of the Victorian age caused attitudes to the theatre slowly but surely to change. The manifestations of this change included the mission of Bishop Fraser of Manchester to that city’s theatres, aiming to purify rather than abolish the stage, the popularity of the Oberammergau Passion Play which inspired home-grown Bible story tableaux vivants at inner city churches, and the foundation of student drama societies at both Oxford and Cambridge, where the authorities had previously discouraged theatricals.41 While the church was undergoing changes, so too was the stage. The middle class audience began to return in large numbers, the professional status of actors and the gentility and moral tone of plays began to be stressed. The cult of Shakespeare as the pre-eminent British cultural hero proved as inspiring to clerics as to laymen. The National Shakespeare Committee planning the Shakespeare tercentenary of 1864 included three archbishops and four bishops. Headlam campaigned ceaselessly for the teaching and performance of Shakespeare in London schools. He was president of the London Shakespeare League from 1914 until his death. Eventually, after the censor had ensured that religious themes and Bible stories were rigorously excluded from the stage for much of the nineteenth century, there was a breakthrough in the 1890s, when the prohibition was relaxed and the religious problem dramas of the Ruskinian Henry Arthur Jones (Judah, Michael and His Lost Angel), Hall Caine (The Christian, The Eternal City) and above all the spectacular melodrama of the early days of Christianity, Ruskinian Wilson Barrett’s The Sign of the Cross, which was recommended by clergymen from the pulpit, achieved theatrical and moral success. The principal institutional expressions of this rapprochement were undoubtedly the Church and Stage Guild and The Church Reformer through which Headlam consistently preached his Ruskinian gospel of the stage. The pessimism of critics such as Jones and Archer was refuted by professionals within the mainstream. Given that their daily work comprised of balancing the often contradictory aims of pleasing a diverse theatrical public, offering work which had artistic integrity, and earning a living (or at least a return on their capital investment in the case of managers such as Irving and Barrett), a defence of both drama and theatre is to be expected. But the defence of the mainstream theatre of the period by its pre-eminent practitioners went much further than this, and neatly turned Victorian antitheatrical prejudices back on themselves, by representing the theatre as the epitome of Victorian morality and respectability. Leading actor-managers became advocates of Ruskinian ideas. The role and future of the theatre in national culture is a recurring topic in publicity, interviews and the other ephemera of fame surrounding Sir Henry Irving, Wilson Barrett and, to a lesser extent, Madge Kendal. In the late nineteenth century the theatrical profession was still subject to some aspersion, suggested by the force and number of articles still being published in this
32 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
period arguing for the theatre as educative and a power for good in society. In their public statements on the theatre and society, all three practitioners take on the role of spokesperson for their profession with enthusiasm, and all three use the occasions offered them to reiterate the double and linked purposes of the theatre: to educate by amusing. All three emphasise the work, the skill, the professionalism of the actor. Understandably, they are enthusiastic about recommending the theatre as a source of pleasure and amusement, as well as a place of honest thought and work. But in this they are at one with a central message of Ruskin’s social theory, which is always to suggest that pleasure must accompany work and art in a seamless wealth of life. In their public utterances over the state of the drama, its morality and its social role, Irving, Barrett and Kendal give the weight of their considerable reputations, as both individuals of probity and theatre practitioners of renown, to the view represented by Ruskin’s private comments about the value of the theatre. As noted in Chapter 1, personal relations between Ruskin and Irving (1838–1905) were soured by the controversy over Irving’s interpretation of Shylock. Nevertheless, Irving continued to be influenced by Ruskin’s aesthetic and educational ideas. Ruskin had laid out in Modern Painters what he considered to be the characteristics of Great Art. He wrote: Great art dwells on all that is beautiful […] great art accepts Nature as she is, but directs the eyes and thoughts to what is most perfect in her […] High art, therefore, consists neither in altering, nor in improving nature; but in seeking throughout nature for ‘whatsoever things are lovely, and whatsoever things are pure;’ in loving these, in displaying to the utmost of the painter’s power such loveliness as is in them, and directing the thoughts of others to them by winning art, or gentle emphasis. Art is great in exact proportion to the love of beauty shown by the painter, provided that love of beauty forfeit no atom of truth. The next characteristic of great art is that it includes the largest possible quantity of Truth in the most perfect possible harmony. If it were possible for art to give all the truths of nature, it ought to do it. But this is not possible. Choice must always be made of some facts which can be represented from among others which must be passed by in silence, or even in some respects, misrepresented (CW 5.56–9). He went on to give Rembrandt and Veronese as examples of artists whose use of colour, light and shade creates a harmonious whole, which conveys truth and beauty. This Ruskinian creed can be seen to lie behind the philosophy of the stage and the drama articulated by Sir Henry Irving. Irving said: ‘in the consideration of the Art of Acting, it must never be forgotten that its ultimate aim is beauty. Truth itself is only an element of beauty, and merely to reproduce things vile and squalid and mean is a
Ruskinian Influences
33
debasement of Art.’ He was committed to a great cause: ‘We go forth, armed with the luminous panoply which genius has forged for us, to do battle with dullness, with coarseness, with apathy, with every form of vice and evil.’ He declared: ‘Truly the actor’s work embraces all the arts. He must first have the gift or faculty of acting […] His sympathy must then realise to himself the image in the poet’s mind, and by the exercise of his art use his natural powers to the best advantage. His form and emotions are, in common with the sculptor’s work, graceful and purposeful; his appearance and expression heightened by costume and pictorial preparation, are in common with the efforts of the musician – to arouse the intelligence by the vibrations and modulations of organized sound.’42 Here is the same concern for compositional harmony as Ruskin expounded in discussing painting. Irving was certainly familiar with Ruskin’s ideas. He possessed a good range of Ruskin’s works. When he fell on hard times at the end of his career and was forced to sell off part of his library, he sold among many other works his five-volume set of Modern Painters, his three-volume set of Stones of Venice (1873–4) and his nine-volume set of Fors Clavigera (1871–87). But he retained until his death a single volume containing Ruskin’s ‘Pre-Raphaelitism’; ‘Notes on the Turner Gallery at Marlborough House’, ‘The Nature of Gothic Architecture’ and ‘Notes on the Royal Academy’ numbers 3, 4 and 5. This was sold with the rest of his library after his death. Despite their disagreements about the portrayal of Shylock, Irving continued to preach an essentially Ruskinian gospel about the uplifting and ennobling role of the stage: Not for a moment is the position to be accepted that the theatre is merely a place of amusement […] it is a living power, to be used for good, or possibly for evil; and far-seeing men recognise in it, based though it be on the relaxation and pleasures of the people, an educational medium of no mean order. Its progress in the past century has been the means of teaching to millions of people a great number of facts which had perhaps otherwise been lost to them. How many are there who have had brought home to them in an understandable manner by stage-plays the costumes, habits, manners, and customs of countries and ages other than their own; what insights have they thus obtained into facts and vicissitudes of life – of passions and sorrows and ambitions outside the narrow scope of their own lives, and which yet may and do mould the destinies of man. All this is education – education in its widest sense, for it broadens the sympathies and enlarges the intellectual grasp. And beyond this again […] there is that higher education of the heart, which raises in the scale of creation all who are subject to its sweetening influences.43 In a true Ruskinian sense, Irving was strongly committed to the spread of culture to the people. He regularly accepted invitations to open libraries,
34 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
galleries and exhibitions. By so doing, he was implicitly linking theatre to libraries and art galleries as a cultural and education force, and as an expression of the gospel of rational recreation. The practical expression of this gospel was a network of mechanics institutes, mutual improvement societies and working men’s clubs, all providing adult education. This was catered for by increasing numbers of art galleries and museums. There were also public libraries funded by both individual philanthropists and local authorities after the 1850 and 1855 Public Libraries Acts, which authorised a penny rate to pay for them. Ruskin was the most influential figure linking art, society and religion. Ruskin wrote in 1867: ‘Every one of our principal cities ought to have a permanent gallery of art of which the function should be wholly educational, as distinguished from the historical and general purpose of the collections of the British Museum and National Gallery’ (CW 19.221). In 1880 he added ‘the first function of a Museum […] is to give example of perfect order and perfect elegance, in the true sense of that test word, to the disorderly and rude population’ (CW 34.247; 251). Ruskin wanted them well-warmed, well-lighted and accessible to all classes, but he proposed a small entrance fee to discourage mere idlers, though overwhelmingly the advocates of museums and galleries argued for free access. He also believed that minor as well as major artists should be included, if they had a moral lesson to teach. As with libraries, the move to provide museums and art galleries was partly due to local government initiative and partly private philanthropic enterprise. Irving enlarged upon the civilising effect of paintings for the masses, when he opened the eleventh annual exhibition of paintings at St Jude’s School, Whitechapel, on 17 March 1891, and again when he opened a free exhibition of pictures at the town hall, Stratford East, on 3 May 1887. He said at Whitechapel: The good which can be done by exhibitions of this kind is incalculable. It is at all times wise to wake in the minds of all, both young and old, new ideas, more especially when such ideas tend to the lovely and imaginative side of life. There is too much sad and squalid realism already and what we want is now and again a glimpse of that ideal which we all yearn for, and yearn in proportion to the exacting nature of our lives. He made a direct link between theatre and gallery: One cannot help thinking there is much in common between my art – the art of the player and the art of the painter. From canvas and sculpture actors have often caught the inspiration of vivid action, and their ambition has been kindled by studies of the statuesque; whilst the theatre has sometimes afforded painters subjects for their work, and also that stimulus and enthusiasm which the living, breathing action of the player may
Ruskinian Influences
35
sometimes inspire. The fields of history and fancy are open to the actor, as to the painter, the actor perhaps having one advantage – inexact and fading though his work may be – of directly moving a multitude of spectators in the mimic scene. Art has its pulpit, and picture galleries and clean and wholesome theatres preach very often very excellent sermons.44 In his Stratford East speech, Irving praised the munificence of West Ham Borough Council in providing municipal institutions for public use – a public hall, free libraries, two recreation grounds and public baths: You are rapidly extending the means and opportunities of rational and aesthetic recreation. These pictures have already enlarged the horizons of many minds. They have done incalculable good by giving impressions of beauty to men and women who toil amidst conditions not always helpful to conceptions of the beautiful. They are true missionaries of civilization, ministering to that eternal need of the ideal, which is as instinctive in us as the craving for material happiness.45 In 1892 Henry Arthur Jones played a prominent role in the movement for the Sunday opening of museums and received a strongly supportive letter from Irving: ‘You are to my mind taking an excellent stand in your advocacy of opening Museums and Picture Galleries on Sundays and I most heartily wish that the movement may be successful.’46 Wilson Barrett’s views of a National Theatre combined education, entertainment, and moral teaching. Like Irving, Barrett was frequently asked questions about the future and role of the theatre. Again, like Irving, he saw it as entirely possible that the right kind of manager, attracting the right kinds of audiences, can bring about the elevation of the theatre. Like Irving, however, Barrett’s views on the ‘right’ kinds of plays and productions were significantly different from the views of critics and theorists such as Jones and Archer. On one of his Antipodean tours, speaking in St Paul’s Cathedral, Dunedin, on 12 January 1902 Barrett gave the fullest outline of his production philosophy, quoting Ruskin in support of his vision of the stage. Referring to himself and his audiences as ‘we Christians’ he sought to reconcile church and stage: Religion is not designed to kill our pleasures, or make them less; it is meant to purify and elevate them; to make them innocent and helpful […] For the desire of recreation and amusement is God’s gift to us […] and it is the duty of Christians not to crush this desire (as the Puritans vainly taught and teach still) but to regulate and guide it. And, in regard to that desire for recreation which finds its gratification in the theatre – it is impossible to ignore the fact that the Drama is, and always will be, a very powerful social instrument for good or for evil, according as it is
36 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
rightly or wrongly directed. The popularity of the Drama, its vividness, the directness of its appeal to the imagination and to the emotions will always secure for it this influence. The theatre appeals to certain aspects of human nature – to the imagination, to the instinct of curiosity about life, to the desire to have the emotions touched by actual pictures of various situations in life which either do not usually come within the ‘ken’ of many people, or if they do are not seen dramatically […] it will always be popular […] the Drama has under one form or another been an important factor in civilization and human development, and has played its part in the social evolution of peoples. In a distinctly Ruskinian spirit, he goes on: I venture to say that in these days, it is more than ever desirable that the drama should exercise an elevating and invigorating influence upon society, for the dry, matter of fact commercial spirit which is so prevalent has a hardening, narrowing tendency – it obscures the larger views of human life with its tragedies and its comedies, its humour and its pathos. I have known business men who found in the amusement of the theatre a wholesome escape from that ‘dustiness’ of the heart (so to speak) which attached to their business hours. A good play afforded them an opportunity of getting a breath of fresh air as it were, and an insight into the largeness of life with its strong emotions and elemental passions. They did their business all the better for it afterwards. In another echo of such Ruskin pronouncements as ‘tell me what you like and I’ll tell you what you are’ and his definition of the elements of greatness in art as ‘nobility of subject, beauty, sincerity and imaginative power’, Barrett said: The influence of the drama may and ought to be a moral influence […] A people’s character depends upon their amusements as well as upon their more serious employments; and what was said of ballads may be said as truly of plays, that they influence people as much as their laws. The stage ought to promote all that is healthiest in morality, as well as that which is inspiriting to the intellect, and pleasurable to the imagination. In short, the true function of theatrical representations should be to purify and elevate […] The business of the dramatist, and of the actor […] should be to interest, to uplift, to refine, to touch the heart and open the eyes, to recall, to suggest, to reveal true and lofty ideals […] He will tell us of the evil, the sordid, the terrible […] but he will never put evil for good, or mislead our judgement, or confuse our moral sense, pervert our sympathies, make vice attractive. All this is false to what is truly natural, false to truth and beauty.
Ruskinian Influences
37
He admitted that there were plays that had a bad influence ‘often clever and brilliant, but […] frankly cynical and almost contemptuous of virtue, honour and truth’, plays which undermined the ideals of true womanhood and the sanctity of marriage, and he urged his hearers to reject them, quoting Ruskin directly: What John Ruskin said about literature may be applied equally well to the drama: ‘In these days’ he says, ‘it is of the greatest importance to keep out of the salt swamps of literature, and live on a little rocky island of our own with a spring and a lake in it pure and good […] It is of more consequence that (books) (and plays) should be right than clever, not oppressively instructive but that the thoughts they express should be just, and the feelings they excite generous. He concludes: ‘The Drama makes for good certainly, it is helpful, not harmful when it presents us with embodied parables of life – with its fair and tragic possibilities; when it enables us to view, as it were from the outside the heights and depths to which we ourselves may rise or fall; when it holds up the contemptible to our contempt, the hateful to our hate, the lovely and the loveable to our love.’47 The fact that Barrett practised what he preached was demonstrated by The Man of the World, in its profile of Barrett: The actor-manager-dramatist may be described in a familiar figure of speech as three gentlemen rolled into one; and Mr. Wilson Barrett is an eminent example of the triple personage, for he has achieved notable success in the several capacities of actor, manager, and dramatist. A good deal of nonsense is talked about the elevation of the drama by this or that manager, although a theatre, as Mr. Bancroft frankly told the public on one occasion, is carried on, like any other business, for the purpose of making money. The theatrical manager should be, above all things, a man of business. Still, Mr. Wilson Barrett, more than any man of his time, may be said to have elevated the drama, for it must be allowed that a new era in the history of the stage in this country dates from the production of The Silver King at the Princess’s Theatre.48 Madge Kendal’s public utterances about the theatre offer further examples of the formal defence of the theatre by its professionals; in Kendal’s case, what is perhaps more interesting is her negotiation of Victorian gender roles generally thought to have limited women theatre practitioners’ choices and reputations. Like Irving and Barrett, Kendal turns disapproving Victorian anti-theatricality back on itself. In Dramatic Opinions and ‘The Drama’, her address to the National Association for the Promotion of Social Science (1884), Kendal argues that the earning capacity of the actress does not run
38 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
counter to her role as a private, domestic woman, but instead enhances and enables the development of a womanly character:49 I do not think there is a thing in the world that a woman could be better than an actress; there is no other calling in which she can earn so much money, – no other calling in which she can keep her own standard so high; no other calling in which she can set a better example and do more good. An actress lives in a world of her own creation and imagination for the time being – a world in which she is perfectly happy or perfectly miserable, as the case may be; and she holds a position which is unique if she has the necessary qualifications, – such as the perseverance which is necessary even when the talent is already there.50 The ‘blessedness of independence’ deriving from earning one’s living in the theatre extends to children as well, in Kendal’s view. In answer to unnamed interlocutors who question the desirability of a stage career for children, Mrs Kendal maintains they have a good life in the theatre, and grow in knowledge, maturity and independence. Rather than interfering with their education, Kendal maintains that work in the theatre provides meaningful and enjoyable work for children, who might otherwise face poverty and ill-treatment: this I do know, that by giving children the recreation of going to a theatre and dancing, you are providing for them an immense pleasure; you employ them in a childish pursuit, and you enable large numbers to make merry together. Why, the dancing-mistress at Drury Lane is simply worshipped by the children. Again, the manager, as a rule, if he keeps them certain hours over time, will give them food. And when they return home, the little child of the lowest and poorest woman in the world will certainly be looked upon and treated with more urbanity and kindness for being the bread-winner.51 In this, she adopts Ruskin’s view of the child pantomime performers he discusses in Fors Clavigera 39, ‘The Cart Goes Better So’. Rachel Dickinson and Sharon Aronofsky Weltman have discussed this letter in detail, finding in it a central example of the ways in which the theatre, pleasure and makebelieve constituted a significant element of his social and aesthetic theory.52 David Mayer’s point, that in his idealisation of the fairy-world of the pantomime stage ‘Ruskin was blind to the strong links between stage illusion and industrialisation’, is cogent and accurate,53 but also assumes that Ruskin intends his aesthetic and social theories to operate at the level of material, practical reality. Ruskin’s social theories were aimed at countering what he saw as the cold logic-chopping of the Utilitarians and other political radicals and reformers. His counter-arguments to the ‘modern soi-disant science of
Ruskinian Influences
39
political economy’ (CW 17.25), as laid out in works such as Unto this Last and Sesame and Lilies, were playful, rhetorical and metaphoric. And the theatre, as part of this counter-blast against the dehumanising effects of industrialisation, was for Ruskin a means of providing similar ‘thoughtful rest’: ‘hours of escapist entertainment, but […] also […] to present what he calls the True Ideal’ which, as Weltman argues, ‘is a paradoxical claim for the greater truth of theatrical illusion’.54 Although Kendal is keen to emphasise the fun and joy child performers have in their work, she also stresses the necessity for hard work and learning, notwithstanding the level of natural talent possessed by a would-be performer. The theatre is a school not simply for child actors, according to Kendal, but an ideal teacher for adults, to develop them into ‘intelligent and cultivated’ professionals.55 However, most middle class aspirants have not ‘the slightest idea of the amount of study, of labour, and of devotion to the art – to say nothing of natural aptitude – that is necessary for success’. Not only is the theatre profession an education for actors, it is an institution ‘more charitable […] than any other’ in the chances it offers ‘to all men and women; no matter what their part has been’.56 Thus, Mrs Kendal’s public statements about the theatre not only refute enduring moral doubts about the theatre (its focus on commerce, the employment of children and women, and the welcoming of aspirants from all classes) but also turn these doubts into examples of the high moral and pedagogical practices of the theatre. As we shall see in Chapter 8, the framework of femininity within which actresses practised their art enacted some of the contradictions of the operation of Victorian gender ideology more broadly. Even Mrs Kendal’s apparently radical support of female work, earning power and independence is cast in the domestic mould of helpmeet and family support. Helen Faucit’s and Madge Kendal’s successes as actresses and authority as commentators are characterised as emanating from their goodness as women, in a celebration of the ‘truth’ of their morality and sensibility. It is this celebration of idealised femininity which Ruskin enjoys in the theatre, but which feminist literary historians have argued is a disabling distancing of women from significant sources of social power and self-determination. This belief in the unique mission of women as guides to an idealised moral world – for their audiences or their families – is one of the twin axes of Ruskin’s major statement on gender roles in contemporary Victorian society, Sesame and Lilies. His second axis is a critique of a materialistic masculinity, and the education system which serves it. Famously, in ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’, Ruskin outlines the queenship of women in the domestic sphere: But the woman’s power is for rule, not for battle, – and her intellect is not for invention or creation, but for sweet ordering, arrangement, and decision. She sees the qualities of things, their claims and their places. Her
40 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
great function is Praise: she enters into no contest, but infallibly judges the crown of the contest (CW 18.121). After two decades of feminist scholarship following Kate Millet’s critique of Ruskin’s ‘compulsive masculine fantasy’ in ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’,57 recent scholarship has focussed on Ruskin’s argument for the education of boys and men, ‘Of Kings’ Treasuries’. Admitting to playful teasing of his audience, Ruskin states at the beginning of ‘Of Kings’ Treasuries’ that: I am not going to talk of kings, known as regnant, nor of treasuries, understood to contain wealth; but of quite another order of royalty, and another material of riches, than those usually acknowledged (CW 18.53). Ruskin goes on to ask his audience to consider the purposes of education. Education for what?, he asks them. His challenge to them is to pursue the right kind of education to fit themselves for a place in life. The ‘court of the past’ of great books, warns Ruskin, is open ‘to labour and to merit, but to nothing else. No wealth will bribe, no name overawe, no artifice deceive’ in this court (CW 18.62). Ruskin’s ‘court’ of great books enables men to be ‘rightly occupied’ so that ‘their amusement grows out of their work’ (CW 18.97). As Jan Marsh points out, Ruskin’s rhetoric in ‘Of Kings’ Treasuries’ is directed against the materialism of the industrial bourgeoisie and the kind of false culture it creates (and she notes that the irony of Ruskin’s own economic position did not strike him, at least in public): ‘But now, we have no true business, we pour our whole masculine energy into the false business of money-making’ (CW 18.97). Ruskin’s blast against this false masculinity is counter-balanced by his positioning of femininity as protector and guardian of the Home, that symbol of all that is not part of the ‘false business’ of industrial capitalism. The authority of the English National poet, and Ruskin’s great touchstone, Shakespeare, is saved for the discussion of the power and moral authority of women. Part of Ruskin’s evidence for the power of women is that Shakespeare has no heroes: he has only heroines. There is not one entirely heroic figure in all his plays […]. In his laboured and perfect plays you have no hero. Othello would have been one, if his simplicity had not been so great as to leave him the prey of every base practice round him; but he is the only example even approximating to the heroic type (CW 18.112). Ruskin is unrelenting in his catalogue of disastrous masculinity in Shakespeare’s plays: The catastrophe of every play is caused always by the folly or fault of a man; the redemption, if there be any, is by the wisdom and virtue of a
Ruskinian Influences
41
woman, and, failing that, there is none. The catastrophe of King Lear is owing to his own want of judgment, his impatient vanity, his misunderstanding of his children; the virtue of his one true daughter would have saved him from all the injuries of the others, unless he had cast her away from him; as it is, she all but saves him (CW 18.97). On the other hand, he writes at length about Shakespeare’s heroines in Proserpina (1879), identifying them as incarnations of various kinds of love. Shakespeare – and Aeschylus, Dante and Homer – are the authorities for Ruskin’s radical proposition that women’s education should fit them for moral leadership in the home. As Marsh points out, Ruskin’s argument touches on several points in common with the later arguments developed in John Stuart Mill’s On the Subjection of Women.58 Linda H. Peterson (in something of an historicist re-thinking of Millet’s position) argues that Ruskin’s use of Shakespeare in ‘Of Queens’ Gardens’ can be read as specifically feminist in its sources and impact, particularly in his unacknowledged debt to Anna Jameson.59 As Ruskin castigates his audience for the corruption of boys by inculcation with the false values of money-making, so he criticises the conventions of bringing up girls ‘as if they were meant for sideboard ornaments’ (CW 18.132). Shakespearean tragic heroines offer a model of moral power which, while perhaps ‘bitter and prickly’ (CW 18.131), offer examples of the rigorous demands of moral ‘queenship’. The plays are blueprints for action when seen, and solid material for reflection when read and re-read. In these published texts of his 1864 public lectures in Manchester, Ruskin uses Shakespeare’s drama as an exemplary intellectual and aesthetic framework for his ‘right thinking’ about books, and to carry his argument about the right thinking approach to education, its purposes and result. More generally, Shakespeare held a special place in Ruskin’s critical thinking in all areas of his moral, social and aesthetic theory. For Ruskin, Shakespeare represented both the native art of the English language and the demonstration of ideal ethics and aesthetics in action. Ruskin’s writings are saturated with references to Shakespeare, suggesting that Ruskin’s deep understanding of Shakespeare’s language and dramaturgy frame much of his aesthetic and moral theory. This familiarity began, according to Ruskin in Praeterita, at an early age, and certainly Ruskin’s private reading of Shakespeare runs in parallel with his attendance at the theatre from his boyhood. One could speculate (as Francis O’Gorman has) on the symbolic filial relationship Ruskin felt for Shakespeare as his moral and aesthetic ‘father’, connected as his reading and seeing of plays was with the figure of his actual father, John James Ruskin.60 Ruskin’s certainty of Shakespeare’s pedagogical power waned in his later life, as he pronounced gloomily in Praeterita ‘his wisdom so useless, that at this time of being and speaking, among active and purposeful Englishmen, I know not one who shows a trace of ever having felt a passion of Shakespeare’s, or learnt a lesson from him’ (CW 35.36). However,
42 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
Shakespeare’s plays, together with the Bible – another authority whose certainty he lost after his ‘unconversion’ in 1858 – remained constant touchstones of Ruskin’s intellectual life. His engagement with these texts, even when disillusioned about their spiritual or moral powers, continued at an intellectual and pedagogical level, until his silence in old age and illness. Ruskin’s writings on Shakespeare and women were recognised by theatre practitioners as well as literary critics. The work of Helen Faucit (Lady Martin) on Shakespeare’s Heroines, for example, bears testimony to the mutual respect developed between her and Ruskin. In fact, one of her essays, on Beatrice, was dedicated to Ruskin. The essays, originally published in Blackwood’s Magazine, were collected in 1885 in a volume called Some of Shakespeare’s Female Characters. It went through 6 editions before 1904. The St James’s Gazette said that only two women had previously had anything worthwhile to say about Shakespeare’s heroines – Anna Jameson and Fanny Kemble – and Helen Faucit should now be added to that number. Helen Faucit’s distinctive innovation was to add passages considering the life of the heroines after the end of the play and she for instance envisaged Portia visiting the sick and broken Shylock and bringing him food and wine. This was objected to by both Ruskin ‘who thought it was not in the spirit of the age’ (i.e. the Renaissance) and Browning (dedicatee of the Rosalind essay) who thought ‘the whole party would be more likely to rejoice over the discomfiture of the Jew’. Helen pondered over whether to delete the passage but eventually decided to keep it in.61 Faucit’s essay on Beatrice, the heroine of Much Ado About Nothing, is addressed to Ruskin. He wrote to her in 1885 about her Beatrice essay: ‘I thought I knew Beatrice, of any lady, by heart, but you have made her still more real and dear to me, especially by the little sentences in which you speak of your own feelings in certain moments of acting her’ (CW 37.515–16). In so doing, he acknowledges the revelatory possibilities of acting as opposed to just reading about a Shakespeare heroine. It is not known if Ruskin saw her on the stage, which, given his avoidance of drama and tragedy, in which she excelled, is perhaps unlikely. ‘Beatrice’ was a late addition to Shakespeare’s Female Characters, and Faucit recorded elsewhere that the role was not a favourite of the first rank with her. However, she offers her essay to Ruskin in an act of shared appreciation of the character: I am glad to see by your letter that Beatrice is a favourite with you. The heresy of Campbell and others, that describes her as a compound of tomboy, flirt, and shrew, – ‘an odious woman,’ I think, Campbell calls her, – has manifestly not enlisted you among its adherents. Whilst, therefore, I am sure of your sympathy in trying to put into words the conception of this brilliant and charming woman which I endeavoured to embody on the stage, still I must approach the subject with great trepidation, as you tell me that you are ‘listening with all your heart to what I shall say
Ruskinian Influences
43
of her.’ […] The lesson Shakespeare teaches seems to me to be entirely in accordance with your own belief, expressed in many ways, ‘that no man ever lived a right life who had not been chastened by a woman’s love, strengthened by her courage, and guided by her discretion.’62 In her review of Helen Faucit’s Shakespeare’s Female Characters, Dinah Mulock Craik mutes some her customary asperity about the modern theatre to praise Shakespeare’s plays in spite of their robustness of plot, topic and expression: ‘over the foulness [of contemporary London theatres] is thrown a certain veneer of refinement. Shakespeare, though often coarse in language […] is always pure at heart […]. His women, too, spite of our ultra-realistic modern actresses […] are and always will be the ideal of all feminine purity.’63 Helen Faucit’s performance and her reflections on her performing career through the characters of Shakespeare’s women are judged by Craik to mirror this wholesomeness and purity. Faucit’s extended series of meditations on the interpretation and performance of Shakespeare’s heroines were powerful because, Craik argues, ‘the secret of her success was not art but nature. She felt all she acted. Her cultivated mind, which, if not absolutely poetic, had a sympathetic appreciation of poetry’.64 Craik’s contention that ‘No woman who was not good, pure, and highminded could have impersonated Shakespeare’s women as Helen Faucit used to do’65 is akin to Mrs Kendal’s comment that audiences expected her to be of a private character similar to those stage characters she represented. Mrs Kendal cites her audience’s satisfaction with her on-stage partnership with her husband: ‘the very fact of knowing we are man and wife, gives them a certain satisfaction in witnessing our performance, which they would not otherwise feel.’66 Mrs Kendal, however, was sceptical about this view of characterisation, but commented that ‘there is no doubt about it that we bring on to the stage an atmosphere of our own’.67 In the late Victorian period, the popular theatre once again became an arena for debates over the possibilities of the theatre as a vehicle for an education in morality and aesthetics. These are debates familiar to the historian of the Victorian theatre, emerging from what might be called the aesthetic panic of the 1820s and 1830s, when the so-called ‘decline of the Drama’ was discussed as a matter of national importance.68 But by the late nineteenth century, several aspects of the theatre as a profession had changed, not least the public voice of prominent women theatre practitioners. Such women, and their male colleagues, challenged Clement Scott’s outrageous claim that no woman who ‘endeavours to keep her purity’ could succeed in a stage career, by turning the very rhetoric of anti-theatricality on its head. They were supported by the personal and institutional power wielded by Victorian critics and sages discussed here, pre-eminent among them John Ruskin. The speeches and lectures by leading theatre practitioners in Victorian England linked their theatre practice in choice of roles and repertoire
44 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
and the writing of plays with the creation of institutions to promote acceptance of the theatre. As Richard Foulkes puts it, the drive to develop theatre into ‘a common culture for all sections of society’69 demonstrates the extent to which Ruskinian ideas on art in general and the theatre in particular had influenced the culture.
3 E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
John Ruskin himself had limited direct personal input into the staging of plays. So who acted as the conduit for Ruskin’s ideas about the theatre and actual theatre practice? The prime candidate must be Edward William Godwin, the man Oscar Wilde dubbed ‘one of the most artistic spirits of this century in England’.1 E.W. Godwin was an architect, archaeologist, antiquarian, furniture designer, textile and wallpaper designer and drama critic. He was to have significant influence on thinking about stage production. Moelwyn Merchant in his seminal work Shakespeare and the Artist (1959) called him ‘the most considerable figure in theatre design in the latter half of the (nineteenth) century’.2 What is extraordinary is that despite his multifarious achievements, there is still only one single-authored biography of this remarkable man, The Conscious Stone by Dudley Harbron, published as long ago as 1949, though the neglect has been partially remedied by a handsomely produced volume of essays on the various aspects of his work, edited by Susan Soros and published in 1999.3 Born in Bristol in 1833, Godwin trained as an architect but was from the first a devotee of the theatre, a regular patron of the Theatre Royal, Bristol, whose productions he reviewed anonymously and without payment for the Western Daily Press during the period 1862–4. Like Ruskin, he was devoted to both Scott and Shakespeare, memorising large chunks of the latter. In 1858 he read Ruskin’s Seven Lamps of Architecture and The Stones of Venice and experienced an instant conversion. When he won the commission to design Northampton Town Hall, he applied Ruskin’s interpretation of the Gothic and declared that the completed building was ‘entirely founded upon the Stones of Venice’.4 During the work, he received several letters of advice from Ruskin, employed a master mason who had studied Ruskin and received a letter of congratulation from Ruskin upon its completion. But his Ruskinian architectural career was far from plain sailing. Although he won the competition for designs for Bristol Assize Court and Leicester Town Hall and encomiums from fellow architects, they were rejected by 45
46 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
the city fathers and other architects employed instead. He was, however, successful in executing his designs for Congleton Town Hall and Plymouth Guildhall. There is an apparent problem in claiming Godwin as a thorough-going Ruskinian. In a lecture on his career to a group of young architects in Manchester in 1875, he recounted his conversion to Ruskin in 1858 but then claimed an unconversion around 1864 when he abandoned Ruskin’s ideas on the Gothic to follow a new path, which led eventually to the Aesthetic movement, the Queen Anne style and the creative eclecticism of later Victorian architecture. Historians have taken this account at face value and claimed that Godwin went over from Ruskin to the Aesthetes, a defection symbolised by his siding with his friend Whistler against Ruskin in the famous Ruskin-Whistler libel case in 1878. In that same year Godwin began a note in the British Architect (15 February 1878) with the question ‘Is Mr Ruskin Living Too Long?’. But that note is a criticism of a letter to the press by Ruskin on the current trade depression, saying that Ruskin knows nothing about the laws and conditions of trade. Elsewhere he defends Ruskin’s architectural criticism against Philistine attack and sees it as constructive for the profession. He adopted a moral position on some art forms, denouncing the prevalence of burlesque in the modern theatre as frivolous and degrading, eclipsing ‘the dignity and beauty of art’, but excepting Gilbert and Sullivan (‘wholly admirable’) and declaring his dislike for paintings which depicted bucolic realism: ‘I do not myself care much for cottage interiors, farm yards, agricultural labourers and the like; nor do I think that the tendency in modern times to paint sad subjects (sometimes in very sad colours too) is a wholesome tendency.’5 In an important revisionist article, Aileen Reid persuasively maintains that, contrary to what he said in his 1875 lecture, Godwin actually remained a Ruskinian to the end.6 He was employing Ruskinian arguments in his debates with the classicists in the 1860s and 1870s. In his architectural journalism, he continued to advocate the importance of a moral basis for design, so that, despite his move away from strict Gothic towards a more free-flowing Aestheticism, he remained committed to the Ruskinian concept of theoria, the grounding of the appreciation of beauty on a moral foundation rather than the ‘art for art’s sake’, morality-free, senses-based Aesthesis embraced by, for instance, Oscar Wilde. Wilde did move from disciple of Ruskin to out-and-out Aesthete, ‘a departure’ as Wilde himself put it, ‘definite and different and decisive from Ruskin’s gospel’.7 Edward Gordon Craig testified to the influence of Ruskin on both of his parents, Edward Godwin and Ellen Terry, in his autobiography. He recalled his own passion for reading Ruskin when he was a teenager: Yes, the books of Ruskin appealed to me, I don’t know why […] I suppose my mother favoured him as good for me and she was quite right. I suppose
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
47
she somehow conveyed pleasure to me without going into the question why his work was so excellent and what it was about. But my father had read Ruskin to her and he, of course, had well understood the great books. And so it was a happiness to my mother – now that my father was no longer able to be near by – to see this happening to me and hear me chattering about Ruskin – slight link as it was to E.W.G.8 One of the reasons for Godwin’s comparative neglect is that although he was a prolific author of articles, reviews and lectures, he produced no great series of books on his artistic philosophy, as Ruskin did. Juliet Kinchin and Paul Stirton have sought to remedy that situation by distilling his philosophy from the full range of his writings in an extensive and handsomely produced selection of extracts. What comes through very clearly in his writing on all manner of subjects is a world-view that the Germans would call Gesamtkunstwerk and what we might describe in English as a holistic philosophy of the arts, in which whether he is writing about buildings, furniture, clothes or plays, the same ideas predominate: the deployment of colour, light and space in harmony, balance, proportion and appropriateness, and the essential unity of all the arts in the creation of great art-work. In his own chosen profession of architecture, he was calling as early as 1863 for a unified approach to the ‘sister arts’ of painting, sculpture and architecture. In his advice to young architects, he called upon them to visit the theatre, the circus, the art gallery, the sanitary exhibition and ecclesiastical functions, as all art was the product of interconnectedness. He advocated the study of archaeology as a progressive force, providing inspiration and education. He did not favour straightforward imitation or ‘superficial skimming’ of the past, but a comprehensive study of all the architectural styles of past ages in search of a personal style. This was in effect a manifesto for the creative eclecticism which came to characterise High Victorian architecture. He continually invoked other art forms when writing about specific works, for example describing Scott’s St Pancras Station, Street’s Law Courts and Waterhouse’s Natural History Museum as ‘frozen music’ and talking about E.G. Gregory’s painting Dawn in terms of its mise-en-scène and stage management. He constantly attacked the leaders of his own architectural profession for failing to provide leadership in the terms which Godwin required to confirm the position of the architect as an artist. He denounced commercialisation, repetitiveness and the desire for respectability as stultifying forces in the profession. He called on the Royal Academy, which consistently favoured painting, to promote a union of the arts of painting, sculpture and architecture. He attacked what he saw as the under-valuation of sculpture in Victorian society and the perpetual interference of customers and patrons in the activities of architects, who he saw as the creative spirits who should combine building, design and decoration in their commissions.
48 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
There were two areas in which he was able to give practical expression to his holistic approach: artists’ houses and the stage. There was a trend for artists to have their houses specially designed and purpose built, and these houses attracted high profile coverage in the press. It began with the building of Leighton House, the home of Sir Frederic Leighton, in Holland Park Road and it continued with Godwin designing and decorating houses for himself, Whistler, Frank Miles and Archibald Stuart Wortley, which excited considerable interest and controversy, and further opportunity for an exposition of Godwin’s views. He was responsible not just for building the houses but designing furniture, curtains, wallpaper, carpets and so forth as part of a harmonious artistic whole.9 It may have been the frustration of having his superb designs for public buildings so regularly rejected that led Godwin to turn from architecture to his other great love, the theatre, in a way which can be described as Ruskinian – using theatre to educate the public. In 1875 he called theatre ‘at once the most evanescent and the most comprehensive of any possible union of the arts. It is only in the theatre that we see (or, rather, might see) the noblest results of civilisation. Poetry, music, architecture, painting, sculpture, meet in undisturbed harmony’.10 He expanded on this in 1880, writing: Certainly nothing would tend more to a refined and artistic enjoyment of life than completeness in dramatic representations. It is not enough to have good writing, or one or two first-rate actors, or merely picturesque scenery and dresses […] Art demands on the stage nothing less than allround completeness. The language must be good; all the actors, to the remotest ‘super’, must be intelligent; their costume must have in it nothing to dispel illusion even to the most accomplished archaeologist; the scenery must never be less excellent and true than Mr Bancroft’s scenery in his production of ‘The Merchant of Venice’, the properties should look genuine to the front row of the stalls; and the stage-management should always be in the hands of a quick-witted, cultured man.11 E.W Godwin’s theatre reviews for the Western Daily Press in 1862–4 set out his philosophy of theatre robustly. Reviewing the latest offering at the Bristol Theatre Royal, Laid Up in Port (‘I hope […] that the introduction of such bloodand-murder tomfoolery was more an accident than a design’), he argued: The theatre is, or ought to be, a school, not to play down to low and narrow desires, but to lift us up from the confined circles of our daily life, that our sympathies may become enlarged, that our hearts may feed awhile on the poetry of humanity as we take our two or three hours’ rest from the wearing thoughts of money making.12 This is a statement directly echoing Ruskin and prefiguring Irving.
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
49
He actually quoted Ruskin in support of his argument when making a plea for the moral elevation of the stage in a review of The Robber’s Wife, which he found as ‘devoid of amusement as it is of instruction’. The use of the word ‘instruction’ is itself instructive, as he evidently saw that as the objective of stage performance. He conceded that it was ‘impossible […] for the management of a provincial theatre to raise the art, which ministers also to our instruction if he is to be left alone, and without that moral support which can be given only by the educated’. He went on: ‘I am not one of those who would deprive the poor or the uneducated of their enjoyment, far from it.’ He saw the role of theatre as ‘infusing some beauty and some good into the lifeless, monotonous, heavy atmosphere which involves so many labourers in populous cities, and which of necessity drives them to seek enjoyment, and rest, and freedom, falsely persuading themselves […] that they are to be found in unrestrained looseness and wild excitement’. If the manager is to draw back to the theatre ‘the great support of the better educated amongst us – the scholar, the clergy, the literary man, the scientific and the artistic’, he must avoid ‘anything of doubtful character’, for example, ‘the loose moralities of French plays, or […] the low ruffianism of the lowest type of humanity’.13 He is constantly urging James Henry Chute, the manager of the Theatre Royal, Bristol, to put on more elevated and elevating material. He called upon theatres to establish their own libraries of reference works, to instruct young actors in pronunciation and to acquire works of antiquarianism and archaeology ‘to decide as to the less familiar costumes and scenery’.14 While he gave detailed analyses of the acting, he returned again and again to the questions of authenticity of scenery and costume. Of a production of Richard III at the Theatre Royal, Bristol, he wrote: I shall pass by the costume (only 800 years wrong!) with the two remarks that chain, mail, or scale or ring armour being introduced made Richard’s reference to the armourer at his work simple nonsense, whilst Richmond ought to have been ashamed of himself for wearing a fashionable helmet, with a suit of mail that must have belonged to the father of his great-great-grandmother…I cannot but think it would have been wiser if Miss Cleveland had denied herself crinoline – bad enough as a modern fashion, irredeemably vulgar when forced upon a graceful fashion of the past.15 Of a production of Romeo and Juliet there he said: Is it quite hopeless to expect anything in the way of decent scenery and dresses upon the Bristol stage? On Juliet and Romeo we had sleeves of the period of Edward III, and bodice of a century or two later, with a scolloped hat and feather of no period at all. The nurse was in costume
50 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
two centuries later even than the time of Shakespeare himself! Lawrence, the Franciscan or grey friar, appeared in a costume compounded of the Benedictine and the Geneva gown!16 Of the 1864 Hamlet he complained: ‘A tall feather, black kid gloves and lace ruffles are not by any means in harmony with the Danish fashion which prevailed in the time of Claudius, King of Denmark.’17 He applied the same strictures to the scenery as to the costumes. Of an 1862 production of Romeo and Juliet at the Theatre Royal, Bristol, he complained that the balcony scene would have been ‘of double value if the balcony itself had been a pierced or open one instead of a solid terracelike wall’, that Friar Lawrence’s cell looked like Peterborough Cathedral and the Apothecary’s shop a Tudor mansion.18 Venturing to London, he dismissed Charles Fechter’s much-praised Hamlet at the Lyceum as a collection of gimmicks: ‘A long flaxen wig, a dark tunic, with a 13th century border, and a colloquialism which is as mannered and conventional as the declamatory style of the old school.’ He declared the company ‘effete’ apart from John Brougham’s Polonius and Kate Terry’s Ophelia (‘I should have preferred less hysterics’). But he railed against the setting: ‘If the scenery, costumes and general appointments of the play be so far from correct, so full of false representation to some – I say false because ignorance on such things now-a-day is no justifiable plea – so replete with confusion to others, and so wearyingly offensive to the Shakespearian student, what words can describe the acting?’ He complained that the architecture, processions, court manners, dress and swords derived from the thirteenth century, in particular the court of Henry III, whereas the play is set in the period before the Norman Conquest. Elsinore Castle was ‘a much magnified Edwardian castle’, a Room of State in the Castle ‘Mr Telbin’s version of Canterbury Cathedral’ and a more remote part of the platform ‘looks very like a sea beach, with a few blasted pines’.19 Of the 1864 Bristol Romeo and Juliet, with Kate Terry as Juliet, he complained: The scenery as of old – not the slightest attempt to improve in this any more than in the costume. As to the ‘properties’, the modern candlesticks, the 19th century toilet table, the bed, the chairs – well, I have seen better in a booth at Henley-upon-Thames. Surely, if Romeo and Juliet is worth acting at all, it is worth some expenditure on the part of the manager.20 Reviewing the Drury Lane production of Cymbeline, he thought that only three of the cast (Samuel Phelps as Posthumus, Helen Faucit as Imogen and Mr Rayner as Cymbeline) ‘seemed to have the smallest notion of what they
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
51
were supposed to be doing’. The rest of the cast were ‘stagy, wearisome, and, at times, offensive’. The scenery was ‘disgraceful’. A chamber in the Palace was ‘like the octagonal lobby […] of the present Houses of Parliament’ and the bedstead of a British Princess ‘a modern French lace-bedecked tentshaped apparatus placed in the middle of the room’. The Romans were dressed ‘à la Octavius Caesar’. The Britons were dressed as Anglo-Saxons and the King’s son in fourteenth century costume with a chain like the modern collar of the Order of the Garter.21 He did not confine his complaints to Shakespearean production, extending them to pantomime and burlesque, of which, like Ruskin, he was apparently a devotee at this period. Declaring ‘the scenery is never out of place in burlesque or pantomime’, he heaped praise on the burlesque Perseus and Andromeda: If managers would take note that the greater truth they can give in their scenic representations of nature or art, the better pleased the public are, and act thereon, we should not be worried out of our proprieties as we often are […] by unmeaning anachronisms in scenery. He singled out two scenes for special praise: the Athenian effect in the first scene and the sunlit scene on the sea-shore where Andromeda was discovered bound to a rock: ‘these two scenes are worth all the money […] we must not grumble if the others fall short.’ However, there was something else which earned his unqualified approval – the statue scene: The group was very powerful, and the effect of white marble could not have been surpassed; but, what was best of all, these statues exhibited the classic learning of the spirited manager in no small measure, and assure us that he is not unacquainted with the Duke of Serradifalco, Professor Cockerell-Gibson, and others, for a close observer could detect traces of colour in the shaded side of the statues, as for instance occasional red on the thigh and blue in out of the way places.22 Then of the pantomime Cinderella being given at the Theatre Royal for Christmas 1862/3, he suggested that of the 15 or 16 scenes, 3 were worth going to see more than once: a corridor in the palace ‘not only brilliantly painted but what is more valuable, because more rare […] a very fair study of the Court of the Lions, Casa Real de la Alhambra’, Bristol bridge and bridgehouse ‘particularly happy’ and the exterior of the Baron’s house.23 Visiting the London pantomimes, he found the transformation scene in Covent Garden’s Beauty and the Beast ‘very pretty’ but ‘the other scenery altogether unworthy of London or any other place’, Astley’s Lady Bird or Harlequin Lord Dundreary ‘a mistake from beginning to end […] The scenery
52 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
is coarse in the last degree’. But he lavished praise on Riquet with the Tuft at the Princess’s Theatre, calling it ‘a true pantomime’: The wild dance of the witches’ brooms in the opening scene, the flying off of the two witches on the broomstick, their arrival in the Country of Mushrooms, the development of the mushroom crop, slowly rising into a mushroom forest, the discovery of the sleeping army within and beneath them, the wild war dance, and the busy cooking scene are all just what they should be – the one kind funny without being ugly, the other beautiful without being tame. The ballet dances were well arranged and admirably danced; but, like most dance, there was too much of it. The great feature, however, at the Princess’s is Mr Beverley’s scenery; with one exception […] there is no fault to be found. The interlaced and twisted and knotted, wintry, wild, and weird-looking branches, stretching the whole width of the stage, were natural and highly effective, while the scenes themselves are pictures well worth special visits.24 The educational imperative lying behind his pronouncements was underlined by his denunciation of the ‘higgledy piggledy’ costuming of a production of The Merchant of Venice in Bristol: I maintain that we do not go to the theatre simply to hear passionate recitations and funny speeches, but to witness such a performance as will place us as nearly as possible in the position of spectators of the original scene or the thing represented, and so gain information of men, manners, customs, and countries – and this result is only attainable where accuracy in every particular is secured.25 Without this being the case, he felt people might just as well stay at home and read the text. From the mid-1870s, Godwin published prolifically in The Architect, Building News and the British Architect, of which he became London editor in 1878. Theatre was a regular theme of his writing. Writing in Building News (19 March 1875), he recalled that ten years previously he had published jottings on the acting, scenery, properties, costume and the management of ‘two of our chief provincial theatres’ (the Theatre Royal, Bristol and the Theatre Royal, Bath). But he added ‘And now, after the lapse of a decade, I do not hesitate to say that, so far from any art progress having been made in theatrical matters, the chief London theatres of to-day are wholly below the standard attained in those two provincial theatres’. His mission was to raise the artistic level of the theatre and he preached tirelessly his gospel of theatre art. He began his campaign by calling for an improvement in the deplorable conditions backstage in most theatres: the cramped, filthy, unventilated and insanitary dressing rooms, workshops, green room,
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
53
scene dock. A second article (18 June 1875) attacked the conservatism and stagnation of theatre design and called for a renaissance in theatre architecture. A third article, prompted by a theatre fire in Vienna (27 January 1882), proposed a series of measures to prevent theatre fires in British theatres. They related to the planning of the building, the materials used for building, means of lighting and style of management. He recommended the inclusion of distinct entrances for each part of the house and ample staircases for each level, the employment of brick, terra-cotta or cement rather than wood and other flammable materials, electric rather than gas lighting and a management that was constantly present on the premises and concerned with the safety and comfort of the audience. The British Architect became the principal vehicle for his criticism of current theatrical practice. He nailed his colours to the mast in a trenchant article called ‘Scenic Art’ (28 November 1879), in which he attacked the current level of scene painting and the over-dressing of the stage with properties: To a certain extent, no doubt, artistic tastes, and even what modern slang calls ‘aestheticism’ are gratified by a show of carved chairs, damask stuffs, and embossed brass work; but such additions to the completeness of stage decoration do not increase the talents of an artist, or call into play more than the taste to choose handsome materials and the will to purchase them. We speak of scenic art as the absolute painting employed on the canvas, which is to show forth, with more or less illusory force, landscapes, with all the perspective of air and outline, or interiors with their marble or wood illusions and carved ornamentation. The upholsterer is killing the artist. He praised the work of master scene painters turned artists, David Roberts and Clarkson Stanfield, whose back-cloths were ‘a monument of scenic talent and puissant effect, with its stereoscopic reliefs and subdued chiaroscuro’. He advocated their revival as a lesson to living scene painters. He admits that ‘we have some excellent scene-painters’, as is demonstrated by Irving’s production of The Merchant of Venice at the Lyceum: The first scene of the Quays of Venice and the Piazza St Mark, by WILLIAM TELBIN the younger, is a worthy example of scene painting. Correct in perspective, and a faithful copy of nature, probably painted from sketches made on the spot, […] there is a brilliancy of atmospheric effect, from the boats and their sails in the foreground wings to the luminous clouds which roll over the far sky, that is too seldom seen on our stage now-a-days […] Mr. WALTER HANN is making great progress. There is a front cloth representing a side canal on Venice, which might have been painted by BEVERLEY. This name recalls some excellent work, and probably most of our present scenic artists have been pupils of
54 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
BEVERLEY, who has had […] a transparency of treatment and a beauty of colour not easily surpassed. But Godwin is critical of Irving’s principal scene painter, Hawes Craven: ‘with all his power, this gentleman is with difficulty persuaded to subdue his pictures.’ He goes on to make a general point about the nature of scene painting: All scenes are backgrounds to the figures in front, in whose action the interest centres. If scenery is so painted that while the action is going on, the eye is continually being called away to note details which rush into prominence, there is something wrong in the hand which produces such a result. Even in spectacular tableaux the whole should be in harmony with the parts, and yet we see continually in the criticisms that appear in the daily press, lavish praise of the veriest daubs, where perspective is conspicuous by its absence, and where reds swallow up all tone, and vulgar chromes drive harmony out of the field. The worst fault of our School of Stage Painting is ignorance – ignorance of simple rules of drawing and colour, but more than all, ignorance of all science connected with art. He recommended English scenic artists to study the work of their French counterparts: Their landscapes are dull and monotonous, their fairy scenes do not revel in brilliancy as on the English stage, but you will never find the rules of history or character violated. Their interiors, as a rule, show an accurate knowledge of the architecture and artistic accessories of the period or the style represented. The details are correct, their drawing studied, and their light and shade well harmonised; but look into the drawing of any figures or arabesques now to be seen on the London boards, and you will find bad design, mixed styles, positive ignorance of authorities, and careless modelling, if any at all. He concluded with a blast, declaring that almost all the scene painters currently at work in London ‘lack the reading and education necessary to give them knowledge, and probably are so imbued with their own individual talents that they have cut their leading string before they could walk, and are now tumbling over paint pots and brushes to the disadvantage of art, and with the result of producing the most glaring and crudest daubing ever yet dignified with the name of scenic art’.26 Thereafter he subjected new productions to minute scrutiny of their component parts. Reviewing W.G. Wills’ Ninon at the Adelphi, he declared: ‘Ninon’ is a four-act play of the period of the French Revolution, and is full of movement and dramatic force. The scenery, bar one interior, was,
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
55
as a rule, fairly good, thanks to Mr Julian Hicks. The acting throughout was careful, though slightly dragging in parts, and the dresses and properties were better than the Adelphi usually exhibits. […] The chief defect of the representation was as usual to be found in the stage management; a riotous crowd eager for blood would not turn itself into a sort of merrygo-round, nor would the noise of a revolutionary mob always be stationary, and just round the corner. To increase the volume of real sound, but subduing it by making it more and more distant, is one of the artistic things stage managers have yet to learn, and it is very easy to do, even with the rawest supers.27 In 1880 As You Like It was produced at the Imperial Theatre, with Marie Litton as Rosalind, Hermann Vezin as Jaques and Kyrle Bellew as Orlando. The costumes were designed by Johnston Forbes Robertson. The Theatre (1 April 1880) declared: Among recent Shakespearian revivals we have had none more complete and careful than this […] The costumes have been artistically and consistently designed by Mr Forbes Robertson, specially fitted for such a task by his accomplishments both as actor and artist. The scenery has been excellently planned and painted by Mr Perkins, the music well selected and superintended by Mr Barnard. But with these elements of effect I am glad to find […] evidence of thorough rehearsal, intelligent study of the text, and supervision of the stage-arrangements.28 As to the acting, Marie Litton was ‘quite one of the best Rosalinds I have seen’, Bellew’s Orlando ‘the best I remember’, but Vezin’s Jaques ‘too sad and serious and not cynical enough’. But Godwin took issue with the general praise: ‘So much had been written in the daily press about the wonderfully complete manner in which “As you like it” was put on the stage of the Imperial Theatre, that I was induced the other Saturday to submit myself to the torture of semi-suffocation for the sake of seeing the New Rosalind, and what Mr Forbes Robertson had done for the costumes.’ He was unimpressed on both counts. ‘Miss Litton in no instance reached, or even came near, either of the other Rosalinds I have seen’, which he identified as Helen Faucit and Kate Terry. There were also problems with the costumes: Unquestionably the most artistic work was Mr Vezin’s personification of Jaques. Had this actor been dressed properly, and not been given up to gauntlets, and placed under the shadow of a huge Maximilian hat, he would have been Jaques […] After Jaques comes Mr Kyrle Bellew’s Orlando – graceful, natural, poetical, and happily rightly dressed. Touchstone is well rendered by Mr Lionel Brough, but a court jester surely never wandered
56 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
through the country attired merely in his ordinary indoor motley? The Duke showed a very poor attempt to realise the furred gown of c.1490, but on one of his attendants was a fairly good costume of 1460. The six pages also represented the genuine costume of the huntsmen in an illumination of about the time of Henry VII, published by Lacroix in his ‘Manners and Customs During the Middle Ages’. These books of Lacroix, I find, are too often in the hands of young students, which is a great pity, for they overflow with error, especially in that most important detail of affixing the right date to a manuscript or illumination. However, taking one thing with another, Mr Forbes Robertson might easily have fallen into worse error than he has. Indeed, one could scarcely expect it to be otherwise. The study of costume is not the easy thing some people assume it to be; even with a dated manuscript before one, the illuminations are not always to be accepted as of the same date; often they are by more than one hand, and in more than one fashion, and sometimes they are altogether spurious.29 As an indication of the standard they should have reached, he printed his own designs for the costumes of As You Like It explaining that he dated As You Like It to the reign of King Louis XI (1461–83) and that he had copied the costumes from some ‘beautiful French MSS preserved in the British Museum’ and all of them deriving from the second half of the fifteenth century.30 The characteristics they shared were: The materials were rich, and the embroidered patterns chiefly of the net and pineapple kind, large and often beautifully worked in Venice gold. Trimmings of fur are constantly found, and a single feather is occasionally seen in the gentleman’s hat.31 When Mrs Bateman produced Romeo and Juliet at Sadler’s Wells with Isabel Bateman as Juliet and a new young actor Clifford Harrison as Romeo, Godwin praised the performances but was dismayed by the costumes. Of Romeo: ‘His costumes, though new and costly, were wholly unlike what the young Montagues of Verona wore in the time of the story, and was as far removed from what obtained in Shakspere’s time.’ Of Juliet: ‘Why cannot her dress be made like those which young ladies of Verona wore in 1300– 1310.’32 Once again, he was inspired to publish his own costume sketches for Romeo and Juliet, citing as the proper sources for a play set in the early fourteenth century the sculptures on the Ducal Palace at Venice (1301), the figures on the tomb of Aymer de Valence in Westminster (1323–6), the paintings of Giotto, Taddeo Gaddi and Orcagna, the illuminations of the Arundel Psalter, and those of the Italian manuscripts from 1300 to 1350.33 Wilson Barrett, with whom he was to enjoy his most fruitful theatrical collaboration, first came to his notice when he presented the distinguished
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
57
Polish actress Helena Modjeska in a season of plays at the Court Theatre. She made her debut in Heartsease, a new English adaptation of Alexandre Dumas Fils’ La Dame aux Camèlias, suitably cleaned up for English audiences. Godwin was enraptured: ‘It is a long time since anyone has appeared so unaffectedly natural, so pretty in her affection, so impassioned in her love as this latest histrionic embodiment of grace and art […] her impersonation was an artistic triumph from first to last.’ He declared roundly: ‘If the whole Art World in London be as grateful to Mr Wilson Barrett as I am for introducing Madame Helena Modjeska to the English stage, then the energetic lessee and manager will have of thanks a mountain heaped on him that will “make Ossa like a wart!”’ He went on to praise the production: ‘Most of her costumes are refined and beautiful, but the first cloak and the china shepherdess hat are poor; and the make of the dress in the third act, which she describes as “simple” and clothed in which she says she “skips along the fields”, should certainly not be tight and with such a train. The scenery is good with the one exception of the interior of the third act, where the curtains with their white lace trimmings are neither beautiful nor appropriate.’34 Godwin was at the Court Theatre for Modjeska’s follow-up production, an English adaptation by Hon. Lewis Wingfield of Schiller’s Mary Stuart, a favourite role of the actress. Godwin called it ‘the great theatrical event of this winter season’ and, although he had some criticisms of her performance, conceded that ‘each and every adverse judgement is swept away in the torrent of her splendidly earnest acting. Not an attitude, not a finger was out of place, and all seemed wholly unstudied. Her dignity was never overstrained, and she never looked other than the daughter of Mary of Guise’. Of the production, he reported: ‘Madame Modjeska was dressed in costly apparel, and like all the rest to a great extent right, but not yet quite right enough to produce the illusion I long to witness. Mr Wilson Barrett deserves to be congratulated on the whole production, and especially on the scenery and most of the furniture […] Perhaps the window in the Westminster Palace mars it a little, the imitation of stained glass being very weak.’35 But Romeo and Juliet, which opened on 26 March 1881, with Modjeska as Juliet, Forbes Robertson as Romeo and Wilson Barrett as Mercutio, roused his ire: We all know by this, that the time of the action belongs to the first years of the 14th century […]; but at the Court Theatre we are introduced to the folk of Verona as they appeared in the second half of the 15th century – for what reason does not appear. We would wish that Romeo would dispense with his white drapery, not that we object to drapery, but the raw whiteness of it makes all Verona dull. The nurse, too, might have secured a more becoming attire, and Tybalt’s wardrobe should have been a trifle handsomer. With the exception of Mr Cooper (Capulet), all were fairly
58 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
fitted to their parts, and the play was full of intelligent readings and lively action.36 Even the Lyceum productions of Henry Irving, universally praised for their beauty and accuracy, prompted critical comment from Godwin. Of W.G. Wills’ Iolanthe, Godwin declared ‘there can be no question that Mr Irving has produced a charming and picturesque ensemble’. But noting that King René of Naples, Sicily and Jerusalem, who figures in the story, lived from 1409 to 1480, he regrets that ‘every feature that bears on the past should recall not Iolanthe’s world but her grandmother’s’. Tristan’s costume is ‘so scalloped on edge of jupon, hood and trailing sleeve that it tells us not merely of a different time, but of a different character – of the court fop rather than the brave knight’. He even complains about Craven’s scene painting: ‘Mr Craven ought […] to know that the flower beds in the fifteenth century garden had a very distinct character of their own, and were not level with the lawn or pathways’. He concludes: ‘Had the mise-en-scène been as perfect as most of the acting, it would have been good indeed.’37 He also dissented from the general verdict on The Cup which was universally praised for its archaeological accuracy and aesthetic beauty. ‘The mounting of Mr Tennyson’s classical play “The Cup” […] is not quite all some of our contemporaries would have us believe.’ He thought the temple of Artemis was laid out more like the tabernacle of the Jews than a Greek temple, with the altar, statue and entrance all in the wrong position. The stunted Ionic columns with bas-reliefs at the base were a contradiction. There was, however, praise for the first scene, ‘Distant View of a City in Galatia’, ‘painted in Mr Telbin’s best manner, and planned with admirable skill’. He admitted to ‘partial praise’ for the costumes: Camma appropriately and convincingly Greek, but Irving’s Synorix looking like ‘an African refugee of the period’.38 Godwin shared the general enthusiasm for the visit of the Meiningen Court Players, whose London season was retrospectively deemed so influential on British theatre practice: ‘Julius Caesar […] was certainly put before us in a manner so thoroughly artistic as to invite the closest attention and the most careful criticism […] the stage management and the lighting arrangements were of the highest order of excellence […] we have seen nothing on the stage during the past thirty years that could compare for energy and realism with the Roman populace that filled the processional scenes.’ However, the play fell down in the area of authenticity: The architectural scenery was admirably painted, and nothing in this country has been done with anything like the artistic vigour and detailed care bestowed by the scene painters on the public place that served for the whole of Act I, and the senate scene, Act 3. But it is as scene painting and as scenic work that we admire them and not for their archaeology
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
59
or history, for the Rome presented to us […] is not the Rome of the Commonwealth, as Julius Caesar saw it […] Classic Rome, as we use the phrase, did not exist and did not even begin to be reared until the comparatively peaceful days of Augustus. The Rome of the time of Julius was a crowded town, chiefly built of brick, tufa, and wood […] What the Meiningen management gave us was far more like the grand marblebuilt, many pillared city of the Flavian dynasty, that commenced more than a century after the date of the play. He found the same fault with the costumes. The crowd was too well-dressed. The senators were pleasingly clad in simple white togas but again they really recalled the days of the Empire rather than the Republic. But leaving these objections aside, he concluded that ‘never before has a great spectacular tragedy, like this of “Julius Caesar” been put on the stage with such complete earnestness […] For with the Meiningen Company their stage work results emphatically in pictures, as if painted by one master hand, the general form, action and colour of which are always good, leaving – nearly always – nothing to be desired’. He earnestly hoped that the visit would leave its mark on the English stage and encourage it to produce plays in the same way.39 Godwin applied his archaeological principles to the study of dress. In a lecture of 1868, Godwin asked the question: ‘What has Dress to do with the study of Architecture and Archaeology?’ and answered by arguing that the study of dress was as much the business of architects as the study of animal and vegetable life.40 He suggested that there were two systems of dress: the historical (the past) and the conventional (the present). The past could be recovered by archaeology but the principles thereby established might help to lift the conventions of the present to the level of art. He advocated rejecting the ‘arbitrary power and sole despotic sway of the French milliners and the west-end tailors’ and in Ruskinian mode declared: ‘I see no reason whatever to question the assertion that all art is the expression of man’s delight in God’s works.’ He praised ‘those who robe themselves in purity of colour, in simple graceful forms, subtle harmonies and delicate contrasts for their own sakes and not because “they are worn”’. He denounced the evils of modern fashion: the changeableness, the absence of colour, the wide difference between male and female fashions, the lack of discrimination. He put it down to the ‘lack of positive art instruction rather than from wilfulness of choice’. Dress, he believed, was an art form dependent on colour, form and harmony. He ended by describing the study of costume as an important branch of archaeology: Archaeology fills in the details of every picture of the past, it forges the links of the chain which binds together all time; it brings into stronger light all those great events which have contributed to build up those
60 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
blessings we now enjoy. It clothes with vivid reality all those noble ones whose figures would otherwise have had but a shadowy indistinctness in the mighty procession of the world’s issue. It tells us among many other things how the decoration of dress was once as much an art as the decoration of a temple […] It helps us to a better appreciation of the wonderful picturings of such poets as Chaucer and Dante, and illustrates every page of our early literature.41 In advocating rational, healthy and artistic dress, like other reformers, he looked to classical, medieval and Japanese styles which all allowed natural movement. He lectured on dress and its relation to health and climate at the 1884 International Health Exhibition, for which he organised a display of fashion on living models, while Lewis Wingfield organised the display of historical costumes. He argued that beauty and health went together. The counterpart to his positive advocacy of historically inspired new fashions was his intolerance of inaccuracy in the reproduction of period costume. He denounced those painters who ‘travestied and vulgarised’ historical costume, painting medieval costume which they had not taken the trouble to study. He was vitriolic about Frank Dicksee’s Othello and Desdemona for its ‘ludicrous costuming’. On the other hand he praised Sir Lawrence Alma-Tadema (‘one of the most correct painters of costume we have’) and Edwin Long’s Babylonian Marriage Market (‘unquestionably the work of an artist who has manfully striven to be right’).42 This was a very Ruskinian stance, in line with Ruskin’s regular insistence that art should neither alter nor improve Nature and should include ‘the largest possible quantity of truth’. It was his mounting annoyance at such inaccuracy that led Godwin in 1882 to set up the Costume Society. It first met on 27 July 1882 and elected Godwin its Honorary Secretary. The subtitle of the Society proclaimed its mission: ‘Society for promoting the knowledge of Costume by copying and publishing Historical Costume from Contemporary Sources only.’ Its members included painters Alma-Tadema, Luke Fildes, Marcus Stone, Sir Noel Paton, John Tenniel, actors Herbert Beerbohm Tree and Hermann Vezin and playwrights W.G. Wills, Joseph Comyns Carr and Oscar Wilde. By October 1882 it had a membership of 98 and, by May 1883, 230. The Standard (28 September 1882) welcomed its foundation: ‘It is indeed of considerable importance that accuracy of costume should be observed in pictures, statuary, and in Theatrical representations.’ It was hoped ‘that there may be an end, once and forever, to the anachronisms and anomalies of all kind in dress by which the works of artists, architects and dramatists are now so often disfigured’. The article considered that it was painters and stage costume designers who would benefit most from membership of the society. One of its aims was the publication of drawings, photographs and descriptions of historical costume from contemporary sources. Its first folio
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
61
of such illustrations appeared in May 1883. But the society was wound up in July 1884, because of financial problems and ‘the all too common burden of labour falling on the shoulders of a few enthusiasts’.43 The presence of Vezin and Tree among the members is significant, as Vezin had worked regularly with Godwin and although Tree did not enter management until after Godwin’s death, he was evidently much influenced by Godwin’s artistic philosophy. Not everyone was as welcoming of the Society as the Standard. In the January 1883 issue of Time there was an attack by A.H. Wall on the Costume Society, claiming that it was established for the purpose of ‘subordinating sentiment, feeling and true dramatic effect to a hard, bold, dry, unsympathetic regard for archaeological correctness’. He argued that the play and the actors were more important than the costume and the scenery and that Shakespeare was full of anachronisms and dressed all his characters in Tudor clothes. This was to be a regular refrain in the attacks on the advocates of archaeological accuracy. This particular attack was answered by Herbert Beerbohm Tree. Tree was a close friend of Godwin, a fellow member of the Costume Society, and met him regularly, despite the strong disapproval of his fiancée and later wife Maud Holt, who thought Godwin profoundly immoral. Writing in The Theatre, the journal in which battle was regularly joined by the proponents and opponents of the Godwin gospel, Tree declared that the object of the Society so far as the stage was concerned was ‘to aid the sentiment, the feeling and the dramatic effect by encouraging archaeological correctness’. Also the public demanded it: ‘The taste displayed by Mr Irving in his revivals at the Lyceum has undoubtedly had the effect of educating the public up to a certain standard of correctness, and who shall say that these beautiful productions do not owe something to the decided advance in the matter of costumes and general correctness.’ He pronounced Shakespeare’s anachronisms trivial and unimportant. He expressed the belief that ‘had he lived, Shakespeare would have been one of the first subscribers’ to the Costume Society.44 In his zeal for archaeological and antiquarian correctness on the stage, Godwin published 33 articles on the correct architecture and costume for each of Shakespeare’s plays in The Architect in 1874 and 1875. His aim was to correct the state of affairs he outlined in the essay on The Merry Wives of Windsor: The usual street scene of the modern stage, if it has the slightest pretension to belong to the Middle Ages, is a wonderfully elastic and convenient device. For we find it in the heart of populous cities, and we recognise the same old friend in quiet market towns and villages; to-day it serves and perhaps not altogether inappropriately, for Eastchepe in the time of HENRY IV, to-morrow it does duty at Windsor. In the summer we find it
62 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
at Venice, supporting with its picturesque gables the figures of SHYLOCK and the merchants, and in the winter the dear old scene turns up again, doing duty in Canada, perhaps as the background of some modern trash or emasculated adaptation. Considering what small amounts are demanded by the most promising, painstaking scene painters, and what enormous amounts are paid for advertisements and monster placards, it does not seem surprising that there should exist throughout the country such poverty of thought and meanness of resource in almost every instance of an architectural scene being placed on the stage. The scene painter is not to blame, his order is to paint, not, mind, a scene altogether fitted to a certain play, but a scene that will serve a manager as a sort of general servant, attempting everything and doing nothing well. I venture to say that there is not a play put on the stage which might not have complete and special scenery of its own, without incurring any extra cost above its present gross outlay, and without reducing the receipts. A play properly represented on the stage makes every spectator a living poster and a walking advertisement.45 He was unsparingly dismissive of those Shakespeare plays which could not be precisely located. He described Pericles, Prince of Tyre as a ‘drama that has not been acted for a long time, and it is devoutly to be hoped never may be acted again […] There is nothing, probably, in the whole range of dramatic writing where the unities of time and place are so persistently disregarded as in Pericles’. Although set in the reign of Antiochus the Great, ruler of Syria (223–187 B.C.), the play ‘teems with anachronisms’, among them pistols, stringed viols, tennis courts, bellows, parish churches, beadles, tournaments, a Spaniard in a ruff and a French knight.46 He was much happier with a play like The Merchant of Venice which he could date precisely to 1590 and ‘with the paintings and prints in our public galleries and the materials of South Kensington to refer to, error in the costume of The Merchant of Venice would be quite inexcusable, for it must arise either from sheer carelessness or childish incompetency to handle the facts’. He even gave advice on how the actors should move and stand in order to conform to the practice of the period in which ‘the manners of the period were characterised by courtesy combined with a stately dignified action, and that what we call stiffness of manner was then regarded as quite the correct thing. But modern actors and actresses rarely hold the mirror high enough to reflect the mien, deportment or bearing of the men and women of a past age. The air or look of gentlemen and ladies during the great period of the Renaissance can be ascertained from the documents and the pictures of the time, and if an actor fails to reproduce it he is not fitted to play in the comedies of the great dramatist of that period. Correctness of costume, and scenery, and properties, and furniture is all very well, but if, through it all, we see nineteenth-century action, modern style […] then
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
63
the picture must be discordant and the dramatic representation woefully incomplete’.47 Godwin’s final grand statement about the importance of stage archaeology came in a series of seven articles he wrote for the Dramatic Review in 1885, in which he stressed the necessity for the stage archaeologist to be at the same time an artist: Archaeology means, literally, the word about old things. The application of the sound principles of induction to the study of the things of the past has resulted in our day in raising this study to the dignity of a science. A science that clothes and reanimates the dead, and gives colour to the pale, shadowy forms of forgotten folk. The purpose of the archaeologist is to bring before us those old times, to make history a reality. That is his purpose as touching the realities of life. The stage demands of the antiquary something more than this. Stage pictures of the past times should be treated pari passu as life itself is treated by the dramatist. The archaeologist, in a word, must be an artist, endowed with the sense of form and colour, having constructiveness well developed and in sympathy with the dramatic purpose. He made a clear distinction between the kinds of plays and the archaeological treatment they required: It follows that plays which run closely parallel to the life of the period of the action, as in society comedies, whether of the 18th or any other century, must be treated by the archaeologist with far greater accuracy of detail than romantic dramas in blank verse, or plays of high poetical value, for such comedies deal as a rule, very largely, with manners and customs and these are much more intimately connected with the costume and external than some people imagine. On the other hand, the higher poetical drama represented by Shakespeare demands, first of all, for its costume, scenery and properties, artistic treatment. If the science of archaeology supplies us with the materials of bygone time that seems in harmony with the plot of the drama or the intention of the poet, the artist cannot do better than accept them as the foundation of his work. And should the materials happen to belong to a period of considerable art culture, as in the classic times of Pericles, or the medieval days of Henry III, then it might perhaps be as well for him to take heed how little he alters one or the other to meet managerial views of any exigency of the stage.48 He also drew attention to: ‘The great difficulty which the archaeologist and artist have to encounter in the mounting of any historical play is in what is called the taste of certain actors and actresses on the subject of dress. If the
64 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
company should happen to include in its number one who can produce a clever sketch, it is specially unfortunate for the mounting, and no costume play will be completely well done until the manager puts his foot down firmly on all interference of any kind whatsoever with the artist-antiquary who is responsible for the designs. The leading actress is often the greatest blot on the picture.’49 So much for Godwin’s gospel. But he had a more personal connection with the theatre than simply as reviewer and theorist. His theatregoing in Bristol had led him to make the acquaintance in 1862 of the 15 year old actress Ellen Terry, who was appearing in repertory in Bristol.50 In 1864 Ellen (only 16) married the 46 year old painter G.F. Watts. After ten months the marriage broke down and they separated. They were not divorced until 1877. In 1867 Ellen met Godwin again and embarked on an affair with him. In 1868 they eloped together and lived in the country for six years. They never married but she produced two children, Edy and Edward Gordon Craig. Ellen had abandoned the stage at the time of the elopement but poverty forced her to resume her stage career in 1874 and the relationship with Godwin ended. Godwin promptly married his pupil Beatrice Philip. But it was the relationship with Ellen that led directly to Godwin’s first involvement with the theatre. The Bancrofts, Squire and Marie, were the actor-manager team who ran the Prince of Wales’s Theatre in Charlotte Street. In 1875 they decided to mount a production of The Merchant of Venice, casting Ellen Terry as Portia and Charles Coghlan as Shylock. Why did the Bancrofts, who had made their name with the series of Tom Robertson’s ‘cup and saucer’ comedies and latterly revivals of classic comedies, Bulwer-Lytton’s Money and Sheridan’s The School for Scandal, opt for a Shakespeare play and in particular The Merchant of Venice? It was one of the best known and most popular of Shakespeare’s plays. It was also one of the most frequently painted: 150 canvases of scenes from the play are recorded for the nineteenth century. Linda Rozmovits calls it ‘a late Victorian popular obsession’, its relevance attributable to three burning issues of the period; mass education, the woman question and the Jewish issue. Following the passing of the 1870 Education Act, it became an important feature in the teaching of English.51 Over 60 school editions of The Merchant were published between 1870 and 1920. It was valued because it was both accessible and morally instructive. The characters of Portia and Shylock became the centre of cultural debate on the proper role of women in society, the presence of the Jews and the question of ‘Jewish usury’. There was also a new vogue for Shakespeare productions in London, sparked by the unprecedented success of Henry Irving’s production of Hamlet at the Lyceum. The Illustrated Sporting and Dramatic News (17 April 1875), noting the opening of The Merchant, observed: ‘It is a significant indication of the revival of a more elevated taste on the part of the public for the legitimate drama that Shakspeare’s plays [sic] are now being represented at and drawing full houses to four of the metropolitan theatres – Hamlet at
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
65
the Lyceum, The Tempest at the Gaiety, Hamlet and Othello at the Surrey; and Othello, with Signor Salvini and his Italian company, on the off nights of the opera at Drury Lane […] At the Crystal Palace, too, Shakspeare’s […] plays, excellently cast, and produced under the direction of Mr Charles Wyndham, have drawn full and appreciating audiences.’ But there was another attraction – Venice. Bancroft revealed that his two favourite Shakespeare plays were The Merchant of Venice and Othello, both plays with Venetian settings.52 But Venice was also something of an obsession for the late Victorian middle and upper classes. ‘All wonder, enchantment […] brightness and the glory of a dream’ said the novelist Margaret Oliphant of Venice.53 Celebrated by Byron, Turner and, above all, Ruskin, Venice was seen as one of the architectural wonders of the world, the quintessence of Gothic and the place where the three great architectural styles, Roman, Lombard and Arab, achieved reconciliation. But Venice was also seen as an analogue of the British Empire, at once an idealised mercantile and maritime republic, proto-Protestant, public spirited and visually splendid, both an ideal and a warning of decay and fall if the dominant values are lost. Travellers to Venice, their numbers increasing in the age of Thomas Cook, clutched and consulted their Stones of Venice as they inspected and marvelled at the architectural glories of what was in essence a preserved heritage site.54 As John Pemble remarks: ‘Those too poor to go to Venice now had Venice brought to them. Venice reconstructed on the stage dazzled theatrical London. For the price of a seat in the gallery you could buy the illusion of travel.’ He points to Henry Irving’s 1879 The Merchant of Venice with its authentic scenery and costumes, and Imre Kiralfy’s spectacular recreation of Venice in his 1892 exhibition ‘Venice – the Bride of the Sea’ at Olympia. But he recognised the Bancrofts’ 1875 production as the first of these theatrical experiences.55 Not surprisingly then, William Kleb in his account of the production notes that ‘To insure absolute realism, the Bancrofts […] took Ruskin’s admonition to “go to Nature” seriously, and, during September 1874, went to Venice’.56 As part of the pursuit of authenticity, Godwin was engaged as archaeological adviser. This was to provoke controversy later, when Edward Gordon Craig, Godwin’s son, writing in 1908, claimed that his father had produced the play. The Bancrofts, infuriated, added a sentence to the 1909 edition of their joint autobiography, writing ‘The scenic artists also consulted a great authority, E. W. Godwin, who kindly gave them valuable archaeological help, which was acknowledged at Gordon’s wish, in the programmes. To attribute further assistance in the production to Mr Godwin is an error’.57 The Gordon is George Gordon, the senior scene painter who with William Harford provided the highly praised views of Venice shown between the acts – the campanile of St Mark’s, the Rialto and the Grand Canal – as well as the sets themselves. There is no doubt that Squire Bancroft himself prepared the text used and that Gordon and Harford painted the scenery, but Gordon evidently followed Godwin’s
66 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
advice about what to see and which artists to study when he paid a research trip to Venice ahead of the production.58 Godwin had set out his views on the architecture and costuming of The Merchant of Venice in two lengthy articles in The Architect (27 March 1875 and 3 April 1875), articles which Moelwyn Merchant thought the finest of his series of Shakespeare articles.59 They undoubtedly contain the information that Godwin furnished to Gordon. Godwin concluded that no more than five scenes were needed for the action (a street, before Shylock’s house, the court of justice, a hall and a garden), but that these could be performed in three sets, which he illustrated in precisely constructed diagrams. He reminded prospective scene painters that Venice was neither a city of palaces nor of ruins and that three styles – Byzantine, Gothic and Renaissance – prevailed in the architecture in 1590, the date he had decided was the most appropriate for the action of the play. He described the buildings, the materials used, the style of decoration, the furniture and fittings, citing Ruskin’s The Stones of Venice in support of his descriptions at one point. For the costumes, he recommended as a basic text a work dated 1589, Habiti Antichi et Moderni di tutto il Mondo. Di Cesare Vecellio, 81 pages of which were devoted to Venetian costume: ‘with this book in one’s hand, the paintings and prints in our public galleries and the materials at South Kensington to refer to, error in the costume of The Merchant of Venice would be quite inexcusable, for it must arise either from sheer carelessness or childish incompetency to handle the facts.’60 The painters he recommended studying alongside the book were Tintoretto, Bassano, Zelotti and Veronese. Evidently anxious to distance themselves from Godwin, the Bancrofts in their autobiography stressed their involvement in the visuals. They had travelled to Venice, met Gordon and while there ‘We bought many books, made many drawings, we were satiated with Titian and Veronese, we bought many photographs and copies of their gorgeous pictures to guide our costumes’. They also selected the Court of Justice, the Sala della Bussola in the Doge’s Palace as the most convenient for reproduction on their stage, rather than the Sala del Maggior Consiglio and the Sala della Scrutinio, which Godwin recommended. Bancroft, in his acting text, divided the play into seven scenes, requiring five major sets, again contrary to Godwin.61 In a letter to The Times (23 April 1875) which had attributed the costumes to his archaeological research, Godwin disclaimed responsibility for the costumes, though he does seem to have designed Ellen Terry’s.62 But this response may have been a reaction to the review in the Building News (23 April 1875) which, recognising Vecchio’s Book of Costume (Godwin’s recommended text) as the source for the costumes, nevertheless detailed the ‘petty incongruities’ that undermined the strict accuracy Godwin would have required. Whatever they may have disagreed about, the Bancrofts certainly followed the Godwin gospel of archaeological and historical authenticity and the
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
67
Ruskinian demand for truth to Nature. The Bancrofts wrote: ‘The utmost realism was attained. Elaborate capitals of enormous weight, absolute reproductions of those which crown the pillars of the colonnade of the Doge’s Palace, were cast in plaster and part of a wall of the theatre had to be cut away to find room for them to be moved, by means of trucks, on and off the small stage.’63 The play opened on 17 April 1875. Along with the historical accuracy, the play met another of the Ruskinian imperatives – education. After the play closed, James Spedding, the eminent Shakespearian scholar, wrote a lengthy article in Fraser’s Magazine, deeply regretting the withdrawal of the production and praising its outstanding educational value.64 He wrote of the Bancrofts: They set it forth with scenery, costume, grouping, and general pictorial effect equal to anything of the kind that has been produced in these times, when the arts of decoration have been so much studied. They took great pains both with the dialogue and the action, in all the parts, and in the minutest particulars. He lamented too the disappearance from the stage of Ellen Terry’s Portia: ‘it will be difficult to find another part so well suited to the exercise of Miss Terry’s peculiar gifts, and impossible to find another actress so well qualified to represent one of the most delightful of Shakespeare’s female creations.’65 The bid for realism was recognised by leading critic Dutton Cook of the Pall Mall Gazette, who praised ‘the pictures, at once brilliant and careful, of Venetian life in the sixteenth century, which occupy the stage. Mr Gordon’s scenery is so admirably painted and contrived that the small space at the command of the performers is never perceived as a defect; the costumes and accessories are remarkable for their picturesqueness not less than for their richness and appropriateness. Since Mr Kean in 1858 converted the play into a pageant and a spectacle “The Merchant of Venice” has not been so handsomely cared for by upholsterers, dressmakers, scene painters and “property” manufacturers’.66 The Morning Post (19 April 1875) thought the characters in the play looked like ‘portraits having stepped down from their frames’. The Times (19 April 1875) had nothing but praise for ‘the beauty and taste’ of the visuals: ‘The most thorough feeling for finish and propriety prevails throughout.’ The Era (18 April 1875) declared: ‘the scenery […] is beyond all praise; and we may say without exaggeration that few, if any, plays within our recollection could equal this in gorgeousness’ (see also the Illustrated Sporting and Dramatic News, 24 April 1875). But these same journals damned the acting of Charles Coghlan. The Times flatly declared his Shylock ‘a failure’. The Era caustically observed that the play was performed ‘without a Shylock’, Coghlan being totally inadequate (‘Shylock is out of his line and manifestly beyond his reach’). The Illustrated Sporting and Dramatic News dismissed Coghlan’s Shylock as ‘tame, spiritless
68 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
and ineffective’. The great success of the evening was Ellen Terry: ‘the prominent figure of the whole was Portia, played in the best spirit by Miss Ellen Terry’ (The Times); ‘The feature of the evening was the Portia of Miss Ellen Terry […] Her acting fairly charmed everybody’ (The Era) and ‘The redeeming and most charming impersonation of the revival is the “Portia” of Miss Ellen Terry, who represents the heiress of Belmont with surprising grace of manner, sprightly wit, and in some portions deep impressiveness’ (Illustrated Sporting and Dramatic News). Bancroft, noting the presence in the audience of ‘a remarkable number of Royal Academicians’, observed of the play ‘it all looked so unlike a theatre, and so much more like old Italian pictures than anything that had been previously shown upon any stage’.67 But already opposition was beginning to be voiced against the concentration on visuals at the expense of the acting. Clement Scott of the Daily Telegraph (19 April 1875) thundered: Beautiful pictures containing no incident, superb robes for the covering of shadows, a city of romance denied its idealism, subject-matter sacrificed for marvellous detail, character put on one side for cameos and frescoes substituted for fancy, the glory of the upholsterer and the neglect of the poet, the play subordinate to the decorator, Shakespeare existing only in name, a Venice without a story, and the ‘Merchant of Venice’ without a Shylock […] The stage is something more than a picture gallery. We go to the theatre to think, as well as to look. No one for a moment disputes the value of all this archaeological study, the beauty of these marvellous stage pictures, the accuracy and completeness of the detail or the depth of the research. But there is a higher value in ‘The Merchant of Venice’ than in Venetian pictures and the perfection of Venetian costume.68 But the critics were not confined to the stalls. There was discontent in the gallery. Bancroft put it tactfully: Some of the dresses seemed to puzzle many among the audience, notably those worn by Bassanio and by the Venetian nobles who accompanied him to Belmont in their beautiful velvet robes of State reaching to the ground, the striking and correct costume of the Prince of Morocco and his gorgeous attendants, and that of the equally picturesque Spanish nobles who accompanied the Prince of Arragon. I need not add that the painters were loud in praise of all this. It may be that it all came before the proper time and we saw things too far in advance.69 Clement Scott more forcibly rep orted: ‘The first performance of Shakespeare at this theatre brought with it a noisy and captious audience, apparently determined to make unnecessary calls, and to laugh at costumes they chose to consider ridiculous; but experience shows that such little
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
69
outbursts as these have their origin very frequently in the feeling of disappointment to which we have ventured to allude’, a feeling that Dutton Cook of the Pall Mall Gazette also picked up.70 The World (21 April 1875) reported periodic ‘outbursts of ribaldry’ directed against ‘quaint medieval costumes’. Coghlan’s failure as Shylock, a failure which unbalanced the entire production, doomed the play at the box office and it closed after only 36 days at a loss to the Bancrofts of £3,000. But the artistic community were conscious that something remarkable had occurred. In her autobiography, Ellen Terry lamented the shortness of the run: It was a pity, if only because a more gorgeous and complete little spectacle had never been seen on the English stage. Veronese’s ‘Marriage of Cana’ had inspired many of the stage pictures, and the expenditure in carrying them out had been lavish. In the casket scene I wore a dress like almond blossom. I was very thin and all the ideal young heroines of Shakespeare ought to be thin. Fat is fatal to ideality. I played the part more stiffly and more slowly at the Prince of Wales’s than I did in later years. I moved and spoke slowly. The clothes seemed to demand it, and the setting of the play developed the Italian feeling in it […] The aesthetic craze, with all its faults, was responsible for a great deal of true enthusiasm for anything beautiful. It made people welcome the Bancrofts’ production of ‘The Merchant of Venice’ with an appreciation which took the practical form of an offer to keep the performance going by subscription, as the general public was not supporting them. Sir Frederick and Lady Pollock, James Spedding, Edwin Arnold, Sir Frederick Leighton and others made the proposal to the Bancrofts, but nothing came of it […] The audience may have been scanty, but they were wonderful. O’Shaughnessy, Watts-Dunton, Oscar Wilde, Alfred Gilbert, and I think Swinburne were there. A poetic and artistic atmosphere pervaded the front of the house as well as the stage itself.71 In 1876 Godwin was called in to advise actor-manager John Coleman on his production of Henry V at the Queen’s Theatre. He was billed in the programme, which said ‘the entire archaeology of the Play has been under the superintendence of Mr E.W. Godwin F.S.A.’. Declaring that this was the first time he had been ‘professionally called in’ to provide historical advice, he devoted a lengthy article in The Architect to explaining his researches. Thanking the officials in the Library and Manuscript Departments of the British Museum, he identified the various illuminated books and manuscripts from the early fifteenth century which he had consulted and described in detail the costumes they had inspired. For the King himself and his various noblemen and warriors, Godwin had copied and measured the details on monumental effigies and memorial brasses of the period. For coats of arms, he consulted the Rous Roll and the Roll of Richard II as well as the Agincourt Battle Roll.
70 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
The architecture, apart from Westminster Abbey and the Jerusalem Chamber, he had had to design where the costumes were merely selected and copied. He found the manuscript drawings of buildings before 1415 defective in proportion and too overly stylised to be accepted as literal scenes. So he combined elements from them with his observations of medieval buildings preserved in Lincoln, York, Bristol and Exeter, to create the required London streets. He concluded his article hopefully: ‘Of the host of details which beset the path of the archaeological referee I need say nothing, many and troublesome as they may be, the trouble is of little count if they are only fairly carried out with ordinary good will and intelligence.’72 In a follow-up article reviewing the opening night of the play, he declared himself shocked to see that many of his designs had simply not been utilised. He claimed to have seen nothing in advance but for ‘the banners, the scenes, some odd properties and some half dressed supernumeraries’, but his diaries record his regularly attending rehearsals and complaining about inaccuracies. He began by recording his pleasure in the scene painting of George Gordon, who had for the most part followed his designs. ‘The scenes which he himself has painted from my sketches are Eastcheap, Harfleur, and London Bridge; and with two, or at the most three, very trifling details any errors that can be fixed on them are wholly mine. The Jerusalem Chamber and the interior of the Palace of Troyes are also painted from my design with tolerable fidelity […] Of the other scenes I know absolutely nothing, except so far as I gave a few hints to Mr Gordon for the interior of Westminster Abbey. The scenes which came on me […] by surprise, are the “Temple of History” and the “Palace of Charles VI”.’ Coleman had replaced Shakespeare’s chorus by Clio, the Muse of History, in her temple and Godwin poured scorn on the idea of the Muse, ‘dressed in the fashion of the best period of Greek art’ in a temple modelled on the Renaissance work in the Ducal Palace in Venice and hung with Greek drapes. Of the Palace of Charles VI, he pointed out that when a building is of various dates, ‘it is not usual to find the whole of the substructure later than the rest by about three centuries’. In addtion the scenery was too far forward on the stage, damaging the pictorial effect for the audience. As to the costumes, the ladies of the French Court with two exceptions wore costumes from the second half of the fifteenth century, as he demonstrated by reference to a variety of medieval manuscripts. Furthermore, they were rendered ridiculous by the fact that the Queen and her attendants were dressed in fashions 25–50 years later than those of the Princess and Lady Alice. Not one of his accurate designs for medieval hoods had been carried out. He attributed Tom Mead’s conception of Pistol sufficient to account for ‘the melodramatic-transpontine character of his dress, a sort of cross between the dissembling villain of tradition and the popular portrait of Guy Fawkes’. He noted that ‘the faults in the execution of the heraldry on banner, surcoat, or shield are very few’, the Marquis of Exeter having
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
71
what looked like kittens rather than the lions of England on his surcoat and the Earl of Oxford having his quarterings reversed. The problem was that the various historical characters were all carrying the wrong banners. ‘The defects in the military costume are quite gratuitous on the part of the makers thereof […] How often must it be said that the skirt of the surcoat of HENRY V’s knights and nobles who are clad in complete suits of armour should not descend half way down the thigh, and that the chain mail should be only just visible beneath it, instead of hanging almost to the knees, bobbing about like an open-worked ballet dress. Again the plate armour itself has been made too much of one size, and that much too small.’ And so it went on. However, Godwin magnanimously acquitted Coleman of responsibility for all this, blaming his subordinates. ‘That Mr COLEMAN heartily wished to give his work an archaeological completeness no former revival of the play had attained, I, for one, most firmly believe, nor do I think that he had any desire of himself to depart from or supplement the studies and researches made for him. And yet had he turned a deaf ear to well-meaning but officious friends and employés, he would probably have made enemies, or at least very luke-warm adherents of them, and this, for his first venture in London, he very naturally dreaded.’ But he ended by expressing the hope that the scenic artists and costumiers would amend their errors during the run of the play.73 But the play failed and was soon withdrawn. Ironically it was the sets and costumes that garnered such praise as there was. The Times (19 September 1876) declared: ‘As a specimen of that “Painting and carpentry” which Ben Jonson declares to be “the soul of mask”, the performance is certainly not without merit. As an adequate representation of the play of Shakespeare, Henry V […] cannot, as it seems to us, be in any way accepted.’ The text had been much rearranged and cut, presented in four rather than the customary five acts, two ballets interpolated (which were booed on the opening night and subsequently dropped) and two scenes from Henry IV, Part 2 introduced, with Samuel Phelps making a guest appearance as the dying Henry IV. Coleman himself played Henry V. However, The Times reported tartly: ‘Neither of the King nor his following is there much more to be said than that their dresses were very sumptuous, and in that respect they were suitable figures in the pageants of which they were apart.’ However, having dismissed the acting, The Times critic praised the production: There were certainly several pictures of remarkable colour and effect presented to the eye, on the composition of which much care and research have been very properly spent. The dresses were very gorgeous, and, there is every reason to believe, correct; and the stage at the proper time was well filled with very creditably trained representatives of soldiers, citizens, lord and ladies in waiting, […] and the care and liberality of the management at these points was suitably acknowledged, as it deserved to
72 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
be. Beyond this, however, we do not know that there is much else to be said for this latest ‘Shakesperian Revival’.74 In his autobiography, John Coleman recalled the production as an artistic triumph, claiming ‘every scene, every costume, every weapon, every suit of armour, every trophy and banner were prepared from the highest authority, after the designs of Mr Godwin, the eminent archaeologist’ and that for spectacle, both Mrs Charles Kean and J.R. Planché told him it had never been equalled, and he adds ‘I am bold enough to assert even now that it has never since been surpassed’. But it led to financial disaster. £6,000 had been spent on the production, £1,000 on redecorating the auditorium and he had lost £5,000 spent on preparing productions of Othello, Hamlet and Macbeth for the celebrated Italian tragedian Salvini, who had decamped to Italy after only three days, causing the cancellation of the season. Henry V resulted in his being overdrawn even before the curtain went up, and he was forced to give up the lease of the theatre.75 Coleman was more caustic about Godwin in journal articles. When Godwin renewed his criticism of Coleman in an article ‘Archaeology on the Stage – II’ (Dramatic Review, 22 February 1885), Coleman responded with a magisterial put-down, claiming that Godwin had been engaged ‘not as an artist, but an archaeologist’, adding ‘I regard the former as a creator, the latter as a copyist – hence I retained this gentleman to copy certain costumes, scenes and properties’ (Dramatic Review, 28 March 1885). In a previous article ‘On Stage Management’ in the Dramatic Review (14 March 1885) he had already pointed out that it was the role of the ‘competent stage manager’ (director) to tell the archaeologist what he needed from him and the costumier ‘the shape, material and colour of the costumes’ and the property man ‘the make, size, dimensions, and date of the furniture and properties requisite’. It was not until the 1880s that Godwin returned to theatrical design and then it was with a series of costume designs for serious productions. Evidently London managements were taking notice of his strictures. In 1881 he designed the costumes for the leads in a production of Romeo and Juliet at the Olympic Theatre. R.B. Mantell wore his Godwin-designed costume and earned from Godwin the praise that ‘Mr Mantell is the first Romeo we have ever seen who looked like a Montague of Verona during the first quarter of the fourteenth century’. But Miss Ellen Wallis did not wear hers, causing Godwin to lament that ‘Actresses will not dress in Medieval costume as they should’, preferring to wear clothes more in line with the contemporary aesthetic taste of the late nineteenth century.76 He also designed costumes for Mrs Bateman’s production of Othello at Sadler’s Wells and for Hermann Vezin’s productions of Hamlet (1881), The Lady of Lyons (1882) and The Merchant of Venice (1883), and Mrs Scott Siddons’ production of Queen and Cardinal (1881).
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
73
Godwin was commissioned at fairly short notice to design the costumes for a production of Othello at Sadler’s Wells which Mrs Bateman was putting on to take advantage of the unexpected availability of Charles Warner to play the title role. Isabel Bateman played Desdemona and Hermann Vezin, Iago. Mrs Bateman had just a fortnight to prepare the production and she may have recalled Godwin’s comments on an earlier performance of Othello at Sadler’s Wells, also featuring Vezin as Iago. ‘Mr Vezin, as Iago, was of course the point of attraction, and I am free to admit that the artists did more than anyone I have yet seen to put before us the character as Shakspere drew it. The costumes were mostly English, of the time of Mary, but Mr Vezin was dressed like a young scholar of Venice, more or less after Vecellio. He would have done better to have consulted Amman. Short trunks and short cloak would have suited Mr Vezin’s figure better than those he wore and would have been more appropriate to an officer.’77 Godwin had no compunction about reviewing the production, despite his own participation, and declared Warner’s Othello the best he had encountered apart from Salvini’s, Vezin’s Iago ‘better than ever’ and Isabel Bateman’s Desdemona ‘earnest and looked well’. With some satisfaction, he declared: ‘Some of the dresses were altogether new and taken from portraits and engravings of the time (1570). Many of the others were modified to agree with them, and, although time did not permit any remarkable excellence, there was little or nothing of the nature of an anachronism, thanks to the exertions of those engaged in the theatre. Still there was no reason why Iago’s shoulder puffs should not have been raised on to the shoulders, or why Cassio and Rodrigo should not have clothed their legs in colours more suitable to the rest of their apparel and more in accordance with Venetian fashion.’78 Clement Scott in the Daily Telegraph (22 September 1880) was unimpressed, declaring of Warner’s Othello: He suffered, we think, from a set of costumes that may be aesthetically correct, but were consistently ugly – so ugly indeed and unbecoming as to jeopardise any chance of success. Archaeology is unquestionably a valuable feature in connection with the Shakespearian drama, but artists should understand that to swathe the Moor during the senate scene in stiff, unyielding petticoats is to create ridicule and not to inspire sympathy, and that faultless imitations of pictures or fancies of colour may well be sacrificed in favour of picturesque appearance. He described Isabel Bateman’s Desdemona as ‘most unbecomingly attired’. Godwin published his costume sketches for Othello in the British Architect (15 October 1880) with an explanation of their style. In 1881 Godwin was commissioned to do all the costumes for Mrs Mary Frances Scott-Siddons’ production of Queen and Cardinal except for Anne Boleyn’s, which was to be done by Lewis Wingfield. Mrs Mary Frances
74 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
Scott-Siddons (1844–96) had been a hit as Rosalind in As You Like It in 1867. The Daily News (9 April 1867) had called her ‘saucy and attractive’. But she had gone abroad for a long time and this was her comeback play. It was a poetic drama on the tragedy of Anne Boleyn by Walter S. Raleigh. Archie Nathan of the costumiers Nathans recalled: ‘The firm had a good deal of trouble with this Mrs Scott-Siddons, who was by no means the great actress she imagined herself to be […] She was most meticulous about materials and matching, but was evidently a better judge of that sort of thing than of the dramatic quality of the play.’79 The Globe (26 October 1881) noted that ‘the play was mounted throughout in excellent taste. The views of castled slope and forest glade were picturesque and striking. The dresses, designed by Mr E.W. Godwin and supplied by Messrs L. and H. Nathan, were admirable alike in accuracy and effect. In saying this, however, all that can be advanced in favour of the performance is said’. It tore into the writing and acting, as did the rest of the press. Clement Scott, who had dismissed the play in six lines, found himself deluged by correspondence from the aggrieved author. ‘Mr Walter Raleigh, in his voluminous correspondence, has threatened me with all sorts of pains and penalties. He has questioned my candour, my common sense, my judgment, and apparently my sanity.’ In one of his letters, Raleigh lamented that ten years’ labour and £2,000 had gone in a moment: ‘On Thursday morning, when the articles of “The Daily Telegraph”, “The Standard”, “The Daily News” and “The Morning Post” appeared, no less than one hundred stalls booked at different places for that morning were cancelled, every one of them, and on Friday the receipts fell to 16 (pounds), the result of “The Times” article.’ Scott’s comment on this was that this represented ‘the triumph and vindication of independent and fair criticism’. Scott declared that Raleigh had attributed the play’s failure to everything but the real cause. He complained that the rehearsals had been insufficient, the dresses had arrived late, he knew nothing of stage management and the critics had been unfair. But Scott declared that the real cause of its failure was ‘the public assembled to see it did not care for it in the least possible degree or was really interested in it for five consecutive minutes […] The age did not want it, the theatre was unsuited to it, and there was no interest whatever in the heroine’.80 The Times (28 October 1881) thought there was ‘no good reason’ for the existence of Queen and Cardinal, the story of Anne Boleyn having been effectively covered in Shakespeare’s Henry VIII and Tom Taylor’s Anne Boleyn. ‘It really throws no new light on a very familiar passage of English history […] also one fails to see in what way it is to contribute to the public entertainment.’ The character drawing was poor, the blank verse ‘flat’ and it concluded: ‘Nor have the faults of the subject-matter been redeemed by any strength or novelty of scene, any ingenuity of construction, any grace of style.’ Punch (5 November 1881) suggested that all Raleigh had done in the play was ‘string together some of the strongest dramatic situations from HARRISON AINSWORTH’S Windsor Castle and […] produced his indifferent
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
75
patchwork as “a new and original poetical historical play” without the slightest acknowledgment of the source whence he derived his materials’. The Times reported on 7 November 1881 that the play had been taken off and replaced by As You Like It with Mrs Scott-Siddons as Rosalind. Godwin made a breakthrough in his bid to control the look and artistic feel of an entire production through his friendship with the Irish playwright W.G. Wills. Wills had written Juana, a tragedy in verse set in fifteenth century Spain, as a vehicle for Helena Modjeska and Wilson Barrett. Wills introduced Godwin to Barrett and Barrett hired him to design scenery, costumes and properties. The scenery was to be executed by Barrett’s team of scenic artists, William Beverley, Stafford Hall and Walter Hann. The play told the story of Juana Esteban who falls in love with the handsome but profligate Don Carlos de Narciso when she tends his wounds after an attack by ruffians who had left him for dead. They marry but he embarks on an affair with her best friend Clara Perez. When Juana discovers the affair, she goes mad and stabs Carlos to death. However, her father confessor, Friar John, who is secretly but unrequitedly in love with her, takes on himself the blame for the crime. He is condemned to be walled up alive. But Juana recovers her reason, confesses her guilt and dies in Father John’s arms. The play opened at the Court Theatre on 7 May 1881. The critics generally praised the poetry and the acting (Modjeska as Juana, Forbes Robertson as Carlos and Wilson Barrett as Father John) but pronounced the play gloomy, verbose and old fashioned, and predicted its rapid closure. ‘Poetry with gloom may be accepted in the study but will not do on the stage’ said The Era (14 May 1881). ‘Hardly a streak of silver is to be seen in the black and heavy cloud from which a ceaseless stream of lamentation and mourning and woe is poured on the unoffending spectator’ lamented The Times (9 May 1881). The Daily Telegraph (9 May 1881) complained about the ‘persistent and impenetrable gloom, with shuddering scenes and the physical horror of distraught minds, with the shrieks of madwomen and the bloodstained details of the dread ordeal by touch, with dirges and wails and “misereres” chanted by processional monks, by the ghastly preparing for walling up impenitent friars, and by a long drawn out note of melancholy agony’. However, the mounting of the play received general commendation. Godwin had researched the period extensively and sought to recreate Toledo in 1496 faithfully on the stage. The Era said: ‘The mounting of the play was simply magnificent, special notice of a commendatory character being due to the loggia of the Castle, which forms the scene of the first and second acts.’ The Daily Telegraph declared: ‘The new tragedy has derived every possible advantage from the taste and archaeological accuracy of Mr E.W. Godwin, who has found here a labour of love.’ The Illustrated Sporting and Dramatic News (14 May 1881) said: ‘Mr Godwin deserves credit for the manner in which arrangements of scene and dress, according to the fifteenth century fashion of Spain, both instruct and delight the eye.’
76 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
The play closed after a month. Madame Modjeska blamed Barrett for casting himself and not Forbes Robertson as Friar John: ‘I believe […] that had Forbes Robertson played the poetic monk instead of Wilson Barrett, the play would have had a better chance. It was a grave mistake, though it would be hard to blame an actor-manager for keeping the best part for himself.’ Forbes Robertson did later play the role with Modjeska on a provincial tour (‘He played beautifully, and looked a saint to perfection’).81 However, Wills was so pleased with Godwin’s work that he dedicated the play to him, writing: ‘To Edward William Godwin this play is dedicated as a slight token of friendship: as an acknowledgement of his sympathy and interest in its creation, and as a tribute to the manner in which he has conveyed the true semblance of past times in those plays to which his researches have been applied.’82 Godwin himself, writing in 1885, recalled of his designs for stage properties, ‘Those for Mr Wills’s play for Juana were perhaps, on the whole, the best that have ever been executed for me’. But he felt compelled to add: ‘But in Juana, as indeed in every costume play with which I have had anything to do, there were touches which rendered the illusion incomplete, and features for which I was entirely irresponsible.’ By this he meant that Madame Modjeska had insisted on wearing her own choice of gowns, ignoring Godwin’s designs.83 Despite the failure of Juana, Godwin began his productive partnership with Wilson Barrett, designing his subsequent productions Claudian (1883), Hamlet (1884), Junius (1885) and Clito (1886), set respectively in the Byzantine Empire, medieval Denmark, Ancient Rome and classical Athens. The high point of this cycle was Claudian, which elicited the admiration of both Oscar Wilde and John Ruskin and led to a productive friendship between Ruskin and Barrett (these plays are discussed in detail below). Even with Barrett, Godwin was to have problems, notably a ferocious row over a Byzantine litter designed for Claudian which Barrett refused to use. Godwin finally gained complete control over the production and design of plays in a series of largely amateur productions: As You Like It (1884), The Faithfull Shepherdesse (1885), Fair Rosamund (1886) and Helena in Troas (1886). Godwin’s opportunity to take complete control of a production and to impose upon every aspect his desired unity of design came in 1884. Lady Archibald Campbell, socialite and aesthete, was painting the portrait of the actress Eleanor Calhoun in the costume of Rosalind in the woods at Coombe Warren when she had the idea of staging an open air production of As You Like It for charity. James McNeill Whistler, who was himself painting a portrait of Lady Archibald, introduced her to Godwin, who undertook to prepare the Shakespeare text for production, design the costumes and direct the actors. The Duke of Cambridge having refused the use of his Coombe estate, Dr McGeagh gave permission for the use of his estate and an acting area was created in Coombe Woods. A cast was assembled which consisted of
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
77
amateurs and professionals, among them Eleanor Calhoun as Rosalind, Hermann Vezin as Jaques and two of the members of Wilson Barrett’s company, Charles Fulton as the exiled Duke and George Foss as Adam. Lady Archibald herself played Orlando. The production attracted considerable interest from both high society and the quality press. It was deemed so successful that the performance was repeated in 1885 and Lady Archibald and Godwin set up the Society of Pastoral Players to undertake further productions. The production consisted only of the forest scenes from the play, arranged by Godwin, and some critics felt that this detracted from the dramatic design of Shakespeare’s original. But other critics found themselves bowled over by the novelty, the realism and the visual coherence. Godwin wore friar’s dress so that he could appear in the scene whenever necessary. A correspondent to The Theatre gave a first hand account of the costumes: Although the designs could not be entirely carried out in the dresses supplied by Messrs May, the costumes were altered to accord, as far as possible, with Mr Godwin’s idea of accuracy and harmonious colouring, due consideration being given to the hues and shades employed, in order that they might blend picturesquely with the surrounding foliage. The period was fixed between the years 1470 and 1480, as after that date there were no more independent dukes in France. Day after day was passed at the costumier’s in selecting colours and materials; and I noticed how especially careful the manager was to choose old dresses for the banished landless lords and their followers, to contrast with the fresher and more showy costumes worn by the ‘young gentlemen of estate’, who were the new arrivals in the forest. Touchstone’s dress was the only absolutely new one furnished by Messrs May, and accurately following the design. Miss Calhoun wore her own dress as Rosalind, the same in which she appeared at the Imperial Theatre. Lady Archibald’s Orlando dress was made from the same pattern in different colours. It struck me as founded more or less on the Saint Hubert of Albrecht Durer. Miss A. Schletter, as Celia, wore a costume that accorded better with Mr Godwin’s ideas than did the dresses of the other ladies. Mrs Plowden certainly made a picture as Phoebe, but her costume might be fairly considered a little out of keeping with the general picture, from its over-brilliant colouring […] The bycocket caps, so familiar to students of the fifteenth century, were donned by Jaques, and the other stage lords, and were more suitable than the head-gear usually worn in the stage presentation of the play. The same correspondent pointed out that ‘All conventional stage business was set aside, and the whole representation thought out from an artist’s standpoint, illustrating the spirit of play in its fullest and most perfect sense’. This involved even the call-boy, Master W. Phillips being dressed as
78 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
a shepherd and leading cattle and sheep across the stage at appropriate points. ‘The procession of the dead deer and the real staghounds, the goats led across the stage, and the claiming of their tuneful set of bells, all contributed to heighten the effect.’84 The poet Alfred Austin, paying tribute to Lady Archibald both for her performance (‘A more graceful and gallant Orlando it would have been impossible to ask for’) and for having the idea of the open-air performance as the best way of rendering the play, wrote: No one who went to Coombe to put the theory to the test of practice, can doubt that Orlando was right. I confess that I, for one, entertained some misgiving as to the soundness of the principle involved. I feared that the perfect naturalness of the surroundings would detract from the illusion of the performance. I cheerfully confess that I was utterly wrong. But I had no conception that the idea would be carried out with such completeness, whether in the mechanical and artistic arrangements, presided over with so much skill and taste by Mr Godwin, in the mimetic presentation of the piece, or in its gay and fascinating accessories.85 Oscar Wilde, who attended the 1885 revival, was also impressed: The condition then under which this comedy was produced […] did not place any great limitations on the actor’s art, and increased tenfold the value of the play as a picture. Through an alley of white hawthorn and gold laburnum we passed into the green pavilion that served as the theatre, the air sweet with the odour of lilac and with the blackbird’s song; and when the curtain fell into its trench of flowers, and the play commenced, we saw before us a real forest, and we knew it to be Arden […] As for the players themselves, the pleasing naturalness of their method harmonised delightfully with their natural surroundings. Those of them who were amateurs were too artistic to be stagey, and those who were actors too experienced to be artificial […] As regards the costumes the colour scheme was very perfect. Brown and green were the dominant notes and yellow was most artistically used. As You Like It has probably never been so well mounted, nor costumes worn with more ease and simplicity.86 Godwin followed As You Like It with open air productions of John Fletcher’s The Faithfull Shepherdesse and Fair Rosamund, an adaptation of Lord Tennyson’s play Becket. The Faithfull Shepherdesse, performed in the same place as As You Like It, with the addition of a statue and altar of the god Pan, created by Godwin from originals in the British Museum, was admired by some critics for its visual effects. ‘It is the effective tableaux, the colouring of the piece, the quaint costumes of the skin-clad shepherds and the lissom
E.W. Godwin and Ruskinian Aesthetics
79
shepherdesses, the statue of the god Pan with the incense-burning altar, the festoons of lilac and laburnum, the arrival of Perigot and Amoret in a golden chariot drawn by two gentle heifers, which enchain the attention of the spectator’ reported The Stage (3 July 1885). But there were beginning to be critical reservations about these open-air productions. One critic, writing under the pen-name ‘Ignotus’, reviewed The Faithfull Shepherdesse. Fanny Baldwin suggests that ‘Ignotus’ is Oscar Wilde but in its facetious style it reads more like George Bernard Shaw, who was writing music criticism for the Dramatic Review in 1885–6. He dismissed it as ‘a piece of exquisite tomfoolery’: If I were asked to tell the outer world my own impression of the affair, it would doubtless be in a critical sense vague and unsatisfactory, for I could only see Lady Archibald Campbell, in green tights striking stained-glass attitudes under a tree, and anon, all the love-sick maidens from Patience disporting themselves to fiddle-de-de music, in company with creatures disguised in tow and yellow ochre, but whom it could be seen by the programme were Shepherds, suffering more or less from temporary insanity. This may sound harsh, and no doubt I am a veritable Goth, but let it be understood that, on the other hand, I fully recognise Mr Godwin’s effort to make the ugly beautiful, and I am conscious of his archaeological accuracy. But when I acknowledge that his costumes were beautifully ugly, there is an end of my appreciation. ‘Ignotus’ challenged the whole idea of the superior authenticity of out of doors production: What one wants to see upon a stage, whether the boards or grass, is art, not nature; nature bores us, and is extremely monotonous, where it is not absolutely repulsive. Art is that which teaches us to be refined when our vulgar natures call aloud for dirtiness. Therefore, bare legs and broad language, in our educated days give place to trousers and smoother tongues.87 The same idea was taken up by Freeman Wills, the brother of playwright W.G. Wills, who in an article on ‘Open Air Theatres’ said: It is in no carping spirit, rather owning the significance of these out-door theatricals, that I would raise the question of their tendency and dramatic value. It is a new experiment of blending the real and the fictitious. I would ask, then, must not the truest art be untrue, a gathering into focus for the eye of scenes which in reality would be widely spread out and separated? There is a necessary unreality in the drama which creates its difficulty for the would-be dramatist. To colour and arrange the optic
80 John Ruskin and the Victorian Theatre
delusion for the eye that has to see from a false distance, and to make the falsity represent truth, is the difficulty of art. When this has been accomplished successfully, the mind is pleased by a harmony and correctness of impression; but when the drama thus adapted to the mental eye is thrown out upon a background of actual nature, then we have the distortion of the mediaeval picture. In its false setting it appeared true; in its true setting it appears false.88 The culmination of these amateur productions was Godwin’s staging at Hengler’s circus in a reproduction of an ancient Greek theatre of John Todhunter’s translation and adaptation of Sophocles’ play, Helena in Troas. It opened on 26 May 1886. Typically Willie Wilde in The Theatre reported that, except for Hermann Vezin, the acting was ‘earnest and well-intentioned but of fire and passion there was none’ and the delivery was ‘slow, sonorous and dull’. But, on the other hand, ‘the designer’s work was altogether excellent. Mr Godwin has given beauty, unity and harmony, to the details of archaeology. His theatre was strictly accurate, his classical lore severe, yet his treatment was poetical, and not pedantic’.89 It played to packed houses for the scheduled two weeks and made ‘a considerable profit’.90 The success of the open air productions tempted Godwin fatally into commercial production. He entered into a partnership with two society beauties, Mrs Sophie Mackintosh and her sister Miss Janette Steer, took a lease on the Opera Comique and prepared a revival of Tom Taylor’s The Fool’s Revenge, an adaptation of Hugo’s Le Roi S’Amuse, which had first been produced in 1859. The appeal for Godwin was the Renaissance setting. The beauties played the leading fema