JEWISH IDENTITY IN EARLY MODERN GERMANY
For Juli My best friend, my inspiration, and the love of my life
In memory o...
101 downloads
1683 Views
685KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
JEWISH IDENTITY IN EARLY MODERN GERMANY
For Juli My best friend, my inspiration, and the love of my life
In memory of my beloved grandparents Herman and Eva Solomon of blessed memory
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany Memory, Power and Community
DEAN PHILLIP BELL Spertus Institute of Jewish Studies, USA
© Dean Phillip Bell 2007 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior permission of the publisher. Dean Phillip Bell has asserted his moral right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, to be identified as the author of this work. Published by Ashgate Publishing Limited Gower House Croft Road Aldershot Hampshire GU11 3HR England
Ashgate Publishing Company Suite 420 101 Cherry Street Burlington, VT 05401-4405 USA
Ashgate website: http://www.ashgate.com British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Bell, Dean Phillip, 1967– Jewish identity in early modern Germany: memory, power and community 1. Jews – Germany – Identity 2. Jews – Germany – History – 1096–1800 3. Jews – Historiography 4. Jews – Germany – Social conditions – 16th century 5. Jews – Germany – Social conditions – 17th century 6. Collective memory – Germany – History 7. Germany – Ethnic relations – History I. Title 943’.004924’09031 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Bell, Dean Phillip, 1967– Jewish identity in early modern Germany: memory, power and community / by Dean Phillip Bell. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references. 1. Jews – Germany – History – 1096–1800. 2. Jews – Germany – Historiography. 3. Judaism – Historiography. 4. History – Religious aspects – Judaism. 5. Memory – Religious aspects – Judaism. 6. Reformation – Germany – History. 7. Germany – Ethnic relations. I. Title. DS135.G31B447 2007 943’.004924dc–22 2006033074
ISBN 978-0-7546-5897-9 Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham, Wiltshire.
Contents Acknowledgements
vii
Introduction
ix
1
Memory, History, and Jewish Identity
1
2
Reconsidering Early Modern German Jewish Memory and History
19
3
Community, Memory, and Governance
35
4
Jewish Social Organization: The Role of Memory, Power, and Honor
67
5
Politics, Polemics, and History: Assessing Jewish Identity
99
6
From Law to Legend: Narrating Jewish and Christian Encounters
131
Conclusion
153
Bibliography
157
Index
179
This page intentionally left blank
Acknowledgements This work has evolved over many years and has benefited from the comments and insights of many people in diverse settings. In the last several years I have presented my findings at a number of conferences and to seminars at the University of Chicago, University of California at Berkeley, University of Illinois-Urbana Champaign, University of Illinois at Chicago, Western Michigan University, and Spertus College. I am grateful for and have benefited tremendously from the comments from all of my colleagues in these settings and in my courses at Spertus. I am also indebted to my colleagues at Spertus Institute’s Asher Library and the Newberry Library, who have supplied me with what must have been an endless request of rare, obscure, or voluminous resources. This work would never have come to be without their assistance. I express here my appreciation for the very helpful comments by the anonymous evaluators at Ashgate, who obviously invested a great deal of time in reading the manuscript and who supplied me with remarkably nurturing and constructive suggestions. Thomas Gray, Commissioning Editor at Ashgate, deserves special thanks for all his encouragement and for his assistance with this project. I thank particularly my friends and colleagues, Stephen Burnett, Constantin Fasolt, Hal Lewis, Lynda Crawford, and Miriam Ben-Yoseph, who have toiled over various drafts of this book. Their patience and encouragement have been remarkable. I owe a great debt of gratitude to Dave and Rheta Harrison for all their support, and particular indebtedness to my father and mother, Edward and Myrna Bell, for all their love, patience, and encouragement for me and for my various and sundry historical musings over many years. Finally, and most importantly, I thank my wife Juli and my children Malkaya, Chanan, and Ronia. They have afforded me a great deal of time and flexibility to think about and write this book, and though they may never realize it, they inspire me in all that I do.
This page intentionally left blank
Introduction In this book I present a variety of examples of how Jews in early modern Germany remembered and narrated the past. Although it has been argued that Jews possessed little in the way of formal historiographical traditions in this period, what follows demonstrates that Jews nevertheless, or precisely because, co-opted the past both consciously and unconsciously for many reasons, and in various and surprising ways. Responding to the particular conditions in which they found themselves in early modern German and Jewish culture, Jews fashioned the past for both internal and external purposes—creating communal identity in contemporary situations, while seeking connections to a broader Jewish past. While Jews related past events to present circumstances in paradigmatic ways that have been seen as traditionally religious, this study reveals that Jews also shaped the past to address both contemporary internal concerns and external relations. This book engages, but then redirects, important discussions by recent historians regarding the nature of time and the construction and role of memory and history in pre-modern Europe and pre-modern Jewish civilization. I argue that even when they did not write formal “histories,” Jews maintained a significant and lively engagement with the past that operated at various levels and divided the past into generally coherent, if long and at times changeable, units. Some of these units were based on the experiences and perspectives of individual Jews, individual communities, or clusters of communities. Some had basis in actual experiences with the past, while others were related to the lore of particular communities, or the broader religious currents and traditions of Judaism. In the end, however, all of these memories helped to define and shape early modern German Jewry. The sources examined in this book are diverse. Any form of German Jewish expression in the early modern period that contains reference to the past or past events is open to investigation. This includes, for example, chronicles, liturgical works, books of customs, memorybooks, biblical commentaries, rabbinic responsa literature, and community ledgers. Throughout, a broad comparative basis is offered, particularly through the juxtaposition of early modern Christian engagement with the past. The period covered here is roughly 1500–1700. These dates were chosen in large part because of the scope of the sources available. There were, however, additional reasons for selecting these parameters. These dates bound important German developments, such as the Reformation, forcing us to consider how more general conditions in Germany impacted the way that Jews engaged the past. But this period also had real meaning for internal Jewish developments, demarcating the boundaries of significant demographic and social shifts within the Jewish communities themselves. Throughout this book the beginning and end dates of investigation are taken rather fluidly, so that late fifteenth- and very early eighteenth-century materials are also examined as they help to clarify developments or trends.
x
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
A critical issue has been the selection of the geographical span of this work. One cannot speak of early modern Germany without immediately running into the complex question of just what “Germany” was. Was it defined by linguistic patterns, political territories, cultural inclinations, religious beliefs, or something still different? Even within Germany, political borders might cross traditional ecclesiastical divisions, so that the duchy of Bavaria and the Rhine Palatinate, for example, each lay in seven different dioceses, while the two Saxonies were in eleven.1 Throughout this research, I have opted to include the broader German Empire, described by Johannes Cochlaeus (1479–1552), the anti-Reformation humanist, in his Brevis Germaniae descriptio of 1512: “I believe that no region in Europe extends further than Germany … It is enclosed in the south by Italy and Dalmatia [Yugoslavia]; in the east by Hungary and Poland; in the north by the Baltic and the North Sea; and in the west by France and the English channel.”2 While one could devise many different definitions for early modern Germany, it is this broad geographical definition that I have selected to bound the investigation that follows. I should note that even for early modern Jews, the question of what was “German” could be complicated. On the one hand, many historians have found increasing evidence to suggest that “Ashkenaz” had very distinct boundaries and meanings in the world-view of early modern Jews.3 Important synods, for example, stipulated the political borders within German Jewry as well as the central location of primary German Jewish courts and tax-collection centers. Restrictions were placed on Jews seeking to take litigation from a particular region, especially crossing over into Italy or Poland. On the other hand, it has become equally clear that while Jews absorbed non-Jewish culture they also absorbed non-German Jewish customs, practices, and outlooks as well. There is a growing body of literature demonstrating the connection between German and Polish Jewish study and customs and between Italian and German Jewish legal decision-making processes. At the same time, Jews traveled broadly and maintained important business and familial connections throughout a very disperse geographical reach. For this reason, the Jewish community of Prague has been included in this study. While Prague is not really part of the German 1 Thomas A. Brady, Jr. “The Holy Roman Empire’s Bishops on the Eve of the Reformation,” in Robert J. Blast and Andrew C. Gow (eds), Continuity and Change: The Harvest of Late Medieval and Reformation History: Essays Presented to Heiko A. Oberman on his 70th Birthday (Leiden, 2000), pp. 20–47, here at p. 31, n. 44. 2 Jörn Sieglerschmidt, “Social and Economic Landscapes,” in Sheilagh Ogilvie (ed.), Germany: A New Social and Economic History, volume II: 1639–1800 (London, 1996), pp. 1–38, here at p. 2. 3 See Joseph Davis, “The Reception of the Shulhan ‘Arukh and the Formation of Ashkenazic Jewish Identity,” AJS Review 26:2 (2002): 251–76. Davis writes that, “A variety of answers, some complimentary, some contradictory, were offered to these questions by sixteenth- and seventeenth-century Jews during the conflict over the reception of the Shulhan ‘Arukh. It was suggested that the Ashkenazim were the descendants of a group of common ancestors; that they were the Jews who lived in Germany, Ashkenaz; that they were those who lived throughout Central and Eastern Europe; that they were Yiddish-speaking Jews; or even, for the purposes of Jewish law, that they were exactly those Jews whose communities accepted the authority of Isserles’ code” (p. 253).
Introduction
xi
experience documented in most of the sources, it is clear that there were extremely significant connections between the Jews in Germany and Prague and, what is more, within the context of political developments in early modern Germany, Prague played a very crucial role. In addition, the very large and important Jewish community in Prague was responsible for a good deal of intellectual and cultural productivity, and the sources produced by Jews living there in this period expand the scope of material available for consideration. What follows is divided into six chapters and a brief conclusion. Chapter 1 reviews the nature of memory and history as discussed in general and Jewish scholarship, with particular emphasis on the diversity of ways in which narration of the past could be used for various political, social, and religious purposes. Chapter 2 turns more specifically to early modern German Jewish notions of memory and history as expressed in theological constructs as well as complex understandings of temporality. Here I argue that while early modern Jews frequently employed traditional paradigms in order to make sense of the past, they also narrated the past in order to forge communal identity and to mediate relations with the non-Jewish world. Chapters 3 and 4 discuss various Jewish uses of the past that had significant internal communal value. In Chapter 3, I consider the role of memory in communal governance. After a review of general and Jewish demography in early modern Germany and the structure of Jewish communities, I examine Jewish engagement with the past in community ledgers (pinkasim) and local and regional customs (minhagim). I conclude that the past narrated by Jews had great communal significance—at certain times confirming traditions and at other times challenging regnant norms and initiating serious communal change. Chapter 4 expands this discussion by considering the social organization of the Jewish communities and highlighting the role of wealth, prestige, and honor in Jewish communal politics. Here I investigate several memorybooks and autobiographical writings for what they reveal about social order and communal power. Throughout, I provide comparisons with the use of memory and history in early modern German Christian writings. Chapters 5 and 6 chart Jewish engagement with the past as a tool for confronting and, at times, contesting external authority. In Chapter 5, the role of history and memory as devices of political contestation are placed particularly within the context of the Reformation and the growth of general historical production in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. On the one hand, Jews narrated the past in order to recalibrate historical reckoning to include their history and to re-inscribe themselves as the Chosen People of God. On the other hand, such narrations also provided a moral yardstick with which to upbraid the Jews themselves. In Chapter 6, I consider the role of the past in the process of legal decision-making, the engagement with mythic time and magical stories, and the solidification of origin stories, all of which helped to re-situate Jews in early modern German society. In the end, this book is about the narration of the past by Jews living throughout the early modern or old German Empire. But, it is a book, it is hoped, that will have comparative value for both Jewish and Christian history as well. It reveals the complexities of early modern German Jewish communal life as well as the multifaceted relations that Jews had with German Christians. Fundamentally, this book challenges the assumption that Jews did not think about the past in any more than
xii
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
typological ways and it asserts that Jews, despite frequent and often bitter antiJudaism and anti-Jewish activity, maintained important autonomy in the governance of their own communities and significant power in their relations with the outside world. In crafting their memories, early modern Jews were remarkably sophisticated and resilient. They remembered for many purposes and with much subtlety. Their narration of these memories allows a marvelous window into their world and perceptions.
Chapter 1
Memory, History, and Jewish Identity Before I turn to the early modern sources themselves, it is instructive to review the recent literature on memory and history for what such theoretical discussions may suggest generally about the understanding and function of the past. First we summarize the important work of Maurice Halbwachs and Pierre Nora on memory and history. The work of these scholars and others serves as context for a discussion of recent approaches to Jewish memory and history, especially the work of Yosef Hayim Yerushalmi. After a consideration of some of the responses to Halbwachs and Yerushalmi in particular I examine broadly the nature and use of history in the Middle Ages. This quick overview indicates that despite their apparent theoretical differences, memory and history exist on a continuum of engagement with the past, which functions in several ways. The narration of this past—whether as memory or history—helps to dictate moral standards, it mediates politics and is itself a form of power, and it reinforces tradition while simultaneously offering the tools to bring about sweeping changes. The vast and growing scholarly literature on memory and history also argues for an important connection between discussions of the past and communal identity and suggests that many significant changes associated with the early modern period can be understood by examining early modern narratives of the past. Memory and History In a now classic study, first published in 1950 but discussed increasingly more recently, Maurice Halbwachs argued that memory and history have very different characteristics and are in a sense in opposition to each other.1 In that work, Halbwachs set much of the current agenda for discussions about the relation of memory and history as well as the nature of collective memory.2 His pioneering concepts have raised significant questions for historians and, as we will see below, the ire of some scholars who prefer less rigid oppositions. 1 See Mircea Eliade, who in the late 1940s raised the question of the ahistorical nature of popular memory: “The anhistorical character of popular memory, the instability of collective memory to retain historical events and individuals except insofar as it transforms them into archetypes—that is, insofar as it annuls all their historical and personal peculiarities—pose a series of new problems, which we are obliged to set aside for the moment” (Cosmos and History: The Myth of the Eternal Return, trans. Willard R. Trask (New York, 1959 (orig., 1949)), p. 46). 2 See the evaluation of Amos Funkenstein, in his Perceptions of Jewish History (Berkeley, 1993), pp. 4, 8–9.
2
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
According to Halbwachs there is an important distinction between memory and history. “General history,” he argued, “starts only when tradition ends and the social memory is fading or breaking up. So long as a remembrance continues to exist, it is useless to set it down in writing or otherwise fix it in memory. Likewise the need to write the history of a period, a society, or even a person is only aroused when the subject is already too distant in the past to allow for the testimony of those who preserve some remembrance of it.”3 History, in this interpretation, is written at points of social disintegration. It is a distant, written reflection of un-experienced events. Whereas memory is continuous and ongoing, history assumes, even demands, that everything is transformed from one period to the next. While memory is a depository and safeguard of tradition, history is merely a record of events. Memory is living, history a detached record of things no longer alive. Memory is particular in focus, but history has the capacity to treat the universal.4 According to Halbwachs, our memory of the past is composed of two kinds of elements: those from a common domain (a social or external memory) and those remembrances that are ours alone (personal and internal memory). This dichotomy is not so simple, for while individuals remember within a broader social context their memories may also vary based on their own experiences and orientations. According to Halbwachs: While the collective memory endures and draws strength from its base in a coherent body of people, it is individuals as group members who remember. While these remembrances are mutually supportive of each other and common to all, individual members still vary in the intensity with which they experience them. I would readily acknowledge that each memory is a viewpoint on the collective memory, that this viewpoint changes as my relationships to other milleus change. Therefore, it is not surprising that everyone does not draw on the same part of this common instrument. In accounting for that diversity, however, it is always necessary to revert to a combination of influences that are social in nature.5
In this assessment, there is a common memory base that is tapped into, processed, and experienced differently by different individuals within unique and varying contexts. Individual and communal memory, therefore, exist in a complex and multidirectional relationship, in which individual memory simultaneously is affected by and contributes to collective memory.6 3 Maurice Halbwachs, The Collective Memory, trans. Francis J. Ditter, Jr. and Vida Yazdi Ditter (New York, 1980 (orig., 1950)), pp. 78–9. Halbwachs notes as well that, “by the term ‘history’ we must understand, then, not a chronological sequence of events and dates, but whatever distinguishes one period from all others, something of which books and narratives generally give us only a very schematic and incomplete picture” (p. 57). 4 Ibid., pp. 80–82. 5 Ibid., p. 48. 6 Pierre Nora writes that, “Memory wells up from groups that it welds together, which is to say, as Maurice Halbwachs observed, that there are as many memories as there are groups, that memory is by nature multiple yet specific; collective and plural yet individual. By contrast, history belongs to everyone and to no one and therefore has a universal vocation.”
Memory, History, and Jewish Identity
3
The influential French historian Pierre Nora, in a seminal work examining French national history, has presented a similar tension between what he understands as memory and history.7 Nora argues for a differentiation between memory, which is concrete and so rooted in space and structure, and history, which is rooted in temporality and so is relative. History is about change and memory about continuity, albeit at times shifting continuity. Nora posits a distinction between memory and history that revolves around a divide between the sacred and non-religious. Memory situates remembrance in a sacred context. History is critical, analytical, and so nonreligious. It is not simply that being critical and analytical are at odds with religion or that history is related to, or a part of a process of, secularization. More significantly, for Nora, is the observation that history has to do with an external reflection as opposed to a true core. Nora writes that “We no longer celebrate the nation, but we study the nation’s celebrations.”8 The less we are able to experience from within, the more we need “external props and tangible reminders of that which no longer exists except qua memory.”9 “The trace,” Nora writes, “negates the sacred but retains its aura,”10 so as history is more “critical,” it is simultaneously also more detached. Memory, while steeped in hazy impressions, symbolic details, emotion, and magic, holds the key to the core, the true or real society that history only knows by separation and reflection. But Nora reads modern memory as more akin to history than traditional memory. He sounds a note of concern, consequently, when he writes that “the ‘acceleration of history’ thus brings us face to face with the enormous distance that separates real memory … from history” and an integrated memory from “our form of memory, which is nothing but history, a matter of sifting and sorting.”11 Indeed, for Nora, the modern transformation of memory “marks a decisive shift from the historical to the psychological, from the social to the individual, from the concrete message to its subjective representation, from repetition to remembrance.”12 Modernity, in this See Realms of Memory: Rethinking the French Past, under the direction of Pierre Nora, 3 vols, trans. Arthur Goldhammer (New York, 1996–98 (orig., 1984–92)), p. 3. 7 Nora writes: “Memory is life, always embodied in living societies and as such in permanent evolution, subject to the dialectic of remembering and forgetting, unconscious of the distortions to which it is subject, vulnerable in various ways to appropriation and manipulation, and capable of lying dormant for long periods only to be suddenly reawakened. History, on the other hand, is the reconstruction, always problematic and incomplete, of what is no longer. Memory is always a phenomenon of the present; history is a representation of the past. Memory, being a phenomenon of emotion and magic, accommodates only those facts that suit it. It thrives on vague, telescoping reminiscences, on hazy general impressions or specific symbolic details. It is vulnerable to transferences, screen memories, censorings, and projections of all kinds. History, being an intellectual, nonreligious activity, calls for analysis and critical discourse. Memory situates remembrance in a sacred context. History ferrets it out; it turns whatever it touches into prose.” Ibid. 8 Ibid., p. 7. 9 Ibid., p. 8. 10 Ibid., p. 9. 11 Ibid., p. 2. 12 Ibid., p. 11.
4
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
representation, becomes shorn of collectivity, the past, and in a certain sense, reality itself. This interpretation rings of a tone of modern alienation. Similarly, Nora’s concepts of history, modernity, and the nineteenth-century nation state fundamentally shape his argument, and lead us to ask how his assessment might or might not work for societies or communities that were not formed in the same national context. It is important to note, however, that for Nora there is some similarity between memory and history. Both are subject to manipulation. Memory can be appropriated and refashioned and is selective. History can be problematic and incomplete reconstruction; different motives and perspectives affect the nature and scope of the representation we call history. Approaches to Jewish Memory and History How have memory and history been assessed in Jewish historiography? Traditionally, the role of memory throughout Jewish history has been seen as important; formal history, however, has been cast as unimportant and often non-existent. Bernard Lewis, the renowned historian of Jews under Islam, for example, some thirty years ago noted that Jewish historiographic literature in the Middle Ages was sparse and poor.13 The purpose of “historical” writing—in the form of martyrologies, heroic narratives,14 commemorations,15 surviving custom and law,16 the history of scholarship and the succession of rabbis and pupils and teachers—was to give medieval Jews the ability to “stiffen the endurance of the survivors” and to legitimize the authority of the rabbis.17 Lewis contended that with no country, state, or dynastic focus, Jews lacked any real need to write history: the vital history was already fixed in Scripture, literature, and the calendar, and so the poverty of Jewish historiography was due not to neglect but to positive rejection.18 According to this line of thinking, critical history would develop only with the disaffection with the past and the desire to control the future.19 Medieval Jewish historiography was, for Lewis, poor, reactionary and intended as a means by which to continue religious traditions. The very topic of Jewish memory and history has received a great deal of attention since the Shoah. In the last quarter century in particular the floodgates opened for the production of a variety of scholarly investigations into the broader ways and purposes for which Jews remember the past. With some of the same assumptions as those forwarded by Lewis, and steeped in the theoretical orientation of Halbwachs and the emerging discussions surrounding Nora and his school, the prominent and ground-breaking historian Yosef Hayim Yerushalmi, in a slender volume of published lectures from the early 1980s, set the stage for much of the subsequent discussion of Jewish memory and history. Yerushalmi concretized some 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
Bernard Lewis, History: Remembered, Recovered, Invented (Princeton, 1975), p. 21. Ibid., p. 44. Ibid., pp. 45ff. Ibid., pp. 52ff. Ibid., p. 22. Ibid., p. 23. Ibid., p. 56.
Memory, History, and Jewish Identity
5
general observations about Jewish historiography and the relationship between memory and history, while forwarding an outline of the production and role of history and historiographical writing in Jewish tradition. In the pages that follow, I will restate Yerushalmi’s position, review some of the criticism and implications of his arguments, and then set a broader context—a context in which Yerushalmi was both participant and product—for the consideration of early modern German Jewish memory and history. For Yerushalmi, it was ancient Israel that “first assigned a decisive significance to history and thus forged a new world-view …”.20 The new perception was based in Israelite faith, by which “the crucial encounter between man and the divine shifted away from the realm of nature and the cosmos to the plane of history, conceived now in terms of divine challenge and human response.”21 Ancient Israel knew God for what He did in history; memory, therefore, became a central occupation.22 But even this remembering was not purely historical. The entire past was not the goal. Rather the idea of recollecting Jewish selection and uniqueness was central. Memory flowed in ancient Israel in two channels according to Yerushalmi, ritual and recital.23 Yerushalmi concludes that there is a paradox in Judaism in that although memory of the past has always been a central aspect of Jewish experience, and indeed, Jews have been divinely commanded “to remember,” it has not been the historian who has recorded that past, at least not before modern secular times.24 In the rabbinic period, the rabbis did not seek to write a new history of the biblical period, they simply sought meaning in the history they received. Nor did they demonstrate much interest in recording contemporary events.25 In the interval between the destruction of the Temple and the future redemption, the primary Jewish task was taken to be responding to the biblical challenge of becoming a holy people. While the biblical past was known and the messianic future assured, the time in between was obscure and needed to be understood according to a previously revealed pattern. The rabbis, therefore, were comfortable in making time elastic. They did not see anachronism as a flaw, nor did they see historical reckoning as of great value. This trend, according to Yerushalmi, continued through the Middle Ages. Jews devoted a great deal of time to “the position of the Jewish people in history, of ideas of Jewish history, of often profound and sometimes daring reflections on exile and redemption, but,” with the exception of the “chain of tradition” literature, expressed “comparatively little interest in recording the ongoing historical experience of the Jews.”26 As for Lewis, this lack of historiographical interest was not for Yerushalmi a flaw, but perhaps reflected a degree of self-sufficiency within Jewish culture itself.
20 Yosef Hayim Yerushalmi, Zakhor: Jewish History and Jewish Memory (Seattle, 1982), p. 8. 21 Ibid. 22 Ibid., p. 9. See also Eliade, Cosmos and History, p. 106. 23 Ibid., pp. 11, 15. 24 Ibid., p. xiv. 25 Ibid., p. 18. 26 Ibid., p. 31.
6
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
Jews did, however, create some historical narratives in the Middle Ages. But these typically focused on the distant past until the destruction of the Second Temple or on the most recent of events.27 New events, however, were generally assimilated within tried and familiar archetypes.28 “There are sufficient clues,” Yerushalmi argues, “to indicate that what was suddenly drawn up from the past was not a series of facts to be contemplated at a distance, but a series of situations into which one could somehow be existentially drawn.”29 For medieval and rabbinic Jews, the past provided a blueprint against which recent and contemporary life might be understood. Yerushalmi emphasizes the ritual and liturgical nature of Jewish history in the Middle Ages, noting that Jewish history was neither exclusively cyclical nor linear.30 He divides medieval Jewish histories into four categories: selihot, or penitential prayers—the religious and literary response to historical catastrophe inserted into the liturgy of the synagogue;31 memorial books, particularly kept by Ashkenazic Jews, that preserved “the names of those for whose souls communal prayers were to be offered in the house of worship;”32 “second Purims,” “instituted in Jewish communities … to commemorate a deliverance from some danger or persecution;”33 and the institution of specific fast days, which recalled “those more bitter occasions when there was no deliverance.”34 The typologies isolated by Yerushalmi as reflective of medieval Jewish historical thinking share a number of elements: they were largely in response to persecution; they were liturgical, ritual, and cyclical—not historical—remembrances of past events retold primarily within the synagogue at set times of the year (that is, they were “religious” and so, by many scholars’ definition, not historiographical); and, although they could reflect broader conditions, they were frequently related to local or regional events. According to Yerushalmi, although these remembrances could contain historical information they more often simply preserved essential memory of an event without necessarily preserving its historical details.35 As such, the methods and forms of memory produced in the Jewish Middle Ages were essentially reactive, religious, and local, at the same time that they were paradigmatic and not specific.36 For Yerushalmi, the situation seems to have changed subtly but significantly in the sixteenth century.37 The move to a more genuinely historiographical orientation at that time Yerushalmi attributes to the tragic event of the Spanish expulsion at the 27 Ibid., p. 34. 28 Ibid., p. 36. 29 Ibid., p. 44. 30 Ibid., p. 41. 31 Ibid., p. 45. 32 Ibid., p. 46. 33 Ibid., pp. 46ff. 34 Ibid., pp. 48ff. 35 Ibid., p. 51. 36 For a discussion on the paradigmatic nature of pre-modern religious and historical thinking in general, see Eliade, Cosmos and History, pp. 34ff. In discussing the regeneration of time, Eliade notes “an element of regeneration through repetition of an archetypal act, usually of the cosmogonic act” and the abolition of concrete time (p. 85). 37 Ibid., p. 57.
Memory, History, and Jewish Identity
7
end of the fifteenth century.38 In this period the history of post-biblical Jews and the history of the nations, particularly contemporary ones, were assigned positions of prominence.39 The shift to critical, historiographical thinking was, according to Yerushalmi, however, not completed until the modern, secular, period. During the sixteenth century instead of history, other outlets, such as Lurianic kabbalah eventually served to provide a psychological solution to the trauma of the expulsion. In modernity, the knowledge of history became more desirable, and with the Wissenschaft des Judentums, there were for the first time, according to Yerushalmi, no apologies for history. Judaism, in a sense, was forced to prove its validity to the world and reveal and justify itself historically. Such an effort to reconstruct the Jewish past, however, began only with a sharp break in the continuity of Jewish life, marked by assimilation without and collapse from within, in which Jewish historiography was divorced from Jewish collective memory. Similar to the position taken by Nora, history in the modern period, for Yerushalmi, became the faith of the fallen, particularly as the uniqueness of the Jews and divine providence in history were being challenged by Jews themselves. Reassessing Memory and History In response to Yerushalmi’s work, a lively debate ensued, with many embracing Yerushalmi’s synthesis, and a number of scholars challenging various aspects of Yerushalmi’s approach, assumptions, and conclusions. One reviewer, for example, writing with an eye toward Zionism and modern Israel, criticized Yerushalmi for suggesting that historical writing was a weak replacement for the fading memory that had more traditionally bound society together. Arguing that modern historiographical research was a positive and constructive force, this reviewer contended that new and deeper knowledge of history led to richer identity and that, in any event, the distant past known to modernity has little to distinguish it from the distant past known previously. The same reviewer made the more general criticism, that Yerushalmi considered only “canonical ‘historical writing,’” thereby ignoring a vast corpus of formal and informal historical works.40 (Despite such criticism, most subsequent studies have continued to focus on more traditional “historiographical” works.41) The eminent historian of Italian Jewry Robert Bonfil has also taken exception to Yerushalmi’s work, challenging the very assumption that the Jewish historiographical production of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries was rich at all. Bonfil asserts that the early modern period witnessed a sharpening of opposing dichotomies (Jewish and Christian) and an increase in the sense of the lachrymose in Jewish writings. The subject matter of history as conceived in the early modern period was largely political and military; however, the Jewish experience of the time could
38 Ibid., pp. 58–9. 39 Ibid., pp. 62–3. 40 See the review of Zakhor by Yaakov Shavit in Studies in Zionism 6 (1985): 143–47. 41 See, for example, Reuven Michael, Jewish Historiography from the Renaissance to the Modern Time (Jerusalem, 1993) [Hebrew].
8
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
supply no such history.42 According to Bonfil, therefore, radical change in Jewish historiography could only be achieved by recourse to two methods. Either Jews could be transformed into actors in political and military history, or the very conception of history could be changed. But, Bonfil concludes, the former was not possible under current conditions and the latter’s time had not yet come.43 Other scholars also responded to and challenged Yerushalmi’s assumptions and conclusions. Amos Funkenstein argued that although one might indeed claim that pre-modern Jews had no true historiography, it would be a mistake to claim that they had no historical consciousness.44 The implication was that although pre-modern Jews did not write formal histories, they might nevertheless have still thought historically. Similarly, in the late 1980s Ivan Marcus also made a very significant contribution to this discussion. Marcus distinguished between historiography more specifically and narratives about the past more broadly. According to Marcus, narratives of the past written by Sephardic Jews were mainly concerned with the rabbinic elites. Ashkenazic texts, on the other hand, generally described a broader social spectrum.45 In the Sephardic world, there was an importance attached to uninterrupted tradition. Continuity with an earlier classical past served as the basis for Sephardic legitimacy.46 Ashkenazic narratives, however, were focused on discontinuity in the community brought about by migration and trauma. Marcus writes that “the Ashkenazic texts seem to emerge especially at times when communal status is in decline, in comparison with an earlier time. The occasion for writing down a narrative about the past is not idle curiosity or 42 Robert (Reuven) Bonfil, “How Golden was the Age of the Renaissance in Jewish Historiography?” History and Theory 27 (1988): 78–102, here at pp. 93, 95. 43 Ibid., p. 101. 44 See David N. Myers, “Remembering Zakhor: A Super-Commentary,” History and Memory 2 (1992): 129–46. Myers contests Funkenstein’s position, and asks whether halakhic [legal] innovation “requires in and of itself historical consciousness, beyond a highly selective, perhaps hagiographic, recitation of one’s favorite scholarly antecedents” (p. 132). Myers maintains that Funkenstein provides no cogent explanation of a conceptual category for historical consciousness, which is intended to mediate collective memory and critical historical study (p. 133). 45 Ivan Marcus, “History, Story and Collective Memory: Narrativity in Early Ashkenazic Culture,” Prooftexts 10 (1990): 365–88, here at p. 379. This distinction is related to the important, if over-extended, theory of Gershon Cohen, regarding the differences between Sephardic and Ashkenazic culture. Cohen argues for the notion that Ashkenazic writing reveals submissiveness and acceptance of divine decrees, until God intervenes in history and restores His people. See Gershon Cohen, “Messianic Postures of Ashkenazim and Sephardim,” [reprinted] in Marc Saperstein (ed.), Essential Papers on Messianic Movements and Personalities in Jewish History (New York, 1992), pp. 202–33, here at p. 220. On the other hand, Cohen argues that Sephardic writing reveals political success and confidence in its own powers (p. 222). 46 Marcus, “History, Story, and Collective Memory,” p. 381. In this context, it might be interesting to consider the attitude toward Sephardic sources; see Eric Zimmer, Fiery Embers of the Scholars: The Trials and Tribulations of German Rabbis in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries (Jerusalem, 1999) [Hebrew], regarding the debate over the use of Sephardic sources in early modern Germany.
Memory, History, and Jewish Identity
9
even family pride or community self-respect but a perceived change or loss.” In a sophisticated application of this observation, he argues that, “the emphasis in the Ashkenazic narratives on the story of the changing holy community makes the remembered changes in the life of the community comparable to a dense, partially obscure, sacred text that requires interpretation.”47 Marcus assumes and then elaborates upon perceived distinctions between Ashkenazic and Sephardic culture and literary production. Working from this bifurcated model, Marcus asserts that Ashkenazic narratives were produced in response to crisis and decline. However, it is worth asking to what extent we can, or should, distinguish between Ashkenazic, and more specifically German, narratives and Sephardic narratives. Recent scholarship has indicated that differences may not have been as great as once perceived. In addition, the early modern period in Germany, just like the medieval, is clearly one that is much too complex to be denoted simply as one of crisis and decline. In fact, in some areas such as Hamburg, Prague, and Frankfurt am Main, one might more appropriately label the period one of rebirth and reintegration. Furthering the perceived differences in Ashkenazic and Sephardic experiences, Marcus’s position assumes that it is the Sephardim, because of their political audacity, and to some important extent political success, who used history for political purposes—to secure, legitimize, and challenge. But did Ashkenazic, specifically German Jewish, “histories” and memories simply retreat into a world of insulated religious segregation and passive waiting for divine intervention and salvation? Might we be able to detect instances when German Jews confronted, and co-opted, the past for other purposes than simply to lick their wounds and strengthen themselves through the hope, and expectation, of better days? Here, I take Marcus quite seriously when he suggests that Ashkenazic memory may tell us a good deal about broader social orientations and concerns; it is simply that I begin without the presupposition that early modern Ashkenazic Jews were necessarily apolitical or unengaged from the social, intellectual, and cultural streams in which they circulated and lived. In the chapters that follow, I will consider the extent to which narratives of the past can tell us about the nature of Jewish community and identity in early modern Germany, as well as how the actual condition of that Jewish community (those Jewish communities?) and the more general conditions of early modern Germany helped to shape such memories. The broader scholarly tradition from which Yerushalmi simultaneously drew and contributed has also generated significant response in recent years. The concepts forwarded by Halbwachs have been highly influential and much adapted, as in the work of Nora and some of his colleagues. Some recent scholarship has confirmed elements of Halbwachs’s argument, while other scholarship has refined, criticized, or even dismissed aspects of it. Amos Funkenstein, for example, had reservations about Halbwachs’s notion of collective memory, even while conceding that collective memory is not a mistaken or misleading term.48 Funkenstein concluded that while “memory can constitute self-consciousness, because self-identity presumes 47 Marcus, “History, Story, and Collective Memory,” p. 381. 48 Funkenstein, Perceptions of Jewish History, p. 4.
10
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
memory,” it also cannot be removed from its social context.49 Indeed, collective memory provides the systems of signs, symbols, and practices which instantiate individual memory.50 A good deal of recent scholarship has refined our understanding of memory and at the same time confirmed some of Halbwachs’s conclusions. Memory, it has been noted, consists of various components. It is changeable and subject to differing interpretations. Memories can take on different meanings in different contexts.51 Personal memories are culled from our perceptions. But these perceptions enter the consciousness, where they combine with other memories that then affect and transform them.52 Perceptions are affected by a variety of physical, psychological, and social factors. Memories, therefore, are constructs that take the raw data of these perceptions and reconstruct them into a broader context of knowledge and experience. Indeed, modern studies on memory have noted that “the process of recollection is not an exact one of information retrieval but rather one in which memories are put together from fragmented sources, often in a simplified form, according to pre-existing patterns. Remembering is a creative activity in which the past is constantly updated according to the requirements of the present.”53 Individual memories contribute to and are influenced by collective memories; the development of shared identity requires that individuals identify and agree on certain memories.54 There are of course also collective memories, some of which the individual him- or herself may never have experienced. Such collective memories at times seem to dictate beliefs and the rules of proper behavior.55 The apparent opposition of memory and history has received particular attention in recent scholarship. In his recent work on history and memory after Auschwitz, for example, Dominick LaCapra has criticized the underlying distinction between memory and history posited by Halbwachs and Nora. According to LaCapra, memory and history are clearly not the same, but they are equally clearly not the opposite either. “Memory,” LaCapra writes, “is a crucial source for history and has 49 Ibid. 50 Ibid., p. 6. 51 James Olney, Memory and Narrative: The Weave of Life-Writing (Chicago, 1998), p. 64. 52 Mary Carruthers, The Book of Memory: A Study of Memory in Medieval Culture (Cambridge, 1990), p. 339. 53 Catherine Cubitt, “Memory and Narrative in the Cult of Early Anglo-Saxon Saints,” in Yitzhak Hen and Matthew Innes (eds), The Uses of the Past in the Early Middle Ages (Cambridge, 2000), pp. 29–66, here at p. 31. 54 Ibid. See also Yerushalmi, Zakhor, p. xv, citing the work of Halbwachs. 55 Walter Pohl, “Memory, Identity and Power in Lombard Italy,” in Hen and Innes (eds), The Uses of the Past in the Early Middle Ages, pp. 9–28, here at p. 10. Regarding the imitation of saints’ lives, for example, see Cubit, “Memory and Narrative,” pp. 33–5. Although testaments of those who were not clergy or noblemen are harder to find north of the Alps before the fifteenth century, such models did serve important roles for the lay and lower orders. See Samuel K. Cohn, Jr., “The Place of the Dead in Flanders and Tuscany: Towards a Comparative History of the Black Death,” in Bruce Gordon and Peter Marshall (eds), The Place of the Dead: Death and Remembrance in Late Medieval and Early Modern Europe (Cambridge, 2000), pp. 17–43, here at p. 24.
Memory, History, and Jewish Identity
11
complicated relations to documentary sources. Even in its falsifications, repressions, displacements, and denials, memory may nonetheless be informative—not in terms of an accurate empirical representation of its object but in terms of that object’s often anxiety-ridden reception and assimilation by both participants in events and those born later.”56 Critically informed memory assists in determining what in history should be preserved in living tradition and history serves to test memory critically. LaCapra concludes that “In the foregoing respects one might contend that history and memory have a supplementary relation that is a basis for mutually questioning interaction or open dialectical exchange that never attains totalization or full closure. Memory is both more and less than history, and vice-versa …”.57 Keith Baker has similarly contested several aspects of Halbwachs’s conception of memory and history. First, he notes that Halbwachs suggests that history is written whereas memory is not, so that “the past moves from memory into history only when it leaves the living consciousness of social actors.”58 But, does writing down the past necessarily change or distance it?59 Second, Baker believes that Halbwachs assumes that history is a specialized discipline external to and above groups. Baker, however, contends that such a view ignores “the close relationship between the historian and the social and political milieu in which he writes, especially in periods before the creation of an organized historical profession.”60 In Baker’s early modernity—he focuses on the period of and leading up to the French Revolution—the historian as recorder of events is not detached from, indeed is often centrally located in relation to the events around him. The historian is affected by events while also affecting them at the same time. Finally, Baker also dismisses the idea that memory and history exist in a relationship that is purely oppositional. Noting that the past is “not always peaceably shed” and that numerous collective memories interact with each other, Baker asserts that the relationship between memory and history does not have to be irreversible. History can again become memory, as the past is redefined. “The opposition between memory and history,” Baker concludes, “appears to be less a simple dichotomy than a constantly shifting, dialectical relationship. History is memory contested; memory is history controlled and fixed.”61
56 Dominick LaCapra, History and Memory After Auschwitz (Ithaca, 1998), p. 19. 57 Ibid., p. 20. 58 Keith Baker, Inventing the French Revolution: Essays on French Political Culture in the Eighteenth Century (New York, 1990), p. 55. 59 Ibid.; see also Patrick H. Hutton, History as an Art of Memory (Hanover, NH, 1993). 60 Baker, Inventing the French Revolution, p. 55. 61 Ibid., p. 56. On the interconnectedness of history and memory, see Hutton, History as an Art of Memory, p. 77. See also David N. Myers, “Between Diaspora and Zion: History, Memory, and the Jerusalem Scholars” in David N. Myers and David B. Ruderman (eds), The Jewish Past Revisited: Reflections on Modern Jewish Historians (New Haven, 1998), pp. 88– 103, here at p. 89: “Rather, I would like to suggest that the categories of history and memory, often cast as irreparably detached from one another, may indeed be closer to one another than we often tend to think, that they may inhabit a continuum of attitudes toward the past …”.
12
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
At the heart of Baker’s analysis is the assertion that the representation of the past plays an important role in the power struggles of the present. Baker contends that “accepted understandings of the events and of the implications of the past constantly become subject to contestation, as social actors draw upon the powerful resources that these understandings offer in the service of competing claims.” He writes that “History, then, becomes the domain, not of discarded memory, but of disputed memory. It does not succeed to memory by an automatic social process; on the contrary, it challenges and subverts memory, bringing into contestation what was previously regarded as fixed.” In a criticism that is particularly meaningful for this study, Baker concludes that “the different analytical categories ascribed by Halbwachs to memory and history appear more clearly as opposing discursive strategies within a continuing competition to control the symbolic meaning of the past than as expressions of entirely different forms of social consciousness.”62 This emphasis on the competition to control the symbolic meaning of the past, with the power to craft new identity and to transform and reinforce collective identity and social order, underpins both memory and history, and in a sense makes the distinction between the two somewhat irrelevant. 63 A similar conclusion—if arrived at through very different means and with somewhat different assumptions—is posited by some “postmodern” historians, who have also been concerned with the relationship between memory, political power, and propaganda. 64 Value of the past, in this scheme, is related to its utility for control of power in the present.65 According to this approach, there is an important connection between the repetition and use of specific memories and the construction and maintenance of power within society.66 In surveying the postmodern literature, Patrick Hutton notes that, “the most powerful group takes possession of the past by crowding out the traditions of its competitors or by reshaping them to conform to its own conceptions.”67 62 Baker, Inventing the French Revolution, p. 57. 63 Pierre Nora also considers the confrontations between groups in flux that lead to the “sacralization of memory.” But his approach fixes these changes within the realm of memory, avoiding the continuum stressed by Baker. Nora contends that, “the social uses of memory are as diverse and varied as the rationales of identity. But the mechanisms involved as well as the reasons for the sacralization of memory are always the same: confrontations between groups subject to constant change and consolidated through constant revival of the memories on which their identities are based” (Realms of Memory: Rethinking the French Past, p. 636). See Patrick J. Geary’s Phantoms of Remembrance: Memory and Oblivion at the End of the First Millennium (Princeton, 1994), pp. 10–11, where Geary argues that Halbwachs “failed to see the political parameters of collective memory formation, and assumed that collective memory was a natural, nonpurposeful creation of a group while history was an intentional, political and manipulative process. He thus postulated a fundamental opposition between the two.” Geary cautions that “It would be a serious mistake to think that this collection of memories is simply the sum total of what he had experienced, heard and read. Rather memory is an active and creative faculty, constantly selecting, interpreting, and transforming experience” (p. 160). 64 Hutton, History as an Art of Memory, p. xv. 65 Ibid., p. 6. Regarding Foucault, he writes that “Rather than culling the past for residual memories, each age reconstructs the past with images that suit its present needs … The reality of the past, he maintained, resides in the artifacts of its representation.” 66 Ibid, p. 7. 67 Ibid., p. 128.
Memory, History, and Jewish Identity
13
The memory related to tradition, therefore, has been seen as an important vehicle both to preserve as well as to modify “the social frameworks of memory over time,” and the “defenders of tradition … are likely to buttress its places of memory through acts of commemoration.”68 The work of Eric Hobsbawm has been especially meaningful in this regard.69 Hobsbawm distinguishes between custom—“what judges do”—and tradition—the “formal paraphernalia and ritualized practices surrounding their substantial action.”70 The invention of traditions, Hobsbawm argues, is much more frequent “when a rapid transformation of society weakens or destroys the social patterns for which the ‘old’ traditions had been designed, producing new ones to which they were not applicable, or when such old traditions and their institutional carriers and promulgators no longer prove sufficiently adaptable and flexible, or are otherwise eliminated …”.71 In the period since the industrial revolution, Hobsbawm asserts that invented traditions belong to three overlapping types, those that seek to establish or symbolize social cohesion or the membership of groups (real or artificial communities); establish or legitimize institutions, status, or relations of authority; and socialize, or inculcate beliefs, value systems, or behavior.72 So, the nature as well as the mode of commemoration is important in power relations and identification. This study asks whether such uses of tradition were employed in the early modern period, and if so, with what implications? In sum, the theoretical discussions reveal that constructing, maintaining, and contesting the past may often go hand in hand and can have significant implications for internal communal structures and identity as well as the place of the community within a broader external environment. Indeed, as the historian Constantin Fasolt has argued recently, history is a form of self-assertion.73 Memory has great power in crafting group or social identity as well as in challenging the established order—it can be a means of separation or continuity.74 The continuum of memory and history reflects a powerful tool that can be utilized in both the conscious and unconscious narration of the past. It can be a formative influence or a descriptive one, revealing to us a great deal about the community or society in question. While memory can be shaped by cultural values and experiences, it can simultaneously create culture and social value and extend them into the future. The past, it seems, never exists in isolation. It is linked in a complex and dynamic relationship with the present, and through the present to the future as well. Identity may be formed through the active engagement with and continuation of the past, or
68 Ibid., p. 79. 69 See Eric Hobsbawm and Terence Ranger (eds), The Invention of Tradition (Cambridge, 1983). 70 Ibid., pp. 2–3. 71 Ibid., pp. 4–5. 72 Ibid., p. 9. 73 Constantin Fasolt, The Limits of History (Chicago, 2004), p. 230. 74 The narratives forged through memory, can, in fact, “come to shape the identity of an entire society” (see the Matthew Innes, “Introduction: Using the Past, Investigating the Present, Influencing the Future,” in Hen and Innes (eds), The Uses of the Past in the Early Middle Ages, pp. 1–8, here at p. 5).
14
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
through a more radical reinterpretation and separation from the past.75 According to one recent historian, … human life is never simply lived in the present alone but rather in three worlds: one that is, one that was, and one that will be. In theory we know these three worlds as separate concepts but we experience them as inextricably linked and as influencing each other in many ways. Every important new discovery about the past changes how we think about the present and what we expect of the future; on the other hand every change in the conditions of the present and in the expectations for the future revise our perception of the past …76
History, in this interpretation, engages the past while simultaneously trying to separate the present society from that past.77 Memory and History in the Middle Ages Do these theoretical conclusions resonate in what we know about the Middle Ages? In the Middle Ages the past was narrated and gained meaning through both memory and history. But what did memory and history mean in the Middle Ages? Already in the early Middle Ages, Augustine had noted that “the past is the remembered present, just as the future is the anticipated present: memory is always derived from the present and from the contents of the soul at present.”78 Memory in the Middle Ages as today was multivalent and its meaning closely connected with the form of its expression.79 When Augustine used the verb contexto, to weave together, he referred simultaneously to memory and narrative.80 And what of the concept of history in the Middle Ages? Since Antiquity history in the West was not a formal discipline in and of itself. It was originally a part of rhetoric, the art of persuasion in writing and speech.81 It also served at times as a form
75 According to one critical theorist, “In this way it [modern western history] is unlike tradition (religious tradition), though it never succeeds in being entirely dissociated from this archaeology, maintaining with it a relation of indebtedness and rejection” (Michel de Certeau, The Writing of History, trans. Tom Conley (New York, 1988; orig., 1975), pp. 2–3; see also p. 37). 76 Ernst Breisach, Historiography: Ancient, Medieval and Modern (2nd edition, Chicago, 1994 (orig., 1983)), p. 2. 77 De Certeau, The Writing of History, p. 37. 78 Funkenstein, Perceptions of Jewish History, p. 7. 79 Jörn Rüsen notes that the border between chronology and historiography is fluid; he argues that chronology is a proto-history. See Jörn Rüsen, “Die vier Typen des historischen Erzählens,” in Reinhart Kosseleck, Heinrich Lutz, and Jörn Rüsen (eds), Formen der Geschichtsschreibung (Munich, 1982), pp. 514–605, here at p. 544. Rüsen isolates four different types of narratives: traditional narratives (inherited from fathers) (p. 545); exemplary narratives (p. 547); critical narratives (opposed to tradition; weapons used in the battle against the memory of a symbol) (p. 551); and, genetic narratives (structural changes of a system) (p. 555). Indeed, the act of narration is significant, whether or not that narration is formal or modern historiography or not. 80 Olney, Memory and Narrative, p. 20. 81 Beryl Smalley, Historians in the Middle Ages (New York, 1974), p. 15.
Memory, History, and Jewish Identity
15
of ethics, as it did for Sallust,82 or it might be akin to biography,83 often beginning with a recounting of the author’s own personal experiences.84 It was only in biblical exegesis that historia had a special meaning, there as a literal understanding of Scripture.85 Medieval historians were thus not historians in the professional sense that we imagine them today,86 rather they were chroniclers and registers, who believed that the past was valuable as a means of instruction.87 According to the German historian Johannes Aventinus (1477–1534), for example: “For in the old histories as in a mirror, one views the life of the other and therefore takes from the other an image, to be reminded … what he should do or allow, what is in evil or good.”88 The connection between the value of the past and behavior and knowledge of the present was frequently maintained. Although some historians have been careful to stress the continuity of historical inquiry, even through the Renaissance,89 others have noted the important developments of the later Middle Ages, and even the work of the medieval scholastics in the creation of greater systematization and the production of new historical-moral works.90 In the later Middle Ages, it has been argued, history increasingly functioned as a guarantee, a centrum securitatis, of the continued life of the individual and the community.91 In discussing the motives for the work of the late medieval German town chronicles, F.R.H. Du Boulay articulates various purposes that could exist alone or in any combination, motives that revolve around issues of politics, personal need, and professional employment. Late medieval town chronicles might furnish memorials of a leading family; record the ceremonial reception of kings; keep reports on feuds and wars, which the town engaged against external enemies; chronicle internal rebellions; and allow for the author’s own gratification, reward, or commission.92
82 Ibid., p. 19. 83 Ibid., p. 21. 84 Ibid., p. 24. 85 Herbert Grundmann, Geschichtsschreibung im Mittelaler: Gattungen—Epochen— Eigenart (Göttingen, 1965), p. 5. 86 František Graus, “Funktionen der spätmittelalterlichen Geschichtsschreibung,” in Hans Patze (ed.), Geschichtschreibung und Geschichtsbewusstsein im späten Mittelalter (Sigmaringen, 1987), pp. 11–55, here at p. 13. 87 Ibid., p. 18. 88 Ibid., p. 19. 89 František Graus, “II. Zusammenfassung der Tagung Oktober 1981,” in Patze (ed.), Geschichtschreibung und Geschichtsbewusstsein im späten Mittelalter, pp. 838–45, here at p. 840, where he argues that there was no radical break between chronicling and historical writing in the old sense and the so-called humanistic historiography. 90 Hans Patze, “Zusammenfassungen: I. Zusammenfassung der Tagungen Oktober 1980 und Oktober 1982,” in Patze (ed.), Geschichtschreibung und Geschichtsbewusstsein im späten Mittelalter, pp. 821–38, here at pp. 824, 835. 91 Graus, “Funktionen der spätmittelalterlichen Geschichtsschreibung,” p. 55. 92 F.R.H. Du Boulay, “The German Town Chroniclers,” in R.H.C. Davis and J.M. Wallace-Hadrill (eds), The Writing of History in the Middle Ages: Essays Presented to Richard William Southern (Oxford, 1981), pp. 445–69, here pp. 448–9.
16
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
History was very fluid in the Middle Ages, and could be expressed in a variety of literary genres.93 As with memory, the very narration of the past could be an active tool in political propaganda,94 and in many lands in the later Middle Ages one can find a noticeable increase in the social and political uses of historiography.95 In the midst of revolts or other crises, for example, an ideal and lost past might be promoted or castigated96 and the past itself might be suborned as a witness to the “truth.”97 Throughout the Middle Ages history could serve as a means of legitimization, interchanging “good” and “old” law,98 noting the “good old time” and so constructing social order,99 or illustrating the authority of God.100 History, as the recalling of both memory and tradition, could serve as a means to legitimate or defend authority.101 The process of writing history might argue for legitimate knowledge, and such knowledge could form a self-defining center.102 Histories, therefore, were (and continue to be) powerful tools that mediate relationships and define identities.103 Historians—as creators and re-tellers of the narrative—themselves could become brokers of power,104 a particularly intriguing concept with the dramatic changes in Western Europe in the early modern period— 93 Graus, “Funktionen der spätmittelalterlichen Geschichtsschreibung,” pp. 25–6. 94 Ibid., pp. 28–9. 95 Ibid., p. 33. 96 Ibid., p. 34; others have also seen the birth of historiography in the fifteenth century. See, for example, Anna-Dorothee von den Brincken, “Die Rezeption mittelalterliche Historiographie durch den Inkunabeldruck,” in Patze (ed.), Geschichtsschreibung und Geschichtsbewusstsein im späten Mittelalter, pp. 215–36, where it is argued that historiography first appeared in the last third of the fifteenth century. 97 Graus, “Funktionen der spätmittelalterlichen Geschichtsschreibung,” p. 54. 98 Ibid., p. 23. 99 Ibid., p. 31. 100 Ibid., p. 24. 101 Leah Shopkow, History and Community: Norman Historical Writing in the Eleventh and Twelfth Centuries (Washington, 1997), p. 253. 102 De Certeau, The Writing of History, p. 127. For Michel de Certeau, narration is the art of speaking as an art of operating and of thinking; as such, it includes both practice and theory. That is to say, that ways of operating designate activities but also organize construction. Narration therefore is different than mere description. The act of narration has more meaning than the actual object or end point that the narration completes. For de Certeau, there also exists a contextual network of messages and operations; “knowledge” is a memory, with many different moments and heterogeneous elements. The very duration of that knowledge and the retelling of that knowledge intercede and change those moments and elements. See also his The Practice of Everyday Life, trans. Steven Rendall (Berkeley, 1984). Some historians have, nevertheless, maintained that it is in fact possible to discern true from false narrative, and, consequently that history both represents facts and participates in making them. Nevertheless, historians themselves make history by deciding what to record and what to ignore (Funkenstein, Perceptions of Jewish History, pp. 30ff). 103 “Histories reflected political relationships of various kinds, including relationships between institutions, between institutions and their communities, and between rulers and their subjects” (Shopkow, History and Community, p. 258). 104 See de Certeau, The Writing of History, p. 7.
Memory, History, and Jewish Identity
17
territorialization, the creation of the centralized state, the scientific development of disciplines of knowledge,105 and the crisis of authority, for example. In order to speak of a real historical tradition, František Graus stipulates three requirements: the narrative in the past is projected and is somehow relevant for the present—curiosities do not found a tradition; the narrative must be differentiated from “folklore;” and the narrative must be passed over a certain period from generation to generation orally or in written form. Graus has asserted, however, that a simple consciousness of the past, which appears in different forms, is older than all chronological historical writing. This consciousness may be clothed in mythic forms and report on the beginning of time. It serves fundamentally to bind the members of a society (Gemeinschaft), through a common past.106 The process of narrating memory and history could lead to moralizing, since the narratives require a system within which to be understood.107 But narratives of the past could also be moral in a different, broader sense as well. They involve the ethics of selecting and re-presenting the past. In describing Norman historical writing in the eleventh and twelfth centuries, Leah Shopkow notes that “in the process of writing a history, the historian decided not only what ought to be remembered but also structured how the material was to be remembered, offering as a substitute for personal, social, and self-referential memories external and abstract written accounts.” Therefore, as the medievalist Brian Stock notes, “historical writing does not treat reality; it treats the interpreter’s relation to it.”108 The historian is involved in the process of creating as much as the “facts” and “texts” are,109 and as such, the product—historical writing—“is thus an apologetic whose moral is coherence.”110 Memory itself becomes moral, and so has the power to define proper behavior and to focus on the (ideal) qualities that identify a group.111 Conclusion As we have seen, in theoretical discussions as well as actual application in the Middle Ages, narration of the past could take different forms and serve a wide range of purposes. Whether couched as memory or more formal history, engagement with the past could be a powerful tool for locating authority (to challenge or uphold it), mediating relationships, and dictating proper behavior. As such, the “remembering” and use of the past played a central role in the formation, identity, and even transformation of communities. What is more, the narrators of the past themselves 105 Ibid., p. 60. 106 František Graus, Lebendige Vergangenheit: Überlieferung im Mittelaletr und in den Vorstellungen vom Mittelalter (Cologne, 1975), p. 1. 107 Consider Hayden White, for example, as discussed in Cubit, “Memory and Narrative,” p. 48. 108 Brian Stock, The Implications of Literacy: Written Language and Models of Interpretation in the Eleventh and Twelfth Centuries (Princeton, 1983), p. 80. 109 Ibid., p. 83. 110 Ibid., p. 84. 111 See Shopkow, History and Community, p. 257.
18
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
served an important function in both recording and structuring community as well as internal and external communal relations. While early modern Jewish communities are generally seen as somehow “traditional” and religious and often simplistic in their understanding and use of the past, we now ask whether early modern German Jews narrated the past, through memory or history, for more sophisticated purposes than simply religious ritual.
Chapter 2
Reconsidering Early Modern German Jewish Memory and History1 Paradigms in Jewish Memory Traditionally, scholars have found pre-modern Jewish memory to be paradigmatic rather than historical. Jacob Neusner, for example, has asserted that time telling in classical Judaism made no distinction between past and present, utilizing paradigmatic modes of thought rather than historical ones.2 He concluded that Jews were indifferent to the specifics of context3 and that “the Judaism of the dual Torah transforms ancient Israel’s history into the categorical structure of eternal Israel’s society, so that past, present, and future meet in the here and now.”4 Similar conclusions have been drawn for medieval Jewish literary production. Regarding Abraham Ibn Daud’s (c.1110–1180) tale of four rabbis taken captive by a Muslim sea raider, for example, Gerson Cohen argued that the tale is not a historical account, but rather a homily, a romance with a moral. It was meant to be consolation for Jews, and it relied heavily on a symmetry in which historical reckoning is imprecise and history conforms to a set pattern.5 Likewise, in examining Hebrew narratives of the 1096 crusade riots, Ivan Marcus contended that, “The events actually reported qualify for inclusion only when they fit the narrator’s preconceived religious-literary schema. Medieval chronicles are, in this sense, fictions: imaginative re-orderings of experience within a cultural framework
1 For a very concise and good treatment of Jewish approaches to history in general, see Jay R. Berkovitz, “Does Jewish History Repeat Itself? Paradigm, Myth and Tradition,” in Dean Phillip Bell (ed.), The Solomon Goldman Lectures, vol. VII (Chicago, 1999), pp. 131–53. 2 Jacob Neusner, “History, Time, and Paradigm in Classical Judaism,” in Approaches to Ancient Judaism, Volume XVI, pp. 189–211, here at pp. 189–90. 3 Ibid., p. 190. 4 Ibid., p. 192. 5 Gerson Cohen, “The Story of the Four Captives,” Proceedings of the American Academy for Jewish Research 29 (1960–61): 70–123, here at p. 95. Cohen writes that, “It is a remarkable fact that virtually no modern scholar has taken seriously Ibn Daud’s repeated contention that history is not a mere record of past events, but essentially a source of consolation for the Jew.” Cohen notes the importance of symmetry in Ibn Daud’s account (overriding biblical passages or historical information) (p. 101); that rough correspondence is sufficient (p. 102); that history is always shown to conform to a pattern (p. 105); and that the reckoning of time is rather vague and imprecise, as when the text notes that “‘4750 a bit more or less’” (p. 108) or when years serve as allusions (p. 111).
20
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
and system of symbols.”6 The accounts were preoccupied with eschatology,7 were as liturgical as they were chronological,8 and utilized central paradigms placed into new situations: Mainz became Jerusalem, for example, as Speyer became Yavneh.9 Indeed, in their approach to pre-modern Jewish memory, most scholars assume that pre-modern Judaism and Jews were a religious and homogenous group.10 Traditional and religious sensibility—often catchwords for subjective and non-critical—is therefore seen as fundamental to any Jewish engagement with the past. The consequences are that pre-modern Judaism is often seen to be unable or unwilling to differentiate modes of temporality, especially past and present, and to be able to understand the past merely in religious ways, primarily through paradigms created in biblical or talmudic texts or the paradigm of causality expressed through the motif of sin and repentance. It is worth reconsidering these assumptions. Given the function of narrations of the past in the Middle Ages and more generally that we saw in the first chapter, what can we say about Jewish memory and history in early modern Germany? Early Modern Paradigms: Sin and Penance as Causal Explanations For Jews, as for their medieval and early modern Christian counterparts, historical events were often seen to follow a particular pattern. The present was understandable within the context of tried and true typologies, or else seen to comport to some divine plan hatched at the time of creation and discernible through various means of biblical interpretation. The paradigm of four world empires that would rise and fall in succession before an expected messianic culmination, for example, was frequently espoused and described. Such a model made the unfolding of history and the ongoing suffering of the Jews understandable, and at times reassuring. The paradigm of the four world empires was not limited to Jewish writers and thinkers and it was still a marvelously powerful tool of interpretation and historical organization even when criticized by early modern Germans. Such an approach seemed to make history disposable and the past understandable only by recourse to theological models and considerations. There were other standard theological ways in which Jews attempted to understand the defeats and victories of the past and present. Early modern Jews, like their Christian contemporaries, traded in an “economy of sin,” in which various misfortunes were attributed to sin and eventual salvation to sincere repentance.11
6 Ivan Marcus, “From Politics to Martyrdom: Shifting Paradigms in the Hebrew Narratives of the 1096 Crusade Riots,” Prooftexts 2 (1982): 40–52, here at p. 42. 7 Ibid., p. 45. 8 Ibid., p. 42. 9 Ibid., pp. 49, 51. 10 Jewish feminists have offered a critique of this assumption. See, for example, Judith Plaskow, Standing Again at Sinai: Judaism from a Feminist Perspective (San Francisco, 1991). 11 See the general literature in the recent work on natural disaster in the early modern period. In particular, the concept of an “economy of sin,” is discussed in Wolfgang Behringer, “‘Kleine Eiszeit’ und Frühe Neuzeit,” in Wolfgang Behringer, Hartmut Lehmann, and
Reconsidering Early Modern German Jewish Memory and History
21
Such an economy took on added significance within the context of various discussions about the power of God and the unique position of God’s chosen people, the Jews. The important early modern legal authority, Yair Hayyim Bacharach, for example, utilized fairly traditional language when, in his introduction to Mekor Hayyim, he noted that “Because of our sins our city of Worms was destroyed in 5449, 13 of Sivan [1 June, 1689, by the French army].”12 Of the same event, he wrote in his Havot Yair, that “In the course of time there came upon us a year of curses. In 5449, 13 of Sivan our city was destroyed and because of our great sins our Beit-ha-Mikdash, our small synagogue, was desolate. The residents of our holy congregation [of Worms] left in terror and became wanderers and roamers.” The description of the destruction mirrored in microcosm the more general and grander history of the destruction of the Temple and the dispersion of the Jews, while linking the event with Jewish sins. In confronting the hostilities of the Fettmilch uprising in early seventeenth-century Frankfurt, the author of the Megillat Vintz, a recounting cast into a rather traditional Purim tale, similarly drew a direct line of causality between sin and suffering. “How great must have been our sins,” he reflected, “even if we did not want to admit it.”13 He pointed out that “many overwhelming disasters had befallen our community up until that time. For eight or nine years we had not slept peacefully.” But the underlying explanation was sin: “The cause of all this was our great sins, revealed or hidden. God, Blessed be He, has directed us that we should act with care. And this is the duty of each one of us … Therefore, we shall turn away from our evil ways. The miracles and wonders shall not be forgotten.”14 In stressing the relation between perceived sin and tragedy, an early seventeenthcentury anonymous Prague chronicle ran through a litany of cause and effect statements, positing specific community events, such as expulsions and fires in the Jewish street, as the result of community sins. “1559 Due to our iniquities, there was a fire in the Judenstrasse here in Prague, in which seventy-two houses were consumed by the flames, as well as the Hochschul [college, referring to a yeshiva?]. This occurred on the 17th of Tammuz [a traditional day of fasting and mourning; in that year on 22 June]. A woman named Friedel Niches perished in the fire as well, due to our iniquities.”15 In part, the purpose of such recounting was to serve as a memory for the future. The Prague chronicler simply explained that “I shall recount the events occurring in the Exile subsequent to the fifth millennium: the expulsions, miracles, and news of other occurrences befalling [the Jews] in Prague and the other lands of our long exile because of our iniquities, to serve as a token of remembrance
Christian Pfister (eds), Kulturelle Konsequenzen der ‘Kleinen Eiszeit’ (Göttingen, 2005), pp. 415–508, here at pp. 466–7. 12 Shlomo Eidelberg, Medieval Ashkenazic History: Studies on German Jewry in the Middle Ages, Volume I English Essays (New York, 1999), p. 168. 13 Rivka Ulmer, Turmoil, Trauma and Triumph: The Fettmilch Uprising in Frankfurt am Main (1612–1616) According to Megillas Vintz (Frankfurt am Main, 2001), p. 127. 14 Ibid., p. 197. 15 Abraham David (ed.), A Hebrew Chronicle from Prague, c. 1615, trans. Leon J. Weinberger with Dena Ordan (Tuscaloosa, 1993), pp. 46–7.
22
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
for us and our descendants forever.”16 The re-telling of specifics, however, might also serve as something of a communal record akin to a ledger. Conversely, salvation in many early modern Jewish narratives was generally attributed to Jewish penance and prayer. According to the Megillat Vintz, for example, “we trusted in Him, Blessed be He. He turned them away because we trusted in His holy and eternal name. We repented and afflicted ourselves with fasting and prayer. We thought we could avert the harsh, Divine decree and our great troubles.”17 The causal relationship between Jewish spiritual action and political deliverance was seen as direct. It was God who saved the Jews from their troubles, but only after Jewish prayer and repentance. Moralizing was, therefore, intimately connected with the narratives of the past that sought to explain both tragedy and redemption.18 Beyond the Use of Paradigms Throughout the early modern narratives, the language of “our sins” was common and rather formulaic.19 But should the frequent invocation of causality between sin and tragedy and repentance and deliverance be taken purely literally? Did Jews ascribe salvation only to divine intervention? Was there room for other explanations of past events? Was the causal relationship different in different Jewish narratives or in different contexts? The seventeenth-century Prague rabbi Yom-Tov Lipman Heller, for example, in describing the 1648 Chmielnicki massacres did not see the massacres only as punishment for perceived Jewish sins, but rather attributed them largely to contemporary political conditions. Indeed, as his writings make clear, Heller did not maintain an ahistorical concept of Jewish suffering.20 Was this a view shared by other early modern Jews? Even when paradigms were the primary explanatory discourse, it is not enough to say that the use of paradigms or traditional narration of the past implied that early modern Jews were only religious or simply static. In what follows we will see that paradigms could be used both to initiate and suppress change. Paradigms could have varying levels of meaning and application—local, regional, national, and even
16 Ibid., p. 21. 17 Ulmer, Turmoil, Trauma and Triumph, p. 113. 18 In a sense, the events of the past had the capacity to reflect and renew the eternal and ongoing covenant between God and His people. The power of God could at times, however, be activated for the assistance of the Jews, even without Jewish action. The anonymous Prague chronicle reported that the King allowed the expelled Jews to return, with the help of God, and did not mention Jewish penance: “5301 [1541]— King Ferdinand, may he be exalted, expelled [the Jews] from all the cities of Bohemia, and here in Prague only ten [Jewish] householders remained. Subsequently, he allowed them to return, with the help of God.” (David (ed.), A Hebrew Chronicle from Prague, pp. 44–5) The actions of the Jews mattered little in this case, since the King was apparently divinely inspired to allow the Jews back into his realm. 19 See, for example, the note by Abraham David regarding the language in the anonymous Prague Chronicle, which he argues is not intended to be literal (ibid., p. 21). 20 See Joseph Davis, Yom-Tov Lipman Heller: Portrait of a Seventeenth-Century Rabbi (Oxford, 2004), pp. 11, 13. See also pp. 146–51 for examples from Heller’s Megilat eivah.
Reconsidering Early Modern German Jewish Memory and History
23
universal. Paradigms could be employed for a variety of purposes and in numerous contexts that belie simple or unwavering engagement with the past. When the community ledgers of the Prague community stressed that “our sins” have led to recent misfortunes, such emphasis did not have to be read only as a paradigmatic understanding of the past, with suffering as the divine punishment for sin. The mention of sins, in this case, provided a current means for moral upbraiding and the reinforcement of old, or the introduction of new, laws. According to one part of the ledger: And here, in the month of Tishri 372, by the shorter calculation [1611], we have gathered together to review what is happening within our holy community. For several days now we have observed a great number of misfortunes around us, as well as terrible dread, the most recent being lives cut sort. For a considerable number of people and children, boys and girls, have died, and they say that surely our sins have brought this upon us. Perhaps there are hidden sins, and we have decided in God’s name, and so that He may relent and take pity on those of us who remain and heal our dear ones … it has thus been decided with the consent of our holy community, to issue a law that must be respected by all those within the gates of our town who must observe it down to its precise details, which will be clarified below.21
While the document clearly posited the relationship between misfortune and sin, it also afforded the opportunity to initiate significant changes in communal legislation. At times, it was, in fact, the present and current social and political conditions that themselves gave meaning to the past! Throughout many of the narratives examined here, the past was utilized as a means to legitimate current practices or lobby for changes. The Frankfurt community minutes provide an excellent example. There it was recorded: “In the year (5)302 [1542], the heads of the people together with the scholars and the leaders of Germany assembled at Worms to correct the state of affairs of Germany. They renewed and re-issued this matter because the ordinance of the ancients was worthy in their eyes. The following scholars were mentioned specifically and signed the document … What motivated them to engage in this burden was (the fact) that they saw the later generations, including their scholars and their leaders, lose heart and faith. Perhaps, some rabbis intentionally and brutally lorded over ‘a holy people’ for their own welfare, benefit and selfaggrandizement.”22 Engagement with the past, of course, was not necessarily the same as acceptance of the past. As the Rules of the hevra kadisha (burial society) of Prague (1692–1702) demonstrate, past decisions and practices could be a means for measuring current 21 Sylvie Anne Goldberg, Crossing the Jabbok: Illness and Death in Ashkenazi Judaism in Sixteenth- through Nineteenth-Century Prague, trans. Carol Cosman (Berkeley, 1996) p. 227, “Rulings and Practices of the Sages of our Community of Prague, issued in the month of Tishri 5372 [1611].” 22 See also the following excerpt: “Now, therefore, we, the young of the flock have humbly proceeded [to re-endorse] the ordinance of the ancients which we view favorably. We listened intently to all their words and have reissued it as a new ordinance.” Eric Zimmer, Jewish Synods in Germany during the Late Middle Ages (1286–1603) (New York, 1978), p. 143.
24
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
practices, deciding proper behavior, and giving a very real sense of authority to both old and new decisions. While the past did possess, in these contexts, a sanctity of its own, it is worth noting that the past could be selected and filtered. It had real meaning only in reference to the present, which could choose to continue, endorse, or, by inference, discard past practices. Often current legislation issued from “old rules,” or it indicated that an “old article may be preserved.” Old rules, however, might also be judged inappropriate or not reissued.23 Even when placing events within a traditional paradigm, such as those refracted into the Purim story, early modern narratives often stressed the unique features and meanings of the events being presented. The introduction to the Megillat Vintz, for example, noted its compilation at the hands of local and distinguished scholars. It detailed the “enormous hardships that befell the Frankfurt community,” specifically to inform and edify the present and future generations, by making public a very special miracle manifest in the eventual salvation of the Jewish community.24 The song recorded that: “We (the Jews) all gathered in a hurry in front of the Bockenheimer Pfort [Bockenheim Gate] with all of the members of our households. We had come from everywhere, as had the other householders who had lived under other lords. They, like we, were running to Frankfurt to be able to see what was going to happen in order that they could tell future generations.”25 While presenting the local events of the Fettmilch uprising and maintaining the local emphasis on Frankfurt and its Jewish community, the song also universalized the meaning of the events for all Jews. Like many early modern chronicles, local, regional, and universal issues and identities could be intimately connected. The anonymous seventeenth-century chronicle from Prague also reported on a broad array of events throughout Bohemia, while offering a special emphasis on the resonance of those events on the Jewish community in Prague. At times the balance between local and regional could be utilized to emphasize the effects of regional developments on or to demonstrate the unique standing of the Prague community. The chronicle was, therefore, local but subsumed within a larger regional context. The chronicle noted, for example, that “Due to our iniquities, there was another decree expelling [the Jews] from all the cities of Bohemia, and here, in Prague, only twelve [Jewish] householders remained.”26 When paradigms were employed, it is worth considering why certain paradigms were selected, for what purposes, with what meanings, and in what contexts. The emphasis on the Purim story and the figure of Esther in particular was, for example, an important motif for Portuguese Jews returning to Judaism in late sixteenth- and 23 For example: “which practices to uphold, both old and new”; “from a document written on an ancient tablet”; “this is a rule from former times …”; “there is an old law that dates back many years … ” (p. 219); “and this issues also from the old rules”; “it was decided to extend an old article” (p. 220); “for this day was chosen a long time ago”; “a general endorsement of an old article of ours”; “this, too, is contained in the old articles” (p. 221); “issues from the old rules”; “This is also an old article that we shall preserve”; “An old rule forbids …” (p. 222). All in Goldberg, Crossing the Jabbok. 24 Ulmer, Turmoil, Trauma and Triumph, p. 90. 25 Ibid., p. 179. 26 David (ed.), A Hebrew Chronicle from Prague, pp. 44–5.
Reconsidering Early Modern German Jewish Memory and History
25
early seventeenth-century Amsterdam and Hamburg.27 These Jews could identify with Esther as the hidden Jew as well as the threats to expulsion and pogrom that were eventually overcome.28 The past was highly engaged and could be highly charged, especially in the numerous comparative statements or equations that appear throughout early modern German Jewish literature. The use of comparison could serve as a means to explain recent events within the spectrum of broader communal or Jewish history—giving that event greater and more relevant meaning—or to demonstrate the uniqueness of a particular event. Often such comparison was rather general, and intended to convey the sense that current events were important or central. The anonymous Prague chronicler wrote that “and the multitude was so great that it erased the memory of former armies.” The Megillat Vintz similarly expressed that, “We had a time of great distress as had never before been the case in our time”29 and in another place that “It was in the year 372, at that time in the great (honorable) city of Frankfurt, a great fight broke out, like none other ever seen before on the face of the earth.”30 In more dramatic fashion some comparison could be quite stirring, directing readers back to central events in Jewish history. Often such comparison presupposed audience familiarity with a range of texts, personalities, and stories. The Megillat Vintz drew significant parallels with the Purim story, writing that “This is what Vintz Hans himself spoke against us. ‘I am your present Haman; I am not afraid of (another) Mordechai, there are no such pious people among you.’”31 Not only was the paradigm of the Purim story replicated, but the central evil character himself
27 See Berkovitz, “Does Jewish History Repeat Itself?,” p. 145. See also Miriam Bodian, Hebrews of the Portuguese Nation: Conversos and Community in Early Modern Amsterdam (Bloomington, 1997), pp. 10, 172 (note 24 for references). 28 Analogies in historical writing “transcend their historical specificity,” and connect past and present. And yet, different durations and periods of time possess different social value (note the concept of overtime). See Eviatar Zerubavel, Time Maps: Collective Memory and the Social Shape of the Past (Chicago, 2003), pp. 26, 45, 50. In this regard, Zerubavel argues that “History thus takes the form of a relief map, on the mnemonic hills and dales of which memorable and forgettable events from the past are respectively featured. Its general shape is thus formed by a handful of historically ‘eventful’ mountains interspersed among wide, seemingly empty valleys in which nothing of any historical significance seems to have happened …” (p. 27). Regarding national memory, he adds that: “As far as national memory is concerned … the social shape of the past is essentially bimodal, with most of the events commemorated on national holidays having occurred either in the very distant past or within the last two hundred years. Events that are calendrically commemorated by nations thus typically form two chronologically dense clusters representing their respective spiritual and political origins and separated from each other by long stretches of commemoratively ‘empty’ time” (p. 31). That certain events or comparisons were more frequently cited, then, is not surprising. That early modern German Jews presented patterns of historical memory in a similar fashion implies that such presentations need not be dismissed as ahistorical or simply paradigmatic. 29 Zimmer, Synods, p. 103. 30 Ulmer, Turmoil, Trauma and Triumph, p. 97. 31 Ibid., p. 135.
26
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
proclaimed his affinity with Haman. In other sections the song elicited comparisons with David and Goliath,32 and, quite incredibly, even the Exodus from Egypt.33 At other times, recourse to the past served to moralize by contrasting perceived low contemporary standards with the exceptional people or behaviors of the past. According to the now famous late seventeenth and early eighteenth century Jewish memoir writer Glückel of Hameln, who had an impressive present-mindedness about her, “To tell the truth, she didn’t have to burden herself with many wares, because formerly people were satisfied with a small turnover.”34 A private Prague letter from 1619, likewise distinguished between “nowadays” and previous times: “What shall I tell you about this? I think you are clever enough to imagine what could happen in such a time. Now we have been saved from this peril, we have certainly profited by the merits of our ancestors. And I particularly have suffered terribly. I have not saved a penny for my own needs, if, God forbid, my life were to be endangered. Nowadays nobody is ready to lend anything to other people, from one hand into another. When I needed something for living, I was obliged to offer double pledges and to pay high interest.”35 In a similar vein, even more formal community accounts, such as the minutes from the Frankfurt Jewish community, utilized comparison with the past to brandish before community members a moral yardstick. It observed that, “If such was the case with previous generations most certainly beyond any doubt [it is with] the contemporary generation of their students’ students which are orphaned and which decline from day to day!”36 While the Temple was much discussed by Jews and Christians in the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries, it is revealing that a simple letter from 1619 found the Temple as an appropriate comparative image: “I had much to write you about horrible things, but I cannot write, about the affliction we had to endure here when riots almost occurred in our streets. It was like at the destruction of the Temple.”37 One of course would be hard pressed to believe that the author wanted to make such a direct comparison. But as a tool to activate the sense of great loss and turmoil, the 32 Ibid., p. 137. 33 “This can be compared to the powerful Exodus from Egypt where we had been slaves. All that has occurred has been the work of God to prevent (our) pride and wrongdoing or any other transgression. God, Blessed be He, cannot be deceived” (ibid., p. 197). See also the anonymous Prague chronicle, which recounted: “I shall recount another miracle as great as the Exodus from Egypt and the Splitting of the Red Sea” (David (ed.), A Hebrew Chronicle from Prague, p. 66). 34 Glückel of Hameln, The Memoirs of Glückel of Hameln, trans. Marvin Lowenthal (New York, 1977; orig., 1932), p. 14 (Glikl Hamil, Memoirs (Buenos Aires, 1967) [Yiddish], p. 50). She also writes that, “no such arrogance reigned in the old days as now, and people were not wont to eat such costly meals” (p. 267; see the Yiddish version, pp. 340–41). 35 Sarel, daughter of Moses, to her husband Loeb Sarel Gutmans, November, 1619, in Franz Kobler (ed.), A Treasury of Jewish Letters: Letters from the Famous and the Humble (London, 1952), vol. II, pp. 466–7. For early modern letters, compare Steven Ozment, Flesh and Spirit: Private Life in Early Modern Germany (New York, 1999). 36 Zimmer, Synods, p. 145. 37 Sarel, daughter of Moses, to her husband Loeb Sarel Gutmans, November, 1619, in Kobler (ed.), A Treasury of Jewish Letters, pp. 466–7.
Reconsidering Early Modern German Jewish Memory and History
27
destruction of the Temple was perceived as an appropriately stirring image. This does not imply that early modern Jews diminished the importance of the past by recalling it in such casual terms; nor does it indicate that Jews could not understand the past or present outside of paradigms. In fact, such comparisons might indicate that early modern Jews were more creative and thoughtful about their use of the past, a use that encompassed all aspects of Jewish life, not simply religious traditions and dogmatism. Resort to the past of paradigms should not, therefore, be seen as simply bowing to the past. Such discourse allowed Jews to reshape, recalibrate, or even explain change. Temporality: The Relation of Past and Present Beginning with the Renaissance, some have argued, a clearer separation of past and present developed. According to one recent study, Renaissance historical writings are characterized, more or less noticeably, by awareness of historical distance. In its purest forms, this sophistication found expression in the principle of anachronism, which began to be current among the learned and remained with them. The popular chronicles, even those of Italian provenance, did not always share the full clarity of the new perspective. Nonetheless, even they reflected, however dimly or brightly, the age’s preoccupation with the past as past.38
In traditional Jewish historiography, however, it has been generally assumed that until the end of the eighteenth century Jews “essentially inhabited a temporal world of their own,” with Jews living in a predominantly eschatological time frame.39 According to this line of thinking, it was only with nineteenth-century modern historical thinking that “pre-modern temporal continuity” gave way to “a model of succession that privileged the present over the past.”40 In this world, the distance between experience and expectation widened, as the breakdown of tradition and the crisis of time made both the past and the future seem more distant.41 Although many scholars have argued that there was a transformation of Jewish historiography in the sixteenth century, they have found the precursors to modern critical historical scholarship that seem to have been forged during the Renaissance in only a few isolated figures, particularly the erudite Azariah de’ Rossi. Sixteenthcentury Jewish historiography has been seen as at once a revival of Jewish historical thinking and a continuation of notions of the past imprinted with traditional religious sensibilities.42 Corresponding to long-standing models of periodization, the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, then, represent a continuum that is still medieval but that 38 Frank L. Borchardt, German Antiquity in Renaissance Myth (Baltimore, 1971), p. 312. 39 Nils Roemer, “Between Hope and Despair: Conceptions of Time and the German-Jewish Experience in the Nineteenth Century,” Jewish History 14 (2000): 345–63, here at p. 346. 40 Ibid., p. 345. 41 Ibid., p. 355. 42 See as well Mordechai Breuer, “Modernism and Traditionalism in Sixteenth-Century Jewish Historiography: A Study of David Gans’ Tzemah David,” in Bernard Dov Cooperman (ed.), Jewish Thought in the Sixteenth Century (Cambridge, MA, 1983), pp. 49–88.
28
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
is moving closer to the modernity of the nineteenth century. One might ask, however, whether Jews experienced broader changes in temporal perspective outside of formal historical writing. Amos Funkenstein has suggested that the period between the sixteenth and eighteenth centuries witnessed the creation of a new kind of contextual understanding of history and the shift, particularly in the seventeenth century, from an idea of history within the religious to one within the secular domain.43 According to Funkenstein: Somewhere between the sixteenth and the eighteenth century, a revolution occurred that was no less radical than the concurrent scientific revolution. It brought about a new contextual understanding of history, in which historical fact became ‘understood’ or meaningful only through the context in which it was embedded. This applies to both historical texts and other monuments of the past. The historian must reconstruct the context, and the reconstruction is always linked to his or her ‘point of view’ in the present.44
It is not too far of a stretch to place early modern Jews within this Renaissance context. Jewish narratives were not, of necessity, internal or hermetically sealed. They often shared similar approaches, sources, and foci with the productions of nonJewish historical writers. Like the chronicle of David Gans, much early modern German Jewish literature engaged the developments and concerns of the non-Jewish world. The anonymous seventeenth-century Prague chronicle, for example—which does not seem to have borrowed directly from Gans45—was written in a simple, unembellished Hebrew, but was influenced by the vernacular. It clearly incorporated both oral and written materials, including information from the community pinkas [community ledger], as well as non-Jewish documentary evidence.46 The chronicle reported on rainbows,47 eclipses,48 weather,49 earthquakes,50 and stars,51 while also recording recent Jewish and general history (within the preceding 50 years), such as the attack of the Turks on Vienna52 and the coronation of the king.53 Given that 43 Funkenstein, Perceptions of Jewish History, p. 15. 44 Ibid., pp. 14–15. 45 David (ed.), A Hebrew Chronicle from Prague, pp. 5–8. 46 Ibid., p. 9. 47 Ibid., pp. 38, 40. 48 Ibid., pp. 38, 51. 49 Ibid., p. 40. 50 Ibid., p. 70. 51 Ibid., p. 52. For 1577, the chronicle recorded the following regarding a star: “May God regard it for good and a blessing, Amen. Its like had not been seen for over forty-five years.” See also Zemah David. Zinberg, in vol. 6 of his far-reaching A History of Jewish Literature, notes Gans’s recording of epidemics, troubles, afflictions, floods, earthquakes, signs as harbingers of coming oppressions and trials (p. 49). Even the minhag [custom] book of the community of Worms refers to a two-hour lunar eclipse, adding the hope that it may be a good omen for all Israel. See Eidelberg, Medieval Ashkenazic History, in his excerpts from the “Minhagim of the Worms Community,” p. 139 (16 Av 5423 (August 19, 1663)). 52 David (ed.), A Hebrew Chronicle from Prague, p. 39. 53 Ibid., p. 40. See also p. 58 for previous royal delegations and p. 61 regarding the 1609 Reichstag.
Reconsidering Early Modern German Jewish Memory and History
29
early modern German Jewry was complex and Jews were involved with internal concerns as well as a myriad of more general developments, it is time we turn to a few illustrative examples of how early modern Jews approached time and how they focused narratives of the past. Early Modern German Jewish Temporality Even if it is true that there were relatively few purely “historical” works to be found among medieval and early modern Ashkenazic Jews, Jews did construct narratives of the past and have a sense of time and historical consciousness. Many genres of Jewish writing contain important narratives of the past: from rabbinic responsa to wonder stories, customs books, necrologies, communal records, and literature. These narratives may be brief or intricate and detailed; they may be discrete renderings or part of a broader concern; they may be based on documents, traditions, or imagination; they may examine various periods in the past. The role of such Jewish narratives of the past could, in fact, be rather complicated—similar in important ways to more general historical narrative and yet inherently different in other ways, revealing unique local concerns. Before we explore these narratives and these issues, we must first ask how early modern Jews conceived of time and what role temporality played in early modern Jewish culture. Late medieval and early modern Jewish art often reflected complex and overlapping temporal patterns. In the Yahuda Haggadah of mid-fifteenth-century south Germany, a large angel, replete with wings, conversed with a biblical Joshua dressed in contemporary garb.54 In the Prague Haggadah of 1526, ancient cities such as Pitom and Ramses were depicted as medieval fortified cities and towers respectively. The fifteenth-century Ashkenazi Haggadah similarly provided a scene depicting Jews enslaved in Egypt hard at work with medieval style buildings, European countryside, and “modern” ladders and pulleys. As in many haggadot, the rasha, or evil son, was depicted as a military figure in full armor; the son who does not know how to ask was a court jester or fool. In these examples we find a transposition of biblical and contemporary time, merging the two together in a message that reinforced the biblical story through the use of contemporary imagery.55 Does this temporal conflation imply the inability to distinguish temporal modes or, perhaps, something different? To answer this question, let us turn to several central early modern German Jewish texts. It seems fair to say that Jewish writers in early modern Germany were rarely precise in their use of memory, historical reckoning, or their understanding of time. 54 Karl Katz, P.P. Kahane, and Magen Broshi (eds), From the Beginning: Archaeology and Art in the Israel Museum (London, 1968), illus. 130. 55 Similarly, Lassner writes that: “Recent events were, therefore, reinterpreted by Muslim historians to make them consonant with the ideals and circumstances of the Prophet and his age. As a result, current times were inevitably recorded as if they were the mirror images of the historic past.” See Jacob Lassner, “Time, Historiography, and Historical Consciousness: The Dialectic of Jewish-Muslim Relations,” in Benjamin H. Hary, John L. Hayes, and Fred Astren (eds), Judaism and Islam: Boundaries, Communication and Interaction, Essays in Honor of William M. Brinner (Leiden, 2000), pp. 1–26, here at p. 17.
30
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
Mekor Hayyim, by Yair Hayyim Bacharach, one of the great early modern German Jewish legal experts, for example, was replete with references to “memory.” A quick inventory of the meanings of such references, however, reveals a complex and at times overlapping set of concepts. “Zakhor,” or memory, had a number of meanings throughout the text. Typically the term referred to scriptural passages or arguments,56 a traditional explanation or ruling in the Talmud57 or in the writings or codes of previous Jewish scholars.58 Often the term was used negatively, noting that the author did not remember the specific ruling in a passage.59 The term could be self-referential, pointing the reader to previous discussions within the volume itself 60 or within previous sections of works cited. Remembrance extended to memories of miracles of redemption as well.61 The term might also, particularly in its infinitive form, refer to recognition or acceptance.62 The concept of time, particularly the distinction between previous times and “our time” (“in our time”)63 or “this time,”64 was also marked throughout Mekor Hayyim and Bacharach’s other writings, suggesting that we need to reevaluate traditional assumptions that pre-modern Jews lacked historical consciousness, or that halakhic [legal] literature is necessarily atemporal. Although a variety of temporal modes were therefore combined, it hardly seems correct to argue that Bacharach did not or was not capable of distinguishing between past and present. In his Zemah David, the important Prague astronomer and historian David Gans’s sense of time was frequently blurred. Gans compared the great expulsion from France with the exodus from Egypt,65 many events were located by reference to the destruction of the Temple,66 and he frequently utilized very general dating such as “around this time”67 or “before this time.”68 Nevertheless, Gans also demonstrated the ability to differentiate time and chronological periods at the same time that he extended his analysis to contemporary times. He wrote of the period of tannaim and the days of Rabbi Akiva,69 at the same time that he discussed historical events that he heard about from great scholars and teachers of his own time.70 Indeed, for Gans, 56 Bacharach’s commentary is in Joseph ben Ephraim Karo, Shulkhan Arukh Orakh Hayyim im Perush Mekor Hayyim, 2 vols (Jerusalem, 1982), here at vol. 1, p. 39. 57 Ibid., vol. 1, pp. 4, 5, 136, 217, 375; vol. 2, pp. 385, 394. 58 Ibid., vol. 1, pp. 8 (“the tradition received from the geonim”), 73 (Rokeah and Maharil), and 136 (Rambam). 59 Ibid., vol. 1, pp. 5, 16, 51 (regarding the Tosafists). 60 Ibid., vol. 1, pp. 52, 60, 220, 333. 61 Ibid., vol. 1, pp. 50, 302 (“the exodus from Egypt”). 62 Regarding a get [bill of divorce], for example, see ibid., vol. 1, p. 162. 63 Ibid., vol. 1, p. 13. 64 Ibid., vol. 1, pp. 150, 230 (“customary in this time”), 245, 336; vol. 2, p. 390; and compare “in the time of the hahamim [sages]” (vol. 2, p. 401). 65 David Gans, Zemah David, ed. Mordechai Breuer (Jerusalem, 1983), p. 129. 66 Ibid., p. 80. 67 Ibid., p. 33. 68 Ibid., p. 66. 69 Ibid., pp. 88, 89. 70 Ibid., see pp. 129, 40.
Reconsidering Early Modern German Jewish Memory and History
31
the force of past events was at times related precisely to their currency. He noted, for example, that until this day the land was called Germany, in the language of the Romans alemania; similarly, to this day the kings of Rome are called Kaiser; and the land of France is called Franken Land.71 While chronology could thus be vague and often not even sequential, Gans clearly did differentiate past and present to a significant degree. The general concept of “our time(s)”72 or “our generation,”73 as expressed in the work of Juspa Hahn of Nördlingen, a leading rabbinic figure in early seventeenthcentury Frankfurt am Main, offers yet another important example of early modern German Jewish conceptions of time, memory, and history, which were anything but systematic. Throughout the Sefer Yosef Ometz, Juspa’s definition of “this time” shifted in various places. He asserted vaguely that “we were accustomed from previous times until now,”74 and that the number of printing presses had increased “in our time” and that they print in many places in Ashkenaz.75 “This time” could include a passage from Emek Bracha in the name of the Maharshal (c.1510–1574);76 a ruling in the sixteenth-century Shulhan Arukh;77 and the writings of the Rosh (c.1250–1327).78 The use of the concept of “our time” could also be made to serve a moralizing principle, for example, when he wrote that “and because in our generation we have practically no kavanna [intention] thus I will not write only that we need more …”79 And yet there was a broad differentiation of time throughout his work. Juspa explicated a number of types of individuals, which could be divided as follows: self, father, teacher, pious person, and sages. In this regard, the text might be said to include reference to the present (himself and contemporaneous figures), the recent past (father, teachers, other scholars of note)—which at times extended several hundred years!—and the more distant past (referring mostly to the talmudic sages). There was a diverse array of words that Juspa utilized throughout the text, as well as a variety of sources of authority. He focused on practices and customs, and his relationship to sources of authority was central for much of his recounting of local customs. Throughout the text Juspa employed the terms “discovered,” “seen,” and “heard.” Corresponding to varying temporal modalities, Juspa utilized these terms to provide authority and knowledge, and to establish tradition. Such terms, which find echoes in the broader ethnographic literature of the early modern period suggest that Jews were in fact capable of distinguishing and giving meaning to periods of time, specific events, and modes of reception.
71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79
Ibid., pp. 174, 204, 205. Juspa Hahn Nördlingen, Sefer Yosef Ometz (Jerusalem, 1965), pp. 30, 286, 292. Ibid., pp. 44, 56, 291. Ibid., p. 49; see also p. 117. Ibid., p. 8. Ibid., p. 57. Ibid., p. 161. Ibid., p. 352. Ibid., p. 56.
32
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
It would seem that Jews were capable of and willing to distinguish types of temporality. The emphasis on religious practice and the search for authority, which were shared in broader German society, may have fostered the dual attempt to recognize recent events and to place them within a broader historical context. Jewish engagement with the past, however, was not simply theological or paradigmatic; rather it could be social and political as well as dynamic and changeable. Conclusions Even when we accept the centrality of the paradigmatic argument, we do not necessarily have to presuppose that the paradigms did not allow Jews to understand the nuances of the past or see recent historical developments as more than typologies. After all, paradigms were part and parcel of early modern German Jewish narratives, and so were, in a sense, part of communal record keeping, identity, and history, often serving to explain past and current events and to provide continuity with the future. One might agree that early modern German Jewish life, as visible in the literary productions that we possess, was imbued with an intimate relationship with the sacred. We do not need to assume, however, that Jewish writing, particularly narratives of the past, reflected only deep and all-consuming religious sensibility and observance. In fact, the growing literature on early modern halakhic flexibility, tolerated dissent, and intellectual confusion—depending on how one wants to approach the period and subject more generally—suggests that early modern Jewish life was more complex than is often assumed. Paradigms were important in pre-modern Jewish thinking, but that does not mean that Jews could not think beyond paradigms. Already for the medieval period, for example, Robert Chazan has argued persuasively—and in some respects similarly to Funkenstein—that there were at least two important genres that allowed Jews to reconsider the “notion of an unbroken continuum of Jewish experience.” The first was Jewish law, in which a careful context of contemporary events was often required. The second was the First Crusade chronicles, which often provided “detailed and diversified” depictions of “actual Jewish actions.”80 As we have seen, early modern German Jewish engagement with the past at times employed paradigms, but with different creative meaning, and at other times went beyond the use of paradigms to engage and refract the past for various present purposes. Given the complex and changeable nature of early modern Germany, and the often-precarious position of the Jews, we may ask how narration of the past—at times forwarded through both “tradition” and innovation—served to orient Jewish society internally and externally. There are a number of common issues that will reappear in the analysis that follows. Throughout the narratives investigated, time and the past can be complicated and changeable concepts. Nevertheless, the sources reviewed reveal that there were two primary categories into which early modern German Jewish narratives of the past fell. First, such narratives provided 80 Robert Chazan, “Representation of Events in the Middle Ages,” in Ada RapoportAlbert (ed.), Essays in Jewish Historiography: In Memoriam Arnaldo Dante Momigliano, 1908–1987 (Middletown, CT, 1988), pp. 40–55, here at pp. 47, 50, 55.
Reconsidering Early Modern German Jewish Memory and History
33
the opportunity for collective group identity. The group was defined internally by relation to an “ideal” past. In this sense, history and knowledge were used to legitimate the present and provided authority for particular ruling groups within the community. In addition, narratives of the past provided the means for defining the collectivity through moral parameters and discussion of proper behavior. But narratives of the past also afforded the opportunity to define the collectivity vis-à-vis external groups, while simultaneously mediating and contesting relationships with external authorities. Along the way it should be clear that early modern German Jewry was multidimensional and complex; it was hardly monolithic, static, or purely religious. It is time now that we turn more fully to the texts themselves.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 3
Community, Memory, and Governance A Context: Population, Settlement, and the Jews Early Modern German Population and Settlement The early modern period throughout Europe, and especially in Germany, was a time of tremendous change and upheaval. While a simple categorization of the period as one of crisis is insufficient, it is clear that dramatic social, political, and religious changes had significant impact on the lives of Jews and Christians alike. General demographic patterns offer one example of the simultaneous volatility and growth of the period. The population of the German Empire, which had peaked to around 11 to 14 million inhabitants in 1340, declined to 7 to 10 million by around 1470,1 but then rebounded to 16.2 million by 1600—making the German population the second largest in Europe, behind the nearly 18.5 million people residing in France in 1600. With the impact of bad harvests throughout the sixteenth century,2 the heavy snow, deep cold, and late frosts between 1584 and 1622, the large number of epidemics throughout the 1630s,3 as well as decades of war, the German population dipped again, however, to 14.1 million by 1700. Such wild population swings caused massive changes in social, economic, and political order. By the late sixteenth century regional settlement density could vary widely. There were ten houses per square kilometer in the western Black Forest, for example, eight in Württemberg and two in Mecklenburg. The most thickly settled area before 1634, the Duchy of Württemberg, possessed 50 residents per square kilometer.4 In Swabia and Bavaria, chronicles of the sixteenth century report a population bursting at the seams, and we know that by 1560 the land available for settlement in these areas had run out.5 The process of growth throughout Germany, however, was geographically uneven, and the effects of settlement patterns and changing demographics could be profound, as we will see below.
1 Werner Rösener, “The Agrarian Economy, 1300–1600,” in Bob Scribner (ed.), Germany: A New Social and Economic History, volume I, 1450–1630 (London, 1996), pp. 63– 83, here at p. 63—9 million in 1500, according to Christian Pfister, Bevölkerungsgeschichte und historische Demographie 1500–1800 (Munich, 1994), pp. 10–11. 2 Robert Jütte, “Poverty and Poor Relief,” in Ogilvie (ed.), Germany: A New Social and Economic History, pp. 377–404, here at p. 380. 3 Pfister, Bevölkerungsgeschichte, pp. 12–13. 4 Ibid., p. 13. 5 Christian Pfister, “The Population of Late Medieval and Early Modern Germany,” in Scribner (ed.), Germany: A New Social and Economic History, pp. 33–62, here at p. 41.
36
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
Around 1500, only 16 per cent of the German population lived in areas with more than 5,000 inhabitants—4 per cent in large cities of more than 10,000. By 1600 that percentage had decreased to 12.6 As in the later Middle Ages, the majority of German towns had populations of less than 2,000,7 and there were some 2,000–3,000 towns (including Swiss and Austrian towns) in early modern Germany. In the early modern period there were few new towns founded, perhaps only 200 between 1500 and 1800, and so the German urban pattern was essentially complete by the end of Middle Ages.8 When all of these cities and towns are included, approximately one quarter of the total population of the Holy Roman Empire lived in urban areas;9 in Hesse-Kassel and Saxony at the beginning of the seventeenth century, for example, 30 per cent of the population was urban (in Thuringia the percentage was 28 and in Württemberg 26).10 Cities continued to be centers of trade and industry, of education, art, and literature. As such, cities were never isolated entities. Indeed, burghers lived within a rich mix of social orders and had the opportunity to associate with a variety of city inhabitants and visitors, such as foreign travelers and businessmen. In addition to longer-term residents, cities could be home to large numbers of foreign migrants. Some 5,000– 7,000 Netherlanders, for example, migrated to Germany in 1567, as did large numbers of Huguenots in the late seventeenth century.11 Migration could, of course, be more regional as well. Württemberg, for example, took in migrants from Switzerland, Vorarlberg, Bavaria, and Tirol,12 and cities generally drew significant proportions of their immigrants from the surrounding countryside. While the percentage of the population from the surrounding land in Cologne and Hamburg was only 5, in early modern Frankfurt and Aachen it was 20 (in some border towns with exceptional religious conditions, such as Emden and Wesel, the percentage could be as high as 40 and 5013). In early modern Colmar, of 922 individuals, whose geographical origins can be ascertained, 385 (41.8 per cent) were born in Colmar, 207 (22.5 per cent) migrated from villages in Alsace, and 330 (35.4 per cent) came to Colmar from other regions.14 This migration to cities—as well as other social, economic, and political developments, such as wealth distribution—could, in many cities, correspond to a variety of factors, including confessional affiliation.15 The city afforded, in a sense almost dictated, interaction between many social and cultural groups.
6 Pfister, Bevölkerungsgeschichte, p. 14. 7 Tom Scott and Bob Scribner, “Urban Networks,” in Scribner (ed.), Germany: A New Social and Economic History, pp. 113–43, here at p. 114. 8 Ibid., p. 115. 9 Bernd Roeck, Lebenswelt und Kultur des Bürgertums in der frühen Neuzeit (Munich, 1991), p. 1. 10 Heinz Schilling, Die Stadt in der frühen Neuzeit (Munich, 1993), p. 9. 11 Pfister, “The Population of Late Medieval and Early Modern Germany,” pp. 49, 51. 12 Ibid., p. 50. 13 Schilling, Die Stadt in der frühen Neuzeit, p. 10. 14 Peter G. Wallace, Communities and Conflict in Early Modern Colmar, 1575–1730 (Boston, 1995), p. 60. 15 See ibid., pp. 62–83, for example.
Community, Memory, and Governance
37
German urban life also continued to be linked closely to agriculture and petty craft production, and 40 per cent of German towns were engaged primarily in production.16 Most smaller towns fell within the sphere of influence of larger towns, which often controlled the economy, politics, and society of smaller surrounding towns and villages. In 1446, Nördlingen, for example, controlled an economic exclusion zone of 30 km. In 1512, Ulm drew its boundaries at a distance of 20 to 40 km. In 1513, Augsburg extended its radius of market monopoly to some 60 km, and later added a lower Bavarian enclave.17 Complicating these general trends and the development of early modern German settlement was the instability and war during the first half of the seventeenth century. In many places the Thirty Years’ War had remarkable demographic, economic, and political effects. In the Duchy of Württemberg, by 1640, the population had declined to one quarter of the pre-war level.18 Augsburg in 1600 had 45,000 inhabitants; by 1635, however, the city was inhabited by only 16,000 people. Between 1632 and 1635, Mainz lost 8,000 people (half of its inhabitants). Such proportional population losses could be experienced in any size town. The small town of Bietigheim on the Neckar, near Stuttgart, had 1,800 inhabitants in 1634; in 1635 there was a loss of 600 people;19 in 1636 and 1637 the loss of another 200 each year, so that by 1638 there were only around 240 people remaining in the town. Although the population losses could be quite significant and in some places long lasting, as a rule, urban populations tended to recover quickly. The war could have other serious consequences besides population loss, however. Between 1625 and 1647, the prosperous and densely populated area around Magdeburg and Halberstadt lost an average of 64 per cent of its dwellings through direct combat, dilapidation, plundering, and arson.20 The indebtedness of Nuremberg rose from 1.8 million Gulden in 1618 to 7.4 million in 1648.21 Some cities and regions were, however, more prosperous even in the midst of the chaos of the war. The north German Hanseatic cities of Hamburg, Bremen, and Lübeck thrived, partly through neutrality, diplomacy, trade, and finance. Hamburg grew from between 45,000 and 54,000 inhabitants in 1620 to 75,000 in 1660. Annual revenues in the city grew from 250,000 marks at the end of the sixteenth century to 1.4 million in the middle of the seventeenth century. Although overall the war did not fundamentally alter social and economic structures in most places, it did frequently allow for increased loosening of social bonds and economic and social mobility.22
16 Scott and Scribner, “Urban Networks,” p. 116. 17 Rolf Kiessling, “Markets and Marketing, Town and Country,” in Scribner (ed.), Germany: A New Social and Economic History, pp. 145–79, here at p. 159. 18 Bernhard Stier and Wolfgang von Hippel, “War, Economy, and Society,” in Ogilvie (ed.), Germany: A New Social and Economic History, pp. 233–62, here at p. 235. 19 Ibid., p. 236. 20 Ibid., p. 240. 21 Ibid., p. 241. 22 Ibid., p. 252.
38
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
Jewish Settlement It has been estimated that at the beginning of the seventeenth century there were approximately 35,000–40,000 Jews spread throughout the German Empire, totaling roughly 0.2 per cent of the population.23 About a third of this population resided in the southeast and another third in the middle west. In addition, about 10 per cent of the Jewish population was concentrated in the southwest and some significant pockets of Jewish settlement were developing in the north and northwest. As in broader German society, Jewish demographic patterns were similarly complex and highly changeable. While there were more than a thousand areas in which Jews settled in the later Middle Ages, from full-blown communities to outposts of individuals or a hand full of Jews,24 very few of these settlements would survive into the modern period.25 Many Jewish settlements, in fact, disappeared between the end of the fourteenth and first half of the sixteenth centuries. Some were impacted by anti-Jewish legislation or expulsion, others by shifting demographics within the Jewish or general societies.26 Still, some Jewish communities managed to survive or, in some cases, were even reconstituted at various times during the early modern period.27 Given the general context we have outlined above, combined with the often frail existence of the Jewish communities in late medieval and early modern Germany, however, it should come as no surprise that Jewish settlement and community development could vary wildly according to region and over time.28 As they had earlier, throughout the early modern period Jews resided in both urban and rural areas. Some cities boasted rather large and at times influential Jewish communities. Around 1660, for example, some 6,000 Jews resided in Prague. This number swelled to more than 11,500 by the beginning of the eighteenth century, when Jews constituted more than a quarter of the total city population. While dramatic, such population increases were not to be taken for granted or easily accomplished. Throughout the sixteenth century there were numerous attempts at expelling the Jews from the city, and several interludes of multi-year banishments from the city. 23 J. Friedrich Battenberg estimates a total population of 18–20 million; here and following, see his Die Juden in Deutschland vom 16. bis zum Ende des 18. Jahrhunderts (Munich, 2001), p. 10. 24 See my Sacred Communities: Jewish and Christian Identities in Fifteenth-Century Germany (Boston, 2001), pp. 126–48, as well as the important work of Michael Toch cited below. 25 Michael Toch, “Siedlungsstruktur der Juden Mitteleuropas im Wandel vom Mittelalter zur Neuzeit,” in Alfred Haverkamp and Franz-Josef Ziwes (eds), Juden in der christlichen Umwelt während des späten Mittelalters (Berlin, 1992), pp. 29–39, here at p. 37. 26 Ibid., p. 38 (diagram 7). 27 Michael Toch, “Aspects of Stratification of Early Modern German Jewry: Population History and Village Jews,” in R. Po-chia Hsia and Hartmut Lehmann (eds), In and Out of the Ghetto: Jewish-Gentile Relations in Late Medieval and Early Modern Germany (Cambridge, 1995), pp. 77–89, here at p. 79 (figure 5.2). 28 For more specific detail, see my essay “Jewish Settlement, Politics, and the Reformation,” in Dean Phillip Bell and Stephen G. Burnett (eds), Jews, Judaism, and the Reformation in Sixteenth Century Germany (Leiden, 2006), pp. 421–50.
Community, Memory, and Governance
39
Not as large, though in some ways equally dramatic, was the Jewish population growth in the important cities of Frankfurt am Main and Worms. By the beginning of the seventeenth century there were at least 2,200 Jews in Frankfurt, congregated in a ghetto that included nearly 200 houses. Worms was home to 300 Jews in the middle of the sixteenth century and 650 by the early seventeenth century. In both Worms and Frankfurt am Main Jews constituted more than 10 per cent of the total population. As in Prague, Jewish settlement could be very tenuous. In both cities menacing social revolts in the second decade of the seventeenth century had significant and negative, if temporary, consequences for the Jews living there. Fulda also maintained a relatively significant Jewish presence, with 75 families, or approximately 450 Jews, in 1633. That number represented nearly a quarter of the total city population. Some scholars have found a pattern of openness to Jewish settlement in areas that had never allowed Jews or that had been closed to Jewish settlement for a long time. In some places, such as Vienna, where the Jews had been expelled already in the early fifteenth century, they were again permitted settlement in the seventeenth century. At the turn of the seventeenth century there were only 12 Jewish families in Vienna. Within a little over a decade, however, there were 44 Jewish families. Jews began to develop communal structures and many became involved in important work as merchants and court purveyors, leading to certain privileges and exemptions and occasional conflict with non-Jewish neighbors. A number of towns scattered throughout the Empire possessed between one and two hundred Jews. Fürth, outside Nuremberg, which was really only first settled by Jews in the sixteenth century had, by 1582, about 200 Jews. By the last quarter of the sixteenth century there were nearly a hundred Jews in Berlin, though the fortunes of that Jewish settlement and others like it hinged on the ebb and flow of various regional fairs and the development of markets. A new, but rather complicated settlement of Jews developed in and around Hamburg at the beginning of the seventeenth century. Several communities, some Ashkenazic and some Sephardic developed in Hamburg and in the neighboring towns, really suburbs that were under different political (even “national” jurisdiction) in Wandsbek and Altona. The 116 Portuguese Jews of early seventeenth-century Hamburg grew to some 600 just after the middle of the century. Most Jewish settlements remained small and dispersed throughout the early modern period. This was particularly true in the south and southwest. In mid-sixteenth-century Palatinate a small number of Jews were spread thinly across nearly 90 different areas, including only one sizeable city (Heidelberg).29 The situation was extreme in the southwest where Jews settled in a wide range of villages, which at times developed into significant local and regional Jewish communities by the beginning of the nineteenth century.30 Often the dispersed Jewish communities organized themselves— or were organized by regional princely authorities—into associations or groupings (Landjudenschaften). Such associations could be tools for territorial governance and taxation. As we will see, they also clearly had important impact on internal Jewish governance and identity. 29 Toch, “Aspects of Stratification,” p. 82. 30 See Rolf Kiessling, “Between Expulsion and Emancipation: Jewish Villages in East Swabia During the Early Modern Period,” Shofar 15:4 (Summer, 1997): 59–87.
40
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
The Structure and Governance of Early Modern German Jewish Communities Communities can be variously defined entities that reflect many different kinds of relationships.31 Early modern German Jewish communities were simultaneously defined from within and without. They might be formed by adherence to particular customs, by geographical location, by economic or political expediency, or even by the dictates of external authorities (local, territorial, or imperial). While the nature and even function of early modern German Jewish communities could vary widely, many communities shared similar needs, organizing principles, and governance. Jewish communities might borrow from the Christian communal organization surrounding them—and in rather provocative, if extremely unusual cases even share administrative structures with Christian neighbors32—even as uniquely Jewish elements were present and specific Jewish needs were addressed. A brief review of the organization and structure helps to contextualize the role of memory in communal organization and structure. Jewish communities in early modern Germany could be organized in various ways. Often a community was equivalent to a settlement of Jews residing in a particular city. Increasingly, however, as Jews were dispersed throughout Germany33 and as rural communities further developed, a community might be defined as a group of proximate settlements that shared geographical, economic, or even political affiliations.34 Various Landjudenschaften of differing sizes and administrative structures evolved, often under the guidance or encouragement of territorial authorities. These rural Jewish communities had lay and rabbinic leaders, Jewish courts, and provided social services as well as a network of bureaucracy that dealt with internal and external affairs. How one became a member of a community could vary tremendously. In some places, communal membership began when someone settled in an area, purchased a 31 See my Sacred Communities, pp. 148ff. See more generally Jacob Katz’s pioneering Tradition and Crisis: Jewish Society at the End of the Middle Ages, trans. Bernard Dov Cooperman (New York, 1993 (orig., 1958)), pp. 65ff and Michael A. Meyer (ed.), GermanJewish History in Modern Times, Volume 1: Tradition and Enlightenment: 1600–1780 (New York, 1996), pp. 165–80, 194–208. For a broad discussion of Jewish community, see the introductory chapter by Alfred Haverkamp, “Jüdische Gemeinden und ihr christlicher Kontext: Konzeptionen und Aspekte,” in Christoph Cluse, Alfred Haverkamp, and Israel J. Yuval (eds), Jüdische Gemeinden und ihr christlicher Kontext in kulturräumlich vergleichender Betrachtung von der Spätantike bis zum 18. Jahrhundert (Hannover, 2003), pp. 1–32. 32 See Rolf Kiessling and Sabine Ullmann, “Christlich-jüdische ‘Doppelgemeinden’ in den Dörfern der Markgrafschaft Burgau während des 17./18. Jahrhunderts,” in Cluse, Haverkamp, and Yuval (eds), Jüdische Gemeinden und ihr christlicher Kontext, pp. 513–34. 33 And even detached from the Jewish community—see Stefan Rohrbacher, “Die jüdischen Gemeinden in den Medinot Aschkenas zwischen Spätmittelalter und Dreißig jährigem Krieg,” in Cluse, Haverkamp, and Yuval (eds), Jüdische Gemeinden und ihr christlicher Kontext, pp. 451–63, here at p. 457, citing a comment by Hayyim ben Bezalel. 34 See Katz, Tradition and Crisis, pp. 95–112; see also Rohrbacher, “Die jüdischen Gemeinden in den Medinot Aschkenas,” pp. 454–55 and on similar and differing structures see also pp. 460–61.
Community, Memory, and Governance
41
house, or conducted a certain level of business. Communal membership meant tax obligations and at times communal service duties as well. At times, decisions on who could be admitted to a community were made by the members of the Jewish community themselves;35 at other times, such decisions were dictated by the policies of the non-Jewish authorities that governed the Jews.36 The Jewish community was generally viewed by Christians as a corporate or legal entity. Among Jews the community was also fashioned in legal terms, almost as a court. But in this regard it functioned as a religious association that also provided ritual services (including burial and care of the sick) and provisions and familial networks. Jewish communities in our period desperately sought to maintain autonomy within a situation in which non-Jewish territorial lords took an ever growing interest in the affairs of their subjects, and when the legal ruling and customs from other German lands, or even from across national boundaries (especially from Poland), were infringing on perceived German customs and rights. Jewish communities served various religious and social needs. As such they were governed by specific principles based on traditional halakhic (legal) literature as well as local customs and ordinances. The actualization of these principles occurred through the work of individuals in various communal positions and through a host of communal institutions. Among the employees—some paid and others “voluntary”— were the rabbi, parnasim, various gabbaim, community scribe, beadle (shammash)— whose duties included summoning people to prayer services37—and the honorary position of shtadlan. In theory the Jewish community was something of a democracy with strict stipulations for voting and office holding. Each community indeed had rules about membership, behavior, and office holding. Even among the powerful lay leaders, individuals often rotated into the main position, the parnas of the month, on a monthly basis. In some communities a new parnas was chosen by other parnasim. At times this election required the participation or at least the approval of the local bishop or city council.38 Often a festive celebration or meal—and frequently additional payments to the non-Jewish overlords—accompanied the appointment.39 Individual communities stipulated the number of parnasim that would serve on the community council. Each parnas was required to take an oath as to his impartiality. It is clear that the position of parnas, like that of the shtadlan, evoked status and recognition but also a good deal of, often financial, responsibility.40
35 See Stefan Litt, Protokollbuch und Statuten der Jüdischen Gemeinde Friedberg (16.– 18. Jahrhundert) (Friedberg, 2003), p. 230 (Hebrew, p. 45) regarding the position of “foreign Jews.” 36 See my Sacred Communities, pp. 174–6. 37 See Shlomo Eidelberg, R. Juspa, Shammash of Warmaisa (Worms): Jewish Life in Seventeenth Century Worms (Jerusalem, 1991), p. 18. 38 Ibid., p. 20; on elections in Friedberg more generally, see Litt, Protokollbuch, pp. 384–5 (Hebrew, p. 154). 39 Eidelberg, R. Juspa, pp. 20–21; Litt, Protokollbuch, p. 424. 40 See the account in the memoirs of Glückel of Hameln.
42
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
Many medieval Jewish scholars had expressed the opinion that community rule was established by majority opinion.41 Of course there were limitations on such a rule, especially when halakhic issues or strong local customs were involved. In practice, many communities were run by a few wealthy or prominent individuals, who formed something of an early modern Jewish oligarchy.42 Generally, communal positions were intended to be held by an individual for only a delimited period, though in many cases positions evolved into lifelong monopolies of the most influential. The rabbi was simultaneously a teacher, instructing yeshivah students in Talmud and commentaries, as Juspa noted in the minhagim of the community of Worms. But he was also meant to be the guidestar for religious and legal concerns. He was expected to deliver various sermons and moral instruction, holding the power to fine and excommunicate those falling short. In Worms the rabbi was provided with housing, given certain honors, and exempted from general and property taxes. In other communities, the rabbi signed a multi-year contract and was paid an annual salary, generally from community coffers or the purses of wealthy lay leaders. As Juspa noted, the rabbi’s jurisdiction “extends to the Jewish inhabitants of neighboring hamlets” and “The rabbi is obligated to visit periodically all the aforementioned communities under his jurisdiction.”43 In the early modern period, the position of the rabbi increasingly weakened in many places. The rabbi was often a subordinate communal official.44 As various rabbinic contracts indicate, the rabbi was becoming more subject to the lay leadership in some ways, though of course individual rabbis might hold a great deal of power and carry much influence. As with communal governance more generally, external rulers often attempted to influence if not to outright appoint rabbinic leaders, with an eye toward serving their own purposes. Throughout our period, there was a palpable and growing tension between lay and rabbinic leaders in many communities. One important communal area that seemed to reflect this tension was the writ of excommunication (herem)45 intended to punish individuals who deviated from communal norms or legislation. While the rabbis generally had to issue the excommunication—so reserving important power—many communal constitutions indicated that the rabbi could do so only with the approval, or even instigation, of the lay community council.46 Community council members were generally from the wealthy strata of society and the positions were not salaried. These parnasim initiated communal legislation and regulated communal governance. Different positions, those of gabbaim, were 41 See the opinion of Yair Hayyim Bacharach, as cited by Katz in Tradition and Crisis, p. 296, n. 20. 42 See Rohrbacher, “Die jüdischen Gemeinden in den Medinot Aschkenas,” p. 459. 43 Eidelberg, R. Juspa, p. 19; for stipulations related to a rabbinic appointment in Friedberg in 1572, see Litt, Protokollbuch, pp. 274ff (Hebrew, pp. 74ff). 44 The “professionalization” theory—see my Sacred Communities, pp. 157, 169–70. 45 Inappropriate or deviant behavior might be punished in any number of ways, especially through banning of synagogue or ritual participation or fines—see my forthcoming article “Confessionalization in Early Modern Germany: A Jewish Perspective,” in Christopher Ocker et al. (eds), Festschrift for Thomas A. Brady, Jr. (Leiden, 2007), as well as Litt, Protokollbuch, pp. 367–8 (Hebrew, pp. 143–4). 46 See ibid.
Community, Memory, and Governance
43
filled for specific purposes, such as the collection of charity for use among the poor of the community and for the poor in the Land of Israel. While in many communities these positions were filled for specific, and limited periods,47 in some cases they became lifelong appointments, as Juspa describes in Worms, where he writes “New Gabbaim are not chosen every year; rather the chosen Gabbaim retain their jobs for life, for they act faithfully.”48 Other communal positions related to the assessment and collection of taxes, most of which were paid to the non-Jewish authorities.49 As in the later Middle Ages, officials were charged to assess communal members’ wealth for tax purposes. In many communities individuals attested to their wealth by means of an oath. Assessors, however, who doubted the veracity of such claims could, in many cases, levy an assessment based on what they believed to be the holdings and value of the individual in question.50 Jewish communities also appointed individuals with ritual responsibilities, such as cantors, shohetim (ritual slaughterers), and educators (these might be communal servants, teaching poorer children, as opposed to the tutors of the wealthier families). Communities, especially larger ones, at times also employed individuals in other professions, such as communal physicians. Frankfurt authorities granted the Jewish community in 1631 the privilege of retaining a communal physician.51 The Jews of Posen were similarly permitted to appoint a communal physician (Isaac Bacharach) in 1631 with a set annual salary of 150 fl. and a contract for three years with exemption from all taxes.52 Serving the Jewish community were various societies or brotherhoods that often appeared to resemble Christian fraternities or civic guilds. Most important in many communities was the burial society, the hevra kadisha, which gained new heights and organization during the course of the sixteenth century.53 One of the oldest such brotherhoods developed in Prague in the 1560s.54 Other associations or welfare societies also developed more fully in the early modern period. In Frankfurt, Rabbi Akiva Frankfurt established a welfare society and fund in 1597. In the seventeenth century we find evidence of these organizations providing care for the sick,55 though by the end of the seventeenth or beginning of the eighteenth century almost every important town in central Europe had a hospital for the sick and poor.56
47 See Katz, Tradition and Crisis, pp. 88ff. 48 Eidelberg, R. Juspa, p. 22. 49 See Litt, Protokollbuch, pp. 426ff; on taxes more generally, see Katz, Tradition and Crisis, pp. 77ff. 50 See Eidelberg, R. Juspa, p. 23. 51 See Jacob Marcus, Communal Sick-care in the German Ghetto (Cincinnati, 1947), pp. 27ff. 52 Ibid., p. 34. 53 Ibid., p. 63. 54 Ibid., p. 68. 55 Ibid., p. 70. 56 Ibid., p. 86.
44
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
In addition to communal positions, various communal institutions were significant in this period.57 Perhaps no edifice characterized the Jewish community more than the synagogue.58 The construction, or even repair, of the synagogue often required non-Jewish approval, and was frequently the subject of intense debate in the various city councils and pulpits. In the early modern period, as before, the synagogue was simultaneously a place of religious prayer, communal administration, and even conflict. The synagogue and the proper order and behavior within it was often the subject of various communal edicts and legislation.59 Jewish communities also had ritual bathhouses (mikvaot), community ovens, cemeteries, as well as study halls and dance houses (the latter of which might be located within the confines of the synagogue itself). Another form of communal institution, though not in the form of buildings, were the various records and assemblies (local or regional, occasionally even “national”) of the Jewish communities. The Jewish community legislated through various ordinances, or takkanot, (sometimes in the form of sumptuary laws that dictated proper dress and behavior) and recorded these laws as well as various transactions and events in community ledgers (pinkasim). Memorybooks, which recorded the deaths of community members, often the wealthiest or most influential, also recorded various bits of communal lore and legend as well. Customs books similarly recorded local and regional practices, while codifying various communal practices. Jewish communities, then, could be defined in many ways, and possessed important governing structures, offices, and tools. Communal Governance and Written Memory Early modern German Jewish engagement with the past was evident throughout various types of community discourse. Such discourse included community ledgers and minutes, which engaged the past to enforce order, empower authority, or record the traditions of the community. Much the same was true of writing about early modern customs. The continuation or contestation of particular customs, like the community ledgers and minutes, helped to create community structure and project that structure into the future. What is more, the very act of narration, particularly when it described conflict between competing centers of authority, could point to significant changes within the community.
57 See also Bell, “Confessionalization in Early Modern Germany: A Jewish Perspective.” See more generally Arye Maimon, Mordechai Breuer, and Yacov Guggenheim (eds), Germania Judaica. Volume III: 1350–1519, Part 3 (Tübingen, 2003), pp. 2081ff. 58 See Sabine Ullmann, Nachbarschaft und Konkurrenz: Juden und Christen in Dörfern der Markgrafschaft Burgau (Göttingen, 1999), p. 154 for Binswagen. 59 See Litt, Protokollbuch, p. 272 for Friedberg (Hebrew, pp. 73–4), as well as pp. 394ff (Hebrew, pp. 161ff).
Community, Memory, and Governance
45
Community Ledgers and Community Memory Community record books became more standardized and more common in the early modern period, just as the memorybooks we will examine in Chapter 4 did. A number of Jewish communities kept ledgers, or pinkasim, in the early modern period. In the seventeenth century, for example, we possess pinkasim from Posen (1621), Schnaittach (1665), Metz (1690), Bamberg (1698), and Düsseldorf (1698), among others.60 Pinkasim were generally in Hebrew, though frequently sprinkled with Judeo-Germanic vernacular as well.61 These documents recorded property acquisitions and legislated order within the community. According to one recent scholar, the early modern pinkas created a permanent written account of business transactions intended both for the contemporary businessmen as well as for later generations.62 The documents within the pinkas could refer to individuals and transactions within the community or throughout a broader region. In the documents from Worms, which was a regional center of commerce, records of business transactions were included for the surrounding villages as well as those carried on with Jews in larger, but distant communities, such as Amsterdam, Prague, and Vienna.63 In addition to general business transactions, the pinkas of Worms recorded the sale of synagogue seats and inventoried possessions and debts. It is perhaps no coincidence that such documents proliferated in this period, a period that was marked by increasing bureaucratic organization in the non-Jewish government and growing regional associations and recordkeeping within the Jewish communities as well. In most cases, it was the rabbis or the scribe of the community who wrote the communal ordinances and pinkasim.64 The entries within the pinkas could be recorded for a variety of reasons. According to one entry in the Worms pinkas, for example, “the parnasim took upon themselves to publicly appease all who protested against or objected to the sale, until the house would be firmly established in the possession of Leser [a Jew by the name of Leser Walch].”65 The pinkas was, therefore, not only a record, but a tool of government and an arbiter of power and social and economic relations. Pinkasim could also contain communal ordinances (takkanot), community records, minutes, and tax-lists.66 Forty-five per cent of the Posen pinkas dealt with direct legislation concerning elections; 26 per cent economics; 19 per cent support for Torah education; and 10 per cent trials and laws.67
60 A. Kober, “Documents Selected from the Pinkas of Friedberg,” Proceedings of the American Academy for Jewish Research 17 (1947–48): 19–60, here at p. 20. 61 Eidelberg, R. Juspa, p. 97; Meir Hildesheimer (ed.), Acta Communitatis Judaeorum Schnaittach. Introductione Natisque Instruxit (Jerusalem, 1992), p. 94. 62 Eidelberg, R. Juspa, p. 97. 63 Ibid. 64 Kober, “Documents,” p. 29. 65 Eidelberg, R. Juspa, p. 102. 66 Kober, “Documents,” p. 20. 67 Dov Avron (ed.), Acta Electorum Communitatis Judaeorum Posnaniensium (1621– 1835) (Jerusalem, 1966) [Hebrew], p. xii.
46
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
Typical of the language of the pinkasim was that the ordinances were received and established “upon ourselves and upon the generations to come,”68 or that it was “for the memory of generations after us in order that they know …”.69 The book of protocols for the community of Friedberg at the end of the sixteenth century noted that they were to serve “as a memory for the generations after us, so that they thereby know how to respond in case anyone should place himself above us in order to ruin our livelihood. As a result we have written in this book of protection, how the matters of the city arose in general, and specifically before the council, may its splendor be raised, to refer to the old ordinances and decisions, according to which the Jews should not carry on illegal business with incorrectly measured wares and should also not sell any spices, salted fish, or other things.”70 At times, the edicts in the pinkas were to be known and stand “from this day and forever,”71 or as in the Bamberg pinkas, “for a statute from today on.”72 As the scribe of one entry in the Friedberg pinkas noted, “I wrote this in order to record in this pinkas.”73 As the Posen pinkas related, the document established order,74 and served as a tool to recall the writing and seal of those in authority.75 The language of the Schnaittach pinkas similarly stressed establishing and guarding laws,76 the transgression of which was threatened with a stringent herem (excommunication). The Bamberg pinkas also stipulated “a fine on anyone who transgresses our words …”.77 The language of the pinkasim revealed both democratic tendencies and social tensions within the Jewish communities. The pinkas of Friedberg frequently recounted that its sections were “written according to the will of the kahal.”78 It was heard before the gabbaim and other officials, and enacted with the consent of the majority of the kahal.79 The authority of the ruling men of the community was significant; but throughout the Friedberg pinkas, the consent and representation of the community was central, as reflected in the phrase “elufim, parnasim, with individuals from the kahal and everyone together as one …”.80 The Posen pinkas stressed the approval of “the entire kahal or the majority of the kahal,”81 and noted that it was “for the honor of the kahal and for the honor of the kehilla.”82
68 Kober, “Documents,” p. 37. 69 Ibid., p. 34. 70 Litt, Protokollbuch, from the Hebrew, p. 88 (the German translation of which, p. 292, is not clear). 71 Ibid., p. 36. 72 David Kaufmann (ed.), Pinkas Kahal Kadosh Bamberg (Berlin, 1895), p. 9. 73 Kober, “Documents,” p. 52. 74 Avron (ed.), Acta Electorum, p. 2. 75 Ibid., p. 6. 76 Hildesheimer (ed.), Acta Communitatis Judaeorum Schnaittach, p. 158. 77 Kaufmann (ed.), Pinkas Kahal Kadosh Bamberg, p. 2; Kober, “Documents,” p. 37. 78 Kober, “Documents,” p. 34. 79 Ibid. 80 Ibid., p. 40. 81 Avron (ed.), Acta Electorum, p. 3. 82 Ibid., p. 20.
Community, Memory, and Governance
47
Two examples from the protocol book of the Portuguese Jewish community of Hamburg from the middle of the seventeenth century throw into relief the growing role of communal recordkeeping. According to one passage, communal archives served to validate the position and privileges of the Jewish communities within their non-Jewish context: “Samuel de Caeseres sent to this community copies of the privileges, which his majesty of Denmark had issued to Glückstadt. Through his recommendation the same was reproduced and extended for a further 25 years. He suggested, therefore, that one would want to send a copy of these privileges to Holland for perusal. The remaining, including two in gilded book-cover (case), should remain in the community archive.”83 But such engagement with past privileges and decisions could be turned inward as well, as when the protocol book noted that: The board considered it reasonable, in this community book, for the attention of the officers to come next, to present the ordinances [Ascamot] of the community both for those who should observe them as well as for those who have to keep watch over their maintenance, often times with great difficulties. It recommended that a revision of the ordinances be made, or be allowed to be made, by experienced people. Therefore, one must examine which ordinances are necessary for the governance of the community and service of God and therefore should be strongly maintained, and which proved to be superfluous or whose observance involved difficulty, in order to abolish these latter. One must direct his attention only to such laws that remain in force, which are also actually respected and are not daily violated by disregard of the board.84
And yet, while the past seems to have had the last word, it was the summoning up of that past—and as we saw earlier, its acceptance or rejection—that gave the past value and meaning. Although the various entries in most pinkasim did not necessarily follow in any chronological order, they did reference previous ordinances, and often enactments within other parts of the pinkas itself. Throughout, the pinkas noted that everything was explained in the pinkas of the takkanot of the kahal, and often stated that something was “explained in the previous takkanah [ordinance].”85 The Posen pinkas related “that [we] established all our writings according to the explanation in the pinkas kahal,” fashioning the pinkas as a legal record of the community.86 In the Bamberg pinkas, frequent reference was made to other parts of the pinkas and to sections of the “old pinkas.”87 Throughout the Posen pinkas, distinction was made between “this pinkas” and the “old pinkas.”88 But in the Posen pinkas there was an 83 Isaac Cassuto, “Aus den ältesten Protokollbuch der Portugiesisch-Jüdischen Gemeinde in Hamburg: Übersetzung und Anmerkungen,” in Jahrbuch der JüdischLiterarischen Gesellschaft 6 (1908): 1–54; 7 (1909): 159–210; 8 (1910): 227–90; 9 (1911): 318–66; 10 (1912): 225–95; 11 (1916): 1–76; 12 (1920): 55–118, here at vol. 10, p. 274 (18th of Tammuz). 84 Ibid., vol. 11, p. 73. 85 Kober, “Documents,” p. 41. 86 Avron (ed.), Acta Electorum, p. 11. 87 Kaufmann (ed.), Pinkas Kahal Kadosh Bamberg, p. 8. 88 Avron (ed.), Acta Electorum: “this pinkas” (pp. 23, 24, 53, 54); “old pinkas” (p. 31); “new pinkas” (p. 64); and “old takkanot” (p. 65).
48
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
important “historical” differentiation. The language employed by the Posen scribe was one that distinguished between ordinances “accustomed until this day”89 and ordinances that are “ordained from new.”90 At the same time, legislation from the distant past was also distinguished.91 The actual date of the enactment or record at times contributed to its authority. The current time was seen, in the Posen pinkas, as one of galut, exile, and the decrees were to last for “our kehilla and our sons after us until the end of all the generations.” Explicit reference was at times made to current or recent events—as in the Thirty Years’ War mentioned in the Posen pinkas.92 Special takkanot were issued particularly at difficult times, in the “hour of trouble.”93 The Posen pinkas noted that “now we make new the takkanah for the sake of the time and for what is therefore the need of the hour …”.94 Similarly, in excerpts from the minutes of Frankfurt am Main referencing the synod of 1542, the following statement was quite telling: That which has been, is that which shall be! See, is this new? It has been already of old times! Behold, all the wise of former generations were induced to perceive [the matter]. They resolved, declared and decreed that no rabbi or [talmudic] instructor, collectively or individually, shall oblige anyone to appear before an alien tribunal other than their own [under the threat] of a ban of excommunication.95
Appealing to previous legislation, the members of the synod attempted to deal with an apparently increasing early modern trend of Jews taking their legal cases outside of their region, perhaps hoping for more favorable conditions or outcomes. Regional Jewish communal authorities as well as non-Jewish territorial rulers and courts, however, attempted to reinforce local authority and better control the governance of the various communities. Customs Books and Community Memory: Juspa Hahn’s Sefer Yosef Ometz A great deal can be gleaned about internal hierarchies and struggles for authority in another type of communal writing, customs books. The early modern period witnessed the collection and publication of a number of important customs books. In Sefer Yosef Ometz, Joseph Juspa Hahn of Nördlingen (1570–1637), a leading member of the Jewish community in Frankfurt am Main, who served as head of the bet din and yeshivah and as communal rabbi during a key, and particularly tumultuous time,96 provided an important collection of laws and customs related to a variety of Jewish practices and holidays. Juspa completed Yosef Ometz around
89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96
Ibid., p. 55. Ibid., p. 31. Ibid., p. 15. Ibid., p. 38. Kober, “Documents,” p. 38. Avron (ed.), Acta Electorum, p. 42. Zimmer, Jewish Synods, p. 141. See Markus Horovitz, Frankfurter Rabbinen (Jerusalem, 1969).
Community, Memory, and Governance
49
1630,97 with many handwritten versions circulating in the family; but the text was not officially published until 1723 (in Frankfurt).98 Sefer Yosef Ometz, it could be argued, had relatively little new to say. It was largely a collection of laws and customs sifted from a variety of well-known and circulating sources. But to the group of frequently cited materials, Juspa added a number of lesser-known works, the customs of his own city of Frankfurt, and the actions of his father, teachers, and personalities of his age, particularly the leading scholars of Frankfurt. In addition to the legal portion, the emphasis on proper pious behavior, drawn from a variety of texts in the kabbalistic and musar traditions, gave the work an important quality that placed it squarely within its seventeenth-century milieu. Drawing from a broad range of sources, Juspa included scattered references throughout the work to the specific customs of his own Frankfurt community and the historical conditions in which he and his co-religionists lived. In his introduction, Juspa offered a number of reasons for compiling his work, including the memory of his father, Rabbi Pinchas Seligman of Nördlingen, who was a leader in synagogue prayers and a hasid in Frankfurt, and for whom every action was for the sake of Heaven, and whose teaching and observance of commandments was very exacting.99 Juspa also wrote of his early years and the influence of “active men” in convincing him to write.100 Juspa presented as well, a number of deeper meanings that explained the title of his work, Yosef Ometz. He wrote that the numerical value (gematria) of Yosef Ometz was equivalent to that of Pinchas, his father, at 297. Of course, Yosef hinted at his own name, and Ometz stood for the abbreviation aleph mem tsadi, or avi mori tsadik, “my father my teacher, the righteous.”101 The title also bore directly on the content and primary goal of the work as well—to increase encouragement and strength.102 Yosef Ometz was divided into three parts.103 The first, and most extensive, part examined laws, obligations, and customs regarding the daily and annual cycle and was termed the “Gate of the Exalted.”104 Section two focused on education, raising children, trust, charity and kindness to the poor, the funeral and laws of the mourner, and welcoming the bride. Juspa denoted this section as the “Earthly Gate.”105 According to Juspa, part three had two components that did not follow any particular order. One examined positive and negative commandments, the other good characteristics
97 Hava Fraenkel-Goldschmidt, “Jüdische Religion und Kultur in Frankfurt am Main im 16. und 17. Jahrhundert: Yuzpa Hahn und sein ‘Yosif omez,’” in Karl E. Grözinger (ed.), Jüdische Kultur in Frankfurt am Main von den Anfängen bis zur Gegenwart (Wiesbaden, 1997), pp. 101–21, here at p. 106. 98 Ibid., p. 107. 99 Joseph Juspa Hahn of Nördlingen, Yosef Ometz (Jerusalem, 1965), p. ix. 100 Ibid., p. x. 101 Ibid., p. xv. 102 See ibid., pp. 205 and 78, in addition to his Introduction. 103 Fraenkel-Goldschmidt, “Jüdische Religion und Kultur in Frankfurt am Main,” p. 107. 104 See Hahn, Yosef Ometz, p. xiii. 105 Ibid.
50
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
(middot).106 Part three was rounded out with a review of the mitzvot generally, sexual relations, idol worship, the submersion of vessels, orlah, pidyon ha-ben, precedence to the elderly and to fathers and mothers, laws of magic, vows, washing, suspension of speech, middot, and the reading of Shema for small children. The most frequently cited sources and authorities were the Shulhan Arukh and commentaries of and introductions to it; the Tur; the writings of Maharil; the works of Isaac Luria, frequently his Sefer ha-Kavannot, and those of his school;107 Reishis Hokhma; Sefer Hasidim and Sefer Haredim; Moses Mat’s108 Matteh Moshe; Seder ha-Yom; Zohar; the work of Solomon Luria (Maharshal, c.1510–74); and Emek Bracha.109 Less frequent, but important, references were also made to a number of kabbalists and kabbalistic works and central German rabbinic authorities of the later Middle Ages.110 Frequently, Juspa attested to the binding authority of the Shulhan Arukh, though at times he chose to follow the German rabbis. For example, when he contrasted the opinions of Jacob Weil and the Shulhan Arukh, he wrote “that one conducts in their lands differently, but we follow according to the renowned fifteenth-century scholar Rabbi Jacob Weil, who was a German …”.111 Juspa, like his Ashkenazic coreligionists, held closely to the binding power of minhag, noting that one must hold to old customs, even when the basis for them was no longer known.112 Yet, although he cited Ashkenazic customs frequently, he did not automatically follow the father of Ashkenazic minhag, the Maharil.113 Although Juspa referred frequently to the “sages,” he did not frequently reference Talmudic sources directly. He was more likely to reference contemporary sources as well as his father, his teacher Hirtz Treves of Frankfurt, and a host of other personalities of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries: Avraham Shaftel; Hayyim Katz of Prague; Levi Micha; Meir ha-Levy; Yakov Lieberman; Rabbi Segal; 106 Ibid. 107 Including Rabbi Yona of Safed, a student of Ari—see Fraenkel-Goldschmidt, “Jüdische Religion und Kultur in Frankfurt am Main,” p. 109. 108 Moses Mat (c.1551–c.1606) was born in Przemysl. His work, a “compendium of Jewish ritual law,” was completed in 1584 and printed in Cracow around 1590. In addition to other things he also wrote Taryag Mitzvot (Cracow, 1581) and Minhagei Maharshal, “which describes the customs and conduct of his teacher, Luria.” See Encyclopedia Judaica. 109 Regarding Emek Bracha, written by Rabbi Abraham b. Shabbetai Sheftel haLevy Hurwitz (Cracow, 1597?)—see Bernhard Friedberg, Bet ‘eked sefarim (Antwerp, 1928–31), p. 486, no. 473. For details regarding Hurwitz, see Zinberg, A History of Jewish Literature, vol. 6, pp. 50–57. Zinberg traces Hurwitz’s life from his early “free-thinking” at Prague, when he was an ardent supporter of Maimonidean rationalism, to his later moral and penitent mystical asceticism, when he consciously refuted his earlier views. It is to this later period that we can trace his work Emek Bracha and his Yesh Nohalim (p. 56). 110 For example, Maharam, Maharik, Jacob Weil, Moses Mintz, the Mordechai, Terumas ha-Deshen; Cordovero, Derekh Hayyim, Sha’arei Teshuva. Passing references were made to a great many more authors and sources. 111 Fraenkel-Goldschmidt, “Jüdische Religion und Kultur in Frankfurt am Main,” pp. 109–10. 112 Ibid., p. 111. 113 Ibid., p. 110.
Community, Memory, and Governance
51
Daniel Landshut; Jacob Schweinfurt; Slumiel of Prossnitz, Moses Menachem, and so on.114 According to most interpretations, although he cited kabbalistic works frequently, Juspa was no kabbalist. In fact, it is generally argued that he was ambivalent about kabbalah and he had nothing to do with many kabbalistic customs and practices.115 Juspa, however, was certainly taken with the works produced by Isaac Luria and the Lurianic school, as well as the more ethically-informed work of the Hasidei Ashkenaz, though in each case for the pietistic elements in these works. Throughout Sefer Yosef Ometz, Juspa distinguished time in the past116 and his own time.117 Often he offered specific dates, especially for community ordinances and events. He noted a custom established in 1589;118 an ordinance drawn up in 1600119 and a prohibition in 1619;120 a brit milah in 1626 that afforded a halakhic discussion about the celebratory meal;121 the expulsion of 1614;122 the pestilence of 1627;123 the date of the death of a great scholar who died in Frankfurt in 1505.124 In fact, the lives of scholars were sometimes taken as measures of the past, as when he noted that “and at the time that gaon our teacher and our rabbi Rabbi Hayyim of Prague was the av bet din [head of the rabbinic court] here.”125 Juspa referred more generally to the time of the expulsion when he mentioned customs in place at the time,126 and, referring perhaps to the salvation after the expulsion, he noted “manifest miracles that occurred in our times.”127 Within the same section, Juspa capitalized on a moralizing opportunity, writing that trust was the great root of our faith, especially in the midst of great suffering of man, which “I saw around the time of the expulsion from our city …”.128
114 See also ibid., pp. 113ff for “other small works.” 115 Ibid., pp. 107–8. 116 See Hahn, Yosef Ometz, pp. 2, 136, 49, 134, 164. See Volker Press, “Kaiser Rudolf II. und der Zusammenschluß der deutschen Judenheit: Die sogenannte Frankfurter Rabbinerverschwörung von 1603 und ihre Folgen,” in Alfred Haverkamp (ed.), Zur Geschichte der Juden im Deutschland des Späten Mittelalters und der Frühen Neuzeit (Stuttgart, 1981), pp. 243–93. 117 Ibid., pp. 37, 24. 118 Ibid., p. 223. 119 Ibid., pp. 346–7. 120 Ibid., p. 163. 121 Ibid., p. 212. 122 Ibid., pp. 211–12. 123 Ibid., p. 106. 124 Ibid., p. 215. 125 Ibid., p. 161. 126 Ibid., pp. 149, 238, 298. 127 Ibid., p. 292. 128 Ibid., p. 298.
52
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
Throughout the text, Juspa referred to previous and future sections. The expressions “recalled” above129 and “mentioned before,”130 ring throughout the text, marking the creation of the work as self-referential and as something of an unfolding process.131 At times, Juspa remarked simply that “I wrote” rather generally.132 Curiously, the “mentioned above” notes occurred at times only a few sections away—in section 1104, for example he noted that he had already written this above in sections 1099 and 1100!133 In other cases, as in a discussion of Purim, he noted that he would address the same issue some 80 pages later.134 At times, he wrote that the same issue was or would be taken up in a different part of the work.135 Frequently, Juspa wrote that he had discovered something different or additional “after I wrote.” There were different modes of discovery that Juspa outlined in this context. The most common was that of “finding,” for example, “after I wrote I found …” a discussion or ruling in a particular book. In a few other instances, the language is followed by the statement that “I remembered” the actions or words of a particular scholar136 or that “I saw” a particular custom or action.137 Indeed, when citing his sources, Juspa utilized a diverse vocabulary of action words, which included “read,”138 “received,”139 and “remembered,”140 but which focused on the actions of “finding,”141 “hearing,”142 and “seeing.”143 In a sense, each of these terms was related to the others, and all, therefore, formed key elements in Juspa’s scholarly method. Yet, each represented a rather different form of knowledge. A consideration of the differences allows us to peek into the mental structure of Juspa and so into his use of memory in the creation of authority and identity. The verb for finding as used by Juspa referred generally to written texts, whether published and common works or manuscripts.144 The action here, as posited
129 See, for example, ibid., pp. 25, 26, 41, 47, 51, 61, 62, 84, 89, 122, 123, 142, 153, 156, 164, 169, 170, 171, 176, 181, 182, 188, 200, 207, 208, 211, 213, 214, 220, 239, 240, 241, 267, 284, 327, 330, 332, etc. 130 For example, ibid., pp. 40, 41. 131 He referred to the writing of his book in a few places. See, for example, the introduction, ibid., pp. 78 (371), 205 (section 924). On p. 40 he wrote to his “dear students” regarding “everything that I have written in this, my book.” 132 See ibid., pp. 34, 67, 81, 86, 94, 219, 233, 271, 280, 353, 356 . 133 Similarly, in section 1086, he detailed what he wrote in section 1081 (ibid., p. 238). 134 See ibid., p. 156. 135 Ibid., pp. 288, 117. 136 Ibid., p. 274. 137 Ibid., p. 40. 138 Ibid., p. 267. 139 Ibid., pp. 216, 288. 140 Ibid., pp. 110, 140, 146. 141 For example, ibid., pp. 14, 44, 114, 144, 152, 156, 160, 176, 183, 184, 192, 202, 261, 261. 142 Ibid., pp. 28, 30, 68, 73, 99, 112, 117, 151, 191, 261. 143 Ibid., pp. 28, 52, 64, 108, 122, 140, 141, 149, 176, 184, 185, 191, 193, 196, 207, 214, 218, 228, 241, 260, 264, 269, 270, 272, 273, 290. 144 Ibid., p. 192.
Community, Memory, and Governance
53
directly in one instance, was that of reading.145 The body of knowledge gleaned from “finding” had the feel of general applicability and acceptability. The language for “hearing,” was as one might expect, less determinative. Its value was in part based on its source, and it appears to have had a general role in a larger process of determining proper behavior.146 There were generally two sources invoked here: the distant, such as reports of customs in Poland,147 in the name of a distant scholar148 or simply from “others”149 or from “before”;150 on the other hand, were the reports Juspa heard directly from his teacher151 or the elders.152 It was, again, the direct transmission of proper behavior, passed down through custom that seemed most central and binding. Finally, the language of “seeing” focused on Juspa’s own experiences— generally;153 actions that he saw and remembered later154 or actions that he saw his father and other “men of action”155 or his teacher156 perform. The term also referred to general practices he had observed or heard157 or to the written text as well.158 Although this form of experience seems to have had greater validity even than the second, that is, “hearing,” Juspa felt concerned to note the truth of his observations in some cases beyond his own words or recollections.159 We saw earlier that Juspa’s use of a number of individual types had meaning for his engagement with the past and can be divided as follows: self, father, teacher, pious person, sages. Throughout, the text was very much centered on Juspa, both in terms of what he had discovered, seen, or heard but also as regards his individual actions. A very common concern was the actions to which Juspa was himself accustomed160 or the observance of which he was particularly stringent.161 The relation between action and writing took on an important dimension when Juspa noted that, “I am accustomed to do everything I write.”162 In addition to mentioning the Sefer Hasidim and the Sefer Haredim throughout the work, Juspa also focused on the actions and teachings of the individual hasid 163 145 See ibid., p. 267. 146 Ibid., p. 191. 147 Ibid., pp. 112, 151. 148 Ibid., p. 261. 149 Ibid., p. 68. 150 Ibid., p. 73. 151 Ibid., pp. 99, 191. 152 Ibid., p. 117. 153 Ibid., pp. 196, 241, 260. 154 Ibid., pp. 108, 140, 193. 155 Ibid., pp. 122, 176, 184, 185, 207, 269, 290. 156 Ibid., pp. 28, 52, 270. 157 Ibid., pp. 228, 264. 158 Ibid., pp. 214, 272. 159 See, for example, ibid., p. 101. 160 Ibid., pp. 28, 97, 113, 127, 150, 158, 159, 168. 161 Ibid., p.19. 162 Ibid., p. 68. 163 Ibid., pp. 9, 69, 86, 100, 295.
54
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
or on pious individuals164 more generally. This type had similarities with those he labeled “men of action.”165 The term “kabbalists” also had much the same valence in the text166—focusing, however, primarily on the words and teachings of the kabbalists, rather than their actions. Here as elsewhere, Juspa folded the language of action and that of writing and teaching. At times, he distinguished between the hasid of his own day and the “early hasidim.”167 The sages also represented a typology for Juspa. He referred to them frequently, though typically in groups. By and large the sages were reflective of the “rabbis” of the Talmud, and various verbal language described their actions: said, interpreted, explained, wrote, debated, ordained, opposed. The rulings of the sages generally took on a past time, even when their rulings had contemporaneous applicability. In a few cases, Juspa used the term sage or wise one of “our city,”168 marking the term with a distinctively local or contemporary meaning. Juspa made frequent reference to his teacher, Rabbi Hirtz Treves of Frankfurt,169 and the local and contemporary scholar Rabbi Yishaya Segal170—mara d’atra [master of the place] in Frankfurt who traveled to Jerusalem,171 and who served as the head of the bet din in Frankfurt.172 From the text, we know that Hirtz Treves was a kabbalist.173 Juspa referred to his teacher frequently and rather formulaically, noting the customs and rulings he received from him.174 We learn about different aspects of Hirtz in many of the passages. However, what is clear is that Juspa saw him as his primary teacher, aside from his father, and that it was important for Juspa to anchor him in an identifiable position as head of the bet din “here” in Frankfurt. Rabbi Yishaya Segal was referenced in much the same way; focusing on his connection to Frankfurt as head of the bet din, on the ordinances he established in and for Frankfurt, and on his rulings and customs that Juspa himself followed.175 A particularly special place was made for Juspa’s father, who appeared frequently in the text,176 even though Juspa mentioned his father’s name—Pinhas Seligman—in
164 “Hasidim”— ibid., pp. 32, 67, 89, 120, 137; or “haredim” [God-fearing]—pp. 41, 61, 142. 165 Ibid., pp. 28, 44, 137, 198. 166 Ibid., pp. 64, 67, 137, 197, 209, 340. 167 Ibid., p. 32. 168 Ibid., pp. 176, 191. 169 Ibid., pp. 9, 28, 29, 37, 52, 61, 99, 111, 123, 155, 191, 216, 270, 353. See Eric Zimmer, The Fiery Embers of the Scholars: The Trials and Tribulations of German Rabbis in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries (Be’er Sheva’, 1999) [Hebrew], and Marcus Horovitz, Die Frankfurter Rabbinerversammlung von Jahre 1603 (Frankfurt am Main, 1897). 170 Hahn, Yosef Ometz, p. 9. 171 Ibid., p. 100. 172 Ibid., pp. 187, 162. “Yishai”—pp. 31, 41, 66, 97, 100, 187, 162, 204. 173 Ibid., pp. 9, 123. 174 Ibid., pp. 29, 37, 99, 111. 175 Ibid., pp. 31, 66, 97. 176 Ibid., pp. 35, 40, 52, 53, 54, 64, 94, 122, 147, 163, 171, 176, 179, 181, 207, 215, 221, 233, 236, 269.
Community, Memory, and Governance
55
only a few places.177 Juspa referred to his father as the “hasid”178 and his teacher.179 It is clear that his father wrote—Juspa noted that his father wrote regarding the minhag that was established with a brit milah on Yom Kippur in Frankfurt in 5349 (1589)180—and that Juspa held him to be part of a chain of scholarly tradition.181 The customs and observances of Juspa’s father were central for Juspa himself.182 The study patterns of his father were at times revealed in passing. Juspa, for example, noted that he saw his father learn the commentary of Isaac ben Jacob Alfasi (Rif, 1013–1103) with his students.183 Often his father’s authority was simply accepted, and in other, less frequent cases, his observance was justified via comparison with the action of other important types,184 or central works, such as the Shulhan Arukh,185 thus completing the important relationship between action, teaching, and printed word so common in the book. A common phrase that expressed Juspa’s use of the texts he culled, was “according to its [the text’s] language”186 or “in summary.”187 When he did cite a text directly, Juspa seemed generally to be very close to the actual language of the text; but he frequently added after the quotation from related sources or the same text in different, but corresponding passages. For Juspa the transmission of religious observance and authority was passed on through memory. But various levels of significance could be attributed to local, regional, and German customs. The text referred to Ashkenaz,188 described as “our land”189 or “our region”190 and contrasted it with Poland.191 Juspa mentioned customs of Ashkenaz;192 sages of Ashkenaz;193 and the language of Ashkenaz(im).194 There were scattered references to important communities such as Prague195 177 Ibid., pp. 153, 216, referring to Isaac Norlingen? 178 Ibid., pp. 135, 153, 163, for example. 179 Ibid., pp. 147, 153, 163. 180 Ibid., p. 223. 181 Ibid., p. 215, for example, when his father cited previous Frankfurt sages from the early sixteenth century, or when he was included in a long list of scholars (p. 221). 182 Ibid., pp. 54, 64, 94, 135, 147, 179, or by negation, p. 140. 183 Ibid., p. 269. 184 “and I saw that my father, my teacher, the hasid [pious one] of blessed memory and other men of action were accustomed [to act thus], and I myself am accustomed so” (ibid., p. 28); “… according to the minhag of my father, my teacher, the hasid of blessed memory and many poskim and also the kabbalist our teacher and our rabbi of blessed memory” (p. 52). 185 Ibid., p. 52; or according to the Tur, p. 213. 186 Ibid., pp. 26, 58, 63, 70, 78, 85, 103, 136, 144, 152, 154, 196, 271, 274, 276, 296, 304, 309. 187 Ibid., pp. 110, 202, 261, 265, 266. 188 Ibid., pp. 8, 12, 15. 189 Ibid., p. 187. 190 Ibid., p. 25. 191 Ibid., p. 12; for Poland, see also p. 51. 192 Ibid., p. 136. 193 Ibid., pp. 346–7. 194 Ibid., pp. 12, 61, 68, 73, 116, 160, 168. 195 Ibid., p. 40.
56
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
and Amsterdam196 and more substantial references to the two largest German communities197 of Worms198 and Frankfurt.199 References to Worms emphasized key rabbinic personalities of the city200 and customs.201 While similar emphases on personalities and customs permeated references to Frankfurt, that city had a very different spatial identity, referred to as “here”202 or “our city.203 When Juspa discussed customs, he included a diverse group: prior customs;204 general customs;205 customs of particular communities,206 especially those of Frankfurt.207 Juspa also mentioned customs of individual scholars,208 especially his father.209 As discussed earlier, many of the customs and personal observances of Juspa himself were stressed.210 The past as related in the customs of particular scholars or communities could be a very powerful force. The acceptance, consideration, or rejection of particular customs or authority could indicate changes in communal authority, external pressures or different means of identifying community. We will now look at some specific examples to see how engaging the past in this regard could be important for early modern German Jews. Narrating Customs and Politics Before we examine a few examples of the intersection of customs, narratives of the past, and internal social structure, it is necessary to provide some context for the history of the Jews in Frankfurt. Throughout the sixteenth century numerous ordinances restricted the business in which Jews could be involved. Early in the sixteenth century, foreign Jews were prohibited from conducting business in Frankfurt (though in some important ways such restrictions had to be remodeled in light of the growth of the Frankfurt fairs). In 1611, for example, Jews were prohibited from involvement with business in new clothes211 and the Schnürmacherordnung of 1591 and 1614 strengthened prohibitions against guild members teaching Jews their
196 Ibid., p. 14. 197 “In Ashkenaz and especially in the community of Frankfurt and the community of Worms it was established and received [as] good and beautiful” (ibid., p. 2). 198 Ibid., pp. 2, 13, 48, 58, 126, 213. 199 Ibid., pp. 2, 15, 97, 101, 121. 200 Ibid., p. 48. 201 “Spinholtz,” in ibid., p. 126; customs for mourners, p. 331. 202 Ibid., pp. 46, 66, 98, 183. 203 Ibid., p. 220; “sages of our city,” pp. 176, 191. 204 Ibid., p. 2. 205 Ibid., p. 136. 206 Ibid., p. 2; regarding Regensburg, p. 12. 207 See, for example, ibid., pp. 146, 155, 186, 187, 189, 212, 238. 208 Ibid., pp. 10, 28, 53, 97, for example. 209 Ibid., 94, 135, 142. 210 See, for example, ibid., pp. 105, 150, 159, 168, 212. 211 Isidor Kracauer, Geschichte der Juden in Frankfurt am Main (1150–1824), 2 vols (Frankfurt am Main, 1925–27), p. 315.
Community, Memory, and Governance
57
handiwork on pain of expulsion.212 Numerous attempts at expulsion and accusations of Jewish criminal activity could be found in the early modern period, and at times, as in counterfeiting, the accusations were not entirely unfounded.213 In 1606, an imperial commission did, indeed find a number of Jewish transgressions.214 In Sefer Yosef Ometz, Juspa discussed the commission and noted that: The hands were exhausted, and all hearts melted, the loins broken. It was in truth a great emergency that suddenly, like water, broke over Jacob. [There was] no possibility that some relief and salvation would come, for the Commission that the Emperor had established pressured us regarding the conduct of the boaster, and especially the one of them that stood completely under the influence of this man, he had an ear to the ruler and closed the doors from us.215
In many significant and instructive ways, the history of the Jews in Frankfurt mirrored the general developments of that city. From humble origins in the later Middle Ages, the community of Frankfurt would blossom into one of the largest and most important in the German Empire. The economic development of the city expanded dramatically between the middle of the fifteenth and middle of the seventeenth centuries. In the early fourteenth century, the city was the focus of a regional economy centered on the lower Rhine, with two annual fairs. These fairs eventually gained European prominence, but had no impact on the general European economy until the late sixteenth century, when the economy was further invigorated by the immigration of Protestant refugees from the Spanish Netherlands. Like many other cities, a depression of a sort ensued during the Thirty Years’ War; but, as in many other cities, the full effects of this depression hit in the late 1620s and early 1630s, giving way in subsequent decades to a revitalization. This is well reflected in the general population, which increased by 28 per cent between 1440 and 1550 and 76 per cent between 1550 and 1620, reaching 20,200. Again, the faltering of the late 1620s and early 1630s was reflected in a 16 per cent decline by 1655 (17,000).216 Reports and legends about Jews residing in Frankfurt date back to the eleventh century. Episodic violence and expulsion characterized the medieval Frankfurt Jewish community. Riots in 1241, for example, resulted in the destruction of Jewish property and the massacre of more than three-quarters of the 200 Jewish inhabitants. Intervening advances of the community were nullified by the pogroms associated with the Black Death in 1349, even if by 1360 Jews were allowed to return to the city. In 1434/35, the Jewish community of Frankfurt paid an imperial tax of 600 Gulden, marking it as only the tenth highest contributing community, behind the
212 Ibid., p. 322. 213 Ibid., pp. 324–5. 214 Ibid., pp. 332, 340ff. 215 Hahn, Yosef Ometz, p. 170; cited in Kracauer, Geschichte der Juden in Frankfurt am Main (1150–1824), p. 344, n. 1. 216 Gerald Lyman Soliday, A Community in Conflict: Frankfurt Society in the Seventeenth and Early Eighteenth Centuries (Hanover, NH, 1974), pp. 1f.
58
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
large communities of Nuremberg, Mainz, Regensburg, and Augsburg; but also behind such middling communities as Oppenheim, Halle, Zurich, and Schweinfurt.217 In 1462, a street constructed for the special purpose of holding the Jews of the city within confined quarters (Judengasse) was completed. Despite the closed quarters, Jewish life seems to have thrived. There were 110 registered inhabitants of the ghetto in 1463, 250 in 1520, 900 in 1569, 1,200 in 1580, 2,200 in 1600, and about 3,000 in 1610. In 1462, Jews constituted roughly 1 per cent of the total population. By 1610, the nearly 3,000 Jews accounted for 11 per cent of the city’s burgeoning population—a total number unlike any other in Germany at the time (outside Prague). In 1462, with the founding of the Jewish ghetto, there were six Jewish houses; by 1610 there were 195.218 The Jewish population increases are also evident when one traces the number of Jewish taxpaying households: 22 in 1473; 43 in 1543; and 453 in 1613.219 As Frankfurt became a growing center of trade, German Jews forged strong connections to the city. By the end of the seventeenth century, there were four synagogues, a cemetery, bathhouse, rabbi’s house, dance and wedding hall.220 By the end of the sixteenth century the community was at its apex and its rabbis and courts were recognized throughout Germany, with rabbinical synods held there in 1562, 1582, and, most importantly, in 1603. Frankfurt developed as a central, if not the most important Jewish community in Germany. The synod of 1603 was described as the last attempt of a powerful rabbinate to express, if ultimately not to enforce,221 its views. Among the issues taken up at the synod were the separation of Jews from Gentiles, the establishment of central courts, the collection of taxes and the territorial organization of the “General Community” or “General Organization,” and the ordination and authority of rabbis.222 At the same time that the fair and trade, particularly in textiles,223 became central in the development of Frankfurt Jewry, the Jews established important familial networks and increasing supra-regional business and credit relations with the land surrounding the city.224 The financial work and contributions of the Jews allowed them to maintain important privileges and continuity of settlement during the sixteenth century. The community, though expelled for a time, was even able to rebound after the storming, plundering and rioting of the followers of Vincent Fettmilch in 1614. The Jews returned triumphantly in 1616 even as Fettmilch and his key henchmen were being executed. 217 Toch, “Siedlungsstruktur der Juden Mitteleuropas im Wandel vom Mittelalter zur Neuzeit,” p. 30. 218 Ibid., p. 39. 219 Ibid., p. 25; see also p. 40. 220 Soliday, A Community in Conflict, pp. 3–4. 221 Louis Finkelstein, Jewish Self-Government in the Middle Ages (New York, 1924), pp. 80–81. 222 See ibid., pp. 78–81; 257–64. See also Zimmer, The Fiery Embers of the Scholars and Horovitz, Die Frankfurter Rabbinerversammlung von Jahre 1603. 223 Toch, “Siedlungsstruktur der Juden Mitteleuropas im Wandel vom Mittelalter zur Neuzeit,” p. 37. 224 Ibid., pp. 35–6.
Community, Memory, and Governance
59
Yosef Ometz is replete with references to the expulsion of the Jews from Frankfurt in 1614, during the Fettmilch uprising, as well as other difficulties that Jews living in the city faced. In one place, Juspa noted that “if a Jew walks through the gentile streets, they cry after him ‘dog’ or other insulting epithets and throw dirt and stones at him.”225 Other repressive measures affected Jewish life and ritual as well. During one year, the gate leading to the river was closed to the Jews and guarded by soldiers, forcing the Jews to perform tashlikh (casting away sins at Rosh ha-Shannah) “at the rampart of the city where through a narrow ditch the waste water flowed.” Juspa expressed hope that the ancient custom would be restored.226 Regarding the events of 1614 Juspa wrote: 27 in Elul we established here a fast on the community [tsibur] with all its particulars because here on that day in the year 1614 we were expelled from our community by the people of the city who conspired against us, who were rebels and stood to destroy us, God forbid, or expel us; and they decided … to expel us. We were expelled from our city and also our money, which remained after the stolen goods that were stolen from us at night, and we were not able to hide it from outside the wall of the street … And the rebels, mentioned before, burned our streets and however many holy writings they found in our houses and in the synagogue, they also mishandled these sifrei Torah on account of our sins … Regarding all these matters, the day mentioned above was established a fast, and prayers and selihot—on that day many troubles overtook … and if the day mentioned above falls on the eve of Shabbat, the fast is not completed; and if it falls on Shabbat the fast is made earlier, on the eve of Shabbat.227
The passage described the expulsion, particularly the fomentation against the Jews and the robbery and destruction perpetrated. It also placed the events squarely in communal memory by establishing a memorial through the fast on the community. This is a very good example of the ritualized memorial Yerushalmi and others have noted when examining the historical thinking of pre-modern Jews (see above, Chapter 1). The Fettmilch uprising wreaked tremendous havoc on the Jewish community of Frankfurt. According to Juspa, “they burned in our streets countless holy writings, which they found in our houses [and] in the synagogue …”.228 During the uprising, 262 Jews were killed and Jewish possessions valued at 175,919 Gulden were lost to plundering. The challenges, however, were more than external. The community had, for some time, been torn by internal divisions and increasing enmity. According to the historian Isidore Kracauer, internal ferment in the Jewish quarter, the desire for a new community constitution, and the political awakening of the ghetto inhabitants were a direct consequence of the Fettmilch uprising.229 The heavily oligarchic Jewish government was already the target of constitutional upheaval at the beginning of the seventeenth century, when a weak rebellion erupted 225 Israel Zinberg, A History of Jewish Literature, trans. Bernard Martin, 12 vols (Cleveland and Cincinnati, 1972–78). Here at vol. 6, p. 71 (Hahn, Yosef Ometz, p. 109). 226 Ibid., paraphrasing Yosef Ometz, p. 121. 227 Hahn, Yosef Ometz, pp. 211–12. 228 Ibid., section 153, in Kracauer, Geschichte der Juden in Frankfurt am Main (1150– 1824), p. 388. 229 Kracauer, Geschichte der Juden in Frankfurt am Main (1150–1824), p. 399.
60
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
against the highly ensconced board members, the Zehner, with calls to add an additional ten directors.230 Two feuding groups eventually emerged, and submitted their case to arbitration by a third party of judges, rabbis from Fulda, Hildesheim, and Metz. The new Zehner were forced to resign, but the old ones were not to remain in power alone—seven new colleagues had to be introduced. The old Zehner refused to accept the decision, prompting one opponent to argue that the Zehner wanted to bring the entire Frankfurt Jewry into “Egyptian servitude, so to speak.” An external imperial commission examined 212 members of the community and found that only a minority of Jews was satisfied with the current communal government. The majority demanded three policies: father and son should not sit on the council at the same time; the service of the Zehner should not be lifelong but limited to two years; and, the current Zehner should abdicate and be replaced by non-partisan men, not closely related to one another.231 The economic divisions within the Jewish community were, however, obvious to non-Jews alike. While the Frankfurt citizens’ committee pressed to have all but the wealthiest 20 Jewish families expelled in 1612, the city council compromised, agreeing in principle to expel only the poorest 60.232 In the same way that the uprising challenged the city’s patrician leaders it was simultaneously anti-patrician and antiJewish.233 In May of 1614, Fettmilch’s supporters occupied city hall, holding the councilmen and forcing them to resign and leave the city.234 The complicated history of the community, combining dramatic growth, increasing internal tensions, and broader external problems, could leave the community itself remarkably volatile. It is in this context that Juspa’s emphasis on authority and practice, and his concern for true customs took on great significance. Juspa was often concerned with new customs and the re-establishment of old customs practiced before the expulsion, once the Jews had been resettled or found themselves in more favorable circumstances.235 After all, as we saw above, Juspa maintained that, “all customs of our fathers are law … and a land cannot change its interpretation.”236 In a rather complicated and revealing passage, Juspa discussed the controversy surrounding the custom of eating the third meal on the Sabbath.
230 Ibid., p. 400. 231 Ibid., pp. 400–405. For information on the diverse wealth of Jews in the early modern period, see for example the literature on rural Jewry, the court Jews, and the Sephardic Jews in Hamburg. 232 Friedrichs, “Politics or Pogrom? The Fettmilch Uprising in German and Jewish History,” p. 192. 233 Ibid., pp. 188, 190ff, 202. 234 Ibid., p. 192. 235 Fraenkel-Goldschmidt, “Jüdische Religion und Kultur in Frankfurt am Main im 16. und 17. Jahrhundert,” p. 111, n. 33 (Hahn, Yosef Ometz, section 671). See for example, Yosef Ometz, p. 238: “… and before we were exiled from our city in the year of the expulsion the simple custom was to give the gabbai two cakes …”. 236 Fraenkel-Goldschmidt, “Jüdische Religion und Kultur in Frankfurt am Main im 16. und 17. Jahrhundert” p. 112; Hahn, Yosef Ometz, pp. 591–2; Zinberg, A History of Jewish Literature—every custom of our fathers is Torah (vol. 6, p. 69).
Community, Memory, and Governance
61
Regarding the time of the third meal, there are various customs here and also in these holy communities in the land of Ashkenaz; there was the custom for a long time to eat the meal before the afternoon prayers, and in these places in the land of Ashkenaz and almost in most, [it was] the custom to eat the meal between the afternoon and evening prayers. Both customs were expressed in the writings of the Mordechai … and the Rosh, there [Shabbat] and [in] other passages.
After explaining the various customs and the rabbinic support for them, Juspa goes on to explain their significance for the Frankfurt communal identity within the context of the turmoil caused by the Fettmilch uprising. He notes that: And at the time of the expulsion, when we were scattered and dispersed between settlements, the villages and small cities that surround us, that were themselves accustomed … to eat between the afternoon and evening prayers, and because we were almost alike imprisoned under their hands … to eat at the time of their meal. And after we were returned to our city by He who performs miracles, the people of our city did not want to abstain from the custom that they were accustomed to when they were outside our city.
While dispersed outside Frankfurt, many Jews began to practice a different custom than that traditionally regnant in Frankfurt. They ate their third Sabbath meal between the afternoon and evening prayers, providing more time for various leisure activities. But, the rabbinic leadership was here confronted with a significant legal question. Although both customs had rabbinic support, there was a widespread practice to treat local custom as law. What is more, local custom could not simply be changed, even despite changed circumstances. Juspa records the decision of the rabbinic leadership: And behold, I put my head between the pillars in this matter and I did what the av bet din and the judge in our city, that was here in these days, [said]. The people of the yeshivah, the sages of our city, the great ones, who were at that time here, and myself, the small, I also did so and was connected to them; our agreement, that was in the va’ad [council] to legislate a response for the usage, what the words of Heaven [dictated] that a person could not alter from the previous custom that was established from olden times … and also the words of the Maharil thus proved that it was the custom in the land of Ashkenaz, and they announced then so according to their words in the synagogue with other ordinances that they then legislated.
Citing the authority of Ashkenazic minhag, Maharil, the rabbis concluded that the previous custom of the community in Frankfurt could not be altered. The decision was proclaimed throughout the community. Foreseeing that opposition to the declaration might be expected, the rabbis also explained how people would be called to the synagogue for prayers on the Sabbath and explicated the punishment for those disregarding the ruling. The av bet din also decreed to the shammash that he was not to call people to the synagogue for afternoon prayers in the summer until after seven o’clock … for the time to eat and take pleasure and for the hour of the time to call the eating before the afternoon prayers, that is five o’clock until seven. And so the gaon, sage of our city, our teacher, our rabbi Moshe Mendels, of blessed memory, resolved very much in this matter and he decreed the herem on the shammash [should he not follow this order].
62
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
But, Juspa concludes, there were some lay leaders who preferred the new custom for personal reasons and influenced the shammash to subvert the old custom over time by calling people to the synagogue in such a way as to force observance of the newer custom. The battle over the custom, here as memory and practice of past tradition, had significant resonance in a community wracked by internal divisions and increasing tensions between rabbinic and lay leadership. And because there were then parnasim, who because of pleasure, wanted to continue the meal between the afternoon and evening prayers, because if they ate before the afternoon prayers, what would they do between the afternoon and evening prayers, they flattered the shammash with their words, until he did not listen to our teacher, and he called [people] to the synagogue at six o’clock so that the people could not eat and enjoy the Shabbat meal before the call to the synagogue came. And little by little, people got used to eating the meal after the afternoon prayers. There were also those individuals who fortified themselves in the matter to eat before the afternoon prayers, and they got used to making hamotzei before the afternoon prayers; in any case, the shammash became little by little accustomed to make the call to the synagogue earlier, every year a little bit earlier, until the previous custom of eating before the afternoon prayers was nullified, in any event.
Juspa went on to complete the section by noting what a terrible development this was, a true stumbling block, since there was a widespread custom for those with deceased parents not to drink water after the afternoon prayers. With the new custom of reciting the afternoon prayers earlier in the day being observed, the time in which people could not drink was extended. The expulsion from the city, the settlement in surrounding communities, and the return to the city served as a powerful backdrop to discussions about communal behavior and identity. This example takes on more powerful meaning when seen within the context of external pressures—such as professional restrictions and attempts at expulsion—and internal crises—such as increasing population and social tensions, declining rabbinic authority, and increasing territorialization.237 The past was engaged here for very important discussions and with very tangible results. Yair Hayyim Bacharach’s commentary to Juspa of Worms’ customs for the community of Worms also offered historical information about some of the key events in the history of the Jewish community in Worms, both in internal social and political developments and in external events. While mentioning the specific rulings of his father, he also detailed the circumcisions, weddings, and deaths of prominent members of the community.238 Particularly important in Bacharach’s work were details of the invasion of Worms by the French and the expulsion of the Jews. In commenting on the holy community of Worms, Bacharach argued that, “whoever did not see Worms in its splendour and order, had never truly viewed a noble community.”239 In being forced to flee, like 237 Friedrichs, “Anti-Jewish Politics,” p. 200. 238 See Shulkhan Arukh Orakh Hayyim im Perush Mekor Hayyim (Hereafter MH), 2 vols (Jerusalem, 1982) p. 179, for example, which mentions the death in 1670/71 of Beila and also his father; p. 249 regarding memorial; particularly members of the Oppenheim family and the parnasim and their families; see vol. 2, pp. 104, 105. 239 Fritz Reuter, Warmaisa: 1000 Jahre Juden in Worms (Worms, 1984), p. 124.
Community, Memory, and Governance
63
other citizens, and witnessing the destruction, “the Jews experienced terrible anxiety, for the majority of houses in the Jewish quarter were constructed on the city wall … The cities of Worms, Speyer, and Oppenheim were almost simultaneously burned. We had to leave our houses and our courtyard and allow our holy synagogue to be ruined. We had to pack all our belongings and flee. God would be compassionate to us.”240 The continuity of the community and its practices was emphasized by Bacharach, who noted that even pious customs practiced, though perhaps not formally and publicly adopted, by the citizens of a community were incumbent upon succeeding generations.241 Responding to inquiries about whether members of the Worms community were bound to continue to observe special fasts and customs of the community after its destruction, Bacharach contended that: Even if some few individuals had given up hope, they must follow the feeling of the entire congregation (who must be assumed not to have despaired) … The summary is that this destruction was only like an expulsion, or a flight before an earthquake, or before an oppressor. Even if all of the people left, nevertheless we hoped every day for the salvation of the Lord in a natural way. Hence, it was certainly their intention to return and therefore it was incumbent upon them to maintain all the strict observances of the earlier community.242
Bacharach noted, in commenting on the customs of Worms, that the community imposed upon itself a fast on the eve of Rosh Hodesh Shevat, to recall the expulsion from Worms, and that “the scholar, our teacher and our rabbi, Vital, who was head of the bet din after the expulsion … took upon himself the fast.”243 The fast was imposed upon the community as a form of communal memory and identification.244 The discussion of particular customs in Worms not only revealed internal struggles and attempts to recollect or reconstruct, or even create, tradition, but also displayed the effects that non-Jewish reactions might have on Jewish practice. To give but one example:
240 Ibid., p. 124. 241 Solomon Freehof, A Treasury of Responsa (Philadelphia, 1963) p. 173; see Kaufmann, R. Jaïr Chajjim Bacharach, pp. 77ff. 242 Freehof, A Treasury of Responsa, pp. 174–5 (Bacharach, Havot Yair, vol. 1, responsum 126, pp. 347–9, here at p. 349). 243 Bacharach, Jair Chajim (ed.), Wormser Minhagbuch des R. Jousep (Juspa) Schammes, prepared by Erich Zimmer, 2 vols (Jerusalem, 1988) [Hebrew], here at vol. 1, p. 248. 244 One question directed to Bacharach revolved around questions of desecration of the Sabbath. The inquirer asked if it was appropriate to declare a fast on the community (tsibur) because of the sins of the community (kahal), noting that many authorities, such as Asheri, and the author of Terumas haDeshen probited such fasts [on the Sabbath] in general (ibid., vol. 2, responsum 236, p. 663). He also asked whether it was a desecration of the Sabbath to save the community by means of money [which would not be allowed to be handled on the Sabbath], if there was not a general threat to life. Bacharach responded that it was appropriate for an individual in danger to desecrate the Sabbath to lament and to impose upon himself a fast.
64
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany I also witnessed the following: In 5429 [1669] a battle was fought between the Duke of Pfalz and the Prince of Lothringen. On Hoshana Rabba they confronted each other—camp against camp, troop against troop. They fought near the mountain known as Wingertsberg. Both sides lost many men, and the Duke himself participated in the battle. He retreated through our city, Worms, with the remnants of his troops. A great fear arose in the Duke’s state, and no bonfire was kindled for many reasons. Nevertheless, the men appointed to complete and reinitiate the annual cycle of Torah reading assembled in the Braut Haus together with the other men who customarily entered with them. They rejoiced in the customary manner as in previous years with wine and fruits. Only the fires were not kindled so as not to appear overly joyful during the Duke’s defeat.245
Conclusions Jewish communities in early modern Germany could be highly variegated and complex. Communal organization differed between communities and regions and was becoming, in some important ways, more formalized and bureaucratic. The intensification of communal recordkeeping in the form of communal ledgers reflected broader social and cultural developments. A close look at these documents reveals that Jews distinguished time and narrated past events in sophisticated ways and for many different purposes. The past was a useful tool in establishing and carrying on tradition or instituting new laws. In the same way, there were reasons for Jewish customs, and Jewish memory could serve to record, explain and, when necessary, justify the past and the practices of the past. The continuation or limiting of past practices was affected not only by internal communal and religious disposition, but by the pressures of non-Jewish society as well. Treading the fine line of negotiating with the past and past practices was a delicate exercise for a minority population; however, such delicacy did not of necessity imply powerlessness, as Jews might adapt past practices to honor custom while responding to present realities and constraints. We need not assume, therefore, that early modern German Jews lived tenuously with no ability to engage their past or shape their future. It is clear from the limited examples reviewed here that continuity with the past was central within the Ashkenazic communities. One can argue reasonably, that the emphasis on tradition was a counter to the throes of discontinuity and trauma as 245 Shlomo Eidelberg, Medieval Ashkenazic History: Studies on German Jewry in the Middle Ages, I English Essays, excerpts from “Minhagim of the Worms Community,” pp. 130–31. Or consider, “In the year 5424, a great war raged between the Kaiser and the Turks. During the war the Turks captured the city of Neustadt from the Kaiser as well as a portion of the Hungarian territory. Certain Jew-hating gentiles slandered the Jews by claiming that we rejoiced in the victory of the Turks’ unmentionable ways. They frightened us dreadfully, so that the congregation did not permit the shammash to kindle the customary fire (for Simhat Torah). However, they permitted the kindling of the fire in the courtyard of the yeshiva because they did not wish the custom to be ignored in the future. They kindled the fire in the Yeshiva courtyard only during the reading of the Torah until the congregation left the synagogue.” (Eidelberg, Medieval Ashkenazic History, excerpts from “Minhagim of the Worms Community,” p. 147).
Community, Memory, and Governance
65
experienced in expulsion and internal social struggles. Yet, the battle over tradition and the power of recalling the past revealed the deep tensions penetrating even the largest and most important early modern German Jewish communities. With social divisions, contention over rabbinic and lay authority, and changing economic, political, and cultural conditions, Jewish community was undergoing serious changes and experiencing significant challenges. Narrating and recalling the past was one way to combat changes—at least changes seen from particular vantage points—but, as we have seen earlier, could also be a means for change as well.
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 4
Jewish Social Organization: The Role of Memory, Power, and Honor Social Order and Change in Early Modern Germany Beyond basic demographic patterns, the social organization of early modern Germany was simultaneously traditional and volatile. While the writer Hans Sachs had noted 114 social and occupational categories already in the early sixteenth century,1 early modern Germany nonetheless remained a society of orders,2 and most scholars have found in the period from 1300–1600 a social structure that remained largely intact. An early seventeenth-century Frankfurt am Main ordinance referenced five broad social categories into which the city population could be divided: patricians; other council members and distinguished merchants; distinguished retailers and members of the legal establishment; craftsmen and ordinary retailers; and unskilled workers.3 The social and economic disparities of the later Middle Ages, however, continued or intensified in the early modern period. In Nördlingen, for example, 6 per cent of the population owned more than 40 per cent of the property recorded in the tax lists in the second half of the seventeenth century.4 In Schwäbisch Hall, in 1625, the poorest 60 per cent of the population paid only 9 per cent of the total wealth tax receipts (Beet); the wealthiest 4 per cent paid 36–42 per cent; the top quintile alone paid 25 per cent. At least one-third of the town’s wealth belonged to a mere 40 households.5 In Augsburg, in the early seventeenth century, the wealthiest 10 per cent of the population possessed 92 per cent of the wealth and the wealthiest 2 per cent owned 61 per cent.6 Similar power and wealth structures could be found in German villages in the early modern period. When combined with complex political and economic ties to cities, territorial rulers, or even the emperor, such village social structure could be quite charged.7 1 Christopher R. Friedrichs, “German Social Structure, 1300–1600,” in Scribner (ed.), Germany: A New Social and Economic History, pp. 233–58, here at p. 234. 2 Ibid., p. 233. 3 Ibid., p. 245. 4 Robert von Friedburg and Wolfgang Mager, “Learned Men and Merchants: The Growth of the Bürgertum,” in Ogilvie (ed.), Germany: A New Social and Economic History, pp. 164–95, here at p. 183. 5 Terrence McIntosh, Urban Decline in Early Modern Germany: Schwäbisch Hall and Its Region, 1650–1750 (Chapel Hill, 1997), p. 50. 6 Ibid., p. 51. 7 See, for example, David Sabean, Power in the Blood: Popular Culture and Village Discourse in Early Modern Germany (Cambridge, 1988 (orig., 1984)).
68
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
It should also be noted that a city’s population included many more groups of people than “citizens.” In Colmar, for example, the 1610 tax registers indicate that 58.7 per cent of the householders (620 out of 1,057) were inscribed in the citizen registers. An additional 18.4 per cent (194) claimed to be citizens in the parish registers.8 But that left a substantial portion of the city’s residents—almost 23 per cent—with no formal citizens’ rights. Given such divisions and various political crises, urban unrest and confessional confrontations continued to be part of the pattern of urban life with, for example, visible protests and revolts in Aachen (1580), Augsburg (1584), Emden (1595), Lübeck (1598), and Worms and Frankfurt am Main (1612).9 The situation could be very similar, and often even more pronounced, in the rural areas. In mid-sixteenth-century Mark Brandenburg, for example, 14 of the 300 knightly families possessed nearly a third of the group’s total landholdings.10 Given this environment of demographic change, social tension, political complexity, and religious ferment, antiquity and authenticity of familial lineage were seen to be as important as economic wealth and very significant tools for the legitimization of power.11 In addition, with the increasing role of Roman Law, and its purveyors— the doctors of jurisprudence—themselves claiming nobility,12 it became ever more important for families to trace and assert their ancestry and lineage. This is a topic that will be treated in more detail later in this chapter. Social tensions were rife in early modern Germany. Great discrepancies in wealth and social status combined with complex and changing social structures. Early modern Germans navigated this world through the use of honor and recourse to the past. The contexts in which Jews found themselves could have significant resonance in internal Jewish development. Even in larger cities, where Jews were segregated in a ghetto or Jewish quarter, Jewish culture was not a culture of the ghetto. Rather, Jews often took part in the ruling cultural norms but could give external ideas a Jewish meaning.13 Indeed, the repeated appearance of sumptuary laws and ordinances (takkanot) attempting to deal with the problem of the attraction of new cultural behavior seems to imply that Jews were much more involved in the world around them than was once believed. Jews were still required to dress in ways that distinguished them from their Christian neighbors and there is evidence of at times heated conflict over religious practices, particularly those that were visible in or affected the larger public space, such as the establishment of an eruv (an extension of the private domain into the public domain, typically by using a wire, to allow carrying on the Sabbath that is 8 Wallace, Communities and Conflict in Early Modern Colmar: 1575–1730, p. 13. 9 R. Po-chia Hsia, “The Structure of Belief: Confessionalism and Society, 1500–1600,” in Scribner (ed.), Germany: A New Social and Economic History, pp. 355–77, here at p. 371. 10 Friedrichs, “German Social Structure, 1300–1600,” p. 235. 11 Ibid., p. 236. 12 Ibid., p. 237. 13 Jews could appropriate chivalric romances, for example, substituting Jewish for Christian fighters and eliminating those elements which were too Christian. See Christoph Daxelmüller, “Organizational Forms of Jewish Popular Culture since the Middle Ages,” in Hsia and Lehmann (eds), In and Out of the Ghetto, pp. 29–48.
Jewish Social Organization: The Role of Memory, Power, and Honor
69
otherwise forbidden) or the employment of Christians on the Sabbath. Nevertheless, social separation did not have to result in political exclusion.14 Particularly in south Germany, Jews seem to have been integrated in their village societies, without being assimilated, and Jews and Christians at times even shared formal government administration.15 There is evidence throughout the early modern period of close Jewish and Christian interaction, in political administration and even in more “religious” events such as weddings and synagogue openings. Given such a permeable environment, it should not be too surprising to find that important and growing social disequilibrium and contestation of power was developing within the Jewish communities themselves. According to one recent assessment, there were four different classes in early modern Jewish society. The conflict in early modern Jewish communities involved the interaction of these groups, and not only along distinctions between rich and poor.16 Like early modern German society more generally, internal Jewish social and political structures were frequently oligarchic and contested. In Frankfurt, for example, there was growing polarization between the wealthy and the rest of the community, with power being increasingly concentrated in the hands of the few wealthy members, and growing discontent “among those Jewish householders who were excluded from political participation.”17 Christopher Friedrichs writes that “these struggles within the Frankfurt community are strikingly reminiscent of the conflicts that took place among the Christian citizens of Frankfurt and countless other German cities during the same epoch.”18 Serious internal constitutional overhaul was called for, both from within and outside the Jewish community. Such struggles within the Jewish community were never “confined to the community itself.” Non-Jewish authorities—local, regional, and even imperial—were also frequently involved in what were ostensibly internal Jewish disputes. Of course conflicts were not necessarily confined to a specific Jewish community. Stefan Rohrbacher argues that Swabian Jewry came to be defined during the course of the late sixteenth and seventeenth centuries not only by a physical territory but by an organizational structure with particular customs, autonomy, and self-identity. The importance of territorialization of internal Jewish governmental structures, as in the establishment of central courts, as well as the external political ramifications of growing territorial state authority have already been considered. Indeed, the nature of legal expertise and the dependence of small Jewish communities on larger halakhic centers were frequently discussed. Recourse to territorial authority could resolve as well as fan tensions.19 What is more, the conflicts within a particular region could 14 Friedrichs, “German Social Structure, 1300–1600,” passim. 15 See Rolf Kiessling and Sabine Ullmann, “Christlich-jüdische ‘Doppelgemeinden’ in den Dörfern der Markgrafschaft Burgau während des 17./18. Jahrhunderts,” in Cluse, Haverkamp, and Yuval (eds), Jüdische Gemeinden und ihr christlicher Kontext, pp. 513–34. 16 See the argument of Elhanan Reiner, as summarized by Joseph Davis in Yom-Tov Lipman Heller: Portrait of a Seventeenth-Century Rabbi, p. 8. 17 See Christopher Friedrichs, “Jews in the Imperial Cities: A Political Perspective,” in Hsia and Lehmann (eds), In and Out of the Ghetto, pp. 275–88, here at p. 283. 18 Ibid., p. 284. 19 See Zimmer, Fiery Embers.
70
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
develop into much larger confrontations between rabbis across and beyond the borders of Germany. At times, community factions and politics could lead to the intrusion of nonJewish authorities into communal governance. In some cases, as in Prague in the 1630s, this could lead to the imprisonment of lay or rabbinic leaders. Such was the case of the important rabbi Yom-Tov Lipman Heller.20 The phenomenon of the wealthy court Jews, with tremendous financial and political resources, and, as many scholars have recently asserted, important connections to various Jewish communities, also reflects well the more general changes we have seen thus far in early modern Germany. The development of the absolutist state in the early modern period and the concomitant centralization of many European economies broke the previous concentrations of power in the noble landed estates and churches and created an important need for financial development, a need filled by Jews, among others. As early as 1695 the prohibition on usury was rescinded in parts of Europe. Moneylending became a less specifically Jewish trade, as mercantilism and the accumulation of state revenues were seen as a means to strong government. State officials did not hesitate to mobilize Jews to help stimulate trade and growth in cities, much as they had done with the original charters in the eleventh century in Germany. The court Jews (Hofjuden) became something of a new phenomenon, though of course Jewish court agents had existed earlier in the Middle Ages, particularly in Spain but also in Germany, for example in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries in Saxony, to the bishops of Würzburg and for the Cologne nobility. Large banks and commercial enterprises were overturned, cities impoverished, coinage devalued, and credit systems ruined, as the Thirty Years’ War drained large sums of money for troops, equipment, and reconstruction. The need for financial services and resources naturally rose sharply, as the financial strength of territories was weakened by the great war. By the end of the seventeenth century the princely expenditures, court display and construction required serious financial resources and reorganization. Within this context, the court factor became a permanent institution in the territorial states. The Jewish factors numbered in the thousands, and served large and small rulers alike. Some court factors simultaneously served several princes. Among the most important Jewish court factors was the Frankfurt banker Moses Löb Isaac Kann (court factor in Mainz, Würzburg, Bamberg, and Vienna). Many Jewish families evolved as dynastic financial powers. Three generations of the Gomperz family, for example, served the prince-bishop of Münster; six served Prussian princes in unbroken sequence; and the Behrend family created a dynasty in Hannover, while the Lehmann family did the same in Saxony, and the Oppenheimers and Wertheimers did so in Vienna. In true dynastic fashion, many court Jews created extensive networks of family and close personal friends. Through carefully planned strategies, many also married among other important court Jew families: Samson Wertheimer, successor to Samuel Oppenheimer, for example, was the latter’s nephew and Leffmann Behrend’s mother was the aunt of the Berlin court Jew Jost 20 Davis, Yom-Tov Lipman Heller, pp. 138, 144–5.
Jewish Social Organization: The Role of Memory, Power, and Honor
71
Liebmann.21 This trend may, in part, help to explain the emphasis on marriages and honor in Glückel of Hameln’s memoirs, which we will examine below.22 Early modern German court Jews played important political and financial roles both within and beyond their communities. Court Jews were active in a variety of economic capacities: procurement, provisioning, industrial enterprises, the leasing of state monopolies, and some had manufacturing monopolies (for example, cloth, tobacco). The function of court Jews might differ by region—in the north we find more urban norms of enterprise, such as manufacturing; in the south we find a culture more akin to noble society.23 Court Jews were often granted special freedom of movement and certain exemptions. Although the position was rife with ambiguity, the court Jew could attain rank, honor, and respect; he was, however, always the servant to his sovereign. Court Jews still did not possess the rights of Christian citizens, and they were not typically viewed as socially acceptable. They were, further, often easy targets for their enemies and their broad sphere of activity and influence often fostered the hatred of an ever-impoverished population. Samuel Oppenheimer (1630–1703), the Viennese court Jew, for example, was previously the imperial army provisioner during the 1673–79 war against Louis XIV of France. He had spent his youth in Heidelberg and was the first Jew to settle in Vienna after the expulsion in 1670/71. Oppenheimer procured enormous sums that helped push back the Turks in 1682, and he played a central role in saving Vienna in 1683, Budapest in 1686, and Belgrade in 1688. Oppenheimer even paid for several of the large peace conferences afterward. Another example of a prominent court Jew was Leffmann Behrends (1634–1714), who began as a small merchant supplying luxury goods to court. He established himself as a moneylender, diplomatic mediator and minter, and further strengthened his position when he helped duke Ernest Augustus (1679–98) procure the title of elector. He was connected by marriage to the Oppenheimer and Wertheimer families in Vienna. But court Jews were not simply influential at court. Many court Jews remained extremely involved in their Jewish communities. The typical court Jew was often the benefactor and champion of his community and its interests and was usually given the title of shtadlan (intercessor) in the Jewish sources. In fact, a large number of court Jews began their careers by being appointed by their sovereign as the leader of all Jews in their particular territory. Most court Jews seem to have been successful at maintaining Jewish tradition within Baroque court lifestyle. Behrends, for example, was an ardent 21 On the court Jews generally, see the overview in Jonathan I. Israel, European Jewry in the Age of Mercantilism, 1550–1750 (3rd edn, London, 1998), pp. 101–18, from which much of this summary is drawn. 22 For a discussion of court Jews and upper Jewish classes in general in relation to Glückel of Hameln’s autobiographical writing, see Rotraud Ries, “Status und Lebensstil – Jüdische Familien der sozialen Oberschicht zur Zeit Glikls,” in Monika Richarz (ed.), Die Hamburger Kauffrau Glikl: Jüdische Existenz in der Frühen Neuzeit (Hamburg, 2001), pp. 280–306, especially pp. 287–98. 23 See Rotraud Ries, “Hofjuden—Funktionsträger des absolutistischen Territorialstaates und Teil der jüdischen Gesellschaft: Eine einführende Positionsbestimmung,” in Rotraud Ries and J. Friedrich Battenberg (eds), Hofjuden—Ökonomie und Interkulturalität: Die jüdische Wirtschaftselite im 18. Jahrhundert (Hamburg, 2002), pp. 11–39.
72
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
talmudist, he supported talmudic study, and for many years he headed the community of Hannover-Neustadt. In 1673 he acquired the right to open a cemetery. In 1687 at his request the duke agreed to permit the Jews of Hannover to appoint a Landesrabbiner. In 1700 he secured support of the elector in suppressing the anti-Jewish writings of Johann Eisenmenger. And in 1703 he built a synagogue and presented it to the community. Behrends’s sons and grandsons were also court Jews, although the family went bankrupt in 1721. Recent research has revealed that court Jews were in reality a force of continuity and tradition, as opposed to one of transformation.24 Memorialization of the Dead The social hierarchy within early modern Judaism could be constructed and navigated by narrating the past. Memorialization of the dead, for example, served to craft a communal identity that was both regional and often oligarchic. Honor, which was of increasing importance in early modern Germany, was addressed by Jews in a variety of memorials and in the burgeoning production of autobiographical writing. In the same way that it could be used to contest external marginalization and re-inscribe the Jews into world history (see chapter 5), memory of the past also allowed for the organization and disbursement of power and authority within the Jewish community itself. The boundaries between the worlds of the living and dead were very fluid in late medieval and early modern society.25 A delicate balance existed between the two worlds; the dead continued, in many important ways, to remain a part, indeed an integral component, of the living community. The relationship between the living and dead was multi-faceted: emotive and cultural, but also economic, “involving the disposition of property and the dedication of resources to the demands of intercession and commemoration.”26 Discourses about the dead, therefore—how they should be treated as well as their place in living society—tell us a great deal about the religious, social, and cultural developments and conflicts within the living communities.27 In the Middle Ages, the chief means of memorializing the dead was within a liturgical context (memoria). Such memorialization recognized the individual nature of the deceased, while allowing for the creation of communal and group cohesiveness and identity.28 Memory of the dead was perpetuated by being included in communal liturgy. The commemoration of the dead thus became a corporate obligation that extended beyond kin groups to involve the broader community, as, for example, in confraternities.29 Despite important differences in theories of salvation, death rituals, and views of the afterlife, Catholic and Protestant responses to the dead in the early
24 See Ries and Battenberg (eds), Hofjuden—Ökonomie und Interkulturalität: Die jüdische Wirtschaftselite im 18. Jahrhundert. 25 Gordon and Marshall (eds), The Place of the Dead, p. 7. 26 Ibid., p. 8. 27 Ibid., p. 3. 28 Ibid., p. 4. 29 Ibid., p. 5.
Jewish Social Organization: The Role of Memory, Power, and Honor
73
modern period could be remarkably similar.30 The extent to which we can compare the memorialization of Jewish dead during this period will be one question treated here. Memory of the dead holds a special place in Judaism.31 In fact, the memorialization of the dead is something of an institution consecrated by ceremony and controlled by the community itself, for which the memorybooks are the surviving testimonies.32 The idea of a memorybook certainly had biblical precedence, and took important shape during the Crusades.33 Lists of Jewish victims of the Crusades exist for the communities of Speyer, Cologne, Mainz, and Worms; and the chronicles of the Crusades often added details to the bare lists of those murdered.34 Similar martyr lists could also be found at times of other grave attacks on the Jews, such as the Rindfleisch pogrom of 1298,35 or the Black Death attacks of 1348, with many entries including entire families.36 The core of the memorybook of Nuremberg, also an early example listing the Jews martyred in that city in 5109 (1349), was similarly simply a list of 105 entries. The genre of the memorybook, similar in format but more broadly focused than the simple listing of martyred Jews, has typically been seen as originating at the end of the thirteenth century, with the Mainz memorybook of Isaac ben Samuel of Meiningen.37 The memorybook genre became more frequent from the middle of the seventeenth century on, however.38 Since the turn of the twentieth century around 150 Jewish memorybooks have been found in Germany. Many of these date from the early modern period, including many from the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, such as those from Binswagen, Koblenz, Cologne-Deutz, and Mainz, all written or begun in the sixteenth century; and those from Hanau, Minden, Frankfurt am Main, Pfersee, Kreuznach, Fulda, Trier, Baiersdorf, and Worms, all from the seventeenth.39 Memorybooks typically included four components: a brief descriptive statement including the name of the community utilizing it, the name of the scribe and the
30 Ibid., p. 12. 31 Schwarzfuchs, Un obituaire Israélite, p. i. 32 Ibid. 33 See Siegmund Salfeld (ed.), Das Martyrologium des Nürnberger Memorbuches: im Auftrage der Historischen Commission für Geschichte der Juden in Deutschland (Berlin, 1898). 34 Magnus Weinberg, “Das Memorbuch,” in Bernhard Purin, Buch der Erinnerung, pp. 9–26, here at p. 9; idem, Die Memorbücher; p. 1, Schwarzfuchs, Un obituaire Israélite, p. iii. 35 Weinberg, “Das Memorbuch,” p. 11. 36 See W.H. Lowe (ed.), The Memorbook of Nürnberg (London, 1881), pp. 16–17. 37 Weinberg, Die Memorbücher, p. 3; Schwarzfuchs, Un obituaire Israelite, p. ii. 38 “Das Memorbuch zu Bonn,” website (last visited July 2006) http://www.steinheiminstitut.de/projekte/memorbuch/index.xml. 39 Felicitas Heimann-Jelinek, “Memorbücher: ‘Milieux de mémoire’,” in Purin, Buch der Erinnerung, pp. 27–38, here at p. 28; and the memorybooks in Salfeld and Stern. Binswagen (sixteenth century); Koblenz (begun 1580); Cologne-Deutz (1581); Mainz (begun 1583); Hanau (1601); Minden (beginning of the seventeenth century); Frankfurt am Main (begun 1629); Pfersee (1631?); Kreuznach (1638); Ehrenbreitstein (begun 1647); Rheinbach (1650); Fulda (seventeenth century); Trier (1664); Mannheim (1673); Baiersdorf (1689); Bergheim/Erft (1677); Worms (1679); Wallerstein (1684); and Fürth (1708ff).
74
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
date of copying;40 a liturgical part, including universal (typically for those fasting on Mondays and Thursdays) and individual mi sheberah prayers;41 Psalms for individual communities, making the memorybooks simultaneously books of customs of the originating community;42 and the actual necrology that included the names of the deceased and their good deeds and accomplishments. The general part of the necrological list included famous scholars or personalities, generally individuals beyond the region. In rather formulaic ways, for example, Gershom ben Judah Me’or ha-Golah (Rabbenu Gershom, c.960–1028), Jacob ben Meir Tam (Rabbenu Tam, c.1100–71), and Meir ben Baruch of Rothenbrug (Maharam, c.1215–93) were listed.43 In a local part, individuals and their relations with roots in or connections to the community were listed, typically in roughly chronological fashion.44 All entries began with the phrase “may God remember the soul” of a particular person; different formularies were then introduced for men and women.45 In most cases, the earliest deceased listed predated the actual compilation of the book by more than a century.46 The necrology was a basic component of all of the German memorybooks, and it included pro forma prayers for individual Jews and Jewish communities in other regions.47 According to Simon Schwarzfuchs, the memorybooks offered information on three principal groups of people: those martyred, those engaged in sacred study, and those engaged in charitable deeds.48 For the memorybook of Metz in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, for example, the giving of charity, for a variety of purposes— such as for the poor of the Holy Land49 or the construction of synagogues—was a frequent appellation and could represent the donation of a large amount of money.50 Other categories included the frequent participation in synagogue prayers51 and intercessions on behalf of the community.52 Memorybooks were often ahistorical and non-chronological. Many entries of the Pfersee memorybook, for example, did not follow a strictly chronological order; or rather, some entries from the eighteenth century seem to have been inserted into the text of seventeenth century entries. Memorybooks focused on particular scholarly or wealthy families, but might offer invaluable information for the general history of the Jews in a given community and region, as well as for the history of particular families.53
40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53
Schwarzfuchs, Un obituaire Israélite, p. ii. Weinberg, Die Memorbücher, p. 7. Ibid., p. 8. Ibid., pp. 8–9. Ibid., p. 9. Ibid., p. 10. Ibid. Ibid., pp. 11–12. Schwarzfuchs, Un obituaire Israélite, pp. ix–x, 14. Ibid., p. 4 (no. 67), p. 12 (no. 168). Ibid., p. 1 (no. 4), for example. Ibid., p. 2 (no. 33), p. 3 (no. 57). Ibid., p. 2 (no. 31), p. 5 (no. 80). Ibid., p. 17.
Jewish Social Organization: The Role of Memory, Power, and Honor
75
In addition to lists of names and titles, the memorybooks do provide insights into historical events as well. The Baiersdorf memorybook, for example, discussed the decision by the Margrave of Bayreuth to expel the Jews in 5440 (1680), noting the salvation of the Jews by God’s hand through the sending of the angel in the person of the protector of the Jews, Samuel Oppenheim of Frankfurt.54 The eighteenth-century memorybook of Marktbreit revealed that part of the community had fled into Marktbreit after the 1671 expulsion from Fulda. The memorybook of Binswagen in the sixteenth century offered a general plea that God should “remember … the soul of all of the dead in the kehilot and yishuvim [settlements]55 … and annul the decrees and forced apostasy and annul the customs duties and remove the sifrei Torah from the hands of the nations and remove the forced apostates from the hands of the nations …”.56 Some individuals were praised for their erudition, as in Metz, where we read of “the humble, pious and knowledgeable syndic, the rabbi Solomon Israel, son of haver [a level of ordination] Gerson, ‘because of his devotion in consolidating the community of Metz. He was a faithful citizen and led the community of Metz with gentleness and integrity for more than fifty years …’ [and] for numerous interventions and numerous charities and [the fact that] he frequented the synagogue morning and night …”.57 At times, the memorybooks tell us about scholarly accomplishments and publications. In Neuburg, for example, Rabbi Meir bar Isaac of Oettingen was listed “on account of his multiplication of Torah in Israel in his novellae … and his book on the Five Books of the Torah …”.58 Many memorybooks focused on the regional associations of the Jewish communities. The Oettingen memorybook acknowledged one individual’s “exertions for the people of the medinah [region] and the faith.” The Heidingsfeld memorybook, written no earlier than 1705, included “50 rabbis within and outside our medinah.” In seventeenth-century Aub, the memorybook included a list of martyrs, kehillot, and regions.59 Often the names of people who did not die in Aub were nevertheless listed if they were otherwise connected to the region through familial ties or had served in the community for a time.60 The Offenbach memorybook was particularly interesting in this regard. The book began with a list of communities (“Remember … Speyer, Worms, Mainz, Oppenheim, Koblenz, Cologne (?)”61) and a list of famous people to remember, such as Rabbenu Gershom, Rabbi Solomon ben Isaac of Troyes (Rashi, 1040–1105), Rabbenu Tam, Maharam, and Jacob Molin (Maharil, 1365–1427).62 But many individuals listed seem only tangentially connected to Offenbach; many 54 Weinberg, “Das Memorbuch.” 55 Similar at this point to p. 32 of the Oettingen memorybook. 56 C. Duschinsky, Gedenkbücher (Memorbücher) von Offenbach a. Main u. anderen deutschen Gemeinden (Frankfurt am Main, 1924), p. 130. 57 Schwarzfuchs, Un obituaire Israélite, p. 4 (no. 59). 58 Moshe Stern, Memorybooks Written during the 16th to the 19th Century in Swabian Jewish Communities (Jerusalem, 1941) [Hebrew], p. 26, from the Neuburg memorybook of the early eighteenth century. 59 Duschinsky, Gedenkbücher, pp. 28–9. 60 Ibid., p. 31. 61 Ibid., p. 8. 62 Ibid., p. 11.
76
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
lived, died, or were buried in the nearby community of Frankfurt63 or in Speyer.64 In fact, at times, the “here” referenced in the text referred to Mainz, and at other times to Frankfurt or Offenbach.65 By combining more universal Jewish figures, such as Maimonides, Rashi, Maharam, Maharil, and Isaac ben Solomon Luria (Ari, 1534–72) (see the memorybook of Veitschheim, 1741, for example)66 with local and regional rabbis,67 memorybooks created a community that was placed in time and multi-dimensional. The connection between great sages and important local figures solidified the image of the Jewish community as both holy and established. The historical blurring of personalities allowed the community to be defined through actions and not delimited by chronological or strictly geographical boundaries; community became in this way more than local or regional. The community created through the historical reckoning and liturgical recounting of the memorybooks was universal, and connected to disparate communities and individuals scattered both geographically and chronologically, a particularly valuable attribute at a time of increasing territorial dispersion and regional identification. A few observations regarding early modern Jewry will set the appropriate context for a clearer examination of the memorybook, particularly that of the Jewish community of Pfersee, near Augsburg. An Early Modern German Jewish Context The development of rural Jewry, particularly in south and west Germany began in the later Middle Ages, but became significant first in the early modern period, particularly after the middle of the sixteenth century.68 By the nineteenth century, some small towns and rural villages boasted more Jews than Christians in their populations.69 But the rural Jewries were more than local communities; they were
63 Ibid., pp. 15, 21 (no. 118). 64 Ibid., p. 16 (no. 90). 65 Ibid., p. 19 (no. 101) died here in Offenbach; p. 20 (no. 110), “here” is equivalent to Frankfurt; p. 17 (no. 86), buried “here” 1661. 66 Ibid., p. 75. It lists Karo, Maimonides, Mordechai Jaffe, Isaac Luria, Hayyim Vital, and local rabbis; see also Duschinsky, Gedenkbücher, p. 11. 67 Ibid., p. 74. 68 Stefan Rohrbacher, “Ungleiche Partnerschaft: Simon Günzburg und die erste Ansiedlung von Juden den Toren Augsburgs in der Frühen Neuzeit,” pp. 193ff; See J. Friedrich Battenberg, “Aus der Stadt auf das Land? Zur Vertreibung und Neuansiedlung der Juden im Heiligen Römischen Reich,” in Monika Richarz and Reinhard Rürup (eds), Jüdisches Leben auf dem Lande (Tübingen, 1997), pp. 9–35. See also Wolfram Baer, “Zwischen Vertreibung und Wiederansiedlung: Die Reichstadt Augsburg und die Juden vom 15. bis zum 18. Jahrhundert (pp. 110–27, especially p. 117) and Wolfgang Wüst, “Die Judenpolitik der geistlichen Terriotorien Schwabens während der Frühen Neuzeit (pp. 128–53, especially p. 131), both in Rolf Kiessling (ed.), Judengemeinden in Schwaben im Kontext des Alten Reiches (Berlin, 1995). 69 See Rolf Kiessling and Sabine Ullmann (eds), Landjudentum im deutschen Südwesten während der Frühen Neuzeit (Berlin, 1999).
Jewish Social Organization: The Role of Memory, Power, and Honor
77
regional associations bound together for a variety of purposes, and subsumed under shifting and at times unstable regional temporal governments.70 The history of the Jews in early modern Germany fluctuated between one of security and privilege on one hand, and expulsion and restriction on the other. A variety of privileges, particularly at the individual level, combined with severe restrictions on Jewish business. In Swabia, for example, this was particularly true in the legislation of 1541, focusing on Memmingen and its surrounding villages; that of 1561 in Ulm, aimed at a variety of small and middling Jewish communities; and that of 1582 in Wettenhausen.71 For the early modern period, the legal position of the Jews was complex and often volatile. The Jews, who at times enjoyed privileges and protection granted by the emperor, were consequently subject to imperial feudal service, the imperial courts, and the whims and needs of the emperor himself. On the other hand, Jews were also caught in a dangerous triangle that put them within the reach of civic authority and the increasingly powerful grasp of regional and territorial lords.72 The bundling of protective relationships at the hands of a great territorial lord led to a certain collectivization of the Jews in a given land or region,73 that had both external as well as internal consequences. Jewish courts, for example, tended to become regional in the sixteenth century, with five central courts emerging.74 As we will see, however, despite such regional boundaries, Jews frequently traveled beyond them, and related to Jews in other regions. Despite the formal expulsion of the Jews from Augsburg in the early fifteenth century and from many cities throughout Bavaria and Swabia in the later Middle Ages, significant communities developed outside of some major cities by the middle of the sixteenth century, such as in Pfersee, Kriegshaber, and Steppach outside Augsburg and Fürth outside Nuremberg. Of the 82 Jewish lenders noted between 1596 and 1603 lending to Christians in Augsburg, for example, 45 were listed with origination names in Pfersee, 13 in Günzburg, eight in Burgau, three in Steppach, two in Kriegshaber, two in Fischach, and one in Binswagen.75 The differing policies 70 Rolf Kiessling, “Between Expulsion and Emancipation: Jewish Villages in East Swabia During the Early Modern Period,” Shofar: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Jewish Studies, pp. 71ff. 71 Ibid., p. 70. 72 J. Friedrich Battenberg, “Rechtliche Rahmenbedingungen jüdischer Existenz in der Frühneuzeit zwischen Reich und Territorium,” in Kiessling (ed.), Judengemeinden in Schwaben im Kontext des Alten Reiches, pp. 53–79, here at pp. 57, 66ff. 73 Ibid., p. 72. 74 Friedrich Battenberg, Das Europäische Zeitalter der Juden, 1: Von den Anfängen bis 1650 (2nd edn, Darmstadt, 2000), p. 238. 75 Sabine Ullmann, ‘Leihen umb fahrend Hab und Gut:’ Der christlich-jüsiche Pfandhandel in der Reichsstadt Augsburg,” in Kiessling and Ullmann (eds), Landjudentum im deutschen Südwesten während der Frühen Neuzeit, here at pp. 310–11. Among the key lenders were Isaac from Günzburg (140 fl., in late 1590s), Sesslin from Burgau (218 fl., in 1599/1600), Seligman of Burgau (248 fl., 1599/1600), Itzig of Pfersee (700 fl., 1600/01), Samuel of Günzburg (600 fl., 1601), Abraham of Günzburg (360 fl., 1601/02), and Solomon of Wassertrüdingen (195fl., 1601). See pp. 325–35.
78
Jewish Identity in Early Modern Germany
toward Jews, combined with changing demographic and social conditions, led further to the appearance of a rather large group of poor Jews, especially after the beginning of the seventeenth century.76 In Hamburg, the minutes of the Portuguese Jewish community recorded that large amounts of money were set aside for both poor local Jews and Jews dispersed throughout Europe and the Holy Land. Indeed, the Jewish communities themselves were far from homogeneous. Mordechai Breuer has posited a distinction between elite and folk religion in the early modern period. The former, according to Breuer, focused on the Talmud, philosophy, and the sciences and arts; the latter on the study of the Pentateuch, Rashi’s commentary, and the narrative-moralizing parts of the Talmud.77 Daily folk religion of Jews, particularly in the rural areas, where Jews increasingly took up residence, was centered on daily customs—particularly local or regional ones—and was largely oral.78 The memorybooks are in many ways reflections of the melding of a variety of customs and concerns, and they offer an important portal to the world of regional Jewish communities and the place of prominent Jewish families of high social and economic standing. The Jews in Pfersee and other suburban and rural areas had extensive regional connections as well as significant business contacts within the major cities. The history of the Jewish community of Pfersee just outside Augsburg in Bavarian Swabia, and the history and communal structure related in its memorybook, is complex. The Pfersee Memorybook The memorybook of the community of Pfersee began with instructions for the proper time for reading it and the injunction to remember Rabbi Gershom for his ordinances and the dissemination of knowledge among the Jews, Rabbi Solomon and his spouse for the acquisition of the cemetery in Mainz and the pains taken for the community, Rabbi Isaac and his wife in Koblenz, Rabbi Shimon bar Isaac and his companion for his efforts on behalf of the community and his poetry and panegyrics to the Omnipresent. The text proceeded to mention Rashi, Rabbenu Tam and the ba’alei Tosafot [the Tosafists], “our” rabbi Meir son of ha-Rav Maharam, and a number of other sages noted for their wisdom and perpetuation of Jewish learning. At this point the text took on a more local quality, beginning with a lengthy entry for Rabbi Shimon son of Eliezer, of blessed memory, of Ulma from Günzburg “because of his exertions for the sake of the community for more than 40 years and the stopping of the taxes, and purchasing of land for the cemetery in Burgau … and enclosing himself for the honor of God, May He be blessed, and for the honor of the deceased pious ones in his frequent intercession to remove prohibitions at the hands of the gentiles and 76 Ibid., p. 235. See also Rudolf Glanz, Geschichte des niederen jüdischen Volkes in Deutschland: eine Studie über historisches Gaunertum, Bettelwesen und Vagantentum (New York, 1968). 77 Mordechai Breuer, “Jüdische Religion und Kultur in den ländlichen Gemeinden 1600–1800,” in Richarz and Rürup (eds), Jüdisches Leben auf dem Lande, pp. 69–78, here at p. 72. 78 Ibid., p. 73.
Jewish Social Organization: The Role of Memory, Power, and Honor
79
support the poor of the provinces of Swabia many years, as if feeding small children.”79 Rabbi Shimon Günzburg was buried in Burgau, the passage concluded, on the ninth of Shevat 5345 (1585). Shimon Günzburg was from the most important family of Jewish Swabia, the Ulma-Günzburg family.80 The founding father of the family was likely Eliezer, or Lazarus, Günzburg, who belonged to the Jews expelled from Ulm, and who settled in the small but increasingly important community of Günzburg, later to be the central community of landed Swabia in the sixteenth century. Lazarus was at the imperial court in Innsbruch in 1534, and he secured in 1542 a Schutzbrief [letter of protection] from the Bavarian Duke. In many ways, Rabbi Shimon was the true progenitor of the memorybook. Many of the subsequent entries were devoted to his familial relations and those of a handful of other central personalities. To this extent, the memorybook was more a representation of a rather oligarchic regional community. The central families were from Günzburg and Ulm, with important connections in Burgau, Worms, Frankfurt, and Prague. Of the roughly 72 entries before the beginning of the eighteenth century, more than 60 per cent were obviously from the Günzburg line; the 20 references after the seventeenth century seem to have been almost exclusively from the Ulma family. In the memorybook, Rabbi Shimon’s wife (d. 1593 in Burgau) was noted for her vows for charity. Mention was also made of the majority of his eight sons and eight daughters, as well as a variety of other relatives. The dispersion of his children and the relations developed and maintained with famous Jewish families in a very diverse geographical radius tells us quite a bit about the conscious forging of elite Jewish circles—in terms of both wealth and Torah learning—and the high mobility of Jews, the wealthy in particular. Such wide-ranging dispersion is evident in what we know about some of Shimon’s sons, who included Rabbi Moses Abraham (d. 1591); Rabbi Abraham, noted for both his community service and his redeeming of captives and maintenance of the poor; Rabbi Asher Aron who served as Landesrabbiner of Swabia around 1600; Rabbi Isaac, who traveled in his old age to Jerusalem where he was buried; Rabbi Samuel Zanvil, who died in Worms (1630); Rabbi Jacob, noted for his charity in Burgau; Rabbi Solomon, who died and was buried in Neuburg; and Rabbi Eliezer who was matched with the daughter of Moses Isserles, and who died and was buried in Safed.81 Among Rabbi Shimon’s daughters, we find Elah (d. 1594), who was married to the renowned Gaon Rabbi Akiva Frankfurter;82 Hanah (d. 1598/99 in Rankburg); Saralah (d. 1604 in Frankfurt); Brunlin (d. 1617 in Worms); Biglin (d. in Frankfurt); Frumet (d. in Worms); Adel (d. in Worms), who was the wife of the head of the Worms
79 p. 6 of the Pfersee memory book—see J. Perles, “Das Memorbuch der Gemeinde Pfersee,” Monatsschrift für Geschichte und Wissenschaft des Judentums 22 (1873):