Issues in African Education
This page intentionally left blank
Issues in African Education S OCIOLOGICAL P ERSPECTI...
46 downloads
2907 Views
896KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Issues in African Education
This page intentionally left blank
Issues in African Education S OCIOLOGICAL P ERSPECTIVES
Edited by
Ali A. Abdi and Ailie Cleghorn
ISSUES IN AFRICAN EDUCATION
© Ali A. Abdi and Ailie Cleghorn, 2005. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles or reviews. First published in 2005 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN™ 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010 and Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire, England RG21 6XS Companies and representatives throughout the world. PALGRAVE MACMILLAN is the global academic imprint of the Palgrave Macmillan division of St. Martin’s Press, LLC and of Palgrave Macmillan Ltd. Macmillan® is a registered trademark in the United States, United Kingdom and other countries. Palgrave is a registered trademark in the European Union and other countries. ISBN 1–4039–7069–6 A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Issues in African education : sociological perspectives / edited by Ali A. Abdi, Ailie Cleghorn. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 1–4039–7069–6 1. Education—Social aspects—Africa. I. Abdi, Ali A., 1955– II. Cleghorn, Ailie, 1940– LC191.8.A4I77 2005 306.43⬘096—dc22 Design by Newgen Imaging Systems (P) Ltd., Chennai, India. First edition: November 2005 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Printed in the United States of America.
2005046428
Contents
List of Tables and Figures
vii
List of Contributors
ix
Preface
xiii
Acknowledgments
xv Part I
Theoretical Foundations
1. Sociology of Education: Theoretical and Conceptual Perspectives Ali A. Abdi and Ailie Cleghorn 2. African Philosophies of Education: Counter-Colonial Criticisms Ali A. Abdi 3. National “Development” and African Universities: A Theoretical and Sociopolitical Analysis Korbla P. Puplampu Part II
3
25
43
Culture, Language, and the Curriculum
4. Reclaiming Our Memories: The Education Dilemma in Postcolonial African School Curricula Edward Shizha 5. Surveying Indigenous Knowledge, the Curriculum, and Development in Africa: A Critical African Viewpoint Nkosinathi Mkosi 6. Language Issues in African School Settings: Problems and Prospects in Attaining Education For All Ailie Cleghorn 7. Cultural Perspectives on Science and Technology Education Meshach B.Ogunniyi
65
85
101 123
C ontents
vi
Part III
Gender and Equity Issues in Education
8. Women’s Education and Social Development in Africa Benedicta Egbo 9. Achieving Gender Equity in Africa’s Institutions of Tertiary Education: Beyond Access and Representation Philomina Okeke-Ihejirika 10. Gender and Education in Sub-Saharan Africa: The Women in Development (WID) Approach and its Alternatives Codou Diaw 11. Quandaries, Prospects, and Challenges of Nomadic Educational Policy for Girls in Sub-Saharan–Africa Lantana Usman 12. Narratives from Ghana: Exploring Issues of Difference and Diversity in Education George J. Sefa Dei and Alireza Asgharzadeh Part IV
159
175
193
219
Education and Change
13. Democratizing Education in Zambia: Sociohistorical Analyses Edward Shizha and Ali A. Abdi 14. At the Mercy of Informal Learning: Education and Development in Stateless Somalia Ali A. Abdi 15. Social Organization of Teacher Education in Africa: A Kenyan Case Study Njoki Wane 16. The Role of the School in Africa in the Twenty-First Century: Coping with Forces of Change Okwach Abagi Index
141
241
259
275
297
317
List of Tables and Figures Tables 8.1 Gross enrollment ratio (%) at the primary, secondary, and tertiary levels of education in selected countries in Africa 9.1 Tertiary gross enrollment ratios (%) in selected African countries, 1998–2001 9.2 Female academic staff in Africa’s tertiary institutions, 2000–2002 11.1 Nomadic Fulani girls’ economic mainstay 11.2 Enrollment of nomadic primary school students by gender, 1990–1999 11.3 Existing types of nomadic classroom structures 11.4 Effect of herding on children’s schooling 11.5 Time children attend school 13.1 Admission to grade 1, 1990–1996 15.1 Number of primary teachers by qualification and sex for the selected years, 1997–1999 16.1 HIV/AIDS statistics and features by region, December 1999
142 165 167 195 200 201 201 202 249 284 302
Figures 6.1 9.1
“Whose culture, whose literacy?” Rates of female enrollment in tertiary education, 1980–1996
116 164
This page intentionally left blank
List of Contributors
Okwach Abagi obtained his PhD from McGill University, his B.Ed. and M.A. from the University of Nairobi. He is the Director of OWN and Associates Center for Research and Development in Nairobi which has offered technical assistance in Eastern and Southern African regions for various organizations including UNIFEM, UNESCO, UNICEF, UNDP, CARE—Kenya, Action AID, CARE—Sudan/Somalia, InterUniversity Council of East Africa (IUCEA) and the Commonwealth Secretariat. Ali A. Abdi is Associate Professor in the Department of Educational Policy Studies at the University of Alberta, Canada. He received his PhD from McGill University. His teaching areas include comparative and international education, sociology of education, and cultural studies in education. He is currently conducting a major research project on citizenship education and social development in sub-Saharan Africa with a focus on Zambia. His articles have appeared in such journals as Comparative Education, Journal of Postcolonial Education, International Education Journal, Horn of Africa Journal, and Western Journal of Black Studies. He is also the author of Culture, Education and Development in South Africa, and coauthor (with Ratna Ghosh) of Education and the Politics of Difference. Alireza Asgharzadeh is a PhD candidate in the Department of Sociology and Equity Studies, Ontario Institute for Studies in Education of the University of Toronto. His areas of concentration and research include: sociolinguistics, social inequality, and sociology of education. Ailie Cleghorn is Associate Professor in the Department of Education at Concordia University in Montreal. Her PhD from McGill University is in the Comparative Sociology of Education. Her qualitative studies in East and southern African primary schools have focused on language issues in the teaching of science and mathematics. Lately her research has included teachers’ conceptions of early childhood in societies undergoing social change. Her articles appear in such journals as the
x
L ist of Contributors
International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, the Comparative Education Review and Early Childhood Research. Previous books include Sociology of Education: An Introductory View from Canada (with Joyce Barakett) and Missing the Meaning (with Alan Peacock). George J. Sefa Dei is Professor and Chair of the Department of Sociology and Equity Studies at the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education of the University of Toronto. His work and teaching areas are in: anticolonial thought, antiracism and minority schooling issues, international development, and indigenous knowledges. His books include Anti-Racism Education: Theory and Practice, and Indigenous Knowledges in Global Contexts: Multiple Readings of Our World. Codou Diaw holds a PhD from the interdisciplinary program in Language, Literacy, and Culture at the University of Maryland. She is a consultant in international educational development. Her current research interests are in gender theory and education policy, especially girls’ education and women’s literacy. She also explores issues of political economy of education, cultural considerations in education program design, language policy and teaching in sub-Saharan Africa. Benedicta Egbo is an Associate Professor of Education at the University of Windsor, Windsor, Canada. Her research interests and publications are in the areas of literacy, gender and development, gender and education, comparative education, educational policy, and social justice. She is the author of Gender, Literacy and Life Chances in Sub-Saharan Africa (Multilingual Matters, 2000), which explores the links between African women’s access to literacy, and their sociopsychological and economic well-being in their respective societies. Nkosinathi Mkosi lectures at the University of Fort Hare, South Africa in history of education and language teaching methods. He is also an associate researcher attached to the university’s Education Policy Unit. He obtained his professional qualifications at the University of Fort Hare and the University of Alberta. His research interests include education and development, and the impact of South Africa’s educational policies on school governance, administration, and leadership. Meshach Ogunniyi is a graduate of the University of Wisconsin and is currently a Senior Professor of Science Education, University of the Western Cape. His research has focused on science and technology education from a sociocultural perspective. He has founded two journals and published over 100 articles in refereed journals and books.
L ist of C ontributors
xi
Philomina Okeke-Ihejirika is Associate Professor in the Women’s Studies Program at the University of Alberta. Her research and teaching focus on gender and development in Africa (including women in politics and public decision-making), the social dynamics of race, class, and gender in North American communities, and gender issues in the globalization process. Her publications include Negotiating Power and Privilege: Igbo Career Women in South-eastern Nigeria. Korbla P. Puplampu is with the Department of Social Sciences, Grant MacEwan College, Edmonton, Canada. His research interests include the politics of knowledge production, and the role of the state in social change. His articles appear in journals such as, Teaching in Higher Education, African Studies Review, the Review of African Political Economy, and the Canadian Journal of Development Studies. He is coeditor of Critical Perspectives on Politics and Socio-Economic Development in Ghana (with W.J. Tettey and B.J. Berman). Edward Shizha, a lecturer at the University of Zimbabwe; recently completed his PhD at the University of Alberta in the Department of Educational Policy Studies. His dissertation was on indigenous knowledge and languages in the teaching and learning of primary science in rural Zimbabwe. His research interests also include postcolonial theory and education, globalization and education, sociology of knowledge, gender studies, and citizenship and human rights education. Lantana Usman is currently Assistant Professor at the University of Northern British Columbia, Prince George, Canada. She obtained her PhD from University of Alberta. She has been a sessional professor and university facilitator for students’ field experience. She was a lecturer and researcher for over ten years with the Ahmadu Bello University, Zaria, Nigeria. Njoki Wane is Associate Professor in the Department of Sociology and Equity Studies, at the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education at the University of Toronto. She teaches in both the graduate school and the pre-service areas. Her research includes teacher education, cultural knowledges, Black Canadian feminist theorizing, and African spirituality. Her publications include: Equity in School and Society (coeditor), Back to the Drawing Board: African Canadian Feminisms (coauthor).
This page intentionally left blank
Preface
T
his book is intended as a comprehensive introduction to major sociological issues in African education. It presents a thoroughly African worldview within a sociology of education framework. While most of the current theory in sociology of education was generated in the West, this book will allow the reader to see where that theory is relevant to the African context and where it is not. We hope that this will lead to more efforts to build on that theory so that it becomes much more international in its scope and application. The sixteen chapters are written primarily for those who work in the field of education, as professors, teacher educators, researchers, teachers, consultants, policy makers, and others. The book aims to provide a sociological understanding of the educational issues, debates, processes, and practices as these take place in a non-Western social context. This being said, the book will also be of interest internationally, to those who are studying or teaching in comparative and international education, and development studies, as well as to those who are working in nongovernmental and government projects in various parts of the world. We believe that the time is right for a text that speaks with an African voice, one that brings the viewpoints of several African scholars together in a collection that would be relevant to the lives of college and university students in African countries as well as others in both the minority and majority worlds. The aim is to disseminate knowledge that will contribute (1) to the development of a critical perspective on the issues that the book presents, and (2) to efforts to indigenize curricula while also keeping an eye on global trends in education. It is important that educators develop the critical skills that are needed in order to respond with good judgment to the constant pressures from within and from abroad to introduce change into their education systems. The reader will find in these pages information about a broad range of issues relating, for example, to the ways in which the formal and informal aspects of the educational system are connected to the political, economic, legal, religious, and other sectors of society. We
xiv
P reface
hope that the book will act as a bridge to understanding local education and society issues in the larger global context. The chapters that have been written mostly by African scholars, do not however, pretend to represent all of Africa, but draw examples mainly from sub-Saharan African settings, both rural and urban. As the title suggests, an African perspective is presented in each of the contributors’ chapters. This is important for several reasons. First, it is important to realize that every society is diverse, linguistically, culturally, and in many other ways, either from long ago or from the recent migration of refugees and immigrants from one region to another. Secondly, it is important for educators to think through their taken-for-granted understandings of how the education system ought to be organized, since the reality may increasingly fall short of this; there may be very local ways of looking upon ethnic, linguistic, racial, and other differences, ways that may no longer work well in the face of the actual diversity just mentioned. These attitudes then, may influence the way we think about the teaching of other languages, for example, or about the need to know a metropolitan language, or about what constitutes an appropriate curriculum in today’s world. Such attitudes may also influence the negotiation of understanding across the social boundaries that define difference. Since people tend to take for granted the way in which they were taught in primary and secondary school, it is sometimes difficult to see the elements of their own education practices clearly; many of the particulars have been internalized through years spent in schools and classrooms since the age of five or six. Another of the aims of this book then, is to assist the reader to stand outside their own experience, to take an objective stance, and to sense that this book is about and for them. There is no current text that we know of which attempts to present a sociological analysis of the controversial issues that affect education in African countries, in the context of a rapidly changing world. It is now essential to be able to attend simultaneously to local and global trends in order to adapt to and teach in situations where the school structures, rules, and expectations and student populations may be very unfamiliar. Thus we hope that this book reflects the theoretical perspectives which illuminate not only the range of ideologies that affect education in Africa but ways in which educators can prepare for future educational, social, and technological change.
Acknowledgments
A
book like this does not come into being without a lot of collaboration and cooperation from many people. We began to think about this book several years ago after Ali finished his doctorate at McGill University and was teaching for a year in Concordia University’s Department of Education. E-mail communications helped to continue the discussion when Ali joined the faculty in the Department of Educational Policy Studies at the University of Alberta. Somehow the plan became a reality and we contacted our chapter authors, to whom we owe the greatest debt. The publisher’s interest in the book soon followed and we have been working closely since then with Gabriella Pearce at Palgrave MacMillan in New York. We thank Gabriella for her diligence and professionalism. Busy academics do not only write or edit books. They teach undergraduate and graduate courses, they supervise graduate student theses, they direct research projects, they are involved in student exchange programs, they sit on various department and university committees, they write articles for publication, and they present papers at conferences. In all of this, their daily lives are a buzz of interaction especially with their graduate students who not only offer technical help, but also stimulate us with new ways of thinking and looking at “old” ideas. It is in this vein that Ali would like to thank Edward Shizha, his former doctoral student and now a colleague, for his editing of a number of the chapters as well as for his chapter contributions to the book. Ali is also thankful for the continuing support of his family, and would like to reminisce, via the “Africanity” of this work, of the exemplary lives of his parents, Ahmed A. Ibrahim and Johorad Warsame, in Somalia. In Ailie’s case, she is grateful to Reem Ben Giaber, a Master’s student in Educational Studies at Concordia, who cross-checked hundreds of items, located missing references, read many of the chapters, put commas back where they belonged, and generally helped to keep the chapters organized. While all this was going on, Caroline Chwojka provided Ailie with some time to work on the book by taking on the job of
xvi
A cknowledgments
teaching assistant for the undergraduate Comparative Education course. It was Caroline who gave extra time to students who were having difficulty and the grading of student papers would never have been finished without her. Finally and again, we extend a special gratitude to our colleagues, the contributors, who have graciously accepted our invitation, and who have produced a book that we hope will reignite discussions and debates about the critical global and local intersections of society and education in the still promising sub-Saharan African context.
P art 1
Theoretical Foundations
This page intentionally left blank
1
Sociology o f E ducation: T heoretical and C onceptual Perspectives Ali A. Abdi and Ailie Cleghorn
T
he objective of this first chapter is to provide an understanding of the ways in which educational systems, structures, and processes connect with various aspects of society, including dominant values, political goals, and ideologies. Key terms, major concepts, and theories in sociology of education will be introduced so that the reader is equipped to reflect on, contextualize, and understand the content of the subsequent chapters from both an insider’s (emic) as well as outsider’s (etic) perspective. In the first section of this chapter we give a definition of sociology; many of the terms and concepts in sociology of education come directly from sociology. The main part of the chapter then provides a general outline of the functions of schooling, several of which lie outside our taken-for-granted assumptions about the purposes of education. Next comes a discussion of the ways in which education systems vary worldwide. Finally, the reader will find a thumbnail sketch of the dominant theories in sociology of education.1 The chapter presents a standard version of educational sociology as that field has developed in Europe and North America. It does not attempt to interpret the terms, concepts or theories for the African context. It is intented that the reader will use this chapter to reflect on the content of the subsequent chapters, coming in due course to an understanding of the strengths and shortcomings of the ideas contained herein with regard to educational issues in Africa. To further this understanding the reader is referred to the African educational, social, and political writings of Julius Nyerere, Frantz Fanon, Walter Rodney, Ali
4
A li A . A bdi and A ilie Cleghorn
Mazrui and Claude Ake as well as novels by Chinua Achebe, Ngugi wa Thiong’o, Wole Soyinka and others. As Achebe (2000) would say, these are exemplary efforts to rewrite the narratives of the social and educational sciences so as to recast the world of Africa that has been, willy nilly, distorted by the harsh realities of colonial writing.
Sociology Sociology is a social science discipline that developed first in nineteenthcentury Europe from the social-philosophical writings of Karl Marx, Max Weber, Emile Durkheim, and others. Sociology explores and offers explanations for the organization and functioning of society. It is a field of study that looks at the social groups (social classes, ethnic, linguistic, and racial groups) and institutions which make up a particular society. The term institution is an abstraction to refer to the family, the economy, the legal, the religious, and the political systems that make up every society, although with huge variation from one place to another. Sociology is also concerned with the relations between the groups as well as the position or status of the individual within the group, groups or institutions that he or she belongs to. The field of sociology concerns itself with the ideologies that underlie the functioning of society’s institutions—the values, norms, and beliefs associated with a society’s dominant group. A society’s relations with the rest of the world are also of interest because every society exists within a larger global context. Matters relating to the economics and power relations between the minority and majority worlds2 are a critical part of understanding the functioning of an institution such as education.
Sociology of Education Sociology of education focuses on the relationship of schooling processes, practices, and outcomes to the organization of society as a whole. At the level of the school system and within the school itself, it focuses on the social groups and the relations between them. These groups include the teachers, students, parents, school administrators, officers of the ministry of education, school inspectors, community representatives, and others. Sociology of education is also concerned with the academic as well as social results of in-school processes. These include the manner in which students come to abide by the norms and values of society at large, and the role that the educational process plays in recreating or changing the social structure as this relates in particular to a society’s system of social stratification and hierarchy of power.
S ociology of E ducation
5
Three kinds of education can be identified. Informal education normally takes place within the family, starting at birth, and is to be distinguished from formal education. Children learn many things from parents, siblings, and community members—for example, the home language and behavioral norms. Formal education refers to the set of organized activities that take place in schools that are intended to transmit skills, knowledge, and values. Non-formal education refers to organized instruction that takes place outside of school settings (e.g., girl guides, boy scouts, and sports groups). Education is sociological because it is part of a network of interrelated societal institutions, because it is a social process and because of its functions, both intended and unintended. That is, education takes place within an established institutional structure (a school system) which is connected to other systems—the economy, the political system, the legal system, the family, as well as the belief or religious system. The dominant norms and values of the society are reflected in all these institutions. Education is also a sociological process at another level: it involves human beings and requires them to interact in order for the intended knowledge, skills, and values to be transmitted. The main participants in this process—the teachers and the students—bring to the teaching–learning situation their prior life experiences, their language background, their racial origins, their beliefs about education, their understanding of how to interact with elders (e.g., teachers), and the like. What goes on in classrooms is greatly influenced by these factors or variables, or, more accurately, by the social meaning which people attach to such matters as language, ethnicity, race, and gender. Many education settings are now diversely populated due to large numbers of immigrants and refugees moving from one place to another. This diversity means that teachers need to be prepared for mixed student groups with a range of prior experiences stemming from varied social class, language, and cultural backgrounds. By culture, we are referring to the ways of seeing, thinking, speaking, believing, and behaving that characterize the members of a social or ethnic group (Geertz, 1973). Culture can affect students’ preferred ways of learning, thus it is not only the social context of teaching and learning that is important but the context as represented by the experience that the learner brings to the setting. To contextualize instruction is to attend to both of these aspects of the culture of schooling. In diverse education settings, the culture that is transmitted in school reflects the values and attitudes of the so-called dominant members of the society; this includes those who make educational policy decisions. Sometimes the dominant group’s culture differs from the
6
A li A . A bdi and A ilie Cleghorn
home culture of students. Thus schools not only play a socialization role from one generation to the next but also a role in the acculturation of the children of newcomers (immigrants) or those who are members of minority groups to the norms and values of the dominant society. Acculturation refers to the changes that occur within a group through culture contact and through the process of adapting to and taking on the values, attitudes, and ways of behaving of the dominant (majority) group. Integration refers to the extent that interaction occurs between members of different groups within a society’s institutions including education.
The Functions of Formal Schooling Intended Functions The functions of schooling can be looked upon as intended or manifest and unintended or latent, though there is considerable overlap between the two (Thomas, 1990). The intended functions refer to those aspects of education that come immediately to mind when we ask ourselves what it is that schools do. Through the formal or official curriculum, schools transmit both generalised as well as specialized knowledge. They transmit skills and values and they develop mental abilities. Schools also transmit the existing culture to the next generation and to new members of the society as well as new knowledge that is produced in universities and in industry; cultural transmission also involves cultural diffusion. For example, Western culture, values, and schooling practices, including curricula, have been spread or diffused to the indigenous communities living in many parts of the majority world through colonization and its aftermath. Cultural diffusion may be increasing globally through the textbook industry that tends to be controlled by Western capitalist interests (Apple and Christian-Smith, 1991; McEneaney, 2003). Cultural production refers to the role that higher education institutions play in producing new knowledge in technology, science, the social sciences, the humanities, business, art, and other areas. In fact, one of the functions of higher education is to research the social and technological changes that are taking place in the world and to consider how these changes affect the educational process at all levels. Through a complex decision-making and implementation process, new knowledge is incorporated into school curricula. In due course it is passed on to the next generation and to new members of the society (Ghosh and Ray, 1987). The formal (official) curriculum refers to the planned learning activities as contained in textbooks and other learning materials as well
S ociology of E ducation
7
as the learning objectives as represented by what is required to be known for important national and local examinations. While the curriculum first may seem like a straightforward matter, we see that it too is complex when we ask whose knowledge is taught in school, who decided what is to be taught at what level, to whom? This is a topic that will arise in one way or another in several chapters in this book. Schools teach children to read, write, and to calculate, that is, to be functionally literate, providing them with the general knowledge they will need to take part in society, to work, and to learn other things. They are also taught facts in subjects such as history, geography, and literature as well as procedures in subjects like science and mathematics. Some are taught computer and other skills that will be useful in specific jobs. Although official statements about educational purposes may refer to the teaching of critical thinking skills, this may be a myth; critical thinking rarely occurs before university (Freire, 1968, 1985; Norris and Phillips, 1990). It is thus important for educators to think about why it is that critical thinking is so rarely encouraged during the earlier stages of schooling. The custodial function refers to the fact that schools are places for children to be looked after, with the school having a legal responsibility to act as substitute parents (in loco parentis) at least for the duration of the school day. While schools may be held responsible for the safety of children, it is of note that they are not held responsible for academic failure; failure is located with the learner and/or his or her parents. In contrast to primary schools, the custodial function of secondary schools is not so clear; in fact secondary schools can be dangerous places due to the presence of drugs, violence, and truancy as well as unscrupulous male teachers who sometimes take advantage of female students. Unintended Functions The unintended functions are sometimes referred to as the hidden curriculum, a term coined by Jackson (1968). The hidden curriculum refers to the implicit messages students receive about such matters as punctuality, neatness, achievement, deference toward teachers (authority relations), and the like. It also includes the subtle ways in which schooling inculcates in students the values of the society’s dominant group. The term dominant group refers to the group that holds the important and powerful positions in the society’s institutions (including the school system). Often this is the group that has lived in the society the longest, or is the largest group. The culture of the dominant group is usually that which is transmitted through the schools. Schools thus play
8
A li A . A bdi and A ilie Cleghorn
an important role in establishing loyalty and consensus over what the society most values (i.e., a sense of national identity or citizenship) since they bring together young people from varied backgrounds in their formative years. However, this does not mean that access to dominant group membership is easily attained. In fact, the hidden curriculum is largely responsible for controlling social mobility. Social mobility refers to the upward (or downward) movement of individuals or groups within the established social structure (the way in which a society’s institutions and groups are organized in patterns or networks that are more or less stable over time). Societies differ greatly in the extent to which social mobility is possible and especially the extent to which acquiring an education permits an individual to move up the social ladder. People everywhere tend to believe that an education will bring upward social mobility. From a functional theoretical (consensus) perspective, society may be compared to a living organism; temporary stresses may move the parts of the social structure away from equilibrium but this tends to be short term, with stability being returned to quite “naturally.” According to this view, inequality between individuals and between different groups (such as between men and women) is considered inevitable if not “natural” and thus “functional” overall for the society as a whole. In contrast, a conflict theoretical perspective focuses on the evident disequilibrium between the parts of the social structure and on inequality between individuals and groups. Inequalities are then considered dysfunctional for the society as a whole, as something imposed by those in positions of power through institutional processes that may well be considered the way things are. Social stratification is an important concept. Every society, including the smallest and most simply organized is stratified or has a system of social stratification—an organized hierarchy of strata based on the value that a society attaches to particular ascribed (inborn) or achieved (acquired) attributes (e.g., ethnic group membership, race, religion, years of schooling, profession). When a person possesses or achieves whatever a society values most highly, that person is likely to be accorded high social status and may also have access to a position of power. A system of stratification is considered to be open when movement up through the strata from the lowest to the highest on the basis of achievement is theoretically possible. However, the extent to which such social mobility is actually possible is still limited by ascription (characteristics obtained at birth—e.g., gender, religion, race). A system of stratification is said to be closed when mobility is virtually impossible. This was the case in India when the caste system was still fully in place.
S ociology of E ducation
9
Thus there are limits on the extent to which achievement in education can compensate for ascribed characteristics on a group basis. A society’s system of stratification is related to its division of labor, the differential distribution of jobs to be done in order for the society to maintain itself economically. Every society has unwritten rules as well as formal criteria (credentials) that determine who performs which tasks. The unwritten rules are generally based on such matters as gender, age, ethnicity, family background, and the like. And every society has some tasks that are considered more desirable than others and pay accordingly. Since the number of qualified people is usually much greater than the number of desirable positions, a selection process exists that tends to result in academic achievement being distributed unevenly (patterned). There also has to be a way for people to accept their lot, otherwise the unattractive jobs would never get done. How is it that people “accept their place” and agree to perform even the most menial of tasks? How is the system of social stratification perpetuated? In the Western world there is a belief in the equality of educational opportunity (equal access to schooling, equal treatment within schools, and the potential of equal results). This is more of a myth than a reality. If educational opportunity were truly equal for all, academic achievement would be distributed evenly from one social class to another, from one racial and ethnic group to another, and between the sexes. While not all individuals are equally able to achieve well in school, there is no biological or genetic reason to explain why one group (race, sex, ethnicity) or another should be over-represented among those who succeed or among those who fail (Ogbu, 1991; Slavin, 1991). In the majority world there is an equivalent belief—that there will be equality of educational opportunity when a country’s economy develops, or if the industrialized countries would share their wealth more generously. Another belief or myth is that education for all will bring about economic development, however, there is more evidence to suggest that it is economic development which brings more education for more people (Arnove and Torres, 1999). Another set of myths states that those who achieve well in school have done so through hard work and by being evaluated according to objective and “fair” examination procedures. The system is therefore believed to be meritocratic, that is, individual effort and ability lead to higher achievement in school and therefore to higher social status. However, there are now many school and classroom-based studies that show how individuals who are members of the lower classes or disparaged minorities may encounter discrimination by teachers and peers at school, with the result that they are excluded from learning in subtle
10
A li A . A bdi and A ilie Cleghorn
ways (Aronowitz and Giroux, 1993; Gibson and Ogbu, 1991). The same set of myths also “explain” why some students fail in school, take up menial jobs, and do not move up the social ladder. If girls, for example, fall behind boys in mathematics, there must be a “good” reason for it. These kinds of commonsense understandings or beliefs justify or legitimize the way things are, and thereby support the status quo. The process of selecting some individuals to perform desirable jobs and of persuading others to perform low status jobs is part of the selection and allocation function of schooling. Although manifest and intended at one level, the selection-allocation function of schooling is difficult for many to see since we have all been socialized to believe that the system is fair and just. It is for this very reason, however, that it is extremely important for teachers and other educators to know about this function of schooling. It is one of the main concerns of the field of sociology of education. Young people learn about the occupational structure of society through the process of schooling. They are introduced, both directly and indirectly, to many occupations as well as to the types of positions and roles within them. They learn early about the hierarchy of power when serious infractions (both behavioral and academic) get referred by the teacher to the head teacher or principal. Similarly, children learn that there are complex rules associated with competition, cooperation and achievement; sometimes chatting in groups in the classroom is cooperative learning, other times chatting in class is considered disruptive behavior. In such ways children slowly come to be very familiar with the norms or “rules” for getting ahead, with what constitutes fair competition, with what “counts” toward academic achievement and what does not. It is through such mechanisms that children also come to accept the results of examinations that are said to be objective, and therefore fair. The belief that testing procedures are unbiased and fair is an important precursor to later acceptance of the fact that the rewards of society are distributed unevenly—some people get ahead and “deserve” to get rewarded while those who do not can only blame themselves. This is known as the ideology of legitimation (Bourdieu and Passeron, 1977). Social control is another unintended function of schooling. Social control is about the definition and imposition of what the expected behaviors are of boys, girls, and members of different racial, ethnic, and linguistic groups, depending on the particular society and setting. Social control refers to the unwritten rules that define who is expected to get ahead and who is not. These are the “rules” that lead some girls to lose interest in science or mathematics around the time of puberty,
S ociology of E ducation
11
and other students to rebel against the system in ways that conform to popular racial or ethnic stereotypes (Dei, 1996; Ogbu, 1991).
How do Education Systems Differ from One Country to Another? Educational systems vary worldwide in many ways. Some of the more obvious ones relate to structure, governance, goals, and historical influences. The reader is referred to a number of comparative education texts for a more complete treatment of this topic than space permits here, including Kubow and Fossum (2003) and Thomas (1990). Structure refers to the formal organization of schooling: the number of years allocated for primary education as well as the number of years for secondary education. For example, Kenya’s 8–4–4 system refers to 8 years of primary schooling, 4 years at the secondary level, and 4 years of university. Japan’s 6–3–3 system is made up of 6 years of primary, 3 years of middle school, and 3 years of secondary school. In addition, most school systems in the West include a voluntary or mandatory preschool year of kindergarten, housed in regular schools. In the developing countries, preschools are proliferating but are usually not incorporated into the formal system. Governance refers to the way an education system is operated. Education systems vary in the degree to which control of such matters as curriculum and teacher education is centralized (in the nation’s capital, for example) or decentralized (in states or local communities, for example). The degree of centralization of control sometimes corresponds to the promotion of nationalism in the schools through “civics” education, China being one example. The centralized–decentralized dimension is subject to change with political circumstances. South Africa, for example, has moved in the last few years from a relatively centralized system that determined who could go to what kind of school and where, to one that has nine administrative units that respond to and correspond to regional requirements. Most countries today are moving toward mandatory school attendance to about the age of 16. However, the reality is that in the majority world many young people must drop out because they are needed to contribute to their family’s livelihood. Access to schooling may also be affected by lack of roads, distance to be traveled, insufficient number of trained teachers, inappropriate and irrelevant curricula (left over from colonial days), teacher absenteeism due to such matters as family health problems (such as AIDS), and so on. Nevertheless, there is no lack of demand for formal schooling throughout the world. Parents
12
A li A . A bdi and A ilie Cleghorn
everywhere want their children educated; however, when faced with economic constraints parents tend to educate their sons far longer than their daughters (Gordon, 1997; Lindsay, 1990; UNICEF, 1994). Gender in education is an important issue that is raised in several of the following chapters. Length of the school year varies greatly. In China it is reported to be 251 days while in Portugal it is 172. Cross-national studies of educational achievement suggest that the number of days in the school year is less important than how things are done in classrooms (Orpwood and Garden, 1998; Stigler and Stevenson, 1998/99). Factors affecting achievement thus constitute a complex issue, one that many education researchers are exploring. Societies do not vary greatly in terms of their stated general education goals but they do vary with regard to specific desired educational outcomes. General educational goals often refer to such matters as producing good people who are faithful citizens with the ability to contribute to the nation’s development. Specific goals are most often tied to the society’s economic conditions and needs. Educational goals are also influenced by historical events such as wars and by the sequel to natural events, such as the discovery of oil in the Middle East, or drought and famine that have occurred in parts of Africa. Educational goals also vary depending on which institutions in the society are responsible for defining the goals (e.g., the state, a religious body or the community). They sometimes shift with regard to which learners may pursue which goals. For example, before the system of apartheid was dismantled in South Africa in 1995, Black students were not permitted access to certain schools and universities. What was offered in the schools designated for Blacks virtually excluded them from a quality education, from certain occupations, and from participation in the society as a whole. Specific educational goals may reflect different views of the learner. In most of the West, the stated goals tend to emphasize teaching children how to learn and how to think. Elsewhere, the emphasis is on the memorization of large amounts of factual material due to the importance of national examinations. National examinations at the end of the primary cycle may literally determine an individual’s chance for further education. When there is a shortage of space at the next level of schooling, a national examination system allows the system to select the number of students for whom there are spaces at the next level and to eliminate the rest. It is important to note that the number of available spaces at the next level determines the “failure” point. Thus the definition of failure has little to do with what has been learned; it selects “objectively” the few who can be absorbed into the next level of the
S ociology of E ducation
13
system. One consequence of this situation is that there are huge numbers of people in some countries who must live with an artificially defined and externally imposed sense of failure, simply because the education system needs expansion. The foregoing suggests that a seemingly straightforward matter such as educational goals quickly raises a number of issues connecting an education system to economics, politics, and the dominant values of the society in which the system is rooted. More importantly, there is no country in the world that succeeds in providing the same educational opportunities for everyone.
Theory in Sociology of Education Earlier it was mentioned that sociology of education stems from the economic and social philosophical nineteenth-century writings of well-known thinkers such as Karl Marx, Max Weber, Emile Durkheim, Charles Cooley, and George Herbert Mead. More recently, new theories have emerged in response to post–World War II events such as massive migration, the independence of African nations, and the social turmoil of the 1960s in the West. In this section, we give thumbnail sketches in order to define briefly the following theories: functional, conflict, interaction, neo-Marxism, postmodern, critical, and feminist. A full understanding of these theories can only come from a much more thorough reading of the suggested readings at the end of this chapter. Karl Marx’s (1864–1920) political ideas have shaped history and influenced how we think about society. He was deeply affected by the living conditions of workers in nineteenth-century Europe. He sought to explain capitalism theoretically and fight it politically. He believed that the economic organization of a society affects the class structure, institutions, cultural values, and beliefs of that society. For Marx, socialism (ownership by workers of their society’s factories, land, and other productive assets) would follow capitalism (private ownership of the means of production) as the final stage in the evolution of history and politics. This would occur only after a social revolution. Marx’s most famous work is Das Kapital, the first volume of which was published in 1867. Emile Durkheim (1858–1917) focused his studies on social order and used statistics and empirical methods to explain the forces that he believed made social events regular and predictable. Throughout his work Durkheim analyzes the function of the moral base underlying society, which according to him, makes order possible. Durkheim’s most famous writings include The division of labour in society and suicide: A study in sociology, first published in 1893 and 1897 respectively.
14
A li A . A bdi and A ilie Cleghorn
Max Weber (1864–1920) wrote on many subjects—religion, economics, politics, authority, bureaucracy, class and caste, and the city. Like Marx he was interested in explaining the rise of capitalism. However, he believed that systems of ideas, including religions, influence economic behavior, not the reverse. One of Weber’s famous works was The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism translated by Talcott Parsons and published in English in 1930. Charles H. Cooley’s (1864–1929) theory focused on the place of the individual within the larger social context. His theory on the origin of the “self,” that is, a person’s sense of self-identity, centered on the notion of the “looking glass effect,” a metaphor that explains how individuals, through interaction with parents, peers, and teachers (significant others), come to see themselves as they imagine others see them. Cooley’s ideas contributed to George Herbert Mead’s (1863–1931) conceptualization of what came to be known as the symbolic interaction perspective. Mead stated that self-development and self-awareness require the capacity to use language and interact symbolically. He argued that to interact with others the individual must take the role of the other in order to imagine how this “other” views him or herself and to know what this other expects of him or her. Mead believed that individuals act and react to one another according to these mental interpretations. Mead’s conception of the self includes the “Me,” a representation of internalized societal attitudes and expectations and the “I,” a unique and emancipated facet that produces spontaneity and individuality. These societal and individual aspects of the self operate together within the individual and highlight the interactive quality of the interaction perspective. Various sociologists, in their search for basic knowledge about schooling and their desire to explain the common assumptions about what schools actually do, drew on many of the concepts put forth by these groundbreaking social philosophers and early thinkers in the field of sociology. The following section describes the sociological perspectives that subsequently developed to explain the educational process. Again, it is to be noted that these theories developed mainly in the West and have been assumed by many social scientists to have universal saliency, a point with which we do not agree. They do, however, provide a starting point for thinking about their strengths and shortcomings with regard to our understanding of the issues that the chapters in this book discuss. We are sure that the readers will find several examples in those chapters of African scholars, who have built on, extended, or modified the theories in ways that render them suitable to the settings under consideration.
S ociology of E ducation
15
Functional Perspective The functionalist view developed and prevailed in the 1950s to offer an explanation and justification for the role of schools in maintaining society in a kind of equilibrium in the face of technological advances, a large influx of immigrants, and movement of people from the rural to urban areas. These social changes dramatically affected the occupational structure. Thus, the need to maintain social order was linked to a deep-seated commitment to capitalism. Schools were seen as important because they teach the necessary skills and norms to participate in society, and because they sort, select, and train people to fill positions in the workplace. From this stance, achievement, assessed through “objective” tests, is a rational and morally justifiable way of sorting the student population for various occupations and social status. The functional perspective is reflected in the works of Talcott Parsons (1967), James Coleman (1966), and Robert Dreeben (1968). They viewed the classroom as a social system, socializing, and allocating individuals on the basis of the criteria assigned to it by the larger society. The school’s function is seen as dictated by the economy and occupational structure of a developing modern industrial society. From this perspective, education expansion offers greater opportunities for attaining higher social status. In sum and to put it simply, a state of equilibrium was needed for capitalistic reasons and supported by a system which convinced people that the selection-allocation process was fair.
Conflict and Neo-Marxist Perspectives In the 1970s, a debate developed about talent/intelligence and school achievement on the one hand and the relationship between schooling and the future status of individuals on the other. Collins (1977) cited by Barakett and Cleghorn (2000) argued against the basic assumptions of the functionalists. He refutes the notions that job skill requirements have increased due to technological advances, and that formal education provides the training necessary for upgrading job skills. He states that the main contribution of education to economic productivity occurs at the level of transition to mass literacy; better educated individuals are not necessarily more productive and furthermore, most skilled manual laborers learn their skills on the job. Collins suggests that schools teach status culture—a particular lifestyle. Consequently, education becomes a means of cultural selection. Collins notes that a conflict theory of education must focus on the struggle between status culture groups and how status culture is learned in school.
16
A li A . A bdi and A ilie Cleghorn
Bourdieu and Passeron (1977) add another dimension to status culture. They view education as a significant social and political force in reproducing the class structure of society, that the language and texts used in schools reflect the interests, values, and tastes of the dominant social class. In this way a link is created between class, power, and education. The children of the elite acquire style and forms of language through “ascription.” Higher status groups transform their cultural capital into academic capital. Children from the lower class do not possess the cultural traits of the elite. They have different linguistic abilities than those prescribed by the school leading to a deficit view of them rather than a full recognition of difference. Due to the embedded assumptions about their educational needs, it then appears “natural” to sort them into lower streams and offer them a different curriculum. This has led to the organization of different schools or streams within schools distinguished by the type of capital they demand of their students. Basil Bernstein (1973) focused on the process of socialization within the family, particularly in the link between social class and the child’s development of language—elaborated (middle class) codes give universal meanings to situations, objects, or events and restricted (working class) codes provide context specific meanings. Since schools operate within the elaborated code, children from higher social classes have an advantage. Bernstein’s work must however be understood to apply to the case of Britain where there is much social class meaning attached to accent, with accent identifying the region or social class that a person is from. Several researchers in applied linguistics have found that the supposedly restricted code of working class children is, upon close study, not restricted at all, just different from the speech of the elite. In the mid-1970s another debate developed about the links between intelligence, school achievement, and the future status of individuals. Bowles and Gintis (1976) argued that IQ scores, occupational status, and income are positively correlated. However, when socioeconomic status is controlled, IQ does not have a significant effect on the individual’s future earnings or occupational status. Bowles and Gintis focus on the ways in which what goes on in schools mirrors the structure of the society at large, reproducing the class system (inequality), and extending the capitalist mode of production. They refer to this process as the correspondence principle. Indeed, for them the root of inequality is the capitalist economy, not education. Schools reproduce and legitimize inequality by perpetuating and reinforcing (1) the meritocratic ideology of allocating individuals in the occupational hierarchy; (2) rewarding personal characteristics that are compatible with the relationships of dominance and subordinance; and, (3) by serving the
S ociology of E ducation
17
interests of the dominant groups through the training of an elite group in the skills of domination (Bowles and Gintis, 1976, 11–13). Symbolic Interaction, Interpretive/Phenomenological Perspectives Beginning with social structural realities of wealth, power, and status, symbolic interactionists have attempted to link these with interactional patterns. The interest was in how structural variables become incorporated into the individual’s interpretations of everyday life and how the individual acts on such a base. Caroline Persell (1977) presents a theoretical paradigm which deals with four levels of analysis—the societal, institutional, interpersonal, and intra-psychic. She draws on Marx as well as Weber to point out the interdependence of structures of dominance and their associated ideologies. The educational system is shaped by the structurally derived ideologies. This system, in turn, supports the existing structures of dominance. The institutional level (the structure of the educational system), then, is shaped by the polity and economy. The schooling process—achievement testing, ability grouping and tracking—reflect the structural needs of society. By drawing on symbolic interaction theory Persell then goes on to explain the interpersonal and intra-psychic levels. Here the focus is on the origins and consequences of teacher expectations. Teachers develop expectations and respond to pupils on the basis of widely accepted criteria of judgment of school performance. Differential expectations of teachers serve to limit educational attainment of minority and lowerclass students. Thus Persell relates teachers’ expectations to institutional and societal structures. Social interaction between teachers and students in the classroom affect broader decision-making processes, such as tracking of students into educational paths that have their parallel in the social structure of the society. Some theorists have turned to Alfred Schutz’ (1973) phenomenological sociology to explain inequality in educational opportunity. This theory focuses on the social construction of knowledge, the common sense world (of everyday life), and the intersubjective world consisting of common experiences which individuals share but take for granted. As participants in a social world people give meaning to actions and situations. As with Cooley and Mead, they grasp the intentions of others through understanding what the world looks like from the “other’s” perspective. These theorists, often referred to as the new sociologists of education or interpretive sociologists, are criticized for not explaining how individuals are controlled and shaped by material as well as ideological
18
A li A . A bdi and A ilie Cleghorn
forces and for omitting reference to the role that institutions have in effecting oppressive social conditions. Critical Theory, Feminist Theory and Pedagogy, Postmodernism Critical theory is derived from the recognition that experience and knowledge are politically charged and interrelated. Knowledge is to be used as a tool for change to transform nature and politics and to alleviate oppression. Social phenomena contain dialectical opposing forces which, when analyzed, permit insight into the objectives, activities, and practical interests of individuals in different groups. In critical theory, everyday life is the theoretical and practical sphere for investigation and the struggle for liberation which is based on human needs and not simply economic ones. Critical theory takes the position that human behavior is more than a reaction to capitalism and that shared meanings of a subjective nature are an important aspect of social reality. With few exceptions, critical educational theorists focus on the libratory works of Freire (1968, 1985), Giroux (1992), Giroux and McLaren (1994), McLaren (1998), Shor (1992), and Simon (1987). The libratory/emancipatory aim of critical educational theory and critical pedagogy became of interest to feminist educational theorists and feminist pedagogists. For the critical educational feminist theorist, the centrality of subjectivity in constructing a synthesis between feminist and critical theory lies in the political dimension of the relationship between knowledge and experience. Emphasis is placed on the relation between domination, knowledge, and experience and liberation from this domination. This position rests on the view that the existing society is exploitative and oppressive due to a dominant patriarchal ideology. Like critical pedagogy, feminist pedagogy is based on the assumptions of the power of consciousness raising in ending oppression and working toward a vision of social change and social transformation (Gore, 1993). Feminist pedagogy has two strands. One emphasizes the instructional aspects of pedagogy through women’s studies programs; the other emphasizes feminism(s) and theory in schools of education. The major difference between the two is that the former focuses on what constitutes feminist pedagogy while the latter focuses on how gendered knowledge and experience are produced. Their criticism of critical pedagogy is that it is patriarchal. Both strands are concerned with democratizing schools and society. A gender inclusive curriculum is essential, one that will prove difficult to realize in some Islamic settings, for example, due to what are sometimes extreme constraints on the lives of women.
S ociology of E ducation
19
Postmodernism represents a major shift in theoretical approach to social phenomena and to the nature of reality. It argues for subjectivism and micro-sociological analysis. Postmodern theorists have argued against positivism.3 They also argue for the existence of a multiplicity of theoretical standpoints, addressing the relationship of the individual to the phenomenon, rather than trying to place either into a broader schema. In this way, postmodern thought emphasizes the need for micro-theory dealing with the nature of “difference,” rather than holistic macro-theory.
Organization of the Book From an African and, by extension, Africanist point of view, the conventional sociology of education elaborated did not represent either the worldview or the culturally induced educational needs of the populace. The fact that this was the case in colonial times (Nyerere, 1968; Rodney, 1982) would not have been a surprise, as the colonial project itself was using European sociology of education to rationalize the imposition of imperial systems of instruction and teaching that did a lot to stunt overall African education and concomitant social advancement possibilities. Post political independence, African learning systems did not speak with any tangible measure of indigenous voice. Hence, the timely focus of this book. The four thematic parts besides this introductory chapter contain 15 chapters that descriptively, analytically, and critically deal with issues including: a recasting of the philosophical foundations of African education; a reexamination of higher education systems; discussion of cultural and linguistic issues and women’s education. All of these are complemented by a number of country case studies that look at selected problems and prospects of education and development in particular social contexts. Chapter 2 of this section (Theoretical Foundations) by Ali A. Abdi looks at the problematique of imposed Western philosophies of learning, how these have underdeveloped African societies, and the urgent need to advance a type of education that illuminates African knowledge systems and ways of knowing. Then Korbla Puplampu analyzes the role that current African institutions of higher education should play in the contemporary development of African societies, relative to the prevailing trends of globalization and emerging information technologies. In part II (Culture, Language, and Curriculum), Edward Shizha examines the postcolonial educational dilemmas located within school curricula, which are by and large, learning remnants of colonial education, and discusses new ways of making the curriculum more inclusive
20
A li A . A bdi and A ilie Cleghorn
and more responsive to the needs of African students. In chapter 5, Nkosinathi Mkosi undertakes a conceptual and theoretical treatment of indigenous knowledge systems. In chapter 6, Ailie Cleghorn explores some main themes that pertain to the use of language in classroom settings, and how the situation could be ameliorated so that the outcomes are conducive to the desired pedagogical and development intentions. In chapter 7, the last chapter of this section, M.B. Ogunniyi looks at how culture and cultural realities would be situated within science and technology (S & T) education. In part III (Gender and Equity Issues) Benedicta Egbo first focuses on the role of education in African women’s development, with the overall understanding that women are still both educationally and socioeconomically highly disenfranchised vis-à-vis men in all zones of the continent. Philomina Okeke-Ihejirika then speaks in chapter 9 about the need for some critical interventions to achieve gender equity in the continent’s institutions of higher education with particular regard to increasing access and representation. In chapter 10, Codou Diaw examines and critiques the triumphalist beginnings of the Women-InDevelopment (WID) project, and how, in real terms, it did not live up to its promise for the overwhelming majority of African women. In chapter 11, Lantana Usman discusses the role of human agency through education so as to ameliorate the situation for nomadic girls in Nigeria. Finally, George Dei and Alireza Asgharzadeh present the results of focus group discussions on university and pre-tertiary education in Ghana. The intention of their study was to find out how that education can become, via its teaching, learning, and administrative capacities, sustainably inclusive and therefore, more conducive to the development needs of the population. Finally, in part IV the last part, Edward Shizha and Ali A. Abdi take a sociohistorical perspective at how education has or has not been democratized (i.e., available to all) in the recent case of Zambia, which although successful in many ways, still has a long way to go. In chapter 14, Ali A. Abdi discusses the serious lack of formal education systems in post–state Somalia, with special analysis of the difficulties posed by non-constructive regimes of informal learning situations since 1991. In the next chapter, Njoki Wane recounts a case study of how primary and secondary teacher education is organized in Kenya. She assumes a historical focus while emphasizing the need to indigenize certain components and contents of teacher education in Kenya and elsewhere. In the last chapter, Okwach Abagi presents what might be seen as a topical conclusion to the educational problems and prospects discussed in the preceding chapters. In a nutshell, Abagi notes that in order to make
S ociology of E ducation
21
education responsive to Africa’s development needs schools must be reconceptualized by Africans. With this call for a more inclusive and prospectively “Africanized” sociology of education, we hope this book enlivens the debate on the greatly needed ameliorative categories that should be injected, le plus tôt que possible, into the continent’s learning and social development spaces.
Notes 1. We are indebted to Joyce Barakett for the parts of this chapter which have been adapted from Barakett and Cleghorn, 2000. 2. The term minority world refers to the industrialized countries whose populations are a numerical minority worldwide. Majority world refers to the less industrialized or still developing countries whose populations are the numerical majority. 3. Belief that natural science, based on observation, comprises the whole of human knowledge. Positivists reject as meaningless the claims of theology and metaphysics. The most influential twentieth-century version is logical positivism, an example being the theory of probability.
References Achebe, Chinua (2000). Home and exile. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Anderson, G. (1990). Fundamentals of educational research. New York: Falmer Press. Apple, M.W. and Christian-Smith, L.K. (Eds.) (1991). The politics of the textbook. New York: Routledge. Arnove, R.F. and Torres, C.A. (Eds.) (1999). Comparative education: The dialectic of the global and the local. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield. Aronowitz, S. and Giroux, H. (1993). Education still under siege. New York: Bergin & Garvey. Barakett, J. and Cleghorn, A. (2000). Sociology of education: An introductory view from Canada. Toronto: Prentice Hall. Bernstein, B. (1973). Call codes and control. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul. Bourdieu, P. and Passeron, J.C. (1977). Reproduction in education: Society and culture. California: Sage. Bowles, S. and Gintis, H. (1976). Schooling in capitalist America. New York: Basic Books. Cleghorn, A. and Rollnick, M. (2002). The role of English in individual and societal development: A view from African classrooms. TESOL Quarterly, 36 (3), 347–372. Coleman, J. (1966). The concept of equality of opportunity. Harvard Educational Review, 38, 7–32. Collins, R. (1977). Functional and conflict theories of educational stratification. American Sociological Review, 36 (6), 1002–1019.
22
Ali A . A bdi and A ilie Cleghorn
Cooley, C.H. (1956). Human nature and the social order. Glencoe, IL: Free Press. Dei, G. (1996). Black/African-Canadian student’s perspectives on school racism. In M.I. Alladin, Racism in Canadian schools (pp. 42–57). Toronto: Harcourt Brace. Dowling, P. and Brown, A. (1996). Pedagogy and community in three South African schools. Paper presented at Research into Social Perspectives in Mathematics Education. Dreeben, R. (1968). On what is learned in school. Reading, MA: AddisonWesley. Durkheim, E. (1951). Suicide: A study in sociology. Glencoe, IL: Free Press. Durkheim, E. (1956). Education and sociology. New York: Free Press. Durkheim, E. (1974). Moral education. Paris: University of Paris Press. Durkheim, E. (1984) Division of labour in society. London: Macmillan. Freire, P. (1968). Pedagogy of the oppressed. New York: Seabury Press. Freire, P. (1985). The politics of education: Culture, power and liberation. Boston: Bergin & Garvey. Geertz, C. (Ed.) (1973). The interpretation of cultures. New York: Basic Books. Ghosh, R. and Ray, D. (1987). Social change and education in Canada. Toronto: Harcourt Brace. Gibson, M.A. and Ogbu, J.U. (1991). Minority status and schooling. New York: Garland. Giroux, H. (1992). Border crossings. New York: Routledge. Giroux, H. and McLaren, P. (1994). Between borders. New York: Routledge. Gordon, R. (1997). Structural adjustment and women in Zimbabwe: Effects and prospects. Canadian Journal of Development Studies, XVIII (2), 263–278. Gore, J. (1993). The struggle for pedagogies. New York: Routledge. Jackson, P. (1968). Life in classrooms. New York: Holt, Rinehardt & Winston. Kubow, P.K. and Fossum, P.R. (2003). Comparative education: Exploring issues in international context. New Jersey: Merrill-Prentice Hall. LeVine, R. (2003). Childhood socialization: Comparative studies of parenting, learning and educational change. Comparative Education Research Centre, University of Hong Kong: Hong Kong. Lindsay, B. (1990). Educational equity in cross-national settings. In M. Thomas (Ed.). International comparative education: Practices, issues, and prospects. New York: Pergamon. Marx, K. (1967) [1867]. Das Kapital. New York: International Publishers. McEneaney, E. (2003). The worldwide cachet of scientific literacy. Comparative Education Review, 47 (2), 217–237. McLaren, P. (1998). Life in schools: An introduction to critical pedagogy in the foundations of education. Don Mills: Langerman. Mead, G.H. (1934). Mind, self and society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Mifflen, F.J. and Mifflen, S.C. (1982). The sociology of education: Canada and beyond. Calgary: Detselig. Norris, S.P. and Phillips, L.M. (1990). Foundations of literacy policy in Canada. Calgary: Detselig.
S ociology of E ducation
23
Nunn, E.J. and Boyatzis, C.J. (1998/99). Child growth and development. Guilford, Connecticut: McGraw-Hill. Nyerere, J. (1968). Freedom and socialism: A selection from writing and speeches 1965–67. London: Oxford University Press. Ogbu, J.U. (1991). Low school performance as an adaptation: The case of Blacks in Stockton, California. In M.A. Gibson and J.U. Ogbu (Eds.), Minority status and schooling (pp. 249–286). New York: Garland publishing. Orpwood, G. and Garden, R.A. (Eds.) (1998). Assessing mathematics and science literacy. TIMMS Monograph Series #4. Vancouver: Pacific Educational Press. Parsons, T. (1967). The school class as a social system. In P. Rose (Ed.), The study of society (pp. 647–665). New York: Random House. Persell, C.H. (1977). Education and inequality. New York: The Free Press. Rodney, W. (1982). How Europe underdeveloped Africa. Washington, D.C.: Howard University Press. Schutz, A. (1973). Collected papers: The problem of social reality. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff. Shor, I. (1992). Empowering education: Critical teaching for social change. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Simon, R. (1987). Empowerment as a pedagogy of possibility. Language Arts, 64 (4), 370–382. Slavin, R.E. (1991). Educational psychology: Theory into practice. Engelwood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice Hall. Stigler, J.W. and Stevenson, H.W. (1998/99). How Asian teachers polish each lesson to perfection. In E.J. Nunn and C.J. Boyatzis, Child growth and development. Guilford, CT: McGraw-Hill. Thomas, R.M. (Ed.) (1990). International comparative education: Practices, issues and prospects. New York: Pergamon. UNICEF (1994). Children and women in Zimbabwe: A situation analysis. Harare. Weber, M. (1930). The protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism. London: Allen and Unwin. Weber, M. (1947). The theory of social and economic organisation. New York: The Free Press.
This page intentionally left blank
2
African P hilosophies of Education: Counter-C olonial Criticisms Ali A. Abdi
A
n important objective of the discipline and, by extension, the possible practice of philosophy is to inquire critically about almost all aspects of our lives relative to the social and physical environments that surround us. Related to this overall understanding of the issue is how the central questions of the philosophy of education would systematically, or as formally as possible, examine questions that can analyze and situate the main reasons people should be educated, how they should be educated, and why should individuals or groups be educated in the first place. As Ozmon and Craver (1998, p. 2) have noted, therefore, “philosophy of education is the application of the fundamental principles of philosophy to the theory and work of education.” In the global configuration of realities and power contours, those who have developed “textualized” and comprehensive bodies of philosophy, that is, Western countries and their “knowledge managers,” have assumed that theirs are the most viable, if not the only meaningful, philosophies and, especially those of education. It is in that problematic plateau of understanding that Cahn (1997, p. 3), tells us that “all work in philosophy of education should be measured against the standard of excellence [Plato] established.” At another time, it was Alfred North Whitehead who forwarded the well known and quasi-presumptive line throughout human history, that we should accept, without any qualifications, that all the formations of philosophical conceptualizations, arguments, and treatises would be a footnote to the idealist philosopher, Plato. Indeed, this caption advances a desired understanding, among all of us, that this Greek thinker was
26
A li A . A bdi
and remains to be the quintessential philosopher of humankind. Needless to add that from the perspective of the still dominant European Canon, a possible temperance in the case may be the occasional bestowal of this top recognition on none other than Aristotle, the other philosopher from classical Greece and Plato’s pupil. The latter should generally get the votes of those who are located more in the realist streams of the philosophical imagination and would, therefore, have some fundamental problems with the nonscientific assumptions of idealism. Expectedly, the preceding pointers could not bode well for the people of Africa. It was, indeed, the case that prominent European philosophers and philosophers of education did not only promote their knowledge systems vis-à-vis the learning and epistemological realities of the old continent, but went so far as to deny Africa of viable philosophical systems or even meaningful and organized learning programs that could effect concretizable notions of cultural development. This was, of course, a component of Europe’s colonial onslaught, which beyond the physical subjugation it wrought on the African people, was also educationally and ontologically oriented. In that vein, Africa was fundamentally an “ahistorical” huge landmass that was supposedly being rescued from itself (p’Bitek, 1972). Based on that, European philosophers, who greatly shaped the theoretical justifications of the colonial project, were at the forefront of creating an image of Africa that was empty of any so-called civilized or rational beings, and was, thus, fit to be colonized and exploited as much as possible. Here, even the so-called French philosophers of freedom and liberty such as Voltaire (1826) and Montesquieu (1975) were on board, and the intellectual project of dehumanizing the persona Africana and willfully attempting to erase and/or comprehensively devalue his or her accomplishments, overall life systems, and attached systematic bodies of thought or philosophies was, without exceptions, well articulated and expansively referenced, albeit all falsely, in the emerging European metropolises. Among the most vociferous proponents of seeing and treating Africa as a place inhabited by a degenerative concoction of races was the German, G. Hegel. Hegel (1965) was, somehow, sure that “Africa was not interesting from the point of view of its own history. . . . Africa [and Africans] were in a state of barbarism and savagery which was preventing them from being an integral part of civilization” (p. 247). For his part, Montesquieu (1975) also told us that “the greatest part of the people on the coast of Africa are savages and barbarians” (p.332). The analytically interesting point, at least for us, of attributing savagery and barbarism to the continent was generally intended to achieve two important objectives for colonialism: (1) to justify the diabolic
African P hilosophies of Education
27
onslaught to the European people and (2) to damage, actually destroy as much as possible, the psycho-cultural being of Africans. Actually, this is what, among many others, Achebe (1958, 2000), Fanon (1968, 1967), and wa Thiong’o (1986), with different emphasis and from diverse angles, so effectively and eloquently wrote about. In all the ensuing colonial encounters among the two groups, one constant issue was the way Europeans portrayed African traditional education and systems of thought as either nonexistent, basically nontenable, and/or non-coherent primitive noises that the native population was to be cleansed of. With these introductory notes on the overall situation, let me submit that precolonial African philosophies and systems of education were, in the context in which they were being undertaken, as practical as any that existed in other parts of the world. In that temper, while our knowledge formations and epistemologies were not necessarily as formalized as those in Europe, African know-how and ways of knowing were situationally responsive to the historical, cultural, and environmental needs of the African people. To support these and similar counter-colonial and counter-hegemonic projects, I focus, in the following pages, on select perspectives that should recast the viability as well as the strength of precolonial, African traditional systems of learning, complemented in the latter sections of the chapter, by some discussions on the possible revival of indigenous knowledge systems for inclusive and sustainable possibilities of educational and social development. Here, the centrality of these and similar arguments for emerging (or emergent) African sociologies of education should be clear: without understanding, critiquing, and reconstructing the philosophical foundations of learning, the interplay between society and education will be problematic and would not affect the achievement of locally inclusive socioeconomic, political, and cultural advancements.
African Traditional Systems of Education It is still the case that different learning and socialization processes across the globe generally take place within organized, classroom situations (formal education), via random interactions with one’s social and physical environment (informal education), or through short-term training programs that are designed to enhance the skills of workers (nonformal education). There may still be other possibilities of learning in select places and communities of the world, but for the most part, these would represent the most widely used components of learning interactions that one would encounter in contemporary socioeconomic and
28
A li A . A bdi
political situations. It is also the case that “after-the-fact” of colonialism, almost all the countries of the world have adopted, in their formal schooling contexts, the Western tradition of learning style, objectives and, for the most part, even subjects/lesson structures and contents. It should go without saying, therefore, that within the current and dominant programs of education across the globe, a given philosophy of education will dominate both the formulation, the evaluation and, of course, the long-term implementation of both learning and teaching methodologies and epistemologies. That being as it may, the fact, not at all the rhetoric, should still remain that pre-colonial, African traditional systems of education were informed and characterized, albeit mainly (though not exclusively) informally, by advanced constructions of learning and concomitant achievement and expectations that were in place many years before the advent of European conquest, which could be officially dated from late sixteenth to mid-twentieth century (Diop, 1990, 1974; Jackson, 1970; van Sertima, 1991;). Here, while the general informality of these education systems were attacked by the colonizers as not effectively organized and, therefore, instructionally weak, the contrary should be true for us. That is, if different education systems in various epochs and locations of human history would emphasize diverse modes and structures of learning that are mainly determined by the specificities of a given people and continents, Africans should also have a right, not only to formulate their own systems of education, but also, and as importantly, to bestow legitimacy upon those systems. In that case, the late philosopher-statesman and President of Tanzania, Julius Nyerere (1968), in his highly referenced book Freedom and Socialism, makes a very important point: The educational systems in different kinds of societies in the world have been, and are, very different in organization and content. They are different because the societies providing the education are different, and because education, whether it be formal or informal, has a purpose. That purpose is to transmit from one generation to the next the accumulated wisdom and knowledge of society, and to prepare the young people for their future membership of the society and their active participation in its maintenance and development. (p. 268)
Nyerere’s anticolonial perspectives are important in also explaining the situational effectiveness of these programs, and how they were able to address specialized life realities that people were confronting in their environments. As such, Walter Rodney (1982), in his excellent book How Europe Underdeveloped Africa, refers to the overall and practical
African P hilosophies of Education
29
advantages of these programs of education: The following features of indigenous African education can be considered outstanding: its close links with social life, both in a material and spiritual sense; its collective nature; its many-sidedness, and its progressive development in conformity with successive stages of physical, emotional and mental development of the child. There was no separation of education and the productive activity. Altogether, through mainly informal means, pre-colonial African education matched the realities of pre-colonial African society and produced well-rounded personalities to fit into that society. (p. 239)
In select zones of the continent, therefore, the example and the values of presettler and precolonial notions of learning, speak about how they were essential in reflecting the social and cultural needs and expectations of the community. That is to say, African informal systems of learning were designed and undertaken under the rubric of select African philosophies of education that were not alien to, but were components of the earthly and related cosmological horizons and connectivities, and within the time-and-space determinants and elasticities, of the vita Africana. Keto (1990), speaking especially about the South African situation, writes that “African societies had invariably created their own institutions and processes of socialization and education before the Dutch settlers arrived in 1652” (pp. 19–20). He adds that “the processes of education began with learning by young from family members [complemented by the] young being trained in manners, roles, responsibilities, and history, the importance of fighting and military skills.” With those realities in place, the tenacity as well as the overwhelming presence of the dominant European ideology could still be adamant in dismissing these structures and philosophies of education as fundamentally disorganized relationships of learning that would be void of any rigor and system. Such hasty observations need not disturb at all, though, for one must fully know that in places where formal classroom education is not common, these programs of inter-generational transfer of information and skills become minimally semi-formalized via the quasipermanency of the contents and learner–instructor relationships, and would be contextually formalized. More precisely, the way communities manage their resources, set up their programs of defense against foreign invaders, and undertake the overall mechanisms of their political and economic systems would all be determined over time—tested (in terms of their effectiveness) informal programs of education. Needless to add that just calling upon these structures of teaching whenever
30
A li A . A bdi
the need arises will not and cannot meet the needs of the people in societies, as those in precolonial Africa, where situations and relationships were complex, intricate and, undoubtedly, responsive to the social and physical demands and requirements imposed by the surrounding or far away environments. As such, no one, as far as I can understand, should be suggesting that “the at-the-moment” things that people talk about wherever they gather were philosophically based systems of learning that would have met the practical as well as the aspirational needs of the community. It was more the case than otherwise, therefore, that the more educated among peoples, in most cases, the oldest members of the community, continually engaged in nonformal and non-school buildingconfined philosophical treatises about the best ways to teach youngsters, complemented by experience-induced improvements that were constantly applied to the actual knowledge and learning formations that would be specific to diverse areas of study and analysis. As such, it should not have been uncommon to different segments of society, to see learners, generally grouped on the basis of age, gathering in select zones of the community, often at the homestead of village chiefs/elders who, again contrary to popular belief, were both men and women, and other localities that would hold the highest number of peoples for a given instructional or educationally oriented consultative processes. These processes should have been, without exceptions, deliberately formulated and undertaken to either advance the knowledge base of the area, or seek novel methodical clusters to address emergent issues, including environmental disasters, crop failure, livestock diseases, and possible social and political upheavals. It would be silly to assume, therefore, that in contexts where so many people had to define and find solutions for their complex and over-millennia developed life situations, the learning systems were simply non-rigorous, selectively non-speculative, perpetually less conscientized, to deploy a Freirean perspective (Freire, 2000 [1970]), and at the mercy of changing climates, relationships, and structures. Hence, the observational strength of Semali’s points confirms how traditional indigenous systems of learning were not only effectively developed and philosophically coherent, but also scientifically and technologically connected. Semali (1999) elaborates on these realities when he writes how African traditional systems of knowledge were “comprehensive bodies of knowledge that, beyond the historical, philosophical and literary components, also address such issues as fishing techniques . . . post-harvest pest control programs . . . [the science and] use of different herbs and plants to manage diseases . . . [and] methods of food preservation and preserving” (p. 308).
African P hilosophies of Education
31
It should be clear by now that as African general philosophies of life and philosophies of education were formulated and applied to the given situations they were located in, one fundamental difference they might have with European thought systems was the vocationalism-based branching out. Some would undoubtedly call this a disciplinary fragmentation of the latter into multiple subareas that have been advanced by new platoons of idealist, realist, analytic, behaviorist, and existentialist philosophers, among other philosophers of education. Needless to add that all these new professional philosophers were advocating that their approach was the best approach to explain and achieve desired projects of educational and social development. In the African context though, I would suggest that the most practical approximation African philosophies of education could share with any of these, is that the latter were pragmatic thought systems and ideas that were developed to function well and lead to the desired results of a given learning and related social advancement platforms. As such, in current analysis, traditional African philosophies of education would be closer, though not identical, to Deweyan (Dewey, 1969, 1963) and Freirean (Freire, 2002 [1974], 2000 [1970]) thoughts and perspectives on understanding and helping the learner, via the creation of curricular and “schooling” environments that are relevant, inclusive and selectively workable and productive. African philosophies of education, therefore, were focused on transforming societies for the best possible ways that would not be counter-community and damaging to environmental cohesiveness and integrity. In that sense, these philosophies were uncompromisingly centered, not on the notions of winning an argument, but on the needs of African life which, before Eurocentricity became the only center (Dei, 1996), was located in, and responsive to the pragmatic realities of our polycentric existences. Designing and operationalizing, as much as possible, philosophies of life and education for the ongoing and always dynamic interests of the community was so fundamental to traditional African systems of learning that the paramount expectation was only modifiable as to the level of responsiveness that these philosophies were supposed to meet. Equally important in those precolonial settings was the reality that as these programs were not imposed from outside the continent, learning projects were almost always responsive to the effective evaluation and implementation of not only the programs themselves, but also the socioeconomic and scientific advancements they effected, which were at pace with the experiences, current needs, and practical (even utopian) desires of the people concerned. That is why I am highlighting the pragmatic (probably mixed with a small dose of existentialism) that
32
A li A . A bdi
African philosophies of education would subsume into their theoretical and experimental spheres.
The Reign of Colonial Philosophies of Education It was with multicentric indigenous philosophies and systems of education relatively speaking intact, and with life for traditional African societies, technically speaking, “friendly,” that European powers decided, for their economic and racist interests, to invade and colonize what was termed the dark and civilizationally closed continent. I do not deem it necessary to engage in any expansive discourses in the WHYs and HOWs of colonialism, especially its false and selfishly concocted anthropological, religious, and philosophical claims that would attempt to justify Europe’s so-called mission civilsatrice. Those issues have been effectively and comprehensively treated by a number of African scholars whose historical works and contemporary criticisms have led to the achievement of many books and articles in the last 50 years. To see some of the most outstanding results in this endeavor, especially those that aim for the historical and sociocultural recasting of Africa’s philosophical and overall ontological realms and dimensions, one could consult, among many others, Achebe (2000, 1958), wa Thiong’o (1993, 1986, 1964), van Sertima (1991), Diop (1990, 1974), Rodney (1982), Nyerere (1974, 1968), Fanon (1968, 1967). As I have done on a number of occasions, though, I would still like to relay this solitary snapshot from van Sertima (1991), which, for me at least, effectively captures the most concise and, at the same time, most complete meaning of the colonization of Africa. No other disaster with the exception of the Flood (if that Biblical legend is true) can equal in dimension of its destructiveness, the cataclysm that shook Africa . . . Vast populations were uprooted and displaced, whole generations disappeared, European diseases descended like the plague decimating both cattle and people, cities and towns were abandoned, family networks disintegrated, kingdoms crumbled, the threads of cultural and historical continuity were so savagely torn asunder that henceforward, one would only have to talk of two Africas: the one before and the one after the Holocaust. (p. 8)
To add to this, and again, from an educational and concomitant social development viewpoint, we know that the arrival of colonialism led to the perforce imposition of European worldview, which was greatly responsible for, as Rodney (1982), Nyerere (1968), and Achebe (1958), in different foci and emphases, explicated many years back, the
African P hilosophies of E ducation
33
deliberate distortion, not only of the traditional projects of education already in place, but also of the indigenously based and comprehensive programs of development that were achieved and put into place over hundreds of years. These realities and historical exegeses should annul, once and for all, the false and ridiculous claim that colonialism developed Africa. In fact, the contrary was true. However, perhaps where colonization had its most destructive impact should not be, as was believed once, the direct physical subjugation and the merciless exploitation of the human and natural resources of Africa and Africans. Reading wa Thiong’o (1986, 1993), Cesaire (1972), and Fanon (1967) should help us understand how the measurable program and effects of colonialism would pale in comparison with the more psycho-social and educational as well as the cultural enduring scars it imprints upon the psyches of what Fanon (1968) called the Wretched of the Earth. It has, indeed, been possible to see people all over the world achieving physical liberation from European colonizers, but the meta-corporeal effects of the case will remain intergenerational and will shape the mental dispositions and as importantly, the self and group confidence of the colonized. As Memmi (1991[1957]) so cogently discussed, even before the end of political colonialism, the colonized were already collaborating with their oppressors on the overall project of their subjugation. As one component of the general practice of colonialism, colonial education supplanted traditional education and was so greatly entrenched it maximally serves the interests of colonialism (Abdi, 2002, 1998). European historians and philosophers of education who were now located in the colonies, situated themselves at the forefront of the theorizing excursions that were previously initiated to justify and strengthen the invasion and the following conquest of the African continent. As Kallaway (1984) points out in the South African situation, for example, education itself and the work of educators were some of the most important tools used to hasten and complete the colonial project. Here it should be useful to hear the opinion of one colonial historian of education who describes the character of the uneducated Bantu and what should/could be done about it. As one should see, Pells (1970 [1930]) accords himself a carte blanche in talking about his victims and, somehow, gets his reductio ad absurdum descriptions accepted as real scholarship. This, indeed, brings to mind Karl Marx’s remark that the ideas of the dominant group are always the right ideas. Pells (1970 [1930]) wrote: The lives of the vast majority of the Bantu are regulated by superstition and witchcraft. They are deficient in the higher ethical sanctions and
34
A li A . A bdi moral standards associated with civilized religions. . . . Even supposing the rank and vile can appreciate the value of education, which they don’t, their poverty will make it impossible for them to provide the necessary funds to equip and maintain schools and pay teachers’ salaries. Everything depends, therefore, on the willingness and the financial capacity of the dominant white race to provide the necessary education facilities. (p. 149)
While Pells’s points are, ipso facto, devoid of any real meaning, they were still accepted and acknowledged (read Marx again) among the important historical and philosophical treatments of educational and social development in the colonial African context. For the sake of our analysis here though, I could be tempted to show the reader the high number of the on-the-surface errors (nothing hidden and analytically camouflaged) Pells commits in this short caption. Based on the pointers hitherto covered in this chapter, though, I refrain from doing that. Instead, I just mention that, perhaps, the historian’s statements would have made some sense if he had at least reminded us that one main trouble with the lives of the natives is that the same people (who Pells calls the dominant white race) who were, in the first place, responsible for robbing them of their resources, were now expected, via the twisted logic of colonizer-colonized relationships, to “humanely” come to the rescue of disenfranchised indigenous populations. Beyond the general demeaning and destruction of African philosophies and psycho-cultural realities of education, colonially imposed systems of learning were also deliberately built on a myriad of marginalizing and exclusionist policies that greatly limited the programs as well as the levels indigenous populations could aspire to. And if a select number of learners were able to go beyond the primary years, almost all were denied any further education. A good example would be that of the Congo where Belgium, as the colonial power “felt that higher levels of training for indigenous populations was bad policy, and thus when the Congo gained independence in 1960, there were only a handful of college graduates” (Altbach, 1994, p. 453). In the following section, I speak about new possibilities for African philosophies of education, but before I do that, let me insert an important qualification: while I have to be exacting, as much as possible, in holding colonialism and colonial education responsible for all the damage they have done to African philosophies and methodologies of learning, and by extension, to African overall livelihood situations, I must also state clearly that I am not calling for the shelving of current systems of learning and/or a total return to precolonial arrangements of knowledge dispensation.
African P hilosophies of Education
35
It is the case that we are now engaged in ex post facto discussions and analyses where, because the world of colonialism has irretrievably permeated that of indigenous population across the globe and current levels of interdependence are so intertwined and complex, a total separation of the two, even if it was desired, will be, for the time being, impractical, if not completely impossible. The new education systems I desire to see for the long-term and inclusive development of Africa and its peoples would actually combine so much that is excellent and still relevant from indigenous knowledge clusters with the au courant, mainly Western-oriented learning programs so as to harness the most effective outcomes for all.
African Philosophies of Education: Revival and Reconstitution Following the discussion on the very active space between European and African philosophies, let us now look at the situation relative to the postcolonial revivals and survivals of African philosophies of education. As should be expected, the total devaluations and attendant disenfranchisement of African philosophies and philosophies of education by the colonizers could not continue unchallenged forever. With the anticolonial struggles that shook colonialism to its foundations in Africa at the beginning of the second half of the twentieth century, therefore, it was also clear that the intellectual counterattack was intensifying in the new and emerging spaces of the anticolonial perspective. Among the pioneering African thinkers to engage the continuities of colonialism primarily in the language and culture theater, which are inextricably linked with education and development, was the Kenyan writer Ngugi wa Thiong’o who produced successive critical works that continued into the 1990s (see Ngugi wa Thiong’o, 1993, 1986, 1964). By combining his educational experiences in colonial Kenya with the actual unchallenged dominance, in all spheres of life, of European languages in post-political independent Africa, Ngugi wa Thiong’o immediately saw the triumph of Europe’s long-term linguistic, cultural, and educational projects. For Ngugi, critically defining and understanding how culture constructs language, and how, in turn, language defines culture was paramount in recasting new educational existentialities for the African people. Critically understanding these issues would immediately highlight, according to him, the urgent need to educate the African people in their mother tongues. For him, for example, language was more than a medium of expression, and meant so much to its native speakers.
A li A . A bdi
36
wa Thiong’o (1993) writes: [Our] language, through images and symbols, gave us a [unique] view of the world. . . . Then I went to primary school and the bond was broken. The language of my education was no longer the language of my culture—it was a foreign language of domination, alienation and disenfranchisement. (p. 13)
Reading Ngugi wa Thiong’o should imprint upon one’s intellectual and psychological imagination the need for a world where all peoples, cultures, languages and learning systems would be perpetually placed at the center. Even as I write this chapter, though, the power/knowledge nexus which is still greatly eschewed in favor of the European worldview is continually marginalizing the cosmos of the African people. So real is the case here that whatever literary and philosophical works are produced about African life and experiences by Africans, would not carry much weight globally if it were not published in the West, and may only be accepted in the extra-Africa sense, if its qualitative attributes were “authenticated” by an expert from the European metropolis. So problematic is this issue that Chinua Achebe (1989) had this to say about it: “Would it be truly invalid for a Nigerian writer seeing dissatisfaction in his society to write about it? I am being told, for Christ’s sake, that before I write about a problem I must verify whether they have it too in New York, London and Paris” (p. 96). The very important answer to Achebe’s question may have to be, and unfortunately so, in the affirmative. Hence, the premium we have to place on his recent call (Achebe, 2000) for a comprehensive project of rewriting and retelling of all the stories written by colonialism’s agents about Africa and its people. That would minimally recast the narrative damage done by the colonial project, thus helping Africans disentangle themselves from the web of a false, ontological wonderland that Fanon (1967) describes in Black skin, white masks, and restitute a bearable measure of self and psyche for the after-colonialism peoples of the old continent. Fanon’s project, as Ngugi wa Thiong’os, involves the prescription and dispensation of heavy doses of psycho-neurological anticolonial therapies and medications for decolonizing the mind, which becomes the sine qua non for the meaningful and long-term liberation of colonized populations. As Ashis Nandy (1997) reminds us, colonialism colonizes minds in addition to bodies and it releases forces within the colonized societies to alter their cultural priorities once and for all. In the process, it helps generalize the concept of the modern West
African P hilosophies of Education
37
from a geographical and temporal entity to a psychological category. The West is now everywhere, within the West and outside the West. (p. 170)
In addition to the descriptive and analytical recasting of African philosophies and epistemologies so they, at least, partially represent and define African systems of learning and possibilities of development, a parallel project that would also be counter-hegemonic in both its discursive and practical formation should be the revival of African indigenous knowledge systems. In fact, the reconstitution of African philosophies of education will not be complete without creating spaces and platforms of learning that are conducive to the promulgation of indigenous epistemes, with all critically important, for the long awaited but still elusive, possibilities of socioculturally inclusive development (see Ake, 1996). One academic who persistently and, I must say, convincingly calls for a concerted and long-term campaign to achieve these paramount intersections of African philosophical, cultural and indigenous-based projects of educational and social development is George Dei. In several critical interventions Dei (2000, 1998, 1996) prospectively reveals the urgent need for new platforms that situate indigenous knowledge on all the contours of Africa’s ongoing physical and mental decolonization. I like the way Dei elaborates on some of these points, so I want to quote him at some length (Dei, 2000): I argue for an approach to African development that is anchored in a retrieval, revitalization and restoration of the indigenous African sense of shared, sustainable, and just social values. I contend that African peoples must re-appropriate their cultural resource knowledge if they are to benefit from the power of collective responsibility for social development. Indigenousness may be defined as knowledge consciousness arising locally and in association with the long-term occupancy of a place. Indigenousness refers to the traditional norms, social values and mental constructs that guide, organize and regulate African ways of living in and making sense of the world. Indigenous knowledges differ from conventional knowledges in their absence of imperial and colonial imposition. The notion of indigenousness highlights the power of dynamics embedded in the production, interrogation, validation and dissemination of global knowledge about “international development.” It also recognizes the multiple and collective origins and collaborative dimensions of knowledge, and underscores that the interpretation or analysis of social reality is subject to different and sometimes oppositional perspectives. (p. 72)
The need to concretize the space between African educational and development systems is also emphasized by those who urge people to
38
A li A . A bdi
reexamine the need to re-culture African education so that it achieves the urgently needed development prospects for all. Again, the cultural components of African education and development would always remain components of the African people’s worldview and philosophies, and thus, will contribute to the new revivals of reawakening the continent’s excellent, precolonial (and to some extent, current) tradition of philosophical positions. It would also be the case that the reestablishment of Africa-oriented social and technological developments comprises a shift, not only in the concrete measurable aspects of the case, but as well, in the mindset of the African people who are not to be continuously relegated to the scrap heap of human progress. In that sense, we should welcome Kwasi Wiredu’s points (2000) when he writes: The quest for knowledge [and development] of any type is a characteristically human endeavor. In the changes and chances of human history some people may come to be ahead of others at some particular time in some particular area of investigation, but there is nothing to indicate that such situations must be permanent, and there is also no reason why any form of genuine knowledge should be attributed to any peoples in a proprietary sense. And what warrant is there for the pessimism that would permanently debar our imagination from foreseeing Africa as an eventual theatre of state-of-the-art science and technology, yielding ground to none in the advancement of scientific knowledge for the promotion of human well being? (pp. 181–182)
With precolonial, traditional African education having been so effectively endowed both philosophically and epistemologically, and the overall Africa project now surviving on the margins of educational and definitional systems that are more marginalizing than otherwise, it is high time that we reconstitute new platforms and intersections of learning and attach development possibilities that once again center the philosophies, cultures, as well as the methodologies of the continent. To achieve that, I would hasten to add, we should develop a new sense of postcolonial thinking and programs that recognize, accept, and operationalize so much that can be harvested from the use of these philosophies of education, which, as mentioned earlier, should not be isolationists, but combine the worldview, value systems, and ways of knowing that emanate from Africa with the best from modern systems of learning. Needless to add that in the new, quasi-hybrid educational and knowledge formations, African epistemes and philosophies of learning should be recognized as being at par if not more advanced in relation to their effectiveness in explaining the current problems of African
A frican P hilosophies of E ducation
39
development, and, by extension, in prescribing reliable ways of achieving better livelihood prospects for the people.
Conclusion My focus in this chapter has been to inform about, and equally problematize, the place of African education and philosophies of education in relation to the project of colonial and postcolonial marginalization that the continent and its people have experienced in the last 200 years. I have stated the fact that precolonial, traditional Africa has had highly developed and effective learning programs and attached philosophies of education that have contextually situated and explained the realities, needs, as well as the aspirations of the African people in different epochs of their history. As discussed earlier, these projects of educational and social development have been destroyed by colonizing Europe, with the main objective of diminishing the value of African ways of life so as to ontologically damage people’s overall existentialities, and, in the process, achieve an unhindered, maximally exploiting colonial march that assures the theoretically concocted superiority of everything that represented the colonizer. The results of these diabolic programs are still with us, and the case of an Africa that is highly underdeveloped vis-à-vis the rest of the world is not a natural accident, but entirely a historic project that has been highly efficient. It is to counter and reverse the current, expansive trends of marginalization that I am calling for the urgent need to revive African educational and philosophical systems, without which, a project of horizontal social development may not be achieved.
References Abdi, A. (1998). Education in Somalia: History, destruction, and calls for reconstruction. Comparative Education, 34 (3), 327–340. Abdi, A. (2002). Culture, education and development in South Africa: Historical and contemporary perspectives. Westport, CT & London: Bergin & Garvey. Achebe, C. (1958). Things fall apart. London: Heinemann. Achebe, C. (1989). Hopes and impediments: Selected essays. New York: Doubleday. Achebe, C. (2000). Home and exile. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Ake, C. (1996). Democracy and development in Africa. Washington, D.C.: The Brookings Institution. Altbach, P. (1994). Education and neocolonialism. In B. Ashcroft, G. Griffiths and H. Tiffin (Eds.), The post-colonial studies reader (pp. 452–456). New York: Routledge.
40
Ali A . Abdi
Cahn, S. (1997). Classic and contemporary readings in the philosophy of education. Toronto: McGraw-Hill. Cesaire, A. (1972). Discourse on colonialism. New York: Monthly Review Press. Dei, G. (1996). Anti-racism education: Theory and practice. Halifax: Fernwood Publishing. Dei, G. (1998). Local knowledges and educational reforms in Ghana. Canadian and International Education, 29 (1), 37–51. Dei, G. (2000). “African development: The relevance and implications of ‘indigenousness.’ ” In G. Dei, B. Hall and D.G. Rosenberg (Eds.), Indigenous knowledges in global contexts: Multiple readings of our world (pp. 70–88). Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Dewey, J. (1963). Experience and education. New York: Collier Books. Dewey, J. (1969). School and society. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Diop, C.A. (1974). African origins of civilization: Myth or reality. Brooklyn, NY: Lawrence Hill Books. Diop, C.A. (1990). Civilization or barbarism: An authentic anthropology. Brooklyn, NY: Lawrence Hill Books. Fanon, F. (1967). Black skin, white masks. New York: Grove Press. Fanon, F. (1968). The wretched of the earth. New York: Grove Press. Freire, P. (2000 [1970]). Pedagogy of the oppressed. New York: Continuum. Freire, P. (2002 [1974]). Education for critical consciousness. New York: Continuum. Hegel, G.W.F. (1965). La raison dans L’ histoire. Paris: U.G.E. Jackson, J. (1970). Introduction to African civilizations. Secaucus, NJ: The Citadel Press. Kallaway, P. (1984). An introduction to the study of education of blacks in South Africa. In P. Kallaway (Ed.), Apartheid and education: The education of Black South Africans (pp. 2–3). Braamfontein: Ravan Press. Keto, T. (1990). Pre-industrial education policies and practices in South Africa. In M. Nkomo (Ed.), Pedagogy of domination: Toward democratic education in South Africa (pp. 19–42). Trenton, NJ: Africa World Press. Memmi, A. (1991). The colonizer and the colonized. Boston: Beacon Press. Montesquieu, B. (1975). The spirit of the laws. New York: Hafner Press. Nandy, A. (1997). The decolonization of the mind. In M. Rahnema and V. Bowtree (Eds.), The post-development reader (pp. 168–177). London: Zed Books. Nyerere, J. (1968). Freedom and socialism: A selection from writing and speeches, 1965–67. London: Oxford University Press. Nyerere, J. (1974). Man and development. New York: Oxford University Press. Ozmon, H. and Craver, S. (1998). Philosophical foundations of education. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. p’Bitek, O. (1972). Reflect, reject, recreate. East Africa Journal, IX (4), 28–31. Pells, E.G. (1970 [1930]). 300 years of South African education. Westport: Greenwood Press.
A frican P hilosophies of E ducation
41
Rodney, W. (1982). How Europe underdeveloped Africa. Washington, D.C.: Howard University Press. Semali, L. (1999). Community as classroom: Dilemmas of valuing African indigenous literacy in education. International Review of Education, 45 (3/4), 305–319. van Sertima, I. (1991). The lost sciences of Africa. In V. Sertima (Ed.), Blacks in science: Ancient and modern (pp. 7–26). New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books. Voltaire (1826). Essai sur les Moeurs. Paris: S.N. wa Thiong’o, N. (1964). Weep not, child. London: Heinemann. wa Thiong’o, N. (1986). Decolonising the mind: The politics of language in African literature. London: James Curry. wa Thiong’o, N. (1993). Moving the center: The struggle for cultural freedoms. London: James Curry. Wiredu, K. (2000). Our problem of knowledge: Brief reflections on knowledge and development in Africa. In I. Karp and D. Masolo (Eds.), African philosophy as cultural inquiry (pp. 181–186). Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
This page intentionally left blank
3
National “Development” and African U niversities: A Theoretical and Sociopolitical Analysis Korbla P. Puplampu
T
he national “development” question continues to draw attention in several African countries. The attention stems from the failure of policies to address the political, economic, and social malaise of Africa. Politically, even though some countries are on the road to political stability, several are still grappling with problems of political succession and uncertainty. The region’s economic fortunes are still tied to prices in the international commodities markets while industrial output has to contend with new tariff regimes in several European countries, their major trading partners. The implications of the political and economic difficulties can be seen in the continuing worsening social conditions—the images of the emaciated children and adults—in the region. Given the prevailing conditions, it is not surprising that several African countries are located at the lower end of the United Nations Development Program’s (UNDP) annual Human Development Index (see UNDP, 2003). However, governments in the region continue to fight the battle for improving national development, sometimes with the help of their foreign counterparts, international public, private, for-profit and nonprofit institutions, by forging new policy initiatives to shore up the work of several important institutions. Institutions of higher education, specifically universities and colleges have been at the center of attention in the task of national development. Universities, among other things, create and disseminate the skills and values required for successful participation
44
K orbl a P. P upl ampu
in the economy. They also provide the context for the transmission of culture from one generation to the other. International financial and development institutions like the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) and the World Bank have been at the forefront in initiating worldwide policies for higher education, and in some cases, specifically for African countries (UNESCO, 1992, 1994, 2003; World Bank, 1988a, 1988b, 1994, 2000). In addition to these external documents, African authorities, sometimes in cooperation with external institutions, have also generated a number of policy documents to guide the restructuring of higher education. Of particular importance is the Association of African Universities’ 2001 Nairobi Declaration on the African University in the Third Millennium (Association of African Universities [AAU], 2001). The policy focus on institutions of higher education, specifically universities, is due to historical and contemporary reasons. From the historical context, development theorists and practitioners presented universities as major players in ensuring that the logic of the nation-state also became one of national development. Indeed, when modernization theories in the 1950s and 1960s equated national development to industrialization and urbanization, among other processes, the explicit and implicit mandate of national universities was to produce the human capital required for the development effort. The more graduates national universities turned out, the better the chances of the nation attaining the goals of development. That, at least, was the assumption. University graduates, with their unique and specialized training, were therefore critical in the modernizing effort of colonized societies and occupied an important space in the national development program. Universities, in discharging their role in national development, were also tied to the nation-state. Modernization theory that also went hand in hand with the Keynesian model that dominated development theory in the 1950s and 1960s, favored a strong centralized state in economic development (Galli, 1992, p. 5; Hettne, 1991, pp. 49–50). Thus the state funded universities in the name of national development. Analysts also privileged the role of the state in universities because of the free rider nature of education.1 To further demonstrate the intricate relationship between the state and universities and the implications for national development, several governments attached the name of the nation-state to their universities (e.g., University of Malawi, University of Nigeria, and the University of Zambia). In the contemporary context, there is an interest in higher education for two major reasons. First, many African universities continue to
National “Development ”
45
depend on the state for their financial support, in some cases to the tune of 90 percent of their funding requirements (Amonoo-Neizer, 1998, p. 301). The declining capacity of the African state, particularly since the 1980s, therefore has implications for the financial needs of African universities. The second reason is the theoretical implications of globalization for the restructuring of African universities, particularly the differentiation of academic institutions and laborers, and the growing importance of knowledge production for national development. Since universities are knowledge-producing centers, the question for African universities is not whether they should produce knowledge for national development, but whether they have the capacity to produce that knowledge in an era of globalization (Hoppers, 2003; Okolie, 2003; Teferra and Altbach, 2004, 2003; World Bank, 2002; Zeleza, 2003). This study focuses on African universities in the contemporary context. The emerging analysis of the growing literature provides a litany of problems facing African universities (see African Studies Association, 2002; Bollag, 2002; Masinda, 2003; Nyamnjoh and Jua, 2002; Samoff and Carrol, 2004; Sawyerr, 2004, 1996; Teferra and Altbach, 2004, 2003; Tettey and Puplampu, 2000). The problems include access to higher education, the emergence of private universities, lack of funding, and the implications for physical and human resources as well as the knowledge-producing capabilities. Other problems include the unpleasant battle academics and students have been waging with their governments, confrontations that sometimes affect their physical safety. Despite the growing literature on the fate of African universities in an era of global restructuring, the literature is yet to confront the changing conditions of academic laborers and institutional differentiation, and the implications for the undergraduate teaching mandate of African universities.2 In what follows, the literature on the contemporary state of African universities is briefly examined and situated in a broader global context. The subsequent section offers a theoretical analysis of the changing conditions of academic laborers in the midst of the restructuring and differentiation of universities. The final section will focus on the politics of academic restructuring and undergraduate teaching, and offer some policy suggestions to improve the work of African universities.
African Universities and Globalization: An Overview Globalization is marked by several factors due to and stemming from the dramatic improvements in communications technologies which have given rise to the compression of time and space (see Giddens,
46
K orbl a P. P upl ampu
1990). The compression of time and space has led to significant changes in political, economic and sociocultural relationships among nation-states (see Burbules and Torres, 2000a; Hoogvelt, 2001; Schuurman, 2001). The political aspects of globalization include a minimal involvement of the state in the economic and social spheres and, with that, “at least the erosion of national autonomy” (Burbules and Torres, 2000b, p. 14), and the rise of powerful non-state actors or forprofit nongovernmental organizations within and beyond national boundaries. The economic aspects of the process can be seen in the increased emphasis on market transactions, an internationalized system of production aided by the enhanced mobility of financial capital due to the dramatic improvements in computerization and telecommunications. Cultural globalization aims at the harmonization of standards and the homogenization of tastes, supposedly, with the emergence of a global culture. Of great significance to this study are the implications of globalization for African universities. Analysts within the Euro-American and Australasia contexts have examined the relationship between globalization and education in general and higher education in particular (Barrow, Didou-Aupetit and Mallea, 2003; Burbules and Torres, 2000a; Currie and Newson, 1998; Currie et al., 2003; Slaughter and Leslie, 1997; White and Hauck, 2000). Morrow and Torres (2000), identify two aspects of globalization for education significant to the current study: “the changed role of the state . . . ” and, the “pressures to develop educational policies that attempt to restructure postsecondary educational systems along entrepreneurial lines in order to provide flexible educational responses to the new model of industrial production” (Morrow & Torres, 2000, p. 35). Slaughter and Leslie (1997, p. 31) also point to the fact that the changes under globalization “are putting pressure on national higher education policy makers to change the way tertiary education does business.” The authors also identify an increasing reliance on technoscience and those areas of study closely aligned with the market; a tightening of the relationship between multinational corporations and state agencies concerned with research, development, and innovation; and multinationals and their quest to secure global intellectual property rights (pp. 36–37). The profound shifts in the power and profit orientations within institutions of higher learning constitute the hallmarks of what Slaughter and Leslie (1997) call “academic capitalism” (see also Press and Washburn, 2000; Slaughter and Leslie, 2000). Beyond the Euro-American and Australasia contexts, the literature on the restructuring of African universities in an era of globalization is
National “Development ”
47
also growing (Mkandawire, 1997; Samoff, 1999; Samoff and Carrol, 2004; Sawyerr, 2004; Tettey and Puplampu, 2000). Schugurensky (1999) examines the international trends in the higher educational systems in developing countries and acknowledges the fact that every developing nation, just as the developed ones, will have a unique set of political, economic, historical, sociocultural forces that will impact higher education. However, Schugurensky identifies a number of processes common to the restructuring of higher education in developing nations. These include “commodification of knowledge,” the “redefinition of the relationship between the university, the state and the market, and a drastic reduction in institutional autonomy” (Schugurensky, 1999, p. 283). As far as education in Africa is concerned, the World Bank has emphasized the rate of return on education (RORE) (World Bank, 2000, p. 39; see also Psacharopoulos, 1991). The RORE represents an attempt to use a market-compatible rationale of state expenditures on education. The World Bank has concluded that the social RORE on primary, secondary, and tertiary education are 24 percent, 18 percent, and 11 percent respectively (Mkandawire and Soludo, 1999, p. 46). Since higher education offers a lower RORE, the argument is that it is not worth supporting. This conclusion, in part, explains the World Bank’s current emphasis on basic education and the “neglect of secondary and tertiary education in many, [African and other] developing countries” (World Bank, 2000, p. 16). Meanwhile, the World Bank’s analysis of RORE has been questioned (Banya, 2001). Ndoye (1997) highlights the following features of global education in Africa: economism, privatization, and loss of identity. The argument for economism and privatization is premised on the declining role of the state and the associated economic difficulties, hence the view “that the solution is to privatize education” (Ndoye, 1997, p. 80). With respect to the loss of identity, Ndoye (1997) demonstrates the hegemonic dimensions of the culture transmitted by the international media. Since educational institutions are also producing culture, the difficulties in sustaining education in Africa suggest that other institutions, and in this context, the international media, would play a vital role. The international media, as Ndoye (1997) further shows and correctly so, are not international in their depiction of culture. Rather, they transmit local issues on a global basis, hence the hegemonic aspect of the cultural aspect of the media explosion. The hegemonic aspects of knowledge construction in general, and the role of African intellectuals and universities in particular, have also been addressed by
48
K orbl a P. P upl ampu
several analysts (see e.g., Emeagwali, 2002; Tettey and Puplampu, 2000). Against the global context, higher education in Africa has to deal with three major related features: chronic funding problems, significant increases in student enrolment, and declines in the quality of teaching and research. Even though funding for higher education, compared to other sectors in the African economy, has been relatively low, the situation has been worsened by the current neoliberal argument for reductions in government subsidies to higher education (Atteh, 1996; Morna, 1995; Saint, 1992; UNESCO, 2003). Overall, the percentage of allocation of public expenditure on higher education has declined in many sub-Saharan African countries. According to the World Bank and UNESCO, the decreases have been $6,300, to $1,500 and $1,241 for 1980, 1988, and 1995 respectively (cited in UNESCO, 2003:6). For example, in Malawi, the educational budget for the University of Malawi, which was 25 percent between 1972 and 1979, declined to 16.4 percent by 1988 (cited in Kerr and Mapanje, 2002, p. 85). The Government of Ghana, at the beginning of the 1990s, decided to limit higher education’s share of the budget to 17 percent in order to increase cost recovery (Eisemon and Holm-Nielsen, 1995). Between 1990 and 1991, the University of Zambia received 79 percent of its funding request, while the University of Ghana and Makerere University received 53 percent and 34 percent of their funding requests respectively (Saint, 1992, p. 36). The funding situation did not show any improvement, even in the latter part of the 1990s. For example, in 1994–1995 and 1998–1999, Makerere University “got only 49.8 percent of proposed recurrent and 6.7 percent of capital budgets” (Kasozi, 2002, p. 127). At the time of reductions in state funding, enrolments in African universities have increased due, in part, to government pressure to admit more students and the growing demand for and realization by society at large about the importance of higher education. Enrolment in African universities as a whole increased from 417,000 in 1980 to 1.4 million in 1995 (UNESCO, 1998, p. 41). For example, the University of Yaoundé, Cameroon had 500 in 1960, but by 1992 had 45,000 students with the facilities that were planned for 5,000 (Morna, 1995, p. 31). In Ghana, for example, university students were about 11,000 in the early 1990s, representing an increase from between 8,000 and 8,500 in the 1980s (Peil, 1996, p. 52). The ultimate impact of the above features is the mass exodus of academic staff, the trying conditions under which those remaining have to work and decline in the quality of teaching and research in many African universities
National “Development ”
49
(Eisemon and Davis, 1991; Land, 1994; Tettey, 2002; Tettey and Puplampu, 2000). The changing nature of public universities in Africa has given rise to the emergence of private universities. Private universities have a long history in other parts of the world, for example, the United States and Latin American subregions. In the case of Africa, their origins can be attributed to or are a response to the dire economic circumstances since the 1970s, a weakening state, and globalization (Ekhaguere, 2000, p. 376). Religious institutions are the key players in the establishment of private universities in Africa. The United Methodist Church established the African University in Zimbabwe, while Protestant, Catholic, and Islamic affiliated universities can be found in Kenya, Tanzania, Uganda, and Zaire (Banya, 2001; Kasozi, 2002, pp. 125–127; World Bank, 2000, pp. 29–31). Two privately owned Seminaries are also providing university education in Ghana (Sawyerr, 1994, p. 25). In total, nine private universities have been established in Uganda since 1998 (Kasozi, 2002, p. 128). Several issues can be identified from the emerging theoretical literature on higher education and globalization. These include the role of the state and non-state actions in the production, distribution, and consumption of public and private education; the role of labor in the production process; the importance of market and nonmarket transactions. The above processes have critical implications for the future of higher education in Africa. For example, declining state expenditure on higher education as mentioned earlier, are occurring against the backdrop of government officials stressing the need to create and have a knowledgeable community and acknowledging the role of universities in that process. The increases in enrolment also attest to the argument that university education is a key prerequisite for effective participation in the global economy. If universities provide the requisite training for most jobs, then, it can be argued that they present a vital link in the process of creating that knowledgeable community needed for effective participation in the global economy. The increases in enrolment have to be reconciled with the financial uncertainties of the diminishing capacity of the state. This has given rise to the state deregulating higher education and the growing desire by many African universities to explore “the diversification of sources of funding, including cost-sharing initiatives” (AAU, 2001, p. 8). This is the context for the introduction of tuition fees in many, if not all, African universities (Woodhall, 1995). The next section offers a theoretical discussion of the differentiation of universities and the changing conditions of academic laborers.
50
K orbl a P. P upl ampu
The Differentiation of Institutions and Academic Laborers: A Theoretical Analysis Academic laborers and learners are the main actors in the teaching of undergraduate learners and the nature of their relationship is essential to learning outcomes. A critical requirement for the successful operation of any institution is resource flows and how those resources, in turn, are utilized to meet the goals of the organization. The availability and conditions of access to resources would influence the quantity and quality of knowledge that is produced and its relevance to the needs of the wider community. The restructuring of universities has led to the emergence of “new type of institutions . . . and new providers” (World Bank, 2000, p. 16) and changes in “who the faculty are, how they behave, the way they are organized, and the way they work and are compensated” (World Bank, 1988b, p. 22). At issue are the emergence of private universities alongside the public ones and the changing nature of academic labor and laborers. The logic behind the emergence of private universities is both ideological and pragmatic. On the former plane, a major argument of the restructuring exercise is to reduce the role of state institutions, because apart from their monopolistic position, political considerations influence the allocation and reward for goods and services. Furthermore, the diminishing capacity of the state and its commitment to funding higher education, calls for other actors to replace the reducing influence and commitment of the state in higher education. Thus on a pragmatic level, Eisemon contends that private higher education “in African countries can help to accommodate some of the social demand for higher education and to diversify university systems and, thus, merits encouragement by governments” (cited in Woodhall, 1995, p. 21). Private universities, Banya (2001, p. 162) argues, also “can deflect student demand away from public institutions under growing financial pressures, while perhaps saving money for other social services” (Banya, 2001, p. 162). The above propositions, it seems are assumed rather than empirically demonstrated. Theoretically, the flurry of private universities at the time when state capacity is on the decline suggests the inability of the state to offer a policy framework that would regulate their activities, let alone enforce existing policies. Since private universities emerged within the market logic, the added question is whether the market alone, without the state policy framework, can guarantee the quality of university education. Kasozi (2002, p. 124) therefore argues that the “state government
National “Development ”
51
should not leave the operation of the private university system entirely to market forces but must regulate key areas in order to strengthen the higher education system for the good of society.” It is obvious that while private universities can fill the void in public universities, their market underpinnings also means they are likely to sacrifice quality for profit and the larger society would be the eventual loser. Furthermore, the market logic of private universities in particular, and the restructuring exercise in general, within the metaphor of learners as “clients” or “consumers” in friendly market situations and making rational choices raises some questions. How would the implied “but not always stated . . . presumption that in higher education as in any other purchasing transaction, the customer is always right” (Banya, 2001, p. 170) be reconciled with the nature of knowledge and the quality of higher education? Put differently, if the market assumption that customers are always right is taken to its logical conclusion, how would that affect the relationship between academic laborers as knowledge producers and learners as consumers of knowledge? Knowledge is a contested phenomenon and the value of knowledge has implications for power relations. For the market argument that customers are always right to be valid in the restructured universities, it means learners can contest and always win battles over how they are evaluated. While the process appears liberating for learners, it can also, in some extreme cases, become constraining. Chomsky (in White, 2000, p. 450) recounts the case of an undergraduate student [who] refused to answer a question on an exam in [a] computer science department and when he was asked why, he said that he was under a condition set by a professor with whom he was working. He knew the answer, he said, but the answer was worked out in some project on which he was working under some professor who was intending to begin a startup company which would use the research they were doing and didn’t want anybody to know about it. (see also Berman, 1998; Press and Washburn, 2000)
In such an environment, inter-faculty sharing of ideas would be kept to the minimum and so also would be faculty–student dialogue. The ultimate effect is that the knowledge pool that could emerge through vigorous dialogue would become poorer. For society at large, the social good, for instance, that universities serve would be in serious jeopardy. The “subversive character” (Chomsky in White, 2000, p. 442) of universities is more likely to be undermined if the value of knowledge is predicated entirely on this market value.
52
K orbl a P. P upl ampu
This is because a successful market commodity does not necessarily mean a quality product. But more importantly, once universities cease being “subversive,” there is the possibility that the knowledge they produce cannot be interrogated and its critical edge cannot be realized and that would likely give rise to a docile, compliant, and uncritical citizenry (see Aronowitz, 2000). The implied powerlessness of academic laborers, reduced to clerks selling knowledge, would also damage the integrity of universities as institutions of higher learning. The establishment of a private university does not amount to a complete termination of state financial support. Even in other jurisdictions, for example, in the United States of America where some of the leading universities are private, the government continues to fund some research activities. The situation is not different in other countries, even if at a diminishing rate (World Bank, 1994). The continued role of the state in financing university education, however, raises some questions. What would the funding of private universities mean for the public ones? What areas of training are the state likely to fund in either public or private universities and why? The underlying issue is the extent to which the university, as an institution would provide the needed resources for academic laborers to produce the knowledge relevant to the needs of learners and the society at large. Two related problems can be identified. These are the low salaries and deteriorating conditions of service for academic laborers and the paucity of academic laborers. For example, between 1986 and 1992, wages had not risen for faculty in Nigerian universities, despite a 95 percent devaluation of the national currency and over 100 percent inflation (Atteh, 1996, p. 37). Land (1994, pp. 1–2) portrays the situation in many universities in Africa as one in which “[d]windling education budgets have sharply eroded staff salaries, making it hard for universities to compete in national and regional labour markets . . . cutbacks in library purchases, equipment and building maintenance, forcing many members to leave. Educational quality is dropping.” This state of affairs has led to institutional instabilities, most noticeable in the frequent and often prolonged closure of African universities. For instance, the “entire Nigerian university was closed for most of 1992 and 1996 as faculty members” (Bollag, 2002, p. A39) waged battles with government over working conditions. In such an environment, academic pursuits take a second seat as academics engage in other economic activities. Those who cannot function in such an environment vote with their feet, hence the worsening mass exodus of academics in many African universities (AAU, 2001, p. 7; Tettey, 2002). Thus, academic laborers are in short supply in the
National “Development ”
53
continent, making it increasingly difficult for the plethora of private universities to recruit and retain the requisite staff (Banya, 2001; Jua and Nyamnjoh, 2002). The impact of the working conditions, mass exodus of academic staff, and the scarcity of personnel “has seen a reduced and increasingly unequal access to education, and a decline in educational quality” (McGinn, 1997, p. 43). Decline in the quality of higher education when the need for knowledge for development is immense calls for an analysis of the potential and the nature of the knowledge production capabilities of African universities. Underlying such an analysis is the politics of knowledge production, propagation, and commodification. To a large extent, knowledge has always being commodified. However, under the current regime there is a conscious attempt by the academy to forge “much closer links with industry and, as a consequence, a move to more applied research agendas with the accompanying loss in curiousity driven research” (Currie, 1998, p. 4). It is therefore not surprising that African universities have decided to “strengthen their linkages with the productive sector, private and public, . . . in order to increase the relevance of their work and to ensure its easy infusion into production for the benefit of society and the economy” (AAU, 2001, p. 8). The issue here is the emergence of private actors (both nonprofit and for-profit) institutions to fill the vacuum left by the state and contribute to knowledge production and propagation. One implication of the closer link between academy and industry is that the emphasis will be placed on business, science, and technology. Technology, for example, is being touted as the panacea for enhancing the knowledge production capacities and responding to increasing university enrolments. To be sure, a number of African universities now have access to the new information technologies, such as the internet, even if access is limited and the systems are unreliable. The African Virtual University (AVU), for example, is one such effort spearheaded by the World Bank (Ekhaguere, 2000; World Bank, 1998). The aim is to equip African universities with computers to enhance the training of students. What is remarkable about the AVU is the areas of training being emphasized— engineers, business managers, and health care providers (World Bank, 1998, p. 2). The intention is not to minimize the significance of the study areas being emphasized. However, it can also be argued those areas emphasized provide tangible expressions of relevance in terms of contributions to society and are also easily commodified. Such thinking partially accounts for the establishment of a new university in Northern Malawi “mostly geared to commercial and tourism studies” (Kerr and Mapanje, 2002, p. 87).
54
K orbl a P. P upl ampu
What is missing is an attempt to draw any linkages between the social and natural sciences. The social sciences, either justifiable or unjustifiable have not been able to command a lot of clout as far as social relevance is concerned (Tettey and Puplampu, 2000). It is correct to note “that science and technology professionals are a key ingredient in . . . economic rejuvenation. They cannot, however, achieve that objective without any input from their counterparts in the social sciences and humanities whose expertise is particularly necessary for the creation of the enabling environment within which technological and economic progress for all can take place” (Tettey, 2002). A serious study of the human condition in any part of the world should demand an adequate understanding of sociocultural processes (Verhelst, 1990). By paying little attention to the social sciences in the restructuring process, there is an omission that would have serious implications for crafting policies that address the nuances of sociocultural processes and thus offer a better chance of making a meaningful impact. The preceding discussion underscores the fact that many universities in Africa are operating at varying levels of differentiation. The result is that the local knowledge production capacity has been undermined. Consequently, knowledge produced from external sources is more likely to assume a prominent place. Although knowledge production about a society is not a monopoly of local experts, the continuation of a situation in which local knowledge producers are not able to produce the requisite knowledge suggests an increasing reliance on external sources of knowledge. It is no wonder that consultancy by foreign experts is a big business in Africa, with $10 billion being spent on about forty thousand foreign experts in 1997 (Mkandawire, 1997, p. 17). The problem with such a trend is, on one hand whether external sources of knowledge would be adequately anchored in the nuances of the local culture and thus be socially relevant (Dei, 1995; Hountondji, 1995; Verhelst, 1990). On the other hand, relevance of eternal knowledge, mediated by the market, would be premised on the ability to pay for a given knowledge. The widespread poverty in several African countries would affect the ability to pay, hence the access to any useful knowledge. The issue is not the inability of local African experts to produce knowledge. Some Western social scientists have acknowledged the significant contributions of African scholars to studies on imperialism, economic restructuring, and regime transitions (see also Hettne, 1991; cited in Jua and Nyamnjoh, 2002, p. 51). Rather, it is the implications of globalization for the dynamics of knowledge production at the local (national or regional) and global levels. Two contradictory forces are at
National “Development ”
55
play in the ongoing process. The breaking down of national boundaries implicit within globalization engenders the theoretical possibility that knowledge production would assume a universal posture and relevance. However, in view of the hierarchization of knowledge at the global level, it would be naïve to expect that knowledge production sites in the North, when producing knowledge, would have as their focus issues or problems in a remote community in the South. The reality is that under globalization, commodification of knowledge and the consequent emphasis on profit are the prime features of the knowledge industry. There is an ongoing hierarchization of knowledge production at the global level in which certain brands of knowledge, especially those produced in the North, are ascribed as dominant relative to that produced in the South (Dei, 1998; Tettey and Puplampu, 2000). If local universities were not able to produce sufficient and quality knowledge because of shortage of human capital and other resources, the hierarchy and marginalization would be further reinforced. In the new dispensation, the emerging actors in the knowledge industry are multinational corporations (MNC) and the increasing importance of global institutions like World Trade Organization (WTO) (Altbach, 2001).
Academic Restructuring: The Politics of the New Pedagogy With higher institutions starved of cash, the extent to which public and private universities, their academic laborers and learners working together would improve the quality of undergraduate teaching depends on the allocation and conditions of access to available resources. The major issue here is how the interaction between the state, the historical guardian of the public good, and non-state actors would affect the future direction of higher education. The reality is that with declining state (public) funding, universities and colleges do not hesitate to solicit funds from non-state actors (private), some of which are for-profit organizations. While the academy and industry need one another, the interaction has to contend with significant problems, due largely to differences in their mandate (Tettey and Puplampu, 2000). The increases in enrolment in African universities establish not only the importance of university education to individuals, but to society as a whole. However, given the declining rate of funding, enrolment increases, and the exodus of academic laborers, it is important to analyze the implications of global restructuring for higher education in Africa. At the national level (the local), the increases in higher education in several African universities attest to the power of social forces
56
K orbl a P. P upl ampu
on political authorities. Social forces have pressured their political authorities to expand access to higher education and the authorities, in turn, have simply asked the universities to increase their intake, but without the commensurate increases in resources. The predictable result has been the myriad problems that African universities have to contend with. The private universities, as nascent institutions in the region, are yet to make any meaningful impact on the educational aspirations of potential university students. This is because private universities, like the public ones, have to compete for the same shrinking pool of available academic laborers. The reality of unlimited resources for both public and private universities suggests differences also in outcomes for their learners. The relationship between educators and learners and its social relevance deserve greater scrutiny, in the context of restructuring, if learning is to offer any measure of critical education (Giroux and McLaren, 1989; McLaren, 1998; Morrow and Torres, 1995). The need for critical education in a time of restructuring stems from the belief that it is “[i]rrevocably committed to the side of the oppressed . . . [along with the belief that] liberation is an authentic goal, and a radically different world can be brought into being” (McLaren, 1998, p. 164). For the restructuring of African universities to be of any relevance to educators and learners and the society at large, it should have the potential to speak to the present, everyday lived experiences as well as fairness in the relationship between the university and the larger society. That calls for a certain direction in the restructuring program. Educators would have to vary their teaching methods, move away from the notion of having monopoly over knowledge and power, since their knowledge is legitimized by the political (read the state) and sociocultural arrangements of the day. It is important to stress that the state, in an age of globalization, may seem “to be losing its power, although, and this is essential, not its influence” (Castells, 1997, p. 243). This suggests that political considerations would continue to shape the nature of the African academy, sometimes, with devastating consequences for knowledge production (see Jua and Nyamnjoh, 2002). It is also possible that with the state losing its power, in a relative sense, to legitimize the knowledge and power of educators, the market would become the decisive factor in the legitimization process. In that scenario, it would be easy for educators to dismiss the experiences of the learners, more so, if those experiences do not enhance the market value of the knowledge the educator seeks to create. If the sale of knowledge is predicated on the authoritative voice or knowledge of the educator, then it might be difficult for learners to raise
National “Development ”
57
questions that might be seen as undermining the market value of the educator’s work. There is already a constant battle between educators and learners, especially when it comes to deriving meaning from, giving voice to as well as acknowledging the varied experiences of learners. The willingness and ability of educators to change the structure and form of the learning process is key in the reconstruction of a mutually beneficial relationship. That relationship, if properly managed can produce critically minded learners, who are able to propose alternate visions of society. Globalization of higher education is exposing African universities to international students, especially from North American universities where study abroad programs in Africa are being encouraged (Pires, Marajh and Metzler, 2000). With a different learning style, a faculty member in an African university “indicated that American students bring to the university classroom a healthy ‘disrespect’ for the dominant ‘culture of silence’ [thus encouraging] African students to be less ‘passive’ and intellectually accepting” (Metzler, 2000, p. 16). If such interactions between African and American students would bring about positive changes not only in learning, but also in attitudes and perceptions about Africa abroad, then it is a development that needs to be cherished and nurtured. However, if the study in Africa programs stem from the desire to address the financial shortfalls in African universities, then a critical opportunity for genuine intercultural understanding would have been sacrificed at the altar of the market god.
Conclusion This study examined the restructuring of higher education in Africa. The chapter discussed the emergence of differential institutions and trends toward the commodification of and politics of knowledge propagation. With regard to the new relationship between educators and learners, the paper argues that such a relationship, grounded on market imperatives, would be without the edge that is necessary for the creation of critical knowledge communities. The findings of this study provide some insights into policy and other theoretical questions concerning the restructuring of African universities. Differentiated institutions would lead to different levels of commitment to the academic enterprise. With worsening economic conditions, the restructuring is bringing to the fore the issue of quality of university education in Africa. If the quality of university education is eroded, the long-term implication would be the growth of the consultancy industry in which Northern-based intellectuals would assume monopoly over
58
K orbl a P . Pupl ampu
the knowledge industry. Such knowledge, however, can be expensive and, as the paper argues, cannot be nuanced enough for addressing the local conditions. The need to share knowledge is critical, the terms of that sharing amidst the hierarchization of knowledge and power differences in the global arena are issues that need to be addressed. The structural location of Africa in the global political economy suggests that the restructuring of higher education would have a differential impact on African countries. Consequently, educational policy analysts need to sharpen their tools in order to address the intricacies of market policies, and to pay attention to context and structure and outcomes. The issue, as indicated earlier, is not the inability of African universities to produce knowledge. It is rather the assumption that they have to produce marketable knowledge, even though a successful market commodity tells us nothing about the social relevance of the product. Since education remains an integral part of the development process in any nation and if “education is a political economic and socio-cultural act, then all facets of the academic establishment and the wider society need to get involved” (Puplampu, 2004, 181) in the restructuring program. Indeed, the nature of the changes in university education could well provide us with the contours of humanity in our current globalized and increasingly commodified twenty-first-century society.
Notes 1. Developed by Olson (1965), the free-rider problem explains individual rational behavior in relationship to the benefits of public goods that are available to everyone, irrespective of their level of contribution. The theoretical problem here is the limits of human rationality. 2. For some international studies on the differentiation of academic institutions and laborers see Puplampu (2004), Pocklington and Tupper (2002), and Rajagopal (2002).
References Association of African Universities (AAU) (2001). AAU Newsletter. Special Issue, Vol. 6, No. 3, March 1–7. African Studies Association (ASA) (2002). Special Issue—African Universities in Crisis and the Promotion of a Democratic Culture. African Studies Review, 45 (2), 1–218. Altbach, P.G. (2001). Higher education and the WTO: Globalization run amok. International Higher Education, 23, Spring, 2–4. Amonoo-Neizer, E.H. (1998). Universities in Africa: The need for adaptation, transformation, reformation and revitalization. Higher Education Policy, 11 (4), 301–309.
N ational “Development ”
59
Atteh, S.O. (1996). The crisis in higher education in Africa. Issue, 24 (1), 36–42. Aronowitz, S. (2000). The knowledge factory: Dismantling the corporate university and creating true higher learning. Boston: Beacon Press. Banya, K. (2001). Are private universities the solution to the higher education crisis in sub-Saharan Africa? Higher Education Policy, 14 (2), 161–174. Barrow, C.W., Didou-Aupetit, S., and Mallea, J. (2003) (Eds.). Globalisation, trade liberalisation, and higher education in North America: The emergence of a new market under NAFTA? Boston: Kluwer. Berman, E.H. (1998). The entrepreneurial university: Macro and micro perspectives from the United States. In J. Currie and J. Newson (Eds.), Universities and globalization: Critical perspectives (pp. 213–233). Thousand Oaks: Sage. Bollag, B. (2002). Chaos on African Campuses. Chronicle of Higher Education, 48 (44), A39. Burbules, N.C. and Torres, C.A. (2000) (Eds.). Globalization and education: Critical perspectives. New York: Routledge. Castells, M. (1997). The power of identity. Oxford: Blackwell. Currie, J. and Newson, J. (1998) (Eds.) Universities and globalization: Critical perspectives. Thousand Oaks: Sage. Currie, J.R., Deangelis, H. de Boer, Huisman, J. and Lacotte, C. (2003). Globalizing practices and university responses: European and Anglo-American differences. Westport, CT: Praeger. Dei, J.G.S. (1995). Indigenous knowledge as an empowerment tool for sustainable development. In V. Titi and N. Singh (Eds.), Empowerment for sustainable development toward operational strategies (pp. 147–161). Halifax: Fernwood. Dei, J.G.S. (1998). Interrogating “African development” and the diasporic reality. Journal of Black Studies, 29 (2), 141–153. Eisemon, T.O. and Davis, C.H. (1991). Can the quality of scientific training and research in Africa be improved by training? Minerva, 29 (1), 1–26. Eisemon, T.O and Holm-Nielsen, L. (1995). Reforming higher educational systems: Some lessons to guide policy implementation. Washington, D.C.: World Bank. Ekhaguere, G.O.S. (2000). African higher education and training: Opportunities and challenges. Higher Education in Europe, 25 (3), 373–379. Emeagwali, G. (2002) (Ed.). Africa and the hegemony: Challenging hegemonic discourses on Africa. Trenton, NJ: Africa World Press. Galli, R.E. (1992). Winners and losers in development and anti-development theory. In R.E. Galli (Ed.), Rethinking the third world: Contributions towards a new conceptualization (pp. 1–27). New York: Crane Russak. Giddens, A. (1990). The consequences of modernity. Stanford: Stanford University Press. Giroux, H.A. and McLaren, P. (1989) (Eds.). Critical pedagogy, the state, and the cultural struggle. Albany: State University of New York Press. Hettne, B. (1991). Development theory and the three worlds. New York: Wiley.
60
K orbl a P . Pupl ampu
Hoogvelt, A.M.M. (2001). Globalization and the postcolonial world: The new political economy of development. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University. Hoppers, C.A.O. (2003). Indigenous knowledge, the African Renaissance, and the integration of Knowledge systems. In M.S. Smith (Ed.), Globalizing Africa (pp. 411–422). Trenton: Africa World Press. Hountondji, P.J. (1995). Producing knowledge in Africa today. African Studies Review, 38 (3), 1–10. Land, T. (1994). African universities seek autonomy. Contemporary Review, 265, 1–3. Jua, N.B and Nyamnjoh, F.B. (2002). Scholarship production in Cameroon: Interrogating a Recession. African Studies Review, 45 (2), 49–72. Kasozi, A.B.K. (2002). The role of the state in addressing challenges and opportunities posed by the rapid growth of universities in Uganda since 1988. African Studies Review, 45 (2), 123–139. Kerr, D. and Mapanje, J. (2002). Academic freedom and the university of Malawi. African Studies Review, 45 (2), 73–91. Masinda, M.T. (2003). The knowledge-based economy and higher education in sub-Saharan Africa. In M.S. Smith (Ed.), Globalizing Africa. (pp. 451–463). Trenton, NJ.: Africa World Press. McGinn, N.F. (1997). The impact of globalization on national education systems. Prospects, 27 (1), 41–54. McLaren, P. (1998). Life in schools: An introduction to critical pedagogy in the foundations of education. New York: Longman. Metzler, J. (2000). Strengthening reciprocity in study-abroad programs. African Issues, 28 (1 & 2), 13–19. Mkandawire, T. (1997). The social sciences in Africa: Breaking local barriers and negotiating international presence. African Studies Review, 40 (2), 15–36. Mkandawire, T. and Soludo, C.C. (1999). Our continent, our future: African perspectives on structural adjustment. Ottawa: CODESRIA. Morna, C.L. (1995). The plight of the universities. Africa Report, March–April, 30–33. Morrow, R.A. and Torres, C.A. (2000). The state, globalization, and educational policy. In N.C. Burbules and C.A. Torres. (Eds.), Globalization and education: Critical perspectives (pp. 27–56). New York: Routledge. Morrow, R.A. and Torres, C.A. (1995). Social theory and education: A critique of theories of social and cultural reproduction. Albany: State University of New York Press. Ndoye, M. (1997). Globalization, endogenous development and education in Africa. Prospects, 27 (1), 79–84. Nyamnjoh, F.B. and Jua, N.B. (2002). African universities in crisis and the promotion of a democratic culture: The political economy of violence in African educational systems. African Studies Review, 45 (2), 1–26. Olson, M. (1965). The logic of collective action. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
National “Development”
61
Okolie, A.C. (2003). Producing knowledge for sustainable development in Africa: Implications for higher education. Higher Education, 46 (2), 235–260. Peil, M. (1996). Ghana’s universities and their government: An ambiguous relationship. Issue, 24 (1), 52–56. Pires, M., Marajh, O. and Metzler, J. (2000) Study abroad in Africa: A survey. African Issues, 28 (1 & 2), 4–12. Pocklington, T. and Tupper, A. (2002). No place to learn: Why universities aren’t working. Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press. Press, E. and Washburn, J. (2000). The kept university. The Atlantic Monthly, 285 (3), 39–54 (Online version http://www.theatlantic.com/issues/ 2000/03/press.htm). Psacharopoulos, G. (1991). Higher education in developing countries: The scenario of the future. Higher Education, 21, 3–9. Puplampu, K.P. (2004). The restructuring of higher education and part-time instructors: A theoretical and political analysis of undergraduate teaching in Canada. Teaching in Higher Education, 9 (2), 171–182. Rajagopal, I. (2002). Hidden academics: Contract faculty in Canadian universities. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Saint, W. (1992). Universities in Africa: Strategies for stabilization and revitalization. Washington, D.C.: World Bank. Samoff, J. (1999). No teacher guide, no textbooks, no chairs: Contending with crisis in African education. In R.F. Arnove and C.A. Torres (Eds.), Comparative Education: The dialectic of the global and local (pp. 393–431). Lanham, Rowan and Littlefield. Samoff, J. and Carrol, B. (2004). The promise of partnership and continuities of dependence: External support to higher education in Africa. African Studies Review, 47 (1), 67–199. Sawyerr, A. (1994). Ghana: Relations between government and universities. In G. Neave and F. van Vughts (Eds.), Government and higher education relationship across three continents: The winds of change (pp. 22–53). Paris: IAU Press and Pergamon. Sawyerr, A. (1996). Academic freedom and university autonomy: Preliminary thoughts from Africa. Higher Education Policy, 9 (4), 281–287. Sawyerr, A. (2004). Challenges facing African universities: Selected issues. African Studies Review, 47 (1), 1–59. Schugurensky, D. (1999). Higher education restructuring in the era of globalization: Towards a heteronomous model? In R.F. Arnove and C.A. Torres (Eds.). Comparative Education: The dialectic of the global and local (pp. 283–304). Lanham, Rowan and Littlefield. Schuurman, F. (Ed.) (2001). Globalization and development studies: Challenges for the 21st century. London: SAGE. Slaughter, S. and Leslie, L.L. (1997). Academic capitalism: Politics, policies, and the entrepreneurial university. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. Slaughter, S. and Leslie L.L. (2000). Professors going pro: The commercialization of teaching, research, and service. In G.D. White and F.C. Hauck
62
K orbl a P . Pupl ampu
(Eds.), Campus Inc. Corporate power in the ivory tower (pp. 140–156). Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books. Teferra, D. and Altbach, P.G. (2003) (Eds.). African higher education: An international reference handbook. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press. Teferra, D. and Altbach, P.G. (2004). African higher education: Challenges for the 21st century. Higher Education, 47 (1), 21–50. Tettey, W.J. (2002). Africa’s brain drain: Exploring possibilities for its positive utilization through networked communities. Mots Pluriels, 20, February (http://www.arts.uwa.edu.au/MotsPluriels/MP2002wjt.html). Tettey, W.J. and Puplampu, K.P. (2000). Social science research and the Africanist: The need for intellectual and attitudinal reconfiguration. African Studies Review, 43 (3), 81–102. UNDP (2003). Human development report. New York: Oxford University Press for UNDP. UNESCO (1992). Higher education in Africa: Challenges and trends in the 21st century. Paris: UNESCO. UNESCO (1994). Future directions for higher education in Africa. Paris: UNESCO. UNESCO (1998). Development of education in Africa: A statistical review. Paris: UNESCO. UNESCO (2003). Recent developments and future prospects of higher education in sub Saharan Africa in the 21st century. Paris: UNESCO. Verhelst, T.G. (1990). No life without roots: Culture and development. London: Zed Books (Translated by Bob Cumming). White, G.D. and Hauck, F.C. (2000) (Eds.). Campus Inc.: Corporate power in the ivory tower. Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books. White, G.D. (2000). Afterword. Business School: An Interview with Noam Chomsky. In: G.D. White and F.C. Hauck (Eds.), Campus Inc.: Corporate power in the ivory tower (pp. 441–455). Amherst, NY: Prometheus Books. Woodhall, M. (1995). Financial diversification in higher education: A review of international experiences and implications for African universities. Higher Education Policy, 8 (1), 16–23. World Bank (1988a). Education in sub-Saharan Africa: Policies for adjustment, revitalization and expansion. Washington, D.C.: World Bank. World Bank (1988b). The financing and management of higher education: A status report on worldwide reforms. Washington, D.C.: World Bank. World Bank (1994). Higher education: The lessons of experience. Washington, D.C: World Bank. World Bank (1998). World development report 1998–99. Background papers: Knowledge for development in Africa. Washington, D.C.: World Bank. World Bank (2000). Higher education in developing countries peril and promise. Washington, D.C.: World Bank. World Bank (2002). Constructing knowledge societies: New challenges for tertiary education. Washington, D.C.: World Bank. Zeleza, P.T. (2003). Rethinking Africa’s globalization, Volume 1: The intellectual challenges. Trenton, NJ: Africa World Press.
P art II
Culture, Language, and the Curriculum
This page intentionally left blank
4
Recl aiming Our Memories: T he Education Dilemma in Postcolonial A frican S chool Curricul a Edward Shizha
T
he case for African school curricula is a contentious phenomenon, especially when the definition of “African curricula” has to be considered and understood within the context of contemporary and multiethnic Africa. The contention is how to define and validate knowledge, particularly the official curriculum in the face of globalization, and the internationalization of knowledge. Even more problematic is the concept and definition of “African” itself. Who is the African in contemporary African society? Profound cultural diversity and interconnectedness has taken place since and after colonialism so much that the African identity has become elusive and evasive. The observed considerable cultural, ethnic, and racial diversity within Africa tends to obscure an African identity. Hall (1996) argues that modern nations are all cultural hybrids. However, this hybridity is loosely observed in African societies as some cultural and ethnic distinctions still persist. Appiah (1992) rejects any theory that seeks to homogenize Africans when he states: Now I am confident in rejecting any homogenizing portrait of African intellectual life, because the ethnographies and the travel literature and novels of parts of Africa other than my home are replete with examples of ways of life and of thought that strike me as thoroughly pretheoretically different from life in Asante, where I grew up. (p. 25)
66
E dward S hizha
Thus, Africa can be described, as a salad bowl of black Africans, white Africans, Arabic Africans, and Asian Africans. These people do not share a common culture that can be described as the African culture for curricula content. Amongst African cultural groups are black African subcultures, white African subcultures, and Asian African subcultures whose cultural differences are based on ethnicity, class, ideology, gender, and religion. Cultural pluralism in modern Africa leads to an elusive definition of the African and the African knowledge that can be institutionalized for the official curriculum.
What Knowledge and Whose Knowledge? Education is not limited to accumulating knowledge and skills; it involves acquiring ways of interpreting and giving meaning to concepts, forming links, and understanding ideas. Knowledge entails ways that individuals look at and give meaning to experiences as characterized by their cultural and social worldview. Thus, the questions that may be considered when defining knowledge in the African school curricula are: 1. What is considered and passed as valid/official knowledge and non-valid knowledge? 2. Who defines and selects curriculum knowledge in a multicultural and multiethnic African society? 3. Who is in control of what and for whom? 4. What is the distribution of sociocultural knowledge in school curricula? According to Eggleston (1977) “differences in thought processes and differences in perception of events and worldviews lead to differences in the store of knowledge possessed by each society and by each group” (p. 1). The stores of knowledge are temporal and spatial as experience and history affect them. Hence, what counts as knowledge in one society or cultural group at a particular time in history may not be considered as knowledge or valid knowledge at a different period. For example, knowledge that was perceived as valid and legitimate during colonial Africa, may be discounted as invalid and irrelevant in contemporary Africa. The significance of the school curricula to the sociocultural worldview of the African student, in both orientation and content, is of great concern to African sociologists. Sociologists in Africa argue that postcolonial school knowledge continues to mirror that of colonial education
E ducation Dilemma in A frica
67
(Baba, 1990). Academic and often irrelevant ways of learning are emphasized even though most African states have localized their examination systems. Localization of examinations has not transformed the knowledge systems that are still largely embedded in colonial constructs. Knowledge constructs, both in content and pedagogy, are highly colonial and teach students a foreign culture and worldview. Andreas Huyssen, cited in Rust (1991) postulates that colonial knowledge is associated with both “inner and outer imperialism”(p. 617). Consequently, the need to redefine and reconstruct school curricula in Africa and de-legitimize Western defined knowledge cannot be overemphasized. Schooling reflects Huyssen’s forms of imperialism in cultural tastes and psychological behavior adopted by students and indigenous African elite that emulate Western lifestyle and popular culture. Perpetuating cultural imperialism in Africa’s education systems is a negation of “narrative of the nation(s), as told and retold in national histories, literatures, and popular culture” (Hall, 1996, p. 614). The narratives provide a set of stories, images, historical events, national symbols, and rituals which stand for, and represent, the shared experiences that give meaning to the African society. While education systems that are embedded in colonialism lead to psychological and cultural alienation and cultural domination (Mazrui, 1993), they no longer go unchallenged. The challenge is to deconstruct and redefine the structures and systems of knowledge. Both inner imperialism, which Habermas calls “inner colonization” (Rust, 1991, p. 617), and the outer imperialism are a threat to the identity and self-perception of the African student. Thus, a redefined African education system should aim at reclaiming the African cultural histories and memories. Schools should be cultural spaces and centers that provide strategies to reclaim African indigeneity and overcome threats from cultural alienation. Schools should empower students to define their own destiny and cultural selves.
Toward a Deconstructive and Reconstructive Discourse Colonial school curricula constituted the voice of the dominant group in society, which defined status, privilege, power, and control in terms of racial differences. The school curricula, as defined by the colonizer, were used to constitute the enclaves of hegemonic discourse and practices that dehumanized the indigenous people. Indigenous Africans were defined as inferior to Europeans and were erroneously taught to internalize the racial stereotypes of the colonizer (Mazrui, 1993). Thus, schooling led to the loss of the indigenous people’s self-identity and
68
E dward S hizha
self-confidence. Through schooling and its cultural hegemony, Africans became willing accomplices and co-constructors of Western cultural imperialism. Education and schooling are the alienating processes that postcolonial Africa needs to transform through the deconstruction and reconstruction processes. To deconstruct colonial curricula is “to displace them into the fabric of historicity out of which they have been shaped . . . it is to become involved in ‘the unmaking of a construct.’ Deconstruction is another strategy by which to ‘read texts,’ though one with a decidedly different self-consciousness and consequences . . .” (Outlaw, 1987, p. 11). Deconstruction of colonial curricula requires rupturing the hegemonic structures of Western defined knowledge. From this perspective, knowledge takes a new form and dimension that celebrates differences without portraying itself as “the culture of reference” (see Jacques Derrida in Lemert, 1999). Opening up new forays of defining and explaining knowledge is a moment when Western knowledge constructs of the so-called modern, but colonial era, are redefined and reexamined using different African perspectives. However, the transformation should be as value-free as possible without prejudicing other ways of perceiving historical, social, and cultural phenomena. Pedagogy should be approached from diverse perspectives that allow the pedagogical process to be culturally sensitive accepting cultural variations that may exist within the classroom. Classroom life should reflect the social and cultural contexts that relate to students’ experiences. At the same time, classroom experiences should also focus on the need to meet the current societal needs. This means that although pedagogy should be culturally sensitive, it should not ignore aspects of Western knowledge constructs that have benefited society for the past century under colonialism. Pedagogical practices that integrate history are conducive to reconstructed curricula that incorporate reality as perceived from different cultural and social backgrounds. Learning, in this context, becomes a meaningful and fulfilling experience that helps students to be useful participants in their society. The new form of curriculum discourse allows the production of knowledge and social relations that were ignored and denigrated by the colonial education system. The discourse prepares what Abdi (2002, p. 9) describes as “new educational possibilities . . . [that attempt] to assure the sustainability of a new and analytically interesting form . . . identified as multicultural education with the inviolable premises of ‘own’ education and ‘common’ education.” West (1999) argues that this new curriculum change is a historical moment for African education systems. It is a moment to acknowledge the discontinuity and disruption from previous forms of cultural hegemony.
E ducation Dilemma in A frica
69
Colonial Curricula—The Subjugation of Indigenous Voices and Stories Citing Hume and Hegel, Outlaw (1987, p. 16) posits that in colonial Africa, “African peoples were explicitly denied the status of rational and historical beings.” European invasion and the subjugation of blacks served to validate the colonial characterization of the European invention of Africa and Africans. Racism and ethnocentrism were used to justify the rationalization and legitimization of European imperialism. Through cultural imperialism, Europe managed to disseminate its values and beliefs as the cornerstone for colonial curricula which was incorporated in formal schooling as the cultural capital to be pursued by African indigenous students. The system used nonindigenous knowledge to silence the voices of the black African student. According to Giroux (1996), the colonial education system led to the separation of individuals from their existential conditions and experiences, from their cultures and individuality. wa Thiong’o (1986) asserts that the process of colonial education annihilated people’s beliefs in their names, their languages, in their environment, in their heritage of struggle, in their unity, in their capacities, and ultimately in themselves. Even in postcolonial Africa, the Eurocentric orientation in African education has attained an even greater domination and control of African school curricula. Rust (1991, p. 619), citing Foucault, argues that such curricula were used in colonial times as “a system of control,” controlling the social, moral, and economic conditions of Africans. Rodney (1982) observes that: The educated (black) Africans were the most alienated Africans on the continent. At each further stage of education, they were battered and succumbed to the white capitalist, and after being given salaries, they could then afford to sustain a style of life imported from outside . . . That further transformed their mentality. (p. 275)
Colonial education did more than corrupt the thinking and sensibilities of the Africans; it filled their minds with abnormal complexes, which de-Africanized and alienated them from the needs of their sociocultural milieu. wa Thiong’o (1986) observes that the lack of congruency between colonial education and African reality created people abstracted from their reality. Africans were denied the right to cultural development and self-expression. By denying indigenous people their self-expression and historical memories, colonialism simultaneously denied them their cultural process. Educators, curriculum developers, and textbook writers ignored the voices of the Others, destroying their sense of hope,
70
E dward S hizha
belonging, existence, and social reality. Cultural imperialism and domination dispossessed the Africans of their “tools of self-definition” (wa Thiong’o, 1986, p. 16). Learning, which according to Giroux (1996, p. 121) was “the mechanical memorization of the profile of a concept” alienated the owners of local knowledge from their social and cultural identity. In colonial Africa, schools were centers for cultural hegemony, centers for discrediting and disengaging the culture of the indigenous Africans. Colonial schools were the vehicles through which European “enlightenment” and “civilization” were forced on to the African and where colonization and exploitation were rationalized. Schools became institutionally created and privileged sites for the production of hegemonic knowledge. Indigenous knowledge, which is intergenerational and intra-generational, and embedded in the customs, habits, rituals, and social institutions of the community, was regarded as “ignorant knowledge.” That is how cultural knowledge was victimized and marginalized from school curricula. Fanon (1967) reports that Africans were thrown into a state of total cultural disorientation as the education system was based on images and perceptions of reality that were masked and perverted. The absence of indigenous realities in school curricula was also masked from the local people. Schooling bore no relation to any reality relevant to indigenous social experiences. The education system was used as an institution that colors all individual identities, directly or indirectly (Bhola, 2002). For Africans, it was pure simulation portrayed in curricula reflecting European colonial reality. In relation to this form of education, Kallaway (1984) says about Bantu Education in apartheid South Africa: There is [was] no place for him [the native] in the European community above the level of certain forms of labour . . . For this reason it is of no avail for him to receive training which has its aim as absorption in the European community, where he cannot be absorbed. Until now he has been subjected to a school system which drew him away from his community and misled him by showing him the green pastures of European society in which he was not allowed to graze. (p. 173)
The form of education described by Kallaway was a cultural bomb, which was unleashed to annihilate indigenous cultures as European culture was used as an extreme form of standardization, requiring blind conformity and masked rationalization. On colonialism, Fanon (1967) argues that colonial schooling affected both the indigenous culture and the people’s intimate sense of selfhood
E ducation Dilemma in A frica
71
and created a hatred of their culture and their Africanness. Schooling was designed to impose the white man’s “mythical racial superiority” (Offiong, 1982, p. 112). Whatever Africans were taught, it was designed to enable them to internalize their “inferiority” and to recognize the white man as their “savior.” The ultimate goal of colonial education might be deduced from Thomas B. Macaulay’s (1994) statement describing the British imposed colonial education in India when he stated, “We must at present do our best to form a class of who may be interpreters between us and the millions whom we govern; a class of persons, Indian in blood and colour, but English in taste, in opinions, in morals, and in intellect” (p. 430). The aim of colonial education was to leave those who were colonized with a lack of identity and a limited sense of their past.
A Legacy of Despair Postcolonial philosophical foundations and constructions of knowledge have not significantly changed from the colonial discourses. In many African schools, European education continues to distort, misappropriate, and misrepresent African realities, their lives, experiences, and thoughts. Since independence, there has been little significant shift from Eurocentric definitions of official knowledge and school pedagogy. Much of African education systems inherited from colonial regimes are not in touch with contemporary Africa. The content of school curriculum, and the language of instruction, notably in secondary schools, continues to mirror those of the metropolitan powers of the West or North. It still perpetuates psychological colonization by making Africans emulate Europeans. However, despite all the desperate maneuvering to become Europeanized, Africans can never attain the European identity, as they are never accepted as full participants in European societies. They are always marginalized and considered as outsiders. Giroux (1996) postulates that postcolonial education “rewrites the relationship between the margin and the center by reproducing the colonialist and imperialist ideologies” (p. 27) that structure Western knowledge, text, and social practices. In this context, the repressed stories and the social memories of the formerly colonized continue to be repressed. Indigenous voices and thoughts are to a large extent silenced and dominated while Western knowledge is continuously rendered visible in schools and society. African indigenous episteme and ways of knowing are embalmed from historical and institutional structures that validate and legitimize knowledge. The “cultural mummification [of indigenous knowledge] leads to a mummification of individual thinking”
72
E dward S hizha
(Fanon, 1969, p. 34). African school curricula promote and give privilege to alien cultures while excluding particular readings, voices, aesthetics, and representations of African reality. Colonial residuals and postcolonial discourses are reported in Young (1990, p. 119) as “deeply implicated in each other” and perpetuate a culture of silence among the marginalized. Colonial residuals continue to imprison the actions, feelings, attitudes, beliefs, and the conceptual capabilities of indigenous people. wa Thiong’o (1986) observes that: Education, far from giving people the confidence in their reality and capacities to overcome obstacles . . . tends to make them feel their inadequacies, their weakness and their capacities in the face of reality; and their inability to do anything about the conditions governing their lives. (p. 56)
Europeanized education, in other words, is a means of mystifying knowledge and reality, an alienating and dehumanizing process that continues to this day. Schanack (1994) concludes that in postcolonial Africa “. . . the formal system of the classroom education looks like a foreign cyst in the social body, a malignant tumour” (p. 52). Schooling reflects foreign cultural symbols that are maintained through curriculum dependency and educational neocolonialism.
Indigenous Knowledge and Cultural Globalization If curriculum is what Lawton (1977) describes as a selection from the culture of society, and culture is a way of life of a people, including its body of accumulated knowledge and understanding (Thaman, 1993), then, whose culture is selected for curricula content in Africa? Cultural pluralism makes the definition of indigenous African culture very fluid and elusive. However, it is important to acknowledge that indigenous people have what Dei (1994, p. 6) portrays as “underlining commonalities and affinities in their thought systems,” which were historically repressed through colonial education. However, these indigenous thought systems are being continuously challenged by Euro-American so-called New World Order of globalization which is reinventing colonization. Globalization is consistent with colonization or neocolonization in that it seeks to “universalize” and “internationalize” the Western concept of knowledge and science, thus continuing the marginalization of non-Western knowledge systems. “Global” technologies have condensed time and space to create a postmodernist consciousness that has
E ducation Dilemma in A frica
73
accelerated Euro-American political, economic, social, and cultural processes at the expense of other cultures. African indigenousness is being weakened by the cultural onslaught from global processes that reify and mystify Western cultural realities. According to Dei (2002), “knowledge resides in the body and cultural memory; however, it is the Eurocentric gaze that has influenced and shaped what to see and not to see, what is [in]valid and [il]legitimate” (p. 167). Globalization has tended to universalize, validate, and legitimate Western knowledge while trivializing indigenous knowledge systems. Universalizing knowledge leads to its “homogenization” and hegemonization. The “homogenized knowledge,” which is being erroneously described as “global knowledge and global culture” (Benson, 1996, p. 64), happens to be Euro-American knowledge that excludes African worldviews. Globalization of Euro-American culture perpetuates cultural imperialism and results in “cultural amnesia” as African scholars pretend to be westernized. How and why then should we expect the African youths to behave and believe in indigenous lifestyles and thinking when all they see and hear on television and the internet is Western ways of life? Globalization is distorting and disfiguring African mental dispositions.
Africanizing School Curricula Deconstruction of colonial ways of perceiving knowledge offers an alternative and desirable form of critical pedagogy that takes history into account. It attempts to keep track of the complex dynamics of institutional and other related power structures in order to offer options and alternatives for transformative praxis. The politics of difference in transformative praxis empowers Africans to reclaim their social and cultural positions and provides school curricula and pedagogical practices with possibilities for a wide range of realities. Since “different local status groups appropriate and create their own versions of mediated cultural forms” (Foley, 1990, p. 193), expanded and diverse school curricula are enriched with the possibility of simultaneously incorporating the past into the present, the distant into the local. In this simultaneity is “a new freedom, a cultural liberation” (Rust, 1991, p. 624) incorporating the best ideas and practices from diverse African cultures. In the process, knowledge breaks out the artificial boundaries created by colonial discourse, thus becoming an echo of resonating multivoices. A reconstructed school curriculum is a tool of liberation based not on a reversal of values accorded to European versus African culture, but
74
E dward S hizha
on incorporating “disalienation” that seeks to pose new terms of reference (Mazrui, 1993), which Abdi (2002) describes as “relative” Africanization. Abdi (2002) and Dei (1998) propose Africanizing schooling as a means of countering Euro-American objectification and ideological domination in African curricula and learning. The Africanization process involves making schools and curricula culturally sensitive and responsive to the needs and aspirations of the African people. The process entails bringing various African realities into the school life. Describing “relative Africanization of knowledge,” Abdi (2002, p. 21) says, “central to [it] is to assume, exceptionally and when necessary, a tendency to indigenise both the production and use of knowledge so [that] these fit African needs, beliefs systems, and expectations for community development.” Dei (1998) describes Africanization of curriculum as leading to a transformative African education in which: [The community] must find ways to tap the cultural resource knowledge of local peoples. Such knowledge was the hallmark of traditional indigenous African education. Rather than tapping such local skills and knowledge, colonial education chose to devalue and neglect home, family and community instruction strategies and practices. These strategies constitute an untapped resource that educational reformers could adapt to advance learning and teaching in schools. (p. 512)
Throughout colonial history in Africa, what counted as school knowledge was shaped by the beliefs, customs, and perceptions that were based on racial definitions and social and cultural segregation. School knowledge was dominated by colonial experiences that trivialized indigenous ways of knowing and explaining social reality. Curricula were constructed within the white middle-class mainstream explanations of what constituted scientific phenomena while indigenous perceptions were demeaned as commonsense. However, today, indigenous and Western forms of knowledge should not be seen as opposites. Throughout the postcolonial years there has been unquantifiable and endless interactions between Western and indigenous knowledge, thus creating a new way of perceiving knowledge. What may be deemed African knowledge has crossed cultural and social barriers that were erected by colonialism. Bray, Clarke and Stephens (1986) argue that apparent knowledge “differences” are in fact often differences in languages, which are used primarily as a means of representing reality. Reality, that is shared experience, is represented in the language used by people. Therefore, by utilizing both indigenous and Western languages, indigenous and Western ways of knowing and thinking can supplement each other in
E ducation Dilemma in A frica
75
Africanizing school curriculum. The solution to Africanization does not lie in abandoning one form of education for another. A formal education system that integrates indigenous and Western ways of knowing and thinking is likely to benefit society more than one that seeks to pursue a separatist perspective. An integrated Africanized system is likely to meet the cultural, social, moral, intellectual, as well as political, and economic needs of Africa. Soon after political independence, the attention of most African states was focused on expanding educational provision and financing educational expansion. In the pressure for quantity, questions about the nature and relevance of education were pushed into the background. In countries where indigenization or Africanization of school curricula was attempted (Tanzania, Zambia, and Zimbabwe) it was met with resistance from Western educated indigenous elite, teachers, and parents. Africanization was despised for lowering educational “standards” that had been set by colonial policy makers. Teachers were not familiar with what indigenization entailed since there were no materials that explained and gave direction to what was to be taught and how it was to be taught. They also did not see how the new expectations could fit within the present school curricula that were examination-oriented. The majority of teachers also lacked and still lack pedagogical skills required to embark on Africanizing curriculum. The colonial model of imparting knowledge and apportioning meaning to ideas as “truths” and “facts” has not shifted in any way to accommodate alternative ways of explaining reality. The absence of other cultural ways of knowing and explaining reality was internalized by African teachers who in turn internalized the Eurocentric values, beliefs and practices that were embedded in colonial school curricula. Most teachers relied [rely] on methods and materials with which they were taught, and it seemed naive on their part to do otherwise. Apart from the pedagogical expectations and change that Africanization entails, indigenization of African education also takes account of the presence of the community in which the school is located. The local people are the vital source of indigenous knowledge and their contribution cannot be overemphasized. The school and the community are cultural circles, which should engage in constant dialogue to promote indigenous ways of explaining what students experience and what schools should promote as relevant ways of explaining community problems. The community provides alternative ways of explaining social phenomenon and this is critical in fostering understanding among students. Community participation transforms and challenges dominant power relations in schools and offers the possibility for
76
Edward S hizha
producing constructive knowledge appropriate to African modes of thinking. The school-community encounter provides opportunities for educators, learners, parents, and other community members to engage in social experiences and social practices that are meaningful and shared to produce dialogue. Dialogue is central to becoming social, historical, and cultural agents that create knowledge that is relevant and sustainable to African needs. Paulo Freire says: is the encounter between men (sic), mediated by the world, in order to name the world. Hence, dialogue cannot occur between those who want to name the world and those who do not want this naming—between those who deny other men [sic] to speak their word and those whose right to speak has been denied them. If it is in speaking their word that men (sic) transform the world by naming it, dialogue imposes itself as the way in which men (sic) achieve significance as men [sic]. Dialogue is thus an existential necessity. (Peters and Lankshear, 1994, p. 179)
Through dialogue teachers, students, parents, and members of the community interested in Africanizing knowledge, simultaneously attain critical thinking and achieve liberation. Teachers are liberated from being dominant sources of knowledge, while students are liberated from being passive recipients of “knowledge.” Teaching and learning become participatory activities in which students go back to their communities to elicit cultural knowledge from elders, conduct research and take back to the community knowledge “refined” by the school. Parents also get involved in classroom activities by contributing to learning as resource persons. Knowledge becomes the product of both the school and the community, at the same time, it finds place in the social and economic activities of the local people. Schooling becomes a cultural activity with teachers and parents acting as cultural brokers in a dialogical fashion that benefits students. Dialogue becomes possible, if students and parents are given voices to participate and be considered as equal participants in the schooling process. It also provides conditions for students and parents to speak so that their narratives and those of their communities can be affirmed and engaged in school practices. As hooks (1989) points out, giving voice means: Moving from silence into speech as a revolutionary gesture . . . the idea of finding one’s voice or having a voice assumes a primacy in talk discourse, writing, and action. . . . Only as subjects can we speak. As objects, we remain voiceless—our beings defined and interpreted by others . . . Awareness of the need to speak, to give voice to the varied dimensions of our lives, is one way [to begin] the process of education for critical consciousness. (p. 12)
E ducation Dilemma in A frica
77
Giving voice to students can be achieved by employing border pedagogy (Giroux, 1992); a process that involves a multiplicity of voices that typify the cultural dynamics that exist in classrooms. Recognizing “voices” empowers students to express themselves in defining what knowledge is and how it should be presented and learned, thus dislocating cultural and political boundaries and social margins that give privilege to some and exclusion to others. Border pedagogy informs curricula by “giving everyday culture back to its owners” (Willis, 1990, p. 129) using cultural knowledge to offer possibilities for alternative symbolization of the cultural experiences of different students. Knowledge construction through cultural pedagogy expresses selfrepresentations and social representations, which are vital for curriculum deconstruction and reconstruction. Giroux (1992, p. 136) notes that crossing borders of differences can be “remapped . . . in ways that allow students to draw upon their own experiences as real knowledge.” Crossing borders enhances dialogue and the formation and enactment of social and cultural identities in which social equality and cultural diversity coexist with participatory democracy, thus, creating an inclusive community of learners. Dialogue empowers students and frees them from alienating school experiences. It brings the home, family, and community into the school arena and classroom practice. Teachers should realize that Africanization of school curricula develops and enhances critical consciousness. It is a process that moves away from the Eurocentric method of teaching and learning. Whereas colonial teaching methods encouraged passivity and the acceptance of predefined knowledge, an Africanized system offers opportunity for critical teaching approaches and alternative ways of explaining learning material. Pedagogy becomes a collaborative process rather than a teacher-centered approach (Freire, 1985). Teachers develop critical pedagogy and critical thinking; a process that is multi-perspectival.
A Multicultural Perspective to Schooling The diversity of social and cultural groups in African schools indicates that individual scholars view sociocultural realities differently. Each scholar has a voice that contributes toward school culture and social reality. Reality is not a simple objective datum, the concrete fact; it is also the individual’s perception of it (Freire, 1985). To achieve Africanization, educationists and academics in Africa should accept multiple ways of knowing that are characterized by the presence, in our schools, of learners from different ethnic and cultural backgrounds.
78
E dward S hizha
Learners come to school with different worldviews and ways of perceiving the world around them. Their ways of knowing are influenced by family and community socialization. They grow up in families and communities that have their unique ways of understanding and explaining the social, spiritual, economic, and political world that is part of their life. Perhaps, as Dei (2002) informs us, curricula planners and designers, including teachers should “work with the idea that the different bodies [cultures], particularly those to be found within contemporary classrooms and central to the larger educational project, bring multiple ways of knowing” (p. 170). Therefore, a multicultural approach to teaching and learning is envisaged to look at the curriculum in a different way and to re-conceptualize the way knowledge has historically been organized. Multicultural schooling practices attempt to give voice to all students and replace the postcolonial hegemonic school practices that continue to permeate African educational systems. A system that recognizes and allows for multiple ways of learning and explaining reality liberates and transforms classroom life. Multicultural education allows for the heterogeneous social structures of African society to be represented in the schooling process. It infuses the entire school curriculum with the lives, experiences, works, practices, attributes, and dreams of the traditionally left out. Multiculturalism offers an emancipatory and liberatory education that frees both the formerly dominated and the former oppressor. Banks (1994, p. 1) describes it as “education for freedom that is essential in today’s ethnically polarized and troubled world.” Multicultural education validates a body of knowledge that deals with the social world and social experiences of the contemporary African student and teacher. It offers experiential realities that are multiples of cultural values, traditions, and histories of various subcultures with different worldviews. These worldviews have to find expressive voices or else they remain subordinated. Freire (1985, p. 72) suggests that, “[the] culture of silence, a result of power structural relationships between the dominated and the dominators” has to be replaced by a culture of voice to legitimize knowledge. Knowledge within the multicultural perspective is non-exclusionary and non-hegemonic; it involves the negotiation and sharing of power (Banks, 1994). In that spirit, schooling leads to the total liberation of the mind and the transformation of learning. Inclusive multicultural schooling is likely to contribute significantly to social, political, economic, cultural transformations, and human understanding. Curricula that are embedded in multivoices incorporate the best ideas and practices of multiple cultures without bias, prejudice or discrimination, ensuring that the local cultural contexts of teaching
E ducation Dilemma in A frica
79
and learning remain pivotal to pedagogical practices (Rodwell, 1998). Multicultural knowledge is capable of transforming educators and students to “think critically, struggle against social injustices, and develop relations of community based on the principles of equality, freedom and justice” (Giroux, 1992, p. 200).
The Language Problem in African Schools The language of instruction in African schools is the major obstacle in students’ cognitive development and learning outcomes. Today, African schools teach already codified texts, written more often than not in a Western language and projecting “unfamiliar Western epistemologies and Western ideologies” (Bhola, 2002, p.13). Knowledge is embedded in language and African students must undertake dual translation to make sense of what they learn. They have to translate what is taught in a foreign language to their mother tongue and then retranslate it to the same foreign language in order to communicate ideas to the teacher. There is an intimate connection between language, meaning making, and practice. Learning in English or French violates the freedom of African students to learn in a language that is familiar and meaningful to them. Cleghorn and Rollnick (2002) report that the foreign content of learning also violates indigenous norms, values, and beliefs. Arguably, curricula presented in a foreign language supports acculturation, if not assimilation, into another set of societal norms. The effect of this acculturation is a disjuncture between the culture of the home and the culture and language of the school. To overcome the language problem in the classroom, sometimes teachers and students resort to code switching, that is switching from English to the mother tongue in order to clarify concepts and meanings. Although teachers often seem to hold negative attitudes toward code switching, there is considerable evidence that code switching can offer a natural, economical, and effective resource for establishing meaning in classrooms (see Adendorff, 1996 and Eastman, 1992, in Cleghorn and Rollnick, 2002). Code switching enables the teacher and the students to communicate in the same home language. Dei (2002, p. 175) supports the use of both languages (colonial language and home language), which he calls “language integration” and “an educational inclusive practice.” Because meaning belongs to culture rather than simply to language, code switching can facilitate the establishment of meaning by providing a linguistic and cultural bridge to understanding.
80
E dward S hizha
One’s language is vital in understanding the cultural reality that surrounds one’s life. Fisherman (1996), quoted in Kirkness (1998), says about the relationship and importance of language and culture: Most of culture is in the language and is expressed in the language. Language is best able to express most easily, most accurately and most richly, the values, customs and overall interests of the culture. If you take language away from culture, you take away its greetings, its curses, its praises, its laws, its literature, its songs, its riddles, its proverbs, its cures, its wisdom, its prayers. You are losing those things that essentially are the way of life, the way of thought, the way of valuing, and a particular human reality . . . It is our unique gift from the Creator; therefore it is the mind, the spirit and the soul of people. Language is important because it is what ties us together, as in a family. (pp. 10–11)
What Kirkness says about the connectedness of aboriginal language and culture equally applies to African languages and culture. You can neither break away African languages from their cultures nor disconnect culture from language. The two have a dialectical relationship that gives meaning to the lives of Africans. Therefore, using foreign languages only as the languages of instruction deviates from the African indigenous cultures and knowledge and virtually ignores the indigenous values and beliefs that should enhance and assist students’ understanding. Indigenous languages used simultaneously with European languages act as languages of possibility and languages of liberation (Freire, 1996; Giroux, 1992) for deconstructing colonial misrepresentations of African knowledge. The languages that students are familiar with create cultural spaces and spheres for creating knowledge and not for knowledge transference, but places where knowledge is produced, not simply presented to or imposed on the learners. Students are presented with what Lankshear, Peters and Knobel (1996, p. 151) call “democratic and humanising alternatives,” which are symbolic resources of their culture.
Conclusion Democratizing school curricula within an African sociocultural milieu challenges the false-consciousness created by Eurocentric realities for African students. Democratizing curricula offers cultural diversity and cultural sensitivity that permits students to cross borders of meaning and knowledge, and establish social relations based on equality in multicultural spaces. Multicultural spaces enable African educators to examine and reflect on their own biases in order to identify cultural
E ducation Dilemma in Africa
81
aspects that will better inform and enrich current and future curriculum decisions; decisions that will reverse the historical Eurocentric school system that worked to demean and disenfranchise indigenous students. African scholars and researchers are challenged to come up with ideas and theories that promote effective cross-cultural pedagogies that are sensitive to both traditional and modern forms of learning. They need to initiate curricula that keep pace with the social, cultural, political, and economic changes; changes that recognize the inevitability of persistent multiplicity and diversity among cultures rather than the inevitability of bland homogenization. An African multicultural discourse that closes social, racial, and cultural ranks in order to build, strengthen, and nurture solid alliances and coalitions between African and non-African cultural influences, is likely to be more effective in countering cultural imperialism, educational neocolonialism, and cultural hegemony. Indigenizing the curriculum in African schools entails portraying different perspectives in the curriculum, being as inclusive as possible. However, it should be noted that total equity and equality is not attainable. The challenge is in recognizing the importance of difference and incorporating cross-cultural experiences, crossing cultural borders and rejecting cultural stereotypes.
References Abdi, A. (2002). Postcolonial education in South Africa: Problems and prospects for multicultural development. Journal of Postcolonial Education, 1 (1), 9–26. Appiah, K.A. (1992). In my father’s house: Africa is the philosophy of culture. New York: Oxford University Press. Baba, T. (1990). Educational development. In K.H. Thaman (Ed.), An introduction to curriculum readings (pp. 1–18). Suva: The University of South Pacific. Banks, J. (1994). An introduction to multicultural education. Boston: Allyn & Bacon. Benson, R. (1996). Global knowledge: How media effects research can aid globalization theorizing. Berkeley Journal of Sociology, XXXX, 57–69. Bhola, H.S. (2002). Reclaiming old heritage for proclaiming future history: The knowledge-for-development debate in African contexts. Africa Today, 3–21. Bray, M., Clarke, H. and Stephens, P. (1986). Education and society in Africa. London: Edward Arnold. Cleghorn, A. and Rollnick, M. (2002). The role of English in individual and societal development: A view from African classrooms. TESOL Quarterly, 36 (3), 347–372.
82
E dward S hizha
Dei, G.J.S. (1994). Afrocentricity: A cornerstone of pedagogy. Anthropology and Education Quarterly, 25, 1–13. Dei, G.J.S. (1998). Interrogating African development and the diaspora reality. Journal of Black Studies, 29 (2), 141–153. Dei, G.J.S. (2002). Situating race and equity concerns in school effectiveness discourse. In C. Reynolds and A. Griffith (Eds.), Equity and globalization in education (pp. 165–181). Calgary: Detselig Enterprises. Eggleston, J. (1977). The Sociology of the school curriculum. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul. Fanon, F. (1967). A dying colonialism. New York: Grove Press. Fanon, F. (1969). Towards the African revolution. New York: Grove Press. Foley, D.E. (1990). Learning capitalist culture: Deep in the heart of Tejas. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania. Freire, P. (1985). The politics of education: Culture, power, and liberation. South Hadley, MA: Bergin & Garvey. Freire, P. (1996). Letters to Christina: Reflections on my life and work. New York: Routledge. Giroux, H. (1992). Border crossings: Cultural workers and the politics of education. New York: Routledge. Giroux, H. (1996). Is there a place for cultural studies in colleges of education? In H.A. Giroux, C. Lankshear, P. McLaren and M. Peters (Eds.), Counternarratives: Cultural studies and critical pedagogies in postmodern spaces (pp. 27–49). New York: Routledge. Hall, S. (1996). The global, the local, and the return of ethnicity. In S. Hall, D. Hubert and K. Thompson (Eds.), Modernity: An introduction to modern societies (pp. 613–619). Oxford: Blackwell Publishers. hooks, b. (1989). Talking back. Boston: South End Press. Kallaway, P. (Ed.), Apartheid and education: The education of black South Africans. Bloomfontein: Ravan Press. Kirkness, V.J. (1998). Our peoples’ education: Cut the shackles; Cut the crap; Cut the mustard. Canadian Journal of Native Education, 22 (1), 10–15. Lankshear, C., Peters, M. and Knobel, M. (1996). Critical pedagogy and cyberspace. In H.A. Giroux, C. Lankshear, P. McLaren and M. Peters (Eds.), Counternarratives: Cultural studies and critical pedagogies in postmodern spaces (pp. 139–157). New York: Routledge. Lawton, D. (1977). Class, culture and the curriculum. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul. Lemert, C. (Ed.) (1999). Social theory: The multicultural and classic readings. Oxford: Westview Press. Macaulay, R. (1994). Minute on Indian education. Postcolonial studies reader (pp. 428–430). New York: Routledge. Mazrui, A. (1993). Language and the quest for liberation in Africa: The legacy of Franz Fanon. Third World Quarterly, 14 (2), 348–365. Offiong, D. (1982). Imperialism and dependency: Obstacles to African development. Washington: Harvard University Press.
Education Dilemma in Africa
83
Outlaw, L. (1987). African “philosophy”: Deconstruction and reconstructive challenges. Contemporary Philosophy: A New Survey, 5, 1–19. Peters, M. and Lankshear, C. (1994). Education and hermeneutics: A Freirean interpretation. In P.L. McLaren and C. Lankshear (Eds.), Politics of liberation: Paths from Freire (pp. 173–192). New York: Routledge. Rodney, W. (1982). How Europe underdeveloped Africa. Washington, D.C.: Harvard University Press. Rodwell, S. (1998). Internationalization or indigenization of educational management development? Some issues of cross-cultural transfer. Comparative Education, 34 (1), 36–53. Rust, V.D. (1991). Postmodernism and its comparative education implications. Comparative Education, 35 (4), 613–627. Schanack, K. (1994). Export of curriculum and educational ideas. Copenhagen: DLH. Thaman, K.H. (1993). Culture and the curriculum in South Pacific. Comparative Education, 29 (3), 244–259. wa Thiong’o, N. (1986). Decolonizing the mind: The politics of language in African literature. Portsmouth: Heinemann. West, C. (1999). The new cultural politics of difference. In C. Lemert, C. (Ed.), Social theory: The multicultural and classic readings. Oxford: Westview Press. Willis, P. (1990). Common culture. London: Oxford University Press. Young, R. (1990). White mythologies: Writing history and the West. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
This page intentionally left blank
5
S urveying I ndigenous Knowledge, the C urriculum, and Development in A frica: A Critical African V iewpoint Nkosinathi Mkosi
T
his chapter is not meant to provide answers to the varied perceived problems identified and proffered by scholars and academicians pertinent to indigenous knowledge, nor is it intended to cause rapture in the indigenous knowledge discourses. Having said this, I have to note that I do make attempts at providing suggestions as to how some of the problems could be tackled. As well, what I do here is to add a critical voice to the calls for the acknowledgment of the possibilities of indigenous knowledge to ameliorate the woes experienced by the poor marginalized African communities. The principle agenda of this chapter is to gain vital insights in and exposure on indigenous knowledge as a discursive practice. Subsumed are the objectives to critically analyze the construct indigenous knowledge, and to explore its limitations as well as its possibilities and implications for education and development with particular reference to Africa. To realize these goals, I first provide a synoptic historico-descriptive analysis of indigenous knowledge. Then will follow an investigation of the epistemological foundations and processes perceived to distinguish indigenous knowledge from Western knowledge. A critique of indigenous knowledge will then precede an advancement of arguments for a case for indigenous knowledge in education and development in Africa. The concluding section contains commentaries informed by notions gleaned from the literature on indigenous knowledge.
86
Nkosinathi M kosi
Indigenous Knowledge: An Historico-Descriptive Analysis Since the 1990s, indigenous knowledge appears to have suddenly been catapulted into the limelight, becoming the focus of a number of academic formations. Organizations like the Inter-institutional Consortium for Indigenous Knowledge (ICIK) domiciled at Pennsylvania State University and founded in 1995, The International Center for Indigenous Knowledge for Agriculture and Rural Development (ICIKARD) housed at Iowa State University and two Netherlands centers have been interrogating the construct of indigenous knowledge. Conferences have also been held on a variety of issues pertaining to indigenous knowledge including epistemological and practical questions related to its discursive practice, and how indigenous knowledge is valued and used. In short, and as a result of these initiatives, a field of study has emerged with its own publication, The Indigenous Knowledge and Development Monitor (Semali and Kincheloe, 1999). It appears that most authors have similar conceptions of the term indigenous, however, as Dei, Hall and Rosenberg (2000) claim, it is problematic to define indigenous knowledges, and equally difficult to demarcate the parameters for purposes of scrutiny. Williams and Muchena (1991) seem to concur when asserting that various definitions and fragmented theoretical conceptions of indigenous knowledge exist, and thus, they conclude, while citing Ette, that indigenous knowledge has a plethora of terminologies referring to it: “indigenous knowledge systems, indigenous technical knowledge, ethnoscience, local science, traditional science, people’s science, and village science” (p. 52). To these authors, these terminologies have negative connotations such as static, conservative, or backward (p. 52), an assumption that will be examined later. Mwadime (1999) states that the term indigenous began to be used around 1980. Maurial (1999) posits that indigenous “reflect ideological connotations, and, contemporarily, connotes plurality instead of otherness” (p. 64). Semali and Kincheloe (1999) note that because the term indigenous has been reduced to mean the primitive, the wild, and the natural, indigenous knowledge has also been accorded similar meanings. To millions of indigenous peoples of Africa and other parts of the globe indigenous knowledge is a significant tool used to exist meaningfully and harmoniously with their environment. To the indigenous communities IK reflects the dynamic way in which the residents of an area have come to understand themselves in relationship to their natural environment
Indigenous Knowledge and the Curriculum
87
and how they organize that folk knowledge to flora and fauna, cultural beliefs, and history to enhance their lives. (Semali and Kincheloe, 1999, p. 3)
George (1999) suggests that the terms indigenous knowledge, traditional, lay beliefs, and common sense beliefs, refer to knowledge generated by a people in a particular societal context, and, commonly, indigenous knowledge is associated with people in non-Western, nonindustrialized, and traditional locales. The following excerpt seems to capture succinctly some foundational imperatives that undergird indigenous knowledge: We conceptualize an “indigenous knowledge” as a body of knowledge associated with the long-term occupancy of a certain place. This knowledge refers to traditional norms and social values, as well as to mental constructs that guide, organize, and regulate the people’s way of living experience and knowledge of a given social group, and forms the basis of decision making in the faces of challenges both familiar and unfamiliar. (Dei, Hall, and Rosenberg, 1999, p. 6)
If we pause momentarily to analyze this conception of indigenous knowledge, the problem of the parameters of indigenous knowledge becomes discernible. Let me use a crude illustration to enhance my proposition. In the case of South Africa, would the knowledge of the European settlers and colonizers who have been occupying South Africa for more than three hundred years be considered indigenous knowledge, or would it be considered foreign Western knowledge? When it appears that long-term occupancy of a certain place is a salient criterion for adjudicating a peculiar knowledge, indigenous or not, I would therefore presuppose an unambiguous definition of what longterm occupancy would mean in the context. It seems appropriate, therefore, that a comparison be made between indigenous knowledge and Western knowledge to facilitate better conceptualization, and to further identify epistemological underpinnings of indigenous knowledge.
Indigenous Knowledge and Western Knowledge: A Comparative Exercise I share Maurial’s (1999) view that constructing a bipolar model of indigenous knowledge versus Western knowledge is instrumental to the understanding of indigenous knowledge. She claims that indigenous knowledge differs from Western knowledge in that it is not found
88
Nkosinathi Mkosi
in archives or laboratories but it forms part of the daily lives of people (p. 63). Sillitoe (2000) seems to echo the preceding claim when he asserts that indigenous knowledge is not found in a “grand repository” (p. 2). George (1999) expresses the idea that indigenous knowledge is distinct from school knowledge in that it is not produced by following certain prescriptive rules or procedures, but is generated by people when attempting to find solutions for day-to-day problematic scenarios. Indigenous knowledge is not found in school curricula, except in rare cases, and the space of knowledge in the curricula is occupied and reserved for academic knowledge. One characteristic that appears to emerge consistently regarding indigenous knowledge is that it is orally transmitted from preceding generations (Castellano, 2000; Sillitoe, 2000). Apfell-Maglin (cited in Prakash, 1999), a point also supported by Quiroz (1999), observes that in an indigenous knowledge system, the people and their environment are not separate entities, mainly because indigenous knowledge is holistic and connected to nature. In addition, Mosha’s (1999) point that indigenous peoples experience life holistically appears to concur with the previous assertions. Furthermore, indigenous knowledge is “idiographic” that is, it is a knowledge of substantive content; while Western knowledge is “nomothetic” constituted by generalized kinds of knowledge (Nagel cited in Parrish, 1999, p. 269). Jegede (1999) indicates, for example, that Western scientific knowledge promotes rational thought, and the opposite could be true regarding indigenous knowledge. Similarly Shiva (2000) observes that indigenous knowledge has been defined as being unscientific because the epistemological foundations of Western knowledge were imposed on indigenous knowledge systems. I would concur here, but would add that this assumption has been one of the major reasons that have led to the devaluation, and the relegation of indigenous knowledge to a second-class status. Claims of a dichotomous relationship between the two concepts seem to abound; nonetheless similarities are identified. Dei (2000) argues that because indigenous knowledge exhibits an attribute— which is the accumulative nature of knowledge—common to knowledge, indigenous knowledge could be seen as dynamic as Western knowledge. Additionally, it possesses moral and cognitive conceptions about the environment and societal structures. This makes it compatible with Western scientific knowledge. Agrawal (1995) alleges that like any other knowledge, Western knowledge cannot be divorced from the day-to-day existence of people. This is also applicable to indigenous knowledge.
Indigenous Knowledge and the Curriculum
89
Critiquing Indigenous Knowledge: Shortcomings, Significance, and Implications Indigenous knowledge seems to have potential as a solution to some problems of great magnitude experienced in Southern countries. While advocates of indigenous knowledge, whom Agrawal (1995) terms the neo-indigenistas, exalt the utilitarian value of indigenous knowledge (pp. 415–416), other authors identify some problem areas associated with its fundamental conceptual foundations and processes. Mwadime (1999) offers a noteworthy counsel when he asserts that it would be a folly and unwise to present indigenous knowledge as devoid of any shortcomings. Indigenous knowledge, he cautions, is not always correct and functional and, thus, has to be modified and adapted so it can effectively function within the contemporary practices and social reality. Along similar arguments, the IK Notes (2000) claim that indigenous knowledge practices in, for instance, West African schools tend not to be vigorously pursued. This is because of several constraints: human resource, financial, and political. For example, teachers having minimal training and previous education, local funds are scarce, and there are hegemonic roadblocks to implementation of curriculum innovations at primary and secondary levels. This preceding stance is given credence by George (1999). He posits that indigenous knowledge is not included in most school curricula, that there are no ready school materials to teach it, and that educators are not trained to “handle” it in classrooms. The implication of this statement could be that educators would have to be ingenious and creative if indigenous knowledge was to be hastily implemented, and the cost of producing teaching-learning and educator training materials might be a financial conundrum for some already impoverished Southern countries. Similarly, Semali (1999) contends that the process of implementing and integrating indigenous knowledge with the dominating school curriculum might prove difficult. A question that may have some relevance could be how nation-states that are ravaged by political, economical, social, and cultural problems of gigantic proportions, would afford and manage the implementation of indigenous knowledge? Serrano (cited in George, 1999) adds another dimension when noting that indigenous knowledge has to exist in Western settings if it has to be viable and if it is to be useful. Further, it is implied that although indigenous knowledge’s traditional methods of inquiry might add value to the existing research approach, they might not be able to produce knowledge that is generalizable or
90
N kosinathi Mkosi
that can advance disciplinary knowledge (Abdullah and Stringer, 1999). Another concern regarding indigenous knowledge pertains to how it is to be collected, documented, preserved, disseminated, and, who will control the activities. Mwadime (1999) postulates that it is not clear how indigenous knowledge is to be recorded and utilized in policy, planning, and programming situations. Moreover, he raises awareness to the fact that indigenous knowledge might not be beneficial to the economically and politically underprivileged, especially when presented as a specialization discursive practice dominated by those already entrenched in educational and political hegemonic positions. Furthermore, he claims that indigenous knowledge might be less effective for the longterm planning due to its vulnerability to changes, and, its advocates and their related institutions might have to contend with a powerful lobby of more financially strong institutions, bilateral agencies and international transnational companies. Reynar (1999), on the other hand, notes that indigenous knowledge might only be beneficial for development if it is regarded as useful for the markets. Reynar adds that indigenous knowledge, to an extent, has been isolated from market forces and exposure to these forces might prelude its demise and, indigenous peoples might be shortchanged because financial compensation for knowledge among indigenous cultures is an incongruent practice to their belief systems. This factor might have serious repercussions for indigenous knowledge in particular and indigenous communities in general. The communities might be denied the opportunity to gain financially, if nothing else, from the knowledge they generate, and indigenous knowledge might be vulnerable and susceptible to exploitation and subsequent destruction. At this point, I deem it appropriate to present unanswered concerns posed by authors like Shiva (2000) and Kawell (2002) that are related to the epistemology and practices of indigenous knowledge, that is, who will decide what counts as knowledge? Who will count as the expert or innovator of indigenous knowledge? Who will have the right to control the circulation of knowledge and who will have the right to benefit from it? Dei, Hall and Rosenberg ask similar pertinent questions: How do we make sense of cognitive processes/categories of local people? How do we deal with questions of access, control, and ownership of knowledge? How do we protect local knowledges from systematization and commodification, and from being swallowed up by corporate material interests? How do we preserve indigenous knowledges? . . . (2000, p. 6)
Indigenous Knowledge and the Curriculum
91
It would appear reasonable to state that for indigenous knowledges to occupy a meaningful position as vibrant fields of study in the academy, and, as possible instruments to alleviate the hardships of the poor and the marginalized, the preceding concerns be seriously interrogated for possible solutions. That being as it may, is it possible that indigenous knowledges could offer some respite from the hardships experienced by the disenfranchised in Africa? To address the question as much as possible, I argue that because indigenous knowledge has generated such tremendous interest in a wide spectrum of constituencies, ranging from the academy to governmental and quasi-governmental agencies, it could achieve a good number of possibilities. Indigenous knowledge is also apparently permeating all spheres of human endeavor, and shall have the potential for enhancing and ameliorating various situations that characterizes the daily existence of the globally excluded. Semali and Kincheloe (1999) emphasize the potential indigenous knowledge has for a multiplicity of societal aspects in variegated establishments, and these societal aspects could be construed to include curriculum related issues. The IK Notes (2000), claims that the educational reforms that have been taking place in Africa have generally created space for new curricula, and, as such, an “ ‘indigenous curricula’ ” might come to utilize this space. To avoid ambiguity, let me quickly digress to synoptically explicate how I operationalize the construct curriculum in this discourse. I shall use curriculum relatively in a broad sense. Curriculum shall be used to mean the decision on and planning of what is to be taught, the practice of the what that has been decided on, and planned to be taught. Additionally, it shall include the experience of those who are exposed to what is taught in all educational levels, ranging from kindergarten to high school, and extending to include institutions of higher learning and other sites where different forms of education are practiced. Also, I have deemed the following extracts worthy of reproducing here because they aptly and succinctly reflect the sentiment I harbor pertaining to curriculum: [C]urriculum studies of indigenous knowledge involves epistemological questions relating to both the production and consumption of knowledge, the relationship between culture and what is defined as successful learning, the contestation of all forms of knowledge production and the purposes of education itself. (Mosha, 2000, p. xiii) The curriculum is socially and historically located, and culturally determined. Curriculum does not develop in a vacuum but proceeds on the basis of beliefs—seldom made explicit—about how people learn,
92
Nkosinathi Mkosi what human beings should be like, what society is. (Hooper cited in Forrest, 2000, p. 1)
The IK Notes suggest that the drive to promote African languages instruction, the gradual shifting of control toward local actors through decentralization of power, and the employment prospects of school leavers, have eroded the hegemony of the single standard Western curriculum and opened space for different and complementary approaches. Furthermore, I could infer from the Notes that innovative indigenous methods of community schooling could be applied within a formal educational framework. The list of dimensions of indigenous knowledge given by Williams and Muchena (1991) that may enrich curricula serves as a testimony to the potential of indigenous knowledge. The list contains the following as possible curricula areas that indigenous knowledge could enrich: physical sciences and related technologies (agriculture, ethnobotany, ethnoecology, medicine, climatology, engineering, irrigation), social sciences (politics, the military, economics, sociology, and ethnology), and humanities (communications, arts and crafts). The authors claim that the list is not even exhaustive of the possibilities of indigenous knowledge for curricula, and that it only serves as an illustration. From the list, it could be concluded that the potential indigenous knowledge has for enriching the curricula of educational disciplines is almost limitless. The Alaska Native Knowledge Network (http://www.ankn.uaf.edu.591/ cbcr.html) provides a “Curriculum Spiral Chart” cataloguing resources that illustrate ways that indigenous knowledge and Western knowledge might be combined in schools in a balanced, comprehensive, and culturally aligned curriculum framework that is possible to adapt to any local circumstances. African curricula designers could learn from this experience. Furthermore, Williams and Muchena (1991) claim that academics, development planners, and contributors to alternative development approaches have not efficiently analyzed the question of how indigenous knowledge systems might contribute to the discipline of agricultural education. They insist that indigenous knowledge systems could contribute to sustainable agriculture through agricultural education. These authors note that the combination of Western agricultural systems and indigenous knowledge systems might lead to an “emic-etic approach” to agricultural education, which might lead to a confluent curriculum (p. 54). Lovelace (cited in Williams and Muchena, 1991) describes an emic analysis of behavior or phenomenon as based on internal structural or functional elements of a particular cultural system,
Indigenous Knowledge and the Curriculum
93
and an etic analysis based on predetermined general concepts external to that cultural system. My interpretation is that notions, constructs, epistemologies, and practices of an “alien” culture that fall outside a particular indigenous culture, could be utilized in the indigenous culture to effect enhancement and to ensure an interface between the cultures. I would like to note that in Williams and Muchena’s scheme of things caution should be taken to be vigilant against the hegemony of one culture. On another forum, it may be informative to explore the question of how the dominance of one cultural system could be checked. Similar to Williams and Muchena, Mwadime (1999) seems to see something in the application of indigenous agricultural systems and traditional food processing methods. These indigenous agricultural systems and food processing methods could be incorporated into the agricultural curricula of all levels of education in South and North countries to, if nothing else, present learners with a multidimensional view of agricultural systems. Another significant implication of indigenous knowledge for educational research is the possibility of enriching these processes. Indigenous methods of enquiry may add a new viable dimension to the dominating Western methods and research tools used (Abdullah and Stringer, 1999). In that vein, indigenous knowledge could have profound potential for educational and social development that would also broaden the relevance of the dominant Western knowledges and epistemologies. In terms of the related issues of indigenous epistemologies, Archie Mafeje, who recently delivered the third annual ZK Matthews Memorial Lecture at the University of Fort Hare, South Africa, had some interesting points to say about the importance of indigenous ways of knowing (Thomas, 2004). Mafeje maintained that there is a need for new research protocols, a need to deconstruct the “received systems of knowledge [and ways of knowing]” (cited in Thomas, p. 1). It is then that there should be reconstruction. Furthermore, Mafeje cautioned South African universities about how they are still highly Eurocentric in their approach to education and knowledge formations, and that they do not strive enough for the “indigenization of knowledge— an approach encompassing, but broader than, the African Renaissance and Afro-centrism, and transcending disciplinary boundaries, while also incorporating indigenous methods and knowledge” (cited in Thomas, 2004, p. 1). I contend that these assumptions speak to all of Africa’s universities. Moreover, the implementation of indigenous knowledge might facilitate the elucidation of aspects rendered cloudy to indigenous students mainly due to a one-dimensional and culturally detached curriculum, and such implementation might counteract epistemicide, that is,
94
Nkosinathi Mkosi
the “destruction of the knowledge of a given social group” (Krijnik, 1999, p. 187). Mule (1999) and Quiroz (1999) also advance arguments that appear to concur with the preceding one. They claim that the inclusion of indigenous knowledge could make many curricula relevant to students, and might equip them with a cultural tool to make sense of the world in which they live. In addition, indigenous music education, as Abrokwaa (1999) observes, which comprises music history, practice, and repertoire, can also enrich school and university curricula. Additionally, African universities curricula could introduce—with rigor—programs that contain elements of indigenous knowledge systems (Barnhardt, 1991). Mwadime (1999) adds an interesting proposition to the equation when he contends that urbanized indigenous populations could be the focus of studies to establish what indigenous strategies they use to cope, and how they generate new knowledge or initiatives to address social problems. It might be a worthwhile activity to inquire about how indigenous knowledge could facilitate the survival of indigenous peoples in the Diaspora. It is on the basis of the preceding discussions and perspectives, therefore, that I see a great possibility for indigenous knowledge to contribute to the lessening of development problems that negatively impact upon the lives of the poor and the marginalized in, among other places, sub-Saharan Africa. By using indigenous knowledge systems, with other systems, in the educational situations in the continent, it may not be impossible to finally create culturally and socially viable spaces of learning, which could all be deployed to usher novel realities of sustainable social development. Again, since development appears to be a subject of contestation, I must state my conception of development in this discussion. I certainly do not subscribe to the inherent belief of the modernization paradigm that purports that “[t]o be ‘developed’ is to become like a rich-world society, especially the western variant” (Toh, 1988, p. 123). Rather, I would align myself with people-centered approaches, such as bottom-up development initiatives that are not focused on economic growth and top-down diffusion of growth impulses (Telfer, 2002). The development approach that I would subscribe to, therefore, is the one that has indigenousness as its primary focus, which should mean that it is community centered, locally conceived and controlled and, as Hashimoto (2002) notes fits the overall indigenous locality. Development not only means targeting socioeconomic, political, and educational problems of the African countries but also the deliberate targeting of the spiritual and cultural rejuvenation of African societies. The agenda of this development
Indigenous Knowledge and the Curriculum
95
ought to be set by the African people themselves, and the meanings attached to constructs associated with the development discourse ought to be people-generated and should not be imperatives and impositions originating from powerful external structures. One aspect of the positive development contributions that indigenous knowledge systems could make is in the area of environmental sustainability. George (1999) notes that indigenous knowledge could play a worthwhile role in environmental management, and might sensitize the exploiters of natural resources in Southern countries to the destruction and possible depletion of the environment. Indigenous knowledge could also educate them how the environmental integrity, in both the local and global situations, should be respected, honored, and valued. In this regard, Wane (2000) illustrates, to a degree, how indigenous knowledge could be beneficial in ecological settings. Wane observes that Kenyan women lament the destruction of medicinal flora owing to “modern farming practices” (pp. 62–63). Dei (2000) adds that incorporating indigenous knowledge holds significant possibilities for social and ecological sustainability. For example, findings by the Medical Research Council of South Africa on five South African plants that are used as traditional medicine, and that could be used to bring relief to those inflicted with HIV/AIDS, give credence to arguments in support of indigenous knowledge (Davids, 2003). One more significant contribution indigenous knowledge could make, is for cultural revaluing, as Semali (1999) notes, among indigenous peoples. I am reasonably convinced that the curriculum might contribute significantly in this regard. It appears axiomatic, therefore, that the introduction of the hegemonic Western knowledge through various historical and economical processes like colonization and globalization led to the invalidation and marginalization of indigenous cultures. I reiterate the thesis that the inclusion and revival of “indigenousness” in curricula and policies and practices of societal institutions might have profound effects on the spirituality of the poor. Williams and Muchena’s (1991) assertions that “there is a great need for a cultural system in the teaching-learning process, given the top-down approach and the assumed superiority of the technological transfer model in developing countries,” also appears relevant here (p. 54). That culture is a crucial feature in the formation of a peoples’ common identity should also be axiomatic, and that language, which mirrors culture because “it is self part of a culture” (Mufwene, 2001, p. 25), is “central to a people’s definition of themselves” (Ngugi wa Thiong’o cited in Mule, 1999, p. 235), is, indeed, a reasonable claim. Indigenous knowledge might provide the cultural link between schools, university,
96
N kosinathi Mkosi
and community. I deem this link salient because, for the most part, African indigenous learners are subjected to culturally alienating institutions that prioritize Western traditions, norms, and customs (Barnhardt, 1991). Indigenous knowledge—understood to be intimately linked to a people’s culture—could, therefore facilitate the spiritual rebirth, or a new project of “a cultural renaissance” (Davis and Partridge, 2001, p. 5) for marginalized African peoples to become self-actualizing communities and individuals with positive self-identities, partially achieved through the curriculum. Equally significant is the issue of underachieving students in schooling, an issue normally attributed to “cultural gaps” between the expectations of the school curriculum and those of the cultures in which the student is socialized (Thaman, 2000).
Conclusions It appears as if what is reflected and is not incorporated in the curriculum is symptomatic of the hegemonic struggles pertaining to knowledge, and therefore, indigenous knowledge might possibly be affected, positively or negatively, by these power struggles. Thus, an appeal could be made to those who are possessors of intellectual capital and power, and those in which political power is invested, to acknowledge the prospects of indigenous knowledge. To Wangoola (2000, p. 275), as explicated in his Mpambo (or African multiversity) project, it is the right time “to articulate a new synthesis between . . . indigenous knowledges and other knowledges.” Again, skeptics may cite economic factors as possible deterrents and roadblocks to the practical application of indigenous knowledge, as if indigenous knowledge and its inherent potential possibilities are newly discovered phenomena. They seem to postulate that the application of indigenous knowledge will require enormous and extraordinary financial and logistical resources to be effectively implemented, which may be viable at this point in time, but efforts should be made to achieve this important educational and development objective. Most of the resources are already in place, as had been indicated. In sum, there is so much that should be gained, indeed, harnessed, from indigenous peoples and their knowledges, and it is high time to reconcile these with conventional knowledges so as to serve the interests of humanity more effectively, and, undoubtedly, more inclusively.
References Abdullah, J. and Stringer, E. (1999). Indigenous knowledge, indigenous learning, indigenous research. In L.M. Semali and J.L. Kincheloe (Eds.),
Indigenous Knowledge and the Curriculum
97
What is indigenous knowledge? : Voices from the academy (pp. 143–155). New York: Falmer Press. Abrokwaa, C.K. (1999). Indigenous music education in Africa. In L.M. Semali and J.L. Kincheloe (Eds.), What is indigenous knowledge? : Voices from the academy (pp. 191–207). New York: Falmer Press. Agrawal, A. (1995). Dismantling the divide between indigenous and scientific knowledge. Development and Change, 26, 413–439. Alaska Native Knowledge Network. Welcome to culturally-based curriculum resources. Alaska Native Knowledge Network. Retrieved June 6, 2003 from http://www.ankn.uaf.edu/:591/cbcr3.html Barnhardt, R. (1991). Higher education in the fourth world: Indigenous people take control. Canadian Journal of Native Education, 18 (2): 1–20. Retrieved on June 18, 2003, from http://www.ankn.uaf.edu/winhec/ FourthWorld.html Castellano, M.B. (2000). Updating aboriginal traditions of knowledge. In G.J. Dei, B.L. Hall and D.G. Rosenberg (Eds.), Indigenous knowledges in global contexts: Multiple readings of our world (pp. 21–35). Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Davids, N. (March 30, 2003). Traditional cures hold seeds of hope. The Sunday Times, p. 1. Retrieved March 30, 2003, from http://sundaytimes.co.za/ 2003/03/30/news35.asp Davis, S. and Partridge, W. (2001). Promoting the development of indigenous peoples in Latin America. The World Bank Group, 1–5. Retrieved June 18, 2003 from http://wbln0018.worldbank.org/essd/essd.nsf/0/ 03f1bda268d0989d852567cc0077f60a? Dei, G.J. (2000). African development: The relevance and Implications of “Indigenousness.” In G.J.S. Dei, D.L. Hall and D.G. Rosenberg (Eds.), Indigenous knowledges in global contexts: Multiple readings of our world (pp. 70–86). Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Dei, G.J., Hall, D.L. and Rosenberg, D.G. (2000) (Eds.), Indigenous knowledges in global contexts: Multiple readings of our world. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Forrest, S. (April 3–7, 2000). Indigenous knowledge and its representation within Western Australia’s new curriculum Framework. [Refereed paper presented at the Australia Indigenous Education Conference, Fremantle]. Retrieved June 18, 2003 from http://www.kk.ecu.edu.au/sub/schoola/ research/confs/aiec/papers/sforrest02.htm George, J.M. (1999). Indigenous knowledge as a component of the school curriculum. In L.M. Semali and J.L. Kincheloe (Eds.), What is indigenous knowledge?: Voices from the academy (pp. 79–94). New York: Falmer Press. Hashimoto, A. (2002). Tourism and socio-cultural development issues. In R. Sharpley and D. Tefler (Eds.), Tourism and development: Concepts and issues (pp. 202–230). Tonawanda, New York: Channel View Publications. IK Notes (2000, July). Indigenous knowledge goes to school: Potential and perils of community education in the Western Sahel. IK Notes, No. 2. Retrieved June 18, 2003, from www.worldbank.org/afr/ik/iknt22.pdf
98
N kosinathi Mkosi
Jegede, O.J. (1999). Science education in nonwestern cultures: Towards a theory of collateral learning. In L.M. Semali and J.L. Kincheloe (Eds.), What is indigenous knowledge? : Voices from the academy (pp. 119–142). New York: Falmer Press. Kawell, J. (2002, March/April). Who owns knowledge? NACLA Report on the Americas, 35 (1): 1–4. Retrieved January 28, 2003, from Academic Premier Search databases. Available at the University of Alberta web site. Krijnik, G. (1999). Indigenous knowledge and ethnomathematics in the Brazilian landless people Education. In L.M. Semali and J.L. Kincheloe (Eds.), What is indigenous knowledge? : Voices from the academy (pp. 179–189). New York: Falmer Press. Maurial, M. (1999). Indigenous knowledge and schooling: A continuum between conflict and dialogue. In L.M. Semali and J.L. Kincheloe (Eds.), What is indigenous knowledge? : Voices from the academy (pp. 59–77). New York: Falmer Press. Mosha, R.S. (1999). The inseparable link between intellectual and spiritual formation of indigenous knowledge and education: A case study in Tanzania. In L.M. Semali and J.L. Kincheloe (Eds.), What is indigenous knowledge?: Voices from the academy (pp. 209–223). New York: Falmer Press. Mosha, R.S. (2000). The heartbeat of indigenous Africa: A study of the Chagga educational system. New York & London: Garland Publishing. Mufwene, S.S. (2001). Colonization, globalization, and the future of languages in the twenty-first century. 1–53. Retrieved February 7, 2003 from http:// www.humanities.uchicago.edu/faculty/mufwene/mufw_colonization.html Mule, L. (1999). Indigenous languages in the school curriculum: What happened to Kiswahili in Kenya? In L.M. Semali and J.L. Kincheloe (Eds.), What is indigenous knowledge? : Voices from the academy (pp. 227–242). New York: Falmer Press. Mwadime, R.K. (1999). Indigenous knowledge systems for an alternative culture in science: The role of nutritionists in Africa. In L.M. Semali and J.L. Kincheloe (Eds.), What is indigenous knowledge? : Voices from the academy (pp. 243–267). New York: Falmer Press. Parrish, A.M. (1999) Agricultural extension education and the transfer of knowledge in an Egyptian oasis. In L.M. Semali and J.L. Kincheloe (Eds.), What is indigenous knowledge? : Voices from the academy (pp. 269–283). New York: Falmer Press. Prakash, M.S. (1999). Indigenous knowledge systems-ecological literacy through initiation into people’s science. In L.M. Semali and J.L. Kincheloe (Eds.), What is indigenous knowledge? : Voices from the academy (pp. 157–178). New York: Falmer Press. Quiroz, C. (1999). Local knowledge systems and vocational education in developing countries. In L.M. Semali and J.L. Kincheloe (Eds.), What is indigenous knowledge? : Voices from the academy (pp. 269–283). New York: Falmer Press. Reynar, R. (1999). Indigenous people’s knowledge and education: A tool for development. In L.M. Semali and J.L. Kincheloe (Eds.), What is indigenous
Indigenous Knowledge and the Curriculum
99
knowledge? : Voices from the academy (pp. 269–283). New York: Falmer Press. Semali, L.M. (1999). Community as classroom: (Re)valuing indigenous literacy. In L.M. Semali and J.L. Kincheloe (Eds.), What is indigenous knowledge? : Voices from the academy (pp. 95–118). New York: Falmer Press. Semali, L.M., and Kincheloe, J.L. (1999). Introduction: What is indigenous knowledge and why should we study it? In L.M. Semali and J.L. Kincheloe (Eds.), What is indigenous knowledge? : Voices from the academy (pp. 3–57). New York: Falmer Press. Shiva, N. (2000). Foreword: Cultural diversity and the politics of knowledge. In G.J. Dei, B.L. Hall and D.G. Rosenberg (Eds.), Indigenous knowledges in global contexts: Multiple readings of our world (pp. vii–x). Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Sillitoe, P. (December, 2000). Let them eat cake: Indigenous knowledge, science and the “Poorest of the poor.” Anthropology Today, 1–8. Retrieved January 28, 2003, from Academic Premier Search databases. Available at the University of Alberta web site. Telfer, D. (2002). The evolution of tourism and development theory. In R. Sharpley and D. Tefler (Eds.), Tourism and development: Concepts and issues (pp. 35–80). Tonawanda, New York: Channel View Publications. Thaman, K.H. (2000). Interfacing global and indigenous knowledge for improved learning. [Paper presented at the UNESCO-APEID International Conference on Education]. Retrieved June 18, 2003 from http:// unescobkk.org/education/aceid/Conference/Panel/_2/Thaman.doc Thomas, C. (January 20, 2004). Mafeje confronts higher education. Fort Hare Today, 1–3. Retrieved March 10, 2004, from http://www.ufh.ac.za/ news_view.asp?newsref⫽133 Toh, S. (1988). Justice and development. In D. Hicks (Ed.), Education for peace (pp. 119–135). London, UK: Routledge. Wane, N.N. (2000). Indigenous knowledge: Lessons from the elders—A Kenyan case study. In G.J. Dei, B.L. Hall and D.G. Rosenberg (Eds.), Indigenous knowledges in global contexts: Multiple readings of our world (pp. 54–67). Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Wangoola, P. (2000). Mpambo, the African multiversity: A philosophy to rekindle the African spirit. In G.J. Dei, B.L. Hall and D.G. Rosenberg (Eds.), Indigenous knowledges in global contexts: Multiple readings of our world (pp. 265–277). Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Williams, D.L. and Muchena, O.N. (1991). Utilizing indigenous knowledge systems in agricultural education to promote sustainable agriculture. Journal of Agricultural education, 32 (4): 52–56.
This page intentionally left blank
6
L anguage Issues in African S chool Set tings: Problems and Prospects in At taining Education For All Ailie Cleghorn
This chapter explores some key issues relating to the language-in-
education debate, with special reference to sub-Saharan anglophone Africa.1 The issues to be discussed are pedagogical, economic, and political in nature; they are looked at in terms of the problems that language can pose for teachers and learners as well as in terms of some possible solutions.
Background: The Language-in-Education Debate The language-in-education debate touches on economic, political, and pedagogical factors in complex ways. In countries where many different home languages are spoken, the debate tends to center on the choice of language for initial instruction.2 The trend until recently has been to select the former colonial language, especially when classes are made up of learners from several language backgrounds, and, when there are few if any text materials available in local languages.3 English has thus been the language of choice in most Eastern and Southern African countries, French the language of choice in many of the former colonies of West Africa, and Portuguese the language of choice in Mozambique and Angola. Some politicians have argued in favor of the former colonial language due to the perceived risk of rivalry between the different
102
A ilie Cleghorn
ethnic groups should one language be chosen over another. Critical theorists counter this point as evidence that the hegemony of the West persists through the minds of the Ministry and other policy makers (see chapter 10 by Diaw and chapter 8 by Egbo in this volume). Regardless, when a former colonial language such as English is used as the language of instruction (LOI), especially in a “submersion” manner, difficult pedagogical, social, and teacher education problems arise. The particular purpose of this chapter is to highlight the critical role that language serves to play in bringing about Education for All (EFA) (UNESCO, 2000). EFA requires that language be used effectively to bring about understanding of subject content as well as providing learners with access to whatever language of wider communication is needed for higher education and/or global participation. In the absence of a wellthought-out and effective bilingual program (Benson, 2004), this may mean using the learner’s home language (L1) from the first grade until the end of the primary cycle, at least. At other times it may mean grouping students in the classroom according to the language they know best so that those who understand what has been taught via the LOI can explain the meaning to their peers. It may mean that the teacher uses code-switching so that those whose knowledge of the instructional language is limited, have a chance to hear the ideas reformulated or translated in their own language. Thus, the position taken here is that there are various strategies that can be employed to create meaningful learning contexts. When learning is meaningful, motivation to stay in school to learn more is fostered (Wells, 1999). One of the aims of EFA is to increase the number of years that young people stay in school; schooling takes on added meaning if the learner’s own language (L1) is not only used at school but is an important part of the curriculum from the earliest primary grades, in a climate that promotes literacy in the L1 and L2. It is via the use of the local (L1) as well the official instructional language (LOI/L2) that access to both local and global knowledge may be provided. The sociocultural/linguistic contexts of schooling in most African countries vary along a number of dimensions, according to such matters as whether or not a school is located in a rural, urban, or semi-urban area. The language environment of the school in each type of locale varies accordingly, for example in terms of the amount of out-of-school exposure to spoken or written forms of the LOI. In addition, there is a sharp economic and lifestyle gradient between urban and rural life in most parts of Africa. Thus, in anglophone African urban school settings, English may be considered a second language because of its use in the immediate environment for business and commerce as well as for
L anguage Issues in African S chool
103
communication between the speakers of different African languages who populate the cities. Under these circumstances there may be relatively frequent exposure to English and increasingly through the media and the internet, providing learners with evident reasons to acquire English as an L2. In contrast, in rural areas English may be considered a foreign language since it is not often used in the local community; then, out-of-school exposure to spoken or written forms of English is likely to be rare. While the second language/foreign language distinction may be too sharp, it is important for understanding the range of learners’ language experiences, and for thinking about language-ineducation policies as these relate in particular to the training of regular teachers as well as teachers of English-as-a-second-language (Cleghorn and Rollnick, 2002; Johnson and Swain, 1997). The role of culture in language learning deserves more than a brief mention. The point to establish here is when learners move from L1 situations (home community) to L2 situations (school), much more than language changes: often the content of available books is foreign, and many of the concepts taught in school are foreign, sometimes lacking familiar equivalents in the local language and culture. In addition, there may be a gap between the home-based norms governing interaction between children and adults and the normative expectations for behavior at school (Shumba, 1999a and b). Economic Considerations Numerous studies of instruction in African schools give evidence of patterns of instruction that can be attributed indirectly to persistent poverty (Cleghorn, 1992; Cleghorn, Merritt and Abagi, 1989; Dube and Cleghorn, 1999; Fuller and Snyder, 1991; Prophet and Rowell, 1990; Rubagumya, 1994; Shumba, 1999b). In Kenya, Zimbabwe, and Botswana, for example, the demand for schooling over the last 20 years has far outstripped the ability of governments to train sufficient number of teachers and to provide enough space at the secondary level to allow EFA to be realized (UNESCO, 2000). As a result, primary level classes may contain as many as 90 pupils; to meet the demand teachers must sometimes be deployed before they are trained at all. The proliferation of in-service and distance teacher certification courses in several countries is attempting to fill the training gap without taking teachers out of the classrooms. As yet however, it is rare to find language learning or other subject specialists at the primary level, where one could argue they are most needed.
104
A ilie Cleghorn
Economic factors interact with language issues as well as with established ways of evaluating student achievement. End-of-primary national examinations, for example, tend to act as the main selection device for the number of primary school graduates for whom there are secondary school seats (World Bank, 1997). In some countries, this means that up to 70 percent of primary school students must “fail” because the examination pass mark is set to include only the number for whom there are available spaces. The result is that there are a large number of students whose schooling terminates at the primary level, virtually cutting off the full development of literacy and numeracy skills as well as the eventual chance for decently paid work in the formal sector, possibly affecting their self-esteem and hope for the future (Hewlett, 1995). These students add to the dropout rate but should actually be considered push-outs.4 The meaning attached to school-dropout/push-out is enormous; life chances come to an end. This is reflected in the fierce competition that arises within and between schools in some countries due to the publication of examination results by region and by school, with further competition ensuing to gain entry to the top ranking schools. Teachers also are evaluated by this ranking, thus teaching is sometimes overly oriented to examinations, with old examinations taking the place of lesson plans, teacher creativity, and curriculum innovation. Since the LOI-only examinations are often multiple choice in format requiring short, fixed answers, instruction tends to emphasize rote question and answer routines requiring single word answers so that students are prepared to recognize the key (English) words in the examination.5 Although much more could be said about patterns of classroom discourse (see Arthur, 1994, 1996; Fuller and Snyder, 1991; Hornberger and Chick, 2001; Wright, 2001) there is ample evidence to suggest that the focus on examinations tends to reinforce less than effective instructional patterns (Cleghorn, 2003; Mbatha, 2003). Political Considerations The language-in-education debate is also heavily political, not only in Africa but in other parts of the world such as the United States where speakers of different languages come together and the language or languages to be used in school are not fully agreed upon (Beykont, 2000; Cummins and Corson, 1997). What is deemed best by politicians for the society as a whole is often at odds with what researchers consider best for individual learners; educators, teachers, parents, and learners get caught in the middle. Complicating the matter further is the pressure imposed by the widespread status of English as well as a popular
L anguage Issues in African S chool
105
misconception that the use of the L1 in school will impede children’s learning. For example, one set of studies carried out in Zimbabwe found that rural parents, school heads, and teachers favored the use of English as early as preschool even though the L1, Shona, was shared by all concerned and could have been used exclusively or bilingually along with English (Alexander, 1992; Cleghorn and Prochner, 2003; Prochner, 2002). An earlier study in Kenya found that the constant presence of school inspectors in an urban area reinforced teachers’ inclination to “stick to English” even where Kiswahili might just as easily have been used as an L1/LOI (Cleghorn, Merritt and Abagi, 1989). The “push” for English as early as possible is not based on sound evidence but on a faulty understanding of what is required for social mobility (to “get ahead”). In fact, there is ample research evidence that bilingually taught children perform better, both in subject matter learning, and in learning the L2 (Benson, 2004; Bunyi, 1999; Cummins, 1996; Durgunoglu and Verhoeven, 1998; Genesee, 1987 and 1993; Hovens, 2002; Johnson and Swain, 1997; Lightbown and Spada, 1999; Rollnick, 2000; Stroud, 2002). The pressure to teach exclusively via English in some African countries may be related to postcolonial matters of elitism, reflecting the wish of some policy makers to be associated with the power of English. This may be why the voices of politicians, researchers, teachers, and parents tend to fall on each others’ deaf ears. There is however, an urgent need for open dialogue and mutual understanding so that both individual and societal requirements are addressed. Two suggestions for language policy makers follow. First, consideration should be given to decentralizing languagein-education policy to allow for rural–urban diversity in school populations and the varied language environments of schools. That is, schooling might be more effective for all if school communities (including parents) were to determine which language or languages would best meet the learners’ needs. Second, knowledge of subject matter needs to be disentangled from the language of examinations. Subject matter knowledge could be tested via the language that students know best (orally if necessary), while understanding, speaking, reading, and writing abilities in the L2/LOI could be tested independently, as a subject. In this regard, it is important for the reader to understand that knowledge among second language learners is not directly tied to the language it has been taught in, but rather becomes integrated within the context of the L1 (Cummins and Corson, 1997). Hence, what is known is more easily expressed via the language with which a person is most comfortable.
106
A ilie Cleghorn
Pedagogical Considerations: Language and Culture Meet in the Classroom Studies on the teaching of science and mathematics via English in African classrooms (Adler, 1998; Clark and Ramahlape, 1999; Cleghorn et al., 1998; Sanders, 1997; Shumba, 1999 a and b) provide insight into the complex manner in which language and culture meet in the classroom, requiring teachers and learners to “travel” between languages and cultures in a process that has been referred to as border crossing (Aikenhead and Jegede, 1999; Cobern, 1998; Giroux, 1992; Heath, 1983). Border crossing refers to the ability to shift cognitively as well as culturally from one worldview to another. Worldview refers to the taken-for-granted understandings that each cultural group holds about the natural world; it refers to a fundamental organization of the mind, a way of looking, and of understanding (Cobern, 1998).The difference between the worldview represented by the school and the worldview that stems from the home community may be inconsequential if children have been exposed through the media or in preschool about what to expect in school. Where this exposure has not been available, as in some rural African communities, the difference between the home and school worldviews may be great, creating an hazardous if not impossible journey from one to the other, greatly exacerbated by instruction in a not yet mastered L2. When the concept of border crossing is applied to teaching situations in which essentially foreign curricula are taught via a former colonial L2, it is necessary for the learner to cross linguistic, cultural, and cognitive borders in order to understand what is taught. Teaching thus becomes a form of cultural transmission and learning a form of acculturation, culture here being defined in terms of a system of meaning and symbols, including ways of thinking and views of the nature of phenomena (Aikenhead, 1996; Geertz, 1973; Ogawa, 1998; Waldrip and Taylor, 1999). Some would argue that this process is akin to oppression coming through the globalization of Western-style schooling (Diaw, 2002; wa Thiong’o, 1987; see also Abagi, chapter 16 this book). The foregoing comments bring us to Vygotsky’s (1978, 1986) position that the role of the teacher is to guide the learner beyond what he/she knows or could learn on his or her own (the zone of proximal development—ZPD). Teaching and learning thus link social action (interaction) with cognition. The principal goal then is to provide “an environment in which students, however diverse their backgrounds, engage collaboratively in productive, purposeful activities which enable them to take over the culture’s tool-kit of skills, knowledge and values
L anguage Issues in African S chool
107
(my emphasis) so that they are able to participate effectively in the practices of the larger society” (Wells, 1999, p. 335). This well accepted theory which evolved out of monocultural/lingual school conditions in the West, is thrown into question when education comes via an L2 and the content of