IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937 ‘The Desired Haven’ ‘I have at last reached the desired haven’, exclaimed Belf...
49 downloads
968 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937 ‘The Desired Haven’ ‘I have at last reached the desired haven’, exclaimed Belfast-born Bessie Macready in 1878, the year of her arrival at Lyttelton, when writing home to cousins in County Down. Utilising fascinating personal correspondence exchanged between Ireland and New Zealand, this book explores individual responses to migration during the period of the great European emigrations across the world. It addresses a number of central questions in migration history such as the circumstances of departure, the prevalence of return and repeat migration, and reasons for staying. Moreover, how did migrant letter writers depict their voyage out, the environment, work, family and neighbours, politics, and faith? In answering these questions the book gives significant attention to the social networks constraining and enabling migrants. The book represents an innovative and original contribution to the history of European migration between the mid-nineteenth century and the interwar years. It addresses broader debates in the history of European migration relating to the use of personal testimony to chart the experiences of emigrants and the uncertain processes of adaptation, incorporation, and adjustment that migrants underwent in new and sometimes unfamiliar environments. The book also adds to the ever-increasing historiography of the Irish abroad. Angela McCarthy currently holds the J. D. Stout Research Fellowship in New Zealand Studies at Victoria University, Wellington, New Zealand. She has published numerous articles on aspects of Irish and Scottish migration in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries and with Enda Delaney is writing Distant Voices: Life Stories of Migrants from Ireland and Scotland, 1920–1960.
Irish Historical Monographs ISSN 1740–1097 Series editors: Marie Therese Flanagan, Queen’s University, Belfast Eunan O’Halphin, Trinity College, Dublin David Hayton, Queen’s University, Belfast
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937 ‘The Desired Haven’
Angela McCarthy
THE BOYDELL PRESS
© Angela McCarthy 2005 All Rights Reserved. Except as permitted under current legislation no part of this work may be photocopied, stored in a retrieval system, published, performed in public, adapted, broadcast, transmitted, recorded or reproduced in any form or by any means, without the prior permission of the copyright owner The right of Angela McCarthy to be identified as the author of this work has been asserted in accordance with sections 77 and 78 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 First published 2005 The Boydell Press, Woodbridge ISBN 1 84383 143 0 The Boydell Press is an imprint of Boydell & Brewer Ltd PO Box 9, Woodbridge, Suffolk IP12 3DF, UK and of Boydell & Brewer Inc. 668 Mt Hope Avenue, Rochester, NY 14620, USA website: www.boydellandbrewer.com A CIP catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data McCarthy, Angela, 1971Irish migrants in New Zealand, 1840-1937 : ‘the desired haven’ / Angela McCarthy. p. cm. — (Irish historical monographs series, ISSN 1740-1097) Summary: “Study of individual experiences of migration through personal correspondence of emigrants from Ireland to New Zealand”—Provided by publisher. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 1-84383-143-0 (hardback : alk. paper) 1. Irish—New Zealand—Correspondence. 2. Irish—New Zealand—History— Sources. 3. Immigrants—New Zealand—Correspondence. 4. Immigrants—New Zealand—History—Sources. 5. Ireland—Emigration and immigration—History— Sources. 6. New Zealand—Emigration and immigration—History—Sources. 7. New Zealand—Ethnic relations. I. Title. II. Series. DU424.5.I74M38 2005 305.891’62093’0922—dc22
2004030870
This publicationDisclaimer: is printed on acid-free paper Some images in the printed of this book are Lodge, not available for inclusion in the eBook. Typeset byversion Keystroke, Jacaranda Wolverhampton To view these imagesPrinted please refer to theBritain printed by version of this book. in Great St Edmundsbury Press Ltd, Bury St Edmunds, Suffolk
Contents
List of illustrations Acknowledgements Abbreviations Editorial notes
vii viii x xi
Introduction 1
1
‘It is well to gain that shore’: Irish migration and New Zealand settlement
50
‘Very perfection of a letter writer’: an overview of Irish–New Zealand correspondence
81
3
‘Seas may divide’: the voyage
97
4
‘How different it is from home’: comparing Ireland and New Zealand
5
‘No rough work here like at home’: work in New Zealand and Ireland 145
6
‘Bands of fellowship’: familial relations and social networks in New Zealand
166
‘I must have you home’: return migration, home, and relationships in Ireland
190
‘Never denie your country’: politics and identity in the Old and New Worlds
210
‘Out of darkness into light’: the importance of faith
236
Conclusion
262
Appendix Bibliography Personal name index Place name index Thematic index
266 281 301 308 310
2
7 8 9
v
120
For my mother and grandmother with much love and in fond memory of Canon John Cameron (1926–2000)
Illustrations
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
Irish origins of emigrant correspondents New Zealand destinations of emigrant correspondents Lizzie Ayson (formerly Ferguson) Philip Carroll Michael Flanagan Rose and Charles Gamble Hamilton, Henry, Samuel, Robert, and John Gilmer John Gilmore with his family, c. 1890 Alice Fenton (formerly Gilmore), c. 1925 Thomas William Hughes Michael and Bridget Harty (formerly Keane) David and Margaret Anne Kilpatrick outside their Newton Road house in Auckland, c. 1903 The family of Agnes and Michael Lambert, c. 1877 The Heldt family Emily, Edith, Jim, Eliza, Olive, and Frank McIlrath at Thorndale, Springfield, Canterbury, 1901 Hamilton and Eliza McIlrath, with two of their children Alexander Neil McKelvey Ellen Maher (formerly Piezzi and Walsh) in her hotel with her sons and daughter
9 12 14 16 20 22 24 26 27 28 30 31 33 36 39 40 41 45
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view these images please refer to the printed version of this book.
vii
Acknowledgements
This book began as a doctoral thesis in the Department of History at Trinity College, Dublin. I am especially grateful to my supervisor, Professor David Fitzpatrick, whose evocative edition of Irish–Australian correspondence inspired the project. He also generously shared several collections of letters used in this book. Lyndon Fraser likewise supplied wise counsel during the thesis stage, and I am deeply appreciative of his enthusiastic support of and interest in this study, which included sourcing several research materials in New Zealand and commenting on most of the manuscript. The initial process of revising the thesis into a book was made possible by the financial support of the New Zealand Federation of Graduate Women (Auckland Branch) who in 2001 awarded the project one of two inaugural Millennium Research Fund Awards. I am deeply grateful to the Branch and also to the Department of History at the University of Auckland for providing me with essential facilities to make substantial preliminary modifications. In particular, I would like to thank Malcolm Campbell, Caroline Daley, and Hugh Laracy, all of whom supplied succinct comment on several chapters. The final process of revision took place at the AHRB Centre for Irish and Scottish Studies at the University of Aberdeen. I would especially like to acknowledge the enthusiastic assistance and invaluable attentiveness of Enda Delaney, who generously and perceptively scrutinised the final draft, offering many fruitful insights that enriched this present study. Enda’s unstinting belief in this project and warm encouragement during disheartening times have been uplifting. Other individuals helped in a myriad of ways. I would therefore like to thank John Bassett, Rory Sweetman, Alasdair Galbraith, Séan Brosnahan, Richard Herbert, Ray Dobson, Lyn Wright, Mary Ryan, Annette McKee, Jim Herlihy, and Dominic Ryan. Several institutions generously waived their fees and provided immense assistance that greatly facilitated this study. I am therefore happy to acknowledge the Central Registry Office, New Zealand, for allowing me access to their birth, death, and marriage records; the University of Auckland Library, for lending privileges; Auckland Catholic Diocese Archives; the Irish Valuation Office; and Limerick Archives. I am also grateful for the assistance provided by Walter Guttery of the New Zealand Defence Force; Alex Ward, viii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
archivist of the Grand Lodge of Ireland; S. J. Cooper from the Grand Lodge of New Zealand Freemasons; and Roderick Milne, P.P. Otaki. The following institutions kindly provided permission to reproduce various documents and illustrations in their care: Alexander Turnbull Library, Archives of the Anglican Diocese of Auckland, Canterbury Museum, National Archives Auckland and Wellington, National Archives Ireland, National Library Ireland, Nelson Provincial Museum, and the Public Record Office of Northern Ireland. Deep appreciation is due to the descendants of the writers and recipients at the heart of this study who generously shared their letters and knowledge. I therefore wish to thank Ann Gilmore Adams, Ned Andrews, Beverley Baird, Pamela Bates, Tom Bell, Reg Brown and Rene Brown, Br Philip Carroll, O.F.M., John Coghlan, Ginny Dow, Orma Fairweather, Lena Fraser, Alice Gemming, Sandra Gilpin, Joan Graham, Catherine Habes, Jenny Hardiman, Richard Herbert, Moore Fisher Johnston, Alan Kilpatrick, Garry Lambert, Patrick Lambert and Helen Lambert, Jenny Langford, Noelene Lavin, Joan Leonard, Suzanne Lisson, John Martin, Vera Major, Virginia McClennan, David McKelvey, Donald Murphy, Tom Murphy, Lorna Neame, Mabel K. Neame, Michael O’Brien, Teresa O’Connor, Molly O’Dwyer, Margaret O’Neil, Peter O’Sullivan, Gwenda Pakenham-Hughes, Dennis Regan, Juann Ryan, Leone Shaw, Mary Slavin, and Gary Walsh. Alas, a great debt that I left too late to acknowledge personally is to Canon John Cameron whose inspired teaching first sparked my interest in history. This book is warmly dedicated to his memory. It is also dedicated with much love to my mother and grandmother for always being there. And a woof for Murph! Angela McCarthy Wellington
ix
Abbreviations
A.C.D.A. A.J.H.R. A.T.L. H.C.P. I.V.O. N.A.A. N.A.C. N.A.D. N.A.I. N.A.W. N.L.I. N.Z.J.H. P.P. P.R.O.N.I. R.C.B.L.
Auckland Catholic Diocese Archives Appendices to the Journals of the House of Representatives Alexander Turnbull Library, Wellington House of Commons, Papers Irish Valuation Office, Dublin National Archives, Auckland National Archives, Christchurch National Archives, Dunedin National Archives, Ireland National Archives, Wellington National Library of Ireland, Dublin New Zealand Journal of History Parish priest Public Record Office of Northern Ireland, Belfast Representative Church Body Library, Dublin
x
Editorial notes
Citations from letters studied in this book are indicated with a reference such as Ar 1. This example refers to John Armstrong’s first letter. These citations can be followed by referring to the Appendix which provides a breakdown of the writer, recipient, and date that the letter was composed. Reproduction of the spelling and grammar contained in the original letters remains unaltered though sentence and paragraph breaks have been incorporated. Editorial excisions have been kept to a minimum but are as follows: Clarifications: Authentic oddities: Illegible words: Illegible words with suggestion: Elements lost through mutilation: Words deleted or omitted:
thos are too mats [those are two mates] untill; in in. [word illegible] [?favour] marr[ied] [erased: to] [omitted: to]
xi
Introduction
In 1878 Bessie Macready, a 28-year-old Belfast orphan, travelled for 79 days on the Pleiades to her maternal aunts, Elizabeth and Sarah McMain, residing at Governors Bay, near Christchurch. Shortly after her arrival Bessie wrote to her cousins in Ireland declaring blissfully, ‘I have travelled over about fifteen thousand miles of water and at last got to the desired haven’ (Ma 1).1 Many Irish emigrants settling in New Zealand shared Bessie Macready’s initial rapturous view of the country as a south pacific paradise, an arcadia, a utopia. But did such favourable impressions linger? Three years after her arrival Bessie Macready sent a vivid outline of colonial life to her cousins. In it she admitted to having spent ‘many a weary time’ managing a shop in Lyttelton, but acknowledged optimistically, ‘I was gaining something and that enabled me to bear up in prospect of a happier future’ (Ma 3). For Bessie Macready this future entailed a stint as housekeeper for a wealthy Christchurch family, an interlude teaching at Governors Bay school, and then a period as dressmaker.2 After her death Bessie was recollected as ‘a cultured Irishwoman with a flair for astronomy. She was tall and dignified and wore beaded mittens and a black dolman with a ruffle around the neck’.3 Regrettably, Bessie Macready’s bubbly, sanguine voice falls silent after 1881. Other sources, however, suggest that colonial life had turned sour. ‘Recluse Dies’ the Lyttelton Times announced audaciously upon learning of Bessie Macready’s death in October 1926. Bessie’s grocer, who called every Friday, discovered the deceased 82-year-old in her home at Governors Bay. He instantly summoned the local policeman who described her corpse as ‘half starved’. The Mount Herbert Council County Clerk, meanwhile, testified bleakly at Bessie’s inquest, ‘Those who knew her were of opinion that she was
1
Extracts from Bessie Macready’s letters, T/3034/1–2, and others held at the Public Record Office of Northern Ireland (P.R.O.N.I.), are kindly reproduced by permission of the Deputy Keeper of the Records, P.R.O.N.I. 2 I am grateful to Lyn Wright for confirming Bessie’s brief stint as a schoolteacher. 3 C. E. Burrell, ‘Governors Bay has a romantic history’, Auckland Weekly News, undated. Typed extract in the possession of Allison Hussey of Governors Bay and kindly brought to my attention by Lyn Wright. 1
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
not taking proper care of herself’.4 Bessie was buried at St Cuthbert’s Anglican churchyard at Governors Bay. Bessie Macready’s last years mirror widespread and influential interpretations of migration as a destabilising process. Her initial reunion with her aunts, followed by their deaths, and her apparent descent into seclusion, echoes Patrick O’Farrell’s analysis of the Irish who ‘brought their kinship mentality to Australia, where it gradually crumbled and fell apart, declining into a residual social atomism marked by separation, isolation, loneliness and eventual alienation of society’s individual parts’.5 This focus on migrant homesickness and alienation also characterises studies of the Irish in North America. Incorporating extracts from Irish emigrant letters sent from North America, together with other personal documents, Kerby Miller contends, ‘Acute homesickness pervaded the letters and journals of most post-Famine emigrants’.6 These depictions of migration involving alienation likewise feature in studies of New Zealand society. In their collection of extracts from the writings of European women in nineteenth-century New Zealand, Frances Porter and Charlotte Macdonald argue that migration was ‘inherently destabilising’, that ‘family ties were to be shrugged off, or were no longer there . . . . It was a place to establish new connections’, and that there was a ‘lack of society’.7 Their grim claims echo Miles Fairburn’s penetrating portrayal of New Zealand’s social organisation as ‘gravely deficient’. According to Fairburn, ‘Community structures were few and weak and the forces of social isolation were many and powerful. Bondlessness was central to colonial life’.8 A significant cause of this atomisation, Fairburn maintains, was that ‘most colonists . . . had already severed their links with place, family, friends, community in the great uprooting that led them to New Zealand’.9 This book provides further support for an alternative portrait. Like recent studies of robust kin-oriented communities at New Plymouth, Waipu, Christchurch, and Taradale, it challenges representations of mid to late nineteenth-century New Zealand as a kinless, atomised society.10 It argues that
4
J46 1926/1235 Macready, Coroner’s Report, N.A.W. Patrick O’Farrell, Letters from Irish Australia, 1825–1929 (Kensington, 1984), p. 6. 6 Kerby A. Miller, Emigrants and exiles: Ireland and the Irish exodus to North America (New York, 1985), p. 512. 7 Frances Porter and Charlotte Macdonald (eds), ‘My hand will write what my heart dictates’: the unsettled lives of women in nineteenth-century New Zealand as revealed to sisters, family, and friends (Auckland, 1996), pp 3, 386–7, 6. 8 Miles Fairburn, The ideal society and its enemies: the foundations of modern New Zealand society, 1850–1900 (Auckland, 1989), p. 11. 9 Ibid., p. 94. 10 Raewyn Dalziel, ‘Emigration and kinship: migrants to New Plymouth, 1840–1843’ in N.Z.J.H., xxv (1991), pp 112–28; Maureen Molloy, Those who speak to the heart: the Nova Scotian Scots at Waipu, 1854–1920 (Palmerston North, 1991); Lyndon Fraser, To Tara via 5
2
INTRODUCTION
many Irish men and women made their decision to leave Ireland and settle in New Zealand based on the guidance of pioneering migrants. These connexions not only directed and sustained Irish migration to New Zealand shores, but also were central to the process of migrant adjustment. Though Bessie Macready’s experience reminds us that settlement abroad could be an isolating experience, other personal stories illuminate another, more positive, aspect of the migration saga. Drawing upon 253 personal letters, together with genealogical material and local sources, this book examines individual accounts of migration. It poses the questions: why did Irish men and women leave Ireland? Why did some of their connexions choose to stay? How did migrant letter writers depict their voyage out, the environment, work, family and neighbours, politics, and faith? How did their representations compare with accounts sent by their family and friends in Ireland? Did contemporary reports from Ireland suggest that settlement abroad had been a worthwhile undertaking? Or was return and repeat migration prevalent? Personal letters offer illuminating insights into such questions. So long as their manipulative function is recognised, they are largely trustworthy sources, for the robust network element involved in Irish migration inevitably meant that the writer’s true condition would be learned. Letters are also a valuable source for information about those who chose not to write or who were illiterate. In using private correspondence, however, we should place the commentary in context by establishing the relationship between writers and recipients, and taking into account background and foreground circumstances. Regrettably, only a few thousand letters have survived in relation to the millions of letters that were exchanged throughout all parts of the Irish diaspora. The hazards of fire, flood, and dampness presumably destroyed many letters while their fragility meant that others were easily torn, lost, or discarded. More significantly, the preservation instincts, or lack thereof, of subsequent generations have also influenced the survival of personal correspondence. Letters that have escaped routine housekeeping tasks or been sold for the sake of a stamp have therefore been deliberately preserved, possibly for genealogical or historical interest. Other letters have survived largely by accident, discovered decades later by curious family historians. Given the mechanisms by which private correspondence has endured, those letters that have survived are exceptional, and therefore unlikely to be representative of all the letters sent throughout the Irish diaspora. Nor can the surviving correspondence be offered as a representative sample of letter writers or participants in the migration process. Nonetheless, personal letters remain an essential source for
Holyhead: Irish Catholic immigrants in nineteenth-century Christchurch (Auckland, 1997); Caroline Daley, Girls and women, men and boys: gender in Taradale, 1886–1930 (Auckland, 1999). 3
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
discovering the diverse responses of migrant and non-migrant correspondents to migration. Despite the potential offered by personal letters to explore aspects of New Zealand and Irish society, migrants’ private correspondence has been largely neglected by previous historians of Irish-New Zealand.11 Instead, most scholars have used other sources and approaches to examine the lives of Irish migrants in New Zealand.12 Parish registers and church records have proved particularly popular among historians concerned with the religious aspect of migrant lives. Yet, to date, this has focused primarily on the clerical rather than lay viewpoint, and has been confined largely to Irish Catholics.13 Other biographical sources, meanwhile, have been utilised in studies of prominent Irishmen,14 and in explorations of ‘prosperous’ and ‘bourgeois’ Catholic Irish in Auckland and Dunedin.15 Analysis of the Protestant Irish has also drawn upon biographical material along with scrutiny of specific communities.16 The
11
Exceptions include D. H. Akenson, ‘Reading the texts of rural immigrants: letters from the Irish in Australia, New Zealand, and North America’ in Donald H. Akenson (ed.), Canadian papers in rural history (Ontario, 1990), vii, 387–406; Trevor Parkhill, ‘“Prospects of this new colony”: letters of Ulster emigrants to New Zealand, 1840–1900’ in Familia, ii, no. 5 (1989), pp 38–42. Patrick O’Farrell has also utilised extracts from his family’s correspondence in Vanished kingdoms: Irish in Australia and New Zealand, a personal excursion (Kensington, 1990). 12 The pioneering work on the Irish in New Zealand is Richard P. Davis, Irish issues in New Zealand politics, 1868–1922 (Dunedin, 1974). A broader overview appears in Donald Harman Akenson, Half the world from home: perspectives on the Irish in New Zealand, 1860–1950 (Wellington, 1990). Recent published work includes collections of essays in Brad Patterson (ed.), The Irish in New Zealand: historical contexts and perspectives (Wellington, 2002) and Lyndon Fraser (ed.), A distant shore: Irish migration and New Zealand settlement (Dunedin, 2000). Anna Rogers has also supplied a strongly illustrated overview in A lucky landing: the story of the Irish in New Zealand (Auckland, 1996). 13 See for instance Michael King, God’s farthest outpost: a history of Catholics in New New [sic] Zealand (Auckland, 1997); Rory Matthew Sweetman, ‘New Zealand Catholicism, war, politics, and the Irish issue, 1912–1922’, Ph.D. thesis, University of Cambridge, 1990; Rory Sweetman, ‘“How to behave among protestants”: varieties of Irish Catholic leadership in colonial New Zealand’ in Patterson (ed.), The Irish in New Zealand, pp 89–101; S. C. MacPherson, ‘“A ready made nucleus of degradation and disorder”? a religious and social history of the Catholic Church and community in Auckland, 1870–1910’, M.A. thesis, University of Auckland, 1987; Rachael Partington, ‘Faith and nationality: Catholic lay societies and Irish immigrant adaptation to Auckland society, 1870–1910’, M.A. Research Essay, University of Auckland, 1993. 14 R. C. J. Stone, James Dilworth (Auckland, 1995). 15 Bernard Francis Cadogan, ‘Lace curtain Catholics: the Catholic bourgeoisie of the diocese of Dunedin’, B.A. dissertation, University of Otago, 1984; Gabrielle A. Fortune, ‘Hugh Coolahan and the prosperous Irish: Auckland, 1840–1870’, M.A., University of Auckland, 1997. 16 Alasdair Galbraith, ‘New Zealand’s “invisible” Irish: Irish protestants in the North Island of New Zealand, 1840–1900’, M.A. thesis, University of Auckland, 1998. See also his essays, 4
INTRODUCTION
separate experiences of Irish Catholics and Irish Protestants is likewise evident in investigations of their fraternal societies. The two most identifiably Irish organisations in New Zealand, the Ancient Order of Hibernians and Orange Order, have received pioneering analysis, though much more research is required.17 Inevitably these institutions raise the issues of ethnic identity and sectarianism. Despite an overblown account of Irish issues on the West Coast goldfields, sectarian disturbances appear overall to have been relatively scattered affairs.18 A focus on specific regions has also generated significant studies, mainly utilising parish and civil registers, street directories, probates, and genealogies.19 This book likewise uses such sources, in conjunction with personal letters, to reconstruct the lives of Irish men and women at home and abroad. It makes a substantial contribution to the historiography of the Irish in New Zealand by adopting a transnational perspective, an analysis dealing with two societies and the migrants who crossed these boundaries. This approach is taken in an effort to break down the inhibitive ‘salt-water curtain’20 characterising many investigations of migration. The book also analyses the role of the family in the migration process. It does so as renewed interest in social networks has resurrected curiosity in the part played by kin at origin and destination in the processes of relocation and adaptation.21 Wider networks based on friendship, neighbourhood, and community are also discussed. These personal networks, which could exploit
‘A forgotten plantation: the Irish in Pukekohe, 1865–1900’ in Patterson (ed.), The Irish in New Zealand, pp 117–30, and ‘The invisible Irish? re-discovering the Irish Protestant tradition in colonial New Zealand’ in Fraser (ed.), A distant shore, pp 36–54. 17 Rory Sweetman, Faith and fraternalism: a history of the Hibernian Society in New Zealand, 1869–2000 (Wellington, 2002); Rory Sweetman, ‘“The importance of being Irish”: Hibernianism in New Zealand, 1869–1969’ in Fraser (ed.), A distant shore, pp 135–54; Patrick J. Coleman, ‘Transplanted Irish institutions: Orangeism and Hibernianism in New Zealand, 1877–1910’, M.A. thesis, University of Canterbury, 1993; T. A. Moyes, ‘The sash their fathers wore: a history of Orangeism in the North Island of New Zealand, 1868–1900’, M.A. Research Essay, University of Auckland, 1994. 18 David McGill, The lion and the wolfhound: the Irish rebellion on the New Zealand goldfields (Wellington, 1990); Seán G. Brosnahan, ‘“The battle of the borough” and the “saige o Timaru”: sectarian riot in colonial Canterbury’ in N.Z.J.H., xxviii (1994), pp 41–59. 19 Fraser, To Tara via Holyhead; Lyndon Fraser, ‘Irish migration to the West Coast, 1864–1900’ in N.Z.J.H., xxxiv (2000), pp 197–225. See also Angela Tindall, ‘From county Cork to the southern corinth: aspects of Corkonian immigration to Auckland in the mid to late nineteenth century’, M.A. thesis, University College, Dublin, 1996. 20 Frank Thistlethwaite, ‘Migration from Europe overseas in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries’ in Herbert Moller (ed.), Population movement in modern European history (New York, 1964), p. 74. 21 See especially Robert L. Bach and Lisa A. Schraml, ‘Migration, crisis, and theoretical conflict’ in International Migration Review, xxxvi (1982), p. 328; Monica Boyd, ‘Family and personal networks in international migration: recent developments and new agendas’ in International Migration Review, xxiii (1989), p. 639. 5
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
as well as facilitate, tied migrants and non-migrants together. To what extent were individuals constrained or enabled by this collective involvement in migration? Were alliances or conflicts more readily conveyed? This book also contributes to the historiography of the Irish abroad. Though not overtly comparative, it contrasts letters to and from New Zealand with correspondence sent and received by their compatriots elsewhere. This is a particularly fruitful approach given the conflicting interpretations surrounding Irish settlement in Australia compared with North America. As Malcolm Campbell has warned: ‘Given the wide divergence between the predominant interpretation of the Irish experience in the United States and the much more positive pattern of accommodation revealed by most scholarship on other settler societies, the development of a rigorous comparative history seems an urgent and essential task’.22 Alas, few scholars have sought to explain the settlement of the Irish abroad in a comparative context.23 The comparisons contained in this book are primarily made with David Fitzpatrick’s Oceans of Consolation, the most innovative study to use personal letters.24 Reproducing full transcripts of letters sent to and from Irish migrants in Australia, and exploring each correspondent’s local context, Fitzpatrick emphasised the consolatory, manipulative, and functional significance of personal correspondence. Moreover, by including letters sent to migrants from family and friends in Ireland, Fitzpatrick has shown the impact of migration on the mobile as well as the immobile. Fitzpatrick’s examination of 111 letters exchanged between Ireland and Australia between 1843 and 1906, selected from several hundred consulted, provides a fascinating insight into life in Australia, life in Ireland, and the process of migration. His rationale for providing transcripts is clear: ‘Assessment of the significance of form and language, as well as content, is impossible in the absence of faithful and uncondensed transcriptions of letters’.25 This book is based on twice as many letters as Fitzpatrick’s and therefore this rules out the inclusion of their transcripts. The exclusion is mitigated to some extent by the reproduction of
22
Malcolm Campbell, ‘The other immigrants: comparing the Irish in Australia and the United States’ in Journal of American Ethnic History, xiv (1995), p. 12. 23 Notable exceptions include Donald Harman Akenson, The Irish diaspora: a primer (Toronto and Belfast, 1993); David Noel Doyle, ‘The Irish in Australia and the United States: some comparisons, 1880–1939’ in Irish Economic and Social History, xvi (1989); and the following articles by Malcolm Campbell: ‘The other immigrants’; ‘Irish nationalism and immigrant assimilation: comparing the United States and Australia’ in Australasian Journal of American Studies, xvi (1996), pp 24–43; ‘Emigrant responses to war and revolution, 1914–21: Irish opinion in the United States and Australia’ in Irish Historical Studies, xxxii (2000–2001), pp 75–92. 24 David Fitzpatrick, Oceans of consolation: personal accounts of Irish migration to Australia (Cork, 1995). 25 Ibid., p. 23. 6
INTRODUCTION
several of these sources elsewhere.26 Unlike Fitzpatrick’s study, then, this book takes a purely thematic approach. Of the 253 letters studied in this book, 135 were sent from New Zealand and 118 from Ireland.27 The sequences vary from one to 38 letters with five series incorporating letters sent in both directions. 28 Several sequences therefore have more than one correspondent and overall there are 74 writers (43 male, 31 female). Men wrote 164 letters while women wrote 89.29 Letters from Protestants (140) slightly outnumber those sent by Catholic writers (113). The migrants in this study do not reflect the religious affiliation of New Zealand’s Irish migrants on a statistical level, but such representation is not an essential requirement of this study. As the following chapters reveal, Irish Catholics and Irish Protestants in New Zealand shared similar preoccupations and there was little to separate them on matters of concern in their letters. This study therefore endorses Akenson’s claim that only ‘small differences’ separated Irish Catholics and Irish Protestants.30 The time-frame of these letters spans the years 1840–1937, thereby recognising that most correspondents arriving in New Zealand between the peak immigration years of 1860 to 1880 were still sending and receiving information by the 1920s (see Table I.1). The letters illustrate the critical role played by family and friends at home and abroad in the processes of relocation and settlement from the early years of settlement through the ‘Vogel’ period of immigration, that is the period 1871–85 during Julius Vogel’s term as Minister of Immigration, and through to the division of Ireland into two states. To limit the study to a certain time period, say between the 1860s and the 1880s, would leave the changing experience of migration and settlement unexamined, and this long-range focus facilitates an assessment of these processes over time. It would also mean excluding the thoughts and feelings at a later date of migrants who arrived during the nineteenth century. All told, this study examines 36 migrants who wrote to or received letters from their connexions in Ireland.31 Most (20) were natives of Ulster, with
26
Angela McCarthy, ‘“Seas may divide”: Irish migration to New Zealand as portrayed in personal correspondence, 1840–1937’, Ph.D. thesis, 2 vols, Trinity College, Dublin, 2000. Complete transcripts of the letters are contained in volume 2. 27 Letters from New Zealand include 11 sent from port or ship, 2 from Australia, and 7 sent within New Zealand. Letters from Ireland include 10 sent from London and 2 sent from the United States. 28 McIlrath, Gilmer, Flanagan, Kilpatrick, and Lambert. 29 99 letters were sent by men in New Zealand and 65 from men in Ireland. Women in New Zealand sent 35 letters while women in Ireland sent 52. 30 Donald Harman Akenson, Small differences: Irish Catholics and Irish Protestants, 1815–1922, an international perspective (Kingston, 1988). 31 This figure of 36 migrants is based on just one migrant selected from each family that contained two or more migrant letter writers: Flanagan, Gilmer, Gilmore, McClure, McIlrath, and Quinn. 7
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
Table I.1 Number of letters exchanged between New Zealand and Ireland Decade
From New Zealand
From Ireland
1840s 1850s 1860s 1870s 1880s 1890s 1900s 1910s 1920s 1930s
0 1 34 39 23 12 18 2 6 0
3 0 8 14 10 15 13 9 41 5
13 emerging from the north-eastern counties of Londonderry, Antrim, and Down. Munster supplied 11 migrants, with four from Tipperary alone, while three left Connacht and two departed from Leinster (see Figure 1). As will be seen in Chapter 1 such origins are not representative of the overall flow of Irish migrants to New Zealand, but they do echo the predominant Ulster–Munster background of the majority of settlers in New Zealand. These migrants were also principally lower middle class and from comfortable backgrounds (see Table I.2). The median annual valuation and area of the households they emerged from was £14 15s and approximately 27.0.20 acres, slightly higher than the correspondents in Fitzpatrick’s study (£12 and 22 acres).32 In this respect, the Irish Protestants in this study fit nicely with their Catholic counterparts who also mainly emerged from middling backgrounds. Not one Protestant migrant at the centre of this study surfaced from a household valued annually at more than £52. Indeed, the two highest valuations related to Catholic migrants. Seventeen migrants in this study were reared on farms, ranging vastly in size from an acre to 319 acres. The remainder were the children of a labourer, shopkeeper, publican, blacksmith, stonemason, coachmaker, constabulary officer (two), teacher (two), Church of Ireland minister, and doctor.33 Of those migrants who arrived as assisted migrants, with their fare either paid by the government or raised by friends and family in the colony, their trades were listed as farm labourers and domestic servants. Once in New Zealand, however, they pursued diverse occupations. Four male migrants were labourers and five were miners while skilled migrants included a carpenter, wheelwright, and tailor. Two migrants pursued a navy and army career respectively while
32 33
Fitzpatrick, Oceans of consolation, p. 31. The occupation for the fathers of seven migrants has not been traced. 8
INTRODUCTION Colgan McSparron McCleland McKelvey
Bell Ferguson
N
ULSTER
Londonderry Antrim
Donegal
Macready McClure Lambert
McCullough
Tyrone Coghlan
Hughes
McIlrath
Fermanagh
Gilmore Monan
Down
Armagh
Cardwell Rea
Monaghan
Sligo
Kilpatrick
Leitrim Mayo
Cavan
Gilmer Treanor
Louth Roscommon
CONNACHT
Longford
Quinn Dawson
LEINSTER
Meath
Flanagan
Westmeath
Armstrong
Galway
Dublin Kildare
King’s Strong
Wicklow
Queen’s Clare
O’Neill
Carlow
Lysaght
Limerick
Sullivan
Furlong
Dempsey
Kilkenny
Dwyer
Kerry
Tipperary
Wexford
Piezzi
Waterford Carroll Farrell
Cork
Keane
O’Regan
MUNSTER
IRELAND
0
50 miles
0
80 kms
Figure 1 Irish origins of emigrant correspondents
commercial migrants included two accountants, a storekeeper, and a hotelkeeper. One migrant was a doctor and three migrants chose to farm. The occupations of female correspondents included a milliner, machinist, dispenser, and hotelkeeper. Six women undertook domestic service, while the only female migrant who remained unmarried was variously a shopkeeper, housekeeper, teacher, and dressmaker. The three married female migrants worked on family farms and also took on sewing duties. The majority of migrants (24) arrived between 1860 and 1885, the peak years of British and Irish migration to New Zealand. Nine migrants in this study travelled to New Zealand during the 1860s and 1870s, while seven 9
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
Table I.2 Annual valuation of correspondents Name
Annual valuation
Acreage
Religion
Rea McCleland Dwyer Gilmore Sullivan Keane Ferguson Coghlan Macready Strong McSparron Carroll Dawson Reid Gilmer Bell Lysaght Cardwell Dempsey McIlrath Colgan McKelvey Armstrong Monan McCullough O’Neill Flanagan
0 5s 5s 6da 7s 101⁄2da £1 10s £1 10s £1 13s £1 15s £2 12s £6 £7 £7 £13 10s £14 5s £14 15s £16 £17 5s £17 5s £18 10s £28 10s £33 5s £33 15s £37 10s £42 £42 15s £52 £68 £138
— 3.2.0b 7b — 6.0.3 1.0.0 0.0.10 0.0.32 — 11.2.3 47.2.32 — 33.1.30 9.1.25 16.2.15 29.2.33 22.0.15 33.0.15 29.2.10 27.0.20 27.3.35 319.0.10 33.1.17 55 45.3.30 — 118.1.12
Protestant Protestant Catholic Protestant Catholic Catholic Protestant Catholic Protestant Catholic Protestant Catholic Catholic Protestant Protestant Protestant Catholic Protestant Catholic Protestant Protestant Protestant Protestant Catholic Protestant Catholic Catholic
Notes: The annual valuation for the families of nine correspondents (Farrell, Furlong, Hughes, McClure, McNeice, O’Regan, Quinn, Treanor, Walsh) has not been traced. a These values are taken from the Tithe Applotment Books. b Acres are Irish.
travelled during the 1880s. By contrast, the migrants in Fitzpatrick’s study generally settled in Australia between 1850 and 1865.34 The age at emigration for the migrants in this study ranged between 16 and 45 with the median age being 24, slightly higher than the mean age of single Irish migrants who arrived 34
Fitzpatrick, Oceans of consolation, p. 33. 10
INTRODUCTION
in New Zealand in 1876.35 Of the 36 migrants in this study, 24 were 30 years of age or under when they arrived in New Zealand.36 As for their marital status, six migrants arrived already married, with children accompanying four of the couples.37 Two migrants wed within days of embarkation, while ten never married. The remainder married between one and nineteen years after arriving in New Zealand. Of those marrying in New Zealand thirteen migrants found partners of Irish birth or descent while five married non-Irish partners. Once in New Zealand these thirty-six migrants settled widely (see Figure 2). Twelve made their residence in Auckland, six each in Westland and Wellington, five in Otago, four in Canterbury, and one each in Southland, Taranaki, and Nelson. Two migrants chose to depart permanently from New Zealand. Before undertaking a thematic analysis of their letters, the remainder of this chapter provides pen portraits of the various migrants whose letters are examined in this book.38
John Henry Armstrong John Henry Armstrong was born on 17 May 1835 at Kiltoom, County Roscommon, the second son and seventh child of eight, to Church of Ireland minister John Armstrong and his wife Catherine Lloyd who had married at Clifton church in July 1825. John Armstrong senior studied at Trinity College, Dublin, and took up his first curacy at Kilgleffin in the parish of Elphin before being appointed vicar of Kiltoom and Camma in 1828. John junior migrated to New Zealand some time around December 1851. In May 1853 John’s father died and his mother relocated to Dublin where she remained until her death in 1873. John Armstrong’s three known surviving letters were composed between 1859 and 1865 and sent to his sister Marian in Dublin.39 Through his articulate and vigorous writing style, John provided illuminating and detailed information about his involvement in the colonial army and events during the New Zealand Wars. Perhaps following in the footsteps of his uncle, John Yeadon Lloyd, who was a major, John became a lieutenant in the Taranaki Militia in 1860 and was made captain two years later.40 On 10 March 1864 John
35 In 1876, the mean age of single Irish migrants was 22.5 for males and 22.4 for females. See Akenson, Half the world from home, Table 11, p. 45. 36 Nine were older and seven are unknown. The median age was 24. 37 The marriages of Cornelius Dwyer, Catherine Sullivan, and Margaret Anne Kilpatrick took place approximately twenty, eighteen, and one year before emigration. They were accompanied by seven, five, and one offspring respectively. 38 Extended profiles of many of these correspondents are contained in volume 1 of McCarthy, ‘Seas may divide’. 39 The Armstrong letters are in P.R.O.N.I., T/1978/1–3. 40 His commission was unwelcome and it was noted that ‘Armstrong has the misfortune
11
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
NEW ZEALAND
North Island
Lambert Kilpatrick Lysaght O’Neill Furlong Strong Quinn McKelvey Carroll Hughes
Monan Auckland
Gilmore
Auckland
Armstrong
Taranaki Treanor Dawson
Wellington Hawke’s Bay
Dwyer
Sullivan
Wellington
South Island Flanagan McCullough
Marlborough
Nelson
O’Regan
McCleland Gilmer Keane
Farrell Piezzi Coghlan
Westland
Christchurch
Macready Cardwell
Canterbury McIlrath Dempsey Bell
Otago
N
McSparron
Dunedin
Gamble
McClure
Southland
Provincial boundaries
Ferguson Rea
Stewart Island
0
125 miles
0
200 kms
Figure 2 New Zealand destinations of emigrant correspondents
Armstrong, aged 29, married 21-year-old Emma Sarah Mace at St Mary’s church, New Plymouth. The couple had six children. Though John’s remaining life is largely undocumented, directories and electoral rolls indicate his permanent residence at Waitara, where he farmed 130 acres of land valued at £1,013 in 1882. When John Armstrong died on to be the Major’s nephew & is young & not very eligible . . . . Some of the nominations are certainly not judicious, and all would prefer a mature man to lead them caeteris paribus’. See G. H. Scholefield (ed.), The Richmond–Atkinson papers (Wellington, 1960), I, 357–8. 12
INTRODUCTION
24 April 1915 at 80 years of age his will was valued at under £1,000 and he had five children still living.41 His sister Marian had spent her remaining years at the Mageough Home for Aged Females on Cowper Road in Upper Rathmines, Dublin. Founded in 1878, the Home provided ‘for the habitations, support, and clothing of aged females professing the Protestant faith, and of good character and sobriety’.42 Marian Armstrong died at the Mageough Home in 1912.
Elizabeth Ayson (née Ferguson) The daughter of John Ferguson and Agnes Atkinson, Elizabeth Ferguson was born around 1862 at Ballynacor in the civil parish of Seagoe, County Armagh, where her father held a small plot of land worth £1 15s annually. Elizabeth, together with her 20-year-old sister Hessie Jane, received an assisted passage on the British Queen, arriving at Westland in February 1884. They were both listed as machinists.43 Almost a decade later, on 28 September 1893, 29-yearold Elizabeth Ferguson married 44-year-old Scottish-born farmer Robert McIntosh Ayson and they settled at Warepa. Between 1894 and 1904 Elizabeth Ayson received at least four letters from her sister Mary Ann Gilpin, who resided at Lowmills, Balteagh, near Portadown. One letter from her brother Hugh also survives. 44 The letters largely document Mary Ann’s health problems, but also record the death of John Ferguson. Elizabeth Ayson died at Toiro on 4 November 1943 aged 83. She had three children still alive.
David Bell David Bell was born on 14 March 1861 at Barnice, Kells, County Antrim, the fifth son and eighth child of eleven, to Presbyterian couple John Bell and Elizabeth Gawn. David’s father and two of his brothers held 89.0.20 acres of land jointly at the time of the Primary Valuation with a total valuation of £49 25s.45 David Bell’s arrival in New Zealand is unknown, but it probably occurred in the early to mid 1880s. He settled in Otago at Duntroon, ‘the centre of a rich agricultural and pastoral district’,46 where three of his brothers
41
The Will of John Armstrong, ABAJ W4079 1915/1823, in N.A.W. Thom’s official directory (Dublin, 1912), p. 1431. 43 IM 15/546, N.A.W. 44 The letters were kindly provided by Lorna Neame, Tauranga. 45 The Primary Valuation was a valuation of property in Ireland undertaken between 1848 and 1864. The value was based on the productive capacity of the land and the potential rent of buildings. 46 Cyclopedia of New Zealand iv, 567. 42
13
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Figure 3 Lizzie Ayson (formerly Ferguson) (Source: Mabel K. Neame/Lorna Neame)
were living. David’s only known surviving letter was composed in 1886 and sent to his eldest brother John.47 Unlike the alleged contentment of his brothers in New Zealand, David Bell’s letter displays a degree of disenchantment with the colony, particularly in relation to its landholding practices. David eventually departed for North America where the remainder of his life is unknown.
47
The letter was kindly provided by Tom Bell, Bangor, County Down. 14
INTRODUCTION
William Cardwell Born on 12 March 1845 at Tonaghmore, County Down, William Cardwell was the eldest of six children born to Presbyterian couple Samuel Cardwell and Jane Patterson. His father’s 33 acres of land in the Saintfield parish fetched an annual valuation of £18 10s. Prior to his departure from Ireland, William worked in Thomas Bassett’s shop in Church Street, Downpatrick, County Down. Also working in the store was David Morrow, who left for New Zealand in the late 1860s and established a hardware and machinery business with Samuel Bassett.48 When Samuel Bassett returned to Ireland in 1875 William accompanied him on the Blairgowrie back to New Zealand, arriving at Lyttelton on 24 August 1875. William Cardwell became the accountant of Morrow, Bassett and Company in Christchurch and his two known surviving letters, written in 1879 and 1880, document the company’s and colony’s difficulties.49 Possibly such negative depictions were to serve as a warning to his brother John who contemplated relocating to the colony following the death of his parents. John eventually made the voyage to the colony in June 1881 on board the City of Tanjore, accompanied by his wife. Tragically, William Cardwell’s life came to an abrupt and dramatic end when he drowned in the Avon River on 10 April 1888 at 43 years of age. Living with his brother and about to be married, William had been ill the week prior to his death. It was also later recorded that having undergone a ‘painful operation’ William became ‘very despondent’.50 John found his brother’s body lying in five feet of water and the inquest returned a verdict of ‘found drowned’. William’s will, made in May 1886, left his estate to John.51 By contrast with his brother, John Cardwell lived on until 15 July 1942 when he died at Riccarton, Canterbury, aged 88 years.
Philip Joseph Carroll Philip Joseph Carroll was born on 2 August 1888 at Nenagh, County Tipperary, the second child of Thomas and Annie Carroll, who had married in 1881 at the Catholic church in Templederry, County Tipperary. The family moved from Borrisoleigh to Nenagh and it was here in 1889 that Thomas 48 ‘Early history of the Bassett family’, compiled by Ken Bassett from data received from Mrs W. Bassett, Richmond. This and other information on the Bassett family was supplied by John Bassett, Downpatrick, County Down. 49 The Cardwell letters are in P.R.O.N.I., T/1698/1–2. 50 Press (Christchurch), 11 April 1888, p. 5. 51 At the time of his death William had £163 in the bank, property worth £660, and a life assurance policy worth £522. See The Will of William Cardwell, 1545/1888, in N.A.C., 171.
15
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Figure 4 Philip Carroll (Source: Br Philip Carroll)
Carroll died at 32 years of age. Less than a year after his father’s death, Philip’s mother married John S. Gleeson. This marriage also produced two children. Prior to his emigration to New Zealand in 1912, which family tradition suggests was for health reasons, Philip was employed as a cleric for the Irish Railways. Once in Auckland he worked as an accountant. A series of letters document his blossoming relationship with 22-year-old [Bridget] Nina Ryan, a young woman of Irish extraction, and on 16 December 1918 Philip, aged 29, married her at St Patrick’s Cathedral, Auckland.52 The couple had three children between 1921 and 1924 and the following year Philip, suffering from a kidney disease, made a return visit to Ireland, primarily
52
These ‘love letters’ are in possession of Philip’s son, Br Philip Carroll, O.F.M., Auckland. 16
INTRODUCTION
for health reasons. During this trip he sent 23 letters to his wife which reveal him to be a devoted father and tender husband. 53 Despite his debilitating health, Philip provided extensive, engaging depictions of Ireland’s people and places. Philip Carroll arrived back in Auckland in December 1925. He survived for a further seven months, dying on 15 July 1926 aged 37. His daughter Maureen died six weeks later. Nina Carroll remarried in 1945 to Edwin Neil, a farmer from Otaua, Waimuku. Nina lived there until she died quite suddenly in 1955 at the comparatively young age of 59 years.
Brigid Dawson (née Quinn) Brigid Dawson was born on 30 May 1884 at Carricknagalliah, County Armagh, to Bernard Quinn and Ann Grant. On 12 January 1909 she married Peter Francis Dawson, an electrician, at the Catholic chapel in Carrickcruppin, near Newry, County Down. Together with her husband and four children, Brigid left Southampton on the Athenic on 1 May 1924, arriving in New Zealand on 9 June 1924. The family settled at Wanganui, where Peter had previously resided and it was from here on 30 July 1924 that Brigid wrote to her sister Ellen.54 Brigid’s letter provides an interesting account of the voyage and the family’s initial progress in Wanganui. Peter Dawson died on 19 March 1959 aged 78, while Brigid lived until 15 October 1981. She was then 97 years of age.
Annie Dempsey The second of three children of James Dempsey and Margaret Kelly, Annie Dempsey was born in January 1852 at Crecrin, County Carlow. Her father held just under 30 acres of land, worth £28 10s annually. Annie emigrated to New Zealand around 1882, accompanied by her aunt. She initially settled at Waihao in the Waimate region. On 30 November 1886 at Timaru’s Catholic church 28-year-old Annie Dempsey married 44-year-old Francis O’Brien, a native of Castledermot, County Kildare. They lived at Midfield farm near Waimate, South Canterbury, and had two children. Between 1883 and 1903 Annie sent at least ten letters back to her family. Her correspondence documents her surroundings and melancholy thoughts of home, as well as seeking news of home connexions. Her later letters also record her despair at her husband’s premature death in April 1891. Apart from Annie’s correspondence, a letter from her brother Michael, written in 1888
53 Photocopies of the Carroll letters were kindly supplied by Br Philip Carroll, O.F.M., Auckland. 54 The Dawson letter was kindly supplied by Joan Leonard, Auckland.
17
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
after his arrival in New Zealand, also survives.55 Annie lived on until 29 May 1929 when at 77 years of age she passed away at Waimate. Her will recognised a wide range of beneficiaries, including her sister Eliza Burke living at Furness, near Straffan, County Kildare.56
Margaret Dodd (née Monan) Margaret Dodd was born around 1846 at Ballyquintin, Portaferry, County Down, the sixth child of nine born to Patrick Monan and Sarah Quinn. Patrick’s holding was valued at £42 15s annually. Margaret’s brother and sister went to North America while Margaret emigrated in the 1860s to Australia where she met and married Irishman John Muir in June 1864. Some time in the 1870s Margaret moved to New Zealand and settled at Thames with John and their four children. In June 1877, after John’s death, Margaret married George Dodd, who went to the South African goldfields and apparently died there. Sympathy for his death was expressed in May 1889 in a letter written to Margaret from her parents.57 Their letter also documented the similar predicament faced by Margaret’s sister Isabella whose husband, a seal hunter, died tragically in Dublin. Margaret Dodd died in January 1892 at Waiatahi, Thames, from cancer of the uterus. She was 44 years of age and left four children.
Cornelius Dwyer Cornelius Dwyer was born at Dromkeen, County Limerick, around 1800. Unfortunately, the records for the Catholic parish of Kilteely only commence in 1815 so it has not been possible to construct Cornelius’s family background. The registers do, however, reveal that Cornelius was married to Mary Cooney and between 1824 and 1840 they produced at least six children. In September 1842 the family left Gravesend on board the Prince of Wales, arriving in Nelson in December that year.58 They settled initially at Nelson, where Cornelius’s mother Hanora wrote to them in 1846.59 The letter outlines family news at home and abroad and is noteworthy for reference to the pending potato famine. At some stage the Dwyer family moved to Waimea East, for it was here 55
The Dempsey letters were kindly provided by Michael O’Brien, Upper Hutt, and Noeline Lavin. 56 The Will of Annie O’Brien, N.A.C., CH145, PR 3059/1929. 57 This letter was kindly supplied by Leone Shaw. 58 The family’s details are recorded in the New Zealand Company emigration lists, 1841–1842, Part 2, Repro 4, in N.A.W. 59 The letters in the Dwyer series were kindly provided by Molly O’Dwyer, Auckland. I am also grateful to Dan Murphy for family information. 18
INTRODUCTION
in 1848 that Cornelius died of consumption at 48 years of age. His wife died at Richmond in April 1874 aged 73. Two letters sent to a descendant of Cornelius Dwyer’s also survive. The correspondent, Catherine Cunnane of Bekan, County Mayo, supplied illuminating information about farming in Ireland.
Ellen Anne Edwards (née Coghlan) Ellen Anne Edwards was born around 1840 at Foxford, County Mayo, the second child of Patrick Coghlan and Ellen McHale. Following her mother’s death, Ellen’s father married Cecilia Barrett and they had a further seven children. The date of Ellen’s arrival in New Zealand is unknown but on 6 October 1872 it was recorded that Ellen Coghlan, then a ‘dispenser’, married Henry John Carruthers Edwards, an English-born chemist, at Hokitika. The couple had three children before Henry’s death in October 1889. In June the following year Ellen received a letter from her stepmother commiserating with Henry’s demise and desiring Ellen to make a return visit to Ireland.60 She never did. Ellen relocated to Auckland where she died on 20 August 1921.
Patrick Farrell Patrick Farrell was born in 1892 at Ballinderry, County Tipperary, the son of Matthew Farrell and Margaret Nevill. In 1913 Patrick followed his siblings Michael, Hannah, and Jack to New Zealand. Having trained as a tailor following a hurling accident which shattered his leg, Patrick worked initially at Christchurch before settling at Greymouth. By 1920 two more siblings, Matt and Margaret, were also resident in New Zealand while another brother Jim lived in Australia. In 1917 Patrick added an ‘O’ to his surname, the only one of his family to do so. His sweetheart, May Sullivan, colonial-born of Irish parents, likewise added an ‘O’ to her surname. Both had met in Ireland when May’s family returned there before May ventured back to New Zealand in 1914. In October 1920 Patrick and May married and eventually had three children. Patrick died on 4 October 1959 at 67 years of age while May died in October 1970. Nine letters dated 1911 to 1920, incorporating a range of correspondence from family and friends, are drawn upon in this study.61 They include three
60
This letter was kindly provided by J. E. Coghlan, Nelson. All told, fifteen letters are contained in the Farrell letters lodged at A.T.L., 77–127. The remaining six letters were exchanged between Patrick and May. The family history is eloquently documented in Patrick O’Farrell, Vanished kingdoms: Irish in Australia and New Zealand, a personal excursion (Kensington, 1990).
61
19
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
letters exchanged between Patrick and his siblings, and five letters sent to May from friends in Ireland and one sent to her from a priest in New Zealand. The letters mostly contain news of family and friends at home and abroad, but are also valuable for their insights into the organisation of migration.
Michael Flanagan Michael Flanagan was born in 1839 near Termonfeckin, County Louth, the fifth child and son of ten children born to John Flanagan and Anne Maguire. His paternal grandfather, Patrick Flanagan, was a substantial landholder of
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Figure 5 Michael Flanagan (Source: Donald Murphy) 20
INTRODUCTION
118 acres valued annually at £138. At some point in time Michael, together with his brother Patrick, elected to voyage to Australia, for in July 1857 their grandfather recorded, ‘Paid Patrick and Michael going to Australia £14’. 62 The brothers went first to Liverpool where they connected with the ship Oliver Lang bound for Melbourne.63 Letters to and from the Flanagans in Australia indicate that Michael and Patrick went their separate ways though they were reunited and both elected to voyage to the goldfields in New Zealand in the mid 1860s.64 The letters sent from and within New Zealand offer a revealing insight into goldmining on the West Coast and Coromandel and the social networks attached to these districts. By April 1865 the Flanagans had settled at Hokitika on the West Coast and two years later moved to Charleston. Patrick then spent time on the Thames goldfields before deciding to join his brother Nicholas in the United States. Michael Flanagan remained in New Zealand until June 1871 at which time he departed for California. In 1890 he acquiesced to his father’s wishes and returned to Ireland. Michael died on 10 November 1904 while his brother Patrick died in California eight years earlier.
Rose Gamble (née McMullan) Rose Gamble was born on 18 June 1866 at Ballynastraid, Ballintoy, on the north coast of County Antrim, the fourth of eight children born to Zachariah McMullan and Catherine McCaughan, who had married at the Church of Ireland church in nearby Dunseverick in July 1858. Zachariah, together with his brother James, occupied just over 27 acres valued at £31 15s annually, at a place known locally as Bridgend in the townland of Ballynastraid. In September 1873 Zachariah McMullan died at the age of 54 and was buried in Dunseverick parish, church in the village of Lisnagunogue, west of Bridgend.65 Some four years later his widow Catherine married Charles Colgan at the Wesleyan chapel in Ballycastle, County Antrim, and relocated to Charles’s farm at Tonduff in the neighbouring parish of Billy.
62
Farm Account Book, 1841–1862, cited in Donald Murphy, The Flanagans of Tobertoby, Co. Louth (1989, privately circulated), p. 30. 63 Unassisted passengers to Victoria, fiche 130, P.R.O. Laverton. I am grateful to Professor David Fitzpatrick for this information. 64 Copies of the original letters were kindly provided by Donald Murphy. A complete transcript of the entire sequence can be found in Fr John Murphy and Donald Murphy (eds), The Flanagan letters, 1864–1909: a transcript of the correspondence of the Flanagan family of Tobertoby, Termonfeckin, Drogheda, Co. Louth (1997, privately printed). Again, I am grateful to Professor David Fitzpatrick for bringing this collection to my attention. 65 Zachariah McMullan’s headstone proclaims, ‘Here am I for thou callest me’ but contains conflicting details. His date of death reads 30 November 1873 and his age 53. I am grateful to Nevin Taggart, Antrim, for this information. 21
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Figure 6 Rose and Charles Gamble (Source: Richard Herbert)
In 1882 Catherine’s son Zachariah McMullan emigrated to New Zealand, following in the footsteps of his maternal uncles who had arrived in the preceding decade.66 Upon arrival, Zachariah promptly set about nominating other members of his family. Rose travelled with her sister Catherine on board the Tongariro from Gravesend to Port Chalmers, arriving in September 1885.67 Another brother, James, emigrated later that year. Chain migration was also a feature of the family of Charles Gamble of Croaghmore, County Antrim, whom Rose McMullan married in June 1889 at the East Taieri
66 Hector McCaughan emigrated in about 1872 and was followed by his brother John in 1879. 67 IM 14/475, N.A.W.
22
INTRODUCTION
Presbyterian church.68 The couple settled at Riccarton where Charles had established a blacksmith and coachbuilding business. By 1902 the couple had six daughters. Rose and her brother Johnny were the recipients of at least seven letters sent from their mother between 1893 and 1901.69 Religious extracts pepper the correspondence, which depicts the declining health of Catherine Colgan, who was in her sixties during the decade in which she wrote. Her main motivation was to encourage Johnny’s return. On 29 March 1903 Rose Gamble died after contracting scarlet fever. She was 36 years of age. Her mother Catherine lived on until August 1911. Charles Gamble remarried in May 1905 and had a further five children before he died in June 1955 aged 95.
Samuel Gilmer Samuel Gilmer was born around 1842 at Mullaghanee, County Monaghan, the fourth of six sons of Hugh Gilmer and Margaret Dorothy (Dolly) Hamilton. When the Tithe Applotment Books were compiled, Hugh, together with his brother Thomas, held just over 13 acres of land at Mullaghanee in the civil parish of Clontibret.70 Both the size of their holding and their annual rent of £20 were the highest in the townland. Just before 1860 when the Primary Valuation was conducted, Hugh’s 16 acres fetched a valuation of £16. Following Margaret’s death, Hugh remarried in 1846 to Anne Smith, a union that produced one son, William. This may have been the stimulus for the migration of all but one of Hugh’s sons from his first marriage. Hamilton Gilmer appears to have been the first of the Gilmer brothers to leave Monaghan, arriving in Victoria, Australia in January 1861 on the Blue Jacket. His eventual relocation to New Zealand was perhaps prompted by the presence there of his maternal uncle, John Hamilton. In around 1864 Samuel joined Hamilton in New Zealand as did another brother, Henry. All were hotel proprietors on the West Coast, having presumably obtained their hotel apprenticeship from their uncle. At Greymouth on 20 July 1877 Samuel married Mary Isabella Martin and the couple had one daughter. Samuel Gilmer eventually moved to Wellington where he ran the Royal Oak Hotel on Cuba Street. It was from here in 1886 that he wrote to his brother William who had previously spent time in the colony before returning 68
For information on the Gamble family see Richard Herbert, The Gamble family of East Taieri: a brief account of the family’s origins at Croaghmore, in Antrim, Northern Ireland, their emigration and settlement at East Taieri, in Otago, New Zealand, in the 1880’s, and of the reunion held 6–7th April 1996 (Dunedin, 1996). 69 I am grateful to Richard Herbert, Wellington, for copies of the Colgan letters. 70 The Tithe Applotment Books were valuation books kept between 1823 and 1837 to record land-based taxes extracted from rural Ireland to support the Church of Ireland in rural areas. 23
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Figure 7 Hamilton, Henry, Samuel, Robert, and John Gilmer (Source: Tasman Bays Heritage Trust/Nelson Provincial Museum, Tyree Studio Collection, 44799/3)
to Monaghan. A letter from William to Robert also survives.71 The letters, though containing evidence of harmony between the brothers, reveal serious dissension among wider kin networks. In the 1890s Samuel’s hotel was acclaimed as ‘one of the finest in the City of Wellington, and its proprietor, Mr Gilmer, is exceedingly popular’.72 Not everyone can have shared this view, for in 1906 Samuel appeared in court to give evidence against Francis Waddell who had assaulted him. Sam, with his ‘index finger, wrapped in a blue rag’ and his face ‘battle-scarred’ was asked if Waddell ‘had the chisel in his hand when he attacked him. Mr Gilmer said yes. Waddell had denied this, and here put in the remark that if he had had the chisel, Mr. Gilmer wouldn’t be there to give evidence.’73 Waddell was found guilty of assault and sentenced to eighteen months’ imprisonment with hard labour.
71 72 73
The Gilmer letters were kindly supplied by Juann Ryan, Auckland. Cyclopedia of New Zealand (Wellington, 1897), i, 665. New Zealand Free Lance, 24 March 1906, p. 3b. 24
INTRODUCTION
Samuel Gilmer, ‘one of the best known old-identities in the Dominion’,74 died at 83 years of age on 14 January 1925 and was buried at Karori. Indeed the Dominion newspaper claimed that ‘There are few men who possess a longer acquaintance with the city, and have been enabled to see its growth and development over such an extended period of time’.75
John Gilmore John Gilmore was born in approximately 1844 to Unitarian couple Robert Gilmore and Letitia Bailie on the Ards Peninsula, County Down. Robert was a blacksmith and had a house and forge at Ballyhemlin, a townland in Ballyhalbert parish, valued at £1 10s annually. John Gilmore apparently taught before spending thirteen years at sea, while his older brother Robert occupied a house and forge at Echlinville. In March 1874 their 25-year-old brother Andrew left Belfast, taking an assisted passage on the Queen of Nations, bound for Auckland.76 After his arrival he moved south to Tauranga where he established a blacksmith’s business. In 1876 Andrew was joined by 28-yearold John and their 18-year-old sister Alice who voyaged as assisted passengers on the Bebington.77 Both Andrew and Alice married in 1878, Andrew to Annie Prebble and Alice to County Antrim native James Fenton. John married in November the following year to Lurgan-born Letitia Emerson and they had four children. The Gilmore siblings wrote at least twelve letters to their family in County Down between 1874 and 1881.78 John penned five letters, Andrew six, and Alice one. The series emphasises the collective nature of their migration and their desire to be joined by brother Robert. Despite the concentration of Irish settlers in the region, the Gilmores made no discussion of their social networks, though several general comments were made about the Katikati settlers. Setbacks and advances characterised the Gilmore lives in Tauranga. In the early morning of Monday 5 April 1880 Andrew’s house burned down and he escaped through a window.79 Two years later he was an unsuccessful candidate for the council elections.80 John, meanwhile, was elected to a seat on the Tauranga Borough Council in 1894 and also served for 35 years on the management committee of the Presbyterian church. 74
Obituary of Samuel Gilmer in New Zealand Herald, 16 January 1925, p. 10. Obituary of Samuel Gilmer in Dominion, 15 January 1925, p. 6. 76 IM 15/118, N.A.W. 77 IM 15/263, N.A.W. 78 A letter from John’s daughter Lizzie also survives. The Gilmore letters are scattered in various locations. Six letters are lodged at P.R.O.N.I., T/1611/2–7. The remainder were kindly provided by Alice Gemming. 79 I am grateful to Jasmine Rogers for this information. 80 A. C. Bellamy (ed.), Tauranga, 1882–1982 (Tauranga, 1982), p. 26. 75
25
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Figure 8 John Gilmore with his family, c. 1890 (Source: Alice Gemming)
In March 1913 Andrew died while John passed away on 21 July 1921 at 77 years of age. His obituary declared that ‘He always took a keen and intelligent interest in all public affairs, and was noted for his independent views and actions’.81 John’s funeral was attended by the mayor, councillors, and members of the local Masonic Lodge, and ‘concluded with Masonic public grand honours. All the services were of an impressive nature and formed a fitting tribute of respect to one of the finest of pioneers, who by his courage and perseverance helped in a very material degree to make New Zealand – and this district in particular – a rich heritage for those who dwell here today’.82 Alice 81 82
Bay of Plenty Times, 21 July 1921. Ibid. 26
INTRODUCTION
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Figure 9 Alice Fenton (formerly Gilmore), c. 1925 (Source: Alice Gemming)
Fenton remained alive until 21 May 1934 when, at 76 years of age, she died at Te Puke. Her obituary noted that ‘She was a woman of strong personality and could tell many interesting experiences of the early days’.83
Thomas William Hughes Thomas William Hughes was born on 1 October 1884 at Emlachfad, County Sligo, to Robert Hughes, a Royal Irish Constabulary (R.I.C.) officer, and Mary Jane Pakenham. Robert was a native of Newry, County Down, and at 20 years 83
New Zealand Herald, 23 May 1934, p. 12. 27
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Figure 10 Thomas William Hughes (Source: Joan Graham)
of age in February 1873 had been appointed to the R.I.C. 84 Restrictions prevented him being stationed in his own county so Robert was transferred to County Mayo. At Balla eight years later, on 6 May 1881, he married Mary Jane Pakenham, whose parents were landed migrants from Pakenham Hall at Castlepollard, County Westmeath. Mary Jane’s parents, Thomas and Maria
84
A microfilm copy of Robert Hughes’s police record is in MFA 24/7 in N.A.I., with the original located at the Public Record Office, London, HO 184. I am grateful to Jim Herlihy for his advice in tracing Robert’s career. For guidance in tracing members of the R.I.C., see Jim Herlihy’s two publications The Royal Irish Constabulary: a short history and genealogical guide with a select list of medal awards and casualties (Dublin 1997) and The Royal Irish Constabulary: a complete alphabetical list of officers and men, 1816–1922 (Dublin, 1999). 28
INTRODUCTION
Pakenham, resided at Lagramuck in Balla parish, County Mayo, where Thomas was a gamekeeper. At the time of the 1901 Census their 16-year-old grandson Thomas Hughes was living with them. In June the following year, Thomas Hughes enlisted in the Navy and travelled extensively. By October 1920 he was engaged by the New Zealand naval forces.85 He married at Auckland in November 1922 to Dorothy Adeline Daniel and two years later was called up for service. The couple had four children. Between 1923 and 1937 Thomas received at least twelve letters from his father Robert, who supplied flattering, witty, lengthy, and evocative accounts of a range of private and public matters.86 A former constabulary officer, Robert Hughes emerges as a proud man and resilient in the face of adversity, particularly as his physical condition deteriorated. His wife Mary Jane and daughter Harriette continued the correspondence following Robert’s death in April 1928. Mary Jane died in July 1943 while her son Thomas died at Christchurch on 16 August 1968.
Mary Anne Keane Mary Anne Keane was born on 2 February 1859, the eldest of seven children of James Keane and Johanna Curreen of Ballinamultina, County Waterford, who had married in July 1858. Though little is known about Mary Anne’s grandfather, Joseph Keane, her great-grandfather, Matthew Keane, was returned as a substantial occupier of approximately twenty-six Irish acres at Shanacoole in the Clashmore civil parish. Together with his wife Mary Anne Bayley and three of their adult children, Matthew Keane lies in the family vault at Ferry Point, looking across the bay towards Youghal. On 23 August 1883 Mary Anne’s 20-year-old sister Bridget emigrated on board the British Queen bound for Otago.87 Whether Mary Anne arrived before or after her sister is unknown, but she was in Dunedin in November 1884 to witness Bridget’s marriage to Michael Harty, a native of Kerry. Mary Anne, meanwhile, married in May 1887 to Walter Lovells Victor Walsh. They lived at Petone and had four children. Mary Anne received eleven letters between 1886 and 1921 from her siblings in Waterford, London, and Chicago.88 Her sister Kate wrote nine letters, and brother John two. The letters depict the dispersal of the Keane
85 Full details of Thomas’s naval career are contained in his personnel file at the New Zealand Defence Force, Upper Hutt. 86 Copies of the original letters and genealogical information were kindly provided by Jennifer Hardiman, Wellington, Pamela Bates, Auckland, Joan Graham, Waiheke Island, and Gwenda Pakenham-Hughes, Nelson. 87 IM 15/444, in N.A.W. 88 Copies of the original letters were kindly provided by Gary Walsh, Germany.
29
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Figure 11 Michael and Bridget Harty (formerly Keane) (Source: Vera Major)
family throughout the world and the haphazard attempts made to maintain sibling solidarity. They also contain signs of serious kin and neighbourhood strain. The letters depict the death of Mary Anne’s father James, who died in August 1902 at the Ballyheeny workhouse from a tumour of the kidney. On 1 November 1932 Mary Anne Walsh, ‘A very old and highly respected resident of Petone’ died ‘after a long illness . . . She was a charming old lady and by her straightforward and affable disposition won the trust and esteem of a host of friends. She was ever ready to help those in distress, and took a keen interest in the advancement and welfare of the town. She lived a good and useful life, and many today will regret her death.’89 Bridget Harty, meanwhile, died in September 1937. She had twelve children alive at the time of her death, ranging in age from 29 to 51 years.
Margaret Anne Kilpatrick (née Reid) Margaret Anne Kilpatrick was born on 5 July 1837 at Balleer, County Armagh, the eighth child of Robert Reid and the fourth and last child of his second marriage to Mary Anne Waddle. Robert was the schoolmaster at Balleer in the parish of Lisnadill between 1819 and the year of his death,
89
Mary’s obituary was kindly supplied by Gary Walsh. 30
INTRODUCTION
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Figure 12 ‘Such a comfortable house’: David and Margaret Anne Kilpatrick outside their Newton Road house in Auckland, c. 1903 (Source: Alan Kilpatrick)
1838. A notation in the family Bible claimed that ‘He lived respected and died lamented by all who knew him, having discharged the arduous task of instructing youth for the space of nineteen years in the Balleer School with great efficiency’.90 The premature death of Robert Reid must have caused significant hardship for the family. The total valuation of his landholding was £14 15s. On 19 February 1861 23-year-old Margaret married 29-year-old blacksmith David Kilpatrick, a native of Ballyards, at the Third Presbyterian church in Armagh. Together with their son William they emigrated to Auckland on the Indian Empire on 28 June 1862. They had a further three children. Between 1862 and 1916 Margaret wrote at least six letters back to home correspondents and received at least nine letters from a range of correspondents including her widowed mother, brothers, her husband’s siblings, and friends in Armagh.91
90 Joyce M. H. Reid (ed.), An introduction to the Balleer school copy book of letters (Belfast, 1977), pp xi–xii. 91 Margaret Anne Kilpatrick’s letters are lodged at P.R.O.N.I., D/3014/3/3/1–3 and D/3014/3/4/1–3. The letters sent to Margaret from Ireland were kindly supplied by Alan Kilpatrick, Gisborne.
31
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
The sequence provides intriguing depictions of male–female interaction and highlights the growing opportunities for young women who remained in Ireland. The letters also convey some of the religious fervour of the correspondents. Indeed Margaret herself was a regular parishioner at the old Wellesley Street church in Auckland, and a leader of the Young Women’s Bible Class. David Kilpatrick died on 23 March 1905 at Auckland and is buried with his daughter Elizabeth at Symonds Street cemetery. Death struck again more tragically in October 1906 when Margaret’s youngest son, Robert Ebenezer Reid Kilpatrick, died. Margaret went to live first with her daughter Mary in Dunedin, and then with her son William in Gisborne. It was here on 2 January 1922 that Margaret Kilpatrick died, at 84 years of age. She was buried at Taruheru cemetery. Her obituary praised her ‘broad Christian sympathies’ and observed that she was ‘Motherly, kind, and of deep personal piety’.92
Agnes Evelyn Lambert (née McNeice) Agnes Evelyn Lambert was born around 1842 in County Antrim. Her parentage has not been established but she may have been the daughter of Presbyterian couple John McNeice and Sarah Johnson, for the recipient of her letters was her half sister Susan Johnson, probably born at Parkgate, County Antrim. When Susan married John Jenkins in the Muckamore, County Antrim Presbyterian church in 1851, her father was recorded as Bunting Johnson and her place of residence was Rathmore, County Antrim. Agnes sailed from Liverpool in January 1860 on the Red Jacket. She was pregnant at the time and delivered a son just weeks after her arrival in Auckland. Her condition was allegedly the spur for her departure, though her reason for selecting New Zealand is unknown. Agnes became a live-in housekeeper for Kilkenny-born Michael Augustus Lambert, his wife, and their children. In October 1862, following the death of Michael’s wife, he and Agnes married. Together they raised his seven children, Agnes’s son, and their own six children, before Michael’s death in 1881. As a widow with four children under 14 years of age, Agnes was compelled to apply to the Auckland Hospital and Charitable Aid Board due to ‘want of employment’.93 Confronted with financial instability, Agnes actively sought aid and in 1888 the St Vincent de Paul Society heard that she ‘required assistance towards paying her rent . . . and also some assistance towards starting a shop’.94
92
New Zealand Baptist, March 1922, p. 43. Kindly provided by Alan Kilpatrick. Auckland Hospital and Charitable Aid Board, A493/65, p. 241, in N.A.A. 94 Minutes of St Vincent de Paul Society, cited in S. C. MacPherson, ‘“A ready made nucleus of degradation and disorder”? A religious and social history of the Catholic Church 93
32
INTRODUCTION
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Figure 13 ‘I have three fine sons and one little Girl’: the family of Agnes and Michael Lambert, c. 1877 (Source: Beverley Baird)
Agnes Lambert sent at least five letters home that have survived and a letter from her sister Isabella McNeice also exists.95 Agnes emerges as a discouraged, troubled woman, with the circumstances of her departure, early widowhood, and absence of kinfolk, presumably adding to her disenchantment. Despite such difficulties she remained resilient. She died, aged 84, on 27 June 1926 at Auckland Hospital, and was buried in Symonds Street Cemetery.
Edward Lysaght Born around 1840 in County Limerick, Edward Lysaght was the son of Edmund Lysaght and Mary Hayes. His father held 22 acres worth £17 5s annually at Clogher and later held land worth £28 at Knocknacarriga. Edmund was one of six sons of Michael Lysaght. In March 1837, together with his five brothers, Edmund was convicted of a Whiteboy offence and sentenced to
and community in Auckland, 1870–1910’, M.A. thesis, University of Auckland, 1987, p. 27. 95 Copies of the Lambert letters and family photographs were kindly provided by Beverley Baird, Newtownabbey, County Antrim. A letter sent from Isabella McNeice to Agnes was kindly provided by Garry Lambert, Auckland. 33
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
transportation to Australia. It transpired, however, that their accuser had committed perjury and the brothers were released in September 1837.96 Edmund Lysaght’s son Edward emigrated from Gravesend to Auckland in November 1862 on the Gertrude. In May 1864 he was joined briefly by his parents and brother William, having married Irishwoman Maria Callaghan at St Patrick’s Cathedral in Auckland in April. They had seven children. Edward Lysaght’s sister Ellen, meanwhile, voyaged to Auckland with cousins Catherine and Patrick Lysaght, arriving in February 1865. All told, seven letters sent to Edward Lysaght from his father and brother are known to have survived, together with a letter from Edward sent to his wife during a return visit to Ireland in 1872.97 Though younger than Edward, William’s tone was authoritative and challenging while their domineering father demanded filial obedience. Edward’s letter, meanwhile, suggests that he was a determined man with deep affection for his colonial family. There was clearly some conflict within the family, however, for in 1891 his daughter Mary Anne alleged that her mother Maria was a ‘Drunken old Prostitute’.98 While Edward Lysaght toiled as a labourer in Auckland, his brother William managed the family farm in Limerick and in May 1871 at Limerick’s Catholic Cathedral, 24-year-old William married Mary Crowe. Four months after the marriage William’s mother died while his father lived on until 1896. In 1899 Edward and Maria Lysaght, in their late fifties, entered the Costley Home for the Aged Poor in Auckland. An official inspection of the Home in 1903 found that ‘many inmates were in a lousy state, vermin literally dropping off them . . . . The Commissioners themselves noted that even fresh linen appeared half washed, that inmates’ clothing and bedding were thin and dirty, and that food was served up cold and inadequately cooked’.99 In such insanitary surroundings, it is hardly surprising that both Edward and Maria died that year. Two years later Edward’s sister, Ellen Bartley, suffering from diabetes, died, aged 61.
96 See W. R. Le Fanu, Seventy Years of Irish Life, p. 67. The Lysaghts were arrested after the claimant alleged they attacked his home and threatened the occupants. Despite denying the charge, the Lysaghts were found guilty and sentenced to transportation. They were, however, released when officials determined that their accuser had commited perjury at the trail. I am grateful to Jim Lycett of Canada and Joanne Mitchell, Geelong, Australia, for providing information about this trial. 97 The Lysaght letters were kindly provided by Reg Brown, Upper Kedron, Queensland. I am grateful to Professor David Fitzpatrick for bringing this collection to my attention and to Orma Fairweather for information about the Lysaghts in New Zealand. 98 Auckland Hospital and Charitable Aid Board Applications for Relief, 7 December 1891, YCAB A493/65, p. 804, in N.A.A. 99 Margaret Tennant, Paupers and providers: charitable aid in New Zealand (Wellington, 1989), p. 153.
34
INTRODUCTION
Elizabeth Macready Elizabeth Macready was born around 1844 in Belfast to Hugh Macready and Jane McMain. Her father, a teacher, occupied a house, worth £6 annually, at 143 Agnes Street in the Shankill parish of Belfast. Bessie had at least three siblings, two of whom died in their twenties. Shortly after 1870, the family moved to 20 Pine Street and it was here, in March 1874, that Hugh Macready died at 70 years of age. Two years later Bessie’s 26-year-old brother Charles died, followed a year later by her 64-year-old mother Jane. Bessie was the sole executrix of her estate valued at under £200.100 With no immediate family in Belfast, Bessie Macready emigrated from London to Lyttelton in December 1877 on the Pleiades to join her maternal aunts at Governors Bay. Bessie was a shopkeeper, housekeeper, teacher, and dressmaker. Though only three of her letters are known to exist, they reveal her to be a well-educated, optimistic, and determined woman.101 The recipients are unknown but it is probable that her cousin William Main of Ballooley in County Down was one recipient. Bessie Macready died in October 1926, aged 82, and is buried at St Cuthbert’s cemetery, Governors Bay.
Ann McCleland Ann McCleland was born in approximately 1815 to John and Elizabeth McCleland of Dunronan, in the civil parish of Desertlynn, County Londonderry. The family occupied just over three Irish acres of third- and fourth-class land, which fetched a tithe composition of 5s 6d in 1828. Ann sailed from Liverpool in March 1840 on the Martha Ridgway bound for Port Nicholson. Ann’s response to her departure is unknown but her mother wrote movingly of her daughter’s absence. This was followed by another letter the following year.102 Three years after her arrival, Ann McCleland wed German-born Johan Augustus Heldt at the Scotch church, Wellington. Heldt had arrived in the colony in February 1841 on the barque Jane from Valparaiso in Chile, where he had been goldmining. Following their marriage the couple returned there, had two children, and eventually paid ‘Eight Ounces & three quartis of Gold’ to return to Ireland on the Equator.103 They settled in a house worth £13 10s annually in the High Street at Moneymore, County Londonderry where they had a further seven children. In July 1859 the Heldts secured berths
100
Indices of Wills and Administrations for 1877 [407], in N.A.I. Bessie’s letters are lodged at P.R.O.N.I., D/1757/2/4–6, along with material relating to the Main family. 102 The two McCleland letters are in P.R.O.N.I., T/3034/1–2. 103 Master of Brig Equator, 10 March 1847, P.R.O.N.I., T/3034/8. 101
35
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Figure 14 The Heldt family (Source: Lena Fraser)
on the Mermaid and returned to New Zealand, this time settling in Auckland. Ann was a milliner while Johan spent time in the goldmines and was a ‘well known cabinetmaker’.104 Ann died, aged 67 in December 1887. Only six children were then living.
Winifred McClennan (née Furlong) Winifred McClennan was born on 17 August 1864 at Kilflyn, County Kerry, the eldest child of Martin Furlong and Ellen Behan. An officer in the Royal Irish Constabulary, Martin Furlong resigned in June 1865 and the following month departed for New Zealand with his wife, leaving Winifred in the care of her aunt, Mary Shanahan. Fifteen years later, on 7 July 1880, 17-year-old Winifred emigrated on the Wanganui bound for Auckland. In 1885 she married Australian-born publican James McClennan. Winifred received at least three letters from her aunt Mary in the early 1890s.105 The correspondence primarily catalogues Mary’s overwhelming grief upon the death of her mother. It seems likely that soon after this Winifred and
104 105
Cyclopedia of New Zealand (Christchurch, 1902), vi, 98. I am grateful to Virginia McClennan, New Plymouth, for supplying these letters. 36
INTRODUCTION
her family went to Australia before returning to New Zealand in 1902, settling at Cambridge. James McClennan died in April 1938 and six months later, on 12 October, Winifred died aged 74. Both were buried at Hillsborough cemetery, Auckland.
James Moreland McClure James Moreland McClure was born around 1825 at Newtownbreda, County Down, to George McClure and Prudence Harrison, while brother [Alexander] Gordon was christened at the Church of Ireland parish church in Newtownbreda in October 1831. George was frequently absent, owing to his employment as a surgeon on vessels transporting convicts to the colonies. In 1847 Prudence died and two years later George reputedly died in Paris attending to the administration of the estate of his brother-in-law, William Harrison. William had died in 1848 and George’s children received their recently deceased mother’s share (£30,000) in trust.106 James and Gordon McClure borrowed from this legacy to finance their migration from London to Dunedin in July 1860 on the Evening Star. Just days before departure, James had married 25-year-old Emily Humphreys. The brothers sent at least five letters back to their sisters residing in Belfast, including three written before and during the passage.107 They settled initially at Invercargill, but moved to Ryal Bush in Southland following approval of their land grant. Their brother, William George McClure, was the first superintendent at the Southland Hospital but abandoned his wife and family to settle in Australia.108 James, meanwhile, continued his farming interests in Southland, but also pursued a political career. In 1867 he was elected to the Provincial Council for the Southland province. James Moreland McClure died at 50 years of age on 17 January 1875. The Southland Times heralded his ‘extensive knowledge’ and ‘fine taste in polite literature’. He was allegedly a man ‘who, in private life, won general esteem; but, in public affairs, he was noted as being a pleasant discursive speaker, with a facile, almost poetical mastery of language, rather than as a peculiarly practical man of business, with an arithmetical cast of intellect’.109 The fate of James’s brothers remains unknown, though it is thought that Gordon drowned at sea.
106
P.R.O.N.I., D/1746/6/1. The McClure letters are in P.R.O.N.I., D/1746/5/1–2 and D/1746/3/1–3. 108 I am grateful to Jim McClure, Christchurch, for genealogical information on the McClure family. 109 Southland Times, 20 January 1875, p. 2. 107
37
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
David McCullough David McCullough was born on 1 September 1851 at Ballycreely, Moneyreagh, County Down, the eldest of three children of Unitarians Samuel McCullough and Margaret Connery, who had married at Moneyreagh’s Non-Subscribing Presbyterian church in November 1850. Samuel McCullough was relatively prosperous, for the Primary Valuation returned him as the occupier of 45 acres of land valued at £47 and a house worth £5 annually, his holding fetching the sixth highest valuation in the townland. In January 1875 David McCullough travelled from London to Dunedin on board the Andrew Reid, accompanied by his friend Alexander Young. They initially settled in Dunedin where David worked for the Albion Brewing and Malting Company. Eventually David elected to try his hand at goldmining on the West Coast. He sent at least five letters home, two of which were composed before his passage, one soon after his arrival, and two composed more than twenty years after his third letter.110 In 1899, less than two months after his last known surviving letter was written, David’s father died, at 77 years of age. His will specified that the farm was to be his wife’s and upon her death was to pass to David if he returned home within two years of his mother’s demise.111 Margaret McCullough died, at aged 75, in 1904. David never returned to Ireland and the estate passed to her grandson James Fisher. David McCullough emerges as a warm correspondent, preferring to hint at his return to Ireland rather than disappoint his parents with his desire to remain in the colony. Although little is known of his remaining years in the colony, some clues are available from his obituary. He was regarded as ‘one of the real old pioneer gold fossickers of the district . . . . Old “Davey” as he was popularly known, was a fine character and highly respected in this district.’112 David McCullough died at Waimangaroa on 17 December 1934, aged 83, and was buried at Orowaiti cemetery. His funeral expenses of £4 10s were paid by the Buller Hospital and Charitable Aid Board and a headstone was ‘erected by his admirers’.113
James Logan McIlrath In December 1834 John McIlrath, son of David McIlrath of Ballyminstra, married fellow County Down resident William Logan’s daughter Jane, of Tollynagee in the Presbyterian church at Killinchy, County Down. The couple settled on just over 27 acres of land at Balloo in County Down, worth £32 25s 110
The McCullough letters were kindly supplied by Moore Fisher Johnston and Sandra Gilpin, Comber, Newtownards, County Down. 111 A copy of Samuel McCullough’s will is in P.R.O.N.I., MIC/15c/2/43. 112 Westport News, 19 December 1934. 113 This information is contained in private correspondence in possession of Sandra Gilpin. 38
INTRODUCTION
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Figure 15 ‘A splendid likeness of us even to the house, horse and dog’: Emily, Edith, Jim, Eliza, Olive, and Frank McIlrath at Thorndale, Springfield, Canterbury, 1901 (Source: Jenny Langford)
annually, the fifth highest in the townland. Five children born between 1835 and 1845 were raised on the land, including the second and third sons James and Hamilton. In 1860 James and Hamilton, 24 and 21 years of age respectively, together with their friend William Martin of Newtownards, County Down, made their way to Liverpool where they sailed on the Donald McKay for Port Phillip, Australia. In September, after only a few months in Australia, James departed for the Otago gold diggings in New Zealand. He was followed three months later by Hamilton and another home compatriot, William James Alexander. The correspondence of the McIlraths incorporates 38 letters: of these, James wrote 23, Hamilton 14, and their father sent one letter to the brothers in 1862.114 The sequence spans forty-seven years and charts the impressions of the brothers from their early twenties until their sixties. Both emerge as confident, conversational, and curious correspondents.
114 Copies of James and Hamilton’s letters were kindly supplied by Jenny Langford, Wellington. A transcript of the series is in MS-Papers-5061, A.T.L. John McIlrath’s letter is in the Hazel Edith Conway Papers relating to the McIlrath family, ARC1993.45, Manuscripts Department, Canterbury Museum, Christchurch. In addition, letters from James and Hamilton’s children survive.
39
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Figure 16 Hamilton and Eliza McIlrath with two of their children (Source: Jenny Langford)
Eventually the brothers elected to purchase 100 acres of land at Lakeside in the Ellesmere district of Canterbury. Five years later James bought out Hamilton’s share and Hamilton purchased land at Thorndale Farm, Springfield. In June 1869 James married Agnes Matthews of Comber, County Down, and together the couple had ten children. Hamilton, meanwhile, married Eliza Atkinson in August 1872. James died at 63 years of age on 26 July 1901, eleven years after his wife, and was buried at Ellesmere public cemetery. Hamilton died on 24 July 1915, aged 75. His daughter Emily informed cousins in Balloo that ‘Altho’ our father was of a quiet disposition, and didn’t go out much among people, great respect was shown to him by the very large funeral he had’.115
Alexander Neil McKelvey In May 1866 at Draperstown Meeting House in the parish of Ballinascreen, County Londonderry, Robert McKelvey, a 24-year-old farmer from Trinamadan, County Tyrone, married Margaret Patterson Hanna, a 21-year-old spinster from Moydamlat, County Londonderry. They settled at Trinamadan 115
Emily McIlrath (Canterbury) to her cousins (Down), 12 August 1915. 40
INTRODUCTION
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Figure 17 Alexander Neil McKelvey (Source: Dave McKelvey/ Mary Slavin)
in Badoney Lower parish where Robert’s various holdings of more than 300 acres were valued at £35 10s. In 1874 he acquired a further 62 acres worth £17 5s per annum. That same year, in September, his fifth child and third son, Alexander Neil, was born. Alexander McKelvey was a physician at the Richmond Hospital in Dublin between 1896 and 1897 before being appointed Assistant Medical Officer at the District Asylum at Omagh, County Tyrone, in the townland of Cranny. He remained there until 1902 and was later remembered as ‘a most efficient, hard working and popular officer’.116 In February 1902 Alexander was initiated 116 This resolution was made on 16 January 1932 after news of Alexander’s death was received. It is in P.R.O.N.I., D/1692/4.
41
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
into the Masonic Gortin Lodge 994, of which his father was Worshipful Master, perhaps to ensure his progress in New Zealand where he ventured later that year on the Papanui.117 After arrival at Wellington Alexander McKelvey moved north to Auckland where he obtained employment at the Auckland Mental Asylum as assistant medical superintendent. By 1910 he was medical superintendent. Alexander continued his Masonic affiliations, joining Auckland Lodge No. 87 in 1907.118 He later became a master of the Auckland Lodge and a second principal of the Supreme Grand Royal Arch Chapter.119 In 1904 Alexander McKelvey married Muriel Grace Mills and the couple produced three children. Three of the letters he sent home between 1904 and 1913 have survived.120 They give an intriguing appraisal of the contrasts Alexander perceived between Ireland’s and New Zealand’s Masonic practices, work relationships, and mental health institutions. His calligraphy was clear and his style somewhat formal and courteous. Muriel died in 1928 and Alexander on 10 November 1931, aged 57. Both were buried at St Andrew’s church, Epsom, Auckland. Robert McKelvey, meanwhile, had died at 84 years of age in May 1923, leaving an estate valued for administration at £4,413 3s.
Oliver McSparron Oliver McSparron was born around 1837, to Archibald McSparron, who farmed nearly 50 acres of land at Umrycam, in the civil parish of Banagher, County Londonderry. Though Archibald’s combined holdings were valued annually at £7, his property fetched the eighth highest valuation among approximately forty holdings in the townland. Oliver departed from Liverpool in November 1859 with two friends on the White Star bound for Melbourne.121 Initially Oliver made his way to his maternal uncle, William Oliver. In September 1861 Oliver McSparron went to the New Zealand goldfields. His six surviving letters assert his own interests in electing to remain in the colony rather than succumb to his father’s repeated demands that he return to Umrycam.122 In 1883, the year after Oliver sent a terse letter home
117 I am grateful for this information to Alex Ward, Archivist of the Grand Lodge of Ireland. See also A short history of Gortin Masonic lodge no. 994. 118 Information provided by S. J. Cooper, Secretary, Grand Lodge of New Zealand Freemasons. 119 Auckland Star, 12 November 1931, p. 11. 120 The McKelvey letters are in P.R.O.N.I., D/1692/3/6–8. 121 Oliver is recorded as ‘Oliver Sparron’, aged 23. See index to inward passenger lists, British and foreign ports, Public Record Office of Victoria, Code B, Fiche 172, page 011, online at http://surnamesupersearch.com/passenger/victoriashipslists.htm. 122 Oliver McSparron’s six letters from New Zealand are lodged in P.R.O.N.I., T/2743/2/
42
INTRODUCTION
demanding money from his father, Archibald McSparron died, aged 72. Archibald had been living at Flanders, Dungiven, County Londonderry with his daughter and son-in-law. Oliver McSparron died on 13 February 1900 at Titipua, Mataura, aged 60, and was buried at Mataura cemetery.
James O’Neill James O’Neill, the second son of ten children, was born in about 1822, probably at Broad Street in the parish of St John’s, Limerick, to James O’Neill and Bridget Kennedy.123 Approximately twenty years later the family moved to Brunswick Street in Prior’s Land in the parish of St Michael’s, Limerick.124 James O’Neill senior promptly converted the building, originally the Stein Distillery, into a coach factory and built a new house beside it.125 A coachbuilder, James O’Neill senior presumably trained his son James, who was recorded as a wheelwright. James O’Neill junior married Bridget Ryan of Pallasbeg, County Limerick in August 1862 in Liverpool and emigrated on 25 August 1862 on the Shalimar. The couple settled at Auckland and it was from here that James wrote his only known surviving letter, composed eight months after his arrival.126 Besides documenting household havoc in Limerick, James’s letter to his brother Thomas relates details of the conflict brewing between Maori and colonial forces. His meticulously inscribed letter also provides a thoughtful, reflective account of conditions in Auckland and reveals him to be a responsible, ambitious man. James and Bridget O’Neill had thirteen children, but when James died on 14 April 1893 at Costley Street in Auckland, only six were still alive. Bridget O’Neill lived on for a further twenty-five years until her death, at 81 years of age, in October 1918.
1–6. The collection also contains letters sent by Oliver from Australia, among other family correspondence. 123 Baptisms between 1798 and 1825 and marriages between 1798 and 1821 are missing from St John’s parish registers. Consequently, the marriage of James and Bridget and the baptisms of their children Thomas, James, and Patrick are not listed. However, the surviving records list the remaining children of this couple. 124 Brunswick Street is now Sarsfield Street. See Gerry Joyce, Limerick city street names (Limerick, 1995), p. 19. 125 James O’Neill appears in the 1844 rate book for St Michael’s parish. Comparison with an earlier rate book suggests that his coach factory was converted from the Stein Distillery as the preceding and subsequent entries in both rate books are the same. 126 The original letter was kindly provided by Peter O’Sullivan, Belfast, and is now in my possession. 43
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
John O’Regan John O’Regan was born around 1831 in County Cork to farmer Florence O’Regan and Johanna Harrington. His father’s godfather was apparently Florence McCarty, a Catholic attorney, who was transported to Australia in 1799, and to whom John refers in his letter.127 John O’Regan went first to North America and arrived in New Zealand in approximately 1866. He spent his life as a miner and in 1899 wrote a letter from Barrytown on the West Coast to his great-niece Ellen O’Regan living in Montana in the United States.128 His very articulate letter reflects intently on his family connexions, Irish cultural issues, and surroundings in New Zealand. John O’Regan, resident of Cobden, died on 6 November 1910 at Grey River hospital aged 79. He was buried in Greymouth cemetery.
Ellen Piezzi (née Walsh) Ellen Piezzi was born around 1849 at Paulstown, County Kilkenny, to stonemason Thomas Walsh and Margaret Hennessy. She emigrated in approximately 1870, following in the footsteps of siblings already in New Zealand. In May 1872 Ellen, 22 years of age, married 28-year-old Swiss-Italian hotelkeeper Julius Piezzi at the Catholic church in Hokitika. The couple ran the Helvetia Hotel and had three children. Julius died in September 1876, leaving his widow to keep the hotel going. Between 1878 and about 1881 Ellen wrote at least seven letters to her brother-in-law Victer Piezzi and his wife in California.129 The letters provide interesting reflections on marriage, news of her children, and fluctuating business fortunes. In October 1883 Ellen, now aged 33, married 25-year-old Tipperary-born Dennis Maher at the Catholic chapel at Rimu, Westland and the couple had three children. They ran hotels on the West Coast and in Wellington. Ellen died on 16 November 1922 at 75 years of age. She was buried at Karori.
William Cunningham Quinn William Cunningham Quinn was baptised in the Catholic parish of Newry, County Down on 13 October 1840, the third child and second son of Bernard 127 Florence McCarty was transported to Australia for forming a committee and administering illegal oaths. See Anne-Marie Whitaker, Unfinished Revolution: United Irishmen in NSW, 1800–1810 (Sydney, 1994), pp 208–9. I am grateful to Barbara Hall for this reference. 128 This letter was kindly supplied by Dennis Regan, Washington, USA. 129 These letters were kindly supplied by Teresa O’Connor. An illuminating portrait of Ellen, written by Teresa, can be found in Sheryll Ofner (ed.), New Zealand women in the 19th century (Auckland, 1993), pp 40–2.
44
INTRODUCTION
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Figure 18 Ellen Maher (formerly Piezzi and Walsh) in her hotel with her sons and daughter (Source: Teresa O’Connor)
Quinn and Eliza Cunningham. His brother Patrick, who also resided in New Zealand, was baptised in March 1836, ten months after the marriage of his parents. John Quinn, the major recipient of the brothers’ letters, was born in 1843.130 A further two children were born in the parish before the family relocated to Bessbrook in County Armagh, where a further two children were born. Eighteen-year-old William arrived in Auckland in 1859 on the Whirlwind. Three years later the War Spirit carried his 27-year-old brother Patrick to the colony. Little is known of the colonial careers of the Quinns but William appears to have made several trips across the Tasman Sea.131 In contrast with William’s repeated migrations across the Tasman, Patrick was a gumdigger, allegedly ‘the last refuge of the waster and the failure’, in Dargaville. 132 Gumdigging, a method to collect gum (or resin) from the kauri tree to produce high quality varnish, provided a form of social security for the elderly before and after the introduction of the pension. Patrick, a beneficiary of the pension
130
The Quinn letters are in P.R.O.N.I., T/1552/1–14. The letters sent from New Zealand are item numbers 10–14. 131 Patrick O’Farrell briefly discusses William’s Australian career in Letters from Irish Australia, pp 54–5. 132 Alan Mulgan, ‘Literature and landscape in New Zealand’, in New Zealand Geographer, ii (1946), p. 198. 45
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
from 1900 onwards, continued to dig for gum.133 His fondness for drink, however, caused brother William great consternation and seemingly created distance between the brothers as Patrick complained repeatedly to brother John that William rarely made contact. Unlike Patrick Quinn, William accumulated a significant amount of money and sent remittances home frequently. The money was undoubtedly welcomed by brother John, who resided at 130 Leeson Street, Belfast, with his wife and eight children ranging in age from 2 to 19 years. Sister Lizzie, meanwhile, lived at Station Road in Larne, County Antrim with her husband Alexander Jenkins. Their son, Robert, a stone cutter, followed in the footsteps of his uncles to New Zealand from where he informed the family of his uncle William’s death on 29 September 1909. When William died on 15 April 1916 at Auckland aged 75, he left a substantial estate valued at between £5,000 and £6,000. To Robert he bequeathed ‘my watches watch chains and personal clothing’ along with £200.134 Two days after his death, William Quinn was buried at Waikumete cemetery. His headstone provides a lasting testimony to his date of arrival in Auckland and his place and date of birth.135
Hugh Rea Hugh Rea was born on 8 December 1844 at Scrib, near Seaforde, County Down, in the parish of Loughinisland. The second of three children of William Rea and Catherine Newell, he was christened three days later in the Presbyterian church at nearby Clough. His father was most likely a son of Hugh Rea, born in 1805, who in 1828 held three acres of land at Scrib. It seems likely that his father died soon after the birth of Hugh’s brother William in 1850, for the Primary Valuation (see n. 45 above) records Catherine Rea at Ardtanagh as occupier of a house valued annually at five shillings. Elizabeth, the first-born child, was also residing here when she married Robert Gracey in 1864. Hugh Rea probably laboured locally before his decision to emigrate at 29 years of age. He sailed on 2 May 1874 on the Peter Denny which arrived at Port Chalmers on 26 July. Little is known of Hugh Rea’s life, but he laboured in the colony and held property at Clinton, ‘the centre of a very extensive district devoted to agriculture and pasturage’.136 It was from here in 1905 that he wrote to his brother William, complaining about the transient nature of 133
Patrick’s claim was received on 27 March 1900 and his pension certificate was granted eight months later. See Record Book, Old Age Pension Claim Register, BADC ACC 497/63, in N.A.A. The Minute Book Old Age Pension, BADC ACC A497/64, p. 101, contains reference to Patrick’s character, considered good, and confirmation of his age. The Old Age Pension Certificate Register, BADC ACC 497/67, p. 1, records Patrick’s death. 134 The Will of William Cunningham Quinn, 10628, in N.A.A., BBAE 1569. 135 William’s grave is in Area 3, Block 5, Lot 99a. 136 Cyclopedia of New Zealand (Christchurch, 1905), iv, 750. 46
INTRODUCTION
colonial employment and hinting at his desire to return to Ireland.137 Although William has not been traced in Irish records, their sister Elizabeth married William McCance in 1878, following the death of her first husband. By the time of the 1901 Census 56-year-old Elizabeth was yet again widowed, living with her 19-year-old son William and 11-year-old grandson Matthew McReynolds. On 11 July 1916 71-year-old Hugh Rea died at Clinton from obstruction of the bowels. The Otago Witness recorded the death of ‘Hughie Ray . . . a resident of many years standing. He was a very handy man with tools, and his services were always in demand with people of the town and district. He was a very clever exponent of the violin and mouth organ, and spent much of his time in company with these cherished instruments.’138 Hugh’s will stipulated that his effects were to be divided between his brother William and sister Elizabeth.139 The following year Elizabeth received £58 11s 5d from the Dunedin law firm, Duncan and McGregor.140 A Clinton correspondent also informed her that Hugh ‘will be greatly missed by a number of friends and especially by the children in the township with whom he was a general favourite.’141
Daniel Strong William Strong married Mary Ryan in February 1849 and they had six children including the fifth, Daniel, who was born on 5 July 1859 at Lehinch, County Tipperary. Tragedy struck in 1864 when publican William died. His assets included a public house at the Ferry, near Lehinch, that Daniel was due to inherit. Family tradition, however, indicates that mismanagement led to the pub being sold.142 Following not only his father’s early demise, but also that of his mother and siblings, Daniel found comfort with the family of his father’s brother, Denis. Indeed it was cousins who wrote to Daniel Strong between 1883 and 1905.143 His cousin John wrote four letters while John’s brother Martin wrote two and their sister Lizzie one. The sequence indicates strong affection between the cousins at home and abroad and conveys the satisfaction of the Strongs who remained in Ireland.
137
The Rea letter is in P.R.O.N.I., D/965/1. It is incorrectly indexed as being to his brotherin-law William McCance. 138 Otago Witness, 19 July 1916, p. 27. 139 The Will of Hugh Rea, 3712, in N.A.D., D239/166. 140 Duncan and McGregor (Dunedin) to Mrs Elizabeth McCance (Scrib), 23 May 1917, in P.R.O.N.I., D/963/3. 141 Letter to Mrs McCance (Seaforde) from an unknown correspondent (Clinton), 10 July 1916, in P.R.O.N.I., D/965/2. 142 Joyce Elaine Strong (compiler), History of the Stronge family (1972), privately circulated. 143 Photocopies of the Strong letters were kindly provided by Ginny Dow, Nelson. 47
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
In November 1902, almost two decades after Daniel’s departure in 1883, he married 31-year-old Mary Mulkere at the Catholic church in Onehunga, Auckland. The couple resided at Selwyn Road, Howick, where their four children were born. Daniel pursued his trade as a carpenter and was elected to the Roads Board for the local council. Daniel Strong died on 17 June 1951, aged 91, and was buried at the Catholic cemetery in Howick. His wife died four years later.
Catherine Sullivan (née Riordan) Catherine Sullivan was probably born on 17 March 1831 to Patrick Riordan and Mary Brown of County Limerick. Little is known about her own family, but her husband John Sullivan, whom she married on 17 November 1855, was the son of Cornelius Sullivan and Mary Lynch who had married in July 1827 at the Catholic church in Ballingarry, County Limerick. John was brought up in a house located in the townland of Common, County Limerick rented for 10 shillings per annum. The Sullivans were assisted to New Zealand with their five children in January 1874 on the Wennington bound for Wellington.144 The family settled at Foxton, Manawatu, renowned for its flax industry and known colloquially as the town of ‘flax, fires and fleas’.145 The sole surviving letter from Catherine Sullivan so far to come to light was written to her brother-in-law in Ballingarry in 1905 informing him of his brother John’s death in April the year previous.146 Three years before her death on 22 February 1917 at 86 years of age, Catherine had relocated to live with her daughter Margaret and son-in-law Michael Spelman at Raumai, Palmerston North. Catherine Sullivan’s obituary proclaimed her as ‘one of the pioneers of the Foxton district . . . well known and highly respected throughout the Manawatu’.147 Catherine was buried two days after her death beside her husband at Foxton.148
Patrick Owen Treanor Patrick Owen Treanor was possibly born at Golan in the Donagh parish, County Monaghan, to Owen Treanor and Ellen McKenna. His brother James,
144
IM 15/95, N.A.W. H. G. Boniface, ‘Foxton: its site and changing function’, M.A. thesis, University of New Zealand, 1947. 146 A copy of this letter was kindly supplied by Catherine Habes, Cincinnati, Ohio. I am also grateful to Suzanne Lisson, Canada, for information relating to the Sullivan family. 147 Manawatu Daily Times, 24 February 1917, p. 4. 148 Catherine is in Plot 20a, Block II, R.C. while John is in Plot 20, Block II, R.C. 145
48
INTRODUCTION
born in 1852, came to New Zealand before Patrick Owen and worked as a policeman. Patrick Owen, meanwhile, worked at Wanganui and in 1876 wrote two letters to another Patrick Treanor, possibly his cousin from the townland of Knocknagrave, County Monaghan.149 His correspondence was largely preoccupied with his work patterns. Details of Patrick Owen Treanor’s death have not been traced, but his brother James died in October 1917. This chapter has briefly indicated that migration was not necessarily an alienating or atomising life event. Rather, it was frequently undertaken within the context of extensive connexions provided by family and neighbourhood, which served to lessen the dislocating effect of relocation. The chapter has also explained the importance of personal letters as a source for exploring the process and experience of migration. Finally, it has outlined the basic demographic features of the migrants and letter writers incorporated in this study and provided brief biographical snapshots of the migrants who feature in the book. We now turn to consider the broader Irish migrant flow to New Zealand. Demographic and official evidence will be used to map the origins and patterns of settlement of Irish settlers in New Zealand as well as indicating the overarching factors facilitating the movement of natives of Ireland to New Zealand. Personal correspondence will be used to assess a range of reasons for leaving Ireland; the ways in which letter writers encouraged Irish migration to New Zealand; and the response of migrants and their loved ones to the process of separation.
149
Copies of these letters were kindly supplied by Leone Shaw, Hamilton. 49
1
‘It is well to gain that shore’ Irish migration and New Zealand settlement In 1886 William Gilmer found himself contemplating leaving Ireland. Gilmer, a member of the Church of Ireland who farmed sixteen acres at Mullaghanee in County Monaghan, was motivated to move by deteriorating local and national economic conditions. As he complained vociferously to his brother Robert in New Zealand, ‘Ireland is a very miserable place. We have not had more than 2 or 3 dry days at once all this summer. Harvest is ripe & no dry weather to cut it. The potato crop is a failure. Things are looking very bad indeed’ (Gr 2). Official reports confirmed that in Monaghan in 1886, ‘The yield of the potato and oats crop is far short of what it was last year. This is owing to the late spring, too much rain during the summer, and a want of ripening in the autumn. The heavy rain of last month had the effect of diminishing the oat crop considerably, and damaging the potato crop.’1 This mounting malaise in Monaghan prompted a disheartened William to reconsider his future: ‘I’ll have to do something else than farming in Ireland, working & spending money for nothing’ (Gr 2). Another of William Gilmer’s New Zealand-based brothers, Samuel, commiserated about the disturbing circumstances in Ireland: ‘I can imagine all there is to be done on a few acres of Irish soil is not much after all said and done’ (Gr 1). Disgruntled with his situation in Ireland, William considered his options. Australia as well as New Zealand was obviously in his mind for brother Samuel queried cheekily, ‘As for you going to new south wales is new zealand not large enough for you.’ Samuel then suggested, ‘Would you not have been better here only for your health’ (Gr 1). Just as crucial as William’s wellbeing, however, was his wife’s employment opportunities: ‘If I had only middling health I wd not stop long in Ireland, altho, I’ve fair health lately. If I thought my wife could get a situation as teacher, I wd very soon leave here’ (Gr 2). Unlike many correspondents in Ireland, William Gilmer had already spent a period of time in New Zealand where five of his six brothers had settled, their staggered chain migration seemingly following the settlement of their maternal uncle, John Hamilton.2 Once in the colony, William nominated his
1 Tables showing the Extent in Statute Acres and the Produces of the Crops for the year 1886, p. 121, in H.C.P., 1886 [C 4902], lxxi. 2 John Hamilton’s arrival has not been ascertained. I am grateful to Ian Cameron and John
50
IRISH MIGRATION AND NEW ZEALAND SETTLEMENT
cousins Abigail and Robert Gilmer to join him. His payment of £7 towards the fare and outfitting of his cousins enabled them to voyage to New Zealand on the Ionic in 1884.3 Five years earlier a relative of the Gilmers, Dorothea Hamilton, had sponsored her sister Sarah.4 Poor health sparked William’s return to Ireland, rather ironic given that New Zealand was frequently acclaimed as a healthy environment. Yet despite his previous colonial experience, William Gilmer was unwilling to depart Ireland without first seeking the advice of his brothers. As he asked Robert, ‘wd you advise me sell & go back again’ (Gr 2). Robert’s response is unknown, but Samuel urged William to migrate, though he was careful to stress that William should ultimately make the final decision: ‘my advice would be to you if health better and no encumbrance that Greymouth should suit you well but please yourself. You should be the best judge off those matters’ (Gr 1). Despite Samuel’s restrained recommendation, this time William Gilmer elected to stay in Ireland. His final decision was probably shaped by inheritance factors. As the youngest son of his father Hugh’s second marriage, William inherited the family holding at Mullaghanee while the eldest son of Hugh’s first marriage, James, was probably assisted in purchasing a nearby farm. The remaining Gilmer sons of the first marriage, without a future claim on the family holding, were presumably provided with a sum of money to pursue their colonial careers. As Kevin Whelan has aptly put it, ‘One for the farm; the rest for the road.’5 The Gilmer letters and family background raise a number of issues that are of central importance when it comes to analysing Irish migration to New Zealand. They not only highlight the critical involvement of family and friends at home and abroad in the process of migration, but they also reveal that a number of factors, encompassing individual, household, regional, and global perspectives, shaped the decision to migrate or remain in Ireland. This chapter sets the stage for the investigation of Irish migration to New Zealand by providing a brief overview of migration from Ireland during the nineteenth century and of settlement patterns of Irish migrants in New Zealand. It focuses closely on the crucial influence of schemes of nominated and assisted migration, and examines the role of propaganda in disseminating information about New Zealand. Migrants’ multitude of reasons for leaving Ireland are gleaned from clues contained within the letters and from biographical information. The encouragement provided by pioneering migrants Hewstone for information relating to the Gilmers which will appear in their forthcoming privately published The hotel that Sam built: the story of Samuel Gilmer and the Royal Oak Hotel Cuba St, Wellington, New Zealand. 3 William’s nomination, dated 6 February 1884, is held in IM 12, no. 656, N.A.W. Details of his cousins appear in the Ionic’s shipping register, IM 15/470, N.A.W. 4 Dorothea Hamilton’s nomination was dated 28 March 1879, IM 11, no. 3238, N.A.W. 5 Kevin Whelan, ‘The famine and post-famine adjustment’ in William Nolan (ed.), The shaping of modern Ireland (Cork, 1986), p. 160. 51
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
for their kin in Ireland to join them is examined, as is the impact of departure on migrant and non-migrant correspondents. It is argued that correspondents were more likely to be attracted to New Zealand by personal recommendations rather than propaganda, but that they required access to assisted passages to facilitate their relocation. In a succinct summary of Irish migration between 1801 and 1921 David Fitzpatrick has observed, ‘Growing up in Ireland meant preparing oneself to leave it.’6 Estimates of migration from Ireland support this statement, since approximately eight million Irish men and women left their homeland between 1815 and 1914.7 This outflow saw the country’s population decline from a nineteenth-century peak of more than eight million people in 1841 to approximately four million in the early twentieth century. The intensity of this movement varied throughout the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries with around one and a half million leaving before the famine of the late 1840s, two and a half million going between 1846 and 1855, and four million departing between 1856 and 1914. This Irish dispersal was part of a larger European movement which saw an estimated sixty million people leave their homelands between 1815 and 1930.8 Ireland lost proportionately more migrants than other European countries during this period9 and, unlike most other nations until the later nineteenth century, women contributed almost half the Irish outflow.10 Regrettably, poor statistical data in Ireland prevents any more conclusive remarks being made about the size of the Irish outflow and the numbers settling at various destinations. One illuminating insight into the rate, timing, origin, and destination of Irish migration, however, is the Registrar General’s returns of direct migration from Ireland.11 Analysis based on this source, though, should acknowledge at least two factors. First, it fails to include those migrants who travelled initially to Britain before voyaging further afield. Second, it is a relatively late source for any analysis of worldwide Irish migration. Despite these drawbacks, Fitzpatrick has utilised this source for the years 1876–85 to
6
David Fitzpatrick, Irish emigration, 1801–1921 (Dundalk, 1984), p. 30. The following figures are drawn from David Fitzpatrick, Irish emigration, 1801–1921 and his articles ‘Irish emigration in the later nineteenth century’ in Irish Historical Studies, xxii (1980–1), pp 126–43; ‘Emigration, 1801–70’, pp 562–616, and ‘Emigration, 1871–1921’, pp 606–42, in W. E. Vaughan (ed.), A new history of Ireland: Ireland under the union, I, 1801–70 (vol. 5) and II, 1870–1921 (vol. 6), (Oxford, 1989 and 1996). 8 Dudley Baines, Emigration from Europe, 1815–1930 (Basingstoke and London, 1991), p. 7. 9 Ibid., table 3, p. 10. 10 Fitzpatrick, Irish emigration, p. 7. 11 This source is useful for examining migration to New Zealand direct from Ireland. It does not, however, include the larger stream of migrants that made their way to New Zealand from British or Australian ports. 7
52
IRISH MIGRATION AND NEW ZEALAND SETTLEMENT
highlight contrasts in the regional origins of Irish migrants selecting different destinations.12 The Irish favouring the United States tended to originate from the western counties in the province of Connacht, while Canada attracted migrants from Ulster and the north-west. Irish settlers in Australia, meanwhile, were largely drawn from the south-west and the north midlands. New Zealand, on the other hand, can be seen as a ‘hybrid’ of Irish emigration to Australia and Canada with its strong Ulster–Munster bias (see Table 1.2 below).13 This dispersal of Irish migrants to various destinations is evident in the letters exchanged between New Zealand and Ireland. Despite the extent of Irish migration to Britain, letters sent between Ireland and New Zealand only occasionally commented on British-based associates. In 1895 Martin Strong informed his cousin Daniel, ‘Willie Ducie our first cousin is a very big fellow in Manchester’ (St 3). This may suggest that most contacts of these families went further afield or that acquaintances closer to home were less likely to have attracted comment. Migration to Britain was also a different type of migration in that it tended to be of a short distance and temporary duration.14 Irish migration to Australia, on the other hand, was discussed frequently, not only because of its proximity to New Zealand, but also because of its popularity among migrants. In 1866, 19-year-old William Lysaght reported from his father’s farm at Doon Glebe, County Limerick, ‘There are a great number leaving this country for Australia and other places. In fact very few people are here now’ (Ly 1).15 Australia was also the favoured destination of several acquaintances of John Armstrong, the second son and seventh child of John Armstrong senior, a Church of Ireland clergyman at Kiltoom, County Roscommon. Among John’s acquaintances in Australia was Adair Crawford, whom John described as ‘a fast young man’ (Ar 2).16 A female acquaintance, on the other hand, returned to Ireland only to voyage once again to Australia prompting John to conclude, ‘Rebecca must be fond of Colonial life to be induced to go to Australia a second time’ (Ar 2). These extracts not only highlight Irish dispersal to Australia, but also the circular movement of some migrations, a theme discussed further in Chapter 7.
12
David Fitzpatrick, ‘Irish emigration in the later nineteenth century’. Ibid., p. 133. 14 For the Irish in Britain see T. M. Devine (ed.), Irish immigrants and Scottish society in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries (Edinburgh, 1991); Graham Davis, The Irish in Britain, 1815–1914 (Dublin, 1991); Donald M. MacRaild, Irish migrants in modern Britain, 1750–1922 (Basingstoke and London, 1999); Enda Delaney, Demography, state, and society: Irish migration to Britain, 1921–1971 (Liverpool, 2000). 15 This population decline is recorded in official statistics for the county, which reveal a decrease of just under 12 per cent during the decade 1861–71. 16 Patrick O’Farrell has termed Crawford a ‘genteel wastrel’. See Letters from Irish Australia, 1825–1929 (Kensington, 1984), p. 51. 13
53
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
Australia also proved popular among migrants from the civil parish of Lisnadill in County Armagh. In 1863 Presbyterian widow Mary Anne Reid informed her migrant daughter Margaret Kilpatrick of ‘a great many that is going to Queens land this week’ (Ki 2). This depopulation is captured in statistics for the townland of Balleer, which suffered a population decline of 22 per cent in the 1860s. That Australia was a relatively popular destination for natives of Armagh is evident in statistics that reveal the county was the eleventh largest supplier of migrants to Australia between 1841 and 1914.17 The attractions of Australia and the mobility of Irish migrants continued to be discussed in the twentieth century. As County Tipperary migrant Michael Farrell wrote cheerfully from Morven, South Canterbury, in 1911 to his brother in Tipperary, ‘I met Tom Houlihan from Ballinderry. He’s a divel has travelled all over Australia’ (Fa 1). Correspondents in Ireland were also keen to discuss the movement of acquaintances to North America, evidence of a transnational consciousness. As Elizabeth Walker revealed concisely from Armagh in 1864: ‘Lucy Reaney & her sister Nancy are gone to America’ (Ki 4). The importance of Canada as a destination was further outlined in 1880 when Sophy Lang reported on the settlement of many Armagh acquaintances there: ‘William Ross and his family is in manatobia in America. Jane Fraim and her son is in America too’ (Ki 7). In all, estimates suggest that between the early seventeenth century and 1922 approximately seven million Irish settled in North America.18 We have no firm data on the numbers of Irish arriving in New Zealand, but they presumably contributed a significant minority of the approximately 112,000 migrants recorded as sailing direct to New Zealand from British ports between 1844 and 1871.19 Most of these early arrivals were English, while Scottish migrants supplied more than double their representation in Britain. Despite being outnumbered by the English and Scots, by 1867 the Irish, at 13 per cent, peaked in their representation of New Zealand’s overall population. That same year, natives of England contributed 30 per cent of the population, while Scots supplied 16 per cent of the population. Thirty per cent of the population was also composed of those born in New Zealand. This peopling of New Zealand continued and during the period 1871–91 natives of Ireland supplied around one-third of the 115,578 recorded assisted newcomers to the country.20 Yet a focus on migrants sailing direct from Britain and Ireland fails to acknowledge that many migrants, especially in the period
17 See David Fitzpatrick, Oceans of consolation: personal accounts of Irish migration to Australia (Cork, 1995), figure 5, p. 15. 18 Kerby A. Miller, Emigrants and exiles: Ireland and the Irish exodus to North America (New York, 1985), p. 3. 19 See Donald Harman Akenson, Half the world from home: perspectives on the Irish in New Zealand, 1860–1950 (Wellington, 1990), table 5, p. 22. 20 Derived from the annual migration returns found in A.J.H.R.
54
IRISH MIGRATION AND NEW ZEALAND SETTLEMENT
before 1870, came to New Zealand via Australia after either a short stopover or a period of residence there.21 The mobility of goldminers is particularly striking in this regard.22 Despite the considerable numbers of miners who crossed the Tasman Sea, it was a movement renowned for its flux, as many returned to Australia or moved on to other destinations within the diaspora. Throughout this period of immigration, few vessels sailed to New Zealand direct from Irish ports. Consequently, most Irish who made their way to New Zealand did so via English and Scottish ports. This may contribute to an underestimate of the number of natives of Ireland arriving in New Zealand, for some Irish sailing from Britain may have stayed in Britain for a short time and given their last place of residence there, rather than place of birth to shipping agents. The decline in Irish arrivals from the late nineteenth century onwards reflects the ending of assisted passages to New Zealand, which were only implemented thereafter during certain years. The proximity of Ulster migrants to Scottish ports provides one explanation for their strong representation among Irish migrants in New Zealand (see Table 1.1). The perception by Ulster Protestants of New Zealand as a Protestant country may also have influenced their decision to settle there. Canterbury, for instance, was a strongly ‘Protestant’ province. This helps explain its popularity for Ulster migrants who, based on their county affiliations, were disproportionately Protestant.23 Assorted studies have also revealed that migrants from Munster were heavily represented among New Zealand’s Irish settlers. Donald Akenson’s figures, based on direct migration from Ireland, exclude those Irish voyaging from British and Australian ports, but still point to an Ulster–Munster dominance.24 Examination of shipping registers to particular provinces also shows this two-province dominance.25 There are, however, difficulties in relying on shipping registers to ascertain the origins of Irish migrants in New Zealand. Most analyses based on this source exclude those Irish who paid their passage to New Zealand and may
21
Akenson, Half the world from home, p. 21. See Lyndon Fraser, ‘Irish migration to the West Coast, 1864–1900’, in N.Z.J.H., xxxiv (2000), pp 197–225, and Terry Hearn, ‘The Irish on the Otago goldfields’ in Lyndon Fraser (ed.), A distant shore: Irish migration and New Zealand settlement (Dunedin, 2000), p. 84. 23 R. H. Silcock, ‘Immigration into Canterbury under the provincial government’, M.A. thesis, University of Canterbury, 1964, tables 7 and 8; K. A. Pickens, ‘Canterbury, 1851–81: demography and mobility, a comparative study’, Ph.D. thesis, Washington University, 1976, table 1:50, p. 222. 24 Akenson, Half the world from home, table 22, pp 70–1. See also Terry Hearn, ‘Irish migration to New Zealand to 1915’ in Fraser (ed.), A distant shore, pp 55–74. 25 Assisted Irish arrivals in Otago and Southland, for instance, were composed primarily of Ulster and Munster migrants. See Seán G. Brosnahan, ‘The greening of Otago: Irish [Catholic] immigration to Otago and Southland 1840–1888’ in Norma J. Bethune (ed.), Work ‘n’ pastimes: 150 years of pain and pleasure, labour and leisure (Dunedin, 1998), table 1, p. 62. 22
55
35.84 45.64 9.72 8.80
43.48 35.27 14.87 6.37
1871–90
1876–90 40.46 40.04 7.06 12.44
Brosnahan (Otago and Southland) 1872–88 33.2 26.4 10.5 6.9
1850–1900
Weber (NZ-wide)
53.3 27.3 10.8 9.6
1855–76
Silcock (Canterbury)
53.2 20.8 17.3 8.8
1851–81
Pickens (Canterbury)
28.61 45.18 16.94 9.27
1864–1900
Fraser (West Coast)
Notes: Akenson’s figures are based on the Irish Registrar-General’s figures for 15,394 Irish residents leaving Ireland with the intention of settling permanently in New Zealand between 1876 and 1890. Hearn’s figures are based on the death certificates of a random sample of 706 Irish migrants, paying and assisted, arriving nationwide between 1871 and 1890. Brosnahan’s figures are based on a sample of 7,907 assisted Irish migrants who arrived in Otago and Southland between 1872 and 1888. Webber’s figures are based on the death certificates of 1,000 Irish migrants dying before 1900. Silcock’s figures are based on 5,134 migrants arriving in Canterbury between 1855 and 1876. Pickens’s figures are based on the places of birth of Canterbury’s population at the Registrar-General’s office in conjunction with biographies contained in the Cyclopedia of New Zealand, vol. 3 (Christchurch, 1903). Fraser’s figures are based on the death certificates of 1,587 Irish-born dying on the West Coast.
Sources: Donald Harman Akenson, Half the world from home: perspectives on the Irish in New Zealand, 1860–1950 (Wellington, 1990), table 22, pp 70–1; Hearn’s statistics were kindly made available by Dr Terry Hearn of the Ministry for Culture and Heritage who, together with Dr Nicholas Bayley, is conducting an analysis of British and Irish migration to New Zealand to 1945. The project is funded by F.O.S.T. and supervised by the Chief Historian; Seán G. Brosnahan, ‘The greening of Otago: Irish [Catholic] immigration to Otago and Southland 1840–1888’ in Norma J. Bethune (ed.), Work ‘n’ pastimes: 150 years of pain and pleasure, labour and leisure (Dunedin, 1998), table 1, p. 62; Heather Webber, ‘Emigration: Ireland to New Zealand, 1850–1900, a demographic study’ in Hylton Tucker (ed.), GRINZ yearbook 1995 (Lower Hutt, 1995), p. 25; R. H. Silcock, ‘Immigration into Canterbury under the provincial government’, M.A. thesis, University of Canterbury, 1964, tables 7 and 8; K. A. Pickens, ‘Canterbury, 1851–81: demography and mobility, a comparative study’, Ph.D. thesis, Washington University, 1976, table 1:50, p. 222; Lyndon Fraser, ‘Irish migration to the West Coast, 1864–1900’ in N.Z.J.H., xxxiv (October 2000), table 2, p. 204.
Ulster Munster Leinster Connacht
Hearn (NZ-wide)
Akenson (NZ-wide)
Table 1.1 The provincial origins of New Zealand’s nineteenth-century Irish population (%) according to assorted studies
IRISH MIGRATION AND NEW ZEALAND SETTLEMENT
also record the last area of residence rather than place of birth for migrants. Death certificates, on the other hand, provide us with a more perceptive insight into provincial origins. Local use of this source has also thrown up intriguing regional variations. On the West Coast, for instance, Munster was strongly represented, supplying almost half of all those Irish migrants settling on the Coast.26 A nationwide analysis of death certificates by Heather Webber, on the other hand, shows a more even Ulster–Munster balance. Her sample, however, is regrettably confined to those Irish dying before 1900.27 Our best insight into the provincial origins of the Irish in New Zealand is therefore the statistics arising from the research of Terry Hearn. Analysing death certificates until 1935 for those Irish who arrived between 1871 and 1890, Hearn’s results point to an Ulster dominance, with Munster a close second.28 Despite some regional variation in the settlement patterns of Irish migrants from Ulster and Munster in New Zealand, it is clear that Irish men and women from Leinster and Connacht were less inclined to settle in the colony. Nonetheless, examining county origins illuminates some important features about the provincial supply of these Irish migrants to New Zealand (see Table 1.2). Galway, for instance, supplied a sizeable number of migrants, compared with other Connacht counties, while Dublin was particularly dominant among Leinster counties. Nationwide, according to Hearn’s figures, the counties of Antrim, Cork, and Down dominated. Yet figures for the entire country obscure those cases where strong links can be identified between certain sending counties with specific recipient regions. Clare, for instance, rates poorly as a supplier of migrants to Otago, Southland, and Canterbury, but provided many migrants to the West Coast, reflecting its connexions with the Australian colonies of Victoria and New South Wales. Antrim and Cork, meanwhile, were particularly prolific providers of Irish migrants settling in Otago and Southland. Canterbury, on the other hand, contained a substantial representation from Down, a connexion reflected in the naming of local Canterbury areas with County Down place names.29 This link between the colony’s provinces and certain counties in Ireland suggests the vital importance of kin and neighbourhood networks in directing migrants to destinations favoured by pioneering migrants. How does this county situation compare with Australia? Only two counties appear in the top ten rankings for both countries (see Table 1.3). Comparison
26
Lyndon Fraser, ‘Irish migration to the West Coast, 1864–1900’ in N.Z.J.H., xxxiv (2000), table 2, p. 204. 27 Heather J. Webber, ‘Emigration: Ireland to New Zealand, 1850–1900, a demographic study’ in Hylton Tucker (ed.), GRINZ yearbook 1995 (Lower Hutt, 1995), p. 25. 28 Statistics were kindly made available by Dr Terry Hearn of the Ministry for Culture and Heritage who, together with Dr Nicholas Bayley, is conducting an analysis of British and Irish migration to New Zealand to 1945. The project is funded by the Foundation for Research, Science and Technology (F.O.S.T.) and supervised by the Chief Historian. 29 The most obvious example is Killinchy. 57
35.84 10.22 2.68 2.58 4.84 1.87 1.71 5.48 1.61 4.85
45.64 10.93 7.58 8.50 8.13 7.92 2.58
MUNSTER Clare Cork Kerry Limerick Tipperary Waterford
30.72 4.45 9.68 4.30 5.22 4.00 3.07
46.69 12.60 4.76 2.92 6.14 3.84 1.23 5.53 1.38 8.29
1871–90
1876–90
ULSTER Antrim Armagh Cavan Down Donegal Fermanagh Londonderry Monaghan Tyrone
Hearn (NZ-wide)
Akenson (NZ-wide)
40.04 3.33 13.94 6.23 8.18 4.48 3.88
40.46 10.86 2.72 1.75 3.34 5.25 1.26 8.38 1.14 5.75
Brosnahan (Otago and Southland) 1872–88
20.8 2.9 3.7 5.7 2.9 4.1 1.5
53.2 8.8 8.8 2.5 16.6 2.9 2.5 3.2 1.5 6.4
1851–81
Pickens (Canterbury)
27.3 1.8 4.4 11.3 2.5 6.0 1.3
52.2 8.1 7.5 2.9 13.6 4.5 2.2 3.3 1.4 8.7
1855–76
Silcock (Canterbury)
Table 1.2 The county origins of New Zealand’s Irish population (%) according to various studies
45.18 11.22 8.38 5.10 6.49 11.85 2.14
28.61 7.37 1.89 1.76 4.03 4.16 1.20 4.16 1.70 2.33
1864–1900
Fraser (West Coast)
9.72 0.51 2.17 0.36 2.15 0.82 0.50 0.11 0.63 0.56 0.66 0.62 0.63
LEINSTER Carlow Dublin Kildare Kilkenny King’s Co. Longford Louth Meath Queen’s Co. Westmeath Wexford Wicklow
15.66 0.61 6.30 0.61 1.69 0.92 0.77 0 0.46 0.46 1.84 1.08 0.92
6.91 4.15 0.61 0.46 1.54 0.15 7.06 0.42 1.59 0.16 1.39 0.52 0.27 0.13 0.33 0.27 0.82 0.77 0.39
12.44 8.09 0.46 1.54 1.11 1.24 17.3 1.7 5.3 0.8 0.1 1.9 0.5 0.1 0.8 1.5 0.4 0.9 3.3
8.8 5.8 0.3 1.3 1.1 0.3
Notes: See Table 1.1. Regrettably, county origins are unavailable for Webber’s sample.
8.8 4.83 0.57 0.65 2.10 0.65
CONNACHT Galway Leitrim Mayo Roscommon Sligo
Table 1.2 continued
10.8 1.2 1.8 0.2 0.8 1.6 0.5 0.4 0.2 1.3 0.4 0.8 1.6
9.5 6.7 0.4 0.9 1.1 0.4 16.94 0.63 4.28 0.82 2.58 1.89 0.69 0.69 1.51 1.07 0.95 0.82 1.01
9.27 5.04 1.64 0.95 1.01 0.63
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
Table 1.3 Top ten county origins of Irish migrants to New Zealand and Australia New Zealand
Australia
Antrim Cork Tyrone Down Dublin Londonderry Limerick Armagh Clare Kerry
Clare Tipperary Limerick Kilkenny King’s Co. Fermanagh Cavan Wicklow Westmeath Carlow
Sources: New Zealand order is based on Hearn, table 1.2, p. 21; see Table 1.1 above. Australian origins are based on Fitzpatrick, Oceans of consolation, figure 5, p. 15.
shows that New Zealand’s Irish settlers were more prone to originate from Munster and north-east Ulster counties whereas Australia was the preferred destination of migrants from Leinster and south Ulster.30 The strong Ulster migration to New Zealand from the dominant Protestant counties of Antrim and Down meant that a large number of migrants in New Zealand were Ulster Protestants.31 Ascertaining their numbers along with those of the entire Irish Protestant group, however, is problematic, as neither shipping registers nor census data link birthplace with religious affiliation. Faced with this situation, Akenson used census figures for Catholicism as an indication of the total multigenerational Irish Catholic group. A national, census-based estimate, it suggests that three-quarters of New Zealand’s Irish ethnic group were Catholic.32 Ascribing all Catholics as predominantly Irish is permissible as most Catholics in New Zealand in the period under discussion were Irish-born or of Irish descent. As one commentator observed perceptively in 1885, ‘Sweep the Irish people from the colonies and Catholicism is no longer there’.33 Yet though it can be argued that between 1880 and 1950 the migrant generation and the entire ethnic group had close to the same proportions of Catholics, this estimate is not directly comparable to sources for the migrant generation. Scholars utilising such records for the migrant generation have reached other conclusions about the religious makeup of the Irish in New Zealand.
30
Fitzpatrick, Oceans of consolation, pp 15–16. Antrim’s Protestant population in 1861 was 75.2 per cent while Down’s was 67.5 per cent. 32 Akenson, Half the world from home, p. 68. 33 New Zealand Freeman’s Journal, 7 August 1885, p. 11. 31
60
IRISH MIGRATION AND NEW ZEALAND SETTLEMENT
Drawing upon 426 entries for Irish-born patients in the Auckland Hospital Register of Patients, Alasdair Galbraith has estimated an Irish Protestant component of 43.67 per cent, but his study is not representative of Auckland’s migrants.34 A higher proportion of Irish Protestants settled in Canterbury, with one study based on the marriage certificates for 897 Irish men in Canterbury showing that 60.5 per cent of them were Protestant.35 Nationwide examination of death certificates, meanwhile, also shows this Irish Protestant prominence, with 40.7 per cent of 1,000 natives of Ireland dying between 1850 and 1900 being Protestant.36 The relevance of these findings can be challenged due to their localised nature, their confinement to the period before 1900, or both. Yet recent analysis of death certificates for Irish migrants throughout the entire country for a broader time-frame affirms these results (see Table 1.4). The results outlined in Table 1.4 were obtained by random sampling of the death certificates of those Irish migrants arriving during selected time periods. For instance, those Irish arriving between 1871 and 1890 were traced in death certificates until approximately 1935. What is most striking from these results is their consistency over time for those Irish arriving during the nineteenth century. Thereafter, with the ending of widespread financially assisted migration, Irish Catholics were less inclined to voyage to New Zealand.
Table 1.4 The religious affiliation of Irish Migrants to New Zealand, 1840–1945, based on figures supplied by the Ministry for Culture and Heritage
1840–1852 1853–1870 1871–1890 1891–1915 1916–1945
Protestant
Catholic
43.24 46.20 44.16 50.60 66.28
56.76 53.80 55.84 49.40 33.72
Source: Figures were kindly supplied by Terry Hearn of the Ministry for Culture and Heritage.
34 Alasdair Galbraith, ‘New Zealand’s “invisible” Irish: Irish Protestants in the North Island of New Zealand, 1840–1900’, M.A. thesis, University of Auckland, 1998, p. 61. A study of Cork migrants in Auckland, though also unrepresentative of Auckland’s Irish, shows that one-third of Cork migrants were Protestant. See Angela Tindall, ‘From county Cork to the southern corinth: aspects of Corkonian immigration to Auckland in the mid to late nineteenth century’, M.A. thesis, University College Dublin, 1996. 35 Pickens, ‘Canterbury, 1851–81’, p. 192. 36 Webber, ‘Emigration: Ireland to New Zealand’, p. 25.
61
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
Table 1.5 Number and percentage of the Irish-born in New Zealand, 1858–1921 Year of census
Number of Irish
% Foreign-born
% Total population
1858 1861 1864 1867 1871 1874 1878 1881 1886 1891 1896 1901 1906 1911 1916 1921
4,554 8,831 20,317 27,955 29,733 30,255 43,758 49,363 51,408 47,634 46,037 43,524 42,460 40,958 37,380 34,419
11.19 12.37 15.52 18.11 18.25 17.10 18.21 18.52 18.47 18.32 17.59 16.96 15.04 13.40 12.24 11.01
7.66 8.92 11.80 12.80 11.60 10.10 10.56 10.08 8.89 7.60 6.55 5.63 4.78 4.06 3.40 2.82
Having discussed the origins and religious affiliation of Irish migrants in New Zealand, we turn now to consider their profile in New Zealand. Using official data, it is possible to trace the number of Irish present in New Zealand at census time, in order to observe their changing representation in New Zealand society. As Table 1.5 shows, natives of Ireland peaked in their representation of the total colonial population in 1867, while the Scots reached their zenith in 1864 and the English in 1861. As a proportion of the foreign-born the Irish peaked in 1881 while in sheer numbers they reached their maximum in 1886. At this time, when the colony’s population had just exceeded half a million people, there were 51,408 Irish, 54,810 Scots, and 125,657 English. From 1891 onwards the number of Irish-born in New Zealand declined, as did their proportions among the foreign-born and total population. What was the gender ratio of these figures? Though Irish women supplied around half the entire outflow from Ireland during the period under discussion, their male counterparts outnumbered them in New Zealand. In 1874 there were 679 Irish women for every 1,000 Irish men in the country; by 1881 this had risen to 784. Variations on this overall gender ratio, however, are discernible in provinces. In 1881 in Wellington, Christchurch, Otago, and Auckland there were more than 800 Irish women for every 1,000 Irish men, while there were just over 400 Irish women for every 1,000 Irish men in Taranaki. In Australia, by contrast, Irish women supplied roughly equal 62
IRISH MIGRATION AND NEW ZEALAND SETTLEMENT
Table 1.6 Birthplaces of persons (exclusive of Maori) in provincial districts, 1881
Auckland Taranaki Wellington Hawke’s Bay Nelson Marlborough Canterbury Westland Otago
Ireland
Scotland
England
New Zealand
Other
Total
12.08 8.41 6.86 9.63 8.47 7.73 11.14 16.08 9.22
6.25 4.79 6.27 6.85 6.38 5.75 7.58 7.20 21.62
25.06 29.67 27.9 29.71 22.01 23.54 31.19 16.15 16.56
48.43 47.45 49.02 41.75 52.79 57.02 43.62 39.51 42.37
8.18 9.68 9.95 12.06 10.35 5.96 6.47 21.06 10.23
100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0
Source: Census, April 1881, Table VI, p. 196.
numbers to their male counterparts and even outnumbered Irish men in New South Wales and Victoria until the mid 1850s.37 These provincial contrasts for the gender ratio are also recognisable in overall Irish settlement in New Zealand. Taking the year 1881 (see Table 1.6), provincial summaries reveal that the country’s 49,363 Irish-born were strongly represented among the foreign-born populations at Westland and Auckland, 26.57 per cent and 23.43 per cent respectively. Large proportions of the Irishborn could also be found in Canterbury (19.75 per cent), Marlborough (17.99 per cent), and Nelson (17.94 per cent). In Otago, Hawkes Bay, and Taranaki, meanwhile, the Irish supplied around 16 per cent of the foreign-born population, while they were significantly underrepresented in Wellington at 13.45 per cent. A closer look at county and borough settlement data also reveals divergent trends. In 1881 almost half of the Irish-born population returned in county data settled in eight of New Zealand’s sixty-three counties,38 while 41 per cent of the Irish-born settled in four of the country’s sixty-five boroughs.39 Several of these counties and boroughs also contained strong proportions of Irish settlers. More than 30 per cent of foreign-born settlers in the counties of Tauranga, Kawhia, Manukau, Grey, and Whakatane were Irish, while in the boroughs of Onehunga, Ross, Greymouth, Kumara, Hamilton, and Westport the Irish formed at least a quarter of the foreign-born settlers.
37
Fitzpatrick, Oceans of consolation, p. 13. 14,029 out of 31,047 Irish settled in Selwyn, Eden, Geraldine, Manukau, Ashley, Southland, Ashburton, and Grey. 39 The boroughs and the number of their Irish-born residents were Auckland (2,106), Dunedin (2,076), Wellington (1,714), and Christchurch (1,475). 38
63
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
This regional distribution probably arose not only because of the economic activity and opportunities prevalent in certain regions, but also as a result of the various schemes of nominated and assisted settlement designed to populate New Zealand. Such schemes were undertaken to attract not just people, but also their economic resources to the colony. As with the Australian colonies, these schemes varied according to time and place. Before 1870 provincial administration districts competed in their attempts to seduce British and Irish migrants by offering assisted and nominated passages or land grants. Canterbury and Wellington provincial governments, for instance, tried to entice settlers with assisted passages, the migrants aided to an amount equal to that paid in cash, though this amount was repayable after settlement in the colony. Auckland, on the other hand, offered 40 acres of land for migrants 18 years and older paying their passage, with 20 acres for every migrant aged 5–18 years.40 Among those migrants availing of this incentive were County Londonderry native Ann McCleland and her Swiss-born husband Johann Heldt. When they contemplated their return to New Zealand from Ireland in 1858, more than a decade after they had left the colony, Robert Greer, the New Zealand emigration agent at Newry, advised Johann, ‘vessels sail to Auckland every month. You will get 40 acres – your wifes 40, and every Childs to 18 years of age 20 acres each.’41 Greer further recommended, ‘when you arrive in Auckland, go direct to the land office and don’t allow any broker or other person to obtrude officious services on you’.42 During the 1860s soldiers participating in the New Zealand Wars were also promised land grants. The New Zealand Immigration Land Act in the 1870s, meanwhile, provided land to the value of £20 for migrants aged between 18 and 60 paying their passage. Among the migrants in this study participating in this scheme were 24-yearold Moneyreagh migrant David McCullough and his companion Alexander Young. They obtained certificates from the Agent-General in London approving their individual applications for a £20 land grant in the colony.43 Migrants were also encouraged to voyage to New Zealand through nomination schemes. By this arrangement friends and family already settled in the colony raised the cost of the passage. As William Lysaght demanded of his brother from Limerick in 1866, ‘dont forget to send on the Passage order’ (Ly 1). Analysis of Auckland’s nomination register, which survives for the years 1859 to 1871, reveals that William Lysaght failed to receive assistance at this time. His father and brother were, however, responsible for paying the passage of other family members from Limerick to Auckland in 1864.
40
See W. D. Borrie, Immigration to New Zealand, 1854–1938 (Canberra, 1991) for details of these various schemes. 41 Robert Greer (Newry) to Johann Heldt (Co. Londonderry), 10 Nov. 1858, P.R.O.N.I., T/3034/11A. 42 Procedures for issue of land certificates, 5 July 1859, P.R.O.N.I., T/3034/14. 43 David and Alexander’s grants are noted in IM 17/1, p. 20, at N.A.W. 64
IRISH MIGRATION AND NEW ZEALAND SETTLEMENT
Examination of this register also shows that two-fifths of applications were directed to Ireland.44 Lyndon Fraser’s analysis of the nominations sent from the West Coast between 1872 and 1873 and from Canterbury between 1872 and 1874 reveals similar findings, with around two-thirds and two-fifths of all nominations from these districts sent to Ireland.45 Such analyses, however, may underestimate the number of Irish migrants availing of nominated passages, as these investigations are generally unable to account for Irish migrants living in Britain who received nominations.46 Nonetheless, manipulation of the nomination system meant that specific areas in Ireland developed vigorous links with particular destinations in New Zealand. Auckland, for example, received many migrants from the civil parishes of Templetuohy and Templemore in County Tipperary,47 while the West Coast had vibrant connexions with Ennis in County Clare, Castlegregory in County Kerry, and Birr in Kings County. Christchurch, meanwhile, developed robust associations with Headford and Tuam in County Galway, Fermoy in County Cork, Tralee in County Kerry, Nenagh in County Tipperary, and Ballycastle in County Antrim.48 That nominated migration was of great significance for Irish migrants is evident in the testimony given by Jeremiah Hurley, a recent arrival at Wellington in 1873: ‘no Irish emigrants are coming here except those who receive nominations from their friends in this Colony, and those who have heard from their friends here that there is such a man in London as an AgentGeneral for New Zealand’.49 The following decade a piece in the New Zealand Freeman’s Journal concluded, ‘It is almost needless to state that the cost of passage to Australia and New Zealand is in all cases so high that unless the whole, or almost the whole, be met by a system of free or very liberally assisted emigration, those countries are closed to emigrants.’50 Appointed as part of the introduction of the central government’s Immigration and Public Works Act of 1870, which provided for assisted
44
68/64, Register of Assisted Immigrants, Repro 4711/448, N.A.A. Of 369 applications sent from New Zealand between 1859 and 1864, 133 (36 per cent) were directed to Ireland. 45 Fraser, ‘Irish migration to the West Coast’, p. 212; Lyndon Fraser, To Tara via Holyhead: Irish Catholic immigrants in nineteenth-century Christchurch (Auckland, 1997), p. 47. 46 Fraser, To Tara via Holyhead, p. 37. 47 These parishes were in south Tipperary whereas Bruce S. Elliott’s pioneering study of Irish Protestants in Canada was confined to migrants arriving from north Tipperary primarily between 1818 and 1855. See Irish migrants in the Canadas: a new approach (Kingston and Montreal and Belfast, 1988). 48 68/64, Register of Assisted Immigrants, N.A.A.; Fraser, ‘Irish migration to the West Coast’, p. 212; Fraser, To Tara via Holyhead, p. 44. 49 Mr J. Hurley to the Under Secretary for Immigration, 29 November 1873, A.J.H.R., 1873, D-1D, p. 17. 50 New Zealand Freeman’s Journal, 10 August 1883, p. 8. 65
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
migration, the Agent-General was a key individual in organising migration to New Zealand. Based in London, he was responsible for ensuring that the quotas desired by the New Zealand government were fulfilled. Under the scheme married couples were to pay £5 in cash each as their full fare, or sign a promissory note scaled according to the amount they had paid.51 Single men could pay £8 in cash for their full passage, or pay £4 in cash with a promissory note of £8 payable after settlement. Single women aged 15–35, in contrast, were offered free fares in an effort to balance the sexes, while the demand for skilled labourers also resulted in free passages for suitable men in some years.52 In Victoria, South Australia, and Tasmania, by contrast, there was little assistance after the 1860s. When the Sullivan family of Ballingarry, County Limerick, migrated to New Zealand in 1874 on the Wennington, the colonial government paid their passage of £65.53 That the Sullivan family comprised five daughters was an asset at a time when couples with families, especially daughters, were encouraged to the colony. The Sullivan migration also appears to be a collective undertaking. They were joining their daughter Mary who had emigrated two years earlier and Catherine Sullivan’s two brothers were also in the colony. Schemes for settlement were also proposed by individuals and companies. The migration of many north of Ireland migrants to Katikati was one such initiative. It was arranged by George Vesey Stewart, a native of Ballygawley, County Tyrone, who travelled to New Zealand in search of suitable land for his proposed settlement.54 He eventually decided on land near Tauranga and drawing on his local networks set about attracting settlers with connexions to the Orange Order in Ulster. Each settler aged 18 and above was to receive 40 acres while 20 acres were granted for each child aged 12 to 18 years. On 8 June 1875 the Carisbrooke Castle sailed from Dublin, followed by the Dover Castle. John Gilmore, writing home in 1876 after his arrival at Tauranga, revealed, ‘there is a Large settlement of North of Ireland people about from 10 to 25 miles from here. The are called Stewarts settlers. The have in all 10,000 acres for ever. Rent Nothing’ (Ge 6). The success of this settlement prompted Stewart to gain another block of land. As John wrote in 1877: There is a man going home to Belfast in a few days from here that has bought 10,000 acres. His name is George Vesey Stewart. He took out a ship of emigrants nearly 2 years ago from Belfast. Here they are on the same block as this. He is now
51
For instance if £1 in cash was paid then the promissory note was for £8. If £4 paid then promissory for £2. 52 For details of this scheme see John Morris, ‘The assisted immigrants to New Zealand, 1871–79: a statistical study’, M.A. thesis, University of Auckland, 1973. 53 IM 15/95, N.A.W. 54 For details of the settlement see Akenson, Half the world from home, pp 123–58. 66
IRISH MIGRATION AND NEW ZEALAND SETTLEMENT
going to get settlers for the land. I think will cost about 30s per acre half the money to be paid down, the remainder in 4 years, the Government to pay all passage and the tenant to pay for the land. (Ge 7)
This settlement, however, was not as promising as the first. As Andrew recounted conspiratorially in July 1878, G. V. Stewart is Expected to arrive soon with No. 2 Settlers from Belfast. It is Expected that He will get Foul play through Inducing them out to so Barran Hills & Making them pay so Dear for the Land. Keep it Quiet for news Like this Flies Like Telegraph. (Ge 9)
Nevertheless, further land at Te Puke was purchased which resulted in settlers arriving in six stages between 1880 and 1884.55 The influx of migrants from the north of Ireland to New Zealand was due not only to Vesey Stewart’s scheme but also to strenuous promotional efforts largely confined to Ulster. As Alasdair Galbraith suggests, such bias was due to the prejudice surrounding the settlement of Irish Catholics in New Zealand, and therefore an attempt to recruit a ‘superior’ class of Irish migrant.56 This bias was also evident in the location of emigration agents, placement of advertising, and the provision of shipping, all of which favoured Ulster.57 In 1873, for instance, of forty-six local agents in Ireland, only nine were located outside of Ulster.58 This Ulster prejudice was also recognisable in the confinement to the north of newspaper advertisements,59 promotional tours, and dissemination of literature about New Zealand. The suggestion that an emigration poster be placed in all railway stations as ‘the most economical and the most thorough [advertising] that could be adopted in this country’60 was also seemingly restricted to Ulster railway stations. Such bias suggests a sectarian element which deemed Ulster Protestants better settlers than southern Catholics. Despite the partiality towards the north, one commentator wrote to the Minister of Immigration, Daniel Pollen, in 1874 expressing surprise at the oversight of migrants from Ulster and the recommendation of small farmers from Antrim, Down, and Armagh: ‘The class of people I
55 These ships were the Lady Jocelyn and Oxford in 1880, May Queen in 1881, Northumberland in 1883, and Northumberland and Lady Jocelyn in 1884. 56 Alasdair Galbraith, ‘The invisible Irish? re-discovering the Irish Protestant tradition in colonial New Zealand’ in Fraser (ed.), A distant shore, p. 42. 57 Ibid., p. 45. 58 Local agents appointed by the Agent-General, A.J.H.R., 1873, D-2, p. 18. 59 Two reports about emigration advertisements to New Zealand in Irish newspapers reflect this Ulster bias. The first report, listing fifteen newspapers, shows that all were confined to Ulster. See A.J.H.R., 1873, D-2, p. 6. The second report reveals that of seventeen newspapers, fourteen were based in Ulster. See A.J.H.R., 1873, D-2, pp 19–20. 60 H. W. Farnall to the Agent-General, 1 October 1872, A.J.H.R., 1873, D2-D, p. 11.
67
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
recommend are generally of numerous families, and are often at a loss to know how to dispose of some of their sons.’61 Despite the writer’s professed concern, these predominantly Protestant counties were among the top ten suppliers of Irish migrants to New Zealand. An uncertain future in these counties, as indicated by the comment, most certainly predisposed many to consider their chances abroad. Not surprisingly, the Ulster bias of recruiting activities prompted condemnation in 1873 from the Minister of Immigration, G. Maurice O’Rorke: You advertise in six Belfast papers, five Londonderry papers, and a few papers in adjoining counties, to the exclusion of such places as Dublin, Waterford, Cork, Limerick, Galway &c. This is one of those things which gives rise to dissatisfaction out here, and it, to my mind, cannot be justified.62
In response, the Agent-General set out a list of Irish migrants outside of Ulster that he had assisted, but this too generated a caustic response from O’Rorke: [C]onsidering the enormous number of Irish emigrants that annually leave that country I can hardly be expected to compliment your agents in having induced in a year and a half 900 souls to emigrate to New Zealand from that country, nor do I care to take advantage of pointing out that of these 900 more than one-third were nominated in the Colony, and consequently reached this independent of the exertions of your officers.63
Other reports condemned the ‘uselessness’ of the Dublin agency, and the ‘slack’ overall emigration from Ireland.64 What explanations account for the vocal opposition to Irish migration solely from Ulster? One contributing factor may have been the considerable influence in government of a number of Irish men, both Catholic and Protestant, with non-Ulster origins.65 Another factor widely acknowledged was the major demand for women in the colony, and Irish women were particularly keen to settle abroad. Emigration agents offered a range of excuses for the poor supply of Irish migrants to New Zealand, including the competition of other destinations offering ‘counter attractions’ and ‘better terms’, primarily Australia and North
61
Alex Bradley to the Minister of Immigration, 20 October 1874, A.J.H.R., 1875, D1. Memorandum No. 29, 1873, for the Agent-General, London, A.J.H.R., 1873, D-1, p. 48. 63 Memorandum No. 167, 1873, for the Agent-General, London, A.J.H.R., 1873, D-1A, p. 12. 64 Vogel to the Agent-General, 11 February 1874, A.J.H.R., 1874, D1, p. 21. 65 See especially Edmund Bohan, ‘“A recollection of the unfortunate failings of my own countrymen”: the Irish in New Zealand politics, 1860–1880’ in Patterson (ed.), The Irish in New Zealand, pp 53–65. 62
68
IRISH MIGRATION AND NEW ZEALAND SETTLEMENT
America.66 The Agent-General also pointed out the difficulty of getting ships to sail direct from Ireland as ship owners ‘cannot get cargo from these ports’.67 Indeed, throughout the nineteenth century only eight ships sailed direct from Irish ports to New Zealand,68 thereby providing Irish migrants with additional expenses to reach English or Scottish ports. The cost of the passage was therefore the most important reason for the poor outflow of migrants from Ireland to New Zealand. When free passages were made available in 1874, there was a noticeable surge in Irish migrants travelling to New Zealand. During most years, however, assisted and nominated passages were confined to those who could pay part of the fare. It does not necessarily follow, then, that just because only approximately 28 per cent of all passages were nominated this implies few kin connexions in the colony.69 Rather, migrants supplied advice and encouragement leaving the funding of the fare to their associates in Ireland. The poor outflow, relatively, of Irish migrants from north and south, despite a plethora of propaganda campaigns, contradicts the claim of New Zealand historian James Belich that nineteenth-century migrants to New Zealand were ‘prised out of their British contexts by powerful myths and prophecies’.70 Propaganda, in the form of books, pamphlets, and articles in newspapers and periodicals, he contends, was persuasive in channelling migration to New Zealand. Yet Belich fails to consider extensively the effect of negative publicity which must also have been influential, particularly given his argument that personal letters prevented migration by counteracting myths.71 But how accurate is this assessment of the private letter? David Fitzpatrick, for instance, has remarked that letters were the ‘most persuasive medium’ in generating migration.72 What light does Irish–New Zealand correspondence throw on this debate? Only two correspondents use terminology that suggests the influence of official propaganda in their decision to migrate to New Zealand. When Bessie Macready arrived at Port Lyttelton in 1878, after a voyage of 79 days, she dramatically announced to her cousins, ‘I have travelled over about fifteen thousand miles of water and at last got to the desired haven’ (Ma 1). Reports from Bessie’s aunts in Governors Bay prior to her migration may have equally
66
H. W. Farnall to the Agent-General, 1 October 1872, A.J.H.R., 1873, D2-D. Agent-General to the Hon. the Minister for Immigration, 13 January 1874, A.J.H.R., 1874, D-3, No. 40, p. 30. 68 These ships were Asia, Caroline, Carrick Castle, Queen of Nations, Dover Castle, Carisbrooke Castle, Conflict, and Lady Jocelyn. 69 This argument is made by Miles Fairburn, The ideal society and its enemies: the foundations of modern New Zealand society, 1850–1900 (Auckland, 1989), p. 167. 70 James Belich, Making peoples: a history of the New Zealanders from Polynesian settlement to the end of the nineteenth century (Auckland, 1996), p. 279. 71 Ibid., p. 282. 72 Fitzpatrick, Oceans of consolation, p. 516. 67
69
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
established this idea of the colony as haven in Bessie’s mind. Likewise, Margaret Kilpatrick’s refulgent confirmation from Auckland in 1862 that her mother ‘dreamed a very straight dream about this place the green hill, the great mountain, the sea below, and the Valley beyond it’ (Ki 1), may be indicative of the influence of propaganda. The letters of most correspondents in this study, however, suggest that propaganda played no role in their decision to migrate to New Zealand, though the absence of reference to such material does not necessarily infer that propaganda was unimportant. Rather, it appears that propaganda was of greater significance in the early years of settlement in New Zealand. Thereafter, despite continued propaganda campaigns, personal recommendation was far more influential. That propaganda was less vital from the 1870s onwards is evident in the number of complaints contained in official documents concerning the poor stream of migrants from Ireland to New Zealand, despite the dissemination of such propaganda materials. Propaganda was therefore of less importance than the combined influence of personal letters and an assisted or nominated passage. This reliance on the recommendations of previous migrants does not, however, imply passivity as Kerby Miller contends of Irish chain migration to North America. In his interpretation, Miller argues that migrants unconsciously followed established chains of migration. This abdication of responsibility, Miller reckons, arose from a ‘distinctive Irish worldview’ which deprecated ‘innovation, initiative, and the assumption or attribution of personal responsibility’.73 It is a thesis that Miller applies largely to Irish Catholics and which has encountered stringent criticism, most consistently from Donald Akenson. This is because, as Akenson carefully explains, Miller’s thesis is not just a view of Irish Catholics in the United States but is by implication a concept of Irish Catholic culture at home and abroad. In counteracting Miller’s claims, Akenson cites a number of studies which indicate that Irish Catholics in the United States and elsewhere were not disadvantaged.74 This chapter also challenges Miller’s assumptions by showing that Irish migrants, Catholic and Protestant, actively and purposefully chose which migrant chains to follow based on the advice they received from their letter writing connexions. Irrespective of the method and means for migration, intending migrants had a range of private motives for leaving home. These reasons are not always discussed, but some clues can be discerned from a careful reading of surviving letters. What explanations for migration, then, can be ascertained from the letters exchanged between Ireland and New Zealand? And why did some correspondents choose to remain in Ireland?
73
Miller, Emigrants and exiles, pp 516, 4, 429. See Donald Harman Akenson, ‘Irish migration to North America, 1800–1920’ in Andy Bielenberg (ed.), The Irish diaspora (Harlow, 2000), especially pp 127–33. 74
70
IRISH MIGRATION AND NEW ZEALAND SETTLEMENT
James and Hamilton McIlrath, second and third sons of a Unitarian farmer who worked 27 acres at Balloo, near Killinchy, County Down, elected to move abroad in 1860. Eight years later Hamilton commented retrospectively, ‘Times seems to be getting better at home since we left’ (Il 14). Apart from unfavourable conditions in County Down at the time of their departure, James and Hamilton McIlrath were probably enticed to leave home by reports from the Australian goldfields to where they initially gravitated. Their three brothers, however, elected to stay at home. Robert, the youngest, died in 1870, while eldest brother William inherited the family farm. The second son John settled on a farm at nearby Carrickmannon. The prospect of obtaining money seemingly lured David Kilpatrick and his wife Margaret to New Zealand with their infant son William in 1862. As Margaret’s sister Martha Jane, who had settled in Canada, queried scathingly of her brother Thomas Reid: What freak could possess David Kilpatrick to start for N. Z. If he wished to make money faster, he might have tried Canada, or some place within the bounds of Christendom but to start on a 10 months voyage, speculating, what an idea, and only think I don’t know yet what Kilpatricks they are.75
The departure of 24-year-old orphan Daniel Strong in 1883, meanwhile, derived from his failure to inherit his father’s pub at the Ferry, near Lehinch, County Tipperary. Just 5 years of age when his father died, Daniel went to live with his cousins. Recriminations about the transfer of the pub out of Strong hands continued to appear in letters sent years after Daniel’s departure. His cousin Lizzie Strong pronounced longingly, ‘It would be the joy of our hearts to see you where you had a right to be’, while her brother Martin hoped ‘to see your name planted there yet’ (St 4, 3). While inheritance issues may have sparked Daniel’s departure, the reasons for his choice of New Zealand remain unknown. Another example of economic factors spurring migration appears in the letters sent in 1886 by Kate and John Keane from Shanacoole, Clashmore, County Waterford. Though their paternal great-grandfather, Matthew Keane, was a substantial landholder, their father James appears to have been a landless labourer. The lack of local employment opportunities prompted Kate to deliberately seek her migrant sister’s assistance to provide a passage for their brother John on account of ‘no work for him here’ (Ke 1). John Keane also bluntly sought his sister’s aid: ‘I would wish you to send for me & If not you ought to send me to America or else to buy tools and work at home’ (Ke 2). John and another brother, James, eventually settled in North America,
75
Martha Jane Wilson (Canada) to Thomas E. Reid (Armagh), 15 December 1862, in P.R.O.N.I., D/3014/2/16. 71
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
while their sisters migrated to England and New Zealand. Seemingly, no member of this branch of the Keane family remained in Ireland. The expectation of work abroad also contributed to departures from Ireland in the twentieth century. Maggie Moran, writing in 1914 from Borrisokane in County Tipperary, reported that two friends ‘are in England. They got jobs there in an hospital (Red Cross Nurses)’ (Fa 6). Twentieth-century correspondence also highlights the importance of career advancement. An acquaintance of Nenagh migrant Philip Carroll, for instance, elected to journey to the United States in 1925, as his career in the railways was stagnant as ‘prospects of promotion at the present time are nil’ (Cl 24). Health factors prompted the departure of some migrants from Ireland. In 1864, Margaret Kilpatrick learned of Elizabeth Walker’s son’s emigration to Australia ‘in consequence of bad health brought on by standing on a flagged floor’ (Ki 4). Evidence of the health benefits of migration continued to appear in the letters in the early twentieth century. Writing from Tipperary, publican John Strong informed his cousin Daniel of ‘a young fellow leaving this place in a few days for New Zealland. He is going for his health’ (St 6). Happiness and freedom from constraints rarely appear as motives for migration in Irish–New Zealand letters. Nevertheless, from Armagh in 1864 Elizabeth Walker asked her friend Margaret Kilpatrick, ‘would you have had the same independence in this country and be happy’ (Ki 4). Thirty years later from the same county, poor farming conditions sparked a mood of gloomy introspection from Mary Ann Gilpin. She meditated glumly to her sister Lizzie, ‘There is little here but disappointments & trouble. There is all joy & peace. It is well to gain that shore’ (Gn 1). Emanating from non-migrants, such comments provide an incisive insight into Irish society. Personal motives of a collective kind spurred Bridget Connell, an acquaintance of the Keanes. According to John Keane, Bridget was leaving Clashmore, County Waterford, to prevent her brother’s marriage in the United States. As John reported, she ‘is in a hurry to try If she could be out Before his marriage would take place to prevent it’ (Ke 2). John’s sister, Kate, on the other hand, indicated that Bridget Connell ‘is gone to try & do for her father & family in a foreign land’ (Ke 3). Whichever explanation is applied, Bridget Connell’s departure points to the dominant role of collective responsibilities over individual ambition. The subjection of Irish women to family decisions is perhaps most prominent in the case of Agnes Lambert. Single and pregnant at 18 years of age, Agnes was banished from her Belfast Presbyterian kith and kin. She departed Liverpool in January 1860 on board the White Star line vessel the Red Jacket. The ship called at Melbourne before continuing on to Auckland where it was acclaimed as ‘the finest merchant vessel which has ever come into New Zealand waters’.76 Within five weeks of her arrival on 17 May, Agnes gave
76
Southern Cross, 18 May 1860, p. 3. 72
IRISH MIGRATION AND NEW ZEALAND SETTLEMENT
birth to a son, James Francis Ferguson. According to family lore the father was a cousin of Agnes’s. Recollecting the circumstances of her departure seventeen years later, Agnes highlights the harshness of her enforced migration and subtly hints at the reason for it: ‘I have Been an outcaste from you all But I forgive him that was the cause of it all as my father ought to have forgiven me’ (La 1). This tellingly illustrates the disturbingly harsh character of some family decision-making. Despite the circumstances of her departure, Agnes expressed remorse about her relationship with her father: ‘My poor father is [erased: I] dead I know for I have Been dreaming about him so much. I Broke his heart But I hope he forgave me before he died’ (La 1). Agnes’s premonitions were unwarranted since her father was still alive, and time had seemingly mellowed him. As Agnes learned from her sister Isabella McNeice in Belfast, ‘I cannot explain to you the joy & grief he experienced when he heard from you. He says he will die contented since he knows yoa are still alive’ (La 2). As with migration generally, the motives for Irish women’s migration have been and remain hotly contested in Irish migration history. American-based studies by Hasia Diner and Janet Nolan have offered divergent explanations including Irish women’s desires to improve their opportunities for employment and marriage abroad.77 Recent commentary has combined both motives by suggesting that Irish women pursued economic gains in order to enhance their marriage prospects.78 The letters exchanged between New Zealand and Ireland give only a brief glimpse into women’s motives for migration, but reveal a range of private factors which could trigger departure from Ireland. The letters also show that responsibilities at home could prevent Irish women’s migration.79 Margaret Kilpatrick, for instance, appears to have elected to stay in Ireland temporarily rather than join her sister Martha Jane in Canada. As Martha Jane complained vigorously in 1862, ‘I wish R. John would marry and let you come to me. It is time he was. He is 28 I think by this.’80 Brigid Dawson, on the other hand, was seemingly the instigator of her Catholic family’s delayed departure
77
Hasia R. Diner, Erin’s daughters in America: Irish immigrant women in the nineteenth century (Baltimore, 1983); Janet A. Nolan, Ourselves alone: women’s emigration from Ireland, 1885–1920 (Lexington, 1989). 78 Kerby A. Miller, David N. Doyle, and Patricia Kelleher, ‘“For love and liberty”: Irish women, migration, and domesticity in Ireland and America, 1815–1920’ in Patrick O’Sullivan (ed.), Irish women and Irish migration (London, 1995), p. 53. 79 For Irish women in New Zealand see Lyndon Fraser, ‘“No one but black strangers to spake to god help me”: Irish women’s migration to the West Coast, 1864–1915’ in Lyndon Fraser and Katie Pickles (eds), Shifting centres: women and migration in New Zealand History (Dunedin, 2002), pp. 45–62; Angela McCarthy, “In prospect of a happier future”: private letters and Irish women’s migration to New Zealand, 1840–1925’ in Fraser (ed.), A distant shore, pp 105–16. 80 Martha Jane Wilson (Canada) to Margaret Anne Kilpatrick (Armagh), 17 March 1862. Transcript at P.R.O.N.I., T/2466/1, p. 12. 73
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
from County Armagh. With a hint of remorse, she explained to her sister in 1924, ‘I am sorry at that we did not come out here sooner or that I kept Peter back so long from coming for it was myself done it as he was at me all the time to say I would come’ (Da 1). Other letters also reveal that responsibilities towards parents were a factor in male kinfolk electing to remain in Ireland. William Lysaght, born at Clogher, Doon, County Tipperary, in April 1847, had diligently accompanied his family to New Zealand in 1864, only to return with his parents to Limerick within two years.81 By 1869 William was defending his decision to his older brother Edward: ‘You chose to take your chances in Newzealand and left us – and therefore lost all right to anything we had. I stuck to my father at both sides of the world and gained by doing so while you lost by leaving him’ (Ly 2). William Lysaght’s stinging remarks expose the tensions between the brothers and also reveal that both brothers made conscious, deliberate decisions concerning migration. It was not until his father Edmund’s death in 1896 that William elected to settle abroad though he chose Australia rather than New Zealand where both his brother and sister had settled. County Down migrant Andrew Gilmore, meanwhile, reluctantly acknowledged his brother Robert’s duty to remain on the Ards Peninsula because of his responsibilities to his parents, but Andrew’s comment implicitly assumed such care to be Robert’s rather than his concern: ‘I am sorry about the old people & could not advise you to Leave while the are alive not But the might be able with a little help to Live without you Being there But it seems so Hard to Leave them in old age’ (Ge 11). Even after their deaths Robert Gilmore stayed in Ireland, providing his blacksmith skills to Echlinville’s population. Indeed, the availability of work in Ireland was regarded as one reason for remaining in or returning to Ireland. John Armstrong, the son of a Church of Ireland minister, queried his sister in 1859, ‘Could Richard not find employment in Australia that he made such a short stay there or has he a prospect of obtaining it at home’ (Ar 1). More than fifty years later, in 1911, Michael Farrell wrote ruefully from Canterbury, in a letter to his brother Paddy, a tailor, in Tipperary, ‘perhaps you will like your trade so well now as you have your time served you wont ever emigrate’ (Fa 1). Despite this recognition, Michael attempted to encourage Paddy’s migration claiming, ‘there is no doubt but you will do well in this colony’. Moreover, Michael revealed that he would ‘be having a chat with some of the tailors here soon and Ill try and have a job got for you’ (Fa 1). Michael also divulged his plans to bring out several other siblings, claiming ‘It’s the best place for them anyway’ (Fa 1). Several years later, the Farrell siblings joined their brother Michael in New Zealand.
81 In May 1864 William, his parents, and his aunt Rosanna Hayes, arrived in the colony on board the Statesman which sailed from Gravesend on 1 January 1864.
74
IRISH MIGRATION AND NEW ZEALAND SETTLEMENT
As with the Farrell family migration, for whatever reasons migrants made the decision to leave Ireland, the choice of destination was often the result of the presence, encouragement, and assistance of family and friends in New Zealand. That pioneering migrants played a significant role in this respect is illustrated by Elizabeth McCleland’s comment to her daughter Ann that sister Nancy ‘longs greatly to hear from you. She intends to goe to you If you give her the least encouragement’ (Cd 1). Several sequences of letters serve to illustrate the explicit inducement provided by settlers in New Zealand. From Canterbury in 1875 married farmer James McIlrath, who had departed fifteen years earlier, promoted emigration when he wondered if his parents knew ‘of any young Woeman or girl that would like to come here Willing to milk & so. There is no rough work here like at home. I would pay all expences from she left home and make this a home for Her too’ (Il 24). In response to his inquiry James’s parents recommended Maggie Auld who was departing Belfast with her brothers for Canterbury on the Conflict. Subsequent letters in the McIlrath sequence indicate that Maggie accepted James’s offer of employment. One of the most determined correspondents seeking family reunion was Andrew Gilmore, fourth son of a blacksmith residing at Ballyhemlin on the Ards Peninsula, County Down. Having been joined in Tauranga in 1876 by two of his three siblings, Andrew wrote home to his eldest brother Robert in 1881 in an attempt to lure him and his family to New Zealand. Fundamental among Andrew Gilmore’s claims was that Robert’s ‘family would get more civilised & I Believe Better connected’ (Ge 11). Aware that personal advancement alone was unlikely to sway Robert, Andrew also suggested that the brothers unite in a business partnership. Andrew also offered to meet his brother on arrival at Auckland. Andrew’s pleas were in vain for, as we have seen, Robert Gilmore elected to remain in Ireland. A decade later, Carlow-born migrant Annie Dempsey sent a request from South Canterbury, with a focus on wages and an offer of assistance with the passage. Unlike James McIlrath, however, Annie clearly had someone in mind: Dear Sister is Mary Byrn of Knock Bally still at home yet or would she like to com to Newzeland. I would like to know as we would like to have a Respectable girl to live with us. We would give her good wages and make her as a companion or if Mr Burk did know of a Respectable girl who would wish to come out it would cost about Ten Pound to Pay there Passage here. We would Pay it. She could earn it afterwards with us when She would come out. (De 7)
Some comments also suggest the implicit encouragement of Irish migration to New Zealand, but for personal rather than altruistic reasons. James O’Neill, for instance, assessed from Auckland in 1863, ‘If Patt had not constant work in Limk I am shure he would do well here provided he would keep from drink’ (Ne 1). Other correspondents offered to act as patrons to prospective 75
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
migrants. John Armstrong, having learned of an acquaintance’s planned migration in 1859, promised to ‘do what little I can to oblige him’ while Daniel Strong was asked almost half a century later to look after a Protestant migrant (Ar 1; St 6, 7). Sixteen years after James McIlrath arrived in the colony, he learned of his nephew’s intended migration and pledged to ‘meet him and give him any assistance in my power’, while in 1905 Margaret Kilpatrick guaranteed a ‘hearty welcome’ at her Auckland residence to any migrants from Armagh (Il 27; Ki 14). Other migrant correspondents conveyed a desire for kin to join them but tempered this with a warning, placing the onus on the recipient to decide what option to pursue. As such, Agnes Lambert admitted reluctantly from Auckland in 1877, ‘I would like to see some of my sisters out here But if they are doing any way [erased: wel] well at home they had Better stay there for this is not much of a place unless you have plenty of money’ (La 1). Likewise, when offering advice about his brother’s intending migration to Christchurch from Tonaghmore, County Down, two years later, accountant William Cardwell hoped that ‘if he comes here there will be something turn up for him to do although trade just now is very dull’ (Ca 1). In June 1881, two years after his father’s death, John Cardwell and his wife voyaged to Canterbury on board the City of Tanjore. His two brothers, David and Samuel, equally divided their father’s 33 acres of land in the parish of Saintfield. Two sisters also remained in Ireland and were living with Samuel at the time of the 1901 Census. Only rarely was a would-be emigrant dissuaded, as in Margaret Kilpatrick’s explicit discouragement of her brother Joseph’s emigration from Balleer in 1862: ‘I would not advise Joseph to come here as he would not stand the work he would have to do’ (Ki 1). Clearly, an intending migrant’s disposition required careful scrutiny before emigration could be specifically recommended. Some correspondents, however, remained uncommitted in their assessments, including Oliver McSparron. After his arrival in Australia in 1860 he explained carefully, ‘I will send no word of encouragement or discouragement to anyone at present as I know little of this country’ (Sp 1). Similar sentiments were penned in the twentieth century. Michael Farrell revealed that ‘I had letters from Matt [word illegible] Dave Forgarty about coming but I told them to please themselves’ (Fa 1). Unlike Irish–Australian correspondence in which encouragement and discouragement were evenly weighted, and letters from the Irish in North America which were more prone to provide outright discouragement for further migration, the letters sent to Ireland from New Zealand were more likely to encourage, but with clear warnings.82 Such a contrast suggests that Irish correspondents in New Zealand responded favourably to their new environment, as we will see later. Whatever their motives for leaving Ireland,
82
Fitzpatrick, Oceans of consolation, p. 520; Miller, Emigrants and exiles, p. 358. 76
IRISH MIGRATION AND NEW ZEALAND SETTLEMENT
a combination of factors therefore played a role in determining migrants’ choice of New Zealand to settle. Apart from positive depictions of New Zealand’s environment and working conditions, the presence of close family and friends, explicit instruction to emigrate, and the availability of assisted passages were all vital ingredients in directing Irish migrants to New Zealand. The scattering of their family and friends around the world prompted many correspondents in Ireland to supply poignant testimony about the migration of their loved ones. Such evidence was generally penned shortly after the migrant’s departure, thereby heightening a sense of despair among those who remained. Daniel Strong’s migration produced deep distress among his cousins, for as John Strong reflected painfully in 1883: We all loved you with more than brotherly love. . . . I liked you as well as the Dearest of a brother and first thing I heard on Wednesday morning was my mother crying for you. You never left our mind for a moment since you left and Lizzie cried after getting up this morning. (St 1)
The departure of an acquaintance to North America from County Waterford in 1886 reminded an agonised Kate Keane of her feelings when her sisters left for New Zealand earlier that decade. ‘I thought my heart would break thinking of ye both when ye were leaving us all’, she recollected mournfully (Ke 3). Protestant correspondents in Ireland echoed the grief expressed by Catholic writers. From Balleer, County Armagh, in 1863, for instance, Margaret Kilpatrick’s widowed mother admitted dejectedly that ‘there is one long heart rending thought that troubles me that is I fear I never will see you in this life’ (Ki 2). Fathers also grieved, prompting David McCullough to sympathise with his aunt, ‘I am sorry to hear my father taking it so much to heart’ (Cu 2). Samuel McCullough’s despair was seemingly compounded by the fact that David was his only son and later letters indicate that Samuel vigorously sought David’s return to take over the family farm. Few letters, however, equal the intense outpouring of desolation contained in the correspondence of the widow Elizabeth McCleland when her daughter Ann departed Liverpool in March 1840 on the Martha Ridgway. Ann’s voyage to the fledgling colony gave her mother the deepest heartfelt sorrow and distress of mind & bodey that it is possible for one of my age & constitution to bear. I suffered after you went away grieving night & day about you. I hoped that you would have perhaps ruid & changed your mind when you would goe to Liverpool but alas to my sorrow you went on leaving me to grieve your absence. (Cd 1)
Other family and acquaintances at Dunronan, County Londonderry, also mourned Ann’s absence: ‘Sister Mary grieves day & Night’; Eliza Jane ‘frequently talks about you & cries’; ‘Sarah is grieved about you’; and Jane ‘longs most earnestly to hear from you’ (Cd 1). Several other family members 77
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
were also ‘in great grief about you when you went away’ (Cd 1). These intensely moving responses to Ann McCleland’s departure probably reflect the timing of her migration. By contrast with later migrants, Ann was voyaging to a country barely known among intending Irish migrants. The extensive expressions of sorrow articulated by non-migrants contrast significantly with the general absence of grief in the letters of migrants. Indeed, only one migrant conveyed such emotion. Preparing to return to New Zealand following a visit to Ireland in 1925, Philip Carroll wrote despairingly, ‘Mother will find the parting hard this time and so will I because I do not expect I will ever see her again in this life’ (Cl 18). In the last surviving letter of the Carroll sequence, Philip brooded sadly, ‘Meetings are lovely but partings are rotten’ (Cl 24). In order to ease his departure, Philip adopted a psychological tactic, claiming to ‘look on my parting with Ireland like I would when leaving a place where I spent an enjoyable holiday’ (Cl 21). Philip Carroll had just received news that he was dying from Bright’s disease, a chronic inflammatory disorder of the kidneys. Undoubtedly this exacerbated his anxiety at leaving his mother. But the desire to reunite with his wife and children in New Zealand took precedence. Not surprisingly, Philip’s personal circumstances shaped his response to his departure from Ireland. His moving reflections, however, stand in stark contrast to the striking absence of similar accounts from nineteenth-century migrant correspondents voyaging to New Zealand. By contrast, Kerby Miller has argued that post-Famine Irish migrants in North America conveyed ‘deep sorrow’ at leaving home and kin.83 However, most of Miller’s examples of post-Famine sorrow at the time of departure emanate from non-migrants.84 Instead, the most extensive examples of grief expressed by migrants destined for North America are drawn from the preFamine period.85 One of the most striking findings from both Miller’s and this study is that most anguished accounts concerning departure from Ireland arose from non-migrants. Perhaps this explains the relative absence of expressions of grief among migrants; did migrants feel sad but remain silent so as not to reinforce the sorrow experienced by their kin in Ireland? Or did some migrants testify to their grief only to have such letters discarded? On the other hand, anticipation of reunion with their friends and family in New Zealand may have suppressed to some degree the pain of separation among migrants. Moreover, the excitement, anticipation, and hustle and bustle of leaving must also have alleviated the ache associated with departure. Whatever explanation is applied, a frequent tactic to combat separation was to look upon migration as a temporary undertaking and the surviving letters of migrants reveal that many viewed their migration as a transient
83 84 85
Miller, Emigrants and exiles, p. 482. Ibid., p. 482. Ibid. Miller’s evidence of pre-Famine migrant sorrow can be found on p. 254. 78
IRISH MIGRATION AND NEW ZEALAND SETTLEMENT
venture. According to sociologists this ‘myth’ of return eased the sorrow for all involved in the process of separation. For example, when David McCullough arrived in London for the second leg of his voyage in 1875 he reassured his aunt at Moneyreagh, ‘I can not turn back now but I hope soon to return’ (Cu 2). Gordon McClure employed the same strategy when he emigrated in 1860. Before sailing he cheerfully encouraged his sisters to ‘enjoy yourselves till I come back which will be in about 2 years when I expect you will all come out with me & settle’ (Ce 2). In similar vein, John Gilmore, in his first surviving letter sent home after his voyage, hinted, ‘I may drop down there some day yet as there is no saying what time may Bring’ (Ge 6). Non-migrants also clung to the possibility of reunion. Despite the distress engendered by his cousin Daniel’s migration, John Strong steadfastly believed, When you receive a letter from me again thousands of miles of oceon shall roll between us and you will be in a strange land making new friends and perhaps forgetting the old ones, or only remembering them sometimes when some stray thought shall wander back to them and the land of your birth. But Dan you will never be forgotten by me and I feel certain that we shall meet again.
John Strong’s anticipation of this reunion appears to be a temporal one. He guesses that at their future meeting they will be ‘much changed in appearance’ as ‘time may whiten the hair furrow the brow and dim the eyes’ (St 2). Possibly John Strong’s focus on reunion was relayed in order to alleviate any distress that Daniel may have felt reading John’s earlier missive, but without Daniel’s response to that earlier letter we must remain uncertain. Regardless, John Strong was also deploying a personal coping mechanism to combat his own misery. Other correspondents, however, did look towards a spiritual reunion, a feature discussed below, in Chapter 9. Such declarations were seemingly designed to soothe the process of separation and console both migrants and non-migrants, for none of these writers returned to Ireland. Nevertheless, such announcements were not simply hollow wishes, but were feasible options as is evident in the extent of return migration, which will be examined in Chapter 7. To conclude, Irish migrants settling in New Zealand were predominantly drawn from Munster and Ulster, were approximately three-fifths Catholic, and supplied a significant minority of New Zealand’s foreign-born population. Irish men and women settled widely in New Zealand and their use of the colonial government’s schemes of nominated and assisted migration meant that robust links developed between specific counties of origin and particular colonial destinations. Though these subsidised passages were crucial in supplying Irish migrants with the means to join their kinfolk, migrants elected to leave Ireland for a range of reasons. Their choice of settlement in New Zealand, meanwhile, was based primarily on the advice and encouragement of their family and friends, rather than propaganda campaigns. The presence 79
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
of these connexions in New Zealand and anticipation of future reunion with their loved ones in Ireland may have made migrants less inclined to articulate their sorrow at departure. Their non-migrant counterparts, however, supplied moving testimony of the grief generated by separation.
80
2
‘Very perfection of a letter writer’ An overview of Irish–New Zealand correspondence Between 1886 and 1921 the Keane family of Clashmore, County Waterford, sent eleven surviving letters to their migrant sister Mary, who had settled at Wellington. These letters placed a range of obligations on Mary. Both Mary and another migrant sister, Bridget, residing in Otago, were clearly expected to communicate regularly with the family: ‘I hope Bridget will write and let us know how she is getting on & if she dont tis the most she can do as not’ (Ke 1). The consequences of Mary’s silence were also keenly felt. A friend ‘was very mad as you did not write to her’ (Ke 1). Another sister, Kate, who settled in London, also conveyed her deep disappointment in Mary, some two decades after Mary’s departure: ‘All the years you have left home you have not written to me’ (Ke 4). Mary Keane’s communications, however, may have been subjected to the precarious transmission of correspondence. In 1886, her brother John puzzled, ‘you spoke about writing so many letters home to Ireland. All the letters ever I read from ye was four two from Bridget & Two from Your-self’ (Ke 2). Alternatively, Mary may have exaggerated her writing activities to counteract these complaints from home, leaving her family to surmise as to the whereabouts of so many letters. When, eventually, Kate received word from Mary, she exclaimed gleefully, ‘Words in writing fail to express my joy to receive a letter from you after all these years’ (Ke 5). Apart from news, the exchange of correspondence among the Keane family also contained photographs. In 1918, approximately forty years after Mary’s departure, Kate sought a photograph for the purposes of recollection: I have one of Bridget taken when she first went to New Zealand & a photo taken with her husband & children when John was a little one. He resembles his mother but I have not a single photo of you Mary. If you have an old photo do send me one just to remember you as I used to in the old days & one taken with the children. I am having some taken & will send you one. (Ke 10)
In response to this letter Mary sent a photograph of her son, prompting Kate to claim enthusiastically, ‘I could at once recall your face Mary as I knew you at home, the same expression’ (Ke 11). The Keane letters also contained demands that Mary provide financial 81
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
support for her family. This was particularly evident during a time when the health of Mary’s mother faltered: She is not well since she threw up the blood. She hardly have any appetite at all but now I am asking you to try and assisst her for you know very well she needs it and it is time for you to think of her now if you will ever think & I hope you wont be so false hearted as not to do so. (Ke 1)
While we do not know Mary’s response, clearly the responsibilities to her family had not ceased to exist with her departure from Ireland. This chapter explores the importance of letters as a ‘cultural institution’.1 It does so by drawing upon extracts from the letters to chart the mechanics of correspondence, exploring how letters were composed, transmitted, and received. The chapter then documents the other items exchanged between Ireland and New Zealand – photographs, newspapers, and gifts were the main items – and considers the range of obligations expected of migrants, beyond maintaining a regular correspondence. The earliest letter in this study was sent in 1840 from Dunronan in County Londonderry to Wellington. Elizabeth McCleland informed her daughter Ann that Samuel Dettey ‘has put himself to this trouble to write this’ (Cd 1). Other correspondents were also assisted with their composition, including Thomas Hughes’s sister Harriet, who revealed almost a century later, ‘George is giving me a hand to write this’ (Hu 19). Most correspondents, however, wrote their own letters. In 1910 John Keane announced to his sister in Wellington, ‘I have taken my pen in hand to speak a few words to you’ (Ke 7). Tipperary correspondent Philip Carroll, meanwhile, referred twice to writing in the sunlight and expressed his astonishment at ‘sitting down at half past ten o’clock in broad daylight writing this letter’ (Cl 5). He would naturally have been accustomed to shorter summer evenings in Auckland with the sun setting around nine at night. Annie Dempsey, from Carlow, meanwhile, stressed the joy of communicating: ‘It Affords me mutch pleasure to write you A few lines’ (De 3). Composition of a letter, by self or amanuensis, could be a thoughtful enterprise or a rushed obligation. In Auckland Agnes Lambert sat ‘Down to rite fue lines to you after a long tine thinking about it’ (La 4). George Reid, Margaret Kilpatrick’s brother, was more rushed. He confessed from Armagh, ‘I have neglected writing so long through simple carelessness that I am determined to run a hurried epistle through while I am in the humour’ (Ki 8). Other writers sent a ‘scribble’.
1 David Fitzpatrick, Oceans of consolation: personal accounts of Irish migration to Australia (Cork, 1995), p. 472.
82
IRISH–NEW ZEALAND CORRESPONDENCE
In the early days of mail delivery, the time of delivery for a letter could take up to five months or more. Elizabeth McCleland’s letter of 1841, composed virtually a year after her daughter’s emigration, highlights the anxiety caused by such delays: After a long times fretting and thinking long about you and wondering whether you were in the land of the living or not or if the sea had become your grave I recived your letter on the sixt of August Which give me and all the rest a great deal of joy to hear that you were well when you rote to us and that that you got safely over after so long a pasag and after the apearing dangers of the sea. (Cd 2)
Delivery times decreased with advances in shipping and routes. In 1876, for instance, the average delivery time fell to less than 45 days with the opening of the Pacific route. By contrast, the Suez–Brindis route took 55 days and the Suez–South route 65 days. The delivery timetable continued to improve and in 1893 mail from Auckland to London averaged 33 days. 2 In 1902, however, the Cyclopedia for the Auckland province observed, ‘Aucklanders are disgusted with a mail service which brings them English letters more than thirty-five days old.’3 Before the start of the First World War the delivery time had fallen only slightly to 31 days.4 Within New Zealand, delivery of the mail was hampered by the colony’s physical terrain. Sea routes initially proved to be the quickest and safest method of delivery before an overland route between Auckland and Wellington was established in the 1840s. Delivery took two and a half weeks and was hindered by the fact that a maximum load of between 50 and 75 pounds was enforced, later reduced in the 1850s to 28 pounds.5 Postal charges also fluctuated throughout the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. In 1840 letters from Great Britain could be sent for a penny if carried by a government ship while private vessels often charged 8d. By 1891 the standard postage rate fell to 21⁄2 d. and in 1901 penny postage was introduced. Internal rates also fell to a penny.6 During the First World War rates were raised to 11⁄2 d. and to 2d. in 1920. Three years later they had fallen back to the penny rate and despite another temporary rise during the depression years penny postage operated until after the commencement of the Second World War.7 As postal charges oscillated with the weight of a letter, Elizabeth Walker claimed to Margaret Kilpatrick, ‘I think we are justified in sending double letters for the double postage’ (Ki 4). Occasionally, recipients were obliged to 2 Howard Robinson, A history of the post office in New Zealand (Wellington, 1964), pp 134, 137. 3 Cyclopedia of New Zealand (Christchurch, 1902), ii. 4 Robinson, A history of the post office, p. 188. 5 Ibid., pp 56–8. 6 Ibid., pp 165, 169–70. 7 Ibid., pp 195, 200.
83
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
pay extra for overweight or underpaid items. Andrew Gilmore, for instance, contacted his brother Robert on the Ards Peninsula in County Down about mail received from their parents. Andrew recommended that, ‘If it could be done it would look much better if there were no deficiency postage nor fines for me to pay on their letter’ (Ge 8). His comment is probably less a reflection of his unhappiness at paying such charges, and more a wish to avoid the stigma of a respectable person receiving underpaid letters. Given such charges, it is not surprising that throughout the nineteenth century many correspondents entrusted their documents to fellow passengers. In 1840, for instance, Elizabeth McCleland revealed that her daughter ‘would have went with the bearer of this letter but she wished to wait for a letter from you’ (Cd 1). The delivery of parcels was more frequently entrusted to migrants from the local neighbourhood. As James McIlrath related in 1866, ‘I was in christ church on the 1st of this month and recieved the parcel you sent Mother by Mr Ward. . . . We place it to the Account of Debt and Duty’ (Il 10). David McCullough’s gift, meanwhile, was transported by his friend William Hobson in 1875: ‘I got the parcels safe from him that you dear father & mother sent me. I thank you both very much as It was a nice new years gift to me’ (Cu 4). Transmission through an intermediary was not only faster and cheaper than official methods of delivery, but also more reliable. Indeed, many letters were frequently delayed or went astray. In cases where the mail could not be delivered, names were published and the recipients given six months to retrieve their post. If unclaimed, the mail was returned. To counteract postponements and missing mail, Elizabeth McCleland adopted a sound strategy. She notified her daughter Ann in Wellington in 1841, ‘we intend sending you another in the corse of a month or two and you will surely get some of them. You may rite in the same way to us and we will have a better chance of getting some of yours’ (Cd 2). Almost two decades later the delivery situation remained equally haphazard. John Armstrong, awaiting a parcel from home, resignedly contemplated, ‘I hope it will not go in search of the missing letter’ (Ar 1). In a later communication, Armstrong expressed concern that the mail failed to arrive when expected: The cause of the delay is not known but I hope it is nothing more serious than the breaking down of the mail steamer through its machinery getting out of order. I still look forward with interest to the arrival of the English Mail and it is no slight disappointment when it does not come in. (Ar 3)
An established correspondent, John Armstrong was alert to the expected arrival times of the mail: ‘We look for English news & letters now in two months from the time they leave England but of course sailing vessels cannot be expected to be quite so expeditious especially those homeward bound’ (Ar 1). 84
IRISH–NEW ZEALAND CORRESPONDENCE
Other correspondents also reflected on the reasons for haphazard deliveries. West Coast goldminer Michael Flanagan, bewildered by the non-arrival of letters from Louth and London in 1867, pondered, I cannot for the life of me think how your letters could have gone astray as they have done for we have written regularly to the post offices and although not being much in the neighbourhood of Hokitika we have been there several times during the last two years and have got no letters nor saw any advertised. (Fl 2)
Little evidence exists of the problems of the postal service in Ireland, but one commentator did note the difficulties prevailing between England and Ireland. As Fr Flanagan logically reassured his nephews in 1867, ‘You need not be disappointed at not hearing from your friends at home. You see one of my own letters has miscarried and I have thro’ the Dead letter, or Returning letter office, a letter that Richd wrote to you when at home here last September twelve months’ (Fl 1). Various situations hampered the delivery of mail in New Zealand. It could go astray due to an incorrect or out-of-date address. As James McClure explained in 1865 from Southland to his sisters in Belfast, ‘the address on your last is not correct, which accounts for so many not reaching me’ (Ce 5). In 1898 David McCullough sent clarification about his communication, presumably in response to his failure to write: ‘He told me in his letter that aunt Nancy wrote to me. He gave the address Reefton. That would not find me. I have never been in Reefton’ (Cu 5). In other cases, mail was delivered to other recipients with the same name. In 1862, just months after his arrival in Canterbury, Hamilton McIlrath informed his parents, ‘When you write to James you must direct to James Logan McIlrath as there is another James McIlrath on the same station that has got all James’s Letters and opened them’ (Il 5). More simply, delayed mail could arise from carelessness. As Philip Carroll surmised from Tipperary in 1925, ‘The mails are indeed most erratic or has someone been carrying them around in their pocket again’ (Cl 16). These continuing problems with the delivery of mail inevitably created misunderstandings between correspondents, which inevitably placed strains on relationships. A friend of Margaret Kilpatrick’s, for instance, had obviously received a testing letter from Margaret. In response she claimed, ‘believe me there never was a letter come from you to your mother but what I answered sooner or later and if you have written any since her death they have gone astray’ (Ki 7). In 1864 Oliver McSparron’s uncle complained from Australia that Oliver had not answered his letters; five years later, Oliver claimed it took six months for a local letter to reach him when ‘I ought to have had it in about six days. He said it was the third he had sent me but I have never got them and indeed I have not even had a letter from Uncle William Oliver for better than a year although I have written him four times and I cannot understand it at all’ (Sp 4). Before arriving in New Zealand, Oliver McSparron 85
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
rebuked his father for failing to maintain regular correspondence with Oliver’s uncle: I think you should think of writing to my Uncle a little oftenere. You have not sent but one letter to him since I came here and he says he thinks he will never hear from home any more when I go away and I think that if you are not able to buy two s[h]eet of note paper and two envelopes in a year it is time you were giving up housekeeping. As regards myself I have not had a letter this last seven now eight months.8
Not all complaints concerning poor communication arose from the nondelivery of mail. Margaret Kilpatrick conveyed her husband’s disappointment with his siblings for their neglect in writing, while conveniently explaining away David’s own disregard: Though he does not write himself he thinks when I write that it should do. Now if you do not write, he says that he will neighter [neither] write himself nor will he let me write. We had a letter from Thomas this mail, and 3 papers, but when there is not a letter from Ballyards David is out of all paitiance. (Ki 3)
Annie Dempsey also sent an ultimatum to acquaintances in Carlow: ‘Tell Mike to write me a Slip. Tell Martin Molloy I will give him a good talken to at Not writin to me’ (De 1). Other correspondents seeking news from home employed more subtle tactics, perhaps fearing that those at home might forget them. ‘You Might write oftener’, Hamilton McIlrath suggested calmly in 1863. ‘You have got more interesting news than I have’ (Il 8). Catherine Sullivan, on the other hand, stated explicitly, ‘I shall be impatient to hear from you’ (Su 1). Home correspondents shared this intolerance of poor writing habits, with some grumbling about their migrant kinfolk. In 1895 Mary Ann Gilpin wrote from Armagh to her sister Lizzie reproaching another migrant sister’s poor communication: ‘She never wrote to me yet. Indeed mother thinks her very unkind. Never answered their letters’ (Gn 2). Nine years later in 1904, little had altered: ‘I often think of H Jane how she never writes’ (Gn 5). Complaints did not just arise from non-communication, and its associated fear that home connexions had ceased to exist, but also from delays in writing. From Canterbury in 1888 Annie Dempsey hoped ‘yous will write soon and I hope yous will never be as long again without writing’ (De 5). The Monan parents in County Down, on the other hand, ‘received your kind letter and we were surprised to see it it is so long since we had a letter from you’ (Mo 1).
8 Oliver McSparron (Geelong) to Archibald McSparron (Umrycam), 8 September 1861, P.R.O.N.I., T/2743/1/7.
86
IRISH–NEW ZEALAND CORRESPONDENCE
For other correspondents, it was the brevity of letters that generated despair. An acquaintance of Michael Flanagan’s explained, ‘I have not heard from home for some time and when they write they send such short letters’ (Fl 17). Monaghan migrant Patrick Treanor, meanwhile, apologised in advance to an acquaintance in New Zealand for his brief reply: ‘I hope that you will excuse me for this short letter compaired with your long kind & affectionate letter’ (Tr 1). Valid complaints of irregular communication inevitably generated a diverse range of excuses from those accused of maintaining sporadic contact. Such explanations further testify to the crucial importance of letters among separated kinfolk. From his Canterbury farm in 1872, eleven years after arriving in New Zealand, James McIlrath protested about a letter received from his family in which you seem to censure me very much for not writing more regular I admit the charge to a certin extent but on the other hand I cannot admit being so very negligent as by your letter it would appear. I had wrote to John just before I recieved yours otherwise I would have wrote to you sooner. As for Hamilton I have done all I could to persuade Him to write and if he has not done so the fault is not mine and he is very ungrat[e]ful indeed. (Il 17)
In the case of the McIlraths, Hamilton had the excuse that James would correspond regularly and inform those at home of his progress: Plea[s]e to ask father and Mother to forgive me for not writeing before for I am heartly ashamed of myself and shall not be guilty of the like again for it was not that the were out of my mind for month after month. I have been going to write this last three years and always put it off for I thought that James would let you know how I was and how I was getting on. (Il 19)
Even though James McIlrath maintained a relatively regular correspondence with home, this obviously did not compensate his parents who preferred to hear directly from Hamilton. Occasionally, the McIlrath brothers admitted to ‘negligence’. Hamilton confessed, ‘I commence at once to answer a letter time wears on u[n]till I feel ashamed and then I think I will wait for another but no second came in this case’ (Il 28). Also writing from Canterbury, Bessie Macready admitted to her cousin William, ‘I have for a long time thought of writing to you but was waiting for something to write about farming’ (Ma 2). Another Canterbury-based correspondent, Annie Dempsey, explained away her silence: ‘I Hope you will Pardon me For not writing Befour this time But realy it was not for want of Good on my Part’ (De 4). Oliver McSparron, on the other hand, attributed his failure to write to an accident: ‘I would have written sooner but I got my hand crushed with a dray’ (Sp 4). As with migrant letter writers, home correspondents also resorted to various reasons to account for their irregular communication, primarily citing the usual 87
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
plea of heavy workload and illness. Writing from Armagh in 1895 Mary Ann Gilpin admitted, ‘You will think me very unkind in not writing before this but I have been so busy all this winter I could never get set down to write’ (Gn 2). Occasionally, the absence of letters was symptomatic of illness and writers in Ireland often conveyed this excuse to explain their silence. In 1871, almost a year after receiving a letter in Limerick from his brother, William Lysaght sought forgiveness ‘for not answering a letter of yours that came here last October. I was not at home when it came here. I was in Dublin at the time in an Hospital’ (Ly 5). From Tipperary in 1900, John Strong regretted that his cousin Daniel ‘must think I have forgotten you altogether when I have not replied to your two last letters. But the facts were at that time poor Will was sick’ (St 5). Catherine Colgan in Antrim also attributed her lack of communication to the illness of herself and others. ‘You must pardon me for not writing sooner, but the reason why, Hector was not well for 2 months’, she wrote in 1893. Eight years later she put her irregular letters down to ‘a bad attack of Influenza’ (Co 1, 6). Meanwhile, Robert Hughes in Sligo confessed, ‘I am not able to half answer it my hand is still & full of rh[e]umetism’ (Hu 4). Just as writers in Ireland explained postponements in writing by illness, they were also more likely to assume that poor health led to delays in receiving mail from New Zealand. William Gilmer, farming at Monaghan, claimed, ‘It is a very long time since I had a letter from you. I feel very anxious. I hope you are quite well’ (Gr 2). If some home correspondents chastised migrants for not writing, others invented their own explanations for the irregular communication. Again, fears of illness played a role. ‘Dear Mother I was expectin a letter from yous this long time but I received hear the one’, wrote Annie Dempsey in 1888 from Canterbury to Carlow. ‘However I hope Sicknes is not the cause of it or have yous forgotten me all together’ (De 5). Richard Flanagan, on the other hand, mentioned to his brothers that ‘your long intervals of silence render us lonely’ but he imagined that ‘in your remote district and in the cares and anxieties of your daily occupation you often miss the oppertunities of writing you had intended availing yourselves of ’ (Fl 10, 3). This was not only a device to console Richard but probably an attempt to cajole his goldmining brothers to write. Correspondents pursued various strategies to ensure regular communication with their kinfolk. One such practice was to write alternately to various home readers. From Tauranga in 1878 Andrew Gilmore requested his brother to ‘Read this to the old people. I shall write next mail to themselves’ (Ge 8). John Armstrong also alternated the recipient of his letters, probably so as not to repeat the same information and also to maintain a regular communication with his various family members. Sometimes he sent two or more letters home in the same envelope: ‘I have just finished a letter to Uncle John which I shall enclose with yours and which you are welcome to read before forwarding to him’ (Ar 2). Three and a half years later he sent a brief message to his sister ‘through Mother and I shall therefore address this months letter to you’ 88
IRISH–NEW ZEALAND CORRESPONDENCE
(Ar 3). James McIlrath also advised his parents that if they wrote every second letter to Hamilton ‘he would have a better chance of writing than waiting until I send them to Him’ (Il 6). The exchange of letters between New Zealand and Ireland ultimately consoled and reassured, with many declarations of joy uttered upon receipt of correspondence. When Michael Flanagan received a letter from his brother Richard in London in 1867 he exclaimed euphorically, The receipt of yours of the 26th May was indeed an ‘event’ and I might say about the most welcome epistle I have read for a long time. It is such a lenght of time since we saw your handwriting before and as you are the very perfection of a letter writer if anything could throw a little light upon or import a ray of hope to the dreary monotony of a life in this climate it would be a few words of encouragement or an assurance that thier were some in the world yet who were anxious to hear from us. (Fl 2)
The anxiousness with which news was awaited and the joy at receiving it highlights the importance of correspondence for separated kinfolk. Other correspondents explicitly emphasised the significance of letters. ‘If you ever see her Father or Mother tell them they must write to her oftener as she is always looking for a letter from them’, revealed James McIlrath about Maggie Auld in 1877 (Il 26). Margaret Kilpatrick also strongly suggested from Auckland to her recipients in Armagh that ‘William Erskines people ought to write to him’ (Ki 3). Some correspondents underlined the reassuring element of letters. In 1883, the year his cousin Daniel voyaged from Ireland, John Strong hoped ‘you will never forget writing to me for I will be always anxious to hear how you are getting on and shall always rejoyce in your success’ (St 2). Twentieth-century correspondents also delighted in the receipt of news from home. ‘I was overjoyed at receiving a letter from you’, wrote Maggie Moran in 1916, a friend of May Farrell’s from Tipperary (Fa 5). Quite apart from their private messages of consolation and reassurance, letters were also passed on to others to absorb in silence or read aloud. In 1862, the year of her arrival at Auckland, Margaret Kilpatrick firmly instructed her brother Thomas, ‘when you receive this to go out to Mama and read her this’ (Ki 1). The following decade from Tauranga, John Gilmore likewise recommended, ‘Let all have a reading who you think would wish’ (Ge 7). The public character of private correspondence demanded a degree of sensitivity on the part of those supplying the letters to other readers. Consequently, when the Flanagan family in County Louth passed on Michael’s letter to members of Pat Kirk’s family, they ‘blotted out a certain name’ (Fl 12). Before confirming that Pat Kirk was indeed murdered, Pat Flanagan mused: ‘I think his Father’s name was James. I am not certain. Is there no letters left after him that would tell that’ (Fl 8). Letters could therefore be significant in providing clues to a migrant’s background when death occurred so far from home. Philip Carroll, when writing to his wife from Tipperary, shrewdly put information to his wife 89
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
on an extra sheet ‘In case you do not want to tell the relations everything’ (Cl 7). There was little Kate Keane could do, however, when she received ‘1⁄2 a sheet torn off by the censor’ from her nephew during the First World War (Ke 10). Robert Hughes also noted the interference of a letter sent from his son: ‘Your letter was found open when it reached Dublin’ (Hu 6). Letters were not the only item exchanged between Ireland and New Zealand. Photographs, newspapers, money, and miscellaneous items frequently accompanied a letter, with photographs the most frequently exchanged item (see Table 2.1). Photographs sent, received, requested, and promised feature in twenty-three sequences. The receipt of ‘likenesses’ generated much comment, some of it complimentary, including Oliver McSparron’s astonishment that he ‘did not think I had so good looking a sister as she appears to be’ (Sp 3). Retired constabulary officer Robert Hughes in Sligo admitted keenly to his son and daughter-in-law, ‘I love to dwell and look upon your beautiful faces and nice handsom forms’ (Hu 1). During his return to Tipperary in 1925, Philip Carroll expressed his pleasure at the positive response that circulation of his family’s photographs generated: ‘Everyone who sees them is raving about them’ (Cl 5). Other remarks were less flattering, the ageing process so obviously evident after years of separation. As James McIlrath commented upon receiving photographs from Killinchy fifteen years after his departure: ‘You Father I would not have known but I should have you Mother. Time does not seem to have changed you so much. . . . I enclose my own and Mrs and I suppose you will find that time has changed me much’ (Il 23). That same year, Hamilton McIlrath was rather more exuberant: Mother is looking very fresh. Father is grayer looking than I expected but is looking smart and well. I should know them both anywhere. For your own I Know very little difference since last I seen you. You wear your whiskers a bit larger and looks a little more of the swell. Your Misses is a fine looking woman. I dare say you are proud of her. The children are Remarkable pretty. Hamilton is nothing like me. He is to fair for that. Jane is a very nice shy looking girl. I think our Johnny resembles yours a good deal. (Il 22)
Upon receipt of a photo from home, Hamilton pronounced, ‘You have realy a nice Family and for yourself and Mrs I wont say anything. I dare say you are Table 2.1 Items exchanged between Ireland and New Zealand
Photographs Newspapers Gifts
From Ireland
From New Zealand
31 16 15
44 32 11
90
IRISH–NEW ZEALAND CORRESPONDENCE
both proud enough of your looks alredy’ (Il 28). When Jane McIlrath requested a photograph of her migrant sons, James responded, ‘I spoke to Hamilton about mother wanting the likenesss but he said Mother said she wanted to see no rough faces and [erased: and] he could not send what he had not got a smoothe one’ (Il 7). And according to A. Burns, a friend of Michael Flanagan’s, in 1890: I am afraid if you were to see the originals you would not say you could see no difference in our appearance now and twenty years ago. I got the portraits of my sister Mary from home and I would not know her. She looks quite old. I think I stand it better than she does. (Fl 17)
While these comments were offered voluntarily, some correspondents had to entice recipients for clarification concerning their remarks on photographs. ‘So you see a great change in me’, Mary Ann Gilpin wrote to her sister Lizzie in 1895. ‘Is it for the better? I was very thin when I got it taken’ (Gn 2). The exchange of photographs helped maintain kinship ties as family members sought to remind themselves of the appearance of dear, departed kin. They also served as mementoes. As Mary Shanahan explained in 1892 from County Kerry to her niece Winifred McClennan, ‘I haven’t got anything left after her to send you only her Photo as her ring got Broken years ago & she never got it mended. Maurice has all & everything belonging to her. I kept the best of her clothes & I gave her cape cloak to Ellen’ (Sh 2). It is also likely that the receipt of photographs sparked nostalgic memories, provoking several correspondents to comment on resemblances. Kate Keane saw similarities between her sons and those of her sister Mary: ‘Every body here who has seen your Ernie’s photo says Jim is exactly like his cousin Ernie’ (Ke 10). In Antrim Catherine Colgan received a photograph of her granddaughter which prompted her remark, ‘Some ones says she looks like yourself’ (Co 7). Robert Hughes declared proudly that his grandson ‘is a picture out of a thousand & to see how he sits for his Photo to be taken why as solid as any man. He is the most wonderful child of his age I have ever saw . . . never saw the like of him at his age for beauty & strength he surpasses all’. Robert then mused cheekily, ‘To distinguish as to which of the families he most resembles would be a hard test but to put it plainly he is just the picture of myself when I was his age’ (Hu 8). For Ellen Piezzi, though, a photograph of her son served as a reminder of her late husband. She therefore promised to send one to her brother-in-law to see ‘What fine littel fellow he is getting and tell me is like his papa. He wake [walk] like and his shape is very like him’ (Pi 2). Photographs, then, not only served as an introduction to family members who had never met, but also documented the changes of kinfolk over the years. In the absence of photographs, correspondents had to rely upon their memory. Kate Keane affectionately recollected her deceased mother as ‘certainly very handsome but since we have not a photo we must picture her dear old good face in our memories’ (Ke 5). Other correspondents provided 91
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
selective descriptions of themselves, rather than sending photographs. ‘My Hair is getting white and my teeth are almost gone’, reported John Strong twenty-two years after his cousin’s departure (St 6). Sophy Lang, Margaret Kilpatrick’s friend, supplied Margaret with a physical description of Margaret’s sister-in-law: ‘she has Sandy hair a good skin and a very good agree[a]ble countenance I think about your own height stout and well made’ (Ki 7). Sophy, on the other hand, portrayed herself as ‘an old gray haired woman wears my specks but has as good health as ever I had’ (Ki 7). Contemplating his mother’s physique, Philip Carroll related flatteringly, ‘only that she has got a few more grey hairs she is looking as young and well as the day I left’ (Cl 5). As for his sister Nance, ‘She has got very goodlooking. She is as tall as I am but twice as stout’ (Cl 6). Philip’s cousin Maggie, meanwhile, ‘is looking every bit as young as she looked when I left Ireland. She must be 76, if she is a day, and honestly she does not look 50. Her hair is still quite black. I do not know whether she dyes it or not’ (Cl 10). Other correspondents had to imagine how their kin looked. Hamilton McIlrath mused, ‘I expect John will have as big A Mustaich now as Me that Has not shaved this Last two years’ (Il 8). Apart from photographs and descriptions, newspapers were also frequently exchanged. In 1862 James O’Neill wrote from Auckland to his brother in Limerick informing, ‘I got 2 newspapers regular from you. I hope you get them as regular from me. I sent one every mail but one since I came here’ (Ne 1). Occasionally, a newspaper’s purpose was to publicly attest to a migrant’s success such as that sent by Daniel Strong to his cousin John who remarked, ‘Thanks for the newspaper. It let me know you have succeeded in a foreign land’ (St 6). Mostly, however, newspapers included commentary on public events that were discussed in greater depth than a migrant was either willing or able to remark upon. Thus Margaret Kilpatrick announced in 1862, ‘There was a great election here but I will send you a paper so you will have the news’ (Ki 1). More than fifty years later, in 1913, Alexander McKelvey informed, ‘We had a pretty bad time here with the strike as you will see by the papers I send’ (Ky 3). John Armstrong, on the other hand, provided some commentary to accompany the newspapers he sent, particularly when his own impressions diverged from that offered by the press: ‘I hope the papers I send you will reach their destination as I shall leave you in a great measure to draw your own conclusions from them as to how near we may be to peace. The “Southern Cross” gives a most disheartening account of the progress, or non progress, of affairs but I would not recommend you to take much notice of it’ (Ar 3). Despite disagreeing with the newspaper account, John Armstrong did not judge the quality of the paper. Medical doctor Alexander McKelvey, on the other hand, swiftly condemned colonial newspapers which he contrasted unfavourably with Irish publications: ‘I like the Daily Irish Times especially. It is a relief after the Dailies here. I am sending the N. Z. Herald with the notice of our marriage in it by this post. It is the best here & you will see it 92
IRISH–NEW ZEALAND CORRESPONDENCE
is a very scrappy publication not nearly so good as even the Derry papers’ (Ky 1). Only one other correspondent named an Irish newspaper. From Sligo Robert Hughes sent the Connaughtman. Only three other colonial newspapers apart from the Southern Cross and New Zealand Herald were named; they were the Lyttelton Times, the Canterbury Times, and the Press, the supplements of which James McIlrath sent to readers in Killinchy. These supplements contained ‘a summary of the news for the month in a conden[se]d form and only what I have read before’ (Il 31). In later years, postcards were also exchanged between New Zealand and Ireland. Both Agnes Lambert and Alexander McKelvey sent vistas of Auckland. ‘I have enclosed 3 Post-Cards of Auckland views’, Alexander informed his County Tyrone family in 1907. ‘You never sen[t] me any postcards of Gortin. Of course there may not be any published’ (Ky 2). In 1913 Alexander sent back panoramas of Rotorua: ‘I have sent you a Photo, of a geyser named Pohutu spouting or playing as they call it’ (Ky 3). Such physical images reinforced the textual impressions of New Zealand, and helped home readers visualise a distinctive terrain. While photographs and newspapers were frequently exchanged between family members in Ireland and New Zealand, miscellaneous other items were also sent and received, though on a less regular basis. Eight sequences feature references to such items, most of which were sent from Ireland. When James McIlrath received a book from home in 1875 he declared, ‘I have not read aneything since I left to please me like it (Bible excepted)’ (Il 24). Another book, received two years later, ‘I esteem as a pearl above price’ (Il 27). The following year Hamilton McIlrath’s family received a book, goblet, Bible, and ‘pretty socks’ (Il 28). From Tipperary, Lizzie Strong sent her cousin Daniel a handkerchief ‘as a token love and rememberance of the old times’ while her brother Martin sought curiosities from Daniel (St 4, 3). Meanwhile, gumdigger Patrick Quinn received a Christmas box from his brother in Belfast (Qu 3). Catherine Colgan exchanged albums between Antrim and Otago (Co 3). After learning of her mother’s death, Annie Dempsey warmly thanked her sister ‘for poor Mothers Hair. I hav it encased in glass. I will keep it in remembras of her as long as I live & then my children’ (De 11). Migrants did, occasionally, remit items from New Zealand to Ireland. In 1872 Edward Lysaght sent his father a watch. Edmund Lysaght’s dismissive response, however, may have made it the last gift he received from his migrant son: ‘I would lose £1 by repairing it and then it would be only worth £2 so you can see it was not worth much’ (Ly 7). In 1899 John O’Regan, writing to his niece in the United States, sent ‘a skeleton leaf and a little Fern’ (Rn 1). Four years later Annie Dempsey in Canterbury promised her sister, ‘The Dress will follow this letter by the first parcel mail that goes’ (De 11). Occasionally, the items exchanged between New Zealand and Ireland were religious tokens. These were confined to Catholic correspondents. After 93
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
receiving news of her mother’s death in Carlow, Annie Dempsey wrote in 1903 from Canterbury to her sister enclosing ‘a little picture of our ladey of good Councle’ (De 11). Sister M. Patrick wrote from the Convent of Mercy at Borrisokane, County Tipperary, to May Sullivan enclosing ‘two blessed for five scapulars’ (Fa 8). All these items helped maintain and sustain the connexions between separated kinfolk. Besides receiving gifts from home, migrants also requested items. In 1877 John Gilmore sent for an unusual mix of items: the nationalist Freeman’s Journal and Unitarian books (Ge 7). His brother Andrew, meanwhile, sent a money order to the Ards Peninsula to obtain farming implements from Ireland (Ge 12). Money was also frequently exchanged between migrants and non-migrants. William Quinn, upon learning of his brother’s ill health from his nephew in 1906, remitted a substantial amount of money: ‘I send to your father a draft for one hunderd and ten pounds. It will be in a seperad Envelope to this. £80 for your father £20 for your ant Lizzia £5 for your self £5 for my Neice Jennie’ (Qu 4). Although the Gilmer series does not contain a list of money sent from the colony, Samuel Gilmer did ask his brother William in Monaghan to ‘let me know if I am to send you another remittance’ (Gr 1). Forty years earlier in 1846, Hanora Dwyer in Dromkeen eagerly informed her son of the receipt of a ‘Five pound order’ from a mystery donor (Dw 1). Hanora also received a letter from relatives who ‘say for me never to want during my life that they will always send me relief’ (Dw 1). This may have been a strategy to prevent her son, with his large family, feeling obliged to provide financial support. Alternatively, she may have hoped such a remark would remind Cornelius of his filial duties. Sometimes migrants remitted money with a stipulation as to what the funds should be spent on. In 1875, Canterbury farmer James McIlrath sent a draft order for £25 to his parents to ‘Buy something easy to go out in’ (Il 24). The following year from Otago, David McCullough requested his parents in County Down to ‘Tell Lizzie that she may be on the look out for a silver watch. By the next mail I will send her the money for one’ (Cu 4). It is unknown whether David fulfilled his promise. From Christchurch in 1880, William Cardwell sent money to Tonaghmore with an instruction that some of it was to be used to purchase a baby’s dress. He also expressed concern as to whether his previous donation had been received (Ca 2). William Quinn likewise sought confirmation that his substantial monetary transmissions had arrived safely in Belfast: ‘Writte me when you get this and let me know if the Money has been got all wright’ (Qu 4). Occasionally, migrant offers to contribute to the household income were rebuffed, as Philip Carroll discovered during his return visit to Tipperary in 1925: When I spoke about paying my board she was going to hit me with the frying pan. ‘The idea’ she says ‘of my only son coming home from New Zealand and wanting to pay for his board in his own house’. Needless to say I did not mention it again. 94
IRISH–NEW ZEALAND CORRESPONDENCE
On the contrary Mother insists [erased: th] on my taking a loan of some money from her which I cannot do unless I am absolutely stuck. (Cl 5)
Among those remitting money from Ireland to New Zealand was Catherine Colgan. She told her son Johnny McMullan to ‘put it to good use as you know money is so easily spent’. As John had previously sent £10 home from the colony his mother may have felt some compulsion to assist him (Co 3, 4). Philip Carroll also hoped to obtain funds from family members in Ireland during his return visit there in 1925. He initially received assistance from his mother and aunt but was reluctant to request further support: ‘asking of them for a loan of money is so hard as to be almost an impossibility’ (Cl 20). Upon learning of his aunt’s wealth, however, he told his wife, ‘I never knew she had so much money and only wish she would push some of it my way’ (Cl 24). Edward Lysaght was more fortunate in securing a sizeable sum during his return to Limerick. As he predicted optimistically to his wife, ‘I think I will take something handsome back with me’ (Ly 6). Although circumstances differed, these extracts provide further support for the findings of historians who have drawn attention to migrant correspondents seeking rather than giving financial aid.9 The exchange of money provides further proof of the lengths separated kinfolk went to in order to maintain their connexions with home and provide comfort for elderly parents. Migrants who failed to fulfil these obligations received searing condemnation. William Lysaght was particularly scathing of his cousins Patrick and Catherine: ‘Is it not an awful shame to say that Patsy or Kitty dont write. The three of them have their mother working for Her living now in her old age. If they had the least shame in them they would not allow such a thing’ (Ly 2). In condemning the failure of Patrick and Catherine to perform their filial duty, William was also highlighting his own adherence to such obligations. Unlike Irish-Australian letters, however, it is difficult to ascertain whether references to old age and illness were implicit appeals for material assistance.10 From Antrim in 1901, Catherine Colgan referred to her bout of influenza and informed her daughter, ‘Your Uncle Thomas Haughey is very low. He has dropsy’ (Co 6, 7). The Hughes sequence contains details of many ailments that afflicted the ageing parents of Thomas Hughes throughout the 1920s. Seventy-four-year-old Robert Hughes informed his son, I am undergoing a course of mechanical treatment for Rh[e]umatism & stiff joints and good circulation of blood with an instrument called a ‘Pulsehaun’ and great 9 Charlotte Erickson, Invisible immigrants: the adaptation of English and Scottish immigrants in nineteenth-century America (London, 1972), p. 5; Patrick O’Farrell, Letters from Irish Australia 1825–1929 (Kensington, N.S.W., 1984), p. 133; Fitzpatrick, Oceans of consolation, pp 511–13. 10 See the discussion in Fitzpatrick, Oceans of consolation, pp 504–7.
95
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
results are following it. The inventer of the instrument went down with the ‘Titanic’ so is a rare little instrument worked on wheels with a Batt[e]ry inside that vibrates the whole frame. I have two Patients under my treatment along with myself. (Hu 9)
Several years later, Mary Hughes also announced her affliction with rheumatism (Hu 18). The exchange of letters therefore played a vital role in the maintenance of ties between separated kinfolk. Joy at the receipt of letters together with complaints about irregular communication and the hazards of delivery, testify to the importance of correspondence. Letters were, however, only one element in maintaining these connexions. The exchange of newspapers, photographs, money, and gifts all served to preserve these bonds. Having documented the emotional importance of letters for migrants and their connexions in Ireland, we can now turn to accounts of the actual voyage. Migrants drew upon the reports of the journey provided by their contacts abroad, and the descriptions supplied by correspondents of their own voyage gave intending migrants essential information about the conditions to expect on their own journey.
96
3
‘Seas may divide’ The voyage In 1876, 28-year-old John Gilmore and his 18-year-old sister Alice travelled from the Ards Peninsula, County Down, to Gravesend in Kent, where they prepared to embark as assisted passengers on the Bebington. As they were listed as a labourer and domestic servant on the shipping registers, their fare of £16 each had already been paid by the New Zealand government. Altogether, 272 passengers prepared to make the voyage on the 17-year-old ship, with the Gilmores among 135 natives of Ireland.1 The vessel’s immediate destination was Auckland, but John and Alice would eventually move on to Tauranga, where their brother Andrew had settled two years earlier. Although assisted passengers had little choice as to the vessel on which they voyaged to New Zealand, migrants were often keenly aware of a ship’s capabilities. John Gilmore ascertained details of his ship’s statistics prior to its departure: This ship is 941 tons reg’d and is 13 years old – has made several voyages with passengers with great success. She is not an extreme but of a medium size and I beli[e]ve her to be a good ship in bad weather so far as my judgment goes and I think I ought to know something about it. . . . I made a mistake about the Capt name. It is not Scott. It is Holdich. (Ge 2)
That the ship was in fact four years older than John indicated suggests that accurate information was not always obtainable. And despite his optimism, passengers would later recollect the 1876 passage of the Bebington ‘as a very grim episode in their lives’.2 Misfortune characterised the sailing from its very outset. A day after leaving Gravesend on 26 February 1876, the Bebington collided with another ship in the English Channel and had to dock at Portsmouth for repairs. The delay was later held responsible for outbreaks of disease on board after less than a week at sea. Foul weather also contributed. As the despatching officer alleged, ‘nothing but gales of wind and heavy rains prevailed and that to the constant state of damp that consequently have existed is to be attributed the generation
1 2
IM 15/263, N.A.W. Henry Brett, White wings (Christchurch, 1976; 1st ed., Auckland, 1924–8), i, 173. 97
IRISH MIGRANTS IN NEW ZEALAND, 1840–1937
of the low fever and not to any defect in the ventilation of the ship’.3 The sickness, combined with bad flour and no bread for three months, added to the discontent of the passengers. Excessive rolling of the ship, insufficient coal, and a condenser that ceased working three months after departure – and two months prior to arrival – were also documented by the surgeon superintendent.4 It is not surprising that such conditions instigated a potential revolt, provoking the captain to comment, ‘The passengers as a body have been exceedingly troublesome, and I shall have occasion to prosecute several on our arrival in Auckland.’5 Disputes between the ship’s officers and passengers were later attributed to the officers’ ‘endeavouring to keep order, and enforce cleanliness and discipline’.6 John Gilmore proved himself a capable, diligent passenger. At the height of the fever he was the only individual to volunteer for nursing duty. In recognition of this action, Captain Holdich recommended that John be paid £2 10s, being one month’s wages.7 Coping in such trying circumstances cannot have been easy for, as John later wrote, 17 died and strange to say that 2 of the young men that went from Belfast was the first that died and 2 Brothers. There name was Trassy. Robert seen them in Belfast. We had very good passage but long and at times looked very hard when our fellow passengers and country men were going overboard so often and did not of course know when it would come our turn but thank Him it has not come yet.8 (Ge 6)
The full ext