Invisible
Work Borges and Translation Efraín Kristal
Invisible Work
Invisible
Work
Borges and Translation
EFRAÍN...
185 downloads
2629 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Invisible
Work Borges and Translation Efraín Kristal
Invisible Work
Invisible
Work
Borges and Translation
EFRAÍN KRISTAL
VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY PRESS
Nashville
© 2002 Vanderbilt University Press All rights reserved First Edition 2002 This book is printed on acid-free paper. Manufactured in the United States of America
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Kristal, Efraín, 1959Invisible work : Borges and translation / Efraín Kristal.— 1st ed. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN
0-8265-1407-3 (cloth : alk. paper)
ISBN
0-8265-1408-1 (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Borges, Jorge Luis, 1899—Criticism and
interpretation. 2. Borges, Jorge Luis, 1899—Views on translating and interpreting. 3. Translating and interpreting. 4. Borges, Jorge Luis, 1899—Translations—History and criticism. I. Title. PQ7797.B635 Z77155
2002
868'.6209—dc21 2002002607
To Christopher Maurer, one of the happy few
Contents
Acknowledgments Introduction
1
ix xi
Borges on Translation
1
The Translatable and Untranslatable 3 On the Translation of His Own Works 11 The Arnold-Newman Discussion 19 On the Arabian Nights 25 Borges’s Doctrine of Translation 30
2
Borges as Translator
36
German Expressionism 41 Whitman and the Translation of Poetry 46 Poe 60 Reyes and Chesterton 67 Translating Names and Titles 70 Borges’s Arabian Stories 71 Kafka, the Fragment, and the Dream 74 The Prose Edda 79 Borges’s Method As Translator
3
86
Translation in the Creative Process “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius” 89 “The Immortal” 98 “Death and the Compass” 103 “Emma Zunz” 111 “Garden of Forking Paths” 113 “The Circular Ruins” 116 “The Writing of the God” 122
88
“The Lottery in Babylon” 124 Original Work as Translation 130 Toward a Poetics of Borges’s Oeuvre 134
Conclusion
135
Afterword: Borges and Philosophy
141
Notes
147
Bibliography Index
191 205
viii
Acknowledgments
I first presented my ideas on Borges and translation in a conference held at the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, organized by Guillermo Guicci in 1996. I continued discussing various aspects of my ongoing research in lectures and conferences in Peru, Australia, Germany, and the United States, as well as in graduate seminars at UCLA, Vanderbilt University, and the University of Göttingen during my tenure as Mercator Visiting Research Professor. In Göttingen I profited from conversations with Professors Manfred Engelbert and Armin Paul Frank. For five years during my research I received annual grants from UCLA’s Faculty Senate with which I enlisted the assistance of several graduate students to gather materials and to prepare aspects of the manuscript for publication: Kelly Austin, Nataly Tcherepashenets, Zaia Alexander, Philip Walsh, Kirsten Mcleary, and Susan Bausch. I would like to express my gratitude to several individuals for their support during this project and for their valuable advice and counsel: Herbert Morris, Charles Backus, Randal Johnson, Dietrich Briesemeister, Karsten Garscha, Alexander Coleman, Roy Boland, Roberto Alifano, Dominic Thomas, Kathleen Komar, Franco Betti, Kryztof Urban, Cathy Jrade, Marcelo Abadi, Erick Felinto de Oliveira, Jorge Wanderley, Carmela Zanelli, Susanne Grosse, José Luiz Passos, Jonathan Post, H. A. Kelly, Suzanne Jill Levine, and Saúl and Gladis Yurkievich. I also would like to offer my gratitude to the wonderful staff at Vanderbilt University Press and to Bard Young for his superb editorial work.
ix
x
Invisible Work
María Kodama, Borges’s widow, graciously met with me on two occasions in Buenos Aires to discuss the translation works on which she and her late husband collaborated. She also gave me permission to look at many books that belonged to Borges and that contain his marginalia. In order to study Borges’s translation of Snorri Sturluson’s Prose Edda, I audited Professor Jesse Byock’s Old Norse language course at UCLA for a year. Subsequently, Professor Byock allowed me to quote from the manuscript of his translation of the Edda (forthcoming at Penguin Press) and was generous in his willingness to answer many queries. Nicolás Helft allowed me to read unpublished letters, rare publications, and manuscripts (including the manuscript of an unpublished translation of a story by Martin Buber) at the San Telmo Foundation in Buenos Aires. Marcelo Gilardoni of the Argentine Consulate in Los Angeles assisted me in the acquisition of microfilm copies of rare materials held at the National Library of Argentina, including the journal Revista Multicolor and Borges’s first translation of Oscar Wilde’s “The Happy Prince,” which appeared in the Buenos Aires newspaper El País (1910). Special thanks go to Romy Sutherland for her support and generous willingness to read, discuss, and improve countless versions of the manuscript. Alberto Cordero and Christopher Maurer are responsible for many improvements in this book. As in previous works, I have relied on their frank, constructive observations; and I write in the hope of meeting their exacting standards. This book is dedicated to Christopher Maurer as a token of my admiration for his contributions as literary critic and translator.
Introduction Immortals have, generally, another destiny. The details of their feelings or thoughts tend to vanish or lie invisibly in their work. —Jorge Luis Borges
O
n September 5, 1953, the author of Fictions and The Aleph wrote a letter to settle the final details of a lecture he would deliver on the Kabbalah. Almost as an afterthought, Jorge Luis Borges offers biographical information requested by his host. After indicating his birth in Buenos Aires in 1899, he introduces himself as the translator of Franz Kafka, Virginia Woolf, William Faulkner, and Henri Michaux.1 The note continues with other aspects of his literary activities, but Borges puts forward his translations before mentioning any of the titles that established his renown as a towering figure of contemporary literature. Borges is best known as a spellbinding fabulist whose literary works often require the creative complicity of his readers—not merely their suspension of disbelief—to produce the sense that a window has been opened onto singular worlds of fiction with a logic of their own. He disconcerts and beguiles with the same conceits. His preposterous situations and impossible objects have the air of the credible, and his characters, usually unendearing and sometimes endowed with extraordinary attributes, are intriguing, if not outright compelling. Borges writes with such aplomb and understated confidence, that he has persuaded readers as demanding as George
xi
xii
Invisible Work
Steiner, Umberto Eco, and Harold Bloom, that they are entering a literary world of momentous significance. Borges is also one of the greatest Latin American poets of the twentieth century. He has shaped an unmistakable lyrical persona who oscillates between the uncanny aperçu and the disarming confession, while producing lines that have enriched the Spanish language. The recent publication of his Selected Non-Fictions (edited by Eliot Weinberger and splendidly translated by Weinberger, Esther Allen, and Suzanne Jill Levine) revealed to an English reading public that Borges is also one of the most engaging essayists of modern literature. For the Hispanic world Borges’s contributions must also include his major anthologies and the collections of translated novels he edited: he introduced fantastic and detective fiction to Spanish American readers, as well as the first Spanish versions of contemporary novelists such as James Joyce, Joseph Conrad, Virginia Woolf, and William Faulkner. Borges wrote a book on Buddhism, as well as eventful essays on the Kabbalah and Chinese literature, and is also responsible for the first history of Old English and Germanic literatures written in the Spanish language. As the critic José Miguel Oviedo has noted, “Borges incorporated a literary culture almost alien to Spanish American literature and that, thanks to him, is now a part of its tradition.”2 His influence on the distinguished Mexican writer Salvador Elizondo makes the point, but Elizondo is not the only major Latin American who embarked on a life of letters after reading Borges.3 His paramount influence on contemporary Latin American fiction—acknowledged by Carlos Fuentes, Mario Vargas Llosa, Gabriel García Márquez, Octavio Paz, and many others—would itself warrant a book-length treatment.4 Borges must also be reckoned a central writer in the context of Argentine literature. Many of his writings require a deep knowledge of the local context, and in seminal essays and anthologies on national themes, he played a decisive role in shaping the contemporary understanding of Argentine literary history. Moreover, he was also a beloved professor of English literature at the University of Buenos Aires, a dazzling conversationalist, and an enthralling lecturer. Notwithstanding his achievement as fabulist, poet, essayist, edi-
Introduction
xiii
tor, anthologist, and specialist of English and Argentine literature, Borges committed no injustice to himself by foregrounding his translations. Indeed, translation played a major role in every one of his literary endeavors, and it was his conviction that some of the most cherished pleasures of literature become available only after a work has passed through many hands and undergone many changes. In his presentation of himself as a translator, one senses the reserved pride of a powerful literary mind able to appropriate and transform what is presumably already present without seemingly changing anything. Borges might have projected his delight in the secret achievement of translation onto some of his most memorable characters: Jaromir Hladík, who was offered a miraculous instant that lasts the time required to finish a play no one will ever read; or the protagonist of “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius,” who translates a Spanish version of Sir Thomas Browne’s Urn Burial not intended for publication; or Tzinacan, who deciphers the highest mystery of his religion and chooses to let it die with him; or Pierre Menard, who writes a few pages of prose syntactically identical with passages from Don Quixote. Borges’s testy narrator hails Menard’s Don Quixote as a masterpiece and calls it an “invisible work,” that is, an unnoticed achievement overshadowed and obscured by another work it has surpassed. Moved by that hyperbole, George Steiner calls Borges’s story “the most acute, most concentrated commentary anyone has offered on the business of translation.”5 In his consideration of Borges, Steiner argues that “a true translator knows his labor belongs ‘to oblivion’ (inevitably, each generation retranslates), or ‘to the other one,’ his occasion, begetter, and precedent shadow.”6 In his own essays, Borges was fond of celebrating unnoticed literary achievements he called secret or invisible. In the preface to his translation of Stevenson’s Fables, for example, Borges calls the work “a brief and secret masterpiece.”7 The purpose of this book is to demonstrate that translation, not as a loose metaphor for influence or intertextuality, but as a process whereby a writer remodels one sequence of words into another, is central to Borges’s reflections on writing and to his contribution to
xiv
Invisible Work
literature. It is well known that Borges was a translator, but this activity has been considered a minor aspect—a mere curiosity—of his literary achievement. In an essay that played a significant role in his reception, Paul de Man lamented that Borges, a brilliant writer and translator of American literature, was not better known in the United States: “Although he has been writing poems, stories, and critical essays of the highest quality since 1923, the Argentine writer Jorge Luis Borges is still much better known in Latin America than in the U.S. For the translator of John Peale Bishop, Hart Crane, E.E. Cummings, William Faulkner, Edgar Lee Masters, Robert Penn Warren, and Wallace Stevens, this neglect is somewhat unfair.”8 Since de Man wrote this article in 1964, Borges has become universally acknowledged as a central figure of twentieth-century literature, but his work as translator is still considered a marginal aspect of his curriculum. Translation, however, is inseparable from the fiber of those works once so little known in the United States and now so widely received. As Roger Callois pointed out some time ago, The Universal History of Infamy, Borges’s first book of prose fiction, includes a series of stories that are actually loose translations of nonfictional texts depicting the lives of criminals and outlaws.9 Callois noticed that Borges recreated and transformed his originals at will. This clue has been ignored in the vast amount of literary criticism devoted to Borges’s most celebrated works. And yet Borges’s translations, and his reflections on translation, are invariably at the core of his creative process. Borges once wrote that the “feelings or thoughts [of great writers] tend to vanish or lie invisibly in their work.”10 The purpose of this book is to make visible Borges’s creativity as translator. Borges wrote famously that “no problem is as consubstantial to literature and its modest mystery as the one posed by translation.” One could add that no activity, other than reading, has been more central to his creative process than translation.11 There is no better vantage point from which to appreciate his creation and recreation of literature. My approach was anticipated by Jaime Alazraki when he argued,
Introduction
xv
in a seminal article, that Borges’s most characteristic literary practice lies in creative recreation of works he read.12 I was also encouraged in my work by the scholarship of Ronald Christ, John T. Irwin, and Daniel Balderston. They have deftly unearthed rich layers of reference and allusion.13 And I would like to praise the brilliant work of Michel Lafon who has demonstrated how relentlessly Borges rewrote and copied ideas, sentences, and entire passages from his own writings as he fashioned new ones.14 In this study I share the belief that contextual approaches enhance our understanding of Borges’s writing.15 My work is intended to analyze the significance of translation in Borges, an area that has not been explored, either systematically or with much clarity. To date, the most significant contribution to the study of Borges and translation is a chapter from Annick Louis’s sedulously researched Jorge Luis Borges: Oeuvres et manœuvres, in which she offers an impressive account of Borges’s views on translation. Louis demonstrates convincingly that, for Borges, a translation is not inherently inferior to its original, but she is mistaken in attributing to Borges the view that it is impossible to “establish a hierarchy between the two.”16 Louis is not interested in making aesthetic value judgments in her literary analysis, but Borges was in his. Depending on the specific case, he at times favored a translation over its original, other times an original over its translation, and he was often interested in weighing their relative merits, aesthetic and otherwise. Louis is one of the few literary critics to notice that Borges sometimes corrected his own translations from publication to publication, but she does not indicate that in his translations Borges often corrected the originals and that those corrections bear on the gestation of his most celebrated literary works. The main purpose of this book is to offer an account of the role translation played in Borges’s creative process. The connections I will draw between Borges’s practice as a translator and his writings do not hinge on any radical epistemological assumptions.17 Borges’s fictional world, which has engaged both deconstructionists and analytical philosophers alike, is hospitable to a variety of approaches. Not all of his stories are philosophical, but even in those that are,
xvi
Invisible Work
Borges’s literary contributions are not contingent on his philosophical coherence or even on his appeal to philosophers of different persuasions, but rather, as Juan Nuño has urged, on his genius for transforming “the most schematic and stiff of philosophical topics into animated tales, and vivid descriptions of fantastic worlds.”18 Indeed, Borges was fundamentally a fabulist.19 My purpose, therefore, is not to examine the metaphysical content of Borges’s writings nor to indicate that his literary world has affinities or discordances with this or that philosophical, political, or cultural approach to literature. I offer an unapologetically literary study of Borges’s engagements with the works he transformed. I am not interested in confirming the global tenants of any literary theory with examples drawn from the Borges canon, but in underscoring the pivotal role translation plays in the gestation of his literary world. Borges was interested in translation as a means of enhancing a work because the work mattered more to him than its author. Since my objective is to offer insights into Borges’s art, I am most interested in translation as it informs his ideas about literature and his creative process. My method, therefore, differs sharply from Borges’s. For Borges translation was a means to enrich a literary work or a literary idea. For me translation provides a way of understanding his oeuvre. I take guidance here, as I have in previous works, from Richard Wollheim’s recommendation that the scrutiny of a literary work ought to include an attempt to reconstruct the creative process. A work of art is, at least in part, the result of a problem-solving operation that can often be mapped: works of art show traces of design, error, changes of intention, and accident. The inevitable rewriting of previous works of art in any individual work is also central to Wollheim’s doctrine of criticism as retrieval: “[The artist] will assemble his elements in ways that self-consciously react against, or overtly presuppose, arrangements that have already been tried out within the tradition.”20 Wollheim’s approach complements Gombrich’s suggestion that the study of a work of art should pay as much attention to the repertoire of the artist as to the finished product.
Introduction
xvii
To understand the possibilities and the choices involved in the creation of a painting, for example, Gombrich would recommend the study of the artist’s palette. Translation figures prominently in Borges’s palette. A significant number of his literary works can be read as solutions to problems resolved in the process of translation or as responses to works he translated. One can trace many of his artistic decisions to the changes he made to works he translated and to the ways in which he incorporated his translations, or his ideas about translation, into the fabric of his fictions. In short, Borges’s translations offer insights into his creative process, and into the workings of his imgaination. Harold Bloom said of Shakespeare that his own powerful imagination erased the status of his antecedents as influences. Rather than “erase” the status of his antecedents as influences, Borges often reorients and sometimes deflates them. In some cases the deficiencies, gaps, and unfulfilled potentialities in the writers he translated were not recognized until Borges engaged with their works. Some of the fictional possibilities Borges foregrounds in his involvements with the work of others may have been available to the writers whose works he translated, and some of them may not have been. Either way, Borges does not leave the majority of his precursors untouched the way most writers do when rewriting aspects of literary works that inspired them. When, for instance, he incorporated his recreation of Poe’s “The Purloined Letter” as an ingredient in his own story “La muerte y la brújula” (“Death and the Compass”). Borges shows by example that Poe never combined detective fiction, a genre he invented, with the fantastic, a genre he mastered.21 Borges is not just rewriting Poe; he is underscoring a possibility in Poe’s writings that Poe never explored. Borges’s transformations amount to a critical practice that, at its most productive, invites readers of literature to reconsider their views about the writers with which Borges engaged himself. According to Borges’s own doctrine of literary influence (generously acknowledged by Harold Bloom), a new work of literature invents its precursors, preparing future readers to identify features that could not have been recognized when the work was written, as when
xviii
Invisible Work
Melville’s “Bartleby the Scrivener,” which Borges translated, is reread as Kafkaesque. This book is intended to make a literary rather than a biographical statement about Borges, but it will draw on some aspects of his personal and intellectual biography that offer insights into his views and methods with respect to translation.22 Borges’s mature views on translation came together in the 1930s (remaining fairly constant ever since), when he abandoned two positions he had considered seriously and in some cases defended vehemently. The first is the idea that literature is fundamentally autobiographical and that its ultimate significance is lost on those who ignore the circumstances of individual authors. The second, which he sometimes related to the first, is the view that literature is the expression of a nationality or a national character. Borges was so embarrassed by these and other views he held in the 1920s—and perhaps also by the baroque language in which he expressed them—that he refused to reissue his first three books of essays in which he had held those views in good steed.23 His friends reported that over the years he would buy any copies of those books he could find in order to destroy them. From Borges’s early period he salvaged his metaphysical bent— or at least the certainty that metaphysics offered him rich literary possibilities—and many of his literary preferences, including his passion for Walt Whitman and his admiration for Sir Thomas Browne, even as he reconsidered their significance. The experience of reevaluating his interpretations of writers he continued to cherish may have had a role to play in the skepticism he developed with respect to interpretation: his belief that interpretation is a secondary, sometimes even an irrelevant practice that can be happily forsaken by those who truly appreciate literature without subterfuges. Given a choice, he preferred to discuss literary effects rather than the meaning of literary works; and he could not countenance any talk about literary theory that did not address the craft of writing. Borges never abandoned altogether the view that personal circumstances can be a relevant factor in the discussion of a literary work, but since the 1930s the individuality of the writer played an ever-diminishing role in his observations on literature, especially
Introduction
xix
when compared to the impersonal and collective factors of the literary experience. In this context Borges developed a view on translation in which an original work does not harbor an advantage over a translation. The work, for Borges, became a collective enterprise that carries more weight than the input of any individual author, reader, or translator. It is also in this context that Borges developed a way of writing fiction informed by his own approach to translation: a way of writing that willfully adopts, transforms, and adapts the works of others.24 There is yet a third period in Borges’s life that must be addressed in the discussion of those aspects of his biography that have a bearing on his views and methods of translation. That period can be dated from 1960, when he lost his ability to read due to a congenital eye disease that led progressively to his blindness. From the 1960s until the end of his life, he could no longer correct manuscripts, drafts, or proofs by himself, and required assistance in the writing process. Before losing his sight, he had collaborated on many translations, but after the 1960s collaboration became a necessity. He also began to compose shorter pieces of prose and poetry in his mind. As he continued to stress the impersonal aspects of literature, he became increasingly interested in sharpening his literary receptivity to such an extent that he felt more comfortable speaking of himself as a reader than as a writer. And yet, his output as a writer was prolific; he continued to publish an impressive number of essays, poems, narrative fictions, and translations. In fact, the last major book he published in his lifetime was a translation of Snorri Sturluson’s Prose Edda, a work in which Borges was at the height of his powers. In his translation he transformed the single most important source of Nordic mythology imbuing it with his most enduring literary concerns. T RANSLATION LOOMS so large in Borges’s work that an exhaustive treatment is neither possible nor desirable in a short book whose aim is to stress its central role in Borges’s craft, a role not yet fully grasped or even acknowledged in the massive body of scholarship devoted to his writings. Of the several essays on Borges’s transla-
xx
Invisible Work
tions, the more instructive ones appreciate stylistic features in the language of those works. But the standard view that Borges wrote faithful translations that sometimes improved the style of the originals needs correction. Some of Borges’s translations are faithful but many are not, and the idea that Borges “required of a translator a rigorous identification with the original,” expressed by many critics with the intention of honoring him, is both mistaken and unintentionally misleading. For Borges translation was a creative process.25 Even though Nestor Ibarra never developed the idea with textual analysis, he made plain the pertinence of translation for Borges better than anybody else: “Here is a man of letters interested in the problem of translation, and when he has two admirable works in front of him, one inspired by the other, all he finds is the happy opportunity to reshape his eternal mask.”26 My analysis of Borges’s translations will show that his strategies as a creative writer have much in common with his methods as a translator but that the two overlapping writing practices are not coextensive. As a creative writer and as a translator, Borges took many liberties in his transformations of other literary works, but his translations remain identifiable reflections of the originals while the literary works he signed as his own are not that at all. His translations transform his originals into drafts that precede them; his own literary works transform his readings into a repertoire of possibilities in which his own translations, and his views about translation, play a decisive role. In this book I will describe Borges’s views on translation, his practice as translator, and the pivotal role of translation in his creative process. For heuristic reasons I will treat these topics in three separate chapters whose themes will sometimes overlap. Chapter 1 is an account of Borges’s ideas about translation, which amount to an original contribution to literary theory and criticism. Chapter 2 studies Borges’s methods as a translator by analyzing a number of his versions from poetry and narrative fiction in which he took liberties as he translated the originals. Chapter 3 explores the role of translation in some of his most important works of narrative fiction. I will discuss translation as a literary theme in Borges’s fic-
Introduction
xxi
tions, especially because many of his principal literary characters are translators and many of his stories are presented as imagined translations. I will also analyze a number of Borges’s translations in the gestation and construction of his literary world. Along the way we will visit many of Borges’s fictions, poems, essays, conferences, interviews, and letters and explore numerous real and apocryphal translations that inform his approach to literature. I underscore the richness of the topic for readers of Borges whose own views and interpretations might be enhanced or refined by the knowledge that translation played a central role in his literary concerns and in the very content of his literary works. I see translation as more central to Borges’s literature than the celebrated labyrinths, mirrors, tigers, and encyclopedias that abound in his literary world. NOTE:
In many essays where Borges compared translations from languages other than Spanish, the Argentine writer would actually quote his Spanish versions as if they were originals. Often, he would say that he was “copying” rather than “quoting” to indicate that he was offering a Spanish text of a foreign work. Borges justified his procedure in as much as the features he wanted to underscore in his comparisons were not affected by the transfer of one language to another. Borges was also fond of comparing translations, in this manner, of works he could not read in the original. He wrote several essays, for example, in which he compared Homeric translations from English in his Spanish “copies.” In chapter 1 I will explain the notion of “copying” in the context of my account of his views on translation. In the sections of this book comparing Borges’s translations into Spanish from English, I will offer my own English versions of Borges’s translations in the body of the work and will include Borges’s Spanish versions in the endnotes. In my comparisons of Borges’s translations from foreign languages (German, French, Italian, and Old Norse), I will also include the foreign language originals in the endnotes. The majority of the transformations that I highlight involve elisions or interpolations rather than linguistic differences be-
xxii
Invisible Work
tween languages. It is quite possible to appreciate, in my English versions, the aspects of Borges’s translations that I will discuss in this book. Scholars who may be interested in checking the foreign language originals, or readers who know any of the foreign languages involved, can look to the endnotes for all of the originals. Finally, I would like to stress that this book is not intended to be a comprehensive review of all of Borges’s translations, or of the significance of translation in each of his creative works where it plays a role. My purpose is to underscore the significance of translation in Borges’s oeuvre, rather than to offer an exhaustive treatment of this rich topic. It is my hope that many more discussions of Borges’s writings will take note of his translations and of his ideas with respect to the practice of translation as an approach to literary creation.
Invisible Work
chapter 1
Borges on Translation It must be visible, or invisible, Invisible or visible or both. —Wallace Stevens
B
orges affirmed, in earnest, that an original can be unfaithful to a translation. He vehemently objected to claims that certain translations he admired are “true to the original” and derided the presuppositions of purists for whom all translations are necessarily deceitful in one way or another. Borges would often protest, with various degrees of irony, against the assumption—ingrained in the Italian adage traduttore traditore—that a translator is a traitor to an original. He referred to it alternatively as a superstition or pun. For Borges the Italian expression, unfairly prejudiced in favor of the original, is an erroneous generalization that conflates difference with treachery. The idea that literary translations are inherently inferior to their originals is, for Borges, based on the false assumption that some works of literature must be assumed definitive. But for Borges, no such thing as a definitive work exists, and therefore, a translator’s inevitable transformation of the original is not necessarily to the detriment of the work. Difference, for Borges, is not a sufficient criterion for the superiority of the original. Those who demand that a translated text be different from the original and yet reproduce the original’s every nuance and detail assume that a work of literature has some sort of religious or legal status, as if a literary work were like the Bible, a sacred text dic1
2
Invisible Work
tated to “copyists by the Holy Spirit.”1 Those for whom an original work has the status of scripture might assume that the alteration of a single detail of the literary work (such as the numerical value that the kabbalists attribute to every Hebrew letter) is akin to mutilating a binding clause in a legal document. In a sense they would hold the literary translator up to an impossible, misleading standard. A translation cannot be identical to its original and claim to be a translation, and the differences between a translation and its original are not necessarily betrayals. A legal clause is not mutilated when a translator finds appropriate equivalencies for the sake of judicial clarity; and the literary qualities of a work are not mutilated when a translator modifies the original to reproduce artistic effects that would otherwise be lost. For Borges, condemning a literary translation because it is not identical to the original is as unfair as condemning the translation of a contract because its equivalencies are not literary. A translator rewrites a sequence of words with a different sequence of words. The unavoidable changes that any translation presents vis-à-vis its original are, in and of themselves, insufficient grounds for claiming a translation is either dishonest or inferior to the original. Borges was certain that a translation could enrich or surpass an original and that one of the most fertile of all literary experiences is a comparative survey of the versions of a work. Borges thought of the original as a text produced not by a superior being but by a fallible human, a text laden with possibilities and potentialities, attainments and failures. Borges, for whom a translation “is a variation one is justified in attempting,”2 would have few scruples about editing the original as he translated. A good translator, according to him, might choose to treat the original as a good writer treats a draft of a work in progress. In fact, for Borges, the translators of a work may be more beneficial to the work than its author, not because they have a superior literary sense but because their lack of vested interest in the text as it was published makes them more effective as editors: “It is far easier to forgo someone else’s vanities than one’s own.”3 According to Borges translators should be willing to cut, add, and transform for the sake of the work. The process can be as endless in a translation as in the creation of
Borges on Translation
3
an original. In the preface to his translation of Paul Valéry’s “Le Cemetière Marin,” Nestor Ibarra makes a comment that Borges would appreciate: “my translation is infinitely perfectible, since it is the first.”4 Ibarra, who appears as a character in Borges’s fictional world, was also one of his first translators into French. In his translations of Borges’s stories and poems Ibarra took many liberties welcomed by his old friend. Borges, who admired Ibarra’s translation of Paul Valéry more than the original, might endorse the claim that the first translation of a work can be thought of as a starting point for further improvements, but he might add that the potential to ameliorate a draft should not be taken as an argument against publication, because correcting drafts is a never ending process. Borges was fond of quoting Alfonso Reyes, who would say, “We publish because otherwise we would spend our lives going over our drafts.”5 That being said, Borges would often make changes to existing published works when they were reprinted. Thanks to Jean Pierre Bernès’s remarkable French Pléiade edition of Borges’s Oeuvre—the first extensive account of Borges’s transformations of his own works (offering rich bibliographical information indicating the original publication of many works)—we can begin to appreciate the full extent of his revisions.6 Just as Borges revised his original works, including the contents of his books, from edition to edition, he also revised some of his own translations when published in new contexts.
The Translatable and Untranslatable Borges knew it could be difficult to transfer the meaning of each word of an original in translation and did not think it desirable to do so when translating a work of literature (“literal translations are not literary”).7 He recognized that in translation some aspects of an original will disappear, but he did not consider those losses necessarily undesirable. He knew that it might be impossible to render a text with the same grammatical qualities, rhythms, and rhymes and that it might be miraculous to find identical meanings, connotations, and associations when one substitutes one word for another. Borges acknowledged the commonplace idea that “a good poem is
4
Invisible Work
always untranslatable,” if by translate one means to replicate the original, maintaining all characteristics and nuances.8 It is also untranslatable if what matters in poetry “is essentially in the intonation, in a certain way of breathing a phrase.”9 Borges became increasingly interested, especially after 1960 when he lost his sight, in poetic lines that provoked emotional effects in him, even before he understood their meaning, on account of the connotations and even the arbitrary associations of words. In some cases, as in Quevedo’s famous line “Y su epitafio, la sangrienta luna” (literally, “and his epitaph, the bloody moon”), Borges felt that the power of a poetic line can be impoverished by its immediate context or by interpretation.10 One of the compensations for his blindness was his memorized anthology of poetic lines, in several languages, which he considered “unique and eternal,” lines which, in or out of context, gave him a joy that had more to do with associations than with meanings,11 for example Gerard Manley Hopkins’s line “Mastering me God, giver of breath and bread.” If translators aim to convey the approximate sense of that which is untranslatable, their works “are a means and a stimulus to bring the reader close to the original.”12 Borges would differentiate between what he called “the language of ideas” and “the language of emotions.” He maintained that in literary translation ideas raise no significant difficulties, while emotions suggested by words raise problems that are almost insurmountable. Certain works, therefore, afford pleasures lost in translation. A writer like Shakespeare cannot be successfully translated into a foreign language, even into modern English, because “in an English that is not Shakespeare’s many things would be lost.” But with regard to the translation of ideas, he could feel deeply affected by a production of Macbeth in a horrible translation, with bad actors, and misguided scenery.13 Umberto Eco utilizes a similar dichotomy to compare the contributions of Borges to those of Joyce (“the two contemporary authors I have most loved and who most influenced me.”)14 Eco calls Borges a “delirious archivist” whose own experimentations, as opposed to those of Joyce, take place at the level of ideas, not language. Whereas Joyce treated language as a “jeu de massacre,” Borges played with ideas, “letting words insinuate new and unexpected horizons.”15 According to Eco, Borges is at his most
Borges on Translation
5
conservative in his own writing when it comes to the organization of sounds in literature, and at his most experimental when it comes to ideas. Eco’s insight can be applied to Borges’s views on translation, with the caveat that for Borges a text is untranslatable not because it is conventional or experimental at the level of language but because its conjunction of cadences and associations are not transferable. Borges would often compare two literal versions of the same text and argue that the emotion of one was lost in the other: “A cadence is akin to the cipher of an emotion. Two lines may be conceptually identical but not emotionally; intellectually they may be the same, but not emotively.”16 In his commentary on Salas Subirat’s translation of Joyce’s Ulysses, a novel he considered failed, tedious, and chaotic, Borges insists on its moments of “verbal perfection.” At times Borges referred to Ulysses as an almost impossible challenge to a translator, by which he meant it would be impossible to render all of Joyce’s verbal experiments into any other language.17 On other occasions he denied that the novel was untranslatable, recommending that it be used as a pretext for the creation of another work. For Borges some works of literature are more translatable than others, but no work of literature is untranslatable in principle, because a translator can always take the necessary liberties to achieve what any creative writer should strive for: a convincing work of literature. As a reader of literature Borges seeks a hedonistic response that involves either perceptual pleasures, as with his response to Joyce’s language, or mind-enhancing satisfactions, as with his response to a Shakespeare play in a poor translation.18 Borges was famous for encouraging his students of English literature at the University of Buenos Aires to read what gave them pleasure and to avoid what did not. It is not necessary, however, to scratch too deeply beneath his hedonistic pronouncements— and sometimes not necessary to scratch at all—to notice that his own judgments about the merits of a translation involve an interplay of relativistic and objectivistic criteria that also inform his general views about literature as an art. Borges is a relativist in as much as he delights in the liberties a translator can take in transforming one text into another. But he is an objectivist in as much as he rejects some translations when those liberties do not produce a text
6
Invisible Work
that meets his aesthetic standards. As an objectivist Borges was persuaded that the cadences and arbitrary associations of words in certain combinations warrant the claim of “verbal perfection,” and that some literary works are more successful than others in producing literary effects. As a relativist, he endorsed transformations and misprisions, and did not mind if ideas and other aspects of an original were either eliminated or transformed in translation. His objectivistic and relativistic standards converge in his conviction that original works do not have, in principle, any advantage over translations from the perspective of their literary merits. Borges does not rule out the unlikely eventuality that a translator might be able to reproduce all the relevant features that characterize a particular work; and at the same time, he recognizes that the most concentrated efforts of a poet, exploiting the unique possibilities of a particular language, may be impossible to translate. However, those linguistic aspects that cannot be reproduced in translation do not cause Borges any more anxiety than the fact that a paraphrase is never identical with its original. In general one paraphrases to underscore certain features of a text while ignoring others, and one generally translates to underscore certain aspects of an original while downplaying others. All the same, an “untranslatable” text remains “translatable” for Borges because it is always “possible to recreate the work, to take the text as a pretext.”19 Where the cadences of the original are lost, the translator may be able to find new cadences that did not exist in the original. In short, for Borges, the poetry of ideas can always be translated in such a way that the original and the translation amount to the “same” text, and the poetry of emotions can be translated also, as a recreation: “[Poetry] can always be translated as long as the translator forgoes either scientific or philological precision.”20 Ultimately, for Borges, the decision as to whether a text is translatable or untranslatable depends not on theoretical but on practical considerations: on whether a translator is able to recreate the text in such a way that it produces a gratifying literary effect. Borges made many general observations about the practice of translation, but he limited judgment on whether a particular work was translatable or untranslatable to his examination of specific cases:
Borges on Translation
7
I believe Benedetto Croce held that a poem is untranslatable, but that it can be recreated in another language. In good logic, it would suffice to have a single well-translated line to refute his assertion. Everything depends on what one means by “well translated.” As for myself, I am a nominalist. I defy abstract affirmations and I prefer to concentrate on particular cases.21 Borges agrees with those who claim that “each language has its own possibilities and impossibilities” but does not draw the inference that a translator is doomed to failure.22 On the contrary, he affirms that the differences between languages and modes of expression offer multiple possibilities to a translator whose aim is to recreate the original. In his insightful commentary on the short story “La busca de Averroes” (“Averroës’ Search”), Marcelo Abadi summarizes Borges’s view that for “a man of letters it is not so terrible to make a mistake in a translation, and it is not so dramatic that there are no strict correspondences between languages.”23 In fact, for Borges the “mistakes” of a translator or the lack of strict correspondences between languages can favor as much as they can play against any particular translation, or any section of a translation. In the case of poetic lines like those of Quevedo and Hopkins quoted above, it makes no sense for Borges to fault a translator for failing to render what cannot be rendered. But such moments of literary concentration are rare in the work of any poet, and they are not the sole province of an original. Indeed, a translation may sparkle in passages where the original falls short. Borges would agree with George Steiner’s contention that a translation can tap into potentialities unrealized in the original, precisely because the linguistic differences or incompatibilities between two modes of expression may bring forth aspects of the work that would be obscured in the language of the original. In a 1934 essay on the forthcoming English translation of Don Segundo Sombra (Argentina’s most celebrated novel about the life of the gaucho), Borges indicated that he was able to observe clearly what he had not noticed in the Spanish original, that the Argentine novel is intimately related to Mark Twain’s Huckleberry Finn: “Go-
8
Invisible Work
ing through the English version of Don Segundo, I have continually perceived the gravitational pull and the accents of another essential book of our America: Mark Twain’s Huckleberry Finn.”24 Borges says he examined the translation with Adelina del Carril (Güiraldes’s widow) in galley proofs. He attributes the English translation of Don Segundo Sombra to a collaborative effort between Federico de Onís, a celebrated professor of Hispanic studies, and Waldo Frank, the American essayist and novelist who had friendly relations with Borges’s literary circle in Buenos Aires.25 Borges says that Onís produced a version that eliminated the localisms of the text and that Waldo Frank transformed the draft into a work of literature. Borges’s account may be a fabrication or a mistake since the translation, which includes a prologue by Waldo Frank, was not signed by Federico de Onís but by his wife Harriet de Onís, the author of many important translations into English from both Spanish and Portuguese, including Borges’s story “La escritura del dios” (“The Writing of the God”) published in Labyrinths. Borges does not indicate whether he assisted those responsible for the English version after reading the proofs, but his observation about the affinities between Huckleberry Finn and Don Segundo Sombra was taken up by Waldo Frank in his introduction when the novel was published in New York in 1935: “Don Segundo Sombra occupies in Argentine letters a place not unrelated to that of Huckleberry Finn in ours.”26 Years later Borges feigned that the original comparison between the American and the Argentine novels was Waldo Frank’s, not his own. He wrote that Frank “established an identical parallelism between Don Segundo Sombra and Huck Finn.”27 Since Borges may have assisted in the translation, one wonders if he discovered the affinities between Mark Twain’s novel and Güiraldes’s as he was reading the galley proofs, or whether he was responsible for suggesting the connections between them in the first place.28 Be that as it may, the point worth stressing is that for Borges, as for Steiner, a translation can bring to light aspects of a work that may be lost on a reader of an original.29 But Borges would go further than Steiner. As far as he was concerned, a translator can also interpolate his own inventions and excise passages that could have been rendered with ease. A translator can produce an unfaithful work that surpasses the original precisely
Borges on Translation
9
because it is unfaithful. This is so because a translator can correct mistakes and inconsistencies of a text and edit sections that may obscure an aspect of the work that might be worth foregrounding. Even if it were possible to do the impossible and produce a translation that captured all the meanings, connotations, and effects of the original, Borges might not prefer it to a translation that modifies it. Even Virgil and Dante, poets Borges greatly admired perhaps more than any others, are susceptible to improvement. Borges was fond of those translators who “thought of Homer as the greatest of poets [but] knew he was human . . . and could therefore reshape his words.”30 For Borges, there are no perfect originals, any more than there can be perfect translations or rough drafts. A translator, therefore, should not be faithful to an imperfect text, but to a perfectible work. Why should a translator find equivalents for what Borges has called the “idiocies of the text” when these may hamper the very effects the text would otherwise produce? Why should a translator forgo those possibilities and potentialities in a text that the author of the original neglected out of carelessness or lack of vision? Borges’s answer to these questions is so unequivocal that he included it verbatim in several of his essays on translation: “To assume that every recombination of elements is necessarily inferior to its original form is to assume that a draft nine is necessarily inferior to draft H—for there can only be drafts. The concept of the ‘definitive text’ corresponds only to religion or exhaustion.”31 Borges’s claim that a translation necessarily involves a transformation with regards to the original is hardly controversial, but some may want to draw the line where Borges encourages translators to take liberties and call such work a “loose translation,” an “adaptation,” or an “imitation.” These considerations, however, are not pressing ones for Borges. He was as cavalier with unconventional views regarding a translator’s liberties as he was with plagiarism. In his general views on literature, the work is more important than the writer: “An artist cares about the perfectibility of the work, and not the fact that it may have originated from himself or from others.”32 It matters little to Borges that his views on translation may be a justification for plagiarism: “If the work improves, why not? Why not make it a collective project?”33 In El oro de las tigres
10
Invisible Work
(The Gold of the Tigers) Borges observes after recalling, with admiration and even an air of nostalgia, that Spanish poets in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries willfully copied texts from Latin poets: “Our concept of plagiarism is, without a doubt, less literary than commercial.”34 In discussing the similarities between Borges’s Haikus and those of the old Japanese masters, María Kodama points out that repetition of certain lines from one poet by another—a common practice in Borges’s own poetry—was not considered an imperfection: “No one thought that repetition was plagiarism, no one thought in terms of personal vanity.”35 Borges was persuaded that the vicissitudes of the translation process can generate literary works to be cherished for their collective, impersonal, ongoing qualities. Alexander Coleman has suggested that Borges’s bent towards impersonality and anonymity in literature is informed by T. S. Eliot’s famous essay, “Tradition and the Individual Talent.”36 Eliot dismisses the need of those literary critics who stress the individuality of a writer as a “prejudice” that should be overcome to see literature as a collective enterprise, where the old speaks through the new and the new reorients the significance of the old: “What happens when a new work of art is created is something that happens simultaneously to all the works of art which preceded it.”37 Borges admired “Tradition and the Individual Talent,” and his views on translation can be read as a compliment to Eliot’s ideas on the depersonalization of literature. Borges’s own skepticism about individuality or personality in literature informs his notion of a perfectible work, his endorsement of the liberties a translator might take, and his suggestion that contradictory versions of the same work can be equally valid. Borges’s views on translation are also underwritten by a claim, which Harold Bloom has held even more forcefully, that ours is a belated age for the creation of original works of literature. On many occasions Borges affirmed that after three thousand years of literary production it is highly unlikely that contemporary writers can generate new or original ideas. There is a sense, therefore, in which translation, in one way or another, is an element of any literary work of the recent past. Borges had highly developed scruples with regards to a translation that impoverishes the work
Borges on Translation
11
on artistic grounds but no qualms about a translation that transforms a previous translation, provided, of course, that he could approve the results. In fact, Borges rewrote his own translations of the same work, and might have stepped over the line into what some may consider plagiarism. Once, for example, he signed as his own a translation of Chesterton’s “The Honour of Israel Gow,” which amounts to a corrected version of a previous translation published by his good friend Alfonso Reyes.38 Borges not only maintained that a new translation can be an improvement over a previous one; he also thought that the chronological precedence of an original with respect to a translation is no guarantee of the literary primacy of the original: “I am not one of those who mystically prejudge that every translation is inferior to the original. Many times I have confirmed, or I have been able to suspect, the exact opposite.”39 Borges was more impressed by Schopenhauer’s translation of Baltazar Gracian’s A Pocket Oracle than by the original because it avoids the original’s fastidious word games that obfuscate “the ideas it proposes.”40 And he preferred De Quincey’s translation of Lessing’s Laocöon for its superior “urbanity and eloquence.”41 He considered Baudelaire a superior poet to Stefan George but maintained that George was “a far more skillful craftsman.”42 He therefore was more partial to George’s Blümen des Böse than he was to the original Fleurs du mal. Borges preferred Dante in the original but Cervantes in an English translation. He remembers, perhaps in jest, that Don Quixote seemed to him like a “bad translation” the first time he read it in Spanish.43
On the Translation of His Own Works On the one hand, Borges disapproved of certain German translations of his own works as excessively literal, relying too heavily on the authority of the dictionary (“dictionaries are misleading”). Borges thought lexicons should serve to enliven, rather than dictate, a translator’s choices.44 On the other hand, he applauded several French and English translations which deviated from his originals. He often insisted that translations resulting from the intelligent or inspired taking of liberties improved his originals. Indeed, some of
12
Invisible Work
the freest translations of his own works were written with his collaboration or approval. Borges collaborated with Norman Thomas di Giovanni in the English translations of at least four books. Di Giovanni reported on the nature of their approach: “We agree that the text should not be approached as a sacred object but as a tool, allowing us, whenever we feel the need, to add or subtract from it, to depart from it, or even, on rare occasions, to improve it.”45 Carter Wheelock considers that in their translations “Borges and di Giovanni have created a situation as ambiguous and subtle as one of Borges’s tales.”46 Wheelock argues that the translation simplifies Borges’s elaborate language of the 1940s and 1950s according to Borges’s inclination, in the 1970s, “toward the simple and straightforward.”47 He also recognizes that the translators decided to take into account that their readership is a much wider audience than the original audience, readers who could ascertain many more of the contextual references, particularly those that pertain to the Argentine context. Wheelock is not disturbed by the losses that these translating procedures entail because, among other reasons, the translations can be thought of as independent versions that will not erase the perception that Borges’s originals are “full of involutions and nuances heavily dependent on a particular vocabulary, often shockingly ill-fitting, ambiguous, or otherwise strange.”48 Others, however, have been more critical. Matthew Howard considers that the collaboration between di Giovanni and Borges has “left a troubling legacy for Borges’s readers and critics,” in as much as they took many liberties with the originals.49 Although Howard, like Wheelock, is willing to consider the translations as an intended self-recreation by Borges and appreciates di Giovanni’s attempt to render the Argentine allusions clear to North American readers, his general assessment is fraught with suspicions about the results and even about di Giovanni’s literary competence. The translation of Borges’s poetry into French by Nestor Ibarra has been equally deplored by some distinguished critics and translators. One of the sharpest rejections of Ibarra’s translation is found in an essay in which Albert Bensoussan argues that all the significant translations into French of Borges’s main poems, including those by Nestor Ibarra
Borges on Translation
13
and Roger Callois, are lamentable. He takes issue with Callois’s literal translation but is especially disconcerted by Ibarra’s work. Bensoussan, a distinguished translator himself, is aware that Borges gave Ibarra full license to translate his poems as he saw fit and knows that Borges wrote a preface with praise and gratitude; and yet, he considers Ibarra’s translations to be dishonest transpositions that take unwarranted liberties with the original.50 However, Borges, in fact, encouraged Ibarra to take those liberties and collaborated with di Giovanni’s transformations of his own works. In each case he considered the end result to be a collective work. In the preface to Ibarra’s translation he reiterated his idea that the work takes supremacy over the author and that, in principle, a translation ought not be judged negatively if it deviates from the original. And Borges also regrets that “no one likes to celebrate those pages whose paternity is uncertain. The same goes for translations of poetry. We want to admire the poet, not the translator, and this scruple, or this prejudice, has favored the literal version.”51 The issue at hand is not a simple one. Borges himself argued in favor of literary practices that were collective and impersonal and often expressed skepticism with respect to the individuality of any author, including himself. And yet, Wheelock, Bensoussan, and others have a valid point to make when they express serious reservations in their assessments of translations that transform or mollify the uniqueness or idiosyncrasies of Borges’s literary genius, even when the gestures appear to be in the spirit of views that Borges himself held or in terms of the very conceits Borges was fond of practicing. My intention is not to make value judgments about Borges’s views on translation—since I am interested in understanding them as they shed light on his practices as a masterful creative translator—but it is important to recognize that the reception of his work, for decades, has faced a dilemma: one can accept Borges’s views about the impersonality of literature and thus downplay the significance of his personal genius, or downplay the significance of his literary views in order to appreciate his genius.52 In a seminal work on the reception of Spanish American literature in France (and the international reception of Borges owes much
14
Invisible Work
to French interest in his work), Sylvia Molloy castigates Ibarra for presenting Borges to the French public with Borgesian tactics and procedures that confused unsuspecting readers about Borges’s individuality: “If Ibarra was keen on mystifying his reader, he could not have been more successful. . . . One would have preferred an introduction, perhaps less brilliant, but one which would have given, to the extent possible, a better articulated image of the writer.”53 Molloy seems to suggest that once Borges’s readers recognize the Borgesian conflation of fiction and fact they can enjoy it, but she also suggests that there is something misleading about the Borgesian game when it is not clear that it is being played. But whether or not Borges was a willing accomplice in the mystification of his own works, he would invariably and enthusiastically express his preference for the translations that took liberties with, or corrected, his originals. In this regard, di Giovanni once reported that a university professor complained that a translation of a Borges short story had corrected an inconsistency. The professor would have preferred that the translation conserve the inconsistency, as he considered it a charming Borgesian touch. As di Giovanni recalled the matter: “Borges was mildly angered; first of all, he found nothing charming in the slip, and, secondly, he feels that he has the right to shape and alter his work as he sees fit. One of the great luxuries of working with Borges is that he’s interested only in making things better and not in defending a text.”54 An original text offers a translator opportunities precisely because an equivalent word may have different connotations and arbitrary associations in the language or in the linguistic modalities of the translator. Borges also conjectured that one of the possible advantages of a translation over an original is its likelihood to eschew aspects of a work involving historical or linguistic idiosyncrasies that have little to do with why the work is worth reading in the first place. That is why Borges would at times recommend to young writers that they read great works of literature in translation rather than in the original: “It is better to study the classics in translation to appreciate the substantive and to avoid the accidental.”55 A translator—like a writer correcting a draft—often cuts, adds, and reorganizes a text to produce a work that improves on rougher
Borges on Translation
15
sketches. For Borges, therefore, translation from one language to another is a special case of rewriting a draft that does not differ, in principle, from the transformation of a text in the same language, from one dialect or one modality to another. It may be easier, for example, to translate a journalistic article from French into English than to modernize Chaucer or Shakespeare into any modern language, including English. In Borges’s earliest statement about translation—a short article he published in 1926—he argued that translation exists fundamentally in two forms, a literal and a periphrastic: I suppose that there are two types of translation. One involves literality, and the other periphrasis. The first corresponds to the Romantic mind-set, and the second one to the classicists. I would like to reason through this affirmation to diminish its paradoxical air. Classicist are interested in the work of art, but never the artist. They believe in absolute perfection and they seek it. They disdain localisms, rarities, and contingencies. . . . Conversely, Romantics never look for the work of art, they look for the man. And the man (as is well known) is not intemporal nor archetypal. He is John Doe, not Bill Smith. He owns a climate, a body, the propensity to do this rather than that, or to do nothing at all. He has a present, a past, a future, and even a death that is all his own. Watch out if you touch a single one of the words he ever wrote!56 In the retrospective light of his later essays on translation, informed by his views on the impersonality of literature, some critics interpret the two options Borges offers as alternatives to which he gives equal weight. Notwithstanding his ironic tone, however, in 1926 he was more skeptical about the option he attributes to the “classicists.” In the 1920s Borges sometimes maintained that literature was the direct expression of an individuality. This view, which he was soon to abandon, is consistent with the “Romantic” approach to translation, which he seems to favor in this essay: “That reverence of the self, of the irreplaceable human differentiation justifies the literal translation.” And yet, Borges’s preference is not categorical.
16
Invisible Work
He recognizes that for texts of the past, it may not be possible to capture the individual who produced them, and to that extent recreations are inevitable. To the extent, however, that the reconstruction of the individual who created the text is no longer possible, translation of ancient works becomes “a game of variants.” By the 1930s Borges had abandoned the view that literature is strictly autobiographical, and he no longer discussed the problem of translation in terms of classicist or Romantic mind-sets. That being said, the 1926 essay expresses a view about language, inspired by his readings of Novalis, that would have a lasting significance in Borges’s general ideas about both literature and translation. Borges cites a fragment in which the German Romantic poet affirms that words have singular meanings (eingentümliche Bedeutungen), connotations (Nebenbedeutungen), and arbitrary associations (willkürlichen Bedeutungen).57 This distinction informed a picture that would remain a constant in Borges’s discussions of language, literature, and translation: that in the passage of time it becomes increasingly difficult to determine the connotations and arbitrary associations of written language that has come down to us from the past. From the 1930s onward Borges continued to think of language in terms of meanings, connotations, and arbitrary associations. This view determined how he examined the vicissitudes of a text over the course of time: the meanings of words survive while connotations and associations change, even across languages and modes of expressions, because the same words may have different connotations for different language communities separated by space or time. For instance, Borges thought that certain Argentine poetry would be lost on contemporary Chileans because the same words in the same language suggest different meanings in the two contexts. He also believed that the transformations of a language, its accidental developments over time, could either improve or impoverish a work as the connotations and arbitrary associations of words evolve, even as general meanings are maintained. Borges would often indicate that meanings, concepts, and ideas are easier to transfer from one mode of expression to another than are connotations and associations, where emotions play a greater role.
Borges on Translation
17
His disdain for translations that supposedly capture the veracity of an original whose theme is foreign or distant also held over from the 1926 essay into future essays on translation. In an idea he expands in his famous essay “El escritor argentino y la tradición” (the Argentine writer and tradition) Borges claims that to capture the “foreign” elements of the original, the translator must necessarily distort: foreign elements are self-evident, require no description in their original context, but when they are explained in a translation, the translation distorts the original. It upsets Borges that the preface of Doctor Madrus’s translation of the Arabian Nights includes the indication “literal and complete,” when he believes it resembles the luxuriant style of Oscar Wilde’s The Portrait of Dorian Gray. Thus, for example, the original “They arrived at a column of black stone, in which a man was buried up to his armpits” is transformed by Madrus into “One evening the caravan came to a column of black stone to which a strange being was chained, only half of whose body could be seen, for the other half was buried in the ground.”58 Borges likens Madrus’s role as translator to the graphic artist charged with illustrating a novel or short story: the artist includes details not necessarily mentioned in the work. Borges does not object, in principle, to the practice of adding details to a work of literature, but it disturbs him when the claim of “complete veracity” is made of any translation that expands the original to produce effects of strangeness or local color: “The announced purpose of veracity turns the translator into an impostor, since in order to maintain the strangeness of what he is translating, he is obliged to express local color, to make the raw rawer, to turn sweetness into syrup, and to emphasize the lot until it becomes a lie.”59 Borges’s insights intriguingly coincide with those of some analytic philosophers who follow Quine by claiming that any given text can have an indefinite number of valid and even contradictory translations. Borges was fond of demonstrating the difficulties of transforming a simple Spanish text into another one. He once offered two different Spanish versions of the first lines of Argentina’s most famous poem, José Hernández’s Martín Fierro: “Aquí me pongo a cantar / al compás de la vigüela” (Here I begin to sing / to the rhythm of my guitar). Borges’s first translation is intended to be
18
Invisible Work
drawn-out, but literal: “In the very place where I find myself, I am beginning to sing with my guitar.”60 His second translation takes a liberty with respect to the original: “Here, with my fraternal guitar, I begin to sing.”61 Borges compares his two translations, and concludes that the second and less accurate one is the better. The first “so ridiculous, and sluggish! is almost literal.”62 Subtle as always, Borges did not mean to reject the literal translation outright, but only the justification of those who might prefer it on the grounds that a writer’s text constitutes his uniqueness. In the 1920s Borges had already identified the benefits of a translation that takes liberties.63 In the 1930s his views on translation coalesced. He vindicated the right of a translator to swerve away from the original and to interpolate, and he formulated a definition of translation he would continue to restate for decades to come: translation is a long experimental game of chance played with omissions and emphasis.64 In his incisive definition Borges recognizes that translation involves choice, chance, and experimentation. For Borges, the incommensurability of any two languages, or even two modes of expression within the same language, provides stimulating challenges to the literary translator, who must choose between registering the singularities of an original work and eliminating the details that obscure its general effects. A literal translation can sometimes generate ridiculous results, but it can also spawn strange and wondrous surprises. Borges’s views on translation percolated into his fictions as well. In “La lotería en Babilonia” (“The Lottery in Babylon”), for example, no two books are alike because “the scribes make a secret oath to cut, interpolate, and alter.”65 Borges first formulated his definition of translation in a sustained reflection on a famous polemic between Matthew Arnold and Francis E. Newman.
The Arnold-Newman Discussion In 1856, after many years of work, Francis Newman published his English version of Homer’s Iliad. The distinguished professor from the University of London had set out to produce a faithful and literal translation that would capture every linguistic detail and
Borges on Translation
19
all of the Homeric peculiarities to such a degree that it would be possible for a contemporary reader to comprehend the Greek world. Once his task was accomplished he announced, with a sense of satisfaction and pride, that his Iliad would be the model for any future English translation of classical Greek, excepting, perhaps, the case of Pindar. It did not take long for the reputation of his Iliad to suffer a damaging blow. Bringing to bear his prestige as an Oxford professor and admired poet, Matthew Arnold announced he would offer not one but a series of lectures to demonstrate that Newman’s Iliad was a dismal failure. Arnold recognized Newman’s erudition and his command of Ancient Greek, but argued that a good translation requires an attribute Newman lacked: the literary sensibility of a good poet who knows when to edit and modify anything in the original that may obscure the general effects of a work. Newman’s approach might be of some use to a certain kind of reader interested in every detail of a text, but it constitutes a recipe tainted with the odd and uncouth. No translator of Homer can respect every detail of a work if the purpose is to recreate the original so that an English reader of the translation would experience the same effects as a reader of ancient Greek. According to Arnold, Homer expressed his ideas with clarity; his Greek is plain, direct, and rapid. Newman’s translation, on the other hand, is slow, rough, and confusing. Rather than reproducing the general effects of Homer’s Iliad, Newman’s translation registers the considerable linguistic incompatibilities between English and ancient Greek. Newman’s literal translation abounds in grammatical constructions that strike any English reader as strange, when it should have flowed with the clarity of Homer’s Greek. He rendered sentence structures from the Greek that do not exist in English, when he should have found English equivalents to reproduce the effects of the original. Homer, for example, uses the double epithet, a common construction of ancient Greek unavailable in standard English usage. For instance, the translation of two consecutive adjectives can produce curious effects in English that are quite commonplace in the
20
Invisible Work
original. With this, and many other examples, Arnold concluded that a good translator must sacrifice linguistic fidelity to reproduce the effects of a work. Newman was hurt and affected by Arnold’s lectures. He accused his fellow Hellenist of bad faith and wrote an entire book to acquit himself of the poet’s objections. The so-called “strange English constructions,” so discordant to Arnold, were inevitable because they reflect Homer’s peculiarities. A Homeric translation ought to sound strange to a contemporary reader because ancient Greek is as foreign to an Englishman of the nineteenth century as the ancient world itself. Had he eliminated the peculiarities of ancient Greek, including the double epithets and other constructions Arnold disliked, he would not have captured the essence of Homer. One would be glossing over substantive differences between the world of the ancient Greeks and that of modern England if one’s translation of Homer read as if written by a contemporary. The famous polemic between Newman and Arnold inspired Borges’s most important observations about the task of producing a new literary version of a preexistent work. In numerous essays and interviews spanning his lifetime, Borges referred to the ArnoldNewman debate as a beautiful exchange or lively and intelligent discussion.66 Most literary critics who have glossed Borges’s take on the Arnold-Newman controversy have assumed that the Argentine writer is simply summarizing the views of the two British professors, but that is misleading. When Borges discussed the controversy, he did it selectively. He did not credit Newman’s aspiration to offer a window onto the ancient world for a modern reader, nor Arnold’s attempt to recreate, in English, the same effects that a contemporary sensitive reader would have experienced with the original. Borges ignores Newman’s concerns regarding the reconstruction of the Greek world and focuses on his literal method. He also ignores Arnold’s insistence on the effects that an ancient work might have on a contemporary who understands Greek and focuses, instead, on the effects of the work without giving the original any special status, ignoring, in fact, the original altogether. Borges shrewdly side-steps the most serious incompatibilities between the
Borges on Translation
21
two Hellenists so that their irreconcilable differences appear to involve matters of preference. In Borges’s personal synthesis the two Hellenists represent the two main options available to a translator: either a literal translation that strives to register all the singularities of a work, or a recreation that eliminates the details, obscuring the work’s general effects. A bad literal translation can produce curious and even ridiculous effects, and a recreation can be more faithful to an original than a literal translation. This, of course, was Arnold’s main objection to Newman’s translation. Borges, however, does not assume that the effects of a literal translation are necessarily objectionable, because they can enrich and even revitalize a language: “The paradox is—and of course, ‘paradox’ means something true that at first appearance is false—that if you are out for strangeness, if you want, let’s say to astonish the reader, you can do that by being literal. [Literal translations can create] something that is not in the original.”67 Borges proclaims that some of the greatest resources available to English speakers came precisely from the unexpected and astonishing effects produced by the approach Arnold objected to in his critique of Newman. Borges accepted Arnold’s description of Newman’s procedure as the encounter between two distinct modes of expression, but he qualified the negative value judgment: “If Matthew Arnold had looked closely into his Bible [and Arnold had recommended to Newman that one might want to approach the translation of Homer with the model of a biblical translation] he might have seen that the English Bible is full of literal translations and that . . . the great beauty of the English Bible lies in those literal translations.”68 Had the powerful biblical phrase “Tower of Strength” been translated according to Arnold’s approach it should have produced something akin to the drab “a firm stronghold,” and the “Song of songs” would lose its poetry had it been translated more faithfully as “the highest song” or “the best song.” Borges corrects Arnold by commenting that “it might be said that literal translations make not only, as Matthew Arnold pointed out, for uncouthness and oddity, but also for strangeness and beauty.”69
22
Invisible Work
The positions of Arnold and Newman are, of course, mutually exclusive, but Borges found merits in each of them: “Newman favored the literal mode that retains all verbal singularities. Arnold, on the other hand, favored the severe elimination of distracting details. The latter produces sound uniformities, and the former produces unexpected surprises.” Informed by his reflections on Newman and Arnold, Borges developed a doctrine of translation that does not favor a priori the views of one or the other as he characterizes them but, rather, appreciates both as options. In short, he relativizes their views. A translator has to decide whether to cut or alter effects in the original. According to Borges, a translation can take place in a single language, and it is possible to copy a text from one language to another. If whatever one would like to say about the English phrase “the black water” could also be said about the Spanish “el agua negra,” Borges would say that the Spanish is a copy of the English. In his famous essay “The Homeric Versions” Borges compares six versions of a passage from the Odyssey in his own Spanish “copies.” Eliot Weinberger restores the original English texts in his superb English translation of Borges’s essay. Borges’s procedure and Weinberger’s restoration are both justified. The aspects Borges underscores in his comparisons do not involve linguistic differences between English and Spanish but other considerations, such as the reverential manner of one version, the luxuriant language of another, the lyric tone of one versus the oratorical tone of another, the visual emphasis of one versus the more factual emphasis of another, the spectacular versus the sedate features of another. A translation, as opposed to a copy, suggests a transformation that may surpass the original. One of Borges’s favorite literary practices was to compare a translation to an original and to judge the translation and the original on equal footing, as two versions of the same work. Borges argued that the ideal arbiter of a translation is the unlikely reader who can resist the almost inevitable prejudice in favor of the original: “If we did not know which was the original and which the translation, we could judge them fairly,”70 which is to say that the best judge of a translation is the unprejudiced reader. In this spirit he sometimes underscored the benefits of ignoring
Borges on Translation
23
the original language of repeatedly translated works: “The Odyssey, thanks to my opportune ignorance of Greek, is an international bookshelf of works in prose and verse.”71 Borges expressed his hope “that someday a translation will be considered as something in itself.”72 In his prologue to Nestor Ibarra’s translation of Paul Valéry’s “Le Cimetière marin,” Borges criticizes several lines of the original with the argument Arnold deployed to censure Newman’s literal translation. “Le changement des rives en rumeur” (the changing of riverbanks in rumor), according to Borges, leaves much to be desired when compared to “La pérdida en rumor de la rivera” (the loss of rumor from the riverbank). According to Borges, Ibarra’s line is not superior merely because it sounds better than Valéry’s; it is superior because it supposedly captures, more effectively than its French counterpart, Valéry’s poetic vision: “To insist on the contrary with too much faith is to renege on Valéry’s poetic vision in favor of the temporal individual who formulated it.”73 Borges held that not even San Juan de la Cruz, “the greatest . . . of Spanish poets,” was beyond improvement.74 Borges preferred Roy Campbell’s “When all the house was hushed” over San Juan’s “Estando ya mi casa sosegada” (when my house was at rest): “Here we have the word ‘all,’ which gives a sense of space, of expanse, to the line. And then the gentle English word ‘hushed.’ ‘Hushed’ seems to give us somehow the very music of silence.”75 “Music of silence,” to the Spanish reader, is an English translation of San Juan de la Cruz’s stunning paradox “música callada,” which in a more literal translation would be “silent music.” Even as he compared many translations to their originals, Borges insisted that the aesthetic value of a translation does not depend on its relationship to the original. Borges would often recommend the reading of translations, as with Juan de Jauregui’s Spanish version of Lucan’s Pharsalia, which are “completely unfaithful and very beautiful.”76 A good translation can be unfaithful to the original as with FitzGerald’s Rubáiyat, but it can also be more faithful to the “vision” of the work than the original, as Borges insists is the case for Nestor Ibarra’s translation of Paul Valéry. The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Quotations offers as its only entry for Borges a comment
24
Invisible Work
on a translation: “The original is unfaithful to the translation.” The context of this quotation is his analysis of Henley’s English translation of William Beckford’s Vathek. Borges thinks that the French original is unfaithful to the translation because it was rendered with sloppy haste, whereas the English version was crafted with thoughtful care and attention to detail.77 The translations Borges condemned with greatest vehemence are those he called spoiled versions of admirable works. In his indignant review of poet León Felipe’s Spanish version of Whitman’s “Song of Myself,” Borges offers his “copies” of Whitman (which he quotes in Spanish as if they were verses by Whitman) to condemn Felipe’s translation. The following transcribes, in English, a fragment of Borges’s review. In the original all of the quotations appear in Spanish including the Whitman quotation, which Borges presents not as a translation but as an equivalent to the original in order to contrast it to Felipe’s translation, which Borges considers a dismal failure (the original Spanish texts of Borges’s “copy” and of Felipe’s “translation” are both in the endnote): Whitman writes (“Song of Myself”): Walt Whitman, a cosmos, from Manhattan the son Turbulent, carnal, sensual, eating, drinking, engendering. . . . Felipe “translates” (Canto a mí mismo): I am Walt Whitman A Cosmos. Look at me! The son of Manhattan. Turbulent, strong, sensual; I eat, drink, and engender. . . . The transformation is notorious; from the psalm-like voice “of Walt Whitman” to the spoiled little cries of an Andalusian deep song.78 Borges was especially interested in the destiny of the translation of ancient literature.79 In “The Homeric Versions” he observes that
Borges on Translation
25
the events of the Iliad and the Odyssey “survive completely” while the connotations of Homer’s language have been lost: “The present state of [Homer’s] works is like a complex equation that represents the precise relations of unknown quantities. There is no possible greater richness for the translator.”80 Borges understands, therefore, why there are so many translations of Homer, “all of them sincere, genuine, and divergent.” To make his point Borges examines a strange Homeric adjective. He offers a few examples including the following: “those rich young men who drink the black waters of the Aesepus” (my emphasis). Borges knows that the waters of the River are probably not “black.” Some translators whom Arnold might have praised omitted the adjective. Others defend the inclusion. Alexander Pope believed such adjectives had a liturgical function the translator ought to retain; and Remy de Gourmont thought they must have had an enchantment that has been lost to us. Borges offers another conjecture: “They may have been to the Greeks what prepositions are to us: modest and obligatory sounds that usage requires and upon which no originality may be exercised.” In the sentence regarding the young men who drink the black waters of a river, “black” could correspond to the word “transparent.” Borges might have been amused to note that Samuel Butler’s translation of the same passage reads, “the limpid waters of the Aesepus,” while Navarro’s celebrated Spanish translation says the exact opposite: “the muddy waters of the Aesepus.”81
On the Arabian Nights In one of his many discussions of the Arabian Nights, Borges celebrated the chain of translations that brought the stories from “the Hindostan to Persia, from Persia to Arabia, from Arabia to Egypt, growing and multiplying itself.”82 After the text was set in the fourteenth Century in Egypt, the copyists supplemented the collection with new stories. Borges applauded the cunning of Antoine Galland who continued the practice by enriching the original with new tales of his own invention (or from oral tradition), such as the stories of Aladdin. Borges also admired Richard Burton for includ-
26
Invisible Work
ing personal interpolations when he translated the Arabian Nights. Borges secretly participated in the process of transforming Arabian stories. He recreated a translation by Galland and invented a story he attributed to Burton.83 Borges’s most sustained and boldest essay on translation is “The Translators of the Thousand and One Nights.”84 Not only a comparison of the various translators of the Arabian Nights, the essay presents a number of his views on translation heretofore not fully articulated. If in other essays Borges maintained that an original and its translations were variations on a theme, no text being a priori superior to any other, in “The Translators” Borges declares that translators often translate against one another. To understand why some translator adopted one approach over another, it might be useful, Borges argues, to know against whom the translator was translating. Harold Bloom has called Borges “a great theorist of poetic influence.”85 Bloom’s own doctrine of “the anxiety of influence” has its acknowledged antecedent in ideas Borges first developed in his meditations on translation, years before he wrote his seminal essay “Kafka y sus precursores” (Kafka and his precursors).86 In his essay on the Arabian Nights Borges also contends that a translator has the option to interpolate passages into a text not in the original. He coins the term “buenas apocrifidades,” which Esther Allen improves with the phrase “fine apocrypha,” to refer to the fortunate additions with which a translator can supplement the original.87 As an example, Borges was fond of quoting Chaucer’s translation of the latin phrase “Ars longa, vita brevis” as “the lyf so short, the craft so long to learn.” Borges approves of the transformation: “[Chaucer] gave the line a kind of wistful music not to be found in the original.”88 Borges approves not only of small apocryphal changes, but even of major ones and holds that the more successful the apocryphal entry, the more it becomes inexorably linked to our notion of the work. As an example, he offers Galland’s interpolated stories in his eighteen-century translation of the Arabian Nights. Borges lists a number of specific examples to make his point that to exclude Galland’s interpolations would now be taken as an amputation of
Borges on Translation
27
the work, which for contemporary readers should include “the stories of Aladdin; the Forty Thieves; Prince Ahmad and the Fairy Peri-Banu; Abu al-Hassan, the Sleeper and the Walker; the night adventure of Caliph Harun al-Rashid; and the two sisters who envied their younger sister.”89 Borges maintained that some interpolations in a translation may leave the content of a work untouched because they are implicit, yet unstated, in the original. He felt, for example, that his short story “El fin” (“The End”) is not so much a continuation of José Hernández’s Martín Fierro as an explicit account of a story that can be deduced from the original. Borges insists that other than an incidental character “nothing or almost nothing is my invention.”90 In the original the gaucho Martín Fierro kills a man and later defeats a vengeful relative of the victim in a verbal duel that diffuses the revenge; in Borges’s story the vengeful relative kills Fierro.91 One of Borges’s tours de force, as a translator, is his interpolation of a paragraph in his translation of Sir Thomas Browne’s UrnBurial.92 The protagonist of the story “La memoria de Shakespeare” (“Shakespeare’s Memory”) argues at length that an interpolation in an eighteenth-century critical edition of an unnamed work by Shakespeare has become an “undeniable part of the canon.”93 Some translations become anachronistic as the meaning of words change. Language shifts may work for or against translations, just as they might for original works.94 In one of Borges’s many reflections on Shakespeare he wonders if some of the bard’s images have been improved by the history of the language. He illustrates his point with a quotation about Christ in Israel: “Over whose acres walk’d those blessed feet, / Which, fourteen hundred years ago, were nail’d, / For our advantage, on the bitter cross.”95 Borges speculates that the word “advantage” (“a word which in a sense is not very beautiful but sounds like the right word”) may have had sharper theological connotations in the seventeenth century when it could have meant “salvation.” If so, “perhaps the line wasn’t as beautiful as it is today. Nowadays, the word advantage comes with a sharp surprise. I am grateful to Shakespeare, but, for all we know, maybe time has bettered the text.”96
28
Invisible Work
Just as shifts in language can have positive or negative effects on a work or on its translations, so, too, distortions by a translator can have positive or negative effects. Borges prefers Galland’s distortion when he translates a tryst between a princess and “one of the lowliest servants” over Richard Burton’s distasteful rendering of the same text as “a black cook of loathsome aspect and found with kitchen grease and grime.” Borges thinks it is legitimate to “mutilate” an original if one has good reason to do so. Thus, for example, he considers it fitting to downplay the sexual content of the Arabian Nights in order to underscore its magical aspects, but inappropriate to do so to uphold a Puritan worldview. He therefore approves of the discreet ways in which Galland suggests aspects made explicit in the original, as with the euphemism “to receive in her bed” to describe an erotic encounter. He deplores, however, the “convolutions and occultations” of Edward Lane when avoiding the word “hermaphrodite” by replacing it with “mixed species,” and when erasing the sexual practices in a harem by replacing a sentence describing a king’s conjugal visits with a comment on his impartiality. If Lane erased the erotic context of the original, which Galland had insinuated into his translation, Richard Burton reinstated them with exaggerated vigor. Borges disapproves of Burton’s sexual amplifications in the Arabian Nights as a deliberate provocation to attract attention and to establish his reputation as an Arabist conversant with the intimacies of the Orient. In the case of the Arabian Nights, Borges urges, the “disinfected” versions are actually a restoration of a primal text. The tales were versions of ancient love stories, not obscene but “impassioned and sad.” Borges defends the “disinfected” versions with another argument: “An evasion of the original’s erotic opportunities is not an unpardonable sin in the sight of the Lord when the primary aim is to emphasize the atmosphere of magic.”97 Borges uses the theme of the unintended restoration of an original in his own stories, as when Herman Soergel in “Shakespeare’s Memory” expresses his admiration for Chapman’s Homeric translations because they “bring English back—without his realizing it—to its Anglo-Saxon origin (Ursprung).”98
Borges on Translation
29
Just as a literal translation that transforms the meanings of the original can produce surprises, Borges does not exclude the possible benefits of carelessness that can produce “involuntary good results.” Borges contends that Lane achieved this in his translation: “At times [his] lack of sensibility serves him well, for it allows him to include commonplace words in a noble paragraph, with involuntary results. The most rewarding example of such a cooperation of heterogeneous words must be: ‘And in this palace is the last information respecting the lords collected in the dust.’”99 In a passage prefiguring a major theme of “Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote” and his essay “Kafka and His Precursors.” Borges argues that expectations can play a consequential role in the reception of a translation: “I have sometimes suspected that the radical distinction between poetry and prose lies in the very different expectations of readers: poetry presupposes an intensity that is not tolerated in prose. Something similar happens with Burton’s work: it has a preordained prestige with which no other Arabist has ever been able to compete. The attractions of the forbidden are rightfully his.”100 So, too, does the intended audience affect a translation: “[the original audience of the tale was] roguish, prone to exaggeration, illiterate, infinitely suspicious of the present and credulous of remote marvels. [Burton’s club of subscribers on the other hand] were the respectable men of the West End, well equipped for disdain and erudition but not for belly laughs or terror.”101 Borges prefers a translator who falsifies to a translator who claims to capture the veracity of the original. He admires Doctor Madrus’s proliferous translation of the Arabian Nights because of its infidelities: “To celebrate Madrus’s fidelity is to leave out the soul of Madrus, to ignore Madrus entirely. It is his infidelity, his happy and creative infidelity, that must matter to us.”102 Of all the translations of the Arabian Nights, the one Borges dislikes more than any other is Enno Littman’s, the one he believes is the most faithful. Borges disapproves of Littman’s version because it is the one that least engages with literature. All of the more unfaithful translations Borges prefers “can only be conceived in the wake of literature.”103 To translate in the wake of literature is to enter into a dialogue with re-
30
Invisible Work
sources fashioned by others, as when Burton engages his translation with English literature, or Madrus with the literature of France. According to Borges, Littman’s dry accuracy sidesteps literary considerations: In some way, the almost inexhaustible process of English is adumbrated in Burton—John Donne’s hard obscenity, the gigantic vocabularies of Shakespeare and Cyril Tourneur, Swinburne’s affinity for the archaic, the crass erudition of the authors of 17th-century chapbooks, the energy and imprecision, the love of tempests and magic. In Madrus’s laughing paragraphs, Salammbô and La Fontaine, the Mannequin d’osier, and the ballets russes all coexist. In Littmann, who like Washington cannot tell a lie, there is nothing but the probity of Germany. This is so little, so very little. The commerce between Germany and the Nights should have produced something more.104 Nestor Ibarra echoed this idea in one of the prefaces to his translations of Borges: “During that ephemeral possession of a text (and to some degree of an author) which takes place in the process of translating, we engage much more than our ideas about translation, literature, aesthetics, and almost everything else.”105 Borges prefers the “contaminated” translations if their approach to literature is worthwhile. And as he laments the “uninspired frankness” of Littman’s translation, he wonders what Kafka would have created had he translated the Arabian Nights: “What wouldn’t a man do, a Kafka, if he organized and accentuated these games, if he refashioned them according to the German distortion, the Unheimlichkeit of Germany?”106
Borges’s Doctrine of Translation As with many other topics that engaged him, Borges never wrote a fully elaborated treatise on translation. In his observations about literary matters he was inclined more toward the scrutiny of par-
Borges on Translation
31
ticular cases than toward theoretical considerations. He preferred the pertinent and sometimes surprising aperçu to the general abstraction. That being said, his views on translation remained fairly constant after the 1930s, and it would be possible to construe an approach, even a doctrine, on the basis of his general observations.107 Borges wrote several essays in which he outlined the parameters of the practice of literary translation, and offered specific criteria to discuss the results. The view of translation most akin to his, although Borges did not accept all its implications, is that of Novalis, whose fragments Borges translated on several occasions. In “Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote,” the narrator indicates that Menard’s project to produce a text identical to Cervantes’s novel was inspired by “that philological fragment of Novalis . . . that outlines the theme of a total identification with a given author.”108 Novalis’s fragment is worth quoting in full: “I show I have understood a writer only when I can act in his spirit, when I, without diminishing his individuality, can translate him and change many things.”109 Borges shared Novalis’s idea that a translator is allowed to transform the original, but would not hold a translator to the demand that he or she should merge with a writer’s spirit or individuality. Borges’s indifference to those aspects of Novalis’s view is illustrated in “Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote,” when Menard considers becoming one with Cervantes and rejects the option as too simple: “[the enterprise is not difficult], it would suffice to be immortal to finish it.”110 Once he rejects the idea of becoming spiritually one with Cervantes, Menard decides to continue with his project of producing a work that would be identical to pages found in Don Quixote but to continue as himself, not as Cervantes. In short, when Borges wrote “Pierre Menard,” he was not interested—as he might have been in the 1920s—in Novalis’s Romantic ideas about the individuality of a poet, but he fully endorsed the view that a translator could reshape and improve an original. Borges also shared Novalis’s view that the beauty of literature, even of poetry, is not necessarily lost in translation. As Kristin Pfefferkorn has indicated: “According to Novalis, if the translator is a conjurer,
32
Invisible Work
so too is the poet. And if there is artistry in one, so there is in the other.”111 For Novalis, a translator may surpass the original by expressing the idea of the work, or perhaps its ideal, with greater success. Borges did not share the view that the translator was beholden to the spirit of the author, to a specific ideal, or to the essence of the work;112 but he was in full agreement with a notion Novalis expressed in a letter in which he congratulated Schlegel for surpassing Shakespeare in his translations of the plays: “To translate is to produce literature, just as the writing of one’s own work is—and it is more difficult, more rare. In the end all literature is translation.”113 And even though Novalis himself did not connect his views about translation with his idea that words have meanings, connotations, and arbitrary associations, Borges did. Borges argued that in the passage of time the meanings, connotations, and associations of words can change to such a degree as to justify repeated translations of the same work, as well as translations of translations. In summary, for Borges a translation is not the transfer of a text from one language to another. It is a transformation of a text into another. The appreciation of a literary work, for Borges, can be enriched by translation, provided that the reader avoids the prejudice of assuming the original is the best version of the work. Judging a translation involves the scrutiny of two or more versions of the same work on equal terms. One can translate within the same language, and one can copy from one language to another. Borges would call a text a “copy” if the most pertinent observations to be made about it could also be made of the original. In contrast, a “version” is a text with relevant differences with respect to either the original or another translation of the same work. For Borges, a literal translation attempts to maintain all the details of the original, but changes the emphasis (understood as meanings, connotations, associations, and effects of the work). A “recreation,” on the other hand, omits many details to conserve the emphasis of the work, and it may add interpolations. Since a “copy” maintains both the details and the emphasis that matter in a discussion of a work, most translations, especially prose translations, include some measure of “copying.” A faithful transla-
Borges on Translation
33
tion, for Borges, retains the meanings and effects of the work, whereas an unfaithful translation changes them. A literal translation that changes the emphasis of the work is therefore unfaithful, as opposed to a recreation, which conserves them. A translation can be more faithful to the work of literature than the original when the original fails to fulfill its own potentialities and latencies. A translation is also faithful when it contains the same idiosyncrasies as the original. It is unfaithful when it does not contain the same idiosyncrasies, when it contains elements of strangeness not present in the original, when it lacks the verbal oddities of the original, or when an irregularity appears that was not in the original. A translator may provide cuts and interpolations that may or may not be unfaithful to an original; such cuts and interpolations may actually restore a text to a form that preceded the original at an earlier stage in the genealogy of the work, or they may succeed in drawing out possibilities latent in the original, even if those possibilities transform it. A translation, for Borges, should be evaluated with the same criteria applicable to any work of literature. A literal translation or a recreation, faithful or unfaithful, can be successful or unsuccessful, depending on the results. And Borges could be hard on the results of a translation when they did not meet his literary standards. Borges did not hesitate to condemn certain translations as dull or inadequate when he felt their originals were of literary interest. He has called such translations “defamations” of a work of art even when more faithful than other versions. Borges recognizes that circumstances or historical considerations bear on the process of translation, or on the reception of a translated work. He thinks, however, that we are burdened by our historical sense. Borges acknowledges that avoiding historical or circumstantial considerations entirely may simply be impossible, but his bias is in favor of bracketing those considerations in the hope that translations may attain the same status as original works of literature. Borges’s essays on translation are beginning to receive the attention they deserve—which places them next to those of Walter
34
Invisible Work
Benjamin, Ezra Pound, and George Steiner—as among the most vigorous contemporary approaches to the literary version. Borges did not offer strict guidelines for translating, and, as Willis Barnstone has underscored, Borges’s favorite word to indicate the choices, judgments, and discriminations of a translator was “preference.”114 That being said, Borges did develop his views on the alternatives available to a translator, and those guidelines amount to a loose methodology for literary translation open to and even encouraging of transformations and modifications.115 He sometimes expressed restraint in modifying an original to avoid hostile reactions, and he also expressed his envy of those translators of classical texts who enjoy the right to transform an original with a freedom not available to a translator of contemporary works. The barriers against transforming a contemporary work are not only legal; they also involve the understandable reservations of readers who prefer a rough approximation to a creative recreation. Borges’s definition of translation as a combination of emphasis and omissions is not isolated from his general views about literature and art: “Time accumulates experiences on the artist, as it does with all men. By force of omissions and emphasis, of memory and forgetfulness, time combines some of those experiences and thus it elaborates the work of art.”116 Borges’s idea that the imperfections of memory make imagination possible is a theme of some of his fictions, such as “Funes el memorioso” (“Funes, the Memorious”). It is also an element he introduced surreptitiously into his own translations. In his version of Kipling’s “ ‘The Finest Story in the World’ ” Borges includes a passage that tellingly corrects Kipling. (Kipling) I had just discovered the entire principle upon which our halfmemory falsely called imagination is based. (Borges) In that instant I had discovered the principles of the imperfect memory which is called imagination.117
Borges on Translation
35
In Kipling’s version the frustrations of the writer attempting to approximate the faulty memory of a man unaware he has lived previous lives are expressed in the assertion that a broken memory is “falsely called imagination.” In Borges’s version imperfect memory is called imagination, presented not as falsity but as a positive fact one can discover. The positive effects of the imperfect memory have Nietzschean connotations akin to the potentially positive effects of the translation process as practiced by Borges, that is, transformations of originals shaped and reshaped until they gain a life of their own, until the old and the new become variations on a theme.
chapter 2
Borges as Translator Admirals, soldiers, statesmen, moved her not at all. But the very thought of a great writer stirred her to such a pitch of belief that she almost believed him to be invisible. —Virginia Woolf
O
ne of Borges’s first literary exercises, as a seven-year-old boy, was a translation of sorts.1 He filled a notebook with transcriptions of Greco-Roman myths in the charmingly clumsy English of a gifted child learning to write in a foreign language.2 In his version of the Minotaur and the Labyrinth, a theme that would inspire some of his most famous pages, the young Borges retains several names in Spanish, as if he felt a special affection for their sound in the language in which he first heard them, even as their stories could be transposed into a language he was learning (before he had mastered its grammar or spelling): When Theseo was young, his father went to another country and was made king, liveing nothing to his son but his sword and sandles. One day his mother gave him the sandles and sword. So he went in serch, in serch of his father. Soon he went there, and soon find himself in his father’s castle. There have had been a war in Creta and Thepas, and Creta was victory, Dedalo made a great laberinto, on which live the moster called minotauro.3
36
Borges as Translator
37
The versions are not mere transcriptions. At this tender age they already include personal additions such as a touching lament in his version of Acteon’s death: “Oh Action, why did you went to look at Diana?” Borges learned early that the vicissitudes of a translation are subject to the accidents of language. In his first published work—a translation of Oscar Wilde’s “The Happy Prince” published in a Buenos Aires newspaper in 1910—we find such a surprise.4 In the original a male swallow loves a fickle female reed-bird. Borges translates swallow as “la golondrina,” using the female article “la,” which does not determine the gender of the bird as there is no masculine alternative for the word. It would, however, sound awkward and technical in Spanish to use the female article to refer to a male swallow and would be poetically unsound. Spanish poetry invariably represents swallows as female. The young Borges transforms Wilde’s male swallow into a female swallow, and the female reed-bird into a male bird. Whatever his reasons, and we shall examine some possibilities below, the young Borges imposes in his translation a set of connotations—regarding the friendship of the Happy Prince and the swallow and their shared kiss—that distinguishes the translation, where the swallow is female, from the original, where it is male. B ORGES DISCUSSED Wilde’s children’s stories in the prologue to a 1966 illustrated edition containing “The Happy Prince.” The book circulated in Latin America in a collection of classics for young people, including modified versions of Don Quixote, The Odyssey, The Divine Comedy, Robinson Crusoe, and the stories of Shakespeare’s plays. Borges’s observations on the pitfalls of translating Wilde may have been lost on most young readers, for whom the collection was intended: “[Wilde] gravely assured his friends he had conceived one of his tales in black and silver, and yet the French translation had come out blue and rose.” Borges proceeds to quote Wilde’s own remark about “a change that reveals the greater capacity of the English language [than the French] to express somber tonalities.”5 Borges alerts his readers to the layers of meaning in Wilde’s tales: “At first we let ourselves go with the plot, we then feel the pleasantry, the tenderness, the jest, the delicate play of con-
38
Invisible Work
trasts, and finally perhaps the secret irony.”6 Borges concludes his prologue praising Wilde’s “perennial youth, and the splendor of his malicious innocence.”7 A Spanish version of “The Happy Prince,” included in the volume with Borges’s prologue but not translated by him, renders the tenderness of the original but not its “secret irony” or “malicious innocence.” In the sanitized translation the veiled love story between the two male protagonists is eradicated by transforming the male swallow of the original into a female swallow.8 Even the earnest declaration “you must kiss me on the lips, for I love you” is rendered more playfully as “it is better that you kiss me on the lips because I like you very much.”9 Borges’s translation, forty-five years earlier, would have been somewhat more suited to his prologue. In his version the love declaration is a command, even more forceful than in Wilde’s original: “kiss me on the lips, because I love you.”10 But, as noted earlier, Borges’s version, like the translation for young readers of 1966, transforms the male swallow into a female bird, and thus censures the possible homoerotic suggestions of the original. In both versions a fickle female becomes a male cad. The gender change in Borges’s translation, as with the young reader’s version, requires a number of other accommodations: in both Spanish versions, the fickle female reed-bird, who toyed with the feelings of the swallow, becomes a male bird, translated as “junco,” a literal translation of the Spanish word for reed and a male-gendered Spanish word. In Borges’s version the swallows constitute a group of cheerful adolescent girlfriends (“amigas”) rather than a colorless group of “friends” as in the original. The “most beautiful Reed” in the original becomes “a very pretty junco” in Borges’s version (or “the most handsome of the juncos” in the more masculine version for young readers).11 The original’s “he felt lonely and began to tire of his lady-love” becomes “she felt lonely and began to tire of her boyfriend [novio]” in Borges’s version, (or “she felt lonely and had begun to get bored with her beau” in the version for young readers).12 It is possible that Borges felt reluctant to translate “swallow” as a male bird because the gendered word “golondrina” in Spanish carries female connotations, especially in the wake of Gustavo Adolfo
Borges as Translator
39
Becquer’s migrating “golondrinas,” which left an indelible trace on the Spanish language. It is also possible that Borges changed the gender of his birds in order to downplay the love relationship between the two male characters. It is more likely, however, that he drew on a preexisting Spanish version that had already made that switch in order to eliminate the homoerotic undertones of the tale.13 Be that as it may, the young translator would learn lessons from the exercise. He experienced first hand that it is sometimes possible, and perhaps required by the language, to undertake such daring transformations in a translation as changing the gender of a principal character and that such transformations have ripple effects, as the translator accommodates the change with other alterations.14 Borges felt proud that his first publication was a translation and continued translating for the rest of his life. Most of his translations were from works published in English, but he also translated from German, French, Italian, Anglo-Saxon, and Old Norse (which he learned while losing his sight in the 1950s). Borges’s translations include Herman Melville’s “Bartleby the Scrivener,” Viginia Woolf’s Orlando, William Faulkner’s The Wild Palms, Ralph Waldo Emerson’s Representative Men, Carlyle’s Heroes and Hero Worship, Robert Louis Stevenson’s Fables, and Henri Michaux’s Un barbare en Asie. In some cases, as in his translation of Walt Whitman’s Leaves of Grass, or in his version of Angelus Silesius’s Cherubinischem Wandersmann, Borges compressed the original to create a self-contained work he did not call a selection. His last major publication was Snorri Sturluson’s Gylfaginning (the literary section of the Prose Edda), which he translated as Gylfy’s Hallucination. He translated many short stories by Franz Kafka, Herman Melville, Jack London, Chesterton, Edgar Allan Poe, Villiers de l’Isle Adam, Guillaume Apollinaire, Nathaniel Hawthorne, and Rudyard Kipling, and poems by, among others, Wilhelm Klemm, André Gide, Wallace Stevens, Langston Hughes, and Herman Hesse. He also translated essays and chapters from books including a section of Sir Thomas Browne’s Urn-Burial, and hundreds of passages from works he quoted in his anthologies and essays. For Borges translation was both a private affair and a gregarious activity shared with some of his closest companions. He translated
40
Invisible Work
many works alone, but years before losing his sight he also collaborated, and assisted others, in translation projects. Amongst his most valued partners in the process were his mother, doña Leonor Acevedo de Borges; his closest literary collaborator and good friend, Adolfo Bioy Casares; the poet and editor Roberto Alifano; and his wife, María Kodama.15 Like Ezra Pound and many others, Borges would sometimes translate works whose originals appeared in languages he did not know by drawing on other translations, as when he reworked fragments of Chinese literature from German and English sources. But even in cases where he could read the original work, he often consulted other translations. He sometimes signed translations as his own that were actually corrected versions of other translations, and he evidently also corrected translations by others in books and anthologies he edited. Borges’s translations of novels tend to be literal, even as he adjusts the nuances of the original; María Elena Bravo has observed this in his version of Faulkner’s The Wild Palms and Frances Aparicio in his version of Virginia Woolf’s Orlando.16 Borges himself provides a précis of his work with Woolf’s novel: [In translating Orlando] I have felt what I always feel when I have to translate or to write. I have felt the conviction of my incompetence, and at the same time, I have felt that I could somehow resolve those apparently insoluble difficulties. As far as the book by Virginia Woolf, I thought at first I would simplify the style. Then I realized that that would falsify it, and so I opted for an almost literal translation. Of course, for reasons of euphony I sometimes have to invert the wordorder, or change one word for another. But in general, I think the translation is rather faithful, in as much as a translation from English can be faithful in Spanish, since the two languages differ so profoundly, each having different virtues and defects.17 A careful stylist in her own translation, Suzanne Jill Levine has pointed out that Borges’s translation of Orlando “is linguistically
Borges as Translator
41
more succinct than the original.”18 Indeed, Borges’s penchant to cut redundancies, to substitute synonyms for word repetition, and to compress are still evident in the longer translations. Some also include other slight modifications in content, not just style, that are decidedly Borgesian. His translation of Orlando, for example, includes a labyrinth where the original does not use the word; and in The Wild Palms he removes the sections pertaining to an abortion, which may have offended his sensibilities or those of his mother, with whom he often collaborated in his longer translations. If Borges was more conservative in his translations of novels, modifying style and adding Borgesian touches in the content here and there, he was adventurous in his translations of many other works.
German Expressionism Borges’s family moved to Geneva in 1914 for a short period of time, which was extended five years on account of the First World War. As Emir Rodríguez Monegal put it, the family was “trapped in Switzerland.”19 This was a period of intellectual discovery and effervescence. He learned French to attend a French lycée; and he taught himself German to read German literature and philosophy. He discovered Schopenhauer, Carlyle, Whitman, Chesterton, Kafka, Flaubert, and many other writers he would revisit for decades to come. This is also a period in which he first encountered Jewish culture, which would inspire future writings.20 He read Heinrich Heine (he remembered crying once able to read Heine’s poetry in German without a dictionary), Gustav Meyrink’s Der Golem, and the writings of Martin Buber. This was also the period in which he developed his interest in Chinese literature and philosophy (“Towards 1916 I resolved to study oriental literatures”).21 Borges recalled the sobering, and perhaps liberating, experience of his first encounters with Chinese literature in translation. It puzzled him that the very same Chinese sentence could be rendered in one version as “Someone who has been condemned to death is not afraid to walk along a precipice because he has renounced to live,” and in another as “The servants destroy
42
Invisible Work
works of art in order not to have to judge their splendors and their failings.”22 The bewilderment he felt confronting incompatible translations of the same original work in a language he did not know became a source of joy, as he confidently found his own way about literature. During his years in Geneva, Borges resumed active translating. He translated a story by Meyrink that he might have revised in a 1938 publication, and he began a translation he never published of Martin Buber’s Die Legende des Baalschem.23 He worked on a brief section of the book called “Jerusalem,” Buber’s version of a mystical Jewish story featuring the founder of Hassidism, Baal Shem Tov, mentioned in “Death and the Compass” and in other Borgesian stories and essays. The original evokes a strong religious piety and not the magical and linguistic aspects of the Kabbalah Borges cherished.24 In the unpublished translation Borges downplays the pious aspects of the tale in which the apparent harshness of God is a shield for a love his people are not yet ready to bear. He transforms the notion of “affliction” (Heimsuchung) in the original to that of “temptation” (tentación), and he substitutes language underscoring weariness for the original’s vocabulary charged with a sense of death looming over the ruins of Jerusalem and with the vain and mystical search to reach the city.25 In his translation Borges appears to shy away from the more pious elements of the original, but he does not offer an alternative version that is both sound and Borgesian. Perhaps this explains why he never published it. All the same, the translation is evidence of an interest in Jewish themes early on in his literary development. The most visible result of his literary discoveries during his stay in Geneva was his interest in and practice of German expressionistic poetry, which he began to publish after his family moved from Geneva to Madrid in 1919.26 Borges was, as Linda S. Meier has indicated, practically single-handedly responsible for bringing Expressionism, the reigning avant-garde movement in Germany from 1910 to 1933, to the attention of the Spanish-speaking
Borges as Translator
43
world. . . . Out of a total of five articles concerning Expressionism which appeared in Spain in 1920 and 1921, four belong to Borges, not to mention the later essay ‘Acerca del expresionismo’ which he included in Inquisiciones.27 Borges’s efforts to disseminate the poetry of German Expressionism were applauded by luminaries of Spain’s literary milieu, including Rafael Cansinos-Assens and Ramón Gómez de la Serna.28 In the introduction to his “Anthology of Expressionism” for the Spanish literary journal Grecia in August 1920, Borges defined the movement as an attempt to elevate the reality of the senses and emotions into what he called an “ultra-reality.” In his characteristically dense, sometimes impenetrable style of the period, Borges pronounced that “[Expressionism’s] main source is constituted by that athletic and Cyclopean vision that comes from Whitman’s rhythms and the plurality of his poetry.”29 Borges sent copies of the journal, along with his translations, to some of the authors themselves. He was thrilled when Wilhelm Klemm responded “with a letter in the style of Whitman and a book of poems with a personal inscription,” as he reported excitedly to his dear friend Maurice Abramowicz.30 Borges’s encounter with Whitman and with German Expressionism, while his family was safely trapped in Switzerland during the First World War, led to a literary vision best summarized by Emir Rodríguez Monegal: “He could not help feeling the impact of those poems that violently attacked war and proclaimed the need for all men to unite in a universal brotherhood.”31 This vision informs both his essays on the Expressionist movement, and his translations. Many of the poems Borges translated were a protest against war. José Luis Vega, in his meticulous analysis of Ernst Stadler’s “Der Aufbruch” (the outbreak), one of the Expressionist poems Borges translated, labels differences between Borges’s translation and the original as errors and distortions.32 Vega attributes the discrepancies to what he considers Borges’s “insecurities with his ability with the source language.”33 It is true that Borges’s German was not as fluent as his English or French when he translated the Expressionist poems and that he may have made mistakes in comprehension, but some of his
44
Invisible Work
changes were clearly intentional. In his translation of “Der Aufbruch,” Borges modifies a line to change an emphasis in the poem. (Stadler) To strip reality from the body as one would the dusty armor of a knight.34 (Borges) To strip naked the reality of the body as from a dusty uniform.35 Borges’s translation distorts the original but underscores his concerns about World War I (Stadler wrote the original in 1912, before the war) by transforming the armor of the original into the uniform of his version. The change also gives more credence than the original to Borges’s claim that “the war did not create expressionism, but justified it.”36 Borges’s version, with more force than the original, seems to prefigure the war with prophetic force, calling attention to the uniforms of contemporary soldiers at the expense of knightly armor. The change of uniform for armor also indicates Borges’s dislike of the picturesque evocations of symbolist poetry as practiced in Spain and Spanish America. In some cases Borges’s changes produce effects different from the original. In his translation of Kurt Heynicke’s “Hinter der Front” (behind the front line), Borges effects a significant shift.37 The poem, contrasting the silent death of bystanders with that of the warriors, concludes with the word “Abend” (evening), which Borges renders as “twilight.”38 The original stresses the respite of a given day of war, while Borges’s translation suggests, perhaps, the Germanic notion of apocalyptic termination. In his compressed version of Wilhelm Klemm’s “Schlacht an der Marne” (battle of the Marne), Borges introduces his personal vocabulary into the poem. Where Klemm writes “Zwei kolossale Stunden rollen sich auf zu Minuten” (two colossal hours turn into minutes)39, accelerating time, Borges instead slows time, as if underscoring the horror or stunned confusion of the war, which induces the sense that time is moving at an excrusciating pace (“Two infinite hours unfold in minutes”). Borges “corrected” other aspects
Borges as Translator
45
of Klemm’s poem, as in the following excerpt that treats the raging of war: (Klemm) The battery raises its lion’s voice Six times in the land. The grenades howl. Silence. Faraway the fire of the infantry simmers. For days, for weeks.40 (Borges) The battery raises its lion’s voice One and six times. Silence. Faraway the infantry is boiling. For days. Also for weeks.41 Borges’s version is shorter and produces a slightly different effect. In Klemm’s original, hand-thrown grenades follow the batteries of tanks, and in the wake of silence one perceives the infantry’s displacements. In Borges’s version the onslaught of the infantry is more focused and threatening. He cuts the hurling of grenades by human hands, which would signal the arrival of the infantry. In Borges’s version one feels the infantry’s imminent onslaught, which follows the bombing that has prepared their arrival. In the original, somewhat in contrast, the infantry has moved away, the immediate danger has passed, but war remains an imminent threat. Borges not only transformed the poems he translated; he modified some of his own translations. The language of his second rendition of a poem by Alfred Vagts, for example, is more direct: (first version) A cloud, a cranium without a lower jaw, smoothes the field gnawed with craters. ............. The gas grenades explode like a punctured intestine, The proboscis of the carts limit their horizon to a minimum of existence.42
46
Invisible Work
(second version) A large black storm cloud [nubarrón], a skull without a jawbone, smoothes the field gnawed with craters. ............. The gas grenades explode like a punctured intestine, The snouts of the carts limit their horizon to a minimum of existence.43 The second version turns the cloud of the first into a “black storm,” which better prepares the reader for the image of a large skull sweeping across the field of battle. The substitute of “snouts” for “proboscis” makes the image of tanks as elephants more direct. Borges’s transformations of the German expressionist poems are modest, but they offer an inkling of more daring translations to come, especially after the 1930s, once he had developed the unconventional views on translation that offer a window into the creative process of the literary works for which he is best known. Borges’s encounter with Walt Whitman offers illuminating insights into his development as writer and translator.
Whitman and the Translation of Poetry Although the most visible contribution Borges made to literary culture after he left Geneva was his dissemination of German Expressionism in the Spanish-speaking world, a more profound discovery for him was the poetry of Walt Whitman. In his “Autobiographical Essay” Borges remembers coming across Whitman in 1915, when he read a poem translated into German by Johannes Schlaf.44 Soon after his discovery he acquired his own English version of Leaves of Grass, which he read with passion. For many years he would say that for him Whitman was synonymous with poetry. His excitement for Whitman did not diminish even as he was eagerly absorbing other currents of world literature. In a letter to Maurice Abramowicz dated 1919, he writes of his fervor over German Expressionism, but he adds that for him “the master continues to be Whitman.”45 One of Borges’s most consequential translations is his version of Whitman’s Leaves of Grass, which had been announced as a forth-
Borges as Translator
47
coming publication as early as 1927. It was only in 1969 that the book appeared in print. In the long interim, however, Borges developed a lively and evolving relationship with the poet he so enthusiastically admired. His earliest publication inspired by his engagements with Whitman was not a translation or an essay but “Himno al mar” (“Hymn of the Sea”) (1919), his first published poem, which appeared in the journal Grecia.46 He referred to it in a letter to Abramowicz as one of “my first Whitmanian attempts.”47 Carlos Cortínez has indicated the exact passages from Whitman that inspired the poem and explains its significance in the context of Borges’s future poetry.48 “Hymn” evinces a number of features Borges considered quintessential in Whitman, including the first person collective voice, what he once called “the vast respiration” of the Whitman’s verse,49 a sense of the erotic, and the exuberance of enumeration; but the poem also includes a pessimistic undertone informed, perhaps, by Borges’s simultaneous engagements with German expressionism: Brother, Father, Lover! . . . I enter the great garden of your waters and swim far away from the earth. ............. The waves come in with a fragile crest of foam, Fleeing towards failure. Towards the coast, with its reddish peaks, with its geometric houses, with its toy palm trees, that have become livid and absurd, like rigid memories! I am with you, Sea. And my body extended like a bow fighting against your impetuous muscles.50 Borges condemned his early poetry as shoddy imitations of Whitman, and yet in “El otro” (“The Other”), a short story from The Book of Sand, he seems to allude obliquely to this early poem with rueful fondness or irony, as if it were a poem by Whitman himself. In the fantastic story in which an old Borges meets his younger double, they discuss the significance of a poem ostensibly written
48
Invisible Work
by Whitman in which an apparent sexual encounter by the sea is belied by hints that it never took place: I remember that brief piece in which Whitman remembers a night shared with a loved one by the sea, in which he was truly happy. “Yes Whitman sang that song,” I observed, “because he desired her and it did not happen. The poem gains when we guess that it is the manifestation of a desire, and not the story of a fact.”51 The story attributes this unnamed poem to Whitman, but it could be a description of Borges’s “Hymn to the Sea” where the line “Fleeing towards failure” belies the depiction of ecstasy. In the story, the young and the old Borges have little in common except their love of Whitman, although they appreciate different qualities of the American poet. The exchange between the older and the younger Borges reflects a profound reorientation in Borges’s understanding of a poet he cherished above and beyond his different interpretations of Leaves of Grass. Borges underwent several considerable changes in his aesthetic and political views through the 1920s. In his literary biography Emir Rodríguez Monegal notes that Borges became a fervent nationalist after returning to Buenos Aires with his family from their long stay in Geneva and Madrid: “The young Borges did everything he could to become a patriotic bard.”52 In the 1920s Borges was proud of his allegiance to Argentina. Some have characterized him during this period as a populist.53 But in the 1930s he did an about face. What seemed a virtue now became a vice (“the most incorrigible Argentine vice is nationalism”).54 If only because of his rejection of nationalism, it is understandable that Borges repudiated his three books of essays expressing his most chauvinistic ideas, as well as a number of xenophobic poems he excised from future editions of his first books of poems.55 But Borges experienced other substantive changes that account for the repudiation of those early works, which were written in highly stylized baroque language—using learned loanwords and Latinate syntax—in a haughty and self-satisfied pitch that
Borges as Translator
49
bears little resemblance to what José Miguel Oviedo has called the unpretentious, affable, “serene, and cordial tone” characteristic of Borges’s essays of later periods.56 Borges went on to reject not only his style but also the substance of some of his most fundamental ideas about literature. Borges would modify in important ways his views on life and literature that he developed in the 1920s. At that time he had expressed a thought he would later reject, that all literature is autobiographical: “I can state my literary credo as the religious man states his: it is mine to the extent that I believe it, not because it was invented by me. I believe that it is universal, even in those who would like to contradict it. This is my postulation: in the final analysis all literature is autobiographical.”57 As he made this declaration, during his most nationalistic period, Borges was preparing a translation of Walt Whitman’s Leaves of Grass. In February 1927 the literary journal Martín Fierro published an anonymous note titled “A New Version of Walt Whitman” to announce Borges’s forthcoming translation. It sung the praises of his methods: Jorge Luis Borges is currently working on a translation of Leaves of Grass. It is an important enterprise, to render the compact production of Whitman into our language; and it is of particular interest to accomplish this task according to Borges’s design: to produce such a close fit with the original and its author’s innovative conception that the reader will be in contact with the most genuine Whitman and his informal style down to his vocabulary in the argot, or low-brow English, of the United States. We only know one other translation of Whitman, that by Mr. A. Vasseur, which certainly does not measure up to those standards.58 This translation was not published and, judging from the surviving fragments, it would have been notably different from the one he did finally publish in 1969, particularly with regard to his credo about literature as autobiography, a view he relinquished in favor of the view that literature is a collective, almost impersonal enterprise, as explained in chapter 1. It is possible that his reconsideration of
50
Invisible Work
Whitman itself played a part in his skepticism about those who stress “individuality” in their literary assessments. It is likely that Borges’s evolving interpretations of Whitman dissuaded him from publishing his early version of Leaves of Grass in 1927. By 1969 Borges had long abandoned the view that Whitman’s poetic voice is an autobiographical expression in any strict sense. Borges had developed a richer and more nuanced view of the matter, that the persona in Whitman’s poetry and the individual who wrote the poems bear a complex relationship with each other and with the “reader” of the poem—a relationship that is hardly autobiographical: When Walt Whitman began, he thought of his own life. He thought of having been born in Long Island, but he thought that this isn’t enough: I should have been born all over America. Then he created this very strange character, Walt Whitman, not to be taken for the writer of the book. . . . He attempted a very daring experiment, the most daring and the most successful experiment in all literature as far as I know. The experiment was this. The central character would be called after the author, Walt Whitman, but he was, firstly, Walt Whitman the human being, the very unhappy man who wrote Leaves of Grass. Then a magnification, or transmogrification of that Walt Whitman, called Walt Whitman, who was not the real Whitman at all, or at least not the Whitman his contemporaries knew, but a divine vagabond. . . . And since this person has to be a trinity—for he thought of it as a trinity— he introduced a third person. That third person is the reader. So Walt Whitman is compounded of Walt Whitman the man, of Walt Whitman the myth, and also the reader, because he thought of the reader as being also the hero of the book.59 One can detect a trace in the shift from Borges’s less nuanced approach to the autobiographical qualities of literature, to this more sophisticated view in his correction of a 1929 newspaper article he wrote about Whitman, which reappeared in Discusión in 1932.60 In
Borges as Translator
51
the newpaper article Borges considers Whitman a model for his own ideal of becoming a national poet: “I am thinking that Whitman’s destiny—a very, very human being, simplified by the alien vision of a mere giant—is an abbreviated symbol of his country.”61 Once Borges cast aside both nationalism and the notion of a transparent autobiographical significance of literature, he transformed this passage. In the 1932 version the phrase characterizing Whitman as a “very, very human being” (hombre humanísimo) becomes “a man of many inventions” (hombre de muchas invenciones).62 In the introductory note to his 1969 translation of Leaves of Grass, Borges hopes that someday it might be possible to “translate and recreate [Whitman] with total liberty,” but since Whitman’s language is too well-known to Spanish readers, Borges opted for a compromise, to “oscillate between a personal interpretation and a resigned rigor.”63 He calls his translation an interpretative recreation. A few critics have already compared Borges’s translation to the original, but they have not noticed Borges’s work as a recreator. Carmen Valero Garcés discusses many stylistic differences between the original and Borges’s version.64 Since she considers many of the differences to be deficiencies, she calls it an imperfect translation that, nevertheless, captures many essential aspects of Whitman. Frances Aparicio has a more positive assessment of the translation, which she considers faithful and “rigorously literal.”65 It is possible to examine how Borges grew more confident, more assertive of his own voice in translating Whitman by comparing fragments of the 1920s translation work on Leaves of Grass to the 1969 publication. In the poem “Once I Pass’d through a Populous City,” Whitman’s poetic voice recalls a passionate encounter with a woman he met casually and left and then remembers the woman as if she were present: “I see her close beside me with silent lips sad and tremulous.” Borges’s earlier translation is quite close, with one important modification: in Borges’s version the woman is not “sad” but “hurt” (dolida) in anticipation that she will be abandoned. The version is somewhat less narcissistic than Whitman’s original, where the woman detains the man “for love of me.” In Borges’s 1927 version he is detained “for love.”
52
Invisible Work
In Borges’s 1969 version the alterations are more dramatic. Whitman’s original and Borges’s 1927 translation conclude with the following two lines, constituting a single sentence: (Whitman) Again she holds me by the hand, I must not go, I see her close beside me with silent lips sad and tremulous.66 (Borges) Again she holds me by the hand, I must not go, I see her close beside me with silent lips, hurt and tremulous. In the 1969 translation the two lines become two independent sentences. In fact, the second sentence is separated from the first by a line space. The effect is significant: (Borges 1969) Again she holds me by the hand, she does not want me to go. I see her once again by my side with silent lips sad and trembling.67 In Whitman’s poem the woman retains him; he thinks he must not go and therefore remains and observes her. In Borges’s 1969 version, Whitman’s “I must not go” and the following comma are changed to “she does not want me to go” followed by a period. Rather than Whitman’s continuation with “I see her” following the comma, Borges offers “Vuelvo a verla,” which can mean either “I turn and see her” or “I see her once again.” By adding the word “again” in the last line, Borges breaks the continuous series of actions of the original, in which she holds him, he stays, he looks at her. In Borges’s 1969 version the final line is a new event; she holds him by the hand and asks him to stay, but he turns away from her, or stops looking at her. Then he looks at her once again. There is yet another possible reading of Borges’s translation—
Borges as Translator
53
an interpretation consistent with his inclination toward cyclical themes in his own poetry. Borges’s fondness for the cycle justifies Saúl Yurkievich’s characterization of Borges as “the circular poet,” in an essay which helped to situate Borges as one of the central figures of contemporary Latin American poetry.68 From this perspective one could read a transforming effect into Borges’s choice of the verb “volver,” an effect absent in Whitman’s original. Whereas Whitman created the illusion of reliving an event in the past, it is possible to read Borges’s version as a regression. In Whitman a vivid remembrance evokes a real presence. In the “circular” interpretation the lyrical voice also remembers having felt the woman’s presence in the past, creating an infinite regress of leaving, remembering, feeling presence, leaving again, remembering again, and so on. Had the final line of the translation read “In my human flesh, eternity keeps recurring,” the poem would have been circular without a doubt, but that line is from one of his own many poems with cyclical themes.69 Borges used Whitman’s conceit of a poem being realized in the process of reading in many of his poems, some of which bear the word “cyclical” in their titles. But he also introduced cyclical themes in more subtle ways that evoke other aspects of Whitman. In his version of those poems in Leaves of Grass in which the lyrical voice anticipates the presence of a future reader, Borges tends to depersonalize Whitman’s poetic voice. Thus, Borges renders Whitman’s “To conclude, I announce what comes after me” as “To conclude, I announce what will come afterwards.”70 In the poem “Full of Life Now,” Whitman invokes those who will read him in the future and says, When you read these I that was visible am become invisible, Now it is you, compact, visible, realizing my poems, seeking me, Fancying how happy you were if I could be with you and become your comrade; Be it as if I were with you. (Be not too certain but I am now with you.)71
54
Invisible Work
Borges modifies the poem somewhat. He simplifies the grammar of the first line and transforms the search for Whitman’s self, through the reading of the poem, to a search for the poem itself. Accordingly, the presence of the poem is more certain than the poet in Borges’s version: When you read them [my songs], I that was visible will be invisible, Now it is you, concrete, visible, who reads them, who seeks them, Fancying how happy you would be if I were by your side and were your friend; Be as happy as if I were by your side. (Do not be too sure that I am not with you). Borges used and adapted Whitmanesque interjections by the poetic voice of an implied writer directed to an implied reader in many poems and short stories. In “To Whoever May Be Reading Me,” Borges offers an inversion of the theme of the writer who may be present with the reader, by exploring the mortality of the “invulnerable” reader who happens to be reading the poem. The poem begins with the line: “You are invulnerable,” and ends with the idea that in reading the poem “in some way you are already dead.”72 The poem “G. A. Bürger” is another variation on the theme. Here a poet has been meditating on Bürger, a nineteenth-century German poet from Göttingen with whom he feels affinities (and whose name resembles Borges’s own). As the poem concludes, Borges’s lyrical voice expresses the idea that the dead poet is actually writing as he is finishing the last lines of the poem, or perhaps even as the reader is reading them: “Bürger is alone, and now / precisely now, he files a few poetic lines.”73 To read Borges’s version of “Once I Pass’d through a Populous City” as a cyclical poem is to assume a consistency with other transformations in his translation of Leaves of Grass. In the section titled “Children of Adam,” for example, there is a poem called “Ages and Ages Returning at Intervals,” which Borges translates as “Cicli-
Borges as Translator
55
camente vuelvo al cabo de largas edades”74 (cyclically I return at the end of long ages.) The idea of a recurring experience is clearly in Whitman’s title, but Borges’s title evokes Nietzsche’s notion of “eternal return.” Our reading of Borges’s translations of some poems by Whitman as cyclical fits with other translations in which Borges unambiguously interpolates cyclical themes. In his translation of a Herman Hesse poem, for example, Borges transforms the intimation of a specific religious experience, perhaps reincarnation, into powerful suggestions of the eternal return. The conceit of the original involves the substitution of the veils of worldly perception for a Godly dress. The poem opens with the image of the veils falling: “Again I see the veils go down, / and the familiar becomes unfamiliar.”75 In the original the first person poetic voice, the familiar, becomes unfamiliar. In Borges’s version, the first person singular voice becomes a plural voice for which the notions of the intimate and the eternal are dissolving: “Once again in front of my eyes, there are descending veils. / What is most intimate and eternal, moves away from us.”76 In the original, there are intimations of “earlier births” and, perhaps, of future ones: “From earlier births / distant presentiments are flashing.”77 In Borges’s version the intimation is of cyclical time: “I have the presentiment of something vague, something vague and remote / that comes to me from lives, from previous cycles.”78 Hesse’s poem ends with the image of a Godly garment woven from the shattered threads of the previous experience: “From torn threads is woven a new and more beautiful garment of God.”79 Borges’s version involves a possible allusion to writing, which replaces the specific reference to God in the original: “The plot unravels, and the Inspiration weaves, / more ungraspable and beautiful, its renewed finery.”80 The changes in this Hesse poem were not accidental, and the five poems Borges translated with Roberto Alifano are all personal recreations. The poem “Irgendwo” (somewhere) begins in the original with the line “I wander [irr ich] through the desert of life, glowing,” which Borges translates as “Blind, I cross the desert of life.”81 In Borges’s version the word “blind” carries a double meaning not
56
Invisible Work
present in the original: the poetic voice is blind in that it does not know where it is going, but “blind” can simultaneously be read as an allusion to Borges’s own blindness. Borges also transforms a love poem by Hesse into a metaphysical poem offering literary allusions not found in the original. Both Hesse’s original and Borges’s version begin with the conceit of a lover’s dark world in the loved one’s absence. Hesse follows with, That you know a golden mean in the turbulence [dem Getribe] of life, made you and your love for me a good spirit.82 Borges transforms the original: That in this world of chaos and death you reveal the true path to me and be my shepherd and my Virgil by the light of your love that will be a star.83 Hesse’s poem concludes with the notion that the woman’s love will be life’s core of goodness (“Lebens süssen Kern”). In Borges’s version her immense love will instruct him “to perceive the primordial sources.”84 Hesse’s love poem in Borges’s pen becomes a salute to Dante. His references to Virgil and to the stars, absent in the original, can be read as allusions to the Paradiso.85 Borges’s transformations of Hesse, or of Whitman, are not limited to metaphysical themes. As Fernando Alegría has pointed out, Borges transforms some of Whitman’s poems of homoerotic love into poems of heterosexual love. In a poem that reads, “I am satisfied, I dance, laugh, sing: / as the hugging and loving bed-fellow sleeps at my side,” Borges makes the “bedfellow” an unambiguous feminine character.86 Borges does not delete all references to homoeroticism in the collection. He includes several poems in which a man is in love with another man. My own conjecture is that Borges did not mean to ignore the homoerotic contents of Whitman’s
Borges as Translator
57
poetry but to explore, in Whitman’s voice, various types of erotic experience. Alegría has argued that in his translation of Whitman, Borges felt freer to explore erotic themes he avoided in his own poetry. According to Alegría, “It is quite possible that no Hispanic translator has ever equaled Borges in his masterful versions of Whitman’s ambiguous sexual poems.” Borges’s translation of Whitman involves a selection from a larger work (Leaves of Grass), but it reads like a coherent whole. He used the same approach in his subtle version of the Cheribunischer Wandersmann (1675), a mystical work by Johannes Scheffler (1624–1677), who assumed the name Angelus Silesius after his conversion from Protestantism to Catholicism. Borges’s book, translated in collaboration with María Kodama, is a bilingual edition, Spanish with the German original, of 101 rhymed couplets that Borges translates into short aphorisms in unrhymed poetic prose. Borges states that his version is “an aid for the good comprehension of the text.”87 The translation, however, like his translation of Whitman’s Leaves of Grass, oscillates between a literal and personal recreation. The original is a lyrical meditation on the relationship between man and God. In the original, man has being and access to divinity by God’s grace. God’s being is self-contained and yet diminished without the loving attention of his human creature, superior to the angels because free to behold or ignore his creator.88 Time, for Silesius, is therefore more noble than eternity. In time man makes the choice to love or not to love his God. Borges, who wrote essays on the refutation of time, might have been more interested in Silesius’s meditations on the relationship between time and eternity in themselves than in the contradictions through which the mystic attempts to approach God. In his translation Borges nuances Silesius’s search, and ultimate attainment, of God as expressed with images from the natural world, including such flowers as the rose, lily, and tulip and such animals as sheep, eagles, and doves. Of these Borges only translates the couplets involving the rose, a recurrent symbol—in his own poems, short stories, and essays—of the unattainable for which literature can be a consoling compensation. Consider one of Borges’s preferred lines in the writings of Silesius:
Invisible Work
58
“The rose is without why, it blooms because it blooms.”89 As a text by Borges the line can be interpreted, as Adelheid Hanke-Schefer has done, as a meditation on “being without cause or end,” a notion Borges used, occasionally to discuss his aspirations as a writer.90 Once, when asked to indicate his greatest literary ambition, Borges responded, “to write a book, a chapter, a page, a paragraph that is everything for all men . . . that is the rose without why, the platonic and intemporal rose of Silesius’s Querubinsicher Wandermann.”91 In the context of Silesius’s religiosity, however, the “rose without why” is not a metaphor for literary ideals but an affirmation of God’s presence and perfection in nature. In Borges’s translation, the relationship between man and God is one of parity. This is not the case in the original, where God’s experience of himself would be diminished without man but where God is also presented as man’s superior. Borges does not translate any of the poems with themes such as baptism, sin, or those addressing the redemptive power of Christ. His work as translator, but also as editor, is marked by a post-Schopenhauerian sensibility in which the human being gains a certain parity, codependency, or even superiority with regard to God. Some couplets from Borges’s translation of Angelus Silesius can be interpreted differently depending on whether one thinks of the author or the translator. There are, however, also texts in his translation of Angelus Silesius that Borges transformed. The following couplet by Silesius holds that God would be diminished without man; Borges’s translation presents God as superfluous without man: (Silesius) Man is the Highest Thing Nothing appears to me to be too high; I am the highest thing, because God without me is diminished in size.92
Borges as Translator
59
(Borges) The Highest Is Man Nothing seems high to me. I am the highest. God is nothing without me.93 Rather than affirming humanity’s highest place in the order of creation, so high that God would be diminished without man, Borges’s translation reads almost as a precursor to the Nietzschean negation of the divine. The couplet titled “Gott schaut man mit Gelassenheit,” which can be translated as “one sees God with composure,” is transformed by Borges as “We see God with abandonment”: (Silesius) One sees God with Composure The Angel looks at God with cheerful eyes I however, even with more happiness, since I can leave God.94 (Borges) We see God with Abandonment The angel looks at God with serene eyes. I see him much better if I can abandon him.95 Borges’s change of cheerful eyes to “serene” and the elimination of “happiness,” coupled with the notion of abandonment, transforms Silesius’s original from the joyful contemplation of God by a being who has the freedom to turn away from his creator, to the sobering suggestion that man can abandon God. Borges also changes the dynamic of the place (“Der Ort”) in Creation, which must be forsaken to experience eternity, into a more radical Schopenhaurian notion that space and time are both prod-
Invisible Work
60
ucts of the will. In the original, “there is a place” will be replaced in the future by eternity. In Borges’s translation, space, time, and eternity are simultaneous: (Silesius) The Place Is in You You are not in the place, the place is in you. If you were to get rid of it, eternity would already be here.96 (Borges) Space Itself Is in You Space is in you. You are not in space. Reject it. Eternity is already here.97 The final couplet of the book, which Borges had quoted in German concluding the essay “A New Refutation of Time,” suggests a relationship between being and writing: (Silesius) Conclusion Friend, it is enough. In case you want to read more, therefore, go and become the writing as well as the being.98 (Borges) Conclusion Enough, friend. If you want to go on reading become the book and its stuff.99
Borges as Translator
61
In the original the relationship between writing and being involves the word of God and man; in Borges’s version it entails the dissolution of being into literature.
Poe As with his translations from verse, in his translations of narrative fiction Borges does not hesitate to omit details, cut sections, or change emphases to recreate an original. Borges revered Poe’s “The Purloined Letter” as one of the most accomplished stories in the genre of detective fiction and, yet, did not hesitate to enact any number of daring adjustments of style and content when translating it with Adolfo Bioy Casares for Los mejores cuentos policiales (1943), an anthology of detective fiction. Borges venerated Poe’s imagination but disparaged his writing skills. He often said that Poe is a writer that one enjoys when remembering his tales, not while reading them in English. Borges praised Baudelaire for vastly improving the style of Poe’s tales in his French version, and he energetically enacted stylistic alterations in his translations of “The Purloined Letter” and “The Facts in the Case of M. Valdemar,” which he also translated.100 He eagerly looked for synonyms to translate around Poe’s repetitions and deleted sections he considered superfluous. Compare a passage from “The Purloined Letter” with Borges’s version: (Poe) “Perhaps it is the very simplicity of the thing which puts you at fault,” said my friend. “What nonsense you do talk!” replied the Prefect, laughing heartily. “Perhaps the mystery is a little too plain,” said Dupin. “Oh, good heavens! who ever heard of such an idea? “A little too self-evident.” “Ha! ha! ha!—ha! ha! ha!—ho! ho! ho!” roared our visitor, profoundly amused, “oh, Dupin, you will be the death of me yet!” “And what, after all, is the matter at hand?”
62
Invisible Work
(Borges) “Perhaps the mystery is too simple,” said Dupin “What is the mystery?” I asked.101 In this passage Borges not only simplifies but eliminates the notion of the mystery being “too self-evident,” an elision consistent with his creative recreation of the tale. Borges compresses Poe’s verbose periphrasis to the essential core. Consider the following fragment: “It is clearly inferred . . . from the non-appearance of certain results which would at once arise from its passing out of the robber’s possession—that is to say, from his employing it as he must design in the end to employ it.” Borges simplifies: “We know it . . . from the nature of the document, and from the fact that certain results would have arisen if the document were not in possession of the robber.”102 Borges also sharpens some of Poe’s points. Before his demonstration that it is relevant to the case that the thief is a poet, Dupin discusses a mathematical equation to show that the thief’s being a mathematician is also irrelevant: I never yet encountered the mere mathematician who . . . did not clandestinely hold it as a point of his faith that x2 + px was absolutely and unconditionally equal to q. Say to [a mathematician] by way of experiment, if you please that you believe occasions may occur where x2 + px is not altogether equal to q, and, having made him understand what you mean, get out of his reach as speedily as convenient, for, beyond doubt, he will endeavor to knock you down. I mean to say . . . that if the Minister had been no more than a mathematician [the Prefect] would have solved the mystery. Borges’s Dupin puts the matter more succinctly: I have not met an algebrist who would not profess as a clandestine point of faith that (a + b)2 is unconditionally equal to a2 + 2ab + b2. Say to one of these gentlemen that in cer-
Borges as Translator
63
tain occasions (a + b)2 may sometimes not be strictly equal to a2 + 2ab + b2, and before you finish your sentence run away so he will not destroy you. . . . 103 Borges’s version is more elegant. A fundamental theorem of algebra is more likely to be a “point of faith” than Poe’s arbitrary equation with one variable and two constants. Borges’s stylistic changes are minor, however, compared to his modifications of content. In the story, Minister D. steals a woman’s letter before her very eyes. She cannot call attention to the theft because she wishes to hide the existence of the letter from another person present as the theft takes place. In Poe’s original the owner of the letter is probably the Queen of France. Poe identifies the thief as a “Minister D.” but does not indicate the purpose of the theft. Perhaps the letter contains evidence of illegitimate love or political intrigue, information that must be kept secret for the common good, or any number of other possibilities. Poe is clear that the owner of the letter is a woman, but Borges deliberately obfuscates the character’s gender. In Borges’s version the content of the letter may indeed compromise a lady, but the owner of the letter is not necessarily a woman. In the original the prefect of the Parisian police tells Dupin that he has information “from a very high quarter” regarding the theft of an important letter. Borges translates “a very high quarter” as “un alto funcionario” (a highly placed male functionary from the royal house).104 The usage of the word “funcionario,” suggesting the anachronistic idea of a civil servant, is not a casual one. It also appears in the original, albeit in a different context. Poe uses the word “functionary” several times in the story to refer to the prefect. Each time Poe does so, Borges substitutes “prefect” for “functionary.” Borges choses to use the term “funcionario” to refer to the individual who informs the prefect of the letter’s theft. Borges, therefore, invents a character who does not exist in the original, “the functionary.” In his version, a male functionary, not a female as in the original, informs the prefect of police about the theft. In the original version a woman is alone in her room reading a
64
Invisible Work
letter. She is interrupted by another person who enters the room and from whom she wishes to conceal the missive. Minister D. enters, notices the letter, and steals it with the woman’s knowledge but unbeknownst to the person who entered the room. In the original both the reader of the letter and the unnamed person who enters the room are referred to as an “exalted personage.” The woman then confides in the prefect of police, Monsieur G., who consults with Auguste Dupin and with the narrator of the story. Borges’s version involves more characters. The owner of the letter is not necessarily a woman; in fact, it may well be that the recipient of the letter is the character Borges invented, the “functionary,” that is to say, the man who communicates to the prefect of police that the letter was stolen from the royal quarters. The letter may indeed compromise a lady, but Borges is judiciously establishing an ambiguity not in the original: the letter belongs either to a man who is involved romantically or politically with a woman of importance, or it belongs to the woman herself. When discussing “The Purloined Letter” Borges specified that his “functionary” is a male “politician”: “In his story ‘The Purloined Letter’ Poe presents a politician who has been robbed of a very important letter.”105 This statement by Borges is consistent with his own translation of the story, but not with the original. In Borges’s translation the victim of the theft could be a man, as per Borges’s own interpretation of the story, or a woman, as per the splendid ambiguity in his text. In his version the indication that a woman of stature could be compromised by the contents of the letter and, therefore, that she may have been the victim of the theft in the first place is not offered until the very last paragraphs of the story, when Dupin expresses his political solidarity with the “compromised lady” (Borges) (“lady concerned” [Poe]).106 Even if the victim of the theft is a woman in Borges’s version, his translation differs from Poe’s original in that there the reader knows unambiguously from the outset that the victim of the theft is female. Borges creates this ambiguity of gender, where Poe does not, by eliminating all feminine articles and personal pronouns indicating the feminine gender of the thief’s victim. Instead, he refers to the character with Spanish words such as “persona” or “víctima,”
Borges as Translator
65
words with the grammatically feminine ending but that do not indicate the gender of the individuals to whom they are applied; Borges also refers once to the victim as “el dueño” (the owner), in context a word grammatically masculine but gender nonspecific. Borges is also thorough in eliminating all clues suggesting the woman’s noble status. Compare a text of the original with Borges’s translation. In Poe’s version the illustrious personage, unannounced, enters the room of the woman reading the letter: (Poe) The document in question—a letter, to be frank—had been received by the personage robbed while alone in the royal boudoir. During its perusal she was suddenly interrupted by the entrance of the other exalted personage from whom especially it was her wish to conceal it. After a hurried and vain endeavor to thrust it into a drawer, she was forced to place it, open as it was upon a table. (Borges) The document—a letter to be frank—was received by the victim of the possible blackmail, while alone in the royal quarters. Almost immediately, a second individual from whom the first individual especially wanted to hide the letter, entered. The individual in question barely had enough time to leave it, open as it was upon a table.107 In Borges’s version the individual who receives the letter is not referred to with the personal pronoun she. Ella in Spanish would have indicated her gender as in the English version. The substitution of “habitación real” (royal quarters) for “boudoir” erases another indication as to the character’s gender. “Boudoir,” a French word used in English and Spanish, would have indicated that the place of the theft was the salon or private room of a woman. The translation suggests that the theft took place in a less intimate place of the royal palace. Borges’s version eliminates the word “exalted,” erasing another clue that—in Poe’s version—the character could be
66
Invisible Work
the Queen of France. Borges also adds a phrase: “the victim of the possible blackmail.”108 The word blackmail (“chantaje”) is not in the original, and although the reader might surmise that blackmail could be involved in the theft of the letter, Poe designed to keep the use of the letter ambiguous. For example, he uses the word “employment” to refer to the possible use of the letter: “It is clear . . . that the letter is still in the possession of the minister, since it is this possession, and not any employment of the letter, which bestows the power. With the employment the power departs.”109 Borges exchanges the ambiguous notion of “employment” for the notion of “sale”: “It is evident . . . that the letter is still in the possession of the minister: in that possession lies his power. Once the letter is sold, his power ends.”110 In the original the purpose of the theft involves political motivations. The prefect indicates that the letter has “been wielded for political purposes.”111 Borges omits this statement to remain consistent with the suggestion that the letter was used for the purposes of financial extortion. The implications of Borges’s modifications are hardly trivial. They reorient the focus of the story from the circumstances of the victim to the relationship between the detective and the thief. What matters in Borges’s story is the interplay between two minds trying to outwit each other in their attempts to anticipate the other’s thought process, while aware that the other is doing the same. Borges downplays the sections in which Poe’s Dupin, the prototype of Sherlock Holmes and other famous literary detectives, indicates that he solves the crime by not overlooking the obvious and emphasizes the significance of understanding the mind of an opponent to solve a mystery. To this end Borges eliminates three long passages of the original, in which Dupin insists that the solution to the mystery unfolds on “account of its being so very self-evident.”112 In Borges’s story several aspects hovering in the background of the original move to the foreground: both the detective and thief are French poets; they have had an encounter in Vienna in which one was humiliated by the other; their current confrontation offers the opportunity for the loser of the previous encounter to humiliate the winner; they may have further encounters in the future; and, finally, they leave literary clues for each other to indicate that one
Borges as Translator
67
of them—and nobody else—has triumphed over the other. In chapter 3 we will see that Borges’s transformation of Poe’s story played a crucial role in the gestation of “La muerte y la brújula” (“Death and the Compass”), one of Borges’s signature tales, in which the criminal and the detective play a game similar to the one played by Dupin and the minister, with kabbalistic rather than literary clues.
Reyes and Chesterton At times Borges edited the work of other translators while leaving his distinctive mark on their texts, on occasion even signing his own name to such a work. Borges and Adolfo Bioy Casares admired Alfonso Reyes’s translations of Chesterton to such an extent that they corrected and republished one of them as their own.113 Borges sent a letter, cosigned with Bioy Casares, to request discretely that Reyes allow them to publish his translation of Chesterton’s “Honour of Israel Gow” for their anthology of detective fiction. In his response Reyes does not oppose their initiative, although he intimates that the rights of the translation belong to the estate of his editor: México. D. F., November 17, 1943 Sr. don Jorge Luis Borges Dear Jorge Luis and Adolfo: Thanks for your letter dated October 23. . . . Israel Gow is honored. Let us hope the estate of Calleja does not object because it was their property. Do not forget to send me your anthology of detective fiction. I am following your writings when I can. I always remember you and I am very fond of you both. (A.R.)114 True to his literary tendencies, Borges did not simply publish Reyes’s translation in its original form. He restored, for example, the original title of “The Honour of Israel Gow,” which Reyes had translated as “The Honesty of Israel Gow.” Whereas Reyes retained
68
Invisible Work
every sentence of the original, making minor shifts of nuance and emphasis, Borges and Bioy Casares excised and cropped. The greatest mystery of Chesterton’s story involves a bewildering clue. On a table, several objects lay arranged at intervals; objects about as inexplicable as any objects could be. One looked like a small heap of glittering broken glass. Another looked like a high heap of brown dust. A third appeared to be a plain stick of wood. On the table in Reyes’s translation lay several objects forming separate lumps, objects as inexplicable as they are inconsonant. One little lump appeared to contain the fragments of a broken glass. Another was a heap of brown dust. The third object was a walking-stick.115 The same passage in Borges’s modifications becomes several objects as inexplicable as they are inconsonant. One appeared to be a little lump of broken glass. The other was a lump of brown powder. The third object was a walkingstick.116 In the original the objects are “as inexplicable as any objects could be,” highlighting the strangeness of each. Reyes modifies this phrase to “as inexplicable as they are inconsonant,” calling attention to the lack of commonalties among the objects, which is precisely what needs to be underscored to produce the sense of mystery the story requires. Reyes could have used the word marrón to translate “brown” but chooses “moreno,” which in Mexico suggests a brownish skin color. Borges accepts Reyes’s suggestion but uses “pardo” the equivalent of moreno in Argentine speech. Reyes calls the third object a “walking-stick,” whereas Chesterton, at this juncture, called it simply a “stick,” identifying it more clearly as a “walking stick” only after the mystery is revealed. Reyes refers to the three objects as “montones” (heaps), whereas Chesterton uses the word “heap,”
Borges as Translator
69
once for the broken glass and again for the brown dust. Borges corrects the inconsistency in Reyes’s version and restores it to the original. Reyes added a comma in the sentence that describes the second object, calling more attention to it than to the other objects. Borges restores the original by eliminating the comma. These various alterations make evident Borges’s care in comparing Reyes’s translation to Chesterton’s original in fashioning his own version. But it is also clear that Borges took liberties to ensure that the story would conform to his own view that Chesterton’s genius lay in his ability to present inexplicable situations that, even once demystified with a prosaic explanation, continue to disconcert. Borges composed beautiful pages about those stories in which Chesterton presents a mystery and offers a demoniacal explanation that is finally corrected by a mundane fact overlooked by all concerned. Father Brown, Chesterton’s most famous detective, “wants to explain an inexplicable fact with reason.” The word “inexplicable” in Chesterton is used to suggest the presence of a fantastic element. Borges at times lamented Chesterton’s mundane explanation of his tales’ irrational elements because, for Borges, they had a force and life of their own. Borges was fascinated by those stories of Chesterton’s that suggest the presence of invisible men, maneating dolls, empty corridors where frightening creatures are “seen” by a variety of people, including father Brown when he thinks he has seen the devil himself. For each of these occurrences, and many others, Chesterton offers a logical explanation that had been hidden by a mistaken perception of a fact or wrong inference. But Borges did not appreciate the explanations. In fact, he felt that Chesterton’s best fictions were those that confounded their author’s intentions, namely, those stories where the fantastic element convinces to the point that the mundane explanation feels somehow inadequate. Borges’s reading of Chesterton illuminates one of his own extraordinary achievements: the combination of the fantastic with the detective genre. In the translation of “The Honour of Israel Gow” Borges cuts Chesterton’s interjections, once the mystery is resolved, that downplay the uncanniness of the story by stressing the psychological oddness of the characters. All the apparently inexplicable objects in ques-
70
Invisible Work
tion were once embedded in gold, which Israel Gow removed after he inherited the gold of the family he had served for many years. Chesterton follows this revelation with an image of collective relief: “The garden seemed to brighten, the grass to grow gayer in the strengthening sun, as the crazy truth was told.” Borges deletes this sentence and other suggestions that shift the focus from the uncanniness of the evidence to the psychology of its characters. When Reyes read the anthology of detective fiction, he congratulated Borges and Bioy Casares for their transformation of his translation: “I have been delighted to see the story by Chesterton transformed with an independent esthetic entity by its accidental translators. As a connoisseur, I have appreciated the fine touches.”117
Translating Names and Titles Some of Borges’s changes affected subtle elements rather than global aspects of the stories he translated. Borges, who wrote himself into many of his fictions, helps Edgar Allen Poe do the same. In his translation of Poe’s “The Facts in the Case of M. Valdemar,” Borges refers to the mesmerizer who narrates the story as Poe. And, poignantly, for our purposes, M. Valdemar (a Spanish name with the French qualifier “M.” in Poe’s version and “Monsieur” in Borges’s) was, as Poe makes clear, the Polish translator of Wallenstein and of Gargantua, under the pen name Issachar Marx. The subtleties compound. Another of Borges’s customs is to change the titles of the stories he translated. His version of Jack London’s “The Minions of Midas” is called “The Concentric Deaths,” and his version of Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “Mr. Higginbothom’s Catastrophe” is titled “The Repeated Deaths.”118 Borges often alters titles that reveal the ending. His translation of Stevenson’s “Something in It” is “There Is Nothing to These Stories” (“En esas historias no hay nada”). In Stevenson’s tale, an antecedent, perhaps, to Borges’s story “El etnógrafo” (“The Ethnographer”), a missionary scorns the fables of the “natives” he intends to convert to his own religion. The proselytizing priest hears a story about a certain potion offered to the dead
Borges as Translator
71
in the netherworld before they are delivered to Miru, their god. The priest dies and, in the realm of the dead, refuses the potion. Then Miru decides to return him to life. The priest is no longer dismissive of the stories he has heard but, on returning to the realm of the living, takes refuge in equivocation: “Perhaps there is not much in it as I supposed; but there is something in it after all. Let me be glad of that.”119 Borges’s version produces an effect different from the original’s. Stevenson’s tale suggests there is something to the otherworldly stories from the very beginning, from the title in fact, and this is confirmed at the end. In Borges’s version the title suggests that the stories are superstitious nonsense. But this suggestion will be altered. The final line reiterates the idea, before underscoring a change of mind: “There is nothing to those stories, but there is something to them after all. That makes me happy.” Borges’s version, by contradicting its own title, appears somewhat less skeptical of the story’s fantastic twist than the original.
Borges’s Arabian Stories Another practice of Borges as translator was to participate actively in the reception of literary works that have been transformed as they have been handed down in time, such as the tales from the Arabian Nights. As we have already observed in chapter 1, Borges was fond of celebrating the chain of translations that brought those stories from Hindostan to Egypt where copyists supplemented the collection with new stories. Borges applauded the cunning of Antoine Galland, who continued the practice by enriching the original with new tales. He also admired the interpolations of Richard Burton. And Borges joined both of them in transforming Arabian stories. Borges rewrote a story from Galland’s translation of the Arabian Nights, the original title of which is “The story of the Blind Man Baba-Abdalla” and which Borges translates as “The Story of Abdula, the Blind Beggar.” Borges compresses the story in two significant ways: by virtually eliminating its long introduction, retaining only the essential fact that a Caliph encounters a beggar who
72
Invisible Work
asks to be slapped in the face after receiving his alms, and, more significantly, by eliminating from the conclusion the protracted narration of the beggar’s feelings of religious guilt, the basis for the original story. Borges changes the point of view of the revelation from the first person to the third and places that revelation at the beginning, not the end of the story: (from Galland’s conclusion) I had to resolve to beg, and that is what I have been doing until the present; but, to expiate my crime against God, I impose upon myself the punishment of a slap in the face from every charitable person who would have compassion for my misery.120 (from Borges’s introduction) The blind beggar who had sworn he would not receive any alms unaccompanied by a slap in the face, told the Caliph the following story. Borges recreated Galland’s version of the tale by removing the religious moralizing of the man whose greed led to his blindness. In Borges’s version the blind man seeks the contempt of others to atone for his guilt.121 Borges’s transformation resonates with the ethos of his own tale “La forma de la espada” (“The Shape of the Sword”), in which a traitor asks to be despised for his perfidiousness, more than with the French original, in which the protagonist suffers for his sins against God. Borges also pretended to have translated Arabian stories that were actually of his own creation. Before publishing “Historia de los dos Reyes y de los dos laberintos” (“The Two Kings and the Two Labyrinths”), as his own short story, Borges had published the tale as “a translation” from Richard Burton’s The Land of Midian Revisited (1879).122 But even when “The Two Kings and the Two Labyrinths” appeared as an original work of his own in the 1952 edition of El Aleph, Borges wrote an explanatory postscript in which he indicates that it may, after all, be a translation of sorts. He writes that it is
Borges as Translator
73
the kind of story copyists interpolated into the Arabian Nights, adding that Antoine Galland refused to translate this kind of tale in his French version of the tales.123 In the story “The Two Kings and the Two Labyrinths” Borges emphasizes precisely those religious elements excised from his translation of Galland’s version of “The story of the Blind Man Baba-Abdalla.” The transformation is not frivolous and makes sense in context. Borges perhaps chose to eliminate the pious aspects from his translation of Galland’s story because they are unrelated to the plot. In Borges’s apocryphal Arabian story, on the contrary, the protagonist prays for divine intervention, and God responds. The shift in moral tone in Borges’s Arabian stories is also evident in his version of a medieval Spanish tale by Don Juan Manuel. The original is called “De lo que contesçió a un deán de Sanctiago con don Yllán, el grand maestro de Toledo” (on that which took place to a deacon of Santiago with don Illán, the grand master of Toledo), which Borges transformed into “El brujo postergado” (the postponed magician). Several critics who have analyzed Borges’s version of the tale have argued that the only changes Borges made involved wording. Marta Ana Diz has set this misconception straight, pointing out that, even though Borges borrowed Don Juan Manuel’s plot, his version differs so significantly from the original that one can rightfully consider them two different stories. In both stories a deacon visits a magician to gain knowledge of his occult powers. The magician appears willing to oblige, but (without the knowledge of his guest) he conjures up the illusion that a few minutes are expanding into many days. The deacon believes, as does the reader, that he is ascending the hierarchy of the Catholic Church on his way to becoming the pope. At that moment the magician reveals the illusion and sends the deacon away from his home. While the deacon lived the illusion that he was gaining power and influence, he never offered a hint of gratitude to the magician. As Diz points out, a major difference between the two stories is Borges’s elimination of the moralizing elements of the original: “[The] moralizing elements move to the background so that magic can become the focus of the story. From a frustrated relationship between a master and a disciple in Don Juan’s story, Borges’s ac-
74
Invisible Work
complished version dramatizes a relationship between enemies.”124 According to Diz, Don Juan Manuel’s story is about a test, and Borges’s story is about a trap. In Don Juan Manuel’s version the magician offers the deacon many opportunities to fulfill his promise to repay him for his services, pointing out the deacon’s mistakes and begging him to mend his ways. All of the magician’s reproaches are eliminated from Borges’s version. In Don Juan Manuel’s story, the failure of an individual to pass a test exemplifies his moral shortcomings. In fact, the deacon’s visit to a master of dark powers is itself suspect in the original. In Diz’s reading of Borges’s version, the test is a perverse triumph of the magician over his guest. It is also possible to read Borges’s version as the process whereby a magician tries to decide— without any of the moralizing or demonic connotations of the original story—whether or not an individual is worthy of becoming his disciple. Borges offers a variation on the theme in his story “La rosa de Parcelso” (“The Rose of Parcelsus”), in which a magician opts to conceal his magical powers from a skeptical disciple. The magician, in Borges’s tale, prefers to gain the reputation of a charlatan than to reveal his secret knowledge to an unworthy soul.125
Kafka, the Fragment, and the Dream Borges recreated many short stories he translated, but he also placed fragments of literal translations into his own works. In his “Poema conjectural” (“Conjectural Poem”), as is well known, Borges includes a literal translation of a line from canto 5 of Dante’s Purgatorio: “Fleeing by foot, leaving a bloodstained trail.”126 The poem depicts an Argentine man killed in the civil wars following independence from Spain. Francisco Laprida, the protagonist, had wanted to be a man of letters, but his destiny was to die at the hands of gauchos he considered barbarians. The poem is not only an inverted allegory of Borges’s nostalgia for a heroic age and a political commentary on the advent of Peronism but, more poignantly, his attempt to fill a gap in a passage from the Divine Comedy.127 “Conjectural poem” can be read also as a brilliant complement to Dante’s canto tale, which begins exactly at the moment where the poem
Borges as Translator
75
ends: when a military man is losing his life from a wound to his throat.128 Borges also assembled new works of fiction based on his translations. For example, he created a story he attributed to Kafka, based on short fragments and aphorisms scattered in posthumously published volumes of Kafka’s works, without indicating his procedure. Isolated, the short texts by Kafka are self-contained. Borges, however, creates a powerful story called “Four Reflections,” based on four connected experiences: the first evokes the need to make virtue out of necessity; the second depicts the paradox of a mighty illusion of power that is underpinned by impotence; the third is a parable addressing the inevitability of defeat; and the final one is an almost humorous observation of the social scruples that preclude escaping misery through suicide.129 Borges changes significantly the vocabulary of the third reflection, a parable about hunting dogs at rest on a patio but that will inevitably capture a fleeing deer in the forest. Borges substitutes a rabbit for the deer in Kafka’s German text, perhaps to allude to a version of Zeno’s paradox, the kind Borges often brought to bear when discussing Kafka. Borges was able to emulate some of Kafka’s literary resources, but he could not transfigure Kafka the way he transfigured most writers he translated.130 At his most daring, Borges was able to alter subtly one of Kafka’s innovative ideas. His translation of Kafka’s “The Truth about Sancho Panza” involves a subtle, but consequential change in vocabulary. In the brief parable, Sancho Panza is depicted as a man haunted by a demon. To neutralize his demon, Sancho is assisted by many novels, especially romances of chivalry. Later, he names his demon “Don Quijote” and decides to follow him in his wanderings. To qualify the performance of Don Quijote’s wildest dreams, Kafka uses the German adverb “haltlos” suggesting a lack of restraint. Borges translates “haltlos” as “desamparado” (forsaken), which suggests both abandonment and helplessness in Spanish. If Kafka’s original highlights the wild adventures of the don in the first part of the novel, Borges’s translation underscores the despair of Cervantes’s protagonist in the second part, which he preferred.131 Sometimes Borges shifted the emphasis of a story by adapting
76
Invisible Work
its context. His version of Kakfa’s “Die Sorge des Hausvaters” (the concerns of a family man) is titled “Odradek” in his Book of Imaginary Beings. The title is an invitation to read the text as a description of an impossible being, thereby underplaying the story’s psychological and theological dimensions. In his translations of shorter works, Borges at times took the kernel of a fragment out of context to create a distinct effect. He was fascinated, for example, by the ancient Chinese story of ChuangTzu, who dreams he is a butterfly but on waking must consider that he may be the butterfly’s dream.132 Many critics have noticed the importance of this tale for Borges, but to my knowledge no one has noticed that Borges significantly transformed the anecdote in several different translations. Borges fashioned his brief versions of the story from longer texts by Herbert Allen Giles and other nineteenth-century sinologists. He included versions of the story in anthologies and literary journals, recreated it in many poems and stories, and discussed it in numerous essays.133 Borges first published a version of the fragment as a story in the Anthology of Fantastic Literature (1940), which he edited with Bioy Casares and Silvina Ocampo: (from “Dream of the Butterfly” in Anthology of Fantastic Literature) Chuang-Tzu dreamt he was a butterfly. Upon awakening, he did not know if it was Tzu who had dreamt he was a butterfly or if he was a butterfly and was dreaming it was Tzu.134 In 1946 he published a new version of the story that he reprinted in Cuentos breves y extraordinarios (brief and extraordinay stories) (1955), an anthology of very short stories he edited with Adolfo Bioy Casares:135 (from “Chuang-Tzu’s Dream” in Cuentos Breves y Extraordinarios) Chuang-Tzu dreamed he was a butterfly but did not know when he awoke if he was a man who had dreamt he was a butterfly or a butterfly who was now dreaming it was a man.136
Borges as Translator
77
A noticeable variant between the two versions is the title. The first version’s title is ambiguous, signifying either a dream about a butterfly or a butterfly’s dream. If the entire story is the butterfly’s dream, the short text produces a vertiginous effect of regress because the dream of the butterfly begins with Chuang-Tzu dreaming he is a butterfly, awakening, and wondering whether he is Chuang-Tzu or the dream of a butterfly. In the second translation the title is unambiguous: “Chuang-Tzu’s Dream.” The second version of the little story is shorter (just one sentence), plainer, with no infinite regress, and it conserves the most significant conceit of the initial version: whether it is Chuang-Tzu who has dreamed he was a butterfly, or whether Chuang-Tzu is the butterfly’s dream. Both versions are creative recreations. Borges cites Herbert Allen Giles as his principal source for the story. In fact, when he includes it in the volume Cuentos breves y extraordinarios, Giles appears in the index as its author. That being said, Giles’s text is not an original work but a translation, considerably longer than the text Borges attributes to him: Once upon a time, I, Chuang-Tzu, dreamt I was a butterfly, fluttering hither and thither, to all intents and purposes a butterfly. I was conscious only of following my fancies as a butterfly, and was unconscious of my individuality as a man. Suddenly, I awaked, and there I lay, myself again. Now I don’t know whether I was then a man dreaming that I was a butterfly or whether I am now a butterfly dreaming that I am a man. Between a man and a butterfly there is necessarily a barrier. The transition is called Metempsychosis. Showing how one may appear to be either of two.137 Borges crops and curtails the sinologist’s version in his literary renditions. He eliminates the first person voice, which gives preeminence to the man, in favor of a more impersonal third person narrative voice, and he suppresses the sentence indicating that during his dream Chuang-Tzu is oblivious of being Chuang-Tzu. Borges knows exactly what he is doing. In a different context, in his essay “A New Refutation of Time,” he offers yet another translation
78
Invisible Work
of the anecdote, in which he includes the idea that in the dream Chuang-Tzu lost his sense of self when he dreamt he was a butterfly: “I dreamt I was a butterfly that was moving in the air and that knew nothing of Chuang-Tzu.”138 Borges quotes this sentence in his essay to reinforce his discussion of the “psycho-physical parallelism” between the two beings. The possibility that two distinct beings appear in each other’s dreams is not excluded in the two versions Borges published as stories, but those versions are also open to other interpretations: they could be about a single being who does not know whether its life is a dream, or an allegory about the fragility of the imagination. Borges’s two literary versions, as well as the version he included in his metaphysical essay, are related more closely to his own tales and poems of dreams within dreams than to a religious vision involving the mutation or transmutation of beings that might have informed the original Chinese tale. Many variations of this anecdote in Borges’s fictions and poems resonate with his translation of a fragment by Novalis: “Dreams show us the malleability of our soul, its gift to penetrate any object, and to turn itself into it.”139 The pervasiveness of dreams and dreams within dreams in Borges’s fictional world has been noted by many critics including Jaime Alazraki, Saúl Yurkievich, and Teodosio Fernández.140 Claudio César Montoto has pointed out that some major stories by Borges can even be read as complex dreams in the sense that their twists and turns might evoke the interventions of dreamers struggling with their dreams in the process of dreaming.141 Drawing on one of the most venerable traditions of Hispanic literature, Borges often compared life as a dream one cannot control (and a source of literary ideas) to literature, a dream that can be shaped and reshaped not only by an individual but by generations. Alazraki has remarked that Borges’s interest in Old Germanic literatures can be explained in part by the significance that dreams have in the ancient sagas. Teodosio Fernández has developed this point proposing that Borges’s interest in the Nordic sagas is due to their dream-like qualities. He identifies several short stories in which Borges introduces elements from Icelandic sagas to imbue his stories with oneiric suggestions:
Borges as Translator
79
It is not hard to find links between his interests for those medieval literatures and stories such as “El espejo y la máscara” (“The Mirror and the Mask”) “Undr,” and “El disco” (“The Disk”) from The Book of Sand, with its Nordic characters and Nordic atmosphere. The use of those possibilities culminates perhaps in “Ulrika.” . . . The encounter between Ulrika and Jacier Otálora in the city of York, an encounter which—like in the old Scandinavian world—unfolds as if it had not taken place, as if it had transpired in a dream.142
The Prose Edda Borges’s version of Snorri Sturluson’s Prose Edda,143 his last major translation, can be read as the culmination of his explorations of the literary dream. The Prose Edda was written in Iceland in the early thirteenth century. According to François-Xavier Dillman it “constitutes the most complete, the most coherent, and the most intelligible compilation of Nordic mythology that has come down to us from the Scandinavian Middle Ages.”144 Borges would add, in his introduction to the saga, that Snorri’s interest in Icelandic mythology was not religious but literary: “Snorri did not believe in the almost forgotten mythology, as he probably did not believe in Christianity either, but he was correct in judging that it was necessary to understand skaldic poetry” (the traditional Norse poetry of the Viking age).145 In his Antiguas literaturas germánicas (1951), the first book published in Spanish treating old Germanic and Scandinavian literatures, Borges offers the following summary of the Gylfaginning, the Prose Edda’s central literary and mythological section: Gylfi is a Swedish King versed in the art of magic who takes up the form of an old man and arrives at the castle of the gods. He tells them his name is Gangleri and that he has come by the roads of the serpent, which means that he is lost. In the hall there are three gods in three seats one on top of the other; these seated gods are called High, Equally High, and
80
Invisible Work Third. Gangleri hears from their lips the story of the beginning and of the end of the world, according to the Voluspa.146
In his book on ancient Germanic literatures, Borges chose to interpret the Gylfaginning as a story about deceit. Nevertheless, he left open a possibility that would become the major emphasis of his translation, some thirty years later, that the core of the tale depicts the dreamlike quality of life. According to Borges the entire work may be “illusory; the gods have deceived the king, but they themselves are a deceit.”147 In his translation of the Prose Edda, Borges concentrates on the Gylfaginning, the most literary section of the Nordic masterpiece, and he removes passages that diminish the original’s most artistic qualities. The excized sections include the introduction that brands the saga as the bearer of an inferior pagan mythology superseded by Christian doctrine. As he had done in his translations of Martin Buber, the Arabian Nights, and “The Postponed Magician,” (his version of El Conde Lucanor’s medieval Spanish tale), Borges removes divine elements from the original to emphasize magical aspects and dreamlike qualities of fiction.148 He is also imaginative in titling the work “Gylfi’s Hallucination.” The original Old Norse “Gylfaginning” would have been translated more literally as “the deluding of Gylfi,” suggesting the tricks in the saga played on Gylfi as well as on other unsuspecting heroes. But Borges’s choice of “Hallucination” erases the divine flavor of the title, which underscores the gods’ ability to deceive mortals. A substitution of the notion of “hallucination” for that of “deception” provided an orientation for the meaning of Borges’s translation. In his version the gods have produced a hallucination for Gylfi, but they themselves may be a hallucination. Borges is shifting an action perpetrated by the gods into a personal experience partially induced by the gods. The systematic translation of deception into hallucination is at the core of Borges’s version. For example, in the original the god Thor is deceived by the magic of the god Utgarda-Loki. In Borges’s version Utgarda-Loki prepares a series of hallucinations that Thor will experience in a
Borges as Translator
81
castle. The original wording “I have tricked you with magical shapechangings” becomes “I planned a series of hallucinations for you.”149 In the original, Utgarda Loki explains the source of Thor’s deception as his own fabrications and subsequently makes the castle disappear. Borges transforms the world into a dream that unfolds to Thor as another hallucination, hiding the realities that remain true in the realm of Utgarda-Loki. Thor’s return to a reality that conceals another level of reality prefigures the end of the Gylfaginning, when the hall and the gods that Gangleri had encountered vanish into oblivion: (Jesse Byock’s literal translation) Next Gangleri heard loud noises coming at him from all directions. He looked to one side, and when he looked back again he was then standing outside on a level plane. He could see no hall and no fortress. Now he left and traveled back home to his kingdom, where he told of the events that he had seen and what he had heard. And after him people passed these stories down from one to the other.
(Borges) Gangleri heard loud noises all around him and when he looked he saw he was outdoors in open air and there was neither hall nor castle. Then he proceeded walking and returned to his kingdom and he told those things he had seen and heard, and after him people continued telling them.”150 Whereas in the original Gylfi returns home to report on the experiences he had with the gods who deceived him; in Borges’s version the protagonist appears to be returning to normality after experiencing an extraordinary hallucination, as one who awakes from a spectacular dream. The original is a tale of divine magic deceiving the human mind. Borges’s version is a story of life as a dream. Beyond this fundamental change Borges’s translation offers many examples of his lyrical abilities at their most concentrated. The origi-
82
Invisible Work
nal is composed of fifty-four distinct prose sections, many of which are accompanied by skaldic poems that often serve as commentaries or summations. Borges translates the whole work in prose but puts the poetic sections into italics as lyrics in prose. These lyrical sections include inspired moments of poetic intensity, as in Borges’s “Dark will be the shining of the sun” for the original “The sunshine becomes dark.”151 Borges changes the original in which the sun is extinguishing to a powerful image where the sun is emitting darkness. Borges’s lyrical intensity in his free version of the Gylfaginning can be gleaned in comparison to versions by scholars translating the Old Norse more literally. Take two examples: (Byock) Loathsome are for me the mountains, I was not long there, only nine nights. The howling of wolves seemed ugly to me compared to the song of swans. (Borges) Deserving of hate were the mountains for me. I was not in them for a long time; nine were the nights. Atrocious was the howling of wolves after the swan song.152 And (Byock) I could not sleep on the beds of the sea for the screeching of the bird. That gull wakes me who comes from the wide sea each morning.
Borges as Translator
83
(Borges) In the beaches of the ocean I was not able to sleep. I was troubled by the sea birds. They woke me every morning when they came from the ocean.153 Borges’s transformations combine his erudition, his own lyricism, and his inclination to take liberties. Take for example the episode in which Gylfi arrives at Odin’s home Valhalla, the hall of the slain, in the form of an old man. He observes “a hall so high that he could scarcely see over it. Golden shields covered its roof like shingles.”154 This passage is followed by a skaldic poem that has been translated faithfully by Jesse Byock: (Byock) On their backs they let shine, when they were bombarded with stones, hall shingles of Odin, the men thinking wisely. (Borges) Over their shoulders, the skillful seamen transported the shingles of Odin’s hall which they had polished with stones.155 To understand this passage it is important to realize that “a shingle of Odin’s hall” is a kenning (or skaldic periphrasis) for a warrior’s shield. This understanding increases one’s admiration for the acute lyrical economy of Borges’s translation. The stones that pelted their shields in battle become the stones that polished the shields of these heroes, suggesting not only their valor in battle but also their pride as tested warriors. Borges had already used the metaphor of polishing to express the passage of time in the story “The Man on the Threshold” (“El hombre en el umbral”), where he describes a very old man similarly: “Many years had reduced and polished him, like water polishes stone or generations polish men, to a sentence.”156 The elegant economy of the metaphor Borges added to his translation of the lyrical passage from the Prose Edda suggests a feeling for the Vikings’ heroic way of life.
84
Invisible Work
In this translation Borges does not always indicate, as in the original, the gender of his characters. For example, he eliminates the gender differences of the planets in a passage where he downplays sexual tensions to produce an effect of serenity. Notice that Borges in the following passage removes the male gender from the sun and the female gender from the moon: (Byock) Sun did not know where she had her home. Moon did not know what strength he had. The stars did not know where their places were. This was before the earth was created. (Borges) The sun did not know where its home was. The moon did not know its power. The stars did not know where they were. This was before the earth was made.157 In other sections Borges discovers ingenious solutions to deal with the differences between Spanish and Old Norse with respect to gendered words. In Germanic languages the sun is feminine and the moon masculine; the opposite is the case in Spanish. Borges uses the Old Norse word “Sól” as a proper name for a female sun, and the Old Norse word “Máni” as a proper name for a male moon. Sections in the original read as if Borges is writing, or rewriting, his own tales. In the passage dealing with the origins of anthropomorphic life, a cow licks salty blocks of ice, either incurring or creating a being. In the original, “the hair of a man” appears on the first day, “a man’s head” on the second, and “the whole man” on the third. In Borges’s version, on the first day “hair” appears, on the second “a head,” and on the third a “man.” Borges’s version is more ambiguous and suggestive than the original. The conceit of the creation of a being in the Gylfaginning is reminiscent of Borges’s
Borges as Translator
85
“Las ruinas circulares” (“The Circular Ruins”) in which a man dreams another man into existence, one body part at a time. There are also sections of the Prose Edda that can be interpreted as corrections of other works he translated. A passage describing impossible objects reads as a correction of his own translation of “The Honour of Israel Gow,” in the light of his critique of Chesterton’s propensity to give prosaic explanations to his powerful uncanny inventions. Borges thought that the uncanniness of Chesterton’s sequence of strange objects turned the prosaic explanation into bathos. In the Prose Edda the description of a sequence of impossible objects is followed by an equally uncanny explanation. Borges was so taken by this passage of the Gylfaginning that he translated it twice, once in 1951 in his book on old Germanic literatures and a second time in 1984 in the translation we have been discussing. It is instructive to compare the 1951 translation of the passage with the 1984 version on account of a few slight but significant modifications, the most important of which is the removal of the word “delusion” from the 1951 version, also systematically removed from other sections of the work to stress a dream-like atmosphere: (Borges, 1951) It was constructed from six elements: the noise of a cat’s footsteps, the beard of a woman, the roots of a mountain, the sinews of a bear, the breath of a fish, and the spittle of a bird. Though previously you had no knowledge of these matters, you can quickly see the proof that you have not been deluded; you will have noticed that a woman has no beard, a cat’s movement makes no loud noise, and mountains have no roots. Truly, I say, all you have been told is equally reliable, although you will have no way to test some things.158 (Borges 1984) It was made of six things: the sound of the footstep of a cat, the beard of a woman, the root of a steep rugged rock, the sinews of a bear, the breath of a fish, and the spit of a bird.
86
Invisible Work And although you still don’t understand this matter well, you will have the proof that I am not lying: you must have noticed that a woman does not have a beard and that a passing cat makes no noise and that there are no roots under rugged rocks. And, on my faith, everything I have told you is no less certain although there are some things you cannot put to the test.159
In the 1984 translation Borges interpolates into the Prose Edda a number of effects characteristically his own: experiments with the representation of time. In the original, for example, there is a passage addressing the agony of waiting experienced by a god. Borges transforms the passage evoking a theme he had explored elsewhere, namely, the contraction and expansion of time. The original ends with the suggestion that the waiting time of days has the feeling of months. Borges’s version, in addition, suggests that each day feels longer than the previous one: (Byock) Long is one night, Long is another. How will I suffer through three? Often a month seemed less to me Than half this waiting time. (Borges) Long is one night, long is a second one. How will I do to wait for a third? There was a time in which one month would pass sooner than that first night.160 In another passage Borges transforms the tantalizing idea of a character living throughout the ages into the even more fantastic idea of a being who “lives simultaneously in all ages.”161 Borges’s version of Snorri Sturluson’s Gylfaginning is the last of his major publications. It is the culmination of his exploration of the literary
Borges as Translator
87
dream. It is also a catalogue of his methods as translator, and its themes resonate with those he pursued throughout his literary career.
Borges’s Method as Translator Borges’s main goal as a translator was to create a convincing work of literature. This principle is at play in his literal translations and recreations, as well as in his faithful and unfaithful ones. Setting aside stylistic issues (difficult or impossible to explore in a book such as this, directed to English-speaking readers), five stratagies cover the cases studied in this chapter. (1) Borges’s most common practice as a translator was to remove what he once called the “padding” of a work: words and passages that seem redundant, superfluous, or inconsequential. (2) He removed textual distractions. This stratagem involves cutting part of the content of a literary work that might distract attention from another aspect Borges would prefer to highlight. (3) Borges often added a major or minor nuance not in the original: changing a title, for instance. (4) Borges sometimes rewrote a work in the light of another, as when he inscribes a post-Nietzschean sensibility to his translation of Angelus Silesius. (5) He sometimes included a literal translation of a work in one of his own works. Borges’s translations are often daring, but they remain identifiable with their originals: they are still versions of the same works even when they have acquired Borgesian touches. He reserved his most adventurous moves as translator to fashion some of his best known literary works. Borges’s translation process, therefore, has been seminal in his work as creative writer.
chapter 3
Translation in the Creative Process In the end all literature is translation. —Novalis
T
he majority of Borges’s short stories include at least one character who translates, and these characters are often the protagonists. Many of his fictions are presented as implied translations, many translated excerpts or fragments are inserted into the body of his writings, and many real and imagined translations play either hidden or transparent roles in the gestation or contents of his fictions.1 Borges’s translations offer illuminating insights into his creative process, and his general approach to translation is fundamental to our understanding of his art. Recognizing the significance of translation for Borges allows us to trace the creative practice underlying the invention of a brand of fantastic fiction that posits impossible objects and connects them with characters driven by unusual designs or endowed with extraordinary attributes (such as a perfect memory or immortality). Since Borges is best known as a writer of narrative fiction, the bulk of this chapter treats some of his best known tales in order to exemplify the different ways in which he integrated translation into his writings. The last few pages of the chapter will explore how his approach to translation has implications in his creative process with respect to works he did not translate, but treated as texts he did translate: as raw material he could adapt into the fabric of his fictions. 88
Translation in the Creative Process
89
Our starting point is “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius,” considered by many his most ambitious and far-reaching story. It is a tale that combines his peculiar brand of fantastic literature, his panache for transforming philosophical ideas into literary themes, his interest in minor genres such as detective fiction and science fiction, his explorations of exotic worlds, his ironic humor, and his political and psychological anxieties. The story can be read as the translation of the universe as we know it into another universe which functions according to assumptions drawn from the speculations of philosophers who think the world is composed of perceptions rather than independent objects that our five senses can identify. But linguistic translation (as in the rewriting of a series of words into another) plays an even greater role.2
“Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius” The protagonist of “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius” uncovers, with the help of others, an extravagant conspiracy involving innumerable individuals who, over several generations, have been fashioning an alternative universe. The conspirators have produced a collective work, an encyclopedia, in which a universe called Tlön behaves according to a version of philosophical idealism. The story moves from the outlandish to the fantastic when the palpable universe, down to its physical laws, begins to transform itself into Tlön according to the designs of the conspirators. In this brave new world, the five senses are no longer coordinated, and nothing is necessarily identical to itself. One need only imagine an object for it to materialize, but the existence of objects is not continuous. Things disappear and are duplicated according to the vicissitudes of consciousness, memory, and the imagination. To illustrate the peculiarities of Tlön, the narrator discusses the difficulties in translating a sentence from Tlön’s Ursprache, the conjectural language (akin to our Indo-European) from which all other languages in Tlön can be deduced: “there is no word corresponding to the word ‘moon,’ but there is a verb which in English would be ‘to moon’ or ‘to moonate.’ ‘The moon rose above the river’ is hlör u fang axaxaxas mlö, or literally: ‘upward behind the on-
90
Invisible Work
streaming mooned.’ ”3 This phrase is an instance of Borges at his most magical. His comment on translation is both engagingly believable and useless for any serious attempt at reconstruction of Tlön’s Ursprache. But that awkward-seeming translation shows an exquisite linguistic sense. It is intended to represent differentiated grammatical features the reader is in no position to identify. The reader must suspend disbelief to accept the existence of a language that corresponds to a world constituted of independent events rather than of independent objects, because Borges does not offer sufficient information to reconstruct such a world in the first place. Borges cleverly conflates two different strands in his story: (1) a secret society’s plot to imagine a universe that works according to the principles of a philosophical view akin to Bishop Berkeley’s idealism, but without a god who would guarantee the continuity of objects or coordinate the experiences of the five senses; and (2) a universe working according to the same principles that slowly takes over our own. He is also superbly imaginative in presenting the transformation in transition, when visible effects of the conspiracy are becoming noticeable but before the obliteration of the world as we know it, that is to say, before our universe becomes unintelligible to Tlön. In Borges’s story the creation of the encyclopedia has a direct bearing on the radical transformation of the universe, but the change also requires the willing participation of many individuals. The idea that human beings can will the transformation of the physical universe is a wild fantasy inspired, perhaps, by Schopenhauer’s conception of the world as will and representation.4 Borges, however, does not and cannot offer a blueprint for a humanly willed transformation of the natural laws of the universe any more than he can give us the rules of Tlön’s Ursprache, because he is creating the spellbinding illusion of an impossible world. Any coherent explanation of the transformation would undermine the fantasy Borges is creating and lay bare its extravagant premises. Borges’s tale is persuasive because his characters take for granted the transformation he delineates, not because his readers can understand how it has taken place. Borges presents so persuasively both the conspiracy and the pathos of his protagonist as he struggles with the unbearable consequences
Translation in the Creative Process
91
of the transformation of his universe that his readers willingly accept the preposterous premises of his clever tale. The rewards for accepting this artifice are considerable because Borges manages to draw momentous consequences from his impossible world that have little bearing on its coherence. The encyclopedia that transforms the universe—the imposition of a universal order concocted by some individuals and imposed upon others—has dire consequences that Borges invites his readers to consider as an allegory of totalitarianism. The narrator, initially fascinated by the attempt to imagine an alternative universe, is horrified by the change that is taking place and dismayed by the willingness of humanity to accept it. With bitter, understated irony the narrator explicitly compares the transformation of his universe to the rise of Nazism, anti-Semitism, and Stalinism: “Ten years ago any symmetry with the appearance of an order—dialectical materialism, anti-Semitism, Nazism—would enchant. Why not submit oneself to the meticulous and vast evidence of an ordered planet?”5 The narrator’s comment is consistent with Borges’s fears, expressed in his political essays of the 1940s, that Fascism and Communism would gradually triumph and undermine individual freedom.6 The narrator protests stoically against a transformation he fears and abhors. While all the Indo-European languages are being replaced by languages based on Tlön’s Ursprache, he decides to translate Sir Thomas Browne’s Urn-Burial (or Hydriotaphia) into Spanish. He does not, however, intend to publish his translation; that would be pointless. Why publish the translation of a text of a disappearing language into another disappearing language in a world where humanity “enchanted, by the rigor of Tlön, is forgetting once and again” that Tlön is obliterating the known world?7 Why publish anything in any of the languages suggested by the title of the story–Germanic (Tlön), Semitic (Uqbar), or Latinate (Orbis Tertius)? There is no better commentary on Borges’s story than his own translation, in collaboration with Adolfo Bioy Casares (who appears as a character in the story), of the fifth chapter of Sir Thomas Browne’s Urn-Burial, where we focus on an interpolation not found in the original:
92
Invisible Work Many more facts have been buried in silence than registered, and the most copious volumes are but epitomes of what has taken place. The chronicle of time began with the night, and obscurity still serves it; some facts never see the light; many have been declared; many more have been devoured by the obscurity and the caverns of oblivion.8
Borges’s interpolation underscores not only the fragility of memory, but the dark origin and conclusion of matters destined for oblivion. The interpolation is consistent with other changes he made to the Urn-Burial that resonate directly with the ethos of “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius.” The comment also results from many years of reflection on the work of Browne. Borges first translated a long fragment of the fifth chapter of the Urn-Burial in an essay featured in Inquisiciones (1923). In the essay he expresses his admiration for the beauty of Browne’s prose —an admiration he would maintain his entire life—but also for Browne’s “paradoxical heroism,” exemplified in his decision to persist in his speculations about beauty in response to a civil war that had broken out around him: “Browne was inspired by the paradoxical heroism with which he ignored the insolence of war, persisting in an endeavor of thought, placing his sights in a pure speculation of beauty.”9 To exemplify the meditative beauty of Browne’s prose, Borges translates two fragments he appreciates. The first, from the Religio Medici, expresses Browne’s distaste for national allegiances or prejudices (a sentiment that may have influenced Borges’s own transformation from a fervent nationalist to a resigned cosmopolitan). The other is a long passage from the Urn-Burial.10 The long fragment from the Urn-Burial begins with “the iniquity of oblivion” and ends with Browne’s affirmation of the nobility of humanity when humbly recognizing the vain illusion of those who seek everlasting fame and glory. Borges’s translation carefully excises sections of the passage referring to the “sufficiency of Christian mortality” in Browne’s original. In Borges’s text humanity’s humble acknowledgment of vanity and the affirmation of beauty over the inevitability of oblivion are not couched in terms of Christian redemption. The fragment contained within his 1923 essay is
Translation in the Creative Process
93
an early draft of a full translation of the fifth chapter of Urn-Burial, published in 1944, after “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius” was already in print.11 Browne’s affirmation of Christian salvation over the illusions of wealth and power are transformed by Borges, in both the 1923 fragment and the 1944 translation, into the affirmation of ephemeral beauty. In the original Browne makes the poignant claim that “to be nameless in worthy deeds, exceeds an infamous history,”12 which Borges subtly strengthens in his 1944 translation by turning “nameless” into “anonymous,” and “exceeds” into “is worth more,” emphasizing human choice in confronting an “infamous history.”13 If Browne’s Urn-Burial is a meditation on the stoic values rewarded in the afterlife, Borges’s translation articulates a quiet protest in the face of obliteration. The pathos of Borges’s Urn-Burial translation, akin to that of “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius,” is a recognition of the contingencies of human history, and a silent disavowal of human vanity. Thus, the story’s narrator responds to the palpable transformation of the universe into Tlön by translating the Urn-Burial, a text in which Sir Thomas Browne poignantly addresses the chimeras of those who expect to subsist “in lasting monuments.” Shortly before writing “Tlön,” Borges published an article to express his outrage at the exclusion of Jewish authors, and other writers who did not sympathize with the National Socialists, from German literary life and from accounts of German literary history. Borges found it obscene that in Germany the speeches of Hitler and Goebbels were presented as literary models, while “Goethe, Lessing, and Nietzsche have been distorted and mutilated.” Borges indicated in passing, that an equal disregard for culture had developed in Russia, whose revolution Borges considered “a generous hope” that degenerated into a new version of Tsarism. The essay concludes with an expression of his outrage at the German situation: “I find it insane to . . . perfect the criminal arts of barbarians.”14 The triumph of Hitler, for Borges, represented the obliteration of those aspects of German culture he most admired. He wrote “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius” in 1940, when he publicly deplored the “indisputable truth . . . that the directors of the Third Reich
94
Invisible Work
are procuring a universal empire, the conquest of the world.” And he decried, with bitter irony, the indifference of those who had not yet taken a stand against National Socialism: “It is childish to be impatient; Hitler’s charity is ecumenical; in short (if the traitors and Jews don’t disrupt him) we will all enjoy the benefits of torture, rape, and mass executions.”15 Borges’s outrage against anti-Semitism was not new. In 1934, when he was labeled a “Jew” by Argentine detractors wanting to disparage his literature, he responded with an article called “I, the Jew,” in which he branded his critics as inquisitorial while expressing his identification with the Jewish people.16 Suzanne Jill Levine describes Borges’s situation, as he was writing the story, with accuracy when she speaks of his “wartime alienation from his fellow Argentines during those terrible years of WWII when many of his friends were praising Hitler and National Socialism, and when he wrote some of his best fiction.”17 Indeed, as he was writing “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius,” the Second World War was raging, and in his journalistic essays Borges was condemning Nazism with an argument paralleled by the plot of his story. Ideas concocted by men can inflict deadly effects on humanity. Current predicaments can result from philosophical speculations that take on a life of their own, that impose themselves upon human affairs many decades after first conceived. In his article, Borges argues that the rise of German Nazism and Soviet Communism, two political movements he despised, can be understood precisely in these terms. To grapple with the implications of political events in the contemporary world, intellectuals require a vision that looks to ideas of the past rather than to ideas of the present, whose effects, if any, will only be felt in the future: “Political events derive from much older theories, and often a great deal of time might elapse between the formulation of a doctrine and its application. . . . Hitler, so horrendous with his public armies and secret spies, is a pleonasm of Carlyle (1795–1881) or even J. G. Fichte (1762–1814); Lenin, a transcription of Karl Marx. That is why the true intellectual refuses to take part in contemporary debates: reality is anachronous.”18 Harold Bloom falls into an unintentional Borgesian trap when he reads the postscript of the story dated 1947 as an addition to a story published in 1940. The 1947 postscript, like the prophetic epilogue to Borges’s
Translation in the Creative Process
95
complete works that summarizes an encyclopedia entry dated 2074, was a willful anachronism intended to surprise his contemporary readers. Bloom does, however, get to the heart of the matter, even if he does not realize that Borges wrote the story while the outcome of the Second World War was far from decided: “Borges, a skeptical visionary, charms us even as we accept his warning: reality caves in all too easily.”19 In his final gesture, as reality is caving in, the narrator of “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius” does not translate Browne’s Urn-Burial into modern Spanish but, rather, in the style of Quevedo’s seventeenthcentury Spanish. Christopher Maurer offers insights regarding the significance of Quevedo in Borges’s later poetry that shed light on the narrator’s choice for his translation: “There is a certain stoic calm in Borges’ later verse which I cannot help but associate with Quevedo. [Both] write of detachment from human passions and calmness in the face of death.”20 To exemplify Quevedo’s presence in Borges’s stoicism, Maurer discusses “Religio Medici,” a poem from El oro de los tigres (The Gold of the Tigers) bearing the same title as a book by Browne. Maurer quotes a fragment of the poem before offering his persuasive gloss: “ ‘Defiéndete de mí [Defend yourself from me]. The words were spoken / By Montaigne and Browne and a Spaniard I forget.’ That Spaniard was probably Quevedo: ‘Desnúdate de mí [disrobe your self of me].’ Certainly the idea is his.” Borges’s Quevedian stoicism found frequent reiteration in his work, including one of his later poems, a Haiku that reads: “The old man / continues to trace verses / for oblivion.” If the “old man” were a translator, the poem would be a summation of “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius” and of Borges’s translation of Sir Thomas Browne’s Urn-Burial. The protagonist of “Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius” is one of a long series of Borgesian imagined scribes who translate and whose practice as translators has a bearing on the stories in which they appear.21 In “Pierre Menard, Author of the Quixote,” the catalogue of Menard’s “visible work” includes several translations. Before embarking on his attempt to produce some pages identical to those that already appear in Don Quijote, therefore, Menard translates.22 Menard’s bibliography includes a French translation of a Spanish trans-
96
Invisible Work
lation by Quevedo that ostensibly restores the original French.23 Albert, the sinologist of “El jardin de sederos se bifurcan” (“The Garden of Forking Paths”), translates a vast work of Chinese literature by an ambitious man who relinquished political power in order to write it. James Nolan Ryan in “Tema del traidor y del héroe” (“Theme of the Traitor and the Hero”) translates several Shakespeare plays into Gaelic, including Julius Caesar, which prefigures the events of the story. Hermann Soergel of “La memoria de Shakespeare” (“Shakespeare’s Memory”) translates one act of Macbeth but decides against translating the remainder of the play, arguing that German lacks the Latinisms he needs to produce a version that would satisfy him.24 His reverse anticipates a more surprising failure—his inability to gain insights about Shakespeare’s creative process—in the tale’s fantastic twist, when he inherits the bard’s memory. Soergel realizes that it is not Shakespeare’s memory but his imagination that offers the key to his creativity. His genius consisted in translating the commonplace into the vivid: “Chance or destiny gave Shakespeare those terribly trivial things that every man knows; he knew how to transmute them into fables, into characters more vivid than the gray man who dreamed them, into lines that generations will not let go, into verbal music.”25 Among Borges’s translators of kabbalistic literature are Marcel Yarmolinsky, the victim of the first murder in “La muerte y la brújula” (“Death and the Compass”), and Jaromir Hladík of “Milagro secreto” (“The Secret Miracle”). They both translated the Sepher Yezirah. The kabbalistic book was especially important for Borges as a source of literary ideas, as Jaime Alazraki has indicated, because it is the first systematic formulation of the notion that the Hebrew alphabet’s written characters constitute the foundation of Creation, and that God begat the cosmos combining them according to a secret order.26 In “Death and the Compass” a translation of Yarmolinsky’s book History of the Sect of the Hasidim gives Scharlach information he needs to lure Lönnrot into a trap. The fame of Nils Runeberg in “Tres versiones de Judas” (“Three Versions of Judas”) depends, in part, on the translation of his works into German. In “La busca de Averroes” (“Averroës’ Search”) the Islamic philoso-
Translation in the Creative Process
97
pher cannot offer a translation of Aristotle’s Poetics concomitant with modern versions because he does not realize that the words “drama” and “comedy” involve the dramatic arts. In a penetrating analysis of the story as, among other things, an essay on translation and language, Marcelo Abadi counterposes Borges’s interest in a literary exploration of the barriers between languages and realities in the process of translation, on the one hand, with a more subtle theme, on the other hand, about the insignificance of such considerations in light of human suffering.27 Some of Borges’s stories focus on characters frustrated by or distrustful of the translating process, for one reason or another. Among those characters who leave a translation unfinished is the above-mentioned Herman Soergel, and Gannon from “La otra muerte” (“The Other Death”). Gannon abandons his lyrical version of “The Past” because “Spanish literature is so tedious that Emerson becomes unnecessary.”28 There are also characters who refuse to translate material easily available to them. The American graduate student of anthropology in “El etnógrafo” (“The Ethnographer”), from Elogio de la sombra (In Praise of Darkness), refuses to reveal the secret of the indigenous community where he has undertaken his field work, not because English is insufficient for the task (“I could spell it out in a hundred different and even contradictory ways”), but because Western science seems to him to be “a mere frivolity.” One of the most common openings of a Borges fiction is a short text by a narrator who introduces a translated manuscript constituting the body of the story. With this conceit Borges honors Cervantes’s invention of an imagined Arab source that must be translated by an unreliable scribe so that the narrator of Don Quixote can write the story of the rueful knight. As in Cervantes, Borges’s narrators are often not in a better position than the reader to understand the contents of the text they have decided to offer to a reading public. These many stories include clarifications regarding the kind of translation the narrator is presenting. In some cases the manuscript is described as a translation of a probable translation. In others, as in “Undr,” it is presented as the translation of an interpolation in a translation:
98
Invisible Work I must warn the reader that the words that I translate will be searched for in vain in the Libellus (1615) by Adam of Bremen. . . . Lappenberg found them in a manuscript in the Bodleian at Oxford and judged them to be, given the number of circumstantial details, a late interpolation, but he published it, as a curiosity, in his Analecta Germanica (Leipzig 1894). The opinion of a mere Argentine amateur is worth little; let the reader judge them as he wishes. My Spanish version is not literal, but it is faithful.29
In “El informe de Brodie” (“Brodie’s Report”), the narrator who introduces the story indicates that he discovered the manuscript signed by David Brodie in a volume of the Lane translation of the Arabian Nights (1840). The translating narrator, who believes the manuscript must have been written shortly after 1840, transposes some of the indigenous words of the source language into Englishsounding words. He indicates that his translation is a literal one with two exceptions: he decided to eliminate biblical quotations as well as a passage about the sexual practices of the story’s “apemen” (also called Yahoos), discretely rendered in the manuscript in Latin. Any reader of Borges’s tales is well advised not to dismiss as gratuitous any section that is the description of an imagined translation presented as the body of a story introduced by the story’s narrator; each such section requires sustained analysis. The significance of this narrative strategy—structuring a story made up of a translator’s note indicating the nature of an imagined translation that follows as the main body of the story—can be illustrated by analyzing Borges’s “El inmortal” (“The Immortal”), a tale inspired perhaps by Virginia Woolf’s Orlando (which Borges translated) in that its protagonist lives multiple lifetimes and experiences more than one self.
“The Immortal” In the story a man drinks from the river of immortality and becomes an immortal. Hundreds of years later the same man drinks from a river of mortality to regain his mortality. The story is com-
Translation in the Creative Process
99
posed of three sections: an editorial introduction by the translator of a manuscript, the text of the manuscript itself, and a postscript commentary on the reception of the manuscript. The anonymous translator indicates that the manuscript was found in the copy of Alexander Pope’s Iliad, once in the possession of a bookseller called Joseph Cartaphilus, whose name, an allusion to the wandering Jew, is a clue to associate this character with both the contemporary and ancient individuals mentioned in the manuscript. To differentiate him from the unnamed editor and translator of the manuscript and because the postscript indicates that the manuscript was attributed to him, I will refer to Cartaphilus as its author. With the exception of the title, the Spanish in the story copies the original English, according to Borges’s definition of a copy: a transparent rendering of a text from one language into another. Both the editor and Cartaphilus wrote in English, but the manuscript appears to Borges’s readers in Spanish. Of greater significance is the note from the editor: “the original was written in English and abounds in Latinisms. The version we offer is a literal one.”30 The narrator certifies that his translation is literal, despite having rendered all the Latinisms in flowing contemporary English. He has not, however, extracted the Hellenisms that appear in the English manuscript as oddities. The note that indicates the nature of the translation is crucial. A translation of the Latin idiosyncrasies of the author’s non-native English prose would add nothing to what the author claims about his own identity: that he was a Roman tribune. This is hardly the case, however, with the Hellenisms the translator chose to retain, for they suggest an acquaintance with a language the tribune did not know when he set out on his quest for immortality. Borges used a similar conceit in the introductory section of “La secta de los treinta” (“The Sect of the Thirty”) describing the translated manuscript a narrator is publishing: “The original manuscript . . . is in Latin but a Hellenism here and there justifies the conjecture that it was translated from the Greek.”31 To appreciate the significance of the Hellinisims in “The Immortal,” one must slowly unravel Cartaphilus’s fabulous autobiographical tale. He claims he was Marco Flavinio Rufo, a Roman who drank from the waters of the river of immortality. The highlights of
100
Invisible Work
his adventures are his encounter with Homer when the author of the Odyssey, also an immortal in the story, could barely remember the poems he had composed; the conflation of his own experiences with those of Homer; and his quest to regain his mortality, which, as the manuscript closes, the reader is assured has been achieved. The text abounds in Homeric locutions, some of which are identical to those Borges has discussed in “Homeric Versions” and in other essays devoted to Homeric translations. An example is the epithet “black” (which Borges speculated could be an obligatory addition to certain Homeric words rather than a qualifying adjective). The translator copies “the black shadow,” “the black pedestal,” “black labyrinths,” among other examples, because Cartaphilus writes them in his idiosyncratic English. If the first clue to unravel the mysteries of the story is the presence of Hellenisms in the language of the manuscript, the second clue involves the concept of the “inexplicable,” which has a specific connotation in the context of Borges’s literary world— a gesture of his debt to Chesterton. Like Chesterton before him, Borges uses the word inexplicable to suggest the uncanny. Borges has used the adjective in his own stories but also in his translations, even when the adjective does not figure in the original. In his version of Herman Melville’s “Bartleby” Borges translated “the unaccountable Bartleby” as “el inexplicable Bartleby.” “Inexplicable” is certainly one of the connotations of “unaccountable” in Spanish, but unaccountable suggests also that an individual may be irresponsible or not responsible for something. Of course, since Bartleby is an accountant, the word unaccountable adds an ironic touch. Borges’s choice of inexplicable erases all connotations of the word regarding responsibility or accounting. This is consistent with the heightened Kafkaesque air informing Borges’s translation. In Borges’s rendition, even more so than in the original, Melville’s classic tale is that which Borges claimed it is: a precursor to Kafka. The Chestertonian use of the word inexplicable sheds light on a number of Borges’s short stories, including “The Immortal,” a tale directly inspired by Borges’s reflections on the history of Homeric translation. Moments after drinking from the “black” waters of the river of immortality, Cartaphilus remembers that “inexplicably I repeated a
Translation in the Creative Process
101
few Greek words: the rich Trojans of Zelea who drink the black water of the Aesepus.”32 It is inexplicable that the uncultured Roman warrior would repeat a line from Homer and, even more inexplicable, that he should quote it in what for Borges would be an unfaithful translation. Borges quotes the same phrase, with slight modification, in his “Homeric Versions” to illustrate the strange effects in modern translations of the Homeric epithets (“the rich men who drink the black water of the Aesepus”).33 It is inexplicable, and humorously ironic perhaps, that the uncultured Roman tribune Flaminius Rufus, who lamented he was not responsible for the destruction of Alexandria, would pronounce a text in Greek that corresponds to the text Borges used elsewhere to exemplify the difficulties contemporary readers of Homer may have in understanding the strange Homeric epithet. The Chestertonian usage of inexplicable suggests an apparently fantastic element that will maintain its power of suggestion even after the strangeness can be explained. With hindsight Cartaphilus knows that the words he may have uttered after drinking from the river of immortality come from the Iliad: “the Roman, after drinking from the immortal water pronounces a few words in Greek; those words are Homeric and they can be found in the catalogue of the ships.”34 That the uncultured Roman drinking from the waters that will make him immortal speaks words identical to a Homeric text is inexplicable. Also strange is that Cartaphilus coincidentally remembers the mention of men who drink black water, and that the waters of the immortal river are also black. It is, however, explicable that Cartaphilus’s language would be permeated with Homeric locutions and that the color of the river in his imperfect memory may have been prompted by his Homeric readings in literal translations. When Cartaphilus rereads his own manuscript, he is convinced he has confused his past with that of Homer and that his language is contaminated by Homerisms. According to Borges’s terminology, the translation is a literal version, as the editor of the manuscript indicates, but it is not a copy, which would retain all of the relevant features of the original. Had the translation maintained all of the Hellenisms and Latinisms of
102
Invisible Work
the original, it would have been a copy, but the translator attests to have eliminated only the Latinisms. The translation, is therefore not a copy. That being said, the Latin idiosyncrasies in the original manuscript were eliminated because they would offer redundant clues about the identity of the protagonist who believes he was a Roman tribune. Importantly in contrast, the Hellenisms retained in the translation are of great interest since they suggest that the character may have been mistaken about his identity, that, in fact, he may have been a Greek rather than a Roman. In short, the translator eliminated the effects that would have stressed the interference of Latinisms in Cartaphilus’s written English, but maintained the Hellenic idiosyncrasies throughout the manuscript, among them the repetition of the epithet “black,” the color of the water of the immortal river, and the words the character thinks he said as he drank from the river. Even though Cartaphilus believed he was an ancient Roman who confused his destiny with Homer as he was writing his manuscript, the translation—which underscores the Homeric locutions while omitting the Latinisms—offers the exact opposite impression: that Cartaphilus has probably forgotten he was Homer and confused his own past with that of the tribune Marcus Flaminius Rufus. In retaining the Hellenisms, the translator suggests that Homer has confused his own destiny with an uncultured Roman tribune who celebrated the fall of Alexandria (and the burning of its famous library that might have jeopardized Homer’s literary posterity). Borges offers a number of hints that Cartaphilus, after writing the manuscript, may have discovered his true identity, namely that he is Homer. The narrator indicates he returned to Smyrna, where he was born, and was buried in the island of Ios. Those are amongst the areas where the author of the Odyssey may have lived. Whether or not Cartaphilus is Homer or the Roman tribune, his memory has confused the destiny of those two individuals, and both have forgotten the Odyssey. Furthermore, Cartaphilus recovered Homer’s writings in English translations, among them a copy of Pope’s translation of the Iliad in which his manuscript was found. Cartaphilus has recovered the Homeric texts by way of translations,
Translation in the Creative Process
103
and his writing style has been contaminated by them (and perhaps by other texts of the chain initiated by Homer). In the postscript that follows the manuscript, the editor discusses a book by a Cordovero who claims that “the narration attributed to Cartaphilus” is made up of fragments by other authors.35 Cordovero detects a number of interpolations and concludes “the document is apocryphal.”36 The editor protests. He does not deny that Cartaphilus’s text is plagued with intrusions and pilfering, but he considers it “inadmissible” to call it an apocryphal document.37 Ronald Christ takes the side of the invented Cordovero over Borges’s invented editor in his observation: “Like Ulysses, like The Waste Land, ‘The Immortal’ uses allusion not only as a means to an end but as an end in itself.”38 Christ is masterful in his rigorous demonstrations of the multiple web of allusions in Borges’s story, but the apocryphal Cordovero may be mistaken, as the editor of the postscript intimates. If the manuscript is an apocryphal game of literary allusions, it is no longer possible to appreciate one of the most significant elements of the story: how translations can contaminate memories and experiences. Cartaphilus could only have composed his text as a hybrid of other texts because his knowledge of Homer and of literature, as Jaime Alazraki would argue, are “one variation of the Homeric text, or perhaps, the reflection of a long chain of reflections produced by the first text.”39
“Death and the Compass” Borges’s translations often play a role in his creative process. While writing “La muerte y la brújula” (“Death and the Compass”), he was preparing, with Adolfo Bioy Casares, their translations of short stories for their anthology of detective fiction Los mejores cuentos policiales, which included “Death and the Compass.”40 The anthology also included their translation of Poe’s “The Purloined Letter,” Jack London’s “The Minions of Midas,” and Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “Mr. Higginbotham’s Catastrophe.” Each of these stories may have played a part in the gestation of “Death and the Compass,” and Borges certainly intended these translations to be read
104
Invisible Work
with his own story, an assertion supported by the fact that he included them all together in his 1943 anthology of detective fiction, before the tale appeared in a collection of his own stories in 1944.41 Each of the translations deviates from its originals in ways that illuminate the gestation of Borges’s tale. His translation of Poe’s “The Purloined Letter” foregrounds a secondary theme in the original as the backbone of “Death and the Compass.” In Borges’s tale, as in his translation of its antecedent, the criminal and the detective both know that the issues involved in understanding the nature of the crime are not merely forensic, and they have more in common than first appearances might suggest.42 The relationship between Lönnrot and Scharlach in “Death and the Compass” is prefigured with more clarity in Borges’s translation of “The Purloined Letter” than in the original, where unspecified intrigues involving a woman, whose noble status (erased from Borges’s translation), matter more than they do in Poe’s tale. In his version of Poe’s “The Purloined Letter” and in “Death and the Compass,” Borges emphasizes the ongoing confrontations between two minds. His signature tale, like his translation of Poe, enacts an audacious intellectual confrontation between a detective and a criminal in an ongoing and open-ended sequence of encounters. In both stories detective and criminal engage in a continuous series of encounters based on intellectual clues rather than on forensic evidence. In Borges’s version of “The Purloined Letter” the clues involve the mind of the poet, and in “Death and the Compass” they entail the knowledge recently acquired by both detective and criminal of the Hebrew Kabbalah and Hasidism, the religious movement and theology founded by Baal Shem Tov.43 In “The Purloined Letter” the revelation that detective Dupin and Minister D. are close, uneasy acquaintances is gradual. Dupin feels free to call on the minister at home, but he also knows that the minister would have killed him if he, Dupin, had recovered the letter with the minister’s knowledge: “D. . . is a desperate man, and a man of nerve. His hotel, too, is not without attendants devoted to his interests. Had I made the wild attempt you suggest [to seize the letter openly], I might never have left the Ministerial presence alive.” Characteristically Borges changes the ending to: “The Min-
Translation in the Creative Process
105
ister . . . is unscrupulous and courageous. Furthermore, he does not lack faithful servants. The act that you suggest [to take the letter away when he first saw it] could have cost me my life.”44 The change from a “desperate man” to an “unscrupulous and courageous” one is the starting point of the metamorphosis of Dupin and Minister D. into Lönnrot and Scharlach. Lönnrot and Scharlach, with the color red imbedded in their Germanic names, have their obvious antecedents in Poe’s Dupin and Minister D., who share the letter D as the first in their respective last names. Just as Dupin harbors a personal grudge toward Minister D. (“D—, at Vienna once, did me an evil turn, which I told him quite humoredly, that I should remember”), so, too, Scharlach holds a grudge against Lönnrot. Dupin puts his life at risk by leaving the note with the literary clues indicating that he, and nobody else, had outmaneuvered his worthy opponent. Following in his footsteps, Lönnrot risks his life by going unaccompanied to the scene where he expects a crime will take place. This last point coincides with the denouement of another story Borges translated with Adolfo Bioy Casares, Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “Mr. Higginbotham’s Catastrophe.” In Hawthorne’s story a peddler has been investigating a mysterious sequence of clues that take him, as in “Death and the Compass,” through displacements that would make a geometric figure on a map, leading him to the scene where a crime is about to be committed. Until its resolution, Hawthorne’s story has a fantastic feel to it because the peddler encounters, on two consecutive days, two different men who furnish him with the exact circumstances of the murder of a Mr. Higginbotham, down to the time at which it allegedly took place. The two accounts differ only over the date of the alleged murder. Each day, the peddler spreads the news he has received, and encounters individuals who claim to have seen Mr. Higginbotham after his murder has supposedly taken place. Hawthorne’s tale conveys the feeling of a ghost story until the very end when the mystery is resolved. The two men who informed the peddler know the details of the crime because they participated in its planning with a third man; but on consecutive days each of the two are afraid to execute the plan, postponing the murder attempt to a third day. The peddler saves the life of Mr. Higginbotham by arriv-
106
Invisible Work
ing on his property, as per the information he was given by his two informants, at the time and the place the third man was poised to commit the murder. Borges’s most important transformation is in the title he calls “La muerte repetida” (“Repeated Death”). The original “Mr. Higginbotham’s Catastrophe” highlights one aspect of the misunderstanding in the story, namely, that Mr. Higginbotham was believed to have been murdered. Borges’s title brings into sharp focus an aspect of the story that might not otherwise catch the attention of its readers: the possibility, belied in the last paragraphs of the story, that on consecutive nights Mr. Higginbotham, or his ghost, is killed in precisely the same way. Had the peddler not spread misinformation about Mr. Higginbotham’s murder, Mr. Higginbotham would not have been saved. The title in Borges’s translation and the role of misinformation with regard to the apparently fantastic events are two elements of Hawthorne’s story featured in “Death and the Compass,” where information and misinformation with regard to knowledge of the Kabbalah are factored in by Lönnrot, as he attempts to solve the ongoing series of mysterious crimes, and by Scharlach who knows Lönnrot’s investigation involves his scrutiny of books about Jewish mysticism. Another story that played a role in the gestation of “Death and the Compass” is Jack London’s “The Minions of Midas.” Borges translated it in 1934 with the title “Las muertes eslabonadas” (The concatenated deaths).45 A corrected version of the 1934 translation appeared with the title “Las muertes concéntricas” (The concentric deaths), in the anthology of detective fiction Borges published with Adolfo Bioy Casares. Since a general note indicates that Borges and Bioy Casares translated all of the stories in the volume, the corrected version of the 1934 translation by Borges may have been a collaborative effort. This story also played a role in the gestation of “Death and the Compass.” The notion of concatenated or linked deaths in the title of the first translation invites the reader to reflect upon patterns in the sequence of murders and suicides that abound in the story. The second title is even more suggestive in implying a geometrical dimension to London’s sordid tale of conspiracy and crime. Borges once provided insight about his penchant for using geometri-
Translation in the Creative Process
107
cal patterns in stories that have a fantastic element. He used them to persuade his readers to accept a fantastic situation: “Reason accepts geometry.”46 London’s “The Minions of Midas” opens with a double mystery: Eben Hale, a millionaire, commits suicide and, although he treasures his family, leaves his fortune to a faithful employee, Wade Atsheler, who commits suicide soon after. Both suicides are linked to “a terrible series of tragedies,”47 which Borges translates as “an uncontainable series of tragedies.”48 A close friend of Atsheler receives a long letter from his friend written only an hour before his suicide. In that letter Atsheler resolves the mysteries. The long letter from Atsheler to his friend begins by reproducing another letter signed “The Minions of Midas” sent to Mr. Eben Hale. The signatories demand payment of $20 million from Mr. Hale, at his convenience. The letter explains that “The Minions of Midas” is a secret organization of anarchists seeking to redistribute wealth. In their view of history the mind of the “Capitalist Class” of the industrial era was able to depose the descendants of the feudal world by force of their superior intellect and lack of “foolish ethical [or] social scruples.” They offer the millionaire a period of approximately six weeks before they kill an innocent man on October 1, 1899, at a location they specify (“on East Thirty-ninth Street”), to confirm their seriousness. Mr. Hale interprets the letter as an elaborate hoax, but on October 1 he receives a second letter indicating that they have killed a man on the appointed day. Atsheler finds confirmation of the crime in a newspaper indicating that a laborer “was stabbed in the heart by an unknown assailant.” The method of the first crime of London’s story is identical to the method of both the first and second crimes in “Death and the Compass,” in which the kabbalistic scholar Yarmolinsky was found dead with a knife in his chest. In fact, the wording of Borges’s translation of “The Minions of Midas” and of his own story is almost identical: “una puñalada en el corazón” (a knifestab in the heart), “una puñalada profunda le había partido el pecho” (a deep knife-stab had split his chest). The Minions also use gunfire in their assaults, just as Borges’s new generation of bandits do in “Death and the Compass.” Borges makes much of these two
108
Invisible Work
methods of killing since Daniel Simón Azevedo, the second victim