INTERNALIZATION, INTERNATIONAL DIVERSIFICATION AND THE MULTINATIONAL ENTERPRISE
i
RESEARCH IN GLOBAL STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT Series Editor: Alan M. Rugman Volume 1: Volume 2:
International Business Research in the 21st Century Global Competition and European Community
Volume 3: Corporate Response to Global Change Volume 4: Global Competition: Beyond The Three Generics Volume 5: Beyond the Diamond Volume 6: Multinational Location Strategy Volume 7: Volume 8: Volume 9: Volume 10:
International Entrepreneurship: Globalization of Emerging Business Leadership in International Business Education and Research Multinationals, Environment and Global Competition North American Economic and Financial Integration
ii
RESEARCH IN GLOBAL STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT VOLUME 11
INTERNALIZATION, INTERNATIONAL DIVERSIFICATION AND THE MULTINATIONAL ENTERPRISE ESSAYS IN HONOUR OF ALAN M. RUGMAN EDITED BY
ALAIN VERBEKE Haskayne School of Business, Calgary, Canada and Solvay Business School, University of Brussels (VUB) and Templeton College, University of Oxford, UK
2005
Amsterdam – Boston – Heidelberg – London – New York – Oxford Paris – San Diego – San Francisco – Singapore – Sydney – Tokyo iii
ELSEVIER B.V. Radarweg 29 P.O. Box 211 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
ELSEVIER Inc. 525 B Street, Suite 1900 San Diego CA 92101-4495 USA
ELSEVIER Ltd The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington Oxford OX5 1GB UK
ELSEVIER Ltd 84 Theobalds Road London WC1X 8RR UK
r 2005 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. This work is protected under copyright by Elsevier Ltd, and the following terms and conditions apply to its use: Photocopying Single photocopies of single chapters may be made for personal use as allowed by national copyright laws. Permission of the Publisher and payment of a fee is required for all other photocopying, including multiple or systematic copying, copying for advertising or promotional purposes, resale, and all forms of document delivery. Special rates are available for educational institutions that wish to make photocopies for non-profit educational classroom use. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone (+44) 1865 843830, fax (+44) 1865 853333, e-mail:
[email protected]. Requests may also be completed on-line via the Elsevier homepage (http://www.elsevier.com/locate/permissions). In the USA, users may clear permissions and make payments through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA; phone: (+1) (978) 7508400, fax: (+1) (978) 7504744, and in the UK through the Copyright Licensing Agency Rapid Clearance Service (CLARCS), 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 0LP, UK; phone: (+44) 20 7631 5555; fax: (+44) 20 7631 5500. Other countries may have a local reprographic rights agency for payments. Derivative Works Tables of contents may be reproduced for internal circulation, but permission of the Publisher is required for external resale or distribution of such material. Permission of the Publisher is required for all other derivative works, including compilations and translations. Electronic Storage or Usage Permission of the Publisher is required to store or use electronically any material contained in this work, including any chapter or part of a chapter. Except as outlined above, no part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission of the Publisher. Address permissions requests to: Elsevier’s Rights Department, at the fax and e-mail addresses noted above. Notice No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made. First edition 2005 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record is available from the British Library. ISBN: 0-7623-1220-3 ISSN: 1064-4857 (Series)
∞ The paper used in this publication meets the requirements of ANSI/NISO Z39.48-1992 (Permanence of Paper). Printed in The Netherlands.
Working together to grow libraries in developing countries www.elsevier.com | www.bookaid.org | www.sabre.org
iv
CONTENTS ix
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS INTRODUCTION Daniel Van Den Bulcke and Alain Verbeke
1
PART A: ALAN RUGMAN AS EMINENT SCHOLAR OF THE ACADEMY OF MANAGEMENT’S INTERNATIONAL MANAGEMENT DIVISION CAVE! HIC DRAGONES! ALAN M. RUGMAN’S CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE FIELD OF INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS Lorraine Eden THE MNE’S SPATIAL POSITIONING Bernard M. Wolf
9
29
PART B: THE 25TH ANNIVERSARY OF ‘‘INTERNATIONAL DIVERSIFICATION AND THE MULTINATIONAL ENTERPRISE’’ RUGMAN AND THE GEOGRAPHY OF MNE ACTIVITY John H. Dunning
41
FINANCIAL AND NON-FINANCIAL THEORIES OF INTERNATIONAL DIVERSIFICATION John Cantwell
59
v
vi
CONTENTS
INTERNALIZATION THEORY AND THE INTERNATIONAL DIVERSIFICATION: PERFORMANCE CONUNDRUM Jean-Franc- ois Hennart
75
PART C: EXTENDING ALAN RUGMAN’S WORK ON REGIONAL STRATEGIES AND THE ENVIRONMENT REGIONAL STRATEGY AND PERFORMANCE IN THE GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE INDUSTRY Alain Verbeke and Paul Brugman
97
REGIONAL AND GLOBAL STRATEGIES IN THE INTERCONTINENTAL PASSENGER AIRLINE INDUSTRY: THE RISE OF ALLIANCE-SPECIFIC ADVANTAGES Alain Verbeke and Sarah Vanden Bussche
119
ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES AND THE MNE Ans Kolk
147
PART D: A CAREER IN PROGRESS: RETROSPECTIVE ESSAYS RETHINKING INTERNATIONAL MANAGEMENT THEORY IN A WORLD OF REGIONAL MULTINATIONALS Alan M. Rugman
165
TWENTY-FIVE YEARS OF ‘‘INTERNATIONAL DIVERSIFICATION AND THE MULTINATIONAL ENTERPRISE’’ Alan M. Rugman
203
Contents
vii
OVERVIEW OF ALAN RUGMAN’S ACADEMIC OEUVRE
219
SUBJECT INDEX
255
This page intentionally left blank
viii
LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS Paul Brugman
Free University of Brussels (VUB), Belgium
John Cantwell
Rutgers University, NJ, USA
John H. Dunning
University of Reading, UK
Lorraine Eden
Mays Business School, Texas A&M University, TX, USA
Jean-Franc- ois Hennart
Tilburg University, The Netherlands
Ans Kolk
University of Amsterdam Business school, The Netherlands
Alan M. Rugman
Kelley School of Business, Indiana University, IN, USA
Daniel Van Den Bulcke
University of Antwerp, Belgium
Sarah Vanden Bussche
Free University of Brussels (VUB), Belgium
Alain Verbeke
Haskayne School of Business, University of Calgary, Canada and Solvay Business School, University of Brussels (VUB), Belgium and Templeton College, University of Oxford, UK
Bernard M. Wolf
Schulich School of Business, York University, Toronto, Canada
ix
This page intentionally left blank
x
INTRODUCTION Daniel Van Den Bulcke and Alain Verbeke This research volume honours Alan M. Rugman, who is the L. Leslie Waters Chair in International Business (IB), Professor of Management and Professor of Business Economics and Public Policy at the Kelley School of Business, Indiana University. The work contains a set of essays developed to celebrate the Academy of Management’s (AoM) recognition of Professor Rugman as the ‘Booz Allen Hamilton Strategy and Business Eminent Scholar in International Management’ at the AoM 2004 Annual Meeting in New Orleans, Louisiana. Booz Allen Hamilton established this award to recognize eminent scholars whose research and writing have contributed significantly to international management scholarship and whose work has had an effect on the practice of international management. This great honour was not the only one Professor Rugman received in 2004. The European International Business Academy (EIBA) organized a special panel honouring Professor Rugman’s 25-year old landmark study on international diversification and the multinational enterprise (MNE) at its 2004 Annual Meeting in Ljubljana, Slovenia. The 10 chapters included in this volume were presented at one of these events or written as a direct result thereof. Alan M. Rugman will long be remembered as one of the founders and intellectual fathers of the modern field of international business studies. He has devoted most of his life to convincing other scholars and the public at large that the MNE is the most important organizational business form worthy of academic study in our globalizing society. MNEs are an efficient response to the economic opportunities provided by the growing interdeInternalization, International Diversification and the Multinational Enterprise: Essays in Honor of Alan M. Rugman Research in Global Strategic Management, Volume 11, 1–5 Copyright r 2005 by Elsevier Ltd. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved ISSN: 1064-4857/doi:10.1016/S1064-4857(05)11001-8
1
2
DANIEL VAN DEN BULCKE AND ALAIN VERBEKE
pendence among nations. They are also the key conduit for the transfer of ideas, values, innovative technology and best practices across national borders. Subject to a number of boundary conditions, mainly a well-functioning institutional structure at the macro-level and the presence of workable competition, MNEs permit developing and developed countries to move to a higher stage of economic, social and ecological development. Through literally hundreds of conceptual and empirical studies, Professor Rugman has developed a scientific oeuvre on the MNE that is second to none. Unlike other influential scholars, Professor Rugman did not limit himself to publishing in ‘A’ journals only. His impatience to disseminate his insights, his ambition truly to span the fields of economics, public policy studies, management and law, and his uncommon eagerness to engage in intellectual debates led to numerous appearances in non-mainstream venues and publication outlets with limited citation count impacts. But Professor Alan M. Rugman is what any great scholar should aspire to be: a person consumed by the goal of describing and explaining phenomena critical to the future of human society, and ready, at any time and place, to articulate and to defend what he believes is true. Simply stated, Professor Rugman studies what the world’s largest business organizations really do, and why this matters to society at large. In several university institutions, inter alia Dalhousie University in Halifax, the University of Toronto and Oxford University, his approach to research and teaching legitimized IB studies as a credible, mainstream area of academic inquiry. His spirited interventions at many academic meetings, especially the Academy of International Business, the AoM and EIBA, always focused on the ethical responsibility of IB scholars to describe accurately what MNEs do in the real world, and to assess their impacts from a comparative institutional perspective. We can distinguish among four stages in Professor Rugman’s intellectual and professional career. The first stage includes his 1979 book on International Diversification and The Multinational Enterprise, and that published a year later, Multinationals in Canada: Theory, Performance and Economic Impact. The contribution of this early work is that the performance impact of diversification is measured in terms of return and risk, with the outcome that more internationally diversified firms do not earn higher returns but do achieve a risk reduction. This outcome is intuitively appealing provided two conditions are satisfied. First, the home country does not provide the same opportunities to buy inputs or sell outputs as those available in international markets. Second, most international activities occur in an environment characterized by external market imperfections that hinder trade and simple
Introduction
3
contracting across borders. Professor Rugman’s early work culminated in what is to date his best-known book, the influential Inside the Multinationals, published in 1981 by Columbia University Press. In this work, Professor Rugman sets forth the foundations of modern internalization theory, i.e., the transaction cost economics perspective (TCE) on the MNE. Interestingly, rather than focusing on transaction cost minimization, Professor Rugman articulated his understanding of the need for MNEs to maximize the net present value (NPV) of their foreign projects through the choice of a particular entry mode. In addition, he focused on the public goods nature of knowledge, rather than the danger of opportunistic behaviour as the key driver of internalization. By focusing on the NPV and on the public goods nature of knowledge, Professor Rugman avoided two of the key problems identified by critics of transaction cost economics more than a decade later. Indeed, those critics wrongly state that TCE scholars focus solely on transaction cost minimizing rather than value maximizing, and that they inappropriately adopt opportunism as a behavioural assumption. In fact, Professor Rugman always did focus on value maximization, and has been much more interested in the managerial challenge of knowledge appropriability than in assuming particular behavioural characteristics of the individuals involved in IB transactions. The 1980s represent the second stage of Professor Rugman’s distinguished publishing career. Here, the focus was on Canadian MNEs as the empirical basis for MNE theory development. The contribution of this work has three components. First, it identified the importance of downstream rather than upstream firm-specific advantages (FSAs) of Canadian resource based MNEs. Second, it also focused on the important role of subsidiaries, even if they are branch plants, in MNE networks. Third, it demonstrated the need for MNE market access (double diamond thinking) as the driver of the Canada–United States Free Trade Agreement (C-US FTA) and the subsequent North-American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA). Through this work, Professor Rugman realized even more than before the need to link economics, public policy, law and management in a pro-active fashion. The third stage in Professor Rugman’s career as an IB scholar covers most of the 1990s, and is characterized by extensive new theory development. He conducted various studies on the effects of trade and investment liberalization on MNEs. Importantly, he observed that trade and FDI are often complements rather than substitutes after regional trade and investment liberalization. Another area of research developed by Alan M. Rugman in this stage is that of environmental regulation and corporate strategy, culminating in an influential article in the Strategic Management Journal in
4
DANIEL VAN DEN BULCKE AND ALAIN VERBEKE
1998. Perhaps Professor Rugman’s most important contribution is the resource-based analysis of the conventional national responsiveness-integration dichotomy, and the related ‘transnational solution’ concept. Here, the key distinction is that between non-location bound (or internationally transferable) FSAs and location-bound FSAs. The former FSAs lead to benefits of integration (scale, scope and exploitation of national differences), whereas the latter FSAs, which cannot be deployed across national borders, lead to benefits of national responsiveness. The fourth stage in the development of Professor Rugman’s scientific oeuvre starts in the year 2000 and continues today. Here, a dual research agenda is apparent. First, Professor Rugman is adopting a descriptive focus on regionalization rather than globalization. Second, his analytical focus is on extending TCE/internalization theory to permit improved dialogue with the strategy field. This important work includes the development of radically new ideas, including the concept of subsidiary-specific advantage in MNEs, the revisiting of Edith Penrose’s true significance for the development of the resource-based view, and the study of internal mechanisms to economize on bounded rationality in network MNEs. It is safe to say, given the importance of both the descriptive and analytical perspectives in Professor Rugman’s new work, that the best is yet to come! The present volume includes ten chapters, in four sections. The first section contains insightful essays by Lorraine Eden and Bernard Wolf on Alan M. Rugman’s career. These chapters provide helpful perspectives on Alan M. Rugman’s intellectual contributions as an IB scholar. The second section includes three truly outstanding papers, by John Dunning, John Cantwell and Jean-Franc- ois Hennart. These papers focus on Rugman’s international diversification and internalization work, and they provide challenging new ideas for future research in these areas, especially regarding the linkages between international diversification and internalization. The third section addresses specific topics in Professor Rugman’s recent research portfolio, and attempts to extend in a substantive fashion Professor Rugman’s insights. Alain Verbeke and Paul Brugman discuss the significance of regional strategies in the global automotive industry, and the implications thereof for internalization and international diversification thinking. The essay by Alain Verbeke and Sarah Vanden Bussche explains alliance formation in the global airline industry, as a tool for regionally constrained companies to implement a global strategy. Finally, the paper by Ans Kolk discusses MNE environmental strategy, extending Profesor Rugman’s recent insights on this increasingly important subject matter.
Introduction
5
The fourth and last section includes two retrospective essays by Professor Rugman himself that constitute interesting reading for readers less familiar with his scientific oeuvre. The book ends with a complete bibliography of Alan M. Rugman’s publications. We hope that the content of this volume will act as an incentive for younger IB scholars to familiarize themselves with Alan M. Rugman’s many novel ideas, and for more established academics to rediscover the many jewels written by Rugman in the first 30 years of his illustrious career. We would like to thank the distinguished contributors to this volume, and Mr. Nathan Greidanus for his excellent administrative support in preparing the manuscript.
This page intentionally left blank
6
PART A: ALAN RUGMAN AS EMINENT SCHOLAR OF THE ACADEMY OF MANAGEMENT’S INTERNATIONAL MANAGEMENT DIVISION
7
This page intentionally left blank
8
CAVE! HIC DRAGONES! ALAN M. RUGMAN’S CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE FIELD OF INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS Lorraine Eden
INTRODUCTION I am delighted to be here today to honor the work of Alan Rugman. Alain Verbeke (Calgary) and I will discuss Alan’s contributions, with me focusing primarily on his contributions to the field of international business (IB); Alain, his contributions to international management (IM). Alan and I first met 25 years ago, introduced by a mutual friend, Judy Alexander, at the Canadian Economics Association annual meetings I believe in 1979 (maybe Alan remembers). Judy and Alan had been office mates while doing their PhDs in Economics at Simon Fraser University. A couple of years later, Alan and I co-sponsored a conference together at Dalhousie University on multinational enterprises (MNEs) and transfer pricing and then co-edited the conference papers as Multinational Enterprises and Transfer Pricing (1985). We have participated in each other’s conferences, read and/or edited each other’s papers, and organized panels at annual
Internalization, International Diversification and the Multinational Enterprise: Essays in Honor of Alan M. Rugman Research in Global Strategic Management, Volume 11, 9–27 Copyright r 2005 by Elsevier Ltd. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved ISSN: 1064-4857/doi:10.1016/S1064-4857(05)11002-X
9
10
LORRAINE EDEN
meetings on a regular basis since then. I have read and own copies of almost all of Alan’s published works. We have also taught occasional executive training courses together for the Canadian government. I have seen him give multiple conference and professional presentations over the years. In my opinion, Alan Rugman is one of the world’s leading scholars of IB, ranking with John Dunning and Raymond Vernon in terms of his contributions to the discipline. He is an extraordinarily prolific scholar, with more books and articles in top journals than almost anyone else in the Academy of International Business (AIB). If asked, I suspect Alan would identify himself as a professor and scholar of international (not global, see below) strategic management (ISM), with his research standing at the intersection of IB, strategic management, international economics and public policy. Trained as an international economist, Alan recognized early on that transaction costs provided an explanation for the existence and success of the MNE. Alan Rugman’s most important contribution to international business theory, in my opinion, revolves around two activities: first, his role in building the theory of internalization as a general theory of the MNE and, second, his bridging the gap between internalization theory and strategic management.1 Other major scholarly contributions are his work with Joe D’Cruz on the double diamond of competitiveness; with Alain Verbeke on political strategies of MNEs (e.g., shelter-based strategies) and MNE theory (location- and non-location bound firm-specific advantages (FSAs), linking internalization theory with the strategy literature); and his own work on regional integration (Canada–US Free Trade and NAFTA). I also believe that our co-edited book, Rugman and Eden (1985), is the seminal work in this area. Along with single and co-authored books, journal articles, book chapters, monographs, and so on, Alan has also been a prolific book series editor in IB and global strategic management, inviting and pulling together the works of dozens and dozens of scholars around the themes he has seen as key in the profession. Alan has also played an extraordinarily active role in professional associations, most notably the AIB where he has held the positions of Vice President, Program Chair, and now President. He is a long-time AIB Fellow also. We all know that Alan Rugman does not ‘‘suffer fools gladly’’; he can make very critical comments about academic papers, comments that others might judge unnecessarily harsh. He says what he thinks and gives honest, but blunt, criticism. Since he is almost always right, the comments are always useful even if they can be hard to hear!
Cave! Hic Dragones!
11
A SEGUE: SUSAN STRANGE AND THE DRAGONS In thinking about how to write this piece honoring the work of Alan Rugman, I was reminded of the similarities between Alan and another wellknown social scientist – Susan Strange (1923–1998).2 I am not sure how many members of the Academy of Management will recognize Susan’s name – certainly Steve Kobrin, John Stopford and Alan himself will – but she was and still is a legend within the International Studies Association (ISA). A long-time faculty member at the London School of Economics, Susan Strange was a British international relations scholar and pioneer in the field of international political economy (IPE). She was a former president of ISA and founder of the British International Studies Association. Susan saw IPE as the interaction between states and markets (firms), where structural power determined ‘‘Qui bono (who benefits)?’’ She enjoyed being contentious and provocative, seeing her role in the profession as a provocateur and agent of change. She regularly railed against what she saw as ‘‘fuzzy thinking’’ and lobbied actively for more interdisciplinary work, arguing that the mainstream social science disciplines were ‘‘silos’’ engaged in a ‘‘dialogue of the deaf’’. Late in life, she began to focus on MNEs, co-authoring with John Stopford the book, Rival States, Rival Firms, which won the Academy of Management’s book prize in 1992 (Stopford & Strange, 1991). Susan was much loved, by her colleagues and students, but perhaps not by those she regularly skewered with her sharp tongue at conferences and workshops. The article for which Susan is perhaps most famous is ‘‘Cave! hic dragones: a critique of regime analysis’’.3 The title comes from the Latin, ‘‘Beware! here be dragons!’’, which Susan notes was ‘‘an inscription often found on pre-Columbian maps of the world beyond Europe’’ (Strange, 1982, p. 479). A dragon was a pitfall for unwary scholars, a theory or concept that Susan saw as potentially not useful to students of IPE, and even possibly ‘‘actually negative in its influence, obfuscating and confusing instead of clarifying and illuminating, and distorting by concealing bias instead of revealing and removing it’’ (ibid., 479). In this particular article (which is on every IPE required reading list), she goes after international regime theory, accusing it of five dragons: that it is a passing fad that makes no long-term contribution to knowledge; it is imprecise and wooly; value biased (‘‘as dangerous as loaded dice’’); distorting by overemphasizing the static and underemphasizing the dynamic elements of change in world politics; and narrow minded. The article is not ‘‘entirely destructive’’ though, as she concludes by developing what she sees as
12
LORRAINE EDEN
a ‘‘more value free, more flexible, and more realistic approach’’ (ibid., p. 480). Susan’s own views about her role in academia are summarized in her biography:4 I have tried to teach both students and children not to expect justice in life – but to try hard to get it; to work hard – but to question authority, whether political or academic; to distrust ideologies – but to respect the evidence; to avoid following the crowd – but to trust your own judgment and to stand up for your own ideas. The freedom to do so is one of which, in free countries, the universities should be the most jealous guardians. That and not the service of the state is the true justification for their existence. (Strange, 1998)
After she died in 1998, the ISA established the Susan Strange Award to recognize her ‘‘unique and extraordinary role within the International Studies Association and the worldwide community of scholars’’. The award would go to ‘‘a person whose singular intellect, assertiveness, and insight most challenge conventional wisdom and intellectual and organizational complacency in the international studies community during the previous year’’ (see http://www.isanet.org/committee/Strange.html). I think Alan Rugman is eminently qualified to win the Susan Strange Award.
ALAN RUGMAN’S DRAGONS I hope Alan Rugman will forgive this segue to Susan Strange, but in many ways, their intellectual role in their own disciplines has been similar. Alan, like Susan, has played a unique role in not only the field of IB, but more generally in strategic management and international management. His intellect, assertiveness, and insights often challenge conventional wisdom and the intellectual and organizational complacency in our discipline. Alan, raised in Britain like Susan, works hard but questions authority; distrusts ideologies but respects the evidence; and avoids following the crowd but trusts his own judgment and stands up for his own ideas. Alan too regularly raises the call, ‘‘Cave! hic dragones!’’ in our own field. Scholars like Susan Strange and Alan Rugman are too rare in our profession. As George Bernard Shaw says in Man and Superman: The reasonable man adapts himself to the world: the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore all progress depends on the unreasonable man.
We all benefit from the unreasonable man (or woman!) – even if we may find the criticism uncomfortable when it is at our own expense.
Cave! Hic Dragones!
13
What I want to do in the rest of my talk is to give you some examples of the dragons – and alternative solutions – Alan Rugman has developed over the 29 years since his first two articles were published in 1975. I could talk about many more dragons,5 but given the time, I will focus on four: the ‘‘big bad MNEs’’, the anti-free traders, Porter’s diamond, and globalization.
The ‘‘Big Bad’’ MNE versus Internalization Theory In the 1960s and 1970s, economists explained MNEs by explaining foreign direct investment (FDI) location patterns focusing on the activity and not the firm. It was highly popular in those days, particularly among the general public and the political science discipline, to see MNEs as big and bad. The first scholar specifically to take a micro look at firms (Stephen Hymer, another Canadian, in his 1960 dissertation) saw MNEs as taking advantage of barriers to entry to exploit monopoly rents. MNEs were therefore welfare reducing (Hymer, 1960/1976).6 Even Ray Vernon’s Sovereignty at Bay (Vernon, 1971) was interpreted as big MNEs taking power away from nation states (although that was not how he intended the book to be interpreted). Popular anti-MNE books at the time included, for example, Barnet and Muller’s Global Reach (1975), later updated in Barnet and Cavanaugh (1995).7 In Canada, Kari Levitt’s Silent Surrender (1970) was trumpeting the negative impacts of FDI on the Canadian economy. The sea change in thinking about MNEs came with the development of internalization theory.8,9 Along with Peter Buckley, Mark Casson, John Dunning and Jean-Francois Hennart, Alan was involved in developing the core theory of internalization that argued MNEs were a reaction to missing and imperfect markets. Their ability to make internal markets was therefore welfare enhancing, and not exploitative.10 Alan was also involved in all the early debates about internationalization versus internationalization, whether market imperfections were always exogenous or could be endogenous, and the roles played by FSAs and CSAs (country-specific advantages).11 His FSA–CSA framework, developed with Alan Verbeke, is a very simple yet telling way to explore firm strategies in different locations. From this simple 2 2 box graph, Rugman has developed a whole series of extensions (Figs. 1 and 2). Let me give two examples. First, one extension I particularly like is the concept of location- and non-location-bound FSAs and CSAs. Since non-location-bound FSAs are, in effect, the ‘‘resources’’ of the resourcebased view, Rugman was able to link Bartlett and Ghoshal’s national
14
LORRAINE EDEN
Fig. 1.
Fig. 2.
The FSA–CSA 2 2 Box.
Location and Non-Location Bound FSAs in a 2 2 Box.
responsiveness-global integration framework to the FSA–CSA framework. Standing between England (internalization theory sina qua non) and the United States (home of Williamson, Porter, and Barney), Alan Rugman from his Canadian location explored (and arbitraged) the overlaps, linkages, and missing links between international business and strategic management. In many ways, Alan Rugman may have been the first economist-trained IB scholar to link IB and SM (strategic management) to create the new field of ISM or IMS (international management strategy) – I will not call it global since ‘‘globalization is dead’’ (see below). Thus, Alan, because of his pioneering role in ISM, is particularly well suited for this new award from the International Management division of academy of management (AOM). A second extension links back to ‘‘Multinationals and Transfer Pricing’’ book (Rugman & Eden, 1985). We argue in the introductory chapter that transfer pricing should be viewed as an efficient response to exogenous structural market imperfections imposed by governments in the form of
Cave! Hic Dragones!
15
tariffs, non-tariff barriers, foreign exchange rate restrictions, and corporate income taxes. Multinationals are able to arbitrage these exogenous government-imposed imperfections and therefore earn higher rents than nonMNEs. In terms of Rugman’s later work, the capability to engage in (lawful) transfer pricing can be viewed as a non-location bound FSA of a transactional rather than asset-based nature. Unnatural market imperfections give rise to this type of FSA, similar to the situation whereby operating in a sector populated by government customers provides an incentive to develop FSAs in government relations. Interestingly, a higher level of international diversification, and thereby a higher number of tax regimes and arbitrage opportunities, may increase the propensity of MNEs to develop an FSA in transfer pricing. On the other hand, at the macro-institutional level, the OECD guidelines on transfer pricing are designed to reduce this propensity through harmonizing national tax rules, establishing meta-national rules of the game within which MNEs set their transfer pricing policies (Eden, 2001). This harmonization has proceeded more quickly within regions than across regions. See, for example, Eden, Dacin, and Wan (2001), on cross-border diffusion of the arm’s length standard within North America.12
The Anti-Free Traders: Alan Rugman and the CUSFTA/NAFTA Debates Alan Rugman has written extensively – and I extensively – on multinationals and government policy, particularly trade and FDI policy.13 If one believes that MNEs are inherently world welfare increasing, then government regulation of their behavior is likely to reduce overall welfare gains; first because regulation prevents MNEs from doing what they do best (internalizing markets) and second governments are likely to get it wrong, making matters worse. The natural implication is that MNEs are better not regulated, and that the role for governments should be to reduce natural and structural impediments to markets.14 In both trade and FDI policy, Alan has argued for liberalization of government policies. While I particularly like his work on administered protectionism (countervailing and antidumping duties) and firm strategies, his work in this area was less about slaying an existing dragon than bringing together concepts from the strategic management literatures and the strategic trade policy literatures to develop the new concept of shelter strategies.15 However, a real dragon appeared in the Canadian naysayers to Canadian free trade with the United States. Here, Alan threw himself into the public
16
LORRAINE EDEN
debate, as he says in his short biography, as an ‘‘outside advisor on free trade, foreign investment and international competitiveness to two Canadian Prime Ministers over the 1986–1993 period’’. This included serving on industry task forces advising the Canadian government during the CUSFTA and NAFTA negotiations (the sole academic among the CEO advisors) and frequent public debates with anti-free traders on national TV and in the press. I cannot think of any other academic who so stepped outside of his/ her normal academic routine and immersed himself in the public policy debate over CUSFTA and NAFTA as did Alan Rugman. His publications over this period related to Canada, multinationals and Canada–US free trade are prolific and argue strongly in favor of free trade.16 A key argument against Canada–US free trade, from the Canadian side, was that with the loss of the Canadian tariff, US subsidiaries in Canada would close up and go home. Alan argued persuasively that while the tariff might have been responsible for bringing US firms to Canada in the first place (a shelter strategy), they had now developed FSAs and Canada had sufficient location-bound CSAs to keep them there. He railed, however, against US countervailing and antidumping duties for their closing off access to the US market. Canadian MNEs, he argued needed to adopt a North American mindset and develop strategies for the region as a whole.
Porter’s Diamond versus the Double Diamond Perhaps Alan’s best-known dragon is Michael Porter’s diamond of competitive advantage. Alan has published at least 14 scholarly pieces, including one book, on this topic.17 The basic argument in Porter’s diamond, of course, we all know: that industries derive their competitive advantage from a strong home diamond. Rugman’s critique is that Porter’s views are conditioned by his being trained and employed as a US academic, in the largest and richest country in the world. For firms in small countries, such as Canada, the implications of Porter’s diamond are disastrous. Confined by geography, limited by locationally bound endowments and labor, what competitive future was open to small countries? Alan Rugman and Alain Verbeke’s key insight was that firms from small countries could access a regional diamond, particularly if they were in a regional trade agreement such as NAFTA. Hence was born the ‘‘double diamond’’ (see Fig. 3). Rugman’s critique of Porter’s diamond appears to have been successful as Porter has since admitted that firms can have multiple home bases.
Cave! Hic Dragones!
Fig. 3.
17
The Rugman-D’Cruz Canada–US Double Diamond.
The Myth of Globalization versus the Reality of Regionalism The most recent dragon that Alan Rugman has tackled is globalization.18 His book, The End of Globalization (2000b) is quite blunt. Abstracting from the Preface: ‘‘I have written this book because I have been convinced by the evidencey . I have been surprised by the lightweight nature of the debate and saddened by the distorted criticisms leveled at multinational enterprises and their managers. It is to help redress this highly relevant but potentially sterile debate that I have written this booky . I have been struckyby the strong opinions, but lack of facts, presented by critics of multinational enterprises. Again, on the internet, a huge volume of material is available on the subject of globalization, but most of it is unscientific and insubstantial at best and downright wrong at worst. We need to move on and look at the evidence on the activities of multinational enterprises. This book is an attempt to redress the balance of the debate on globalization.’’ (Rugman, 2000b, p. xi)
In sum, his ‘‘theme is that a paradox of globalization is that it never really occurred; it is a myth’’ (p. 12). This is despite the large number of centers of globalization research that exist around the world.19
18
Fig. 4.
LORRAINE EDEN
Exports in the Broad Triad, 1997 (US$ Billion). Source: Rugman (2000b, p. 116).
While the book covers a wide variety of topics including the WTO and the Multilateral Agreement on Investment (MAI), a core part of the book is statistical. A major theme in Alan’s work has been the Triad – over 90% of trade and investment activity takes place among the United States (sometimes replaced by North America), the European Union and Japan. Trade and FDI flows and stocks among these three regions are a common theme in Alan’s work; see for example, Figs. 4 and 5. However, if one examines the top MNEs by sales or assets, he argues with Alain Verbeke that multinationals are regional not global entities. They do not have global strategies but rather regional strategies because almost none of the top MNEs have a significant percentage of sales in all three regions of the Triad. Most firms sell most of their products within their home region. While their assets may be more globalized, sales are not. He concludes there is no evidence for globalization, nor evidence of a trend toward globalization, but rather that Triad blocs are hardening as a result of political and NGO pressures. MNEs have regional not global strategies.
CONCLUSION Alan’s paper presented here today includes all of the themes I have outlined above – and then some. He has been actively involved in academic and
Cave! Hic Dragones!
Fig. 5.
19
Total Outward FDI Stocks in the Broad Triad, 1997 (US$ Billion). Source: Rugman (2000b, p. 120).
public policy debates involving MNEs since the mid-1970s. He has fought a variety of dragons or pitfalls for the unwary, on both the academic and public policy fronts, over the past 25 years. In this brief note, I have highlighted four dragons – the ‘‘big bad’’ MNE, the anti-free traders, Porter’s diamond and the globalization debate – and tried briefly to show his own counter-arguments. Interestingly, he has fought these dragons almost entirely with theory, statistics and graphs (most notably 2 2 boxes of which there are dozens), not with weighty econometric regressions built around testing large datasets. He has extensively used qualitative methods, directly interviewing company CEOs and managers. He has brought the data to the theory and when he found the theory wanting, has developed his own. At the 2004 AOM International Management doctoral consortium, Bob Hoskisson (Arizona State) told the doctoral students that three things were critically important for success in this profession: passion, playfulness, and perseverance. Alan has exhibited all three characteristics over his 30-year career: a long-run passion about MNEs and public policy, a playfulness in his gently poking fun at others in the AOM and AIB (and occasionally himself!), and perseverance in his view of the world as it applies to MNEs.
20
LORRAINE EDEN
Therefore, in honor of Alan being honored today, I want to bestow on him a new title in addition to the one from Booz Allen Hamilton – Alan Rugman, the dragon slayer!
NOTES 1. Many of the core readings are brought together in Rugman (1996b). 2. Although Alan criticizes Susan for associating the large size of MNEs with political power; see Rugman, The End of Globalization (2000b, p. 6). 3. Strange (1982). 4. Strange (1988). 5. Some other examples are Rugman’s work on administered protectionism and shelter strategies of MNEs, subsidiaries with world product mandates, business networks and flagship firms, beyond the three generics, megafirms, MNEs and environmental regulations, and the ‘‘imbalance’’ in US–Japan FDI stocks. 6. See Dunning and Rugman (1985). 7. Barnet and Cavanagh (1995). For a review that illustrates the dragon is still alive and kicking, see http://www.innovationwatch.com/books/ bks_0671633775.htm. 8. Seminal works were Buckley and Casson (1976), Dunning (1977), and Hennart (1982). 9. I am putting internalization theory together here with John Dunning’s OLI Paradigm, which may upset some of the key participants, but this is not the time or place to discuss the differences. 10. A recent example that many AIB members will remember is Alan’s first remarks from the floor at the AIB meetings in Charleston, South Carolina, at a session on the Janus Face of Globalization organized by Stefanie Lenway. The session dealt with the Janus (positive and negative) aspects of the MNE. Alan’s remarks immediately after the presentations were about the ‘‘unambiguously welfare-enhancing’’ aspects of MNEs and asked for direct evidence (proof) that MNEs could potentially lower welfare. 11. The core internalization readings are: Rugman (1980a,b,c, 1981a,b,c, 1982a,b, 1985a, 1986a, 1996b, 1998a, 2001a), Rugman and Verbeke (1992, 2003a), and D’Cruz, Rugman, and Verbeke (1995). 12. I am indebted to Alain Verbeke for suggesting this point. 13. Some of his works on trade policy are reprinted in Rugman (1996a). 14. A recent piece outlining this view is Rugman and Verbeke (2000, 2003b). 15. See, for example, Rugman and Verbeke (1990c). 16. His work in this area includes: Anderson and Rugman (1990, 1987), Boyd, Rugman, and Weintraub (2004), D’Cruz and Rugman (1990, 1995a), Gestrin and Rugman (1993a,b, 1994, 1996a,b,c), Kirton and Rugman (1998, 1999), Luxmore, Rugman, and Verbeke (1991), Rugman (1986b, 1987, 1988, 1990a,b,c, 1991a, 1994a,b,c,d, 1997, 1998b, 2004a), Rugman and Verbeke (1988a,b,c, 1989, 1990a,b,d, 1991, 1994), Rugman and Warner (1988, 1989), Rugman and Waverman (1991).
Cave! Hic Dragones!
21
17. His work in this area includes: Chang Moon, Rugman, and Verbeke (1995, 1997, 1998, 2000), D’Cruz and Rugman (1993, 1995b), Rugman (1991b, 1992, 2001b), Rugman and Verbeke (1993a,b,c) and Rugman, Van Den Broeck, and Verbeke (1995). 18. His work on this topic includes: Anderson and Rugman (1993), Brain and Rugman (2004), Collinson and Rugman (2004), D’Cruz and Rugman (1995a), Girod and Rugman (2003), Hodgetts and Rugman (2001), Rugman (1985b, 2000a,b, 2001c,d, 2002a,b, 2003a,b,c, 2004b, 2005), and Rugman and Verbeke (1997a,b, 2003c,d, 2004a,b,c). 19. See, for example, the list of centers posted on the Internet at: http:// www2.warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/csgr/activitiesnews/conferences/gsnconfpr.pdf.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This paper was first presented at the Booz Allen Hamilton IMD Eminent Scholar Session, 2004 Academy of Management, New Orleans, LA. I would like to thank Tim Devinney, Alan Rugman and Alain Verbeke for helpful comments and Celina Sconochini for her research assistance. I would also like to thank Randall Rothenberg and Booz Allen Hamilton for sponsoring the IMD Eminent Scholar award.
REFERENCES Anderson, A., & Rugman, A. (1987). U.S.–Canadian trade liberalization and adjustment mechanisms: A survey. International Trade Journal, 1(3), 219–250. Anderson, A., & Rugman, A. (1990). The Canada–U.S. free trade agreement and Canada’s agri-food industries. Northeastern Journal of Agriculture and Resource Economics, 19(2), 70–79. Anderson, A., & Rugman, A. (1993). Globalization of banking services: Canada’s strategies in the Triad. In: Y. Aharoni (Ed.), Coalitions and competition: The globalization of professional business services (pp. 253–279). London: Routledge. Barnet, R. J., & Cavanaugh, J. (1995). Global dreams: Imperial corporations and the new world order. New York: Simon & Schuster. Barnet, R. J., & Muller, R. E. (1975). Global reach: The power of the multinational corporations. London: Jonathan Cape. Boyd, G., Rugman, A., & Weintraub, S. (Eds) (2004). Free trade in the Americas. Cheltenham, UK: Elgar (296pp.). Brain, C., & Rugman, A. (2004). Regional strategies of multinational pharmaceutical firms. Management International Review, 3(special issue), 61–79. Buckley, P., & Casson, M. (1976). The future of the multinational enterprise. London: Macmillan. Chang Moon, H., Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1995). The generalized double diamond approach to international competitiveness. In: A. Rugman, J. Van Den Broeck &
22
LORRAINE EDEN
A. Verbeke (Eds), Research in global strategic management (Vol. 5.) Beyond the Diamond (pp. 97–114). Greenwich: JAI Press. Chang Moon, H., Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1997). The new global competitiveness of Korea: The generalized double diamond approach. The Korean Economic and Business Review(Fall), 48–57. Chang Moon, H., Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1998). A generalized double diamond approach to the global competitiveness of Korea and Singapore. International Business Review, 7(2), 135–150. Chang Moon, H., Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (2000). The new global competitiveness of Korea and the generalized double diamond approach. Korean Economic and Business Review, 48–57. Collinson, S., & Rugman, A. (2004). The regional nature of the world’s automotive sector. European Management Journal, 22(5), 471–482. D’Cruz, J., & Rugman, A. (1990). Canadian strategies for international competitiveness. Business in the contemporary world, III(1), 93–100. D’Cruz, J., & Rugman, A. (1993). The double diamond model of international competitiveness: The Canadian experience. Management International Review, 33(2), 17–40. D’Cruz, J. R., & Rugman, A. (1995a). Strategic responses of Canadian firms to globalization. In: D. F. Simon (Ed.), Corporate strategies in the Pacific rim: Global versus regional trends (pp. 35–165). London: Routledge. D’Cruz, J. R., & Rugman, A. (1995b). The double diamond model: Canada’s experience. In: B. David & M. Foster (Eds), Regions at the crossroads: Strategic development case studies for the new economy (pp. 35–57). Sydney, NS: University College of Cape Breton Press. D’Cruz, J. R., Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1995). Internalization and de-internalization: Will business networks replace multinationals? In: G. Boyd (Ed.), Competitive and cooperative macromanagement (pp. 107–128). Northampton, MA, USA; Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar. Dunning, J. (1977). The location of economic activity and the multinational enterprise: Search for an eclectic approach. In: B. Ohlin, P. Hesselborn & P. Wiskman (Eds), The international allocation of economic activity (pp. 395–418). London: Macmillan. Dunning, J., & Rugman, A. (1985). The influence of Hymer’s dissertation on the theory of foreign direct investment. American economic review: Papers and proceedings, 75(2), 228–232. Eden, L. (2001). International taxation, transfer pricing and the multinational enterprise. In: A. Rugman & T. Brewer (Eds), The Oxford handbook of international business (pp. 591– 619). London, UK: Oxford University Press. Eden, L., Dacin, T., & Wan, W. (2001). Standards across borders: Diffusion of the arm’s length standard in North America. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 26, 1–23. Gestrin, M., & Rugman, A. (1993a). The investment provisions of NAFTA. In: S. Globerman & M. Walker (Eds), Assessing NAFTA: A transnational analysis (pp. 271–292). Vancouver, BC: The Fraser Institute. Gestrin, M., & Rugman, A. (1993b). The strategic response of multinational enterprises to NAFTA. Columbia Journal of World Business, 28(4), 18–29. Gestrin, M., & Rugman, A. (1994). The impact of NAFTA upon North American investment patterns. Transnational Corporations, 3(1), 77–96. Gestrin, M., & Rugman, A. (1996a). The NAFTA investment provisions: Prototype for multilateral investment rules? In: P. Sauve´ & A. B. Zampetti (Eds), Market access after the
Cave! Hic Dragones!
23
Uruguay round (pp. 63–78). Paris: Organization for Economic Co-Operation and Development. Gestrin, M., & Rugman, A. (1996b). The North American free trade agreement and foreign direct investment. In: K. P. Sauvant (Ed.), Companies without borders: Transnational corporations in the 1990s (pp. 188–207). London: International Thomson Business Press. Gestrin, M., & Rugman, A. (1996c). Conceptual framework for a multilateral agreement on investment: Learning from the NAFTA. In: P. Sauve´ & D. Schwanen (Eds), Investment rules for the global economy: Enhancing access to markets (pp. 147–175). Toronto: C.D. Howe Institute. Girod, S., & Rugman, A. (2003). Retail multinationals and globalization: The evidence is regional. European Management Journal, 21(1), 24–37. Hennart, J. (1982). A theory of multinational enterprise. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press. Hodgetts, R., & Rugman, A. (2001). The end of global strategy. European Management Journal, 19(4), 333–343. Hymer, S. (1960/1976). The international operations of national firms: A study of direct foreign investment. MIT Press: Cambridge, MA. Kirton, J., & Rugman, A. (1998). Regional environmental impacts of NAFTA on the automotive sector. Canadian Journal of Regional Science, 22(2), 227–254. Kirton, J., & Rugman, A. (1999). Multinational enterprise strategy and the NAFTA trade and environment regime. Journal of World Business, 33(4), 438–454. Levitt, K. (1970). Silent surrender: The multinational corporation in Canada. Ottawa: Carleton Library Series. Luxmore, S., Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1991). Corporate strategy and the free trade agreement: Adjustment by Canadian multinational enterprises. Canadian Journal of Regional Science, 13(2/3), 307–330. Rugman, A. (1980a). A new theory of the multinational enterprise: Internationalization versus internalization. Columbia Journal of World Business, XV(1), 23–29. Rugman, A. (1980b). Implications of the theory of internalization for corporate international finance. California Management Review, XXIII(2), 73–79. Rugman, A. (1980c). Internalization as a general theory of foreign direct investment: A reappraisal of the literature. Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 116(2), 365–379. Rugman, A. (1981a). A test of internalization theory. Managerial and Decision Economics, 2(4), 211–219. Rugman, A. (1981b). Inside the multinationals: The economics of internal markets (Japanese edition) (186pp.). London: Columbia University Press. New York: Croom Helm. Rugman, A. (1981c). Internalization as a general theory of foreign direct investment. In: K. C. Dhawan, H. Etemad & R. Wright (Eds), International business: A Canadian perspective (pp. 282–301). Canada: Don Mills, Addison-Wesley. Rugman, A. (1982a). Internalization and non-equity forms of international involvement. In: A. M. Rugman (Ed), New theories of the multinational enterprise (pp. 9–23). London: St. Martin’s Press. New York: Croom Helm. Rugman, A. (Ed.). (1982b). New theories of the multinational enterprise (304 pp.) London: St. Martin’s Press. New York: Croom Helm. Rugman, A. (1985a). Internalization is still a general theory of foreign direct investment. Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 121(3), 570–575.
24
LORRAINE EDEN
Rugman, A. (1985b). Multinationals and global competitive strategy. International Studies of Management and Organization, XV(2), 8–18. Rugman, A. (1986a). New theories of the multinational enterprise: An assessment of internalization theory. Bulletin of Economic Research, 38(2), 101–118 Kobe Gakuin Economic Papers 18(3) (December 1986) (in Japanese). Rugman, A. (1986b). The role of multinational enterprises in U.S.–Canadian economic relations. Columbia Journal of World Business, XXI(2), 15–27. Rugman, A. (1987). The firm specific advantages of Canadian multinationals. Journal of International Economic Studies No. 2 (Tokyo: Hosei University, March 1987): 1–14. Also published in International Studies of Management and Organization XVIII(1), 67–85. Rugman, A. (1988). Multinationals and the free trade agreement. In: D. L. Brown & M. Gold (Eds), Trade-offs on free trade: The Canada–U.S. free trade agreement (pp. 4–12). Toronto: Carswell. Rugman, A. (1990a). Corporate strategy after the free trade agreement and Europe 1992. In: J. Longair (Ed.), Regional integration in the world economy: Europe and North America (pp. 92–101). Ottawa: Conference Board of Canada. Rugman, A. (1990b). Multinationals and Canada–United States free trade (205pp.). Columbia: University of South Carolina Press. Rugman, A. (Ed) (1990c). Research in global strategic management (Vol. I) International business research for the twenty-first century; Canada’s new research agenda (238pp.). Greenwich, CT: JAI Press. Rugman, A. (1991a). Adjustments by multinational firms to free trade. In: F. C. Menz & S. A. Stevens (Eds), Economic opportunities in freer U.S. trade with Canada (pp. 53–66). Albany, NY: State University of New York Press. Rugman, A. (1991b). Diamond in the rough. Business Quarterly, 55(3), 61–64. Rugman, A. (1992). Porter takes the wrong turn. Business Quarterly, 56(3), 59–64. Rugman, A. (1994a). A Canadian perspective on NAFTA. The International Executive, 36(1), 33–54. Rugman, A. (Ed) (1994b). Foreign investment and NAFTA. S.C (353pp.). Columbia: University of South Carolina Press. Rugman, A. (1994c). North American economic integration and Canadian sovereignty. In: M. Delal Baer & S. Weintraub (Eds), The NAFTA debate: Grappling with unconventional trade issues (pp. 97–116). Boulder and London: Lynne Rienner. Rugman, A. (1994d). Strategic management and Canadian multinational enterprises. In: S. Globerman (Ed.), Canadian-based multinationals (pp. 241–262). Calgary: University of Calgary Press. Rugman, A. (1996a). Multinational enterprises and trade policy: The selected scientific papers of Alan M. Rugman (Vol. 2, 428pp.). Cheltenham, UK and Brookfield, USA: Edward Elgar. Rugman, A. (1996b). The theory of multinational enterprises: The selected scientific papers of Alan M. Rugman (Vol. 1, 318pp.). Cheltenham, UK and Brookfield, USA: Edward Elgar. Rugman, A. (1997). Canada. In: J. H. Dunning (Ed.), Governments, globalization and international business (pp. 175–202). Oxford: Oxford University Press. Rugman, A. (1998a). Foreign direct investment and internalization in processed foods. In: D. H. Pick, et al. (Eds), Global markets for processed foods (pp. 121–134). Boulde, CO: Westview Press.
Cave! Hic Dragones!
25
Rugman, A. (1998b). The rules for foreign investment in NAFTA. Latin American Business Review, 1(1), 77–94. Rugman, A. (2000a). From globalisation to regionalism: The foreign direct investment dimension of international finance. In: J. Daniels, C. Kaiser & J. Kirton (Eds), Shaping a new international financial system (pp. 203–220). Ashgate: Aldershot. Rugman, A. (2000b). The end of globalization (237pp.). London: Random House Business Books. Paper edition 2001. Also published by McGraw Hill/Amacom, 2001. Rugman, A. (2001a). My contributions to internalization theory. Journal of International Business and Economy, 2(1), 1–13. Rugman, A. (2001b). The generalized double diamond approach to the global competitiveness of Korea and Singapore. In: D. Van Den Bulcke & A. Verbeke (Eds), Globalization and the small open economy (pp. 36–56). Cheltenham: Elgar. Rugman, A. (2001c). The illusion of the global company. In: J. Pickford (Ed.), Financial times mastering management 2.0 (pp. 129–133). London: Pearson Education. Rugman, A. (2001d). The myth of global strategy. International Marketing Review, 18(6), 583–588. Rugman, A. (2002a). Globalization and business strategy. In: Business: The ultimate resource (pp. 97–98). Cambridge, MA: Perseus Bloomsbury Publishing. Rugman, A. (2002b). Multinational enterprises and the end of global strategy. In: J. H. Dunning & J. Mucchielli (Eds), Multinational firms: The global-local dilemma (pp. 3–17). London and New York: Routledge. Rugman, A. (2003a). Multinational enterprises are regional, not global. Multinational Business Review, 11(1), 3–12. Rugman, A. (2003b). Regional strategies for service sector multinationals. European Business Journal, 15(1), 1–9. Rugman, A. (2003c). Regional strategy and the demise of globalization. Journal of International Management, 9(4), 409–417. Rugman, A. (Ed). (2004a). North American economic and financial integration (Vol. 10) of Research in Global Strategic Management (370pp.). Oxford: Elsevier. Rugman, A. (2004b). The regional nature of world banking. Multinational Business Review, 12(3), 5–22. Rugman, A. (2005). The regional multinationals. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Rugman, A., & Eden, L. (1985). Multinationals and transfer pricing (336pp.). London: Croom Helm/New York: St. Martin’s Press. Rugman, A., Van Den Broeck, J., & Verbeke, A. (Eds) (1995). Research in global strategic management: (Vol. V) beyond the diamond. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1988a). Strategic management and the Canada–U.S. free trade agreement. North American Review of Economics and Finance, 1(1), 63–93. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1988b). Strategic responses to free trade. Hitotsubashi Journal of Commerce and Management, 23(1), 69–79. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1988c). Strategic responses to free trade. In: M. Farrow & A. Rugman (Eds), Business strategies and free trade (pp. 13–29). Toronto: C.D. Howe Institute. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1989). The impact of free trade on small business in Canada. Journal of Small Business and Entrepreneurship, 6(3), 51–56. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1990a). Global corporate strategy and trade policy (179pp.). London and New York: Routledge.
26
LORRAINE EDEN
Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1990b). Multinational corporate strategy and the Canada–U.S. free trade agreement. Management International Review, 30(3), 253–266. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1990c). Strategic trade policy is not good strategy. Hitotsubashi Journal of Commerce and Management, 25(1), 75–97. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1990d). The Canada–U.S. free trade agreement and its impact on Canadian business. In: J. E. McConnell (Ed.), Canada–United States trade centre annual: An economic profile of North America (pp. 17–26). Buffalo: State University of New York at Buffalo. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1991). Globalization and industrial policy: An assessment of the report of the premier’s council of Ontario. In: D. Conklin & L. Deschenes (Eds), Canada’s information revolution (pp. 59–69). Halifax: Institute for Research on Public Policy. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1992). A note on the transnational solution and the transaction cost theory of multinational strategic management. Journal of International Business Studies, 23(4), 761–772. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1993a). Foreign subsidiaries and multinational strategic management: An extension and correction of Porter’s single diamond framework. Management International Review, 33(2), 71–84. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1993b). How to operationalize Porter’s diamond of competitive advantage. The International Executive, 35(4), 283–299. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1993c). Porter’s single diamond framework. Management International Review, 33(2), 71–84. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1994). FDI and NAFTA: A Canadian perspective. In: K. Fatemi & D. Salvatore (Eds), The North American free trade agreement (pp. 249–263). Oxford: Pergamon. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1997a). Global strategies for multinational enterprises. In: I. Islam & W. Shepherd (Eds), Current issues in international business (pp. 137–150). Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (1997b). Trade policies and strategy of MNEs in an era of globalization. In: N. Kobayashi (Ed.), Management: A global perspective (pp. 40–59). Tokyo: The Japan Times. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (2000). Multinational enterprises and public policy. In: C. Choi, R. Grant & C. Muller (Eds), International business: Emerging issues and emerging markets (pp. 21–43). London: Macmillan. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (2003a). Extending the theory of the multinational enterprise: Internalization and strategic management perspectives. Journal of International Business Studies, 34(2), 125–137. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (2003b). Multinational enterprises and public policy. In: T. Brewer, et al. (Eds), The new economic analysis of multinationals (pp. 122–144). Cheltenham: Edward Elgar. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (2003c). Regional multinationals and Triad strategy. In: A. M. Rugman (Ed.), Research in global strategic management (Vol. 8): Leadership in international business education and research (pp. 253–268). Oxford: Elsevier. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (2003d). Regional multinationals: The location-bound drivers of global strategy. In: J. Birkinshaw, G. Yip & C. Markides, et al. (Eds), The future of the multinational company (pp. 45–58). London: Wiley. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (2004a). A perspective in regional and global strategies of multinational enterprises. Journal of International Business Studies, 35(1), 3–18.
Cave! Hic Dragones!
27
Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (2004b). Regional transnationals and Triad strategy. Transnational Corporations, 13(3), 7–20. Rugman, A., & Verbeke, A. (2004c). Towards a theory of regional multinationals: A transaction costs economics approach. Management International Review, (special issue 4/2004), 3–15. Rugman, A., & Warner, M. (1988). Foreign ownership, free trade and the Canadian energy sector. Journal of Energy and Development, 14(1), 1–18. Rugman, A., & Warner, M. (1989). Strategies for the Canadian multinationals. In: A. M. Rugman (Ed.), International business in Canada: Strategies for management (pp. 200– 229). Toronto: Prentice Hall of Canada. Rugman, A., & Waverman, L. (1991). Foreign ownership and corporate strategy. In: L. Waverman (Ed.), Corporate globalization through mergers and acquisitions (pp. 59– 87). Calgary: University of Calgary Press. Stopford, J., & Strange, S. (1991). Rival states, rival firms: Competition for world market share. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Strange, S. (1982). Cave! hic dragones: A critique of regime analysis. International Organization, 36(2), 479–496. Strange, S. (1988). I was never meant to be an academic. In: J. Kruzel & J. N. Rosenau (Eds), Journey through world politics; Autobiographical reflections of thirty-four academic travelers. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books Online. Available: http://csf.colorado.edu/isa/ newsletter/25-8/Strange-Academic.htm. Vernon, R. (1971). Sovereignty at bay. New York: Basic Books.
This page intentionally left blank
28
THE MNE’S SPATIAL POSITIONING Bernard M. Wolf INTRODUCTION Alan Rugman, in the course of his professional career, has not shied away from controversy, whether the issues were international diversification versus internationalization, internalization versus use of the external market, double diamonds versus single diamonds or global multinational enterprises (MNEs) versus regional MNEs. Whatever was the bone of contention, he has formulated strong hypotheses and then engaged in empirical work to provide evidence for his position. He has taken the issues to a wide audience – scholarly, government and business. To each group he has hammered the ideas home until he was associated with a position on the issues. In fact, Alan seems to have relished being in the middle of storms of controversy as he beat the drums furiously for what he saw as right regardless of whether he offended others taking an opposite view. The result has been that he has had a huge impact on the field of international strategic management and an influence on government policy and business activity.
CAREER PARALLELS Alan Rugman and I presented papers at the same session of the Canadian Economics Association, over two decades ago, way back in the spring of Internalization, International Diversification and the Multinational Enterprise: Essays in Honor of Alan M. Rugman Research in Global Strategic Management, Volume 11, 29–37 Copyright r 2005 by Elsevier Ltd. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved ISSN: 1064-4857/doi:10.1016/S1064-4857(05)11003-1
29
30
BERNARD M. WOLF
1974. At the time we had positions at Canadian universities; he at the University of Winnipeg and I at York University in Toronto. Alan was an immigrant to Canada from England and I from the United States. He spent his sabbatical at the University of Reading in 1976–1977, working with John Dunning, Peter Buckley and Mark Casson. The latter had just published their seminal work, The Future of the Multinational Firm (Buckley & Casson, 1976). I also had been at the University of Reading briefly in February 1975 and had already met Buckley and Casson in 1974 in Budapest, where we were participating in an International Economics Association World Congress. My discussions in Budapest with Buckley and Casson earned me an acknowledgement in the Buckley and Casson volume. Both Alan and I have been heavily influenced by Buckley and Casson. I stayed at York while Alan moved onto Dalhousie University in Halifax and then to the business school of the University of Toronto. With both of us in Toronto in the late 1980s, we collaborated on a proposal to the Ontario Government that resulted in the establishment of the Ontario Centre for International Business at Toronto and York. It was one of the rare occasions where the two rival business schools in the same city elected to cooperate for a common purpose. Unfortunately, the Centre was dissolved after the initial 5-year term because of a tightening in the government’s fiscal position. An outgrowth of the Centre was York’s International MBA Degree Program, which I currently direct. Hence, our paths crossed many times in those days. Alan, after leaving Toronto, went to Oxford in the UK and then to the University of Indiana, where he is at present. Unfortunately, in recent years our interaction has been limited mainly to participation at the same scholarly conferences, notably the Academy of International Business (AIB) and the International Management Division of the Academy of Management (AOM). Alan and I also have somewhat similar research interests, both taking the MNE as the key unit of analysis. Each of us was trained as an economist – I at Yale and he at Simon Fraser with Herb Grubel as his thesis supervisor, a Yale PhD degree holder. Alan in his early work (Rugman, 1979), stemming from his thesis, looked at international diversification by which he meant ‘‘ya financial economics term involving assessment of risk of a portfolio of assets, real rather than financial, when applied to the activities of MNEs.’’ He has argued that ‘‘[i]t should not be used as a term for variables used to explain internationalization, geographic sales dispersiony’’ (Rugman, 2004, pp. 6–7). In other words he was looking through the finance glass. In contrast, in my thesis and 1977 article, I was looking at internationalization more in the tradition of Edith Penrose, who was concerned about
The MNE’S Spatial Positioning
31
how firms use resources for growth. Thus, the internationalization or geographical expansion to different countries by MNEs was not strictly diversification in the sense of the finance literature, but it was still a way for MNEs to use their resources in multiple markets.
ADDING OUTSOURCING TO THE MNE’S SPATIAL POSITIONING In this essay, my objective is to illustrate how the MNE can position itself in various spaces. The firm can redefine itself in various markets over time making liberal use of concepts with which Alan is associated. These include internalization (Buckley & Casson, 1976; Rugman, 1980) and the firm-specific advantage – country-specific advantage (FSA–CSA) framework (Rugman, 1981). My major contribution here is developing a model that adds vertical integration or outsourcing. Basically, I want to incorporate a discussion of the upstream or downstream section of the value chain in terms of how much the firm does internally (internalize) and how much it does outside, as well as to what extent it engages in internationalization and also diversifies in terms of product mix. In other words, there are three avenues for firm expansion: geographical, horizontal and vertical in the value chain. All three can be done by contracting out on an arm’s length basis, with partners (strategic alliances) or by internalizing. In my Journal of Industrial Economics article (Wolf, 1977), I postulated that those firms successful at geographical expansion would also have the key ingredients for product diversification. Unlike most work done up to that time, the paper did ‘‘not consider domestic industrial diversification and the various forms of internationalization as isolated phenomena;’’ rather it suggested ‘‘ythat they have a common foundation as part of a firm’s complex innovating, producing and marketing strategy.’’ ‘‘The evidence provided seemed to suggest that large firm size and technical know-how stimulate the U.S. manufacturing firm to operate on a multi-national and multi-industry basis.’’ Large firms are able on average to achieve economies of scale (and scope) and firms with technical expertise are innovators who use their expertise in new markets (Wolf, 1977, p. 189). I still think the view is correct. More specifically, using firm size and the proportion of workers that could be classified as engaging in R&D (broadly defined) as my independent variables, I found empirically through regression analysis that the combination of (1) the sum of exports and the foreign sales of United
32
BERNARD M. WOLF
States affiliates as a percentage of domestic production and (2) domestic product diversification could be explained better than individually. In other words, two independent variables explained more of the variation in the combined dependent variables than they did of the variation of the dependent variables when assessed separately. Thus, firms expand across industries and countries as they activate their under-utilized resources (and combine these with additional resources). Their choices depend upon CSAs as well as the prospects for product groups. Sometimes and perhaps most often, at least initially, the expansion paths are substitutes, but there may be, in addition, complementary elements. The empirical work was rather crude due to severe data limitations. There was also no discussion of vertical integration (the firm undertaking upstream or downstream activities related to the core activity) or outsourcing. Today, outsourcing is the subject of much scholarly work as well as a frequent issue in the media. Firms are tending to define their core competencies and then outsource whatever else they require, domestically or internationally. For example, call centers have multiplied like rabbits in India (downstream outsourcing) because of the availability of a relatively cheap, educated and English-speaking labor force. Even more sophisticated software engineering has migrated to India (upstream outsourcing). Developed countries find that more and more is being outsourced to the developing world. Fig. 1 illustrates how outsourcing can be viewed as part of the spatial positioning of the MNE. The inner ring represents the firm’s domestic core activities. The outer ring (or Wolf’s donut, in the tradition of Alan’s 2 2 matrices) is divided into international expansion or internationalization, product diversification and vertical integration. For MNEs, the configuration will differ from firm to firm and over time. Thus, the two concentric circles represent all the activities of the firm. Change can be indicated by shifting the proportions allocated to each activity. This is illustrated in Fig. 2 where international expansion has increased relative to product diversification and vertical integration. One additional benefit of the framework is the ability to illustrate not only expansion of the MNE, but contraction, including outsourcing and de-internationalization. Actually, product diversification can take place at home or be done abroad, something not taken into account in Fig. 1 or 2. The deficiency is corrected in Fig. 3. Product diversification that is done abroad is illustrated separately. Similarly, vertical integration could be domestic or international. The next three figures consider the components of the outer circle. Fig. 4 looks at the firm’s upstream and downstream activities that can be divided
The MNE’S Spatial Positioning
33
Product Diversification
International Expansion Domestic Core Activity
Vertical Integration
Fig. 1.
MNE’s Space: Equal Allocation.
Product Diversification International Expansion
Domestic Core Activity
Vertical Integration
Fig. 2.
MNE’s Space: Unequal Allocation.
34
BERNARD M. WOLF International Product Diversification
Product Diversification
International Expansion
Domestic Core Activity
Vertical Integration
Fig. 3.
Domestic Outsourcing
Downstream
Fig. 4.
MNE’s Space Accounting for Overlap. Vertical Integration International Outsourcing
Upstream
MNE’s Space Dissected – Vertical Integration.
into those that are vertically integrated, outsourced domestically or outsourced internationally. Fig. 5 examines international expansion that can be divided into licensing, exporting and foreign direct investment (greenfield or acquisition.). The breakdown could be finer still such as separating production from marketing. Clearly, foreign direct investment embodies internalization, but exporting and even licensing, if accompanied by some equity ownership, have elements of internalization. The international expansion
The MNE’S Spatial Positioning
Internalization
35
Licensing
Ma rk et
Exporting
Fig. 5.
MNE’s Space Dissected – International Expansion.
Product Diversification: Importance of Other Industries
Fig. 6.
Foreign Direct Investment
[Product Diversification in One Other Industry]
MNE’s Space Dissected – Product Diversification.
36
BERNARD M. WOLF
can be regional or global, in line with another of Alan’s themes (Rugman & Verbeke, 2004). Again each firm will have a different profile and each individual firm itself may have different profiles over time. Fig. 6 represents product diversification. Here the segment can be divided according to the number of industries. As shown the product diversification is into only one industry. If the firm had diversified into three industries, the circle segment would have been divided into three as in Figs. 4 and 5; the number of segments would equal the number of industries in which the firm has diversified. The framework can be extended to include linkages (strategic alliances) between firms. Each MNE would have its own circle drawn and a cable would link the relevant parts of the two circles. Virtually any relationship could be represented. Consider a few concrete examples from the automotive industry. First, if Toyota and General Motors establish a joint venture to research alternative fuels, the Toyota and General Motors circles would be linked by the cable between their respective vertical integration sections. Second, the GM–Toyota joint venture assembly plant in Fremont, California would be shown as a cable linking GM’s core activity with Toyota’s foreign expansion. Third, if GM outsources key auto parts from a Toyota factory in the United States, the cable would run from GM’s domestic outsourcing segment to the foreign direct investment section of Toyota’s foreign expansion section. If one desired, all three relationships could be shown using one circle for GM and the other for Toyota. Moreover, relationships among more than two companies can be depicted quite easily.
SIGNIFICANCE OF THE SPATIAL FRAMEWORK Alan Rugman and Alain Verbeke use FSAs and CSAs to explain the positioning of MNEs (Rugman & Verbeke, 2003). John Dunning uses the OLI (ownership specific advantages, location and internalization) paradigm (Dunning, 1973). In both cases, activities are internalized, internationalized and/or diversified. Once having explained the behavior, the framework outlined in this essay is a good accompaniment in that it provides a way to see where an MNE has positioned itself and where it might be heading. Various scenarios for the future then can be contemplated easily. At the same time it permits a comparison of the positioning of a number of MNEs. Extending the framework to the linkages between one firm and another, or among several firms is also easily doable.
The MNE’S Spatial Positioning
37
Thus, this framework, similar in its simplicity to the many Rugman– Verbeke 2 2 matrices, can readily be operationalized for the use of managers seeking to improve the international strategic management of their MNEs. In addition, it can prove to be valuable as a classroom expository tool. At my own business school, MBA students are required to engage in a firm strategy study in which they are expected to propose a strategic course for a firm. The framework should simplify the task by putting the elements of firm expansion or contraction in one context.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank Allen Goss, Schulich School of Business for assistance with the graphics.
REFERENCES Buckley, P. J., & Casson, M. (1976). The future of the multinational enterprise. London: Macmillan. Dunning, J. H. (1973). The determinants of international production. Oxford Economic Papers, 25(3), 289–339. Rugman, A. M. (1979). International diversification and the multinational enterprise. Lexington, MA: D.C. Heath. Rugman, A. M. (1980). A new theory of the multinational enterprise: Internationalization versus internalization. Columbia Journal of World Business, XV(1), 23–29. Rugman, A. M. (1981). Inside the multinationals: The economics of internal markets. New York: Columbia University Press. Rugman, A. M. (2004). Twenty five years of international diversification and the multinational enterprise . Paper for the 2004 European International Business Academy, Ljubljana, Slovenia. Rugman, A. M., & Verbeke, A. (2003). Extending the theory of the multinational enterprise: Internalization and strategic management perspectives. Journal of International Business Studies, 35(1), 3–18. Rugman, A. M., & Verbeke, A. (2004). A perspective on regional and global strategies of multinational enterprises. Journal of International Business Studies, 35(1), 3–18. Wolf, B. M. (1977). Industrial diversification and internationalization: Some empirical evidence. The Journal of Industrial Economics, 26(2), 177–191.
This page intentionally left blank
38
PART B: THE 25TH ANNIVERSARY OF ‘‘INTERNATIONAL DIVERSIFICATION AND THE MULTINATIONAL ENTERPRISE’’
39
This page intentionally left blank
40
RUGMAN AND THE GEOGRAPHY OF MNE ACTIVITY John H. Dunning INTRODUCTION I think it would be fair to say that explaining the geography of multinational enterprise (MNE) activity has never been a major part of Alan Rugman’s scholarly research and writings. Nevertheless, over the last 25 years, he has provided us with several useful nuggets of understanding and empirical evidence about the territorial expansion of firms, and its impact on their global competitiveness. In this short contribution, I shall identify some of the benchmarks of Alan’s contribution to this subject area, from the time of his seminal volume on the international diversification of multinational enterprises MNEs in 1979 through to one of his latest papers (with Alain Verbeke) on the regionalisation of the sales of the largest MNEs (Rugman & Verbeke, 2004). In doing so, I shall try and set his writings within the framework of the then contemporary thinking on the international location of economic activity; and more particularly, of my own perceptions of how the determinants of the geography of MNE activity have changed over the last three decades, and the reason for this. In taking a chronological or dynamic perspective of Alan’s work, I shall consider four time frames, viz. the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s and 2000s. To keep Internalization, International Diversification and the Multinational Enterprise: Essays in Honor of Alan M. Rugman Research in Global Strategic Management, Volume 11, 41–57 Copyright r 2005 by Elsevier Ltd. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved ISSN: 1064-4857/doi:10.1016/S1064-4857(05)11004-3
41
42
JOHN H. DUNNING
this chapter within manageable proportions, I shall be deliberately selective in my review of both Alan’s writings and what is a very extensive literature on the geography of foreign direct investment (fdi),1 and content myself with identifying the main thrusts of research. However, in doing so, I shall take an interdisciplinary perspective, as indeed Alan has done in much of his work. More especially, I shall concern myself with three strands of literature dealing with locational issues, viz. those emanating, respectively, from economists, management scholars and geographers. Each of these strands, I believe, has contributed and is contributing to our appreciation of the geography of MNE activity.
THE 1970s In November 1973, Oxford Economic Papers published an article of mine entitled The determinants of international production (Dunning, 1973). In that article I tried to set out the (then) received wisdom on the geography of international production. I suggested that, at the time, the main contribution to this subject came from economists, who were essentially interested in identifying and evaluating the factors influencing the locational choices of MNEs. Broadly speaking, these scholars took a neoclassical approach to this topic, and used traditional locational theory to explain the ‘where’ of international production. The second group of economists took a more strategic perspective to understanding the internationalisation of business activity. Ray Vernon pioneered this approach (1966, 1974). His well-known product cycle offered one of the first dynamic explanations of the cross border locational choices, of MNEs, which he asserted would vary according to the market structure in which they competed, and the stage of the product cycle in which they were producing. One of Vernon’s students, Frederick Knickerbocker (1973) took up this theme by observing and explaining the clustering of the foreign subsidiaries of US MNEs in particular countries. The third approach was that of Stephen Hymer who took the view that the territorial expansion of firms added a new layer to their hierarchical decision-making. More particularly, he argued that the higher order activities were likely to be centralised in the head offices of MNEs, while the lower order functions were likely to be dispersed in both their home countries and abroad. Alan’s earlier work was perhaps most influenced by a third group of economists who took a capital theoretical approach to understanding the
Rugman and the Geography of MNE Activity
43
structure and scope of MNE activity. This group of scholars can itself be broken down into three sub-groups. The first consisted of economists who were dissatisfied with the ability of the received portfolio theory of capital movements to explain fdi. Second, there were those who sought to explain cross-border capital formation by the use of similar models to those which explained domestic capital formation. Essentially, these economists asserted that the geography of fdi would be determined by the expected profits offered by different locations. These, in turn, reflected differences in the type of demand and supply variables, which were then incorporated into the models. The third sub-group of economists specifically acknowledged the role of risk and uncertainty in influencing the international diversification of MNE activity.2 Their work was the direct antecedent of Rugman’s (1979) book, in that one of its critical hypotheses was that the cross-border location of value-added activity was likely to reflect both the expected profits likely to be earned, discounted by the risks involved, and the particular risks involved in the extent and pattern of the diversification itself. It was this second type of risk which particularly interested Alan. In his 1979f book, he cleverly integrated a traditional economic approach, based on the expectation of profits and a strategic approach, which recognised that stability of earnings was also an influencing factor in its own right. But in explaining the extent and pattern of diversification (and implicitly its geography), he (like Hymer) found financial explanations unsatisfactory. Instead, he argued that the explanation of such diversification could best be explained by their need to reduce the risks and volatility of individual intermediate product markets by internalising them. These insights were subsequently applied to explaining why particular MNE functions were centralised and others were decentralised. In this respect, Alan added an important new dimension to the earlier work of Hymer (1960, 1976), Vernon (1966, 1974) and Buckley and Casson (1976). A re-reading of Alan’s (1979) book confirms my earlier belief that he was not primarily interested in the determinants of the international diversification of MNE, and still less with its geography. Rather, his emphasis was first on how far the MNE could achieve one of the main benefits of diversification, i.e., the stability of its global earnings, as a risk-reduction measure, as compared with how such benefits might be captured by investing in the international stock market; and second, on his insistence that intra-firm diversification is best explained by the internalisation of market imperfections (of which exchange and political risks are examples) rather than by purely financial variables.
44
JOHN H. DUNNING
At the same time, I would also assert that Alan’s analysis directly advanced our thinking on the geography of MNE activity in two ways. First, by specifically introducing risk reduction as a motivation for MNE activity, he opened the door for a strategic approach to understand the extent, structure and geography of International Business (IB) activity. Second, in his empirical work, he identified the extent to which the correlation between stock price indexes in different national markets might reflect the benefits of diversification, relative to the concentration, of MNE activity. However, what is not entirely clear from Alan’s writings is the extent to which the global profits of the investing firm and their stability is affected by the efficiency of resource usage, as compared with the internalisation of market risks associated with exchange and other imperfections. What of other work on location in the 1970s? Apart from that already mentioned, we might specifically identify three particular thrusts. The first was that of the Uppsala School, the proponents of which asserted that the stages of the internationalisation process were governed by the need to minimise spatial transaction costs (including those associated with psychic distance) and to maximise the benefits of knowledge acquisition and learning capabilities (Johanson & Vahlne, 1977). Though not explicitly incorporating Rugman type risk models into their analysis, implicitly this was done. Second, mention should be made of Seev Hirsch’s classic article in 1976, which formalised some of the critical variables affecting the export v. fdi mode of international business activity (Hirsch, 1976). Seev was one of the first trade economists to incorporate the additional intra-firm communications associated with international diversification into a model, which compared the production and transportation costs of servicing a foreign market from a home or foreign base. However, it was not until the 1980s that mainstream international economists began to take an industrial organisational approach to explaining the activities of MNEs, and the interface between received trade theory, increasing returns to scale and the cross border integration of intermediate product markets.3 Lastly, brief mention might be made of my own work on location in the 1970s. It was primarily directed towards the implications of the UK joining the European Common Market. In a paper presented to the Manchester Statistical Society, Dunning (1972), I set out some of the static and dynamic consequences of trade liberalization, and the extent to which UK firms were likely to be more or less geographically diversified. I must own I did not inject a risk component into my analysis. Instead, I concentrated on some 13 firm-, industry- and country-specific variables, which I hypothesised would influence the locational choice of MNEs; and, also, the extent to
Rugman and the Geography of MNE Activity
45
which such firms themselves possessed (or could acquire) particular competitive advantages. The results (which were essentially consistent with trade theory) were that the geographical diversification of MNE activity in Europe might be expected to increase in sectors in which there were few economies of scale, high transport costs and there were limited opportunities where intra-firm horizontal or vertical specialisation, and where there were few government (or other) imposed constraints on inward or outward investment. By contrast, it might be expected to decrease in sectors where there was little product differentiation, low transport or transaction costs, and where the product(s) could be produced under substantial scale economies.
THE 1980s Research on the geography of MNE activity took on a new lease of life in the 1980s. This was for three main reasons. The first was that both the data on the scope and distribution of MNE activity and on some of the locationspecific variables thought to influence that activity was starting to improve. This led to several empirical studies, particularly in respect of US fdi in Europe.4 Second, both economists and geographers were increasingly recognising that it was difficult to formulate any generalised theory of the location of international economic activity (and for that matter of trade!). So much depended on the type of motive for fdi (cf. e.g., those for resource seeking with those of market seeking and efficiency seeking fdi), and the functions performed by the foreign affiliate(s) (cf. e.g., the geography of innovation in the pharmaceutical industry with that of the assembly of motor vehicles). Third, due to the work of Paul Krugman and others, trade economists were now starting to take an interest in the geography of economic activity, and particularly the extent to which and the reasons for which particular value-adding activities were dispersed or concentrated. This stimulated a new generation of economists and geographers to direct their attention to spatially related issues.5 Yet, only a few scholars applied the models to understand the geography of fdi. Of these, James Markusen (1984), Elhanan Helpman (1985) and Wilfred Ethier (1986) took the lead, and, in doing so, used IB concepts, and more especially my own Ownership Location Internalisation (OLI) paradigm, in the construction of their formal models. Third, there were several emerging issues of the late 1970s and 1980s that demanded economists, geographers and business strategists should rethink
46
JOHN H. DUNNING
many traditional approaches to the geography of MNE activity. At a macro level, perhaps the most important of these was the renaissance of marketbased economic systems – particularly in China and central and eastern Europe – and the burgeoning of regional integration schemes. These events led to a marked realignment of the geography of both intra- and interregional fdi, particularly in Europe, North America and East Asia. At a micro level, various new issues came to the fore, not least as a consequence of the more confrontational stance in the 1970s between governments and MNEs about the costs and benefits of fdi. One outcome of this confrontation was the introduction of a wide range of policy and legislature measures introduced by host governments in an attempt to discourage perceived unacceptable business practices on the part of MNEs or their affiliates. These included extra territoriality restrictions of technology transfer and exports, and, perhaps most contentious of all, the manipulation of transfer prices. It was in this latter area that Alan Rugman made his contribution in the early 1980s – along with one of his colleagues from Dalhousie University – Lorraine Eden. In a volume jointly edited with Lorraine in 1985, Alan and his contributors set out their views on the theory of, and empirical evidence for, cross-border transfer pricing. Again, although neither Alan nor his fellow contributors were primarily concerned with the implications of other than arms length intra-firm administered prices for the geography of MNE activity, their analysis and findings did help to identify the conditions under which the opportunity for such transfer pricing might affect this geography. Alan, in particular, made the critical distinction between transfer pricing designed to combat government-imposed market imperfections and/or endemic market failures, which might well be consistent with a more globally efficient spatial distribution of fdi; and that which was specifically designed to exploit and extend the monopoly power of MNEs, and to evade taxes. However, as Alan and Lorraine discovered, the question of ‘when is a transfer price a distorted price, and from whose viewpoint?’ is by no means easily answered. In the 1980s, much intra-corporate transfer pricing was designed to reduce their global tax burden, and to bypass governmentimposed restrictions on capital repayments and dividend transmissions. To the MNEs such a readjustment of prices was regarded as a legitimate business strategy. The taxation authorities, on the other hand, viewed such practices as a way of evading the legal obligations of the investing firms, and as a challenge to national sovereignty (Rugman & Eden, 1985, p. 9). Whatever the rationale for transfer pricing, it is a fact that, whenever it differs from its arms length counterpart it has consequences (for good or
Rugman and the Geography of MNE Activity
47
bad) on the geography of fdi. Clearly in its absence, and ceteris parabis, MNE activity would gravitate to low tax countries which impose the fewest regulations on remittances, and operate stable currencies. Accepting intrafirm price manipulation however, allows fdi to take place in higher tax, and in less stable and more regulatory regimes, provided, of course, that these regimes do not counteract the motive for, or the practice of, such pricing. In other words, the possibility of transfer pricing permits firms to better take advantage of differential demand and cost differences that might have been nullified by the actions of governments. Certainly, the findings of an empirical study by Roger Tang (1981) suggested that among the more significant environmental variables influencing the motivation for transfer pricing were the disincentives to fdi imposed by national governments;6 and, too, that there was some reason to suppose that the benefits gained by firms from transfer pricing shifted the geography of MNEs to countries which otherwise might have lost out. However, notwithstanding the attention paid to transfer pricing issues in the 1980s, to my knowledge, there were no serious attempts to either evaluate how important this variable was, in relation to other economic or strategic determinants of fdi, either from the perspective of individual firms or countries. However, one of the contributors to the Rugman and Verbeke (1995) volume (Benvignati, 1985) in her study of US manufacturing firms, found that the larger number of countries in which MNEs operated, the more likely they were to engage in administered cross-border pricing. It would then appear that, in the 1970s and early 1980s, geographical diversification and transfer pricing might have gone hand in hand, at least in those instances where MNEs were induced and were able to overcome both endemic and government-imposed market imperfections. My own interests in the geography of MNEs in the 1980s largely centred around the investment development path, (IDP), a concept I first put forward and tested in 1981 (Dunning, 1981).7 Though primarily intended to explain the changing pattern of inbound and outbound fdi for particular countries as they moved through various stages of their economic development, it also suggested how its geography might change. Inter alia, the IDP hypothesised that, at a particular stage in their development, most countries would begin to engage in outward fdi, while the destination of that MNE activity would become more diversified. It also asserted that the geography of fdi would very much depend on the motivation for such investment and the economic policies pursued by host governments. Thus, while asset-augmenting fdi was likely to be of an intra-Triad variety, natural resource-seeking fdi was likely to be directed to resource rich
48
JOHN H. DUNNING
countries, most of which were located in the Southern Hemisphere. Or to take another example, restrictions placed on inward direct investment by Japan in the 1970s and 1980s caused it to be very much an outlier as far as its position in the IDP was concerned.
THE 1990s In my judgement, there were four critical features which fashioned the changes in the geography of MNE activity in the 1990s.8 The first was the emergence of the erstwhile Communist countries as major recipients of inbound fdi; and, in the case of China, of outbound fdi. In 1990, such countries accounted for 1.4% of the stock of inbound fdi; by 2003 this had risen to 89% (UNCTAD, 2004). The second feature was the growth of efficiency and market-seeking fdi, which was the direct result of the widening and deepening of regional economic integration, particularly in Europe and North America. Again, the share of the inbound fdi stock directed to developed countries accounted for the European Community (EC) and the North American Free Trade Area (NAFTA) rose from 91.3% in 1990 to 93.5% in 2003. The third feature was the growth of strategic asset-seeking MNE activity, particularly within the Triad. Such fdi was designed as much (if not more) to tap into, or augment, existing competitive, or ownership-specific, advantages of the MNEs, as to exploit them. Inter alia, this feature was illustrated by the huge growth of intra-Triad mergers and acquisitions (M&A), particularly in knowledge- and information-intensive sectors, throughout the 1990s.9 The fourth, and partly paralleling the second and third features, was the gradual geographical diversification of higher value functions of MNEs away from their home country locations to that of their foreign affiliates. Recent data both on the research and patenting activities of MNEs outside their national boundaries are showing an increasingly important role of affiliates, both in the creation of knowledge and human resource development, and as intermediaries between the local technological environment in which they operate, and their parent organisations (Cantwell & Kosmopoulou, 2002; Frost, 2001; Pearce, 1997, 1999; Pearce & Singh, 1992). In analysing the character, rationale and consequences of these features, both from the perspective of the firm and from that of national economies, IB scholars in the 1990s played a major role. Inter alia, this was reflected in (i) a plethora of papers on the determinants of fdi in Central and Eastern
Rugman and the Geography of MNE Activity
49
Europe;10 (ii) new theoretical models on asset seeking fdi (Makino, Lau, & Yeh, 2002; Wesson, 2002) and on the role of foreign-based R&D laboratories and strategic alliances in augmenting (both within and outside the firm) innovating activities (Kuemmerle, 1999; Narula, 2001, 2003; Narula & Guyster, 2004); (iii) an increasing interest in the role of collaborative ventures and that of the geographical clustering and networking of related activities;11 and (iv) a better appreciation by scholars of the dynamics of the interface between the changing locations and attractions of countries, and the ownership strategies of MNEs (Buckley & Ghauri, 2004). Alan Rugman was at the centre of many of these debates. I shall highlight just two of his contributions. The first was his criticism of Michael Porter’s diamond of competitive advantage (Porter, 1990) for inadequately taking account of the extent to which MNEs (and in Alan’s case, Canadian MNEs) might be able to advance their global competitive advantages as a direct result of their fdi. In several papers including those jointly authored with Joseph D’Cruz, Alan coined the term ‘‘double diamond’’, and, in doing so, confirmed the importance of the geography of a firm’s value-added activities as a factor influencing its competitiveness.12 Basically, his contention was that both the received theory of MNE and our understanding of the strategy of MNEs needed to be modified to take account of the fact that many MNEs were engaging in asset-seeking fdi. I supported Alan in this debate, and in a paper I wrote in 1996 (Dunning, 1996) documented the fact that the majority of the world’s largest manufacturing companies perceived they gained a significant proportion of their knowledge-based and managementrelated advantages as a consequence of their foreign activities; and that, and apart from fdi-directed to resource-based sectors, the geography of such gains originated from nations which were technologically the most advanced. Excluding China, for example, fdi flows directed to the US and Western Europe rose from 60.2% between 1991 and 1996 to 71.4% between 1993 and 2000, and the greater part of these took the form of M&As (UNCTAD, 2003). Alan’s recognition of the importance of the need for some firms to tap into the foreign diamonds of competitive advantage, and how this affected the geography of their fdi was confirmed by several empirical studies in a special issue of Management International Review which he edited in 1993 (Rugman, 1993), and in a volume which he jointly edited with J. Van Den Broeck and Alain Verbeke which was published in 1995. In his more recent writings, while still preferring his own nomenclature, Michael Porter is also increasingly accepting the idea of geographically diversified centres of competitive advantage.
50
JOHN H. DUNNING
The second contribution by Alan in the 1990s to our understanding of the geography of MNE activity relates to his work on North American regional economic integration (Rugman, 1990, 1994). Both in respect of the Canadian US Free Trade Agreement and the North American Free Trade Agreement, Alan was at the forefront of the policy debate on how these moves towards regional integration might affect Canadian trade and fdi, both into and out of Canada. Once more, while his main concern centred on the extent and industrial composition of fdi between Canada and the US – and later Mexico – he also expressed views on the likely consequences of the reduction on intra-regional transaction costs on fdi diversion and fdi creation, and on how these might affect the intra-NAFTA distribution of different kinds of MNE activity. Alan’s conclusions on the likely reallocation of different kinds of economic activity between the member countries of the NAFTA very much accorded with my own findings with respect to the impact of the enlarged EU on the geography of intra-EU fdi. I expressed these first in a chapter in Lorraine Eden’s edited volume Multinationals in North America (Dunning, 1994) and later in the two articles in Journal of Common Market Studies (Dunning, 1997). In particular, like Alan, on the one hand, I foresaw an increased concentration of the higher order value-added activities of MNEs in the more advanced localities (hence the need for ‘cluster’ building in which such firms could play a flagship role) (Rugman & D’Cruz, 1994). On the other, I predicted a more geographical diversification of lower order value-added activities. At the same time, due to a removal or reduction of trade barriers, in both the NAFTA and EC, I foresaw that there would likely be an increase in rationalised or efficiency-seeking fdi and more geographical diversification, but a decrease in defensive (e.g., tariff-jumping) fdi, and less diversification. Inter alia, this suggested to me, that, to become globally competitive, MNEs from less prosperous parts of a regionally integrated area might wish to acquire an fdi stake in firms from more prosperous parts; while, to attract such investment, the governments of the former would need to give especial attention to upgrading the educational and innovatory infrastructure and institutions for which they were responsible.
THE 2000s Perhaps, however, the most influential contribution of Alan Rugman to our understanding of the geography of MNE activity has been made in the last
Rugman and the Geography of MNE Activity
51
5 years or so, in the form of his original and incisive analysis of the spatial distribution of the sales of the world’s largest MNEs. In one of his most recent papers, with Alain Verbeke (Rugman & Verbeke, 2004), he extended and updated his earlier work by revealing that 320 of the leading 380 MNEs in 2001 recorded at least 50% of their sales in their home regions (defined as North America, Western Europe or Japan). Another 25 were bi-regional in that they recorded at least 25% of their sales in each of two regions, but less than 50% in any one region. Only nine of the 280 MNEs were classified as being genuinely global in the sense they had an active sales presence (defined as 20% or more of their sales) in all three regions. To some extent, Alan’s findings are compatible with those of the Uppsala School which, nearly 30 years earlier, had asserted that firms first embarked on their internationalisation process by investing in territories most familiar to them; and then, with the knowledge gained from such ventures, further extended their boundaries (Johanson & Vahlne, 1977). They are also broadly consistent with the data on the geographical distribution of the fdi stock of the leading foreign investors, which two colleagues and myself have recently compiled (Dunning, Fujita, & Yakova, 2005). At the same time, I believe that the spatial distribution of MNE activity in the early 2000s is strongly influenced by the size and stage of development of both home and host countries. Thus, over the next half century or so, I would expect the geographical focus of fdi by all major investors to shift increasingly towards China and India.13 These are not only the two most highly populated countries in the world, but ones whose gdps per capita are currently rising considerably faster than those of the major industrialised countries. Yet again, as I read Alan’s writings, they are less directed to evaluating the rationale for, or economic determinants of, the (changing) location of MNE activity, and more to a description of it, and its implications for the diamond international competitiveness and of our understanding of the functioning of and organisational structure of MNEs. In each of these areas, Alan’s evaluations are both pertinent and valid a propos locational issues. In particular, the contributions by Rugman and Verbeke (2001, 2004) do much to integrate the economic and strategic approaches to cross border diversification by examining the significance of country- and firm- (ownership-) specific advantages to enhancing the global competitive advantages of both firms and countries. One of their critical conclusions is that the geography of MNE activity is influenced by the desire of their parent companies to tap into foreign knowledge-based clusters, and in doing so, leverage them to their global competitive advantage (Rugman & Verbeke, 2004).
52
JOHN H. DUNNING
This finding is entirely backed up by our 1996 study, which not only showed that the largest industrial MNEs were increasingly deriving their competitive strengths from their foreign-based activities, but that the majority of these were based in countries that spent the most on R&D activities and had the most supportive innovatory institutions. Work by John Cantwell and Odile Janne (1999) and Tony Frost (2001) further demonstrates an increasing reliance of MNEs on their overseas subsidiaries for knowledgerelated expertise, and particularly so in those countries which have a strong innovatory support structure, and which offer good opportunities for collaborative research, learning capabilities and networking. At the same time, I would hope that in his future writings, Alan may use his rich database to examine the main determinants of fdi. For, in the last decade or so, a great deal of new empirical data has emerged on the firm and country-specific variables influencing the international location of valueadded activities. Some of these are in the outcome of surveys of business opinion, as, for example, conducted and/or published by such organisations as the Economist Intelligence Unit (2003) and the IMD in its World Competitiveness Yearbook (2004). Others relate to data collected and indices compiled by specialist organisations such as Transparency International and the International Country Risk Group. The quantity and quality of countrylevel data compiled and analysed by such international organisations, e.g., UNCTAD, OECD, the UNDP, WTO, World Bank and the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) have also greatly improved. Paralleling and partly consequential on developments in the world economy, data improvements and the changing character of fdi, IB scholars, geographers, economists and business strategists are giving more attention to location-related questions from both a firm and country perspective.14 In particular, the quality of institutions have become a more important variable affecting the spatial decision of firms. To give just one example. A good deal of research in the last 5 years has been directed to explaining the growth of inbound fdi into Central and Eastern Europe.15 Since the main feature of the countries in this region has been their transition from a centrally planned to market economy, scholars have paid especial attention to institutionally related variables. The upgrading of these has consistently been found to be one, if not the critical variable affecting the location decisions of foreign firms. This, coupled with the growing ease at which many kinds of knowledge can be transfered across national boundaries, the lessening or convergence of some kinds of spatial transaction costs, and the need for MNEs to participate in cross-border alliances and networks, has led scholars, business executives and governments to reappraise
Rugman and the Geography of MNE Activity
53
the relative significance of location-specific variables; and to better appreciate that these are likely to vary according to both the raison d’etre for particular kinds of MNE activity, and to the particular institutional and economic characteristics of the countries to which such activities might be directed.
CONCLUSIONS With the exception, perhaps, of his work on transfer pricing, Alan Rugman’s foray into the geography of MNE activity has been part and parcel of his wider interest into the economic and strategic determinants of the international diversification of the value-added activities of MNEs, and of how these might affect their global competitiveness. In extending and deepening our knowledge on these issues, Alan has made a significant and valuable contribution to the IB literature. But indirectly, he (with Alain in some of his more recent contributions) has also helped put location issues central to our understanding of the objectives and organisational operation of MNEs. Using his well-known 2 2 matrix, he has also greatly advanced our appreciation of the ways in which locational issues may and do affect the interface between the competitive advantages of countries and firms. Coupled with interdisciplinary research more directly related to the firm and country-specific determinants of fdi, and, in particular, to the content and quality of institutions as a locational attraction, our knowledge about the geography of MNE and its causes is now in a much richer state than it was when Alan wrote his seminal monograph on international diversification, a quarter of a century ago. No doubt the next 25 years will produce their own particular scholarly challenges. Equally I feel sure that Alan will respond to these, and to do so in a way which will benefit all of us.
NOTES 1. Recent reviews of this literature are contained in Cantwell (2004), Clark, Feldman and Gertler (2000), Dunning (1993, 1998a, b, 2000 and 2004), and Rugman and Verbeke (2001, 2004). 2. As typified by that of Grubel (1968), Stevens (1969), Miller and Whitman (1970), Prachowy (1972), Cohen (1972) and Mellors (1973). 3. See e.g. Krugman (1982). The later writings of trade economists are described in the next section.
54
JOHN H. DUNNING
4. As, for example, summarised in Dunning (1993) and Caves (1996). However most of the location-related work of IB scholars in the 1980s centred on testing established theories. One exception was an attempt to explain the changing geography of fdi in terms of the investment development path (IDP). 5. As, for example, identified or discussed by various contributors in Clark, Feldman, and Gertler (2000), and especially by the editors (Chapter 1), Allen Scott (Chapter 2) and Paul Krugman (Chapter 3). 6. Foremost among these were the rate of custom duties, anti-dumping or antitrust legislation, limitations on repatriation of profits and dividends and on royalties or management fees, and import restrictions. 7. There have been several modifications to the concept over the last two decades. See, for example, those set out in Dunning and Narula (1996). 8. Others not mentioned include the growth of Third World fdi and the growth of all kinds of service fdi. 9. For example, between 1990 and 2000 the value of cross-border M&A sales as a proportion of the inward direct stock rose from 7.8 % to 18.8%. This proportion subsequently dropped back dramatically to 3.6% in 2003. 10. See, for example, Holland, Sass, Benacek, and Gronicki (2000) and Bevan, Estrin, and Meyer (2004). 11. See, for example, several contributions to Contractor and Lorange (2002). 12. See especially a collection of essays in Rugman (1993). 13. Already this is happening. To give just one example, between 1990 and 2003, the share of the world’s outward direct investment stock directed to mainland China increased from 1.1% to 6.1% (UNCTAD, 2004) 14. For a recent forward-looking appraisal of the evolving interface between locational issues and international business strategy see Ricart, Enright, Ghemawat, Hart, and Kharnea (2004). 15. For a review of the literature see Meyer (2004), Manea and Pearce (2004) and Dunning (2005).
REFERENCES Benvignati, A. M. (1985). An empirical investigation of international transfer pricing by US manufacturing firms. In: A. M. Rugman & L. Eden (Eds), Multinationals and transfer pricing (pp. 193–211). London and Sydney: Croom Helm. Bevan, A., Estrin, S., & Meyer, K. (2004). Foreign investment location and institutional development in transition economies. International Business Review, 13(1), 43–64. Buckley, P. J., & Casson, M. (1976). The future of multinational enterprise. London: Macmillan. Buckley, P. J., & Ghauri, P. M. (2004). Globalisation, economic geography and the strategy of multinational enterprises. Journal of International Business Studies, 35(2), 81–98. Cantwell, J. (Ed.) (2004). Globalisation and the location of firms. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar (Reference Collections). Cantwell, J. A., & Janne, O. E. M. (1999). Technological globalisation and the innovatory centres: The role of corporate technological leadership and locational hierarchy. Research Policy, 28(2–3), 119–144.
Rugman and the Geography of MNE Activity
55
Cantwell, J. A., & Kosmopoulou, E. (2002). What determines the internationalisation of corporate technology? In: M. Forsgren, H. Hakanson & V. Havila (Eds), Critical Perspectives on Internationalisation. Oxford: Pergammon Press. Caves, R. (1996). Multinational enterprises and economic analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Clark, G. L., Feldman, M. P., & Gertler, M. S. (Eds) (2000). The Oxford handbook of economic geography. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Cohen, B. I. (1972). Foreign investment by US corporations as a way of reducing risk. Economic Growth Centre Discussion Paper No.151, Yale, Yale University, New Haven. Contractor, F. J., & Lorange, P. (Eds) (2002). Cooperative strategies and alliances. Amsterdam and London: Pergammon Press. Dunning, J. H. (1972). The location of international firms in an enlarged E.E.C. An exploratory paper. Manchester: Manchester Statistical Society. Dunning, J. H. (1973). The determinants of international production. Oxford Economic Papers, 25(November), 289–295. Dunning, J. H. (1981). Explaining the international direct investment position of countries: Towards a dynamic or developmental approach. Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 119, 30–64. Dunning, J. H. (1993). Multinational enterprises and the global economy. Wokingham, Berkshine addesion: Wesley. Dunning, J. H. (1994). MNE activity: Comparing the NAFTA and the European Community. In: L. Eden (Ed.), Multinationals in North America (pp. 277–308). Calgary: University of Calgary Press. Dunning, J. H. (1996). The geographical sources of competitiveness. Transnational Corporations, 5(3), 1–30. Dunning, J. H. (1997). The European internal market program and inbound foreign direct investment. Journal of Common Market Studies, 35(1), 1–30 (2), 189–223. Dunning, J. H. (1998a). Location and the multinational enterprise: A neglected factor. Journal of International Business Studies, 29(1), 45–66. Dunning, J. H. (1998b). Globalisation and the new geography of foreign direct investment. Oxford Development Studies, 26(1), 47–69. Dunning, J. H. (Ed.) (2000). Regions, globalisation and the knowledge based economy (pp. 8–44). Oxford: Oxford University Press. Dunning, J. H. (2004). Determinants of foreign direct investment: Globalisation-induced changes and the role of policies in World Bank (Ed.). Proceedings of Annual World Bank Conference on Development Economics, Europe, 2003, (pp. 279–290). Dunning, J. H. (2005). Institutional reform, FDI and European Transition Economies. In: R. Grosse (Ed.), International Business and Government Relations (pp. 51–78). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Dunning, J. H., Fujita, M., & Yakova, N. (2005). Some macro-data on the regionalisation/ globalisation debate. A comment on the Rugman/Verbeke analysis. Reading: Reading University and Geneva: UNCTAD. Mimeo. Dunning, J. H., & Narula, R. (1996). Foreign direct investment and governments. London and New York: Routledge. Economist Intelligence Unit. (2003). World investment prospects. London: E.I.U. Ethier, W. J. (1986). The multinational firm. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 101, 106–133. Frost, A. S. (2001). The geographical sources of foreign subsidiaries’ innovations. Strategic Management Journal, 22(2), 101–123.
56
JOHN H. DUNNING
Grubel, H. G. (1968). International diversified portfolios: Welfare gains and capital flows. American Economic Review, 58, 1299–1314. Helpman, E. (1985). The multinational firm and the structure of trade. Review of Economic Studies, 52, 443–457. Hirsch, S. (1976). An international trade and investment theory of the firm. Oxford Economic Papers, 28(July), 258–270. Holland, D., Sass, M., Benacek, V., & Gronicki, M. (2000). The determinants and impact of fdi in Central and Eastern Europe: A comparison of survey and econometric evidence. Transnational Corporations, 9(3), 162–212. Hymer, S. (1960). The international operations of national firms: A study of direct investment. PhD. Thesis, MIT, Boston: Published by MIT. Hymer, S. (1976). The international operations of national firms: A study of direct investment. PhD. Thesis, MIT, Boston: Published by MIT. IMD. (2004). World Competitiveness Yearbook. Lausanne: IMD. Johanson, J., & Vahlne, J. E. (1977). The internationalisation process of the firm: A model of knowledge development and increasing market commitments. Journal of International Business Studies, 8, 23–32. Knickerbocker, F. T. (1973). Oligopolistic reaction and the multinational enterprise. Cambridge: MIT, Harvard University Press. Krugman, P. (1982). The new theories of international trade and the multinational corporations. In: D. Audretsch & C. Kindleberger (Eds), The multinational corporation in the 1980s. Cambridge: MIT Press. Kuemmerle, W. (1999). The drivers of foreign direct investment into research and development: An empirical investigation. Journal of International Business Studies, 30(1), 1–24. Makino, S., Lau, C.-M., & Yeh, R. S. (2002). Asset exploitation versus asset-seeking: Implications for location choice of foreign direct investment from newly industrialised economies. Journal of International Business Studies, 33(3), 403–422. Manea, J., & Pearce, R. (2004). Industrial restructuring in economies in transition and TNCs investment motivations. Transnational Corporations, 23(2), 7–27. Markusen, J. R. (1984). Multinationals, multi-plant economies and the gains from trade. Journal of International Economics, 16, 205–226. Mellors, J. (1973). International tax differentials and the location of overseas direct investment: A pilot study. Discussion Papers in International Investment and Business Studies, No. 4, University of Reading, Reading. Meyer, K. (2004). Perspectives on multinational enterprises in emerging economies. Journal of International Business Studies, 35(4), 259–276. Miller, N. C., & Whitman, M. V. N. (1970). A mean variance analysis of US long term portfolio foreign investment. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 84(May), 175–192. Narula, R. (2001). Choosing between internal and non internal R&D activities: Some technological and economic factors. Technological Analysis and Strategic Management, 13, 365–388. Narula, R. (2003). Globalisation and technology. Cambridge: Polity Press. Narula, R., & Guyster, G. (2004). Globalisation and trends in international R&D alliances. Journal of International Management, 10, 199–218. Pearce, R. D. (1997). Global competition and technology. London: Macmillan.
Rugman and the Geography of MNE Activity
57
Pearce, R. D. (1999). Decentralised R&D and strategic competitiveness: Globalised approaches to the generation and use of technology in multinational enterprise (MNEs). Research Policy, 28, 157–178. Pearce, R. D., & Singh, S. (1992). Globalising research and development. London: Macmillan. Porter, M. E. (1990). The competitive advantage of nations. New York: The Free Press. Prachowy, M. J. (1972). Direct investment and the balance of payments of the US: A portfolio approach. In: F. Machlup, W. Salant & L. Tarshis (Eds), International mobility and movement of capital. New York: National Bureau of Economic Research. Ricart, J. E., Enright, M. J., Ghemawat, P., Hart, S. L., & Kharnea, T. (2004). New frontiers in international strategy. Journal of International Business Studies, 35(3), 175–200. Rugman, A. M. (1979). International diversification and the multinational enterprise. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books. Rugman, A. M. (1990). Multinationals and the Canada–United States free trade agreement. Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina Press. Rugman, A. M. (Ed.). (1993). Management International Review, 33(2). Special issue on Michael Porter’s Diamond of Competitive Advantage. Rugman, A. M. (1994). Foreign Investment in NAFTA. Columbia, SC: University of South Carolina Press. Rugman, A. M., Broeck V. D. & Verbeke, A. (Eds). (1995). Beyond the diamond research in global management (Vol. 5). Greenwich, CT: JAI Press. Rugman, A. M., & D’Cruz, J. R. (1994). A theory of business networks. In: L. Eden (Ed.), Multinationals in North America (pp. 103–115). Calgary, University of Calgary Press. Rugman, A. M., & Eden, L. (1985). Multinational Enterprises and Transfer Pricing (pp. 193– 211). London and Sydney: Croom Helm. Rugman, A. M., & Verbeke, A. (2001). Location, competitiveness and the multinational enterprise. In: A. M. Rugman & T. L. Brewer (Eds), The Oxford Handbook of International Business (pp. 150–180). Oxford: Oxford University Press. Rugman, A. M., & Verbeke, A. (2004). A perspective on regional and global strategies of multinational enterprises. Journal of International Business Studies, 35(1), 3–18. Stevens, G. V. G. (1969). Fixed investment expenditure of foreign manufacturing affiliates of US firms: Theoretical models and empirical evidence. Yale Economic Essays, 9(Spring), 137–200. Tang, R. Y. (1981). Multinational transfer pricing: Canadian and british perspectives. Toronto: Butterworth. UNCTAD. (2003). World Investment Report: FDI Policies for Development: National and International Perspectives. New York and Geneva: UN. UNCTAD. (2004). World investment report: The shift towards services. New York and Geneva: UN. Vernon, R. (1966). International investments and international trade in the product cycle. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 80, 190–207. Vernon, R. (1974). The multinational enterprise and the location of economic activity. In: J. H. Dunning (Ed.), Economic analysis and the multinational enterprise (pp. 89–114). London: Allen and Unwin. Wesson, T. (2002). Foreign direct investment and competitive advantage. Cheltenham: Glos Edward Elgar.
This page intentionally left blank
58
FINANCIAL AND NON-FINANCIAL THEORIES OF INTERNATIONAL DIVERSIFICATION John Cantwell BACKGROUND Alan Rugman was one of the first to examine in a systematic way the connection between the internationalization of the firm and the diversification of assets within the multinational enterprises (MNE). He has since moved on to deal with many other issues surrounding the MNE, but his major contribution to the subject of international diversification (Rugman, 1979) was for many years essential reading for anyone with serious pretensions to be or to become an international business scholar. Rugman (2005) himself sees the key idea in his early book as being an appreciation of the role of risk in foreign direct investment (FDI). MNEs in the place of individual investors, diversified their portfolio of assets, and thereby served as a vehicle for risk reduction. This argument can be applied especially before 1970, before advances in financial markets and international asset instruments enabled individual investors (or funds acting on their behalf) to directly conduct for themselves such strategies of international diversification to reduce risk.
Internalization, International Diversification and the Multinational Enterprise: Essays in Honor of Alan M. Rugman Research in Global Strategic Management, Volume 11, 59–73 Copyright r 2005 by Elsevier Ltd. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved ISSN: 1064-4857/doi:10.1016/S1064-4857(05)11005-5
59
60
JOHN CANTWELL
Although it is true that Rugman’s empirical study fits well into this framework – since his data were of US MNEs in the 1960s – in many ways it does his book an injustice to say that the applicability of its central contention was confined to the time when it was written. There is a further and more general underlying theme in Rugman (1979), and that lies in its notion of the MNE as a holder of a diversified portfolio of locational assets. Placed in these terms, then far from it having described a phenomenon that in retrospect represents little more than an historical curiosity, Rugman’s (1979) was a book ahead of its time. In this wider context of the MNE as the creator of asset diversification through an appropriate combination of geographically dispersed location-specific resources, there is now a great topical research interest. A recent literature has proposed that location heterogeneity provides critical opportunities for MNEs and so must now be at the heart of business strategy considerations (e.g. Ghemawat, 2001; Ricart, Enright, Ghemawat, Hart, & Khanna, 2004). Yet in this wider international business strategy context, the risk reduction motive for a diversified locational portfolio (the conventional finance perspective) is only one element of a broader story. The alternative nonfinancial perspective suggests another motive in constructing a coherent portfolio of locational assets that together represent a good fit with one another. When considered as a whole the diversified structure of locationspecific assets becomes a source of competitive advantage where the particular combination that has been found is synergistic or superadditive. Note that this portfolio-type argument is rather different from another recent strand of thought that has emphasized the attractions of an individual location on its own terms (such as, say, a cluster of companies in a location) as a source of competitive advantage to the firm that situates there (e.g. Porter, 2000). In connection with the diversified locational portfolio approach, it is important to reiterate (as does Rugman, 2005) that internationalization – which is defined as the international (or geographical cross-border) dispersal of activity – is not the same as or a sufficient condition for international diversification. Internationalization may entail no more than the conduct of the same activity in multiple locations, in which case it is not accompanied by diversification (except in the obvious sense of geographical diversification, but if that was all that was meant then there would be no need for a different term). International diversification is instead defined as the conduct of different activities in different locations, for which internationalization is necessary but not sufficient. The first motive for international diversification, as originally stressed by Rugman (1979) and in the finance perspective,
Financial and Non-financial Theories of International Diversification
61
is the reduction of risk over a cross-locational portfolio of dispersed assets. The second motive for international diversification is the creation of new value through the development of internationally interdependent structures that connect together a range of complementary activities.
A SHIFT IN FOCUS IN DISCUSSIONS OF CORPORATE DIVERSIFICATION The second motive for international diversification has become steadily more important over the period since Rugman’s (1979) book was published. In recent years, technological capabilities have been diversifying in large multiproduct firms to the extent that this type of diversification has become increasingly the focus of analytical attention in contrast to the other ‘classic’ types of diversification, namely product and market diversification. This has brought the ‘multi-technology corporation’ centre stage (Pavitt, Robson, & Townsend, 1989; Granstrand, Patel, & Pavitt, 1997; Silverman, 2002; Fai, 2003; Cantwell, Gambardella, & Granstrand, 2004). A critical importance of information and communication technology (ICT) to the now more complex management of innovation in MNEs is that it enables firms to better exploit their corporate technological diversification across national boundaries, as well as across business areas. This owes to the dual role of ICT as being both a means of combining fields of knowledge creation that were previously kept largely apart, and a managerial process technology that lowers internal coordination costs, and thus extends the potential boundaries of firms. The first facet of ICT entails the greater facility to develop related combinations of formerly separate lines of technological development. With respect to the second facet, the methods of managing more complex combinations and greater diversity have also improved. Thus, the social technology of management practice has itself developed to facilitate technological diversification (Granstrand, 2004). This implies the feasibility of the kind of organizational structure that is needed to sustain a more diverse firm, and one that is more flexible and potentially adaptable. However, while this use of ICT has led many smaller firms to extend the breadth of their technological diversification to create new combinations, in some of the very largest MNEs the extent of technological diversification has been reduced, so as to better focus on the most promising possible combinations from among the broader initial dispersion of innovative
62
JOHN CANTWELL
activity that such companies have inherited from the past (Cantwell & Santangelo, 2000). The particularly pronounced trend towards a wider dispersion of innovative effort in ICT across firms seems to be evidence of a paradigm shift in the general conditions for innovation and growth, according to the neo-Schumpeterian perspective upon long-run techno-socioeconomic change (Freeman & Perez, 1988). However, empirical investigations also show that industries differ in the propensity of their firms to diversify into technologies that lie in complementary or non-primary fields for the industry. Two Strands of Analysis While the expanded contribution of ICT is a widely acknowledged feature of the so-called ‘new economy’ or a new paradigm, with its associated need for more general and multiple skills on the part of the workforce, the greater significance of business process re-engineering and the more frequent changing and reconstitution of firm boundaries may not have been so widely appreciated. The new paradigm is one of continual experimentation over the right mix at the firm level, seeking out the most productive combinations of business areas and technologies. Since individual locations are inevitably specialized in their activity, and indeed increasingly specialized in part owing to greater subsidiary-level specialization within MNEs (Cantwell & Vertova, 2004), the most suitable and potentially innovative combinations of activity now commonly require international connections. For this purpose, the MNE is the principal vehicle. Of course, this combinatory rationale for experimenting with different resource mixes is at odds the traditional finance perspective on diversification. In the finance perspective on the subject, diversification is believed to be a means of reducing risk by holding a portfolio of distinct lines of activity. In the finance perspective we should observe diversification into unrelated assets, whereas in the alternative view we should see the reverse, namely diversification into related assets and the establishment of patterns of corporate coherence (Rumelt, 1974; Teece, Rumelt, Dosi, & Winter, 1994; Piscitello, 2004). From the standpoint of international business, the former finance perspective can best be applied to local market-seeking activities, in which diversification across unrelated products or geographically unconnected markets (and preferably both) may reduce risk. Local marketseeking was the dominant motive for FDI in the 1960s, which fits well with the arguments and data of Rugman (1979). It remains crucial today, although markets are now much less segmented than they once were.
Financial and Non-financial Theories of International Diversification
63
In the latter non-financial perspective, diversification is instead a business strategy for bringing together combinations of related assets as a means of constructing corporate coherence. In the international business context, this perspective can be applied most readily to asset–seeking activities that become locally competence-creating. Asset–seeking strategies have become gradually more important as a motive for FDI especially since the 1980s. MNEs are now increasingly undertaking investments (especially through mergers and acquisitions) or divestments as a means of developing new structures of relatedness between in-house activities. One key aspect of this that relies on corporate technological diversification is to bring together new combinations of technologically complementary fields of activity to promote a greater ease of innovation (Schumpeter, 1934, had long ago argued that innovation generally entails such ‘new combinations’). The relationship between technological diversification and the internationalization of production is a complex one, in that it is mediated by the accumulation of competence and competence creation in the MNE. It has also changed in nature over the years, from being an historically negative relationship (a choice between greater diversification in established markets and entry into new markets) when most international investments were local market-seeking, to a positive one in the most recent period (there being a complementarity between extending the competence base of the multinational firm at home and abroad) when a rising share of international investments are technology or asset-seeking (Cantwell & Piscitello, 2004). Both the financial and non-financial strands of analysis of MNE operations are valid, since MNEs have a mix of risk-reducing unrelated diversity and value-creating synergy in their strategies. However, a closer recent association between technological diversification and internationalization has been the outcome of more closely internationally integrated MNE networks. The newer perspective on innovation and the MNE sees MNEs as evolutionary learning organizations, that create (and draw upon) a regular and cumulative flow of knowledge and capabilities from locationally differentiated sources.
Innovation in the MNE as an Evolutionary Process: The Analytical Background The view that technological change is an endogenous property of firms (and especially, although not exclusively, large firms) as evolutionary learning institutions, can be traced back in recent times to the pioneering contribution
64
JOHN CANTWELL
of Penrose (1959). In other words, the new competences a firm is able to create are a product of its prior capabilities or resources and not a simple response to external markets or discoveries. Innovative new competences (capacities to introduce new products and processes) are achieved through an internal search and problem-solving process that can only be revealed by opening up the black box of the firm (Rosenberg, 1982, 1994). It is true that interactions between the learning firm and its markets, with the science and discovery base, and with other firms (especially through cooperative relationships within the same industry, as emphasized by Richardson, 1972) all play important roles. However, technological change is essentially the outcome of continual experimentation within each firm along some path-dependent course with a certain logic of its own, which have been usefully described as technological trajectories (Dosi, 1982). Hence, the evolving profiles of technological competence of firms tend to remain stable over long periods of time and to change only gradually and incrementally, despite the much more dramatic changes in their markets or discovery base (Cantwell & Fai, 1999). Once the black box of the firm has been opened to examination, the organizational and social aspects of technological capability become clear; technology consists of a localized and tacit element which is context-specific, as well as potentially public knowledge (Nelson, 1992). Nelson and Winter (1982) provided the pioneering analysis of how, when technological change is rightly understood as a path-dependent and localized process of experimental learning and search activities undertaken within firms, the fruits of innovative improvements become embodied not just in new devices, equipment or products, but also in the organizational routines of companies. Therefore, it is not surprising that the innovation systems of countries depend largely on the accumulated capabilities of large local firms, which become repositories of technological competence, even if their activities in turn depend upon the supporting structure of other institutions that characterizes the local environment (Nelson, 1993). The technological paths or trajectories that are followed by firms can also be described as a process of corporate technological diversification, which depends upon gradual changes in the degree of relatedness between competences in different technological fields. Firms can be expected to move away from combinations of technological development that have become less related, and towards new combinations of fields of activity between which there is an increase in technological complementarity. If there is a general background rise in technological interrelatedness then this will be associated with a broadening in the average degree of corporate technolog-
Financial and Non-financial Theories of International Diversification
65
ical diversification relative to any given extent of product or market diversification (Piscitello, 2004). However, for some very large firms that had achieved an already high degree of technological diversification, the effect may run in the opposite direction (Cantwell & Santangelo, 2000). That is, greater interrelatedness implies that each firm must utilize more carefully than in the past the most complementary combinations of technologies, which may entail a sharper focus on those combinations in an existing portfolio that are most closely complementary, partially at the expense of other lines of development which have only ever fitted moderately well. Somewhat more distant but still relevant capabilities may be better accommodated through supporting some in-house facilities as a means of monitoring and accessing developments in alliance partners or suppliers or customers, for which the fields in question are more critical and a central area of competence. The other aspect of the localization of technological change is that it tends to be not just firm-specific but also location-specific, as confirmed by the continuing significance of regional and national systems of innovation (Nelson, 1993), and by the tendency towards geographical proximity in the linkages between science and technology (Jaffe, Trajtenberg, & Henderson, 1993; Rosenberg & Nelson, 1996; Cantwell & Piscitello, 2005). As a result, MNEs can gain competitive advantage by strategically integrating complementary streams of innovation across geographically dispersed facilities (Cantwell, 1989). By further developing the technological capacities in which a location is already specialized, such international integration of networks for innovation within MNEs may thereby have the effect of reinforcing established national and regional systems of innovation (Cantwell, 1995). In this event the closer international integration of complementary lines of technological development within the MNE also becomes bound up with the process of technological diversification at the level of the global corporate group as a whole (Cantwell & Piscitello, 2000). Although the measures of technological diversification and product diversification may be similar, our arguments thus far suggest that the dispersion of technological competence within firms is not theoretically the same as the dispersion of their product markets, even if we would expect a correlation of the two across firms. Over time there could well be periods in which technological diversification and product diversification move in different directions on average. It has been suggested that in recent times there has been a tendency for product ranges to become more concentrated while technological capabilities have become more diversified. More substantively, cumulativeness and path-dependency apply to the process of corporate
66
JOHN CANTWELL
technological competence development, but not necessarily (or only to a lesser extent) to the composition of a firm’s markets.
Implications for the Analysis of MNEs At a general level, a firm’s operations may be dispersed across different types of productive activity (the diversification of technologies or products), or over geographical space (the internationalization of the same). However, the analysis of technologies and product markets is different in this respect. Spreading the product markets in which the firm is involved may be a matter of exploiting more effectively established competencies, while moving into new areas of technological development means creating new competence. In terms of product markets, diversification and internationalization have often been considered and analysed separately as two distinct phenomena or alternative routes to growth, in the analytical framework that originated from Penrose (1959). Historically, it was usually a matter of how established competences could be more fully exploited in new markets in related industries, or in other countries. More recently, Penrose’s resource-based view of the firm as a collection of productive assets has given rise to a competence-based theory of the firm (Teece, Pisano, & Shuen, 1997; Chandler, Hagstro¨m, & So¨lvell, 1998), in which the firm is seen as an institution that constructs capabilities through internal learning processes in the form of evolutionary experimentation. In this event the major issue is not so much how the firm exploits a given competence, but rather how it establishes a (spatially and sectorally) diffuse system for the creation of new competence. In order not just to exploit effectively but also to consolidate an existing capability, it is generally necessary for a firm to extend that capability into new related fields of production and technology, and across a variety of geographical sites. The corporate internationalization and diversification of technological activity are indeed both ways of spreading the competence base of the firm, and of acquiring new technological assets, or sources of competitive advantage. In this context, recent studies have shown that firmspecific technological competence may be diversified and internationalized thus leading to the most recent emergence of corporate international networks more and more resembling heterarchies rather than hierarchies (Hedlund, 1986). At the same time, the increasing role of MNEs in the generation of technology has been facilitated by their recent trend to ‘globalize’ their activities; that is, to establish internal and external cross-border networks for inno-
Financial and Non-financial Theories of International Diversification
67
vation which may lead to an improvement of innovation capacity both of the MNE and of host locations (Cantwell & Iammarino, 2000). Globalization and in particular the international integration of technological activities is indeed a process leading to structural transformation of firms, nations and regions (Dunning, 2000), both when directed to augmenting home-based assets – often tapping into foreign research and development (R&D) – and to more effectively deploying existing technological capabilities (Kuemmerle, 1999). The growing role of the reorganization of technological activities by MNEs as a source of competitive advantage has been indeed recently recognized to have an important impact on the shape and character of national systems of innovations and local growth prospects both for the home and host countries.
International Diversification of the Technological Competence Base in the MNE In the earlier stages of development of large firms in the interwar and early post-war periods until around 1970, it is reasonable to depict diversification and internationalization of markets as two alternative strategies for corporate growth, as suggested by Penrose (1959). However, in this phase while large firms were commonly diversifying their technological competence in the normal course of growth (as shown by Chandler (1990) and in company case studies by those such as Hounshell & Smith (1988) and Warner (1978), their internationalization of R&D was aimed at the wider exploitation of the basic competence they had already established at home rather than at extending that competence into new fields or ‘sourcing’ technology abroad). Subsidiary R&D concentrated upon the adaptation of products to local tastes, and the adaptation of processes to local resource availabilities and production conditions (Cantwell, 1995). Thus, in the early stages, although the internationalization of corporate technology should not be underestimated (a criticism of some recent literature advanced by Cantwell, 1995), it was motivated mainly by the extent of dissimilarity between home and foreign markets rather than by the rationale of the process of further competence accumulation. This motivation of the dissimilarity of markets is also entirely consistent with Rugman’s (1979) explanation of international diversification. In the second phase, from about 1970 until around the mid-1980s, the old technology paradigm ran into difficulties (Freeman & Perez, 1988), as the opportunities for integrating diverse technologies in large scale plants had been gradually exhausted. Thus, it seems reasonable to expect that at
68
JOHN CANTWELL
around this time the relationship between the accumulation and diversification of competence may have broken down. Technological diversification was now increasingly based instead on the growing interrelatedness between formerly separate technologies (Kodama, 1986), but like with the formation of corporate international networks, the new opportunities for innovative development were still at an early stage in the 1970s. Even in the second phase, after the early post-war period, there seems to have been a general widening of the internationalization and diversification of technology across a wider range of firms (Cantwell, 1995). The most common explanation is that lower transport and communication costs contributed to a general expansion across large firms in the internationalization of technological activity (Vernon, 1973), while an increase in technological interrelatedness prompted a broader cross-section of firms into technological diversification (Pavitt et al., 1989; Patel & Pavitt, 1997, 1998). Another aspect which has recently entered into the discussion is the changing nature of technological knowledge itself (Nelson & Thomson, 1997), that with the development of scientific and engineering communities became more susceptible to transmission between fields of activity and between countries. More recently, however, from the mid-1980s the nature of the competence creation process seems to have entered a third phase in the technologically leading firms (Cantwell, 1995). What previously had been a dispersed set of loosely connected efforts for the consolidation and adaptation of competence within the firm (achieved through some combination of diversification and internationalization), has been transformed in some companies into a more complex integrated and interactive network for the generation of new competence. This new system for corporate development relies on the interrelatedness between specialized activities conducted in particular locations, each of which takes advantage of spatially specific resources or capabilities. In this event internationalization, diversification and competence creation become for the first time necessarily interconnected and thus mutually positively related parts of a common process. The wider picture of which this is part is one which formerly local market oriented affiliates have been increasingly integrated into international networks within their respective multinational companies, such networks coming to resemble ‘heterarchies’ more than hierarchies (Hedlund, 1986; Doz, 1986; Porter, 1986; Bartlett & Ghoshal, 1989; Dunning, 1992), and affiliates have increasingly pursued ‘asset-seeking’ motives (Dunning, 1995, 1996). Beyond the emergence of a new interrelationship between the accumulation, diversification and internationalization of corporate technological competence, the third phase is distinctive in changes in the cross-firm pat-
Financial and Non-financial Theories of International Diversification
69
tern of activity in another respect too. Given that the internationally dispersed development of technology is now a source of competitive advantage, two different types of firm behaviour can be observed, depending upon whether a firm that begins with relatively little international activity needs to ‘catch-up’ (Cantwell & Sanna-Randaccio, 1990), or an established multinational reorganizes its existing international network to better exploit the respective comparative advantages in innovation of the locations in which it operates (Cantwell & Sanna-Randaccio, 1993). Due to the first kind of consideration, we expect that the absolute extension of company networks for technological development has become linked on average to a widening of their international scope. Yet due to the second factor, we have reason to also believe that the firms with the fastest proportional increase in competence will tend in the latest phase to be established multinationals that are restructuring their international networks to better effect, and hence selectively concentrating the development of key fields in the most suitable centres (Cantwell & Piscitello, 1999).
Patterns of International Technological Diversification The most typical pattern of international specialization in innovative activity within the MNE is for the development of technologies that are core to the firm’s industry to be concentrated at home, while other fields of technological activity may be located abroad, and in this sense the internationalization of research tends to be diversified and complementary to the home base (Cantwell & Kosmopoulou, 2002). Thus, when science-based technology creation is internationally dispersed it is most often attributable to foreign technology acquisition by the firms of ‘other’ industries – for example, chemical industry MNEs developing electrical technologies abroad, or electrical equipment MNEs developing specialized chemical processes outside their home countries (Cantwell & Santangelo, 2000). From the other side of host countries as opposed to investing MNEs, a local centre of excellence for some specialized field of innovation (say in chemicals) will tend to attract investments in local chemical research not so much by foreign-owned MNEs in the chemical industry, but to a greater extent by MNEs from other industries, whose objective is to tap into the resources of the centre in order to diversify their own technological base (Cantwell & Kosmopoulou, 2002). Evidence has now emerged that the choice of foreign location for technological development in support of what is done in the home base of the
70
JOHN CANTWELL
MNE depends upon whether host regions within countries are either major centres for innovation or not (termed ‘higher order’ regions by Cantwell & Iammarino, 2000; Cantwell & Janne, 1999). Whereas most regions are not major centres and tend to be highly specialized in their profile of technological development, and hence attract foreign-owned activity in the same narrow range of fields; in the major centres much of the locally sited innovation of foreign-owned MNEs does not match very well the specific fields of local specialization, but is rather geared towards the development of technologies that are core to the current techno-economic paradigm (notably ICT) or earlier paradigms (notably mechanical technologies) (Cantwell, Iammarino, & Noonan, 2000). The need to develop these latter technologies is shared by the firms of all industries, and the knowledge spillovers between MNEs and local firms in this case may be inter-industry in character. Thus, ICT development in centres of excellence is not the prerequisite of firms of the ICT industries, but instead involves the efforts of the MNEs of other industries in these common locations. A deficiency of the literature on innovation and the MNE to date, and of most of the literature on the MNE in general, is that either the MNE is essentially treated as being bi-polar (the key distinction is between the home base and foreign operations considered collectively), or the focus is on the subsidiary as the unit of analysis and on the characteristics of the location in which it is situated. Too little still is known of strategies to construct portfolios of locationally differentiated activities that between them represent beneficial combinations for the corporate group as a whole. The focus here needs to be on the precise locational spread of the MNE network, and not so much on what is done abroad as a whole, or on what is done in specific locations when treated in isolation. Although the context of this discussion is admittedly very different from that supposed in the financial perspective on the subject, in many ways this critical and emergent issue in international business strategy today requires the conceptualization of international diversification as an overall portfolio of locational assets as suggested by Rugman (1979).
REFERENCES Bartlett, C. A., & Ghoshal, S. (1989). Managing across borders: The transnational solution. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press. Cantwell, J. A. (1989). Technological innovation and multinational corporations. Basil Blackwell: Oxford. Cantwell, J. A. (1995). The globalisation of technology: What remains of the product cycle model? Cambridge Journal of Economics, 19, 155–174.
Financial and Non-financial Theories of International Diversification
71
Cantwell, J. A., & Fai, F. M. (1999). Firms as the source of innovation and growth: The evolution of technological competence. Journal of Evolutionary Economics, 9, 331–366. Cantwell, J. A., Gambardella, A., & Granstrand, O. (Eds) (2004). The economics and management of technological diversification. London and New York: Routledge. Cantwell, J. A., & Iammarino, S. (2000). Multinational corporations and the location of technological innovation in the UK regions. Regional Studies, 34, 317–332. Cantwell, J. A., Iammarino, S., & Noonan, C. (2000). Sticky places in slippery space the location of innovation by MNCs in the European regions. In: N. Pain (Ed.), Inward investment, technological change and growth (pp. 210–239). London: Macmillan. Cantwell, J. A., & Janne, O. E. M. (1999). Technological globalisation and innovative centres: The role of corporate technological leadership and location hierarchy. Research Policy, 28, 119–144. Cantwell, J. A., & Kosmopoulou, E. (2002). What determines the internationalisation of corporate technology? In: M. Forsgren, H. Ha˚kanson & V. Havila (Eds), Critical perspectives on internationalisation (pp. 305–334). Oxford: Pergamon. Cantwell, J. A., & Piscitello, L. (1999). The emergence of corporate international networks for the accumulation of dispersed technological capabilities. Management International Review, 39(Special Issue 1), 123–147. Cantwell, J. A., & Piscitello, L. (2000). Accumulating technological competence – its changing impact on corporate diversification and internationalization. Industrial and Corporate Change, 9, 21–51. Cantwell, J. A., & Piscitello, L. (2004). The relationship between technological diversification and internationalization. In: J. A. Cantwell, A. Gambardella & O. Granstrand (Eds), The economics and management of technological diversification (pp. 101–115). London: Routledge. Cantwell, J. A., & Piscitello, L. (2005). Recent location of foreign-owned R&D activities by large multinational corporations in the European regions: The role of spillovers and externalities. Regional Studies, 39, 1–16. Cantwell, J. A., & Sanna-Randaccio, F. (1990). The growth of multinationals and the catchingup effect. Economic Notes, 19, 1–23. Cantwell, J. A., & Sanna-Randaccio, F. (1993). Multinationality and firm growth. Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 129, 275–299. Cantwell, J. A., & Santangelo, G. D. (2000). Capitalism, profits and innovation in the new techno-economic paradigm. Journal of Evolutionary Economics, 10, 131–157. Cantwell, J. A., & Vertova, G. (2004). Historical evolution of technological diversification. Research Policy, 33, 511–529. Chandler, A. D. (1990). Scale and scope: The dynamics of industrial capitalism. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Chandler, A. D., Hagstro¨m, P., & So¨lvell, O¨. (Eds) (1998). The dynamic firm: The role of technology, strategy, organization and regions. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press. Dosi, G. (1982). Technological paradigms and technological trajectories: A suggested interpretation of the determinants and directions of technical change. Research Policy, 2, 147–162. Doz, Y. (1986). Strategic management in multinational companies. Oxford: Pergamon. Dunning, J. H. (1992). Multinational enterprises and the global economy. Wokingham: AddisonWesley.
72
JOHN CANTWELL
Dunning, J. H. (1995). Reappraising the eclectic paradigm in an age of alliance capitalism. Journal of International Business Studies, 26, 461–491. Dunning, J. H. (1996). The geographical sources of the competitiveness of firms: Some results of a new survey. Transnational Corporations, 5, 1–29. Dunning, J. H. (2000). Regions, globalisation and the knowledge economy: The issues stated. In: J. H. Dunning (Ed.), Regions, globalisation and the knowledge based economy. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press. Fai, F. M. (2003). Corporate technological competence and the evolution of technological diversification. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar. Freeman, C., & Perez, C. (1988). Structural crises of adjustment, business cycles and investment behaviour. In: G. Dosi, C. Freeman, R. R. Nelson, G. Silverberg & L. L. G. Soete (Eds), Technical change and economic theory. London: Frances Pinter. Ghemawat, P. (2001). Distance still matters: The hard reality of global expansion. Harvard Business Review, 79, 137–147. Granstrand, O. (2004). Multi-technology management. In: J. A. Cantwell, A. Gambardella & O. Granstrand (Eds), The economics and management of technological diversification (pp. 297–332). London: Routledge. Granstrand, O., Patel, P., & Pavitt, K. L. R. (1997). Multi-technology corporations: Why they have ‘‘distributed’’ rather than ‘‘distinctive core’’ competencies. California Management Review, 39, 8–25. Hedlund, G. (1986). The hypermodern MNC: A heterarchy? Human Resource Management, 25, 9–25. Hounshell, D. A., & Smith, J. K. (1988). Science and corporate strategy: Du Pont R&D. 1902– 1980. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press. Jaffe, A. B., Trajtenberg, M., & Henderson, R. (1993). Geographic localization of knowledge spillovers as evidenced by patent citations. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 63, 577–598. Kodama, F. (1986). Technological diversification of Japanese industry. Science, 233, 291–296. Kuemmerle, W. (1999). The drivers of foreign direct investment into research and development: An empirical investigation. Journal of International Business Studies, 30, 1–24. Nelson, R. R. (1992). What is ‘‘commercial’’ and what is ‘‘public’’ about technology, and what should be? In: N. Rosenberg, R. Landau & D. C. Mowery (Eds), Technology and the wealth of nations. Stanford: Stanford University Press. Nelson, R. R. (Ed.) (1993). National innovation systems: A comparative analysis. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press. Nelson, R.R., & Thomson, R. (1997). The internationalization of technology, 1874–1929: Evidence from US, British and German patent experience. Mimeo, University of Vermont and Columbia University, New York. Nelson, R. R., & Winter, S. G. (1982). An evolutionary theory of economic change. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Patel, P., & Pavitt, K. L. R. (1997). The technological competencies of the world’s largest firms: Complex and path-dependent, but not much variety. Research Policy, 26, 141–156. Patel, P., & Pavitt, K. L. R. (1998). The wide (and increasing) spread of technological competencies in the world’s largest firms: A challenge to conventional wisdom. In: A. D. Chandler, P. Hagstro¨m & O¨. So¨lvell (Eds), The dynamic firm: The role of technology, strategy, organization and regions. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
Financial and Non-financial Theories of International Diversification
73
Pavitt, K. L. R., Robson, M., & Townsend, J. (1989). Technological accumulation, diversification, and organisation in UK companies, 1945–1983. Management Science, 35, 81– 99. Penrose, E. T. (1959). The theory of the growth of the firm. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press. Piscitello, L. (2004). Corporate diversification, coherence and economic performance. Industrial and Corporate Change, 13, 757–787. Porter, M. E. (1986). Competition in global industries: A conceptual framework. In: M. E. Porter (Ed.), Competition in global industries. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press. Porter, M. E. (2000). Location, competition and economic development: Local clusters in a global economy. Economic Development Quarterly, 14, 15–34. Ricart, J. E., Enright, M. J., Ghemawat, P., Hart, S., & Khanna, T. (2004). New frontiers in international strategy. Journal of International Business Studies, 35, 175–200. Richardson, G. B. (1972). The organisation of industry. Economic Journal, 82, 883–896. Rosenberg, N. (1982). Inside the black box: Technology and economics. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press. Rosenberg, N. (1994). Exploring the black box: Technology, economics and history. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press. Rosenberg, N., & Nelson, R. R. (1996). The roles of universities in the advance of industrial technology. In: R. S. Rosenbloom & W. J. Spencer (Eds), Engines of innovation: US industrial research at the end of an era. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press. Rugman, A. M. (1979). International diversification and the multinational enterprise. Lexington, MA: DC Heath. Rugman, A. M. (2005). The twenty-five years of ‘‘International diversification and the multinational enterprise. In: A. Verbeke (Ed.), Internalization, international diversification and the MNE: Essays in honor of Alan M. Rugman. Amsterdam: Elsevier. Rumelt, R. P. (1974). Strategy, structure and economic performance. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Business School Press. Schumpeter, J. A. (1934). The theory of economic development. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Silverman, B. S. (2002). Technological resources and the logic of corporate diversification. London and New York: Routledge. Teece, D. J., Pisano, G., & Shuen, A. (1997). Dynamic capabilities and strategic management. Strategic Management Journal, 18, 509–533. Teece, D. J., Rumelt, R. P., Dosi, G., & Winter, S. G. (1994). Understanding corporate coherence: Theory and evidence. Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 23, 1–30. Vernon, R. (1973). Sovereignity at bay. Harmondsworth: Penguin. Warner, J. C. (1978). Radio, corporation of America: Part I – the years to 1938. In: RCA: Five historical views (pp. 2–8). New York: RCA.
This page intentionally left blank
74
INTERNALIZATION THEORY AND THE INTERNATIONAL DIVERSIFICATION: PERFORMANCE CONUNDRUM Jean-Franc- ois Hennart The last 10 years have witnessed an explosion of empirical studies trying to explore the relationship between a firm’s size and scope of international operations and its profitability. An unsystematic search of the recent literature yields 39 empirical studies in journals such as the Journal of International Business Studies, the Academy of Management Journal, the Strategic Management Journal, and Management International Review that have investigated the relationship between multinationality and performance. While the various authors who have contributed to this literature cite each other, and seem to suggest that they are working within a well-known and accepted framework, this literature seems based on ad hoc theorizing, and uses dependent and independent variables that do not necessarily measure the same concept. Not unexpectedly, its findings are mixed: the relationship between multinationality and performance ranges from negative (e.g. Michel & Shaked, 1986) to zero (e.g. Tallman & Li, 1996), to inverted U-shaped (Gomes & Ramaswamy, 1999), and to sigmoid (Contractor, Kundu, & Hsu, 2003).
Internalization, International Diversification and the Multinational Enterprise: Essays in Honor of Alan M. Rugman Research in Global Strategic Management, Volume 11, 75–93 Copyright r 2005 by Elsevier Ltd. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved ISSN: 1064-4857/doi:10.1016/S1064-4857(05)11006-7
75
76
JEAN-FRANC - OIS HENNART
Part of the reason for the lack of robust findings is that this literature has in fact investigated two separate research questions (1) how a firm’s international diversification (i.e. the geographical dispersion of its sales or assets) affects its profitability or the variance of its profits and (2) how a firm’s ratio of foreign sales (or foreign assets, employment, or income) to total sales (assets, employment, income) affects its profitability or the variance of its profits. These two research questions are distinct, both conceptually and empirically. Conceptually, geographic diversification may yield some advantages which are separate from those that accrue from the relative size of foreign operations. Empirically, a firm can be highly geographically diversified, with sales offices in the four corners of the globe, but with foreign assets that are small relative to domestic assets. Inversely, many US-based multinational enterprises (MNEs) have extensive operations in Canada, but few elsewhere, resulting in a high ratio of foreign to domestic sales, but very little dispersion across countries. ‘‘Multinationality’’ covers therefore very different realities. In general the literature does not seem to see this as two separate questions, both in terms of theoretical arguments and of measurement. First, authors often confuse the two in the terminology they use. Geringer, Tallman, and Olsen (2000, p. 61) describe under the heading ‘‘international diversity’’ their main independent variable, which is the share of foreign subsidiary sales over total sales, a measure that does not reflect diversification, but rather the relative importance of foreign over domestic business (the common understanding of diversification is that it refers to ‘‘dispersion into more or less related categories’’ as in ‘‘product diversification’’). Theoretical arguments that purport to explain why firms with more geographically spread activities should be more profitable (for example the argument that having geographically diversified operations allows firms to develop more diverse capabilities, which themselves lead to higher profitability) are used to explain a dependent variable which is in fact the ratio of foreign to total sales (see for example Kotabe, Srinavasan, & Aulakh, 2002). To make comparisons even more difficult, some authors have used as dependent variable a composite measure of ‘‘multinationality’’ that incorporates both the share of foreign sales and its dispersion across countries (e.g. Gomes & Ramaswamy, 1999). It is not my goal here to do a comprehensive review of this very large and heterogeneous literature. Because the arguments made for a relationship between multinationality and performance (under their various measurements) are highly complex, I will only discuss a few of them. Within these limitations, my goal is to show how the hypotheses, the variables, and the
Internalization Theory and the International Diversification
77
measurements of this literature would benefit from a firmer theoretical grounding, and in particular from a grounding in the internalization theory put forth by Rugman (1981) and his colleagues. I first review the arguments made in the literature as to why the relative importance of a firm’s foreign activities and its geographical diversification should affect its profitability, starting with the international diversification/ performance relationship, then examining the reasons put forth why a firm’s ratio of foreign to total sales should affect its profitability. The arguments are found to be less than persuasive, in part because of a failure by most authors to see the presumed advantages of MNEs in comparison to those available on markets. I then show that internalization theory provides such a comparative-institutional framework. Its implications are that, everything else constant, the size and scope of firms should have no impact whatsoever on their performance, and that any statistical relationship between multinationality and performance is due to measurement biases and/or omitted variables.
A CRITICAL REVIEW OF THE THEORETICAL REASONS WHY INTERNATIONAL DIVERSIFICATION AND INTERNAL EXPANSION SHOULD AFFECT PERFORMANCE International Diversification and Performance We start by looking at the arguments put forth as to why having operations evenly spread in a large number of countries should make firms more profitable. Kim, Hwang, and Burgers (1993) argue, for example, that global market diversification, which they measure as the dispersion of a firm’s business between seven global market areas, provides a series of advantages that should allow globally diversified firms to earn both higher return on assets and lower risk. Because their arguments are complex and multifaceted, I cite them in extenso. First, global market diversification offers possibilities for exploitation of economies of scale and scope above and beyond the potential of product diversification (Grant, Jammine, & Thomas, 1988). Second, the diversity of national markets exposes firms to multiple stimuli which provides [sic] with a broader learning opportunity and the ability to develop more diverse capabilities than are available to purely domestic firmsy. Third, different nations have different factor endowments which, in the absence of efficient markets, lead to intercountry differences in factor costs. Global market
78
JEAN-FRANC - OIS HENNART diversification allows firms to gain cost advantages by configuring their value added chain in such a way that each link is located in the country which has the least cost for that link (Kogut, 1985a). Global market diversification thus provides firms with unique opportunities to increase returns by spreading its [sic] activities [emphasis in original] across multiple global market areas, rather than by choosing higher risk activities. At the same time, global market diversification endows firms with three unique options [emphasis in original] over domestic firms which are reasoned to reduce the level of corporate risk. First, global market diversification provides a firm with multiple national market bases from which it can retaliate against aggressive moves made by competitors (Hamel & Prahalad, 1985; Kim & Mauborgne, 1988). This option reduces the risk for the global firm of having to face aggressive challenges from its competitors. Second, the multiplicity of national markets allows firms to minimize the effect of adverse changes in a country’s interest rates, wage rates, and commodity and raw material prices by providing the added option to more readily shift production and sourcing sites to other more favorable national markets (Kogut, 1983, 1985b; Porter, 1986). Finally, global market diversification releases firms from the mercy of supply and demand fluctuations of any one national market, smoothing the peaks and troughs of firms’ revenue streams. In sum, the spreading of activities across global market areas provides the firm with operational flexibilities that will serve to reduce earning and profit fluctuations. Taken together, the above discussions suggest that the unique opportunities and options of global market diversification may simultaneously increase firms’ returns and reduce their risk.’’ (Kim et al., 1993, pp. 276–277)
Once duplication is taken out, Kim et al.’s arguments can be summarized as follows: global market diversification increases profitability at a given level of risk because it (1) reduces risk; (2) makes it possible to choose optimal locations and to access cheap resources; (3) allows for the exploitation of scale economies; (4) provides greater learning opportunities; and (5) reduces competition. While much can be said on reasons (4) and (5), I will concentrate on the first three, starting with the argument that an important reason why MNEs have a better profit/risk profile than domestic firms is because their operations are geographically dispersed.
The ‘‘Portfolio Diversification’’ Argument Kim et al.’s last argument in the citation above is that ‘‘global market diversification releases firms from the mercy of supply and demand fluctuations of any one national market, smoothing the peaks and troughs of firms’ revenues streams.’’ In other words, Kim et al. are arguing that owning revenue-yielding assets whose returns are uncorrelated will reduce risk at any level of profits. This is the argument made by Markowitz (1959) that individuals who want to reduce the risk of any given portfolio at a given level of returns should invest in assets whose returns are uncorrelated. If
Internalization Theory and the International Diversification
79
economic conditions are less than fully correlated across countries, then investing in securities of firms or institutions located in a number of countries may reduce the variance of one’s portfolio. Kim et al.’s argument can be seen as an application of this portfolio diversification model to MNEs. If returns are not perfectly correlated across countries, then a firm which generates profits in a large number of countries may have more stable returns than a firm which earns its income in a smaller number of countries. Markowitz has in mind individuals diversifying their assets, and a first question is why it is firms that should build diversified portfolios of assets rather than individuals. In other words, why should individuals invest in a small number of partly diversified MNEs rather than in a highly diversified portfolio of ‘‘pure plays,’’ i.e. single product, single country firms? The reason has to be that the costs of building internationally diversified portfolios of income earning assets are higher for individuals than for firms. The best way for individuals to geographically diversify their portfolios would then be to buy securities in partly geographically diversified MNEs. Portfolio investors buying shares in foreign firms run the risk that the firms in which they have invested will defraud them. Since direct investment carries control, this particular risk is somewhat alleviated for those who invest abroad through home MNEs. On the other hand, MNEs lack knowledge of the foreign markets they enter, have fewer contacts, may be victims of discriminatory treatment, and shoulder the added costs of having to manage their investments at a distance (Hennart, 1982). For these reasons, we would expect them to make worse investments on average than local firms, and to incur higher management costs. The relative efficiency of capital market diversification vs. MNE diversification hinges therefore on a comparison of the transaction costs incurred by individuals in diversifying in the share market vs. the management costs MNEs incur in running their foreign affiliates. The latter are likely to both limit the scope and increase the costs of MNE diversification. The question then is how efficient are MNEs as mechanisms for diversification? One way to answer this question is to ask what MNEs would be like if they were designed to reduce portfolio risk at any level of returns. In other words, how does the actual pattern of investments by MNEs compare to one that would be predicted by portfolio diversification? Roughly, it can be argued that an MNE whose main goal was to reduce risk would look like a global mutual fund: it would take small stakes in a variety of industries in as large a number of countries as possible, making sure that the business cycles of the countries where it invests are uncorrelated with each other and with its home country.
80
JEAN-FRANC - OIS HENNART
The typical configuration of most MNEs is quite different. Most affiliates of MNEs are wholly owned: 57% of all US foreign affiliates were wholly owned in 1975, with only 18% minority owned (Vernon, 1977, p. 34). Most MNEs manufacture abroad what they manufacture at home: in 1966, 83% of the sales of the foreign affiliates of US firms were in the same Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) classification (roughly equivalent to a 3-digit Standard Industrial Classification industry) as that of their parents. Likewise, 80% of the US affiliates of Japanese firms were manufacturing in the United States the same product as was manufactured by their parent in Japan (Hennart & Park, 1993). Lastly, the geographical dispersion of MNE assets does not seem to reflect a desire to reduce risk. Hennart (1982) compared the 1966 geographical pattern of US investments abroad with that which would be predicted if investments were located so as to maximize returns and minimize risk, i.e. the optimal country portfolio for US investors calculated by Levy and Sarnat (1970) for the 1951–1967 period. The two patterns were drastically different. In fact, almost half the assets of US MNEs were then held in Canada and Europe, countries with business cycles highly correlated with that of the US. To sum up, MNEs do not seem to be primarily designed to reduce risk, and hence their risk-reduction potential must be limited compared to what can be achieved on stock exchanges. This appears clearly from a study by Jacquillat and Solnik (1978), who compared the reduction of risk achieved by US investors buying a portfolio of securities to that of buying stock in US-based MNEs. Buying shares of US MNEs reduced risk by 10% over a portfolio of US domestic securities, whereas an international diversified portfolio of stocks reduced risk by 50–70%. It is therefore not surprising that the evidence on the impact of a firm’s multinationality on its risk profile is mixed, with Rugman (1979, Chapter 3) finding that a firm’s ratio of foreign to domestic sales lowers the variability of its rate of return on equity capital, while Reeb, Kwok, and Baek (1998) find that it increases a firm’s systematic risk. To conclude, if an MNE‘s geographical dispersion brings some risk reduction benefits, we would expect them to be modest.
The Resource Access Argument The second argument put forth by Kim et al. as to why firms should obtain higher returns at lower risk as they spread their operations in a wider circle
Internalization Theory and the International Diversification
81
of countries is that this allows them to access cheaper resources. They argue that ‘‘global market diversification allows firms to gain cost advantages by configuring their value added chain in such a way that each link is located in the country which has the least cost for that link (Kogut, 1985a)’’ and further that ‘‘the multiplicity of national markets allows firms to minimize the effect of adverse changes in a country’s interest rates, wage rates, and commodity and raw material prices by providing the added option to more readily shift production and sourcing sites to other more favorable national markets (Kogut, 1983, 1985b; Porter, 1986).’’ Does having affiliates evenly dispersed across global market areas (Kim et al.’s measure of geographical dispersion) actually increase the ability of MNEs to access cheaper resources? Firms can access cheap inputs by buying products incorporating these inputs on the international product market. For the argument to be persuasive, one must be able to show that the only, or the most efficient way, of obtaining cheap or idiosyncratic resources is to own them through wholly or partly owned affiliates. For example, one must show that the most efficient way to take advantage of China‘s cheap labor costs is to have manufacturing operations there. Clearly a firm can take advantage of China’s cheap labor costs by buying Chinese parts or intermediate products through supply contracts. Toy manufacturers have been doing this for years. Which is the most profitable sourcing method depends on the costs of organizing interactions within MNEs (internalizing them) as opposed to through the market. Hence, absent some convincing argument that internalization is always preferable to market transactions, a firm with subsidiaries in a large number of countries (i.e. more geographically diversified) may not have any advantages, and indeed, as we will argue below, may have disadvantages, over a less geographically diversified one. As to the similar argument that an MNE, which is operating in a large number of countries is more able than the one present in only few countries to minimize the adverse effects of changes in the country’s environment by shifting production or sourcing to more favorable markets or sources of supply, again the argument seems to hinge on the assumption that the only way a firm can shift production or shift procurement is to an affiliate; but firms can also use the market, so the issue of whether a firm with more dispersed affiliates is more flexible than one with less dispersed affiliates depends on whether MNEs can shift production faster within their existing network of affiliates than a firm without foreign affiliates using an equivalent network of arm’s length agreements. There are arguments in both directions. On one hand, we would expect the greater difficulty of estimating the costs of internal supply than those of
82
JEAN-FRANC - OIS HENNART
external purchases, which are likely to be put to bids periodically, to make it more difficult for managers to know when prices have changed, and to adjust in consequence. Certainly this has been the case in the US automobile industry, which did not know that the prices of the parts they sourced internally were out of line until this was made obvious by Japanese competition (Keller, 1989). Williamson (1985, pp. 150–151) argues that internal sourcing is less flexible than market sourcing because internal sourcing decisions are more influenced by due process than market ones. On the other hand, Rangan (2000) argues that the efficient global location of production requires good information on where to locate production (search costs) and whom to trust with it (deliberation costs). MNEs may have an advantage over firms with no preexisting foreign activities because their preexisting network of affiliates may reduce the costs of gathering information on relative prices and reliable producers. Hence, they might be able to make quicker and larger adaptations to changes in the environment. Rangan compared total US imports from nine countries in four industries to the intra-firm imports by US MNEs for the same industry and country. He found that MNE imports reacted more strongly to changes in exchange rates than overall US imports, suggesting that US MNEs can use their network of affiliates to more quickly adjust to environmental changes than the average US firm. However, this is not the whole story. Rangan’s test is in terms of marginal, not total costs. In other words, it presupposes a preexisting MNE network of affiliates in the right places. Assume that unit labor costs converge between India and the United States, but continue to diverge between China and the United States. An MNE will capture the advantages of a faster transfer of production from the United States to China through its internal network only if it has a preexisting affiliate there. Having operations in India does not help. If the MNE does not have operations in China, then setting them up there is likely to take more time and money than contracting with an independent Chinese firm. Given the difficulty of forecasting trends in production costs and trade barriers, it is very difficult for an MNE to know in which countries it should pre-position subsidiaries.1 Using the market involves lower fixed costs and may be more efficient if the environment is subject to rapid and unpredictable changes. Hence once we take into account the fixed costs of setting up operations in many countries, only a subset of which will turn out to be useful locations, it is unclear whether an MNE has a clear advantage over arm’s length transactions. Once again, flexibility seems to be a rather marginal by-product of the real reasons that lead to MNE expansion.
Internalization Theory and the International Diversification
83
The Economies of Scale Argument The third argument of Kim et al. as to why an MNE‘s geographical dispersion of operations would lead to superior performance is that ‘‘global market diversification offers possibilities for exploitation of economies of scale and scope above and beyond the potential of product diversification.’’ It is obvious, however, that exploiting economies of scale and scope does not necessarily require foreign expansion, let alone foreign market diversification. Inversely, a firm can have a high ratio of foreign to domestic sales for reasons that have nothing to do with scale economies. Let us start with this last point before considering economies of scale and their exploitation. There are two main strategies that explain foreign sales, arbitrage and aggregation (Ghemawat, 1993). Arbitrage takes advantage of comparative or absolute advantages. It is made possible by the unequal geographic dispersion of unique factors or by differences in their comparative abundance. These differences lead to exports. While some exports result from the exploitation of scale economies (see below), a substantial part is based on comparative or absolute advantage, and has nothing to do with scale economies or any of the arguments used by Kim et al. and by other scholars who have studied the multinationality/performance relationship. Note, however, that whenever exports based on absolute or comparative advantage are sold abroad by sales affiliates (as opposed to by independent agents), these exports enter the ‘‘foreign sales’’ numerator and denominator of the ‘‘foreign sales/total sales’’ ratio used as a measure of multinationality.2 Aggregation takes advantage of economies of scale at the plant and firm level. Plant scale economies lead to sales to foreign market through exports whenever the Minimum Efficient Scale (MES) of production of the plant is for a level of output that is larger than that which can be absorbed in the country where the plant is located. Given low transport costs, trade barriers, and the absence of adverse government regulations, the firm will exploit these scale economies through exports. Note again that some measures of multinationality may take these exports into account if they are handled by the MNE‘s sales affiliates, while others do not. For example, a multinationality measure that is based on foreign sales will count these exports more heavily than one based on foreign assets. Firm-level scale economies arise because R&D programs and brand building are often characterized by high fixed and low variable costs. When the MES of producing these intangibles is greater than the size of the domestic market for the products incorporating the intangibles, the firm will seek to amortize its fixed costs by exploiting its knowledge beyond its home base.
84
JEAN-FRANC - OIS HENNART
There are many options. First, the MNE can export products incorporating its intangibles. If these exports are handled by the MNE’s sales affiliates, they will increase some of the measures of multinationality used in the literature, such as its ratio of foreign to total sales. Second, the MNE can rent its intangibles to foreign producers. I do not know of any measure of multinationality used in the literature that actually picks up the sales that result from this option. Lastly, the firm can exploit its intangibles by setting up operations abroad that produce products and services that incorporate these intangibles. Selling and manufacturing abroad almost always involves some adaptation of the marketing mix (product, price, promotion, and distribution) to local conditions. Adaptation tends to reduce some of the gains available from the exploitation of intangibles. Optimum exploitation of intangibles occurs when the firm can sell abroad exactly the same product as at home using exactly the same marketing mix (same packaging, advertising campaigns, etc.). Hence, when it comes to the exploitation of intangibles, the most desirable situation is one where they can be exploited without crossing borders, or if this is not possible, in a way that requires as few adaptations as possible, i.e. in a small number of countries with similar characteristics. Consequently, at a given level of intangibles, firms which can amortize them at home will be more profitable than those that need both domestic and foreign markets to do so. And among the latter, those which have to operate in a large number of disparate markets are in the worst position. From this line of reasoning, one would predict exactly the opposite relationship than that postulated by Kim et al.: at a given level of intangible investments, the greater the ratio of foreign to domestic sales, the worse the performance. Note also that the conditions under which economies of scale are optimally exploited (little foreign presence, or if so in homogeneous countries) are exactly the converse of those that lead to global learning (exposure to varied stimuli through operations in a heterogeneous group of countries).
INTERNATIONAL EXPANSION AND PERFORMANCE As argued before, the literature on the impact of multinationality on performance has addressed two issues: (1) does international diversification lead to better performance? and (2) does international expansion (i.e. the share of foreign sales over total sales) also lead to higher profits? We have seen that the arguments as to why geographical diversification should
Internalization Theory and the International Diversification
85
improve performance are less than persuasive. Let us now turn to the reasons given why firms which have a higher ratio of foreign to total sales (or a higher ratio of foreign to total assets or of foreign to total employment) should enjoy higher profitability.
The Economies of Scale Argument The main argument why having a relatively higher ratio of foreign to domestic sales should lead to superior profitability is that foreign sales allow the firm to spread its fixed costs. Contractor et al. (2003), for example, argue that ‘‘advantages of international expansion accrue by spreading common and central overheads over more and more nations: this is especially critical in R&D-intensive industries that require amortization of R&D from more than a few markets.’’ As we have seen above, amortizing a given level of R&D requires a particular market size. But if this market size can be had by selling to domestic customers, then the firm can avoid the additional costs of having to adapt the product to one or many foreign markets. Everything else constant, the less the firm needs to sell to foreign customers to amortize its R&D investment (e.g. the lower the ratio of its foreign to total sales), the more profitable it should be, in contradiction to the argument made by Contractor et al. (2003) and others.
The Resource Access/Learning/Competition Arguments Other arguments as to why a high ratio of foreign to local sales should improve performance parallel those used to support the international diversification/performance relationship. Contractor et al. (2003), for example, argue that ‘‘international expansion provides access to cheaper and idiosyncratic resources in foreign countries,’’ that ‘‘international expansion provide greater learning or international experience,’’ and that it provides ‘‘better cross-subsidization, price discrimination, and arbitrage potential with larger geographic scope.’’ The resource access argument is based on the fact that MNEs with a dispersed network of affiliates may be able to switch production faster than a firm relying on market contracts. We have seen earlier the limits of such an argument. Whatever its strength, the hypothesized relationship relates geographical diversification to performance, not the relative share of foreign operations to performance. Since Contractor et al.’s measure of multinationality is the ratio
86
JEAN-FRANC - OIS HENNART
of domestic to foreign operations, the argument has less power than those used by Kim et al. while remaining subject to the same criticisms.
INTERNALIZATION THEORY TO THE RESCUE It stands to reason that the proper basis for an investigation of how the size or the geographic dispersion of an MNE‘s foreign operations affects its profitability is a clear understanding of why firms operate abroad. The remaining part of this chapter will show that the internalization theory of the MNE (Buckley & Casson, 1976; Rugman, 1981; Hennart, 1982) can throw considerable light on this issue. Internalization theory is a theory of the size and scope of firms. It argues that interdependencies between economic agents can be organized through the price system or through hierarchy (through employment contracts). MNEs arise whenever interdependencies between agents located in different countries are more efficiently organized through hierarchical processes than on a market through spot prices or contracts. There are many types of interdependencies which are typically more efficiently organized within an MNE than on a market, and which provide motives for MNEs to expand abroad (Hennart, 1982, 2001). MNEs internalize some markets for raw materials and marketing services (backward and forward integration), capital, and intangibles (knowledge and reputation). Whenever they do this, they replace potential or actual independent agents by their employees. Hence the foreign operations of MNEs (and hence their foreign sales and assets) are a mix of extractive, marketing, and manufacturing and service operations set up to exploit or to acquire raw materials, marketing services, and intangibles. Some intangibles, such as tacit knowledge, which are costly to transact on markets, will be transferred within MNEs because such transfer will earn higher rents than exchange through the market: MNEs will set up abroad affiliates to sell products or services that incorporate their knowledge and/or reputation, and/or they will acquire foreign firms so as to access the brand names and knowledge that is embedded in these firms. International operations which are not justified by these considerations will incur the higher costs of operating in a foreign country without the corresponding advantages of internalization, and hence should make net losses. As we have just seen, internalization (i.e. coordination through employment contracts) is only one of the many possible ways to organize the purchase of inputs, the sale of outputs, or the exploitation or acquisition of
Internalization Theory and the International Diversification
87
knowledge and goodwill. An alternative is the market (market sales or contracts). Hence firms can choose between purchasing foreign inputs through contracts or setting up subsidiaries, between selling their output through independent agents and distributors or through their own sales force, and between exploiting intangibles by renting them on the market through licensing or franchising or by setting up foreign operations that sell products or services that incorporate their knowledge and goodwill. This has a number of implications for the study of the relationship between multinationality and performance. First, the theory explains why MNEs are relatively poor vehicles for risk reduction. Second, it explains the connection between intangibles and foreign expansion. Third, it throws light on the relationship between multinationality and performance.
Multinationality and Risk Reduction For internalization theory, international expansion is the replacement of market by hierarchical coordination. Hierarchical coordination is based on central direction and behavior constraints (Hennart, 1982). In firms bosses tell employees what to do and constrain their behavior. This is more costly when the target market is both geographically and culturally distant because geographical distance increases the cost of observing behavior and cultural distance that of obtaining the information necessary to direct the behavior of employees (Hennart, 1991). Hence, the well-noted preference of MNEs for investing in geographically and culturally close countries (Davidson, 1980; Rugman, 2000). Since countries which are geographically close and culturally similar to the MNE’s home country are often also economically integrated with it,3 a substantial share of a firm’s foreign investments will be in countries whose business cycle is closely linked with that of its home country, thus reducing geographic diversification benefits. Second, because both knowledge and reputation are to a large extent industry specific, MNEs end up producing abroad the same products and services they produce at home (most exceptions being cases of backward and forward vertical integration). Hence MNEs provide little product diversification benefits. Third, since managerial control is obtained by equity ownership, and the raison d’etre of MNEs is to replace prices by managerial control, it is not surprising that most affiliates are majority or wholly owned by their parents. This means that MNEs will not spread their investments into a large number of small stakes, thus reducing the diversification benefits they can offer.
88
JEAN-FRANC - OIS HENNART
To sum up, internalization theory shows that risk reduction can only be a weak side effect of the foreign expansion of firms. MNEs did not arise to provide diversification, and they are not particularly good at risk reduction.
Investment in Intangibles and Foreign Operations We have seen that MNEs operate abroad to obtain access to raw materials and parts and to knowledge and brand names, and to exploit abroad their own knowledge and reputation. This suggests that foreign expansion that is not motivated by internalization should have negative profitability consequences. To the extent that intangible-exploiting affiliates dominate the mix of foreign affiliates, and that MNEs exploit their intangibles through foreign direct investment, we would expect a noisy statistical relationship between a firm’s investment in intangibles (as measured by its R&D and advertising intensities) and the extent or spread of their foreign operations. The relationship will be noisy because (1) intangibles can be exploited through other means than foreign manufacturing and/or service operations, namely through exports and contracts (e.g. licensing and franchising), (2) foreign operations are also established for other reasons than the internalization of intangibles, e.g. to vertically integrate backward or forward and to internalize capital flows (Hennart, 2000), and (3) R&D and advertising expenditures are input measures, which do not necessarily correspond to the outputs that are being internalized. Nevertheless, R&D intensity has been found to be a statistically significant determinant, ceteris paribus, of the ratio of net foreign sales to domestic sales for Swedish firms (Swedenborg, 1979, Table 5.7) and of the probability that a firm will manufacture in the United States a product it manufactures in Japan (Hennart & Park, 1994). Similarly, Morck and Yeung (1991) found that the market value of a firm’s intangibles (its Tobin’s q) was positively associated with its R&D and advertising intensities (and more weakly with the cross-product of its R&D and advertising intensities and the number of foreign countries in which it was operating), but not with the number of foreign countries in which the firm was operating. This suggests that multinationality has no significant value to firms which do not invest in R&D or advertising. Since Tobin’s q is the ratio of the market value of the firm to its fixed assets (i.e. the part of the stock market value that is due to intangibles), this finding casts doubt on the contribution of geographical diversification per se to a firm’s profitability. Specifically, contrary to the global learning hypothesis, a firm’s stock of knowledge does not seem to benefit from geographical diversification unless
Internalization Theory and the International Diversification
89
the firm is also investing in intangibles. Note, however, that existence of a relationship between multinationality and investment in intangibles does not imply one between multinationality and performance. Multinationality and Profitability Internalization theory also throws light on the possible relationship between the relative size and dispersion of international operations and profitability. MNEs expand abroad when they have to. Their foreign network will survive as long as the rents obtained by organizing internal transactions are at least as high as those obtained by organizing transactions on the market. For example, an MNE will use its affiliate in a given country to source transactions as long as the alternative of using independent suppliers is less profitable. While it may take some time for MNEs to compare the rents that can be obtained by internal and external links and to adjust accordingly, we would expect MNEs to ultimately decide at the margin whether each of their specific affiliate brings them net rents. For example, whether an MNE will keep or get rid of a specific affiliate will hinge on whether the inputs it supplies can be more cheaply bought on the market; whether it makes more sense to franchise local producers than to operate company-owned outlets; or whether knowledge is more efficiently exploited through licensing foreign producers than through investment in manufacturing plants abroad. The configuration of MNE affiliates abroad is thus likely to be in constant flux, with MNEs adding and closing affiliates in specific countries and industries (Boddewyn, 1983). At the margin, the profitability of internalizing the transaction and that of externalizing it should be the same, the only exception being cases where the MNE has failed to make the right decision and is either internalizing a transaction that should be externalized or doing the reverse (Chiles & McMackin, 1996; Brouthers, Brouthers, & Werner, 2003). Aggregating over all transactions, it is hard to see why, keeping everything else constant, the proportion of a firm’s foreign sales to total sales, or the dispersion of its sales abroad, should have any impact on its profitability. The only profitability differences one should observe are those between firms which have the right, and those which have the wrong degree of internalization, either because they are making mistakes, or because they have not yet fully adapted to new conditions. Since it is difficult to assess the appropriateness of MNE decisions and to identify the misfits from Compustat data, it is unlikely that differences in MNE performance can be satisfactorily investigated within the present framework of the multinationality/performance literature.
90
JEAN-FRANC - OIS HENNART
In spite of my predictions, a number of studies report a positive correlation between a firm’s return on assets on one hand, and its share of foreign to total sales (and/or some index of the geographical dispersion of operations) on the other (e.g. Geringer, Tallman, & Olsen, 2000; Contractor et al., 2003; Gomes & Ramaswamy, 1999). How can this be explained? It is difficult to guess what factors may account for these results, but, at least when performance is measured as return on assets, there would seem to be a simple explanation. Accounting rules do not treat expenditures incurred in building intangibles as assets. Hence firms which invest large amounts in R&D and in building up brand names have undervalued assets, in the sense that the assets they report in their balance sheet are systematically lower than their ‘‘real’’ assets. Because they have undervalued assets, their return on assets should be higher, ceteris paribus, than firms which invest less on intangibles (and hence whose assets are less undervalued). Since the firms which invest a lot in intangibles are also those with operations abroad, measuring performance by a firm’s ROA leads to a spurious correlation between multinationality and performance.
CONCLUSIONS An important and apparently growing strain of research in international business tries to establish a statistical relationship between a firm’s relative importance and spread of international operations (its multinationality) and its performance. After nearly 40 empirical studies, we are no closer to understanding this relationship, in part because of a lack of a clear consensus on how to measure the ‘‘multinationality’’ concept. This lack of consensus arises from a lack of solid theoretical grounding. In this chapter, I critically examine some of the theoretical arguments used in this literature to support the existence of a theoretical link between multinationality and performance. The discussion is split in two parts: (1) why should a firm’s geographical dispersion of its foreign operations lead to higher performance and (2) why should a firm’s relative size of foreign operations lead to superior performance. Five main reasons have been given why firms which have geographically spread foreign operations should perform better. I examine three of them. The first reason is that MNEs are better able to diversify risk. I show that the empirical evidence suggests that the diversification benefits of MNEs should be modest. Another reason advanced why MNEs with dispersed foreign operations should be more profitable is that they are able to minimize the impact
Internalization Theory and the International Diversification
91
of changes in the environment because of their superior ability to shift production between markets. My point is that, when the fixed cost of setting up a network of foreign affiliates is taken into account, the benefits of intra-firm trade vs. market transactions are not that obvious. A third reason why firms with diversified foreign operations should be more profitable is that such firms can better amortize the fixed costs of generating intangibles. However, at a given level of intangible investments, it is clear that the reverse is true: firms which can exploit them without having to go abroad will in fact be more profitable. The same arguments can be made a fortiori when the dependent variable is the share of foreign over total operations. If one agrees with me that the theoretical arguments made in the literature leave much to be desired, then what theoretical framework should we use to understand the relationship between multinationality and performance? The last part of the paper reviews internalization theory. This theory shows that the size and scope of an MNE‘s foreign operations results from a comparison of the rents that can be derived from organizing interactions within an MNE network as opposed to on the market. At the margin, the rents derived from internal coordination should be exactly the same as those that accrue from effecting the transaction on the market. Hence, absent mistakes, and keeping everything else constant, there should be no performance differences between an MNE with operations in 50 countries and a firm with no operations abroad at all, or between a Swiss-based MNE with 95% of its sales abroad and a US firm with 2%. In each case, unless we believe that firms commit systematic errors and fail to correct for them for long periods of time, the size and scope of a firm’s international operations should be the ones that maximize its profits. This suggests that any observed profitability differences between firms with different degrees of multinationality are likely to be due to measurement biases or to omitted variables. Since the usual databases used in this literature do not provide the detailed data necessary for controlling for all the variables that may affect profitability, this suggest looking at more micro data, such as detailed comparisons of firms in the same industry.
NOTES 1. The optimal location of production changes in often unpredictable ways. Japan was a highly profitable production location for aluminum in the 1960s, but the 1973 oil crisis put quickly an end to that. Similarly, the expiration of the Multifiber
92
JEAN-FRANC - OIS HENNART
agreement is casting doubt on the long-term viability of textile production in Cambodia and Vietnam, where production was located to get around US quotas on Chinese imports. 2. This can be deduced from the description in Tallman and Li (1996). 3. For example, Canada and the United States, or the Netherlands and Germany.
REFERENCES Boddewyn, J. (1983). Foreign and domestic divestment and investment decision: Like or unlike? Journal of International Business Studies, 14, 23–35. Brouthers, K., Brouthers, L., & Werner, S. (2003). Transaction cost-enhanced entry mode choices and firm performance. Strategic Management Journal, 24, 1239–1248. Buckley, P., & Casson, M. (1976). The Future of Multinational Enterprise. London: Macmillan. Chiles, T., & McMackin, J.-F. (1996). Integrating variable risk preferences, trust, and transaction cost economics. Academy of Management Review, 21(1), 73–99. Contractor, F., Kundu, S., & Hsu, C. C. (2003). A three-stage theory of international expansion: The link between multinationality and performance in the service sector. Journal of International Business Studies, 34, 5–18. Davidson, W. H. (1980). The location of foreign direct investment activity: Country characteristics and experience effects. Journal of International Business Studies, 11, 9–22. Geringer, J., Tallman, S., & Olsen, D. (2000). Product and international diversification among Japanese multinational firms. Strategic Management Journal, 21, 51–80. Ghemawat, P. (1993). The forgotten strategy. Harvard Business Review(November), 77–84. Gomes, L., & Ramaswamy, K. (1999). An empirical examination of the form of relationship between multinationality and performance. Journal of International Business Studies, 30, 173–188. Grant, R., Jammine, A., & Thomas, H. (1988). Diversity, diversification and profitability among British manufacturing companies. Academy of Management Journal, 31, 771–801. Hamel, G., & Prahalad, C. K. (1985). Do you really have a global strategy? Harvard Business Review(July/August), 139–148. Hennart, J.-F. (1982). A theory of multinational enterprise. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press. Hennart, J.-F. (1991). Control in multinational firms: The role of price and hierarchy. Management International Review, 31(special issue), 71–96. Hennart, J.-F. (2000). Transaction costs theory and the multinational enterprise. In: C. Pitclis, & R. Sugden (Eds.), The Nature of the Transnational Firm, (2nd ed.). London: Routledge. Hennart, J.-F. (2001). Theories of the multinational enterprise. In: A. Rugman & T. Brewer (Eds), The Oxford handbook of international business (pp. 127–149). Oxford: Oxford University Press. Hennart, J.-F., & Park, Y. R. (1993). Greenfield vs. acquisition: The strategy of Japanese investors in the United States. Management Science, 39(9), 1054–1070. Hennart, J.-F., & Park, Y. R. (1994). Location,governance and strategic determinants of Japanese manufacturing investment in the United States. Strategic Management Journal, 15, 419–436.
Internalization Theory and the International Diversification
93
Jacquillat, B., & Solnik, B. (1978). Multinationals are poor tools for diversification. Journal of Portfolio Management, 4, 8–12. Keller, M. (1989). Rude awakening. New York: Morrow. Kim, W. C., Hwang, P., & Burgers, W. (1993). Multinationals’ diversification and the riskreturn trade-off. Strategic Management Journal, 14, 275–286. Kim, W. C., & Mauborgne, R. (1988). Becoming an effective global competitor. Journal of Business Strategy, 9(January/February), 33–37. Kogut, B. (1983). Foreign direct investment as a sequential process. In: C. Kindleberger & D. Audretsch (Eds), The multinational corporation in the 1980s (pp. 38–56). Cambridge: MIT Press. Kogut, B. (1985a). Designing global strategies: Comparative and competitive value-added chains. Sloan Management Review, 26(Summer), 27–38. Kogut, B. (1985b). Designing global strategies: Profiting from operational flexibility. Sloan Management Review, 26(Fall), 27–38. Kotabe, M., Srinavasan, S., & Aulakh, P. (2002). Multinationality and firm performance: The moderating role of R&D and marketing capabilities. Journal of International Business Studies, 33(1), 79–97. Levy, H., & Sarnat, M. (1970). International diversification of investment portfolios. American Economic Review, 60, 668–675. Markowitz, H. (1959). Portfolio selection: Efficient diversification of investments. New York: Wiley. Michel, A., & Shaked, I. (1986). Multinational corporations vs. domestic corporations: Financial performance and characteristics. Journal of International Business Studies, 17(3), 89–101. Morck, R., & Yeung, B. (1991). Why investors value multinationality. Journal of Business, 64(2), 165–187. Porter, M. (1986). Competition in global industries: A conceptual framework. In: M. Porter (Ed.), Competition in global industries (pp. 15–60). Boston: Harvard Business School Press. Rangan, S. (2000). Search and deliberation in international exchange: Microfoundations to some macro patterns. Journal of International Business Studies, 31, 205–222. Reeb, D., Kwok, C., & Baek, H. Y. (1998). Systematic risk of the multinational corporation. Journal of International Business Studies, 29, 263–279. Rugman, A. (1979). International diversification and the multinational enterprise. Lexington: Lexington Books. Rugman, A. (1981). Inside the multinationals. New York: Columbia University Press. Rugman, A. (2000). The end of globalization. London: Random House. Swedenborg, B. (1979). The multinational operations of Swedish firms. Stockholm: Almqvist and Wiksell. Tallman, S., & Li, J. (1996). Effects of international diversity and product diversity on the performance of multinational firms. Academy of Management Journal, 39, 179–196. Vernon, R. (1977). Storm over the multinationals. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. Williamson, O. (1985). The economic institutions of capitalism. New York: Free Press.
This page intentionally left blank
94
PART C: EXTENDING ALAN RUGMAN’S WORK ON REGIONAL STRATEGIES AND THE ENVIRONMENT
95
This page intentionally left blank
96
REGIONAL STRATEGY AND PERFORMANCE IN THE GLOBAL AUTOMOTIVE INDUSTRY Alain Verbeke and Paul Brugman In this paper, we address regional strategy and performance in the global automotive industry. We briefly review two strands of literature that explain the limited geographical dispersion of multinational activity across industries. We then confront these theories with an original dataset from the automotive industry. After analysing this sample, we predict that competitive pressures will force firms in the automotive industry to increase further the size and scope of their foreign operations. The presence of firm-specific advantages explains the performance differences observed among the firms.
INTRODUCTION Twenty years ago, Kenichi Ohmae (1985) published Triad Power, a pathbreaking book, which has become a classic in the international business literature. Ohmae concluded that the world was far from global, but rather regionally organised, with the United States, Europe and Japan as the ‘triad powers’, dominating world trade and investment. Extending this line of thought, Rugman demonstrated that the vast majority of trade is intraregional (meaning it takes place within either North America, the European Internalization, International Diversification and the Multinational Enterprise: Essays in Honor of Alan M. Rugman Research in Global Strategic Management, Volume 11, 97–117 Copyright r 2005 by Elsevier Ltd. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved ISSN: 1064-4857/doi:10.1016/S1064-4857(05)11007-9
97
98
ALAIN VERBEKE AND PAUL BRUGMAN
Union or Asia), rather than inter-regional (Rugman, 2000, 2005). The following statement on the automotive industry is illustrative: y more than 85% of all the automobiles produced in North America are built in North American factories owned by Japanese and European MNEs as well as by General Motors, Ford and Daimler-Chrysler. In Europe the story is the same, as it is in Japan. (Rugman, 2000, p. 2)
Rugman concluded in his 2000 book, The End of Globalization, that there is no global automotive firm, and his 2005 follow-up book, The Regional Multinationals, confirms this result. Rugman suggests in his 2000 book that most large multinational enterprises (MNEs), and not only automotive firms, sell the vast majority of their products in the same region as they are produced. Because of this absence of inter-regional activity, Rugman advises managers to adopt a regional, rather than a global view of operations. In addition, the 2005 book demonstrates that no single automotive firm has a balanced spread of its sales across the triad (with less than 50% of sales in the home region, and at least 20% in each of the two other triad regions), meaning that automotive firms are systematically more successful in one region than in the other ones. However insightful, Rugman (2005) leaves some issues open to refinement. These issues are the content of the regional sales distribution in the automotive industry, and the linkage with firm performance. For example, Rugman’s regional distribution of sales is based on total automotive sales. This means that no distinction is made between firms that also sell trucks and busses (i.e. commercial vehicles), and those that do not. Although Rugman’s main findings are corroborated, correcting for this difference yields less outspoken results with respect to sales concentration.1 The fact that these results are less outspoken is important, as it lends support to our hypothesis that in the future, automotive firms are likely to become more global, a hypothesis that is in sharp contrast with Rugman’s predictions.2 A second issue that requires closer scrutiny than provided by Rugman is that of performance. In Rugman (2005), a firm’s total revenues and/or sales are given. However, total revenues and/or sales are not good indicators of financial performance. Therefore, making use of our own dataset, we calculate operating income per car, to provide a credible proxy of financial performance. The results we obtain add further support to our expectation of an increase in the geographic spread of MNEs. The remainder of this paper is organised as follows: in the second section, we analyse the reasons for the observed narrow geographic spread of multinational activity. We do this by making use of both a transaction cost
Regional Strategy and Performance
99
economics (TCE) approach and the latest insights from the multinationality-performance (M-P) literature. In the third section, we present and analyse the dataset, and confront the results with the theory. In the fourth section, we discuss the issue of competitive pressures and explain how these affect geographical dispersion.
TRANSACTION COST ECONOMICS Rugman and Verbeke (2004a, b) have established that only 9 of the 500 largest MNEs in the world are truly global while the vast majority of MNEs are regional. A firm is considered global when it has at least 20% of total sales in each of the triad regions: North America, the European Union and Asia and less than 50% in the home region. TCE helps to explain this relative absence of global firms. Any firm that sells abroad is considered to possess a bundle of firmspecific advantages (FSAs) that it can successfully exploit.3 Foreign sales can be realised through various options such as exports and foreign direct investment (FDI). The latter occurs in the presence of internalisation advantages, i.e. benefits of hierarchy vis-a`-vis the market. In such a case, a location needs to be found to serve as production or distribution point. Given that locations are non-homogenous, there will be at least one location with country-specific advantages (CSAs).4 However, a firm cannot just establish production or distribution operations in a foreign country and expect to make a profit. Rather, investments must be made to overcome the liabilities of newness (Stinchcombe, 1965) and foreignness (Hymer, 1976). The former concept implies that a foreign subsidiary is essentially a new firm and is therefore confronted with a variety of start-up issues such as finding good personnel and establishing local relations. The second concept implies that what may work in one location does not necessarily work in another. In other words, the MNE will need to adapt some of its products and practices to local conditions in order to be successful. The required adaptation investments are ‘melding investments’ as they meld the firm’s existing knowledge base with the local environment. However, as Ronen & Shenkar (1985) have shown in their work, we can distinguish among nine different country clusters, each representing a specific geographic region of the world.5 In this context, as the distance between the country of origin and the country of destination increases, in terms of cultural, administrative, economic and cultural differences (Ghemawat, 2001),
100
ALAIN VERBEKE AND PAUL BRUGMAN
the required melding investments will also increase. In the spirit of Fujita, Krugman, and Venables (1999), we will represent the above distance components through a single variable t. If t increases, melding investments need to increase as well for the MNE to be successful. Importantly, the size of these melding investments is not equal across value-chain activities. Downstream activities such as marketing and distribution typically require more local knowledge and embeddedness than upstream activities due to the one-sided nature of the investments intended to increase sales in host regions. In contrast, upstream activities such as R&D, component sourcing and production involve the MNE as a purchaser and combiner of inputs rather than a seller of outputs. In this context, not all types of FDI entail the same risk. Specifically, market-seeking FDI is more risky than strategic asset-seeking FDI or resource-seeking FDI. The reason is that in the former case, a firm makes a one-sided investment to try and service a local market. In the latter two cases however, several partners, both foreign and local ones, tend to engage in simultaneous commitments, which make the investments worthwhile for all parties involved (Rugman & Verbeke, 2005). In other words, there are substantial costs and risks associated with investing abroad, especially for market-seeking FDI in another region, and these act as an entry barrier. It follows immediately that a firm will remain within its ‘home region’ as long as the expected benefits of expanding intraregionally (¼ EBintra ) are equal or larger than the expected benefits of expanding inter-regionally (¼ EBinter ) when corrected for the melding investment alpha (a). In simple formulae,6 if EBintra X½EBinter a-expand intra-regionally if EBintra p½EBinter a-expand inter-regionally and if t "! a " if t #! a # Thus, if t "! P [expand intra-regionally] m and ! P [expand inter-regionally] k if t #! P [expand intra-regionally] k and ! P [expand inter-regionally] m We can also represent this trade-off with graphs. On the vertical axis, we visualise the expected benefit of an investment at location 1, while on the vertical axis we show the expected benefit of an investment at location 2.
Regional Strategy and Performance
101
A, B and C each represent investment opportunities that can be undertaken in either location. However, the site of the investment will have an impact on its performance. Project A is expected to yield 28 if undertaken at location 1, while it would yield 8 when undertaken at location 2. Project B will yield 32 at either location, while project C leads to locational outcomes that are the opposite of those for project A. Graph 1 shows a hypothetical situation in which no melding investments are required, i.e. we assume that t and a are zero; the two regions are homogenous. The firm can be expected to choose investment opportunity B since it has a higher expected benefit than either A or C. The site of this investment is of no importance, since the expected benefit in either location is identical. This situation is more likely to occur when choosing between sites in the same nation, rather than in an international setting. Graph 2 introduces melding investments (a), associated with investing in location 2. Because of these, an investment in location 2 must now have a higher expected benefit before it is undertaken. This means that B will now decisively be undertaken in location 1. However, since C is still expected to yield a higher benefit in location 2 than in location 1, the firm will likely also consider this international investment. Finally, Graph 3 represents the issue of investments in a ‘high distance’ host region (in this case region 2), vis-a`-vis a more ‘low distance’ region
Expected Benefit Location 1
40
B
30
A 20
10
C 0
0
10
20
30
40
Expected Benefit Location 2
Graph 1.
Hypothetical Situation of Zero Melding Investments.
102
ALAIN VERBEKE AND PAUL BRUGMAN
Expected Benefit Location 1
40
B
30
A 20
α 10
0
C
-10
0 10 20 Expected Benefit Location 2
30
Graph 2. Inter-Regional Melding Investment.
Expected Benefit Home Region
40
B
30
A 20
α 10
C 0 -30
-20
-10
0
10
Expected Benefit Host Region
Graph 3. Inter-Regional Melding Investment.
Regional Strategy and Performance
103
(typically the home region, in this case region 1). The required melding investments (a) are much higher in the distant host region. Clearly, even project C is no longer undertaken, as the costs outweigh the benefits. A firm will choose to expand within its home region unless a spectacular opportunity is found. To summarise, downstream activities of MNEs typically face higher melding investments than upstream activities. Thus, barriers to invest abroad (especially outside the home region) are higher for those firms. In addition, especially if downstream activities are contemplated outside the home region, the likelihood of success is low, given the one-sidedness of contracts. This situation is exemplified by the unsuccessful attempt of Renault to enter the US market, or the exit of supermarket chain Albert Heijn from South America. The managerial implication is clear: firms should be very selective when choosing their geographical spread of activities, and typically abstain from a truly global roll out. In addition, market-seeking firms should either stay in their home region or expand in regions with a low distance from the home region.
MULTINATIONALITY AND PERFORMANCE In addition to the TCE-based rationale for a narrow geographic focus, especially as regards market-seeking FDI, it is also useful to investigate possible performance differences between firms that are at different stages of their international expansion. For the past 30 years, a large research stream has focused on this topic, commonly known as the literature on the M-P relationship. Despite (or perhaps because of) 30 years of research on this topic, the empirical results of this research have been ambiguous, and many results are contradictory, ranging from linear and negative to cubed and positive relationships.7 In the past few years, the cubed form has been postulated as the ‘‘true’’ form of the relationship. The hypothesis is that as a firm commences with foreign operations the costs are higher than the benefits due to the liability of foreignness and the liability of newness. As a firm learns how to operate in the new environment, the operating costs decline (since fewer mistakes are made) while benefits increase (due to the increased scale and scope of operations) so total performance increases as well. However, as the firm increases its foreign operations, it is argued that a threshold will be reached. That is, there is an ‘optimal firm size’ or a ‘maximum efficient scale’
104
ALAIN VERBEKE AND PAUL BRUGMAN
after which the business gets too complex for management to handle. Once a firm crosses that threshold, performance will decline as the costs of for example monitoring, communication or management outweigh the benefits. This behaviour, when represented graphically leads to a horizontal ‘S’-curve. Recent research however, has suggested that this S-curve is not universal but dependent upon many factors such as firm size, firm nationality and the locus of destination. For example, smaller firms may encounter more difficulties and have fewer benefits when initially entering a foreign market than larger firms (Lu & Beamish, 2001). The reason is that smaller firms have fewer resources to make a foreign venture a success while at the same time they have not yet achieved enough critical mass that would yield substantial economies of scale or scope. Also, firm nationality plays a significant role. For example, MNEs from small nations that share cultural, administrative and economic similarities with a large neighbour in the context of a regional trading block will face reduced costs of newness and