Imagining Sustainable Food Systems Theory and Practice
Edited by Alison Blay-Palmer
Imagining Sustainable Food System...
86 downloads
2822 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems Theory and Practice
Edited by Alison Blay-Palmer
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
To our families, friends and communities of food with thanks
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems Theory and Practice
Edited by Alison Blay-Palmer Wilfrid Laurier University, Canada
© Alison Blay-Palmer 2010 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior permission of the publisher. Alison Blay-Palmer has asserted her right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, to be identified as the editor of this work. Published by Ashgate Publishing Limited Ashgate Publishing Company Wey Court East Suite 420 Union Road 101 Cherry Street Farnham Burlington Surrey, GU9 7PT VT 05401-4405 England USA www.ashgate.com British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Imagining sustainable food systems : theory and practice. 1. Food supply. 2. Nutrition policy. 3. Food industry and trade--Moral and ethical aspects. 4. Sustainable agriculture. 5. Food supply--Case studies. I. Blay-Palmer, Alison, 1961 338.1'9-dc22 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Blay-Palmer, Alison, 1961 Imagining sustainable food systems : theory and practice / by Alison Blay-Palmer. p. cm. Includes index. ISBN 978-0-7546-7816-8 (hardback) -- ISBN 978-0-7546-9609-4 (ebook) 1. Sustainable agriculture. 2. Food supply--International cooperation. 3. Food security. I. Title. S494.5.S86B587 2010 630--dc22 2010015520 ISBN 9780754678168 (hbk) ISBN 9780754696094 (ebk) I
Contents List of Figures
vii
Notes on Contributors
ix
Acknowledgements
xi
Part 1: Interrogating Sustainable Food Systems 1
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems Alison Blay-Palmer
2
Conceptualizing and Creating Sustainable Food Systems: How Interdisciplinarity can Help Clare Hinrichs
3
Sustainability: A Tool for Food System Reform? Mustafa Koc
3
17 37
Part 2: Inclusion and Exclusion in Sustainable Food Systems 4 Greening the Realm: Sustainable Food Chains and the Public Plate 49 Kevin Morgan 5
Thinking About Labour in Alternative Food Systems Yael Levitte
6 The Urban Food Desert: Spatial Inequality or Opportunity for Change? Ellen Desjardins
71
87
PART 3: The Case for Sustainable Food Systems 7 Food Systems Planning and Sustainable Cities and Regions: The Role of the Firm in Sustainable Food Capitalism Betsy Donald
115
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
vi
8 The Nexus between Alternative Food Systems and Entrepreneurism: Three Local Stories Hélène St. Jacques 9 Scaling Up: Bringing Public Institutions and Food Service Corporations into the Project for a Local, Sustainable Food System in Ontario Harriet Friedmann 10
Food Policy Encounters of a Third Kind: How the Toronto Food Policy Council Socializes for Sustain-Ability Wayne Roberts
135
157
173
11 Food Insecurity in the Land of Plenty: The Windermere Valley Paradox Alison Bell
201
12 Imagining Sustainable Food Systems: The Path to Regenerative Food Systems Alison Blay-Palmer and Mustafa Koc
223
Index
247
List of Figures 4.1
Commonly cited barriers to sustainable procurement
63
8.1 ONFC warehouse 8.2 Mapletons’ logo 8.3 Mapleton sales sheet 8.4 Arwa hillside 8.5 Inside the Mapleton’s store 8.6 Wagon ride 8.7 Tractor ride 8.8 Long Point Regional Conservation Authority tour 8.9 Prairie grass 8.10 Bee in a bore hole
138 142 143 144 145 148 149 152 153 154
12.1 Policy, socio-communal, economic and environmental spaces through a Sustainable Food Systems lens
225
This page has been left blank intentionally
Notes on Contributors Alison Bell, Chef Training Teacher and Program Co-ordinator at the David Thompson Secondary School, Invermere, British Columbia. Alison Blay-Palmer, Associate Professor in the Department of Geography and Environmental Studies at Wilfrid Laurier University. Ellen Desjardins, Registered dietitian (R.D.) and Doctoral student in the Department of Geography and Environmental Studies, Wilfrid Laurier University. Betsy Donald, Associate Professor in the Department of Geography at Queen’s University. Harriet Friedmann, Professor of Sociology at the University of Toronto Mississauga and the Centre for International Studies, University of Toronto. Clare Hinrichs, Associate Professor of Rural Sociology at The Pennsylvania State University. Mustafa Koc, Associate Professor in the Department of Sociology, Ryerson University, Toronto. Yael Levitte, Executive Director in the ADVANCE Center at Cornell University. Kevin Morgan, Professor of Governance and Development in the School of City and Regional Planning at Cardiff University. Wayne Roberts, Manager, Toronto Food Policy Council, Public Health, City of Toronto. Hélène St. Jacques, M.Ed., President, Informa Market Research Co. Ltd.
This page has been left blank intentionally
Acknowledgements The Imagining Sustainable Food Systems conference was generously funded by the Canada Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council and Wilfrid Laurier University particularly the Office of Research Services, the Dean of the Faculty of Arts and the Vice President, Academic. Their support made the conference and this volume possible. My sincere thanks to all the Imagining Sustainable Food Systems conference participants. Without you there would not be a book. Those who made the most substantial contributions are included in this volume. It has been a privilege to work with all of you. Thanks are also due to those who attended the conference but are not represented in this collection. In particular I am grateful to Sarah Wakefield, Robert Feagan, Karen Landman, Steffanie Scott, Tony Winson, Katherine Pigott, Alex Lovell, Melanie Bedore, Jennifer Sumner, Veronika Mogyorody, John Smithers, Rod MacRae, Marc Xuereb and Reiko Omoto who contributed their thoughts and insights throughout the conference and afterwards. I am also grateful to Valerie Rose, Katy Low and Elaine Couper for their editorial expertise. I am indebted to my family and friends for their support and patience – thank you. I am especially grateful to Walt Palmer for helping me go the distance.
This page has been left blank intentionally
Part 1 Interrogating Sustainable Food Systems
This page has been left blank intentionally
Chapter 1
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems Alison Blay-Palmer As a relatively new concept, sustainable agriculture does not yet reflect a coherent vision of possible and preferable modes of agricultural production and distribution. In the current moment we have the opportunity to create conceptual and practical forms that eliminate exploitive conditions in agriculture, both for the environment and for human beings. (Allen and Sachs 1993: 162)
As the current global political gridlock repeatedly thwarts attempts to develop consensus on pressing issues including climate change, global hunger and poverty the world screams out for reform. The need for change is particularly acute in the realm of food systems as over 1 billion people are malnourished and another 1.3 billion are overweight (Popkin 2009). Before launching the World Food Summit in Rome in November 2009, Jacques Diouf, head of the UN Food and Agriculture Organization went on a 24hour hunger strike proclaiming, ‘We have the technical means and the resources to eradicate hunger from the world so it is now a matter of political will, and political will is influenced by public opinion’ (UN FAO 2009). Confronted with these frustrating contradictions, the question becomes how to ignite change? Sustainable food systems loom large as a key dimension in addressing many of these challenges (Friedmann 2009, Sustainable Development Commission 2009, Marsden 2008, Maxey 2007). The International Assessment of Agricultural Knowledge, Science and Technology for Development (IAASTD) multistakeholder, global assessment group asserts that, … the widespread realization that despite significant scientific and technological achievements in our ability to increase agricultural productivity, we have been less attentive to some of the unintended social and environmental consequences of our achievements. We are now in a good position to reflect on these consequences and to outline various policy options to meet the challenges ahead, perhaps best characterized as the need for food and livelihood security under increasingly constrained environmental conditions from within and outside the realm of agriculture and globalized economic systems. (IAASTD 2008:3)
As we search for answers, Friedmann and McMichael’s visionary work on food regimes points to the potential for wholesale structural change as systems shift from one regime to another (Friedmann and McMichael 1989, Friedmann 1993a
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
2005 2009, McMichael 2005 2009). Existing structures that need to be challenged include: 1. The increasing consolidation of corporate interests; 2. Underinvestment in grounded, scale- appropriate agricultural research for developing countries; 3. Demand side pressures on food supplies from declining food reserves, increasing meat consumption and biofuel use; 4. Supply side pressures stemming from poor harvests arguably linked to climate change; and, 5. The emergence of food commodities as a source of international speculative investment (Clapp and Cohen 2009, IAASTD 2008, Friedmann 1993a). However, within the context of so much uncertainty and discord, there may be the seeds for germinating more sustainable global structures. While the exact pathway of the next regime is not clear, two possibilities warrant our attention. On the one hand, Friedmann suggests new directions are emerging along trajectories of corporate versus democratic governance (Friedmann 1993b). In the wake of decades of trade disputes between the US/EU and North/South, and an awakening of environmental consciousness, the next regime may be coalescing around corporate-environmental lines. In the face of stalled international multilateral trade talks corporations have done an end run around the state to create their own set of standards in a move to shape the food system on their terms. Friedmann (2005) suggests that this emerging trend threatens to further bifurcate consumer markets into rich and poor. On the rich end, traceability programs such as EUREP-GAP and its successor GLOBAL-GAP require ‘elaborate technologies of quality control and documentation’ (2005: 259). Not only do these technologies risk embedding an elite food chain in countries and regions that are able to comply with quality assurance requirements (e.g. north eastern Brazil, South Africa ad New Zealand) it also draws lines between people who are privileged enough to engage and those who are unable to partake (e.g. some people can fill out the forms and others who cannot). This leaves the poor with the food and opportunity remnants from the ‘standard’ (Friedmann 2005: 260) commodified, industrial food system. On the other hand, social movements such as Slow Food and Via Campesina resist corporate domination, unfair WTO trade rules and marginalization (Friedmann and McNair 2008, Morgan 2008, Chapter 10). The value of these new institutions is reflected in the Coyote Rojo initiative in the Mexican western highland region of Michoacan, The Coyote Rojo bioregional label, linked intellectually to Slow Food and concretely to Mexican agricultural and environmental politics, is a practical project by one community to help safeguard regional biodiversity and cultural practices. The ability of people to maintain themselves and their families on
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
their lands and rebuild regional ecology by marketing their products locally but, importantly, also in distant markets. (Friedmann and McNair 2008: 424)
In these cases food is a site for solidarity in the quest for social and environmental justice through new democratic forms of governance. These food groups resist property seizure (both land and intellectual) through coalitions that have stalled multilateral agricultural negotiations. They have united North and South through the valuation of agro-ecological growing and by ‘relinking consumption in municipal regions and protecting, reviving or creating regional food cultures’ (Friedmann 2005: 253). These new spaces offer the chance to ‘reassert the deeper meanings of agroecology and community in ways that do not reject markets but rather seek to “multiple niches” as an alternative strategy to the expansion of one set of products at the expense of all others’ (Fonte and Boccia 2004, Friedmann 2005: 261). These new approaches embed food in ecologically and socially defined localities and regions by ‘making known’ food quality and origins through institutional innovation in the form of new certification programs that link the North and South (Friedmann and McNair 2008: 409). The accompanying modes of regulation and social engagement may provide an opening for increased attention to social and environmental justice in line with principles of sustainability and a new role for public as governance is reconstituted (Friedmann 2005, 2009) so that, Interstitial social transformation is an idea that invites us to depart from a polar divide between autonomous oppositional movements on one side, and a cooptation by powerful corporations and states on the other. It is a muddy terrain into which one can sink at any time, yet perhaps one from which one can renew and redirect the journey as swamps are mapped. (Friedmann and McNair 2008: 430)
This is one hopeful crack in the neo-liberal sidewalk (Leyshon et al. 2001). A second space may be emerging in the form of food policy. According to Friedmann (1993b) there are opportunities for food policy – as opposed to the agricultural policy that framed the second regime – to contribute to re-regulation in the third regime. Food policy shows promise as a more inclusive foundation for new food relationships giving marginalized participants in the global food system voice through consumer and urban communities (Chapter 10). While food policy is still largely linked to municipal governments across North America and the UK (Chapters 9 and 10), there are a handful of examples of national food policies (Chapter 4). In Canada an NGO founded on principles of food security is using a participatory process to draft a national food security policy. In the UK, the Strategy Unit reporting to the Cabinet Office published ‘Food Matters: Towards a Strategy for the 21st Century’ (2008). The power of and challenges for consumers are described as,
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems Diet and attitudes to food have changed markedly in recent years in the UK – and will continue to do so. Demand for better quality food has risen, and people aspire to eat both more healthily and to buy food that has a reduced impact on the environment. But consumers also want affordability and food that fits their lifestyles – as demonstrated by the demand for convenience and by people eating outside of the home more often. Over the longer term, food prices have fallen relative to incomes and to the prices of other goods and services, although recent rises in food prices have put a brake on this trend. The less well off continue to devote a significantly higher proportion of their income to buying food than the better off. (Cabinet Office 2008: i)
The intention to implement a consistent UK food policy is reflected as, The Government’s vision for the food system is one that is more sustainable – economically, socially and environmentally. The future strategic policy objectives for food should be to secure: fair prices, choice, access to food and food security through open and competitive markets; continuous improvement in the safety of food; a further transition to healthier diets; and a more environmentally sustainable food chain. (Cabinet Office 2008: i)
This signals a commitment in the UK from upper levels of government to move towards a substantive sustainable national food policy. However, we must heed Morgan’s well-taken cautions about public procurement as representative of the challenges to enacting sustainable policy. As Morgan reminds us, policy is only the first step and needs to be underpinned by processes, knowledge and leadership to translate the lofty goals into reality (Chapter 4). The case of Brazil provides important insights into the potential successes and problems of food policy from a developing country perspective (Rocha 2009). Brazil’s groundbreaking food policy draws on a national strategy to reduce food security challenges by providing families with conditional monetary transfers, school and community meal programs, and the creation of local distribution opportunities for family farmers. Where feasible, actual governance is devolved to local, tripartite social councils through participatory responsibilities and processes that include budgeting. These councils are supported at the national scale by the National Council for Food and Nutrition Security and the national legislation that entrenched food and nutrition security as a right (Rocha 2009: 51-52). These starting points provoke questions about what would be needed to create and support an equitable, viable food system that accounts for social, economic and environmental concerns for citizens in developing and developed countries, rural and urban regions alike. One of the primary challenges is to unpack the reconstitutive dynamic between the global structures and the spaces for change at the local level. As part of the thinking about the challenges at the community scale, there is an emerging focus in the literature on civil society as a driver of change (Chapters 2, 3 and 10, Hinrichs and Lyson 2008, Morgan et al. 2006, Sumner
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
2005). Lyson anchors this idea to food through his vision for civic agriculture that ‘represents a broad-based movement to democratize the agriculture and food system.’ (Lyson 2008: 19). In these contexts local, grassroots movements emerge to champion individual and community rights and responsibilities in the face of global pressures. The consequent redistribution of power has the potential to create food centric polities, conventions and institutions. These emerging alternative relational networks could then be a platform to reconfigure local social, environmental and economic structures (Blay-Palmer 2007, Hall and Mogyorody 2007, Sonnino and Marsden 2006). Food systems offer a lens to dissect these new relationships. As a fundamental human need and right (UN 1948) food offers a prism to consider and address sustainability challenges as it translates complicated issues into meaningful ideas, policy and actions. First, as we all eat, food is something everyone can relate to and understand. Second, food unites all dimensions of sustainability – environmental, economic, and socio-cultural spaces – and allows us to explore the interconnected, fluid relationships simultaneously. We can grasp the importance of environmental stewardship when we consider the need for healthy food, soil and biodiversity, all of which can be achieved through ecologically sensitive, enabled farmers. It becomes clear through local food consumption that we can diminish our impact on the environment by reducing food miles. And, it is now more widely understood that buying food from nearby farmers, food processors and retailers keeps money in local economies. Further, social justice issues are more sharply defined as we compare access to healthy, culturally appropriate food across different communities and simultaneously consider the need to support fairly-traded food from developing countries (Morgan 2008). As Kloppenberg and his colleagues explain, to bring about a societal transformation, ‘We start with food. Given the centrality of food in our lives and its capacity to connect us materially and spiritually to each other and to the earth, we believe that it is a good place to start’ (1996: 40). This book offers a window into how we do/can create and theorize sustainable communities through food systems. On the practical side we explore the role of planning, social inclusion, public procurement and innovation as lenses for understanding sustainable food systems. Theoretically the book merges rural sociology, geographies of food, the greening of the economy and the politics of care as we expand our discussions about the connections and pull of/on food in society, the environment and the economy. The book adds to international scholarship through the identification of best practices for sustainable food systems. Importantly, the volume provides a grounded interdisciplinary approach to how we think about and create sustainable, flexible food systems by merging thinking from multiple disciplines with insights from practitioners. Imagining Sustainable Food Systems builds on papers presented at a workshop at Wilfrid Laurier University in Waterloo Ontario Canada in May 2008. The workshop brought together EU and North American academics and practitioners to consider questions about envisioning a sustainable food system from the
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
perspective of developed countries. While questions of food security are not as dire in developed countries, equitable access to quality food is extremely uneven. In Canada, for example, nearly 15% of Canadians report being food insecure. This is reflected in a recent food bank study that reported nearly 800,000 Canadians used a food bank in March 2009 (CAFB 2009). In considering the creation and delivery of a more sustainable food system, caution is required. Behind the hype about the benefits of sustainability lurk critical questions that need to be fore grounded as we try to move to more progressive food relationships. To this end, it is important to ask: What defines a sustainable food system? How can it be more inclusive? What are the trade-offs and how do we weave sustainability into food systems? To what extent can local and global scales interact without one swamping the other? How do we leverage an interdisciplinary approach to realize sustainable food system goals? And, how do we activate for change? These are some of the questions explored in Imagining Sustainable Food Systems. Overview The book is divided into three sections. In Part 1, we tackle contextual questions and begin by asking how to define ‘sustainable’, ‘food’ and ‘systems’ given the baggage that is associated with each of these terms. We are particularly interested in the role the global scale plays and explore how debates about and pressures from social injustice realities, the need for food democracy and the environmental and economic pressures that impact food systems. In Chapter 2 Hinrichs launches the book with a critical reflection on the meaning, scope and utility of the notion of ‘sustainable food systems’. Briefly tracing the movement from farming to food systems studies, the chapter goes on to examines scholarship on sustainability and systems. Considering the legacies and interplay of discourses of sustainable agriculture, sustainable development, sustainable livelihoods, and more recently sustainability transitions produces more nuanced understandings of sustainability than have generally been evident in food systems scholarship and practice. Hinrichs suggests themes that could enrich food systems scholarship and practice include the emergent and provisional character of knowledge, the inevitability of ‘trade-offs’ and the significance of power and politics. The term ‘systems’ has intuitive appeal, given its attention to comprehensiveness, connections and feedback. Yet despite these contributions, food systems scholarship and practice have generally overlooked critical systems issues, including how to draw boundaries for the system and how to remove the blinders that obscure internal differences within any designated system. The chapter concludes by demonstrating the rising importance of interdisciplinarity if both research and practice on sustainable food systems are to meet and transcend these various challenges.
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
Koc’s chapter explores the global food system and the ways that sustainability feeds and perpetuates the neo-liberal discourse related to large scale, commodity based agriculture. He questions the usefulness and potentially counter-productive effects of using the sustainability concept. As others have pointed out, employing ‘sustainable development’ to draw attention to the equal consideration of social, ecological and environmental factors may in fact be irreconcilable. Koc points to the contradictions between the modern food system and the resulting devastation of farmland and displacement of millions world-wide. Drawing on documents from the UN and elsewhere, Koc links sustainability and neo-liberal discourse with claims about ‘market failure’ to calls for an even more intensified approach to food production. In Koc’s analysis, an intensification of agriculture would serve to entrench the growing divide between those who have food and those who do not with the call for sustainability providing the rationale for ‘stability’. Koc tells us what is needed is fundamental and sweeping structural reform to address poverty and food security in a meaningful and lasting way. To accomplish this, he challenges us to be more precise in our definitions so that terms like sustainability cannot be hijacked. As Koc explains, ‘This is the time for re-evaluating our current practices, learning from our strengths and also weaknesses.’ (Chapter 3: 42) As a cornerstone of moving forward, Koc posits the need for increased food democracy so that all people participate in food (re)production/consumption and have voice in the realm of food by transforming the food system and its social institutions, practices and related governance structures. In Part 2, the book drills down to address specific questions from the perspective of inclusion/exclusion. The topics addressed focus on social justice issues particularly the potential role for public procurement, labour in alternative food systems, and food access. Questions asked in this section probe the dividends that accrue from new food systems, and at what cost? The second part of the book begins with Kevin Morgan’s chapter on public procurement. In this chapter, Morgan makes an extremely coherent and convincing case for public procurement as a springboard for sustainable economic development. Starting with the fact that British public purchasing power equals £150 billion annually, Morgan uses the school food service program to illustrate how public purchasing can lead to a more sustainable society. He makes a clear case for public procurement as one of the most promising levers to improve the health and well-being of all citizens. By activating the public procurement lever, the ‘state was in effect fashioning new markets in the public sector for more sustainable products by creating opportunities for local farmers and growers to supply locally-produced fresh produce’ (Chapter 4: 59). However, Morgan is also clear that public procurement – as a form of sustainable policy in action – needs to be built on organizational capacity founded on skills, knowledge, regulation, diffused good practice and devolved power (subsidiarity) so sustainability policy is translated into reality. In Chapter 5, Levitte assesses the existing literature on labour in organic and alternative agriculture. While the bulk of her review focuses on developed countries,
10
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
she does engage with developing countries and presents instructive examples for developed countries. Issues tackled include the rapid growth and consolidation within mainstream and sustainable food systems and how this impacts labour conditions and opportunities. Her review points out contradictions so that, for example, while sustainable agriculture as a whole offers better compensation and benefits to workers this applies mostly for larger, market garden organic farms. Levitte identifies multiple challenges and tensions including compensation, benefits, working standards and conditions, and the financial viability and quality of life of farm owners and farm workers. Levitte provocatively concludes by suggesting that lessons about learning and knowledge transfer from the biotechnology industry could have relevance for those working in sustainable food systems. Given the common process of ‘creative destruction’ in both biotechnology and sustainable agriculture, Levitte argues that face-to-face interaction and the importance of farmer/trade associations and networks as critical information sharing nodes needs to be further explored as a way to uncover learning pathways and the power structures of farmers and farm workers that underpin sustainable food systems. Desjardins engages with the literature on food deserts to identify gaps in the thinking and assumptions in this now well-established area of inquiry. Through the analysis of two case studies, one in Harlem New York and the other in Los Angeles, Desjardins focuses on the dangers of oversimplification. Pointing to the need for a much more nuanced and broadly informed approach to food access, she highlights the need to consider: the commitment and critical role of small retailers including corner stores, bodegas and farmers’ markets as community food purveyors; the delicate balance between small business opportunities for dispersed community employment and food provisioning with the need for appropriate food access; and, opportunities for civic engagement as a focal point for addressing food desert challenges. Using examples from the UK including Glasgow and Coventry, Desjardins challenges assumptions about food access and large-scale grocery stores as the panacea for food security. The third part of the book presents case studies as specific examples of doing food in a new way. Our case studies draw on the unique perspectives of their authors and explore issues of: planning and the role of the firm; entrepreneurialism and innovation; certification programs as a vehicle to scale up SFSs; the intersection of sustain-ability and social capital through the eyes of the Toronto Food Policy Council; and, the paradox of food insecurity in rural communities. The section begins with Donald’s innovative take on food systems that links sustainable regional development, food systems planning with the role of the firm. The chapter uses research in the Toronto organic, ethnic and specialty food industry to assess the opportunities to merge thinking in economic geography about the role of the firm with food systems planning. By fusing these multiple perspectives Donald overlays firm dynamics with the emerging realities of food systems planning to offer important insights about how to create more SFSs. In Chapter 8, St. Jacques documents three case studies as she explores the intersection between growing consumer awareness and the demand for local and
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
11
organic food with opportunities for market development, communications and branding. The first case describes the Ontario Natural Food Co-op (ONFC), a ‘flagship’ co-operative distributor with over 400 natural and health food stores in central and eastern Canada. As part of its mission, the co-op makes food accessible and educates people about their food as a way to empower them as food citizens. St. Jacques recounts the journey ONFC embarked upon as they launched a new brand and describes the process and thinking that supports a successful new product. Mapleton’s Organic Dairy is the second case study. Through the lens of diversification and managed risk-taking, the chapter outlines how the family run dairy evolved a successful, national ice cream brand. The final case study tells the story of YU Ranch – a tobacco farm turned eco-champion. The family who owns the farm now raises Texas long-horns for local consumption and helps to run a program that compensates farmers for responsible environmental stewardship. Together, the three cases speak to the merits of building linkages with customers and providing them with food that enhances local SFSs. Friedmann’s chapter puts flesh on the public procurement model bones by sharing the story of Local Food Plus (LFP) – an emerging Toronto success story – that is helping to scale up local food by linking institutions with local farmers. The chapter elaborates how LFP used its third party-certification program to create step-up opportunities that build a more sustainable food system. This project is firmly rooted in nearly three decades of food security-related work that nurtured the social capital and institutions needed to build these new food relationships. The initiative is a testament to the ‘communities of food’ in Toronto. Understanding LFP is especially germane to this volume and SFSs as it has created certification standards that attend to biodiversity, energy use, fair labour practices, animal welfare and regional food sourcing from farms that seek to tread as lightly as possible on the land. In Chapter 10, Roberts challenges us to consider the role of the food policy council as an agent of social innovation for sustainable change. Through his personal account about and frank insights into the dynamics of the Toronto Food Policy Council, Roberts shares his vision and experience of food policy councils as empowering catalysts for societal transformation. Roberts makes a convincing case for food policy councils as engines for sustainable change at all levels of government and institutions demonstrating how FPCs develop social and problemsolving skills and connect people across departments, sectors, communities and approaches. Roberts explains sustain-ability needs to be ‘an action verb, not a passive noun, and food councils are the agencies to activate this change’ (Chapter 10: 174). He describes the challenges encountered by FPCs as they undertake their SFSs missions and puts forward ways to meet and overcome these challenges. Services and programs top the list, as does relationship/ally building. He spells out the nuts and bolts of running an effective FPC ‘to brand sustainable food security policy emotively as well as logically’ (Chapter 10: 181) and the importance of building relationships. Roberts clearly demonstrates the multifunctional benefits of SFSs and the role subsidiarity – illustrated by something Roberts calls
12
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
‘linktanking’ – can play in making food policy work. With inimitable verve Roberts challenges us to, ‘get on with rolling up their [our] sleeves for the real policy and practice of animating, supporting, facilitating, connecting, educating, advocating for, championing and celebrating existing and emergent projects, all the while building strategic bridges for cooperative relations with people who work on projects that either link to or border on food systems.’ (Chapter 10: 177) Bell brings a historical approach to the subject of food access as she contrasts food security in the early 1900s and current levels for the inhabitants of a town in British Columbia, Canada. Her research describes the settling of the region by the British and the creation of award-winning orchards through the development of a vast irrigation system. However, despite earlier food security and related prosperity, in the last two decades the region has seen a decline in the number of farms and a related threat to local food security. The fore grounded contributing factor is decreased farming capacity due to land development pressure as the region has became a site for recreational properties layered onto ineffective land protection policy and the loss of farm autonomy. Bell suggests increased food access and education through CSAs and community gardens as a way to raise the profile about local food security and to stimulate more civic engagement through food. The final chapter ties together the themes discussed throughout the book. The chapter introduces a framework that builds from the literature and empirical work presented in the volume. The framework applies a sustainable food system lens to existing policy and global food structures. Through this prism (Morgan et al. 2006) we are able to envision the socio-communal, economic and environmental spaces that could emerge by framing questions and challenges through the eyes of a SFS. The framework elaborates the guiding principles, practices and institutions central to each space. To test the relevance of the framework, it is applied to a community produce market pilot project. The analysis allows us to identify areas of improvement for both the community markets project and the framework. This underscores the dynamic, hybrid nature of SFS as they are constantly being adapted and reconstituted in the places they evolve. Through the case study we unpack how and where theory and practice converge to produce more sustainable food systems. This final chapter explores the commonalities between sustainable food systems while acknowledging the need for flexible, adaptive food systems. The framework provides a vision for how to move forward as we think and act to increase sustainability. Acknowledgements I am very grateful to Harriet Friedmann for her thoughtful comments. As well, the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council is recognized for their
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
13
generous support of the workshop that inspired this book. That said, all errors and omissions are my responsibility. References Allen, P. and Sachs, C. 1993. Sustainable Agriculture in the United States: Engagements, Silences and Possibilities for Transformation. In Food for the Future: Conditions and Contradictions of Sustainability ed. P. Allen, 139168. Toronto: Wiley. Blay-Palmer, A. 2007. Relational Local Food Networks: The Farmers’ Market @ Queen’s. In M. Koc and K. Bronson (eds): 111-120. Buttel, F. and McMichael, P. (eds) 2005. New Directions in the Sociology Of International Development: Research in Rural Sociology and Developments Vol. 11. Oxford: Elsevier. Cabinet Office, Strategy Unit 2008. Food Matters: Towards a Strategy for the 21st Century. Accessed online January 26, 2010 at: http://www.cabinetoffice. gov.uk/media/cabinetoffice/strategy/assets/food/food_matters_es.pdf. Canadian Association of Food Banks 2009. Hunger Counts 2009. Accessed online January 24, 2010 at: http://www.cafb-acba.ca/main2.cfm?id=107185CBB6A7-8AA0-6FE6B5477106193A. Clapp, J. and Cohen, M. (eds) 2009. The Global Food Crisis: Governance Challenges and Opportunities. Waterloo, ON: WLU Press. Friedmann, H. 2009. Discussion: Moving food regimes forward: Reflections on symposium essays. Agriculture and Human Values 26: 335-344. Friedmann, H. and McNair, A. 2008. Whose rules rule? Contested projects to certify ‘local production for distant consumers’. Journal of Agrarian Change 8(2&3): 408-434. Friedmann, H. 2005. From Colonialism to Green Capitalism: Social Movements and the Emergence of Food Regimes. In F. Buttel and P. McMichael (eds): 227-264. Friedmann, H. 1993a. The political economy of food: A global crisis. New Left Review Jan-Feb: 29-57. Friedmann, H. 1993b. After Midas’s Feast: Alternative Food Regimes for the Future. In Food for the Future: Conditions and Contradictions of Sustainability ed. P. Allen, 213-234. Toronto, Wiley: . Friedmann, H., and P. McMichael 1989. Agriculture and the state system: The rise and decline of national agricultures, 1870 to the present. Sociologia Ruralis 29: 2, 93-117. Hall A. and V. Mogyorody. 2007. Organic farming, gender and the labour process. Rural Sociology. 722: 289-316. Hinrichs, C. and Lyson, T. (eds) 2008. Remaking the North American Food System. Lincoln, NB: University of Nebraska Press.
14
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
International Assessment of Agricultural Knowledge, Science and Technology for Development (IAASTD). 2008. Agriculture at a Crossroads: Synthesis Report. Washington: Island Press. Accessed online January 24, 2010 at: http://www.agassessment.org/reports/IAASTD/EN/Agriculture%20at%20a %20Crossroads_Synthesis%20Report%20English..pdf. Kloppenberg, J., Hendricskon, J., and Stevenson, G. 1996. Coming into the Foodshed. Agriculture and Human Values 133: 33-42. Leyshon, A. et al. (eds). 2003. Alternative Economic Spaces. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Lyson, T. 2008. Civic Agriculture and the North American Food System. In C. Hinrichs and T. Lyson (eds): 19-32. Marsden, T. 2008. (ed.) Sustainable Communities: New Spaces for Planning, Participation and Engagement. Oxford: Elsevier. Maxey, L. 2007. ‘From ‘Alternative’ to ‘Sustainable’ Food’. In Maye et al. (eds). Maye, D. et al. (eds) 2007. Constructing Alternative Food Geographies: Representation and Practice London: Elsevier Press. McMichael, P. 2009. A food regime analysis of the ‘world food crisis’. Agriculture and Human Values 26: 281-295. McMichael, P. 2005. Global development and the corporate food regime. In New directions in the sociology of international development: Research in rural sociology and developments, Vol. 11, ed. F.H. Buttel, and P.D. McMichael, 227–264. Amsterdam: Elsevier. Morgan, K. and Sonnino, R. 2008. The School Food Revolution: Public Food and the Challenge of Sustainable Development. London: Earthscan. Morgan et al. 2006. Worlds of Food: Place, Power and Provenance in the Food Chain. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Popkin, B. 2009. The World Is Fat: The Fads, Trends, Policies and Products that Are Fattening the Human Race. New York: Penguin. Rocha, C. 2009. Enhancing Engagement in Civil Society. Presentation to the UN High level meeting on Food Security for all. January 26-27. Madrid, Spain. Sonnino, R. and Marsden, T. 2006. Beyond the Divide: Rethinking the Relationships Between Alternative and Conventional Food Networks in Europe. Journal of Economic Geography 6:2: 181-199. Sumner, J. 2005. Sustainability and the Civil Commons: Rural Communities in the Age of Globalization. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Sustainable Development Commission. 2009. Setting the Table: Advice to Government on priority elements of sustainable diets. Report to the Prime Minister, the First Ministers of Scotland and Wales and the First Minister and Deputy First Minister of Northern Ireland. Accessed online January 24, 2010 at: http://www.sd-commission.org.uk/publications/downloads/Setting_ the_Table.pdf.
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
15
UN – FAO. 2009. FAO Head Starts Hunger Strike. Will be joined by UN Secretary General Ban Ki-Moon. Accessed online January 24, 2010 at: http://www.fao. org/news/story/en/item/37338/icode/. UN. 1948. Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Accessed online February 21, 2010 online at: http://www.un.org/en/documents/udhr/.
This page has been left blank intentionally
Chapter 2
Conceptualizing and Creating Sustainable Food Systems: How Interdisciplinarity can Help Clare Hinrichs
Introduction The cynical and fatigued may suggest that, however well-intentioned, the term ‘sustainable food systems’ is fairly thin gruel. It may be comforting and familiar in the winter of our concern about the food system, but how well does it fortify us for the hard intellectual or practical work that needs to be done? The term appears widely and disparately – on both longstanding and newcomer university websites dealing with food and agriculture, in the titles of more than a few academic publications, in the documents and displays of various NGOs, and even in the marketing pitches of food service consultants. Despite its varied use and the perils of trend-inspired overuse, I argue in this chapter that the notion of ‘sustainable food systems’ presents conceptual merits and opportunities that, overall, justify its retention. Indeed, with care, caution and some creativity, ‘sustainable food systems’ can provide a useful springboard for thinking about theory and practice surrounding food and agriculture. How then do we conceptualize and create ‘sustainable food systems’? To begin, it can be instructive to pull apart the terms comprising ‘sustainable food systems’. We should grapple with several issues associated with the first term – ‘sustainable’ – and the third term – ‘systems’. (The middle term ‘food’ has its own conceptual and analytical complications, but they will be a minor focus in this chapter.) This excursus on ‘sustainable food systems’ will be unavoidably selective, reflecting issues towards the end of the first decade of the 21st century, ideas borrowed from assorted other writers, questions emerging in my own work, chance conversations and just a little of the 24/7 news that washes over us all now. In this chapter, I suggest that devising an ironclad definition of ‘sustainable food systems’ is neither possible nor desirable. Rather, we need to forge commitment to ongoing critical reflection about this term and the interplay of goals that shape it, as well as the tensions between them. I examine the legacies and interplay of different discourses on sustainability to deepen reflection on sustainable food systems. I further suggest that recognizing and developing the possibilities for
18
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
interdisciplinarity in our own research and practice will help move us forward in the work of conceptualizing and creating more sustainable food systems. Excursus: Sustainable Food Systems The movement for sustainable food systems has become one of the more exciting and pivotal movements of our time, tying together issues of urgent importance and animating growing numbers of sometimes disparate people and social groups (Wright and Middendorf 2008, Hinrichs and Lyson 2007, Kloppenburg et al. 2000). In broad terms, this movement sees much that is worrying and wrong in the current large scale, industrialized, consolidating and increasingly global food system. Outsized, standardized, environmentally degrading, wasteful, unjust, unhealthy, placeless, disempowering – these are a few of the tags that the industrialized, globalized food system invites (Blay-Palmer 2008). Public and academic concerns about the implications of industrialization and globalization in the food system now find some relief (and hope) in the gathering signs of new trends and different directions. Such encouraging signs include large increases in organic acreage worldwide; the proliferation of farmers’ markets, community supported agriculture, and farm-to-school and -college programs; growing public demand for fairly traded products; and other developments, some documented in this book. Various labels, such as ‘local’, ‘alternative’, ‘quality’, ‘transformative’ and ‘sustainable’ have been affixed to these new manifestations. But in the rush of documenting and fostering these encouraging changes in the food system, we may not ask how well these labels work as broad equivalents or whether they, in fact, represent distinct content. And why ask? Under any of these labels, an emerging and different food system faces the onerous assignment of challenging that dominant and dominating food system. Isn’t that work enough? Yet this food system picture, however heroic and stirring, is both simplistic and misleading. First, it resorts to those stark, easy binaries such as global vs local (Hinrichs 2003) or conventional vs alternative (Maye, Holloway and Kneafsey 2007) that ultimately caricaturize the settings and actors in food system struggles and politics. This minimizes the extent to which thinking and practice about food systems have now moved away from essentialized and potentially static formulations. Second, the picture above misses important temporal and spatial aspects of food system change. For example, Selfa and Qazi (2005) demonstrate that patterns, processes and understandings of food system localization have varied across sub-regions of Washington State in the US due to differing sociospatial and agricultural histories. Similarly, in their book Worlds of Food, Morgan, Marsden and Murdoch (2006) trace and explain how food and agricultural networks, conventions and regional legacies and structures interact differently in Tuscany, Wales and California. This approach generates more nuanced, variegated and useful accounts of actually existing and changing food systems, and the possibilities for sustainability.
Conceptualizing and Creating Sustainable Food Systems
19
Sustainability in food systems is unlikely to result from one blue ribbon recipe, publicized, circulated and followed to the letter. Instead, multiple recipes need to be located, tested, perused, adapted and shared. With the steady press of recent news about changing land uses, changing diets, changing climate, new appropriations of agriculture for energy feedstocks, rising food prices worldwide, record numbers of visits to emergency food pantries in the global North and the re-ignition of food riots in parts of the global South, it is clear that issues surrounding food, agriculture and environment remain central and urgent. If anything, the evidence also suggests that these issues are more complex, connected and frequently contested than we may have previously recognized. How then does the concept of sustainable food systems provide insight for the work before us? Food That middle term – ‘food’ – requires some brief discussion. It offers its own interesting, conceptual complications, which cannot be explored at length in this chapter. The growing hold of food as an analytical, practical and experiential touchstone remains most important. In my field, rural sociology, historical trends and theoretical shifts have retrained our gaze from agriculture and farming to the larger food system. First, the new political economy of agriculture that took hold in the 1970s and 1980s gave research centered on farms, farmers and farming a more critical cast. From a focus on farm production emerged analytical attention to how upstream and downstream economic relations and the role of the state at multiple levels shape the structures and outcomes of agriculture. Such concerns became situated within the quickening and often contradictory forces of globalization. Rural sociologists entered new and productive conversations with geographers and anthropologists initially, and later with nutritionists, planners and others about the food and farming system. A focus on food, indeed the ‘power of food’ as McMichael (2000) puts it, helped to place these concerns within a framework taking into account both production and consumption relations. Food sits at the socio-ecological nexus in this framework. In production, it ties us to the land – land in its broadest, indeed its Leopoldian land-as-community sense. And in consumption, food nourishes bodies, both human and non-human, with crucial implications for health. In this respect, food’s material and cultural salience, and its extraordinary reach into and through our lives, makes it a compelling focus for research and practice. We know food as those materials produced and gathered, sometimes processed and traded and ultimately eaten and imbibed by humans. We turn to food most fundamentally for nourishment, but pleasure figures too. As biological necessity, but also cultural expression, as personal taste and group tradition, as profit opportunity and as human right, food serves as fulcrum for endless analysis. Given its material and social importance, food beckons as an entry point to questions of sustainability that involve joining environmental and socio-economic concerns. However, the further jump to ‘sustainable food systems’ sometimes
20
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
elaborates the set of concerns in broader, visionary directions. ‘Sustainable food systems’ have been characterized by those working in the field with lengthy, encompassing lists of attributes ranging from ‘more environmentally sound, more economically viable for a larger percentage of community members, and more socially, culturally and spiritually healthful’ (Feenstra 2002: 100) to ‘relational, proximate, diverse, ecologically sustainable, economically sustaining, just/ethical, knowledgeable/communicative, seasonal/temporal, healthful, participatory, culturally nourishing, and sustainably regulated’ (Kloppenburg et al. 2000: 181). Such lists are helpful in underscoring that people understand and value food systems according to multiple, sometimes finely grained dimensions. They eschew simple compartments and reach for comprehensiveness. But does the sweeping normative ambition of such sustainable food system characterizations render them difficult to bring to earth, for either research or practice? You expect all of that? Exactly how? Looking more closely now at ‘sustainability’ and at ‘systems’ can offer further insights. Discourses of Sustainability Not long ago, I was invited to join a task force working to devise a suite of indicators to track the progress of sustainable agriculture and food systems in my state of Pennsylvania. The effort was organized by a prominent Pennsylvania sustainable agriculture NGO and funded by some of the ubiquitous private foundations behind many sustainable agriculture and food initiatives in the US. Participating in that task force were farmers, activists, public educators, and researchers, among others – a thoughtful and engaged group. Nonetheless, our discussions never moved very far beyond the familiar ‘three-legged stool’ of sustainability – with its assumption of compartmentalized and more or less balanced attention to environmental quality, economic vitality and social/community equity and health. Some of the difficulty arose because good data measuring what seemed to matter were just not available. But more often it was difficult to agree on what outcomes mattered most for sustainable food systems. As no one in the group felt satisfied with the results of our efforts, the NGO decided to shelve the sustainable food system indicators project for the time being, with plans to resume sometime in the future. The qualified and still incomplete experience in Pennsylvania measuring and monitoring sustainability-relevant trends in the food system illustrates some of the broad challenges of reductionism, agenda-setting and politics that Bell and Morse (1999) identify in efforts to develop sustainability indicators. How well can any one set of indicators capture, communicate and advance the sustainability However, this is not to suggest that it is impossible or futile to develop sustainable food system indicators. Some efforts have achieved more resolution. In the US, see, for example, the Charting Growth project of the Wallace Center, in partnership with the Kellogg Foundation’s Food and Society Project (http://www.wallacecenter.org/our-work/currentinitiatives/sustainable-food-indicators). For a critique of the neoliberal underpinnings of
Conceptualizing and Creating Sustainable Food Systems
21
of a given region’s food and agricultural system? Buttel (2006: 214) stresses that ‘sustainability is a contested notion’ that ‘remains [ ] useful [ ] – partly on account of the fact that it is not so static or formulaic that it cannot be debated and contested.’ Sustainability’s uptake across domains, time and national settings certainly demonstrates its pliability. This broad use (and in some cases, it could be argued, appropriation) suggests why ‘many analysts have come to regard it [sustainability] as an insubstantial and clichéd platitude unworthy of further interest or research’ (Drummond and Marsden 1999: 1). However, I believe it would be premature to abandon sustainability as a concept. Instead, more consideration of the shifting currents of sustainability discourse and politics can inform and potentially strengthen our research and practice on food systems. In particular, discourses on sustainable agriculture, on sustainable development, on sustainable livelihoods and on sustainability transitions highlight the flux, contest and possibilities in sustainability. Sustainable agriculture has most readily focused on the ‘environmental or ecological soundness of the production system or agro-food commodity chain’ (Buttel 2006: 214). From its earliest activist glimmers to the institutionalization of formal (though still modest) government programs (at least in the US) to support sustainable agriculture, making farm production practices more energy efficient and protective of natural resources have been paramount priorities for sustainable agriculture. Pretty (1998: 25-26) maintains that sustainable agriculture eschews any ‘concretely defined set of technologies, practices or policies’ aiming instead for the general goal of replacing external inputs with more site-specific agro-ecological processes that reduce environmental harm and depletion. Allen (2004) has long argued that the discourse of sustainable agriculture has largely subordinated any consideration of social equity and justice in its concern for more environmentally sound production. She and other researchers (e.g. Shreck, Getz and Feenstra 2006) have helped to legitimize attention to community food security, farm labor, hunger and poverty, and more importantly to establish their relevance and connection to production agriculture. Yet even so, sustainable agriculture still carries its historical legacy of privileging production practices and relations over those of consumption. Sustainable development gained global prominence with the 1987 publication of Our Common Future by the U.N. World Commission on Environment and Development. That report provided the now iconic definition of sustainable development as ‘development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.’ The definition’s recognition of intergenerational obligations represented something new, encoding an ethical logic for the preservation of ecological resources and such efforts, see Guthman’s (2008) assessment of the process undertaken by the Vivid Picture project in California.
22
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
integrity. But the unqualified reference to ‘needs’ offered little guidance on how to negotiate differing constructions of ‘need’ vs. ‘want’ in the global North and the global South nor on how to accommodate the possibility that ‘needs’ of future generations might not resemble those of present generations (Redclift 2005). Indeed, skirting the critical question of what exactly is to be sustained and for whom facilitated growing embrace of sustainable development, on their own terms, by some corporate businesses after the 1992 Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro (Redclift 2005). As a contradictory discourse, sustainable development retains core commitments to economic growth within its loose call to link and address human poverty and environmental deterioration (Kemp and Martens 2007). As many have noted, the term ultimately stands as something of an oxymoron (Redclift 2005). Dryzek (2005: 157) observes that sustainable development involves ‘a rhetoric of reassurance. We can have it all: economic growth, environmental conservation, social justice; and not just for the moment, but in perpetuity.’ Among other things, sustainable development bequeaths to sustainable food systems such approaches as green business, green marketing, and green consumption. The sustainable livelihoods framework, which gained favor with international development-focused NGOs and agencies in the 1990s, offers a sustainability discourse with a different, more micro inflection. Arising from recognition of the intractable food and income security challenges facing the rural poor in many developing countries, sustainable livelihoods are to be analyzed and facilitated at the household and community levels. Sustainable livelihoods share the multi-dimensionality of other sustainability discourses. In a much-cited paper, Scoones (1998: 5) builds the definition of sustainable livelihood: A livelihood comprises the capabilities, assets (including both material and social resources) and activities required for a means of living. A livelihood is sustainable when it can cope with and recover from stresses and shocks, maintain or enhance its capabilities and assets, while not undermining the natural resource base.
Within this sustainability discourse, the amelioration of poverty is central. But rather than making income growth an end in itself, sustainable livelihoods prioritize the well-being and capabilities of people, as they themselves understand them (Scoones 1998). The approach highlights the complex portfolios of activities (agricultural and otherwise) that households engage in and underscores the implications of how activities are clustered and sequenced. But despite the utility of a sustainable livelihoods framework for describing how production and consumption activities intersect to create particular sustainability outcomes, the framework has been applied almost exclusively to poor people and communities in the global South, despite the potential for parallel analysis of livelihoods
Conceptualizing and Creating Sustainable Food Systems
23
(and lifestyles) in the richer global North (Chambers 2009). The discourse of sustainable livelihoods emphasizes possibilities for rebalancing and integrating food production and consumption at the micro and household level, but any such efforts need to marry inquiry seeking to understand and improve the situation of the poor with critical analysis of the sustainability impacts of affluent lifestyles and practices. Sustainability transition (or transitions) is the most recent variant of sustainability discourse, emanating from the global North, and thus far, mostly researched and applied there. More developed (and discussed) among academics in Europe than in North America, sustainability transition implies steering and management of technology, economy and resources to effect more sustainable outcomes for society (O’Riordan and Church 2001). The concept originated in Dutch policy circles, as a partnership approach to longterm policymaking to transform entire sectors, such as energy (Heiskanen et al. forthcoming), in light of challenges such as shifting resource availability and climate change. The term has a decided whiff of social engineering, in the idea that large-scale socio-technical transitions can be rationally managed. But that may be offset to some degree by recognition that transitions are plural. The distinctive interactions of global forces and structures with specific local contexts necessitate multiple pathways, plural transitions, rather than cookiecutter approaches to sustainability. Such transitions, as explored in the EU context, entail complex and shifting multiple tier governance, by different government entities and civil society groups (O’Riordan and Church 2001). Furthermore, Heiskanen et al. (forthcoming) observe that different national cultures and policy histories necessitate translation and hybridization of the original Dutch transition management model. Others point back to the goals of sustainable development, which remain ‘ambivalent’ and suggest that any transition management can only handle such ambivalence through ‘strategies of reflexive governance’ (Walker and Shove 2007). Related to this, Shove and Walker (2007) caution that the politics of who defines and manages sustainability transitions needs far greater scrutiny. Nonetheless, while not yet widely applied to food systems, the discourse of sustainable transitions emphasizes deliberative planning and ‘constructive dialogue’ (Heiskanen et al., forthcoming) across levels and actors to design and chart more sustainable pathways.
However, grassroots activist and charity initiatives to support ‘transition towns ‘ have now emerged in both North America and Europe, as well as elsewhere around the globe. Prompted by concerns about peak oil and climate change, transition efforts in specific places often center on relocalization of food economies, health services, and education; appropriate technology; community-building and cooperation, with the aim of developing local community self-reliance. See http://transitiontowns.org and http://www.transitionus.org/.
24
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
These somewhat compressed accounts of four discourses of sustainability offer distinct emphases, based on the sector of initial interest, national and institutional origins and historical context. Across these sustainability discourses, three themes can be detected: the emergent and provisional character of knowledge, the inevitability of ‘trade-offs’ and the significance of power and politics. Taken together, these three themes underscore the ongoing tensions in conceptualizing and creating sustainable food systems. Tensions of Knowledge, Trade-offs and Power Recognition of the emergent and provisional character of knowledge has shaped both well-established work on sustainable agriculture practices and newer policy attention to sustainable transitions. The very complexity of food and agricultural systems has stimulated strong reservations, at least in some quarters, about the limits of normal science and traditional models of technical expertise. Work on multi-scalar sustainability analysis of agroecosystems builds on recognition of uncertainty and underscores the emergent, partial and provisional character of any knowledge about the system (Giampetro 2004). It may seem, for example, that sustainability in urban food systems rests less on the hard sciences, than on logistical matters of distribution, exchange and access. But the emergent and contested character of scientific knowledge remains relevant. How, for example, should new knowledge asserting specific nutritional benefits in organic produce over conventional be factored in to the design of community food security programs? What if the next study overturns or complicates that claim? ‘To the best of our knowledge at the present time…’ becomes the critical qualifier for research and practice on sustainable food systems. But, if we are honest with ourselves, one’s best knowledge today may look somewhat dog-eared by next year, as we witness or become further aware of the complexity and uncertainties in food and agricultural systems. This emergent quality is captured in understandings of sustainability that stress its undetermined, rather than prescribed character: Most current efforts to define a sustainable food system assume a steady-state situation; i.e., if we just tweak our current food system so it causes less pollution, promotes conservation, regulates food safety more effectively, and includes more of the ingredients that a healthy diet requires, then it will be sustainable. Probably nothing could be further from the truth. Since nature is full of emergent properties, sustainability is always an emerging concept. Sustainability is about maintaining something indefinitely into the foreseeable future. Consequently, to be sustainable we have to anticipate and successfully adapt to the changes ahead. Sustainability is a process, not a prescription. This process always requires social and ecological as well as economic dimensions. There is therefore no simple definition. It is a journey we embark on together, not a formula upon which we agree (Kirschenmann 2008: 113).
Conceptualizing and Creating Sustainable Food Systems
25
Because of the emergent character of knowledge, and growing recognition now of different kinds of knowledge, sustainability requires thoughtful and more explicit engagement with the question of ‘trade-offs’ (Gibson 2005). While our utopian visions of sustainable food systems construct long comprehensive lists of desirable attributes, how are the inevitable compromises negotiated and experienced on the ground? With some ring of calculated exchange, the notion of trade-offs means we allow for some effects that may be adverse for sustainability in order to ensure other valued sustainability gains (Gibson 2005). Canadian researcher Robert Gibson (2005) provides guidelines for how to handle such sustainability trade-offs in the context of resource development projects. Trade-off guidelines include prioritizing maximum net gains, putting the burden of argument on the trade-off proponent, avoiding significant adverse effects, protecting future options and explicitly justifying all trade-offs. Starting to think more seriously about trade-offs seems a necessary next step for food system practice. However, any actual implementation and use of trade-off guidelines will be complicated, given tensions and contest around the knowledge necessary to embark on productive discussion of trade-offs. While needing more focused and creative attention, the issue of trade-offs inevitably brings divergent values into play, as suggested in work addressing the carbon footprint and energy implications of local food systems (Mariola 2008). Does an environmental criterion for sustainable food systems trump the importance of more direct relationships between farmers and consumers? If it does, I may need to reconsider meandering the countryside in my private automobile to an array of local markets and farms where I experience that farmer connection. But who decides? Whose values matter? Ultimately, the issue of trade-offs leads directly to one of the most significant tensions in sustainability – the crucial importance of power and politics. For example, decisions about sustainability trade-offs could end up being handled by ‘transition managers’ whose procedures and politics do not incorporate the range of divergent social interests. If that were to happen, sustainability would become a largely top-down, mechanistic and technical-administrative project. However, genuine democratic process and unfamiliar models of more reflexive governance could well be slower and messier for designing, negotiating and working for sustainability, precisely when the problems we face seem more urgent than ever. Because values inform the varied criteria constituting sustainability, the privileging of certain criteria over others has political implications, even when technical considerations might be invoked to justify that decision. In this respect, the rise of public fora on food and agriculture issues, food policy councils, and other expressions of civil society represent important and promising, though still experimental social instruments for creating more sustainable food systems. This fuller consideration of sustainability – its history, variants and tensions – enables us to accept that sustainable food systems represent visions whose empirical reality cannot be captured by fixed, assured knowledge. That does not mean that sustainable food systems are only a shimmering utopian goal at the gates of heaven. As Wakefield points out in this volume, inclusive, flexible
26
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
‘food utopias’ are possible. Ultimately, sustainable food systems will emerge from participation in everyday practice. They must involve a collaborative and inevitably political process of inquiry and adjustment. This means incremental and collective tinkering, work that agroecologists call adaptive management. As Buttel (2006: 214) writes, ‘sustainability is not so much an end-point as it is a process; the notion of sustainability reminds us that there will always be new ways that agro-food systems can be rendered more ecologically sound, more economically viable and more socially just.’ Systems Following this consideration of sustainability, the term ‘systems ‘ in sustainable food systems also merits attention. Referring to food and agricultural systems may be more common in North America than in Europe, where ‘chains’ and ‘networks’ have been favored handles. Perhaps none of these terms is ideal. I’ll cautiously make the case here for ‘systems’. I earlier described rural sociology’s shifting focus from farm to the broader food system. That resonates with varied efforts to provide more comprehensive accounting of the flows and sustainability impacts of the many spheres of social and economic activity depending on and supporting the agricultural sector (Dahlberg 1993, Heller and Keoleian 2003). Life cycle-type approaches, for example, attempt to account for material and energy inputs and outputs, as well as environmental impacts, across the entire system (Heller and Keoleian 2003). In some respects, life cycle assessment is an engineer’s version of commodity chain analysis, but with the human actors (indeed any actors) submerged beneath the material resource flows and impacts. What commends many ‘systems’ approaches is their attention to comprehensiveness, connections, juxtapositions, places of leverage, and potential feedback (Sundkvist, Milestad and Jannson 2005). They avoid the implied linearity of ‘food chains’ and conjure a bigger picture than ‘food networks’. Complexity registers in ‘systems’ and sometimes it’s daunting. Yet ‘systems’ metaphors also trigger concern on the part of some social scientists. Bell (2005) warns of the functionalist tendencies in many systems approaches, and hence an inherent leaning to the status quo, and argues against the sweeping holism and unity privileged in systems-type theory. Writing more specifically about agrifood systems, Bell (2008: 84) claims we ‘miss much potential for a transformative progressivism by focusing on connectedness without an equal focus on disconnectedness.’ Shove and Walker (2007) note that the very process of defining any complex system for analysis can, through sheer weight of the technical abstractions, obscure the significance of unequal social power. Brief consideration of two ideas – boundaries and blinders – helps to clarify some of these systems issues in conceptualizing sustainable food systems. It is well recognized that setting the boundaries of the system has implications for any assessment of that system (Heller and Keoleian 2003). If the system is drawn expansively so that multiple and overlapping relationships of influence
Conceptualizing and Creating Sustainable Food Systems
27
must be considered, it becomes more difficult to get our hands (or minds) around it. Everything relates to everything! But conversely, if a smaller, more comprehensible ‘system ‘ is drawn, we risking missing critical influences and impacts, and possibly trivialize our efforts. This issue of boundaries poses particular challenges for assessing sustainable food systems. Born and Purcell (2006) write convincingly about the peril of the ‘local trap’ in food systems planning research, where local serves as a presumed stand-in for other sustainability goals. Edwards-Jones et al. (2008) test that assumption empirically by widening the system boundaries within which the impacts of ‘local food’ should be considered. They assess carbon footprints and livelihood impacts associated with vegetables produced in the UK and overseas. Within a larger system perspective, they conclude that the ‘food miles’ advantage of local produce masks a more complex picture of sustainability trade-offs, including farmworker health and well-being. Another challenge to conceptualizing and creating sustainable food systems is what Patricia Allen and I have described as the ‘blinders’ problem (Hinrichs and Allen 2008). Drawing system boundaries, in a sense, sets up the field of concern. It means that those processes within the boundaries are subject to active consideration and analysis, and those outside are designated ‘context’. However, human perception can remain incomplete and uneven in its acuity and interest, even across a specific field of concern, such as ‘the system’. Sociologically, this results in bracketing out – not seeing or not fully seeing – particular social actors and groups within the system. For example, in an ongoing research project examining US Buy Local Food campaigns, we identified tendencies towards social justice ‘blinders’ in the organization and practice of these local food initiatives. We found that more disadvantaged farmworkers and consumers, arguably within the system, have still remained largely outside the scope of these efforts to move the food system in more sustainable directions (Hinrichs and Allen 2008). Local food campaigns have social justice models in other historical ‘selective patronage’ campaigns urging consumers to ‘Buy Union’ or ‘Buy Black’ but participants may wear blinders to important differences within the construction of ‘local’. It may not be entirely possible to overcome these boundary and blinder challenges. But we can be more aware of how they affect our conceptualizations of sustainable food systems. The Interdisciplinary Turn Given the evident flux, complexity and contest in the food and agricultural system, where should we turn theoretically to guide our research? Even within the social sciences, we see less rigid adherence to particular theories now, and more of what we might consider theoretical bricolage. Researchers mine political economy veins, posit actor-networks, provide a dash of conventions theory, dip their toes in political ecology waters. Some of the results may be ad hoc, perhaps misguided.
28
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
But some represent creative efforts to develop more comprehensive theoretical frameworks for understanding both complexity and change in food systems. Academic social science offers rich insights about the food and agricultural system, but alone, social science can only go so far in apprehending food systems and their possibilities for sustainability. We’ve reached a point where the challenges facing the food and agricultural system require more interaction and collaboration across disciplines. We know it’s fruitful to have more exchange across various social science disciplines, as demonstrated by the range of participation in the workshop that inspired this volume. But beyond mobilizing a broader community of social scientists, work on sustainable food systems also requires social scientists to work in new, more productive ways with natural and technical scientists. We’ve arrived at a more pressing interdisciplinary moment, one that reconceives knowledge, innovation and problem-solving as arising from improved (though not necessarily easy) collaboration between the social and the natural and technical sciences. In North America, the academic institutionalization of interdisciplinary approaches to the food and agricultural system is evident in the vigor of professional societies such as the US-based Agriculture, Food and Human Values Society, and the more recently inaugurated Canadian Association for Food Studies. In both the UK and US, we now see increasing dedication of public funding streams to specifically interdisciplinary research on food, agricultural and environmental issues. Furthermore, there is more formal discussion and even research about interdisciplinary practice (see Hinrichs 2008, Lowe and Phillipson 2006, Lowe, Phillipson and Lee 2008 for elaboration). Both the pushes and pulls towards interdisciplinarity are complicated, historically situated, and not entirely the same in different national contexts, where research norms and institutional resources and incentives may differ. What exactly do we mean by interdisciplinarity? Definitions abound, but for purposes of work on sustainable food systems, knowledge and integration are critical components. We can think of multi-disciplinary research as involving one or more academic disciplines. Each addresses a common problem, working to generate its own discipline-based knowledge, which is then shared at the end, arraying the different disciplinary contributions to the problem. Interdisciplinary research is more integrative of effort and knowledge. It entails more collaboration between researchers at the outset. Throughout the research process, there is greater integration of knowledge and theory from the participating disciplines, with final results more cross-fertilized. But more fully interdisciplinary research on certain issues may also integrate other less typical research partners. In the case of food systems, non-academic participants – citizens, practitioners, activists, farmers, ‘stakeholders’ if you will – can have important roles in problem definition, knowledge generation and integration (Lowe and Phillipson 2006). This kind of interdisciplinary research breaks with many longstanding norms in the academy. For a fuller discussion of the typology of interdisciplinary research, on which I base this discussion, see Tress, Tress and Fry (2006).
Conceptualizing and Creating Sustainable Food Systems
29
However, sustainability questions arguably require a more complex ‘ecosystem of expertise’ to produce relevant and useful knowledge (Brand and Karvonen 2007). What then does interdisciplinarity look like in sustainable food systems research and practice? Interdisciplinarity and Sustainable Food Systems Research Thus far, my own interdisciplinary food systems research experiences have more often involved collaborations with other social science disciplines. My work has benefited, I think, from that cross-disciplinary friction and engagement. The challenges of sustainable food systems, however, necessitate finding ways to generate more creative collaborative friction between the social and the natural sciences. To highlight the innovative research possibilities when social scientists and natural scientists join forces, I will describe one specific research project of the UK’s RELU (Rural Economy and Land Use) Programme. A few years ago, I had the opportunity to shadow a research project called ‘Eating Biodiversity: An Investigation into the Links Between Quality Food Production and Biodiversity Production.’ Henry Buller, a geographer at the University of Exeter was principal investigator. His collaborators included three additional geographers, two animal scientists and two grassland ecologists, some based at other institutions in England. So how was this a sustainable food systems research project? I’ll borrow from the project’s official profile: ‘the research seeks to develop opportunities for ‘win-win-win’ situations where farm enterprises can gain added value from producing high-quality products in terms of taste and nutrition from significant biodiverse pasture types, such as moorland, heathland and salt-marshes, in ecologically sustainable ways.’ At the time I visited, the researchers were studying lamb and beef systems; they hoped also to examine cheese. This project involved agro-ecological analysis of species abundance and richness in pastures, scientific indicators of meat quality and consumer assessments of taste, farmers’ accounts of land use management and livelihood practices, description of processing and retailing enterprises, and analysis of regulatory barriers and opportunities. The research was still midstream when I visited, though it has since concluded. I saw a project that demonstrated innovative practices and approaches holding promise for sustainable food systems research. The research team deliberately constructed cross-disciplinary exchanges from the outset that served to open team members to other members’ disciplinary world-views and improve working RELU is a landmark £24 million interdisciplinary research initiative, funded through contributions from the UK’s main research councils (Economic and Social Research Council, Natural Environment Research Council, Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council). Its first year cycle funded 8 projects on ‘sustainable food chains. ‘ Through an ESRC/SSRC Fellowship in 2006, I spent 10 weeks visiting investigators with four of the projects and observing their practice.
30
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
relationships. For example, the research team found resources that enabled them to travel together to France to visit agricultural settings where the unique biodiversity attributes of place contribute to the valorization of particular (or typical) products. As described to me by members of the research team, there were social and intellectual benefits in terms of sharing informal downtime on long train rides, eating out together as a way to probe assumptions about food, and making sense of the French ‘context’ through a common ‘foreigner’ experience. The opportunity to spend time in a topically relevant, but non-British and non-academic environment allowed interdisciplinary research partners to see each other (and themselves in interaction) as other than disciplinary cogs in the academic machine. This research team also recognized the challenge in their interdisciplinary enterprise, including the most basic disciplinary-inflected assumptions about their object of study – food products from animals. Shortly after I left, they planned a team ‘retreat’ session to work specifically on the interdisciplinary aspects of their research process. Among the plans were to put a large cut of meat in the middle of a table around which they all would sit. They would then speak in turn about their respective perceptions of that meat – what it was, what it represented, how it should be used. While this may sound like a rather novel research encounter session, it can be seen as a serious effort to bring their different disciplinary assumptions, ontological readings and epistemological bents into more explicit conversation. Such an exercise demonstrates the partiality of disciplinary knowledge and also new openings for understanding the larger system. Interdisciplinarity and Sustainable Food Systems Practice Incorporating knowledge and concerns of non-academic stakeholders is another way interdisciplinary research can improve understanding of the food system and create possibilities for change. Concerns for accountability, legitimacy and relevance have helped to create openings for including more non-academic stakeholders in the research process (Lowe and Phillipson 2006). Non-academic stakeholders from farmers to consumers may offer edifying definitions of the ‘research problem’ or highlight complexities or contingencies in the system that researchers have overlooked. To posit interdisciplinarity as including partners outside formal academic disciplines throws down the gauntlet to those who see research as the preserve of the academy. It may be jarring, given academic and disciplinary training, and risky, given the structure of rewards and incentives in the academy. But for many, this aspect of interdisciplinarity will be invigorating and consistent with commitments to ‘real-world’ application.
See Buller (forthcoming) for the principal investigator’s own more recent account of how the research group experienced and enlivened interdisciplinary process by considering the representation, translation and mediation of two ‘intermediate objects’ crucial to the research – grass and sheep.
Conceptualizing and Creating Sustainable Food Systems
31
I could highlight several compelling examples of stakeholder engagement undertaken by the RELU research projects I observed in the UK. Instead, to bring in a North American example, I’ll point to the less formalized, but still notable efforts recently made by some US food systems researchers within our land grant university system, who have participated in interdisciplinary ‘multi-state research projects’ set up by the US Department of Agriculture. The USDA’s Multi-state Projects are governed by the Hatch Act of 1888, which established agricultural experiment stations in each state to conduct research to support and strengthen the nation’s then developing agricultural sector. The mandate has broadened over the years to address environment and natural resources, food and nutrition, family and youth, and rural community development. USDA intends that these Multi-State Research funds encourage cross-state collaborations on critical, often emerging issues that are of high national or regional priority. Specific Multi-state Projects frequently begin with stakeholder groups and concerned faculty or staff at particular land grant universities who have identified problems, potentially also of concern in other states, that would benefit from interdisciplinary research (Lund et al. 2004). The projects bring together researchers working on some specific problem concerning food systems, agriculture and/or environment. They are not generally as deliberate or reflexive about interdisciplinary research, and certainly not as well funded, as the RELU research projects in the UK. However, the US model does create durable communities of research interest, where researchers across disciplines and states commit to conversation and coordination, sharing of research protocols and results toward a common purpose. I participated for 10 years in two related and now concluded projects addressing the development of local food systems in a globalizing environment. I am now participating in another that investigates the opportunities and barriers for mid-scale values-based food chains. In both cases, a noteworthy feature of the research project has been commitment to non-academic stakeholder input, participation and partnership. The local food systems project obtained foundation monies early on to bring food system activists and practitioners to our annual meeting for discussion about the information and research needs they saw. The session was enormously productive for the academics in terms of refocusing research questions and illuminating unseen issues. It also produced several humbling moments. Researcher jargon, the non-academics respectfully submitted, got in the way. Some of what we researchers saw as brilliant, career-advancing theoretical work brought yawns from the activists and practitioners, who wanted marketing information and policy reforms, as well as locally appropriate and at that time unavailable information on varieties, breeds, processing, storage and handling that could better serve emerging local food systems. Nonetheless, partnerships emerged from this session and ongoing interactions. In a book that resulted from the project, non-academic partners collaborated on several of the chapters (see Hinrichs and Lyson 2007). Interdisciplinarity in sustainable food systems practice, however, is not a simple story of everyone happily holding hands. As Harriet Friedmann notes
32
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
in this volume, discussing the collaboration between the University of Toronto and Local Food Plus, productive relationships grow, sometimes slowly, from a history of interaction and receptivity to organizational learning. Nonetheless, some researchers may wrestle with issues of who is steering the work, given rewards and incentives structures of the academy alluded to earlier. And some non-academic researchers may chafe with the slowness of results, or results that question cherished programmatic agendas. Interdisciplinary partnerships take work to nurture and sustain. They offer encouraging possibilities, though no panacea, for advancing sustainable food systems practice. Conclusion We do need to imagine sustainable food systems, to consider possibilities we’ve not yet seen, reflect on the options for getting there, and learn from our designs and our accidents. Ultimately, there can be no ironclad, all-purpose definition of ‘sustainable food systems’. While environmental integrity, economic viability and social equity are likely part of the mix, sustainable food systems in the making are perhaps more tellingly characterized by places of creative tension, including the emergent and provisional knowledge, the inevitability of ‘tradeoffs ‘ that may not be easy or obvious, and the ongoing significance of power and politics. Because sustainability is a process, rather than an endpoint, a tightly drawn definition is not only difficult, but undesirable. Sustainability may look different, depending on how we draw boundaries on the system of interest and what kind of blinders we wear or successfully remove in studying that system. Our success in conceptualizing and creating more sustainable food systems will also depend on new experimentation and continued reflection about the place of interdisciplinarity in this important work. References Allen, P. (ed.) 1993. Food for the Future: Conditions and Contradictions of Sustainability. New York: John Wiley and Sons. Allen, P. 2004. Together at the Table: Sustainability and Sustenance in the American Agrifood System. University Park, PA: Penn State University Press. Bell, M. 2005. The vitality of difference: Systems theory, the environment and the ghost of Parsons. Society and Natural Resources18: 471-478. Bell, M. 2008. Shifting agrifood systems: A comment. GeoJournal 73: 83-85. Bell, S. and Morse, S. 1999. Sustainability Indicators: Measuring the Immeasurable. London: Earthscan. Blay-Palmer, A. 2008. Food Fears: From Industrial to Sustainable Food Systems. Aldershot: Ashgate.
Conceptualizing and Creating Sustainable Food Systems
33
Born, B. and Purcell, M. 2006. Avoiding the local trap: Scale and food systems in planning research. Journal of Planning Education and Research 26: 195-207. Brand, R. and Karvonen. A. 2007. The ecosystem of expertise: Complementary knowledges for sustainable development. Sustainability: Science, Practice and Policy 3(1): 1-11 (available on-line at: http://ejournal.nbii.org). Buller, H. (forthcoming) The lively process of interdisciplinarity. Area [doi: 10.1111/j.1475-4762.2008.00856.x]. Buttel, F. 2006. Sustaining the unsustainable: Agro-food systems and the environment in the modern world. In Cloke et al.: 213-229. Chambers, R. 2009. Practising what we preach? ID Viewpoints 21 (July). (available on-line at: http://www.id21.org/viewpoints/PDFs/ChScoones.pdf ). Cloke, P., Marsden, T. and Mooney, P. (eds) 2006. The Handbook of Rural Studies Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Dahlberg, K. 1993. Regenerative food systems: Broadening the scope and agenda of sustainability. In Allen: 75-102. Drummond, I. and Marsden, T. 1999. The Condition of Sustainability. London and New York: Routledge. Dryzek, J. 2005. The Politics of the Earth: Environmental Discourse (2nd ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press. Edwards-Jones, G., Mila I., Canals, L., Hounsome, N., Truninger, M., Koerber, G., Hounsome, B. 2008. Testing the assertion that ‘local food is best’: The challenges of an evidence based approach. Trends in Food Science and Technology 19(5): 265-274. Feenstra, G. 2002. Creating spaces for sustainable food systems. Lessons from the field. Agriculture and Human Values 19: 99-106. Giampietro, M. 2004. Multi-scale Integrated Analysis of Agroecosystems. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. Gibson, R. 2005. Sustainability Assessment: Criteria and Processes. London: Earthscan. Guthman, J. 2008. Thinking inside the neoliberal box: The micro-politics of agrofood philanthropy. Geoforum 39(3): 1171-1183. Heiskanen, E., Kivisaari, S., Lovio, R. and Mickwitz, P. (forthcoming) Designed to travel: Transition management encounters environmental and innovation policy histories in Finland. Policy Sciences [doi: 10.1007/s11077-009-90942]. Heller, M. and Keoleian, G. 2003. Assessing the sustainability of the US food system: A life cycle perspective. Agricultural Systems 76: 1007-1041. Hinrichs, C. 2003. The practice and politics of food system localization. Journal of Rural Studies 19: 33-45. Hinrichs, C. 2008. Interdisciplinarity and boundary work: Challenges and opportunities for agrifood studies. Agriculture and Human Values 25(2): 209213.
34
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
Hinrichs, C. and Allen, P. 2008. Selective patronage and social justice: Local food consumer campaigns in historical context. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 21: 329-352. Hinrichs, C. and Lyson, T. (eds). 2007. Remaking the North American Food System: Strategies for Sustainability. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press. Kirschenmann, F. 2008. Food as relationship. Journal of Hunger and Environmental Nutrition 3(2): 106-121. Kloppenburg, J., Lezberg, S., DeMaster, K., Stevenson, G. and Hendrickson, J. 2000. Tasting food, tasting sustainability: Defining the attributes of an alternative food system with competent, ordinary people. Human Organization 59(2): 177-186. Lowe, P. and Phillipson, J. 2006. Reflexive interdisciplinary research: The making of a research programme on the rural economy and land use. Journal of Agricultural Economics 57(2): 165-184. Lowe, P., Phillipson, J. and Lee, R. 2008. Socio-technical innovation for sustainable food chains: Roles for social science. Trends in Food Science and Technology 19: 226-233. Lund, D., Fretz, T., Harrington, M. and Young, E. 2004. Multistate Research Fund: A Research Program that Promotes Relevance, Excellence and Accountability (available online at: www.agnr.umd.edu/users/NERA/LandGrant/ MultistateR esearchFund%20Article11-09-2004.pdf) Mariola, M. 2008. The local industrial complex? Questioning the link between local foods and energy use. Agriculture and Human Values 25: 193-196. Maye, D., Holloway, L. and Kneafsey, M. (eds). 2007. Alternative Food Geographies: Representation and Practice. Oxford: Elsevier. McMichael, P. 2000. The power of food. Agriculture and Human Values 17(1): 21-33. Morgan, K., Marsden, T. and Murdoch, J. 2006. Worlds of Food: Place, Power and Provenance in the Food Chain. Oxford: Oxford University Press. O’Riordan, T. and Church, C. 2001. Synthesis and context. O’Riordan: 3-24. O’Riordan (ed.) 2001. Globalism, Localism and Identity: Fresh Perspectives on the Transition to Sustainability. London: Earthscan. Pretty, J. 1998. Supportive policies and practice for scaling up sustainable agriculture. In Röling and Wagermakers: 23-45. Redclift, M. 2005. Sustainable development (1987-2005): An oxymoron comes of age. Sustainable Development 13(4): 212-227. Röling, N. and Wagermakers, M. (eds) 1998. Facilitating Sustainable Agriculture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Schreck, A., Getz, C., and Feenstra, G. 2006. Social sustainability, farm labor and organic agriculture: Findings from an exploratory analysis. Agriculture and Human Values 23: 439-449. Scoones, I. 1998. Sustainable Rural Livelihoods: A Framework for Analysis. Institute for Development Studies Working Paper #72. University of Sussex.
Conceptualizing and Creating Sustainable Food Systems
35
Selfa, T. and Qazi, J. 2005. Place, taste or face-to-face? Understanding producerconsumer networks in ‘local’ food systems in Washington State. Agriculture and Human Values 22: 451-464. Shove, E. and Walker, G. 2007. Caution! Transitions ahead: Politics, practice and sustainable transition management. Environment and Planning A 39: 763-770. Sundkvist, A, Milestad, R. and Jansson, A. 2005. On the importance of tightening feedback loops for sustainable development of food systems. Food Policy 30: 224-239. Tress, B., Tress, G. and Fry, G. 2006. Defining concepts and process of knowledge production in integrative research. Tress et al.: 13-26. Tress, B., Tress, G., Fry, G. and Opdam, P. (eds) 2006. From Landscape Research to Landscape Planning: Aspects of Integration, Education and Application Dordrecht: Springer. Walker, G. and Shove, E. 2007. Ambivalence, sustainability and the governance of socio-technical transitions. Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning 9(3): 213-225. Wright, W. and Middendorf, G. (eds). 2008. The Fight Over Food: Producers, Consumers and Activists Challenge the Global Food System. University Park, PA: Penn State University Press.
This page has been left blank intentionally
Chapter 3
Sustainability: A Tool for Food System Reform? Mustafa Koc
The concept of sustainability has been one of the key alternative food discourses challenging the limitations of the current practices in the agri-food system. Yet, like many other alternative food discourses certain institutionalized interpretations of sustainability have been subverting sustainability into a legitimizing tool to justify current practices. As a concept, recognizing the need for balance among environmental, social and economic priorities, sustainability seem to be particularly vulnerable to the interventions of pro-market visionaries during the neo-liberal era. By looking at some of the mainstream reactions to the global food crisis in 2008, I will argue that sustainability needs to be seen as a discursive tool, concurrently aiming to legitimize and transform the structures and institutional practices of the modern capitalist system. If we exclude foraging societies where the primary focus of human activity has been subsistence, it is not an exaggeration to claim that the modern food system is the most efficient, most productive and most profitable food system humans have had in the last 20,000 years. Despite this efficiency and productivity and despite the huge profits made in a commodified food economy, the modern food system suffers three main problems: unequal access to means of livelihood, concerns about the sustainability of current practices in the agri-food system, and worries about the health and safety of modern foods and dietary practices. These problems affect the quality of life of the majority of the world’s population and raise concerns about global food security in the long term. As a researcher studying discourses of alternative food systems, I find the terms ‘food security’, ‘food sovereignty’ or ‘sustainability’ only useful as discursive tools to identify problems with current practices, and for describing an ideal state that may change over time. In this chapter, I will focus my attention on my reservations with the particular interpretations of sustainability, but most of my criticism may apply equally to other ‘alternative food discourses’ such as ‘food security’. My first concern has to do with conceptual clarity. Similar to many other ‘alternative discourses of food’ such as food security, food sovereignty, or food democracy, sustainability has been a vague concept defining a condition that changes depending on the political and ideological perspective of the user. In a way, it can be argued that there are multiple competing and often contradictory
38
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
definitions of sustainability. Compare the definition of sustainability by the Conference Board of Canada ‘“as strategy of choice” for Canadian corporations to promote a better bottom line and long-term prosperity’ (cited in Sumner 2007: 86) with Mendes’ (2007) who talks about ‘a “just and sustainable food system” … as one in which food production, processing, distribution, consumption and recycling are integrated to enhance the environmental, economic, social and nutritional health of a particular place’ (Mendes 2007: 98). In this sense, sustainability needs to be seen not as an objective condition, but as a discourse that can imply different goals depending on the political, ideological or paradigmatic approach one may take (Owens 2003). Talking about sustainability of the modern food system that has systematically encouraged destruction of rural livelihoods while turning millions of people into urban consumers suffering from either malnutrition, eating disorders, or obesity should be a seen as an alarming tendency rather than a societal objective. Development, as we currently understand and practice it, destroys the environment and social forms and should be problematized not legitimized. Sifting through the pages of Food Sustainability: A Guide to Private Sector Action (2008), a document prepared in collaboration with a number of UN and Breton Woods institutions in response to the food price crisis of 2008, one can empathize with the conservative columnist Terence Corcoran: We are now by all accounts in the midst of a global food crisis: key grain prices were up 40% to 130% in the last year, people are protesting and hardship is mounting. But it could soon be worse. Governments and agencies all over the world are gearing up for a global ‘New Deal’ on agriculture policy to solve the food crisis, which means the people who brought us the food crisis are the same people who now want to fix it [my emphasis]. (Corcoran, 2008)
A cursory look at some of the recommendations of the UN report demonstrate that what is being defined as food sustainability is nothing but an intensification of the existing commodity relations that are responsible for the problems that created poverty and hunger in the first place: Investing and improving access to agricultural inputs such as locally adapted seeds, fertilizer and pesticides … Strengthening market linkages and integrating local producers and smallholder farmers into supply chains...Engaging in policy dialogues with stake holders to ensure that the development of economic, regulatory and administrative policies that address the concerns of the private sector, and contribute to better functioning markets. (UN 2008: 5)
As we can see from the above suggestions, in its conservative use, the sustainability discourse serves as a legitimizing ideology to justify commodification,
Sustainability: A Tool for Food System Reform?
39
industrialization, and globalization of the agri-food system (Cleaver 1997). Whether this was due to a deliberate neo-liberal attempt to subvert the sustainability agenda, or to reformist efforts to offer sustainable alternatives to the dominant market forces in a language that they can relate to, by not challenging the dominant structures and institutional practices, sustainability discourse loses its power to transform and instead turns into a legitimizing ideology. In its liberal version, the sustainability discourse identifies structural problems of the market economy as ‘market failures’ that need to be remedied with proper policy initiatives. This view gets further exaggerated by neo-liberal discourse that identifies union politics, environmental regulations, and social programs as price distortions. In neo-liberal discourse, privatization and deregulation become crucial practices for sustainable and fiscally responsible development. Since the early 1980s, as a result of the neo-liberal reforms, the gap between the rich and poor widened globally (Koc and Dahlberg 1999). A recent study of global inequalities reported that the richest 10% of adults accounted for 85% of the world total while the bottom half of the world’s adult population owned barely 1% of global wealth (Davies et al. 2008: 3). Globally, there are now over one billion people suffering from hunger and malnutrition, and almost all of these individuals are either producers themselves or descendents of producers who lost their capacity to produce livelihoods on their land in the last few hundred years. The United Nations Development Program estimated that 2.6 billion people survive on less than US$2 a day (UNDP 2008). According to the World Bank figures, the wealthiest 20% of the world population accounted for 76.6% of total private consumption while the poorest fifth accounted for just 1.5% in 2005 (World Bank 2008). The poorest 40% of the world’s population accounts for 5% of global income while the richest 20% accounts for threequarters (World Bank 2008). In addition to social and geographic inequalities in terms of income, wealth and consumption patterns between the North and the South, and between the poor and the rich, there are inequalities in terms of market power that effect livelihoods of the great majority of the worlds population. Neoliberal reforms created the optimum conditions for intensification of corporate concentration (Qualman 2007, Winson 1993). For example, in the US, in beef packing, control of the top four firms increased from 72% in 1990 to 83.5% in 2006. In pork packing, these figures jumped from 37% in 1986 to 66% in 2006. Likewise in broilers, the top four firm shares jumped from 35% in 1986 to 58.5% in 2006 where the top two, Pilgrim’s Pride and Tyson, controlled 47% of the market (Hendrickson and Heffernan 2007). High levels of concentration and vertical integration can also be observed in different sectors of the food system such as seeds, agro-chemicals and retailing, affecting producers and consumers alike. The advantages of the modern food system are unevenly distributed wherein the inequalities are not due to market failure but rather systemic problems created by the current structures of the market economy (Friedmann 1993). One wonders
40
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
about the sincerity of sustainability discourses that would seek ways to protect these structures instead of dismantling them. Food Crisis: Stability as Sustainability In recent years, where blatant violations of human rights have been justified as fiscal prudence and national security, and sustainability subsumed under free market ideology, there was nothing surprising about the food crisis of 2008. It was only a few years ago, when an international consensus to reduce hunger by half by the year 2015 was reached at the World Food Summit (WFS) in 1996 (Koc et al. 2008). The Rome Declaration on World Food Security and the WFS Plan of Action were reading sustainability manifestos identifying ‘sustainable food security for all’, ‘sustainable progress in poverty eradication’, ‘sustainable agriculture, fisheries, forestry and rural development’, and ‘sustainable management of natural resources’ as prime objectives. All of these required ‘further large increases in world food production’ while pursuing ‘food trade and overall trade policies’ and ‘technology transfer consistent with international trade rules’ of course ‘through the sustainable management of natural resources’. What accompanied this commitment to sustainability was also a commitment to stability. ‘Stable and enabling political, social and economic environment’, ‘stable food supplies’, ‘stable employment’, and ‘stable funding from private and public, domestic and foreign sources.’ As the WFS Plan of Action stated ‘A peaceful and stable environment in every country is a fundamental condition for the attainment of sustainable food security’ (FAO 1996: Action #3). Yet, only six years later at the WFS-Five Years Later meeting in 2002, the FAO would announce that the commitment to reduce the amount of global hunger by half by 2015 was no longer attainable. The distributionist anti-poverty approach of WFS reformism was effectively conceiving of sustainability as stability by not offering any structural or institutional changes in the current practices of the food system. When the hungry masses went out to the streets in several Third World cities protesting rising food prices, there was little reason for the world leaders, the UN experts or the media to be surprised. Of course, multi-factor explanations were offered ranging from the rising price of oil, to the increasing consumption of meat in middle class India and China, to the demand as a result of gasohol in response to sustainability concerns. But, following the news trail, one can wonder if the real concern was sustainability or food security, or the political stability of the regimes that continued to feed the world with their cheap labour. As a recent document produced by the Human Security Unit at the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affair (2009: 1) states, [f]ood insecurity is inherently interlinked with political security, socio-economic development, human rights and the environment. Consequently, a sharp rise in
Sustainability: A Tool for Food System Reform?
41
food prices can have significant impact on human security reaching far beyond the immediate effects of hunger and malnutrition.
In his response to the crisis caused by rising food prices, the UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon warned that the ‘international community will also need to take urgent and concerted action in order to avoid the larger political and security implications of this growing crisis’ (UN Radio 2008). Similar concerns were raised by John Holmes, Undersecretary General for Humanitarian Affairs and Emergency Relief Coordinator of the UN, ‘[r]iots today mean you need a solution tomorrow’ and ‘[g]overnments with no ‘policy space’ and under pressure from organized discontent in urban centres ‘is not likely to be the best decision’ in trying to solve the problem’ (Surk 2008). As an editorial in Time magazine summarized, The idea of the starving masses driven by their desperation to take to the streets and overthrow the ancien regime has seemed impossibly quaint since capitalism triumphed so decisively in the Cold War. … And yet, the headlines of the past month suggest that skyrocketing food prices are threatening the stability of a growing number of governments around the world. (Karon 2008)
Yet, the UN report on ‘Food Sustainability’ (2008) in response to the food crisis would argue that ‘a precondition for food sustainability is a stable climate offering suitable conditions for agriculture and animal farming’ (UN 2008: 14). What was offered as ‘food sustainability’ was institutional legitimization of current practices, ensuring a public that ‘[o]ver the course of time, fair market pricing and understanding of supply and demand will help the poor become better business people and enhance their sustainability in terms of food production and livelihood’ (UN 2008: 37). Democratizing Institutions and Food Democracy Sustainability is a crucial discursive tool in the struggle for a democratic and just food system, as it is quite simply one of the most effective tools to demonstrate the irrationality of the food system (Allen 2004, Feenstra 2002, Heintzman and Solomon 2004, Schlosser 2001), capital’s inability to deal with food provisioning and rational agriculture (Albritton 2009), and structural nature of the problems, such as the farm crisis, hunger and obesity (Blay-Palmer 2008, Roberts 2008, Simontacchi 2001, Riches 1997). Yet, by aiming to offer a balance among social, economic and environmental priorities, sustainability discourse can become open to more conservative interpretations that turn it into a legitimizing tool of the status quo. In our effort to use sustainability as a discursive tool for a democratic and just food system, we need to go beyond developing objective measures, indicators and indices of sustainability and instead ‘transform the premises and ideology of sustainability discourse’ (Allen 1993: 14) to one that ‘proscribes the exploitation
42
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
of people as well as that of nature’ and ‘working toward emancipatory social strategies while at the same time building on the work already done to learn about nature-constrained boundaries on social possibilities’ (Allen 1993:14). There is no doubt that the modern food system has been one of the most efficient, productive and profitable human endeavors ever. Yet, as we are entering into a new century, we have increasing concerns about hunger and malnutrition, about sustainability of the agri-food system, and the health and safety of foods we consume. As the current accumulation and fiscal crisis of the state deepens, we are likely to see some of these problems deepen as well (Koc 2009). This is the time for re-evaluating our current practices, learning from our strengths and also weaknesses. An honest re-evaluation necessitates identifying how the structures of the modern society and the food system contribute to these problems. Change, however, cannot come without democratization and an opening up of space for individual creativity and social innovation in existing institutions. Using the concept of ‘food democracy’ Lang (2007) emphasizes the need for democratizing the food system. This means looking at ‘food as a locus of the democratic process... to ensure that all have access to affordable, decent healthenhancing food’. This means going beyond ‘adequacy of supply and stresses decency and social justice in the food system wages, working conditions and internal equity. Against food democracy, we can posit ‘food control’, using food as vehicle of control’ (Lang 2007: 12-13). In a similar way, Busch (2000: 3) defends the need for deepening ‘our practice of democracy in the political sphere by making it more participatory and deliberative’. Busch proposes ‘networks of democracy’ that create ‘individual autonomy while defining and reaching for the common good, in a manner that embeds moral responsibility’ while informed individuals can participate in the decision making process and political debates (2000: 186-87). This notion of democratization may sound redundant for those who see democracy simply as an electoral process. Yet, in the first decade of the 21st century, we have already observed disastrous examples of political and corporate irresponsibility that have brought the world economy to near collapse, widened income gaps among the haves and have-nots, and led to blatant violation of basic human rights and dignities, in addition to declining social citizenship. To counter neo-liberal assault on democratic citizenship, we need to demand democratization of all social institutions in modern society including the science, the state, the market, the media, the education, and the civil society. For sustainability of any social system, we need to create spaces for public participation and structures to embed public responsibility and vision of public good in all institutions. Lyson (2004) and DuPuis (2006) point out the importance of alternative institutional practices and governance as part of their sustainability agenda. As Lyson’s ‘civic agriculture’ or DuPuis’ ‘civic markets’ concepts demonstrate, no matter how small they might be, what makes the community based solutions so significant is that they not only offer alternatives against the socially, economically and environmentally destructive practices of conventional agriculture and markets, but
Sustainability: A Tool for Food System Reform?
43
also set examples of alternative ways for democratic engagement and governance structures (Hinrichs 2003, 2000). Alternative discourses of food, such as ‘food security’, ‘food democracy’, ‘food sovereignty’ or sustainability are important tools in this democratic engagement for transforming the food system and existing social institutions and practices. However, we need to see them as evolving societal goals that can have multiple different interpretations, and as vulnerable to becoming legitimizing tools in the arsenal of the dominant forces. For this reason, rather than defining them as ‘ends’ that can be reduced to a number of indicators, we need to open them to a critical scrutiny and define them as means but not ends for a more democratic society. References Albritton, R. 2009. Let Them Eat Junk: How Capitalism Creates Hunger and Obesity. New York: Pluto Press. Allen, P. 2004. Together at the Table: Sustainability and Sustenance in the American Agrifood System. University Park, Penna.: Pennsylvania State University Press. Allen P. (ed.) 1993. Food for the Future: Conditions and Contradictions of Sustainability. New York: Wiley. Blay-Palmer, A. 2008. Food Fears: From Industrial to Sustainable Food Systems. Aldershot: Ashgate. Busch, L. 2000. The Eclipse of Morality: Science, State, and Market. New York: Aldine de Gruyter. Cleaver, H. 1997. Nature, neoliberalism and sustainable development: Between Charybdis and Scylla. Paper prepared for the 4th Ecology Meeting Economy and Ecology held by the Instituto Piaget, Viseu, Portugal, April 17-19, 1997. Available at http://libcom.org/library/nature-neoliberalism-sustainabledevelopment-cleaver [accessed September 14, 2009]. Corcoran, T. 2008. Who caused the world food crisis? National Post. April 8. Accessed online July 21 2010 at: http://www.nationalpost.com/opinion/ columnists/story.html?id=428913. Davies, J., Sandstrom, S., Shorrocks, A. and Wolff, E. 2008. The world distribution of household wealth. Discussion Paper No. 2008/03, UNUWIDER. Available at http://www.wider.unu.edu/research/2006-2007/20062007-1/wider-wdhw-launch-5-12-2006/wider-wdhw-report-5-12-2006.pdf [accessed August 21, 2007]. Denis, A. and Kalekin Fishman, D. (eds) The New ISA Handbook in Contemporary International Sociology: Conflict, Competition, Cooperation. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. DuPuis, E. 2006. Civic markets: Alternative value chain governance as civic engagement. Online. Crop Management doi:10.1094/CM-2006-0921-09RV.
44
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
Heintzman A. and Solomon E. (eds) 2004. Feeding the Future: From Fat to Famine, How to Solve the World’s Food Crises. Toronto: House of Anansi Press. FAO 1996. Rome declaration on world food security and world food summit plan of action. Rome: FAO available at http://www.fao.org/docrep/003/w3613e/ w3613e00.HTM (accessed August 14 2009). Feenstra, G. 2002. Creating space for sustainable food systems: Lessons from the field. Agriculture and Human Values 19(2): 99–106. Friedman H. 1993. The political economy of food: A global crisis. New Left Review. I/197:29-57. Hendrickson, M. and Heffernan, W. 2007. An Overview of Concentration in the Food System. Available at http://www.foodcircles.missouri.edu/leopold/index. htm [accessed August 21, 2007] Hinrichs, C. 2003. The practice and politics of food system localization. Journal of Rural Studies 19: 33-45. Hinrichs, C. 2000. Embeddedness and local food systems: Notes on two types of direct agricultural market. Journal of Rural Studies 16: 295-303. Karon, T. 2008. How Hunger Could Topple Regimes. Time Friday, Apr. 11, 2008, available at http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1730107,00.html Koc, M. 2009. Hunger and Plenty: Fragmented Integration in the Global Food System. In Denis et al.: 323-335. Koc, M. and Dahlberg, K. 1999. The restructuring of food systems: Trends and research and policy issues. Agriculture and Human Values, 16(2): 109-16. Koc, M., MacRae R, Bronson K. (eds). 2007. Interdisciplinary Perspectives in Food Studies. Toronto: McGraw-Hill Ryerson. Koc, M., MacRae, R., Desjardins E. and Roberts, W. 2008. Getting civil about food: The interactions between civil society and the state to advance sustainable food systems in Canada. Journal of Hunger & Environmental Nutrition 3(2/3): 122-144. Lang, T. 2007. Food security or food democracy. Pesticides News, 78, 12-16. Lyson, T. 2004. Civic Agriculture: Reconnecting Farm, Food and Community. University Park, PA: Penn State University Press. Mendes, W. 2008. Implementing social and environmental policies in cities: The case of food policy in Vancouver, Canada. Ideas 32 (4): 942-967. Morgan, K., Marsden, T., and Murdoch, J. 2006. Worlds of Food: Place, Power, and Provenance in the Food Chain. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Owens, S. 2003. Is there a meaningful definition of sustainability? Plant Genetic Resoruces 1 : 5-9. Qualman D. 2007. The Farm Crisis and Corporate Profits. In Koc M. et al.: 95-110. Riches, G. (ed.) (1997) First World Hunger: Food Security and Welfare Politics. London: Macmillan. Roberts, W. 2008. The No-nonsense Guide to World Food. Oxford: New Internationalist. Schlosser, E. 2001. Fast Food Nation: The Dark Side of the All-American Meal. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Sustainability: A Tool for Food System Reform?
45
Simontacchi, C. 2001. The Crazy Makers: How the Food Industry is Destroying Our Brains and Harming our Children. New York: Tarcher/Putnam. Sumner, J. 2007. Sustainability and the Civil Commons: Rural Communities in the Age of Globalization. Toronto: University of Toronto Press. Surk, B. 2008. UN: Food riots ’warning sign,’ Toronto Star April 8, 2008 available at, http://www.thestar.com/article/411406#survey. United Nations. 2008. Food Sustainability: A Guide to Private Sector Action, September 2008, UN Global Compact Office available at http://www. unglobalcompact.org/docs/news_events/9.1_news_archives/2008_09_24/ food_sustainability.pdf on September 3, 2009. UNOCHA. 2009. United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs – Human Security Unit. Human Security at the United Nations Newsletter Issue 5, Spring 2009. UN Radio. 2008. UN hosts high-level meeting to tackle growing food crisis. UN Radio 14/04/2008 available at http://www.unmultimedia.org/radio/english/ detail/37265.html. UNDP (United Nations Development Program). 2005. Human Development Report 2005: International Cooperation at a Crossroads: Aid, Trade and Security in an Unequal World. New York: The United Nations Development Programme. Winson A. 1993. The Intimate Commodity: Food and the Development of the Agri-Industrial Complex in Canada. Toronto: Garamond Press. World Bank. 2008. World development report 2008: Agriculture for development. Washington, DC: World Bank.
This page has been left blank intentionally
Part 2 Inclusion and Exclusion in Sustainable Food Systems
This page has been left blank intentionally
Chapter 4
Greening the Realm: Sustainable Food Chains and the Public Plate Kevin Morgan
Introduction Recent debates on the state in urban and regional studies have paid too much attention to spatial scale and too little to organizational capacity. With an increasingly complex multi-level polity emerging in the European Union, embracing sub-national as well as national and supra-national political scales, it is hardly surprising that the spatial structure of the state has commanded so much attention of late (Brenner 2004). However, in this article I want to suggest that the state’s organizational capacity – its capacity to regulate the economy, deliver public services and procure goods and services – needs to be better understood if we are to arrive at a finer appreciation of the scope for, and the limits to sustainable development in advanced capitalist countries. Sustainable development, it is always worth stressing, needs to be understood in a multiple sense to include the social, economic and environmental dimensions of development because all too often it is reduced to the third of these dimensions. As we will see later, this narrow and emasculated conception of sustainable development is becoming all too apparent in the UK, where it is justified by the claim that the environmental dimension is easier to measure and manage compared to the social and economic dimensions. It is also the case, however, that the environmental side is perceived, by governments and corporations alike, as less threatening and more easily contained than the social and economic dimensions, which open up questions of social justice and economic democracy that constitute more of a challenge to the status quo. In other words ‘greening the realm’ can be understood in one of two ways. In a minimalist sense it refers to the narrow environmentalist interpretation of sustainability identified above. On a broader interpretation, it also refers to the political project of creating a ‘green state’, which has been defined in generic terms as ‘a democratic state whose regulatory ideals and democratic procedures are informed by ecological democracy rather than liberal democracy’ (Eckersley 2004: 2). In substantive terms, this means a state that accords parity of esteem to This chapter first appeared as a journal article in 2008 in Regional Studies, 42(9), 1237-1250. Reprinted with kind permission from Taylor & Francis.
50
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
all three dimensions of sustainable development, a state that seeks to implement sustainable practices not merely in the public sector but also, through the powers at its disposal, in the private sector as well. The very possibility of a ‘green state’ under capitalist conditions is, of course, open to question; indeed, it is the subject of a lively debate between ecologicallyminded Marxists (Hay 1996, O’Connor, 1998) and ecological modernizers (Hajer 1995, Eckersley 2004). While the former tend to argue that ‘sustainable capitalism’ is something of an oxymoron, the latter contend that the prospects for ‘green growth’ under capitalism may be better than the critics allow, even if some of them concede that a deeply green democratic state would be tantamount to ‘a postcapitalist state’ (Eckersley 2004: 84). The prospects for sustainable development under capitalism will clearly also vary from one country to another, depending on the strength of the ecological coalition in the nation-state. Where there is a strong ecological coalition, it is more likely that the state will be pressured to exercise its powers in favour of sustainable development. The key powers of the state – particularly its power to levy differential taxes, its power to regulate and its power to deploy its procurement budget – can be used to favour some activities over others. Potentially, this amounts to a powerful set of incentives and sanctions to change the behaviour of the public, private and third sectors, as well as the behaviour of individuals and households. Of all the powers at the disposal of the UK state, I shall argue that none has been as neglected as the power of public procurement. This is more surprising than it may seem because the public procurement budget amounts to some £150 billion per annum, and this constitutes an incredibly powerful mechanism for the state to promote sustainable practices throughout the national economy. As we will see, however, this power is more apparent than real because it is fragmented across hundreds of functionally distinct bodies which have little or no incentive to collaborate for common ends. The state’s organizational capacity to engage in green or sustainable public procurement is further compromised by a lack of skills, which means that procurement managers have neither the competence nor the confidence to play a catalytic role in greening the realm – certainly not in the stronger sense discussed above. There are exceptions to this generalization of course, and the case of public food provisioning may be one of them. The public provision of food – in schools, hospitals, care homes, prisons and so forth – is arguably a litmus test of the state’s commitment to sustainable development in the fullest sense of the term because, depending on the nature of the provisioning, it can address social justice, human health, economic development and environmental goals, the main domains of sustainable development. Food is an especially good prism through which to explore these domains because agri-food has a unique status. Although it is invariably treated as one ‘sector’ or ‘industry’ among others, food is actually unlike any other for the simple reason that we ingest its output. Accessing the products of the agri-food ‘sector’ is therefore essential to human health and well being in a way that access to other products is not, which is why
Greening The Realm: Sustainable Food Chains And The Public Plate
51
the moral economy aspects of food are so important (Morgan et al, 2006). The concept of the moral economy has re-emerged in recent years, partly as a response to the excessive utilitarianism of mainstream economics and partly as a vehicle for academics and activists to address the normative issues that they consider to be intrinsically significant (such as health, education and well being), rather than merely instrumentally significant (such as income). According to Andrew Sayer, one of the leading social theorists in this field, the moral economy, embodies norms and sentiments regarding the responsibilities and rights of individuals and institutions with respect to others. These norms and sentiments go beyond matters of justice and equality, to conceptions of the good, for example regarding needs and the ends of economic activity. They might also be extended further to include the treatment of the environment (Sayer 2000: 79).
The moral economy of food is nowhere more apparent than in the case of food provisioning through public canteens, or what I call the ‘public plate’ for short, because it is in these prosaic settings that we find the most vulnerable consumers of all – namely pupils, patients, pensioners and prisoners. The nutritional quality of public food, its organoleptic properties (smell, taste, texture) and its provenance (how and where it is produced) can be used as an indicator of the moral economy of food as well as of the sustainability of the food chain itself. To explore these issues of moral economy and sustainability I shall focus on the recent reform of the school food service in the UK. The barriers to the sustainable procurement of school food are similar in many ways to the barriers facing green procurement more generally in the UK, therefore it is necessary to have some understanding as to why this function of the British state has been so poorly deployed for so long. The Fallible Client: The Paradox of UK Public Procurement One of the puzzling paradoxes of economic policy in the UK is that successive governments have shown an avid interest in areas (like money markets) where they have little or no control, but have virtually ignored other areas (like public procurement) where they enjoy almost complete control. Perhaps not surprisingly, therefore, the history of public procurement in the UK is littered with costly and embarrassing delays, especially in the defence, information technology and civil engineering sectors. Far from being a recent phenomenon, the fallibility of the British state in the public procurement arena predates iconic failures like the Millennium Dome, raising deeper questions about the competence of the state to act as an intelligent customer. Long forgotten examples of problematic public procurement projects would include the System X digital exchange and the Advanced Passenger Train, both of which were commercial disappointments despite their innovative technical qualities. In contrast to France, where public procurement power was successfully deployed to modernize key sectors of the economy, particularly mass
52
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
transit, energy and telecommunications, the history of public procurement in the UK is a story of untapped potential (Cawson et al. 1990). The fallibility of the British state as a customer is nowhere more evident than in the defence sector, where the Ministry of Defence (MoD) is ostensibly in charge of the procurement process. The scale of the problems in this sector is without precedent in the UK, even if smaller fiascos like the Dome continue to haunt the popular imagination. In its latest progress report, the National Audit Office disclosed that the largest twenty weapons projects are currently overspent by almost £3 billion and, taken together, they have been delayed by a total of 36 years. Such are the delays and cost overruns on the notorious Eurofighter aircraft (now called Typhoon), that the current cost is no longer even published because it is deemed to be ‘commercially sensitive’ (NAO 2006). There is no easy explanation for this lamentable public procurement performance, though the main reasons would have to be sought in some combination of the following: the lack of project management skills at the highest levels of the civil service; a bureaucratic culture which extolled policy design over project delivery; the silo-based structure in Whitehall, which stymied the dissemination of good practice; and the fact that this lack of technical competence is both cause and consequence of a lack of political confidence, rendering civil servants and their masters reluctant to assert public sector priorities over private sector interests (Cawson et al. 1990, House of Commons 2001, Craig 2006: 206). Although it created more problems than it solved, the Thatcherite offensive against the state was partly an attempt to import private sector business skills into the heart of the public sector, a trend that actually intensified under New Labour. Between 1997 and 2005 for example, the Blair governments are estimated to have spent some £10 billion on management consultancy fees. New Labour’s modernization of government agenda is such a bonanza for private consultants that it amounts, in the words of a whistleblower, to the ‘plundering’ of the public sector in which civil servants have ceded too much control to external private sector suppliers on the advice of their internal private sector consultants (Craig 2006). According to this analysis New Labour convinced itself that it needed private sector skills to deliver more effective public services, a skill set that was beyond the ken of the traditional civil service. Here it was merely echoing the words of a senior partner at Ernst and Young, who said ‘the public sector must have access to the skills needed to perform successfully in this more competitive regime: skills more commonly found in the private sector than in public service’ (Craig 2006). A new era in the history of public procurement began in 2000, when the Office of Government Commerce (OGC) was formed to modernize public purchasing and to secure better value for money from government contracts. The creation of the OGC as an office of the Treasury was the main outcome of a major review of civil procurement in central government conducted by Peter Gershon, the first chief executive of the OGC. The Gershon Review of civil procurement exposed a woefully inadequate if not shocking picture:
Greening The Realm: Sustainable Food Chains And The Public Plate
• • • • • •
53
No one really knew how much was being spent by the government on a whole range of products and services The government was not utilizing effectively its position in the market place, for example through leveraging its relationship with suppliers The fragmented approach to procurement meant that there was enormous variations in performance Public procurement was not regarded as a core competence and its professional status within government suffered as a result There was plenty of scope for government to become a more intelligent and professional customer, but this potential was not being tapped There were major value for money improvements to be gained simply by doing things better (Gershon 1999)
The modernization programme that followed this catalytic review begged an important question that has never been resolved – should procurement be modernized within an old, cost-cutting business model (doing things better) or does modernization embrace a new, more sustainable value-adding business model (doing better things)? According to Gershon (2001), the modernization and greening of public procurement went hand in hand, as he told a Greening Government Procurement conference, Our attention is firmly focused on value for money – not simply the lowest price. This means looking at quality and whole life costs, including disposal and packaging, which are areas where environmentally friendly products tend to score well...Your task is to work out how to procure environmentally friendly goods while retaining value for money. We should not accept a ‘green premium’ as an inevitable consequence of greening Government procurement.
As we will see later, the notion that the ‘green line’ is synonymous with the ‘bottom line’ in public purchasing decisions has proved to be a profoundly difficult claim to substantiate, despite repeated assurances from Whitehall that there is no conflict between them. What threw this issue into sharper relief was the second Gershon review, which claimed to have identified £21.5 billion in ‘efficiency savings’ that could be made over a three year period, all of which could be reinvested in front line services (HM Treasury 2004). This was doubly attractive to New Labour ministers because it promised to increase investment in public services by cutting civil service bureaucracy and public sector inefficiencies. More than a third of the £21.5 billion ‘efficiency savings’ was scheduled to come from public procurement as a result of buying goods and services more cheaply. One of the main mechanisms for realizing cost savings, according to the review, was through the economies of scale that would be achieved by aggregating demand by cutting local government purchasing centres from some 400 separate local centres to perhaps 10 regional centres or even four national centres. Regional purchasing consortia, along with new ‘toolkits’ to help public sector managers to design value
54
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
for money procurement policies, heralded ‘nothing less than a revolution in the way government does business’ (Timmins 2004). Taken together the Gershon reviews constitute a tipping point, signalling the formative moment when the state ceased to be the naïve and fallible client it had been for much of the post-war period. Belatedly, the strategic potential of procurement was beginning to be recognized at the highest levels of government, an epiphany that occurred in the private sector at least a decade earlier, when firms in the auto and electronics sectors woke up to the fact that strategic sourcing was one of the ‘secrets’ behind the success of Toyota and Nissan (Cooke and Morgan 1996). Although the Gershon reviews acknowledged that value for money should not be confused with low cost, the pressure to realize ‘efficiency savings’ often means that, in practice, these can easily become one and the same thing. What constitutes ‘value for money’ has emerged as the central question in the new politics of public procurement because the challenge of sustainable development is first and foremost a challenge to the conventional ways in which we view and value things. The Ecological Client: The Challenge of Green Procurement The political commitment to sustainable development in the UK began with the 1992 Earth Summit, when the UK government signed up to the UN-sponsored Rio Declaration. The first formal sustainable development strategy appeared in 1994, followed by another in 1997 and a third in 2005, underlining the growing significance of sustainability issues in mainstream British politics. Although there were some ad hoc initiatives in the late 1990s, green public procurement emerged in a systemic way in the UK in 2001 with the formation of the Sustainable Procurement Group in Whitehall, an inter-departmental group created to consider how central government procurement could support sustainable development. DEFRA and the OGC took the lead in this process and, in 2003, they jointly announced the first minimum environmental standards for all new central government contracts, covering such aspects as energy efficiency, recycled content and biodegradability. This was said to be ‘a vital first step’ in putting in place the structures and strategies to support and encourage sustainable procurement (DEFRA 2003b). Like charity, ecological behaviour begins at home and therefore one of the key tests of the political commitment to sustainable development is the sustainability of the Government Estate, the collective term for all government departments and their executive agencies. The Framework for Sustainable Development on the Government Estate began to set targets for central government departments in 2002, though it was not until 2004 that public procurement targets were included. Progress in meeting these targets used to be reported annually in the Sustainable Development in Government (SDiG) report, which was originally complied by government itself. This may help to explain the fact that the 2004 SDiG report was charged with exaggerating the progress that the Government Estate was making with its sustainable development targets (NAO 2005). To overcome
Greening The Realm: Sustainable Food Chains And The Public Plate
55
this conflict of interest, where government was effectively assessing itself, the SDiG report is now compiled and analysed independently by the Sustainable Development Commission (SDC), which has been given a watchdog role in this area. In its first report the SDC used a ‘traffic lights’ analysis to rate progress and it concluded by giving government red marks against performance on waste, water and commitment to sustainable development, and amber warnings against performance on energy, travel, estate management, biodiversity and public procurement (SDC 2005). Central government’s green procurement efforts began by focusing on a small number of products, in particular paper, timber, electrical products and food, where it was believed that some ‘early wins’ could be secured. Of these products, public sector food purchasing has received the most attention, largely because of the unexpected political salience of school food, an issue addressed in section four. In reality central government had begun to focus on public sector food catering long before school food became a cause celebre in 2005. An official inquiry into the future of farming and food, held in the wake of the foot and mouth crisis, concluded by saying that ‘local food’ offered untapped opportunities for hard pressed primary producers to re-connect with their consumers, and it identified public procurement as one of the means to this end (Policy Commission 2002). It was against this political background that the Public Sector Food Procurement Initiative (PSFPI) was launched by DEFRA in 2003. The main aim of the PSFPI is to encourage public sector purchasers to work in concert with farmers, growers and suppliers to ensure that sustainable food is consumed in public canteens. It has five broad objectives: • • • • •
To raise production and process standards To increase tenders from small and local producers To increase consumption of healthy and nutritious food To reduce adverse environmental impacts of production and supply To increase the capacity of small and local suppliers to meet more exacting demand standards. (DEFRA 2003a)
In addition to these broad objectives, the PSFPI aims to promote the demand for organic food; to improve choice for minority ethnic communities; to enhance working conditions for public sector catering staff; to reduce food waste; and to improve the standard of data collection and monitoring. Despite its modest resources, the PSFPI is an innovative and inclusive programme embracing a wide array of very different actors, including central government and local government, public sector purchasing bodies, farmers, food service companies, NGOs and universities. As we will see, there are major barriers to the design and delivery of sustainable food throughout the food chain, from farm to fork. To help overcome these barriers, the PSFPI offers purchasers and suppliers a one-stop shop of guidance, advice and inspiration through a dedicated web site, which includes
56
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
practical projects, model specifications, training, professional contacts and case studies of sustainable food chains. What constitutes a ‘sustainable food chain’ is of course open to debate, but the key feature would surely be the internalization of the costs that are externalized in conventional food chains by, for example, factoring into the equation the effects on human health and the environment of the entire agri-food cycle from farm to fork. This is clearly what DEFRA had in mind when it launched the initiative by highlighting the multi-dimensional nature of public sector food procurement: If we are what we eat, then public sector food purchasers help shape the lives of millions of people. In hospitals, schools, prisons, and canteens around the country, good food helps maintain good health, promote healing rates and improve concentration and behaviour. But sustainable food procurement isn’t just about better nutrition. It’s about where the food comes from, how it’s produced and transported, and where it ends up. It’s about food quality, safety and choice. Most of all, it’s about defining best value in its broadest sense. (DEFRA 2003a: 2)
For the worlds of policy and practice, this statement succinctly captures the multiple benefits of sustainable food chains. However, at the same time it also identifies two of the biggest challenges to their development when it says that sustainable food chains are about ‘where the food comes from’ and most of all about ‘defining best value in its broadest sense’. The following section examines these two issues – value and provenance – in the highly charged political context of school food. Sustainable School Food Chains: The Potential of the Public Plate Having been marginalized in Westminster and Whitehall for more than 20 years, school food was unexpectedly propelled to the top of the political agenda in the UK in 2005, where it became a litmus test of New Labour’s avowed commitment to public health, social justice and sustainable development. In this section I use the school meal service as a prism through which to explore two key issues in the burgeoning debate about sustainable food chains – namely value for money and the geographical provenance of the food. To understand these issues in the context of the school meal service, one needs to appreciate the regulatory worlds in which the service evolved (Morgan 2006). The Regulatory Worlds of School Food The welfare world of collective provision Given the low political prominence of the school food issue in the 1980s and 1990s one would never know that the school food service was once considered to be one of the foundation stones of the British welfare state. But the origins of school food as a national system owe as much to
Greening The Realm: Sustainable Food Chains And The Public Plate
57
warfare as welfare because it was the Boer War, when the poor physical condition of recruits impaired the campaign, that effectively triggered the Education (Provision of Meals) Act of 1906, which gave all local education authorities the power to provide meals free for children who needed them (Passmore and Harris 2004). Although the origins of the welfare era can be traced back to local initiatives in the 1880s, it was the Education Act of 1944 that inaugurated the welfare era of collective provision in the UK as a whole. Among other things the 1944 Act laid a duty on all LEAs to provide school meals and milk in primary and secondary schools; it specified that the price of meals could not exceed the cost of the food; and it established that the school lunch had to be suitable as the main meal of the day and meet mandatory nutritional standards (Sharp 1992). Whatever the limitations of the welfare era, the fact that it would later appear as a ‘golden era’ spoke volumes for what followed it. The neo-liberal world of choice The neo-liberal era was introduced in stages by successive Conservative governments after 1979 and it was predicated on two totemic Tory values – less public spending and more private choice. The neo-liberal era was enshrined in two radical pieces of legislation. The first was the 1980 Education Act, which transformed the school meals service from a compulsory national, subsidized service for all children, to a discretionary local service. The 1980 Act introduced four fundamental changes: it removed the obligation on LEAs to provide school lunches, except for children entitled to free school meals; it removed the obligation for meals to be sold at a fixed price; it eliminated the requirements for the lunches to meet nutritional standards; and it abolished the entitlement to free school milk. These changes, it was claimed, would help to reduce public expenditure. The second piece of neo-liberal legislation was the 1988 Local Government Act, which introduced compulsory competitive tendering (CCT) into public sector catering and other local services. Under the CCT regime, local authorities were obliged to subject their school meals services to outside competition – a requirement that led to a dramatic reduction in costs (Davies 2005). Lower costs carried a cost of their own because CCT triggered a series of profoundly negative changes in the school meals service, notably a lower skilled workforce, a loss of kitchens in schools, and a service ethos deemed to be inimical to healthy eating. Of all the changes wrought by CCT, however, by far the most important was the debasement of the food itself, which was colourfully described by one leading dinner lady as ‘cheap processed muck’ (Orrey 2003). The net effect of this neo-liberal revolution was a consumer-led school meals service where the menu was based on a simple calculation, namely ‘if a food sold well and was profitable, it was provided. If it did not sell, or was not profitable, it was not provided’ (Passmore and Harris 2004). From today’s vantage point, when there is a moral panic about childhood obesity, the neo-liberal era of food policy appears to be a monstrously myopic mistake. In its desire to make short-term public expenditure savings, it actually contributed
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
58
to the problem of unhealthy eating which now costs the public purse many times what was saved by trimming the school meals budget (Morgan 2006). The ecological world of sustainable provision The fact that a radically new school food policy did not appear (in England) until 2006, nine years after New Labour came to power, illustrates the fallacy of thinking that regulatory eras change when governments change. Although the revolution in British school food policy is generally attributed to a celebrity chef’s popular television series in 2005, the real breakthrough came three years earlier in Scotland, where the Scottish Parliament commissioned an expert panel to design a radically new school meals strategy called Hungry for Success (Scottish Executive 2002). Three of the panel’s recommendations would eventually resonate throughout the UK, namely: (i) the need for a whole school approach to school meal reform to ensure that the message of the classroom was echoed in the dining room; (ii) the need for better quality food to be served in schools, and for this to be underwritten by new nutrient-based standards; and (iii) a plea for the school meals service to be seen more as a health service than a commercial service (Scottish Executive 2002). The ripple effect of this Scottish social policy innovation stimulated the campaign for similar reforms in England and Wales, which took place in 2005 and 2006 respectively (SMRP 2005, WAG 2006). Far from being concerned simply with the environment, the ecological world seeks to address one of the core principles of sustainable development – the need to render visible the costs neglected by conventional cost-benefit analysis, where many of the negative costs of the industrial agri-food system have been externalized (Morgan et al. 2006). Because it appeared so much later than its Scottish counterpart, the English report, Turning the Tables, went further in embracing the ecological approach in the sense that it also included the food procurement process, which it said should be ‘consistent with sustainable development principles and schools and caterers should look to local farmers and suppliers for their produce where possible’ (SMRP 2005). The government accepted the main thrust of these recommendations when it made its seminal announcement that a new regulatory regime would come into effect in September 2006 to ensure that: • • • • • •
School lunches are free from low quality meat products, fizzy drinks, crisps and chocolate or other confectionary High quality meat, poultry or oily fish is available on a regular basis Pupils are served a minimum of two portions of fruit and vegetables with every meal Deep-fried items are restricted to no more than two portions in a week Schools and vending providers are required to promote sales of healthy snacks and drinks such as water, milk and fruit juices Schools will be required to raise the bar even higher when more stringent nutrient-based standards – stipulating essential nutrients, vitamins and
Greening The Realm: Sustainable Food Chains And The Public Plate
59
minerals – are introduced in primary schools by September 2008 and in secondary schools by September 2009 (DfES 2006). In political terms, Turning the Tables is arguably the most radical school food policy statement since the founding of the welfare state, not least because it makes the case for a high quality food system in terms of health, educational and behavioural benefits, in contrast to the narrow commercial values of the neoliberal world. In setting new and more exacting regulatory standards the state was in effect fashioning new markets in the public sector for more sustainable products by creating opportunities for local farmers and growers to supply locally-produced fresh produce. Under pressure from health and environmental NGOs, public bodies throughout the world are coming to similar conclusions about the need for more sustainable food chains. However, such chains face a number of significant barriers, not least the higher costs of better quality food and EU regulations that forbid the explicit purchasing of local food. Accounting for sustainability: From low cost to best value A ‘cheap food’ culture was, as we have seen, systematically introduced into the school meal service in the 1980s, when local authorities were exposed to CCT regulations that spawned a radically new cost-cutting mindset. Although New Labour jettisoned some of the cruder, more debilitating features of the CCT regime when it introduced its own Best Value regime, the ‘cheap food’ culture lingered on, leaving local authorities unsure about how to make the transition from low cost to best value. To illustrate this conundrum it is worth considering the case of Carmarthenshire County Council (CCC), where a Best Value inspection was conducted in 2001 with the aim of improving the quality of the school catering service. On a four point scale embracing poor, fair, good and excellent, the CCC catering service was said to be ‘a good level of service’ because primary school pupils receive healthy and nutritionally balanced food; secondary schools provide a range of food that most pupils considered to be good quality; paid meal uptake was the highest in the country and free school meal uptake was in the upper quartile for all schools; and front line staff had a common sense of purpose and a commitment to quality provision. On the negative side the inspectors were concerned that pupils paid more for a meal (£1.35 in 2000/01) than in other local authorities and, concluded that if ‘productivity’ and ‘competitiveness’ could not be achieved, CCC should engage the private sector to deliver the service. Overall the inspectors found that the catering service was ‘a high quality, high cost service’, the implication being that it should be a high quality and lower cost service (Audit Commission 2001). This Best Value review is not above criticism itself because it takes as resolved what actually needs to be explained. Such terms as ‘high cost’ and ‘low productivity’, for example, may be appropriate to an industrial context, but what validity do they have here? The metric used by the inspectors – meals produced per staff hour – would seem to be more attuned to a widget-making factory than a health-promoting school. Had the council meekly accepted the Best Value
60
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
recommendations it might have found itself in the absurd position of seeking higher productivity at the expense of the children’s well being (Morgan 2004). Fortunately, CCC decided to defend its ‘high quality, high cost service’ by accounting for it in terms of a community health metric, which was radically removed from the industrial-like metric used in the Best Value review. However, without the resolve of senior officers who were committed to maintaining a healthpromoting school meal service, and local politicians who were able to defend the service in terms of the council’s ‘joined-up’ community strategy, the CCC catering service might have been forced to emulate the lower cost services of other local authorities, where lower costs had been achieved at the expense of lower quality school food provision. Even in Carmarthenshire, however, there is a perennial struggle to justify the costs associated with high quality provision because, like local authorities throughout the UK, it is difficult to quantify the benefits of good food and healthy eating, many of which are long term in nature. This raises the question of whole life costing, one of the most important ingredients in the recipe for sustainable food chains. Re-localizing the School Food Chain Sustainable food chains are generally thought to be synonymous with local food chains, though a more robust definition would include fairly-traded global food chains as well. Recent efforts to re-localize the food chain have encountered a whole series of barriers, one of which is the fact that under EU procurement rules it is illegal to specify ‘local’ food in public catering contracts. Although this is less of a barrier than was originally thought, many public procurement managers in the UK believe they are unable to purchase locally-produced food by EU directives that forbade it on the grounds that this would violate the free trade principles of transparency and non-discrimination. While EU procurement rules do indeed outlaw explicit ‘buy local’ policies on the part of public bodies, our research shows that some member states have been far more creative than the UK in how they chose to interpret these EU rules. Public bodies in Italy and France, for example, design contracts that specify certain product qualities – like freshness, seasonality, organic and so forth – which enabled their municipalities to privilege local food because such specifications favoured local producers. Through such creative procurement policies, public bodies in Italy and France are able to purchase local food without specifying it as such (Morgan and Morley 2002, Morgan and Sonnino 2007). What constitutes ‘local food’ is a debate that will never be fully resolved because there is no consensus as to what is meant by ‘local’. At one extreme there is the National Farmers Union, which equates local food with British food, at the other there is the Council for the Protection of Rural England, which defines local food as food that is grown and processed within 30 miles of its point of sale (Morgan and Morley, 2002). Rural areas would have less of a problem meeting the 30 mile radius than urban areas, so one needs to avoid hard and fast rules as to what
Greening The Realm: Sustainable Food Chains And The Public Plate
61
constitutes the ‘local’ when designing re-localization strategies. Specifying the radius of local food is perhaps more art than science and the least of the difficulties involved in creating sustainable food chains. Far more difficult is the problem of calibrating demand and supply. Stimulating demand for local food is a long term endeavour and, to be effective, it needs to be part of a wider process of consumer education, and the latter has to be more imaginative than the conventional injunctions from the health promotion industry. Here the UK has much to learn from Italy, where local food products are used as learning materials for teachers and pupils in a programme called Cultura che Nutre – culture that feeds. Aside from learning about the links between products and places, the key aim of this educational programme is to create knowledgeable consumers who have an awareness of, and a commitment to, locally-produced nutritious food. Discerning and demanding consumers are ultimately the most important factor in the process of creating sustainable food chains (Morgan and Sonnino 2007). However, if more locally-produced food was demanded in school meals tomorrow it could not be delivered because farmers have neither the skills nor the distributional infrastructure to get it from farm to fork. The dangers of creating a new market, by stimulating demand, and doing nothing to create a local source of supply would provoke a flood of imports, which is precisely what happened with the rapid growth of the organic food market in the UK. Farmers and growers have found it difficult if not impossible to break into the public sector catering market, where the barriers to entry include an exacting and time-consuming tendering process and the caterers’ preference for dealing with large food service companies that offer lower transaction costs and sponsorship deals which feature the ‘brands’ to which children are drawn. Equally debilitating is the lack of a localized infrastructure to get local produce from farm to fork. The lack of local processing capacity for fresh meat is an especially acute problem, which has been exacerbated by the inadvertent effects of EU hygiene regulations that are rendering small abbatoirs uneconomic. This implies that locally-reared livestock have to travel long journeys to be processed, creating animal welfare problems as well as unnecessary food miles. Farmers and growers will need to collaborate to a much greater extent if they are ever to overcome the supply-side barriers that continue to keep locally-produced food out of local public sector markets. If sustainable school food chains are to become the norm rather than the exception a more concerted effort will have to be made to calibrate demand and supply because, according to one public procurement director: The food supply chain from farmer, through distributors to schools (and other public sector customers is complex, fragmented, inefficient, distorts markets, under-utilises UK producers, has no planning or coordination, and is far from supporting the need for local fresh food cooked on site (Taylor 2006 n.p.).
62
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
While it is probably true overall, this bleak assessment understates two aspects of the school food chain. Firstly, while there is no public planning of demand and supply, there is certainly a good deal of private planning on the part of food service companies like Brakes and 3663 for example, and there is mounting evidence to suggest that these companies are no longer impervious to local food offers where the latter are available. Secondly, it fails to acknowledge the innovative role of NGOs in calibrating demand and supply at a local level. East Anglia Food Link, Sustain and the Soil Association have taken the lead in nurturing locally integrated school food chains. Especially significant is the Soil Association’s Food for Life programme, which is widely perceived to be the gold standard in sustainable school food chains in the UK (Melchett 2005). The main problem with the Food for Life programme, however, is that it remains a localized phenomenon, confined as it is to the islands of good practice. Although the PSFPI aims to provide a supportive national framework for sustainable food chains, good practice is a notoriously bad traveller because, for whatever reason, it is slow to disseminate from one local authority area to another (Morgan and Morley 2006). Belatedly, mainstreaming good practice has been recognized as one of the key challenges facing the government in its avowed aim of making the UK a leader in sustainable procurement. The Barriers to Sustainable Procurement It is not too much of an exaggeration to say that the British public sector – central government, local government and a wide array of other public bodies – is only now beginning to appreciate the potential of public procurement. As we have seen, the modernization of the public procurement process did not begin until 2000, when the OGC was created to act on the shocking findings of the Gershon review of civil procurement in central government. Although the UK public procurement budget amounts to £150 billion per annum, equivalent to 13% of GDP, the power of this budget is more apparent than real because it is chronically fragmented over hundreds of different public sector bodies, few of whom cooperate to achieve economies of scale or share good practice, though this is beginning to change. The UK government may have announced its intention of being one of the European leaders in sustainable procurement by 2009, but it has a long way to go before it catches up with leading countries like Denmark and Sweden, where green procurement strategies were launched in the 1990s (Erdmenger 2003). Furthermore, central government’s actions to date have been almost entirely focused on the environmental dimension of sustainability, to the exclusion of the social and economic dimensions, which means sustainable procurement in the narrowest sense of the term (NAO 2005). Food is one of the sectors where all three dimensions of sustainable procurement are being pioneered in the UK, thanks to the popular outcry that transformed school food into a serious political issue. The public catering sector in the UK spends
Greening The Realm: Sustainable Food Chains And The Public Plate
63
some £2 billion per annum and this budget has enormous potential to raise the nutritional quality of food provisioning, especially in deprived areas, where poor nutrition is one of the most insidious and least visible signs of multiple deprivation (Dowler and Turner 2001, Lang and Heasman 2004). Over the past decade there has been a revolution in the quality of British food, with the re-discovery of local and regional products and a new cachet attached to fresh ingredients (Ilbery and Kneafsey 2002). However, the customers of public canteens – in schools, hospitals, care homes and the like – have yet to enjoy the benefits of this quality food revolution, unlike their counterparts in other European countries (Peckham and Petts 2003). The barriers to the sustainable procurement of school food are similar in nature to the barriers in other sectors, which are shown in Figure 4.1.
Cost: a perception of increased costs associated with sustainable procurement. Value for money is perceived to be inconsistent with paying a premium to achieve sustainability objectives. Knowledge: a lack of awareness of the need for and processes required to conduct procurement more sustainability. Awareness and information: a lack information about the most sustainable option; a lack awareness of products; a lack of monitoring of supplies; perception of inferior quality Risk: risk-averse buyers prefer to purchase from suppliers with a good track record; organizations fear criticism from the media and are therefore less keen to take innovative approaches Legal issues: uncertainty about what can and cannot be done under existing rules (both UK and European Commission) on public procurement Leadership: a lack of leadership – both organizational and political – leading to a lack of ownership and accountability at all levels Inertia: a lack of appetite for change. A lack of personal or organizational incentives to drive change.
Figure 4.1 Commonly cited barriers to sustainable procurement (National Audit Office 2005) Many of these barriers surfaced again in the most comprehensive study of sustainable procurement ever conducted in the UK, the product of a task force chaired by Sir Neville Simms (SPTF 2006). Of all the barriers identified in the Simms report, two deserve special attention – namely the failure to apply whole life costing and the lack of sustainable procurement skills. As regards the first barrier – whole life costing – the report put it very succinctly when it said that ‘the efficiency message was being interpreted throughout the public sector in ways which drowned out sustainability considerations’ (SPTF 2006: 52). The ‘efficiency message’ is shorthand for the Gershon Efficiency Review that we encountered earlier, which aimed to squeeze savings of £21.5 billion from the
64
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
public sector, over a third of it from procurement savings. To address this problem the Simms report said there needed to be ‘a clear message from the top that value for money must be assessed on a whole life basis’ (SPTF 2006: 53). The second barrier – the lack of sustainable procurement skills – helps to explain why the public sector systematically fails to apply whole life costing to its purchasing decisions. The Simms inquiry argued that ‘many parts of the public sector currently lack professional procurement expertise and that people are routinely allowed to spend money without being appropriately trained’ (SPTF 2006: 47). This knowledge deficit chimes with an earlier inquiry which found that less than a quarter of all procurement staff was fully qualified (NAO 2005). A poorly qualified public sector workforce also helps to explain why ‘examples of good practice are presently not being shared fast enough or widely enough to encourage the dissemination of smarter procurement throughout the public sector’ (SPTF 2006: 60). What all the barriers to sustainable procurement seem to have in common is a conspicuous lack of political leadership. The Simms report freely acknowledged this problem when it said that the ‘lack of leadership from the top is then reflected down the organization in lack of accountability for sustainable procurement’ (SPTF, 2006: 29). These barriers – the failure to apply whole life costing, the knowledge deficit and the lack of political leadership – help to explain why sustainable procurement continues to be more an aspiration than a reality in large swathes of the public sector today. Conclusions and Implications The British public sector currently finds itself torn between two very different political pressures. At the rhetorical level there is a growing official commitment to sustainable procurement, so much so that the government has formally committed itself to becoming one of the leading European practitioners by 2009, a policy that is rationalized in value for money terms. However, the public sector is also being subjected to the ‘efficiency message’ and this is a much more powerful pressure because it is easier to understand, easier to implement and its results are easier to measure. Although Whitehall insists that ‘efficiency gains’ are not to be confused with budget cuts, the latter are invariably interpreted to be synonymous with the former, and this false equation constitutes the biggest single impediment to the development of sustainable public procurement. While public procurement is belatedly being modernized, then, this is occurring within a cost-cutting, rather than a value-adding, business model. Notwithstanding these barriers, some genuine progress has been made in certain areas, most notably with school food. Although government ministers are wont to give the impression that much has been achieved here, the truth is that the UK is merely on the cusp of an ecological school food service in the sense that new services have been designed but not yet delivered on a systemic basis
Greening The Realm: Sustainable Food Chains And The Public Plate
65
throughout the country. In other words, the creation of sustainable school food chains is a process not an event and the UK is merely at the beginning of this process because the implementation of the new service – which crucially depends on financially-strapped local authorities having the wherewithal to deliver – is by no means assured. Yet it is here, in the prosaic realm of the school food service, that the UK government’s avowed commitment to sustainable public procurement will be tested more profoundly than anywhere else because, if ‘greening the realm’ means anything, it must surely mean the provision of fresh, locally-produced nutritious food in schools, where children ought to be able to eat healthy food and learn about the links between food, diet and well being. If the UK cannot ensure an ecological school food service, then it cannot hope to meet the grander visions of its sustainable development strategy. Through an empirical analysis of public procurement, this article has argued that the organizational capacity of the state needs to be given far more prominence if we want to explore the scope for more radical forms of sustainable development. In the case of public procurement, for example, the state’s capacity for action has been stymied by a chronic lack of internal skills to design and deliver sustainable procurement contracts. Significant as it is, however, this knowledge deficit reflects a larger, and much more important drag on the state’s capacity for action, and the source of this problem is the subjugation of the public realm to the marketized norms of the private sector, one of the many consequences of a fashionable but flawed neo-liberal ideology (Marquand 2004, Harvey 2007). Under the guise of ‘modernisation’ the public procurement process in the UK is being reformed through an infusion of marketized knowledge and business models from private management consultants, a sector that is highly adept at persuading state bodies that the latter can overcome their internal knowledge deficit by ‘outsourcing’ their requirements to the private sector (Craig 2006). The public sector urgently needs to redress its internal knowledge deficit, principally by investing in new skill sets and by developing business models that are informed by whole life costing methodologies, thereby ensuring that low cost can no longer masquerade as best value. Reforming public procurement is a challenge that central government must share with the nations, regions and localities of the UK because the public sector straddles all these spatial scales. In terms of the food economy, for example, local government in cities, towns and rural municipalities could play an enormously important role in re-localizing the supply-side if they acquired the competence and the confidence to mobilize the power of the public plate. Under the auspices of the CARPE (Cities as Responsible Purchasers in Europe) project, 12 cities have already begun to explore the potential of green and ethical procurement (Eurocities 2005). With more than 50% of public procurement expenditure deployed at the sub-national level in EU member states, cities could secure multiple dividends by including the food economy as one of their early priorities for promoting sustainable development. As well as helping to tackle
66
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
the epidemic of diet-related diseases, and making a major contribution to human health and well being, a sustainable food economy can be a prism through which to address the burgeoning planning problems associated with food-related waste, food-related transport and food-related retail disputes, especially the growing asymmetry between supermarkets and farmers’ markets. A more sustainable, low carbon food economy also creates new incentives for cities to re-engage with their regional hinterlands, allowing city-regionalism to assume a collaborative rather than a competitive form. Urban planners in the US appear to be ahead of their European counterparts in recognizing the need for what they call food system planning. As they put it recently, As a discipline, planning marks its distinctiveness by a strong claim to be comprehensive in scope and attentive to the spatial interconnections among important facets of community life. Yet among the basic necessities of life – air, food, shelter, water – only food has been given short shrift by the planning community. Given the increasing support among planners for creating more sustainable communities, it’s time for the food vacuum in planning to be filled in. (Born et al. 2006: n.p.)
Greening the realm through sustainable public procurement policies carries threats as well as opportunities, with the biggest threat being a pious and self-referential localism in which the local is always extolled over the global. A sustainable food strategy, by contrast, would involve a judicious combination of ‘local and green’ and ‘global and fair’, the former to reduce the ecological damage of the food system, the latter to improve the prospects of desperately poor commodity producers in developing countries (Morgan 2007). Public sector canteens – in schools, universities, hospitals, care homes, prisons and the like – represent a significant part of the food economy in every country. What happens in these prosaic institutions ought to be at the centre of food system planning because, day in and day out, they constitute a source of demand that is stable and predictable over time, in contrast to the hyper-mobile branch factories that come and go in peripheral regions. To design and deliver more sustainable public procurement strategies, local municipalities need regulatory environments that positively foster food system planning, and national and supra-national regulatory reform ought to facilitate this process at the sub-national level. Even with a more benign regulatory environment, however, the evidence suggests that good practice is a bad traveller, in the sense that it does not diffuse as freely as neo-classical economic theory would have us believe. If good practice is to become the norm rather than the exception as regards green procurement, the public realm will need to devise more creative and more effective diffusion mechanisms. These will take different forms in different countries. In the UK, for example, the diffusion mechanisms would include professional associations of public sector managers, the local authority catering association for school
Greening The Realm: Sustainable Food Chains And The Public Plate
67
cooks, regional centres of excellence in procurement and networks of cities like the Eurocities network. Although the mechanisms will vary from place to place, the goal ought to be the same everywhere – to tap the power of the public plate to deliver the intrinsically significant benefits of human health and sustainable communities. References Born, B. et al. 2006. Food System Planning White Paper, American Planning Association Brenner, N. 2004. New State Spaces: Urban Governance and the Rescaling of Statehood. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Cawson, A., Morgan, K., Webber, D., and Holmes, P. 1990. Hostile Brothers: Competition and Closure in the European Electronics Industry. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Cooke, P. and Morgan, K. 1998. The Associational Economy: Firms, Regions and Innovation, Oxford University Press, Oxford Craig, D. 2006. Plundering the Public Sector. London: Constable. Davies, S. 2005. School Meals, Markets and Quality. London: Unison. DEFRA 2003a. Unlocking Opportunities: Lifting the Lid on Public Sector Food Procurement. London: Defra. DEFRA 2003b. Government Buys into Sustainable Procurement. News Release, 30 October. DfES 2006. Setting the Standard for School Food. Press Notice, 19 May, London: DfES. Dowler, L. and Turner, S. 2001. Poverty Bites: Food, Health and Poor Families. London: Child Poverty Action Group. Eckersley, R. 2004. The Green State: Rethinking Democracy and Sovereignty. Cambridge MA: MIT Press. Erdmenger, C. (ed.) 1997. Buying into the Environment. Sheffield: Greenleaf Publishing. Eurocities 2005. The CARPE Guide to Responsible Procurement. Brussels: Eurocities. Gershon, P. 1999. Review of Civil Procurement in Central Government. London: HM Treasury. Gershon, P. 2001. Speech to Greening Government Procurement Conference, 22 May, London Gershon, P. 2004. Releasing Resources to the Front Line: Independent Review of Public Sector Efficiency. London: HM Treasury. Hajer, M. 1995. The Politics of Environmental Discourse: Ecological Modernisation and the Policy Process. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Harvey, D. 2007. A Brief History of Neo-liberalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
68
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
Hay, C. 1996. From crisis to catastrophe? The ecological pathologies of the liberaldemocratic state. Innovations 94: 421-434. Ilbery, B. and Kneafsey, M. 2000. Producer constructions of quality in regional speciality food production: A case study from South West England. Journal of Rural Studies 16: 217-230. Lang, T. and Heasman, M. 2004. Food Wars: The Battle for Minds, Mouths and Markets. London: Earthscan. Marquand, D. 2004. Decline of the Public. Oxford: Polity Press. Melchett, P. (ed.) 2005. Double Dividend? Promoting Good Nutrition and Sustainable Consumption Through Healthy School Meals. London: Sustainable Consumption Roundtable. Morgan, K. 2004. School Meals and Sustainable Food Chains: The Role of Creative Public Procurement. The Caroline Walker Lecture 2004, Royal Society, London. Morgan, K. 2004. Sustainable Regions: Governance, Innovation and Scale, European Planning Studies Volume 12 (6): 871-889. Morgan, K. 2007. The Ethical Foodscape: Local and Green versus Global and Fair, Paper presented to the ESRC Science Week Conference on Local Food, St Asaph, 13 March. Morgan, K. and Morley, A. 2002. Relocalising the Food Chain: The Role of Creative Public Procurement. The Regeneration Institute, Cardiff University. Morgan, K. and Morley, A. 2006. Sustainable Public Procurement: From Good Intentions to Good Practice, Welsh Local Government Association, Cardiff. Morgan, K. and Sonnino, R. 2007. Empowering Consumers: The Creative Procurement of School Meals in Italy and the UK. International Journal of Consumer Studies 31(1): 19-25. Morgan, K., Marsden, T, and Murdoch, J. 2006. Worlds of Food: Place, Power and Provenance in the Food Chain. Oxford: Oxford University Press. National Audit Office 2005. Sustainable Procurement in Central Government. London: NAO. National Audit Office 2006a. Ministry of Defence: Major Projects Report 2006. London: NAO. National Audit Office 2006b. Smarter Food Procurement in the Public Sector: A Good Practice Guide. London: NAO. O’Connor, J. 1998. Natural Causes: Essays in Ecological Marxism. New York: Guilford Press. Orrey, J. 2005. The Dinner Lady. Bantam Press, London. Page, L. 2006. Lions, Donkeys and Dinosaurs. London: Heinemann. Passmore, S. and Harris, G. 2004. Education, Health and School Meals. Nutrition Bulletin 29: 221-227. Peckham, C. and Petts, J. 2003. Good Food on the Public Plate. London: Sustain. Policy Commission. 2002. Farming and Food: A Sustainable Future. London: Cabinet Office.
Greening The Realm: Sustainable Food Chains And The Public Plate
69
Sayer, A. 2000. Moral economy and political economy. Studies in Political Economy 62: 79-104. Scottish Executive. 2002. Hungry for Success: A Whole School Approach to School Meals in Scotland. Edinburgh: Scottish Executive. School Meals Review Panel. 2005. Turning the Tables: Transforming School Food, London: Dept of Health. Sharp, I. 1992. Nutritional Guidelines for School Meals. London: Caroline Walker Trust. Sustainable Development Commission 2005. Leading By Example? Not Exactly. London: SDC. Sustainable Procurement Task Force 2006. Procuring the Future: Sustainable Procurement National Action Plan. London: Defra. Taylor, I. 2006. A Modern Integrated and Collaborative Supply Chain for the Supply of Fresh Local Food to Education – Why Not? London: DfES. Timmins, N. 2004. Powerful Message That Has Found its Moment. Financial Times, 17 February. Welsh Assembly Government 2006. Appetite for Life. Cardiff: WAG.
This page has been left blank intentionally
Chapter 5
Thinking About Labour in Alternative Food Systems Yael Levitte
Growth Trends in the Organic Food System The organic food sector has been growing steadily in the past decade. According to the International Federation of Organic Agricultural Movements, the global market for organic products reached a value of $38.6 billion in 2006 with the vast majority of products being consumed in North America and Europe (IFOAM 2007). The American Organic Trade Association (OTA) reports that US Organic Food Sales increased 15-20% annually between 1997 and 2006, from around $3.5 billion in 1997 to $23.6 in 2008. Market penetration for organic products also increased from 0.8% to nearly 3% in the same period. OTA’s survey of manufacturers anticipates growth of approximately 18% overall each year on average for 2007 through 2010 for organic food products in the USA. The United States Department of Agriculture reports similar growth trends: Between 1995 and 2005 the total acreage of certified organic crops and livestock increased by approximately 300%, while the number of certified operations has increased by 75% (from 4,856 operations to nearly 8,500). Similar growth trends apply to the EU and Canada. In the UK, for example, evidence shows a 20% annual growth rate in sales. Statistics Canada also reports a market growth of 60% between 2001 and 2006. These trends come with mounting evidence of the corporatization of the organic food sector. Phil Howard (2009) has been tracking the acquisitions of organic food processors by mega processors since 1997 and has also reported on the introductions of new organic lines by the top 30 food processors in the country. Howard documents the consolidation of ownership in organics in the hands of large corporations as independent, family-owned organic processors have been acquired by MNCs. He also explores the idea of ‘stealth ownership’ where the ownership of smaller organic firms by large corporations is not disclosed in an attempt to disguise ownership. He points to examples of corporations that have been exposed in these attempts (e.g. Anhauser-Busch) and the negative image that resulted for companies when they are subjected to public scrutiny (see also Allen and Howard 2008). In this chapter I address a number of issues stemming from these market pressures on organic food. I look first at some trends in the global food system that have driven the expansion of the sector, and then explore the opportunities
72
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
and concerns related to the rapid market growth, highlighting labour implications. From the labour perspective, the opportunities such growth has to increase the number of green jobs (defined below) are elaborated. I also examine the quality of these jobs, looking critically at whether these green jobs are truly sustainable, i.e., are they able to address current concerns related to the working conditions of farm workers in the conventional food system? Finally, the chapter suggests that the sustainable agri-food system is experiencing a similar paradigmatic shift to the one that the biotech industry experienced in the 1980s, where old knowledge bases can be reconfigured, and learning processes have the potential to flow through networks of firms, workers and support institutions. The chapter concludes with highlighting the need to explore the potential for social innovation among actors in the sustainable food network. The Global Food System – Nutrition and Renewable Resources The growth trends in the organic food sector are a response to increasing concern with the performance of the global food system. In a recent report, Renner et al. (2007) document the environmental impacts of the global agri-food system. In their analysis they draw attention to the conflict between nutrition and the imperative to protect renewable resources. Citing the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), they show that although in the last four decades per capita food production has increased by 25%, and food prices in real terms have fallen by 40% (FAO 2002), there are roughly 1 billion people who suffer from food insecurity and a similar number that are obese (World Health Organization 2006 in Renner et al. 2007: 224, also Chapters One and Three). As the earth’s population is predicted to increase to up to 11 billion by 2050, so will the demands on the global food system. Food demands are expected to triple (Renner et al. 2007: 224). In addition, Renner et al. also report that the current food system, which we rely on to address the above nutritional concerns accounts for many environmental challenges. The global industrial agriculture sector is responsible for 15% of global GHG emissions according to emissions inventories submitted to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC in Renner et al. 2007: 224) with fertilizers being the largest single source of emissions from agriculture (38%), followed by livestock (31%). Agriculture emissions are expected to rise almost 30% from 2005-2020 (Stern 2006 in Renner et al. 2007: 224). Other environmental impacts of the current system include deforestation largely caused by agricultural encroachment (13 million hectares of annual deforestation globally World Bank 2007: 37) and overuse of water through irrigation and industrial use (ibid). In addition, the sharp fall in the prices of grains, sugar, and coffee has led producers to move towards higher-value exports like fruit, wine and flowers (ILO 2000 in Renner et al. 2007: 226) some of which are more energy and chemical intensive than many low-value products (Renner et al. 2007: 226). Renner et al. also note that the global nature of food production has added to air, sea and road traffic,
Thinking About Labour in Alternative Food Systems
73
all of which worsen pollution and contribute to global warming. Moreover, up to 50% of all food produced is discarded according to some estimates (Lindquist et al. 2008). Thus, the discarded food not only used carbon and chemical inputs that were ultimately thrown away, but the discarded food generates GHGs such as methane when it rots in landfills (Waste and Resource Action Program 2007 in Renner et al. 2007: 227). The global environmental impact of the industrial food system has intensified in tandem with the consolidation in the industry. Consolidation of Farms, Processors and Retailers Those who observe the increased consolidation of actors within the organic food system are concerned that the system mirrors the very problematic mainstream food system which is dominated by the market power of large companies (Guthman 2003, 2004, Winson 1993). Renner et al. observe that the ten largest firms in agriculture control about 80% of the organic market valued at $32 billion (ILO 2003 in Renner et al. 2007: 228) and two companies distribute 80% of the world’s grain (ibid). Similarly, the authors note that food retailing is dominated by a few companies. In the US, between 1997 and 2001 six companies nearly doubled their market hold increasing their market share from 24% in 1997 to 42% in 2001 (Hendrickson et al. 2001 in Renner et al. 2007: 228). This consolidation resulted in a shift in the balance of power away from small farmers and producers and towards large retailers, resulting in lower returns to those who plant and grow the food (Renner et al. 2007: 229). The extent of the challenge for workers is significant. The US has seen a marked decline in agricultural employment in the agriculture sector. For example, consolidation has meant the loss of over 200,000 jobs in the hog industry since the 1990s (Renner et al. 2007: 229). Wages for migrant workers in the US agriculture sector declined by 10% between 1989 and 1998 so that workers earned between $7500 and $10000 annually by the end of the 1990s. Over half these workers do not have work authorization making them libel to exploitation including working over 80 hours a week without additional compensation and they experience inadequate access to unemployment and health benefits (Carroll et al. 2005 in Schrek et al. 2006: 441). Despite this concentration in the mainstream food system, organics seem to still be dominated by small family farms (Schwind, 2007); its increasing consolidation and industrialization seems to be unevenly distributed among crops and across space. A number of studies have explored conventionalization trends (see Hall and Mogyorody 2007 for a review of the literature and current state of affairs in Canada). As a discussion about the scope of consolidation and its future sustainability is outside of the scope of this chapter, instead I explore the challenges and opportunities that the expansion of the sustainable food systems poses for local and global labour markets.
74
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
Opportunities for Wage Labour in the Sustainable Agri-food Business There are 450 million global agriculture wage earners, and many smallholders also work for wages for some or part of the time (Renner et al. 2007: 230). In the US, the Bureau of Labour Statistics (BLS) counted 859,000 agricultural workers in 2006. Looking out to 2016 the BLS projected that fewer farm workers will be needed as a result of farm consolidation and technological advancements in farm equipment. Moreover, farm workers will increasingly work for farm labour contractors rather than being hired directly by farmers. As a discussion on labour condition below will illustrate, this latter trend has negative implications for daily working conditions on farms. Data on farm workers in sustainable food operations are very hard to come by and the growing interest in sustainable agriculture has not translated to similar interest in employment in this sector. The few efforts to explore the connections between organic farming and labour report that larger organic farms are more likely to provide benefits to their workers, while organic farms in general tend to pay higher wages (Guthman 2004, Schrek et al. 2006). However, organic standards do not necessarily translate into more worker benefits due to economic pressures as according to farmers interviewed, ‘‘We can’t afford to hire help, much less pay benefits.’’ (Shreck et al. 2006: 445) Another wondered, ‘‘How can you think of insurance and paid leaves [for workers] – as a farmer I have neither.’’’ (Shreck et al. 2006: 446). This said, from a small sample of in-depth interviews their research also found economic benefits to paying a higher wage and providing year round work as training costs decreased. As well, some organic farmers indicated it was what their customers would expect. In Canada, Hall and Mogyorody (2007) examined the links between gender and organic farming. They identified a link between increased gender equality, decreased levels of mechanization and ideological leanings more towards organic as opposed to conventional farming. So organic vegetable farms were more likely to display gender equity and have women involved in production and management than commodity based conventional farms. Below I discuss possible reasons for the scholarly and policy silence on sustainable farm work, but start by exploring whether a shift to a more sustainable food system globally has the potential to create green jobs. Green jobs are defined as non-exploitative and safe positions that alleviate the myriad environmental threats faced, in this case, by agricultural practices. Specifically, but not exclusively, jobs included are ones that help to protect and restore ecosystems and biodiversity, reduce energy, materials, and water consumption through high-efficiency and avoidance strategies, de-carbonize the economy, and minimize or altogether avoid generation of all forms of waste and pollution (Renner et al. 2007: 3).
Thinking About Labour in Alternative Food Systems
75
Green Job Opportunities in Sustainable Agriculture – An Overview ‘Greening’ of Industrial Agriculture Practices The World Bank’s 2008 World Development Report focuses on agriculture, although the structure and trajectory of the global food system is taken more or less uncritically. Renner et al. (2007) suggest that the Bank’s proposed improvements in natural resource management appear to have some employment-creating potential. For example, activities like terracing or contouring of land, and building of irrigation structures to prevent further land depletion and degradation are labour intensive (World Bank 2007 in Renner et al. 2007: 20). Employment could also be generated as part of the broad effort to raise water productivity (ibid.). In addition, farmers who rotate and diversify their crops reduce the need for pesticides and fertilizers and create positive employment opportunities. This kind of farming is knowledge-intensive and requires research and extension systems ‘that can generate and transfer knowledge and decision-making skills to farmers rather than provide blanket recommendations over large areas’ (World Bank 2007:189 in Renner et al. 2007: 236). Farm workers can also gain knowledge and skills while doing these jobs. Other sustainable practices in industrial systems, however, have the potential of reducing labour inputs. For example, conservation tillage, which uses half as many tractors to cultivate a field as conventional tillage, translates into lower fuel consumption and decreased material inputs but also to reduced labour inputs. Some argue that it may increase manufacturing jobs for the equipment required, but others argue that it eliminates manufacturing jobs for the obsolete equipment associated with conventional tillage (notes 898-9 Renner et al. 2007: 238). Evidence from the Post-industrial/Grow Local Productions Since much of the discourse around sustainable food systems focuses on postindustrial models based on ‘grow local’ policies and practices and small farm production, I explore the possible employment implications of these systems. Small farm-based agriculture shifts farming methods away from dependency on environmentally harmful inputs, such as fossil-fuel based energy, chemicals and fertilizers, towards methods that utilize more human labour, farmer expertise and community experience. The system rests on the better use of locally available natural resources (such as water harvesting, irrigation scheduling and reclamation of formerly unproductive land), the intensification of microenvironments in the farm system (such as gardens, orchards and ponds), diversification through adding new regenerative components as well as making better use of non-renewable inputs and technologies (Renner et al. 2007: 243). Small farmers play an important role in the developing world. For example, in Brazil over 70% of food consumed by the Brazilian population is produced by small farmers, and small properties with less than 200 hectares generate more
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
76
than 14.4 million jobs in the countryside, or 86% of rural employment. The 1996 agricultural census in Brazil showed that, using the average productive strategies of small-scale agriculture, each 8 cultivated hectares produces one rural job whereas large-scale mechanized farms require an average 67 hectares for each unit of rural employment (Wittman 2005 cited in Renner at al. 2007: 244). In the rest of this chapter, the focus shifts to developed countries, where rural communities experience an advanced state of disintegration. The chapter thus examines whether sustainable small farm operations have the potential to create quality jobs in these places. Renner et al. (2007: 246) highlight case studies that provide evidence that organic farming and local food systems generate positive sum employment gains while protecting the environment. For example: •
•
•
•
A study of 900 food businesses in Devon, UK, showed that producers involved in the local economy hired more workers on average than those that were not. The study found that 38% of producers have created new jobs at an average of 0.5 per farm, 3.4 full time equivalents (FTE) per farm compared to 2.34 FTE’s for the regional average with a total of 170 on-farm and 113 off-farm jobs created (Devon Country Council 2001 in Renner et al. 2007: 246). The USDA reports on the impact of farmers’ markets as incomeemployment generating opportunities. In 2000, the 2900 registered markets produced over $1 billion in income for their 20,000 farmer vendors. The USDA estimates that the markets are the only marketing venues needed by 6700 of these farmers (Pretty 2001: 4). Local food shops in East Suffolk provide jobs to 548 people and purchase food goods from nearly 300 local producers and processors (Pretty 2001: 5). Similarly, Nya Mon and Holland (2005 in Renner et al. 2007: 246), conducting an input-output analysis of organic apple production in Washington State assert that for every $1 million in sales, organic apples generated 29.4 FTEs whereas conventional farms generated 25.9 FTEs. More effective waste management in the food industry translates into hundreds of jobs in the United States. One composting project in California created over 400 jobs. Landfill to gas energy (LFTGE) initiatives may also offer employment opportunities through the application of bioreactor technology. It is estimated that this process could generate up to 1% of US energy needs. While this is questionable as a sustainable long-term solution as many advocate for the elimination of landfills it could offer bridge employment opportunities as we move in the direction of sustainability.
Similar results about improved job opportunities are reported by other researchers. Morison et al. (2005 in Renner et al. 2007: 246) studied 1,144 organic farms in the U.K. and the Republic of Ireland and showed that organic farms employed one third more FTEs than conventional farms. They calculated that if the amount of
Thinking About Labour in Alternative Food Systems
77
land dedicated to organics increased by 20%, it would result in 73,200 additional jobs in the UK and 9,200 in the Republic of Ireland. Using an input-output analysis Conner et al. (2008) estimate that if Michigan residents met the USDA fruit and vegetable healthy eating guidelines by consuming more Michigan produce, 1,780 jobs and $200 million in new income would be created. A comparable study in Iowa linked increased consumption of local produce with an additional $430 million in annual incomes and spin-off an estimated 6000 jobs (Cantrell et al. 2006). There are different employment generation capacities based on farm-type. For example, the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) (2003) finds that labour demands in organic agriculture depend on the industry and country. The report finds that horticulture enterprises need considerable more labour than arable and mixed farms or dairy farms. Farm Workers in the Sustainable Food System Discourse Working Conditions on Conventional Farms While the findings above suggest employment gains generated by organic farming, sometimes the differences between the quality of work in organic and conventional farms are harder to detect. There are no comprehensive studies comparing working conditions on the two types of operations. Schwind (2007) provides data on the general farm worker population, and indicates that 75% of farm workers in the United States are Mexican-born; crop workers earn an average annual salary of $10,000-$12,500, ranking them second to private household employees who have the lowest earnings. Consequently, one in three farm worker families in the US falls below the federal poverty line, and very few are covered by health insurance. Mehta et al. (2000 in Shcreck et al. 2006: 441) assert that only 5% of farm workers have health insurance. Lack of health insurance is particularly worrisome in an industry with dismal injury rates and with high exposure to toxic pesticides (see Allen 1994 and Schreck et al. 2006 for more statistics on exposure and injury rates). The ILO (cited in Renner et al. 2007: 231) identifies agriculture as one of the most dangerous industries to work in (alongside mining and construction) with many workplace fatalities and occupational accidents and diseases. Another income-related challenge farm workers face is adequate housing as employee incomes are not enough to pay for expensive housing, especially in some California communities where housing prices are soaring. This parallels challenges faced in other industries. Silicon Valley, for example, is the site of vast social inequity as fully-employed workers live in shelters and are the victims of ‘environmental racism’ (Naguib Pellow and Sun-Hee Park 2002).
78
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
Opportunities and Barriers for Adoption of Positive Labour Practices Allen argues that sustainable agriculture practices reduce worker exposure to toxic chemicals but other problems such as low wages or poor housing have not been adequately addressed (Allen 1994: 54). In the fifteen years since Allen’s assertion, few studies have compared the working conditions of farm employees in organic and conventional farms. A recent study in the UK (Cross et al. 2009) examines the self-reported health and well-being status of field and packinghouse migrant workers on UK vegetable horticulture farms. The study found that farm workers’ health was significantly poorer than published national norms for three different health instruments, and that there were no significant differences in the health status of workers between conventional and organic farms on three physical test instruments. Using a mental well-being test, however, the study found that workers on organic farms were happier than conventional farm workers. Further analysis indicated that this latter finding is related to the diversity of tasks performed each day on organic farms, compared to conventional farms. Strochlic and Hammerschlag (2005), examining positive labour practices on 12 Californian organic farms also found that the majority of the farms in their sample were highly diverse (ten or more crops), with over a third growing at least 50 different crops. This diversity, they argue, leads to worker satisfaction, as employees express appreciation for the ability to switch tasks during the day (2005: 14). Strochlic and Hammerschlag (2005) report that sustainable growers in their study expressed a strong interest to improve labour conditions on their farms, but believed they could not afford to do so. Schreck et al. (2006) similarly found farmers’ reluctant to include labour practices in organic certifications because of economic constraints. Analyzing USDA data, Schwind (2007) provides background information for these findings. Schwind finds that commercial family-owned small- and medium-scale farms (73% of the commercial farms in the US) operate at a loss on average, even when they generate up to $175,000 annually in sales, and many rely on off-farm supplementary income. Large family farms and non-family farms, on the other hand, operate, on average, at a 10-15% profit. These data thus suggest why progressive large farms in Strochlic and Hammerschlag’s research are able to offer a broad range of traditional benefits like health insurance, paid time off, retirement plans and housing assistance. Similarly, in an analysis of California’s organic sector, Guthman (2004 cited in Schreck et al. 2006) found that the ‘farms with higher than average wages and benefits tend to be all-organic larger farms that are highly diversified and oriented toward direct marketing’ (Schreck et al. 2006: 444). Schreck et al. also found that large farms tend to provide their employees with more benefits (e.g., health, dental, life, or vision insurance; paid vacation, pension, and sick leave) than smaller farmers. Specifically, they found that farms with sales of over 1 million dollars are 31% more likely to provide health insurance to workers than those with sales of $150,000–$999,999 and 49% more likely than the smallest farms (sales up to $49,000) (ibid: 444). Smaller farms, whose owners often do not have such benefits
Thinking About Labour in Alternative Food Systems
79
for themselves, offer non-traditional benefits, including personal loans, food from the farm (which unlike additional income, is not taxable), assistance with social services and educational assistance. Taken together, these finding suggest that large profitable farms have the potential, given the right management attitude, to be agents of change in farm work quality. Other conditions noted in the study as appreciated by workers on both small and large farms include respectful treatment and a humane pace of work, fair wages, profit-sharing and bonuses, regular information sharing and training meetings, opportunities for worker input, year-round employment, minimal use of farm labour contractors, improved health and safety conditions, opportunities for professional development, the ability to advocate for improved conditions without fear of retribution and the provision of opportunities for loyal aging workers (Strochlic and Hammerschlag 2005: iii). Interestingly, the researchers found that farm workers ‘ranked respectful treatment on par with – or higher than – wages in terms of importance’ (ibid: 3) and that ‘profit-sharing and bonuses have a significant positive impact on worker motivation and sense of investment in the farm’ (ibid: 5). In addition, the researchers found that farm workers greatly appreciate the absence of foremen, ‘given the harsh treatment and exploitative behavior that is often associated with that position’ (ibid: 11). Foremen are often hired to communicate with the majority non-English speaking workers; in all the farms participating in the above study farmers spoke some Spanish enabling them to communicate directly with their employees (ibid). The research highlighted that better working conditions resulted in a more satisfied and committed workforce, higher retention rates, a more skilled, knowledgeable and productive labour force, higher quality products, reduced training and supervision costs, and ultimately, higher revenues and profits. Both Strochlic and Hammerschlag (2005) and Schreck et al. (2006) find that such practices can result in training and supervision savings of around $30,000 annually. These findings are consistent with research on Genuine Progress Indicators. This new set of measures has been developed to replace GDP and accounts for environmental and social indicators as measures of overall well-being. In describing the need to move beyond GDP, Costanza and his colleagues explain, Useful measures of progress and well-being must be measures of the degree to which society’s goals (i.e., to sustainably provide basic human needs for food, shelter, freedom, participation, etc.) are met, rather than measures of the mere volume of marketed economic activity, which is only one means to that end. Various alternatives and complements to GDP are discussed in terms of their motives, objectives, and limitations. Some of these are revised measures of economic activity while others measure changes in community capital – natural, social, human, and built – in an attempt to measure the extent to which development is using up the principle of community capital rather than living off its interest. (Italics in original, Costanza et al. 2009: 1)
80
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
Extending the way we conceptualize well-being to include fair labour practices in the food system merits more attention. Certification of Fair Labour Practices Given the benefits to both worker and owner, Strochlic and Hammerschlag suggest that the certification of positive labour practices can provide farmers access to niche markets offering price premiums for such practices. In a series of case studies, Friedberg, 2004 shows how NGOs and organizations like Christian Aid managed to drive an effective grassroots media campaign focusing on labour conditions in Latin American and African supply regions for British supermarkets. These campaigns led to the delisting of suppliers in Peru, for example; although some criticized such campaigns as resulting in the loss of hundreds of Peruvian jobs, they did result in ‘supermarkets joining the Ethical Trade Initiative (ETI), an alliance’ of companies, NGOs, and trade unions formally established in 1998, with support from the British government.’ (Friedberg 2004: 523) (See also Chapters 1, 4, 9 and 12). More formalized attempts to codify and standardize labour conditions have been undertaken recently. Henderson et al. (2003) describe the Social Accountability in Sustainable Agriculture (SASA) project, a collaboration among the International Federation of Organic Agriculture Movements (IFOAM), Social Accountability International (SAI), Fair Trade Labeling Organizations International (FLO), and the Sustainable Agriculture Network (SAN). Raynolds (2000) highlights IFOAM’s addition of social standards (regarding basic human rights and labour conditions) to its certification process (Raynolds 2000: 300-301). Raynolds also describes the Fair Trade certification process, which requires that growers adhere to a set of strict social, as well as more limited environmental, conditions. Fair Trade distinguishes, however, between small-holder and plantation enterprises, but generally upholds basic ILO conventions (ibid: 301). The labour cost associated with of certification, however, is born by the producers, not retailers. In the US, certification opportunities for positive labour practices are limited and as Schreck et al. (2006) have shown, there is much resistance to such proposals (see Guzman et al. 2007 for a proposed Action Plan for US farm workers). As an exception to the lack of standards, the Scientific Certification Systems’ Fair Labour Practices and Community Benefits Certification program is designed for all sizes of farms and food processors, for all foods and all countries. The goal is to certify that fair labour practices are used at every point in the food production chain. This labour certification program operates apart from organic certification. The stated benefits of participation are: transparency for ethical consumers through a commitment to social responsibility, improved worker productivity and satisfaction, as well as better community relations (SCS 2009). As well, Slow Food convivia around the world promote ‘good, clean and fair food’ so that, ‘Fair food is accessible to all,
Thinking About Labour in Alternative Food Systems
81
and provides a just and healthy living for everyone involved in its production.’ (Slow Food Portland 2009) Problematizing Ethical Labour Standards Ethical labour provisions, then, are complex. Friedberg shows, for example, that the ‘no child labour’ provision in the ETI Base Code, which exclude youth under sixteen from working on farms, means that in Zambia, children cannot help their mothers after school, even though this can help pay their school fees. Moreover, farms cannot offer jobs to teenage AIDS orphans. In addition, in the implementation of the ETI, the costs of improved working conditions, argues Friedberg, are born by suppliers without being shared by retailers, which in Zambia meant abandonment of exports by growers, and a loss of hundreds of farm jobs (Friedberg 2004: 524) (refer to labour and Local Food Plus in Chapters 9 and 10). Lack of consumer interest in labour practices is one reason for the slow adoption of ethical labour standards. Mintel (1999 quoted in Friedberg 2004: 515) reports that although the percentage of consumers who are concerned with ethical labour practices is on the rise, only about 2% of consumers express a willingness to actually pay more for ‘socially just’ products. Friedberg suggests that pressure to change in labour practices does not come from consumers, even educated ones, but rather from the media (for an extensive review, see Friedberg, 2004: 517). Farm workers have been generally ignored in the sustainable agriculture movement, not only by consumers, but also by the media and in research; one explanation for this omission is that farmers, not their employees, are clearly the focus of this movement (Allen 2004). Allen and Kovach (2000: 221) suggest that, ‘the focus on ecological issues and natural materials in organic agriculture obscures social relations’. These relationships are obscured in the same way that distancing occurs in the conventional food system. Using Marx’s notion of commodity fetishism, they explain how the social tensions between owners and their farm workers have been ignored for so long. The fetishism of commodities, they explain, is a condition in which the social relationships through which commodities are produced are concealed from the consumer. Consequently, the invisibility of the social relations leads consumers to ‘see value as something that inheres in the material commodities themselves, rather than something that is created by particular social relations’ (Allen and Kovach 2000: 226). Disguising the social relations, however, leads to their social reproduction, as social action and resistance is muted. Allen (2004) further argues that in studying conflict and inequality in the sustainable food systems, corporate food actors and family farms have been positioned in the center, masking conflict and inequality between smaller, familyfarm owners and their waged employees. She argues, however, that ‘both family farms and corporate farms share an economic position in the sense that they are generally entrepreneurial, property – owning firms that hire workers.’ (Allen 2004: 132). The firm metaphor is useful as it allow us to link some of the industrial innovation
82
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
literature, and explore how this relatively new sector experiences innovation and how learning takes place among farms, not only along the environmental/scientific dimensions but also in the social justice components of the sustainability approach. (See Chapter 7 for other insights regarding firms in SFS.) Sustainable Food Systems: A Paradigm Shift and Future Horizons In this final section, I pose a somewhat unorthodox proposition that suggests that the paradigmatic shift that the sustainable food sector is experiencing is similar in many ways to what the biotech industry has been undergoing in the last quarter of a century. Morgan and Murdoch (2000) suggest that as a response to the crisis of the conventional food system, a new model of food production emerged. This model, according to the authors, constituted a ‘radical break with the productivist paradigm which informs the industrial food chain’ (2000: 166). In this process, they argue, firms undergo a radical shift in which knowledge networks transform from their upstream, hierarchical formats (dealing with chemical fertilizers and pesticides) into tacit, face-to-face information sharing systems among farmers, who must acquire new knowledge and skills. Morgan and Murdoch thus see organics as a ‘radical innovation’ (following Dosi 1988), a radical discontinuity with the past, where ‘some kind of “creative destruction of knowledge” is necessary before radical innovations can diffuse throughout the economy’ (Johnson 1992 in Morgan and Murdoch 2000: 167). In this sense, organic farmers are like biotech firms, where innovations are often considered as ‘competence destroying’ (Powell et al. 1996, Powell & Brantley 1992). Competence destroying discoveries build on a radical shift in the knowledge base producing them, from one scientific paradigm to another (in the case of biotechnology, from organic chemistry to molecular biology). Because of the lucrative nature of biotech discoveries, i.e., they engender specialized knowledge with high potential commercial returns (Zucker et al. 1998), much of the learning and its commercialization is tacit, requiring a great amount of faceto-face interaction among actors in the industrial system, including researchers, investors, regulators and clinical testing facilities. Similarly, Morgan and Murdoch suggest that farmers learn a good deal from other farmers, especially in the organic sector. A farmer interviewed by Hall and Mogyorody (2007) confirmed this interactive process when they say, ‘because organic is a change, a complete change from conventional farming, there is more a tendency for it to be partnership thing’ (2007: 307). Morgan and Murdoch argue that learning can be either formal (e.g. civic interaction) or informal (farm visits, study groups or regional associations 2000: 167) and Hincrichs et al. (2004) suggest that farmers’ markets can serve as mediating social institutions that promote social learning and innovation by vendors/farmers. Data from the 4th National Organic Survey, conducted in 2002 show that organic farmers are highly educated with one in five holding a graduate degree and are involved in a multitude of organizations,
Thinking About Labour in Alternative Food Systems
83
in addition to farmer’s markets, which can promote their learning. Specifically, 84 % of respondents in the survey indicated that they belong to at least one farm organization or trade group, 40 % belong to an organic-specific association, almost as many belong to the Farm Bureau. This points to a high degree of engagement and presents opportunities for the exchange of tacit knowledge. One could suggest that these associations function in the same way as conferences would for high tech, knowledge based industry and offer the chance to build trust and create innovation (Maskell et al. 2005). Aside from trade associations, and farmers, there is a need to learn more about who are the actors in the organic knowledge networks: To what extent do these networks extend to university researchers, regulators, and other actors in the food chain? How are they governed, and where do farm workers fit into this conceptualization of a learning and innovation network? In most industrial sectors we examine the learning processes of workers. Can growers learn from their workers, or alternatively, how is knowledge transmitted among growers and workers? World Wide Workers on Organic Farms (WWWOOFers) may be one pipeline that spreads knowledge as volunteer farmers move throughout the world. The Collaborative Research Alliance for Farmer Training (CRAFT) system also provides an interesting model for knowledge exchange as farms within regions are networked to provide learning opportunities for farm interns. This helps to train new farmers and also allows existing farmers to gain new experience and knowledge (CRAFT Ontario 2009). A third option could be to compensate farmers for responsible ecological stewardship (consistent with aspects of the EU Common Agricultural Program, the Suzuki Foundation Greenbelt report). These initiatives acknowledged, the lack of attention to these opportunities needs to be addressed, … it is imperative to move beyond the deafening silences within the sustainable agriculture and organic communities in regard to the distinctly different structural positions and power asymmetries in certified organic food chains. The structural positions and interests both between actors at the point of production (of farmers and farm workers) on organic farms and between the point of production and other nodes in the commodity chain (processing, distribution, and consumption) must be clearly delineated and addressed if we hope to envision, much less create, an agriculture that is characterized by a truly comprehensive definition of sustainability – an agriculture that is ecologically sound, economically viable, and socially responsible. (Shreck et al. 2006: 448)
References Allen, P. 1994. The Human Face of Sustainable Agriculture: Adding People to the Environmental Agenda. Sustainability in the Balance Series No. 4. University of California, Santa Cruz: Center for Agroecology and Sustainable Food System.
84
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
Allen, P. and Kovach, M. 2000. The capitalist composition of organic: The potential of markets in fulfilling the promise of organic agriculture. Agriculture and Human Values. 17(3): 221-232. Cantrell, P., Conner, D., Erickcek, G. and Hamm, M.W. 2006. Eat Fresh and Grow Jobs, Michigan. Beulah, Michigan, Michigan Land Use Institute, C.S. Mott Group. September 2006. Collaborative Research Alliance for Farmer Training (CRAFT) 2009 Home: The CRAFT season has begun! Accessed online October 16, 2009 at: http://www. craftontario.ca/ Conner, D.S., Knudson, W., Hamm, W. and Peterson, H. 2008. The Food System as an Economic Driver: Strategies and Applications for Michigan. Journal of Hunger & Environmental Nutrition,3:4, 371–383. Costanza, R., Hart, M., Posner, S. and Talberth, J. 2009. Beyond GDP: The Need for New Measures of Progress. The Pardee Papers, No. 4, Boston University. Cross, P., Edwards, R., Nyeke, P. and Edwards-Jones, G. 2009. The Potential Impact on Farmer Health of Enhanced Export Horticultural Trade between the UK and Uganda. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 6(5): 1539-1556. Dosi, G. 1988. Sources procedures and microeconomic effects of innovation. Journal of Economic Literature 36: 1126-1171. Food and Agriculture Organization, (FAO) 2002. Agriculture: Towards 2015/30. Global Perspective Studies Unit, FAO, Rome. Freidberg, S. 2004. French Beans and Food Scares: Culture and Commerce in an Anxious Age. Oxford University Press: New York. Guthman, J. 2004. Agrarian Dreams: The Paradox of Organic Farming in California. Berkley CA: University of California Press. Guthman, J. 2003. Fast food/organic food: Reflexive tastes and the making of ‘yuppie chow’. Social and Cultural Geography 4(1): 45-58. Guzmán, M., Runsten, D., Strochlic, R., Garza, J., Mcintyre, J. and Mason, N. 2007. A workforce action plan for farm labour in California: Toward a more sustainable food system. Report to the Roots of Change Foundation. Accessed online February 13, 2010: http://www.cirsinc.org/Documents/Pub0707.1.pdf. Hall, A. and Mogyorody, V. 2007. Organic Farming, Gender and the Labour Process. Rural Sociology. 72(2). Henderson, E., Mandelbaum, R., Medieta, O., Sligh, M. 2003. Toward Social Justice and Economic Equity in the Food System: A Call for Social Stewardship Standards in Sustainable and Organic Agriculture Pittsboro, NC: Rural Advancement Foundation International. http://www.rafiusa.org/pubs/ SocialJustice_final.pdf. Hendrickson, M., Heffernan, W., Howard, P. and Heffernan, J. 2001. Consolidation in Food Retailing and Dairy: Implications for Farmers and Consumers in a Global Food System. University of Missouri, Department of Rural Sociology, National Farmers Union. January 8, 2001.
Thinking About Labour in Alternative Food Systems
85
Hinrichs, C., Gillespie, G. and Feenstra, G. 2004. Social learning and innovation at retail framers’ markets. Rural Sociology 69: 31-58. Howard, P. 2009. Consolidation in the North American organic food processing sector, 1997 to 2007. International Journal of Sociology of Agriculture and Food, 16(1), 13-30. Howard, P. and Allen, P. 2008. Consumer willingness to pay for domestic ‘Fair Trade:’ Evidence from the United States. Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 23(3): 235-242. International Federation of Organic Agricultural Movements, The World of Organic Agriculture 2007. Agriculture for Development, Washington, DC, 2007 http://www.ifoam.org. International Labour Organization (ILO) 2000. Sustainable Agriculture in a Globalized Economy Accessed online February 13, 2010 at: http:// docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:i203BPNw7H0J:www.ilo.org/ public/english/dialogue/sector/techmeet/tmad00/tmad-r.pdf+Internatio nal+Labour+Organization+(ILO)+2000.+Sustainable+Agriculture+in +a+Globalized+Economy&hl=en&pid=bl&srcid=ADGEEShb_7jaJo_ RKQOnkbVo-TjzVJY6gHOQzPSHW9_x7CqDHn6DnIiVQNwq-SMCRLoIbaiGZxUpdUJ3D8nBXnN5yGEWtlTUoTAmGfnUwyrg7n_Lpl2IoG-dAyyZ wiM4kCwV6I1fjg0&sig=AHIEtbQ7Qexn4GnmnlHJrLGKpodVghiXCw Lundqvist, J., de Fraiture, C. and Molden, D. 2008. Saving Water: From Field to Fork – Curbing Losses and Wastage in the Food Chain. SIWI Policy Brief. SIWI, 2008, available online at: http://www.siwi.org/documents/Resources/ Policy_Briefs/PB_From_Field_to_Fork_2008. pdf Maskell, P., Bathelt, H. and Malmberg, A. 2005. Building Global Knowledge Pipelines: The Role of Temporary Clusters. DRUID Working Paper 05-20. Accessed online October 16, 2009 at: http://openarchive.cbs.dk/bitstream/ handle/10398/7883/DRUID_05_20.pdf?sequence=1. Morgan, K. and Murdoch, J. 2000. Organic vs. Conventional agriculture: knowledge, power and innovation in the food chain. Geoforum, 31(2) pp. 159-173. Naguib Pellow, M. and Sun-Hee Park, L. 2002. The Silicon Valley of Dreams: Environmental Injustice, Immigrant Workers and the High-Tech Global Economy. New York: New York University Press. Nya Mon, P. and Holland, D. 2005. Organic Apple Production in Washington State: An Input-Output Analysis. Washington State University, School of Economic Sciences, Working Paper Series, WP 2005-3, March 2005. Organisation for Economic Co-operation and development (OECD). 2003. Organic Agriculture: Sustainability, Markets, and Policies. Oxfordshire: CABI Publishing. Powell, W. and Brantley, P. 1992. Competitive cooperation in biotechnology: Learning through networks? In N. Nohria and R.G. Eccles (eds), Networks and organizations: structure, form, and action. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press: 365-394.
86
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
Powell, W., Koput, K. and Smith-Doerr, L. 1996. Interorganizational Collaboration and the Locus of Innovation: Networks of Learning in Biotechnology. Administrative Science Quarterly 41(1): 116-45. Raynolds, L. 2000. Re-embedding global agriculture: The international organic and fair trade movements. Agriculture and Human Values 17(3): 297-309. Renner, M., Sweeney, S. and Kubit, J. 2007. Green jobs: Towards sustainable work in a low carbon world. Preliminary Report. Prepared for: UNEP, ILO, ITUC. Accessed online February 13, 2010: http://www.unep.org/civil_society/ PDF_docs/Green-Jobs-Preliminary-Report-18-01-08.pdf. Schwind, K. 2007. Growing Local Food into Quality Green Jobs in Agriculture. Race, Poverty and the Environment. Accessed online July 24:2010 at: http:// urbanhabit.org/files/RPE14-1_Schwind-s.pdf. Scientific Certification System. 2009. Certified Labour Practices. Accessed online: October 16, 2009 at: http://www.scscertified.com/fff/fair_labour_practices.php. Shreck A., Getz, C. and Feenstra, G. 2006. Social sustainability, farm labour, and organic agriculture: Findings from an exploratory analysis, Agriculture and Human Values 23:439-449. Slow Food Portland OR (2009) Our work. Accessed online October 16, 2009 at: http://slowfoodportland.com/our-work/. Stern, N. 2006. The Economics of Climate Change. The Stern Review UNFCCC website, www.unfccc.int, The World Bank, World Development Report 2008. Strochlic, R. and Hammerschlag, K. 2005. Best Labour Management Practices on Twelve California Farms: Toward a More Sustainable Food System. Report prepared for California Institute for Rural Studies. Accessed online July 25 at: http://www.cirsinc.org/Documents/Pub1205.3.pdf. Winson. A. 1993. The Intimate Commodity: Food and the Development of the Agro-Industrial Complex in Canada. Toronto: Garamond Press. World Bank. 2007. World Development Report 2008 Accessed online February 14, 2010 at:http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTWDR2008/Resources/WDR_ 00_book.pdf.
Chapter 6
The Urban Food Desert: Spatial Inequality or Opportunity for Change? Ellen Desjardins
Introduction A key dimension of a sustainable food system is equitable access to healthy food. Ideally, food is a lively presence in the public life of communities, with multiple retail spaces interspersed throughout towns and cities, and many citizens involved in food-based livelihoods of various sizes and scales. Diverse food-sale venues enable healthy sustenance, social interaction, cultural expression, physical activity and local commerce; they are central to a healthy urban or rural environment. In reality, while such spaces do exist, the past four decades of food retail evolution in developed countries have seen unequal shifts in patterns of regional food provision – an irregularity that leads to questions about the sustainability of food access within the current system. The concept of ‘food desert’ emerged in the early 1990s, when the UK government was alerted to concerns about social and geographical exclusion with respect to services of all kinds, raising the spectre of inequality and poor health (Wrigley 2002). Wrigley and co-authors have cited the earliest uses of the term as ‘areas of poor access to the provision of healthy affordable food where the population is characterized by deprivation and compound social exclusion’ and ‘those areas of cities where cheap, nutritious food is virtually unobtainable’ (Wrigley et al. 2002: 2061). A parallel phenomenon in Los Angeles, California, was referred to as ‘nutritional apartheid’ (Ashman et al. 1993: 14). The search for the origins of and solutions to food deserts, as well as evidence of their existence, has led researchers, citizens and policy-makers down a variety of often contradictory paths. It has directed attention to the fact that food access, a consumer issue, is closely tied to the supply side of the food system, with the related influences of governance and urban planning. One approach to alleviating food deserts accepts the conventional system’s ability to supply lowcost food, advocating more supermarkets and better public transportation to get there. Another approach circumvents the conventional food supply chain and its reliance on car-culture, experimenting with smaller-scale, more communitybased provisioning of food. Two themes are embedded within these divergent approaches to improve food access. One concerns the complex politics that lie behind the main components of
88
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
access: proximity and price. Explicating this theme involves looking at the history of food retail and how the quest for profit and efficiency led to structural changes in the built environment, bringing with it sporadic place-based social injustice. The other theme concerns the agency of consumers and their level of engagement with their food environment. Consumer responses to food deserts have ranged from resignation to activism, from myriad coping methods to the pro-active pursuit of alternatives (Smith and Morton 2009, Williams and Hubbard 2001, Ashman et al. 1993). It would be simplistic, however, to reduce the food deserts conundrum to a ‘structure versus agency’ based opposition. Issues that emerge from examining the two themes reflect an interplay between the interests of food retailers and consumers. For example, food chain competition built upon the sale of cheaper, non-perishable foods also filled the need for affordability on the part of low income consumers. At the same time, it made the idea of low-cost, nutritious food somewhat of an oxymoron. It helped create the belief that highly processed (or ‘value-added’) food, and by extension the productionist food system, is the answer to hunger and fills the gaps where healthier, often more perishable, food is considered financially ‘out of reach’. It is significant how the notion of food deserts has been defined and framed over time. Their first recognition during the early 1990s was based on the absence of any type of food retail in certain parts of cities. In recent years, however, the supermarket has become such a ubiquitous icon of food access that food deserts are now commonly defined by areas of supermarket scarcity (Larsen and Gilliland 2008, Morton and Blanchard 2007, Smoyer-Tomic et al. 2006, Nayga and Weinberg 1999). Rural food deserts are defined by miles of car travel to supermarkets (Smith and Morton 2009). Blinders exist (Hinrichs 2008) within research and policy, to the presence and even the value of other types of food retail that signify growing attention to inclusiveness, local entrepreneurship and sustainability. Arguably, the lasting value of the food desert metaphor may be the fact that it has stirred up a storm of research, debate, activism and experimentation with novel local solutions. This chapter will explore some basic questions and deconstruct some of the discourse related to differences in food access. In lands of plenty, what has happened over time that caused the drift of retail food into spatial unevenness? How have those spaces changed over time, and how have people and policy-makers reacted? Should food access solutions be viewed as ‘one size fits all’, or should a two-tiered or multiple-tiered system be explored for different types of population groups? Most importantly, should the very existence of geographical areas devoid of healthy food retail be viewed as an anomaly that can be easily fixed, or as a symptom of systemic injustice that requires policy-level re-thinking? Origins of Food Deserts, or Unevenness in Food Access Food deserts have been diversely defined, as will be seen later; but for the purpose of this chapter a food desert will be understood to be simply a residential area that
The Urban Food Desert: Spatial Inequality or Opportunity for Change?
89
lacks walkable access to nutritious, affordable food (Clarke et al. 2002). It is worth looking at the historical pathways that underlie the occurrence of food deserts. These roots are most accurately revealed without suggesting the influence of one dominant causal force, as food retail systems are recognized as multiplicitous: they are ‘shaped and reshaped in different places and at different scales and grounded in specific historical geographies’ (Niles and Roff 2008: 3, Guptill and Wilkins 2002). Nevertheless, since food deserts are based on a dearth of food retail, it is the development and growth of this sector that provides important clues to its own patterning over time. The Historical Rise and Spatial Shift of the Supermarket In Canada, the UK and the US, significant transformation of the food retail market began during the 1930s with the development of chain stores (Gottlieb 2001, Wrigley and Lowe 1996, Winson 1993). This strategy of increased efficiency, achieved through integrated buying and wholesaling, allowed the chains to out-compete smaller independent grocery stores. In the post-war period the ‘supermarket’ concept emerged, based on a large selection of products in one big store, combined with in-store self service and lower prices. High volume sales were made possible by the growing consumer ownership of refrigerators and cars. The chain stores adopted the supermarket model soon thereafter, and were hugely successful, expanding in number during the 1940s, 1950s and 1960s. In the US, for example, the food retail market share of supermarket chain stores rose from 34% in 1948 to 62% in 1982 (Winson 1993). Before the advent of supermarkets, smaller-scale chain stores during the Depression era commonly served community-building functions such as providing culturally-specific foods or spaces for community interaction, and consumer services such as credit and home delivery. Supermarkets, on the other hand encouraged consumer buy-in through marketing strategies such as ‘Every Day Low Price’ (Ashman et al. 1993) and continuous introduction of new products. They positioned themselves as serving consumers’ interests in terms of convenience, efficiency, quality and affordability, while becoming increasingly divorced from their community role (Gottlieb 2001: 200, Wrigley and Lowe 1996). Throughout the rest of the 20th century, several systemic factors combined to create an infrastructure that supported the viability of supermarkets. The building and maintenance of vast highway networks throughout developed countries was an essential component to transport food to warehouses and supermarkets. Suburban retail landscapes typically featured through-roads with malls and parking lots at major intersections. The 1950s and onwards saw the growth of suburban housing developments based on car culture, with retail outlets at driveable, not walkable, distance. ‘Proximity’ gained new meaning in this context: a 10-minute drive to a supermarket parking lot became as convenient as a 10-minute walk. Beyond viability, the extremely lucrative market created by supermarkets led to a drive for further growth and dominance. Successful strategies included
90
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
increasing supermarket size, greater control within the food supply chain and consolidation within the food industry. Supermarket floor space grew in the US from an average of 15,000 square feet in 1950 to 38,000 square feet in 1980, to over 60,000 square feet in the late 1990s, correspondingly increasing space (Millstone and Lang 2003, Gottlieb 2001). Another strategy initiated in the mid1990s was ‘efficient consumer response’ (ECR) in which every component of the food supply chain is coordinated to work in tandem, aided by computerized systems (Millstone and Lang 2003, Guptill and Wilkins 2002). Wrigley (1996: 9) has noted the positioning of retail, especially in the UK during the 1970s and 1980s, as the ‘cutting edge of technological and organization innovation’ with ‘logistically efficient stock control system and quick-response, centrally-controlled warehouse-to-store distribution networks’. To further enhance its own power and control, both vertical and horizontal corporate concentration in the retail sector began in the 1980s. Mergers were negotiated faster in the UK and in Canada than in the US due to anti-trust legislation there (Wrigley and Lowe 1996, Winson 1993). For example, in 1987 Canada’s largest five grocery distributors represented about 70% of total sales (ibid.). In the UK, the top five firms accounted for almost 90% of the food retail market in 1998-99 (Wrigley and Lowe 2002:158). In the US, the top five supermarket chains controlled 20% of sales in 1995 and 29% in 1999 (Guptill and Wilkins 2002); however, by 2002 the top eight American grocery chains accounted for 46% of market share (Schwartz and Lyson 2007). Consolidation helped offset the cost of starting new stores by passing costs such as advertising and inventory holding to partnering manufacturers; nevertheless, it has been shown that greater retail concentration was associated with higher rather than lower food prices to consumers (Schwartz and Lyson 2007, Wrigley and Lowe 1996, Winson, 1993). The result of such strategies was competitive advantage over smaller-scale and independent rivals, and succeeded in putting many of them out of business. Nevertheless, overhead costs for supermarkets remained high. Food price competition remained strong among supermarket chains and mass retailers like WalMart and the newer ‘deep discount’ grocery chains that were introduced in the 1990s in North America and the UK (Guptill and Wilkins 2002, Wrigley and Lowe 1996). Consequently, and significantly, the on-going viability of supermarket chains over time meant further cost cutting measures and discontinuance of stores where profitability was compromised in any way (Lang 2003). Strategies for cutting costs included lower wages for workers, partially through low-skilled labour (Wrigley and Lowe 2002). Cost-cutting was also significantly reflected in the type of food sold. A particular problem was the sale of perishable food, which incurs higher costs and waste at all stages of the retail process and yields a lower profit margin. Therefore, when the manufacturing industry introduced hydrogenated fats and a greater variety of preservatives during the 1980s, the shelf life of processed foods increased immensely and started to take a more prominent place in grocery stores. Secondly, the introduction of high fructose corn syrup enabled a plethora of new products, sweetened cheaply and advertised
The Urban Food Desert: Spatial Inequality or Opportunity for Change?
91
widely. Profit margins for these highly-processed foods were higher than those of fresh produce, meat and dairy; furthermore, supermarkets could charge suppliers for access to optimally-located shelf space. Thirdly, corporate retailers were able to import foods globally by developing long-term relationships with suppliers in developing countries where labour is cheap (Atkins and Bowler 2001). In spite of these cost-cutting strategies which affected the food environment and workers’ wages within supermarkets, cost increases in the form of higher property values, taxes and utility costs were faced by large-size inner city stores (Turgue 1992). The building of new central supermarkets with adjoining parking lots became prohibitively expensive. Especially in the United States during the 1970s, many of these same inner city neighbourhoods experienced a demographic shift by race and class as wealthier people joined the exodus to the suburbs. Faced with a clientele with less spending power, as well as a greater incidence of crime in some places, supermarkets started closing down in many urban cores throughout the 1980s. For example, in Boston, 34 of 50 big-chain markets closed between 1970 and 1990; Los Angeles County went from 1,068 supermarkets to 694 during that period (Turgue, 1992). Between 1978 and 1984, Safeway closed over 600 stores in American inner city neighbourhoods. Business Enterprise Trust (BET) was quoted as saying in 1993 that ‘it makes no sense to serve distressed areas when profits in the serene suburbs come so easily’ (Eisenhauer, 2001: 128). Thus, a major source of unevenness in food retail availability to consumers was the disappearance of many smaller independent and specialty stores where supermarkets had located during their period of expansion; now this was exacerbated when supermarkets started to close in low-income areas. By 1995, the poorest 20% of urban American neighborhoods, where fewer people owned cars, had 44% less retail supermarket space than the richest 20% (Eisenhauer 2001). It must be noted that the term ‘food deserts’ was not used in the US at that time, and it is not known to what extent this phenomenon existed in parts of cities. In the UK, a similar trend was happening to a lesser degree, although some city neighbourhoods like the Seacroft area of Leeds drew attention due to their extreme isolation from food stores (Wrigley 2002). Cummins (2002:437) has pointed out that there was no clear evidence for widespread food deserts in the UK, and claimed that the term had become ‘convenient shorthand for a complex problem’ of social exclusion and poverty in general. External Factors that Contributed to Food Retail Patterning Because of the dominance of food retail by supermarkets in wealthier countries, and the common assumption that this model is the most effective way to provide food for the population, supermarkets are often blamed for leaving some neighbourhoods without food. There were other factors, however, that influenced community food access, including lending practices by banks, municipal zoning laws, public health regulations and development.
92
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
Redlining, for example, is the practice of refusing mortgage credit to businesses in a specific neighborhood by a bank or lending institution, based on assumed creditworthiness of the applicants, value of the property for sale or apparent quality or stability of the area (Kantor and Nystuen 1982). When these criteria are correlated with race or income, the result is the concentration of economic and service development in some neighborhoods while others deteriorate. Redlining originated during the 1930s in the United States with racial connotations; it was widespread in Canada from the 1930s to the late 1950s, marking suburban districts where companies declined to approve loans (Harris 2003). Redlining in Canada represented discrimination by social class rather than the distribution of ethnic minorities, and later disappeared as large city suburbs became more affluent (ibid.). Although there is denial that redlining still exists, some critics have referred to the tendency of large chains to avoid locating in inner cities or low-income residential areas as ‘supermarket redlining’ (Eisenhauer 2001). This situation was considered urgent enough by the US Conference of Mayors that a House committee held hearings on the issue (Turgue 1992). Furthermore, in the marketing world, the rationale for supermarket location appears to be normally based on market forces; this could be interpreted as a positive form of redlining. For example, electronic marketing tools such as ‘geodemographic segmentation’ are available to distinguish average shopping habits by different geographic areas to aid the selection of optimal locations for retail stores (Gonzalez-Benito and Gonzalez-Benito 2005). It is considered financially astute and justified that food stores are attracted to areas of greater wealth, less competition or lower crime (Ver Ploeg et al. 2009). The roles of municipal governments should not be overlooked: they have both helped and hindered the establishment of supermarkets. On one hand, higher taxes in city centres have added to the ‘fixed cost’ burden that led so many supermarkets to close. In many cities the separation of commercial from residential zoning has kept retail out of certain areas altogether (Mair et al. 2005). On the other hand, municipal food safety laws have helped supermarkets in many cities by disallowing or limiting street food vendors and small markets, in the interest of ‘food safety’ (Taylor et al. 2000). In terms of store development costs, property values are usually lower on the periphery of cities, and suburban structure is designed for cars. Mall developers often prefer to include an established grocery chain over an independent grocer, and charge more for a lease to a non-chain store because it does not attract as much business for itself or for neighbouring business tenants (Ashman et al. 1993). The Plight of Small-scale Food Retail With all the emphasis on supermarkets, how has smaller retail contributed to food access over the decades? Outside the world of concentrated ownership, the presence of independent grocers, specialty food shops and convenience stores has persisted. In spite of the diversity and variety of models, in much of the literature
The Urban Food Desert: Spatial Inequality or Opportunity for Change?
93
they are lumped together and typecast as poor substitutes for supermarkets, as, for example, ‘inner cities have been left with smaller and less accessible stores that are generally unable to provide both the quality and variety of foods needed for a healthy population nor the affordable prices to inner city households’ (Nayga and Weinberg 1999). Ignoring or downplaying the role of small-scale food retail, without assessing what they sell, has led to a tendency to overestimate the existence of food deserts and to oversimplify the context in which policy decisions are made (Short et al. 2007, Guy and David 2004, White et al. 2003, Cummins and Macintyre 2002, Wrigley, 2002, Williams and Hubbard 2001). Small convenience stores, sometimes referred to as ‘corner’ or ‘mom and pop’ stores, often remained in spite of the presence of supermarkets, not being seen as major competition as they generally charged somewhat higher prices and were not used for major food purchases. They were able to keep overhead costs down because they were family run and could keep longer opening hours. Often their business relied on the sale of cigarettes, alcohol, candy and non-perishable food; thus giving the small store a reputation for poor quality and selection and higher prices in exchange for the convenient location and opening times (Moore and Diez Roux 2006). This reputation may be borne out in some cases but not in others, as shown by a detailed food scan of a low-income Chicago community where most residents live within a quarter mile of a corner store or independent grocery store (Block and Kouba 2006: 840). Food prices, selection and produce quality varied considerably among these stores, ranging from poor to good. The study concluded that a large, diversified store mix, rather than a few supermarkets, could better serve the needs of a population with low car access (ibid: 844). Small-scale specialized retail and ethnic stores have long been part of the city food environment in Europe, the UK, and older parts of North American cities. There has been considerable variation within and among cities; in some cases, inner city retail landscapes with small retail remained and flourished, while in others they closed down. The Welsh city of Cardiff, for example, which saw a few large supermarkets take over the periphery, still maintained in the inner city ‘a dense network of local shops plus discount shops to provide range of food needed’ as many people preferred them for social or ethnic reasons (Guy and David 2004: 224). In Coventry, UK, many residents of a deprived neighbourhood tended to travel to traditional shops rather than newer supermarkets and shopping centres, as they valued the social context as much or more than the physical setting (Williams and Hubbard 2001). The fragmentation of the consumer market among different sizes and types of grocery stores, in spite of many closures, started in the early 1970s. Qualitative research with smaller-scale grocers shows considerable diversity in the way they source their food and their interactions with consumers. (Guptill and Wilkins 2002). Their success varied by community, but they have shown viability as part of, as well as alternative to, the conventional food system (ibid.). Other research in Toronto has demonstrated that, since the mid-1990s, small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), which includes retail, have been growing at an unprecedented
94
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
rate, responding to consumer demand for healthier, local and ethnic foods (Donald and Blay-Palmer 2006). These authors argue that this trend is not exclusionary due to higher prices, as is often suggested, but has been embraced by consumers of all income levels due to perceived multiple benefits of both the food and its socioenvironmental context. Short et al. (2007) noted the oft-unrecognized value of small-scale retail; they assessed food affordability, nutritional adequacy, cultural acceptability and accessibility in the San Francisco area. Their mapping exercise demonstrated a different mix of store sizes and types in each of six neighbourhoods, varying from the presence of small grocery stores on almost every block to a food desert in one area. Most small grocers offered a variety of healthy and affordable food, including produce to attract customers and to distinguish themselves from liquorselling convenience stores – even though produce did not bring much profit. Many of the small stores were ethnically (Latino) based and served this sub-community in particular, while other groups may have felt underserved. This study ‘added complexity to the food deserts argument’ (Short et al. 2007: 361) and advocated that food access is a unique community level indicator determined by the sum contributions of all food retail in a neighbourhood (Short et al. 2007). The lack of supermarkets in minority neighborhoods in Erie County, New York, could have pronounced it a food desert, but a closer inspection revealed an extensive network of small grocery stores (Raja et al. 2008). The researchers felt that ‘supporting small, high-quality grocery stores may be a more efficient strategy for ensuring access to healthful foods in minority neighborhoods’ (Raja et al. 2008: 469). The same finding came from four low income census tracts in central New Orleans, where fresh vegetable and fruit availability within 100 m of a residence, often from small neighbourhood food stores, was a positive predictor of vegetable intake (Bodor et al. 2008). A related exploration in New Orleans showed that the food desert rate was 46% if it meant that the distance for residents to the nearest supermarket was greater than 2 km, but the proportion of food deserts dropped to 17% if food retail provision referred to ‘finding significant quantities of fresh foods sold in a neighbourhood’ – regardless of store size (Rose et al. 2009: 10). Urban Regeneration Programs in late 1990s and 2000s – Impact on Small-scale Retail By the mid-1990s in the US, supermarket firms were under pressure to reinvest in inner cities as inequalities in access were revealed (Gottlieb 2001, Turgue 1992). In the UK as well, governments started to prioritize the vitality of city centres (including ‘brownfield’ development), and tightened land-use planning regulations so that it became more difficult to obtain permission for out-of-centre or ‘greenfield’ retail development (Wrigley et al. 2002). Thus some major food retailers were adopting an ‘urban regeneration’ agenda at the same time that issues of social exclusion, including food deserts, came to the fore and influenced retail planning policy (ibid.). Consequently, and ironically,
The Urban Food Desert: Spatial Inequality or Opportunity for Change?
95
the problem for some communities was compounded: first abandonment by the supermarkets in the previous decades; then, reintroduction of supermarkets to the inner city but without attention paid to the needs of communities – nor to existing small retail. The next section will discuss two case studies in more detail. It includes, for example, the story of Pathmark Stores Inc. in the Harlem district of New York during the early 1990s, where the re-establishment of a supermarket in a food desert caused conflict because it threatened the livelihood of existing smaller grocery stores in the adjacent neighborhood (Lavin 2000). A decade later, the Green Cart program was introduced in New York as a neighbourhood regeneration program; again, the smaller grocers objected because of unwanted competition (Rivera 2008). Food deserts, it appears, represent more than manifestations of spatial inequality. They can also become spaces of power struggles when attempts to regenerate neighbourhoods bring disagreement over ‘who owns, who occupies and who controls the city’s public spaces’ (Zukin 1995: 291). The Portrayal of Food Deserts Any attempt to portray food deserts as a fixed, physical phenomenon will be confounded by the variations that happen over time and the perspectives from which they are described. The lens of spatial inequity, applied, for example, to a neighbourhood as time-lapse photography, or focusing its gaze on the resident, the grocer, the activist or the analyst, will reveal the inherent complexity. Discourse of food access and food deserts Given the political nature of food access and food deserts, it is perhaps not surprising that the discourse in both published and unpublished literature varies considerably. This variation stems not only from the vantage points of different disciplines, but also from different time periods. Reports from the early 1990s, when food deserts were first recognized as related to areas of poverty, class and race, presented the issue boldly as one of social injustice and prejudice. It painted a bleak picture of urban wastelands that exacerbated conditions of poverty, calling them ‘deprived’, ‘disadvantaged’ and ‘food insecure’. The lack of planning that led to food deserts has been equated to a disregard for food as a human right (Ashman et al. 1993). Concurrently, research with a political economy of food perspective chronicled the history of retail, noting the almost impossible amassing of profit and power that came with the new food regime, and exposing the global social inequities that came with it (Atkins and Bowler 2001). A health perspective accompanied the British food desert phenomenon from the beginning, making presumed malnutrition and susceptibility to disease one of the main leverage points in obtaining government commitment towards policy change. It is notable that the connection of food deserts with dietary behaviour and health outcomes was often assumed as intuitive. Consequently, many studies
96
Imagining Sustainable Food Systems
within the areas of public health, nutrition and epidemiology in high-income countries focused here after the turn of the century, concerned mostly with quantitative measures of population-based diet and health but generally ignoring political aspects of the food economy. The ‘healthy’ vs ‘unhealthy’ binary came into common use to characterize food, diet, food stores, food policy and even communities. The sub-discipline of health geography, since the turn of the century, injected an emphasis on space and place into the overlap of food access and public health; it was also responsible for the flurry of attention to new methodologies made possible by GIS (geographic information systems). Neighbourhoods, distinguished by average economic or demographic characteristics, were assessed for their density of certain types of food stores, conflating physical proximity with food accessibility. The conflicting results that emerged from thes