HYDROSTATIC LUBRICAT10N
TRIBOLOGY SERIES
Advisory Board W.J. Bartz (Germany, F.R.G.) R. Bassani (Italy) B. Briscoe (Gt. Britain) H. Czichos (Germany, F.R.G.) D. Dowson (Gt. Britain) K. Friedrich (Germany, F.R.G.) N. Gane (Australia)
Vol. 1 Vol. 2 Vol. 3 VOl.
4
5 Vol. 6 Vol. 7 Vol. 8 VOl.
VOl. 9 VOl. 10 VOl. 11
VOl. Vol. Vol. Vol. Vol. Vol. Vol. VOl. VOl. Vol. VOl.
12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22
W.A. Glaeser (U.S.A.) M. Godet (France) H.E. Hintermann (Switzerland) K.C. Ludema (U.S.A.) T. Sakurai {Japan) W.O. Winer (U.S.A.)
Tribology - A Systems Approach to the Science and Technology of Friction, Lubrication and Wear (Czichos) Impact Wear of Materials (Engel) Tribology of Natural and Artificial Joints (Dumbleton) Tribology of Thin Layers (Iliuc) Surface Effects in Adhesion, Friction, Wear, and Lubrication (Buckley) Friction and Wear of Polymers (Bartenev and Lavrentev) Microscopic Aspects of Adhesion and Lubrication (Georges, Editor) Industrial Tribology - The Practical Aspects of Friction, Lubrication and Wear (Jones and Scott, Editors) Mechanics and Chemistry in Lubrication (Dorinson and Ludema) Microstructure and Wear of Materials (Zum Gahr) Fluid Film Lubrication - Osborne Reynolds Centenary (Dowson et al., Editors) Interface Dynamics (Dowson et al., Editors) Tribology of Miniature Systems (Rymuza) Tribological Design of Machine Elements (Dowson et al., Editors) Encyclopedia of Tribology (Kajdas et al.) Tribology of Plastic Materials (Yamaguchi) Mechanics of Coatings (Dowson et al., Editors) Vehicle Tribology (Dowson et al., Editors) Rheology and Elastohydrodynamic Lubrication (Jacobson) Materials for Tribology (Glaeser) Wear Particles: From the Cradle to the Grave (Dowson et al., Editors) Hydrostatic Lubrication (Bassani and Piccigallo)
TRIBOLOGY SERIES, 22
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICAT10 N
R. Bassani Dipartimento di Construzioni Meccaniche e Nuclear; Facolta di lngegneria Universita di Pisa Pisa, Italy
B. Piccigallo Gruppo Construzioni e Tecnologie Accademia Navale Livorno, ltafy
ELSEVIER Amsterdam London New York Tokyo
1992
ELSEVIER SCIENCE PUBLISHERS B.V. Sara Burgerhartstraat 25 P.O. Box 21 1, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
ISBN 0 444 88498 x
0 1992 ELSEVIER SCIENCE PUBLISHERS B.V. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., Copyright & Permissions Department, P.O. Box 521, 1000 A M Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Special regulations for readers in the U.S.A. - This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC), Salem, Massachusetts. Information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the U.S.A. All other copyright questions, including photocopying outside of the U.S.A., should be referred to the publisher. No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Printed in The Netherlands
Preface
Hydrostatic lubrication is characterized by the complete separation of the conjugated surfaces of a kinematic pair, by means of a film of fluid, which is pressurized by an external piece of equipment. Its distinguishing features are lack of wear, low friction, high load capacity (even when the relative velocity of the lubricated surfaces is low or nought), a high degree of stiffness and the ability to damp vibrations. As compared with the other types of lubrication, it may have clear advantages against one main disadvantage: the lubricant supply system is, generally, more complicated. This book deals with the study of externally pressurized lubrication, both from the theoretical and the technical point of view, thereby claiming to be useful for researchers as well as for students and technical designers. In this connection, design suggestions for the most common types of hydrostatic bearings have been included, as well as a number of examples. The substantial and up-to-date lists of references may constitute a further aid. The first chapter, after a very brief historical note, describes the principal types of hydrostatic bearings, while the second describes the principal types of supply systems and compensating restrictors. The third chapter briefly reviews lubricants and their main properties, including viscosity, that plays the most important role in lubrication, and compressibility, that may considerably affect the dynamic behaviour of bearings. The fundamental equations on which the study of lubrication is based are given in chapter 4 and are used in chapter 5 in order to obtain certain characteristic parameters (e.g. effective area, hydraulic resistance, friction force) for the most common pad bearings. The principal types of hydrostatic bearings (single-pad and opposed-pad thrust bearings, slideways, journal bearings and so on) are then examined in detail, in combination with the principal supply systems, in the subsequent four chapters, with
vi
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATlON
a view to providing a full description of their behaviour in the case of static loads. Afterwards, the dynamic behaviour of the same bearings is considered (chapter 10): the thin viscous film, typical of hydrostatic lubrication, generally makes them stiff, stable and well damped, although certain phenomena (chiefly lubricant compressibility) may reduce the margin of stability. Chapter 11 deals with the problem of the optimization of bearings, aimed a t obtaining the minimum waste of total power (that is, pumping power plus friction power). The thermal balance of the lubricant flowing in a pad bearing is also investigated (chapter 121, taking into account the thermal flow through the bearing itself and the relevant supply ducts. Some brief notes on the important matter of the experimental testing of hydrostatic bearings are given in chapter 13. Finally, a number of examples of actual applications of hydrostatic lubrication are to be found in the last chapter. We wish to express our gratitude to the authors, all quoted in the author index and in the lists of references, whose work we have widely used and whom we have not been able to thank directly. We also wish to thank the firms (namely: FAG Kugelfischer, INNSE Machine Tools, Pensotti Machine Tools, SKF) which kindly provided us part of the graphical material that we used in the final chapter. Lastly, we wish to thank Dr. Paola Forte, who helped us in a number of ways, Mr. Sergio Martini and Mr. Aldo del Punta, who carried out part of the graphical work.
Contents
List of main symbols Chapter 1
XiV
HYDROSTATIC BEARINGS
1.1 INTRODUCTION ..... 1.2 WORKING PRINCIP 1.3
........................................................... ................................................................ ADVANTAGES AND DRAWBACKS .............................................................
.................................
1
................................... ..............................
3
1
1.4 APPLICATIONS ........................................................................................... 1.5 TYPES OF BEARINGS ........................................................ 1.5.1 Thrust bearings .................................................................. ........................... 7 ...... ................................................. 9 1.5.2 Radial bearings ....................................... ................................................................................. 11 1.5.3 Multidirectional bearings 1.5.4 Bearing arrangements .......... ..........................................................................
.................................................................................
REFERENCES ...............................
Chapter 2
14
COMPENSATING DEVICES
2.1 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................
.................................................................................................
16
2.3 COMPENSATED SUPPLY SYSTEM ............................................................................... ......................................... 2.3.1 Fixed restrictors ................................................................. 2.3.2 Variable restrictors ........................................................... .................................. ..................................................... 2.3.3 Inherently compensated bearings ......... .......................................................... 2.3.4 Reference bearings ....
17 18 19 25
2.2 DIRECT SUPPLY SYSTEMS
2.4 THE COMMONEST SUPPLY SYSTEMS ................................................................. 2.4.1 Direct supply ................................................... .................................................... ............................................................... 2.4.2 Compensated supply ...................................... 2.5 HYDRAULIC CIRCUIT ...................................... REFERENCES ............................................................
Chapter 3
................................ ................................
LUBRICANTS .......................................................................................
3.1 INTRODUCTION
30 30 31 33
...........35
3.2 MINERAL LUBRI ..................................................................................... .................... 3.2.1 Types ....................................................... ......................................................
36 36
viii
HYDROSTATIC LUBRlCATlON 3.2.2 3.2.3 3.2.4 3.2.5 3.2.6 3.2.7
Viscosity ................................................................................................................................... Oiliness .................................................................................................................................... Density ... Thermal properties Other properties ...................................................................................................................... Additives ..................................................................................................................................
36 41 42 49 50 50
3.3 SYNTHETIC LUBRICANTS ...............................................................................................................
52
REFERENCES ......
52
Chapter 4
..........................................
.........
............
BASIC EQUATIONS
4.1 INTRODUCTION ........................................................... 4.2 NAVIER-STOKES AND CONTINUITY EQUATIONS 4.2.1 Rectangular coordinates ....................................... 4.2.2 Cylindrical coordinates ..................................... 4.2.3 Spherical coordinates ..............................................................................................................
57
4.3 THE REYNOLDS EQUATION ............................................................................................................ 4.3.1 Rectangular coordinates ......................................................................................................... 4.3.2 Cylindrical coordinates ........................................................................................................... ....................................................... 4.3.3 Spherical coordinates
58 58 61 64
4.4 THE LAPLACE EQUATION ...............................................................................................................
65
4.5 LOAD CAPACITY, FLOW RATE, FRICTION ................................................................................... 4.5.1 Load capacity .......................................................................................... 4.5.2 Flow rate .................. .................................. 4.5.3 Friction ...............................................
66 66 66
4.6 THE ENERGY EQUATION 4.7 LAMINAR FLOW THROUGH CHARACTERISTIC CONFIGURATIONS ..................................... 4.7.1 Parallel surfaces ...................................................................................................................... 4.7.2 Infinite-length rectangular pad ....................................................... 4.7.3 Flow recirculation inside recess .......................................... 4.7.4 Annular clearance. .................................................................................................................. 4.7.5 Circular pad .............................................................................................................................
4.9 INLET LOSSES ..................
..........................................................................................
69 69 71 73 75 76 77
..........................................................................................
79
........................................................................................................
80
4.10 TURBULENT FLOW .........................................................................................................................
80
4.11 THE FLOW IN ORIFICES ................................................................................................................
83
REFERENCES ..
85
Chapter 5
.........................................................................................................................
PAD COEFFICIENTS
5.1 INTRODUCTION .............................. 5.2 GENERAL STATEMENTS ................ 5.3 CIRCULAR RECESS PAD ....... 5.3.1 Basic equations ............. 5.3.2 Design chart ............................................................................................................................. 94 5.3.3 Effects of errors in parallelism ............................................................................................... 95
ix
CONTENTS
5.3.4 5.3.5 5.3.6 5.3.7
Effects ofthe loss of pressure at the inlet .............................................................................. 98 Turbulent flow ....................................................................................................................... 101 Effects of the inerti ............................................................. 103 Thermal effects ..... ................................................ 107
5.4 ANNULAR RECESS PADS ................................... .......... 112 ................................................ 112 5.4.1 Basic equations ..... 5.4.2 Effects of errors in parallelism ............................................................................................. 117 5.4.3 Effects of pressure losses at the inlet ................................................................................... 118 5.4.4 Turbulent flow ....................................................................................................................... 119 5.4.5 Effects of the inertia forces ........................................ 5.4.6 Thermal effects ........................................................... 5.5 TAPERED PADS ..................................................................... ................................ 5.5.1 Basic equations ...................................................................................................................... 5.5.2 Effect of the inertia forces ................... ........................................................... 5.5.3 Effect of misalignment ........................ ...........................................................
123 123 125 126
.................................................................. 128 5.7 RECTANGULAR PADS ..................................................................................................................... 133
5.6 SPHERICAL PADS ...........
5.8 CYLINDRICAL PADS........................................................................................................................
138
5.9 HYDROSTATIC LIFI'S ........................................................... 5.10 SCREW AND NUT ASSE
.......................
REFERENCES ............................
Chapter 6
SINGLE PAD BEARINGS
6.1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................... 149 6.2 DIRECT SUPPLY ................................................................... 6.2.1 Bearing performance ................................................. 6.2.2 Temperature and viscosity ........................................................
..................
6.3 COMPENSATED SUPPLY................................................................................................................ 6.3.1 Laminar flow restrictors (capillaries)................................................................................... 6.3.2 Orifices .... 6.3.3 Constant flow valves .............................. 6.3.4 Spool valves ............................................................... 6.3.5 Diaphragm-controlled restrictors .............................. 6.3.6 Infinite-stiffness devices ....................................................................................................... 6.3.7 Inherently compensated bearings ................................................................ 6.4 DESIGN OF SINGLE-PAD THRUST BEARINGS ... 6.4.1 Direct supply (constant flow) .................................... 6.4.2 Compensated supply (constant pressure) ............................................................................
Chapter 7
153 155 160
169 172
180
OPPOSED-PAD AND MULTPAD BEARINGS
7.1 INTRODUCTION 7.2 OPPOSED-PAD B 7.2.2 Capillary compensation............................................. 7.2.3 Orifices .......... ...........................
.............................................................. ..................
197
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICA TlON
X
................................................
213
8.1 INTRODUCTION ...............................................................................................................................
236
7.2.6 Design of opposed-pad bearings ................... 7.3.1 Direct supply ............ 7.3.2 Constant pressure supply ....... 7.4.1 Direct supply .................................................
7.6 MULTIPAD JOURNAL BEARINGS
Chapter 8
MULTIRECESS BEARINGS
8.2 ANALYSIS ..........................................................................................................................................
236
8.3 MULTIRECESS JOURNAL BEARINGS ......................................................................................... 8.3.1 Bearing performance 8.3.2 Effect of geometrical ................................................................ 8.3.3 Design of multirecess journal bearings. 8.3.4 Design procedure ..................................
239
8.4 ANNULAR MULTIRECESS THRUST BEAR1
.....................................
249
260
8.5 TAPERED MULTIRECESS BEARINGS.......................................................................................... 263 ............................................................................... 265 8.5.1 Single-conejournal bearings 8.5.2 Opposed-cone assemblies ............................................................................... 210 8.1 YATES BEARINGS
8.7.5 Design procedure ...
..................................
REFERENCES ...........................................................................................................................................
Chapter 9
283 285
HYBRID PLAIN JOURNAL BEARINGS
9.2 PERFORMANCE OF THE HYBRID PLAIN JOURNAL BEARINGS .....
REFERENCES
Chapter 10 DYNAMICS 10.1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................. 301 10.2 EQUATION O F MOTION ............................................................................................................... 302
CONTENTS
Xi
10.3 PAD COEFFICIENTS ............................................................... ........................................ 305 ........................................ 305 10.3.1 Circular-recess pads ................... 10.3.2 Annular-recess pads ................... ....................................................... 307 ........307 10.3.3 Tapered pads .............................................................................................. 10.3.4 Screw and nut assemblies ................................................................................................... 308 .................... 308 10.3.5 Other pad shapes .........................................................
.........................................................
10.4.1 Direct supply (c
311
.................314 10.4.4 Spool or diaphragm valves.. 10.4.5 Infinite stiffness devices
.......................................................
320
....................................................................................................................
322
10.5.1 Transfer hnction 10.5.3 Frequency response ...................................................... 10.6 OPPOSED-PAD BEARINGS ....................................................
10.6.1 Direct supply (constant flow) .......................................
10.7 SELF-REGULATING BEARINGS ......................................................... 10.7.1 Constant flow feeding .......................................................................................................... 10.7.2 Constant pressure feeding ..................................................................................................
339 341 342
10.8 MULTIPAD BEARING SYSTEMS 10.8.1 Hydrostatic slideways ......................................................................................................... 10.8.2 Multipad journal bearings ..................................................................................................
344 346
10.9 MULTIRECESS JOURNAL BEARINGS ....................................................................................... 10.9.1 Analysis ..................................................................... 10.9.2 Non-rotating bearings, incompressible lubricant 10.9.3 Rotating bearing, incompressible lubricant ......... 10.9.4 Compressible lubricant ....................................................................................................... REFERENCES ...............
349
358
......................................................... 360
Chapter 11 OPTIMIZATION 11.1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................. 362 11.2 GENERAL PROCEDURE ............................................................................................................... 362 11.3 CONDITIONS OF MINIMUM ........................................................................................................
365
11.4 EFFICIENCY ....................................................................................................................................
365
11.5 DIRECT SUPPLY............................................................................................................................. 366 11.5.1 Steady pad .......................................................................................................... 11.5.2 Moving pad ........................................................................................................................... 373
.........................................................
11.6 OPTIMIZATION
11.6.3 Given load ........
................................
385
xii
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
11.7 REAL PADS ...................................... ...... ............... 11.7.1 Rectangular pad .................................................................................................................. 11.7.2 Other types of pads .............................................................................................................. 11.7.3 Circular pad ......................................................................................................................... 11.7.4 Annular pad ......................................................................................................................... 11.8 COMPENSATED SUPPLY .............................................................................................................. 11.8.1 Capillary tubes .................................................................................................................... 11.8.2 Steady pad ...........................................................................................................................
.................................................. 11.8.4 Dissipated power and efficiency losses...............................................................................
415 419 420 422 425 425 426 431 432
11.9 OPl'IMIZATION
11.10 OTHER TYPES OF COMPENSATING ELEMENTS ....... ........................ 11.10.1 Orifices ............................................................................................................................... 11.10.2 Flow-control valves ............................................................................................................
443 443 444
11.11 REAL PADS ....................................................................................................................................
444
REFERENCES ...........................................................................................................................................
446
Chapter 12 THERMACFLOW 12.1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................. 447 12.2 TEMPERATURES IN THE BEARING ...... 12.2.1 Temperatures in the film .................................................................................................... 12.2.2 Temperatures a t the film outlet .........................................................................................
447 449
12.3 SUPPLY PIPELINE .........................................................................................................................
456
12.4 COMPENSATING ELEMENTS......................................................................................................
458
12.5 PUMP ......................................
................................................
459
12.7 SELF-COOLING CAPILLARY TUBE ............................................................................................
461
12.8 VISCOSITY AND TEMPERATURE ...............................................................................................
463
REFERENCES ...........................................................
464
12.6 COOLING PIPELINES
...........................................................................
Chapter 13 EXPERIMENTAL TESTS
13.3.1 Electric analog field plotter
................................................ 13.3.5 Screws and nuts REFERENCES ......
469
xiii
CONTENTS
Chapter 14 APPLICATIONS 14.2 MACHINE TOOLS .........
.......................................................................... ....................... ............................................. ..................................................................... .....................................................................
...................................................................... 14.2.3 Feed drives ........ 14.2.4 Guideways and r 14.4 OTHER APPLICATIONS ......................
.............................................. .............................................
14.5 HYDRAULIC CIRCUITS............................................. 14.5.1 Simple layout ............................ 14.5.3 Multiple pumps REFERENCES .......
483 483 491 492 496 511 513
.............................................. 513
..................................................................... .....................................................................
APPENDICES A.l SELF-REGULATED PAIRS AND SYSTEMS.....................................
..................................................................... A.3.1 Resistances ..........
.............................................. ............................................... ...................527
REFERENCES ..
................................................
Author index
533
Subject index
537
List of main symbols
An inverted comma (') generally indicates that the relevant quantity has been made non-dimensional by dividing it by a suitable reference value (often the value in the reference configuration, when it is applicable); since the reference values may depend on the bearing type and on the type of supply system, only a few have been indicated below. Meaning of most frequently used subscripts: generally means 'in the reference configuration', that is, in particular, the centred or concentric configuration whenever it is applicable; in chapter 11 generally indicates a suitable (although arbitrary) value used as reference in the optimization process; means 'land'; mean 'maximum' and 'minimum', respectively; means 'restrictor' or 'recess'; in chapter 10 refers to the static equilibrium configuration, except for p s (supply pressure), whereas in chapter 12 refers t o the land area of a pad; refers to controlled restrictors.
effective area nondimensional effective area effective friction area land area recess area effective area of spool or diaphragm (controlled restrictors) land length a l L or ul(r4-rl) characteristic parameter of flow dividers (Eqn 7.49) pad width; squeeze coefficient (pad bearings) or damping coefficient (journal bearings)
B'
BO
b b' C C
D e F
Ff
f
BIL; B I Bo (single pad and selfregulating bearings); BI2Bo (opposed-pad b.) reference squeeze coefficient of a pad or reference damping coefficient of a journal bearing recess width blB radial clearance specific heat diameter displacement loading force friction force friction coefficient
LIST OF SYMBOLS
recess friction factor Qpc (chapter 12) see Eqn 12.7 actual value of axial play (opposed-padbearings) friction power nondimensional friction parameter reference friction power of a Pad H f I H f o(single pad and selfregulating bearings); H f l 2Hf0 (opposed-padb.) land friction power recess friction power pumping power (dissipated in a pad) pumping power total power see Eqn 6.58 or 8.32 film thickness normal film thickness (tapered pads) recess depth stiffness KIKo reference stiffness reference stiffness for capillary compensation stiffness of lubricant (Eqn 10.19) equivalent bulk modulus tilting stiffness stiffness of spring or diaphragm (controlled restrictors) speed enhancement factor speed parameter (chapter 11) bearing length recess length IIL moment; mass friction moment number of recesses; number of active turns (screw-nut assemblies) pitch
Pr Ps
Q R R*
R’ RO Ri Re Rr r r’
6 Sh
Si T Ta Tt? Ti
U V W wf2
wz X
a
8 8” Y
xv
recess pressure supply pressure flow rate hydraulic resistance; thermal resistance (chapter 12) nondimensional resistance parameter RIR, (pad bearings) reference hydraulic resistance of a pad RIRo (self-regulating bearings) Reynolds number hydraulic resistance of compensating restrictor radius inner to outer radius ratio rllr2 (self-regulating bearings) velocity parameter (Eqn 8.8) inertia parameter temperature ambient temperature temperature at the outlet of a land (chapter 12) temperature at the inlet of a land (chapter 12) sliding speed volume of recess and relevant supply pipe (chapter 10) load capacity hydrodynamic load capacity axial load capacity (tapered or spherical journal bearings; Yates bearings) displacement of spool or diaphragm (controlled restrictors) half-cone angle; thermal conductance (chapter 12) reference pressure ratio valve parameter load angle (spherical journal bearings); reference pressure ratio (selfregulating bearings)
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATlON
area ratio (infinite-stiffness valves) temperature rise 2(C&f-C,) pitch error non-dimensional pitch error (Eqn 7.67) eccentricity: e l h o or e l C axial eccentricity (tapered journal bearings; Yates bearings) damping factor clearance error (Eqn 7.20) circumferential length of inter-recess lands (multirecess bearings); flank angle (screws) helix angle; transfer function of a block (chapter 10); thermal conductivity coeficient (chapter 12) transfer function of the feedback block transfer function of the feedback block in the case of fixed restrictor
dynamic viscosity see Eqn 6.60 see Eqn 6.62 or 8.33 kinematic viscosity; Poisson ratio non-dimensional displacement of spool or diaphragm (controlled restrictors); stiffness ratio w 2 / w 1 (chapter 10) reference power ratio density restrictor parameter (Eqns 10.29 or Eqn 10.40) shear stress tilt angle; squeeze parameter (Eqn 10.52) squeeze parameter (Eqn 10.9) angular speed angular frequency characteristic frequencies undamped natural frequency
Chapter 1
HYDROSTATIC BEARINGS
1.1
INTRODUCTION
Hydrostatic lubrication consists in pushing a lubricant between the surfaces of a kinematic pair by means of an external pressurization system. This lubrication mechanism has now a well-defined collocation in the large field of lubrication engineering. In particular, it can be used instead of hydrodynamic lubrication when this last proves to be not very effective. The main advantages of externally pressurized lubrication are very low friction and negligible wear, whereas the only actual drawback is a certain complexity of supply circuits. Applications thus vary from large, generally slow, machines to small, generally fast, machines: this is also made possible by the wide range of kinematic pairs to which hydrostatic lubrication can be applied.
1.2
WORKING PRINCIPLE
It is well known that, to ensure the setting up and the persistence of a steady hydrodynamic pressure field in the lubricant separating the surfaces of any kinematic pair, two important conditions have to be met: - the mating surfaces must not be parallel; - a sufficient relative velocity must exist. When one, or both, of these conditions cannot be satisfied, a n “external pressurization” of the lubricant may be the solution: the pressurized field allows the lift and the bearing of the moving member on the fixed member of the pair.
2
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
Fig. 1.1contains an outline of the principle of "externally pressurized lubrication", which is most commonly referred t o as "hydrostatic lubrication". The recess (of which the projected area is A) of the bearing pad [ l l of the pair is fed by a pump; the bearing runner [21 is loaded by a force W (Fig. 1.l.a). When the pump begins to run, the pressure in the recess grows (Fig. l.l.b), until the "lifting pressure" p = W I A is reached (Fig. 1.1.~);at this point member 121 is lifted, a lubricant film builds up to separate the surfaces, and a flow Q is delivered, due t o the pressure step along the clearance (Fig. 1.l.d). Different loads lead to different values of the recess pressure and of the film thickness h (Fig. l.l.e, f).
Fig. 1.1 Hydrostatic lubrication: pressure diagrams and fluid film formation in an axial single-pad bearing.
To also sustain loads in the reverse direction, member [21 is put between two pads [l],as shown in Fig. 1.2. Now flows Q cause recess pressures p>O even for W=O: the system is preloaded (Fig. 1.2.a.). When a load W is applied, the pressure in
3
HYDROSTATIC BEARINGS
the lower recess [11] increases, and pressure in the upper recess decreases (Fig. 1.2.b). Consequently, a greater stiffness is obtained, compared with the single pad. When two, o r more, recesses exist, as in Fig. 1.2, it is clearly necessary to feed each of them by means of separate pumps; alternatively, a common source of lubricant may be used, but each recess must be fed through an adequate compensating device (restrictor). We shall deal extensively with this point in the following chapters. -b-
-a-
ri
tttlt t tr
Pr,
Fig. 1.2 Hydrostatic opposed-pad axial bearing: pressure diagrams.
Hydrostatic lubrication can be applied to every type of elementary pairs with one degree of freedom: prismatic pairs (Fig. 1.1; 1.2), rotating pairs (Fig. 1.12.a), helical pairs (Fig.l.1O.a); with two degrees of freedom: rotating pairs without side supports; with three degrees of freedom: prismatic pairs without side supports, spherical pairs (Fig. 1.13.b). Every type of motion can be carried out: plane (Fig. 1.1, 1.2, 1.3.a), spherical (Fig. 1.3.b), and general (Fig. 1.3.c).
1.3
ADVANTAGES AND DRAWBACKS
All contact between the surfaces of the two members is prevented by the externally pressurized lubrication; this produces several favourable effects:
4
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
- no wear practically exists; - friction can be very low, especially when the relative velocity of the surfaces is low; - no stick-slip exists; - stiffness can be considerable: i.e. a very slight variation in the thickness of the lubricant film may be obtained, for any given variation of the load; - the lubricant film produces an "averaging" of the roughness and the other defects of the mating surfaces; - no localized overpressure exists: the pressure field is uniform in the recesses (which are generally large) and decreases in the clearances; - the pressurized fluid film has high damping characteristics; - the effectiveness of the lubrication is hardly influenced a t all by thermal problems and by a n y variation in the speed regime; - every fluid may, in principle, be used as a lubricant; - the performance of the hydrostatic bearings is simpler to evaluate than in the case of hydrodynamic bearings, since the boundary conditions are, generally, well defined. The main drawback consists in the need for a supply system, a t medium o r high pressure, with the relevant control and safety devices. However, some sort of supply system is generally required in hydrodynamic lubrication, and even for rolling bearings. In Table 1.1 the hydrostatic slideways, journal bearings, and screw-nut assemblies are compared with analogous usual pairs, to give some rough direction for the effective use of externally pressurized lubrication.
1.4
APPLICATIONS
The first application of hydrostatic lubrication was carried out by the Frenchman L. D. Girard, who, in the second half of the last century, built a water hydrostatic journal bearing (ref. 1.1)and, subsequently, thrust bearings, too. In the second decade of this century, a hydrostatic annular thrust bearing was applied in a hydraulic turbine, see ref. 1.2, and Lord Rayleigh worked out the equations for calculating load capacity, lubricant flow rate, and friction moment for a circular thrust bearing (ref. 1.3). In the third decade an interesting and spectacular application of hydrostatic lubrication was that of the Hale telescope of Mount Palomar (ref. 1.4). Several authors, of whom D. D. Fuller (ref. 1.51, H. C. Rippel (ref. 1.6),and H. Opitz (ref. 1.7) deserve special mention, subsequently contributed to the development of hydrostatic bearings.
5
HYDROSTATIC BEARINGS
TABLE 1.1 Considerations on types of bearings. ~~
Types Characteristics
Design Availability of standard parts Finish and hardness of surfaces Space required Positioning accuracy Assembly Guard Cost (to manufacture) Cost (to install) Life Lubrication circuit Cost of lubrication circuit Supply pressure and pumping power
Axial pairs Radial pairs Helicoidal pairs (Slides) (Journals) (Screw-nuts) Boun Hyst Rol Hydy Hyst Rol 3oun Hyst Roll
3 3 4 4 2 5 1 4 2 5 3 4 4 1 4 3 2 2 4 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 2 3 3 2 3 3 2 3 3 3 2 3 2 3 3 2 4 4 2 2 4 3 4 3 3 2 4 3 2 3 2 4 3 2 3 2-31 4 3 2-31 Load 3-51 2-32 2-41 3 2 2-41 Stiffness 2-32 2-4' 3 3-51 3 2-41 Vibration damping 2-33 4 2 3 4 5 Friction coefficient and friction power 3-52 3 3-52 4 2 3-52 Stick-slip 5 4 5 5 1 5 Wear 5 3 5 3 1 5 (Rating 5 is best or more desiderable. Boun: Boundary lubrication; Hyst: Hydrostatic lubrication; Hydy: Hydrodynamic lubrication; Roll: Rolling elements). It depends on supply type. It depends on speed. 3 Whirl. &@: 5 4 2 4 3 4 3 3 3 3 4 4 3 3 4 3 2 1 2
4 3 4 3 3 3 3 2 3 5 2 2 2-41
3 4 3 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 3 3 4 3 3 2 3 5 4
3 4
3 2 2 2 2 2 3 3 3 3 4 3 3 2 3 5 3
Externally pressurized lubrication is a t present used in the entire field of mechanical engineering, from large machines, where speed is in general low, t o small high-velocity machinery. Certain characteristic applications will now be briefly listed. (i) Large machines Telescopes, radio-telescopes, big radar antennas, which must move slowly and accurately. A well-known example is the Mount Palomar telescope already mentioned: a 500 ton mass, which makes one revolution every 24 hours, supported by hydrostatic thrust bearings. Air preheaters for boilers of electric power plants: in this case the hydrostatic bearings are exposed to high temperatures. Rotating mills for ores or slags; thermal problems exist here, too.
6
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATlON
Machine tools (ref. 1.8), where medium or high precision is required t o move great weights; for instance large boring or milling machines. The moving carriages are supported by hydrostatic slideways and are sometimes driven by hydrostatic screw and nut assemblies. Hydrostatic steady rests for large lathes. Assembly lines, where the component parts are carried along on hydrostatic slides; this allows a very accurate positioning of the components. Structures, even of very large ones, which can be easily moved on hydrostatic bearings. (ii) Medium size machines Grinding machines, numerical control machine tools, machining centers, which require very accurate positioning and freedom from vibration. Due to the absence of stick-slips, and to the high degree of stiffness and damping of the pressurized fluid film, hydrostatic lubrication is particularly suitable for such machines. High velocity spindles; in this application hydrostatic bearings often prove to be better than hydrodynamic ones (particularly in the start and stop stages) as well as being better than the rolling bearings (where some problems are encountered, due to the effects of wear and to the high centrifugal forces on the rollers).
(iii) Small machines Precision balances, dynamometers: hydrostatic bearings are better than the usual ones, because friction practically vanishes at very low speeds, even in the case of alternate motion. Their use is particularly advisable for electrical rotating-field dynamometers. Vibration attenuators for measuring instruments. Frictionless oil seals; these seals may be useful in certain cases e.g.: distributors of lubricant for hydrostatic slideways, hydraulic cylinders for flight simulators. -a-
-b-
-c -
i-
w
t-----+--
. _
I
I
Fig. 1.3 Circular pad bearings: a- circular recess pad; b- annular recess pad; c- multirecess pad.
7
HYDROSTATIC BEARINGS
TYPES OF BEARINGS
1.5
Hydrostatic bearings may be classified on the basis of the direction of the load that may be carried. So we have: - thrust bearings; - radial bearings (journal bearings); - multidirectional bearings. Let us examine briefly the most common shapes.
1.5.1
Thrust bearings
(i) Circular p a d bearings. Figure 1.3 shows: -a- a central-recess pad; -b- an annular recess pad; -c- a multirecess pad. As rotary speed becomes very high, the behavior of pad -a- becomes "hybrid": hydrodynamic pressure, caused by centrifugal force, joins the hydrostatic pressure (see section 6.3.l(vi)). Provided each recess is independently fed, pad -c- may also sustain tilting moments. (ii) Opposed-pad circular bearings. When the load may act in two opposite directions, or when greater stiffness is needed, two circular pads may be assembled a s shown in Fig. 1.4.a. If the load has a prevalent direction, it may be found useful to select two different pads (Fig. 1.4.b). The bearing in Fig. 1.4.c is a "self-regulating" one; i.e., thanks to its shape, the flow rates supplied to the two halves of the bearing are always equal to each other. Consequently, only one supply device is needed. (iii) Rectangular p a d bearings. A number of shapes of rectangular pads are -a -
- b-
-c-
Fig. 1.4 Opposed-pad circular bearings: a- equal pads; b- unequal pads; c- "self-regulating" bearing.
8
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
shown in Fig. 1.5. If the pads are moving a t very high speed and have a fixed tilt, their behavior becomes "hybrid": a hydrodynamic effect (in the clearances) is added to the hydrostatic effect. As for the similar multirecess circular pad, the multirecess rectangular pad in Fig. 1.5.f can also sustain tilting moments. -a-
- b-
-c-
-e-
-f-
+I
-d-
I
Fig. 1.5 Rectangular pad bearings: a- equal sill width pad; b- different sill width pad; c-, d-, e- pads with rounded comers; f- rnultirecess pad.
(iv) Opposed-pad rectangular bearings. Some examples of this kind of bearings are given in Fig. 1.6: in case -a- the two pads are equal to each other; different pads are used in case -b-. (v) Tapered pad bearings. The conical pads shown in Fig 1.7 are similar to the circular pads in Fig. 1.3. They require less pumping power (but larger friction power) for the same load and radial size.
(vi) Spherical pad bearings. They are shown in Fig. 1.8. (vii) Screw-nut assemblies. In Fig. 1.9.a a hydrostatic screw-nut is shown, which may sustain loads in only a direction: the recess may be continuous (Fig. 1.9.b) or, more often, discontinuous (Fig. 1.9.~).In general, however, a double effect
9
HYDROSTATIC BEARINGS
-b-
-a-
Fig. 1.6 Opposed-pad rectangular bearings: a- equal pads; b- unequal pads.
I
- a -
'
I
-b-
Fig. 1.7 Tapered pad bearings: a- circular recess pad; b- annular recess pad.
device is needed, as in Fig. l.lO.a. It is also possible to have a self-regulating screwnut (Fig. 1.lO.b); in this case, a double-thread screw must be used. Note its similarity with the self-regulating bearing in Fig. 1.4.c.
1.5.2
Radial bearings
Fig. 1.ll.a shows a cylindrical pad; since it can sustain loads only in one direction, it should be considered to be a thrust bearing, in spite of its shape; the same goes for the opposed-pad bearing in Fig. l.ll.b. The assembly in Fig. l.ll.c, on the other hand, is able to sustain loads in all the radial directions including a certain angle; this angle is expanded to the whole turn for the multipad journal bearing in Fig. 1.12.a.
10
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
-b-
- a -
Fig. 1.8 Spherical pad bearings: a- circular recess pad b- annular recess pad.
-a-
-b-
-c
. _
Fig. 1.9 Screw-nuts: b- continuous recess; c- multirecess.
If the drainage grooves separating the pads are eliminated, the "multirecess" journal bearing is obtained (Fig. 1.12.b), which in general proves to work better than the multipad bearing. In this kind of bearing, if the turning velocity of the shaft is high enough, a hydrodynamic pressure field is superimposed on the hydrostatic field, shown in Fig. 1.12.b. This fact is exploited in the case of so-called "hybrid" bearings (Fig. 1.12.c, ref. 1.9), in which the recesses are reduced to a minimum to enhance hydrodynamic lift. They are designed to sustain the load by means, in the main, of the hydrodynamic effect a t the regime velocity, while the hydrostatic pressure field is used, in the main, to prevent any contact of the surfaces i n the startstop phases.
11
HYDROSTATIC BEARINGS
-a-
-b-
t t 1 Fig. 1.10 Double effect screw-nuts: a- conventional; b- self-regulating.
-a-
- b-
-c-
Fig. 1.11 Radial bearings: a- cylindrical pad; b- opposed-pad; c- double-pad partial journal bearing. 1.5.3
Multidirectional bearings
The bearings shown in Fig. 1.13 are able to sustain loads in the axial direction as well as in any radial one. Type -a- is made up of a tapered journal sustained by a multirecess sleeve; in type -b- the surfaces are spherical. In both cases, to sustain reversible axial loads, o r to ensure greater stiffness, two opposite bearings must be used. In the peculiar bearing in Fig. 1.14 the same lubricant supplied t o the recesses of the radial bearing is then used in the annular recesses of the axial pads; such an arrangement produces a reduction in pumping power.
12
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
c-
I
-
i
-a-
I
Fig. 1.12 Journal bearings: a- multipad; b- multirecess; c- hybrid.
-a-
I
Fig. 1.13 Multidirectionalbearings: a- conical bearing; b- spherical bearing.
Fig. 1.14 "Yates"bearing.
-c-
13
HYDROSTATIC BEARINGS
1.5.4
Bearing arrangements
Hydrostatic bearings are variously combined to build hydrostatic bearing systems. Figure 1.15.a shows a spindle which is sustained by a journal bearing on the right-hand side, and by a combined axial and radial bearing on the other side; whereas, in Fig. 1.15.b, the spindle is sustained by a pair of conical bearings. -a
-
-b-
Fig. 1.15 Hydrostatic spindle: a- with a journal bearing and a combined journal and thrust bearing; b- with two conical bearings.
Fig. 1.16 Hydrostatic slideway.
14
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
Figure 1.16 shows a slide sustained by a system of opposed-pad bearings in the vertical and horizontal directions. Figure 1.17 shows a special hybrid bearing in which a rolling bearing is combined with a hydrostatic one (the centrifugal oil feed is also shown). This arrangement allows the ball-bearing inner ring to rotate a t a lower speed than the shaft.
Fig. 1.17 Combined rolling-hydrostatic bearing.
REFERENCES
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7
1.8 1.9
Girard L. D.; Noueau Systkme de Locomotion sur Chemin de Fer; Bachelier, Paris, 1852. Vogelpohl G.; Betriebssichere Gleitlager; Springer Verlag, 1958; 315 pp. Lord Rayleigh; A Simple Problem in Forced Lubrication; Engineering, 104 (1917),617-697. Karelitz M. B.; Oil Pad Bearings and Driving Gears of 200-Znch Telescope; Mech. Eng., 60 (19381,541-544. Fuller D. D.; Theory and Practice of Lubrication for Engineers; Wiley & Sons, 1956; 432 pp. Rippel H. C.; Design of Hydrostatic Bearings, Pt. lt10; Machine Design, Aug.+Nov. 1963. Opitz H.; Aufbau und Auslegung Hydrostatischer Lager und Fuhrungen und Konstruktive Gesichtspunkte bei der Gestaltung von Spindellagerungen mit Walzlagern; VDW-Konstrukteur-Arbeitstagung, 1969 Stansfield F. M.; Hydrostatic Bearings for Machine Tools and Similar Applications; The Machinery Publishing Co. Ltd., 1970; 227 pp. Rowe W. B.; Hydrostatic and Hybrid Bearing Design; Butterworth & Co, 1983; 240 pp.
Chapter 2
COMPENSATING DEVICES
2.1
INTRODUCTION
It has been already pointed out that two bearings are necessary to bear loads in reverse direction. Two bearings are also needed if load is not coaxial with the bearing as i n Fig. 2.1.a (that is equivalent to a centered load plus a moment). Bearing runner [2] inclines on bearing pad [l], and may touch it on one side while flow leaks from the other side, This does not occur if member [2] is supported by two pads (or more, and not necessarily equal) and different pressures occur in the two recesses (Fig. 2.1.b). For this to happen, the supply system must allow for these different
-a-
- b-
tt'tttlLv Fig. 2.1 Eccentric load on hydrostatic pads: a-single pad; b- two-pad arrangement.
16
HYDROSTATIC LUBRlCATlON
pressures. In practice this may be accomplished in two ways: - by using a separate pump to feed each recess directly; this is commonly referred to a s the "constant-flow supply system"; - by using a common source of pressurized lubricant, which is carried to each pad through compensating devices (restrictors); since the pressure is generally held constant upstream from the restrictors, this is commonly referred to as the "constant pressure supply systems". Furthermore, certain particular types of bearings are proposed t h a t are "inherently compensated"; i.e. they have a built-in compensating device. In this way, they can be fed directly by a lubricant source (in general, a t constant pressure). From the foregoing considerations i t is clear that the proper working of the hydrostatic bearings depends on the correct selection of the devices which make up the supply system, as well as on the correct design of the bearing itself.
DIRECT SUPPLY SYSTEMS
2.2
Figure 2.2 shows a direct supply system. If the losses in the supply pipes are negligible, the pressure ps of the lubricant in each pump is the same as the recess pressure Pr. For any given flow rate Q, of a lubricant of viscosity p, the film thickness h is related to the recess pressure Pr (e.g. see Eqn 4.39). Since &=const., when load W grows, h decreases, while Pr increases. If a tilting moment exists (say because the load is displaced toward the pad [12]), pressure grows in [12], and decreases in [11]. Since Pr=Ps,because no restrictor can dissipate power, the system dissipates the smallest pumping power.
h
Fig. 2.2 Constant flow supply system: one pump for each bearing.
17
COMPENSATING DEVICES
In theory, the only limitation to the increase ofp,, and hence of the load capacity (and stiffness) of the bearing, comes from the power of the motor, and from the maximum allowable pressure in the supply system. In the last analysis, the constant flow system proves to be quite efficient. Its limit is of an economic nature, due to the need for a pump, with the relevant motor, for each recess. The problem can be partially overcome, particularly when all the pumps are equal, all being driven by means of a single motor. It is worth noting that this method also makes it possible to reduce the power required, lower than the sum of the peak power required for each pump. Figure 2.3 shows a particular arrangement (ref. 2.1), in which a motor drives a main pump (which steps up pressure to a n intermediate value) and at the same time a series of smaller pumps feeding the recesses. The delivery of the main pump is a little greater than the sum of the flow rate of the other pumps. Such a n arrangement makes it possible to reduce the pressure step in the pumps, and the related problems, especially in the case of gear pumps.
-
--
Hydrostatic Bearings
-.
--
-.--
j
Fig. 2.3 Constant flow supply system: double pressure step.
Another arrangement is shown in Fig. 2.4 (ref. 2.2). The main pump supplies the two (or more) bearings thorough a "flow divider" made up of the same number of equal gear pumps, connected by a shaft. A n eccentric load W tends to decrease the film thickness hz of bearing 1121 and to increase the film thickness of bearing [111; so the flow rate of gear [32], if disconnected, should tend to decrease, while the flow rate of gear [31] should tend to increase. The connection, forcing them to rotate at the same speed, make them produce the same flow rate.
2.3
COMPENSATED SUPPLY SYSTEM
The general layout of a compensated supply system is shown in Fig. 2.5. The lubricant delivered by the pump is sent to the recesses of the bearings through the
18
HYDROSTATIC LUBRlCATlON
u Fig. 2.4 Constant flow supply system: flow divider.
compensating devices (restrictors) Ri. The pressure p s upstream from the restrictors is kept constant by means of a suitable regulating system (pressure reducing valve). Of course, the pressure in every recess is always less than p s as a consequence of the losses in the restrictors. Many types of device can be used, with a fixed or defonnable geometry. In the following sections we shall see how the compensating devices work.
2.3.1
Fixed restrictors
Let us assume that the compensating devices in Fig. 2.5 are fixed laminar-flow restrictors (e.g. capillary tubes). When an eccentric load is applied, the clearance h2 of the pad [12] is squeezed, and so its hydraulic resistance increases. Hence, the total resistance of the series constituted by the restrictor R2 and the relevant clearance h2 also increases. Since pressure p s is held constant, the rate of flow must decrease, so the pressure step ps-pr2 must decrease a s the rate of flow, until pr2 reaches a value that balances the load. The contrary happens in the case of the lesser loaded pad [111. Orifices can also be used a s compensating devices. Unlike the laminar restrictors, their hydraulic resistance is no longer a constant. This leads to a slightly better performance of the bearing. This point will be dealt with further elsewhere (chapter 6).
COMPENSATING DEVICES
19
Fig. 2.5 Constant pressure supply system: one restrictor for each bearing.
2.3.2
Variable restrictors
Many kinds of restrictor have been proposed that are able to vary their own resistance, depending on the pressure step: more precisely, the hydraulic resistance should grow (often in a non-linear fashion) as the pressure step ps-pr increases; the contrary happens if ps-pPrdecreases. With reference to Fig. 2.5, it follows that, as thickness h, is reduced by the load, the recess pressure pr2 grows faster than in the case of the fixed restrictor; the contrary occurs in the case of the other recess. Consequently, a greater static stiffness of the bearing is obtained, i.e. any variation in the thrust is accomplished with a variation in the thickness of the film which is smaller as compared to that is found in the case of constant restrictors. The flow-pressure (load) and film thickness-load characteristics of certain typical restrictors are compared in Fig. 2.6 (ref. 2.3). It is easy to understand that the ideal restrictor (from the point of view of the bearing stiffness) should be able to deliver a flow rate which is proportional to load. Indeed, in this case, the film thickness remains constant. Certain controlled restrictors virtually behave in this way ("infinite stiffness") at least in certain loading conditions. Let us now examine some typical variable restrictors. (i) Elastic capillaries. The simple device in Fig. 2.7 is made up of a small diameter pipe, filled with a suitable rubber-like material, in which a capillary hole is
20
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
-a-
-b-
h
Q
w
w
Fig. 2.6 Flow rate (a) and film thickness (b) versus load for different supply systems: 1-constant flow system; 2- capillary; 3- orifice; 4- constant flow valve; 5- diaphragm-controlled restrictor; 6- infinite stiffness (h=const.).
Fig. 2.7 Plastic throttle. drilled (ref. 2.4). With any increase in recess pressure p r the hole clearly expands further, and the hydraulic resistance decreases. Elastic orifices have also been proposed. (ii) Spool-controlled restrictors. An outline of a cylindrical-spool valve is given in Fig. 2.8.a. The lubricant flows into the small clearance surrounding the spool [s], which keeps its balance due to the opposite thrusts exerted by the spring and recess pressure p r on area A,. As Pr varies, the length x of the restrictor varies too, and so does its hydraulic resistance. The shape of the valve may also be that seen in Fig. 2.8.b.
The tapered-spool valve in Fig. 2.9 works in a similar way (note that the aperture angle is very small). However, since its hydraulic resistance varies faster with x as compared to the preceding device, its performance is better (ref. 2.5). (iii) Diaphragm-controlled restrictors (DCR). In the device shown in Fig. 2.10, the lubricant is drawn through the annular clearance between the inlet duct and
the elastic diaphragm [ml. The device may be tuned by means of the adjustable spring [s] in such a way that the flow rate becomes almost proportional to p r , thus
21
COMPENSATlNG DEVICES
- b-
-a-
t
I
1
PS
1
ps
pr
Fig. 2.8 Cylindrical-spoolvalves.
Ips
\
Fig. 2.9 Tapered-spoolvalve.
t
pr
Fig. 2.10 Diaphragm-controlledvalve. approaching the "infinite stiffness" behavior for a certain range of loading conditions (ref. 2.6). (iv) Constant-flow valves. Many kinds of devices able to produce a constant flow rate are widely used in oleodynamic plants. The spool valve in Fig. 2.8 may also be
22
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
made to deliver a constant flow if it is properly tuned. To improve its performance, a reference restrictor RU can be added as in Fig. 2.11 (ref. 2.7). In order to fix the flow rate a t a certain constant value, it is necessary to ensure that the pressure step across RU does not vary when the load varies. Pressure p,, acting on the left side of the spool is balanced by pressure Pr and the thrust of the spring on the other side. If p r varies, the spool is displaced, changing the inlet resistance RU1, until a new equilibrium point is reached. Since displacements of the spool are small, compared to the compliance of the spring, Pu-Pr practically does not vary. By setting up the restrictor Ru (which in general is an orifice) it is possible to adjust the rate of flow.
Fig. 2.11 Constant-flow valve
The performance of this supply system is similar to that of the direct supply systems examined in sect. 2.2, except that: - the maximum value of the recess pressure (i.e. of the load) is limited by the supply pressure; indeed the device ceases to work properly when Ps-Pr reaches a characteristic minimum value; - efficiency is much lower, due to the great loss in pressure Ps-pr in the valve itself. (v) Infinite-stiffnessualue. The device shown in outline in Fig. 2.12 (ref. 2.8) is able to deliver a flow rate that is proportional to recess pressure Pr. The differential piston is in equilibrium due to pressures P r and p,, that act on different areas. Consequently, the piston searches for its own position of equilibrium, adjusting the inlet resistance until ratio pJp,, is equal to the inverse ratio of the relevant piston areas. Since the hydraulic resistance of restrictor RU is a constant, the rate of flow across it is proportional to p r . An infinite static stiffness is therefore obtained, until p,, approaches supply pressure p s .
COMPENSATING DEVICES
t
23
ps
Fig. 2.12 Infinite stiffness valve.
(vi) Electronic compensators. All the controlled restrictors cited above are driven by the recess pressure; new types of variable restrictors have been recently proposed (ref. 2.24) which are controlled by means of a n electromagnetic actuator. A feedback signal, drawn by a displacement probe which measures the film thickness of the bearing (or else by a load cell sensing the force which loads the bearing), is elaborated by a combination of proportional, integral and differential operators and then amplified in order to drive the actuator. The benefits of electronic control, confirmed by experimental evidence, consist in infinite static stiffness, very large dynamic stiffness and short settling time. moreover the system is not affected by fluctuations of supply pressure or lubricant temperature. (vii) Flow dividers. When two opposite pads have to be fed, as in Fig. 1.12.a, a flow divider may prove to be more effective than the use of a separate controlled restrictor for each recess. Most flow dividers are really based on the foregoing controlled restrictors. As an example, consider the device in Fig. 2.13. When the pressure in any of the two recesses increases, the spool is clearly displaced; hence the lengths of the restrictors vary, thereby increasing bearing stiffness (ref. 2.9). The behavior of the tapered-spool flow divider (Fig. 2.14) is similar, but its performance is better (ref. 2.10). Figure 2.15 shows the lay-out of a diaphragm flow divider (ref. 2.11). The restrictors are made up of the annular clearances between the diaphragm and the outlet ducts. If the stiffness of the elastic diaphragm is properly selected, a very high degree of bearing stifiess can be obtained.
24
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
pi Fig. 2.13 Cylindrical-spoolflow divider.
I
I
I 1
r
I
I
Fig. 2.14 Tapered-spool flow divider.
Fig. 2.15 Diaphragm-controlledflow divider.
"Infinite stiffness" dividers may also be proposed (Fig. 2.16),which are clearly based on the valve in Fig. 2.12.
COMPENSATING DEVICES
25
Fig. 2.16 Infinite-stiffness flow divider. 2.3.3
Inherently compensated bearings
The inherently compensated bearingsmain drawback of constant pressure supply systems is that a considerable fraction of the available pressure step is dissipated in the external compensating restrictors. To overcome this disadvantage certain inherently compensated bearings have been proposed, all of which are based on the same principle: the shape of the pressure profile in the bearing clearance is subject to change with load, due to the peculiar recess shape (Fig. 2.171, o r to the presence of a n elastic element, such as a layer of elastomer or a flexible metallic plate (Fig. 2.18). Let us take a closer look, for instance, a t how the bearing in Fig. 2.17.a (ref. 2.12) works. Its distinguishing feature is to have a recess depth h, that is comparable with clearance h; consequently, the pressure drop in the recess is no longer negligible and the shape of pressure profile is that represented by a dashed line. If a higher load is applied, h is reduced and the ratio hlh, increases; it is clear that the pressure drop now tends to concentrate in the clearance, and the pressure profile begins to take on the typical shape of deep-recess pads, characterized by a constant recess pressure, making i t possible to sustain a higher load without increasing recess pressure. Similar considerations could be made in the case of the tapered-recess bearing in Fig. 2.17.b (ref. 2.13):obviously, in this case, too, the recess depth must be comparable with clearance. These types of bearings create considerable manufacturing problems (precision machining of a very shallow recess); to overcome these, the bearing depicted in Fig.
26
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
2.18.a (ref. 2.14) has a flat layer of elastomer [l] bonded to a rigid base. Since pressure decreases from the center to the pad boundary, deformation obviously causes the development of a "recess" (similar to the one in Fig. 2.17.b) whose shape varies with load. The flexible-plate bearing in Fig. 2.18.b (ref. 2.15) works on the same principle; since it is all-metallic, it is free from problems like rubber-oil compatibility. -b-
-a-
Fig. 2.17 Inherently compensated bearings: a- shallow recess bearing; b- tapered-recess bearing. -b -
-a-
m
,I
\,
, , , , I,\, /
/
,
-
\ /
/
, ,, /
/
I
A 1
Fig. 2.1 8 Inherently compensated bearings: a- elastomeric bearing; b- flexible-plate bearing.
COMPENSATING DEVICES
27
Certain bearings have been proposed which have a built-in controlled restrictor. Let us consider the bearing in Fig. 2.19 (ref. 2.16). It is supplied at a constant pressure p s . Before entering the bearing gap, the lubricant flows through the clearance b around the tapered plug C , retained by the perforated elastic diaphragm D. Clearly, the bearing simply performs as if it were supplied by means of a diaphragm valve of the type already examined.
Q ? Fig. 2.19 Diaphragm bearing.
Inherent compensation has also been proposed for journal bearings. The bearing in Fig. 2.20 (ref. 2.17) is fitted with a bush [13 mounted by means of elastic rings [21 and baffles [31 in the casing [41. Before entering bearing gap h , the lubricant flows through variable clearance b.
Fig. 2.20 High stiffness journal bearing.
The bearing in Fig. 2.21 (ref. 2.18) is fitted with a hydrostatically-controlled restrictor (HCR). The bearing i s made up of an inner [ l l and an outer [23 sleeve fixed to a flange [3], and of a moving ring [4] between the sleeves. Oil, supplied at pressure p s , is restricted when i t passes through the gaps between the moving ring and
28
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
Fig. 2.21 Infinite stiffness journal bearing with a hydrostatically-controlled resmctor. the inner sleeve. The gaps can be changed because the outside of the ring is supported hydrostatically with oil supplied by another pump a t pressure p:. By adjusting p t the stiffness of the bearing can be made infinite. The self-regulating bearing in Fig. 1.4.c (ref. 2.191, on the other hand, is based on a different principle. It does not need any external compensating device and does not increase the number of degrees of freedom of the system. The lubricant supplied to the bearing divides into two parts, one flowing through the hydraulic resistance Rs=Rsl+Rs2and the other through Ri=Ril+Riz. Due to the particular geometry of the bearing, it is always Rs=Ri, whatever the displacement of the moving member, or load W. Consequently, the flow-rates in the two half bearings are always equal. This kind of bearing may be directly supplied by a pump, at a constant flow rate, a s well as by a constant pressure supply system. In the first case, it behaves just like a n opposed-pad bearing fed by two pumps. In the second case, it behaves better than the corresponding opposed-pad bearing fed through fixed restrictors. Its dynamic behavior is also very good. The self-regulating bearing idea is not the first to use a bearing clearance as a restrictor: a journal bearing with these restrictors was presented in ref. 2.20. As can be seen from Fig. 2.22 (ref. 1.81, the restrictors are the clearances of the small pockets, supplied at constant pressure, essentially diametrically opposite to the main pockets. Owing to the fact that lubricant through these variable restrictors may, in part, flow out of them (or vice-versa), the behavior of the bearing is only a little better than that of bearings supplied through capillaries and orifices. In the combined journal and thrust bearing in Fig. 1.14 (ref. 2.21) the journal bearing acts as a pair of compensating devices for the thrust bearing.
29
COMPENSATlNG DEVICES
Restrictor lands
No3
No4
No2
NO1
A,
I
I
Main pocket
I
No2
No1
I
No3
I
I
I
Gmove restrictor pocket
Supply hole
1
~ o 4
Fig. 2.22 Developed view of a hydrostatic journal bearing having integral variable restrictors. 2.3.4
Reference bearings
A small bearing r in Fig. 2.23, compensated by a diaphragm valve, has been proposed (ref. 2.6) to control the behavior of the large main bearing m by means of a spool relay s. The positioning accuracy of the main bearing is the same as the accurately manufactured and positioned "reference" bearing, and its stiffness is very high. -a-
-b-
Fig. 2.23 Reference bearing: a- beitring r controls the main bearing m by means of a diaphragm valve v and a relay s; b- the reference bearing is an interface restrictor bearing ri. and the diaphragm valve is controlled by a solenoid.
30
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATlON
A bearing which seems particularly suitable for use as a reference bearing is the "interface restrictor bearing" (ref. 2.22) shown in Fig. 2.23.b. It is enclosed by flat washer (made from low friction material) that prevents leakage of the lubricant, which flows radially to the central hole. The bearing may be supplied by a diaphragm valve, and this feature allows it to operate at large gaps with great stiffness and accuracy. Especially if external controlling force is operated by a solenoid, the bearing becomes an effective reference bearing.
2.4 2.4.1
THE COMMONEST SUPPLY SYSTEMS
Direct supply
Systems provided with a separate motor-pump (usually axial or radial pistonpumps) for each recess (Fig. 2.2) are not very often encountered, because of the relevant plant (and maintenance) costs. It is more common to find plants in which the pumps are driven by a single motor (as in Fig. 2.3), or are linked together to form a flow-divider, as in Fig. 2.4. The cost of these systems are lower, while at the same time maintaining the same performance, i.e. high load capacity and stiffness, and greater eficiency than in the case of the other types of supply systems.
A certain use may be foreseen for the self-regulating bearings (Fig.l.4) a s well as of systems of self-regulating pads (ref. 2.23) and self-regulating screw and nut assemblies (Fig. 1.lO.b) for their high load capacity and stiffness, and not high cost.
2.4.2
Compensated supply
(i) Fired restrictors. The most common fixed restrictors are laminar-flow restrictors, especially capillary tubes. They are easy t o find o r to build, and hence cheap. Hypodermic needles are sometimes used as capillaries, as well a s many types of small-diameter pipes of adequate length. Furthermore, their design is very simple, since their hydraulic resistance is proportional to their length (provided the latter is some tens times greater than the diameter).
On the contrary, there are bigger problems with the use of orifices, because their diameter is generally very small: apart from the fact they tend to be easily obstructed, this means a great sensitivity to manufacturing tolerances. Furthermore, in the case of the orifices, the system is more sensitive to any change in the temperature (i.e. in the viscosity) of the lubricant. (ii) Variable restrictors. Constant flow valves are sometimes used, even though they are somewhat complicated and costly devices. The reason is that they are easily available and widely used in many oilhydraulic plants.
COMPENSATING DE VlCES
31
For almost all the other controlled restrictors experimental applications are known (chapter 14). Diaphragm flow dividers, in particular, have been widely studied in connection with opposed-pad bearings, journal bearings, hydrostatic slideways and screw-nut assemblies. A wider use of such devices is recommended, since they are simple to build and their performance is excellent. (iii) Inherently compensated bearings. For almost all inherently compensated bearings only experimental applications are known.
2.5
HYDRAULIC CIRCUIT
Figure 2.24.a contains the layout of the hydraulic circuit of a hydrostatic system supplied at constant pressure. The system in the figure is made up of one (or more) opposed-pad bearing. A pump P driven by a motor M pushes the lubricant from the reservoir Sm in the intake line, in which pressure is kept constant by a relief-pressure valve V, which discharges the surplus lubricant. The lubricant, passed through a filter F, arrives a t the pads through the restrictors R, which should be as near a s possible to the pads for good dynamic behavior of the bearing. The lubricant then flows from the bearing to the collector S, and from this to the reservoir S m . Besides filter F, a strainer may be put a t point [l].After filter F a pressure gauge measures supply pressure p s . A pressure-sensing emergency switch is generally put a t the same point [ Z ] , which may, for instance, switch off the motor driving the moving members of the bearings if a pressure-drop occurs. An accumulator, preceded by a a check valve Vn, can supply the system during its inertia movements. Pressure gauges may be put after the restrictors to indicate the pressures in the recesses, but they should be switched off during running for good dynamic behavior of the bearing. If the gravity discharge is not sufficient, ever in large pipes, a n exhaust pump may be inserted a t point [4]. As will be explained more extensively later, lubricant is heated in the circuit, and especially in restrictors and in the bearing pads, a s a consequence of viscous friction. So, if natural cooling in the reservoir is not sufficient, a cooler may be inserted a t point [5], or a t point [l] if a close temperature control is required. The cooler may also be put in parallel to the reservoir. Thermometers T are generally inserted in the circuit, in particular after the cooler [5]. A temperature transducer, located a t point [3], may switch off the driving motor if temperature exceeds the admissible value.
If pads are provided externally with low-friction seals, a low pressure a t the film exit may pump the return lubricant directly to reservoir S m , thereby simplify-
32
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATlON
-a-
- b-
%& I! I
1
W a
I
a5
&
Fig. 2.24 Schematic diagram of a typical hydrostatic system supplied at constant pressure. a- Hydraulic circuit. b- Load versus eccentricity for the opposed-pad bearing, supplied: (A) through capillary tubes, (B) through constant-flow valves. For comparison diagram C is also presented of an opposed-pad bearing supplied at constant flow.
ing the return circuit. Further details in thus connected are to be found in chapter 14. Figure 2.24.b shows the non-dimensional load capacity W'=W/Ag, of the bearing in Fig. 2.24.a, versus eccentricity E=(ho-hi)lho,for certain values of the ratio P=p,dp,, ho being the film thickness and pro being the recess pressure for W=O; A, is the "effective" area of a pad. Diagrams have been drawn for the supply through capillary restrictors (A) and flow control valves (B). In the latter case, W' increases much more quickly than in the former case. For comparison in Fig. 2.24.b a n indicative diagram is also given for a bearing directly supplied a t constant flow (C): this bearing clearly behaves better, but in this case there is a pump for each recess, instead of a restrictor.
COMPENSATING DEVICES
33
REFERENCES
2.1 26 2.3 2.4 2.6 2.6 2.7 2.8 29 2.10 2.11
2.12 2.13 2.14 2.16 2.16 2.17 2.18
Siebers G.; Hydrostatische Lagerungen und Fiihrungen; Verlag Technische Rundschau, Bern, 1971; 75 pp. Kundel K., Arsenius T.; Cuscinetti Idrostatici; Rivista dei Cuscinetti-SKF',47 (19721, 1-8. Opitz H.; Pressure Pad Bearings; Proc. Instn. Mech. Engrs., 182,3A (1967-681, 100-115. Wiener H.; The Plastic Throttle - a Novel Component for Hydrostatic Sliding Bearings; Ball and Roller Bearing Engineering-FAG, 1974, N. 2; pp. 41-44. Morsi S. A.; Tapered Spool Controller for Pressurized Oil Film Bearings; Proc. Instn. Mech. Engrs., 184,l (1969-701,387-396. Mohsin M. E.; The Use of Controlled Restrictors for Compensating Hydrostatic Bearings; Advances in Mach. Tool Des. and Res., Proc. 3rd Int. MTDR conf,, Birmingham, 1962; pp. 429-442. Merritt H. E.; Hydraulic Control Systems; J o h n Wiley & Sons, N. Y., 1967; 350 PP. Royle J. K., Howarth R. B., Casely A. L.; Applications of Automatic Control to Pressurized Oil Film Bearings; Proc. Instn. Mech. Engrs., 176,22 (19621, 532541. Mayer J. E., Shaw H. C.; Characteristics of an Externally Pressurized Bearing Having Variable External Flow Restrictors; ASME Trans., J . of Basic Engineering, 86 (19631,291-296. Bassani R.; Divisore di Flusso a Spola Conica: sua Applicazione a Supporti Idrostatici; Fluid-Apparecchiature Idrauliche e Pneumatiche, lS,17 1-172 (19781,31-37. De Gast J. G. C.; A New Type of Controlled Restrictor (M.D.R.) for Double Film Hydrostatic Bearings and its Application to High-Precision Machine Tools; Advance in Mach. Tool Des. and Res., Proc. of the 7th Int. MTDR Conf., Birmingham, 1966; pp. 273-298. O'Donoghue J. P., Hooke C. J.; Design of Inherently Stable Hydrostatic Bearings; Proc. Instn. Mech. Engrs., Tribology Convention, 1969. Hirs G. G.; Partly Grooved Externally Pressurized Bearings; Proc. Instn. Mech. Engrs., Lubrication and Wear Convention, 1966; paper 21. Dowson D., Taylor C. M.; Elastohydrostatic of Circular Plate Thrust Bearings; ASME Trans., J. of Lubrication Technology, 89 (19671,237-262. Davies P. B.; Investigation of an All-Metallic Flexible Hydrostatic Thrust Bearing; ASLE Trans., 17 (19741, 117-126. Tully N.; Static and Dynamic Performance of an Infinite Stiffness Hydrostatic Thrust Bearing; ASME Trans., J. of Lubrication Technology, 99 (19771, 106112. Brzeski L., Kazimierski 2.; High Stiffness Bearing; ASME Trans., J. of Lubrication Technology, 101 (19791,520-525. Mizumoto H., Kubo M., Makimoto Y., Yoshimochi S., Okamura S., Matsubara T.; A Hydrostatically-Controlled Restrictor for Infinite Stiffness Hydrostatic Journal Bearing; Bull. Japan Soc. of Precision Eng., 21 (19871, 4954.
34
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
2.19 Bassani R.; A New Opposed-Pad Hydrostatic Bearing: the Flow Self-Regulating Bearing; Meccanica, 10 (1979, 107-113. 2.20 Geary P. J.; Fluid Film Bearings, A Survey on their Design, Construction and Use; SIRA, 1962. 2.21 Yates S.;Combined Journal and Thrust Bearings; UK Patent 639293, 1950. 2.22 Wong G. S. K.; Interface Restrictor Hydrostatic Bearings; Advance in Mach. Tool Des. and Res., Proc. of the 6th Int. MTDR Conf., 1975; pp. 271-290. 2.23 Bassani R.; Self-Regulated Hydrostatic Pads; Wear, 61 (19801, 49-68. 224 Ohsumi T., Mori H., Ikeuchi K.; Zmprovement of Characteristics of Externally Pressurized Bearings; Proc. of the Japan Int. Tribology Conf., Nagoya, 1990;pp. 1791-1796.
Chapter 3
LUBRICANTS
3.1
INTRODUCTION
Lubricants are put between two surfaces to prevent direct contact. They may be subdivided into solid lubricants and fluid lubricants. Fluid lubricants are used in hydrostatic lubrication; these may be subdivided into liquid lubricants and gaseous lubricants. Of the two, liquid lubricants are more frequently employed, including water, also utilized in the first hydrostatic experiments (ref. 1.1), and liquid metals, especially sodium. But the liquid lubricants most often employed are mineral lubricants. Nowadays synthetic lubricants are also used. Mineral lubricants are obtained from the distillation and refining processes of crude petroleum, which is separated into fractions of progressively decreasing volatility, with the elimination of the unwanted ones. Mineral oils are made up of hydrocarbons, i.e., compounds of hydrogen and carbon. Synthetic lubricants are produced by the substantial chemical modification of raw materials, which may also be obtained from crude petroleum. Mineral lubricants are mainly used in hydrostatic lubrication.
36
HYDROSTATICLUBRICATION
3.2
MINERAL LUBRICANTS
3.2.1
Types
Hydrocarbons, which mineral lubricants are mainly made up of, have three basic structures: paraffinic, naphthenic, and aromatic. Figure 3.1 shows their typical configurations. Paraffinic hydrocarbons generally predominate in mineral lubricants, followed by naphthenic hydrocarbons. Aromatic hydrocarbons are usually few in number.
If the percentage of carbon present in paraffinic chains is considerably higher than the percentage in naphthenic rings, the lubricant is called a paraffinic lubricant; otherwise, it is called a naphthenic lubricant. Even a small amount of carbon in aromatic rings helps boundary lubrication, owing to the presence of unsaturated bonds. -a-
-b-
H
-C
-
I
I
Fig. 3.1 Typical hydrocarbon configurations: a- paraffinic chain; b- the so-called naphthenic ring; c- aromatic ring.
3.2.2
Viscosity
Viscosity represents the internal friction of a fluid. Consider two layers in a fluid, a distance dy apart (Fig. 3.2). If we apply a tangential stress, ,z along one of these layers and observe a shear rate du ldy, with u as the velocity d x l d t , then we may define the differential viscosity as p~ (ref. 3.1)
Note that Eqn 3.1 does not imply that the ratio 6zZx/&duJ d y )is necessarily constant throughout the fluid or during the time of flow.
LUBRICANTS
37
Fig. 3.2 Laminar shear between parallel planes in a fluid.
If Sz,,/ &du l d y ) is constant and the shear rate is zero when the shear stress is zero, then a flow is said to be Newtonian. The conditions for a Newtonian flow are: (3.2)
du=O dY
when z = O
A fluid which conforms to Eqn 3.2 is called Newtonian. Indeed, we owe Eqn 3.2 to Newton.
Figure 3.3 illustrates a number of ideal shear rate curves against the shear stress of a Newtonian fluid (the straight line through the origin), a pseudoplastic fluid, a dilatant fluid, and a pseudoplastic material (for example a grease) with a yield stress (ref. 3.1, 3.2). I
Shear stress, Z
Fig. 3.3 Shear rate - shear stress characteristics of materials: A - Newtonian fluid; B - pseudoplastic fluid; C - dilatant fluid; D - pseudoplastic material.
38
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
Parameter p, defined by Eqn 3.2, is called dynamic viscosity. In system SI its unit is Ndm2 or Pas, in system c.g.s. it is dynes/cm2 or poise. Mineral lubricants and synthetic lubricants of low molecular weight are Newtonian in many practical working conditions. In many fluid flow problems the ratio
(3.3) is used, where p is the density of the fluid, v is the kinematic viscosity, its SI unit is m2/s and its c.g.s. unit is cm2/s or Stoke (St).
In selecting a n oil for a given application, viscosity is a primary consideration, especially from the point of view of its change with temperature. Various systems are used to classify and identify oils according t o viscosity ranges, including the "Viscosity system for Industrial Fluid Lubricants", devised by IS0 (Std 3448) and now coming into wide use. Viscosity systems establish a series of definite viscosity levels a s a common basis for specifying the viscosity of industrial fluid lubricants. Reference viscosities are measured in mmVs or cSt (centistokes) a t the reference temperature of 40°C.The viscosity ranges and the corresponding marks t o classify oils are shown in Table 3.1, for v=5.06+242 cSt. For comparison, the partial SAE (Society of Automotive Engineers) classification is also shown. The reference temperature of the SAE classification is lOO"C,and sUmx W is intended for use in cases where low ambient temperature is encountered. TABLE 3.1 Viscosity System for Industrial Fluid Lubricants. I
Viscosity System Grade Classification and Identification
Mid-Point viscosity Kinematic viscosity SAE Classification cSt (m2/s)at 40°C limits cSt (mm%)at 40°C Min Max
I S 0 VG 5 IS0 VG 7 ISOVG 10 IS0 VG 15 IS0 VG 22 I S 0 VG 32 I S 0 VG 46 I S 0 VG 68 I S 0 VG 100 IS0 VG 150 I S 0 VG 220
4.6 6.8 10 15
22 32 46 68 100 150 220
4.14 6.12 9.0 13.5 19.8 28.8 41.4 61.2 90.0 135 198
5.06 7.48 11.0 16.5 24.2 35.2 50.6 74.8 110 165 242
5w low 20w 30
50
LUBRICANTS
39
(i) Viscosity-temperature. The viscosity of liquid lubricants decreases with increasing temperature. Variations in temperature may be due to external causes and to energy dissipated because of viscous friction and changed to heat. The following is an equation of the viscosity-temperature relationship, which is simple but fairly accurate:
(3.4) where po is the viscosity at reference temperature To and p is a constant determined from measured values of the viscosity; its dimension is that of the inverse of temperature. Another widely-used equation is log log(v + a) = a - b logT
(3.5)
where a and b are constants, and a varies with the viscosity level. For viscosities over 1.5 cSt, a is 0.8; above 1.5 cSt, a is 0.6. Using this type of log-log relationship, charts have been worked out in which viscosity is represented by straight lines. In Fig. 3.4 Eqn 3.5 is plotted for certain typical trade lubricants, which have been classified in conformity with IS0 (in actual fact IS0 VG 46 and IS0 VG 68 fall a little outside the kinematic viscosity limits at 40°C). The diagrams refer to a Viscosity Index =lo0 or a little higher (ref. 3.3). Note that the log-log relationship compresses the scale for high values of viscosity, so a graphic error of 1% may produce an error of as much as 10 cSt. Ever since the Thirties, the viscosity index ( V n has been of practical use for the approximate estimation of the behavior of kinematic viscosity with temperature. It makes it possible to give a numerical value to such behavior. The viscosity index is based on two groups of oils. In one group, that is naphthenic in nature, VZ=O because of its sensitivity to temperature; in the other, that is paraffinic in nature, VZ=100 because of its lower sensitivity. Two oils are selected, one for each group, with the same viscosity a t 100°C as the oil to be tested. The viscosities of the three oils at 40°C are then evaluated. Taking L as the value of the oil with VI=O,H as that of the oil with VI=lOO, and U as that of the oil being tested, the viscosity index is given by the equation
u vz=L----loo L-H
(3.6)
A t present the VZ of mineral oils is often larger than 100, and as Eqn 3.6 gives largely inexact results for VZ>lOO, an empirical equation can be used:
40
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
Fig. 3.4 Viscosity-temperature chart for certain typical lubricants.
VI = lW0.00715 + 100 ~
(3.7)
where
N=
logH - l0gU logy
and Y is the kinematic viscosity in cSt a t 100°C for the oil being considered. The influence of different viscosity indexes on oils with the same reference viscosity is taken from Fig. 3.5 (ref. 3.4).
(ii) Viscosity-pressure. The viscosity of lubricants increases with pressure. A widely-used model of the viscosity-pressure relationship is
41
LUBRICANTS
-40
-20
0
20
40
60
80
100 120 140 160 180 200
TEMPERATURE .Dc
Fig. 3.5 Viscosity-temperaturebehavior for oils with different viscosity index
where po is the viscosity at atmospheric pressure and y is a constant determined from measured values of viscosity; its dimension is that of the inverse of a pressure. Indeed, pronounced deviations from the above relation are often encountered. Naphthenic oils are more sensitive to pressure than paraffinic ones.
A t hydrostatic pressures viscosity may be considered t o be constant with pressure.
3.2.3
Oiliness
Oiliness may be defined as the capacity of a fluid to adhere to the surfaces of materials. In usual conditions, especially if pressures are not high, the forces of molecular adhesion are sufficient. If pressures increase, adsorption of the fluid on the surfaces is then necessary. Adsorption occurs especially if polar molecules are present in the fluid, i.e. molecules in which a permanent separation exists between the positive and negative electric charges. Mineral lubricants are not very oily, which is particularly unfavorable in boundary lubrication.
42
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
3.2.4
Density
As is well known, the density of a liquid is the mass of a unit volume, generally calculated a t 15°C. In paraffinic mineral oils p=0.85-0.89 kgfdm3; in naphthenie mineral oils p=0.90-0.93 kg/dm3. Density varies with temperature and with pressure. (i) Thermal expansion. For a liquid, thermal expansion can be defined as the property of being changed in density with temperature. It can be stated approximately by the equation
p(T) = po 11 - a ( T - To)]
(3.8)
where a increases as p decreases; approximately: a=4.1.10-4 + 8.2.10-40C-1for p=0.22+0.01 Ns/m2. In hydrostatic lubrication thermal expansion is often negligible.
(ii) Compressibility. The compressibility of a liquid can be defined a s the property of being changed in density with pressure: (3.9) Compressibility can also be expressed as a change in volume with pressure; indeed, if V is the volume (of a mass M )of liquid, then from Eqn 3.9 c=---
1 dV
v dP
(3.10)
Compressibility changes with pressure and temperature; it also changes with molecular structure, but cannot be changed by means of additives, since i t is a physical property of the base liquid. Very often, instead of compressibility, its reciprocal is used: the bulk modulus
KL.Figure 3.6 (ref. 3.4) shows a method for predicting the bulk modulus of mineral oils: 1) with density pT calculated a t ambient pressure (105 Pa) and a t the desired
temperature T, Fig. 5.6.a defines the bulk modulus at pressure 1380.105 Pa; 2) with this bulk modulus enter into Fig. 3.6.b: a vertical line at the intersec-
tion with the 1380.105 Pa line gives the modulus at any other pressure and at the selected temperature.
43
LUBRlCANTS
-b-
-a-
E
5 cn-
2n
3450 3105 2760 2415 2070
p
1725
5
1380
3
m
1035
690 0 80 160 240 320 400 480 560 (-18 27 71 116 160 204 249 293)
/ / /'
p= 5 M
N
~
TEMPERATUREFF, (OC)
Fig. 3.6 Bulk modulus of mineral oils
For instance, let us consider a mineral oil with density p,=0.90 kg/dm3 at ambient pressure and at temperature T=40°C:its bulk modulus a t pressure -5 MPa and a t the same temperature is K1=1680 MN/m2. Alternatively, bulk modulus KLcan be calculated by the semi-empirical equation (ref. 3.6) K1= (1,44 + 0,15 logv) [10°.00235(20-n].109 + 5.6 p , Nm-2
(3.11)
where v is the kinematic viscosity in cSt a t a temperature of 20°C and at ambient pressure; T is the temperature in "C; p is the pressure in Pa. So, if the dynamic viscosity of the oil in the previous example is p 0 . 0 6 Ns/m2, from Eqn 3.11 the bulk modulus is K2=1570 MN/m2. Values of K1 obtained from Fig 3.6 or by means of Eqn 3.11 are fit for high pressures; nevertheless they can also be used, approximately, at mean and low pressures (the equation is preferable), as seen in the examples.
(iii)Gas solubility. Solubility of gases in liquids is a physical phenomenon which can be evaluated by the ratio
(3.12)
where Vgis the gas volume and Vi is the liquid volume, at the given partial pressure of the gas and at the given temperature.
44
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
Solubility varies with pressure and temperature. In Fig. 3.7.a solubility of air versus pressure is shown in a mineral oil (Mil-h-5606A) and in other liquids (ref. 3.5). Also at higher temperatures air solubility varies almost linearly. Figure 3.7.b shows solubility versus temperature in the case of certain gases in a mineral oil with p=850 kg/m3 The air dissolved may affect lubricant properties, such as viscosity which grows worse. The air dissolved in an oil comes out of solution when temperature and pressure decrease and may produce air bubbles and foam. - b-
-a-
MINERAL OIL
0
2
4
6
8
1
0
PRESSURE, M P a
0
25
50
75
100 125
TEMPERATURE PC
Fig. 3.7 Solubility of gases versus: a- pressure; b- temperature.
(iv) Air entrainment. Common causes of entrained air in a liquid are, for example, leaks in the pump suction or when the return line discharges liquid above its surface level in the reservoir. In any case, air is inevitably taken into a mineral oil as it passes into a lubricating system so that the oil in the reservoir may contain as much as 15%of dispersed air (ref. 3.7). In a large and suitable reservoir this air should be given up and reduced, after a fairly long time, to about 1.5%, and after a very long time to about 0.5%. But the air bubble content is rarely reduced to the desired levels.
Air bubbles, when compressed, go into solution, but not immediately. In Fig. 3.8, the percentage of air bubbles dissolved in a hydraulic oil is shown as a function of time, for certain pressures (ref. 3.5). We see, for example, that for p=3 MPa, after 1 second, less than 10% of the air bubbles go into solution. Thus, as a result of the oil velocity in the supply lines of hydrostatic systems (0.5t50 m/s and even more), these percentages are generally low.
45
LUBRICANTS
40
7 7
0
1
2
3
4
5
TIME , s Fig 3.8 Rate of solution of air bubbles in a mineral oil.
Air viscosity is low, i.e. p=1.78.10-6 Ns/m2 a t l0C and 0,981.105 Pa; therefore, entrained air affects the viscosity of oils. Fortunately, the effect is relatively slight, and can be expressed by the empirical relation
clp =
(1+ 0.015 B )
where B is the percentage of bubble content, po the viscosity of oil and pb the effective viscosity of bubbly oil. The air bulk modulus is also low, so the entrained air affects the actual bulk modulus of oils. The equation of state of a perfect gas (to which air may be assimilated) for an adiabatic process (to which the compression of air bubbles in mineral oils may be compared) is p VCP'~V = const.
(3.13)
where cp and cv are the specific heats a t constant pressure and constant volume, respectively. If Eqn 5.13 is introduced into Eqn 5.10, the bulk modulus Ka of air is obtained (3.14)
A t temperature T=40"C and a t pressure p=0.981.105 Pa, we have cp=1.0048~103 J/kg"C, and cv=0.717.103 J/kg"C; thus we have cplcv=1.401, and Ka=1.37.105 Pa. In
46
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATlON
the context of hydrostatic lubrication, the variations of cp with temperature and pressure are slight, while those of cv are negligible. Figure 3.9 shows cp /cv versus p for certain values of T (ref. 3.8), and the bulk moduli of the air at the pressures in Table 3.2 become those given in the same table.
0
1,96
3,92
5,aa
7,a5
9,ai
p , MNrn-'
Fig. 3.9 Ratio of specific heats of air versus pressure, for certain temperature values.
TABLE 3.2
(v) Apparent bulk modulus. Air entrainment affects the properties of mineral oils, especially bulk modulus, which greatly decreases. Indeed bulk moduli of mineral oils are clearly much higher (even more than lo* times) than those of air. It is possible to evaluate the apparent bulk modulus of a volume Vi of oil a s follows: (3.15)
in which Va is the volume of bubbly air uniformly entrained in oil, and whose bulk modulus is K, a t working pressure. If the lubricant contains 5% of bubbly air a t ambient pressure (it must also be taken into account that bubbles of other gases may also exist, which may be dissolved in oil in a greater proportion than that of air, as is shown in Fig. 3.71,for Eqn 3.13 at pressures given in Table 3.2 that percentage is reduced to the values given in
LUBRlCANTS
47
the same table. So, for Eqn 3.15, the apparent bulk moduli given in Table 3.2 may be assigned to the oil a t those pressures. The elastic deformation of the supply line may also influence the bulk modulus of mineral oils. For a circular pipe, the internal pressure ps causes a change in volume, which should be added to the change in volume due to the compressibility of the fluid when evaluating effective compressibility (Eqn 3.10) and hence the apparent bulk modulus. The equivalent bulk modulus of a metallic pipe is, approximately,
(rs is the internal radius of the pipe, ra is the external one, E is the modulus of elasticity and v is the Poisson ratio). Equation 3.15 may then be completed as follows:
(3.16)
For instance, let us consider a copper pipe, with ra=6 nun, rs=5 mm, and E=118 GPa, v=0.25; the equivalent bulk modulus of the pipe may be calculated a s Ks=10.2.109 Nlm2. For a steel pipe of the same dimensions, with E=206 GPa, v=0.3, we have KS=17.6.1O9N/m2. Generally, values of Ks for metallic pipes are much higher than the apparent bulk modulus Kla of mineral oils (see Table 3.2) so their influence may be disregarded. The same is not true for flexible pipes (also for high-pressure pipes made of hard rubber or FTFE with an interwoven sheet of stainless steel) as transpires from existing experimental results. Figure 3.10.a (ref. 3.9) shows the considerable increase in the inner volume of certain flexible hoses. Obtaining realistic design values of the apparent bulk modulus of oil in hydraulic hoses is quite difficult. Values of Kla in the 70t350 MN/m2 range can be found in the literature. Some results are shown in Fig. 3.10.b (ref. 3.5)for a woven hose with rs=6.4 mm: the experimental data are clearly scattered. Recent design practice in relation to equipment dynamic noise reduction has tended to encourage the use of hydraulic hoses in fluid power systems. This does not always seem convenient in hydrostatic systems, as a way of preventing possible dynamic instability. Elastic deformations of instruments (manometers), pressure reservoirs (accumulators) and other elements in the supply line may also influence the effective value of the apparent bulk modulus.
48
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATlON
-a-
"
48
n QJ 40 32:
I - 24 -
Y
/ 0
0
o o o
16-
o
e
810
15
PRESSURE, MNrn-'
20
0
I
I
I
I
4
8
12
16
20
PRESSURE, MPa
Fig. 3.10 Flexible pipes: a- Inner volume variation (for unit length) versus pressure; (i) internal radius rs=5 mm, rated pressure pN=26 MPa; (ii) rs=6.5 mm, pN=26 MPa; (iii) rs=5 mm, p ~ = l l MPa. b- Apparent bulk modulus of lubricant versus pressure: rs=6.4 mm, SAE R2 Hose.
(vi) Foaming. The foaming of a liquid is due to the air bubbles that collect above its surface. Common causes of foam are the same, but even greater, as in the case of entrained air. Foam in a lubricating system can cause a decrease in pump efficiency, vibrations, and above all inadequate lubrication.
(vii) Cavitation. In fluid systems "gaseous cavitation" refers to the formation in the liquid of cavities that may contain air or other gases. "Vaporous cavitation" refers to the fact that, if pressure is reduced far enough, the liquid will vaporize and will form vapor cavities (mineral oil vapors may contain volatile fractions of lubricants). The vapor pressure of a liquid depends on its temperature and decreases with it.
A t atmospheric pressure water boils a t 100°C, so its vapor pressure is 1.0128 bar; a t 21.1"C its vapor pressure is reduced to 0.025 bar. The vapor pressure of mineral oils is much lower than that of water, typically 6.10-4mbar at 4OOC; hence cavitation is less likely to occur in the case of these liquids. In Fig. 3.11 the vapor pressure of certain liquids is given as a function of temperature (ref. 3.5). Cavities are well known to be associated with nucleation centers such as microscopic gas particles (or microscopic solid particles which gases join to), and their development is caused by the rapid growth of these nuclei. Hydraulic liquids used in
49
LUBRICANTS
io'r
/ 1
0)
I E
E
m
Ba
> 40
80
(494
26,7
120 160 200 49 71 93
TEMPERATURE,
OF,
280 360 138 1821 (OC1
Fig. 3.11 Vapor pressure versus temperature..
conventional systems contain sufficient nuclei to ensure that cavitation will occur when pressure is reduced to vapor pressure. Cavitation damages hydraulic machinery and systems. Wear rate in particular can be greatly accelerated if cavitation erosion develops. Cavitation may also increase viscosity and reduce the bulk modulus of oils. In hydrostatic systems cavitation may also occur in the sills and in the recesses where depression occurs, and in the recesses where turbulence occurs, which also favours the formation of gases.
3.2.5
Thermal properties
(i) Specific heat. Specific heat in mineral oils varies linearly with temperature; it is: - for naphthenic oils, c=1850-2120 J/kg"C from 30 to 100OC; - for paraffinic oils, c=1880-2170 J/kg°C from 30 to 100°C. (ii) Thermal conductiuity. Thermal conductivity in mineral oils is: 0.133-0.123 Wm/m"C from 30 to 100OC; it also varies linearly with temperature.
50
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
3.2.6
Other properties
Pour-point is the temperature a t which a n oil ceases to flow freely. This is caused by the formation of crystals, mainly of a paraffinic type. The pour-point of paraffinic oils is a t about -1O"C, that of naphthenic oils a t about -40°C. Flash-point is the lowest temperature a t which the vapors given off by an oil ignite momentarily on the application of a small flame. The flash-point of naphthenic oils is a t about 170"C, that of paraffinic oils a t about 190°C. Acidity. Low acidity is advantageous €or reducing corrosion. Oxidation. High stability to oxidation is advantageous, because one cause of deterioration in lubricant oils is the formation of oxidation products. This also leads to a reduction of the life of the lubricant and to corrosive effects. Thermal decomposition. In the presence of oxygen, high temperatures may produce the thermal decomposition of mineral lubricants, which shortens their life. Figure 3.12 gives the approximate time-temperature characteristics of refined mineral lubricants, including oxidation (ref. 3.8).
1
10
10 Life, h
Fig 3.12 Approximate life-temperature characteristics of a mineral oil: A - oil without anti-oxidant; B - oil with anti-oxidant. 3.2.7
Additives
Nowadays lubricants often have chemical compounds added to them to improve them.
Viscosity index improvers are generally organic polymers which are soluble in oils, with a high molecular weight, such as polymethylmetacrilates. They cause a decrease or a small increase in viscosity a t low temperatures, and a substantial increase a t high temperatures. See also Fig. 3.5 and Fig. 3.13 (ref. 3.10).
Oiliness improvers are, for example, fatty acids. They have polar molecules, with a -CH3 group a t one end and a -C02H group a t the other. This latter group would be adsorbed on metal surfaces. Actually, owing to surface motion, and in the
51
LUBRICANTS
10
I
1 -
.In
0.003-
0
50
100 120
Temperature,%
Fig. 3.13. Viscosity-temperature characteristics of A - a plain mineral oil; B - a mineral oil with a viscosity index improver; C - a silicone fluid. presence of a metal acting as a catalyst, oiliness improvers seem to change into more complex compounds.
Foam additives decompose and, therefore, reduce foam. Common foam decomposers include, for instance, silicones and polyacrylates, but the best way to reduce foam is a suitable mechanical design. Pour-point depressants are generally complex polymers which coat the paraffinic crystals, thereby preventing them from increasing. Oxidation inhibitors, such as certain phenols, amines and olefines, prevent or reduce the formation of oxidation products. They also prolong the life of the lubricant and act as corrosion inhibitors. Corrosion inhibitors. Rust, a hydrate iron oxide, is a widespread form of corrosion. Corrosion inhibitors, such as sulphonates, generally form a protective coating on metal surfaces. Many others additives, such as detergent, dispersant and extreme-pressure additives, are used in lubrication; but they are of little importance in hydrostatic lubrication. More than one additive may be used a t the same time. It must be borne in mind, however, that indiscriminate mixing can produce undesired interactions.
52
3.3
HYDROSTATIC LUBRlCATlON
SYNTHETIC LUBRICANTS
The performance of synthetic lubricants is better than that of mineral lubricants, but the former are much more expensive. They are often used in extreme conditions, for instance in cases of high pressure or temperature. Synthetic lubricants include the following: Synthetic hydrocarbons; the polyolefins and hydrobenzene in particular, which have very good fluidity a t low temperatures, and a very good VZ. Organic esters; those of dibasic acids in particular, which also have very good fluidity a t low temperatures, and good thermal stability. Phosphatic esters, whose oiliness is very good and whose thermal stability is fair. Polyglicols, with very good oiliness, a high VZ and also fluidity a t low temperatures. Silicones (with a polymer-like structure, in which the carbon is replaced by silicon). They have a high VZ (see also Fig. 3.131, a high flash-point, a low pourpoint, high thermal stability and oxidation stability and a good anti-foam performance. On the other hand, their oiliness is poor. Various synthetic lubricants may be used as additives. On lubricants see also ref. 3.11.
REFERENCES 3.1
39 3.3 3.4
3.6 3.6
3.7
Dorinson A., Ludema K. C.; Mechanics and Chemistry in Lubrication; Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1985; 634 pp. O'Connor J., Boyd J.; Standard Handbook of Lubrication Engineering; Mc Graw-Hill, New York, 1968. Wills J. G.; Lubrication Fundamentals; M. Dekker Inc., New York, 1980; 465 PP. Booser E. R.; Handbook of Lubrication, 2nd Vol.; CRS Press, Boca Raton (Florida), 1984; 689 pp. McCloy D., Martin H. R.; Control of Fluid Power; Ellis Horwood Ltd., Chichester, 1980; 505 pp. Liste des Caractkristiques Exigkes pour les Fluides Olkohydrauliques; CETOP (ComitB Europben des Transmissions Olbohydrauliques e t Pneumatiques), London, 1971. Fowle T; Aeration in Lubricating Oils; Tribology International, 14 (19811, 151157.
LUBRICANTS
53
Raznyevich K.;Tables et Diagrammes Thermodynamiques; Eyrolles, Didion, 1970. 3.9 Speich H., Bucciarelli A.; L’Oteodinamica; Techniche nuove, 1971; 727 pp. 3.10 Neale J. M.;Tribology Handbook; Butterworths, London, 1973. 3.11 Lansdown A. R.; Lubrication. A Practical Guide to Lubricant Selection; Pergamon Press, Oxford, 1982; 252 pp. 3.8
Chapter
4
BASIC EQUATIONS
4.1
INTRODUCTION
This chapter contains the equations which constitute the basis for calculating the performance of hydrostatic bearings, which will be the subject of the following chapters. Specialized publications may be consulted for a more detailed analysis, such a s ref. 4.1 for viscous fluid mechanics and ref. 4.2 and ref. 4.3 for lubrication theory. Those primarily interested in the results applied to the most common types of bearings, may prefer to omit this chapter.
dx
Fig. 4.1 Equilibrium of a fluid element along direction x. 4.2 4.2.1
NAVIER-STOKES AND CONTINUITY EQUATIONS Rectangular coordinates
Let us consider a fluid element (Fig. 4.1).Along each coordinate axis we can write a n equilibrium equation, expressing the balance of the relevant components of the body force, the external action on the element surfaces, and the inertia force. A set of equations is obtained, which may be written in vector form a s follows:
BASlC EQUATlONS
Dv p E =pf+Vo
55
(4.1)
In the preceding statement (generally called the momentum equation), f is the body force per unit mass, V o is the divergence of the stress tensor, v is the velocity vector. D/Dt means the total (also called "material") time derivative:
In order to reduce the number of unknowns, one must resort to the constitutive equations of the medium. Here we shall consider isotropic fluids alone, with a linear relationship between stresses and strain rates (Stokes law of friction) and with no bulk viscosity (Stokes approximation). On these assumptions, the constitutive equations may be written in the following form:
The tensors I and Dq are the unit tensor and the so-called strain rate deviator
respectively. With these equations, we have implicitly defined "pressure" p as the opposite of the mean principal stress and "viscosity" p a s the coefficient of proportionality between the shearing stresses and the shearing strain rates ( S i j is the well-known Kroneker delta). The "Navier-Stokes" equations are obtained by combining Eqn 4.1and Eqn 4.2:
where u, u, w and X,Y, Z are the components of the velocity vector and of the body force (per unit mass), respectively. Since four unknowns are involved (namely, the velocity components and the pressure), another equation is needed: this is the "continuity" equation, expressing the balance of the mass flowing through a n infinitesimal control volume:
P+a
(PU) +
a
ay (pv)+
a
(pw) = 0
(4.4)
56
HYDROSTATICLUBRICATION
In the field of hydrostatic lubrication, the lubricant parameters p and p can, in the large majority of cases, be regarded as constants, but they are, generally speaking, functions of pressure and of temperature. When the dependence on temperature cannot be disregarded, a further equation is required to define the problem completely, i.e. the equation which expresses the energy balance. When, on the other hand, p and p are constant, and the body forces are negligible, the NavierStokes equations simply become:
where the Laplace operator V2 is defined as:
The continuity equation is reduced to
vv =o
4.2.2
(4.6)
Cylindrical coordinates
In many cases it proves to be convenient to use cylindrical coordinates (Fig. 4.2.a). Transforming Eqn 4.5 and Eqn 4.6 for z=r COSB,y=r sin6, the following is obtained:
(4.7)
and (4.8)
In the equations above, u, u and w are the radial, tangential and axial components of the velocity. The operators DDt and V2 become
57
BASIC EQUATIONS
~a = - + + - + -a- +vw - a ~t
at
a
az
ar rat9
-b-
Fig. 4.2 Coordinate systems: a- cylindrical coordinates; b- spherical coordinates. Spherical coordinates
4.2.3
In t h e spherical coordinate system of Fig. 4.2.b (i.e.: x = r s i n q cos19, y=r sinq sinI9, z=r cosq) the Navier-Stokes and continuity equations become:
(4.9)
and
_i _ a r2
i
a
(U r2)+ - at9 (v r sinq
where
1
aw
sinq) + -r sinq 329 =
(4.10)
58
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
The symbols u , u , and w now indicate the components of the fluid velocity in the r, Q and 0 directions, respectively.
4.3 4.3.1
THE REYNOLDS EQUATION Rectangular coordinates
In the field of fluid film lubrication we are involved in most cases with the study of thin films (Fig. 4.3).In this connection, the complexity of the Navier-Stokes equations may be greatly reduced, thanks to the following considerations: - the thickness of the fluid film (in the y direction, in Fig. 4.3)is small, compared to its size in the other directions; - consequently, the pressure, as well as the density and the viscosity, may be averaged alongy: i.e. it is stated that aplay=O,arlay=O, apJay=O; - compared to aulay and awldy all the other velocity gradients are negligible; this is justified because u and w are generally much greater than u , and the film thickness along y is small; - the flow is laminar: no turbulence nor vortex exists; - the body forces are negligible compared to the viscous forces; - the inertia terms, too, are negligible compared to the viscous forces, i.e.
Du/Dt=Du/Dt=Dw/Dt=O; - on the surfaces bounding the fluid film, the velocity of the lubricant coincides with
the velocity of the surfaces. Accepting the foregoing assumptions, the second of Eqns 4.3 can be released, while the others become:
/-
2
Fig. 4.3 Thin fluid film.
t
59
BASIC EOUATlONS
14.11)
az The first of Eqns 4.11 may now be integrated twice, with the boundary conditions u=U1 for y=O and u=U2 for y=h, to obtain the component of the fluid velocity in the x direction:
u = L*y 2 Dax 0, - h) + (1 - f ) Ul + f U2
(4.12)
In the same way the component (4.13)
is found, from the second of Eqns 4.11, with the boundary conditions w=O for y=O and y=h (in other words, we have assumed that the surfaces of the pair do not slide in the z direction). Let us now integrate the continuity equation (Eqn 4.4) along the thickness of the fluid film:
h
h
h
h
Substituting the above expressions for u and w and using V=u(h)-v(0)to indicate the squeeze velocity of the surfaces, it is easy to find:
$(?$) + $(?$)
= 6 $ [ p h (U1+U2)] - 12 p U 2ahz+ 12 p V +12
h
(4.14)
Equation 4.14 is the generalized Reynolds equation, which is characteristic of hydrodynamic lubrication (see also ref. 4.4). Concerning plane hydrostatic bearings, velocities U1 and U2 of the surfaces often do not depend on the coordinates; furthermore, it is generally assumed that the density and the viscosity of the lubricant do not appreciably vary in the film. Since velocity V may be written as
equation 4.14 is simplified to
60
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATlON
(4.15) where we have stated U=Ul+U2. Equation 4.14 is still valid when the lubricant film is not flat, on the condition that its thickness is much smaller than the curvature radius of the bounding surfaces. Let us consider a journal rotating in a sleeve (Fig. 4.4): D is the diameter of the bearing and C c c D is the radial play. If x=6D/2 and y are the tangential and radial coordinates, respectively, Eqn. 4.14 is valid; however, it is important to note that, in general, U and V may not be considered independent from 6. The velocity of any point of the journal surface is the vectorial sum of the velocity of its axis (we assume that it always remains parallel to the axis of the sleeve) and of the turning velocity R=const. around the same axis. Referring to Fig. 4.4, i t transpires that, because the film is very thin, the tangential and radial components of the journal velocity may be written as:
(4.16)
Fig. 4.4 Thin fluid film between cylindrical surfaces.
When we have stated p=const., p=const., U1=0,Eqn. 4.14 becomes: (4.17) From Eqns. 4.16, it is clear that V=dUla&&?ahlals; since h
BASIC EQUATIONS
61
After having substituted Eqns 4.16 and the film thickness:
h = C [l-E C O S ( ~ $ ) ] ; we finally obtain
In the last equation, the term proportional to sin2(6-@)may also be disregarded, since, on average, it is much smaller than the others.
4.3.2
Cylindrical coordinates
Let us consider a thin plane clearance: when we state the usual simplificative hypotheses above, the Navier-Stokes equations (Eqns 4.7), are reduced to the following:
(4.19)
In the first equation the inertia term pv2/r has been retained, since i t may prove not to be negligible at high turning velocity, as will be shown in sect. 6.2.1. Integrating the second of Eqns 4.19, with the boundary conditions v(O)=O, v(h)=V,the tangential velocity of the fluid is obtained: (4.20)
Substituting it in the &st of Eqns 4.19 and integrating for u(O)=O, u(h)=U,the radial velocity turns out to be (after further simplification): (4.21)
Let us now integrate the continuity equation (Eqn 4.8) along the film thickness:
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
62 h
Substituting in it Eqn 4.20 and Eqn 4.21, the Reynolds equation i s obtained:
+ 1 2 p W + 3~ ; z~( h 3 V 2 ) (4.22) where W=h=w(h)-w(O)is the squeezing velocity of the surfaces. If the upper surface does not slide, but rotates around the z axis at a constant speed 0, it is U=Oand V=r; Eqn 4.22 now becomes:
Equation 4.22 may also be used for a conical film, provided the thickness of the film is much smaller than the minimum curvature radius, i.e. all the points of the domain are far enough from the vertex of the cone. With reference to the coordinate system in Fig. 4.5, Eqn 4.22 may be rewritten as:
If we now assume that the axes of the conical surfaces bounding the lubricant film always remain parallel (i.e. the thickness of the film does not depend on r), and that the turning velocity of the journal is Ckconst., it is possible to obtain simple expressions for U,V , W. The velocity of each point of the surface of the journal is the vectorial sum of the velocity of its axis, plus the turning velocity around the same axis; hence, the velocity components are:
u = E c sina cos(++) + E 4 c sina sin(+@)- R t V = - E C sin(+@ + E
~ cos(+$) C
+0
ah
g a s + V , cosa
r sina
w = - E C cosa cos(99) - E 4 C cosa sin(+$) + O ah,x + V , sina
(4.25)
BASIC EQUATIONS
63
Fig. 4.5 Thin fluid film between conical surfaces.
In Eqns 4.25 V, is the axial velocity of the journal (squeeze velocity) and C& t g a is the radial play. Let us now introduce Eqns 4.25 in Eqn 4.24.Taking into account that yl=&ina, hn=C cosafl-e cos(&$)], and that for all the domain being considered i t is C<
+ 12 p V, sina + 35;P hnlZ 3 sina [lZ r sina - C & sin(+@)- C E 4 cos(+$)]
(4.26)
As for the journal bearings, the term that is proportional to sins(&-$)may be discarded, since, on average, i t is much smaller than the others.
64
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
4.3.3
Spherical coordinates
Let us write the Reynolds equation for a thin film between two spherical surfaces, whose diameters are D and D-2C, respectively, with C
(4.27)
where we have made the coordinate change r=D/2-6. Furthermore, we have assumed that the rotational velocity of the surfaces are small enough to allow cancellation of the inertia terms. If we assume that the outer sphere is stationary, the boundary velocities are:
In this case, we use U,V, W to indicate the radial and tangential (in the cp and 19 directions, respectively) components of the velocity of a generic point of the inner spherical surface. From Eqns 4.27 it is easily obtained:
(4.28)
Substituting velocities u and w in the continuity equation
and integrating it along the film thickness, the Reynolds equation is obtained:
For the sake of simplicity, we shall limit ourselves to the steady-state case, in which the velocity of the points of the inner surface is due solely to rotation around a
65
BASIC EQUATIONS
diameter that is assumed to remain parallel to the axis z=(p=O), whatever the displacement of its center is. Hence the components of the velocity of a point of the journal are:
Substituting them in Eqn 4.29, it is reduced to:
(4.30)
4.4
THE LAPLACE EQUATION
It is well known that, if no external pressurization of the lubricant is provided, the film of lubricant cannot sustain any load when one of the following circumstances occurs: - no squeeze nor sliding relative velocity of the surface exists (V=U=O); - a sliding velocity exists, but thickness h is a constant all over the film of lubricant. In this case, Eqn 4.15 is reduced to: (4.31)
-a-
-
-b-
Fig. 4.6 Hydrostatic bearings: a- without recess; b- with recess. Pressure profiles are also represented
66
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
which is the so-called Laplace equation, for which, as is well known, only one solution exists when the value of p on the boundary is assigned. Furthermore, if p is a constant on the entire boundary (e.g. the atmospheric pressure), it takes on the same value on all the inner points as well. So, if the boundary pressure is the atmospheric pressure, a source of pressurized lubricant must be provided to ensure a lubricant film between the surfaces, as in Fig. 4.6.a; this is precisely the principle of hydrostatic lubrication. In Fig. 4.6.b a recess is widened around the source, in which the pressure is constant. Of course, both the hydrostatic and the hydrodynamic pressure fields may exist a t the same time, a s in the so-called "hybrid" bearings.
4.5
LOAD CAPACITY, FLOW RATE, FRICTION
4.5.1
Load capacity
The load capacity W of a film of lubricant is defined as the resultant of the pressure field. Hence, if A is the surface on which the pressure acts, and n is its normal direction. it is:
4.5.2
Flow rate
Integrating the velocity components (Eqn 4.12 and Eqn 4.13) between y=O and y=h, the components of the flow rate per unit length q are obtained:
(4.32)
(it should be borne in mind that Eqn 4.12 and Eqn 4.13, and consequently Eqns 4.32, refer to the case of two planes sliding one on the other in the x direction). For a system of polar coordinates, Eqns 4.32 are best substituted by the following:
(4.33)
where it has been assumed that the upper surface (z=h)of the pair rotates around the z axis.
BASIC EQUATIONS
67
To obtain the volume flow rate of lubricant crossing a certain contour S, whose external normal direction is n,it is necessary to integrate the scalar product qn:
Q = Jq.n dS S
4.5.3
Friction
In connection with bearings, it is important to evaluate the friction forces on the surfaces. The shearing stresses in the lubricant can be found by means of the constitutive equations (Eqn 4.2). On the basis of the assumptions stated in section 4.3, they are reduced to:
i.e. to the well-known Newton formula of the shear stress (see also sect. 3.2). Substituting Eqn 4.12 and Eqn 4.13 in these equations, we obtain:
(4.34)
When the pressure field is known, (that is after the relevant Reynolds equation has been solved), Eqns 4.34 directly give the shearing stresses in the film of lubricant between two surfaces sliding with a relative velocity U=U2-U1 in the x direction. The stresses on the surface y=O are, therefore,
On the opposite surface (y=h)we have:
68
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
Integrating shear stress z, one obtains the tangential force on the surfaces. Hence in the direction of the sliding velocity, the total drag is: (4.35)
the upper sign referring to the fixed surface (y=O), the lower to the moving surface (y=h). In a very similar way, i t is possible to evaluate the friction moment which acts on two surfaces rotating around a common axis, with a relative velocity Lk (4.36)
4.6
THE ENERGY EQUATION
As has been already pointed out, the characteristics of a fluid depend on temperature T.In particular, for the most common lubricants, the variation in viscosity is notable, even for temperature changes of few degrees. Thus, in order to carry out a rigorous analysis, ,u should be considered a s a function of the temperature, and a new equation is required to compensate for the introduction of the new unknown.
The energy equation is obtained by imposing the energy balance for a n infinitesimal control volume. Assuming that heat radiation is negligible and that no heat is generated in the fluid (except for the dissipation of mechanical work due to shearing), we obtain (ref. 4.2): (4.37)
In the equation above, the left-hand side is the rate of change in internal energy of the fluid (c being its specific heat). On the right-hand side, the first term accounts for the power due to the expansion in volume of the fluid; the second term accounts for the heat conduction in the fluid (k being the coefficient of thermal conductivity); the last term is the dissipation of mechanical power. Since the energy equation must be applied to the thin films typical of hydrostatic and hydrodynamic lubrication, some further simplification can be introduced: - the specific heat is a constant (since no great temperature change is expected), as well as coefficient k;
69
BASIC EQUATIONS
-the fluid is considered to be incompressible (hence Eqn 4.6 is valid); - only steady-state conditions are considered (i.e. aT/dt=O). Introducing Eqn 4.2 in Eqn 4.37, we obtain:
As in section 4.3, it is possible to disregard all the velocity gradients, except for au& and awlay. Furthermore, heat conduction in the x and z direction is small, compared to the convective term; thus Eqn 4.38 becomes: (4.39) Heat conduction may sometimes be totally disregarded (i.e. k=O) as well as the heat transfer to the boundaries (adiabatic flow).
A similar equation may be obtained in cylindrical coordinates. Limiting ourselves to axial-symmetric configurations, we find: (4.40)
4.7
LAMINAR FLOW THROUGH CHARACTERISTIC CONFIGURATIONS
4.7.1
Parallel surfaces
Let us consider a plane surface of infinite length moving on another with velocity U (Fig. 4.7.a). The velocity of the lubricant is obtained from Eqn 4.12: (4.41) When U=O, the velocity profile is a parabola, whose axis of symmetry is y = h / 2 (pressure flow, or "Poiseuille flow"). In general, the linear term Uy / h (shear flow or "Couette flow") has to be added to the parabola. In Fig. 4.7.b the velocity profile is plotted for certain values of the non-dimensional pressure gradient
P*
=& (-g)
When p*
70
HYDROSTATICLUBRICATlON
-a-
-b-
Yt
L
a
J
Fig. 4.7 Flow between infinite-length parallel surfaces: a- pressure profile; b- velocity profiles. by imposing aufay=O on the lower surface. The point of inversion y* is easily found by stating u(y*)=O, i.e.:
The Reynolds equation (Eqn 4.15), for h=const., is simply reduced to:
which, integrated twice with the boundary conditions p = p 1 for x=O and p=p2 for x=a gives the linear relationship: X
P = P 1 - @ 1 -P2),
(4.42)
The flow rate per unit length is, from the first of Eqns 4.32 and from Eqn 4.42:
For a length L, the flow rate is:
The "hydraulic resistance" of the clearance may be defined as the ratio of the pressure drop to the flow rate in the Poiseuille flow. So, from Eqn 4.43, for U=O, we obtain:
71
BASIC EQUATIONS
(4.44)
The tangential force on the moving surface is given by Eqn 4.35:
It should be stressed that, in order that flow is laminar as presumed, Reynolds number ReZPuh P
(4.45)
u
should be lower than the critical value Re=2300.In Eqn 4.45 is the mean velocity
4.7.2
Infinite-length rectangular pad.
Let us consider a segment L of a hydrostatic pad of infinite length, as in Fig. 4.8. The recess is bounded by two clearances. If we now use p to indicate the relative pressure in the clearances, and p r to indicate the relative recess pressure (which can be considered to be constant, since the recess depth is much greater than the thickness of the film), from Eqn 4.42 we get: (4.46)
The load capacity of the pad is found by integrating the pressure on the two land areas and adding the contribution prLb of the recess: ~ r 2
(4.47)
The total flow of the pad is found from Eqn 4.43: 11
L
&=-3 P h3 ~ -Prb The hydraulic resistance may therefore be defined as
(4.48)
72
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
Fig. 4.8 Hydrostatic pad of infinite length.
Note that, in Eqn 4.48, the term that i s proportional to the velocity (shear flow) no longer exists. Indeed, it is easy to establish that the flow rates crossing each clearance are Ql2ULUl2, and hence their s u m does not depend on U.
Similar considerations hold good for the tangential force. In this case, the terms due to the pressure flow are opposite in sign for the two clearances, and the drag on the whole pad is null when U=O. The friction force on the lands is hence proportional to the velocity:
(the contribution of the recess area is often negligible because the recess depth h, is much greater than h). In the equation above we have released the minus sign, since it is implicit that the friction force on the moving member is opposite in direction to the velocity.
73
BASIC EQUATIONS
4.7.3
Flow recirculation Inside recess
Examining the simple pad in Fig. 4.8 it should be easily understood that velocity U induces a continuous recirculation of the fluid in the recess, and hence a velocity field exists even when Q=O (see Fig. 4.9.a). The simplest approach for studying the flow recirculation is to consider that huhrnb, hence disregarding the end effects at the recess edge. Assuming laminar flow,the velocity profile is given by Eqn 4.12
$[u - $8 (1 - $)] 2
u=
At any given section, flow rate must be null; hence, imposing hr
Judy=O 0
it follows
(the same result could have been directly obtained from Eqn 4.32). - b-
-a-
h
X
b
m
-
10
lo2
3
3
lo3
Re
)
lo4
lo5
lo6
Fig. 4.9 Recess flow recirculation: a- velocity profile; b- friction factor.
One consequence is that pressure is not constant, and a pressure drop exists across the recess. Furthermore, a critical speed exists a t which pressure near the leading edge becomes atmospheric (4.50)
74
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
The friction force over the moving member is (Eqn 4.35)
F C , . = 4 U A IL 'hr For a sliding hydrostatic pad this force should be added to the friction force on the lands, obtaining a total friction force
where A1 and A,. are the land and recess area, respectively, and factor fr takes on a value f,.=4-
h hr
under the simplifying assumptions made above. More detailed and thorough studies of recess flow recirculation can be found in ref. 4.5. and ref. 4.6. Better approximations for critical velocity and recess friction factor are to be found in ref. 4.6: (4.52)
h h hr hr
f,. = (4 - 3 - ) -
(4.53)
All the foregoing equations are based on the assumption that recess flow is laminar, i.e. that the Reynolds number
is smaller than 1000. Actually, the problem is more complex because of the pressure head build-up a t the inlet of the clearance (ref. 4.7). For turbulent flow it may be stated that: f
r
=--f Re
h 2h,P
(4.54)
and f, may be read in Fig. 4.9.b (proposed in ref. 4.5 on the basis of experiments on journal bearings) or calculated (ref. 4.8) from the equation (4.55)
BASIC EQUATIONS
75
Annular clearance.
4.7.4
Let us examine the flow between two parallel ring-shaped walls (Fig. 4.101,rotating around the z-axis with a relative velocity a, which, however, is not so great as to require the effects of the inertia of the lubricant to be considered. Since the thickness of the film is small, compared to width r2-r-1,Eqn 4.23 (the Reynolds equation) is valid, which, due to the radial symmetry, is now reduced to (4.56)
Integrating it twice, with the boundary conditions at r = r l ,
p=p1
p = p 2 at r = r 2 ,
the pressure field is obtained: P 'P2
In rlr2 +
(P1 - P 2 ) & &
i.e. p decreases on the land area with a logarithmic trend. The flow rate per unit length is, from the first of Eqns 4.33 and Eqn 4.57,
Fig. 4.10 Annular clearance.
(4.57)
76
HYDROSTATICLUBRICATION
Consequently, the total flow across any circle of radius r1esr-2 is (4.58)
Hence, the “hydraulic resistance“ of the clearance may be defined as:
=P 1 - p 2 = 6 Q n
In r 2 h p 7
(4.59)
The friction moment, from Eqn 4.36, is:
The Reynolds number is again given by Eqn 4.45. Since the mean velocity at mean radius 7=(rl+r2)/2is
--8 U. 2xFh
’
it follows that: 1 P Re=--Q ”
4.7.5
1
(4.61)
r2(1+3
Circular pad
The simple hydrostatic bearing, shown in outline in Fig. 4.6.b, is made up of a circular recess bounded by a n annular clearance, like the one examined in the previous section. Assuming that p2=0 (ambient pressure), pressure p r in the recess is related to the rate of flow by Eqn 4.58, which can be rewritten as (4.62)
The pressure in the clearance decreases with a logarithmic trend, given by Eqn 4.57, in which pl=pr and p2=0. The hydraulic resistance is still given by Eqn 4.59. The load capacity of the pad is found by integrating the pressure on the land area and adding the term m$pr due to the recess pressure: (4.63)
BASIC EQUATIONS
77
If Eqn 4.62 is introduced in Eqn 4.63, we obtain
$(
W=3-Q
i)
1--
(4.64)
The friction moment is given by Eqn 4.60, since the friction in the recess is negligible.
4.7.6
Pipes
In the case of laminar flow in a straight circular pipe, whose length is much greater than the diameter, certain simplifying hypotheses, similar to those stated in section 4.3, may be applied to the Navier-Stokes equations. In particular, the pressure can be considered to vary with the z coordinate alone. The third of Eqns 4.7 is now reduced to the following:
Integrating it with the boundary conditions w=O for r=d/2 and aw/&=o for r=O (due to matters of symmetry), the velocity field is obtained as a function of the pressure gradient: (4.65)
which is the equation of a paraboloid. The maximum velocity of the fluid is a t r=O:
while its mean velocity is:
Since the continuity equation (Eqn 4.8) is reduced to dpldz=const., the pressure drop along the pipe is linear. If a length 1 is considered, the flow rate is related to the pressure drop by the law: (4.66)
Equation 4.66 is used to evaluate the hydraulic resistance: (4.67)
78
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
of a capillary pipe used as a compensating device for hydrostatic bearings. In general, in this kind of restrictor, the flow proves to be laminar, due to the smallness of the diameter. However, a check should be made to ensure that the Reynolds number
wpd 411 Re = p - l-t p d-Q
(4.68)
is lower than the critical value Re=2300. Equations similar to Eqn 4.66 are obtained in ref. 2.7 for straight pipes with differing sections (Fig. 4.11). Namely, for a rectangular section (Fig. 4.11.b) with a>h (i.e. a is selected as the larger dimension):
and if a>>h:
If a=h (square section, Fig. 4.11.~):
For a triangular equilateral section (Fig. 4.11.d):
For an annular duct, with Cc
-a-
-b-
-C-
-d -
-e-
A3 fJ Fig. 4.1 1 Cross sections of pipes.
79
BASIC EQUATIONS
4.8
FLOW INTO THE INLET LENGTH
inlet lengthIn section 4.7, a number of cases of laminar flow have been examined; the equations which have been obtained expressing the flow a s a function of the pressure step are not strictly accurate, since certain distributed energy losses have been disregarded. As a n example, let us consider a circular pipe. When the fluid begins to flow into the pipe, the velocity w is a constant for the entire section (Fig. 4.12); the velocity of the fluid on the wall of the pipe, however, is null, and this layer exerts a great shearing stress on the inner layers, whose velocity must become greater than the mean value W i n order to satisfy the continuity requirement. The thickness of the "boundary layer" grows until, a t a distance li from the inlet, the whole section of the pipe is involved; a t this point, the fluid velocity reaches the parabolic profile already seen in sect.4.7.6, and remains so thereafter.
\
'. ,-
I I
I 1
2
Fig. 4.12 Velocity profiles in the inlet length of pipes. The length Zi is named "inlet length" (ref. 4.9) and its value is found to be li=0.0575 d Re. When the length of the pipe is greater than li, which is generally true for the capillaries used as compensating devices for hydrostatic bearings, Eqn 4.65 should be substituted by the following:
Q = - -xd 41 128
'
1 d 1 1+ 0.0356 i Re
(4.69)
In other words, the value of the flow rate found in sect. 4.7.6 should be multiplied for a correction coefficient, which accounts for the pressure loss required to accelerate the inner fluid layers in the inlet length.
80
HYDROSTATIC LU5RlCATlON
Similar considerations hoId good for pipes of different shapes, and for the clearances of hydrostatic pads (see, for example, sect. 6.2.14~)).
INLET LOSSES
4.9
In the preceding section, the pressure loss in the inlet length of a circular pipe was examined; other pressure losses occur in the tank near the pipe inlet and a t the inlet itself. The loss in the tank may be considered to be the sum of two terms: the first is used to accelerate the fluid in the tank (in the conoid bounded by dotted lines in Fig. 4.12) to the inlet velocity, the other is due to the viscous dissipation in the same area. The loss at the inlet, on the other hand, is due to the "uena contructu", which is generally present, especially when the inlet edge is sharp. The overall pressure loss is (ref 2.7): (4.70)
The values of resistance coefficient k are given in Fig. 4.13 for the cases of (a) a well-rounded entrance, (b) a slightly rounded entrance, (c) a sharp-edged entrance. The pressure loss a t the inlet, given by Eqn 4.70, should be added to the pressure loss in the pipe, given by Eqn 4.69. -a-
-b-
-C-
K = 0.05
Fig. 4.13 Resistance coefficients due to the geometry of pipe entrances.
4.10
TURBULENT FLOW
The flow of the lubricant in the gap between two close surfaces is, in most cases, of a laminar kind, i.e. the Reynolds number is lower than 1000. Nevertheless, in certain circumstances, it may be not so. For instance, with reference to a circular pad and to Eqn 4.61, if high values are selected for p r and r h (due to the need to sustain a heavy load) and if the viscosity of the lubricant is low (e.g. when water or
81
BASIC EQUATIONS
liquid metals such a s Sodium have to be used), and, above all, if the gap is higher than the values commonly adopted, Re may be greater than 1000. When Re is greater than 1000, a transition regime sets in; a t Rez2300 the flow is prevalently turbulent, and it is totally turbulent for higher Reynolds numbers (see ref. 4.10). When the fluid gets into the clearance, the boundary layer is at first laminar but becomes turbulent (except for a thin laminar sublayer) a t a distance from the inlet of 25+40 times the clearance. The velocity profile is similar to the one plotted in Fig. 4.14.b and the maximum fluid velocity is about 1.2 times its mean value.
-a
-
-b-
Fig. 4.14 Velocity distribution in a pipe: a- laminar flow; b- turbulent flow. In turbulent flow, the velocity components and the pressure in the clearance a t a given time may be written as a sum of two terms: u=u*+u1; u=u*+u1; w=w*+wl; p=p*+pl: the first terms are the average values, the others are the fluctuations due to turbulence. These expressions should be introduced into Eqns 4.7 and Eqn 4.8 (i.e. the Navier-Stokes and continuity equations). Certain assumptions can now be made: the viscosity and density of the lubricant are considered to be constants; the average flow is stationary and merely radial (i.e. u*=u*(F,z);u*=w*=O); the turbulent components are considered to depend solely on r and z , due to the radial symmetry. The first of Eqns 4.7 becomes (ref. 4.2,4.4) (4.71) in which z,=p(au*/az) and zt=-p(ulwl)* are the viscous and turbulent components of the shear stress. It may be assumed that z,<
where l=zfor 02&/2,1=X(h-z) for h/2Q
x should be determined by
Equation 4.71 may be further simplified (ref. 4.11) and then integrated with the following boundary conditions
82
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
where zo is the thickness of the laminar sublayer on the surfaces. We thus obtain (4.72)
where z'=zlh, zb=zdh, and
The blunt profile of u* (Fig. 4.14.b) is rather different from the parabolic profile (Fig. 4.14.a) pertaining to laminar flow. Equation 4.8 becomes u* -+-=oau* r ar
(4.73)
Introducing Eqn 4.72 into Eqn 4.73, and integrating with the following boundary conditions
we obtain
P* -PI =PI[--
1 - rz/r
11
(4.74)
For circular pipes, whose Reynolds number is given by Eqn 4.68, the drop in pressure is given by the well-known equation (ref. 2.7)
where the friction coefficient f can be evaluated, for ReelO5, by means of the experimental relation:
For pipes of different sections, the pressure drop can be approximately evaluated using the same Eqn. 4.75, in which the "hydraulic diameter" d=4AIS is introduced: A and S are the area and the perimeter of the cross section of the pipe, respectively.
83
BASlC EQUATlONS
4.11
THE FLOW IN ORIFICES
In a sharp-edge orifice (Fig. 4.15.a), the Reynolds number often has a very high value and the flow becomes "turbulent". The turbulence, however, is of a particular type. The fluid particles crossing the orifice are accelerated until the velocity of sound is reached, a t section 2 of the duct. The flow between sections 1 and 2 is of a potential kind (or, better, the energy dissipation is small). Area A2 of the critical section of the vein is lower than area A0 of the orifice (since the velocity has increased), and the ratio CC=A2IAois defined a s the "coefficient of contraction". Between sections 2 and 3, a rapid mixing of the jet occurs with the fluid downstream; "turbulence"sets up and the kinetic energy of the fluid is transformed into internal energy, with a consequent increase in its temperature. - b-
-a-
'
'
O
7
Fig. 4.15 Sharp-edge orifice: a- flow; b- contraction coefficient. Applying the Bernoulli equation between sections 1 and 2 (i.e. imposing the balance of the kinetic and potential energies of the fluid), one may write:
On the other hand, the continuity of the flow rate implies:
Eliminating the inlet velocity w1, the velocity w2 may be written as:
04
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
Due to the viscosity of the fluid, the actual velocity w i a t section 2 is slightly lower than the above value, the velocity coefficient C,=w;/w2 being about 0.98. The flow rate of lubricant through the orifice is:
So, if we write
C" c,
we get
(4.76) The "discharge coefficient" Cd is approximately equal to C,, since Cu=l and, in general, Ao<
I"'
turbulent flow
0 0
I
10
I
20
I
VRe
I
30
Fig. 4.16 Discharge coefficient versus Reynolds number for an orifice.
In the case of a low pressure drop and if viscosity is high, the Reynolds number may become sufficiently low to permit laminar flow. Although the analysis above is not valid at low Re, Q may still be calculated by means of Eqn 4.76, in which the
85
BASIC EQUATlONS
discharge coefficient Cd is now given in Fig. 4.16. The initial value of Re has to be calculated for Cd=0.6. The sharp-edge orifices are sometimes substituted by less costly orifices (Fig. 4.17) whose length 1 is no longer negligible. In such cases, the discharge coefficient can be calculated by means of the following equations (ref. 2.7):
[
Cd = 1.5 + 13.74
1 m -m (a) ]
(4.77)
for ?<50
;
the relevant values of Cd also being plotted in Fig. 4.16. Re has to be initially obtained from Eqn 4.68, with Q being taken from Eqn 4.76 for Cd=0.6. Since Cd is now a function of the Reynolds number, the flow rate for any certain pressure step is no longer completely independent from variations in temperature and viscosity.
0s
1
o,61 0.4
cd
a2
I
0.14
10
I
lo* DRe / I
I
lo3
1 4
Fig. 4.17 Discharge coefficient for a short-tube orifice.
REFERENCES 4.1 43
45 4.4
Goldstein S. D.; Modern Deuelopments in Fluid Dynamics; Claredon Press, Oxford, 1952; 702 pp. Pinkus O., Sternlicht B.; Theory of Hydrodynamic Lubrication; McGraw-Hill Book Co., N.Y., 1961; 465 pp. Tipei N.; Theory of Lubrication; Standford Univ. Press, 1962; 690 pp. Cameron A,; The Principle of Lubricatioq; Longmans, Green and Co. Ltd., 1966; 591 pp.
86
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
Shinkle J. N., Hornung V . G.; Frictional Characteristics of Liquid Hydrostatic Bearings; ASME Trans., J . of Basic Eng., 87 (19651,163-169. 4.6 Ettles C. H. M., O'Donoghue J . P.; Laminar Recess Flow in Liquid Hydrostatic Bearings; Instn. Mech. Engrs., C27 (19711,215-227. 4.7 Tipei N.; Flow Characteristics and Pressure Head Build-up at the Inlet of Narrow Passages; ASME Trans., J . Lubr. Tech., 100 (1978), 47-55. 4.8 El-Sherbiny M., Salem F., El-Efnawy N.; Optimum Design of Hydrostatic Journal Bearings; Tribology International, 17 (19841, 155-166. 4.9 Langhaar H. L.; Steady Flow in the Transition Length of a straight Tube; J . of Applied Mech., 9,2 (19421, A55-A58. 4.10 Streeter V.;Handbook of Fluid Dynamics; McGraw-Hill, 1961. 4.11 Bassani R.; Sul Regime Turbolento nei Cuscinetti Zdrostatici di Spinta Molto Caricati; Atti 1st. Mecc Appl. e Costr. Macch., 1968-69, N 15; 36 pp. 4.6
Chapter 5
PAD COEFFICIENTS
5.1
INTRODUCTION
In this chapter, generalized equations for load capacity W, stiffness K,flow rate Q, pumping power Hp, friction power H f and total power Ht are proposed, which are valid for every type of pad. In order to simplify the representation of the behavior of bearings and make their design easier, use is made of characteristic parameters, such as the effective area A, and the hydraulic resistance R, as well as of the power ratio ll and the pressure ratio J/.’ For the same purpose, certain p a d coefficients (A*,,R*, HF) are introduced, which are characteristics of the actual pad shape. They are also considered the effects on the bearing behavior of misalignment and of certain phenomena, such as turbulence, inlet pressure losses and lubricant inertia, which are not typical of plain hydrostatic lubrication.
5.2
GENERAL STATEMENTS
Whatever the shape of the bearing pads and the supply system, certain general expressions may be stated. The load capacity of a pad (the resultant of the lubricant pressure in the bearing) may be put in the following form:
W = Pr A,
(5.1)
p r is the recess pressure; A, is the “effective“pad area. This last is a fraction of the projected area and, in general, depends on the operating conditions; in the most common cases, however, A, may be considered as a constant, related solely t o the shape and size of the pad.
88
HYDROSTATICLUBRlCATlON
The lubricant flow rate may be related to the recess pressure by the "hydraulic resistance" R of the bearing lands:
W
Q=pr / R = At?R
(5.2)
If the land surfaces of the two bearing members are parallel to each other, as occurs in the majority of pad types, R is proportional to the inverse of the third power of the film thickness h: e.g. see Eqn 4.59. The 'pumping power" is the power needed to push lubricant into the bearing and dissipated, because of viscous friction, mainly in the compensating restrictor (when it exists) and in the bearing clearance. The total pumping power is
Hp=psQ
(5.3)
where p s is the pressure of the lubricant obtained by means of the pumping device. The pumping power dissipated in the bearing is:
Hi = P r Q
(5.4)
For a constant pressure system, p s may be much greater than the recess pressure, while for a constant flow rate system p s is only slightly greater than pr (the pressure losses are due, in this case, solely to the pipes linking the pump to the recess). Friction force Ff and friction moment M f have been defined in section 4.5.3. The lyriction power" is the power needed to keep a relative motion between the members of the bearing; it is due to viscous friction and it is given by the following equation:
Hf= Ff U + MfR
(5.5)
where U is the sliding velocity, and R is the turning velocity of the bearing. The total power dissipated is clearly the sum of the pumping power and the friction power:
Ht = Hp + Hf
(5.6)
Power H t is transformed into heat, part of which is lost through the walls bounding the oil path; the remainder, however, remains in the lubricant, whose temperature increases as it passes through the compensating devices and the bearing clearances. This increase in temperature must be evaluated, a t least approximately, to allow the supply devices to be correctly designed. In every case, AT should be kept a t a few degrees; indeed, if a large increase in temperature is allowed, the viscosity cannot be considered as a constant, and the performance of the bearing may be considerably affected.
PAD COEFFlClENTS
89
For a fast (and safe) evaluation of AT it is often assumed that all the dissipated power H , remains in the lubricant (adiabatic flow). As a consequence, we have simply (5.7)
where c is the specific heat of the lubricant, and p is its density (for further discussion on thermal running see chapter 12). The term H f I H , is commonly called the "power ratio" and has also been used (ref. 1.9) for the following grading of hydrostatic bearings: Hf/Hp=O, zero-speed bearings (purely hydrostatic bearings); H f I H p < l , lowlmoderate speed bearings; and H f / H p > l , moderate/high speed bearings. In the last case, for certain bearings (e.g. journal bearings), hydrodynamic load capacity may become important (hybrid bearings). The static "stiffness" K may be generally defined a s the limit of the ratio of a small change A F of the applied load to the consequent displacement Ae of the moving member in the direction of the load. In steady-state conditions the external load F is balanced by the resultant W of the pressure of the lubricant, so the stiffness of the bearing may be defined as:
For a single-pad thrust bearing, if we use h to indicate the component of the film thickness along the direction of the load, we clearly have Ah=Ae, and hence Eqn 5.8 becomes
K=-dW dh
It is important to note that the derivative on the right-hand side of Eqn 5.8 is a total derivative. Indeed, W is proportional to recess pressure; this is linked to the flow rate and to the thickness of the film by a relationship which depends on the supply system and the compensating devices. For this reason this point will be examined more closely in sections 6.2 and 6.3. Once a design value ho has been selected for the clearance of any given pad bearing, it may be worthwhile writing the expressions of each of the foregoing parameters as the product of the value of the parameter in the reference configuration h=ho times a function of the non-dimensional film thickness h l h , or of the non-dimensional displacement E=-
h - ho h0
(5.9)
90
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
It should be noted that fqr certain types of pad a "natural" reference configuration exists (e.g. the concentric configuration for the cylindrical or spherical pads). In non-dimensional form, hydraulic resistance R and friction power H f can now be rewritten as:
R=RoR'
(5.10)
Ro and Hfo being the relevant reference values. For the pads whose clearances have an uniform thickness the results obtained in Chapter 4 allow us to write: (5.12)
(5.13) The stiffness may also be written in the form:
K=KoK
(5.14)
but now both KO and K' are dependent on the supply system, and will be defined later. One parameter which will be widely used in the following chapters is the "pressure ratio" in the reference configuration: (5.15)
Another important parameter to take into consideration is the "referencepower ratio", that is the power ratio in the reference configuration:
The importance of this parameter consists in the fact that it provides a simple but effective way of optimizing the selection of the lubricant and of the clearance, as will be shown later. In order to evaluate the actual bearing performance, it is now necessary: to evaluate the foregoing parameters for the main types of pad; this will be done in the remainder of this chapter; to establish the relationship between the flow rate, the recess pressure and the supply pressure for the most common supply systems. This will be done in section
PAD COEFFICIENTS
91
6.2 (for the "direct"supply system) and section 6.3 (for the "compensated" supply systems).
5.3
5.3.1
CIRCULAR RECESS PAD
Basic equations
A set of equations, with which the parameters of the simple bearing in Fig. 5.1.a may be calculated, have been already obtained in section 4.7.5. In particular, it was found there that the flow rate Q and the load capacity W (written as functions of the recess pressure p r ) are (5.17)
(5.18) where
is the ratio of the inner radius of the land surface to the outer one. Comparing these equations to Eqn 5.1 and Eqn 5.2, the effective pad area and the hydraulic resistance are easily obtained:
n A, = 4 Dz A:
(5.20)
R=:$R*
(5.21)
A*, and R*, which are plotted in Fig. 5.l.b, are: (5.22)
R* = In llr'
(5.23)
The pumping power dissipated in the bearing is given by Eqn 5.4. It may prove useful to express it as a function of the load capacity: (5.24) where
92
HYDROSTATlC LUBRlCATlON
-a-
-b10
r
5
h
3
Fig. 5.1 Circular recess pad: a- pad geomc y; b- pad coefficients. 1
r*=AT
(5.25)
If we now want to assess the value of the ratio r’, which minimizes the pumping power (for any given load and film thickness), we have to solve the equation
It is easy to obtain r&,=0.5291. Note that this optimal value is not a critical value; in many cases i t may be advisable to increase r’ in order, for example, to decrease recess pressure, and hence the increase in temperature of the lubricant. Furthermore, when velocity Q is not too low, it proves to be convenient to use high values of r‘, in order to reduce the total power loss, as we shall also see later. The moment of the friction forces Mi due to an angular velocity R has already been calculated, in section 4.7.4;Eqn 4.60may be rewritten here as:
where
PAD COEFFICIENTS
Fig. 5.2 Nomograph for a circular pad.
93
94
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
is plotted in Fig. 5.1.b. The friction power is:
H f = Q M =EED4Q2Hf* f 32h
(5.28)
The friction coefficient, referred to the mean radius of the land P=(rl+r2)/2, is (5.29)
It can be shown (ref. 5.1) that, for moderate speeds, f can be as little as 0.01 times the friction coefficient of the rolling bearings.
EXAMPLE 5.1 A pad bearing, which has to carry a load W=20,000 N, rotates at a speed Q=2n radls (i.e. 60 rpm); its external diameter is D=O.l m. The lubricant viscosity, at a working temperature T=4OoC, is p=O.l Ns im2. For the ratio re, the "optimal" value is chosen: rAPt=0.53, because of low velocity. For the film thickness the value h=50 p m is chosen i n order to avoid the influence of errors in parallelism (see section 5.3.3). Let us calculate the main bearing parameters. From Eqn 5.22 or from Fig. 5.1.b it is easy to obtain Af =0.566 and hence the effective area is (from Eqn 5.23) A,=4.45.10-3 mz. As a consequence, the recess pressure which is needed to sustain the design load is (from Eqn 5.1) pr=4.5 MPa. From Eqn 5.23, or from Fig. 5.1.b, we find R*=0.635, and a hydraulic resistance (Eqn 5.21) RO=970.10sNsIm5. From Eqn 5.2 it immediately follows that the flow rate which is required to sustain the load with the planned clearance is &=4.63.10-6 m3Is. The pumping power dissipated in the bearing is Hi=prQ=20.8 W: for a direct supply system (i.e. &=const,ps=pr) this is also the actual pumping power. Equation 5.27, or Fig. 5.1.b, gives Hf*=0.921. The friction power is obtained from Eqn 5.28: Hf=O.714 W; this low value justifies the choice of r'=rApt.The friction moment is Mf=Hf/LkO.114N m and the friction coefficient(Eqn 5.29) is f=0.149.10-3
5.3.2
Design chart
For the calculus of a circular-recess hydrostatic thrust bearing, it may prove worthwhile to use, as a first approach, the design chart in Fig. 5.2.) obtained from Eqn 5.17 and Eqn 5.18 rewritten in logarithmic form. It allows us t o obtain the main design parameters of a bearing in graphical form. By way of example, let us con-
PAD COEFFICIENTS
95
sider the bearing in Example 5.1. Starting from point r’=0.53 on the scale in the lower left corner, trace a horizontal line to meet the curve p,; then a line is drawn vertically t o the assigned value of W, and again horizontally, until the external radius r2 is met; a value of 4.5 MPa can now be read on the scale of the recess pressures. To calculate Q a similar path has to be traced, except that the curve pq has to be used instead of p,; moreover, after meeting r2, a vertical line is drawn to reach the selected viscosity, and then a horizontal line (after a rotation of 90 degrees) leads to the selected value of h and hence to &=4.6.10-6m%.
5.3.3
Effects of errors in parallelism
As has been noted above, it is generally expedient to select a low value for the film thickness, but the minimum admissible value of h can be limited by a lack of parallelism between the pad surfaces (see Fig. 5.3).
Fig. 5.3 Misaligned circular pad.
Since the radial symmetry is lost, the one-dimensional Reynolds equation (i.e. Eqn 4.56) can no longer be used. Resorting to the complete equation (Eqn 4.23) but disregarding the effects of velocities R and A, we may write: (5.30)
where the clearance a t any point (r, ts) is
96
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
and
ih:
Ah'=-=-
tanly
(5.31)
As usual, it has been assumed that the mean film thickness than the diameter of the pad, and hence the angle ylis small.
K
is much smaller
This problem has been solved in ref. 5.2, by means of a finite-difference technique. Once the pressure field has been obtained, the load capacity can be calculated (by integration), as well as the velocity of the lubricant (from Eqn 4.20 and Eqn 4.21) and then the rate of flow (from Eqns 4.33). In Fig. 5.4 pressure p'=pIpr on the bearing lands and the flow velocity
a t the inner edge (r=rl)areplotted (for several values of 0)for r'=0.53, Ah'=l. Finally, on the basis of these results, certain approximate correction factors may be proposed. The effective area could now be expressed as: -a-
- b1.0
0.8
0.6 2 h
0.4
0.2
0 0.5
0.6
0.7
-r
0.8
0.9
1.0
0
r2
Fig. 5.4 Misaligned circular pad: a- pressure field; b- velocity profile.
0.2
0.4 U'
0.6
97
PAD COEFFICIENTS
(5.32)
where: (5.33) Since, however, the correction introduced is of the order of 1%, even for Ah’=l, it can be disregarded.
res 0.53
0.60
0.65
0.m 0.75
0.80 085
090
0.8
0.9
1
Fig. 5.5 Misaligned circular pad: correction factor CRversus parallelism error Ah‘.
98
HYDROSTATC LUBRlCATlON
The hydraulic resistance of the pad becomes:
(5.34) where: cR=
3
1
(5.35)
l+g(l +r’)ZAh‘2
(a more accurate but rather complicated equation for CR is given in ref. 5.2). It is easy to verify that, when Ah’=@ the correction factors are reduced to 1. The correction factor C,, which may also be interpreted a s the decrease in load capacity when Q a n d x are given, is plotted in Fig. 5.5 for certain values of r’. The decrease in W may be compensated by increasing Q. The friction moment, power and coefficient may still be calculated as in the case of M’=O. The effect of the turning velocity R (which is not considered in the equations above) is studied in ref. 5.3,where the Reynolds equation (Eqn 4.23)is solved by means of a prediction-correction method, in order to get the pressure field. Load capacity, flow rate, and friction coeficient are then obtained. The variability of the pressure with 19,already seen for R=O, is increased by the turning speed, and even cavitation may occur at the higher values of R and Ah’. This effect is counteracted by using higher values for r‘. The load capacity is found to increase with R. Note that the lubricant inertia has not been taken into account; actually, it should lead to a further increase in load capacity (as will be seen below) when r b 0 .5 . The flow rate proves to be unaffected by R (since the forces of inertia have been disregarded). The friction coefficient decreases with Ah ’ and obviously increases with the rotation speed.
5.3.4
Effects of the loss of pressure at the inlet
The equations expressing the performance of the bearing should be modified if pressure losses, other than those due to viscous forces, have to be taken into account. The effects of these losses, which have already been examined in sections 4.8 and 4.9 with regard t o the lubricant pipes, are evaluated in ref. 5.4 and 5.5. While the consequences on the effective area are negligible, the hydraulic resistance should be corrected as follows:
(5.36)
PAD COEff/C/ENTS
99
Fig. 5.6 Pressure losses at the inlet of clearance: correction factor C p for circular pads.
where the correction factor Cp is given by the equation:
(5.37)
and Re is the Reynolds number (Eqn 4.61); F=(Fl+F2)/2 is the mean radius of the land surface; ti,. is the inlet length:
(5.38) The first term of the numerator in Eqn 5.37 takes into account the pressure losses due to the viscous forces in the bearing gaps; the second stands for the energy
100
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
used to accelerate the fluid in the inlet zone; the third term represents the contraction loss. Equation 5.38 of the inlet length is valid for Ar=r2-r121ir; for greater values of lir, one can simply substitute Ar for li, in Eqn 5.37, unless (in which case the bearing gap would virtually behave as an orifice!). Coefficients k l , k 2 , and k3 are obtained in ref. 5.5 from the experimental data given in ref. 5.4, with the following values: k1=0.75, k2=0.235, and k3=0.021;thus the correction factor for R becomes
1 Cp=l+--
0.0313
1 (l+l/rY 1 + 0.00525 l n p
2 + 0.00979
(5.39)
_-
h Re
It is plotted in Fig. 5.6 as a function of Arl(h.Re)for a number of values of r'. Unlike the case of error in parallelism, the inlet losses have favorable effects. These effects would be rather important for very small ( ~ 0 . 1values ) of Arl(h.Re), which are, however, unusual in actual fact. The coefficient Cp may also be explained as a n increase in load capacity, for any given flow rate, or as a decrease in flow rate, for any given load. It should be noted that C, becomes considerable in the case of ArchaRe.
EXAMPLE 5.2 A circular pad bearing, whose diameter is D=O.l m, has been selected to sustain a load W=50 M v rotating at 750 rpm (i2=251rradls). Furthermore, the recess pressure needs to be smaller than 7.2 MPa and the friction torque needs to be smaller than 0.05 Nm. Let us assess the flow rate, assuming that a lubricant with p=O.O18 Nslm2 and p=880Kglm3 must be used. From the condition p,<7.2 MPa, it follows that Ae>6.94.10-3 m2 (Eqn 5.1), and Az>0.884 (Eqn 5.20). From Fig. 5.1.6 a radius ratio of about 0.9 seems to be neehd. I f we select r'=0.9, we easily obtain A50.902, R*=0.105, Hf*=0.344. The effective area is then Ae=7.08.103 m2, and hence the recess pressure will be p,=7.06 MPa. Since necessarily Mf<0.05 Nm, it follows from Eqn 5.26 hat h 9 5 . 5 pm. If a clearance h=100 pm is selected, it follows that R=3.62.109 NslmS (Eqn 5.21) and Q=1.95.10-3 m31s. Since Q is high, it is advisable to verify the effect of the pressure losses at the inlet. From Eqn 4.61, the Reynolds number is Re=319 and, from Fig. 4.6, Cp=1.26. Hence, the new value of the flow rate is calculated: Q=1.54.10-3 m3/s. This is still a high value; it should be borne in mind, however, that a very low friction was required, the friction coefficient being of the order of 2.10-5.
PAD COEFFICIENTS
5.3.5
101
Turbulent flow
Although the flow in the clearances of hydrostatic bearings is, generally, of a laminar type, in certain circumstances (as already noted in section 4.10) the Reynolds number (Eqn 4.61) may become greater than 2300, at which value the flow is prevalently turbulent. Equations giving pressure and lubricant velocity in the clearance of a circular pad in turbulent regime have been obtained in section 4.10. Integrating the mean pressure (Eqn 4.74) on both the recess and land area, the load capacity proves to be: K
W = 4 D2 r' p ,
(5.40)
while, if we integrate the radial velocity field (Eqn 4.72), the following flow rate is obtained:
where (ref. 4.11): (5.42) and (5.43) The nondimensional quantities x and A (which depends on zb and accounts for the rate of flow in the laminar boundary sublayer along the land surfaces) are evaluated in ref. 4.11, for Re>2300:
Comparing Eqn 5.40 and Eqn 5.41 with those obtained for the laminar flow, two correction factors are easily obtained for the effective area as well as the hydraulic resistance of the pad. After stating that: (5.44)
(5.45)
102
HYOROSTATIC LUBRICATION
it follows that:
(5.47)
When r’ is greater than 0.80, we have 0 . 9 9 < C ~ ~ 0.5, we have 6 % ~ ) l n ( l / r 7 , thus 1
‘RT
(5.48)
O X 5 ( l + A ) zb F(zb)
and, hence, C R T may be considered to depend on zb alone. Both CAT and CRTare plotted in Fig. 5.7.
-a-
1.oo
-b-
10
CAT CRT
0.95
5
0.90 0.50
0.75 f
1.oo
0
0.00
0.10
0.05 zb
Fig. 5.7 Turbulent flow: a- correction factor CATfor effective area; b- correction factor C,, for hydraulic resistance.
Since CRTproves to be greater than 1, we can see that, at high Reynolds numbers, turbulence brings about a considerable decrease in flow rate or, if flow rate remains constant, a considerable increase in load capacity. On the other hand, turbulence may cause a large increase of foam in the lubricant; the persistence of the foam
PAD COEFFICIENTS
103
depends on the physico-chemical properties of the oils, and may be counteracted by means of suitable anti-foam additives (see chapter 3). EXAMPLE 5.3 Let us re-examine the hydrostatic pad in Exumple 5.2, in order to evaluate how the flow rate would vary if the clearance and the viscosity were changed to h=200 pm and p=0.005 Ns I m2 ( I S 0 VG5),respectively. From Eqn 5.21 it follows that R=O.126.1@ NslmS, and hence Q=56.1.10-3m31s. Since the Reynolds number proves to be greater than 2300 (Eqn 4.61), a correction factor should clearly be evaluated. From Eqn 5.42 we obtain z&0.0112, and hence C~,=7.78, R=0.979.109 Nslm5,Q=7.23.103 m3/s (in spite of the considerable reduction due to turbulence, this is a very high value). The Reynolds number proves to be Re54260. Bearing in mind the above results, it may be concluded that, for values of R e lower than 10, which is the most common case for these hydrostatic thrust bearings, the whole pressure loss in the clearance is due to viscous forces; when Re is greater than 100, the pressure losses examined in section (v) become considerable; when Re is greater than 1000, the effect of turbulence should be taken into account. In both these cases, for any given load capacity and film thickness, the flow rate proves to be lower than that expected on the basis of the laminar theory.
5.3.6
Effects of the inertia forces
When the angular speed of the bearing in Fig. 5.1.a is high, the forces of inertia in the fluid can no longer be disregarded. Supposing h=const, but retaining the inertia term, Eqn 4.23 becomes: (5.49)
where the “inertia parameter”
(5.50) has been introduced.
This kind of problem has been solved in ref. 5.6. When r o o l , the depth h,. of the recess should be at least 5 times greater than the film thickness h, while hr=20h is considered to be a n optimal value.
104
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
Fig. 5.8 Pressure distribution for certain values of inertia parameter (ref. 5.6).
In Fig. 5.8 the pressure field is plotted for a number of values of the inertia parameter Si;it is assumed that r1=0.5r2 and that the radius of the supply duct is ro=0.05r2.A pressure peak can be seen a t the inner edge of the bearing land. When no recess exists (i.e. ro=rl),negative pressures, and hence cavitation phenomena, may occur. Note that in Fig. 5.8 the depth of the recess is h,=5h. For higher values (i.e. h,.220h, as is common practice) the depth of the recess does not affect pressure distribution. When h,/h>>5, 0 . 0 5 ~ , / r 2 < 015, . 0.534'10.9 (i.e. in the large majority of cases), simplified equations are available for the pressure in the recess fro
Integrating p on the entire pad surface, we obtain the load capacity, and hence the effective pad area. Equation 4.20 gives the tangential velocity of the lubricant:
PAD COEFFICIENTS
105
Since u a n d p are now known functions, the radial flow velocity, and hence the volume flow rate, may now be easily obtained from Eqn 4.21. The effective area and the hydraulic resistance may thus be expressed as (5.53)
R=:$R*
cRI
(5.54)
where: c,=l+si
CRI=
[( $)+ ( 1--
1 1 + si(1-
);":I.
1-- -
3)
(5.55)
(5.56)
It is clear, however, that
c,=1+si CRI=
1
(
1--):2 :
(5.57)
(5.58)
are very good approximations in the large majority of cases. In Fig. 5.9 CAI,is given a s a function of Si for certain values of F'. In the same figure CRI is also given as a function of Si. The increase in flow rate (the inverse of CRI)may be appreciable even for moderate values of the inertia parameter. It is moderately compensated by the increase C increases with Si,load capacity W is increased in load capacity (i.e. C,). Since , by inertia effects if inlet pressure is held constant; thus these bearings are often named hybrid. However, as CRI simultaneously decreases more quickly, flow rate Q increases more greatly than W, so an efficiency loss of the bearing may occur. The Reynolds number, as given by Eqn 4.61, is usually very low. Nevertheless, turbulence could set in, due to the tangential flow velocity. In ref. 5.10, in which the circular pad is compared to the case of a couple of faced rotating disks (ref. 5.71, the Reynolds number Re,=ar;/ v is introduced, and the flow is proved to be laminar for
106
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
Re,
L?Fh
Re, = 7
(5.59)
is smaller than lo3. The latter result agrees closely with the former, since
Re,
=:
Re,
r2
and r2/h>102. Reference 5.8 also shows that, when the flow is turbulent, for any given flow rate, the load capacity and the stiffness of the bearing increase notably with Re,; it should however be noted that values of Re, greater than 1000 are rarely reached.
i
f=0.9
0.8 CAI
0.7
CRI
0.6
0.5 1
0 0
1
2
Si
Fig. 5.9 Correction factor CA,versus inertia parameter Si for certain values of ratio r‘. Correction factor CRIversus inertia parameter Sk
EXAMPLE 5.4 A pad bearing, with D=O.l m, r’=0.9, sustains a load W=lO Mv. It is fed by a constant flow source at a rate &=0.3.1O3m 3 / s with a lubricant with the following characteristics: p=0.05 Nslm2, p=880 Kglm3, c=1900 JIK&jC Let us evaluate how bearing performance is affected as speed becomes G30Oz rad Is (9000 rpm). Proceeding as usual, we find Az=0.902, R*=0.105, Hf*=0.344. Thus, at Q=O, Ae=7.08.10-3m2, and p,=1.41 MPa, the hydraulic resistance of the pad must be R=p,l&=4.70.1O9 Nslm5 and hence h=129 pm. At the highest speed, inserting the value of pr calculated above into Eqn 5.50, we find Si=O.208, and (from Eqn 5.57’ C ~ = l . 0 9From . Eqn 5.53 it follows that Ae=7.73.10-3m2 and hencep,=1.29 MPa. For
PAD COEFFICIENTS
107
a more accurate calculation it is advisable to evaluate Si again. We now obtain: Si=0.227, CN=l.lO, C~1=0.816;consequently, A,=7.79.10-3 m2, p,=1.28 MPa. The hydraulic resistance of the pad becomes R=4.27,1O9 Nslm5 and, from Eqn 5.54, h=124 pm. The pumping power is Hi=384 W a n d the friction power is Hf=1209 W (disregarding the lubricant inertia, Hi=423 W and Hf=1167 W would be obtained, respectively). It is easy to verifv that the temperature step is small and the flow is laminar.
5.3.7
Thermal effects
When velocity L?of the pad is high, the temperature increase, due to the viscous friction in the lubricant, should also be taken into account, as well as the inertia forces. This kind of problem has been studied in ref. 5.9 (see also ref. 5.10). The energy equation must also be associated to the customary Navier-Stokes and continuity equations, as well as a viscosity-temperature relationship; this last may be Eqn 3.4, where it can be stated that p=0.04 for most mineral oils.
For a n axial-symmetric configuration, applying the simplifying hypotheses stated in section 4.3 to Eqns 4.7 (except that p is no longer considered a constant), the Navier-Stokes equations may be written as:
+$)=o a
(5.60)
For the same reasons, Eqn 4.8 is reduced to: (5.61) The energy equation has already been obtained in section 4.6(Eqn 4.40). Suitable boundary conditions should be associated to this set of equations €or pressure, velocities and temperature. In particular, as far a s temperature is concerned, adiabatic flow is often considered (ref. 5.11,5.12). In ref. 5.13 thermal exchange is considered between the lubricant and the pad surfaces held at constant temperature. In ref. 5.14,instead, a n approximate evaluation of the boundary temperatures is considered, obtained by means of experiments (ref. 5.15). The above equations can now be integrated by means of an iterative procedure, based on the finite difference method, to give p , T , u , and v , from which the load capacity, the flow rate, and the friction moment can be calculated. Let us now examine a few results.
108
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
The temperature field plotted in Fig. 5.10 refers to a lubricant, with a n inlet temperature T=35'C, in the clearance of a bearing with the following characteristics: r2=0.0657 m, r1=0.0348m (r'=0.53),r0=0.006m, h=100 pm, &419 rads, pr=0.294 MPa; the data concerning the lubricant, at 2OoC, are: p=0.0645 Ns/m2, p=857 Kg/m3, c=1890 J/Kg"K, ~ = 0 . 1 4 W/m°K. 4 The maximum temperature, at r=r2 and z=0.54h, is T=5OoCwith an increase AT=15OC. In comparison with the case of isothermal flow, taking into account inertia effects, pressure in the clearance proves to be slightly lower. Moreover we have: W=2190 N, Q =13.8.10-6m3/s, Mf=2.22 Nm. So, compared to the case of isothermal flow, in which we should have W=2054 N, Q =18.3.10-6 m3/s, Mf=3.2 Nm, the load capacity proves to be 6.2% lower, the flow rate 24.5% greater, and the friction moment 30.6% lower. Moreover, in the case of isothermal flow, from Eqn 5.7, we should have AT=45OC.
34
35
37
39
43
41
45
47
49
50
T (OC)
Fig. 5.10 Temperature distribution in the clearance of a circular pad: rl= 0.0348 m, r2=0.0657 m, h=lO-4 m, -19 r d s , pr= 0.294 MPa.
As parameter Si,given by Eqn 5.50, increases, the deviation from the isothermal case becomes prominent. For example, for the pad considered above, let us now suppose f2~628.3rads, pr=98.1 KPa, and hence Si=2.196. The maximum temperature increase now proves to be AT=45"C a t r=r2 and z/h=0.8; along the upper pad surface we have AT=31°C and AT=25.5"C along the lower surface. The calculated pressure field is shown in Fig. 5.11, where a negative (relative) pressure (confirmed experimentally, ref. 5.15) indicates the possibility of cavitation phenomena. Moreover, we have W=642 N, Q =14.6.10-6 m3/s, Mf=2.25 Nm, and in comparison with the isothermal case, the load capacity proves to be 33% lower, the flow rate 68% greater and the friction moment 55% lower.
PAD COEFFlClENTS
109
Fig.5.1 1 Pressure distribution in two circular pads. To avoid the problems related to the relevant increase in temperature and to the onset of cavitation, a proper choice of pad geometry is recommended. Let us now consider a pad with r2= 0.0435 m, r1=0.0348 m (r'=0.8) and ro=0.006 m, while all the other characteristics remain as before; we now have Si=0.963. The
110
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
maximum A T proves to be lower than 8°C;the pressure pattern (also shown in Fig. 5.11) is very close to the isothermal case, and so obviously occurs for the load capacity W=642 N, while the flow rate Q=17.7.10-6 m3/s is greater by 17.4%. In comparison with the previous pad, the load capacity is similar, but the flow rate is even greater. A possible countermeasure may be a reduction in film thickness. If we take h=50 pm, the maximum temperature increase proves to be AT=23'C, but the pressure pattern is still close to the isothermal case (Fig. 5.11) and we have W=618 N, Q=2.43.10-6 m3/s, Mf=0.821 Nm. So, due to the thinner clearance, the actual flow rate proves to be about one 7th of what i t was before.
We must point out i t is best to use pads with a small radius and a large recess, when Q is large. The convenience of large recesses will be demonstrated in section 6.4 and in chapter 11. All the above results agree closely with those obtained in ref. 5.11 and 5.12 in the simplifying hypothesis of adiabatic flow. Reference 5.11 suggests that the possibility of adopting the isothermal theory (ref. 5.6), instead of the adiabatic theory, depends on the "viscosity parameter"
where g is the acceleration of gravity. By way of example, for water-lubricated bear-
K'
Fig. 5.12 Correction parameters kw. k~ and k~ for thermal regime.
PAD COEFFICIENTS
111
(due to the low viscosity and high specific heat, ings, V takes on values of about compared to the mineral oils) and the isothermal theory is fairly valid. Although the iterative procedure mentioned above can be quite accurate, i t is still very complicated and does not lead to any direct expression of pressure, load capacity, flow rate, and friction moment as functions of the parameters of the pad. A simpler method is described in ref. 5.16,which is based on using the results contained in ref. 5.14,to obtain an approximate expression of viscosity a s a function of r, in the thermo-fluid-dynamic regime. The Navier-Stokes and the continuity equations are then solved to give the pressure field; finally we obtain the following:
(5.62)
(5.63)
(5.64) 5.16 as functions of
(5.65) and are plotted in Fig. 5.12. In Eqn 5.65,p l = p ( r l ) ,Q , and H f are the values that these parameters take on in the isothermal case. The method has been tested for a number of bearings, with k* in the 0.211.3 range, and good agreement was found with the numerical results referred to above (deviations were smaller than 5% for W and M ,and smaller than 10% for Q 1. It should be pointed out that, for k*<0.2, the isothermal theory may be applied, while k*=1.3is quite a high value.
112
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
4
li
Fig. 5.13 Annular recess pad.
5.4
ANNULAR
5.4.1
RECESS PADS
Basic equations
Figure 5.13 shows an annular recess pad; the inner hole is, in most cases, crossed by a shaft: hence, in general, it is large. From Eqn 4.57, the pressure in the pad is easily expressed:
In rlrq p=pr P=Pr
113
PAD COEFFICIENTS
In rlr2
P=Pr
(l-w)
(rl I r I rz)
Integrating the pressure field on the whole bearing area, we obtain load capacity W. Bearing Eqn 5.1 in mind, we may express the effective pad area as follows: (5.66) where (5.67)
A*, is plotted in Fig. 5.14.a as a function of u'=(r4-r3)/(r4-rl), for certain values of r'=rllr4 and for the most common case r4-r3=r2-r1. The hydraulic resistances of the outer and inner clearances are (Eqn 4.59):
Since the flow rate is the s u m of Q3-4 and Q2-l, bearing Eqn 5.2 in mind, the total hydraulic resistance of the pad is: (5.68) where:
R* =
1 1
+- 1 In r4fr3 In r2/rl
(5.69)
R* is also plotted in Fig. 5.14.b. The pumping power lost in the pad (Eqn 5.4), written a s a function of the load, is still given by Eqn 5.24. Given the inner and outer radii of the pad, it is now possible to assess its "optimal" geometry, looking for the minimum of r*=l/(A*,'R*).If we state that r4-r3=r2-r1,we find that the optimal value of a' is very close to 113 (see Fig. 5.14.d). However, this is not a critical value, and a larger recess (perhaps a'=0.2) is often preferred in order to decrease supply pressure and friction power.
114
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICAT/ON
0.
R'
0
0.0 0.00
'
'
0
0.25
0.50 a'
0.50
a'
-c-
1.01
0.25
a'
Fig. 5.14 Coefficients of annular recess pad.
-d-
115
PAD COEFFlClENTS
It should be pointed out that to configure the pad with equal length of the lands is by far the most common practice, since it is simple and give very good results, but it is not, strictly speaking, the best choice from the point of view of pumping power. Indeed, looking for the absolute minimum of r* it is possible to find the values of ratios r3Jr4and rl lr2 that ensure the least loss of pumping power for any value of r'; the results contained in Table 5.1 show that the equal-length configuration practically gives the same results as the true optimal configuration. Other authors (ref. 1.8) prefer pads with equal radius ratios, i.e. r3/r4=r1/r2, in such a way that flow rates crossing the inner and outer clearances are equal; Table 5.1 shows that this practice also gives good results, especially a t the highest values of r'. The friction moment is, from Eqn 4.60, (5.70) where (5.71) which is plotted in Fig. 5.14.c. The friction power is, hence, (5.72) The friction coefficient, referred to the mean radius F=(r4+r1)/2of the pad, is therefore: (5.73)
- r' 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9
General case rllr2 r3/r4 r* 0.680 0.758 0.823 0.877 0.924 0.965
0.791 22.1 0.827 35.8 0.863 65.7 0.898 146.8 0.933 468.5 0.967 3552
a'
0.337 0.335 0.334 0.334 0.333 0.333
r2-rI=r4-r3 rl/r2 r3/r4 0.664 0.749 0.818 0.875 0.923 0.964
r*
0.798 22.1 0.833 35.8 0.866 65.8 0.900 146.9 0.933 468.5 0.967 3552
rl11-2 0:746 0.798 0.845 0.889 0.928 0.966
r1/r2=r3/r4 r3/r4 r* 0.746 23.5 0.798 37.1 0.845 67.0 0.889 148.3 0.928 470.3 0.966 3555
116
HYDROSTATICLUBRICATION
Hydrostatic thrust bearings with annular recesses are frequently used, very often coupled to hydrostatic journal bearings. When the turning velocity is not high, pumping power is much greater than friction power; on the basis of the above results, it is easy to make certain elementary suggestions:
r' should be low. In practice, due to design constraints, we almost always find that r50.5. Values greater than r'=0.8 should be avoided;
a' should be in the 0.2+0.4 range;
D, i.e. the bearing area, should be as large as is allowed by the other design constraints; The film thickness h should be low; The lubricant viscosity p should be high.
EXAMPLE 5.5 A n annular recess bearing must sustain a load W=20 KN, rotating at n = 2 n radls (60 rpm); its outer diameter is D=O.l m, the inner one is 2rI=0.04 m (i.e. r'=0.4). For clearance h=50 pm is chosen, and for a' the near-optimal value a'=l/3. 0 The lubricant data at T=40OC are: p=O.l Nslmz, p=9ooKglm3, ~ 1 9 0 JlKgSC. From Eqn 5.66 we get A,=4.40.10-3 m2 and hence a recess pressure pr=4.55 MPa is needed to sustain the load. The hydraulic resistance of the pad (Eqn 5.68) is R=22O,lO9 Nslm5and the flow rate proves to be Q=20.7.10-6m31s. The pumping power is Hi=94 W. For friction we find: MfzO.0857 Nm, Hf=0.54 W, f=O.l22.lO-3, respectively. The temperature step of the lubricant, from the inlet to the outlet of the pad, is (Eqn 5.7) AT=2.7%, which is practically negligible. Comparing these results to those already obtained for a circular recess pad with the same diameter (Example 5.1), it may be noted that the friction of the annular recess pad is lower; slightly greater pressure is required, but the flow rate and power consumption are more than 4.5 times greater. EXAMPLE 5.6 Let us change the inner radius of the bearing in the former example to rI=0.03 m (i.e. r'=0.6), and the angular speed to R=4n radls (120 rpm). We obtain p,=5.97 MPa, Q=46.8.10-6m3/s, Hi=279 W, Mf=0.147 Nm, Hf=1.85 W, f=0.18.10-3,AT=3.5oC. In comparison with the former example, a small increase i n pressure may again be noted, while for flow rate and pumping power the increase is much larger. EXAMPLE 5.7 I f the inner radius is again increased to rl=0.04 m, r' becomes 0.8;let the angular speed now be Q=6n radls (180 rpm). We find: pr=10.6 MPa, Q=187.10-6m 3 / s , Hi=1989 W, Mf=0.146 Nm, Hf=2.76 W, f=0.16.10-3 and AT=6.2"C. Temperature in-
PAD COEFFlClENTS
117
crease may no longer be negligible: hence, it will be best to put a heat exchanger in the oil reservoir. When this bearing is compared to the one in Example 5.5, one may note that pressure is more than doubled, while a greater increase occurs for the flow rate and pumping power (the latter increases more than 10 times). It may be useful to increase the viscosity of the lubricant: if p is doubled, Q and Hi are halved; Mf and H f are doubled, too, but they still remain quite low. Another way to reduce Q is to use a lower value for a' (i.e. to reduce the width of the recess); on the contrary, a greater a' causes a decrease in pressure. It should be pointed out, however, that, for the highest values of r', a slight displacement of a' from its optimal value can lead to a notable increase in Hi (see Fig. 5.14.d).
5.4.2
Effects of errors in parallelism
The bearing pad in Fig. 5.15 is affected by a lack of parallelism of the surfaces of the bearing components. We may state:
ah;=%&* r4
Fig. 5.15 Misaligned annular recess pad.
(5.74)
118
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
1.oo
0.95
CR
0.90 r'=0.4 0.6
'
0.85 0.0
0.8
1.o
0.5 Ah'
Fig. 5.16 Misaligned annular recess pad: correction factor C, versus parallelism error Ah' for two values of the land width ratio a'.
where Ah' is given by Eqn 5.31. Bearing the results of section 5.3.3 in mind, we find that, for a certain recess pressure p r and mean film thickness E, the only conspicuous effect of misalignment is an increase in flow rate; such an increase may be expressed as l/CR(Ah';r 3 / r 4 )for the external gap, and 1/cR(Ahi;r l / r z )for the internal one. Thus, while the effective area A, may be considered to be practically unaffected by a misalignment Ah'<1, the hydraulic resistance R may be expressed in the form of Eqn 5.34; the correction factor CR, calculated as above, is plotted in Fig. 5.16 as a function of Ah', for certain values of r' and a'.
5.4.3
Effects of pressure losses at the inlet
When the Reynolds number is greater than 100, the pressure losses at the inlet should be taken into account. Applying the results of section 5.3.4 to both the gaps in the annular recess pad, the whole hydraulic resistance of the pad should be corrected as in Eqn 5.36, where Cp is given approximately by Eqn 5.39 (or by Fig. 5.61, but the Reynolds number is (5.75) and r', r and A r must be substituted by the following:
PAD COEFFICIENTS
119
- rl + r2 + r3 + r4 r=
Ar =
4
r2 - rl + r4 - r3 2
EXAMPLE 5.8 A pad bearing with an annular recess has an outer diameter D=O.l m; the inner one is 2rI=0.08 m (r'=0.8). It has to sustain a load W=15 KN, with a recess pressure pr lower than 8 MPa. The angular speed is Q=6.28 ra d ls (60 rpm); the main characteristics of the lubricant are: p=0.03 Nslm2,p885 e l m 3 . Let us select a'=0.3; h=100 pm. We immediately find A,=1.98.10-3 m2 and, hence, pr=7.58 MPa, which is safely smaller than the maximum pressure allowed. I f the pressure losses at the inlet are disregarded, we also find R=1.91.109 Nslm5, and Q=3.97.1 0-3 m3 I s. From the above equations, we find Re=207, F'=0.935, r=0.045 m, Ar=3 mm. A correction factor Cp=1.28 can be obtained from Fig. 5.6. Since the flow rate is inversely proportional to the hydraulic resistance, a new value is found: Q=3.10.10-3 mats, which is still very high. On the other hand, the friction power is very small, compared to the pumping power (Hf=O.O4 W,His23.5 Kw). I f such a low friction is not a design constraint, it is clearly advisable to reduce the selected clearance and to increase lubricant viscosity, in order to greatly reduce flow rate and pumping power.
5.4.4
Turbulent flow
When the Reynolds number is high, the flow becomes turbulent. The results already obtained in section 5.3.5 can be extended to the annular recess pad. In particular, since in most cases both r l l r 2 and r31r4 are greater than 0.8, the influence on the effective bearing area can be disregarded. The hydraulic resistance of the pad, on the other hand, can now be written as: (5.76)
Correction coefficient C R is~still given by Eqn 5.48 (also plotted in Fig. 5.7.b)in which parameter zb is now defined as follows:
120
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
The flow rate may prove to be much lower than expected on the basis of the laminar theory, a s in the case of the central recess pads, but the problems connected with turbulence also remain the same.
5.4.5
Effects of the inertia forces
When the turning velocity of the pad is high, the forces of inertia in the lubricant should be taken into account. The Reynolds equation (Eqn 5.49) can be solved on the land surfaces to give the relevant pressure field, while the recess pressure is hypothesized to be a constant (see ref. 5.17). Integrating the pressure field, we find the load capacity of the pad, while the flow rate is obtained by integrating qr, as obtained from Eqns 4.33, along the recess boundaries.
Fig. 5.17 Annular recess pad: correction factor CR,versus inertia parameter Si for certain values of ratio r' and of land width ratio a'.
As usual, Eqn 5.66 and Eqn 5.68 have to be substituted by the following equations: (5.77)
(5.78)
where
121
PAD COEFFICIENTS -a-
-b-
I.€
11
1.1
I?
1.2
1.: 2 1 -
SI'O
1.0
1.c
-P
P Pro
Pro
a8
0.8 ~
0.6
0.6
0.4
0.4
0.2
0.2 r; =0.95
0
0 0.6
0.8
1
0.6
0.8
r
-
-r
4'
r4
1
Fig. 5.18 Annular recess pad: pressure distribution for one value or ratio r'=r1/r4and certain values of inertia parameter S,.[Note that pm=(3/7r)pQ( l/h3)ln(r2/r,)].
(5.80)
122
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
For the correction factor CAI, however, we always have 0.99
123
PAD COEFFICIENTS
5.4.6
Thermal effects
It has been shown for the central recess pads that, at very high turning speeds, temperature, and hence lubricant viscosity, vary considerably in the bearing clearances. In the annular recess pads, however, the ratio of the inner to the outer radius of each clearance is, generally speaking, higher, and this leads to lower increases in temperature. This is confirmed by the examples above.
5.5
5.5.1
TAPERED PADS Basic equations
Figure 5.19 contains a sketch of two tapered pads fitted with central recess (a) and annular recess (b).
* -a-
-b-
Fig. 5.19 Tapered pads: a- central recess; b- annular recess.
The Reynolds equation for a conical clearance was obtained in section 4.3.2; assuming steady state operation] and uniform clearance h, on all the land surface, Eqn 4.26 is reduced to:
(5.81)
124
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
The term on the right-hand side accounts for the inertia forces due to angular velocity 0, in the simplest case, it is negligible, and hence Eqn 5.81 is reduced to Eqn 4.56, which does not depend on the aperture angle a; thus the pattern of the pressure field is exactly the same as for a plane clearance (a=d2) of identical radius ratio r'. Stating pr=l, and integrating p.sina on the recess and land surfaces, we obtain the effective area of the pad. Again it turns out to be the same as for the plane bearings, i.e. Eqn 5.20, where A: is given by Eqn 5.22, or Fig. 5.l.b, for the central recess pad, and by Eqn 5.67, or Fig. 5.14, for the annular recess pad. The flow rate a t radius r is obtained by integration of the radial velocity: (5.82)
Let us disregard velocity R for the time being. The hydraulic resistance of the tapered pads may be written as follows:
(5.83) where R* is given by Eqn 5.23 or Fig. 5.l.b, and by Eqn 5.69 or Fig. 5.14, respectively. It follows that the flow rate through a conical clearance will turn out to be proportional to sina. The moment of the friction forces for an axial-symmetric conical land of length dr is dMf = 2 x- CrQ hn
r3 sin3a
dr
which may be easily integrated to give the friction moment: (5.84)
and the friction power:
(5.85) HF is exactly the same as that already calculated for the plane bearings: i.e. Eqn 5.28 for the central recess pad, and Eqn 5.71 for the other. When a tapered pad is compared to a plane bearing of the same diameter, with equal values of the normal film thickness and the same radius ratios, it is easy to see that:
125
PAD COEFFICIENTS
the load capacity for any given recess pressure is the same (or, for an equal flow rate, is greater for the conical pads: actually, it is proportional t o llsina); the flow rate, a t any given load, is proportional to sinq i.e. it is lower for the conical pads. The same Consequently, the same occurs for the pumping power; on the other hand the axial stiffness, which proves to be inversely proportional to h=h,lsina, for any given load capacity, is lower (proportional to sina) for the conical pads; the friction power (proportional to llsina) is greater for the conical pads. Furthermore, tapered pads have a greater axial size than the plane pads and may prove to be more sensitive to assembling misalignments.
EXAMPLE 5.11 An annular recess tapered bearing has to sustain a load W=20 KN, rotating at Q=4a radls (120 rpm). The main geometrical parameters are: D=O.l m; L=0.02 m, a=45'(i.e. rt=l-(2Ltga)lD=0.6).The viscosity of the lubricant is p=O.l N s l m z at operating temperature. I f we select a'=113 and hn=50 pm (or h=70.7 pm), we easily obtain A50.427, A,=3.35.103 m2, and hence p,=5.97 MPa; moreover, R*=O.0835, R=180.109 Nslm5, and hence &=33.10-6 m 3 / s . The pumping power is thus Hi=197 W. The friction moment is easily calculated as Mf=0.208 Nm, while Hf=2.6 W. Compare these results with those in Example 5.6.
5.5.2
Effect of the inertia forces
As has been pointed out before, when Q is large, the inertia term should be retained in Eqn 5.81. This kind of problem is examined in ref. 5.17 for the annular recess pad, and in ref. 5.19 for the central recess pad. In the latter, thermal effects are also considered, as in ref. 5.13. If we solve Eqn 5.81, and integrate the pressure field, we finally find that the effective area A, is again given by Eqn 5.53 and Eqn 5.77 for the circular-recess and the annular-recess pads, respectively. In the same way, the hydraulic resistance will be: (5.86)
126
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
where correction coefficient CRIis given by Eqn 5.58 or by Eqn 5.80 (or by the relevant plots).
5.5.3
Effect of misalignment
Two possible types of misalignment are shown in Fig. 5.20. In Fig. 5.20.a, the shaft is tilted (by a n angle y) with respect to the axis of the fixed member; this case is similar to the error in parallelism for the plane bearings, seen in sections 5.3.3 and 5.4.2. The coaxiality error (case b), on the contrary, is meaningless for the plane pads. Of course, all these errors may occur together and the problem will prove to be quite complicated. -b-
-a -
aw I
-+I
Fig. 5.20 Tapered pads: a- misaligned; b- non coaxial.
Since the radial symmetry is lost, and hence the film thickness h is no longer a constant, but a function of the coordinates, Eqn 5.81 should be substituted by the twodimensional Reynolds equation:
(5.87) obtained from Eqn 4.26 in the steady state case. Equation 5.87 should be solved, in general cases, by means of suitable numerical methods, as seen in the case of the error in parallelism of the plane bearing. Some rough approximation will, however, be enough in most cases. For instance, in the case of Fig. 5.20.b, one may assume that, for small eccentricities, the flow remains
127
PAD COEFFlClENTS
essentially radial. In this assumption, the effective area does not vary; the flow rate on a sector dfi of the conical surface is (see Fig. 4.5):
The clearance may be written in the following form:
[ " cos (19- @]
h, = C cosa 1-
where C&tga is the mean radial play. The flow rate is, hence: 21r
x x3
Q = J d Q = G z p r sin4a(l+t$) 0
Thus correction factor C R x for the hydraulic resistance can be evaluated as: (5.89)
Friction is also affected by a radial displacement x . Proceeding as above, we can assess a correction factor Cfx for M f and Hf, which may be written as:
1.21 1.1
-
1.o
0.9 -
0.8 * 0.7 -..
0.0
0.1
0.2
0.4
0.3
0.5
X/C Fig. 5.21 Non coaxial tapered pad: correction factors C R for ~ the hydraulic resistance and Cfx for friction versus radial displacement xlC.
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
128 1
Cfr =
(5.90)
$ <
It is clear that a radial displacement, comparable to the design value of the film thickness, greatly affects the hydraulic resistance of the pad, and consequently the performance of the bearing. This point should be carefully considered when designing. For example, if a conical thrust bearing sustains a shaft which is also loaded in a radial direction, the stiffness of the radial bearings will interact with the axial load capacity. The case of Fig. 5.20.a (tilting error) is examined in ref. 5.20 by means of numerical integration (finite differences) of Eqn 5.87. The effect of a relative tilt 1y'=1yDl(2h,)10.6 on the hydraulic resistance (at low speed) is found to be always smaller than for a flat bearing (a=90"). In particular, it is negligible for a=60"+75", while a=45" is a n intermediate case. When the speed is high, the hydrodynamic effect, due to the uneven clearance, may in part counterbalance the effect of the tilting error, and a tilted bearing may even prove to perform better than a centered one!
SPHERICAL PADS
5.6
To overcome the problems connected with the tilting errors, a spherically-shaped pad (Fig. 5.22) could be used, instead of the flat or tapered types.
As usual, to calculate the performance of the pad, the relevant Reynolds equation must be solved to find the pressure in the clearances. Such a n equation has been obtained in section 4.3.3. For an axial-symmetric spherical clearance, Eqn 4.30 is reduced to:
The above equation is easily solved when E=O (concentric configuration), giving:
tan (~112
Pr
(5.91)
In for the central recess pad, with p=pr for p q l andp=O for p q 2 . A general solution may however be obtained (ref. 5.21, 5.22), although the relevant equations are quite cumbersome.
129
PAD COEFFICIENTS
-a-
-b-
Fig. 5.22 Spherical pads: a- central recess; b- annular recess.
The load capacity is calculated by integrating the pressure on the recess and land area. For E=O, we obtain: (5.92)
From the first of Eqns 4.28; the velocity of the fluid in the tangential direction is: u=-
*(@-h,@ DPaP
and hence the rate of flow, for E=O, is: (5.93)
Load and flow rate can be written in the usual form (i.e. Eqn 5.1 and Eqn 5.21, where the effective area is: A, = x4 0
2
sin2q2A*,
and A*,, calculated from Eqn 5.92, is plotted in Fig. 5.23.a.
(5.94)
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATlON
130 2
A', Hi
0.8
0.8 0.6
1
0.4
0.4
t I"
60"
90"
0.0 30'
90"
60" (92
(92
-c-
-d0
0.05
.
1
5
-
7
1
0.00' 30"
'
'
.
'
60"
.
'
'
90" (92
Fig. 5.23 Spherical pads. Pad coefficients A*,, R* and H,? (in the case of E=O) versus included angle (p2 for certain values of ratio (p1/(p2:a, b- central recess pad; c, d- annular recess pad with (pa=O.25'((p2-(pl).
PAD COEFFlClENTS
131
The hydraulic resistance may be written as: (5.95) Again R* is plotted in Fig. 5.23.b. The friction moment is:
in which the shear stress
should be substituted. As usual, we may write the friction moment and the friction power in the following form:
Mfo=
2$ f2
0 4 sin4q2 H,F
(5.96)
where HT (which is also plotted in Fig. 5.23.a) is: (5.98) Unlike for the plane pads, A*, cannot be considered as a constant] but depends on E especially when cp2 is great and q1/cp2 is small. Also Eqn 5.12 and Eqn 5.13 cannot be considered valid for large included angle q2. For instance] Fig. 5.24 (ref. 5.22) shows how load capacity and flow rate are subjected to change with E for a pad with cp2=85". It is easily seen that for negative displacements the effective area may experience a severe reduction] while the increase of hydraulic resistance is smaller than the cubic trend predicted on the basis of Eqn 5.12. Depending on the supply system, even negative stiffness may occur, and the bearing may prove to be unstable (ref. 5.23). However, this kind of problem may be prevented by using q1/q2 ratios in the order of 0.5 and values of q2S75".
A peculiar type of central-recess spherical pad is the "fitted' type, characterized by having a null clearance in the concentric configuration. It is obvious that most of the foregoing equations now become meaningless, and it is necessary to write load
132
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
-a-
-
b-
1.0
0.8
w
20 0.6 2
n
a
5
0.4
0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
to
a8
? 1%
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
4 ’%
Fig. 5.24 Spherical pad with cenh-a1 recess: a- load factor W.4/(zDzprsin&p) and b- flow factor Q-pl[(l+~)%?p,]versus ratio q1/(p2for a number of values of eccentricity E (ref. 5.22).
capacity and flow rate a s functions of the displacement h=h,(cp=O). We obtain (ref. 5.24):
tan2q2 - tan2cpl
x
W = 4 D2 pr
tan 472
tan2472 - tan2ql + 2 In tan 471
& = -xh3 - p
1
3 P
tan472 tan2472 - tan2cpl + 2 In tan471
Torque is found to be (ref. 5.21)
M r=
gf RD4
-
( ~ 0 ~ 2 4 7cos2ql ~ -2
ln-
Spherical bearings have also been studied from the point of view of the effects of fluid inertia (ref. 5.21) and of change in viscosity due to adiabatic flow (ref. 5.25). It
PAD CO€FF/CENTS
133
has been shown that high values of the inertia parameter Si defined in Eqn 5.50 (perhaps Sp0.25) are detrimental for divergent film shapes, i.e. for negative eccentricities: load capacity may be notably reduced, and even cavitation is likely to occur. On the contrary, for converging film shapes (e.g. for the fitted type of bearing) load capacity is improved and, due to the large pressures developed near the edge, bearings with a wide included angle (p2 also feature a notable radial load capacity. The annular recess pads (Fig. 5.22.b) feature an effective area W l p , that does not vary much with eccentricity, especially when cpz is small. Proceeding as above, we can calculate the relevant values of parameters A:, R* and HF to be inserted in the equations from Eqn 5.94 to Eqn 5.97. They are plotted in Fig. 5.23.c and Fig. 5.23.d. For A*,it may be taken approximately (see also ref. 5.26): (5.99)
at least when (pa is smaller than 0.25((p2-cpl).
5.7
RECTANGULAR PADS
For a rectangular pad, such as in Fig. 5.25, the two-dimensional Reynolds equation Eqn 4.15 has to be solved, which, if h=const or U=O, is simply reduced to Eqn 4.31 (Laplace equation). The boundary conditions are, as usual, p=pr at the inner boundary of the clearance, and p=O at the outer one. Once the pressure on the land area has been evaluated, the load capacity is obtained by integration. The rate of flow, on the other hand, is given by the following: (5.100)
where S is the inner boundary (or any closed contour including it), and n is the outer normal direction of S (see also section 4.5.2). In spite of its simplicity, Eqn 4.31 may be solved, in the general case, only by numerical methods. A first rough approximation can be very easily obtained by partitioning the land area as in Fig. 5.26 (ref. 1.8).The pressure is assumed to vary with a linear trend (see section 4.7.1) along the z. coordinate, for parts [ll and 121, and along z for parts 131 and [41. In the corners, a logarithmic trend is assumed (see section 4.7.4); if we have ri=O, the corners may be neglected altogether. Calculations for load and flow rate are now straightforward: on the analogy with the other pad types, the effective area A, and the hydraulic resistance R may be written as:
134
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
4
J
Fig. 5.25 Rectangular pad.
A, = L B A:
(5.101)
R=$R*
(5.102)
with
- 4 ri 6' (a' + rib' B') + Za'
a'lB'+ 2 rib' a' In l+rib B )
(5.103)
(
R* =
6
(5.104)
n:
(
In l+- rl E ' B ) where a' - a
-L;
b
b'=B;
B ' =B -
and
ri q'=Z
PAD COEFFlClENTS
135
Fig. 5.26 The assumed shape of a rectangular pad.
A more refined approach is explained in ref. 5.27, in which a n approximate solution of the Laplace equation is searched for as a linear combination p=Xcjqj of n harmonic functions qJx, z ) ; coefficients cj are determined by imposing that the mean square error in certain points (xk, Zk) of the boundaries (on which pressure is known) is the least possible. In other words, the following system of n equations must be solved
If a certain skill is used in selecting the harmonic functions, only a few terms are needed (perhaps n=4) to obtain a good approximation of the pressure field: the relevant error can be easily checked, since it can be shown that it is maximum on the boundary. Once a closed form solution has been obtained for p , load capacity is calculated by integration, while flow rate is simply proportional to coefficient c1 (this is another consequence of the appropriate selection of functions 9). A t present, the solution of Eqn 4.31 is based on numerical methods, such as finite-difference or finite-element methods (for instance see ref. 5.28, 5.29, 5.30): in particular, the charts in Fig. 5.27, 5.28 and 5.29 (taken from ref. 5.31 and ref. 5.32) are calculated by means of a finite-difference method.
The pumping power dissipated in the bearing is still given by Eqn 5.4. As for the circular pad, it is useful to write Hi as a function of the load capacity: (5.105)
r* also is plotted in Fig. 5.29; it appears that an “optimal”value exists for a‘,in connection with the minimum of the r* curves. Concerning the effect of the inner
136
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATlON
-b-
-a0.
0.
0.3'
0.0
0.2
a'
0.4
.
'
0.0
'
' 0.1
.
.
'
0.2
a'
Fig. 5.27 Rectangular pads: pad coefficient keversus land width a'.
3
F]
.
R'
2-
1.o
1
0.5 0.5
0.5 0.25
0
-b-
1.5
0.0
0.1
a'
0.2
Fig. 5.28 Rectangular pads: pad coefficient R* versus land width a'. fillet radius ri, although this yields a lower load capacity, it appears to be effective from the point of view of power. On the contrary, the outer radius r,, which is not considered in the charts above, has negative effects on both A, and H i , and should be avoided (however, when r,+r,lBs0.25, it has no practical influence on the performance of the pad). The friction force on the pad, due to a sliding velocity U,is (from Eqn 4.35):
137
PAD COEFFICIENTS
-b8
r
0.25
r 6-
0.5
54 .J
0.o
0.1
a'
0.2
Fig. 5.29 Rectangular pads: pad coefficient r*versus land width a'.
(5.106)
and, consequently, the friction power is:
The effective friction area Af coincides, as a rough approximation, with land area Al; as a matter of fact, the contribution of recesses to friction is often small, since recess depth h, is much greater than h. However, this is not always true; the flow recirculation in the recess can make recess friction comparable to land friction (and even greater, for turbulent recirculation). Moreover, h, should not be too high for reasons connected with the dynamic behavior (see chapter 10) and, when the speed is high, the lands should be narrow and, hence, the recess area greater than the land area. A better approximation for the effective friction area may be written in the following form:
A t = Al -I-f, A, = =L€?{l-(l-f,)(l-2~')
+ B ' ( 4 - d [ ( l - f r ) ( 1 - 2 8a' ;) 2 ri2-ri2]]
Coefficient f, can be calculated as indicated in section 4.5.3.
(5.108)
138
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATlON
EXAMPLE 5.12 A rectangular pad has to be designed, able to carry a 45 KN load. The width of the pad should be B=O.I m; the recess pressure should be lower than 4 MPa and the friction coefficient lower than 10-4 at a speed U=0.2 m l s . The viscosity of the lubricant to be used is p=0.03 Nslm2. Due to the constraint on pr, the effective area (Eqn 5.1) must be greater than 11.3.10-3 m2. Figure 5.27 shows that, for values of a’ near to the “optimal”,A: takes on values greater than 0.55; consequently, we may take LB=0.02 m2, i.e. L=0.2 m and B’=0.5. If we select a’=0.125 (i.e. b’=0.5) and ri=0.5, in Fig. 5.27 and Fig. 5.28 we read Az=0.6, R*=0.77; hence A,=0.012 m2, pr=3.75 MPa. The land area is easily calculated as A1=0.013 m2; from Eqn 5.106 it follows that, for f d O - 4 , it must be h>17.3 pm: a very small value. A more suitable selection may be h=30 pm; now Eqn 5.104 gives R=0.86.1012 Nslm5 and hence &=4.4.10-6mats; the pumping power dissipated in the bearing clearaAce is Hi=16.5 W. A more accurate calculation of the effective friction area (Eqn 5,108) gives, for hr=0.5 mm, Af=0.015 ma; the friction power is, hence, Hf=O.6 W (Eqn 5.107) and the friction coefficient is f=0.67.lfY4. It should be stressed that in this case a relatively small recess has been selected since the speed was quite low: indeed, the friction power turns out to be much smaller than the pumping power. For higher speeds, a larger recess would have been a more suitable selection. This kind of problem, extensively dealt with in chapter 11, will also be considered in section 6.4.
5.8
CYLINDRICAL PADS
Cylindrical pads may be used to support a shaft in a radial direction. They may be thought of as extensions of any flat pad shape (e.g. the pad with a circular projected area in Fig. 5.30.a), although the rectangular shape is by far the most common (Fig. 5.30.b). It must be pointed out that a single-recess cylindrical pad is practically unable to sustain side loads; this greatly reduces the usefulness of such pads, unless they are a part of a multipad bearing system (see section 7.5). The study of these pads is made, as usual, by finding a solution for the relevant Reynolds equation, i.e. of Eqn 4.18.In that equation, the right-hand side accounts for the effects of the turning velocity of the journal and for the squeeze effect under dynamic loading. Film thickness h depends on the displacement of the journal center:
h = C [I- E C O S ( ~ - ~ ) ]
(5.109)
in which C is the film thickness in the concentric configuration E=O (see also Fig. 4.4).Once the pressure field on the pad lands is known, both the load capacity and the rate of flow are easily evaluated, as in the preceding sections.
139
PAD COEFFICIENTS
-b-
-a-
IW
IQ
lQ
.i Fig. 5.30 Cylindrical pads: a- circular recess; b- rectangular recess.
Even in the simplest case (E=O, &=O, h=C), in which the right-hand side of Eqn 4.18 vanishes, a numerical solution is needed. In Fig. 5.31, 5.32 and 5.33,the pad coefficients are plotted, for certain rectangular shapes, obtained by means of a finite element approximation. Other data are available in the literature: e.g. in ref. 5.33, where they are obtained by means of the electric analogue technique (ref. 5.34).
As in the case of the flat pads, one may write the effective bearing area and the hydraulic resistance of the pad (for E=O) in a form: a A, = L D sinTA*,
(5.110)
R~=&R*
(5.111)
Certain notable differences should, however, be stressed; first, the reference config uration is no longer arbitrary: a natural reference point exists, in which the centers of curvature of the two pad surfaces coincide, and h=ho=C.Coefficient A*, is not independent from the journal displacement (however, this dependence is in most cases negligible). The hydraulic resistance is no longer exactly related to the dis-
140
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
placement by Eqn 5.12, which, however, remains approximately valid for small included angles a and small values of displacement E = e / h o in the normal direction rp=O.
As for other types of pad, it is convenient to write the pumping power Hi=p,Q as a function of the load, in order to try to obtain a n optimization of the pad design:
-a-
1.o
A',' o.8#
0.6
\ 60"
0.4
-b-
75"
a'
0.4' 0.0
.
'
'
' 0.2
.
.
a'
'
0.4
Fig. 5.31 Cylindrical pads. Pad coefficient Heversus land width a'.
-a-
R'
0.0
0.1
0.2
a'
0.3
0.0
Fig. 5.32 Cylindrical pads. Pad coefficient R* versus land width a'.
0.2
a'
0.4
141
PAD COEFFICIENTS
In particular, given L, D, and a,the relevant "optimal" value of a' may be readily evaluated by means of the plots of T*=lfR*A*, in Fig. 5.33. The friction moment, in the concentric configuration E=O,is: (5.112)
The friction power is, consequently, (5.113)
The effective area Af may be calculated as for rectangular pads; namely, as a rough approximation, Af coincides with the developed land area; if instead the recess friction is also taken into account, Afmay be written as: (5.114)
The friction factor f , is evaluated as in section 4.7.3;however, in most cases one may simply take f,=4C/h,.
-a-
-b-
6-
r* 4
u=90"
t
2
2'
0.0
0.1
0.2
a'
0.3
0.0
0.2
a'
0.4
Fig. 5.33 Cylindrical pads. Pad coefficient r*versus land width a'. 5.9
HYDROSTATIC LIFTS
A particular application (ref. 1.5) of externally pressurized lubrication consists in relieving large hydrodynamic bearings in certain critical operations, such as starting or stopping, in which, due to insufficient velocity, the lubricant film would be ruptured, leading to high friction and fast wear. In certain applications, in
142
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATlON
which the torque available is not much greater than the normal regime torque, starting can even prove to be impossible without the aid of a hydrostatic lift. This kind of bearings (Fig. 5.34) are often referred to a s "hybrid" journal bearings; it seems, however, more appropriate to define them as hydrodynamic bearings with a hydrostatic lift, since external pressurization is generally confined to low speed running, while it is removed during normal running.
)Wa-
I
IQ
IQ
lw
-b-
Li II Fig. 5.34 Hydrostatic lift: a- axial recess; b- circumferential recess.
Behavior of such a "hybrid" bearing (studied for instance in ref. 5.35-5.37) is beyond the scope of a work on hydrostatic lubrication; we shall therefore present results relevant to the hydrostatic lift alone. Due to the large included angle (we may assume a=180°) and to the smallness of the recess, Eqn 5.12 is clearly far from representing the actual increase of hydraulic resistance with eccentricity, and even the effective area can no longer be considered as a constant. In Table 5.2, values are reported of the nondimensional load capacity for eccentricities from E=O &=0.8,assuming constant-flow direct supply, obtained by means of a finite element program (ref. 5.38). Several sizes of recesses have been
143
PAD COEFFICIENTS
considered, developed in the axial direction (small a,,Fig. 5.34.a), as well as in the circumferential direction (small I', Fig. 5.34.b). Table 5.3 also contains an evaluation of the ratio of recess pressure p , to mean pressure WILD. It should be noted, however, that the actual recess pressure can be notably higher; in particular in the case of axial recess (Fig. 5.30.b), a t starting the recess may be shut off as a result of elastic deformation and hence the pressure can be very high until the journal rises: values up to five times the normal running pressure are reported (ref. 1.5). It is good practice to use a pressure relief valve in order to protect the pump, limiting the maximum pressure. Concerning the dimensions of the hydrostatic pocket, it is generally suggested that its area LDl'sina, is 2.54% of the projected area LD. Indeed, from Table 5.3 it is clear that larger recesses have no practical advantage from the point of view of ratio W / Q , while the advantage in terms of pocket pressure is small; furthermore, the interference of recess with the hydrodynamic pressure pattern should be borne in mind.
T A B L E 5.2 Iydro: tic lift:
-
on-dimensional load capacity. W DLpQ/C3
a 1' VD L 1
0.1
1
0.1 0.1
E
=O
E = 0.3
E
= 0.6
E
= 0.8
E
=0.9
~~
2.19
7.88 6.67
29.6
48O
1.03 0.99
2.36
20.3
44.6
72"
0.93
1.95
5.17
2.31 2.14
7.73 6.50
12.3 29.1
20.6 87.3
19.8
43.5
1.73 1.60 1.44 1.68
35.2 24.1 14.3 34.3 23.3
130.8 64.7 28.4 127.6 62.4
24O
88.2
1 1
0.2
24"
1.01
1
0.2
48"
0.5
0.1 0.1 0.1 0.2 0.2
48" 72" 24"
48"
0.96 0.66 0.64 0.61 0.65 0.62
1.56
7.18 6.07 4.74 6.98 5.90
6" 12O
0.88 0.87
2.08 2.05
7.34 7.22
31.0 30.0
115.5
6' 12"
0.65 0.61
1.57
5.82
1.54
5.67
26.1 25.1
102.3 94.3
0.5 0.5 0.5
0.5 1 1 1
0.5 0.5 0.75 0.75
24"
1 --
106.6
144
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
TABLE 5.3 [ydrol itic lift: o-f
non-dimensional recess pressure. PI
W I D L 1' UD a, 1 1 1
1 1 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 1 1 1 I
0.1 0.1 0.1 0.2 0.2 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.2 0.2 0.5 0.5 0.75 0.75
24" 48" 720 24"
48" 24O
48" 720 Z"
48" 6" 12" 6" 12"
- --
E=O
3.38 2.73 2.36 2.97 2.42 3.97 2.95 2.41 3.55 2.65 2.76 2.56 2.40 2.23
= 0.8
E = 0.3
E = 0.6
E
3.75 2.95 2.49 3.26 2.58 4.15 3.06 2.47 3.72 2.74 3.05 2.81 2.63 2.42
4.53 3.38 2.73 3.85 2.90 4.55 3.25 2.58 4.05 2.90 3.66 3.31 3.12 2.82
5.85 4.02 3.06 4.81 3.34 5.21 3.52 2.7 1 4.55 3.11 4.72 4.13 3.92 3.43
E
= 0.9
7.35 4.67 3.38 5.85 3.77 5.88 3.80 2.82 5.08 3.30 5.99 5.03 4.83 4.05
EXAMPLE 5.13 The following are the data of a hydrodynamic journal bearing: D=0.5 m, L=0.4 m, C=0.3 mm, W=300KN. The lubricant is a SAE 30 oil (p=O.l Nslm2 at operating temperature). Let us try to design a suitable hydrostatic lift. First, one may establish the dimensions of the recess. For instance, we may select 1=60 m m (i.e. l'=0.15) and a circumferential width b=100 m m (ar=23?. The flow rate and pressure of the pump can be calculated once the working eccentricity has been selected. If we choose &=0.8(corresponding to a minimum film thickness h=60 pm), by interpolating data i n the relevant column of Table 5.2, the flow rate m31s. From Table 5.3 we may obtain a turns out to be Q=WC31(32~DLp)=0.013~103 recess pressure pr=Wl(0.19.LD)=7.9 MPa; as noted above, the lifting pressure will be much greater, and the value above should be considered as only a rough indication.
5.10
SCREW AND NUT ASSEMBLY
This particular kind of bearings (ref. 5.39),shown in Fig. 5.35, is dealt with in the usual way, i.e. by writing down the Reynolds equation in a suitable coordinate system, and solving it for the pressure field. Then, to find the load capacity and the rate of flow is straightforward: e.g. see ref. 5.40 and ref. 5.41.
145
PAD COEFFlClENTS
From the point of view of load capacity, every turn of a screw flank may be regarded, with a very good approximation, a s a tapered annular-recess pad (section 5.51, i.e. the effective bearing area is: x
A, = n 4 0 2 A*,
(5.115)
Fig. 5.35 Hydrostatic screw and nut.
where n is the number of active turns and A*,is given by Eqn 5.67, or Fig. 5.14. In evaluating flow rate, on the other hand, the effect of the helix angle, which actually increases the length of the recess boundaries in relation to the analogous tapered pad, should be taken into account as follows: (5.116) where
is the mean value of the helix angle of the flank
2. = atan(p*/2xr)
and R* is given by Eqn 5.69, or Fig. 5.14. Note that the actual film thickness is h,=h cose c o d , which, strictly speaking, varies with r; however, Eqn 5.116 retains a very good approximation for all the usual values of ratio rl/r4 and of the screwpitch (i.e. r1/r4<0.6,AclO"). Another approximation made in obtaining Eqn 5.116 is that no lubricant leaks out through the clearance a t the ends of the recess: this amount is generally negligible (ref. 5.421, except in certain special cases, e.g. partial-arc hydrostatic nuts. In addition to the misalignments already mentioned in the case of tapered pads, an error of pitch between screw and nut may considerably affect the performance of
146
HYDROSTATIC LUBRlCATlON
the assembly (ref. 5.43).Film thickness is no longer a constant: if 6 is the mean film thickness in the axial direction, the hydraulic resistance becomes:
(5.117)
where Sp is the pitch error, i.e. the pitch difference between screw and nut, which is assumed to be a constant. The friction power is:
(5.118) where HHf*may be taken from Fig. 5.14,or obtained from Eqn 5.71.
REFERENCES
Bassani R.; Cuscinetti d i Spinta a Facce Piane a Lubrificazione Forzata Rotanti a Piccola Velocita; Ingegneria Meccanica, 16,12(1966),45-57. Bassani R.; Conseguenze dell%rrore di Parallelismo tra le Facce Piane dei 52 Cuscinetti di Spinta a Lubrificazione Forzata (Part 1 and 2); Ingegneria Meccanica, 17,8(1968),17-28; 17,9(19681,21-28. 53 Safar Z. S., Mote C. D.; Analysis of Hydrostatic Bearings under Nonaxisymmetric Operations; Wear, 61 (19801,9-20. Bassani R.; Sulla Portata Effettiva di Lubrificante nei Cuscinetti Zdrostatici di 5.4 Spinta; Atti 1st. Mecc. Appl. Costr. Macch., Univ. di Pisa, Anno Acc. 1971-72, N. 35;39 pp. Bassani R.; Perdite Totali di Pressione e Valori Effettivi della Portata di Lu5.5 brificante e Della Capacitb di Carico nei Cuscinetti Zdrostatici d i Spinta; Fluid - Apparecchiature Idrauliche e Pneumatiche, 113 (19731,43-49. 5.6 Dowson D.; Inertia Effects in Hydrostatic Thrust Bearings; ASME Trans., J. of Basic Engineering, 83 (19611,227-234. 5.7 So0 L. S.;Laminar Flow over an Enclosed Rotating Disk; ASME Trans., 80 (1958))287-296. 5.8 Shen F. A.; Optimum Stiffness of Externally Pressurized Thrust Bearings in Turbulent Regime; ASME Trans., J. of Lubrication Technology, 92 (1970))457465. 5.9 Bassani R.; Le Equazioni del Regime Termofhidodinamico nei Cuscinetti Idrostatici di Spinta; Atti 1st. Mecc. Appl. Costr. Macch., Univ. di Pisa, Anno ACC.1968-69,N. 7;50 pp. 5.10 Bassani R.; The Thermodynamic Flow Equations for Hydrostatic Thrust Bearings; Meccanica, 5 (1970))262-269.
5.1
PAD COEFFICIENTS
147
6.11 Ting L. L., Mayer J. E.; The Effect of Temperature and Inertia on Hydrostatic Thrust Bearings Performance; ASME Trans., J. of Lubrication Technology, 93(19711,307-312. 6.12 Kapur V. K., Verma K.; The Simultaneous Effects of Inertia and Temperature on the Performance of a Hydrostatic Thrust Bearing; Wear, 54 (19791, 113-122. 6.13 Kennedy J. S., Sinha P., Radkiewicz Cz. M.; Thermal Effects i n Externally Pressurized Conical Bearings With Variable Viscosity; ASME Trans., J. of Tribology, 110 (1988),201-211. 6.14 Bassani R.; I Cuscinetti Idrostatici di Spinta in Regime Termofluidodinamico; 1st AIMETA Congr., Udine, 1971; p. 25-68. 6.16 Bassani R.; Ricerca Sperimentale sul Regime Termofluidodinamico nei Cuscinetti Idrostatici di Spinta; Atti 1st. Mecc. Appl. Costr. Macch., Univ. di Pisa, Anno Acc. 1968-69, N. 9; 40 pp. 6.16 Bassani R.; Proporzionamento dei Cuscinetti Idrostatici di Spinta Rotanti a Velocitd Anche Elevate; Atti 1st. Mecc. Appl. Costr. Macch., Univ. di Pisa, Anno ACC.1968-69, N. 12; 56 pp. 6.17 Prabhu T. J., Ganesan N.; Characteristics of Conical Hydrostatic Thrust Bearings under Rotation; Wear, 73 (1981), 95-122. 6.18 Bassani R.; Cuscinetti Zdrostatici di Spinta a Recess0 Anulare; Atti Dip. Costr. Mecc. Nucl., Univ. di Pisa, DCMN 003(87), 1987; 37 pp. 6.19 Salem E., Khalil F.; Thermal and Inertia Effects i n Externally Pressurized Conical Oil Bearings; Wear, 66 (1979), 251-264. 6.20 Prabhu T. J., Ganesan N.; Non Parallel Operation of Conical Hydrostatic Thrust Bearings; Wear, 86 (1983),29-41. 6.21 Dowson D., Taylor C. M.; Fluid Inertia Effects in Spherical Hydrostatic Thrust Bearings; ASLE Trans., 10 (1967), 316-324. 5 s Ragab H.; Pe4ormance q f Spherical Thrust Bearings; Wear, 29 (1974)) 11-20. 6.23 O'Donoghue J. P., Lewis G. K.; Single Recess Spherical Hydrostatic Bearings; Tribology, 3 (19701,232-234. 624 Sasaki T., Mori H., Hirai A.; Theoretical Study of Hydrostatic Thrust Bearings; Bull. JSME, 2,5(19591, 75-79. 5.26 Salem E., Khalil F.; Variable-Viscosity Effects in Externally Pressurized Spherical Oil Bearings; Wear, 50 (19781,221-235. 526 O'Donoghue J. P.; Design of Spherical Hydrostatic Bearings; Mach. Prod. Engineering, Oct. 21, 1970; p. 660-665. 527 Massa E.; Sulla Determinazione della Forza di Sostentamento e della Portata nella Lubrificazione Idrostatica; Apparecchiature Idrauliche e Pneumatiche, 3,16 (1963),31-39. 6.28 Castelli V., Shapiro W . ; Improved method for Numerical Solutions of the General Incompressible Fluid Film Lubrication Problem; ASME Trans., J. of Lubrication Technology, 89 (19671,211-218. 5.29 Reddi M. M.; Finite Element Solution of the Incompressible Lubrication Problem; ASME Trans, J . of Lubrication Technology, 91 (19691,524-533. 6.30 Szeri A. Z.; Hydrostatic Bearing Pads: a Matrix Iterative Solution; ASLE Trans., 19 (1975),72-78. 6.31 Bassani R.; Rectangular Hydrostatic Bearings; Ann. CIRP, 19 (1971), 53-59.
148
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
532
Bassani R., Culla C.; Coefficienti Caratteristici di Pattini Zdrostatici di Forme Diverse; Atti 1st. Mecc. Appl. Costr. Macch., Univ. di Pisa, Anno Acc. 197273, N. 45; 29 pp. Rippel H. C.; Hydrostatic Bearings. Part 8: Cylindrical-pad Performance; Machine Design, Nov. 7, 1963; pp. 189-194. Loeb A. M.; Determination of the Characteristics of Hydrostatic Bearings Through the Use of the Electric Analog Field Plotter; ASLE Trans., 19 (19751, 72-78. Heller S., Shapiro W.; A Numerical Solution for the Incompressible Hybrid Journal Bearing with Cavitation; ASME Trans., J . of Lubrication TechnolO ~ Y 91 , (19671, 508-515. So H., Chen C. R.; Characteristics of a Hybrid Journal Bearing with one recess. Part 1: Dynamic Considerations; Tribology Int., 18 (19851, 331-339. S o H., Chang T. S.; Characteristics of a Hybrid Journal Bearing with one recess. Part 2: Thermal Analysis; Tribology Int., 19 (19861, 11-18. Straccia P. F.; Dimensionamento dei Cuscinetti Zdrostatici Conici; Doct. Thesis, 1985; 263 pp. Rumbarger J. H.;Wertwijn G.; Hydrostatic Lead Screws; Machine Design, April 11, 1968; pp. 218-224. Lombard J., Moisan A.; Caractkristiques Statiques et Dynamiques d'un Syst&meVis-Ecrou Hydrostatique; Ann. CIRP, 18 (19701, 521-525. El Sayed H. R., Khataan H. A.; The Exact Performance of Externally Pressurized Power Screws; Wear, 30 (19741,237-247. Bassani R., Piccigallo B.; Perdite per Trafilamento dalle Tenute di VitiMadreviti Zdrostatiche; Ingegneria, 1981; pp. 213-224. Bassani R., Piccigallo B.; Effetti delle Tolleranze d i Fabbricazione sulle Prestazioni di Coppie Zdrostatiche Autoregolate; I1 Progettista Industriale, 1,7 (19811, 62-72.
5.33
5.34
5%
5.36
537 5.38 539
5.40 5.41
SA2 5.43
Chapter 6
SINGLE PAD BEARINGS
6.1
INTRODUCTION
Pad coefficients, obtained in chapter 5 for several types of hydrostatic pad bearings, are not enough to completely define the static behaviour of a bearing, since it also depends on the behaviour of the supply system. In the simplest case, the pad is directly fed by a pump at a constant flow rate Q and supply pressure practically coincides with recess pressure (that is ps=pr); the performance of the bearing is then easily assessed by means of equations from Eqn 5.1 to Eqn 5.8. On the other hand, in the case of a compensated supply, pr is smaller than p s and a further relationship between these pressures is needed, which depends on the characteristics of the compensating restrictor. In this chapter the steady-state performance of thrust bearings is studied, when these are directly fed by a pump as well as by means of several types of compensating devices. Finally, a number of remarks on the optimum design of these bearings are made and design procedures are proposed.
6.2 6.2.1
DIRECT SUPPLY Bearing performance
When a pad bearing is directly fed by a volumetric pump, flow rate Q may be said to be constant; moreover, if the hydraulic resistance of the lubricant supply ducts is low compared to the hydraulic resistance R of the clearances of the pad, the recess pressure is nearly equal to the pressure a t the pump: pr=ps. The equations examined in section 5.2 can now be rearranged as follows:
150
HYDROSTATICLUBRICATlON
(6.1)
w(t”
H p = p s Q = p,. Q = Q2 R =A; R~R’ H f = Hfo H i
(6.3) (5.11 rep.)
In the above equations, the subscript “0“ refers to the “design configuration“ in which the film thickness is h=ho for all the land surfaces. R’ and H i are non-dimensional functions of the non-dimensional displacement and are given by Eqn 5.12 and Eqn 5.13. These equations are, strictly speaking, only valid for the plane pads, in which the lands bounding the lubricant film always remain parallel to each other; however, they c a n also be used as a n approximation for the other pads when small eccentricities are involved. In the rest of this chapter we shall assume that Eqn 5.12 holds good. Combining the foregoing equations, it is possible to study the behaviour of the clearance and of the power consumption when the load varies in relation to the reference value Wo=A,QRo. Figure 6.1 shows a plot on non-dimensional film thickness, pumping power and friction power as functions of the non-dimensional load. The bearing stiffness is easily obtained from Eqn 5.9. Since Q and A , do not depend on the clearance, while R is proportional to h-3, it follows that: (6.5)
The stiffness KO in the reference configuration is, of course, (6.6)
and, hence, (6.7)
151
SINGLE PAD BEARINGS
0
1
W
2
3
w,
Fig. 6.1 Direct supply. Film thickness, pumping power, friction power and stiffness versus load.
As has already been observed above, Eqn 6.5 (and consequently Eqn 6.6 and Eqn 6.7) is only valid as an approximation for the pads whose film thickness is not uniform (e.g. cylindrical and spherical pads).
6.2.2
Temperature and viscosity
The temperature step of the lubricant (assuming adiabatic flow) is given by Eqn 5.7; in the reference configuration we have:
When the load increases, the temperature step also increases: AT Ht -=-=
ATo Hto
R'+nHj-
l+n
(6.9)
In Fig. 6.2 it is plotted as a fhction of the load. Careful consideration of AT is of great importance when a constant-flow supply system is selected, since a change in lubricant temperature involves a variation in its viscosity, which, in turn, directly affects the bearing performance. Let us consider Eqn 6.2, which gives the load capacity: the hydraulic resistance of the pad (evaluated in chapter 5 for several types of pad) proves to be proportional to viscosity
152
HYDROSTATIC L UBRlCATlON
consequently, if the lubricant, say, warms up, Ro must be substituted in Eqn 6.2 by the lower value ROpIpO and a higher value of R’ is needed to sustain the same load. In other words, this will result in a smaller clearance. The influence of the viscosity on the clearance-load relationship is shown in Fig. 6.3.a. ,LL;
3
2
AT AT0 1
-0
n
1
2
3
Fig. 6.2 Direct supply. Temperature step versus load, for certain values of reference power ratio.
-a-
-b-
2
6
K KO
-tl h0
4 1
2
0
Fig. 6.3 Direct supply. Clearance (a) and stiffness (b) versus load for certain values of viscosity.
SINGLE PAD BEARINGS
153
On the other hand, it is easy to verify that p has no effect on pumping power (indeed, Q is fixed and the recess pressure depends on the load alone, since A, is not affected by p); friction power, for any given load, decreases if the temperature goes up:
(Hf is proportional to p, for a certain clearance). Because of the reduced film thickness, stiffness is increased if viscosity is reduced; on the contrary, a cooler lubricant (e.g. during the starting phase) may cause a considerable reduction in stiffness:
The effect of p on bearing stiffness is shown in Fig. 6.3.b.
6.3
COMPENSATED SUPPLY
Let us now consider a pad bearing, supplied through one of the compensation devices seen in section 2.3,from a lubricant source, which is maintained a t a constant pressure p s . Whatever the kind of compensation system we have, Eqn 5.1 and Eqn 5.2 remain valid for any given pad. The recess pressure is then a fraction, proportional to the load, of the supply pressure:
The relationship between the hydraulic resistance of the pad (which in its turn is closely connected to clearance h ) and the load is easily evaluated by equating the flow rate crossing the restrictor Q =-Ps Pr
Rr
to the flow rate crossing the clearances of the pad
We obtain: (6.10)
154
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
The reference pressure ratio is commonly named 8: (6.11) it also represents the ratio of the design load to the limiting value A g , .
From Eqn 6.10 and Eqn 6.11 we obtain:
R, B WIWO R'=R&pW/Wo
(6.12)
The hydraulic resistance of the compensation device is, in general, dependent on flow rate and on recess pressure. Once such a relationship is known, as well as the relationship between R' and h, Eqn 6.8 allows us to obtain the clearance as a function of the load. For the plane pads, Eqn 5.12 and Eqn 6.12 give: (6.13) The required flow rate, at any given value of the load, is
PPW 1 W Ro Wo R' - Q0
Q="----
h 3
(G)
(6.14)
Consequently, the relevant pumping power is: (6.15) The friction power is given by Eqn 5.11:
(values of Iffo for several types of pad are calculated in chapter 5). Hence, the reference power ratio is (6.16) The temperature step, in the design configuration, is still given by Eqn 6.8, while, for different values of the load,
(6.17)
155
SlNGLE PAD BEARINGS
The bearing stiffness is, on the basis of Eqn 5.8,
W
1
K = 3 r
(6.18)
w a,
1
l - p w / w o + KdW
It is worth noting that in order to obtain explicit equations connecting the bearing parameters (h, K, etc.) to the load, knowledge is needed of the actual value of R,.. In other words, the foregoing equations need to be specialized for the various compensating devices.
Laminar flow restrlctors (capillaries)
6.3.1
The recess is supplied by a source of lubricant, kept at a constant pressure p s , by means of a capillary tube or some other laminar-flow fixed restrictor. The hydraulic resistance R, of such devices proves to be a constant for any given lubricant viscosity (see section 4.7.6). It may be expressed in terms of Ro and 8:
(6.19)
- b-
3
1.0 -
h
2
K KO
.
ho 0.5 -
1
t
0
1
2
3
w
OAe PS
4
5
0
0
1
2
3
W PS
Fig. 6.4 Capillary compensation. Bearing clearance (a) and stiffness (b) versus load.
4
5
156
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
The equations describing the static behaviour of the bearing may be easily obtained from Eqn 6.10 and the following, up to Eqn 6.18. The reference values of flow rate and pumping power are: (6.20)
The main non-dimensional bearing parameters are also plotted in Fig. 6.4 and Fig. 6.5 against the non-dimensional load W/ Wo=W/(jlpsAe).In particular, it follows that: n
(6.21)
Bearing stiffness comes from Eqn 6.18 and Eqn 6.19. In the reference position, it is: (6.22)
thus (6.23) KO is plotted in Fig. 6.6 as a hnction of 8.
-b-
0
1
3
2 W BA, Ps
4
0
1
3
2
4
W 0 4 Ps
Fig. 6.5 Capillary compensation. Flow rate, pumping power and friction power (a), and temperature step (b) versus load.
157
SINGLE PAD BEARINGS
0.0
1.o
0.5
f3 Fig. 6.6 Reference values of stiffness versus design pressure ratio for capillary and orifice compensation.
When the temperature of the lubricant is different from its design value, both the hydraulic resistances of the restrictor and of the bearing gaps vary as does lubricant viscosity p. The effect of such a viscosity change is easily evaluated by substituting RopI po and €€fop/p o for Ro and H f o , respectively, in the foregoing equations. It is easy to see that the clearance, as well as the stiffness, do not depend on the actual value of p . Flow rate and pumping power are proportional to l / p . Friction power is proportional to p and the power ratio is therefore proportional to p2.
6.3.2
Orifices
When orifices are used instead of laminar restrictors, it should be borne in mind that the hydraulic resistance R, of such devices is no longer independent from the recess pressure. The flow rate through these devices is proportional to the square root of the pressure drop ps-pr (see section 4.11). Since in the reference configuration we must have
the hydraulic resistance of a sharp-edge orifice may be written in the following form: (6.24)
158
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATlON
By introducing Eqn 6.24 into Eqn 6.13, the relationship between clearance and load may be explicitly rewritten as: (6.25)
The other bearing parameters can now be obtained straightforwardly (Eqn 6.14 to Eqn 6.18) and are also plotted in Fig. 6.6, Fig 6.7 and Fig. 6.8. In particular, stiffness becomes: (6.26)
where (6.27)
is its reference value. The orifices are clearly characterized by greater stiffness than the laminar-flow restrictors (see Fig. 6.6). On the other hand, a more careful control of the lubricant temperature is now required.
-a-
-b-
3
L
1.0 -
h ho
2 K KO
. .
0.5 -
0
1
1
2
3 W
OA, Ps
4
5
a
0
1
2
3
W OA, Ps
Fig. 6.7 Orifice compensation. Bearing clearance (a) and stiffness (b) versus load.
4
5
159
SINGLE PAD BEARINGS
-a-
4
I
0.7
I
1
/ 0.5
/'"=0.3
9 QO
1
L!f HfO
c
2
1
3
4
1
0
W fl Ae PS
3
2
4
W fl Ae PS
Fig. 6.8 Orifice compensation. Flow rate, pumping power and friction power (a), and temperature step (b) versus load.
0
1
2
JL
3
4
PO Fig. 6.9 Orifice compensation. Effect of viscosity (temperature) on clearance and stiffness. Unlike laminar restrictors, the temperature of the lubricant affects the load capacity of the bearing. The hydraulic resistance of the pad is proportional to the viscosity of the lubricant, which in turn depends on temperature; this last, on the contrary, has no practical effect on R,. Consequently, if a viscosity p occurs, differe n t from the design value po, each value W of the load will be sustained with a clearance which does not tally with the value calculated by means of the preceding
160
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATlON
equations. It is easy to see that the actual film thickness is proportional to the cubic root of the viscosity; the opposite applies for stiffness (see Fig. 6.91, whereas the flow rate does not vary. Actually, we have Q
=-Ps Pr
Rr but R , depends on pressure drop ps-pr alone; this last depends on the applied load and is not related to viscosity. In brief, the consequences of a change in lubricant temperature are the following: a cooler lubricant causes lower stiffness; a warmer lubricant causes smaller clearance and, consequently, higher friction and higher temperature step.
6.3.3
Constant flow valves
A simple constant flow device is shown in Fig. 2.11. The spool compares force F, exerted by the spring with the action of the differential pressure pv-pr on spool area A,. If restrictor RV1varies much more rapidly with spool displacement than spring force F,, differential pressure pv-pr=F,/ A , is practically kept constant; the same occurs for flow rate Q , which depends on pressure drop pv-pr across reference restrictor R,. If R, is a true sharp-edged orifice, and its bore diameter is small enough to ensure that the discharge coefficient Cd is not dependent on the Reynolds number (see F'ig 4.161, Q does not actually depend on any change in lubricant viscosity. Indeed, we have (Eqn 4.76):
Q can be adjusted by setting up the spring force. However, since the orifice section A, cannot be too small (to avoid an excessive drop in pressure in the device), and true sharp-edged orifices are difficult to build (and to maintain), a certain dependence on p often exists (see Fig. 4.16 and Fig. 4.17), at least near the lower end of the flow rate range. If, on the other hand, R, is a laminar-flow restrictor, its hydraulic resistance becomes a constant, and thus, for a capillary restrictor, Eqn 4.66 gives:
i.e. Q becomes inversely proportional to viscosity (in the last equation, 1 and d are the length and equivalent diameter of the restrictor). It should be noted that, when a
I61
SINGLE PAD EEA RINGS
hydrostatic pad has to be supplied, the proportionality of Q and p ensures that the bearing stiffness is independent from lubricant temperature.
As long as recess pressure p r is lower than p s - F v / A , , the bearing simply behaves like a constant flow system: (6.28)
(6.29)
Ps B
(6.30)
=&-P2B
(6.31)
Q=&o=R, H~ = H~~
(5.11 rep.)
(6.32)
(6.6 rep.)
(6.7 rep.)
Once Fv is fixed, pressure drop Ap=pV-pr=Fv/ A v is a characteristic parameter of the device (in most cases, a few bars). Of course, it must always be pv
the device ceases to produce a constant flow rate, with a sharp drop in stiffness. In Fig. 6.10 clearance and stiffness are plotted versus load. Dashed lines represent indicatively the limit behaviour of the valve for a number of values of @, for the sample case Ap=O.lps.
162
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICAT/ON
-a-
1.5
61.o
K KO
h -
’
4 -
h0
0.4
0.5
2-
0.0 0
1
2
3
W 0 % Ps
4
5
0
1
2
3
4
5
W OA, Ps
Fig. 6.10 Constant flow valves. Bearing clearance (a) and stiffness (b) versus load.
The response of the system to a change in lubricant temperature is closely connected to the behaviour of the reference restrictor R,. As noted above, if R, is a laminar-flow device, Q is inversely proportional to p . Since the hydraulic resistance of the pad is proportional to p, h and K are not affected by temperature change, while friction power proves to be proportional to p . If R , is a true orifice, the system simply reacts like the “direct-supply” system examined in section 6.2; i.e. actual clearance is proportional to the cubic root of p , whereas stiffness is inversely proportional to the same value; in general, however, orifice-type valves also show a certain dependence on lubricant viscosity.
6.3.4
Spool valves
The controlled restrictors in Fig. 2.8 are able to decrease their own hydraulic resistance a s recess pressure (i.e. the sustained load) increases; consequently, greater bearing stiffness occurs than for a fixed restrictor featuring the same pressure ratio 8. Furthermore, a lower rate of flow is obtained for lower loads. The hydraulic resistance R, of the device depends on the displacement of the spool by means of a linear relationship:
SINGLE PAD BEARINGS
R,.=C,x
163 (6.34)
On the other hand, for the equilibrium of the spool, the force exerted on it by the spring is:
where FvS is the spring force for complete spool displacement (x=O) and K, is the stiffness of the spring. Under the design load, we have Pr=/3ps and Rro=Ro(1-a)/a; thus F0s,/J, and Ro are connected together by the relationship: (6.35)
If the device is such as to allow us to adjust the spring force, it is possible to achieve any design value of Ro (i.e. of film thickness ho)under the design load psA$. Note that, since R,. is a laminar-flow restrictor, both Ro and C, are proportional to viscosity; F,s does not then depend on lubricant temperature. The displacement of the spool under the design load is
Combining the foregoing equations, the hydraulic resistance of the controlled restrictor may be written as follows: (6.36)
where
For any given value of p, flow rate Q, is a characteristic parameter of the device. Introducing Eqn 6.36 into Eqn 6.13, it is possible to obtain clearance as a function of the load:
"--;I
-a
1 w/wo PWIW,
(
1 W ) & + U
l-woPo
(6.37)
a
where (6.38)
164
HYDROSTATIC LUBRlCATiON
-b-
-a1.5
1.0 -
h
.
ho
.
-
0.5
0
2
1
0.0 0
W fi Ae PS
-d-
-c-
2
4
2
W fi Ae PS
10
Op0.25
0.3 0.4
K Koc c
c .
.
,
, 0 . 2 ; g j (
.c
0
2
1
W fi Ae PS
2
1
W fi Ae PS
Fig. 6.11 Cylindrical spool valve. Bearing clearance (a, b), flow rate (c) and stiffness (d) versus load for certain values of valve parameter.
SINGLE PAD BEARINGS
165
A plot of hlho as a function of W /Wo is given in Fig. 6.11.a,b for certain values of 8 and 8,. It should be pointed out that, when we have Pu=/3, the system produces a flow rate which does not depend on load. The spool displacement will generally be limited to a certain range X,+XM: outside the relevant load range W,+W,, Eqn 6.37 is no longer valid and the bearing would merely perform like a capillary compensated one; furthermore, for very small values of x,, the flow is no longer laminar. The other bearing parameters (flow rate, power, etc.) are still given by Eqn 6.14 and the following equations; the flow rate is also plotted in Fig. 6.1l.c. The bearing stiffness is obtained by combining Eqn 6.18 and Eqn 6.36. In particular, for the reference load, it is (6.39) where KO, is the stiffness of the same pad supplied at the same pressure ratio through a fixed restrictor (Eqn 6.22). For a generic load we have: 1- Pl8v
1-8 W
1-8- 1 + WO
El??
WOPV 1- WIWO
p
1-8
Pv
8
(6.40)
Nondimensional stiffness K/Kocis plotted in Fig. 6.11.d as a function of Wl W O(it has been chosen to show K / K o c instead of K in order to display the gain in stiffness of the system, compared to a capillary-compensated one). By tuning the elastic constant of the spring, a very great, and even negative, stiffness could clearly be obtained. On the other hand, the stiffness would be much smaller than KO for loading conditions different from the reference one, and the flow rate would increase sharply for loads greater than Wo. Furthermore, the behaviour of the bearing under dynamic loading must be carefully considered. Concerning the effects of a change in lubricant temperature, i t has already been pointed out that, provided R , is a laminar-flow restrictor, the ratio C, / Ro does not depend on p; thus, only flow rate and power are affected, Q and H p being proportional to Up and H f being proportional to p. Other types of devices have been proposed, with better performances than the cylindrical spool. For example, let us consider the tapered spool valve (ref. 2.5) in Fig. 2.9. Its hydraulic resistance may no longer be expressed by a linear relationship such a s Eqn 6.34. Provided aperture angle a: is very small, we have:
(6.41)
HYDROSTATIC LUBRlCATlON
166
-b-
-a-
0.0'
0
'
' . . '
1
.
'
.
'
0
2
2
-d-
-c-
2
4
W DA.9 Ps
W BAe Ps
10
9
K
00
Koc
5 1
0
1
2
-5 0
2
1
W BAe PS Fig. 6.12 Tapered spool valve. Bearing clearance (a, b), flow rate (c) and stiffness (d) versus load for certain values of valve parameterg, and R,=Ro.
SINGLE PAD BEARINGS
167
where &xal c is the non-dimensional spool displacement. Proceeding as in the former case, it is easy to verify that F,s (spring force for {=O), to(spool displacement in the design configuration), p and Ro are connected by the following equations:
(6.42)
The hydraulic resistance of the device may thus be rewritten as:
(6.43)
where 1 c pu = ---(i2aA,
Ro Ku RlJ Ps
(6.44)
The clearance for any load W now proves to be (from Eqn 6.13):
h
-
q-
3
11 - p WlWo Ro
1
(6.45)
The rate of flow is still given by Eqn 6.14.The stiffness for the reference load is again given by Eqn 6.39,whereas, for different loads, the relevant stiffness may be evaluated by introducing Eqn 6.43into Eqn 6.18.Film thickness, the flow rate and stiffness are plotted in Fig. 6.12as functions of the load. Again no effect follows a change in viscosity, except for different values of flow rate and pumping power.
6.3.5
Diephragm-controlled restrictors
The device shown in Fig. 2.10 (ref. 2.6)works like the spool valves examined in the previous section, but its hydraulic resistance varies according to a cubic law:
(6.46)
168
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
where <=x / lo is the non-dimensional displacement from an arbitrary configuration (say, lo may be assumed a s the restrictor clearance when no force is exerted on the diaphragm, Fig. 6.13).
Fig. 6.13 Diaphragm-controlled restrictor.
For the equilibrium of the membrane, the elastic force has to be:
A , is the effective area of the membrane, Fvs is the elastic force exerted by the spring, for x=O, from which the constant effort exerted on the membrane by the supply pressure p s has been subtracted. To have a hydraulic resistance Ro of the pad when the design load Wo=ppsA,is applied, F,s must be:
Fvs = P P s A , -k 5OlOKu
(6.47)
where
Note that we should have Fus cKvloto prevent a complete shut-off of the restrictor for small loads. By rewriting R, in the form
1-8
1
(6.48) 1-P
SINGLE PAD BEARINGS
169
where
(6.49) and by inserting it into Eqn 6.13,one can obtain the relationship between load and clearance:
(6.50)
A plot of the film thickness , as well as of the flow rate (obtained as usual from Eqn 6.14))as a function of the load, is given in Fig. 6.14. The stiffness in the reference configuration is again given by Eqn 6.391,where Eqn 6.49 has now to be used for Po. For different loads, the non-dimensional stiffness is:
K
W
1 -PIP,
h0
h
WP 1-p- wo P u 1-8-w 1--11-w/wop
wo
3
1-p
(6.51)
P"
Comparing Fig. 6.14 to Fig. 6.11 and Fig. 6.12,we see that the performance of the diaphragm-controlled restrictor is better than that of the spool-controlled devices; in particular, the load range is larger. Furthermore, due to the small mass of the membrane, the dynamic behaviour should also be better.
As happens in the case of the spool valves, any change in the temperature of the lubricant does not affect the set-up of the device, but only flow rate and pumping power.
6.3.6
Infinite-stiffness devices
Certain controlled restrictors, such as the one shown in Fig. 2.12 (ref. 2.81,are able to keep bearing film thickness constant for a wide range of loading conditions. For the equilibrium of the spool we must have:
(6.52) When the load, and therefore p r , vary, the spool is displaced, changing the inlet restrictor of the device, until Eqn 6.52 is again fulfilled. The flow rate is:
170
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICA TlON
-b-
-a-
1.5
1.o
h h0
0.5
OS 0
2
2
1
-c-
2
Qo
-d-
1C
\
9
K Koc
1
(
0.5 1
pzq
n . 0.25
0
4
W OAe PS
W DAe PS
2
1
W fl Ae PS
-11
2
1
W fl A, Ps
Fig. 6.14 Diaphragm-controlled restrictor. Bearing clearance (a, b), flow rate (c) and stiffness (d) versus load for certain values of valve parameter.
171
SINGLE PAD BEARINGS
-b-
*
1.o
.
\ yp0.25
\
\
\
0.5\
0.75\
\
\
\
" \
' \ ' \\
0.5 -
\
\ \'
\\ \ 0.0 0.0
0.5
-!&
1.o
Ae PS
0.5
W -
1.o
Ae PS
Fig. 6.15 "Infinite-stifSness"valve. Bearing clearance (a) and flow rate (b) versus load, for certain values of the valve parameter.
Q
=-Pv - Pr
R,
This means that the hydraulic resistance of the pad clearances is pegged to the constant value
R=Ro=R,
Yv l-~,
(6.53)
and thus the film thickness is kept constant as well. ho can be adjusted by setting restrictor R,. It is noteworthy that, if R , is laminar in kind, the system is not sensitive to any change in lubricant viscosity, except as far as flow rate and pumping power are concerned. The flow rate proves to be proportional to load W=p,.Ae:
W Q= A x
(6.54)
We obviously must have pu yvps, the whole hydraulic
172
HYDROSTATC LVBRlCATlON
resistance of the device will be reduced to the fixed value R,, and the system will merely work like a capillary-compensated bearing with a pressure ratio b=y, (see Fig. 6.15).
6.3.7
Inherently compensated bearings
The simplest of the inherently compensated bearings described in Chapter 2 is represented in Fig. 2.17.a (see also ref. 2.13). From Eqn 4.58,flow rate is:
then pressure at radius rl is:
Ps lnrz/rl
1
+E& (1+ hp/h)3 Load capacity is:
Inherently compensated bearings are generally used with compressible Iubricants.
6.4
DESIGN OF SINGLE-PAD THRUST BEARINGS
The specifications of a pad bearing consist, in most cases, in a range of loads W,+WM to be sustained with a certain stiffness at any given sliding or turning velocity. A further set of constraints is generally specified, involving important parameters such as: size and shape of the pad film thickness overload capacity lubricant viscosity flow rate supply pressure friction. The first step in design often consists in establishing suitable pad dimensions, in such a way that the effective area of the pad be greater than the ratio of the maximum expected load t o the maximum available pressure. The shape of the pad
SINGLE PAD BEARINGS
173
is often constrained. However, a few remarks on the most convenient land width to choose may be useful. In the foregoing sections it has been shown that, for any pad shape, the land width ratio (e.g. parameter a' for annular-recess pads) may be chosen in such a way a s to minimize pumping power. It is clear that when pad velocity is null, or very low, total power consumption practically coincides with pumping power, and then such a choice of the land width may be considered to be the "optimum"one. However, this is not a critical point: for instance, it may be convenient to select narrower lands to increase load capacity without affecting the external size of the pad. On the other hand, when the speed is high enough, it is generally more convenient to select narrow lands to minimize the total power Ht=Hp+Hp The selection of the thickness of the film depends on certain contrasting factors: it must be small enough to ensure sufficient stiffness a t any load to meet the specifications; it must be small enough to ensure small flow rate and pumping power (of course, this point, as well a s the next, is also connected with the choice of lubricant viscosity); it must be large enough to avoid excessive friction; it must be much larger than the geometric errors of the mating surfaces (roughness, planarity, parallelism).
As far as the problem of a suitable choice of h and p is concerned, i t is possible to demonstrate that, for any given pad and any given viscosity, an "optimum" clearance may be calculated (from the point of view of total power) on the condition that Hf=3Hp. Conversely, if h is given, "optimum" viscosity is the one which gives Hf-&lp (ref. 2.3). Let us now briefly examine this problem applied to rotating pads. Total power in the reference configuration may be written in the form:
valid for constant-pressure supply, as well as for direct constant-flow supply (in this case it must be stated that /j'=l).For axisymmetric pads, such as plane or tapered circular pads, the effective area can be written a s in Eqn 5.20, and the hydraulic resistance as in Eqn 5.83: of course, the relevant equations must be used for A*, and R*, and a=d2 for plane pads. For these pads total power may hence be rewritten as:
(6.55)
174
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
Once all the other parameters are given, the power ratio will depend on turning velocity; from Eqn 6.16 and Eqn 5.85:
Conversely, the last equation may be used to evaluate the viscosity needed to obtain a given power ratio: (6.56)
Introducing the last equation into Eqn 6.55, we obtain: (6.57)
where
(6.58)
The dimensionless value H,*, plotted in Fig 6.16 and in Fig. 6.17, only depends on the geometric ratios of the pad. It is clear that a similar equation for Ht can be obtained for any pad shape o r any supply system; however, for sliding bearings H , will no longer be independent from the pad size (e.g. B.L or D2) or supply pressure. Equation 6.57 allows us to draw some important conclusions concerning "optimum" bearing design. First, it clearly seems convenient to get the greatest values for H t : that is, to reduce land width, obtaining the further advantage of lower supply pressure and temperature step. However, in many cases, the variation of H,* with the land width is small (see Fig. 6.16). There is no doubt, on the other hand, that film thickness should be as small as possible, since the power expense for any given value of the power ratio is proportional to ho (for the sake of completeness, however, i t should be noted that the increase in stiffness which follows the choice of a smaller clearance is not always beneficial, since it may lead to smaller margins of stability). Finally, the reader may easily verify that, once ho has been fixed, the minimum power is obtained when n=1, although Ht varies little for values of the power ratio in the range 113SIlS3. To obtain the desired value of IT, viscosity must satisfy Eqn 6.56, which for the sake of practicalness may be rewritten as: (6.59)
SlNGLE PAD BEARlNGS
175
where (6.60)
or alternatively as: (6.61)
where (6.62)
These equations are valid for any supply system (for direct supply p=1 and ps=pro). Both p$ and p; are plotted in Fig. 6.16 for central-recess circular pads and Fig. 6.17 €or annular-recess pads.
A problem now arises, since in practice it is not always possible to select a lubricant with the theoric "optimum" value of viscosity given by Eqn 6.59 or Eqn 6.61 for n=1.In particular, a t low speed, this optimum viscosity may prove to be impracticably high. Although one may try to increase land width or pad size, sometimes a value of l 7 smaller than 1 must be accepted: indeed, for Q=O, a n infinite viscosity would be the optimum! On the other hand, a t high speed, the optimum viscosity
Hi
Fig. 6.16 Circular recess pad. Total power H: and optimum viscosities p$ and p; versus radius ratio r'.
176
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
-b-
-a40
4
400
\
r'=O.8
Hi
GI
2
0 0.0
20
0.4"
0.2 a'
200
O
0.0
0.2
a'
0.4
Fig. 6.17 Annular recess pad. Total power H: and optimum viscosities p$ and p; versus land width ratio a'.
would be the optimum! On the other hand, a t high speed, the optimum viscosity might prove to be very low, even after having reduced the land length to a minimum and having increased recess pressure (reducing the pad diameter) as much as possible. In these cases i t is recommended t o select a suitably low viscosity (sometimes, however, p is explicitly prescribed) increasing ho in such a way as to have n13.Actually, it can be shown that, once p is fixed, the "optimum" clearance is the one which leads to n=3,but the problem is complicated by the fact that h and p may not be considered to be constant values, since they are subject to change according to load and temperature. The following is a design criterion which generally produces good results: take a s reference load Wo the one (in the normal load range) which gives the minimum value of power ratio H f / H p :namely, Wo=WMfor constant-flow supply and W,=W, for constant pressure supply; select h,, p, and the land width ratio in such a way a s to obtain n=1.The value of p selected in this way should be the one which tallies with the maximum lubricant temperature allowed by the supply system. However, when velocity is too low or too high, it is necessary to accept values of ll that are smaller than 1 or greater than 3, respectively.
SINGLE PAD BEARINGS
177
For a more general and complete discussion of the optimization problem for hydrostatic thrust bearings, the reader is referred to chapter 11. Let us now examine detailed design procedures for constant-flow or eonstantpressure systems.
6.4.1 Direct supply (constant flow)
As stated above, it is convenient, in this case, to take the greatest load of the normal load range a s reference ( W o = W ~ The ) . design may then be carried out as follows: i)
choose a trial set of geometric parameters. If pad velocity is very low, select a land width ratio close to the one which gives minimum pumping power, otherwise, select narrower lands. For instance, for a central-recess circular pad, one may select r’=0.53 in the former case, and a greater value (perhaps r’=0.9)in the latter;
ii)
choose a suitable effective area A,. This parameter is closely related to the supply pressure and the load, since ps=pr=WIAe. If a certain overload capacity is required, it must be A e > W ~ l pwhere ~ , WEand pE, are, respectively, the extreme load and the greatest allowable pressure (i.e. the the pressure tallying with the set-up of the relief valve); evaluate the size of the pad, and check that it is compatible with the specifications;
iii)
select the minimum film thickness ho: bear in mind that the thinner ho is, the smaller the power loss will be (provided a sufficiently low viscosity is available) and the greater the stiffness; on the other hand, greater manufacturing accuracy will be required; calculate KO(Eqn 6.6); (by means of Eqn 6.2) calculate the film thickness h~ which tallies with the minimum load W m ; calculate the minimum stiffness Km=3Wml hM; if Km does not meet the specifications, decrease ho. However, when a wide load range is expected, there will be great variations in stiffness as the load changes (see Eqn 6.5); in this case, the use of an opposed-pad bearing may be more suitable (Chapter 7);
iv)
calculate the optimum viscosity, that is the value b p t that makes Z7=1 (Eqn 6.4). For circular bearings, this may be done quickly with the aid of Fig. 6.16 o r Fig. 6.17; check that b p t is a plausible value (sometimes p may be directly imposed by the specifications). If it is not, modify the geometrical parameters (namely
178
HYDUOSTATIC L UBUlCATlON
the land width ratio) or ho and start again from point (ii) o r (iii). If popt cannot be brought into the admissible range, because the velocity is too small, select the highest available viscosity. On the other hand, a very high speed would require too low viscosities to be optimized with n=1,and consequently a greater value of the power ratio must be selected; values of n greater than 3 should, however, be avoided, or else excessive temperature steps could follow (Eqn 6.8); if the supply system is not able to hold the temperature of the lubricant within narrow limits, the designer should take a certain viscosity range into account, instead of a single value. A simple method consists in considering popt as the lower limit of the viscosity range, which tallies with the highest lubricant temperature. For a cooler lubricant viscosity will be greater, as well as film thickness and, above all, bearing stiffness will be lower. Consequently, it is necessary to check K for the whole temperature range; v)
calculate the required flow rate; calculate pumping power H p o and friction power H f o (for circular bearings Eqn 6.57 and Fig. 6.16 o r Fig 6.17 give total power Hto: now Hpo=HtoI(l+17) and Hfo=Hto17).For loads smaller than Wo, both the powers will be lower; check the maximum temperature step in the lubricant (Eqn 6.9); if a range of viscosities is to be allowed in the plant, check friction power and temperature step for the maximum viscosity too;
vi)
check the Reynolds number; for bearings rotating a t high speed also check the effect of inertia forces (parameter Si) and the circumferential Reynolds number;
vii)
check the dynamic behaviour of the system (see chapter 10).
In certain cases it may be necessary to have a flow rate which differs from the value calculated a t point (v) above (for instance, because the pump which has to be used does not feature an adjustable flow rate); clearly, if this happens it is necessary to repeat the calculations (in particular, as far as film thickness and stiffness are concerned) using the actual value of the flow rate. If the difference is large, it may be considered convenient to modify viscosity o r geometrical parameters in order to approach the optimum value of the power ratio again.
EXAMPLE 6.1 Design a circular-recess pad to sustain a thrust varying in the W,=30 KN t W ~ = 4M 0 v range at a speed G=lOradfs, with a friction moment lower than 1 Nm. Further constraints are the following: the outer diameter must be DSlOO mm; the lubricant viscosity can be chosen in a range of 0 . 0 2 4 1 Nslm2; the displacement as
SINGLE PAD BEARINGS
179
the load varies (slowly) from the minimum to the maximum value must be smaller than 10 pm; the recess pressure must always be smaller than 7 MPa. i) Since the turning velocity is low, a first trial value for r' could be r'=0.5, and hence A2=0.541. In order to sustain the maximum load WO=wM=40KN, the effective area must be greater than w 0 / 7 MPa, i.e. A , ~ 5 . 7 . 1 0 -m2; ~ consequently, due to the limited diameter, it must be (Eqn 5.20) A*,>0.727, and a considerably larger value is needed for r' (Fig. 5.1. b). ii) Let us select D=lOO mm, r'=O.75; it is easily obtained (from Fig. 5.1.6 or by means of the relevant equations) A50.760, R*=0.288, Hf*=0.684;the effective area is then A,=5.97.10-3 m2 and the maximum recess pressure is pro=WolA,=6.70 MPa. iii) A suitable value for minimum film thickness may be ho=30pm. The maximum film thickness, which tallies with the minimum load Wm=30KN, is (Fig. 6.1) h~=1.10.ho=33pm. Note that the displacement h ~ - h o = pm 3 is much smaller than required. iv) In Fig. 6.16 we may read &=8.72, i.e. bpt=0.31Nslm2. This last value is too high, hence the maximum allowable ualue p=O.1 Nslm2 should be selected, accepting a power ratio smaller than 1 (the friction power will prove to be much smaller than the pumping power). v) The reference hydraulic resistance is easily calculated as Ro=2.03.1012Nslm5 (Eqn 5.21), and hence Q=prolRo=3.29.10-6m3/s, Hpo=proQ=22W. A s far as friction is concerned, we have Mf0=0.22Nm, Hf0=2.2 W. Obuiously, for loads smaller than Wo, both Hp and H f will be smaller. The temperature step is maximum in correspondence to the maximum load: from Eqn 6.8, assuming c.p=l.7.10-3 J l m 2 " C , dTod.3 "c. EXAMPLE 6.2 Design an annular-recess bearing to sustain a load W=75 KN with stiffness K0>5.109N l m , at a speed l2=628 radls (6000 rpm). The outer diameter of the pad must be smaller than 200 mm, and the inner one greater than 120 mm. The maximum recess pressure can be as high as 12 MPa, but the bearing should be able to KN. the data of the lubricant sustain, exceptionally, a maximum overload d W ~ = 7 5 to be used are: p=0.02+0.03 N s lm2 (depending on the actual operating temperature), p =go0 e l m 9 c=1890 JlQOC. i) Since the speed is high, let us start with a small value of a', say a'=0.1. I f the greatest allowable pad area is chosen, it follows that r'=120/200=0.6. ii) It follows immediately that: A*,=0.576 and A,=0.0181 m2. The maximum load WE=150KtV hence tallies with a recess pressure p ~ = 8 . 2 9MPa; for the normal load Wo we have pr0=4.14 MPa. iii) Since Ko=3W0Ih, to obtain the required stiffness we must have hoc45 pm. However, since a wide viscosity range is expected, to obtain hc45 p for the highest
180
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
viscosity value (0.03 Nslm2) we must have ho<39 pm for the lowest viscosity p=0.02 N s I m2 (see Fig. 6.3). iv) From Fig. 6.1 7, p:=15.2: to get Il=l with p=0.02 Ns lm2 a clearance ho=60 pm is needed (Eqn 6.60).Since ho must be much lower to ensure adequate stiffness, friction power would be much greater than pumping power. To reduce total power it is possible to reduce the land width. For instance, a=2.5 mm (a'=0.0625) may be selected. From equations of section 5.4 it follows that A:=0.60, R*=0.0156, Hf*=0.119; hence Ae=0.019 m2, pro=WolAe=3.98MPa. In Fig 6.17 we may read pz=25.2, thus for l7=3 and p=0.02 Nslm2 a clearance ho=36.9 pm is needed, whereas we may select ho=39pm in order to have Il=2.4 for p=0.02 Ns I m2 and n=3for p=0.03 N s I m2. v) Flow rate is &=0.395.10-3mats. The power consumptions are Hp0=l.6 KW, Hf0=3.8 KW and Ht0=5.4KW. When the lubricant is cool (p=0.03 Nslm2), clearance increases to 44.7 pm (Fig. 6.3.a) and friction power increases to 5.0 KW. Note that if viscosity is further increased, stiffness may fall under the designed minimum value. The maximum temperature step is (Eqn 6.8)AT=6.61(0.395.0.9.1.890)=9.7"C. ui) The Reynolds number is given by Eqn 5.75: Re=17.7; the circumferential Reynolds number in the outer clearance is (from Eqn 5.591 Re,=109; consequently, no turbulence is expected. Also, the inertia forces i n the lubricant not need be taken into account since we have Si=O.13 (Eqn 5.50).
6.4.2
Compensated supply (constant pressure)
In this case we suggest taking the smallest load in the normal load range as reference. The design procedure is then similar, in its main aspects, to the one outlined in the previous section. Although the procedure below refers to bearings compensated by means of capillary restrictors, it may be easily extended to other compensating devices, including controlled valves: i)
choose a trial set of geometric parameters. If the pad velocity is very low, select a land width ratio close to the one which gives the minimum pumping power; else select narrower lands. For instance, for a central-recess circular pad, one may select r'=0.53 in the former case, and a greater value (perhaps r'=0.9) in the latter; choose pressure ratio dependent on load ratio WMIWo (for instance, with the aid of Fig. 6.4): i t is advisable for to be considerably smaller than Wo1 WM(e.g. 8 ~ 0 . 8W . o /W M )to ensure enough overload capacity and to avoid the stiffness corresponding to W M being too small. In particular, as far as overload is concerned, if a certain overload capacity AWE is given, we must obviously have PCWOIWE, where WE=WM+AWE.I t should, however, be stressed that the total power will turn out to be proportional to (Eqn
l/fi
SINGLE PAD BEARINGS
181
6.57), but, on the other hand, stiffness KO is proportional to (1-p).When the load range is wide (i.e. when Wo is much smaller than W,) a very small value is needed for p; in this case, an opposed-pad bearing may be the most suitable choice (see chapter 7); ii)
choose suitable values for effective area A , and supply pressure p s , in such a way as to obtain Wo=AJ?p,; evaluate the size of the pad, and check it is compatible with the specifications;
iii)
select the minimum clearance h,, tallying with the maximum load W M ; evaluate the reference clearance ho (e.g. for capillary compensation from Eqn 6.21 or Fig. 6.4.a). The thinner ho is, the smaller the power losses (provided a sufficiently low viscosity is available) and the greater the stiffness will be; on the other hand, greater manufacturing accuracy will be required; calculate KO (e.g. from Eqn 6.22) and stiffness K=KoK' tallying with load W, (e.g. from Eqn 6.23 or Fig. 6.4.b). For controlled restrictors, the relevant parameters (e.g. 8,) must also be selected; check that stiffness is great enough for the whole load range: if i t is not, one may try to decrease p, starting again from point (i), or to decrease ho, if possible, starting again fkom point (iii);
iv)
calculate the optimum viscosity, that is the value popt that makes I7=1(Eqn 6.4). For circular bearings, this may be done quickly with the aid of Fig. 6.16 or Fig. 6.17; check that k p t is a plausible value (sometimes p may be directly imposed by the specifications). If it is not, modify the geometrical parameters (namely the land width ratio) or ho and start again from point (ii) o r (iii). If popt cannot be brought into the admissible range, because the velocity is too small, select the highest available viscosity. On the other hand, a very high speed would require too low viscosities to be optimized with n=1,and consequently a greater value of the power ratio must be selected; values of Il greater than 3 should, however, be avoided: otherwise excessive temperature steps could follow; if the supply system is not able to hold the temperature of the lubricant within narrow limits, the designer should take a certain viscosity range into account, instead of a single value. A simple method consists in considering popt a s the lower limit of the viscosity range, which tallies with the highest lubricant temperature. For a cooler lubricant viscosity will be greater: for many compensating devices this will have no effect on clearance and stiff-
182
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
ness; instead, the power ratio will be greater (proportional to p2 for laminarflow devices); v)
calculate the flow rate; calculate pumping power Hpo and friction power Hfo (for circular bearings Eqn 6.57 and Fig. 6.16 o r Fig 6.17 give total power Hto: now H p o = H t o / ( l + ~ ) and Hfo=Hto17).For loads greater than WO,the pumping power is smaller, but Hf increases (Eqn 5.11); check the maximum temperature step in the lubricant (Eqn 6.8 and Eqn 6.17); if a range of viscosities is to be allowed in the plant, check friction power and the temperature step for the maximum viscosity, too;
vi)
design the restrictor: its hydraulic resistance RrO must be given by Eqn 6.19; if capillary pipes are used, select length and diameter by means of Eqn 4.67; check the Reynolds number in the restrictor to ensure laminar flow (Eqn 4.68);
vii)
check the Reynolds number; for bearings rotating a t high speed, also check the effect of inertia forces (parameter Si) and the circumferential Reynolds number;
viii)
check the dynamic behaviour of the system (see chapter 10).
EXAMPLE 6.3 A large slide is sustained by a set of rectangular pads (supplied through capillary restrictors) whose dimensions are B=0.3 m and L=0.4 m. Each pad must sustain a load W=60 KN with a stiffness K>2.5.109 N l m and a f i l m thickness not smaller than 40 pm. The friction force should not be greater than 6 N at a speed U=0.05 m I s. i) Since velocity is low, it is convenient to have large lands; i f we select a'=0.15 and rL: =0.25, from Fig. 5.27 we obtain Az=0.645. Since no great load variations are expected, we may try to select a relatively high value, such as 8=0.6, for the pressure ratio. ii) The pad dimensions are given: the effective area is A,=LBA:=0.077 m2. The supply pressure should hence be p,=1.29 Pa. iii) I f we select ho=40 pm, Eqn 6.22 immediately gives K0=1.8.109 N l m , which is not enough. Hence it is necessary to select a smaller value for p, such as p=0.4. Repeating the above calculations, we now get: ps=1.95 MPa and Ko=2.7.1@ N l m . iv) From Fig. 5.28 we obtain R*=0.75, and from Eqn 5.108 (stating h,=l mm) Af=0.079 m2. Since the friction force must be smaller than 6 N,Eqn 5.106 gives an upper boundary for viscosity: p=0.0607 Nslm2. For such a viscosity Eqn 6.16 gives n=0.14 (of course, the pumping power will prove to be much greater than the fric-
SINGLE PAD BEARINGS
183
tion power). A lubricant is therefore selected, whose viscosity is p=0.06 Nslm2 at the lowest operating temperature. v) Calculations of flow rate and power are now straightforward, leading to: Qo=1.1.10-6 m3/s; Hp=2.1 W, H ~ 0 . 3W. Temperature step proves to be slightly greater than 1 "C(assuming c.p=1.7.106 Jlm3"C). For lower viscosities H f decreases while Q and Hp prove to be proportional to 1 I p. vi) The hydraulic resistance of the restrictor can be calculated by means of Eqn 5.102 and Eqn 6.19, which lead to R,/p=17.6.1012 m-3. From Eqn 4.67 it follows that such a hydraulic resistance may be obtained with a pipe 27 mm i n length and with a 0.5 mm bore. The Reynolds number, calculated by assuming p=0.06 N s l m 2 and p 9 0 0 Kglm3, is Re=42, considerably less than its critical value. EXAMPLE 6.4 Design a capillary-compensated annular-recess bearing to sustain a load which varies i n the 2 0 4 5 KN range, with a displacement Ah smaller than 20 pm. The outer pad diameter must be smaller than 0.2 m, and the inner diameter must be equal to 0.1 mm. A further requirement is that the friction moment needed to rotate the bearing at e 6 2 8 radls (6000rpm) must be smaller than 5 Nm. The supply system to be used delivers lubricant at pressure ps=4 MPa; viscosity is expected to vary i n the p=0.0154.020 Ns 1m2 range, depending on actual operating conditions; density and specific heat are p=920KgIm3andc=1850 JIKgOC. i) Since the speed is high, choose narrow lands, say a=2 mm. The load ratio is WMIWo=1.75,hence p=0.45 should be a proper selection (see Fig. 6.4). ii) W i t h the given supply pressure, the effective area should be A e = 2 ~ / ( O . 4 5 . 4 . 1 O 6=)0.0111 m2. For the sake of simplicity, let us choose D=0.16 m (i.e. r'=O.625; a'=0.067), obtaining Az=0.569, R*=0.0154, Hf*=0.122;hence, A,=0.0114 m2 and p=0.437. iii) From Eqn 6.21 (or Fig. 6.4.a), for any certain design clearance ho the minimum clearance (which tallies with the maximum load) is hm=0.62.ho. To ensure Ah=ho-hm<20 pm we must therefore have ho152.7 pm. On the other hand, to have Mf<5 N m for p=0.02 Nslm2, the minimum film thickness cannot be smaller than 19.8 pm, i.e ho must be not smaller than 31.8 pm (see Eqn 5.70). iv) From Fig. 6.17, pJ=119; to have ll=1 for p=0.015 Nslm2 we should have (Eqn 6.59) ho=41.4 pm. Selecting ho=40 pm, the reference power ratio will vary in the 1.1411712.04 range, depending on the actual value of the viscosity. Flow rate, powers and temperature step depend on load and viscosity and are summarized i n the following table. v) The hydraulic resistance of the restrictor must be R,=1.29.Ro (Eqn 6.19), i.e. R,.=8.87.109 Nslm5 for p=0.015 Nslm2. Note that, due to the high value of the flow rate, such a restrictor cannot be made with a small pipe without accepting high
184
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATION
Reynolds numbers. A more suitable approach may consist in using a narrow annular clearance as a restrictor (Fig. 4.11.e). A further solution may consist in substituting the laminar-flow restrictor with a n orifice, which works well at a high Reynolds number (section 4.11).
W
p
h
(KN) (Ns/m2)
(m3/s) (KW)
0.015 20
Q.103 H p
Hf
AT
(KW)
("(2
0.25
1.02
1.16
5.0
0.19
0.76
1.55
7.1
0.11
0.42
1.87
12.8
0.08
0.32
2.49
20.7
40. 0.020 0.015 24.8
35 0.020
vi) It is easy to verifv that the radial Reynolds number of the bearing (Eqn 5.75) is suitably low, as well as the tangential Reynolds number (Eqn 5.59) and the inertia parameter (Eqn 5.50).
EXAMPLE 6.5 The stiffness of the bearing designed in Example 6.4 needs to be improved, without changing the dimensions of the pad, nor the supply system (except for the compensating device). Namely, Ah needs to be reduced to a value of 10 p m or smaller. i) First, one may try to reduce the design value of clearance. In the previous example it is shown that ho cannot be smaller than 32 pm, in order to avo& excessive friction; consequently, Ah cannot be smaller than 32.(1-0.62)=12 pm. It is clear that another type of restrictor must be used to emure adequate stiffness. W One test may consist in substituting the laminar flow restrictor with a sharpedge orifice. In this case, Eqn 6.25 gives a minimum film thickness hm=O.717.h0; assuming ho=30 pm, it follows that h,=21.5 pm and Ah=8.5 pm. For orifice compensation, however, clearance depends on the actual value of viscosity, as shown in Fig. 6.9: i f p is increased from 0.015 NsIm2 to 0.02 Nslm2, clearance experiences a 10% increase, and Ah becomes greater than 9 pm. By repeating the calculations, the flow rate, powers and temperature step are obtained, as shown in the following table. The stiffness constraint has clearly forced us to select values of the power ratio greater than 3, leading to large temperature steps in the lubricant. The diameter of the orifice can be calculated by means of Eqn 4.76, in which Q=Qo=O.ll m3/s, Ap=(l-p)p,=2.25 MPa. The discharge coefficient depends on practical considera-
185
SlNGLE PAD BEARlNGS
tions (see Fig. 4.16 and Fig. 4.17), a typical value being Cd=0.65. d=1.72 m m is readily obtained. W
p
h
(KN) (Ns/m2) (pm)
Q.103 H p (m3/s) (KW)
Hf
AT
(KW)
(T)
0.015
30.
0.11
0.43
1.55
10.9
0.020
33.
0.11
0.43
1.88
12.7
0.015
21.5
0.07
0.28
2.16
20.8
0.020
23.7
0.07
0.28
2.61
24.7
20
35
iii) In the last case examined, it is clear that power, flow rate and temperature step are subject to large variations when the load and viscosity change. A great improvement from this point of view may be obtained by means of a constant flow valve. Figure. 6.10 shows that now h,=0.830.ho; it is therefore possible to select a greater value for clearance, such as ho=40 pm. Assuming that a temperature compensated valve is used, calculations now give:
It may be verified that by reducing the flow rate, say to 0.1 .lO-3 m3/s, clearance hoproues to be close to 30 pm, with a higher friction power, but the total power expense will not be notably affected (it will be slightly reduced).
Chapter 7
OPPOSED-PAD AND MULTIPAD BEARINGS
7.1
INTRODUCTION
A multipad bearing system is made up of a certain number of pads, with a common moving member. The pads may be, in general, quite different, and they, too, might be fed by means of differing devices.
All these bearings may be studied by applying to each pad the equations already developed for the single pads in chapter 5, and by summing together the effects of all the pads, after having expressed all the pad clearances as functions of the displacement of the moving member. The case of the opposed-pad bearings is of particular importance.
7.2
OPPOSED-PAD BEARINGS
For any opposed-pad bearing, such as the one in Fig. 7.1, the total load capacity is, obviously,
The flow rate is, from Eqn 5.2 and Eqn 5.10, (7.2)
OPPOSED-PAD AND MULTIPAD BEARINGS
187
It is useful to take the origin of the displacements in such a way as to split the axial play into two equal parts; thus, if e is the axial displacement (see Fig. 7.11,ho is the axial half-play, and &=-
e h0
(7.3)
is the non-dimensional eccentricity; the non-dimensional clearances are:
(7.4)
Fig. 7.1 Opposed-pad bearing.
The bearing stiffness may now be defined as:
(7.5) It is obvious how the expressions for H p and H f may be obtained. In the most common case of symmetrical bearings ke. that in which the two pads are equal), we have Ae,=Ae2=Ae and R10=R20=R0, and the above equations turn out to be simplified even further.
188
HYDROSTATIC LUBRICATlON
7.2.1
Direct supply
(i)Basic equations. When the two opposite recesses are fed by separate pumps,
providing the constant volume flows Q1 and Q2, respectively, the recess pressures are:
The load capacity is given by Eqn 7.1. For a symmetrical bearing, provided that Q1=Q2=Q/2(see Fig 7.21, we have: 1
W=ijRoA, Q W ( E )
(7.7)
where
A, and Ro are the relevant values, for each type of pad, calculated in chapter 5. When Eqn 5.12 is valid, i.e. for plane pads, and, approximately for many other pads,