Norwegian Petroleum Society (NPF), Special Publication No. 7
Hydrocarbon Seals Importance for Exploration and Producti...
73 downloads
2177 Views
36MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Norwegian Petroleum Society (NPF), Special Publication No. 7
Hydrocarbon Seals Importance for Exploration and Production
Further titles in the series:
1. R.M. Larsen, H. Brekke, B.T. Larsen and E. Talleraas (Editors) STRUCTURAL AND TECTONIC MODELLING AND ITS APPLICATION TO PETROLEUM GEOLOGY- Proceedings of Norwegian Petroleum Society Workshop, 18-20 October 1989, Stavanger, Norway 2. T.O. Vorren, E. Bergsager, Q.A. DahI-Stamnes, E. Holter, B. Johansen, E. Lie and T.B. Lund (Editors) ARCTIC GEOLOGY AND PETROLEUM POTENTIAL- Proceedings of the Norwegian Petroleum Society Conference, 15-17 August 1990, Tromso, Norway 3. A.G. Dorb et al. (Editors) BASIN MODELLING" ADVANCES AND APPLICATIONS - Proceedings of the Norwegian Petroleum Society Conference, 13-15 March 1991, Stavanger, Norway
4. S. Hanslien (Editor) PETROLEUM" EXPLORATION AND EXPLOITATION IN NORWAYProceedings of the Norwegian Petroleum Society Conference, 9-11 December 1991, Stavanger, Norway 5. R.J. Steel, V.L. Felt, E.P. Johannesson and C Mathieu (Editors) SEQUENCE STRATIGRAPHY ON THE NORTHWEST EUROPEAN MARGIN Proceedings of the Norwegian Petroleum Society Conference, 1-3 February, 1993, Stavanger, Norway
6. A.G. Dor~, R. Sinding-Larsen (Editors) QUANTIFICATION AND PREDICTION OF HYDROCARBON RESOURCESProceedings of the Norwegian Petroleum Society Conference, 6-8 December, 1993, Stavanger, Norway
N o r w e g i a n P e t r o l e u m S o c i e t y (NPF), S p e c i a l P u b l i c a t i o n No. 7
Hydrocarbon Seals Importance for Exploration and Production
Edited by
Dr. P. Moller-Pedersen
Norwegian Petroleum Society, Lervigsveien 32, Postboks 547, N-4001 Stavanger, Norway and
Dr. A.G. Koestler
Geo-Recon S/S, Munkedamsveien 59, N-0270 Oslo, Norway
1997 ELSEVIER Amsterdam - Lausanne - New Y o r k - Oxford - Shannon - Singapore - Tokyo
ELSEVIER SCIENCE (Singapore) Pte Ltd No. 1 Temasek Avenue, #17-01 Millenia Tower Singapore 039192
ISBN: 0-444-82825-7 91997 Elsevier Science (Singapore) Pte Ltd. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elsevier Science (Singapore) Pte Ltd. Copyright & Permissions, No. 1 Temasek Avenue, #17-01 Millenia Tower, Singapore 039192. Special regulations for readers in the U S A - This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923. Information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the USA. All other copyright questions, including photocopying outside of the USA, should be referred to the copyright owner, Elsevier Science (Singapore) Pte Ltd., unless otherwise specified. No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Printed in The Netherlands.
Preface
In January 1996 a total of 270 conference participants gathered for 3 days in Trondheim, Norway, to focus on and to discuss the complex topic of hydrocarbon seals particularly related to deformation zones and to caprocks. All together 32 oral papers and 9 poster were presented. There was also a plenary discussion and informal gatherings. The conference was the first in Norway and one of the first in Europe to exclusively address this very important subject. The purposes of the conference were to present some of the most recent research results, to establish state-of-the-art with respect to understanding hydrocarbon seals and to discuss where to go from here to find some of the keys to successful future exploration and enhanced oil and gas recovery. Out of the presented papers and posters, 17 are compiled and published in this volume. These provide a good overview of and an introduction to the numerous aspects covered during the fruitful days in Trondheim. In the introductory paper by K.J. Weber, a wide-ranging and well illustrated historical overview, the development of theories and methods to predict and quantify trapping mechanisms is presented. The paper covers the period from the early days of the oil business around 1850 up to now and it contains a significant amount of previously unpublished historic material. The section on fault seals comprises a total of 10 papers ranging from case studies to in-depth studies of specific sealing mechanisms. R.J. Knipe et al. provide an introduction to fault seals and processes, describe how properties and evolution of seals within fault zones can be evaluated and suggest ways forward to improve fault seal risk evaluation. F.K. Lehner and W.F Pilaar document some previously unpublished observations from a study of clay smears in synsedimentary normal faults displayed in lignite mines at Frechen in Germany. Although several earlier studies covered these beautiful outcrops, a new approach to the well documented observations confirm that substantial clay smears can occur if ductile shale source beds are faulted at slow displacement rates. J.R. Fulljames with co-authors present a method to systematically analyse fault seals and to quantitatively approach the prediction of two types of fault seals, namely juxtaposition seals and fault gouge seals. C. Childs et al. provide a description of the complexity of fault zones based on outcrop studies. They outline a model for the development of the complex internal structures which seem to be important for the evaluation of the sealing potential. The way forward in fault seal prediction is in the authors' opinion by refinement of current empirical and comparative methods through more detailed characterisation of sub-surface faults. A study of fracture systems and rock mechanical properties of the cap rocks of the Late Jurassic Fuglen and Hekkingen Formations in the south-western Barents Sea, Norway, is presented by R.H. Gabrielsen and O.S. Klcvjan. They propose that leakage of hydrocarbons to the surface caused by the Tertiary uplift and erosion could be related to one of four fracture groups associated with major fault zones. To predict deformation mechanisms and cementation of faults in sandstones, E. Sverdrup and K. BjCrlykke developed models by studying cores and outcrops. Timing of faulting relative to the diagenetic processes is critical and fault characteristics and cementation can be predicted by relating fault episodes to the diagenetic history of the basin. T. Fristad et al. describe a methodology to predict fault-seal behaviour from analysis of a detailed depth model in conjunction with detailed lithological mapping. The case study concentrates on the Oseberg area in the North Viking Graben, Norway. Another case study done by A.I. Welbon et al. documents a fault seal analysis of the Greater Heidrun area in Mid-Norway. The study assesses the control of fault seal on migration, trap integrity and filling history, which serves as a basis for assessment of risk parameters for exploration prospects and their subsequent ranking. A. Makurat et al. present results from laboratory tests to study flow behaviour associated with fractures. They conclude that five factors in addition to the fracture orientation affect the flow along and across fractures. These are uniaxial compressive strength, permeability and porosity of the intact rock, fracture roughness, shear displacement and the ratio between effective
vi
Preface
stress on the fracture and the compressive strength of the intact rock. T.R. Harper and E.R. Lundin review the predictability of juxtaposition and deformation seals, describe the mechanisms of shear bands and clay smear, estimate the sealing capacity of shear bands and assess the influence of presentday stress on the sealing capacity of faults. G.M. Ingram and M.A. Naylor introduce the section on migration and top seal integrity totalling 6 papers by presenting an approach to top seal assessment. They review the physics of capillary sealing and flow barriers, discuss static versus dynamic sealing and present a technique for assessing the effect of sub-seismic fault populations within the top seal. A model for gas migration is developed by D. Kettel based on history matches of gas flow by diffusion and Darcy flow through nine known gas fields sealed by salt. The model can be used to derive permeability/depth functions for rock salt that may be used in the prediction of the degree of gas fill for a prospect. N.C. Dutta describes a technique to predict pore pressure before drilling based on seismic velocity data. Examples from deep water areas of the Gulf of Mexico are shown. The technique allows seal failure risk assessment for prospects. R. Olstad et al. has studied the porewater flow and petroleum migration in the SmCrbukk area, Norway. They found that a major sealing fault zone has affected lateral migration and has caused the development of high overpressure cells. The authors conclude that petroleum migration cannot be inferred from the pressure distribution because the permeability changes continuously due to diagenetic processes. The Njord Field, Norway, is an interesting case of reservoir compartmentalization as demonstrated by T. Lilleng and R. Gundesr Formation pressure data confirms the presence of sealing faults creating hydraulic compartments. A dynamic model of active hydrocarbon migration coupled with vertical leakage through breaching of the reservoir top seal is discussed. D.M. Hall et al. review the processes for top seal failure in the greater Ekofisk area, Norway. There is no evidence that a significant amount of leakage has occurred as a result of hydraulic breaching, tectonic breaching or capillary leakage. The authors argue that pressure-inhibit charge is an alternative explanation for the limited extent of the hydrocarbon columns in some structures. The editors hope that this volume will make a contribution towards a better understanding of hydrocarbon seals and that it may stimulate further research and studies. The aim would be to improve understanding and promote proper application for the numerous cases where sealing prediction might be the key for enhanced recovery or more effective exploration. We would like to thank all the contributors for their interest in the topic and their cooperation during the preparation of this volume. The important work done by reviewers of the papers is highly acknowledged. Thanks are given to NPF, who made this conference possible. Finally, we would like to encourage further research within this field of geology and engineering to make creative steps towards unraveling the true potential of seal evaluation and predictions to improve hydrocarbon exploration and production. Per MOller-Pedersen The Norwegian Oil Industry Association, P.O. Box 547, N-4001 Stavanger, Norway Andreas G. Koestler Geo-Recon A/S, Munkedamsveien 59, N-0270 Oslo, Norway
vii
List of Contributors
L. BACKER
Norwegian Technical Institute, P.O. Box 3930 Ullevaal Hageby, Sognsveien 72, N-0806 Oslo, Norway
A. BEACH
Alastair Beach Associates Ltd., 11 Royal Exchange Square, Glasgow, G1 3AJ, UK
K. BJORLYKKE
Department of Geology, University of Oslo, P.O. Box 1047, N-0316 Oslo, Norway
P.J. BROCKBANK
Alastair Beach Associates Ltd., 11 Royal Exchange Square, Glasgow, G1 3AJ, UK
C. CHILDS
Fault Analysis Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Liverpool Liverpool L69 3BX, UK
M.R. CLENNELL
Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK
B.A. DUFF
PetroFina sa, Rue de l'industrie 52, B-1040 Bruxelles, Belgium
N.C. DUTTA
BP Exploration Inc., 200 Westlake Park Boulevard, Houston, TX 77079, USA
M. ELIAS
Fina Italiana, Viale Premuda 27, 1-20129, Milano, Italy
A.B. FARMER
Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK
Q.J. FISHER
Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK
O. FJELD
Phillips Petroleum Company Norway, P.O. Box 220, 4056 Tananger, Norway
R.C.M.W. FRANSSEN
Shell Oil Company, OPA, P.O. Box 4704, Houston, TX 77210-4704, USA
B. FREEMAN
Badley Earth Sciences Ltd., North Beck House, North Beck Lane, Hundleby, Spilsby, Lincolnshire, PE23 5NB, UK
T. FRISTAD
Norsk Hydro, P.O. Box 200, N-1321 Stabekk, Norway
J.R. FULLJAMES
Shell International Exploration & Production BV., P.O. Box 60, 2280 AB Rijswijk, The Netherlands
R.H. GABRIELSEN
Department of Geology, University of Bergen, All~gaten 41, N-5007 Bergen, Norway
A. GROTH
Norsk Hydro, P.O. Box 200, N-1321 Stabekk, Norway
R. GUNDESO
Norsk Hydro Produksjon a.s., N-5020 Bergen, Norway
M. GUTIERREZ
Norwegian Technical Institute, P.O. Box 3930 Ullevaal Hageby, Sognsveien 72, N-0806 Oslo, Norway
S.R. GYTRI
Fina Exploration Norway, SkOgstostraen, P.O. Box 4055, Stavanger, Norway
D.M. HALL
PetroFina sa, Rue de l'industrie 52, B-1040 Bruxelles, Belgium
viii
List of Contributors
T.R. H A R P E R
Geosphere Ltd., Netherton Farm, Sheepwash, Beaworthy, Devon EX21 5PL, UK
A. HARRISON
Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK
G.M. INGRAM
Shell International Exploration and Production, Research & Technical Services, P.O. Box 60, 2280 AB Rijswijk, The Netherlands
G. JONES
Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK
D.A. KARLSEN
Department of Geology, University of Oslo, P.O. Box 1047, N-0316 Oslo, Norway
D. KETTEL
Kettel Consultants, Ch~tellon de Cornelle, 01640 Boyeux St. Jgr6me, France
B. KIDD
Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK
O.S. KLOVJAN
Norsk Hydro U&P Research Centre, N-5020 Bergen, Norway
R.J. KNIPE
Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK
S.D. KNOTT
3 Creagbat Avenue, Quarriers Village, Bridge of Wear, UK
F.K. LEHNER
Institute for Geodynamics, Bonn University, Nussalle 8, D-53115 Bonn, Germany
T. LILLENG
Norsk Hydro Produksjon a.s., N-5020 Bergen, Norway
E.R. LUNDIN
Statoil Research Centre, Postuttak, 7005 Trondheim, Norway
A. M A K U R A T
Norwegian Technical Institute, P.O. Box 3930 Ullevaal Hageby, Sognsveien 72, N-0806 Oslo, Norway
E. MCALLISTER
Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK
M.A. NAYLOR
Petroleum Development Oman LLC, PDO Office, Mina al Fahal, Muscat, Oman
R. OLSTAD
Esso Norway AS, PO Box 60, N-4033 Forus, Norway
T. P E D E R S E N
Conoco Norway Inc., Randberg, PO Box 488, N-4001 Stavanger, Norway
W.F. PILAAR
J.F. Kennedy plantsoen 63, 2252 EV Voorschoten, The Netherlands
J.R. PORTER
Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK
E. SVERDRUP
Saga Petroleum as, P.O. Box 490, N-1301 Sandvika, Norway
S. THOMAS
Statoil a.s., 4035 Stavanger, Norway
J.L. URAI
Geologie-Endogene Dynamik, RWTH Aachen, Lochnerstrasse4-20, D52056 Aachen, Germany
J.J. W A L S H
Fault Analysis Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Liverpool Liverpool, L69 3BX, UK
J. W A T T E R S O N
Fault Analysis Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, L69 3BX, UK
K.J. W E B E R
Faculty of Applied Earth Sciences, Delft University of Technology, P.O. Box 5028, 2600 GA Delft, The Netherlands
List of Contributors
ix
A.I. W E L B O N
Alastair Beach Associates Ltd., 11 Royal Exchange Square, Glasgow, G1 3A J, UK (now at Statoil a.s., Stavanger, Norway)
E.A. W H I T E
Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, Uni, versity of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK
G. YIELDING
Badley Earth Sciences Ltd., North Beck House, North Beck Lane, Hundleby, Spilsby, Lincolnshire, PE23 5NB, UK
L.J.J. ZIJERVELD
21 Oxford Street, Edinburgh EH8 9PQ, UK
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Contents
Preface .............................................................................................................................................. List of Contributors
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
,
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
v vii
A historical overview of the efforts to predict and quantify hydrocarbon trapping features in the exploration phase and in field development planning ............................................................. K.J. Weber
I. Fault Seals Fault seal analysis: successful methodologies, application and future directions ............................ R.J. Knipe, Q.J. Fisher, G. Jones, M.R. Clennell, A.B. Farmer, A. Harrison, B. Kidd, E. McAllister, J.R. Porter and E.A. White
15
The emplacement of clay smears in synsedimentary normal faults: inferences from field observations near Frechen, Germany ...................................................................................... F.K. Lehner and W.F. Pilaar
39
Fault seal processes: systematic analysis of fault seals over geological and production time scales J.R. Fulljames, L.J.J. Zijerveld and R.C.M.W. Franssen
51
Complexity in fault zone structure and implications for fault seal prediction .................................. C. Childs, J.J. Walsh and J. Watterson
61
Late Jurassic-early Cretaceous caprocks of the southwestern Barents Sea: fracture systems and rock mechanical properties ...................................................................................................... Roy H. Gabrielsen and OddbjCrn S. KlCvjan
73
Fault properties and the development of cemented fault zones in sedimentary basins: field examples and predictive models .............................................................................................. E. Sverdrup and K. BjCrlykke
91
Quantitative fault seal prediction: a case study from Oseberg Syd .................................................. T. Fristad, A. Groth, G. Yielding and B. Freeman
107
Fault seal analysis in hydrocarbon exploration and appraisal: examples from offshore midNorway .................................................................................................................................... 125 A.I. Welbon, A. Beach, P.J. Brockbank, O. Fjeld, S.D. Knott, T. Pedersen and S. Thomas Fracture flow and fracture cross flow experiments .......................................................................... A. Makurat, M. Gutierrez and L. Backer
139
Fault seal analysis: reducing our dependence on empiricism ........................................................... T.R. Harper and E.R. Lundin
149
II. Migration and Top Seal Integrity Sealing processes and top seal assessment ....................................................................................... 165 G.M. Ingram, J.L. Urai and M.A. Naylor The dynamics of gas flow through rock salt in the scope of time .................................................... D. Kettel
175
xii
Contents
Pressure prediction from seismic data: implications for seal distribution and hydrocarbon exploration and exploitation in the deepwater Gulf Of Mexico .............................................. N.C. Dutta
187
Pore water flow and petroleum migration in the SmCrbukk field area, offshore mid-Norway ........ R. Olstad, K. BjCrlykke and D.A. Karlsen
201
The Njord Field: a dynamic hydrocarbon trap ................................................................................. T. Lilleng and R. Gundesr
217
Pre-cretaceous top-seal integrity in the greater Ekofisk area ........................................................... D.M. Hall, B.A. Duff, M. Elias and S.R. Gytri
231
References index ..............................................................................................................................
243
Subject index ....................................................................................................................................
249
A historical overview of the efforts to predict and quantify
hydrocarbon trapping features in the exploration phase and in field development planning K.J. Weber
The story of the development of theories and methods related to trapping mechanisms is a fascinating succession of brilliant observations, ludicrous misconceptions, empirical trials, and eventually the breakthrough of sound geological and physical principles. It took some 30 years from the start of the oil industry before petroleum geology began to have an impact. The period from 1885 to 1915 was very fruitful although the pendulum swung too much the other way and exploration focussed on anticlinal traps only. However, by 1915 considerable progress had been made and most trapping configurations had been recognised. Also the basic physical principles of trapping were understood in a qualitative sense. The years from 1915 to 1935 saw the development of most of the important exploration tools and also the invention of wireline logging and many petrophysical analysis methods. Consequently, the structural control on traps and the petrophysical characterisation improved significantly. By 1935, so much oilfield data had become available that several geologists in succession designed detailed classification systems for trapping configurations. After 1935, the physics of rock mechanics, flow in porous media and interfacial tension formed the subject of important studies that put petroleum geology and engineering on a much more scientific footing. This led in turn to more quantitative analysis of trapping capacity and trap integrity. After 1955, there was another upsurge in technical sophistication with respect to seismic quality, wireline logging, geochemistry and laboratory equipment. More recently, the understanding and quantification of trapping has improved steadily through sophisticated well test analysis, reservoir performance monitoring, borehole imaging logs and, in particular, the detailed images provided by 3D-seismic. Outcrop studies have been undertaken to learn more about fault zones. Research is by no means finished and there is still a wide variety of uncertainties and controversies concerning trapping phenomena.
Early struggles, 1850-1885 In nearly all oil-producing basins, numerous seeps exist. Early usage of petroleum goes back to biblical times in the Middle East. The fact that seeps are often related to faults and fractures was noted, and it was even observed that seepages along the Dead Sea were activated during earthquakes. The beginnings of petroleum production are always around seeps. Some petroleum was collected as medicine, for example, near Modena (Fig. 1). In this case, the seep is along a thrust fault and nearby oil fields are not situated directly underneath the seep. However, many seepages take place along crestal fractures of anticlinal structures. The earliest mention of this fact was made by William Logan, the first director of the new Geological Survey of Canada, in 1842. He observed the coincidence of oil seeps with anticlinal crests in the Gasp6 peninsula near the mouth of the St. Lawrence. Prior to drilling for oil, some oil was produced from hand dug pits in places like Burma and along the Caspian Sea. Thomas Young of the Geological Survey of India reported the occurrence of oil seeps
and oil production on anticlinal structures in the Yenang Yaung field in Burma already in 1855. That other types of accumulation existed also was clear from studies of the Pechelbronn field along the Rhine graben in the Alsace, where oil production from mine shafts was started in 1735. In Indonesia, the oil seeps on Java were studied by a group of mining engineers from the Delft University who started to inventorise the mineral resources in 1850. In 1865 they had located 52 seeps in the parts of Indonesia accessible at that time. Interestingly, the famous naturalist Junghuhn advised against drilling on Java. He argued that the strongly disturbed and faulted beds were likely to be incapable of holding sizeable accumulations. Nevertheless, present maps show that the recorded seeps overlie nearly all oil provinces that have since been located. Drilling wells was already common practice by the time the first oil wells were planned. Particularly the drilling of brine wells for the production of salt was carried out in many places. In Pennsylvania this had occasionally led to the inadvertent penetration of oil accumulations, which rendered the wells useless. Seneca Indians in this region used petroleum scooped
Hydrocarbon Seals: Importance for Exploration and Production edited by P. M~ller-Pedersen and A.G. Koestler. NPF Special Publication 7, pp. 1-13, Elsevier, Singapore. 9 Norwegian Petroleum Society (NPF) 1997
2
K.J. Weber
ilblrlu liI lililolllr Ilul~lf:, Ioqiit:llc lltII;illilill cI ploiifllillllr Fig. 1. Oil seep near M o d e n a , Italy, used since m e d i e v a l times to prepare medicines.
from pools to impregnate torches. Thus, the first oil company was named Seneca Oil Company (Fig. 2). In 1859, Drake drilled the first well which penetrated a productive oil accumulation at about 21 m depth. Production amounted to 25 barrels per day, soon dropping to 15.
~
Elsewhere, drilling for oil started at about the same time, for instance, in Germany, at Wietze, in 1857, near a well-known seep. In Rumania, after starting with hand dug wells, drilling started in 1882. In Baku and Grosny, in Russia, hand dug wells were followed by drilling in 1869. In Galicia, which at that time was
~ '
__
~ j ~ "
f
~,
.i.
4
~'.:dh.ed/
/
.,
C , , . l .....
/
# #
#
,e
tgtRl ; "~
rre~<. .Lith by ~'undeilioa/r Cris,~nd lqewll~.veRl~t
, .--~_-,r
k.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Fig. 2. Share of the first A m e r i c a n oil c o m p a n y that u n d e r t o o k the first dedicated drilling c a m p a i g n for oil.
A historical overview of hydrocarbon trapping features
3
Austrian, drilling started in 1862. In Indonesia, drilling started in 1871 near the seep at Madja, on Java. In Canada, discoveries were made in 1857 in Ontario. Independently of each other, two geologists published their theories on anticlinical trapping in 1861. T. Sperry Hunt of the Canadian Geological Survey observed that the oil produced in western Ontario was associated with a broad, moderately folded anticline. Furthermore he recognised that the oil was situated in porous strata between impermeable shale layers. The gravity segregation of gas, oil and water was another interesting feature which he described. E.B. Andrews, Professor of Geology at Marietta, OH, also observed the close association of productive wells with anticlinal axes in West Virginia. He attributed this partly to the numerous cracks and fissures in these regions caused by the folding. These observations had little impact on the exploration practice which relied on local empirical lore and much pure wild-catting near seeps. Several fields were even found with the aid of a divining-rod! Even in Pennsylvania, where Professor H.D. Rogers indicated that several of the successful new wells were located on anticlines less than a year after the drilling of Drake's well, such information was ignored. Of course, it is always easy to ridicule this primitive approach. However, undoubtedly many geological advisors were quite unreliable. Moreover, if the structural style is not too complicated, empirical rules often work. Trends of rivers frequently played a part in predictions and these are often parallel to the structural strike. Another characteristic of early exploration efforts was the technical difficulty of drilling to any considerable depth and the poor recording of stratigraphic detail, which both hamper the subsurface analysis.
The situation in the USA is well illustrated by the statement by J.P. Lesley, the director of the Geological Survey of Pennsylvania, in 1875: "The supposed connection of petroleum with anticlinical and synclinical axes, faults, crevices, cleavage planes, etc., is now a deservedly forgotten superstition" (Landes, 1951). One gets the impression that the situation outside the USA was generally somewhat better and that geologists were involved at an earlier stage. In Europe, several interesting papers on petroleum geology appeared between 1870 and 1885. A striking example is the section through a salt dome from a paper by Posepny, dating from 1871 (Fig. 3). This form of trapping against the flanks of piercement domes was only discovered in the USA in 1925. In Vienna, in 1877, Hans von Hofer published a paper on anticlinical trapping (Owen, 1957). In 1870, B.S. Lyman a Pennsylvanian geologist, working for the Public Works Department in India, published the first structural contour maps of oil bearing strata. In the USA. the breakthrough of petroleum geology was mostly the work of two men: J.F. Carll and I.C. White. Carll, a civil engineer who had worked in the oil fields, joined the Pennsylvanian Geological Survey in 1874. His seven reports are a major contribution to petroleum geology. One can also see him as a petrophysicist and reservoir engineer. He realised the role of a gas cap in providing a drive mechanism for the oil but also the magnitude of the sandstone porosity and its importance for production and storage capacity (Lytle, 1957). Professor I.C. White is chiefly known for his reinvention of the anticlinal theory for oil accumulation, which he started to promote as of 1880. By 1885
c
¢ -.==.
1, /
!
L
I
//
,,
Fig. 3. Carpathian salt dome as depicted by F. Posepny (1871) showing the potential trapping configurations along the flanks.
4
K.J. Weber
he had already made several discoveries and his ideas began to have influence (Landes, 1951). From this time onwards petroleum geology was clearly on the way up in the USA, although one can say that the anticlinical theory got too much attention to the detriment of consideration of other trapping configurations. Later geologists have criticized some of White's publications (White, 1885) and pointed out serious discrepancies with the much more complicated reality. However, his influence was what counted and we must remember the saying: "A petroleum geologist's life is a never-ending struggle between brilliant concepts and inconvenient facts!" (Lament of a Shell exploration guru).
Start of petroleum geology, 1885-1915 As an example of the state-of-the-art in petroleum geology around 1885, it is interesting to follow the history of exploration on the island of Sumatra in Indonesia. The initial story is rather similar to the Pennsylvanian situation. In 1880, a Dutch tobacco planter, A.J. Zijlker, sheltering on a rainy night, noticed the long-burning torches of the natives and found that these were soaked in petroleum scooped from a nearby pool. He managed to obtain a concession from the Sultan of Langkat. To obtain capital for his venture, Zijlker needed the assurance of a competent geologist that an economic volume of oil might be present. For this he had to turn to the government mining department. Initially, he only received help in the form of a drilling engineer and the first well was spudded near an oil-covered pool. The well encountered some oil at a depth of about 100 m, but deepening only led to water production. However, a second well, placed by pure luck on the crest of an anticline, resulted in significant oil production at about 30 m and a blow-out of gas, oil and water when a depth of 121 m was reached. This event, in 1885, heralded oil production in Indonesia and is also the origin of the Shell company (Gerritson, 1939). A proper analysis of the find came after a government mining engineer, R. Fennema, was put in technical charge in 1886. Fennema was not only a competent engineer but also an accomplished geologist. He carried out geological surveys and showed the anticlinical nature of the oil accumulation at Talaga Toenggal, the site of the discovery well. In one of his letters from 1888 one can read the following: At one boring near Telaga Toenggal really magnificent results were obtained. Here the proper petroleumreservoir had been reached; geological investigations related with the results of the wells has shown us that this petroleum-reservoir (a thick sand layer soaked with
petroleum) is covered by a protective layer, which has
been bent to a so-called saddle or anticline. The saddle axis runs about parallel to the longitudinal axis of Sumatra and a section perpendicular to the axis is shown in the adjacent figure (Fig. 4); a-b is the petroleum soaked layer, which is encountered at 120 m below the surface at c, and produces the large amounts of gas and oil; d. are fissures in the coveting rock, in which the oil rises by the pressures of the gasses in the oil layer to the surface locally. Some of the covering layers that are more or less porous have been fed by the fissures and have in that way become secondary locations. (From the special commemorative book A Century of Exploration, 18851985, Shell Internationale Petroleum Maatschappij B.V., The Hague.) It is obvious from the above that the basic trapping conditions were well understood. Surface mapping of structures also started at this time and on the section of the Telaga Said field, the surface dips measured around the field are indicated (Fig. 5), This structure is situated on the same axial trend as the Telaga Toenggal anticline at a distance of about 1 km towards the NW). In the USA this surface mapping became popular after the famous Spindletop discovery in the anticlinical structure overlying a salt dome in 1901. However, it would take 25 years before the oil reservoir trapped against the flanks of the dome would be found. Good fieldwork and continued drilling near seeps resulted in numerous discoveries in the USA but also in Argentina, Venezuela, Trinidad, Mexico, Indonesia and very importantly in the Middle East, in Iran. Typically, the discovery well in Iran at Masjid-iSuleiman is only a stone's throw away from a large seep. The first book on pertroleum geology appeared in 1915 (Hager, 1915) and in it, several types of trap are described (Fig. 6). Production geological problems such as the gap in a reservoir as a result of a normal
.e,,
e,,.
...~
,,_ q
.
Fig. 4. Sketch of a section across the Telaga-Toenggal anticline drawn by the mining engineer R. Fennema (1886). This section clearly shows the stratigraphy, structure and fissures which control the hydrocarbon distribution (from A Century of Exploration, 18851985, Shell Internationale Petroleum Maatschappij B.V., The Hague).
A historical overview of hydrocarbon trapping features
5
. . . . . . . .
Beri~l
Z.W.
~
2t~ - " " "
..-.
9 "
~
"%
z az,, u
.......
'
-
"
.--"
9
mndT
2our
-. --
--
N.O.
_
r-r-" d=a,,,.,
....
,
s I
--
_,Iv___
""
.t. , . .r , "~
"l , ,
u,
' ,, 9
"-
~-~ter
. . . . .
~,
, ,'~
,
x x
"--;
_.._
D r Z. B / u ~
Fig. 5. Section of the famous Telaga Said oil field which was the major oil producer in Sumatra at the end of the 19th century. The surface expressions of the structure of this overturned anticline are indicated showing that geological field work had been executed (from Gerritson, 1939).
fault had been understood (Fig. 7). Correlations between wells were carried out with the help of logs made by glueing cuttings to narrow wooden planks. Because the regular bailing out of the holes in cable tool drilling gives a quite accurate depth control on the sampling, this method results in excellent well records. From Hager's book, it is worthwhile to paraphrase some of the keys statements: - All oil and gas deposits, so far as known, are capped or covered by practically impervious beds of shale, sandstone or limestone; also such beds are underlaid by impervious beds. - No beds are actually impervious but are impervious only in a relative sense. - Where faults or unconformities occur, water will force oil to enter the upper strata by driving it from the lower sands. - Since water has about 50% higher surface tension than oil, it tends to be drawn into the finest capillaries with half again as much force as that drawing oil into the fine openings. Thus the tendency is for water to occupy the shale and oil and gas to fill the pores of the coarser strata.
Migration can thus be upwards, downwards or laterally. - Sometimes the more volatile oils will escape where the strata have been eroded, unless asphaltic or paraffinic deposits coat the faces of the strata, and act as seals. The above gives a good overview of the state-ofthe-art in 1915. By that time the USA produced 65% of the world's oil, Russia was second with 16%, followed by Mexico with 6%. Rumania and Indonesia produced 3% each, Burma and East Galicia with 2% and finally Japan and Iran with 1% close the list of prominent oil producing countries in the fateful year 1914. -
Years of development, 1915-1935 This is a period in which technical development was rapid. Rotary drilling led to much deeper drilling compared with the now outdated cable tool drilling. Surface mapping was insufficient to reveal the traps at greater depth, and a search was made for other methods. In 1915, the first field use was made of the torsion balance in gravimetric surveys in Czechoslo-
1 /k S A
)
- -
Fig. 6. Fault trap from the early book on petroleum geology by Hager (1915).
o
6
K.J. Weber
Fig. 7. Fault cut-out from the book of Hager (1915), illustrating the increasing understanding of subsurface reservoir configurations.
vakia. This instrument had been developed over the period 1888 to 1896 by the Hungarian Baron R. von Ei3tvtis. After the First World War the method was introduced in the major oil producing countries. Shell tested the method in 1922 over the already known Hurghada structure in Egypt, resulting in a clear "high" in the gravity map (Forbes and O'Beirne, 1957). Elsewhere, particularly good results were obtained over salt domes. Improved gravimeters were developed and after 1935 these instruments are in general use throughout the oil provinces. Magnetic surveys were tried out after the Askania
factory produced a sensitive magnetometer in 1915. These proved to be much less successful than the gravimetric surveys for mapping structures, although the method yields much useful information on regional structural trends and rock composition. Of much greater importance with regard to the unravelling of trapping configurations was the development of seismic methods. The first seismic profile was actually already recorded by O. Hecker in 1900 but it took some time to achieve practically useful results. The first seismic method used in exploration for oil
5oo
5oo
moo
IOOO
| | i= 15oo
2OOO
O
__A__
=a= 2500
!
-i
-
/
~o00
/
___t_ L~O0
Fig. 8. Interpreted reflection-seismic section from Venezuela, carried out in the period 1939-1941, showing the limited resolution in the period prior to the 1960s (from LeRoy, 1951).
A historical overview of hydrocarbon trapping features
<
~~176
. . . .
~ " .._
7
a German, L. Mintrop, to locate enemy artillery. Mintrop was engaged by Shell after the war to try out this method for delineating structural features in Mexico. Useful results started to be obtained in the period 1924 to 1930, mainly in locating and mapping salt domes along the Gulf Coast. The reflection seismic method, that would eventually supplant the refraction technique, was patented in 1914 by R. Fessenden in the USA. Use of this method for oil exploration was proposed by J.C. Karcher in 1917. In 1921 the first field tests were carried out in the USA, but it took until 1929 before the first successes were achieved (Forbes and O'Beirne, 1957). Soon afterwards the method was already used in several countries often together with the refraction technique. A good example of an early reflection seismogram that resulted in the discovery of a field is shown in Fig. 8. The Tucupita field in eastern Venezuela was discovered on the basis of seismic surveys carried out in the period 1939-1941 (LeRoy, 1951). In 1927, the first wireline logs were recorded by the Schlumberger brothers at P6chelbronn in the A1-
51MPLE CONVEX TRAP
(BY FOLDING)
511dPLE CONVEX TRAP
(BY DIFFERENTIAL THICKNESS)
! .C
B
PERMEABILITY TRAP
C
PINCHOUT T R A P
F
FAULT
G
PIERCEMENT TRAP
C
Fig. 9. Correlation of electrical logs from the Midcontinent area in the USA. Logs of this type were invented in 1927 by the Schlumberger brothers (from LeRoy, 1951).
TRAP
POROUS BED
was based on recording the arrival at the surface of refracted waves originating from an explosion. This technique was developed during the World War I by
Fig. 10. Elementary reservoir traps from the classification of O. Wilhelm (1945).
K.J. Weber
8
Homoclinical ravines 4. Quaquaversal structures (domes) Domes and anticlines Domes on homoclines and monoclines - Closed salt domes Perforated salt domes Domal structures caused by igneous intrusions 5. Unconformities 6. Lenticular sands (on structure) 7. Crevices and cavities irrespective of the structure In limestone and dolomite In shales - In igneous rocks 8. Structures due to faulting On upthrown and downthrown sides - Overthrusts - Fault blocks Gradually it became clear that the anticlinal trapping theory had been given too much emphasis. Especially the discovery of the giant East Texas field in 1930 was seen as a demonstration of the importance of stratigraphic trapping. Actually, the word trap, as used in petroleum geology, was first introduced by McCollough in 1934, in an article on the influence of structure on the accumulation of petroleum in California (McCollough, 1934). Towards the end of this period, petroleum geologists were already starting to look back and a book on the historical development of the structural theory of the accumulation of oil and gas appeared (Howell, 1934). -
-
-
-
A (F} - I a
-
-
-
[A + B) - I a
rn(Al-Ia
re{B) - ] : a
-
Fig. 11. A set of composite and complex reservoirs with identifying symbols from O. Wilhelms classification (1945).
Classification and quantification, 1935-1955
sace (Gruner-Schlumberger, 1982). Electrical logging soon became an important oilfield method which not only helped to identify hydrocarbon bearing zones but also provided excellent correlations (Fig. 9). In 1931, a tool was invented to take reliable PVT sampies. Laboratory equipment was also improved and measurements of interfacial tension under in situ conditions became possible (Hocott, 1938; Livingston, 1938). Clapp (1910) proposed a classification of oilfields. He kept working on this system and eventually (Clapp, 1929) the following classification was proposed: 1. Anticlinical structures Normal anticlines - Broad geanticlinal folds - Overturned folds 2. Synclinical structures 3. Homoclinical structures - Structural terraces Homoclinical noses
At the end of the 1930s, a number of scientifically minded geologists took a hand in improving the understanding of the physical principles of migration and trapping. In 1941, Leverett published his famous paper on capillary behaviour in porous solids (Leverett, 1941). Hubbert studied dynamic trapping conditions (Hubbert, 1940, 1953). Very useful for the understanding of reservoir behaviour and sealing mechanism is Physical Principles of Oil Production, the classic work of Muskat (1949). This book contains an excellent discussion of capillary effects and also of the diffusion process. The efforts to classify every conceivable trapping configuration finds its culmination in the paper by Wilhelm (1945). He subdivided reservoirs into five groups: convex traps, permeability traps, pinch-out traps, fault traps and piercement traps. He constructed a set of diagrams illustrating all the various basic types (Fig. 10) and their numerous combinations (Fig. 11). With this classification, we can consider the recognition of trap types as
-
-
A historical overview of hydrocarbon trapping features
9
:-'~!~,~r-~jj
,',.~.,-. ~. , : . ~ .~. .~.
"r
-
~.~,w,r
.
-,&-n.,
~....~.._~ ~,. ....
~ ~
~
..
~
"'r
.... "':-.-
, ,~,,t~.,"Z.,_". ~.~,~.,~,S,
,,,,~,,,,~,..., . .
.
.
.
. ,,..,,,.
~
-I~
.-~-'~. ~i~-
9
a ~ , .~ # ~~t , ~-f l Tt / hv ' " ~ r .r' ~'t ~ t#'?'~'~.[
~10tt'7.'.,t,''",= "~'t*tt~ . . . . . . .
',-,~,ttttt,,,.~kl.Ltl~-t,-,,nn,-~-,
,el L(tt~-
.---~k~.t~.~,.,l~lO/t.~.t,~,
.,~J,'~'----~'-
~7. t , ' ~
..
Fig. 12. Photograph of a surface exposure of a fault iri east Texas. A sandstone is juxtaposed across a 180 m throw fault with another sandstone. The fault zone consists of about a meter wide soft clay (from Smith, Company Report).
complete if we take diagenetic trapping as a very rare case. Limitations to the proper analysis of accumulation conditions were still formed by poor seismic resolution, unreliable pressure measurements and lack of sophisticated geochemistry. Until the wireline formation tester had reached such a state of development that it could provide reliable and repeatable pressure measurements, it was often difficult to recognise either separate or connected accumulations in the more complicated structures. In this period, a start was made on the study of fault zones. On the Gulf Coast, it had already been noticed that faults can separate oil or gas accumulations from water-bearing sands. Hubbert, in deriving the theoretical concepts of petroleum trapping, had shown that the boundary of a reservoir rock is a barrier to hydrocarbon migration because of its capillary properties (Hubbert, 1953). Observations of fault zone material showed the effect of cataclasis but also the presence of smeared-in shale. One finds fairly extensive descriptions of fault
sealing in the books Petroleum Geology by Landes (1951) and Geology of Petroleum by Levorsen (1954). However, most observations were reported within the oil companies and the general literature does not reflect the actual knowledge of the time. An interesting attempt at quantification of trapping of oil and gas was published by Gussow (1954), who analysed the differential entrapment of oil and gas. Overpressures were still poorly understood and attributed to undercompaction of the sands or diagenesis (Waldschmidt, 1941).
Modern times After 1955, there was an avalanche of papers on trapping and the subject gradually reached a status that one can speak of as true quantification, with the possibility of making reliable predictions. Undoubtedly, the development of seismic methods made a very large impact in the delineation of trapping configurations. However, also outcrop observations and laboratory experiments contributed markedly to the
10
K.J. Weber
Fig. 13. Schematic section of a Nigerian field showing the migration and accumulation conditions (from Weber, 1987).
gave an excellent overview of his observations in an article on sealing and non-sealing faults in Louisiana (Smith, 1980). More recently there appeared a paper on outcrop studies of shale smears on fault surfaces (Lindsay et al., 1993). Research by Shell resulted in predictions of the sealing capacity of normal faults in sand/shale sequences (Bouvier et al., 1989). The research concluded that sealing capacity of a fault at a
understanding of trapping, especially of fault sealing phenomena. Experiments with shearing granular material (Mandl et al., 1977) and observations in active open pit mines (Weber et al., 1978) led to a good description of shale smearing into fault zones. This phenomenon had already been described by Smith (1966) in the Gulf Coast fields and outcrops (Fig. 12). He
"ACTIVE" SEALING
1.(Mechanical) of faultzone
Permeability reduction due to
properties
~
Formatlon of Clay Gouge (clay smear) Downward Intrusion of weaker materlal Cataclasls (Grain crushing)
Pressure solution 2. Dlagenetlc processes (associated w i t h f a u l t i n g )
J
. ..
Cementation of grains
Authlgenlc growth of clay minerals, etc "PASSIVE" SEALING
Juxtaposition of llthologles across the
Fig. 14. Fault sealing mechanisms.
fault
A historical overview of hydrocarbon trapping features
given point is a function of the squares of the thicknesses of the shales that passed by that point, divided by the distance to each shale. The integration of fault sealing and along fault migration into field models was used in both Nigeria (Weber, 1987) and Trinidad (Gibson, 1994). It is obvious that one must consider the structures and the hydrocarbon migration as a dynamic system in time (Fig. 13). A classic paper describing the evolution of migration and trapping in the Middle East was written by Murris (1980). The mechanics of secondary hydrocarbon migration and entrapment were treated in a comprehensive way by Schowalter (1979). Fault gouge resulting from faulting of brittle materials was the subject of several papers (Engelder, 1974; Pittman, 1981; Scholz, 1987). Scholz showed that the thickness of the gouge zone for brittle faults increases linearly with total slip. Considering the fault zone as a membrane, one can introduce some numerical values on interfacial tensions, permeabilities, columns and pressures, and describe the various resulting trapping or non-trapping configurations (Watts, 1987; Zieglar, 1992). An overview of the various fault sealing mechanisms recognised at present is shown in Fig. 14. In producing oil fields, useful data can be measured to aid in fault sealing studies. Maximum differential pressures across fault zones, pulse testing (Dake, 1982; Zung Huinong, 1984) and dipmeter logs (Mercadier and Livera, 1993) all give important in-
11
formation concerning fault zone properties. The increase in the number of horizontal wells is also resuiting in a large number of fault penetrations at angles which allow a better analysis of fault zones (Nurmi et al., 1994). The use of gas chromatography is now common practice in many areas. This method is particularly useful in studying the origin of oils and, hence, migration pathways, but also to clearly recognise separation between adjacent reservoirs (Kaufman et al., 1990; Nederlof et al., 1994). In 1990, the first conference on cap-rocks was held in London but no significant new concepts emerged at that time. An overview of the cap-rock problem in all oil provinces was compiled by Grunau (1987). The objective was to investigate geological aspects of the cap-rock problem to provide guidelines for assessing the sealing and retention risk in exploration ventures. Again, it is important to place the cap-rocks in the framework of a hydrocarbon habitat with its alterations with time, taking into account geomechanical deformation, faulting and rate of diffusion through the cap-rocks. The present status of the trapping theories has been summarized in Fig. 15. Most of the configurations are well understood but still very difficult to quantify. There is a need for continued research on trapping and sealing phenomena comprising outcrop studies, field monitoring, core analysis, borehole imaging, analysis of cap-rocks, geochemistry, and detailed
,I
w,T. oar - .ocK _
1
CONTROLLED BY ENTRY PRESSURE OF LARGEST INTERCONNECTED PORE THROAT (ONCE THICKNESS EXCEEDS CRITICAL SLUG PINCH - OFF LENGTH )
1
FOR INFINITE ENTRY PRESSURE OF C A P - ROCK (eg. SALT~ ANHYDRITE )~ SEAL CAPACITY RELATED TO= o ) MINIMUM HORIZONTAL EFFECTIVE STRESS (TO WITHOLD HYDROCARBON COLUMN PRIOR TO FRACTURING ) b) THICKNES (OFTEN INDICATES LATERAL CONTINUITY + RELATION TO FRACTURE C O N T I N U I T Y )
1
CONTROLLED BY ENTRY PRESSURE OF LARGEST INTERCONNECTED PORE THROAT ACROSS FAULT PLANE
SEAL MECHANISMS INCLUDE : a ) CLAY SMEAR b ) CATACLASIS c ) DIAGENETIC HEALING
Fig. 15. Overview of sealing mechanisms.
,T.ouT car
1
"OCK i
CONTROLLED BY EXCESS HYDRODYNAMIC HEAD ABOVE ACCUMULATION. HYDROCARBON COLUMN REACHES EQUILIBRIUM LENGTH WHEN U P W A R D / DOWNWARD FLOW FORCES EQUAL
12
K.J. Weber
Fig. 16. Examples of perched hydrocarbon-water contracts in Borneo and the UK offshore (from Weber, 1995).
seismic studies of cap-rocks and faults. A good example of the use of seismic data for fault sealing prediction is the paper by Bouvier et al. (1989), describing the three-dimensional modelling of fault throw and shale smearing for a field in Nigeria. Finally, there is still a trapping configuration which, although quite common, is often overlooked or misunderstood, the so-called perched water-contact (Johnson et al., 1986; Weber, 1995). This occurs when a reservoir has a U-tube shape with a fault seal or a pinch-out at the closed end. The water cannot escape from this side of the U-tube resulting in different hydrocarbon-water contacts in the same reservoir. In the North Sea, we find perched oil-water contacts in Fulmar (Fig. 16), Tern, Ulla and Logger fields, but there are probably many more cases.
Conclusions The physical principles of the trapping of oil and gas are well established but quantification remains problematic in many cases. Consequently, the trapping capacity of structures and the retention of hydrocarbons with time is difficult to predict in exploration ventures. In a production setting, with a number of similar fields, the situation is much more favourable for the quantification of sealing capacity. There is still too little attention being paid to the four-dimensional aspects of migration and trapping. In some places we are looking at remigrated oil, trapped after several phases of deformation, while in other cases we are dealing with active migration and accumulations which have not reached equilibrium conditions. Thus, there is a large scope for additional research covering virtually the entire range of trapping mechanisms. Much data will have to be derived from wellstudied producing fields and this is a subject in which
exploration and production geologists must cooperate
closely. References Bouvier, J.D., Kaars-Sijpesteijn, C.D., Kluesner D.F., Onyejekwe, C.C. and van der Pal, R.C. 1989. Three-dimensional seismic interpretation and fault sealing investigations, Nun River field, Nigeria. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 73: 1397-1414. Clapp, F.G. 1910. A proposed classification of petroleum and natural gas fields. Econ. Geol., 5: 503-521. Clapp, F.G. 1929. Role of geologic structure in the accumulation of petroleum. In: Structure of Typical American Oil Fields, Vol. 2. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol., Tulsa, OK, pp. 667-716. Dake, L.P. 1982. Application of the repeat formation tester in vertical and horizontal pulse testing in the Middle Jurassic Brent Sands. Paper EUR 270, Proc. Eur. Offshore Pet. Conf. 1982. Engelder, J.T. 1974. Cataclasis and the generation of fault gouge. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull., 85: 1515-1522. Forbes, R.J. and O'Beime, D.R. 1957. The Technical Development of the Royal Dutch/Shell, 1890-1940. E.J. Brill, Leiden. Gerritson, C. 1939. Geschiedenis der Koninklijke, 3 Vols. N.V.A. Oosthoeks's Uitgeverij, Utrecht. Gibson, R.G. 1994, Fault-zone seals in siliciclastic strata of the Columbus Basin, offshore Trinidad. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 78: 13721385. Grunau, H.R. 1987. A worldwide look at the cap-rock problem. J. Pet. Geol., 10: 245-266. Gruner-Schlumberger, A. 1982. The Schlumberger Adventure. Arco, New York. Gussow, W.C. 1954. Differential entrapment of oil and gas: a fundamental principle. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 38: 816-853. Hager, D. 1915. Practical Oil Geology. McGraw-Hill, New York. Hocott, C.R. 1938. Interfacial tension between water and oil under reservoir conditions, AIME Pet. Trans., 32:184-190. Howell, J.V. 1934. Historical development of structural theory of accumulation of oil and gas. In: Problems of Petroleum Geology. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol., Tulsa, OK, pp. 1-23. Hubbert, M.K. 1940. The theory of ground-water motion. J. Geol., 48: 785-944. Hubbert, M.K. 1953. Entrapment of petroleum under hydrodynamic conditions. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 37: 1954-2026. Johnson, H.D., Mackay, T.A. and Stewart, D.J. 1986. The Fulmar oilfield (Central North Sea): geological aspects of its discovery, appraisal and development. Mar. Pet. Geol., 3:99-125. Kaufman, R.L., Ahmed, A.S. and Elsinger, R.L. 1990. Gas chromatog-
A historical overview of hydrocarbon trapping features raphy as a development and production tool for fingerprinting oils from individual reservoirs: applications in the Gulf of Mexico, Gulf Coast Section of the Soc. Econ. Paleont. and Min. Foundation, 9th Annual Research Conf. Proc., pp. 263-282. Landes, K.K. 1951. Petroleum Geology. Chapman and Hall, London and Wiley, New York. LeRoy, L.W. 1951. Subsurface Geologic Methods (A Symposium). Colorado School of Mines, Department of Publications, Golden, CO. Leverett, M.C. 1941. Capillary behaviour in porous solids, AIME Pet. Trans., 142: 152-169. Levorsen, A.I. 1954. Geology of Petroleum. W.H. Freeman, San Francisco, CA. Lindsay, N.G., Murphy, F.C., Walsh, J.J. and Watterson, J. 1993. Outcrop studies of shale smears on fault surfaces. Int. Assoc. Sedimentol. Special Publication, 15:113-123. Livingston, H.K. 1938. Surface and interfacial tension of oil-water systems in Texas oil sands. Pet. Technol., 1: 1-13. Lytle, W.S. 1957. John F. Carll. Geotimes, 1: 8-14. Mandl, G., de Jong, L.N.J. and Maltha, A. 1977. Shear zones in granular material. An experimental study of their structure and mechanical genesis. Rock Mech., 9: 209-221. McCollough, E.H. 1934. Structural influence on the accumulation of petroleum in California. In: Problems of Petroleum Geology. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol., Tulsa, OK, pp. 735-760. Mercadier, C.G.L. and Livera, S.E. 1993. Applications of the formation micro-scanner to modelling of Palaeozoic reservoirs in Oman. In: S.S. Flint and I.D. Bryant (Editors), Spec. Publ. Int. Ass. Sediment., no. 15. Blackwell Science, pp. 125-142. Murris, R.J. 1980. Middle East stratigraphic evolution and oil habitat. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 64:597-618. Muskat, M. 1949. Physical Principles of Oil Production. McGraw-Hill, New York. Nederlof, P.J.R., Gijsen, M.A. and Doyle, M.A. 1994. Application of reservoir geochemistry to field appraisal. In: M.I. A1-Husseini (Editor), Geo'94, The Middle East Petroleum Geosciences, Vol. II. Gulf Petrolink, pp. 709-722. Nurmi, R., Wiltse, E., Sapru, A. and Akbar, M. 1994. Geological characterisation of horizontal wells during and after drilling. In: M.I. AIHusseini (Editor), Geo'94, The Middle East Petroleum Geosciences, Vol. II. Gulf Petrolink, pp. 724-736.
K.J. WEBER
13 Owen, E.W. 1957. Trek of the oil finders: a history of exploration for petroleum. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Memoir, 6. Pittman, E.D. 1981. Effect of fault-related granulation of porosity and permeability of quartz sandstones, Simpson Group (Ordovician), Oklahoma. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 65: 2381-2387. Scholz, C.H. 1987. Wear and gouge formation in brittle faulting. Geology, 15: 493-495. Schowalter, T.T. 1979. Mechanics of secondary hydrocarbon migration and entrapment. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 63: 723-760. Smith, D.A. 1966. Theoretical considerations of sealing and non-sealing faults. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 50: 363-374. Smith, D.A. 1980. Sealing and non-sealing faults in Louisiana Gulf Coast salt basin. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 64: 145-172. Waldschmidt, W.A. 1941. Cementing materials in sandstones and probable influence of migration and accumulation of oil and gas. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 25: 1839-1879. Watts, N.L. 1987. Theoretical aspects of cap-rock and fault seals for single- and two-phase hydrocarbon columns. Mar. Pet. Geol., 4: 274-307. Weber, K.J. 1987. Hydrocarbon distribution pattems in Nigerian growth fault structures controlled by structural style and stratigraphy. J. Pet. Sci. Eng., 1: 91-104. Weber, K.J. 1995. Perched hydrocarbon-water contacts- a common but poorly understood phenomenon. In: Extended Abstracts, Vol. 2, F035, 7th EAPG Conf. and Tech. Exhib., Glasgow, UK. EAPG Business Office, Zeist, pp. 1-2. Weber, K.J., Mandl, G., Pilaar, W.F., Lehner, F. and Precious, R.G. 1978. The role of faults in hydrocarbon migration and trapping in Nigerian growth fault structures. Offshore Conf., Houston, TX, Paper OTC 3356. White, I.C., 1885. The geology of natural gas. Science, 5: 521-522. Wilhelm, O. 1945. Classification of petroleum reservoirs. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 29: 1537-1580. Zieglar, D.L. 1992. Hydrocarbon columns, buoyancy pressures, and seal efficiency: comparisons of oil and gas accumulations in California and the Rocky Mountains area. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 76: 501-508. Zung Huinong, 1984. Interference testing and pulse testing in the Kenli carbonate oil pool - a case history. J. Pet. Technol., 1009-1017.
Faculty of Applied Earth Sciences, Delft University of Technology, P.O. Box 5028, 2600 GA Delft, The Netherlands
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
15
Fault seal analysis: successful methodologies, application and future directions R.J. Knipe, Q.J. Fisher, G. Jones, M.R. Clennell, A.B. Farmer, A. Harrison, B. Kidd, E. McAIlister, J.R. Porter and E.A. White
Fault seal prediction in hydrocarbon reservoirs requires an understanding of fault seal mechanisms, fault rock petrophysical properties, the spatial distribution of seals, and seal stability. The properties and evolution of seals within fault zones can be evaluated using the combined results of structural core logging, microstructural and physical property characterisation, together with information on fault populations from seismic and outcrop studies and well test data. The important structural elements of fault zones which require characterisation are: the microstructural/petrophysical properties of the different fault rocks present; the population of faults and fractures which define damage zones around large faults; the spatial distribution, orientation and clustering of the deformation in individual fault zones; the history of fault activity, diagenesis and migration; the distribution and volume of fault rocks with different properties. Fault rocks in siliclastic sequences range from quartz-rich cataclasites, developed from pure sandstones, to phyllosilicate smears developed from shales. Fault rocks developed along sand/sand fault juxtapositions can have transmissibility reduction factors of > 106. The exact value depends upon the conditions of faulting and the amount of self-sealing experienced by the fault rock. An important class of intermediate fault rocks are those generated from impure sandstones, or from sandstones with concentrations of fine phyllosilicate laminations. The localisation of cement precipitation within the damage zone may occur, which will remove the applicability of simple seal prediction based only on the host-rock lithology and fault displacement. The density of structures present in damage zones around faults is related to the cumulative displacement across the zone. The detailed internal structure of a fault zone is dependent on the conditions of deformation, the lithological architecture present and the position in the fault array. Successful seal analyses depends upon the amalgamation of data from the micro-scale to the macro-scale. This review demonstrates that improvements in fault seal risk evaluation are possible. The future directions for improving fault seal risk evaluation are also discussed. The most critical of these are; characterisation of the internal structure of fault zones, generation of a database for fault rock petrophysical properties and incorporation of the impact of realistic fault zone geometries into reservoir modelling programs.
Introduction
The fault seal problem Fault sealing is now recognised as one of the key factors controlling hydrocarbon reservoir trapping and behaviour during production (Bouvier et al., 1989; Harding and Tuminas, 1989; Knipe, 1992a; Gauthier and Lake, 1993; Berg and Avery, 1995). Fault seal represents a significant unknown in any risk analysis associated with both hydrocarbon exploration and development strategies. Characterisation of the properties and distribution of structural heterogeneities, which can form barriers to fluid flow, is a prerequisite for detailed reservoir simulation. Despite the acknowledged importance of fault behaviour to reservoir management and development, as well to the role of faults during hydrocarbon migration, the detailed properties of faults remains poorly defined. This paper reviews the critical limitations which re-
strict present fault seal evaluation and identifies a number of methodologies and approaches which can improve the understanding of fault seal processes and significantly reduce the risk associated with fault seal prediction.
Towards solving fault seal issues The fundamental concepts needed for understanding fault sealing and trapping of hydrocarbons were introduced and reviewed by Smith (1966, 1980), Schowalter, (1979), Watts, (1987), Allan (1989) and Bouvier et al. (1989). A recent renewed interest in the behaviour of faults has resulted in a number of approaches to assessing different aspects of fault sealing (Knipe, 1992a, 1993a,b; Jev et al., 1993; Knott, 1993; Gibson, 1994; Berg and Avery, 1995). Fig. 1 outlines the important components needed for fault seal evaluation. The evaluation route shown emphasises that a range of different elements have to
Hydrocarbon Seals: Importancefor Exploration and Production edited by P. M~ller-Pedersen and A.G. Koestler. NPF Special Publication 7, pp. 15-40, Elsevier, Singapore. 9 Norwegian Petroleum Society (NPF) 1997
16
R.J. Knipe et al.
Define geometry of fault array
Establish sub-seismic
fault density and fault zone structure
I I Map seal distributions Test models against I I on fault planes which ~ hydrocarbon contact ~-'~might form compartment levels if known 1 ~ 1 boundaries
Assess sealing mechanisms and fault rock properties
Evaluate critical juxtapositions and seal distributions
I Model reservoir flow and the impact of faults on drainage I Fig. 1. Outline of the important components in a fault seal evaluation.
be combined in order to assess the fault sealing potential. Each of these components carries its own resolution limits and sources of error. One of the limitations of fault seal analysis has been the complex nature of the variables involved and the difficulty in accurately defining each of the important factors. Calibration of any method is dependent upon the ability to separate the impact of individual components in the analysis and the need to include all the critical variables. The lack of data on the accurate characterisation of fault zones and fault properties has resulted in the adoption of a number of assumptions about faults which are not always applicable and have resulted in the exclusion of a number of important factors from fault seal risk evaluations. Such omissions have reduced the success of fault seal analysis and generated a perception that risk evaluation is impossible rather than difficult. Recent progress in understanding faulting processes (Scholz 1989; Cowie et al., 1993; Sibson, 1994), fault rock evolution (Knipe, 1989), fault geometry (Peacock and Sanderson, 1994), fault populations (Gillespie et al., 1993; Cowie et al., 1996) and improved analysis of reservoir hydrodynamics as well as new core recovery techniques and the capabilities of 3D seismic, all provide a platform for improving the understanding of fault seal. The data available to the geoscientist, geophysicist and reservoir engineer now allow a new level of integration needed to develop and test different methodologies of fault seal evaluation. The challenge is to make use of these advances and to identify the best practices which lead to a more cost-effective and accurate prediction of faulting related influences on hydrocarbon reservoir behaviour. The critical questions which now require evaluation in order to advance fault seal analysis are listed below: - Can fault rock properties be predicted?
-
Can sub-seismic fault zone structures and population characteristics be predicted? Can fault seal distributions be mapped? What is involved in fault seal risk analysis and what future requirements can be defined?
The structure of this paper Each of the questions listed above forms a subsection of this paper. A review of the recent advances in these areas, the requirements for answering the questions, and likely limitations to present solutions are discussed. The final section of the paper integrates these different aspects into a discussion of the risks associated with fault seal evaluation, and attempts to identify the future directions which will help remove the present limitations.
Prediction of fault rock properties Without a detailed understanding of the fundamental processes which control the evolution of fault rocks and their properties, the prediction of sealing capacity and the evaluation of the behaviour of a faulted reservoir will never be anything more than speculative.
Critical information required for fault-rock property evaluation Surprising little has been published on the detailed physical properties or microstructural evolution of fault rocks in hydrocarbon reservoirs. Recent papers which have begun to address this aspect of sealing include: analysis of clay smears (Knipe 1992a, 1994; Berg and Avery, 1995), cataclasites from pure sandstones (Pitman, 1981; Underhill and Woodcock, 1987; Antonellini and Aydin, 1994; Fowles and Burley, 1994), and deformation in impure sandstones
Fault seal analysis: successful methodologies, application and future directions
(Sverdrup and Bjcrlykke, 1992; Gibson, 1994). A detailed evaluation of fault-rock properties requires the integration of microstructural information on the deformation mechanism history of fault rocks with quantification of the porosity, pore geometry and pore aperture distributions, which control the capillary entry pressure characteristics. Such an analysis should involve the use of electron microscope based techniques (especially BSEM and CL) for detailed microstructural analysis. In addition, equipment capable of accurately measuring low (>>0.01 mD) permeabilities is required. Some of the studies reported in the literature listed above have not used techniques which allow clear resolution of the important microstructural elements or have been restricted by the measurement ability of equipment used for petrophysical property determination. Without such information, the identification of the origin and controls of seal petrophysical properties may be impossible, because the type of (and timing of) deformation processes which control the pore characteristics and the strength, of the fault-rocks remain poorly defined.
Fault seal processes The fundamental processes which result in the development of fault related permeability barriers have been reviewed by Mitra (1988) and Knipe (1989, 1992a, 1993a,b). There are five groups of processes which can operate individually or which may combine to alter the pore structure during or after deformation events. These processes are briefly reviewed below. (a) Deformation induced porosity collapse by
disaggregation, mixing and grain boundary sliding without large scale cataclasis. This group of processes dominates deformation of unconsolidated or unlithified material and is therefore characteristic of the deformation at shallow depths of burial. The processes result in the reorganisation of grain packing, redistribution of phyllosilicate material from peloids or lamina to a more homogeneous micro-fabric, and may involve the introduction of new fine-grained phyllosilicate material by fluid flow. The replacement of macroporosity with microporosity induces a permeability decrease and a change in the pore aperture sizes. In addition, the changes in the structure of the deformed material can alter the response of such early formed faults to later deformation events. For example, the lower grain size and concentration of phyllosilicates can induce pressure solution, or diffusive mass transfer, and create an effective seal which postdates the initial fault event. (b) Diffusive mass transfer. This process involves the redistribution of material away from sites of high
17
stress by dissolution, transport and precipitation (Rutter, 1983; Dewers and Ortoleva, 1990; Spiers et al. 1990; Mullis, 1993). The rate of diffusive mass transfer in lithified rocks is particularly enhanced by small grain sizes and the presence of phyllosilicates at grain contacts is therefore an important factor in the modification of fault rock properties following cataclasis in fault zones (see Knipe, 1993a,b). (c) Cataclasis. Processes which induce grain size reduction by fracturing are grouped together as cataclasis (Aydin, 1978; Antonellini and Aydin, 1994; Knipe and Lloyd, 1994), and dominate the deformation associated with faulting in lithified rocks. (d) Cementation. Faults may act as conduits for fluid flow during deformation (Burley et al., 1989; Carter et al., 1990; Knipe et al., 1991; Sibson, 1994) and are therefore susceptible to mineralisation. In addition, the higher rates of diffusive mass transfer in fine-grained cataclasites, as well as the concentration of local dilation sites, render fault zones susceptible to "self-sealing" processes via local dissolution and precipitation processes. (e) Clay or phyllosilicate smearing. This is a general term used to describe deformation induced shearing of clays or phyllosilicates (Smith, 1980; Bouvier et al., 1989; Gibson, 1994). Lindsay et al. (1993) have identified three types of clay smear associated with: (i) abrasion by movement past sandstones; (ii) shearing and ductile deformation between hanging-wall and footwall cut-offs of shale beds; and (iii) injection of clays during fluidisation. Knipe (1992a) and Gibson (1994) have recognised that the deformation of impure sandstones, with either high phyllosilicate contents or concentrations of phyllosilicate-rich lamina, can also give rise to micro-clay smears and emphasise that discrete shale beds are not a prerequisite for clay smear formation.
Fault seal types and faulting processes? The terminology and classification of fault-rocks and seal types is not yet universally agreed (Knipe, 1992a; Knott, 1993). The classification presented below is based on identification of the main process responsible for the reduction in permeability associated with the faults. Mechanistic terms have been combined with textural descriptive terms to provide a more expansive nomenclature system which covers the most common fault rocks and seal types. The fault seal types and associated fault-rock types can be divided into two broad categories: (a) Juxtaposition seals. These seals are associated with the cross-fault juxtaposition of lithologies with different petrophysical properties, e.g., sand on shale or sand on cemented unit.
18
(b) Fault rock seals. These seals are associated with the type of fault rock developed during deformation. Their development is primarily dependent upon the original host rock lithology, the deformation processes, and conditions as well as the amount of cementation involved. The seals can be sub-divided into seven types reviewed below (see also Fig. 2): 1. Cemented faults and fractures: The main porosity reduction mechanism is cementation (Fig. 2a). Cementation is taken here to cover situations where cements have developed from (i) fluids flowing along the fault zone, or (ii) preferential growth in cataclasites because of the high concentration of nucleation sites on the newly created fracture surfaces. 2. Phyllosilicate/clay smears: These are developed by the deformation of material with high concentrations of phyllosilicates. The type and continuity of the clay smear (Fig. 2b) depends on the architecture or proximity of the shale units, the lithification state of the phyllosilicate rich units at the time of deformation and the amount of shearing or fault offset. 3. Framework - phyllosilicate fault rocks: This class of fault rock, developed in impure or immature sandstones (with low framework silicate to phyllosilicate ratios) where the clay/phyllosilicate content is in the r a n g e - 1 5 % to -40%. These rocks can develop seals by a combination of shearing, smearing and mixing of detrital clays/ phyllosilicates, enhanced pressure solution during the late stages (or after) faulting, cataclasis, and finally the precipitation of new phyllosilicates (see Fig. 2c). 4. Framework - phyllosilicate/microcrystalline quartz fault rocks: This class of fault rock is introduced here to describe fault rocks which form in sediments with concentrations (>20%) of dissolvable sponge spicules and varying amounts (15-40%) of phyllosilicates (Fig. 2d). Although not common, sediments with high sponge spicules contents are prone to the development of fault rocks by the cataclasis, dissolution and reprecipitation of silica. The process may be initiated by the collapse of secondary pores created by spicule dissolution and induce the redistribution of more soluble material " by mixing.
R.J. Knipe et al.
5. Cataclasites developed in clean, mature sandstones with less than - 1 5 % cIay/phyllosilicate material. The evolution of these fault rocks is
dominated by grain fracturing and gives rise to zones sometimes referred to as granulation seams, cataclastic seams or deformation zones. Cataclasites can be divided into three types depending on the degree of lithification (Knipe 1992a, 1993b). Firstly, weakly lithified cataclasites, (Fig. 2e) which show little or no evidence of post-faulting compaction/cementation and which are dominated by point contacts between angular fracture fragments. Secondly, partially lithified cataclasites (Fig. 2f), characterised by some compaction and precipitation processes. Thirdly, lithified cataclasites (Fig. 2g), composed of interlocking grains formed by dissolution/precipitation processes. This sequence controls the evolution of fault rock petrophysical properties developed in sand on sand faults discussed in the next section of the paper. The degree of lithification is controlled by the extent of the grain size reduction, the amount of pressure solution, the amount of post-deformation quartz cementation by self-sealing processes, the conditions (pressure, temperature) of deformation and the timing of deformation relative to hydrocarbon emplacement. 6. Disaggregation zones are formed where no or little grain fracturing occurs during the deformation (Fig. 2h). These can develop as deformation bands in unlithified or poorly consolidated lithologies and in general do not form effective barriers to flow in sandstones with clay/phyllosilicate contents below - 15%.
Properties of different fault rock/seal types Fundamental to a successful fault seal analysis is quantification of the petrophysical properties of the different fault rocks present in the hydrocarbon field under investigation. The critical properties which require quantification are permeabilities, capillary entry pressures, transmissibility, fault-rock thickness and the strength of the fault rocks. One of the reasons why fault seal analysis and reservoir modelling has proved difficult has been the absence of data on these properties. Analysis of the petrophysical properties of
Fig. 2. Microstructures of fault seals. (a) Cemented fault zone where the main porosity reduction mechanism is cementation. (b) Phyllosilicate/clay smears formed by the deformation induced alignment of phyllosilicates. (c) Framework-phyllosilicate fault rock developed in impure or immature sandstones. Note the shearing, smearing and mixing of detrital clays/phyllosilicates, the elongate fabric created by pressure solution the as well as the generation of a fine-grained matrix formed by cataclasis. (d) Framework-phyllosilicate/microcrystalline quartz fault rock formed in a sediment with concentrations (>20%) of dissolvable sponge spicules. (e) Weakly lithified cataclasite with little or no evidence of post-faulting compaction/cementation and dominated by point contacts between angular fracture fragments. (f) Partially lithified cataclasites, characterised by some compaction and lithification by dissolution-precipitation processes. (g) Lithified cataclasite, composed of a low permeability interlocking array of grains formed by dissolution and precipitation processes. (h) Disaggregation zone formed in unlithified or poorly lithified sediment, where no or little grain fracturing occurs during the deformation.
Fault seal analysis: successful methodologies, application and future directions
19
20
R.J. Knipe et al.
Fault seal analysis: successful methodologies, application and future directions
21
22
R.J. Knipe et al.
Fault seal analysis: successful methodologies, application and future directions 10000 []
I000 -
DD
[] 100 -
9
[]
[]
_~D H~ []
[]
[]
[]
mD
I
[] 9 ""
9
1-
Eo.1El.
9 Cataclasites 0.01-
9
Undeformed [] s a n d s t o n e s
_Hi 0"001 l 0.0001, 0
t
I
I
I
I
5
10
15
20
25
Porosity
(%)
30
Fig. 3. Porosity-permeability plot of cataclastic fault rocks developed from sandstones with low (<6%) clay contents. Note the values extend over six orders of magnitude.
more than 300 fault rocks by the Rock Deformation Research group from over 25 hydrocarbon fields in the North Sea has allowed the construction of a database on fault rocks developed in different host sediments under different conditions and with different geohistories. Presentation of the results of these analysis is not possible in this short contribution. However, some of the important trends and themes which emerge from these analyses which have general implications for fault seal analysis are outlined below. (a) Cataclastic fault rocks developed from sandstones with low (<10-15%) clay content can have permeability values which extend over six orders of magnitude (Fig. 3). This is extremely important to fault seal analysis as it is often assumed that sand on sand faults (i.e., cataclastic fault rocks) leak. This is not a viable assumption for fault seal analysis as the sealing capacity of the low permeability (<<0.001 mD) cataclastic fault rocks can be -- 1000 m and equivalent to the cap-rock lithologies. The factors which control the exact values for particular cataclastic rocks are related to the geohistory experienced by the specimen, particularly the conditions of deformation, the depth of burial and the timing with respect to the hydrocarbon influx. Permeability measurements of cataclastic fault rocks reported in the literature are often quoted as being much higher than the values reported here. This is considered to reflect in part the inability of standard permeability equipment used to accurately measure permeabilities below 0.1 mD. (b) Impure sandstones with clay contents of between --15% and -40% form an important, but neglected, class of fault rocks which can form effective seals (see also Knipe 1992a; Gibson, 1994). This conclusion means that a simple fault seal analysis,
23
which considers the potential of clay smearing in sediment/reservoir sequences, based only on the distribution and proximity of shale units may be inaccurate. A more detailed analysis of the small scale (--cm to m) distribution of phyllosilicate rich units as well as impure sandstones is needed for accurate assessment of fault rock properties. (c) Fault rocks often show complex entry pressure characteristics which do not allow the accurate representation of this property by a single pressure value. Fig. 4 shows some representative mercury injection curves for two different fault rocks. The data emphasise that while a single entry pressure does describe the properties of material with a simple pore structure, the complex mixing of grain and pore sizes in impure sandstones and some cataclastic and phyllosilicate framework fault rocks generates a pressure curve which reflects a membrane behaviour. In this case the ability to retard flow will depend upon the pressure conditions imposed on the material. Accurate modelling of reservoirs containing such fault rocks will require inclusion of membrane behaviour. (d) Cement seals associated with faults are not uncommon. The presence of cemented fault zones renders incorrect the common assumption that prediction of fault rock properties can be based on an evaluation of the host rocks juxtaposed by faulting. An assessment of fault propagation into stratigraphic units, which can provide sources for cements (tip-tapping (Knipe, 1993a), using seismic data, or microstructural analysis of core material) is needed to evaluate the potential for cement seals (see e.g., Leveille et al., 1997). (e) Inversion or fault reactivation has a complex influence on sealing behaviour with both seal enhancement and breakdown occurring. (f) Fault rock seals have a wide range of lithification states and therefore a wide range of strengths. The strength of the fault rocks will control the changes in the flow properties in response to changes in the stress conditions applied to the reservoir. Very few studies have considered integration of microstructural and rock mechanics testing programmes with well test data to evaluate the importance of these factors in reservoir management.
Improved prediction of fault rock properties Each of the points made in the last section above highlights the complex interaction of variables which can control the final properties of fault rocks. The list also demonstrates that although a difficult problem, understanding of fault rock behaviour is possible if systematic investigations of fault rock evolution are
24
R.J. Knipe et al.
Fig. 4. Capillary pressure curves for two fault rocks. The data emphasise that while a single entry pressure does describe the properties of material with a simple pore structure, e.g., (a), the complex mixing of grain and pore sizes in the cataclastic shown in (b) generates a more complex pressure curve where a single characteristic entry pressure is more difficult to define, i.e., reflects more of a membrane behaviour.
undertaken. The creation of a database on the fault rock products from different host lithologies deformed under various conditions is clearly a vital component in fault seal analysis. The following list of points is important to the improvement of fault seal analysis and the reduction of risks associated with the quantification and prediction of fault rock petrophysical properties. - Microstructural studies have an important role in identifying and characterising the sealing mechanisms, and the diagenetic timing associated with fault activity (including reactivation) in particular fields and regions. Analysis which does not make use of available core material carries a higher risk of inaccurate and poorly constrained fault seal analysis. - The role of impure sandstones in generating flow barriers has been largely ignored (see however, Knipe, 1992a; Gibson, 1994). The critical role of the clay content in fault rock development can be assessed more accurately if phyllosilicate content logs are generated from sedimentary analysis of reservoir stratigraphies. Note that down-hole tool information on phyllosilicate contents may require careful inteqaretation and/or validation against core material as the detection of some minerals (e.g., kaolinite) may not be a simple process. - Accurate permeability measurements of fault rocks as well as characterisation of capillary entry pressure data of fault rocks requires different equipment and procedures than those applicable to
high permeability well sorted sandstones with large and unimodal pore size distributions.
Prediction of sub-seismic fault zone structures and populations
Why is the sub-seismic fault population important ? A large proportion of the structural features which can impact on the flow properties of a reservoir are below the resolution of seismic data. Therefore, understanding the spatial distribution and internal structure of fault zones can be fundamental to the flow behaviour of hydrocarbon reservoirs. This section reviews the important geometrical characteristics of fault zones and sub-seismic deformation features which can influence fault seal analysis. Two aspects of sub-seismic fault arrays are particularly important. Firstly, the recent recognition that some fault geometrical characteristics appear to be fractal (Sornette et al., 1990; Walsh and Watterson, 1992; Gillespie et al., 1993; Hatton et al., 1994; Yielding et al., 1996) raises the possibility of predicting sub-seismic fault patterns from seismic data for input into reservoir modelling. Secondly, the internal structure of individual fault zones needs characterisation because this influences the distribution of fault rocks and juxtapositions. Information on both these aspects of fault seal analysis can be obtained from core material recovered from drilling pro-
Fault seal analysis: successful methodologies, application and future directions
grammes. The data presented in this section are based on the analysis of >25 km of core from North Sea reservoirs and onshore outcrop studies of exposed faults.
Is the structure of fault zones usually assumed in fault seal analysis valid and what is the impact of fault damage zones? A common but important assumption made about faults during many fault seal analysis is that the seismically defined throw represents the magnitude of throw on a single fault. This assumption is valid for locating the general position of large structural discontinuities and assessing the overall fault displacement and coherency but can be incorrect for detailed flow or fault seal analysis. That fault zones are composed of clusters of deformation features which surround (or form a halos to) large offset faults has been recognised for some time (e.g., Engelder, 1974; Chester and Logan, 1986; Wallace and Morris, 1986). The importance of these damage zones to fault seal analysis in hydrocarbon reservoirs was highlighted by Knipe (1992b, 1994). The impact of the damage zones on fault seal are reviewed in Fig. 5. The pri-
Fig. 5. Cartoon of the main structural elements of a fault damage zone. The zone is composed of a clusters of deformation features around a large offset fault. Note that the juxtapositions present differ from those which would be present if only a single fault was present and that the presence of an array of deformation features can induce the development of micro-compartments or sealed cells in the fault zone.
25
mary influences of damage zones on fault seal and reservoir behaviour analysis are: The juxtapositions inferred by using a single fault model are different from those associated with a cluster of smaller faults. - The volume of deformed rocks around faults can affect the volume of reservoir with recoverable hydrocarbons. - The presence of an array of deformation features rather than a single fault can influence the changes in cross- or along-fault communication induced by reactivation events. -
What fault zone properties need to be incorporated into a robust fault seal analysis? A robust fault seal analysis requires incorporation of information on the internal architecture of large fault zones. The important factors include the population, the clustering and the orientation distribution of faults present close to the largest fault. An example of the complexity of a fault damage zone is shown in Fig. 6a. The illustration is of a seismic attribute map (dip magnitude) and shows that the fault zone is composed of linked segments and domains where different sub-structures are present. The intemal structure of the northem and southern segments is made up of anastomosing faults which enclose lenses of more intact reservoir. The central segment has fewer faults and appears to be composed of a smaller number of faults with larger throws. It is also interesting to note that a concentration of low amplitude discontinuities occur on the esstern side of the fault and probably represent the accomodation zone of small structures. The width of this zone increases towards the central (high displacement) portions of individual segments. Fig. 6b illustrates the type of simple interpretation of the fault structure often used as a basis of fault seal analysis. This interpretation is based on representation of the fault as a single fault plane, where the offset is assumed to be equal to the seismic (cumulative) offset. This is clearly not valid as a representation of throw distributions for use in fault seal analysis. Fig. 6 also illustrates that sub-seismic fault populations can be clustered around larger faults with extensive areas of low fault densities away from the large faults. This has important implications for the spatial distribution of sub-seismic faults and emphasises that uniform distributions of small faults are not always applicable (except perhaps in areas where more uniform straining is associated with doming). The information contained in Fig. 6 reinforces the results of other recent studies which have noted different fault
R.J. Knipe et al.
26
Fig. 6. (a) An example of the complex architecture of a fault damage zone as imaged on a seismic attribute map (dip magnitude in this case). Note that the fault zone is composed of linked segments and domains where different sub-structures are present. (b) The simple interpretation of the fault zone which would be misleading if used as a basis for fault seal analysis.
architecture associated with fault segment structures or domains (Cartwright et al., 1996), relay zones (Peacock and Sanderson, 1994), and tip zones (McGrath and Davison, 1995). It is also clear that attribute mapping from high-quality 3D seismic surveys offers an important direction for the future characterisation of fault segment and damage zone geometries (see Jones and Knipe, 1996).
What are the important characteristics of fault damage zones? Damage zones represent the accommodation of strain around large faults, and are the products of fault propagation, displacement and linking processes operating during the growth of the zone. It is important to recognise that the damage zone is the final product of the total history of strain accumulation in the volume around the fault and should therefore be separated from fault processes zones (Cowie and Scholz, 1992), which develop at fault tips during propagation. A detailed report on the internal structure (Knipe et al., unpublished data) is beyond the scope of this paper and only some aspects of damage zones important to fault seal analysis are reviewed here.
The critical elements of fault damage zones which are needed for fault seal evaluation and for input into reservoir behaviour simulation include: (i) the dimensions of the damage zone; (ii) the fault clustering characteristics; (iii) the fault offset populations, which can control the distribution of fault rocks and juxtapositions; (iv) the orientation distributions of deformation features present within damage zones; and (v) the total thickness of fault-rocks. Each of these aspects are reviewed below, where the data presented are part of a large database collected from the structural analysis o f - 9 0 wells, (-25 km of core) from the North Sea area (see example in Fig. 7). The final part of this section presents a simple model which demonstrates the impact of damage zone structures on flow.
Damage zone dimensions The development of an increased frequency of structural features in the volume around large faults is a ubiquitous characteristic of the cores studied from the North Sea. The frequency of deformation features can increase from background levels of <50/100 m of core to values exceeding 600/100 m of core close to faults. The data set reveals that the structural frequency increases with increasing offset, and that
Fault seal analysis: successful methodologies, application and future directions
27
Fig. 7. Structural log of core entering a fault damage zone. The high structural frequency, faults and fractures concentrated at the base of the core, are arranged in clusters which define steps in the cumulative frequency curves.
faults with offsets of >75 m have damage zones which can extend for > 150 m. The edge of the damage zone is taken here as twice the background structural density. An example of the variation in the frequency of structural features away from one fault (the Ninety Fathom fault exposed in Whitley Bay, Tynemouth) is shown in Fig. 8. These data highlight the degradation of the reservoir properties close to the faults. The size of the damage zone is also dependent upon the lithologies which have been faulted, the deformation conditions and the distribution of strain between the hanging wall and footwall (Knipe et al.,
unpublished data). Fig. 9 is a cartoon which reviews the main factors which can control the dimensions and shape of damage zones and illustrates how the observed concentrations of deformation in either the hanging wall and the footwall can arise. It should be noted that these variations are part of the 3D variation in fault zone structure likely along faults as noted from the earlier discussion on fault segments and domains.
Fault clustering patterns Analysis of the frequency of structures in depth intervals (widths) which constitute clusters of defor-
R.J. Knipe et al.
28
120
E or)
lOO 80
|
60
"It
ml
"6 40 6 z 20
mm
9
9
9
9
9 9
mm
9
9 mmm_.
2:0
o
40
60
80
1;0 1:~0 140 16-0
Distance from Ninety Fathom Fault (m)
400 350 E 300 r
r 250 73 m o 200 z ' 9 "5 150 m
6 100
z
50 I 0
0
I
N 9 mmm
9 mm
9 9
9 9
9
mm.m
=
20 40 60 80 1()0 1;20 i z~0- 16"0 Distance from Ninety Fathom Fault (m)
Fig. 8. Example of the increased structural frequency and number of fault insection nodes present in a damage zone associated with the Ninety Fathom Fault, Whitley Bay, Tynemouth).
mation in cores (see Fig. 7, for examples of such clusters) reveals a clear power-law relationship. This has been found to hold for all well/cores assessed from the North Sea. Fig. 10 shows an example of data from one area which illustrates the relationship and reveals the presence of a lithological control on the cluster dimensions. The importance of this type of data is that it can be used to quantify the number of structural features which develop in clusters during fault growth. This helps to define a critical parameter needed for modelling the impact of faults of fluid flow.
Fault offset populations in damage zones Most fault offset population analysis (see Cowie et al., 1996) have concentrated on prediction of the number of sub-seismic over large areas (>1 km 2) faults rather than the distribution of the faults within the fault zones. In many cases a uniform distribution of faults across an area is assumed. The data from the structural logging of North Sea wells illustrate that the characteristics of faults found on a field scale are also present within individual fault zones identified on seismic or from well data. Because the population of small faults around larger structures will control the distribution of juxtapositions and fault rocks, detailed characterisation of the offsets is important to seal analysis. Fig. 11 illustrates the population characteristics of three fault zones with different offsets.
The plot illustrates the increasing population with a similar slope (or power-law, fractal relationship) for the central part of the measured populations. The identification of fractal characteristics is not a simple process and a recent work suggests that using a straight line fit to the log cumulative population data can be misleading. Fig. 12 shows a larger number of fault offset population analyses from cores through different faults and presents new information on the growth of fault populations. The figure shows that with increasing fault development (increasing total population) there is a change in the fractal number or slope towards higher values. This indicates that as the level of deformation increases (either with increasing fault offset magnitude or proximity to a fault) the fault population grows to contain a larger proportion of small offset faults. This is an important result as it reveals that this core data set on individual fault zones is preserving evidence of the continued addition of small faults throughout the fault development. This also emphasises the important distinction between population addition associated with initial propagation, process zone related, and the finite population which includes development from later displacement and accommodation events, i.e., damage zone related, (Knipe et al., unpublished data). This behaviour, of adding more small faults, may contrast with the late stages of fault growth on faults, when displacement activity may localise on established larger faults from an initial, more uniform, distribution (Cowie et al., 1993). An important part of modelling the impact of fault damage zones of reservoir flow relies on the ability to
t'--..
""
\',,, (--.,
,,,%,,
~ "'"'
Fault
""'---"
~ .
~ ,,, "'" Faul{",,% i
Steps
F ~ Splays "'..~ .,'
"---" ,.---.. i\
,,, Strains
,,, ,.
) t I,) ,,; '...."
x -..
L
Control
"-..., -~
Fig. 9. Cartoon which reviews variations in the geometry of fault damage zones. The simple elliptical geometry (a) is likely to be modified in reality by strain fields caused by (b), deviations away from a planar plane; (c) at the fault splay points; (d) from extensional tip strains; and (e) variations in the strengths and architecture of lithologies present.
Fault seal analysis: successful methodologies, application and future directions
1000
29
-
O C 100::3
m
0
9Siltstone
10-
t._
Conglomerate [] Sandstone
:
i
,,
9 i
9
~
i
i
_
O. 1
1
10
1 O0
1000
c l u s t e r width (vertical) rn Fig. 10. Plot of the relationship between the number of faults present in a cluster and the vertical size of the cluster. Note that different lithologies have different response to the deformation with the silt stones developing narrow clusters compared to the coarser grained sandstone and conglomerates.
evaluate if certain fault sizes (or offsets) are preferentially developed or if gaps in the fault offset population are present. Analysis of fault populations form the core database indicates that there can be gaps as well as some order in the offset population of individual clusters. Fig. 13 presents a conceptual model of a fault damage zone using a Sierpinski Carpet as an analogue. This model can be considered as the repositioning of faults which together make up a cluster of deformation features into an ideal arrangement. There are two properties of this ideal structure which may prove important to the analysis of natural fault clusters: (i) the population series, which defines the cascade of fault populations of different sizes (e.g., 1:8:64 in Fig. 13), and the dimension series, which describes the cascade of fault size attributes (length, offset, etc.) present relative to the largest fault (e.g., lengths 1:1/3:1/9 in Fig. 13). The presence of such order has been detected in fault clusters from core and field data. Fig. 14 shows an example of a probability density function analysis of one natural fault cluster and illustrates that there is a relationship between the largest offsets present and the number and size of smaller offset groups in the cluster. Such analysis is important to modelling fault zone flow
behaviour because the combination of the population series and the offset series will control the gradient of the fault population data on cumulative or frequency vs size attribute plots; i.e., will determine the fract# number of the population. In addition, it is important to establish the size of the largest fault offset in an array where only the cumulative throw is available from seismic.
Fault orientation distributions The 3D orientation distributions of structural features within damage zones are important for modelling of fluid flow as the non-parallel members of the arrays induce an intersection network which will control the connectivity of barriers. It is insufficient to characterise the average fault orientations or to identify average fault trends or families. A more detailed statistical analysis of fault orientations is needed in order to evaluate the 3D distribution of flow paths and barriers. An analysis of fault dips from North Sea wells (-20 km of total core studied) yields an average dip of 59 ~. However the standard deviations of these data sets, which will control the density and pattern of intersections, is typically between 15 ~ and 26 ~ Fig. 15 illustrates one example which com
R.J. Knipe et al.
30
Populations of Cores Intersected by Seismic Faults
---1000 o
[] 60m (49%)
> D
0 .E__ 100< 0(1)
[]
[]
0 []
915m (56%) 7m (47%)
[] [] DDDCIDDD_
9 9 9 9m m m m m mUDnDDD []
[]
[] []
10
[] <>
[]
ooo o
1
I
1
10
Offset (ram)
100
Fig. 11. The fault offset populations of three fault zones with different cumulative offsets. The plot illustrates the increasing population with a similar slope (or power-law, fractal relationship) for the central part of the measured populations.
The thickness of the low permeability fault rocks is an important variable in evaluation of cross-fault flow behaviour. Because fault zones are usually composed of complex arrays of intersecting sub-seismic faults and fractures and because the permeability reductions associated with faulting develop after low amounts (-cm) of displacement incorporation of the impact of complex fault zones (as opposed to single faults ) is not a simple procedure.
Two variables are fundamental to assessing the flow across complex fault zones. The first variable is the cumulative fault-rock thickness across the fault zone, i.e., the total thickness of fault-rock from all faults along the flow path. This depends upon the fault frequency along the flow path and is not equivalent to the fault damage zone thickness (cf. Knott, 1993) unless the fault zone is invaded by cements. The second variable is the connectivity of the faults or deformation features with low permeabilities in the fault zone. In the case of a completely connected array with no windows of undeformed material along possible flow paths, the flow is controlled by the permeability of the fault rocks. Where a more open network of faults is present then the flow will depend upon the tortuosity associated with flow around the low permeability zones and the ratio of matrix to fault-rock permeability. The interaction of these two factors will control the effective transmissivity of the zone. We have constructed a database on
Fig. 12. Fault offset populations from cores through different faults. Note that with increasing fault development (increasing total population) there is a change in the fractal number or slope towards high values.
Fig. 13. Conceptual model of a fault damage zone using a Sierpinski carpet. The fault zone structure can be considered to be characterised by a population series (i.e., the number of faults of different sizes, 1:8:64) and a dimension series (i.e., the size cascade of the faults present, 1, 1/3, 1/9).
pares the orientation distribution derived from an analysis of faults on seismic data with an orientation distribution of smaller scale fault orientation derived from core data. It is clear that the small scale structures exhibit more variation in orientation than the larger scale structure, and demonstrates that seismic fault orientation distributions cannot be used in a simple way to predict sub-seismic fault patterns.
The volume and continuity of fault rock in the damage zone
Fault seal analysis." successful methodologies, application and future directions I
I
I
I
I
r _ _ j Clusters
m
31
the thickness of fault rocks in fault zones with different sub-seismic populations.
I
0
H o w can a m o r e refined evaluation of fault zone structure a n d flow b e h a v i o u r be achieved?
U. "a
I L. ,
"0 e"
I,
I,
,I
Depth (metres)
,,,,J,JLI,
V
CLUSTER 2 Probability Density Functions
0.6
I
I
I
I
=4,9
Offset
e- 0.5 O O t:~ 0,4 LL >, u~ c(9 0.3 >,
= 17,0
Offset
~9 o.2 .13 0L ft. 0.1
O.
I
. .
20
-
"
.,. Offset=714 l , ., , . .
4"13
-
"60"
Fault Offset in
.Offset=114]'.,,,,.
8"0
"
~
00-
120
mm
Fig. 14. Example of a probability density function analysis of a natural fault cluster illustrating a relationship between the largest offsets present and the number and size of smaller offset groups in the cluster.
The data presented above on sub-seismic fault populations highlight the complexity of fault zones and that a detailed analysis of fault sealing can be of limited value if a simple fault zone structure is assumed. Despite these complexities, it is also clear that a more constrained analysis of fault sealing is possible if the detailed fault zone architecture is considered. The model of fault damage zones which emerges from the data presented above is of a volume of deformed reservoir surrounding fault zones, where with increasing proximity to the main fault, the structure of the fault zone alters (Knipe, 1994). The damage zone can be viewed as being composed of "onion skins" each with different densities, architectures and connectivities between potential barriers. Damage zones can be considered made up of two main domains with different flow properties: an outer zone and an inner zone. The outer zone of the damage zone will be composed of a volume with a higher structural density (minor faults and fractures) than outside where, if the fault rocks are effective barriers, tortuosity controls the flow behaviour. The inner zone, is where the structural density and architecture (i.e., the fault population, clustering and orientation
Fig. 15. Comparison of the orientation distribution derived from an analysis of fault orientation based on seismic data with an orientation distribu-
tion of smaller scale fault orientation derived from core data in the same area. Note that the small scale structures exhibit more variation in orientation than the larger scale structure.
R.J. Knipe et aL
32
Fig. 16. Numerical analysis evaluating the connectivity of faults with a damage zone. The analysis is aimed at identifying the critical density of structural features needed to separate domains with (a) fault-rock controlled flow behaviour and (b) tortuosity controlled flow behaviour. In the example shown, a transition from an openarray of faults with tortuosity flow to a connected array occurs when the structural frequency is equivalent to between 200 features/100 m of core and 400 features/100 m of core.
characteristics present) generate a linked 3D array, which together form a continuous barrier, where flow is controlled by the fault rock properties. This can create sealed cells or micro-compartments within fault zones. The challenge for fault seal analysis is to be able to define the geometry and location of these inner and outer zones of damage zones. For the analysis of fault flow behaviour identifying the characteristics of the boundary between the outer and inner damage zone domains is essential. Fig. 16 presents a simple numerical analysis evaluating the critical density of structural features needed to define the boundary between the inner (with fault-rock controlled flow behaviour) and outer (tortuosity controlled flow behaviour) damage zones. The analysis shown is based on the concept of creating an array of faults with defined population, size, spatial and orientation distributions and then testing the flow properties of the array by creating "fires" at specific points and evaluating the spread of the "fire" or flow through the grid matrix, where the faults act as barriers to flow. The array can then be sampled to determine the density of structural features present when flow or penetration is prevented across the grid/lattice
system. The example shown is for a 2D situation and the progressive increase in the density of structural features causes a transition from flow to sealing when the structural frequency is equivalent to between 200 deformation features/100m of core and 400 features/100m of core. The transition zone between these values reflects the different spatial arrangements possible in this range where some specific geometries are able seal and others form open networks. It is clear that such modelling can provide an important step in the analysis of flow properties of faults before more detailed flow modelling with a reservoir simulation package is undertaken.
Mapping fault seal distributions The basic requirement for mapping fault seals is the generation of a realistic, maximum probability map of sealing capacities along individual fault zones. This involves evaluation of the possible juxtaposition patterns within the zone as well as an assessment of the variance of fault rock properties. The method most commonly used in evaluating fault seal distributions is the construction of Allan
Fault seal analysis: successful methodologies, application and future directions
maps (Allan, 1989) which illustrate stratigraphic geometries of horizon/fault plane intersections and are either drawn by hand or used in conjunction with fault mapping software (such as FAPS) (Freeman et al., 1990; Needham et al., 1996). Construction of these maps can be an essential, but difficult and timeconsuming task and the important limitations of these maps are not always considered in detail. The assumption made in constructing these fault plane maps is that the throw indicated across a fault identified on seismic represents a single fault plane. The real situation is more complex and the seismically defined fault should be considered as the cumulative throw of the zone, which may not be accommodated on a single fault. Two factors are therefore critical in the evaluation of the geometrical distribution of seals in fault zones. The first relates to the accuracy of mapping, the stratigraphic horizons, the fault zone location and the cumulative throw distributions. This is usually controlled by the resolution of seismic data and is generally of the order of 20-30 m for high quality data sets. Such a resolution of both surface and fault mapping can introduce a large range of possible juxtapositions patterns, even if a fault zone with a single fault plane is present. The second limitation centres around the problem of characterising the sub-seismic fault damage zone architecture along the fault zones and in tip areas. The last section of the paper on sub-seismic faults reviewed how characterisation and modelling of the critical parameters of sub-seismic faults can reduce the risk associated with fault seal analysis. How many fault seal analyses or reservoir modelling attempts have produced poor history matching because the potential variation in fault juxtapositions arising from the combined impact of resolution limitations and fault zone sub-structure have not been considered?
Towards a solution to fault seal mapping The evaluation of fault-seal potential along individual faults can be time consuming if each fault has to be mapped in enough detail to allow accurate definition of reservoir and fault intersections. It is often more efficient to divide the evaluation process into two phases: (a) Phase 1: involving a rapid assessment of the impact of fault throw, sedimentary architecture and fault zone structure on the juxtapositions and sealing properties of faults in the field. This can be achieved by the use of simple juxtaposition/fault seal diagrams (Knipe, 1992b, 1997) without the need for detailed (or in some cases any) seismic mapping of either stratigraphy horizons or faults. The advantage of this procedure is that critical fault throws, which create
33
"leaky" windows across faults, can be identified and used to help locate areas of the field where more detailed analysis of the seismic data is needed. (b) Phase 2: seismic mapping (in selected areas) of detailed fault and reservoir horizon geometries to constrain the depth and location of, leaky windows, and to provide a platform for analysis of the potential controls on hydrocarbon/water contacts, drainage patterns and field communication. Some important aspects of each of these phases of fault seal distribution analysis are reviewed below. Phase 1 is aimed at investigating the seal potential of faults with different throws and rapidly assessing the consequences of seismic resolution problems, fault damage zones and variations in the internal reservoir architecture. Fig. 17a,b illustrates the basis of the juxtaposition and fault seal diagrams. The details of the construction of these diagrams are presented by Knipe (1997); a software package is available. The figure plots the reservoir stratigraphies in the footwall and hanging-wall along the vertical axes and increasing fault throw along the horizontal axis. The diagrams can be considered as a horizontal view of a "transparent" fault where the stratigraphy in the footwall is horizontal and the hanging-wall inclined. The juxtapositions between the hanging-wall and footwall are represented as either triangles or parallelograms on the fault surface. The range of juxtapositions along a fault with constant or variable throw can be assessed from therange of triangular and parallelogram areas intersected by either a vertical or inclined line. The impact of seismic resolution can be assessed by considering the intersection of a band of throws with a thickness which accounts for the resolution. Damage zones can be evaluated by considering an array of faults, where the combined throw is equal to the cumulative throw interpreted from seismic. The diagrams can be adjusted for reverse and syn-sedimentary fault-growth fault situations. We have also found it useful to include "side-wall" plots of the critical depth property data which help in the delineation and classification of fault rock types and properties. These side-wall plots can include porosity, permeability, net gross ratios, and various down-holetool log data sets (see Fig. 17c). Fault seal types, based on the analysis of fault rock properties derived from the different host rocks as well as on the throw and juxtaposition history, can be generated on a separate (fault seal type) diagram. Areas on the diagram with different properties can then be identified (see Fig. 17c). This procedure allows the mapping or contouring important sealing properties on the diagrams. The fault properties which can be mapped onto these diagrams include permeabilities, shale smear potential, transmissibilities, sealing ca-
R.J. Knipe et al.
34
Fig. 17. Juxtaposition diagrams for use in fault seal analysis. See text for details.
pacities, and seal strengths. The diagrams can also be used to correlate these properties with well test or production data to validate the analysis. Phase 2 involves the detailed mapping of both reservoir horizons and faults and requires assembling fault plane maps, as well as integration with well data
on hydrocarbon/water contacts, pressure distributions and production data. The following is a list of the important considerations which should be involved in this stage of the analysis: (1) Evaluation of the coherency of fault offset patterns and gradients (Walsh and Watterson, 1991)
Fault seal analysis: successful methodologies, application and future directions
to identify faults intersections, erosion of fault tops at unconformities, the sub-structure of tip areas and connectivity of fault zones (tip-tapping) into stratigraphic horizons able to generate cements. (2) Assessment of data on the presence of fault damage zones and structural variation along fault zones, from both individual seismic lines as well as attribute data, if available (Jones and Knipe, 1996). The aim is to identify segments or domains, where different fault patterns may be present. For example, early relay zones, which mark the ends of linked fault segments, have a high probability of developing from overlapping faults and often represent areas where accommodation of displacement is distributed on a number of faults, i.e., these areas will be characterised by low throw juxtapositions (see Knipe, 1997). (3) Analysis of the location and heights of potential leaky fault juxtaposition windows which arise from variations in: (i) the possible depths, geometries and locations of stratigraphic horizons and faults; (ii) the difference between the cumulative throw on individual fault zones, indicated from seismic and the most likely size of the throw on the largest real fault in that zone; and (iii) the sediment architecture and continuity. The end result should be a probability map of the distribution of sealed and leaky windows along the critical fault zones.
35
(4) The generation of communication and drainage maps for potential compartments and the correlation and integration of these with hydrocarbon/water contacts, pressure test and production data. (5) Input of the most robust reservoir characterisation geometries and properties into simulation models. Note that in the exploration situation, versus the development case, the different levels of data availability will dictate which of the above analytical procedures are possible and which missing (or poorly defined) elements represent the high risk factors.
Fault seal risk analysis and future requirements This paper has highlighted that a number of components, important to fault seal analysis, are often either not included or not quantified in sufficient detail to allow a low risk seal evaluation. The main components which are not always considered in detail are: (i) the errors in throw patterns which arise from seismic resolution and fault damage zone structures; (ii) the assumption that juxtaposition of reservoir against low permeability units and shale smear are the only sealing mechanisms; and (iii) that fault seal data from anywhere is directly applicable to any other sealing problem, i.e., that the geohistory is not critical
Fig. 18. Reviews of the critical factors needed for an integrated seal analysis. These include: (i) data on the 3D sediment architecture; (ii) the petrophysical properties of the fault rocks present; (iii) the architecture of individual fault zones; and (iv) the fault array evolution.
R.J. Knipe et al.
36
to the seal evaluation. Each of these factors can have a major impact on seal analysis, induce a poorly constrained, high risk model and render detailed reservoir modelling of little value. It is interesting to evaluate the success of the simple fault seal analysis, based on the list of common assumptions outlined above, after a more detailed and integrated seal analysis has been performed. The following results from our analysis of >25 North Sea seals are applicable here: Seal analysis based on the assumption that juxtaposition analysis (i.e., construction of Allan diagrams, clay smear assessment and leaking sand/sand contacts) would only have been successful in -40% of the cases studied. - Clay smearing is the critical sealing mechanism in only -35% of cases. - A cement seal may be present in -60% of fields. Cross fault sand juxtaposed against sand seal in -65% of cases. Inversion/reactivation creates leaks in -20% of cases. It should be noted that these figures refer to an amalgamation of North Sea data and do not reflect the risk assessment of smaller sub-areas in the North Sea where more restricted and consistent geohistories are present. The analysis presented in the paper has highlighted the need to integrate data sets from different scales into a seal analysis (e.g., Leveille et al., 1996). Fig. 18 reviews the four critical factors needed from the different scales. These include: (i) data on the 3D sediment architecture; (ii) the petrophysical properties of the fault rocks present; (iii) the architecture of individual fault zones; and (iv) the fault array evolution. It is the combined resolution and characterisation level of each of these which defines the risk level of the seal analysis. There is an important geohistory component in each of these factors. This emphasises the problems associated with transferring data or resuits from areas with different geohistories, with-out consideration of the different geohistories involved. Despite the common assumption of fault sealing in hydrocarbon fields, very few faults have been characterised in the detail needed which allows identification of the sealing mechanism or controls. Without the construction of a robust set of case histories from such analysis, future seal evaluation will remain a high risk venture. These case histories are also needed to integrate seal behaviour with pressure test, production and in situ stress analysis. The paper has highlighted the importance of an integrated approach from micro to macro and stressed the value of corebased studies to quantify fault rock properties, subseismic fault populations and sealing mechanisms.
-
-
-
The aim of this review has been to demonstrate that although a complex problem there are techniques which can be, and should be, applied to fault seal analysis as they allow a clearer understanding, quantification and therefore predictability associated with a fault seal analysis.
Acknowledgements Support from AGIP, British Gas, BP, Conoco, Phillips, Mobil and Stratoil is gratefully acknowledged. Comments on the initial manuscript from Roy Gabrielsen also gratefully acknowledged.
References Allan, U.S. 1989. Model for hydrocarbon migration and entrapment within faulted structures. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull. 73: 803811. Antonellini, M. and Aydin, A. 1994. Effect of faulting on fluid flow in porous sandstones: petrophysical properties. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 78: 335-377. Aydin, A. 1978. Small faults formed as deformation bands in sandstone. Pure Appl. Geophys., 116: 913-942. Berg, R.B. and Avery, A.H. 1995. Sealing properties of Tertiary growth faults, Texas Gulf coast. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 79: 375-393. Bouvier, J.D., Sijpesteijn, K., Kluesner, D.F., Onyejekwe, C.C. and van der Pal, R.C. 1989. Three-dimensional seismic interpretation and fault sealing investigations, Nun River field, Nigeria. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 73: 1397-1414. Budey, S.D., Mullis, J. and Matter, A. 1989. Timing diagenesis in the Tartan Reservoir (U.K. North Sea): constraints from combined cathodoluminescence microscopy and fluid inclusion studies. Mar. Pet. Geol., 6: 98-120. Carter, N.L., Kronenberg, A.K., Ross, J.V. and Wiltschkko, D.V. 1990. Control of fluids on deformation of rocks. In: R.J. Knipe and E.H. Rutter (Editors), Deformation Mechanisms, Rheology and Tectonics. Geol. Soc. Special Publication 54, pp. 1-13. Cartwright, J.A., Mansfield, C. and Trudgill B. 1996. The growth of normal faults by segment linkage. In: P.G. Buchanan and D.A. Nieuwland (Editors), Modern Development in Structural Interpretation, Validation and Modelling. Geol. Soc. Special Publication 99, pp. 163-177. Chester, F.M. and Logan, J.M. 1986. Implications for mechanical properties of brittle faults from observations of the Punchbowl Fault zone, California. Pure Appl. Geophys., 124: 77-106. Cowie, P.A. and Scholz, C.H. 1992. Displacement-length scaling relationships for faults: data synthesis and discussion. J. Struct. Geol., 14:1149-1156. Cowie, P.A., Vanneste, C. and Sornette, D. 1993. Statistical physics model for the spatio-temporal evolution of faults. J. Geophys. Res., 98: 21809-21821. Cowie, P.A., Knipe, R.J. and Main, I.G. 1996 Introduction to the Special Issue. Scaling Laws for Fault and Fracture Populations Analysis and Applications. J. Struct. Geol., 18: 135-383. Dewers, T. and Ortoleva, P.J. 1990. Interaction of reaction, mass transport, and rock deformation during diagenesis: mathematical modelling of integranular pressure solution, stylolites, and differential compaction/cementation. In: I.D. Meshri and P.J. Ortoleva (Editors), Prediction of Reservoir Quality through Chemical Modelling, Memoir, 49. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Tulsa, OK. Engelder, J.T. 1974. Cataclasis and the generation of fault gouge. Bull. Geol. Soc. Am., 85: 1515-1522.
Fault seal analysis: successful methodologies, application and future directions Fowles, J. and Burley, S.D. 1994. Textural and permeability characteristics of faulted, high porosity sandstones. Mar. Pet. Geol., 11: 608-623. Freeman, B., Yielding, G. and Badley, M. 1990. Fault correlation during seismic interpretation. First Break, 8: 3. Gauthier, B.D.M. and Lake, S.D. 1993. Probabilistic modelling of faults below the limit of seismic resolution in Pelican Field, North Sea, Offshore United Kingdom. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 77: 761-777. Gibson, R.G. 1994. Fault-zone seals in siliclastic strata of the Columbus Basin, Offshore Trinidad. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 78: 1372-1385. Gillespie, P.A., Howard, C.B., Walsh, J.J. and Watterson, J. 1993. Measurement and characterisation of spatial distributions of fractures. Tectonophysics, 226:113-141. Harding, T.P. and Tuminas, A.C. 1989. Structural interpretation of hydrocarbon traps sealed by basement normal blocks and at stable flank of foredeep basins and at rift basins. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 73:812-840. Hatton, C.G., Main, I.G. and Meredith, P.G. 1994. Non-universal scaling of fracture length and opening displacement (letter). Nature, 367: 160-162. Jev, B.I., Kaars-Sijpesteijn, C.H., Peters, M.P.A.M., Watts, N.L. and Wilkie, J.T. 1993. Akaso field, Nigeria: use of integrated 3-D seismic, fault slicing, clay smearing, and RFT pressure data on fault trapping and dynamic leakage. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 77: 1389-1404. Jones, G. and Knipe R.J. 1996. Seismic attribute maps; application to structural interpretation and fault seal analysis in the North Sea Basin. First Break, in press. Knipe, R.J. 1989. Deformation mechanisms - recognition from natural tectonites. J. Struct. Geol., 11: 127-146. Knipe, R.J. 1992a. Faulting processes and fault seal. In: R.M. Larsen, H. Brekke, B.T. Larsen and E. Talleraas (Editors), Structural and Tectonic Modelling and its Application to Petroleum Geology. NPF Special Publication 1, Stavanger, pp. 325342. Knipe, R.J. 1992b. Faulting processes, seal evolution and reservoir discontinuities: an integrated analysis of the ULA Field, Central Graben, North Sea. Abstracts of the Petroleum Group Meeting on Collaborative Research Programme in Petroleum Geoscience between UK Higher Education Institutes and the Petroleum Industry. Geological Soceity, London. Knipe, R.J. 1993a. The influence of fault zone processes and diagenesis on fluid flow. In: A.D. Horbury and A.G. Robinson (Editors), Diagenesis and Basin Development. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Studies in Geology, 36. American Association of Petroleum Geologists, Tulsa, OK, pp. 135-154. Knipe, R.J. 1993b. Micromechanisms of deformation and fluid behaviour during faulting. The Mechanical Involvement of Fluids in Faulting. USGS, Open-File Report 94-228, pp. 301-310. Knipe, R.J. 1994. Fault zone geometry and behaviour: the importance of the damage zone evolution. Abstracts of Meetings Modem Developments in Structural Interpretation. Geological Society, London. Knipe, R.J. 1997. Juxtaposition and seal diagrams to help analyze fault seals in hydrocarbon reservoirs. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 81: 187-195. Knipe, R.J.,and Lloyd, G.E. 1994. Microstructural analysis of faulting in quartzite, Assynt, NW Scotland: implications for fault zone evolution. Pure Appl. Geophys., 143: 229-254. Knipe, R.J. and McAllister, E. 1996. Fault population analysis: identification of fractal characteristics for scaling. J. Struct. Geol., submitted. Knipe, R.J., Agar, S.M. and Prior, D.J. 1991. The microstructural evolution of flow paths in semi-lithified sediments from subduction complexes. Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London, Ser. A, 335: 261273. Knipe, R.J., Fisher, Q.J., Jones, G., Clennell, M.R., Farmer, A.B.,
37
Harrison, A., Kidd, B., McAllister, E., Porter, J.R. and White, E.A. The architecture of fault damage zones. Unpublished data. Knott, S.D. 1993. Fault seal analysis in the North Sea. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 77: 778-792. Leveille, G.P., Knipe, R.J., More, C., Ellis, D., Dudley, G., Jones, G. and Fisher, Q.J. 1997. Compartmentalisation of Rotliegended gas reservoirs by sealing faults, Jupiter Area, Southern North Sea. In: K. Ziegler, P. Turner and S.R. Daines (Editors), Petroleum Geology of the Southern North Sea: Future Potential. Geol. Soc. Special Publication No.123, pp. 87-104. Lindsay, N.G., Murphy, F.C., Walsh J.J. and Watterson, J. 1993. Outcrop studies of shale smears of fault surfaces. Special Publication Int. Assoc. Sediment. 15, pp. 113-123. McGrath, A. and Davison, I. 1995. Damage zone geometry around fault tips. In: J. Struct. Geol., 17:1011-1024. Mitra, S. 1988. Effects of deformation mechanisms on reservoir potential in central Appalachian overthrust belt. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 72: 536-554. Mullis, A.M. 1993. Determination of the rate limiting mechanism for quartz pressure solution. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 57: 14991503. Needham, D.T., Yielding, G. and Freeman, B. 1996. Analysis of fault geometry and displacement patterns. In: P.G. Buchanan and D.A. Nieuwland (Editors), Modem Developments in Structural Interpretation Validation and Modelling. Geol. Soc. Special Publication No. 99, pp. 189-200. Peacock, D.C.P. and Sanderson, D.J. 1994. Geometry and development of relay ramps in normal fault systems. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 78: 147-165. Pitman, E.D. 1981. Effect of fault-related granulation on porosity and permeability of quartz sandstones, Simpson Group (Ordovician), Oklahoma. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 65:2381-2387. Rutter, E.H. 1983. Pressure solution in nature, theory and experiment. J. Geol. Soc. London, 140: 725-740. Scholz, C.H. 1989. Mechanics of faulting. Annu. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci., 17: 309-334. Schowalter, T.T. 1979. Mechanisms of secondary hydrocarbon migration and entrapment. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 63: 723760. Sibson, R.H. 1994. Crustal stress, faulting and fluid flow. In: J. Parnell (Editor), Geofluids: Origin, Migration and Evolution of Fluids in Sedimentary Basins. Geol. Soc. Special Publication 78, pp. 69-84. Smith, D.A. 1966. Theoretical consideration of sealing and nonsealing faults. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 50: 363-374. Smith, D.A. 1980. Sealing and non-sealing faults in Louisiana Gulf Coast salt basin. Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geol. Bull., 64: 145-172. Somette, A., Davy, P. and Somette, D. 1990. Growth of fractal fault patterns. Phys. Rev. Lett., 65, 18: 2266-2269. Spiers, C.J., Schutjens, P.M.T.M., Brzesowsky, R.H., Peach, C.J., Liezenberg, J.L. and Zwart, H.J. 1990. Experimental determination of constitutive parameters governing creep of rocksalt by pressure solution. In: R.J. Knipe and E.H. Rutter (Editors), Deformation Mechanisms, Rheology and Tectonics. Geol. Soc. Special Publication 54, pp. 215-228. Sverdrup, E. and Bjorlykke, K. 1992. Small faults in sandstones from Spitsbergen and Haltenbanken. A study of diagenetic and deformational structures and their relation to fluid flow. In: R.M. Larsen, H. Brekke, B.T. Larsen and E. Talleraas (Editors), Structural and Tectonic Modelling and its Application to Petroleum Geology. NPF Special Publication 1. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 507518. Underhill, J.R. and Woodcock, N.H. 1987. Faulting mechanisms in high porosity sandstones; Nw Red Standstone, Arran, Scotland. In: M.E. Jones and R.M.F. Preston (Editors), Deformation of Sediments and Sedimentary Rocks. Geol. Soc. Special Publication 29, pp. 91-105. Wallace, R.E. and Morris, H.T. 1986. Characteristics of faults and shear zones in deep mines. Pure Appl. Geophys., 124: 107-125.
R.J. Knipe et al.
38 Walsh, J.J. and Watterson, J. 1991. Geometric and kinematic coherence and scale effects in normal fault systems. In: A.M. Roberts, G. Yielding and B. Freeman (Editors), The Geometry of Normal Faults. Geol. Soc. Special Publication 56, pp. 193-203. Walsh, J.J. and Watterson, J. 1992. Populations of faults and fault displacements and their effects on estimates of fault-related regional extension. J. Struct. Geol., 14: 701-712.
R.J. KNIPE Q.J. FISHER G. JONES M.R. CLENNELL A.B. FARMER A. HARRISON B. KIDD E. MCALLIsTER J.R. PORTER E.A. WHITE
Watts, N.L. 1987. Theoretical aspects of cap-rock and fault seals for single and two phase hydrocarbon columns. Mar. Pet. Geol., 4: 274-307. Yielding, G., Needham, T. and Jones, H. 1996. Sampling of fault populations using sub-surface data: a review. J. Struct. Geol., 18: 135-146.
Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK (e-mail: r.j.knipe@ rdr.leeds.ac.uk) Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK Rock Deformation Research Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Leeds, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK
39
The emplacement of clay smears in synsedimentary normal faultsinferences from field observations near Frechen, Germany F.K. Lehner and W.F. Pilaar
Background and methods: This paper reports on an outcrop study of clay smears in synsedimentary normal faults that were exposed in the open-cast lignite mines at Frechen near Cologne, Germany. The observations made are interpreted in terms of a mechanism of clay smear emplacement.
Results and conclusions: The fault zones at Frechen contain clay fillings of up to 1 m in thickness, derived from extremely plastic shale source beds and smeared out over distances as much as 70 m in dip direction. The generation of substantial smears requires slow fault displacement rates and sufficient shale ductility. When a thick shale source bed is traversed by a normal fault, it is first flexed and eventually disrupted by a pull-apart mechanism that creates room for the emplacement of thick clay smears. Simple theoretical considerations suggest that the source bed thickness to some power n + 1 > 2 may be a key parameter in the ranking of seal quality. The length of continuous smears increases with source bed thickness, but will ultimately be controlled by the smearing process. The latter remains to be investigated.
Introduction Among the various conditions known to promote sealing of shear faults in sediments, the presence of "clay smears" or "shale smears" has long been recognized as important. Field observations, indicating mud stone flow into fault zones, were reported by Edwards et al. (1944). "Fault plane fillings" consisting of clay material from side walls were described even earlier in faulting experiments on soft sediments by Rettger (1935). Perkins (1961), in a study of certain fault closure-type fields in the Lousiana Gulf Coast, explained accumulations in sands upthrown against massive sands by shale flowage along the fault zone, whereby he envisaged the formation of a "natural mudcake" over the sand interface by impregnation of the pore space of the sand with plastic shale material. In the same region, Smith (1980) studied the occurrence of fault seals in deltaic sand/shale sequences in relation to the age and lithology of the juxtaposed sediments and found: (1) fault sealing, with hydrocarbon-bearing sandstone in juxtaposition with shale; (2) fault non-sealing, with parts of the same sandstone body juxtaposed within the hydrocarbon column; (3) fault non-sealing, with sandstone bodies of different ages juxtaposed within the hydrocarbon column; and (4) fault sealing, with sandstone bodies of different ages juxtaposed within the hydrocarbon column. In some places, all four relations were found to be present at different levels along the same fault. In the last case, the seal was attributed by Smith to "the presence of boundary fault-zone material (i.e., material from the fault walls)
emplaced along the fault by mechanical or chemical processes related directly or indirectly to faulting". Smith discusses evidence from fault-zone exposures for cemented and indurated sandstones, a fairly frequent observation (see, e.g., Knipe (1992) and further references cited therein), but also describes a fault zone which separates two different sandstones by a clay-fill of 1 m thickness. According to Smith, "the clay is not fault-gouge material, but is apparently part of a shale formation that has become stretched and trapped in the fault zone". As Smith observes, if the fault-zone shale provides the seal, the thickness and physical properties (soft or indurated) of the shale at the time of faulting are factors which may determine whether or not shale will form boundary fault-zone material for hydrocarbon entrapment. Growth faults, relatively near the surface in soft sediments, may thus have a different capacity to trap hydrocarbons than post-depositional faults at depth in more indurated sediments. The last observation could indeed have major practical implications as a guiding principle in assessing fault trap prospects. It is therefore of some interest that Lindsay et al. (1993) have observed clay smears in tectonic faults that affected a Westphalian sand/shale sequences after lithification. These smears were apparently formed by abrasion of indurated shales. In this process, the surface of a sandstone becomes coated by a thin veneer of abraded material in much the same way as the surface of sandpaper. This veneer may run continuously along polished slip surfaces, but - as Lindsay et al. have documented in their s t u d y - with increasing fault displacement and de-
Hydrocarbon Seals: Importance for Exploration and Production edited by P. Mr
and A.G. Koestler. NPF Special Publication 7, pp. 39-50, Elsevier, Singapore. 9 Norwegian Petroleum Society (NPF) 1997
40 pending upon the thickness of the shale source bed, the veneer will eventually be eroded. Clay smears formed by a process of abrasion in the faulting of lithified sediments must thus be distinguished carefully from smears that are formed by the injection of soft clay material from plastic source beds. Clay smears of the latter kind were found in coal-bearing sequences by Lindsay et al. and were associated characteristically with soft seat earths. The picture emerging from these studies tends to confirm the results of an earlier outcrop study, conducted in 1973-1974 by the present authors on synsedimentary normal faults in the open-cast lignite mines of the lower Rhine Graben at Frechen, west of Cologne in Germany. Although an abbreviated and limited exposition was given in a paper by Weber et al. (1978), the results of this study have so far never been published in full. The work of Weber et al. (1978) and Weber (1987) was in fact primarily concerned with the broader issue of hydrocarbon migration and accumulation patterns in the Niger Delta. In presenting a brief synopsis of the observations made at Frechen, Weber et al. (1978) were, however, offering a rational explanation for observed lithologytrapping relationships in soft deltaic sand/shale sequences in terms of sealing clay smears, in much the same way as was proposed later by Smith (1980). The quality of the fresh fault-zone exposures in the Frechen mines was in fact unique and some of the most interesting unpublished observations made there relate to the mechanism of clay-smear emplacement. Clay smears ranging in length from a few centimeters (on minor shear faults) to more than 70 m (on major graben faults) provide strong evidence of an injection-type mechanism of emplacement, the mechanics of which remained enigmatic, however, especially for clay smear thicknesses of nearly 1 m. Here a detailed study of the deformation and rupture behavior of some shale source beds, as they become affected by normal faulting during burial, has shed light, not only on the mechanism of clay smear emplacement in a fault zone, but also on the broader question of fault propagation through a rheologically layered sequence of soft sediments. It was therefore felt that a detailed account of the observations made in 1973-1974 in the Frechen mines would provide a useful contribution to the discussion on fault sealing mechanisms and potential.
Main findings of outcrop study The open-cast lignite mines near Frechen (west of Cologne in Germany) provide an excellent location for studying well exposed normal faults, which had been brought to our attention by J. Haremboure (pers.
F.K. Lehner and W.F. Pilaar
commun.). The faults occur in a deltaic sequence of moderately cohesive sediments. At the time of this study, outcrops could be examined down to about 200 m depth below surface. The faults chosen for study are situated on the eastern flank of the Tertiary graben system of the lower Rhine Valley and affect the deltaic sequence that filled this part of the graben. The faults are synsedimentary normal faults, i.e., growth faults, that have been active during the Upper Miocene and lowermost Pliocene (Quitzow, 1954; Prange, 1958). Throws up to about 100 m and dip angles averaging around 70 ~ are observed in the open pits. The exposed sediments comprise altemating well-bedded loose to slightly consolidated, sands, silts, shales, and gravels with an intercalation of a thick brown-coal layer in the lower part of the exposed section. Sand predominates over the other lithological constituents, the average sand/shale ratio being near 3:1 in the Frechen mine. The focus of our investigation lay on the structure and composition of fault zones and in particular on any evidence that would shed light on the process of clay smear emplacement. We begin with an overview of the most important observations.
Shear zones associated with normal faulting Fault displacement along the major normal faults is typically partitioned (in space and time) over a number of slip surfaces that define a "shear zone". The style of shearing within such a shear zone contrasts with the pattern formed by minor shear bands in the adjacent sediments. The width of the shear zones varies with the lithological composition of the fault walls over the throw interval. With sand against sand displacement, the shear zones are usually only a few centimeters wide. Where sand is displaced against other material, shear zones are often wider and include material from different locations along the fault walls. Such shear zones often have a lithologically layered appearance. They contain clay smears in almost every location within the throw interval of a faulted shale bed, be it along a minor shear band or a major fault. These observations are documented in Plates 1 and 2. Minor shear bands, called "shears" in the following, appear as streaks of discolored material in outcrop. Shearing in combination with fluid transport through dilated shear bands appears to remove the fine coal particles that are attached to the sand grains and are responsible for the brownish color of many (unsheared) sands in the mines. This creates a unique opportunity for locating minor shears in sandy material, where they would otherwise remain invisible to the naked eye.
The emplacement of clay smears in synsedimentary normal faults
PLATE
41
PLATE 2
1
(a) (a)
1IlL
ay source beds
D
~c~
(b)
F cl smear
1l 11 t~
(b)
F
Jl o,~yg.uge
li
Plate 1. (a) "Max Rudolph" fault (Frechen mine): continuous clay smear over approx. 70 m throw, visible as a thin streak between sand and downthrown coal (Height of exposure approx. 40 m). (b) Earlier exposure of same fault, showing continuity of clay smear in strike direction over approx. 400 m. (c) Detail of fault zone with compact clay smear (approx. 30 cm thick) and fault-parallel minor D-shear in upthrown block. Plate 2. (a) Clay smear in minor shear. (b) Sample of clay smear (approx. 5 cm thick) filling fault zone of "Max Rudolph" fault (Frechen mine). Sigmoidal shear pattern became visible upon drying.
The style of shearing within major shear zones varies with the lithology of the fault-zone material. In sandy material, one encounters the patterns of shear of the "classical" shear zones described by Skempton (1966), Morgenstern and Tchalenko (1967), Tchalenko (1970), Mandl et al. (1977) and Logan et al. (1979) (see also more recent work on experimental shear zones by Logan et al. (1992) and Gu and Wong (1994). Typical of this style are the fault-parallel "principal displacement shears" (D-shears) and enechelon "Riedel shears" (R-shears) that are inclined at 10-30 ~ to the D-shears, the acute angle pointing in the direction of the relative movement of the fault block on which they occur.
In freshly cut, i.e., wet clay smears, such as shown in Plate 1, much less evidence is found of discontinuous deformation along well-defined slip planes than in sandy shear zones. Dried samples, however, reveal intense sheafing along often slicken-sided, slip surfaces across which the material retains a certain reduced cohesion. On a centimeter scale, the mode of plastic deformation of the soft clay smears appears to be slip along distributed, often gently warped surfaces. This is visible in the clay smear sample shown in Plate 2b from a fault zone whose main slip surfaces (or Dshears) coincided with the margins of the clay smear, as is often observed. After some drying, a very regular pattern of sigmoidal shears appeared in the sample.
F.K. Lehner and W.F. Pilaar
42
PLATE 4
PLATE 3
R
F
F
/)
coal shale
(a)
(a) R
F
F
sand coal
shale
(b)
(b)
~/I
Plate 3. (a) Clay smear and sets of R- and conjugate W-shears in near-surface position on upthrown and downthrown blocks of "Max Rudolph" fault (F). (b) Detail of (a) showing R-shears offset by later R'-shears and truncation of shears by fault. Plate 4. (a) "Max Rudolph" fault (Frechen mine, throw approx. 70 m). Clay from different source beds on upthrown and downthrown blocks merges to form layered clay smear free of sandy or coal material. (b) Hexed shale bed on downthrown side of "Max Rudolph" fault (F). The clay smear (approx. 20 cm thick) and sand wedge to the left of the person resemble situation shown in Fig. 2.
D e f o r m a t i o n outside the s h e a r z o n e s
On either side of the "shear zone proper" (the term is used here to designate the zone that accommodates most of the fault displacement and is typically bounded by D-shears), a much wider zone of continuous and/or discontinuous (slip) deformation is usually discernible. Faulted monoclinal flexures in shale layers (Plate 3) furnish the most prominent examples of continuous, fault-related deformation. At places, the coal seam is flexed together with an overlying or underlying shale. Almost everywhere along a fault, a fringe zone of (discolored) shears is observed in the sands (Plate 4). On the downthrown side, the flexed shales are often intersected by these shears
(Plate 5b). A large number of observations suggests that these shears form two sets of conjugate shears whose attitude with respect to the major slip planes of the fault is the same as that of the Riedel shears (Rshears) and their conjugates (W-shears) in the abovediscussed "classical" shear zone. We have therefore used the abbreviations R and R' to denote these sets in the plates shown. In Plate 4 these sets can be seen on the upthrown and downthrown sides of a fault. An important observation, to which we shall return presently, is that this pattern of R- and W-shears is discontinuous across the fault, i.e., is truncated by it. The material has been deformed along these sets of shears by a double-gliding motion involving alternating slip on two conjugate sets of slip surfaces, with some pre-
The emplacement of clay smears in synsedimentary normal faults
Plate 5. (a) Near-surface exposure of "Max Rudolph" fault (F) forming narrow shear zone in sand. Sets of precursory R- and R'-shears on upthrown and downthrown blocks are truncated by fault (shears open upon drying of slope face). (b) Shale A in juxtaposition with shale B and underlying coal across "Max Rudolph" fault (F). Note the small graben feature, where shale is intersected by R- and R'-shears. Rshear visible also upon upthrown side.
dominance of slip along R-shears in the early phase of the deformation. The same pattern is shown in Plate 5a, where the shears form open superficial cracks upon drying. Where R- and R'-shears cut into a sand/shale bedding plane, characteristic graben structures are formed, as is seen in Plate 5b. Shears that cut into a shale at such localities have been found to end in a zone of continuous deformation.
Clay smears The clay smears found in the major fault zones form a continuous band which is gradually thinning away from the source bed (see Plates 1 and 3). The smears consists of remarkably pure clay material. At places these smears can reach a thickness of approximately 1 m, but thicknesses of the order of 1020 cm are more common. Along portions of the "Max Rudolph" fault, a continuous smear exists over the
43
total throw interval of more than 70 m (Plate 1). Smears occasionally contain clay material from different beds, that tends to become sharply aligned, with hardly any inclusions of other material from the fault walls, giving the smear a layered appearance (Plate 3). Sandy material between two distinct clay smears is found only at locations where a shale bed merges with a smear from a different source bed, but the sand wedges seen at these locations were associated with the flexure formed by the shale source bed, allowing the two distinct clay smears to merge into a single, layered smear beyond the zone of flexing (Fig. 1). The material forming the clay smear is supplied both from the upthrown and the downthrown parts of a source bed (see Plate 3a, for example). The thicker clay beds clearly produce thicker and longer smears. Full continuity in strike direction could be confirmed for about 400 m of exposure of the smear shown in Plate 1. In the Frechen mines, there is substantial evidence to suggest that continuous smears extend over large distances in strike and dip direction and that these smears act as a seal against transverse flow of groundwater, a fact that requires careful consideration in the mining operations. Fig. 2 summarizes in a schematic fashion the main features associated with the continuous clay smears that were observed in the major fault zones of the Frechen mines. It is reproduced from Weber et al. (1978), again to provide a synthesis of the most pertinent observations and a convenient reference in the subsequent discussion.
Mechanism of clay smear emplacement suggested by observations The overall picture emerging in the course of this field study was that clay smears are formed consistently on all scales in the Frechen exposures, where they represent a "universal" phenomenon. This would suggest that the conditions necessary for the emplacement of clay smears in minor shear bands are the same as those met along the major faults. Among the factors that are likely to determine the thickness, length and continuity of a smear, the thickness of the source bed and the fault throw are readily identified in the field. The requirement that the shales possess the necessary "plasticity" is also clearly met, i.e., the shale source bed material may be characterized as highly plastic, fat clay in accordance with the standard soil mechanics classification (Bowles, 1984).
Extrusion of plastic clays from source beds In the Frechen mines, one often sees evidence for
F.K. Lehner and W.F. Pilaar
44
Fig. 1. Merging of two clay smears to form layered smear (cf. Plate 3b).
extrusion of plastic clay material into the open air, where source beds are intersected by the excavation surface. This observation can be made on all scales, from clay seams only a few millimeters thick to major shale beds. Drying hardens the clay and this embrittlement process appears to stop the squeeze-out. This suggests that a similar extrusion phenomenon may be involved in the emplacement of clay smears. The argument is based on the reasonable assumption that the large-scale stresses giving rise to normal faulting in the sands may be approximated in terms of the average bulk density of the sediments p, the density of water Pw, the burial depth D, and the angle of internal friction q~ by crv = p g D
vertical total stress in sands
trh = k p ' y D + p w g D
horizontal total stress in sands
(1)
(2) where p ' = p - P w is an effective overburden density, while k = (1 - sin ~p)/(1 + sin ~p) for poorly consolidated, i.e., only slightly cohesive sands. Outside any flexed portion in the immediate vicinity of a fault, a shale may be assumed to remain under stresses close to hydrostatic, so that for horizontal shale beds one may put t7h - "
(7 v
=
pgD
stresses in shales
(3)
It is now evident that if the above stress distribution in a horizontally stratified sand/shale sequence were to persist even after the truncation of a particular shale bed by the fault, then this hydrostatically stressed source bed would be put in juxtaposition with a sand at a much lower horizontal stress. In con-
sequence, the soft shale would be expected to flow towards the fault intersection, i.e., would extrude from the source bed in a manner similar to that observed along the totally unloaded excavation faces. As discussed by Weber et al. (1978), the same mechanism appears to have operated in experiments performed by Mandl et al. (1977), during which continuous clay smears were produced in a ring-shear apparatus by extruding material from a sheared-off clay band. In these experiments, the much smaller difference between the fault-parallel and the faultnormal stress within the plastic clay, as compared with that in the sand, must have caused the observed extrusion. Extrusion, as such, of plastic clays from faulted source beds does not fully explain the emplacement of clay smears in a fault zone, however. Are clay smears put in place by an "injection" process, in the manner of a dyke intrusion? In fact, nothing appears to support such the idea of a forced injection. On all scales clay smears always tend to connect the offset portions of a source bed. They are never observed to extend upwards from the upthrown or downwards from the downthrown source bed and must indeed be viewed as genuine smears. Thus, while the abovediscussed horizontal excess stress will be essential as an agency for clay extrusion from a source bed, it clearly cannot account for the transport of the clay material in the fault zone. In other words, clay smear emplacement requires the shearing action of active fault motion and cannot be viewed solely as the result of injection into a stationary plane of weakness. On the other hand, shearing alone also cannot possibly account for the emplacement of tens of meters of continuous clay smear. The main observation ruling out this "simple shearing" interpretation is that major fault zones, such as that of the Max Rudolph fault shown in Plate 1 accommodate almost the total fault displacement within a fault-zone width that tends differ only little from the clay smear thickness (cf. also the sample shown in Plate 2b, where the clay smear is found to be bounded by principal displacement shears). A further pertinent observation in this context is the extreme narrowness of the fault zone that is observed in positions with sand/sand juxtaposition above an upthrown and below a downthrown source bed (cf. locations (3) in Fig. 2). This suggests that the mechanism of clay smear emplacement must involve both a component of shear transport within the faultzone as well as a component of continuous supply from the source bed. How do these different mechanisms cooperate in reality? A solution to this problem is suggested by observations made at Frechen and will now be described.
45
The emplacement of clay smears in synsedimentary normal faults
Fig. 2. Mainobservations along sealing faults.
Pull-apart mechanism of clay-smear emplacement A continuous supply of clay material from the source bed to the shear zone can be maintained, given the necessary "plastic" properties of the material, if a driving horizontal stress difference between distant parts of the source bed and the immediate vicinity of the fault can be maintained. This requires some mechanism of horizontal stress relief to operate at the fault intersection of a source bed. Preferably, the same mechanism should be capable of resolving the space problem implied by the emplacement of massive clay smears. Such a mechanism was in fact conceived at some stage in the course of this study, in the first place as a way to overcome the space problem kinematically. Thus we invented the "pull-apart" mechanism shown in Fig. 3. On traversing a shale source bed, a normal fault only has to be offset in the direction of the downthrown block in order to make room for the emplacement of a clay smear. Evidently, this mechanism
can also provide an effective way of unloading the source bed along the rupture faces, thus facilitating the extrusion of plastic clay material. The extruded material will fill the gap created by the pull-apart mechanism. It will thereby enter the shear zone proper, where it will be subjected to the slow shearing imparted by the relative displacement of the fault blocks, to be smeared out along the fault. The pull-apart mechanism that has just been described served as a valuable working hypothesis, which, in its final form (see Fig. 4), provided a unifying explanation for all main observations as summarized in Fig. 2 above. The difference between the process depicted in Fig. 4 and the principle sketched in Fig. 3 is that the former suggests an explanation for the fault offset, by linking it to the development and eventual mode of failure of a monoclinal flexure in the shale bed. Our observations thus suggest the following main stages in the development of a continuous clay smear long a major fault (cf. Fig. 4). (a) A newly deposited, highly plastic shale first forms a monocline in re-
46
F.K. Lehner and W.F. Pilaar
reconstructed from field evidence, such as shown in Plates 4 and 5. The pattern of shear bands formed in the course of this early deformation is eventually cut through by the fault, the part lying on the downthrown block becoming displaced along the fault into a position corresponding to that of Plate 4 and explaining the observations made there, in particular the truncation of R'-shears that exhibit several centimeters of slip displacement close to the fault. A simple approximate argument can explain the spatial orientation of the pattern of shears shown in Fig. 5, as follows. First, it is stipulated that on traversing the shale bed, the fault is offset in the direction of the downthrown block, but maintains its angle of dip in propagating into the accumulating sand above. Moreover, if the deformation immediately preceding the development of a fault in the overlying sand is visualized as forming a plastic "hinge" zone in a Coulomb material at peak strength, with the maximum rate of shearing taking place on planes roughly parallel to the future fault plane, and if it is further
Fig. 3. Kinematics of "pull-apart" of shale source bed during faulting.
sponse to faulting of its substratum, in a manner observed by Cloos (1930) in experimentally deformed clay layers. The slip systems described by Cloos correspond closely to the R- and R'-shears seen in the sands and along the sand/shale interface, but rarely visible in the freshly cut shales (see also the discussion of Fig. 5 below). (b) With continuing burial, the shale bed is gradually disrupted as faulting progresses from the underlying sand into the accumulating sandy overburden. There the fault follows a path that is slightly offset towards the downthrown block. (c) The gap implied by the pull-apart and accompanying fault offset is closed by the extrusion of clay material from the truncated source beds and the subsequent formation of a clay smear. Extrusion is consistent with the thinning and associated faulting of the source bed close to the fault (cf. also Figs. 1 and 2). The same sequence of events also explains more subtle features. For example, the consistently observed gradual increase in shearing intensity (i.e., density of fault-parallel D-shears) within the sandy portion of a fault zone as one moves against the relative slip direction on either side of a clay smear, i.e., in the direction of increasing total slip displacement of sand against sand (cf. Fig. 2). Fig. 5 depicts the early stage in the deformation of the sandy material immediately above a shale bed as
Fig. 4. Three stages in the disruption of a ductile shale bed by an upward propagating normal fault; pull-apart allowing the emplacement of massive clay smears.
The emplacement of clay smears in synsedimentary normal faults
47
ments. This is not to say that the problem of fault propagation through rheologically layered sequences offers no scope for further experimental studies, especially perhaps, if one were to adopt a strategy of "conservation of material" (Mandel, 1962) in combination with centrifuge techniques. Certain essential aspects of the problem may well be tackled theoretically. Thus, it should be possible to model the important initiation phase of faulting in the overlying sands prior to the development of a throughgoing fault in the highly ductile shale, i.e., while the latter is forming a macroscopically smooth monocline. Of particular interest would be studies of rupture transgression across a shale bed, focussing on the development of a fault offset in the manner depicted in Fig. 4. Since fault offset is likely to determine the thickness, continuity, and overall length of clay smears along a throw interval, any quantitative link of fault offset to factors such as material characteristics of the shales, shale bed thickness, depth of burial, and possibly fault slip rate, should contribute significantly to our ability to predict the occurrence of substantial clay smears. Fig. 5. Mohr-circle construction of precursory R- and R'-shears that form early during upward-propagation of normal fault through ductile shale bed. The maximum shear stress is assumed to occur on faultparallel planes; the shear orientations are obtained through the use of Terzaghi's pole construction (Mandl et al., 1977).
assumed that the maximum shear stress occurs along the same plane, then the R- and R'-shears can readily be explained as conjugate sets of Coulomb slip surfaces by means of the Mohr-diagram construction shown in Fig. 5 (see also Mandl et al. (1977) for a detailed discussion of this coaxiality assumption for shear zones in frictional materials). This simple argument can explain the consistently observed orientation of conjugate sets of R- and R'shears in the field; it also links the presence of such shears in a fringe zone or "damage zone" on either side of the shear zone proper to a precursory deformation, which is visualized here as taking place in a "process zone" just ahead of the tip line of the propagating fault. The fault offset shown in the conceptual Figs. 3 and 4 not only solves a geometrical problem, but may also correspond to a mechanically preferred rupture transgression of the shale bed, primarily because faulting at the shale/overburden interface would be expected to nucleate where the strains are largest, i.e., near the point of maximum curvature of that interface (cf. Fig. 4a,b). Early laboratory model experiments appear to support such an interpretation (Cloos, 1930; Rettger, 1935; Wunderlich, 1957), but can hardly be viewed as conclusive in view of the notorious difficulty of satisfying scaling require-
Criteria for the ranking of seal quality We shall now discuss a simple dimensional argument, put forward in our original report, where we attempted to establish criteria that would allow one to discriminate between conditions favorable and unfavorable for the formation of clay smears. Taking as a starting point the picture drawn in Fig. 4, we considered that a continuity requirement on the relevant fluxes might furnish a first rough criterion. Thus, on one hand, one has the rate of extrusion qextr of ductile clays from their source beds, while on the other hand there is the rate of transport or "smearing" qsmear o f the clay material within the fault zone proper. If it is assumed then that the rate-dependent response of the soft clay material may be characterized simply by an effective viscosity, as for a Newtonian viscous fluid, then the total rate of extrusion from a horizontal source bed through a vertical cross-section close to the fault is given by an expression, well-known in the theory of lubrication squeeze flows (Langlois, 1964): h 3 ap
qextr =
12r/Ox
(4)
Here h is the source bed thickness (in m), r/ is the effective viscosity (in Pa s), and ap/ax is the pressure gradient in the source bed in the horizontal direction (in Pa/m); thus, qx is the total volumetric extrusion rate (in m2/s) per unit width perpendicular to a fault-
F.K. Lehner and W.F. Pilaar
48
dip section. A rough estimate of the magnitude of the pressure gradient in the source bed is provided by the ratio of the maximum stress difference in the surrounding sands divided by the layer thickness. Using Eqs. (1) and (2) we have crv - crh = (1 - k)p'gD and hence arrive at the estimate
(1-k)p'gDh 2 qextra --
12r/
Let it be assumed further that transport of clay or "smearing" within the shear zone proper is accomplished by simple shearing. Then the rate of transport per unit width perpendicular to a fault-dip section is given by qsmear =
lw3 2
where w is the local clay smear thickness and ~ is the local rate of slip of the downthrown block relative to the upthrown block. If we imagine now, that the sequential processes of clay extrusion and smearing progress through a sequence of approximately steady states such that, for reasons of continuity, the rates of these processes must be approximately equal, then qextra = qsmear
h 2 (1 - k)p' gD = 1 2Y]Wt~
where w must now be interpreted as the clay smear thickness close to the source bed. The last relationship provides some information on parameters that are likely to control the quality of a clay smear, where quality is expressed simply in terms of clay smear thickness close to the source bed. Other things remaining equal, it suggests that the smear "quality" may be expected to improve with increasing source bed thickness and burial depth, but to deteriorate with increasing fault slip rates and clay viscosity. The negative effects of an increase in slip rate and clay viscosity are intuitively expected. However, the capability of relation (7) to capture these effects quantitatively should not be overrated in view of the strongly simplifying assumptions on which it is based. Indeed, the most useful conclusion to be drawn from Eq. (7) is that clay smear thickness may be expected to depend strongly on source bed thickness. Thus, for linear viscous behavior Eq. (7) predicts the proportionality w ,,~ h 2. The equivalent result for a power-law secondary creep behavior of the clay would take the form w o~ h(" + ~, where n is the appropriate power-law stress exponent. Again, however, this distinction should not be overrated in view of the fact that very little appears to be known about secondary (deviatoric) creep of clays at strain rates less
than 10-1~ s-l, which are likely to characterize the slow process of clay extrusion from a source bed. The proportionality w ~ h 2 or w ~ h(" § 1) does, however, provide a simple criterion for ranking the sealing quality of any two clay smears that originate from distinct source beds with thicknesses h l and h2, respectively. In particular, in instances where two source beds form a layered clay smear within a given throw interval, the total contribution from these source beds to the smear would be ranked below the contribution from a single source bed of thickness h 1 + h2, simply because w ~ (hi 2 + h2 2) in the former case while w ~ h i + h 2 in the latter. In practice, any ranking procedure which is based on a partial description and limited quantitative understanding of a process should be used only in combination with additional empirical evidence, e.g., evid e n c e - in a specific geological setting - for the occurrence of clay smears along major faults. Adding to such knowledge, the geologist can then proceed to rank potential fault seals on the basis of the above criterion for "seal quality". Major uncertainties may indeed be set aside by a "calibration" against field data. Among others, these include the question of sufficient clay ductility (the factor r/) and slow enough fault slip rates (the factor 6 ). The latter, in particular, may be improperly constrained by the stratigraphic record, if faulting occurs in a jerky fashion, with long periods of quiescence or slow creep followed by episodes of accelerated creep or seismic slip. In situations where most of the fault displacement is due to rapid slip, the formation of smears by extrusion of clay material from source beds will become impossible, in qualitative agreement with criterion (7). An obvious shortcoming of the above criterion stems from the steady-state assumption which underlies Eq. (7). It implies, in particular, that nothing can be learned from Eq. (7) about the maximum length that might be attained by a clay smear. The criterion assumes indeed an unlimited supply of clay material at a fixed rate. In reality, however, the extrusion process must go together with a progressive thinning of the source bed and this phenomenon is indeed observed in the field (cf. Plates 3a and 5b). The maximum length of any continuous clay smear must therefore be controlled by the depth of penetration of the extrusion flow into the source bed, i.e., by the size of the region of supply. The actual length of a smear will of course be determined by the effectiveness of the transport mechanism that is implied by the term "smear". Here one can visualize several processes at work. Thus, for small enough fault throws, clay injection by excess pressures within the source bed may well furnish an important contribution, giving rise to
The emplacement of clay smears in synsedimentary normal faults
a combined shear- and squeeze-flow mode of transport of ductile clay material, although these excess pressures would not suffice to squeeze the material against the direction of shearing upwards beyond the upthrown source bed and downwards beyond the downthrown source bed. For larger throws, direct observations on fault zone structure (cf. Plates 1 and 2b) would suggest that the process of smearing involves episodes of smearing-without-slip and slipwithout-smearing, whose occurrence is governed by such factors as clay properties, depth (i.e., stress level) and fault displacement rates. That such behavior would tend to limit seal length is clear, but the process itself remains poorly understood. In the absence of further experimental and theoretical work that would elucidate and help quantifying the smearing process, one is therefore left with an empirical ranking procedure that rests on a number of key observations, which have been incorporated together with other factors in the procedure used by Fulljames et al. (1997) in this volume.
Conclusions The clay smears observed in the shallow deltaic sequence of the Frechen mines occur on all scales, ranging from minor shears with clay source laminae less than 1 cm in thickness and slip displacements of the order of centimeters to major normal faults with clay source bed thicknesses in the meter range and continuous smears over some 70 m of fault throw. Direct observations in the Frechen mines show that soft clay material is extruded from source beds, where these are intersected by an excavation surface. We also present evidence for clay extrusion at fault intersections of minor and major source beds. We explain the occurrence of extrusion by horizontal excess stresses in highly ductile source beds. The emplacement of the extruded material within a fault zone as clay smear we ascribe to the shearing action imposed by the wall rock. Thick clay smears appear to be accommodated within a faultzone by a slight offset of the fault in the direction of the downthrown block, as the fault cuts upwards through a shale source bed in the course of its burial. Slow fault displacement rates, typical of synsedimentary faults, and sufficient clay "plasticity" appear to be essential to the occurrence of these phenomena. Thicker source beds produce thicker smears and from simple theoretical considerations one may expect the square of source bed thickness to enter as a key parameter into the ranking of seal quality. The length of continuous smears increases with source bed thickness, but must ultimately be controlled by the smearing process. The latter remains to be investigated in detail.
49
Acknowledgements The field studies in the Frechen mines were made possible by the kind permission of the management of Rheinische Braunkohlenwerke AG, Ki31n and the generous support offered by its technical staff, which are herewith gratefully acknowledged. The paper is published by permission of Shell Research B.V.
References Bowles, J.E. 1984. Physical and Geotechnical Properties of Soils, 2nd edn. McGraw-Hill, New York. Cloos, H. 1930. Zur experimentellen Tektonik. Geol. Rundschau 21: 353-367. Edwards, A.B., Baker, G. and Knight, J.L. 1944. The geology of the Wonthaggi coal field, Victoria. Proc. Aust. Inst. Min. Met. N.S. 134: 1-54. Fulljames, J.R., Zijerveld, L.J.J., Franssen, R.C.M.W., Ingram, G.M. and Richard, P.D. 1997. Fault seal processes. In: P. M~llerPedersen and A.G. Koestler (Editors), Hydrocarbon Seals: Importance for Exploration and Production, NPF Special Publication 7. Elsevier, Singapore, pp. 51-59. Gu, Y. and Wong, T.-f. 1994. Development of shear localization in simulated quartz gouge. PAGEOPH, 143: 387-423. Knipe, R.J. 1992. Faulting processes and fault seal. In: R.M. Larsen, H. Brekke, B.T. Larsen and E. Talleraas (Editors), Structural and Tectonic Modelling and its Application to Petroleum Geology, NPF Special Publication 1. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 325342. Langlois, W.E. 1964. Slow Viscous Flow. Macmillan, New York. Lindsay, N.G., Murphy, F.C., Walsh, J.J. and Watterson, J. 1993. Outcrop studies of shale smears on fault surfaces. Special Publication 15. Int. Assoc. Sediment, pp. 113-123. Logan, J.T., Friedman, M., Higgs, N., Dengo, C.A. and Shimamoto, T. 1979. Experimental studies of simulated gouge and their application to studies of natural fault zones. Proc. Congr. VIII - Analysis of Actual Fault Zones in Bedrock. US Geol. Surv. Open-file Report 79-1239, pp. 305-343. Logan, J.T., Dengo, C.A., Higgs, N. and Wang, Z.Z. 1992. Fabrics of experimental fault zones: their development and relationship to mechanical behaviour. In: B. Evans and T.-f. Wong (Editors), Fault Mechanics and Transport Properties of Rock. Academic Press, New York, pp. 34--67. Mandel, J. 1962. Essais sur models r6duit en mechanique de terrains. Etude des conditions de similitude. Rev. Industrie Minerale 44: 611-620. Mandl, G., de Jong, L.N.J. and Maltha, A. 1977. Shear zones in granular material. Rock Mech. 9: 95-144. Morgenstern, N.R. and Tchalenko, J.S. 1967. Microscopic structures in kaolin subject to direct shear. G6otechnique. 17: 309-328. Perkins, H. 1961. Fault-closure type fields, Southeast Lousiana. Trans. Gulf Coast Assoc. Geol. Soc. 11: 177-196. Prange, W. 1958. Tektonik und Sedimentation in den Deckschichten des Niederrheinischen Hauptbraunkohlenfl6zes in der Ville, mit Bemerkungen zur Feintektonik der Niederrheinischen Bucht. Fortschr. Geol. Rheinld. Westf. 2: 651-682. Quitzow, H.W. 1954. Tektonik und Grundwasserstockwerke im Erftbecken. Geol. J. 69: 455-464. Rettger, R.E. 1935. Experiments on soft-rock deformation. Am. Ass. Pet. Geol. Bull. 19:271-292. Skempton, A.W. 1966. Some observations on tectonic shear zones. Proc. 1st Congr. Int. Soc. Rock. Mech. Lisbon, Vol. 1, pp. 329385. Smith, D.A. 1980. Sealing and nonsealing faults in Lousiana Gulf Coast salt basin. Am. Ass. Pet. Geol. Bull. 64: 145-172.
F.K. Lehner and W.F. Pilaar
50 Tchalenko, J.S. 1970. Similarities between shear zones of different magnitudes. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. 81: 1625-1640. Weber, K.J. 1987. Hydrocarbon distribution patterns in Nigerian growth fault structures controlled by structural style and stratigraphy. J. Pet. Sci. Eng. 1: 91-104. Weber, K.J., Mandl, G., Pilaar, W.F., Lehner, F.K. and Precious, R.G.
1978. The role of faults in hydrocarbon migration and trapping in Nigerian growth fault structures. Proc. 10th Ann. Offshore Technol. Conf., Houston, TX, Vol. 4, pp. 2643-2653. Wunderlich, H.G. 1957. Briiche und Gr~iben im tektonischen Experiment. N. Jahrbuch f. Geologie u. Pal~iontologie. Monatshefte pp. 477-498.
F.K. LEHNER Institute for Geodynamics, Bonn University, Nussalle 8, D-53115 Bonn, Germany W.F. PILAAR J.F. Kennedy plantsoen 63, 2252 EV Voorschoten, The Netherlands
51
Fault seal processes- systematic analysis of fault seals over
geological and production time scales J.R. Fulljames, L.J.J. Zijerveld and R.C.M.W. Franssen
Fault seal analysis should apply a rigorous, integrated strategy, including all possible aspects of fault seals as well as top seals. In this paper we describe data and empirical relationships that enable a quantitative approach to fault seal prediction. We subdivide fault seals into juxtaposition seals and fault gouge seals. Clay smear continuity along a fault is quantified using the clay smear potential formula, which can be calibrated using data from proven oil accumulations. Prediction of brittle deformation mechanisms, and related retention capacities as well as fault transmissibilities can be based on empirical relationships with measurable matrix properties presented in this paper. On geological time scales the retention capacity of a fault seal depends on the minimum capillary entry pressure encountered along it. All categories of fault seals may greatly affect production behaviour. The effects on production of faults acting as transmissibility barriers are illustrated using reservoir simulation models.
Introduction
P e HCwater n f c o l u m n --
The initial step in quantification of fault sealing is to identify the mechanism(s) involved in fault sealing. We subdivide fault seals into two types based on: (1) geometrical or juxtaposition fault seals, where the hydrocarbons are trapped by the sealing properties of the juxtaposed lithology and (2) fault gouge seals where the fault gouge material itself retains hydrocarbons. Fault seals caused by processes such as clay smear, brittle deformation and diagenesis fall into this latter category (Fig. 1). The prediction of fault seal capacity requires the evaluation of each fault seal mechanism and its possible effect on fault sealing.
(1) g(/gwate r - - / 9 HC )
If a fault is hydrocarbon-wet or the pressure difference across it exceeds the capillary entry pressure, it will leak and become a permeability barrier to flow. The probability that a hydrc:arbon column will be retained by a permeability barrier over geological time is a function of the rate of flow through the fault. In the case of Darcy flow, the rate of flow (Q) per unit area is proportional to the pressure gradient (AP/Ax) across the fault, the fault permeability (x), and inversely proportional to the fluid viscosity (,u): x AP Q=--• (2) kt Ax
Capillary seals versus permeability barriers Fault sealing over geological time scales Faults that are water wet act as capillary seals, i.e., retention is controlled by capillary entry pressure (Smith, 1980; Watts, 1987; Ingram and Naylor, 1997). In a water-hydrocarbon system, the fault's minimum capillary entry pressure is the maximum pressure difference which can be maintained across the fault before the hydrocarbons have sufficient pressure to breach through the pore throats and leak across the fault. Over geological time a fault is only as sealing as its most leaky part. The static sealing capacity of a fault is the maximum hydrocarbon column length (HCco~umn) which can be retained by this fault over geological time. It depends on the capillary entry pressure of the seal for a specific hydrocarbonwater interface (Pencwat~,), the difference between water and hydrocarbon densities at depth (DwaterPuc), and the acceleration of gravity (g)
In the following sections we outline a systematic approach to analyse fault sealing over geological time scales, integrating geometric fault seals and fault gouge seals (Fig. 2).
Juxtaposition fault seals A pre-requisite for fault seal analysis is a consistent structural model, with sufficient detail and proper fault linkage relationships. The first step of static fault seal analysis (Fig. 2) involves the construction of a juxtaposition diagram (Allan, 1989), in which areas where reservoir is juxtaposed against a sealing lithology are identified. The retention capacity is calculated from the minimum capillary entry pressure of the juxtaposed lithology, which can be measured or
Hydrocarbon Seals: Importance for Exploration and Production edited by P. M~ller-Pedersen and A.G. Koestler. NPF Special Publication 7, pp. 51-59, Elsevier, Singapore. 9 Norwegian Petroleum Society (NPF) 1997
52
J.R. Fulljames, L.J.J. Zijerveld and R. C.M.W. Franssen
Fig. 1. Classification of fault seal processes. Fault seals are divided into two types: juxtaposition fault seals and fault gouge seals (e.g., cataclasis and clay smear). One fault may have a combination of different sealing processes affecting its sealing capacity.
predicted from a database of lithology properties. Shales have high entry pressures due to their small pore throat sizes (Ingram and Naylor, 1997). They retain large columns and traps with juxtaposed shales tend to be filled to the fault spill point (geometry dependent). Coarser lithologies, such as siltstones, have lower retention capacities due to their larger pore throat sizes (Watts, 1987). The retainable hydrocarbon column lengths are therefore strongly controlled by
properties of the juxtaposed lithology (lithology dependent). Fault gouge seals The second stage of static fault seal analysis is the evaluation of the properties of the fault gouge (Fig. 2). In the presence of clay layers, the introduction of clay into a fault is one way of strongly increasing the capillary entry pressure. A common process is the
Fig. 2. Strategy for the analysis of fault seals over geological time scales. Based on a fault juxtaposition diagram, the effects of the different fault seal processes are assessed in a systematic manner for their seal capacity due to clay smear, brittle fault sealing and juxtaposition fault seal.
Fault seal processes: systematic analysis of fault seals over geological and production time scales
smearing of clay into the fault by a combination of ductile flow and dilation of the fault zone (Lehner and Pilaar, 1997). The effectiveness of clay smearing strongly depends on the ductility of the clays at the time of deformation, which can be assessed from sonic log trends and consolidation history (Ingram and Naylor, 1997). In high net to gross stratigraphies, or if clays were not ductile at the time of deformation, faults should be assessed for their sealing properties due to brittle faulting.
Clay smear Clay smear forms as a result of a ductile flow of clay source bed whereby the clay is squeezed into and smeared along the fault between the up and down
53
thrown source beds (Fig. 3) (Weber et al., 1978; Smith, 1980; Lindsay et al., 1993; Lehner and Pilaar, 1997). The amount of clay smear at a point on the fault reduces with distance to the source bed. The smear forms a layered gouge containing clay from each source bed. The greater the number and thickness of source beds, within the throw window, the greater the thickness of the smear. A thick smear is more likely to be continuous across the area of the fault, whereas a thin smear is more likely to be discontinuous. Aside from easily derivable quantities like fault throw and stratigraphic bed thickness there are several other factors which affect the amount of clay smear, like the clay rheology during deformation, the
Fig. 3. Outcrop picture of a clay smear. Photograph was taken in a lignite quarry in SE Germany, throw ca. 10 cm. It shows the cumulative effect of two thin clay layers. The deformation occurs by a combination of squeeze flow, as indicated by thinning of the source bed, and simple shear as evidenced by the sharp contacts between fault gouge and undeformed rock.
54
Fig. 4. Schematic diagram of the clay smear potential calculation. The CSP is calculated at a certain point at a fault from the thickness of individual clay source beds (hi), and the distance from the source beds to that point (si). For each clay bed that passed the calculation point, the thickness is squared and divided over the distance (h i + si). The clay smears derived from all source beds that passed the calculation point are summed, both for the upthrown and downthrown side (CSP-, CSP+). The highest of these is found to have the most predictive power and taken as the CSP. A calibration term (c) is included to cover rheological properties and stress dependencies of clay smear.
depth of deformation and the angle of the fault. The present quantification of clay smear potential (CSP) includes 0nly the geometrical effects of fault throw and stratigraphic bed thickness (Fig. 4) (Bouvier et
J.R. Fulljames, L.J.J. Zijerveld and R. C.M. W. Franssen
al., 1989). A calibration term is included to cover rheological properties (i.e., weaker clays form better smears) and stress dependencies of clay smear (clay smear formation is favoured by low normal stress on the fault). The CSP value is interpreted to represent an indication of the continuity of a clay smear seal. As it is a relative measure, it can be used to rank prospects along faults of similar type within similar stratigraphies. To actually calculate the hydrocarbon column length retained by a fault sealed by clay smear, a calibration must be performed using faults known to retain hydrocarbons across sand to sand juxtaposition windows. By overlaying both CSP data and hydrocarbon fill data on the juxtaposition diagram, the lowest CSP values at sealed sand to sand contacts can be found. A compilation of CSP studies shows that an increased number of traps are filled at higher CSP (Fig. 5), i.e., CSP should be used in a probabilistic manner, where high CSP indicates a greater chance of an intact fault seal, than low CSP.
Brittle deformation of reservoir sandstones The prediction of the sealing effect of brittle deformation in reservoir sandstones involves several steps (Figs. 2 and 6). At present, predictions are limited to clean sandstones. The initial step assesses the potential for and extent of cataclastic deformation. If cataclastic deformation can be shown to be the likely deformation mechanism, then the fault properties can
Fig. 5. CSP calibration. The data for this calibration were gathered on 91 reservoirs along 10 faults in three different fields. Comparing the CSP in hydrocarbon bearing sand to sand windows with those in water bearing sand to sand windows results in a fault seal probability curve. The fault seal probability increases with increasing CSP up to a certain value above which sealing is independent of CSP.
Fault seal processes: systematic analysis of fault seals over geological and production time scales
55
Fig. 6. Brittle fault seal analysis strategy. The strategy aims to quantify the sealing capacity of brittle faults by first predicting the deformation mechanism. Particulate flow faults are treated as non-sealing. Cataclastic faults have variable sealing properties according to fault throw and matrix properties. The chart in the lower left of this figure is reproduced at a larger scale in Fig. 8.
be estimated from empirical relationships. These estimates together with throw and fault continuity are combined to predict the fault's overall retention capacity. The brittle deformation mechanism map for clean reservoir sandstones (Fig. 6) relates the type of deformation to matrix porosity and depth of burial at the time of deformation (Loosveld and Franssen, 1992). It is based on data from deformation experiments on cored samples and field specimens. As a rule of thumb, at less than 1 km depth, high porosity sandstones deform by particulate flow (Fig. 6). During particulate flow, the grains roll past one another without grain crushing and the pores within the fault zone tend to dilate. After deformation, the faults are buried and compacted. Unless significant diagenesis occurs, the resulting fault gouge has properties not significantly different from the surrounding matrix and negligible retention capacity. At greater depths (and consequently lower porosities), faults tend to deform by cataclasis (Fig. 6). Grain crushing along discrete shear faults leads to significant grain size reduction within fault zones (Fig. 7). Subsequent compaction and cementation of the deformed fault gouge during further burial, cause significant reductions in fault porosity and permeability and increased capillary entry pressures. An extensive database has been collected to develop empirical relationships which enable the prediction of cataclastic fault properties from measurable matrix properties. Fig. 8 illustrates how the perme-
ability change of a fault, relative to the surrounding reservoir rock, varies with porosity. Faults which are currently deforming are termed active faults whereas faults which have been buried, compacted, and cemented are termed inactive faults. The available data cover deformation bands and to a lesser extent slip planes. The normal statistical variation in these types of data tends to be quite large. Apart from that, some of the spread in the data may be due to variations in lithology, strain rate, total displacement and burial depth at which the faults were active. These effects are not accounted for. At small fault displacements, deformation bands form a loosely anastomosing network. As displacement increases slip planes develop. Ultimately, deformation bands become more and more linked, forming a closer network and slip planes become increasingly continuous. On slip planes, the intensity of cataclasis is significantly increased, which results in a further reduction in permeability of two orders of magnitude compared to small scale cataclastic deformation bands (Fig. 8). An empirical relationship of capillary entry pressures and permeability (Fig. 9) can be used for the prediction of retainable hydrocarbon column length for cataclastic faults (Eq. (1)). The development described from loosely anastomosing deformation bands to zones of highly interconnected deformation bands and slip planes has major implications for retention capacity (Loosveld and Franssen, 1992; Antonellini and Aydin, 1994, 1995). At low fault displacements the retention ca-
J.R. Fulljames, L.J.J. Zijerveld and R. C.M.W. Franssen
56
Fig. 7. SEM image of a cataclastic fault gouge in a clean sandstone.
pacity will be negligible and as displacement increases, the retention capacity will increase to deformation band properties and subsequently to slip plane properties. Improved understanding of internal fault geometries will enable better estimation of retention capacities (ideally from a mapable quantity like fault displacement).
Permeable fault seals
Simple one-dimensional reservoir models (two phase Darcy flow) indicate that, in general, the flow rates across permeable fault seals will be too high to sustain high pressure gradients or corresponding differences in hydrocarbon column lengths over geo-
Fig. 8. Matrix porosity versus permeability reduction in faults. The upper trend describes the range of permeabilities observed within actively deforming cataclastic deformation bands. Permeabilities are enhanced at low porosities, and slightly reduced at high porosities. The lower trend describes how inactive faults after burial show highly reduced permeability relative to the matrix. This permeability reduction gets more significant with increasing matrix porosity.
Fault seal processes: systematic analysis of fault seals over geological and production time scales
57
Fig. 9. Permeability versus capillary entry pressure. Entry pressure increases with decreasing permeability. The regression line drawn through the data was derived for a range of lithologies by Ibrahim et al. (1970) (Watts, 1987; Antonellini and Aydin, 1995). The relationship appears to hold for the cataclastic faults as well. Some of the deviations from the regression are due to uncertainties in the thickness of the deformation bands and slip planes, which lead to overestimated fracture permeabilities of up to one order of magnitude.
logical time (several millions of years). This is due to the fact that the widths of faults are small and fault permeabilities are relatively high. On a production time scale, however, these faults are seen to have a significant effect on reservoir behaviour.
Fault sealing over production time scales On production time scales, faults may leak and become permeability barriers if the entry pressure has been exceeded by the pressure difference across the fault. Once the seal is breached, "Darcy" flow of hydrocarbons occurs across the fault. In the case of a juxtaposition fault seal, the large thickness and low permeability of the sealing lithology lead to negligible flow rates. Due to their variable permeabilities and relatively small widths, the leak rates through fault gouge seals tend to be significantly higher. We describe a systematic strategy to quantify the various factors which inhibit the flow of hydrocarbons across faults. Faults acting as flow barriers over production time scales will develop pressure lags, and reduce the drainage efficiency of faulted reservoirs. Fault properties controlling the magnitude of the pressure lag across a permeable fault are the fault transmissibility (its capacity to resist flow based on average sealing properties) and the size of the area on the fault across which flow can occur. Additional controls are the size of the reservoir compartments (the bigger the non-producing compartment the bigger the pressure lag), and the rate of pressure draw down in the producing block.
The effectiveness of a fault as a flow barrier is hard to measure directly but can be estimated from 1-D and 3-D flow simulations of field examples. The results give estimates which can be applied to similar faults of unknown properties. An example where such a methodology was used is schematically illustrated in Fig. 10. A hydrocarbon filled block, in an existing field, was produced over a number of years from a single producing cluster. A series of observation wells monitoring the depletion profiles over several years in different fault blocks, revealed pressure lags developing through time. The magnitude of these pressure lags was different across different faults. A model was built using the best estimates of the variables including volumetrics, stratigraphy, leak window area, hydrocarbon and aquifer properties. By "producing" hydrocarbons, the pressure in one block was depleted at the measured rate while the depletion profiles of the non-producing block were monitored. The least known parameter, the transmissibility of the faults, was varied until a history match was achieved between the modelled and observed depletion profiles. Comparison for different faults showed that faults with small displacements had to be modelled with higher transmissibilities than faults with large displacements.
Discussion We strongly recommend a rigorous, integrated strategy to fault seal analysis, including all possible aspects of fault as well as top seals. The rigour of the
58
J.R. Fulljames, L.J.J. Zijerveld and R. C.M. W. Franssen
Fig. 10. Flow simulation pressure history match. A simple block model was depleted by producing gas from a production well. The fault transmissibility varied to alter depletion rates in the non-producing block until a best-fit pressure history match was achieved. The resulting transmissibility could be related to the observed throw on the fault.
analysis strongly depends on the quantity and quality of the data available. We have reached a high level of understanding of clay smear seals and cataclastic seals in clean reservoir sands. Our studies are currently aimed at expanding our knowledge to other lithologies like micaceous sands, carbonates and brittle shales. In addition we focus on an improved understanding of the internal fault zone geometry, and how this varies with fault displacement. It seems unlikely to formulate a general approach to analysis of diagenetic overprints on the mechanically formed fault gouge fabrics. In our present approach, these are assessed on a field by field basis.
Conclusions We subdivide fault seals into juxtaposition seals and fault gouge seals. Juxtaposition seals retain hydrocarbons due to the geometrical juxtaposition of a
sealing lithology across a fault. At fault gouge seals, hydrocarbon retention depends on the properties of the material in the fault zone itself. The minimum capillary entry pressure of a seal determines the retainable hydrocarbon column length on geological time scales. Permeable fault seals are unlikely to retain significant hydrocarbon columns on geological time scales, but may have a significant effect on production behaviour. Effective clay smears are likely to form along synsedimentary faults in low net to gross sections. It can be quantified using the geometrically derived CSP equation, which requires fault throw and stratigraphic data. High CSP values relate to thick, continuous clay smears with high retention capacities. Low CSP values relate to thin, discontinuous clay smears which may act as strong transmissibility barriers over production time scales. The prediction of the retention capacity of a fault due to Clay smear requires calibration on known fault-bounded accumulations
Fault seal processes: systematic analysis o f fault seals over geological and production time scales
Faults in sandstones deformed at depths greater than 1 km tend to deform by cataclasis. Permeability and entry pressure of such faults can be predicted from estimates of matrix properties. Static seal capacities of cataclastic faults depend on the minimum sealing properties, which are related to the fault displacements. Identifying fault barriers, and the compartments resulting from them, at an early stage of production can help to optimise development well planning. Faults become more effective transmissibility barriers with increasing average sealing properties, decreasing leak window areas and increasing size of nonproducing blocks.
Acknowledgements Shell International Exploration and Production B.V. is thanked for granting permission to publish this paper.
References Allan, U.S. 1989. Model for hydrocarbon migration and entrapment within faulted structures. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 73: 803811. Antonellini, M. and Aydin, A. 1994. Effect of faulting on fluid flow in porous sandstones. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 78: 355-377.
Antonellini, M. and Aydin, A. 1995. Effect of faulting in porous sandstones: geometry and spatial distributions. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 79: 642-671. Bouvier, J.D., Kaars-Sijpesteijn, C.H., Kluesner, D.F., Onyejekwe, C.C. and van der Pal, R.C. 1989. Three-dimensional seismic interpretation and fault sealing investigations, Nun River Field, Nigeria. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 73: 1397-1414. Ibrahim, M.A., Tek, M.R. and Katz, D.L. 1970. Threshold Pressure in Gas Storage. American Gas Association, Arlington, VA, 309 pp. Ingram, G.A. and Naylor, M.A. 1997. Top seal processes and assessment. In: P. Mr and A.G. Koeslter (Editors), Hydrocarbon Seals: Importance for Exploration and Production, NPF Special Publication 7. Elsevier, Singapore, pp. 165-174. Lehner, F.K. and Pilaar, W.F. 1997. On a mechanism of clay smear emplacement in synsedimentary normal faults. In: P. M~llerPedersen and A.G. Koeslter (Editors), Hydrocarbon Seals: Importance for Exploration and Production, NPF Special Publication 7. Elsevier, Singapore, pp. 39-50. Lindsay, N.G., Murphy, F.C., Walsh, J.J. and Watterson, J. 1993. Outcrop studies of shale smears on fault surfaces. Special Publication 15. Int. Assoc. Sediment, pp. 113-123. Loosveld, R.J.H. and Franssen, R.C.M.W. 1992. Extensional versus shear fractures - implications for reservoir characterisation. SPE.25017. Smith, D.A. 1980. Sealing and non-sealing faults in Louisiana Gulf Coast basins. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 64: 145-172. Watts, N.L. 1987. Theoretical aspects of cap-rock and fault seals for single and two-phase hydrocarbon columns. Marine Pet. Geol., 4: 274-307. Weber, K.J., Mandl, G., Pilaar, W.F., Lehner, F. and Precious, R.G. 1978. The role of faults in hydrocarbon migration and trapping in Nigerian growth fault structures. Proc. 10th Annual Offshore Technology Conf.
Shell International Exploration & Production BV., P.O. Box 60, 2280 AB Rijswijk, The Netherlands Shell International Exploration & Production BV., P.O. Box 60, 2280 AB Rijswijk, The Netherlands Present address: 21 Oxford Street, Edinburgh EH8 9PQ, UK R.C.M.W. FRANSSEN Shell International Exploration & Production BV., P.O. Box 60, 2280 AB Rijswijk, The Netherlands Present address: Shell Oil Company, OPA, P.O. Box 4704, Houston, TX 77210-4704, USA
J.R. FULLJAMES L.J.J. ZIJERvELD
59
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
61
Complexity in fault zone structure and implications for fault seal prediction C. Childs, J.J. Walsh and J. Watterson
In their simplest form, brittle faults consist of a single zone of intense deformation which macroscopically is seen as a slip surface and/or a zone of fault rock. More generally, fault zones have complex geometries with multiple slip surfaces and/or deformation zones. The most common pattern in complex fault zones observed at outcrop is a fault zone bounded by a pair of sub-parallel slip surfaces. In three dimensions, fault zones bounded by paired slip surfaces alternate both laterally and up/down dip with areas of only one slip surface. Within this overall framework, a range of fault rocks is irregularly distributed as spatially impersistent sheets and lenses. Due to seismically irresolvable complexities of fault zone structure, the juxtapositions of footwall and hangingwall rocks predicted from seismic data will in most cases be different from those actually present. The importance of such differences to the prediction of across-fault connectivity, of both hydraulically passive and hydraulically active fault zones, is strongly dependent on the reservoir sequence. Connectivities are calculated for hydraulically passive and active faults offsetting an Upper Brent Reservoir sequence. Shaley fault rocks within brittle fault zones often represent a spatially persistent, although variable thickness, component of the zones and provide a basis for the application of empirical methods of fault seal prediction to brittle faults. The distribution of fault rocks cannot be characterised from well data, raising the question of whether purely deterministic methods for fault seal prediction can ever be successful. The way forward is refinement of current empirical methods by achieving a more detailed characterisation of sub-surface faults, allowing more quantitative comparisons of target faults with those of known sealing behaviour.
Introduction
Data for characterisation of faults in the subsurface are limited to two sources, seismics and wells. Seismic reflection data allow the displacement distribution over a fault surface to be mapped while well and core data may allow determination of fault rock types and deformation mechanisms at specific points, in addition to characterising the lithologies of the host sequence. It is evident from outcrop studies that the internal geometries of fault zones are usually complex, in terms of the numbers of individual slip surfaces, the partitioning of slip between them and in the distribution of different fault rocks, all of which vary over a fault surface. This 3-D complexity of fault zone structure may not be apparent from either seismic or core data but is nevertheless crucial to the bulk hydraulic properties of a fault. A model for the development of the complex internal structures of fault zones has recently been proposed (Childs et al., 1996). Although this model does not increase the predictability of sub-surface fault zone structure, it demonstrates how complexity can arise from the operation of simple processes and provides a framework for consideration of the uncertainties inherent in prediction. The purpose of this paper is to describe and develop this model in terms relevant to the problems of fault seal prediction. While
the model represents a further step towards development of a deterministic method of fault seal prediction, the successful application of a reductionist approach to seal prediction remains a remote possibility. The fault sealing mechanisms considered are those which occur as a direct result of the faulting process, i.e., those due to either across-fault juxtapositions of reservoir and non-reservoir units or to the presence of sealing fault rocks, i.e., membrane seals. The diagenetic contribution to seals (Knipe, 1992) is not considered. Fault zone structure
Brittle fault zones comprise discrete slip surface(s) and fault rocks. There is a general positive correlation between fault displacement and the thickness and complexity of the fault zones (Robertson, 1983; Hull, 1988). Complex fault zones generally comprise multiple slip surfaces or zones of intense shear (Childs et al., 1996). The simplest and most common multi-slip fault zones observed in outcrop are structures with two discrete bounding slip surfaces, enclosing fault rock which may vary from intensely deformed to virtually undeformed (Koestler and Ehrmann, 1991; Childs et al., 1996). Where sufficient data are available, areas of a fault zone with the paired slip surface geometry can be seen to alternate with areas with a
Hydrocarbon Seals: Importancefor Exploration and Production edited by P. Mr
and A.G. Koestler. NPF Special Publication 7, pp. 61-72, Elsevier, Singapore. 9 Norwegian Petroleum Society (NPF) 1997
C. Childs, J.J. Walsh and J. Watterson
62
a
a
b
b C
Fig. I. Cartoon illustrating the asperity bifurcation model of fault zone widening. An irregularity on a fault surface (grey fill) in (a) is sheared off by the formation of a new slip surface in (b). Subsequent fault movement may result in deformation of the newly formed slip surface bounded lens.
" ,~iiiiii!iiii!iiiiiii!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiili!i!i~ ............ ~,iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!!ii!iiiii~ ......
single slip surface or zone of intense deformation. This type of structure, with rock lenses bounded by slip surfaces, is developed by either or both of the processes, asperity bifurcation and tip-line bifurcation (Childs et al., 1996), illustrated in Figs. 1 and 2, respectively. Asperity bifurcation is due to the shearing off of fault surface irregularities by the formation of new slip surfaces. These irregularities may occur anywhere on a fault surface and on any scale. Irregular Fig. 2. Successive stages of the tip-line bifurcation process of fault zone widening and generation of paired bounding slip surfaces (see text). The tip-line of a fault surface (e), part of which is shown shaded in (a)-(d), propagates upwards through a rock volume. The area shown in (a)-(d) is indicated by the rectangle in (e). With fault growth the elliptical tip-line bounding the fault surface propagates radially to the successive positions, a-d, shown in (e). The lines labelled I-III in (a) indicate successive positions of the fault surface tipline.
e
Complexity in fault zone structure and implications f or fault seal prediction
fault surfaces can either be inherited from non-planar surfaces formed when a fault propagated or be developed during continued fault growth, for example by bedding-parallel slip. Strain of a rock volume adjacent to a fault (Barnett et al., 1987) is often partly accommodated by bedding-plane slip which disrupts existing planar fault surfaces. Asperity bifurcation at outcrop or larger scales is equivalent to the grain scale wear process described by Engelder (1978). A paired bounding slip surface geometry will persist until the newly formed active slip surface has significantly higher displacement than its predecessor. Tip-line bifurcation is a process related to the radial propagation of the fault surface tip-line which accompanies increase in fault displacement, as shown in Fig. 2e. Tip-lines are locally retarded where they encounter mechanical heterogeneities (Huggins et al., 1995) and tip-line embayments are formed as shown in Fig. 2a by local arrest of a propagating tip-line. An embayment locally divides the fault surface into two lobes which are free to propagate independently and slightly out of plane with respect both to the main fault surface and to one another (Fig. 2b). At this stage the overall fault tip-line has by-passed the point of embayment, as shown in Fig. 2e. With continued fault growth the two fault lobes propagate laterally and overlap one another (Fig. 2c) to form a relay zone (Peacock and Sanderson, 1994; Huggins et al., 1995). With further fault growth, failure occurs by linkage of the overlapping fault surfaces (Fig. 2d). This evolution is accompanied by increasing strain of the sliver of rock between the slip surfaces. The end result of this process is the formation of a fault bounded lens of relatively undeformed rock, a cross-section through which displays a paired bounding slip surface geometry. Both bifurcation processes are independent of scale and can result in the formation of slip surface separations and lens dimensions on different scales, often simultaneously. Whereas asperity bifurcation can occur at any point on a fault surface, the tip-line bifurcation process is restricted to tip-lines but can occur on a range of scales at the same location. The varied scales can be visualised by thinking of the simple elliptical tip-line shown in Fig. 2e as having embayments on all scales. Offset and overlapping fault geometries (Fig. 2b,c) occur on faults of all sizes (Griffiths, 1980; Larsen, 1988; Peacock and Sanderson, 1991; Stewart and Hancock, 1991; Peacock and Sanderson, 1994). The action of either, or both, bifurcation processes at a point on a fault surface generally results in a stepwise increase in fault zone thickness and in a highly complex internal fault zone geometry. The asperity bifurcation process, and the formation of new slip surfaces within a fault zone, may also cause
63
fault zone thinning by "structural erosion" of previously formed fault rock as fault displacement increases. Both bifurcation processes result, at least initially, in lenses or pods of relatively undeformed rock becoming incorporated in a fault zone. Fig. 3a-c shows an outcropping fault zone consisting of lenses of fault rock each of which is bounded by discrete slip surfaces, These lenses range from intensely deformed to virtually undeformed. Each lens of fault rock may differ from neighbouring lenses in respect of both deformation intensity and rock composition. Each lens is a distinct element many of which are interpreted as having been incorporated into the fault zone by a fault surface bifurcation event. In the fault zone illustrated (Fig. 3), the numerous slip surface bounded lenses of similar size are consistent with this fault zone having widened dominantly by asperity bifurcation. Many of the slip surfaces which form boundaries to lenses within this fault zone may have formed within the existing fault zone and therefore would not have contributed to widening of the fault zone. Fault zone thickness
Measurement of fault zone and fault rock thicknesses in complex fault zones (Fig. 4) can be very subjective (Evans, 1990). In particular, the distinction in either outcrop or core between a single multi-slip surface fault zone and two or more individual faults is dependent on the distances between slip surfaces relative to their displacements, their relative orientations, the deformation state of the intervening rock and the larger scale context. Slip surfaces which at one scale of observation appear as separate faults may, with a more extended view, be clearly seen to be part of a single fault zone. As this problem can occur on any scale of observation and is effectively intractable, it should be borne in mind when assessing fault zone thickness data. The fault zone thickness versus fault displacement data in Fig. 4 are assigned to one of three fault zone categories. These are (i) single zones of fault rock, (ii) complex fault zones containing both fault rock and weakly deformed lenses of rock enclosed by two or more slip surfaces, and (iii) unclassified zones. The data distribution is broadly similar to that shown by previous workers (Otsuki, 1978; Robertson, 1983; Segall and Pollard, 1983; Hull, 1988; Blenkinsop, 1989) except that the data in Fig. 4 define a wider band and larger range of fault zone thicknesses for a given throw value than previously published datasets. This difference is largely, but not entirely, due to inclusion of category (ii) fault zones. Inclusion of these
C. Childs, J.J. Walsh and J. Watterson
64
a
b
C
Fig. 3. (a) A normal fault with a throw of 18 m in a Carboniferous mixed sandstone/shale sequence from a quarry in Lancashire, UK. The fault zone dips towards the observer. The hangingwall rocks have been removed by quarrying operations to expose the fault zone rocks which occur as lenses. Outlines of the most prominent lenses are shown in (b). Lenses dominantly of sandstone are stippled and those dominantly of shale are shaded. Mixed sandstone/shale lenses also occur (shaded and heavy stipple). Rocks in the lenses range from almost undeformed to highly deformed. (c) Detail of the sandstone breccia lens marked SB in (b), which, during quarrying operations, has slipped along its lower bounding slip surface and broken open, revealing a ca. 1 m thickness of sandstone breccia which tapers in all directions. The hammer at the centre of the photograph is 0.5 m long.
complex fault zones increases by an order of magnitude the range of fault zone thicknesses for a given displacement. A complex multi-slip surface fault zone may even have a thickness greater than the fault displacement. Although prediction of fault hydraulic properties is relevant to both exploration and production, a differ-
ent prediction is required in each of the two situations. For exploration, prediction of the sealing capacity of a particular fault is required, while for production purposes prediction of the combined effects of many faults within a reservoir volume may be the main concern. Uncertainties in the two cases are therefore viewed differently. In exploration, a fault is
Complexity in fault zone structure and implications for fault seal prediction
OEb
[]
., ",
E u~
[] i~"
n
0
!
[]
"
~L
"i
,,= i~
..
" Ii 'Ill
.,j t ~ . . t9 cF-o
9~
"
-I
:.. -2
.:q,~ 9
til,.
Ii .
9
,m "
.,, ,,
9
9
o.r%~
-3 e
9
9
ii
9
e" lille
9
II
II
Is
-4
'"
'1''"~1 ' '"1''" -3 -2 -I
''"1'' 0
log Displacement
1
"1 .... 2 3
(m)
Fig. 4. Plot of fault displacement versus fault zone thickness. Faults zones are distinguished as (i) simple fault zones comprising a single slip surface or zone of deformation (small crosses), (ii) complex fault zones comprising multiple (normally two) slip surfaces separated by undeformed or slightly deformed rock (squares), and (iii) fault zones n o t assigned to either category (filled circles). Many of the data assigned to category (i) are from published sources (Robertson, 1983; Hull, 1988; Otsuki, 1978; Segall and Pollard, 1983; Blenkinsop, 1989). Published data in category (ii) are from Wolf (1985). Data from a coastal section exposing small normal and oblique-slip faults cutting a chalk sequence at Flamborough Head, UK, represent maximum (large crosses) and minimum (small circumscribed crosses) fault rock thicknesses (category (i)) measured on individual fault traces.
predicted to be either sealing or non-sealing, and a level of uncertainty is attached to the prediction. In the case of production, uncertainty in the estimation of hydraulic properties of faults is expressed as uncertainty (or probability) in the results of reservoir flow simulation. The crucial difference between the two types of requirement can be summarised by saying that production requires estimation of the average hydraulic properties of a typical reservoir fault on a relatively short timescale, while exploration requires estimation of the hydraulic properties of the "weakest link" on a fault surface on a geological timescale. For production purposes, data relating fault displacement to fault thickness (Fig. 4) can readily be applied by taking a median line through the data distribution. For individual fault seal prediction it is the minimum rather than the average fault rock thickness in a fault zone which is crucial in determining whether or not an oil column can be supported. Fig. 4 shows that for a given throw, fault rock thickness varies by more than two orders of magnitude. B lenkinsop (1989) showed that, on a fault with 23 m strike-slip move-
65
ment, the fault rock thickness varied by an order of magnitude over an exposed fault trace length of only 12 m. If thickness had been measured over the entire fault surface rather than on a single short section, this range is likely to have been greatly extended. Fault rock thickness data from small (throw <11 m) normal and oblique slip faults from Flamborough Head, UK, show that on individual fault traces, fault rock thicknesses vary by more than two orders of magnitude (Fig. 4). The bifurcation mechanisms for formation of multi-slip fault zones suggest that maximum fault zone thickness will often correspond to the strikenormal distance between the traces of two overlapping slip surfaces (Fig. 2c). Fault overlaps and their breached equivalents occur on faults of all sizes as do, by implication, paired and multi-slip surface fault zones. Complex and paired slip surface fault zone structures will occur on scales below that resolvable by even high quality seismic data (lateral resolution is no better than 5 0 - 1 0 0 m at North Sea reservoir depths). The possible impact of sub-seismic complexity and paired slip surfaces on connectivity and sealing across faults offsetting an Upper Brent type sequence are briefly considered below. Across-fault juxtapositions" sequence
Upper Brent
Hydraulically passive fault rocks The consequences of sub-resolution fault zone complexity can be assessed for both hydraulically passive and hydraulically active fault rocks. Hydraulically passive here refers to fault rocks which have hydraulic properties identical with their host rocks and, therefore, only primary juxtaposition effects need to be considered. Fig. 5a shows two fault zones which offset an Upper Brent sequence, each with an aggregate displacement of ca. 40 m. On the scale of observation, fault zone A comprises a single slip surface, while fault zone B comprises two parallel slip surfaces each of which accommodates about half of the total displacement. In this case the paired slip surfaces are separated by ca. 15 m of rock with low shear strain, as indicated by bedding re-orientation. Two slip surfaces would not be distinguished even with good quality seismic data. Across-fault juxtapositions calculated on the basis of a single slip surface would be valid in the case of fault A, but invalid for fault B. The consequences of incorrect juxtapositions on fault B are illustrated in Fig. 5b-d), for the Upper Brent sequence shown in Fig. 5a. Fig. 5b shows the range of across-fault juxtaposi-
66
C. Childs, J.J. Walsh and J. Watterson
a
b
Complexity in fault zone structure and implications for fault seal prediction
tions for the 84 m thick Upper Brent sequence for fault throws from 0 to 84 m; all the juxtapositions represented in this figure would occur at some point on a fault with throws from 0 to 84 m. The traces of fault zone A and both of the slip surfaces of fault zone B (Fig. 5a) are sufficiently short for the throws along them to be constant, and so to be represented in Fig. 5b by a vertical line. If the traces were longer and throws along them varied, then the locus of each fault trace in Fig. 5b would be curved rather than straight. Across-fault reservoir connectivity for a single slip surface, over the 0-84 m range of throw values, is represented in Fig. 5c. For hydraulically passive faults the across-fault connectivity is 0.65, or 65%, at zero throw and is identical with the sequence net/ gross. The connectivity is sharply decreased by even a small throw. The subsequent, approximately linear, reduction in connectivity with increasing throw, reflects the relatively regular and frequent alternation of reservoir and non-reservoir lithologies within the gross reservoir sequence (Knott, 1993). Minor irregularities in the curve are due to connectivity peaks when individual sandstone units are juxtaposed. Connectivities for fault zones comprising two slip surfaces with equal displacements are shown in Fig. 5d for aggregate throw values over the range 0-84 m; an aggregate throw of 40 m is represented by two slip surfaces each with a throw of 20 m. The connectivity for paired slip surfaces is derived from Fig. 5b as follows. For each reservoir unit within the fault zone and bounded by slip surfaces, the connectivity across each slip surface is measured and the minimum of these taken as the net connectivity for that unit. The process is repeated for all reservoir units within the fault zone and the aggregate of the net connectivities represents the connectivity of the fault zone. For the Brent sequence shown here, across-fault connectivity is higher for a single slip surface than paired slip surfaces for all throws less than 80 m. For this sequence the across-fault sandstone connectivity of fault zone A is 23% of the gross reservoir thickness, and that of fault zone B is 14%. The difference in connectivity between the two fault zones is relatively small in this example. In general, however, the
67
difference in connectivity between single and paired slip surface geometries is highly sequence dependent. For some reservoir sequences, fault zone B would have a higher connectivity than fault zone A.
Hydraulically active fault rocks Fault zones with hydraulically active fault rocks may act as either conduits or barriers to flow, but only the latter case is discussed here. Hydraulically active fault rocks in clastic reservoir sequences form primarily either by cataclasis of sandstones or by incorporation of shale into fault zones, or both. The effects on fault seal potential of fault rocks formed by cataclasis of reservoir quality sandstones are not considered. The hydraulic properties of these cataclastic rocks as measured in outcrop samples suggest that they can form hydrocarbon seals (Antonellini and Aydin, 1994), but there is no consensus on their importance in the trapping of large oil columns (Smith, 1980; Gibson, 1994). By contrast, shaley fault rocks are believed to support significant hydrocarbon columns and there is a variety of methods for relating the amount and distribution of shale in a faulted sequence to the sealing potential of faults within it (Bouvier et al., 1989; Gibson, 1994; Fristad et al., 1997, this volume). In one of the simplest and most widely applied methods, the percentage shale of that part of the sequence which has been displaced past a point is calculated for each point on the fault surface. The percentage shale calculated in this way is expressed as the shale gouge ratio (SGR), as shown colour coded in Fig. 5b. Given data on faults of known sealing behaviour in a particular reservoir or province, SGR can be calibrated to provide cut-off values for fault seal for target faults within the same reservoir or province (Fristad et al., 1997, this volume; see Implications for fault seal: fault rock distribution). The software used to produce Fig. 5b calculates SGRs, and a range of other fault seal parameters, to provide a range of uncalibrated values for a given reservoir sequence. The reservoir sequence is represented either as lithological units classified as either reservoir or non-reservoir or shale, or as a percentage shale curve as derived, for example, from a gamma log.
Fig. 5. (a) A typical Upper Brent gross reservoir sequence (reservoir units, grey; non-reservoir (shale), black) offset by two fault zones, A and B. The fault geometries are from a fault map of strike-slip faults offsetting vertical beds (Childs et al., 1996). (b) Sequence/throw juxtaposition diagram (Bentley and Barry, 1991) for the reservoir sequence shown on the left (same sequence as in (a)). The diagram illustrates the across-fault juxtapositions for the range of throw values 0-84 m, non-reservoir units are shown black. Footwall shale layers are represented by horizontal black lines and hangingwall shales by oblique lines. Reservoir/reservoir across-fault juxtapositions are colour coded (see key) according to the SGR (see text) calculated for each element of the surface area. (c) Across-fault connectivity curves for the reservoir sequence in (a) and (b). The reservoir/reservoir across-fault connectivity for a given SGR cut-off value is expressed as a proportion of the gross reservoir sequence thickness (84 m). Connectivity curves for SGR cut-off values are based on the premise that reservoir/reservoir juxtapositions are not connected if the SGR is above the specified cut-off value. The connectivity curve for SGR = 100 is the curve for simple juxtaposition, i.e., hydraulically passive faults. (d) Across fault connectivity curves for the same sequence as (c) but with the total throw distributed equally on two slip surfaces.
68 Connectivity curves for a single slip surface are shown in Fig. 5c for a range of SGR cut-off values, for the Upper Brent sequence shown in Fig. 5b. The forms of the connectivity curves are very different. For an SGR cut-off = 20 there is no connectivity for throws >33 m. For an SGR cut-off = 30, there is no connectivity for throws from 40 to 60 m, but 8% connectivity at a throw of 65 m. For an SGR cutoff = 40, there is a sharp increase in connectivity at 45 m when the Tarbert and Lower Ness reservoirs become juxtaposed. Connectivity curves for paired hydraulically active slip surfaces can be calculated by the same method used for hydraulically passive faults. Connectivity curves for a range of SGR cut-off values are shown in Fig. 5d. For the Upper Brent sequence the connectivity of a single slip surface, for a given SGR cutoff, is generally higher than that for a fault zone with paired slip surfaces. The difference in connectivity between paired and single slip surface geometries is greatest at an SGR cut-off = 40. Although connectivities for the single and paired slip surfaces, at SGR cut-off = 40, are equal at a throw of 25 m, they are 24% (the same as that for a hydraulically passive fault) and 3%, respectively, at a throw of 50 m. For an SGR cut-off = 20 the connectivities for the single and paired slip surfaces are similar at all throws, so the sequence is insensitive to fault zone structure at this cut-off value. These variations in relative connectivities between single and paired slip surface geometries illustrate the complexity and non-linear consequences of multiple slip surfaces.
Summary The significance of sub-seismic fault zone complexity to calculation of across-fault connectivities and of fault seal potential is very strongly dependent not only on the amount but also on the distribution of non-reservoir and shale units within the gross reservoir sequence. The effect of an increased number of slip surfaces within a fault zone is twofold, namely increased average connectivity across individual slip surfaces and increased probability of an individual reservoir unit being juxtaposed against a nonreservoir layer or shaley fault gouge. Complex interplay between these two opposing effects determines the overall connectivity of a fault zone. Fault surface bifurcation processes result in areas of a fault zone with paired bounding slip surfaces alternating with areas with only a single slip surface. Either laterally or up-/down-dip, the two slip surfaces of fault zone B may give way to a single slip surface. Similarly, it is unlikely that fault zone A is characterised everywhere by only a single slip surface. As
c. Childs, J.J. Walsh and J. Watterson
there is no requirement for displacement to be partitioned equally between two slip surfaces, the range of possible connectivities across a 40 m fault zone is much greater than is indicated by the simple example illustrated. If more than two slip surfaces are present, the range of possible connectivities is increased further. The complexity of sequence juxtapositions due to sub-seismic fault zone structure is therefore compounded by the 3-D variation of fault zone structure. We consider that the sensitivity of individual sequences to partitioning of slip onto multiple slip surfaces in 3-D can be assessed only in very general terms. Although sensitivity studies can be performed, existing empirical methods, which implicitly incorporate sub-seismic fault zone complexity, may represent the best approach to fault seal prediction (see below).
Implications for fault seal: fault rock distribution The combined effects of the asperity and tip-line bifurcation processes can result in the formation of fault zones with highly complex internal geometries and highly variable fault rock compositions and distributions. Even detailed information on the fault rocks at a point on the fault zone shown in Fig. 3a-c, as would be provided by a well for example, would not enable valid extrapolation even to nearby parts of the fault zone. The implications of fault zone complexity for the distribution of potential sealing lithologies over a fault surface are illustrated in Fig. 6a which shows a cross-section through a shale-rich normal fault zone. Two distinct layers of shale-derived fault rock are present, a thicker layer derived from an 8 m thick shale source layer and a thinner gouge layer derived from thinner shale units within the footwall sequence. This fault zone has paired external slip surfaces with the intervening rocks intensely deformed. One slip surface occurs along the very thin lower layer of shale gouge and the other along the contact between the thick shale layer and the hangingwall sandstones. The fault zone thins upwards from 2 m at the base of the illustrated section to 1 m at the top. Both the relative and absolute thicknesses of sandstone and shale within the fault zone are determine by lenses of footwall derived sandstone, so the thickness of shalederived fault rock varies rapidly within the section. Rapid changes in both fault rock deformation state and fault rock composition also occur along the fault strike. Fig. 7 shows a map section through a fault of similar throw and offsetting the same sequence as the fault shown in Fig. 6. The mapped surface is 1-2 m below the footwall cut-off of the 8 m thick shale unit and shows paired bounding slip surfaces. The fault
Complexity in fault zone structure and implications f or fault seal prediction
a
69
distribution precludes the possibility of these breccias forming a seal. The shales within these fault zones show highly irregular thickness variations but, nevertheless, display a high degree of conl~inuity. The sealing integrity of a fault would be maintained if this continuity occurred over the whole fault surface. However, given the very small proportion of an entire fault surface which is represented by any single crosssection or map trace, nothing can be concluded about the likelihood of a continuous shale layer over the whole fault surface. A cross-section through a series of minor faults offsetting a mixed sandstone shale sequence (Fig. 8)
b
Fig. 6. (a) Cross-section through a normal fault in a Carboniferous mixed sandstone/shale sequence from a quarry in Lancashire, UK. The fault dips to the left, with a throw of ca. 15 m. (b) Sketch of the outcrop in (a). The well developed shale gouge layer within the fault zone (black) is derived from an 8 m thick shale unit. The base of this shale unit is ca. 1 m above the top of the exposed face in the footwall and 1.5 m below ground level in the hangingwall. The fault separates sandstones in the hangingwall (stippled) from a mixed sandstone (no ornament) and shale (black) footwall sequence. Dense coarse stipple indicates sandstone breccia. Mixed sandstone and shale breccias are shown shaded with a coarse stipple. The boundary between the fault zone and the footwall country rock is a slip surface with a thin (<2 cm), but continuous, layer of clay gouge; this gouge layer is too thin to be represented in the figure. Only structural features which are clearly not the result of quarrying activity are shown in (b).
rocks include shale gouge, sandstone breccias and relatively undeformed blocks of sandstone and shale within which bedding has been rotated towards the hangingwall, as shown in the vertical cross-sections. The fault zone is of more or less constant thickness (2 m) over its mapped length but the fault rock content is highly variable. On cross-section C the fault zone contains 2 m of shale, of varying degree of deformation, while 8 m along-strike (cross-section B) the shale component is reduced to 3 cm of shale gouge. These rapid variations in fault rock content and, particularly, in the content of potentially sealing lithologies raise the question of whether or not deterministic predictions of fault seal potential are feasible. Sandstone derived breccias within the fault zones shown in Figs. 3, 6 and 7 occur either as thin sheets of limited extent or as localised lenses. This patchy
Fig. 7. Map (left) and three cross-sections, A-C, through a normal fault with ca. 15 m throw. The fault offsets the same sequence as shown in Fig. 7. The mapped surface is at a level ca. 1 m below the top of the outcrop in Fig. 6. Deformed shale, either strongly foliated or shale gouge, is shown in black. Shale with preserved bedding is dark shaded with broken lines indicating approximate bedding orientations. Hangingwall sandstones are ornamented with regular stipple and footwall sandstones with irregular stipple. Sandstone bedding directions on cross-sections are shown by thin lines. Sandstone breccias are indicated by a coarse stipple. The boundary between the fault zone and the footwall sandstones on cross-sections B and C is a discrete slip surface.
70
C. Childs, J.J. Walsh and J. Watterson
t
2m
Fig. 8. Cross-section showing a number of small faults offsetting a carboniferous sandstone/shale sequence. Thin shales are shown as subhorizontal lines. Fault traces are shown as steep lines and those with shale smears are shown as wide grey lines. There is no horizontal connectivity across this 2-D section but 3-D connectivity is likely.
shows the frequency with which shale is incorporated into the fault zones and the apparent absence of sandstone connectivity. However, this 2-D section allows no conclusion to be drawn concerning the sandstone connectivity in 3-D. The observations reported here are consistent with those of Lindsay et al. (1993) who concluded that for faults in the same working quarry as Figs. 3, 6, 7 and 8, shale smears in outcrop can be discontinuous when the displaced sequence has an SGR value of <15. This SGR value does not, however, imply a sharp cut-off and continuous shale smears do occur at SGR values <15. These results are broadly comparable with those of Fristad et al. (1997), who find that significant static seal on subsurface faults does not occur for SGR values <15 but does occur at SGR values >18. Gibson (1994) estimates the SGR cut-off value to be 2 2 - 3 0 . Variation in SGR cut-off values is expected for different datasets from different geological settings (Fristad et al., 1997). Observations of shale smear continuity from outcrop are not directly comparable with SGR cutoffs derived from sub-surface datasets, because outcrop observations are small scale and generally only 2-D (Gibson, 1994) and do not allow assessment of the sealing effects of shale-derived fault rock in the 3-D system. A mechanism by which regular and continuous clay smears are generated on relatively low strain rate faults in soft sediments has been described by Weber (1978) and Lehner and Pilaar (1997, this volume). Soft-sediment faults are effectively ductile shear zones and may lack the discontinuities and complexity typical of fault zones, in rocks of either low or high shear strength, characterised by high instantaneous slip rates, i.e., "brittle" faults. Although the faults we have described formed in already lithified sedi-
ments (Lindsay et al., 1993) and the clay smears do not show the thickness regularity of those described by Weber (1978), the continuity of the clay smears may be comparable. The frequency of thick shale smears in the quarry (as in Figs. 6 and 7) is such that the local quarrymen refer to them as "vertical shales".
Discussion Faults are not directly imaged on seismic sections but interpreted, where reflections are offset, as discrete fault surfaces. It is acknowledged by interpreters that these discrete surfaces may comprise two or more seismically unresolved slip surfaces. The bifurcation model of fault growth implies that multi-slip surface fault zones are the rule rather than the exception and that there will be a minimum of two discrete slip surfaces on at least some places on a fault zone. More generally, the high degree of complexity within brittle fault zones, which is evident on all scales of observation, means that no fault surface can be fully defined in three dimensions and on the relevant scale. The fault zone structure observed either at a point or on a cross-section of the fault surface, cannot be extrapolated any significant distance from the point or line of observation. Given these limitations, we question whether it is possible, even theoretically, to predict deterministically the sealing potential of fault zones in the sub-surface. Clearly, detailed observations of fault zones have a role in fault seal prediction. Data from wells which penetrate fault zones can be used to determine both the deformation mechanisms which operated and the fault rocks which are present or which are likely to occur. However, well data provide no constraints on the spatial distribution of the fault rocks and on the sealing potential of faults
Complexity in fault zone structure and implications f or fault seal prediction
on geological timescales. The poroperm properties of fault rock sampled from wells may provide useful constraints on the permeabilities of faults for production timescale flow simulations A contrasting approach to fault seal prediction is to apply the empirical method by which a prediction is made simply on the basis of the known behaviour of comparable faults. We suggest that progress will best be made by moderating the extreme empirical approach by applying deterministic methods to quantifying the degree of comparability between a target fault and faults of known behaviour. An important aspect of an empirical approach is quantifying the degree to which one fault can be considered a valid hydraulic analogue of another. Methods of fault seal prediction employing empirical databases in which faults of known sealing capacities are characterised by reference to shale smear parameters (Gibson, 1994; Fristad et al., 1997, this volume; Lehner and Pilaar, 1997, this volume) represent a combination of the deterministic and empirical approaches. The methods of shale smear parameterisation are, implicitly or otherwise, based on the assumption of a regular and predictable distribution of shale-derived fault rock within a fault zone. While the complexity in fault zones suggests that the juxtaposition diagrams on which these methods are based may not represent the actual across-fault juxtapositions, the methods have nevertheless achieved a measure of credibility within the industry. This apparent contradiction can, however, be resolved. Although the constructions on which fault seal potential calculations are based take no account of subseismic complexity of fault zones, the complexity is incorporated implicitly in the databases against which fault seal potentials are calibrated. For some reservoir sequences, calculated fault seal potentials are to some degree independent of a certain level of fault zone complexity. Figs. 6 and 7 illustrate the extreme spatial variation in thickness of shale-derived fault rock within a fault zone but, together with Fig. 8, they also demonstrate the high degree of continuity of shalederived fault rocks which can occur. It is this continuity of shale-derived fault rock which, despite the complexity of its distribution, provides a physical basis for methods of prediction of fault seal potential based on shale smear parameterisation.
Conclusions Observations show that the internal structure of fault zones is highly complex, largely as a consequence of bifurcation processes. Simple examples of fault zone complexity, in which displacement on a fault of constant displacement is partitioned onto two
71
slip surfaces, illustrate the sensitivity of across-fault connectivity to fault zone structure. In general fault zones have multiple slip surfaces separating volumes of mildly to intensely deformed rock, with chaotic spatial variation in structure of the fault zone. We question whether it is even theoretically possible to characterise deterministically, complex fault zone architectures of subsurface faults, given the limited data available. Empirical risking methods implicitly take account of the unpredictable complexities in fault zone structure which inevitably are present. The way forward is by further refinement of current empirical methods, i.e., by more detailed characterisation of sub-surface faults to allow more objective comparison of target faults and faults of known sealing behaviour.
Acknowledgements This research was part funded by the EC Joule II Reservoir Engineering Project (Contract No. JOU2CT92-0182) and the EC Joule III PUNQ Project (Contract No. JOF3-CT95-0006). The lithological sequence in Fig. 5 was interpreted by Kees Geel from a well log provided by Norsk Hydro. We are grateful to Barry Murphy and Nick Lindsay for fieldwork leading to the production of Fig. 8. We thank Marie Eeles for help in preparing the manuscript. Peter Keller and Andreas Koestler are thanked for their helpful reviews of the manuscript.
References Antonellini, M. and Aydin, A. 1994. Effect of faulting on fluid flow in porous sandstones: petrophysical properties. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 78: 355-377. Barnett, J.A.M., Mortimer, J., Rippon, J., Walsh, J.J. and Watterson, J. 1987. Displacement geometry in the volume containing a single normal fault. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 71: 925-937. Bentley, M.R. and Barry, J.J. 1991. Representation of fault sealing in a reservoir simulation: Cormorant block IV UK North Sea. In: 66th Ann. Tech. Conf. and Exhibition of the Soc. Pet. Engineers, Dallas TX, pp. 119-126. Blenkinsop, T.G. 1989. Thickness-displacement relationships for deformation zones: discussion. J. Struct. Geol., 11: 1051-1054. Bouvier, J.D., Kaars-Sijpesteijn, C.H., Kluesner, D.F., Onyejekwe, C.C. and Van Der Pal, R.C. 1989. Three-dimensional seismic interpretation and fault sealing investigations, Nun River Field, Nigeria. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 73: 1397-1414. Childs, C., Watterson, J. and Walsh, J.J. 1996. A model for the structure and development of fault zones. J. Geol. Soc. London, 153: 337-340. Engelder, T. 1978. Aspects of asperity-surface interaction and surface damage of rocks during experimental frictional sliding. Pure Appl. Geophys., 116: 705-716. Evans, J.P. 1990. Thickness-displacement relationships for fault zones. J. Struct. Geol., 12: 1061-1065. Fristad, T., Groth, A., Yielding, G. and Freeman, B. 1997. Quantitative fault seal prediction: a case study from Oseberg Syd. In: P. Mr and A.G. Koestler (Editors), Hydrocarbon Seals:
C. Childs, J.J. Walsh and J. Watterson
72 Importance for Exploration and Production. Norwegian Petroleum Society (NPF), Special Publication No. 7. Elsevier, Singapore, pp. 107-124. Gibson, R.G. 1994. Fault zones seals in siliciclastic strata of the Columbus Basin, offshore Trinidad. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 78: 1372-1385. Griffiths, P.S. 1980. Box-fault systems and ramps: atypical associations of structures from the eastern shoulder of the Kenya Rift. Geol. Mag., 117: 579-586. Huggins, P., Watterson, J., Walsh, J.J. and Childs, C. 1995. Relay zone geometry and displacement transfer between normal faults recorded in coal-mine plans. J. Struct. Geol., 17: 1741-1755. Hull, J. 1988. Thickness-displacement relationships for deformation zones. J. Struct. Geol., 10: 431-435. Knipe, R.J. 1992. Faulting processes and fault seal. In: R.M. Larsen, H. Brekke, B.T. Larsen and E. Talleras (Editors), Structural and Tectonic Modelling and its Application to Petroleum Geology. Norwegian Petroleum Society Special Publication (NPF), Special Publication 1. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp. 325-342. Knott, S.D. 1993. Fault seal analysis in the North Sea. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 77: 778-792. Koestler, A.G. and Ehrmann, W.U. 1991. Description of brittle extensional features in chalk on the crest of a salt ridge (NW Germany). In: A.M. Roberts, G. Yielding and B. Freeman (Editors), The Geometry of Normal Faults, Special Publication 56. Geol. Soc. London, pp. 113-123. Larsen, P.-H. 1988. Relay structures in a Lower Permian basementinvolved extension system, East Greenland. J. Struct. Geol., 10: 3-8. Lehner, F.K. and Pilaar, W.F. 1997. On a mechanism of clay smear emplacement in synsedimentary normal faults. In: P. Mr Pedersen and A.G. Koestler (Editors), Hydrocarbon seals: Importance for Exploration and Production. Norwegian Petroleum Society (NPF), Special Publication 7. Elsevier, Singapore, pp. 39-50.
C. CHILDS J.J. WALSH J. WATTERSON
Lindsay, N.G., Murphy, F.C., Walsh, J.J. and Watterson, J. 1993. Outcrop studies of shale smears on fault surfaces. In: S. Hint and A.D. Bryant (Editors), The Geological Modelling of Hydrocarbon Reservoirs and Outcrop Analogues. Int. Assoc. Sediment., 15: 113-123. Otsuki, K. 1978. On the relationship between the width of shear zone and the displacement along fault. J. Geol. Soc. Jpn., 84:661-669. Peacock, D.C.P. and Sanderson, D.J. 1991. Displacements, segment linkage and relay ramps in normal fault zones. J. Struct. Geol., 13: 721-733. Peacock, D.C.P. and Sanderson, D.J. 1994. Geometry and development of relay ramps in normal fault systems. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 78: 147-165. Robertson, E.C. 1983. Relationship of fault displacement to gouge and breccia thickness. Soc. Mining Eng., Am. Inst. Mining Eng. Trans., 35: 1426-1432. Segall, P. and Pollard, D.D. 1983. Joint formation in granitic rock of the Sierra Nevada. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 94: 563-575. Smith, D.A. 1980. Sealing and non-sealing faults in Louisiana Gulf Coast salt basin. Am. Assoc. Pet. Geol. Bull., 64: 145-172. Stewart, I.S. and Hancock, P.L. 1991. Scales of structural heterogeneity with neotectonic normal fault zones in the Aegean region. J. Struct. Geol., 13:191-204. Weber, K.J., Mandl, G., Pilaar, W.F., Lehner, F. and Precious, R.G. 1978. The role of faults in hydrocarbon migration and trapping in Nigerian growth fault structures. In: 10th Ann. Offshore Technology Conf., Soc. Pet. Eng., Paper No. 3356, pp. 2643-2653. Wolf, R. 1985. Tiefentektonik des linksneiderrheinischen Steinkohlengebietes. In: G. Drozdzewski, H. Engel, R. Wolf and V. Wrede (Editors), Beitr~ige zur Tiefentektonik westdeutscher Steinkolhlenlagerst~itten, Geologisches Landesamt NordrheinWestfalen, Krefeld.
Fault Analysis Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, L69 3BX, UK Fault Analysis Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, L69 3BX, UK Fault Analysis Group, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, L69 3BX, UK
73
Late Jurassic-early Cretaceous caprocks of the southwestern Barents Sea: fracture systems and rock mechanical properties R.H. Gabrielsen and O.S. Klovjan
The late Callovian-Oxfordian Fuglen and Oxfordian-Ryazanian Hekkingen Formations of the Teistengrunnen Group provide cap rocks for the bulk of the hydrocarbon structures drilled so far in the southwestern Barents Sea. Remnant oil is common in many of the drilled structures, and it has been suggested that Eocene-Oligocene and late Neogene to Pleistocene uplift and erosion caused cap rock failure and hydrocarbon leakage. Investigations of cores have revealed that fracturing is common throughout the study area. Still, considerable differences with regard to fracture frequencies, fracture orientation and distribution exist. Four main groups of fractures have been identified. Group I and II fractures are presumably related to burial and/or unroofing. The frequencies of fractures of these groups are low, and these fracture types are regarded as a minor risk for hydrocarbon leakage on the regional scale. Fractures of group III are low-angle structures, probably making up comprehensive fracture networks near and within major fault zones of the study area. The fracture intensity is highest within the master fault complexes, and particularly along those which were affected by inversion in Tertiary times. Although experiments suggest that these types of fracture have small apertures when loaded, they are still regarded as potential conduits for transport of hydrocarbons. Group IV fractures are rare, mainly subhorizontal structures which can contribute little to hydrocarbon migration.
Cap rock problems and hydrocarbon leakage in the southwestern Barents Sea In the early phase of hydrocarbon exploration in the southwestern Barents Sea (Fig. 1) several promising gas discoveries were made in the Hammerfest Basin area (Alke and Askeladden in 1981; Albatross in 1982; e.g., Westre, 1984). The reservoir zones are situated in the mid-Jurassic Str Formation (Fig. 2), and the discoveries were associated with moderately rotated fault blocks. Oil shows were frequent in the cores below gas zones, but wireline log data showed that these parts of the formations carried water. The first significant oil leg (15 m) in the Barents Sea was encountered below the gas zone in the SnChvit Field, but also in this case traces of oil were reported to occur in the deeper, presently water-saturated part of the reservoir (Linjorde and Grung-Olsen, 1992). It was clear that the Hekkingen Formation, which is the principle source rock in the area, had more than sufficient potential to fill the major structures of the Hammerfest Basin. Recent studies have confirmed that many of the traps in the southwestern Barents Sea, now dry, have been filled by hydrocarbons (Augustson, 1993), and that leakage accordingly is a problem of regional dimensions (Nyland et al., 1992). Several explanations for hydrocarbon leakage in the southwestern Barents Sea have been attempted. Although tilting of fault blocks and lack of continuity of the cap rocks may provide the simplest explanations, modelling suggests that other mechanisms must
be evaluated. Thus, Nyland et al. (1992) and Skagen (1992), in calculating expansion of the hydrocarbon phase resulting from Eocene-Oligocene and late Neogene to Pleistocene uplift and erosion, which in total amounts to between 1000 and 2000 m or more in the southwestern Barents Sea, concluded that this effect was sufficient to cause the observed hydrocarbon spill. In a rock mechanical model study, Makurat et al. (1992) demonstrated that failure of the Hekkingen Formation cap rock may occur due to build-up of deviatoric stresses during uplift and unroofing. Still, since there seems to be a close correlation between the present oil-water-contacts, the spill-point of the structures, and geophysical anomalies ascribed to gas accumulations, and the presence of reactivated faults (Fig. 3), leakage of hydrocarbons along reactivated fault planes may not be entirely ruled out.
Structural history of the southwestern Barents Sea The southwestern Barents Sea continental shelf is dominated by ENE-WSW to NE-SW, and NNE-SSW to NNW-SSE trends with local influence of WNWESE- to E-W-striking elements (Faleide et al., 1984, 1993; Gabrielsen et al., 1990). In the southern part of the Barents Sea, a regional ENE-WSW grain is defined by the major fault complexes bordering the Hammerfest and Nordkapp Basins. To the west and northwest, N-S trends prevail (Tromsr Basin, Knr Fault, Hornsund Fault Complex).
Hydrocarbon Seals: Importance for Exploration and Production edited by P. Mr
and A.G. Koestler. NPF Special Publication 7, pp. 73-89, Elsevier, Singapore. 9 Norwegian Petroleum Society (NPF) 1997
74
R.H. Gabrielsen and O.S. KlCvjan
Fig. 1. Main structural features of the southwestern Barents Sea, and locations of wells used in the present study. Geology after Gabrielsen et al. (1990).
The major regional fault zones in the Barents Sea were probably established by Carboniferous times. In the subsequent structuring of the southwestern Barents Sea area, activity was associated with these important elements, causing repeated reactivation of the fault complexes (Gabrielsen, 1984). After Carboniferous structuring, and following a tectonically quiet period in the Triassic, block-faulting started in midJurassic. During the period from late Jurassic and into the early Cretaceous, the fault activity increased, terminating with formation of the major basins and highs, with extreme subsidence in the Tromsr Basin and the BjCrnCya Basin during Aptian-Albian. Indications of local early Cretaceous inversion occur,
e.g., along BjCmCyrenna Fault Complex (Gabrielsen et al., 1992, 1997a), near the junction between the RingvassCy-Loppa Fault Complex and the Asterias Fault Complex and along the Trollfjord-Komagelv fault trend (Gabrielsen and Fa~rseth, 1989). Towards the end of the Cretaceous period, reverse faulting and folding, combined with extensional faulting in some areas, became locally more abundant, even though subsidence may have prevailed on the regional scale. Inversion peaked in early Tertiary times, and was followed by severe regional uplift and erosion in the Pliocene-Pleistocene (Nansen, 1904, 1920; Nyland et al., 1992; Riis and Fjeldskaar, 1992; Gabrielsen et al., 1997a).
Late Jurassic-early Cretaceous caprocks of the southwestern Barents Sea: fracture systems and rock mechanical properties
Fracture types in Fuglen and Hekkingen Formations Rocks of the late Callovian-Oxfordian Fuglen and Oxfordian-Ryazanian Hekkingen Formations of the
75
Teistengrunnen Group (Fig. 2) commonly provide the hydrocarbon seal in the basin areas of the southwestern Barents Sea. These are predominantly dark grey to brownish shales and pyritic mudstones interbedded by stringers of limestones. The Hekkingen Formation may locally contain dolomites, silt and sandstone (Dalland et al., 1988). A total of 92 m of cores of the Fuglen and Hekkingen Formations, and 9 m from the Ryazanian/Valanginian-Barremian Knurr Formation from nine wells (7321/9-1, 7219/9-1, 7120/2-2, 7120/6-1, 7120/12-1, 7125/1-1, 7228/2-1, 7228/9-1 and 7117/92) (Fig. 1) were included in the present study. With the exception of wells 7120/6-1, 7117/9-2 and 7324/10-1, where only mounted B-cuts were avail, able, the cores were inspected both previous to and after core slabbing. The fracture analysis included fracture frequency studies, orientation studies, fracture- characterisation (core inspection, light microscope and electron microscope investigation)and rock mechanical experiments. All fractures observed, including those ascribed to drilling and core handling, were included in the original fracture logs. In the final logs, which were applied for statistical calculations and further descriptions, however, "artificial" fractures were excluded. To identify this type of structure, the criteria suggested by Arthur et al. (1980), Carson et al. (1982), and Lundberg and Casey Moore (1982) were applied. Core discing is common in shales and mudstones in the study area. Surfaces of this type of structure are either dull with parallel-oriented flaky mineral grains, or glossy to lustrous, in a few cases with faint traces of slickenside lineations. The former is considered to represent the primary fissability of the rock, and were not included in the final logs. Based on fracture morphology, characteristic mineralogy and orientation, a classification system of the main fracture types was constructed. An overview of the fracture characteristics and their distribution as given below is summarised in Table 1.
Fracture types
Fig. 2. Stratigraphic column, Barents Sea. Arrows indicate the units studied. After Gabrielsen et al. (1997a), based on Dalland et al.
(1988).
Planar fractures represent the most common fracture type in the investigated rocks of the Fuglen, Hekkingen and the Knurr Formations, and approximately 70-90% of the structures fall into this group. The planar fractures are commonly single structures, but are also found in clusters of 2-5, and as swarms of more than 5 closely spaced parallel or sub-parallel fractures. Based on morphology, the planar fractures are subdivided into four sub-types. Type FI are polished, glossy fractures without or with faint slickenside striations (Fig. 4a). This frac-
76 R.H. Gabrielsen and O.S. KlCvjan
o
~9
.=.
t~ o
r~
. ,.q
Late Jurassic-early Cretaceous caprocks of the southwestern Barents Sea: fracture systems and rock mechanical properties Table 1 Geometrical/morphological classification of fractures in cap rocks of the southwestern Barents Sea Type
III IV V VI
Characteristics
Mode
Polished, faint slicken side lineations Growth of illite occ. plumose markings Strong slicken side lineations Slightly wavy surfaces Wave, heavily striated surfaces Low-angle with mineral fill Fibrious calcite c. Listric, small scale Planar/curvi-planar, smooth surfaces
Tensile (I) (dominant) Shear (II) Shear (II) Tensile (I) Shear (II) Tensile (I)
ture type is found in most of the investigated cores. It may constitute complete, remarkably smooth (Fig. 4b) surfaces on the scale of the core, or may be typical of a certain part of the fracture surface, perhaps indicating a step-wise development. In most cases, however, a faint pattern of slickenside striations is found on closer inspection in the scanning electron microscope. Thin section studies reveal mineral grain rotation and growth of tiny white illite flakes. The illite grains are frequently oriented at an angle of 2530 ~ to the fracture planes, indicative of shear along the fractures (Fig. 4c). There are also examples of combinations of growth of illite parallel to, and at right angle to the fracture surfaces (Fig. 4d). The latter situation suggests that extension has taken place across the fracture (Groshong, 1975; Ramsay and Huber, 1987). Type FII are polished fractures with well developed slickenside striations (Fig. 4e,h) and are the most common type of tectonic feature in the cap rocks investigated. The surfaces are commonly slightly wavy, and more than one set of slickenside lineations may occur. These may represent two different stages of deformation (Fig. 4f), but there are good examples of slickenside lineations which seem to belong to one single set, but which have angular linear geometries, suggesting deflection of the relative movements during deformation (Fig. 4g). Slickenside striations both parallel, oblique and perpendicular to the strike of fractures are observed, indicating strike-slip as well as oblique and dip-slip displacements. Particularly in the wells of the BjCmCyrenna Fault Complex, oblique slickenside striations are frequently seen. Also in Type FII fractures mineral rotation and growth of white mica adjacent to fracture planes are common. The mica flakes may be oriented both parallel and perpendicular to the fracture surfaces. Type Fill, wavy, heavily striated fractures, are not common, but have been recorded in a few cases. This fracture type seems to be more common in the more
77
silty lithologies, and mica growth has not yet been recorded in association with these structures. Examples of type FIII-fractures are given in Fig. 4i,j. Fracture types FI-FIII may be characterised by their striation frequencies ~ = striations/ktm as measured transverse to the striation strike-line). Table 2 gives one example of results from striation countings from well 7321/9-1, illustrating that type FI and FII fractures have typical fs values in the range of 0.0100.035, significantly different from type FIII which has typical f~ values of 5.5-8.3 x 10-3. Type FIV, low-angle fractures with mineral fracture fill, are seen in a few cases. They are commonly oriented parallel to bedding, or are cutting the bedding by a small angle. Fibrous mineral growth with fibres at right angles to the fracture surfaces indicates that the fractures may be related to vertical stress release (Fig. 4k,1). Type FV are listric, small-scale structures, usually restricted to one layer or a small scale sequence. A (small scale) detachment fault is usually developed. Type FVI, planar to curviplanar, smooth fractures without slickenside striations or polished surfaces, are frequently recorded. They are often blind on the scale of the core, or may end at bedding surfaces or other fractures. It has not been possible to determine absolute offsets on any fractures, mainly due to lack of marker horizons on the cm and mm scales. Planar fractures with polished surfaces and slickenside lineation are interpreted by most authors to be tectonic in origin. Arthur et al. (1980) and Carson et al. (1982) stressed that mineralization is a meaningful criterion for the identification of natural fractures, whereas Lundberg and Casey Moore (1986) added healed fractures which restore cohesion across the fracture plane as an equal criterion. Most planar
Table 2 Striation frequency (fs) correlated to fracture type. Example from well 7321/9-1 Depth (m)
Type
fs
1366.00 1366.00 1366.10 1366.10 1366.10 1366.10 1366.10 1366.20 1366.20 1366.20 1366.20 1366.20 1367.00 1370.00
FII FII FI FII FII FII FII FII FII FII FII FII Fill Fill
0.010 0.038 0.035 0.022 0.021 0.012 0.055 0.017 0.018 0.020 0.051 0.036 5.46 x 10-3 8.27 x 10-3
78
R.H. Gabrielsen and O.S. KlCvjan
Late Jurassic-early Cretaceous caprocks of the southwestern Barents Sea: fracture systems and rock mechanical properties
79
80 R.H. Gabrielsen and O.S. KlCvjan
Late Jurassic-early Cretaceous caprocks of the southwestern Barents Sea: fracture systems and rock mechanical properties
Fig. 4. (a) Composite planar fracture, well 71 1719-2,depth 3477.20 m; (b) SEM imagery of Type FI surface, well 7219/9-1. Scale bar is 48.5 pm. (c) Micrograph of fracture, type FI, perpendicular to fracture surface, well 7219/9-1, 1934.25 m. Note grains of illite growing with an angle of approximately 25-30" to the fracture surface. (d) Growth of illite associated with planar fracture surface type F1, well 721919-1, 1942.50 m. Note that illite growth is both parallel to and at a right angles to the fractures. ( e ) Type FII fracture, with dip-parallel slickenside lineation, well 7219/9-1, 1934.20 m. (f) Type FII fracture with composite, oblique slickenside lineation. Well 71 17/9-2, 3477.65 m. (g) SEM imagery of fracture with slickenside lineation, Fuglen Formation, well 7321/9-I, 1366.00 m. Note change in strike of striation, indicating change in relative movement. Scale bar is 31.9pm. (h) SEM imagery, slickensided fracture surface, well 7219/9-1, 1934.45 m. On this scale, the slickensides appear as a series of grooves. Scale bar is 386pm. (i) Type FIII fracture. Well 721919-1, 1934.20 m. (i)Thin section across surface of type FIII fracture, Fuglen Formation, well 7321/9-1, 1370 m. (k) Mineral fill on planar fracture surface. Well 712012-2, 2639.70-75 m RKB. (I) Micrograph of calcite mineralisation on fracture surface. Well 7228/2-I, 1172.50m RKB. (m) Scaly foliation, well 7120/2-2. (n) Scaly foliation, well 7321/9-1.
81
82
fractures of types FI, FII and Fill satisfy one or more of these criteria. Thus, many of the fractures are healed, and the samples split along the fracture planes only when knocked upon or during slabbing. As described above, slickenside lineations are frequent, as well as recrystallization/mineralization along fracture planes, and in some cases mineral fill is observed. It is therefore concluded that the bulk of the planar fractures of types FI, FII and FIII are tectonic in origin. Type IV (subhorizontal) fractures were probably initiated during unloading and/or anomalously high fluid pressure build-up. Some of the type IV fractures are filled by fibrous carbonate, confirming tensile origin, and that the fractures were activated in situ. It 9is still reasonable to assume, however, that some of the type IV- fractures, which are not filled by minerals, were generated during stress release when brought to the surface. Fractures of type FV probably represent soft sediment deformation or collapse associated with water escape, whereas the origin of type FVI fractures is more uncertain. It seems, however, most reasonable to ascribe the latter structures to drilling, core handling or drying during storing. The origin of type VI fractures is enigmatic, but it may be speculated that these are associated with volume reducing processes during burial. Since this fracture type is rare, no further steps have been taken to determine their origin.
Rubble zones, anastamosing fractures, scaly foliation and breccias Rubble zones are very common in cored mudstones and shales in many regions of the Norwegian continental shelf, and the southwestern Barents Sea seems to be no exception. Three types of rubble zones are recorded in the wells investigated. Type RI is characterised by pencil-shaped fragments with hackly or rough surfaces. X-Ray tomographic investigations of similar structure elsewhere has show that such fragments are commonly oriented parallel to the core axis (Gabrielsen and Koestler, 1987; their Plate lh), and accordingly should be regarded as drilling-induced artificial structures. Type RH contains tablet-shaped fragments with smooth larger ("upper" and "lower") surfaces and rough to irregular smaller "side walls". The larger surfaces have the morphology which is typical of undeformed bedding, and it is reasonable to interpret the
R.H. Gabrielsen and O.S. KlCvjan
type RII rubble zones to represent the original fissibility of the rock. Type Rill rubble zones are frequently associated with anastamosing fractures, and are characterised by lens-shaped chips with slickensided surfaces (Fig. 4m,n). In the electron and light microscopes, the morphologies and textures of the fractures defining the surfaces of the fragments are similar to those seen on planar fracture surfaces of type FII (see above). Rubble zones of types RI and RII are not considered to have any tectonic implications. In contrast, rubble zones of type RIII, which are characterised by slickensided lens-shaped chips are typical of tectonized zones (faults) (Lundberg and Casey Moore, 1986), and have been reported to be typical in accretionary complexes (shear-fracture fabric (Cowan, 1974) and pervasively sheared fabric (Hsia, 1974)). It is noted that slickensided lens-shaped chips are also typical of pedogenic structures (Buol et al., 1980; Gray and Nickelsen, 1989). Pedogenic slickensides typically occur in the upper part of fining-upward sequences of floodplain and upper delta-plain facies, which have experienced multiple cycles of wetting and drying. Still, most zones of scaly structure encountered in the cores presently investigated are believed to be of tectonic rather than pedogenic origin because: (a) the scaly foliation is frequently associated with or delineated by anastamosing fractures which dip steeper than the bedding; (b) zones of scaly foliation are developed in well defined zones which do not seem to reflect any contrast in primary texture or composition; (c) the fragments of the zones are truly lensoid in shape, rather than trapezoid which may be expected for pedogenic structures; and finally (d) since the shales of the Fuglen and Hekkingen Formations were deposited in a marine environment, multiple cycles of wetting and drying are difficult to imagine. Accordingly, it seems most reasonable to interpret rubble zones of type RIII to be intensely deformed zones, most likely faults with throws in the order of decimetres or metres.
Observed fracture frequencies and dip relations Figure 5 summarises fracture frequencies and dip relations as recorded in the wells investigated. The diagrams demonstrate that the fracture frequencies vary considerably and unsystematically with depth, and between the wells. The fractures which are of
Fig. 5. Diagram showing lithology, fracture frequency, fracture orientation and rock strength of Fuglen Formation in (a) well 7321/9-1, (b) well 7219/9-1, (c) well 7120/2-2, (d) well 7120/6-1, (e) well 7120/12-1 and (f) well 7228/9-1.
Late Jurassic-early Cretaceous caprocks of the southwestern Barents Sea: fracture systems and rock mechanical properties
a Core Oep
WELL 7321/9-1 GAMMA-LOG
C LITHO-
LtTHOLOGY STRAT.
ff
ROCK MECH,
DIPANGLE
--
~
83
WELL 7120 / 2-2
Core Depth (m) GAMMA-LOG 2636 . . .
fi
LIIHO-
LITHOLOGY STRAT. . .
DIP ANGLE
ROCK MECH.
3? 38-
F 3SU
50%
n = 25
264C -
G L
40"/=-
<
i
<
i
41 -
a i
42 -
o
i
z
E
i
43N
30%-
44 24
45-
F 20-
264E
M.
i
.... 5
5
10
15
20
0" 10' 20" 30"40'50"60'70"80" S.S
Eso
Core Depth (m) GAMMA-LOG 2371 ....
LfTHOLITHOLOGY STRAT,
72
WELL 7219/9-1 ft
20'
30'40'50'60"70'80'
DIP ANGLE
40=/0 -
G
n=18
L
76
30%-
E~
<
,
77
N
78
I
79
O
8O
i
M.! =
2381 ,, lOO M S SNqO
0
5
15
20
0" 10' 20" 30"40"50"60"70"80"
WELL 7120/12-1
e
Core Depth (m) GAMMA-LOG 1337 ......
L
10
k
T
G
ROCK MECH.
F
75
ROCK MECH,
DIP ANGLE
O' 10'
ff
ul
74
UTHO LITHOLOGY STRAT.
20
50%-
73
GAMMA-LOG Core Dept" " "
15
WELL 7 1 2 0 / 6 - 1
d
10 M S SAND C TOP UD /L ~L ST~ T FM.
10
LITH0. LITHOLOGY STRAT.
ff
DIP ANGLE
ROCK MECH.
!
38 -
E
i!
N
40=/=-
39 40 41 -
60-
421-
43i 44' 45j
50-
P n ,,65
M.
i
40-
-I
RI
Q
R
o z
! !
!
F
i
M.
1546 i
....
MAX
5
10
15
20
I
0' ,0" 20' 30"40"50'60"70'80"
1562 1
30*/,
501
~
63
<
64 65 lO%~
"
"-
66
lO
IM-I
1567 ~11111
~o ~ ~ ~ D TL
I
I
I
I
5
10
15
.20
L
0' 10' 20'30'40'50"60"70"80" S.S
Eso
GAMMA-LOG
oo,h i
s.s = shear strength
I
i
E so = Young's modulus
,
,
,5
20
LITHOLITHOLOGY STP~T.
(
H
44
ff = fracture frequncy
, 10
WELL 7228/9-1
f Core
LEGEND
, 5
...i.
KI
I
45
K R K I I L
max
46
NL G
rain
47
EM. I
20% -
N
48
10% -
49 1050
30%-
MF . ~ 5
"~
' '
' '
'
lO ~ ,~ sAND~ D L T
L
,
S
,
,
~o ,5
I
,,
2O 0: 10"20' 3o"4o'50'80'70'60'S.S Eso
R.H. Gabrielsen and O.S. KtCvjan
84
tectonic origin, and which define observable angles to the bedding, are recorded in the ft column in the logs (ft = number of fractures per core meter). Rubble zones and zones of scaly foliation believed to be of tectonic origin, have also been marked individually. Dips of fracture planes have been measured whenever possible. Except for well 7125/1-1, the cores are not oriented, and strikes of fractures are accordingly generally unknown. Dip measurements have preferentially been carried out on unslabbed cores, or on Acuts. For some of the cores, however, only B-cuts have been available. In these cases, dip measurements are less reliable, and even a minimum dip angle may be difficult to assess. In such cases, the measurements were excluded from that database. The dips were measured assuming that the core axis is vertical. In general, the dips are measured with an estimated error of less than 5 ~. This is in accordance with similar estimates of errors of dip measurements in cores done by others (e.g., Lundberg and Casey Moore, 1986). As seen from Fig. 5, there are considerable differences in fracture frequencies and fracture orientation between the rocks of the Teistengrunnen Group encountered in the wells of the study area. For geological interpretation of the fracture systems, data presented in Fig. 5 need to be combined with "fracture dip profiles" which illustrate the distribution in percent of fractures (y-axis) with different dips (x-axis) (Fig. 6). The figures illustrate a clear difference between the three main fault complexes. The fracture dip profiles from the BjCrnCyrenna Fault Complex display a Poisson distribution with a clear dominance of low-angle fractures, whereas results from the Hammerfest and Nordkapp Basins reveals a Gaussian distribution with a maximum for the dip angle around 50 ~ Also steep dip angles (80-90 ~ are seen in the latter domain. (In evaluating the "fracture dip profiles", it should, however, be noted that the total number of fractures in the eastern basin areas is only 15 as compared to 150 in the master fault complexes.) From the fracture orientation and frequency data, the following general observations are made: (1) the shales in the western part of the investigated area, and especially those situated within or near the major fault complexes, generally are more heavily fractured than those from the eastern areas. (2) The shales of the Fuglen Formation sampled within the BjCrnCyrenna Fault Complex are dominated by low-angle fractures. (3) The shales of the Hammerfest and Nordkapp Basins are characterised by more highangle (50-60 ~ fractures. This seems to be a valid observation, even when the small number of fractures observed in this domain are taken into account.
Rock mechanical data from cap rocks of the southwestern Barents Sea Two series of rock mechanical experiments (consolidated anisotropically undrained (CAU) triaxial and uniaxial compression tests) were performed on shales and mudstones from the Fuglen and Hekkingen Formations for Norsk Hydro by the Norwegian Geotechnical Institute. Using "vertical" samples (drilled and loaded at a right angle to bedding) from well 7219/9-1, shear strengths between 22.6 and 37.5 MPa were obtained, compared to 16.3-40.2 MPa for samples from well 7321/9-1 (Table 3). The tests made on a shale from the Hekkingen Formation (well 7228/2-1, 7228/9-1, and 7125/1-1) gave values be-
6050I
40-
30 -
"\~.a
oi:.] ..... ,,%x
..o. .." -
,:.i.- "~R< '.. "\ ~ "..~-._.~,..~. .....
1
\ m- / /~ -\..
....
9
I
Y
oooO
....
I
~
\
.
.\""t:k, ,.9 1o.,. ~
"1"
"-~
T
.o
r
0-10 11-20 21-30 31-40 41-50 51-60 61-70 71-80 81-90 50 45
I ~
I
40
35 30 25"1~
I I
201 \ 1 /N 5~
0-10
3530252015-
I?,,\ \ ~
p\
I / \\
11-20 21-30
/
/
~,
31-40 41-50
///
51-60
a \\\
81-70
71-80 81-90
i
1051 0 0-10 11!20 21!30 31-40 41-50 51!60 61!70 71-80 81-90 Fig. 6. Fracture dip profiles, (a) well 7321/9-1 (Fuglen Formation), (b) well 7219/9-1 (Fuglen Formation), (c) well 7120/2-2 (Hekkingen Formation), (d) 7120/6-1 (Fuglen Formation), (e) well 7120/12-1 (Fuglen and Hekkingen Formations), (f) well 7228/9-1 (Hekkingen Formation), (g) wells 7321/9-1, 7219/9-1 and 7228/9-1, experimental results, x-axis, dip-angle from 0 to 90 ~ y-axis, percentage number of fractures.
Late Jurassic-early Cretaceous caprocks o f the southwestern Barents Sea: fracture systems and rock mechanicaJ prqpertres
,__
Table 3 Summary of rock mechanical properties of shales from the Fuglen (wells 7321/9-1 and 7219/9-1) and Hekkingen (well 7228/9-1) formations Well
Orientation
Ymax (MPa)
7219/9-1 7321/9-1 7321/9-1 7228/9-1 7125/1-1 7125/1-1 7228/2-1 7228/2-1 7324/10-1 7324/10-1 7324/10-1
Vertical Fuglen Vertical Fuglen Horizontal Fuglen Vertical Hekk. Vertical Hekk. Horizontal Hekk. Vertical Hekk. Horizontal Hekk. Vertical Horizontal Horizontal (cc) Snadd
22.6-37.5 16.3-40.2 13.7-22.4 7.5-22.7 8.9-32.0 30.2-39.0 7.5-27.2 15.8-30.6 >25-35 25-35 60--65
E50 (MPa) 7600-9500 1800-1600 5700-9500 2400-3500 4000-6000 7500-8700 2800-5510 6310-9570 15000 35000
eef (%)
CS (MPa)
~' (o)
o"2' or o"3'/Ol ' ratio
0.2-0.8 1.18-1.64 0.49 0.5-2.7 0.6-1.9 0.9-1.4 0.6-1.9 0.4-1.3 >0.3
11.5-16.0 9.1-20.0 6.4 4.5-5.5 16.9-17.5 12.5 14.5-18.5 4.75 35 2.5 37
15-20 13-20 30 19-23 8-13 25 4-9.5 26.5 5 48 23
0.20-0.43 0.32 0.32 0.1-0.5 0.48 0.25 0.1-0.54 0.23-0.31
c. 0.3
The following data are given: rma x = range of measured shear strength, ES0 = range of tangent Young's modulus, eef = range of axial strain at failure, C ' = "cohesion" intercept, ~ ' = angle of internal friction, a 2' or o.3'/o'1' = ratio of cell pressure to axial stress at failure. "Cohesion" and angle of internal friction are given in terms of effective stress. Note that data from both vertical and horizontal specimens are given for wells 7321/9-1, 7125/1-1 and 7228/2-1.
tween 7.5 and 32.0 MPa. For "horizontal" samples (drilled and loaded parallel to the bedding), shear strengths in the range between 13.7 and 22.4 MPa were obtained. During CAU triaxial testing, most specimens showed a general brittle deformation, although brittleness varied from sample to sample. With one exception (test 3 of well 7321/9-1 where the rock strength exceeded that of the apparatus), the tests were run to failure. The dip angle of the experimentally generated fractures were measured after the deformation. For the Fuglen Formation of well 7321/91, planar conjugate fractures (double shears) were developed, and nine fractures with an average dip of 56 ~ were measured. Shales of the Fuglen Formation in well 7219/9-1 revealed a slightly different pattern in that single shears were predominant and fractures with gentle dips (10-25 ~) were developed in connection with the steeper fractures (mean dip angle 55~ For the shales of the Hekkingen Formation in Well 7228/9-1 the mean was 58 ~. This indicates that the shales of the Fuglen as well as the Hekkingen Formation develop fractures very close to the theoretically value of 20 = 60 ~ during vertical loading.
A model for the fracture development of cap rocks in the southwestern Barents Sea Both mode I (tensile) and mode II (shear) fractures are commonly generated in sedimentary rocks during burial and uplift, and it is well established that the horizontal stresses (all and ah) as a function of burial and loading alone are related to the vertical stress av according to
v (XH = Uh =
1-v
aEAt -