Hong Kong Cinema Since 1997
This page intentionally left blank
Hong Kong Cinema Since 1997 The Post-Nostalgic Imagi...
60 downloads
2300 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Hong Kong Cinema Since 1997
This page intentionally left blank
Hong Kong Cinema Since 1997 The Post-Nostalgic Imagination Vivian P. Y. Lee
© Vivian P. Y. Lee 2009 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No portion of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, Saffron House, 6-10 Kirby Street, London EC1N 8TS. Any person who does any unauthorized act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The author has asserted her right to be identified as the author of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. First published 2009 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN Palgrave Macmillan in the UK is an imprint of Macmillan Publishers Limited, registered in England, company number 785998, of Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS. Palgrave Macmillan in the US is a division of St Martin’s Press LLC, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010. Palgrave Macmillan is the global academic imprint of the above companies and has companies and representatives throughout the world. Palgrave® and Macmillan® are registered trademarks in the United States, the United Kingdom, Europe and other countries. ISBN-13: 978–0–230–22143–7 hardback This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. Logging, pulping and manufacturing processes are expected to conform to the environmental regulations of the country of origin. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 09 Printed and bound in Great Britain by CPI Antony Rowe, Chippenham and Eastbourne
In memory of my brother, James Lee
This page intentionally left blank
Contents
Introduction
1
Part I Time and Memory 1 Post-nostalgia: In the Mood for Love and 2046
21
2 Cinematic Remembrances: Ordinary Heroes and Little Cheung
43
3 Allegory, Kinship, and Redemption: Fu Bo and Isabella
66
Part II Schizophrenia, Amnesia, and Cinephilia 4 Lost in the Cosmopolitan Crime Zone: Johnnie To’s Urban Legends
87
5 The Kung Fu Hero in the Digital Age: Stephen Chow’s ‘Glocal’ Strategies
117
6 Karmic Redemption: Memory and Schizophrenia in Hong Kong Action Films
138
Part III In and Out 7 Migrants in a Strange City: (Dis-)Locating the China Imaginary
163
8 Outside the Nation: The Pan-Asian Trajectory of Applause Pictures
184
The Hong Kong Multiplex: An Unfolding Narrative
211
Notes
218
Hong Kong Cinema Since 1997: Glossary
236
Bibliography
242
Index
250
vii
This page intentionally left blank
Introduction
This book is a critical study of the developments of Hong Kong cinema after the transfer of sovereignty from Britain to the People’s Republic of China in 1997. Neither an empirical survey nor historical account of the film industry, it attends to what I call the post-nostalgic imagination in Hong Kong cinema in the first decade of Chinese rule. Aesthetically, the post-nostalgic has nuanced connections with a long tradition of filmmaking that has developed from creative synergies of both local and foreign sources. Historically, one and a half century of colonial rule and its postcolonial aftermath has also shaded the local cinema with a tinge of ‘homesickness’, from nostalgia for a lost (Chinese) homeland in early years to a fin-de-siècle melancholy at the end of colonial rule, and ambivalence towards the prospects of the de-colonized present. The ‘Chineseness’ of this local cinema, however debatable, is still felt in the resilience of the realist tradition: refined and updated by the Hong Kong New Wave cinema and subsequent arthouse films, elements of the Chinese realist cinema still find varied employment in the mainstream cinema, with an overall thrust to reflect and occasionally critique social conditions albeit in lighter-hearted and throwaway entertainment packages. (The grassroots consciousness of Cantonese comedies and melodramas, and the national allegory in Tsui Hark’s new martial arts films are good examples in this category.) It is important therefore to point out early in this study that the post-nostalgic imagination explored in the following chapters is as new as it is not, in the sense that newness always has a genealogy and is always informed by it. Yet it is new because it gives expression to changing categories of value and frames of reference at a time of paradigm shifts, registered in the change in political sovereignty, realignments of power in the global economy, and multiple financial and biological epidemics 1
2
Hong Kong Cinema Since 1997
that have ravaged the local society since the Asian financial crisis in 1997. The analysis in the following chapters aims to identify key features of the post-nostalgic imagination in a range of post-1997 Hong Kong films across different styles and genres, and offer some points of departure for further research. More specifically, it addresses three important recurrent themes since the so-called ‘golden age’ of the New Hong Kong Cinema from the early 1980s to the early 1990s: nostalgia, memory, and the problematic of the ‘local’. These themes, I believe, provide clues to understanding the permutations of the local cinematic imagination in the post-handover years. Two sets of questions underscore the present inquiry: firstly, what is the nature of nostalgia in the film text? What are its constituent features? Does the deployment of nostalgia serve as a critique of the nostalgic, and hence result in a new practice of the image? Secondly, what happens to the ‘local’ under the double hegemony of the national and the global? Is the local still relevant to Hong Kong cinema in a state of flux? In my discussion, these questions are seen through specific thematic, contextual, and formal elements of the films and filmmakers in question in each chapter. The post-nostalgic, therefore, is not a reductive category or a universal formula. Rather, it points to a shared aesthetic temperament behind a diversity of filmic imaginations. Nonetheless, it is not impossible to conceptualize this diversity in more concrete terms. Among these are the notion of intertextuality as both a means and a formal expression of the post-nostalgic, and the idea of the local and its enduring instability when applied to the case of Hong Kong. To the extent that the production of the local in Hong Kong cinema since the 1980s has a dual register in the arthouse cinema’s rethinking of history and the recycling of past images in commercial films, intertextuality and the local also provide vantage points to access the post-handover milieu. As we shall see, the post-nostalgic is used to characterize certain particularities of post-1997 Hong Kong cinema so as to distinguish it from the kind of postmodern nostalgia in Fredric Jameson’s critique of the late capitalist society. In the local context, intertextuality articulates quite different desires and meanings, to which I will return later in this introduction. Before turning to intertextuality as a formal and symbolic component of the post-nostalgic, it is useful here to first revisit the trajectory of the local in popular and critical discourse, and how it is understood in this study. The two decades prior to the handover is a period that marked the city’s political transition from a British colony to a Special Administrative Region (SAR) of the People’s Republic of China. Beginning from
Introduction
3
the mid-1990s, the local film industry ran into a period of recession. Many critics lamented the decline in both quality and box-office returns of local productions, thus almost confessing a fin-de-siècle nostalgic mourning of loss, as the film industry took further plunges thanks to the Asian financial meltdown in late 1997 and the SARS epidemic in 2003. The fate of Hong Kong cinema, it seems, ‘mirrors’ the political uncertainties, economic failures, and the concomitant social malaise that visited the ex-colony at this critical historical juncture. As I will explain later on in this introduction, while nostalgia triggered by the apprehension of the ‘end of (colonial) history’ pervaded the local cinema during the two decades of political transition, neither history nor the historical imagination ended with the arrival of the ‘future anterior’, that is, the anxiety over ‘what will have been’,1 as filmmakers have made crossovers to the post-handover realities of the ex-colony with an awareness of the new social, political, and cultural configurations and their impact on the understanding and articulation of the local, a problematic made more so by its multiple entanglements with the national, the transnational, and the global. This awareness calls for a self-evaluation among filmmakers and the film industry as a whole in order to survive the new challenges from within and outside the local-national context. The mutual entwinement of the local/global and national/transnational has been a central concern of recent academic discourse in the humanities, especially the way in which globalization has weakened old forms of identities and affiliations through drastic realignments of political, social, and economic interests, thereby redrawing and redefining national, regional, and cultural boundaries that used to provide frames of reference for communal and individual identification.2 In film studies it has been acknowledged that the forces of globalization and their uneven encounters with local specificities are inextricably linked to the emergence and increasing predominance of transnational cinema, which Ezra and Rowden describe as being ‘most “at home” in the in-between spaces of culture . . . between the local and the global’ and ‘a marker of cosmopolitanism [that] at once transcends the national and presupposes it’.3 In the context of Hong Kong, this fourfold problematic is heavily inflected by the history of colonialism and the condition of postcoloniality that not only follows national reunification, but also precedes it, in what Ackbar Abbas calls ‘pre-postcoloniality’ as an attribute of pre-1997 Hong Kong films. If the cinema of Mainland China in the 1980s and early 1990s has been concerned with reconstructing a common, albeit ‘unofficial’ cultural past as an integral part of a bigger quest for a renewed sense of nationhood, Hong Kong cinema of
4
Hong Kong Cinema Since 1997
the same period was in the grips of a cultural imaginary of the ‘local’ that is neither completely (comfortably) Chinese nor British, but an in-between entity that draws attention to and calls into question the ambiguities of its own histories and cultural roots vis-à-vis both the colonial and the Chinese ‘heritage’. Instead of being a claustrophobic imagination of origins, the local, thanks also to the thoroughly commercialized and commodified nature of Hong Kong cinema, is open to other inflections: Hollywood, international film festivals and arthouse circuits, and the work of a critical mass of film critics and scholars have promoted Hong Kong films and filmmakers to the world. If a key aspect of transnationalism ‘is the recognition of the decline of national sovereignty as a regulatory force in global existence’, it is also true that ‘its nationalist other is . . . a canny dialogical partner whose voice often seems to be growing stronger at the very moment that its substance is fading away’.4 In Hong Kong cinema since the 1980s, the ‘China factor’ has been a looming presence, just as the nation itself has now become both a symbolic and a material force. Ironically, this takes place at a time when globalization, and transnational filmmaking thereof, has rendered oblivious established understanding of the nation and national cinema.5 In film studies, ‘Chinese cinemas’ has replaced ‘Chinese cinema’ as a standard term of reference. While Sheldon Lu (1997: 3) sees more relevance in the term ‘transnational’ to conceptualize Chinese cinemas today, Berry and Farquhar (2006) propose to rethink the relation between cinema and the national, in which the latter term is less a geopolitical given than a problem: ‘Within the framework of cinema and the national, the national appears as multiple and constructed . . . places that have the most evidently complex relation to the national [e.g. Hong Kong, Taiwan, and the People’s Republic of China] are likely to emerge as privileged sites of analysis now’.6 ‘[W]ith the shift to a framework of cinema and the national that puts the focus on the national as a problem’, say Berry and Farquhar, ‘other local and transnational identity formations [i.e. region, class, race, religion, gender, and sexuality] take center stage’.7 The complex dynamics between the local/global and the national/ transnational underline many Hong Kong films that deal with nostalgia and memory. Scholarship on this ‘nostalgic wave’ in Hong Kong cinema, and indeed in the cultural production of Hong Kong and Mainland China during the 1990s, has shed light on the nature of this nostalgia and its cinematic manifestations. In the same collection of essays on Hong Kong cinema, Linda Lai Chiu-han and Rey Chow write respectively on the use of nostalgia in the films of Stephen Chow (what Lai
Introduction
5
calls ‘enigmatization’) and Stanley Kwan’s Rouge (see below).8 Commenting on the commercial exploitation of the ‘grand narrative’ of Hong Kong’s success story, Eric Ma exposes the ideological underpinnings of the officially sanctioned nostalgic story of Hong Kong’s past shared by both the Chinese and the British authorities (Chapter 7).9 Nostalgia manifests itself in a wide range of 1980s and 1990s films which can be broadly put under three categories: (1) the overtly nostalgic: films that mainly recycle past images in self-reflexive parody (Chapter 1); (2) the projection of a fin-de-siècle sentiment through direct reference to impending crisis, personal reminiscence, or displacement, usually featuring characters caught in a present state of flux. This category includes John Woo’s hero films (a ‘cinema of crisis’ according to Tony Williams), as well as films of a more intimate and personal nature, for example Ann Hui’s Song of the Exile/Ke tu qiu hen (1990), Yim Ho’s Homecoming/Si sui liu lian (1984), and Wong Kar-wai’s Days of Being Wild/A fei zhengzhuan (1990); and (3) superimposition of nostalgic imagery on the present in the form of a ghost and/or haunting memories, for instance Stanley Kwan’s Rouge/Yanzhi kou (1987), Center Stage/Ruan Lingyu (aka. The Actress, 1991), and Ann Hui’s Spooky Bunch/Zhuang daozheng (1980). In these films, nostalgia takes three main forms: the present seen through a hallucinatory reconstruction of the past (horror and supernatural thrillers); a hallucinatory projection of the present as a moment of impending crises and ruins (John Woo and action cinema); and the past as an amalgamation of past images being rediscovered as a source of collective cultural memory (popular nostalgia films). These traits speak to the peculiar intertextuality of the nostalgic imagination in Hong Kong films in the 1990s. This study will look at mutations of the nostalgic imagination in Hong Kong horror, action, comedy, and arthouse drama films after the political handover not merely as historical and political allegories, but also as an important part of the local visual culture that enables new critical engagements with established visual codes and conventions of Hong Kong cinema. Running through my discussion is the belief that the nostalgic, hence the post-nostalgic, is a key to understanding the nuanced connections between the cinematic imagination and the larger sociopolitical realities of Hong Kong; it also demonstrates the importance of the local cinema to the collective cultural memory of the ex-colony by supplying it with both entertaining and thought-provoking images to make sense of the present. More importantly, the intimate link between nostalgia and historical memory in the Hong Kong context helps to explain a specific quality of Hong Kong films in the last decade, in that nostalgia
6
Hong Kong Cinema Since 1997
is transformed by an active re-visioning of past visual codes that bespeak not a break with the past, but a need to embrace the nostalgic in new ways, that is, new treatment of old themes and new configurations of tried images to speak to the realities of the present. As the following chapters will demonstrate, whether in arthouse or commercial films, the nostalgic resurfaces in the intertextual links between past images and the film text in the present in ways and for purposes quite different from earlier films. In essence, the post-nostalgic is not ‘anti-nostalgic’, but implies a nuanced relatedness to the past as history/text/image; as such, the post-nostalgic can also be construed as a form of meta-(con)textual self-critique. I am, of course, speaking in general terms, but, as Mike Featherstone says of the relation between modernism and postmodernism, it is within the tension between a break from old forms and the discovery of a budding presence of the new in the old that the prefix ‘post’ can best be understood.10 In this light the term ‘post-nostalgic’ used in this study is an attempt to better describe and understand the new face/phase of nostalgia in Hong Kong films in the post-handover period. This term therefore is highly contextualized in meaning and has to be understood and applied as such. One other reason for coining the ‘post-nostalgic’ is to avoid a likely conflation with the kind of ‘postmodern nostalgia’ that Fredric Jameson has eloquently argued in his discussion of late capitalism and commodity culture in the post-industrial West.11 While postmodern nostalgia, as Jameson sees it, is undeniably present in some Hong Kong films, and I agree that Hong Kong society does share many of the characteristics of Jameson’s late capitalist consumer society, the nostalgic as manifested in Hong Kong cinema has other equally important traits and qualities that need to be differentiated from Jameson’s theory of the postmodern.12 For one thing, the characterization of postmodern nostalgia as ‘depthless’ and symptomatic of a weakening or loss of history does not do full justice to the kind of nostalgic and post-nostalgic imagination discernible in Hong Kong cinema. As Ackbar Abbas has cogently argued, Hong Kong cinema ‘has to be popular in order to be at all’. Granted, it is also possible, if not imperative, to make ‘a virtue out of necessity’.13 Shelly Kraicer rightly notes that in Hong Kong cinema, the opposition between art film and commercial genre film is a ‘false dichotomy . . . since its origins contains . . . a rich array of genres’, ranging from ‘artistic melodrama, social realism, didactic political commentary . . . satirical comedy, adult romance, youth coming-of-age, and historical nostalgia [to] a home-brewed authentic “art film” genre,
Introduction
7
the HK New Wave’. 14 If being ‘postmodern’ inevitably means a blatant disregard of boundary, such as that between art and commodity, Hong Kong cinema has indeed been postmodern in order to be modern, an anachronism befitting the dilemma of being ‘post-’ anything. Thus, in this study, the post-nostalgic is invoked to investigate the critical revisitation of the nostalgic in the local cinema stripped of fin-de-siècle splendor, when the ‘will have been’ has become passé, when the ‘culture and politics of disappearance’ has to be re-negotiated in the materialized present at a time when the territory is under a new set of rules governing its social, economic, and political well-being. Readers also will discover in the following chapters that the local is used in conjunction with a range of cultural and filmic practices associated with the emotional attachment to old forms, which include narrative and visual culture, architectural spaces, and various visual and generic codes that have helped establish Hong Kong cinema as a unique regional trademark in its global circulation. Nonetheless, as a predominantly commercial cinema, this trademark is, and will continue to be, subject to pragmatic adjustments and structural re-engineering that respond to not only the vicissitudes of the global market, but also the newly important ‘national domestic’ market in Mainland China. As the local becomes part of the global, the transnational is also increasingly redefined by its nuanced connections and reactions to the national. In the post-1997 milieu, these new conditions of possibilities find expressions in Hong Kong films at the levels of style, content, and production and marketing strategies. This study contends that while the national and the local are being challenged by the transnational and the global, in Hong Kong cinema the problematic of the local remains central to a wide spectrum of films and filmmakers. This is partly due to the as yet unanswered quest for identity—a local identity constituted not by some authentic essence but impurities and ambivalence at the very enunciation of the word. As mentioned above, the post-nostalgic is not anti-nostalgic, but designates a mutation in the nature of cinematic nostalgia and the shifting frames of reference that result. It is useful here to outline the contextual and theoretical considerations in analysing the nostalgia film and the use of nostalgia in film in Hong Kong cinema since the mid-1980s to provide an anchorage for the forthcoming chapters. Since this book is concerned with the post-handover years, the two decades prior to the change of sovereignty will serve mainly as the historical context for more recent developments. To this end, I try to engage current critical
8
Hong Kong Cinema Since 1997
scholarship on nostalgia, memory, and historical representation in film to situate my analysis in a broader theoretical framework.
Nostalgia: Images and memory The box-office and critical success of 92 Legendary La Rose Noire/92 Hei meigui dui hei meigui (Jeffrey Lau 1992) set the decade’s trend of nostalgic films parodying 1950s and 1960s Cantonese movies and star personae (Chapter 1). Other commercial productions, most notably John Woo’s ‘hero films’ and Tsui Hark’s eclectic corpus of action-comedies, selfconsciously reflect on Hong Kong’s political uncertainties, with a deep sense of loss imbuing both the film narrative and a cinematography that indulges in Hong Kong’s fin-de-siècle cityscape (Chapter 4). In Tsui’s case, national allegory carries satirical remarks on Chinese history, as in the case of the Once Upon a Time in China/Huang Feihong series starring Jet Li as the legendary kung fu master, Huang Feihong, a character resurrected from old Cantonese movies from the 1950s. Playful, sentimental, and at times irreverent, the nostalgia articulated in these films, by virtue of their self-conscious theatricality, that is, their self-awareness as commodities, is not about the search for a founding cultural myth, or a collective national past to be condemned or redeemed (which better describes 1980s cultural imagination in Mainland China and much of pre-1980s Taiwan literature). Instead, the nostalgic imagination celebrates its eclecticism in articulating a sense of the local, very often portrayed as an uprooted subject. At about the same time, cinematic nostalgia infused more serious arthouse films exemplified by the Hong Kong New Wave and the ‘second wave’;15 instead of hilarious gags and explosive action, these films engage with nostalgia as a vehicle for historical reflection, self-discovery, and cultural critique. Stylistically and thematically diverse, these films revisit the past as a site of contending personal memories. While Yim Ho’s Homecoming depicts China as a benign hometown for the Hong Kong migrant, Ann Hui’s Song of the Exile problematizes such naturalized homecoming: in Hui’s film, the truly nostalgic figures are die-hard (Japanese and Chinese) nationalists, and by refuting their claim to truth Hui effectively deconstructs nostalgia as national myth. Stanley Kwan’s Center Stage juxtaposes fictional and documentary fragments showcasing two actresses from 1930’s Shanghai and 1980’s Hong Kong as mutually reflexive timeframes to destabilize the authenticity of the bio-pic, and Wong Kar-wai’s Days of Being Wild re-enacts the sad tale of being banished from one’s origin to ‘de-link’ identity and authenticity.
Introduction
9
Defending the nostalgia film of the 1970s in American cinema against Jameson’s criticism of the pastiche as a de-historicizing commodity form, Vera Dika points out the potential resistance of certain nostalgia films (e.g. American Graffiti and The Conformist), noting, via Roland Barthes, that the recycling of old forms ‘does not demythify the original’ but implies ‘a tendency to utilize original forms for critical oppositions or displacements’ (original italics).16 Although this critical function does not apply to all nostalgia films, Dika’s argument illuminates the complex, sometimes subconscious, impulses in filmic recycling of past images, and also the tension between the ‘depthless’ recycled images and the weight of historical memory these images refer to and evoke in the audience. Commenting on the historical meaning of nostalgia films in 1990s Hong Kong, and also as a corrective to the Jamesonian critique of nostalgia mentioned above, Natalia Chan writes, The reconfiguration of the idols of 1950s and 1960s cinema and the reconstruction of the social setting and moral values of the historical past that carry out the nostalgic emotion in audience reception signifies the collective unconsciousness and the social memory of the people of Hong Kong. It is a nostalgia that points to the introspection of the past, the anxiety of the present, and the uncertainty of the future of the city. It is also a nostalgia that awakens the sense of social belonging as well as the search for cultural identity.17 If nostalgia as manifested in Hong Kong cinema constitutes a form of social memory, this memory, or its cinematic evocation, is less rooted in actual historical events than in a shared cultural imaginary (hence the ‘collective unconsciouness’) and a shared sentiment when experiencing, and re-experiencing, images from the past. Indeed, nostalgic films during this period usually display a self-conscious artificiality to draw attention not to a verifiable past but to the film styles and period codes of the local popular culture. While it is tempting to dismiss this kind of nostalgic appropriations as mere ‘surfaces’, a kind of pastiche that is depthless, de-historicizing, and devoid of critical content typical of the postmodern commodification of art and culture, contemporary art, high and low, seems to have embraced the pastiche as a potential tool for cultural critique and subversion: ‘Postmodern pastiche is about cultural memory and the merging of horizons past and present’, says Ingeborg Hoesterey;18 it is a ‘dialogical mode . . . of cultural production in postmodernism’ and ‘a vast semantic field in which . . . superimpositions of genre and mode come about as a result of cultural perceptions
10
Hong Kong Cinema Since 1997
and conceptual traditions’.19 As a form of pastiche that merges horizons past and present, cinematic nostalgia in its high and low forms invites critical re-appraisal as a self-reflexive mode of historical representation characterized by self-conscious theatricality and a creative engagement with pre-existing images and texts.
Nostalgic intertexts: Locating the local in the post-1997 imagination In her article on Stanley Kwan’s Rouge, Rey Chow reflects on the nature of nostalgia and its ‘embodiment’ in the filmic image: ‘Nostalgia is not simply a reaching toward the definite past from a definite present, but a subjective state that seeks to express itself in pictures imbued with particular memories of a certain pastness’ (215, italics added).20 In Chow’s reading, nostalgia is a subjective state and a powerful presence in the filmic image, or what she calls ‘the filmic-image-as-nostalgia’, for the image, says Chow, is replete with objects and details, and bodily gestures and facial expressions that, when projected on screen, ‘becomes collective as well as completely private’.21 Thus nostalgia as an imaginary has to be understood in terms of its fantastical qualities, that is, the ‘pictures’ that carry memories of pastness. This understanding of the visuality of nostalgia, or nostalgic envisioning of pastness, highlights not only the imagistic quality of nostalgia, but also the (inter)textuality of a nostalgic invocation of pastness, for every pictorial (re)construction of pastness necessitates repetition and appropriation of other texts—a pastiche of certain pre-existing images that constitute the collective or private repertoire of cultural memory. This is precisely what Rey Chow discovers in the work of Li Bihua (author of the novel on which Rouge is based): ‘Li Bihua’s writings are always characterized by a fascination with the materials of past literature—with words, phrases, idioms, legends, history books . . . Li constructs loss as something that is not specifiable and yet traceable in the intertextual relation between the past and the present’ (original italics).22 The ‘idiomatic’ nostalgia is similar to what Linda Lai Chiu-han calls ‘enigmatization’ in 1990s Hong Kong films (especially Stephen Chow’s ‘cinema of nonsense’), referring to the genre’s strategy of ‘addressing a distinctly local viewer with quotations of popular stereotypes, stock characters, recognizable plot lines, and other conventions from classical Cantonese and Mandarin films, either in a period context or a contemporary setting’. In her analysis, Lai not only acknowledges the social function and subversive potential of these popular texts, but she also notes that ‘the substance of popular memory [in these films] is
Introduction
11
centrifugal to the dominant discourse of Hong Kong’s economic success story’ or the ‘official grand narrative of “Hong Kong history”.’23 While both Chow and Lai’s essays deal with nostalgia in pre-1997 Hong Kong cinema, their arguments are insightful to a critical appraisal of what comes after. First of all, they suggest that nostalgia is not simply a depthless pastiche but, in its localized form nostalgia in Hong Kong cinema reflects the unique character of the social memory it embodies, as reconstituted forms of popular culture, a text created by parodying and appropriating older texts. This aspect of cinematic nostalgia, as a means to re-appropriate the past through revisiting pre-existing images, is at work in many post-1997 films discussed in the following chapters. As the following chapters will demonstrate, the aesthetic of nostalgia after 1997, especially in the mainstream cinema, tends to be less celebratory in its evocation of the past; more importantly, it is less certain about the meaning of the past images and codes being recycled in the present. While there remains an emotional attachment to old form, this nostalgic sentiment is often countered by a desire to anchor the past in the present, that is, to reinvent the film medium through a conscious reconfiguration of past images. In some cases, the reconfiguring act carries as much thematic weight as what is signified on-screen. Different from the recycling of past images in most nostalgia films, the high degree of selfconsciousness in the use of intertextual references at the stylistic and sometimes thematic levels across genres, from visual styles and characterization to spatial representation, seems to go beyond nostalgia. In other words, the post-nostalgic is a serious attempt to regain a sense of history by a self-conscious grounding in the local popular cultural tradition, especially that of filmmaking. As such, the post-nostalgic can be understood as an aesthetic temperament shared by the films discussed in this study, and by many others I cannot cover due to the limitation of space. The urge to reinvent through self-reflexive intertextuality also demands a reinterpretation of the local against the repertoire of clichés, be they visual, verbal, ideological, social, or political. Among such clichés is the so-called grand narrative of the Hong Kong success story, which seemed to have lost its credibility during a prolonged economic depression in the wake of the Asian financial crisis in 1997. The HKSAR government’s repeated policy failures in managing these unprecedented crises, especially in its handling of the SARS epidemic in 2003, added fuel to the already widespread social discontent and further demoralized the public, culminating in the 500,000-strong mass protest on July 1, 2003 and subsequent resignations of two high-ranking officials and
12
Hong Kong Cinema Since 1997
the then Chief Executive Tung Chee-wah himself in 2005. The local film industry, like other sectors of the economy, took further plunges during these trying years. In fact, the local film industry had been hard-hit by the erosion of the domestic market by Hollywood films and a growing piracy market since mid-1993. As box-office revenues continued to drop and local productions declined, filmmakers were under tremendous pressure to either sink or swim. It was at this critical time that new angles were sought to engage with old genres, and new light was shed on conventional modes. At the same time, the success of a few directors in capturing overseas (Western) audiences, as in the cases of John Woo and Wong Kar-wai, and the growing interest in Chinese films worldwide prompted Hong Kong filmmakers to rethink the relationship between local content and international film cultures. Meanwhile, the loosening restrictions on cultural import and joint-venture productions in Mainland China had drawn many to seek opportunities in the lucrative film market up North. Hong Kong films, it seemed, must reach out to the global market for its future survival. This awareness translates to an increasing presence of Hong Kong films at international film festivals and expos, which in turn necessitates corresponding adjustments in filmmaking and marketing strategies. Given the complex topos of the global mediascape (Appadurai) and the overlapping interests and territories in trans/national cultural production, local articulations are usually shrouded in ambivalence, running the risk of either a regressive politics that essentializes (fantasizes?) primordial identity or depoliticized apologetics of consumerism. These tendencies are observed at different levels of social and political discourse in Hong Kong nowadays. One can hardly miss the nationalistic overtones communicated through top-down soft propaganda in the mass media: government-sponsored ‘theme songs’ and musical performances by Canto pop idols; television dramas and documentaries reinforcing patriotic feelings; regular well-orchestrated ‘visits’ by Olympics gold medalists, Chinese astronauts, and other Mainland public figures sporting a modern, affluent lifestyle—all these are efforts by the local and central authorities to cultivate a sense of national belonging in Hong Kong, and to instill pride in the achievements of the Motherland (zuguo), a term that somehow has been adapted by the media to replace the more neutral word ‘China’ (zhongguo) after the handover, especially since the 2008 Beijing Olympics. The current CEO of the Hong Kong government, Donald Tsang, provoked public furor in his 2008 policy speech, which proposed increased spending on government-funded ‘educational’ trips to China for high-school
Introduction
13
students while demanding individual background checks on a minimal increment (HKD 300/month) in old-age benefits, at a time when the ‘financial tsunami’ originated in the United States had thrown the world economy into unprecedented turmoil, and many locals out of jobs. On the other hand, a particular brand of nostalgic consumerism still holds sway, as popular products and images carrying an aura of ‘old Hong Kong’ run in parallel with the cult of ‘old Shanghai’.24 As Ackbar Abbas puts it, the real issue lies not with a lack of identity, but with too many. What is needed, instead, is a new subjectivity that can resist the temptation of ‘identity’ as an innocent given, be it superimposed or oppositional.25 Between global citizenship and national belonging, it seems, the local as a site for cultural self-reinvention and ‘minoritarian’ practice easily slips into an ideological cul-de-sac. But it is by no means passé as a critical category. Instead of seeing identity as an end in itself, the local in Hong Kong films is better posited as a new problematic, one that situates itself in the interstices of past and present, mobilizing its own cultural resources as a form of memory without any pretensions of authenticity, of being well-defined and absolute. This understanding of the local, in its multiple articulations and engagements with the material and ideological forces of globalism, nationalism, and transnationalism, allows us to enter the variegated cinemascape of post-1997 Hong Kong through many generic doors; it also partakes of a larger effort by film scholars to re-examine the relationship between film as entertainment/commodity, film as art, and film as a powerful form of social discourse.26 After all, if the local is a construct invented to cope with a ‘bad situation’, its slipperiness becomes ‘something good’, a ‘weakness’ that a postcolonial subject uses to resist the rigid codification of power. Such an understanding of the local offers an opportunity to rethink the questions of nationhood, specifically those relating to China (originary culture), Mainland China (geopolitical power), and Chineseness (ethnic-cultural affiliation). This book consists of three parts: ‘Time and Memory’, ‘Schizophrenia, Amnesia, and Cinephilia’, and ‘In and Out’. The chapters in ‘Time and Memory’ examine the treatment of nostalgia and memory in a cluster of films that illustrate the post-nostalgic mode of historical imagination. The first two chapters examine the works of three arthouse directors: Wong Kar-wai, Ann Hui, and Fruit Chan. These directors mark the different stages of the New Hong Kong Cinema and its subsequent development since the early 1980s, each showing its own distinctive style and thematic concerns. All three directors exhibit a penchant for evoking
14
Hong Kong Cinema Since 1997
cultural memories through critical engagement with nostalgia, a mode of historical imagination that infiltrated many Hong Kong productions in the pre-1997 period. Chapter 1 looks at two of Wong Kar-wai’s ‘60s trilogy’, In the Mood for Love/Huayang nianhua (2002) and 2046 (2004). While these films can be classified as ‘nostalgia films’ according to the period style and nostalgic ambience that dominates the narrative and mise-en-scène, my analysis is concerned with the more intricate aspects of the use of nostalgia in these films. Through an examination of the visual and structural strategies of Mood and 2046, I argue that the films’ self-reflexive intertextuality, hybrid temporal/spatial references, and stylistic flourishes offer not only nostalgic reminiscences but also a critique of nostalgia in the form of a close self-analysis. This chapter ends with a preliminary outline of the nature and characteristics of the post-nostalgic imagination that the rest of this study will further investigate and elaborate. Wong Kar-wai may be the ‘Hong Kong auteur’ par excellence by virtue of his internationalist aesthetics and distinctively postmodern appeal; yet the more down-to-earth approach to cinematic representation characteristic of the social realism of the Hong Kong New Wave is still upheld by fellow arthouse practitioners. Chapter 2 looks at two such examples, Ann Hui’s Ordinary Heroes/Qian yan wan yu (1999) and Fruit Chan’s Little Cheung/Xiluxiang (1999). Ann Hui is a pioneer of the New Wave; while Fruit Chan made his first commercial film in 1993 (Finale in Blood/Da nao Guangchanglong), his truly breakthrough film is Made in Hong Kong/Xianggang zhizao (1997). Nonetheless, both directors show a penchant for social criticism in film, and both demonstrate a strong preference for shooting on location, using the local urbanscape not only as a backdrop but also as a repertoire of memories and local histories. This being said, Ordinary Heroes and Little Cheung represent two modes of remembering: Ann Hui’s film seeks to give voice to the silenced and marginalized by re-enacting the social and political events of the 1970s and 1980s, while Fruit Chan’s film uses the popular cultural tradition, particularly Cantonese opera and Cantonese cinema, as the locus of collective memory and social critique. In both films, the grand narrative of Hong Kong’s historical transformation into an ‘economic miracle’ and first-class global city is persistently challenged. The interweaving of references to old texts, real or imaginary, underscores the critical function of the post-nostalgic in these films. The subject of Chapter 3 is the younger generation. The films in question are Fu Bo (2003) by Wong Ching-po and Lee Kung-lok, and Isabella (2006) by Edmond Pang Ho-cheung. Wong and Lee’s film is a low-budget independent production shot on video, while Pang, with a track record in
Introduction
15
commercial productions, was able to obtain studio backing for his arthouse debut. Both films are set in Macau, a former Portuguese colony. While the tiny colonial enclave is not unfamiliar to Hong Kong film audiences, with a few exceptions Macau has functioned mainly as an excursion or adventure spot where the main action happens to spur. In Fu Bo and Isabella, Macau is neither the typical ‘Las Vegas of the East’ nor a backwater colonial enclave. Instead, the intense human drama in these films alludes to an existential crisis unfolding against the backdrop of the two cities’ (post-)colonial landscape. In all three chapters, the post-nostalgic encapsulates what I see as a common denominator of the films examined. Under this rubric I examine how these films translate the nostalgic mode of historical imagination into a renewed engagement with history as part of the living present. The second part, ‘Schizophrenia, Amnesia, and Cinephilia’, focuses on the action film. The rationale behind this choice is, firstly, Hong Kong action film (together with the martial arts film) is one of the most transnational and geographically mobile genres and for decades has been the film industry’s major export and source of domestic and overseas revenues. Secondly, in recent years the action film has increasingly become part of a global visual culture to which Hong Kong artists have made tremendous contribution. This development is closely linked to the problematic of the local and the cinema’s adaptability to political and economic vicissitudes domestic and otherwise. In this part, I look at the permutations of the action film in terms of a struggle with its own memory. The commercial weighting of action films precludes the kind of philosophical contemplations exemplified by the art directors mentioned above. Memory, as it were, is always a negotiated existence, mediating between a sharpened awareness of the genre’s need to internationalize itself to survive in the global market, the emotional attachment to local traditions, and an anxiety of losing its own history to the new global visual regime of which it is ineluctably a part. The three chapters deal with the works of Johnnie To and his Milkyway Production team, Hong Kong’s ‘King of Comedy’ Stephen Chow, and veteran action directors Andrew Lau and Alan Mak, to examine the way in which their films reflect and reflect on the changing landscape of Hong Kong cinema through genre refashioning. The chapter on Johnnie To traces the development of the new aesthetic of the ‘group hero’ and the inevitable decline, literally and symbolically, of the traditional hero prototype. These two trends were already present in other action films since the mid-1990s, but To is a key figure in transforming the genre and bringing it to international audiences. As we shall see, To’s
16
Hong Kong Cinema Since 1997
aesthetic signifies a creative synergy of conventional elements, foreign influences, and contemporary sensibilities, which account for his growing popularity among local and overseas audiences. To’s reworking of genre rightly places him among the ranks of ‘internationalized Hong Kong auteurs’ after Wong Kar-wai and John Woo. Chapter 5 temporarily shifts the focus from action to comic kung fu films, Stephen Chow’s Shaolin Soccer/Shaolin zuqiu and Kung Fu Hustle/Kung fu. These two films, I argue, embody Chow’s ‘glocal’ strategies, that is, to reinvent the local for a global audience. Known for his prolific career in ‘nonsense’ comedies (mo lei tau), Chow’s ground-breaking kung fu films earn him the much delayed recognition outside Hong Kong. To some scholars, Chow’s Shaolin Soccer partakes of the ‘new localism’ in contemporary East Asian cinema, through which the ‘local’ is recoded in a film language amenable to a wider audience in the region.27 My reading of Chow’s films attends to the creative deployment of conventional themes, visual vocabulary, and subject matter alongside mixed references to Hollywood classics to obtain a postmodern ‘remix’ of style and images. In this process, the incorporation of CGI (computer graphic imagery) plays an important role in updating and perfecting kung fu in a world obsessed with digital technologies. Indeed, Chow’s glocal strategies are a way to accommodate the filmmaker’s dialectical impulses: a deep reverence to the local cultural traditions (especially Bruce Lee-style kung fu, Cantonese melodrama and martial arts films) and a desire to transcend his localism. Chapter 6 concludes this part with a close-reading of Andrew Lau Wai-keung and Alan Mak Siufai’s Infernal Affairs/Wujian dao trilogy (2002, 2003) and Confession of Pain/Shang cheng (2006). The Infernal Affairs trilogy has been regarded as a turning point in Hong Kong’s action film, if not Hong Kong cinema per se since its decline in the mid-1990s. The box-office grossing of Part 1 surpassed the Titanic in 2002, and the trilogy has been hailed as a landmark Hollywood-style ‘high concept’ blockbuster in Hong Kong cinema. Comparatively, Lau and Mak’s subsequent and no less high concept film, Confession of Pain, has received less critical attention. Upon closer look, the latter film offers a fertile ground for comparison with its exemplary predecessors. My discussion probes the distorted psyche of the cop-hero in these films to uncover their hidden links: the obsession with memory and its schizophrenic articulations; the symbolism of the hero–villain; and the configuration of the city, its relationship to nostalgia, and resistance to its temptations. My analysis of the these films yields a different conclusion on the Infernal Affairs trilogy, especially Part 2, whose recycling of stock images from the past is symptomatic of a failed nostalgia
Introduction
17
due to its inability, or unwillingness, to re-engage the past with critical hindsight. This setback is addressed, and to some extent redressed, in Confession of Pain, when the past is de-sentimentalized, when the camera’s black humour allows the hero–villain’s memory to fade into the banalities of Christmas festivities. The last part, ‘In and Out’, is concerned with the self-positioning of Hong Kong vis-à-vis China. It approaches this local/national dynamics from two angles: (1) the changing role of the Chinese Mainland and the Mainland Chinese in the cinematic imagination, hence the open-ended question and questioning of Chineseness in the filmic text; and (2) the phenomenon of pan-Asian filmmaking and the implications for the local cinema outside the bounds of the nation. This boundary-crossing perspective on Chineseness is reflected in the generic range of films under discussion: Samson Chiu’s Golden Chicken/Jin ji 1 and 2 (2002, 2003, mainstream comedy) and Fruit Chan’s Durian Durian/Liulian piaopiao (2000) and Hollywood Hong Kong/Xianggang you ge Haolaiwu (2001, alternative/drama) in Chapter 7; and in Chapter 8 the pan-Asian co-productions of Applause Pictures, a relatively new production company founded by filmmakers Peter Chan Ho-sun and Allan Fung. This part has its point of departure the so-called ‘China factor’ in Hong Kong cinema during the last decade of colonial rule. In this study the ‘China factor’ is seen not as passé but as liberated from the rather clichéd allegorical tenor in pre-1997 cinematic discourse. The liberation, I argue, is a function of the post-nostalgic as a response to the arrival of a political certainty that has hitherto caused an overwhelming amount of uncertainties in the lived and imagined realities of many a local Hongkonger. Instead of being simply a play to end all play, this non-negotiable certainty ironically opens up new angles to contemplate the past with critical hindsight; more importantly, the reality of national reunification has become a new ground for rethinking old barriers and new barricades in social and cultural life. This part will take into consideration gender and gender stereotypes in the representation of Hong Kong–China relations. Gender and sexuality in post-colonial identity politics is a very broad and complex issue and it would take another book-length study to do a comprehensive research on this subject. In this part, gender politics are entangled with the changing perceptions of Hong Kong and China, or the ‘Hongkonger’ and the ‘Mainlander’. In Chapter 7, the figure of the prostitute makes fun of not only a long-held local bias against Mainland women, but also a timehonoured narrative of the Hong Kong success story endorsed by both the British and the Chinese authorities. It is through the contrastive
18
Hong Kong Cinema Since 1997
filmic representations of the ‘happy prostitute’ (Golden Chicken) and the ‘northern chick’ (bak gu/bei gu, meaning prostitutes from Mainland China) that the latent tension between mutual (mis-)perceptions is brought to light. As the last chapter of this book, Chapter 8 takes the discussion a little further away from the local context, looking at cross-border co-productions sporting a pan-Asian outlook. Given that co-productions have almost become a new benchmark in Asian cinema, a consideration of the impact of co-production on the content and style of films made by Hong Kong-based studios is in order. To this end I have chosen a cluster of co-produced films from Applause Picture: Going Home/Huijia (Peter Chan, 2002) and Dumplings/Jiaozi (Fruit Chan, 2004), the Hong Kong segments of Applause’s horror omnibus films, Three/San geng and Three . . . Extremes/San geng 2; and Perhaps Love/Ruguo ai (2005) and The Warlords/Toumingzhuang (2007), Peter Chan’s most recent international blockbusters. While the omnibus segments belong to an experiment to gauge the pan-Asian markets, the latter two blockbusters are made with the international (Western) audiences in mind. The difference in the films’ conceptualization and market positioning, I argue, account for the choice of subject matter, cast, genre, and filming style. My reading of the horror films examines the mutation of the ‘China factor’ in the pan-Asian context, while the portion on Perhaps Love and Warlords reflects on how the mechanism of transnational filmmaking has interfered in the creative process. The fin-de-siècle splendour of Hong Kong cinema before the end of British rule has paved the way for a post-fin-de-siècle search for new beginnings. The open-endedness and versatility of the current situation informs my closing thoughts in ‘The Hong Kong Multiplex: An Unfolding Narrative’, which recasts the main arguments in the core chapters in the light of new and developing trends and what they might hold for the future. These conjectures will better serve the purpose of this book than the finality of a conclusion. If cinematic nostalgia in the 1990s was nurtured by a commodity culture threatened by disappearance, a decade later it has become part of the collective memory of how the city has got by. In the following chapters, each film/filmmaker constitutes a site of self-reflective encounter with some aspects of personal and collective memories. The remainder of this book, perhaps, can be read in the same way: a story of how the local cinema has got by.
Part I Time and Memory
This page intentionally left blank
1 Post-nostalgia: In the Mood for Love and 2046
Wong Kar-wai is probably the most rigorously studied auteur from Hong Kong. Described by Tony Rayns as a ‘poet of time’,1 Wong has been under considerable critical spotlight ever since his 1988 debut, As Tears Go By, and his name has become synonymous with Hong Kong’s auteur cinema in critical circles worldwide. With a collection of ten features to date, Wong has been the subject of three book-length studies in English, two monographs and numerous critical essays, not to say regular reviews in printed and electronic media in different languages.2 This proliferation of writings on Wong testifies to his status as an auteur of Hong Kong cinema and world cinema as a whole. Peter Brunette, for example, sees in Wong’s films the ‘future of cinema’, while Ackbar Abbas, writing more than a decade ago, already gave credit to Wong’s idiosyncratic rewriting/destabilizing of genre that makes him a representative ‘Hong Kong filmmaker’.3 Wong’s credentials as Hong Kong’s unique ‘auteur of time’ are convincingly argued in Stephen Teo’s study on Wong, from his early stints as a television script-writer to his latest Chinese-language film, 2046 (2004). Teo’s book contextualizes Wong’s work within the Hong Kong film and television industries, noting the multiple influences from local genre films, Western cinematic traditions, and in particular Chinese and Latin American literature.4 Shelly Kraicer, commenting on Brunette’s and Teo’s works, notes that while Wong’s films are no doubt amenable to the ‘internationalist’ approach of (art) film studies (c.f. Brunette), the richness and complexity of Wong’s cinema, and by extension much of Hong Kong cinema, cannot be fully grasped without accounting for the historical context from which Wong’s films emerge, both as a continuation of the genre-steeped tradition and as a departure from it.5 Wong’s background as a television script writer and his continuous involvement in commercial projects 21
22
Time and Memory
speak volumes about the blurry line between arthouse and commercial cinema in Hong Kong. Indeed, Wong’s career path shares a lot in common with the Hong Kong New Wave, whose emergence in the early 1980s formally (and formalistically) gave birth to what Kraicer calls a ‘home-grown authentic genre’ that co-existed side-by-side with artistic melodrama, satirical comedy, and political commentary.6 These varied interpretations underscore the mutual embeddedness of local sensibilities and ‘internationalist’ aesthetics in Wong’s work. From the early films to the latest, the perennial themes of frustrated love, time, memory, and nostalgia have sustained a haunting presence in Wong’s cinematic imagination. His postmodernist aesthetics—the fragmentation of time, memory, and narrative structure, and the emotional intensity invested in the cinematic image that frequently jettisons storytelling—is nonetheless traceable to an urban sensibility nurtured by the experience of growing up in a colonial city which ‘is not so much a place as a space of transit’.7 In Wong’s films, his fascination with the urban landscape is manifest in stunningly original images in which the city mutates in a fascinating variety of tones and textures, his characters embodiments of the lost or displaced affect trying to reconnect past and present in a labyrinthine urban dreamscape in which they are perpetually caught. No doubt these qualities have global resonances (albeit mainly in arthouse circuits), but it is also true that this globality has a local origin: the time-bound specifics of colonial history, and the end of that history in 1997. Intensely personal and yet subtly allegorical, Wong’s films bear the imprint of the anxieties and disorientation of the (ex-)colonial city trying to come to terms with its identity, or lack of one thereof, at a critical historical juncture. In this way they also epitomize the cinema of Hong Kong, and perhaps Hong Kong itself, as a point of intersection, between global currents and local realities, city and nation, ‘high art’ and popular culture, affections and disaffections, memory and the loss of memory. In Wong’s films, one sees a creative symbiosis of local subject matter and a ‘universal’ film style that nonetheless borrows heavily from local genre films. Among the perennial themes of time, memory, and the impermanence of human relations, time is always the central obsession and propellant of the main action, or more frequently action-as-stasis. From the young rebel Yuddy in Days of Being Wild to the nameless lovelorn cops in Chungking Express to the melancholy middle-aged swordsman Ouyang Feng in Ashes of Time, to name a few, Wong’s characters indulge themselves in obsessive reveries as an alternative to living in the present. This nostalgic impulse is present in much of Wong’s work, in which
Post-nostalgia
23
time is deliberately fragmented into blurry images so that time itself becomes an expression and agent of subjectivity in its most vulnerable and fluid form. While these motifs are always interlocked and hardly exist in isolation in Wong’s filmic universe, in his more recent films nostalgia assumes more intriguing properties. In the Mood for Love and 2046, Stephen Teo points out, form a trilogy of ‘nostalgia films’ about the 1960s together with Days of Being Wild.8 While nostalgia is the defining ‘mood’ in these films, nostalgia also stands on its own as a subject, as the film self-reflexively contemplates the nature of its own nostalgia, which in turn is woven into the broader cultural imagination of the local in the post-1997 era. In the last two nostalgia films, Wong’s interrogation of generic modes, this time the wenyipian (or roughly called Chinese melodrama), takes the form of a profusion of signs, colours, and objects that constitute a certain ‘period code’ through which nostalgia is powerfully evoked in the film image. If, in his earlier films, the study of genre involves ‘destabilizing the clichés’,9 that is, a playful distortion of conventions to obtain a ‘new practice of the image’, I argue that Wong’s cinematic re-creations of 1960s Hong Kong in Mood and 2046 extends this deconstructive impulse and turns nostalgia into a field of interrogation by an aesthetic of visual indulgence, a strategy that works to critique the nostalgic as a predicament of the present. Situating Wong’s films within the cultural nostalgia that has swept through Hong Kong and parts of China in the 1990s, the rest of this chapter will show how this critique undercuts not only the characters’ indulgence in time past, but also the nostalgic desire aroused in the audience by the carefully designed mise-en-scène, characterization, and cinematography. I propose to read Wong’s films less as ‘nostalgia films’ than as ‘films about nostalgia’, in the sense that they recast the nostalgic within an original film medium that goes beyond the nostalgic. In this respect, the post-nostalgic imagination in Mood and 2046 provides a vantage point to approach Wong’s ongoing dialogue with the local cultural imagination oftentimes couched in an internationalist cinematic form. The rich and tantalizing visual texture of the two films, moreover, serves as a prologue to the discussion of intertextuality and self-referentiality in the production of the local in the following chapters.
Nostalgia in 1990s Hong Kong films Prior to the handover, Hong Kong filmmakers sought to capture the elusive, fin-de-siècle qualities of the colonial city. The distinctive texture
24
Time and Memory
of the city as a fluid, mutant, dizzying postmodern space is the hallmark of Wong Kar-wai’s films, in which identities and subjectivities are in a constant flux. In Chungking Express/Chongqing senlin (1993) and Days of Being Wild/A fei zhengzhuan (1990), for instance, repeated references to specific dates and times heighten the tension between the characters’ desire to hold on to their memories and their subconscious fear/anxiety of remembering. As a ‘poet of time’ and Hong Kong auteur, Wong is also a ‘director-flaneur’ fascinated by the complex and problematic global space of Hong Kong.10 History, in Wong’s cinema, is situated within the fissure of remembering and forgetting, or exists in a void that annihilates all effort to locate time.11 Sometimes classified under the ‘second wave’ of the Hong Kong New Wave, Wong’s thematic preferences are traceable in the works of his immediate predecessors in the 1980s, in whose works new interpretations are given to the past/present, nation/city dynamics; for instance, Tsui Hark (the Once Upon a Time in China series), Ann Hui (Song of the Exile, 1990), and Yim Ho (Homecoming, 1984), and fellow ‘second wave’ director, Stanley Kwan (Rouge, 1987; Center Stage, 1992). During the 1990s, nostalgia films were a new fad in the mainstream market. While most are commercial productions capitalizing on the political uncertainty and mounting anxiety of their audiences, their creative and playful engagement with the past as a collective imaginary has achieved some unexpected results. Instead of a ‘faithful’ representation of the past, films such as 92 The Legendary La Rose Noire (Jeff Lau ChunWai, 1992); Rose, Rose, I Love You (Jeff Lau Chun-Wai, 1993); and He Ain’t Heavy, He’s My Father (Lee Chi Ngai and Peter Chan Ho-sun, 1995) seek to appropriate the imaginary landscape of popular Cantonese cinema of the 1960s and 1970s through parodies of well-known genres.12 In fact, the first two films cited above overtly play with subject matter, setting, and characterization to recall popular Cantonese films of the sixties, characterized by formulaic plotlines, exaggerated acting, onedimensional characters, and hyperbolic coincidences leading up to a happy denouement. In their original form, these earlier films had been immensely popular with local audiences by offering them momentary flights from reality at a time when the conditions of life were generally harsh, and entertainment was either lacking in variety or too expensive for the majority of the working class. The 1960s also saw the emergence of a new urban sensibility and increased openness to Western cultural influences. These early transitions to a modern way of life was reflected in the urban comedies and ‘youth musical films’ (gewu qingchun pian) during this period,13 from which a new generation
Post-nostalgia
25
of superstars emerged. These young super-idols (including the all-time favourites Josephine Siu Fong-fong, Pauline Chan Po-chu, and Sit Karyin) became household names, attracting hordes of fans wherever they went. Interestingly, rather than a reinterpretation or remaking of earlier films, it is the screen personality of the flesh-and-blood superstars that the later ‘adaptations’ are after. Instead of fictional characters, what confronts the audience are the familiar public personas of film stars from the bygone days, as the younger artists put greater emphasis on impersonating their predecessors than on making serious sense of their dramatic roles. Not surprisingly the adapted screenplay has this ‘metafictional’ dimension built into it at the conceptual level. Film scholar Luo Feng (Chan Siu-hong/Chen Xiaohong) has rightly argued that these contemporary imitations of earlier genres are intent more upon ridicule than paying tribute to an earlier generation.14 This kind of playful mimicking is unique to Hong Kong, for strictly speaking none of the above examples can be categorized as a remake of an earlier work. In fact, at least two (92’ The Legendary La Rose Noire and He Ain’t Heavy, He’s My Father) present a parade of trademark characters and dramatic elements from the entire repertoire of Cantonese comedy and melodrama. In this regard, the breaking down of differences between fictional characters and real-life actors/actresses is a phenomenon unique to the Hong Kong nostalgic wave not found elsewhere. (For example, instead of having fictional names, the characters are named after the older actors, and their dramatic appearances are carefully culled to create comic versions of the real.) Very often, the parodied versions of the actors/actresses themselves are the biggest selling point of these films, and their success is judged by how far the younger generation can ‘copy’ the ‘originals’. The nostalgic world as reconstructed in these films is doubly removed from the empirical, lived reality of the past: it is in fact a simulacrum of a previous simulacrum inhabited by imaginary and idealized characters, who nonetheless seemed to enjoy a continued existence outside the silver screen as flesh-and-blood actors. While these adaptations can be easily dismissed for being frivolous and opportunistic, their emergence and popularity (as judged by the profusion of imitative works in the market) in the last decade of the twentieth century bespeaks the relationship between nostalgia and the anxiety over loss of memory and identity during the years of political transition.15 These nostalgia films hence serve as a contrastive reference to the post-nostalgic in Wong’s films and those discussed in the following chapters. It must be pointed out, however, that the nostalgic and the post-nostalgic are not treated as pure period
26
Time and Memory
markers but different manifestations of, and reactions to, specific historical, social, and economic situations. Not only can they co-exist at any single point in time, but also dialectically in any single text. In this study, the post-nostalgic indicates a continuation, revision, and transformation of some of the more intriguing traits of earlier style and conventions, a phenomenon that invites further reflections on Hong Kong cinema, and the prospects and perils faced by local filmmakers trying to negotiate their future in the local, national, and global arenas.
Nostalgic text/desire, nostalgia as text/desire The above subheading refers to two possible interpretive frameworks for the 1960s trilogy. These two frameworks are present in various degrees in existing critical studies of In the Mood for Love, explicitly or implicitly. Whether one sees the film as a nostalgic text (hence a representational relation between text and desire), or attends to the textuality of nostalgia (a construct, or an effect of textual production), nostalgia is generally seen as a function of lost time, love, and memory, that is, nostalgia as both the ‘signified’ or manifest content and a vehicle for a certain (impossible) desire, whereas the latent potential of the film’s selfreflexive engagement with nostalgia as both text and desire, something that amounts to a self-parody, remains underdeveloped. For example, Peter Brunette’s study gives a detailed account of the films’ aesthetic features, especially the innovative use of music, lighting, editing, and framing devices that elevates Wong to the status of an auteur of world cinema. Brunette’s discussion of the motifs of time, memory, and the impossibility of love sees nostalgia and desire as a kind of universal human predicament that Wong has powerfully communicated in visual form. His observation is well validated in the detailed visual analysis, but what is of interest here is that this argument itself is also couched in a language that is no less nostalgic than the film in question: Individuals have always suffered, and they always will, and this is a secret that all of us know and could, ourselves, tell the hole in the wall. . . . The longing, the desire that will never be satisfied . . . But now that’s something bigger than any one of us.16 The ‘universality’ of nostalgia is given a more contextualized reading in Stephen Teo’s study, which is more grounded in the sociohistorical contexts of the 1960s films, revealing deeper cultural roots traceable to the
Post-nostalgia
27
director’s childhood experience as a young immigrant living in a community of fellow Shanghai émigrés. Teo traces the genealogy of Mood in both Western and Chinese cinema, noting particularly the film’s affiliation to early Hong Kong and Shanghai films of the 1940s, for example An All-Consuming Love/Bu liao qing (1947) and Song of a Songstress/Tianya genü (1948) starring the sing-song star Zhou Xuan; and Fei Mu’s masterpiece, Spring in a Small City/Xiaocheng zhi chun (1948), all classic melodramas of the period. The film’s Chinese title Huayang nianhua also is a direct reference to Zhou Xuan’s 1948 theme song, Huayangde nianhua.17 This cultural lineage is well-explored in Teo’s critical appreciation of the film’s ‘enthusiasm for nostalgia’, which infuses the film’s use of repetitive visual motifs, such as food and clothing, mise-en-scène and visual composition: the real theme behind all that food is nostalgia: the different types of food being eaten at different times and seasons mark not only time but a remembrance of time . . . what we have eaten . . . stir our fond memories of the past as much as do the exposed brickwork, the cobblestones, the mouldy walls, the posters disintegrating on concrete pillars that we walk past day after day. Herein lies the essence of repetition.18 Similar views on the film’s treatment of time past are noted in Chineselanguage reviews on Mood. Luo Feng, for example, detects a ‘fetishistic’ impulse in Wong’s ‘formalistic spatial design’, which in itself is a ‘collage’ of different period signs and symbolisms from the 1930s (Shanghai) and 1960s (Hong Kong), all in the service of projecting the director’s nostalgia for lost time.19 To many Chinese critics nostalgia communicates specific cultural and historical meanings; this is especially true as the objects that saturate the screen—images, costume, human bodies, and even sound bites—evoke memories of bygone eras. The 1960s, the films’ explicit time past, was a time of transition, and the year 1966 (where the film ends, for the time being) saw the beginning of the Cultural Revolution in China and subsequent anti-government riots in Hong Kong in 1967. The chaos and uncertainties led the colonial administration to implement a series of economic reforms instrumental to the city’s rapid modernization in the 1970s. (This portion of Hong Kong’s history is discussed in more detail in relation to Ann Hui’s Ordinary Heroes in Chapter 2.) More importantly, as recent scholarship on Hong Kong history indicates, the 1960s was the city’s formative stage, paving the way for the emergence of a
28
Time and Memory
local consciousness in subsequent decades.20 More than just a prologue to the 1970s, the 1960s saw the emergence of a ‘Hong Kong ethos’ that gradually replaced the more traditionalistic attachments (dependence) on linkages to China.21 Looking back from the vantage point of the present, historical writings on the 1960s give a picture quite different from that in Wong’s films. The above examples support a dynamic image of change and progress amidst conflicts and contradictions, of the fading away of certain elements of traditional Chinese culture in favour of a modern, Westernized lifestyle accompanied by a forwardlooking cosmopolitanism at a time when social and cultural ties with Mainland China gradually retreated to the background. The changing waves of fashion give further evidence to these transformations. The late 1960s saw the eclipse of the cheongsam/qipao and ‘saam fu’ (meaning shirt-and-pants, a traditional two-piece outfit) as the dominant code and its eventual replacement by Western-style designs. This new code of fashion is featured in the so-called ‘youth films’ from the decade, where the ‘young and rebellious’ are seen dressed in fancy T-shirts, shiny leather shoes, and tight-fitting pants as they frequent dance parties and nightclubs, while professional suits and skirts are showcased in popular melodramas and comedies featuring an emerging white-collar middle class. Filmic representations of this new urbanism abounded in the local cinema, and new stars were born to embody this Westernized, if not rebellious, outlook of this era.22 This new urban youth culture is also the backdrop of Days of Being Wild, the first of the 1960s trilogy, where Leslie Cheung plays the emblematic ‘Chinese James Dean’. Curiously, in Mood and 2046, costume design seems to have favoured a more conventional, though no less gorgeous, style, featuring an array of exquisite cheongsam tailor-made to replicate the ‘authentic’ Shanghai cut, just as Wong made repeated references to the films and material culture of pre1949 Shanghai. One plausible reason is that the films resemble Wong’s maturing vision, as the young rebels and their wasted passion give way to a more sober middle-age sensibility.23 Given the heavy investment in re-creating a sense of ‘pastness’ by mixed references to different time periods, arguably Wong’s films are not just about the 1960s , but a ‘collective memory’ of a certain imaginary past that Hong Kong, at the turn of the twenty-first century, has lost and dearly misses. This imaginary past is not to be taken negatively as being unreal or false consciousness, but positively as a constituent of the social imagination in reaction to a present situation that one cannot yet fully grasp; this past, as I argue below, becomes a parable for a future imagination whose real implications are less promising than the official promise of ‘one country two
Post-nostalgia
29
systems’ would have it. (More than coincidentally, Wong said on one occasion that 2046 is also a film about promises.24 ) As such, Wong’s films can also be read as (self-)critical comments on the cultural nostalgia of the 1990s. In Mood and 2046, objects, as period signs, provide a grid for the viewer to search for affective links to the past, or more precisely an idea of time past, since even those who were born too late to claim first-hand experience can participate in this mood-creation thanks to the recent nostalgic wave mentioned above. One can say that the film has succeeded in creating a nostalgic effect in the viewing process: by careful design the film offers a nostalgic mode of relating to the fictional universe. Hence, instead of seeing nostalgia as the intended or manifest content, I suggest that, in Mood and 2046, nostalgia is a self-reflexive construct that facilitates an analytical scrutiny of its own subject, a tactic very much in line with Wong’s deconstruction of cliché in his earlier films. Wong has characteristically mobilized intertextual resources of varied origins to obtain the ultimate signified, the nostalgic image/film. The films’ mixed references to the 1960s (Hong Kong) and 1930s/1940s (Shanghai), moreover, suggest that they are not mere products of nostalgia, for they also self-consciously refer to a pre-existing nostalgia from the standpoint of the present—the nostalgia for pre-1949 Shanghai among the Shanghai émigrés in 1960s Hong Kong (which came back as a referent in the cultural nostalgia in the 1990s). This nostalgia for Shanghai/China as the lost homeland is also noted in the Mandarin films of the period.25 Given the complex intertextuality of nostalgia referenced in the film, it can be argued that as a reworking of the romantic melodrama, the two films also meta-textually evoke the ethos of the local film culture of the 1960s, which itself was indebted to an earlier era of Chinese cinema. The film’s remembrance of time past, thus, reflects an imagined relation between artefact and history—and the affect associated with the artefact-as-history. In this regard, Wong Kar-wai is probably the preeminent master of the artefact as a filmic medium, for in Mood and 2046, animate and inanimate artefacts are invested with great emotional power and historical significance. Here also lies the clue to Wong’s self-reflexive engagement with nostalgia and the post-nostalgic imagination that this study seeks to unveil: within the fissures of colonial and national histories, and the temporal-spatial displacements that result, the local cinema has reinvented itself as form of visual history. Unlike the documentary as ‘visualized history’, this visual history is a dynamic register of codes, styles, and images that help to recall and critically reposition the historical in a popular and highly
30
Time and Memory
idiomatic visual medium. It is, I believe, one important contribution of the local cinema to the historical imagination of Hong Kong against the grain of a de-historicized nostalgia that always ends up elsewhere, for example a Shanghai that never really existed in 1960s Hong Kong, and the official (clichéd) story of an ‘economic miracle’, a linear progression from rags to riches culminating in the political homecoming of 1997 (c.f. Chapter 7).
In the Mood for Love: Role-play and nostalgic citation One way to understand the nostalgic image in Mood is to examine the kind of intertextuality at work and revisit the idea of role-play, a thematic element that inform many existing critical interpretations of the film. In brief, Wong Kar-wai’s play with role-play is made explicit through a complex doubling: Chow Mo Wan (Tony Leung Chiu-wai) and So Lai Chen (Maggie Cheung) move into adjacent rooming apartments on the same day. After a series of chance encounters in the crowded apartment where barely a few words and glances are exchanged, affection develops between Chow and So when the two begin to playact the affair between Chow’s wife and So’s husband. The conspicuous absence of Chow’s wife and So’s husband, except for a few brief back shots and off-screen lines, helps focalize and condense the dramatic tension in Chow and So and their make-believe playacting. Chow and So’s relationship is complicated by a simultaneous desire for each other and for being ‘not like’ their disloyal spouses. Instead of giving in to their desire, the undeclared lovers take refuge in a surrogate union: co-authoring a martial arts novel. Knowing that So will not divorce her husband, Chow leaves for Singapore to take up a journalistic job. The pain of unrequited love finally brings Chow to the Angkor Wat ruins in Cambodia, where he pours out his secret into a hole in a temple wall. Wong’s play with understatement and ambiguity through ellipsis and inconclusive scenes provokes a parallel desire in the viewer to figure out what ‘really happens’, that is, whether the two actually consummate their love, a scene obliquely suggested but never shown. The role-play, thus, motivates the narrative, while the doubling effect of playacting motivates the viewer to participate in constructing the ‘missing’ scene (‘Did the two consummate their love?’). This is a well-calculated suspense, but for a film in the traditional wenyi category Wong seems to have taken suspense beyond its normative limit, by not satisfying the curiosity and desire of the viewer for an ‘answer’ to the central enigma.
Post-nostalgia
31
Indeed, this suspense virtually spills over into the sequel, 2046, which will be discussed in the next section. The second level of role-play is intertextually grounded in the film’s self-reflexive citations of other texts. The most explicit use of intertextuality is the citations from literary works. Apart from the influence of Western literature on the structure of Wong’s films, Mood intermittently quotes passages from Hong Kong writer Liu Yichang’s fiction, Intersections (Duidao, from French ‘tête-bêche’, meaning ‘head to tail’) not only as explanatory notes but also as the conceptual core of the film itself: I think tête-bêche is not only a terminology in philately [referring to a pair of stamps in which one is printed upside down] or a literary technique—it is also a kind of film language, that is, the intersection of light and colours, sound and picture. Tête-bêche can even be the intersection of time.26 Two layers of role-play, textual and intertextual (one can say diegetic and non-diegetic), open up the possibility of reading the film itself as a citation constituted by a cacophony of objects, signs, and images suggestive of a bygone era. (Note that this is also a highly selective image of mixed temporal and spatial references. This tête-bêche motif also recalls the upside down image of a Hong Kong street scene in Happy Together, as a projection of the homesickness of Tony Leung’s character.) This perhaps explains why Wong’s films have always been characterized as being ‘unfinished’, like an ‘endless sprawl’ that leaves as much emptiness as it fills up screen space with details created by colour and light.27 Apart from this unfinishedness as a schematic design befitting the film’s postmodern appeal, the use of citation invites further reflection on the dialectical relation between nostalgia and the cinematic representation of nostalgia. The film’s self-referential intertextuality betrays an implicit metafictional, and meta-critical, use of nostalgia projected through multiple ‘intersections’ of times and images on-screen. Commenting on the use of everyday details in Mood, Rey Chow discerns a more subtle trait in these ‘reminders of a bygone era’, noting that ‘these ethnographic details constitute a kind of already-read text’ (italics added).28 In the film, the meticulous details that make up Wong’s replica of 1960s Hong Kong—the coiffures, fashion (the cheongsam, or qipao in Mandarin), the radio broadcast, newspapers, popular songs by Zhou Xuan and Nat King Cole, as well as public spaces such as the restaurant, newsroom, street corners, and taxi-cabs—fill up the visual field to the point of saturation. This profusion of objects from the past is
32
Time and Memory
partially the effect of cinematography: the extensive use of close-ups and medium close-ups, slow motion, tight framing, and silhouetted lighting and colour scheme amounts to a close-reading of the material texture and cultural fabric of the bygone era projected through the impressionistic lens of the camera. One obvious example is the sensational appeal of So’s body-hugging cheongsam in a mesmerizing variety of colours and floral patterns. Few who have seen the film would fail to notice this central icon. Technically, So’s cheongsam is the primary clue to temporal shifts between scenes that otherwise would look like mere repetitions. Commenting on the importance of fashion codes in Mood, Pam Cook argues that ‘[the cheongsam’s] power lies in the way it encapsulates past, present and future in a single image, resolving irreconcilable social tensions and contradictions in much the same way as myth’.29 This ‘mythical’ quality lies in Maggie’s dress code: her outfits are careful replicas of the 1930s Shanghai style created by a reputed tailor.30 The cheongsam, as a temporal sign, embodies Wong’s reflections on time, and change in time, for it functions both as a nostalgic object (a fashion code of a past era, something frozen in time but has come back to life in the retro fashion of the present), and change (a marker of temporal flow within the film narrative). The cheongsam, too, is as a metaphor for the city itself, a seductive body couched in colourful, mesmerizing fabric, blooming in evanescence. Arguing against the general perception of verisimilitude of Wong’s reinvented nostalgic world, Rey Chow emphasizes the ‘defamiliarizing’ and ‘aestheticizing’ effect of the quotidian in the film, noting in particular its emphatic use of slow motion, dramatized body movements and the daily ritual of cooking and eating; instead of being a realistic portrayal of a bygone era, the everyday in this film ‘points rather to a familiar cliché, namely, the fundamentally unfulfilled . . . nature of human desire, to which history . . . becomes subject and subordinate’.31 Chow’s reading places the film in the category of the 1990s nostalgia films, in which the past, as an image-commodity, is dehistoricized in its global circulation, so much so that the ‘most local details’ are transcoded into ‘vague generalities’.32 From the look of the film, it is quite true that the past thus reconstructed is not exactly a copy of the good old days, but a defamiliarized and aestheticized vision made up of already-read texts in various written, visual, and material forms. On the other hand, if we shift the focus from what is represented to the processes of representation, that is, the camerawork, editing, as well as sound and lighting, a different interpretation of the nostalgic image becomes possible. I would
Post-nostalgia
33
call it a technique of denaturalization through self-conscious aesthetic indulgence, which is explained in more detail below. Framing and close-ups Using medium and medium-long shots mainly for establishing mood and setting, the camera persistently pursues the characters’ subtle emotional changes and facial expressions in close-ups and medium closeups. The close-ups, too, capture the characters in isolation even though they are in the company of others. As we watch them move in and out of overcrowded apartments and offices or in conversation, the on-screen space is curiously imbalanced: on the one hand, the characters’ faces are prominently displayed, but on the other hand the camera deliberately positions them either on the far left or on the far right, leaving a large area of ‘empty space’ on-screen. This framing method is repeatedly used in rendering dialogues between two characters. Where two-shots are used for establishing a scene, the camera favours close-ups on a character facing the extreme left or right of the frame. As one party talks, the other remains off-frame. Instead of creating an illusion of continuity through two-shots and eyeline matches, visual imbalance interrupts the dialogue as a means of communication. This happens when Chow speaks to his colleague Ping in the newsroom early in the film. A variation on this visual trick is seen in the numerous conversations in the narrow passages inside the rooming apartments. Usually, one character is seen in profile facing an opened door, the wall and door frame occupying/blocking one half of the screen so that the interlocutor remains unseen. This kind of framing has a disorienting effect on the viewer, as the speakers on-screen are seen staring into the out-of-field or some visual obstacle, or facing a direction contrary to what is suggested by the establishing shot, a far cry from the customary shot/reverse shot composition. The unnaturalness effected by the use of framing, while emphasizing the impossibility of communication, unsettles the continuity of our vision by shattering the unity or wholeness of a scene. What we see, then, is largely an effect of the skewed perspective created by the camera’s manipulation of cinematic space, which in this film tends to yield not to our desire but to the camera’s own. In the film, close-ups and framing do not reveal as much as they obscure, but impose on us a denaturalized vision of parts, rather than wholes. The overall effect is a dramatization of the camera’s own subjectivity, and its power to select and frame what is perceived to be real, as an independent consciousness that glides through time and space.
34
Time and Memory
Camera movement The camera as a hidden persona is reinforced by downplaying point-ofview shots, which would have engendered alternative ‘viewing subjects’. As the viewer is given the sole privilege of sharing the camera’s perspective (sometimes from under a bed and behind street corners), he/she is interpellated into a voyeuristic position as the characters’ personal and intimate secrets are revealed. Within this denaturalized, voyeuristic vision, the reality of the past is subject to an aesthetic metamorphosis, so much so that the collection of nostalgic objects and characters, like the play-within-the-play of love and betrayal Chow and So try to re-enact, are de-realized into eye-pleasing artefacts. The film’s deliberate cropping out of Chow’s wife and So’s husband from the frame is a brilliant move to emphasize skewed emotional relations, as their ‘formidable absent presences’ remain in the consciousness of the main characters throughout the film.33 The close-ups and off-focus framing, ironically, conjures up a nostalgic world whose reality rests upon our desire to see what is not there. This play with presence/absence echoes the processes of ‘hallucination’ and ‘reverse hallucination’ Ackbar Abbas observes in Hong Kong’s visual culture in the 1980s and 1990s, a problem of vision and visibility that Wong’s films repeatedly address.34 If the nostalgic, as projected image, is a symptom of hallucination (seeing what is not there), then Wong’s meta-textual/meta-fictional approach to the hallucinated image here initiates a reverse hallucination, by distracting, if not forbidding, us from seeing (completely) what is there. Reverse hallucination is most vividly present in the oft-quoted scene where So Lai Chen walks up the spiral of stairs leading to Chow’s hotel room. The scene is one of the most sophisticated examples of ellipsis and slow/stop-motion editing in Wong’s films to dramatize a character’s complex psychological states and inner conflicts. A series of jump cuts shows So walking up the stairs from different angles, while the back-and-forth movement of her feet is edited in a dance-beat sequence, dramatizing not only her hesitation but also the yearning and desire behind the hesitation. The camera then cuts to a brief high-angle shot of Chow waiting anxiously in his darkened room. After these forgoing shots have prepared us for their eventual meeting, the camera cuts to their parting, swiftly concluding the scene with a back-tracking shot of So walking down towards the retreating camera followed by a freeze-frame. This shot sequence, probably the ‘signature’ of the whole film, is a prime example of how the film disrupts narrative progression and frustrates our desire to see more, to go behind the scene to find out what has really happened.35
Post-nostalgia
35
In Mood, as in 2046, camera movement turns space into sheer affect, a psychological rather than a physical entity. One good example is the use of panning. On several occasions, panning is used as a transitional device to create an emotional connection between Chow and So. Panning is also used in a scene when the two are seen working intimately on Chow’s martial arts fiction. The camera pans across the room to show multiple reflections of the characters in the mirror. Rendered without diegetic sound or dialogue, the background music serves as an emotional marker and dictates the basic rhythm of the action on-screen. In a different scene where Chow and So meet in a Hong Kong-style steak house, the camera shows the characters in profile, sitting face-to-face. Maintaining the same angle, the camera alternates between close-ups on Chow and the dishes on the table. A short pan to So breaks the monotony of the one-sided view of Chow, but in the process the camera ‘inadvertently’ sweeps past So and swiftly swings back to refocus on her, creating a slight blur as it moves back. A similar pattern of panning and close-up shots is used in an earlier meeting between the two in the same setting. This playful use of the short pan certainly has an improvisatory quality, as if the camera was participating in (eavesdropping?) the conversation like a third party, constantly trying to fix and adjust its focus as the dialogue unfolds. The persistent close-up shots, again, make it almost impossible to view the scene in its wholeness, replacing the objective distance of the two-shot and the shot/reverse shot with a visual intimacy bordering on the erotic. The animated use of the camera is complemented by a different technique, that of the static, empty shot that usually accompanies an emotionally charged scene. The finishing shot can rest on a street corner deserted by the lovers, a lonely street lamp against a rough stone wall, old adverts melting on concrete pillars, or the spiraling smoke of a cigarette dancing to the rhythm of the background music. It is as if the camera is in no hurry to follow the characters or further develop a scene (by a transition, for example); rather, by indulging in the lingering melancholy of a deserted scene it submerges the viewer in its own reverie, endowing the empty shot with a nostalgic aura more for its own aesthetic pleasure than for narrative continuity. For a director known for his postmodernist style, Wong Kar-wai’s treatment of the nostalgic image in this film begs the question of historicity, that is, the degree to which the film is about a past era, or whether it is a collage of images, signs, and objects that constitute our imagination of the past. Nostalgia as text/desire/intertext also invites reflections on what critical positions, if any, are made possible. Here it is important to
36
Time and Memory
look beyond Wong’s overtly nostalgia films to gauge the director’s more complex mediation of the nostalgic. Both Ackbar Abbas and Stephen Teo have pointed out Wong’s close connection to Hong Kong’s genre films, noting that almost his entire corpus is devoted to the reworking of genre, and in each case the genre concerned is given fresh and thought-provoking interpretations.36 This aesthetic inclination is akin to some of his Western counterparts whose reworking of genre ‘does not demythify the original [but] utilize original forms for critical oppositions or displacements’.37 The fact that the nostalgic image is not completely demythified in Wong’s films, hence retaining the aura of the coded image, endows the film text with a double register; the latent tension between two possible readings, I believe, is what makes his films an intriguing yet pleasurable adventure. If we read it as a nostalgia film, Mood is no doubt a product of the director’s ‘mood of love’ for Hong Kong in the 1960s, a period of great emotional import to Wong as a Shanghai immigrant-turned-Hong Kong director. Yet, the authenticity of the represented past is fractured by the camera’s indulgence in its own aesthetic pleasure. The film thus effects another doubling: it tenderly evokes the bygone era in all its nostalgic glamour in order to repossess a certain mood of the past, that is, nostalgia as the signified or manifest content; at the same time, the pastas-artefact is anchored, and slowly dissolved, in a host of images and texts, creating a language through which an imaginative engagement with history is articulated. Nostalgia, as an image, is held not exactly in awe but in tension with its own inauthenticity, as the film enters into a dialogue with its own nostalgia. Seen in this light, Wong’s revisitation of the 1960s differs from most other nostalgia films from the late 1990s in at least one important way: the assemblage of period objects and personas in Wong’s film aims not at a parody of the originals for comic relief or a sentimental return to the past; rather, it creates a stylized image as a specimen of a cultural nostalgia that is intimately personal and collectively shared at the same time. The specimen, it follows, is subject to the camera’s scrutiny. The film spectator’s imagination of the 1960s, activated by the profusion of past signs, inevitably becomes part of the scrutinized (inter)text.
2046: Parallel time-spaces As a sequel to Mood, 2046 created its own legend even before it was first screened at the Venice International Film Festival. Not only did Wong miss the deadline for submission but when the film was premiered it was
Post-nostalgia
37
still a ‘work in progress’.38 During production, one of the main characters, Japan’s no. 1 teen idol Takuya Kimura, complained about Wong’s improvisational working style and threatened to walk out. Granted that the two films were made almost at the same time, the over-drawn production schedule put exorbitant demands on the lead actors, especially Tony Leung, as he was asked to play ‘the same man in a different way’. The difficulty of rendering two ‘similar yet different’ interpretations of the same character at the same time is complicated by the playacting in Mood, where Chow tries to imitate So’s husband. Be it a coincidence or not, the anachronism in the film’s production echoes the thematic of temporal disjunction in the narrative, which is then played out in the mise-en-abyme structure of story-telling—the film’s main narrative is punctuated by scenes from Chow Mo Wan’s science fiction, 2046 (and its sequel 2047), that serve as a projection (if not confession) of Chow’s repressed memory and emotions. As the last instalment of Wong’s 1960s trilogy, 2046 has been read as a meta-criticism of Wong’s corpus, with frequent allusions to the earlier films from As Tears Go By, Days of Being Wild to Ashes of Time and In the Mood for Love.39 It is also Wong’s most overtly political film today, with the film’s title literally referring to another ‘deadline’ for Hong Kong, the last year of the first 50 years of Chinese rule, during which Hong Kong’s status quo will remain unchanged (wushinian bubian, or literally ‘no change for fifty years’), a promise made by the late Chinese leader Deng Xiaoping and subsequently stipulated in the 1984 Sino-British Joint Declaration that sealed the political fate of the ex-colony. Thus the film’s symbolic reference to the past is twofold: it is a re-examination of the 1960s and a ‘time odyssey . . . looking at the future from the vantage point of the 1960s’.40 As a sequel to Mood, 2046 nonetheless has its own (and very different) structure of meaning: the 1960s is used as a vantage point to imagine a distant future that only obtained historical significance two decades later, when the Sino-British negotiations over Hong Kong’s future began in the early 1980s. On the other hand, the narrating present, 1999–2004 (when the film was made), makes its oblique presence felt through the allusive double-reference to the 50-year promise, 2046 (the title of the film and Chow Mo Wan’s novel). If nostalgia in Mood is understood as a disguise for the critique of the nostalgic embedded in the complex fabric of inter-texts, in 2046 nostalgia takes the form of a temporal implosion, by which I mean the past, as an obsession or fetish, is turned into a futuristic myth in the fantasy world of Chow Mo Wan’s serialized science fiction, in which a lone traveller (Kimura) falls in love with an android (Faye Wong) on an inter-galactic train on
38
Time and Memory
his way back from ‘2046’, a place where one can recover lost memories, and where no one else before has ever returned. Indeed, the overlapping meanings of the number 2046 mirror the complexity of the film’s narrative structure and use of nostalgia. While intertextual references and meta-criticism constitute a ‘summation’ of the director’s ‘lyrical melancholia’ and the ‘sum and substance’ of his previous feature films to date,41 the political allegory boldly uncovers a collective nostalgia for Hong Kong’s ‘pre-postcolonial’ history that was given an extended lease on life for another 50 years, or what Wong calls ‘changeless time’.42 Time, it seems, takes on a much more explicit and historically and politically grounded signification in this film than Wong’s previous films. It seems as if Wong, at this point of his own cinematic journey through time, has reached a synthesis of the two sides of his artistic persona: the philosophical aesthete touched by the tragic human condition, and the social and historical subject trying to grapple with the pains and contradictions of his time. In the film, Chow Mo Wan, still engrossed in past regrets, also wants to take refuge in changeless time. In order to hide his pain he has turned himself into a different person, from the reticent and shy husband in Mood to a dandy and womanizer in late 1960s Hong Kong. We are told that in Singapore he has had another lover, Su Lizhen (Gong Li), the Mandarin equivalent of So Lai Chen, a charismatic professional gambler who helped him to win back the money for his return ticket to Hong Kong. Knowing that Chow was still in love with the other So Lai Chen, she rejected his offer to ‘leave with him’ (a line repeated in Chow’s fiction). Returning to Hong Kong, Chow begins a non-committal relationship with a nightclub hostess, Bai Ling (Zhang Ziyi), his neighbour and occupant of room 2046, the same number as the hotel room where Chow and So once spent their most intimate time together in Mood. Disillusioned by Chow’s refusal to commit, Bai Ling later leaves Hong Kong for a job in Singapore (repeating Chow’s movement in Mood). Meanwhile, Chow finds himself intrigued by another woman, Jingwen (played by Faye Wong/Wang Jingwen), but she is in love with a Japanese boyfriend Tak (also played by Kimura) despite her father’s objection. As if cursed by fate, Chow begins another platonic relationship, this time with Jingwen, who also becomes his writing buddy like So before. In 2046, these complicated romances are the raw material of Chow’s science fiction, in which he projects his own frustration and unfulfilled desire into Kimura’s lone traveller character and the female androids played by none other than Faye Wang, Carina Lau (whose brief appearance as Chow’s old acquaintance in the opening scenes subtly recalls
Post-nostalgia
39
her role in Days of Being Wild), and for one split-second shot Maggie Cheung. The film narrative progresses along intercutting scenes of Chow’s love affairs and his ongoing sci-fi, ‘2046’. The juxtaposition of retro late 1960s Hong Kong with futuristic sci-fi inserts not only plays up the artificiality of both, but also creates a double referencing of the two fictional universes. Symbolically, Chow’s fiction posits the future as a repository of memories to be reclaimed, hence ‘changeless time’ as a resistance to the transience of love and human relationships in the present. However, given the multiplicity of meaning attached to the futuristic time-space ‘2046’, it would be an oversimplification to read Chow’s attempt to project his present stasis into the future as an assertion of the power of the imagination to overcome life’s tragic losses; nor is it simply Chow’s (and vicariously the director’s) poetic lament of the inevitability of such losses. If the over-determined signifier ‘2046’ is the result of an intensely personal nostalgia, it also alludes to a collective memory of Hong Kong’s past that may not correspond to the actual historical circumstances and experiences of the Hong Kong people, who never have been given a say as to what they would like to see unchanged, or changed, for the better. In a different context, Vera Dika qualifies the represented past in a 1970s nostalgia film, American Graffiti, as ‘a simulacral image, referring to a lost time, to past images, and to its own status as a commodity sign’. What’s more, comments Dika, ‘[t]hrough this particular re-creation of the past, and the undeniable pleasure of reexperiencing it, [the film] subtly confronts a generation with its moment in history’.43 Dika’s observation also illuminates the kind of nostalgia evoked in 2046. If Chow Mo Wan’s fictional 2046 is a symptom of a present stasis, Hong Kong’s 2046 is not necessarily a blessing of any given sort. Although the 1984 Joint Declaration stipulates ‘Hong Kong’s previous capitalist system and life-style shall remain unchanged for 50 years’, the neutralizing vocabulary used in the official document, such as ‘inhabitants’ and ‘residents’ instead of ‘people’ and ‘citizens’, has raised critical concerns. On the ambiguity of the term ‘life-style’, Matthew Turner writes,
What is the Hong Kong life-style? . . . does life-style suggest . . . the subjective texture of identity? . . . Or is life-style like fashion, changing from moment to moment? Since no society could ‘remain unchanged for fifty years,’ how will social change be legitimized? At the heart of the agreements on Hong Kong’s future lies a slippery neologism which may be interpreted to mean almost anything.44
40
Time and Memory
In a fantastic twist, Wong’s film poses a related question in kindred spirit: Every passenger who goes to 2046 has the same intention. They want to recapture lost memories because nothing ever changes in 2046. Nobody knows if that’s true because nobody’s ever come back. This line by Chow Mo Wan’s fictional narrator is a direct comment on China’s promise to the Hong Kong ‘inhabitants’. To the extent that ‘recovering lost memories in the future’ is a fiction, 2046 alludes to a political myth that legitimizes a condition of stasis (wushinian bubian). This, I believe, is the fiction/myth that the film’s critical engagement with nostalgia seeks to demystify, displace, and resist by reworking familiar referential frameworks through which conventional meanings are destabilized and transformed into something else. In Mood, as we have seen, what Rey Chow calls ‘ethnological reminders’ are replicas of historical artefacts; in 2046, two or more referential frameworks—the textual and the extra-textual, or the fictional and the meta-fictional—are mobilized to create an internal montage that ‘rupture[s] an established coded system, the sign itself’.45 This in part is achieved by the multiple register embedded in the number 2046 (a film, a novel, a place, a room number, and a time in future). This density of meaning is complemented by another aesthetic indulgence, the resounding musical notes from Bellini’s opera, Norma, which adds allegorical weight to Shigeru Umebayashi’s heart-rending original score. Amy Taubin notes that the opera tells the tale of a high princess who is ‘torn between her loyalty to her people and her love for a leader of the occupying Roman army’, which ‘parallels the political tensions between Hong Kong and China’.46 This is not to say that 2046 is a political film; rather, politics is a catalyst for deeper reflections on personal and collective destiny. The internal montage of parallel times and parallel universes functions like a distorted mirror held up to the smooth surface of reality: Chow Mo Wan’s affected tranquility and nonchalance, the evasiveness and detachment of the film’s narrating/viewing present, and a mythical future stasis. Ironically, that future, like the canned pineapples in Chungking Express, has an expiry date, rendering what may happen afterwards even less promising. Perhaps this is why Chow’s fiction necessitates a sequel, ‘2047’ (Chow’s room number), in which Kimura’s lone traveller and Faye Wang’s android are able to find short-lived comfort in a passionate embrace before the android’s fateful decline. This is another instance of ‘love at last sight’ similar to
Post-nostalgia
41
the fin-de-siècle condition in the pre-handover years. In 2046, time is experienced in a loop: past, present, and future are entwined and convoluted in their respective stasis, as history threatens to repeat itself, a repetition (Wong’s favourite visual and narrative schematic) that ironically reminds us of the danger of ‘changeless time’. Arguably, the film’s treatment of nostalgia is diametrically opposed to that in Mood: the earlier film is presented as a self-conscious artefact to create a nostalgic effect in the audience, arousing both critical and uncritical pleasure at the same time. The memory at stake belongs virtually to no one— not the characters, and not exactly the viewers, but an assemblage and disassemblage of past codes and style that exposes the artificiality, and vulnerability, of nostalgia. 2046, on the other hand, takes on the ‘artificial memory’ of Mood to create a double narrative—the futuristic past in Chow’s fiction vis-à-vis the futuristic present in Wong’s film. As a sequel to Mood, 2046 is a more complex film in its treatment of time: by taking the audience on a virtual journey into a paradoxical ‘futurepast’ as a distorted mirror of ‘changeless time’, it is both a summation of Wong’s cinematic career and an exhaustion of the very nostalgia that saturates the filmic universe and the viewing present. This exhaustion is subtly expressed in the delayed reaction suffered by the androids when the train passes the symbolic zones ‘1224/1225’ (i.e. Christmas Eve and Christmas Day). According to the minder on the train, in time androids will lose their ability to give instant emotional responses, a sign of physical decay. Delayed emotions, it seems, concludes our journey into the future-past of 2046, for it sums up the film’s examination of nostalgia as a time-travel to revisit the past with an emotional debt long overdue, something that may no longer be meaningful once its historical moment is over. (‘Love is a matter of timing. It doesn’t work if it is too early or too late’, says Chow.) If nostalgia is less about the past than a present lack, the future-past of 2046 can be read as a parable: Chow Mo Wan’s 1960s brings the viewers into direct confrontation with their own historical moment; it seeks to confront them with their own (affected) complacency with the present by fracturing/disturbing the collective nostalgia for time past and the equally fictive (mythical?) ‘history of the future’, that is, a 50-year changeless time.
Conclusion: Points of departure My reading of Wong Kar-wai’s two recent nostalgia films has sought to establish several vantage points to approach the post-nostalgic imagination in Hong Kong cinema, which now has entered the zone of
42
Time and Memory
changeless time. First, the cultural nostalgia of the 1990s has undergone subtle transformations in the cinematic reworking of old styles and codes; as a subject of representation, nostalgia carries meaning beyond its manifest content and meaning, reflecting a meta-textual/metacritical consciousness in the visual language and film narrative. Second, the post-nostalgic has a tendency towards intertextuality, that is, a selfreflexive use of pre-existing texts and conventions, both as a tribute to the local cultural tradition and as a means to capture the elusiveness of the local. Third, the post-nostalgic is inherently border-crossing in nature; it is neither a convention nor a style, but a mode of cinematic imagination running through both arthouse and commercial films. Finally, as the following chapters will show, genre and genre conventions have shaped the ‘cinematic recovery of lost memories’47 in Hong Kong films—in the conscious or subconscious drive to retain and reconstruct personal and collective memories by reworking pre-existing visual codes and images, and by capturing and transforming the changing and disappearing urban spaces. Wong’s films exemplify the way in which the past as a nostalgic image/text is being reinscribed in a discourse of the present and the future. If embedded in the post-nostalgic is the temptation to look back at what ‘would have been’, the ‘post’ here implies a desire to translate what is lost into a continued questioning of what is and what will become. As we shall see, across different genres and subject matter, Hong Kong films exhibit a tendency to use past codes and styles to reconstruct cinematic memories in refreshingly and sometimes problematically new ways. These films and their creators chart a broad spectrum of the local film industry and differ widely in style and purpose, but it is precisely their differences that speak volumes about what they have in common.
2 Cinematic Remembrances: Ordinary Heroes and Little Cheung
The 1990s saw the end of colonial rule in Hong Kong and the city’s accelerated development into a ‘global city’, where Western and Chinese capital vied for both profit and prestige in the run-up to 1997. This prospect and the accompanying social and political misgivings provided a frame of reference and subject matter for some filmmakers to reflect on issues of local history and identity. As I have pointed out in the ‘Introduction’, the search for a local identity has largely remained an unfinished project. In the post-1997 milieu, ‘Hong Kong identity’ is still debated in film criticism and critical writings on Hong Kong as an indicator of the territory’s, and the film industry’s, ongoing negotiation with China and the socioeconomic transformations brought on by globalization.1 The complexity of local identity articulation in Hong Kong is effectively summed up in Michelle Tsung-yi Huang’s study on the global city with reference to Fruit Chan’s Little Cheung (1999): unlike most other post-colonial cultures, the lack of a ‘native place’ (xiangtu) as a stronghold for resistance has left the old cityspace being the only possible ‘native place archetype’, which also necessitates a remapping of ‘native place’ on to the larger geopolitics of global space.2 In this connection, recent theorizations of contemporary identity politics have shed light on the constructed nature of all identities, and Judith Butler’s idea of ‘performativity’ has further put gender and other identity norms into question.3 Inasmuch as identity has always been a slippery term whose meaning is always subject to negotiation, in this digital age it is increasingly a mass-mediated conglomerate of signs and images disseminated through transnational communications networks. It is beyond the scope of this study to offer an analysis of how digital media nowadays have created, shaped, and commodified various types of identities, and whether globalization has (not) undermined more localized forms 43
44
Time and Memory
of identity politics in historically underprivileged sites such as former colonized and Third World societies. As far as Hong Kong and its cinema are concerned, this over-determined term today lies not in whether a ‘Hong Kong identity’ has existed, disappeared, or will come into being by discursive consensus, but in a new problematic of the local in the cultural imagination, not in the sense of a positivistic self-assertion as in localism, but of a constructivistic, non-essentializing use of images as a form of historical and cultural critique. This problematic of the local is also a critical response to the fin-de-siècle scenario triggered by the ‘1997 issue’ and the crisis of disappearance, and the concomitant quest for cultural identity as a resistance to disappearance (by ‘re-colonization’?) that underlies the nostalgic imagination in Hong Kong cinema and cultural productions since the mid-1980s. Rather than reiterating what the local is by revisiting familiar formulations of instability, hybridity, and marginality, it emphasizes the polyvalence of the term, that is, how different meanings of the local are generated in various instances when it is invoked, and what implications for the cultural imagination will result from these contending visions and narratives of the local. All this, of course, cannot be taken for granted, since the history of Hong Kong cinema is itself a product of conflicting social and cultural hegemonies under which the local is always deprived of specificity. But the handover endowed the recent portion of a century-old historical tale with a special flavour mixed with nostalgia, political anxiety, and a disturbing sense of impermanence, all attributable to an apocalyptic apprehension of the end, a fin-de-siècle sentiment that fueled the imagination of the local, or what it means to be local. As 1997 approached, some filmmakers began to turn their attention to the marginal communities and alternative spaces of the city to capture the rhythm and texture of city life undergoing major social and economic transformations, for example Derek Yee Tung-sing’s C’est la vie mon chéri/Xin bu liao qing (1992) and Ann Hui’s Summer Snow/Nüren sishi (1994).4 The portrayal of everyday life in these movies goes beyond social commentary, a trait inherited from television docu-drama in the 1970s, to focus on issues of subjectivity and historical agency. If, in Benedict Anderson’s often-quoted words, the nation is an imagined community, then identity, too, is an act of the imagination, which by extension is an act of reckoning with its elusiveness, if not ambivalence when engrossed in national and party politics. The versatilities brought on by globalization have further unsettled old forms of national imagination: now the nation is no longer contained within geographical boundaries, but is dispersed into pockets of diasporic localities with overlapping and
Cinematic Remembrances
45
contending interests, affiliations, memories, ideological orientations, and even lifestyles and customs that are not necessarily regulated by well-defined national traditions.5 Hong Kong and its cinema present a case of overlapping and contending national, (post-)colonial, and transnational interests and practices within a highly compact social space. Approaching the issue of identity in terms of the problematic of the local, I intend to explore through the works of Ann Hui (Ordinary Heroes/Qian yan wan yu, 1999) and Fruit Chan (Little Cheung/Xilu Xiang, 1999) internally dispersed and variegated localities as embodiments of a new historical subjectivity rooted not in the meta-narratives of nation and decolonization, but in the social and cultural imaginations of the almost ‘forgotten’. In particular, I look at how filmic representations of space can generate such imaginations as they reflect on ‘disappearance’ as both a cultural symptom and a cultural practice; on what remains possible to the imagination of the future when nostalgia is passé; and what comes after anxiety when loss has become cliché. A decade down the road, the Hong Kong way of life has changed in ways that seem to concur with pre-handover apprehensions of ‘a future undoing of its past achievement’;6 yet, this changed reality lacks the aura of distance (in time and space) and is devoid of the lure of the by now over-sensitized cultural nostalgia of previous years, precisely because the anticipated future has crossed the temporal buffer zone. Hong Kong cinema, like the city itself, can no longer claim the privileged future anterior point of view. This change also necessitates a reassessment of the aftermath of this allegorical future: if pre-handover nostalgia refers not to history but the disappearance of the present as/into future-history, the post-nostalgic has the advantage of a critical hindsight accompanied by a self-reflexive consciousness. This critical hindsight can be located in Hong Kong’s social realist cinema, a tradition that can be traced back to early Chinese cinema since the early twentieth century. In Hong Kong, social realist films with strong moral and political messages lost their popular appeal during the early 1970s to lighter and more upbeat entertainment such as kung fu, action, and urban comedy. However, a new stream of social realist films sprang up in the late 1970s, culminating in the Hong Kong New Wave cinema in the 1980s. It is now a well-known fact that the New Wave marked the beginning of Hong Kong’s arthouse cinema, and their artistic explorations into local subject matter with contemporary relevance are powerful articulations of a local subjectivity unprecedented in the history of Hong Kong cinema at that time. The intellectual outlook of New Wave films anticipated the ‘second wave’ directors such as Wong Kar-wai and
46
Time and Memory
Stanley Kwan.7 In Ordinary Heroes and Little Cheung, this social realist perspective is at the service of the filmmaker’s desire to re-examine the local in the absence of the future anterior. As we shall see, the filmmakers’ identification with the local is complicated by their identification of the local as a specific social group whose existence is threatened by vested political and social interests. In these films, the construction of historical and social space as a form of collective memory and resistance to disappearance reflects this complex relationship between the local as subject and the local as a subject of representation. If the critique of the nostalgic in Wong Kar-wai’s films (Chapter 1) takes the form of a critique of the image as cultural self-indulgence, in Ordinary Heroes and Little Cheung this critique is articulated through their dissonance with the official image of Hong Kong and the concomitant ‘economic miracle’ narrative. In the two films, a variety of historical ‘actors’, real or fictional, form the basis of a counter-discourse vis-à-vis official and elitist representations pre- and post-handover.
Ghosts of the past: Nostalgia and the old city revisited In a study on local history writing in Hong Kong before and after the ‘1997 divide’, Jeremy E. Taylor identifies a cluster of texts that he calls ‘topographical histories’, a mixed genre of anecdotal essays, gazetteerlike narratives, photograph albums, and so on, that ‘take their premise locality and topography’ in depicting the city’s history.8 Taylor’s reading of these texts helps unravel an alternative dimension of narrativizing the city’s past that goes against the discourse of the nation which tends to erase all traits of historical, cultural, and ideological difference in characterizing the ex-British colony as an essentially Chinese city. More specifically, topographical writing ‘focuses primarily on the city’s built environment and streets for its expression’ and has indirectly revealed the unique relation between urban geography and the city’s identity.9 These ‘other’ historical narratives are not rigorous historical scholarship, but an integrated form of personal memoir, fiction, and gazetteer writing. The old streetscape that these narratives seek to preserve is very often heavily invested in nostalgia that points directly towards the ‘non-national’ past of the city.10 This nostalgic reconstruction of local histories through subjective re-visitation of old streetscapes underscores a general anxiety over the voraciousness of a national narrative that threatens to submerge all local memories into its homogenizing discourse of race (Chineseness) and unity. It is therefore no coincidence that in other realms of social life, mini-discourses have sprung up before
Cinematic Remembrances
47
and after 1997, the year of Hong Kong’s ‘return’ to China, to negotiate, in different forms and perspectives, a local sense of identity that befits the city’s unique historical experience. The cityspace as a repository of local articulations and contestations of identities has inspired new readings of Hong Kong’s urban landscape. Ackbar Abbas’ theorization of Hong Kong’s colonial space identifies three key features of the city’s architecture, namely, a capacity for foreign influence, constant rebuilding, and hyperdensity. With the exception of a few ‘architectural showpieces’, however, ‘the presentday form of the urban vernacular presents us with a visual anonymity that spreads to most parts of the city and deprives it of architectural character. Yet . . . the Anonymous may be the most articulate and significant of all.’11 Michelle Huang traces the relation between the forces of globalization and cinematic representations of the urban space as a site of cultural critique and resistance.12 Cultural historians, on the other hand, have discovered how historical landmarks were connected to the power dynamics between the colonial administration and local elites since the early days of British rule.13 These and other writings reveal a much more complex historical situation embodied in the lived environment of Hong Kong, and thus problematize any straight-forward characterizations in popular media images and official representations. The architectural space in Little Cheung and Ordinary Heroes displaces two official images of the city: (1) the tourism-board image of ‘the city of lights’, the oriental Manhattan, or ‘Asia’s world city’, and (2) the complementary postcard image of ‘old Hong Kong’, a sanitized and no less exoticized construct to promote tourism. As part of the government’s self-promotion campaign, these two diametrically opposed images conjure up an ultra-modern city with a cultural heritage and ‘trademark’ culled in Orientalist language, but history seems to be lost in a vacuum: between the Oriental Manhattan in the twenty-first century and the nostalgic recollections of rickshaws and fishing boats is a void, a silence that betrays the formulaic and simplistic grand narrative of Hong Kong history as an economic ‘miracle’, a rags to riches transformation from a fishing village to a world-class city.14 The city is sketched in quite different strokes in Ordinary Heroes and Little Cheung: ultramodern architecture and supermalls give way to congested boat homes and matchbox-like lower class neighbourhoods as an organic part of social and cultural memory threatened by material and symbolic erasure. The symbiotic relationship between the city and its inhabitants, especially the marginalized and downtrodden, revises the narratives of colonial modernity and national reunification by reinscribing these disappearing
48
Time and Memory
figures as historical subjects. The reconstruction of the cityscape, which effectively brings in contradictory historical times and spaces, constitutes a visual mode of remembering that informs the vision of the present.
Little Cheung: City narrative at the ground level Little Cheung is the second instalment of Fruit Chan’s ‘Hong Kong Trilogy’ together with Made in Hong Kong/Xianggang zhizao (1997) and The Longest Summer/Qunian yianhua tebie duo (1998). Released in three consecutive years starting from 1997, these films capture the complex texture of Hong Kong’s social margins, a lower class life world of the disenfranchised that is far from homogenous. Made in Hong Kong is a sad tale of three lower class youths driven to tragic ends by the prejudices and negligence of society, while The Longest Summer traces the footsteps of ex-Hong Kong British troops struggling for a living after their discharge from the colonial service. Compared to the bleakness and cynicism of Made in Hong Kong and Longest Summer, Little Cheung presents a more communal and down-to-earth picture of life in a lower class neighbourhood. Little Cheung is the child protagonist, the son of the proprietor of a Hong Kong-style deli commonly known as caa caan teng (cha can ting in Mandarin) in Portland Street, Mongkok, one of the busiest commercial districts dotted with old and new shopping malls, cinemas, hawkers, sundry stores, eateries, nightclubs, and brothels. Mingling among the dilapidated vernacular buildings and old shop fronts are the homes of shop owners and workers in the same area. Together they constitute what can be conveniently called the ‘street community’ or ‘street habitat’ that characterizes the livelihood of a significant proportion of ordinary Hong Kong people. In the film, the street community has developed its own hierarchy of power and unofficial codes of practice that have been upheld by the inhabitants for generations. As a long-time resident in the neighbourhood, Cheung has made friends with a large number of people as a part-time delivery boy and earns precious little from his customers. Little Cheung’s street world presents the local space from the perspective of an insider. From the very beginning, the film assaults the viewer’s senses with densely packed scenes of the Portland Street market, using Cheung’s voice-over to introduce us to a bread-and-butter, hustle-bustle world: ‘Money is everybody’s dream’, Cheung informs us in the opening scene, fully embracing this characteristic Hong Kong ethos. Cheung occupies a marginal position vis-à-vis the adults and other figures of
Cinematic Remembrances
49
authority (his father, the street’s elders, and the hooligans), but his marginality also enables him to play a border-crossing role: among his good friends (and fans) are the subalterns of the street community, for example prostitutes, street hawkers, ethnic minority workers, and illegal immigrants. Watching their daily interactions, the audience is guided by this ‘childish’ perspective into the inner landscape of the city. It is neither Oriental Manhattan nor a government-sponsored ‘heritage walk’. Juxtaposing the old neighbourhood with occasional shots of the better-known metropolitan Hong Kong, the subtle demarcation of social and cultural boundaries becomes apparent. The ultra-modernity of the metropolitan global space, as Michelle Huang has remarked, is out of reach for the ordinary folks, among whom are legal and illegal migrant workers on underpaying jobs, a far cry from the professional managerial staff of multinational corporations primarily for whom this global ‘monumental’ space has been created.15 These boundaries are somehow reproduced within the street community, where migrant workers and illegal immigrants are never truly integrated into world of the locals. As the narrative proceeds, a more complex and heterogeneous world is revealed. The street as a local (unofficial) geographical and social unit has its own power structure and social hierarchy similar to that of the traditional village community. But it is never static: change is registered in the comings and goings of different ethnic and migrant groups (Filipinos, Southeast Asians, and Mainland Chinese); while the succession of generations poses a steady threat to the delicate power balance of the community and its time-honoured communal bonding among the inhabitants. Consistent with Fruit Chan’s preoccupation with the urban locale, Little Cheung presents a familiar yet often neglected vista of the city. The street world itself emits a distinctive local flavour not because of its Chineseness, but an inchoate mix of social classes and ethnic groups. Little Cheung, being the young master of his father’s restaurant, has the privilege of being a veteran member of the established street community. According to this community’s miniature rule of sovereignty, the current leader is Uncle Kin, an elderly restaurant owner who used to have a crush on Cheung’s Grandmother and still cares for her. This gives Cheung and his father some extra protection from extortion and bullying by the hooligans led by Kin’s eldest son. Little Cheung’s attachment to Ami, the Filipino maid, is an indirect comment on the typical Hong Kong nuclear family, where parents usually work full time, leaving the care of their children to domestic helpers hired from the Philippines or Indonesia. In an ironic twist of the mother–child relationship, the
50
Time and Memory
film has Little Cheung roaming the streets to look for Ami, and finally reunites with her in the middle of a huge Filipino religious gathering in Central, a Sunday morning phenomenon quite uniquely Hong Kong. Within its compact locale, the film throws in a high density of signs and images to allude to the sociopolitical context prior to the 1997 handover, intercutting scenes of everyday commotions with news footage of the Sino-British negotiations, real-life celebrity gossip, and the increasing public concern over the influx of illegal Chinese immigrants. The larger historical frame, however, is not meaningful to the street community as if granted. In the film, the relevance and significance of this larger frame of reference is seen and felt through the reveries of Cheung’s Grandmother and Cheung’s friendship with Fan, a nine-year-old illegal immigrant from Mainland China. The film’s main action follows Cheung’s daily delivery itineraries, his friendship with Fan, and his failed attempts to reunite with the older brother he has never seen. His Grandmother’s recollections serve as a link between past and present until her death, which coincides with the death of a real-life celebrity, the ‘king of charity and Cantonese opera’ San Ma Sizang/Xin Ma Shizeng (also known as Tang Wing-cheung or Brother Cheung), and Hong Kong’s reunification with China. The street world in Little Cheung is created as a mode of remembering that also locates the act of remembering in the present. Like Grandmother, it is a repertoire of past memories kept alive by the everyday activities of shop owners, hawkers, labourers, local bullies, pimps, and prostitutes. This compact street world is complete with details as the camera follows Cheung on his daily errands through the back lanes and alleyways of Mongkok. Probably due to his early training with the Hong Kong New Wave,16 Fruit Chan’s films often contain a good facility for social criticism. In Little Cheung, the quest for social meaning is realized in the integration of character and setting. Throughout the film, characters are frequently framed in long and medium shots against matchbox-like vernacular buildings, hawker stalls, and labyrinthine back alleys, while the modern skyline and architecture in the same area are carefully avoided except in a few well-planned shots. Indeed, the disappearing architectural spaces of the old city occupy a central importance in Fruit Chan’s films, which he admits is due to the inspiration he gets from lower class neighbourhoods.17 In Little Cheung, the Portland Street community presents us with a collage of objects from bygone days; for instance, Grandma’s vernacular apartment features an array of treasures of old: an antique radio and a fuzzy black-andwhite television, old albums filled with vintage photos, and a worn-out,
Cinematic Remembrances
51
timeless-looking rocking chair. As a monument to time past, Grandma is almost never seen outside her apartment until towards the end of the film, when she walks down with great difficulty upon hearing the news of Brother Cheung’s death. A more mobile extension of Grandma’s antique collection is Cheung’s over-sized bicycle used for everyday deliveries, which is becoming a rarity in urban areas today. Cheung’s mobility is echoed in the thriving presence of human characters, whose on the minute alert to television news returns contemporary significance to old signs and objects. An ironic contrast is created when the weight of everyday trivialities fall upon the relatively light sketches of political events leading up to the July 1 handover. While public worries over the political future of Hong Kong keep flooding through television broadcasts, the street world stays tuned on what it intuitively reckons as worthier headlines: the impending death of Brother Cheung and the escalating scandal between his wife and children over his estate. Fruit Chan wittily summarizes this almost uncanny political apathy in the words of Ami, the Filipino caretaker when she talks to her country folk on the phone: ‘You know when [Brother Cheung] dies he will get more attention than [when] Deng Xiaoping died’. Michelle Huang considers this displaced comment as a deliberate centering of the regional character of Cantonese opera symbolized by Brother Cheung, and also a key to Fruit Chan’s local ‘myth-making’.18 The juxtaposition of Ami on the phone and Brother Cheung’s black-and-white TV clip on a split screen not only legitimizes Ami’s ‘foreign’ perspective, but also obliquely illuminates the irony behind the locals’ muddled priorities. The story of Brother Cheung’s family scandal and the story of Hong Kong’s return to China seem to be contending for the street’s attention on the many TV screens foregrounded in the film’s mise-en-scène. The crowds gathering in front of the television gradually takes on totemic significance, making visible the film’s political message behind this obsession with celebrity gossip: the disproportional public attention paid to a dying Cantonese opera legend reveals not public confidence in the two governments’ goodwill and commitment to Hong Kong’s longterm well-being, but self-abandonment of the disempowered masses as a result of 150-years-long ‘freedom without democracy’, which is also guaranteed to continue in Deng Xiaoping’s promise of wushinian bubian or ‘no change for fifty years’ (Chapter 1). Little Cheung, on the other hand, is a keen audience of Grandmother’s stories about her youthful days in Cantonese opera and an imaginary romance with Brother Cheung, feeling as if he was re-living a special part of the old woman’s past. This cross-generation sharing gives the film its most
52
Time and Memory
intimate moments, like a shelter against the harsh realities of the outside world, as we watch Grandmother and Cheung, once joined by Fan, sharing past secrets accompanied by Cantonese opera music coming through Grandmother’s antique television and radio. In the midst of, and in sharp contrast to, all the ‘hard talk’ about politics and economics, the street world is generating its own counter-narratives, a kind of ‘street talk’ that authenticates the sentiments of the common folk far better than any political speeches and joint declarations. It encapsulates the politics of everyday life, within which history is lived without foregone conclusions. In Little Cheung, temporal and spatial changes are registered in the endless stream of Cantonese opera soundtracks and clips from early Cantonese films on Grandma’s television. The audience hardly misses a chance to watch with Grandma her favourite Brother Cheung films whenever we see her. The significance of the ubiquitous television screen in this film is twofold. First, this intertextual frame of reference situates the film within the popular cultural history of Hong Kong. Cantonese opera was once a major genre in the local film industry ever since it was pioneered by Lai Man-wai (Li Minwei) in the 1930s.19 Cantonese filmmaking since the early twentieth century has undergone many ups and downs, and its dynamic and competitive relationship with Mandarin cinema parallels the political tug of war between China, Taiwan, and the colonial government in Hong Kong.20 The film’s title, Little Cheung, is a direct reference to a 1950 Cantonese film, My Son A-Chang/Xilu Xiang in which Bruce Lee, then a child actor, plays a street-smart boy who relies on his wit and tricks to survive the perils of an exploitative society. A clip of this much older film is actually shown on Grandma’s television towards the end of the film to reinforce the symbolic bond between Cheung and the Bruce Lee character. The overlapping signification of Brother Cheung and the two Little Cheungs—what appears to function like triple-framing—points towards the film’s intertextual selfreference: three years after the handover, it seems, Fruit Chan offers his own version of Little Cheung as a site of collective remembrance within the continuum of the city’s cultural memory. The repeated shots of people gathering around the television inside local eateries reflect the nature of this memory: in a city where digital media has created an instantaneous culture, news is consumed like fast food; in effect, the television/film screen becomes an imaginative space where a kind of collective cohesiveness is enabled and maintained. A spectacular tribute to Cantonese opera and Cantonese cinema appears in the scene where Little Cheung openly defies his father, who forces
Cinematic Remembrances
53
Cheung to stand outside the family restaurant after taking off the boy’s pants (punishment in public being a common practice in traditional Chinese family/school education). Anguished, humiliated but refusing to back down, Cheung sings in a defiant but emotionally charged voice Brother Cheung’s classic Cantonese opera song. The camera stays on Cheung’s fragile body as he slowly turns towards the camera (audience). At the peak of his performance21 Cheung, facing the camera in a fullfrontal shot, urinates in pouring rain as if Heaven, too, is in sympathy for the boy. This declaration of Cheung’s independence is visually compelling, as the camera moves from a low angle shot to a full frontal, confronting the viewer with the violence of the father. The song Cheung has chosen tellingly suggests the allegorical meaning of this scene: it is a song about a blind beggar reflecting on his father’s admonition not to bear grudge against a mother who abandoned him at an early age. Whether this lament of orphanhood refers to the experience of colonization or to a more disturbing sense of alienation after reunification with the Motherland is not clearly spelled out,22 but the pathos sustained throughout Cheung’s performance belies Cheung’s, and the city’s, predicament. Symbolically, this scene legitimizes Cheung as the true heir of his Grandmother’s memory, and the cultural legacy she comes to represent. The pathos of orphanhood and abandonment implied in this scene is sustained in contradistinction from the political apathy of the street community, whose disproportional enthusiasm for TV gossip seems to work well as an over-compensation. While the television as a symbol of the modern media-saturated society is a primary vehicle for the dissemination of news and entertainment, the two roles of the television as a source of information and fast food are repeatedly juxtaposed in the film’s mis-en-scène, until the deaths of Grandma and Brother Cheung on the eve of the handover. This harks back to the discussion of nostalgia in the previous section. The difference between Little Cheung and the nostalgic films mentioned above lies in the use of nostalgia as a culturalhistorical frame of reference outside the mainstream political discourse of the time. It is important that the film is not just about the adventure of Little Cheung but is primarily told/viewed from the perspective of the child protagonist, whose unintentional misinterpretation of signs and meanings emanating from the adult world reveals the absurdities and contradictions of everyday life. From this perspective, the relationship between the street world and the world ‘outside’ is complicated by Cheung’s occasional misreading/subversion of the street world’s hierarchy and code of conduct. In a scene bordering on a carnivalesque
54
Time and Memory
reversal of power positions, Cheung takes revenge on the hooligans by pissing into their drinks and manages to get away unscathed. In another scene, David, the hooligan leader, is seen enjoying his icy lemon drink at an outdoor food stall with his underlings. The gang is temporarily distracted by a beautiful woman passing by. Cheung, looking down from the balcony of his prostitute friend’s apartment, seizes this opportunity to drop a used tampon into his glass. David of course fails to turn his head back soon enough to discern the changed colour of his lemon tea before he gulps it down. Allegedly, he falls ill soon afterwards and never fully recovers. Rendered in a series of jump cuts and slow motion, this comic episode delivers the joke in a rhythmic, almost celebratory manner. In a slow motion close-up shot, the camera playfully prolongs the tampon’s descent into David’s drink as if inviting the viewer to savour the mischief befalling the hooligan at a leisurely pace. The daring imagery of a blood-soaked tampon falling into a glass turns a tabooed feminine object into a phallic image of toxic intrusion, instantly debilitating the culprit (menstrual blood here works like black magic on its victim). These comic moments inject an element of fantasy into an otherwise realistic portrayal of grassroots life in the city. They may sound unconvincing, but the hyperbolic quality and the readiness to sacrifice verisimilitude for comic relief are very much in line with the tradition of filmmaking in Hong Kong since the early days of Cantonese cinema. Realistically speaking, these hilarious incidents can only be made credible in a setting like the Portland Street market, where a tiny block of vernacular building is shared by an inchoate mix of users at any given time of the day. Indeed, Cheung’s characterization reminds the audience of the street-smart child-protagonists in earlier Cantonese films whose only means of survival is their own wit. Yet, Cheung’s world is also radically different from his predecessors’: his journey of self-discovery goes far beyond the struggle-for-survival motif to reveal a more complex set of social and cultural relationships that have come to define the local experience of ordinary people in late colonial Hong Kong. So much has been said about the past and the present. What about the future? While Little Cheung looks back into Hong Kong’s pre-handover years for clues to its changing identity, the film’s ending offers an ambivalent and obliquely satirical view of the future that parodies the handover celebrations and problematizes the notion of national identity: a group of primary school children attend a morning assembly in their school’s playground. Dressed in white shirts with red neckribbons, they sing the national anthem as they solemnly observe the flag-raising ceremony. As the camera pans across the assembly, the
Cinematic Remembrances
55
children’s diligent but clueless faces display neither emotion nor understanding as the flag slowly rises against a downcast sky. At the same time, the solemnity of the flag-raising ceremony is undermined by the awkward lecture by the class teacher on the meaning of the five-star symbol on the Chinese flag. Reciting from memorized notes in a monotonous, lack luster voice, her speech is as unconvincing as it is out of place with the surrounding environment. This cynical view of the post-handover situation is a direct comment on Hong Kong’s problematic identification with China, characteristic of the city’s ambiguous relationship with the Chinese nation in its century-long colonial history.23 Like the school assembly, the ex-colony’s political return is a ceremonial and technical necessity, but the transition is not yet complete at the psychological and intellectual level. In this sense, the ceremony, like the handover itself, is formality without substance, conformity without conviction. The crisis of identity is poignantly expressed in a scene showing Cheung and Fan shouting at the top of their voices, ‘Hong Kong belongs to us!’, as they look over the Victoria Harbour, eager to muffle the other’s voice. This scene is perhaps the only one set in a touristy spot of the city, vividly reproducing familiar views of Hong Kong’s waterfront and skyline at a distance. At the same time, this scene conjures up a visual contrast that works to undermine the vista of promise and hope by juxtaposing the distance and magnitude (unreality?) of this hope with three vulnerable child-figures. The sight of the frail bodies leaning on the stone benches of the harbour front promenade crying out loud for a sense of belonging seems to suggest a lack and a gap rather than fulfillment. The subconscious contention between the children for a sense of ownership suggests that, their mutual good will and friendship aside, the collective pronoun ‘us’ has different meanings to the two friends. While Fan, an outsider, is making a deliberate and difficult effort to make herself at home in a hostile and still foreign city, Cheung aspired to becoming his own master in his native town. The word ‘us’ (wo men) is therefore equivocal in nature, its articulation underscored by an invisible barrier between the two interlocutors and the ‘native places’ each represent: Cheung is eager to assert his heritage as a Hong Konger, while Fan envisions a new beginning in her adopted hometown in future. This difference in self-perception is so deeply rooted in the collective historical experience that the barrier between the two friends (peoples?) cannot be overcome easily by innocent friendship and good will. The vulnerability of this relationship is carried through to the end: Fan is taken away by the police, Cheung hops on his bike trying to catch up with the police car, in the hope that he could bid farewell and,
56
Time and Memory
more importantly, make amends. A series of long and medium shots reveal Cheung on his oversized bike, cutting every possible corner in the back lanes to race the police car. The child’s skinny figure is pressed against the matchbox-like buildings as he rushes haphazardly down the narrow passages, his face mixed with anxiety and regret. Unfortunately, Cheung keeps chasing after the wrong vehicle. At this point Fan takes over as the voice-over, and ends her narrative with a lingering sense of disillusionment and alienation. As in Chan’s other films, alienation and abandonment both preconditions and pre-empt the search for meaning by young people and those living on the social margin. Their stories confront mainstream society with its hypocrisy, self-deception, arrogance, and cowardice, showing how a shared inertia to bury unpleasant truths result in collective amnesia, which at least in part explains why political apathy is often used to excuse draconian governance. Little Cheung takes an insider’s look at the heterogeneous space of the margin and reveals a dynamic life-world not of rickshaws or skyscrapers, but of ordinary people and everyday objects on which social and cultural memories can be anchored. From Chan’s cinematic perspective, the street-world, as a vantage point of history, is a new mode of remembering and an antidote to the homogenizing discourse of nationalism and reunification.24
Ann Hui’s Ordinary Heroes: The silences of history Forgetting and remembering are constituents of the nostalgia critically revised in Ann Hui’s Ordinary Heroes. This film can be read as the city’s rite of passage from youthful idealism to the sober present. The main story takes place during the late 1970s and the 1980s, a period of economic transformation and political transition, ending in the wake of the June 4th Tiananmen Incident in 1989.25 The narrative interweaves the flashbacks and voice-over of two key characters who look back to earlier times from the vantage point of the 1990s. In re-telling the story of a group of social activists, the film seeks to interpret the social and political forces that shaped the destinies of individuals who came of age during the 1980s, and how these individuals eventually came to terms with the pressing socio-political realities of their time. A broader theme built into these personal histories is the problematic between city and nation. As a British colony located on the southern border of its historical ‘motherland’, Hong Kong’s position in Chinese history is at best ambivalent, if not embarrassing. Its ‘double marginality’ vis-à-vis both the colonial master and China has had a tremendous impact on
Cinematic Remembrances
57
the territory’s cultural development.26 In Ann Hui’s film, the series of events leading up to the public outrage at the June 4th military crackdown can be read as a prologue to Hong Kong’s coming to terms with its own historical destiny in full awareness of this ‘double marginality’, registered in the clashes of political ideologies, conflicts of values, and the growing pains of a younger generation of educated elites and social activists as they negotiate their identities both inside and outside the political establishment. My reading of Hui’s film focuses on the multiple displacements effected by the film’s representation of space and history. I look at how the film shifts the terms of reference from dominant narratives of history to marginalized personal memories, which are paralleled by the film’s representation of the city as a subaltern space that no measure of well-meaning political idealism has ever managed to reform or improve. Ann Hui’s take on the city, I argue, bespeaks the dilemma of a self-reflexive intellectual filmmaker trying to ‘speak for the masses’. In Ordinary Heroes, the time frame of 1979–1989 recasts Hong Kong’s recent past against the dominant discourse on this crucial decade in Chinese history, which saw China’s re-emergence on the stage of world politics beginning with Deng Xiaoping’s Open Door Policy in 1978, and the beginning of a new phase of nation-wide modernization. The 1980s encapsulates the renewed hope in China’s economic and political progress, which came to an abrupt halt in 1989. On the other hand, standard narratives of Hong Kong history often credit this crucial decade as an important phase of Hong Kong’s economic take-off and subsequent rise to an international financial centre in Asia. As a response to the outbreak of anti-government riots in 1966–1967, the British government adopted a more tolerant and socially responsive colonial policy in order to redirect public attention to domestic social and economic development in the 1970s and 1980s. Under the leadership of Governor Sir Murray MacLehose (1972–1982), the first governor elected from the democratic camp in Britain, major reforms in social welfare, public housing, and education were implemented to restore the public’s faith in the political system and to defuse social tension and anti-British sentiments among the working class and young people.27 The 1980s saw the rise of Hong Kong to dynamic global city, accompanied by substantial improvement in public education, employment, and overall living standards. Ann Hui’s film fills in what this narrative has omitted: the marginalized groups whose livelihood has remained more or less static throughout this era of social and economic progress. Interestingly, Hui deliberately plays down the significance of 1997 in shaping the course
58
Time and Memory
of events. Instead, the China factor is reintroduced through the dismal lives of the fishing community and the so-called ‘boat brides’ (Mainland wives of local fishermen who were refused legal abode by the colonial government), culminating in a public mourning for June 4th victims. This recasting of the recent past that displaces the China-focused narrative is complemented by the film’s representation of the urban space. Ordinary Heroes recreates the ambience and ethos of the city in the late 1970s and 1980s through the stories of four characters. Sow and Tung grew up in boat families and became close allies to Yau, a student activist turned legislative councilor, and Father Kam, an Italian cleric influenced by Maoist thought. They are brought together during the Boat People Incident of 1979.28 An early scene at the Yaumatei typhoon shelter strategically introduces the main characters and subtly demarcates the different social spaces they each inhabit in a well-designed shot sequence. After a few establishing shots of the fishing community and the commotion of public demonstrations at the pier, the camera slowly closes in on the child Sow kneeling in front of a funeral alter on which are placed photos of her family. Hundreds were killed in a fire that incinerated dozens of boat homes. Beginning with young Tung’s point-of-view shots, the camera gradually expands its vision to capture other characters in a picture befitting the clashes between generations, social groups, and moral and political beliefs. Symbolically, embedded in this picture are the differential power positions assigned by class: Yau at the centre appears as the voice of justice and reason, but his impatient tutoring of the ‘unenlightened’ masses betrays an arrogance that will become more visible later on. Father Kam comes into the picture from the lower right, singing and playing a guitar on a small boat, a typical ‘man of the people’ image he carries through to the end. (These two fellow activists turn out to be contrastive models of political action in and outside mainstream politics.) Around these two focal points are boat families and fire victims engrossed in traditional rituals. Visually, this early scene subtly demarcates the internal divisions along class and gender lines (the protestors and leaders are predominantly male) within a local community typical of the tension-prone Hong Kong society in the late 1970s. The concluding shots of this scene further problematizes the political idealists’ assumed position of superiority by an ironic mix of incompatible social practices infiltrating into one another. The chasm between the intellectual elite and the ‘silent masses’ they vow to protect is vividly presented: in slow motion, strips of spiritual money float across a smoky screen; a fade-in of paper deities briefly appears before it dissolves into a long shot of Yau and a group
Cinematic Remembrances
59
of clueless protestors barely able to read their lines, the spiritual money still visible in the sky. This shot sequence is accompanied by a diegetic sound track, mixing Yau’s voice shouting through the loudspeaker and traditional funeral music from nearby boat homes. This cacophony of images and sounds conjure up an historical image of a particular social milieu in late 1970s Hong Kong, magnifying the clashes between the lower-class mobilized by committed intellectuals and the colonial administration represented by the then Royal Hong Kong Police. The social and political divide is further complicated by internal divisions among the activist group made up of left-leaning intellectuals, a Maoist Italian cleric, the marginalized fishing community, and later on husbands demanding right of abode for their Mainland wives. A more direct political statement comes from the intercutting scenes of a street drama about a real-life activist and steadfast Trotskyite, Ng Chung-yin,29 whose story bears witness to the ideological conflicts and in-fights in the leftist camp in the 1960s, which the film suggests was the reason for their eventual break-up and oblivion. The intermittent inserts of Ng’s play also serve as a critical commentary on the differences between two generations of the local educated elite: Ng’s generation embraced a clear sense of national identity and patriotic mission (anti-British colonialism), whereas Yau and his peers display a closer emotional attachment to the city as their hometown. In the new generation’s agenda, nationalism in the form of anti-colonial rule has largely disappeared, replaced by a deeper commitment to local welfare and social progress. This early exposition helps anchor the film’s spatial representation within a set of social parameters. Almost all the shooting locations are in poor neighbourhoods: the typhoon shelter, boat homes, public housing estates, temporary settlements, homeless camps under a busy flyover. These spaces cut a broad spectrum of Hong Kong’s underbelly, a subaltern space characteristically absent from the city’s public images. The only exceptions are a few scenes of public protests in front of the Legislative Council in Central and the now dismantled Star Ferry in Tsimshatsui. This choice of setting is a practical necessity, since it is difficult to re-create the cityscape of twenty years ago in many parts of the presentday Hong Kong, a city known for rapid urbanization and redevelopment. Strategically, these dilapidated neighbourhoods are foregrounded as the key sites of struggle against collective amnesia, as the film’s intertitles ‘To Forget’ and ‘Not to Forget’ explicitly point out. As a director known for her social commitment and sympathy for women oppressed by patriarchal power,30 Ann Hui has made Ordinary Heroes to speak for the voiceless masses, whose existence and struggles cannot comfortably
60
Time and Memory
sit with the success story of a booming and upwardly mobile metropolitan city. In the film, a sense of betrayal and futility saturates the images of poverty and social injustice captured in snapshots of the city stripped of its usual metropolitan aura: impoverished and hazard-prone boat homes, dying drug addicts and homeless people in makeshift card-box dwellings, dilapidated tenement buildings and a line-up of disillusioned activists and ex-patriots. Repeatedly, and sometimes in quick succession, these images fill up the screen, and much screen time, like a collection of exhibits on display, as if the filmmaker is trying to make an imprint on our visual memory that will last longer than the time of viewing. Much in line with her docu-drama credentials, Ann Hui blends in real and fictional news footage, black and white still shots, scenes from another street drama, and a film-within-the-film interview between the actors and the director herself. Slightly off-coloured and grainy in texture, these documentary fragments carry the immediacy of reportage, like a series of images culled and reassembled from historical archives in order to shed light on the present moment. If Ordinary Heroes stands as a fictional memoir of a bygone era, the film narrative reorganizes fragments of the larger ‘social text’ to obtain critical meaning. As an historical docu-drama, Ordinary Heroes does not seek political participation as its characters do; rather, it sets out to test the fundamental beliefs and moral calibre of its fictional characters as historical metaphors. Father Kam, a localized foreigner, had to leave the territory when tension was building up between him and the Catholic Church due to his controversial politics. Sow and Tung are neither political idealists nor social elites. Quietly observing and supporting their respective ‘hero’, the two youngsters aspire to finding a purpose and vocation in life, a new horizon from which they can transcend their class constraints and thereby assert themselves through social participation. Yau begins as a socially committed university student who tries to bring his beliefs into practice by joining mainstream politics. He becomes, in the end, an elected member of the Legislative Council (now Legislative Assembly) working his way up the political ladder. An idealist turned seasoned politician, Yau remains a split figure in his public career and private life. Lacking moral courage to face up to his flaws yet unable to completely reject his past ideals, Yau remains haunted by a guilty conscience and a sense of impotence, which climaxes when Beijing’s military crackdown in Tiananmen Square left the entire Hong Kong public paralysed in anger and disbelief. Precisely because of his being a disappointment even to himself, Yau is a convincingly realistic character living through the dilemma and inner conflicts of a well-meaning intellectual trying to prove himself in the political establishment.
Cinematic Remembrances
61
In Ordinary Heroes, Yau represents a new generation of the educated elite, those who came of age in the late 1970s and early 1980s. As some critics have noted, Ann Hui’s final treatment of the complexity of Yau’s character is far from sympathetic: seeing no way out for his pent-up anger and frustration, he rapes Sow in his own office just when the woman is leaving him. Running away from Yau in deep agony, Sow is knocked down by a car and loses her memory as a result. This scene casts Yau in an extremely negative light. He admits feeling like a ‘bad guy’ compared to Kam’s selfless sacrifice. Portrayed as an ambivalent character trapped in a dead-end in all aspects of his life, Yau’s political/sexual power and disempowerment are almost concurrent, culminating in the final rape scene. The parallel between the June 4th military crackdown and sexual violence throws as much light on Yau’s character as on his complicity with the system of power that characterizes both the British and the Chinese regimes. Ending a long, strained relationship with sexual violence and memory loss may well be seen as a projection of Ann Hui’s own political disillusionment and scepticism. At the same time, the film’s political meanings are to be found in the private realm of individual experience. The tortuous relationship between Sow and Yau and her subsequent refusal to play the mistress signify as much the shattering of hope in the hero figure as her gradual discovery of her own subjectivity, which remains in conflict with the role of a sexual/social victim imposed by Yau and the institution of power he has come to symbolize. From the very beginning, the film locates the voice of history in Tung, Sow, and intertextually Ng Chun-yin in a dramatized autobiography. The young people’s voice-over narratives provide key anchor points for narrative unfolding. Unlike in a nostalgic reminiscence, the past as memory recalled is constantly interrupted by Tung and Sow’s perspectives in the present. In the film’s opening scene, Sow, dressed in a hospital gown, runs down an underground tunnel as if she was haunted by a ghost; when she suddenly comes to a halt and turns back to face the camera, the close-up shot reveals an eagerness to confront the monster behind her. A number of Ann Hui’s films deal with the issue of forgetting. Memory loss is frequently used as a pretext for a soul-searching journey in which memory is never taken for granted. Many characters in her films are haunted by memories of the past, but the act of remembering always results in conflicting claims and interpretations. Even in Hui’s light-hearted supernatural thriller, Visible Secret/Youling renjian (I) (2001), characters are haunted by a ghost seeking revenge for his death, but the only person who can see the ghost has lost her childhood memory. While the scariest moments of this supernatural thriller are often
62
Time and Memory
defused by comical twists, memory loss and recovery remains a central concern in Visible Secret: the ghost realizes that his revenge has been meaningless when the heroine finally remembers the real cause of the tram accident that decapitated him some fifteen years ago. In a more sombre tone, national and personal histories have created an insurmountable barrier between mother and daughter in Hui’s Song of the Exile/Ketu qiuhen (1996), in which reconciliation is made possible only when the daughter re-visits her mother’s past (the misunderstanding and discrimination suffered by a young Japanese woman married to a Chinese man) and realizes, for the first time, both of them are in fact fellow exiles in the long journey of life. In Hui’s films, the past always comes back to disturb the precarious equilibrium of the status quo and forces a confrontation with repressed memories. In Ordinary Heroes, Sow is a victim of sexual violence and social injustice, but she is also the agent through whom hidden truths are recalled. The personal stories presented do not come to any solid conclusions about the politics or morals each represents. Rather, the film poses questions about whether, and how much, social justice for ordinary people is achieved after all the turmoil and personal sufferings. With the exception of Kam,31 the other two intellectual figures are confronted with a choice between self-marginalization and self-betrayal. While Yau moves on in his political career, the memory of Ng Chung-yin the idealist is retained in a post-humus street drama. The film’s treatment of Ng’s fragments shows the same sensitivity towards space and its relation to voice and memory: bit by bit throughout the film, the camera reframes his performance to reveal more and more of the surrounding off-stage, which turns out to be the Temple Street public night market in Kowloon, a lively conglomerate of hawkers, fortune-tellers, as well as professional and amateur performers. The last time the street drama appears coincides with Tung’s return to Hong Kong, Sow’s car accident, and the military crackdown in Beijing. For the first time Ng’s drama is integrated into the film’s diegetic space as Tung walks through the night market in search of Sow. This scene visually and spatially links together Sow’s rape and memory loss, the dwindling voice of the political idealist, and the tragedy of June 4th. The political symbolism is imbued with a sense of futility and angst that cannot be easily dispelled by any amount of public protest. The most politically charged episodes are perhaps those relating to the Tiananmen tragedy. In fact, the film’s final scene shows Tung attending the annual Tiananmen commemoration in Victoria Park. In slow motion, the hand-held camera moves with the footsteps of those
Cinematic Remembrances
63
attending the event, as people lay their white candles on the muddy ground. The movement halts as the camera slowly moves up to reveal Tung’s face in profile in a close-up, as he lays his candle on the ground. The film ends with a freeze frame on Tung. It is understandable that the tragedy has left a great impact on a majority of Hong Kong people, and to this day annual gatherings are still held to commemorate the students who were killed fifteen years ago. It is perhaps for this reason that Ann Hui resorts to a fusion of her subjects by subtitling the final part of her film ‘Not to forget’, when collective memory and personal memory are simultaneously evoked and funnelled into a final tribute to the martyrs of the June 4th crackdown. Such a twist in the narrative direction, however, weakens the film’s cohesiveness by overtly replacing the ambiguities and complexities of local/national and personal/collective and subsuming the former terms under the banner of collective mourning. This setback aside, Ann Hui’s take on the 1980s can be read as an indirect tribute to the ‘ordinary heroes’ who have provided substance to her work, a leitmotif similar to Fruit Chan’s in Little Cheung. In fact, Hui herself has admitted in an interview that her interest in politics grows out of a ‘sense of duty’.32 In Ordinary Heroes, she tries to evoke the ‘spirit’ of an important era of Hong Kong’s coming of age. To evoke the mood of an epoch by piecing together disjointed memories is far from being epic (recall the very different historical dramas from Mainland China in the same period). The film’s Chinese title has quite honestly confessed its sober ambition: qian yan wan yu, thousands and thousands of words, but something is always missing. Unlike the more sensational nostalgic movies that saturated the local market at that time, the past in Ordinary Heroes has more to offer than nostalgia; it is a self-reflective critique of the Bildung of a generation. This critical impulse echoes Hui’s autobiographical documentary As Time Goes By (Qu ri ku duo, 1997), in which Hui and her friends relish memories of their college days. Despite their Westernized upbringing, the act of ‘talking about oneself at the age of fifty’ (wushi zhishu) is a very Chinese form of self-examination. The Chinese title phrase, qu ri ku duo, is borrowed from a famous classical poem by Cao Cao in third century AD, in which the poet laments the transience of life as his army is getting ready for an important battle. Ann Hui and her fellow classmates represent a broad profile of Hong Kong’s educated elite, and are familiar names to the Hong Kong people. Made and released in 1997, the film complements Ordinary Heroes as a personal memoir of the same era. In Ordinary Heroes, the dominant narratives of history, that is, China’s re-entering the world stage, Hong Kong’s rise from rags to riches, and the
64
Time and Memory
fin-de-siècle imagination triggered by the 1997 handover, are displaced by stories of individuals on the verge of oblivion. If ‘the subaltern cannot speak’ (borrowing Spivak’s caustic remark), Ordinary Heroes could well be a cinematic reflection on this dilemma: the self-consciousness of an intellectual-filmmaker of her predicament to ‘speak for the masses’, and the simultaneous desire to ‘let them speak’, for ‘[r]epresentation has not withered away. The female intellectual as intellectual has a circumscribed task which she must not disown with a flourish’. The film, and Ann Hui herself, illustrates this dilemma and its promises.33 Speaking through its own images, the city as a subaltern space is re-constructed as social memory, in a film narrative that self-reflexively critiques its own intellectual roots.
Conclusion In Ordinary Heroes and Little Cheung, we have discerned a more down-toearth local temperament. Their reconstruction of urban space restores a certain degree of continuity between past and present as two mutually reflective time-spaces. These films seek out their historical subjects among the silenced and marginalized obscured by popular images of metropolitan Hong Kong. Fruit Chan uses the street-world and the perspective of a street-smart boy to articulate his vision of the city, a versatile and sometimes bleak picture of a grassroots community and their way of coping with political and social change. The city seen from ‘ground zero’ effects a counter-narrative to the solemn political event of reunification, generating its own ‘street talk’ to reinterpret history and reality, a collective ‘speech act’ that eclipses the grand narrative of metropolitanism and nationalism. Ann Hui’s film reconstructs the city as a space of the subalterns whose stories question the educated elite’s legitimacy to ‘speak for the masses’ by revealing the ideological and moral blind spots of its self-representation. This self-reflective mode of remembering is akin to the social realist cinema of earlier decades; with critical hindsight, post-fin-de-siècle, Ordinary Heroes problematizes the local by de-essentializing the official narrative of the city, using the voices of two down-trodden youths and an ostracized activist to destabilize the elitist discourse of political idealism, just as the subaltern space of the city speaks out against collective amnesia. In a similar vein, in Fruit Chan’s film the local exists in the popular cultural traditions symbolized by Cantonese opera and Cantonese cinema as lived experience rather than heritage exhibits; but the local is also defined by its elusiveness, in the ever-changing ethnic, social, and mini-political
Cinematic Remembrances
65
constituencies of the street world, where the ‘untold story’ of the cosmopolitan global city unfolds. Unlike the nostalgic, exoticized localism and the stylized allegorical locale that distinguishes the popular nostalgic and gangster/kung fu genres of the late 1980s and 1990s, Little Cheung and Ordinary Heroes make use of nostalgic reminiscences to reinscribe historical ‘others’ as historical subjects. Ann Hui’s nostalgia for the ‘age of idealism’ leads not only to a critique of the later decades but also an ironic self-questioning of political idealism. Fruit Chan’s nostalgia for the communal grassroots ethos and vernacular lifestyle inspires an updating of the street kid figure as a son and heir of the local tradition. In upholding the margin as the centre of historical unfolding, both films have risked a degree of romanticizing their subject (c.f. Chapter 7). Sow’s recovery, Tung’s return to social service, and Father Kam’s Sunday Mass at an outdoor food stall feel too contrived a ‘happy ending’. In Fruit Chan’s film, the happy-go-lucky street world seems a little too happily immune from outside threats. As cinematic remembrances, however, these are sincere efforts to articulate a local consciousness by revisiting the lived experiences and imaginations of time past. This aspect of the social realist cinema, as we shall see, is also found in mainstream commercial films. It seems, for a doubly marginalized post-colonial city like Hong Kong, the imagination remains the most effective tactic for self-preservation.
3 Allegory, Kinship, and Redemption: Fu Bo and Isabella
Macau,1 a former colony of Portugal within less than an hour’s journey by ferry from Hong Kong, had been a Portuguese settlement since 1557.2 To this day, this long legacy of European settlement and colonization is still visible in city’s architecture, the street names, and the Macanese population. Though not as dominant as English in Hong Kong, Portuguese still finds nominal usage in official titles, public documents, and institutional names. Part of the legacy of Portugal’s colonial rule is the Catholic Church, which remains the largest religious establishment, though, as Christina Cheng reveals in her illuminating study, indigenous religious traditions and cultural practices have created a ‘cultural Janus’ that is far more complex than existing stereotypes and assumptions can explain.3 Like Hong Kong, the majority of the population in Macau is Cantonese-speaking Chinese, and Hong Kongers have long been regular patrons of the city’s casinos and holiday resorts. Notwithstanding its geographical and cultural affinity to Hong Kong, and despite its frequent appearance in Hong Kong films, Macau is rarely treated as a subject on its own. In Ann Hui’s Song of the Exile, for instance, the Portuguese colony is a refuge and temporary exile for the heroine’s grandparents, who eventually return to ‘New China’ before the Cultural Revolution. The Longest Nite/An hua (Yau Tat-chi, 1998) is a gangster film set in Macau with strong allegorical references to Hong Kong. In Exiled/Fang zhu (2006), Johnnie To (Yau’s mentor and action auteur) uses a bloody battle between Hong Kong and Macau triads on the eve of Macau’s reunification with China in 1999 to underscore the existential and moral crises of both places before and after the change of sovereignty (Chapter 4). This chapter focuses on two films by younger directors who began their filmmaking careers in the 1990s. Fu Bo (Wong Ching-po and Lee 66
Allegory, Kinship, and Redemption 67
Kung-lok, 2003)4 and Isabella (Edmond Pang Ho-cheung, 2006) are set in Macau in the last days of colonial rule. Both films display a penchant for visual manoeuvring in the creation of mood and atmosphere. In Fu Bo, the thin line between life and death is transgressed in the macabre images of executions, autopsies, and triad violence that have become a way of life for its characters, while Isabella’s romanticized rendition of Macau’s colonial cityscape endows the crime-stricken city with a controlled sentimentalism bordering on the lyrical. These contrastive images of Macau, nonetheless, carry within them a fin-de- siècle flavour pregnant with nostalgic overtones: Fu Bo features a Portuguese character (the prison cook) who acts in a priest-like manner and speaks alternately in Cantonese and Portuguese; Isabella makes direct references to the uncertainty and social turmoil in precisely the last forty-seven days before the handover to Mainland China. Both films foreground morally and psychologically tarnished characters: corrupt cops, criminals, prostitutes, and traumatized individuals persecuted by their guilt-ridden pasts. Stylistically, both Fu Bo and Isabella are more concerned with style than plot integrity, a feature that dismays some reviewers yet absolved by others.5 This ‘primacy of the image’ over narrative may not have been perfectly mastered by the young directors, but the common pursuit of an expressive visual schema in handling setting, characterization, and subject matter suggests something more than a directorial exercise. Emerging from the film texts is a desire to address a perceived impossibility of narrative coherence in the worlds portrayed. The existential landscapes in the two films are manifestations of this desire and the limitations to its fulfilment. Both films exhibit a conscious borrowing of popular genre elements in mise-en-scène and choreography, yet the revisitation of the last days of colonial rule in Macau in these films goes beyond nostalgia to expose an existential crisis that pervades the present. In Fu Bo, crisis is articulated through the invocation of an allegorical landscape in which the tensions between past and present, memory and forgetfulness, father and child, human agency and a certain notion of providence play out in an intense human drama. Isabella on the other hand exploits the fin-de-siècle splendour of the end of colonial history to project a romantic(ized) vision of the father–child relation as a means to survive in a chaotic and morally bankrupt world. Both films draw upon kinship as a site of conflict and the resolution of conflict, where redemption is sought with varied results when all other spiritual means for transcendence have failed. I seek to uncover the existential crisis that haunts the film narrative, and to suggest why this crisis forges a kind of kinship between Macau and Hong Kong in the two cities’ post-colonial present.
68
Time and Memory
Mortal spaces: Fu Bo Fu Bo consists of three connected story strands leading up to the execution ground and the autopsy room: a mortuary assistant’s daily routine of dissecting and stitching up human bodies, a gangster’s violent killings leading to mental breakdown, and a prison chef’s interactions with inmates on the death row, culminating in a cannibalistic ‘last supper’ offered as a last wish granted. The primary setting is the mortuary where the clinical procedure of autopsy is repeatedly and analytically displayed. The film’s interest in mortality and the legal and illegal institutions through which mortality is managed and processed requires a convenient and convincing setting where these elements are all present. Since Hong Kong has long abandoned capital punishment, Macau offers the necessary social and institutional parameters for a story about mortality to unfold. Practical factors aside, the Portuguese colonial enclave is filmed in retrospect: the story goes back to the final days of colonial rule in Macau to seek out the socio-political dimensions of this ‘crisis of mortality’, something like a universal tragic fate at the end of times. By confining its main action to the mortal spaces of the mortuary and the prison, punctuated by fragmented scenes of brutal murder and brief outdoor excursions, Fu Bo presents an allegorical landscape where scenes of killing, human disembodiment, and the everyday ritual of eating go hand in hand, where mortality is confronted head-on in a professional, business-as-usual manner. The bleakness, and insignificance, of human existence is visualized in the macabre images of mutilated bodies and human organs, a key visual motif of the film. Characters in Fu Bo, consciously or subconsciously, react in different yet equally bizarre ways to extreme violence that defines their everyday existence: Fu (Liu Kai-chi) takes refuge doing his ‘dirty job’ inside the mortuary and virtually insulates himself from the outside world; the nameless prison chef (Jacob Mense) devotes himself to preparing elaborate last meals for death-row inmates and recording their stories; Giu, the contract killer, makes perfect the art of torture and murder but inevitably falls victim to his own guilty conscience. Different from Ann Hui and Fruit Chan’s social realism, Fu Bo’s cinematography and narrative structure do not prioritize verisimilitude, favouring instead expressionistic sketches to capture extreme psychological states and hallucinations. This probably has to do with the necessity to improvise on a small-budget project shot in DV.6 The overall effect evokes a vision of Macau as a space of inner chaos for which the occasional excursions into an idyllic ‘outside world’ only help to
Allegory, Kinship, and Redemption 69
intensify the characters’ sense of alienation and entrapment. Such a nightmarish vision of the colonial city on the eve of regime change might well be a continuation of similar sentiments in pre-handover Hong Kong through displacement. Yet, the link between pre-colonial Macau as a displaced imaginary and post-colonial Hong Kong as a lived reality is more complex than a direct nostalgic projection, for the film was made well after the political handovers (Hong Kong in 1997 and Macau in 1999), and the economic depression and crisis of public governance before and during the 2003 SARS epidemic had greatly depreciated Hong Kong’s privileged position over Macau. Curiously, it was also during these years of great turmoil that Hong Kong cinema began to take its (ex-)colonial neighbour seriously as an entity in itself, something like its ‘equal’ in post-colonial times. Fu Bo (and Isabella) treats Macau as a parallel universe in which the Hong Kong imagination seeks out an alternative narrative to its own—incoherent though it remains. This narrative allows for a renewed engagement with the historical condition of the fin-de-siècle not as unique but universal, in the sense that (colonial) history is always entangled histories. Here also lies the importance of kinship: the problematic relation between father and child in the two films shed light on the conflicting claims on identity. In Fu Bo, the fathers’ blood-stained hands are directly linked to mental collapse, neurosis, and the breakdown of kinship; its replacement by the dubious connections between the prison chef (the priest figure) and the inmates is undermined by the moral ambivalence of the cannibalistic feast. (In Isabella, on the other hand, kinship is less as a product of biological lineage than circumstance and personal choice.) The plot of Fu Bo follows a circular pattern: the opening scene shows a prisoner in orange uniform, leaning on the wall of a dark and gloomy prison cell, his back facing the screen. The voice-over is rendered in Portuguese, the subtitle of which is withheld until much later in the film. A series of jump cuts knit together the execution of prisoners, an execution-style gang murder, and the masked face of what we know later to be the central character Fu, holding a surgical knife ready to cut into something off-screen. These interlocking scenes of the prison, the execution ground, and autopsy in the mortuary anticipate the revelation of the stories of Fu, Giu, and the prison chef. The spaces each inhabits are linked by the circulation of bodies: death-row inmates, gang murder victims, and those who handle dead bodies in the mortuary. The different stories of Fu, Giu, and the prison chef are connected by their proximity to death. The ending reveals the identity of the prisoner facing the
70
Time and Memory
wall, as the English and Chinese transcriptions of the chef’s voice-over appear on a darkened screen. The extensive use of dissolves and fades renders these disconnected spaces visually fluid and interchangeable. The smudginess created by over-exposed and under-exposed colours infuses these spaces with an oppressive eeriness in sharp contrast to the consistently and almost deceptively bright outdoor scenes occasionally thrown in. In the prison, the mortuary, and the apparently ubiquitous underworld, the main characters’ professions are seen as different stages of a system of disposal—the triads run an uninterrupted supply chain of dead bodies for final discharge by the mortuary staff. The leading character prefers to be called ‘Fu’, a pseudonym taken from his profession, the so-called Fu Bo’s or mortuary assistants. Always carrying the air of an experienced, no nonsense old-hand, Fu appears to be emotionally detached from the hideous tasks he carries out on order every day. The film repeatedly shows Fu quietly doing his job: dissect dead bodies, take organ samples, and stitch up cuts. As the lead actor, Liu Kai Chi’s low-key and controlled performance compellingly portrays an agonized and conflicted individual behind a mask of indifference, struggling in his disintegrating inner world to maintain his sanity. His indifference is soon undercut by shots of his wandering in a park, languidly looking at young couples and children walk past. Soon we learn that Fu is divorced, his wife is a prostitute and he never gets to see his son until the boy’s body is laid on the autopsy table, awaiting final discharge by his father. Unlike the graphic horror of the previous autopsy scene, Fu’s final on-screen operation borders on fantasy: the already over-exposed whiteness of the autopsy room is further magnified to produce a surrealistic space in which a blinding whiteness dominates the visual field. In slow motion, Fu is seen working at an empty operation table, as the little boy happily chases after bright orange ping-pong balls (echoing the death-row inmates’ uniform) bouncing all over the place. The ending shot of the scene shows Fu in a medium close-up, an enigmatic smile gradually emerges on his face as he looks down at the child’s body off-screen. It is as if a ritual has been performed, and Fu, being both the exorcist and the accursed, has performed the final rite of redemption, both for his son and for himself. Viewers may find this denouement for Fu puzzling or even dehumanizing. Not so if it is read symbolically, that is, as the culmination of Fu’s traumatized existence. It could be argued that, in this episode, the real horror lies not in the graphic details of cutting up bodies, but in the complete turn-around from one extreme to another—from extreme agony to nearly transcendental calm—within minutes. Fu, after some painful effort, manages to
Allegory, Kinship, and Redemption 71
suppress his natural human instinct and emotions and turns back to his detached, impersonal, efficient, impeccably clear-cut professional self. Instead of a final outburst or breakdown, as would usually happen to a psychologically repressed character, Fu seeks to transcend his repression by turning the autopsy into a ritual. The irony of redemption-in/through-death is repeated in the other two story strands. The Portuguese prison chef is required to take last orders from inmates before their execution. In preparing the meals, the chef would take notes of their final confessions. The numerous conversations between the chef and the prisoners cast him in a very different light from what we usually expect. His sympathy, or indeed empathy, towards those facing death and his determination to grant last wishes effectively turn him into a priest figure. In the film, he is forever the quiet counsellor. His voice-over narration poses questions about sin and human existence without necessarily answering them. The morbidity and grotesqueness of the prisoners’ confessions are matched by the chef’s undeterred desire to grant the sickest of all last wishes: a feast of human flesh. Unlike the graphic details of the autopsies, this cannibalistic feast is only implied, when the chef asks another inmate if he is willing to ‘go’ two days earlier. This plot detail is significant for its cynicism and ambivalence: here we have a priest figure preparing a cannibalistic last supper, but this time it is not the symbolic body of Christ being consumed, but another human being in flesh and blood. The biblical/spiritual prototype of the priest is therefore displaced by a cannibalistic impulse, revealing an existential wasteland in which spiritual meanings are lost in the endless recycle of human bodies. Death, it seems, draws the common equation of all that exist, and the lifeless bodies of the dead are neither sacred nor profane: redemption comes through the contentment of the final moment, and only in death can this moment be made eternal. Giu, the hitman, attains a similar redemption as he diligently (and quite happily) kneels before the shooting squad. Throughout the film, he has been suffering from schizophrenic fits of extreme violence and self-condemnation. His mental breakdown is punctuated by shots of nightmare in which he revisits scenes of murders, and his last ditch attempts to seek salvation through religion. In an ironic twist, Giu’s meeting with a Catholic priest in shot/reverse shots is mapped onto Giu’s conversation with his boss-as-priest/God: Giu: Why do people die? Priest: Because they have sinned/[Boss: Because they have sinned.]
72
Time and Memory
Giu: What sin have they committed? Priest: They did not obey God, therefore they have to die/[Boss: They did not obey Me, therefore they have to die.] Giu (raises his hand, pointing a finger at the ceiling): So, you mean He has also sinned, don’t you? (Cut to the priest’s terrified face before Giu takes out his gun and shoots randomly at the furniture and decorations behind him.) This unexpected outbreak of violence contrasts sharply with Giu’s otherwise morbid serenity when carrying out his various assignments. Previously we have seen him leisurely eating cup noodles next to a gutted man in a pool of still-warm blood. Giu’s schizophrenic split is confirmed by the concluding shot of the church shooting scene: in two superimposed slow motion shots we see Giu and his duplicate image walk out of the church in opposite directions. Giu’s mental illness reaches a breaking point after he kills Fu’s son. The film’s treatment of Giu’s psychological and mental states is fragmentary and scattered, so that Giu’s role resembles that of a chorus to the existential wasteland outside the mortuary. Giu’s characterization epitomizes the corrupt forces of the underworld in Macau. Organized crime reached an alarming state shortly before Macau’s handover to China, a period when cross-border crimes were escalating. The threat to public security in the pre-handover period began to trigger widespread concern and the new Macau SAR Government, under the China-backed first Chief Executive and local tycoon Edmund Ho Hau-wah, made tackling security problems the top priority of government objectives in his Policy Address in 2001. While the situation has improved since he took office, the government’s enthusiasm for the ‘liberalization’ of its ‘gaming business’ (an umbrella term including casinos, grey hound racing, horse racing, and lottery) has virtually turned the economy into a conglomerate of casinos run by local and international operators.7 While it is uncertain whether economic revival brought on by the internationalization of casinos (being the biggest tax payers and employers) has a direct bearing on the reduction in crime rates, it certainly has a homogenizing effect on social life, in a society where everyday activities—jobs, entertainment, and the use of public spaces—are perfunctory to one unifying theme: the city of gam(bl)ing, in which value is equated with revenue, thus making Macau a diligent child of China’s ‘socialist capitalism’ in the twenty-first century. Indeed one can hardly miss the rhetoric of prosperity-cum-unity and the patriotic subtext in Ho’s vision for the future:
Allegory, Kinship, and Redemption 73
In response to the trend of economic globalization, we shall give priority to strengthening regional cooperation. We have always had the support of our Motherland, whose economy has been enjoying robust growth and has achieved basic prosperity. Indeed, the all-out support of the Central People’s Government provides the strongest guarantee for our development. (Policy Address, 2001) Ho’s speech also underscores the HKSAR government’s favourite slogan: ‘Backed by the Motherland, Looking to the World’ (beikao zuguo, mianxiang shijie). In this light, Giu’s story carries the film’s central social message: institutional excess, symbolized by official and unofficial ‘mortal spaces’, is complicated and accelerated by the conflation of value and revenue, means and ends. This is further visualized through the functional overlap of God/godfather and Church/prison. The film’s vision of the city runs counter to the rosy picture portrayed by both governments; it reveals a space that has been hidden and repressed by the upbeat rhetoric of unity and prosperity. Giu’s gradual decline therefore can be seen as an intensification and externalization of the inner decay of these mortal spaces. Several details related to the food motif capture the ennui that runs through the film. The scene in which Giu leisurely savours a bowl of instant noodles in front of a mutilated victim dying in a pool of blood recalls an earlier scene where Fu expressionlessly eats from lunch boxes full of greasy meats and animal organs in the autopsy room as he tutors a young apprentice. The cinematography employed is the same as that which sustains the spectral eeriness of the mortuary: the lighting gradually brightens through a series of dissolves during their conversation. In glaring white light, the two figures (in white uniforms) also dissolve slowly into the white wall in the background. Visually, their bodies become indifferentiable from the wall while their disembodied faces look like decorative masks floating on the white backdrop. The symbolic significance of the mortuary, the primary setting of the film, is evident in the use of lighting, camera movement, and colour schemes that defines the film’s visual style. The autopsy room is uncomfortably lit in white light, its ghastliness further accented by the colour contrast of close-up shots of blood flowing down the drains. The oppressive, almost claustrophobic, isolation of the mortuary staff is rendered in several long takes where a tracking camera follows the mortuary assistants as they carry dead bodies through dark, meandering corridors. A thick, crimson red is occasionally spotted in scenes where Fu’s terrified young apprentice is seen alone checking the corpses. These visual motifs
74
Time and Memory
effectively create an infernal-like vision that works surprisingly well with the horrific scenes of murder and autopsy, a quality quite common in horror films. No doubt the directors have lavishly exploited horror conventions in mise-en-scène and shot compositions, but the social and political underpinnings of the genre, that is, the articulation of a deeply held but unacknowledged crisis,8 are equally relevant. As an existential wasteland, the mortuary is on the receiving end of social and political excesses. Filmed and released in 2003, this vision of Macau on the eve of regime change rings true to many viewers, Hong Kong and Macau alike, still in the grips of the SARS epidemic. Indeed, the aversion to outdoor scenes and the minimalism in the use of backdrop characters speak volumes about the resounding sense of emptiness and angst felt by many in those years. As mentioned above, the circularity of death from execution to disposal is reinforced by frequent intercutting of scenes from the three main story lines. This pattern is also reflected in the alternate patterns of over-exposed and under-exposed shots, and glaring white and dark red colour schemes, creating a series of visual cycles both connecting and demarcating the prison, the mortuary, and the shooting ground. In the end, the film returns to the beginning shot of the prisoner facing the wall: it is Giu before his execution. The chef/priest’s voice-over, now rendered in Cantonese, appears in both Chinese and English on screen: ‘Many people exist in shadows, never entering the light; then, there is only one step between life and death.’ This last statement by the priest figure (a killer nonetheless) brings neither catharsis nor poetic justice, but an oppressive discomfort, as the priest, too, cannot but ‘exist in shadows’—he is mostly seen in the dark jail and the execution ground. The only exception is when he is out on an errand to get ready for the cannibalistic last supper. To him, as to all, life and death are always one step apart. If this last statement is intended to be a sermon of any sort, the religious message is lost in the moral ambiguities of the priest. The film’s vision of Macau’s fin-de-siècle condition thus is more than just a nostalgic echo of what Hong Kong used to be a decade ago; the configuration of the city as a montage of mortal spaces, fractured selves and broken families precariously held together in a fragmented narrative suggests not a nostalgic imagining of what used to be, but unnamed horror of what has become. The short-circuiting of historical (narrative) continuity is metaphorically articulated in the relationship between father and son: Fu, who lives forever in the shadow of his father (a forensic doctor and mentor of Fu’s boss, Dr Lee), cannot fully function as a father himself. The film makes this point poignantly by
Allegory, Kinship, and Redemption 75
disallowing Fu from meeting his son until the boy’s body is laid before him on the autopsy table. In the words of Dr Lee, the boy ‘didn’t manage to make [Fu] change before he died. This was his biggest regret’. In many Hong Kong films in the 1980s and 1990s, parent–child relationship is an expression of the anxiety of returning to the Motherland, and by extension an identity crisis encompassing generational conflicts, self-sacrifice, and the clash between traditional and modern values.9 In Fu Bo, while Fu as a son recalls a similar pattern of parent–child conflict, a new problematic arises as Fu, as a son, becomes a father. The film does not offer much detail concerning Fu’s failed marriage and his withdrawal except his passive acceptance of misfortunes, focusing rather on the consequence of his defeatism. As a symbolic character Fu’s son has only a few brief appearances. There is, literally, no interaction between parent and child in the narrative, not even a negative one. In essence, Fu, as the disgruntled son in the past, fares even worse as the father in the present. Dysfunctional patriarchy, it seems, concludes this bleak representation of the father figure, and the film triplicates this bleakness in the three male leads: the chef, Giu, and Fu. As parent–child relationship is also central to Isabella, it is useful here to briefly summarize the critique of the father in Fu Bo, in which three father figures personify three dimensions of the spiritual crisis of the mortal spaces. For Fu, it takes the boy’s violent death (he’s muffled and cut through the throat) to reunite father and son through the bizarre ritual of autopsy, while the chef/priest takes refuge in satisfying the perverse appetites of death-row inmates before they head for the execution ground. Giu in his delusion defies God and kills his godfather, and in death he relinquishes his role as parent. It is important to note that these fathers have little in common with the conventional patriarch who embodies both the persistence of tradition and its inevitable erosion/replacement by modern values. Fu, Giu, and to a lesser extent the prison chef are themselves prodigal sons of a disintegrating social/moral order. The film’s treatment of these grown-up sons thus goes beyond the formula of alienation-conflict-reconciliation (c.f. the teacher–pupil duo in kung fu movies, and Ang Lee’s Pushing Hands/Tui shou and A Wedding Banquet/Xi yan), but mediates between empathy and ambivalence.10 Whether one interprets the ending of Giu, Fu, and the chef’s stories as redemptive or cynical, there is little hope of leaving the mortal space of the prison, where all three stories attain at best a discomforting denouement. The religious message of the chef’s final meditation, in this light, sounds too contrived and superficial an effort to dilute the bleakness of the film’s macabre images.
76
Time and Memory
Read contextually, the dysfunctional father as both victim and agent of mortality could also be a radical statement on a perceived condition of existence shared by many in and around 2003. As one local critic has commented, by the end of 2003, Hong Kong films seemed to have relinquished its ‘local flavour’ in order to tap into the Mainland market, a phenomenon made more pervasive by the ‘Closer Economic Partnership Agreement’ (CEPA) signed between Hong Kong and China in the wake of the SARS.11 A breed of ‘impotent males’, says another critic, defined the Hong Kong film scene in 2003. While the multiple political, economic, and public health crises seemed to have announced the death of the ‘Hong Kong way of life’, the sense of gloom intensified with the tragic deaths of two legendary Hong Kong pop-culture icons, Lesley Cheung and Anita Mui in the same year. The cinematic demasculinization of Hong Kong men, it seems, is symptomatic of the lost pride and injured ego of the city as a whole.12 Countering this statement is the view that ruptured masculinity is the result of female empowerment, as more and more independent modern and martial arts women began to popularize Hong Kong screens, an effort by filmmakers to attract female audience to the theatre.13 While these observations primarily concern romantic comedy and the action film, in Fu Bo there is a tendency to outplay this patriarchal anxiety not by the ‘death of the father’ in favour of female empowerment, but by equating the father to death (all three male-leads are butchers on the literal and symbolic levels, and one of them is executed). The film’s critique of the father begs the question of its gender politics. As the film progresses, the rather superficial portrayal of women becomes obvious. There are only two female characters in the film, Fu’s wife and the nameless prostitute whose role is mainly that of a corpse except for one brief scene in Fu’s flashback. Both women are sex workers and both play a part in Fu’s misfortune. Fu’s anger and disgust at a cop who throws malicious insults at the prostitute’s dead body during an autopsy contrasts sharply to his subdued agony at the sight of his son’s corpse, revealing his need for a surrogate for emotional expression. In this scene, the helpless and silent body of the woman lies naked on the autopsy table like a court exhibit crying out for its vindication. The camera cuts between the cop pacing up and down the room and Fu’s anguished face while keeping the woman’s body in sight. In this and a subsequent scene, several high-angle shots capture the woman’s bruised body in full, followed by close-up shots of Fu cutting and stitching up the cuts. Fu’s brief conversation with the woman in flashback reveals the woman’s request for a ‘whole body’ in future, which means she knows
Allegory, Kinship, and Redemption 77
what fate will befall her, but has no way out. In Fu Bo, both women and children are powerless victims of a corrupt and chauvinistic sociopolitical order. Curiously, the film’s disempowerment of women and children also works to feminize the dysfunctional fathers when they, too, surrender to this order. The institution power given to them has turned them into living dead, and it is this very power that undoes the ‘fathers’ it begets. On an intertextual level, Fu Bo re-examines the narrative of the rebellious son since the Hong Kong New Wave and brings it forward to the existential wasteland of 1999/2003; the obsession with death and male impotence is characteristic of the social sentiment and cinematic imagination of the time; and the drama of lost potency set on the stage of pre-handover Macau tellingly suggests a common ground (fate) after the handover, which saw the eclipse of Hong Kong’s social and cultural superiority, together with its rebellious spirit, in the post-CEPA years.
Eros and ethos: Isabella In Isabella, Edmond Pang’s treatment of Macau on the eve of the political handover goes down a different path. Beginning exactly forty-seven days before the handover, the film tells the story of two drifters separated by age and gender. Ma Chun Shing (Chapman To Man-chak), a middle-aged police officer, is accosted by a teenage girl named Cheung Pik Yan (Isabella Leung Lok-sze) at a time when he is caught up with a series of police corruption scandals. After spending a night with a prostitute at home Shing wakes up to find Yan eating instant noodles in the living room. Yan keeps following Shing, giving him hints that she might be his illegitimate daughter. While incest is more a gimmick in the film to heighten suspense and sustain an atmosphere of erotic decadence, through a series of mishaps Shing and Yan find in each other strength and compassion to take responsibilities for their own lives. This rather straightforward plot would have made for a transparent moral lesson, but Isabella strays quite far away from cinema verite. Pang’s effort to go beyond moral education of his characters is evident in the romanticized vision of the colonial city, idealism in characterization, and self-conscious play with style, coincidences and intertextual references, all of which endow the film with a fairy tale-like quality. The film’s interest in sensual details at times can obscure its more thoughtprovocative elements. This aspect is not missed by critics pondering whether Pang is more concerned with stylistic flourishes than engaging thought through story-telling.14 In following the sojourns of Yan and
78
Time and Memory
Shing across Macau’s historic cityscape, the camera offers up colourful vignettes of the city’s colonial-style architecture and touristy scenery as if the city was blessed by an eternal summer, night and day. As a young director reputed for his penchant for commercial genrebending in such films as A.V./Qingchun meng gongchang (2005), Men Suddenly in Black/Da zhangfu (2003), and You Shoot, I Shoot/Mai xiong pai ren (2001), in Isabella Pang shows a determined effort to establish his arthouse credentials.15 There is, for instance, a tendency to eroticize and romanticize the incestuous relationship between Shing and Yan, an orphaned teenage girl and femme fatale-wannabe, while Yan is also seen as a redeeming force in Shing’s life. The ambivalence and vulnerability of their affectionate connection is visualized through a warm colour scheme (a combination of red, yellow, and bright green tones) occasionally punctuated by touches of darker shades and silhouettes. Compared to the claustrophobic spaces of mortality in Fu Bo, space in Isabella has an expansive and idyllic quality enlivened by harmless, though calculated, coincidences and comic reversals. For example, when Yan and Shing are out looking for Yan’s puppy (named after her mother, Isabella), Yan catches sight of a little girl walking with a dog at a distance, and soon realizes that Isabella has found a better owner. Yan resists the temptation to claim ownership; instead, after a passionate embrace, she bids farewell to the pet and the child. This scene takes place in a deserted alleyway on a bright summer day. The idyllic tranquillity of the mise-enscène temporarily insulates the two girls from the outside world as Yan quietly accepts the fate of losing Isabella, who so far serves as a living memory and link to her deceased mother. This brief episode turns out to be a turning point in the relationship between Yan and Shing, as Shing, perhaps still unaware, begins to take up his new role as a father. As the narrative unfolds, Shing’s fatherly self elevates him from a corrupt past to embrace genuine compassion. Close to the end, we see Shing looking into a mirror. He soon shaves off his moustache, his face revealing a calm composure. Beardless, Shing’s face emits a youthful air not seen before. Dressed in a clean suit for the first time in the film, he quietly rubs his face against Yan’s shoulder as they ride off to the court on a motorcycle. It seems that Shing and Yan’s roles have reversed once again—this time the father is in the care of the child. The concluding shot of this scene shows a pad of tears left on Yan’s shoulder. A smile on Yan’s face suggests she is aware of her new role in this relationship. The separation of father and child recalls Yan’s encounter with her puppy and its new owner much earlier on, but the overlap is more than a mere parallel. Yan’s rubbing her face against the puppy is repeated in Shing’s similar
Allegory, Kinship, and Redemption 79
gesture, but in both scenes Yan is the centre of gravity, as a maturing youth who has learned to accept the pain of losing a loved one to a better course. Renewal, it seems, is always premised on a bitter-sweet goodbye. The director’s sense of humour in playing up the visual pun of the father/puppy notwithstanding, the father being compared to a submissive, child-like ‘puppy’ also reunites him with the real Isabella (Yan’s mother) he deserted some eighteen years ago. In Isabella, the creation of the idyllic, fairy-tale landscape in the film is complemented by elements of comic romance. Almost standard features in Hong Kong’s action films, comic moments are usually inserted into high-octane action sequences through body movements and gestures, in-jokes, slapsticks, and black humour, reflecting an influence from earlier Cantonese cinema and Cantonese opera. In Isabella, the romantic tale between Yan and Shing is placed within a pseudo-police and gangster back story that propels the main action, from Shing’s initial moral bankruptcy to redemption through compassion, courage, and self-sacrifice. Yan’s initial appearance as a deviant youth and her deliberately contrived pretence as seductress and femme fatale enable many scenes of comic reversals. For instance, in a series of disconnected scenes Yan plays out her fantasy as Shing’s true love. In an attempt to persuade Shing’s numerous girlfriends to leave him, Yan assumes the air of an experienced woman as she lectures the others about life’s priorities. These shots are shown in sequence, each showing Yan acting out the same role as if they were discarded scenes or rehearsals. Dramatic irony is magnified since Yan’s secret is known to the viewer, and the self-reflexive artificiality of Yan’s role-play draws as much attention to her defiant immaturity as to the complex feelings of a teenage daughter towards the father. All this points to a conscious design by the director to align Shing and Yan, despite their age gap, in the same idealism associated not with childhood innocence but adolescence, symbolized by Yan’s slender body and budding sexuality quite explicitly conveyed in the numerous medium- and close-distance shots that emphasize the youthfulness of her face and body, especially her legs and feet. In one scene, Yan and Shing are seen walking along the waterfront chatting and teasing each other. The camera cuts from a medium tracking shot to a low-angle shot horizontal to the ground, showing Yan and Shing’s feet in plastic slippers. Shing walks off-screen to make space for a closeup on Yan’s feet, one of which is struggling to get back into a loosened slipper. All the while, their tête-à-tête goes on as background voice, but visually the bare legs and feet of Yan occupy the foreground, looking both sensuous and vulnerable. There are, as one critic comments, erotic
80
Time and Memory
overtones in the portrayal of Yan and her ambivalent attachment to Shing, an eroticism motivated by sexual fantasy of middle-aged men.16 This reading reveals another dimension of the film’s idealized vision of Macau: this idealism has to do with a deeper-running anxiety of the (male) subject caught up with an impending doom. As in Fu Bo, police corruption and involvement in triad-related crimes and violence are rampant in pre-handover Macau, and Shing as a smalltime cop deserted by both his police and triad associates epitomizes the uncertainty and demoralization of the colonial administration and Macau’s society as a whole on the eve of regime change. But unlike Fu Bo’s claustrophobic vision of mortality that envelops all, Isabella opts for comic reversal, a conscious artistic effort to lift its socially and emotionally doomed characters to an imaginary realm of summer romance, albeit one that is only partially insulated from intrusions by the much harsher realities of adulthood. Such a vision is indeed artificial, and the camera is fully aware of its presence as a guiding lens in numerous tracking shots, long takes, and wide-angle shots of Yan and Shing roaming deserted streets, alleyways, and beachside walkways of the city, whose old-style colonial architecture and cityscape emit a nostalgic flavour through the reflexive rays of sunlight in the day and chiaroscuros at night. Pang’s genre-bending interests make their imprint, too, in this style-conscious film. The characterization of Shing as a corrupt cop running out of luck and the back story of police corruption and illegal arms trade provide ample space for staging scenes of bar fights, secret meetings, backdoor bargaining, and chase-and-runs throughout the film. Generic conventions are also playfully engaged in the dialogues between Yan and her high-school classmate and admirer, in which Yan rather childishly imitates the speech and behaviour of a young triad as she speaks about the imaginary affair and elopement with Shing. Arguably, the configuration of Macau as a fin-de-siècle city is informed by a dual vision of doom and redemption through comic reversal, which can be seen as an artistic temperament inherited from Hong Kong’s commercial cinema tradition, especially romance and gangster films. While Pang’s Macau has been compared to Wong Kar-wai’s 1960s Hong Kong (which is also a version of pre-1949 Shanghai), the film’s most overt nostalgic reference to a bygone era—the 1980s—is Anita Mui’s early Canto-pop hit, ‘Dream Pal’ (Mung boon/Mengban), a song Yan sings from time to time in memory of her mother, Isabella, who allegedly was a fan of Mui. A big hit in its time, the song is about lost love and the memory of that loss in medium dance beat. The choice of this particular
Allegory, Kinship, and Redemption 81
song by Mui might well be a tribute to the queen of Canto-pop whose premature death in 2004 had been described as symbolic of the ‘end of an era’ by the local media. In the eyes of many Hong Kongers Mui remains the biggest icon of Hong Kong’s popular culture in the 1980s, and the reference to her song functions as a temporal and emotional link between Yan and her mother, Shing and his ex-lover, Shing and Yan, Shing and his own younger self, and perhaps the director and his own adolescence. In a scene when Yan and Shing are half-drunk dining at a local street stall, a nearby radio begins to play this song. Yan rises from the table and begins to dance and lip-synch Mui’s voice. A relatively light and non-sentimental piece from the golden era of Canto-pop and its biggest teen icon at her prime, ‘Dream Pal’ highlights the adolescent quality of Yan and Shing’s deepening bond while recalling the heyday of Hong Kong’s popular culture. This scene is tellingly followed by Shing teaching Yan an ad hoc lesson of the art of ‘cracking bottles’ on the heads of opponents during a fight, a direct reference to a ubiquitous feature in local gangster films. What accounts for the polar visions of Macau at a critical historical juncture in the two films? Do these contrasts also allow for a complementary reading of the fin-de-siècle imagination at the ‘end of history’? How do we understand the nostalgic invocation of Macau’s colonial cityscape in Isabella and how does it compare to the mortal spaces in Fu Bo? The contrastive visualizations of the city in the two films, as noted above, are informed by the common plot element of kinship embedded in the father–child relation. In Isabella the father–child relation is a redemptive force, while in Fu Bo it signifies the breakdown of kinship as a result of social and psychological disintegration; in both films the nature and meaning of kinship is not seen as mere blood relations but an act of will or the absence of will that may or may not be defined or contained by social/familial norms. In Fu Bo autopsy is ritualized as a bridge between the dead and the living, as a final tribute to the abused bodies of crime victims. Fu’s calm composure and ambivalent smile after his son’s autopsy implies neither redemption nor transcendence, but sublimation of otherwise blocked feelings and emotions. Little in the ending of the film suggests that things will be better; the rather lame sermon projected on-screen in the last shot reads more like an indirect admission of the exhaustion of positive energy, for having literally rejected the authority of the father and spiritual transcendence symbolized by Giu’s final acts, the sermon is left with little meaning. While Fu Bo’s critique of the father reverses the conventional representation of the patriarchal structuring of the father/son duo by looking
82
Time and Memory
at the afterlife of the disgruntled sons as failed fathers in middle age, Isabella restores an ageing father’s youthful energy and dignity through a comedy of errors, that is, by giving him a daughter that is not his biological offspring just when his life is falling apart. As the story unfolds, the power relation between Yan and Shing is also reversed, too, as Shing falls more into the role of the child in need of Yan’s nursing. After the opening bar fight recalling the Hong Kong gangster film, Shing’s role as a corrupt cop under siege by both sides of the law is gradually eclipsed by his new role as a novice in parenthood brought to confront the child within, and by a past he seems to have forgotten. Seen from this angle, Isabella, otherwise a drama of human relations, is akin to the Hong Kong action films discussed in the next section, in which the conventional cop- or gangster-hero undergoes a dramatic and critical reinvention. One can say that Isabella represents a selective hybridization of conventionalized cinematic vocabularies in Hong Kong cinema and probably a way-station in a young director’s journey of self-discovery, as Pang, too, seems to be making a conscious transition from the mainstream commercial cinema to more experimental films.17 Kinship, thus, runs through the two films not as something natural but, in Judith Butler’s words, performed.18 It is, therefore, an articulation of a subjective selfpositioning that reflects a certain social, cultural, and political stance. To take this line of logic further, the very discourse of kinship in the two films can be read as a wry comment on the meta-narrative of panChinese nationalism propagated by the Chinese and local authorities, an official ideology well-captured in the oft-quoted jargon, ‘blood is thicker than water’ (xie nong yu shui), an emotionally charged expression of patriotism based not on legal status or conviction but on race. The blood-stained hands of the fathers in Fu Bo and the surrender of the father’s authority through comic reversal in Isabella articulate alternative imaginations of kinship, whether positively or negatively, that call for a rethinking of the validity and implications of the official discourse.19 Curiously, both films play down on the role of the mother, by relegating her either to the stereotypical role of the victim or to a name-pun and memento that motivates the comedy of errors. I have mentioned how Fu Bo’s female stereotypes work to ‘mirror’ the impotence of the male characters. In Isabella, the ‘name of the mother’ is central to the identity confusion between mother and daughter, and also between the fictional character Yan and the real-life actress Isabella Leung on the part of the viewer, thus creating a circular movement of erotic desire within and outside the film text. The empowerment of Yan from an orphan exposed to sexual exploitations in a patriarchal society to an
Allegory, Kinship, and Redemption 83
independent, motherly figure is hung in precarious balance with her role as an object of desire and redemptive angel to Shing. This aspect of the film has raised critical concern over its misogynous and opportunistic treatment of women that is much harder to defend than the female stereotypes in Fu Bo. Whether a guilty pleasure or not, the film’s gender politics is symptomatic of a fin-de-siècle vision in retrospect, in the sense that the post-handover contemplation of the end of history in light of a cop’s mid-life crisis ineluctably duplicates the gender politics reminiscent of popular genre films in the 1980s and early 1990s, which usually favour predominantly masculine values.20 Seen in this light, Isabella, like its subject matter (a city going through a kind of mid-life crisis), is also a work in transition; it borrows, updates, and revises pre-existing representational modes to construct a vision of the (post-)colonial city as an orphan trying to redefine its own lineage. The ambivalence and categorical confusion of Yan and Shing’s relationship, therefore, can be better understood as the result of this transitoriness.
Conclusion In much of Hong Kong’s popular cinema, Macau is usually featured as an offshoot of the heroic action of Hong Kong characters. Fu Bo and Isabella are films made and released after the financial crisis that greatly damaged Hong Kong people’s pride and confidence in their city’s past achievements, especially when compared to Macau which had apparently outperformed Hong Kong since reunification.21 This closing gap between the two cities provided the impetus for a kind of congeniality in the collective imagination in the two films. Both films retain features and motifs reminiscent of Hong Kong cinema since the 1980s, that is, gangster threats and violence, police corruption, comic romance (in Isabella), and most of all masculinity in crisis, which is articulated through a gender politics that seeks to expose and/or salvage a father caught up in mid-life crisis. Kinship, or the father–child relation, is a site where all these various elements and forces are played out: Fu Bo’s mortal spaces are filled with macabre imagery, whose real terror lies in the psychological disintegration of individuals who cannot free themselves from a certain past. In the case of Fu and Giu, their sins are not forgiven (at least not by themselves) but sublimated in their final acts of submission—Giu to the executioner’s gun and Fu to his own surgical knife. Isabella, on the other hand, relieves Shing from his guilty conscience through comic reversal, which is made possible partly by a plot twist late in the story, and partly by a suspension of disbelief, a
84
Time and Memory
tacit agreement between the film text and the viewer on the desirability of a happy ending in the form of a socially acceptable heterosexual romance, be it real or imaginary. The resulting contrastive landscapes of Macau embody precisely two distinct ‘authorial intentions’ in their treatment of a common theme. In both films, kinship is at risk. The extreme alienation in Fu Bo and the idyllic romance in Isabella represent two responses to the crises of the fin-de-siècle and the nostalgic impulse thus triggered. The very choice of setting may be seen as a transposition of the nostalgic to another space, when the nostalgic is no longer chic in one’s hometown; yet, in both films Macau is not Hong Kong’s Other, but has a history of its own that is equally perplexing and scriptable. The different visions of Macau in these films prompt further reflections on the changed perception of relations between the two cities; their respective pasts, presents, and futures have to be rethought, too, on a coeval basis.
Part II Schizophrenia, Amnesia, and Cinephilia
This page intentionally left blank
4 Lost in the Cosmopolitan Crime Zone: Johnnie To’s Urban Legends
This chapter, together with Chapters 5 and 6, investigates the changing aesthetic of Hong Kong’s action cinema. In particular, it examines the recent productions by Johnnie To and his Milkyway Image Productions as representatives of a new aesthetic of police and gangster films, a major branch of Hong Kong’s action cinema since the 1980s. While the action film has played a central role in the internationalization of Hong Kong cinema since the days of Bruce Lee, the 1980s saw the emergence of a new type of action aesthetic that is closely connected to the political events leading up to the territory’s reintegration with Mainland China, an aesthetic steeped in a ‘crisis consciousness’ triggered by the awareness of impending doom and the fragmentation of time-honoured beliefs and traditions that used to inspire the cinematic imagination of kung fu and wuxia films. This new aesthetic is epitomized in John Woo’s ‘cinema of crisis’,1 which persistently portrays Hong Kong as a lawless city where violence and bloodshed erupt at random at any moment. As Chris Berry and Mary Farquhar observe, in John Woo’s films ‘Hong Kong is a city beset by extreme lawlessness and graphic violence’, where ‘[c]ompeting regimes of justice merge’.2 Such a vision of the city on the verge of a material and cultural disappearance is symptomatic of a nostalgia for the lost time and lost values of the traditional jianghu, the idealized world of the wuxia where good and evil have relatively well-defined parameters, and the heroic virtues of loyalty, brotherhood, and justice are actively engaged in the resolution of conflicts and restoration of the moral order. While John Woo’s ‘hero film’ has played a key role in shaping Hong Kong action cinema thematically and stylistically, from the mid-1990s on there have been major revisions to the flamboyance and romanticism of Woo’s aesthetics. In this regard, Johnnie To is arguably the next action film director to ascend to the status of an auteur after Woo with a corpus 87
88
Schizophrenia, Amnesia, and Cinephilia
of works that exemplify a deconstructive aesthetic as they revisit the genre’s legacy. Existing writing on To’s work gives credit to his ability to balance aesthetic innovation with commercial considerations, especially his effort in reinvigorating the action genre through self-reflexive parody and experimentation.3 This chapter examines manifestations of the postnostalgic in To’s action aesthetic, that is, a critical re-engagement with time past through displacement and reinterpretation of generic conventions. My discussion is organized around three inter-related traits of To’s work: (1) the eclipse of the individualistic, romantic hero by the professional ethic of the group that emphasizes flexibility, mobility, efficiency, and the protection of the group; yet this kind of ‘corporatism’ is also shown to be vulnerable and problematic; (2) the construction of an urban space where order and chaos are purely contingent and coincidental, where human agency is less defined by individual (heroic) qualities than by desire and circumstance; and (3) the de-rationalization of both the group and the hero’s existential and moral claims through a ‘negative fantasy’ in which heroism is synonymous with madness. To’s use of the urban space echoes that of Ann Hui and Fruit Chan in its frequent invocations of historical and personal memory; yet To’s artistic vision also generates nuanced references to certain fantastic and romantic elements of Hong Kong’s action cinema. The mix of cinematic realism and fantasy thus conjures up a unique film city—an existential landscape in which the parameters of action, and lack of action, are redrawn. In the following, I begin by situating To’s films within the permutations of the action film as a struggle with its own memory, both in the form of an emotional attachment to the local cultural tradition and an astute awareness of the genre’s need to reinvent itself amidst changing conditions of the local film industry. The changing facets of the action hero provide a vantage point for an assessment of To’s nuanced relationship with the local filmmaking conventions. More specifically, I take a closer look at the two poles of To’s vision of the group in The Mission/Qiang huo (1999) and Exiled/Fang zhu (2006), which raises the possibility of reading To’s ‘break’ from the past as a dialogic gesture that seeks out new ground not by resolving, but embracing ambivalences and contradictions. This preoccupation is staged in a different register in PTU (2003), in which the group’s activities are used as anchor points for the camera to map out a defamiliarized urban space as a mode of visual cognition through which the city returns in the form of familiar signs in a new configuration, hence resisting disappearance. The last film
Lost in the Cosmopolitan Crime Zone
89
discussed is Mad Detective/Shen tan (2007), another breakthrough from the stylistic experiments since Mission. My reading of To’s films suggests that action, and the attributes of heroism thereof, is produced out of the tensions between cinematic nostalgia and contemporaneity, between a sense of identity anchored in the local filmmaking tradition and the urgency of self-reinvention against the chaotic flux of the present. The radical re-envisioning of the hero and heroism as a form of madness, seen in this light, sheds important light on how much this tension has impacted the creative minds of the Milkyway crew.
Heroism, group identity, and ‘corporatism’: The Mission and Exiled From the mid-1990s on, many Hong Kong action films have shown a growing interest in probing the limits of 1980s-style heroism popularized by John Woo, who has come to represent the so-called ‘hero films’ in Hong Kong cinema since A Better Tomorrow/Yingxiong bense I & II (1986, 1987). Woo’s ‘cinema of crisis’ signifies an important landmark in the development of the action genre, and by extension an aesthetic response to the versatile political and social realities of Hong Kong in the 1980s and 1990s closely associated with the nostalgic, finde-siècle apprehension of the ‘end of (colonial) history’. However, since the mid-1990s there have been efforts by other Hong Kong filmmakers to downplay the heroic prototype in favour of less idealized, more psychologically and morally conflicted characters struggling to survive the challenge of the moment. The countdown to the change of sovereignty further facilitated this critical reflection as filmmakers sought to look beyond the 1997 deadline for new articulations of the local. Meanwhile, the decline of the local film industry beginning in 1993 continued throughout the decade. Market depression deepened as a result of the Asian financial crisis in 1997–1998, and the already pervasive pessimism grew more pronounced during the SARS pandemic in 2003. Thus the mid-1990s to the first half of the 2000s was a time of enduring crisis for both Hong Kong society and its cinema, a time when filmmakers struggled to maintain morale and creativity in local productions.4 As far as the action film is concerned, there was an obvious effort to reinvent itself through a self-reflexive revisiting of its own legacy. These explorations into new possibilities were also a function of the shortening life cycle of popular trends in the mainstream cinema5 and the domination of Hollywood productions in the domestic market. The deconstruction of the hero and heroic individualism (e.g. Wai Ka-fai’s
90
Schizophrenia, Amnesia, and Cinephilia
Too Many Ways to Be No. I/Yige zitou de dansheng, 1998) undermines the agency of the central characters in controlling their own fate. A shifting emphasis from the individualistic hero to the group was also an emerging trend that gained momentum in the wake of the new millennium. In this ‘deconstructive’ aesthetic, loyalty to an entrenched patriarchal tradition, usually symbolized by a father figure, is replaced by a more dynamic, forward looking, and flexibly managed collectivity defined by a relational network, or the group (e.g. Gordon Chan’s First Option/Fei hu, 1996, Johnnie To’s Lifeline/Shiwan huoji, 1997, and The Mission, 1999). Johnnie To’s Milkyway films offer a palette of such deconstructions.6 For example, Expect the Unexpected/Feichang turan (1998) subjects a team of police officers to a cruel twist of fate. Lifeline is entirely devoted to the creation of a group identity (firemen) as an embodiment of the heroic in everyday life without any resort to the good/evil binary. The group is a professional unit, a collective ‘whole’ bonded by a certain work ethic, be it strictly or loosely defined. In these films, crises are moments that put the group as a whole to test. In Expect the Unexpected the group falls apart when it is engrossed in a gunfight completely unprepared by a heavily armed gang, while Lifeline celebrates the group spirit only in a low-keyed and matter-of-fact ending, when the fire-fighters are ordered back to their duties in heavy rain not long after a heroic rescue mission. Inspired by Kurosawa’s Seven Samurai, To experiments with a kind of ‘motion in stillness’ in The Mission.7 The film privileges the group (five bodyguards) over the authority of the father figure (the triad gang boss), as it evolves from an emotionally detached mechanical operation into an organic community bonded by a deep sense of brotherhood. On the other hand, their professionalism (visible through the immaculate dark suits and extremely efficient, target-oriented teamwork) opts for flexible solutions to defend the status and authority of the boss without obeying his order to execute one of their own (see below). This flexible ‘group philosophy’ extends further into To’s later police stories, PTU and Breaking News/Da shijian (2004), and gangster films, Election/Heishehui and Election II/Heishehui zhi yi he wei gui (2005, 2006). In these films, the group, be it a police unit or a triad society, exhibits a corporate spirit that emphasizes the need to survive in an increasingly versatile, crisis-stricken, and business-oriented world. Here, heroism is repeatedly sidestepped by professionalism, emphasizing self-/group preservation, operational efficiency, and shrewd and unscrupulous decision-making. If the Woo-style hero film dramatizes the heroic act as a spectacle in and for itself, in To’s films there is a movement away from
Lost in the Cosmopolitan Crime Zone
91
action-as-spectacle to action as a part of, if not subsumed under, an unfolding psychological drama. Stephen Teo (2007) observes important changes in the hero figure in To’s films, from the ‘fatalistic hero’ who seeks out his vengeful destiny to a more problematic type characterized by physical and/or psychological disabilities. Calling To an ‘uneven auteur’, Teo sees in the filmmaker an urge to go in different directions that both enriches and impairs his art.8 To’s ‘unevenness’ obviously is behind his binary vision of the group in The Mission and Exiled, the latter being a stylistic and thematic elaboration of the earlier film. My analysis of the two films below demonstrates how these films represent the two poles of To’s still evolving vision of the ‘group hero’. In these films, I argue, the repetition of visual and thematic motifs works towards a mutual critique of the respective vision of the group and its moral and symbolic meanings each film seeks to articulate, and eventually undermine.
The Mission If Kurosawa’s Seven Samurai was a key inspiration for The Mission, especially the controlled and stylized choreography of the shooting scenes, hence ‘motion-in-stillness’, the film also shows a high degree of self-awareness in adapting the visual language of Kurosawa to reenvision a specific local terrain, the jianghu (underworld), reworking the themes of brotherhood and loyalty within a patriarchal hierarchy in a contemporary urban setting where male bonds are more defined by team spirit rather than pre-determined by some higher moral or social order. As mentioned above, the flexible group philosophy outsmarts the patriarchal law of the (god)father Lung (Eddie Ko) when he orders the execution of Shin (Jackie Lui Chung-yin), a junior member, after the latter’s affair with his wife has been exposed. In the tradition of the jianghu, such transgression is a cardinal sin for which death is the non-negotiable penalty. However, in To’s film the godfather, though commanding respect in general, is a patriarch not quite well in command of things. From beginning to end he is under attack by unseen assassins at the same time his sexual power is being eroded. In the film, Lung’s gang leader image is dented by acts of weakness and domesticity: he is seen hiding inside a refrigerator during a shootout and making coffee for his bodyguards in the morning. These softer edges perhaps explain why his has been a target of sabotage by Fat Cheung (Wong Tin-lam), a senior member and co-founder of the triad society. To protect himself and hunt down the culprit, Lung calls upon his former
92
Schizophrenia, Amnesia, and Cinephilia
number-one aide, Curtis (Anthony Wong Chau-sang), to head a team of five bodyguards. It turns out that Curtis, a low-keyed and cool-headed character, becomes the true mastermind behind the scene: he successfully mediates tensions among his subordinates, build a cohesive and highly organized team out of rivals, and finally rescues one of his own by outwitting his boss. Teo remarks that Curtis, though a role model for his teammates, is also a ‘feminine’ figure, an attribute subtly suggested in his passive submission to a wrongful accusation and beating by his own man, Roy (Francis Ng). Ironically, Curtis’ feminine virtues save the group from disintegration and eventually consolidate his leadership. Loyalty in this film is less a marker of absolute difference between the good and the bad, the traitor and the betrayed than a flexible code of practice that aims to dissolve tension and crises, and to create a ‘win-win situation’ for all. Instead of celebrating lone heroes, the film’s interest is more in tune with the evolving male bond, which resembles that of a Boy Scout or youth soccer team, a motif to be repeated with a nihilistic twist in Exiled. Mission’s lightest touches are found in a scene where the five bodyguards, all professional hit men on duty, start a paper soccer game to kill time as they wait rather impatiently outside Lung’s office. The pleasure of this 1.5-minute scene for the viewer is both visual and psychological. On the one hand, the scene is a carefully choreographed performance by the actors. It shows, within a very compact space (a narrow passageway in the boss’ office), the guards kicking a paper soccer ball back and forth with exceptional skill and precision. Body movement here is restricted to kicking and holding the ball, while the bodyguards remain immobile in their respective positions throughout. Except for a couple of close-ups on Curtis and Roy, the scene is primarily captured by a static camera placed close to the ground. Completely without dialogue, the ‘soccer game’ visually echoes the gunplay sequences that immediately precede it. On the other hand, the incongruity between the guards’ mission, the mundane office setting, the appearance of the bodyguards (all in immaculate dark suits and shiny leather shoes), and the frivolity of the soccer game provides temporary comic relief from the tension of the main action. This scene also is significant to the film’s diegesis, for it marks the completion of the team by showing an almost seamless integration and cooperation among the guards, with Curtis overseeing the whole process as their coach and caretaker. More importantly, the visual overlap between the soccer game and the gunfights serves as a footnote remark on how the aesthetic of the two can be interpreted through a ‘boy-scout’ thematic.
Lost in the Cosmopolitan Crime Zone
93
Though less elegant and formalistically conceived than other action sequences, the soccer scene is a stylistic analogue to the ‘shopping mall scene’ (the film’s centrepiece gunfight) that immediately precedes it. Escorting Lung back home from office, the five guards and some unknown hit men cross-fire inside a deserted shopping mall. Instead of explosive action, To keeps body movement to the minimal. This is a technique that To would repeatedly employ in his subsequent films, and one that fully exposes his preoccupation with the tension between action and inaction, and the visuality of stillness as a form of action. Other than stylistic considerations, the absence of dialogue reinforces the deepening bond of the guards, who can now act in unison in complete silence. (As we shall see, in Exiled, To seems to be working with a ‘split consciousness’. The stylized gunplay and controlled tempo of Mission alternates with improvisatorial acting/directing in developing a scene.) This boy-scout thematic, however, also exposes its own gender politics—by revealing the way in which male bonds operate in a sexless, claustrophobic world that excludes non-members, especially the other sex. Laikwan Pang observes that this bond is broken by the intrusion of the femme fatale figure, the wife of the boss.9 In a patriarchal order, sexual transgression is not to be tolerated; yet, the punishment is not equally apportioned, for in Mission only the woman is executed, not her male co-defendant. Perhaps this drawback in the film’s gender representation is a reflection of how a certain ‘generic imagination’ operates in To’s creative dialogue with conventions. In Mission, as well as his other ‘all-boys’ films, women are usually relegated to stereotypical roles and are usually treated as obstacles or threats to male bonding. However, just as To has subtly displaced some feminine traits on to the character of Curtis (and the godfather) in Mission, his awareness of this ‘gender imbalance’ is made more emphatic in films that showcase powerful women as active agents taking charge of their own lives, thus initiating what Pang calls a new phase of Milkyway’s woman-centred films (mainly urban romance) as a response to changing audience demographics and to a possible ‘exhaustion’ of creativity in the male-oriented action films.10 An exception in this category, however, is noted in Breaking News, where the heroine, a woman superintendent played by Kerry Chan, is portrayed as a cool-headed, no-nonsense career woman who outsmarts all her male peers in playing the corporate game. In an almost fantastic register, To has his heroine mastermind a massive media event to turn into a publicity victory a badly handled mishap involving a few armed Mainland criminals. Yet, To’s more ‘experimental’ films remain
94
Schizophrenia, Amnesia, and Cinephilia
focused on the dynamics of male bonding, a subject which continues to inform his more ‘auteurist’ work in the post-1997 period. While scepticism towards gender stereotyping may not be easily dispelled, a self-reflective/self-reflexive critique is noticeable in the boyscout ethic of the group movies. This critique also works on the intertextual level. Teo’s analysis of the film shows that To’s self-awareness of his ‘mission’ explains the tendency towards ‘meta-criticism’ in his films, hence the built-in extra-textual self-references to and critical rethinking of genre conventions and themes, such as violence, masculinity, and the nature and purpose of action.11 In this scene the action takes place in an empty shopping mall, but ‘action’ is limited to subtle body movements: the gunmen remain virtually immobile, making only slight adjustments to their posture as they hide behind pillars most of the time. The whole scene is rendered through alternating medium shots and close-ups. The medium shots capture the topography of the gunfight as the hit men, as a group, freeze, aim, and fire at precise angles. The close-ups on the guards and the assassins give further accent to the individual poses, emphasizing intensity and concentration rather than action per se. Visually, this scene resembles a multi-player video game, positioning the viewer more or less like an anonymous player off-screen (though rather passive without a gun); yet the camera movement allows us an omniscient view of the topography of the gunfight as it pans and cuts between the gunmen, both the camera and the players displaying a high degree of self-awareness of the act of shooting as performance. The mise-en-scène thus exhibits an intricate geometry of the gunfight, the spatial constraints of the shopping mall arcade being manipulated to such an extent that the form of the fight and the form of the human figures become the very content of the narrative. This and other highly stylized action sequences constitute the key visual motif of the film, infusing the narrative with a kind of theatricality to be taken up in two subsequent films discussed later in this chapter, Exiled and PTU. This also is part of To’s continuous effort to create a new cinematic vocabulary that synthesizes old and new forms. Apparently a brief ‘time out’ for the guards and the audience, the ‘soccer scene’ lets loose a spirit of the group as an all-boy team, a recurrent motif in To’s later film, Exiled. It not only prefigures the ‘happy ending’ and the triumph of the group, but also casts a different light on their mission, for it is not so much about serving a righteous course as about playing a good game that everybody enjoys. Indeed, the parallelism of the soccer game and co-ordinated gunplay in the shopping mall enhances the metaphoricity of both—they are part of
Lost in the Cosmopolitan Crime Zone
95
the film’s rhetoric, a conscious play with semblance and dissemblance on that very same stage of action-in-inaction. Can this be understood as the film’s lighter ‘mission’ as well? By diffusing allegorical heroism into more or less identical constituents of a professional unit—we can call it a troupe of professional hit men-as-players—the new To-style action-drama elevates visual pleasure to a thematic level through an eclectic and self-conscious play with pre-existing and emerging signs and references in contemporary visual culture. Exiled Released in 2006, Exiled tells the story of five hit men balancing the impossible demands of loyalty, brotherhood, desire, and individual survival. The story takes place in Macau on the eve of the ex-Portuguese colony’s return to China in 1999. This choice of setting strongly echoes Fu Bo and Isabella, which, as suggested in Chapter 3, may be a signal of a changing perception of Macau in Hong Kong’s cultural imagination. Stylistically and thematically varied, these films show an interest in Macau as a city in flux, something like a shared history between the two ex-colonial cities. Although this is not To’s first film to have a Macau element (c.f. The Longest Nite/An hua, a.k.a. Dark Flowers, 1998), Exiled is more clearly a re-staging of To’s group aesthetic in Mission in a different setting. At first glance the film recalls Mission in some significant ways. The beginning of the film is actually a continuation of where Mission leaves off—Blaze (Anthony Wong) is under his boss’ order to eliminate a traitor, and the hit men who subsequently appear are played by almost the same cast with the exception of Shin, now replaced by Wo (Nicholas Cheung Ka-fai). Thematically, there is emphasis on the collective identity of the group, the conflict between group survival and loyalty to a patriarch figure (the godfather) who can kill at will or whim, and the homosocial male bond threatened by a subversive female figure: Wo’s wife, Jin (Josie Ho). Although To has employed what he calls a more ‘liberal’ approach in Exiled, saying at an interview that he has shot the film ‘without a script’,12 the opening sequence of the hit men’s encounter contains explicit references to their ‘look’ in the previous film: their dark suits and trench coats, slow-paced and rhythmic body movements, conscious posing before the camera are typical of To’s group-protagonist. As in Mission, the movement of the group is laid out in a geometrical pattern, captured here in high-angle and tracking shots at varying degrees and distances that position these dark figures against the architectural contours of historic buildings, deserted streets and boulevards, and carefully partitioned interior spaces in multi-coloured tones.
96
Schizophrenia, Amnesia, and Cinephilia
The opening scene has two hit men, Tai (Francis Ng) and Cat (Roy Cheung), knocking at the door of an old apartment. The brief conversation between Wo’s wife and the two men asking to see Wo in reverse shots is followed by a parallel sequence, in which two other hit men, Blaze and Fat (Lam Suet), repeat the same ritual in almost identical manner. The two pairs meet downstairs, exchange glances, and stop under a tree. The short dialogue that follows establishes their antagonistic positions. Blaze’s pair is out to kill Wo on an execution order, while Tai vows to save Wo at all costs. It transpires that the four men were childhood friends and under the employ of Boss Fay (Simon Yam). This encounter is interrupted by Wo’s arrival. Wo, Fai, and Blaze walk into the building in silence and start a gunfight almost immediately. The choreography of the gunfight recalls the shopping mall scene in Mission with a difference. While each party occupies a specific spot in the mise-en-scène, slow motion is used to space out the three men as they shoot at their targets at much closer distance, utilizing doors, curtains, and partitions as shields. There is also a more emphatic use of gun smoke to obtain a hazier image, an obvious departure from the crisp, clearly delineated contours of Mission. However, the topography of the gunfight remains a central preoccupation of the camera, which cuts between different positions to follow the bullet tracks, fully aware of the dramatic tension and excitement created by spatial constraints. This sensitivity towards space, especially compact indoor space, and movement in and across space harks back to earlier kung fu and martial arts films that To was first trained in. In this scene, however, To’s camera is not pursuing the acrobatic skills of the fighters-in-space as usually seen in standard kung fu movies, but the image of a fight launched in an empty apartment that offers virtually no protection or way out. This intention is made apparent when the three men equalize the number of bullets in their guns, a gesture that contradicts their ‘mission’: to kill and to survive the killing. Yet, their action is in tune with the soccer scene and the rule of fair play. Considering this unrealistic ‘game’ is also motivated by the players’ childhood friendship, the ensuing gunfight enacts the tension between nostalgia for lost innocence and the simultaneous desire to finish the game with no foul play. To’s aesthetic imprint is hard to miss in this first gunplay in the film. The staging presents the gunfight within a geometrical pattern that calls attention to itself, enhanced by a bold colour