Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 108 HETEROGENEOUS CATALYSIS AND FINE CHEMICALS IV
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis Advisory Editors: B. Delmon and J.T. Yates Vol.108
HETEROGENEOUS CATALYSIS AND FINE CHEMICALS IV Proceedings of the 4th International Symposium on Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals, Basel, Switzerland, September 8-12,1996
Editors H.U.BIaser Ciba-GeigyAG, Basel, Switzerland A. Baiker ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland R. Prins ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
1997 ELSEVIER Amsterdam — Lausanne — New York — Oxford — Shannon — Tokyo
ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. Sara Burgerhartstraat25 P.O. Box 211,1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
ISBN 0-444-82390-5 © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elsevier Science B.V., Copyright & Permissions Department, PO. Box 521,1000 AM Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Special regulations for readers in the U.S.A. - This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923. Information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the U.S.A. All other copyright questions, including photocopying outside of the U.S.A.,should be referredtothecopyrlghtowner,ElsevierScienceB.V.,unlessotherwisespecifled. No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Printed in The Netherlands
Contents Foreword Scientific Committee Organizing Committee Financial Support
XIII XIV XIV XV
Industrial and Engineering Problems 1
2 3
4
5
6
7
Homogeneous catalysis for fine chemicals synthesis - new trends and perspectives M. Beller Catalysis for agrochemicals: the case history of the DUAL herbicide R.R. Bader, H.U. Blaser Heterogeneous vs. homogeneous catalysis in manufacturing of terbinafine - a case study for route selection of an industrial process U. Beutler, C. Fleury, P.C. Fimfschilling, G. Penn, Th. Ryser, B. Schenkel Multiple use of palladium in a homogeneous and a consecutive heterogeneous catalytic reaction P. Baumeister, W. Meyer, K. Oertle, G. Seifert, U. Siegrist, H. Steiner The optimization of the catalytic hydrogenation of hydroxybenzamidines to benzamidines M.G. Scaros, P.K. Yonan, S.A. Laneman Catalytic hydrogenation reactors for the fine chemicals industries; their design and operation K.R. Westerterp, E.J. Molga, K.B. van Gelder Selective catalytic hydrogenation of 2-butyne-l,4-diol to c/y-2-butene1,4-diol in mass transfer efficient slurry reactors J.M. Winterbottom, H. Marwan, J. Viladevall, S. Sharma, S. Raymahasay
1 17
31
37
41
47
59
Alkylation andAcylation Reactions 8
9
10 11
Replacing liquid acids infinechemical synthesis by sulfonated polysiloxanes as solid acids and as acidic supports for precious metal catalysts St. Wieland, P. Panster Amine functions linked to MCM-41-type silicas as a new class of solid base catalysts for condensation reactions M. Lasperas, T. Llorett, L. Chaves, I. Rodriguez, A. Cauvel, D. Brunei Modified clay catalysts for acylation of crown compounds S. Bekassy, K. Biro, T. Cseri, B. Agai, F. Figueras Acylation of aromatics over a HBEA Zeolite; effect of solvent and of acylating agent F. Jayat, M.J. Sabater Picot, D. Rohan, M. Guisnet
67
75 83
91
12 13
14
15 16
17
18
Zeolite-catalysed acetylation of alkenes with acetic anhydride K. Smith, Zhao Zhenhua, L. Delaude, P.K.G. Hodgson Influence of the acidity and of the pore structure of zeolites on the alkylation of toluene by 1-heptene P. Magnoux, A. Mourran, S. Bernard, M. Guisnet Reductive O- and N-alkylations; alternative catalytic methods to nucleophilic substitution F. Fache, V. Bethmont, L. Jacquot, F. Valot, A. Milenkovic, M. Lemaire N-Methylation of aniline over AIPO4 and AlP04-metal oxide catalysts F.M. Bautista, J.M. Campelo, A. Garcia, D. Luna, J.M. Marinas, A.A. Romero Preparation of symmetrical and mixed secondary alkylamines over Raney nickel and supported copper catalysts S. Gobolos, M. Hegedus, E. Talas, J.L. Margitfalvi Synthesis of dimethylethylamine from ethylamine and methanol over copper catalysts Y. Pouilloux, V. Doidy, S. Hub, J. Kervennal, J. Barrault Catalyst acid/base properties regulation to control the selectivity in gasphase methylation of catechol L. Kiwi-Minsker, S. Porchet, R. Doepper, A. Renken
99
107
115 123
131
139
149
Enantio- and Diastereoselective Hydrogenation Reactions 19
20
21
22
23
24
25
Enantioselective hydrogenation of ethyl-pyruvate and isophorone over modified Pt and Pd catalysts A. Tungler, K. Fodor, T. Mathe, R.A. Sheldon Controlling the enantioselective hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate using zeolites as catalyst support K. Morgenschweis, E. Polkiehn, W. Reschetilowski Kinetic modeling of the ligand accelerated catalysis in the enantioselective hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate; influence of solvents, catalysts and additives H.U. Blaser, D. Imhof, M. Studer Modeling of kinetically coupled selective hydrogenation reactions: kinetic rationalization of pressure effects on enantioselectivity J. Wang, C. LeBlond, C.F. Orella, Y. Sun, J.S. Bradley, D.G. Blackmond Enantioselective hydrogenation of (£)-a-phenylcinnamic acid on cinchonidine-modified palladium catalysts: influence of support Y. Nitta, K. Kobiro, Y. Okamoto Enantio-differentiating hydrogenation of 3-alkanones with asymmetrically modified fine nickel powder T. Osawa, T. Harada, A. Tai, O. Takayasu, I. Matsuura Diastereoselective hydrogenation of a prostaglandin intermediate over Ru supported on different molecular sieves F. Cocu, S. Coman, C. Tanase, D. Macovei, V.I. Parvulescu
157
167
175
183
191
199
207
Vll
26
27
Diastereoselective hydrogenation of substituted aromatics on supported rhodium catalysts: influence of support and of thermal treatment M. Besson, P. Gallezot, C. Pinel, S. Neto Stereoselective reductions of aromatic compounds E. Auer, A. Freund, P. Panster, G. Stein, Th. Tacke
215 223
Chemoselective Hydrogenation Reactions 28 29
30
31
32 33 34
35
36
37
38
39
Selective reduction of nitro groups in aromatic azo compounds M. Lauwiner, R. Roth, P. Rys, J. Wissmann Selective catalytic hydrogenation of 2,4-dinitrotoluene to nitroarylhydroxylamines on supported metal catalysts M.G. Musolino, C. Milone, G. Neri, L. Bonaccorsi, R. Pietropaolo, S. Galvagno Kinetics and pathways of selective hydrogenation of l-(4-nitrobenzyl)1,2,4-triazole C. LeBlond, J. Wang, R.D. Larsen, C.J. Orella, A.L. Forman, F.P. Gortsema, T.R. Verhoeven, Y.-K. Sun Design of selective l-ethyl-2-nitromethylenepyrrolidine hydrogenation for pharmaceuticals production V.A. Semikolenov, I.L. Simakova, A.V. Golovin, O.A. Burova, N.M. Smimova Kinetic study of a nitroaliphatic compound hydrogenation V. Dubois, G. Jannes, P. Verhasselt Kinetics of the hydrogenation of citral over supported Ni catalyst P. Maki-Arvela, L.-P. Tiainen, R. Gil, T. Salmi Selective hydrogenation of a,p-unsaturated aldehydes to allylic alcohols over supported monometallic and bimetallic Ag catalysts P. Glaus, P. Kraak, R. Schodel Surface organometallic chemistry on metals; selective hydrogenation of acetophenone on modified rhodium catalyst F. Humblot, M.A. Cordonnier, C. Santini, B. Didillon, J.P. Candy, J.M. Basset Use of Ni containing anionic clay minerals as precursors of catalysts for the hydrogenation of nitriles D. Tichit, F. Medina, R. Durand, C. Mateo, B. Coq, J.E. Sueiras, P. Salagre The effect of co-adsorbates on activity/selectivity in the hydrogenation of aromatic alkynes S.D. Jackson, H. Hardy, G.J. Kelly, L.A. Shaw Simple preparation of bimetallic palladium-copper catalysts for selective liquid phase semihydrogenation of functionalized acetylenes and propargylic alcohols M.P.R. Spee, D.M. Grove, G. van Koten, J.W. Geus Catalytic hydrogenation by polymer stabilized rhodium G.W. Busser, J.G. van Ommen, J.A. Lercher
231
239
247
255 263 273
281
289
297
305
313 321
Oxidation Reactions 40 41
42
43
44
45 46
47
48
49
50
51
52
Epoxidation of cycloalkenones over amorphous titania-silica aerogels R. Hutter, T. Mallat, A. Baiker Selective aerobic epoxidation of olefins over NaY and NaZSM-5 zeolites containing transition metal ions O. Kholdeeva, A.V. Tkachev, V.N. Romannikov, I.V. Khavrutskii, K.I. Zamaraev Effect of preparation methods of titania/silicas on their catalytic activities in the oxidation of olefins M. Toba, S. Niwa, H. Shimada, F. Mizukami Heterogeneous catalysts from organometallic precursors: how to design isolated, stable and active sites; applications to zirconium catalyzed organic reactions A. Choplin, B. Coutant, C. Dubuisson, P. Leyrit, C. McGill, F. Quignard, R. Teissier Selective sulfoxidation of thioethers on Ti-containing zeolites under mild conditions V. Hulea, P. Moreau, F. Di Renzo AUylic oxidation of cyclohexene catalysed by metal exchanged zeolite Y O.B. Ryan, D.E. Akporiaye, K.H. Holm, M. Stocker Ammoxidation of methylaromatics over NH/-containing vanadium phosphate catalysts - new mechanistic insights A. Martin, A. Bruckner, Y. Zhang, B. Liicke Hydrogen peroxide oxidation of methyl a-D-glucopyranoside, sucrose and a,a-trehalose with Ti-MCM-41 E.J.M. Mombarg, S.J.M. Osnabrug, F. van Rantwijk, H. van Bekkum On the role of bismuth-based alloys in carbon-supported bimetallic Bi-Pd catalysts for the selective oxidation of glucose to gluconic acid M. Wenkin, C. Renard, P. Ruiz, B. Delmon, M. Devillers Selective oxidation of 5-hydroxymethylfurfural to 2,5-furandicarboxaldehyde in the presence of titania supported vanadia catalysts C. Moreau, R. Durand, C. Pourcheron, D. Tichit Dehydrogenation of methoxyisopropanol to methoxyacetone on supported bimetallic Cu-Zn catalysts M.V. Landau, S.B. Kogan, M. Herskowitz Butadione synthesis by dehydrogenation and oxidative dehydrogenation of 2,3-butanediol G.V. Isagulyants, LP. Belomestnykh Phase transition of crystalline a-Te2Mo07 to the vitreous P-form, surface composition, and activity in the vapor-phase selective oxidation of ethyl lactate to pyruvate over TeOj-MoOj catalysts H. Hayashi, S. Sugiyama, T. Moriga, N. Masaoka, A. Yamamoto
329
337
345
353
361 369
377
385
391
399
407
415
421
53
Selective oxidation with air of glyceric to hydroxypyruvic acid anu tartronic to mesoxalic acid on PtBi/C catalysts P. Fordham, M. Besson, P. Gallezot
429
Immobilized and Encapsulted Complex Catalysts 54 55
56 57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
PDMS occluded Ti-MCM-41 as an improved olefin epoxidation catalyst I.F.J. Vankelecom, N.M.F. Moens, K.A.L. Vercmysse, R.F. Parton, P.A. Jacobs Epoxidation with manganese N,N*-bis(2-pyridinecarboxamide) complexes encapsulated in Zeolite Y P.P. Knops-Gerrits, M. L'abbe, P.A. Jacobs Selective oxidation of benzyl alcohol on a zeolite ship-in-a-bottle complex A. Zsigmond, F. Notheisz, Z. Prater, J.E. Backvall Oxidation of pinane using zeolite encapsulated metal phthalocyanine catalysts A.A. Valente, J. Vital Hydrogenation of carbonyl groups containing compounds over Pt(II)-salen complexes occluded in zeolites W. Kahlen, A. Janssen, W.F. Holderich Novel clay intercalated metal catalysts: a study of the hydrogenation of styrene and 1-octene on clay intercalated Pd catalysts A. Mastalir, F. Notheisz, Z. Kiraly, M. Bartok, I. Dekany Catalytic enantioselective addition of diethylzinc to benzaldehyde induced by immobilized ephedrine: comparison of silica and MCM-41 type mesoporous silicates as supports N. Bellocq, D. Brunei, M. Lasperas, P. Moreau The immobilization of sulfonated Ru-BINAP chloride by anion exchange on layered double hydroxides D. Tas, D. Jeanmart, R.F. Parton, P.A. Jacobs Regiospecific hydrosilylation of styrene by rhodium complexes heterogenised on modified USY-zeolites A. Corma, M.I. de Dies, M. Iglesias, F. Sanchez Polymer-supported Al and Ti species as catalysts for Diels-Alder reactions B. Altava, M.I. Burguete, J.M. Fraile, J.I. Garcia, S.V. Luis, J.A. Mayoral, A.J. Royo, R.V. Salvador Molecular imprinting; polymerised catalytic complexes in asymmetric catalysis F. Locatelli, P. Gamez, M. Lemaire Environmentally friendly catalysis of liquid phase organic reactions using chemically modified mesoporous materials A.J. Butterworth, J.H. Clark, A. Lambert, D.J. Macquarrie, S.J. Tavener
437
445 453
461
469
477
485
493
501
509
517
523
Zeolite and Clay Catalysts 66
67
68
69 70
71 72
73 74
75
76
77
Meerwein-Ponndorf-Verley and Oppenauer reactions catalysed by heterogeneous catalysts E.J. Creyghton, J. Huskens, J.C. van der Waal, H. van Bekkum Selective synthesis of monoglycerides from glycerol and oleic acid in the presence of solid catalysts S. Abro, Y. Pouilloux, J. Barrault Zeolite-catalysed hydrolysis of aromatic amides B. Gigante, C. Santos, M.J. Marcelo-Curto, C. Coutanceau, J.M. Silva, F. Alvarez, M. Guisnet, E. Selli, L. Fomi Hydration of a-pinene and camphene over USY zeolites H. Valente, J. Vital Dehydration of 2-(2-hydroxyethyl)-pyridine to 2-vinyl-pyridine over solid acid catalysts L. Fomi, D. Moscotti, E. Selli, I. Belegridi, M. Guisnet, D. Rohan, B. Gigante, C. Coutanceau, J.M. Silva, F. Alvarez The use of heterogeneous copper catalysts in cyclopropanation reactions J.M. Fraile, B. Garcia, J.I. Garcia, J.A. Mayoral, F. Figueras Reaction between haloaromatics over Cu-HZSM-5 zeolite; mechanistic study S. Vol, L. Vivier, G. Perot Selective isomerization of a-pinene oxide with heterogeneous catalysts A.T. Liebens, C. Mahaim, W.F. Holderich Reactions of 2,2-dimethyl-l,3-pi'opanediol with zeolites: correlation of selectivity with acidity H.U. Blaser, B. Casagrande, B. Siebenhaar Clay-catalyzed reactions of imidazole and benzimidazoles with propiolic esters M. Balogh, C. Gonczi, I. Hermecz Selective synthesis of cyclohexylcyclohexanone on bifunctional zeolite catalysts; influence of the metal and of the pore structure F. Alvarez, A.I. Silva, F. Ramoa Ribeiro, G. Giannetto, M. Guisnet Solid acid catalyzed disproportionation and alkylation of alkylsilanes T. Yamaguchi, T. Yamada, M. Shibata, T. Tsuneki, M. Ookawa
531
539
547 555
563 571
579 587
595
603
609 617
Miscellaneous Topics 78
Intramolecular ene reactions promoted by mixed cogels N. Ravasio, M. Antenori, F. Babudri, M. Gargano
625
XI
79
80
81
82
Rh^^ ions and Rh^^-diamine complexes intercalated in a- and y-zirconium hydrogen phosphate as stable and effective catalysts for the conversion of aniline or nitrobenzene to carbamates and/or N,N*-diphenylurea; Part 3 P. Giannoccaro, S. Doronzo, C. Ferragina 1,4-Butanediol conversion routes over bifunctional supported Co-Zn catalyst L. Leite, S. Kruc, Zh. Yuskovets, V. Stonkus, M. Fleisher, E. Lukevics, J. Stoch, M. Mikalayczyk Preparation of solid superbase catalyst and its application to the synthesis of fine chemicals G. Suzukamo, M. Fukao, T. Hibi, K. Tanaka, M. Minobe Synthesis of delicious peptide fragments catalyzed by immobilized proteases M.D. Romero, J. Aguado, M.J. Guerra, G. Alvaro, R. Navarro, E. Rubio
633
641
649 657
Author Index
665
Other volumes in the series
669
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Foreword After three meetings in Poitiers, France, the 4th International Symposium on Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals was held under the auspices of the New Swiss Chemical Society in Basel, Switzerland, from September 8 to 12,1996. 270 scientists attended the meeting, more than a third of them from in industry - reflecting the importance of catalysis not only as an academic but also as a practical science. The focus of the symposium remained unchanged: fundamental as well as applied contributions on the use of heterogeneous catalysis for the preparation of fine chemicals were presented and discussed. The program consisted of 4 plenary lectures, 28 oral contributions and around 90 posters covering a broad range of reactions and catalytic aspects. 82 of these contributions are collected in the present proceedings, grouped into the following 8 topical areas: -
Industrial and engineering problems (7 contributions) Alkylation and acylation reactions (11 contributions) Enantio- and diastereoselective hydrogenation reactions (9 contributions) Chemoselective hydrogenation reactions (12 contributions) Oxidation reactions (14 contributions) Immobilized and encapsulated complex catalysts (12 contributions) Zeolite and clay catalysts (12 contributions) Miscellaneous topics (5 contributions)
Compared to the first three symposia, there are two developments worth mentioning. First, the number of contributions describing stereoselective hydrogenation reactions has increased noticeably, pointing to the growing importance of stereochemically pure active compounds. Second, immobilized and encapsulated complexes are making a comeback. There obviously is still hope that such heterogeneous catalysts can be usefiil for solving special selectivity problems. The Organizing Committee would like to acknowledge the efforts of all members of the Scientific Committee who helped to select the oral and poster contributions and in addition reviewed most papers of the present proceedings. We would also like to thank the staff of AKM Congress Services, Basel (Switzerland) and all other persons who helped to organize the symposium.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Scientific Committee Chairmen Baiker, ETH Zurich, Switzerland H.U. Blaser, Ciba-Geigy AG, Switzerland R. Prins, ETH Zurich, Switzerland Members C. Andersson, University of Lund, Sweden Amtz, Degussa AG, Germany R. Bader, Ciba-Geigy AG, Switzerland M. Bartok, Jozsef Attila University, Hungary A. Corma, Universidad Politecnica de Valencia-CSIC, Spain B. Delmon, Universite Catholique de Louvain, Belgium I. Dodgson, Johnson Matthey Ltd., UK F. Figueras, IRC Villeurbanne, France L. Fomi, Universita di Milano, Italy P. Fiinfschilling, Sandoz AG, Switzerland P. Gallezot, IRC Villeurbanne, France E. Gehrer, BASF AG, Germany P. Gravelle, CNRS-PIRSEM, France J. Heveling, Lonza AG, Switzerland W. Holderich, Technische Hochschule Aachen, Germany J. Kervennal, Elf Atochem S.A., France K. Kiihlein, Hochst AG, Germany T. Mallat, ETH Zurich, Switzerland G. Perot, Universite de Poitiers, France F. Rossler, Hoffmann-La Roche AG, Switzerland F. Schmidt, Siid-Chemie AG, Germany R. Sheldon, Delft University of Technology, The Netherlands K. Smith, University of Wales, UK M. Spagnol, Rhone-Poulenc, France M. Studer, Ciba-Geigy AG, Switzerland H. van Bekkum, Delft University of Technology, The Netherlands E. Zimgiebl, Bayer AG, Germany
Organizing Committee R. Bader, Basel (Chairman) H.U. Blaser, Basel (Secretary) D. Fritz, Basel (Secretary's office) A. Baiker, Zurich; W. Graf, Visp; G. Perot, Poitiers; R. Prins, Ziirich (Members)
XVI
Financial Support The organizers gratefully acknowledge the financial support of the following sponsors: Canton and City of Basel Ciba-Geigy AG, Basel Degussa AG, Frankfurt a.M./D Engelhard Corporation, Iselin NJ/USA Hoechst AG, Frankfurt a.M./D Hoffmann-La Roche AG, Basel Johnson Matthey, Royston/UK Lonza AG, Basel New Swiss Chemical Society Novartis AG, Basel Sandoz AG, Basel Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH), Ziirich
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Homogeneous Catalysis for Fine Chemical Synthesis - New Trends and Perspectives Matthias Beller Anorganisch-chemisches Institut der TU Miinchen, Lichtenbergstr. 4, 85747 Garching, Germany
Abstract Homogeneous catalysis used for fine chemical synthesis is a success story of both organometalhc chemistry and organic synthesis. The wide scope for application of recently developed transition metal catalysts and ligands is illustrated by selected exanq)les. Emphasis is given on efficient catalytic CC-couphng reactions, atom economic processes, and new stereoselective methods. Apart fi-om the synthetic possibihties of homogeneous catalysts trends to overcome the basic problem of catalyst recychng are briefly reviewed. Here, two phase catalysis offers the most elegant solution. Recent achievements, e.g. the use of alternative two phase systems as well as the design of new hgands in this area are reported. Keywords: Homogeneous catalysis; Organometallic chemistry; Two phase catalysis; CC-coupling reactions; Asymmetric catalysis 1. Introduction In the area of classical fine chemicals significant changes are taking place worldwide because a number of estabHshed productions in the western world e.g. for chlorinated aromatics, Bnaphthol, resorcin, and others, which are characterized by large amounts of unwanted sideproducts and waste can not con^ete with productions ia industrially developing countries which operate under different conditions. As a consequence the development of profitable production of already established fine chemicals can only be achieved with innovative methods which have ecological and economical benefits. In this regard catalysts in general are of key in:q)ortance due to their abilities to open up new reaction pathways and to improvQ all kinds of selectivity (chemo-, regio-, and stereoselectivity) in a given reaction. Consequently it is possible to use cheaper feedstocks and to avoid unwanted side-products. Compared to heterogeneous catalytic systems homogeneous catalysts ofl:en show very attractive selectivities under remarkably mild conditions. Moreover, homogeneous catalysis is generally better understood on a molecular level which leads to a more rational driven design and variation of homogeneous catalysts. However, many published homogeneous systems show only poor activities (turnover fi-equencies) and hfetune (total turnover numbers). In addition, even with very stable catalysts recycling is often not possible. As a consequence catalyst costs are dominating for certain processes and prevent commercial application.
Various strategies have been pursued to overcome these problems. On the one hand the introduction of new hgands has proved to be extremely successfiil in gaining new reactivity and inq)roved activity and on the other hand the concept of two phase catalysis nowadays allows recychng of highly sophisticated catalysts and Ugands even in the synthesis of advanced organic building blocks. 2. New transition metal catalysts and ligands Traditionally the strength of homogeneous catalysis results from the concept of tuning catalyst properties by changing the electronic and steric environment of a given transition metal center. Here, the hgands play an extremely inq)ortant role. Thus, the introduction of new types of Hgands often parallels breakthroughs in catalytic appHcations. Selected examples from our own research as well as highhghts from the hterature in the 90's will be adressed and discussed: The palladium-catalyzed activation and subsequent fimctionalization of aryl haHdes has received increased attention in the last decade^l The enormous synthetic possibihties are demonstrated in Scheme 1 by the synthesis of aromatic intermediates such as cinnamic acid derivatives, styrenes, biaryls, benzoic acids, benzonitriles, or anilines. .CN
Scheme 1: Palladium-catalyzed activation of aryl haHdes Until now aromatic fine chemicals are often synthesized using classical stoichiometric organic reactions. In principle, catalytic methodologies based on the pioneering work of Heck^^ offer an interesting alternative for the generation of new carbon-carbon or carbonheteroatom bonds in a selective and economicaUy feasible manner. However, the reactions
generally suffer from serious limitations which have precluded widespread industrial apphcations so far^\ Typically, a large amount of catalyst (1-5 mol %) is needed for reasonable conversions and often catalyst recycling is hankered by early precipitation of palladium black. Even more in:q)ortant for industrial apphcations is that the attractive aryl chlorides are generally unreactive. In recent years there have been only few contributions towards catalyst improvement hke the use of highly basic and sterically hindered phosphines by Milstein'^^ Osbom^^, Alper^\ and Reetz^\ or the appUcation of high pressure conditions recently described by Reiser^l In 1991 at the Central Research Laboratories of Hoechst AG we became interested in the palladium-catalyzed olefination (Heck reaction) of aryl hahdes and aryl diazonium compounds^^ which is arguably one of the most powerfiil methods for the synthesis of substituted olefins. In collaboration with Herrmann and co-workers we have shown that active catalyst mixtures obtained by using in situ mixtures of Pd(II) salts and commercially available tri-o-tolylphosphine consist under the conditions of the Heck reaction primarily of cyclometallated palladacycles^^^
R
Pdcat
.^^^^^./'^^^^/^
base 135 °C
R
— - Qi R
^\ Pd cat. =
OAc
/< V
^< /^K
^
2
^
R^
X
4-CH3CO C02BU Br Br 4-CH3CO Ph 4-CH3CO Ph CI 4-CH3CO CO2BU CI
^-
Yield (%) >95 45 43 50
TON 1.000.000 450.000 43.000 50.000
R = o-tolyl Scheme 2: Heck reaction with palladacycles as catalysts The metallacycles themselves show outstanding catalyst activities for the reaction of aryl hahdes with e.g. alkyl acrylates, and styrenes (Scheme 2). In particular the C-C bond forming reactions using aryl chlorides and palladacycles as catalysts seem to be technically viable for the first time. Thus, we were able to reach turnover numbers in the range of 30.000 - 50.000, albeit at conversions of 30-50% for olefinations of aryl chlorides substituted by electron-withdrawing groups^^\ The importance of Heck reactions for the synthesis of pharmaceuticals is illustrated in the synthesis of 6-methoxy-2vinyhiaphthahn which is a possible intermediate for naproxen, one of the most knportant nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. The key step of process is the vinylation of 2-bromo-6methoxynaphthahn with ethylene (Scheme 3). Despite the possibihty of double arylation the Heck reaction proceeds highly selective in the presence of a palladacycle catalyst, thus yielding the mono-arylation product in 80% yield with turnover numbers of the catalyst above 10.000.
Pd cat.
^ CH30
+ HBr
base 135°C
CH3O
1. Hydrocyanation (DuPont) 2. Hydrolysis or 1. Hydroformylation(Takaya 2. Oxidation
Pd cat.
CO2H CH3O
Scheme 3: Synthesis of Naproxen via Heck technology Apart from the generation of C-C bonds extension of the Heck methodology towards C-N bond formation has been reported independently by Buchwald^^^ and Hartwig^^\ Aromatic amines can be prepared directly from amines and aryl bromides in the presence of a palladium catalyst and a stoichiometric amount of a strong base. Again a catalyst system containing the sterically hindered tri-o-tolylphosphine hgand gave the best results.
Br
|T
N(R')R"
Pdcat.
+ R'(R")NH
»
+ HBr
base toluene Buchwald: Pdcat. = [(o-tolyl)3P]2PdCl2orPd(dba)2/2P(o-tolyl)3 base = NaO/Bu Hartwig:
Pd cat. = [(o-tolyl)3P]2Pd or [(o-tolyl)3P]2PdX2; X = Br, C base = LiN(SiMe3)2, NaO/Bu, LiO/Bu
Scheme 4: Palladium-catalyzed amination of arylhaUdes Both electron-rich and electron-poor aryl bromides react in good yields, albeit with turnover numbers below 1000. Nevertheless, this new palladium-catalyzed amination protocol is a first step towards substitution of the traditional copper-mediated Ullmann condensation. In the area of polymerizations new Hgand systems have dramatically improved catalyst performance. The developed organometaUic complexes might also find widespread apphcation in organic synthesis. As an example metallocene catalysts offer new opportunities in asymmetric catalysis^"^^ after having proven to be industrially viable for olefin polymerization^^^
Very recently, palladium or nickel complexes in the presence of ligands with a 1,4diazabutadiene structural unit have shown superior activity for the coupling of fimctionalized olefins with non-fimctionahzed olefins^^. Although long known, this class of Hgands may also be able to effect transformations regarding fine chemicals not readily achieved witib the corresponding phosphine catalysts. Not only changing the hgand sphere but also the addition of a co-catalyst can dramatically increase catalyst-efficiency. In an interesting exanq)le is the cobalt-catalyzed amidocarbonylation. In a perfectly atom economic way N-acylamino acids can be produced fi^om simple amides, aldehydes and carbon monoxide. Although amidocarbonylation reactions which were originally developed by Wakamatsu in the early seventies^^^ cannot conq)ete commercially against cheap natural sources or fermentation, for non-natural amino acids this salt fi-ee process must be considered as a viable alternative to the conventional Strecker reaction.
9N
QO RR""
9II
I N - "
+
R-^-'^^H
H
+ CO
»-
«
R^'^N^'^C
i > 95% yield
Scheme 4: Atom economic synthesis of N-acylamino acids Recently, we discovered at the Central Research Laboratories of Hoechst AG that the addition of acids as co-catalyst dramatically improves the amidocarbonylation of Nalkylamides^^\ Under very mild conditions (50°C and 10-20 bar CO) extremely high conversions (> 99%) and selectivities (> 95%) can be achieved in the synthesis of sarcosinates. Most significantly a wide variety of non-natural N-acyl and N-acyl-N-alkyl amino acids such as arylglycines, arylalanines, and alkylglycines can be prepared in good to excellent yields^^\ Because of industrial appHcations of N-acyl amino acids as chelating reagents and detergents this method has aheady been up scaled to a 200 1 scale. Due to recent pharmaceutical interest in peptides containing non-natural amino acids an asymmetric amidocarbonylation would constitute a sophisticated tool for catalytic asymmetric synthesis. This leads over to new developments in the area of stereoselective catalysis. 2.1. Stereoselective catalysis It is undisputed that asymmetric synthesis has gained increasing importance both at the university level and in industry. The last ten years have seen enormous advances in asymmetric catalysis using transition metals and during the next decade fiirther progress will be made. The market for optically-pure pharmaceutical compounds grows faster than for classical fine chemicals. In 1994 bulk intermediates for pharmaceuticals reached a market volume of $9.2 biUion. At the beginning of the next century the potential market for synthetic chiral products in bulk form alone is estimated to be much more. Special interest in asymmetric catalysis has been paid towards the refinement of olefins because alkenes are the most versatile feedstock of the chemical industry and moreover for
organic synthesis. In future industrial realizations will be seen especially for oxidations and hydrogenations. Emerging technologies include the Sharpless dihydroxylation, the Jacobsen epoxidation, and hydrogenations with ferrocenyl phosphines and phospholanes. From the standpoint of general appHcabihty, and scope the osmium-catalyzed asymmetric dihydroxylation of alkenes (Sharpless dihydroxylation) has reached a level of effectiveness which is unique among asymmetric catalytic methods^^l In the presence of an optimized catalyst hgand system nearly every class of olefin can be dihydroxylated with high enantioselectivities.
' x ^ ^ p
K20s03(OH)2 K3Fe(CN)6 >> ligand t-BuOH, H2O
OH yields > 80% ee's > 90-99%
ligand:
^eO,
quinidine derivatives
OMe
quinine derivatives
Scheme 5: Sharpless dihydroxylation The synthetic success of the Sharpless dihydroxylation (AD) is based on the hgand acceleration phenomenon^^^ and an incredible optimization program, which resulted in the preparation and testing of more than 500 hgands. Pseudoenantiomeric cinchona alkaloid derivatives support extremely efficient catalysis, as shown in the homogeneous dihydroxylation of 2-vmyhiaphthalene. Turnover fi-equencies of 3000 min'^ which mimic enzymatic catalysis have been achieved. Numerous synthetic apphcations of the asymmetric dihydroxylation have aheady appeared and some are of potential industrial interest including the synthesis of propranolol, diltiazem, 4-amino-3-hydroxybutyric acid, azole antifimgals, chloramphenicol, taxol side cham, and canq)tothecin intermediates^^^ (Scheme 6). An extension of the AD process, the asymmetric amidohydroxylation reaction has been reported by Sharpless et al. early this year^^l The resulting B-amido alcohols can be easily transferred to B-amino alcohols, which are an unportant structural element in pharmaceuticals. Although the enantioselectivities are generally lower conq)ared to the AD they can often be raised to enantiopurity by sinq)le crystallization due to the crystalline nature of the products. For the epoxidation of a variety of olefins chiral Mn(III)-salen complexes have been introduced by Jacobsen^^^ and subsequently Katsuki^'^^ These catalysts have emerged as the most enantioselective epoxidation catalysts uncovered to date. The system is particularly well suited for the epoxidation of c/5-disubstituted olefins and trisubstituted olefins. Trans-epo^dos are obtained with high enantioselectivities in the presence of an additional chiral quartemary ammonium salt^^l
OAc
OH H2N^
Propranolol
^COsH
GABOB
OH
Ar
NHBz
^^X/CH20H
^"
-OH >;^v^ O2N
OH Azole antifungals
NHCOCHCI2
Chloramphenicol
Scheme 6: Selected products from asymmetric dihydroxylations (AD) Epoxidations can be carried out at room temperature in a two phase system employing commercial bleach or a combination of oxygen and pivaldehyde. Due to the practical utihty of a number of epoxidations the salen catalyst derived from chiral 1,2-diaminocyclohexane has been prepared at the multihundred kilogramm level^^^ Nevertheless industrial apphcations seem to be difficult so far because of a Umited catalyst efficiency and stabiHty (TON < 1000). R'
Mn - Catalyst
R'
NaOCI
cis - olefins:
80 - 99% ee
trans - olefins: 20 - 40% ee trisubst. olefins: 50 - 70% ee terminal olefins: 35 - 70% ee
Scheme 7: Jacobsen epoxidations It will be interesting to see whether manganese salencon^lexes can be made more efficient or if more active epoxidation catalysts, e.g. methyltrioxorhenium^^^ in the presence of chiral hgands will lead to more practical solutions. Apart from oxidation reactions hydrogenations offer an easy access for the mtroduction of stereogenic centers in a given molecule. Again the preparation of new classes of chiral Ugands, especially phosphines led to significant progress. Although the enantioselective hydrogenation
of olefins has been extensively investigated, and relatively high enantioselectivities have been achieved with certain substrates synthetic procedures still need to be inq)roved. In this regard the so-called DuPHOS hgands 1 based on the 2,5-dialkylphospholane moitey proved to be well-suited for rhodium-catalyzed hydrogenation of enamides to give a wdde range of nonnatural amino acids^^^ Advantageously, both (E)- and (Z)-isomers of enamides can be hydrogenated in high enantiomeric excess to give products with the same absolute configuration. Even B,B-disubstituted acetamidoacrylates gave B-branched amino acids in up to 99% Qe^^\
R..„ /
1
R
/
1
PPh2
c; P-^.
'
o
CH3
Fe '
1: R = CH3,C2H5,i-C3H7
2
3
Scheme 8: New Ugands for asymmetric hydrogenations In the past the concept of C2 symmetric catalysts has played an inq)ortant role in the design and understanding of asymmetric catalysis. Even so, examples of chelating phosphines without C2 symmetry appear in the hterature with increasing fi-equency and open generally new opportunities. In this respect, chiral ferrocenyl hgands have at present a specific potential. An easy to use enantioselective ortho-hthiation of ferrocenylamidesfi*omthe Snieckus group^^^ offers availabihty of a number of new ferrocenyl hgands wdth high optical purity and extends the first mdustrial apphcations for ferrocenyldiphosphines^^l While Lonza Ltd. apphes the hgand 2 in a rhodium-catalyzed hydrogenation for a new biotin synthesis Ciba-Geigy performs an iridium-catalyzed hnine hydrogenation using 3 for the herbicide (S)-Metolaclilor^^\ New mrpetus for asymmetric hydroformylations came primarily fi-om Takayas phosphinephosphinite hgand (BINAPO) 4 which constitutes an enormous breakthrough^^\ In combination with rhodium the BINAPO hgand gave enantioselectivities up to 95% and i/n ratios > 86/14 in the hydroformylation of substituted styrene derivatives. Conversions are > 99% at substrate/catalyst ratios between 300 and 2000. Shortly afterwards, similar catalytic results were reported by Union Carbide with chiral diphosphinite hgands, e.g. 5^^\ After many years of stagnation these new catalysts now point the way towards fixture developments in asymmetric hydroformylation. Another impressive example for the importance of electronic asymmetry in the design of chelating chhal hgands was reported by RajanBabu and Casahuovo for the asymmetric hydrocyanation reaction^'^^ As chiral Hgands 3,4-phosphinites fi"om D-finctofiiranoside derivatives were synthesized. The imsymmetrical phosphinite with the more electron-deficient phosphorous at the C4-position of fiuctose gave superior enantioselectivities for the hydrocyanation of 6-methoxy-2-vinyhiaphthalene.
Ph^
^
CHO
RhI cat./ligand + CO + H2
^CHO Ph
OlVfe
Scheme 9: Chiral ligands for asymmetric hydroformylation Obviously, basic research is needed to provide a more comprehensive insight into the dependence of enantioselectivities on Ugand electronics which is only poorly understood compared to steric effects. Nevertheless the concept of electronic asymmetry to enhance enantioselectivity in other Hgand systems is very appealing and should be considered to a greater extent forfixtureligand optimization studies.
3. New applications of transition metal catalysts The search for new reactivity and new reactions is an mq)ortant target in homogeneous catalysis. A declared goal is the selective activation of C-H bonds under mild conditions. Although there are numerous exanq)les of stoichiometric C-H bond oxidative additions to transition metal centers, successfiil examples regarding catalytic fimctionalization of C-H bonds have been made only during the last five years. Notable advances have been achieved by Moore and coworkers who described in 1992 the or^/zoacylation of pyridine with olefins and carbon monoxide. The cluster compound triruthenium dodecacarbonyl has been used as catalyst (Scheme 10).
1.3mol% C4M9
N
9
Ri^(C0)i2 60 CO, 150°C C4H9
5%
Scheme 10: Catalytic acylation of pyridine
10 High regioselectivities and turnover frequencies of 300/h have been achieved. It is beheved that the cluster framework remains intact during the course of the acylation reaction and chelation of the nitrogen atom facihtates CH-activation^^l Until now no extension of this chemistry or ftirther results have appeared in the Hterature. Thus, the couphng reaction seems to be applicable only to pyridine derivatives. Similar chelation assistance has been used to affect the addition of ortho C-H bonds of aromatic ketones to olefins albeit in the presence of a totally different catalyst system. Here, Murai et al. use certain ruthenium conq)lexes, e.g. Ru(H)2(CO)(PPh3)3^^\ in refluxing toluene (Scheme 11). The chemical yields based on the aromatic ketones are often close to quantitative. The resulting products, ortho alkylsubstituted aromatic ketones, are not easily available by classical organic chemistry, demonstrating that new catalytic reactions can be new synthetic tools, too. Clearly, at present there are significant limitations to the range of olefins that are suitable for this reaction. Neither olefins having strong electron-withdrawing groups or electron-donating groups react yet. Probably modification of the catalyst may overcome these limitations in fixture.
RuH2(COXPPh3)3 < ^ R 110°C, 18h
Scheme 11: Alkylation of aromatic ketones (Murai reaction) Immediate extensions of the Murai alkylation are akeady underway, e.g. catalytic addition of alkynes to aromatic C-H bonds, and alkylation of 2-phenylpyridines with olefins^^\ Another exanq)le that the successfiil discovery of new reactions may effect fine chemical synthesis is the selective cross-metathesis of acrylonitrile with terminal olefins to give substituted acrylonitriles. This is the first time that an olefin fimctionalized directly at the double bond undergoes cross-metathesis^^l In the presence of Schrock's molybdenum catalyst Mo(CHCMe2Ph)(NAr)[OCMe(CF3)2] yields of 18-90% and total turnover numbers of 4-25 were achieved. As a matter of fact, the ubiquitious avaUabihty of terminal olefins combined with their low prices makes this methodology potentially usefiil for industrial appHcations.
4. New methodical developments In addition to the synthesis of specific Hgands and the resulting catalysts new ideas and concepts begin to combine with transition metal chemistry to open up new areas in homogeneous catalysis, hke catalysis under supercritical conditions^^\ colloidal catalysis'*^\ organometalHc electrocatalysis and multi-metallic catalysis"*^^ ("cooperative catalysis"). Beyond these methodical developments which will prove their utility in the next decade catalyst recycling is of crucial importance in homogeneous catalysis. In contrast to heterogeneous catalysis recychng of the expensive metal is usually difficult. To faciUtate catalyst/product separation often the attachment of a catalyst to an organic polymeric resin has been used'*^^ Although this concept workes nicely on a laboratory scale decreased activity and
11 the more serious leaching of catalyst under industrial conditions has prevented any apphcation so far. Todays best solution to surpass the recychng problem is Uquid/liquid two phase catalysis'^^l 4.1. Two phase catalysis The most hnportant methodical progress in homogeneous catalysis since 1980 has been the introduction of industrially feasable Hquid/Uquid two phase catalysis. This technique uses a homogeneous catalyst, dissolved in a hydrophiHc phase, advantageously water, while organic starting materials and products form a second phase. By sinaple phase separation the catalyst is separated from reactants and products. In relation to the reaction products the catalyst is immobihzed as well as heterogenized. Although industry created sophisticated processes already in the seventies (Shell higher olefin process) and early eighties (Ruhrchemie/Rhone Poulenc hydroformylation process)"*"*^ it is surprising that two phase catalysis has gained more academic interest only fakly recently. The following topics are currently investigated in the area of multi-phase catalysis: Synthesis of new hydrophihc Hgands, especially phosphines, has been pursued. The solubihty in hydrophiHc solvents (water) is achieved by introduction of polar substituents such as SO3H, -CO2H, or -NRs^ into the corresponding Hgand. Traditionally and by far the most examined class of hydrophiHc Hgands are sulfonated phosphines, e.g. trisulfonated triphenylphosphine (TPPTS). Often sulfonation of phosphines constitutes a problem because of concomitant oxidation of the phosphorous atom. Using a combination of boric acid and concentrated sulfiiric acid Herrmann and coworkers developed a very selective and efficient sulfonation technique'*^^ It is beheved that a super acidic medium is generated that protects the phosphorous atom by protonation. In order to use highly hydrophobic starting materials for two phase catalysis with water as hydrophiHc medium Hanson et al. synthesized surface-active phosphines. These form more active catalysts for the hydroformylation of 1-octene conq)ared to TPPTS"*^. Apart from ionic Hgands neutral hydrophiHc Hgands seem to be very interesting. Berbreiter et al. described polyaUcylene oxide substituted bis-(2-diphenylphosphinoethyl) amides'*^^ Because of an inverse tenq)erature-dependant solubiHty in water these Hgands solubilize a catalyst at room temperature in the hydrophiHc medium and at higher reaction temperatures in the organic phase ("smart Hgands"). By carefiil fine tuning the solubiHty change can be highly specific. Similar polyethyleneglycol modified phosphines (scheme 12) have also been described for 0x0 reactions'*^^ To enlarge the scope of "smart Hgands" we recently prepared a new class of sugar-containing phosphines'*^^ Based on a highly specific glycosidation reaction a large number of carbohydrate based triarylphosphines (scheme 12) are available for testing in new catalytic appHcations. In addition to aqueous biphasic systems a number of alternative two phase processes using non-aqueous Hquid/Hquid systems are emergmg. One exanq)le is Horvath's proposal of a fluorous biphase system (FBS)^^^ using the immiscibiHty of a fluorinated compound with organic solvents. Based on the increasing knowledge of two phase catalysis newfimechemical processes Hke butadiene telomerisation, aUylation with carbon nucleophiles, and the carbonylation of benzyl chlorides with water-soluble catalysts have aheady been commercialized or are Hkely to be industriaUy reaHzed in the near fiiture^'^^^
12 0(CH2CH20)nH
.-^^^^P—C^
SOsNa
^—0(CH2CH20)nH
H(OCH2CH2)nO
HO HO
X X = OH,NHAc
Scheme 12: Hydrophilic ligands for two phase catalysis Clearly, Hquid/Uquid two phase catalysis has not yet reached its culmination poiQt and will see fiirther apphcations in fiitm*e. 5. Conclusion and outlook On the verge of the 21. century we live in an interdependant global economy which has also effects on fine chemical synthesis. Following the general trend the chemicalfixturein Emope will be determined to a large extent by realization of new manufacturing processes for highly specialized products. In this area sophisticated structures for pharmaceuticals, agrochemicals, food additives, and other speciahties offer the best opportunities. For the purpose of fast and flexible apphcations homogeneous catalysis is ideally suited as an interdisciphnary science^ ^^ which apphes basic organometalHc chemistry in an efficient manner to organic synthesis. So far the focal point of organic synthesis was the development of new methods, often highly stereoselective reactions, but was not always usefiil for practical purposes. Traditional organometalHc chemistry was concentrated on the synthesis of new complexes but not so much on apphcations. This still creates a need for more research directed towards the inq)rovement of catalyst activities and productivities. Infixturethe combination of high level organometalHc chemistry with state of the art organic synthesis Hnked together by efficient catalysis wiH be crucial for the development of technicaUy usefiil processes for advanced organic building blocks. In this respect homogeneous catalysis wiU gain increasing inq)ortance in the industrial production of fine chemicals. Which trends wiH dominate homogeneous catalysis in academia the next years? The search for more active catalysts and easy catalyst recycling for aheady estabHshed methodologies wiU be of continuing interest. Atom economic processes using mdustriaUy viable starting materials wiH be considered to be of most importance. Concerning the inteHectuaUy appealing rational design of new catalysts one has to istinguish between catalyst development in general and catalyst optimization. Wlule mechanistic knowledge is and wiH be
13 the key to get a "catalyst lead structure" catalyst optimization will be in reality still very much empirical in nature despite all progress in computational chemistry. Fundamental research in the next decade will concentrate on more efficient catalysis for CHactivation, all kinds of catalytic additions of nucleophiles to double bonds as perfect atom economic procedures, and asymmetric catalysis. It is clear that Ugands will retain their inq)ortance for controlhng the metal catalyst. In order to improve hgand properties more and more comphcated, and thus more expensive Hgand systems will be designed. This seems especially true for asymmetric catalysis. Here, two phase catalysis will surely gain increasing importance due to the easy recycling not only of the metal but also of the appropriately designed Hgand. TraditionaUy carbonylation reactions are imderestimated in fine chemical business. Due to an abundance of starting materials and relatively inexpensive carbon monoxide or syn gas carbonylations wiU be enq)loyed more often to synthesize interesting building blocks: amino acids via amidocarbonylation, profenes by asymmetric hydroformylations or hydrocarboxylations, reductive and oxidative carbonylations towards urethanes and ureas, etc. In conclusion the development of homogeneous catalysis wiU have significant industrial intact and provide societal benefit in fixture. Besides this, it wiU be also much firn to participate actively in this scientificaUy interesting area.
Acknowledgements The author would like to thank the many coUeagues of the catalysis group at Hoechst AG for fiiendship and discussions. Special thanks go to Prof K. Kiihlein who initiated and supported always the catalysis research at the Central Research Laboratories of Hoechst AG. I particularly thank our coUaborators at the TU Miinchen Prof W. A. Herrmann and his coworkers and especiaUy my co-workers M. Eckert, J. Krauter, T. Riermeier, F. VoUmuUer, A. Zapf for then work and enthusiasm to join me in the areas of carbonylations. Heck reactions and two phase catalysis.
References: [1]
[2]
[3] [4]
a) J. Tsuji, PaUadium Reagents and Catalysts, John Wiley & Sons, Chichester (1995); b) A. de Meijere, Angew. Chem. 106 (1994) 2473, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 33(1994)2379. a) R. F. Heck, PaUadium Reagents in Organic Synthesis, Academic Press LTD, London, Great Britain (1985); b) R. F. Heck, Vinyl Substitutions with OrganopaUadium Intermediates hi Trost/Fleming (Eds.), Comprehensive Organic Synthesis, Pergamon Press, Oxford, Vol. 4 (1991) 833. An exception is the synthesis of Ciba-Geigy's herbicide Prosulforon: R. R Bader, P. Baumeister, H.-U. Blaser, Chhnia 50 (1996) 99. a) Y. Ben-David, M. Portnoy, D. Milstem, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 111 (1989) 8742; b) Y. Ben-David, M. Portnoy, M. Gozin, D. Milstem, OrganometaUics 11 (1992) 1995; c) M. Portnoy, D. Milstein, OrganometaUics 12 (1993) 1665.
14
[5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]
[11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20]
[21] [22]
[23]
[24] [25] [26]
M. Huser, M. T. Youinou, J. A. Osbom, Angew. Chem. 101 (1989) 1427. a) V. V. Grushin, H. Alper, J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun. 1992, 611; b) Review: V. V. Grushin, H. Alper, Chem Rev. 94 (1994) 1047. M. T. Reetz, R Breinbauer, K. Wamiinger, Tetrahedron Lett. (1996) in press. S. HiUers, S. Sartori, O. Reiser, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 118 (1996) 2087. M. BeUer, K. Kiihlein, Tetrahedron Lett. 35 (1994) 8773. W. A. Herrmann, C. BroBmer, K. Ofele, C.-P. Reisinger, T. Priermeier, M. Beller, H. Fischer, Angew. Chem 107 (1995) 1989; M. BeUer, H. Fischer, W. A. Herrmann, C. BroBmer, K. Ofele, Angew. Chem. 107 (1995) 1992. W. A. Herrmann, C. BroUmer, C.-P. Reisinger, T. Riermeier, K. Ofele, M. Beller, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1996, submitted. A. S. Guram, R A. Rennels, S. L. Buchwald, Angew. Chem Int. Ed. Engl. 34 (1995) 1348; Review: M. BeUer, Angew. Chem Int. Ed. Engl. 34 (1995) 1316. J. Louie, J. F. Hartwig, Tetrahedron Lett. 36 (1995) 3609. Review: A. H. Hoveyda, J. P. Morken, Angew. Chem Int. Ed. Engl. 35 (1996) 1263. Review: H.-H. Brintzinger, D. Fischer, R Miilhaupt, B. Rieger, R Waymouth, Angew. Chem 107 (1995) 1255. L. K. Johnson, S. Mecking, M. Brookhart, J. Am. Chem Soc. 118 (1996) 267. H. Wakamatsu, J. Uda, N. Yamakami, J. Chem Soc. Chem Commun. (1971) 1540. M. BeUer, H. Fischer, P. GroB, T. Gerdau, DE 4.415.712 (1994). M. BeUer, F. VoUmuUer, M. Eckert, H. GeiBler, S. Bogdanovic, unpubUshed results. Reviews: a) M. BeUer, K B. Sharpless in AppUed Homogeneous Catalysis (Eds.: B. Cormls, W. A. Herrmann), VCH, Weinheun, 1996; b) H C. Kolb, M. S.VanNiewenhze, K. B. Sharpless, Chem Rev. 94 (1994), 2483; c) R A. Johnson, K B. Sharpless in Catalytic Asymmetric Synthesis (Ed.: I. Ojima), VCH, Weinheim, 1993; d) H. Waldmann, Nachr. Chem Tech. Lab. 40 (1992) 702; e) B. B. Lohray, Tetrahedron Asymm 3 (1992) 1317. D. J. Berrisford, C. Bohn, K. B. Sharpless, Angew. Chem Int. Ed. Engl. 34 (1995) 1059. a) G. Li, H. T. Chang, K B. Sharpless, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 35 (1996) 451; b) H Becker, K. B. Sharpless, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 36 (1996) 448; c) Review: O. Reiser, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 35 (1996) 1308. a) W. Zhang, J. L. Loebach, S. R WUson, E. N. Jacobsen, J. Am. Chem Soc. 112 (1990) 2801; b) E. Jacobsen, W. Zhang, A. R. Muci, J. R Ecker, L. Deng, J. Am. Chem Soc. 113 (1991) 7063; c) Review: E. N. Jacobsen in Catalytic Asymmetric Synthesis, I. Ojhna (Ed.), VCH, New York (1993). a) R Irie, K. Noda, Y. Ito, T. Katsuki, Tetrahedron Lett. 32 (1991) 1055; b) H. Sakai, R Irie, T. Katsuki, Synlett (1993) 300. S. Chang, J. M. Galvin, E. N. Jacobsen, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 116 (1994) 6937. J. F. Larrow, E. N. Jacobsen, Y. Gao, Y. Hong, X. Nie, C. M. Zepp, J. Org. Chem. 59(1994)1939.
15 [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37]
[38] [39] [40]
[41]
[42] [43]
[44] [45] [46]
[47] [48]
Review: W. A. Herrmann, J. Organomet. Chem. 500 (1995) 149. a) M. J. Burk, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 113 (1991) 8518; b) M. J. Burk, J. E. Feaster, W. A. Nugent, R. L. Harlow, J. Am. Chem Soc. 115 (1993) 10125. M. J. Burk, M. F. Gross, J. P. Martinez, J. Am. Chem Soc. 117 (1995) 9375. M. Tsukazaki, M. Tinkl, A. Roglans, B. J. ChapeU, N. J. Taylor, V. Snieckus, J. Am Chem. Soc. 118(1996)685. Review: a) A Togni, Angew. Chem. 108 (1996) 1581; b) A. Togni, Chimia 50 (1996)86. N. Sakai, S. Matio, K. Nozaki, H. Takaya, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 115 (1993) 7033. J. E. Babin, G. T. Whitecker (Union Carbide) PCX Int. Appl. WO 93/03839 (1993). T. V. RajanBabu, A. L. Casalnuovo, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 118 (1996) 6325. W. E. Crowe, D. R. Goldberg, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 117 (1995) 5162. E. Moore, W. R Praetzer, T. J. O'Conell, J. Harris, L. LaBounty, L. Chou, S. S. Grimmer, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 114 (1992) 5888. a) S. Murai, F. Kakiuchi, S. Sekine, Y. Tanaka, A. Kamatani, M. Sonoda, N. Chatani, Nature, 366 (1993) 529; b) Review: F. Kakiuchi. S. Sekine, Y. Tanaka, A. Kamatami, M. Sonoda, N. Chatani, S. Murai, Bull. Chem Soc. Jpn. 68 (1995) 62. Y.-G. Lim, Y. H. Kim, J.-B. Kang, J. Chem Soc. Chem. Commun. (1994) 2267. R G. Jessop, T. Ikariya, R. Noyori, Nature 368 (1994) 231. a) G. Schmid, Clusters and Colloids, VCH, Weinheim, Germany, 1994; b) H. Bonnemann, W. Brijoux, R Brinkmann, E. Dinjus, T. Jouen, B. Corall, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 30 (1991) 1312; c) M. T. Reetz, S. A. Quaiser, Angew. Chem. IntEd. Engl. 34(1994)2240. A recent example for the long known slogan "Two metals are better than one" for hydroformylations: M. E. Broussard, B. Juma, S. G. Train, W.-J. Peng, S. A. Laneman, G. G. Stanely, Science 260 (1993) 1784. F. R Hartley, Supported Metal Complexes. A new Generation of Catalysts, Reidel, Dordrecht, Netherlands, 1985. Reviews: a) B. Comils, Angew. Chem. 107 (1995) 1709; b) W. A. Herrmann, C. W. Kohlpaintner, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 32 (1993) 1524; b) P. Kalck, F. Monteil, Adv. Organomet. Chem 34 (1992) 219. a) M. Beller, B. Comils, C. D. Frohning, C. W. Kohlpaintner, J. Mol. Catal. 104 (1995) 17; b) B. Comils, Nachr. Chem. Tech. Lab. 42 (1994) 1136. W. A. Herrmann, G. P. Albanese, R B. Manetsberger, H. Bahrmann, P. Lappe, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 34 (1995) 811. T. Bartik, B. Bartik, I. Guo, B. E. Hanson, J. Organomet. Chem. 480 (1994) 15; b) H. Ding, B. E. Hanson, J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun. (1994) 2747; H. Ding, B. E. Hanson, T. E. Glass, Inorg. Chim. Acta 229 (1995) 329. D. E. Bergbreiter, Li Zhang, V. M. Mariagnanam, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 115 (1993) 9295. Y. Yan, H. Zhuo, Z. Jin, Fenzi Cuihua, Chem. Abstr. 121: 111.875.
16 [49] [50] [51]
M. Beller, J. G. E. Krauter, A. Zapf, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 36 (1997) in print. I. T. Horvath, J. Rabai, Science 266 (1994) 72. Recent monograph: B. Comils, W. A. Herrmann, Applied Homogeneous Catalysis, VCH, Weinheimi, 1996.
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
17
CATALYSIS FOR AGROCHEMICALS: THE CASE fflSTORY OF THE DUAL®HERBICn)E Rolf R. Bader and Hans-Ulrich Blaser*, Central Research Services, R-1055.628 CIBA-GEIGY AG, CH-4002 BASEL, Switzerland 1. SUMMARY The use of catalytic methods for the technical preparation of agrochemicals is illustrated by the case history of the herbicide metolachlor (trade name DUAL®), the most important herbicide for maize. The key step for the technical synthesis of the racemic compound is a reductive alkylation catalyzed by a Pt/C catalyst in presence of sulfuric acid. The commercial production of the biologically active S-enantiomers was made possible by the development of a new Iridium ferrocenyl-diphosphine catalyst system. Important aspects of the development of the two catalyst systems as well as in^)ortant prerequisites for the use of catalysts for the production of agrochemicals are discussed. 2. INTRODUCTION Metolachlor is at the present time the most important herbicide of Ciba-Geigy's Crop Protection Division. It is produced since 1978 in volumes of >10'000 tons per year and is sold under the trade name DUAL® . In the near future, an enantiomerically enriched form will replace the racemic mixture, leading to a reduction of the environmental load by ca. 40%. The case history that is presented here might not be prototypical for an agrochemical, but it serves several purposes. First, it is an impressive example demonstrating the importance of catalysis to the fine chemicals industry. Second, it illustrates how catalytic process technology evolves and, third, it describes how a technically feasible chiral homogeneous catalyst was developed for such a large volume product. The history of this project covers many years and several teams worked on many different aspects (Table 1). We will mainly discuss the problems related to the development of a technically feasible synthesis both for racemic and ^-metolachlor. Metolachlor was first described in 1972 [1]; it is an N-chloroacetylated, N-alkoxyalkylated ortho disubstituted aniline (Figure 1). The unusual fimctionalization pattern renders the amino function extremely sterically hindered. In addition, metolachlor has two chiral elements: a
18 chiral axis (atropisomerism, due to hindered rotation aroimd the C ^ - N axis) and a stereogenic center, leading to four stereoisomers. 1982 it was found that the two S-enantiomers provide most of the biological activity [2].
CIT^N'^CH''"
"'""uT^''"'
'^N-'^CH.CI
^N^CHJCI
ir ~^ ir aR.rS
metolachlor
^'"^N'^CH.CI
aS.rS
the active enantiomers
V^-'^N^CHJCI
w
aR.rR
aS.I'R
the inactive enantiomers
Figure 1. Structure and stereoisomers of metolachlor
Table 1. Milestones in the history of metolachlor 1970
Discovery of the biological activity of metolachlor (patent for product and synthesis)
1973
Decision to develop a production process
1974
First 100 kg of racemic metolachlor produced
1975
Pilot plant in operation (40001 reactor)
1978
Full-scale plant with a production capacity >10'OOO t/y in operation
1982
Synthesis and biological tests of the four stereoisomers of metolachlor
1983
First unsuccessful attempts to synthesize S-metolachlor via enantioselective catalysis
1985
Rhodium / cycphos catalyst gives 69% ee for the imine hydrogenation (UBC Vancouver)
1987
Discovery of new Iridium diphosphine catalysts that are more active and selective than Rh catalysts for MEA imine hydrogenation
1987
Ca-Sn-Pt catalyst for direct alkylation of MEA in the gas phase developed
1992
Patent for racemic reductive alkylation is granted
1993
Ir / ferrocenyl diphosphine catalysts and acid effect discovered
1993/4 Patents for rac-metolachlor expire 1995/6 Pilot results for S-metolachlor: ee 79%, ton I'OOO'OOO, tof >200'000/h, &st 300 t produced 1996
Full-scale plant for production of > lO'OOO t/y S-metolachlor starts operation
19 3, THE FIRST PRODUCTION PROCESS In August 1973 it was decided to develop and establish a technical process for the production of rac-metolachlor. Two synthetic approaches were proposed and tested in the laboratotry (Figure 2): The alkylation of 2-methyl-6-ethyl-aniline (MEA) with methoxyisopropanol (MOIP) and the reductive alkylation of MEA with methoxyacetone (MOA% followed by chloroacetylation. This was obviously a chance for heterogeneous catalysis.
Figure 2. Two synthetic routes to rac-metolachlor 3.1. Acid catalyzed alkylation It was weU known from the literature that anilines can be mono- or di-alkylated with alcohols in presence of acidic catalysts. However, preliminary experiments on several solid acidic catalysts in the vapor-phase gave complex mixtures of the desired product (NAA), as well as N-methyl-, N-dimethyl-, N-propyl- and N-isopropyl-Affi/4 as by-products. These can be e5q)lained by cleavage of the ether group of MOIP followed by reaction of the fragments with MEA, All attenq)ts to inprove the selectivity of this acid catalyzed alkylation failed. Therefore, the reductive alkylation route was chosen for fiuther investigations.
20
3.2. Reductive Alkylation Reductive alkylation of anilines is a very convenient and broadly used method to synthesize secondary and tertiary aryl amines. Many examples were described both in the primary literature and in reviews, nickel, palladium or platinum catalysts being recommended without any strong preference [3]. Surprisingly, we could not find any information on the reductive alkylation of highly sterically hindered anilines like MEA. The course of the reaction is well understood. In a first step, imines are formed by condensation of the aniline with the aldehyde or ketone, leading to an equilibrium where unreacted carbonyl compound and amine are present besides the imine. The resulting imines can either be isolated or hydrogenated directly out of the condensation equilibrium. For industrial applications the second method is preferred because it saves operational costs and costly isolation losses of raw materials are avoided. On the other hand, this in situ method rises a selectivity problem. The catalyst must be able to selectively hydrogenate the imine but leave the carbonyl con:q)ound untouched. This problem is aggravated when the rate of imine formation is slower than that of the hydrogenation step. This leads to even lower imine concentrations in the reaction mixture and as a result, an increase of the undesired carbonyl hydrogenation is likely. To circumvent this problem, the condensation reaction has to be catalyzed by the addition of small amounts of acids. For our process development we concentrated on the in situ method. i.e., the hydrogenation of the Schi£F-base formed in the equilibrium reaction of MEA and MOA to produce the Nalkylated aniline (with the working name NAA)(see Figure 2). Surprisingly, and in contrast to the literature, under moderate reaction conditions no hydrogenation took place with nickel and palladium catalysts. Hydrogen consumption started only at 80-90 °C with these catalysts but after consunq)tion of 1 mol of hydrogen, unreacted MEA was recovered in nearly quantitative yield. That means that MOA was hydrogenated preferentially to give MOIP whereas the imine was not reduced. Platinimi catalysts turned out to be more active and selective. With sulfided platinum on carbon catalysts, especially recommended for reductive alkylations [4], up to 75% ofNAA were formed at 50-60 °C in preliminary screening experiments. During later process development we found that unsulfided Pt/C catalysts were just as selective as the sulfided catalysts for the reductive alkylation, a significant advantagefi*omthe industrial point of view [5]. After intensive development work, first in the laboratory (con:q)rising >1500 experiments) and later in the pilot plant (also used for the production of the first commercial quantities), the following production process was established in early 1978 (see Figure 3): MOIP is dehydrogenated in the gas phase and MOA is isolated by azeotropic distillation with water. The MEA imine formed in situfi*omMOA and MEA is hydrogenated in a batch process at 5 bar
21 hydrogen pressure and 45-50 ^C using a 5% Pt/C catalyst. No additional solvent is used and the purified hydrogenfi*omthe MOA production can be employed. Under these conditions, the hydrogenation is very fest and small amounts of sulfuric acid must be added to catalyze the relatively slow condensation reaction ofMEA and MOA. NAA is worked up by continuous distillation in nearly quantitative yield and is then chloroacetylated to give rac-metolachlor. 0
Cu/ZnCrOx
OH
gas phase continuous process 300X
H2 used in hydrogenation
MOIP
MOA
CHjO^ NH^ Pt/C
jL^om^
liquid phase
^+ H2
batch process
H2O/H2SO4
&
Pt/C can be recycled
50'C, 5 bar MEA
NAA
CHjOv.^^^ ^ ^ ^ 4 H
1
Vi U NAA
+ P I P O ^ u '^i ^ . .2V..
fc
w
>
0
XX 1 YS^
u
metolachlor
Figure 3. The production process for rac-metolachlor 3.3. Some unusual phenomena of the reductive alkylation reaction Space-filling models of the imine gave us a first idea to understand the unusual preference for platinum as the catalytic metal. These models showed that the imine double bond is completely hidden by the two bulky ortho substituents, thereby preventing interactions with the metal surface. This led us to consider the possibility that not the imine but the isomeric enamine(s) shown in Figure 4 were hydrogenated. Enamine hydrogenation would also explain the strong preference for Pt, that in our experience is the catalyst of choice for this transformation. Since we were imable to detect any enamines by spectroscopic methods, we tested our hypothesis by carrying out deuteration experiments (Figure 5). Indeed, about 85 % of the products were bis-deuterated products with deuterium at the two a-positions of the
22 imine carbon atom. Based on this evidence we propose an equilibrium between the MEA-mme and the isomeric enamines present in very low equilibrium concentrations. Then, the observed high reaction rates require both a very &st isomerization as well as a very fast enamine hydrogenation by the platinum catalyst.
CHo
CH3
CH«
A/°^CH,
HN
N H3C
H3C.
CH^
Ql^
HN
and/or H3C
HC
^"3
CH^
Figure 4. Imine - enamine equilibrium CHjD
CH3
,CD
CH3 CD ^0.^ HN^ ^CHD CH3 1
.0.
1
fK^OU
^
HjCv,^
11
\ ; ^
J
*" Dj/Pt-Carbon
A^CH,
H3CV
U
,'
1J
\ ^ < = H ,
85% dg-Products
Figure 3. Deuteration experiment Another phenomenon was also not easy to understand. The catalyst seemingly showed almost no deactivation during its use in the reductive alkylation. On average, it is reused 70 times without much loss in activity or selectivity. The best catalyst lots lasted even up to 160 times! This behavior is quite unusual for a catalytic system, especially when some of the starting materials are recycled. We suspected some sort of an in situ regeneration during the catalyst cycle. While optimizing the operation procedure, we got a clue as to the nature of the regeneration. Before filtering off the catalyst, the hydrogen is replaced by technical nitrogen. In order to save hydrogen, we attempted to filter without first changing the gas atmosphere. To our surprise, the recycle rate of the catalyst dropped drastically and in some cases, the catalyst had to be replaced after only a few uses! We remembered that technical nitrogen as used in production plants contains up to one volume-percent of oxygen. Therefore, the working catalyst is exposed to traces of oxygen during the flushing procedure. We think that catalyst poisons like CO or higher molecular weight by-products are oxidized under these conditions.
23
thereby cleaning the catalyst siirface. In absence of oxygen such species accumulate and lead to a fast catalyst deactivation. 4. A 'DIRECT ALKYLATION PROCESS' Even though the production process described above was very eflScient, we went back to our first process idea: The synthesis of the NAA intermediate in one single process starting fi*om MEA and MOIP because this would allow to eliminate the dehydrogenation step and the distillation of the MOA, Obviously, acid catalysis did not work, therefore M. Rusek turned to multifunctional catalysts that are known to work by dehydrogenation - condensationhydrogenation mechanism. However, probably due to the steric properties of the MEA, it turned out to be very difficult to get the high activities and selectivities necessary for a commercial process. In the end, M. Rusek nevertheless succeeded to develop both the catalyst and find the reaction conditions to produce NAA directlyfi-omMOIP and MEA. At 200 °C in the gas phase NAA was produced with >98% selectivity at ca. 66% conversion over more than 1000 hours [7].
?*'
f
HN
0
H,C
MOIP
^^
1
if^""'
ii
NAA
A
yf
Dehydrogenation
Hydrogenation
t
CH,
Condensation
oX-V MOA
^CH,
1 MEA
^
H,C
< MEAImlne
Figure 6. Proposed steps for the direct alkylation of MEA with MOIP over the Pt-Sn/Si02(Ca) catalyst
24
Table 2. AUcylation of MEA with MOIP: Eflfect of catalysrt composition catalyst
conversion
selectivity
Pt - Si02
2%
29%
Pt - Si02 ( C a ^
3%
65%
Pt - Si02 Sn-doped
14%
93%
Pt - Si02 Sn-doped; Ca"^ 200°C, lbarH2
66%
97%
The key to the success was the development of a new bimetallic platinum tin catalyst on silica support that was treated with calcium salts. As shown in Table 2 all three components as well as the silica support are absolutely necessary to get a good catalysts performance, i.e. there is a remarkable synergy between the various elements. This promoted Pt catalyst catalyzes the alkylation of various sterically hindered anilines with both primary and secondary alcohols with high selectivities and acceptable conversions. [7]. It is remarkable that increasing steric demand either of the aniline or of the alcohol part, only marginally afifects conversion or selectivity. It seems quite reasonable to assume that enamines are involved also in this gas phase reaction. In the end, M. Rusek's very elegant process was not developed further. The two major reasons were the lack of a technical catalyst and the need for extensive (and therefore costly) changes in the production plant. 5. TOWARDS S'METOLACHLOR VIA ENANTIOSELECTIVE HYDROGENATION When it became clear that the two IS-enantiomers of metolachlor were responsible for most of the biological activity (see Fig. 1), there was the obvious challenge of finding a chemically and economically feasible production process for the active stereoisomers. Many methods allow the enantioselective synthesis of chiral molecules (that is the preferential formation of one enantiomer instead of the usual racemate). However, the selective preparation of ^-metolachlor was a formidable task, due to the very special structure and properties of this molecule and also because of the extremely eflBcient production process for the racemic product as described above. During the course of the development efforts, the following minimal requirements evolved for a technically viable catalytic system: ee >80%, substrate to catalyst ratio (s/c) >50'000 and turnoverfirequency(tof) >10'000 h'^.
25 5.1. Problem analysis and a first unsuccessful approach via enamide hydrogenation A careful aiialysis in 1982 lead to the conclusion that only an enantioselective catalytic process was feasible for an economical production of such large volumes . Further, the state of the art of enantioselective catalysis at that time indicated some chances of success for only two approaches: First, the hydrogenation of an enamide precursor of metolachlor (Figure 7) in analogy to the L-dopa process of Monsanto [8], even though nobody had ever tried to reduce such highly sterically hindered enamides using homogeneous chiral catalysts. Second, and more attractive from a practical point of view, the enantioselective hydrogenation of the imine intermediate that was produced in situ in the racemic reaction. However, enantioselective imine hydrogenation at that time was virtually unknown [9]. Accordingly, in 1982/3 we started to prepare all three isomers of the metolachlor-ermrmde shown in Figure 7. This was by no means easy and to our disappointment none of the catalysts described in the literature was active for the hydrogenation of either isomer and the feasibility study was terminated.
CHjOv,^^^
CH3O
[
CHjOv,^^^
CHjOx.
I
^
Figure 7. Enamide hydrogenation 5.2. The first success: Imine hydrogenation with Rh and Ir diphosphine complexes The next attempt at solving our problem was carried out in collaboration with a team at the University of British Columbia (UBC) who investigated the hydrogenation of both MEA and DMA imine with Rh diphosphine conq)lexes. They were indeed successful [10]: Under ambient conditions enantioselectivities in the range of 3 - 50% were obtained. The best optical yields of 69% ee were achieved using Rh(nbd)Cl]2/cycphos at -25°C (for Ugand structures see Figure 8). The best activities were observed in methanol/toluene but the maximum tof was only 15 hr^ at 65 bar, r.t., fer too low for an industrial application. Nevertheless, these results represented a remarkable progress for the enantioselective hydrogenation of N-aryl imines. Based on these results, we realized that the catalyst activity would be the critical issue. Therefore, F. Spindler, who was responsible for the project, was very much attracted by the results of Crabtree et al. who described an extraordinarily active Ir / tricyclohexylphosphine / pyridine catalyst that was able to hydrogenate even tetra substituted C=C bonds [11]. He decided to give iridium catalysts a try even though he was aware of their fest deactivation and
26 also of the very low activities of Ir diphosphine catalysts for the hydrogenation of enamides described by Brown [12]. The very first experiments with an in situ formed [Ir(cod)Cl]2/ diop catalyst were quite encouraging and an extensive screening of then available diphosphines, solvents, additives as well as an optimization of the reaction conditions was carried out. Here, we only summarize the best results [13], a more detailed report can be found in [14].
.CH,
R
0
^ R=CH3 (DMA-imine) R=C2l^5 (MEA-imine)
= H
xXi
PPhj PPH,
diop
bdpp
a
pph, cycphos ^PPh,
Figure 8. Imine hydrogenation: Structure of knines and of important ligands The highest optical yields were obtained with Ir-bdpp catalysts in presence of additional iodide (ee 84% at 0 °C) but the activity was disappointing. Better activities but with somewhat lower ee's were obtained for Ir-diop catalysts: Maximum turnover numbers of lO'OOO and higher, with an average tof of 250 h'^ could be achieved at 100 bar and 25 °C. When s/c ratios >10'000 were applied, the reaction did no longer go to completion. A major problem of these new Ir diphosphine catalysts was an irreversible catalyst deactivation. These results, especially the good enantioselectivities, were very promising and represented by fer the best catalyst performance for the enantioselective hydrogenation of imines at that time. Nevertheless, it was also clear that we could probably not reach our ambitious goals using Ir complexes with "classical" diphosphine ligands. Even though Ir/diop and Ir/bdpp catalysts showed much higher activities than the best Rh complexes for MEA imine, they were still far below the requirements: A new approach was clearly required. 6. A NEW LIGAND CLASS LEADS TO A PRODUCTION PROCESS Since we could not get stable catalysts with the known diphosphine ligands we started to test new types. Among others, we screened novel ferrocenyl-diphosphines (PPF) developed recently by Togni and Spindler [15]. Their mode of preparation (see Figure 9) allowed an eflScient fine tuning of the electronic and steric properties of the two phosphino groups, something
27 that is often very dfficult with other ligand classes. When they were tested in the hydrogenation of MEA imine there was a pleasant surprise: While the in situ catalyst derived from [Ir(cod)Cl]2 and the rather basic josiphos (R = Ph, R' = cyclohexyl) was not very active, the analogous catalysts with two diarylphosphino groups (R, R* = Ar) gave very promising results. Especially PPF-P(3,5-(CH3)2C6H3)2 (R = Ph, R = 3,5-xylyl) turned out to give an exceptionally active catalyst and, even more important, it did not deactivate!
Figure 9. Structure and preparation of ferrocenyl diphosphine ligands €250-1 o
rlOO 200*0010
1,200-
-80
^B
^^m
** 150-
-60
100-
-40 50*000
50-
-20
t best tof) e
200
15 1
1
1
Rh/ pAp
EZZDbesttof
-I
1
Ir/P'^P
1r/PPF
-r
-
A w
pilot results
Figure 10. Milestones of progress for the enantioselective hydrogenation of MEA imine (requirements: ee >80%, tof >10'000 h ^ s/c >50'000) In collaboration with H.P. Jalett and H.P. Buser, Spindler again carried out an extensive screening of diphosphines, solvents, additives as well as an optimization of the reaction conditions. Most remarkable was the effect observed when 30% of acetic acid were added to the reaction mixture resulting in a rate increase by a factor of 5 while the time for 100% conversion was more than 20 times shorter than without additives. Using optimized conditions, the isolated imine was hydrogenated at a hydrogen pressure of 80 bar and 50 °C using a substrate to catalyst ratio (s/c) of 750*000. Complete conversion was reached within 4 h. The
28
the initial tof exceeded I'SOO'OOO h"* and optical yields were >80%. I'OOO'OOO turnovers were achieved within 6 h. These results set a new standard for the enantioselective hydrogenation of imines (see Figure 10). One molecule of the Iridium catalyst can produce more than 500'000 molecules of S-NAA within two to three hours. The selectivity to the desired S-enantiomer is not extremely high but fulfills the requirement for the production of enantiometically enriched metolachlor. The technical handling of the organometallic catalyst precursor is rather easy, scale up presented no problems and at the moment, the production plant is being con:q)leted. 7. CONCLUSIONS The case history of this large volume herbicide demonstrates that * catalytic methods are very suitable for the synthesis of molecules of low to mediimi complexity in medium to large volumes as is often the case for agrochemicals. * imine hydrogenation is a very powerful synthetic method to produce sterically hindered Nalkyl anilines both chemo- and enantioselectively. The choice of the catalytic system is unusually important for getting the necessary high catalyst activities and selectivities. * catalysis by solid acid in the gas phase is unsuited for the alkylation of anilines with alcohols containing alkoxy groups. * a chiral switch fi'om the racemate to an enriched form is not only attractive for pharmaceuticals [16] but is also an inqx)rtant strategy for agrochemichals [17]. * the time for process development dependends very much on the state of the art of a given catalytic technology. It was quite short for the reductive alkylation, a well known method already in 1972, whereas it took more than 10 years to develop a suitable catalyst for the enantioselective imine hydrogenatioa * an empirical approach is the festest way to find or develop a catalytic system for a problem that has no close precedent. Mechanistic information is especially helpful in later stages of process development or for trouble shooting. 8. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The results described in this case history are due to the eJBForts of several teams of very dedicated chemists, engineers and technicians and we would like to acknowledge their contributions. Reductive alkylation process: C. Gremmelmaier, P. Flatt, P. Radimerski, A. Balmer. Alkylation process: M. Rusek, B. Casagrande. Enantioselective hydrogenation: H.P. Buser, R. Hanreich, H.P. Jalett, U. Pittelkow, B. Pugin, F. Spindler, A. Wirth-Tijani, B. Eng, R. HSusel, S. Maurer, M. Parak, G. Thoma, N. Vostenka.
29 9. REFERENCES 1 2 3 4 5
6
7 8 9
10
11 12 13 14
15 16 17
C. Vogel, R. Aebi, DP 23 28 340 (Ciba-Geigy AG, 1972). H. Moser, G. Ryhs, H. Sauter, Z. Naturforsch. 37b (1982) 451. a) M. Freifelder, Practical Catalytic Hydrogenation, Wiley-Interscience, 1971; b) P.N. Rylander, Catalytic Hydrogenation over Platinum Metals, Academic Press, 1967. US 3,336,386 (Uniroyal Inc., 1967): Sulfidation of catalyst leads to higher selectivity for imine hydrogenation. Sulfided catalyst are not stable for storage. Therefore, sulfidation has either to be carried out just before the start of the reaction or the inhibitor has to be added to the reaction solution. In addition, most sulfidation procedures are not easy to reproduce. Interestingly, this process was patented only much later when several patents describing less efficient syntheses of NAA had been published by other groups: R. Bader; P. Flatt, P. Radimerski, EP 605363-Al (Ciba-Geigy AG, 1992). M. Rusek, Stud. Surf Sci. Catal. 59 (1991) 359. D. Vineyard, W. Knowles, M. Sabacky, G. Bachmann, D. Weinkau£ J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 99 (1977) 5946. For recent overviews on enantioselective imine hydrogenations see H. U. Blaser and F. Spindler, ChimicaOggi, 1995, June, p. 11; H. U. Blaser and F. Spindler, Proceedings of Chiral Europe *94 Symposium, Spring Innovations, Stockport, UK, 1994, p. 69. W.R. Cullen, M.D. Fryzuk, B.R. James, G. Kang, J.P. Kutney, R. Spogliarich, I.S. Thorbum, US 4,996,361 (Ciba-Geigy AG, 1987); W. R. CuUen, M. D. Fryzuk, B. R. James, J. P. Kutney, G-J. Kang, G. Herb, I. S. Hiorbum and R. Spogliarich, J. Mol. Catal. 62 (1990) 243. R. Crabtree, H. Felkin, T. Fellebeen-Khan and G. Morris, J. Organometal. Chem. 168 (1979) 183. N. Alcock, J.M. Brown, A. Derome and A. Lucy, J. Chem Soc, Chem Commun. (1985) 575. F. Spindler and B. Pugin, EP Patent 0256982 (Ciba-Geigy AG, 1988); F. Spindler, B. Pugin and H. U. Blaser, Angew. Chem Int. Ed. Engl. 29 (1990) 558 . F. Spindler, B. Pugin, H.P. Jalett, H.P. Buser, U. Pittelkow and H.U. Blaser, in Catalysis of Organic Reactions, R.E. Malz Ed., Marcel Dekker Inc., New York, 1996, p.153. A. Togni, C. Breutel, A. Schnyder, F. Spkidler, H. Landert and A. Tijani, J. Am. Chem Soc. 116(1994)4061. S.C. Stinson, C&EN October 9 (1995) 45. G. M. Ramos Tombo and D. Bellus, Angew. Chem 103 (1991) 1219. H.P. Fischer, HP. Buser, P. Chemla, P. Huxley, W. Lutz, S. Mirza, G.M. Ramos Tombo, G. Van Lommen and V. Sipido, Bull. Soc. Chim Belg. 103 (1994) 565.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
31
Heterogeneous vs. Homogeneous Catalysis in Manufacturing of Terbinafine A Case Study for Route Selection of an Industrial Process Ulrich Beutler, Christian Fleury, Peter C, Fiinfschilling, Gerhard Penn*, Thomas Ryser and Berthold Schenkel Sandoz Pharma Ltd., Technical Research & Development, Process Development Department CH-4002 Basle, Switzerland
Abstract The antimycotic agent terbinafine can be prepared from the vinylchloride 1 and tert.-butylacetylene 2 using different homogeneous or heterogeneous palladium-catalysts. Alternatively terbinafine was synthesized from the aUyl acetate 3 and N-methyl-N-(a-methylnaphtyl)-amine 4 with the aid of a polystyrene-supported Pd(PPh3)4-catalyst. AU processes gave terbinafine in high yield and stereoselectivity. For the selection of a new production process of terbinafine ecological, economical, and technical aspects are compared.
1. INTRODUCTION Terbinafine is an antimycotic agent, which is registered with the brand-name Lamisil®. Lamisn® is well tolerated and is used in topical and oral form for the treatment of fungal infections [1]. Terbinafine is the first manufactured drug substance containing an (£)-l,3-enyne substructure [2]. The former synthesis followed a 6-step sequence using the very toxic and nasty starting materials acrolein and phosphorus pentachloride [3]. In order to overcome the handling of these compounds and to reduce the number of process steps we have developed inter alia two synthesis for terbinafine using palladium catalyzed coupling-steps for the construction of the molecule. The advantages and disadvantages of the different couplingroutes are discussed. 2. EXPERIMENTAL 2.1 Catalysts As heterogeneous catalyst polystyrene-supported Pd(PPh3)4 [4] was used. The catalyst contained 0.7 weight-% of Pd after exchange reaction with Pd(PPh3)4. For experiments under homogeneous conditions Pd(PPh3)2Q2 or Pd(PPh3)4 were used as catalysts. Copper(I) iodide was used as co-catalyst.
32 2.2 Catalytic experiments (scheme 1) Careful exclusion of oxygen is necessary in all experiments (argon atmosphere). Heterogeneous experiments were performed in glass-reactors with conventional stirring or in loopreactors pumping the educt^roduct-solution over a bed of polymer-supported catalyst. Preparative homogeneous experiments were performed in glass-reactors following a standard protocol [5,6] whereas kinetic experiments with Pd(PPh3)4 or Pd(PPh3)2Q2 were performed in a copper autoclave. All analyses of product mixtures were done with the aid of GLC (internal standard method for quantitative measurements). Scheme 1
AcO
-=CH
'^Xi
2
homogendous or hetorogerraous Pck^atalyst / Cul
polymer-suppoiled Pcksatalyst
solverit butylamine / water
solvent methanol
Ha
Terbinafine
2.3 Synthesis of starting materials (scheme 2) Vinylchloride 1 can be prepared in a one-step reaction from N-methyl-N-(a-methylnaphtyl)-amine 4 and (E)-l,3-dichloro-propene in high yield [7]. The latter is commercially available or can be separated from an E/Z-mixture via rectification. Allyl acetate 3 was prepared by the following manner: tert.-butyl-acetylene was converted into the Grignard-compound with n-butyl-magnesium chloride followed by reaction with epichlorohydrin. Treatment of the resulting chlorohydrin 6 with NaOH in water gave the epoxide 7 in good overall yield. Isomerisation of 7 was achieved with butyllithium/ N J»J,N'^'tetramethyl-ethylenediamine in THF at -60 °C. Acetylation of the resulting allyHc alcohol with acetic anhydride furnished the required 6,6-dimethyl-hept-2-en-4-yne-l-yl acetate 3 as a 9:1
33
E/Z-mixture. The minor Z-isomer is the lower boiling component and pure E-isomer can be obtained via rectification. Scheme 2 I C I N X ^ / - CI NaOH 70-90'»C
-=CH
I.BuMgCI
:
^.
o
HO
2. ^—y
01
/20»G 01
6
NaOH,20*C
1.BuLI/TMEDA,-60*»C AcO 3
2. ACaO/NEtj
'' _^_ \7 o
E/Zca.9:1
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 3.1 Reactions with homogeneous catalysis Coupling of tert.-butyl-acetylene 2 with vinylchloride 1 under homogeneous conditions in the presence of 0.05 mol-% of Pd(PPh3)2a2 or Pd(PPh3)4 and 5 mol-% of Cul in butylamine as solvent at 60 °C gave terbinafine-base 5 in > 95 % yield and excellent stereoselectivity. Kinetic experiments of this quite exothermic reaction have shown, that water has a slight influence on the rate of the reaction. First experiments were performed with Pd(PPh3)4 as catalyst. A model based on a kinetic first order in 1, 2, and the concentrations of the catalysts permits to describe the reaction rate in the whole of the concentration domain (equation 1). A slight reduction of the reaction rate constant after 80% conversion of 1 was observed. This can be explained by the the slight temperature increase observed at the beginning due to the fast exothermic reaction. A possible mechanism for the reaction imply the reversible formation of activated complexes between Cu"^ and 2 as well as Pd(PPh3)4 and 1. A quasi stationarity assumption (Bodenstein kinetics) for these activated complexes permitted to derive a kinetic model which was simplified in further steps.The reaction orders werefittedwith computer modeling for the
34
four species according to equation 1. The reaction orders were in all cases not significandy different from 1. -
^
= ^1 [ n [2 ] [Cul\ {Pd(PPh,),l
(1)
The system using Pd(PPh3)2Cl2 as a catalyst was studied in more details. An experimental plan with 3-4 levels (30 - 40 experiments) was designed. The concentrations of Cul, Pd(PPh3)2Q2, butylamine, water, 1, and 2, as well as the temperature and the reaction time were varied. The reaction should be first order in 1, 2, Cul, and Pd(PPh3)2Q2. However, the fit of the kinetic model with equation 1 was not as good as for the system using Pd(PPh3)4. It can be supposed, that the reduction of Pd(PPh3)2Q2 by 2 to a Pd^-species at the beginning of the reaction may produce different catalyst activities depending on the reaction conditions. Tert.butyl-acetylene can serve as reducing agent under formation of 2,2,7,7-tetramethyl-3,5octadiyne. The reaction rate is also dependent on the concentration of water and butylamine. A maximum reaction rate is obtained at a water concentration of about 1 mol/l. A linear model was adapted for determining the influence of the reaction conditions on the selectivity. The Cul-concentration does not affect the selectivity of the reaction, while an increase in the Pd(PPh3)2Q2-concentration reduces significandy the selectivity. The selectivity decreases slowly with time, since the product 5 reacts slowly to minor amounts of side products. The selectivity decreases also slighdy with increasing temperature and increasing excess of acetylene 2. 3.2 Reactions with heterogeneous catalysis Reaction of 1 with tert.-butyl-acetylene in presence of 0.36 mol-% of polystyrene-supported Pd(PPh3)4-catalyst gave terbinafine-base 5 with 90 % yield and excellent stereoselectivity. However, the turnover-rate of the re-used catalyst dropped dramatically in the second and third mn. A prolonged reaction time is necessary for complete conversion (table 1). Table 1 Influence of re-used polymer-supported Pd(PPh3)4-catalyst on the reaction time. Conditions: T = 40 ""C, 0.36 mol-% Pd-catalyst, 6 mol % Cul, butylamine as solvent mn
conversion
reaction time [h]
ration E/Z of 5
1 2 3
99.9% 97.6 % 98.7 %
17 40 68
99.6: 0.4 99.6:0.4 99.6: 0.4
Analysis of the crude product after thefirstmn showed a contamination of ca. 850 ppm of palladium. At the same time the polymer-supported catalyst contained up to 3 % of copper. Thus, a copper-palladium exchange led to the observed decrease of the catalyst activity. An altemative to the above discussed preparation of terbinafine is the palladium-catalyzed coupling of the allyl acetate 3 with N-methyl-N-(a-methyln2^htyl)-amine 4 [8]. This reaction
35
can be performed in a loop-reactor, where the reaction solution is pumped over a bed of polymer-supported Pd(PPh3)4-catalyst. The reaction proceeds very smoothly with 0.08 mol-% of Pd-catalyst at 50 °C in methanol as solvent. Starting from 99.5 % pure (E)-allyl acetate 3 the yield of 5 was 90 %. However, the E/Z-ratio of the product was only 97 : 3. The cycle can be repeated several times without loss of catalyst activity. 3.3 Route selection For the selection of the final production process ecological, economical, and technical aspects were compared. Criteria for the route-selection were: catalyst activity, stability and storage properties of the catalyst, number of reaction steps of the different processes, concepts of metal recovery and recycle, safety aspects of the coupling reactions, and other more. Table 2 Comparison of different routes to terbinafine route
reaction sequence
number of steps
catalyst
comment
A
4^1-^5
2
Pd(PPh3)4/CuI (homogeneous)
Pd-catalyst less stable
B
4-^l->5
2
Pd(PPh3)2a2/CuI (homogeneous)
catalyst stable and commercially available
C
4-^1-^5
2
Pd(PPh3)4 -polymer catalyst activity decreases very rapidly /Cul (heterogeneous)
D
2-^6-^7-^3-»5
4
Pd(PPh3)4-polymer (heterogeneous)
stable catalytic system but less selective coupling reaction and more reaction steps
Route B was chosen as the superior process since a stable, commercially available catalyst can be used at very low molar concentration (technically superior) [9]. The number of reaction steps in route B is lower than in route D and the E/Z-selectivity is significantly higher. Thus, route B is more economical. All metals can be recovered and recycled. REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
G. Petranyi, N.S. Ryder, A. Stiitz, Science 1984,224,1239. A. Stutz, Angew. Chem. 1987,99, 323. A. Stiitz, G. Petrani, J. Med. Chem. 1984, 27,1539. B.M. Trost, E. Keinan, J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 1978,100,7779. Review: K. Sonogashira, Comprehensive Organic Synthesis, Vol. 3, p 521, Pergamon Press, 1990. V. Ratovelomana, G. Linstrumelle, Synth. Commun. 1991, i i , 917. D. Chemin, G. Linstrumelle, Tetrahedron 1994,50,5335. U. Beutler, J. Mazacek, G. Penn, B. Schenkel, D. Wasmuth, Chimia 1996,50,154. For a preliminary communication of this reaction see ref. 2. Route B is also superior to a recently published synthesis of terbinafine (5 mol-% of Pd(PhCN)2Q2 as catalyst). See: M. Alami, F. Ferri, Y. Gaslain, Tetrahedron Lett. 1996,37,57.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
37
Multiple use of Palladium in a homogeneous and a consecutive heterogeneous catalytic reaction. P. Baumeister", W. Meyer\ K. Oertle", G. Seifert^ U. Siegrist" and H. Steiner^ 'Scientific Services CIBA-GEIGY AG, CH-4002 Basel, Switzerland ^Crop Protection Division CIBA-GEIGY AG, CH-4002 Basel, Switzerland ' Central Research CIBA-GEIGY AG, CH-4002 Basel, Switzerland
1. SUMMARY The Pd^^)-catalyzed reaction of aryl diazonium salts with monosubstituted alkenes [1] was found to be an interesting alternative to the weUknown Pd - catalyzed arylhalide alkene coupling (Heck t5^e reaction) or the copper mediated reaction of aryl diazonium salts with alkenes (Meerwein arylation) [2]. The reaction can be run without isolation of the diazonium salt in presence of only 0.5 to 1 mol% of the Palladium catalyst in a one pot procedure, in high jdeld and under mild conditions. The resulting styrene is reduced in a subsequent hydrogenation step with an in situ generated heterogeneous Pd-catalyst. The combination of three reaction steps without isolation of intermediates and the virtually complete recovery of the Pd-metal at the end of the reaction sequence makes this process [4] extremely efficient.
"
^
2
3
Figure 1. Reaction-Scheme
2. INTRODUCTION Benzenesulfonates carr3dng alkyl- substituents in ortho position to the suLfonato-group are intermediates in the synthesis of a new class [3] of potent herbicides. More conventional synthetic routes as, e.g. Friedel-Crafts alkylation fail to yield these products at economically acceptable costs.
38 Starting from readily available aniline-2-sulfonic acid we have developed a highly "atom efficient" production process for sodium-[2-(3',3',3'- trifluoropropl'-yl)]-benzenesulfonate based on the combination of three different reactions, among them a homogeneous and a heterogeneous Pd-catalyzed step.
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The arylation of trifluoropropene with the diazonium salt of aniline-2sulfonic acid proceeds with extraordinary ease due to the outstanding reactivity of the olefinic compound and the relative stabiUty of the diazonium salt. The temperature must be set at a range where the relative rate of the arylation reaction versus decomposition of the diazonium salt is high. Experiments performed under elevated pressure (not cited here) showed the catalyst to develop its highest productivity under conditions with high olefin concentration. The low solubility of a gaseous olefin can be overcome, either by increasing the pressure, or by selecting a solvent with favorable solvating properties. In this work we found Pd(dba)2 to be the preferred catalystprecursor, since it is easily prepared according to the literature [5,6] by reacting an aqueous solution of H2PdCl4 with dibenzyhdeneaceton (dba). Contrary to the weU known classical Heck-type arylation with arylhalides, the so called Matsuda variation does not require the use of phosphine Ugands. Contacting the reaction mass with hydrogen gas after the completion of the arylation step, optionally by adding activated carbon as a carrier, generates a heterogeneous Pd on carbon catalyst with sufficient activity to hydrogenate the styrene formed. After the filtration of the catalyst, the product is isolated from the filtrate in very high yield. The Pd used to form the Pd(dba)2-precursor was reclaimed nearly without any losses (Pd-yield: 95%) after work up of the spent catalyst by incineration [7].
4. EXPERIMENTAL Preparation of diazosulfonate Aniline-2-sulfonic acid, is slurried in dry ethanoic acid at room temperature. Sulfuric acid is added to the reaction mixture. At between 18 and 20 °C aqueous sodium nitrite solution is added dropwise to the reaction mixture. After all nitrite is consumed, ethanoic anhydride is added and the resulting suspension is cooled to between 12 and 15 °C. Preparation of sodium-[2-(3',3\3'trifluoroprop-l'-enyl)]'benzenesulfonate At that temperature sodium acetate is added and stirring is continued at room temperature. Pd(dba)2 is added and 3,3,3-triQuoropropene is bubbled in. After the end of the mildly exothermic reaction no more nitrogen is evolved. The ethanoic acid is distilled off and the residue is dissolved in water.
39
Preparation of sodium'[2'(3',3',3'' trifluoroprop'l'-yl)]-benzenesulfonate The solution is transferred into a hydrogenation flask and activated carbon is added. Under the hydrogen atmosphere the heterogeneous catalyst is formed and the catalytic hydrogenation is carried out. The palladium containing catalyst is separated by filtration and washed with water. The aqueous solution of the product is concentrated in vacuo, the remaining ethanoic acid is neutralized and after cooUng to room temperature the precipitated product is filtered of and washed with NaCl brine. The wet cake is dried and the identity is confirmed by ^HNMR. The yield is higher than 90% for each individual step.
5. CONCLUSIONS The high potential of a skillful combination of different catalytic and noncatalytic steps to a high performing process is exemplified in the present work. The main achievements are: Accessibility of an intermediate in high 5rield and purity, which is not available economically and/or ecologically by more conventional synthetic methods. Low catalyst costs: (i) By using Pd(dba)2 as the catalyst-precursor for the Heck arylation step, prepared from readily available Palladium salts (aqueous H2PdCl4 solution). (ii) Use of the same Palladium for two different catalytic reactions by in situ generation of a heterogeneous Pd/C hydrogenation catalyst from the Heckreaction mass. (iii) Quantitative separation of the Palladium from the product stream by filtration of the spent hydrogenation catalyst (95% Pd reclaimed after refining).
REFERENCES 1 K. Kikukawa, K. Nagira, F. Wada and T.Matsuda, Tetrahedron, 37 (1981) 31. 2 C.S. Rondestvest, Organic Reactions, 11 (1960) 189; 24 (1977) 225. 3 W. Meyer and K. Oertle, EP 120'814 (to Ciba-Geigy AG), 1984. 4 P. Baumeister, G. Seifert and H. Steiner, EP 584^043 (to Ciba-Geigy AG), 1992. 5 M.F. Rettig and P.M. Maitlis, Inorg. Synth., 1990, 28, 110. 6 Y. Takahashi, T. Ito, S. Sakai and Y. Ishii, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Comm., (1970) 17, 1065. 7 Data from workup of large amounts of spent catalyst by DEGUSSA
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
41
THE OPTIMIZATION OF THE CATALYTIC HYDROGENATION OF HYDROXYBENZAMIDINES TO BENZAMIDINES Mike G. Scarosa, Peter K. Yonana and Scott A. Lanemanb a G. D. SEARLE Skokie, IL 60077, USA bNSC Technologies, Mount Prospect, IL 60056, USA Abstract The hydrogenation of hydroxybenzamidine to benzamidine has been investigated with various catalysts and solvents. It was determined that palladium was the catalyst of choice, however, when employed with glacial acetic acid as the solvent, colloidal palladium was generated. When the solvent system was changed to water with 5 equivalents of acetic acid the colloidal problem was eliminated and the hydrogenation rate increased. The isolation of the benzamidine from water/acetone was instrumental in eliminating a key impurity. The various steps leading to a large scale manufacturing process are also discussed.
NH2
HO Ac
Results and Discussion Initial investigations successfully employed conditions using 4% Pd/C as catalyst at 60 °C and 60 psig hydrogen pressure in glacial acetic acid (Scheme I). The use of acetic acid served two purposes. Acetic acid was a good solubilizing solvent for the hydroxybenzamidine and it improved the reaction rate by either protonation of the hydroxyl group or by formation of an N-acetoxy intermediate by proton-catalyzed esterification. Both of these would produce a better leaving group during catalysis. Scheme I
5'"Y
If NH2
NR
4% Pd/C, HOAc
'NR H
60 °C, 60 psig H2
NH2 HOAc
42
The reduction of hydroxybenzamidine to benzamidine was studied with various acids, both organic and inorganic. A summary of reactions performed is Hsted in Table I. In general, the reaction proceeded very well when organic acids were employed. Organic acids, such as methanesulfonic acid, L-tartaric acid and acetic acid, produced benzamidine in good yields. Inorganic acids, such as HCl and HBr, resulted in poor reaction rates and incomplete reactions. As can be seen in Table I, the best conditions were found when acetic acid was used as a solvent. One possible reaction pathway of the reduction involved the formation of the N-acetoxy intermediate prior to hydrogenation, as shown in Scheme II. Proton-catalyzed esterification of hydroxybenzamidine would produce the "N-acetoxy derivative" with the respective organic acid which would then be carried onward to benzamidine by catalytic hydrogenolysis of the N-0 bond. This may explain why hydrogenation proceeded better with organic acids compared to inorganic acids. However, one should not overlook the possibility that halide ion can poison catalysts and inhibit certain hydrogenationsCil. Table I: 1 Catalyst
Conditions for initial experiments for the hydrogenation of hydroxybenzamidine to benzamidine. Catalyst Temp. Solvent Acid Isolated Yields H2 Load (%) Press. (%)
0
1
60^
30 91
1 1
60 psig
6or
81
HBr
60 psig
60°C
EtOH[a]
HCl
60 psig
1 1
18
EtOHW
MsOH
60 psig
88
1
12
EtOH/H20
6or 6or 6or
0 0 91[c]
1
1 5% Pt/C
43
EtOH[a]
HOAc
5 psig
23 °C
1 5% Pt/C
50
3A EtOH[b]
HOAc
60 psig
23r
1 4% Pd/C
20
HOAc
HOAc
60 psig
1 4% Pd/C
18
MeOH
L-Tartaric Acid
4% Pd/C
18
EtOH[a]
1 4% Pd/C
18
1 4% Pd/C 1 4% Pd/C a. b.
60 psig
Anhydrous ethanol 95% ethanol denatured with methanol
Hydrogenation of N-acetoxy derivative.
Scheme II ^
NRAC20^
H2N.
HO
^N
THE, 60 "C
rT^v
rrV^NR
%>' H
HaN^A^
O H
AcO"
4% Pd/C
H2(60psig)
^
H2O, EtOH^ H g N V ^ 60 T
KT"^,,
fY NH
r^^ ^ C
N-Acetoxy derivative
Early studies probing a possible mechanism centered around the synthesis and reduction of the N-acetoxy intermediate. The N-acetoxy derivative was synthesized, as shown in Scheme II, by heating hydroxybenzamidine with AC2O in THF at 60 °C. The reaction mixture was a slurry from start to finish producing N-acetoxy in -88% yield. Hydrogenation of the N-acetoxy intermediate in EtOH with 4% Pd/C produced benzamidine in - 9 1 % yield. The N-acetoxy intermediate could be produced in situ during the hydrogenation by performing the reaction in the presence of 2 equivalents of AC2O in glacial acetic acid. This procedure had previously been
43
reported for the reduction of similar hydroxybenzamidines to benzamidines[2,3] The preferred catalyst was Pd/C (see Table I) with an organic acid (acetic acid), since platinum was more expensive and reduced the hydroxybenzamidine slowly. Colloidal Palladium It became very evident that during the course of the hydrogenation in acetic acid a small amount of colloidal palladium was being generated and that colloidal palladium was contaminating the isolated benzamidine. High RPMs and the use of a sparger to deliver the hydrogen at a high concentration to the surface of the catalyst (mass transfer) minimized colloidal palladium. "Palladium can be rendered insoluble if the metal (reduced metallic palladium or unreduced palladium oxide catalyst) can be maintained as a hydride during catalytic reduction. This can only occur if the rate of hydrogen arrival at the metal surface is greater than the rate of consumption"[4]. Potential solutions for improving mass transfer include the following: * Low catalyst loading
*
High hydrogen pressure
* Low temperature
*
HighRPM's
* Sparging of the hydrogen
*
Low substrate concentration
The only practical solutions were the sparging of the hydrogen and high RPM's. These were tried in the laboratory and incorporated in our pilot plant campaign. Unfortunately, while it was successful in lowering the colloidal content it was not sufficient to reduce the colloidal amount below the required 10 ppm. At about this time we became aware of a new product from Degussa, a macroporous organofunctional polysiloxane chemically bonded thiourea (DELOXAN) THP® that had a high affinity to precious and heavy metals. The manufacturer claimed that the use of the resin, either in suspension or in a fixed-bed, resulted in removal of metals from aqueous or organic solutions. When a small amount of the Deloxan resin was added to the filtered hydrogenation solution containing high amounts of colloidal palladium, stirred and filtered, the palladium content of the filtrate dropped well below the 10 ppm level (Table II). Table II:
Colloidal Palladium Levels Before/after Deloxan Resin Treatment^
Colloidal Palladium Level Before Resin Treatment
1
1 1 1 1 1 a b
(ppm)
^^^ ^^-^ ^^^ ^^-^ 15.8
Colloidal Palladium Level After Resin Treatment (ppm)b
<3.2
1
<5 <5
1 1
<7.5
<6.6
1
9.9 g of Deloxan (on a dry basis) per 100 g of benzamide ( quantity was not optimized), The level of detected Pd is dependent on the quantity of the sample assayed. The above levels would have been lower if larger samples were assayed.
44
Symmetrical Urea During the course of the piloting an intermediate in the synthetic sequence, 5% of symmetrical urea impurity was formed (see structure below). Various attempts to remove the impurity at the subsequent step were unsuccessful.
Symmetrical urea Fortunately, based on our earlier experience with sulfonic acid resins, it was decided to try a resin treatment of the hydrogenation filtrate. The strategy being that the acid resin would adsorb the synmietrical urea in preference to benzamidines. Several acid resins were tried, which included Dowex 5x8-200, Dowex 5x2-200, Aberlite 15, and Bio-Rad Chelex 100. The resin which was found to be the most effective was the Dowex 5x2-200. The resin treatment was successful in lowering the symmetrical urea to < 1%. New Hydrogenation Process In our continued effort to improve the hydrogenation/isolation step, a hydrogenation process that employed water as a solvent with 5 equivalents of glacial acetic acid at 60 psig hydrogen pressure and 50 °C (vs 60 °C) using a more active 5% Pd/C catalyst was developed. The new process had the following advantages over the acetic acid solvent method: 1. Shorter hydrogenation time, i.e., 2 h vs 16 h 2. Palladium levels < 1 ppm without Deloxan treatment
Isolation Process The isolation of the benzamidines as done originally by Searle's Discovery group was carried out by removal of the glacial acetic acid by vacuum distillation followed by the crystallization from a mixture of MeOH, EtOH and CH3CN. An intermediate process that was developed for this isolation involved the removal of the majority of the glacial acetic acid by vacuum distillation and recystallization of the residue from a mixture of glacial acetic acid and IPA in the ratio of 1 g of crude residue to 2 mL of glacial acetic acid to 12 mL of IPA. While this process was doable it was less than ideal. Subsequently, a new process employing water/acetone instead of acetic acid/IPA for the crystallization/isolation of benzamidines was developed. This hydrogenation was run more concentrated, i.e., 28% concentration (based on grams of hydroxybenzamidines/mls water) as compared to 10-20% used in the previous process. The optimum ratio for the crystallization i.e., addition of acetone to the aqueous filtrate was 1 g of benzamidines to 3.8 mL of water to 9 mL of acetone. The advantages of this change were:
45 3. 4.
1. Higher isolation throughput. 2. Eliminated water distillation.
Reduced processing time. Higher purity and yield.
Table III reports the results of yield and purity profile of the new hydrogenation process. The results of the isolated benzamidine clearly demonstrate the advantages of the new hydrogenation/isolation process as shown by the higher yields and purities. An additional problem has been with the aromatic amide (see structure below) that is produced in an earlier step. Table III clearly indicates an almost total elimination of aromatic amide in benzamidine when the water/acetone method is used.
Aromatic Amide
Table III
Typical hydrogenation results[a] Analysis after Hydrogenation (crude) HPLC area%
Lot
Benzamidine
5
60
50
5
60
50
5% Pd/C 10 5% Pd/C 10
(%)
1 ^ 1 ^ a
Hydrogenation pressure (psig)
Temp. (°C)
Eq. of Acetic Acid
Catalyst (Loading)
Analysis after crystallization HPLC area%
Aromatic Amide
Benzamidine
Aromatic Amide
98.53
1.14
99.71
0.06
86.2 1
98.54
1.18
99.71
0.09
84.5 II
Yield
(%)
The hydroxybenzamidine was 97.59% (area) pure by HPLC and contained 1.43% aromatic amide.
Experimental Typical preparation of the Benzamidines Procedure: A 250 ml Parr Shaker bottle was charged with 0.05 moles of hydroxybenzamidine, 4.0 g of 5% Pd/C (50% water wet) and 60 ml of deionized water containing 0.25 moles of acetic acid. The Parr shaker was purged with nitrogen and hydrogen. The reaction was shaken and hydrogenated under a constant hydrogen pressure of 60 psig and 50 °C for 4 h. The reaction was initially a slurry but as hydrogenation proceeded the product dissolved in the water. Upon completion, the hydrogen was vented and a nitrogen atmosphere was applied to the reaction vessel. A sample was then taken for HPLC analysis to confirm reaction completion. The catalyst was then removed by hot filtration (50 °C) through a layer of powdered cellulose and the catalyst was washed with 10 ml of hot deionized water. The filtrate was placed in 500 ml 3neck RB flask fitted with a thermometer, addition funnel and reflux condenser and heated to 50-
46 55 °C. Then 160 ml of room temperature acetone was added over 30 min while maintaining 5055 °C. The suspension was cooled to 5 °C after acetone addition and maintained at 5 °C for 1 h. The resulting crystallized product was collected by filtration and washed with 30 ml of acetone. The product was dried at 50 °C in a vacuum oven (-80 kpa) for 24 h to give the corresponding benzamidine in yields of 80-85% with a purity of >99% by HPLC. Conclusion An improved procedure for the hydrogenation of hydroxybenzamidines to benzamidines and their isolation was developed. The advantages are: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Shorter hydrogenation time. Elimination of colloidal palladium contamination. Higher hydrogenation and isolation throughput. Reduced processing time. Higher purity and yield.
The improvements addressed above were instrumental in making large scale hydrogenation/isolation feasible and economical. Acknowledgements The 4% Pd/C and 5% Pt/C catalysts were obtained from Degussa and the 5% Pd/C catalyst was obtained from Johnson Matthey. The authors would like to thank James Groce and Richard Frost for performing the HPLC analyses. References 1.) P. N. Rylander, Catalytic Hydrogenation over Platinum Metals, Academic Press, New York, 1967, p. 18. 2.) B. D. Judkins, D. G. Allen, T. A. Cook, B. Evans, and T. E. Sardharwala, Synthetic Communications, 26, 4351-4367 (1996). 3.) C. D. Eldred, B. Evans, S. Hindley, B. D. Judkins, H. A. Kelly, J. Kitchin, P. Lumley, B. Porter, B. C. Ross, K. J. Smith, N. R. Taylor, and J. R. Wheatcraft, /. Med. Chem., 37, 3882 (1994). 4.) A. J. Bird, and D. T. Thompson, Catalysis in Organic Reactions (W. H. Jones ed.). Academic Press, New York, 1980, pp. 61-106.
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
47
Catalytic hydrogenation reactors for the fine chemicals industries. Their design and operation K.R. Westerterp", E.J. Molga^ and K.B. van Gelder' ^) Chemical Reaction Engineering Laboratories, Faculty of Chemical Engineering, University of Twente, P.O. Box 217, 7500 AE Enschede, the Netheriands ^) Chemical and Process Engineering Department, Warsaw Technical University, ul. Warynskiego 1, 00-645 Warsaw, Poland ') Dow Benelux N. V., PDCD, P.O. Box 48, 4530 AA Terneuzen, the Netheriands ABSTRACT Design and operation of reactors for catalytic hydrogenation in the fine chemical industries are discussed. The requirements for a good multiproduct catalytic hydrogenation unit as well as the choice of the reactor type are considered. Packed bed bubble column reactors operated without hydrogen recycle are recommended as the best choice to obtain a flexible reactor with good selectivities. The results of an experimental study of the catalytic hydrogenation of 2,4-dinitrotoluene (DNT) in a miniplant installation are presented to prove that the maximum yield in such a reactor can be achieved without a hydrogen recycle and with a hydrogen supply somewhat higher than the stoichiometric amount. Some characteristic properties of the reactor system and the influence of the reactor pressure and the hydrogen supply ratio are elucidated. Introduction In fine chemicals industries the so-called Bechamps reaction was widely spread for hydrogenation reactions. Here hydrogen is produced by the interaction of Fe or Zn powder and hydrochloric acid, producing very active hydrogen. This reaction is executed in the batch mode in the liquid phase. The reaction rate can be controlled by the addition rate of the metal powder and the reaction occurs at low temperatures. These properties made it the most important hydrogenation tool for fine chemicals. Regretfully large amounts of waste materials are being coproduced after neutralization, like iron hydroxide sludges and neutralization salts, both often contaminated with organic chemicals. The amounts of waste materials are often 5 to 20 times larger than the amount of desired chemicals produced. This waste problem demanded for environmental protection measures and therefore catalytic hydrogenation came under consideration also in the fine chemicals industries. Catalytic hydrogenation, of course, for many years has been applied in bulk chemical processes in specially designed reactors. For fine chemicals a reactor installation is normally used for many different chemicals and production series usually last only from a few days to a few weeks, so that in the same installation often 10 to 30 different chemical reactions are executed in the course of a year. Production quantities are so small, that the construction of a unit dedicated to a single product is economically not feasible. So multiproduct use is a conditio sine qua non, also for a catalytic hydrogenation unit for fine chemicals. In our laboratories therefore a large experimental and theoretical study has been made to determine the most economical method to change from Bechamps to catalytic hydrogenation reactors [1]. To this end a number of possible reactor types has been tested and here, we will report on our initial considerations to come to a selection, discuss the arguments pro and contra for certain solutions and the final choice made. We will also report on experimental work to corroborate our selection, the continuously operated, packed bubble column reactorfilledwith a packed catalyst bed and with hydrogen feed rates, slightly higher than the stoichiometrically required amount.
48
Requirements for a good multiproduct catalytic hydrogenation reactor for fine chemicals For catalytic hydrogenations we usually are concerned with three phases: gaseous hydrogen, an, often dissolved, component to be hydrogenated in the liquid phase and a heterogeneous solid catalyst. Homogeneous catalysis is not very widespread. A number of good three phase reactors is available in process industries. Therefore we will restrict ourselves to the classical three phase reactors which already have proven their value in bulk chemicals processes. However, for fine chemicals applications a number o^special requirements have to be met, which will be discussed in detail below. Catalyst, suitable for many reactions In a multiproduct unit a multiproduct catalyst should be applied. Quick changing of catalyst is difficult. Slurry catalysts, of course, can be washed out and filtered off, but also here their removal is time consuming and specially for expensive catalysts,filtrationwith a high efficiency is difficult to achieve and slow. Filtration can be avoided if a stationary bed of catalyst particles is used, but also the change of afixedbed catalyst is time consuming. Therefore, it is preferred to keep the catalyst in the reactor system. In order to avoid the replacement by each time different catalysts, peferably one catalyst must be used for all different hydrogenation reactions to be executed. Ni, Pt and Pd catalysts are all rather universal and the choice of the most suitable catalyst depends on the production programme. We tested all three and selected Pd. Ni catalysts are cheaper, but for our applications demanded for higher temperatures and hydrogen pressures to achieve the same conversion rates as with Pd catalysts. In the selection of a catalyst also possible deactivation must be considered and methods be developed to regenerate the catalyst in an economic way. A universal method of heat removal Hydrogenation reactions usually are very exothermic. Therefore much cooling area must be installed in the reactor per unit of volume and also agitation levels must be high in order to obtain high heat transfer coefficients. This demands for extensive and complicated cooling coils or externally located circulating coolers for batch equipment. Further mixing and/or recirculation may influence the selectivity in a process. As the method to remove the reaction heat under all circumstances and at all rates, we opted for heat withdrawal by evaporation of a solvent. Many reactions are executed in dissolution or the reactants are volatile at reaction conditions. A wide range of temperatures and solvents must be handled For many different hydrogenation reactions also various solvents with different properties have to be used, specially with respect to vapour pressures and boiling points. Each reaction requires its own temperature range and also this demands for a greatflexibilityof a multiproduct reactor. Good selectivities Many hydrogenations are carried on up to completion, but as soon as only partial hydrogenation of a molecule is required, also selectivity plays a major role. For multicomponent reactions of the consecutive type it is known that the batch or plug flow reactor gives higher yields and selectivities than mixed reactors, so mixing should be suppressed. This is often more complicated if competing reactions are of different reaction orders, but in general mixing should be avoided as much as possible. Ease of operation also without much information on kinetics The determination of adequate and reliable kinetic data is laborious and time consuming. To test three phase catalytic reactors we used as a test reaction the hydrogenation of 2.4. dinitrotoluene to intermediate andfinalproducts. Langmuir-Hinselwood expressions were developed for the five main reactions and it took us several man years to obtain accurate rate equations valid over a wide range of temperatures and pressures [2,3,4]. Such a large input of manhours cannot be afforded in fine chemicals industries, where often only a few tonnes of product are made in a short period of time. Therefore units must be well operated with the highest possible selectivities and yields without detailed information on kinetics. Ease of control For a wide range of process conditions the reactor must be reliably controlled and kept at the desired conditions under all circumstances avoiding runaways or other instabilities. The control
49 system must be easy to understand and to handle, so that operators can dedicate their attention above all to the execution of the ever changing recipes for the production of desired chemicals. Process economics It is evident that the process economics must be sound. This not only demands for much detailed attention to equipment selection and mechanical design, but also to fiirther process development and easy possibilities for modifications. Hydrogen excess and recirculation is costly, the gas carries away evaporated liquid, which has to be condensed in condensors with low heat transfer coefficients due to the presence of gas; after that the gas must be recompressed and recycled to the reactor. Compression is an expensive unite operation and, moreover, in recirculation systems a purge is required to prevent accumulation of inert components: this inevitably leads to hydrogen losses. Short switch over times must be feasible to reduce losses to off*-spec products to a minimum. For the same reason also rapid startup and shut down methods must be developed. This also leads to long on-stream-times and a good productive use of the plant. Also the catalyst life is extremely important. The change of catalyst batches should be avoided as much as possible. The replacement of a fixed catalyst bed is cumbersome and involves a loss of possible production time. So some kind of rapid in situ regeneration is to be preferred. Choice of reactor type and batch or continuous mode of operation In fine chemicals industries the batch reactor is used almost exclusively. For catalytic hydrogenations the batch reactor has a number of inconveniences in case a slurry catalyst is used. The complicated cooling coils, dead spaces behind baffles, etc. are difficult to clean if the catalyst has to be removed from the vessel. After each batch the vessel has to be emptied, which also implies that the catalyst falls dry. It is known that specially in this period all reactants and products, still contained in the pores of the catalyst, rapidly may deteriorate via unwanted side reactions and so deactivate the catalyst. Usually deactivation starts as soon as the catalyst is no more protected by the solvent. As a production series of one product consists of a number of batches, the exposure of the catalyst to deactivation conditions is frequent. Despite the experience with batch reactors it may be worthwhile to operate continuous reactors also for fine chemicals. Continuously operated reactors only demand for one start-up and one shut-down during the production series for one product. This increases the operating time efficiency and prevents the deactivation of dry catalysts; this implies that the reactor volume can be much smaller than for batch reactors. As to the reactor type for three phase systems an agitated slurry tank reactor [5,6] is not advisable, because of the good mixing characteristics. Specially for consecutive reaction systems the yields to desired products and selectivities will be considerably lower than in plug flow type reactor. The cocurrent down flow trickle flow reactor [7,8,9,10] at high flow rates approaches best the plug flow character. Regretfially, for a good wetting of the catalyst particles, liquid velocities must be high so that residence times usually are limited and not higher than a few minutes to a maximum of about a quarter of an hour. Many reactions demand for much longer reaction times. For that reason the packed bubble column reactor remains; this reactor has been tested by us and its many features were amply discussed [11,12,13]. In this reactor the liquid and the gas flow cocurrently upward through the packed catalyst bed. It exhibits axial dispersion in the liquid phase [13], but by choosing a high and slender column the influence of the axial dispersion can be largely suppressed: under normal operating conditions and with not too large catalyst particles several "reaction units" per meter column height can be obtained. By changing the liquid flow rate a any residence time for the liquid phase can be achieved, a residence time of several hours is not a problem. This implies that also selectivities approaching those in a plug flow reactor can be expected in this type of reactor, as is desired. For the case of heat removal in the reactor by evaporation of the reactant or a solvent and condensing the vapours a cooler-condensor in the exit vapour line, a wide range of operating temperatures can be chosen by setting the reactor pressure. For these reasons we feel the packed bubble column reactorfilledwith a stationary solid catalyst bed is the best suited reactor with a very high versatility for application in the fine chemicals industries.
50 Operation of the continuous packed bubble column reactor A number of the previously mentioned points will now be further elaborated. For further information see o.a. [14]. Start-up and shut-down The solvent, which is heated up via a feed preheater to a temperature at which the reaction starts, can be put in the reactor and the reactor completelyfilledwith liquid. After that the liquid reactant feed and the hydrogen gas are supplied to the reactor in the desired ratio. The reaction starts, the reaction mixture heats up and at reaching a temperature somewhat below the boiling point of the solvent at the set reactor pressure, the evaporation will become so high that a stable operating point is reached. Solvent vapours are condensed and returned to the reactor, the liquid phase leaves the top of the catalyst bed via an overflow. For stopping the reaction the catalyst bed is washed out with pure solvent and the catalyst is kept covered with liquid. Switch over to a new product If for the new product a different solvent is used, first the old solvent is washed out over the top of the catalyst bed by the new solvent and the solvent mixture sent to the solvent recovery system of the plant. After that the same start-up procedure as before is followed and the reactor pressure adjusted if necessary. The catalyst is kept wet under liquid all the time in order to prevent decomposition reactions or coke formation at the catalyst surface if exposed to gas and/or air. Catalyst life and reactivation We observed that for our reactions the catalyst was prone to deactivation if the catalyst was exposed to gas or air. Via polymerisation and condensation reactions tar and coke was formed. We could reactivate our catalyst bed by burning off of cokes and tar [11] with air diluted with steam or nitrogen. The bed had to be preheated to a temperature where the tar and coke combustion started. This empirically determined temperature in our case was 130°C. In [15] we have described how the oxygen content in the regeneration gas can be determined and where thermocouples in the catalyst bed must be placed to be sure that always at least one thermocouple is located in the zone with the highest temperature in the bed, where the combustion takes place. Ease of control Besides rate controllers for the gas and liquid feed flows and liquid level controllers, the most important instrument is the reactor pressure controller. By setting the pressure also the maximum temperature is set. The liquid will evaporate at a temperature somewhat below the boiling temperature of the solvent or reactants at the set pressure. At the boiling temperature itself no hydrogen can dissolve anymore in the liquid and so the reaction would automatically stop. This also insures that a runaway never can occur; the temperature never can surpass the solvent boiling temperature. By adjusting the pressure we also automatically adjust the temperature level in the reactor. A large temperature range can be covered depending on the vapour pressure curve of the liquid reaction phase and on the maximum allowable pressure of the reactor vessel. Hydrogen excess and gas recirculation In [1] and [12] on the basis of the analysis of a mathematical model describing the packed bubble column reactor for catalytic hydrogenation applications, it was suggested - in order to produce an intermediate product in a consecutive reactions system - to supply a hydrogen stream slightly larger than stoichiometrically required amount to hydrogenate the feedstock to the desired intermediate product. It was suggested that in this way also automatically the highest yield was obtained. The reaction stops as soon as almost all hydrogen supplied has been consumed. This implicates that the feed rate is so low that the reaction stops already before the top of the catalyst bed is reached. Or in other words the catalyst bed is larger than required for the desired conversion at the feed rate set. The hydrogen stream in such a case must be diluted e.g. with nitrogen in order to carry the solvent vapours to the condensor. The same holds, of course, also for a complete hydrogenation. This mode of operating a packed bubble column reactor has two great advantages.
51 The first one is that we do not use an excess of hydrogen. This implies that we do not need to recirculate the excess of hydrogen and that the very costly hydrogen recycle compressor can be avoided, resulting in important investment and energy savings. The second advantage is that we do not need to know the reaction kinetics, we only need to know the stoichiometry. Of course, in preliminary laboratory tests a suitable solvent has to be found and also a minimum temperature level has to be determined at which sufficiently high reaction rates are obtained. In the upper part of the catalyst bed, where the reaction has stopped, no temperature increase takes place anymore. In order to increase the capacity of the reactor the gas and liquid flow rates can be raised simultaneously as long as the last two thermocouples in the upper part of the reactor indicate equal temperatures, that is the reaction is complete before the end of the catalyst bed. These suggestions based on a study of the mathematical model have been verified experimentally. Therefore an experimental program as explained in the following part has been executed. We present results of the hydrogenation of 2,4-DNT obtained in a miniplant packed bed bubble column reactor and in methanol as the evaporating solvent. The corresponding reaction network consisting of parallel and consecutive pathways is shown in Fig. 1. The aim of our work is to determine the best method of operating the reactor to obtain the maximal yield of an intermediate product.
Fig. 1. Reaction scheme for the catalytic hydrogenation of 2,4 - DNT
Experimental installation and procedure The flow scheme of the miniplant installation is shown in Fig. 2. The reactor consists of a cylindrical stainless steel shell H and an internal tube 12 which contains the catalyst bed.
Fig. 2. Flowsheet of the miniplant installation. PI - pressure indicator, TI - temperature indicator, MFC - mass flow controller.
52 Both gas and liquid enter the reactor at the bottom and flow cocurrently to the top of the bed. The gas leaves the reactor at the top, whereas the liquid flows over the edge of the inner tube and downward in the annulus between the shell and the inner tube and then leaves the reactor at the bottom. A heating jacket is installed around the reactor shell to shorten the time required to reach steady state conditions and to maintain an almost adiabatic operation of the reactor. For further details and drawings see [11]. The liquid feed is stored in a jacketed supply vessel 13 equipped with an U-shaped agitator. This vessel is heated by means of hot water from a thermostat. Before starting an experiment oxygen is stripped out of the solution by slow bubbling through of nitrogen. The liquid is fed to the reactor by means of Lewa membrane pump 14 and the flow is controlled by changing the stroke length. By means of two burettes 22 in the liquid line the pump can be calibrated. The liquid reaction product is collected in a buffer vessel H . The gas feed, being either hydrogen or a hydrogen-nitrogen mixture, is taken from high pressure feed lines. Magnetic valves are installed in both feed lines and the flow rates of hydrogen and nitrogen are controlled by Brooks 581 Mass Flow Controllers 16. Gas and liquid are mixed before entering the reactor bed in a gas-liquid chamber 17 at the inlet of the reactor. The gas leaving the reactor flows through a condenser 18, where evaporated solvent is condensed, and then to the gas-liquid separator 19. The condensed solvent is collected in a separate buffer vessel 20 and returned to the reactor if necessary, the gas leaves the system through a backpressure valve controlling the pressure in the system. The volumetric flow of the effluent gas is measured with a gas meter 21. A system of sampling tubes and thermocouple tubes, inserted directly into the bed, enables us to determine the temperature as well as the liquid phase composition at four locations along the reactor. The sampling tubes are equiped with magnetic valves installed outside the reactor. The reactor system is automated with a computer HP 9816 and a data acquisition and control unit HP 3497A of Hewlett Packard. The programme a.o. checks if all variables are within preset safety limits. In case of emergency the programme switches the gas feed from H2 to N2 and stops the liquid feed. The key variables are the temperatures in the catalyst bed, the gas and the liquid inlet temperatures as well as the gas and the liquid outlet temperatures andfrirtherthe reactor pressure, the inlet and the outlet gas flow rates and the liquid feed flow rate. They are temporarily stored in the computer memory and later transferred on floppy disk. The temperatures at all other locations are monitored and recorded with a Philips PM 823 7A multipoint data recorder. The catalyst used is a shell catalyst, contains 0.08 % wt. of Pd on 4*4 mm porous cylindrical alumina pellets and is manufactured by Girdler Slid Chemie A.G.; the penetration depth of palladium in the cylindrical support is estimated to be about 100 mm. Methanol is used as an evaporating solvent. A solution of DNT usually in the range of 0.11 to 0.20 kmol/m^ in methanol is used as a feed. About one hour after reaching steady state conditions liquid samples are collected and immediately analysed with a Varian 3300 gas chromatograph using a 6ft*8" Tenax 60/80 mesh column and a HP 3 3 92A integrator. The entire sampling and analyzing sequence at all detection points takes between two and three hours, during which period all operating parameters are kept constant. The whole experiment, including warming up of the reactor, stabilizing conditions, sampling procedure and cooling down of the reactor, takes usually about 7-8 hours. Temperatures measured in the reactor bed during the entire experiment are plotted in Fig.3. We can see that steady state is reached after 1.5-2 hours from the start of the process, which is equivalent to 4-5 times the liquid residence time. At a hydrogen supply ratio - defined as molar hydrogen feed rate over the stoichiometric molar rate needed to convert all DNT to DAT - of OCDAT < 1 equilibration of the reactor took usually as much as 2 to 3 hours.
53
100-
o-o^c
80 H
- + - T 3
-%-
T
M-o 100
200
300
t [inin]
Fig. 3 Measured reactor bed temperatures. Locations of thermocouples: 3 - points (+), 2 - points (*), 1 - points (o) - see Fig. 2. Experimental results To describe the reactor performance the following aspects have been taken into account: 1. The pressure drop is small in comparison to the reactor pressure: the reactor is practically isobaric. 2. Because of the heating jacket temperature following the reactor temperature we can also assume that the reactor is nearly adiabatic. 3. The temperatures of the gas and the liquid phases are equal to each other over the crosssection of the reactor bed. 4. The flow regime in our reactor was checked with criteria given in literature. The gas mass velocity has never been higher than 2,5 10"^ kg/m^ s and the mass flow ratio \\}X\J{jQViQ) varied between 10 and 35, so according to the flow map by Turpin and Huntington [16] all our experiments have been performed in the bubble flow regime. With a minimum gas velocity of UG,min = 0.3 10" m/s according to the criterion of Saada [17] two-phase flow must take place in all voids for all operating conditions. So the available catalyst area is fully wetted and utilized. The most important experimental data are given in Figures 3, 4 and 5 and further in [18]. The hydrogen conversion has been defined as the ratio of the amount of hydrogen actually consumed over the amount of hydrogen consumed for a complete conversion of DNT to DAT. According to this definition experimental values of the hydrogen conversion at the j-th measurement point have been determined as follows: J
1
^. -1
^
-(Xc
XD)
+
XE
(1)
where Xi are relative molar fractions of the i-th reactant in the liquid phase, respectively, defined as follows:
54
X, = ^
(2)
The temperature of samples taken at different locations in the packed bed was sometimes as high as 393 K, so a certain amount of methanol vapour wasflashedoff and consequently the measured molar concentrations of the organic compounds were higher than in the reactor. On the basis of Eq. 1 and 2 we still obtain the correct hydrogen conversions, automatically compensated for the evaporation loss during sampling. The overall hydrogen conversion Ztop,cai as measured at the top of the catalyst bed can also be calculated according to the equation: - ^H,out ' top.co/
6 (lu,
(3)
CAO
where fno and f^out are the inlet and the outlet molar hydrogen flow rates and qLo the inlet flow rate of the liquid. The hydrogen supply ratio aoAi is defined as: CCDAT -
-r-——
(4)
The hydrogen conversions determinedfi-omconcentration measurements, Ztop (Eq. 1) compared well to those calculated with Eq. 3, Ztop,cai; only for a few experiments the differences exceeded 10%. The amount of gas measured in the outlet mainly consisted of nitrogen, non-converted hydrogen and not condensed methanol vapours. The amount of methanol vapours condensed has been measured and varied between 1.3 to 127 * lO'^NmVs. Deactivation of the catalyst Initially the deactivation of the catalyst is very fast. The decrease in the catalyst activity becomes smaller adfter several weeks. As catalyst deactivation may be caused by an irreversible adsorption of reaction products we washed the catalyst bed after every experiment with methanol with a volume of five times the liquid hold-up of the reactor; in between two experiments we kept the reactorfilledwith methanol and under nitrogen. We observed that the activity can be stabilized in this way and that deactivation does not occur any more. Based onfiartherstudies performed to investigate the influence of the hydrogen supply ratio and the reactor pressure under conditions where aDAi < 1, we are sure that the catalyst activity is almost constant and reproducible, provided the catalyst is kept wetted al the time. Reactor operation Observing the dependence of the total hydrogen conversion and the reactor pressure in Figure 4 only at P = 0.8 MPa almost all supplied hydrogen is consumed. At lower hydrogen partial pressure, the reaction rate significantly decreases, so not all supplied hydrogen can be converted in the reactor: the total hydrogen conversion Ztop is smaller than the hydrogen supply ratio aoAT- For a hydrogen supply ratio of aoAT < 1 and at long enough residence times we can expect the total hydrogen conversion Ztop equals aoAi, because all supplied hydrogen is converted.
55
',.,,' I
Fig. 4 Hydrogen conversions as a function of the reactor pressure P. Fixed hydrogen supply ratio aoAT = 0.62.
Fig. 5 Yield of the intermediate C at the reactor outlet as a function of the hydrogen supply ratio aDAx- Fixed reactor pressure P = 0.81 MPa.
Yield of the intermediate product C The optimization of the production of intermediates without an expensive recycle of recompressed hydrogen, can be achieved at a hydrogen supply ratio aDAx < 1. The yield of the intermediate product C, he, can be determined directlyfromthe concentration measurements because he = Xc. For economical reasons it is also important that all supplied hydrogen is converted. The influence of the hydrogen supply ratio on the yield towards the intermediate compound C at P = 0.81 MPa is shown in Fig 5. A distinct maximum in the yield of component C is noticed in thisfigureat a fixed value of the hydrogen supply ratio. At aoAx = 0.52 and at P = 0.81 MPa the highest value of he = 0.67 is obtained, also almost dl supplied hydrogen is converted at these conditions. In Fig. 5 we have indicated with a full line the yields as calculated with the model discussed in [12] and with the kinetics given in [4]; with a band has been indicated the range, where the yield deviates less than five per cent of the maximum yield. It demonstrates that by setting a stoichiometric hydrogen supply ratio of a little above 0.50 the optimum yield is already approached almost correctly. For consecutive reactions, of course, it is impossible to know what the correct ratio is without knowing the kinetics. In our case of the hydrogenation of 2.4 DNT we only can be sure it must be beyond a = 0.50 because in the maximum also already part of the C has been converted into E. So in practice the operator would set the ratio e.g. at 0.55 and then empirically increase it slowly step by step till the maximum yield eventually has been found. In our case with ratios between 0.49 and 0.59 we loose less than 5% of our raw material, which loss must be acceptable in the initial period of a run. We also have seen that a certain minimum pressure is required. Also this has to be determined step by step, in our case pressures of 0.2 and 0.4 MPa, see Fig. 4, are still somewhat too low; at 0.8 MPa the reactor runs fine. Summary and conclusions Experimental results obtained in a miniplant installation with a packed bed bubble column reactor for the catalytic hydrogenation of 2,4- DNT with an evaporating solvent have been presented and discussed. A deactivation of the catalyst has been noticed and the method to stabilize the catalyst activity by a special treatment of the bed after each experimental run has been developed. The influence of operating parameters as the hydrogen supply ratio and the pressure of the reactor has been discussed. The method, as suggested by Westerterp et al [1] and by Van Gelder et al [12], to obtain the maximal yield of an intermediate product without hydrogen recycle has been experimentally evaluated. The packed bubble column reactor can be run with a correct amount of hydrogen supplied to achieve the maximum yield of intermediate product at a certain feed rate of reactant in the liquid phase. A small amount of the inert gas - in our case nitrogen - must be added to the reactor to assure a stable performance of the reactor in case almost all supplied hydrogen is consumed. The reactor pressure
56 must be high enough to maintain a sufficiently high hydrogen consumption rate and assure almost complete conversion. Both the hydrogen supply ratio as well as the required reactor pressure can be determined experimentally without studying reaction kinetics. For the investigated system and after stabilizing the catalyst activity good conditions were aoAi = 0.53 and P = 0.81 MPa at which the maximal yield of the intermediate product C is obtained without losses of not consumed hydrogen. This proves the suggestion of Westerterp, Van Gelder et al [1,12] that the maximum yield of a desired product can be obtained Avith a supply of hydrogen slightly higher than stoichiometric, provided the reactor pressure is set high enough for sufficiently high reaction rates to convert the hydrogen supplied. We also discussed the choice of the reactor. A batch reactor has a much larger volume per unit of reaction product and tank like pressure vessels are much more expensive than cylindrical vessels. This combined with the difficulties of handling catalyst slurries and above all of preventing losses of the often rather expensive catalysts made us consider continuously operating reactors with fixed catalyst beds too. We eventually chose for the packed bubble column as a well suited reactor. We also should mention some drawbacks of the proposed reactor. Axial mixing is not fiilly suppressed, so additional bed height is required to compensate for it. Further additional bed height is required for the production of intermediate products in a consecutive reaction system to ensure the hydrogen is almost completely consumed. Further we have to realize that the evaporation of solvent or reactant reduces the partial pressure of hydrogen, above all in the upper part of the reactor. Also this aspect demands for additional catalyst. As a consequence the productivity of the reactor per unit of catalyst bed will be only afi-actionof a reactor with cooling coils or catalyst in wall-cooled, small diameter tubes without evaporation. However, at the expense of productivity the reactor has a simple construction and does not need a hydrogen recycle compressor. We therefore expect it to be also a very cheap if not the cheapest reactor. Acknowledgement. This work has been supported by the Netherlands Foundation for Chemical Research (SON). Mr A. Pleiter for his technical support and advice is gratefiilly acknowledged and Prof S. Wronskifi-omCPE Department of Warsaw Technical University for his favourable interest and support, and also dr.ir. M.H. Oyevaar, dr.ir. W. Wammes, dr.ir. H.J. Janssen en dr.ir. D. Stegeman, who also participated at some stage in the project. Notation Ci
P QL
q T To
u Xi
Xi
z
concentration of component i, mole/m^ reactor pressure, MPa liquidflowrate, m^ / s gasflowrate, Nl/min temperature, K temperature of gas and liquid entering the reactor bed, K gas or liquidflowvelocity, m / s molefi'actionof i-th component in liquid phase,relative molefi-actionof i-th component axial coordinate, m
Greek letters OCDAT hydrogen supply ratio,h yield,Zj hydrogen conversion at j-th measurement point.,f molar flow rate, mol/s Subscripts ccnd superscripts in inlet G gas
57 N2 o out H L
nitrogen initial outlet hydrogen liquid
Abbreviations A 2,4-DNT, B 4-HA-2-NT, C 4-A-2-NT, D 2-A-4-NT, E 2,4-DAT,
2,4-dinitrotoluene 4-hydroxylamino-2-nitrotoluene 4-amino-2-nitrotoluene 2-amino-4-nitrotoluene 2,4-diaminotoluene
Literature 1. K.R. Westerterp, KB. vanGelder, HJ. JanssenandM.H. Oyevaar, Chem. Eng. Sci., 43 (1988) 2229-2236. 2. H.J. Janssen, A.J. Kruithof, G.J. Steghuis and K.R. Westerterp, Ind. and Eng. Chem. Res., 29 (1990) 754-766. 3. H.J. Janssen, A.J. Kruithof, G.J. Steghuis and K.R. Westerterp, Ind. and Eng. Chem. Res., 29 (1990) 1822-1829. 4. E.J. Molga and K.R. Westerterp, Chem. Eng. Sci., 47 (7) (1992) 1733-1749. 5. K.R Westerterp, H.J. Janssen and H.J. van der Kwast, Chem. Eng. Sci., 47 (1992) 4179-4189. 6. H.J. Janssen, H.J. Vos and K.R. Westerterp, Chem. Eng. Sci., 47 (1992) 4191-4208. 7. W.J.A. Wammes, S.J. Mechielsen and K.R. Westerterp, Chem. Eng. Sci., 45 (1992) 3149-3158. 8. W.J.A. Wammes and K.R. Westerterp, Chem. Eng. Sci., 45, (1990) 2247-2254. 9. W.J.A. Wammes, J. Mddelkamp, W.J. Huisman, CM. de Baas and K.R. Westerterp, AIChE Journal, 37 (1991) 1849-1854. 10. W.J.A. Wammes and K.R. Westerterp, Chem. Eng. and Techn., 14 (1991) 406-413. 11. K.B. van Gelder, J.K. Damhof, P.J. Kroijenga and K.R. Westerterp, Chem. Eng. Sci., 45 (1990) 3159-3170. 12 K.B. van Gelder, P.C. Borman, RE. Weenink and K.R. Westerterp, Chem. Eng. Sci., 45 (1990) 3171-3192. 13. K.B. van Gelder and K.R. Westerterp, Chem. Eng. and Techn., 13, (1990) 27-40. 14. M.H. Oyevaar, T. de la Rie, C.L. van der Sluijs and K.R. Westerterp, Chem. Eng. and Proc, 26 (1989) 1-14. 15. K.R. Westerterp, H.J. Fontein and F.P.H. van Beckum, Chem. Eng. and Techn., H (1988) 367375. 16. J.L. Turpin and R.L. Huntington, AIChE Journal, 13 (1967) 1196-2001. 17. M.Y. Saada, Chem.Ind. Genie Chem., 105 (1972) 1415-1418. 18. K.R. Westerterp, E.J. Molga and K.B. van Gelder, Chem. Eng. & Proc, 36 (1997) 17-27.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
59
Selective Catalytic Hydrogenation of 2-Butyne-l,4-diol to ci5-2-Butene-l,4diol in Mass Transfer Efficient Slurry Reactors J.M. Winterbottom*, H. Marwan, J. Viladevall, S. Sharma, and S. Raymahasay School of Chemical Engineering, The University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham B15 2TT, United Kingdom
Abstract - The hydrogenation of 2-butyne-l,4-diol over a commercial 5% Pd/charcoal and a 5% Pd/Ti02 catalyst prepared in-house was investigated and the selectivity towards cis-lbutene-l,4-diol under various reaction conditions is reported. The experiments were carried out in a glass stured tank reactor (STR) and a cocurrent downflow contactor reactor (CDCR). It was found that besides c/5-2-butene-l,4-diol and 1,4-butanediol, some side products such as cis- and trans-crotyl alcohol, n-butanol, and n-butyraldehyde were also observed. A reaction scheme is proposed. In the STR, the effects of catalyst loading, temperature, base, poisons and metal additives on the selectivity were studied. The results indicate that triethyl phosphite and lead acetate led to inhibition of fiuther hydrogenation. The use of lead poisoned Pd/charcoal catalyst gave partial hydrogenation with selectivity towards c/5-2-butene-l,4-diol of 97.498.8%. The use of Pd/Ti02 catalyst exhibited higher selectivity, more than 99%. In the reaction with Pd/charcoal, CDCR has shown its potential giving increased selectivity (up to 100%) to c/5-2-butene-l,4-diol, at the end of first hydrogenation step, even with no addition of poison and with much higher reaction rates. 1. INTRODUCTION The sohd-catalysed reaction of a gas with a hquid is often carried out in a slurry reactor andfindsfi-equentapphcation in fine chemical and pharmaceutical synthesis. A typical exanq)le is found in the selective hydrogenation of acetylenic conq)ounds. The selectivity of the net formation of the intermediate conq)ounds in these reactions has been of scientific and economic concern for a long time. For a variety of reaction conditions, it is not surprising to find that selectivity is sometimes markedly influenced by small variations in the amount of hydrogen adsorbed, by numerous additives that change the rate of hydrogenation relative to the rate of mass transfer, the rate of acetylene hydrogenation relative to that of the olefin, and also by reaction variables such as the concentration of catalyst, agitation, tenq)erature, solvent and catalyst support [1]. The selective catalytic hydrogenation of 2-butyne-l,4-diol to cw-2-butene-l,4-diol over palladium represents a common situation involving a multifimctional conq)ound. Fortunately, the reduction of triple bonds is very selective over palladium [1,2]. Butenediol is an in^ortant chemical intermediate due to its use in the production of several insecticides and pharmaceuticals (i.e. endosulfan and vitamin B6). The use of supported palladium [3-8], Raney nickel [9] or nickel [10] catalyst has been reported for this reaction under relatively mild operating conditions. However, due to the possibihty of several side reactions [3-4], the problem of selectivity towards c/^-butenediol becomes inq)ortant. Over Pd/C, it was reported * To whom correspondaice should be addressed. E-mail:
[email protected]
60 that the formation of butanediol during the course of the first step, i.e. butynediol to cisbutenediol indicated the possibility of a sequential reaction without preferential formation and/or desorption of desired intermediate product. Besides cw-butenediol and butanediol, the formation of side products such as ;^hydroxybutyraldehyde, n-butyraldehyde, n-butanol, and an acetal also were observed in small amounts during first reaction step, and in significant quantities at conq)lete reduction stage [4]. Fukuda and Kusama [11] successfiiUy partially hydrogenated butynediol by enq)loying PdCaCOg and quinoline as poison. Li later work of Fukuda [3], the combination effect of lead acetate and quinoline on Pd/BaCOs gave partial hydrogenation as well. In order to selectively produce cw-butenediol, Chaudhari et al. [12] reported the use of Lindlar catalyst doped with zinc acetate that gave partial reduction with selectivity as high as 99.8% toward cw-butenediol. The aim of this work is to produce cw-butenediol using a commercial Pd/charcoal catalyst in high yield and purity by inhibiting the production of 1,4-butanediol. The influence of reaction conditions and poisoning on the selectivity has been investigated in a 0.5 dm^ glass stirred tank reactor (STR) operated at atmospheric pressure and in the tenq)erature range 1555^*0. Preliminary experiments were carried out by varying catalyst loading and ten[q)erature, and solvent. The use of various additives was investigated, either by adding the additive into the reaction solution or by pre-inq)regnating the additive onto the catalyst surface. As a corq)arison, a Pd/Ti02 catalyst was also prepared ia-house by the incipient wetness inq)regnation method and then used for the reaction. The pilot plant scale experiments were studied in a 50 dm^ cocurrent downflow contactor reactor (CDCR) operated at pressure 5-15 bara and in the tenq)erature range 40-110''C. The CDCR allows greater operational flexibility for a wide range of reactions [13]. As reported elsewhere, the CDCR has been proved to offer mass transfer performance superior to that of not only conventional bubble columns but also STR's for three-phase catalytic hydrogenation reactions [14,15]. 2. EXPERIMENTAL METHODS The commercial catalyst used for hydrogenation was a palladium on charcoal catalyst (type 37), manufactured by Johnson Matthey (UK)) with metal content 4.89% and suppHed as powder. The Pd metal was deposited on the exterior surface of the charcoal. The Pd/Ti02 catalyst was prepared using sodium tetrachloropalladate (U), suppHed by Johnson Matthey (UK) and titanium dioxide,firomDegussa (Germany). The hydrogen gas was supplied by BOC (UK), with >99.98% purity and was used directlyfi-omcyhnder. The reactant, butyne-l,4-diol 99%, was procured fi'om Aldrich (UK) and water and 2-propanol, obtainedfi:omFisons (UK), were used as solvents. Additives such as lead acetate, quinoline, thiophene and triethyl phosphite were suppUed by Aldrich (UK) and cupric acetate, zinc sulphate, ferric nitrate and potassium hydroxide were provided by Fisons (UK). A glass stirred tank reactor (STR), 0.5 dm^ capacity of solution, with four baffle plates was used. The agitation device consisted of glass inq)ellers with six flat turbine blades. The STR was operated as a dead-end system, meanwhile hydrogen was suppUed continuously according to consun:q)tion rate by a hydrogenation control unit (HCU). The HCU was set to maintain the reactor pressure at 3.5" water gauge. A 50 dm^ stainless steel cocurrent downflow contactor reactor (CDCR) system was also enq)loyed and operated as a slurry system with the catalystfiillywetted. The CDCR was equipped with a control unit capable of allowing operation at pressures up to 30 bara and temperatures up to 250*'C. The flow regime
61 of reactor is a combination of mixed and plug flow, based on residence time distribution studies [14, 17]. The system was purged by flowing nitrogen and then hydrogen before reaction started. For the reaction in the STR, the reactor ten^erature was controlled by immersing the reactor base into a water bath. Afl;er the desired ten^erature was attained, the e?q)eriment was started by switching the stirrer on and then by opening low pressure outlet of the HCU. Runs were performed at a catalyst loading in the range of 0.5 to 4.0 g/1 of solution, initial butynediol concentration of 20 g/1 of solution, and temperatures in the range of 15 to 55°C under atmospheric pressure. The stirring speed was kept constant at 1500 rpm. In the case of reactions in the CDCR, the slurry containing butynediol was charged into the feed tank and then pun]5)ed into the reactor. The slurry was recirculated within a siagle loop, using a slurry punq), through the reactor and the receiver. The operational principles of the CDCR have been reported elsewhere [13, 17]. In these experiments, Uquid san^les were collected at different times during the reaction and analysed for the products. The analysis was carried out by gas chromatography. A type 94M Ai Cambridge gas chromatograph (GC) equipped with FID, an electronic integrator, and a printer was used. The column used was a capillary column of DB-WAX with 30 m long and 0.25 microns of fihn thickness. The ten^erature column was set at three ranq)s, namely 80 to 120T, 120 to 195T, and 195 to 220''C with different rate for each ranq). A carrier gas (heUum) flowrate of 0.7 ml/min and injection tenq)erature of 240*'C were used. The products such as cw-butenediol, butanediol, cis- and tram-cxotyX alcohol, n-butyraldehyde and n-butanol were identified by comparing with standard samples in GC and confirmed using a GC-MS technique. The 5% Pd/Ti02 catalysts were prepared by the incipient wetness ur^regnation method. In each preparation, initially 10 g of the support was weighed out. The mass of sodium tetrachloropalladate (11) required was calculated to give 0.5 g of palladium metal and the weighed palladium salt was dissolved in the volume of water that is needed just to fill the pores of the support. The weighed support was added into the solution and mixed for 2 hours. The water was evaporated to give a dry sanq)le in a Gallenkanq) evaporator. The dried catalyst was calcined in a fiimace at 200*'C overnight. The inq)regnation of the Pd/charcoal catalyst with various metal salts was effected by dissolving the metal salt in 200 cm^ deionized water with 50 cm^ acetone to which the Pd/charcoal catalyst was added. The slurry was stirred for 30 minutes at room tenq)erature, then dried on a hot plate with stirring to a paste. The later was dried in an oven to remove remaining water and calcined in an air fiimace at 200°C overnight. 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 3.1 Product Identification and Reaction Route Analysis of the reaction products in the STR indicated that the solution predominantly contained c/5-butene-l,4-diol as the desired product during the first reaction step. In the second step, besides the formation of butanediol the other side products, namely cis and transcrotyl alcohol, n-butyraldehyde and n-butanol, were observed in significant quantities. The formation of these side reactions was not surprising due to the possibility of hydrogenolysis and isomerization of alkenes over palladiimi [1, 16]. Figure 1 shows the reaction scheme proposed based on the reaction mechanism as suggested by other workers [6, 16].
62 +2H2 Ho
butyiie-l,4-diol
Ho
=^-> c/.s-butene-l,4-diol -H2O
>
1,4-butaiiediol
+H2
CIS- or tranS'CTOtyl alcohol -> n-butyraldehyde
i+H2
+H2
"^
n-butanol
Figure 1. Reaction Scheme in Hydrogenation of Butynediol over Pd/Charcoal Catalyst 3.2 Preliminary Results in the STR The hydrogenation of butynediol using a commercial 5% Pd/charcoal was carried out in the STK It was found that in the solvent 2-propanol, the selectivity to butenediol was 73.587.1% at the end of first stage and the selectivity to butanediol was 4.6-21.1% on conq)lete hydrogenation, depending on reaction conditions. A typical plot of product distribution against conversion is presented in Figure 2. The results revealed a reduction in selectivity with 100
80
CB = 20g/L; w = 1 g/L; T = 1 5 T .^^ solvent = 2-propanol
P
butynediol cw-butenediol butanediol cis-croty\ alcohol trans-CTotyl alcohol n-butyraldehyde n-butanol ^
200
Conversion (%)
Figure 2. A Typical Products Distribution in Hydrogenation of Butynediol over Pd/Charcoal (200% conversion corresponds to 2 moles of hydrogen) increasing catalyst loading and ten^erature. In such conditions, the availabihty of hydrogen on the catalyst surface becomes less and as a consequence it could promote hydrogenolysis reaction products [1]. The pH measurements in the presence of butynediol and/or butenediol indicated that the solutions were acid with pH values in the range 4-5.5. Hence, the formation of butyraldehyde is likely due to acid catalysed homogeneous transformation of trans-ciotyl alcohol. Solvent variations studies showed that water gave higher selectivity toward butenediol
63 conq)ared with 2-propanol, even though the solubiHty of hydrogen in 2-propanol is greater than that in water. The addition of base (KOH) reduced considerably the production of side products both in alkyne hydrogenation stage and in alkene hydrogenation stage by ehminating hydrogenolysis [6], presumably because the presence of KOH increased the pH of the solution, resulting in an elimination of butyraldehyde via acid catalysed isomerization. The selectivity to butenediol was increased to 98.9% by increasing the amount of base in the STR, and the selectivity to butanediol was increased from 14.1% (without base) to 79.4%. Figure 3 shows the distribution of products in reaction using KOH. This effect was more marked in 2propanol than in water since more side products found in 2-propanol. Without poison or additive, the reaction using Pd/Ti02 catalyst prepared by incipient wetness method exhibited higher selectivity towards butenediol conq)ared to the selectivity using a commercial Pd on 100 <>
CB = 20g/L;w = 4g/L ^ ^ . T = 35T;KOH = 0.1g/ / osolvent = 2-propanol ^
O ::
80 -\
o
I
/
40
20
1
\ 1 \^
Y
/
//
/ ^
1 20
/
/
^ V ^ ° 0
\\ ^\
/ 60
s
\
\
/
/ X 0-
A 40
v^
60
^
= ? ^ ^-&<^
80
\
/ y
butynediol cis-butenediol A butanediol /M[ unknown ^ n-butanol/^
^y \
/^
^\
~R
^
/
\
-nr"'--ff--""
100
/
\
T 'MJ^ 1—'-'—1 ^^
—u—1
120
\
140
160
180
200
Conversion (%)
Figure 3. Products Distribution in Hydrogenation of Butynediol over Pd/Charcoal with KOH (200% conversion corresponds to 2 moles of hydrogen) Table 1. Selectivity in Hydrogenation of Butynediol Using Pd/Ti02 Catalyst CB = 20 g/L, T = 25T, w = 5 g/L, solvent = water, 100 ml STR Selectivity (%) no modifier 40 mg KOH 0.4 ml triethyl phosphite 0.25 ml quinohne 0.5 g lead acetate 0.25 ml quinohne + 0.07 g lead acetate
Butenediol*
Butanediol**
95.84 99.49 97.89 99.05 96.84 99.23
29.16 91.71
* selectivity in the end offirstreaction step ** selectivity in the end of second reaction step
-
64 charcoal catalyst, possibly due to stronger adsorption of butenediol into the charcoal support than that into the titania support. Table 1 gives some results using Pd/Ti02 catalyst. By adding KOH to the reaction, the selectivity using Pd/Ti02 catalyst rose to 99.49%, whereas the second step of reaction gave mainly butanediol with less side product. 3.3 Partial Hydrogenation of Butynediol In attempts to selectively produce cw-butenediol without further hydrogenation, two approaches were enq)loyed, namely: (i) by adding the poison into the reaction solution and (ii) by pre-inq)regnating the poison onto the catalyst surface. Figure 4 shows the selectivity measured when the reaction ceased consuming hydrogen. Triethyl phosphite prevented reaction proceeding beyond one mole hydrogen uptake, but thiophene and quinohne did not and the reaction proceeded into the second mole hydrogen uptake and ceased dunng this stage. In these cases, the effect of poison in inhibiting fiuther hydrogenation of butenediol increased in the following order (2-propanol used as appropriate solvent for dissolving the additives): quinoline < thiophene < triethyl phosphite. Surprisingly, addition of small amounts of triethyl phosphite to Pd/charcoal catalyst successfully gave partial hydrogenation with selectivity as high as 94%. In the reaction in water, the use of 7.5 ml of quinohne led to selectivity of 99.23% with no subsequent reduction of butenediol. However, the system gave agglomeration of the catalyst in the presence of quinoline due to problem of immiscibihty of water/quinoline system
Volume (ml) Figure 4. Effect of Different Poisons on Butenediol Selectivity on Conq)lete Reaction The pre-inq)regnation method was enq)loyed also for metal ion additives such as Pb, Cu, Zn, and Fe. The use of a lead poisoned Pd/charcoal catalyst for partial hydrogenation showed excellent selectivity. With the weight ratio of catalyst and lead acetate of 1:0.1, the reaction in water solvent gave selectivities of 97.4-98.8% with neghgible effects of tenq)erature and catalyst loading. In the case of Pd/Ti02 catalyst, as shown in Table 1, the use of some additives such as triethyl phosphite, quinohne, and lead acetate which were dissolved in the reaction solution also gave partial hydrogenation with high selectivity toward c/^-butenediol.
65 Table 2. Cw-butenediol Selectivity Using Metal Salts Pre-inq)regiiated onto Pd/Charcoal CB = 20 g/L, solvent = v^ater, 500 ml STR Metal additives
Ratio*
(CH3COO)2Pb
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
(CH3COO)2Pb + 0.1 ml quinoline (CH3COO)2Pb + 0.2 ml quinoline ZnS04 (CH3COO)2Cu Fe(N03)3
0.025 0.05 0.10 0.10 0.125 0.05 0.05 0.10 0.10 0.10
TCC)
w(g/L)
Selectivity (%)
55 55 55 35 55 55 55 55 55 55
4 4 2 4 4 4 4 4 4 4
2.47 92.20 98.78 97.76 96.45 96.41 93.11 11.69 28.05 3.83
* weight ratio of Pd/charcoal catalyst and metal salt 3.4 Reactions in the CDCR The reaction carried out in the high pressure CDCR using Pd/charcoal catalyst conjQrmed the initial findings in the STR as given in Table 3. A slightly different trend, however, was found as selectivity towards butenediol increased with increasing tenq)erature. The selectivities obtained varied between 92-100% even without the use of poisons, depending on reaction conditions. The production of by-products was observed to be predominant at higgler Table 3. Cw-butenediol Selectivity at the End of First Step for Reactions in the CDCR CB = 10 g/L, KOH = 0.2 g/L, solvent = water P (barg) 1 5 10 10 10 10 10 10 5 10 10 5
T(oC) 50 50 50 50 65 65 65 35 50 50 65 50
w(gfL) 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.10 0.25 0.01 0.005 0.005 0.005 0.25
Conversion (%) 65 65 65 92 80 95 99 99 90 75 95 99
Selectivity (%) 98.7 99.2 99.7 97.4 100.0 97.3 94.1 92.1 99.2 99.6 98.3 98.9
catalyst loading and only when butynediol was ahnost totally reacted. In the second step, butanediol was produced in higher selectivity than found in the STR, When the reaction was allowed to continue to conq)letion, the by-product formation also reduced and was practically ehminated as the reaction achieved concpletion. However, in the case of the CDCR significantly greater rates were obtained with much lower catalyst loadings, i.e. the lowest
66 catalyst loadings were respectively 0.005 g/L and 0.2 g/L in the CDCR and the STR. It is suggested that the greater reaction rates are a direct result of the in^roved hydrogen mass transfer achieved in the CDCR and when con^ared on the same basis, i.e. without addition of KOH at 35''C and 5 barg, the reaction rate observed in the CDCR was over thirty tunes greater than that in the STR The greater selectivity observed without recoiu-se to poison addition in the CDCR is attributable also to the greater availabihty of hydrogen at the catalyst surface as provided by the CDCR and its superior mass transfer capabihties. 4. CONCLUSIONS Partial hydrogenation of butynediol with high selectivity to c/5-butene-l,4-diol has been achieved using poisons such as triethyl phosphite and lead acetate, and the CDCR has shown its potential givhig increased c/^-butenediol selectivity with no addition of poison even with the Pd/charcoal catalyst, which appears to give lower selectivity than the Pd/Ti02 catalyst. It is possible that significant inq)rovements in selectivity towards c/5-butene-l,4-diol may be achieved by enq)loying lower metal (palladium) loading on the support and this is being investigated. The CDCR also gave rise to greater reaction rates conq)ared with the STR and this attributed to its superior mass transfer capacity. ACKNOWLEGDEMENT All of us kindly acknowledge Syiah Kuala University (Indonesia) for H.Marwan's scholarship, Johnson Matthey (UK) for loan of the precious metal catalysts, EPSRC (UK) and ICI-Katalco (UK) forfinancialsupport.
REFERENCES 1. Rylander, P.N. (1990); Hydrogenation Methods, Academic Press, New York. 2. Bond, G.C., Webb, G., and Winterbottom, J.M. (1962); J. Catal., 1, 74. 3. Fukuda, T. (1958); Bull. Chem. Soc. Japan, 31, 343. 4. Chaudhari, RV., Jaganathan, R, Kolhe, D.S., Emig, G., and Hofinann, H. (1987); Appl Catal., 29, 141. 5. Russel, T.W., and Duncan, D.M. (1974); J. Org. Chem., 39, 3050. 6. Tedeschi, RJ., McMahon, H.C., and Pawlak, M.S. (1967); Annals New York Academy of Sciences 145 91 7. McQuiUin, KJ.Tand Ord, W.O. (1954); J. Chem. Soc, 2902 8. Jardine, L, Howsam, RW., and McQiulKn, F.J. (1969); J. Chem. Soc. (C), 260. 9. General Aniline and Fihn Corp. (1962); in Alcohols, J. A. Monick, Reinhold, New York. 10. Canq)elo,J.M., Guardeno,R, Luna,D., and Marinas, J.M. (1993); J. Molec.Catal, 85, 305. 11. Fukuda, T., and Kusama, T. (1958); 5w//. Chem. Soc. Japan, 31, 339. 12. Chaudhari, RV., Parande, M.G., Elamachandran, P.A., Brahme, P.H., Vadgaonkar, H.G., and Jaganathan, R {19^5), AIChE J, 31, 1891. 13. Sharma, S., Wiaterbottom, J.M., Boyes, A.P., Raymahasay, S., and Khan, Z. (1996); The 1996 IChemE Research Event, vol. 2, Rugby (UK), 829 14. Lu, X.X., Boyes, A.P., and Winterbottom, J.M. (1994); Chem. Eng Sci., 49, 5719. 15. Boyes, A.P., Chughtai, A., Lu, X.X., Raymahasay, S., Sarmento, S., Tilston, M.W., and Winterbottom, J.M. (1992); Chem. Eng Sci., 47, 13/14, 3729 16. Bond, G.C. (1987); Heterogeneous Catalysis, 2nd ed.. Clarendon Press, Oxford. 17. Lu, X.X. (1988); PhD Thesis, The University of Bhmingham.
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
67
Replacing Liquid Acids in Fine Chemical Synthesis by Sulfonated Polysiloxanes as Solid Acids and as Supports for Precious Metal Catalysts Stefan Wieland and Peter Panster DEGUSSA AG, Inorganic Chemical Products Division, Research and Applied Technology Chemical Catalysts and Organosilanes P.O.Box 1345, D-63403 Hanau
The use of solid acid catalysts, consisting of polysiloxanes bearing alkylsulfonic acid groups, is described, in organic synthesis and in technical applications . Although sulfonated polysiloxanes have been reported in the literature and have been found to show excellent activities in comparison to conventional polystyrene based cation exchange resins, no large scale technical use has become known thus far. We now report on the esterification of free fatty acids and phthalic anhydride to obtain the corresponding esters in quantitative yield and high purity (acid number < 0.1 mg KOH/g) as well as on acid catalyzed fat splitting at temperatures from 140-200°C. The condensation of phenol with acetone was also extensively studied and a catalyst prepared that gives high conversion and good selectivity to the desired product p-,pbisphenol-A. The alkylation of phenol was studied with isobutene in the temperature range from 90 - 130°C and high conversion was found as well as in the alkylation of a-methyl-styrene with 2,3-dimethyl-l-butene. Finally, the catalytic hydrogenolysis of the model substance 1-phenyl-ethanol to ethylbenzene proceeds quantitatively at 30°C without addition of a soluble acid. 1. Introduction Sulfonated polysiloxanes have been described and reported in the literature for their excellent activities in comparison with polystyrene based cationic exchange resins ^. Inorganic materials with the exception of zeolites, have been used less often than organic polymers as solid acid catalysts, although the better physical properties of the former in general more than compensate for the better chemical properties and simplicity of synthesis of the latter. Advantages of the oxide supports are their rigid structure, which prevents deactivation, and a higher temperature, solvent and aging stability. Finally, a defined pore structure independent of solvent, temperature and pressure gives greater control over diffusional factors. Polycondensation (sol-gel process) of suitable alkyl sulfonic acid functionalized organosilane monomers leads to solids with a siliceous matrix and a high concentration of anchored ligand groups , thus leading to the development of specially designed polysiloxane based solid acid catalysts Deloxan" ASP (like in formula 1, 2a, 2b, and 3).
68
0
/
\ / 0—Si — 0 / \
— O—Si —O
/ \
\
— 0—Si —CH2CH2R
0
0—Si— CH2CH2CH2SO3H
/ \
0
0
— 0—Si— CH2CH2CH2SO3H
c/
\
'4m
— O—Si— CH2CH2CH2SO3H
/
(2a R=CH3, 2b R=CH2SH) These organofUnctional polysiloxanes overcome the drawbacks of organic polymers by virtue of their inert matrix material and excellent compatibility with almost all organic solvents. The sol-gel process upon synthesis of the Deloxan® catalysts allows to obtain products of consistently controllable size with a relatively narrow particle size distribution, e.g. from 100 |im to 400 |im, for use in suspension or as spheres with diameters up to 1.4 mm for fixed-bed applications. Furthermore, the catalysts are characterized by their high porosity, large pore diameters (> 20 nm) and high BET surface areas (300-600m^/g). These catalysts are extremely stable in gas phase reactions (like the splitting of MTBE to isobutene) and in organic media. Special advantages of the catalysts include: High structural stability: no swelling and no shrinking in organic media, in contrast to polystyrene based cation exchange resins, high temperature stability (e.g. 200°C), High catalytic activity, comparable to soluble acids as H2SO4 or p-toluene sulfonic acid, based on a high Bronsted acid strength, High selectivity. 2. Results and Discussion 2.1 Esterification of free fatty acids An illustrative example for the use of the Deloxan® ASP solid acid catalyst is the esterification of free tallow fatty acid (acid number: 205) with high boiling alcohols like 2ethylhexanol. In the initial stages of the esterification reaction, the rate of 1000 reaction is determined by the B effectiveness of water removal, an a increase of catalyst concentration has only a minor effect on the rate under the selected test conditions within the first hour. For the sake of selectivity, i.e. decreasing side product formation by dehydration of the used alcohol, the catalyst concentration was kept low. The reaction readily goes to completion Q Qg ^ -,5 2 2,5 3 and the acid number in the raw product time [h] is found to drop to < 0.2 mg KOH/g. pig. 1. Esterification of free tallow fatty acid
69 2.2 Esterification of acid anhydrides to form the corresponding diesters The high thermal stabihty of the Deloxan ASP catalysts is also a key factor when looking at the achieved conversion rates in the esterification of phthalic anhydride with various alcohols, e.g. 1-octanol or 2-ethyl-hexanol, to yield di-octyl-phthalates (reaction 1) that are used as plasticizers. Product yields of > 99% for the diester are obtained for residence times between 30-50 minutes, at temperatures between 150°C and 180°C.
o
o6'
o 2
CgHiyOH
O C8Hi7
+
H2O
(1)
O CsHiy
O 4
phthalic anhydride
1 -octanol or 2-ethyl-hexanol
di-octyl-phthalate
O B
§
0,01 7
8
batch time [h] Fig. 2: Esterification of phthalic anhydride with 2-ethyl-hexanol. 293.3g 2-ethyl-hexanol and 111.2 g phthalic anhydride were placed in a round flask and heated up. After one hour, 20.Og catalysts 2a (Deloxan® ASP IV) with a capacity of 0.9 mmol [H"^] / g were added.
Typically the reaction was conducted in a round flask. The reaction water was removed by azeotropic distillation using a water separator. The raw product was separated from the catalyst by filtration and excess of alcohol was removed by distillation. The recovered catalyst was re-used up to five times with no loss of activity being observed. With the use of the temperature stable catalysts 1 and 2a it is possible to develop alternative processes (cascade like processes) for 6 besides the established routes, which use e.g. amphoteric compounds such as titanates"*.
70
2.3 Acid catalyzed fat splitting Transesterification of fats into its corresponding methylesters, as well as fat splitting to produce the free fatty acids is of great industrial relevance. Solid acid catalyzed fat splitting was achieved by reacting rape seed oil with a large excess of water (weight-ratio= 2:25) in an autoclave at 180°C and 11 atm. The amount of catalyst 1 used was 25 wt.-% of the used rape seed oil, the reaction time for complete splitting was about 12 h and the final acid number of the free fatty acids after separation from the water-glycerol phase was determined to 193.5 mgKOH/g. 2.4 Condensation reaction to form bisphenol-A For special applications it is of interest to incorporate also non-functional, e.g. propyl-, or functional siloxane units with cocatalytic properties, e.g. mercapto-functionalized siloxanes, into the polysiloxane matrix. One example in which this is very important is the industrial production of bisphenol-A (eq. 2). OH
HOv.
/ \
^^
/OH
O
H^ H^C
(2)
CH3 H3C
8 acetone
7 phenol
CH3
p-,p-bisphenol-A
Improvements with respect to activity, selectivity, and over-all productivity (see fig. 3) of the catalyst in the condensation reaction of acetone with phenol have been demonstrated using specially designed Deloxan® ASP catalysts (10). 100 95,6 95,4 95
90
^^^^H
95,2 170
^H
200
a to
150
^^
93^^H
^H
--
O
100
0
85
50
o
o
250
230
0
80 phenol / acetone 10:1
\
IS OH
0^
^
phenol / acetone 7:1
conversion selectivity productivity (right side axes) T= 70°C, WHSV = 0.83 h"^ Fig. 3: Condensation of phenol and acetone; conversion and selectivity to bisphenol-A and production output using Deloxan ASP V
71 A co-catalytically active mercapto group was incorporated within the polysiloxane matrix. The desired 4,4'-bisphenol-A is produced with a selectivity of 95-96% whereas the total selectivity for the 4,4'- and 2,4'-bisphenol-A is higher than 99%. These results are achieved with extremely short residence times as compared to the state-of-the-art^ technology. Whereas the use of polystyrene resins gives selectivities of about 4 to 5% less at WHSV = 0.2 - 0.5 K\ the above reported excellent selectivities obtained with the Deloxan" catalysts are reached at space velocities from 0.5 up to 2.0 h" . Increasing the feed rate increases the overall production output. The latter can be improved further when using a lower molar excess of phenol over acetone like 7 : 1 instead of the technically used ratio of 10 : 1. Using polystyrene resins, this leads to an intolerable decrease in selectivity, whereas selectivity remains at a constant high level for the Deloxan® catalyst. State-of-the-art technology uses conventional polystyrene ion exchange resins that have been modified by ionic fixation of mercaptoalkylamines (11). The differences with our catalyst are shown schematically in figure 4.
^^3^ 9*^2 I
^^ CH2
I
I
CH2
H3N^-CH2CH2SH sOo" . .^
CH2
o /
SO3H
o /
- CH2 - CH2 ~ CH2 " CH2 - CH2 -
10 Deloxan" ASP V
n ionically modified polystyrene ion exchange resin
Fig. 4: Schematic representation of bifunctional polysiloxane catalysts and ionically modified polystyrene cation exchange resins.
Beside the increase in productivity, a higher quality of the raw-product (colorless, reduced amount of traces of several side-products) is obtained using catalyst 10, which is of great importance for the application of bisphenol-A, e.g. for the production of polycarbonates. 2.5 Alkylation of phenols with branched and linear terminal olefins Alkylation of phenols and phenol derivatives with olefins like isobutene, octene, and nonene to synthesize industrially very important alkylphenols, -cresols, or -xylenols is typically performed at temperatures between 80°C and 120°C. High yields and good selectivities are obtained at these temperatures by using Deloxan" catalysts. The very good thermal stability of the Deloxan" catalysts allows their use at even higher operating temperatures, like 110°C to 150°C, which results in a higher productivity. The reaction of phenol with isobutene was studied by introducing the olefin into the phenol melt in a rate that was comparable to the reaction rate. Samples were taken at constant time
72
intervals and analyzed by gas chromatography. Addition of isobutene was stopped when the stoichiometric amount for disubstitution was consumed. It is interesting to note, that in the alkylation of phenol with isobutene, a change in temperature seems also to change the course of the alkylation reaction with the polysiloxane based catalysts. The principal reaction pathways to the main substitution products (according to the theory for electrophilic substitution, only very small amounts of meta-alkylation products are observed) are given in fig. 5.
Fig. 5:
Reaction pathways for the alkylation of phenol with isobutene
Results in table 1 show, that a higher reaction temperature gives a greater selectivity to the p-substituted alkylphenol, thus increasing the rate of para-substitution as opposed to orthoalkylation and increases the 2,4-di-tert-butyl-phenol. The tested zeolite BETA has a pronounced selectivity for the mono-alkylated para-substitution product as would be expected from its shape-selectivity.
catalyst
ASP I ASP II (Al) zeolite BETA Table 1:
temperature [°C] 80 90 90 130 90
2-tert.-butylphenol [GC area-%] 8.2 1.3 16.1 13.3 2.5
4-tert.-butylphenol [GC area-%] 4.1 11.1 5.4 27.5 73.2
2,4-di-tert.butyl-phenol [GC area-%] 61.6 70.5 51.8 54.5 15.1
2,4,6-tri-tert.butyl-phenol [GC area-%] 18.8 12.1 12.7 2.6 0.3
Alkylation of phenol with isobutene. Values reported correspond to a stoichiometry of phenol: isobutene = 1 : 2 and complete conversion of the phenol
73
2.6 Selective alkylation of a-methylstyrene as test reaction Using the catalyst 1, the alkylation reaction (3) which is a probe reaction for the synthesis of fragrances proceeded with better yields compared to various other solid acid catalysts (see figure 6). The drying method of the catalyst and the amount of residual water is critical for the reaction rate.
O 12 a-methylstyrene
(3)
13 2,3-dimethyl-1 -butene
14 1,1,2,4,4-pentamethyltetralene
30,0
„
25,0
I
20,0
o
15,0 10,0
O OH
5,0
6,0
7,0
reaction time [h]
Fig. 6: Yield [area-%] of 1,1,2,4,4-pentamethyltetralene as function of solid acid catalysts. ^ ^ Deloxan® ASP I/7;^o- Amberlyst ®15;-«- Lewatit® SP 120;-^Deloxan® ASP 1/7, extracted with ethanol before drying. solvent: cyclohexane, equimolar amounts of reactants (50 mmol each), catalyst weight: 12,5g, temperature: 60°C The Deloxan® ASP 1/7 catalyst has a [H^]-capacity of 1.2 mmol/g which is lower than the typical [H ]-capacity of about 2-4 mmol/g determined for organic (polystyrene based) ion exchange resins. Nevertheless, the Deloxan catalyst gives the highest product yield, which is even higher than that obtained either by using H2SO4 / glacial acetic acid (homogeneous) according to a published procedure or by synthesis according to the standard Friedel Crafts procedures with AICI3. The used Deloxan" ASP 1/7 catalyst had a surface area (BET) of 510 m^/g and a pore volume of 0.6 ml/g (maximum in the pore size distribution at 5 nm). 2.6 Hydrogenolysis reactions using acidic Pd catalysts The alkyl sulfonic acid bearing polysiloxane is also used as a support for powder type precious metal catalysts 3 (particle size < 200 jiim) that can be used in hydrogenolysis reactions. The conversion of 1 -phenylethanol to ethylbenzene proceeds quantitatively (>99%) with the same rate as achieved with the combination of H2SO4 and a Pd/C catalyst. Therefore,
74
no homogeneous acid is necessary for the hydrogenolytic cleavage of the carbon-oxygen bond. This is of great importance in fine chemistry, e.g. for debenzylation. Hydrogenolysis reaction
ASP /2% Pd, H2 (1 atm) suspension, T =
15 phenylethanol
Lv^J
(4)
C
16 ethylbenzene
3. Experimental The synthesis of organoflinctional polysiloxanes and the preparation of these catalysts were conducted following published procedures ' ' . The reactions reported were carried out in standard glass apparatus or in thermostated glass columns, where data from continuous testing are reported (conditions reported together with results). GC or HPLC was used for analysis. 4. Conclusion Comparison data were presented, that demonstrate the use of the polysiloxane material as an advantageous substitute for organic cation exchange resins, sulfuric acid, p-toluene sulfonic acid and acidic zeolites. It is demonstrated, that materials like 1 and 2 are costefficient and reliable catalysts in esterification, alkylation, and condensation, whereas use of the bifunctional catalyst 3 gives excellent conversions in hydrogenolysis reactions in general. The use of the described solid acid catalysts helps to minimize waste of production, as it reduces the amount of salts formed upon neutralization of the former used liquid acids. Furthermore, when selectivity is increased as in the synthesis of bisphenol-A, the use of the Deloxan® catalyst results in a better (i.e. higher) utilization of the raw material. Altogether, it is seen that improvements of the catalysts as described in this contribution are a significant contribution to the further development of the currently needed ecology-minded processes. References ^ ^ ^ "^ ^
^
Yoshio Ono, Sadakatsu Suzuki in: Acid-Base Catalysis, Proceedings of the Int. Symp. on Acid-Base Catalysis, Sapporo, 1988 pp. 379-396. P. Panster, European patent EP 548 821 to Degussa AG. P. Panster, German patent DE 42 23 589 to Degussa AG. F. K. Towae, W. Enke, R. Jackh, N. Bhargava in: UUmann's Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry, 5'*" Ed., 1992, Vol A 20, pp. 181-211. K. Berg, German patent DE 43 12 039 to Bayer AG; K. Berg, European patent EP 620 041 to Bayer AG; K. Berg, European pat. EP 583 712 to Bayer AG; J. B. Powell, United States pat. US 5,105,026 to Shell; M. J. CipuUo, United States pat. US 5,315,042 to General Electric. T.F. Wood, W.M. Easter, M.S. Carpenter, J. Angiolini: J. Org. Chem. 28, (1963), 2248-55.
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
75
Amine functions linked to MCM-41-type silicas as a new class of solid base catalysts for condensation reactions. M. Lasperas*, T. Llorett, L. Chaves, I. Rodri^ez, A. Cauvel and D. Brunei* UMR 5618-CNRS-ENSCM Laboratoire de Materiaux Catalytiques et Catalyse en Chimie Organique. Ecole Nationale Superieure de Chimie 8, rue Ecole Normale, 34296 - MONTPELLIER Cedex 5- (France)
MCM-41 type silica surfaces were grafted with primary amino groups through silanation process. Tertiary amino groups covalently bound to the surface were prepared through displacement of previously anchored halogen atom by piperidine. The catalytic activities of the immobilized amino groups were studied in the Knoevenagel condensation of benzaldehyde with ethylcyanoacetate. The mechanism of the catalyst action is discussed 1. INTRODUCTION Widespread interest is now devoted to solid catalysts possessing both active sites and high surface area because of their potential in the development of clean processes for the production of fine chemicals. Besides acid catalysts, recyclable solid base catalysts need to be explored. Such catalysts we have examined [1-4] for this purpose included zeolites containing occluded alkali oxide species [5-9]. However, the constraints imposed by the framework limit their use to organic molecules of small dimensions. That promped us to recently develop the design of base catalysts featuring large mesoporous surfaces [10] in order to perform base-catalyzed reactions in the fields of perfumes, pharmaceuticals and agro-chemicals which include high molecular weight compounds. In this respect, the recently discovered family of materials synthetized by silicate condensation around surfactant micelles (Micelle-Templated Silica, MTS) provides unique inorganic support [11,12] due to their regular arrays of uniformly sized channels in the mesopore range of 20-100 A. This solid was recently impregnated with cesium oxides with the aim to obtain superbase catalysts [13]. Nevertheless, the leaching of the basic particles cannot be excluded. In view to avoid such possible phenomena, we have studied the covalent attachment of basic functions such as amino groups on the MTS surface
76 taking into account the use of piperidine as base catalyst in homogeneous conditions [14,15]. The primary amino groups bound on silica was previously reported to be an efficient catalyst for the Knoevenagel condensation reaction in mild conditions [16]. However the mechanism of the action of the catalyst was not demonstrated. The aim of our study is to understand the role of the amine function United on MTS surface with the opportunity of benei&tting from the unique pore structure and surface of this recently discovered family of mesoporous materials. Our previous works on the Knoevenagel reaction (scheme 1) have born witness to its model behaviour for testing the base catalyst activity. Moreover they have emphasized the unique properties of DMSO as solvent for this kind of catalytic reaction as it was shown for homogeneous reactions [17]. In this work, we report the study of the catalytic activity of immobilized amino groups in the Knoevenagel condensation of benzaldehyde (BA) with ethylcyanoacetate (EGA) in DMSO solution (scheme 1). Scheme 1
H^
^CN BA
-H2O
H^
N^N
EGA
A special attention was focused on the catalyst reuses. Simultaneously we examined the mechanistic aspects of carbonyl activation by the primary amine via activated imine intermediate on the condensation reaction in considering also the activity of a tertiary amine group covalently grafted to the surface. 2. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2.1 Catalyst preparation The primary amino groups were anchored to the MTS sihca surface through the grafting of 3-aminopropylsilane to the siloxy groups (silanol, siloxane) by t r e a t m e n t with refluxing anhydrous toluene solution of 3aminopropyltriethoxysilane (scheme 2, eq. 2). The tertiary piperidino moieties linked to the MTS surface were obtained through the grafting of 3-chloro- or 3-iodo-propylalkoxysLlane (scheme 2, eq.2) followed by the nucleophilic displacement of the halogen atom by piperidine (scheme 2, eq. 3).
77
The organic chains linked to the mesoporous surface thus obtained have been characterized by IR and l^C CP-MAS-NMR spectroscopies. The textural characteristics were determined by X-ray diffraction and nitrogen sorption isotherm analysis. Scheme 2
/J—OH
(EtO)3Si (CH2)3 X (2) refluxing toluene
Piperidine (3) refluxing toluene
The number of grafted moieties have been calculated from both elemental analysis and thermogravimetric data reported on table 1. Table 1 Textural characteristics and compositions of the catalysts 1-4. Surface Area Mesoporous Diameter Chain content Solids (m2 g-1) Volume (ml g-1) (A) x 103(mol g" 1) 1 0.76 958 32 2a 821 0.60 29 0.8 2b 3a 3b 4a 4b 4b»
698 827 721 740 657 639
0.45 0.55 0.43 0.49 0.36 0.34
26 27 24 26 22 21
1.7 1 1 0.7 1 0.9
It should be noted that the average diameter determined acccording to the relation 4V/S, monotically decreases with the steric hindrance of the organic chains. In addition, the results obtained with 2a and 2b possessing the same
78
anchored moiety show the same trend related this time with the surface organic coverage. Moreover, the best efficiency of the nucleophiUc displacement of iodine compare to that of chlorine by piperidine provided immobilized N-piperidinyl chains on mesoporous silica having two different contents of tertiary amino groups in addition with different surrounding fiinctions since 3a contains some residual chloropropyl chains. On the other hand the washing of 4b with hot ethanol did not significantly alter the grafted amino group content. Nevertheless, the higher % C observed by elemental analysis of 4b* suggests that some additional ethoxy groups would be grafted on the residual silanols during the washing proccess. 2.2. Catalytic Knoevenagel reaction The Knoevenagel condensation reaction of equimolar solution of BA and EGA in DMSO was carried out on the various catalysts 1-4 in batch conditions. During all the experiments, the selectivities observed in the Knoevenagel condensation product are nearly 100% (>95%).
0
20
40 60 t (min)
80
100
Figure 1: % product versus time using BA (1.75 g) EGA (1.87 g) and 0.22 g of catalyst in DMSO (55 ml) at G X A
0H-MTS1 NH2-MTS2a NH -MTS2b
GI-MTS3a
0.0
1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 Grafted moieties x 10"* (mol)
Figure 2: Gomparison of the grafted primary and tertiary amine activities versus amino group content 0HMTS1 GI-MTS3a X NH2-MTS2a, 2b Reused NH^ - MTS A Gl- Pip MTS 4a I - Pip MTS 4b V I - Pip MTS 4b'
79 The catal5^ic activities of immobilized primary groups (2a: initial rate ro = 0.5 10"^ m o l . m n ' l ; 2b: ro = 1.1 10"^ mol.mn"!) are demonstrated by comparison with the inactivity of anchored neutral function as chlorine (3a) and the very low activity observed with the parent mesoporous silica 1 (ro = 0.03 10'^ mol.mn"!), also reported in Figure 1. The initial rates of the condensation reaction are plotted versus molar grafted moiety numbers in Figure 2 for both primary and tertiary amino groups. The number of catalytic sites was varied using either different mass of the same solid in the case of 2a or using a constant mass of solids having different grafted amino group contents as 2a and 2b or 4a and 4b respectively. The activity of each of the two various catalyst series is linearly related to both mass of catalyst and amino site content. The interesting fact that the activity of each amino group is independent of both grafted chain density and nature of the surrounding groups is consistent with the absence of internal diffusional Hmitation effect. That emphasized the interesting properties of the mesoporous materials related to their large channels which can easily adsorb large molecules even though their surface are lined by organic chains leading to a decrease in the pore radiius. Another interesting result concerns the easy reuses of the NH2-MTS catalyst 2. Its activity is totally maintained during several batch experiments after reactivation which simply consisted in washing with methylene dichloridedi-ethyl ether mixture, water solution of sodium hydrogenocarbonate (2%) and pure water, successively then evacuation in vacuum at 150°C overnigth. That illustrated the good stabiUty of the grafted MTS solids as catalyst in organic solvent which is also demonstrated by the preservation of the textural characteristics in addition with the composition and the catalytic activity of the Pip-MTS material 4b* resulting from the washing of 4b with hot ethanol. Hence we conclude that the observed activation is effectively a true heterogeneous catalysis. On the other hand, it is noteworthy that the turnover of the two different amino groups determined from the straight Hne slopes is much higher for the primary amine than the tertiary one. That suggests two different activation mechanisms. The catalysis induced by tertiary amine groups would be a classical base activation of the methylene group of EGA followed by the nudeophilic attack of the carbonyl function. In the case of the primary amine, the condensation activity induced by the basic character of the amino group in the methylene activation would be enhanced when the carbonyl function of the other substrate was firstly activated by the linked primary amine via imine formation. This tj^Dical phenomenon, studied long time ago in homogeneous catalysis [14,18] could be represented in scheme 3. We propose a concerted mechanism as more probable than a multistage one because the imine intermediate possesses a greater basic character than the
80
amine function itself. Moreover a single amine site seems to be involved during each cycle due to the absence of an amine group density effect. Scheme 3
o
o NH2
>
o
N
/
C.
,c—o
<.
H2C O2C2H5
o <. O2C2H5 H^
^02C2H5
o O2C2H5
This assumption is also argued by the possible role played by DMSO which is the well-adapted solvent for this condensation reaction, in the assistance at N-H bond polarization [17] during the imine formation from carbonyl group of the benzaldehyde. 3. EXPERIMENTAL 3.1. Materials. 3.1.1. MTS silica (OH-MTS) 1. MCM-41 type-silica (MTS) 1 was prepared by addition of Zeosil 175 MP precipitated silica (Rhone-Poulenc, 0.17 weight % Al) to a stirred solution of cetyltrimethylammonium (CTMA) bromide (Aldrich), sodium hydroxide and deionized water. The reaction mixture was heated in a stirred autoclave at 393 K for 16 hours. After filtration and washing with deionized water to pH 9, then with ethanol, the soHd phase was dried at 353 K in air then calcined at 823 K in flowing air for 7 hours to eliminate the occluded organic template. X-ray powder diffiraction shows a main pic at 2 0 = 2.4° using Cu Ka radiation corresponding to hexagonal lattice parameter equal to 46.2 A. The nitrogen sorption isotherm
of MTS is a type IV isotherm, showing a sharp, reversible step at P/PQ 0.38 characteristic of capillary condensation within a regular mesoporous system. Composition of the OH-MTS soUd: Al/(AH-Si): 0.003; Na/(A1+Si): 0.0014 2.1.2. 3-aminopropylsilyl-MTS (NH2-MTS) 2a and 2b 2a and 2b were prepared by addition of 3-aminopropyltrialkoxysilane (3 g, 13 mmol. and 0.7 g, 3 mmol. respectively) to a suspension of freshly activated MTS silica (3 g) in refluxing toluene (50 ml), then stirred for 5 hours. The modified solid was filtered, washed in a soxhlet apparatus with di-ethyl ether and dichloromethane, then dried at 393 K. Elem. anal.:2a % C 3.48, %N 1.18, %Si 40.54; 2b % C 7.07, %N 2.22, %Si 37.60. % organic weight / dry mineral weight: 2a: 6.8; 2b: 11 IR (cm-l): 3732, 3650, 3375, 3306, 2979, 2936, 2867, 1974, 1836 . 13C CP-MAS-NMR (ppm): = 2b: Si -aCH2-PCH2-YCH2-NH2: «£: 8.9; P^: 26.4; Y£l: 43.3 2.1.3. 3-chloropropylsilyl-MTS (Cl-MTS) 3a and 3-iodopropylsilyl-MTS (IMTS) 3b. 3a and 3b were prepared using 3-chloro- and 3-iodopropyltriethoxysilane as silanating agents, respectively, according to the previous procedure. Elem. a n a l : 3a % C 7.22, %C1 5.23, %Si 38.43; 3b C 6.65, %C1 0.62, %I 10,%Si 35. % organic weight / dry mineral weight :3a: 12.9 ; 3b: 20.3. IR (cm-l): 3a 3732, 3650, 2970, 2940, 1974, 1836 . 13C CP-MAS-NMR (ppm) : 3a: = Si (OCH2CH3)aCH2-PCH2-YCH2-Cl: 0£H2CH3: 58.7; OCH2CH3: 16.3; ^Q: 8.9; P£: 26.3; Y£: 46.3. 2.1.4. 3-N-piperidinopropylsilyl-MTS (Cl-PipMTS) 4a and (I-PipMTS) 4b. A suspension of activated 3a or 3b (3 g) in toluene (30 cc) was refluxed and stirred in an excess of piperidine (1 g) for 6h. The modified solid 4a or 4b was then washed in succession with water, then with di-ethyl ether-dichloromethane mixture in a soxhlet aparatus overnight. 4b was subsequently washed with ethanol in a soxlhet apparatus overnight leading to 4b'. Elem. anal. : 4a % C 6.86, %N 0.86, %C1 0.20, %Si 38.54; 4b %C 9.72, %N 1.42, %C1 0.12, %I 0.24, %Si 38.05; 4a' % ClO.26, %N 1.27, CI 710 ppm, %I 0.47, %Si 35.55. % organic weight / dry mineral weight: 4a: 12.5; 4b: 15.0; 4b': 15.7 IR (cm-l): 4a: 3731, 3649, 2945, 2892, 2867, 2818, 1974, 1866 . 2.2. General condensation procedure Benzaldehyde (1.75 g, 16.5 mmol.) and ethylcyanoacetate (1.87 g, 16.5 mmol.) was added to the modified catalyst (0.22 g) previously activated at 150°C under vacuum overnight and stirred in suspension in DMSO ( total volume : 55 ml) under nitrogen atmosphere at 80°C. The reaction progress was
82
monitored by periodically withdrawing samples which were analyzed by G.C. using decane as internal standart for mass balance. 4. CONCLUSION MTS silicas functionalized with amino groups exhibit interesting base catalytic properties in condensation reaction which are well-correlated with their physico-chemical characteristics. The greater activity of the immobilized primary amine sites compare to the tertiary amine sites in the Knoevenagel condensation is explained by the imine intermediate formation which is much more reactive than the parent carbonyl group of the reactant. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors thanks Francesco Di Renzo for fruitful discussions on the characterizations of mesoporous materials. One of them (A.C.) is indebted to ADEME (Agence de TEnvironnement et de la Maitise de I'Energie) for a doctoral grant. REFERENCES 1 I. Rodriguez, H. Cambon, D. Brunei, M. Lasp6ras, P. Geneste, Stud. Surf.Sci.Catal., 78(1993)623 2 M. Lasperas, H. Cambon, D. Brunei, I.Rodriguez and P. Geneste, Microporous Mater., 1(1993)343 3 M. Lasperas, I. Rodriguez, D. Brunei, H. Cambon, P. Geneste, Stud. Surf. Sci.Catal. 97(1995)173; 4 M. Lasperas, H. Cambon, D. Brunei, I.Rodriguez and P. Geneste, Microporous Mater., 7(1996)61 5 C. Naccache, D. Archier and G. Coudurier, Abstr. IX^^ IZC, Montreal Eds. JB Higgins, R. von Ballmoos and M.M. J. Treacy, (1992) FP18. 6 P.E. Hathaway and M.E. Davis, J. Catal., 116 (1989) 263 and 279 7 J.C. Kim, H.-X. Li, C.-Y. Chen and M.E. Davis, Microporous Mater., 2 (1994) 413 8 H. Tsuji, F. Yagi and H. Hattori, Chem. Lett. (1991) 1881 9 F. Yagi, N. Kanuka, H. Tsuji, H. Kita and H. Hattori, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 2Q (1994) 349 10 A. Cauvel, G. Renard and D. Brunei, Europacat II, Maastricht (1995); J. Org. Chem. (in print) 11 D. Brunei, A. Cauvel, F. Fajula and F. Di Renzo, Stud. Surf. Sci., Catal. 22, (1995) 173 12 A. Cauvel, D. Brunei, F. Di Renzo and F. Fajula, Amer Inst.of Phys., 254 (1996) 477. 13 K.R. Kloetstra and H. van Bekkum, J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun.,(1995) 1005 14 Knoevenagel, Ber., 22 (1896) 172 15 A. Corma, V. Fom6s, R.M. Martin-Aranda, H. Garcia and J. Primo, Applied Catal., 52(1990)237 16 E. Angeletti, C. Canepa, G. Martinetti and P. Venturello, Tetrahedron. Lett., 22 (1988) 2261 17 A.Reyes and R.M. Scott, J. Phys. Chem., M (1980) 3600 18 G. Charles, Bull. Soc. chim. Fr., (1963) 1559
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
83
Modified clay catalysts for acylation of crown compounds S. Bekassy^ K. Bir6^ T. Cseri''^'^ B. Agai' and F. Figueras^ ^Department of Organic Chemical Technology, Technical University of Budapest, H-1521 Budapest, Hungary ^Institut de Recherches sur la Catalyse du CNRS, 2 Avenue Albert Einstein, F-69626 Villeurbanne, France
1. SUMMARY Heterogeneous catalytic acetylation of benzo-15-crovm-5 was investigated using different ion exchanged KIO catalysts. The nature of the transition metal ions introduced in the mesoporous clay plays an important role in the activity of the catalysts. Fe^^-KlO is particularly advantageous for practical preparative purposes. 4'-Acetyl-benzo-15-crown-5 was isolated with 55% yield under optimal conditions.
2. INTRODUCTION Crown ethers are well known for their ability to form strong complexes with alkali metal and organic cations. Introduction of lipophilic substituents into crown ethers has a great importance e. g. for their application as electroactive substances in ion-selective electrodes [1] and as complexing agents for recovering precious or radioactive metal cations [2]. These substituents can be introduced into benzo annelated crown ethers by S^ reactions (alkylation, acylation, nitration, halogenation). The introduced substituents modify the complexing properties of the crown ether macroring through the aromatic ring. We have taken an advantage of this phenomenon at the planning of the K-selective ionophore BME-44 (2) and at its synthesis starting from benzo-15-crown-5 (B15C5) (1). In order to study how the NH group of the molecules of type 2 influences the complexation it was necessary to synthesize the analogue of type 4 [3]. To clear up the role of the NO2 group we have synthesized the derivatives of type 5 [4,5] having the similar electron-withdrawing ester group which is also sufficiently lipophilic in the case of an appropriate R substituent. Both these types as target molecules have the same 3 acetyl derivative (4'Ac-B15C5) as key intermediate. The obvious way to prepare the latter compound is the acetylation of _!, therefore it was extremely important to develop a well controllable procedure for the preparation of 3. Acylation of B15C5 in a Friedel-Crafts type reaction with the classical Lewis acid AICI3 can be performed only with poor yields (about 30%) in the presence of a large excess of ' present address: Institiit FrauQais du Petiole, F-92506 Rueil-Mabnaison, France s work was supported by the VARGA JOZSEF Foundation of the Technical University of Budapest and by the Hungarian Science Foundation OTKA (grant No. T-015673 and T-015677).
84 catalyst (catalyst/substrate ratio is about 5.5) [6] because of the formation of a stable AlCl,crown ether complex [7]. In reality the acetylation can be carried out with P2O5 or in polyphosphoric acid [8,9]. Both homogeneous catalytic reactions give rise to serious corrosion and environmental problems and their practical application is therefore very limited. Substitution of mineral acids by solid acids as catalysts can reduce these difficulties. Moreover solid catalysts offer by their nature other advantages such as an easier separation and work-up because of the heterogeneous system.
C"" N^V^"^ """^W
"^
<^o
^
^^^^"
H N ^ o
BME.44 FLUKA product No. 60397
.y...
o - c^ -?0
85 Mesoporous clays, such as the commercial catalyst KIO, ion exchanged with transition metal cations (Me"^-K10) were active for benzylation of aromatic compounds [10]. The reaction rate appeared to be related not to the acidity of the solid, but to its redox properties. In other words, the formation of the carbocation involved a redox step of the type: O-CH2CI + Fe^^ -^ Fe"^ + O-CHjCl"^"
a)-CH2Ci'^" -^ o-CH2'^ + c r Cr + F e ' ^ - > F e ' V c r Such a mechanism for C-Cl activation should be valid for acyl chlorides and we reported recently a heterogeneous catalytic acetylation of B15C5 with an acceptable 32% yield of isolated product, using Cu^^-KlO [11].
C "
AcCl, 83°C (ill 1,2-dichloroethane)
»
o
CH,
Cu^^-K 10 catalyst
This work presents an optimization of the reaction and an extension to other catalysts in order to clarify the role of acidity and achieve a yield high enough for production purposes. 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Previous work was performed with a fairly diluted reaction mixture, and it was first attempted to increase the total concentration in order to reduce the volume/product ratio. Under unchanged component ratios two steps of increase could be realized (Table 1) with the limiting amount of the solid material (about 17 g catalyst for 100 cm^ solvent) provided that sufficient stirring was used. The gained 9% B15C5 concentration in the reaction mixture is already a useful level for fine chemical synthesis. Table 1 Development in reaction conditions for Cu^^-KlO catalyst B15C5 concentration g/lOOcm^
Component ratio mol/mol CU^VB15C5
ACC1/B15C5
4'Ac-B15C5 % By-products (time to reach the final level) %
0.18
0.2
20
42
(3h)
traces
3.6
0.2
20
66
(Ih)
11
oa
5
60
(2h)
10
0.1
5
64
(1.5h)
liiH^^^^
8
After the first concentration jump it was established that both the catalyst/B15C5 ratio and the AcCl excess could be reduced, at practically unchanged yield (determined by HPLC) and by-product level. The amount of the by-products could not be reduced by decreasing the reaction temperature to 60°C. We have also examined how catalysts exchanged with other transition metal cations can be used for this acetylation reaction. ZnClj is good catalyst of special Friedel-Crafts reactions (activated aromatic compounds, e.g. phenols) therefore Zn -exchanged KIO was one of the selection. The results of two hours reaction time are presented in Table 2. The reaction conditions are the same as found best for Cu'^^-KlO (3.6 g B15C5/100cm', 0.1 mol Me"Vmol B15C5, 5 mol AcCl/mol B15C5). The optimum conditions for Fe^^-KlO were identical to those determined with Cu^^-KlO. Table 2 Comparison of catalysts containing different exchanged metals 4'Ac-B15C5 By-products
Acidity
rel. int.
%
%
Bronsted
Cu^'^-KlO
60
10
0.13
0.68
Zn^'^-KlO
55
10
0.16
0.73
Fe^'^-KlO
85
14
0.35
0.34
KIO(H^)
45
8
0.33
0.28
Lewis
Cu^^-KlO and Zn^^-KlO catalysts result in practically the same reaction rate and product yield. On the other hand Fe ^-KIO leads the reaction substantially faster (Fig. 1) and till a practically complete conversion, although the amount of the by-products is also higher. With a double quantity of Fe -KIO catalyst the reaction is completed in 30 minutes. For comparison the performance of the original KIO (without ion exchange) is also presented in Table 2. The differences are always significant in favour of the ion exchanged catalysts, so the introduced metal ions play an important role in the activity of the catalyst. These metal ions increase the Lewis acidity of the catalysts [10] but the efficiency does not depend directly on this acidity: Fe -KIO is particularly active although it has a lower Lewis acidity than the two other ion-exchanged catalysts. At the same time the Lewis acidity of the salts in homogeneous phase diminishes in the sequence Fe^^> Zn^^> Cu^^; CuCl2 itself is not used in this type of organic reactions. Nevertheless, the Lewis acidity could play a role because the heat treatment of the catalysts at 250°C is advantageous: in the case ofFe^'^-KlO the reached product yield increases from 55% (with only dried catalyst) to 85%. The question arises why Fe -KIO catalyst has a special reactivity in this reaction. The activity pattern observed on the same series of catalyst samples for the alkylation of aromatics by benzyl chloride i.e. Fe^^-KlO > Zn^'^-KlO > Cu^'^-KlO » KIO is compatible with the activities observed here, and suggests that the mechanism of formation of the carbocation could be similar, therefore occiu-s by oxidation.
87 4'Ac-B15C5 (%) UU -| ^,
80 60-
_.
^Zi
__ ^ — 5
4020 0 i (.
y
, 0.5
,
,
Fe3+-K10 -Cu2+-K10 - - 3 K - Zn2+-K10 "ik' O -
->Zi--
,
1.5 Reaction time (h)
Figure 1. Activity of the investigated catalysts. In order to evaluate the reactivity of Fe^^-KlO it is worth mentioning that KIO itself contains Fe in the octahedral layer (1.97%, Table 3), which has become at least partly accessible upon steam treatments or acid leaching during the manufacturing process. This Fe could be one reason of its activity. The exchanged Fe ^ represents a smaller amount (0.95%) but it is deposited at the surface, certainly more accessible then far more effective since the final conversion rises from 45 to 85%. The usual work-up procedure of the reaction mixture made with Fe^^-KlO under optimum conditions (Table 2) resulted in 4'Ac-B15C5 with 55% yield. This result gives a practical preparative method which is really competitive with the 65-70% yield of the P2O5 or polyphosphoric acid acylation methods and eliminates their drawbacks: difficult handling and mixing because of high viscosity, costly neutralization. 4. EXPERIMENTAL KIO clay is manufactured by high temperature acidic treatment from bavarian montmorillonite and was purchased from Siid Chemie as original sample. Cation exchange was performed by gradually adding 10 g KIO clay to 125 cm^, 1 mol/1 stirred solution of CuClj, FeClg or ZnCl2 at room temperature and stirring the suspension for 24 hours. After exchange, the suspensions were filtered and washed with deionised water. The resulting solids were dried on a thin bed at 100°C and ground. Specific surface areas were calculated fi'om BET nitrogen isotherms determined at -196°C on samples degassed at 250°C for 12h before the experiment. Chemical analyses were obtained by plasma emission spectroscopy. Acidity of the catalysts was measured by intensity of the IR bands of pyridine coordinated to Bronsted and Lewis sites respectively. For a quantitative characterization the area of the absorption bands was related to the area of a structural band of the clay in the same spectral region (values indicated as rel. int.) [10].
88
Table 3 Some characteristic data of the catalysts Catalyst
Specific surface Surface area of Fe content Metal retained Charge exchanged area micropores m^/g m^/g wt % wt% meq/g cat
KIO
229
2.5
1.97
Cu^'^-KlO 236
-
Cu''^=1.24
0.39
Zn^'^-KlO 213
-
Zn^'^=1.19
0.36
Fe^'^-KlO 239
10
Fe^"^ = 0.95
0.54
2.92
General reaction conditions [11]: Acetylation was made by acetyl chloride in 15 cm^ 1,2dichloroethane at 83°C (boiling point) using a batch reactor. The catalysts were normally heat treated at 250°C. After filtration the solvent was evaporated in vacuo, from the residue 3x15 cm^ dichloroethane was distilled to eliminate the traces of acetyl chloride. The dark, thick residual oil was repeatedly extracted with boiling n-heptane. After cooling the crystals were filtered. Yield: 55% isolated product (in the case ofFe' -KIO catalyst). The reactions were monitored by HPLC (CI8 reversed phase column, eluent methanolwater 50:50 v/v, UV-detection at 254 nm). 5. CONCLUSIONS Benzo-15-crown-5 has been acetylated efficiently using KIO clays ion-exchanged by Cu ^, Fe^^ or Zn^^. The best results were obtained with Fe^^-KlO. The catalytic properties are not related to the acidity of the solid and it can therefore be admitted that the C-Cl bond is activated by a redox mechanism, as proposed earlier for the alkylation of aromatic compounds by benzyl chloride. The results give a practical preparative method, competitive with the P2O5 or polyphosphoric acid acylation processes. The method can be generalized and was successfully applied in acetylation of other benzo-crown compounds.
REFERENCES 1. E. Lindner, K. Toth, J. Jeney, M. Horvath, E. Pungor, I. Bitter, B. Agai and L. Toke, Microchim. Acta I., (1990) 157. 2. J. Beger and M. Meerbote, J. prakt. Chem., 327 (1985) 2. 3. L. Toke, I. Bitter, B. Agai, E. Csongor, K. Toth, E. Lindner, M. Horvath, S. Harfouch and E. Pungor, .Justus Liebigs Annalen der Chemie, (1988) 349. 4. L. Toke, L Bitter, B. Agai, Z. Hell, E. Lindner, K. Toth, M. Horvath, S. Harfouch and E. Pungor, Justus Liebigs Annalen der Chemie, (1988) 549.
89 5. K. Toth, E. Lindner, M. Horvath, J. Jeney, I. Bitter, B. Agai, T. Meisel and L. Toke, Anal. Lett., 22 (1989) 1185. 6. K. Szabo, Diploma Thesis, Technical University of Budapest, 1990. 7. F. Wada and T. Matsuda, Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 53 (1980) 421. 8. W.W. Paris, P.E. Stott, C.W. McCausland and J.S. Bradshaw, J. Org. Chem., 43 (1978) 4577. 9. S. Kano, T. Yokomatsu, H. Nemoto and S. Shibuya, Tetrahedron Lett., 26 (1985) 1531. lO.T. Cseri, S. Bekassy, F. Figueras and S. Rizner, J. Mol. Catal. A: Chemical, 98 (1995) 101. 1 l.T. Cseri, S. Bekassy, Z. Bodas, B. Agai and F. Figueras, Tetrahedr. Lett., 37 (1996) 1473.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Acylation of aromatics over a HBEA Zeolite. Effect of solvent and of acylating agent. F. Jayat\ M. J. Sabater Picot^ D. Rohan^ and M. Guisnet\ ^ URA CNRS 350, Catalyse en Chimie Organique, Universite de Poitiers, 40 avenue du Recteur Pineau, 86022 Poitiers Cedex, France. Fax : 33 - 5 49 45 34 99 ^ Instituto de Tecnologia Quimica UPV-CSIC, Univ. Politecnica de Valencia, Avd. Los Naranjos S/n, 46022 Valencia, Spain. ^ Dept of Chemical and Life Sciences, University of Limerick, Limerick, Ireland.
Summary. A kinetic study of the acylation of phenol with phenyl acetate was carried out in liquid phase at 160°C over HBEA zeolite samples, sulfolane or dodecane being used as solvents. The initial rates of hydroxyacetophenone (HAP) production were similar in both solvents. However the catalyst deactivation was faster in dodecane, most likely because of the faster formation of heavy reaction products such as bisphenol A derivatives. Moreover, sulfolane had a very positive effect on p-HAP formation and a negative one on o-HAP formation. To explain these observations as well as the influence of phenol and phenyl acetate concentrations on the rates of o- and p-HAP formation it is proposed that sulfolane plays two independent roles in phenol acylation : solvation of acylium ions intermediates and competition with phenyl acetate and phenol for adsorption on the acid sites. Donor substituents of phenyl acetate have a positive effect on the rate of anisole acylation, provided however there are no difRzsion limitations in the zeolite pores.
Introduction. Fries rearrangement and acylation of aromatics are of great importance in many areas of the fine chemical and pharmaceutical industry. The manufacture of several major pharmaceuticals (e.g. Ibuprofen, (S)-Naproxen) involves an aromatic acylation step, whereas some synthetic fragrances of the musk type contain an acetyl group [1,2]. Considerable effort has been devoted to the development of solid acid catalysts, since the traditional catalyst, AICI3, causes many environmental problems. Tridirectional large pore zeolites (in particular HBEA and HFAU zeolites) are very promising catalysts for the synthesis in liquid phase of benzenic ketones [3-5]. Furthermore, Rhone-Poulenc has recently developed an industrial process using zeolite catalysts for the selective acylation in para position of arylethers [5]. The acylation of
92 aromatics is also very interesting from a fundamental point of view because of the general complexity of the reaction scheme. This paper is devoted to the acylation in liquid phase of phenol and anisole by aromatic acetates. Reaction mechanisms are presented and the effect of the solvent polarity which is known to play an important role on the rate and on the selectivity of zeolite catalysed reactions [6] and of the nature of the acylating agent are discussed.
Results and Discussion. 1. Influence of the solvent on the transformation of a phenyl acetate - phenol mixture. The transformation of an equimolar mixture of phenol (P) and of phenyl acetate (PA) (2.2M) was carried out in dodecane (2.3M) or in sulfolane (5.5M) solvents over 100 mg and 500 mg of H-BEA-10 and over 100 mg of H-BEA-70. 0-hydroxyacetophenone (o-HAP),phydroxyacetophenone (p-HAP), p-acetoxyacetophenone (p-AXAP) and phenol appear as primary products while bisphenol A and its mono and diacylated products as well as a low amount of hydroxy-benzoate of benzyle and traces of trimethylbenzene appear at high conversion only.
sulfolane
25 n 20 -
a dodecane
V""^""^^
y - ^
1^ 16 <
^
jT^
10 -
X
sulfolane D dodecane
5 A J
P
1
()
5
1
1
1
1
10 15 20 25
time (h) Figure 1 : Transformation of the phenolphenyl acetate mixture over 500 mg of HBEA-10. Yield in HAP (%) as a function of time (h) in sulfolane and in dodecane solvents
10 20 30 40 50 PA conversion (%) Figure 2 : Transformation of the phenolphenyl acetate mixture over 500 mg of HBEA-10. Yield in heavy products (%) as a function of PA conversion (%) in sulfolane and in dodecane solvents
The initial rates of HAP production are similar in sulfolane and in dodecane (Fig 1). However, after 5 hours reaction in dodecane a constant value of the HAP yield of around 12% is obtained. In sulfolane the HAP yield increases more significantly with time and reaches a constant value, at a longer reaction time (afl:er approximately 20 hours HAP yield = 23 %). Therefore, the catalyst deactivation is faster in dodecane than in sulfolane. Figure 2 shows that the selectivity to heavy reaction products (bisphenol A derivatives etc.) which can poison the
93 active sites or block their access, is higher in dodecane than in sulfolane, which could explain the more rapid deactivation observed in dodecane. The effect of the solvent is different for the production of o- and p-HAP (Fig 3): the rate of o-HAP production is greater in dodecane than in sulfolane (about 6 times initially) while it is the contrary for p-HAP production particularly for long reaction times. The consequence of this solvent effect is that, whatever the PA conversion, the p/o HAP ratio is much greater in sulfolane than in dodecane e g around 8 in sulfolane at 30%PA conversion against 1 in dodecane.
6 -[
a
5] ^"^
^ 4
n
<
^ 2 o 1 n
]f
sulfolane 1 D dodecane | 1
U i*
1
c)
2
1
1
1
1
1
4 6 time (h)
8
10
sulfolane D dodecane
6 time (h)
8
10
Figure 3 : Transformation of the phenol-phenyl acetate mixture over 500 mg of H-BEA-10. Influence of the solvent on the yields in o-HAP (a) and in p-HAP (b). This contrary effect of solvent on the productions of o-HAP and p-HAP is in favour of the recent proposal of different mechanisms for their formation [4] : intramolecular rearrangement of PA for the formation of o-HAP
OAc
o„o
ar
-CH3
(1)
and acylation of P by PA for that of p-HAP OH
OAc (2)
p-AXAP would result from the autoacylation of PA with simultaneous formation of phenol OAc
'^ 0 II
C-CH3
OH
+
(3)
94 An excess of phenol is formed, due either to the decomposition of PA (reaction 4) and/or to the reaction of PA with water (reaction 5) or with the zeolite hydroxyl groups.
QAc
OH OH
6^
CH2=C=0 (ketene) (4)
OAc
6^
H20
*-\( ) \ + CH3COOH (5)
Water can result, for instance, from the formation of bisphenol A and of its derivatives. Indeed bisphenol A could result from the acid catalyzed condensation of two molecules of phenol with one molecule of acetone (reaction 6) resulting from the bimolecular condensation of acetic acid. Through this scheme one water molecule per molecule of bisphenol A is formed. HO
o
O + CH3-e-CH3
(6)
For simplification the production of this excess of phenol will be henceforth called PA 'hydrolysis'. The initial rate of p-AXAP formation is greater in sulfolane than in dodecane. Whatever the solvent, a maximum is observed in the yield of p-AXAP. This maximum can be explained by a secondary transformation of this product probably by 'hydrolysis' into p-HAP. At low PA conversion the ratio of the rates of p-HAP and p-AXAP productions is equal to 5 in sulfolane and to 7 in dodecane. These high values are expected from the better donor effect of the OH group compared to the OAc group. An increase in this ratio is observed at high PA conversion due to 'hydrolysis' of p-AXAP into p-HAP. The negative effect of sulfolane on the formation of o-HAP, already observed during the transformation of pure PA, could be explained by a competition between sulfolane and PA for adsorption on the acid sites. However, if this were the case, sulfolane would also decrease the initial rates of p-HAP and p-AXAP formations which involve adsorbed PA species (for the acylation of P or of PA). The initial rates of production of p-HAP and p-AXAP in sulfolane and in dodecane are less easy to compare than the rates of o-HAP production. Indeed the apparent greater production of p-HAP and p-AXAP in sulfolane could be due to the greater catalyst stability in this solvent. However, from the two experiments with H-BEA-10 (lOOmg and 500 mg) and from the experiment with H-BEA-70 it can be concluded that the initial production of p-HAP and p-AXAP is faster in sulfolane than in dodecane. Moreover, the same conclusion can be drawn from acylation of anisole with phenyl acetate or p-tolyl acetate : the initial rate of formation of p-methoxyacetophenone is higher in sulfolane than in dodecane. Therefore sulfolane would have, besides a negative effect on the reaction rates due to its
95 competition with PA for adsorption on the acid sites, a large positive effect (larger than the negative one) on the formation of p-HAP and of p-AXAP. This positive effect of sulfolane could be related to better dissociation of phenyl acetate into acylium ions.
H^
+ CH3-C=0
^
(7)
The solvation of the acylium ions would displace to the right the thermodynamic equilibrium of reaction 7. This better dissociation of phenyl acetate would favour the bimolecular formation of p-HAP and p-AXAP and would be unfavorable for the intramolecular formation of o-HAP. Experiments with equimolar amounts of P and PA (2.2 M) in sulfolane - dodecane mixtures of different compositions were carried out to specify the effect of the sulfolane concentration (Csuif) on the formation of products. The rate of o-HAP formation decreases with the introduction of sulfolane into the reaction mixture then becomes constant for Csuif ^ 1.6 M. On the other hand the rates of p-HAP and p-AXAP formation first increase with the introduction of sulfolane into the reaction mixture then decrease to remain constant for Csuif > 1.6 M (Fig 4). The curves with a maximum obtained for the latter products indicate that sulfolane has two effects on their formation : i) sulfolane increases their rate of formation owing to a solvation effect ii) sulfolane competes with the reactants for adsorption on the active acid sites, hence limiting the rate of formation of p-HAP and p-AXAP. Furthermore the decrease in the rate of o-HAP formation when Csuif increases can be explained either by the competition between sulfolane and PA for adsorption on the acid sites or by this competition plus a solvation effect. To discriminate between these two proposals the effect of the concentration of PA (CPA) and of P (Cp) on the initial rates was determined.
O)
o O-HAP
"o E E^
6 -
a p-HAP A p-AXAP
4 -
2 m E 2 4 Csuif (mol/l)
b
8 -[
2^ 0-
A~_
H
1
-\
2 4 Csuif (mol/l)
Figure 4 : Transformation of the phenol-phenyl acetate mixture over 100 mg of H-BEA-10. Rates of o-HAP (a), p-HAP and p-AXAP (b) formations as a function of the concentration of sulfolane Csuif.
96 2. Kinetic study of the transformation of the phenol-phenyl acetate mixture. The effect of Cp and CPA was determined under the following conditions : a) effect of C?, CpA = 2.2 moU'\ Cp = 0.6, 1.2 and 2.2 mol.r\ Csuif being then equal to 7.0, 6.5 and 5.5 mol.l"^ respectively b) effect of CPA, CP = 2.2 moU'\ CPA = 1.1, 2.2 and 3.2 mol.l'^ and Csuif = 6.9, 5.5 and 4.1 mol.l'V Very high sulfolane concentrations were chosen so that their change did not affect the initial reaction rates. Table 1 shows that the reaction orders are not very different in sulfolane and in dodecane for the formation of p-HAP and p-AXAP. On the other hand the effect of Cp and CPA on the rate of o-HAP formation is completely different in sulfolane and in dodecane. Table 1 : Transformation of the phenol (P), phenyl acetate (PA) mixture on a H-BEA-10 zeolite sample. Reaction orders. Formation of With respect to o-HAP p-HAP p-AXAP Solvent 2 PA Sulfolane 1 1 1.5 0.3 0.6 Dodecane P Sulfolane -1 0.1 0.1 -1 -0.5 0.2 Dodecane The following scheme in which the surface reaction (step b) is the limiting step has been previously proposed [4] to explain the formation of o-HAP. X is the active acid site. PA+X PA-X o-HAP-X
^
^
^ ^
PA-X
(a)
o-HAP-X
(b)
o-HAP+ X
(c)
This reaction scheme which does not take into account solvation effects leads to the following equation of the initial rate Vo
1+ Kp^ CpA + K p Cp + K s Cs with kb the rate constant of step b, C^ the total concentration in acid sites, KPA, KP and Ks the equilibrium constants of adsorption of PA, P and S (the solvent). Equation 8 can explain the effect of Cp and CPA on the reaction rate found in dodecane : KPA CPA, in comparison to 1+Kp Cp, is not negligible i.e that PA is strongly adsorbed. Phenol is also strongly adsorbed (reaction order around-0.5). This equation can also explain the effect of Cp and CPA on the rate of o-HAP formation in the sulfolane solvent if we admit that sulfolane is strongly adsorbed on the acid sites. Indeed, in this case, Ks Cs will be greater than the other terms of the denominator, which leads to reaction orders with respect to PA equal to 1 and to P equal to 0 i.e practically to the experimental values (Table 1). Therefore, if a solvation effect on the rate of o-HAP formation cannot be excluded, all the kinetic resuks can be explained just by the competition between sulfolane and the reactants for adsorption on the acid sites.
97 3. Influence of the acylating agent. A preliminary study of the effect on the anisole acylation rate of the aromatic acetate used as acylating agent, was carried out in sulfolane under the standard conditions. Phenyl acetates substituted with donor groups (acetate, methyl, methoxy) were chosen. Indeed these donor groups should increase the basicity of the oxygen atoms of the acetyl group, hence favouring the formation of the acylium ion. Whatever the acetate, p-methoxyacetophenone was practically the only product of anisole transformation (selectivity >98%). On the other hand aromatic acetates were transformed through intramolecular and intermolecular acylation and through hydrolysis. Table 2 : Yield of p-methoxyacetophenone (mole %) obtained during the acylation of anisole with various acetates under the standard operating conditions (see experimental section) Acylating agents Phenyl p-tolyl 2-methoxyhydroquinone 2-methoxy2,4,6-trimethyl hydroquinone phenyl acetate acetate acetate phenyl acetate diacetate diacetate OAc OAc OAc QAc OAc OAc 3Me T OMe
or
p 9 p
Time (h)
0.25 24
CH3
3.0 12.5
4.0 15.2
^^^
3.7 14.0
1.4 1.5
sXy
¥ 1
OAc 2.5 10.3
0.05 0.05
The rate of anisole acylation depended on the acetate (Table 2). Initially it was about 1.5 times greater with p-tolyl acetate and with 2-methoxyphenyl acetate than with phenyl acetate, slightly lower with 2-methoxyhydroquinone diacetate, 2.5 times lower with the hydroquinone diacetate and very low with 2,4,6-trimethylphenyl acetate. The low reactivity of this latter acetate can be related to limitations in the rate of diffusion of this bulky compound in the BE A zeolite pores. Furthermore, a greater reactivity of this acetate was found with HFAU zeolites whose pore size is greater. Curiously, with hydroquinone diacetate (but not with the 2methoxyhydroquinone acetate), there was a quasi immediate deactivation. We are carrying out additional experiments so as to understand how the reactivity of aromatic acetates changes with their nature and the zeolite acidity and porosity.
Experimental. All the reactions were carried out at 160°C in a flask equipped with a cooler and a magnetic stirrer (600 rpm). Two HBEA zeolite samples were used as catalysts : HBEAIO (total and framework Si/Al ratios of 11 and 15.5 respectively, provided by PQ Zeolites : CP 811-DL-25) and HBEA70 resulting from the dealumination of HBEAIO by acid treatment [7] (total and framework Si/Al ratios of 72). The standard operating conditions were as follows : 100 mg catalyst (previously activated overnight in air at 500°C), 20 mmol of reagent (phenol or anisole) at a concentration of 2.2 M, 20 mmol of acylating agent (phenyl acetate, etc.) also
at a concentration of 2.2 M and the corresponding quantity of solvent (sulfolane, dodecane or sulfolane-dodecane mixtures). Small samples of the reaction mixtures (about 0.1 cm^) were taken at various reaction times, diluted with methylene chloride and analyzed by gas chromatography on a 25 m capillary column of CP Sil 8 CB.
Conclusion. Under mild conditions (liquid phase, 160°C) HBEA zeolites can catalyse the acylation of phenol with phenyl acetate. High selectivity to p-hydroxyacetophenone is obtained by using sulfolane as a solvent, which can be explained by a better dissociation of phenyl acetate into acylium ions due to a solvation effect. However a competition between sulfolane and phenyl acetate for adsorption on the active acid sites is also demonstrated. A preliminary investigation of the effect of the acylating agent shows that generally, donor groups in aromatic acetates have a positive effect on the rate of acylation provided they do not block the access of the acetate to the acid sites of the zeolite pores.
Acknowledgement. Financial support by the European Commission within the Human Capital and Mobility program (contract n° ERBCHRXCT940564) is gratefully acknowledged. F. Jayat gratefully acknowledges the 'Region Poitou-Charentes' for a scholarship.
References. 1. H. van Bekkum, A. J. Hoefhagel, M. A. van Koten, E.A. Gunnewegh, A.H.G. Vogt and H.W. Kouwenhoven, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 83 (1994) 379. 2 H.G. Franck, J.W. Stadelhofer, in 'Industrial Aromatic Chemistry', Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg, 1987. 3 A. Vogt, H.W. Kouwenhoven and R. Prins, Appl. Catal. A : General 123 (1995) 37. 4 F. Jayat, M.J. Sabater Picot and M. Guisnet, Catal. Lett.,41 (1996) 181. 5 M. Spagnol, L. Gilbert, R. Jacquot, H. Guillot, P.J. Tirel, A-M. Le Govic, Proc. 4**^ Int. Symp. on Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals, September 8-12, 1996, Basel, Switzerland. 6 L. Gilbert, C. Mercier, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 78 (1993), 51. 7 C. Coutanceau, J.M. Da Silva, M.F. Alvarez, F.R. Ribeiro, M. Guisnet, J. Chim. Phys., to be published.
99
Zeolite-Catalysed Acetylation of Alkenes with Acetic Anhydride Keith Smith, *a Zhao Zhenhua,^ Lionel Delaude,^ and PhiHp K. G. Hodgson^ ^Department of Chemistry, University of Wales Swansea, Singleton Park, Swansea SA2 8PP, UK ^BP Chemicals Ltd, Sunbury Research Laboratory, Chertsey Road, Sunbury-onThames, TW16 7LN, UK
Abstract Among various microporous adsorbents such as alumina, silica, clays, molecular sieves, etc., the HY zeolite was found to be best at promoting the acylation of 2,3-dimethyl-2-butene with acetic anhydride. The influence of numerous experimental p a r a m e t e r s on the course of the reaction was investigated. Variations in the silica/alumina ratio of the zeolite, or in the relative proportions of reagents and catalyst, markedly affected the yield of 3,3,4trimethyl-4-penten-2-one, whereas the reaction time and temperature were less influential. The procedure was extended to various other alkenes and it was possible to regenerate and to reuse the solid catalyst without significant loss of activity. 1.
INTRODUCTION
Friedel-Crafts acylation is one of the most important methods for the synthesis of ketones [1]. To achieve satisfactory reaction rates, "catalysts" such as aluminium chloride are usually needed in more than stoichiometric amounts because of complexation to starting materials and/or products. Work-up often involves hydrolysis, which leads to loss of the catalyst and causes problems with corrosion and disposal of potentially toxic wastes. Also, reactions are not always clean and may lead to mixtures of products. Recourse to recoverable and regenerable solid catalysts can overcome many problems of these types [2]. Therefore, the development of new heterogeneous catalytic procedures for the acylation of organic compounds has become a priority for the chemical industry. Significant advances resulting from the use of aluminosilicate solids were made during the last few years [3-6] and the first industrial application of zeolites in large scale Friedel-Crafts acylations was reported very recently [7]. However, most of the efforts devoted so far focused on the acylation of aromatic compounds. To the best of our knowledge, recourse to heterogeneous aluminosilicate catalysts for the acylation of alkenes has not yet been reported. Conventional methods for alkene acylation [8] involve the use of Br0nsted or Lewis acids such as sulfuric acid [9], boron trifluoride [10], zinc chloride [11], or
100
tin(IV) chloride [12]. In this pubhcation, we present the results obtained in the acetylation of various alkenes with acetic anhydride in the presence of zeolites. 2. EXPERIMENTAL 2.1 Materials Commercially available alkenes (Aldrich) were used as supplied. Acetic anhydride (Aldrich, 99%) was refluxed overnight over P2O5 and distilled under dry N2. Unless otherwise specified, zeolite HY refers to a sample supplied by Merck Ltd UK (product code B-157, Si02/Al203 = 29, specific surface area 700 m^/g). Hp, H-mordenite, H-ZSM5, and HY zeolites with other Si/Al ratios were gifts fi:om PQ Zeolites. All solid catalysts were calcined in air at 400 or 550°C for 2-5 h prior to use and cooled to room temperature in a desiccator over silica gel. 2.2 Acylation procedure Afi:*eshlycalcined zeolite catalyst was added to a mixture of 2,3-dimethyl-2butene (1), acetic anhydride, and chlorobenzene (internal standard). The suspension was stirred at room temperature or heated for a few hours (see Tables for details). The solid was filtered off with suction and rinsed with acetone. The filtrate was analysed by GC on a Pye Unicam Series 104 chromatographic system using a glass column packed with SE-30 stationary phase. A sample of pure 3,3,4-trimethyl-4-penten-2-one (2) was prepared and characterised according to literature indications [13] and used for calibration. Yields were determined using the internal standard method. 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION To start our investigations, we examined the conversion of 2,3-dimethyl-2butene (1) into 3,3,4-trimethyl-4-penten-2-one (2) as a model reaction (eq. 1). The choice of acetic anhydride as the acetylating agent was made in the light of related studies on the acylation of aryl ethers. Our work in this field had shown that acetic anhydride was the most efiective reagent for the Friedel-Crafts acylation of anisole in the presence of Hp zeolite. A lower degree of conversion was achieved with acetyl chloride, while hardly any reaction occurred with ethyl acetate or acetic acid [6].
H (1)
COCH3
ACoO
V
C
+
AcOH
(1)
(2)
The ability of numerous microporous adsorbents to catalyse the acylation of (1) was scrutinised. Amorphous materials such as alumina, silica-alumina, or zinc oxide afforded only traces of the product (2) or were totally devoid of catalytic activity. KIO montmorillonite clay and two types of aluminophosphate or silicoaluminophosphate molecular sieves were equally inefficient in promoting acylation, whereas acidic forms of zeolites were much better catalysts. As can be seenfi:-omTable 1, proton-exchanged aluminosilicates with the ZSM-5, p, or
101
faujasite Y structures led to significant amounts of the desired ketone within 2 h at 60°C. Only HX zeolite, which lacks strongly acidic sites, and H-mordenite, which has monodimensional pores, gave very low yields of (2). Table 1 Comparison of activity between various proton-exchanged zeolite catalysts Catalyst
Si02/Al203
GCYieldof2(%)
2.4 HX zeolite H-mordenite 35 H-ZSM5 80 Hp zeolite 25 HY zeolite 12 HY zeolite 40 All reactions were carried out using a l/Ac20/zeolite ratio mmol/0.05 g at 60°C for 2 h.
0.1 0.9 9 22 41 49 of 1 mmol/1.2
Since the most encouraging results were obtained with catalysts possessing the faujasite Y structure, various other ion-exchanged forms of this molecular sieve were prepared and their catalytic activity assessed. Replacement of the proton counter-ions with either sodium, magnesium, aluminium, iron(III), copper(II), lanthanum(III), or mixed rare earths reduced the yields of (2) to trace amounts. Conversely, impregnation of HY zeolite with ZnCl2 or FeCls led to highly active catalysts. Preliminary experiments with these composite materials revealed, however, t h a t they did not withstand h e a t t r e a t m e n t , t h u s compromising their chances of recycling and reuse. Therefore, research in this direction was abandoned and unmodified HY zeolite was used as a catalyst for all our subsequent studies. To complement the data in Table 1, we investigated further the influence of the Si02/Al203 ratio of zeolite HY on the outcome of the reaction (Fig. 1). A sharp increase in the yield of (2) was first observed when the Si02/Al203 ratio increased from 5.4 to 10.5. This threshold effect probably indicates that a specific high acidic strength must be reached in order for the catalyst to play its role. An optimum efficiency was attained with the sample having a Si02/Al203 ratio of 29, then the conversion rate slowly decreased as the number of acidic sites per unit cell of the crystalline aluminosilicate dropped. In order to investigate the influence of the amount of catalyst on the acylation rate, the proportion of zeolite HY (Si02/Al203 = 29) was varied between 0.02 and 0.4 g per mmol of (1) and the model reaction, carried out at 25°C, was monitored by GC. The results after 2 h are plotted in Fig. 2. The yield of (2) steadily increased with the proportion of catalyst. In addition, analyses of the reaction mixtures at various time intervals indicated that the acylation was almost complete within one hour or less. Extending the reaction time to 24 h did not result in any significant improvement. The 5delds increased by only a few per-cent or remained unchanged after 2 h at room temperature. As an alternative to altering the amount of catalyst, we examined the influence of the alkene/acetic anhydride molar ratio on the course of the reaction
102
g 60CM
D 0
> 0 0
40-
20-
/
0 - flC—
100 Si02/Al203 Figure 1. Effect of the Si02/Al203 ratio of zeolite HY on the 5deld of 2 (all reactions were carried out using a I/AC2O/HY ratio of 1 mmol/ 10 mmol/O.l g at 25°C for 2 h).
0
0.1
1 0.2
, 0.3
, 0.4
0.5
Amount of HY (g/mmol of 1) Figure 2. Effect of the amount of zeolite HY on the 5nLeld of 2 (all reactions were carried out using a I/AC2O molar ratio of 1/15 at 25°C for 2 h).
(Table 2). In a first set of experiments, a fixed amount of alkene (1) was acetylated using a 5-, 10-, 15-, or 21-fold excess of acetic anhydride. Taking into accoimt the experimental errors, identical 5delds of ketone (2) were obtained in the three latter cases. Thus, an optimum was reached for an AC2O/I molar ratio close to 10/1. Exceeding this limit only added to the cost of the process without any practical advantage. In a second set of reactions, the amount of anhydride was kept constant and the amount of alkene was progressively increased. This modification of the proportions of reagents also led to increased formation of the acylated product. The yield of (2) was maximum for a I/AC2O molar ratio of 8/1 and slightly decreased when larger excesses were used. The use of a ten-fold excess of alkene led to a higher 5deld than when acetic anhydride was used in the same excess under otherwise identical conditions. Excess amounts of the low boiling point alkene could also be separated from the reaction mixture by distillation and recycled more easily than acetic anhydride (b. p. 73°C and 138-140°C respectively). Therefore, recourse to an excess of alkene would be more efficient and more economic than the use of excess acetic anhydride in an industrial process. To continue our systematic study of the acylation of 2,3-dimethyl-2-butene, we examined the influence of the temperature on the reaction course (Table 3). Using various amounts of the HY catalyst, the acylation of (1) was carried out at 25 or 65°C. Surprisingly, increasing the temperature had only a minor effect on the yield of (2), which increased by just a few per-cent. This confirmed previous indications that the acylation proceeds very quickly and that the time allowed for the reaction (2 h) is sufficient to afford completion at room temperature. To confirm this h5T3othesis, we followed the time course of the model reaction at
103 Table 2 Influence of the alkene/anhydride ratio on the yield of ketone I/AC2O (mol/mol)
GCYieldof2(%)a
Conditions
A 38 1/5 A 45b 1/10 46 A 1/15 A 1/21 45 B 18 1/1 B 27 2/1 B 34 5/1 44 B 8/1 42 B 10/1 15/1 B 37 Conditions A: reactions were carried out using a 1/HY zeolite ratio of 1 mmol/0.14 g at 22°C for 4 h. Conditions B: reactions were carried out using a AC2O/HY zeolite ratio of 1 mmol/0.1 g at 25°C for 2 h. ^Yield based on the reagent in deficiency. ''The yield was 32% using conditions B. 23°C (Fig. 3). The results clearly demonstrate that conversion occured rapidly and that almost no more reaction took place after 1 h. Table 3 Influence of the temperature on the yield of ketone Amount of HY Zeohte (g/mmol of 1)
GC Yield of 2 (%) Reaction at 25°C
0.2 0.3 0.4 All reactions were carried out using a
Reaction at 65°C
55 56 62 59 64 61 I/AC2O molar ratio of 1/10 for 2 h.
Next, we tried to introduce a solvent in our system, instead of using only neat liquid reagents. Three experiments were carried out in ethyl acetate, dichloromethane, and chloroform respectively (Table 4). Dilution of the reaction mixtures in these polar organic solvents did not have any beneficial influence on the acylation, as the yields of (2) were consistently lower than that obtained in the absence of any solvent. Ethyl acetate had the most negative effect, probably because this Lewis base competes with acetic anhydride for coordination to the acidic sites of the zeolite catalyst. A series of reactions was also performed using different grades of acetic anhydride, viz., (i) not purified before use, (ii) refluxed over P2O5 and distilled
104
Table 4 Influence of solvents on the yield of ketone Solvent
GCYieldof2(%)
AcOEt 28 CH2CI2 41 CHCI3 50 none 58 All reactions were carried out using 1 (1 mmol), AC2O (15 mmol), HY zeolite (0.2 g) in 1.718 g of solvent at 25°C for 5 h.
0
2 4 6 Reaction Time (h)
24
Figure 3. Time course of the acetylation of 1 (the reaction was carried out using a I/AC2O/ HY ratio of 1 mmol/15 mmol/0.138 g at 23°C).
under N2 prior to use, (iii) contaminated with small known amounts of acetic acid (5 or 10 molar %). The results were unambiguous: while satisfactory yields are obtained if acetic anhydride is purified before use, only traces of the ketone (2) were obtained in the presence of even relatively small amounts of acetic acid. This impurity is inevitably foimd in acetic anhydride left in contact with humidity. Therefore, it is essential to remove the acid accompan5dng the anhydride as completely as possible before starting the acylation of (1) in the presence of zeolite HY as the catalyst. The generation of acetic acid during the reaction also explains why the catalyst is deactivated before conversion is complete. As an alternative to prior removal of acetic acid, we performed this operation in situ by adding phosphorus pentoxide to our reaction mixtures. The results showed that the association of P2O5 and unpurified acetic anhydride led to inferior 5delds compared against purified anhydride alone. Yet, adding the drying agent to already purified anhydride boosted the yield of ketone (2), but made the work-up more cimabersome. Having established the influence of the various experimental parameters on the acylation of 2,3-dimethyl-2-butene, we extended the procedure to a few other alkenes (Table 5). Unsubstituted cyclohexene gave a mixture of 1-acetyl-lcyclohexene and 3-acetyl-l-cyclohexene in almost equimolar amounts. The best overall yield was obtained by reacting a five-fold excess of acetic anhydride and 0.1 g of zeolite HY per mmol of alkene for 1 h at 25°C. Increasing the reaction time or the proportions of acylating agent and catalyst had a detrimental effect on the yields of the a,p- and p,Y-unsaturated ketones. Acid-catalysed side reactions and degradations probably account for these observations. The acylation of the trisubstituted double bond of 1-methylcyclohexene was easier to carry out and afforded a 60% yield of 6-acetyl-1-methylcyclohexene within 3 h. Similarly, ethylidenecyclohexane led to a satisfactory 66% 5deld of 3-(lcyclohexenyl)-2-butanone after 1 h. In the case of 2,4,4-trimethyl-1-pentene, three isomeric ketones were obtained, viz., 4-(2,2-dimethylpropyl)-4-penten-2-one and (E)- or (Z)-4,6,6-trimethyl-4-hepten-2-one in an overall 72% yield. The first isomer, with the terminal double bond, was the major product of the reaction, but
105
the GC conditions adopted for analysis did not allow us to fully separate the different compounds and to obtain quantitative determinations. Table 5 Acetylation of various alkenes Substrate
o o O-' XA
I/AC2O/HY (mmol/mmol/g) 1/5/0.1
Time GC Yield (h) (%) 1
23
Product(s) (See Text for Isomer Distributions) {
^—COCH3 /
1/10/0.2
3
V-COCH3
60 COCH3
1/10/0.25
1
66
0^
1/10/0.25
2
72
>O^C0CH3
^
^
COCH3 .COCH3
COCH3 All reactions were carried out at 25°C. To conclude this study, we examined the possibility of recycling and reusing the HY catalyst. Initially, the spent solid was simply recovered by filtration, washed with acetone, dried at 110°C, and reused. Under these conditions, the recycled aluminosilicate exhibited only poor catalytic activity, and the conversion of the alkene to ketone was limited to a few per-cent. When an additional calcination step was performed before reuse, on the other hand, the recycled material was almost as active as a fresh sample of zeolite HY. For instance, the yield of (2) dropped only firom 45 to 39% when catalyst regenerated by calcination in air at 400°C was used instead of the original fresh molecular sieve. Furthermore, it was possible to reemploy the same catalyst in a third, and even a fourth run, without any further decrease in yield, provided t h a t the solid was regenerated by calcination between each successive reaction.
106
4.
CONCLUSION
The above results clearly demonstrate that proton-exchanged Y zeolite is an efficient heterogeneous catalyst for the acylation of alkenes with acetic anhydride. The ease of separation and of regeneration of the spent solid is particularly attractive in view of possible industrial applications and contributes to the environmental friendliness of the process, together with the absence of any solvent. Nevertheless, a careful optimisation of the experimental parameters is required in order to achieve high 5delds of ketones. In the case of 2,3-dimethyl-2butene, we were able to obtain a 79% yield of 3,3,4-trimethyl-4-penten-2-one (based on acetic anhydride) by adopting the following conditions: 10/1 alkene/anhydride molar ratio, 0.2 g of HY zeolite per mmol Ac20, reaction temperature 25°C, reaction time 4 h. No alkene oligomerisation was observed. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT We wish to thank the British Government for an ORS Award to Z. Z. and PQ Zeolites for gifts of zeolite samples. Financial support from BP Chemicals and from the European Union within the Human Capital and Mobility Programme (Contract CHRX CT 940564) is gratefully acknowledged, as is the use of the EPSRC's Chemical Database Service at Daresbury [14] and the EPSRC Mass Spectrometry Service in Swansea. REFERENCES 1. G. A. Olah, Friedel-Crafbs Chemistry, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1973. 2. K. Smith (ed). Solid Supports and Catalysts in Organic Synthesis, Ellis Horwood, Chichester, 1992. 3. H. van Bekkum, A. J. Hoefhagel, M. A. van Koten, E. A. Gunnewegh, A. H. G. Vogt and H. W. Kouwenhoven, Stud. Surf Sci. Catal., 83 (1994) 379 and references cited therein. 4. Q. L. Wang, Y. Ma, X. Ji, H. Yan and Q. Qiu, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun., (1995) 2307. 5. F. Jayat, M. J. Sabater Picot and M. Guisnet, submitted. 6. K. Smith, Z. Zhenhua and P. K. G. Hodgson, manuscript in preparation. 7. M. Spagnol, L. Gilbert, R. Jacquot, H. Guillot, P. J. Tirol and A.-M. Le Govic, preprints 4th Int. Symp. on Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals, Basel, 1996, p. 92. 8. For reviews see C. D. Nenitzecsu and A. T. Balaban, in Friedel-Crafts and Related Reactions, Vol. Ill, G. A. Olah (ed), Wiley, New York, 1964, pp 10331052; J. K. Groves, Chem. Soc. Rev., 1 (1972) 73. 9. A. C. Byrns and T. F. Doumani, Ind. Eng. Chem., 35 (1943) 349. 10. K. Hideo, N. Yoshinori and H. Yasno, Jpn Pat. 05 163 189; Chem. Abstr. 119 (1993) 249581s. 11. P. Beak and K. R. Berger, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 102 (1980) 3848. 12. J. E. Dubois, I. Saumtally and C. Lion, Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr., II (1984) 133. 13. E. F. Kiefer and D. A. Carlson, Tetrahedron Lett., (1967) 1617. 14. D. A. Fletcher, R. F. McMeeking and D. Parkin, J. Chem. Inf. Comput. Sci., 36(1996)746.
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
107
Influence of the acidity and of the pore structure of zeolites on the alkylation of toluene by 1-heptene. P. Magnoux, A. Mourran, S. Bernard and M. Guisnet URA. CNRS 350, Catalyse en Chimie Organique, University de Poitiers, 40 avenue duRecteur Pineau - 86022 Poitiers cedex France. Summary The alkylation of toluene with 1-heptene was used as a model reaction for the synthesis of long-chain linear alkylbenzenes which are precursors of biodegradable surfactants. The effect of the pore structure and of the acidity of large pore zeolites : HFAU (framework Si/Al ratio from 4 to 100), HMOR (Si/Al from 10 to 80), HMAZ (Si/Al=10), HBEA (Si/Al=10) and of an average pore size zeoUte, HMFI (Si/Al=40) on their catalytic properties was determined in Kquid phase at OO^'C with a toluene/heptene molar ratio of 3. With the large pore zeolites the main reactions are alkene double bond shift and toluene alkylation which occur through a consecutive scheme. Some of the alkylation products, mainly triheptyltoluenes, remain trapped in the zeolite pores. With HMFI, alkylation products are only found in the zeolite pores, because of the impossibility of desorbing these bulky products from the narrow pores of this zeolite. The activity of large pore zeolites depends on their acidity but also on the ease of desorption of alkylates from their pores. In particular mesopores created during dealumination which facilitate the product desorption have a positive role on the zeolite activity. Thus, HFAU with a Si/Al ratio of 30 which has a relatively high acidity and which contains mesopores is the more active catalyst. Highly dealimiinated (hence mesoporous) HMOR samples are also active. Moreover, their selectivity to 2-phenylalkanes which are the most biodegradable isomers is much higher than that of the HFAU samples. By comparison of the compositions of the heptene mixture and of the monoheptyltoluene mixture in the liquid phase and in the zeolite pores, this shape selective preference can be attributed to transition state control. INTRODUCTION Linear mono C10-C13 alkylbenzenes (LAB) which are used in the production of biodegradable surfactants are produced industrially by benzene alkylation with linear alkenes, HF or AICI3 being used as catalysts (1,2). Because their degradabilityis very high, the 2-phenylalkanes are preferred to the other isomers (3). A great effort is now being made in order to substitute soUd adds (in particular zeolites) for these polluting, corrosive, industrial catalysts (4-9). That is why it is important to understand how the alkylating activity, stability and selectivity of zeolite catalysts change as a function of their physico-chemical characteristics (pore structure, acidity). The effect of these characteristics is investigated here on a model reaction, the alkylation of toluene with 1-heptene. The interest which this
108
reaction presents is due to the ease in the quantitative analysis of the complex reaction mixture : heptene isomers, all the monoheptyltoluenes, biheptyltoluenes, triheptyltoluenes, etc. This model reaction is carried out over large pore zeolites : HFAU (framework Si/Al ratio of 4,16, 30,100) which wiUbe called HFAU4, 16, 30 and 100, HMOR (Si/Al=10, 20, 40, 80), HMAZIO (Si/Al=10), HBEAIO (Si/Al=10) and over an average pore size zeolite: HMFI40 (Si/Al=40). RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 1. Physico-chemical characteristics of the zeolite samples The main characteristics of the zeolite samples are given in table 1. Their unit cell formula was drawn from their elemental analysis and from the nimiber of framework aluminium atoms per unit cell (NAI) estimated from the relationship between the wavenumber of IR structure bands and NAI- Among the zeolite samples, only HFAU4 and 100 and HBEAIO contained a large amount of extraframework aluminium species. Table 1 Characteristics of the zeoUte samples : unit cell formula, number of extraframework aluminium atoms ( N E F A L ) , volume (cm^^-l) of micropores (V^) and of mesopores (VM) and acidity : nimiber (lO^Og-l) of protonic acid sites estimated from the imit cell formula (NH"^) and of sites retaining ammonia adsorbed above lOO'^C (NiooX Zeolite HFAU4 HFAU16 HFAU30 HFAUIOO HMORIO HMOR40 HMOR80 HMAZIO HBEAIO HMFI40
Unit cell formula Na0.4Al39.2Sil52.8O384 Nao.3Alll.3Sil80.70384 Nao.l5Al6.2Sil85.80384 Nao.5All.9Sil90.l0384 Nao.05Al4.4Si43.6O96 Nao.05All.lSi46.9O96 Nao.OlAlo.6Si47.4O96 Nao.03Al3.3Si32.7O72 Nao.2Al3.9Si60.lOl28 Nao.oiAl2.lSi93.90i92
NEPAL
v»
VM
9.6 2.4 0.1 10.0 2.1 0 0 0 1.5 0
0.298 0.295 0.282 0.249 0.195 0.210 0.210 0.170 0.240 0.175
0.056 0.140 0.193 0.161 0.030 0.070 0.085 0.105 0.540 0.000
Nioo 20.3 10.2 3.9 5.7 3.2 1.8 0.85 2.7 9.3 6.3 2.2 2.0 1.2 0.8 9.2 6.0 8.4 7.1 2.4 2.5 NH^
Nitrogen adsorption shows that all the zeolites except HFAU4, HMORIO, HMAZIO and HMFI40 have in addition to micropores a significant mesopore volume. The very large mesopore volume of HBEAIO is due to intercrystalline voids resulting from the agglomeration of the very small crystallites of this zeolite (10). The number of protonic acid sites estimated from the unit cell formulas was compared to the nimiber of sites on which ammonia remained adsorbed above lOO^^C and SOO^'C. In the FAU and MOR series, the number of ammonia molecules
109 which remained adsorbed decreased with the theoretical number of protonic acid sites. However, with HFAU 100, the number of ammonia molecules detected was greater than expected from the unit cell formula, which coxild be attributed to the presence of a large amount of extraframework Al species. Furthermore the lower N A I the greater Sie proportion of strong acid sites (retaining ammonia adsorbed above 300°C). 2. Alkylationof toluene with 1-heptene With all the zeolites 1-heptene isomerizes into 2 and 3-heptenes, monoheptyltoluenes are formed by alkylation of toluene with heptenes, biheptyltoluenes by alkylation of monoheptyltoluenes. Non desorbed products are also found. Neither skeletal isomerization and dimerization of heptenes nor formation of C i 4 alkyl toluene are observed. 2-Heptyltoluene (Mi), 3-heptyltoluene (M2) and 4-heptyltoluene (M3) can be separated by GC : three peaks of M i and M2 and two peaks of M3 are observed, which correspond to ortho, meta and para isomers. Most likely the two major peaks correspond to the ortho and para isomers which can be expected with electrophiUc aromatic substitution. Double bond shift and toluene alkylation involve n-heptyl carbenium ions as intermediates. By considering the toluene alkylation mechanism it can be concluded that Ml results from toluene alkylation with 1- or 2-heptenes, M2 from alkylation of toluene with 2- or 3-heptenes and M3 only from alkylation with 3-heptenes (Figure 1).
c-c-c~c-c-c-c Ml
+ I-C7
ill \
^
c-c-c-c-c-c-c
O ^ -'
M2
^
c-c-c-c-c-c-c
+ 3-C7
M3
Figure 1 : Formation of monoheptyltoluenes Only a small amount (<10%) of the non desorbed products are soluble in methylene chloride when the zeoUte is treated by soxhlet. However, after dissolution of the zeolite in a hydrofluoric acid solution and extraction with methylene chloride all of the products were recovered. This shows that most of the non desorbed products are located inside the zeoUte pores. With all the zeolites these products are constituted of mono, bi and triheptyltoluenes.
110
2.1. Activity and stabiliiy of the zeolite samples. The initial rates of 1-heptene isomerization and of alkylation were estimated from curves : the conversion of 1-heptene into isomers and of n-heptenes into alkylation products plotted as a function of time. To obtain accurate values the experiments were carried out over three different weights of catalysts. The initial rates obtained with the series of FAU zeolites are plotted as a function of nH+, i.e. the theoretical number of acid sites estimated from the unit cell formula (Figure 2). With both reactions the most active catalyst is HFAU30 (nH+=:3.2 1020g^l). The shape of the curve represented in figure 2 is the one predicted by the topologic model of Barthomeuf (11-12). For low values of nH+ (hence of NAI the number of framework aluminium atoms per unit cell) the A104" tetrahedra have no close Al neighbour atom in the second layer of T atoms and the acidity of the protonic sites is maximal. Above a certain value of NAI, the aluminium atoms are no longer isolated and the strength of the corresponding protonic sites, hence their activity is lower. However, the value of NAI for which this situation occurs in the case of FAU zeolites was estimated to be equal to 28, which corresponds to a framework Si/Al ratio of 5.8 i.e. a Si/Al ratio much lower than the one corresponding to the maximum activities. Moreover, the alkylating activity of HFAU4 is abnormally low. All this indicates that acidity is not the only parameter determining the HFAU activity. i
^Ao (10"^mol h''' g"'')
600 -
/V
400
1-/ X. /
200
IKA
0 -^
MOR\
MAZ BE)^^s^ T| ^^1 1 10 + 20 nH (10
Figure 2 : Initial rates R of isomerization (I) and of alkylation (A) as a function of the theoretical number of protonic sites (nH+).
-P-
>
15 -1
sites g )
Figure 3 : Initial activities (Ao) of toluene alkylation as a function of the theoretical number of protonic sites (nH+).
The same occurs with HMOR zeolites : the maximum activity is found for a Si/Al ratio of 80 (Figure 3) while the aluminium atoms become isolated for Si/A1^9.4 (11, 12). Moreover the alkylating activity of HMORIO, the non dealxmiinated sample, is very low, much lower than that of a HFAU zeolite with the same number of acid sites. This is also the case for the non dealuminated HMAZ and HBEA samples. However, figure 3 shows that the greater the Si/Al ratio of the HMOR samples (hence the more pronounced their degree of
Ill
dealumination) the smaller the difference in activity between the HMOR and the HFAU samples. This can be explained by the presence of mesopores created by dealumination. Indeed these mesopores sJlow a quasi tridimensional diffusion of the reactant molecules (13) favouring the desorptionof the alkylates. The activity of non dealuminated HMAZ and HBEA samples is also very low, and with HMFI, an average pore size zeolite, alkylation occurs with the alkylation products remaining trapped inside the pores (13wt% of non desorbed mono and biheptyltoluenes after 10 hours reaction) thus no products appear in the liquid phase. Limitations in the desorptionof alkylation products from non dealuminated large pore zeolites could also be responsible for their low activity. In agreement witfithis, the lower the amount of non desorbed products retained in the HFAU or HMOR zeolites at 100% conversion of heptene into alkylation products, the faster the alkylation (Table 2). The increase in the alkylation activity caused by dealumination can be related to the creation of mesopores which would favour the desorption of the alkylation products. However, with this hypothesis a h i ^ alkylating activity should be found with the HBEAIO sample whose crystallite size is very small (around 200A). This is not the case, most likely because the extraframework aluminium species present in this sample Umit the desorption of alkylation products. In agreement with this proposal the amount of products retained in the pores of HBEAIO after complete conversion of heptenes into alkylation products is approximately 10 times greater than that retained in the pores of HFAU30 (Table 2). Table 2 Initial rates of alkylation of toluene, A (10'^ mol.h"l.g"l) and percentage of non desorbed products, C(wt%) at complete conversion of alkenes into alkylation products. Zeolite HFAU HFAU HFAU HFAU
4 16 30 100
A 20 350 600 40
C 23.0 8.1 2.3 9.6
Zeolite HMOR HMOR HMOR HBEA
10 20 80 10
A 7 27 120 13
C 4.4 2.8 2.2 23.5
2.2. Product distribution As shown in figures 4 for HFAU30, double bond shift and toluene alkylation occur through consecutive schemes with all the zeoUte samples: 1- Heptene ,^ ^ 2- Heptenes .^ ^ 3- Heptenes Toluene ^ ^ = = ^ Monoheptyltoluenes (M) ^
^
Biheptyltoluenes (B)
However the product distribution depends on the zeoUte. Thus, with HFAU30, biheptyltoluenes appear at a heptene conversion of 30%, 40% with HBEA, 60% withHMORSO and 80% with HMAZ. Whatever the heptene conversion, M l in the monoheptyltoluene fraction is more favoured with HMOR80 than with the other zeoKtes.
112
FAU30 Vo
100
M 80
60 '
40 B
20 f 20
0
1
i
40
60
^ 80
100
X(%)
Figure 4a : Percentages of 2-heptenes Figure 4b : Yields in mono (M) and (2-C7=)and3-heptenes(3-C7=)inthe biheptyltoluenes (B) as a function of heptene mixture as a function of the ^^P^^^ conversion into alkylates (X). percentage of isomerized 1-heptene (Xi):Xi = 2C7= + 3C7=. Figure 5 illustrates the change in the monoheptyltoluene distribution on the more active faiyasite sample (HFAU30) as a function of n heptene conversion. At low conversion, Ml is formed with a high selectivity (>90% at zero conversion). The percentages of M2 and M3 increase with conversion at the expense of Ml, which can be related to the increase in the amount of 2-heptenes and 3-heptenes in the heptene mixture (Table 3). 80 T
FAU30
MOR80
00 -1 Ml
60 +
-*M1
80 60
5^ 40 I 40 20
20
M2
0
-I I I
_
20
40
60
80
100
X (% heptenes)
Figure 5 : Distribution of monoheptyltoluenes on HFAU30 as a fimction of heptenes conversion into alkylation products (X).
29
1
40
60
"T"- ^ 80
M3 1
100
X (% heptenes)
Figure 6 : Distribution of monoheptyltoluenes on HMOR80 as a function of heptenes conversion into alkylation products (X).
113
By considering the relative distributions of heptenes and monoheptyltoluenes (Table 3) with respect to the alkylation scheme (Figure 1) it can be concluded t h a t the monoheptyltoluene distribution is determined by the heptene distribution. There is no shape selective effect: steric constraints on certain alkylation steps or limitations of the desorption of the bulkier monoheptyltoluenes. The absence of limitations in the monoheptyltoluenes (M) desorption is confirmed by the very low amount of M in the non desorbed products (5%) and by the fact that the distribution of these monoheptyltoluenes is identical to that found in the desorbed products. Table 3 Comparison of the compositions of the mixtures of heptenes and of monoalkylation products at 40 and 90% conversion (X) of heptenes into alkylation products. X(%)
HFAU30
HMOR80
40
1-C7=:71% ; 2-C7=:24% ; 3-C7=:5% Mi:70% ; M2:25% ; M3:5%
1-C7=:50% ; 2-C7=:45% ; 3-C7=:5% Mi:88% ; M2:10% ; M3:2%
90
1-C7=:50% ; 2-C7=:40% ; 3-C7=:10% 1-C7=:30%; 2-C7=:60% ; 3-C7=:10% Mi:60% ; M2:30% ; M3:10% Mi:85% ; M2:10% ; M3:5%
Whatever the n-heptene conversion (Figure 6) the percentage of M l in the monoheptyltoluene fi*action found with the more active mordenite sample (HMOR80) is higher than the one found with HFAU30 (Figure 5). This observation is unexpected when the heptene distributions are compared at identical conversions (Table 3). Therefore this high selectivity to Ml can only be explained by the shape selectivity of mordenite. This selectivity could be partiy due to difficulties in the desorption of the more bulky M2 and M3 products. Indeed non desorbed products contain a larger amount of M products with HMOR80 than with HFAU30 (56% against 5%). However this diffusion control plays only a limited role, for non desorbed monoheptyltoluenes have practically the same composition as the desorbed monoheptyltoluenes (85% of M l instead of 90%). Therefore the high selectivity to M i is most likely due to steric constraints affecting the alkylation of toluene into M2 and M3 in the mordenite pores. EXPERIMENTAL The zeoUte samples were suppUedfi^om PQ (HFAU, HBEA, HMFI), fi-om Zeocat (HMOR) and fix)m Elf Aquitaine (HMAZ). These samples were characterized by IR spectroscopy (structure bands), by nitrogen adsorption at 77 K and by NH^ stepwise TPD. Alkylation of toluene with heptene was carried out in liquid phase under the following operating conditions : 90''C, toluene/alkene molar ratio of 3, 0.07 to 0.5 g powdered zeoUte with a stirring rate of 200 RPM. Before introduction into the toluene/alkene mixture the zeoUte samples were activated under dry air
114
flow at 500^*0 for 12 hours. Small samples of the reaction mixture (approximately 50 jil) were taken at various reaction times, diluted with methylene chloride and analj^ed by gas chromatography on a 25 m column of fused silica (DB5). The reaction products were identified by gas chromatography/mass spectrometry coupling. The experimental methods used to recover and to analyze the non desorbed products are described in ref. 14. CONCLUSION The activity of zeolites for alkylation of toluene with 1-heptene depends on their acidity and on the ease of desorption of alkylates. Thus average pore size zeolites such as HMFI and monodimensional large pore zeolites are practically inactive. Extraframework aluminium species which Hmit the product desorption have a negative effect, while mesopores (in particular with monodimensional zeolites such as HMOR) have a positive effect. HMOR zeolites are more selective for 2phenylalkanes than HFAU zeolites. This is mainly due to shape selective preference via transition state control. REFERENCES 1. P.R. Pujado, in "Handbook of Petroleum Refining Process" (R.A. Meyers, ed.) McGraw-Hm,1986. 2. J.L.G. de Almeida, M. Dufaux, Y. Ben Taarit and C. Naccache, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc, 71 (1994) 675. 3. R.J. Larson, T.M. Rothgeb, R.J. Shimp, T.E. Ward and R.M. Ventullo, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc, 70 (1993) 645. 4. J.L.G. de Almeida, M. Dufaux, Y. Ben Taarit and C. Naccache, Appl. Catal. A : General 114 (1994) 141. 5. S. Sivasanker, A. Thangar^], J. Catal. 138 (1992) 386. 6. S. Sivasanker, A. Thangar^', R.A. Abulia and P. Ratnasamy, in L. Guczi et al. (Eds.), Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. vol. 75, Elsevier, Amsterdam(1993) p.397. 7. A. Mourran, P. Magnoux and M. Guisnet, J. Chim. Phys., 92 (1995) 1394. 8. L.B. Zinner, K. Zinner, M. Ishige and A.S. Araujo, J. Alloys and Compounds, 193 (1993) 65. 9. P. Magnoux, A. Mourran, S. Bernard and M. Guisnet. in J.Weitkamp and B. Liicke (Eds.), Proceedings of the D.G.M.K. Conference "Catalysis on SoUd Adds and Bases". Berlin (1996) p.49. 10. C. Coutanceau, J.M. Da Silva, M.F. Alvarez, F.R. Ribeiro and M. Guisnet, J. Chim. Phys., to be published. 11. D. Barthomeuf, Mater. Chem. Phys., 17 (1987) 49. 12. D. Barthomeuf, in J.W. Ward (Eds.), Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. vol. 38 Elsevier, Amsterdam (1987) p.l77. 13. N.S. Gnep, Ph. Roger, P. Cartraud, M. Guisnet, B. Juquin and Ch. Hamon, C. R. Acad. Sci., 309 (1989) 1743. 14. M. Guisnet and P. Magnoux, Appl. Catal., 54 (1989) 1.
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
115
Reductive O- and N-alkylations. Alternative catalytic methods to nucleophilic substitution. F. Fache, V. Bethmont, L. Jacquot, F. Valot, A. Milenkovic and Marc Lemaire* Institut de Recherches sur la Catalyse, Laboratoire de Catalyse et Synthese Organique, Universite Claude Bernard Lyon I, CPE, 43 bd du 11 nov. 1918, 69622 Villeurbanne CEDEX France. Different amides and anilines have been selectively mono-N-alkylated using catalytic heterogeneous palladium and carbonyl compounds as alkylating agents. The same method has been applied to the synthesis of ethers from alcohols. Reaction parameters have been studied in details and a mechanism is proposed. 1. INTRODUCTION The increase of environmental awareness forces chemists to reconsider the way they used to work and to take into account the concept of atom economy 1. One solution to the waste problem is the replacement of stoichiometric reagents generating organic or inorganic by-products by catalytic methods. Thus, nowadays, the main challenge is not only the complexity of the target molecule but the way to synthesize it. There is a need for simple, selective and efficient catalytic methods allowing to perform whatever modification of basic structures we need. Therefore, we studied two well-known and extremely useful classical organic reactions, the N-alkylation of anilines and amides and the Williamson's synthesis of ethers in order to turn them into catalytical ones. Moreover, due to the advantages of heterogeneous catalysis versus homogeneous one in terms of catalyst separation and recycling, we searched for heterogeneous catalytic systems. We have reconsidered the old Eschweiler-Clarke procedure^ which allowed the reductive alkylation of amines with aldehyde under hydrogen with P d / C . This method is widely used in organic synthesis for the N-alkylation of amines^. Generaly speaking it is considered to be unefficient on amides. Analysis of the reaction mechanism made us hope a possible transposition to amides, anilines and alcohols (Figure l).The first step of the reaction is the nucleophilic attack of the amine on the carbonyl compound leading to the hemiaminal A^ in equilibrium with the starting materials. Then, there are two possibilities : the first one is the hydrogenolysis of the hemiaminal A into the corresponding amine C. The second one is the dehydration of A into the related imine B. which after hydrogenation leads to the amine C.. This compound can undergo further Nalkylation via the hemiaminal D which can give after hydrogenolysis either the
116 tertiary amine F directly or first be dehydrated into the enamine E if at least one of the substituents on the nitrogen atom is a primary or secondary alkyl group. O R1NH2 R2
R2
Dehydration^
R,—N
Rl—N R'l
R3
R2
R3
Hydrogenation
Imine B
Hemiaminal A HO ^2
H
-H2O
Hydrogenolysis
^^\0^
H Ri — N Monoalkylation Secondary amine C O
R2
A' R3
Ro
Y
R3 Dehydration OH
R2
R,—N
R3
R2 R3 Enamine E if R2 primary or secondary alkyl
Hemiaminal D
-H2O
R2
r
R3
Hydrogenolysis
R3
Rl—N^
p R2
Dialkylation
Tertiary amine^
Figure 1 : mechanism of the N-mono or di-alkylation of amines.
117 In the reverse case, for the dimethylation with formaldehyde for example (R2 = R3 = H) , the dehydration is impossible. Thus, in this last case, the only possible pathway is the hydrogenolysis of the hemiaminal D. The competitive hydrogenation of carbonyl must be considered carefully because it influences the choice of the reaction conditions. We assume that with amides, anilines and alcohols similar mechanisms should be possible. 2. RESULTS and DISCUSSION 2.1.N-alkylation of amides Table 1 : influence of the substrate and of the alkylating agent. Substrate
isolated yield
Product
Alkylating agent
(%)
Q.
octanal H
Ok N
^ 0
1
octanal
Ok
N
^ 0
1
butanal
a
acetone
Ok
N 1 C4H9
H
Ok 1
N
A
H
Ok N
^ 0
1
N
^ 0
1
0
Ok
0
N 0 1 CHj-Ph
1 CH3 f
butanal acetone
V
C-N—C4H0
—
/
butanal
97
0 >—O-N
II H 0
(
81*
\
> - C - N - Q H ,
}—C-NH. 0
81
formaldehyde
>—C—NH2 0
0
93
7 — C— NH2 ^^^"^
98
Ok
H \
0
benzaldehyde
H
Ok
93
N 0 1 QH17
H
Ok
96
89
0
Conditions : Carbonyl/amide = 4(molar ratio), Pd/C (10%) = 2%mol/amide, Na2S04 (99.99%)/amide = 1 (molar ratio), 40 bar H2, 100°C, AcOEt = 10ml, [substrate] = IM, 4h.M8h.
118 The N-alkylation of amides is an important reaction involved in the synthesis of numerous amines^. Most of the time, strong bases and alkyl halides are required to perform such a reaction^. These methods are not chemioselective mainly due to the competitive O- or C-alkylation. Moreover, mono- and di-Nalkylated amides are generally obtained. In the literature, methods using phase transfer catalysis or inorganic solids were proposed but they are limited to aromatic amides^ or lead to poor yields^. In both cases these methods generate salts due to the use of alkylhalides and bases. Catalytic methods have also been reported. Ruthenium^ has been used with alcohols as alkylating agents generating only water but this procedure could not be applied to lactames and the yields fell down when the chain length of the alcohol diminished. We have developed the reductive alkylation of amides with carbonyls^ and optimized the reaction parameters (Table 1). This work is based on the assumption that the hemiaminal form of the amide is reduced faster than carbonyls. We went to the conclusion that a polar aprotic solvent is necessary as well as an excess of the alkylating agent to go to complete conversion. We have also to shift the reaction towards the proposed intermediate, the hemiaminal, and therefore we need to add Na2S04 as dehydrating agent. When using a preactivated palladium (Pd/C 10% Aldrich treated at 100°C, 2h, under H2), the reaction can be performed using 0.2% of Pd/substrate whereas 2.5% are necessary with a non activated one. In order to make our method easy to reproduce in a classical organic laboratory, we describe here results obtained with an inactivated catalyst, which is also much easier to handle. This method allowed the selective mono-N-alkylation of primary amides and lactames with good isolated yields (>80%) using aldehydes or ketones as alkylating agents. No O- or C- alkylation was detected. Above all, it generated only little amount of by-products as both the catalyst and the dehydrating agent could be recycled. Finally, if we consider the mechanism, there are evidences of hydrogenolysis in the case of several products but the pathway dehydrationhydrogenation could not be excluded. 2.2. N-alkylation of anilines The N-alkylation of aniline derivatives provides access to numerous interesting products such as fungicides or herbicides^^. Most of the time, the alkylating agent is a chloro or bromo reagent which generates halogenated byproducts^O'ii. Several other methods, catalytic or not, have been reported but they either lead to poor yields or need harsh conditions'^"!"*. The procedure reported by Watanabe et al. '^ using RuCl2(PPh3)3 as catalyst is much more convenient but limited to primary alcohols. We have used the same methodology as for amides in order to obtain selective alkylation of aniline(Table 2). Unnatural N-aryl dipeptides can be easily obtained using our procedure direct acylation of a-aminoacid esters with nitro-benzoyl chlorides followed by reductive alkylation leads to the preparation of derivatives of methyl prolinate 1 and methyl valinate 2 (Table 3). A small but significant diastereoisomeric excess (d.e.) of 20-30% is measured by ' H NMR. Optimisation of the reaction conditions as well as of the nature of the inductor may generate better d.e.. These
119 Table 2 : N-alkylated anilines obtained by reductive alkyktion. Product Isolatedyield (%) Starting material Alkylating agent
o'
V
aK
V
o'
95
88
CyHgCHO CH3CHO CH3CHO
O'
85
o a'
r
86
78
78 u
78 NH2
H N-
u
^ COOMe
COOMe
60
COOMe NH,
u
67 NHj
'
78
83 Conditions : Carbonyl/aniline= 4 (molar ratio), P d / C (10%) = 2.5%mol/aniline, N a 2 S 0 4 (99.99%)/aniline = 1 (molar ratio), 50 bar H2, 20°C, cyclohexane= 20ml, [substrate] = 2M, 4h-24h.
120
preliminary results show that our method can lead to the formation of new unnatural aminoacid precursors (Table 3). Table 3 : diastereoselective experiments. Synthesis of unnatural dipeptides d.e. (%) Product Starting material Alkylating Isolated agent yield (%) H,COOC
HjCOOC*^
Y ^ OMe 0
1
4(|V'''^ H 6
0
6
60
20
COOCH, 13 16
COOCH3
^
30
H ^
6 1
0
93
H 7^ " ' COOCH, 9 10' 1
Conditions : see Table 2.
2.3. Synthesis of ethers One of the oldest reaction used by organic chemists is the synthesis of ethers according to Williamson. Thus, since 1850, a great variety of bases and alkyl halides had generated the desired ethers but also their counterparts, the corresponding inorganic salts^^. Moreover, the reaction conditions are generally unusable for base sensitive molecules. Industrially, diisopropylether is synthesized from isopropanol in strong acidic conditions!^. Metal from group VIII have been used for catalytic reaction of alcohols on olefins^^ or on carbonylsl^ but they either led to poor yields or (and!) required stoichiometric amounts of acids. Using the same approach as for the N-alkylation of amides^ we performed the catalytic synthesis of ethers from both aldehydes or ketones with palladium as catalyst^O. Nevertheless, in the case of ethers, the proposed intermediate, the hemiketal is easy to synthesize and it is not necessary to find special conditions for its formation. This method allowed the selective formation of ethers from both aldehydes or ketones with good to excellent isolated yields (up to 95%) and the catalyst could be recycled. There are evidences for the hydrogenolysis pathway (Table 4, last entry) but nothing can be excluded. We have described the synthesis of dissymmetric ethers because of their higher synthetic interest but, of course, symmetric ones could be obtained in the same way, with probably higher selectivity as the only observed by-product is due to carbonyl reduction. 3. CONCLUSION We have shown that heterogeneous catalysis can be applied to reductive alkylation with success in reactions such as ether synthesis or N-alkylation of amides and anilines. Concerning the mechanism, several pathways are in competition depending on the structure of the substrate and of the alkylating agent. The important point is that both the product of addition (the hemiacetal or hemiaminal) and the product of elimination (imine, enamine or enolether)
121
which are the probable intermediates of the reaction, are reduced faster than the carbonyl compound, which makes the reactions possible. We plane to go further and to extend the scope of application of heterogeneous catalysis in organic synthesis by systematically reconsidering the classical synthetic methods Table 4 : synthesis of ethers Substrate
Solvent
Product
Isolated yield(%)
Octanal
1-butanol
C4H9-O-C8H17
95
Octanal
2-butanol
80
0 CgHn
methanol
Octanal Octanal
CH3-O-C8H17
n
2methoxyethanol
—0
O-CgHn
95 95
Hi3C6^^ 1-butanol
2-octanone
0
92
1
C4H9 Hi3C6v^^ 2-octanone
2-butanol
1-octanol
acetone
CgHn-O-iPr
90
r^r-butanol
octanal
-
0
octanal
-
0
octanol
CF3(CF2)2CHO
-
0
octanol
(CH3)3CCHO
^o-c8Hi7
75
0
3 r
50
Conditions : [substrate] = 0.2M, Pd/C = 2.5%mol./substrate, 100°C when the substrate was an alcohol, 50°C when the substrate was a carbonyl compound, 40 bar H2.
4. TYPICAL PROCEDURE Amide, aniline or alcohol, carbonyl compound, N a 2 S 0 4 (leq. molar/substrate) and P d / C 10% (2. 5% molar/substrate) were mixed in the
122 appropriate solvent and put under H2 pressure (40 bar) at the appropriate temperature until complete conversion of the starting material. After filtration and evaporation of the solvent the crude product was obtained (for more details see tables). The reaction is monitored by gas chromatography (J&W, DB1701, 25 m X 0.25 mm0). In the case of : -amides : 100°C, solvent AcOEt, -anilines : 20°C, solvent: cyclohexane, -ethers : 50°C or 100°C, see table, solvent: the alcohol or the carbonyl compound. P d / C (10%): Acros (19503-0500); Na2S04 (99.99%+): Aldrich, 20,444-7. REFERENCES 1. B.M. Trost, Science, 254 (1991) 1471; R.A. Sheldon, Chem. Ind., (1992) 903. 2. J. March, "Advances in Organic Chemistry", third Edition, John Wiley and Sons, eds., Wiley Interscience Publication, N. Y. 1985, p. 798. 3. P.N. Rylander, Academic press. Inc. London limited, 1985. 4. P.G. Mattingly and M.J. Miller, J. Org. Chem., 46 (1981) 1557. 5. W. Fones, J. Org. Chem., 14 (1952) 1099; J. Park and R. Englert, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 74, (1952) 1010; D.W. Slocum and F.E. Stonemark, J. Org. Chem., 38 (1973) 1677. 6. T. Gajda and A. Zwierzak, Synthesis, (1981) 1005. 7. J. Yamawaki, T. Ando and T. Hanafusa, Chem. Lett., (1981) 1143; K. Sukuta, Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn, 58 (1985) 838. 8. Y. Watanabe, T. Ohta and Y. Tsuji, Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn, 56 (1983) 2647. 9. F. Fache, L. Jacquot and M. Lemaire, Tetrahedron Lett., 35 (1994) 3313; F. Fache, V. Bethmont, L. Jacquot and M. Lemaire, Reel. Trav. Chim. Pays-Bas, 115 (1996) 231. 10. W. Lunkenheimer and W. Brand, Ger. Offen., 2,915, 026 (1979); R. Bader, P. Flatt, P. Radimerski, Eur. Pat., 605,363 (1994); Ibid, U.S. Pat., 5,430,188 (1995). 11. M. Onaka, A. Umezono, M. Kawai and Y. Izumi, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun., 17 (1985) 1202. 12. Y. Watanabe, N. Suzuki, S.C. Shim, M. Yamamoto, T. Mitsudo and Y. Takegami, Chem. Lett., 4 (1980) 429. 13. H. Hauck and H.J. Nestler, CA 95 : 42611s, Ger. Offen. 2, 941, 070 (23 apr. 1981). 14. H.R. Morales, M. Perez-Juarez, L. Cuellar, L. Mendoza, H. Fernandez and R. Contreras, Synth. Commun., 14(13) (1984) 1213. 15. Y. Watanabe, Y. Tsuji, H. Ige, Y. Ohsugi and T. Ohta, J. Org. Chem., 49 (1984) 3359. 16. S.D. Burke, F.J. Schoenen and M.S. Nair, Tetrahedron Lett., 28 (1987) 4143. 17. A. P. Lurie, Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedie, 2^ Edition, John Wiley and Sons, eds., Wiley Interscience Publication, N. Y. 1971, vol. 8, p.470. 18. J. Ehlers, G.J. Hochstadt, P. Greenough, M.P. Atkins and W.J. Ball, Ger. Offen. DE 3, 813, 689; 17 Nov. 1988. 19. M. Verzele, M. Acke and M. Anteunis, J. Chem. Soc, (1963) 5598. 20. V. Bethmont, F. Fache and M. Lemaire, Tetrahedron Lett., 36(24) (1995) 4235.
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
123
N-methylation of aniline over AlPO^ and AlP04-metal oxide catalysts F. M. Bautista, J. M. Campelo, A. Garcia, D. Luna, J. M. Marinas and A. A. Romero Organic Chemistry Department, Faculty of Sciences, University of Cordoba, Avda. S. Alberto Magno s/n, E-14004 Cordoba, Spain.
Summary The alkylation of aniline with methanol was studied over a series of middly acidic AlPO^ and AlP04-metal oxide (25 wt% AI2O3. TiOj or Zr02) catalysts prepared in different ways. Surface acidity was measured by pyridine adsorption and its effect on aniline alkylation activity is discussed. The influence of feed rate, time-on-stream and temperature on the activity and selectivity of the products, namely N-methyl (NMA) and N,N-dimethylaniline (NNDMA) were also investigated. Selectivity to N-alkylation (NMA+NNDMA) attained 100 mol% in the temperature range 523-623 K. Besides, N-methylaniline decreased as contact time/temperature increased. At 673 K, N,N-dimethyltoluidines (NNDMT, p->o-) appeared, although in very small amounts. AIPO4-AI2O3 proved to be a better catalyst for aniline methylation than AIPO4. Moreover, AlP04-Zr02 shows little acidity and hence decreased methylation ability with respect to AIPO4.
1. INTRODUCTION Aniline alkylation is an industrially important reaction due to the fact that alkylanilines form the basic raw materials for the synthesis of organic chemicals and chemical intermediates or additives in dyes, synthetic rubbers, explosives, herbicides and pharmaceuticals. Vaporphase aniline alkylation over environmentally safe solid catalysts is an answer to the conventional method of producing alkylanilines using mineral acids and Friedel-Crafts type catalysts. Metal oxides [1] and more recently zeolites [1-3] are conmionly used as catalysts. Previous studies indicated that the major factors influencing the activity and selectivity of vapor-phase aniline methylation are acid-base properties (number and strength) and shapeselectivity in the solid catalyst as well as reaction conditions (temperature, composition and feed rate). The activity of acid catalysts for this reaction might be suppressed by the adsorption of aniline since the aniline itself has a strong basic characteristic. Moreover, aniline molecule can protonate reducing the effective concentration of reactant. It therefore seems that the use of a strong acid catalyst is not suitable for this reaction. In the present work, we have carried out the vapor-phase N-methylation of aniline over middle acidic AIPO4 and AlP04-metal oxide (25 wt% AI2O3. Ti02 or Zr02) catalysts [4]. A comparison with strongly acidic SAPO-5 [5] and a commercial Si02-Al203 (13 wt% AI2O3, Si-235 Harshaw Chemie) is also drawn. Our results indicate that N-methyl (NMA) and N,N-dimetylaniline (NNDMA) are almost exclusively formed by a sequential reaction path.
124
2. EXPERIMENTAL 2.1. Catalysts AIPO4 (AP) catalysts were obtained by precipitation, from aluminum chloride and H3PO4 aqueous solutions, with aqueous ammonia (A), ethylene oxide (E) or propylene oxide (P). AIPO4-AI2O3 (25 wt% AI2O3,) catalysts were obtained by adding aluminum hydroxide to a reaction medium where the precipitation of AlPO^, from aluminum chloride and H3PO4 aqueous solutions was initiated by the addition of aqueous ammonia (APAl-A), ethylene (APAl-E) or propylene oxide (APAl-P). The total precipitation of AIPO4 was carried out in all cases with aqueous ammonia. AlP04-Ti02 (25wt% Ti02) and AlP04-Zr02 (25wt% Zr02) were prepared by adding, respectively, commercial Ti02 (anatase) or Zr02 (monoclinic, ceramic grade) to a reaction medium where the precipitation of the AIPO4 was initiated, and later completed, by the addition of aqueous ammonia, ethylene or propylene oxide (A, E or P samples). After filtration, washing and drying at 390 K, all the solids were calcined at 923 K for 3 h. Details on the characterization of all catalysts have been previously described [4]. A comparison with strongly acidic SAPO-5 [5, 7] and a commercial Si02-Al203 (13 wt% AI2O3, Si-235 Harshaw Chemie) is also drawn. The surface area (Sggj), pore volume (V ) and mean pore radius (r ) are collected in Table 1. 2.2. Surface acidity measurements The surface acidity was measured in a dynamic mode by means of the gas-phase adsorption of pyridine (PY) using a pulse chromatographic technique [11,12]. 2.3. Catalytic activity measurements The alkylation of aniline with methanol was carried out in a down-flow reactor (Ld, 6 mm, length 120 mm) and at atmospheric pressure. Catalyst samples (ca. 120 mg, <0.149 mm) were pretreated for 1 h at 523 K in a nitrogen flow (3 L h" , 99.999%). The aniline-methanol mixture (1-10 M) was feed from the top through a calibrated motorised syringe (Harward 44) to achieve different WHSV and different aniline conversion levels. Experiments were carried out at temperatures in the range 523-673 K (mostly 523 K). Blanks runs at 673 K showed that the thermal reaction could be neglected. The products were sampled on-line every 15 min and analyzed by GLC by using a column (2nix3mm) of 10% Carbowax 20M/2% KOH on Chromosorb W-AW 80/100. The alkylated anilines were identified (HR-MS, VG AutoSpec) as being mainly N-methyl (NMA) and N,N-dimethylaniline (NNDMA) and minor amounts of N,N-dimethyltoluidines (NNDMT, p- > 0-). The conversions reported here are on a methanol free aniline basis and selectivities are expressed as the ratio of moles of a given product to the sum of moles produced (mol%). AN and methanol (99.5 %, Merck) were used without further purification.
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 3.1. Surface acidity Although pyridine is not specific because it interacts with both Bronsted and Lewis acid sites, the conversion of Lewis sites into Bronsted ones cannot be ruled out since the alkylation reaction generates water. So, the pyridine adsorption can still be useful for surface acidity measurements. Thus, the surface acidity of catalysts is given in Table 1 as the amount of
125 Table 1 Textural properties and surface acidity v^:. PY of AlPO^ and AlPO^-metal oxide catalysts Catalyst
^BET
P
Pyridine (mol/g)
p
(m^/g)
(mL/g)
(nm)
373 K
AP-A
109
0.48
8.8
AP-P
228
APE
573 K
673 K
135
1^
~
0.75
6.6
336
23
a
242
0.52
4.3
417
33
a
APAl-A
244
0.37
3.1
234
41
12
APAl-P
319
0.67
4.2
247
70
30
APAl-E
242
0.54
4.5
272
67
35
APTi-A
192
0.73
7.6
195
9
a
APTi-P
258
0.81
6.3
321
20
a
APZr-A
82
0.71
17.3
_b
7
a
APZr-P
193
0.69
7.1
_b
21
a
APZr-E
204
0.57
3.6
_b
11
a
Si-235
318
0.57
3.6
192
81
47
1.7
b
L60
141
SAPO-5
214
0.18
There is no adsorption of the probe molecule.
Not measured.
pyridine (PY) adsorbed at saturation at a given temperature. As expected, on increasing temperature from 373 to 673 K, the surface acidity gradually decreases since only the strongest acid sites retain the adsorbed base. The acidity measurements show that the total acid amount value of AIPO4 (AP) and AIPO4AI2O3 (APAl) catalysts depends upon the gellification medium, increasing in the order ammonia < propylene oxide < ethylene oxide. Besides, total acidity in AP catalysts is great compared to that of APAl ones except when the catalyst is obtained in aqueous ammonia. Notwithstanding, APAl catalysts display a greater number of medium and strong acid sites (measured vs. PY at 573 and 673 K, respectively) regardless of the precipitation medium. Also, it can be seen that the surface acidity is almost the same for APAl-P and APAl-E catalysts while for the APAl-P sample, the decrease in acidity, as adsorption temperature increases is faster than that of the APAl-E sample, suggesting a lower acid strength of its acid sites, and supporting the higher catalytic activity achieved with the APAl-E catalyst in typical acid-catalyzed reactions, like cyclohexene isomerization [6] and toluene methylation [4]. Moreover, APTi and APZr catalysts are less acidic than AP and APAL ones. Furthermore, SAPO-5 and Si-235 catalysts displayed a greater number of medium and strong acid sites than AP and APAl catalysts. Thus, SAPO-5 is the most acidic catalyst used here.
126 3.2. Catalytic measurements The alkylation of aniline with methanol on AIPO4 and AlPO^-metal oxide catalysts produces NMA and NNDMA as principal products in all cases. NNDMT (p->o-) appeared only at the highest reaction temperature and in small amounts. In the absence of boundary layer, inter- and intraparticle diffussional influences (feed rates over 3 10" mol/s and catalyst particle sizes lower than 0.149 mm) aniline conversion data (X^j^) are fitted in a first-order rate equation In [1/(1-X^)] = k (W/F) where W is the catalyst weight and F the feed rate. The slope of the straight lines yields the values of the pseudo-first rate constants in mol/g s. At least three feed rates in the range 3.06.7 10"^mol/s are used for k calculations. The values obtained at 523 K after 2 and 8 h on stream are listed in Table 2 for the different catalysts. Calculations are performed only in order to compare the reactivities of the different catalysts and are not aimed at finding the detailed rate equations. A least squares regression analysis and a Students' ^test of significance show, in all instances, that k values are significant at levels over 1%. All values are reproducible to within about 8%. X^^^ and selectivities to N-methylaniline (Sj^^j^y^) and N,N-dimethylaniline (Sjyfjyfj^j^^) are also collected in Table 2. On AIPO4 the conversion varies from 4 to 20 mol% and follows the order AP-A < AP-P < AP-E, i.e. as the surface acidity increases. The incorporation of AI2O3 to the AIPO4 increases the conversion except in the case of the APAl-E catalyst in which it remained almost unchanged in relation to the AP-E one; the increase in activity is more significant in the case of APAl-A. Moreover, the incorporation of Ti02 develops an APTi catalyst that is more active than the AP one when ammonia is used as the gellification agent while the reverse is true when propylene oxide is used instead ammonia. Furthermore, the incorporation of Zr02 brings down the aniline activity in relation to AP catalysts, due to the low surface acidityof APZr catalysts, regardless of the precipitation method. The order of activity does not agree with that of acidity obtained for PY adsorption at 673 K (strong acid sites). This may be because as aniline and its derivatives are basic, they could be strongly adsorbed at strong acid sites and thus deactivate the catalyst. Nevertheless, the results obtained for PY adsorption at 373 (weak acidic) and 573 K (medium acidic) generally agree with the activity. On the other hand, the use of stronger acid SAPO-5 [5, 7] and Si-235 catalysts, not only supposed any increase in AN alkylation but also decreased it. A similar decrease in aniline alkylation activity with an increase in acidity has been reported [8,9]. In this sense. Woo et al. [8] suggested that strong, medium and weak acid sites are active sites to produce C-alkylate and coke, NNDMA and NMA, respectively, so that strongly acidic catalysts ought to be modified by alkali metal species to increase Sj^^^^j^j^. So, our results corroborate that strong acid sites are not required for the N-alkylation of aniline and that weak to moderate acid sites are responsible for the reaction.
3.2.1. Effect of feed rate, time-on-stream and temperature The effect of feed rate (WHSV: 1.9-18.9 h"^) on the aniline conversion and product selectivities for APAl-P catalyst is shown in Fig. 1. The trends observed are comparable for other catalysts. Thus, both aniline conversion and Sj^^^^j^^ decrease with WHSV whereas ^NMA continuously increase. At the low feed rate studied here (1.9 h'^), NNDMT (p- > 0-)
127 Table 2 Aniline conversion (X^^^, mol%), reaction rate constant (k, mol/g s) and product selectivities (S, mol%) in aniline alkylation with methanol over AlPO^ and AlPO^-metal oxide catalysts^ Catalyst
8 h on stream
2 h on stream ^AN
^NNDMA
^AN
k 10^
^NMA
^NNDMA
AP-A
4.6
1.34
90.9
9.1
4.4
1.30
91.6
8.4
AFP
9.7
2.91
86.3
13.7
9.2
2.73
86.7
13.3
APE
20.2
6.40
74.3
25.7
19.0
5.96
74.7
25.3
APAl-A 15.6
4.84
79.7
20.3
15.4
4.76
79.0
21.0
APAl-P
16.8
5.25
73.7
26.3
16.8
5.25
75.4
24.6
APAl-P*' 38.3
13.78
57.3
42.7
37.7
13.49
56.7
43.3
APAl-P^ 57.1
24.10
38.8
59.7
55.6
23.20
40.1
58.5
APAl-E
19.7
6.27
78.8
21.2
19.8
6.28
78.3
21.7
APTi-A
8.8
2.61
88.0
12.0
8.8
2.61
88.5
11.5
APTi-P
9.3
2.77
88.2
11.8
7.1
2.10
88.7
11.3
APZr-A
3.9
1.12
91.1
5.9
2.7
0.78
95.0
5.0
APZr-P
7.8
2.32
89.4
10.6
7.3
2.14
89.3
10.7
APZr-E
4.4
1.29
81.6
18.4
4.3
1.25
85.5
14.5
Si-235
11.1
5.10
83.1
16.9
8.2
3.67
83.3
16.7
SAPO-5
1.6
0.45
96.0
4.0
_d
^ T: 523 K; F = 3.36 10"^ mol/s; WHSV = 9.53 h"^ 5 M aniline in methanol. ^ T: 573 K. T: 623 K. "^ Not measured. also appears although in small amounts. A WHSV of 5.93 h"^ is chosen to study the effect of time on stream and reaction temperature. The effect of time on stream is shown in Table 2. X^^^ and each of the S^^j^^ and ^NNDMA 1*^^1^1115 almost unchanged during the initial 8 h on stream. Besides, the selectivity of N-alkylation remains 100 mol% during this period of process time. However, Si-235 catalyst deactivates more rapidly; this can be associated to its strong acid sites. The effect of reaction temperature (523-673 K) on aniline methylation (after 2 h on stream) over AP-P, APAl-P and Si-235 catalysts is shown in Fig. 2. It is clearly seen that conversion increases continuously up to 673 K. As regards reaction selectivity, as temperature and/or conversion increases, S^^j^^ steadily decreases and Sj^^j^j^^^ increases. More or less the same trend is maintained on remaining catalysts. Moreover, C-alkylated anilines (mostly N,N-dimethyl-/?-toluidine) are formed only at the highest temperature (673 K) and, even with the more active catalysts, never surpass 20 mol% of the total selectivity.
128
^AN A
A S NNDMA
o
T SNNDMT(p-)
CO
><
''NNDMT(O-)
10 WHSV(h-i)
15
Figure 1. Effect of feed rate on the aniline conversion and selectivity over APAl-P catalyst (T: 573 K; time-on-strean: 2h).
AP-P X'AN o E^
o
APAI-P Si-235 © Q
-'NMA
CO
X'
250
300
350
^NNDMA
^
^NNDMT
V
400
T(K) Figure 2. Effect of temperature on the aniline conversion and selectivity over AP-P, APAl-P, and Si-235 catalysts (F: 3.36 10"^ mol/s; WHSV = 9.53 h"^ 5 M aniline in methanol).
129 In order to obtain more knowledge about the reaction sequence, we have constructed the Optimum Performance Envelope (OPE) curves [10] by plotting fractional conversion to each reaction product against aniline conversion, for different weight ratios of catalyst with respect to introduced aniline (Figure 3). In these curves, we have included experimental data corresponding to different temperatures and feed rates on the same diagram. Using such a procedure, an insignificant scattering of the data is evident in the selectivity diagrams and clear tendencies can be observed from these curves. OPE selectivity curves indicated, in all cases, that N-methylaniline is a primary product coming from aniline by alkylation although it is an unstable product since a maximum on its OPE curve is found. Moreover, N,N-dimethylaniline is a secondary unstable product and, furthermore, N,N-dimethyltoluidines (p- > 0-) seem to be secondary reaction products. From the data on feed rate, temperature and OPE curves, it can be concluded that aniline methylation on AIPO4 and AlP04-metal oxide catalysts follows a sequential reaction path of formation of NMA, to NNDMA and then C-alkylated products: MeOH
AN
NMA
MeOH
-^ NNDMA
MeOH
-
NNDMT(p->o-)
as occurs on other acid catalysts [1,2,8,9]. N-methylaniline react faster than aniline due to the its greater negative charge on the nitrogen-atom, by the electron donating effect on the methyl group, that facilitates its alkylation. Moreover, dimethylsubstitution on nitrogen-atom facilitates ring alkylation at o- or p-position although the steric hindrance in the o-isomer is responsible for the bigger formation of /7-isomer. Notwithstanding, N-methylation always predominates.
o ^NMA I-
o
X.NNDMA
<
^NNDMT(p-)
o z z
X,NNDMT(o-)
X <
40
60
X^N (mol %) Figure 3. OPE curves for aniline methylation: fractional conversion at a particular reaction product (X) vs. aniline conversion (X^j^) for APAl-P catalyst.
130 The formation of N,N-ciimethylaniline via disproportionation is less favorable than that of its formation via successive alkylation [2].
4. CONCLUSIONS AIPO4 and AlP04-metal oxide catalysts exhibited high activity and selectivity in aniline alkylation to produce N-alkylated products in a consecutive first-order reaction process. N-methylaniline was easily formed at low temperatures/contact times and converted to N,Ndimethylaniline as temperature/contact time increased. N-alkylated products remained 100 mol% at 523-623 K. At 673 K, N,N-dimethyltoluidine (p->o-) also appeared although in very small amounts. The results obtained for pyridine adsorption at 373 (weak acidic) and 573 K (medium acidic) generally agreed with catalytic activity. 5. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors acknowledge the subsidy received from the DGICYT (Project PB92/0816), Ministerio de Educacion y Ciencia, and from the Consejeria de Educacion y Ciencia (Junta de Andalucia). They also acknowledge the linguistic revision of the manuscript carried out by Prof. M. Sullivan
6. REFERENCES 1 A.N. Ko, C.L. Yang, W. Zhu and H. Un, Appl. Catal. A, 134 (1996) 53, and references cited therein. 2 P.S. Smg, R. Bandyopadhyay and B.S. Rao, Appl. Catal. A, 136 (1996) 177, and references cited therein. 3 S.M. Yang and T.W. Pan, J. Chin. Chem. Soc, 42 (1995) 935, and references cited therein. 4 A. Blanco, J.M. Campelo, A. Garcia, D. Luna, J. M. Marinas and A.A. Romero, J. Catal., 137 (1992) 51, and references cited therein. 5 J.M. Campelo, F. Lafont and J.M. Marinas, Zeolites, 15 (1995) 97. 6 J.M. Campelo, A. Garcia, D. Luna, J. M. Marinas and M.I. Martinez, Mater. Chem. Phys., 21 (1989) 409. 7 J.M. Campelo, F. Lafont and J.M. Marinas, Proc. 13th Iberoamerican Symp. Catal., Segovia (Spain), 1992, p. 1031. 8 S.I. Woo, J.K. Lee, B.S. Hong, Y.K. Park and Y.S. Uh, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 49 (1989) 1095. 9 Y.K. Park, K.Y. Park and S.I. Woo, Catal. Lett., 26 (1994) 169. 10 D.A. Best and B. W. Wojciechowski, J. Catal., 47 (1977) 343. 11 A.K. Ghosh and G. Curthoys, J. Chem. Soc, Faraday Trans. I, 79 (1983) 2569. 12 J.M. Campelo, A. Garcia, D. Luna and J. M. Marinas, J. Mater. Sci., 25 (1990) 2513.
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
131
P R E P A R A T I O N OF S Y M M E T R I C A L AND MIXED SECONDARY A L K Y L A M I N E S O V E R RANEY N I C K E L AND SUPPORTED C O P P E R CATALYSTS S. G6b616s, M. Hegediis, E. Tfilas and J. L. Margitfalvi Central Research Institute for Chemistry of the Hungarian Academy o f Sciences, 1525 Budapest, OB 17, Hungary Summary Raney nickel catalyst was modified with 0.5 wt % V or Mg to increase the selectivity to secondary amines in the alkylation of ammonia with n-propanol or i-butanol. Due to the modification selectivities around 70-80 % were obtained at 90-95 % conversions. The mixed secondary alkylamine, N-ethyl-N-n-butylamine was prepared from ethylamine and n-butanol on a commercial CuO-ZnO-AI20 3 catalyst. The highest yield of EtNHn-Bu around 76 % was obtained at 190 °C and EtNH2/n-BuOH molar ratio 5 or above. Introduction
Symmetrical and mixed secondary alkylamines with the general formula of R-NH-R and RNH-R', respectively are used as epoxy hardeners and plant protecting agents. Lower aliphatic secondary amines are frequently prepared by the alkylation of a primary amine or ammonia with an alcohol on a nickel or copper catalyst [1]. In this work highly selective preparation of di-npropylamine (n-Pr2NH), di-i-butylamine (i-Bu2NH) and N-ethyl-N-n-butylamine (EtNH-nBu) is described. Di-n-propylamine can be produced in industrial scale by the alkylation of ammonia with npropanol on Ba(OH)2 modified Ni/A1203 catalyst [2], by the reductive
amination of
propionaldehyde over a cobalt-containing catalyst [3] or by the hydrogenation acrylonitrile in nexane on Ni/AI20 3 catalyst [4,5]. However, only scare data is available about the alkylation of ammonia or i-butylamine with i-butanol [6-10]. Di-i-butylamine was prepared from i-butanol over alumina at 370-380 °C with 28 % yield [7]. 20 wt% Co - 5 wt% Ni catalyst supported on alumina was used to prepare di-i-butylamine from i-butanol and i-butylamine at 200 °C with a yield o f 60 .6 [10]. Aliphatic mixed secondary amines prepared from a pimary amine and an alcohol were usually obtained on copper-containing catalysts at 190-200 o c with 30-50 % yields [11-13]. In this paper the effect of modification of Raney nickel catalyst with V or Mg on the selectivity of secondary amine in the alkylation of ammonia with n-propanol and i-butanol is studied. In addition, we report the preparation of N-ethyl-N-n-butylamine over a commercial CuOZnO-AI203 catalyst. The effect of reaction temperature and ammonia or primary amine to alcohol molar ratio on the selectivities and yields of symmetrical and mixed secondary amines will be discussed.
132
Experimental The skeletal nickel catalyst (Ni) was prepared by leaching a 50 w4% Ni-Al alloy with 20 wt% NaOH-H20 solution at 50 °C as desrcibed elsewhere [14]. Modification of Raney Ni catalyst with 0.5 wt% V or Mg was carried out by adsorption using an aquoeus solution of NH4VO3 or MgCl2, respectively [15]. V an Mg modified catalysts will be referred as Ni(V) and Ni(Mg), respectively. Prior to activity test the catalysts were heated to 250 ^C at a rate of 2 ^C/min in a flow of 75 % H2 - 25 % N2 mixture and kept at 250 ^C for 3 hours. A commercial CuO-ZnO-Al203 catalyst (referred as CuZn/Al, with composition: 37 wt% CuO, 36 wt% ZnO, 27 wt% AI2O3 and particle size: 0.31-0.63 mm) treated in 75 %H2 - 25 % N2 mixture at 250 ^C for 3 hours was used in the preparation of mixed amine. The composition, the textural and surface properties of the catalysts were studied by AAS, mercury porosimetry, XRD, XPS and TG-DTA [16,17]. The amount of metallic copper on the surface of catalyst was determined by titration with N2O [18]. The characterization of bulk and surface properties of the catalysts is given elsewhere [14,16,17]. The alkylation of NH3 with n-PrOH and i-BuOH and that of EtNH2 with n-BuOH was carried out at 0.45 MPa partial pressure of ammonia, under 1.3 or 2.1 MPa total pressure and at a H2/NH3 or H2/EtNH2 molar ratio of 3 in a continuous-flow reactor charged with 20 g of skeletal or 13 g of CuZn/Al catalyst (WHSV = 0.7-1.5 h'^). The reaction products were analysed by GC using FID and a glass column (3 m x 3 mm) filled with 60/80 mesh Chromosorb P NAW containing 5 % wt% KOH and 18 wt% Carbovax 20M. The conversion of alcohol and the quantitative yields of amines were determined using i-propanol as an internal standard. Results and Discussion Conversion and selectivity data obtained in the alkylation of ammonia with n-propanol over different Raney nickel catalysts are listed in Table 1. Data given in Table I indicate that n-Pr2NH can be obatined on unmodified and vanadium modified Raney nickel catalyst with 70-72 % selectivities at 92-95 % conversions. Upon modifying the Raney nickel catalyst with Mg the selectivity of the secondary amine increased to 74-75 % at 94-97 % conversions. The increase of the reaction temperature from 225 to 245 ^C resulted in slight increase of the conversion and the selectivity to the primary amine both on unmoified and Mg modified catalysts. The introduction of V or Mg modifiers affected both the selectivity of the secondary amine and the ratio of primary to tertiary amines. The effect of NH3/n-PrOH molar ratio on the selectivites in the alkylation of ammonia with npropanol is shown in Fig. 1. The selectivity of n-Pr2NH is represented by the difference of values of the two curves shown in the figure. Upon increasing the ratio of ammonia to alcohol in the range of 1.4-2.0 the selectivity of the desired secondary amine was only slightly altered, whereas the selectivity of the primary amine increased and that of the tertiary amines decreased as expected from the thermodynamics. The effect of reaction temperature on the conversion of n-PrOH in its reaction with ammonia is shown in Fig. 2a. As seen in the figure 215 and 240 ^C is required to achieve 90 and 95 % conversions, respectively. In this reaction upon increasing the reaction
133
temperature in the range 190-250 ^C the selectivity of n-Pr2NH slightly increased at the expense of the primary amine (see Fig.2b). Table 1 Alkylation of ammonia with n-propanol over different Raney nickel catalysts (P=2.1 MPa, WHSV=1.5 h-^ NH3/n-propanol molar ratio) N^ Catalyst
Xa % 92.1 94.6 94.7 93.5 97.5
T OC
225 1 Ni 245 2 Ni 225 3 Ni(V) 225 4 Ni(Mg) 245 5 Ni(Mg) a) X = conversion of n-propanol
Selectivities, % n-Pr2NH n-PrNH2 9.2 69.8 9.5 70.7 11.3 71.7 9.3 75.3 10.0 74.4
Yield, % n-Pr^N 21.0 64.3 19.8 66.9 17.0 67.9 15.4 70.4 15.6 72.5
100
CO
0)
o 0)
CO
1.5
1.7
1.9
2.1
NHg/nPrOH molar ratio
Fig.l Effect of NH3/n-PrOH molar ratio on the selectivities in the alkylation of ammonia with npropanol over vanadium modified Raney nickel catalyst (T= 225 ^C, WHSV=1.4 h'^, H2/NH3=3, conversion of n-PrOH=93-95 %). Conversions, selectivities and yield of i-Bu2NH obtained in the alkylation of ammonia with ibutanol are summarized in Table 2. The modification of the Raney nickel catalyst with vanadium resulted in 4-5 % increase in the selectivity of secondary and primary amine, whereas the conversion only slightly decreased (compare exp.s N^l and N^2 in Table 2.).
134
135
an ammonia/alcohol ratio of about 1.4. Further increase of the NH3/i-BuOH ratio resulted in an increase of the selectivity to the primary amine and decrease of the selectivities o f the secondary and tertiary amines, especially above an ammonia to alcohol ratio of 2. The mixed N-ethyl-N-n-butylamine was prepared 60 either from ethylamine or its 70 wt% go .~ aqueous solution. The results obtained in the alkylation of 70 wt% ethylamine-water solution with ~ 40 n-butanol on CuZn/AI catalyst are listed in Table 3. Table 3 Alkylation of ethylamine in 70 wt% aqueous solution with n-butanol on CuZn/Al catalyst (P=l.3 MPa, WHSV=0.7 h -1) N°
T na Xb Selectivities, % Yield c °C % EtNI-InBu nBuNI-I 2 nBu2NH % Fig. 2 190 5 83.1 82.5 10.9 5.7 68.6 Effect of reaction temperature on the conversion of n-PrOH (a) and the selectivities (b) in the alkylation 195 of ammonia 5 90.9 with n-propanol 79.6 over magnesium 13.0 modified 5.4 Raney nickel 72.8 catalyst (WHSV= 1.25 h- 1,5NH3/n_PrOH 200 93.0 molar ratio 77.7= 1.7, H2/NH3=3 15.5 ). 5.9 72.3 203 5 93.6 76.8 16.5 6.1 71.9 5 96.6 71.5 19.7 7.7 69.1 Table 2 207 209of ammonia 5 96.8 68.6 21.0 8.1 with vanadium 66.4 Alkylation with i-butanol over Raney nickel catalyst modified (P=2.1 10 83.4 83.1 15.8 1.1 69.2 MPa) 180 186 10 91.5 78.8 19.5 1.7 72.1 10 78.4 20.0 Selectivities, 1.6 % 72.7 N ° T 190 WHSV n a 92.7 X b Yield c 0 96.9 % 71.6 iBuNH 224.0 iBu2NH 3.8 iBu3N 69.4 o C 205 h-1 10 % 11d 220225 1.0 10 65.1 13.5 26.5 70.4 7.0 16.1 63.4 1.597.9 88.0 62.0 a)2n=EtNH2/n-butanol molar ratio, b) X = conversion of n-butanol, c) yield o f EtNHn-Bu 220 1.0 1.5 86.6 18.2 74.7 7.1 65.0 3 240 1.0 1.0 85.5 14.5 75.7 9.8 64.7 4 given 240 in Table 1.0 3 indicate 1.2 16.3 6.7 the molar 69.6 Data that89.8 depending on the reaction77.5 temperature and ratio of 5 240 1.0 1.5 91.5 19.6 78.0 2.4 71.4 amine to alcohol the mixed secondary amine can be obtained over the copper-containing catalyst 6 240 1.0 2.5 95.2 32.2 62.4 5.4 59.4 with 65-83 % selectivities at 98-83 % conversions, respectively. Upon increasing the reaction 7 240 1.6 1.3 86.4 17.2 75.5 8.3 65.2 temperature conversion alcohol monotonously increased, whereas 8 240 the 1.6 1.4 of the90.1 21.9 75.0 3.1 the selectivity 67.6 of EtNHn-Bu The 72-73 % yield 9 240 decreased. 1.6 1.6 highest91.2 25.4 of EtNHn-Bu 72.9 was achieved 1.7 at 190-195 66.5 °C reaction It 2.0 is worthwhile that 68.0 upon increasing1.2the molar 64.5 ratio of 10 240temperature. 1.6 94.8 for mentioning, 30.8 11 240 to alcohol 2.2 1.3 5 to 78.0 20.0 increase 76.7 3.3 and the 59.8 ethylamine from 10 no significant in the selectivity yield of 12 240 2.2 1.6 85.9 24.9 73.0 2.1 62.7 EtNHn-Bu was observed. The high amine to alcohol ratio provided very low selectivity o f tertiary
a) n=NH3/i-butanol molar ratio, X = conversion of i-butanol, of i-Bu2NH d) exp. and N° amines (Et2Nn-Bu, EtNn-Bu 2 andb)n-Bu3N ). Correlation between c) theyield conversion o f n-butanol carried out on unmodified Raney nickelofcatalyst. thewas selectivity of EtNHn-Bu in the alkylation ethylamine with n-butanol over CuZn/AI catalyst is shown in Fig 3. It is interesting to note, that above 95 % conversions the selectivity o f the desired increasing reaction temperature from 220 to 240 oc, both the conversion of i-BuOH mixed Upon secondary amine the sharply decreased.
andThe the results yield of significantly increased from 86.6 %onand 65.0 %,respectively, and the o f i-Bu2NH the alkylation of ethylamine with n-butanol CuZn/AI catalyst at different yield of the secondary amine reached 71.4 % at 91.5 % conversion (compare exp.s N°2 and N°5 in temperatures and amine/alcohol ratios are listed in Table 4. Upon increasing the reaction Table 2). Itfrom is noteworthy, increasing the NH3/i-BuOH molar at constant of WHSV temperature 175 to 205that°Cupon at EtNH2/n-BuOH molar ratio of 1.3 ratio the selectivity the values (1.0 secondary and 1.6 h "l) bothsharply the selectivity andat the of di-i-butylamine reached maximum symmetrical amine increased the yield expense of the mixed amine andathe yield ofat
135 an ammonia/alcohol ratio of about 1.4. Further increase of the NH3/i-BuOH ratio resulted in an increase of the selectivity to the primary amine and decrease of the selectivities o f the secondary and tertiary amines, especially above an ammonia to alcohol ratio of 2. The mixed N-ethyl-N-n-butylamine was prepared either from ethylamine or its 70 wt% aqueous solution. The results obtained in the alkylation of 70 wt% ethylamine-water solution with n-butanol on CuZn/AI catalyst are listed in Table 3. Table 3 Alkylation of ethylamine in 70 wt% aqueous solution with n-butanol on CuZn/Al catalyst (P=l.3 MPa, WHSV=0.7 h -1) N°
T na Xb Selectivities, % Yield c °C % EtNI-InBu nBuNI-I2 nBu2NH % 190 5 83.1 82.5 10.9 5.7 68.6 195 5 90.9 79.6 13.0 5.4 72.8 200 5 93.0 77.7 15.5 5.9 72.3 203 5 93.6 76.8 16.5 6.1 71.9 207 5 96.6 71.5 19.7 7.7 69.1 209 5 96.8 68.6 21.0 8.1 66.4 180 10 83.4 83.1 15.8 1.1 69.2 186 10 91.5 78.8 19.5 1.7 72.1 190 10 92.7 78.4 20.0 1.6 72.7 0 205 10 96.9 71.6 24.0 3.8 69.4 1 225 10 97.9 65.1 26.5 7.0 63.4 a) n=EtNH2/n-butanol molar ratio, b) X = conversion of n-butanol, c) yield o f EtNHn-Bu Data given in Table 3 indicate that depending on the reaction temperature and the molar ratio of amine to alcohol the mixed secondary amine can be obtained over the copper-containing catalyst with 65-83 % selectivities at 98-83 % conversions, respectively. Upon increasing the reaction temperature the conversion of the alcohol monotonously increased, whereas the selectivity of EtNHn-Bu decreased. The highest 72-73 % yield of EtNHn-Bu was achieved at 190-195 °C reaction temperature. It is worthwhile for mentioning, that upon increasing the molar ratio of ethylamine to alcohol
from 5 to 10 no significant increase in the selectivity and the yield of
EtNHn-Bu was observed. The high amine to alcohol ratio provided very low selectivity o f tertiary amines (Et2Nn-Bu, EtNn-Bu 2 and n-Bu3N ). Correlation between the conversion o f n-butanol and the selectivity of EtNHn-Bu in the alkylation of ethylamine with n-butanol over CuZn/AI catalyst is shown in Fig 3. It is interesting to note, that above 95 % conversions the selectivity o f the desired mixed secondary amine sharply decreased. The results o f the alkylation of ethylamine with n-butanol on CuZn/AI catalyst at different temperatures and amine/alcohol ratios are listed in Table 4. Upon increasing the reaction temperature from 175 to 205 °C at EtNH2/n-BuOH molar ratio of 1.3 the selectivity of the symmetrical secondary amine sharply increased at the expense of the mixed amine and the yield of
136 EtNHn-Bu varied between 54-60 %. The incerase of the amine/alcohol molar ratio to 5 or 10, resulted in high selectivity and yield of the mixed amine (see exp.s N®6, N^7 and N^IO in Table 4).
100 Conversion, % Fig. 3 Correlation between conversion and selectivity in the alkylation of ethylamine with n-butanol over CuO-ZnO-Al203 catalyst. (Data given in Table 3 and Table 4 are used; n>5 - data obtained at n = 5 and 10 are used.) Table 4 Alkylation of ethylamine with n-butanol on CuZn/Al catalyst (P=1.3 MPa, WHSV=0.7 h"!) NO
T
na
OC
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
175 178 190 195 205 191 193 201 208 190 201
1.3 1.3 1.3 1.3 1.3 5 5 5 5 10 10
Xb % 67.1 70.3 88.4 93.9 96.9 91.1 93.5 95.6 97.1 93.1 97.5
EtNHnBu 81.8 79.2 67.3 62.6 55.9 83.3 80.4 77.5 75.1 82.4 74.1
Selectivities, % nBu2NH nBuNH2 4.9 9.9 11.4 5.2 8.2 19.0 9.1 22.2 26.3 10.2 4.1 12.1 13.4 5.2 14.9 6.4 7.5 15.9 13.3 3.9 6.1 19.2
8 9 10 11 a) n=EtNH2/n-butanol molar ratio, b) X = conversion of n-butanol, c) yield of EtNHn-Bu
Yieldc % 54.9 55.7 59.5 58.8 54.2 75.9 75.2 74.1 72.9 76.7 72.2
137
Fig.4 gives further data on the effect of reaction temperature at diffferent EtNH2/n-BuOH molar ratios. As seen in Fig. 4 the selectivity of EtNHn-Bu is significantly higher when pure ethylaraine was used instead of 70 wt% EtNH2-H20 mixture. This can be explained by the fact that water is one of the reaction products in the alkylation of ammonia or an amine with an alcohol, therefore the addition of water to the ractants thermodynamically is unfavourable [1]. Neither the concentration of ethylamine (70 or 100 %) nor the amine/alcohol molar ratio had changed the reaction temperature (190 ^C) at which the highest yield of mixed amine was obtained (see Fig. 4).
90i EtNHz, n>5
210
220
Fig.4 Correlation between the yield of EtNHn-Bu and reaction temperature in the alkylation of ethylamine with n-butanol over CuO-ZnO-Al203 catalyst. (Data given in Table 3 and Table 4 are used; n>5 - data obtained at n = 5 and 10 are used.) Conclusions Raney nickel modified with Mg or V can be used for the highly selective preparation of symmetrical amines by the alkylation of ammonia with n-propanol or i-butanol. Upon modifying the Raney nickel catalyst with 0.5 wt % V or Mg, 4-5 % increase in the selectivity to secondary amines was observed and the selectivities reached 70-80 % at 90-95 % conversions. In the alkylation of ammonia with an alcohol symmetrical secondary amines can be obtained with 70 % yield over Mg or V modified Raney nickel catalyst at 220-240 ^C and ammonia/alcohol ratio of 1.5. In an industrial application 2-4 % increase of the selectivity results in an important finantial benefit. It was shown that pure (100 %) ethylamine and 70 % EtNH2 in water can be used for the preparation of N-ethyl-N-butylamine over a commercial CuO-ZnO-Al203 catalyst.
138 In the preparation of EtNHn-Bu from ethylamine and n-butanol over a commercial CuO-ZnOAI20 3 catalyts the highest yield, about 76 % was obtained at 190 °C and EtNH2/n-BuOH molar ratio 5 or above. Here we report the first time such a high yield in the preparation of a mixed aliphatic secondary amine over a copper-containing catalyst. References
1.
A. Baiker and J. Kijenski, Catal. Rev. Sci. Eng., 27 (1985) 653
2.
U.S. Patent 2,636,902 (1953), CA: 48, 3991 (1954)
3.
B. Cornilis, E. Wiebus, P. Ruprercht, W. Konkal (Ruhrchemie AG) Ger. Often. 2,624,63
(1977) 4.
L. T6th et al. (Nitroil, Hungary) Hung. Teljes HU 39,711 (1986)
5.
J. Margitfalvi, S. Grbrlrs, M. Hegediis and E. T~las, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., Vol. 41, Elsevier
Amsterdam, 1988 pp. 145-152 6.
M.A. Popov, Zh. Obsh. Khim., 18 (1948) 438
7.
N.S. Kozlov and N. I. Panova, Zh. Obsh. Khim., 26 (1956) 2602
8.
F.V. Belchev, N. I. Sujkin and S. S. Novikov, Izv. AN SSSR, OHN (1961) 649
9.
F.V. Belchev, Tr. Belorus Seljskohoz., Akad., 42 (1968) 232
10. A. Buzas, C. Fogarasan, N. Ticusan, S. Serban, I. Krezsek, L. Ilies, Ger. Often. 2,937,32 (1981) 11. L. W. Hoffman, R. M. Guertin (Pennsalt Chemical Co.) Fr. Demande 1,490,929 (1967) 12. D.Z. Zavelski, L. A. Lavrenteva, U.S.S.R. 170,517 (1965) 13. K. Klier, R. G. Herman, G. A. Vedage, EP P 127,874 A2 (1984), U. S. Patent 4,480,13 (1984) 14. S. Grbrlrs, E. T~las, M.Hegediis, J. L. Margitfalvi and J. Ryczkowski, Stud. Sure Sci. Catal., Vol. 59, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1991, pp. 335-342 15. J. Antal et al. (Nitrogen Works P&, Hungary), Hung. Patent 206,667 (1987) 16. J. Margitfalvi, S. Grbrlrs, E. T~ilas and M. Hegediis, Stud. Sure Sci. Catal., Vol. 63, Elsevier Amsterdam, pp. 669-678 17. S. Grbrlrs, M. Hegediis, I. Kolosova and J. L. Margitfalvi, submitted to Appl. Catal. 18. J.W. Evans, M. S. Wainwright, A. J. Bridgewater and D. J. Young, Appl. Catal., 7 (1983) 75
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
139
SYNTHESIS OF DIMETHYLETHYLAMINE FROM ETHYLAMINE AND METHANOL OVER COPPER CATALYSTS. Y. POUILLOUX^ V. DOroY% S. HUB^ J. K E R V E N N A L ' ' and J. BARRAULT* ""Laboratoire de Catalyse, URA CNRS 350, ESIP, 40 avenue du Recteur Pineau , 86022 POITIERS CEDEX, FRANCE ^CRRA ELF - ATOCHEM, 69140 PIERRE BENITE, FRANCE
ABSTRACT : Over a copper chromite type catalyst, a DMEA (dimethylethylamine) yield of 70 % was obtained from monoethylamine (MEA) and methanol with diethylmethylamine (DEMA) as the main by-product. The formation of DMEA was increased to 85 % by just changing the basicity of the catalyst resulting from a change of the rate of the determining steps. The rate of the MEA condensation compared to that of the MEA methylation decreased. Moreover the mechanism of the second methylation step which could involve an intermediate amide ((MEFA) or aminoalkoxide) was different from that of the first methylation step. Keywords : Dimethylethylamine synthesis, monoethylamine reaction with methanol, copper or copper chromite catalysts, alkaline or alkaline-earth modifiers. 1. INTRODUCTION Light amines are important intermediates in chemistry and in the pharmaceutical industry. The substituted light amines are prepared from alcohol, ammonia and/or monosubstituted amine in the presence of a solid catalyst (1-4). The heterogeneous catalysis process requires the formulation of a multifunctional catalyst which at a first approximation presents (i) acidic properties (amine adsorption, dehydration,...) and (ii) a hydro-dehydrogenating function (methanol dehydrogenation, hydrogenation of imine and enamine intermediates). Previous works have shown that copper catalysts are selective in the dehydrogenation of esters (5-7), in the hydrolysis of nitrile (8), in the selective hydrogenation of nitrile or in alcohol amination (10). The catalyst systems such as copper chromite are often used for the preparation of substituted amines. These solids, however, are very sensitive to the presence of water and ammonia (formation of copper nitrides (12)). Moreover, the catalysts promoted by alkaline or alkaline-earth species are more stable than the unpromoted CuCr. For example, barium impregnated on copper chromite increases the stability of the active CuCr02 phase (13). Furthermore, the presence of barium or calcium on copper chromite catalysts influences strongly the selectivity to the methylation of amines : N-alkylation/N-methylation.
140 In our laboratory, we have shown that copper chromite doped with barium, calcium or manganese can lead selectively to dimethyldodecylamine from lauronitrile, ammonia, hydrogen and methanol but not to methyldidodecylamine (14). Among the light amines, the dimethylethylamine (DMEA) is quite an important product i.e. as a catalyst in polymerisation processes. DMEA can be prepared from the reaction of ethanol with dimethylamine or from the reaction of methanol with monoethylamine; H2 CH3CH2NH2 + 2CH3OH
CH3CH2N(CH3)2 + 2H2O
We report, in this paper on the properties of promoted copper for the main and the side-reactions and we propose a reactional scheme of monoethylamine transformation. 2. EXPERIMENTAL 2.1. Catalytic test The reaction was studied in a dynamic fixed bed reactor under hydrogen pressure (1.0 MPa) at 210°C. The molar ratio MeOH/MEA was 8.2, the ratio (MeOH + MEA)/H2 « 0.85 (where MEA : monoethylamine or ethylamine) and the catalyst weight « 5g (particle size 1.2-1.6 mm). The reaction products were analysed by a gas chromatograph equipped with a SGE BPl column (L : 25m ; ID : 0.3 mm ; thickness of film : 5 jiim). Each catalyst was characterised by its activity and selectivity under standard conditions. The activity was obtained from the reagent conversion, the selectivity being expressed as follows : - The first calculation refers only to monoethylamine (MEA) and to products resulting from the conversion of MEA: Si(%) =
— X 100 ZMEA-^Pi - The second refers to all the products formed during the reaction (example : TMA) ^Zr%)zz:—XIOO
2.2 Catalysts The catalyst used in this study was a copper chromite doped with barium (YPl). The other solids were prepared from that catalyst by impregnation with alkaline salts from Prolabo (LiNO^,, KOH, CSNO3). After impregnation, the catalysts were dried in a sandbath (120°C), and then calcinated at 350°C for 4 hours under a dry air stream. 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 3.1. Monoethylamine methylation in the presence of modified copper chromites 3.1.1. Activity and selectivity of the reference catalyst (YPl) In the first part of our work, we examined the properties of a copper chromite catalyst for the selective synthesis of dimethylethylamine (DMEA) from monoethylamine (MEA) and methanol (MeOH). Under our experimental conditions at 230°C, this catalyst
141 was quite selective (70%) at total conversion of the reactant. However, at this temperature, there was a significant formation of trimethylamine (TMA). Table 1 N-Methylation of monoethylamine (M£A) in the presence of a YPl catalyst. Effect of the temperature Time
T(°C)
(h)
Conversion
TMA
Selectivity (except TMA) (%) ^
(%) MEA
EMA
DMEA
DEA
DEMA
(%)
32
210
89.0
13.0
61.0
2.4
23.8
6.3
37
230
100
0.1
68.0
-
31.7
23.6
44
190
36.0
64.3
11.8
20.1
3.7
-
Pj^ : 1.0 MPa, Catalyst weight: 5g, Contact time : 1.3 s. (a) Selectivity to product i with reference to transformed ethylamine: Si(%) = (nMEA)conv
-xlOO
Moreover, the study of the influence of residence time showed that methylethylamine was the primary product of the reaction, whereas dimethylethylamine (methylation of EMA) was a secondary compound. The other products, issued from condensation and methylation reactions, were DMEA ((C2H5)2NCH3), DEFA (H-CON(C2H5)2), TEA ((C2H5)3N) Moreover, we observed the formation of monomethylamine MMA (CH3NH2), dimethylamine DMA ((CH3)2NH) and trimethylamine TMA ((CH3)3N).. The overall reaction scheme of the transformation of MEA is ; MeOH
+ MeOH EMA
DMEA
H2O
H2O
MEA+ MEA >3
+ MeOH ^ -H2O
DEA
DEA + [CH3OH 3 MeOH + NH3
^
-H2 -H2O
DEMA
HCHO]
H2O -^
DEFA
>- TMA
In order to increase the DMEA selectivity, the YPl catalyst was modified. As the formation of DEA and DEMA was favoured by the presence of acid sites on the surface of the catalyst, we showed that the addition of alkaline or alkaline-earth elements decreased
142 the condensation reaction rate of MEA. Moreover the presence of an alkaline-earth agent like barium stabilised the active phase (CuCr02) and led to a more stable catalyst (12). 3.1.2. Effect of the addition of alkaline elements (15) The YPl catalyst was impregnated with lithium, potassium or cesium. Table 2 shows that the addition of an alkaline (with the exception of cesium) improves the selectivity to DMEA (up to 90%). The addition of a small amount of KOH (0.5 to 2%) decreases the quantity of DEMA formed without changing the activity. The impregnation of lithium leads to a similar effect. However, in the presence of Li catalyst, the TMA selectivity is much more significant. We think that lithium which has a smaller particle size than potassium, can be easily inserted in the copper chromite phase. It can thus modify the hydro-dehydrogenating properties of copper and change the rate determining steps of side-reactions (TMA formation). The TMA selectivity is reduced when the solid is impregnated with cesium. However, DEFA is formed and it seems that DEMA could be obtained from DEFA;
2MEA^;F=^
DEA
+ CH3OH -H2O ^ DEFA = ^ = ^ DEMA
Table 2 N-Methylation of ethylamine. Comparison of the catalytic properties of YPl catalysts modified with Li, K or Cs. Catalyst
time
Conv.
(h)
EMA
DMEA
DEA
DEMA
DEFA
(%)
0
90.1
0
9.9
0
32.5
TMA
Selectivity (:%) (except TMA)
Li* 0.2%
24
MEA (%) 100
K 3.5%
16.5
99
0
94.2
0
5.8
-
7.5
69
59
22.0
1.3
1.0
17.0
0
100
0.1
68.1
0
31.7
-
23.6
Cs YPl
37
* impregnated with nitrate salt. T : 230°C, PH2 time : 1.3 s.
10 MPa, Catalyst weight : 5g, Contact
It can be observed that the rate of the secondary methylation is much slower than the one observed over the unpromoted solid and it decreases when the size of the alkaline ion increases. Moreover, it seems that the mechanism of the second N-methylation step is different from the one involved in the first N-methylation step. The mechanism of the second N-methylation step for the formation of DMEA or DEMA requires an adsorption step of intermediates MEFA or DEFA via alkoxide species because there is no hydrogen linked to the carbon of the CO bond. The following concerted elimination-hydrogenation reaction can lead to DMEA ;
143 + H2 CH3CH2NHCH3 + (CHsOH =^ EMA
,CH2CH3 H2CN. I ^CH3 OH
H-C—H) =5= II O
-H2 ^CH2CH3 HCN^ II CH3 O MEFA DMEA and a similar mechanism can explain the formation of DEMA via the intermediate DEFA. CU3 CH3CH2N^ ^CH3
H2O
3.2. Reactivity of monoethylamine or other intermediates In order to corroborate the main steps of the synthesis of dimethylethylamine and of the main by-products, we studied the reactivity of some intermediates and products with or without reagents (MEA, MeOH) under the same experimental conditions ; i) In the absence of methanol (replaced by n-heptane), monoethylamine is transformed mainly into diethylamine (DEA), the deactivation of the catalyst being very fast due to an increase of the formation of ammonia (15). Baiker and Kijenski showed, for instance, that part of the copper was transformed into copper nitride during the amination of alcohols (12). In the presence of methanol, the monoethylamine surface coverage is lower and a decrease cf the DEA formation can be observed. Methanol acts as an inhibitor in the synthesis of DEA and as a promotor of the catalyst duration. Table 3 Reactivity of various intermediates with methanol over a YPl catalyst. Reagent
Selectivity (%)
Time
Conv.
(h)
MEA (%)
DMEA
EMA
8
100
DEA'
8
100
DMEA
10 45
TMA + EtOH
DMA
DEMA
(%)
(%)
95.1
4.9
5.0
4.9
4.7
95.3
2.5
2.2
6.8
0
100
5.4
33.1^
66.9
T : 210°C, PH2 10 MPa, Catalyst weight: 5g, Contact time : 1.3 s. (a) catalyst weight: Ig ; (b) ethanol
ii) The methylation rate of diethylamine with methanol is more significant (selectivity to DEMA : 95%) than that of methylethylamine EMA (Table 3). Indeed, we obtained a total DEA conversion with five times less catalyst weight than for the reaction with EMA. This
144
result was expected on account of the change of amine reactivity with the N-substitution. On the other hand, DMEA does not react with methanol or with DEMA and there is no formation of TMA or of TEA. Moreover, the study of DMEA reactivity shows that this compound is much less reactive and can be converted only into DMA and ethanol. The presence of ethanol is more difficult to explain. However, the water issued from the dehydration of methanol into dimethylether can react with DMEA especially in the presence of the fresh catalyst; H2O + DMEA 2 CH3OH
^
DMA + EtOH (CH3)20 + H2O
Figure 1 shows that in the absence of methanol, initially, monoethylamine (EMA) and methylethylamine (MEA) are transformed rapidly. Surprisingly, we observe that: I) the imine, CH3-CH2-N=CH-CH3 is the main product. This compound is the intermediate in the formation of DEA (reactions 1 and 2); CH3CH2NH2 ^
CHsCH^NH + H2
CH3CH = NH + CH3CH2NH2
-NH3 ^
(1) + H2
CH3CH2N - CHCH3 ^ imine DEA
(CH3CH2)2NH (2) DEA
and 2) the enamine, CH3-CH2-(CH3)-N-CH=CH2; compound formed from the reaction of MEA with ethylenimine (reaction 3) which is further hydrogenated into DMEA ; CH3^
CH3^ CH3 CH3^ NH + CH3CH = NH««—^ N - C H ; ^i—^ ^ N H - C H = CH2 (3) CH3CH2'^ CH3CH2'^ NH2 CH3CH2'^ EMA imine MEA enamine DMEA
The hydrogenation steps are the rate limiting steps over the fresh catalyst. After an experiment lasting two hours, we observed a dramatic decrease of the activity, specially of the MEA conversion and the disappearance of the intermediates. Furthermore, the main products, DEMA and DEA, were formed. These results show that the adsorption properties of the catalysts vary very much during the reaction since ethylamine was mainly adsorbed and led to DEA. We suppose that these significant modifications could be due to the polymerisation of reaction intermediates such as imine or enamine. The polymers could remain on the catalyst surface and modify the nature and the number of active sites. In previous works, we remarked that these secondary reactions could modify the catalyst surface (16,17).
145
100
> o o c o
2 > C o
o
Figure 1: Reaction between monoethylamine and methyiethylamine over the 2.5Li*YPl catalyst. Methyiethylamine EMA Conversion (M)^ Ethylamine MEA conversion (x). Selectivity to Diethylamine DEA (O), imine ofDEA (0), Diethylmethylamine DEMA (^), enamine ofDEh/lA (<^) T : 210°C, PH2 10 bar, Catalyst weight: 5g, Ts : 1.3 s. This brief part of our work on the reactivity of intermediates or of by-products shows why an excess of methanol is necessary for the synthesis of DMEA from [MEA,MeOH,H2]. On the one hand, it acts as a methylating agent of monoethylamine and on the other hand, it inhibits strongly the alkylation reactions i.e the MEA disproportionation into DEA and TEA From this study the following reaction scheme describing the transformation of ethylamine to the main product DMEA and by-products was established. From a kinetic point of view, steps 2 and 3 are the rate determining reactions. It follows that the DMEA selectivity is increased by modifying the acido-basicity of copper chromite used as a catalyst. In fact, the change of the catalyst basicity can decrease the MEA condensation to form DEA without modification of the hydro-dehydrogenating properties of the catalyst which are necessary for the methylation of ethylamine with methanol (steps 1 and 3).
146 TEA + MEA -NH3 + H2/-H2O
+ MeOH
DEA MEA .NH3
^
DEFA
^
DEMA
(2)
+ MeOH/-H20
EMA (3)
DMEA + MeOH
EtOH + TMA
+ H2O
+ H2O -MeOH
EtOH + DMA ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors from the University of Poitiers are very grateful to ELF-ATOCHEM for their financial support and fruitful discussions.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13.
DE 3 627 592 (1986), BASF EP 0 107 457 (1982), ICI EP 0 103 176 Al (1979) DE 3 010 791 (1979), UCB SA H.W. Chen, J.M. White, J.G. Ekerdt, J. Catal., 99 (1986) 293 J.W. Evans, M.S. Wainwright, N.W. Cant, D.L. Trimm, J. Catal., 88 (1984) 203 A.K. Agarwal, N.W. Cant, M.S. Wainwright, D.L. Trimm, J. Catal., 43 (1979) 79 J.C. Lee, D.L. Trimm, M.A. Kohler, M.S. Wainwright, N.W. Cant, Catal. Today, 2 (1988)643 J. Volf and J. Pasek, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, 27 (1987) 105. Ed C. Cerveny A. Baiker and J. Kijenski, Catal. Rev. Sci. Eng., 27 - 4 (1985) 653 Z. Gaizi, Thesis, Poitiers, France (1990) A. Baiker, D. Monti and Y.S. Fan, J. Catal., 88 (1984) 81 H. Abe, Y. Yokota and K. Okabe, Appl. Catal., 52 (1989) 171
147 14. 15. 16. 17.
J. Barrault, S. Brunet and N. Essayem, J. Mol. Catal., 77 (1992) 321-332 Y. Pouilloux, V. Doidy, S. Hub, J. Kerveimal and J. Barrault, J. Mol. Cat., submitted to publication N. Essayem, Thesis, Poitiers, France (1991) J. Barrault, S. Brunet, N. Essayem, A. Piccirilli and C. Guimon, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, 78 (1993) 305
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
149
Catalyst acid / base properties regulation to control the selectivity in gas-phase methylation of catechol L. Kiwi-Minsker, S. Porchet, R. Doepper and A. Renken Institute of Chemical Engineering, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (EPFL) CH-1015 Lausanne (Switzerland) The reaction of catechol methylation by methanol in gas-phase over modified y-alumina was studied with the aim to correlate catalytic activity and selectivity to acid/base properties of the catalysts. Catalytic activity and selectivity towards guaiacol formation (0-alkylation) was found to increase with surface acidity. A 20-fold change in the 0/C-methylation ratio was achieved by varying the catalyst acid/base properties, keeping constant the other reaction parameters.
1. INTRODUCTION Alkylation of catechol is an important industrial reaction. Until now only very limited information regarding this reaction can be found, mainly in the patent literature. Monomethylated derivatives of catechol are useful organic intermediates in the pharmaceutical and agrochemical industries [1]. Previous studies in our laboratory [2-4] revealed that vapour phase catechol alkylation over y-alumina in the temperature range 260300°C is a promising synthetic approach to produce selectively guaiacol and 3-methyl catechol. These studies show a competition between O- and C-methylation depending on reaction parameters such as temperature, reactants concentration, conversion and acid-base properties of the catalyst used. Mg^"^-modified y-alumina was observed to be a suitable catalyst to produce 3-methyl catechol. The dependence of C-alkylation selectivity on the amount of magnesia added to y-alumina and the optimal catalyst composition has been reported [4]. The study also showed that basic oxides (MgO, CaO) were not active for the methylation reaction at a temperature below 300°C. A certain basicity seems to be necessary at the catalyst surface for the formation of C-alkylated products. The reaction of phenol alkylation with methanol over oxides and zeolites to produce anisol and cresols presents some of the features of the reaction under investigation. Studies of phenol alkylation revealed that the reaction was sensitive to the acid-base properties of the catalyst [5-13]. The catalytic activity increased with acidity, but the selectivity towards O- or Cmethylated products did not follow a simple correlation with observed acid-base properties. According to [7,12,16] the catalysts with basic sites favour C-methylation. Other authors [6,11] recently reported that an increase in catalyst acidity promote C-methylation. Therefore, a variance in the results concerning acidity and catalytic properties exists in the literature.
150 This work intends to correlate the catalytic activity and selectivity of catechol methylation to catalyst acid-base properties under constant reaction operating conditions. The work also aims at the study of the reaction selectivity towards O- or C-alkylated product formation through suitable catalyst modification.
2. EXPERIMENTAL 2.1. Catalyst preparation As a starting material y-alumina from Engelhard (Al-3982) was used. The aluminas modified by cations were prepared by wet capillary impregnation with aqueous solutions of nitrate salts. H3BO3 and H3PO4 aqueous solutions were used in the case of modification by anions. The concentrations of the solutions were adjusted to the required ratio cation(anion)/AP"^ in atomic percentage (at.%) by varying the amount of nitrates or acids added to y-alumina. Before the impregnation alumina was dried at 200°C for 2 hours. After impregnation (2 h, 25°C) and drying (50°C, 12 h) the samples were calcined in air for 8 hours at 620°C.
2.2. Catalytic test The catalytic reaction was carried out at 270°C and 101.5 kPa in a stainless steel tubular fixed-bed reactor. The premixed reaction solution, with a molar ratio catechol : methanol : water of 1:1:6, was fed into the reactor using a micro-feed pump. Detailed description of kinetic experiments and the experimental set-up have been recently reported in [2-4] . Catechol conversion (Xi) was always less than 0.05, allowing the reaction to be carried out in the differential kinetic region. Before reaction, the catalyst was activated in N2 flow at 270°C for 30 min. The yields (Yi) of the monomethylated products were measured under steady-state conditions after 8-10 hours of the catalyst activity stabilisation. The rate of catechol transformation (-Ri) over different catalysts was used to compare catalytic activity.
2.3. Catalyst characterisation Specific surface areas of the catalysts used were determined by nitrogen adsorption (77.4 K) employing the BET method with Sorptomatic 1900 (Carlo-Erba). X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns of powdered catalysts were carried out on a Siemens D500 (6/29) diffractometer with Cu Ka monochromatic radiation. The total amount of surface basic sites was determined via surface titration by benzoic acid from dry hexane solution as reported elsewhere [14]. Before the titration catalyst samples were dried at 300°C for 2 hours. IR spectra of the samples were obtained in the range of 4000 cm'^ to 900 cm'^ by a Nicolet 710 (Nicolet Analytical Instruments) FT-IR spectrometer with a MCT detector. All spectra were recorded after 100 scans. A self-supporting disk of catalyst sample was mounted in a transmission IR cell. Prior to the methanol adsorption experiment the sample was dried under vacuum at different temperatures, then exposed to the methanol vapour for 60 minutes and dried under vacuum again.
151
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 3.1. Kinetic reaction scheme The kinetics of the gas-phase methylation of catechol (Ai) over 'y-Al203, with methanol (methylating agent), showed [2,3] that the reaction leads to a mixture of different alkylated products. The reaction conditions have been optimised via preliminary experiments [2] to avoid the formation of polymethylated products. Three monomethylated products were observed: guaiacol (A2), 3-methyl catechol (A3), 4-methyl catechol (A4) at low catechol conversion (Xi < 0.05) and in the temperature range 260-300°C since the rates of rearrangement and consecutive steps were negligible. Fig.l presents the dependence of monomethylated product yields on the catechol conversion for Mg^'^(5at.%)/y-Al203. It seen that the three monomethylated products were formed in parallel pathways.
0.05Y3
0.041
>H"
0.03 -
y^^j^
^ 0.02-
0.01.^^^""'"^ '
0.00 H'
0.02
0.00
^
WW '
—1
_Ii-^
*
— 1—
'
0.04
1
0.06
0.08
Conversion, X, [-] Figure 1. Yields Yi of monomethylated products A, as a function of catechol conversion Xi. Similar behaviour was observed with other catalysts in the reaction:
pH
CH30H [Qj ^ (Ai) I -OCH3
CH30H \ ^
i ™^^"
A^OH (A4)
(A3)
Q T
+H2O
OH
C O T + H2O CH3
'CH3
Figure 2. Reaction scheme of catechol methylation at 260-300°C ( Xi < 0.05 ).
152 The experiments were carried out always under the conditions to form the products in parallel pathways. That allowed to evaluate the influence of catalyst acid/base properties on the reaction selectivity towards O- or C-methylation. 3.2. Comparison of catalysts activity and selectivity Catalytic activity and selectivity of pure and ion-modified aluminas are presented in Table 1. The activity and selectivity of aluminas used depend on the added ion and its concentration. It is seen from the data of Table 1 that activity increases with the decrease in surface basicity. This is in agreement with previous work regarding the reaction of phenol alkylation with methanol over oxides [5-10,16]. Table 1. Characteristics of the different catalysts. Ion content
Activity, -Ri
(at.%)
(mol-m-^-h-^)
S2
S3
S4
(|Limolb.a.-m'^)
Y-AI2O3
-
2.0910-^
0.71
0.26
0.03
2.59
P04^/Al203
5
3.2610-^
0.88
0.07
0.05
2.06
P04^/Al203
10
3.4010"^
0.89
0.06
0.05
BOs^/AhOs
5
8.7 MO-^
0.75
0.22
0.03
2.15
Li'-ZAhOa
5
2.93-10"^
0.60
0.39
0.01
3.00
Mg^^/AhOs
2.5
9.3510"^
0.55
0.41
0.04
2.65
Mg^^/AhOs
5
7.56-10-^
0.34
0.62
0.04
Mg^VAhOs
6
6.00-10-^
0.31
0.64
0.05
Mg^^/AhOs
7.5
5.1010"^
0.30
0.65
0.05
Mg^^/AhOs
10
4.64-10-^
0.45
0.51
0.04
Catalyst
Selectivity
Basicity
3.07
The modification of y-AI2O3 by boric acid increased the initial activity, but the catalyst was rapidly deactivated due to coke formation. Under steady-state conditions a much lower activity, compared to the case when pure Y-AI2O3 was used as a catalyst, was observed ( see Table 1 ). In comparison with boric acid, phosphoric acid supported on Y-AI2O3 did not exhibit important deactivation and showed 50% higher steady-state activity than the Y-AI2O3. Modification of Y-AI2O3 by Mg^"^ and Li"^ leads to the diffusion of these cations into the YAI2O3 lattice and results in non-stochiometric spinel formation: MgAl204 and LiAlsOg, as was confirmed by X-ray data [4]. The amount of incorporated cation seems to determine the surface basicity: the benzoic acid (b.a.) adsorption per surface unit of the catalyst increased with the Mg^"^ amount added ( Table 1). This way the surface basicity can be regulated without changing the structure of the catalyst surface or bulk, since Y-AI2O3 is known to have the same spinel structure with unit cell of cubic type and cell parameter a = 7.907 A.
153 To assess the surface acid/base site modification due to Mg^"^ and Li"^ incorporation into the lattice, FTIR spectroscopy of adsorbed methanol as a probe molecule was used. Methanol is known to interact with the acid-base pair (M""^, O^") of the oxide surface [19] and to form methoxy and hydroxyl groups by dissociation of its 0-H bond. The Vco (C-0 stretching) and VcH3 (C-H stretching of the methyl group) bands of the methoxy species are measured since they are known to be sensitive to Lewis acid site nature [20]. Fig. 3 shows spectra of methanol adsorbed on Y-AI2O3 and Mg^"^-modified Y-AI2O3. From the spectral observations it is seen that methanol forms methoxy species in which oxygen is co-ordinated to two cations as shown by the Vco band at 1090 cm'^ [21]. No new Vco band appears when Mg^"^ is incorporated into the lattice, but the maximum of the Vco band is shifted to higher values concomitantly the VCH3 bands are shifted to lower values with increasing Mg.2+.concentration
X)
<
3109
2963
2817
1149
1109
1069
Wavenumber [cm-^]
Figure 3. IR-spectra of adsorbed methanol: (A) y-Al203; from B to E: Mg^'^(n at.%)/ y-AliOs, where n = 5 ( B ), 10 ( C ), 20 ( D ), 30 ( E ). This observation suggests that the O-C bond of the methoxy group gains in strength with concomitant weakening of the oxygen bond with Lewis acid site ( O-M""^) indicating a decrease in the acidity for the surface Lewis sites. This leads to an increase of the energy needed to activate the methyl group. Our results of methanol TPD experiments [4] seems to confirm this suggestion. Fig. 4 presents the shift Avco (characteristic for surface acidity) on the right hand side axis and the catalytic activity on the left hand side axis as a function of the Mg^"*" concentration. Figure 4 shows that the catalytic activity goes down simultaneously with surface acidity under constant reaction conditions. The reaction selectivity also depends on catalyst modification. We compared the reaction selectivity over modified catalysts with the selectivity observed for pure Y-AI2O3 Boron modified Y-AI2O3 shows a small decrease of selectivity towards 3-methyl catechol in favour of guaiacol formation without any change in 4-methyl catechol selectivity (Table 1).
154
10
15
20
Mg^''/Al^''[at.%] Figure 4. Catalytic activity and basicity (shift Avco» see text) as a function of the Mg^"*" concentration. Modification of Y-AI2O3 by phosphoric acid was observed to lead to a significant increase in O/C alkylation ratio: up to 7.33 from 2.45 for Y-AI2O3. The selectivity towards 4-methyl catechol formation is seen to be only slightly affected. The rise in surface basicity of Y-AI2O3 by incorporation of Mg^'^ and Li"^ cations into the lattice leads to the increase of 3-methyl catechol selectivity up to 0.65 at 7.5 at.% of Mg^"^ added. On Fig. 5 the selectivities towards O- and C-monomethylated products are plotted as functions of the amount of benzoic acid adsorbed per unit surface area, [m^], of the catalyst (characteristic of surface basicity). The O/C alkylation ratio is seen to go down when basicity increased. 0-alkylation is reduced with a concomitant increase in C-alkylation, but the ring methylation stays preferentially ortho-selective. It was possible to change the selectivity towards 3-methyl catechol about 10 times, from 0.06 to 0.65, by varying the acid/base character of the catalyst surface without observing any significant change in the selectivity towards 4-methyl catechol. 1.0 H
O-methylation
0.8 H
. 0.6-1
O
0.4-
C/5
0.02.0
2.2
2.4
2.6
2.8
2 3-0
3.2
Basicity [^mol^^^i^^^.m- ] Figure 5. Selectivity towards O- and C-methylated products as a function of surface basicity.
155 It is known that boric and phosphoric acids supported on Y-AI2O3 introduce Br0nsted acidity on the catalyst surface. Borated alumina has mostly strong acid sites [15] and phosphated alumina from medium to weak ones [17,18]. In agreement with Tanabe and Nishuzaki [16] the orientation of reactant molecules during the adsorption plays an important role in the reaction selectivity. Strong Br0nsted acid sites interact with n- electrons of the ring, resulting in horizontal catechol adsorption which leads to the destruction of the molecule and coke formation. The formed coke blocks the surface active sites for further reactant adsorption. This process results in deactivation of borated alumina. Probably, under steady state conditions, the distribution in the strength of the acid sites does not differ from those found in Y-AI2O3. That is why the observed selectivity changed very little with boron modification. Phosphoric acid introduces Br0nsted acid sites of weak to medium strength on the Y-AI2O3 surface which avoid the coke formation. The y-AliOs and Mg^^ modified Y-AI2O3 has been known to have moderate acid/base sites [22-23]. No significant deactivation of these catalysts was observed. During the catechol methylation under the conditions used, three parallel reactions take place (see Figure 2). The rates of these pathways (Ri) can be easily calculated from the data of Table 1, since Ri = Si(-Ri), where Si is the selectivity towards the monomethylated product Ai. The rise of acidity affects differently the rates of the reaction pathways: for the phosphated alumina the rate of guaiacol formation (R2, 0-methylation ) doubled and the rate of Cmethylation pathways simultaneously decreased 1.5 times, if compared to pure y-Al203. The increase in surface basicity due to incorporation of Mg^"^ in the Y-AI2O3 lattice affects the reaction as shown below ( Fig. 6). 2.0- ^ J7^
^'
1.6- \ - ^ l
s0 6 1.2-
b -0.80) i 15 0.4-
0.0-
x^'^^^-^ .^3
X 1
1
0
,
1
4
-~-~~^
T-
6
10
Mg^'^/Al^"' [at.%] Figure 6. Rate dependencies on the amount of Mg added to Y-AI2O3. As is seen from Fig. 6, the increase in basicity leads to the important decrease in Omethylation rate (R2) without significant changing in the rate of 3-methyl catechol formation (R3) until 7.5 at.% of Mg^"^. At higher magnesium concentration the rate R3 goes down more rapidly, than for guaiacol formation. It results in the observed maximum for 3-methyl catechol selectivity at 7.5 at.% Mg^V Y-AI2O3, reported as an optimal catalyst composition [4]. The acid/base properties of the surface active sites, their surface density and the distribution in their strength seems to govern the selectivity towards O- or C-methylated products and will be further investigated.
156 4. CONCLUSIONS The reaction of catechol methylation in gas phase at temperatures below 300°C is seen to proceed efficiently over modified y-aluminas with moderate acid sites. At low catechol conversion (Xi < 0.05), O- and C-methylated products are formed in parallel reaction pathways. The 0/C methylation ratio has been regulated by varying acid/base properties of the catalyst. Modification of Y-A^OB by phosphoric acid was observed to increase the selectivity towards guaiacol formation (0-methylation) up to S2=0.89. The catalyst Mg^"^ (7.5 at.% )/ Y-AI2O3 showed the maximum selectivity towards 3-methyl catechol formation (Cmethylation) to be 83=0.65. It means that a 20-fold change in the 0/C methylation ratio was achieved, when the catalyst acidity was modified, keeping constant other reaction conditions. ACKNOLEDGMENT The financial support provided for this work by the Swiss National Science Foundation is gratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES 1. H. Fiege, et al., Phenol Derivatives, in Ullmann's Encyclopaedia of Industrial Chemistry, Vol. A19, VCH Verlagsgesellschaft, Weinheim, 1991, p. 313. 2. S. Porchet, S. Su, R. Doepper, A. Renken, Chem. Eng. TechnoL, 17 (1994) 108. 3. S. Porchet, L. Kiwi-Minsker, R. Doepper, A. Renken, Chem. Eng. Sci., 51 (1996) 11 2933. 4. L. Kiwi-Minsker, S. Porchet, P. MoeckU, R. Doepper and A. Renken, in: "Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis", vol. 101 A, Elsevier Sci. B. V., 1996, p. 171. 5. V. Durgakumari, S. Narayanan, J. Molec. CataL, 65 (1991) 385 and references cited therein. 6. S. Velu., C. S. Swamy, Appl. Catal. A: General, 145 (1996) 141 and references cited therein. 7. E. Santacesaria, D. Grasso, D. Gelosa, S. Carra, Appl. Catal. A: General, 64 (1990) 83. 8. E. Santacesaria, M. Diserio, P. Siambelli, D. Gelosa, S. Carra, Appl. Catal. A: General, 64 (1990) 101. 9. M. Marczewski, J. P. Bodibo, G. Perof and M. Guisnel, J. Molec. Catal, 50 (1989) 211. 10. Z. H. Fu and Y. Ono, Catal. Lett., 21 (1993) 43. I L L . Garcia, G. Giannetto, M.R. Goldwasser, M. Guisnet, P. Magnoux, Catal. Lett., 37 (1996) 121. 12. C. Benzuhanava and M. A. Al-Zihari, Appl. Catal, 83 (1992) 45. 13. R. T. Tiemat-Manzalji, D. B. Bianchi and G. M. Pajonk, Appl Catal, 101 (1993) 339. 14. A. Gervasini, A. Auroux, J. Phys. Chem., 97 (1993) 2628. 15. S. Sato, M. Kuroki, T. Sodesawa, F. Nozaki, G. E. Maciel, J. Molec. Catal A: Chemical, 104 (1995) 171. 16. K. Tanabe and T. Nishizaki, in Proc. 6'*' ICC, G. C. Bond, P. B. Well, F. C. Tompkins (Eds.), The Chemical Society, London (1977) p.863. 17. S. Malinowski, in "Catalysis by Acids and Bases", B. Imelik et al. (Eds.), Elsevier, Amsterdam (1985) p.57. 18. E. C. DeCanio, J. C. Edwards, J. W. Brunot, J. Catal, 148 (1994) 76. 19. H. Knozinger, AJv. Catal Relat. Subj., 25 (1976) 184. 20. C. Lahousse, F. Mauge, J.-C Lavalley, Proceedings of 11* ICC, Baltimore, 1996. 21. G. Busca, P.F. Rossi, V. LorenzeUi, J. Phys. Chem., 89 (1985) 5433. 22. J. A. Lercher, React. Kinet. Catal Lett., 20 (1982) 409. 23. J. A. Lercher, C. Colombier, H. Noller, J. Chem. Soc, Faraday Trans.l, 80 (1984) 949.
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
157
Enantioselective hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate and isophorone over modified Pt and Pd catalysts Antal Tungler^ ,Karina Fodor^, Tibor Mathe^, Roger A. Sheldon'' ^Technical University of Budapest, Department of Organic Chemical Technology 1521 Budapest ^Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Res. Group Organic Chemical Technology ''Delft University of Technology, Lab. for Organic Chemistry and Catalysis The present study aimed at revealing the mode of enantiodifferentiation in the asymmetric hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate and isophorone over platinum and palladium catalysts. The effect of adding the modifier after an initial phase of racemic hydrogenation and the combined use of different vinca and cinchona type modifiers on enantioselectivity and activity were studied. A mechanistic rationale is proposed to account for the experimental observations. 1. INTRODUCTION The most well-known heterogeneous catalysts for enantioselective hydrogenation are Ni modified with tartaric acid for the hydrogenation of P-keto esters [1] and Pt modified with cinchona alkaloids for the hydrogenation of a-keto esters [2]. Premodification of the catalyst prior to the hydrogenation (Ni/tartrate) or in situ modification, i.e. simple addition of the modifier to the reaction mixture (Pt^cinchona), can ensure enantioselectivities up to 95 % under optimised conditions. In recent years new chiral modifiers [3-9] have been found and new prochiral substrates [8-12] have been used in enantioselective heterogeneous catalytic hydrogenations with promising ee's. Several mechanistic proposals have been made to explain the enantiodifferentiating processes. For example, it was proposed that P-keto esters are hydrogenated on chirally modified nickel according to the Langmuir-Hinshelwood mechanism. Competitive reaction on unmodified sites affords racemic product [13]. It was assumed that the interaction between the modifier and the substrate involves hydrogen bonding through hydroxyl and carbonyl groups. In addition to the enantioselective effect, cinchona alkaloids also produce a rate acceleration , i.e. this is an example of ligand accelerated catalysis [14]. The model of a nonclosepacked ordered array of cinchonidine molecules adsorbed on platinum, proposed by Wells and co-workers, was abandoned in their later study [15]. Augustine [16] deduced from the behaviour of this system at low modifier concentrations that the chiral sites are formed at the edge and comer platinum atoms, which involve the adsorbed cinchonidine and a metal adatom. The different authors agreed that the quinoline ring of the modifier is responsible for the adsorption on platinum, the quinuclidine part, through the nitrogen atom, interacts with
158 tbe carbonyl group of the pyruvate, and the product configuration is determined by the C8 and C9 geometry of the modifier molecule. Protonation of the basic nitrogen of the modifier increases the enantiomeric excess. Baiker and co-workers [17] carried out molecular modelling calculations in order to find out the likeliest conformation of the substrate-modifier adduct on the platinum surface. Margitfalvi [18] concludedfiromNMR, kinetic measurements and molecular modelling calculations that the interaction between the modifier and the substrate, which also exists in solution, changes the reactivity of the pyruvate and the conformation of the cinchonidine. The quinoline ring of the latter exerts a shielding effect on the pyruvate determining the direction of the entering of the hydrogen. The emergence of new prochiral substrates and chiral modifiers and new enantioselective reactions have created a need for identifying common mechanistic features in all of these reactions: the structural, reactivity- and affinity characteristics of the effective modifiers, the interactive functional groups of the prochiral substrates and the appropriate catalysts. A vinca-type alkaloid, dihydroapovincaminic acid ethyl ester (dihydrovinpocetine, DHVIN, I) (Fig. 1), proved to be an effective chiral additive in the Pd mediated hydrogenation of C=C and in the Pt mediated reduction of C=0 double bonds [8].
EtOOC
Figure 1. Structure of dihydrocinchonidine and (-)-dihydroapovincaminic acid ethyl ester. The discovery of the new additive afforded the opportunity for the combined use of different chiral modifiers in the asymmetric hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate and isophorone. The present study aimed at revealing the mode of enantiodifferentiation through the variation of modifiers and catalysts. 2. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The model reactions were the following:
Pd catalysts H2 MeOH,AcOH modifier
^ o
o
Pt catalysts
H2 ^
\*^i<^^Et
o-^* MeOH,AcOH modifier
^^
Figure 2. Model reactions.
^
159 In both reactions (Fig. 2), different Pd and Pt catalysts (Fig. 3, 4) and the combination of vinca and cinchona modifiers (dihydrocinchonidine (DHCND) and dihydrocinchonine (DHCNN)) were tested (Fig. 5, 6, 7). The effect of hydrogen and product adsorption was investigated; for this reason the hydrogenation was allowed to proceed to 15-30% conversion before addition of the modifier (Table 1, 2). e.e. (%)
(-)-DHVIN DHCND 11 DHCNN
Pd black
Pd/TiOz
Pd/C
Pd/AlgOa
Pd/SiOa Pd powder
Figure 3. Hydrogenation of isophorone with different catalysts and modifiers. Conditions: 0.05 mol isophorone, 0.1 g modifier, 0.5 g acetic acid, 25 ^C, 0.5 g catalyst, 100 ml MeOH, 40 bar. e.e. (%) (-)-DHVIN DHCND DDHCNN
Pt/AlaOa
Pt/C
Adams Pt
Pt/TiOg
Pt/SiOa
Figure 4. Hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate with different catalysts and modifiers. Conditions: 0.1 mol ethyl pyruvate, O.lg catalyst, O.lg DHCND, 0.1 g DHCNN, 0.2 g (-)-DHVIN + 0.2 g acetic acid, 100 ml MeOH, 250C, 10 bar.
160 The same substrate-modifier-metal systems give different enantiomeric excesses using catalysts on different supports and different preparation methods (Fig. 3, 4). In some cases even the product configuration changed with the catalyst. In the hydrogenation of isophorone, the catalysts of small or moderate dispersion (Pd black, D<0.05, and Pd/Ti02, D<0.1) resulted in the highest enantioselectivities[ll]. In the hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate the two cinchona alkaloid derivatives (differing in the absolute configuration at C8 and C9) afford the opposite enantiomer in excess. The resulting optical yields are substantially higher than in the hydrogenation of isophorone, where the product configuration depends on the catalyst used (see Fig. 3). Some hydrogenations were carried out in the presence of two modifiers, a vinca type producing, for example, the (S) enantiomer and a cinchona type producing the (R) enantiomer in excess. The catalysts used were Pd black and Pd on titania in the hydrogenation of isophorone, and Pt on carbon, Pt on alumina and Adams Pt in the hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate. The amount of vinca alkaloid was kept constant, while the amount of the other was increased in each experiment. The results are shown in Figure 5, 6 and 7.
e.e. (%) 20
20 mg (-)-DHVIN and X mg DHCNN 4
10
DHCNN (mg)
Figure 5. Hydrogenation of isophorone over Pd black in the presence of (-)-DHVIN and increasing amount of DHCNN. Conditions: 0.05 mol isophorone, 0.3 g Pd black catalyst, (-)-DHVIN constant 20 mg, 6th bar 0 mg, 50 ml MeOH, 25 ^C, 45 bar. When isophorone was hydrogenated over Pd black, the vinca type alkaloid controlled the enantioselection even if the amounts of the modifiers were equal in the reaction mixture. These results are in good agreement with the considerably higher enantiomeric excesses induced by dihydroapovincaminic acid ethyl ester compared with that of cinchona alkaloids. Using Pd/C catalyst, the cinchona alkaloid dominated with small enantioselectivities, indicating that the combined effect of the modifiers depends also on the catalyst type. In contrast, in the hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate [19], the cinchona alkaloid controlled the enantiodifferentiation with every platinum catalyst used, as well as inducing much higher optical yields than dihydroapovincaminic acid ethyl ester. In the hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate using Pt on carbon and Adams Pt, which has a much higher activity, the resulting
161 enantioselectivity significantly decreased with increasing conversion when dihydrocinchonidine was used. The smaller the amount of dihydrocinchonidine, the greater the decrease of the enantiomeric excess. The reason for this behaviour probably is that the quinoline ring of dihydrocinchonidine can be more easily hydrogenated over these catalysts than the indole ring of dihydroapovincaminic acid ethyl ester and as a result, the adsorption ability of molecules and their role in determining the enantioselectivity becomes smaller. e.e. (%)
0.521
1.04
5.21
10.4
DHCND (mmol/l)
Figure 6. Hydrogenation of isophorone over Pd/C in the presence of (-)-DHVIN and increasing amount of DHCND. Conditions: 0.05 mol isophorone, (-)-DHVIN constant 17.4 mmol/l, 0.2 g Pd/C catalyst, 25 ml MeOH, 25 °C, atm. press. e.e. (%) 60 40 (R) 20 0 20 (S) 40
ffll
100 mg (-)-DHVIN and X mg DHCND
20
50
100
100
DHCND (mg)
Figure 7. Enantiomeric excess in the hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate with (-)-DHVIN and increasing amount of DHCND. Conditions: 0.1 mol ethyl pyruvate, 0.1 g Pt/Al203 thermal-treated (Engelhard), 100 mg (-)DHVIN, 6th bar 0 mg, 0.5 g acetic acid, 100 ml MeOH, 250C, 50 bar.
162 From the results described above, the catalyst-modifier-substrate interaction on and with the catalyst surface seems to be the most important in the enantioselection process. This finding led us to examine the influence of the chiral product molecules and the hydrogen covering the catalyst surface on the asymmetric effect of the chiral modifiers. For this purpose, the modifier was added to the reaction mixture not at the beginning of the hydrogenation, but at 15-30% conversion, thus a racemic mixture of the product molecules was produced in the initial stages of the reaction. The results of these experiments and the ones where the chiral modifier was present from the start of the reaction were compared and are summarised in Table 1 and 2 (ee values were corrected with respect to the modified course of the reactions). The catalysts used were Pd on titania and Pd black in the hydrogenation of isophorone, Pt on carbon and Adams Pt in the hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate. Table 1. Effect of racemic starting in the hydrogenation of isophorone (e.e. %) Pd black Pd/Ti02 * ** * ** 40 34 19 (-)-DHVIN 40 15 10 5 DHCND 20 <5 5 DHCNN 15 7 * start after modification, ** racemic starting: modification after 15-30% conversion Conditions: 0.05 mol isophorone, catalyst 0.3 g Pd black, 20 mg modifier, 0.5 g acetic acid; or 0.5 g Pd/Ti02 and 100 mg modifier, 50 ml MeOH, 25 *"€, 45 bar. Table 2. Effect of racemic starting in the hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate ([e.e. %) Adams Pt Pt/C * * ** ** 30 14 12 (-)-DHVIN 10 37 25 5 DHCND 20 15 25 5 DHCNN 12 * start after modification, ** racemic starting: modification after 15-30% conversion Conditions: 0.1 mol ethyl pyruvate, 0.1 g Pt/C catalyst, 100 mg modifier, 0.2 g acetic acid, 10 bar; or 0.05 g Adams Pt and 50 mg modifier, 100 ml MeOH, 25 °C, 50 bar. One general observation is that the chiral effect of both the cinchona and vinca type alkaloids appears to change, in most cases to decrease, if the reaction is started as a racemic hydrogenation compared with the case when the chiral modifier is added at the beginning of the hydrogenation. But no clear conclusion can be made as to whether or not the modifier molecules interact less with the catalyst surface, which is covered by hydrogen and chiral product molecules, and as a result exert less asymmetric effect. 3. CONCLUSION Our results clearly show that the behaviour of the same modifier-substrate system strongly depends on the catalyst used (the same metals on different supports or Adams Pt or Pd black), indicating that the catalyst-modifier-substrate interaction on the catalyst surface is a crucial factor in the process of enantioselection and the observed rate acceleration of pyruvate hydrogenation. On the other hand, it has been shown by CD and NMR measurements that the
163 modifier and the substrate molecules also form a complex or associates in the liquid phase [18, 8]. Nevertheless the formation of the substrate-modifier complex is a necessary but not a sufficient condition for inducing enantioselectivity. We suggest that the modifier-substrate complex is in an equilibrium between the liquid phase and the catalyst surface as well as the "free" substrate and modifier molecules. Whereas it is uncertain that the separately adsorbed substrate and modifier molecules can react on the catalyst surface to give adsorbed substratemodifier complex (Scheme 1). The observed enantioselectivity depends on the equilibrium constants and reaction rates. The differences in the performance of the different catalysts cannot simply depend on the adsorption strength of the modifiers on them, but also on their ability to accommodate the substrate-modifier adduct in an appropriate conformation. To summarise, the most important conditions for enantioselection in precious metal mediated hydrogenations are the following: - condensed aromatic part of the modifier, responsible for the adsorption on the metal, secondary or tertiary nitrogen atom in rather rigid chiral environment to interact with the carbonyl group of the substrate, and protonation of the modifier with a weak acid, - conjugation in the substrate, containing one of the two structural units consisting of two carbonyls or a carbonyl and a C=C double bond: - besides the activity of the metal to saturate the C=0 or C=C double bond, its ability to accommodate the substrate-modifier adduct in an appropriate conformation on its surface. In solution
*- optically active catalyst surface
catalyst surface In adsorbed state
Scheme 1. EXPERIMENTAL The catalysts used were partly commercial products: 5 % Pt/C Merck, 5 % Pd/Al203 Aldrich, 5 % Pd/BaS04 Aldrich, Pd powder Degussa and 10 % Pd/C Selcat of Fine Chemical Co. Budapest. 10 % Pd/Ti02, 10 % Pd/Si02 were prepared as follows. The calculated amount of the catalyst precursor (K2PdCl4) was added to the aqueous suspension of the support. The pH value of the solution was adjusted to 10-11 by addition of KOH. The suspension was boiled for 1 hour then Na(HCOO) was added to the boiling mixture. After half an hour the suspension was cooled, the catalyst was filtered and washed with distilled water.
164 Pd black catalysts were prepared according to the following procedures: 18 mmol (6.0 g) K2PdCl4 was dissolved in 50 ml water and reduced at boiling point with 74 mmol (5.0 g) Na(HCOO) dissolved in 20 ml water. When the reduction was complete, the pH of the suspension was basic (pH 11 ). The catalyst was filtered and washed several times with distilled water. The platinum catalysts used were also partly commercial products: 5% Pt/C Heraeus, Aldrich and Janssen, 5% Pt/Al203 Engelhard, Aldrich, Janssen. Pt02 was the product of Degussa. Pt/Si02, Pt/Ti02 were prepared as follows. The calculated amount of the catalyst precursor ( (NH4)2PtCl5) was added to the aqueous suspension of the support. The pH value of the solution was adjusted to 10-11 by addition of KOH. The suspension was boiled for 1 hour then Na(HCOO) was added to the boiling mixture. After half an hour the suspension was cooled, the catalyst was filtered and washed with distilled water. Some catalyst samples (tt) were heat-treated three hours in hydrogen stream at 400°C in a glass reactor, they were cooled down in nitrogen to room temperature. Ethyl pyruvate, cinchonidine and cinchonine were supplied by Merck. Vinpocetine® was supplied by Richter Gedeon Co. (-)-Dihydrovinpocetine was prepared in our laboratory by catalytic hydrogenation of vinpocetine followed by separation of the epimers[8]. Hydrogenation The hydrogenation of isophorone and ethyl pyruvate was carried out in methanolic solution at 25°C and 1-50 bar hydrogen pressure in a conventional apparatus or in a Biichi BEP 280 autoclave equipped with a magnetically driven turbine stirrer and a gas-flow controlling and measuring unit. Before hydrogenation the reaction mixtures were stirred under nitrogen for 10 minutes in the reaction vessel. During the hydrogenations samples were taken. These samples were analysed with GC on a P-cyclodextrine capillary column (ethyl lactate on 9(fC, dihydroisophorone on llO^'C). The analysis provided base-line separation of the enantiomers. The chromatograms were recorded and the peak areas were calculated with a CWS (chromatography work station). Enantimoric excess values were calculated fi'om the peak areas of the enantiomers with the usual method: [R]-[S]/[R]+[S]. Acknowledgements The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support of the Commission of European Communities, COST PECO 12382 and the support of the Hungarian OTKA Foundation under No. 6 and 1/3/2239, they are grateful to Gedeon Richter Co. for supplying vinpocetin.
REFERENCES 1 2 3 4 5 6
Y. Izumi, M. Imaida, H. Fukawa and S. Akabori, Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 36 (1963) 21. Y. Orito, S. Imai and S.Niwa, J.Chem.Soc.Jpn., 8 (1979) 1118. T. Heinz, G. Wang, A. Pfaltz, B. Minder, M. Schiirch, T. Mallat, A. Baiker, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun. (1995) 1421. B. Minder, T. Mallat, A. Baiker, G. Wang, T. Heinz, A. Pfaltz, J. Catal. 154 (1995) 371. B. Minder, M. Schiirch, T. Mallat, A. Baiker, Catal. Lett. 31 (1995) 143. K. E. Simons, G. Wang, T. Heinz, T. Giger, T. Mallat, A. Pfaltz, A. Baiker, Tetrahedron: Asymmetry 6 (1995) 505.
165 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19
G. Wang, T. Heinz, A. Pfaltz, B. Minder, T. Mallat, A. Baiker, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun. (1994)2047. A. Tungler, T. Mathe, T. Taraai, K. Fodor, J. Kajtar, I. Kolossvary, B. Herenyi, R. A. Sheldon, Tetrahedron: Asymmetry 6 (1995) 2395. A. Tungler, T. Tamai, T. Mathe, G. Vidra, J. Petro, R. A. Sheldon in G. Jannes and V. Dubois, Eds., 'Chiral Reactions in Heterogeneous Catalysis", Plenum Press, New York, (1995) p. 201. H. U. Blaser, H. P. Jalett, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 78 (1993) 139. T. Tamai, A. Tungler, T. Mathe, J. Petro, R. A. Sheldon, G. Toth, J. Mol. Catal. 102 (1995)41. W. A. H. Vermeer, A. Fulford, P. Johnston, P. B. Wells, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun. (1993) 1053. E. I. Klabunovszkii, A. A. Vednyapin, Asymmetricheskii Kataliz. Gidrogenizatsiya na Matallakh, Nauka, Moszkva (1980). M. Garland, H. U. Blaser, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 112 (1990) 7048. K. E. Simons, P. A. Meheux, S. P. Griffiths, I. M. Sutherland, P. Johnston, P. B. Wells, A. F. Carley, M. K. Rajumon, M. W. Roberts, A. Ibbotson, Reel. Trav. Chim. Pays-Bas 113(1994)465. R. L. Augustine, S. K. Tanielyan, L. K. Doyle, Tetrahedron: Asymmetry 4 (1993) 1803. a. K. E. Simons, G. Wang, T. Heinz, T. Giger, T. Mallat, A. Pfaltz, A. Baiker, Tetrahedron: Asymmetry 6 (1995) 505. b. A. Baiker, T. Mallat, B. Minder, O. Schwalm, K. E. Simons, J. Weber in G. Jannes and V. Dubois, Eds., "Chiral Reactions in Heterogeneous Catalysis", Plenum Press, New York, (1995) p. 95. c. O. Schwalm, B. Minder, J. Weber, A. Baiker, Catal. Lett. 23 (1994) 271. d. O. Schwalm, J. Weber, B. Minder, A. Baiker, J. Mol. Struct. (Theochem) 330 (1995) 353. a. J. L. Margitfalvi, M. Hegedus, E. Tfirst, Tetrahedron: Asymmetry 7 (1996) 571. b. J. L. Margitfalvi, J. Catal. 156 (1995) 175. J.L.Margitfalvi, P. Marti, A. Baiker, L. Botz, O. Sticher, Catal. Lett., 6, (1990) 281.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
167
Controlling the Enantioselective Hydrogenation of Ethyl Pyruvate Using Zeolites as Catalyst Support K. Morgenschweis, E. Pdlkiehn and W. Reschetilowski Karl-Winnacker-lnstitut der DECHEMA e. V., Theodor-Heuss-Allee 25, D-60486 Frankfurt am Main, Germany 5 wt.-% Pt/carrier catalysts (carrier materials: NaY, mordenite, erionite and NaX as well as Y-AI2O3 as a microporous, non-zeolitic support) combined with (-)cinchonidine as the chiral auxiliary were used successftiUy for the enantioselective hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate to R(+)ethyl lactate. With acetic acid as the solvent, the catalysts Pt/NaY, Pt/mordenite and Pt/erionite produced high enantiomeric excesses (86 to 90% ee), whereas Pt/NaX (77% ee) and Pt/y-AljOg (67% ee) gave comparatively poor optical yields. With regard to the k^ values, which were obtained from kinetic data of the hydrogenation related to the mass of the catalysts only, a correlation between enantioselectivity and catalytic activity was not discernible. This changed significantly, if referring to the k value related to the mass of the catalyst and its specific Pt surface area (derived from volumetric CO chemisorption measurements). Then, the catalysts producing the highest enantiomeric excesses also resulted in the highest catalytic activities. Therefore, catalytic activity and enantioselectivity essentially depend on the specific Pt surface area of the catalyst. This means that Pt particles of appropriate geometry and size are necessary to generate high enantioselectivity and catalytic activity. Zeolites Y, mordenite and erionite turned out to be appropriate templates for the creation of such Pt particles during catalyst preparation. This was confirmed by temperature-programmed CO desorption measurements. Zeolite X was partially destroyed by acid solution during catalyst preparation, which was proved by DTA and XRD measurements. Therefore, zeolite X, as well as Y-AI2O3, could not act as a template for the creation of appropriate Pt particles. 1. INTRODUCTION In syntheses offinechemicals, heterogeneously catalyzed enantioselective hydrogenations have been gradually developing into a topic of great interest over the past few years, as enantiomerically pure substances are required in pharmaceuticals, biochemistry and food technology. For these purposes, chirally modified metal/carrier catalysts have been used, but the effect of the catalytic system is little known [1-8]. Having chosen appropriate chiral auxiliary, solvent and reaction parameters, it is necessary to apply tailor-made metal/carrier catalysts in order to optimize enantioselectivity and catalytic activity. Since the carrier material significantly influences the properties of the active Pt particles.
168 it is interesting to investigate its effect on enantioselectivity and catalytic activity. This paper deals with the asymmetric hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate to ethyl lactate showing a high enantiomeric excess in favour of the R-enantiomer over (-)cinchonidine modified Pt/carrier catalysts. Due to their regular structures, zeolites in particular have been used as carrier materials.
2. EXPERIMENTAL 2.1. Catalyst preparation The commercial zeolites mordenite, X, Y and erionite as well as Y-AI2O3 (microporous material with an irregular pore system) were used as supports in catalyst preparation, having comparable crystallite and particle sizes (1-2 ^im) that were determined by SEM. The materials were impregnated with 5 wt.-% Ft using an aqueous solution based on H2Pt(OH)6 and HNO3. The precursors were conditioned in a nitrogen stream (16 h at 523 K, flow: 10 1 h"*) and afterwards reduced in a hydrogen stream (3 h at 523 K, flow: 8 1 h"^). The catalysts were used for the enantioselective hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate to ethyl lactate immediately after having been reduced. 2.2. Catalyst characterization The specific surface areas of the Pt/carrier catalysts were determined by volumetric N2 adsorption at 77 K, and the specific Pt surface areas were derived fi"om volumetric CO chemisorption measurements at 298 K (as described in Ref [8]). The resuhs are shown in Table I. The values of the pore access diameters are obtained from Ref [9]. Only the Pt particles sited at the external surface of the zeolites can participate in the enantioselective hydrogenation, because the cinchonidine used as chiral auxiliary is too large to penetrate the zeolitic pore systems. Table 1 Textural data of the carriers and the catalysts S catalyst ^cat. / '/ m^g-^ m^g-^
m^g-^
dporet^]/ nm
Pt/NaY
970
490
5.0
0.74
Pt/mordenite
440
250
2.5
0.65x0.70 0.26x0.57
Pt/erionite
250
22
8.3
0.36x0.51
Pt/NaX
435
215
4.1
0.74
Pt/Y-Al203
235
205
12.6
irregular
^carrier^cat.'
Specific Surface area of the carrier specific surface area of the catalyst
Spt/
Sp^: specific Pt surface area ^pore- pore access diameter [9]
169 2.3. Catalytic and analytic procedure The hydrogenations were performed at 293 K and an initial hydrogen pressure of 7.1 MPa under constant stirring at 1200 min"^; 10 ml ethyl pyruvate were hydrogenated in a mixture of 20 ml solvent (acetic acid or cyclohexane), 5 mg (-)cinchonidine (chiral auxiliary) and 100 mg Pt/carrier catalyst. The conversion of ethyl pyruvate was monitored by measuring the pressure drop in relation to time. The amount of ethyl pyruvate converted per time unit was derived from this drop in pressure. It provides the initial reaction rate constant k^, if related to the mass of the catalyst only, and the initial reaction rate constant k', if related to both the mass of the catalyst and its specific Pt surface area. Final conversion and enantiomeric excess were determined using GC-MS as described in [8].
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 3.1. Influence of the carrier on the catalytic activity, related to mass^ and on the enantioselectivity 1«-1 ko/mmols"^g
solvent: cyclohexane
NaY
mordenite erionite NaX carrier of the catalyst reaction rate constant kg Q
y-Al203
enantiomeric excess ee
Figure 1. Dependence of A:^, and ee on the catalyst support (solvent: cyclohexane)
170 Fig. 1 shows the dependence of the initial reaction rate constant k^ (related to mass) and the enantiomeric excess on the support of the catalyst. In this case, cyclohexane is used as the solvent. The catalysts Pt/NaY, Pt/mordenite and Pt/erionite yield the highest enantiomeric excesses (75 to 80% ee), whereas Pt/NaX (64% ee) and Pt/Y-Al203 (54% ee) give comparatively poor optical yields. On the other hand, the high ko value of Pt/Y-Al203 is remarkable. Therefore a correlation between enantioselectivity and the mass-related k^ values is not discernible. The influence of the catalyst carrier on the initial reaction rate constant k^ and on the enantiomeric excess with acetic acid as the solvent is depicted in Fig. 2. 1/1-1 ko/mmols'^g
NaY
ee / %
mordenite erionite NaX carrier of the catalyst
Y-AI2O '2^3
reaction rate constant kg EH enantiomeric excess ee
Figure 2. Dependence of ^^ ^^^ ^^ ^^ ^^e catalyst support (solvent: acetic acid) By comparison with the series of measurements using cyclohexane as the solvent, the enantiomeric excesses are generally about 10% higher when acetic acid is used as the solvent, whereas the ko values derived from the catalysts Pt/NaY, Pt/mordenite, Pt/erionite and Pt/NaX diminish significantly but, in relation, analogously. On the contrary, the mass-related catalytic activity of Pt/Y-Al203 is much reduced when acetic acid is used as solvent. This disproportionate diminution of the k^ value might be induced by
171 metal/solvent interaction in acid solvents, e.g. acetic acid, which partially conceals the metal/support interaction between Pt and Y-AI2O3, featuring Lewis acid properties. This metal/support interaction probably does not occur between Pt and the commercial zeolites X, Y, mordenite and erionite. Generally, a correlation between enantioselectivity and catalytic activity is not identifiable yet. Therefore, catalytic activity has been related to a further parameter, the specific Pt surface area of the catalyst, giving the k' value that is discussed in section 3.2. 3.2. Influence of the carrier on the catalytic activity, related to mass and specific Pt surface area, and on the enantioselectivity The series of measurements portrayed in Fig. 3 is the same as given in Fig. 2, but a new measure of catalytic activity has been employed, considering both the mass of the catalyst and its specific Pt surface area: the initial reaction rate constant k'.
k*/mmols"'*m"^
ee/% 100
NaY
mordenite erionite NaX carrier of the catalyst reaction rate constant k' O
y-Al20 2^3
enantiomeric excess ee |
Figure 3. Dependence of A:' and ee on the catalyst support (solvent acetic acid) By establishing the initial reaction rate constant k', the correlation between enantioselectivity and catalytic activity becomes obvious. This is in accordance with the "ligand-accelerated"
172
character of the reaction, established by Blaser and co-workers [6]. Thus, it is concluded that Pt particles of appropriate size and geometry are necessary to generate high enantioselectivity and catalytic activity. Furthermore, zeolites Y, mordenite and erionite seem to act as appropriate templates for the creation of such Pt particles during catalyst preparation. However, these theses have to be proved, and the question has to be answered, why NaX does not act as an appropriate template ahhough isomorphous to NaY. 3.2. Differential thermal analysis (DTA) The catalysts and the carrier materials were investigated by differential thermal analysis to ascertain whether the carrier materials had been affected by the catalyst preparation.
Pt/NaX exothermic
200
400
600
800 1000 temperature / K
1200
1400
Figure 4. DTA thermograms of Pt/NaX and Pt/NaY compared to the pure supports (heating rate: 20 K min'^; gas flow: Nj (7 1 h'^); reference: a-AljOj) The reason for the very different catalytic performances of Pt/NaX and Pt/NaY can be derived from Fig. 4: Whereas the broad peak at 400 K (desorption of water) and the sharp peak at 1200 K (destruction of the zeolitic lattice) have vanished during the catalyst preparation in the case of Pt/NaX, they have been preserved for Pt/NaY. As these peaks are typical of zeolites X
173 and Y, it is concluded that NaX was partially destroyed during the catalyst preparation. This conclusion was supported by XRD measurements indicating a loss of crystallinity by more than 20% in the case of NaX only. The experimental findings can be explained by the high susceptibility of NaX (Si/Al = 1.35) to aciJs, whereas NaY is more stable towards acids (Si/Al = 2.6). 3.3. Temperature-programmed CO desorption (CO TPD) Before performing the CO TPD measurements, the catalysts were calcined for 24 hours at 623 K and 10"^ Pa. Afterwards they were charged for 1 hour with CO at 10^ Pa and 323 K, followed by thefinalevacuation at 323 K and 10"^ Pa for 16 hours. The CO TPD measurements were carried out with a heating rate of 5 K min"\
Pp/10^Pag"^ 1E-6 Pt/NaY Pt/mordenite Pt/erionite Pt/NaX PVy-MzOzl
_
3E-7 //* * 'x til f'y ' * ^
1E-7
-
. .- .^'""''^ *N
H n
'7/ | / iu / |S 11
'' ^
Ul1
1
I
\
400
^
^
\
\ -
\\ .^ ' . \ \ \ ^ \ ^ \ \ \ \ 1
500
\
\
JL
/ \ 1\J
\
, /
/ V \J /
\ V-. \
/ I
» * '
**
*
\y^^
y ,1 A]/'.
N
**
\
^
" x
*
\
11 A1
1E-8
.'^
y. » . - . A.
ill 3E-8
*\
\
^ ^
» . ' ' "' '. \ '. ' 1
'
/
/
/ ; /
\ /
600 temperature / K
/ /ii 7/s
/
'\
/'
;
* / /:
/I
' w i
/ *
.' '*;/ 1 / 1 ' ' ij j / » ' ' 1 :
/
*i ' / I, ;
700
1
\\
800
Figure 5. CO TPD spectra of the prepared Pt/carrier catalysts (Pj^: specific desorption pressure) Fig. 5 illustrates that the catalysts Pt/NaY, Pt/mordenite and Pt/erionite give rise to defined peaks between 370 K and 570 K. This is due to an appropriate range of Pt particle sizes, which are induced by the regular structures of the supports during the catalyst preparation. Pt/support interaction is negligible in this case (commercial zeolites as supports).
174
The broad desoq)tion peaks between 370 K and 730 K, which are related to Pt/NaX and Pt/Y-Al203, result mainly from the irregular Pt particle sizes of these catalysts and partially from Pt/support interaction. As it was partially destroyed by the acid solution during the catalyst preparation, zeolite X, similar to Y-AI2O3, could not act as a template for the creation of appropriate Pt particles.
4. CONCLUSIONS Enantiomeric excess and catalytic activity of the asymmetric hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate over (-)cinchonidine modified Pt/carrier catalysts depend significantly on the specific Pt surface area. This is due to the morphology of the Pt particles and to surface chemical Pt/support interaction. Thus, reaction pathway control is possible by varying these parameters. Zeolites NaY, mordenite and erionite are appropriate carrier materials, because they induce the formation of Pt particles with fairly appropriate geometry and size during the catalyst preparation.
5. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors thank the AiF for support of this project, which was funded by the BMWi.
REFERENCES 1. Y. Orito, S. Imai, S. Niwa and G.H. Nguyen, J. Synth Org. Chem. Jpn., 37 (1979) 173. 2. A. Baiker and H.U. Blaser, "Enantioselective Catalysts and Reactions", in "Handbook of Heterogeneous Catalysis" (eds. G. Ertl, H. Knozinger, J. Weitkamp) VCH, Weinheim, in press. 3. U.K. Singh, R.N. Landau, Y. Sun, C. LeBlond, D.G. Blackmond, S.K. Tanielyan and R.L. Augustine,./. Catal, 154 (1995) 91. 4. K.E. Simons, G. Wang, T. Heinz, T. Giger, T. Mallat, A. Pfaltz and A. Baiker, Tetrahedron:Asymmetry, 6 (1995) 505. 5. J.L. Margitfalvi, Chem. hid., (Dekker), 62 (Catal. Org. Reactions) (1995) 189. 6. M. Garland and H.U. Blaser,./. Am. Chem. Soc, 112 19 (1990) 7048. 7. W. Reschetilowski, U. Bohmer and K. Morgenschweis, Chem.-Ing.-Tech., 67 2 (1995) 205. 8. U. Bohmer, K. Morgenschweis and W. Reschetilowski, Catal. Today, 24 (1995) 195. 9. W.M. Meier and D.H. Olson, "Atlas of Zeolite Structure Types", 2"^ edition, Butterworth, London (1987).
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
175
Kinetic Modeling of the Ligand Accelerated Catalysis in the Enantioselective Hydrogenation of Ethyl Pyruvate: Influence of Solvents, Catalysts and Additives H.U. Blaser, D. Imhof and M. Studer* Central Research Services, CfflA-GEIGY AG, R-1055.6, CH-4002 Basel, Switzerland 1. SUMMARY The modifier concentration dependence of rate and enantioselectivity (e.e.) was investigated for the hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate catalyzed by hydrocinchonidine (HCd) modified platinum catalysts. A model assuming the reversible adsorption of one (described by Km) or two molecules of HCd (Kna) on unmodified active sites (Ptu) was used. Good agreement between measured and calculated data was obtained for different types of Pt catalysts, several solvents and also for experiments in presence of additives. It was shown that high enantioselectivities were obtained only for catalytic systems with a high km/ku ratio (rate constants of the modified and unmodified sites) and high intrinsic selectivity (s). No correlation exists between the observed maximum e.e. values and the absolute size of Km or km. The results in presence of small amounts of quinoline and triethylamine indicate a competitive adsorption with HCd on modifiable sites, whereas thiourea seems to adsorb irreversibly. 2. INTRODUCTION
©0(3©©©-"r unmodified (Pt^)
OH
o rate^ = k^' [PtuJ
HCd
p^
O
modified (Pt^)
2^
H
o rate^ = k ^ [ P t J intrinsic selectivity s
Figure 1. Reversible adsorption of modifier on catalyst and reaction scheme
176 There is an ongoing interest in the mode of action of the enantioselective hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate (etpy) with modified Pt-catalysts [1-3]. Garland and Blaser described a kinetic model which is able to explain the dependence of rate and e.e. on the modifier concentration [4]. The model assumes that the modifier adsorbs reversibly on modifiable sites (Figure 1). With ethanol as solvent, the measured data is well described. For toluene and AcOH, however, adsorption of a second HCd molecule had to be introduced to explain the effects at high modifier concentration. With the work presented here, we wanted to answer the following questions: Is this model also useful for other catalytic systems (different catalyst type, solvent etc.)? Which parameters make a 'good' or a 'bad' system? Which modifier concentration is optimal for screening experiments? This paper describes the application of the kinetic model to catalytic systems with different types of Pt catalysts, solvents and additives. Conclusions are drawn concerning the limitation of the model and the parameters that are important for obtaining a selective catalyst. 3. EXPERIMENTAL All reactions were carried out in a thermostated, magnetically stirred 50 ml autoclave (baffles, two thermocouples, X-shaped stirrer, 1=25 mm, max. 900 rpm). A reservoir and a pressure regulator allowed experiments to be carried out under isobaric conditions, p and T in the autoclave and in the reservoir were recorded every 10 s. Usually, the reactions were stopped after 10 min corresponding to conversions of 10 - 50%. Conversion and e.e. were determined by GLCanalysis of the crude reaction mixture (30 m capillary P-Dex 100, 75°C). In all experiments with HCd modifier, the R-enantiomer was the major enantiomer. The initial rates of hydrogenation were calculated with a linear least square method from the pressure drop in the reservoir, accounting for the compressibility of hydrogen. In all series, one experiment was carried out without modifier to determine ku (see below). 100
75
75 -
^ '50 4
50 — # — 0 . 1 mgHCd
1 mgHCd :
--»--
-
1.2mgHCd
25 -
25 -f
r ^
::S:
1.2 mgHCd
- 5.0 mgHCd
---A--- 5.0 mgHCd
" 1—
\
10 20 Conversion (%)
0 - ___________v_
30
\ 10 20 Conversion (%)
30
Figure 2: Dependence of e.e. and A e.e. on conversion at different modifier concentrations. (50 mg 5% Pt/AlzOs (JMC 94), 10 ml e^y, 20 ml toluene, 20X, 100 bar).
177 Etpy was purchased from Fluka (purum). Before use, it was distilled and kept at 5 °C for a maximum of 3 weeks. 10,11-Dihydrocinchonidine (HCd) was prepared from commercially available cinchonidine by hydrogenation with Pd/C. All catalysts had a Pt-loading of 5% and are commercially available from Engelhard (E 4759, E 4762) Johnson Matthey (JMC 94) and Degussa (F 407, F 209, PtSi). The dispersion D of the catalysts was determined as described in [5]. The catalysts were pre-reduced for 2 h at 400^C under H2. They could be stored for 2 weeks under air with no significant loss in selectivity or activity. Because e.e.-values can strongly depend on conversion [3], e.e. vs. conversion was measured in cases where considered critical and incremental e.e. values (Ae.e.) were determined (Figure 2). At low modifier concentration, the Ae.e. decrease after 10% conversion. This means, that the modifier is unstable under the reaction conditions. Therefore, e.e.'s were measured at about 10% conversion in this case. For higher modifier concentration, the stability of the modifier is not critical. In these cases, e.e.'s were measured after 30-50% conversion, ku was determined for every series independently with an experiment without modifier. All curve-fitting was done using the EXCEL-Solver Program (MS EXCEL 4.0, least squares method) with the settings TSfewton' method, Torward' derivatives and 'Tangent' estimates. 4. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
4.1. Catalyst types Table 1 and Figure 3 show the results obtained with different catalyst types. As seen in Figure 3, a good fit of the measured data was obtained for the different catalysts. It is obvious that both the acceleration factors (km/ku ratio) and the intrinsic selectivity (s) have to be optimal in order to get high e.e.max The reason for the observed differences is not clear, however. The following points are noteworthy: High e.e.max are only observed with high kjku ratio and high s (entries 3, 4). e.e.max are low when km/ku is low (1, 2, 5), irrespective of the absolute values of the kinetic parameters. Similar ku-values are found for all catalysts except Pt/Si02: This indicates that the support, the dispersion, and so on have little influence on the activity of the unmodified sites. With Pt/Si02, the highest values for Km, ku and km are observed. However, kjk^ as well as s are low. This means that this catalyst is very active, but not particularly selective. Km/Km2 is similar for all catalysts (17-35) except for 4 (78). With this catalyst adsorption of the second modifier molecule is less favored than on the others. This gives a very high e.e.maxTable 1. Parameters obtained for various types of Pt catalysts with differort dispersion (D). No.
catalyst
type
D
ku
*^m
'^ny'^u
K-m
s
Km2
6-®-inax
1
F407
Pt/CaCOs
0.06
1.6
24
15
14'000
0.92
860
72%
2
PtSi
Pt/Si02
0.69
5.6
89
16
17'000
0.87
480
68%
3
JMC 94
WM2O3
0.19
1.8
53
29
32'000
0.94
r400
83%
4
E4759
WM2O3
0.37
1.3
28
22
37*000
0.94
480
84%
5
E4762
WM2O3
0.22
1.8
27
15
14'000
0.92
860
76%
6
F209
WM2O3
0.22
1.0
21
21
16'000
0.88
670
75%
50 - 200 mg catalyst, [HCd] = 0-0.02 M, 20 ml toluene, 10 ml etpy, 100 bar H2.
178
T 4.E-04
100 X
o
ee caic JMU 94 ee obs F 407 -eecalcF407 ee obs RSi D —eecalcRSi r obs RSi
+ 3.E-04
A
+ 2.E-04 o E
1.E-08
I i.f^^ I - - y ^ p 1.E-07 1.E-06 1.E-05
1 1.E-04
O.E+00 1.E-02
1.E-03
eeobsJMC94
A - - - - -
" r caic rUoi robsJMC94 -rcalcJMC94 r obs F 407 - i fja\G r
'iuf
HCd concentration (mol/l)
Figure 3. Measured and calculated ee. and rate curves for different catalysts.
4.2. Solvent Table 2 and Figure 4 show the results obtained with different solvents. A good fit of the measured data was obtained for different solvents. AcOH is the outstanding solvent with high s and high acceleration kJK [4]. Table 2. Kinetic parameters for different solvents. Solvent
Kuj/Ku
Km
s
53
30
32'000
93 38
53 87
4'000 16'000
6
15
78'000
14
31
7'000
97
240'000
k„ 1.8
k„
EtOH acetone CH3CN
1.8 0.4 0.4
DIPE
0.4
AcOH§
0.9
85
toluene
Km2
Kn/Kni2
0.94
r400
24
83%
0.86 0.86
2'900 2'400
1 7
67% 74%
0.58
180
440
18%
0.85
r5oo
5
65%
0.96
r800
130
92%
C'6'max
§ k^ =140, S2=0.96. 50 mg JMC 94, [HCd] = 0 - 0.02 M, 20 ml solvait, 10 ml etpy, 100 bar H2. The following points are noteworthy: High e.e.max are observed with toluene and AcOH. Both solvents have a high kjku, a high s, andK„/K„a>10. Intermediate e.e.max are observed with EtOH, acetone and diisopropyl ether (DIPE). Both s and Kni/Km2 are significantly lower. It is interesting to note that similar e.e.-profiles are observed with EtOH and DIPE, even though the absolute rates are very different. A low e.e.max, is observed with CH3CN. This solvent shows a very low rate and a very low km/ku. This could be due to strong competitive adsorption of the solvent on modifiable sites. In AcOH, e.e.max and a first rate plateau is reached at very low modifier concentrations. In contrast to all other catalytic system, increasing the modifier concentration leads to a fiirther
179 increase in rate with no change in e.e.. This can either be interpreted that the doubly modified sites are also active or that further sites are modified (see below).
100
X 2.0E-04
D
ee obs AcOH
O
+ 1.5E-04
ee obs toluene —eecalc toluene
A
+ 1.0E-04 ^
ee obs DIPE ee calc DIPE r obs AcOH
g_ + 5.0E-05 j?
- r calc AcOH r obs toluene
robs DIPE
O.OE+00 1.E-09 1.E-08 1.E-07 1.E-06 1.E-05 1.E-04 1.E-03 1.E-02
-r calc DIPE
HCd concentration (mol/l)
Figure 4. Measured and calculated ee. and rate curves for different solvents.
4.3. Additives Table 3 and Figure 5 show the results obtained in presence of quinoline, EtsN and thiourea. As seen in Figure 5, small amounts of additives have a strong influence on rate and ee.. Thiourea and the amines show a different behavior. With the amines, e.e.max is almost unchanged and the maximum rate is somewhat higher. However, more HCd is necessary to reach to maximum values. Tentative Explanation: Competitive, reversible adsorption of EtsN and quinoline and HCd on the modifiable sites. Using k^, K,n and s of the unmodified system, Kadd can be calculated (Scheme 2, results in Table 3). Table 3. Parameters obtained with different modifiers additive
k„
"^m
Km
s
Kni2
K-add
Xmax
e.e.max
-
1.8
53
32'000
0.94
1300
-
0.50
83%
quinoline
2.2
53
32'000
0.94
1300
3'600
0.50
82%
EtsN
2.2
53
32'000
0.94
1300
5'000
0.50
81%
thiourea
0.9
53
32'000
0.94
1300
-
0.05
63%
Xmax =fi-actionof modifiable sites. 50 mg JMC 94, [HCd] = 0-0.02 M, 20 ml toluene, 10 ml etpy, [additive]/[Ptsurf] = 1.7 (quinoline, EtsN) and 0.18 (thiourea), 20 ml toluene, 10 ml etpy, 100 bar H2. modifier
Pt„
->
base Pt,u
4
^
^*add
*^dd
Scheme 1: Competitive adsorption of bases and HCd on modifiable sites.
180 With thiourea, e.e.nax and ratCmax are significantly lower but they are observed at the same HCd concentration as without additive. This suggests, that thiourea poisons the modifiable sites irreversibly. This can be simulated by varying thefi*actionof modifiable sites while using km. Km and s of the unmodified system. The optimal fit is obtained at x max = 0.05, suggesting that 90% of the modifiable sites are poisoned by thiourea (one molecule of thiourea poisons 12 modifiable site). With these refined models, a good fit is obtained with all additives.
x1.E-04
100 T
o
ee obs toluene ee calc toluene
+ 8.E-05
75 +
+ 6.E-05 g^ o E + 4.E-05 B 2
50 +
D
eeobsEtSN
A
ee ot)S thiourea ee caic thiourea r obs toluene -r calc toluene robsEtSN
25 +
+ 2.E-05
' r caic ttoN r obs thiourea
I
"l^
\
h
O.E+00 1.E-08 1.E-07 1.E-06 1.E-05 1.E-04 1.E-03 1.E-02 HCd concentration (mol/l)
Figure 5. Measured and calculated curves with different additives
4.4. Kinetic Treatment The definitions and the kinetic treatment were described in detail by Garland and Blaser [4b]. Reversible adsorption of the modifier (adsorption constant Km) on unmodified surface platinum atoms, Ptu, creates modified Pt atoms, Ptm (see Figure 1) which catalyze the reaction with the rate constant km* and selectivity s^. In principle, two situations are possible: i) all Ru sites are modifiable ii) only part of all Ptu are modifiable. In [4b], both situations are discussed. With both approaches it is possible to fit the data presented in this paper. However, we think that for geometrical reasons, not all Ptm-atoms can be modifiable. Therefore, we arbitrarily assume for all our calculations that only 50% of all Ptatoms can be modified (xmax = 0.5), giving 50% Pt^ and 50% Pt^ in the fully modified system. As a consequence, the racemic reaction on unmodified sites contributes in variable degrees to the over-all reaction but is never negligible.
^ km and K are lump constants and not rate ccmstants. They (xmtzm the dependence of the rate on hydrogen pressure, ethyl pyruvate omc^itration and ten^erature. Since these parameters were kept constant during all experiments, the values of k are conq>arable. ^ s and S2 give the selectivity of the modified sites. s=0.9 means that 90% of all molecules of ethyl lactate produced on the corresponding sites have the R-configuration.
181
One HCd alkaloid occupies and / or blocks a certain number of modifiable platinum atoms. For geometrical reasons it was assumed that an asymmetric site consists of 15 Pt atoms and one adsorbed cinchona molecule. By calculating x^ (the fi*action of modified sites), the observed e.e. and rate can be expressed as a fimction of [HCdJtot (the total HCd concentration in solution) and [Ptsmf] (the concentration surface platinum atoms) [4b]. Adjustable parameters are Km, s, and km, and ku, is obtainedfi*oman experiment without modifier. At high modifier concentration ([HCd] >10"^M), this simple model is no longer valid and a refined model has to be designed [4]. This can be done by assuming that a second HCd molecule is adsorbed at high [HCd]. Again, two situations are possible: a) A second molecule of HCd adsorbs reversibly on a already modified site (Ptm) to form Ptm2 which can hydrogenate with km2, and S2. b) At second type of hitherto unmodified site v^th a much lower affinity of HCd is modified reversibly at high [HCd]. Again, in [4b] both situations are discussed. At least for AcOH, it is possible to fit the data presented in this paper with both approaches. Because a) can be used for all solvents, however, we decided to use only this approach here. Furthermore, to make the model as simple as possible, we made in contrast to [4] the assumption, that doubly modified sites are no longer active (km2 = 0) for all solvents except AcOH. Here, km2 > 0, and S2 = s. Since this second adsorption is only important at high modifier concentrations, the approximation HCdsoi « HCdtot used here is valid and Xm2 can be estimated easily form the definition of Km2. ^2— Km2 Xm [HCdtot]
E.e.obs and robs can again be expressed as a fimction of [HCd]tot with the adjustable parameters Km, Km2, s, km, and in AcOH with km2. With this somewhat simplified model, the data for all catalysts and solvents could be explained.
CONCLUSIONS Our refined models allow a good description of the concentration dependence of rate and e.e. with different Pt-catalysts and additives in various solvents. This is well in line v^th results reported for various modifiers [6a, 6c, 6d] and supports like Pt/Al203 [4], Pt/Si02 [6b], Pt-zeolite [6e] or Pt-coUoids [1]. With etpy as substrate, a qualitatively similar behavior is observed in all cases. Therefore, the concept of reversible adsorption of the modifier on the catalyst seems to be generally applicable. No simple correlation is found between e.e.max and the absolute values of ku, km. Km or Km2 Decisive for good results is a high acceleration factor (ratio of kjku) and a high intrinsic selectivity s. In some cases, also the ratio of Km / Km2 plays a role. A correlation between the model parameters and the properties of the solvents or the catalysts is impossible. Therefore, the models is only of limited value for the characterization of catalysts and solvents. On the other hand, the models allow to differentiate between reversible competition of the modifier and different bases, and the irreversible poisoning of thiourea. The optimal modifier concentrations for modifier screening is not very sensitive. Between 10"^ M and lO'^M, good results are obtained.
182 REFERENCES [1] H.U. Blaser, H.-P. Jalett, M. MuUer, and M. Studer, Catalysis Today, accepted for publication (1996). [2] H.U. Blaser, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 59 (1991) 177. [3] J. Wang, Y. Sun, C. LeBlond, R.N. Landau and D.G. Blackmond, J. Catal. 161 (1996) 752. [4] a) H.U. Blaser, M. Gariand and H.P. Jalett, J. Catal. 144 (1993) 569. b) M. Garland and H.U. Blaser, J. Amer. Chem. Soc, 112 (1990) 7048. [5] H.U. Blaser, H.P. Jalett, D.M. Monti, A. Baiker, J.T. Wehrli, Stud. Surf Sci. Catal. 67 (1991) 147. [6] a) B. B. NCnder, T. Mallat, A. Baiker, G. Wang, T. Heinz and A. Pfaltz, J. Catal. 154 (1995) 371. b) K.E. Simons, P.A. Meheux, S.P. Griffiths, I.M. Sutherland, P. Johnston, P.B. Wells, A.F. Carley, M.K. Rajumon, M.W. Roberts and A. Ibbotson, Reel. Trav. Chim. Pays-Bas 113 (1994) 465. c) A. Tungler, T. Mathe, K. Fodor, R.A. Sheldon and P. Gallezot, accepted for publication in J. Mol. Catal. 1996. e) W. Reschetilowski, U. Bohmer and J. Wiehl, in G. Jannes and V. Dubois, Eds., "Chiral Reactions in Heterogeneous Catalysis'*, Plenum Press, New York, 1995, p. 111.
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
183
Modeling of Kinetically Coupled Selective Hydrogenation Reactions: Kinetic Rationalization of Pressure Effects on Enantioselectivity Jian Wang\ Carl LeBlond^ Charles F. Orella*^ and Yongkui Sun** John S. Bradley*' and Donna G. Blackmond''* ^Merck Research Laboratories, Merck & Co., Inc., Rahway, NJ 07065 U.S.A. ^'Max-PlancklnstitutfiirKohlenforschung, Mulheima.d. Ruhr D45470 Germany 1.
ABSTRACT
A two-site, two-step kinetic model is proposed to rationalize the observed effects of solution hydrogen concentration on enantioselectivity in the asymmetric hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate using a dihydrocinchonidine-modified heterogeneous Ft catalyst. The model successfully predicted enantioselectivity at a hydrogen concentration outside the range used in the kinetic fit. This work demonstrates how the perturbation from equilibrium adsorption of the organic substrate on a heterogeneous catalyst may account for the observed effects of pressure on enantioselectivity. Both positive and negative hydrogen dependences on enantioselectivity may be rationalized using the same model. 2.
INTRODUCTION
Many asymmetric hydrogenation reactions have been shown to exhibit a marked dependence on enantioselectivity of kinetic variables such as pressure, although the hydrogenation of a-keto esters over Pt surfaces containing chiral modifiers (1-8) remains the only widely studied system in heterogeneous catalysis. In the homogeneous asymmetric catalytic hydrogenation of enamides, Halpem and coworkers (9) combined kinetic and spectroscopic measurements to develop a kinetic model to rationalize observed effect of hydrogen pressure on enantioselectivity that has become a textbook example (10). Recently, Boudart and Djega-Mariadassou (11) discussed these data as the only quantitative example of kinetic coupling of elementary steps in and between parallel catalytic cycles reported in the homogeneous, heterogeneous, or enzymatic catalysis literature. In the present study, this concept of kinetic coupling is shown to rationalize and predict the effect of pressure on enantioselectivity in the hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate using dihydrocinchonidine-modified Pt/AljOg. The kinetic model is developed from a simple two-step mechanism in the parallel (R) and (S) branches of a catalytic cycle involving two different catalytic sites. In the pressure range investigated, the model is analogous to that developed in the homogeneous catalytic system discussed above and demonstrates the kinetic consequences of coupling in catalytic cycles for a heterogeneous catalytic system. 3.
EXPERIMENTAL
The organic substrate, ethyl pyruvate (Aldrich, > 99%) and the solvent 1-propanol (Aldrich, 99.5%) were used without further purification at a substrate concentration of 0.5-1 M. Dihydrocinchonidine, prepared by hydrogenation of cinchonidine (Aldrich) as described
184 previously (7), was used in a concentration of 100 mg/1. The catalyst employed in these studies was a 1 wt% Pt/AljOg (Precious Metals Corporation, prereduced, 4-11 g/1). Reactions were carried out at 303 K and at constant pressure ranging from 135-2500 kPa. A fiilly automated reaction calorimeter (Mettler RCl) was used for reactions up to 600 kPa. Higher pressure reactions were carried out in a stainless steel autoclave (PanInstruments). Since it has recently been shown that diffusion processes may play a role in determining enantioselectivity, care was taken in these experiments to insure that the reactions were kinetically controlled, as has been discussed previously (3,8). Enantioselectivity was constant after the initial induction period (GC, Chiraldex B-TA column). Calorimetric measurements provide a simple and rapid means of monitoring reaction rate on-line. The energy balance for an isothermal reacting system shows that the heat flow is proportional to the reaction rate: (1)
Qr=VrZ,MIr.n.i('-lt)
where qr is the heat released or consumed by the reaction, Vj is the volume of the reactor contents, (dCj/dt) is the reaction rate and AHrxn,i the heat of reaction of the ith reaction. When the heat flow of a reaction is calibrated as described previously (8a), qr gives a quantitative measure of the overall reaction rate. In terms of consumption of the reactant ethyl pyruvate ([EP]) this rate becomes: d[EP]_[EP\_^,-[EP\^^
Qrit)
(2)
Our previous studies of this system (8b) found strong agreement between conversions derived from analytical sampling and from fractional heat evolution, confirming that the concentrations of the R and S products may be determined from a mass balance and the definition of instantaneous enantioselectivity (%ee=100*(d[R]-d[S])/(d[R]+d[S]). The rate of R formation is given by Eq. (2):
^=y2h^}-{-^}H-)4«o{[£''i
-m.}^
(3)
The solution hydrogen concentration at any time t, [H2], may be found by integration of the hydrogen mass balance:
^ = .4«,]- -[«,])-(-«)
(4,
The term for the rate of consumption of ethyl pyruvate, d[EP]/dt, is given by the heat flow data. Gas-liquid mass transfer coefficients, k^^a, and hydrogen solubilities, [H2]^^^ were measured as described previously (8a). Experimental rate and enantioselectivity data were acquired over a range of concentrations of both reactants, ethyl pyruvate and hydrogen. The experimental data were fit using the Excel Solver program (Microsoft) to Eq. (3) and Eq. (11) (see Results Section), which describes the relationship between enantioselectivity and hydrogen concentration predicted by the kinetic model. Since it has recently been shown (8c) that this catalytic system exhibits an unusual induction period in which increasing reaction rate and enantioselectivity are observed, experimental data obtained at conversions greater than 30% were used in kinetic modeling.
185 4.
RESULTS
4.1
Development of Proposed Mechanism and Kinetic Expressions Scheme 1 presents the mechanism used to develop a kinetic model for the asymmetric hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate on dihydrocinchonidine-modified Pt/Al203 catalysts. Although a consensus concerning the origin of the effects of the modifier has not been reached, a metal site which is modified by an interaction with the cinchona alkaloid has been implicated in the enhancement of both rate and enantioselectivity. The model which we develop here consists of two separate catalytic sites, those which have been modified (Q^^d) ^Y ^^e presence of dihydrocinchonidine and those which have not (0^). We describe the enantiodifferentiation as occurring through the formation of two separate intermediate species upon the reversible adsorption of the substrate, ethyl pyruvate, on the modified sites. Unmodified sites may undergo reversible adsorption of the organic substrate and hydrogen. Reaction occurs through the irreversible addition of hydrogen, adsorbed on unmodified sites, to these intermediate species adsorbed on modified sites. From the more than ten-fold rate acceleration which we observe in the presence of the modifier, it may be inferred that the contribution to the observed catalytic behavior from the racemic pathway on unmodified sites is negligible, and it is not included in our model. However, the unmodified sites influence the enantioselective reaction by controlling the supply of adsorbed hydrogen atoms to the intermediate species formed on the modified sites.
organic substrate
modified catalyst site
(/?)-intermediate
(S)-intermediate
Scheme 1. Proposed reaction mechanism for the hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate using a dihydrocinchonidine-modified Pt catalyst. The adsorption of the substrate on the modified site results in the formation of {R) and (5) intermediates which undergo hydrogenation with hydrogen adsorbed on unmodified sites.
0H
unmodified catalyst
unmodified catalyst (/?)-product
(5)-product
The rate expression for the asymmetric hydrogenation reaction may be written as the sum of the rate of reaction for the two intermediate species ©^EP.mod ^^^ ®^EP,mod ^^^h adsorbed hydrogen 0^.: r =
rS + Z = (h ®£P,mod + h®EP,mod )QH
(5)
As shown in Scheme 1, the rate constants k^ and k, in each pathway refer to the substrate adsorption and desorption steps on the modified sites, while the two k2's are constants for the irreversible hydrogenation steps for each pathway. Expressions for the intermediate species 0^ on unmodified sites and 0^EP,mod ^ ^ ®^EP,mod ^^ modified sites are given below. Adsorptiondesorption equilibrium on unmodified sites is assumed, with K^p and K^ referring to the
186 adsorption equilibrium constants for ethyl pyruvate and hydrogen, respectively, on the unmodified sites. The steady-state approximation is used to determine the concentration of the two intermediates on the modified sites.^This equation sets the change with time in 0\p„iod ^ ^ 0^EP,inod ^ ^ ^ to zero and equal to production terms (adsorption step, rate constant ki)* minus consumption terms (dissociation and hydrogenation, rate constants k.j and kj).
(6)
{I + A:„'^[H,]^+A:^,[£/']}
9i^fiP.mod (7R)
k!\EP] ^£i»,mod
The rate expression for the R and 5 pathways which is found when Eqs. (6) and (7R,7S) are inserted into Eq. (5). This expression consists of three different parts: . .«v,. . 1 \ concentration driving forces] .«. r . « . . . rate{R) + rate(S) = [(R) kinetic term + (S) kinetic term] * ^ —^ ^ [adsorption term]
/ox (o)
Because adsorption-desorption equiUbrium is not assumed for ethyl pyruvate on the modified sites, the kinetic terms is a function of surface hydrogen concentration: (/?)-pathway kinetic term:
k^k2 k-i-^k^^H
(5)-pathway kinetic term:
(9R,9S)
k^^ AC_i "T K2^
fj
The concentration driving forces are given simply by the reactant concentrations [EP] and Q^. The adsorption term takes into account the presence of both the R and S surface intermediates formed from interaction of the substrate with the modified site and is given by: ^^
k^EP] k\^k^Qjj
^ k,'[EP] k^.x-^klBfj\
(10)
It is important to note that the concentration term and the adsorption terms above are identical in the R and S pathways, and hence any difference between (/?) and (5) rates (the origin of enantioselectivity) must result from differences in the kinetic terms for the two pathways. Positive reaction order in both ethyl pyruvate and hydrogen was always observed under the range of experimental conditions we studied, indicating that the uimiodified sites were not ^ The use of the steady-state approximation instead of assuming substrate adsorption-desorption equilibrium was a key feature of Halpem's studies (9) of pressure effects on enantioselectivity, and its implications for enantioselectivity in the current system will be discussed later in the text.
187 saturated. If we make an assumption that surface coverage on the unmodified sites is low (i.e., 1 » KH^^^[H2]^^^ + KEP[EP]), the rate expression for /^-production (with an analogous equation for ^-production) becomes: (11)
[EP][H,r k^,^k,'K-^[H,f
k^EP]
1 1
k'lEP]
1
L ^-^.
1
k'-.
Enantioselectivity is related to the ratio of (R) and (5) reaction rates: r«
l + ee _ k ^ \-ee klk',
ki,+klK^;^'[H,r k^+k^K'l^lH^]'"
(12)
Lumping the rate constants together illustrates the functional form of the hydrogen dependence: r" _ \ + ee _ a + b[H^\'^ 1 -ee
(13)
l + c[//,]"
It is important to note that a consequence of the use of the steady-state assumption for surface intermediates is that enantioselectivity is a function of hydrogen concentration. The model predicts that enantioselectivity ceases to be a function of hydrogen concentration at the limits of low pressure and high pressure: high pressure limit:
(14)
l + ee l-ee
-^high P
low pressure limit:
l + ee \-ee
k,'K/2
K^
k'Kj2
K'
(15)
While Eqs. (11-15) have been developed for the case of low surface coverage on the unmodified sites, the general model may also be used to consider other cases. When surface coverage of ethyl pyruvate on the unmodified sites becomes very high (i.e., KEP[EP] » 1 + K^^ [H2]'^^), the rate and enantioselectivity become complicated functions of hydrogen and ethyl pyruvate concentrations. This Hmiting case can give a reaction rate showing a negative order in ethyl pyruvate, which has been observed experimentally at very high ethyl pyruvate concentrations (12). ^H
^EP
L
h
R
(16)
\H,
"^
KH}^[H2^ KEP[EP]
jcnm
k^EP]
1+
l^-l "^ l^l
KrplEP]
'^-l "^ '^2
KpplEP] KEP[EP]
KHy2[H2]y2
^r'
l + ee high OEP
/C_i
T" /C2
KEP[EP]
l-ee 2
KEP[EP]
(17)
4.2 Kinetic Model Applied to Experimental Results A comparison of experimental data to this kinetic model is given in Figures 1 and 2. The open symbols in Figure 1 show the relationship between enantioselectivity and hydrogen concentration over a ten-fold change in hydrogen concentration (8d). The solid curve in the figure is a fit of these discrete experimental data points to Eq. (12) using solution hydrogen concentrations up to 0.013 M (corresponding to the solubility of hydrogen in propanol at 600 kPa and 303 K). Experimental data for the rate of (R) production at 303 K two different pressures obtained from heat flow and analytical measurements (Eq. 3) are compared in Figure 2 with the fit of these data to Eq. (11). The more than four hundred discrete experimental data points collected in each experiment over the time interval shown in Figure 2 form an apparentiy continuous line in excellent agreement with the model. The predictive capability of the model was also tested by comparing the enantioselectivity obtained experimentally with that predicted from the model for a reaction carried out at higher pressures. This is shown in Figure 1, where the dashed line represents the model prediction from Eq. 12 and the filled symbols give the experimental result. Thus the model is shown to give an accurate prediction of the enantioselectivity obtained at hydrogen concentrations up to three times greater than that of the highest value used in the kinetic fit. 80-
O
Figure 1. Enantioselectivity as a function of solution hydrogen concentration. Solid line represents the fit of experimental data given by the open circles fit to Eq. (12). Dashed line represents the prediction of the model to higher pressures. Closed circles represent experimental data obtained outside the range used in the model fit.
Experimental Data Kinetic Model Kinetic Model Prediction
200,01
5.
0,04 0,02 0,03 Hydrogen Concentration (M)
0,05
DISCUSSION
The excellent agreement between the experimental data and the proposed model fit shown in Figures 1 and 2^ reveal the power of this simple two-step mechanism in rationalizing complex (and heretofore inexplicable) observed relationships between reaction variables. Further support for this model comes from its prediction of enantioselectivities at pressures outside the range used in its development, corroborated by independent experimental data. ^ Eqs. (11) and (12) yield six constants (where KH*'^ is combined with the constants kj'^ and k2^ to give a lumped constant in the irreversible hydrogenation step) in the kinetic fit. Data obtained over a range of ethyl pyruvate and hydrogen concentrations are required to obtain the solutions shown in Figure 2. Because of the similiarity in the form of the (R) and (S) contributions to the adsorption term for the modified sites (Eq. 10), the overall fit to the rate equation may produce a non-unique solution for the individual constants unless a wide pressure range is employed in obtaining the experimental data.
189
20
30
Time (min)
40
25
Time (min)
Figure 2. Comparison of experimental data for (R) production (solid lines) and kinetic model fit to Eq. (12) (dashed lines) for hydrogenation of 0.5 M ethyl pyruvate in n-propanol at 303 K and two hydrogen pressures. The experimental data curve is comprised of more than 400 data points for each reaction.
The proposed model demonstrates that a pressure dependence on enantioselectivity may be explained by the concept of kinetic coupling between two parallel branches of a reaction network. The model describes a reaction network in which the (R) and (S) pathways involve surface intermediate species occupying sites on a common catalytic surface and sharing a common reactant pool. Because the species in these two parallel pathways may communicate with each other through the reversible adsorption-desorption steps, the rate of formation of each product may be linked to the other through this kinetic coupling. Enantioselectivity is related to the ratio of rates of (R) and (S) production. Each rate has a dependence on hydrogen concentration which is a function of the rate constants for the elementary steps in its own branch of the reaction network. As a result, the individual (R) and (S) rates may have different sensitivities to changes in hydrogen concentration. The model predicts that changes in pressure may result in both increasing and decreasing enantioselectivity, with the trend being determined simply by the relative magnitudes of the rate constants in the network. This description of the reaction network does not require the postulation of different mechanistic pathways for the (R) and (S) branches, or even a different rate-Umiting step in the two branches of the same network. The critical feature which allows the pressure effect to be rationalized is simply the deviation from the Langmuir isotherm assumption requiring that adsorption-desorption equilibrium exists under all conditions of hydrogen pressure. This was elegantly demonstrated by Landis and Halpem (9), and more recently discussed by Boudart and Djega-Mariadassou (11), in the context of hydrogen pressure effects on enantioselectivity in a homogeneous asymmetric catalytic hydrogenation example. The model predicts that enantioselectivity ceases to be a function of hydrogen concentration at the limits of extremely high ([H2] becomes infinite) and low ([H2] approaches zero) pressure. Examination of the physical significance of these limits is informative. The low-pressure limit of Eq. (15) is in fact equivalent to the Langmuir assumption of adsorptiondesorption equilibrium for ethyl pyruvate on modified sites. The high pressure limit (Eq. (14)) gives the case where the rate-limiting step shifts from the irreversible hydrogenation step to the substrate adsorption step in each branch of the cycle. Here enantioselectivity is related simply to the ratio of the forward rate constants for the adsorption step. Another intriguing point in our model is that, while enantiodifferentiation occurs due to the interaction of the substrate with the modified sites, the unmodified sites play a significant role in determining both rate and enantioselectivity. Hydrogen availability is a driving force for the reaction, and competition between hydrogen and other adsorbates on the unmodified sites
190 may thus influence rate. The sensitive relationship between hydrogen availability and enantioselectivity shown in Eq. (12) reveals that the unmodified sites act as "gatekeepers" for hydrogen entry into the irreversible reaction step with the chiral surface intermediate. Thus it may be suggested that the characteristics of these achiral surface sites are as important in the ultimate determination of enantioselectivity as is the concept of the "chiral efficiency" of the modified catalyst sites. 6.
CONCLUSIONS
A mechanism involving reversible substrate adsorption and irreversible hydrogenation was proposed for both the (R) and (S) pathways in the asymmetric hydrogenation of ethyl pyruvate using a dihydrocinchonidine-modified heterogeneous Pt catalyst. This kinetic model gives a quantitative rationalization of the effects of hydrogen concentration on enantioselectivity in a heterogeneously catalyzed asymmetric hydrogenation reaction. The model provided an excellent fit to the experimental data and successfully predicted enantioselectivities attained at pressures greater than the highest value used to develop the model. The two branches of the network share the same pool of reactants and hence are coupled, resulting in this case in the perturbation from equilibrium adsorption of ethyl pyruvate under all conditions except the extreme of very low hydrogen pressure. Both reaction rate and enantioselectivity are sensitive functions of the ability of hydrogen to be delivered to the (R) and (S) surface intermediate species. The model may be applied to cases exhibiting positive, negative, or no pressure effect on enantioselectivity without invoking a change in mechanism or even in rate-limiting step to explain the observed enantioselectivity trends.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
6. 7. 8.
9. 10. 11. 12.
Blaser, H.U., Garland, M., and Jallet, H.P., / CataL, 1993,144, 569. Wehrli, J.T.; Baiker, A.; Monti, D.M.; Blaser, H.U.; /. MoL CataL, 1990, 61, 207. Garland, M.; Jalett, H.P., Blaser, H.U.; in Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals II, Guisnet et al., eds., Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1991, p. 177. Schwalm, O., Weber, J., Minder, B., and Baiker, A., Int. J. Quantum Chem., 52, 191 (1994). a) Wang, G.; Heinz, T.; Pfaltz, A.; Minder, B.; Mallat, T.; and Baiker, A.; J.C.S. Chem. Comm., 1994, 2047; b) Minder, B.; Mallat, T.; Baiker, A.; Wang, G.; Heinz, T.; and Pfaltz, A.; /. Catalysis, 1995, 154, 371; c ) Minder, B.; Schurch, M.; Mallat, T.; Baiker, A.; Heinz, T.; and Pfaltz, A.; J. Catalysis, 1996,160, 261. a) Sutherland, I.M.; Ibbotson, A.; Moyes, R.B.; Wells, P.B.; /. Catal, 1990, 125, 11. b) Meheux, P.A.; Ibbotson, A.; Wells, P.B.; J. Catal, 1991,128, 387. Augustine, R.L.; Tanielyan, S.K.; Doyle, L.K.Tetr. Asymm.., 1993, 4, 1803. a) Singh, U.K.; Landau, R.N.; Sun, Y.; LeBlond,C.; Blackmond, D.G.; Tanielyan, S.K.; Augustine, R.L. /. Catalysis, 1995,154, 91; b) Sun, Y., LeBlond, C., Wang, J., Landau, R.N., and Blackmond, D.G., J. Catalysis, 1996, 161, 759; c) Wang, J., Sun, Y., LeBlond, C , Landau, R.N., and Blackmond, D.G., /. Catalysis, 1996, 161, 752; d) Sun, Y., Landau, R.N., LeBlond, C., Wang, J., and Blackmond, D.G., J. Amer. Chem. Soc, 1996,118, 1348. a) Landis, C.R.; Halpem, J. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1987, 109, 1746; b) Halpem, J. in Asymmetric Synthesis, ed. by J.D. Morrison, (Academic Press, New York, 1985) p.41. Collman, J.P.; Hegedus, L.S.; Norton, J.R.; Finke, R. Principles and Applications of Organotransition Metal Chemistry, 2nd. Ed. (University Science Books, Mill Valley, 1987). pp. 538-541. Boudart, M.; Djega-Mariadassou, G. Catal. Lett. 1994, 29,1. It should be pointed out for clarity that the designations of (/?)- and (S)- in the Halpern work in Ref. (9a) are transposed in Ref (11). Blaser, H.-U., in Catalysis Today, Proceedings Pre-Congress Workshop on Organic Reactions, 11th ICC, Baltimore, MD, June 1996, in press.
^ This concept might be considered in other selective hydrogenation reactions, for example the case of unsaturated aldehydes where parallel pathways for C=C and C=0 bond hydrogenation exist.
Heterogeneous Catalysis and Fine Chemicals IV H.U. Blaser, A. Baiker and R. Prins (editors) © 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
191
Enantioselective hydrogenation of (£)-a-phenylcimiamic acid on cinchonidinemodified palladium catalysts : influence of support Y. Nitta^
K. Kobiro^*, and Y. Okamoto^
^ Niihama National College of Technology, Niihama, Ehime 792, Japan Department of Chemical Engineering, Osaka University, Toyonaka, Osaka 560, Japan
Significant support effects are observed in the enantioselective hydrogenation of (E)-aphenylcinnamic acid to (*S)-(+)-2,3-diphenylpropionic acid on cinchonidine-modified Pd catalysts, especially when the catalysts are pre-reduced at elevated temperatures. The amounts of the modifier and the substrate adsorbed on Pd are strongly influenced by the support employed, indicating the importance of the surface concentration of the modifier for obtaining a high enantioselectivity. A support having appreciable amounts of both acidic and basic sites with a moderate specific surface area is preferable; a Pd/Ti02 catalyst exhibited the best performance.
1. INTRODUCTION Enantioselective hydrogenation of C=C double bonds with heterogeneous catalysts has been a challenging subject [1, 2]. Perez and co-workers [3] showed that (£)-a-phenylcinnamic acid (1) was enantioselectively hydrogenated to (*S)-(+)-2,3-diphenylpropionic acid (2) with an optical yield of 30.5% using a cinchonidine-modified 5wt% Pd/C catalyst. The cinchonidinemodified platinum catalyst, a well-investigated catalytic system for the enantioselective hydrogenation of ketones (a-ketoesters) [1, 4], was found inactive for the hydrogenation of 1 [5]. On the other hand, Bartok and co-workers [6] applied the tartaric acid-modified RaneyNi catalyst, another well-studied system for the enantioselective hydrogenation of ketones (Pketoesters and alkanones) [2], to the hydrogenation of substituted cinnamic acids and their salts. They reported that the hydrogenation of 1 resulted in a very low optical yield of 0.21%, while the hydrogenation of the sodium salt of 1 gave an optical yield of 17%. Subsequent reports have shown that palladium is the superior metal for the enantioselective hydrogenation of alkenes [7-11]. In the course of the studies to improve the enantioselectivity of cinchonidine-modified Pd catalysts for the hydrogenation of 1, we found that the support materials used in the catalyst preparation, as well as the preparation method, had significant influence on the activity and selectivity of the resulting catalysts [12-14]. The highest optical yield (72%)ee) of 2 was obtained with a Pd/Ti02 catalyst under optimal reaction conditions [15]. In the present study. * Present address. ERATO, Japan Sci. Techn. Corp., 1-2-35-103 Onoharahigashi, Mino, Osaka 562, Japan
192 we have examined the effects of the nature of support materials on catalytic properties of the supported Pd catalysts, in order to obtain some insight into the surface state of the modified catalyst and the mechanism of this reaction.
COOH
c'n<^honidine
^
.^^^^
5wt5K Pd/support
2. EXPERIMENTAL The supported Pd catalysts (Pd 5wt%) were prepared by a precipitation-deposition method unless otherwise noted. The standard procedures were as follows. An aqueous suspension of PdCl2 solution, containing 0.05g of Pd in 0.72wt% HCl, and 0.95g of a support, was gently stirred for 15 min at 348 K. A Na2C03 solution was added dropwise to the suspension under vigorous stirring. The final pH value of the solution was adjusted to 10-11. Afl;er gentle stirring for 15 min at the same temperature, the precipitate wasfiltered,washed three times with distilled water, and dried in air at 383 K for 20 h. A portion of the catalyst precursor (0.06 g) was reduced immediately before use by stirring in a solvent under an atmospheric pressure of hydrogen at 298 K for 1 h, or by heating at 473 K for 1 h in a hydrogen flow of 8 1/h. The catalysts prepared are listed in Table 1, together with the supports employed. Commercial Pd/C catalysts were also used for comparison. Cinchonidine and 1 were used as received. The hydrogenation reactions were carried out in 10 ml of a mixed solvent (A) ethyl acetate and 95% ethanol (3:2 in volume) [3], or (B) A^,A^-dimethylformamide (DMF) and water (9:1 in volume) [13], both at 298K under an atmospheric pressure of hydrogen. Cinchonidine (usually 0.06 mmol) was added to the suspension of the reduced catalyst and, by stirring in a hydrogen atmosphere, immediately hydrogenated to dihydrocinchonidine. After 20 min, the substrate 1 (usually 2 mmol) was added and the hydrogenation was started with the stirring speed of 1200 rpm. The reactions were kinetically controlled under our reaction conditions. After the hydrogen uptake finished, the products were isolated from the reaction mixture according to the procedure described before [12], esterified to the methyl ester by the reaction with CH3OH/BF3 CH3OH, and analyzed by HPLC equipped with a chiral detector (JASCO OR990) on a chiral column (CHIRALCEL OJ-R). The optical yield was expressed as the enantiomeric excess (ee) of 2 : ee (%) = 100 X (S—R) I (S+R). The initial hydrogenation rate (rg) was measured at 20% conversion based on the hydrogen uptake. Adsorption measurements with different supports or catalysts were carried out by using a mixed solution of cinchonidine and substrate 1 (4 mmol/1 for each) in solvent B. After stirring at 298 K for 1 h, the amount of each compound adsorbed was determined from the decrease in the concentration of the solution. The concentrations were monitored by HPLC. The mean crystallite sizes of Pd in the reduced catalysts were obtained from XRD line broadening. The total surface areas (SBET) and the areas of Pd metal surface (Spd) were determined using the nitrogen adsorption at 77 K and by the CO chemisorption at 323 K, respectively.
193 Table 1 Supported 5wt% Pd catalysts prepared in this work and the supports used Catalyst
Support
Source of support
Super M-30 Pd/C-1 Osaka Gas Company Pd/Si02 Wakogel C-200 Wako Pure Chemical Ind. JRC-ALO-4 Catalysis Society of Japan Pd/Al203 EP Daiichi-Kigenso Pd/Zr02 Pd/Ti02-2 JRC-TIO-2 Catalysis Society of Japan Pd/Ti02-3 JRC-TIO-3 Catalysis Society of Japan Pd/Ti02-4 JRC-TIO-4 Catalysis Society of Japan Pd/Ti02-5 JRC-TIO-5 Catalysis Society of Japan Pd/Ti02-3n ^ JRC-TIO-3 Catalysis Society of Japan JRC-TIO-3 Pd/Ti02-3i' Catalysis Society of Japan ^ Specific surface area of support. ^ PrecipitatedfromPd(N03)2 instead of PdCl2. Prepared by an impregnation method with Pd(NH3)4Cl2.
Sa^'/mV^ 3000 370 170 25 16 51 49 2.7 51 51
Type
y-alumina anatase rutile anatase rutile rutile rutile
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION First, support effects were studied with the catalysts reduced in situ at 298 K in solvent A. As shown in Fig. 1, the ee values for all the catalysts except Pd/C-1 were between 20 and 25% irrespective of the support used for the catalyst preparation, whereas the activity varied significantly, depending on the catalysts. Pd/Ti02-3 was found most active in the catalysts examined. The unexpectedly low activity and selectivity of Pd/C-1 suggest that the Pd particles incorporated in micropores of the support cannot play a role in this reaction; both the substrate and the modifier are too bulky to reach the surface of Pd in micropores. The XRD measurements showed that the mean crystallite sizes of Pd were smaller than 3 nm for all the catalysts reduced at 298 K. Since the relatively high optical yield of 2 was reported with a Pd/C catalyst [3], we tested four kinds of commercial Pd/C catalysts, after reduction at 298 K for 1 h, under the same reaction conditions as above. As shown in Table 2, the activity and selectivity of these catalysts considerably varied depending on the catalyst origin. Pd/C-NE exhibited the highest enantioselectivity, i.e., similar selectivity to that reported by Perez and co-workers [3]. Pd/CNt and Pd/C-W showed higher selectivities but lower activities than Pd/C-1 prepared in this study. The amount of chlorine remaining in the catalysts could be a factor which decreases the activity. The catalysts prepared by an impregnation method using PdCb or Pd(NH3)4Cl2 had lower activities than those prepared by a precipitation method [12]. On the other hand, the favorable effects of remaining CI on the enantioselectivity have been reported with cinchona alkaloid-modified Pt and Ir catalysts [16,17]. Also with Pd/C catalysts of similar surface area, shown in Table 2, and Pd/Ti02-3 catalysts shown in Figs, land 2, it can be said that catalysts having higher chloride contents provide higher optical yields of 2. Further studies on the effects of the CI content are now underway. Published data on enantioselective catalysts for the hydrogenation of ketoesters indicate that the high metal dispersions are detrimental for achieving high enantioselectivities [7, 19-21]. In
194 60 50 ^ o
40
I 30
iftftftliiiyl
20 l5
10
«s O CO
m
<S
o
9
^
OH
<S fS
ro
Tf
O
o §
o ^
o
OH OH
OH
§ OH
PH
OH
«s
s OH
Figure 1. Hydrogenation activity, TQ, ( D ) and enantioselectivity, ee, ) of different Pd catalysts reduced in situ at 298 K for 1 h. Reaction conditions: 0.06 g catalyst, 2mmol 1, 10 ml solvent A, atmospheric pressure of H2, 298 K. Table 2 Commercial Pd/C catalysts and their properties Catalyst Pd/C-NE Pd/C-K Pd/C-W Pd/C-Nt
Source (5wt%Pd) (7.5wt%Pd) (5wt%Pd) (5wt%Pd)
N. E. Chemcat Co. Kawaken Fine Chemicals Wako Pure Chemical Ind. Nacarai tesqu Inc.
Sa/mV^ Clcontent/% 1200 1100 800 760
0.13 0.01 0.74 0.17
ro
ee/%
30.1 25.1 0.8 1.1
32.2 26.0 24.9 15.8
^ specific surface area. ^ Initial hydrogenation rate (mmol/g h) observed in the reaction in solvent A. Optical yield of 2 obtained in the reaction in solvent A. the previous paper [12], we reported that the pre-reduction of the precipitated precursors at elevated temperatures much improved the selectivity of Pd catalysts in the enantioselective hydrogenation of 1. The reduction of Pd/Ti02-3 at 473 K resulted in the highest optical yields of 2, up to 72%ee, for the reactions carried out in solvent B under optimal reaction conditions [13, 15]. Therefore, we examined the support effects with the catalysts reduced at 473 K for 1 h, for the reactions carried out in solvent B. As shown in Fig. 2, the enantioselectivity, as well as the activity, varied significantly depending on the support employed. Simi