Healipg the Planet O N E P A T I E N TA T A T I M E l edicine A P r i m e ri n E n v i r o n m e n t aM C\
tr
+
Joze...
78 downloads
1972 Views
25MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Healipg the Planet O N E P A T I E N TA T A T I M E l edicine A P r i m e ri n E n v i r o n m e n t aM C\
tr
+
Jozef J, KroP' MD, FAAEM
Healing the Planet One Patientat a Time: A Primer in EnvironmentalMedicine Copyright @2002 by |ozef Krop All Rightsreserved.No part of this book may be reproducedin any manner whatsoeverwithout prior written permission from the publisher exceptin the caseof brief quotations embodied in review. National Library of CanadaCataloguingin Publication Krop, Iozef 1., 1944Healing the planet: one patient at a time : a primer in environmental medicinellozef I. Icop. Indudes bibliographical referencesand index. ISBN0-9731945-0-2
J (
1. Environmentaltoxicology. 2. Environmentalhealth. 3. Environmentally induced diseases.I. Title.
RA56s.K76 2002
615.9'02
I
I
c2002-905674-8
\ I
Secondprinting Cover and text design/layout: Heidy lawrance Associates
T .I
Photo credit: Arne JacenryAf Photographic
( (
Printed and bound in Canada. Textpagesprinted on recydedpaper
,A
P
ts
Publishedand distributed by KOS Publishing Inc. 1997 BeechgroveRoad, Alton, ON Canada LON lA0 Tel/Fax(5r9) 927-1049 Quantity discountsauailable
E B T 'tl lr
The nutritional,medicaland healthinformationpresented in this book is basedon the research, trainingandpersonalexperience of theauthorandis trueandcompleteto the best of theauthor'sknowledge. Theopinionsexpressed arethoseof theauthorandin no wayrepresentthoseof the medicalprofession or anymedicalassociation. Thisbookis intendedonly
fn
Ir M C
as an informativeguide for thosewishing to know more about the subiectmatter covered.It is sold with the understandingthat the publisherand the author are not liable for the misconceptionor misuseof information provided.Everyeffort hasbeenmadeto makethis book as completeand as accurateas possible.The author and KOS PublishingInc. shall haveneither liability nor responsibilityto any personor entity with respectto any loss,damage,or injury causedor allegedto be causeddirealy or indirectly by the information contained in this book. The information presentedherein is in no way intendedto replacesupervisionby a doctor for medical or health relatedproblems.
o
[):
Cr
ct
ei o
Iia
Ai l\C
O:
I
L
-
Table of Gontents iltittiriii::j:#z:i1#iiti#|,:t PrefaceY
Ozone Holes 86 UV Light 87 F"9_1e_gg1-d,.....ix - " Organochlorines 88 fgk1,oy1!ed9e.r9.-e$ l,ti PCBs-Polychlorinated Biphenyls 89 Introduction I Volatile Organic Compounds, VOCs r.r] "1" ^"-"--"' WtiiTffi'M;Aiii;"iJ-p" i;;{' Pesticides,Herbicides and lrungicides : : One Doctor's Prescription for Every-Day Petrochemicals 95 Rebellion 5 Hydrocarbons 97 Flow I BecameAn Environmental lrormaldehyde 97 Physician 7 Alcohols 99 'l'he I{azards of Being An llnvironmental Food Constituents of Alcoholic Physician 12 Beverages 100-101 Medicine, the I Iouse of Many Mansions L7 tsthanol/EthylAlcohol 102 Causefor Cautious Optimism 2L Phenol (Synthetic) 103 Ilndnotes 25 Naturally Occurring Phenols 104 Phenolic (Aromatic) Irood P:irsip-t$-s!F-,n:i:.p:vstltL[s.iisits-.*?2""_.-__ Compounds 105-106 What is Environmental Medicine? 32 Asbestos 107 Principles and Practice of Environmental Radon 108 Medicine 34 Heavy Metals 108 Psycho-Neuro-Endocrino-lmmunology 36 'l'ypes Human Exposureto Lead 110 of Exposures 37 Aluminum 111 Changing Facesof Sensitivity 38 Cadmium 111 Children 38 Mercury ll2 Adults 40 Oxides 113 Principlesof Environmental Medicine 4l Bipolarity (Biphasic Pattem of Reaction) 45 Carbon Monodde (CO) 113 Nitrogen Oxides (N0, N02) 1i4 Environmental Control Units 47 Carbon Dioxide (COr) 115 Biochemical Individuality 49 l n d o o r P ollution 115 Medical Office 52 'lypes : Average Daily'l'ime Spent In: 24-Hr of 1'esting 56 'lteatments AverageHome Could Be Polluted I'r , , 58 Many Sources 118 Immunotherapy 60 Air Quality in Schools 119 Autogenous Vaccines 63 Problems Contributing to Sick Buii,i r : !$-qls1t:, Bsgi-a,$1!-ol9,:. "-6J , . Syndrome L2l fn d o o r I n h a l a n t s 6 5 'Ibbacco Smoke 123 Molds and |ungi 67 Perfumes/|ragrances 125 Candida Albicans 69 Plastics 127 lractorsContributing to Candida Infection 69 Irabrics 130 Outdoor Inhalants 71 Clothing 131 Patternof Outdoor Inhalant Allergy SympFoodard Nutrition 133 toms 73 F;a'ffiifi;sht" i33 Concomitant and SynergisticSensitivities 73 'lbtal llody l,oad and lrood Reactions 12,1 Chemicals 75 Cyclical Irood Sensitivities 135 Lnemlcats / 5 IrixedFood Sensitivities 135 Outdoor Pollution 76 Anaphylaxis 135 IractorsContributing to Outdoor Pollution 77 Do You Crave Certain Foods? l':, , Air Quality lndex 79 Digestion of a Food 137 Acid Rain 84 Carbohydrates 138 Ozone(0,) 85 Proteins 140
rv
pa H E A L TTNHGEP L A N E T : O n tei e natt a T i m e
Lipids r4L Chelation Therapy 247 RecommendedNutrient Intake for Canadians ,s-p-qqiqlj*e"rs!.iJp* r43 Arrenrio n D;n;if Hy#ffi;ffi'bil;A;;*Quality Levelsof Eating t44 (ADHD) 24e You Are What You Eat-Food Additives t46 Autism 252 An Apple a Day May Nor Keepthe Doctor Preventionof Sensitizationto ljoods in Away! 147 Newbornsand Infants 263 OrganicFoods L49 EPD 267 CertificationBodies L52 Hydrotherapy(Sauna) 269 Sourcesof Information 153 Hormones 270 CeneticallyEngineeredAgribusiness_ Hormone DisruptingChemicals Pandora'sBox? 154 (HDC) 270 The label Game tsZ The Most Common Hormonal Grains 158 Problems 279 Anatomy of a Grain 159 Thyroid Gland 280 Hidden Food Ingredients 160 Adrenal Gland 284 Com 160 Premenstrual Syndrome (pM.S) 286 Wheat 162 Menopause is Not a Disease 2gg Alternativesto WheatFlour 163 Stealth Infections 2g2 Soy 165 Dental Amalgams 296 Dairy Products t66 Cancer 301 Yogurt 168 Prevention At Home 303 Sweeteners l7l Electromagnetic Radiation(EMR) 309 Yeast 174 Nuclear Radiation 3ll Eggs 176 Another Piece oftheTotal Load puzzle_ NamesAppearingon Ingredientlabels l7z How Safe fust Is It? 311 Pork 178 HospitalAdmissionsfor patientswith Beef 179 EnvironmentalHypersensitivity Flaxseed 179 Disorder 315
tl:nrqene$**!gl**^ General tuail#ffi
r-Gndip;;*TB{*****
Let Nature Help you lg9 Changesin Lifestyle t9t Detectionof Problemltems lg2 TowardsAn EnvironmentallySafeHome lg4 MicrowaveOvens l9g A SpecialNote on Computers 2OO The School Environment 202 AlternativePersonalCareproducts 204 Water 209 TravelTips for the SensitiveIndividual 2I5 If You Must Usepesticides...2lz PestControl Without pesticides... 217 Natural PestControl products 2Ig SpecialNore on Head Lice 220 OrganicLawn Care 220 Four-DayRotaryDiversifiedDiet 222 A Note on Food Families: 223 Food Combining 229 What Can I Do About Candida Overgrowth? 230 NutrionalSupplements 232 Amino Acids 236 IntravenousUse of Vitamins 246
lpr:n{i:--l!9
DentalAmtisimRdffi;#il?;Ad"lt
-* "
*"xe
J j
I i
ChallengeTestfor HeavyMetals in Children 320 ChelationTherapyfor HeavyMetalsin Children 322 Adult ChelationChallengelbst for Heavy Metals 323 'lreatment for Mercury/HeavyMetalsToxiciw in Adults 324 CollagenDiseaseprorocol (Rheumatoid Arthritis,Scleroderma, Etc.) 326 IntravenousProtocols322
li
Resources329 "C""-^l^;2g
a
Suppliers and Services 333 Supportive Resourcesfor Environmentally SensitivePatients 335 Altemative Cancer'lieatment Resources 336 ProfessionalOrganizations 336 Laboratories 338 CompoundingHolisticpharmacies 340
P!9!igsrarlr,"""1{:." Index 353
l I t
I I S
e, C C w st ta
to Preface Publisher's Printing the Second Thefirst printingof this book,November 2002,was quickly sold out, making a second printing necessaryeight months later. It is a matter of special satisfaction to me personally,that while sold in maior bookstoreseverywhere, most were sold in doctors' offices.This meansthat this book is primarily in the hands of patients whose doctors work with them. For more than two decades,Dr. Krop's name has been associatedin North America with the politics of medicine. He is best known for his role "Kwinter Bill" (after Ontario's in helping to launch the popularly known Liberal MPP Monte Kwinter), which enshrined patient's freedom of choice in the Medicine Act of Ontario in 2000 (seeOntario Hansardof August28, 1991). Dr. Krop also contributed, in the early 1980'sto the World Commission on the Environment (the BrundtlandReport),and his practice was used by the Ontario government to begin the processof establishingguidelines for dealing with environmental causesof illness (the 1985 Thomson Report).He also participated in various university and federal governmentsponsoredeffortsto raiseawarenessof the environment'Simpact on popuand for many yearsserved lation health. In the 1980'she was a cp-fo_under, as the secretaryof the CanadianSocietyfor EnvironmentalMedicine. As is the fate of many pioneers,he spent more than a decadedefending environmental medicine in a disciplinary trial initiated againsthim by the of ond Surgeons Ontario medical licensingauthority, the Collegeof Physicians Ontario.The CPSObasedtheir prosecutionnot on patientcomplaints(there were none), adversetreatment outcome (they admitted all files studied showed the patientshad improved), but allegedthat practicingenvironmen"lackedacceptablescientificevidence"r.The CPSOthen ensured tal medicine
E
G, ,|Dr *:: ',tl*r,
vr
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e natt a T i m e HEALIN
' r.
,iD, ;{sl ,tD, ,,IH, .*, :r*i:
,,:i:ir.l
that such scientificevidenceappearedindeed to be missing by totally ignor-
that
ing its existencewhen handing down their final 1999 Decision. Many of
ase
those hundreds of scientificarticles,all from the mainstream medical iour-
witl
nals, provided by the defenselawyersduring the trial, are now part of the ref-
lace
erencesection in this book. Of course,this throwback to medieval doctrinal
all r
wars and its legal instrument, the Inquisition, begins to make some sense
dise
when one realizesthat the majority of CPSO council members are either
disc
directly or indirectly connectedto the pharmaceuticaland pesticideindustry.
sior
Dr. Krop's trial is legally, politically, and medically one of the great scandals in medical history. His patients and supporters fortunately
Dr.
believed in this causeand footed most of the defensebill which, over that
lacl
long decadeof the trial, reachedalmost Can. $ 2 million. However,due this
autl
immense effort and the involvement of so many first classlawyers,the legal
emt
professionbecamesensitizedto the abuseof processand law the CPSO and
env
other regulatory bodies committed without everbeing checked.Today there
pari
are many lawyersworking for many more innovative doctors and defend-
fan(
ing medicine properly. Before the Krop casefew lawyers and fudges knew
and
iust how deep the rot ran. Those who want to know more about this story and the world-wide battle for Environmental Medicine, may want to read
the
Malice in Medicine-The 74-YearTlial of EnuironmentalMedicinePhysician
t"."
Or, Iozef Krop written by me and due to be published in 2OO4. This book is a primer prefacein environmentalmedicine.It is unique among the many excellent books currently available on many aspectsof health and environment becausethis one is meant for both patients and doctors. Knowing that patients are intelligent people who can understand anything in medicine if the courtesyof full explanation is offered, Dr. Krop includesin this book the completetreatment protocols which the reader can take to his or her doctor to study.Theseprotocols are supported by an exhaustivemedical bibliography intended especiallyfor those Doubting Thomaseswho are willing to examinewidely-held prejudicesagainstenvironmental medicine and are willing to consider seriouslyits claim to be able to help those many illnessesstandardmedicine calls idiopathic, i.e. causeunknown. Everyyear more and more researchis published showing;
pla<
D r .J . K r o p
vrl
;;iE:, r ..Gli;:,, : ]:a:::-:
;/ii:ii;::iljt!:.:?;:..,iifii:it?i;i;!.t1ttti.::i4:tii,:;..1.tltittiiia!:r.ttiai:1
.:
.i:,}?.i:.'t .,
[ f , :l9i'.:'::.:
'liicl:1:,.':,'i ,1,19.,:1,',.t,., '"!ft:t::t:
,f
that what was once consideredan idiopathic illnessis now well understood as environmentallyand nutritionally mediated.Water,air and soil polluted
t-
with neuro-toxins and carcinogens,and nutrient-deficient processedfood laced with endocrine disrupters and pesticidescauseor trigger virtually
,e
all modern epidemics,such as asthma, chronic fatigue, most neurological diseases,Parkinson's,Alzheimer's, allergies,osteoporosis,attention deficit
:r
disorder and many psychiatric conditions, cardiovasculardisease,depres-
v. rt
sion, and the greatestscourgeof our time-cancer.2 Since Healing The Planet Once Patient At A Time appearedlast year,
v
Dr. Krop was reprimanded in September2003 for practicing medicine
rt
lacking scientific proof-as interpreted by Ontario's medical licensing "victory" more of an is authorities. Dr. Krop is free to practice;the CPSO's
il
is 'd
embarrassmentthan a triumph and will serveto help spreadthe word about environmental medicine rather than deter its practice.For purposesof com-
re
parison, the readermay be interestedin how the CPSO'Smonumental igno-
t-
ranceand arrogancemeasureup to current developmentsin environmental
w
and nutritional medicine.This is merely a sample-a completelist is beyond
ry
the scope of this preface.Indeed, a great shift in understanding is taking
rd
place in medicine, which will, no doubt, eventually leave the corporately
tn
contaminated regulatoryauthorities and medical practitionersin the dust. o The December2000 health-freedomamendment to the Ontario Medi-
al
JC
cine Act sponsoredby Liberal MPP Monte Kwinter and whose wording
of
he took from the 1988 intemational Helsinki Accord on Human Rights,
rd
has taken on a lifer of its own. Similar bills are now being sponsoredby
rd
Manitoba, and Quebec.It provincial legislatorsin Saskatchewan,
)p
already existsin British Columbia; Alberta was the first to make it law.
Ier
. Following the CanadianSupremeCourt's Hudson Decisionof 2OO2
an
on the right to passlocal by-laws againstpesticideuse,an immense
n8
public campaignbrought about in March this year the passageof an
vi-
anti-pesticidelaw for the whole Provinceof Quebecwhere its cosmetic use will be phasedout completely.Within a decadewe may have epi-
be
demiologicalevidencethat in Quebecpopulation health has markedly improved, comparedto the rest of Canada.
t.e. 1g;
;r
G=___
,,'-|*i,,: ,:.. ,,,iil!,1,,,,,,;t i::!Gr:!::r:r
::
vnt
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e natt a T i m e HEALIN :ijii:i.i|i'i.:iiili1i|ii..j|:.!iii:i:i.|)|i:.|.;1i.ii|i'*..!iil:i'i':..|:|i|:4..:|.||!,i,|.|iiii:j||.i|,.jj!:j:.|f!.:i:.!
o The World Health Organization recently published a consensusreport on the need to reducedrasticallythe use of refined sugar,remove vending pop machinesfrom school cafeterias,and reducethe amount
a /
of sugar in processedfoods. The sugarindustry was infuriated and
l
demanded from the WHO's Director General,Gro Brundtland, that this report be withdrawn, threateningthat otherwisethe industry would seeto it that the WHO's annual financial contribution from the United Statesgovernmentwould be withheld. Dr. Brundtland
!
responded by publishing both the report and the threats.3Incidentally,
i
in 1993 the CPSOreprimandedToronto's Dr. Carolyn Dean for warn-
1
ing againstthe intake of too much sugarwhile being interviewed on
I
the Dini Petti television show-the warning was specificto diabetic
(
patients and warned also againsthigh sugar intake as causingdiabetes.
(
A complaint by Canada'sSugarInstitute had initiated this disciplinary investigation on the grounds that there was "no scientific basis" for such a claim againstrefined sugar.This castsan interesting light
I
1 . l
on where the CPSOgets its scientificadvice.a(For in formation on
(
Dr. Dean'sand many other such physicians'cases beforethe CPSO
1
visit: www.collegeofu hysicianswatchdog.com
i
o Commencing in April of 20O2,the Canadian Medical Association's official iournal, the CMAL published a six-part serieson environment and health coveringthe proper way to take an exposurehistory
\ 1 1
(April 16), the effectsof outdoor pollution (April 30), recognizing and treating lead exposure(May 14), managementand prevention regardingpesticides(May 28), the health effectsof persistentorganic pollutants (lune 11), and understandingcarbon monoxide poisoning (lune 25). The authors are leading expertsin those areasand teach at Canada'smedical school. Most noteworthy is the fact that the referencesand researchsourcesprovided in those articleswere almost all also those Dr. Krop's defenselawyershad given to the cpso during his trial.s o In October 2003 the Ontario Collegeof Family Physicianshosted its first medical conferenceon EnvironmentalMedicine and participating
I-'ryq'*--
a 1 !
( t
1
D r .J . K r o p
IX
2::,. Gl ,l -.,
j::::l:jl:r::jl'jj::jl::::;lr:ijl:j.1j:jal:!j:!jr'.:l!rlttr::.::iirl
i
lF.,;
t}, ,!D,,ir:, it:,,,,i
physiciansreceivedfull continuing study credits from the Ontario
rt
Medical Association. r At the beginning of this year,Canada'sMinistry of Human Resources
rt
responded to requestsfor help from advocacygroups working with victims of Multiple Chemical Sensitivity (UCS). RAINET (Research, Advocacy.)approachedthe Minister, the Hon. JaneStewart and provided casehistories of individuals who were totally disabled by expo-
he
sure to certain toxic chemicals,but were denied CPP and other
llv,
applicable benefits solely on the basis of an MCS diagnosis.A review
n-
was initiated and MCS is now in the processof being included for CPP benefits.The core problem in the caseof Dr. Krop before the CPSOwas the diagnosis of MCS which was rejectedas being "scientifi-
es.
cally invalid" the same month, June 1999, when the international
ry
consensusstatementon MCS as a valid diagnosiswas published by the National Institutes of Health in the USA.6 o One of the treatmentsfor which the CPSO condemned Dr. Krop is a desensitizationprocedure for environmental and food allergies through the use of sub-lingual drops. (Seefootnote no. 1 for Internet accessto the CPSOdecision). In April 2002,4 months after the CPSO verdict, the World Health Organization published a report, based on the review by 3a internationally recruited allergists,stating that this
,ry
treatment should be consideredthe treatment of choice.T o The Ontario Human Rights Commission wrote in April of this year to Ontario's Minister of Health, the Hon. Tony Clement,instructing him
llc
that in the event of spraying for West Nile Virus being considered,the
rng
Minister has the obligation to protect people with chemical sensitivi-
.at
ties and to ensurethey receivemedical care if affectedby the spraying. The federal government made a similar statement.s o A few yearsago, the American PreventiveMedical Association (APMA)
rll
sued the Llnited StatedFood and Drug Administration (FDA) because
g
of that agenry'spersecutionof anybody making any health claims for I
vitamins and other neutraceuticals.The casewas decided in favor of
ng
the APMA, but in clear defianceof the court order, the FDA continued
*.'
|[ ;|' :l;r' i(*, ,= iGI.-
'. , iG,
.l.-,
:G
to harassdoctorsand neutraceuticalcompanies.This year in May, another court casewas decided once again in favor of the ApMA, and
wll
now the FDA obeyed the court. Health claims for all antioxidants (such asvitamins c and E), Folic Acid, variousfiber supplementsand
of
Saw Palmetto are now appearingon supplement bottles. In an abrupt turn-around only comparable to a conversion experience, one of the world's leading expertsin nutrition and health, BruceAmes of the university of california ar Berkeleypublished a comprehensive review article in April 2oo2 in which he assertsthat Linus pauling was right all along. coming from BruceAmes, that's a bit like the leader of the Alliance Party joining the NDp. shortly thereaft.er,the Iournal of the American Medical Associationpublished in Iune 2002 two arricles,
cot
serl cat
pat aII
("n sup ind thir
which conclude that everybodyneedsto take vitamin and mineral supplementsto prevent chronic disease,and that no diet provides
thir
enough of the nutrients neededfor basic good health and to prevent chronic illnesslater in life.e
an(
bel
one of the sectionsin Dr. Krop'sbook dealswith autism, its causes and treatment for which he provides the appropriate protocols. Due to
bei
the efforts of congressman Dan Burton in the uSA, whose grandson becameautistic after being vaccinatedfor Mumps Measlesand
abl,
Rubella, the vaccineindustry has been forced this spring to remove the offending mercury used as a preservativein vaccines.l0
byt cha anc gair rec(
AII thesedevelopmentsin such a short period of time led Dr. Iftop to observe "lf we wait long enough, they'll make intravenousvitamin c the iokingly,
on con
standardof treatmentfor SARS." While all theseshifts in understandingare very encouragingindeed, this is not the time for complacency.Nutritional and environmental medicine is
ofr
still under attackbecauseits claims, researchand successare a fundamental
trut
threat to the pharmaceuticaland pesticideindustry.As Comell University's ecologist and cancerexpert SandraSteingraberhas pointed out, the world's economy is "chemically addiCted",lrand that the health of the world is endangeredby nothing as much as by that "toxic trespass"l2committed
ha'
divi
Hel Kos Altc
Dr.J. Krop
xl
aitlajlt#t1.iaii.:L;t::::liiii:!..::t:ijti:+aii:!:tjaa:,1:;,a;ti1;tlr\:iitjr4ttlltlt!r.t:i..j.E:.ij7:r4r::t:ir:.::
without our knowledge,and often againstour will, by a chemical industry in consciousdisregardof the biological requirementsand biochemical integrity d
of humanity. Similarly, the drug industry's products are now due to their "side"-effects, consideredto be the second most frequent serious adverse
C€,
causeof death13.Clearly,we have a long way to go before doctors and patientsbecomefree from quick-fix delusions an
es
a matter of prevention, proper nutrition, and therapiesthat work withnature. The fact that a book such as this one sellswell and that all of the above
te
as
(and much more) is published by the mainstreammedical iournals, and
of
supported by standard national and international medical organizations, indicates that a big change is happening. People are taking charge and thinking critically.Fortunately,the Internet ensuresthat informhtion cannot
€S,
be buried as it usedto be and high-speedcommunication has createdsomething of a level playing field for health activists. Yet, there are many actions still ongoing which are of graveimportance and require our determined support. For example,the international battle being waged against CODEX, the international regulatory body controlled :to
by the pharmaceuticalcompanies;it seeksto make all neutraceuticalsavail-
1
able by prescription only. Another important and parallel cause is that championed by Canadian federal MPP Dr. f. Lunney'sand his courageous and timely effort (Bill C 420) which seeksto prevent Health Canada from
the
gaining control over food supplements;in view of Health Canada'strack record with regard to drug approval and its efforts to prevent information on food safetyfrom becoming publicly known, they certainly don't need to control neutraceuticals as well.la
:rye the
In antiquity it was believed that the source of medical knowledge was divine and that the ability to practicemedicine was a gift granted by the god
this re is
,a
of medicinehimself,Asklepios.By definition godsare immortal and divine
ntal
.
truth cannot be destroyedand, therefore,will once again make us free.
ity's 1d's
Helke Ferrie,Publisher
Cis
Kos Publishing Inc. o Bookson Medicinethat Works!
tted
Alton, Ontario, Canada
August2003
-, (' *: F.: C* :t
xtl
HEALIN TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e na tt a T i m e
CL
€ * F *;
ENDNOTES ' CPSO Decision on Dr. Krop, December23, 1998, available on their website: wuw.cDSo.on.ca 2 One of the best sources for information on the environmental component or cause of any diseaseis found in Enuironmentall{eabh Perspectiues, a medical journal published monthly by the National Institutesof Ilealth and FlarvardUniversity'sSchool of Public Health; availableon-line. t 'I-heMedical Post,May 13,2003. a 'fhe College of Physiciansand Surgeonsof Ontario reprimanded Dr. Carolyn Dean on April 29, 1993, based on a complaint filed by Sandra Marsden of the Sugar Institute of Canada; the complaint was filed, as stated in the admonishment document, because Dr. Dean had spoken about the dangersof refined sugar intake by diabeticson a television show aired on December11, 1990. The reprimandstates:"The respondentmade inaccurateand misleading statementsaddressinghealth issuesrelated to sugar and sugar substitutes... which tended to potentially arouseconcern in the viewing public . The Committze belieuesthe respondent expressedopinions which appearedto be exaggeratedwith respectto the relationship between " sugar and diabetes,infection, osteoporosis, hyperactiviryand addiction This amazing nonsense, unsupported by any published medical evidence, was signed by Dr. D.M.C. Walker, then the CPSO president and now the Dean of medicine at Queen's University in Kingston, Ontario. In her defence, prior to this admonishment, Dr. Dean had submitted more than 200 citations from the then current, standard, peer-reviewed medical literature on sugar and sugar substitutes upon which her remark on television had been based. This material is not even mentioned in the admonishment. s CMAI, Vol. 166, April 16 through !:une25,2002 6 Archiuesof EnvironmentalHeahh, vol. 54, No. 3, pp. 147-149, Iune 1999 7 See summary in ScientificAmerican,April 2O02,p.26, "Drink Your Shors" by B. Goodman d l,etter from the Ontario Human RightsCommission, dated April 16, 2003, signed by Chief Commissioner Keith C. Norton, addressedto the Hon.'Iony Clement, Ontario's Minister of Health; the legal basis cited is the Ontnrio Human RightsCode,Section 29 and the Policy and Guidelineson Disabilityand the Duty to Accommodate e The American Journalof Clinical Nutrition, April 2002 and lournal of the American Medical Association, Iune 19, 2002 ro lror a copy of my article on autism contact Vitality magazine at 416-964-0528; it provides the historical, legal and treatment information. See also Autism Canada Foundation, P.o. Ilox 1998, Burlington, onrario, L7R 4L8, call 905-332-4266or 905-331-4480,visit www.autismcanada.org. Dr. I. B radstreet'sinstitute can be reached via www.icdrc.org and www.autismresearchinstitute.com rr S. Steingraber,Living Downstream'. An L,cologistLooks at Cancer,2nded. 1999 r2 S. Steingraberin the upcoming documentary lf YouLove Our Children,sponsored by'l'he National Film Board of Canada. 'lhrcher-Putnam, lr f .S. Cohen Ouerdose:'Ihe Case Againstthe Drug , Companies, 2001. J. Robinson, PrescriptionCames,Mclelland & Stewart,'lbronto, 2001.1..1.Moore, Prescriptiont'or 'Ibuchstone L)isaster, Simon & Schuster,1998. I. Glenmullen, ProzacBachlash, llooks, 2000. Canadian Assoctaiori of University teachers,T-heOlivieri Report,Lorimer, 20021. r4'lb help stop the international efforts under the United nations' CODEX ALIMENIARIUS to restrictthe availability of vitamins and supplements,contact the worldwide effort being coordinated by Dr. Matthias Rath in Germany at www.4.dr-rath-foundation.org. In Canada, Dr. lames l,unney introduced Bill C 420 for the same purpose,to maintain freedom of choice for Canadians.'l'hebill is availableon www.parl.gc.ca/37/2parlbus/ chambus/house/bills/private/C-420l/C-420cover-E.html and you can contact your own MP and expressyour support for this bill
W
Dr.. AIth med poll treal (
nigh The hon I trav( toge disp wer( I and I rea as sl spac as di
t.
Preface
I am a citizen of the United State s " D r .Jo ze f K ro pi s a ci ti ze nof Canada. Although we may residein different countries,when it comes to health and medicine, our problems are the same. Both countries suffer from the same pollution, and from a similar Medical-Pharmaceutical monopoly in the n ief cy
treatment of disease. Severalyears ago, I spent the night at the home of a friend. That same night, Edgar Mitchell a former astronaut, also stayedat my friend's house. The next morning they were making a film in the front yard of my friend's home. Ed Mitchell sat beside a large globe of the world. He said,
"As
we were
traveling towards the moon, our crew of three realizedthat we had to work togetherwith our limited space,our limited resourcesand our limited waste disposal systemin that spaceshipif the flight was to be successfuland we n-
were to survive." He said, "l looked out that little window and saw that beautiful blue
r0.
and white ball we call Earth.Then a strangething happened.All of a sudden
; irg
I realizedthat that blue and white ball we call Earthwas a spaceshipjust as surely as was the one in which we were traveling. And it had lirnitetl space,limited resourcesand a limited waste disposal system iust as surely as did ours.
xlv
.!., ,,!}', :*._
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e na tt a T i m e HEALIN
.:rli 'c} : :i!l
,
,31 : ,,il!:,',
x
But whereasthe threeof us wereworking togetherto try to bring the flight the crewon spaceshipEarthwas not doing the same." through successfully,
,.1+, ;l*;|: .i::!tl!l:,
How right he was, aswe pollute our planet with insecticides,pesticides and manufacturedchemicalsof all types. We not only pollute our planet,we alsopollute our bodieswith cigarette
An thr an tio
smoke in our lungs; chemicalsin our clothing, furniture and carpets;mercury
to
in our teeth; and chemicalsand pollutants in the air we breathe,the water
or
we drink and the food we eat. When GeorgeWashinSon becameill, he was treatedwith bloodletting and mercury one of the most poisonous materialsknown. He died. Now we no longer treatpeoplewith mercury.We simply put it in people's
Alt
1i'
teeth, so that they can absorb this powerful poison day and night, whether
m(
they are sick or well.
m(
We no longer bleed cancerpatients.We simply inject into their blood a poison so strongthat patients'hair falls off, and those administeringit dare
thi
not get any of it on their skin.
to
Conventional medicine may not have changedthat much, but people
m(
havestartedto changesincethe time of GeorgeWashington. Peopleare also
sin
startingto rebel. Many of them are no longer willing to submit to the poi-
the
sonous treatments advocated by many conventional doctors. More and
sta
more peoplearebuying organicproduce,and more of them are buying bottled water to avoid the chlorine and poisonous fluoride added to the water by many water treatment plants. All through history sciencehas ridiculed and persecutedthose who have challengedthe prevailing beliefs and systems.we can thank God for the Calileosand the Darwins.And yes,we can thank God for Iozef Krop and other courageousindividuals who are willing to challengerhe system. Todaythe practiceof toxic medicine is evenmore entrenchedthan at the time of GeorgeWashington.Billions and billions of dollars of profits are ar stake.It is alreadyobvious that this powerfirl monopoly will do whateverit has to do to protect its turf and profits.
har.-
*
Y_
**wr,***tr,***-r****"********),)),),)))rr:
But all through history in the final analysis,the people have prevailed. And now a revolution has begUn. People are starting to take command of
rt
their health with decisionson the food, water and air they consume.More and more are refusing the toxic treatments frequently prescribed by conven-
CS
ry
tional doctors.And more and more they want to learn for themselveshow to keep healthy and avoid toxicity, whether it comes from the environment
er
or is administeredby a doctor.
18
That is why this book and the life and work of JoeKrop are so important. Although attacked and scorned by the medical-pharmaceuticalmonopoly
te
with their toxic treatrnents, foe Krop has refused to buckle. This book is a step into the present for those who think their health is
3'S
more important than the income and profits of a medical-pharmaceutical
Lef
monopoly.
tre
I am thanld-ll to God for people like Ioe Krop and for books such as this. I urge those who wish to remain healthy or recoverif they become ill
r le
to read and study this book and to become part of this revolutionary movement that is finally starting to take place. It has been over tlvo hundred years
la
ri-
since the death of GeorgeWashington. It is about time that we recognize that the consumption of chemicals,toxins and poisons is not the way to
nd
stay healthy or become healthy.
so
ctter
\i
BerkleyBedell
I
:, ii i.
lve
.he nd -he :at rit
,
,$
L
Former US Congressman Founder,National Foundation for Alternative Medicine.
XVI
O:N EP A t i E NAtt A T i M C H E A L I NTGH EP L A N E T
This bookis dedicatedto my children, Ioanna,Iessica,Adam and Andrew, as well as to all the childrenof the world, bornand yet to bebornt0 protectthemfrom the insidiouspollutants0f this world.
Wffffi#j
W
"Aboueall, do no harm." "Meilicine is not a sciencebut an art." "Eueryiliseasehas its own nature and arises
Itis, book the e
from an external carrse."
begar
"Let
cially
food be your meilicine." (c460-c377B.C.) Hippocrates
"To understandthe man we haueto understandhis world, the enuironmenthe liuesin." -Aristotle (c384-c 322B.C.) "The doctor of the future will giue no medicine but will interest his patientsin the core of the humon frame, in diet ond in the cause and preuentionof disease." ' -Thomas (18471931) A.Edison "Setrch for the cure within the cause; the body itself is the bestheoler." -Plato(c429-c 347B.C.)
ously to for term NYe prob becar and r V upor with and epidt w hi c contl
Foreword
1.
It is a great honourfor me to prepare a foreword for this groundbreaking book by Dr. Krop. I first became acutely awareof the catastrophiceffect of the environment on community health when the tragedyof the Love Canal beganto unfold at NiagaraFalls,New York.This toxic wastedump was offi"disaster area"for pollution. Simultanecially recognizedas America'sfirst ously,we saw the severecongenital deformities and diseasesin babies born to former University of Buffalo students,who had been enticedto take shortterm jobs at the WestValley Nuclear Reprocessingfacility south of Buffalo, NY, exposingthem to high dosesof nuclear radiation. Although the health problem generatedby WestValley were never officially admitted, the site becamethe first demonstrationsite in the United Statesfor nuclearcleanup and radioactivewastestabilization. We,at RoswellParkMemorial Institute,in Buffalo, New York,were called upon to help thesetwo communities in trauma. Both community groups, with environmentallycausedhealth problems,had self-identifiedtheir plight and the likely cause.Dr. Beverly Paigen,a toxicologist, and mysell an epidemiologist,tried to help the communities officially document the truths which they knew through their own observations.We had no idea how controversialsuch health assessment and professionalassistance would be!
L
The spectreof lawsuits against the polluters rose up at every turn, and no
cial
healthassessment or sensibleepidemiologicalsurveyat either placewas ever
mot
permitted.The barriersto understandingthesephenomenavaried from
ing I
cuttingout any interviewing or clinical components of retrospectivestudies,
norl
demandingdata to be based on publically collected (inadequate)vital
l
statisticsto actually closing the Environmental Health Division of the Erie
ped
County Health Department,which was preparinga detailedepidemiological
addi
survey.
pl i n
While I spent nine yearsstudying the impact of ordinary diagnostic X-
sent
ray exposureon the health of a very large population followed over three
pror
years (The Tri-State Leukemia Survey), I had discovered that the whole
new
questionof exposureof the public to ionizing radiation had been relegated
the
to the expertiseof the physicistsof the Manhattan proiect (which built the
sion
first nuclear bombs), and that it was these military participants who gave
ther
nuclear industries radiation standards which allow for routine radio
1
nuclide emissionsto the environment, and set worker standardsquite high
mur
relativeto observedmedical problems. Then I found that physiciansaccepted
tion
the standardsset by the military during atmosphericweapon testing as the
and
appropriatestandardsfor the hospital and radiology laboratories.In fact,
han,
many radiologists opposed releasing information on the harm of diag-
tion
nostic X-raysbecausethey were afraid that the public would refuseneeded
drot
X-rays,making their work more difficult. Eventually I found that many
tern
other hazardsto the public had the samemilitary origin and were protected
path
with the similar fears and secrecy.
fragr
Currentlythere is much concern about pesticidesand organic com-
oth€
poundswhich mimic the effectsof hormones.Thesederivehistorically from
can
the large-scale separationof chlorine gasfor military use in World War I,
duri
and the subsequentmilitary production of chlorinated compounds, both
ont
organicand inorganic, culminating in the Agent Orangewidely dispersedin
I
Viet Nam. One of thesechlorine compoundswas chloroform, which found
are I
an early medical use as an anaesthetic,but was soon abandonedwhen
chil,
it was found to causeliver damage.Carbon tetrachloride is another artifi-
adul
D r .J . K r o p XIX
/et
cial chemical introduced,which we now trying to rid ourselvesof by pro"green The organicchlorides,includdry cleaning"establishments. moting
rm
ing many pesticides,arenow ubiquitous around the world, and many disrupt
€S,
normal hormonal functions.
10
tal
It is not surprisingthat thoughtful and intelligent physicians,especially
rie
pediatricians,would seethe results of these and so many other reckless
cal
additions of hazardoussubstancesto the biosphere.Dr. Krop is to be complimented on being open to learningnew waysof dealingwith patientspre-
x-
senting with damagefrom theseexposures.All university training claims to
ree
promote a goal of lifetime learning, but few graduatesexcel in pioneering
rle
new fields of research.Dr. Krop is also to be commended for standing up for
:ed
the truth he has found, in spite of the many serious attackson his profes-
he
sional conduct from those who are not open to what is happening around
lve
them and the new challengesto the traditional art and scienceof medicine.
lio
lVe can expectmany more challenging situations for human and com-
igh
munity health to resultfrom global warming, changesin land use,popula-
ted
tion growth, migration, modern forms of war, drug use, international trade
the
and commerce,technological changes,new \,!'aysto processfood, livestock
rct,
handling, organ transplants,microbial changes,and breakdown in sanita-
ag-
tion, vaccination and insect control. Extreme weather events, such as
led
drought followed by torrential rain, can be expectedto changesurvival pat-
rny
terns of both mosquitos and birds, and affect the life cycle of many
ted
pathogens.Social and human activitiesbring us into more contact with fragmentsof forest,and increasethe incidenceof Lyme diseaseand perhaps
rm-
other pathogenswhich we do not now expect.The climate warming trend
om
can mean survivalof many pathogenswhich were previously killed ol1"
rr I,
during the winter. Who then, exceptthe EnvironmentalPhysicians,will be
oth
on the alert for new manifestations.ofillnesseswith unfamiliar symptoms.?
lin
EnvironmentalHealth is not iust a branchof occupationalhealth.There
rnd
areno children in the workplace.Chronic low-dose24-hour exposuresol
len
children or the elderly are biologically and biochemicallydifferent from
rifi-
adult male higher occupationalexposuresfor eight hours a day,followed by
a 16-hour respite.And then we have a toxic "soup" not seenin the limited environment of the workplace,where hazardscan be counted and monitored. Production agentsin the workplace cost money, and so tend to be conserved.Any delving into the irresponsibleabandonmentof multiple forms of hazardouspollution in the living spacewill lead the prudent government regulatorsto welcome and facilitate the work of Environmental Physicians. The road aheadwill not be easy.In the struggle 150 yearsago to understand germs, no one was standing there saying: "lt is not My germs causing the trouble." There were no lawsuits around the corner of every finding.
w
Hazardous chemical materials in the environment are just as invisible as germs,and researchinto their action in the body no more complex than was the sorting out of pathogens which causedidentifiable diseases.However, this researchmust be seriously undertaken!
Th
The struggleagainstharmful environmental hazardsand pathogenshas
ca'
iust begun. The work of Dr. Krop is welcomed by all of us who have opened our eyesto the culrent suffering and the future potential of all of the changes
lTlt mr
and human interventionsin our living spacewith its vital air, water and food.
str ric
RosalieBertell,PhD
Dz
International Institute of Concern for public Health Toronto, CANADA
wi ge!
He inr en La' rhi
dflt
nar the ign
i
f..,.
.ed )nbe ms
Acknowledgement
ent .ns. lering ng. ras 'VAS
ver, "Ecology Guide," a handbook, a simple eduThisbook beganas a practical
has
cational tool for my patients, soon after I startedto practiceenvironmental
ned
medicine. A great deal of thanks must go to past and current members of
rges
my staff, who put enormous effort into helping educatepatients in their
rod.
struggleto improve health, gatheredinformation and helped arrangeever richer versions into a reader-friendlyformat. Theseinclude Wanda Wilson, Darlene Koski, Dawn Betts, Virginia Anderson, and Maureen Bot. I also "angels,"Andrew Pompa, who first sugwish to thank one of my many gestedthat the guide should be published as a book for wider distribution. "arrgel,"was able to realize that idea, as well as make Helke Ferrie,another invaluable suggestions,reviewing editing, recommending referencesand encouraging me tirelessly in all things. Thanks to everyone at Heidy LawranceAssociates,as well as to Simone Gabbay,for helping to produce this book in short order. I am indebted to RosalieBertell,whom I have known for many years, and with whom I worked togetheron two projectsassociatedwith the International Institute of Concern for Public Health, for her input and review of the pieceon nuclearradiation, an areaabout which most of us arewoefully ignorant. Thank you to former CongressmanBerkleyBedell, whose efforts,
E
T g__
iG ll |i+:
f.l ii'
,lEl'
,,(l ,::x;, ':. t-, 't-
with Senator'fom Harkin, led to the creation of the Office of Alternative Medicine at the US National Institutesof Health. A very specialexpressionof gratitude to the many wonderfrrl colleagues I have met over the yearsat the American Academy of Environmental Medicine, in particular physician mentors and now friends, Drs. John Maclennan and Iohn Gerrard of Canada,aswell as Drs. Frank Waickman, Bill Rea, Iohn Boyles,Charlie Hinshaw Denis Remington,Doris Rappof the US, and especiallythe late Drs. Theron Randolph and Larry Dickie true pioneers in
ffi
the field. Prof. Lynn Trainor, physicist and dear friend, has been a pillar of support offering insight from the beginning, as have Drs. Lynn Marshall, William La\ralley,Gerry Ross,and Roy.Fox. For their unflagging support over the past decade,I am grateful to:
wl
Helma Trass,Pat and Bruce Houghton, Diana Tus4mski, Audrey Sillick and
"lr
Rena Singer-Gordon of the Environmental Health Group; Eleanor lohnston, Bruce Lofquist and Don McNicol of Citizens for Choice in Health
firr
Care;fudy Spenceof EISC;Harold Dickert, Bob Fenie Maria French,Robert
im
McMaster,Alex and LeslieTrass,SiegfriedGurscheand Rhody Lake of Aliue
tur
Magazine;Julia Woodford of Vitality Magazine;Libby Gardon of Consumer
cer
Health Organizationof Canada.Thereare many others whose names may not
na
be mentioned here,but for whose support I am neverthel€ssmost grateful.
gI€
Thank you to my parents,simple and humble farmers,from whom I
chi
learned hard work, perseverance,and to appreciatethe bounty of this good
pal
earth. Finally, thank you to my wife and closestfriend of thirty years,Eliza-
esc
beth, for standing beside,behind and sometimesin front of me in all my
Ou
struggles,and for correcting everything I ever wrote in English.
de' col
ser in cul ver
;1 h
fuo,,...,,.
VC
res :drn?4,
Introduction
nd in of rll, to: nd
I SEI M P O R T A N T W H YT H I SM E D I C I N
In-
"ln the middleof the tw'entiethcentury,we saw our planet from spacefor the
Ith
first time. Historians may eventually find that this vision had a greater
ert 'iue
irnpact on thought than did the Copernicanrevolution of the sixeenth century, which upset the human self-imageby revealingthat the earth is not the
ner
centerof the universe.From space,we see a small and fragile ball domi-
rot
nated not by human activity and edifice,but by patternsof clouds, oceans,
ul.
greenery and soils. Humanity's inability to fit its doings into that pattern is
n l
changing planetary systemsfundamentally. Many such changesare accom-
'od
panied by life-threateninghazards.This new reality,from which there is no
za-
escape,must be recognized-and managed."l
rny
This is the opening statementfrom the Brundtland Commission'sreport, Our Common Future, the world commission report on environment and developmentpublishedin 1987.All the nations of the world presentedtheir concernsto this commission. I was among those who spoke as one representativefrom Canadaon behalf of medicine.I spokebeforethe commjssion in 1985 about my fears as a doctor, namely that "we discussforests,agricultural land, plant and animal life, but virtually ignore the real threat to the very existenceof the human species."2
2;;,it:,,
(s.,,:ri +,.:.:l',, l+ {t '3,,l; c:l,r., g,;ii. ftl.',,,i'. P r 7,;, di!!!i'
TH HEALIN G EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e na tt a T i m e
I1 1985,thosewerestrongwords;today,neitherscientistsnor politicians of our situation. Indeed,the future of the human can deny the seriousness
abou
raceis most clearlyvisible in our children. How threatenedour future is becomesclear when contemplating iust three instancesamong the many
incre
disturbing known facts: o since 1950,the human sperm count in the industrial world has gone
almo
primarily due to the sudden increasein pesticide use.3 down by 50o/o, o Over the last decade,cancerin children has increasedby 200%o,also primarily due to pesticideuse.a
illnes
rONIT
coul< toaI E polit
. Studiesfollowing severalgenerationsof children over two decadeshave shown that pregnantmothers exposedto low dosesof pesticidesgive
to th
birth to children with irreversibleand profound intellectual deficits.s
histo
menl not (
In 1996,Theo Colborn'sOur StolenFuture6was published,with a foreword by then Vice-PresidentAl Gore, providing the whole range of scientific evi-
hum
dence of this threat to human survival. In 1997, then US PresidentClinton issued an executiveorder in which he officially recognizedthe scientific "a basisfor this threat and ordered as high priority" that pesticidesand all "environmental endocrine-disrupting substancesbe identified and that all
hum
A long list of specificsfollowed, health risks affectingchildren" be assessed.T which resulted in all pesticidesbeing brought under review,and some were
Our
taken out of circulationwithin months, otherswill no longer be produced, again others can only be used in low concentrations.Becauseof their dif-
histc
ferent metabolisms,children are especiallyvulnerableto the effectsof such toxins. ln 2002, Canada'sfederal Health Minister incorporated the same
on tl
protections for children in the new PestControl ProductsAct. Many mote
a cri
initiatives,involving people at everystageof life, areunderwaythroughout the world, among them environmentaland orthomolecularmedicine.
a lar
Environmentalmedicine treatsthose recentlyarisenillnessescausedby the contamination of air, water,and soil, and by food that is depletedof
Ract
nutrients and contaminatedby toxic additives.Thesenew illnesses,such as Sick Building Syndromeand Multiple Chemical Sensitivity,have also come
amc
to trt chan trac€ inter proli I ano
new fun< one.
D r .J . K r o p
IS
.n
is ry
about through unhealthy workplacesand home environments.Well-known illnesses,such as cancer,asthma, diabetesand autoimmune disordershave increasedto epidemic levels for the same reasons.The hallmark of environmentally mediated illness is that it appearsat first totally mysterious,but almost alwaysyields to a very simple explanation. It would be nice if one could add that these kinds of patients are a small minority. The fact is that, to a greateror lesserdegree,this describesall of us. Environmental medicine, Iike all good medicine, has an inescapable "uery simple explanation" points always political component becausethat
TC
to the need for public action, political intervention, and the acknowledgement that we are almost alwaysthe authors of our own misfortunes. The history of public health'measuressupports this statement.Angry gods do not capriciously visit illness upon us. There is a rational explanation for
rd vicn fic all tal
human illness.We can understandthe causesand we can respondintelligently to treat and prevent illness. How totally human health is dependent upon human behavior, nutritional choices,and anthropogenic environmental changescan be learned from the researchin medical anthropology, which tracesthe origin and history of disease.This researchhas shown that this interdependent processcan be traced back all the way into the paleolithic.
3re
Our current problems with cancerand chronic disease,causedby the sudden proliferation of toxic chemicals,is but the latest dramatic chapter in a long
ed,
history.8
tif-
In the past,toxicology (which is an exactsciencelike physics)was based "the dose makesthe poison," meaningthat most substances on the dictum
3d,
rch me ore
an organismencounteredwere benign and becametoxic only when reaching a critical strength.A tiny amount of poison, it was thought, was no problem;
the
a largeamount would kill you. Followingthe introduction of some 600,000 new syntheticchemicalssinceWorld War II, and the classicresearchby
by
Rachel Carsone and other scientists,the principles of toxicology have fundamentally changed.We now know that frequent exposuresto small
lof ras me
amounts of toxins oft.enhave much more seriousand deadly effectsthan a one-time big exposure.Tiny amounts of formaldehyde seeping into your
l:r :.':l': :, , i::.','i,:il: :;r:;,,:.iiEl: '::'i:",i:;,i::llli 'i,i',.iiNllj ,,:':,,iiit9: :+i;t:ii,ti .' :;'::lirl:fr,t ,.l,ilD. ,,t,i#, ';r,ir,la-,
:ii;1fi:nalr:i: llirllii
,:tii.#,
HEALIN TG H EP L A N EOTn: eP a t i e na tt a T i m e
home environment through insulation materialsand furniture can ruin the lives of the entire family. The daily low-dosevapor of mercury coming from your "silverl' amalgam tooth fillings can give you Alzheimer's diseaseyears later.r0A low-dose exposureto pesticides,or walking barefoot on pressure-
oE,
pt tl,
treated wood during the critical early period of pregnancy,may causeyour baby to be born with serious central nervous systemdefects.s,ttThese are
ONE
iust three examples.Therefore:
Wher
o Environmental meilicine is the clinical application of modern toxicology.l2 o Environmentalmeilicine is the clinical applicationof environmental biochemistry. o Environmenuil doctors find the environmental sourcesof diseaseand deuelopnon-toxic treatmentsand strategiesfor prevention. o Environmental physiciansusestanilard medical drugsuheneuer aryro-
autor he or ances of int their lister
priate, but usually only as emergencymeasuresbecauseof the known tolcicityof synthetic drugs; theyfauour biocompatibletherapies,provide
ulatir
the patient with the knowleilge of how to control the personol enuiron-
requ.
ment, cure the condition, or, at the uery least,stabilizesymptoms.ls
beinl
Environmental medicine worhs on solutionstn general problems in
stand
medicine,such as antibiotic resistanceand how to treat bamrial infeaiorc in patien* who cannot tolerateantibiotics.
charr
Enuironmental medicine is not so much interestedin categorizing a group of symptoms(i.e., o "diagnosis"for which a pharmaceutical agent
v
gene
ated of cri
is then usually targeted) as it is in assessing and correcting the numerousfactors which haue led an individual to feel pain, weahness,iliscom-
medi
fort or disability, which are the definitions of illness,the reuersalor alleuiation of which is the goal of medicine.
prod basis
Becauseof its critical attitude, enuironmental medicineis especiallyintcr-
mys€
estedin loohing at well-known iliseasessuch as arthritis, inflammatory bowel conditions,and autoimmune illnessesand often finds causesneuer
yourr
beforesuspected-such as mycoplasmabacteria, which can cause classic
a
lupus erythematosis,arthritis and sclerodermaand are treatable by new,
2. I
and often dramatically successful,protocolsusing standard antibiotics.
self i
7.L
d
D r .J . K r o p
:2t,:':r,':l:.:.::t .'i.:.i ,.ltr :..i.,:r F , . , ' .i::.:1,:r: :.,i', 'liJ; lt,!!}j,i::iiir,!,iil!:i .',:f|l'':,,:,.,j.:tr ,.(}.:.ij' ::i:.
.he
. Enuironmentnlmedicineis also an international social mouement,because
)m
physicianspracticing it feel it is their inescapableresponsibilityto demand that the worlil should becomeonceagain fit for peopleto liue in.
ars te-
)ur are
REBELLION FOREVERY.DAY PRESCRIPTION ONEDOCTOR'S When you decide to take chargeof your health, you stop functioning on
12
automatic piiot. You no longer blindly trust your doctor becauseyou suspect he or she can't know everything,either; you doubt the government'sassuranceson health matters becauseit is the nature of power to be in conflicts of interest;you question the advertisementson drugsbecauseyou realizethat their aim is to sell drugs and not to cure you and thus lose a customer.laYou listen to your body becauseit knows best; you are not a statistic or a population average,but a unique person with an individual genetic endowment and a very personal health history requiring personalizedattention.rsThe health careindustry being as gearedto massproduction asthe car industry,understandably finds that an inconvenience. Living things are
,ru
characterizedby diversity; even our sufferings are not created equal. Without the birth of fundamental doubt and the growth
,nt
of critical thinking health is not possible, nor is advancein medicine. Doubt is the beginning of the cure.Trusting your-
a-
I would consider the effort of self is the first step on the road to recovery.16 producing this book well worth it if it causesyou to check for yourself the basis for the claims the health industry and doctors make (including
er-
myself!).That is why I hope this book will enableyou to do two things for
v
yourself and your loved ones:
er ic W,
7. Learn that your enuironmentcausesor triggersspecifichealth problems anil what you can do to treat such problemsand preuentthem. 2. Haue scientificanil clinical ammunition with which to approachyour doctors n help educatethem.
rgl,r,li.i
.,,,:71i.i'rrii.i ;'ii ;r',,ii'.,:l rllij
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e na tt a T i m e HEALIN
;,;:0.&ir,:,:::,,,:, ll' : .:,:*,.i
,,,1*,:,,. ' :IJ 5 ,tl ,:
at)t:r&..at:i::a:.:,:::,),1:i::+..i.;:1r1,:tt::!!+:ta,).,:t:t:t.:atttr:t!at:j:ji;44/jiiti,iiAalril/t:jji,:ttjijLjJt!,;rjt;.ri;i,;lt;.+:rr:;
,,,F,itl't,,, :,i#::,;i::,jt: ,,,,i[#;:i!tii:i 'ti:i*t:t:i::tiiti:i:
We need to know that human beings on planet earth are like fish in a tank
of
of finite dimensions.As the Greekmasterphysician,Hippocrates,taught
of the
2,500 yearsago, our health is determined by the air we breathe,the food
dialog
we eat, the soil in which we grow it, the water we drink, and the way we feel
got on
and behavetowards others.All illness and all health is ultimately a func-
Th
tion of our physical and emotional environment. Even most genetically mediated illnesses are triggered by unhealthy environments and are ultimately preventable.
HOW
Second,modern medicine ecology and biochemistry have provided us
Iwast
with the answersto the prevention of illness.Medical sciencehas gone well
enoug
beyond telling us not to smoke. We now know that we have . wHENvou No
to break the lethal dependenceon toxic chemicalsnot only in
Stalin' "equa.
INDIY LONGERi::ts
ourselves,but also for our lawns,our agriculturalpractices,and
"auth<
f6fiow *ov,rcr,.
our industrial economy.We can prevent cancer,heart disease,
thing
auiri*c,noi,,rn
diabetes,arthritis, and many more illnesses.What's more, we
mothr
:
very often evencure theseillnesses.To foster .,.t*tCitttd*!. , . can improve and '$nCtt,.F.d* your healthy doubt, t have provided an extensivebibliography, ,,,, VCft iii i*; researchand treatment resources,and even information on
made.
.r*on*EULE,, sdt Urtois, YoU
how doctorscan obtain training in environmental medicine.
wand,
When you no longer blindly follow advice,but engagein
W
rie AtSO:,BfCflt
a critical searchfor verifiable and workable solutions, you also
of 4o
14,9xoF,,snVlNc, begin the task of saving planet earth and human life. Like a PLANET EARTH stone thrown into a pool, (he stone is small, but the ripples go
the fe
Icans annot
right,
ANDHUMAN
on and on, coveringimmense distancesfor a very long time.
ment,
LIFE.
In fact, what you actually do is to become politically engaged
dolog
on behalf of life itselfwhen you assumeresponsibilityfor what
this b
you eat and drink, what you permit to be in your surroundings, and what
wherr
you will exposeothers to. You begin to make choicesthat have an effect on
took
everythingaround you: your supermarket,your pharmary,your local school,
with
your garbagedisposal,the way you furnish your home, the recreationsyou
from
pursue, the car you buy, the information you spread among your friends
T
and relatives.
medi
Dr.J. Krop
,.;2..,.,;:tt.,
:.,(D,,,,:.,, . ,, 'i ,rit, t,lii.:i!::.
lii' :t::,.t111!...i:.r'. "r'rat! :
:,lr,.:,:,,t! tl,.:l ':.,ij'lti:;:ir:1jri : i j:
i:';,Il:,,1'r, :,.:.'.:., , l:Itli.l':.':rl,i,:. ::
Of course,you will alwaysact on incompleteinformation (we all do, all of the time), but if you are in chargeand engageyour doctor in a critical dialogue and partnership,the result will alwaysbe better than whateveryou
tank ught food : feel 'unc-
got on automaticPilot. The truth does make us free.
cally I are
NH TY AS L ICIAN I B E C A MAENE N V I R O N M EP HOW I was bom in Poland and grewup on a farm. My family was poor, but we had enough to eat.As a child, I observedthe brutalities of the Communist regirne.
:d us well
, and
Stalin'sSovietUnion, which controlled Poland like a colony, ensuredsocial "equality" in many cruel anclabsurdways.When I was still a young boy, the "authorities" walked into our old farm house one day and removed every-
ease,
thing we owned-not
have ly in
a stick of furniture was left, and they even took rny mother's foot-treadle sewing machine, on which most of our clothes wete
3, We
made.The reasonsfor this action are as mysterioustoday as they were then. "Papa" Stalin in 1953. Loudspeakersin cars I can still rememberthe death of
oster rphy,
announced his death everywhere.T'hetraffic stopped as if touched by a magic wand, and all pedestriansstood to attention, as did I. I was nine yearsold.
non cine.
When I was fourteen, I contractedthe Asiatic Flu and had a temperature of 40 degreesCelsius for severaldays.I recovered,but only temporarily, as the fever kept returning. The doctor assuredmy mother that I would be all
ge in also ike a
right, but a mother's instinct often tends to be superior to a doctor's iudgement, and she took me to a homeopath. FIehappenedto be trained in iri"There is something wrong with dology. He looked into my eyesand said, this boy's left lung." My mother took me at once to a tuberculosishospital,
3sgo .ime. aged what :t on
where the diagnosisof pulmonary tuberculosiswas confirmed. The recovery took the better part of ayeat,and during that time, I becamevery impressed
lool,
with the doctors who took careof me. I promised myself that, if I recovered
,you
from this illness, I would become a doctor.
ends
The ancient Greeks believed that the prerequisite for the practice of medicinewas the experienceof illness.The god of medicine,Asclepios,was
what
a.a
g I
L_
1,:,'.;l|!);;,.,,,,,, I :: ::E: ;ii:i:":i:: t:.r:l ,lr..H,t.,it:.,,,'n ;,,1,;f,;;:r',;,,,,,, .!1lir.lt
:r:ii! i:.:ri'irl
gt:i:;: !,iii.ltl:iji
HEALIN TG H EP L A N T T : 0Pnaet i e na t a T i m e
::|::::*a:i::
i;,i:,}ltt,,1,, !r:l(p::::::.
..,,.ll,. ,..Cl ,', .iii(}.:,;:: Xi;Gi,l. ,il.l?,:i,l .iiiifi.lir i::li::!*::::;
known as the "wounded healer,"becausehe had been struck by lightning
about
and limped as a result.This prerequisitese€msto hold true today especially
astonis
for practitioners of environmental medicine. A medical iournalist recently told me that a surveyof the attending doctors at a recentAmericanAcademy
men's l
of EnvironmentalMedicineconvention showedthat most of them had them-
time, h
selvesbeen seriouslyill (or had a family member fall ill) with an environ-
didn't
mentally-mediatedcondition for which their standard medical training
late," h
had not preparedthem.
the de,
me an(
In medical school, I soon discoveredthat nothing in life, leastof all sci-
resear(
ence,was free from the contamination of politics. University studentswere
puttinl
made to be part of the extensivespy systemthrough which the Communist
more (
regimessupported their power. Studentswere expectedto spy on their professorsand report back to the Party on aryrthing and everything "suspi-
was n(
cious." To my horror, my favourite professor,who taught pediatrics,was
In
out of
assignedto me for surveillancewhen I becamean assistantin pediatrics
Saskat
during my residency.The resultingemotional conflia was totally unbearable,
ity, I u
and one day I decidedI could not and would not do this, no matter what
three r
the consequences. I went straightto my professorand told him what I had been askedto do and that I would not do it. To my total surprise(and immeasurablerelie0, -y professorsmiled and said, "Oh, I know. I have known all along." That wasthe end of my involvement in the political spying
less tt
business,and I somehowcoastedthrough universitypolitics in Communist
funda
Polanduntil 1972,when I completedmy medicalspecializationin pediatrics -and escapedto Canada.
were I
disord quiliz, B')' z
l r
What precipitatedthis decisionto escapewas the following evenr.Early
medi<
on in my pediatrictraining,in the early 1970s,I becameinterestedin growth
trainir
hormone researchthat had begun in the 1950sand which eventuallyled to
Saska
its syntheticform. As I was a young pediatrician,the practicalimportance of this researchfor children whose growth is stunted,was clear.My first
dard ;
co-publicationsin peer-reviewed medicaljournalsdealwith growthhormone.
dram
I was in the universitylab often sevendaysa week till the wee hours in the morning. One day I was working in the lab with a closefriend of mine at
interr
descri
comp
I
i.
.fu*"*
--
D r .J . K r o p
:ning :ially ently demy nemironning I sciwere
about midnight, when we heard footsteps in the hall. To my speechless astonishment,my friend urged me to disappearas fast as possible into the rnen'sroom and staythere until he would come to fetch me. I did as he told me and waited, wondering what this could possiblybe all about. After some "What happened?"I asked."Oh, I time, he told me I could come out now. didn't want the head of the department to seeyou once again in the lab so late,"he replied. Then I found out-and this was confirmed by others-that the department had become increasinglyirritated with my enthusiasrnfor "slow down Krop," as my performancewas The word was out to reSearch. putting demandson the other departrnentmembersthat interferedwith their
pro'
more comfortable pace.Any serioushint of a desirefor personal excellence was not encouragedin a collectivizedsociety.That night, I knew I had to get
uspi-
out of Communist Poland.
unist
was rtrics able,
In Canada,I neededto re-qualiff. I was able to obtain an internship at SaskatoonCity Hospital,where t worked from 1975 to 1976. By serendipity, I was assignedto Dr. Abram Hoffer for my rotation in psychiatry.Those
had
three months totally transformed my approachto medicine. It was nothing lessthan a revolution for me. I-IereI saw people with severepsychiatric
Iand have
disorders being hospitalized and Dr. Hoffer-instead of prescribing tranquilizers and various psychotropicmedication-gave them niacin (vitamin
rying rnist
Br), zinc and various other vitamins and minerals,as well as prescribing fundamental dtanges in their diets.17Their delusions disappeared,and they
rtrics
were returned to a normal life.
larly
I could not believe it! Here I saw for the first time orthomolecular medicine in action-a branch of medicine I knew nothing about. All my
)wth
training in Poland, then later at Sick Children's Hospital in Toronto, and in
:d to
Saskatoon,up to this point, had been radically different and followed standard allopathic medicine. Dr. Hoffer also kept detailed patient charts.f'he
what
ance first one. r the re at
descriptionsof the patient'scondition before and after treatment were very dramatic. His resultswere terrific, but he never pushed anything on his interns.It was simply through observationthat one's eyeswere opened to completelynew possibilitiesin medicine.At the end of my internshipwith
,3 ',,(i , .1.5:
l''1.-.,i i'iiil ' ;',il:| =t : .i:llD',r. ::i:ffi:::t i:,.}h,,r,' ililE.ri: :'ii.lii',,ir
l0
H E A L I NTG H EP L A N E T : Opnaet i e nat t a T i m e
him, I askedhim how I could learn more about orthomolecularmedicine. "well, if you are interested,"he said in his typical low-key manner, ,,thereare
ordinar
somebooks I would suggest."And so I beganto read the work, among others,
differer
of Drs. H.L. Newbold, Carl C. Pfeifferand Linus pauling.rB
(as ther
ular ha'
After startingmy own practicein 1977,I applied orthomolecularprinciples with great successfor some time. However,I began to notice that some
to undr
patientsdid not respondwell enough.vitamins, minerals and diet were
The no
simply not enough.
atric"the offt
In 1979,one of my patientsmentioned to me that therewas a doctor in Hamilton, ontario, who treated asthma successfully,not with steroids,but
treatinl
with sublingual desensitizationdrops.That was Dr. GeorgeJohn Maclennan.
the offe
He was one of the foundersof the society for clinical Ecology,now known as the American Academyof Enuironmentnl Medicine (AAEM), the study of
dard rn
which began with Dr. Theron Randolph of chicago university in the 1940s.leTheir observationsand initial researchlaid a foundation through
killing
which environmental medicine spread throughout the world and became part of modern medical research.Dr. Mclennan suggestedthat I attend the
ronmer
upcoming annual conference, which I did. At that conference,I was exposed to a new perspectiveon health and health problems and to the most gen-
Le76).
etous and genuine physiciansI had ever met. At that conference,I also saw a videotape of provocation-neutralizationtesting for food sensitivitiesdone in Dr. Doris Rapp'smedicaloffice.2o Dr. Rapp was testinga child for food sensitivities,and when she tested for oats,the child had a dramaticreaction.This food actuallyhad a neurotoxic effectand the child beganto screamand thrash about. when Dr. Rapp finally establishedand administeredthe neutralizingdose,the child rapidly and totally recovered.Then Dr. Rapp askedthe patient, ,,Do you remember anything that happenedduring the pasr two hours?"The child, genuinely bewildered,said, "No, I don't."
revolut
control Iw, Dickie and lai this." I tion to to war medici back." ial infe learnec medici and try Itv
well, at that point I got goosebumpsand I knew deep down and with_ out any doubt, that this wasthe medicine I had to practice.WhateverI had
and nt
learnedin standardmedicinedid not evenconsiderthe neurotoxicitvof
Harri.
annual
7
D r .J . K r o p
1l
:.!i::rai;tai;ar:ait::!:;i:i::!ailrai:l!t\a,:i:ai:t7!;ttt;i:Ltar,a,iia:tl:til:tt:,lt:i:ia:ll
icine. re are thers, rincisome
ordinary foods-l had only been taught about IgE mediatedallergies(regular hay feverand the like). What I had iust seenwas somethingcompletely different, and even if the biological pathwayswere not yet fully understood (as they are in the caseof lgE-mediatedallergies),here was the opportunity "psychito understand and treat conditions otherwise simply discardedas atric"-unfair to psychiatryand brutally negleaful of the patient'sreal needs.
were
The notion that such reactionscould be treated with neutralizing doses of the offending substance,rather than with symptom-controlling drugs, was
lor in
revolutionary.What's more, the sameapproach,I learned,could be taken in treating the toxic effectsof environmental chemicals.The key point was that
t, but lown
andfor treated.Stanthe offendingcausecouldbefound, eliminatedif possible dard medicine teacheshow to classifysymptoms, what drugs to use to
dy of
control them, and how to use them cautiouslyto preventtheir toxicity from
r the
killing the patient.
ough
I went to Hamilton and took Dr. Maclennan's training course in environmental medicine. He also suggestedI read a 700-pagebook by Lawrence
lnan.
came d the rosed gen-
Dickie entitled Clinical Ecology(C. Thomas Publications, Springfield, Ill. I976).After reading about thirty pagesof Dickie's book, I was overwhelmed "I and laid it aside and said to myself, won't be able to go through with
done
this." I realizedthat I wouid be striking out in a 180-degreeopposite direction to where all my colleagueswere going. Dr. Theron Randolph used
ested
to warn young doctors, eager to learn the techniques of environmental medicine, saying ,"You realizethis is a one-way street.There is no turning
) saw
euroRapp pidly mber
back." Not that the training I had had so far was useless-standardbacterial infection and trauma are perfectlytreatedby the standardmedicine I had leamed. However,chronic disease,which has become the subjectof most of' medicine,is dealt with primarily by symptom control, not finding causes
inely
and trying for a cure. I was devastatedand actually rather scared. It was clear to me that, if the findings and treatmentsof environmental
with-
and nutritional medicine would be taken seriously,the whole hefty bi-
I had
annually updatedtome on internal medicine-the bible of the discipline-* Harrison's Principles of lnternal Medicine, wortld have ttl be
rty of
12
HEALIN TG H EP L A N EOTn: eP a t i e natt a T i m e
fundamentally rewritten.Harrison'sis like the huge descriptivetreatisesby
envlr(
the eighteenth and early ninteenth-century naturalists,who classifiedand describedthe natural world in every minute detail without being able to
toxic critiq
explain any of that diversity and how it all hangs together, until Charles Darwin in 1859 provideda dynamic explanationfor evolution,and modern
M not o
geneticsproved that it all does hang together as one huge web of life. It was an intense- but not a very long-war that I wagedwithin myself.
progr
It was the patients that decided it in the end. Whenever I looked at them with the search frame of standard medicine, and then again with that of
Medi,
environmental medicine,I quickly knew what I had to do. The patient'senvironmental exposureand nutritional history generally explained the causes
hand,
of the observed signs and symptoms often quite elegantly and rationally. Symptom-control becameintolerably frustrating. So, I returned to the study
of co.
of Dickie'sbook and took everyavailablecourse,including one intenseone
contr
with Dr. Theron Randolph himself. I am still taking courseseveryyear.The treatment protocols environmental physiciansuse are regularly adjusted to
by gr,
take advantageof new researchand information. Unfortunately, however, there are powerful forcesopposing this progress.
cerns
from 1 5 0y profer dollar
Ir the ct as etl Cana
THEHAZARDS OFBEINGAN ENVIRONMENTAL PHYSICIAN
tice a
Not only do we have to detoxifi on a daily basis the carcinogenicand hormone-disrupting chemicals and synthetic materials we ingest through
direcl
water,air, and food-we also have to deal with the dead weight of outdated and intellectually toxic ideaswhich make the birth of the new alwaysso dif-
plina
indur those
ficult and even outright prevent good medicine from reaching patients. I knew from my teachersin environmentalmedicine that doing medicine in
mine
this new and revolutionary manner could be dangerous to one's professional health. After all, identi&ing pesticides,petrochemicals,many symp-
matir
tom-controlling drugs, and processedfoods (to name iust a few serious health hazards)asthe causesof cancerand chronic diseasesis not going to
cians
make a doctor very popular with the captainsof industry.The findings of
Assoct
A office Feb.t
t F, 6
-
,ryt*.*
--
Dr.J. Krop
rby rnd
13
environmental medicine, and the demonstration that avoiding all these toxic substancescan restore people's health, constitute a most formidable
ern
critique of our modern world and its commercial values. Medical regulatory bodies today are slow to tolerate new approaches, not only becausebureaucracieshave alwaysbeen slow to acceptany sort of
relf.
progress,but becausethe values dominant in a bureaucracyare far removed from the valuesthat guide a doctor in his real-life relationshipto the patient.
:to rles
rem tof nvirses ,lly. udy one Ihe lto ver,
Medical regulatory bodies are as conflicted in their interestsas they were 150 years ago, when bacteriawere the heresyof the day and washing one's hands, before examining a patient or performing surgery was an affront to professionalpride. Finally,while ethicsdemandsthat medicineshould be free of commercial interests,the fact is that symptom control is a rnulti-billion dollar businessand not likely to take the back seatwithout a fight. Symptom control is the market, and wealth is measuredin this rnarket, as in any other, by growth, not by the diminishing returns cutes would generate. Indeed, we have become so used to the priority of all commercial con"stakeholder,"with the patient being merely cerns-to the rights of every the consumer-that we have effectivelyceasedto even qu.estionsomething as ethically incomprehensible as the following fact: the very councils of
I
Canada'sCollegesof Physiciansand Surgeons,which control medical Practice and standards,have on them non-elected, appointed members who
ugh
directly come from, or are associatedwith, the pharmaceuticaland insurance industries.Those non-medical members are even permitted to sit on disci-
rted
plinary committees.Even the electedmembers havetheir researchfunded by
dif-
those same companies-nobody is free.The standard of medicine is determined by forcesthat have little to do with curing sick people.2l
lor-
ts. I ein 'fesnpous gto sof
As for the practicingdoctor, the fact also is that most learn new infbrmation primarily from the drug company representativeswho visit their officesregularly(seeendnote 14). An astonishing80o/oof all Canadianphysicianshave some financial tie to the pharmaceuticalindustry (Globe& Muil, Feb.6, 2002), which a recenteditorial in the lournal of the CanadianMedical "dancingwith the porcupine."22 ,\ssociation describedasa relationshipakin to
& (t,
14
HEALIN TH G EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e na tt a T i m e
{a 3 tl (D E F *
One Canadian doctor published the total number of visits and personal-
andlb
ized mailings he receivedfrom drug companiesin TheMedicalPosr(Feb.9,
to stay
1999):the total was 452 promotional encountersin
tonic sl
one year.
defend
As for medical research,it is hardly surprising
with th
that researchcapableof generatingpatentablehigh-
that lic
tech treatments,promising the dependenceof large
based,
numbers of peoplq gets the grant money, almost all
oppos(
of which comesfrom the pharmaceuticalcompanies.
cians.I
(ln continental Europe, most researchis paid for by
Th
governments and, therefore, truly independent and
uncon
not so drug-oriented.)Following the recentrevelations
organir
about how Dr. Nanry Olivieri23wasorderedby a drug
tion pr,
company to remain silent about the dangers of one
mental
of their drugs shewas researching,Doctorsfor Research
above,
Integritywas createdto protect researchers from drug companies'commercial "research priorities.Indeed,the conceptof integrity" is in dangerof becom"health ing as much an oxymoron at Canada's protection branch." Drs. Shiv
vitami.
Chopra and MargaretHaydon had to take the Canadiangovernmentto court
of thei
in order to establishtheir right and scientificduty to warn the Canadian
medic
public of the dangersto their food supply from unlawfully introduced
throug
carcinogensand hormone disrupting chemicals.They won that precedent-
they c:
settingcasein a federalcourt decisionin 2000.2a
Univer
Multip all wer
variou
The environmental physician is also pitted againstmuch government policy on a national and internationallevel.Speakingthe truth about what
US anr
we see in our patients on a daily basis-carcinogensand neurotoxins in
appea)
their blood, pesticidesin their fat biopsies,heavymetalsin their urine and
demnt
stools-is nothing lessthan a total indictment of governmentsthat have
ofohv All
ceasedto be regulatorsand protectorsof societyand becomepublicly funded
patien
butlers servingthe big corporations. The history of medicineis full of martyrs,and I had no intention of join-
tribun
ing their ranks.In fact,I am cursedwith an enthusiasmfor stuff that works,
charts
i !
,,[,_-, *_
F-
D r .J . K r o p
15
ilr:,
'' '-' (:! 'l r:' ,: ' :r ::i ,' ';Ejr,r rli:,: i. .'!l;;;:.lil.'i,,,
''rr,*l:.-.:i,.i,.,,
rnal-
and I becameentangledin the politics of medicine despitemy best efforts
eb.9,
to stayout of politics! When scientificparadigmsclash,it is much like a tec-
rs in
tonic shift: one getscaught in a huge social upheaval and does one's best to defend the facts and basic principles. And so I fought a thirteen-yearbattle
Lsing
with the College of Physiciansand Surgeonsof Ontario (CPSO), the body
righ-
that licenses doctors in this province. This disciplinary ordeal was not
large
based on patient complaints-on the contrary,my trial was energetically
st all
opposed by..ty patients,my colleagues,the generalpublic, and even politi-
nies.
cians.Seewww.ikropmd.com.
rr by and
Th CPSOformally chargedme with suggestingto patients they drink uncontaminated water, have air filters installed to alleviate asthma, eat
ions
organically grown foods free of carcinogenicpesticides,utilize detoxifica-
d'..'g
tion protocols for solventsand pesticides,etc.The treatmentsused by environ-
one
mental doctors,such as the provocation-neutralizationtechnique described
nrch
above, the various detoxification and diet-centeredtherapies, the use of
:rcial
vitamins and minerals as therapies,and the diagnosesof illnessessuch as
:omShiv
Multiple Chemical Sensitiviry Sick Building Syndromeand Candidiasis"guilty" and I was,after a four-yeartrial, found all were/ormulatedascharges,
ourt
of their use.The entire body of scientific evidencefrom the world's leading
dian
medical journals and the World Health Organization, which I provided
rced
through my lawyers,was reiected,aswere my defencewitnesses,eventhough
lent-
they came from JohnsHopkins Medical School,the medical schoolsof the UniversitiesofToronto, Saskatchewan, Nova Scotia,Stanford, and from the
nent
variousgovernment-sponsored environmentalhealth clinicsof Canada,the
vhat
US and Europe.I am now askingthe SupremeCourt of Canadafor leaveto
rs in
appealthe absurdityof having an entirebranch of medicinearbitrarily con-
and
demned.(For more information, alsoon other physicians,seewww.college
nave rded
ofo hysicianswatchdog.com. ) All this took placein spite of the fact that the patient chartsshowedthat patients had greatlybenefited from thesetreatments-a fact even the (,PS()
oin-
tribunal acknowledgedin their decision! Most of the very patientswhosc chartshad been used to formulate the chargesprotestedand testified on my
ffi
-F--
to
HEALIN TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e natt a T i m e
behalf at the end of the trial. The purposeof this trial-possibly the longest disciplinary investigation in medical history-was made very clear in the
nates what r
official Sentencehanded down by rhe CPSOin 1999: 1. "Dr. Krop must mahe it clear to his patients that the diagnosesand
MEDI
therapies...Areunsupporteilby scientificallyacceptableeuiilence." 2. "Members of the professionat large-a professionwhose integrity res*
Parapl
on the practice of scientifically basedmedicine-must hnow why and
it is vi
hou Dr. Krop'spracticefails the standard." 3. "The public...must be protectedfrom practitionerswho lach that creilibility."
cured, develc and h Iv
The motives for reiecting all of the defence'sscientific evidence supporting environmental medicine'streatment and diagnosticmodalities can
the fo
only be guessedat. Iust how far out of touch with medical reality the CPSO
astati<
Decision is becomesclear when considering the following: The united Nations Environment programme issuedits GEo-3 Report, to which more than a thousand scientistscontributed (Nature, May 30th, 2OO2,p. a75). It statesthat "the benefits of some environmentally friendly policies will not be apparent until decadesafter they have been enacted." The report statesthat "even if environmentally friendly approacheswere adopted now carbon dioxide concentrationswould continue to rise until
medic
2050. Water shortageswould continue and coastalpollution would increase slightly." The cartoon that went with it showed a speedboatnamed "Human
merel'
ence a
dirt ci dous I seewl docto. biolol levelgratefi
Behavior" cruising full speed ahead towards the edgeof an abyss.Its pilot, a skeleton, said with his head turned to the terrified passengers,"Brakes?
being
What brakes?"
as mu
I wrote this primer to enableyou to find out what environmental medicine can do for you and to introduce you to the excellentscienceon which
icolog
these therapies are based. I have also provided in its appendix the treatment protocols for some of the most serious environmentally-mediated
only i
conditions. They are intended for you to researchand to use for the purpose of making an informed decision.In medicine,everythingultimately origi-
from t
Er
and ir l ook i life oJ : I ;
il, t F.
E
A*
Dr.J. Krop ,l:ti.iiitti:;iiiti.iat
fi
1.,i!i;:.j:i.i:r:ajia)a:!lrijl!tti+tltitit::l;tat::::i;!::.:,a;i:t:i::tti:j,::::iia:t.:1:a:::l
,,:'-;,,"'. :'. ;,Gl',:':::, :,:*.:..: .,,.,,,. '1*,1 t J ',,,i , ,:',':i:-:!},,',,.,i .':,.:,,;.,,lE| ,,:,,:
gest the
nates in patient experience,so you need to iudge for yourself how much of what you read applies to you and how much does not.
MANSIONS TE H,EH O U SOEFM A N Y MEDICIN rJ
"In my father'shouse are many mansions," Paraphrasingthe saylngby lesus, it is vital to understandthat there are many waysby which an illness can be cured, and new approachesare being discoveredand will continue to be developed.Only fools and those with a vestedinterestbelieve they control and have the one and only answer. I was trained in twentieth-centurymedicine, and it is my conviction that
can
the focus of environmental medicine is the natural evolution of medical science at its best. Environmental medicine developedin responseto the dev-
PSO
astation of our planetary life-support systems, iust as bacteriological
sup-
medicine developedas a responseto the objectivefindings that bacteriaand )ort,
dirt can causedisease.Both these advanceswere stimulated by the tremen-
0th,
dous breakhroughs in technology which enabled scientistsand doctors to
ndly
seewhat was previously mysterious.Similarly, the possibilities now open to
ed."
doctorswith regardto early detectionof pathology,the analysesof a person's
Nere
biological material enabling one to seewhat is happening on the cellular
mtil
level-all this is a fabulous tool bag the previous generation of physicians
ease
merely dreamed of as sciencefiction. As a physician, I am amazed by and
man
grateful for the use of all of thesediagnostic and therapeutic modalities.
ilot, kes?
Environmental medicine dependsupon and arisesout of the discoveries being made in endocrinology, immunology, biochemistry and cell biology as much as it does on the researchresults in all the ecologicalsciences,tox-
ned-
icology,and especiallyepidemiology.All of life is interdependentin sickness
hich
and in health. Environmental medicine differs from traditional medicine
:eat-
only in that it can-in the face of the overwhelming evidence-no longer
ated
look at patientsand their presentingpathology and complaints isolatecl
)ose
from the air,water,soil, food, workplace,home environment, and emotional
'rigi-
that person's environment. Environmental medicine broadens the
a:,!:4.:a i.:,.tt.i..,i.: ..':,':.:3ll,::.,.:..i i:iiti:il .,ii.i:tit:: tiiati:;a:l :,,',,,.;il.|*'i:,:;:*:,tt:t:,.,.i :;ii;iti i:;i::,.|::. :11:11fr1;:,;i ..:: :. '.j i.
..i
ilE.i1i;i.ii::i: Gl,::,.,,,: 'l'+'".:j : CJ,,.. :$r,r:,1,,:, |L,,.:' Cll:,rr,,: *ii.i.tr,i llllli:;ri;i, gj,l1t;liil t.-.'ililii:',.
i
1.lilrir.i;ir
18
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e natt a T i m e HEALIN
perspectiveof medicine as a whole. It vastly increasesour understanding of everything in medicine and increasesour options dramatically.Consider
nutt
how the various medical specialitiescan benefit and improve patient outcome by adding these new insights to all that is alreadyknown and found
o The
thes, thin
to be beneficial through long experience: o The surgeon can haue better resultsin wounil healing if the knowledge
pote
of viumins anil other uitnl nutrients is incorporatedin the treatment of trauma;2s long-term problemsare prwented by ensurtng that the intra-
notl
uenousdelivery system (tubes, bags,etc.) do not contain enilocrinedisrupting phthalates (now beginning to be phosedout in hospitals). o the pediatrician treating childhood asthma neeil no longer worry about the long-term iletrimental ffias of steroid inhalerswhen it is so often
carc this c For tog byt the
possibleto eliminate the cause,such as food intoleran@or tonc chemicols
Dr.
in the home or schoolenuironment.26
beir
o The gerontologistcan help resnre a consiilerable measureof independence to many Alzheimer's patient by eliminating the causal dennl mercury
o The not
amalgam and W chelating a lifetime'sstoredbodyburdenof nxic tnetnls.2T o The urologist,frustrated by the lack of success with antibiotics in patients
adj
plagued by recurrent cystitisand urinary tract infections, can cure most
Atb
of thesepatients by dealing with the generally undnlying condiiliasis or e-coli infection through the use of probiotics, uoriousfrienilly bacteria
o The
and dietary adjustments.2s o The rheumatologist can erpanil treatment options dramotically fu loohing for mycoplasmaas the causein many casesof arthritis and scleroderma, both of which will respondto the old sundby-antibiotics used in new treatment protocols;alternatiuely,many orthrtfis patients
as1
cor' wit abt Aflt
All thir
respondwell to the elimination of cerUin foods they are unhnowingly sensitiueto, such as coffie and the deadly nightshadefamily of plants
institu
(potatoes,tomatoes,peppersetc.)2e
medic
. The neurologist,usually helplesswhen facing tenible diseasessuchas
all do, As
myastheniagrauis,or Parkinson's,cnn with environmultiple sclerosis,
most
mental toxins in mind turn to detoxificationanil subsequentrestoratiue
antibi
{
D r .J . K r o p
19
ng of
nutrient enhancementpratocolsthat often not only arrest the progressof
sider
theseiliseases,but actually cun cure them.3o
out>und
. The gynecologistfamiliar with natural hormone therapy can treat werything from endometriosisto menopouseonil not be concernedabout potential deadlyside fficts in the long run. The rwelations about the
Ige
carcinogicity of spthetic hormones,cutrently dominating the newq are
rt of
nothing new to the enuironmentally trained physician: we haue known
cr4-
thk for ot least nuo decadesand haue auoidedtheir use in our patients.3l o For the oncologist, the tediouswrtting of death certificates is beginning to giue way to a whole new world of healing anil. preuention openeilup
,out,
with euen vy\*arthomolecular and nutritional meilicine as their success,
:en
the most virulent cancers,achie,uedby the Gersonlnstitute, the worh of
icals
Dr. NicholasGonzalesand other researchersin this area is now finally being tahen sefiouslyby medical research.32
l.ence
. The physician treating heart cardiouasanlariliseasecan more often than
ry
not auoiil bypasssurgery through chelation therapy,dietary and lifestyle
tls.27
adjustmentsand the dramatic healing fficts of uitamin E and niacin,
imts
as well as other nutrients. (This treatment is now protected by law in
tost
Alberta since 7997.) (Seeendnote27)
bor ia
. The psychiatrkt, as I learneilfrom Dr. Abraham Hoffer in the early 7970s, can offn control ouer someof the most debilitating mental conditions with the new hnowleilgenutritional biochemistryhas made ouailable
,oho-
about the role of essmtialfotty acids, minerals anil vitarnins (e.g., niacin) anil herbal meilicines{e.g., St. Iohn's Wort) in mental disease.33
sed All this information comesfrom the world's most prestigiousmedicalresearch
ly
institutions and is found in the international medical journals availableto
fs
all doctors (and patients) through the Internet searchengines that access medical libraries.
ts
As for drugs,used appropriatelyand in pharmacologicaldoses,they are
tn-
most certainly at times miraculous and indispensable. I certainly use
tive
antibiotics, drugs that control fungi and parasites,various steroidsand hor-
ill:iiil .G):i;,ir: in:i,:i:li: |;ra;rl tt;,,j Sjir.,i {lI,jir,l €1,-lr, G:,,: ,H,iii:,it -,tl;lll
'-r:::::i:!
?0
H EP L A N E0Tn: eP a t i e natt a T i m e H E A L I NT G
mones and pain medication in my practice.The art of medicine, however, is to help the patient back to a normal, productive life, such that the person
occupa
is hopefully no longer dependenton the doctor or on any drugs! Used long-term, and without regardfor the bioindividuality of the patient, modem
today r
drugs can be deadly. In 1998, the University of Toronto and the American FDA published the results of a large meta-analysiswhich showed that the
parts.
side effects of properlyprescribeddrugs taken as prescribedare the fourth leading causeof death in North America.3aDllay Cohen, a professor of
works
Air, Wt edge, t headar a parti
preventivemedicine at the University of California in San Diego, published
Th,
His survey of the medical literature showsan astounding book, Ouerdose. and his own clinical experienceconfirmed-that lust about everydrug is
Teachi
basically overdoseand hence dangerousand even lethal. In fact, the rate of death from apparently properly prescribedmedication would, accordingto
ing, ea
his research,be much higher than previously thought (seeendnote 35). The reason is, he writes, that the drug companies createone-size-fits-alldrugs
of ever
to make them easierto market and inflate effectivenessstatistics.Coming from the orthodox medical communiry this is a very seriouscondemnation
and te
physic more \ use to illness
indeed.3s What sets environmentally trained doctors apart is the way we take a patient history becausewe see human beings embedded in the whole of
CAUS
Nature.When we take a history we listen, and listen, and listen, and listen-
As do<
and visualize our patient in their personal environment. No detail is too trivial and will include the carpeting,the method of heating, the location of
the nr
the garage,the possible fungi in the bathroom, the foods most frequently eaten, a recent changeof location, the air-conditioning the windows (or
about
lack thereof) in the office,the brand of shampoo,etc.,and our questionnaires
orienl
are very long-exhaustive and exhausting!
SYrnP'
Canac lt is, t
philosophy that seesthe body as a machine, out of the eighteenth-century
becau oIn
the paradigmthat causedmedical scienceto split into specialtiesand sub-
pL
specialtiessuch that nothing hangs together anymore. A machine is not
5U
dependent upon Nature. Hippocrates taught us about the effectsof food,
n
As I stated before the Brundtland Commission, medicine needsto get
I i
t I
i L E
&.
--
!.,.:..::.j:l::i!ii;.;:1:11i!.:ti.'!.!tiii:!:iji:.ti.;tir::j.;:L;,r::...ttit):;r:iiii!.;r
'-vet, 'son lsed lem
occupation, and the quality of water and air, on health. His book entitled Air, Water and Placesprovided 2,500 years ago the basic conceptsof what today we call ecology.That extremespecializationhas brought much knowledge,to be sure; but organisms are dynamic functioning totalities, not
the
parts. When something goes wrong, always the totality is affected. A headache can ruin your day completely,eventhough the rest of your body
rrth
works fine. Cancer,no matter where it is located, is a systemicdisease,not
'r of
a partial malfunction. "doctor" comesfrom the Latin "dacere," meaning "to teach." The word
ican
rhed vsrg is te of rg to
Teachinghealth should once again be central to the iob description of every physician. It is important, but not sufficient, to tell people to stop smoking, eat more vegetablesand take more exercise.What is the point of eating more vegetablesif they are loaded with carcinogenicpesticides?It is the ainr
rugs
of every environmental doctor to equip patients with knowledge they can use to make their own homes, gardens and workplaces supportive of life
ning
and teach their family, friends and employerswhat can be done to prevent
.tion
illness.
The
kea le of
C A U T I OO UP STIMISM C A U SFEO R
3n-
As doctors and patients,we haveour work cut out for us. Health has become the number one political and economic issue worldwide. Currently, in
, too :ntly
Canada,the Romanow Commission is understandablyprimarily concerned about how to make universal health carework when its cost is out of control.
i (or
It is, therefore, extrernely important to understand that an environmentally
aires
oriented approach to medicine is infinitely cheaper than the high-tech symptom-control approach so popular in standard medicine, primarily
r get hine,
becauseit does not need patentabletherapiesto achieveresults.. o ln 7987, the prestigiousmainstreom meilical journal, Annals of Allergy,
sub-
published the resultsof o fiue-year follow-up on two setsof patients
i not
suffertngfto*
bod,
The group treated by conuentionol methodshad more than two hundreil
rn of
thrombophlebitk. There wefe tpn patients in eachgroup.
:t
22
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e natt a T i m e HEALIN .:....: .1 ' !:a::..:::: : t:t :::r:::)a:,:i:t:.:,::ii.:i::1;:::::::.:r:a:lrt:j::j:111L:j!::l,ti:ll:tt:.:.i::.:::i
J:
= g
c
E
e
by environmentnl flare-ups during that fiue-yearperiod. The group treated meilicinemethods(nutrition, uitamins etc.) only reportedtwo flare-ups. The first group had a total of 114hospitalizations to report, while those treateil according to enuironmental meilicine techniquesdid not haue a singlehospitalizntion to report. Only one of the conuentionally tteated patientswas oble to feturn to worh, while all ten of the other Sroup returned to worh. Cosfsfor the conuentionalgroup was o totnl of US $300,000 during that period, while the environmentalmeilicinepatients spenta total o/ US $2,500.s6 o ln 7998, the German gouernmentpublished the results of a gouernmentfunded pilot project: o hospital specializingin enuironmental medicine, locatedin Bredsted.The resultsuere so imptessiae,the German gouernmentdecidedto build four more such hospitals.3T o I tahe comfort in the fact that ouer the past ilecade,virtually euery uniuersityin the industrialized uorld has begun to offer some coursesin enuironmentallyoriented medicine. . The agricultural departmentsof the European llnion, led by Denmark, haue made organic agriculture their top priority. . The international POP'skeaty (on persistentorganic pesticides)was ratified. . The IIS National lnstitutes of Health is funding the researchinto Dn alternatiue c&ncertherapy. NicholasGonznles' successful
> Folt Cot wol tlal
Ch, ues, frot cin to' abt syn
up Un tTh on eih ral
.Th CI As, ml oIt
. Through the American Associationfor the Aduancementof Scienceand the US National Center for Enuironmental Health, the US Souernment in 2000 started an ambitious program of testing thousanik of people
fo, Pr, pr,
annually for oll the uarioustoxic substancesin their blood and estoblishing a gouernment registry to trace their sourcesanil effecU-a
th
funilamental necessityif we ore euerto clean up the human organism. (Accordingto lohns Hopkins Medical School,of the 3,000 mostftequmtly usedchemicals,only 7o/ohauesafetyscreeningdata.) o ln the [IK, the Houseof Lords commissioneilmajor researchinto pesticidesond has tnken a proactiuestancein protectiuelegislation.
FI, oful eo N H
-
D r .J . K r o p
23
.::l?1ft1:1i::.:
ntnl
, Following the recent "Hudson Decision" by the Canadian Supreme
tps-
Court, city after city is banning the useof pesticidesand pressure-treated
ose
wood in Canada. Similar efforts hauebegunin the US.
,,4
zil
t I already mentioned the succestf"l tffortt by scientistssuch as Drs. Chopra, Haydon anil Oliuieri. Due to their determined refusal to bow to uestedinterests and political pressure,dangerousdrugs are being kept
;
ients
fto* entering our food supply. Bouinegrowth hormone (a hnown carcinogen anil enilocrine disrupter) was not only forbidden in Canada due to Drs. Chopra and Haydon's ffirts
"ent-
at Health Canada, but the facts about BGH thus becameauailable to the EuropeanUnion, wherethis
e,
synthetichormonewas also banned. Furthermore, Dr. Oliuieri has taken up the battle against unsafe ilrugs with court action in the European Union as uell. . The national meilical associaiionsof North America and Europe not
15tn
only giuefull study creilitsfor docnrs pursuing enuironmentalmedicine education,but are worhing on new guidelinesto get control ouer the
tk,
rampant conflict of interest in medical research. . Thanhsto the effor* of Dr. Lynn Marshall at the EnuironmentalHealth
s
Clinic at Women'sCollegeHospital in Toronto,the Canadian Medical Associationlournol recentlypublisheda six-part serieson enuironmental
r.
medicine,introducing doctorsto its protocolsand diagnosss.3s o lt is a pleasure to recall that Canada led the way for North America in
ent
of the environmentallymeiliatedhealth focusing on the seriousness problems,first through the ThomsonCommissionin 7985 (for which my
,
practicewas chosento serl)eas o major sourceof information), and then
\-
through a seriesof worluhops,sytnposiaand researchprojectsfunded by Health Canada and the uniuersitiesof Torontoand Dalhousie.3e
nd
m. ently
o Most heartening is the uoluntary initiatiue to clean up this polluted earth comingfro* industry. Dauid Suzuhi, in his latest booh,Good News for a Change: Hope for a Troubled Planet (Dauid Suzttki; Holly Dressel,Stoddort, 2002) destibes thesedeuelopments.
.::;.fi:1;t::,i!:: lG.,:.i;.i.i.: !:-:.t: :: l;': ,: ,:*},,;..,,,i :r,trI:::ii:i;,,, :HI.:r'':
(t": :*,::,,: t:r
:,1*,i;,: :-,:lit,,j
24
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e natt a T i m e HEALIN
',i"i: "pesky" patients I am personallyencouragedby the increasingnumber of
ENDN(
everywhere!Most of my patients have slogged,on average,through at least
I woRlt
sevendoctors' offices (the last one was usually a psychiatrist)and persevered until they were finally taken seriously.I was amused to learn that in June 2OO2the same observationwas troubling the delegatesattending the international convention of medical regulatory agencies,hosted by .tty very own
Future, 2 My sub 3 Web sir a Statisti, Epsteir
CPSO.They agreedthat patients today no longer iust acceptwhat they are their health problems and told. They come to their doctorshaving researched wish to engagetheir physiciansin discussion.One of the speakersfrom the
throug ON, M s For per MaSS.,
UK lamented that control is fust not what it used to be. Thank God for that! Most amazing of all, I never ceaseto be astonishedby the resilienceof
6 't col 7 The ter
the human body-Nature's stubborn urge to heal that cooperateswith the
govern
doctor's efforts and keepsthe patient going with tireless patience.Nature's
n M.N. (
determination to restorewhat is iniured is the constant sourceof hope and
9 R. CAT editior
couragefor patient and doctor. Iozef f. Krop
IOS. KHI AIzhei
Mississauga,Ontario, August 2OO2
source for Ort ll For pr, debor r2'LG. F printir the su Lewis l3 Accor< every the ha '4
J .R O I
'tR.J.v l ( ' O n ec standi by usi proto, CONVE
-lbron
r_
.,.,::::'_.,:::,:,*,',*,,::
3nts
ENDNOTES
east
' WORLD COMMISSION ON ENVIRONMENTAND DEVELOPMENT,Our Common
:red une lterlwn 'are and the hat! :e of , the
Future, Oxford, 1987 2 My submission was later publishedin Clinical Ecology, Vol. IV No.3, 1986 3 Web site for the World Health Organization: www.who.int/whr/l99?exsumgTehtm 4 Statisticspresented at McMaster Universiry Hamilton, Ontario, Canada, 1999, by Dr. S. Epstein at EverydayCarcinogens:Stopping Cancer Beforeit Stcrfs, transcripts available through Canadian Environmental Law Association, Suite 401, 517 College Street,Toronto, ON, M6G 4A2, or download from www.stopcancer.org. s For pesticides and fetal development: S. STEINGRABER,tlaving Faith, Perseus,Cambridge Mass.,2001. 6 't COLBORN et al, Our StolenFuture, Plume-Penguin, New York, 1997 7 'lhe text of this. presidential order of April 21, 1997 can be downloaded from the US , government site: www.health. gov/environment/TaskForc4whouseprenv.html
Jre's
8 M.N. COHEN, Health and the Riseof Civiliution, Yale University Press,1989
and
e R. CARSON, Silenr Spring, (1962), Houghton Mifflin, Co., New Yorh 25th anniversary edition, 1987
(rop
r0 S. KHlflCION et al. 'Aberrant Guanosine Triphosphate-Beta-Tubulin Interaction in Alzheimer's Disease" in Annals of Neurology,vol,.26, no. 2, 1989. The most comprehensive
!002
source for primary researchand clinical applications in this area is the tnumational Academy for Oral and Medical Toicology at www.IAOMT.org or tel. 407-298-2450 It F-orpressure-treatedwood hazards: www3.qympatico.ca/pbarrie or e-mail: deborahbarrie@ hotmail.com 12T. G. RANDOLPH, M.D., Human Ecologyand Susceptibilityto the ChemicalEnvironment, 7Lh printing Charles C.'fhomas, Springfield, Ill., 1980.'Ihe most comprehensivetreatment of the subject is the 4-volume work by W. I. RAE, M.D., Chemical Sensitivity,Volumes 1-4, L e w i sP u b l i s h e r s ,1 9 9 2 - 1 9 9 6 rr According to the Journalof the American PharmaceuticalAssociation41.:192-99,2001, for every US $i.11 spent on a prescription drug another US $1.77 needsto be spent to treat the harmful side effects of that drug. t4
I. ROBINSON, PrescriptionGames,McClelland & Stewart Ltd., lbronto, 2001
ts R.
lndiuiduality,(1956), Keats,New Canaan, Ct., 1998 J. WtLLIAMS, Biochemical
r6 One of my colleaguesobserved,in summing up a lecture comparing the poor outcomes of standard cancer treatment (chemotherapy and radiation) with the excellent results obtained by using vitamins, minerals, amino-acids, enzymes, specialized diets, and detoxification protocols: "... and so the resultsshow that if you take conventional treatment, you die a conventional death." Dr. Michael Conzales atthe i}th Annual lnternational Conference, 'lbronto, May 2001
rG:rrlr O;iil *ll!
26
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e na t a T i m e HEALIN
l
ts.lt': (*i;r:
=iif.r
CI,i:x,, Arii; Elli e4;,ll dtiiii -iiit;r:: ::.,r..r,1;,:l
2uAIifllR
I7 A. HOlrIrFR, M.D., Vitamin Il-3 & Schiznphrenia:Discouery,Recovery, Controversy,Quarry I'Iealth Books, Kingston, ON, Canada, 1998 (this is the new and updated edition of the
Iruture
researchpublished in the 1950s-1970s).A comprehensiveoverview of orthomolecular
Handb
medicine, also for patients is in A. HOFFER, OrthomolecularMedicinet'or Physicians,Keats,
2eAltern
N e w C a n a a n ,C t . , 1 9 8 9
19 9 9 .
rsThe many publications by Linus Pauling and complete accessto the worldwide research
ROGI]
on vitamins and orthomolecular medicine is available through the Linus Pauling lnstitute at
:ttt1'1-r"g;
Oregon State University, 571 Weniger llall, Corvallis, Oregon, 9733I-6512, or
WAS OI
www. htto : / / | ni. orst.edu.
The'fc
reT. MNDOLPH,
M.D., EnvironmentalMedicine: Beginnings& Bibliographiesof Clinical Ecology,
]' U. REI
Clinical Ecology Publications Inc., Fort Collins, CO, 1987
BERKI
'l'he 20D. RAPR M.D., Is This YourChild?, video Quill-William Morrow New York, 1991. tapes of Dr. Rapp's clinical work ahd other information for parents can be obtained from:
32The re from I
PracticalAllergy ResearchFoundation,P.O. Box 60, Buffalo, New York, 14223-0060. The
Natior
classicin this field is T. RANDOLPH, M.D., An AlternatiueApproachto Allergies,Revised
the wr
Edition, I-Iarper & Row New York, 1990
3] M, PE
21An affidavit filed by my defence lawyers on December 3, 1995, with the CPSO disciplinary
Press,
tribunal, outlined how the expert witnesses,whom the prosecution was going to call, were
reader
compromised by conflicts of interest. Iror example, the 16-page affidavit stated with regard "Drs. S. and M. have a personal stake in the outcome of the to two of these witnesses:
Nutrit, ta1.IAZ
Disciplinary Committee's decision by reason of their financial ties to those drug companies
Hospi
whose interest lies in opposition to Dr. Krop. Dr.M. has, from 1985 to 1995, receivedover
279,r "Nake
one million, three hundred thousand.dollars in grants from drug manufacturers Sandoz, Upjohn, Fisons,Schering,Astra,Ciba-Geigy,IanssenGlaxo and Abbott."'Ihe reason this
3sl.s. c( York,
situation represented a conflict of interest was becausethe drugs researchedby these prosecution witnesses were of the kind that the treatment modalities of environmental
tu w.l. R follor,r
medicine render unnecessary.'l'hesetreatment modalities were what I was defending. 22CNmJ editorial, Sept. 18, 2001
37The G
23J.THOMPSON et al, The Oliuieri Report,Canadian Association of University'feachers, 2001
Abschl Luebe
2aOn the Internet, you will find more than 400 referencesand informational items about the efforts of Dr. Shiv Chopra and his colleaguesat Health Canada to inform the public
Germr
about the dangers posed to our food supply by carcinogensand endocrine disrupters. Search "Shiv-Chopra." under
38Canaa 1 6 6 ,r (lune
2sA.DAVIS,Let'sCet Well,Signet,New York, 1972 26R. IrlRSIlElN, Reversing Asthma,Warner Books, New York, 1998.
3eSeehi
27M. WAI,KBR,et al. The ChelationAnswer,SecondOpinion Publishing Atlanta, Georgia,
Minis
1994. As chelation is an excellenttherapy also for diabetic neuropathy,heart and cardio-
Stakes
vasculardisease,good sourcesof information are the AUfERNAIIVL MEDICINIl GUIDE by the llurton Coldberg Croup, l;uture volume Heart Disease,Stroke& Iligh Blood Pressure Medicine Publishing, 1998 and cardiothoracicsurgeon M. OZ's Healingfrom the Heart, Plume llooks,New York, 1998.
l , i: t
t
E
Jo,..
D r .J . K r o p
z7
.& .lD,' ::H::
.,|*,'
2tiAUI'L,RN,{flVllMEDICINE CUIDll, Women'sHealth Seriesvol. 1, Ilurton Goldberg Group, lruture Medicine Publishing, New York, 1998. W.G. CROOK, M.D., The YeastConnection Handbook,ProfessionalBooks Inc., Iackson,'lbnnessee,1998
s,
2eAlternative Medicine Guide, Arthritis, Burton Goldberg Group, Alternative Medicine llooks, 1999. J.tl. tRWIN, M.D., ArthritisBe Gone!,KeatsPublishing, New Canaan, Ct., 1997. S.A.
1
te aL
ROGIIRS, M.D., Pain Freein Six Weehs,SandkeyeCo. Sarasota,FL., 2001 r0'l'he Klenner Protocol (after Dr. IlR. Klenner) for Multiple Sclerosisand Myasthenia gravis was originally published in the lournal of Applied Nutrition in 1973 and is available through 'fhe'lbwensend Letter for Doctors and Patients at 360-385-6021 or http:/iwww.tldp.com
c8y'
3t U. RIllSS, M.D., Natural Hormone Balance t'or Women,Pocket Books New York, 2001. D.L. BERKSON, Hormone Deception,Contemporary Books, New York, 2000 32'l-heresearch papers and treatment information by Dr. N. GONZALES can be downloaded 'l-he currently ongoing research at the from his web site at www.dr-gonzalez.com. National Institutes of health into the. Gonzales treatment can be downloaded for free fionr the web site of the US National Cancer Institute at www.cancer.gov 33M. PIIL"I,I. GLEN, D.F. HORROBIN, PhospholipidSpectntmDisorderin Psychiatry,Marius
nary vere
Press,UK, 199:, contains the medical scientific research for the specialist. For the general
;ard
Nutrition, Keats,New Canaan, CT., 1996
nies )ver \2,
is
reader are recommended; A. HOITFER,M.D., Putting It All Together:The New Orthomolecular ra;. LAZAROU, B.H. POMERANZ, P.N. COREY "lncidence of Adverse Drug Reactions in I{ospitalized Patients,"Journal of the American Medical Association,April 15, 1998, vol. 279, no.15. For an overview on specific dangerous drugs see CBC ldeas, transcript of "Naked in the Pharmaceutical Marketplace," 2001, www.radio.cbc.ca/programs/ideas/ 3sJ.S.COHEN, M.D., Overdose:The Case Againstthe Drug Companies,'lhrcher-Putnam, New York, 2001 36W.l. RAE,et al. "Recurrentenvironmentally triggered thrombophlebitis: a five-year followup." Annals of Allergy47:338-44, l99l
t001
37'l'heGerman Government's report on the Bredstedtenvironmental medicine clinic is entitled Abschlussbericht: Ambulanz Bredstedt,published by the University of Umweltmedizinische
lt ic :arc}t
Luebeck,availablethrough Institut fur Sozialmedizin, Beckergrube43-47, 23552l,uebeck, Germany 38Canadian Medical Association loumal serieson environmental medicine is published in vol 1 6 6 ,n o . 8 ( A p r i l 1 6 , 2 0 0 2 ) , n o . 9 ( A p r i l 3 0 ) , n o . l 0 ( M a y 1 4 ) , n o . 1 1 ( M a y 2 8 ) , n o . l 2 ( l u n e 1 1 ) ,n o . 1 3 ( l u n e 2 5 ) 3eSee historical overview regarding the impact of the 1985 Thomson Report to the Ontaricr Ministry of Ilealth in N. ASI{FORD & C. MILLIIR, Chemical Exposure:Low Levelsand High
iorE ure
Stakes,second edition, Van Nostrand Reinhold, 1998
,G,,ll ,!t, ,lll' i(! :IH. .iI ,
:.* ::tr
P r i n c i p l eosf Environmental Medicine
anyillness,we must look at the environmentalaspectsof health Tounderstand and disease.Centuriesago, the Greekphilosopher and physician, Aristotle, "to understandthe man one has to understand the environment he taught, livesin." His disciplq Hippocrates,carriedon this philosophy in his teaching and his work. In his book, Air, Water and Places,he developed the practicalapplication of this concept,looking at how air, water, soil and food have an effect on health and diseaseof human beings.Environmentalmedicine combinesthosebasicprinciples,with modem diagnostictechniquesto treat many immune related diseases. In today'sworld, many illnessesarethe result of reactions to substancesfound in the places where we live, work, and go to school. Many chronic illnesses,such as autoimmune disorders,including lupus erythematosus, iuvenile onsetdiabetesmellitus, rheumatoid arthritis, and multiple sclerosis, can be triggeredby environmental factors,particularly toxic chemicals. Patientswith environmental illnessusuallypresentwith multisystemicdisorders,
MANYCHRONIC t L L N E S S E SS . U C HA S ' . ' ' AUTOTMMUNEDrSqRDERS, TNCLUDING LUPUS ;
ERYTHEMAroslls,
JUVENILEONSET . : . : : : DtAts,ETEs MELLrr,Us, RHEUMATO!D ARTHRrTr5, SCLEROSIS, AND MULTIPLE CAN.EETRIGG.ERED BY ENV!RONfilEl.lTAL FACTOR$,PARTICULARLY TOXICCHEMICALS.
30
:iiii; : oii;;;:l Ui't,jiiir, aj|:'ir'r,.ji.:
o'j,i.ri;,.:, ':: frr'rr
i:
.tllril
l.
:Fi ii .X..;:iii.ri.:
E;lll-i .*.irir::,,: l;tiir;ir;t
i:itir+,r.i
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e natt a T i m e HEALIN
including the central nervous system, which is particularly sensitive to toxins. The symptoms can usually be traced to specific causative factors
the batt
found in surrounding environmental exposures,diet or drugs. Our body is built from elementsof the external environment, arranged
by anal
accordingto the geneticcoding of the Deoxyribonucleicacid (DNA), which we received from our parents. These elements are supplied through the
but hig
foods we eat. It is important to realizethat during our cultural evolution we have continually contaminated the environment, and at the same time "iunk foods'" With the introduced an overabundanceof non-nutritious introduction of toxins and extensiveagricultural techniques,the soil, the
andfur
baseof the food chain, has becomedeficient in many basicnutrients (i.e., magnesium, zinc, vitamins, etc.). As a result, foods produced contain too many toxic substancesand are deficient in some nutrients. Poor auailability
brains <
of oppropriate nutrientsfor the human body has a negatiueffict not only on its structure but alsoon i* function. There are two important aspectsin this area: genetic makeup of generationsto come and poor functioning of the central nervous system. Genetic information contained in the DNA is basicallyidentical today to the information contained thousands of years ago. This information dictates how to build, as well as how to regenerateour bodies. Since the quality of our daily food intake has decreased,it is not comparable to the parameterscodedin the DNA. This meansthat the human organismbuilds and regeneratesitself from poor quality materials. By analogy, it could be compareiln buitding a home accorilingto sounil architectural plans, but using substnndnril materials. The enil result wilt be'a house that looks exoctly as planneil by the architect (DNA), but will be more uulnerobleto destruction. It would seemthat the contemporaryhuman body is in a parallel situation. .One of my mentors, Prof. Dr. Julian Aleksandrowiczof Krakow shared the following thoughts with me: A human being is only able to maintain his or her integriry identity and sovereigntyas long as the psychological processesare energeticallysupported by the correct supply of nutrients and oxygen.Intoxicatedbrain function becomessubclinicallyabnormal: When
simple functior and soc environ Furt small d functio
{
D r .J . K r o p
3l
ve to
the batteryof a calculatorbeginsto weaken,the calculatorcan perform only
tctors
simple functions and fails with complicatedones.A polluted brain works, by analogy,in the same way. It can perform its basic functions (brain stem
. :;::: ,,'.;: ''6!,;
.
' :.,,:,ltl:,rr:r:;.:: i '.,.,j,.iijlii:,,',.,
rnged
functions) of maintaining breathing,circulation, instinctsof sexand hunger,
vhich
but higher functions (cortical) such as learning, love, friendship, sharing
i.rl'jE#'.. ,,,lrl:ili l:L:,r:.t
h the
and social responsibilitybecomedistorted.Maintenanceof body structure
'.,',,.,HtI
ution
and function can only be achievedthrough sustainablemanagementof our
' ''r:;,11ii:i:1
:time
environment.
h the
Furthermore,neurobehavioraltoxicology provesthat toxins, even in a very
l, the
small dose, can changethe human brain, and more so, the very vulnerable
i ( i.e . ,
brains of developing children. Thesetoxins can causedecreasedintellectuai
n too
functioning and even hallucination.
tbility nly on n this of the today ration ce the to the builds ulil be : using ctly as rction. .tion. ;hared .intain logical ts and When
P o l i s h E c o l o g i c a lt , i : . i E c o l o g i c a lP o s t e rC o r i t t ' : !J o t Y o u t h ,E a r t h D a y 1 ) { : i Artisl: lwona Brojewslirt
,:r,,,H,ij:if:..
', li!:tU!,:i
;iHiiii.',
32
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e natt a T i m e HEALIN
DLI C I N E ? NE TA W H AITSE N V I R O N M EM
Enviro
Environmentalmedicine providesa real understandingof any diseaseprocess by taking into consideration an individual's geneticendowment, as well as
I
environmental stressors(immediate, local and global). Ironically it is very closely relatedto the original thoughts and teachingsof Hippocrates,which had mostly been forgotten until recently. EnvironmentalMedicine (EM), or Clinical Ecologyasit is also referredto, the effect of environis the medical discipline which studies and assesses mental factors upon individuals with particular emphasis on the effect of foods, chemicals,water, indoor and outdoor air quality, at home, work or
. Revie syste envir . Histo facto adiar
I
school. It considerseach patient as an exceptional individual exposedto a unique set of circumstancesand needing a custom-tailored therapy.
. Diagr pre-n
Once the causeof the health problem is discovered,the treatment is as direct as possible with minimal use of pharmaceutical drugs, effectively
dam i
I
avoiding any adverse side effects.Treatment consists of environmental controls, diet modification, nutritional supplements and immunotherapy
. Focu cherT
(injectable and/or sublingual), detoxification (I.V., sauna), modification of metabolic/hormonal imbal anceswith natural produAs/horrnones,chelation
exp0 psycl
for heavy metals, cardiovascular and degenerative disordersetc.
I
. Conc beca
The father of Environ-
affec
mental Medicine, Theron
SYMI
G . R a n d o l p h , o ri g i n a l l Y designed this Iogo. It e n c o m p a sse sth e i n te r-
' Avoir
relationshipbetweenAdaP-
diet;
tation, Allergy, Nutrition
SUPF
and Toxicology as it pertains to the practice and understandingof Environmental Medicine.
dese prev
{-
Dr.J. Krop
Environmental
vs.
33
A l l o p a t h iM c edicine
CCSS
ll as
very rich
each involving symptoms Reviews for andsearches system to illness. contributors environmental
Cto, ronrof
. Takes relating 0nlyto organhistory problems fordifferent oriented nephrol0gy, neurology, specialties, e.9.,
witha limited emphasis etc., andenvironmental cardiology, ofdietary History habits andminimal ondietary at inarriving areconsidered factors factors. to environmental attention a diagnosis.
kor toa
mustbepresent damage insubclinical, . End-organ canbemade Diagnosis pre-morbid andtreat. to diagnose end-0rgan statebefore
nt is
damage.
ively :ntal :rapy ln of rtion
p
intoaccount isholistic, taking Focus andphysical biological chemical, and habits, dietary exposures, psychological stress. islimited Concept ofspecialization factors can because environmental andproduce affect anyorgan simu ltaneously. symptoms
among them). 0r relati0n connecti0n
. Anatomically according demarcated i.e., view, Cartesian to theprevailing specialty devoted to oneorgan each particularly thedivision between only, psychiatry medicine. andinternal
and Avoidance ofenvironmental dietary use0f nutritional offenders,
I
. Focus and isonseparate bodyparts (asif there were n0 theirmalfunction
supplements, ication, detoxif desensitization andneutralization; preventative andcost-effective.
. Primarily pharmaceutical and drugs inside which mayresult surgery, (caused by iatrogenic and/or effects problems while intervention) medical process highrisk, continues; disease highcost.
34
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e na tt a T i m e HEALIN
'fhere aresome subtledifferencesbetweenenvironmentaland allopathic medicine,particularlyin relationto history taking,the stageat which disease is diagnosed, focus of medical attention, specialization and therapies, as * describedby Ashford and Miller. (Seepreviouspage') * A s h f o r d , N i c h o l a sa n d M i l l e r , C l a u d i a , C h e m i c a l l l x p o s u r e s - L o w L e v e l s a n d H i g h S t a k e s , V a n N o s t r a n dR e i n h o l d , N ' Y . , 1 9 9 1
Ther ill healtt
. 0rgani ( many
0rgan(
bipher
MEDICINE OFENVIRONMENTAL ANDPRACTICE PRINCIPLES A specificenvironmentallyoriented medical history (EOMH) is one of the most important factors in the recognition of environmentally triggered An EOMH relatesphysicalor psychologicalsignsand symptomsto diseases. a patient's environmental exposuresat home, work or school, different seasonsor effectson diet. For example: . If a patient developsa headachewhile in the basement,think about an excessof mold from a leaking or flooded basementor fumes from a faulty furnaceor storedchemicals. o Increasedsymptoms during a specifictime of year,influencedby seasons. Getting hyper after a school lunch or birthday party. Getting tired and sleepythirty minutes after a meal. "flu-like Experiencingmuscle pain, bruising, extremefatigueor symptoms" after exposureto pesticides. o Irritation of eyes,nose,breathingproblems after newly installed carpets,furniture, renovation,etc.
. Inorga
chlorin
sm0ke
r4nKn . Heat, c tion(fr
atomi(
f;rfffm
' Bacte fromt
gtr*r
. Anypr disrup relatic other realal On
It has to be rememberedthat any stressor,evena very local trauma, can affect the entire system,e.g.,iniury to any o.nebody part can lead to fibromyal-
singlecr
gia. This occursthrough the responseof the ground regulatingsubstance (GRS),the basis of which was introduced to us by the Austrian physiol-
logical
ogist, A. Pishinger,in Matrix and Matrix Regulation:Basisfor a HolisticTheory in Medicine,1991,Ild. I-1.I-Ieine.
compor insuran A detail
T
D r .J . K r o p
3s
!!.!!j.{.!!ia::.-:ti
There are four categoriesof environmentalfactorswhich may trigger
rthic
ill health (total body load):
ease s, as : r: 3h
plus phenol, toluene, xylene, benzene, suchasformaldehyde, substances Organic including compounds, Chlorinated fromgas,oilandcoal. derived many chemicals polychlorinated pentachl0r0phen0ls, pesticides, chloroform, organ0chl0rides,
NE
(PCB) herbicides suchas?, 4-Dandotherpesticides. andvari0us biphenols aluminum, asbestos, lead, cadmium, asmercury, such substances Inorganic
f the
drugs, tobacco copper, nickel, illegal dioxide, ozone, oxides, sulfur nitrous chlorine,
ered
andothers. medications smoke,
ns to :rent ut
. Heat, positive ions, radiaandnegative electromagnetic noise, cycles, cold, weather (radioactivity fromx-ray, radiation ionizing 0fthelightspectrum), tion(fullrange gas). radon foodirradiation, reactor accidents, explosions, atomic
om
. Bacteria, parasites, d la n d edru, sat n dp o l l e n s foods, anima viruses, fungi(molds), grasses andweeds. fromtrees, . Anyprolonged (alcoholism, psych0l0gical family sexual abuse, stress inthefamily poor prolonged member, etc.), 0ratwork(overwork, ofa family sickness disruption, jobloss, and inthefamily, lossdueto fireor bankruptcy etc.); a death relationships, These factors are bodyresponses. unfavourable events cantrigger otheremotional therapy. 0rneglected during realandcan'tbeoverlooked
affect nyaltance rsiol-
.heory
On the other hand, psychologicalstresscan not only be considereda or singlecauseof prolongedenvironmentalsickness,but can also aggravate compound existingenvironmentalstress.Additional or secondarypsychological stresscan also occur when family or medical staff, employers or insurancecompanies,negateor reiectcontributing environmental factors. A detailedEOMH will sort out the qpe of stressinvolved, as improvenlent
35
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e na tt a T i m e HEALIN
will not occur unless both the stressand the causativeenvironmental factors
TYPES
are dealt with.
One of is low-lt fering p
INO.IMMUNOLOGY DOCR PSYC HO-NEURO.EN It is very artificial to divide diseasesinto psychosomaticand somatic con-
accumu "safeler
ditions. It has to be rememberedthat anything that affectsthe body can also
reactior
affect the mind, and vice versa.After all, man-made chemicalsin minute
exposur
exposuresdo affect the central nervous system function as well as other bodily systems.Furthermore body systemssuch asthe central nervoussystem,
The
immune endocrine system,etc.,communicate with each other through spe-
upon: o The
cial neuropeptides circulating in the blood. The diagram below represents
toxi
the interrelationship betweenthe environment and the body.
o The diff . The o The tim o The o Syn
Typeo oMa wal
int an(
.ch tox pai The interactions between immune systetntbody, mind, anil environment. S o u r c e :C u n n i n g h a m ,A l a s t a i r/ . . M i n d , B o d y a n d I m m u n e R e s p o n s e , P s y c h o n e u r o - i m m u n o l o g y , E d i t e d b y R o b e r tA d e r , A c a d e m i c P r e s s ,I n c . , 1 9 8 1.
och
D r .J . K r o p
hctors
37
T Y P EO SFE X P O S U R E S One of the most important factors in today's chronic degenerativediseases is low-level exposureto chemicals,which causeschemical sensitivity in suf-
: conn also rinute other r/stem, h speesents
fering patients.Chemical sensitivityis defined as an adversereaction to low accumulativelevels of toxic chemicals,which are usually believed to be at "safelevels."Practicallyanything we eat,breatheor touch can triggeradverse reactionsin a sensitiveindividual. These reactions can occur as a result of exposureto both natural and man-made chemicals. The diversity of the manifestationsof reactionsto chemicalsdepends upon: o The pharmacologicalnature and the toxicity of the substance(more toxic, less toxic, neutral) o The tissue or organsof the body involved (different symptoms front different organs) o The age of the patient (newbom, youngest and oldest are most affected) o The susceptibility of the exposedindividual (state of nutrition at the time of exposure,geneticmakeuP) o The length of time of exposureand the amount of body stress . Synergismbetrareen different chemicalsor their metabolites.
couldinclude: Typeof exposure o Massive(acute):industrial accidents(e.g.,Bhopal, India, 1984), wartime exposure(nerve gas,Agent Orange defoliant herbicidesused in the Vietnam War during 1967 to 1968, mix of chemicals,vaccines and depleteduranium-Gulf War, 1991) o Chronic exposure:takes place when there is chronic accumulaticlnof toxins at work, home, or school (e.g.repeateduse of pesticides, painting, cleaningproducts,renovationsupplies) o Chronic use of antibiotics. i 1.
r 38
T :N CP A t i E NAtt A T i M C H E A L I NTGH EP L A N E O
R o u t eos f e x p o s u r e :
Slitirill . legcra . n o ta b l
o Lungs,through inhalation of a substance iriiilrillr:i:i:iiri i iU[:itii;,i: liitll:tli::i:i .,i .,',,:,..'.
t*"': ;,
,,:i*laii:i:::::,!
o Gastrointestinal tract, through ingestion o Skin, due to touching and absorption,e.g.,solvents.
't1:".,, "f?i:i.,.
iiriHirlr:irar::j iti.&t:i:-.lnl:
. s l e e tp . vomitir
t i':il'i
::;ijt:itli;!!i:a:!i!!:i::
. temper . rem0vi
C H A N G IF NA GC EOSFS E N S I T I V I T Y ( N OY , O UW O N '"TO U T G R OIW T )' ' Environmental sensitivitiesand allergieshave many faces.Manifestations,
. sleepi . chroni
signs and symptoms during the life of the affected individual change and intertwine. Parentsof a child suffering from allergiesand sensitivitiesare "outgrow" the problem. As a matter of fact, the often told that the child will child never does.I was once memorably told by my professorof pediatrics "outgrow our pants,but not the disease." that we
rfffiT . runny
breath c0nst.
The following are common symptoms in a sensitiveindividual through-
rushin
to adulthood: out the courseof his/her life from infancy through adolescence
CXCCSI
t i r e dr
CHILDREN chron
mrlrlfir|l . thebabyis excessively isvery, veryquiet in utero, hashiccups and/or active . theexpectant foods which hascravings forspecific sheindulges, mother, meanwhile, e.9., milk, sugar andwhich inturnsensitize thebabyinutero,
IIIHIIN c o l i c kbya b yf r, e q u e cn ht a n g e o sf f o r m u l a c 0 n s t asnttu f f i n easns d / or ru n n nV0 s e eczema r o c k i nagn db a n g i nt hgeh e a a d g a i n tsht ec r i b d i f f i c u l t iiensf a l l i nags l e eapn dv v a k i n ug p c h r o n ai cn dr e c u r r eenat ri n f e c t i o n s perspiration, excessive drooling
m
depre
muscl
bowel forgel al c o h
obesil
rD r .J . K r o p :: ::1+'!; \ +i )::t:::j::::i.:
ia::!:r:tj::::.
'r':.:
Sft|-rrrfl|i|.il . legcramps or "growing Pains" . n 0 ta b l et o c u d d lce0, n s t aw n itg g l i n g . temper biting tantrums, . removing clothes . s l e eP problems . vomiting clearwhitemucous . s l e e p i na gl o t - c h i l dn' sa r c o l e p s y tions,
,!:.i:;,:|!r!ata,:ajn:::!aaijaialrta;:tiatiti::Eittlaltalj1:j:at:t:ta.:;ai1::?4.i,t1fri.nt\::
w W
35are atrics
. runny andstuffiness nose . breathing pr0blems, bronchitis asthma, . c0nstant bedwetting, 0rconstipation, diarrhea tothebathroom rushing . excessive gas, badbreath belly aches, . tired0rexcessively problems learning active,
]j['r'flffififif
rt lges,
/-),,-,
useofantibiotics andrecurrent infections respiratory chronic
: and 1, the
. chronic irritability instability, emoti0nal tiredness, . d e p r e s ssi ouni c, i dt a e ln d e n c i e s . m u s cal ec h ehse, a d a c h e . bowel problems ' forgetf to concentrate inability ulness, . alcoholism ' obesity, nervosa anorexia
3e
r-
40
HEALIN TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e natt a T i m e
ADULTS
PRINC
Some adults may presentwith any number of the following symptoms:
To under the four; bipolarit
Central Nervous System
System Gastrointestinal System Hematological
Genitourinary System
Musculoskeletal System
fa t i g u e tension c 0 nuf s i 0 n hallucinations hyperactivity s l e e dp i s o r d e r s
heartburn nausea
h i g ho r l o wp l a t e l e t s b r u i s i n g anemia leucopenia frequency i nef r t i l i t y i n a b i l ittoyv o i d infection of urinarytract urgency to urinate interstitial cystitis prostate problems j o i n tp a i n m u s cpl ea i n backaches s w o l l el inm b s muscle weakness
Respiratory System
ENTSystem
Skin
Cardiovascular System
headache loss memory depression dizziness numbness tremors bloating constipation/d iarrhea
Totallo Total loa taminan vidual. \ i
i:
allergics
t
is the str
!
m u s csl ep a s m s m u s ctlw eitching
frequent colds asthma bronchitis heavy chest shortness ofbreath s i g h i nr egs p i r a t i o n nasal stuffiness s i n u isn f e c t i o n s watery eyes fl u s h i n g eczema c o l de x t r e m i t i e s rapid h e a rbt e a t skipbeats
fill it to <
earaches e a ri n f e c t i o n s rashes hi v e s i r r e g u lhaer a rbt e a t hypertension/hypotension
I Radiatio I explosio I depleted radi; I EMF
(1I'*
lndoor P - dust,d - housel - perfun produr - gasstr
Ove
{-
D r .J . K r o p
41
P R I N C I P LOEFSE N V I R O N M E NMTEADLI C I N E ls:
To understandenvironmentalaspectsof health and diseasewe must look at the four principlesinvolvedin the process:total load, maskingphenomenon, bipolarity, and biological individuality.
T o t al o a d( t o t a lb o d Yb u r d e n ) Total load consistsof past and presentphysical,chemical,biological contaminants in food, air and water,aswell as the emotional stateof the individual. You can comparetotal body burden to a container-you can only fill it to capacity.Anything above capacitycausesspillover or, in other words, allergicsymptoms and ultimately sickness.Another imageto keep in mind is the straw that breaksthe camel'sback.
ract
Chemicals - pesticide spraying - aerosol chemicals - contact chemicals - foodchemicals
Foods nuclear Radiation, - allergic foods X-ray, explosions, - foodsmostoften uranium, depleted eatenor craved radiation EMF (antennas, computers) (
Pollution lndoor - dust,dustmites, molds - household chemicals - perfumed personal care products - gasstoves
Pollution 0utdoor - vehicle pollution exhaust, fromfactories - inhalants pollens dust,molds, - smog
l I
I
Overflow
.- {kTli',gl'=.'j lx-
"lt
'rn.
I
t
Barrell'i
oui ResiStb'nc
;ion
SFillover= SymPtoms
42
' il,i:i.l..i. ::l*l.tjl.,:tti:t:i :ri|., .,::.i-:.: Eii',::1,,','l :::ffi:!i::i:l:i:r::::
.itti;lr .:;ft;,'1:;i;;,1 r:i+,'.,t...:,:l lX,,,.l.,
'*..,i.,1
O:N CP A t i C NAtt A T i M E H E A L I NTGH EP L A N E T
M a s k i nPg h e n o m e n(oand a p t a t i otno,l e r a n c ea,d d i c t i o n )
withdrar
The human body is brilliantly designedwith a complex and comprehensive
smoke c
mechanismsfor mainnetwork of psychoneuro-endocrino-immunological
reactionl
taining good health and equilibrium, which is homeostasis.Stressorsare
this poi
handled through the processof adaptation,which allows for compensatory
health o
physiologicalresponses(e.g.,detoxification) to the chronic stressof environ-
damage
m e n t a l c h a l l e n g e s.Il l n e ss o ccu rswhen the adaptivepr ocessbecomes
toxic effi
exhausted.
The
"mashing,"makes it difficult sometimes to seethe Adaptation, through
chemica
connection betweena particular exposureand symptoms. For example,you
ees exp(
renovateor move into a new home-fresh paint, refinished floors, new car-
other or
peting, etc.,or you sprayyour home with pesticides.Initially the odour of
toms or
outgassingchemicals is strong; you can hardly breathe upon entering the "fresheners" and house.After a while you get used to the smell or use air
symPtor
believe the problem is gone. However, you begin to increasingly have
endocrir
headaches,eye, nose and throat irritations, fatigue, muscle pains, etc. The "of unknown origin." toxic effectshavecontinued and led to illness
level ex1
exposur
sure, ar
Another exampleof this phenomenon is the use of tobacco,which we
(avoida
now know can lead to cardiovascularand lung disease,among others.That
prevent
first cigarettesmoked is rarely enfoyed and causesan unpleasant reaction
Son
(choking). With time, the smoker (or family member) developsa tolerance
sweets,
and becomesunawareof even the odour, but the potentially fatal effectsof
repeate(
smoking cigarettesor being exposedto second-handsmoke continue and
meal or
only show up some time later.
such as " not, a
It is generallyrecognizedthat the use of narcotics,nicotine and alcohol can createa stateof addiction. After an initial unpleasantreaction (cough, "pleasurable" throat and eye irritation) tolerancedevelopsand deceptively
effect ir
effectson the central nervous systemare experienced.With time, even more
wich w
of thesesubstancesare neededin order to maintain the same effect.If the
pastafc
addictivesubstanceis removed,severewithdrawal reactionscan take place
often cr
such as irritability, fatigue, moodiness, headache,etc. Severaldays after the
the caur
breakfa
D r .J . K r o p
43
withdrawal reaction, the individual remains hypersensitiveto secondary ensive
smoke or the smell of alcohol, with a recurrenceof the initial unpleasant
main-
reactions upon exposure but still a strong need to continue the habit. At
)rs are satory
this point, the individual can tough it out, kick the habit and regain "feel good" "relieved," while or health or he/shecan retum to the habit, and
viron-
damageto the heart,brain, lungs, liver and other organscontinues from the
:ome s
toxic effects. The same masking phenomenon can occur with low-level exposureto
ee the
chemical toxins. This has been documented in studies on factory employ-
e, you
ees exposed to solvents, nitroglycerin, welding fumes, cotton, grain and
w car-
other organic dusts. Workers unknowingly experiencedwithdrawal symp-
our of
toms on the weekend and often preferred to return to work, where these
:rg the
symptoms cleared upon re-exposureto the substances.However, years of
;" and 'have
exposureled to demonstrable pathological changesin the central nervous,
c. The
level exposuresover a long period of time can be as harmful as acute expo-
endocrine, cardiovascularand immune systems,resulting in disease.Lowsure, and only the time factor makes a difference. Early intervention
ch we
(avoidance, making the workplace safg detoxification treatment) can
i. That
prevent the development of chronic illness.
action
Somethingsimilar can happenwith foods consumedeveryday (breads,
:rance
sweets,coffee, milk, etc.). The individual learns to eat a particular food
3ctsof
repeatedlyat whateverinterval of time is required to feel satisfied.When the
re and
meal or snack of this food is postponed or missed,withdrawal symptoms
lcohol
such as fatigue,depression,irritability, headache,etc. occur. Consciouslyor not, a "fix" is needed.By eating the masking food regularly,a gratification
:ough,
effect is maintained. A typical pattern may include cereal with milk for
rable"
breaKast,coffeeand danish/muffin for a mid-morning break,cheesesand-
more
wich with milk or pop for lunch, afternoon coffee and snack bar breah
If the
pastafor dinner with a sweetdessert,milk and cookie at bedtime. Patients
place
often can't understandthat commonly eaten and well-liked foods can be
,erthe
the causeof their ill health,sincefood is consideredbeneficial,not harmful.
44
O:N CP A t i C NAtt A T i M C H E A L I NTGH EP L A N E T a..tjtliiij:i.!:;,jiiai::i:;!ir.:ti/1.,tai.t1l::.ii.l|iiitti:il::,ia1rl;i:;!iaai:;,4ii+traotr.lilii
the food happily r ''':::-:::
him feel
rA.l';r. *l;r,,i.,: illr:.li:,:,' A;rr,;;,i,
with it il
*:;;1:,..;l
A sin
*1,,0;:ll,.
*iii;iii
4.iL,trliti:,.:
*i;i;'lii
elrrl:,iri 'j:tilirliil I iiiil.'i,.i
It is not known how we becomeaddictedto foods (seepage 141). However,foods consist not only of protein, fats and carbohydrates,but also of natural chemicals(phenolic food compounds and even morphine). Daily indulgent consumption of a limited number of foods can cause not only nutritional deficiency, but also sensitization and allergy. This creates immune complexesthat can causeinflammation of targetorgans in susceptible individuals, leading to various symptoms. For example,wheat products can be a factor in irritable bowel syndrome for one person, migraines in another, arthritis in a third , eczemain a fourth, etc. Foods can also cause psychologicalsymptoms in the geneticallysusceptibleindividual. physicians,poorly trained in understanding adaptation mechanisms,or not trained at all, do not connectcausewith effect.For example,a patient comesi.ncomplainingof initable bowel syndrome,arthritic pains or migraine, etc. If the doctor doesn't know that foods can causethese syrnptoms, the complaints will only receivea label and medication offering symptomatic relief,while the diseaseprocesscontinuesunintemrpted. In another instance, a patient for some reasonhas been unable to havethat favourite food for a couple of days (due to an illness,an operation,a trip, a diet). Withdrawal reactions set in and the individual feels sick but doesn't know why. The Patient then goes to the doctor, who wouldn't make the connection to the food becauseshe doesn't know what questionsto ask and because
in any fc five to sr or three ing to th the bod' symptor offendir substan< and effe Whe pounde, mechan under tl causedt then ful sight, y, somese not onl leadsto being.I to the ' could ir
BIPOL Dr. The of patit
D r .J . K r o p
45
the food wasn't ingestedrecently.In the caseof a diet, the individual may happily return to eating that favouritefood convincedthat eating it makes him feel better.The addiction continues and, as any addiction, can carry with it ill consequences. A simple way to unmask sensitivitiesis to avoid an offending substance
\
Howlso of Daily t only teates Isceprducts res in cause rls/ or atient gaine, rs, the 'matic tance, ; been : food to an diet). r and < bu t
in any form and relatedfood family rnembers(e.g.,all grains,all dairy) for five to sevendays.Withdrawal reactionswill take placewithin the first two or three days,after which there is total freedom from any symptoms relating to the offending substance.Upon re-exposureto the suspectsubstance, the body will give clear-cut, reproducible reactions.The disappearanceof symptoms during a longer period of time, when there is no contact with an offending substance,and a rapid recurrenceafter re-exposureto the same substanceis the basisfor challenge or provocative tests,which prove cause and effect. When exposuresto toxic or allergic substancescontinue and are compounded by the other environmental factors listed earlier, the adaptive mechanismsbecome exhausted.While your body is brilliantly designedto, under the right circumstances,detoxifii and/or fight disease,overload can causedamageto the detox and immune systemsand the diseaseprocesscan then fully develop.The encouraging news is that, with education and foresight, you can practice preventative medicine. This does, however, require some self-disciplineand a senseof responsibility; moreover the benefitsare not only improved health, but also regaining control over it. This in tum leadsto higher self-esteemand subsequentphysicaland psychologicalwellbeing. It's all connected.Taking it a step further and introducing this concept to the whole family may also benefit other members.Children's health could improve,along with their listeningand learningskills.
atient w ho ion to know :cause
BY I P H A SPI C B I P O L A R I( T ON FR E A C T I O N ) ATTER Dr. Theron Randolph,* the father of Clinical Ecology,observingthousands of patients in environmental units reactingto different substances(foods,
{
PAtiCN At a T i m e TN : C H E A L I NTGH EP L A N EO
46
tt:i.::ai:ri,iltii.ii:::!j).::i.tri:i1ri.!.?..r.;iitt:;.4r..,1ij:i!./ii..+t:i:i:a!j.ll:it
inhalants,chemicals),noted that at the beginning of a reaction,the patient
doesnc
showed stimulatory symptoms which could last varying lengths of time
reactior
(period of development of adaptation to the substance).After the stimula-
ficulties
tory phase,the patient showed signs of depression(withdrawal reaction as
bronch
a loss of adaptation or maladaptation response).The graph below shows that phenomenon.
Therefo levels-l
*Randolph,Theron.EnvironmentalMedicine-Beginningsand Biographiesof Clinical Ecology.CitizenPrinting,Fort Collins,Colorado,1987.
the ten< -4 and festatio
c0ntact withreactive substance
ENVIR
stimulatory symptoms
The cor Dr. The
clear
Reaofl
alternating stimulatory
_>
with n<
withdrawal symptoms
withdrawal symptoms
ventilat over th properl and apl toms o Unit (E
(From O'Banion,D.R., Ecological and NutritionalTreatment of Health Disorders,7987, p. 68. CharlesC. Thomas,Publisher,Springfield,Illinois)
Often the frequenry of the stimulatory and depressivephasedependson the amount of contactwith the substance. The amplitude of thesereactions dependson the characteristicsof the substanceand the individual reactivity of the patient. Many levelsof these reactionsare characteristicof CNS manifestations such as excitability,nervousness, confusion and depression.Levels+1 and +2 are reactionscharacteristic of the adaptiveresponseand the patient usually
Ver or regu tions (r allerger ously (r determ Inr noise," param( enters
D r .J . K r o p
47
f time
doesnot seekhelp from a doctor.The beginning of depressive(withdrawal) reactionsat levels-1 and -2 givessystemicsymptoms such as tiredness,dif-
rmula-
ficulties in concentrating, headache etc. and/or local reactions, including
.ion as
bronchitis, asthma or diarrhea,which prompt the patient to seea doctor.
shows
Therefore,aft.erstimulatory phase +2, the depressivephase may develop at levels-2 or -3, which is the withdrawal reaction. It is interesting to note that
ratient
the tendencytoward psychiatrictlpes of reaction manifest at levels +4 and -4 and are at the peaks of the sinusoid curve,while classicalallergy manifestationsare at levels-1 and -2 (SeeTable on page48.).
NLT RU ON LITS E N V I R O N M EC NO TA The concept of Environmental Control Units (ECU) was first developed by Dr. Theron Randloph and brought to a state of the art level by Dr. William Reaof Dallas,Texas.It is a segregatedinpatient ward, constructedespecially with no outgassingmaterials (ceramics,steel, porcelain on steel), special ventilation, air filtration and positive air pressureto ensure 100o/ocontrol over the indoor air quality. An ECU is the ideal place for a patient to be properly diagnosed,the appropriate causeof symptoms to be established and appropriatetherapy instituted. The graph on page 49 depicts symptoms of an individual before and after entering an Environmental Control Unit (ECU). 1981,
Very subtle reactions can be difficult to observein a patient's home or regular hospital becausethere are many factorscontributing to the reac-
rds on ctions ctivity ations rnd +2 sually
tions (natural gas,perfumes,tobacco smoke, paints, solvents,foods, coffee, allergenssuch as molds, trees,etc.),which can affectthe patient simultaneously (time period A). Differentiation of causeand effect can be difficult to determine. In order to exclude interfering environmental factors or "background noise," it is important to place a patient in an ECU, where the number of parametersinfluencing a patient is minimal. In time period B, a patient enters the unit and starts to fast, consuming only well tolerated spring
48
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e na tt a T i m e HEALIN
E n v i r o n m e n t a l - p e r si notnear lr e l a t i o n s h i p s
water. ' (headac four to r
, te m ent, IAg i ta ti oenxci Specifically MA N (a i tho rw i th o ut b l a cko uwts, adapted stimulatory convulsions) (hyperresponsiveHYP0MANIA levels panic reactions, anxiety, ness, me n tal al p se s) (restlesslegs, HYPERACTIVITY vercef , ul i n so mnai ag,g re ssifo b e h a vi o u r) (active, selfSTIMULATI0N withsuppressed centered
( bOth ADDICTION DRUG andsynthetic) natur al
In ti The effe A CdUSe t
(addictive ALCOH0LISM drnki i ng) ++
O}IA1{EVEil BEHAVIOUR KEEL,ASIN HOMEOSTASIS ECOLOGIC PHYSICAL Specifically LOCALIZED i nNi tis, T I0 S maladapted MA N IF E S T A(rh d e, rmatitis, a s, sth ma withdrawal b ro n ch i ti g a stro i n te stigneanli,tour inar y levels svndromes) ECOLOGIC PHYSICAL SYSTEMIC (fa ti gNue, MA N IF E S T A T I0 S mya , ralgia, h e a d a ch e , l g iaarth ta,ch ycar dia, a rth ri ties,d e ma a rrh yth mi a ) BRAIN IFFECTS-MODIRATELY SYNDROMES CERIBRAL ADVANCED (mo och d a n g ei rri s, ta b ilitY, i mp a i rethdi n ki nre g ,a ding & me mo ry) a b i l i ty DEPRISSION-ADVANCID CEREBRAL &BEHAVIOURAL (confabulation, SYNDR0MES obsessions, hallucinosis, amnesia) &temporary delusions
(addictive eating) 0BESITY
(thE COMPLAINTS ABSENT wayto feel) desired
ONAN BEHAVIOUR KEEL EVE}I OFTASTE SENSES IMPAIRED L ,T N I E R T ' S A N DS M E LM SYNDROMI
Ashfordt', 2ndediti, lna in speci can be 1 be obfe, It is
VASCULITIS, VESSEL SMALL COLLAGEN HYPERTENSION,
provide
DISEASES
accurat( The
AND CONFUSION MENTAL MOROSE OBFUSCATION,
should diagnor
INEBRIAIION
COMA, STUPOR, DEMTNTIA, CATATONIA, RESIDUAL AMNESIA
R a n d o l p hT , M o s s R . A n A l t e r n a t i v e A p p r o a c h ' l ' o A l l e r g i e s . I . B . L i p p i n c o t C o . , 1 9 8 0
BIOCH This fin No two our ind mins, n
D r .J . K r o p
49
water. There is cessation of previous exposures,withdrawal effects (headache,nausea, etc.), and symptoms continue for some time usually four to sevendays,until patients feel 100o/onormal, the baseline. ln time period C, singlechallengesto suspectincitants are administered. and measuredindividually and The effectof each substancecan be assessed a causeand ffia
relationshipcan be established.
tntryinto Unit [nvironmental
Challenges Begin
ing)
he
A Ashford NicholasA, Miller Claudia S, Chemical Exposures,Low Levelsand High Stakes, 2nd edition. Van NostrandReinhold,1 9 9 8 .
\STE
ln an Environmental Control Unit, specializedtests can be performed in specially constructedbooths, where the concentration of any chemical can be preciselymeasuredand the effectof that chemical on the patient can
lTts,
by carefully monitoring signs and symptoms. be obiectively assessed It is mandatory that any physician practicing Environmental Medicine
JEN
provides a very clean, scent-freeoffice, especiallythe testing area,to assure accuratetest results.
ID
The effects of chemicals, foods or inhalants on a patient's health should be examined and considered before excluding in favour of a diagnosis of a mental or psychological disorder, as is often the case.
tA,
B I O C H E M IICNADLI V I D U A L I T Y This final principle is key to the understandingof environmental medicine. No two individuals are exactlyalike; biological individuality is the basis for our individual susceptibility.We have individual needs of amounts of vitamins, minerals, enzymes,protein, fat, and carbohydratesfor appropriate
)80
50
A tt A T i M C PAtiEN TN : C H E A L I NTGH EP L A N EO
i?.?!X:i|/!Ji/,t1nt!.roi!.tir,/r,!.Wt!,!n?jtl+n?/.i/j:illtNli.r,!.{ar,!itijitJk
function of our organs and particularly our CNS and immune system,so that we are able to respond to environmental factorsthat we are challenged
rilirflE Ind ustrir
with on a daily basis.There are three conditions upon which our biological individuality depends: o Genetic makeup of the fetus (result of the parents'genes) o Health of the mother, toxic burden during pregnancy,nutritional
Tight-Bu
0ccupan
statusof the mother (past e)(posures,Q.8.,workplace) o Individual's toxic body burden in relationship to his/her nutritional statusduring chemical exPosure. The combined outcome of thesethree factorscan createa situation in which the individual has fewer detoxi$ring enzymes,which are neededto rid the
Contami Commun
body of toxins. If the body is unable to detoxi$r fast enough' a situation is set up which can aliow a serious diseaseto develop.There ate over 2000 so-calledinborn errors of metabolism (geneticmetabolic defects),and the "time bomb" only awaiting the opportune number is growing. They are a
Individu
moment when environmental triggerselicit their expression. In summary the development of an environmental sensitivity looks something like this:
INDUCERS Infectious aqents: bacteria Viruses, Yeasts, molds Pollens agents: Chemical solvents Pesticides, Foods, drugs Toxic metals Antibiotics
SUSCEPTIBLE INDIVIDUAL
HYPERSENSITIVE INDIVIDUAL
','Y
According to recent researchof Ashford and Miller, there have emerged four major groups of people sufferingfrom chemicalsensitivities:
Ashford, t Stakes,V
Multipl The foll formula ation, d disorde 7. "Tht 2. "Tht i. "Lol resu
{
r i
i
: w
f
f
i
i
n, SO
nged rgical
ral
vhich d the .on is 200 0 d the rtune loolis
lndustrial WorkersAcute andchronic P r i m a r im l ya l e b s ;l u ec o l l a r ; exposure to industrial 20to 65years old chemicals Tight-Building from 0ff-gassing Females morethanmales; materials. white-collar 0ccupants construction workers office and professionals; equipment office or 20to 65years supplies; tobacco smoke; o l ds; c h o o l c h i l d r e n inadequate ventilation Contaminated Toxic waste sites, aerial Allages, male andfemale; Communities pesticide spraying, maybe children orinfants ground pregnant watercontamina- affected firstor most; tion, aircontamination by women withpossible effects on nearby industryandother fetuses, middle to lower class community exposures I n d i v i dl u sa Heterogeneous; indoor air 70-80% females; 50%30to 50 (domestic), years consumer old(Johnson andRea, products, drugs, and 1989); white, middle to upper pesticides middle class andprofessionals Ashford,Nicholasand Miller, Claudio, Chemical Exposures-Low Levelsand High Stakes,Van NostrandReinhold,N.Y., 1991)
M u l t i p lC e h e m i cS a le n s i t i v i t(yM C S ) The following are consensuscriteria for the diagnosisof MCS, which were formulated by researchers and clinicianswith experiencein the study, evaluation, diagnosisand/or careof adults and children with chemical sensitivity disorders: L. "The sryptnms are reproduciblewith (repeatedchemical) exposure." 2. "The condition is chronic." 3. "Law leuelsof exposure(lower than preuiouslyor commonlytolerated) result in manifestationsof the s'yndrome."
F
F
sz
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e na tt a T i m e HEALIN
zjii::i:lir..;!.!.i::::ti.:iilr..F.iii;ari:;4i!i:.tt?rittiliar.;ttit:iirita;:i.tri:
4. "The symptomsimproueor resoluewhen the incitants are remoued." "Responses occur to multiple chemicallyunrelatedsubstances." 5. 6. (Addedin 7999): Symptomsinuoluemultiple or84n systems.
Full. in the tr seizures wood. I
The only other explicit consensusto have been published on MCS was a lg94 statement of the American Lung Association,the American Medical
should l
Association, the US Environmental Protection Agency, and the US Con"complaints (of MCS) sumer Product Safety Commission, to state that should not be dismissed as psychogenic, and a thorough workup is
Ther
sure. St, to worl. relaxed
essential."It is recommendedthat MCS be diagnosedwhenever all six of the consensuscriteria are met, alongwith any other disordersthat may alSo
cisein a
be present, such as asthma, allergy, migraine, chronic fatigue syndrome
Ap,
of inves
(CFS),and fibromyalgia (FM).
sympto
Archiuesof EnvironmentalMedicine; Muttiple Chemical Sensitivity:A 1999 Consensus, Mayllune 1999 (Vol. 5+ (No.i))
in such
T h eI n i Remember the case history of each person is very individual. While the causes of reactions and symptoms will differ, it is the total body load ' that must be brought under control, and awarenessand knowledge is the first step towards making a positive change. The aim of this handbook is to provide you with information about the elements that can affect an individual's health, and to offer management techniques.
o Cor env. reac sch< phy o Blor pulr the o Test
MEDICO A LF F I C E
o Cot
The ideal medical office will try to achievethe best air quality using chemi-
offi,
cal and particulate filtration systemswith appropriate air exchange,humid-
env
ity levelsand positive air pressure.The floors will be ceramic or hardwood
o Foll
with a non-toxic finish. If cost precludesceramic or porcelain steel walls, plasterwalls are preferableto drywall and painted with low outgassingpaint.
Dr.J. Krop
53
li'i.ia.iti.;!a"4,ti1t:Iriil)7a ai';!41:iaii.;:it?:.iti_j..jrj!iaJjlt;;i;,r.!;iii?!.iii!;i:r:.lr)1f.it:;!i?}i.:.irirr:t:ai:.,it
Full-spectrumincandescentlighting is preferableto fluorescent,certainly in the testing areas,as fluorescentlighting can causereactions,particularly seizures,in some patients.Furniture should be metal or alreadyoutgassed wood. Administrative areasshould be separatefrom testing and lab areas 'as a
should be vented. All supplies should be stored away from patient expo-
lical
sure. Staff should not be using any scentedproducts.
lon-
rcs)
These arrangementsmake everyonehappier and healthier and able
rp is
to work and concentrate better. Patients generally feel better right away, relaxedand confident. Any testing to be carried out is easierand more pre-
ix of
cisein a clean environment. Patientsare provided with a model of the value
also 'ome
of investing in proper air ventilation and filtration. A patient who is suffering from outdoor allergy or chemical exposure q/mptoms should be able to feel relief from such symptoms iust by sitting in such an office for half an hour.
T h eI n i t i a l n v e s t i g a t i oPne r i o d : e the
o Consultation with the doctor, including detailed past, present,and
load
environmental medical history systemreview,past surgeries,adverse
ge is
reactionsto medication and/or supplements,occupational and/or school history dietary analysis,including patterns of eating and
rt the ment
physical examination; o Blood and urine analysis,sputum, mouth, throat, and vaginal swabs, pulmonary function tests,etc. as deemednecessaryby the doctor for the individual patient; o Testingfor food, inhalant, and/or chemical sensitivities; o Counseling(individual or group with trained staff member) involving
remi-
office orientation, four-day rotation diet, addressingwater and
rmid-
environmental control techniques;
wood walls, paint.
o Follow-up visit with the doctor.
r 54
O:N CP A t i C NAtt A T i M C H E A L I NTGH EP L A N E T :::::i:|:::!.)::::|::.:!:|:.:i::j:::|.}::.i.:1:||:.v.):i.|||41:|.,:7:.)!:.1,.1i:!4ii:i;
Testing: Laboratory Most laboratories, and particularly those in Canada, are not able to offer precisetests measuringbiochemical, nutritional and immunological status of the patient. Most laboratoriesuse outdated methods and tests,which are not able to detectand measuresubtle biochemical changes.This unfortunate
After th o Add r Rete (6v tion
situation leads doctors, insurancecompanies and the Workers' Compensa"abnormal" is found but tion Board to label the patient, in whom nothing "p.ywho neverthelessreportsmulti-systemiccomplaints, as sufferingfrom chosomatic" illness. This is an unfair label for many genuinely sick indi-
if yc
viduals, particularly since there is no test to prove psychosomaticdisease, but this diagnosis often seemsto be easierthan finding the causeof illness
Det
alte if y, Add Reft
in our sociopolitical environment. There are laboratoriesavailable in the United Statesthat perform more sophisticatedtests,but they are often dismissedby some criticswhose vested "entrepreneurial"and "non-scientific."Despite interestslie elsewhereaSbeing the critics,there are some very reliable laboratoriesthat can assessthe nutri-
Enviro While r out of r
perfrrm
tional status of the patient. These laboratories are licensed at both the federaland state levels,and the test resultsare acceptedby the United States
office.
medical insurancecompanies.
are sm
family causea
Someof the specializedtestsperformedinclude: o Measurementof intracellular minerals and levels of vitamins, amino acidsand lipids . Assessmentof oxidative damageto the cell o Assessmentof detoxifring ability o Measurementof toxic levels of chemicalsin blood or fat tissue such as solvents,chlorinatedpesticides,herbicides,PCBs,etc. o Assessmentof immune stafus,measurementof immune functions, specificantibodies(formaldehyde,plastics),auto antibodies(CNS, peripheral nervoussystem),etc. o Neuropsychologicaltesting.
Pol other s,
D r .J . K r o p
5s
iri!;i.?i.ii;:it;?.;t:it:ti;+,*,Kirrnjri:.it?.4t:;/ilili:.!//.i:1lj;jja:it:!:!..r1.1:iti;.?n
offer
After the initial period, you may require: . Additional visits with the doctor
tatus
Retestingof the allergy treatment extract-seasonally, for iniectable
h are
(6 weeksprior to the beginning of an antigenseason);upon comple-
lnate
tion of your first bottle of sublingual, and then whenever necessary;
:nsa-
if you have recently experienceda viral infection, it may sometimes
I but "psy-
alter your body's responseand you may require a different extracqor
indi-
Additional counseling (at your request)
iease,
Detoxifi cation, I.V. therapy, immune stimulation
Iness
Referralto other physicians.
more
Environmental 0fficePolicies
ested
While each individual office will set its own policies, generally speaking
:spite
out of care and concem for patients and staff individuals with tobacco or
rutri-
perfirme odours or otherwise scentedclothing will be asked to leave the
h the
office. Some physicians do not accept patients who smoke or whose
itates
family members smoke, and require that the patient and family members
if you suspectyour treatment is not working (symptoms have retumed).
are smoke-free for three months. Tobacco smoke and secondarv smoke causeand compound many health problems. Policiesregardingtestingand procedures,serumordering and re-ordering other seryices,payment, etc.,will be at the discretion of the individual office.
ch as s/ S,
s6
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e natt a T i m e HEALIN
2. Ser
T Y P EO S FT E S T I N G Variousforms of testingfor allergiesor sensitivitiesare usedbasedon individual needs.Most commonly used are SerialDilution Endpoint Titration (SDEIrI) and Provocation/Neutralization.Thesetestswere pioneeredby Drs.
pre
Carleton Lee,Herbert Rinkel and foseph Miller. It was found that introducingvarious dilutions of antigensintradermallynot only produceda whealing
Ad
responseon the skin, but also generalsignsand symptoms.Sublingual testing was pioneered by Dr. LawrenceDickey.All these methods can be used
by,
to test for food, inhalant and chemical allergiesor sensitivities. 1. Provocative/Neutralization (n/N): The patient is systematicallyexposed
pro me ma this anc me:
to a seriesof dilutions of a suspectantigen extract.When symptoms appear (are provoked), a neutralizing dose is found and used in
pre
treatment.Dilutions of an antigencan be administered:
pre,
the skin.
Prir
a) Intradermally-into
Using a syringe a preciseamount of measuredantigen is injected into the skin producing a 4mm wheal. During the ten minutes aft.er
onl
the injection, signs and symptoms are recorded.After ten minutes, the pulse is recorded and the size of the wheal is measured.The
thrr
first strongestnegativewheal, with no symptom, is often the neutralizing dilution and is used for treatment (Miller technique). b) Sublingualty-under the tongue. Using a dropper or syringe,a precisequantity of measuredantigen
ant thir not is tl imr
extract is dropped under the tongue, held for thirty seconds,then swallowed. Pulse,signs and s;rmptomsare measuredand recorded
nor
every five minutes. The dilution after which no signsor symptoms
sanr,
are recorded is the dilution used for therapy. Provocativetesting often uncoversthe causeof chronic symptoms in a
Rac
very convincingway to the patient and is an educationalexperience for patients observingthe reactions.Some patientscan hardly believe
inh
that even minute amounts of their favourite foods or fragrancescan createthe symptomsthat are part of their chronic health problems.
dial Ele, bio ber
,;t',.,:,,:.,:r,r,,,.+,".'tr.,i,,:ia*',,,..),.)'*r:'-r:'-:',,,',,,',,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ,,1
Serial Dilution End-Point Titration (SDEPT):Using a syringe,a ndi-
precisequantity of the suspectantigen is injected into the skin,
.tion
producing a 4mm wheal. After ten minutes, the growth of the wheal is
Drs.
measured.Testingcontinues until two positive wheals are produced.
duc-
A delayedreaction may occur; thereforg all patients treated in this
rling
manner must inform the office the next day to have their arm checked
test-
by a technician. Sincewheal growth is the only determining factor for
used
this technique,severalantigenscan be tested at the same time. SDEItt testing is time-consuming but precise,and discoversthe safe
osed
and oract dose that is used for desensitizationtreatment. It is funda-
1S
mentally different from the standard allergy prick testing and serum preparation used by most so-calledtraditional allergists.It is not only preciseand reliable, but also very safewith no reports of any fatalities. Prick Test This test is primarily used by conventional allergistsand is
:d
only useful as a basic test for inhalant allergr. A drop of undiluted
after
antigen is placed on the patient's forearm or back. A prick of the skin
ttes,
through the drop is performed using a needle.Skin responseis read
e
thirty minutes after the prick.
:U-
The prick test is really only a guide to existing sensitivities,but is not able to define a safe point at which to start immunotherapy. This is the reasonfor which sometimes-fatalreactionscan develop during
rgen r€Il
immunotherapy based on use of the prick test. For all three tests,PiN, Snfpf and Prich, a negativecontrol with
ded
normal saline and a positiuecontrol with histamineare performedat the
lms
same time. 4. Radio-Allergo-Sorbent (RAST)Test This is a blood test and has gor-rd
iina
diagnosticvalues,specifically for IgE-mediatedallergies(primarily
rce
inhalants).
.ieve
Electrodermal Testing (EDT): This testing technique is basedupon
an
bioenergeticregulatorytheory.Various electrodermalequipment (an
ts.
be used,including Dermatron accordingto Voll, Listen,Best,Entero,
ff
s8
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e natt a T i m e HEALIN
Vega,Biomeridian MSA-21,etc.Newer models are computerized.Practitioners use them to assessstressconditions of tissuesor organsto a
and i n
variety of substancesand assesspatients for sensitivities,intolerances, etc. All measuregalvanic skin responseby employing a minute electri-
ever,sc
cal current conducted through a probe to responsiveacupuncture has a unique vibrational characteristic points. Everysubstanceassessed
detoxil
or electromagneticwave,which is conducted by a weak electrical signal through the device,affectingthe autonomic nervous systemof
is a ner
the individual to increaseor decreasesweatproduction. These changes causean increaseor decreasein skin resistance,which is recorded by
good h
the galvanometer.In the caseof environmental medicine screening, neutralizing dosescan be quickly and easily determined and then
family.
confirmed sublingually. The method is time-efficient, accurate,and exposesthe patient to lessStressthan, for example,invasiveneedle
provid,
testing. It is particularly useful for highly sensitivepatients and for
Educa
children. None of thesetestsprovide a medical diagnosis.They are used for screeningand for gathering information. www.healthy.net/ aaabem/EAV/earexplained. htm
symptc until a longer. Wh patien Thr
o hor o sol . en\ . foc o org t saf,
TREATMENTS
o det
There is no easysolution to improvement of the patient's allergies and/or sensitivities;nevertheless,better managementis the key to enhancementof
' unt
health. The principles of EnvironmentalMedicine can be applied to the
D i e ta
treatment of many chronic, degenerativediseaseswith resultant improve-
o Fot
ment of overall well-being. It empowersthe patient and provides the nec-
oem
essarytools to improve and maintain optimal health.
. cot
In the practice of Environmental Medicine, in the absenceof any acute problems,which requireimmediateintervention,the emphasisis placedon
. enl . us€
education, diet, nutrition, detoxification, oral or I.V. chelation for heavy
o elir
metals or cardiovascularand degenerativediseases,exercise/relaxation
O US€
D r .J . K r o p
rac) a :es, :tri'istic
59
a n d i mmu n o th e ra p y. P reventionis pr efer ableto pr escr ibingcountles s symptom-suppressing and side-effect-causing pharmaceuticaldrugs. However,some pharmaceuticaldrugsareused in acutecasesor chronic situations until appropriate recoverycan take place with an effectivenutritional and detoxification prescription. In the caseof Stealth Infections (seepage 292), longer-termuse of antibioticswith appropriateprobiotic supplementation is a necessity.
of nges
by t t
What the patient must realizeis that there is no magic pill. Maintaining good health and preventionof diseaseentailseffort and self-discipline.The patient must take responsibilityfor his/her own health and that of their family. Family support in patient efforts is also crucial. The following is a short description of treatment areas.More details are provided in the ManagementSectionbeginning on page 1g1 of this guide.
t l
Education for
o how environmental factorscan affect the individual sourcesof inhalants and chemicalsat home, work and/or schclol environmentalcontrol at home (creatinga safeand healthy home) food as a causeof symptoms or adversereactions o organic versusinorganic food . safewater supply o detoxification
rd/or
o understandingallergy,anaphylaxisand sensitivities
:nt of o the ,rove: nec-
D i e ta n dN u t r i t i o n o Four-DayRotation Diet . emphasison organic foods
heavy
. correctionof nutritional deficiencies o enhancementof detoxificationand immune system ' use of tolerablevitamin and mineral supplements,oral and I.V "junk r elimination of food"
ation
. use of safewater for drinking and cooking
acute ed on
50
O:N CP A t i C NAtt A T i M C H E A L I NTGH EP L A N E T .i||:.j.,:|:::!;:!::':::|:.i':.1:::::.1::.:|...:|,|.||i':;|):i1!,.i:.|!..!:!..||fi||r!!/|i!',ir?.?|i1|l'!!i!!.;1-+'#iljl!;|.!|f!1'|1:,
Exercise/Relaxation . regUlarand moderate exerciseat least three times per week . adequateoxygenation through proper breathing o positive thinking, meditation
Fi I
II. Subl a) F( b) f. pl
. psychological support if necessary
HowDo Specific
IMMUNOTHERAPY
ment ex dles, the
Therapy Antigen
whereas
Allerry treatment extracts are an infectable or sublingual dilution of the antigen which testing has shown to be the most effective for control of
lingualh
symptoms for the individual. For each antigen that aggravatesan individual, there is a dilution of the same antigen that will improve tolerance
family <
and neutraltze symPtoms'
a readju
Anti the staf{ instructi
WhatAreTheyFor? To improve an individual's toleranceto items that are difficult to avoid, and to desensitizethe individual.
for retes If yc once p€ weekly t
tt{hatElseDoTheyContain?
yourselt
Antigens can be diluted in water, glycerin, or a phenolated saline solution. Phenol-free antigens are also available to accommodate the needs of
your dr
patients who are sensitiveto this substance.
(sDErrf
these p unlike r
Typesof AntigenTheraPY I.
Iniectable: foods, chemicalsand inhalants
and blir Witl
a) basedon SDEPT,P/N methods
year,on
b) Enz'rrmePotentiated Desensitization(EPD) (seepage 267)a highly dilured mixture of antigens(foods, inhalantsand chemicals)
a year o
mixed with beta glucuronidaseenz\r/rneto enhancethe desensitization
needle,
process
nutritio
follow I
Dr.J. Krop
61
II. Sublingual: foods, chemicalsand inhalants a) For individual or mixed subsrances b) for phenolic food compounds (naturally occurringchemicalsin the plant kingdom)
HowDoI TakeThem? Specific written instructions will be given to the patient when their treatment extractis provided. Generally,if the patient has been testedwith nee-
f the rl cif ividance
dles, then their extract will be injected subcutaneously (under the skin), whereasantigenstestedwith drops, or on the EDT device will be taken sublingually (under the tongue). Antigen injections are usually given once a week in the patient,s family doctor's office. If you notice immediate or delayed reactions,notiry the staff before your next injection and insist on a readjustment of the dose basedon the written instructions given. If reactions persist, arrange for retesting.
, and
rtion. ds of
If you require injections more often than once per week or you are unable to make
\
weeklytrips for injections,you can give them to yourself after receiving full instructions in your doctor's office. The iniections based on these precise and individually rested dilutions (SDEI'[ / P/N) are perfectly safe to self-administer, unlike regular allergyshots,for which dilutions are arbitrarilv and blindly defined.
.icals) zation
with EPD, injections are given once every two months during the first year,once everythree months in the secondyear,a+d then, two or three times a year on an individual basisas a maintenancedose.There is a protocol to follow before the needle is given, during the four critical days arouncl the needle,and afterthe needle,that involvesgastrointestinalpreparation, diet, nutritional supplementsand environmentalcontrol.
{
52
O:N CP A t i C NAtt A T i M C H E A L I NTGH EP L A N E T
itt/j:.ji:i!,!!j'!?.!ilijlz!r:r$.!s/il
.,t,iti.it.,.,,,.,
#ltt:i |Ill.'irt::;:: gtti.,i;ii: *.tirtltli:. iiii:lii::ti.
l*:{ti:* *i'ilfii:,:
..*iEf+ii.i
ffift
'ij!!.?;:!:|+.t1?.::4.'!.i:!.ril:jf!!:ittL j:!lL'/t"'ttitt
ii
HowLongWillI Needto TakeThem?
AUTOG
Once again, each patient is individual. A great deal depends on the ability to maintain environmental controls and dietary changes.Some patients
In some
only need a period of time to become desensitized,others feel better using allergy treatment extractson a regular but progressivelyinfrequent basis, and still others require daily or weekly treatment to control symPtoms.This question is best discussedwith your doctor.
tasis,ch have de sometin Europe. in Eurol Asa
Have? lmmunnotherapy WhatEffectCould . Immediate beneficial effect-neutralization, clearing of symptoms; r Delayed beneficial effect-within three to six weeks,the patient will be able to tolerat€ environmental exposuresand foods much better; o Immediate or delayed negativeresponse-more symptoms. If this occurs,discontinue treatment and schedulea retestingappointment.
etc.)to 1 in norrr filtered Testingr negativ€ to 0.5- c volume times p< ity of ca Seel
The goal of treatment is to establish balance, or homeostasis.
D r .J . K r o p
53
A U T O G E N OVUASC C I N E S bility
In some rarecasesof patientswith chronic urinary tract infections,bronchiec-
.ients
tasis,chronic bone infections, etc.,which do not respond to antibiotics or
using
have developed antibiotic resistance,autogenous vaccine is useful and
>asis,
sometimes even life-saving. It has been mostly used and researchedin
. This
Europe. Before antibiotics were widely available this was a major method in Europe to control infections. A sample from the affectedorgan is taken (urine, pus, sputum, biopsy, etc.) to test for culture and sensitivity in a lab. If positive, a sample is placed
s; 'ill be
in normal saline, all bacteriakilled by heat or radiation, and the solution filtered through a 0.221t,bacterial filter and serially diluted by a factor of 5. Testingusing the SDEPTmethod is carried out. 0.05 cc of the first strongest negativewheal is iniected on a daily basis,with an increasingvolume of up
:nt.
to 0.5-0.8 cc. Once the first skin reaction is achieved,return to the previous volume with a negativeskin response.Continue iniecting this volume two times perweek for a period of from sixweeksto three months. In the majority of cases,a complete resolution and healing occurs. SeeResourcesSection.
rt I
I t I
lnhalants, Fungi a n dM o l d s
Inhalantsare airborneparticlesthat we breatheon a daily basis.In fact,it has been statedthat everyday we breathe two tablespoonsof assortedparticles. The averageindividual can deal with these intruders; however, they do add stressto the body. For the allergic person, theseinhalants can be a catastrophe as their body copespoorly with them. For discussion purposes, inhalants can be divided into two groups: indoor and outdoor Listedbelow are the common inhalants testedin many environmental medicine or allergy offices.
I N D O OIR NHALANTS H o u sD e u s (t H D ) o A mixture of whatever is floating in the air, including; lint, mites, danders,insect parts, bacteria,food particles,bits of plants and other particulate matter, bacteria,cosmetics,dirt, feathers,wool fibres, molds, and human epidermis; o The disintegration of household articlesalso contributes to dust (foam, mattresses,fibres).
66
TG H EP L A N E0Tn:eP a t i e natt a T i m e HEALIN
H o u s e h oI lnds e c t (sH H l )
MOLDS
o Insectparts (scales,wings,bit of hard outer shell); o Dried secretionsfrom: - ant, black fly, cockroach,mosquito, fly.
Facts oThei in se
A n i m aDl a n d e r
and r
o Cats and dogs are the usual offenders,but horsesand other animals can also be offenders;
o Fung yeast
o Dander is particlesof hair and skin that cling to the animal's fur; o A sensitivity can develop at any time; Animal salivaand urine can also be a problem; Mohair, alpaca,horse hair, feathersand down tised for textiles and stuffing may also causeproblems.
molc o Thesr IIlilttr
o Fung like < even
D u sM t ites o A microscopic relative
immunotherapy. Short course major Protection against allergens.
levelr orm
of ticks and spiders o Thrive in warm, humid
Molds ter
placesand feed on
found in
human skin scales
be tested . Alter
. Harmful allergensare found in the house
state(
dust mite's fecalpellets
allerg
o Livesprimarily in bed
o Aspe. o Horn
pillows and mattresses, carpet
leath, in air ' Ragweed . TreePollens . Grass Pollens Pollens 'MouldSpores'House DustMite
o Peni< foods
"Dust Mite." Picturecourtesyof BencardAllergy Laboratories.
Note:Oc, environn
V D r .J . K r o p
67
i
ANDFUNGI MOLDS Facts . The inhalation of spores(reproductive part of fungi) causesa reaction in sensitiveindividuals. Once inhaled, sporescan enter the digestive and circulatory system,and therefore symptoms can be wide-ranging. ,als
o Fungi fall into 2 categories: yeast:single-celled,divide to form clusters. mold: multi-celled, grow as branching threads that form colonies. r Thesesimple organismstake their food from plants, animals, decayed matter, paint, pasteand human skin.
rd
. Fungi can grow almost anywhere,'indoorsand out. They particularly like dark, damp places,and can survive at low temperatures.Some can even live through the first frost of the winter. The only time outdoor levels are low is when there has been snow on the ground for five or more days. Molds testedin an environmental medicine office are those most commonly found in the given geographicalarea.Any mold speciesor combination can be tested and treated.They can include: . Alternaria Tenuis: found on plants and plant material. It has been statedto be one of the most common causesof symptoms due to allergyto airborne mold spores. . Aspergillus Fumigatus: found in soil, damp hay, grains, sausage,fruit. o Hormodendrum (Cladosporium): found in decomposingplants, leather,rubber,cloth, paper and other wood products.It is abundant in air samplesand releasedafter rains,and when the weatheris damp" o Penicillium Notatum: found in soil, fruits, breads,cheeseand other foods. A mutant strain of this is used for the medication,penicillin. l{ote:Occasionallyit is necessaryto grow a mold from your own home environment in order to diagnoseand treat your specificsymptoms.
tn::t o 'l**==*r:01',* ,:n:.::'::::_::_:_:::_:_""_,r,_ ,l,t-t-"t . T.O.E.:A combination of three pathogenicfungi: - Tricophyton - Oidomycetis (Candida) - Epidermophyton . Candida: lives on mucous membraneswithin the human body and on the skin.
CANDID Candida, particulal different cific circu involved dependin
e o l disn H o m e s S o u r c eosf A i r b o r nM o Damp rooms with poor ventilation, e.g.flooded, leaky basements, kitchens, shower areasof bathrooms o Carpeting o Closets,drawers,hamperswith damp or unwashed clothing r Storageareas,including fruit cellars
Concern o Cand o Accor cultur festat
o Old upholstered fumiture o Old newspapers,books o Plants,soil and leaves o Humidifiers, unless cleaneddaily . Old wallpaper o Air conditioning systemsleft without cleaning o Window sills
FACTOF . Broa< frien< o Sugar o Birth
Symptoms of MoldAllergy Pattern
Srow o Use<
Increasein symptoms:
o Imm'
o Between5 and 9pM,"cool evening air" o In damp places(woods,leaky basements) r Moving or raking leaves
(Imu . Infan devel
o Sitting on the grass o From Septemberuntil the first heavy frost
o Cene o Nutr
Improvement of symptoms: o In dry, clean areas
o Starv . Expo
o When the temperatureis below freezingand there is snow on the
r Indr,r
ground
lines
Y J
rr
D r .J . K r o p
I
t
'*.!*ffi/ffi3,!j
F ?
:!i jtta:.i:r;i:i::i':,li::ti1:rtii;lr:.|'iii.;i..,,:.,.,,.
t:,:tt:ti:::':,ii
:...':, ':'.: ..r
AA LBICANS CANDID Candida, a yeast, is a pathogen that lives on mucous membranes and particularly in the colon of the gastrointestinaltract. There are about 140 nd on
different candida species,the maiority being pathogenic,which under specific circumstancesare able to causecandidiasis.Any internal organ can be involved in the diseaseprocess,aswell asthe skin and mucous membranes, depending upon the stateof health of the individual (host resistance).
s,
Concerns . Candida createstoxins that weaken the immune system; o According to Europeanstudies,the presenceof any candida in the cultures of any body surfaceor organ is abnormal,'even without manifestation of diseaseand should be prevented and treatedvigorously.
AF E C T I O N NCGA N D I DI N F A C T OC RO S N T R I B U TTIO . Broad-spectrumantibiotics (erythromycin,tetracydine, etc.), which kill friendly bacteria,providing more room for the candida to multiply; o Sugar-richand refined carbohydratediets (yeastfeedson simple sugars); o Birth control pills and pregnancy(hormonal changespromote yeast growth); o Use of steroidsin creamsand tablets; o Immunosuppressanttreatments for cancerand use of cytostatic drugs (lmuran); o Infancl and old age,when the immune system is either not yet fully developed or is beginning to be faulty; o Genetically faulty immune system; o Nutritional deficiencies; o Starvation; o Exposureto chemicalsand subsequentalteration of immune de{'ense; le
. Indwelling cathetersand invasiveprocedures(urinary catheters,central lines for parenteralnutrition);
r O:N CP A t i C NAtt A T i M C H E A L I NTGH EP L A N E T
70
o
Some diseasestates,e.g.,diabetes,leukemia,cancer,high fever;
o
Contact with other people in swimming pools or saunas;
o
Sexualcontact;
o
Poor hygiene and overcrowding;
Cand that is in
Diagno r Discr
Chef Pierre I $ONT KN{^I"/ FOR gUI?E UNTTL I'V6 poNe 50Hg TE5T5..
dida' 9u1 oFfiANp t'p 5AY YOU HAVE A Flll&u5 rdFEcTloll.
a
Yeasl
a
lntra (tyt treat
o Bloo (Seepag if you hi
C a u s ebdy C a n d i d a Typical Symptoms Any symptom from any organ or systemcan be causedby candida.
OUTDO MenandWomen
Fatig ue
"Spacey" feeling
Headache
Depression
loss N u m b n e s s / t i n g l i n gMemory A b d o m i np a li n Bloating/gas
Women
Men
N a s ac lo n g e s t i o n M u s c l e / j opianitn
Earproblems problems Skin
Hives/itching N a iflu n g u s
Athlete's foot pation/diarrhea Consti
Vaginitis
Pelvp i ca i n
V a g i ndails c h a r g e M e n s t r upar ol b l e m s
C r y i nsgp e l l s
sexdrive Decreased
PMS
Prostatitis Jock itch
lmpotence
Infertility
POLLEI o Part . Alth ofn o ltis dtYl Differer on the 1
Dr.J. Krop r!:V.ii4i!4i.!:.a::!il
71
4ll\2?!Ar..:;i!ttitj|l4l.1.;:1l1j17Al::..ia.!j:ar.l::lial:?;t:.i.1::itii!i
Candida infection often causesan allergicresponsein the host individual that is infected.
Cga n d i d a Diagnosin o Discussyour casehistory with a doctor (one that is familiar with candida) and explore all predisposingfactors; o Yeastculture from vagina, mouth, sputum; o Intradermal testing with candida e)ftractto prove systemic reactions (symptoms), as well as to establisha dose of immunotherapy treatmenu . Blood test for candida. (Seepage 229 in the Managementsection for ways to improve your healttr if you have excesscandida.)
I
I NRH A L A N T S OUTDOO POTLENS o Part of the reproduction systemof plants; . Although it is a seasonaloccurrence,the wind can transport it thousands of miles (i.e., from the south during the middle of winter); o It is at its highest in late evening and early moming and is worse on drylwindy days. Different pollens aretestedin eachenvironmentalmedicineofficg depenr{iug on the geographicallocation.
7Z
TG H EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e natt a T i m e HEALIN ra/!:. a!1i!r/ali/.a;//i//.47.Ljlf.il1!!ft
The following pollens are common for Ontario:
TreeMixSl (earlytrees)
TreeMixS2 (latetrees)
MixSl Grass Brome Smooth Fescue Meadow Rye Perennial Timothy
MixS2 Grass June 0uack 0rchard RedTop Vernal Sweet
ea , gA l d e r , S u g aMr a p lT Birch, White Ash, White ilm, American Cottonwood, Common Wormwood Annual Locust, Black Hickory, Pine, Oak, Mulberry, Poplar, Privet Willow, BlackWalnut BlueSpruce,
February to May
WTED MIX Mugwo Redroo E nlgi s h Giant R Short F Russia Sheep Wormw
PATTER forhayandpasture cultivated hayandpasture
May
places, hay,pasture waste
June
pastures lawns, places waste
J ul y
to
to pastures lawns, grass meadow fragrant
MixS1 WEED MIX. WeCd Cocklebur (Curly Dock) Yellowdock places, where there waste Marsh Buryveed water hasbeen Elder Golde r ond Water Hemp Western Lamb's 0uarters
September
to September August J u n et o A u g u s t
lncreasei o Outsir o Ona o While Improven o Indoc . After r . When
c0Nc0 It is possi This is wh ergisticse
August to September J u l yt o A u g u s t M a tyo0 c t o b e r
another.'l qmergisti,
Dr.J. Krop
f
73
MIX. Weed MixS2 WEED Julyto 0ctober Mugwort Redrooted Pigweed Latesummer lawn E n g l i sPhl a n t a i n weed April to September anywhere Giant Ragweed damp August to September ShortRagweed roadsides August to October (Tumbleweed) Russian Thistle June to September (Field Sorrel) Sheep Sorrel M a tyoJ u n e Wormwood
f INHALANT ALLERGY PATTERN OFOUTDOOR SYMPTOMS Increasein symptoms: r Outside, in season a
On a dry, sunny, windy day
a
While mowing the lawn (grassand weed terpens)
lmprovement of syrnptoms: o Indoors with windows closed and/or air-conditioning o After rain rI
r When seasonpasses
f ember IUSt
C O N C O M I TAANNDT S Y N E R G I SSTEI N CS I T I V I T I E S It is possible to be sensitiveto a food only during certain inhalant seasons" This is what is referredto as a concomitant sensitivity.This differs from synergisticsensitivities.In this case,a reaction from one food is made worse by
ember ust ber
another.The following chart outlines some of the known concomitant arrd synergisticpairs.
74
HEALIN TG H EP L A N EOTn: eP a t i e natt a T i m e
When thisis inhaled Ragweed l v aC i l i a t a Sage Pigweed
Andthisis eaten= reaction Milk,Mint Wheat Potato Pork
Grass
Legumes
Cedar Elm
Beef. Yeasts Milk,Mint
Cottonwood
Lettuce
0ak
t g g ,A p p l e C o r nB. a n a n a C a nS e u g aO r ,r a n g e
Pecan
Mesquite Dust
(seafood) 0ysters
w
CHEM
Chemicalr usein ou
Dust
Nuts
own bod
I n f l u e nvzaac c i n e
0nr0n
to reasor
l v aC i l i a t a
Iea
Chenopods
egg
When thisis eaten Corn
Together withthis= reaction Bana na
Beef
Yeasts
C a nS eugar Mitk
0range Mint
tgq
Apple
us. For s sensitivit cem is tl and tranr Since chemical Chemica in Weste FDA star southwel
Wheat Pork
Iea Chicken
Mitk
Chocolate
Cola
Chocolate
Coffee
Cola-Chocolate
Source:D. W, Brown,Ir., M.I). I.redericksburg, Texas,1180
are not r alreadyh food we with pes drink an chemica
Ghemicals
C HE MI C A L S are the buildingblocks of the world as we know it. The items we Chemicals use in our daily life are composedof an arrayof chemical components. Our own bodies function through a complex set of chemical processes.It stands to reason,then, that chemicalsthat we breathe, eat,and touch interactwith us. For some individuals, this interaction causesproblems. The degreeof sensitivityvaries,and any substancecan createdifficulties. Of particular concern is the myriad of man-made and man-mobilized (naturally occurring and transformed by man) chemicals. Since the advent of the chemical industry in the 1940s, thousands of chemicals have been produced and releasedinto the air, water and food. Chemicalsnow contaminateeventhe remotestpartsof the globe. Breastmilk in Westerncountries is so dangerouslycontaminatedthat it would not pass FDA standardsif it were a packagedproduct. In the Easternseaboardand southwesternUnited States(the most highly industrialized parts), mothers are not recommended to breastfeedpast six months, as the baby by then alreadyhas the maximum lifaime amounts of carcinogernin its cells.Wtren the food we eat is grown in nutrient-poor soil, watered with acid rain, sprayed with pesticides, and treated with food additives, and when the water we drink and the air we breathe are also contaminated, is it any wonder that chemicals have been detected in human blood and fat tissue?
76
O:N CP A t i E NAtt A T i M C H E A L I NTGH EP L A N E T
Researchinto toxic levels of some chemical exposureshas occurred; however,the findings do not take all variablesinto consideration.Testsusu-
and the
ally monitor the effectsof one chemical in isolation, when in reality we are exposed to a wide variety. What are the interactive effects?Are the levels
classof
identified as safe for the averageindividual necessarilysafe for the hypersensitive?What are the effectsof long-term exposure?With these questions
househ,
unanswered,we owe it to ourselvesto increaseour awarenessof our chem-
of the cr
ical world.
in the q
also coI forty-or provide
Health Canada and the Ministry of the Environment are two govern-
and loc
ment bodies that should be able to provide you with information about
in your
chemicalsin your surrounding environment. Among the organizationsthat work for our benefit to fight the pollution from chemicals are the World
FACTO
Wildlife Fund and Pollution Probe. Pollution Probe: (416) 926-1907
It has rr
www.pollutio nprobe org
deaths;
World Wildlife Fund: (416) 489-8800
hospita
www.wwf.ca
attacks, any otl
In the following pages,you will find key information pertaining to indoor
growth
and outdoor pollutants. Factsheetson particularly troublesome chemicals
be to er
have also been induded. This material can be overwhelming but remember,
the city
awarenessis the first step towards positive action. With increasedunder-
You
standing comes the ability to control your exposureto chemicals and to
body ar
improve your health. Referto the Managementsection of this book for sug-
(andbr
gestionson how to do iust that.
even fo not po The cle there's
PO OUTDOO RLLUTION "toilet
bowl" ring
the city
of smog is plainly visible on the horizon. Further afield, lakes are devoid of
couple
life, maple trees are dying, the earth's protective ozone layer is threatened,
body.
Outdoor pollution is a visiblethreat.In urban centersthe
D r .J . K r o p
:urred; ts usu-
and the list goes on. We are affectedby pollution, and we, as individuals, also contribute to the problem. According to Pollution Probe, the largest
levels
classof toxic waste generatorsis Canadian households,with an,averageof forty-one litres a year per household. In addition, the averageCanadian
hyper-
household throws away one ton of garbageper year.The following pages
:stions
provide information regardingsourcesof outdoor pollution. Although many
chem-
of the culprits are related to industry don't forget you can make a difference
we are
in the quality of the air we breathe: become aware,be active, rerycle, reusg ovem-
and look for safe alternativesto toxic products. Remember,changesbegin
about
in your own home.
ns that World
TOOUTDOOR CONTRIBUTING POLLUTION FACTORS It has recentlybeen reportedthat toxic air triggersone thousand premature deathsand 5500 hospitalization per year in Toronto. When azone is high, hospitalizations increasein Toronto by over 30o/o.Bad air promotes heart attacks,cardiovasculardisease,asthma and lung cancer.It can contribute to any other disease in the susceptible individual. Pollution affects lung
indoor
growth development and function in children. The effort of societyshould
:micals
be to ensurethat all children can spend at leastpart of their summer out of
ember,
the city.
under-
Your lungs are the gateway for life-giving orygen to every cell in your
and to
body and unfortunately the gatewayfor toxins as well. Ventilate your lungs
or sug-
(and brain) with fresh air asoften aspossible.Going out of the city regularly, even for one or two dap on a weekend into the countryside (but where it's not polluted with pesticides,e.8., orchard areas),can make a difference. The cleanestair is at sealevel. I don't need a double blind study to prove there'sa.differencein my white cat'sfur coat colour when she'sat home in
rl" ring
the city (yellowish) and after she'sbeen at our cottagein the country for a
void of
couple of weeks (crystalwhite). The same thing will happen inside the
rtened,
body.
78
O:N EP A t i C NAtt A T i M C H E A L I NTGH EP L A N E T ktY4:.i?,i7,1,/a#r/ti#4
r Pestic garde o Indus o Asphi . Engin . Barbe o Burni electr o Paint o Sewal . Chen volati
AIRQU, In Ontar cooperat pollutior They Quality I pollutant function Autor their fin< advisory tion, suc peoplew Smogale The I updated Critical Condition: Human Health and the Bnvironment. Editedby Eric Chivian, M.D. et al. The MIT Press, C a m b r i d g e ,M a s s .1 9 9 4 . Photo: JamesNachtwey, Magnunt Photos,lnc.
www (4161
Dr.J. Krop i.{ni1/.lilti/1.?/"+i:i:!.iir;.
7e
tii:fllltaiti?;ii};!!:,}.?;n;!i!f..ri?.in
o Pesticides/herbicides from home lawns, orchards,golf courses,flower gardens,crops, parks o Industrl (metal, paper,rubber, oil refineries,smoke) . Asphalt o Engine exhaust (car,planq diesel, lawn mowers,snowmobiles, etc.) o Barbecues . Buming fuel (paper,wood, garbage,oil, gas,coal and coal-burning electricalpower plants) o Paint o Sewagefumes r Chemicalsleading to acid rain; S0r, N0r, and toxic rain; general volatile substances,PCBs,etc.
A I RQ U A L I TI N YDEX In Ontario, the Ministry of the Environment and Environment Canada cooperativelydeliver air quality advisorieswhen widespreadelevatedair pollution levels are forecast. They rely on two systemsof measurement,the AQI and the API. The Air Quality Index (AQI) measuresand reports on the six most common city air pollutants. The Air Pollution Index (API) is a sub-index of the AQI and its function is to wam of deteriorating air quality. Automatic air monitoring stations are constantly analyzing the air, and their findings are reported to you in news and weather reports. During an advisory people are encouragedto limit activitiesthat contribute to pollution, such as reducing car usage, gas-poweredlawn mowers, etc, Also, people with respiratoryproblems are advisedto limit their outdoor activity. Smog alerts are triggeredif air is poor or very poor. The Ministry of the Environment provides AQI readings for your area, updated once a day: n, M.D. ,tos, Inc.
www.ene.qov.on.ca (4 1 6 )2 4 6 -0 4 1 r
80
H E A L I NTGH EP L A N E T : 0Pn ae t i e natt a T i m e
The folk to AQI:
CARBON MONOXIDE
NITROGTN DIOXIDE e L:
$,'r=t#
€iE5€
(lJ
Q
v,
Y'
q,, n
(:>
E
PEc l
a I
Srrr
SUSPENDE PARTICLES
ivE
-(l) (f,i c)
r-1is P E I lr-r L- l 5 6 O) (/,
c o (cI
o (o
1/'
O) .CJ
c . v o
-...
(J:
'
-.r.
LrJ L
dJ
= g
5ro 9 5 qf,
<) .n
i5
TOTAL REDUCED SULPHUR
(O
o .g
(u o
(T .:l (O CIJ .J
p lr a c t i c e sc a n c o n t a m i n a t et h e g r o u n d w a t e rs y s t e m .C r i t i c a l C o n d i t i o n : How waste-disposa H u m a n I l e a l t h a n d t h e E , n v i r o n m e n t .E d i t e d b y E r i c C h i v i o n , M . D . e t a l . M I ' l ' P r e s s , C a m b r i d g e ,M a s s . 1 9 9 4 .
SULPHUR DIOXIDE
Dr.J. Krop
8l
The following are the six most common city air pollutants contibuting to AQI: CARBON MONOXIDE
gas tasteless Colourless, odourless, A u t o m o bei m l e i s s i oanrsep r i m a rsyo u r c e vision andclumsiness of C0poisoning areblurred Firstsymptoms (occurring at veryhighconcentrations) discomfort for people withheartor cancause Lower concentrations lungdisease
NITROGEN DIOXIDE
gas Toxic, irritating processes, trucks e.9., heating systems, cars, byallcombustion Emitted withwater, it canformacidrain lncombination (lung andacidaerosols irritant) It helps formsmog infection thelungs andlower resistance torespiratory Can irritate C o l o u r l egsassw i t ha s t r o nsgm e l l photochemical onhydrocarbons and bythesun's action Produced nitrogen oxides partof photochemical smog It isthebiggest results in chest tightness, to highconcentrations of ozone Exposure andwheezing coughing eachyear;causes foragricultural croplossin 0ntario Responsible noticeable leafdamage comes f romsources intheUnited More than50%of Ontario's ozone States
ndition Press,
SUSPENDED PARTICLTS
particles in theair of solidor liquid matter thatstaysuspended Small fumes, soot, etc. form of dust, mist, aerosols, smoke. inthe deepintothelungsand lessthan10microns canpenetrate Particles contribute to lungdisease damaqe and corrosion, material soiling, vegetation Canalsocause v i s i b i l irtey d u c t i o n
TOTAL REDUCED SULPHUR
nm i n pg o u nsdusc, ha sh y d r o g seunl p h i d e T h e saer es u l p h u r - c o n t aci o r i l l sc,o k eo v e n s C o mfer o mi n d u s t r isa0l u r c es su c ha sp u l pa n dp a p em a n dr e f i n e r i e s so l u r c es su c ha ss u l p h us rp r i n g s A l s oc o m fer o mn a t u r a (rotten eggsmell) Primary cause of odours or headaches mayiausenausea Veryhighconcentrations
SULPHUR DIOXIDE
t atches C o l o u r l egsasst h a ts m e l l si k eb u r nm breathing cancause discomfort, to highconcentrations Exposure l u n g r e s p i r a t oi lrl yn e sasn da g g r a v a toi of enx i s t i n g a n dh e a rdt i s e a s e s n da g r i c u l t ucr raol p s D a m a gleesa v eosnt r e e a formacidaerosols to acidrainandhelps Contributes
A tt a T i m e PAtiEN T :N C 8 ? . H E A L I NTGH EP L A N E O ::t:t::t::jttt:4..r'tli.iat:ijr:i:a,.)tj.i::rj:i!iiltr:ilF/7]liii:?,iy'iy'r%r4
Remember: ground-level ozofie and the ozone layer in the stratosphere is naturally are not the same. Ozone 20 to 50 km abovethe earth's surface ozone createdand screensus from harmful ultraviolet radiation. Ground-level is harmful to plants, animals and humans'
Below is ment, Fa
Publications source:Ministryof the EnuironmentFax-on-demand t063001Ontario'sAirQuatitylndex,Consumerlnformation
N KI h el
N02
N kr h, e1
N kr h el
TRS
N kr n, e1
S02+ SP
N kr lli
e1 N l(l I ll
pl
Nr
kr hi el
o Krahow Poland, 1997 Artist: Andrzej Mleczho . Ekologia (or how to love nature)
Dr.J. Krop
83
i..1'illi:il!.:??'2't:i,.'1j.ii4|:!:i::!:|:j.:::|:|:|::|:.:.i:::::1!7.::::|:.:.:+:::.::|:*.:'
iphere
turally
Below is the Air Quality Index as provided by the Ministry of the Environment, Fax-on-demandpublication service:
ozone
NO know n harmful effects
NO known harmful effect s
Increasing symptomsIncreasing symptoms in smokers with in non-smokers with heart disease heart disease; blurred vision; some clumsiness
NOZ
No Sl i g h t known 0 0 0 u r harmful effects
0dour
Airsmells andlooks Increasing sensitivity brown; some forasthmatics and increase in bronchial people withbronchitis reactivity in asthmatics
03
NO
NO
known effects
known harmful effects
Respiratory irritation in people sensitive during vigorous people exercise; withheart/lung disorders at risk; some damages very plants sensitive
people Sensitive may Serious respiratory experience irritation effects, evenduring when breathing and lightphysical possible people lungdamageactivity; with physically when heart/lung disorders people with active; at highrisk;more heart/lung disorders vegetation damage at greater risk; damage to some plants
NO
Slight
0dour
Strong odour
known harmful effects
r odou
No known harmful effects
NO
NO
Some decrease in visibility
visibility: Increasing Decreased sensitivity evident forasthmatics soiling and people withbronchitis
effects
No known harmful effects
NO
Damages
Damages some
known harmful effects
s0me
vegetation
increasing 0dours; vegetation damage
h a r muf l
TRS
S02+ SP
SP
Kn0wn h a r muf l
s02
Kn0wn harmful effects
vegetation i nc o m b i nation with
1991
Blood chemistry changes, butno noticeable impairment
0z0ne
Severe odour; some people mayexperience nausea and headaches
Damaqes vegetationIncreased symptoms Significant effects (i.e., people tomatoes, for with forasthmatics white beans) lungdisease andpeople dueto chronic with sulphur dioxide bronchitis
Increasing sensitivity forasthmatics and people withbronchitis
84
H E A L I NTGH EP L A N E T : 0Pn ae t i e nat t a T i m e
A C I DR A I N Nl volatile chemicals,gasesSO, (sulPhurdioxide) and NO, (nitrogen dioxide), aswell as all pesticidesand herbicides,are caught up in clouds and are transported thousands of kilometres from the polluted site. When the clouds release the accumulated moisture they have been carrying, the toxins are transported down to the earth with the rain and are soaked up in the soil. This acid rain depletes the soil of magnesium, the mineral required for effectivefunctioning of chlorophyll in all greenplants. Photosynthesis,the processwhereby green plants absorb carbon dioxide and water and produce oxygen, cannot occur without chlorophyll and/or magnesium. Plants produce all of the earth'soxygen' In uery real terms, aciil rain interferes with the production of oxygen tn sustoinhuman necessctry life. An additional threat is presented W acid rain in respectto hearrymetals. As minerals such as calc i u m a n d ma g n e si u m are remoued from the soil, less nutrient-ilense foods are grown and naturally pressntheavymetals leach out of the soil and enter inn our foods.Plnnts and fooils containing a lower leuel of magnesium afe more susceptibleto m o l d o u e rg ro w th a n d mycotoxin contamination.
OZONE Facts Naturall' . high, o this r . Prod or th Man-ma . punf . canl o indir ozor
MajorS o Crea sewi
Dr.J. Krop
85
. dioxnd are n the & the ed up ineral . Phoe and rnd/or
Fishfry in waterwith a normalpH.
Fishfry in water with a low pH causedby acid rain. When the pH of a water body goesbelowa certainleuel,fish fry either die or, if they suruive,are hatchedwith severedeformities.Source:Environment Canada1982
ozoNE (03) Facts Naturally occurring: . highest concentrationin the upper atmosphere,10-50 km in altitude o this ozone laver absorbs most of the ultraviolet Iight coming to earth o Produced through photochemical action of the sun on hydrocarbons or through electricalstorms Man-made: . pungent, colourlessgas can be very bothersomeeven in small amounts (.0appm) individuals with respiratorydifficulty are parricularlybothered by ozorle
MajoS r ource o created by electricalequipment such as kitchen appliancemotors, sewing machinesand power tool motors;
r A tt A T i M C PAtiCN T :N E H E A L I NTGH EP L A N EO
85
I Electrostaticair cleaners,ion generators,photocopiers,and computers
When th,
and computer Printers;
lessthan
o Presentduring smog conditions, electricalstorms and near power
would bt The r
transmissionlines.
higher th Suns,
O Z O NHEO L E S
Rather,a
Man-made pollution emits a lot of chlorine into the atmospherein the form of chlorofluorocarbons, dischargedfrom air-cooling systems,plastic foam
beneficia
production, propellants used in spraycans,auto exhaust,etc' This chlorine reactswith the ozone in the upper atmosphere (10 to 60 km above) caus-
UVLIG
ing ozone to disappear,thus creating huge holes in the ozone layer. This reducesthe protectivenessof the ozonelayet,allowing an excessof W light to reach the earth. This has a detrimental effect on the food chain in the
W light
animal and plant kingdom by killing plankton, a maior food source.It also causesincreasedincidents of skin cancer. Depending on various conditions, a different amount of LIV light can
or web a:
reach the earth daily; therefore,a [IV Index was created.
thrive be
Organic beneficia plant roc feed the They are
UV-B Degree of Danger Scale: LIV-Bis measuredon a scaleof 0 to 10,with 10 being a typical amount you would receiveon a summer day in the tropics-where [IV-B is at its highest on earth. The higher the number on the UV index, the more IJV
-B you will
with wat can't use I.]Vli deliverir diseasen
get, and the fasterYou'll sunburn.
isms incr vulnerab
What does the UV index mean to me?
usuallys Plant
Over9
extreme
l e s st h a n1 5m i n u t e s
by manu
7-9
high
the frien
4-7
m0derate
20minutes about 30minutes about
0-4
low
thanonehour more
www.m!
own sun
-:_:.::::":
':,i:!.i.!ji.r:Jfi lt:ir
Iters
When the LIV index is over 9, tfV-B is extremelystron& and you will burn in lessthan 15 minutes. (Sunburn times are for light untanned skin, the times would be somewhatlonger for thosewith darker skin.) The maior concern with UV light is development of skin cancer.The higher the I"IV inden the higher the risk for cancer. Sunscreensdo not necessarilyprotect or shield the skin from W light. Rather,a good level of vitamins A, C, E and other anti-oxidants would be
,f orm
beneficial in helping protect the skin from developing cancer.
foam lorine caus-
U VL I G H T
/ light
W light depletesnutrient content in all plants (fruit, vegetablq grain) [see Organic Foodssection page 1491.This is due to the effect of tJV light on the
in the
beneficial microorganism, mycorrhizza, a fungus which lives in the colony
lt also
or web around plant roots. Its role is to deliver nutrients from the soil to the plant roots, and in return the roots deliver "sweets"from photosynthesisto
ht can
feed the fungus. 80% of the world's plants, including crops and forests,
:. This
thrive becauseof the friendly relationship benareenplants and this fungus. They are connectedunderground, which allows the fungus to provide plants with water and nutrients. It can also extract nutrients that plants usually nt you
can't use e.9.,protein from dead organisms.
righest
LIV light stressesthe fungus, which then storesthe nutrients instead of
>uwill.
delivering them to the roots. This encouragesparasites,pathogensand diseasemicrobesto attack the fungi to get at its nutrients. Unfriendly organisms increasein the soil. Plantsweakenedby poor nutrient levels are more vulnerable to attack by malevolent pathogens.The cycle of using pesticides usually startsat this point. Plants protect their leavesfrom UV light, which in excesscan kill them, by manufacturing bioflavinoids. To do this, they need nitrogen deliveredby the friendly fungus which is already compromised, needs nitrogen for its own survivaland doesn't deliverenough to the plant. www. myco rrhiza. ag.utk. edu
H E A L I NTGH EP L A N E T : 0Pnaet i e natt a T i m e
88
r
:..:j:.:|||.|i|li!)t:ii:|;j;:!:iii|:'.+|j,..|!jj:;i;!ai:.i.::..1..|i.i:i:!:|:i:.':.;
LO HR INE S OR G A N O C
P C B-s
Facts
Facts
. organic chemicalscontaining