spine width 41mm MW 200906
Reviews of Handel’s Operas 1704-1726
Jacket: Caricature of Senesino and Faustina Bordoni in...
625 downloads
4436 Views
11MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
spine width 41mm MW 200906
Reviews of Handel’s Operas 1704-1726
Jacket: Caricature of Senesino and Faustina Bordoni in the final scene of Admeto, 1727 (front); Set design by John Devoto for a palace scene (perhaps for Lotario,, 1729 1729) (back).
This volume is a monument to the source-critical method. It is a rigorous investigation of the bewilderingly abundant musical and literary sources of each opera, and its most lasting influence will be on all future editions of Handel’s music. Early Music
HANDEL’S
OPERAS 1726-1741
1726-1741
H
ANDEL ranks with Monteverdi, Mozart, Verdi and Wagner among the supreme masters of opera, yet between 1754 (when Handel was still living) and 1920 not one of his operas was performed anywhere. Their revival in the modern theatre has been among the most remarkable phenomena in the history of the art. But they are still too little understood, or studied, and until recently no reliable modern editions existed. This long-awaited book is the sequel to Handel’s Operas 1704-1726 1704-1726, published in 1987. It is the first study in depth of Handel’s last twentytwo operas, including major masterpieces such as Orlando, Ariodante and Alcina and the brilliant lighter works Partenope, Serse and Imeneo. Each chapter contains a full synopsis and study of the libretto, a detailed assessment of the opera’s musical and dramatic qualities, a performance history and comparison of the different versions. In addition four general chapters throw a vivid light on the historical background. Two Epilogues touch on Handel’s dramatic vision, the revival of his operas in the twentieth century, and their performance today. There are a number of valuable Appendices. Together with its predecessor, the book provides the first complete overview of these works. WINTON DEAN was educated at Harrow and
BOYDELL & BREWER Ltd PO Box 9, Woodbridge IP12 3DF (GB) and 668 Mt Hope Ave, Rochester NY 14620-2731 (US) www.boydell.co.uk / www.boydellandbrewer.com
Handel's Operas 1cut.indd 1
HANDEL’S
Alessandro Admeto, Re di Tessaglia Riccardo Primo, Re d’Inghilterra Siroe, Re di Persia Tolomeo, Re di Egitto Lotario Partenope Poro, Re dell’Indie Ezio Sosarme, Re di Media Orlando Arianna in Creta Ariodante Alcina Atalanta Arminio Giustino Berenice, Regina di Egitto Faramondo Serse Imeneo Deidamia
One of the great monuments of musical scholarship of our day – a mine of information lucidly delivered, sharply stimulating... a pleasure to read for its crisply expressed, infinitely discerning, and above all loving responses to the works themselves. Financial Times
OPERAS
Handel’s Operas, 1726-1741
DEAN
WINTON DEAN
King’s College, Cambridge. It was taking part in a Cambridge stage production of Saul nearly seventy years ago that fired his interest in Handel as a dramatic composer. His first book was on Bizet, followed by his major study Handel’s Dramatic Oratorios and Masques, which set new standards in Handel scholarship, Handel and the Opera Seria, and (as co-author) Handel’s Operas 1704-1726. With Sarah Fuller he edited Handel’s 1704-1726 Giulio Cesare. He has written extensively on other operatic topics, and is the foremost British authority on Handel’s dramatic works.
BOYDELL
26/09/2006 17:20:17
handel’s oper as 1726–1741
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 1
06/10/2006 14:51:02
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view the image on this page please refer to the printed version of this book.
Frontispiece: Plan of Covent Garden Theatre, from Gabriel Dumont, Parallèle de plans des plus belles salles de spectacles…’ (c.1774), plate 20. Image reversed.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 2
06/10/2006 14:51:12
handel’s oper as 1726–1741
Winton Dean
THE BOYDELL PRESS
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 3
06/10/2006 14:51:12
© Winton Dean, 2006 All rights reserved. Except as permitted under current legislation no part of this work may be photocopied, stored in a retrieval system, published, performed in public, adapted, broadcast, transmitted, recorded or reproduced in any form or by any means, without the prior permission of the copyright owner. The right of Winton Dean to be identified as the author of this work has been asserted in accordance with sections 77 and 78 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 First published 2006 The Boydell Press, Woodbridge ISBN 10: 1-84383-268-2 The Boydell Press is an imprint of Boydell & Brewer Ltd PO Box 9, Woodbridge, Suffolk IP12 3DF, UK and of Boydell & Brewer Inc. 668 Mr Hope Avenue, Rochester, NY 14620, USA website: www.boydellandbrewer.com A CIP catalogue record for this publication is available from the British Library This publication is printed on acid-free paper Typeset by Carnegie Book Production, Lancaster Printed in Great Britain by MPG Books Ltd, Cornwall Disclaimer:
Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view these images please refer to the printed version of this book.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 4
06/10/2006 14:51:12
To the Dear Memory of my Wife THALIA (born 7 August 1918; married 4 September 1939; died 10 December 2000)
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 5
06/10/2006 14:51:12
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 6
06/10/2006 14:51:12
Preface
T
his is the second half of what was originally intended as a single-volume study of Handel’s operatic career, undertaken in collaboration with the late John Merrill Knapp in the mid-1960s. It soon became apparent that the plan was too ambitious. No study in depth of Handel’s operas, nearly forty in number and a conspicuous landmark in the history of the Baroque musical theatre, had been published in any language. The amount of unpublished material, both in the scores themselves and linked with their performance and reception, was so vast that we decided to split the work into two volumes, making the break first at the temporary collapse of the Royal Academy of Music in 1728, and then, when it became apparent that this would have resulted in two volumes of unequal size, two years earlier at the arrival of Faustina Bordoni in London in the spring of 1726. The first volume, Handel’s Operas 1704–1726, was published by Oxford University Press in 1987, two years later than planned; a paperback edition, lightly revised by me after J.M.K.’s death in 1993, followed in 1995. Before the completion of the first volume J.M.K. withdrew from the project in circumstances explained in its Preface. He had however contributed some notes, of which I have made occasional use, for the early chapters in the present volume before the decision was taken to move the division back to 1726. The popularity of Handel’s operas after their long neglect, increasing as it were by compound interest over the last half-century, has led to the release from public record offices and private archives of more and more material throwing light on the background, performance and reception of the operas. Handel’s was an age of settled prosperity and increased leisure, at least for the upper and middle classes, with consequently a greater demand for entertainment of all kinds. For the whole period (nearly fifty years) of his residence in England Handel was continually in the public eye as a provider and eventually a national figurehead. His activities were announced, reported and discussed in the rapidly expanding press (not only in London), in pamphlets and in private correspondence. He himself seems to have written relatively few letters; not many have survived, and surely most recipients would have kept any they received. But copious correspondence was a feature of the age, not least among those who could afford to patronise the opera house. Otto Erich Deutsch in his Handel: A Documentary Biography (1955) reaped a fair harvest from this field, which has since yielded a further crop resulting from the researches of Elizabeth Gibson (Owen Swiney’s letters to the Duke of Richmond), Donald Burrows and Rosemary Dunhill (the extensive correspondence of the Harris family), Lowell Lindgren (the letters of Gio. Giacomo Zamboni and the Italian circle in London), Carole Taylor (letters relating to the Opera of the Nobility) and others. The correspondence between Charles Jennens and Edward Holdsworth appeared in Volume 4
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 7
06/10/2006 14:51:12
viii
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
of the Halle Händel-Handbuch, an enlarged version of Deutsch edited by Siegfried Flesch containing further additional material. There is no reason to suppose that all manuscript sources have been exhausted. It is even possible that the minutes and records of the Royal Academy of Music after 1719 may lurk unsuspected in some unexplored archive. Among other recent publications of major importance for the operas are A Catalogue of Handel’s Musical Autographs by Donald Burrows and Martha J. Ronish (1994), John H. Roberts’s nine volumes of Handel Sources (1986), a number of pioneer articles dealing with theatre finances by Robert D. Hume and Judith Milhous, and the first fruits of the reconstituted Hallische Händel-Ausgabe (see below). At the time of writing five of the operas covered in this book have appeared, and others are in preparation. It is perhaps worth clarifying one or two misunderstandings arising from reviews of the first volume. The plot summaries in each opera chapter include full stage directions (italicised) taken from autographs and printed librettos. Their importance has been too little recognised. Like the discussions of libretto and music that follow, they reflect Handel’s first performances. The new opera volumes of the Hallische Händel-Ausgabe adopt the same principle. There is overwhelming evidence that Handel took immense care over the original productions, but with rare exceptions such as the second version (December 1720) of Radamisto was casual about revivals when the heat of inspiration had died down and he had to accommodate fresh singers. They cannot be considered on a par with first versions. The sections on source materials at the end of each chapter appear to have been a stumbling-block in some quarters, on the ground that this was the business of the editors of the scores. So of course it is. But as Reinhard Strohm pointed out in his review (Music & Letters, October 1988), it was intended to shorten the road to new critical editions – which I am reliably informed it has done – and conversion into tabulated form ‘simply would not work’. When we embarked on this enterprise some forty years ago, no modern edition of the operas was in existence or even on the horizon. A Society for the republication of Handel’s works had been founded in Halle during the Second World War and had issued a handful of scores, including one opera (Serse). But owing to the political division of Germany the editors in the (then) German Democratic Republic had limited access to the basic sources, nearly all located in the West, and the few volumes they produced were little advance on Chrysander’s nineteenth-century edition, which, though invaluable in its time, was long out of date. Some progress had been made when in June 1984, partly as a result of pressure from the London Handel Institute and the American Handel Society, the decisive step was taken to upgrade the current HHA edition with an international editorial board and full scholarly guidelines. It issued its first volume under this dispensation (anthems) in 1987, the same year as Handel’s Operas 1704–1726, and its first opera (Rinaldo 1711 version) in 1993. There was every reason to include the results of our investigation of the copious, extremely complex and largely unpublished source material relating to the operas. See Annette Landgraf, ‘Halle und die Hallische Händel-Ausgabe – Idee und Verwirklich ung. Ein Exkurs in die Jahre 1940–1946’, Georg Friedrich Händel – Ein Lebensinhalt. Gedenkschrift für Bernd Baselt (1934–1993) (Halle an der Saale, 1995), 315–42.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 8
06/10/2006 14:51:12
Preface
ix
Nor is it inconceivable that serious students other than specialists might find it useful to see such matter gathered in one place without being put to the expense of buying the scores. Moreover the material is segregated at the end of each chapter so that fastidious readers can pass by on the other side. In order to confine this volume within reasonable limits I have not repeated the first two chapters in the first volume, ‘Handel as Opera Composer’ and ‘Performance Practice’, though of course they are equally applicable here. Portions of the chapters on Atalanta, Giustino and Serse have appeared in Festschriften for O.W. Neighbour, Andrew Porter and Daniel Heartz. While working on this book over many years I have accumulated a huge number of debts to public and private libraries and to individual scholars, colleagues and friends. Most of my acknowledgements in the Preface to Handel’s Operas 1704–1726 still apply. Anyone who has worked on Handel must make obeisance to the great institutions that hold nearly all his autographs, performing scores and contemporary parts: the British Library, London; the Fitzwilliam Museum, Cambridge; the Staats- und Universitätsbibliothek Carl von Ossietzky, Hamburg; and the Henry Watson Music Library, Manchester (the Newman Flower Collection). Their staffs have been unfailingly helpful, both in person and correspondence, and in supplying microfilms. So have those of the following institutions, whose holdings, while less extensive, have often proved of great importance: the Bodleian Library, Oxford; the Rowe Library, King’s College, Cambridge; the Royal College of Music; the Royal Academy of Music; the National Library of Scotland, Edinburgh; the Hampshire Record Office, Winchester; the Berlin Staatsbibliothek, Preussischer Kulturbesitz; the Herzog August Bibliothek, Wolfenbüttel; the Niedersächsische Landesbibliothek, Hanover; the Stadtbibliothek, Brunswick; the Oesterreichische Nationalbibliothek, Vienna; the Bibliothèque Nationale, Paris (Schoelcher Collection); the Bibliothèque Royale, Brussels (Fétis Collection); the Statens Musikbibliotek, Stockholm; the Library of Congress, Washington; the Huntington Library, San Marino, California; and the Music Library of the University of Maryland, College Park (Coopersmith Collection). I exchanged information on the location of librettos in our respective countries with Professor Ellen T. Harris. I owe a more personal and very substantial debt of gratitude to the late Earl and Countess of Malmesbury and the late Gerald and Patricia Coke, who not only allowed me unlimited access to their valuable libraries over a long period but gave me much hospitality as well. (The Malmesbury Collection is now at the Hampshire Record Office, the Coke Collection at the Foundling Museum, London.) Others no longer living who gave me assistance in various ways were, in the early stages Professor Jens Peter Larsen, Professor Howard Brown, Dr James Hall, Philip Radcliffe and Charles Cudworth, and over a longer period Professor Bernd Baselt and Otto Gossmann. The late Lord Shaftesbury allowed me to examine his manuscript collection before it was purchased by Gerald Coke. Others to whom I owe a sometimes very considerable debt, in addition to what I derive from their work listed above, include Professor Donald Burrows, on whom
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 9
06/10/2006 14:51:13
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
I have relied for details of paper, watermarks and rastration; Dr Terence Best (and through him the members of the Halle editorial office); Professor Reinhard Strohm; Professor Robert D. Hume; Professor Judith Milhous; Professor John Roberts; Dr Sarah Fuller-Lessard; Dr Sarah McCleave; Professor Curtis Price; Professor Brian Trowell; Professor Manfred Rätzer; Professor Lorenzo Bianconi; Professor Lowell Lindgren; Professor Colin Timms; Dr Elizabeth Gibson; Oliver Neighbour; Bruce Phillips and especially Anthony Hicks, who read the book in typescript, dug out some mistakes, and made a great many helpful suggestions, rendering particular assistance with the Appendices. If the lapse of time has removed any other benefactors from my memory, I ask their forgiveness. Finally I thank Mrs Gabrielle Mabley, who typed the whole book, much of it twice, and triumphed over the obstacles presented by my handwriting; Dr Nigel Fortune for applying his eagle eye to scrutinising and amending the proofs; and my son Stephen for manifold assistance and support and for compiling the index.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 10
06/10/2006 14:51:13
contents
List of illustrations Abbreviations
xiii xv
Note on the text
xvii
Note on sources
xviii
1 The Rival Queens 1726–1728
1
2 Alessandro
10
3 Admeto, Re di Tessaglia
36
4 Riccardo Primo, Re d’Inghilterra
62
5 Siroe, Re di Persia
88
6 Tolomeo, Re di Egitto
108
7 The ‘Second Academy’ 1729–1734
125
8 Lotario
137
9 Partenope
151
10 Poro, Re dell’Indie
169
11 Ezio
194
12 Sosarme, Re di Media
210
13 Orlando
235
14 Arianna in Creta
256
15 Covent Garden 1734–1737
274
16 Ariodante
285
17 Alcina
312
18 Atalanta
335
19 Arminio
349
20 Giustino
362
21 Berenice, Regina di Egitto
380
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 11
06/10/2006 14:51:13
xii
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
22 The Last Operas 1738–1741
393
23 Faramondo
401
24 Serse
417
25 Imeneo
448
26 Deidamia
471
Epilogue 1 From Oratorio to Opera Epilogue 2 Handel’s Operas on the Modern Stage
484 487
Appendices A. Structural Analysis B. Instrumentation C. Performances during Handel’s Life D. Borrowings E. Modern Stage Productions to end of 2005
493 494 495 503 512
Select Bibliography
541
Index of Handel’s Works
547
General Index
550
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 12
06/10/2006 14:51:13
list of illustr ations
Frontispiece: Plan of Covent Garden Theatre, from Gabriel Dumont, Parallèle de plans des plus belles salles de spectacles …’ (c.1774), plate 20. Image reversed. Plates (between pp.332–333): 1. Two theatre sets by Servandoni, ink with grey and brown wash: (a) fortified city wall; (b) city wall breached. 2. Alessandro autograph, suppressed duettino ‘Amo, spero’ (Tassile and Lisaura) in Act II scene 3 (1726). 3. (a) Caricature of Senesino and Faustina Bordoni in the final scene of Admeto (1727, from An Epistle from S-r S-o to S-a F-a …) (b) Design by John Devoto for a Prison Scene, perhaps for Lotario (1729), pen, ink and watercolour. 4. Genserico, abandoned autograph draft adapted for Siroe (aria ‘Chi è più fedele’), c.1727. 5. Siroe, S2 copy with cut and amendments by Handel ?during original run (1728). 6. Set design by John Devoto for a Palace Scene (perhaps for Lotario, 1729). 7. Set design by John Devoto for a Palace Chamber (perhaps for Ezio, 1731). 8. (a) Titus l’Empereur, aria ‘Mi restano le lagrime’: text used in Alcina, music in Ezio (‘Peni tu per un’ingrata’), 1731. (b) Dionisio re di Portogallo, opening scene of autograph, adapted for Sosarme (1731/2). 9. Orlando autograph, part of Act II finale, showing 5/8 bars (1732). 10. Ariodante autograph, sketches for Act II dream pantomime ballet (1734). 11. Alcina autograph, opening of chorus ‘Dall’orror’ in Act III finale, with singers’ names (1735). 12. Ariodante cembalo score (?S4 copy), bass of unidentified aria ‘Se rende nel cor mio’ for Conti replacing ‘Dopo notte’ in Act III (April 1736).
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 13
06/10/2006 14:51:13
xiv
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
13. Jupiter in Argos, opening of autograph draft with cues for insertions from earlier works (1738). 14. Ariodante, copy of ‘Scherza infida’ with vocal embellishments (?c.1740). 15. Rossane, manuscript libretto sent for censorship, adapted from Alessandro, produced at King’s Theatre, 1743. 16. Rossane, manuscript libretto sent for censorship, 1743, opening of Act I. The author and publishers would like to thank the following institutions for their kind permission to use the illustrations reproduced in this book. Frontispiece: the Syndics of Cambridge University Library [LE.41.17, plate 20]; 1a and b: Albertina Museum, Vienna [inv. 1296 and 1297]; 2: British Library © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved [RM 20 a 5, f.61v.]; 3a: British Library © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved [Printed Books, 11630.h.62], 3b: Harvard Theatre Collection, The Houghton Library, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA [pfMS.Thr.200]; 4: British Library © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved [RM 20 c 9, ff.31v., and 32r.]; 5: Bibliothèque Royale de Belgique, Brussels [Fétis MUS MS II 3976, formerly MS 2540, ff.80r. and v.]; 6: British Museum © Copyright the Trustees of the British Museum [1891-6-27-1 (50)]: 7: British Museum © Copyright the Trustees of the British Museum [1891-6-27-1 (28)]; 8a: British Library © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved [RM 20 d 2, f.55v.]: 8b: British Library © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved [RM 20 c 10, f.5v.]: 9: British Library © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved [RM 20 b 8, f.56r.]; 10: British Library © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved (RM 20 a 7, f.61v.]; 11: British Library © British Library Board. All Rights Reserved [RM 20 a 4, f.81v.]; 12: Staats- und Universitätsbibliothek Carl von Ossietzky, Hamburg [MA/1006a, f.80r.]; 13: the Syndics of The Fitzwilliam Museum, Cambridge [MU MS 258, p.35]; 14: Copyright of The Royal Academy of Music, London [MS 139, f.70r.); 15 and 16: Huntington Library, San Marino, CA [Larpent MS 41].
Disclaimer: Some images in the printed version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. To view these images please refer to the printed version of this book.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 14
06/10/2006 14:51:13
ABBREVIATIONS
Add. MS Additional Manuscripts, British Library Baselt, Verzeichnis B. Baselt: Händel-Handbuch 1–3. Thematisch-systematisches Verzeichnis. 1: Bühnenwerke. 2: Oratorische Werke, Vokale Kammermusik, Kirchenmusik. 3: Instrumentalmusik (Leipzig, 1978, 1984, 1986) Best, Twenty Overtures G. F. Handel, Twenty Overtures in Authentic Keyboard Arrangements, ed. T. Best (London and Sevenoaks, 1985–6) BL British Library Burrows and Dunhill D. Burrows and R. Dunhill: Music and Theatre in Handel’s World. The Family Papers of James Harris 1732–1780 (Oxford, 2002) Burrows and Ronish D. Burrows and M. J. Ronish: A Catalogue of Handel’s Musical Autographs (Oxford, 1994) Clausen H.-D. Clausen: Händels Direktionspartituren (‘Handexemplare’), Hamburger Beiträge zur Musikwissenschaft, 7 (Hamburg, 1972) Coke Harvester Microform, The Gerald Coke Handel Collection (Catalogue, 1988) Deutsch O. E. Deutsch: Handel: A Documentary Biography (London, 1955; repr. 1974) Flower Newman Flower Collection, Manchester Central Library GHB Göttinger Händel-Beiträge, 1984– Gibson E. Gibson: The Royal Academy of Music (1719–1728): The Institution and Its Directors (New York, 1989) Granville Granville Collection, British Library (Egerton MSS 2910–46) HG Händel-Gesellschaft edition (ed. F. Chrysander) HHA Hallische Händel-Ausgabe HHB Händel-Handbuch, 1–3: Verzeichnis (Leipzig, 1978–85) Händel-Handbuch, 4: Dokumente zu Leben und Schaffen (Leipzig, 1986; revision of Deutsch) HJb Händel-Jahrbuch, 1928–33, 1955– HWV Verzeichnis der Werke Georg Friedrich Händels Handel’s Operas I W. Dean and J. M. Knapp: Handel’s Operas 1704–1726 (Oxford, 1987; rev. 1995) JAMS Journal of the American Musicological Society JRMA Journal of the Royal Musical Association
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 15
06/10/2006 14:51:13
xvi
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
Lennard
Barrett Lennard Collection, Fitzwilliam Museum, Cambridge (MU MS 789–855) Lindgren, Bononcini L. Lindgren: ‘A Bibliographical Scrutiny of Dramatic Works set by Giovanni and His Brother Antonio Maria Bononcini’ (Ph.D. dissertation, Harvard University, 1972) Lindgren, Zamboni L. Lindgren: ‘Musicians and Librettists in the Correspondence of Gio. Giacomo Zamboni (Oxford, Bodleian Library MSS Rawlinson Letters 116–138’, Research Chronicle of the Royal Musical Association 24 (1991) M & L Music & Letters MQ Musical Quarterly MT Musical Times Music and Theatre N. Fortune (ed.): Music and Theatre. Essays in Honour of Winton Dean (Cambridge, 1987) PRMA Proceedings [later Journal] of the Royal Musical Association RM Royal Music Collection, British Library Smith, Descriptive Catalogue W. C. Smith: Handel: A Descriptive Catalogue of the Early Editions (London, 1960; rev. 1970) Strohm, Essays R. Strohm: Essays on Handel and Italian Opera (Cambridge, 1985) Taylor, Italian Operagoing C. Taylor: ‘Italian Operagoing in London, 1700–1745’ (Ph.D. dissertation, Syracuse University, 1991)
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 16
06/10/2006 14:51:13
Note on the text
Unless otherwise qualified, references in the text to Clausen, Deutsch, Eisenschmidt, Leichtentritt and Mainwaring are to the items cited in the Bibliography; references to Dent are to his chapter on the operas in Handel: A Symposium; references to Burney are to the 1935 edition of his History, where the operas are indexed under ‘Operas, Handel’. Unattributed quotations are taken from Deutsch (English edition). The revised German edition of Deutsch (Händel-Handbuch 4), published without consultation with British and American scholars, expands the German sources and adds some other details, notably the Jennens–Holdsworth correspondence, but omits much significant material and repeats a good many mistakes in the English edition. Virgole are inverted commas printed in the margins of librettos, indicating passages omitted in performance. Stage directions in libretto summaries are italicised. The Colman Opera Register was not compiled by Colman since the entries continue after the date of his death. The Register is reproduced in K. Sasse, ‘Opera Register from 1712 to 1735 (Colman-Register)’, HJb (1959), 199–223. Performing scores and other manuscripts with prefix MA are in the Staats- und Universitätsbibliothek, Hamburg. Pitches are identified by the Helmholtz system, where middle C is identified as c’, the C above as c’’ and the C above that as c’’’, similarly the C below middle C is identified as c, the c below that as C. The Gregorian calendar (NS) was adopted in Britain in 1752. Dates are given in Old Style (OS) except where specified. Occasionally both forms are given.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 17
06/10/2006 14:51:13
NOTE ON SOURCES
The voluminous manuscript sources on which this study, like its predecessor, is based require a brief description. The celebrated collection of autographs in the Royal Music Collection at the British Library, the fifteen volumes of miscellaneous works and fragments, many of them autograph, in the Fitzwilliam Museum, Cambridge, and the substantial body of Handel’s performing scores in the Staatsund Universitätsbibliothek Carl von Ossietzky, Hamburg, have long been available. Chrysander used the autographs and performing scores (chiefly the latter) in preparing his edition, but did not print or mention a sizeable proportion of their contents, and was not primarily concerned with the light they throw on Handel’s method of work. Although aware of the Fitzwilliam manuscripts, he did not incorporate their evidence. All three collections have yielded much fresh information. They are far from exhausting the sources, even of primary material. In addition to the performing scores, five large eighteenth-century collections of Handel manuscript copies survive, cited as follows: (i) Malmesbury: copied for Elizabeth Legh, who died in August 1734, thereby supplying a terminal date; now owned by the Earl of Malmesbury (microfilm in the Hampshire Record Office, Winchester); (ii) Flower: copied for Charles Jennens, whence it passed to the Earls of Aylesford; most of it was bought by Sir Newman Flower and is now in the Henry Watson Music Library, Manchester, but a number of volumes are in the Royal Music Collection and elsewhere; (iii) Shaftesbury: copied from about 1736 for the Fourth Earl of Shaftesbury, since 1987 in the Gerald Coke Collection; (iv) Lennard: copied c.1736–41, possibly for Handel’s publisher John Walsh the younger; later owned by H. Barrett Lennard, who left it to the Fitzwilliam Museum, Cambridge; (v) Granville: Copied for Bernard Granville (the operas c.1740–43), now among the Egerton MSS at the British Library. Flower contains volumes of widely varying date and importance, including unperformed music copied from the autographs and a few passages whose originals have been lost. It has interesting annotations by Jennens, but its most remarkable Cited as Aylesford to distinguish them from those in Manchester. The bulk of this collection disappeared from view in 1855 and was only rediscovered in 1983.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 18
06/10/2006 14:51:13
Note on Sources
xix
feature is an almost complete collection of vocal and instrumental parts. They were never used in performance, and it is not known why Jennens required them, but in the absence of Handel’s theatre parts they throw light on the practice of a copyist from Handel’s circle (generally S2, who was probably a member of Handel’s orchestra) in extracting parts from a score. They can clarify doubtful details, but occasionally misinterpret Handel’s intentions. They omit overtures, presumably because they were available in print, and secco recitatives, and sometimes accompagnatos and sinfonias. They never include every aria in an opera, omitting not only those requiring unusual or elaborate forces, which Jennens might not have required, but others as well. Since the movements present are invariably numbered in sequence, we know that nothing has been removed, whether by design or accident. In no case do the contents reflect any surviving source. The principle of selection remains a mystery. With the possible exception of the parts, none of the music in these collections was intended for public performance. They are library copies, and therefore contain alternative and rejected versions often missing from the performing scores. Ranking with them is the large modern collection assembled by the late Gerald Coke (augmented since his death), now at the Foundling Museum in London. It contains much manuscript material relevant to the operas, from complete scores to selections and miscellanies, copied by professional and amateur scribes (with occasional ornamentation by singers) and a few sets of parts. The British Library (Royal Music and Additional MSS) and Hamburg collections hold many important sources in addition to those listed above. Smaller collections and single items of varying significance (not all directly linked to the operas in the present volume) are to be found in Berlin, Munich, Weimar, Kassel, Wiesentheid, Vienna, Stockholm, Washington, Tokyo, Oxford, Cambridge, Cardiff, Durham, and the Royal Academy of Music and Royal College of Music, London. Some of the Shaftesbury, Coke and Royal Music copies contain autograph insertions. The contemporary scores published by the Walshes, father and son, omit secco recitatives and occasionally other movements, and vary in the details of instrumentation supplied. Their habit of substituting da capo for dal segno in most but not all arias, omitting lead-back ritornellos, may have been designed to save space (and type). It is shared by many volumes in the Lennard Collection and seems to have originated with Handel’s chief copyist, J. C. Smith senior. If the opera was popular, the Walshes published one or two groups of Favourite Songs and an arrangement for amateur flautists. They also issued collections of overtures, in score, parts and keyboard arrangement. For the full assessment of this material it is essential to study, and if possible identify, and date the copyists. Much valuable preliminary work was done by Jens Peter Larsen in his book on Messiah and Hans Dieter Clausen in his study of the performing scores. Clausen’s work however was virtually confined to the contents of the Hamburg library, and Larsen did not have access to Flower and was unaware of the Malmesbury, Shaftesbury and Coke Collections. The symbols for copyists they propounded are thankfully adopted here where applicable: Handel’s Messiah, Origins, Composition, Sources (London, 1957). Händels Direktionspartituren (‘Handexemplare’) (Hamburg, 1972).
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 19
06/10/2006 14:51:13
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
xx S1–S13
the Smith circle
RM1–RM9 Royal Music Library Hb 1, 2, and H1–12 Hamburg Staats- und Universitätsbibliothek Of the additional copyists identified by Greek letters in Handel’s Operas 1704–1726 only Kappa and Lambda seem to have been still active during the years covered by this volume, and then only c.1728–29. I have added three more: [Mu (1720)
BL Add. MS 31562 (Radamisto)]
Nu (c.1729–35)
Flower MS 130 Hd4, v. 51 (Arianna) [and RM 18 c 4, Flavio aria]
Xi (mid-late 1730s) BL Add. MS 31572 (arias); Hamburg MA 165 (Alcina), MB 1654 (bass arias); parts – often in collaboration – in Durham (Esther), Coke 3 (Alexander’s Feast), 16 (Arianna) and 17 (Arminio); Flower (Arianna, v. 59–62). The copyist of Royal Academy of Music MSS 138–40 (opera arias, date uncertain, possibly c.1740) has been conjecturally identified by John Roberts with William Savage, who sang under Handel as boy and man from 1735. Excerpts from the operas copied by many unidentified hands, professional and amateur, occur in contemporary manuscripts, notably in the Coke Collection. The librettos on sale in the theatre, which served as programmes and listed casts, can generally be accepted as accurate for first performances. Those issued for revivals are less reliable; they were sometimes amended before sale by hand or hastily printed addenda, and occasionally later by members of the audience. For a few revivals a libretto has not yet been found (see Appendix C). All have their value in determining the texts of Handel’s performances. Note. Manuscripts in the British Library and elsewhere are numbered by folio, those in the Fitzwilliam Museum by page.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 20
06/10/2006 14:51:14
chapter 1 The Rival Queens 1726–1728
T
he Royal Academy of Music’s final years were and are notorious for the rivalry between the two greatest sopranos of the age and the scandal it provoked. Faustina Bordoni’s engagement for London had been projected as early as 30 March 1723, ‘as soon as Cuzzoni’s Time is up’ in the words of The London Journal, only a few weeks after Cuzzoni’s arrival. Competition was not then in view. The two nightingales held sway together without apparent casualty in C. F. Pollarolo’s Ariodante in Venice in 1718, since when Faustina had won increasing fame in Italy. She had strong support from Owen Swiney, the Academy’s agent there, through whom she was contracted in June 1725. According to Hawkins, Handel had had enough of Cuzzoni’s ‘rebellious spirit’ and wanted to get rid of her. However, Riva’s letter to Muratori of 7 September 1725, quoted below, implies that both singers were engaged for three seasons. The London Journal stated on 4 September that Faustina was ‘to rival Signiora Cuzzoni’ for a salary of £2,500. It is not clear whether this was supposed to cover one, two or three seasons. In any case it was probably a guess. Different figures have been quoted, but it seems likely that Cuzzoni, Faustina and Senesino were each paid something in the region of 1,500 guineas for a season; and they may have received as much again from benefits. The equivalent today would be astronomical. Faustina arrived in March 1726 after an engagement in Vienna and made her début on 5 May in Handel’s Alessandro, the last opera of the season. Odious comparisons were soon afoot. Antonio Cocchi heard Faustina for the first time on 12 May and considered her ‘far inferior to Cuzzoni’, an impression he confirmed on a second For the Royal Academy’s seasons up to the arrival of Faustina Bordoni in March 1726 and the constitution under which the Academy operated, see Handel’s Operas I. Unattributed quotations in this chapter are taken from Deutsch or Gibson, the latter being the best documented study of these years. It contains the sections devoted to music in Owen Swiney’s letters to the Duke of Richmond. For Swiney (1676–1754) see Gibson and Handel’s Operas I, 321–3. His correspondence with Richmond, while a valuable source, shows him as violently partisan, alternately garrulous, cantankerous and obsequious. He complains repeatedly that the Academy had not paid him his due for, among other things, ‘treating of Damned Eunuchs with a dish of Chocolate, or Tea’. J. Hawkins, A General History of the Science and Parctice of Music (London, 1776; repr. 1853; facs. 1963), 873. See J. Milhous and R. D. Hume, ‘Opera Salaries in Eighteenth-Century London’, JAMS 46 (1993), 35–6. For a table of performances given by the Royal Academy, see Handel’s Operas I, 308–9.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 1
06/10/2006 14:51:14
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
visit. On 20 May the directors banned the practice of allowing privileged persons on the stage during performances (it had been forbidden before but had crept back), a wise precaution in view of what was to follow. Swiney thought Alessandro a bad choice and expected it to be a failure, but it was a rousing success, in part perhaps for non-musical reasons, attaining thirteen performances in a month. The public flocked to the Haymarket until Senesino’s illness brought the season to an abrupt end on 7 June. Although The British Journal of 4 September 1725 described Faustina as ‘a second Cuzzoni’ their voices and skills – not to mention their characters – were very different. Cuzzoni’s was the higher voice, with a compass about a tone above Faustina’s. Her effective range in her Handel parts was e ’ to b ’’ with a rare top B and low D (and a single b’ in Alessandro), Faustina’s c’ to a’’. Quantz, who heard Admeto and Bononcini’s Astianatte in spring 1727, gives their respective compasses as c’–c’’’ and b –g’’. His assessment of their individual skills won general agreement, and is confirmed by the manner in which Handel wrote for them. Both possessed exceptional powers, perfect intonation and breath control, and taste in embellishments, Faustina’s the more brilliant, Cuzzoni’s the more expressive. Brilliance was Faustina’s supreme quality. According to Hawkins, ‘In the powers of execution, and a distinct manner of singing quick passages, she exceeded Cuzzoni’, whereas the latter commanded ‘a power of expression that frequently melted the audience into tears’. Burney singled out ‘the neatness and velocity’ of Faustina’s divisions and Cuzzoni’s control of crescendo, diminuendo and rubato with ‘a native warble [that] enabled her to execute divisions with such facility as to conceal every appearance of difficulty’. Tosi, a singing teacher of an older generation and a laudator temporis acti, agreed, praising Faustina’s ‘prodigious felicity’ in executing difficulties and Cuzzoni’s ‘delightful, soothing cantabiles’ and command of the Pathetick. There is no question, however, that in character and appearance Faustina was by far the more attractive of the two. She was also the finer actress, and, as Quantz tactfully put it, ‘Cuzzoni’s figure was not advantageous for the stage’. Horace Walpole’s similar opinion is well known. The loyalties of the Academy directors were divided from the start. The seeds of the future strife between Handel’s company and the Opera of the Nobility had perhaps already been sown. Faustina’s engagement had met with opposition even before she left Italy; Swiney, who referred to her as ‘the incomparable Faustina’, considered this ‘very unjust and very unnatural’. Cuzzoni had been the reigning queen and the toast of the town ever since the 1722/23 season and undoubtedly resented the appearance of a rival. The resident Italians – Riva, Rolli, Bononcini, Cocchi, Zamboni and others – who formed a Roman Catholic group in a Protestant city and generally acted together, took her side. She acquired other doughty champions, especially among aristocratic ladies (the men for understandable reasons were more Cocchi’s Diary, quoted in Lindgren, Bononcini, 338. As translated by Burney, History, II, 745–6. Observations on the Florid Song, tr Galliard (London, 1743), 171. For Walpole’s comments and more detailed estimates by Quantz and other contemporaries, see the entries on both singers in The New Grove (1980, 2001).
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 2
06/10/2006 14:51:14
The Rival Queens, 1726–1728
inclined to Faustina), but the split soon widened to embrace all ranks of Society. As in the world of modern football, the partisans became more virulent, or at least more vociferous, than the protagonists; and the press joined in the fun. There were signs of trouble before the 1726/27 season began. It was delayed by the allegedly prolonged illness of Senesino, though Swiney reported from Bologna on 13 August that he had never seen him in better health. Senesino told him that he was not due in London till the latter part of January 1727. The Academy tried but failed to find a replacement, and let the theatre to a company of Italian comedians, who played on non-opera nights till the end of the season. A year before, on 18 December 1725, Daniel Defoe had aired in the Weekly Journal a project for an Academy of Music to perform operas in English (he was to elaborate it in 1728 in a pamphlet entitled Augusta Triumphans, or The Way to make London the most flourishing City in the Universe).10 It provoked a vigorous reply from the Italian party, but the cause gained support. On 19 November 1726 John Rich, proprietor of the Lincoln’s Inn Fields Theatre, revived Bononcini’s Camilla, last heard in 1719, as ‘an English opera’. It captured the town and enjoyed twenty-six performances before the end of the season. The Prologue alluded to Senesino’s constant absence While, twixt his Rival Queens,11 such mutual hate Threats hourly Ruin to yon tuneful State [i.e. the Royal Academy]. A week later Mrs Pendarves wrote ominously to her sister, ‘They say we shall have operas in a fortnight, but I think Madam Sandoni [Cuzzoni] and the Faustina are not perfectly agreed about their parts’. On 10 December Mist’s Weekly Journal published an ironical report: ‘Our last Advices from the Haymarket take Notice of a second Reconcilement between the Rival Queens ... an unhappy Breach being made betwixt them since their first Reconcilement, occasioned by one of them making Mouths at the other while she was singing. This Treaty has been three Months in negotiating, and could never have been brought about had it not been for the great Skill and Address of some of the ablest Ministers of the Royal Academy’. Senesino arrived in mid-December, not the first or the last singer to blame the English climate for damage to his voice, accompanied by his brother Giovanni Bernardi, another castrato, who Swiney thought might come in useful, since he could like Boschi ‘go on and off the Stage without Songs’. Giovanni never reached that eminence, though he sang in at least one concert. The season began at last on 7 January 1727, with seven performances of Ariosti’s Lucio Vero, followed on the 31st by Admeto, which gave Handel another instant success, celebrated by Henry Carey in a laudatory poem published anonymously in the British Journal of 25 March. In February his naturalisation went through both Houses of Parliament with remarkable speed: he applied on the 13th and received the Royal Assent on the 20th. Shortly 10 B. Trowell, ‘Daniel Defoe’s Plan for an Academy of Music at Christ’s Hospital ...’, in Source Materials and the Interpretation of Music, ed. I. Bent (London, 1981), 403–27, and Gibson, 388ff. 11 Nathaniel Lee’s popular tragedy The Rival Queens, or The Death of Alexander the Great (1677) was revived nearly every season. The double link with Handel’s latest opera was a coincidence too happy to ignore.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 3
06/10/2006 14:51:14
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
afterwards, surely as an act of thanksgiving, he embarked on the patriotic opera Riccardo Primo. On 4 April Admeto had its seventeenth successive performance, with Princess Amelia, one of the King’s granddaughters, among the audience. The December ‘Treaty’ was wearing thin: the performance was interrupted by barracking, something tolerated in most circumstances but taboo when a member of the Royal Family was present. On or about the 8th the Countess of Pembroke, a strong Cuzzoni supporter, wrote an apologetic letter to Mrs Charlotte Clayton, Lady of the Bedchamber to the Princess of Wales (Amelia’s mother), claiming that the singer had been told she would be hissed off the stage; she threatened not to appear, but was ordered to do so by Lady Pembroke. She was cat-called in one aria, whereupon her supporters ‘would not suffer the Faustina to speak afterwards’. That was evidently the principal cause of offence. At this point, according to the Daily Journal of 15 April, Faustina fell ‘very ill of the Measles, attended with a high Fever’. Ottone was hastily put on for two performances (11 and 13 April). Then Cuzzoni in turn fell sick; the première of Bononcini’s Astianatte was twice postponed, from 22 April to 6 May, and Handel filled the gap with two performances of Floridante. It was perhaps at this time that Handel added (incomplete) vocal embellishments to a copy of Teofane’s arias transposed down for alto or mezzo-soprano.12 This must have been for an English substitute; no Italian would need it. Teofane had been Cuzzoni’s part in Ottone. Cuzzoni’s illness may have been diplomatic, though one listener reported that her voice ‘was prodigiously out of order on 6 May’ and Faustina’s partisans say ‘very confidently that she will never recover it. Some say it is a great cold, others the Pox, and some that she is breeding.’13 She did not breed till a year later. The libretto of Astianatte goes back to Racine’s Andromaque via Haym’s adaptation of Antonio Salvi’s 1701 libretto for Perti. Bononcini’s opera is not remembered for its music, which according to Burney made little impression and was soon forgotten; he mentions only two arias, both in Cuzzoni’s part, one of which he censures for the ‘aukward and difficult’ divisions in the voice part. Quantz says it was less acclaimed than Admeto, and that Handel’s ‘Grundstimme’ prevailed over Bononcini’s ‘Oberstimme’ (translated in Deutsch as ‘harmonic structure’ and ‘melodic invention’). Only seven Favourite Songs and a minuet were published. Astianatte was Bononcini’s only opera for the Academy after 1724, when the younger Duchess of Marlborough (Sarah’s daughter) engaged him as a household musician to conduct private concerts for £500 a year. It is not known if he continued to play the cello continuo at the Haymarket. The Academy may have hoped to boost its revenue by planning a public contest, as with Muzio Scevola in 1721: on 4 February 1727 the directors had anounced that ‘after the Excellent Opera composed by Mr. Handel [Admeto] ... Signior Attilio [Ariosti] shall compose one: And Signior Bononcini is to compose the next after that. Thus, as this Theatre can boast of the three best Voices in Europe, and the best Instruments; so the Town will have the Pleasure of hearing these three different Stiles of composing’. The directors may have known that Bononcini was considering 12 See Handel: Three Ornamented Arias, ed. W. Dean (Oxford, 1976). 13 Robert Hassell to Robert Cotesworth, 10 May 1727 (Gibson, 252).
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 4
06/10/2006 14:51:14
The Rival Queens, 1726–1728
an opera on Racine’s play as early as autumn 1725.14 In the event Ariosti’s opera, Teuzzone, was apparently not ready in time and was postponed till the following season. Astianatte retains its place in history thanks to ‘a great Disturbance ... occasioned by the Partisans of the Two Celebrated Rival Ladies’ at its ninth performance on 6 June in the presence of Caroline, Princess of Wales, who was to be queen within a week. ‘The Contention at first was only carried on by Hissing on one Side, and Clapping on the other; but proceeded at length to Catcalls, and other great Indecencies’. These came mostly from the gallery and were so persistent that the opera was never finished.15 A week later Lord Hervey, in a letter to Stephen Fox, gave a vivid description of the event and its repercussions on Society. ‘In short, the whole world is gone mad upon this dispute. No Cuzzonist will go to a tavern with a Faustinian; and the ladies of one party have scratched those of the other out of their list of visits.’ The scandal brought the season as well as the opera to an abrupt end, though the news of George I’s death in Germany on 11 June would in any case have closed the theatre. One of his last acts had been to send the directors a letter informing them that if they did not satisfy Cuzzoni he would refuse to attend the theatre or pay the Academy his usual bounty of £1,000.16 The directors hastily smoothed things out, leaving the way open for a possible da capo with embellishments the following season. All this gave the London press the opportunity of a lifetime. Throughout the summer satirical pamphlets in prose and verse, mostly doggerel and sometimes indecent (jocular speculation about what Senesino could and could not perform), mingled with denunciations of the huge salaries paid to foreigners to utter sentiments that no one could understand.17 The Devil to pay at St. James’s; or A full and true Account of a most horrid and bloody Battle between Madam Faustina and Madam Cuzzoni, advertised in June and July and formerly attributed to John Arbuthnot, charged them with pulling each other’s hair on stage and recommended that they settle the matter in the boxing ring. The Academy’s final season began a month earlier than usual on 20 September 1727 and, apart from three performances of Ariosti’s Teuzzone, was devoted wholly to Handel, whose activity at this time was prodigious. He staged significantly modified versions of three old operas (Admeto, Alessandro and Radamisto), rewrote much of Riccardo Primo in response to the new reign, began an abortive Genserico, and composed two wholly new operas, Siroe and Tolomeo, all before mid-April 1728, not to mention such substantial trifles as four anthems for the coronation of George II. An unexpected feature of this season is the absence of reported hostilities on the Cuzzoni–Faustina front, though relations between them probably remained cool. They sang together at a Crown and Anchor concert in honour of St Cecilia on 22 November, and again in a serenata at the Portuguese Envoy’s residence in Golden Square early in April 1728 to celebrate a double Royal Marriage on the Iberian 14 Lindgren, Bononcini, 377. 15 ‘They jumped from the end of the second act to the coro’, Zamboni to Jacques Le Coq, 13 June (Lindgren, Zamboni, 100). 16 Ibid., 6 June. 17 Many are printed in Gibson, Appendices D and E.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 5
06/10/2006 14:51:14
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
Peninsula. The Envoy subsequently ‘promis’d to repair the Damage done to Golden Square’, doubtless resulting from the provision of ‘a large Cask filled with several Hogsheads of Wine’. Nevertheless, prospects were gloomy. It might be thought that the excitements and scandals would have raised attendances and supplemented the Academy’s coffers. For various reasons such was not the case. Thanks to Senesino’s hypochondria the Academy had mounted only thirty-nine performances in the previous season after an average of nearly sixty in the first six; the stock market had been upset by the discovery at the end of 1726 of a new plot to restore the Pretender; and the huge salaries demanded by the star singers had exhausted the capital guaranteed by the subscribers, some of whom were in arrears with their payments. Hence Mrs Pendarves’s letter of 25 November 1727: ‘I doubt operas will not survive longer than this winter, they are now at their last gasp; the subscription is expired and nobody will renew it. The directors are always squabbling, and they have so many divisions among themselves that I wonder they have not broken up before.’ There was another reason for Mrs Pendarves’s despair. Rich returned to the attack at Lincoln’s Inn Fields with a revival of Camilla in November, and followed it with a more deadly threat, the production of The Beggar’s Opera by Gay and Pepusch on 29 January 1728. The satire at once hit the mark. The proceedings at the Haymarket had become increasingly ridiculous and the champions of opera in English had long been seeking a banner to follow. The result was one of the most sensational successes in the history of the English theatre. Gay wrote to Swift on 15 February that it was affecting audiences at the Haymarket: ‘The outlandish, as they now call it, opera has been so thin of late that some have called that the Beggar’s Opera.’ And on 30 March, ‘The Beggar’s Opera has now been acted thirty-six times, and was as full last night as the first, and as yet there is not the least probability of a thin audience.’ It had sixty-two performances in the Lincoln’s Inn Fields season and twenty more by another company during the summer. Meanwhile the Haymarket season, after struggling on with Siroe, Tolomeo and a revival of Admeto, was cut short yet again, on 1 June, when Faustina was taken ill. The Academy had for some time been making agitated noises about its finances. During each of the last two seasons the directors made three calls on the subscribers, with repeated threats against defaulters. Haym in his dedication of the Tolomeo libretto to the Earl of Albemarle (30 April) appealed to all opera lovers for support. The twenty-first and final call was payable on 24 April 1728. The Academy both owed and was owed considerable debts. All through the winter of 1727–28 and into the spring Faustina complained lustily that money was still due to her from the previous season, and that she had not received the customary gratuities when she sang in private. As late as October 1729 Swiney was still browbeating Richmond with grumbles that he had not been paid in full for his services over several years. On the other side of the balance the directors called a meeting for 3 April 1728 ‘in order to consult with such Measures as may be thought most proper for the speedy Recovery of all their Debts’, and another on 22 May ‘in order to receive any further Proposals that shall be offered for Carrying on the Operas’. On the 25th they sent one subscriber a notice: ‘As the Operas will soon be over & the Royal Opera stands very much
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 6
06/10/2006 14:51:14
The Rival Queens, 1726–1728
indebted to the Performers & others engaged in their Service which in Honour and Justice must be paid, but cannot be done till the Calls are answered. Wee therefore desire you’l please to order the Immediate payments of your last 3 Calls amounting to £21.’ Finally ‘All subscribers are desired to be present’ on 5 June ‘to consider of proper Measures for recovering the Debts due to the Academy, and discharging what is due to Performers, Tradesmen, and others; and also to determine how the Scenes, Cloaths, &c are to be disposed of, if the Operas cannot be continued’. What happened next is still obscure. The generally accepted verdict seems to be that the Academy promptly collapsed. According to Mainwaring, ‘The Nobility would not consent to [Handel’s] design of parting with Senesino, and Handel was determined to have no farther concerns with him ... and thus the Academy ... was at once dissolved’. Hawkins speaks of ‘the disagreement between Handel and the directors of the opera, which terminated in the dissolution of the Royal Academy’. Burney declared himself unable to determine whether the quarrels of the queens or Handel’s disagreement with Senesino ‘precipitated the dissolution of the Royal Academy’. There is confusion here with the events of five years later. The Academy had no intention of giving up. In a letter to Senesino (21 December 1728) Rolli says specifically that the Academy ‘is not yet dissolved’ and at first wanted to have both ladies back.18 Within days after the end of the season Heidegger left for Italy to engage singers for a projected 1728/29 season; he reported that they refused to come, as Faustina and Senesino had been threatening, but he could engage the same singers for 1729/30. The Academy decided to give concerts as a stopgap ‘to entertain the Ladies’. On 6 December it held a meeting to elect a Deputy Governor and Directors for the following year. The result is not known, and the concerts may never have taken place; newspapers neither advertised nor reported them. But this was not the end (see Chapter 7). So far from winding itself up, the Academy set about organising a new subscription. Elizabeth Gibson discovered in the Richmond archives a list – undated but probably from spring 1728 – of thirty-five persons who ‘promise to subscribe the sum of two hundred pounds to the corporation of the Royal Academy of Music towards carrying on of Operas which are to begin in October 1728’.19 The list includes twenty-one former directors. This could lie behind Swiney’s statement on 27 May 1728 that Handel and Heidegger had both told him the Academy had money in the Bank. He added in another letter (undated) that both had promised to support his claims. The necessity of dealing even-handedly with the two prima donnas profoundly affected the structure and quality of the operas Handel wrote for them. On 7 September 1725 (NS) Giuseppe Riva, the Modenese Representative in London, wrote to the historian L. A. Muratori in Rome, in response to an enquiry: ‘For this year and the two following there must be two equal parts in the operas for Cuzzoni and Faustina; Senesino is the chief male character, and his part must be heroic; the other three 18 If this letter is correctly dated, Deutsch (229–30) confuses Heidegger with Handel, whose continental journey was not till the following year. 19 Gibson, 278–9.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 7
06/10/2006 14:51:15
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
male parts must proceed by degrees with three arias each, one in each Act. The duet should be at the end of the second Act, and between the two ladies.’ Handel ignored the last injunction, for reasons that soon became obvious. In any case, only in one opera (Ottone) did he end the second Act with a ladies’ duet. The two preceding conditions presented no difficulty. But the first was absolute; he had to conform, if only to keep the peace. It imposed serious restrictions on both libretto and music. It was no easy matter to find librettos that (a) had equal parts for two sopranos, (b) allowed full scope for the peculiar qualities of each, and (c) created a coherent and convincing drama. It is no surprise that of the five operas Handel wrote for the rival queens only one, Admeto, comes close to establishing a satisfactory balance. The others are pulled out of shape, and though each is full of splendid music none carries conviction as a whole. This accounts for the fact that they have enjoyed fewer revivals on the modern stage than all but two or three of the twenty-eight operas Handel composed from Agrippina in 1709 to Alcina in 1735. Table 1. Instrumentation of the Haymarket orchestra as reported in three accounts Guildhall 10 Oct. 1727 Violins Violas Cellos Double Basses Flutes/Recorders a Oboes a Bassoons Horns Trumpets Timpani Archlute/Theorbo Harpsichords
18 5 2 2 — 6 7 4 2 1 — —
Fougeroux, spring 1728 24 (including violas) — 3 2 present — 3 present presentb — 1 2
Clerk, 5 May 1733 24 (including violas) — 4 2 — 2 4 — — — 1 2
Flutes, recorders and oboes were regularly played by the same players. So on occasion were horns and trumpets.
a
b There are no trumpets in the three operas Fougeroux heard. Did he mistake Handel’s exuberant oboes for clairons? Orlando too has no trumpets but requires recorders and horns.
While a great many words were lavished on singers, the Haymarket orchestra received comparatively little attention. Most contemporaries who mentioned it agreed on its excellence. Quantz said that it ‘consisted for the greater part of Germans, several Italians, and a few Englishmen ... All together, under Handel’s conducting, made an extremely good effect.’ He does not give numbers, and names only Pietro Castrucci who, with his brother Prospero, led it for many years, probably from 1720
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 8
06/10/2006 14:51:15
The Rival Queens, 1726–1728
till 1736,20 and was held in high repute. For further details, apart from those projected in February 1719 for the Academy’s first season,21 we have slightly incomplete accounts by two amateur enthusiasts, Pierre Jacques Fougeroux, a Frenchman making a kind of reverse Grand Tour of southern England in the spring of 1728,22 and Sir John Clerk of Penicuik, who heard Orlando five years later (see Table 1). Fougeroux, who heard Siroe, Tolomeo and Admeto, praised the brilliance of the violins and the ‘grand fracas’ made by the whole band. Clerk said the violins ‘made a terrible noise & often drown’d the voices’; but the Castrucci ‘play’d with great dexterity’.23 Fougeroux’s witness is important for the light it throws on performance practice. He reports that in secco recitatives Handel used two harpsichords, playing one himself, a cello and a theorbo, and cut short the accompanying chords, a practice that Fougeroux disliked because it contradicted the conventions of French opera. The Guildhall concert in Table 1 was at the Lord Mayor’s banquet, attended by the new King George II, when ‘the performers [were] all from the opera and both Theatres and the Musick Composed by Mr. Hendell’.24
20 See Lord Shaftesbury’s letter of 18 January 1737 to James Harris (Burrows and Dunhill, 22). 21 See Handel’s Operas I, 303 and 33–4. 22 W. Dean, ‘A French Traveller’s View of Handel’s Operas’, M & L 55 (1974), 172–8; repr. Essays on Opera (Oxford, 1990), 39–44. 23 See Chapter 13. 24 See D. Burrows, ‘Handel’s London Theatre Orchestra’, Early Music 13 (1985), 349–57.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 9
06/10/2006 14:51:15
chapter 2 Alessandro
T
he action takes place at and around Oxidraca, an Indian city on the Ganges (but unknown to classical geography). The Argument points out that Alexander the Great’s almost single-handed capture of the city, his quarrel with Clito, whom he kills for deriding his claim to be the son of Jupiter, and his passionate love for Rossane ‘are Facts deduced from the History of those Times. But the Amours of Lisaura Scythian Princess with Alexander, as those of Taxilis the Indian King with Lisaura, and the rest, are entirely fabulous.’ Act I begins with a spectacular tour de force: Alessandro, proclaiming himself the son of Jove, by the Means of a Scaling Engine, mounts the Walls of Oxidraca ... The Besieg’d fly at the Approach of Alexander ... He throws himself within the Wall: The Besieged rally thither again, and repulse the Besiegers back with their Scaling-Machine. Leonatus, a Macedonian captain arrives with other Soldiers, and with a Batt’ring Ram to demolish the Wall ... The Wall tumbles; and Alexander is seen among a Heap of slaughter’d Enemies, and defending himself against others, who are all put to flight by Leonatus, and his Macedonians (see Plate 1a and b). Leonato remonstrates with Alessandro for risking his precious life by rushing ahead to ‘gain the Palm alone’. Alessandro prefers a short life with fame and honour. Exeunt all re-entering thro’ the Breach. In an Encampment Rossane and Lisaura, issuing forth, each from her Pavilion, within Sight of the ruin’d Wall. Each loves Alessandro and fears for his fate. Tassile informs them that Oxidraca has fallen and Alessandro is safe. Lisaura would be delighted but for jealousy of her rival. Rossane (Alessandro’s captive) feels much the same, and resolves to exercise all her charms on the victor. Tassile is grateful to Alessandro for restoring his throne but resents him as a rival for Lisaura’s love and prays that he may fall for someone else. In the Breach Alessandro, echoed by Tassile and the three Macedonian captains, Leonato, Cleone and Clito, boasts of his glory and regrets that there are no more worlds to conquer. Cleone flatters him. The ladies enter; he embraces first one, then the other, making both and Tassile jealous. Lisaura resolves to stand it no longer. In an Apartment Rossane laments that all her beauty cannot ‘conquer this unconstant man’. Alessandro asks why she ran away from him; she says she must be the only woman in his life. His reply is ambiguous: he loves but must dissemble. Puzzled, she likens herself to a branch at the mercy of contrary winds but hopes for the best. The three captains confer. Clito asks Cleone, who loves Rossane, how he can tolerate Alessandro as a rival. Cleone disgusts him by replying that it is hopeless to strive against gods. Leonato assures Clito of his friendship. Clito says he will follow Alessandro as his leader, but never flatter him with impious worship. In the Temple of Jupiter Ammon; with the Statues of Jove, Hercules, He does not give the reason, but see below, p. 14.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 10
06/10/2006 14:51:15
Alessandro
11
and Alexander. Cleone at the Head of the Sacrificers hails Alessandro as the conquering son of Jove and bids all sacrifice to him. Alessandro accepts the title; Tassile concurs, but Clito will bow to Jupiter only and tells Alessandro not to insult the gods. Alessandro, furious, lays him prostrate by Force. Both women ask him to pardon Clito, calm his anger and turn to love. He agrees ‘to take some short repose and taste the fruitful Sweets of pleasing Love’ before resuming a career of glory that shall reach ‘beyond the Confines of the Sun’. Act II. In a shady Retreat in a Garden Rossane implores breezes and fountains to ease her pain and composes herself to Sleep. Alessandro enters and goes to kiss her, observed by Lisaura. (‘Rossane sleep! and Alexander wake! Due observation of this Scene I’ll take.’) Alessandro, annoyed by the presence of Lisaura, changes course and begs consolation from her. Rossane, waking up and seeing this, pretends to sleep again. Alessandro pursues his advances to Lisaura, but with a nice irony she repeats his words addressed to Rossane and goes out. Glad to be rid of her, he again approaches Rossane, who quotes back his words to Lisaura and likewise departs, leaving him hurt, chiefly in his pride: one of them is a slave, the other a barbarian, and he the monarch of the world! His love turns to contempt and hatred. Lisaura, longing to be free of ‘tyrant passion’, meets Tassile, who tells her that Alessandro’s love is false but he himself will always love her. Suspecting that Alessandro loves Rossane, Lisaura wishes she could view him with detachment, but the intensity of her feelings overpowers her. In a Chamber Rossane resolves to break free from Alessandro’s inconstancies. She asks him to prove his love by setting her free. Although he suspects that she means to leave him, he consents. She likens herself to a singing bird which, released from its cage, returns to be near its master. He decides to abandon the pretence of loving Lisaura. When the latter reports that Rossane is preparing to return to her native land, Alessandro renounces love as a tiresome and painful occupation: he will resume his military career. Lisaura begins to hope once more, believing that Rossane, like a deer escaping from a trap, will take care not to be caught again. In the next scene Alessandro, seated on a Throne accompanied by Tassile and the three captains, distributes his empire among his supporters, giving India to Clito but again referring to himself as the son of Jove. Clito says he will accept honours only from Philip’s son, and when Alessandro waxes indignant accuses him of slighting his mother’s honour. Alessandro snatches a Spear from one of the Soldiers, and is going to smite Clitus, but is prevented by Taxilis. While Alessandro is thus engaged the Canopy over the Throne is by Conspiracy made to fall. Alessandro, sensing treason, attributes his escape to Jove, orders Tassile to prepare his Indian troops and Cleone to arrest and imprison Clito. Clito, citing his gallant deeds by the side of Alessandro and his father, asks rather for death on the spot, but is hurried away. Rossane, believing Alessandro dead beneath the ruins, faints away. Alessandro, delighted that his danger reveals her love, is about to embrace her when Leonato reports that the conquered people, believing Alessandro dead, have taken up arms. Alessandro hurries off to fight, confident that Rossane’s love will bring him fresh laurels. She is resolved to love him for ever, whether he speaks true or false. Salone con Trono in the autograph; unspecified in the libretto.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 11
06/10/2006 14:51:15
12
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
Act III. A Tower, in which Clitus is confin’d, under the Guard of Cleon. Clito scornfully refuses to answer Cleone’s suggestion that he humble himself before Alessandro. Leonato enters with armed Men and releases Clito, who goes out of the Tower, and Cleon is confin’d there by the Followers of Leonatus. Leonato and Clito depart, resolved ‘to reform unbridled Pride’ and break the yoke of tyranny. Cleone summons his soldiers, who return and demolish the gates of the prison. He will fan Alessandro’s anger like a wind, humble his enemies and ‘engross the Favour of the Throne’. In a Garden Rossane and Lisaura agree to cease their rivalry: since both love the conqueror of the world, let him choose between them. Lisaura asks Alessandro to cease tormenting her and free her from uncertainty. He replies that he cannot love her without wronging his friend and ally Tassile, and offers her any of his kingdoms. She loves him so much that she desires only his happiness. Rossane returns with the news that Clito and Leonato have imprisoned Cleone and are leading the Macedonians against him. She begs him to escape. Tassile goes to raise his Indian troops. Alessandro is confident of disarming the rebels on his own, after which he will fly to Rossane’s arms. Rossane, her spirits swinging between hope and fear, prays to the gods to protect the hero and avert civil war. In the next scene (locality unspecified) Clito, Leonato and a Chorus of Soldiers oddly declare that the tyrant’s fury is abating. Alessandro quells them with a word. Tassile reports that the rebels of Oxidraca have been arrested and put in chains. Clito orders his supporters to lay down their arms, and Alessandro pardons everyone, adding a sententious aria about true greatness paraphrased from Virgil’s line ‘Parcere subjectis et debellare superbos’. In the final scene in the Temple of Jupiter the two princesses pray for peace and all give thanks for Alessandro’s clemency. He offers Lisaura his friendship, paying tribute to her generosity, and Rossane his love. Both are accepted in a pair of duets leading to a trio and final coro. The source of this libretto, based ultimately on Plutarch, is La superbia d’Alessandro by Ortensio Mauro, set by Agostino Steffani, produced at Hanover in 1690 and revived with alterations the following year as Il zelo di Leonato. Rolli and Handel drew on both versions. Aside from printed librettos, Handel had access to Steffani’s autograph, imported along with the Hanoverian dynasty and now in the British Library, which combines the two versions. Less cavalier than usual, Rolli took over two of Mauro’s most impressive sequences, the opening episodes of the first two acts, almost without change. Nearly all the recitative in the first five scenes of Act I comes from Mauro (a good deal shortened), including the accompanied sections ‘Ossidraca superba’ and ‘Che vidi? Che mirai?’, as well as Alessandro’s aria ‘Fra le stragi’ and the ensemble ‘Fra le guerre’. Leonato’s prominence in Scene ii derives from the 1691 version. Tassile’s aria ‘Vibra, cortese Amor’ replaces a similar aria in a later Mauro scene (I.ix), but is introduced by the same recitative. The first two scenes in Act II are virtually the same in both librettos. Rolli made only minor changes and cuts, retaining Rossane’s scena ‘Solitudini amate’ – ‘Aure, fonti’, the ‘To spare the humble and fight down the proud’ (Aeneid VI, 853). BL RM 23 f 12–14. For Steffani’s two versions see C. Timms, Polymath of the Baroque: Agostino Steffani and his Music (New York, 2003), 222–9.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 12
06/10/2006 14:51:15
Alessandro
13
repeated arioso ‘Permettete ch’io vi baci’ and Alessandro’s disillusioned aria ‘Vani amori’ (slightly altered). Elsewhere he kept a few lines of recitative in I.vi and vii, including ‘Vilipese bellezze’, a couple of lines in I.ix, about ten lines for Tassile and Lisaura in II.iii including a miniature duet (set by Handel but cut before performance), a dozen lines of recitative in II.vi (Alessandro’s second assault on Clito) and a few words in III.iii (though the action here – Clito’s rescue from the tower – is the same). In Mauro’s libretto the two princesses agree peace terms towards the end of Act I; Rolli transferred this to III.iii, but it makes little difference to the plot. Rolli’s changes were largely a matter of contraction. He simplified the amorous cross-currents in one respect (in Mauro Cleone and Clito are both in love with Rossane) while complicating them in another by enlarging Alessandro’s vacillations between Rossane and Lisaura. In Mauro it is Leonato whom Alessandro knocks down in the Act I temple scene. Rolli has Alessandro twice attacking Clito without doing him much damage (in the historical account he kills him); the second assault on the same man merely duplicates the first, especially as Clito does not appear in between. What fatally undermines Rolli’s libretto and unsettles the whole opera is his casual treatment of the conspiracy. In Steffani’s opera we see it developing and can follow its course step by step. Ermolao, a young nobleman in Alessandro’s bodyguard, rashly asks for the most beautiful slave in the sacked city, for which Alessandro has him whipped. Eager for revenge, he enlists the targets of Alessandro’s two assaults, first Leonato and then Clito, as well as others who resent Alessandro posing as the son of Jupiter. Tassile pretends to sympathise with them, but finally traps them on a wooden bridge, whose ends are broken down by his Indian troops, so that all the conspirators except Leonato are drowned in the Ganges. In Rolli we hear nothing of the plot either before Alessandro’s first assault on Clito or between the two. This destroys the cumulative rhythm of the drama, leaving the collapse of the canopy unmotivated. When this occurs without warning in II.vi per Cospirazione the effect is ludicrous. And when Alessandro finally confronts the conspirators in III. vi they sing a brief ensemble of defiance and promptly capitulate. No doubt the idea was to demonstrate Alessandro’s charisma, but it is ineffective in the theatre since it receives no dramatic or musical sustenance. Moreover Rolli abridges the parts of all three captains so ruthlessly that they have little room to develop as characters. Ermolao was perhaps eliminated because an extra singer was not available, though Rolli would have done better to conflate him with one of the other Macedonian captains. Undoubtedly the basic reason for Rolli short-changing the conspiracy was the need to expand the women’s parts for Faustina and Cuzzoni. They had also to be balanced in dramatic and musical prominence. The task of creating a series of situations in which an aria for one princess was followed as soon as possible by an aria for the other was in itself liable to pull the opera out of shape, and would have taxed a more skilful librettist than Rolli. The librettist – Mauro in the first instance – was circumscribed in another way. Alexander the Great was so familiar a figure in history and the arts that deviation from the stereotype was limited. The received Alexander was a military hero, brave to the point of recklessness in challenging cities and armies single-handed; generous to defeated enemies, yet sometimes brutal to his supporters; given to ungovernable
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 13
06/10/2006 14:51:15
14
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
rage when disobeyed or thwarted; above all, possessed of an overweening pride – the classical hubris – in proclaiming himself the son of Jupiter and insisting on others acknowledging this by prostrating themselves before him. He is a man of contradictory qualities, admirable and odious, both in extremes. The audience would expect to encounter this in the opera, and to see some of the principal incidents in his career enacted on the stage. Richard G. King has discussed this aspect at length in his doctoral dissertation, but he goes too far towards equating the hero of the opera with the historical Alexander. The librettists, as was to be expected, put their own slant on history, not only by softening the fate of Clito (Alexander murdered many other innocent persons as well) but by introducing the crucial but unhistorical character of Lisaura. Plutarch’s Alexander was not particularly interested in women, yet for much of the opera his counterpart is concerned with little else. If Alessandro is to be judged as a work of art, his historical prototype is only marginally relevant and needs to be kept in the background. In both Mauro’s and Rolli’s librettos Alessandro’s behaviour carries more than a touch of cynicism. In both, he loves Rossane but keeps Lisaura stringing along. In Mauro his insincerity is clear from the outset; he courts Lisaura because he needs to keep the Scythians on his side. Handel at first accepted this and copied Mauro’s lines into his autograph (I.vii) but did not set them. Alessandro is left with no motive but his own lasciviousness (which meets its just reward in the Act II garden scene) for toying with Lisaura. His eventual explanation for rejecting her in III.iv, that he needs to reward Tassile’s loyalty, reads like a lame excuse, prompting the thought that he might have made the point earlier. Moreover his generous acts are to some extent devalued because a ruler’s forgiveness of enemies was an almost invariable feature of current operatic convention, even when it defied every canon of human probability or consistency. Handel never quite manages to fuse the contradictory aspects of Alessandro’s character in a convincing portrait. He swings like a weathercock between soldier, lover, tyrant and benevolent despot. He does not move us as a human being in the same way as Grimoaldo, Bajazet or other divided characters. The opening sequence establishes the heroic, military and overweening sides of his character. His aria ‘Fra le stragi’, like others in the opera, has a very long ritornello (36 bars), saved from monotony by pianissimo episodes for reduced upper strings over a silent bass line, later filled by Senesino’s trills and messa di voce. Standing in the breach, he sings his own praises in a spirited ensemble in gavotte rhythm, warmly endorsed by the other male characters, horns and independent oboes. Most of his music proceeds in ‘The Composition and Reception of Handel’s Alessandro (1726)’, (Ph.D. diss., Stanford niversity, 1991). See also his ‘Classical History and Handel’s Alessandro’, M & L 77 (1996), 34– U 63. King raises the wider question of the extent to which the characters in Handel’s operas were true to history and recognised as such. Many of them are so obscure that the audience probably had no preconceived opinion. Julius Caesar of course is an exception, but his love affair with Cleopatra, the motive force of Handel’s opera, is a historical fact. The opening bars had done duty in Maddalena’s aria ‘Se impassibile’ and the final coro of La Resurrezione.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 14
06/10/2006 14:51:16
Alessandro
15
extrovert fashion. His eight arias – a larger ration than either of the ladies – with one notable exception are all in major keys. This is appropriate: he is so self-confident, not to say smug, that he need not bother about conscience or inner conflicts. ‘Men fedele’, in which his short phrases (‘ma son vinto, son amante’) are punctuated by a spiky five-note violin figure that becomes increasingly prominent, is a not very subtle attempt to convince his captive Rossane of his love. The rather obscure text of the B section hints at reservations. This is a relic of a more arrogant original following his admission that his motives for courting Lisaura are political. Alessandro next appears in his public persona, dedicating the spoils of victory to his supposed father Jupiter. His fury at Clito’s refusal to prostrate himself inspires a burst of semiquavers for strings in octaves in a passage of recitative, not a particularly strong section in musical terms. After the intercession of the ladies he relaxes in an aria (‘Da un breve riposo’) that is well composed but dramatically something of an anticlimax, especially at the end of an act. The ritornello is rich in ideas, variously developed through both sections. The dancing rhythm at the start over a tonic pedal, with a flattened seventh in the first bar, and the Adagio very early in the A section as his thoughts turn to love, illustrate his mood and the words to a nicety, though the treatment is a trifle sequential. Alessandro is at his most humanly credible, and enjoys his finest music, early in Act II. The first two scenes are the high point of the opera. They show him in a far from heroic light. There is a delicious irony in Handel’s treatment of this episode, prompted by Mauro’s amusing text. Finding Rossane asleep, he addresses her amorously in E flat (Affettuoso in the autograph), unaware that Lisaura is watching. When he catches sight of Lisaura he addresses her in different but equally amorous terms in G minor, observed now by the waking Rossane. Each of them then quotes back the aria he addressed to the other, Lisaura in A, Rossane in C minor. His ego is deftly punctured. Furious at the lèse-majesté inflicted by two mere women on the conqueror of the world, he explodes in the tremendous G minor aria ‘Vano amore’, a miracle of contrapuntal and rhythmic energy and ingenuity. The sixteenbar ritornello, which never returns, is scored in concerto fashion, the woodwind (divided oboes and bassoons) pitted against upper strings, the violins rising from their bottom G, and both against the full orchestra (Ex. 1). Alessandro gives vent to his rage in short breathless phrases, with long divisions on key words (‘cedete’, ‘m’agita’, ‘dispetto’). The change in the B section from Andante 3/4 to Presto 4/4 and an unexpected key, C minor, when we expect the relative major B flat, is intensely dramatic, the tension screwed up before and after by taut contractions of the initial ritornello to eleven and three bars. Handel’s original aria at this point, of which the first eight bars survive in the autograph, was quite different and much less appropriate, a gentle Andante in E flat on material later used for Tassile’s ‘Sempre fido’. King plausibly suggests that Handel was following Steffani’s even blander setting (F major, 6/8) in La superbia d’Alessandro, and stigmatises both as ‘impotent whining’. In Scene v, after releasing Rossane from captivity, Alessandro repels Lisaura’s advances and repudiates love altogether in a conventional anger aria, ‘Risolvo abbandonar’, redeemed by an initial surprise: he interjects an emphatic ‘No!’ on F ‘Classical History and Handel’s Alessandro’, 49.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 15
06/10/2006 14:51:16
16
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 16
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
06/10/2006 14:51:17
Alessandro
17
natural (the key of the aria) after a half-cadence in A major before the ritornello. The word is Handel’s interpolation; it is not in the libretto. ‘Il cor mio’, addressed to Rossane after he has been summoned to deal with the rebellion, is a simple love song, unexpected in the mouth of this cantankerous conqueror. The gentle rocking figure for violins in thirds that punctuates the vocal phrases throughout both sections suggests rather the address of some pastoral swain. Though unimpressive on paper it has great charm and is welcome in an opera heavily encrusted with virtuosity and display. There is no initial ritornello, but a fully scored one after the A section, the only passage in which oboes and viola take part. Neither of Alessandro’s Act III arias rises high or contributes anything new. ‘Pupille amate’ is the better, but it merely echoes the context of ‘Il mio cor’: another love song to Rossane before going into action, again with the only ritornello after the A section, a simple binary design with repeats. In the more fully scored B section a striding chromatic figure in octaves illustrates the image of threatening storms at sea – not very aptly, for they are ‘in van’. Alessandro’s last aria, ‘Prove sono’, falls back on routine, as if Handel were tired of his hero; he wrote innumerable 3/8 arias of this type. The finale, in which Alessandro sings duets with each lady in turn, followed by a short trio and concluding coro, all thematically linked, is more remarkable for its design and scoring than for invention, though the material, again in 3/8, is pleasant enough, with a faint anticipation of ‘O thou that tellest good tidings of Sion’. The need to provide equal opportunities for two vivacious prima donnas clearly taxed Handel, not so much in musical invention as in characterisation. Although the parts are not exactly equal – Rossane (Faustina) has an extra aria in Act II as well as a superb accompagnato in Act I – he achieved a remarkable degree of parallelism. The ladies make their first entrance together in I.iii in an accompagnato verging on arioso, with an eloquent ritornello led by solo oboe. Their last utterance before the finale is a similar episode with a ritornello at the start and another at the end (omitted by Chrysander), resolving the A minor into C major. Each has a slow aria in Act II, and they are the only two arias in the opera with a tempo mark slower than Andante. They also have a regular duet, ‘Placa l’alma’, the single example in the five operas that Handel wrote for them. Whenever they sing together, if they are not echoing each other’s phrases, they take the top melodic line in turn. It was more difficult to distinguish their characters, since the sole motive for each is love for Alesssandro, varied by jealousy. This problem was solved brilliantly in the next opera, Admeto; it was not solved in Alessandro. Handel clearly devoted a great deal of care to his music for Faustina, whom he had almost certainly never heard, though he must have gained an idea of her voice from using some of her arias in the pasticcio Elpidia the year before. He provided lavish scope in aria after aria for the rapid trills and agile coloratura for which she was renowned. Her best note was said to be E; Handel wrote four of her seven arias in sharp major keys, two of them and a duet in A major (Cuzzoni has no solo music in sharp keys). Except in the accompagnato ‘Vilipese bellezze’ (I.viii) Rossane’s music is predominantly cheerful, confident and sparkling with ornament. She is in love with Alessandro from the start, but seldom plumbs the emotional depths, and there is no development in her character. In ‘Alla sua gabbia d’oro’ (II.iv) and ‘Brilla
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 17
06/10/2006 14:51:17
18
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
nell’alma’ (III.iii) she receives two of Handel’s most spectacular – even extravagant – receptacles for virtuosity. They are brilliantly effective if well sung, but have little other purpose than to display Faustina’s gifts and excite applause. The former is full of warblings and twitterings for unison violins, to illustrate the bird simile, and a forest of rapid triplets and sextuplets for the singer; its most imaginative moment is the sudden drop into the tonic minor for the lines ‘la sua prigion gli è cara più della libertà’ after a pause on ‘sai perchè’ (bars 29–32). ‘Brilla nell’alma’, which outshines Lisaura’s immediately preceding ‘Sì, m’è caro’, is in the fully developed Vinci–Hasse style with marching quaver accompaniment (except when the violins break into excited semiquavers) characteristic of the arias Handel wrote some years later for Carestini in Arianna and Ariodante. Burney amusingly referred to its ‘quick, pulsative accompaniment ... as regular as the vibrations of a pendulum’. Harmonically very simple, it depends entirely on the athletic voice part, in which scales and octave leaps alternate with long scintillating divisions. Handel may have chosen this style as a compliment to Faustina, though she was not yet Hasse’s wife. Rossane’s first aria, ‘Lusinghe più care’ – her London stage début – has a catchy tune in a tripping rhythm that won immediate popularity. The tone is light, almost flirtatious, and perhaps more characteristic of Cuzzoni. It is neatly organised, the long ritornello contracted after the A section and still more at the dal segno, so that it never outstays its welcome. ‘Vilipese bellezze’, one of Handel’s finest accompagnatos (F minor immediately after Lisaura’s G minor aria), is a marvellous depiction of Rossane’s shifting moods. The ritornello, rich in suspensions, crossing string parts and downward chromatic motion, strikes a passionate, tragic note (Ex. 2). The music moves beautifully to the relative major as Rossane’s hopes begin to rise, only to fall back into the minor when they fade and the opening words return. ‘Un lusinghiero’ sounds like a first shot at Morgana’s ‘Tornami a vagheggiar’ in Alcina (same key and some common material).10 It swings again between two moods (does Alessandro love her or does he not?) without the undercurrent of anxiety. The B section, with new material and some effective syncopation, is unusually long (57 bars). Handel shortened it later, probably for Strada in 1732, removing much elaboration. Both sections tend to overwork the divisions. The ladies’ duet, on a favourite theme that turns up in numerous instrumental works, is neatly worked. The trilling initial motive is extended in the closing ritornello (sixteen bars after twelve at the start) to compensate for the absence of a B section and da capo. The full orchestra, including oboes, is
She does not seem to have liked the aria, which Handel replaced; see below. 10 In fact both arias echo ‘Tornami a vagheggiar’ in the cantata O come chiare e belle, the vocal line of which is much closer to the Alcina version.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 18
06/10/2006 14:51:18
Alessandro
19
confined to the ritornellos, but a cello obbligato adds a warbling commentary to the solo sections from bar 20. Rossane opens Act II with one of Handel’s most magical sleep scenes, a compound of sinfonia, accompagnato and cavatina, in which the lulling dotted figure of the introduction, richly scored for divided recorders and oboes, independent bassoons and five-part strings (three violins) returns in varied form to accompany the cavatina ‘Aure, fonti’. The carefully marked diminuendo, with the winds dropping out, before the first entry of the voice is a happy touch. The rhythm , representing perhaps the gentle breeze in the garden or the trickle of the fountains, pervades the cavatina, occurring in every part, the falling interval sometimes inverted, and brings it to a pianissimo end in the tonic C minor after Rossane has fallen asleep on the dominant. ‘Dica il falso’, with which Rossane ends Act II, is scarcely strong enough for its position, and suffers from being the third consecutive aria in 3/8 time. Based on a suppressed aria (‘Spesso suol bella tiranna’) for Cleone in Act I, it begins with a near echo of Cornelia’s ‘Cessa omai di sospirare’ in Giulio Cesare. The music is adequate, and makes varied play with phrases of different length in both sections, but tells us nothing new about Rossane. It is exceptional for Handel to end the first two acts without some strong gesture. Rossane’s last aria in Act III, ‘Tempesta e calma’, is her weakest, unusual only in beginning on the sharpened seventh of the scale as if in the middle of a sentence. It reverts to the contrasted moods of fear and hope, but without much conviction, and seems designed merely to make up her quota. Lisaura’s career runs parallel with Rossane’s, but she is the more emotional of the two. Four of her six arias and an arioso are in minor keys. It is not at first clear how deeply in love she is, or if she has been dazzled by Alessandro’s reputation. She is certainly in the toils by Act II, but she accepts her rival’s success courageously and without too deep a wrench. The temper of ‘Quanto dolce’ suggests that she is still playing with the idea of love. The material is standard, but the phrase-lengths are variously and attractively extended in both parts, and the enriched ritornello after the A section, with new suspensions and fuller scoring, adds distinction. ‘No, più soffrir non voglio’ is more passionate and more interesting. The big opening ritornello (fourteen bars, reduced later to five, then three) has a flavour of the concerto: first violins pianissimo, echoed by a tutti and then by the bassoons in thirds, with a descending chromatic bass in bars 11–12, taken up by the voice towards the end of the A section. The ideas are not particularly striking (the voice’s first phrase looks back to ‘Vanne, sorella ingrata’ in Radamisto), but they are developed with a good deal of fire, carried through the B section, and hint at a spitfire quality in Lisaura. The coloratura leaps to an occasional b ’’, a note beyond Faustina’s normal reach, but comfortable for Cuzzoni. Lisaura’s music in Act II is more deeply expressive than Rossane’s. The little arioso ‘Tiranna passion’ (A minor, following the G minor of Alessandro’s ‘Vani amori’) has a haunting eloquence scarcely to be expected in a mere four bars;11 its repetition after eight bars of agitated recitative ending in an interrupted cadence produces a 11 Handel was a master of such multum in parvo fragments, for example Atalanta’s ‘A piangere ogn’ora’ in Act II Scene ii of Serse.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 19
06/10/2006 14:51:18
20
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
miniature da capo form. Finer still is the F minor siciliano ‘Che tirannia d’amor’, a combination of key and rhythm that so often finds Handel at the height of his powers. The ritornello sets the mood with the initial four-note bass figure, later omnipresent, and the violins’ drooping thirds, and sits down firmly on the dominant, whereupon the voice enters with a new melody in the tonic. Handel had trouble with this ritornello, making many changes in the third bar. The aria gives vivid expression to Lisaura’s heartache, in love with a man who fails to respond, notably in the suspensions over a pedal at the words ‘vana speranza! misera fedeltà!’ as the violins soar above (Ex. 3). Both later ritornellos modify and develop the initial material, emphasising the rhythm of the first bar, which the voice adopts, filling the third, to start the reprise, a tiny but telling detail. ‘La cervetta’ too, reverting to A minor, is a beautiful aria, strongly reminiscent of ‘A suoi piedi’ in Tamerlano (same key, metre, tempo and accompaniment, similar angular phrases with rising sevenths, especially in the B section). The music quite transcends the tame simile of the text, with the aid of cross-rhythms (much hemiola) and a series of unexpected progressions on the word ‘ingannator’ and again in the B section.
In Act III Lisaura, like Rossane, has little to do except mark time. ‘Sì, m’è caro’ is just saved from triviality by lively rhythm. ‘L’amor che per te sento’ is an odd piece, in which the voice’s abrupt phrases are repeatedly answered by a strong top line, entrusted in the ritornellos to all the oboes and two-thirds of the violins. The three silent bars, each with a fermata, may be intended to suggest the effort it costs Lisaura to accept her rival’s success; but her renunciation deserved a more signal emphasis. It is interesting to note that Handel changed his mind about Lisaura, resulting in a late change to the plot. Originally she was to soften towards Tassile in II.iii and pair off with him in the final scene. Handel set the passages of recitative to that effect (subsequently cancelled in the autograph), the first containing a short duet arioso
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 20
06/10/2006 14:51:18
Alessandro
21
(Plate 2; he was following Steffani’s opera here, both in words and music12), and they were both copied into the performing score (words only in the first episode; the page containing the second was torn out when the recitative was reset). Chrysander printed the second from the autograph (version A, HG 124), but omitted the first: his version A on HG 71 gives the music as performed in 1726; B was substituted when ‘Sempre fido’ was transposed to F for Bertolli in 1732. The first version is worth quoting (Ex. 4). Handel may have felt that for Lisaura to toy with and accept Tassile was inconsistent with the intense emotion (exploiting Cuzzoni’s gift for pathos) of her ensuing aria in II.iii, ‘Che tirannia d’amor’; or Cuzzoni may have felt slighted at being paired off with the second castrato, Baldi. The effect is to emphasise the strength of Lisaura’s love for Alessandro, making it impossible for her to perform an
12 See King, ‘Composition and Reception’, 42–5.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 21
06/10/2006 14:51:19
22
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
about-turn in the last scene. Curiously the words of the first passage are in Handel’s 1726 libretto but not Rolli’s, that of the second in Rolli’s libretto but not Handel’s. (See below, under Libretto.) Handel had to devote so much space to his three virtuosos that the subsidiary characters are rather elbowed out, Tassile having to be content with two arias, Clito with one and a cavatina, Cleone and Leonato with one apiece. None of them is allowed to develop; Clito in particular is not given enough music to establish him as a virtuous foil to Alessandro. Tassile’s arias are both admirable. ‘Vibra, cortese amor’, introduced by an expressive recitative, builds on a tonally restless ritornello – an oriental touch perhaps (he is an Indian king) as well as a reflection of his uneasiness at Alessandro’s attentions to Lisaura. Spare in texture, it is enlivened by harmonic interest and a tendency for the phrases to extend beyond what the ear expects. ‘Sempre fido’ deploys an attractive figure for recorders in thirds that Handel had used several times before, for example in Agrippina and Muzio Scevola, after lifting it in the first place from Keiser. He is so pleased with it that it permeates both sections. Tassile pleads his devotion to Lisaura with a delightful freshness. The light opening without preamble builds up to a fully scored ritornello after the A section, the only bars in which the viola is independent. Clito’s ‘A sprone, a fren leggiero’ also lacks an opening ritornello, though it had one originally. It jogs amiably along, as befits an equine simile, but is scarcely up to Handel’s usual standard in arias for Boschi. On the other hand the cavatina ‘Sfortunato’ that opens Act III is as powerful as it is brief (fourteen bars, of which the voice sings only in eight). As so often when he finds a sympathetic character incarcerated, Handel rises to the occasion. The texture is rich, in five parts throughout, the bassoons anticipating the voice entry; they are directed to play forte while the rest of the orchestra is piano. The music moves beautifully to the relative major when Clito mentions his faith and honour. Leonato’s ‘Pregi son d’un alma grande’ breathes vigour and defiance, based mostly on rising arpeggios, the diminished seventh arpeggio in bar 8 worked neatly into the B section, but is not specially distinguished. Cleone’s ‘Sarò qual vento’ too is largely a matter of arpeggios, contrasted with blustering semiquaver scales representing the wind likened to Alessandro’s anticipated anger. It is not personal to Cleone, whose sycophantic character is indicated only in recitative. Perhaps to balance the virtuosity of the solo music, Handel introduced a measure of flexibility into the overall plan. There are four sinfonias (though that in II.vi is very brief), six accompagnatos (two of them virtually duet-ariosos equipped with ritornellos), two cori in addition to that at the end, two outstanding cavatinas, one regular duet (without da capo), and not least a composite finale combining two more duets, a trio and the concluding coro. This is enhanced by the cumulative scoring, a single strand of unison violins for Alessandro’s duet with Lisaura, recorders and violins in thirds for his more committed relationship with Rossane, oboes replacing the recorders in the brief trio, and the full panoply with trumpets and horns in the coro, which develops material from the preceding movements to form a spacious, original and musically satisfying conclusion. At this period Handel was beginning to expand the opening and closing scenes of his operas, a process initiated some years earlier in Act III of Radamisto and prominent in the first acts of Scipione and Riccardo Primo.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 22
06/10/2006 14:51:20
Alessandro
23
In Alessandro both the opening and closing scenes are expanded, and they share the same key. The finale balances the opening sequence, a complex embracing two military sinfonias, recitatives of both types and Alessandro’s aria ‘Fra le stragi’, bound together by the key of D major. The substance of the music is conventional, but in conjunction with the spectacular action, fully detailed in the stage directions, it works splendidly in the theatre and gives the opera a powerful initial boost. The second sinfonia expands the first and introduces a second trumpet, though it has little to do. The very spirited overture should be viewed as part of the sequence, for which reason it has no dance movement. It opens with a fine far-flung gesture; the fugue, much admired by Burney, who otherwise gives a rather perfunctory account of the opera, is a good illustration of Handel’s skill in digesting ungainly subjects. Another impressive complex launches the first temple scene (I.ix). The C minor sinfonia enlarges the French overture design by interposing a recitative before a tense double fugue, leading into a stately accompagnato as Alessandro addresses his ‘divine’ father. The Act II throne-room scene originally began with another French overture, but Handel transferred it to Scipione and substituted the rather flat four-bar Grave. The whole opera shows great care in the workmanship. The varied treatment of subsidiary ritornellos in most of the arias, always a strong point with Handel, is particularly resourceful. The countless small insertions and corrections in the autograph13 – as well as more substantial changes – are a further indication. Nevertheless Alessandro, though it rises very high, especially in Act II, is not a satisfactory whole. Thanks to the lopsided libretto the action too often hangs fire. The chief characters cease to develop as they do in Handel’s finest operas and begin to repeat themselves. Alessandro’s relationship to Rossane is settled before the end of Act II, and the conspiracy is so scurvily treated that it never leaves the ground. The almost relentless brilliance of the vocal writing for the three central characters, especially the two sopranos, threatens to become wearisome and to express only virtuosity itself, a fault also prominent in Riccardo Primo. There are rather too many movements in rapid triple time, especially 3/8, in which Handel is sometimes inclined to doodle, but in the entire opera only one aria and two cavatinas with a tempo slower than Andante. It is not surprising that Alessandro, along with Siroe, has had fewer modern productions than any of Handel’s other Royal Academy operas.
History and Text Alessandro was composed in the expectation of Faustina’s arrival. The Academy had been anxious to acquire her services since 1723, and negotiated with her through Owen Swiney, their agent in Italy, in the spring of 1725; she signed an agreement in late June–early July.14 Handel began the music in the autumn of 1725; the part of 13 For an admirable survey, citing many examples of improvement in detail, see King’s dissertation (‘Composition and Reception’). Alessandro of course is not unique in this respect. 14 Gibson, 354ff. Swiney, a strong Faustina supporter, disapproved of the subject of Alessandro (chosen apparently by Haym and Handel) because it was likely to provoke the personal rivalry that subsequently ensued, and he was afraid that Faustina would suffer more than the established Cuzzoni.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 23
06/10/2006 14:51:20
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
24
Leonato, sung by the tenor Antinori, who reached London in November, was written for an alto as far as the coro in I.v (Handel then wrote ‘Leonato in tenor’ against his stave). But Faustina was slow in coming; she had been engaged for the carnival season in Vienna that winter. Handel hurriedly composed Scipione as a stopgap and produced it on 12 March 1726. Much of Alessandro had been written by then; to save time Handel lifted the substantial sinfonia from II.vi, after Smith had copied it in the performing score, and used it to begin Act II of Scipione. Faustina’s arrival was announced in the press on 19 March. Handel dated the autograph at the end 11 April 1726. The first performance took place, before the serried ranks of the Royal Family and nobility, at the King’s Theatre on 5 May, with the following cast: alessandro Senesino (alto castrato) lisaura Francesca Cuzzoni (soprano) rossane Faustina Bordoni (soprano) tassile Antonio Baldi (alto castrato) cleone Anna Dotti (contralto) leonato Luigi Antinori (tenor) clito Giuseppe Boschi (bass) The opera was very successful, receiving thirteen performances in a month; a fourteenth at the end of the season (14 June) was cancelled owing to Senesino’s illness. Swiney was told that it would otherwise have had four or five more. The demand was such that Lady Sarah Cowper had great difficulty in obtaining tickets. The Daily Journal reported that Faustina was received ‘with great Applause’, but Antonio Cocchi was less impressed.15 Many years later Horace Walpole remembered that Senesino at the siege of Oxidraca ‘so far forgot himself in the heat of the conquest, as to stick his sword into one of the pasteboard stones of the wall of the town, and bore it in triumph before him as he entered the breach’.16 During the run Handel introduced two substitute arias for Faustina, which strangely displaced the catchiest and the most brilliant in the score. ‘L’armi implora’, a spacious prayer to the goddess of love, ousted Faustina’s first aria, ‘Lusinghe più care’ in the same key. It is an attractive piece, fitting the context, and has the advantage of giving the opera another slow aria. ‘Si dolce lusingar’, though lively enough, scarcely measures up to ‘Brilla nell’alma’ (the key change, C minor in place of E major, would have required adjustment of the previous recitative, but there is no sign of this in the performing score). Perhaps Faustina objected to the fullness of the orchestral accompaniments in the originals, particularly in ‘Brilla nell’alma’. This would accord with the fact that in two of her other arias, ‘Un lusinghiero’ and ‘Tempesta e calma’, Handel thinned out the violin part. Handel revived Alessandro on 26 December 1727 with most of the original cast. Leonato was cut out, but Cleone was retained and may have been sung by the bass Giovanni Battista Palmerini, the only unemployed member of the company. He probably had no aria; Handel on similar occasions did not bother to change the 15 See Chapter 1. 16 The World, 8 February 1753. The reference could of course be to a revival.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 24
06/10/2006 14:51:20
Alessandro
25
clefs of recitatives in his performing score. The absence of a printed libretto makes it impossible to identify any changes, but it is likely that some of the cuts made in 1732 date from this occasion; the performing score shows signs of progressive abbreviation. There were at least four performances up to 4 January, and probably about five more; the Daily Courant, the only paper to advertise opera performances at this date, is missing for some weeks. Handel’s second and last revival took place on 25 November 1732 with the following largely new cast: alessandro Senesino lisaura Celeste Gismondi (soprano) rossane Anna Strada del Pò (soprano) tassile Francesca Bertolli (contralto) clito Antonio Montagnana (bass) Leonato and Cleone were both omitted. Viscount Percival was present at a rehearsal in the opera house on the 22nd. There were six performances, at least four of them attended by George II and the Royal Family in force. The Colman Opera Diary reported ‘a full House’ on the first night (but ‘Sigra Gismonda had a Cold’), ‘a thin House’ on the second. Handel made extensive cuts in the score, especially the recitative (nearly 250 lines, spread over all three acts). III.iii with ‘Sì, m’è caro’ and ‘Brilla nell’alma’ was omitted altogether, along with the accompagnato, ‘Vilipese bellezze’, ‘Pregi son d’un alma grande’, ‘Risolvo abbandonar’, the coro ‘D’un fiero tiranno’, and the two duets in the finale. The opening scene of Act III was rewritten to include Faustina’s ‘Si dolce lusingar’ transposed to A minor for Tassile, after which Clito sang Cleone’s ‘Sarò qual vento’ down an octave with slight modifications for bass voice and new B section text: he will fly to Alessandro not to rouse his anger against the conspirators but to proclaim his own fidelity, a change scarcely supported by the music. Tassile’s two original arias were put up a tone for Bertolli, ‘Vibra, cortese Amor’ to E minor, ‘Sempre fido’ to F major. One of Strada’s arias, ‘Lusinghe più care’, was similarly raised to A major. Alessandro did not take long to reach Germany. It was staged at Hamburg on 18 November 1726 (NS) as Der hochmüthige Alexander, a translation of Steffani’s title used when La superbia d’Alessandro was produced at Hamburg in 1695. The 1726 production was a hybrid, some of Steffani’s recitatives, in Gottlieb Fiedler’s 1695 German translation, being yoked to Handel’s arias in Italian, though there must have been adjustments. The libretto leaves no doubt that it was essentially Handel’s opera. Only two performances are known. The arias ‘Pregi son’, ‘Che tirannia d’Amor’ and ‘Pupille amate’ were cut, and ‘Sempre fido’ replaced by ‘No, non si teme’ from Scipione. The coro ‘D’un fiero tiranno’ in III.vi was sung twice; the scene, a good deal longer than in Handel’s opera, restored some of the action in La superbia d’Alessandro. A production at Brunswick on 17 August 1728 (NS), presumably arranged by Schürmann, went a good deal further, rejecting all Rolli’s contributions except some aria texts. It was in effect a setting of Mauro’s 1690 libretto with most of Handel’s fitted in where possible, retaining of course his Mauro scenes at the start of the first two acts. Four arias were transferred to different scenes, ‘Da un breve riposo’ from
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 25
06/10/2006 14:51:20
26
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
the end of Act I to near the end of Act III. The result is a much stronger drama, with the conspiracy and the character of the conspirators developed in detail, and the rivalry between the ladies eliminated in the middle of Act I. Six of Handel’s arias (‘Vibra cortese amor’, ‘Pregi son’, ‘Il cor mio’, ‘Dica il falso’, ‘Brilla nell’alma’ and ‘Prove sono di grandezza’), two duets (‘Placa l’alma’ and ‘In generoso onor’), the coro ‘D’un fiero tiranno’ and most of the accompagnatos were omitted. Alessandro did not have a duet with each lady at the end; instead Lisaura and Tassile received one earlier. In addition eleven airs were inserted, including one from Rodelinda (‘Con rauco mormorio’) and three in Mauro’s libretto that Handel did not set; Schürmann no doubt supplied them. Alessandro’s ‘Risolvo abbandonar’ was transferred to Clito. In total Alessandro, who emerges as a less trivial character, and Rossane each lost two arias, while the other male characters (including Ermolao) gained eight between them – nine if Jupiter is included. Act I ended, as in Mauro, with a supernatural scene. Jupiter descends in a machine with many other deities to support his ‘son’, and the Act concludes with a composite ballet danced by gods in the machine and priests on the stage. There was more extra spectacle: in Act I Alessandro entered through a triumphal arch in a chariot drawn by elephants and towards the end of the opera a practicable bridge over the Ganges was cut at both ends, precipitating the conspirators into the river. J. F. A. von Uffenbach attended two performances and was particularly struck by the spectacular machinery, mentioning the realistic elephants, though he also praised the music.17 On 8 November 1743 the Daily Advertiser announced the revival at the King’s Theatre of ‘an Opera, call’d Roxana; or, Alexander in India. Compos’d by Mr. Handel. With Dances and other Decorations entirely new’. It was produced on 15 November as Rossane and received twelve performances to the end of the year and four more in March 1744. Three apparently related productions followed in the next few years: ‘Alexander in India. A new Opera’ on 15 April 1746, ‘Roxana’ on 24 February 1747, and ‘Roxana. Compos’d by Mr. Handel’ on 20 February 1748. For the first two no composer was named. There has been much confusion about these productions, ever since Burney attributed all four to Lampugnani, who was resident composer at the King’s Theatre in 1743–44. A further source of confusion was the use of the title Alexander in India: Metastasio’s famous libretto Alessandro nell’Indie was the source of Handel’s Poro but had no connection with his Alessandro.18 Handel, though not personally involved, lent his performing score of Alessandro in 1743, probably to redeem a broken promise to compose two new operas for Lord Middlesex, manager of the King’s Theatre. A manuscript libretto in the Larpent Collection,19 heavily encrusted with cancellations, insertions and paste-overs, shows that the original intention was to perform a somewhat reduced version of Handel’s 1726 score under the title Le rivali regine, but a series of successive alterations resulted in a pasticcio. The printed libretto includes all accompagnatos, duets and ensembles 17 Tagbuch einer Spazierfarth durch die Hessische in die Braunschweig-Lüneburgische Lande, ed. M. Arnim (Göttingen, 1928), quoted by King in ‘Composition and Reception’ but not in Deutsch. 18 For a full account of these productions, see W. Dean, ‘Rossane: Pasticcio or Handel Opera?’, GHB 7 (1998), 143–55. 19 In the Henry E. Huntington Library, San Marino, California. See Plates 15 and 16.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 26
06/10/2006 14:51:20
Alessandro
27
(except the trio in the finale), but only ten of Handel’s twenty-seven arias (including cavatinas), together with ten alien aria texts. No complete score survives, but with the aid of fragmentary musical sources (manuscript selections in Hamburg, MA/196, and the James Hall Collection at Princeton University, and Walsh’s Favourite Songs) it is possible to identify four of the ten as parodied on earlier Handel arias: ‘Vedeste mai sul prato’ and ‘Sgombra dell’anima’ from Siroe, ‘Là dove gli occhi’ from Admeto, and ‘Return, O God of Hosts’ from Samson. One aria, distinguished by an asterisk, is not by Handel, and may be ascribed to Lampugnani. The remaining five could also be Handel parodies. This version gravely weakened Alessandro’s character in Act II, destroying the impact of the finest scene in the opera and turning the conqueror of the world into a limp self-pitying lover. It is hardly surprising that Mrs Delany was disappointed, as she wrote to her sister (18 November 1743): ‘I was at the opera of Alexander, which under the disguise it suffered, was infinitely better than any Italian opera; but it vexed me to hear some favourite songs mangled.’ The 1746 production was almost certainly a pasticcio on Metastasio’s libretto put together by Lampugnani, although he was no longer in England; it had nothing to do with Handel. The 1747 Rossane, performed eight times, was much closer to Alessandro than that of 1743. Six or seven arias reverted to their original positions (the setting of ‘Pregi son d’un alma grande’ could have been that composed for Scipione in 1730). Only two of the 1743 insertions (both Handel parodies) remained, but four arias from other Handel operas were added: ‘Più che penso’ and ‘Se bramate di amar’ from Serse, ‘Qual leon che fere irato’ from Arianna, and ‘Non si vanti un’alma audace’ from Giustino, the last two with slightly modified texts. The 1747 printed libretto has been wrongly ascribed to 1748; it names the cast of the 1746/47 season, not that of 1747/48. No libretto for 1748 is known, but it was evidently a revival of 1747, perhaps with changes. The mezzo-soprano Caterina Galli succeeded the castrato Reginelli as Alessandro. The third of the four performances, on 8 March, was for her benefit, when it was announced that she would sing ‘all the Original Songs of Senesino’. It is doubtful if she did: only five of the eight are in the 1747 libretto. The casts for 1743 and 1747 were: 1743 1747 alessandro Angelo Maria Monticelli Nicolò Reginelli (soprano castrato) (soprano castrato) lisaura Rosa Mancini (soprano) Marianna Pirker (soprano) rossane Caterina Visconti (soprano) Domenica Casarini (soprano) tassile Giulia Frasi (soprano) Giovanni Triulzi (?tenor) cleone Maria Maddalena Caselli Giulia Frasi (soprano) clito Fratesanti (bass) Giuseppe Ciacchi (?bass) Leonato, though included in the first draft of Act I in the Larpent libretto, was subsequently omitted. Handel included ‘Lusinghe più care’ in his 1730 revival of Scipione. It also appears in a pasticcio score based on Vinci’s Artaserse, perhaps for Vienna in August 1730.20 20 R. Strohm, Italienische Opernarien der frühen Settecento (1720–1730) (Cologne, 1976), II, 234.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 27
06/10/2006 14:51:20
28
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
Many of the arias became popular in London as concert pieces: ‘L’amor che per ti sento’ sung by Miss Warren at Lincoln’s Inn Fields on 8, 13, 18 and 30 May 1728, on the first occasion for her joint benefit; by Ann Turner Robinson, also for her benefit, at Drury Lane on 26 March 1729, together with ‘Solitudini amate’ and presumably ‘Aure, fonti’; and by Miss Sheward for her benefit at the Great Room in Dean Street on 17 March 1752. ‘Lusinghe più care’ was played by Kytch on the oboe for his benefit at Hickford’s Room on 16 April 1729, and sung by Susannah Arne (Mrs Cibber) at the Little Haymarket on 26 January and 4 February 1734. ‘Il cor mio’ and ‘Men fedele’ were sung by Monticelli at the King’s Theatre on 25 March 1746 in a Musicians Fund benefit concert that Handel gave with Gluck. ‘Dica il falso’ was sung by Domenica Casarini (from her part in Rossane) at a similar Musicians Fund benefit on 14 April 1747 and by Francesina at the Great Room in Dean Street on 22 February 1752. Galli sang ‘Prove sono’ at a Musicians Fund benefit on 21 March 1749. The overture featured on numerous occasions, at the Little Haymarket on 20 and 22 October and 19 November 1733, 26 January 1734 and 27 December 1751; at a Manchester Subscription Concert on 14 May 1745; and at a subscription concert in the Great Room in Dean Street on 11 January 1752. There have been three modern stage revivals, at Dresden (1959), Chichester (1981) and Halle (1983). Westdeutscher Rundfunk issued a complete recording conducted by Sigiswald Kuijken in connection with concert and broadcast performances in 1984. A second recording, conducted by Mieczyslaw Nowakowski, appeared on the Schwann Studios Classique label in 1989.
Autograph The autograph (RM20 a 5), which Handel did not foliate in his usual manner, shows signs of haste and many second thoughts, some affecting the plot. Three arias were rewritten or replaced, and only the opening bars remain; another is complete but was never performed; a fifth received a new text. Several scenes contain lines of recitative that Handel either did not set, or set and subsequently cancelled, here or in the performing score or both. As one would expect, where Chrysander printed A and B versions the autograph has A. Act I contains many insertions (fols 7–8, 27–9, 30–1, 35–8, 40–1), mostly made during the course of composition or very soon after. As already mentioned, Handel began the part of Leonato for alto. He, not Clito, has the recitative ‘Oh smisurato ardire!’ Handel later added the tenor version, omitted by Chrysander, on fol. 6. The B section and da capo of the second sinfonia (HG 8–10) were inserted after Smith had copied the score but before the first performance, perhaps to accommodate the elaborate stage action. ‘Quanto dolce’ is written as a dal segno aria, the opening ritornello omitted after the B section. In the recitative of Scene vi Handel added two lines for Tassile in the margin, but later crossed them out. Scenes v–vii underwent a great deal of reorganisation, involving a major change to the plot and some confusion in scene numbering. Handel labelled both v and vii as Scena 6: ‘Fra le guerre’ may once have been intended to come later. He set Lisaura’s ‘No, più soffrir’ twice
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 28
06/10/2006 14:51:20
Alessandro
29
on the same material, extending and greatly improving the ritornello;21 only the first eleven bars of the first setting survive. The recitatives of vii, both accompagnato and secco, are an insertion. This – or at least the secco – replaced a very different recitative for Alessandro of which Handel wrote out the text (taken from Mauro) but no music. Here Alessandro is quite cynical: he is only pretending to woo Lisaura to keep the Scythians on his side. The aria ‘Men fedele’ followed, the words parodied on a different text beginning ‘Vincitore trionfante’. This scene may have been altered because it made Alessandro too unsympathetic. The scene for the three captains (HG 44) was marked to follow, but not set. Instead Rossane’s recitative on HG 41 led to what looks like a tired simile aria, ‘Qual onda e quest’alma’ (Andante 3/8 A minor), of which the first twenty-two bars survive, though like the first ‘No, non soffrir’ it was probably completed. Again Handel used the material for its substitute, ‘Un lusinghiero’, changing many small details. ‘Un lusinghiero’, on Cantoni paper, was then further revised, perhaps to fit the imagery of the text. In the first version of the scene for the three captains Cleone had an aria but Leonato did not. Cleone’s ‘Spesso suol beltà tiranna’ (no tempo 3/8 F major) survives complete, but was soon rejected. It is a dull piece on a sententious text with an A section in binary form with repeats, the violins doubling the voice at the octave. Handel expanded the music for ‘Dica il falso’ at the end of Act II. He probably inserted Leonato’s ‘Pregi son’ when he rejected ‘Spesso suol’. ‘A sprone a fren leggiero’ has a cancelled eight-bar ritornello. Something was intended to follow Cleone’s recitative ‘Al magnanimo, al forte’ (HG 49); there is a gap, and a leaf was removed. Handel changed his mind twice about the spacing of the chord before Alessandro’s ‘Primo motor’. In Act II the top line on HG 62 (opening of ‘Aure, fonti’) was originally for flauto solo, and Alessandro’s recitative ‘Eccola in preda’ had an extra line enlarging on Rossane’s beauty; this was cancelled in the performing score. Handel added the direction Affettuoso to Alessandro’s ‘Permettete’ in lighter ink. He composed Lisaura’s repetition of these words in B flat, but noted that it was to be copied in A. ‘Vano amore’ (fols 57–60) is an important insertion. As already noted, he first set a slightly different text in a very different mood, of which the first eight bars survive. The music was used soon after for Tassile’s ‘Sempre fido’, to which it is much more suited. The recitatives on HG 71 (version A) and 74 were originally longer: the former contained a miniature duet with continuo accompaniment for Lisaura and Tassile (Ex. 4 and Plate 2), modelled (as King has shown) on the corresponding passage in Steffani’s opera. The recorders doubling the voice at the octave in bars 16–21 and 34–54 of ‘Sempre fido’ were added by Handel in the performing score. The closing bars of the B section of ‘La cervetta’ were much rewritten. Scene vi began with the twomovement sinfonia in B flat transferred to Scipione; Handel crossed it out and wrote the four-bar Grave at the end. The stage direction at the bottom of HG 87 is Cade la machina. Originally Cleone went out at ‘al suo sdegno’ (top of HG 89); Handel added the next four bars on a slip (fol. 77). Scenes vii and viii contain passages of unset recitative for Alessandro and Leonato. After ‘di sempre amarlo’ (HG 92) Handel wrote Scene 9 Lisaura e detta and the opening words of a recitative for the two ladies. 21 King gives an excellent analysis of this (‘Compositon and Reception’, 49–53).
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 29
06/10/2006 14:51:21
30
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
He may have intended to end the act with a duet of reconciliation corresponding to III.iii, but the continuation has been torn out. The last three and a half lines of recitative on HG 92 and ‘Dica il falso’ (fols 81–4) are an early insertion. The cries of ‘All’ armi!’ in III.ii were an afterthought written in the margin. ‘Si dolce lusingar’ (fols 97–9) is an insertion following Lisaura’s line of recitative ‘Io non ti cedo’, where it is misplaced, no doubt because the key fits; it was certainly composed for Rossane (Faustina). The coloratura at the bottom of HG 107 was originally different in line and rhythm; in several places in the autograph Handel was concerned to modify the coloratura for Faustina. ‘L’armi implora’ (A and B versions in Chrysander’s appendix) is another example. ‘Tempesta e calma’ has many corrections, both the violin and voice parts being simplified. In the coro ‘D’un fiero tiranno’ the soprano line is marked S. An (i.e. Senesino and Anna Dotti), the alto Baldi – all three backstage, since they are singing against their own side – the tenor Leonato, the bass Clito; there are no chorus parts in the opera. The accompagnato duet ‘Spegni, oh supremo’ has a three-bar ritornello after ‘rendi la pace!’ After the coro Handel added the date li 11 [originally 9] d’Aprile 1726. Two leaves at the end carry the additional aria ‘L’armi implora’ in version A, with signs indicating that bars 9–11 are to be altered. The new bars 9–13 modifying and extending Faustina’s first burst of coloratura, are in place in Chrysander’s B version (as printed by Walsh), which also has a couple of harmonic changes in the B section.
Librettos 1726 Handel. ‘Drama. Da Rappresentarsi Nel Regio Teatro di Hay-Market; per la Reale Accademia di Musica ... Printed, and Sold at the King’s Theatre in the HayMarket.’ 63 pp. Brief Argument in Italian and English. Handel is named, but not Rolli. The text contains five short passages of recitative, in I.vi, II.iii (2), II.vii and III.iv, that Handel either did not set or subsequently cancelled. On the other hand Chrysander includes two passages, the first four bars on HG 32 and the A version of the final recitative (HG 124), removed before the libretto was printed. Alessandro’s extra line in the recitative ‘Eccola in preda’ (II.ii) is also not present. 1726 Edlin. ‘Drama di Paolo Rolli. Londra: by Thomas Edlin, at the Prince’s Arms, over-against Exeter-Exchange in the Strand.’ Greek quotation from Plato’s Republic, otherwise in Italian only, published by Rolli without reference to the theatre. Dedication to Princess of Wales, who saw the original in Hanover when she went to make her Royal Consort happy (?when they married in 1705). No da capos indicated. III is headed Campo. Otherwise text as 1726 theatre libretto, except that it includes the two removed passages mentioned above and a few minor variants. 1726 Hamburg. ‘Der hochmütighe Alexander. In einem Sing-spiele auf dem Hamburgischen Schau-Platze Vorgestellet ... Gedruckt mit Stromerschen Schrifften.’ Handel is named. Vorbericht rather fuller than in the London librettos. Recitatives in German, set pieces including cori, the four short ariosos in II.ii and ‘Spegni, O supremo’, in Italian with German translation alongside. Ballets included in each Act: Entrée der Combattanten after ‘Fra le guerre’ in I.v, Entrée Comique at the end of Act II, Grand Ballet in the finale, placed before ‘In generoso onor’. Three arias are omitted
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 30
06/10/2006 14:51:21
Alessandro
31
and one replaced, as noted above. There are a few changes to the plot. Evidently it was thought (with reason) that the conspiracy needed strengthening; a scene for Leonato looking forward to the collapse of the canopy was inserted before II.vi, and the latter part of Act III rearranged to include episodes from Steffani’s opera omitted by Rolli. The conspirators do not surrender without a word; most of them (but not the leaders) are drowned when the bridge is cut. 1728 Brunswick. ‘Der Hochmüthige Alexander. In einer Oper vorgestellet Auf dem Grossen Braunschweigischen Theatro In der Sommer-Messe MDCCXXVIII Wolfenbüttel Christian Bartsch.’ Handel not named. Characters listed as in Mauro’s 1690 libretto, including Cleone Alexander’s favourite, a flatterer and a Sicilian, Ermolao a young nobleman in Alexander’s bodyguard, and Jupiter in a machine. Dances at the end of the first two Acts, for gods and priests in Act I, Greek heroes and Persian ladies in Act II. All recitatives and ensemble in I.v in German only. Arias and other set pieces in Italian with German translation. Alessandro assaults Leonato, not Clito in Act I; only Leonato survives immersion in Act III. 1732 Handel. Title as 1726 without ‘per la Reale Accademia di Musica’, but ‘Printed by T. Wood in Little-Britain, and are to be sold at the King’s theatre in the Hay-Market’. 43 pp. Neither Rolli nor Handel named. The recitative cuts affect nearly every scene: 72 lines in Act I, 105 in Act II, 72 in Act III. Leonato and Cleone are omitted, their lines (when essential) transferred to Clito (e.g. in II.ii) or Tassile (in I.ix, II.viii and III.ii); but Cleone is still present as a ghost. Alessandro addresses him by name in II.vii, and he is listed in the heading of III.i. Other changes are noted above.
Copies and Editions The performing score (Hamburg MA/199) is a complex document. Basically a Smith copy, made by stages while Handel was still at work on the score, it contains additions and annotations in at least eight different hands: Handel himself, four of his copyists (S1, S3, H6 and ?H5), two at least in 1743, and Chrysander. It reflects changes made before the 1726 première, in 1727/28, 1732 and for Rossane in 1743. Of the nine insertions listed by Clausen, five antedate the first performance: the B section of the sinfonia on HG 7 (probably), the aria ‘Pregi son’ and connecting recitatives (fols 56–8, HG 45–7), the four-bar sinfonia at the start of II.vi together with the recitative as far as ‘trafiggi’ (bottom of HG 88, fols 102, 105–6), the continuation of this recitative to the first bar on the bottom system of HG 89, recopied perhaps to take in the added bars on fol. 77 of the autograph (fol. 107, bound back to front), and the B version of the recitative on HG 124. ‘Si dolce lusingar’ in C minor (fols 128–30, clefs H 6, remainder ?H 5) was inserted during the 1726 run. There is no sign of Faustina’s other extra aria, ‘L’armi implora’. The 1727–28 revival is probably reflected in some of the recitative cuts, perhaps including the severe contractions in II.vi (the new shortened version copied by S1 on fols 103–4, an insertion within an insertion), as well as the transference of some of Leonato’s music to Cleone and Clito (Cleone was omitted in 1732). There are signs of cumulative cuts in some recitatives, for example in II.viii and III.ii. Leonato’s ‘Sire,
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 31
06/10/2006 14:51:21
32
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
il popolo’ (top of HG 90) is altered for alto Cleone, which must date from 1727/28, since in 1732 it was given to Tassile. The drastic 1732 cuts are indicated by cancellation or paste-overs (sometimes both, though most of the paste-overs have been removed) and inserted cadences; by no means all are bracketed by Chrysander. ‘Lusinghe più care’ was recopied in A major for Strada with small changes in the bass line (S1, fols 25–9). Upward transpositions by a tone are marked for Bertolli in ‘Vibra, cortese Amor’ and ‘Sempre fido’. In the new III.ii ‘Si dolce lusingar’ was recopied for her in A minor (S3, fols 118–21), and the main cadences in Cleone’s ‘Sarò qual vento’ modified for Montagnana (Clito), or possibly for Palmerini if he sang the aria in 1727/28. Scattered through the score are a number of changes to the words of recitatives, and a few to the notes, some probably written by Handel. At some stage, perhaps in 1732, he cut the three-bar coda to ‘Spegni, O supremo’. Two or three hands annotated the manuscript in connection with the 1743 Rossane, probably as guidance to a copyist for preparing a fresh score. New texts were parodied on the coro ‘D’un fiero tiranno’, adopted in error in HG, and on part of ‘Pregi son’, though this aria was in the event replaced. Among other points indicated are cuts (‘No, più soffrir’, Alessandro’s recitative ‘Che onor si rende’, ‘Tempesta e calma’), substitutions (‘Sgombra dell’anima’ for ‘Sarò qual vento’) and the insertion of new recitatives in II.viii and III.iv, passages in the 1726 libretto that Handel had not set. Chrysander added the completion of the B flat sinfonia in II.vi and (as noted above) the A version of the recitative on HG 124. The Malmesbury score (music written by S2 and Smith junior in alternation, text by Smith senior) is the earliest copy (from the performing score), probably dating from 1726. It is the only source for the placing of the two substitute arias for Faustina. The text agrees with the A versions in HG, except in the final recitative. It is short on instrumentation and stage directions, even at crucial points such as Alessandro’s two assaults on Clito. Some tempos are omitted, but ‘Dica il falso’ is Allegro, as in the Cluer print and Lennard. ‘All’armi!’ (HG 96) is for Alessandro and Tassile (alto) and Leonato (tenor), all off-stage (so also in Granville). RM 19 c 3 (S2, mid-1740s) was once part of the Aylesford (Flower) Collection; it contains annotations and corrections by Jennens, including bass figuring in ‘Men fedele’. It was copied from the autograph, with full 1726 recitatives and a number cancelled there or in the performing score, but not the four-bar ‘Apprestati’ (HG 32). It has both sinfonias in II.vi and all HG A versions, including that in the last recitative. Not surprisingly S2 misread the abbreviated names against the coro ‘D’un fiero tiranno’, giving the soprano part to a mythical Sigr Andr. Faustina’s substitute arias are not present. The Granville copy (Eg. 2923, S5, early 1740s) also derives closely from the autograph, probably at one remove, and contains nothing later than 1726. The text is similar to RM 19 c 3, including the complete 1726 recitatives and HG A versions. The recitative ‘Apprestati’ and the extra bars in ‘Eccola in preda’ are present, but not two suppressed recitative passages in II.iii. Otherwise the only material differences are that it gives only the four-bar sinfonia in II.vi and adds ‘Si dolce lusingar’ in C minor at the end.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 32
06/10/2006 14:51:21
Alessandro
33
Lennard (Smith, c.1735) gives an intermediate text between the 1726 and 1732 librettos, and may to some extent reflect the version performed in 1727/28. Apart from ‘Apprestati’ it makes only two recitative cuts in Act I (in ii and vii), a good many more in II.iv–viii and III. iv–vi, but fewer than in 1732. In II.vi the shortened text agrees with the insertion on fols 103–4 of the performing score. It has version A on HG 55, 71, 81 and 124 (contrary to both printed librettos), but B on HG 43 and 84. Tassile takes Leonato’s part in II.viii, as in 1732. The sinfonia on HG 7 is missing, replaced by an instruction to repeat the ‘piccola sinfonia’ on HG 5, and so are the coro ‘D’un fiero tiranno’ and Faustina’s substitute arias. Smith follows Cluer in giving scant instrumental detail and undercutting most dal segno arias with a da capo. ‘Quanto dolci’ (erroneously), ‘Dica il falso’, ‘Pupille amate’ and ‘Tempesta e calma’ are all Allegro. Berlin MS 9053, in the miniaturist hand found also in the Coke Collection, was copied from Cluer (omitting the ariosos ‘Permettete’ and ‘Superbette’) but includes the two substitute arias for Faustina at the end. Add. MS 31563 is a nineteenth-century copy from the autograph. The Flower parts – cembalo, violins 1 and 2, viola, cello, oboes 1 and 2 (including flauti), horns 1 and 222 – were copied by S2 c.1743, mostly from the autograph (the cancelled opening ritornello of ‘A sprone’ is included), but there are some odd omissions: not only the overture and secco recitatives (as usual), but the accompagnatos ‘Ossidraca superba’ and ‘Spegni, O supremo’, the two Ossidraca sinfonias, the arias ‘La cervetta’ and ‘Sarò qual vento’, the cavatina ‘Sfortunato’, and the coro ‘D’un fiero tiranno’. The B flat (Scipione) sinfonia is misplaced to the start of Act III. The two extra Faustina arias (‘L’armi implora’ in the B version) are included at the end. Both oboe parts generally double the first violins, but they are divided in ‘Da un breve riposo’ (perhaps incorrectly) and ‘Vano amore’. S2 supplies them in ‘Quanto dolce’ and ‘A sprone’ because the autograph has Tutti (ignored by Chrysander) and in ‘Si dolce lusingar’ (autograph only unisoni), but omits them in ‘L’armi implora’ (they may not have been present in his unidentified source). They drop out in the arias when the voice enters, except in bars 39–48 of ‘Da un breve riposo’, possibly an error. The cello part mentions bassoons only in ‘No, più soffrir’. Many excerpts from Alessandro appear in mixed volumes in the British Library and elsewhere. Those in RM 18 c 3 (‘Sempre fido’), RM18 c 10 (nine items, mostly sinfonias and accompagnatos but including the cori ‘Fra le guerre’ and ‘D’un fiero tiranno’, probably intended to supplement the Cluer score) and RM 18 c 11 (the two sinfonias of II.vi, the ariosos ‘Tiranna passion’ and two unpublished pieces cancelled in the autograph, Cleone’s aria ‘Spesso suol’ and the duet recitative and arioso ‘Amo, spero’ for Lisaura and Tassile in II.iii, c.1746) were copied by S2 for Jennens. ‘Si dolce lusingar’ in C minor in RM 18 b 4 (S1) and Jennens’s own arrangement of flute parts in ‘Men fedele’ and ‘Quanto dolce’ in RM 19 a 8 also came from the Aylesford Collection. Other isolated items are the two extra Faustina arias in Add. MS 31521 (S2, c.1726), ‘Solitudini amate’ and ‘Aure, fonti’ in Flower MS 130 Hd4, v. 313 (Smith, c.1746), ‘Prove sono’ in RM 19 d 12, ‘Pupille amate’ in Add. MS 24307, and the duets ‘Placa l’alma’ and ‘In generoso amor’ in the Coopersmith Collection 22 The horn parts are in the library of the University of Maryland.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 33
06/10/2006 14:51:21
34
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
at the University of Maryland (S5, c.1744). The Coke Collection has a manuscript supplementing the Cluer score (ex-Shaftesbury, S2, ?1736). Handel’s keyboard arrangement of the overture23 exists, with only a few slight variants, in six early manuscripts: two Malmesbury volumes (both Smith, c.1726 and 1728), the Coke Rivers manuscript (Smith junior, c.1726/27), RM 18 c 1 (S2, c.1728), RM 18 c 2 (Lambda, c.1728), and New York Public Library Mus. Res. MN* (copyist unknown, c.1739). Cluer published the score on 6 August 1726, having invited a subscription on 27 May. There were eighty subscribers for 106 copies, some from as far away as Dublin, Hamburg, Stockholm and New York. The score omits all sinfonias and recitatives of both types (except ‘Solitudini amate’), the cori ‘Fra le guerre’ and ‘D’un fiero tiranno’, the arioso ‘Tiranna passion’, and the aria ‘Sempre fido’, but includes the three duets and the ariosos ‘Permettete’ and ‘Superbette’ in II.ii in the keys first sung, misattributing the first to Senesino and Faustina, the second to Senesino and Cuzzoni. The scoring is complete, but the instruments are seldom named, except in the overture, ‘Solitudini amate’ – ‘Aure, fonti’ and the final coro. The bassoons however are mentioned in ‘No, più soffrir’ and ‘Sfortunato’. Nearly all dal segno arias have a da capo, omitting the ritornello after the B section. A few pieces have no tempo mark, but ‘Lusinghe più care’, ‘Da un breve reposo’, ‘Dica il falso’ and ‘Tempesta e calma’ are Allegro.24 The opera’s success provoked a good deal of piratical activity from other publishers. Benjamin Cooke advertised two collections of ‘the most celebrated Songs’ on 4 August. They were issued without imprints as ‘Sold at the Music-Shops’, and included the overture and the two additional arias for Faustina, which thus appeared before Cluer’s authorised score. There is some confusion over this publication, the contents varying in different copies, including duplication. Smith (A Descriptive Catalogue of the Early Editions, nos 3 and 8) misinterpreted ‘Permettete’ and ‘Superbette’ as duets. Walsh soon took over Cooke’s publications, if he was not behind them from the first. He (with Hare) and Cluer (with Creake) advertised rival flute arrangements in October and November 1726, and Cooke and Walsh advertised the overture in parts in January and April 1727. Walsh and Hare published Handel’s keyboard arrangement of the overture in their second collection in October 1728; David Wright issued a pirated edition in the same year. There was even a Paris publication of the overture, in four parts, issued jointly by three publishers in 1743. The Rossane productions in 1743 and 1747/48 inspired some confusing activity by Walsh. The Favourite Songs in Roxana or Alexander in India, issued in February 1744, contains twelve pieces printed from old plates of various publications carrying the names of the original singers. Nine come from Alessandro (‘Il cor mio’ in A major), two from Siroe and one from Admeto, with their original words, not those sung in Rossane. The Opera of Roxana or Alexander in India (c.1748) contains all the arias and duets in the 1726 Alessandro, with the two Faustina additions at the end, again from old plates. ‘Sempre fido’ is ascribed to Cuzzoni (perhaps a guess, since it it is not in Cluer). 23 Edited by Terence Best in G. F. Handel: Twenty Overtures, II. 24 ‘Lusinghe più care’ is Allegro ma non troppo in the autograph, Allegro in the performing score. The other three and ‘Pupille amate’ have no tempo in autograph or performing score.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 34
06/10/2006 14:51:21
Alessandro
35
Randall published ‘Ah no, non voler, mio ben’ from Rossane as sung by Pacchierotti in a pasticcio based on Metastasio’s Alessandro nell’Indie (c.1780). Chrysander’s score of Alessandro (1877) is accurate in the main but inconsistent and sometimes casual in detail, for example in the treatment of cuts in the performing score and 1732 libretto; there are about twenty more than indicated in HG. It is not clear why he includes the four bars of recitative ‘Apprestati, oh Cleone’ in I.v (HG 32), which are not even in the 1726 libretto and are cancelled in the performing score, while excluding passages of equal or greater validity, such as the three-bar ritornello after ‘rendi la pace’ (HG 123). He contradicts the autograph in the instrumentation of ‘Quanto dolce’ and ‘A sprone’. Omissions include the tenor setting of Leonato’s recitative ‘Oh smisurato ardire’ in I.ii (autograph), Adagio on ‘Che vidi!’ in I.iii (all sources), Affettuoso on Alessandro’s ‘Permettete’ in II.ii (autograph), and the direction tenero which occurs three times on the word ‘perdonar’ in ‘Prove sono’. This is in the autograph, performing score and copies and even survives in the 1743 Rossane (Hamburg MA/196).
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 35
06/10/2006 14:51:21
chapter 3 Admeto, Re Di Tessaglia
T
he action takes place in Larissa, the capital city of Thessaly, in classical times. In the royal apartments of the palace Admeto, the King, lies indisposed in his Bed, where he sleeps. A ballet of spectres carrying blood-stained daggers enacts his dreams. He rises up from his Bed in a Fit of Rage, calling on the spectres to cease tormenting him. They vanish. He goes again to repose himself, longing to die in peace. Orindo, a courtier, brings him two messages: his guest Ercole (Hercules) desires to take his leave, and Trasimede, the King’s brother, ‘raves over the portrait of some painted beauty’ and is as distraught as Admeto himself. In a brief visit to the sickroom Ercole declares that the motive of his mighty deeds is glory, not love for Iole. Alceste, the Queen, prays to Apollo to soften her husband’s pain and her own. The god’s statue replies that only the death of a near relative can cure him. As Admeto composes himself to sleep, Alceste resolves to die for him and looks forward to their next meeting in Elysium. The set changes to A Wood, where the Trojan princess Antigona and her tutor Meraspe are living both in Shepherd’s Habit. They are refugees from Troy, which has been sacked by Ercole. Antigona, who was betrothed to Admeto before his marriage to Alceste, denounces him as a traitor, and blames his illness on Jove’s anger at his broken vows. She laments the death of her father Laomedon at Troy and, seeking a means of introduction to the palace, asks Meraspe to pose as her father. In the Inside Walks of a Garden Alceste with a Ponyard in her Hand, and a Train of Damsels that are veil’d, and weeping, tells them not to bewail her willing sacrifice. All depart, and Admeto enters with Ercole and guards, rejoicing in his recovered health. He is interrupted by cries of woe within. Here all the back Part of the Theatre opens, and near a Fountain’s Side is presented to View Alceste slain, with the Sword in her Bosom. Orindo gives Admeto a note from Alceste saying she chose death to save his life. Here the Theatre shuts in again. Admeto, overwhelmed with grief, begs Ercole, who among other mighty deeds once rescued Theseus from hell, to go down again and release Alceste. Ercole agrees, leaving Admeto to ponder on the delusions fostered by hope. Meanwhile in the wood Meraspe brings Antigona the news that Admeto is better and Alceste dead by her own hand. They rejoice that Antigona may marry Admeto after all, but retire into a thicket on hearing the approach of a hunt. Trasimede enters with the Picture [of Antigona] in his Hand, and followed by the Hunters. He dotes on the portrait. Seeing a means of gaining access to court, Antigona and Meraspe advance. She astonishes Trasimede by denying her identity; she is Rosilda, and Fidalbo (Meraspe) is her father. Trasimede at once invites her, ‘since a rural life’s habitual to you’, to look after the royal garden, hails her as the goddess Diana, tells one of his Followers who These and many other stage directions are omitted by Chrysander; see below, under Libretto. As n. 1.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 36
06/10/2006 14:51:21
Admeto, Re di Tessaglia
37
goes out to collect the huntsmen, and departs. Antigona, likening herself to a ‘coasting sparrowhawk’, looks forward to showing Admeto the error of his ways. Act II presents Hell, in which is seen Alceste chain’d to a Rock, and tormented by two Furies. This Scene opens to the Sound of a Symphony, which strikes Terror. Hercules, with his Club, who leads about Cerberus in a Chain. Presently he throws Cerberus into a deep Abyss, out of which issues a great Quantity of Smoke and Flames. During a second symphony he descends into the Abyss, beats the Furies with his Club ... who being all struck with Fear, fly on their Wings thro’ the Air, and go out of the Summit of the Cave. Hercules unlooses Alceste, and conducts her out of Hell, helping her to mount over the Rocks with him; the abyss slowly disappears. She looks forward eagerly to Admeto’s welcome. In A Garden Antigona, depressed by Admeto’s unresponsiveness, meets Orindo, who beckons her, and offers to kiss her. She indignantly rejects his advances. Trasimede enters with a Picture in his Hand. Preferring the substance of Antigona to the shadow, he throws down the Portrait, and Orindo privately gathers it up. Antigona is resolved to have Admeto or nobody and rejects Trasimede too. When Admeto enters, Orindo gives him Antigona’s Picture. Admeto says it cannot represent Antigona since Trasimede, when sent to Troy to negotiate the marriage, brought back a different portrait. He sends Orindo to watch Trasimede and thinks longingly of Alceste. While Admetus stands ready to enter the Scene (having left it after his aria), he comes in joined by Antigona and Meraspes. Thrasymedes observes them apart. Antigona kneels at the Feet of the King, he raises her from the Ground and observes first the Picture, and then Antigona, astonished at the resemblance between his gardener Rosilda and the portrait. In answer to his enquiry she says she saw Trasimede doting on the picture and mourning ‘the fatal loss of dead Antigona’. Admeto realises that Trasimede must have fobbed him off with a picture of someone else (Trasimede overhears this and resolves to have the picture stolen) and believes her assurance that Antigona is dead. When she asks if he would marry her if she were alive he says he does not know and abruptly departs. Meraspe asks Antigona why she did not reveal herself. She says the time is not yet ripe; her hopes are drowned in a sea of troubles. The set changes to A Wood. Alceste, disguis’d in a military Habit, tells Ercole that she wants to see if Admeto has taken another love in her absence, and sends him ahead to say he could not find her in hell. Left alone, she is consumed by jealousy. Admeto, depressed at the thought of loving two women both of whom are dead, resolves to die himself. Trasimede enters with ‘Rosilda’ forced along by Soldiers, but releases her when she asks indignantly if this is his fidelity to Antigona. To him a Page, who presents him a Picture, and Antigona retires aside. He surveys the Picture, recognises it as one of Admeto, not Antigona, and orders it to be taken back to the royal cabinet. As the Page is making his Exit with the King’s Picture, he drops it unadvisedly. Antigona is delighted to pick it up. The disguised Alceste sees her kissing it and assumes the worst. She asks Antigona, who admits to loving Admeto, if she has any hope of her love being returned. Antigona does not answer: her fate hangs uncertain as a trembling star. Alceste begins cursing Admeto, but checks herself: the girl may have stolen the portrait. Until she finds out she will be true to her duty. Chrysander omits this direction, which comes between Ercole’s accompagnato and Alceste’s cry of ‘Alcide!’ Stage direction in Italian text only.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 37
06/10/2006 14:51:22
38
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
Act III opens in A Courtyard. Meraspe tells Admeto about the arrest of ‘Rosilda’, revealing her identity and her hopes of marrying the widowed King (he does not know that Trasimede has since released her). Orindo reports that Ercole has returned from hell alone, and is sent to find Antigona and her abductors. Meraspe assures Admeto of Antigona’s love and fidelity. Admeto is torn between longing for the dead Alceste and the thought of Antigona being maltreated by the licentious soldiery. He feels he ought to love her and sings a not very relevant simile aria about a tigress and a turtle-dove. While Admetus is offering to go, Hercules comes in and meets him. He says Alceste must be in Elysium since he could not find her in hell. Admeto remarks (aside) that everything is conspiring to throw him into Antigona’s arms. Ercole, surprised that his false news evoked no expression of regret, concludes that Alceste has reason for jealousy. In the next scene (a wood in the Italian text, clearly a mistake for a Piazza in the English translation and HG) Antigona, again kissing Admeto’s portrait, has barely begun an aria when Alceste comes in and wrings the Picture out of her Hands by Force. Orindo enters with Soldiers and takes the disguised Alceste for the abductor mentioned by Admeto. The Soldiers surround Alceste, whom they bound in chains. Antigona takes again from her the Picture in a disdainful manner, resumes and completes her interrupted aria and goes out. Ercole, astonished to find Alceste under arrest, raises his Club, forces the soldiers to release her, and sends them and Orindo packing. He tells Alceste bluntly that the King loves another woman, and advises her to return to court at once. Striving to conquer her jealousy, she sings an aria about flowers, breezes and birds gracing Admeto’s path. The last scene takes place in the palace. Trasimede hears from Meraspe that Antigona is to marry Admeto and for the first time learns her identity. She points out that she cannot help loving Admeto; Trasimede will find someone else. Unappeased, he works himself into a fury and vows to kill his brother. Admeto and Antigona, determined to marry at once, sing a love duet overheard by Alceste and Trasimede. At the end the latter offers to smite Admetus; but being met with by Alceste, she takes the Sword out of his Hand, and he goes off unobserved. Admeto takes Alceste for his assailant and orders her arrest. The Guards surround Alceste to carry her off. Only then does he recognise her. Amid general explanations Trasimede returns and kneels before Admeto, who lifts him from the Ground and forgives him. When Admeto hesitates between the two women, Antigona takes Alceste by the Hand, and presents her to Admetus as having twice saved his life. Trasimede’s hopes begin to rise, but he is not rewarded. Alceste sings a love song to her husband (Plate 3a), who acknowledges his debt to both ladies; he owes his life to one, to the other his honour. The origin of this libretto is an old Venetian opera, L’Antigona delusa da Alceste, with words by Aurelio Aureli and music by P. A. Ziani, first produced in 1660. Aureli took the central situation from the Alcestis of Euripides (Alcestis dies to save her husband and is rescued from hell by Hercules) and combined it with a typical Venetian imbroglio of misunderstandings, dropped portraits and disguised identities. As in Monteverdi’s last two operas, and many others of the period, the action takes place A mistranslation for ‘angrily’. The libretto accidentally omits the heading.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 38
06/10/2006 14:51:22
Admeto, Re di Tessaglia
39
on three loosely connected levels, inhabited by gods, heroes and servants. There is also an allegorical Prologue, sung by a miscellany of personified abstractions. The gods’ decrees affect the destiny of the heroes; the servants supply a parallel strain of comedy and ironic comment. The plot is complicated by numerous extra characters, including three servants (Orindo, Lesbo and Lillo) and a pair of subsidiary estranged lovers. Ziani’s opera was often revived – in Bologna (1661), Milan (1662), Naples (1669), Venice (1670), and Hanover (1679 and 1681) – and the libretto underwent progressive changes, not of a radical order. Handel’s immediate source was that of Hanover 1679, whose text had been revised by the court poet Ortensio Mauro, and Ziani’s music supplemented by the obscure composer Mattia Trento. Mauro’s contribution was comparatively slight; apart from a few new aria texts and the insertion of the Act III duet, he expanded the comic element, ending the first two acts with knockabout scenes for Lesbo beset by groups of satyrs and gladiators, followed by a ballet. Handel was thus confronted by a typically old-fashioned libretto of the mid-century. His changes were necessarily radical. He abolished the Prologue, the immortals Pluto, Cloto (one of the Fates) and Mercury, who extend the scene in hell (II. i) with much frigid argument, the secondary lovers, and the low-life episodes, for example in the first scene, where Admeto’s servant Lesbo, asleep in the bedroom of his dying master, enjoys an amorous dream. In earlier librettos much more was made of Lesbo’s love for Antigona (in her disguise as a shepherdess), which Handel transferred to Orindo, a courtier rather than a skittish page, and confined to a single scene. He reduced the unruly mass of characters to a manageable seven. His collaborator, sometimes assumed to be Rolli,10 was almost certainly Haym. The text carries few of Rolli’s fingerprints, for example his tendency to rewrite the recitative dialogue, to substitute new, verbose and confused aria texts, and to put his name to the result.11 By far the greater part of the dialogue, as in the Haym librettos, was taken unchanged from 1679, though a good deal shortened. As in the Strohm (Essays, 54) cites the 1681 issue, which does not contain Alceste’s aria ‘Gelosia spietata aletto’. According to H. D. Clausen (‘Händels Admeto und Bononcini’s Astianatte’, GHB 6 (1996), 146) both versions were drawn upon, but he states incorrectly that the Act III duet ‘Alma mia, dolce ristoro’ appears only in 1681. There is no reason to suppose that Handel’s librettist used more than one issue. A scholarly article by Georg Ellinger, ‘Händels Admet und seine Quelle’ (Vierteljahrsschrift für Musikwissenschaft 1 (1885), 201–24), contains perceptive comments on Handel’s treatment of plot and character, but compares his libretto with Aureli’s original, which he dates c.1664. Lillo had disappeared by 1662. Earlier versions ended Act I with shepherdesses and huntsmen, Act II with Lesbo and ‘artegiani’ searching for the lost portrait, both concluding with a ballet. Aureli had ended Act II with a burlesque dialogue for Orindo and Lesbo. 10 By Strohm (Essays) and Ellen Harris in her collected edition of Handel’s opera librettos (The Librettos of Handel’s Operas (facsimile), 13 vols (New York and London, 1989)). 11 Rolli was a compulsive rewriter, retaining only a few lines of recitative in Floridante and Scipione, four arias in the final version of Riccardo Primo, and the opening scenes of Acts I and II of Alessandro.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 39
06/10/2006 14:51:22
40
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
nearest parallel, Giulio Cesare, another libretto with a remote seventeenth-century source, most of the original aria texts were clearly unsuitable, banal in diction or in strophic form with refrains after each stanza. Only seven were retained, mostly modified: ‘Chiudetevi’ and ‘Luci care’ in Act I, ‘Sparite, O pensieri’ and ‘Gelosia spietata aletto’ in Act II, ‘A languir ed a penar’, ‘Amor è un tiranno’ and ‘Armati, O core’, together with the duet in Act III. The accompagnato in which Ercole addresses Cerberus was taken over without change, and Trasimede’s Act I aria ‘Se l’arco avessi’ adapted from some lines of recitative. Handel removed a number of entrance and mid-scene arias, and created two cavatinas for Admeto in I.i and III.i, but did not keep rigidly to the exit aria convention. Neither he nor Mauro bothered about the liaison des scènes. Many of the most striking scenes in the opera were new: the ballet of spectres; Admeto’s accompagnato and the link to the overture (the 1679 libretto began with ‘Chiudetevi’); Alceste’s farewell to her attendants (I.v); the ending of the first two acts with strong arias for Antigona and Alceste – an almost invariable feature of Handel’s operas – in place of the comic ballets; the solo scenes for Antigona (II.iv), Admeto (II.viii) and Trasimede (II.x), enabling principal characters to give full vent to their emotions; most of III.vii, in which Trasimede discovers Antigona’s identity (this came earlier in 1679, before Handel’s III.iv); and the whole final scene after the pardon of Trasimede. In 1679 Admeto calmly orders Antigona to yield to fate and marry Trasimede, and is echoed by Alceste. Handel showed his care for dramatic propriety by not pairing Trasimede with Antigona. In addition he greatly improved the balance of Act I by bringing forward Antigona’s first entrance to follow Alceste’s farewell to her husband. In 1679 the act falls into two unequal parts, the first fifteen scenes dealing with Admeto, Alceste and the court, and only the last four with Antigona and Meraspe in the wood. For the most part Haym and Handel did a good job, without eradicating all traces of an obsolete convention. The hide-and-seek with dropped and stolen portraits (somewhat simplified from 1679), the conveniently vacant post for a female gardener (as in Giulio Cesare), and the Chinese-box system of disguises (for long periods the identity of both heroines is concealed from some of the other characters, but not from all) strain credulity, though less so in the theatre than on paper. The discrepancy between two aesthetic levels, the tangles woven by Antigona, Meraspe and Trasimede on the one hand and the classical grandeur of the Euripides plot on the other, is largely mitigated by the power of Handel’s music. More open to criticism is the abrupt change in Alceste’s character in Act II. Immediately after her rescue her thoughts are all for her husband. By her next appearance she has disguised herself as a soldier and is consumed by jealousy. Though Ercole points out that she has no grounds, she sends him to Admeto with a false message – thereby bringing her later troubles on her own head – and explodes in the furious aria ‘Gelosia, spietata Aletto’ (II.vii). Handel’s impassioned response is characteristic, but the aria pulls the character out of focus.12 12 Mauro perhaps spotted this; at the 1681 revival he substituted a less convulsive text in two strophes, the first addressed to jealousy, the second to constancy. This is the only major difference between the two Hanover librettos. Aureli’s aria at this point expressed conflicting emotions of love and jealousy.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 40
06/10/2006 14:51:22
Admeto, Re di Tessaglia
41
It might be argued ex post facto that Alceste’s sojourn in hell may have affected her mental balance, or that Handel wished to emphasise the mutability of women, or that he found it advisable to give Faustina a trenchant aria as different as possible from the rest of her part. In any event the contrast with earlier and later scenes is out of proportion. Jealous without a cause in II.vi, she fights down unworthy thoughts when Antigona gives her cause by admitting her love for Admeto (II.xii); and when Ercole says that Admeto reciprocates it she sings a tender aria about flowers and birds (III. vi). It is clear that Handel wished to stress the nobility of her character, quite apart from her heroic death. ‘Vedrò fra poco’ in II.xii is an insertion for which there is no parallel in the source. ‘Là dove gli occhi’ in III.vi flatly contradicts the source, where she sings an aria renouncing love – and Handel underlines the point by changing the last words of her recitative from ‘Admeto ingrato’ to ‘Admeto amato’. Nevertheless her furtive behaviour in Act III, lurking behind corners disguised as a man, detracts somewhat from her dignity. It is not surprising that the music falters at the same point. The last act, though a certain relaxation towards comedy was clearly deliberate, shows a decline from the superb level of the first two. But for this weakness Admeto would rank among Handel’s greatest operas. The variety of the music is as striking as its inventive resource. As usual he was inspired by the Greek setting: he realises the central issues of the myth, at once individual and symbolic, with extraordinary power. Admeto is a clear step forward on the road from Medea in Teseo and Acis and Galatea to the glories of Semele and Hercules. The supernatural episodes at the start of the first two acts are very impressive. The situation leads Handel naturally into formal experiment, combining symphonic movements, dancing, scenic spectacle and accompagnato in sequences of lapidary splendour. The raising of the curtain in the middle of the overture, whose conventional dance movement is replaced by the magnificent Lentemento sinfonia during which the spectres hover round the dying King – a dance indeed, but how different from the usual Minuet or Gavotte! – launches the opera on a stroke of transcendent genius. The second overture, at the start of Act II, is still finer. It is a tone picture of hell, with the three dolce cadence figures in the introduction perhaps suggesting the heroic Alceste. The astonishing chromatic fugue has parallels in similar contexts (‘They loathed to drink’ in Israel in Eg ypt, ‘And with his stripes’ in Messiah), but there is a hint of Bach in the ruthless precision with which it is worked out. As Burney noted with admiration, ‘the subject, in itself very curious and uncommon, is reversed [inverted] in the answer, and then interwoven and carried on as a counter subject throughout the movement’ (Ex. 5). Unison violin figures on the G string evoke the barking of Cerberus in Ercole’s accompagnato, and another close-knit fugal sinfonia follows as he subdues the furies. Both these scenes, especially the second, throw the mind forward to Gluck, whose debt to Handel’s treatment of the supernatural has been insufficiently recognised. Quite as striking as Handel’s illumination of the classical myth, and less predictable, is the degree to which he integrates the secondary plot and conceals some of the cracks in the libretto. The ultimate perfection may elude him, but he makes the motives and behaviour of Antigona entirely credible and saves the opera from collapsing into two irreconcilable halves. This is a triumph of characterisation.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 41
06/10/2006 14:51:22
42
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
Handel exploits to the full his unrivalled command of the voice, and particularly of the contrasted talents of his two leading ladies, the dramatic intensity of Faustina and the warbling fluttering eloquence, at once decorative and appealing, of Cuzzoni. Admeto is unquestionably the finest of the five Handel operas in which they appeared together, thanks in part to the sharp differentiation between their two characters. It is easy, in glancing through the score, to overlook the skill with which he subdues bravura pieces and simile arias to the demands of the drama. In the theatre we may be conscious of uneven inspiration, especially in the third act, but we never feel, as might be expected from the libretto, that one half of the plot, and one heroine, is outclassed by the other. This is also a measure of Handel’s understanding of Admeto, who supplies not only the title but the central pivot of the opera. He is a much more sympathetic character than in Euripides; Streatfeild’s ‘selfish amorist’ is a total misconception. It is his death scene, not that of Alceste, that we witness; he does not promise not to remarry (as he does in Euripides), he knows nothing in advance of Alceste’s intention to die for him, and he does not commit himself to wooing Antigona until he is convinced that Ercole’s mission has failed. He has every reason to feel that fate is throwing him into her arms, especially as he was betrothed to her before he met Alceste and would have married her but for Trasimede’s deception. The introduction of this episode puts any close comparison with Euripides out of court. Handel’s Admeto may not be the most virile of heroes, but he is no weakling. ‘Sparite, O pensieri’ leaves no doubt of his deep love for Alceste. His indecisiveness after her death arises from a genuinely divided conscience, and her reappearance lands him in a moral dilemma from which only Antigona’s self-sacrifice can release him. The faint aura of self-indulgence which his music exhales is due in part to the fact that fate constantly calls the tune and in part to the comparative weakness of two out of his three quick arias. There is more variety of mood and design in his music than in that of the other characters; he has two accompagnatos, two cavatinas, a duet and five arias, one of which (‘Un lampo è la speranza’) exhibits a hybrid form, the A section being a binary vocal dance with repeats. The death-bed scene represents Handel at the height of his powers as musician and dramatist. As the spectres disappear Admeto wakes with a start, uttering his first words con stupore, and we realise that we have been witnessing the tortured dreams of a dying man. The tempo of the recitative veers
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 42
06/10/2006 14:51:23
Admeto, Re di Tessaglia
43
abruptly between Agitato or Furioso13 and Adagio e piano, the mood between frenzy and exhausted resignation. Bold modulations, unexpected juxtapositions and interrupted cadences establish a harmonic tension of romantic violence. Some of the transitions are startling, especially the jump from F major via the chords of B flat minor and C major to E major at the words ‘Non avrò mai dunque riposo?’, where a gentle figure of falling semiquavers brings consolation as exquisite as it is unexpected and temporary (Ex. 6). From this suffering only death can bring release, and at ‘morir in pace’ the music passes into a cavatina whose valedictory sweetness is heightened by a major key (E flat) and a dotted figure of caressing tenderness on the violins. But the tonality droops, as if the effort were too much, into the related minor keys, F minor, C minor and G minor, and the momentary gleam of C major in the ritornello is beautifully darkened by a seventh suspension in the foreshortened coda.
Admeto’s recovery is treated with equal artistry. The jaunty melody of ‘Cangiò d’aspetto’ conveys very happily the King’s mingled relief and surprise, and there is a touch of light-headedness about the lively cross-rhythms that break out in bars 5–7 of the ritornello. By this means, by the change of texture towards the end of the A section and by the chromatic inflexions of the B section, Handel dispels any hint of complacency. The sudden lifting of the burden is further accentuated by the choice of key – D major, immediately following the E minor close of Alceste’s farewell to her attendants – a brilliant instance of Handel’s manipulation of tonality for a dramatic purpose. Admeto also has the next aria in this scene, suitably couched in B minor, but the obscure words seem to have baffled Handel’s search for the right tone. It was a difficult choice, for the part is already replete with expressions 13 One such marking, on the last beat of bar 16, is omitted by Chrysander (HG 6, final bar).
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 43
06/10/2006 14:51:23
44
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
of grief and anguish. The King’s meditation on the delusiveness of hope sounds almost detached.14 Both his arias in Act II on the other hand are beyond praise. ‘Sparite, O pensieri’, in that typically Handelian E major mood of serenity trembling on the brink of tears, expresses the ache in his longing for Alceste, most notably in the lingering cadences where the voice comes repeatedly to rest on the third of the chord. The sequential movement of the melody reflects the persistence of his emotion; a fastidious choice of harmony repels monotony. His despair, perfectly placed after Alceste’s jealousy aria, finds vent in another magnificent scena. The Adagio accompagnato is a simple succession of deliberately spaced chords passing through many keys, but so infallibly judged – especially the plunge into D flat and the move from G minor to B flat minor at ‘Giusti Numi’ – as to convey a profound searching of the heart. The aria, in the tragic key of F minor, is based on a creeping semiquaver figure of inexpressible sadness that wanders from one instrument to another, eventually reaches the voice at ‘dividere quel cor’ and haunts the B section as well. Other phrases of varied shape and length are cunningly woven into the instrumental texture. As in many arias of this type, the first three words (‘Ah, sì, morrò’) precede the ritornello. Their return unaccompanied in the middle of the aria, and later a silent bar followed by a quiet diminished seventh, are two of many masterly details. The reflective little cavatina with which the love-lorn Admeto begins Act III belongs to a type in which Handel’s operas are marvellously rich. Though only eighteen bars long and deceptively simple, it contrives, with the aid of eloquent suspensions, the hint of a ground bass, and an independent violin part in wide-ranging arpeggios, to make an impression, at once concentrated and spacious, altogether out of proportion to its length. ‘La tigre arde di sdegno’ no doubt gave Senesino a chance to let off steam, but it scarcely surmounts a strained zoological text in which the angry tigress of the first part is forced into awkward contrast with the querulous turtle-dove of the second; the simile, instead of illuminating the drama, leads it into a cul-de-sac. But the love duet with Antigona just before the dénouement is one of the gems of the score. It is overheard by both Alceste and Trasimede, and the irony of the situation is deliciously conveyed by the music, not least in the unharmonised ritornello, whose demure little tune suddenly drops two octaves to form a bass for the voices (Ex. 7). It continues to punctuate the duet at irregular intervals, like a sly commentary, in a variety of shapes and textures: now over a dominant pedal, now with a touch of canon, and in the final ritornello above a suave new bass disarmingly built from a rising scale. It never appears on the voices, which keep up a mellifluous cooing in thirds and imitations. The whole duet has a most original flavour, quite unlike the conventional congruence of operatic lovers but exactly apt to a situation in which the hero, in the unsuspected presence of his ‘dead’ wife, makes advances to the other woman.
14 At some performances Handel may have substituted a different aria; see below.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 44
06/10/2006 14:51:24
Admeto, Re di Tessaglia
45
For the greater part of two acts Alceste is a heroine beyond compare, noble in her self-sacrifice, tender, loving, yet at the same time regal. She has all the grandeur of Gluck’s Alceste, softened by a more touching humanity. ‘Luci care’, the aria in which, having taken her decision, she addresses the sleeping Admeto as she thinks for the last time, is a wonderful creation, as subtle in design as it is poignant in expression. The two principal motives, a cry of anguished farewell and a smoother phrase invoking sleep, are combined in a form that is neither cavatina nor da capo aria nor rondo but takes elements from all three. The gradual intensification of the texture, instrumental and harmonic, produces an overwhelming effect. The six-bar ritornello is for continuo alone; the coda, extended to ten bars and richly harmonised in five instrumental parts, takes the overflow of emotion when it becomes too strong for the voice to utter. Perhaps the most sublime moment is the unheralded entry of a single flute (its only appearance in the opera) at bar 45, overlapping a cadence in the dominant and introducing new material, which reappears in the coda. This withholding of an instrument or group of instruments for a late entry, whether in an aria, an act or an opera, is typical of Handel’s structural cunning. The E minor siciliano in which Alceste takes leave of her ladies is scarcely less moving, though the means employed – points of imitation between treble and bass at the beginning of phrases, intricate four-part writing with much crossing of parts, quiet switches between minor and major, subtly varied sequences, Neapolitan sixth harmony – are found in many Handel arias of this type. The B section, as befits the situation, all but eschews major tonality. ‘Quanto godrà’ is another magnificent inspiration. Alceste does not merely anticipate Admeto’s joy at seeing her again; the music glows with a personal radiance, soon to be quenched in bitter irony. Again two rhythmically opposed ideas are interfused, the resolute gesture of triumph in the dotted first phrase and the urgency of the semiquaver figure introduced by the oboes in thirds (symbolising perhaps her eagerness for a speedy reunion), which rises resplendently from the bass towards the end of the first part and is captured by the strings in the second. The immense drive and vitality of the aria springs from these contrasted rhythms and the splendid progression in bars 6 and 7, with viola and bass moving in contrary motion against a double internal pedal, tonic and supertonic (Ex. 8). ‘Gelosia’ with its downward unison scales and blazing coloratura cannot fail to make an impact, but as we have seen it strains the characterisation, nor does it equal similar outbursts in Hercules and elsewhere. More distinguished, as music and drama, is ‘Vedrò fra poco’, which restores Alceste’s stature by releasing her from the suspicion of pettiness and brings the act to an exuberant close. Quite apart from the superb melody, unfolding in extended paragraphs, there is much subtle contrivance here. The workmanship is solid, even learned, as in the treatment of the walking motive introduced in the bass of bar 4 and imitated by the treble two bars later. After the twenty-two-bar ritornello in four parts, with its long string of seventh suspensions, the voice takes up the opening phrase against a new and independent string accompaniment (pianissimo), and the music surges on in five real parts with very little doubling. Yet it makes an impression of vernal lightness and spontaneity, as if walking on air.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 45
06/10/2006 14:51:24
46
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
Alceste fades out in Act III. Her two arias, one an ornithological fantasy perhaps intended to demonstrate that Faustina could chirrup and trill as well as Cuzzoni or any violin, the other an amiable love song doubtless inserted as a set-off to the duet, call for little comment. The music is not bad; it simply marks time, communicating nothing fresh. As often elsewhere, Handel’s inspiration gives an intuitive response to what is weak or conventional in the libretto. Nowhere is his grasp of female psychology more comprehensive than in his portrait of Antigona, who makes the perfect foil to Alceste and is neither dwarfed nor shamed by the comparison. She has greater pliancy and resilience and a kittenish streak absent from her rival, but she lacks neither courage nor depth of feeling. If her motive in approaching Admeto’s court seems to be as much wounded pride as love for the King, we cannot suppose that the emotion of ‘Da tanti affanni’ is feigned. She is considerate of Trasimede’s wounded feelings (‘E che ci posso’), and
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 46
06/10/2006 14:51:25
Admeto, Re di Tessaglia
47
her ultimate retirement in favour of Alceste strikes us not as a structural convenience but as dramatically right and consistent. Behind her natural cheerfulness – indeed ebullience (her entire part except for ‘Da tanti affanni’ is in major keys) – there is undaunted determination; but besides claws and cunning she possesses irresistible charm, and knows how to exercise it. Handel calls on all Cuzzoni’s powers of trilling, warbling and pearly coloratura to etch her character; the decoration is functional, not extraneous or superimposed; almost every bar of the part is as individual to Antigona as the more regal and impassioned music of Faustina is to Alceste. The accompagnato that introduces Antigona is unusual. The exceptionally long and beautiful ritornello (19 bars), with its pedals and curious treatment of the strings, sometimes slurred, sometimes martellato, sometimes both at once, must be designed to establish a pastoral open-air contrast to the tragic enclosed mood of Alceste’s ‘Luci care’. But Antigona’s first words, denouncing Admeto as traitor and faithless lover, are set reflectively against a pianissimo accompaniment in an unclouded major key, and repeated four bars later to create a tidy cyclic form. She seems to be savouring the idea rather than surrendering to the emotion. Perhaps Handel is already preparing the way for her final renunciation. There is something at once touching and ironical – a very Handelian compound – about the episode, which in a few bars brings Antigona unmistakably to life. Her seven arias are very even in quality. Several are simile pieces, but even when Handel gives full vent to his gift for picturesque illustration, as with the swooping and hovering sparrowhawk in ‘Sen vola lo sparvier’ and the twinkling star in ‘La sorte mia’, he never falls into empty passage-work or loses touch with character. The sudden pedals in the voice part, contrasted with the tumbling violin figures, vividly suggest the flight of the bird in the former aria; the latter makes sparkling use of Cuzzoni’s trill, especially on the word ‘tremula’, and indulges felicitously in phrases of three bars and other unsymmetrical lengths. Four of Antigona’s arias are in B flat, a key as apt to Cuzzoni as A is to Faustina, but that is about all they have in common. ‘Spera allor’ veers constantly and eloquently towards C minor, in the ritornello and later, and once moves on through C major. The repetitions are softened by a good deal of rhythmic variety. Irregular phrase-lengths and a varied pattern of melodic material are still more prominent in ‘E per monti’, where short units of contrasted shape – groups of four semiquavers, three firmly repeated crotchets, arpeggiated quaver triads – are built up into an exhilarating demonstration of Antigona’s resolve to get her own way. ‘Io ti bacio’, based on a discarded setting of ‘Piangerò’ in Giulio Cesare, is brief but eloquent, and gains much from its context. Antigona begins an address to Admeto’s portrait. Cut short by Alceste, she presently resumes the aria,15 omitting the two-bar ritornello and taking off from the dominant instead of the mediant minor. Every detail is deftly placed, not least the interrupted cadence towards the end of the A section and the crowning entry of the strings, for a mere one and a half bars, after the da capo. ‘E che ci posso’, though dramatically apt, conforms with the general decline in invention in the last act. There remains Antigona’s single incursion into the minor, ‘Da tanti affanni’, a siciliano in the same key, rhythm, tempo 15 With the opening word changed; it should be ‘Sì, ti bacio’ in the first version, ‘Io ti bacio’ in the second. There is nothing to suggest the repetition in the source libretto.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 47
06/10/2006 14:51:25
48
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
and layout as Alceste’s ‘Farò così più bella’. The resemblance is perhaps too close, as if Cuzzoni had insisted on a copy of Faustina’s aria. But ‘Da tanti affanni’ is a most beautiful piece, in that mood of tragic pathos that Handel so often found for the heartache of frustrated lovers; Asteria’s ‘Se non mi vuol amar’ in Act I of Tamerlano is a close parallel in all respects, including key and the plaintive chromaticism of the B section. This access of emotion after Admeto’s abrupt departure inevitably wins sympathy for Antigona. Trasimede’s part in the action is undignified and scarcely consistent. A weak and indecisive man who spends hours poring over the portrait of a pretty girl, he makes a murderous attack on his brother with the sole apparent purpose of giving Alceste another chance to display her heroism. Yet Handel endows him with some exquisite music. All four of his arias have character, and they explore a wide range of mood. ‘Se l’arco avessi’ and the hunting sinfonia earlier in the scene are the only pieces apart from the coro in which the horns appear. They bring a welcome touch of colour to the serious tone of the act, and the aria, in which Handel explores the sonority of horns, oboes and four-part strings with the utmost resource, is a dazzling piece of orchestral virtuosity; to Burney it was ‘one of the best and most agreeable hunting songs that was ever composed’. The long A section, assembled from a few simple phrases, all pervaded by the quaver figure introduced in the second bar, depends entirely on texture; the tonality in 126 bars just attains the dominant. If in this aria Handel displays his skill in concealing the limitations of the horns, ‘Da te più tosto’ makes our heart bleed for a character who has done little to command credibility, let alone sympathy. It is a love song of ravishing tenderness with one of those wonderful E flat melodies whose perfection defies analysis. Its simplicity – the texture is largely a matter of thirds and octaves – is of course heightened by art, as in the delicious clashes between E flat and D natural towards the end of the A section and still more in the opening: the aria slides out of the recitative without cadence or ritornello, beginning on a pianissimo first inversion of E flat after a chord of G minor. ‘Chi è nato’ seems short-winded at first glance, but gains character from the processional rhythm and the colouring of the oboes in thirds, often independent of the strings. ‘Armati, O core’ is a vigorous outburst of wrath, unimpaired by the fact that Handel often used the same ingredients to similar effect elsewhere. The first phrase comes from the tenor aria ‘Brich, brullender Abgrund’ in the Brockes Passion; the jagged diminished seventh arpeggios in octaves are a regular vengeance motive. Ercole is little more than an agent for executing Admeto’s wishes – though a very potent one, as his treatment of Cerberus demonstrates – and has no chance to develop. The hint of comedy with which this professional strong man was traditionally portrayed never becomes grotesque, but (as in Hercules) his utterances have an undercurrent of humorous self-satisfaction; it is difficult not to smile at his ‘Opportuno qui giungo’ (III.x) when he turns up to help straighten the muddle which with a little imagination and initiative he might have prevented. Both his arias exhibit that brand of bluff heartiness (generally in a minor key) that seems to have been Boschi’s stock-in-trade; Handel nearly always wrote well for him, but there is no denying the standardised nature of the product. ‘La gloria sola’ is considerably the better of the two. Contrasted with the usual doubling of the vocal and instrumental bass is
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 48
06/10/2006 14:51:25
Admeto, Re di Tessaglia
49
a good deal of close-packed counterpoint. The opening motive appears in all three instrumental parts as well as the voice, and is interestingly developed in the ritornello at the end of the A section, which is two and a half bars longer than that at the beginning. The ascending chromatic line may hint at the dangers in the path to glory and Ercole’s confidence that they can be overcome. The B section, contrasted in material and tonality – smooth rhythms, richer part-writing, untroubled major key – is a notable source of strength. A curious feature of this aria is Handel’s reuse, perhaps subconscious, of material from the Allegro of the overture (see in particular HG 3, bottom line). Orindo and Meraspe are confined to a single aria apiece. Though neither is quite vintage Handel, Orindo’s is touching in its context; every lover found a friend in Handel. Meraspe’s is compact and dignified, as befits a man who enjoyed some standing in Troy. It will be seen that Handel’s writing for Palmerini differs from that for Boschi; the voice is almost independent of the instrumental bass. The scoring demands no detailed consideration, apart from the points already mentioned, but it partakes of the careful workmanship characteristic of the whole opera. This is equally true of the secco recitatives; Alceste’s decision to sacrifice herself (I.iii) and Admeto’s final recognition (III.x) are treated with particular sensitivity. The tonal scheme is interesting. Each act begins in a flat minor key and ends in a major key, without duplication (Act 1, D minor-A major, Act II, G minor-E major, Act III, C minor-F major); the close in the relative major of the original tonic brings the wheel full circle. Flat keys govern most of the important scenes (including all five accompagnatos) and outnumber the sharp keys by nearly three to one; this is not unusual in Handel’s more serious dramatic works.16 The tonal scheme of the opening scene (D minor, G minor, E flat major, C minor, F minor) reflects an obvious search for unity, and the scene in hell is firmly rooted in G minor, resolving on to B flat after the rescue. The latter is, however, the key principally associated with Antigona; there is no doubt a deliberate intention behind the fact that both her arias in Act III are in this key, whereas both Alceste’s are as far away as possible, in A. Although no autograph survives, the known compass of the singers suggests that few if any pieces were transposed before performance.
History and Text Handel finished the score on 10 November 1726; this date was added by Jennens at the end of the Flower copy and must derive from the lost autograph. The first full rehearsal on 25 January 1727 was attended by Elizabeth Legh and Mrs. Pendarves, who wrote to her sister on the following day: ‘Mrs. Legh is transported with joy at ... hearing Mr. Handel’s opera ... she is out of her senses.’ Handel conducted the first performance on 31 January, with the following cast: admeto Senesino (alto castrato) alceste Faustina Bordoni (soprano) antigona Francesca Cuzzoni (soprano) 16 Hercules and Theodora are conspicuous examples.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 49
06/10/2006 14:51:25
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
50
trasimede Antonio Baldi (alto castrato) ercole Giuseppe Boschi (bass) orindo Anna Dotti (contralto) meraspe Giovanni Battista Palmerini (bass) The opera was an instant success, receiving seventeen consecutive performances, interrupted only by the illness of first Faustina and then Cuzzoni, and two more before the end of the season. The Colman Opera Register recorded that ‘during this time the House filled every night fuller than ever was known at any opera for so long together’. Burney quoted ‘a gentleman who constantly attended its representation’ to the same effect. There was one dissentient voice; Robert Hassell, a provincial music publisher, wrote in a letter of 27 April: ‘Admetus has had a great Run much above its merits in my opinion. For it is not so good as Rodelinda and two or three more, but has been more followed and cryed up than any of them’.17 All three principal singers were acclaimed by the public, though in the case of the two leading ladies not the same public. The rivalry between their supporters came to the boil during the run, and found expression in several satirical pamphlets, some deplorable verses, and disturbances in the theatre, one of which, at the seventeenth performance of Admeto on 4 April, gave great offence to Princess Amelia.18 The part of Admeto suited Senesino’s gift for pathetic expression (Burney uses the word ‘pathetic’ again and again of his music and his singing in this opera), and he surpassed himself as an actor. Burney was ‘told by persons who heard this opera performed when it first came out, that Senesino never sung or acted better, or more to the satisfaction of the public, than in the opening scene’. Quantz, who arrived in London on 7 March and heard some of the later performances, thought the music magnificent and described the singing at length in his Autobiography.19 The French traveller Fougeroux too was full of praise for the orchestra. The formalities for Handel’s naturalisation were completed on 20 February during the run of Admeto, when George I gave the Royal Assent to a special Bill. The Hanover Alceste had been the first Italian opera he attended in February 1679.20 Admeto was probably one of the last.21 He left London for Hanover on 3 June and died suddenly on the 11th.
17 Gibson, 251. 18 See the letter from the Countess of Pembroke to Mrs Charlotte Clayton, quoted on p. 4. According to Burney it was while Cuzzoni was singing ‘Sen vola lo sparvier’ in Admeto that a man in the gallery shouted ‘Damn her: she has got a nest of nightingales in her belly’. Lady Cowper wrote ‘She is the devil of a singer’ against Faustina’s name in her copy of the libretto. 19 See p. 2. 20 Strohm, Essays, 55. 21 According to D. Burrows and R. D. Hume, ‘George I, the Haymarket Opera Company and Handel’s Water Music’, Early Music 19 (1991), 332–3, he attended all nineteen performances of Admeto, followed by two of Floridante and five of Bononcini’s Astianatte. This is most unlikely. The items cited in evidence do not refer specifically to the King. Had he been present during the disturbances, the fact would surely have been mentioned in the press and elsewhere (and the disturbances might not have occurred). A. H. Scouten, The London Stage, Part 3: 1729–1747, makes no mention of his presence at any of these performances.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 50
06/10/2006 14:51:25
Admeto, Re di Tessaglia
51
The eleventh performance, on 7 March, was for Faustina’s benefit, said to have brought her £1,800, and ‘several New Additions’ were advertised. Two of these can be identified in the first two arias in Chrysander’s appendix. ‘Spera, sì, mio caro bene’ and ‘Io son qual fenice’ replaced ‘Luci care’ and ‘Quanto godrà’ respectively. This preference for one moderate and one flashy piece over two of the greatest inspirations in the score reflects little credit on Faustina’s taste. She may have resented the fact, noted by Burney, that in ‘Quanto godrà’ the divisions are given more liberally to the instruments than to the voice. A third insertion was the fine B minor aria ‘Amor ed empietà’, sung by Senesino with a different B section text in the revival of Floridante a few weeks later (29 April).22 The three arias are found together, headed Additional Songs in Admetus, in the Barrett Lennard volume of ‘Miscellanys’; ‘Amor ed empietà’ also appears in the Shaftesbury manuscript supplementing the Cluer score of Admeto. It may have replaced ‘Un lampo è la speranza’ in the same key, on which it is a distinct improvement. These additions were advertised for the rest of the run, but some patchwork may have been required at the last two performances. On 8 and 11 April Admeto was postponed on account of the indisposition of Faustina, but returned to the bill, in what form we do not know, on the 15th and 18th. Handel revived Admeto for six performances at the start of the next season, the first on 30 September 1727, and for three more at the end, the first on 25 May 1728. It was the last opera given under the auspices of the Royal Academy of Music, on 1 June; another performance was advertised for 11 June, but cancelled owing to a possibly diplomatic illness of Faustina. With one exception the cast was unchanged. Anna Dotti was singing in Brussels in late autumn 1727 and was probably replaced in September by Mrs Wright, a soprano, who certainly sang Orindo’s part in May 1728. This lady, whether for reasons of temperament or figure, was judged incapable of playing a male role. Accordingly Orindo became ‘Orinda, a Lady of the Court’.23 This had strange consequences for the plot, since Orinda cannot decently make love to Antigona or command troops. The latter task in Act III falls incongruously to Meraspe, who as a result nearly finds himself in two places at once; he has Orindo’s recitatives in Scenes v, vi and ix. The love scene in II.ii was replaced by a new recitative and aria, ‘Dolce riso, dolci sguardi’, a floridly ornamented affair in A major based on material from the duet ‘Placa l’alma’ in Alessandro.24 The whole part is shortened; Orinda appears only once in Act I (vii) and not at all in Act III, though some residual matter in the libretto suggests that it was the original intention to include her in the first scene. The three arias inserted for Faustina’s benefit were not retained. The 1731/32 season began with three revivals hastily adapted to a new company of singers. The third of them was Admeto, produced on 7 December and given six times 22 This was doubtless the reason why, unlike the two arias for Faustina, it was not incorporated as a regular feature of the score, for example to the copies acquired for the Brunswick and Hamburg productions. 23 Compare the transformation of Nireno into Nerina for Benedetta Sorosina in Giulio Cesare in 1725. 24 This aria was at some time put down a fourth to E major for alto, possibly for Bagnolesi (Alceste) in 1731. It appears in this key at the end of the Flower score and parts.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 51
06/10/2006 14:51:25
52
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
up to 11 January (a performance on 4 January was cancelled owing to the illness of a singer). The Royal Family attended every performance in force. Only Senesino of the 1727 cast retained his part. Alceste was sung by Anna Bagnolesi (contralto) – her first role in England – Antigona by Strada, Trasimede by Campioli, Ercole by Pinacci (tenor), Meraspe by Montagnana; Orindo was omitted. The new pitch of Alceste’s and Ercole’s parts necessitated many changes; others, including copious cuts in recitative, were inspired by a desire to shorten at all costs. The result is a sorry hash, which sacrifices music and drama alike to expediency. Alceste retained two of her seven arias (‘Vedrò fra poco’ and ‘Sì, caro’, presumably transposed25); of the other five, ‘Luci care’ was replaced by ‘Spera, sì, mio caro bene’ (as in March 1727, but in a lower key, probably D minor), ‘Quanto godrà’ by the slight ‘Mostratevi serene’,26 ‘Là dove gli occhi’ by ‘Sento prima le procelle’, a spectacular outburst of fire and brimstone composed fifteen years earlier for the castrato Bernacchi in a revival of Pirro e Demetrio.27 ‘Farò così’ was cut, and ‘Gelosia’ inaptly transferred, with some modification of the words, to Ercole. The latter lost both his original arias; ‘La gloria sola’ was replaced by ‘L’aquila altera’, a simile aria written for Faustina in Riccardo Primo, ‘Amor è un tiranno’ by ‘Vanne amor tu sei tiranno’, an unidentified piece probably taken from another opera with parodied words. Antigona sang ‘E per monti’ from II.iv at her first appearance instead of ‘Spera allor’; Faustina’s ‘Io son qual fenice’ instead of ‘E per monti’ (a love song here, when Antigona has just rejected Trasimede, is peculiarly ill-timed); and Alceste’s ‘Là dove gli occhi’ instead of ‘E che ci posso’. Meraspe had two arias, ‘Volate più dei venti’ from Muzio Scevola, introduced by a recitative in which he asks the god of love to console Antigona, inserted after ‘Da tanti affanni’ in II.vi, and Ercole’s ‘Amor è un tiranno’ in place of ‘Signor lo credi a me’. This is not only maladroit in Meraspe’s mouth; it means that each of the lower voices sings an aria enshrining the same trite sentiments within a few minutes. Trasimede’s ‘Da te più tosto’ and of course Orindo’s ‘Bella, non t’adirar’ were cut. Several of Admeto’s scenes were emasculated, the great accompagnatos ‘Orride larve’ and ‘Quivi tra questi’ being reduced to six and four lines respectively and ‘Cangiò d’aspetto’ and ‘Un lampo è la speranza’ losing their B section and da capo. The abbreviation of Senesino’s part is not the only oddity about this revival. It is surprising that Montagnana was given the less important of the two lower male parts, with only two arias. He had first sung for Handel in the Tamerlano revival a month earlier, and perhaps his exceptional gifts were not yet recognised (he sang three arias in Poro in November, but all were taken from earlier works); the tenor Pinacci had arrived with a higher reputation. Alceste lost three of her finest arias, doubtless occasioned by the change of pitch and Bagnolesi’s lower status. As a result Antigona (Strada) emerged as the principal character. Altogether nine of the arias sung at the première disappeared; two of the three additions for Faustina’s benefit 25 One of them may have been replaced by ‘Dolce riso, dolci sguardi’ in E major. 26 Handel took the text of this aria and ‘Amor ed empietà’ from Salvi’s Dionisio re di Portogallo, which he was later to set as Sosarme. 27 Handel simplified the aria for Bagnolesi, shortening the A section by fourteen bars and removing a messa di voce sustained for 4½ bars on the first note as well as much coloratura.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 52
06/10/2006 14:51:25
Admeto, Re di Tessaglia
53
were restored, one of them for a different character; and five were added, at least four of them lifted from earlier works. With the possible exception of ‘Mostratevi serene’ there was no fresh composition. At least three of Alceste’s arias and two of Ercole’s must have been transposed, the latter’s perhaps down an octave. The unpublished tenor aria ‘Spirti fieri dell’alme guerrieri’ (see below, under Autograph) was certainly composed for Pinacci as Ercole in this revival, and may have been inserted (in I.vi) after the libretto had been printed. It is a reworking, with considerable improvements and a new B section text, of the aria beginning with the same words in Rodrigo. Admeto was the last Handel opera acted in London (or anywhere else) during the composer’s life. On 12 March 1754, long after the switch to oratorio, Vanneschi revived it for five performances at the King’s Theatre with ‘New Decorations’. Burney says it was ‘received with great indifference’ and is contemptuous of the singers, who included two sopranos associated with Handel’s oratorio seasons, Giulia Frasi (Antigona) and Christina Passerini (Trasimede). Admeto was sung by the castrato Pietro Serafini, Alceste by Caterina Visconti (soprano), Ercole by Ottavio Albuzio (tenor), and Meraspe by Ranieri (bass); Orindo was again cut. The text was based on 1731, but ‘Luci care’, ‘Quanto godrà’, ‘Là dove gli occhi’ and ‘E che ci posso’ reverted to their proper positions, and Trasimede (now a soprano) received Alceste’s ‘Farò così’ in place of ‘Da te più tosto’. Admeto sang the full da capo version of ‘Un lampo è la speranza’, but the other cuts in his part remained. Manuscript annotations in a copy of the Cluer score in the Coke Collection were evidently written by someone preparing the 1754 revival. For the most part they agree with the libretto. Of the two arias not in Cluer, ‘Volate più dei venti’ is not mentioned; an ambiguous note suggests that ‘Vanne amor’ (in III.iii in the libretto) may have been considered as a substitute for ‘Da te più tosto’ in II.iii, though this would make little sense. A few transpositions are indicated: ‘Io son qual fenice’ up a tone to G for Antigona (this may date from 1731), ‘Farò così’ up a minor third to G minor for Trasimede, ‘Chi è nato’ (Trasimede) up a tone to D minor, ‘La tigre arde’ (Admeto) up a major third to A. This is the only transposition in Admeto’s part, but the annotations are clearly incomplete. Trasimede’s ‘Armati, O core’ is marked ‘transposed’, but the word is crossed out. William C. Smith28 claimed that the annotations are in Handel’s writing; they certainly are not (in any case he was blind by 1754), but they could be in that of the younger J. C. Smith. Handel, though not responsible for the revival, might have authorised Smith to prepare it. That could account for the disappearance of the performing score and perhaps the autograph as well. If they left Handel’s house and found their way to the King’s Theatre, they could have perished when the building was burnt down. It certainly looks as if the annotator was familiar with the text of the 1731 revival. The popularity of the music is attested by frequent performances of single items. Handel himself incorporated ‘Sì, caro’ in his 1731 revival of Rinaldo, and ‘Mostratevi serene’ in his pasticcio Oreste (Covent Garden, 18 December 1734). ‘Là dove gli occhi’ was sung with parodied words in Lampugnani’s arrangement of Rossane at the King’s Theatre in 1743 (see Chapter 2), and three arias from Admeto (‘Sen vola lo sparvier’, ‘Un lampo è la speranza’ and ‘Se l’avessi’) figured in the pasticcio Lucio Vero in 28 ‘The 1754 Revival of Handel’s Admeto’, M & L 51 (1970), 141–9.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 53
06/10/2006 14:51:26
54
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
November 1747. During Handel’s last years ‘Sen vola lo sparvier’ was adapted, probably by the younger Smith, for a new setting of ‘From virtue springs’ in Theodora. Burney mentions ‘Un lampo è la speranza’, ‘Se l’arco avessi’ and ‘Sì, caro’ as general favourites. The London Stage records nine performances of ‘Sì, caro’ up to 1731 by three different singers (Miss Warren, Mrs Hill and Mrs [?Ann Turner] Robinson) at five different venues, and ten of ‘Se l’arco avessi’ up to 1735, some of them of an eccentric nature. Mrs Barbier sang it three times at Lincoln’s Inn Fields in 1728–29, once for her own benefit at a performance of Hamlet; in 1730 the trumpeter Burk Thumoth played it three times as a trumpet solo (once as a ‘Trumpet Farce’); Mrs Wright offered a different version at Covent Garden on 20 April and 1 May 1733, on the first occasion ‘accompanyed with a Trumpet’, on the second by ‘Trumpets, French Horns, etc.’; Osborne, a boy pupil of Henry Carey, sang it at the Little Haymarket Theatre on 31 August 1735. Only one performance of ‘Un lampo è la speranza’ is recorded (by Clarke at Drury Lane on 26 March 1729), and one of ‘Sparite, O pensieri’ (by Mrs Barbier at Lincoln’s Inn Fields on 5 March 1729). Domenica Casarini sang ‘Là dove gli occhi’ at a Musicians Fund benefit at the King’s Theatre on 14 April 1747 (not mentioned in The London Stage). Mrs Barbier sang ‘La tigre arde’ at Lincoln’s Inn Fields on 5 March 1729 and in the Crow Street Music Hall, Dublin, on 4 December 1731; Clarke sang it at Drury Lane on 26 March 1729. The overture figured at the Little Haymarket on 1 December 1733 (at a performance of The Relapse), and at the Manchester Subscription Concerts on 14 May and 23 July 1745. Admeto enjoyed considerable early success in Germany. An arrangement by G. C. Schürmann with the set pieces in Italian, the recitatives in German, was produced at Brunswick in August 1729 and revived in February 1732 and August 1739. A different German translation by C. G. Wendt had three performances at Hamburg in 1730, the first on 23 January (NS) and was revived every year till 1736, for thirteen performances in all. Both German productions gave a very full text: see below, under Librettos. There have been about a dozen modern productions, the earliest at Brunswick (1925) and Halle (1958). These and the four in England (Abingdon 1964, Birmingham 1968, Colchester 1973, Cambridge 1999) were in translation. Admeto was the first Handel opera broadcast by the BBC Third Programme (1 February 1947), translated by Geoffrey Dunn and conducted by Stanford Robinson in an edition prepared by Anthony Lewis, who conducted the very successful Birmingham production with Janet Baker as Alcestis. A BBC studio performance of this version, broadcast in August 1968, was issued as a commercial recording by Ponto in 2004. A recording under Alan Curtis was issued by EMI Electrola in 1978.
Autograph Only two arias and a fragment of a third, all composed after the première and all unpublished, survive in autograph. ‘Dolce riso, dolci sguardi’ (RM 20 f 11, fols 22–3) was composed for Mrs Wright (Orinda) probably in autumn 1727, ‘Spirti fieri dell’alme guerrieri’ (RM 20 d 2, fols 9–10) for Pinacci (Ercole) in 1731. The tempo, originally Allegro, was changed to Andante. Handel followed it with a new four-bar
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 54
06/10/2006 14:51:26
Admeto, Re di Tessaglia
55
recitative for Admeto and a cue for ‘Un lampo è la speranza’ to follow, thus locating it firmly at the end of I.vi. An incomplete tenor setting of ‘Fra le spine’ in Fitzwilliam Mus. MS 256, pp. 1–2, a reworking of another Rodrigo aria, undoubtedly dates from the same occasion.29 Handel abandoned it in the thirtieth bar.
Librettos 1727. ‘Admeto, Re di Tessaglia, Drama. Da Rappresentarsi Nel Regio Teatro di Hay-Market Per La Reale Accademia di Musica ... Printed, and Sold, at the King’s Theatre in the Hay-Market’ [viii +] 77 pp. Handel is named, but not the librettist or the scene designer.30 Argument in Italian and English, the former taken almost word for word from Aureli’s 1660 libretto. The English version, after summarising the story as told in the Alcestis, declares: ‘This is collected out of the Fables of the Ancients: The rest is the Work of Fiction, purely for the ornamenting the Drama’. The text is substantially Chrysander’s, but the latter omits many important stage directions, including the attribution of the accompanied recitative ‘Risanarti non puoi’ in I.iii to Apollo’s statue, Admeto’s falling asleep before Alceste proclaims her resolve to die for him in the same scene, the whole rubric for I.v (the garden, Alceste with a dagger and her veiled and weeping attendants), Ercole’s drastic treatment of Cerberus (II.i), Alceste’s disguise as a soldier (II.vii), Trasimede’s release of Antigona (II.ix), the location of III.i, and much action in III.v and vi, including the soldiers chaining Alceste and Antigona snatching back the portrait. Many of these directions are in copies of the score as well as the libretto. Chrysander places the cue for the closing of the back scene in I.vii (HG 28) seven bars too early. The ballet of spectres in the opening scene is not mentioned in the libretto, though it appears in all copies of the score; it could have been a late addition. 1728. Title as 1727 except for date, text reset. 79pp. The only important change is that ‘Orindo, Gentleman of the Court’ becomes ‘Orinda, a Lady of the Court’, with the modifications and cuts noted above. One line for Antigona in the last scene is omitted. 1729 Brunswick. ‘Drama per Musica da rappresentarsi nel famosissimo Teatro di Braunsviga Nella Fiera d’Estate L’Anno 1729. Wolfenbüttel druckts Christian Bartsch’. Bilingual, including title and all preliminaries; Italian and German text on opposite pages. Full text including both Faustina replacement arias. Orindo, listed as court cavalier or Admeto’s Hof-Junker, takes Orinda’s aria ‘Dolce riso’ but not her sex. Scene headings mostly more elaborate than in London librettos, but theatre evidently not equipped for flying in II.i. II.vii (Luogo delizioso con Campi de Tessaglia in Lontananza) begins with Ercole singing ‘Serenatevi, O luci belle’ from Teseo. Dances in I.i, II.i and after II (Thessalian peasants of both sexes). 1730 Hamburg. ‘Admetus, König in Thessalien in einer Oper auf dem Hamburgischen Schau-Platze vorgestellet ... Gedruckt mit Stromerschen Schriften.’ 29 HHB prints it under Rodrigo but the watermark (K10) confirms the 1731–32 date. 30 Deutsch (201) attributes the scenery to Goupy, but the sentence he quotes comes from the libretto of Riccardo Primo, not Admeto.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 55
06/10/2006 14:51:26
56
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
Handel and the translator Wend(t) are named, but no cast. Possibly based on the Brunswick version, though the translation is new; contains the same dances, Faustina’s two substituted arias and ‘Serenatevi, O luci belle’ but not ‘Dolce riso’. Recitatives in German, arias, duet and coro in Italian with German text alongside. 1731 Hamburg. Title as 1730 except for date and ‘Gedruckt mit Piscators Schrifften’. Text unchanged. 1731 Handel. ‘The Second Edition, with many Additions ... Printed and Sold by T. Wood in Little-Britain ... [Price 1s.]’ 55 pp. It was in fact the third edition. The Argument, in English only, is reduced to its first three paragraphs on the classical half of the plot. Handel is not named. The many changes – more subtractions than additions – are summarised above. A few extra lines of recitative are inserted as links, and one new stage direction, A Guard gives him [Admeto] a Letter in I.vii (now vi) two lines after the revelation of Alceste’s body. 1732 Brunswick. ‘Admetus König in Thessalien in der Winter-Messe Anno MDCCXXII’. As 1729 but in German only (except arias and duet in both languages). Coro in German identical with 1729 translation, fits Handel’s music and was probably sung to it. II.iv shifted from a pleasure garden to a suburban desert, presumably to fit available scenery. 1739 Brunswick. As 1732 with date changed to ‘In der Sommer-Messe 1739’. In none of the Brunswick librettos are Handel or any singers named. 1754 London (Vanneschi). ‘Drama per Musica pel Teatro di S.M.B. ... Printed by G. Woodfall, at the King’s-Arms, Charing-Cross ... [Price One Shilling.]’ 77 pp. Handel is once more acknowledged. Based mostly on 1731, but with six earlier arias restored, one of them (‘Farò così’) for a different character in a fresh context, indicating a partial return to the 1727 text in the roles of Alceste and Antigona. ‘Farò così’ is introduced by a new recitative, ‘Quanto godrà’ by that preceding ‘Mostratevi serene’ in 1731.
Copies and Editions In the absence of autograph and performing score some details of the textual history are obscure. The earliest complete copy is Malmesbury (S2), signed and dated 1727 by Elizabeth Legh. It contains two unica: the statue’s recitative is a different setting for tenor, and Meraspe’s recitative in III.i is for a considerably lower bass voice. Both tie in with two unpublished settings of Meraspe’s aria ‘Signor, lo credi a me’, copied by S2 in RM 19 a 1. All three settings are based on the same material. It is clear from internal evidence, in the treatment of both the verbal text and the musical ideas, that the tenor setting (in D minor with an independently written part for bassoons and a much shorter B section) came first, that the bass setting (in A minor for a deep voice going down to E) followed, and that both preceded the more mature published version. (They were probably copied from the lost autograph in accordance with the practice S2 was later to adopt for Jennens.) It would be tempting at first glance to suppose that the bass setting was written for Montagnana in 1731, as indicated in HHB, but the content rules this out. Handel must have first conceived Meraspe’s part for a tenor of limited capacity – probably Antinori,
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 56
06/10/2006 14:51:26
Admeto, Re di Tessaglia
57
the tenor of the previous season – who was also assigned the brief utterance of the statue, then transferred it to the low bass for whom the recitative in III.i was written, and finally settled on Palmerini, whose voice (like that of Boschi) had the compass of a baritone. The six complete copies – the others are Lennard (S1, late 1730s), Flower (S2, c.1738), Granville (S5, early 1740s), RM 19 c 1 (S5 or S6,31 c.1755) and RM 19 c 2 (S13, 1784/85)32 – show no wide variation; but Malmesbury, though sparing in instrumentation, dynamics and stage directions, is the only score (with the exception of the eccentric and incomplete Add. MS 38002) that antedates Handel’s first revival. Its text therefore brings us as near as we can get to that of the first performance. The most significant details in which it differs from some (not all) of the later copies are the recitative cadences before Ercole’s first entry (bottom of HG9, G minor), before ‘Luci care’ (HG13, C major), and before ‘Là dove gli occhi’ (HG 102, E major). In these respects it agrees with Lennard and RM 19 c 1, which must have come from the same stable. The other copies have cadences respectively in B minor, A (? major) and A major (except that this cadence in Flower is in E major). In each case this points to the subsequent insertion or replacement of an aria. It is not clear what could have preceded Ercole’s entry; an aria for Orindo is unlikely in this context (Chrysander conjecturally ascribes ‘Mostratevi serene’ to Orindo, but it does not fit here dramatically and is in the wrong key). Before ‘Luci care’ Chrysander altered the cadence in A in RM 19 c 2 to C (he annotated both this copy and RM 19 c 1). Faustina sang ‘Spero, sì’ here in March 1727, but it is in the same key as ‘Luci care’, F minor. It must, however, have been transposed when the contralto Bagnolesi sang it in 1731; D minor would fit. The A major cadence on HG 102 almost certainly introduced the D major aria ‘Sento prima le procelle’ in 1731. Some copies show further traces of Handel’s revivals; for example RM 19 c 1, like the 1731 libretto, omits the last fourteen bars of the recitative for Antigona and Meraspe in I.viii (HG 31), ending with a D minor cadence at ‘svenata Alceste’. Granville and RM 19 c 2 have the same three additional arias as HG; RM 19 c 2 despite the implication in Squire (p. 99), contains many more stage directions than RM 19 c 1, but the latter has the vital one for Admeto to sleep after ‘E non si tema’ (HG 13). Flower, which contains most of the stage directions not in Chrysander, derives from the same stable as Granville and RM 19 c 2, but has some unusual features. Its appendix, in addition to the three additional arias in HG (‘Mostratevi serene’ copiously figured), contains ‘Dolce riso’ for alto in E major and a seven-bar B section (Lentement) for the second sinfonia in II.i (HG 46–8) with da capo indicated. This occurs elsewhere only in the supplementary Shaftesbury manuscript, and was doubtless copied from the autograph. So probably was the interesting and unique stage direction in II.i (HG 49), where at the words ‘ritorna ravvivata’ Ercole restores Alceste to life by touching her with Mercury’s wand (La tocca con il caduceo di Mercurio e la ritorna in vita). 31 The two hands are very similar. Larsen opts for S6, but the clefs seem more characteristic of S5. The words are in a different hand. 32 See J. H. Roberts, in T. Best (ed.), Handel Collections and their History, 51.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 57
06/10/2006 14:51:26
58
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
The Flower parts (S2, c.1743) – cembalo, violins 1 and 2, viola, basso, oboes including traversa 1 and 2, (plus horns 1 and 2 at the University of Maryland) – offer the usual strange selection. Besides secco recitatives, overture, sinfonias and coro, which Jennens may not have required, S2 left out the accompagnatos in I.iv and II.i and seven arias (‘Farò così’, ‘Quanto godrà’, ‘Bella, non t’adirar’, ‘Da te più tosto’, ‘A languir ed a penar’, ‘Signor, lo credi a me’, and ‘Armati, O core’). An appendix contains ‘Se l’arco avessi’ (misplaced), the four supplementary arias in the Flower score (‘Dolce riso’ in E major) and ‘Sento prima le procelle’ – not as sung in 1731/32 but in its more elaborate version composed for Bernacchi in 1717. The movements are numbered consecutively throughout from 1 to 29, so there is no question of accidental loss. The parts were not copied from the Flower score; apart from omissions and one addition, ‘Io son qual fenice’ and ‘Spera, sì’ are full da capo arias in the parts, dal segno in the score. S2 probably compiled the parts from several sources. Both score and parts give many more dynamics than Chrysander, or even than RM 19 c 2, as well as some differences in scoring. In the Lentemento (HG 5, the only non-vocal movement) the last five bars, except the first beat, are for strings only pianissimo, and the tutti at bar 15 is piano, not forte (as it is also in RM 18 c 3, a copy of part of the opening scene). The dynamics in this short piece are exceptionally detailed, including many pianissimos. The last beat on HG 6 is Furioso, as in Malmesbury and nearly all later copies. In bars 31–2 and 81 of ‘Se l’arco’, where Chrysander supplies forte marks, the Flower score and parts have piano. Many other examples could be cited. In the opening ritornello of the duet ‘Alma mia’ the basso part doubles the treble two octaves below (in Lennard and RM 19 c 1 it doubles the first five notes only – lazy copying no doubt, yet rests follow). It contains passages for cellos only in ‘E per monti’ and ‘Vedrò fra poco’. ‘Sì, caro’ has a viola part in the four-bar ritornello leading to the dal segno. The oboes are divided more often than usual, and play more frequently while the voice is singing, though in the absence of autograph and performing score there is no knowing if this is correct. In ‘La gloria sola’ they double the violins throughout, including the B section, except in the first phrase of bars 9 and 23 and where the violins go below their compass. In ‘Vedrò fra poco’ they play throughout the A section, marked pianissimo when the voice enters. They double the violins in the ritornellos of ‘E che ci posso’ and ‘Spera, sì’ but are silent in ‘Ah, sì, morrò’. Add. MS 38002 (Smith, c.1727–28) is an incomplete aria collection made for a soprano singer, probably one of the Prince of Wales’s daughters, Handel’s pupils.33 The fact that it includes the unpublished tenor setting of ‘Signor, lo credi a me’ (with the voice up an octave) chimes with the early date, supported by the paper. All names of characters, recitatives and stage directions are omitted, together with the hunting sinfonia, the coro and three arias (both of Ercole’s and ‘Armati, O core’, the least suited to a soprano voice). Both overtures are in keyboard arrangements. The first includes the Lentemento, marked Larghetto with many changes of detail; the second embraces the two fugal movements, marked Andante and Allegro respectively. The arias are complete in full score, though not quite in the correct order. Nearly all 33 RM 19 f 3 (Giulio Cesare) is an exact parallel, with some of the same tools used in the binding. See Handel’s Operas I, pp. 520–1 and note 70. RM 19 f 4 (Floridante) is a similar copy for alto voice.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 58
06/10/2006 14:51:26
Admeto, Re di Tessaglia
59
those for alto voice – Admeto’s seven, Orindo’s one, and two of Trasimede’s – are transposed up a third or a fourth; only ‘Se l’arco’ retains its original pitch, no doubt on account of the horns. The duet is included, with Admeto’s part unchanged; it has some interesting dynamics that appear in no other source. Another aria collection, Berlin Staatsbibliothek, Preussischer Kulturbesitz, Mus. MS 9053, was copied (?mid-1730s) by the microscopic hand found in two volumes of the Coke Collection, evidently from the Cluer score, whose arrangement it follows exactly. However ‘Io son qual fenice’ and ‘Spera, sì’ have additional figuring, and there are a few minor variants: the overture’s introduction is Largo, bar 25 of its Allegro is senza organo, and ‘Luci care’ is Larghetto. All dal segno arias are da capo, though ‘Farò così’ was originally written with a correct segno on all staves, subsequently cancelled. All but four of the arias have an English version squeezed in above the voice part. This is illegible on film, but the incipits in the index prefixed to the volume suggest that it is a straight translation, unlike other operas in this hand.34 Six ex-Aylesford volumes in the British Library contain excerpts from Admeto copied by S2 (unless stated otherwise), mostly c.1728–30: RM 18 c 1 (overture, Larghetto= Lentemento in I.i, sinfonia in II.i, keyboard arrangements), RM 18 c 2 (overture for keyboard), RM 18 c 3 (Lentemento and accompagnato ‘Orride larve’ in I.i; ‘Quanto godrà’ (H4); accompagnato ‘Quivi tra questi’ and ‘Ah, sì, morrò’), RM 18 c 10 (‘Mostratevi serene’, ‘Sento prima le procelle’ – both with voice part in treble clef an octave too high – the statue’s recitative ‘Risanarti non puoi’, the sinfonia and accompagnato in I.iv, the sinfonia in I.ix and the accompanied recitative ‘In van ti scuoti’ in II.i), RM 18 b 4 (‘Dolce riso’ in A major, ‘Mrs. Wright in Admetus’; ‘Mostratevi serene’ unfigured (H8)), RM 19 a 1 (the two unpublished settings of ‘Signor, lo credi a me’). The keyboard transcriptions of the two overtures in Add. MS 38002, RM 18 c 1 and RM 18 c 2 are in Handel’s arrangements,35 as are three other early copies of both overtures, in the Coke Rivers MS (Smith junior, c.1727) and two volumes in the Malmesbury Collection (Smith junior, c.1727; Smith senior, c.1728). A number of other excepts survive in several libraries: four arias, two of them incomplete, in BL Add. MS 24307 (‘Vedrò fra poco’ in D major and ‘Ah sì morrò’ in 3/4, copied by S2; ‘Sparite, O pensieri’ and ‘Sì, caro’ in G major, copied by H6/9); the three arias added for Faustina’s benefit (‘Amor ed empietà’,36 ‘Spera, sì’ and ‘Io non qual fenice’) in Fitzwilliam Mus. MS 798 (S5, 1738 or later); ‘Mostratevi serene’ and ‘Volate più dei venti’, ‘Additional Song in Admetus’, ascribed to Ercole instead of Meraspe, in BL Add MS 31572 (copyist Xi);37 ‘Vedrò fra poco’ in RM 19 d 12 (? S1) and Manchester MS v. 313 (Smith, c.1746); ‘Dolce riso’ (S2) in Bodleian MS Mus. c 1080. The Coke Collection has excerpts from Admeto in no fewer than twelve volumes. 34 See Handel’s Operas I, pp. 257, 362, 480. 35 See Terence Best, Twenty Overtures, III. 36 There is another copy of this aria in RM 18 b 4 (‘by Sr. Senesini’). The version sung in Floridante (RM 18 c 3) has a different text in the B section. Both are S2 copies. 37 This copyist seems to have had some connection with the Smith circle. In addition to the whole of Add. MS 31572, he was responsible, sometimes in conjunction with S2, for copying parts in Esther (Durham), Alexander’s Feast (Coke), Arminio (Coke) and a cello part in Arminio (Flower).
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 59
06/10/2006 14:51:26
60
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
They include two different arrangements (one Handel’s, copied by Smith junior, the other in an untidy unrecognised hand) of the overture and two sinfonias in II.i, and a number of arias in full or short score. ‘Sì, caro’ appears in five manuscripts, twice (in G major) with almost identical vocal ornamentation. There are S2 copies of ‘Ah, sì morrò’, ‘Sparite, O pensieri’, ‘Cangiò d’aspetto’ and ‘La tigre arde’, and two volumes containing parts: twenty-four items for flute (voice), strings and figured bass, nearly all in transposed keys with occasional cues for other instruments, and a not quite complete set for ‘La tigre arde’, ‘Ah, sì morrò’ and ‘Se l’arco avessi’. A volume from the Shaftesbury Collection (S2) supplements the Cluer score, including five accompagnatos (HG 6, 13, 16, 46, 72), three sinfonias (HG 16, 31, 46) and two arias, ‘Spera, sì’ (HG 121) and ‘Amor ed empietà’, reflecting an early state of the score. ‘Risanarti’ is in the tenor version (as in Malmesbury), the hunting sinfonia in I.ix has no violins, and the sinfonia in HG 46 has an unpublished B section (Lentement) and da capo, as in the appendix of the Flower copy. Cluer’s score (‘Admetus, an Opera, Compos’d by Mr. Handel’) was published on 24 June 1727. The list of fifty-seven subscribers (for ninety-three copies) includes one from New York. All recitatives, the Lentemento in I.i, the hunting sinfonia and the second sinfonia in II.i are omitted, but both overtures and the coro are present. ‘Io son qual fenice’ replaces ‘Quanto godrà’; ‘Spera, sì’ appears at the end of Act II under the heading ‘Additional Song Sung by Siga Faustina in ye 1st Act’.38 Dal segno arias are given a lazy da capo. ‘Io ti bacio’ lacks its string coda. Some tempo marks are missing, but others are present that Chrysander ignores (see below). ‘Io son qual fenice’ is Allegro – a mistake; it is Andante in Malmesbury and later copies, as in HG. The success of the opera stimulated publishers into lively activity. Before the appearance of the score Walsh and Hare brought out the overture in parts (April) and a flute arrangement on 3 June, though Benjamin Cooke had already issued a flute arrangement ‘by Authority of the Patentee’ (i.e. Cluer) on 20 May. Walsh followed up with nine Favourite Songs (14 September 1728), both overtures for keyboard (not in Handel’s arrangement, 28 October 1728), and ‘Se l’arco’ in parts in a collection of Six Celebrated Songs made on purpose for French Horns (26 June 1731). He included a version of the same aria arranged for two horns in Forrest Music, vol. II (1733). ‘Sì, caro’ (more than once), ‘Io ti bacio’ and ‘Un lampo è la speranza’ appeared on single sheets. Most of these editions were reissued later, besides further arrangements and selections. Chrysander based his edition (1877) mainly on RM 19 c 2, the latest of the copies, and Cluer, but made some use of RM 19 c 1. Though accurate in the main, it is often defective in detail. Apart from the missing stage directions noted above, without which it is difficult to follow the intricacies of the plot, it is short on dynamics and tempo indications. The following movements are all Allegro in sources available to Chrysander: ‘La gloria sola’, second sinfonia in II.i (HG 46), ‘Quanto godrà’ (sometimes Allegro e staccato), ‘Chi è nato’, ‘La tigre arde’, and ‘E che ci posso’. ‘A languir ed a penar’ and ‘Io ti bacio’ (the complete aria) are Largo in all sources 38 The copy of the Cluer score in the Shaftesbury (Coke) Collection contains the Lentemento and ‘Quanto godrà’ as manuscript insertions in the hand of S2, which suggests that the Lentementos may have been omitted at Faustina’s benefit.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 60
06/10/2006 14:51:27
Admeto, Re di Tessaglia
61
except RM 19 c 2, which also omits some of the Allegro tempos. Why Chrysander should have given it preference remains a mystery. All librettos and most manuscripts agree that the four-bar fragment of ‘Io ti bacio’ should begin ‘Sì ti bacio’, and Malmesbury, Flower and Granville give the tempo as Larghetto, with Largo for the full aria, which makes a good point: Antigona savours her apparent triumph by lingering over it.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 61
06/10/2006 14:51:27
chapter 4 Riccardo Primo, Re d’Inghilterr a
T
he Argument, taken partly from Briani’s libretto, relates some political history, how Isacio (Isaac Comnenus) obtained the throne of Cyprus from the Byzantine Emperor by forgery, followed by a military victory over his successor, which ‘puffed him up with Pride, and made him insolent and cruel ... Hence he refused the port of Limissus [Limassol] ... to the English Navy, without having any regard for the Princess of Navarre [Berengaria in history, Costanza in the opera], who was there to espouse Richard [Cœur de Lion], and who had laboured her Way thither through a strong and violent Tempest’. The date is ‘towards the Year’ 1190 [recte 1191]. Richard was on his way to the Third Crusade. ‘The Scene is the Court of Limissus, and the Palace of Isacius’. Act I. Like a certain later opera set on the coast of Cyprus, Riccardo Primo begins with a spectacular storm. The Coast near Limissus, a tempestuous Sea, with Ships bulging [rotta] amongst the Rocks. Costanza, with her ‘Cousin and Tutor’ Berardo is in despair over the fate of Riccardo; although she has never seen him, she claims to adore him and wants to die if he has perished. Isacio, his daughter Pulcheria and Oronte, ‘Prince of Syria, Confederate’ of Isacio, arrive with Guards. In reply to Pulcheria Costanza says her name is Doride, and her companion is her cousin Narsete; Costanza perished in the storm. Isacio, impressed by her manner (‘Quanto è gentile!’), tells Pulcheria to entertain the strangers in his palace and prepare for her wedding to Oronte. She is happy to obey both commands. She takes Costanza by the hand and they go out followed by Berardo, but Oronte is held back by Isacio. Isacio orders Oronte to burn the wrecked British ships and leaves. Oronte gives vent to his passion for Pulcheria. In A Pavilion not far from the Rivers of Limissus Riccardo, with his Commanders and a letter open in his hand, from which he has learned that Costanza is at Isacio’s court, resolves to go there, where he is not known. He likewise burns with passion for a woman he has never seen. In A Room with a Table Costanza tells Berardo of her friendly reception from Pulcheria. Oronte enters from one side, Pulcheria from the other. Oronte begins to Handel, vague in dealing with proper names, writes Limisso, Lamisso, Larisso indiscriminately. This direction in the autograph is missing in the libretto, the performing score (as reconstituted) and HG; it belongs strictly to Handel’s first version but is equally applicable to the second. Sic; but rive means shores, or banks. Omitted from the libretto, as are almost all stage directions from here to the end of the Act and the set change at I.iv. Thanks to omissions and mistakes this scene is almost incomprehensible in the libretto. The second occurrence of the couplet beginning ‘Doride, hai nel sembiante’ belongs to Pulcheria, preceded by a line for Costanza. The HG text is correct.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 62
06/10/2006 14:51:27
Riccardo Primo, Re d’Inghilterra
63
pay extravagant compliments to ‘Doride’, who remains silent. Pulcheria suddenly comes between them and laughing repeats his words, to his acute embarrassment. He tries to interrupt, but in a burst of anger she calls him a traitor and continues to mock him. She assures Costanza that she feels no hostility towards her; she wants only to punish Oronte. Isacio enters suddenly, sends away all but Costanza (Berardo under protest), and first tries to take her hand, then approaches as if to embrace her. She first retires, then kneels before him. Oronte enters hurriedly (Costanza quickly gets up) and announces that an ambassador from the English King is on his way. Isacio, laughing with Oronte, asks what he wants. Oronte reports that Riccardo landed by night with a large army from a hundred ships. Isacio tells him to admit the ambassador. Costanza leaves with a plea to be left in peace. The ambassador is Riccardo himself. He asks Isacio for the King’s bride. Isacio, standing weightily [grave] and proudly, leaning on a table, at once guesses that ‘Doride’ is Costanza, and tells the ambassador that Riccardo will soon behold his royal spouse. Riccardo likens himself to a mariner who beset by furious storms catches sight of his guiding star. Act II. In A Room [in Isacio’s Palace] Costanza is in despair: if heaven is against her, what can she hope for? She and Berardo have been prevented from seeing the ambassador. She sends Berardo to find out if Riccardo knows that she is at the court. She is forced to admit her identity to Isacio, who replies with deliberate ambiguity that she will soon see her husband. He has no intention of giving her up: ‘Successful Fraud, in Love, is call’d a Virtue’. Pulcheria asks Isacio to postpone her wedding to Oronte, to test his fidelity after his behaviour in Act I. He tells her brusquely that she must marry Riccardo under Costanza’s name; interests of state require it; Riccardo has seen neither woman and will doubtless fall for her charm. Appalled, she shrinks from the deception, but decides to obey and then expose it. In the next scene (no set change specified) Berardo tells Costanza and Oronte of Isacio’s plot, which he has overheard, and that Pulcheria is about to set out on her mission. Both are furious. Costanza tells Oronte who she is; he denounces father and daughter as criminals and promises condign vengeance. Costanza calls on the absent Riccardo to avenge her sufferings. The set changes to The shore of Limissus with a royal pavilion; a golden throne on one side. Riccardo enters accompanied by his army, then Pulcheria with a train of young ladies. Riccardo frets that Costanza is slow in coming. When Pulcheria approaches he finds her very different from her description, but nevertheless beautiful; she recognises him as the ambassador. A Military Salvo follows, saluting her as Queen. Oronte enters, having broken through a hundred men, and reveals the truth. Riccardo explodes with wrath against Isacio. Pulcheria offers to remain as prisoner, but he orders her back to her father to ‘teach him Reason’. When Oronte points out Chrysander took this direction from the autograph of the first version. It is in no secondversion source, but could still apply. The libretto specifies no place here or in II.vii (HG 63). The scene numbering, particularly in the last two Acts, is confused in all sources, due partly to Rolli’s usual neglect of scene structure, partly to changes from Handel’s first to second version. Libretto has only A Royal Pavilion. Corrado in the HG heading is a survival from Handel’s first version. The direction is in the autograph without music.
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 63
06/10/2006 14:51:27
64
Handel’s Operas, 1726–1741
that Isacio promised Pulcheria to him but has broken his word, she calls him a traitor and departs after a split aria addressed to Riccardo and Oronte in turn. Oronte gives Riccardo a royal signet as authority over his thousand Syrians. Riccardo resolves to demonstrate how an English monarch can be gracious while punishing crimes and places English troops under Oronte’s command. Oronte, impressed by Riccardo’s valour and constancy in love, observes that not without reason is he called Cœur de Lion, and looks forward to seeing ‘Fraud overcome, and Valour, Justice, and fair Truth Triumphant’. In A Hall [in the Palace] Riccardo returns to Isacio, still as ambassador, and denounces him for treachery and abuse of ‘the Sacred Laws of Hospitality’ and ‘for the last time’ demands the release of Costanza. Isacio tries to brazen it out – Riccardo will profit from the deal, gaining Cyprus with Pulcheria’s hand – and asks for time to think. Riccardo refuses, offering him the choice of war or peace. Isacio chooses war, and says Riccardo began it by keeping Pulcheria prisoner.10 Pulcheria enters, praises Riccardo’s courtesy and generosity, and begs Isacio to give Costanza up. He surprisingly agrees. The set changes to A Closet. Costanza, seated, leaning on a Table, quotes her cavatina at the beginning of the Act, changing the first word from ‘if’ to ‘yes’. Pulcheria introduces the ‘English ambassador’, but soon blurts out the truth. Riccardo asks her to keep the secret a little longer, to give them time to escape. Pulcheria departs with an aria of supreme irrelevance, and the Act ends with a love duet. Act III. Outside the city of Limissus11 Richard, Sword in Hand, follow’d by the Souldiers and Orontes, who comes with the English Army to the Succour of Richard. Riccardo curses the city and Isacio, who has apparently broken diplomatic etiquette and made a treacherous attack on the returning embassy. Riccardo himself has been driven back by force of numbers, Costanza captured and forced within the walls, and the drawbridge raised. Oronte suggests holding back the assault till he and his Syrians reach the walls via a secret passage and unfurl his standard. Riccardo makes a rousing patriotic address to his companions from the Thames, invoking British valour and honour. In A Hall [in the palace] Costanza calls on death to end her sufferings. Pulcheria offers to go to Riccardo as hostage for her safety. Costanza prays for the protection of justice and innocence. Isacio enters and claims to be motivated not by injustice and anger but by love: he would rather die than lose Costanza. She says she is pledged to Riccardo; he replies that she ‘must be the Conqueror’s Reward’. Berardo reports the approach of the British army and says there is still time to make peace, but Isacio cannot bear the prospect of losing Costanza to another, and goes off to fight. Costanza agrees to Berardo accompanying Pulcheria to Riccardo and asks him to kiss his hand; either he or death shall have her. The set changes to The Walls of Limisuss under an Assault, Part of which is to tumble down by the Force of a batt’ring Ram. A Warlike Symphony. Meanwhile the Army Advances. Riccardo sings a military aria. Here the Wall tumbles, and thro’ the Breach Isacio is seen at the Head of his Soldiers, who appears holding his Sword in his Right Hand, and Constantia on his Left. He threatens to kill her unless Riccardo halts. Pulcheria rushes in and asks him to kill her (Pulcheria) instead. Riccardo offers to stop the assault if 10 An echo of the first version, in which Riccardo has kept Pulcheria in chains. 11 The libretto gives no location (see below), places Scene ii (HG 88) in A Closet (Cabinetto), and indicates no change of set in Scene viii (ix in HG 109).
W_Dean, Handel's Operas.indd 64
06/10/2006 14:51:27
Riccardo Primo, Re d’Inghilterra
65
Costanza is released, but Isacio is implacable: if the attack advances a single step, Costanza will die. Pulcheria goes to take hold of one of the Soldiers Swords and threatens to kill herself. Riccardo tries to stop her, but Isacio tells her to go ahead and is about to stab Costanza when Oronte enters (?from the secret passage) with his Soldiers, who stay the Blow, and disarms Isacio, who flees. Oronte tells his men to pursue him and ‘put the vile Crowd about him to the Sword’. Riccardo orders only those who resist to be killed. Pulcheria asks if he will be a compassionate victor. ‘For my own glory’, he replies, and leads an ensemble ‘On to Victory’. In A Royal Hall Costanza is still afraid, but Berardo (who has apparently rescued her) assures her that the tyrant will soon be in chains, a suppliant at her feet, since nothing can resist British soldiers. Pulcheria hopes that Riccardo will spare her father’s life and Costanza promises to melt him with her prayers. Oronte brings happy news: Isacio has surrendered, and Riccardo has pardoned everyone. In the final scene, A Triumphal Arch, with a long Range of Pillars, introduced by a March, Riccardo gives Pulcheria the kingdom of Cyprus and the husband of her choice. She picks Oronte. Riccardo offers love to Costanza, sincere friendship to Pulcheria. There is nothing to indicate Isacio’s presence in this scene, but he joins in the conventional coro, having evidently been included in the general amnesty off-stage. That summarises the plot in Handel’s performances. The source is Isacio Tiranno by Francesco Briani, set by Antonio Lotti for Venice’s San Giovanni Grisostomo Theatre in autumn 1710,12 when Isacio was sung by Carli, Pulcheria by Durastanti and Costanza by Scarabelli, who had all appeared in Agrippina some months earlier. But there was an intermediate stage. Earlier in 1727 Handel