HANDBOOK
OF
COMPOUND SEMICONDUCTORS Growth, Processing, Characterization, and Devices
Edited by
Paul H. Holloway Uni...
63 downloads
2166 Views
56MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
HANDBOOK
OF
COMPOUND SEMICONDUCTORS Growth, Processing, Characterization, and Devices
Edited by
Paul H. Holloway University of Florida Gainesville, Florida
Gary E. McGuire Microelectronics Center of North Carolina Research Triangle Park, North Carolina
NOYES PUBLICATIONS Park Ridge, New Jersey, U.S.A.
Copyright 0 1995 by Noyes Publications No part of this book may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the Publisher. Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 95-2 1450 ISBN: O-8155-1374-7 Printed in the United States Published in the United States of America by Noyes Publications Mill Road, Park Ridge, New Jersey 07656 10987654321
Library
of Congress
Cataloging-in-Publication
Data
Holloway, Paul H. Handbook of compound semiconductors /Paul H. Holloway and Gary E. McGuire. cm. P. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN O-8155-1374-7 1. Compound semiconductors--Handbooks, manuals, etc. I. McGuire, G. E. II. Title. QC611.8.C64H65 1995 95-21540 621.3815’2--dc20 CIP
Editors Rointan F. Bunshah, University of California, Los Angeles (Series Editor) Gary E. McGuire, Microelectronics Center of North Carolina (Series Editor) Stephen M. Rossnagel, IBM Thomas J. Watson Research Center (Consulting Editor)
Electronic
Materials
and Process
HANDBOOK OF DEPOSITION TECHNOLOGIES Edition: edited by Rointan F. Bunshah CHEMICAL
VAPOR
SEMICONDUCTOR by Gary E. McGuire
DEPOSITION MATERIALS
FOR FILMS AND COATINGS,
FOR MICROELECTRONICS: AND PROCESS
HYBRID MICROCIRCUITTECHNOLOGY Enlow
BEAM DEPOSITION
HANDBOOK OF CONTAMINATION Donald L. Tolliver
AND TECHNIQUES:
AND EPITAXY: AND
CONTROL
HANDBOOK:
edited
by James J. Licari and Leonard R.
PROCESSES
DIFFUSION PHENOMENA IN THIN FILMS edited by Devendra Gupta and Paul S. Ho
Second
by Arthur Sherman
TECHNOLOGY
HANDBOOK:
HANDBOOK OF THIN FILM DEPOSITION Klaus K. Schuegraf IONIZED-CLUSTER
Technology
by Toshinori
edited by
Takagi
MICROELECTRONIC
MATERIALS:
IN MICROELECTRONICS:
edited
by
HANDBOOK OF ION BEAM PROCESSING TECHNOLOGY: Stephen M. Rossnagel, and Harold R. Kaufman
edited by Jerome J. Cuomo,
CHARACTERIZATION McGuire
Volume 1: edited by Gary E.
OF SEMICONDUCTOR
MATERIALS,
HANDBOOKOF PLASMA PROCESSINGTECHNOLOGY: Jerome J. Cuomo, and William D. Westwood HANDBOOK OF SEMICONDUCTOR SILICON O’Mara, Robert B. Herring, and Lee P. Hunt HANDBOOK OF POLYMER Licari and Laura A. Hughes HANDBOOKOF Hayakawa
SPUTTER
COATINGS
DEPOSITION
TECHNOLOGY:
OF VLSI MICROLITHOGRAPHY:
CHEMISTRY
OF SUPERCONDUCTOR DEPOSITION
TECHNOLOGY:
FOR ELECTRONICS,
HANDBOOK N. Helbert
CHEMICALVAPOR E. J. Schmitz
edited by Stephen M. Rossnagel,
edited
by William
2nd Edition:
by Kiyotaka Wasaand
edited by William B. Glendinning
MATERIALS:
OF TUNGSTEN
ELECTROCHEMISTRY OF SEMICONDUCTORS McHardy and Frank Ludwig V
C.
by James
Shigeru
and John
edited by Terre11 A. Vanderah
AND TUNGSTEN
SILICIDES:
AND ELECTRONICS:
byJohn
edited by John
vi
Series
HANDBOOK DIAMOND
OF CHEMICAL
VAPOR
FILMS AND COATINGS:
ELECTRODEPOSITION:
DEPOSITION:
by Hugh 0. Pierson
edited by Robert F. Davis
by Jack W. Dini
HANDBOOK OF SEMICONDUCTOR Werner Kern
WAFER
CONTACTS
edited by Leonard J. Brillson
TO SEMICONDUCTORS:
CLEANING
TECHNOLOGY:
HANDBOOK OF MULTILEVEL METALLIZATION FOR INTEGRATED by Syd R. Wilson, Clarence J. Tracy, and John L. Freeman, Jr. HANDBOOK Pierson
OF CARBON,
MOLECULAR
GRAPHITE,
BEAM EPITAXY:
HANDBOOKOF E. McGuire
DIAMONDS
AND FULLERENES:
SEMICONDUCTORS:
DIAMOND
CHEMICAL
SOURCES:
VAPOR
DEPOSITION:
FRICTION
CERAMIC
COMPOSITES:
PROCESSING
FOR INDUSTRIAL
MELTING
AND CERAMIC
FILMS AND COATINGS:
TECHNOLOGY
CARBON-CARBON D. Edie CODE COMPLIANCE SEMICONDUCTOR David G. Baldwin
HANDBOOK:
MATERIALS
SUPERCONDUCTORS:
edited by
by Stephen C. Carniglia
and Richard A. Haber
Titles by Arthur H. Landrock
TECHNOLOGY
HYGIENE
E. Murr
edited by G. K. Bhat
TECHNOLOGY:
AND COMPOSITES:
FOR ADVANCED INDUSTRIAL
edited by Lawrence
edited by John 9. Wachtman
Related ADHESIVES
Volume 1: edited byJon G. P.
by Peter J. Blau
TECHNOLOGIES:
REFRACTORIES
ELECTRONICS
edited by K. S. Mazdiyasni
APPLICATIONS:
CORROSION OF GLASS, CERAMICS David E. Clark and Bruce K. Zoitos
CERAMIC
PREFORMS,
OF MATERIALS:
AND PROCESSING
HANDBOOK OF INDUSTRIAL and Gordon L. Barna
L.
and Technology
ANDTECHNOLOGY,
AND WEAR TRANSITIONS
SHOCK WAVES SPECIAL
CERAMIC
edited by Raymond
by Huimin Liu and David S. Dandy
SOL-GEL TECHNOLOGY FOR THIN FILMS, FIBERS, AND SPECIALTY SHAPES: edited by Lisa C. Klein
ADVANCED Binner
by Hugh 0.
edited by Oleg A. Popov
Ceramic and Other Materials-Processing
FIBER REINFORCED
edited
edited by Paul H. Holloway and Gary
HANDBOOK OF VACUUM ARC SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY: Boxman, Philip J. Martin, and David M. Sanders PLASMA
CIRCUITS:
by
edited by Robin F. C. Farrow
COMPOUND
HIGH DENSITY
edited
edited by John D. Buckley and Dan
FACILITIES:
HANDBOOK:
by William R. Acorn
by Michael
E. Williams
and
Contributors
Shin-ichi Akai Sumitomo Electric Industries Ltd. Itami, Hyogo, Japan
Sidney I. Ingrey Bell Northern Research Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Kambiz Alavi Department of Electrical Engineering University of Texas at Arlington Arlington, TX
Nan Marie Jokerst Microelectronics Research Center Georgia Institute of Technology Atlanta, GA
Scott A. Chambers Molecular Science Research Center Pacific Northwest Laboratory Richland, WA
Kevin S. Jones Department of Materials Science & Engineering University of Florida Gainesville, FL
Eric Y. Chan Boeing Company Seattle, WA
Avishay Katz Standard Motor Products, Inc. Long Island City, NY
Stephen W. Downey AT&T Bell Laboratories Murray Hill, NJ
Richard Y. Koyama TriQuint Semiconductor Beaverton, OR
Paul H. Holloway Department of Materials Science & Engineering University of Florida Gainesville, FL
Derek L. Lile Department of Electrical Engineering Colorado State University Fort Collins, CO
ix
x
Contributors
Vinod Malhotra Department of Electrical Engineering University of Hawaii Honolulu, HI
Brian J. Skromme Department of Electrical Engineering Arizona State University Tempe, AZ
Gary E. McGuire Microelectronics Center of North Carolina Research Triangle Park, NC
Eberhard Veuhoff Siemens AG Munich, Germany Carl W. Wilmsen Department of Electrical Engineering Colorado State University Fort Collins, CO
Stephen J. Pearton AT&T Bell Laboratories Murray Hill, NJ Rajendra Singh Department of Electrical Engineering Clemson University Clemson, SC
Masamichi Yokogawa Sumitomo Electric Industries Ltd. Itami, Hyogo, Japan
NOTICE To the best of our knowledge the information in this publication is accurate; however the Publisher does not assume any responsibility or liability for the accuracy or completeness of, or consequences arising from, such information. This book is intended for informational purposes only. Mention of trade names or commercial products does not constitute endorsement or recommendation for use by the Publisher. Final determination of the suitability of any information or product for use contemplated by any user, and the manner of that use, is the sole responsibility of the user. We recommend that anyone intending to rely on any recommendation of materials or procedures mentioned in this publication should satisfy himself as to such suitability, and that he can meet all applicable safety and health standards.
Preface
This book is a state-of-the-art reference on the growth and processing of compound semiconductors. The leading experts in the important growth techniques, processing steps, characterization methods, packaging, and devices have contributed their knowledge. While the scope of the book is compound semiconductors, there are so many different semiconductors being studied and used that complete coverage of all materials is impossible in one book. Therefore the emphasis in this book is on gallium-arsenide- and indium-phosphide-based materials. Several other III-V and some II-VI compound semiconductors are discussed where they provide particular insight or illustrate specific properties and/or processes. Chapters in the book provide a complete overview of the technologies necessary to grow bulk single-crystal substrates, and grow hetero- and homoepitaxial films using molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) or metal-organic chemical vapor deposition (MOCVD). Technologies necessary to process compound semiconductors into test structures and devices are covered, including electrical contacts, dielectric isolation, interface passivation, ion implantation, wet and dry etching, and rapid thermal processing. Techniques to characterize the materials and devices using electrons, ions, and photons, are described. While the emphasis of the book is on materials growth and processing, the technologies are placed in perspective by a review of the important electronic and optoelectronic devices, and epitaxial lift-off, and other device packaging issues.
vii
viii
Preface
With this complete coverage of the critical topics, we believe the book will be a valuable reference for persons currently performing research on compound semiconductors. It will also be an excellent reference for advanced graduate courses in materials science, electrical engineering, and applied physics. In ourjudgement, the authors ofthe chapters have provided exceptionally comprehensive, authoritative work, and for this we are extremely grateful September,
1995
Gainesville,
Florida
Research Triangle Park, North Carolina
Paul H. Holloway Gary E. McGuire
Contents
1
Bulk Crystal Growth ............................................ Shin-ichi Akai and Masamichi
1
Yokogawa
1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................ 1.0 REDUCTION OF DISLOCATION DENSITY ........................... .2 .4 2.0 HB GaAs ................................................................................ .4 2.1 Cooling Methods ............................................................... 2.2 Influence of Solid-Liquid Interface Shape ........................... .4 7 3.0 LEC GaAs ................................................................................. 7 3.1 History of Technology Development.. .................................. 9 3.2 Carbon Control.. ................................................................. 11 3.3 Annealing ......................................................................... 12 3.4 Vth Control ...................................................................... 15 3.5 Large-Diameter Crystal .................................................... 17 4.0 InP ............................................................................................ 17 4.1 Low-Dislocation InP ......................................................... 21 4.2 Semi-Insulating InP .......................................................... 22 5.0 SUMMARY .............................................................................. . ...................................................................................... 23 REFERENCES 23
xi
xii
Contents
2
MOCVD of Compound Semiconductor
Layers
29
INTRODUCTION ..................................................................... GROWTH PROCESS ............................................................... 2.1 Reactor Design ................................................................. 2.2 Growth Precursors ............................................................ 2.3 Safety Aspects .................................................................. 3.0 SPECIFIC MATERIAL SYSTEMS ........................................... 3.1 GaAs and InP Based Materials ......................................... 3.2 Narrow Bandgap Materials ............................................... 3.3 Wide Bandgap Materials ................................................... 4.0 SUMMARY AND FUTURE DIRECTIONS .............................. ACKNOWLEDGMENT ..................................................................... REFERENCES ...............................................................................
29 31 32 33 36 37 38 56 63 72 74 74
3
84
Eberhard
Veuhoff
1.O 2.0
Molecular Beam Epitaxy .................................... Kambiz Alavi
1.O
2.0
3 .O 4.0
INTRODUCTION 1.1 Scope of Molecular Beam Epitaxy .................................... 1.2 Major Factors in the Initial Development of MBE ............. 1.3 MBE Reference Material .................................................. 1.4 Synopsis.. ......................................................................... IMPORTANT FEATURES OF MBE ......................................... 2.1 III-IV Environment and Ultra-High Purity Source Material 2.2 In-Situ Real-Time Monitoring and Control on a Sub-Monolayer Scale.. ..................................................... 2.3 Important Features of the MBE Growth Mechanism ......... 2.4 In-Situ Processing and Lateral Patterning .......................... 2.5 Variations on the Theme of MBE ...................................... ......................................... MBE SYSTEM CONFIGURATION THE GROWTH CHAMBER COMPONENTS ........................ 4.1 The III-IV System ............................................................ 4.2 Beam Generation ............................................................ 4.3 The Substrate Holder ...................................................... 4.4 Ion Gauges: Measurement of Beam Flux, Growth Rate, and Composition .............................................................
84 88 90 91 91 92 94 .95
97 98 99 10 1 103 104 112 114
Contents
4.5 Crystal Thickness Monitor: Flux Measurement ............... 4.6 Substrate Temperature Measurement ............................... 5.0 REFLECTION HIGH ENERGY ELECTRON DIFFRACTION @HEED) ...................................................... 5.1 Surface Reconstruction: General ..................................... 5.2 Surface Reconstruction: GaAs ........................................ 5.3 RHEED Intensity Oscillation and its Application.. ........... ...................................................... 6.0 MASS SPECTROMETRY 6.1 Modulated Beam Mass Spectrometry (MBMS) ............... 6.2 Desorption Mass Spectrometry (DMS). ........................... 7.0 IN-SITU AUGER ELECTRON SPECTROSCOPY (AES) ...... 8.0 OPTICAL METHODS FOR REAL-TIME GROWTH MONITORING ....................................................................... 8.1 Optical Pyrometry .......................................................... 8.2 Transmission Spectroscopy ............................................. 8.3 Photoluminescence: Low Substrate Temperature Measurement .................................................................. 8.4 Reflectance Difference Spectrometry (RD) ...................... 8.5 Laser Light Scattering (LLS) .......................................... 8.6 Spectroscopic Ellipsometry ............................................. 9.0 GROWTH OF III-V COMPOUNDS ....................................... 9.1 Substrate Preparation Prior to Transfer to MBE .............. 9.2 Substrate Preparation in the MBE System ....................... 9.3 MBE Growth .................................................................. ............................. 10.0 POST-GROWTH CHARACTERIZATION ................................................ 10.1 Structural/Compositional ................................... 10.2 Electrical and Magneto-Transport 10.3 Optical and Infrared Spectroscopy .................................. 10.4 Structural Defects in III-V Compound Epilayers ............. 11.O BUILDING BLOCKS OF MODERN DEVICES: BANDGAP ENGINEERING IN III-V STRUCTURES ............................... 11.1 Doping ........................................................................... 11.2 Quantum Wells and Superlattices .................................... 11.3 Strained-Layer Superlattices and Quantum Wells ............ 11.4 Bandgap Grading and Chirped Superlattices.. .................. 12.0 EPILOGUE ............................................................................. ................................................................. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS REFERENCES .............................................................................
xiii
114 115 115 117 118 125 134 134 137 137 139 140 14 1 14 1 142 142 142 143 144 147 149 149 150 150 15 1 15 1 153 154 154 155 156 156 15 7 157
xiv
Contents
4
Physical and Chemical Depo Ohmic Contacts to InP and R Avishay
Katz
INTRODUCTION ............................... OHMIC CONT FUNDAMENTALS 2.1 Generic Definition of Schottky 2.2 Interface States and Fermi-Leve 2.3 Determination of Schottky Bar 2.4 Determination of Ohmic Conta and Related Materials .............. 2.5 Concepts of Formation of Ohm InP-Based Materials ................ DESIGN CONCEPTS OF PROCESS 3.0 CONTACT TO InP.. ........................... 3.1 Conceptual Assumptions ......... 3.2 Interfacial Reaction Concerns 3.3 Electrical Performance Require 3.4 Thin Film Mechanical Propertie 4.0 OHMIC CONTACT PROCESSING 4.1 Introduction ................................ 4.2 Contact Processing by Metal 4.3 Contact Processing by Chemica 5.0 CONCLUSIONS ................................. ............................ ACKNOWLEDGMENTS .......................................... REFERENCES
1.0 2.0
5
Surface Processing of III-V Sidney
1.O 2.0
I. Ingrey
INTRODUCTION .............................. REACTIONS ON CLEAVED (110) 2.1 Hydrocarbon Contamination . 2.2 Native Oxides on III-V Compo 2.3 Br/CH,OH ................................. 2.4 H,SO,/H,O, ............................... ....................................... 2.5 HCl ....................................................................... 263 2.6 NH,OH263 ....................................... 2.7 I-IF
Contents
xv
3.0
EFFECTS OF AIR-FORMED CONTAMINATION ON INTERFACE CHARACTERISTICS ................................... 3.1 Epitaxial growth ............................................................. 3.2 Schottky and Ohmic Contacts ......................................... 3.3 Dielectric Overlayers ...................................................... 4.0 CONTAMINATION REMOVAL ............................................ 4.1 Sputter Removal ............................................................. 4.2 Plasma Surface Treatments ............................................. 4.3 Thermal Desorption ........................................................ 4.4 UV/Ozone Oxidation ...................................................... 5.0 SURFACE PASSIVATION ..................................................... 6.0 APPLICATIONS ..................................................................... 7.0 SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS ....................................... ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ................................................................. REFERENCES .............................................................................
6
Ion Implantation Induced Extended Defects in GaAs .............................................................
263 263 264 267 270 270 270 27 1 27 1 272 276 280 28 1 28 1
285
Kevin S. Jones 1.O
2.0 3 .O 4.0 5.0 6.0
TYPE I DEFECTS ................................................................ 1.1 Type I Defect Formation ................................................. 1.2 Type I Defect Formation Thresholds ............................... 1.3 Type I Defect Density and Distribution.. .......................... 1.4 Type I Defect Stability .................................................... I.5 Effects of Type I Defects ................................................. TYPE II DEFECTS ................................................................. TYPE III DEFECTS ................................................................ TYPE IV DEFECTS ................................................................ TYPE V DEFECTS ................................................................. CONCLUSIONS .....................................................................
REFERENCES
7
.............................................................................
286 289 289 297 301 302 312 3 14 3 15 316 324 325
Passivation of GaAs and InP . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 328 Vinod Malhotra and Carl FK Wilmsen
1.O 2.0
SURFACE DEFECTS, FERMI-LEVEL PINNING, AND DEFECT MODELS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . t.. . . . . . . . . . . 33 1 NATIVE OXIDES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 335
xvi
Contents
3 .O HYDROGEN AND NITROGEN ............................................. 4.0 SULFUR ............................................................................. 5.0 SELENIUM.. ........................................................................... 6.0 SILICON ............................................................................. 7.0 EPITAXIAL REGROWTH ..................................................... 8.0 EPILOGUE ............................................................................. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ................................................................. REFERENCES .............................................................................
8
Wet and Dry Etching of Compound Semiconductors .................................................
3 36 342 357 358 360 361 362 362
370
Stephen J. Pearton 1.O 2.0
INTRODUCTION ................................................................... WET CHEMICAL ETCHING ................................................. 2.1 General Principles.. ......................................................... 2.2 Wet Chemical Etching of GaAs ....................................... 2.3 Wet Etching of InP ......................................................... 2.4 Wet Etching of InGaP.. ................................................... 2.5 Wet Etching of AlInP ...................................................... 2.6 Wet Etching of Other III-V Materials .............................. 3.0 PLASMA ETCHING.. ............................................................. 3.1 General Principles of RIE ............................................... 3.2 Gas Chemistries.. ............................................................ 3.3 Surface Chemistry .......................................................... 3.4 Damage.. ........................................................................ 3.5 Masking Materials .......................................................... 3.6 Electron Cyclotron Resonance Discharges ....................... 3.7 Device Processing.. ......................................................... 4.0 CONCLUSION ....................................................................... ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ................................................................. REFERENCES .............................................................................
9
Rapid Isothermal Processing (RIP) .................
370 370 371 373 377 379 380 38 1 382 384 387 397 402 4 14 42 1 426 437 437 437
442
Rajendra Singh 1.O 2.0 3.0 4.0
INTRODUCTION ................................................................... WHY RAPID ISOTHERMAL PROCESSING?. ...................... HISTORY OF RAPID ISOTHERMAL PROCESSING.. ........ SCOPE OF RAPID ISOTHERMAL PROCESSING ...............
442 443 .447 447
Contents
xvii
5.0
PRINCIPLES OF RAPID ISOTHERMAL PROCESSING ..... .448 448 5.1 Operating Principle of RIP.. ............................................ 5.2 Interaction of Radiation with the Sample ......................... 449 5.3 Thermal Dynamics and Temperature Calculations .......... ,452 5.4 Fundamental Differences Between Furnace and 453 Rapid Isothermal Processing ........................................... 454 5.5 Role of Photoeffects in RIP ............................................. 456 5.6 Thermal Stress and Control of Defects ............................ 6.0 EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS IN SUPPORT OF 458 PHOTOEFFECTS IN RIP ....................................................... 458 6.1 Surface Cleaning of Semiconductors ............................... 458 6.2 W Annealing.. ............................................................... 460 6.3 Oxidation ....................................................................... 460 6.4 MBE and Gas Source MBE ............................................ 460 6.5 Chemical Vapor Deposition ............................................ 6.6 Metalorganic Chemical Vapor Deposition ....................... 46 1 7.0 DESIGN OF EQUIPMENT AND ENGINEERING ISSUES .. .466 466 7.1 Basic Characteristics of RIP Systems .............................. 7.2 Temperature Measurement, Control, and Uniformity ...... ,472 7.3 Current Status of Commercial RIP Systems .................... 479 480 7.4 Future Direction ............................................................. 48 1 8.0 VARIOUS APPLICATIONS OF RIP ...................................... 8.1 Stand-Alone Systems for the Annealing of 48 1 Various Materials ........................................................... 8.2 Stand-Alone Systems For the Formation of Silicides ....... .49 1 8.3 Stand-Alone Systems for Shallow Junction Formation 491 and Non-Alloyed Ohmic Contacts ................................... 8.4 Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) and Metalorganic 493 Chemical Vapor Deposition (MOCVD) ........................... 494 8.5 In-Situ and Integrated Processing .................................... 9.0 RESULTS OF VARIOUS DEVICES AND CIRCUITS.. ........ .498 500 10.0 FUTURE APPLICATIONS ..................................................... 500 11 .O CONCLUSION ....................................................................... 50 1 ACKNOWLEDGMENT ................................................................... 50 1 REFERENCES .............................................................................
10
Epitaxial Lift-Off for Thin Film Compound Semiconductor Devices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . .. . . . 518 Nan Marie Jokerst
1.O
INTRODUCTION
........... . .
........ .......... ...... ...... .... .
. . . . . . 5 18
xviii
Contents
THIN FILM DEVICE FORMATION AND BONDING ......... 2.1 Gallium Arsenide Based Thin Films ................................ 2.2 Indium Phosphide Based Thin Films ............................... 2.3 Modified Epitaxial Lift-Off Processes ............................. 3.0 CHARACTERIZATION OF EL0 THIN FILMS .................... 3.1 Photoluminescence, Hall Measurements, and Minority Carrier Lifetime ............................................... 3.2 Laser Threshold Current and Dark Current ..................... 4.0 NEW THIN FILM CHARACTERIZATION TECHNIQUES AND DEVICES.. ..................................................................... 4.1 Characterization Techniques: Absorption Coefficients and Nonlinear Refraction ................................................ 4.2 New Device Formulations: Resonant Cavity and Bottom Contacted ........................................................... 5.0 NEW INTEGRATION FORMULATIONS USING THIN FILMS .......................................................................... 5. I Thin Film Optoelectronic and Optical Devices on Host Substrates .......................................................... 5.2 Thin Film Circuits on Host Substrates ............................. 5.3 Three-Dimensional Integration ........................................ 6.0 CONCLUSIONS ..................................................................... ............................................................................. REFERENCES
.521 522 527 528 534
Packaging ..........................................................
563
2.0
11
535 536 539 540 542 544 545 552 555 558 560
Eric E Chan 1.O 2.0
3.0
563 INTRODUCTION ................................................................... III-V OPTOELECTRONIC DEVICE PACKAGES ................. 564 564 2. I Laser Diode Packages ..................................................... 578 2.2 LED Packages ................................................................ 2.3 Semiconductor Optical Amplifier (SOA) Packaging ........ 585 589 2.4 Detector Packages .......................................................... MULTICHANNEL DEVICE PACKAGES FOR OPTICAL 594 INTERCONNECT APPLICATIONS ....................................... 594 Introduction ................................................................... 3.1 5 94 3.2 LED Array Packaging .................................................... 596 3.3 PIN Detector Array Packaging.. ...................................... 3.4 Individually Addressable Laser Array Packages ............. .600 3.5 Hybrid Optoelectronic Integration Using a 603 Silicon Wafer Board ....................................................... 605 3.6 Array Issues ...................................................................
Contents
xix
4.0
HIGH FREQUENCY GaAs DIGITAL AND MICROWAVE INTEGRATED CIRCUIT PACKAGES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 607 4.1 High Frequency GaAs Digital Integrated Circuits Packages . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . 607 4.2 Monolithic Microwave Integrated Circuit Packaging . . . . . . .608 5 .O CONCLUSIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 10 REFERENCES . . . . .. . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 10
I2
Chemical, Structural and Electronic Characterization of Compound Semiconductor Surfaces and Interfaces by X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy and Diffraction Techniques ....... 613 Scott A. Chambers
INTRODUCTION ................................................................... 1.1 Overview of the Topic .................................................... SPECTROSCOPY AND 2.0 X-RAY PHOTOELECTRON DIFFRACTION.. ..................................................................... 2.1 The Essential Experiments and Interpretations ................. 3.0 CHEMISTRY OF SURFACE AND INTERFACE FORMATION ......................................................................... 3.1 Oxide Formation and Removal from GaAs(OO1). ............. 3.2 Metal/III-V Compound Semiconductor Interface Formation ....................................................................... 4.0 DETERMINATION OF ELECTRONIC ENERGY LEVELS AT COMPOUND SEMICONDUCTOR SURFACES AND INTERFACES BY XPS .......................................................... 4.1 Measurement of Band Bending and Schottky Barrier Heights ............................................................... 4.2 Measurement of Surface State Charge Densities .............. 4.3 Measurement of Band Offsets ......................................... 5.0 STRUCTURE OF THE NEAR-SURFACE REGION ............................................................................. BY XPD 5.1 Surface Termination of HgCdTe( 111) ............................. 5.2 Surface Passivation of III-V Semiconductor Surfaces with Group VI Anions .................................................... 6.0 CONCLUSIONS ..................................................................... ................................................................... ACKNOWLEDGMENT REFERENCES ............................................................................. 1.0
6 13 613 6 14 6 14 623 623 627
632 632 636 639 646 646 648 649 650 650
xx
Contents
13
Characterization of Compound Semiconductor 653 Material by Ion Beams ..................................... Stephen K Downey
INTRODUCTION ................................................................... 1.1 RBS References .............................................................. SIMS References ............................................................ 1.2 1.3 Fundamentals of Ion-Solid Interactions .......................... RUTHERFORD BACKSCATTERING SPECTROMETRY 2.0 ................................................................... (RBS) Kinematics ................................................................... 2.1 Depth Resolution ........................................................... 2.2 2.3 Nuclear Reactions ........................................................... Channeling ..................................................................... 2.4 SECONDARY ION MASS SPECTROMETRY (SIMS) 3.0 AND RELATED TECHNIQUES ............................................ . ............................ Sputtering.. ........................................ 3.1 3.2 Depth Profiling ............................................................... Depth Resolution ............................................................ 3.3 Static SIMS .................................................................... 3.4 Preferential Sputtering .................................................... 3.5 Mass Spectrometers ........................................................ 3.6 Matrix Effects ................................................................ 3.7 Sputtered Neutral Mass Spectrometry (SNMS) ............... 3.8 Depth Profiling with SNMS ............................................ 3.9 3.10 Other Alternative Techniques .......................................... ............... ............ .......... .. ..... ...... ........ ....... . .... REFERENCES 1.0
14
Optical Characterization of Compound Semiconductors .................................................
65 3 654 654 655 656 656 659 660 660 66 1 661 662 663 666 667 667 669 672 672 675 675
678
Brian J. Skromme 1.O 2.0
................................................................... INTRODUCTION EXPERIMENTAL TECHNIQUES AND ........................................................... INSTRUMENTATION 2.1 Light Sources ................................................................. Spectrometers ................................................................. 2.2 Detectors ........................................................................ 2.3 Cryogenics ..................................................................... 2.4 Sample Mounts.. ............................................................. 2.5 Optics ............................................................................. 2.6
678 680 680 68 1 685 686 687 688
Contents
xxi
3.0
BASIC THEORY AND APPROACHES ................................. Luminescence ................................................................. 3.1 Raman Scattering ........................................................... 3.2 Reflectance and Modulated Reflectance ........................... 3.3 4.0 APPLICATIONS.. ................................................................... Intrinsic Materials Properties .......................................... 4.1 Impurities and Defects .................................................... 4.2 Strain ............................................................................. 4.3 Surfaces and Interfaces ................................................... 4.4 5.0 SUMMARY ............................................................................ ................................................................. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS LIST OF ACRONYMS.. ................................................................... ............................................................................. REFERENCES
689 689 713 7 16 720 720 726 744 748 751 752 752 754
15
Gallium Arsenide Microelectronic Devices and 772 Circuits .............................................................. Richard E Koyama
773 A BRIEF HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE ................................ 775 GALLIUM ARSENIDE CRYSTALS ...................................... Some Basic Properties of Gallium Arsenide.. ................... 775 2.1 Some Basic Physics of Gallium Arsenide ........................ 778 2.2 LEC Crystal Growth of Gallium Arsenide.. ..................... 780 2.3 3 .O GALLIUM ARSENIDE DEVICES AND STRUCTURES ...... .783 Metal Semiconductor Field Effect Transistors ................. 784 3.1 794 Junction Field Effect Transistors ..................................... 3.2 795 High Electron Mobility Transistors ................................. 3.3 797 Heterojunction Bipolar Transistors .................................. 3.4 798 Other Advanced III-V Device Structures ......................... 3.5 ........... 799 4.0 GaAs MESFET IC FABRICATION TECHNOLOGY.. 799 Ion Implantation and Anneal ........................................... 4.1 Dielectric Deposition, Definition, and Etching ................. 803 4.2 Metal Deposition, Definition, and Etching ....................... 804 4.3 Photolithography in GaAs MESFET Fabrication ............. 806 4.4 806 GaAs MESFET IC Process Technology .......................... 4.5 809 5.0 APPLICATIONS of GaAs MESFET ICs ................................. 8 12 ............................................................................. REFERENCES 1.O 2.0
xxii
Contents
16
Optoelectronic
Devices .....................................
813
Derek L. Lile 8 13 1.O INTRODUCTION ................................................................... 8 15 2.0 THE?SOLID STATE LASER ................................................... 823 3.0 MODULATORS AND SWITCHES ........................................ 4.0 OPTOELECTRONIC INTEGRATED CIRCUITS (OEICs) .... .842 4.1 Optical Communications ................................................. 842 846 4.2 Optical Interconnects ...................................................... 849 4.3 Optical Computing ......................................................... 856 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ................................................................. 856 REFERENCES .............................................................................
Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..*...........................
866
1 Bulk Crystal
Growth
Shin-ichi Akai and Masamichi Yokogawa
INTRODUCTION III-V compound semiconductors are widely used as substrates for optical devices such as LED’s and laser diodes and for electronic devices such as FET’s, HINT’s, HBT’s and IC’s. These applications are becoming key elements in an advanced information society. In this chapter, our focus is on GaAs and InP and recent advancements in their crystal growth technology. Horizontal Bridgman (HB) and Liquid Encapsulated Czochralski (LEC) are two representative growth methods of III-V compound crystals. The HI3 method is favorable for reducing the dislocation density and is, therefore, used in providing substrates for optical devices. The LEC method is advantageous for increasing the crystal diameter and is, therefore, used in providing substrates for electronic devices. Incorporating the advantages of both growth methods, practical applications of early hot wall crystal growth techniquestll such as Vertical Gradient Freeze (VGF)121,Vertical Bridgman (VB)131and Liquid Encapsulated Vertical Bridgman (LEVB)141have recently been tried. The basic objectives in the development of crystal growth technology are larger crystals (diameter and length), reduction of crystal defects (such as dislocation) and higher purity. In addition, stoichiometry control is important in the case of compound crystals.
1
2
Compound Semiconductors
1.0
REDUCTION OF DISLOCATION
DENSITY
Dislocations affect device performance. Therefore, the reduction of dislocation density is a very important issue in crystal growth technology. Various techniques to achieve low dislocation density are summarized in Fig. 1. Among them are the reduction of thermal stress (or reduction of temperature gradient) and the increase of critical resolved shear stress. It has been reported by Matsumoto et a1.151 that a roof-shaped thermal baffle installed on the top of a heat shield alleviated very strong gaseous convection in a chamber, thus reducing the temperature gradient in the B,O, layer to 30 - 6OWcm. This gradient is about one third of the temperature gradient in the conventional LEC method. The radiation effect becomes more significant in LEC-grown crystals having a high melting point. In a conventional single-zone heater puller, the heat outflow from the surface of growing crystals is large because of the heat radiation toward the cold chamber wall. Consequently, the temperature gradient at the solid-liquid interface becomes large. On the other hand, in a puller with a multi-zone heater, the heat inflow to the surface of a growing crystal is large because of the heat radiation from the after-heater and consequently, the temperature gradient can be reduced161 A low temperature gradient means that the
r Reduction of thermal stress Reduction of temperature gradient >
r(
9
improved hot zone Multizone heater FEC (Fully Encapsulated Czochralski)
l-
Ambient gas
I
Control of stoichiometry
Prevention of As (or P) dissociation
I
I-
L- Melt
Increase Of CRSS ___I I
composition
Isoelect,ronic doping In, B (for GaAs) t
Ga, As (for InP)
Fire 1. Various approaches to the reduction of dislocation density in III-V compound semiconductor crystals.
Bulk Crystal Growth
3
solidified crystal stays at elevated temperature longer and therefore, the group V element tends to dissociate from the crystal surface. LEC growth with a low temperature gradient requires a special measure to suppress the dissociation of group V elements. Crystal growth in an arsenic (or phosphorus) atmosphere l~[i~l and crystal growth with full encapsulation by B,O,[“l have been attempted. The stoichiometry of the crystal also affects the dislocation density.[121-[141 The effect of impurity doping on the dislocation density and dislocation mobility in semiconductor crystal is well-known. In order to obtain a semi-insulating crystal for IC applications, an isoelectronic impurity must be used. For GaAs, these dopants are N, Al, In, Sb, B and P.[i51-11*l However, to date, only indium doping has been effective for obtaining lowdislocation, semi-insulating GaAs crystals of an industrially useful size (that is, with a diameter larger than 2 inches and a lot size greater than 50 wafers). [1gl-[211 Doping with inditmr, together with the VM-FEC (Vertical Magnetic field applied, Fully Encapsulated Czochralski) method, has enabled the growth of dislocation-free and striation-free GaAs crystal~.[~il A 4” diameter dislocation-free GaAs crystal has been obtained using this method.t221 While In doping yields materials of high quality, it has the disadvantages of smaller lot sizes and higher wafer costs in comparison with conventional rmdoped crystals. This is due to the fact that a cellular structure is generated during crystal growth, thus greatly reducing material yield. This phenomenon occurs when the In concentration in the melt exceeds a critical value. The melt then goes to a compositional supercooled state. In order to retard the generation of this cellular structure, two techniques have been tried. The first method is the G/R techniqueI23l in which the temperature gradient (G) and the growth rate (R) are simultaneously controlled, and the second is a double crucible method[24l in which the segregation coefficient of In in GaAs is artificially adjusted to unity. The In doping method is also effzctive in HB GaAs crystal growth.Izl Because the HB method has a lower temperature gradient compared to the LEC method, the In concentration necessary for reducing the dislocation density is relatively small. Horizontal Zone Melting (I-IZM), which can alter an impurity segregation coefficient, has been tried in order to obtain a uniform impurity distribution along the growth direction.t261 Isoelectronic impurities for InP are Ga, As and Sb. An impurity segregation coefficient is not generally unity, and therefore, the impurity concentration changes along the growth direction. Accordingly, co-doping of two kinds of impurities, where the segregation coefficient of one impurity
4
Compound Semiconductors
is smaller than tmity and that of the other impurity is larger than unity, has been tried to obtain a uniform distribution of total impurity concentration in hlP crystal.161
2.0
HB GaAs
The HB method is extensively employed as a low dislocation density crystal growth technique. This is because reduction of the temperature gradient is relatively easy and precise control of the stoichiometry is possible in comparison with the LEC method. Basic approaches to achieve a low dislocation density have already been described in the previous section. This section addresses the methods of cooling a solidified crystal and the solid-liquid interface shape in order to obtain very low dislocation density GaAs crystals. 2.1
Cooling Methods
Figure 2 shows a schematic diagram of the HB method. An entire ingot is kept in the T2 zone after solidification at the solid-liquid interface and then gradually cooled to room temperature. A temperature distribution is generated in the crystal during this cooling process, and accordingly, thermal stress is induced in the crystal. Since GaAs is more susceptible to dislocation’s generation and propagation at low temperature by lower thermal stress in comparison with Si, optimization of the cooling process is critical for the reduction of dislocation density. Figure 3 shows the influences of the cooling process and crystal diameter on the dislocation density. When the cooling rate is 5 - 1O”C/h in the temperature range between 900°C and 1,2OO”C,the etch pit density (EPD) of 2” diameter crystals can be reduced to lower than 5,000 cmm2.However, when the cooling rate is 10 100°C/h in the same temperature range, the EPD increases to about twice this value. 2.2
Influence of Solid-Liquid Interface Shape
It has been found that the generation of lineage, which is a collection of dislocations, is related to the shape of the solid-liquid interface in LECY2’l and GF (Gradient Freeze) growth.12*l We have investigated the relation between the solid-liquid interface shape and the dislocation density by doing
Bulk Crystal Growth
5
AB etching[29]on Si-doped lIB GaAs crystals. These crystals were grown along the [ III] crystallographic direction, and samplewafers were then cut along the [211] direction, which is parallel to a free surface of the ingot. The results are shown in Fig. 4. The shapeof the solid-Iiquid interface of case (a) is nearly flat and the EPD is quite low across the wafer. On the other hand, the solid-Iiquid interface shapeof case(b) is not symmetric from right to left and shows a strong concavity toward the melt. The EPD in the corresponding region is high. Figure 5 shows the EPD maps of a 2" diameter Si-dopedlIB GaAs crystal grown in a thermal environment, which makes the solid-Iiquid interface shapesymmetric and flat. It shows that the entire ingot has an EPD of less than 400 cm-2.
Figure
2.
Schematic
crystal growth
method.
diagram
of three-temperature
zone lIB
(Horizontal
Bridgman)
6
Compound Semiconductors
DIAMETER OF WAFER [mm] Figure 3. Cooling rate dependence of EPD of HE3 grown GaAs crystal. Cooling rate in the temperature range between 900°C and 1,200T is (a) 10 - lOO”Cih, and (b) 5 - lO”C/h.
(a)
(2iT)plane
(XlO*cm*)
Ave Max
1 10cmq 700cmQ
(b) (277) plane (XlO*cm.*)
Ave 960cm” Max 5.2OOcm.*
Figure 4. Relationship between solid-liquid interface shape and dislocation Solid-liquid interface shape is (a) flat, and (7~)not symmetric from right to left.
density.
Bulk Crystal Growth
7
Wafer No.
EPD
Average
(Cm21 Maximum
3.6X102
1.6X102
0.1 x102
13.0x102
6.0X102
l.0X102
iartier Concentration (cl-n-s)
1.3x10’s
1.7x10’s
3.0x10’s
Fraction Solidified
0.10
0.37
0.70
Figure 5. EPD maps of 2” diameter Sidoped HB grown GaAs. Fraction solidified means the wafer position along the growth direction.
3.0
LEC GaAs
3.1
History of Technology Development
LEC GaAs crystal growth technology has made progress toward providing a substrate for use in GaAs IC fabrication. Figure 6 shows the trend of crystal technology for GaAs IC’s. Undoped semi-insulating GaAs crystals were developed in the late 1970’s using an LEC technique with a pyrolytic boron nitride (PBN) crucible instead of quartz.[301 Semi-insulation in undoped LEC GaAs is realized by compensating the carbon-originated shallow acceptor with the deep donor EL2.r311The EL2 concentration strongly depends on melt composition[321and it is higher in a crystal grown from an As-rich melt. It is lower in a crystal grown from a Ga-rich melt. These issues are particularly important for GaAs MESFET, a type of GaAs IC fabricated by the ion implantation technique.[331 In a wafer, the threshold voltage (Vd must be uniform in order to yield MESFETs for use in high-integration density GaAs IC’s. It was found in 1983 that dislocations af%kctthe threshold voltage of a GaAs MESFET.[341 However, soon it was reported that there is no correlation between V, and dislocations.[351 This caused great controversy in the GaAs community, which has accelerated the development of a dislocation-free GaAs crystal. As mentioned in
8
CompoundSemiconductors
the previous section, at present, large-diameter, low-dislocation semi-insulating crystals are achieved by doping with In.t1gl-[211 In parallel with progress in low-dislocation density crystal growth technology, a postgrowth annealing technique has been developed which can greatly improve the crystal quality of dislocated undoped Ga.A~l~~ll~~lIt has been shown that GaAs MESFET’s fabricated on annealed material have excellent V+,, uniformity across the wafer, and an annealed ingot seems to be adequate for use as a GaAs LSI substrate.138113gJ 1980 GaAs integration
IC Density
I
I
I
(SRAM) (Gate
I
1985
I
m
3x3 1.5 <30
1990
,,,,,,,,,
m
Array) 2-3K
Chip Size (mm”) Gate Length ( pm) aVth ImV1
I
m
1995 I[
1 OK
20-30K
70-80K
5x5 1.0 c 20
7x7 0.8 cl5
10x10 0.5 < 10
Process Wafer Size
Wafer Technologies
Flatness ( pm)
~~~~~i
LN
: 2.0
1.5
1.0
0.8
0.5
Wafer Cleanliness
Pa;i$m;ize
: o3
0.2
0.15
0.1
Figure 6. Trend in substrate technology for GaAs ICs.
Currently, GaAs digital ICs have an integration density of 20 - 30 k gate array or 16 kb SRAM. The ingot annealing technique can fully meet the requirement for uniformity of threshold voltage (aV,,J necessary for the fabrication of these GaAs LSIs. Presently, an important subject of crystal growth is the reproducibility of V,, not only from wafer-to-wafer but also from lot-to-lot. Reproducibility is indispensable for the mass-production of GaAs ICs. Moreover, parasitic effects in GaAs MESFET such as sidegating and low-frequency oscillation, must be diminished in terms of both crystal quality and IC fabrication.l4o1
Bulk Crystal Growth 3.2
9
Carbon Control
Control of carbon incorporation in a crystal is essential for obtaining highquality, semi-insulating crystal with good reproducibility. Various methods for carbon control have been reported. For example : .
PBN coating of graphite parts in a chamber.l41l
.
Replacement of graphite parts by AlN.t421
.
Reduction in volume of graphite pa.rt~3.1~~1
.
Control of water content in B2O3.r441
.
Control of melt duration time.l45l
.
Crystal growth from an arsenic rich melt.l43l
.
G%O, doping.l46l
Our results are shown in Fig. 7. It can be seen that for higher water content in B2O3 or longer melt duration time, the carbon content in the crystal is lower. The carbon concentration in the crystal relates directly to V, of MESFETs fabricated on the crystal using the direct ion implantation technique.l47l Figure 8 shows the carbon concentration distribution along the growth direction of 3” diameter undoped conventional (6 kg charge) and super-long (10 kg charge) ingots. 12q The horizontal axis shows the wafer number, representing the position along the growth direction. The carbon concentration gradually decreases toward the tail of the conventional ingot, but it remains almost constant in the super-long ingot. It can be seen from Fig. 8 that the V,,, distribution for MESFETs made on these crystals reflect the carbon concentration distribution. 100
_..-..-.._..-..-,._.. Deteotlon
Umlt
Melt duration (hr)
Figure 7. Relationship between growth conditions and carbon concentration in undoped GaAs.
10
Compound Semiconductors
m- 10’”
r ,
I
I
‘E s
E OX_ ‘F; Y e E 8 0 -0 s 10’” -
I
I
I-I
-@-Improved long (IO kg): _s_ o---Conventional (6kg) ‘Q.,
0
.. 4.-o-
o-o-.
‘0
-
E E uo
I
I
0
50
I
I
100
150
Wafer
I
I
200
250
No.
2eSi , 120 KeV, 3x1d2
-O-Improved long ( 10 kg1 ---(-J--- Conventional (6 kg) I
0
50
1
100
I
150
I
200
1
25
Wafer No. Figure 8. Distributions of carbon concentration and V+,, along the growth direction in 3” diameter undoped GaAs. The conventional ingot is grown with a 6 kg charge. The improved (super-long) ingot is grown with a 10 kg charge. Wafer number means the position along the growth direction.
As the requirement for V, uniformity is now becoming even more severe, precise control of carbon concentration is needed. In view of this, the correlation between the CO gas content in the high-pressure inert gas ambient and the carbon content in the crystal has been extensively
Bulk Crystal Growth
11
investigated.1481~t501 Boron is another representative impurity in an tmdoped LEC GaAs crystal. When a boron atom sits on a Ga site, it becomes an isoelectronic impurity and is electrically neutral. However, it has been reported that when the boron concentration increases, some of the boron atoms sit on As sites and form an acceptor.1511-1531 It has also been found that when the boron concentration increases, the short channel effect of the GaAs MESFET is enhanced.l54l 3.3
Annealing
A condition for semi-insulation in undoped LEC GaAs is given by
NELZ ’ [Cl - (Ns, - Ns7.J ’ 0 where [C] is the carbon concentration, NS% is the concentration of shallow acceptors other than carbon, N, is the concentration of shallow donors and NELzis the concentration of deep donor EL2. The quantity of ND(= Ns, - NS$J is quite sensitive to the thermal history of the crystal. It becomes about 5 x 1014cmW3 when high temperature annealing is followed by slow cooling, while it becomes about 1 x 1014crnm3when high temperature annealing is followed by rapid cooling. Figure 9 shows the change in resistivity due to rapid cooling after annealing at 850°C in an ASH, ambient. The cooling rate is 9OO”C/h over the temperature range from 850°C to 400°C. The resistivity increases after annealing. Moreover, if the initial resistivity is lower, the rate of increase of the resistivity is larger. Although the origin of ND has not yet been identified, it is plausible that the origin is a native defect EL6 which forms a donor level at about 0.4 eV below the conduction band.l55l156lThe generation and annihilation of EL6 occurs in the temperature range of 500°C - 600°C.1571When the carbon concentration is reduced to the range of 1 - 5 x 1014cms3, the crystal becomes thermally unstable and a strange phenomenon can be observed. The crystal becomes semi-insulating after rapid cooling, but becomes semiconducting after slow cooling. Both states are thermally reversible.l58l It was reported that the EL2 concentration is greatly reduced when an undoped LEC GaAs crystal is annealed at high temperature (around the melting point) followed by rapid cooling. 15gl When this crystal is subjected to annealing at 700 l,OOO°C,the EL2 concentration can increase again. This finding opened the door to EL2 engineering.
12
Compound Semiconductors
0 : Sinch undope 0
lE8 -
d
: 4inch undope
Wafer annealing condition
ki =
85V’C, 1Omln
G
-
-
Nu, ([CL] ND)
AsHa/Hz/Na atmosphere capless
k=34xlO’ NN I 14 x 10”
850°C lE7
SE7 Pbf0r0
Figure 9. atmosphere
3.4
lE8
4OlPC : 30min
5E8
(n-cm)
Resistivity change a&r wafer annealing followed by rapid cooling.
at 850°C for 10 min in an AsIX,
V,, Control
Since the carbon concentration in the crystal directly influences the V,,, of MESFETs, the measurement of the carbon is necessary in order to predict the V,. Carbon in GaAs is usually measured by a local vibrational mode absorption line using the FIIR method.l6ol As the absorption coefficient is very small, the measurement’s accuracy is not reliable in a wafer and a thick sample should be prepared. Accordingly, an alternative method is necessary. As suggested previously, the resistivity of a crystal can be a function ofthe carbon concentration, as long as the thermal history is the same. This is shown in Fig. 10. All ingots shown in this figure are tmdoped and were subjected to the same ingot annealing. The theoretical line fits well through the experimental data. Figure 11 shows the relation between the resistivity of the semi-insulating substrate and the V, of an ion-implanted layer. The V, becomes shallow when substrate resistivity becomes high, and vice versa. The substrate resistivity can be a good indicator of V,. Next let’s consider the V, uniformity in a wafer as reflected by the standard deviation of V, (crV&. It has been foundl61l that there is a good correlation between oV,,, and the standard deviation of resistiviiy (designated o/p because it is actually the standard deviation of p normalized to the average resistivity). Our results are shown in Fig. 12. The resistivity was measured at 100 l.trnpitch using the three-electrode guard-ring method.[‘j21 It is seen from the figure that the substrate with a better uniformity of microscopic resistivity can give a smaller oV,.
Bulk CrystalGrmvth
13
k.3.lxlO: Ntzuz15x10tl No= 0.5x 10"
“0
2
1
3
4
5
Carbon concentration (x 10’6cmJ)
Figure 10. Relationship between carbon concentration and resistivity in undoped GaAs. All ingots are annealed as a whole boule, and followed by slow cooling. Theoretical line is derived from a three-level model.
- 4.0
- 3.8
- 3.6 2 5
- 3.4
- 3.2
- 3.0 _ 0
1
2
Resistivity,
Figure 11. Relationship in undoped GaAs.
3 p ( x 1O’R
4 l
5
cm)
between substrate resistivity and V+,, of the ion implanted layer
14
Compound Semiconductors
Undoped LEC GaAs 8.01 7.0 -
Vbl : 0.75 eV
3‘;; E
6.0 -
s: z
5.0 -
5 fi
4.0-
b .&
3.0
E 5 g a
2.0
5
1.0
Olmm pitch n I400 pohlt*
lmm pitch n I81 pohlN
i
01 ’ 0
’
I
’
’
’
’
50
Micro p uniformity,
’
’
’
’
’
100
6 /P (%I
Figure 12. Relationship between microscopic uniformity of substrate resistivity (o/p) and V, uniformity (CV&. V, uniformity is normalized to V, - V,.
The Hall mobility (& of semi-insulating crystals should be characterized by a mixed conduction model. However, the Hall mobility becomes almost equal to the drift mobility (~3 after the ingot annealing because the electron concentration increases sufficiently and the crystal becomes n-type semi-insulating. In this case, the difference in the Hall mobility corresponds to the difference in the drift mobility of electrons. The drift mobility is infhrenced by crystal purity and crystal homogeneity. Since the concentration of total ionized impurities is at a level in the low 1015cmm3 range, the contribution to the drift mobility from ionized impurity scattering is thought to be neglected. Accordingly, the difference in drift mobility comes primarily from the difference in crystal homogeneity.163l We have investigated the relation between the Hall mobility and the uniformity of microscopic resistivity, which is thought to reflect crystal homogeneity. The results are shown in Fig. 13. It can be seen that the crystal with high Hall mobility has better uniformity of microscopic resistivity. Considering this result together with the relation shown in Fig. 12, it can be deduced that the crystal with a higher Hall mobility can produce a smaller oV,.
Bulk Crystal Growth
15
l-
_----._ , /=;
-. -.
*.
/
-. \
i
I -a\
Group I *. 8.
\
l. .
.. . i
‘.
--__
Group II
:
--__
)_w------_
#’ ----m-m-
0
l
/)
:
,‘e
l
I
*
l
I.... \\ l
l-
.
a
. . --__-- ..y ,.0, >-
I -
0
\ ;
,,I
_---_
Group Ill l ;.,
\
l l
I.
‘.
I31,000
\\
4,000
5,000
.--______---
6,000
0 0’
7,000
\
II
8,000
Hall mobility, p H (cm* /V&) Figure 13. Relationship between Hall mobility (& and microscopic substrate resistivity (o/p) in undoped semi-insulating GaAs.
3.5
uniformity
of
Large-Diameter Crystal
In the past, substrates for GaAs IC’s have increased in diameter by one inch every four years. At present, a transition to 4” diameter is rapidly taking place, especially in the US market. What diameter will we reach in the future? Figure 14 shows a 5” diameter undoped LEC GaAs crystal which we have grown. The EPD is 5 - 7 x lo4 cms2,which is slightly higher than that of a 4” diameter crystal. The EL2 concentration is around 1.3 x 1016cme3and is quite uniform, not only in a wafer but also along the growth direction. Figure 15 shows the resistivity and mobility distributions in a wafer. The mobility is as high as 7,000 cm2/vs at both the seed and the tail ends. On the other hand, the resistivity is high at the center of each wafer and gradually decreases toward the periphery. This reflects the carbon concentration distribution caused by the convex solid-liquid interface shape. This can be improved by modifying the thermal environment.l64l
16
Compound Semiconductors
Figure
14.
Five inch diameter undoped LEC grown GaAs crystal.
Figure
15.
Radial distributions
of resistivity
and mobility
in 5" diameter undoped GaAs.
Bulk Crystal Growth 4.0
17
InP
InP crystal growtb is generally divided into two processes: synthesis of InP polycrystals, and the single crystal growth. There are various methods to synthesize polycrystals, such as HB, GF,t651SSD (Synthesis from Solute Diffusion)[661and phosphorus injection.[‘jfl The HB method has a high growth rate so it is presently the most suitable method for massproduction. However, the HB method results in Si contamination from the quartz ampoule in the high temperature growth environment. Conversely, the SSD method is very suitable in terms of purity. The conventional LEC method is also employed as a growth technique for InP single crystals.[681[6gl LEC growth in a phosphorus atmosphere[g1t101[701t711 and VGF growM21 have been developed to reduce the dislocation density in InP crystals. Recent advancements in low dislocation InP and semi-insulating InP will be mentioned in this section. 4.1
Low-Dislocation InP
Figure 16 shows a schematic diagram of the VCZ (Vapor Pressure Controlled Czochralski) method, which we have developed to suppress phosphorus dissociation at elevated temperatures. Using this method, the temperature gradient in the B,O, layer can be reduced to 30 - SOT/cm, which is much lower than the 100 - 13OWcm of conventional LEC method. Figure 17 shows x-ray topographs of 2” diameter S-doped InP crystals grown by the conventional LEC and VCZ methods. In the case of conventional LEC, the dislocation density is high at the center and the periphery of the wafer. However, since the thermal stress is small in the case of VCZ, the wafer is almost dislocation-free except for a few slip lines extending from the wafer periphery. In order to suppress the S outdiffksion from the substrate into the epitaxial layer, lower S concentrations in the substrate are preferable. In view of this, lower dislocation densities at low carrier concentrations are definitely needed. The VCZ technique is a powerful tool for this purpose. Figure 18 shows the dependence of EPD on the carrier concentration in 2” diameter S-doped InP. The impurity hardening effect is observed above a carrier concentration of 4 x lo’* cmm3in the case of conventional LEC. On the other hand it is observed above a carrier concentration of 1 x lOi* cmm3in the case of VCZ. The EPDs of Sndoped and Fe-doped InP crystals grown by conventional LEC have a level of 1 - 5 x 1O4cmm2,but this level can be reduced by one order of magnitude using the
18
Compound Semiconductors
VCZ method. Dislocations in the substrate tiect the surface morphology after epitaxial growth. In view of this, low dislocation density InP crystals are useful. Two inch diameter InP wafers are widely used in current fabrication processes for InP-related devices. However, as can be seen in the case of GaAs, the need for higher yield and better device performance will require larger-size and higherquality wafers. Figure 19 shows the dependence of EPD on the carrier concentration in 3” diameter Ir1P.1~~1It can be clearly seen that both Zndoped and S-doped 3” diameter InP crystals grown by the VCZ method have low EPD at low carrier concentrations. Figure 20 shows EPD maps of Zndoped 3” diameter InP wafers. The low EPD area of VCZgrown crystals is about double that of conventional LEC-grown crystals.
p
(s)
It
P2 + P4 piziiaq
\
P4
/ B203
Figure 16. Schematic diagram of VCZ crystal growth method.
J
N () >
O w -.J ro c: 0 +-' c: a> > t: O ()
I
E
Bulk Crystal Growth
I
~M T-
CX)CJ 0 ~ x
19
.,;
~
i N
] ~ ~ . ~ ~
0 .+= ~
]
.
II
(\I
() 8 ;>0, .0
~
()
C')
~ ~ rn S ~ t)
'E (,) 00 ..-0 ~
~ r-=
>'::
I
1 "9 00 ~ "'6 ~ :a N O rn
x ("1') II . () . ()
~ ~
20
Compound Semiconductors
iI lo3
I
.
0”
\
5
I
i 2
Cl
0;
lo’*
rru,r,mmIw
EPDs
5
2
Carrier Figure 18.
I
\
!
,02c111
of 2” diameter
I
lOi
I-l 5
2
concentration S-doped
I
(cm-3)
InP crystals
as a function
of carrier
concentration.
0 Cl Conventional
LEC (S)
Carrier concentration
Figure 19. EPDs of 3” diameter S-doped, Fe-doped function of carrier concentration.
(cm-3)
and Zndoped
InP crystals as a
Bulk Crystal Growth
Conventional
vcz
LEC
13" "' Zn doped
21
InPl
EPD (cm-2 ) D <500
c.c
C.C=4.7x10'8cm-3
EPD
Low
area = 16.5cm2
20.
concentration
4.2
III
2000-5000
III
>5000
= 4.7 x 10'8 cm-3
EPD
area = 34cm2
«500cm-2)
«500cm-2)
Figure
500-2000
Ave. EPD = 0.5 x 102cm-2
Ave. EPD = 45.4 X 102cm-2 Low
D
EPD distribution
in a wafer in 3" diameter Zn-doped InP crystal.
The carrier
is p = 4.7 x 1018 cm-3 for both wafers.
Semi-Insulating InP
Semi-insulation in Fe-doped InP is achieved by compensating shallow donors with the Fe deep acceptors. Si is incorporated into InP crystals as a donor impurity because InP polycrystals, used as source material for single crystal growth, are synthesized in a quartz ampoule. It is desirable to reduce the Fe content in InP crystals since Fe impurities out-diffi1se from the substrate into the epitaxial layer. This affects the epi-Iayer's characteristics. In order to obtain semi-insulating InP with low Fe content, the concentration of background shallow donors must be decreased. Figure 21 shows the relationship between the resistivity and the Fe content in a crystal. In the case of standard purity polycrystal (n = 4- 8 x 1015cm-3), Fe must be doped to more than 0.25 wt.ppm (= 1.25 x 1016 cm-3) to obtain a semiinsulating crystal. However, in the case of a high purity polycrystal (n = 1 -4 x 1015cm-3), the Fe content necessary for a semi-insulating be reduced to 0.10 wt-ppm (= 5 x 1015cm-3).
crystal can
22
Compound Semiconductors
0 n (Source material) = 5 - 8 x lO’“cm-” El n (Source material) = 2 - 4 x lO’%m-”
10’”
10.’
Fe concentration (cme3) Figure 21. Relationship between Fe content and resistivity in Fe-doped InP. The carrier concentration of standard-purity polycrystal is 4 - 8 x 10” cmJ and that of high-purity polycrystal is 1 - 4 x lOI cm3.
It has recently been reported that a high purity undoped semiconducting InP crystal can be converted into a semi-insulating crystal by annealing it in a high-pressure phosphorus atmosphere.[731-t761 Homrann et a1.173ldid the annealing at 900°C for 80 hrs under 5 atm of phosphorus pressure. Kainosho et a1.l74ldid the annealing at 900°C for 20-40 hrs under 15 atm of phosphorus pressure. Although the mechanism for resistivity increase is not well known, there is a possibility that Fe contamination may occur during annealing, since undoped semi-insulating InP shows nearly the same activation energy as Fe doped semi-insulating InP.1751[761 However, this is not enough to fully explain the semi-insulation mechanism and it is suggested that some hind of native defect may be involved.
5.0
SUMMARY
We have reviewed several important issues in III-V compound crystal growth. As the crystal size increases, it is even more difficult to reduce the dislocation density. In order to overcome it, a low temperature gradient growth under an ambient of group V element must be necessary. In addition, a control of solid-liquid interface shape will become essential.
Bulk Crystal Growth
23
A present level of crystal quality fully meets a requirement of oV,,, for GaAs ICs with an integration density of 20 - 30 k gates. The most important subject to be grappled by a material supplier is to increase the reproducibility of carbon content (or resistivity) from wafer-to-wafer or lotto-lot. In order to further increase the integration density of GaAs ICs, one will have to clarify the influence of a dislocation on the device performance. Stoichiometry affects the crystal quality very much in compound semiconductors. Much attention should be paid to this point.
REFERENCES 1. Fischer, A. G., Crystal Growth, (EL R. Pamphn, ed.), pp. 357-393, Pergamon Press, New York (1980) 2. Gault, W. A., Monberg, E. M., and Clemans, J. E., J. Cryst. Growth, 74: 149 (1986) 3. Kremer, R. E., Frarcomano, D., Freidenreich, B., Marshall, H., and Burke, K. M., Semi-Insulating III-VMaterials, (A. G. Mihres and C. J. Miner, eds.), p. 205, Adam Hilger, Toronto (1990) 4. Hoshikawa, K., Nakanishi, H., Kohda, H., and Sasaura, M., J. Cryst. Growth, 94:643 (1989) 5. Matsumoto, K., Morishita, H., Sasaki, M., Nishine, S., Yokogawa, M., Sekinobu, M., Tada, K., and Akai, S., Semi-Insulating III-V Materials, (D. C. Look and J. S. Blakemore, eds.), p. 211, Shiva Publishing (1984) 6. Shim&u, A., Nishine, S., Morioka, M., Fujita, K., and Akai, S., Semi-Insulating IILVA4aterials, (H. Kukimoto and S. Miyazawa, cd.), p. 41, I-k&one (1986) 7. Tornizawa, K., Sassa, K., Shimanuki, Y., and Nishizawa, J., J. Electrochem. Sot., 131:2394 (1984) 8. Ozawa, S., Miyairi, H., Nakajima, M., and Fukuda, T., Int’l Symp. GaAs and Related Compounds, Inst. Phys. Conf Ser., 79:25, Karuizawa (1985) 9. Tada, K., Tatsumi, M., Nakagawa, M., Kawase, T., and Akai, S., Int’l Symp. GaAs and Related Compounds, Inst. Phys. Conz Ser., 91:439 (1987)
24
Compound Semiconductors
10. Kohiro, K., Mori, M., Yamamoto, H., and Oda, O., Ext Abst. 36th Spring Mtg. Jpn. Sot. Appl. Phys. and Related Societies, Chiba (April 1989) 11. Kohda, H., Yamada, K., Nakanishi, H., Kobayashi, T., Osaka, J., and Hoshikawa, K., J Cyst. Growth, 71:813 (1985) 12. Parsey, J. M., Jr., Nan&i, Y., Lagowski, J., and Gatos, H. C., J Elctrochem. Sot., 128:938 (1981) 13. Parsey, J. M., Nan&i, Y., Lagowski, J., and Gatos, H. C., J. Electrochem. Sot., 129:388 (1984) 14. Lagowski, J., Gatos, H. C., Aoyama, and Lin, D. G., Appl. Phys. Lett., 45:680 (1984) 15. Seki,Y., Watanabe, H., andMatsui, J.,J Appl. Phys., 49:822 (1978) 16. Mil’vidsky, M. G., Osvensky, V. B., and Shifiin, S. S., J: Cryst. Growth, 52:396(1981) 17. Jacob, G., Semi-Insulating III-VMaterials, (S. Markam-Ebeid and B. Tuck, eds.), p. 2, Shiva Publishing (1982) 18. Tada, K., Kawasaki, A., Kotani, T., Nakai, R., Takebe, T., Akai, S., and Yamaguchi, T., Semi-Insulating III-VMaterials, (S. MarkamEbeid, and B. Tuck, eds.), p. 36, Shiva Publishing (1982) 19. Tada, K., Murai, S., Akai, S., and Suzuki, T., GaAs IC Symposium, Tech. Digest, p. 49, Boston (1984) 20. Duseaux, M., and Martin, S., Semi-InsulatingIII-VMaterials, (D. C. Look and J. S. Blakemore, eds.), p. 118, Shiva Publishing (1984) 21. Hobgood, H. M., Thomas, R. N., Barrett, D. L., Eldridge, G. W., Sopira, M. M., and Driver, M. C., Semi-Insulating IiFVMaterials, (D. C. Look and J. S. Blakemore, eds.), p. 149, Shiva Publishing (1984) 22. Ibuka, T., Seta, Y., Tanamura, M., Orito, F., Okano, T., Hyuga, F., and Osaka, J., Semi-Insulating III-VMaterials, (H. Kukimoto and S. Miyazawa, eds.), p. 77, Hakone (1986) 23. Matsuura, T., Nakai, R., and Yokogawa, M., Semi-Insulating III-V Materials, (G. Grossmann and L. Ledebo, eds.), p. 453, Adam Hilger (1988)
Bulk Crystal Growth
25
24. Matsumoto, K., Yamashita, M., Nakai, R., Yazu, S., Tada, K., and Akai, S., Semi-Insulating III-V Materials, (G. Grossmann and L. Ledebo, eds.), p. 447, Adam Hilger (1988) 25. Inoue, T., Nishine, S., Shibata, M., Matsutomo, T., Yoshitake, S., Sato, Y., Shimoda, T., and Fujita, K., Int’l. Symp. GaAs and Related Compounds, Inst. Phys. ConJ: Ser., 79:25, Karuizawa (1985) 26. Mizuniwa, S., Kashiwa, M., Kurihara, T., Nakamura, K., Okubo, S., and Ikegami, K., J Cryst. Growth, 91:676 (1990) 27. Nambu, K., Nakai, R., Yokogawa, M., Matsumoto, K., Koe, K., and Tada, K., Int’l. Symp. GaAs and Related Compounds, Inst. Phys. Conf Ser., 91:141, Heraklion (1987) 28. Fujii, K., H.&a, M., Fujita, H., and Takeda, S., De$cts Control in Semiconductors, (K. Sumino, ed), p. 667, Elsevier Science Publishers (1990) 29. Abrahams, M. S., andBuiocchi, C. J.,J. Appl. Phys., 36:2855 (1965) 30. AuCoin, T. R., Ross, R. L., Wade M. J., Savage, R. O., Solid State Technol., 221569 (1979) 3 1. Martin, G. M., Farges, J. P., Jacob, G., Hallais, J. P., and Poiblaud, G., J. Appl. Phys. 51:2840 (1980) 32. Holmes, D. E., Chen, R. T., Elliott, K. R., and Kirkpatrick, C. G., Appl. Phys. Lett., 40:46 (1982) 33. Welch, B. M., and Eden, R. C., IEDMTech. Digest, p. 205 (1977) 34. Miyazawa, S., Ishii, Y., Ishida, S., andNanishi, Y., Appl. Phys. Lett., 43:853 (1983) 35. Winston, H. V., Hunter, A. T., Olsen, H. M., Bryan, R. P., and Lee, R. E., Appt. Phys. Lett., 45:447 (1984) 36. Rumsby, D., Ware, R. M., Smith, B., Tyjberg, M., Brozel, M. R., and Foulkes, E. J., GaAs IC Symp., Tech. Digest, p. 34, Phoenix (1983) 37. Miyazawa, S., Honda, T., Ishii, Y., and Ishida, S., Appl. Phys. Lett., 44:410 (1984) 38. Kasahara, J., Arai, M., and Watanabe, N., Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 25:L85 (1986)
26
Compound Semiconductors
39. Decor&k, P., Farges, J. P., Martin, G. M., Nagel, G., and Lhnert, H., Semi-Insulating III-VMaterials, (G. Grossmann and L. Ledebo, eds.), p. 505, Adam Hilger (1988) 40. Koyama, R., Odekirk, B., Vetaner, W. A., Finchem, E. P., and Beers, I. G., Semi-Insulating III-VMaterials, (G. Grossmann and L. Lcdebo, eds.), p. 203, Adam Hilger (1988) 41. Inada, T., Fujii, T., Kikuta, T., and Fukuda, T., Appl. Phys. Lett., 50:143 (1987) 42. Washizuka, S., Nishio, J., Terashima, K., and Watanabe, M., SemiInsulating III-VMaterials, (H. Kukimoto and S. Miyazawa, eds.), p. 65, Hz&one (1986) 43. Kikuta, T., Emori, H., Fukuda, T., and Ishida, K., J: Cyst. Growth, 76:517 (1986) 44. Hunter, A. T., Kimura, H., Baukus, J. P., Winston, H. V., and Marsh, 0. J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 44:74 (1984) 45. Mass, Y., Tanaka, A., Kadota, Y., and Yokoyama, T., Ext. Abstr. 31st SpringMtg. Jpn. Sot. Appl. Phys. and Related Societies, Tokyo (April 1984) 46. Kadota, Y., Kakimoto, S., Abe, T., Kazuno, T., and Yokoyama, T., Ext. Abstr. 46th Autumn Mtg Jpn. Sot. of Appl. Phys. and Related Societies, Kyoto (October 1985) 47. Chen, R. T., Holmes, D. E., and Asbeck, P. M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 45:459 (1984) 48. Nishio, J., and Nakata, Y., J. Cryst. Growth, 99:680 (1990) 49. Doering, P. J., Freidenreich, B., Tobin, R. J., Pearah, P. J., Tower, J. P., and Ware, R. M., Semi-Insulating III-VMaterials, (A. G. Mimes and C. J. Miner, eds.), p. 173, Adam Hilger, Toronto (1990) 50. Sato, N., Kakimoto, M., and Kadota, Y., Semi-Insulating III-V Materials, (A. G. Mihres and C. J. Miner, eds.), p. 212, AdamHilger, Toronto (1990) 5 1. Elliott, K. R., X Appl. Phys., 55:3856 (1984) 52. Kikuta, T. and Ishida, K., GaAs and Related Compounds, Inst. Phys. ConJ: Ser., 83:45, Las Vegas (1986) 53. Osaka, J., Hyuga, F., Kobayashi, T., Yamada, Y., and Orito, F., Appl. Phys. Left., 50:191 (1987)
Bulk Crystal Growth
27
54. Asai, S., IEICE Technical Report, ED91-129 (1990) 55. Kitagawara, Y ., Noto, N., Takahashi, T., and Takenaka, T., SemiInsulating III-VMaterials, (H. Kukimoto and S. Miyazawa, eds.), p. 273, Hakone (1986) 56. Raichhnaier, S ., Lhnert, K., and Baumgartner, M., Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 27:2329 (1988) 57. Ogawa, O., Semi-Insulating III-VMaterials, p. 237, (II. Kukimoto and S. Miyazawa, eds.), Hakone (1986) 58. Ford, W., Mathur, G., Look, D., and Yu, P., Semi-Insulating III-V Materials, (H. Kukimoto and S. Miyazawa, eds.), p. 227, Hakone (1986) 59. Lagowski, J., Gatos, H. C., Kang, C. H., Skowronski, M., Ko, K. Y., and Lin, D. G., Appl. Phys. Lett., 49:892 (1986) 60. Brozcl, M. R., and Foulkes, E. J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 49:337 (1986) 61. Asai, S., and Ohata, K., IEICE Technical Report, ED89-109 (1989) 62. Obokata, T., Matsumura, T., Terashima, K., Orito, F., Kikuta, T., and Fukuda, T., Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 23:L602 (1984) 63. Waltiewicz, W., Le Wang, Pawlowicz, L. M., Lagowski, J., and Gatos, H. C., J Appl. Phys., 59:3 144 (1986) 64. Miyajima, H., Kami&a, K., Nishiura, T., Oida, K., Nakai, R., Yokogawa, M., and Nishida, Y., Semi-Insulating III-V Materials, (A. G. Mimes and C. A. Miner, eds.), p. 219, Adam Hilger, Toronto (1990) 65. Adamski, J. A., J Cryst. Growth, 64:l (1983) 66. Kubota, E., J. Cryst. Growth, 68:639 (1984) 67. Farges, J. P., J: Cryst. Growth, 59:665 (1982) 68. Bonner, W. A., J: Cryst. Growth., 54:21 (1981) 69. Shinoyama, S., Uemura, C., Yamamoto, A., and Tohno, S., J. Electron, lo:941 (1981) 70. Tatsumi, M., Kawase, T., Arai, T., Yamabayashi, N., Iwasaki, T., Miura, S., Tada, K., and Akai, S., Int’l. Conj InP and Related MateriaZs, p. 18, Oklahoma (1989) 7 1. Kohiro, K., Kainosho, K., and Oda, O., Int% ConJ InP and Related Materials, p. 8, Cardiff (1991)
28
Compound Semiconductors 72. Hosokawa, Y., Kawarabayashi, S., Yabuhara, Y., Morioka, M., Yokogawa, M., and Akai, S., Int’l. Conf InP and RelatedMaterials, Rhode Island ( 1992) 73. Hof&mn, D., Miiller, G., and Strecffifi, N., Appl. Phys., A48:315 (1989) 74. Kainosho, K., Yamamoto, M., and Oda, O., Ext. Abstr. 52ndAutwnn Mtg. Jpn Sot. Appl. Phys. and Related Societies, Okayama, (October, 1991) 75. Oda, O., Kainosho, K., Kohiro, K., Hirano, R., Shimakura, H., Inoue, T., Yamarnoto, H., and Fukui, T., Int’l Conf: InP and Related Materials, p. 2, Cardiff (1991) 76. Hirt, G., Hof%mn, D., Mosel, F., Sctifer, N., and Miiller, G., Int’l. Conf InP and Related Materials, p. 16, Cardiff ( 199 1)
MOCVD of Compound Semiconductor Layers Eberhard Veuhoff
1.0
INTRODUCTION
Epitaxial growth of compound semiconductor layers is mandatory for the fabrication of electronic and photonic devices. The possibility of growing high quality multilayer heterostructures with excellent control of uniformity in layer thickness and composition, has led to tremendous progress in device developments in the last years. In this progress a continuous interplay between device improvements and advances in materials has taken place. The evolution of metalorganic chemical vapor deposition, MOCVD, as a growth technology for multilayer heterostructures has provided access to improved and new device concepts and facilitated the large scale fabrication of multilayer device structures. In general MOCVD (also referred to as MOVPE, metalorganic vapor phase epitaxy, in order to stress the epitaxial character in the growth process, or OMVPE) is the growth of compound semiconductor layers by metalorganic and hydride precursors in the gas phase. First experiments were reported by Didchenko, Alix and Toeniskoetter in 1960, when they investigated the formation of InP by trimetbylindium and phosphine at about 270 to 300°C.t11 Independent of these first growth studies with metalorganic compounds and hydrides, Harrison and Tompkins prepared GaAs and InSb in 1962[*1and Manasevit grew single crystal GaAs fihns on insulating substrates in 29
30
Compound Semiconductors
1968.t31 Excellent documentation of the vast development of this growth technology since then can be found in review articles [41+81 and books.tglt’Ol Though the success of the MOCW technology in device fabrication is evident, it has to be admitted that a fundamental tmderstanding of the MOCW growth process is still lacking. This was the main reason for carrying out the MOCW process under molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) conditions in order to be able to apply surface analytical tools and to distinguish between homogeneous and heterogeneous reactions. This step led to the introduction of a new growth technology in 198 l,[lll which was labelled MOMBE (metalorganic molecular beam epitaxy) shortly thereafter,ti21and later also CBE (chemical beam epitaxy).[131In the past ten years, this new MOCW related technology has successfully been established as which can be regarded as supplean independent growth technology, lr41tr51 mentary to MOC W. The objective of the present review is to give an overview on the current MOCW activities with emphasis on recent advances in this growth technology. First, some general issues on the basic MOCW growth process are presented, as reactor design and flow dynamics play an important role for large scale fabrication. Especially in manufacturing environments, the use of the MOCW technology might result in a confrontation with safety issues due to the toxic nature of several precursors; therefore, safety aspects have to be considered. In the following paragraph, the flexibility and versatility of the MOCW technology are highlighted by specific examples from different material systems. The strongest MOCW efforts have taken place in III-V material systems, mainly GaAs and InP based materials, for example, AlGaAs and GaInAsP, respectively.t5-101For these compound layers growth and dopant incorporation are outlined. The applications of these materials in electronic devices such as high speed transistors, and photonic devices such as lasers, photodiodes and optical waveguides has led to the commercialization of the MOC W technology for III-V compound layers. For monolithic integration of different devices on the same wafer, selective area epitaxy is gaining increasing importance; therefore, recent developments in this technique are discussed. The MOC W growth of narrow and wide bandgap compound layers appears to be more complex. Device applications of these materials are in in&red and, respectively, green-blue light-emitting diodes and lasers, where some breakthroughs have recently been obtained. For these materials the current status in MOCW of II-VI compounds and alternative compounds is described. Here, the increasing interest in Sbcontaining compounds is also taken into
MOCKS of Compound Semiconductor Layers
31
account. In the conclusion, the potential of this growth technology for future applications in new devices and its relationship to other growth technologies are evaluated.
2.0
GROWTH PROCESS
Theoretical models describing the MOCVD growth process are helpful for finding an appropriate design of the reactor cells and also for optimizing the epitaxial parameters. Generally, for gas phase deposition of epitaxial layers, a thermodynamic driving force has to be present in order to achieve supersaturation of the gas phase. The growth precursors are introduced into the reaction zone, and their concentration and reaction rate must be high enough in order to ensure sufficient decomposition so that this local supersaturation is produced. This shows that the stability of the precursors for example is an important parameter determining the thermodynamic driving force. In a very simple model, the MOCVD growth process can be described in four steps:181(i) mass transport of the reactants to the growth surface, (ii) reaction at or near the surface, (iii) incorporation of the new material, and (iv) removal of the reaction by-products. Of course, the slowest step in this sequence will be the growth rate limiting step. For example, for MOCVD of GaAs and InP based compounds, it has been found that under typical experimental conditions, the growth rate is determined by the mass transport of group III reactants to the growth surface.151-Ii01 While the growth rate is determined by the group III precursor flow [step (i)], the properties of the grown layers are a&cted by the gas phase and surface chemical reactions [steps (ii)-(i Jensen and coworkers established a physiochemical model that describes two- and threedimensional transport phenomena as well as gas phase and surf= reactions underlying the growth of compound semiconductors.1161 The model simulated growth rates and impurity incorporation as a function of epitaxial parameters; for example, the computations showed that the temperature of the reactor walls plays an important role in controlling uniformity. Good agreement between model predictions and experimental data was found. Two alternative routes should be mentioned plasma enhanced MOCVD (PE-MOCVD) and atomic layer epitaxy (ALE). The former technique is very promising for a growth process where relatively stable precursors are used. For example, it has been shown that for growth of the h&based compounds in PE-MOCVD, the plasma precracking of the
32
Compound Semiconductors
hydrides amine and phosphine facilitates the controlled incorporation of the different group V elements, since the phosphorus incorporation efficiency is increased and the pronounced temperature dependence of the solid alloy composition is reduced.l17l In ALE growth of compound layers, the same precursors as in conventional MOCVD can be applied; growth is achieved by the separate and alternate exposure of the substrate to the reactants containing the group III and group V elements of the compound. This leads to an ideal two-dimensional growth process offering excellent control of the growth process at the monolayer level by a self-limiting growth mechanism.ll*l In both techniques, the overall consumption of the hydrides arsine and phosphine is reduced, which is attractive for safety considerations (reduced storage, reduced toxic waste). In the present section, some practical issues for MOCVD growth are outlined. As these are discussed in full detail in recent reviews,151-liOl only a short description is given here with emphasis on latest developments. First, some recent advances in reactor design are presented. In the following subsection, the latest investigations on MOCVD precursors are discussed, and the section concludes with a brief presentation on safety aspects. 2.1
Reactor Design
In MOCVD growth of semiconductor compound layers, the different precursors are introduced via a fast switching gas manifold into a cold wall reactor. In many cases, the reaction cell is made out of quartz and the graphite susceptor is RF heated. The growth process is performed in a hydrogen carrier gas at atmospheric pressure or at reduced pressures requiring a pressure control system. Doping profiles with steep slopes and abrupt interfaces in heterostructures should be obtained. Furthermore, uniformity in layer thickness, doping concentration and composition across larger substrate areas or even among several substrates simultaneously, is the basis for large scale fabrication. To fulfill these requirements, careful design of the gas manifold and reactor cell with inlet region and mixing region is necessary to reduce any dead volumes and to fkihtak Ihst gas exchange in the reactor. Several approaches have been taken in the last years. Three different reactor types can be distinguished:l*l vertical, horizontal, and barrel reactors. In the vertical reactor, the incoming gas flow direction is perpendicular to the substrate surface, whereas in the latter two types, the gas flow is tangential to the growing surface. Vertical and horizontal reactors are mostly used in research or small fabrication facilities;
MOCKS of CompoundSemiconductorLayers
33
the barrel reactor is designed for high throughputs in large scale production.[lgj In 1988, a new type of MOCVD reactor was introduced for epitaxial growth of layers simultaneously on seven 2-inch wafers in planetary motion using a circular growth chamber with horizontal geometry and a radial gas flo~.[~~jIn levitating the wafer carrier on a gas foil, the rotation of the wafers was possible by using the momentum of the gas (gas foil rotation). This configuration led to very uniform GaAs layers with a variation of typically f 1% both in thickness and doping over a 2-inch wafer and ll % in thickness and doping between the wafers. The superior interface quality was demonstrated by a selectively doped GaArJAlGaAs heterostructure with low temperature mobilities (1.5 K) of 720,000 cm21 Vs.t201This design was successfully extended to the (Ga,In)(P,As) material system, where variations in thickness and composition of less than 1.5 % over 80 % of a 2-inch wafer were reported.t211 In a recent study, uniformity in layer thiclutess and composition of better than *1.5% were obtained for AlGaAs across 4-inch wafer areas. In conjunction with a thickness variation of less than *1.5% and an emission wavelength variation of less than f 1 nm obtained on seven 2-inch wafers in multiwafer growth of GaInP, the potential of this reactor type for growth of AlGaInP alloys can be recognized.t22j Recently, GaInAsP layers with excellent layer thickness and composition uniformity have been grown in a wide area stagnation point flow MOCVD reactor, where the stagnation point flow was obtained by a flow controlled multiple gas injector technique.[231 Layer thickness uniformities within f 1%, k2%, and lt3 % were reported for 2-inch, 3 -inch, and, respectively, for three 2-inch wafers grown simultaneously. The standard deviation in the photoluminescence wavelength was between 1.5 and 4 mu and the lattice mismatch variation was within f 100 ppm for both single and multiple wafer growth over the entire composition range. 2.2
Growth Precursors In MOCVD growth, alkyls of the group II and III metals, and
hydrides of the group V and VI elements are usually used as precursors. Generally, the search for improved and new precursors is driven by the requirement for improved layer properties, by the aim to achieve low temperature growth and to reduce premature reactions, and by the demand for improved safety conditions. Furthermore, new techniques-for example, selective area epitaxy-may require specific properties such as
34
Compound Semiconductors
comparable stability of the different precursors, which will stimulate further developments in alkyl precursors. A potential precursor candidate should fulfill several fundamental requirements: (il it should be sufficiently volatile so that acceptable growth rates can be obtained; (ii) appropriate stability of the compound should allow for efficient decomposition at the desired growth temperature without appreciable premature reactions which may result in undesirable depletion; (iii) the compound should neither contain any residual impurities (requirement of extreme purity) nor molecules leading to intrinsic contamination (e.g., carbon problem); (iv) parasitic gas phase reactions should be excluded. Based on these requirements, “design” of a suitable precursor should be accomplished. Generally, it can be stated that significant progress in the purity of the precursors has taken place in the last years. Background doping levels in GaAs and in InP layers well below 1015cmm3 with 77 K mobilities above 100,000 cm*/Vs are state-of-the-art for both materials today. A variation of these values from batch to batch, however, can still be observed. Furthermore, the development of compound layers which are less standard, such as AlGaInAs, makes precursor purity a very stringent requirement for the next years. In the following, a brief description of the application of some precursors is given; a detailed discussion on material properties (vapor pressure, stability, etc.) can be found in recent rev&7s_Pl-V01
For most group Il and III precursors in MOCVD of III-V and, respectively, II-VI compound layers, methyl or ethyl groups containing reactants are commonly chosen. The nature of these alkyles is the most important factor dete rmining the carbon incorporation in GaAs based material.l*l The importance of selecting the appropriate precursor for reduced intrinsic contaminations and reduced premature reactions has been discussed in detail before,181-1101 and is, therefore, omitted here. One recent development, however, should be mentioned: in MOCVD of AlGaAs, carbon contamination is a general problem due to incomplete elimination of methyl groups from [Al-CH,] species. In MOMBE, this problem of carbon contamination is even more severe,l15ltherefore, alternative Al precursors were studied. It was found that with trimethylamine alane, AlH3:N(CH3),, as a replacement for the conventional metalorganic Al sources, AlGaAs layers with excellent structural and optical properties could be grown by MOMBE, since this alternative aluminum compound has no direct Al-C bond. In addition, the reduced ability of this compound to form volatile alkoxides leads to lower oxygen incorporation in the AlGaAs Group II and III Precursors.
MOCKS of Compound
Semiconductor
Layers
35
layers than with the standard aluminum precursor.1241After the successfU application of this alternative Al precursor in MOMBE, it was also tested in MOCVD. A recent study on MOCVD of AlGaAs has shown that with this alternative Al source, the carbon contamination can significantly be reduced compared to growth with the standard aluminum precursor Al(CHs),.t251 The application of this alternative precursor was recently extended to MOCVD growth of Inp based compounds; the suitability of this precursor was already proven in AlInAs/GaInAs photonic and electronic devices.[261 This example clearly demonstrates how results obtained in the related growth technology MOMBE can be transferred to MOCVD, leading to similar improvements in the layer quality. In MOMBE, reaction mechanisms can be studied using surface analytical tools, and the MOCVD technology can take advantage of the MOMBE results. Another problem is the control of the concentration of the precursor in the gas phase. For growth of InP-based ternary and quaternary compounds, for example, a small variation in the concentration of the iridium precursor will lead to severe problems concerning lattice mismatch and compositional uniformity. With In(CH,), as the indium precursor, these problems are observed due to the solid nature of the precursor at the commonly used bath temperature, resulting in incomplete saturation of the carrier gas passing through a crystalline solid matrix. Several approaches have been studied to overcome this problem: the use of quite high temperatures of the precursor bath (> 88‘C), alternative liquid precursors, thermal cycling of the solid source before use, trimethylindium in a saturated solution, or bubblers with With the liquid indium precursor DAD1 special configurations. (dimethylaminopropyldimethyhndium), higb quality single layers and quantum well structures could be grown,.[27l however, the rather low vapor pressure might limit wide application of this precursor. The following two approaches appeared to be the most practical and promising: (i) with trimethylindium dissolved in an involatile solvent, InB and GaInAs layers with excellent electrical and crystalline properties were reproducibly grown;t2*l(ii) in another very recent study, it was shown that it was possible to achieve constant and reproducible indium concentrations in the reactor by the use of a configuration of double reverse precursor bubblers.[2gl These results are especially important for the commercialization of MOCVD technology. A newly developed indium precursor, triisopropylindium, was recently introduced. Compared to the standard precursor trimethylindium, it has a lower stability facilitating low temperature growth which was successfully demonstrated for growth of InAs below 500°C.[301
36
Compound Semiconductors
Group V and VI Precursors. In the past, mostly hydrides were used as group V and VI precursors because of their convenient handling.t*l In the last years, however, safety considerations (see next section) have resulted in the search for a replacement for the very toxic and, if exposed to air or other oxidizing substances, explosive group V hydrides, especially amine and phosphine. In analogy to group II and III precursors, group V methyl compounds were studied. Due to the high stability of trimethylphosphine and trimethylarsine compared to the hydrides phosphine and amine, however, successful application to MOCVD growth was not possible; fkthermore, with the methyl based arsenic compound, a significant carbon contamination in GaAs layers was observed.l31l The use of ethyl based group V precursors was not successfil either because of problems concerning stability and vapor pressure. ~1 Tertiarybutylarsine and tertiarybutylphosphine are now the leading candidates for a replacement of arsine and phosphine. These compounds exhibit convenient vapor pressures and comparable low pyrolysis temperatures; they are available in high purity quality, and yield fairly stable radicals during pyrolysis, so that carbon contamination does not appear to be a larger problem.110113111321 For low temperature growth of II-VI and of Sb based compounds, alternative precursors are o&en applied, as discussed in the following paragraphs. For doping of III-V compounds, hydride sources such as H2S and H,Se are very convenient to use.l*l
2.3
Safety Aspects
The safety considerations in MOCVD laboratories are focused on the highly toxic and flammable properties of the chemicals used in the process. As discussed in detail in the literature,110113111321 amine and phosphine are extremely dangerous because of their extreme toxicity combined with their high vapor pressures and reactivity with air; liquid alkyle sources are approximately one hundred times less hazardous due to their lower vapor pressures, resulting in a lower dispersal into the atmosphere leading to lower concentrations, but also due to the lower toxicity of the alkyle molecules.l1ol Not only the use, transportation, and storage of these gases in sufficient quantities, but also increasing public concern and the possibility of more stringent environmental regulations, raise questions concerning safety issues and even the availability of these gases in the future. The search for a replacement has briefly been outlined in the preceding section. For example, the replacement of phosphine by tertiarybutylphosphine results in a reduction of toxicity by several orders of magnitude.l1ol
MOCKS of Compound Semiconductor Layers
37
Besides the search for alternative precursors, the in-situ generation of the hydrides has been proposed as another solution of this problem of toxicity. Growth of InP layers using solid red-phosphorus and a hydrogen plasma for generation of phosphine was reported, the layers had a high quality surface morphology, though the electrical properties had still to be optimized.l33l Another approach is the electrochemical generation of arsine; the process essentially consists of the cathodic reduction of elemental arsenic in an aqueous potassium hydroxide solution.l34l GaInAs/InP structures were grown and enhanced Schottky GaInAs MBSFETs were fabricated; no significant differences in material properties or device characteristics between in-situ generated amine and tank amine were observed.l35l Growth of GaAs and AlGaAs layers with good electrical properties was recently discus~ed;l~~lthe application of this generator to long term reproducible growth of GaInAsP layers, however, has still to be demonstrated. Besides safe handling and storage of the hazardous chemicals, the safe disposal has to be considered. Wet scrubbing and dry scrubbing systems are currently used. In the former, the toxic hydrides and dangerous metalorganics are oxidized, and the reaction products subsequently neutralized.13’l In dry scrubbing systems, active charcoal or other appropriate materials, pyrolyzers, thermal oxidizers, etc. are applied.t3*l With both types of scrubbing systems, the concentration of arsine and phosphine during epitaxial growth at the outlet is below the detection limit of several ppb. The MOCVD technology has been established in research laboratories for many years already, as stated in the introduction. In addition, in the last years, this technology has been introduced to manufacturing environments requiring the design of a more fail-safe system. Lum and co-workers described in detail an integrated laboratory-reactor MOCVD safety system providing multiple-zone status monitoring and alarm warning signals for critical reactor and laboratory subsystems.[3gl This example shows how, in MOCVD laboratories, dependable fail-safe environments can be achieved.
3.0
SPECIFIC MATERIAL SYSTEMS
In this section, MOCVD of layers from specific material systems is discussed. GaAs and lnP based materials have most extensively been studied and find their applications in electronic and photonic devices, whereas, not as many studies have been carried out on MOCVD of narrow and wide gap materials; one reason for this may be the much more complex nature
38
Compound Semiconductors
ofthegrowthprocessofthelattermaterials. Thecurrentunderstandmginthe MOCVD technology ofthese compound semiconductor layers is presented. 3.1
GaAs and InP Based Materials
This section contains MOO growth lattice matched on GaAs and InP substrates; for GaAs based material, not only GaAs and AlGaAs but also growth of AlGaInP on GaAs substrates is considered; for InP based material besides MOCVD of InP, ternary (GaInAs) and quatemary (GalnAsP) layers the phosphorus-free AlGaInAs is also discussed and compared with the conventional GaInAsP system. Selective area epitaxy is described with emphasis on the InP based system, and the section concludes with some selected examples of device applications. Growth and Dopant Incorporation. One of the basic problems in MOCVD of GaAs with Ga(CH,), and ASH, was the intrinsic contamination of the layers by carbon from the metalorganic compounds.[*l The carbon incorporation rate can be afFected by the growth parameters.181[401 An intentional injection of methane (CH,) into the growth reactor, however, did not result in an increased carbon concentration, neither did a substitution of To explain these results, a hydrogen by a helium carrier gas. [81[411[421 hydrogen transfer reaction was proposed occurring at or close to the substrate surface. In this reaction, atomic hydrogen from decomposed ASH, is probably transferred to the hydrocarbons from the metalorganic precursors forming the stable methane.[421By this mechanism, the carbon concentration at the surface is decreased. These considerations were supported by 13C isotopic labeling studies t43land have to be taken into account when looking for alternative As compounds as replacement of the toxic ASH,, which is the source of atomic hydrogen. [311[32JThese investigations are mentioned here in order to demonstrate the importance of a more basic understanding of the growth chemistry for the improvement of the quality of the grown layers and also for the development of new precursors. Though MOCVD is a well established technology, there is a considerable amount of recent doping studies in the literature, both for GaAs and InP based materials, as an improvement of the material quality still appears to be desirable. Some examples of the recent developments are given here. Kuech et al. took advantage of the effect of enhanced carbon incorporation (see above) for p-type doping of MOCVD GaAs layers. Carbon levels between 1016and 10lg cmm3could be achieved by using Ga(CH,), and either As(CH,), or mixtures of As(CH,), and ASH, under typical growth conditions.[441
MOWD
of Compound Semiconductor
Layers
39
These carbon doping studies were successfully extended to AlGaAs layers.1451 In GaAs and AlGaAs, carbon is certainly the p-type dopant of choice. It has a very low diffusion coefficient, and high quality precursors, As(CH,), and Ccl,, are available.l46l147lThe other commonly used dopants are Si and Zn for n- and p-type doping, respectively.lsl The strong temperature dependence of Si incorporation with SiH, as dopant source, resulting in nommiform electron concentrations across large wafer areas, led to the introduction of a new Si dopant precursor, S&I&, which was applied first in Si doping of GaAs and later also in InP and related materials.1481-1501 Problems regarding Si redistribution or migration are not observed as long as the maximum dopant concentration is kept below a critical level, which is in GaAs and AlGaAs approximately 3 x 1018cmW3. This effect of Si concentration on Si migration is visualized in a SIMS depth profile of a AlGaAs/GaAs laser heterostructure (Fig. 1). For a better comparison, the SIMS signals corresponding to Al and Si were normalized. An increasing Si concentration in the Al cladding layer (samples 1 to 4) leads to an increased Si migration into the active GaAs zone; therefore, structures grown with Si concentrations above the critical level resulted in devices with deteriorated laser characteristics .15ll Recently, for Ga,_Jn& layers, Ccl, has successfully been applied as a p-type dopant precursor. Hole concentrations above lO*OcmW3for x < 0.12, and as high as 10lg cmq3for lattice matched layers (x = 0.53) were achieved.15*l The role of carbon in InP, however, is still not as clear as in GaAs. In carbon implanted InP, n-type conductivity is reported with carrier concentrations larger than 10lg cm-3.1531In contrast to GaAs, with Ccl, as the precursor, any incorporation of carbon in InP layers could not be observed.l54l Therefore, for p-type doping, Mg or Zn have been used as dopants.1551-1571 Because of large Zn diffusion coefficients obtained for intentional in-difl%sion after growth, similar large dopant diffusion and redistribution during growth may be suspected. However, recent studies have shown that no significant dopant diffusion takes place as long as the dopant is incorporated mainly on substitutional sites.1551-1571 Figures 2a and b demonstrate the effect of Zn concentration in InP on Zn difE.rsion.1571 Below a critical level of approximately 2 x 10i8 cmm3,the hole concentration along with the Zn concentration in the layers, exhibits a linear increase with the precursor gas flow. In this range, dopant profiles with steep slopes can be achieved, indicating negligible Zn diffusion during growth (Fig 2a). Above the critical level, the carrier concentration saturates; Zn, however, continues to be incorporated with increasing precursor flow, probably on
40
Compound Semiconductors
interstitial sites, resulting in an onset of Zn diffusion (Fig. 2b); as seen in Fig. 2c, this diffusion can markedly be reduced by co-doping with silicon (Fermi level effect of dif%sion).1571A similar effect of Si co-doping on acceptor di&sion has also been observed in MBE-grown GaAs and AlGaAs layers which were doped with Be.15*IThese results show that the dopant type and dopant level of the layer adjacent to the doped layer have a significant effect on dopant diffusion during growth, for example, an n+doped neighboring layer would be very beneficial. Similar results were found for Mgdoped InP based layers, but Zn may be preferred as p-type dopant in InP and related compounds, as discussed in Ref. 57. As in ternary and quaternary layers, the saturation level of the carrier concentration is higher ( 10lg cmm3)than in InP, the onset of diffusion takes place at higher concentrations in these layers than in InP.ls71 With Si as a donor in InP and related materials, some problems concerning doping control and efficiency have been reported. Therefore, for these materials, S or Sn have been preferred.15gl-1611
growth
lo3
direction
-. \ \ \
lo*
-
\ \ \ sample
10’
-
\
4 3 2
1,
\
/
\ . -/
27Al
___
I
I
I
1
2
3
SPUTTER Figure 1. Effect of Si concentration
TIME
[a.
u.1
on Si migration in AlGaAs/GaAs laser structures. Samples 1,2,3, and 4 exhibit Si concentrations (SIMS) in the AlGaAs cladding layer of 3 x lo’*, 4.1 x lo’*, 5.1 x lo’*, and 5.7 x lOI* cmS, respectively.[51]
UO!leJ)UWUO3
Uz
MOCVB of Compound Semiconductor
[ E UJ3/SUJOje]
Layers
41
42
Compound Semiconductors
Growth and dopant incorporation has mainly been investigated on (100) substrates with or without a slight misorient&ion only. Earlier studies have shown an effect of substrate orientation on dopant incorporation already.l8ll4gl A recent investigation has revealed that this orientation dependence is quite complex, as the variation of doping with increasing misorientation from (100) towards { 111) appears to be non-monotonic. This behavior can be applied for selective growth of alternating p/n layers and lateral p-n junction arrays on non-planar surfaces. The technique has been used to create current blocking layers in InP/GaInAsP laser structures grown in groves or on mesa ridges in one single epitaxial ~tep.1~~1 The phosphorus-free (Al,Ga,In)As system opens an interesting alternative to the conventional (Ga,In)(P,As) system because it offers several advantages with respect to material properties and MOCVD growth control. The larger conduction band offset in AlGaInAs/GaInAs structures, compared to InlVGaInAs or GaInAsP/GaImk, is expected to lead to improved device performance in high speed electronic devices (HEMTs) and in multiple quantum well lasers (MQW lasers) as well. An additional advantage is the potential of impurity-induced disordering in these phosphorusfree structures, as in AlGaAs/GaAs laser structures, for obtaining lateral optical and carrier confinement. 1631In MOCVD growth, the almost linear relationship for group III species between layer composition and gas phase composition in the phosphorus-free system, makes accurate composition control easy, not only in unstrained but also strained quaternary layers,l63l whereas in the conventional quaternary material system, the different thermal stability of arsine and phosphine might lead to problems concerning composition reproducibility and uniformity across large areas. Following these arguments, the layer composition in AlGaInAs is expected to be less sensitive to the growth temperature compared to the composition of GaInAsP layers. This effect can be used for the overgrowth of gratings, for example. It was shown that for perfect grating preservation, overgrowth by a quaternary AlGaInAs layer can be started at a temperature as low as 300°C without any deterioration of the laser structure.l64l Another example is growth of quaternary AlGaInAs layers with graded composition revealing that growth in the phosphorus-free system appears to be less complex.[651 However, ultimate pure precursors have to be chosen (especially “oxygenfree” precursors) and extreme precautions have to be taken concerning the leak tightness of the growth apparatus because of the high sensitivity of this material to moisture and oxygen contamination.l66l
MOCVD of Compound Semiconductor
Layers
43
The GaAs-based material system, (Al,Ga,In)P, has attracted considerable interest in recent years because of its potential use for light-emitting diodes (LEDs) and lasers in the visible range between red and green. As this material exhibits a direct band structure, improved brightness in LEDs is expected compared to AlGaAs and GaP LEDs. In a recent overview, the importance of high purity precursors for MOCVD growth in this material system was pointed out. An additional in-situ purification of phosphine, for example, significantly improved the optical properties of AlGaInP/GaInP quantum well structures. f6’j A detailed comparative study between Zn and Mg for p-type doping of AlGaInP showed that though the Mg incorporation efficiency is much higher, especially at elevated growth temperatures, its fast diffusion makes the control of the position of p-n junctions difficult so that Zn may be preferred.i6q So far, examples of growth and dopant incorporation in bulk layers have been given. For many applications, control of layer thickness and composition at the monolayer level in growth direction has to be achieved, such as for MQW layers. With a carefully designed reactor cell and gas manifold, the successful growth of MQW layers, for example with ternary or quaternary wells and quaternary barriers of different composition of InP based material, was demonstrated (see, for example, Ref. 68). Though there is a large number of studies in the literature on growth interruption, purging times, and valve switching sequences for obtaining high quality interfaces, a discussion here is omitted, since most of the published data are too dependent on the specific geometry of the MOCVD system used in the corresponding study. A general rule is to keep any growth interruption intervals as short as possible in order to avoid interface contamination from background impurities. Selective Area Epitaxy. For advanced devices thickness and composition control, not only the vertical (growth) direction but also the lateral direction is necessary. Examples are overgrowth of structured surfaces and growth of various multilayer device structures on the same wafer for the monolithic integration of different devices on this wafer. For this task, selective area epitaxy (SAE) has become a powerful technique in the last years.[6gl SAE can be achieved by several approaches. This discussion focuses on studies where masked substrates or surfaces were used for localized growth in order to obtain epitaxial growth on unmasked areas only. Already in 1978, Duchemin and co-workers reported that, for MOCVD of GaAs on masked substrates, the total amount of material grown on the unmasked area is comparable to that which would have grown in the
44
Compound Semiconductors
absence of the mask.1701This early experiment suggested that growth rate and composition of selectively grown layers might be infhtenced by the geometry of the mask. Indeed, studies in the following years have shown that surface morphology, planarity, and compositional inhomogeneities of selectively grown layers by MOCVD can severely limit the application of this growth technique. 1711-1731 Generally, selectivity can be improved at decreased reactor pressures, increased growth temperatures, and reduced masked areas.1711-t731In recent studies fiuther improvements have been achieved by using chlorinated group III sources,l74l by injection of small amounts of arsenic trichloride t751or HCl I761for growth of GaAs and by introduction of Ccl, for growth of InP.154117rl This section discusses the selective area growth mechanisms for InP based materials. In contrast to AlGaAs, composition inhomogeneities in GaInAs and GaInAsP result in lattice mismatch and could be detrimental to device applications. In SAE, understanding the effect of growth parameters on the shape of selectively grown structures is important for obtaining planarity in these areas. Additionally, it is important to be able to control the shape of selectively grown structures, as the dopant incorporation can be significantly affected by the surface orientation, as mentioned in the preceding section.l62l In order to avoid the formation of undesired (111) planes in SAE, growth rates on these planes have to be enhanced. From MOCVD of GaAs, it is known that kinetically limited growth rates on (111) surfaces can be affected by the V/III ratio.l78l Therefore, in a recent study, the V/III ratio was taken as the key parameter. Furthermore, a low growth rate (0.5 pm/h) and an appropriate substrate orientation [( 100) and (100) 2” off to (1 lo)] were chosenl7gl analogous to optimized growth parameters of a recent MOMBE study on SAE.lgoJ The substrate was sputtered with SiO, double stripes; the length of the 14 pm wide stripes was 500 pm with a 3 pm wide gap in between them. In these studies the masked samples were exposed to growth of InP for two hours which would lead to growth of 1 pm of InP in the case of unmasked substrates. Figure 3 focuses on the gap between the double stripes; the SEM micrograph shows the ridge cross section area with a view of the (O-l-l) plane. Though a relatively low growth temperature was chosen (6OO”C),no deposition on the masked areas could be detected, and a high quality surface morphology of the selectively grown areas was obtained. At a low III/V ratio, the formation of the typical (111) planes was observed (Fig. 3a), which was suppressed at high V/III ratios (Fig. 3b); note the vertical side walls in this figure. This effect of the V/III ratio on ridge geometry of SAE grown InP is demonstrated in Fig. 4. The rate is
MOCVD of Compound Semiconductor Layers
45
approaching the large area value for high V /lli ratios; even at the highest V / III ratio, the rate is still larger by approximately 15% than in the case of growth on unmaskedsubstrates(growth rate ~). This increasedrate, R, is certainly causedby supersaturationof the gas phase,becauseon the masked areasno material consumption takes place, whereas in MOMBE due to the absenceof a gas phase the growth rate is not affected by the presenceof a mask.[80] In addition, it can be recognizedfrom Fig. 4 that the ridge cross section area appearsto be independentof V /III ratio, since with increasing V /III ratio the effective growth rate of the ridge is decreased,but simultaneously, the growth rate in lateral direction is increased.
Figure 3. SEM micrograph of ridge cross section, view of the (0-1-1) plane; ridges were grown under V/Ill ratios of (a) 420, (b) 2800 on misoriented substrates; (c) as in (b). but on (loo) just oriented substrate.[79] (~ 1992 IEEE.)
46
Compound Semiconductors
4 ,
I
,8
I
I
p”
3.5 -
-7
h
“E 1
2 a, -l-J (d L
-
3 -
___.~____________. I____. ______
-0
iii
? 2-
\\
b-l 1.5 -
:
H-5
2.5 -
_c z
-6
-
-4
\
“w_ --_
‘-__
5 zz u ii
-3
l ---_
--------
rl
0
0
.-: Yi
1 -
-2
b
E’ ;
0.5 -
-l
E-I -cl .L
0 ’
0
I
I
1000 V/III
2000
I
3ooo”
ratio
Figure 4. Effect of VA ratio on ridge geometry of SAE grown InP between SiO, stripes on misoriented substrates; circles and squares represent data for left and right y-axis, respectively.[79] (0 1992 IEEE.)
This constant ridge cross section area is an important parameter for establishing a qualitative model describing the mechanisms ruling SAE (Fig. 5). The adsorption flux& of the adsorbing species may be consumed as the fluxes An,, f&, and&_, which nominate the fluxes determining the incorporation on (111) planes, surface diflksion and desorption of the adatoms, respectively. At a lower group V adsorption flux, the adsorbed species are supposed to have a higher surface mobility on (111) planes [721 (largef&,n smallJ;,,), resulting in formation of these planes. As the adatoms move rapidly to the top of the ridge, an increased thickness of the ridge at the edges is obtained covering a distance Z,,fi which nominates the diffusion length of the adatoms on top of the ridge. Under this assumption, we expect a ridge shape as visualized by the solid line in Fig. 5, and actually observed in the experiments with a low V/III ratio (Fig. 3a). At a higher group V adsorption flux, however, the mobility of the adatoms may be reduced along with a reduced desorption flux (small f&+nd f&s), growth on the (111)
MOCKS
of Compound Semiconductor
Layers
47
planes should be increased (large&), i.e., growth in the lateral direction is enhanced resulting in a ridge with decreased height and improved planarity (small ldif; dashed line in Fig. 5). Note that in this model, the ridge cross section area should be the same as in the case of the lower group V adsorption flux. Our experimental results support this model (Fig. 3b).
Figure 5. Sketch (not to scale) for qualitative model describing SAE under low and high group V adsorption fluxes (solid and dashed lines, respectively).[7g] (0 1992 IEEE.)
The phosphorus sticking coefficient during MOMBE has been interpreted to be substantially higher on misoriented surfaces than on just oriented surfaces, leading to an increased group V adsorption flux, and consequently, to vertical side walls of the grown structures.[801 The results in Fig. 3c show that even at the highest V/III ratio the formation of (111) planes cannot be suppressed on surfaces without some misorientation. On substrates with a m&orientation, a higher density of steps, and consequently, more adsorption sites are available resulting in a decreased surface diffusion length ,and therefore, in an improved planarity, as explained above (Fig. 5, dashed line). Therefore, this influence of substrate orientation on SAE is not unexpected. 17gl This example of SAE in MOCVD of InP has been discussed here in more detail not only in order to elucidate some basic growth mechanisms, but also in order to demonstrate how trends found in SAE of another technology, MOMBE, are transferable to MOCVD, resulting in an improvement in SAE of MOCVD. However, it has to be mentioned that in MOCVD, both surface kinetics and gas phase diffusion play an important role, whereas in MOMBE only surface kinetics effects are present which are almost comparable to the mechanisms in MOCVD.
48
Compound Semiconductors
It is possible to take advantage of this increased growth rate in SAE in MOCVD. Growth enhancements, because of a varying supersaturation of the gas phase, can be controlled by the mask dimensions; an increasing mask stripe width, for example, will result in an increasing layer thickness adjacent to the mask. Therefore, this technique allows one to taper semiconductor structures, which can find applications in thickness modulated waveguide structures. 18il Lateral thickness variations can also be achieved by the use of a crystalline shadow masks.l82l Implementing MQW layers in the SAE grown structures with intentional thickness variation leads to a shift of the emission wavelength, due to the variation of the thickness of the quantum well so that lateral bandgap engineering can be achieved by these techniques. The drawbacks of these techniques are a broadening of the photoluminescence peaks caused by lateral thickness variations in the quantum wells and large lattice mismatches in InP based materials, induced by a variation in composition of the layers, as discussed below.l83l Not only the growth rate, but also the composition of the layers is affected by the presence of masks on the surface in SAE of MOCVD: an increase of the In content in GaInAs layers is found with decreasing d&an= to the ~&~[@‘1[7W’31W1 n ese results cannot be explained just by surface diffusion of the species, moreover, it is assumed that a frequent interaction of the precursors with the mask (adsorption/desorption processes) leads to partial decomposition; as trimethylindium is less stable than trimethylgallium, an increased concentration of partially decomposed compounds, i.e., dimethyl- and monomethylindium, should be present in the gas phase. For these species, higher gas phase diffusion rates are expected than for trimethylgallium giving rise to In-rich layers close to the masked areas.l73l Therefore, precursors for Ga and In with comparable stability should be chosen in order to obtain an improved homogeneity in SAE of MOCVD. So far, any effect of group V precursors on SAE has been neglected. In a very recent study on binary and ternary layers, however, SAE of GaInAs and GaIr# could not be related in a simple way to SAE of the corresponding binary layers. Therefore, for an interpretation of these results a catalytic effect of the decomposed group V fragments on the decomposition of group III metalorganics was postulated.l85l This example demonstrates the complexity of SAE in MOCVD of III-V compound layers.
MOCKS of Compound Semiconductor Layers
49
For several device applications, SAE around mesa structures is essential. There are not many basic studies in the literature on the SAE of InP-based material around reactive ion etched mesa ridges without mask overhang. For the sake of reproducibility, however, the dry etching technique might be preferred. It was found that planarity is significantly improved at higher growth temperatures, mainly because of lower growth rates on the (0 11) planes forming the mesa side walls; growth at 680°C and at 100 mbar was recommended for sufficient planarity and selectivity for laser fabrication.[861 In a very recent study, it was shown that by the addition of Ccl, selective and planar regrowth of InP around stripe mesas up to 5.5 pm height can be further improved.[771 With unmasked mesa ridges, remarkable differences in growth rates on ridges and on channels between ridges compared to growth rates on planar surfaces have been reported; this effect makes monolithic integration in a single epitaxial step possible, for example in laser-waveguide integration .I87l Selective area epitaxy can also be applied for the fabrication of lowdimensional semiconductor structures. Recently, it was reported that GaAs growth of tetrahedral quantum dots can be achieved resulting in zerodimensional electron-hole systems. [88l SiO,-masked (11 l)B GaAs substrates were used; the masks were partially etched to remove triangles of SiO,. First, AlGaAs truncated tetrahedral structures with three { 1 lo} facets were grown on GaAs triangular areas, and then GaAs dots were sequentially grown on top of the tetrahedral structure; finally, AlGaAs was overgrown on the whole tetrahedral structure. Photoluminescence properties showed zero-dimensional quantum confinement.[881 Another approach to SAE is to make use of different growth rates on planes with different orientations. For example, in contrast to growth of InP, GaInAs does not grow on low-index planes like { 111) or { 1lo} for certain growth conditions. With this technique, growth of buried GaInAs quantum wires and quantum dots in one epitaxial step can be achieved.l8g1l9ol These results demonstrate the potential of the MOCVD technology for the fabrication of nanometer scale quantum wires and quantum dots. A technique for SAE that has not found as many device applications yet as SAE on masked wafers is photon-assisted selective area epitaxial growth. Selectivity can be achieved either by a thermal or a photochemical effect; in the former case, a laser is used for locally heating restricted areas
50
Compound Semiconductors
of the wafer, whereas in the latter case, local decomposition of the precursors at, or close to, the substrate is obtained.t731tg11t921 However, the quality of the grown material may be limited by radiation damage. Additionally, several problems concerning surface morphology, defects and selectivity have still to be solved. Device Applications. In the preceding section, some general device applications related directly to MOCVD of compound semiconductor layers have been outlined. In the following, some selected examples will be presented with emphasis on modem MQW devices and on monolithically integrated devices. In recent overviews, the importance of advanced MOCVD technology was pointed out for electronic devices as well as for optoelectronic devices. lgsl[941GaAs based low noise HEMTs are commercially available now. Large scale fabrication has been achieved in a barrel reactor with twelve 3-inch wafers for AlGaAs/GaAs HEMT ICs with thickness uniformity off 1 % both within each wafer and among the twelve wafers, and similar results were obtained for doping uniformity. Standard deviations in threshold voltage were as small as 10.1 mV for E-HEMTs and 16.1 mV for D-HEMTs across an entire 3-inch wafer.tg51 The application of these wafers in LSI circuits has recently been demonstrated. A HEMT 64 kb SRAM with 0.6 pm gates was fabricated, in a 5 l-stage ring oscillator with an average delay time of 22.6 ps/gate with a 0.8 ps standard deviation over the 3-inch wafer and a power dissipation of 0.8 mW/gate.t%l These results demonstrate that with MOCVD technology an extremely precise and highly reproducible control of layer parameters such as thickness, composition, and carrier concentration can be achieved including superior two-dimensional electron gas characteristics. InP-based HEMTs and HBTs are promising next-generation heterostructure devices, and therefore, a topic of continuous research and development.lg31 For example, in I&based HEMT structures care has to be taken in selecting an appropriate buffer layer for good carrier confinement and low leakage. The use of n&P as a sub-channel layer has led to further device improvements; in an MOCVD grown 0.6 pm gate AlInAs/GaInAs/ n-InP HEMT an extremely high transconductance of 1290 mS/mm was achieved.lg71 For an MOCVD grown AlInAs/GaInAs HEMT using 0.1 urn T-gate technology, operation above 150 GHz was obtained. Here, the background doping in the AlInAs buffer below the channel layer, a critical parameter, has to be kept at low levels (below 5 x 1015cmm3)in order to reduce parasitic conduction through this layer.tg81
MOWD
of Compound Semiconductor
Layers
51
The GaInAsP material system has increasingly gained importance in optical telecommunication fiber systems. The incorporation of a GaInAsP/ GaInAs MQW structure as the active region in laser structures is driven by the requirements of high modulation speed, high power, high operation temperature, narrow linewidth and low threshold current. Even further improvements could be realized by introducing intentional strain into the quantum well. G~,&-,,As/GaInAsP strained-layer MQW lasers emitting at 1.55 pm with cw output powers as high as 200 mW exhibit an extremely high differential external efficiency of 82 %; threshold currents as low as 10 mA and a T, value of 97 K were reported.l99l A comparison has shown that using a confinement region with continuously graded composition leads to improved T, values compared to ungraded structures. The graded region was achieved by simultaneous gas flow ramping of the metalorganic group III and hydride group V precursors.[100l So far, mainly ternary layers for the quantum well layers have been used in both unstrained and strained MQW structures. With ternaries, however, bandgap and lattice constant (strain) cannot be chosen independently of each other, so that for a given lattice constant the emission wavelength can only be tailored by the thickness of the well layer. This leads to very thin well layers, and consequently, to an increased sensitivity of the wavelength to thickness variations. In addition, the optical confmement factor is reduced. To overcome these disadvantages in these structures, quaternary layers as quantum well layers were introduced.l1o1ll1o2l For example, for ridge waveguide lasers (emission wavelength: 1.55 pm) with 1.5% compressive strain in the quaternary well layer, improvements in device characteristics compared to unstrained MQW lasers were obtained. In 1 mm long strained devices, a high characteristic temperature, T,, of 85 K has been measured (lo-50°C) compared to 68 K for unstrained devices. The maximum cw output power at 30°C of the as-cleaved devices could be increased from 35 mW/facet to 50 mW/facet by introducing strain in the layers, and a maximum operation temperature of 140°C was reported.lioll These values are the highest yet observed for long-wavelength lasers with all-quatemary strained MQW active regions. The thickness of the strained layers has to be kept below the critical thickness in the structure. To avoid this problem of thickness restriction, the barriers can be strained in the opposite sense to the wells, resulting in a zero-net-strain structure. In a BH heterostructure laser with 16 quantum wells, the differential gain in case of zero-net-strain was 40% higher than in the case of conventionally strained and unstrained devices. Damping
52
Compound Semiconductors
coefficients imply potential modulation bandwidths in the range of 34 to 42 GHz in these devices .[lo31 An alternative technique for obtaining strained quaternary quantum well layers appears to be the use of the phosphorus-free system AlGaInAs, since the Ga in GaInAs can be partially replaced by Al resulting in a change in emission wavelength at constant well thickness and constant lattice constant. Thus, the wells can be made thicker while maintaining the strain and the emission wavelength. In addition, the emission wavelength can be adjusted either to 1.3 or 1.55 pm while keeping the strain and well thickness constant. Results on QW lasers with both compressive and tensile strain were reported.t631 The presence of the Al did not degrade the laser performance; threshold current densities as low as 96 A/cm2 were obtained in compressively strained 5 mm long 1.32 pm lasers. It was verified that the emission wavelength was TE and TM mode in case of compressive and tensile strained lasers, respectively. The first successful fabrication and operation of gain-coupled 1.55 pm A1GahuA.sMQW metal clad ridge waveguide DFB lasers, was recently reported .[‘j41Figure 6 shows the structure with a first order grating. The 40 nm thick n-GaInAs layer, which was grown in the first epitaxial step, provided the loss grating. The crucial epitaxial step in such a structure is the overgrowth of the grating. Perfect grating preservation was achieved by starting the overgrowth of the quaternary layer at 300°C, as pointed out already in a preceding section. For as-cleaved devices, the single mode yield was as high as 70 % and 95 % for 600 and 800 pm long devices, respectively; typical threshold currents were 40 and 55 mA, respectively. For 600 pm long devices, a cw output power of 10 mW and a minimum linewidth of 1.6 MHz were measured. In the conventional GaInAsP system, the fabrication of a 1.55 urn index/gaincoupled DFB laser with a strained MQW active grating was achieved .[io41The structure in Fig. 7 shows that the overgrowth of the first order grating was performed using an InP layer. The five 5.5 nm thick quaternary wells exhibited a compressive strain of 1.5 %, the four 10 nm thick quaternary barriers were unstrained. More than 90 % of the 115 ascleaved devices with 125 pm and 250 pm cavity lengths showed single longitudinal mode oscillation. A side-mode suppression ratio as high as 52 dB was obtained for 125 pm long lasers under dc operation. A maximum output power of 10 mW and a threshold current of 19 nu4 were measured, the latter value is among the best for previously reported gain-coupling type DFB lasers.
MOCKS of CompoundSemiconductorLayers
p“
53
6lnAs
p-MIAS
n-MIAs
, / I
‘-A
\
n’- InP substrate \ \
Figure 6. Layer structure of gain coupled 1.55 pm AlGaInAs MQW MCRW DFE3 laser, black triangles represent the ternary loss grating layer.[641 @I 1992 IEEE.)
54
Compound Semiconductors
0.2um l&m
cap
pt-InGaAs
cladding
plnP I
30A
O&m
p-InGaAsP plnP
etch stop buffer 7OOAInGakP(1 .Oum) SCH MQW active region: well 55A x 5 barrier IOOA x 4(1.2!5um)
Figure 7. Layer structure of index/gain coupled 1.55 pm GaInAsP MQW ridge waveguide DFB laser.[104] (Reprinted by permission of the publisher, Electronic Letters)
The importance of the GaAs-based AlGaInP material for optical devices has been mentioned in a previous section. A high-efficiency MOCVD AlGaInP surface emission LED with an AlGaAs window layer was successfully fabricated with emission at 620 nm; at 20 mA injection current the external quantum efficiency was 1.5 %. This LED was five times more efficient at 620 nm than AlGaAs and GaAsP LEDs. A 563 run green electroluminescence was also achieved with an (Al,,,Ga&,&,,P active layer.[lo51In another recent study, an MOCVD-grown AlGaInP LED structure with a lattice mismatched GaP conductive window was described.[lo61 With increasing thickness of this window layer from 5 to 15 urn, an increased efficiency due to the effect of current spreading was obtained. Green emitters (554 nm wavelength) were fabricated representing the shortest wavelength devices yet reported for the AlGaInP system. The high material quality in MOCVD grown AlGaInP/GaInP laser structures was also demonstrated by narrow index-guided ridge lasers emitting at 670
MOCKD of Compound Semiconductor Layers
55
nm, where cw operation up to 100°C was reported.16~ A study on long-term stability of strained MQW lasers in this material system (5 pm wide buried ridge stripe structure) revealed stable operation for more than 5500 h at 50°C, resulting in an estimated mean time to failure of 10,900 h.[lOq In uncoated devices, cw operation with an optical output power exceeding 3 mW was observed up to 160°C, which is the highest operation temperature reported for visible lasers. lio81 For AlGaAs/GaAs narrow oxide stripe lasers (870 run), degradation rates below low5h-l were measured at 80°C and 5 mW cw optical output/facet and at 60°C, 10 mW, operating more than 16,000 h;llogl today the operating time of these lasers is exceeding 85,000 h under these conditions.l11ol Vertical cavity surface emitting lasers (VCSEL) offer several advantages over edge emitting designs, especially in two-dimensional high density arrays, chip-to-chip optical interconnection, or for monolithic integration. For good device performance, however, very tight tolerances have to be fulfilled, for example, concerning control of the quantum well thickness. A systematic error exceeding &to.5% in thickness deviation can not be tolerated indicating the stringent requirements on for properly working devices, 11111 the growth technology. It has been demonstrated that MOCVD is a viable growth technology for AlGaAs/GaAs VCSEL structures. Room temperature optically pumped cw lasing has been observed with powers of 22 mW, power efficiencies over 45% and single fundamental transverse mode operation.[111l The monolithic integration of proven discrete devices such as lasers, photodetectors, and waveguides is gaining increasing importance for the fabrication of economic chips. As described in the preceding section, selective area epitaxy (SAE) has become a powerful technique for reaching this aim. Lateral bandgap engineering can find applications, for example, in an array of lasers emitting at different wavelengths. Though this can be achieved by different individual lasers, monolithic integration might be preferred. Recently, this was achieved in one single MOCVD run by the use of shadow masked growth in combination with MQW active regions. In GaInAs/GaInAsP strained-layer MQW Fabry-Perot lasers, it was possible to obtain a wavelength span of 130 nm centered around 1.55 pm at constant threshold current.l112l The integration of a low threshold buried ridge DFB laser with a waveguide has been realized by SAE in MOCVD. Laser threshold currents as low as 10 mA and waveguide output powers in excess of 3 mW were achieved for 1 mm long waveguide devices.l113l Laser-waveguide integra-
56
CompoundSemiconductors
tion is even possible in just a single epitaxial step using non-planar surfaces.[114l SAE was also applied for the integration of a GaInAs photodetector and butt-coupled InP/GaInAsP/InP waveguide. The device showed a fast pulse response (60-65 ps FWHM with a 3 dB bandwidth of 2.7 GHz) and appears to be easy integrable with FET receiver circuitry.l115l The integration of both GaInAsP lasers and GaInAs photodiodes with impedance matching circuits for 6 GI-Iz transmission, should be mentioned. The characteristics of integrated and discrete lasers were quite similar indicating that the more complex technology does not result in any deterioration.l116I Finally, another example of lateral bandgap engineering should be given: a butt-jointless MQW DFB laser-modulator integrated light source was fabricated.l117l The bandgap energy of the selectively grown MQW structure was controlled by the mask stripe width, as described in the preceding section. l*ll A total energy shift of 58 meV was obtained for the GaInAs/GaInAsP MQW structure grown with 3 to 10 pm wide mask stripes.l117l The threshold current of the DFB laser was 35 mA, and more than 5 mW light power was obtained at the modulator output. The coupling efficiency between laser and modulator was estimated to be approximately 100%. 3.2
Narrow Bandgap Materials
In this section, recent developments in MOCVD growth of narrow bandgap materials are outlined. The main efforts in this field have been in Because of problems in the II-VI material system Hg,,C4;Te. 11181111gl epitaxial growth and thermal stability of these compounds, increasing research activities in Sb containing compounds as a replacement of II-VI compounds can be observed in recent years. Therefore, in the second part of this section this III-V material system is described as an alternative to the IIVI material system. II-VI Compounds. The advanced state of MOCVD of GaAs and InP based systems has been described in the preceding section. Growth of the II-VI compound HgCdTe (MCT), however, is much more complicated, since the optimum growth conditions for HgTe and CdTe are quite different, as discussed in detail in a recent review.l12ol The major problem in MOCVD of MCT is the choice of an appropriate growth temperature. For deposition with the standard precursor diethyltelhuide, a temperature around 400°C has to be chosen, whereas at this temperature, high Hg pressure is required for surface stabilization. 11211Furthermore, at these high tempera-
MOCVD of Compound Semiconductor
Layers
57
trues, significant selfditfusion takes place, and large concentrations of Hg vacancies are created, acting as acceptors. Therefore, in the last few years among the most important research topics were uniformity control across larger areas and conductivity control. To solve these problems, several approaches have been proposed. In the more traditional direct alloy growth (DAG) process, all three precursors are simultaneously introduced into the reactor to grow HgCdTe of the required composition.l12oll121l In the interdiffised multilayer process (IMP), alternate layers of HgTe and CdTe are sequentially grown under conditions optimized for the respective binary layers, and then annealed immediately after the growth period for homogenizing the structure by interdif&sion.ll**l By the latter technique, improved uniformity of the layers across larger areas could be obtained, however, due to the lattice mismatch between HgTe and CdTe, the possibility of defect generation exists, and the nucleation of CdTe on HgTe might be difficult to control.[1201Another approach is to reduce the growth temperature, which can be achieved in a photon-assisted growth process 1123111241 or by the use of alternative Te precursors.l125l In MOCVD growth of the ternary GaAs and InP based material (AlGaAs and GaInAs, respectively), the growth process is mass transport limited, the growth rate of the ternaries is the summation of the rates of the corresponding binaries, and the alloy composition is directly related to the ratio of group III precursors in the gas phase. In contrast to this behavior in MOCVD of the ternary Hg,,C&Te with dimethylcadmium (DMCd), diethyltelluride (DETe) and elementary mercury (Hg) as precursors, the growth rate of HgTe is affected by the presence of the Cd precursor. A significant decrease of the total growth rate and an increase in composition x were observed, when the DMCd flow is increased.l120l Similar results were obtained with diisopropyltelluride (DIPTe) as the Te precursor, and adduct formation was proposed as an explanation for these results.l126l Hence, it is very important to avoid any depletion of DMCd over a larger area, in order to achieve good uniformity over the substrate. For device applications, the composition, x, has to be kept at 0.2 kO.005 over the area of interest, a uniformity which is difficult to achieve in the DAG process.11201In the IMP process, the significant advantage is the uniformity of the layers; here a radial uniformity (Ax) of *to.003 over a square of 9 cm* on a 2-inch GaAs substrate was reported.tlrgl Replacing the standard CdTe substrates by CdTeSe substrates has led to growth of high quality HgCdTe layers by the DAG technique; the layers were grown in a vertical reactor and had a compositional uniformity of
58
Compound Semiconductors
kO.005 over a 1 cm x 2 cm area substrate. With a rotating substrate, an improvement to values better than *to.002 is expected.l127l The FWHM value of about 47 arcsec in the x-ray rocking curve was about three times smaller than that for layers grown simultaneously on CdTe substrates. The reason for this improvement in crystal quality cannot only be found in the better lattice match, but also in the superior crystal quality of the CdTeSe substrate itself compared to CdTe. In the IMP process, growth of HgCdTe on CdTeSe and CdZnTe substrates was reported.l128l Though HgCdTe could be grown at temperatures as low as 33O”C, for improved crystal quality the temperature was raised to 420°C for x in the range of 0.19 to 0.24. This effect of growth temperature on the FWHM values ofthe rocking curves is shown in Fig. 8; it can be seen that values below 30 arcsec were obtained. This study indicated that the quality of the HgCdTe layers was still restricted by that of the CdTeSe and CdZnTe substrates. Therefore, an alternative approach would be to grow buffer layers on high quality lattice mismatched substrates such as GaAs.
Growth Temp.( W
Figure 8. Effect of growth temperature on rocking curve widths of HgCdTe layers grown on CdTeSe substrates (circles) and on CdZnTe substrates (triangles).[128] (Reprinted Sv permission of the publisher, American Institute of Physics.)
MOCKD of Compound Semiconductor
Layers
59
Recently, a vertical reactor with a multinozzle injector and a rotating susceptor was proposed for improving the uniformity; precursors were DMCd, DIPTe and Hg.t 12gl As the composition profile of the layer grown by the injection of DMCd from two nozzles was the same as the summation of the two profiles produced with one nozzle, the profile for injecting DMCd from multinozzles could be calculated. This simulation calculation showed that with 4 nozzle injectors a composition uniformity (Ax) of 0.04 should be achieved across a 3-inch wafer, and that 8 nozzle injectors are needed to achieve a compositional variation (Ax) of 0.002 over the same area demonstrating the significant improvement in composition uniformity. Compositional control has also been accomplished by photon-assisted MOCVD using a KrF excimer laser;t1241by increasing the laser repetition rate from 100 to 400 Hz, the composition x decreased from 0.8 to 0.2. This decrease in composition was associated with increased photodecomposition of the precursor DETe. It was suggested that the composition x did not necessarily increase with increased photodecomposition of the precursor DMCd. Undoped layers are p-type due to the presence of Hg vacancies. A conversion to n-type conductivity can often be observed after annealing the layers under Hg-rich conditions, probably because of the presence of residual donor impurities after elimination of the Hg vacancies.[1201 With trimethylindium, n-type doping can be achieved. The net donor concentration was found to exhibit a linear relationship with the dopant partial pressure over a range of carrier concentration from 5 x 1016 to 3 x lo’* cmm3. Saturation of the In incorporation was observed for even higher TM1 concentrations and is believed to be due to the formation of In2Tes precipitate~.t’~~1[~~~1 The In incorporation probably occurs mainly on Hg sites. High electron mobilities measured over the entire dopant range indicated a low compensation of the layers. The incorporation of acceptors in HgCdTe can be achieved by injecting arsine1131Jor alternative As precursors such as tertiarybutylarsine and diethylarsine. [1321Carrier concentrations over the range from approximately 5 x 1015to 2 x 1017 crnm3have been obtained. At increased Hg pressures an enhanced As incorporation was observed. A higher arsine flow, however, leads to a decrease in composition so that with increasing amine flow an increasing DMCd flow is required in order to keep the composition constant. This behavior suggests the formation of a DMCdASH, adduct in the gas phase.[1201
60
Compound Semiconductors
As discussed above, the stringent requirements of compositional and conductivity control in HgCdTe are beginning to be fulfilled. Recent overviews on photovoltaic detectors and photoconductors have revealed tbat MOCVD is now capable of producing HgCdTe devices with state-of-the-art performance.111gl11201 The peak responsivities of detectors fabricated with MOCVD material are comparable to those from LPE material. These accomplishments underline the significant progress that has been made in MOCVD of HgCdTe in the last few years. Sb-Containing Compounds. The interest in antimony-containing compounds in the material system (Ga,In)(As,Sb) is generated by the extremely large bandgap range which can be covered in this system resulting in many applications in optoelectronic and electronic devices. With an emission range from 0.9 to 12 pm (1.43 to 0.1 ev), this material exhibits the Optoelectronic applicasmallest bandgap of III-V semiconductors. 1133111341 tions are infrared detectors in the 2 to 4 pm range as well as in the 8- 12 pm range. Additionally, a low electron effective mass makes InSb attractive for high-speed circuits, for example. However, this alloy system is known to have a very large miscibility gap, but this makes it an ideal candidate for the study of met&able III-V alloys. [1331[1341 In spite of these interests, there has been much less MOCVD activity for this material system than for the larger bandgap GaAs and InP based materials. The problem in MOCVD growth of Sb-containing compounds is the non-volatility and the very low surface mobility of elemental antimony compared to As or P in the GaAs and InP based material systems. Therefore, only a very narrow range of V/III ratio and growth temperature can be used for obtaining layers with high quality surface morphology. For example, for growth of GaSb, a strong effect of V/III ratio on layer morphology was found; mirrorlike surfaces could be observed at V/III ratios in the range of 6 to 8 at a growth temperature of 600°C and a reactor pressure of 100 torr; bound-exciton peaks in the photoluminescence spectra only appeared in samples grown at a V/III ratio of 6.8 demonstrating the narrow window of growth parameters for high quality layers. This narrow window can also be recognized in Fig. 9, where the effect of V/III ratio on the FWHM of acceptor-band peaks is visualized: the FWHM value is smaller for V/III ratios in the range of 6-8 and increases drastically for V/III ratio larger than 10.11351Additionally, in another study, it was found that the optimum V/III ratio varies with growth pressure; at lower pressures, a decrease of this ratio was required for maintaining good morphology probably due to the reduced sticking coefficient of the gallium compounds
MOCKD of CompoundSemiconductorLayers
61
on the growing surface. A drastic decrease of the growth rate at 500°C was observed and was thought to be caused by the less efficient decomposition of the Sb precursor trimethylantimony.[1361 44.
L j 4. _
24
0
I .
100 toll 6OO*C
I 2
I 4
I 6
I 8
I IO
8
TtlSb/TEGa RATIO
Figure 9. Effect of V/m ratio on the FWHM of the acceptor bands in photoluminescence spectra measured on GaSb at 17 K .[‘351 (Reprinted by permission of the publisher, American Institute of Physics.)
For growth of InSb on GaAs substrates (lattice mismatch 14.5%), a very narrow range of V/III ratios (2 to 3) was reported for obtaining high mobility layers. Under optimized growth conditions, Hall mobilities up to 60,900 and 27,000 cm2Ns were measured at 300 and 77 K, respectively. Best surface morphologies were achieved at a V/III ratio of 3 .1137lAnother study on high mobility InSb emphasized the importance of high-purity sources and strict control of V/III ratio across the susceptor.113*l In layers grown at 450°C on InSb substrates, an optimum V/III ratio of 7.4 was found. Carrier concentration and mobility measured at 77 K were 1.4 x 1015 cms3and 2.53 x lo5 cm2Ns, respectively, whereas growth on GaAs substrates appeared to be largely affected by the lattice mismatch resulting in 77 K mobilities of 5-9 x lo4 cm2Ns.11381
62
Compound Semiconductors
The optimization of the initial growth process is important for growth of Ga,_,In$b layers on GaSb and GaAs substrates due to the large lattice mismatch. Surface morphology and electrical properties were markedly improved using graded GaInSb buffer layers, step buffer layers with 5, 15, 22.5 and 30% In for the Ga,&n,&b final layer, and strained layer superlattice buffer layers (20 nm Ga,Jn,,sSb/20 nm GaSb).113gl Due to the thermal stability of the precursor trimethylantimonide, low temperature growth in this material system is difficult to achieve. For example, in MOCVD of InSb with this Sb precursor at 4OO”C,the formation of In droplets was always observed. Therefore, for this growth temperature, it was replaced by the less stable triethylantimonide.11371 Lower growth temperatures, however, should be explored because of two main reasons. Firstly, the potential for growing metastable bismuthcontaining compounds should not be ignored, as these compounds, such as InAsSbBi, are an attractive alternative material for infrared detectors operating in the range from 8 to 12 urn. For growth of these metastable compounds, low temperatures are required.ll““l Secondly, due to the low melting point of InSb (525OC), high temperatures are not acceptable for growth of thin InSb layers with abrupt interf!ace~.l~~~lA substitution of the stable Sb alkyle by less stable Sb hydride SbH, was proposed to achieve the aim of low temperature growth.11411By inserting a buffer layer grown at 400°C, the single crystal InSb layer was grown at 300°C on an InSb substrate in a vacuum MOCVD system without carrier gas. A V/III ratio (gas flow ratio of stibine to triethylindium) higher than 8 had to be chosen. The nominally undoped epitaxial layers were n-type with a carrier concentration and a mobility at 77 K of 1.5 x 1016 cmm3and 7.6 x lo4 cm2/Vs, respectively. The instability of this Sb source, however, may prevent wider applications. With triisopropylantimony as an alternative source, InSb growth was possible at temperatures as low as 300°C. However, a high V/ III ratio had to be u~ed.1~~~11~~~1 A 77 K carrier concentration of 3.7 x 1016 cms3and mobility of 6.3 x lo4 cm2iVs were obtained for InSb layers grown on InSb substrates at 350°C.11421A recent study has shown that the most promising Sb source appears to be tertiarybutyldimethylantimony. Even at temperatures below 400°C, very low V/III ratios were acceptable, and a high growth efficiency indicated negligible parasitic reactions between the In and Sb precursors.llUl Another approach for low temperature growth was recently described. The Sb precursor triethylantimonide (TESb) was precracked in a dc plasma.l145l Growth of InSb and GaSb was performed at 20 mbar on
MOCKS
of Compound Semiconductor
Layers
63
GaAs and GaSb substrates, respectively; the plasma power was 10 W. The results indicated that at low temperatures (below SOOOC),growth of InSb is limited by the stability of the Sb precursor. For example, at 450°C, an enhancement of the InSb growth rate by about a factor of two could be achieved applying a dc plasma; best electrical data (300 K) were 2 x lOi crnv3 and 35,000 cm2/Vs for electron concentration and Hall mobility, respectively, compared to 7 x 1017cm-3 and 2000 cm2/Vs, respectively, for growth without plasma. For growth of GaSb with trimethylgallium (TMG) and TESb, additional TESb-precracking did not affect the growth kinetics; therefore, it was concluded that the thermal stability of TMG limits the GaSb growth rate. When substituting TMG by the less stable triethylgallium (TEG), a strong enhancement of the growth rate was detected, and an additional effect of TESb-precracking on the growth kinetics of GaSb could clearly be observed at growth temperatures below 53OOC. A further improvement of the electrical quality of the layers, however, was not found. Several donors have been investigated in I&b. As revealed by secondary ion mass spectrometry, with tin as the n-type dopant, sharp dopant profiles could be achieved. These SIMS results and the improved current-voltage characteristics of InSb diodes indicate that tin is a much better dopant than Te or Se. 1146l In another investigation, w,h’b4Sb/ GaSb p-n homojunctions on GaSb substrates exhibited an external quantum efficiency of 43 % at 2.6 pm, and a long wavelength cutoff up to 2.9 pm was measured. These results are the highest quantum efficiency and wavelength cutoff yet reported for GaInSb photodiodes in this wavelength range.l147l Long wavelength photodiodes were also fabricated using a p-n junction embedded in an InAs,,SbJInSb strained-layer superlattice (SLS), where a composition-graded InAs,,Sb, layer acted as a strain-relief buffer between the SLS and the p+-InSb substrate. The detectors displayed broad spectral response extending to wavelengths of 10 um.l148l Because of the difficulties in epitaxial growth and processing of the II-VI compounds, the generally more developed III-V compounds may be preferred for narrow bandgap applications. Possibly with Sb-containing compounds, problems concerning large area uniformity and dopant control are easier to overcome than with II-VI compounds. 3.3
Wide Bandgap Materials
The development of wide bandgap materials has been stimulated by the demand for optical devices such as light-emitting diodes and laser diodes
64
Compound Semiconductors
operating in the green-blue-near-UV region. For this material, the main activities have been in II-VI compounds for several years already, similar to the work on narrow bandgap material. Additionally, GaN and related compounds have attracted much interest as wide bandgap material in the recent past. Therefore, in this section, the main efforts in both material systems are described. II-VI Compounds. A significant breakthrough in wide bandgap IIVI compounds was the fabrication of the first blue-green laser diodes in 199 1. An MBE-grown &Se-based single quantum well structure was chosen, and the devices emitted coherent light at a wavelength of 490 nm under pulsed current injection at 77 K.114glThis success was made possible after the difficult problem of growing p-type material with sufficiently high carrier concentrations had been overcome. This was accomplished by doping with nitrogen from an RF plasma source with N2 gas. In MOCVD of wide bandgap II-VI compound layers, similar problems of conductivity control exist. liislli5~lli5il Growth of ZnSe on GaAs substrates has been studied most extensively. With hydrogen selenide as precursor, premature reactions were observed. Therefore, zinc and selenium alkyls were used as precursors. 115*1Decomposition of these alkyles, however, requires relatively high growth temperatures, around 5OO”C, resulting in the formation of native defects. These defects act as acceptors such as Zn vacancies in ZnSe and ZnS or as donors such as Se and S vacancies in ZnSe and ZnS, respectively.t1501 In order to reduce this selfcompensation, the growth temperature should be reduced as low as possible. It has been shown that at temperatures as low as 350°C, photo-assisted growth of ZnSe is possible with 365 run light from a high-pressure mercury arc lamp. However, the surface morphology was reported to deteriorate with increasing irradiation intensity. 1153lThe growth rate at low temperatures in the range of 300 to 400°C can also be increased by using the abovebandgap irradiation of the 458-5 15 nm lines from an Ar laser.t1541As the precursors have absorption bands at wavelengths shorter than 250 nm, direct absorption by the source materials cannot be expected. The photoassisted process is, therefore, attributed to photocatalysis in which the growing material acts as a catalyst and promotes growth reactions. This technique appears to be promising for the reduction of compensating native defects and for achieving p-type doping control. From the results published in the literature, there appears to be no problem in controlling the carrier concentration in n-type layers over a wide range of lOi to lOi cm-3, if the growth temperature is lower than about
MOCVD of Compound Semiconductor
Layers
65
350°C. At higher temperatures, the self-compensation effect becomes dominant, resulting in lower free carrier concentrations.1150j1151j The results on p-type doping, however, indicate the necessity for more research. Croup V elements as acceptors have been extensively studied in the past. As the host material is grown under group VI rich conditions, the introduction of group V acceptors in the crystal lattice substituting on group VI sites has been diflicult to achieve. Therefore, lithium as shallow acceptor substituting on an Zn site has been proposed. With lithium nitride as the doping source for growth of p-type ZnSe at 450°C, the lowest resistivity of the layers was 0.2 Szcm at the highest carrier concentration of 9 x 10” cm-3.1155jFigure 10 shows the temperature dependence of the carrier concentration for two specific samples with lower and higher carrier concentrations. For the former sample, an activation energy of about 80 meV was estimated, whereas the temperature independence for the latter sample could be explained by the formation of a degenerate impurity band at such a high acceptor concentration.l155l In another study, secondary ion mass spectrometry on Lidoped ZnSe layers revealed that the Li concentration in the layers could be varied from 4 x 1016to 4 x 1017cmm3by a variation of the carrier gas through the tertiarybutyllithium source. The growth was performed at 500°C which resulted in the electrical activity of only 1% .1i5’jlThese results suggest that these ZnSe layers may contain a high concentration of compensation centers. In addition, it was suspected that part of the dopant atoms might not be incorporated on Zn sites, but probably on interstitial sites acting as compensating donors. 11571In Lidoped ZnS layers, the lowest resistivity was about 4 x 1O2Szcm, and the highest p-type carrier conccntration was 7.5 x 1015cmm3.As revealed by x-ray rocking curves, the crystal quality appears to be improved by lithium incorporation at an appropriate level suggesting a reduction of the dislocation density in the layers .[158lIn a recent study with the new Li precursor dimethylaminolithium, well defined p-n junctions were realized in ZnSe.t15gl With lithium nitride and triethylaluminum as p-type and, respectively, n-type dopants ZnSe p-n junctions for light-emitting diodes could be fabricated. An example of the ZnSe electroltiesccncc spectrum at room temperature is given in Fig. 11. It is composed of a blue emission band peaking at about 467 nm and a broad band located in the longer wavelength region.t1551 First lasing experiments in MOCVD grown structures were performed under optical pumping. The growth temperature of the ZnSe/ ZnSSe structure was held at 515°C; a ZnSe/ZnSSe superlattice grown directly on the GaAs substrate worked as an optical confinement layer and
66
Compound Semiconductors
helped smoothen the grown surface. The sample was excited with a N, pulsed laser at the wavelength of 337 run. A high output power of 24 W was observed at room temperature. At this power, an external quantum efficiency, defined by the ratio of the output photon flux to the input photon flux, of 1.5 % was obtained. An emission wavelength of 473 run was measured.l16ol A local restriction of the photoexcitation to the active ZnSe layer only resulted in a drastic decrease of the lasing threshold.[1611 Figure 12 shows that the lowest threshold was 10 kW/cm2 at room temperature, which is equivalent to a current density of 3.6 kA/cm2. The lasing wavelength at room temperature was about 470 run, and was observed through a monochromator in order to suppress the scattered excitation light. A characteristic temperature T,of 124 K was found, as measured up to 400 K. This is the lowest threshold yet reported on II-VI photopumped lasers at room temperature. These recent advances in MOCVD of wide bandgap IIVI materials demonstrate the potential of this growth technology, so that the realization of practical devices such as current injection lasers operating at room temperature seems to be within reach. TEMPERATURE (K I ~~~~
b
0 \
I
0
103/T
(K-l)
Figure 10. Temperature dependence of carrier concentration for Li doped ZnSe layers.[~5*] (Reprinted by permission of the publisher, American Institute of Physics.)
MOCKS
600
of Compound Semiconductor
550
WAVELENGTH 500
inm
Layers
67
1 450
RT
2.0
2.2 PHOTON
2.4 2.6 ENERGY (eVI
2.6
Figure 11. Electroluminescence spectrum at room temperature of a ZnSe p-n diode.[155] (Reprinted by permission of the publisher, American Institute of Physics.)
Excitation Power (kW/crn*) Figure 12. Light output vs excitation optical power characteristics measured on a device with a cavity length of L,= 200 pm in the temperature range of 300 to 400 K. The excitation was at a wavelength of 450 nm.[ ‘6’1 (Reprinted by permission of the publisher, American Institute of Physics.)
68
Compound Semiconductors GaN and Related Compounds.
As mentioned above, the majority of the efforts for blue/UV lasers is still concentrated on ZnSe and its alloys, nevertheless, recent improvements in MOCVD growth in the material system (Al,Ga,In)N have demonstrated the potential of this material for optical devices.t1621This material system is of considerable interest, as the direct bandgap can be tuned from 2 to 6.2 eV. A major problem is the selection of an appropriate substrate; sapphire has been used most widely. The lattice mismatch, however, is as large as 22 % to InN, 14 % to GaN and 12 % to AlN.11621Another problem is the extremely high equilibrium vapor pressure of the group V elements at growth temperature, making Incontaining compounds the most difficult to grow in this material system. In addition, the high stability of the standard nitrogen source, ammonia, may lead to high growth temperatures and high V/III ratios. These problems have been attacked by introducing additional buffer layers, by growing on a lattice matched substrate, by applying hydrazine instead of ammonia as the nitrogen source, and by using excitation techniques such as an electron cyclotron resonance plasnn~l~~~l-[~~~l GaN grown directly on sapphire exhibits poor crystal quality, as expected, from the large lattice mismatch and the chemical dissimilarity between both materials. Introduction of a thin AlN buffer layer led to a significant improvement in crystal quality. The key growth parameters for high quality GaN layers were the growth temperature and thickness of the AlN layer as well as the growth temperature of the GaN layer; the growth temperature of the buffer layer had to be kept below llOO”C, and the thickness below 150 nm in order to avoid polycrystalline growth.11661[1671 Another approach for optimizing GaN growth on sapphire has been the insertion of a 20 run thick GaN buffer layer grown between 450 and 600°C and subsequent growth of the 2 pm thick GaN layer between 1000 and 1030°C resulting in better crystal quality than without a buffer layer.11681 With this technique, a maximum mobility of 3000 cm2/Vs was obtained at 70 K indicating the low impurity concentration in these layers.[1691This is the highest mobility value reported for GaN films so far. The first successful growth of InN was achieved by using low growth temperatures (550-600°C) and very high V/III ratios (above 16,000). The composition in the material system (Ga,In)N from GaN to InN could be controlled by adjusting the flow rates of the gallium and indium precursors, triethylgallium and trimethylindium, respectively.11701The growth of GaInN lattice matched to a substrate was recently accomplished by utilizing a ZnO single crystal wafer and an In content of 22% in the ternary layer.l”j31 The
MOCVD of Compound Semiconductor
Layers
69
FWHM values of the x-ray rocking curves of these layers on ZnO were about 20% smaller than that on the standard sapphire substrates. In all cases, however, the FWHM values were still quite large (about 50 min) compared to the FWHM values of the standard III-V compound layers in the GaAs and InP based material systems, suggesting that a careful optimization of the surface treatment of the ZnO substrates and the growth conditions is still required.11631These ZnO substrates are not yet commercially available. The next step then was quite recently the first growth of a quaternary alloy AlGaInN on a sapphire substrate at 800°C. It was possible to measure an optical transmission of the 0.2 urn thick AJ,74G~.231n,,,,-,3N layer.l163l Due to the high group V equilibrium vapor pressure, conductivity control is expected to be difficult to achieve in this material system. With SiH, as the dopant precursor, electron concentrations of 5 x 101*cms3have been reached in GaN.li7il Conductivity of the p-type, however, appeared to be a much larger problem. The resistivity of Mgdoped GaN layers has been found to be reduced by after-growth treatments. With low-energy electronbeam irradiation (LEEBI), the high resistivity of the as-grown layers was markedly decreased; a value as low as 0.2 !A cm was measured at room temperature, the hole concentration was 3 x 1018cm-3.11721 This resistivity value is the lowest and the carrier concentration is the highest reported for ptype GaN layers up to now. Thermal annealing of Mgdoped GaN at temperatures above 700°C resulted in a carrier concentration of 3 x 10” cmm3;the resistivity was 2 Sz cm, whereas before this heat treatment, values around lo6 n cm were measured .lI731 It should be mentioned that in both studies 1172111731 similar GaN buffer layers were used. With the LEEBI technique, however, only thin regions below the surface are affected so that, for obtaining larger p-type regions, the annealing technique may be preferred.1162111731 It appears that GaN layers grown with GaN buffer layers are superior to those grown with AlN buffer layers in terms of crystal quality and p-type conductivity control. After this success in conductivity control, p-n junctions in GaN were fabricated. In light-emitting diodes (LEDs) with a GaN buffer, a forward voltage as low as 4 V at a forward current of 20 mA was measured.l171l The schematic of the structure and the typical I-V characteristics of this p-n junction GaN LED are shown in Fig. 13. This is the lowest value of the forward voltage reported for GaN LEDs up to now, and was made possible by the significant reduction of the resistivity (0.2 Sz cm) in the p-type GaN layer.l172lThe output power ofthese GaN LEDs was almost 10 times higher
70
Compound Semiconductors
than that of commercially available SIC LEDs in the range of forward currents between 1 and 4 mA. For example, at 4 mA, the output power of GaN LEDs was 20 pW compared to 2 pW of Sic LEDs; at 20 mA, the output power of GaN LEDs was 42 pW and that of SIC LEDs was 7 pW. A peak wavelength of 430 nm was measured for the GaN LEDs.[1711 Besides this emission peak in the blue region, an additional peak in the W region (366 MI) was observed at low forward currents (below 30 mA) in GaN LEDs with an AIN buffer.[ 1741 This difference in emission spectra might be attributed to the difference in buffer layers, resulting in a lower electrical activation in the case of an AlN buffer layer.[1711
a)
P-Elcctmde
Sapphire Substrate
b)
Figure 13. (a) Structure of a p-n junction GaN LED; (b) typical I-V characteristics of the p-n junction GaN LED.[“‘] (Reprinted by permission of the publisher, Japanese Journal of Applied Physics.)
MOCKS
of Compound Semiconductor
Layers
71
The first observation of room temperature stimulated emission near UV from MOCVD grown GaN on sapphire with an AlN buffer layer was reported in 1990.f 1751 The sample was excited by a pulsed N, laser at a wavelength of 337.1 nm. The threshold for stimulated emission was determined as approximately 0.7 MW/cm*, the emission wavelength was around 373 nm, as shown in Fig. 14, where the emission spectra are plotted with the excitation power as parameter. Whereas in this study, long cavities (2.15 mm) were used and edge emission was measured, in another study, vertical-cavity stimulated emission (i.e., surface emission) from 1.5 urn thick GaN cavities was described; in spite of the large differences in the cavity lengths (1.5 pm and 2 mm, respectively), nearly identical thresholds for vertical and edge emission geometries were obtained.[1761 The near-UV emission line (around 375 mn) shifted to longer wavelengths with increasing pump power, probably due to a heating of the sample at high pump power densities.
Laser
WAVELENGTH
‘9x:.’
W/cm2
( nm>
Figure 14. Emission spectra at room temperature from a GaN layer grown on sapphire with an AIN buffer layer. The sample was excited with different power densities from an N, laser.[17s] (Reprinted by permission of the publisher, Japanese Journal of Applied Physics.)
72
Compound Semiconductors
Besides optical devices, the wide bandgap III-V compounds may find applications in electronic devices. Very recently the first observation of the presence of a two-dimensional electron gas (2DEG) in a wide bandgap GaN/Al,Ga,_a heterojunction was reported.l177l A 2DEG mobility of 834 cm2/Vs was measured in a GaN/Al,,#a,,s7N heterostructure at room temperature. The 2DEG mobility monotonically increased with decreasing temperature and saturated at a value of 2626 cm2/Vs at 77 K; it remained nearly constant for temperatures ranging from 77 to 4.2 K. The twodimensional electron gas was confirmed by the quantum Hall effect. For aluminum compositions in excess of 13 %, however, the peak mobility decreased with increasing aluminum content. These results clearly show the significant progress in MOCVD of wide bandgap III-V compound layers in recent years. The potential of GaN for the realization of carrier injection W laser diodes can be recognized.
4.0
SUMMARY AND FUTURE DIRECTIONS
In the preceding paragraphs, the application of the MOCVD technology to growth of compound semiconductor device structures has been described revealing the tremendous progress that has been made in this growth technology during the last years. Several device applications have been addressed as significant breakthroughs of this growth technology not only for GaAs and InP based materials but also for narrow and wide bandgap compound layers. In GaAs and InP based material systems, excellent uniformity of layer thickness and alloy composition combined with significant improvements in material and device properties make this technology a suitable candidate for commercialization. Besides applications in high speed electronics and long wavelength optical communication, a large commercial market can be recognized in the production of light-emitting diodes and laser diodes in the visible range (550-670 nm). For these applications, the AlGaInP alloys are gaining increasing importance, and for the production of these alloys, the MOCVD technology offers several advantages over other growth technologies. For the growth of the more complex narrow and wide bandgap materials, MOCVD technology has already opened the path to the development of new compound semiconductors, such as AlGaInN, for example. For these III-V and II-VI compounds, both conductivity control and uniformity control over larger substrate areas have been discussed as major
MOWD of Compound Semiconductor Layers
73
challenges and have successfully been attacked already. Sb-containing compounds have been described as a promising III-V alternative to narrow bandgap II-VI compounds. Several examples of device applications have been given in order to demonstrate the powerful potential of this growth technology for growth of these compounds. Based on recent advances in wide bandgap materials, for example, a blue injection current laser fabricated by MOCVD seems to be within reach. In the future, for further development of the MOCVD technology a better basic understanding of the growth process has to be accomplished. This will not only help to improve the material quality in standard multilayer structures but will also be beneficial for the design of new growth precursors. Especially the last years have brought impressive developments in improved and in new precursors, for example, for Al-containing compounds, and also for the future further advances are to be expected. Low temperature growth will be a key issue in order to minimize defect generation in narrow and wide bandgap materials; here, new precursors may also play an important role. Besides these developments in new precursors, new substrate materials have to be explored especially for growth of both narrow and wide bandgap compound layers. After the achievement of excellent thickness and composition control in the vertical direction in GaAs and InP based compounds, the next step now is to obtain this control in the lateral direction for the fabrication of advanced integrated devices. Selective area epitaxy (WE) will gain further importance for the fabrication of monolithically integrated circuits both in GaAs and InP based systems. The results of the last years are quite encouraging already, and significant improvements are to be expected for the future. The development of group III precursors with comparable stability should lead to improved composition uniformity in SAE of ternary and quaternary layers. In another approach, the combination of MOCVD with the closely related growth technology MOMBE may help to solve many problems in SAE. Integrated MOCVD and MOMBE growth technologies may be conceived for realizing advanced integrated devices. The versatility of the MOCVD technology can also be recognized in the advances in depositing superconducting materials, where superconducting transition temperatures above liquid nitrogen temperature have been measured in MOCVD films already. [17*1A combination of MOCVD of superconducting films with MOCVD of standard semiconductor layers shows great promise for modem device applications.
74
Compound Semiconductors
The examples described in this chapter clearly reveal the impressive advances in MOCVD technology for a wide range of compound semiconductor layers from narrow to wide bandgap materials (0.1 to 6 eV) in the last years. For several years, this technology had to duplicate results obtained by the well-developed LPE technology, not only for III-V, but also for II-VI compounds. MOCVD material and devices have proven to be equal or superior to LPE material and devices. Besides the well known advantages of thickness control and uniformity control, MOCVD has been used to grow semiconductor layers which are impossible to grow with LPE like AlGaInP or metastable compounds. In the future, the interaction with the related growth technology MOMBE should be very fruitful in terms of exploring new precursors and developing new techniques such as SAE. It is obvious that MOCVD technology plays a key role in device production today, and it will also have a significant impact on the development of advanced device concepts in the future.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT The author would like to acknowledge the contributions of H. Heinecke, M. Druminski, T. F. Kuech, H. Baumeister, and J. Rieger in stimulating discussions and experimental collaborations.
REFERENCES 1. Didchenko, R., Alix, J. E., Toeniskoetter, R. H., J. Inorg. Nucl. Chem., 14:35-37 (1960) 2. Harrison, B. C., Tompkins, E. H., Inorg. Chem., 1:951-953 (1962) 3. Manasevit, H. M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 12:156-159 (1968) 4. Manasevit, H. M., J. Crystal Growth, 55:1-9 (1981) 5. Dapkus, P. D., Ann. Rev. Muter. Sci., 12:243-269
(1982)
6. Stringfellow, G. B., Organometallic Vapor-Phase EpitaxiaI Growth of IIIV Semiconductors, in: Semiconductors and Semimetals, (R. K. Willardson
and A. K. Beer, eds.), pp. 209-259 (1985) 7. I.udowise, M. J., J. Appl. Phys., 58:R31-R55 8. Kuech, T. F., Materials
Science Reports, 2( 1): l-50
M., The A4OCkD Challenge, Bristol and Philadelphia (1989)
9. Razeghi,
(1985) (1987)
(C. Hilsum, ed.), Adam Hilger,
MOCKS of Compound Semiconductor Layers
75
10. Stringfellow, G. B., Organometallic Vapor-Phase Epitaxy: Theory and Practice, (Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, eds.), Academic Press, San Diego (1989) 11. Veuhoff, E., Pletschen, W., Balk, P., Ltith, H., J. Crystal Growth, 55:3034 (1981) 12. Vodjdani, N., Lemarchand, A., Paradan, H., Journal de Physique, C5:339349 (1982) 13. Tsang, W. T., Appl. Phys. Lett., 45:1234-1236 (1984)
14. Heinecke, H., Mater. Sci. Eng., B9:83-91 (1991) 15. Tsang, W. T., J. Crystal Growth, 120:1-24 (1992) 16. Jensen, K. F., Fotiadis, D. I., Mountziaris, T. J., J. Crystal Growth, 107: l-
11 (1991) 17. Behet, M., Brauers, A., Balk, P., J. Crystal Growth, 107:209-214
(1991)
18. Dapkus, P. D., Maa, B. Y., Chen, Q., Jeon, W. G., Den Baars, S. P., J. Crystal Growth, 107:73-82 (1991) 19. Nakamura, F., Kawai, H., J. Crystal Growth, 93:292-300 20. Frijlink, P. M., J. Crystal Growth, 93:207-215
(1988)
(1988)
21. Schmitz, D., Strauch, G., Jilrgensen, H., Heyen, M., J. Crystal Growth, 107:188-191 (1991) 22. Schmitz, D., Lengeling, G., Strauch, G., Hergeth, J., Jtirgensen, H., J. Crystal Growth, 124:278-285 (1992) 23. Kondo, M., Okazaki, J., Sekiguchi, H., Tanahashi, T., Yamazaki, S., Nakajima, K., J. Crystal Growth, 115:231-235 (1991) 24. Abernathy, C. R., Jordan, A. S., Pearton, S. J., Hobson, W. S., Bohling, D. A., Muhr, G. T., Appl. Phys. Lett., 56:2654-2656 (1990) 25. Jones, A. C., Rushworth, S. A., J. Crystal Growth, 107:350(1991) 26. Kohzen, A., Tohmori, Y., Akatsu, Y., Kamada, H., J. Crystal Growth, 124:70-75 (1992) 27.
Scholz, F., Rudeloff, R., Henle, B., I%rle, V., Scheuble, E., Ttitken, T., Hangleiter, A., Pohl, L., Proc. 4th International Conference on InP and RelatedMaterials, Newport, RI., pp. 155-158 (April 1992)
28. Frigo, D., M., Van Mier, G. P. M., Gal, A. W., Wilkie, J. H., J. Crystal Growth, 124:99-105
(1992)
29. Gerrard, N. D., Smith, L. M., Jones, A. C., Bosnell, J. Crystal Growth, 121:500-506 (1992) 30.
Chen, C. H., Chiu, C. T., Stringfellow, G. B., J. Crystal Growth, 124:8892 (1992)
31. Stringfellow, G. B., J. Electron. Mater.,
17:327-335
(1988)
32. Lum, R. M., Klingert, J. K., J. Crystal Growth, 107:290-296
(1991)
76
Compound Semiconductors
33. Naitoh, M., Saga, T., Jimbo, T., Umeno, M., J. Cry&l Growth, 93:52-55 (1988) 34. Valdes, J. L., Cadet, G., Mitchell, J. W., J. Electrochem. Sot. 138:16541658 (1991) 35. Buckley, D. N., Seabury, C. W., Valdes, J. L., Cadet, G., Mitchell, J. W., DiGiuseppe, M. A., Smith, R C., Filipe, J. R C., Bylsma, R B., Chakrabarti, U. K., Wang, K.-W., Appl. Phys. Let& 57:1684-1686 (1990) 36. Burk, A. A., Jr., J. Crystal Growth, 1241232-249 (1992) 37. Kaufinann, L. M. F., Heuken, M., Tilders, R, Heime, K., Jtigensen, H., Heyen, M., J. Crystal Growth, 93:279-284 (1988) 38. Moerman, I., Coudenys, G., Demeester, P., Grantham, T., Crawley, J., Dual Chamber Active Charcoal Scrubber, IC-MOVPE-VI, Cambridge/ USA, June 1992, paper Pll. 39. Lum, R. M., Klingert, J. K., Dutt, B. V., J. CgMal Growth, 75:421-428 (1986) 40. Kuech, T. F., Veuhoff, E., Kuan, T. S., Deline, V., Potemski, R, JCrystul Growth, 77:257-271 (1986) 41. El Jani, B., Leroux, M., Grenet, J. C., Gibart, P., Journal de Physique, C5: 303-3 10 (1982) 42. Kuech, T. F., Veuhoff, E., J. Cryskzl Growth, 68: 148-156 (1984) 43. Lum, R. M., Klingert, J. K., Kisker, D. W., Abys, S. M., Stevie, F. A., J. Cystal Growth, 93: 120-126 (1988) 44. Kuech, T. F., Tischler, M. A., Wang, P. J., Scilla, G., Potemski, R., Cardone, F.,Appl. Phys. Lett., 53:1317-1319 (1988) 45. Tischler, M. A., Potemski, R M., Kuech, T. F., Cardone, F., Goorski, M. S., Scilla, G., J. Crystal Growth, 107: 268-273 (1991) 46. Cunningham, B. T., Guido, L. J., Baker, J. E., Major, J. S., Holonyak, N., Stillman, G. E., Appl. Phys. Lett. 55:687489(1989)
47. Cunningham, B. T., Baker, J. E., Stillman, G. E., Appl. Phys. Let& 56:836-838 (1990) 48. Kuech, T. F., Meyerson, B. S., Veuhoff, E., Appl. Phys. Let& 44:986-988 (1984) 49. Veuhoff, E.,Kuech, T. F., Meyerson,B. S.,J. Electrochem. Sot., 132:19581961 (1985) 50. Rose, B., Kazmierski, C., Robein, D., Gao, Y., J. Cry&z1 Growth, 94:762766 (1989) 51. Veuhoff, E., Baumeister, H., Treichler, R, J. Crystal Growth, 93:650-655 (1988) 52. Stockman, S. A., Hanson, A. W., Stillman, G. E., Appl. Phys. Let& 60:2903-2905 (1992)
MOCKS of Compound Semiconductor Layers
77
53. Pearton, S. J., Chakrabarti, U. K., Abernathy, C. R, Hobson, W. S., Appl.
Phys. Lett., 55:2014-2016 (1989) 54. l%rle, V., Rose, B., Robein, D., Gao, Y., Landsbeck, E., Scholz, F., J. Crystal Growth, 124:260-264 (1992) 55. Veuhoff, E., Baumeister, H., Brandt, O., Treichler, R., J. Crystal Growth, 105:353-358 (1990) 56. Glade, M., Hergeth, J., Griitzmacher, D., Masseli, K., Balk, P., J. Crystal Growth, log:449454 (1991) 57. Veuhoff, E., Baumeister, H., Rieger, J., Gorgel, M., Treichler, R., J. Electron. Mater., 20:1037-1041 (1991) 58. Harris, J. J., Clegg, J. B., Beall, R B., Castagne, J., Woddbridge, K., Roberts, C., J. Crystal Growth, 111:239-245 (1991) 59. Logan R. A., Tanbun-Ek, T., Sergent, A. M., J. Appl. Phys., 65:37233625 (1989) 60. Pinzone, C. J., Gerrard, N. D., Dupuis, R D., Ha, N. T., Lt.&man, H. S., J. Appl. Phys., 67:68236829 (1990) 61. Veuhoff, E., Rieger, J., Baumeister, H, Treichler, R, Proc. 4th International Conference on InP andRelatedMaterials, Newport, R.I., pp. 44-47 (April 1992) 62. Bhat, R., Caneau, C., Zah, C. E., Koza, M. A., Bonner, W. A., Hwang, D. M., Schwarz, S. A., Menocal, S. G., Favire, F. G., J. Cystal Growth, 107:772-778 (1991) 63. Bhat, R., Zah, C. E., Koza, M. A., Hwang, D. M. D., Favire, F. J., Pathak, B., Proc. 4th International Conference on InP and Related Materials, Newport, R.I., pp. 453-456 (April 1992) 64. Borchert, B., David, K., Stegmtiller, B., Gessner, R, Beschorner, M., Sacher, D., Franz, G., IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., 3:955-957 (1991) 65. Carr, N., Wood, A. K., Thompson, J., Maung, N., Ash, R. M., Moseley, A. J., Sci. Eng., B9:355-360 (1991) 66. Buchali, F., Scheffer, F., Heedt, C., Gyuro, I., Speier, P., Prost, W., Tegude, F. J., Proc. 4th International Conference on InP and Related Materials, Newport, R.I., pp. 534-537 (April 1992) 67. Roentgen, P., Heuberger, W., Bona, G. L., Unger, P., J. Crystal Growth, 107:724-730 (1991) 68. Griitzmacher, D., J. Crystal Growth, 107:520-530
(1991)
69. Davies, G. J., Duncan, W. J., Skevington, P. J., French, C. L., Foord, J. S., Mater. Sci. Eng., B9:93-100 (1991).
70. Duchemin, J. P., Bonnet, M., Koelsch, F., Huyghe, D., J. Crystal Growth, 45:181-186
(1978)
78 71.
Compound Semiconductors Heinecke, H., Brauers, A., Grafahrend, F., Plass, C., Ptitz, N., Werner, K., Weyers, M., Ltith, H., Balk, P., J. Crystal Growth, 77:303-309 (1986).
72. Kayser, O., J. Crystal Growth, 107:989-998 (1991). 73. Bhat, R, J. Crystal Growth, 120:362-369 (1992) 74. Kuech, T. F., J. CtystuI Growth, 115:52-60 (1991) 75. Azoulay, R., Dugrand, L., Appl. Whys. Lett., 58:128-130 (1991) 76. Korte, L., Thamrer, Ch., Huber, M., Hoyler, Ch., J. Crystal Growth, 124:220-226 (1992) 77. Nordell, N., Borglind, J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 61:22-24
(1992)
78. Heinecke, H., Veuhoff, E., Ptitz, N., Heyen, M., Balk, P., J. Electron. Muter., 13:815-830 (1981)
79. Veuhoff, E., Heinecke, H., Rieger, J., Baumeister, H., Schimpe, R., Prohl, S., Proc. 4th International Conference on InP and Related Materials, Newport, R.I., pp. 210-213 (April 1992) 80. Heinecke, H., Baur, B., Schimpe, R., Matz, R., Cremer, C. Hager, R., Miklis, A., J. Crystal Growth, 120:376-381 (1992) 81. Colas, E., Shahar, A., Soole, B. D., Tomlinson, W. J., Hayes, J. R., Caneau, C., Bhat, R., J. Cystal Growth 107:226-230 (1991) 82. Coudenys, G., Moerman, I., Zhu, Y., Van Daele, P., Demeester, P., Proc. 4th International
Conference
on InP and Related
Materials,
Newport,
R.I., pp. 202-205 (April 1992) 83. Joyner, C. H., Chandrasekhar, S., Sulhoff, J. W., Dentai, A. G., Extremely Large Band Gap Shifts for MQW Structures by Selective Epitaxy on SiO, Masked Substrates, IC-MOPVE-VI, Cambridge/USA, June 1992, paper PD6. 84. Finders, J., Geurts, J., Kohl, A., Weyers, M., Opitz, B., Kayser, O., Balk, P., J. Cgatul Growth, 107:151-155 (1991) 85. Caneau, C., Bhat, R., Frei, M. R., Chang, C. C., Deri, R. J., Koza, M. A., J. Crystal Growth, 124:243-248 (1992) 86. Nordell, N., Borglind, J., J. Crystal Growth, 114:92-98 (1991)
87. Buydens, L., Demeester, P., Van Ackere, M., Ackaert, A., Van Daele, P., J. ElectronMuter., 19:317-321 (1990) 88. Fukui, T., Saito, H., Kasu, M., Ando, S., J. Crystal Growth, 124:493-496 (1992) 89. Galeuchet, Y. D., Roentgen, P., Graf, V., J. Appl. Phys., 68:560-568 (1990) 90. Galeuchet, Y. D., Rothuizen, H., Roentgen, P., Appl. Phys. Letf., 58:24232425 (1991) 91. Bedair, S. M., Whisnant, J. K., Karam, N. H., GrifEs, D., El-Masry, N. A., Stadelmaier, H. H., J. @stul Growth, 77:229-234 (1986)
MOCKS
of Compound Semiconductor
Layers
79
92. Balk, P., Fischer, M., Grundmann, D., Ltlckerath, R, Ltith, H., Richter, W., J. Vacuum Sci. Technol., B5: 1453-1459 (1987) 93. Inoue, K., Recent Advances in InP Based HEMT/HBT Device Technology, Proc. 4th International Conference on InP andRelatedMatertals,
Newport,
R.I., USA, pp. lo-13 (April 1992) 94. Puetz, N., J. Crystal Growth, 107:806-821 (1991) 95. Komeno, J., Tanaka, H., Tomesakai, N., Itoh, H., Ohori, T., Takikawa, M., Suzuki, M., J. Crystal Growth, 105:30-34 (1990) 96. Ohori, T., Tomesakai, N., Suzuki, M., Kasai, K., Komeno, J., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 31:L826-L828 (1992) 97. Enoki, T., Arai, K., Kohzen, A., I&ii, Y., InGaAs/InP Double Channel HEMT on InP, Proc. 4th International Conference on InP and Related Materials, Newport, RI., pp. 14-17(April 1992) 98. Ng, G. I., Pavlidis, D., Kwon, Y., Brock, T., Davies, J. I., Clarke, G., Rees, P. K., 0.1 mm MOVPE Grown InAlAs/InGaAs HEMTs with above 150 GHz Operation Capability, Proc. 4th International Conference on InP and RelatedMaterials, Newport, R.I., pp. 18-21 (April 1992) 99. Thijs, P. J. A., Montie, E. A., Van Dongen, T., J. Cystal 107:731-740
Growth,
(1991)
100. Carr, N., Thompson, J., Wood, A. K., Ash, R. M., Robbins, D. J., Moseley, A. J., Reid, T., J. Crystal Growth, 124:723-729 (1992) 101. Evans, J. D., Makino, T., Puetz, N., Simmons, J. G., Thompson, D. A., IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., 4:299-301
(1992)
102. Grodzinski, P., Osinski, J. S., Zou, Y., Mathur, A., Dapkus, P. D., Proc. 4th International Conference on InP and Related Materials, Newport,
R.I., pp. 449-452 (April 1992) 103. Seltzer, C. P., Perrin, S. D. Tatham, M. C., Cooper, D. M., Electron. Lett., 28:63-65
(1992)
104. Li, G. P., Makino, T., Moore, R, Puetz, N., Electron. Lett., 28:1729-1727 (1992). 105.
Sugawara, H., Ishikawa, M., Hatakoshi, G., Appl. Phys. Lett., 58:10101012 (1991)
106. Fletcher, R. M., Kuo, C. P., Osentowski, T. D., Huang, K. H., Craford, M. G., J. Electron. Mater., 20: 1125-l 130 (1992)
107. Hashimoto, J., Katsuyama, T., Shinkai, J., Yoshida, Hayashi, H., Electron. Lett., 28:1329-1330
(1992)
108. Katsuyama, T., Yoshida, I., Hashimoto, J., Taniguchi, Y., Hayashi, H., J. Crystal Growth, 124:697-702
(1992)
109. Druminski, M., Gessner, R., Kappeler, F., Westermeier, H., Wolf, H.-D., Zschauer, K.-H., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 25:L17-L20 (1986)
80
Compound Semiconductors
110.Wolf, H.-D., Unger, R, private communication, (Sept.1992) 111. Schaus, H. E., Schaus, C. F., Sun, S., Raja, M. Y. A., Jacome-Torres, A., McInemey J. G., I&. Phys Con$ Ser., 106:749-745 (1989) 112. Coudenys, G., Moerman, I., Zhu, Y., Van Daele, P., Demeester, P., IEEE Photon. Technol. Lett., 4: 524-526 (1992) 113. Williams, P. J., Charles, P. M., Griftith, I., Considine, L., Carter, A. C., Electron. L&t., 26:142-143 (1990) 114. Rose, B., Remiens, D., Homung, V., Robein, D., J. Crystal 107:850-854 (1991)
Growth,
115.Soole, J. B. D., Schumacher, H., LeBlanc, H. P., Bhat, R, Koza, M. A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 56:1518-1520 (1990) 116. Renaud, J. C., Rondi, D., Hirtz, P., Blondeau, R., Maricot, S., Vilcot, J. P., Decoster, D., Proc. 4th International Conference on InP and Related Materials, Newport, R.I., pp. 78-81(April 1992) 117. Kate, T., Sasaki, T., Komatsu, K., Mito, I., Electron. (1992)
Lett., 28:153-154
118. Mullin, J. B., Cole-Hamilton, D. J., Irvine, S. J. C., Hails, J. E., Giess, J., Gough, J. S., J. Crystal Growth, lOl:l-13 (1990) 119. Triboulet, R, J. Crystal Growth, 107:59&604
(1991)
120. Bhat, I. B., J. Crystal Growth, 117:1-9 (1992) 121. Irvine, S.,J.,C., Mullin, J.,B., J. Crystal Growth, 55:107-115
(1981)
122. Tunnicliffe, J., Irvine, S. J. C., Dosser, 0. D., Mullin, J. B., J. Crystal Growth, 68:245-253 (1984) 123. Irvine, S. J. C., Mullin, J. B., Tunnicliffe, J., J. Crystal Growth, 68:188193 (1984) 124. Terada, T., Fuji& Y., Fujii, S., Iuchi, T., J. Crystal Growth, 117:54-57 (1992) 125. Hoke, W. E., Lemon&, P. J., Appl. Phys Lett., 48:1669-1671
(1986)
126. Takada, H., Murakami, T., Suita, M., Yasumura K., Endo, Y., Takahashi, K., Nunoshita, M., J. Crystal Growth, 117:44-48 (1992) 127. Ghandhi, S. K., Bhat, I. B., Fan%, H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 52:392-394 (1988) 128. Bevan, M. J., Doyle, N. J., Greggi, J., Snyder, D., J. Vat. Sci. Technol., A8: 1049-1053 (1990) 129. Murakami, S., Sakachi, Y., Nishino, H., Saito, T., Shinohara, K., Takigawa, H., J. Crystal Growth, 117:33-36 (1992) 130. Ghandhi, S. K., Taskar, N. R., Parat, K. K., Bhat, I. B., Appl. Phys. Lett., 57:252-254 (1990)
MOCVD of Compound Semiconductor Layers
81
131. Taskar, N. R., Bhat, I. B., Parat, K. K., Ghandhi, S. K., Scilla, G. J., J. Crystal Growth, 110:692-696 (1991) 132. Edwall, D. D., Chen, J.-S., Bubulac, L. O.,J. Vuc. Sci. Technol., B9:16911694 (1991) 133. Chemg, M. J., Jen, H. R., Larson, C. A., Stringfellow, G. B., Lundt, H., Taylor, P. C., J. Crystal Growth, 77:408-417 (1986) 134. Bougnot, G., Delannoy, F., Foucaran, A., Pascal, F., Roumanille, F., Grosse, P., Bougnot, J., J. Electrochem. Sot., 135:1783-1788 (1988) 135. Juan, F. S., Su, Y. K., Li, N. Y., Gan, K. J., J. Appl. Phys., 68:6383-6387 (1990) 136. Haywood, S. K., Mason, N. J., Walker, P. J., J. Crystal Growth, 93 56-61 (1988) 137. Biefeld, R M., Hebner, G. A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 57:1563-1565
(1990)
138. Gaskill, D. K., Stauf, G. T., Bottka, N., Appl. Phys. Lett., 58:1905-1907 (1991) 139. Bougnot, G., Delannoy, F., Pascal, F., Grosse, P., Giani, A., Kaoukab, J., Bougnot, J., Fourcade, R, Walker, P. J., Mason, N. J., Lambert, B., J. 0ystul Growth, 107:502-508 (1991) 140. Ma, K. Y., Fang, Z. M., Cohen, R. M., Stringfellow, G. B., J. Appl. Phys., 68:4586-4591 (1990) 141. Sugiura, O., Kameda, H., Shiina, K., Matsumura, M., J. Electron. Muter., 17:11-14 (1988) 142. Stauf, G. T., Gaskill, D. K., Bottka, N., Gedridge, R. W., Jr., Appl. Phys. Lett., 58:1311-1313 (1991) 143. Chen, C. H., Fang, Z. M., Stringfellow, G. B., Gedridge, RW., Jr., Appl. Phys. Lett., 58:2532-2534 (1991) 144. Chen, C. H., Stringfellow, G. B., Gordon, D. C., Brown, D. W., Vaartstra, B. A., Appl, Phys. Lett., 61:204-206 (1992) 145. Behet, M., Stoll, B., Brysch, W., Heime, K., J. Crystal Growth, 124:377382 (1992) 146. Biefeld, R. M., Wendt, J. R., Kurtz, S. R.,J. Crystal Growth, 107:836-839 (1991) 147. Pascal-Delannoy, F., Bougnot, J., Allogho, G. G., Giani, A., Gouskov, L., Bougnot, G., Electron. Lett., 28:531-532 (1992) 148. Kurtz, S. R., Dawson, L. R., Biefeld, R M., Fritz, I. J., Zipperian, T. E., IEEE Electron. Dev. Lett., 10:150-152 (1989) 149. Haase, M. A., Qiy J., DePuydt, J. M., Cheng, H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 59:1272-1274 (1991) 150. Kukimoto, H., J. Crystal Growth, 107:637-643 (1991) 151. Kukimoto, H., J. Crystal Growth, 101:953-957 (1990)
82
Compound Semiconductors
152. Mitsuhashi, 222 (1986)
H., Mitsuishi,
I., Kukimoto,
H., J. Crystal Growth, 77:219-
153. Yasuda, T., Koyama, Y., Wakitani, J., Yoshino, Appl. Phys. 28:L1628-L1630 (1989)
J., Kukimoto,
154. Fujita, Sz., Fujita, Sg., J. Crystal Growth, 117:67-74 155. Yasuda, (1988)
T., Mitsuishi,
I., Kukimoto,
H., Appl.
H., Jpn. J.
(1992)
Phys. Lett.,
5257-59
156. Mitsuhashi,H., Yahata, A., Uemoto, T., Kamata, A., Okajima, M., Hirahara, K., Beppu, T., J. Crystal Growth, 101:818-821 (1990) 157. Haase, M. A., DePuydt, 58:1173-1175 (1991) 158. Mitsuishi, Kukimoto,
J. M., Cheng, H., Potts, J. E., Appl. Phys. Lett.,
I., Shibatani, J., Kao, M.-H., Yamamoto, M., Yoshino, H., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 29:L733-L735 (1990)
159. Yanashima, K., Koyanagi, K., Ham, K., Yoshino, Crystal Growth, 124:616-619 (1992)
J., Kukimoto,
160. Nakanishi, K., Suemune, I., Fujii, Y., Kuroda, Y., Yamanishi, Appl. Phys., 3O:L1399-L1401 (1991) 161. Nakanishi, K., Suemune, Phys. Lett., 59:1401-1403 162. Matsuoka,
163. Matsuoka, T., Yoshimoto, 21:157-163 (1992) 164. Mizuta, M., Fujieda, Phys., 25:L945-L948 165. Zembutsu,
M., Appl.
(1992)
N., Sasaki, T., Katsui, A., J. Electron. Mater.,
S., Matsumoto, (1986)
Y., Kawamura,
T., Jpn. J. Appl.
S., Sasaki, T., J. Crystal Growth, 77:250-256
166. Amano, H., Sawaki, 48:353-355 (1986)
N., Akasaki,
167. Akasaki,I., Amano, H., Hiramatsu, 91:633-636 (1987)
I., Toyoda,
(1986)
Y., Appl.
Phys. Lett.,
K., Sawaki, N., Inst. Phys. Conf: Ser.,
168. Nakamura,
S., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 30: L1705-L1707
169. Nakamura,
S., Mukai, T., Senoh, M.,J. Appl. Phys., 71:5543-5549
(1991)
170. Matsuoka, T., Tanaka, 106:141-146 (1989)
H., Sasaki, T., Katsui,
171. Nakamura, S., Mukai, L2001(1991)
T., Senoh, M., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys.,
172. Nakamura, (1991)
H., J.
M., Jpn. J.
I., Fujii, Y., Kuroda, Y., Yamanishi, (1991)
T., J. Cgmtal Growth, 124:433-438
J.,
(1992)
A., Inst. Phys. ConjI Ser., 3O:L1998-
S., Senoh, M., Mukai, T., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 3O:L1708-1711
173. Nakamura, S., Mukai, 31:L139-142 (1992)
T., Senoh, M., Iwasa, N., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys.,
MOCKS
of Compound Semiconductor
Layers
83
174. Amano, H., Kitoh, M., Hiramatsu, K., Akasaki, I., Inst. Whys. Con$ Ser., 106:725-730 (1989) 175.
Amano, H., Asahi, T., Akasaki, I., Jpn. J. Appl. Whys., 29:L205-L206 (1990)
176. Khan, M. A., Olson, D. T., Van Hove, J. M., Kuznia, J. N., Appl. Whys. Let& 58:1515-1517 (1991) 177. Khan, M. A., Kuznia, J. N., Van Hove, J. M., Pan, N., Carter, J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 60:3027-3029 (1992) 178. Hirai, T., Yamane, H., J. Cg&zl Growth, 107:683491
(1991)
Molecular
Beam
Epitaxy
Kambiz Alavi
1.0
INTRODUCTION
1.1
Scope of Molecular Beam Epitaxy
Molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) is an ultrahigh vacuum (UHV) atomiclayer by atomic-layer crystal growth technique based on reaction of molecular or atomic beams with a heated crystalline substrate (Fig. 1). MBE is capable of producing extremely high purity and highly crystalline thin films with precise control over composition, doping, and interfaces in the fraction of nanometer range in the growth direction with precise lateral uniformity.111-1131 MBE is widely employed to grow semiconductor, metal, insulator, and ceramic thin films. The precision and control afforded by MBE has brought about remarkable advances in semiconductor thin film technology, by making possible creation of a wide variety of heterostructures with extremely abrupt composition and sharp interfaces, or precisely graded composition, as well as periodic superlattices with periods comparable to interatomic distances. Furthermore, MBE precision control and relatively low growth temperature also allows highly accurate donor and acceptor profiles in the growth direction, be it constant, graded, or planar down to an atomic layer (delta doping), or highly abrupt p-n junctions (Fig. 2).
84
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
Ultra High Vacuum Deposltion on Heated Monocrystalline Substrate
n.oopant
Gallium
Furnace
Figure
1.
Alummum
Precisely Controlled Temperatures and Shutters
Schematic diagram of geometry of molecular beam epitaxy.
85
86
Compound Semiconductors
\5
Substrate and Furnace Temperatures
Materials Flux Control + Surface Kinetics Control
Control of: Material Composltlon Doping Thickness Interfaces Crystal Quality
BAND-GAP ENGINEERING Abrupt or Graded Composition & Doping Homojunctions Heterostructures Planar Doping Multiple Quantum Wells Superlattices: Lattice-Matched Strained-Layer Chirped Doping
Figure 2. Block diagram of principles of MBE leading to bandgap engineering.
The remarkable degree of freedom in materials composition and doping profiles in the sub-nanometer range afforded by MBE directly translates into freedom to tailor bandgaps, electron and hole wavefunctions, effective masses, carrier density of states, and optical transition energies and optical density of states. Because of the fundamental properties of such microscopic and mesoscopic structures, especially prevalence of quantum
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
87
effects due to confinement of electrons, holes and photons, new physics and novel device concepts have emerged.[141-[221Examples of such quantum structures abound, including quantum wells, compositional or doping superlattices, graded composition or chirped superlattices, two-dimensional electron or hole gas, delta doping, and strained layer superlattices. These flexibilities in tailoring the microscopic properties of layered materials is referred to as bandgap engineering,[“1[241band structure engineering,t251wave function engineering,[261 or density of states engineering[271by various authors. An example of the degree of freedom afforded by MBE growth is incorporation of predetermined coherent strains, (compressional and/or tensile), which also leads to the modification of bandgap, effective mass, and the density of states especially in the valence bands.[211 This is achieved by growth of alternating layers with different lattice constants which are thin enough so as to leave the strains unrelaxed. The precision, control, flexibility, and simplicity of MBE, coupled with its ability of real time growth monitoring for understanding and optimization of growth process, has made MBE a powerful and popular technique in two respects: (i) significant improvements in standard semiconductor devices, (ii) enormous activity in conception and realization of a wide variety of novel electronic and optoelectronic devices with superior performance. The precise control of doping and compositional profile in the growth direction, together with reproducibility and lateral uniformity of *l% over a large area (demonstrated over 8 inch diameter platens for simultaneous growth on three 4-inch diameter wafers) has made MBE a technology for consumer electronics. New structures with new transport and optical properties have been achieved which are remarkably rich in physics, materials science, and technological properties and has made possible the realization of many new semiconductor high speed optoelectronic and electron devices and circuits .[281-[3 ll The many remarkable achievements of MBE range from extremely high speed or low noise transistors and integrated circuits, to extremely low threshold diode lasers and femtosecond optoelectronic switches, to the discovery of a new quantum fluid whose elementary excitations possess fractional fundamental charge. Applications range widely from lasers for CD players (3-5 million/month) and fiber-optics communications, to measurement of fundamental constants and resistance standards. MBE is truly a multifaceted and multidisciplinary endeavor fostering and benefiting from interaction among various branches of science and technology for its development and evolution, while contributing to science and technology by
88
Compound Semiconductors
allowing the control and freedom to create an endless variety of multilayer thin film crystals with tailorable properties. 1.2
Major Factors in the Initial Development of MBE
The term molecular beam describes a unidirectional kinematic flow of atoms or molecules with no collisions among them as opposed to a viscous fluid-like flow. The term epitaxy is composed of the Greek words epi meaning akin or upon, and taxis meaning arrangement or order. Epitaxy refers to ordered growth of one crystalline layer on another crystalline layer, with the same (or related) crystal arrangement. Consequently, a critical issue in MBE is the surface condition of the starting crystal (the substrate) and the subsequent layers as they are being grown. Molecular beam epitaxy is a form of vacuum evaporation technique, however it distinguishes itself from other evaporation crystal growth methods by its precise control of beam fluxes using collimated beams and rapid flux switching, more precise control of growth conditions, and the UHV environment which ensures high purity. Most importantly, it allows real time in-situ monitoring and control during the substrate preparation andfilm growth to ensure best conditions for stoichiometry and epitaxy. Excellent reviews of the prehistory and early history of MBE is given in the authoritative accounts by Cho and Arthurt and more recently by Cho.t13j An important feature of these references is that they describe the work that preceded MBE and articulate how MBE differs from the earlier evaporation techniques. There were two major factors in the initial development of molecular beam epitaxy. First was the application of in-situ real time surface analysis to the understanding and optimization of processes involved in the substrate preparation and epitaxial growth. Second was the conscious and sustained focus on applying and refining the MBE growth system and technique for successful realization of epitaxial heterostructures for various electronic and optoelectronic devices, which put a much more stringent requirement on the quality of the films beyond the question of stoichiometry and epitaxy. In late 196Os, Arthur at Bell Laboratories used a pulsed beam mass spectrometry technique to investigate the kinetics of reaction of collimated beams of As, and Ga on heated GaAs { 11 l} surfaces in IJHV.[~~] For T < 750 K, no Ga desorption was observed, with sticking coefficient of Ga being unity. Above 500 K, the sticking coefficient of As2, in contrast, was virtually zero unless excess Ga was present on the surface, in which case the sticking coefficient of As, was proportional to Ga coverage, increasing to
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
89
unity for full Ga coverage. Arthur concluded that the growth was kinetically controlled and stoichiometry could be achieved by providing sufficiently greater flux of As, to ensure that all the Ga reacted, with the excess As simply evaporating. 1331This observation formed the basis for epitaxial growth. Cho at Bell Laboratories used reflection high energy diffraction @HEED) in combination with collimated beams in UHV for the first time in 1969,1331and extensively thereafter, 1341-1371 to investigate the outermost layers of the substrate and the deposited films under different temperature and flux conditions. This was out of the conviction that in-situ real-time monitoring was critical for the establishment of proper epitaxial conditions to reproducibly grow good quality films, and that RHBED provided the ideal geometry for simultaneous growth and monitoring. Among his many important observations were oxide desorption from the substrate and subsequent surface reconstruction of the cleaned substrates, changes in surface structure and reconstruction as a function of substrate temperature and beam fluxes, changes of surface morphology and surface smoothing as a function of thickness of epilayer, and transition from polycrystalline to single crystalline for room-temperature-deposited films as a function of annealing time, temperature, and film thickness. Using systematic RHEED measurements, Cho established phase diagrams for transition from As-stabilized to Ga-stabilized surfaces as a function of V/III flux ratio and substrate temperature. Quite significantly he made the observation that certain properties of the deposited films depend significantly on the surface reconstruction during the growth.1381-13glCho observed the evolution of RHEED patterns from short spotty streaks to long narrow streaks as the growth proceeded. Pt-C replica of the surfaces at various stages of the growth showed that this corresponded to continued smoothing as the growth proceeds. 13’1 A step-growth model is consistent with these results since surface asperities would be excellent step sources. The term molecular beam epifaxy was used for the first time in 1970.1401Vigorous effort was soon spearheaded by Cho to apply and refine the MBE system and growth technique in the electronic and optoelectronic device arena. The major steps included successful incorporation of n- and p-type dopants in MBE GaAs,138113g1141j growth and optical evaluation of AlXGa,_.Js14011421 demonstrating optical absorption features that were as well defined as in LPE-grown samples, and growth of multilayer structures.14011431 These led to the first demonstration of an MBE-grown double heterostructure laser,144lvoltage varactor1451and IMPATT diode,1461all in
90
Compound Semiconductors
1974. In the early stage, MBE was employed to pursue optical and electronic devices based on quantum effects arising from confinement of electrons within dimensions comparable to the deBroglie wavelength. At IBM, superlattices were successfully grownt471[481 and resonant tunneling in double barriers observed.[4g1 Electron transport in a superlattice by Esaki and Chang of IBM,tSol and optical transitions in quantum wells by Dingle, Wiegmann and Henry of Bell Laboratoriest5il were reported in 1974. Further work on pulsed mass spectrometry techniquet521 and the elegant modulated beam mass spectrometry work of Foxon and Joyce and coworkers gave better understanding of the surface kinetic processes in the MBE growth.[531-1551 The important point is that to this date the original major factors, namely in-situ surface characterization and quest for improved and novel materials structures and devices, have remained the driving forces for the development and evolution of MBE. Significant contributions have come from many scientists and engineers internationally. 1.3
MBE Reference Material
Soon after the original work at Bell Laboratories, other research laboratories followed with important contributions. A number of articles from these various laboratories review the development and status of MBE prior to 1983 .t11-161 Two excellent books present a collection of chapters by various authorities providing pedagogical and comprehensive treatment of historical background, fundamental aspects of MBE growth, the technology of MBE systems, MBE growth and characterization of various materials systems and heterostructures, and application of MBE to devices and fundamental physics. t81tgl A more recent book with a large bibliography gives a comprehensive treatment of MBE, with special emphasis on three themes: MBE equipment, physics of growth, and characterization method~.[~~lA chronological account of principal achievements in MBE through 1983 appears in the appendix of the “Introduction” chapter of Ref. 9. A more detailed review appears in Ch. 17 of the same book.Isal A detailed bibliography has been compiled for III-V compound MBE.1571A comprehensive account of Si MBE and its application are presented in a recent two volume book which includes an extensive bibliography through 1985.1S81 More recent review chapters give an account of MBE technology with emphasis ongrowthmechanismandcharacterization ofIII-Vcompounds.tlol[lll
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
91
An annotated collection of key papers on molecular beam epitaxy spanning the last twenty-five years has been recently prepared by Cho where the criteria for selection was (i), they started a new area of research, and (ii) the sustained and successful work of the author aroused a large following.li31 Molecular beam epitaxy from materials science and thermodynamics point of view is presented by Tsao. Is91Invaluable information regarding progress in MBE growth, apparatus, materials characterization, novel physics, and device applications can be found in various volumes on proceedings of MBE workshops and international conferences,l5gl and NATO Advanced Science Institutes Series (Ser. B, and Ser. E) books.~s~~16~~1gl~25~~611-~631 In particular, Ref. 6 1 provides the latest information on the interface properties at the sub-nanometer (atomic) scale as related to growth conditions. A recent development in MBE is the use of gas sources to generate the beams. This is reviewed in a recent book.l64l 1.4
Synopsis
In this chapter, we highlight the important features of MBE, techniques for investigating the growth mechanism, system components, and their function with emphasis on in-situ real-time monitoring and control, growth mechanisms, growth procedures, ex-situ materials analysis, and the main ingredients which go into bandgap or band structure engineering. The emphasis is on the III-V compounds grown by conventional (elemental) MBE because of their technological importance and maturity of the understanding of growth issues. Brief discussions on other materials systems and variations of MBE are included.
2.0
IMPORTANT FEATURES OF MBE
Molecular beam epitaxy is unique in that it is a growth technique performed in UHV and is based on reaction of atomic and/or molecular beams with a crystalline surface relying on kinetic processes such as adsorption, desorption, dissociation, migration, reaction, and incorporation. These factors make MBE a highly controllable and versatile technique allowing the growth process itself to be probed, understood, and hence, optimized and controlled on a submonolayer scale.
92
Compound Semiconductors
2.1
UHV Environment
and Ultra-High Purity Source Material
The UHV environment ensures high purity and allows extremely clean surfaces. A 10mg torr pressure could be achieved in the early 1970s by incorporating liquid nitrogen cooled shrouds around the sources together with the UHV pumps. This is equivalent to about 10e3monolayer per second (ML/s) impingement rate of background gases at the substrate compared to 1 ML/s typical growth rates. Fortunately, most of background gases which act as contan&rants have a much smaller partial pressures and have sticking coefficients much less than unity. In modern MBE systems, base pressures of lo-lo to lo-” torr are normally achieved after bakeout. The residual gases are mainly Hz and N,, which are often benign, and a small amount of H,O, 02, CO, and CO, which are often contaminants, but have partial pressures as low as lo-r4 torr. Source materials used in conventional MBE are of extreme purity with contaminant concentrations of the order of few parts per billion. Extremely low impurity concentration in the low 1013cmm3in MBE GaAs have been reported by Chand et al.[65l Pfiffer et al. have achieved extremely high electron mobilities, in excess of lo7 cm2/Vs (below 1.5 K), in modulation-doped AlGaAs/GaAs structures grown by conventional MBE using elemental sources[661(Fig. 3). The GaAs impurity concentration is estimated to be less than 2 x 1013cmm3.This is the bigbest mobility in any materials system by any growth method. This can be attributed to extremely high purity solid sources, extreme care to achieve the best UHV environment with extensive cryopumping and bakeout, and the use of superlattice buffer layer, planar doping, and interrupted growth, all features accessible by MBE growth. With the typical growth rate of one monolayer per second (1 ML/s) and 2.83 A per ML, the 2 x 1013 ems3 impurity is equivalent to less than 6 x 1O5impurity atoms per cm2 per second sticking on the growing surface. The sheet atomic density on GaAs (001) surface is 6.25 x 1014per cm2. This means that it takes about log seconds for one monolayer of contaminants to stick to the surface of the clean substrate. Impurity levels of no more than a few times 1014crnm3can be achieved routinely with a reasonable amount of care in conventional MBE. The bigb purity is important not only for optical and electrical properties of the films but also from crystal growth point of view since surface contamination has adverse effects on the growth process itself and on the resultant morphology.
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
93
(4
D.2
0.5
I
2
5
10 20
Tcmpcmturc
SO IO0
f(K)
2 DIMENSIONAL
Cr OOPEO
GaAs
SUBSTRATE
Fire 3. An example of achievement in elemental source MBE, as exempliIkd by high mobility two-dimensional electron gas obtained at the interface of selectively doped GaAs/AlGaAs heterostructures: (a) mobility vs. temperature over the years by various authors (open circles), (b) epitaxial structure corresponding to highest mobility obtained. (Figures a and 6 are adapted from Ref. 66.) It is interesting to note that in more than one instant experimental results exceeded those predicted by theory at the time, necessitating revisions of the theory.
94
Compound Semiconductors
2.2
In-Situ Real-Time Monitoring and Control on a Sub-Monolayer Scale
The UHV growth environment allows installation of surface analytic instrnments directly in the growth chamber. This can be utilized in two crucial ways: first, to examine and optimally prepare the substrate before the growth, and second, to monitor and control the growth process on a submonolayer scale in real time as a function of beam fluxes, flux interruptions, substrate temperature, thickness, annealing, and the underlying surface composition and condition. The growth is kinetically controlled and proceeds at a slow rate (typically 1 ML/s). This leads to the understanding and real time control of epitaxial growth mechanism, growth rate, composition, and epilayer and interface morphology. This is an extremely significant advantage of the MBE. In the following, we list the most important of these UHV in-situ techniques and their role in monitoring and control of the MBE process, with the details deferred to Sets. 5-8. 1. Modulated beam mass spectrometry (MBA@) is used for identification of desorbed species, desorption rate, sticking coefficients, order of chemical reactions, thermal accommodation coefficients, surface lifetimes, and surface binding energies. W1Wl~WlWl This technique is somewhat elaborate and specialized and is not used on a routine basis. (See Sec. 6.1.) 2. Desorption mass spectroscopy can be used routinely during the growth to monitor desorbed species and can be used to monitor and control growth rate and composition in a closed loop feedback system even with substrate rotation.[681-[711 (See Sec. 6.2.) 3. Reflection high energy electron diffraction @HEED) is used for observation of oxide desorption, surface reconstruction, surface coverage, establishment of phase diagram, observation of surface steps, domains, disorder, surface smoothing, and effects associated with surface rnisorientation.[331-[361[721-[751 (See Sec. 5 .) 4. RHEED intensity oscillations are used for the observation of the time evolution of growth of each monolayer, roughening and smoothing during monolayer growth, surface mobility of adsorbed atoms and molecules, and growth mechanism and kinetics.[621[761-[861 (See Sec. 5.3.)
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
95
5. Auger electron spectroscopy is used for chemical identification of surface species especially at different stages of oxide desorption. This technique requires more elaborate arrangements and is not used routinely in every growth. However, it is a powerful technique for developing optimal surface preparation techniques for new substrate materials.1871+901(See Sec. 7.0.) 6. Scanning tunneling microscopy and atomic force spectroscopy are powerful novel techniques for atomistic observation and determination of surface reconstruction as a function of growth, surface preparation, and growth conditions.1881-1921 Surface mconsuuction has profound effects on dopant incorporation and optical and transport properties of epitaxial layers and interfaces. These elegant techniques are specialized and are not used in typical MBE studies/ growths. (See Sec. 5.2.) 7. Optical characterizations. These are powerful techniques for real time monitoring and control of substrate temperature, growth rate, composition, thickness, and surf&e morphology. Optical characterization equipment can be installed on viewports on the periphery of the growth chamber and either view the radiation from the substrate (pyrometry, pyrometric interferometry, IR transmission spectroscopy), or monitor the optical response of the wafer to an external light source (ellipsometry, reflectometry, interferometry, photoluminescence). (See Sec. 8.0.) 2.3
Important Features of the MBE Growth Mechanism
In addition to the extensive in-situ, real-time surface analysis techniques, theoretical investigations of the growth process have been pursued in two directions leading to better understanding of the growth process and doping and impurity incorporation. First are atomic scale modeling of surface processes during the growthl%l using Monte-Carlo simulations,18611g~lg81molecular dynamicslWl11ooland continuum equations of motion.l%l Second are thermodynamic investigations of the growth process and impuThese investigations are complerity and dopant incorporation. 15gl11011 mented by a variety of post-growth measurements which are categorized as
96
Compound Semiconductors
structural, electrical, and optical, which provide additional information on the various properties of the epilayers and their interfaces. These can be correlated with the growth conditions and the observation made during the growth using the in-situ real-time techniques. This has made MBE perhaps the best understood and controlled epitaxy method. A list of important features of MBE growth follows: 1. Epitaxial growth proceeds monolayer by monolayer in a two dimensional manner at relatively low growth rates, typically 0.1 to 1.5 ML/s. Step-growth or 2-D nucleation and islaudgrowth prevails over 3-D nucleation growth. Surface smoothing takes advantage of surface migration and incorporation at step edges. The sides of any nucleated island serve as new stepedges for the incorporation of newly arriving elements, leading to two dimensional growth. 2. Growth rate, composition, and doping concentration is determined mainly by arrival rate of different species in collimated beams and can be precisely controlled during the growth allowing precisely controlled, abrupt or graded composition and doping profile in the growth direction. 3. Use of growth interruption and relatively low temperature growth allows planar doping with extremely high sheet doping concentrations (Si = 1013crne2in GaAs). 4. Multilayer structures with smooth, abrupt, interfaces can be grown because:
near-ideal
a. The constituent atoms arrive at the surface as atomic or molecular beams without collision with other atoms or molecules, as opposed to viscous or diffusive flow. Growth proceeds by reaction of these species with the surface. Those that do not get incorporated leave the surface without interacting with the arriving beams and do not linger over the surface. Therefore, no stagnant layer is involved. b. Shutters can be opened and closed much faster (CO.1 set) than the time it takes to grow one monolayer (typically 1 set).
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
97
c. Normal substrate temperature is low enough that layer interdifision can be negligible (e.g., for GaAs, typical growth temperature is between 550-620°C). d. Growth mechanism is based on kinetic processes and is two dimensional. e. RHEED intensity oscillation monitoring during the growth, together with shutter sequencing, flux adjustment, and substrate temperature adjustment can be applied to ensure exact monolayer material deposition and incorporation. The above can also be used to ensures optimal surface migration and incorporation for surface smoothing on one monolayer scale (phase-locked epitaxy, migration enhanced epitaxy, atomic layer epitaxy). 5. For MBE growth of III-V compounds using elemental atomic or molecular beams, epitaxial growth can be achieved over a wide range of substrate temperatures. The growth rate and composition are independent of substrate temperature over a wide range and are determined solely by group III element fluxes (sticking coefficient near unity), provided sufficient group V flux is present. The incorporation of the group V element is self regulatory and ensures stoichiometry since the excess desorbs. For high substrate temperatures and for mixed group V compounds, this picture is somewhat modified. 2.4
In-Situ Processing and Lateral Patterning
Because of the beam nature of material delivery, removable proximity shadow masking can be performed to grow two dimensional patterns or buried structures. Growth on a crystalline substrates with amorphous dielectric patterns may also be area selective since nucleation and growth on the oxide region may be amorphous or extremely slow. In case of MOMBE (introduced below), a deposited mask may be chosen (such as Si or SiO,) which does not catalyze the decomposition of the metalorganic compounds, leading to no material deposition in that area.l64l Shadow masking can be utilized along with laterally selective growth for patterning. Since MBE is a UHV growth technique, it is natural to merge the growth of epitaxial
98
Compound Semiconductors
layers with UHV processing to allow the growth and fabrication of 3-D single devices, as well as integration of optoelectronic devices, all without breaking the vacuum. These processing techniques include metallization and plasma deposition and etching, as well as more complicated maskless writing by focused ion beams and implantations by focused ion beams. Techniques such as chemical beam assisted ion beam milling may be used to provide etched mirrors for lasers which can also be integrated through buffer chambers and interlocks to insure integrity of the UHV chambers during sample transport. 2.5
Variations on the Theme of MBE
As the success of MBE over the years became established, a number of variations on the original theme were employed to extend its applicability to new materials, or to simplify new aspects of the technique. The most basic and most common form of MBE uses elemental beams delivered from heated solid or liquid sources. This is variously referred to as conventional MBE, elemental MBE, condensed phase MBE, or simply MBE. Gas source MBE (GSMBE) is a generic name used when one or more of the beams are derived from a gas source. The simplest of GSMBE’s is hydride MBE, where As and P are derived from cracked ASH, and PH, at the source end and are delivered to the substrate as elemental dimeric or monomeric beams. In this sense, hydride MBE is very similar to conventional MBE except that the background pressure is higher. In metalorganic MBE (MOMBE) or Chemical Beam Epitaxy (CBE), the metallic elements are delivered to the substrate as volatile organometallic compounds, relying on the substrate thermal energy for decomposition and release of the metallic element. A variety of approaches are possible in this method, namely using metalorganits for some of the beams (e.g., for Ga and In), hydrides for others (e.g., ASH,), and elemental for yet others (e.g., Be for p-doping), or all fluxes can be from gas sources. The use of the word chemical in this conjunction is to emphasize that the constituents are delivered to the substrate in chemical beams and depend on surface chemical reactions to release the element before incorporation. It is important to emphasize that although the background pressure can be orders of magnitude higher in Gas Source MBE vs. conventional MBE, nevertheless, the material is delivered as collisionless kinematic beams, as opposed to the viscous flow in MOCVD.
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 3.0
99
MBE SYSTEM CONFIGURATION
MBE systems normally consist of three bakeable stainless steel UHV chambers: the load lock or entry/exit chamber, the growth chamber, and the buffer chamber which connects the two (Fig. 4). Other UHV chambers for analytic studies or processing can be connected in series or parallel via the buffer chamber. The various chambers are isolated from each other using UHV swing gate valves. The substrates are mounted on substrate blocks made of refractory metals such as molybdenum (MO) (Fig. 5) and are transferred from chamber to chamber using transfer rods, which are moved using magnetic coupling from outside, or wobble sticks using flexible bellows. Several substrate blocks could be installed on cassettes or trolleys or other multiwafer stations (Fig. 5).
Figure 4. Schematic drawing of an ME3E system (Varian Gen Il) showing load lock, preparation/analysis and growth chambers and vacuum control cabinet. Other electrical instrumentation and control cabinets and data acquisition/control and computer are not shown. (Courtey EPI.)
100
Figure
Compound
5.
Semiconductors
Wafer mounting
blocks and troUey.
Left block shows a 2 inch wafer (non-In
bonded, middle block contains an Mo plate for In bonding, inch diameter wafer, non-In bonded.
and right block contains a 3
(Courtesy EPI.)
The load lock or entry/exit chamber allows the introduction, pump down, preheating, and storage of substrates prior to growth, and their removal after the growth. The fore-pumping of the load lock is accomplished using liquid nitrogen sorption pumps and the vacuum is generated and maintained using closed cycle He cryopumps and/or ion pumps. The introduction of a load lock to the early MBE systemsgreatly improved the throughput and the purity of the growth chamber, since the load lock is the only chamber exposedto the atmosphereduring wafer loading and unloading. This leaves the growth chamber under UHV for extended periods of time, only to be openedoccasionally for source loading or repair . In modem MBE systems,a buffer chamberconnectsthe load lock and growth chamber to each other and to other processing and analysis chambers. This chamber is usually equipped with heaters for baking the substrates. In someMBE systems,this chamber also housessomeanalysis equipment, usually Auger electron spectroscopy for surface composition
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 101 analysis, and in this case, it is called the preparation/analysis chamber. Depth profiling could also be accomplished by sputtering in that chamber using Ar through a leak valve. Other chambers connected to the buffer chambers include those for metallization using ion beam sputtering, evaporation, focused ion beam for area selective deposition, reactive ion beam etching, chemical-assisted ion beam etching, or electron cyclotron resonance (ECR) plasma source for etching or deposition of dielectrics such as silicon nitride. The ECR can also be used for pre-cleaning the surface of the substrate prior to the growth. This method is much gentler and produces less heat on the substrate compared to sputtering, leaving the surface with much less damage. In some cases, two or more growth chambers are connected for the growth of incompatible materials system such as III-V and II-VI compounds with transition chambers equipped with proper buffering to prevent cross-doping of III-V elements with II or VI materials and vice versa. The swing gate seal is usually a high temperature elastomers such as Viton since gates with metal seals require higher maintenance. However, it is important that those seals that are used to secure the swing mechanism to the housing sleeve be metallic, since repeated baking of the system will eventually cause elastomer seals under compression to leak. 4.0
THE GROWTH CHAMBER COMPONENTS
The key components most commonly included in the MBE growth chamber are (see Fig. 6): 1. Vacuum pumping system to generate, maintain, and monitor an ultra high vacuum (UHV) environment. 2. Beam generators and controllers with fast shutters or valves capable of generating atomic or molecular beams with precisely controlled fluxes. These are arranged on a source flange and are aimed towards the substrate. 3. Substrate holder equipped with (a) heater and thermocouple to generate, maintain and monitor temperatures sufficient for epitaxy on atomically clean substrate, (b) continuous azimuthal rotation capability for lateral uniformity (since the beams arrive at different angles on the substrate), and (c) a manipulator to position the substrate to face towards the transfer or the growth position.
102 Compound Semiconductors 4. Ionization gauges for beam flux measurement and for background pressure monitoring. 5. In-situ characterization equipment for the real-time, in-situ monitoring, optimization, and control ofthe growth. Typically these include: (a) RHEED measurement system, and (b) quadrupole mass spectrometer for monitoring of leaks and contaminants or for mass spectrometry of desorbed species from the substrate at various stages of substrate preparation and growth 6. Optical viewports for installation of optical characterization equipment on the periphery of the growth chamber for realtime monitoring of the growth. Most common is an optical pyrometer used mainly for substrate temperature measurement. In the following subsections, details of items (l)-(4) are given. Sections 5-8 deal with items (5) and (6). LIQUID NITROGEN COOLED SHROUDS
HEED GUN
/
MAIN SHUTTER
?/I
EFFUSlOil CELL SHUTTERS
/=
FLUORESCEN? SCREEN
i/i TO VA&ABLE SPEED MOTOR ANDSUBSTRATE HEATER SUPPLY
Figure 6. Schematic of a typical MBE growth chamber (top view). AT&T Bell Laboratories.)
L6AD LOCK
(Courksy A. I’. Cho,
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 4.1
103
The UHV System
The growth chamber is the most critical element with the highest demand for UHV generation. In solid source MBE, the pumping of the growth chamber is accomplished by large capacity ion pumps and periodic Ti sublimation pumping. To achieve the best base pressure after the growth chamber is opened for source loading or maintenance, MBE systems are usually baked extensively at 180°C prior to growth. After the bakeout and cool down to room temperature, the pressure in the total system can reach as low as 2 x lo-” torr which is mostly Hz and often is benign. When high volume pumping is required in GSMBE (hydride, MOMBE or CBE), turbopumps, cryopumps, and even properly trapped diffusion pumps, are employed. For the majority of MBE systems, diffusion pumps are avoided. There are three regions in the growth chamber which have extensive cryoshrouds using liquid nitrogen or other coolants: the area surrounding each individual beam t$nace (when high temperature sources are used), the area surrounding the substrate station, and the area or the sump surrounding the Ti sublimation pump. The purpose of the cryoshrouds around the sources is to prevent excessive heating of the chamber, especially around the hot furnaces which can otherwise lead to thermal crosstalk and desorption of unwanted residual contaminant molecules. The cooling around the substrate is to condense residual gases, especially those desorbed by the substrate heater, and to provide heat dissipation. The combination of vacuum pumps and cryoshrouds keeps the partial pressure of contaminating gas molecules such as CO, CO,, and 0, or other oxygen-containing molecules below lo-l4 torr during the growth, even though the operating pressure of the growth chamber is much higher than the base pressure. For conventional solid source MBE, the base pressure is about 10mgtorr due to scattered beam species and excess group V flux. In CBE, it can be as high as 1O4torr due to the carrier gases and pyrolysis of the alkyls. Even at these pressures, the beam nature of molecules is preserved. In preparation for the growth, the cryoshrouds are normally filled with liquid nitrogen several hours before the furnace temperatures are raised. They are kept cold until the furnace temperatures are reduced after the completion of the growth. When liquid nitrogen costs are of no concern, it is preferred to continuously trap the shrouds and allow the furnaces to outgas at about 200°C below growth temperature while the growth chamber is idle overnight. This has several advantages: it helps the source material to outgas continuously; it prevents the adsorbed residual gases from desorbing
104
Compound Semiconductors
during the idle time; it saves time during the day for growth; and it avoids the risk of cracking PBN crucibles containing Al during repeated cycles from solid to liquid state. Al wets PBN and shrinks upon solidification, creating stresses high enough to crack the crucible. To avoid this, one must slowly raise and lower the Al crucible temperature while it is close to the melting temperature. Continuous trapping also allows overnight outgassing of the substrate and the substrate heater for reduction of residual impurity gasses. It is preferred that the liquid nitrogen be gravity fed in parallel to each shroud in the MBE growth chamber from a phase separator (open) reservoir above the growth chamber. It should be returned to the reservoir, through vacuum jacketed pipes. This ensures a steady flow of the liquid (containing no gas and with minimal turbulence) into each shroud, resulting in a constant low temperature on the shrouds. The return liquid/gas mixture is then phase-separated in the reservoir, and the liquid portion recycled. Temperature fluctuations in the shrouds are believed to cause sporadic release of adsorbed residual gases, which may compromise the epilayer purity. A less expensive alternative to LN, is the use of glycol/water mixture recirculated through a refrigeration station. However, water can in the long run cause corrosion of stainless steel and result in leaks. Some systems use water cooling in conjunction with liquid nitrogen around the hot furnaces or the substrate heating station. Beside the danger of corrosion, there is also a risk of water freezing in case the water pump fails while the liquid nitrogen is flowing. A burst can result in a water leak in the growth chamber. 4.2
Beam Generation
In its most basic form, the growth chamber of MBE consists of a UHV chamber fitted with several independent material sources which generate beams aimed towards a crystalline substrate mounted on a heated holder. There are generally two different types of beams leading to two somewhat different methods of material delivery to the substrate, and some differences in the details of the growth mechanism. The first type, which can be called physical beams, uses a physical transport (or deposition) technique, in which elemental atomic or molecular beams are generated from elemental sources or from polycrystalline or amorphous sources by local high temperature at the source (evaporation, sublimation, or decomposition). The second method of material delivery to the substrate is through use of chemical beams (chemical transport or deposition) in which
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
105
the element of interest is a part of a volatile chemical species delivered at lower temperatures to the substrate in a chemical beam (CBE or MOMBE). In both cases, the distance between the sources and the substrate is smaller than the mean free path of the material particles traveling towards the substrate to ensure collisionless beam nature of the material flux as opposed to viscous or diffusive flow. Those that leave the substrate surface do not interact with the arriving beams. The background pressure in the growth chamber during the growth is higher than the base pressure but is maintained sufficiently low to ensure these points. The beam fluxes are independently controlled with high precision and determine the composition, the growth rate, and the doping of the layers as they are grown. The beams can be turned on and off independently, using high speed shutters or mass flow controllers at the source end. Physical Beams. Physical beam delivery can be achieved by a number of means: (i) melting and evaporation of solid or liquid elements (e.g., Ga, Al, In, Sb, Hg) in crucibles heated by radiation from resistive heaters; (ii) sublimation of solid elemental material in crucibles heated by radiation from resistive heaters (e.g., As, or Si and Be for doping of III-V compounds); (iii) ion beam bombardment (e.g., Si, Ga, Al, refractory metals); (iv) direct current heating through the material acting as a resistor (Si, C dopants for III-V compounds); (v) high temperature cracking of elemental molecules (e.g., As, from cracking of As,); (vi) high temperature cracking of hydrides (e.g., obtain arsenic and phosphorus beams from high temperature cracking of ASH, and PH,; (vii) congruent or noncongment evaporation of binary material (e.g., GaAs, CdTe). Conventional Elemental Sources. In these sources, the beam generator is an effusion cell or oven, which is a compromise between Langmuir and Knudsen cells (Fig. 7). It consists of a furnace and a crucible containing the source material. The crucible is usually made of high purity pyrolytic boron nitride (PBN) usually conical (or trumpet) shaped, designed to give maximal uniformity profile beams at the substrate (usually 2, 3, or 4” diameter wafers located at a distance of about 10 to 20 cm). The metals used in the furnace are high purity, low reactivity, refractory metals. The furnace heaters, typically, are Ta wires going up and down in a cylinder which surrounds the crucible. Extensive Ta foil shields are used to reduce thermal leak to the surrounding. The insulators are mostly PBN in the hot region. The temperature of the crucible is usually measured using WiRe 5%-W/Re 26% junction thermocouples touching the bottom of the crucible with spring loading to ensure secure contact. The furnace is assembled on a
106
Compound Semiconductors
UHV conflat flange, with the power and thermocouple leads coming through the flange using ceramic isolators with metal to ceramic seals. Effusion cells are designed to withstand temperatures as high as 1400°C, with minimal outgassing of contaminants. For a knace with uniform heater winding, a negative temperature gradient towards the opening of the crucible is usually encountered due to the larger heat loss at the opening. In case of Ga, this can lead to the condensation of droplets near the lip of the crucible. Droplets can lead to flux variations and surface defects. In new furnace designs, this situation has been drastically reduced by either increasing the density of heater winding near the top of the crucible or by making two heater zones, independently controlled Both short term and long term temperature stability of the crucibles is of utmost importance for composition and growth rate control, and good MBE furnaces meet this requirement. Using high precision controllers, short term stability within 0. l°C and long term stability of better than a degree is achieved. In some cases, one can obtain elemental beams from evaporation of binary compounds. For example, in the early days of MBE, high fluxes of As, were generated by high temperature evaporation of GaAs in ovens of the type mentioned above. This beam was accompanied by a much smaller flux of Ga (-15%) due to noncongruent evaporation. A similar situation can also be achieved with CdTe.
Figure 7. Conventional high temperature effusion cell consisting of a furnace and a PBN crucible. (From ReJ 9.)
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
107
High Temperature Crackers. Arsenic and phosphorus sublime at low temperatures (<3OO”C) to produce a sufficiently large flux for normal MBE growth rates. The low temperature sublimation produces tetramers (As4 or P4) and negligible amount of dimers (As2 or Pz). However, since the vapor pressure is high at such low temperatures it is next to impossible to alter the arsenic or phosphorus fluxes or their ratios in an abrupt or even in a reasonably fast manner. There is also significant leakage around the conventional shutters when closed. These memory effects are a detriment to the growth of sharp interfaces or controlled compositions in the growth of the all-important III-V compound containing both As and P. In some applications involving As alone, it may be preferred to use dimers and not tetramers (see Sec. 6.1). This has prompted the use of high temperature crackers to resolve these problem in two different fashions as described below. Arsine andphosphine Crackers. As, and P, can be obtained by high temperature cracking of ASH, and PH, gases at high temperature (about 900°C, well above the substrate temperature).11021-[1051 These crackers are normally equipped with high precision mass flow controllers to obtain precise fluxes of As, or P, with precise flux ratios and with the capability to turn the beams on and off with negligible memory effect. Rapid switching is crucial for growing sharp interfaces in III-V compounds containing both As and P. In addition, ASH, and PH, ensure an inexhaustible source for arsenic and phosphorus. As a drawback, large quantities of H2 are generated in the growth chamber, raising the growth pressure to 1OS5torr which puts a large demand on the vacuum pumps. However, this pressure is sufficiently low to preserve the beam nature of the various species impinging on the substrate. The growth mechanism, thus, is identical to conventional MBE, and the growth rates do not appreciably depend on the substrate temperature. The presence of hydrogen is believed to help reduce undesirable contamination by oxygen and carbon in the epilayers. tio41 This approach does necessitate major precautionary measures for handling the extremely toxic hydrides. It is important to note that although the hydrides are considered chemical species, they are not volatile and the substrate temperature is not sufficient to crack them. As a result, cracking is accomplished at the source end and the group V elements are delivered as elemental beams. Therefore, one can argue that hydride source MBE is quite close to conventional MBE as far as the growth mechanism at the substrate is concerned.
108
Compound Semiconductors
Solid Source Valved Crackers. These crackers have evolved from earlier two zone furnaces consisting of low temperature sublimation and high temperature cracker zone (Fig. 8). The valved crackers consist of a large capacity low temperature sublimation cell containing pure As or P separated by a high precision needle valve from a high temperature high efficiency cracker zone which points towards the substrate (Fig. 9). The low and the high temperature regions are thermally isolated. The cracker can almost completely convert the tetramers to As, or P, and the needle valve is capable of fast and precise control and switching of Asz and P, fluxes (within 1 second). This attractive alternative has the advantage that no toxic gas handling is involved and no extra pumping is required since no hydrogen is generated. The approach is expected to gain in popularity as an extension of conventional MBE. Using such solid source valved crackers, rapid and precisely controllable arsenic flux switching and grading has been used in composition control of AlGaAs,r711and ~GaI_&.[1061 The details are presented in Sec. 6.2. Using solid source valved crackers, high quality and A~,&I,,~P~~~~I have been reported. Gao.Jno,,P and Aso.,Itb.,P,[ 1071[1081 Using two solid source valved crackers, GaJn,,5P/GaAs heterostructures,[l loI and strained InAsP/J.nPtl 111quantum wells have been demonstrated.
Figure 8. Conventional high temperature As cracker effusion cell consisting temperature sublimation and high temperature cracking zone. (From ReJ: 9.)
of a low
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
109
A Cracking Zone and Conductance Tube B Mounting Flange C
Bulk Evaporator
D Back flange
D
E Valve Actuator
Figure 9. Schematic
of a high capacity solid source valved cracker.
(Courtesy EPZ.)
Ion Beam Sources. An alternative method to high temperature evaporation or sublimation is the use of ion beams to locally heat a supply of elemental material to generate the require beams with sufficient flux. This is normally used in Si MBE. It has also been explored in MBE growth of IIIV compounds.11121 An advantage of this method is faster change of flux since the source material is heated locally and there is less thermal inertia. A disadvantage is possible accidental contamination of the chamber in case of failure of the beam directing mechanism. Conventional Dopant Sources. The conventional dopants are solid materials. For example, in III-V MBE Si is used for n-type and Be for ptype doping, both of which sublime at high temperatures. Since much smaller fluxes are needed compared to the constituent materials, the dopants are evaporated from smaller crucibles and smaller furnace are employed. This helps reduce the thermal load and gives better control for quicker ramping of the fluxes. Filament Dopant Sources. An alternative approach for evaporation of dopants from elemental sources is to use evaporation from filament sources by directly passing a current through the dopant filament. In this manner, a faster ramping of the dopant profile can be achieved since the filament has a small thermal mass compared to conventional furnaces. Carbon is an interesting alternative to Be for p-doping of III-V compounds since it has a smaller diffusion coefficient than Be and allows growth at higher substrate temperature without redistribution, and may lead to higher doping concentration. In conventional MBE, carbon doping from solid
110
Compound Semiconductors
sources is preferred to chemical sources. Evaporation of carbon from a solid carbon filament source for p-doping of GaAs compounds was pioneered by Malik et a1.t1131 The filament was S-shaped to accommodate thermal expansion of C and could be heated to 2500°C. Doping concentration as high as lO*Ocm3 was achieved. Experiments have shown that a reproducible doping concentration can be achieved using regulated power supplies.[~~31-[1151 & pi‘d ramping of several hundreds of degrees in ten seconds could be achieved.t114j The doping concentration could be changed from lo’* to 1O*Ocmm3by raising the filament temperature from 2 100 to 25OOOC.Doping limits of C and Si using resistive filament evaporation, and Be using conventional furnaces have been studied by Malik et al.t1161 Application of C doping to devices have been reported by Hoke et al., t1171Ito et al.,[118land Micovic et al.tligj Activated Doping Source (Free Radical Source). Until recently, the p-doping of wide bandgap II-VI compounds had been a difficult task. The problem has been solved by using plasma sources to generate atomic nitrogen and successfully dope ZnSe.t l*Ol The plasma generators are either RF discharge or compact electron cyclotron resonance plasma sources built specifically to be compatible with the MBE UHV environment. Shutters. Shutters are made of refractory, low reactivity metals to provide a means of abrupt beam interruption in conjunction with conventional sources. There are various designs and method of operation such as rotary or sliding activated by flexible feedthroughs or magnetic coupling. It is preferred that the shutters be angled so as to minimize the reflected heat radiation back into the crucible, to minimize a flux transient upon shutter opening (see, for example, Ch. 2 in Ref. 9). The shutter mechanisms using flexible bellows have a simpler design, but repeated use especially during growth of short period superlattices may eventually lead to weakening and leaks. This is not expected during the first several hundred thousand shutter operations. The magnetically coupled shutter mechanisms have a more complicated control mechanism to ensure proper acceleration and deceleration for proper shutter speed and timing, while avoiding mechanical shock to the growth chamber. Chemical Beams. There are certain advantages associated with the chemical beam deposition method involving organometallic species.[1211-t231 Organometallic gases such as alkyls may be supplied at near room temperature through high speed precision mass flow controllers, either as pure beams or using hydrogen as a carrier gas (Figs. 10 and 11). For III-V compounds, these are trimethyl (TM) and triethyl (TE) metals such as
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
111
TMGa, TMAl, TMIu, and TEAl, TEIn. Organometallic sources for group V include TEP, TMAs and TMSb. These can form individual beams or be combined together in one vapor beam perpendicular to the substrate. The latter allows excellent uniformity without substrate rotation. It is important to note that individual molecules are again delivered as beams, with no viscous flow or diffusion at the substrate. The dopants can be solid or also organometallic. One can see a variety of combinations of sources leading to several variation on the theme of MBE depending on whether all sources are organometallic gases, or some are supplied from solid sources or high temperature cracking of amine and phosphine. Associated with this, a number of different names have been used by various authors including Gas Source MBE, MOMBE, or CBE. In CBE, the growth process is more complex than in conventional MBE. The growth rate depends critically on the substrate temperature and group V to group III flux ratio. The composition in ternary and quaternary compounds also varies in a complex manner and is not simply related to binary growth rates. RHEED
GUN
LIOUID NITROGEN COOLED SHROUDS
+Hz
0
CONVENTIiNAL MBE OVEN
PRECISION ELECTRONIC FLOW METER 8
MASS
RHEED
I SCREEN
RESIDUAL GAS ANALYZER
VALVE
Figure 10. Schematic of a Gas Source h4BE (MOMBE or CBE) system (top view).[‘24]
112
Figure
Compound
11.
input lines.
4.3
A multiple
Semiconductors
input gas injector with
run/vent
high speed actuators with
four
(Courtesy EPI.)
The Substrate Holder
Another critical componentof the MBE system is the substrateholder (Fig. 12), which normally has the following componentsand capabilities: (i) a substrate mounting ring which holds the substrate block in place and is capable of continuous azimuthal rotation (CAR) to ensure lateral uniformity; (ii) a stationary resistive heater which consists of heater wires behind a PBN heat diffilser (for temperatureuniformity) radiating heat towards the substrate; (iii) a thermocouple which mayor may not be spring loaded dependingon whether the wafer is mounted on a Mo block with In or has no backing and is under direct radiation heating; (iv) a beam flux monitoring Bayard-Alpert ionization gauge in the opposite position of the substrate (directly behind the substrate heater), and (v) a manipulator v,rhich allows the substrate holder assembly to be oriented in different positions. In the loading or transfer position, the substrate faces away from the furnaces towards the transfer mechanism with the beam flux gauge in the growth
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
113
position facing the beam cells. In the growth position, this is reversed and the substrate faces the beams. Finally, the manipulator allows other positions in which the substrate may face up or down or in between. When the substrate is in the growth position, an electron beam generatedby the RHEED gun at one side of the growth chamber can be directed towards the substrate at a glancing angle (1-3°) and the specular and the diffracted beams can be intercepted and displayed by a phosphorus screen at the opposite side.
Figure PEN
12. Substrate holder, showing substrate mounting heat diffusion
throughs,
disk, CAR
and manipulator.
mechanism,
pins and springs, thermocouple,
thermocouple
and heater wires
and feed-
114 Compound Semiconductors 4.4
Ion Gauges: Measurement of Beam Flux, Growth Rate, and Composition
The flux of individual beams arriving at the substrate can be measured or inferred by swinging a Bayard-Alpert ion gauge into or near the substrate position. In this manner one can accurately measure the flux transient (if any), the steady state flux for constant cell temperature, or the evolution of the flux vs. time when the furnace temperature is varied to achieve graded compositions. The measurements obtained in this method are actually beam equivalent pressures (BEP). These can be converted to flux by obtaining the growth rate and composition on a number of epilayers which are grown for this purpose and calibrated ex-situ, or by direct in-situ measurements such as RHEED intensity oscillations. For each beam, a simple proportionality constant will relate the BEP to the flux Cp. This can be used to determine the total growth rate and percentages of different elements (i.e., the composition) using simple arithmetic. For example, in case of conventional and hydride MBE at substrate temperatures where Ga sticking coefficient is unity (T < 62O”C), the alloy composition parameter x in the growth of Al,Ga,_.@ is determined by
x=
Q(W @(Al)+ @(Ga)
or alternatively by X=
gw+=w
- l3ww
iW=W
where g stands for growth rate and 0 stands for flux. Also note that g(AlGaAs) = g(AlAs) + g(GaAs). For CBE, the relation between growth rate and composition of ternary or quaternary with the binary compounds is more complicated and does not obey the above simple relations. Currently, the RHEED intensity oscillations are used to more accurately measure the growth rates, as discussed in Sec. 5.2. 4.5
Crystal Thickness Monitor: Flux Measurement In Si MBE, often a standard quartz thickness monitor is used to
precisely measure the thickness of the Si deposited. In III-V MBE, a quartz
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 115 crystal can be used for measuring Ga and Al fluxes provided the pressure of volatile species such as As is negligible (As cell is turned off). The sensitivity is l-2 A and the quartz monitor needs to be changed for every 50-100 pm deposited material which is not too practical. 4.6
Substrate Temperature Measurement
Substrate heating plays a crucial role in MBE growth since it provides the energy for proper mobility of surface atoms at the growth interface to ensure that the growth proceeds epitaxially, and also has a direct influence on all the other kinetic processes. In chemical beam deposition, it also governs the pyrolysis of the chemical species, which can lead to several intermediate species, surface migration of these intermediates, complete dissociation, and finally incorporation. Substrate temperature measurement before and during the growth is an intricate task. The most common method has been to use a thermocouple which is spring loaded against, or imbedded in, the MO block. The MO block temperature is assumed to be a close representation of the temperature of the substrate mounted by In. For direct radiation heating of substrates with no In bonding, the thermocouple reading does not depend on contacting the substrate and is more reproducible. However, the thermocouple in this case is exposed to the radiation from the heater and reads a higher temperature than the actual substrate temperature. This can be calibrated to the actual temperature by other means such as optical pyrometry or optical absorption spectroscopy. Optical pyrometry and transmission spectroscopy are useful techniques for higher temperature measurements (>4OO”C). Below that, photohuninescence spectroscopy using external laser and detectors can be employed. Further details are given in Sec. 8.
5.0
REFLECTION HIGH ENERGY ELECTRON DIFFRACTION (RHEED)
In this technique, an electron gun at one end of the growth chamber produces a high energy collimated monoenergetic beam of electrons in the 3-50 keV range which is directed at a glancing angle (~1-3”) towards the wafer. The diffracted and the specularly reflected beams are intercepted and displayed by a fluorescent phosphorus screen at the opposite end of the chamber. Even though the electron energy is high, the normal component of
116
Compound Semiconductors
the energy for electron penetration into the solid is small (e.g., only 50 to 175 eV for normally applied 3-10 keV electrons at 1” incidence) because of the shallow angle of incidence. At this energy range, the probability of inelastic scattering is very high, therefore, mostly the electrons which are elastically scattered near the surface are able to escape without energy loss. This means that RHEED is sensitive only to the top few atomic layers on the surface, as is the case in low energy electron diffraction (LEED). One advantage of RHEED over LEED is that in RHEED the glancing angle geometry allows simultaneous molecular beam deposition and electron diffraction measurement. The deBroglie wavelength of the electron (with relativistic correction) is given by h = [ 15O/V(1 + 10” V)]” in A, where V is the accelerating voltage given in volts. For the above energy range, this varies from 0.22 to 0.05 A, which is much smaller than the monolayer distance of about 3 A and surface interatomic distance of about 4-5 A. This makes RHEED a very sensitive tool for probing the surface structure on the atomic scale both laterally and vertically. In diffraction of electrons from a 3-D crystal lattice, the ditiction pattern is obtained from the intersection of the reciprocal lattice points with the Ewald sphere. [71[1261The Ewald sphere is formed in the following manner: the head of the incident electron k-vector, h, is positioned at the reciprocal lattice point designated as the origin of reciprocal lattice space. The Ewald sphere is centered at the tail of k, and the radius is k,, = 27rlh. For example, for 5 keV electrons, the radius of the Ewald sphere is 36.4 A-’ and for 10 keV it is 5 1.6 A-l (much larger than for LEED). This is much larger than the reciprocal lattice spacing of the crystal. For example, for GaAs with a cubic lattice constant of 5.65 A, the reciprocal lattice is cubic and the spacing is 1.1 A-l. For a truly 2-D surface, the diffraction condition requires only that the projection of k,, - k,,, on the surface be equal to a 2-D reciprocal lattice spacing, where k, is the wave vector for the diffracted beam. This means that the diffraction condition is satisfied by the intersection of the Ewald sphere with rods emanating Corn the 2-D reciprocal lattice points above the surface, or so called reciprocal lattice rods (Fig. 13). Due to a small spread in the electron beam angle, the Ewald sphere is actually a thin shell, and due to thermal vibrations of surface atoms and imperfection in flatness of the surface, the reciprocal lattice rods are actually very thin cylinders. Therefore, the intersections will be elongated streaks. Note that this is exaggerated by the fact that the radius of the Ewald sphere is so large compared to the reciprocal lattice rod spacing. For a rectangular 2-D surfaces of unit cell
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
117
d, x d2 with the substrate oriented such that the grazing electron beam is perpendicular to the d, direction, the spacing D of these streaks on the phosphorus screen is related to the distance from the substrate L, by the relation D = 2hL/d,.
PLAN
EWALD
FLUOI
/SPHERE
SC
, (1;“‘(2.$ (l.$
(2&l)
t2.$1
l&l,
to331 (O&2) toi,
($2) $I)
$1
.
.
1
_---
_---
I
t2.01---(l.O)_(O.O)---
i.0)_ _
RECIPROCAL
.O)
____------
-------__
---_
---_
.O)
--.
(i
-
.O)
‘%%’
: :. ELEVATION
0.0) IllCaL
Figure 13. Schematic representation of RHEED diffraction geometry sowing reciprocal lattice rods and their intersection with the Ewald sphere, leading to streaks on the phosphorus screen.[g]
5.1
Surface Reconstruction:
General
A properly prepared crystalline substrate has a thin native oxide before introduction into the growth chamber. The corresponding diffraction pattern appearing on the RHEED screen is composed of one or more diffuse semicircles. As the oxide is removed by means such as thermal desorption, the underlying atomically clean surface emerges. An ideal surface (unreconstructed surface) is defined by clean termination of the lattice at a plane
118 Compound Semiconductors of chosen orientation by removal of all the atoms on the other side of this plane while leaving the atoms on the lattice side in their original, unchanged position.1125l In reality, this is not generally realized since the top atomic layer has lost its nearest and/or next-nearest neighbors above the surface. This leaves the topmost atoms with dangling bonds, which can result in distortion and/or rearrangement of the atoms at or near the surface. Surface reconstruction occurs to minimi ze the surface energy and to take care of the dangling bonds. This results in a new arrangement of atoms on a reconstructed surface with a new 2-D symmetry, according to substrate temperature, surface orientation, and background species impinging on the surface. As we recall, a 3-D crystal is comprised of a triperiodic lattice of points together with a basis made up of a specific arrangement of atoms which is repeated at each lattice point throughout the crystal. For example, for GaAs and InP crystals and related compounds, the 3-D lattice has a unit cell which is atbcecenteredcubeofsidea(wherea=5.653~forGaAsanda=5.869~ for InP), and the basis is a III-V pair separated by a&/4 and the orientation is along a body diagonal. Similarly, a 2-D crystal (e.g., a reconstructed surface) is made of a biperiodic or 2-D lattice, usually called a net whose 2D unit cell is usually called a unit mesh.[1261 The basis is again a specific arrangement of atoms repeated at each point of the net. The unit mesh of the reconstructed surface is larger than the corresponding unreconstructed unit mesh (unit mesh of the ideal surface). The surface reconstruction is then notated as (mxn)-RB where m and n indicate the ratio of the sides of the reconstructed unit mesh to that of the ideal unit mesh and 8 indicates the angle of rotation (in degrees) between the two meshes. 5.2
Surface Reconstruction:
GaAs
Cho was the first to use MBE to prepare GaAs surfaces prepared under well defined conditions and used RHEED to investigate reconstructions occurring on [ 11l] and (00 1) surfaces. The reconstruction was related to growth conditions and subsequent processing.1331-1401 Cho’s most fundamental work on surface structure of GaAs (001) face appeared in 1971t361 and 19761721where he performed experimental investigations of the surface reconstructions on GaAs (001) with respect to atomic-bond directions as a function of substrate temperature and As and Ga fluxes. The GaAs (00 1) is the most relevant surface for MBE, and surface reconstruction is extremely crucial to the epitaxial growth and properties of the epilayers. The ideal GaAs (001) surface has a (1 x 1) unit mesh along the [l lo] and [ 1701
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 119 directions (4.00 8, x 4.00 A), and a single As or a single Ga as its basis. To distinguish the [ 1101and [ 1lo] directions unambiguously, a thick sample of GaAs was oriented by x-ray diffraction and cut with dimensions 1.5 x 1 x 0.4 cm3 with the larger faces being parallel to (001 } and the side faces parallel to { 11I}. The end faces were {1 lo} cleavage planes. The determination of (111) and (111) planes was done by selective chemical etching which leaves the former shiny and the latter hazy. Once these two planes were determined, the exact faces of (001) and (OOi) were distinguished and on each face the [ liO] and [ 1lo] directions were distinguished (see Fig. 14). For an ideal As-terminated (001) surface, the dangling bonds of the top As atoms are in the (110) plane and the back bonds to Ga atoms (in the lower plane) are in the (110) plane. The reverse is true for the Asterminated (OOl> surface or a Ga-terminated ideal (001) surface. The sample was mounted in the MBE chamber with the (00 1) surface facing the beams. As
PO’1
iii01 -7
(Go]
Figure 14. Schematics of the arrangement of dangling bonds on (a) (00-l) and (b) (001) faces of GaAs before surface reconstruction.[72]
120
Compound Semiconductors
RHEED measurements at different azimuths revealed a number of surface reconstructions and the important symmetry structure of the reconstructed unit mesh was determined for each case. Reconstruction was observed to be dependent on the substrate temperature and arsenic pressure at the surface. The most important of these were (2 x 4) and c(2 x 8) reconstructions which were observed at lower substrate temperatures and/or higher As pressures (As-stabilized), and (4 x 2) and c(8 x 2) reconstructions which were observed at higher temperatures and/or lower As beam flux (Ga-stabilized) and are rotated 90” with respect to (2 x 4) and c(2 x 4) reconstructions. The surface coverage favoring As in the former case and Ga for the latter case was confirmed by in-situ Auger electron spectroscopy. Many transition structures were observed during the change in surface stoichiometry, such as (4 x 6), (6 x 6), (2 x 6), (3 x 6) (3 x 4), and (4 x 4). It should be pointed out that the original RHEED gun was capable of operating with up to 50 keV electrons making possible the distinction between these various reconstructions, especially (2 x 4) and c(2 x 8) reconstruction. Most current commercial MBE systems have RHEED guns which are limited to 10 keV and some reconstructions are not as clearly distinguishable. Figure 15 shows 15 keV RHEED patterns obtained for GaAs (O_Ol)c(2 x 8) (As-rich) and c(8 x 2) (Ga-rich) reconstructions for [ 1lo] and [ 1lo] azimuths, for the zeroth Laue zone. RHEED diffraction streak patterns along these two azimuths and in the zeroth Laue zone are indistinguishable for the (2 x 4) and the c(2 x 8) reconstructions, as discussed later in this section. Figure 16 shows the real space and reciprocal space unit meshes and their orientations obtained by Cho from his RHEED measurements at different azimuths. For example, for the (2 x 4) reconstruction on the (00 1) surface the RHEED pattern showed a 2x or a 4x symmetry with the electron beam along the [ 1lo] or [ 1701 directions, respectively. In other words, for the electron beam along the [ 1lo] azimuth, an additional streak was found half way between bulk-like (unreconstructed) streaks. For the case of the [ liO] azimuth, three additional streaks were found equally spaced between two adjacent bulk-like streaks. This means that the reciprocal 2-D lattice for (2 x 4) is one-half as long in the [ 1701 direction and onequarter as long in the [ 1lo] direction as the ideal (bulk-like) (1 x 1) 2-D lattice. This, in turn, means that for the (2 x 4) reconstruction on the (00 1) surface, the unit cell (in real space) is a rectangle twice as large in the [ liO] and four times as large in the [ 1 lo] direction, compared to the (1 x 1) unconstructed ideal mesh (4.00 Ax 4.00 A).
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 121
Figure 15. RHEED patterns obtained by 15 keYelectron beam from GaAs (001) surface: c(2 x 8) As-stabilized reconstruction and c(8 x 2) Ga-stabilized reconstruction as obtained in [110] azimuth (a and c) and [-110] azimuth (b and d). The arrows indicated the position of bulk-iike (unreconstructed) streaks. (Courtesy A. Y. Cho, AT&T Bell Laboratories.)
122
Compound Semiconductors REAL SPACE
b0~I
ITiol
m
-7 [ITO]
xxxx
\
CIZXBI
CIZXBI
Figure 16. Real space and reciprocal space unit meshes corresponding to (2 x 4) and c(2 x 8) reconstructions on (001) surface of G&s. The (4 x 2) and c(8 x 2) reconstructions are obtained by a 90° rotation.[72]
Based on these experimental results, Cho suggested a simple model of two d@kent mechanisms giving the (2 x 4) and c(2 x 8) reconstructions, namely, that the two fold symmetry was probably due to a bond pairing mechanism while the 4 fold or the 8 fold symmetry was due to another effect such as Fermi surface instabilities or surface vacancies.t72J. More than a decade later, Chadi used total energy calculations to suggest that the (2 x 4) unit cell arises from the formation of arsenic dimers while the 4x symmetry arises from a regular dimer vacan~y.[~~~l This was soon confirmed by scanning tunneling microscopy [g11[1281 which also showed that the c(2 x 8) is simply a different arrangement of (2 x 4) unit cells (8.0 A x 16.0 A). A detailed discussion of scanning tunneling microscopy studies of the surface structure and electronic properties of GaAs (001) surface is given by Pashley and Haberern.[921 Figure 17 shows the missing dimer model of (2 x 4) and c(2 x 8) reconstructions on (001) surfacet 12glbased on pairing of dangling bonds shown in unreconstructed (00 1) surface depicted in Fig. 14. In Fig. 17_(top and center), we see rows of dimers along [ 1lo] with bonds along the [ 1lo], with every fourth dimer missing (suggesting 75% As coverage) forming (2 x 4) unit cells. In Fig. 17 (bottom), we see staggered arrangement of (2 x 4)
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
123
unit cells resulting in c(2 x 8) reconstruction. On a real surface, different arrangements of the (2 x 4) unit cell leads to different domains of (2 x 4) and c(2 x 8) to coexist with different configuration of missing dimer rows.[gll Experimentally, the area1 ratio of between (2 x 4) to c(2 x 8) domains is statistically between 2 and 1.[12glThree different 2 x 4 phases were found to exist on GaAs (001) depending on the MBE-growth condition: a, p, y, corresponding to 1,0.75, and 0.5 ML As coverage. The /3phase is depicted in Fig. 17. The y phase is similar except that two dimers are present and two dimers are missing .[1301
.
.
.
0
m-fa
/.
.
.
.
.
;
. . . . . . . ‘7m zllzxx )
.
.
.
(
.
.
0
0
0
l
0
0
.
-
.
.
.
.
.
0
l
l
11101
~12x81 unit mesh
Figure 17. Arsenic dimer pairing leading to (2 x 4) (fop) and ~$2 x 8) @oftom) reconstruction on (001) face of III-V compound. Note that the twofold symmetry in both cases results from dimer paring with the bonds parallel to [ilO] direction as expected from Fig. 15. The 4-fold symmetry (top and confer) results from rows of missing dimer along [ilO], every fourth position. The c(2 x 8) (bottom) is formed by staggered arrangement of 2 x 4 cells. (Adapted@om Ref: 129.)
124 Compound Semiconductors Figure 18 represents the arrangement of 2-D reciprocal lattice point for bulk (1 x l), (4 x 2), and c(8 x 2) reconstructions, together with expected RHEED patterns along [fiO], [ilO], and [TOO]azimuths, for different Laue zones,l73I showing how the two different reconstructions may be distinguished. RHEED studies have also been carried out on GaAs and AlGaAs grown on vicinal GaAs substrates to study different surface reconstructions and transitions as a function of substrate temperature and arsenic flux. Phase diagrams have been generated based on these studies.1132l Finally it should be mentioned that the surface reconstruction influences the metalsemiconductor Schottky barrier height value (Table VII, Ref. 75). For example, for Al deposited on GaAs (00 l), the Schottky barrier height has a value of 0.66-0.76 eV for c(2 x 8) and 0.72-0.80 eV for c(8 x 2) GaAs surface reconstruction.
. Bulk Isltlce ” (4x2)
only
0 C(8X2) only 1 common to (4x2) and ~(8x2)
Figure 18. Representation of reciprocal lattice for unreconstructed (bulk), (4 x 2) reconstruction, and c(8 x 2) reconstruction on GaAs (001) surface, together with the RHEED patterns expected in different azimuths for different Laue zones. Note that the (4 x 2) and c(8 x 2) patterns are identical for the [EO] and [ilO] azimuths in the zeroth and first Laue zone.[‘3]
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 125 5.3
RHEED Intensity Oscillation and its Application
An exciting feature of MBE growth is that the intensity of the difficted beam (and the specular beam) in reflection high energy diffraction undergoes oscillations with the period corresponding to one monolayer growth (Fig. 19). In case of GaAs (001) surfaces, one monolayer is composed of a complete layer of Ga and a complete layer of As amounting to a total thickness of u/2 (2.83 8, at room temperature). This feature of MBE was first observed in the growth of GaAs[761-[*01 using conventional MBE but was later found to be a universal feature of the MBE growth mode. It has been found to be true for a wide variety of material systems as well as A simple picture of the oscillation of during gas source MBE growth.[811-[861 the RHEED intensity corresponds to transitions of the surf&e from smooth to rough to smooth[781[1321-[1331 (F’lg. 20). This comes about since MBE is a monolayer-by-monolayer growth process where individual layers start with random nucleation sites which grow into islands, leading to a maximum roughness due to step edge density, when the islands cover 50% of the surface. This roughness reduces the specularly reflected beam intensity to a minimum. As the growth proceeds, the islands eventually coalesce into a complete monolayer and the roughness gives way to maximum smoothness, corresponding to a minimum in step edge density, manifesting itself in a maximum specular beam intensity. In the case of growth on As-stabilized GaAs (2 x 4 reconstruction), it was observed that the amplitude of oscillation was larger for the e-beam along the [ 1lo] direction implying a larger step edge density in this direction. This is consistent with the previous discussion about surface reconstruction and direct STM results. In these studies, the islands were elongated along the [110] (separated by longer rows of missing dimers along that direction). This leads to higher step edge density as the e-beam cuts across the islands in the [ 1lo] direction (Fig. 20). Study of different features of RHEED intensity oscillations as a function of growth conditions and substrate orientation provides valuable information on monolayer formation, growth rate, surface migration, and growth kinetics and dynamics. This has led to fine adjustment to the growth process to achieve one monolayer smoothness in heterostructures, phaselocked epitaxy, and interface smoothness control to within an atomic layer. RHEED intensity oscillations also allows accurate real time determination of growth rate in a layer-by-layer manner. For the conventional MBE, the composition in the ternaries and quatemaries can also be determined from comparing the growth rate of the binary constituents with the total growth rate. This method is not compatible with substrate rotation.
126 Compound Semiconductors RHEED INTENSITY
OSCILLATIONS
Substrate 597 ‘C Al closed Ga Closed --:
--Al Opened
GaAs 1 71Mlis
I
0
I
5
I
I
Al 8 Ga Opened
AlAs 0.585 MVs
llu
AlGaAs 2 29MVs
, , , , , , , I , ,.,
I0
19
E0
25
TIIIE
Figure
-- >
30
35
40
45
50
CSECI
19. RHEED intensity oscillations during growth of GaAs, AL4s, and AlGaAs.
8 = 0.5 8 = 0.75
8= 1.25
0
m
number of monoloyers
deposited
Figure 20. Representation of the formation of the first two monolayers leading to RHEED intensity oscillations. @f&r Ref: 132.)
of GaAs (001)
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 127 Growth Rate and Composition. One direct advantage of monitoring RHEED oscillation is that the actual growth rate of any layer can be directly measured even at temperatures where the sticking coefficients are not unity, since each period corresponds to completion of one monolayer. As an example, we consider the situation for growth of GaAs, AlAs, and AlGaAs on GaAs substrate. Figure 19 shows RHEED intensity oscillations obtained by opening the Ga shutter, then closing the Ga and simultaneously opening the Al shutter, and finally opening both Ga and Al. The As shutter was left open during the growth. The growth rates of each of the three layers may be directly obtained from the corresponding frequency of oscillations, f, either directly or by a fast Fourier transform routine. Note that in this particular example f(AlGaAs) = f(GaAs) + f(AlAs) which then gives the Al fraction, x, as
f-WW
x=@lGaAs) or equivalently
This implies that the incorporation rates of Ga and Al are independent of each other. This is generally the case in conventional and hydride MBE over a wide range of substrate temperatures (<63O”C for AlGaAs). For higher substrate temperatures in conventional MBE growth of AlGaAs, the Ga incorporation rate depends on the substrate temperature, Al flux, and even As flu~.t~~1t*r1tr341 For InGaAs or InAlAs, In desorbs at a faster rate compared to Ga. In contrast, the sticking coefficient of Al remains unity for a wider temperature range (up to about 730°C). For MOMBEKBE, the growth rates can also be obtained from RHEED oscillation measurements.[841 However, even for the growth of GaAs, the growth rate is highly dependent on substrate temperature (Fig. 21).rs41 For ternary compounds, the growth rate in general is not simply obtained by adding those of the binaries. The incorporation rates have a more complicated interdependence and are governed by the arsenic beam flux as well as the substrate temperature. They are also influenced by the gas species and the intermediate products of pyrolysis at the substrate.[1351
128
Compound Semiconductors
400
so0 SUBSTRATE
600 TEMPERATURE
TOO (‘Cl
Figure 21. RHEED intensity oscillations and growth rate determination in chemical beam epitaxy (or MOMBE).[84]
Damping of the Oscillations. Another feature of the RHEED intensity oscillations is that the oscillation is accompanied by a damping; the maxima progressively get smaller, and the minima get larger until small or no oscillations are observed (Fig. 19). This implies that an equilibrium terrace length and step edge density has been reached, depending on the growth conditions. The damping is observed to be faster for higher substrate temperatures. Another factor leading to damping is variations in the growth rate across the portion of the wafer being sampled by the beam. This corresponds to a narrow but very long region since the e-beam strikes the wafer at a glancing angle. This complication is prevented by using a small sample for RHEED oscillation studies. Increase of the Amplitude. The intensity oscillations can be observed to increase when a dopant beam flux is turned on.[‘*l This indicates a larger fluctuation in step edge density with dopants and is consistent with the idea that preferential nucleation is occurring at the terraces in the presence of the dopants. [1331 A common observation is that, after the growth of GaAs has been going on for a while and the oscillations have
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 129 damped, opening of the Al shutter can renew large amplitude oscillations. This could be due to the fact that the Al surface difksion is smaller than that of Ga thereby leading to the presence of more islands of smaller sizes with a resulting increase in the step edge density. Growth Interruption and Intensity Recovery. It is also commonIy observed that after the RHEED oscillations have been damped, as in growth of GaAs over several monolayers, an interruption in the growth leads to the recovery of the intensity (Fig. 22a). The nature of the recovery depends on the growth conditions and the duration of growth time, as studied by Lewis et al.1801Sakaki and collaborators studied the effect of growth interruption on the smoothness of GaAs-AlAs interfaces by growing quantum wells of various thicknesses and as a function of duration of interruption with growth interrupted at the GaAs-AlAs interface either at a maximum of intensity oscillation or at a minimum.l136l The photoluminescence lineshape of the different wells were studied as a measure of interface smoothness, and the smaller the linewidth, the smoother the interface. It was found that the smoothness was enhanced when the growth interruption was at a RHEED intensity oscillation maximum and had a duration of 90 s. The growth interruption technique, together with photoluminescence as a probe, has been used by various authors to optimize interface smoothness.113~-11401 Phase-Locked Epitaxy. A direct application of the RHEED intensity oscillation is that one can achieve heterostructures A/B with near-perfect interfaces by terminating layer A at precisely the time when a maximum in RHEED intensity oscillation has been reached; growth of layer B should be commenced at that moment.1142J11431 Thi s ensures the completion of the top monolayer of material A, before growing the first monolayer of material B. This technique has been used to grow short period superlattices such as (GaAs),(AlAs), which signifies 3 monolayers of each (Fig. 23). The growth of each new material follows after a short interruption (about 6 s in this case) to allow for the smoothing of the interface. Details of the applications of RHEED intensity oscillations in the growth of III-V interfaces as wells as Si and WSiGe are reviewed by Sakamoto.11441 Migration Enhanced Epitaxy. An alternative approach to achieve smooth interfaces in III-V compounds is to take advantage of the fact that the surface migration of group III elements (such as Ga) is enhanced when no group V atoms are present. In this technique, the group III and group V elements are deposited alternately in a periodic manner. In each period, the group V shutter is opened for precisely half the time it takes to grow one monolayer, while group V shutter is closed, then the two shutters are
130
Compound Semiconductors
reversed for the other half cyclei 1451~1 (Fig. 24). This enhances the surface lifetime of isolated group III atoms which are quite mobile on the growing surf& resulting in longer migration distances until they reach a step edge. Step flow growth therefore dominates even for surfaces where step densities are 10w.[~~l
10 set
Time Figure 22. Effect of Growth interruption on RHEED intensity: (a) for low substrate temperature intensity recovers indicating surface smoothing, (b) for high substrate temperature a partial recovery is accompanied with intensity oscillations indicating monolayer by monolayer desorption.[144]
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
(GoAs), (AlAsI, 41 open , Al close Go open / Go close
0
131
superlattlce
1 Time (minl
( a I Non phose - locked eprtaxy
( b I Phase-locked
epitaxy
Figure 23. Shutter sequence and RHEED intensity oscillations during phase-locked epitaxy of short period GaAs-AlAs superlattice (top), and schematic comparison of surface smoothness with or without phase-lock epitaxy.[lU]
132 Compound Semiconductors
Ga Jlnn Aqq_Ofmkycle
580’c
Ga(O.SNs)+Ass I
(a) flat surface (lOO)GaAs
HlOnm
lb)
H32nm (C)
Figure 24. Shutter sequence and RJXED intensity oscillations during migration hanced epitaxy (MEE) of GaAs (001) flat and vicinal surfaces at 580°C. Note that RHEED oscillations are modulated for the flat and 0.5” off surfaces (a and c) but is modulated for the 2” off surface (b). This indicates that in case (b), the growth completely by step flow mode from the outset, and migration length of Ga is larger than nm and smaller than 32 nrn.[14’j]
enthe not is 10
Growth on Vicinal Surfaces: Adatom Migration and Step Flow Growth. The combination of growth on vi&al surfaces and RHJZED intensity oscillations gives insight regrading surface kinetic processes, as well as allows new flexibilities. Vi&al surfaces are obtained by cutting the
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 133 crystal at a small angle (a few degrees), misoriented with respect to a low index surl&e such as (100) or (110) towards a specific direction. This results in a surface comprised of large, low index terraces separated by small (usually one monolayer high) steps. The average width and length dimensions of the terraces would depend on the angle and the direction of cut. If the migration length of the group III element is larger than the step free length &of the terraces, the group III element will migrate freely over the terrace until it reaches a step edge. It then has a very high probability of being incorporated in the crystal at the step. This results in a stepflow mode of growth. In this case, the average step edge density will remain essentially constant and no appreciable RHEED oscillation will be observed. This has a number of applications, including measurement of surface migration lengths of adsorbed species, and growth of quantum wires. The observation of RHEED intensity oscillation, or lack thereof, in conjunction with growth on vi&al substrate can be used to measure the migration length of different group III atoms as a function of temperature, group III flux, and group V flux. In this manner, surface migration lengths for Ga and Al on GaAs has been studied by Neave et al.11471This technique is also used in conjunction with migration enhanced epitaxy to investigate lateral migration, and vertical replacement processes both in MBE and in MOCVD step flow growth mode, as reported and reviewed by Horikoshi et al.t1461 Another application of growth on vicinal surfaces is for the formation of laterally defined superstructures which include quantum wires and quantum boxes. These have a number of exciting properties including suppression of both optical phonon and impurity scattering for high mobilities,[148111501 and excellent laser operation with very high efficiency, good temperature stability,l151l extremely low threshold current (in the microampere r~ge),[1W[lW and higher modulation bandwidth and narrower spectral line widths.l155l Fabrication of these structures has been extremely difficult. In 1984, Petroff et al. proposed a brilliant method for deposition of laterallydefined superlattices by depositing half monolayers of GaAs and AlAs alternately on a (100) vicinal GaAs surface where terrace lengths were smaller than the migration length of group III adatoms.l156I This was realized only after use of RHEED oscillation for step-edge flow growth was well understood and implemented by Petroff and collaborators. They used lateral periods of 80-160 ~.11571-[1581 Independently, Sakaki et al. achieved similar structures with lateral periods of 40-80 A.[1591 FU-IEED Oscillations During Desorption at High Substrate Temperature. When the substrate temperature is higher than 65O”C, the
134
Compound Semiconductors
desorption rate of GaAs from the epilayer cannot be neglected compared to the deposition rate.[81J[1341[1441 F igure 22b shows that for GaAs substrate temperature of 700°C RHEED oscillations appear after the Ga shutter is closed, whereas such oscillations are absent for substrate temperature of 580°C (Fig. 22a). This indicated monolayer-by-monolayer desorption of GaAs at high substrate temperature. In case of In containing III-V compound, this desorption is more prominent.[1611This results in a decrease of the growth rate. This sublimation process proceeds in a layer-by-layer manner and is also manifested by RHEED intensity oscillations. It is seen that an increase in the As flux can suppress this desorption at high temperatures.lgll
6.0
MASS SPECTROMETRY
Modulated beam mass spectrometry has played an important role in the early development of MBE to study the kinetics of adsorption/desorption of the modulated beams of Ga and As on GaAs substrate.[321[541-1571 After these initial studies, the most common use of mass spectrometry was He leak checking and residual gas analysis to check the integrity of the UHV system, and to monitor outgassing of the growth chamber components such as furnaces, crucibles, and source materials to ensure the cleanest possible environment for the growth. In recent years, mass spectrometry of the species desorbed from the substrate during the growth has been revived as a tool for monitoring and controlling the growth process, especially to monitor In desorption during growth of In-containing III-V compounds. More recently, modulated mass spectrometry has been applied to the study of MOMBE or CBE as well. 6.1
Modulated Beam Mass Spectrometry (MBMS)
This is an elegant method for studying kinetics of beam-surface interaction. Application of this technique to the study of adsorption/ desorption kinetics of Ga and As beams on GaAs surface has played an important role in the early development of MBE, as discussed previously. In this technique, modulated molecular or atomic beams are directed onto the surface to be studied and the desorbed fluxes are detected by a mass spectrometer facing the surface at some distance within the UHV system. The modulation of the incident beam (or beams) results in a modulation of
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 135
the desorbed flux and the signals from the mass spectrometer are examined for a correlation. In another variation, the desorbed fluxes are modulated instead. The simplest version of MRMS is the transient beam method. The incident flux is changed abruptly (stepwise) and the desorbtion signal is examined as a response to this stepwise change. This is the method that Arthur used in studying the kinetics of reaction of Ga and As2 beams on heated GaAs, discussed in Sec. 1.2.t321An improved approach is based on periodic modulation of the incident beam and synchronous detection of the desorbed beam, correlating phase and amplitude of the desorbed signal to the incident beam modulation at a given frequency. The advantage of this method is that it distinguishes between background and desorbed signals even for more volatile species such as arsenic and phosphorus which do not readily stick to the walls of the chamber and can lead to memory effects and false signals. To obtain maximtmr information on the surface kinetics, it is necessary to repeat the experiment at different frequencies. An improved version of the periodic modulation has been developed by Foxon and Joyce and coworkers and was applied extensively to the study of kinetics of reaction of As, and As, on G~As.[~~~[~~I Jn this approach, data acquisition and analysis is improved by signal averaging the time varying desorption signal and then Fourier transforming the detected signal and the known time dependence of the incident flux. The attenuation and phase shift of the Fourier components of this flux due to all the events between beam modulation and detection is obtained. Information on the surface processes is extracted by deconvolution. Using the above technique, the following information can be extracted on the nature of surface kinetic processes and parameters: (i) identification of desorbed species, (ii) desorption rates, (iii) accommodation coefficient of an adsorbed species, (iv) surface lifetime of an adsorbed species, (vj sticking coefficient of incident molecules, (vi) binding energy of surface species, and (vii) order of chemical reactions. Reaction Kinetics of Ga and As, or As, on GaAs. Foxon and Joyce and coworkers applied the above technique to study the reaction kinetics of Ga and either As, or As, on GaAs (00 1).[531[671 In the following, we present the summary of these findings as reported in Ref. 12. For the case of As,, they found that these molecules were first adsorbed into a weakly bound mobile precursor state with a surface residence time of less than 10s5s. The basic process of As incorporation was found to be a simple first order dissociative chemisorption on surface Ga atoms. The sticking coefficient of As, was found to increase linearly with Ga surface coverage to a maximum
136
Compound Semiconductors
of unity when the surface was covered with a complete monolayer of Ga atoms. At relatively low substrate temperatures (<600 K) there was an additional associative reaction to form As, molecules which desorbed very slowly by a first order reaction. Above 600 K, some dissociation of GaAs could occur. A significantly more complex reaction mechanism with As, incident beam was encountered. As, molecules were first adsorbed into a mobile precursor state, with an activation energy of about 0.25 V for their surface migration. The surface residence time was temperature-dependent with a desorption energy of about 0.4 eV. A crucial finding was that the sticking coefficient of As, could never exceed 0.5, even when the Ga flux was much higher than the As, flux, or when the surface was completely covered with a monolayer of Ga atoms. This was explained by assuming painvise dissociation of As, molecules chemisorbed on adjacent Ga atoms. This second order reaction is an important feature of MBE growth of GaAs growth with As, beams. From every two As, molecules, only four As atoms are incorporated and the other four desorb. The properties of epitaxial film grown by As, vs. As, seem to have certain advantages. It has been observed that using Asz beams, the deep level state densities are decreased, the photoluminescence intensity is increased, AlGaAs morphology is less dependent on substrate temperature, oval defect densities are decreased, minority carrier lifetime is increased, interface quality is improved, and shallow donor incorporation is increased. On the other hand, in delta-doping with Si and Be, spatial confinement and carrier confinement is seen to decrease and in low temperature grown MBE layers the deep levels, carrier concentration, and PL intensity is seen to decrease, while As incorporation is seen to increase.l161l Application to MOMBE and CBE. This technique cannot be used to study intermediate species generated by pyrolysis of chemical beams at the heated substrate, since the detection is made far away from the surface under study. However, recent modulated beam mass spectrometric studies by Foxon and coworkers in CBE have shown that some intermediate volatile species such as di- and mono-methylgallium (DMGa and MMGa) were desorbed from the surface and could reach the mass spectrometer and be detected.[1351[1621-[1641 These studies also indicated that, for a fixed group III arrival rate and fixed substrate temperature, a strong dependence on As flux was observed even when group V species was supplied in excess. In fact, the growth rate was seen to decrease with an increase of group V flux. This was the case for both TMGa and TEGa.
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 6.2
Desorption Mass Spectrometry
13 7
(DMS)
In principle, a mass spectrometer in the vicinity of the growth position can be used to measure the beam fluxes before the growth, just as in the case of the ion gauge. However, this is not practical during the growth itself. On the other hand, the mass spectrometer can be placed in one of the furnace ports facing the substrate and used to monitor the desorbed fluxes from the substrate during the oxide removal before the growth, and monitor desorption of Ga during the growth at a high substrate temperature.16*l This information can be used for real time growth rate and composition monitoring, and control during the growth of different III-V compounds even with substrate rotation.1681-1711 This is an exciting development in MBE since it provides a convenient method not only for composition monitoring and control of AlGaAs compounds, but also for other III-V compounds where desorption of more volatile group III species, such as In, can be monitored and compensated to avoid compositional variation and lattice mismatch. Compositional Grading using DMS and Solid Source Valved Crackers. As mentioned at the end of Sec. 5.3, when the substrate temperature is higher than 65O”C, the desorption rate of GaAs from the epilayer cannot be neglected compared to the deposition rate.l81ll134l1144l It is seen that an increase in the As flux can suppress this desorption at high temperatures.lgll Therefore, the incorporation of Ga in AlGaAs can vary with As flux at high substrate temperatures. Taking note of this fact, Evans et al. took advantage of the highly controlled arsenic flux manipulation of a solid source valved cracker, combined with real-time monitoring of Ga desorption using DMS, to grow a parabolic Al,Ga,_& (x = 0.15 to 0.05 over 30 ML) profile1711(Figs. 25 and 26).
7.0
IN-SITU AUGER ELECTRON
SPECTROSCOPY
(AES)
In this method, a focused electron beam impinges on the surface of the solid sample creating secondary electrons near the surface. Some of these secondary electrons have energies characteristic of the elements and their chemical environment and are called Auger electrons.l87l This technique is used to analyze the topmost 10 to 30 A of the sample and has detection limit of 0.1% to 1% of a monolayer. Depth profiling can be achieved by performing AES in conjunction with Ar+ sputtering. This technique is not
138 Compound Semiconductors
Secondr
Figure 25. Variation in desorption mass spectrometry signal during growth of AlGaAs as a function of time obtained from changing the substrate temperature (a), or the arsenic flux from a valved cracker (b). Note the sharp response due to latter. The change in desorption of Ga results in a corresponding change in GsAl ratio of the composition since desorption of Al is negligible.[71]
Seconds
0.65 -w
. >o.so z 3
-0.35 3
-
go.20 l.E
-
0.05
* ’ *a
-
-
Obswwd
- - - Drrind
Monoloytn
Figure 26. Growth of a parabolic composition AlGaAs well by controlled variation of arsenic flux using a valved cracker and utilizing desorption mass spectrometry signal for composition monitoring and control.[711
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 139 sensitive enough to determine dopant concentration. In the initial development of MBE, in-situ Auger electron spectroscopy was used to study the procedure for obtaining oxygen- and carbon-free substrate surfaces prior to growtht**l and to study the relative surface compositional changes.[8gl Auger electron spectroscopy has also been used to study surface cleaning of InP by heating in the growth chamber under an arsenic beam.IgOl In those experiments, the Auger electron gun and cylindrical mirror analyzer were bellows-mounted and could be rolled in and out to measure Auger peak intensity of In, 0, P and As at any given substrate temperature. In this manner, desorption of P,05 and As,O, from the surface and onset of InP decomposition were observed as a function of temperature. From these data, optimal heating of substrate for oxide desorption with minimum damage to InP was determined. In modem MBE systems, Auger electron spectroscopy is not done in the growth chamber and is used only for surface analysis before and after the growth.
8.0
OPTICAL METHODS FOR REAL-TIME GROWTH MONITORING
Optical monitoring methods are powerful non-invasive techniques which can be used for real-time growth monitoring and control even with substrate rotating. With a few exceptions such as simple one-color pyrometry, these techniques have not found common use and are not standard equipment on MBE systems. The optical equipment can be installed on viewports on the periphery of the growth chamber and either view the radiation from the wafer (substrate plus the epitaxial layers), or monitor the response of the wafer to external light sources. These techniques can be used for real-time measurement of substrate temperature, growth rate, composition, layer thickness, and surface morphology. Among these techniques are optical pyrometry, pyrometric interferometry, *ared transmission, ellipsometry, reflection difference spectrometry (RD), dynamic optical reflectivity @OR), photoluminescence (PL), and laser light scattering (LLS). Some of these approaches depend on detailed knowledge of material optical parameters and may require sophisticated computer programs for data extraction and are not yet in common use.
140
Compound Semiconductors
8.1
Optical Pyrometry
This technique involves detecting radiation emanating from the wafer in a narrow wavelength range at one or at two different wavelengths below the band edge (for GaAs onecolor pyrometry, this is usually 940 nm f 30 nm).t1651This choice of wavelengths is important since at these wavelengths the material can be considered opaque, and the radiation from the heater filaments is excluded from the detector. This method is most accurate for higher temperature range where the grey body radiation is more copious (e.g., down to 340-380°C for GaAs). Care must be taken to interpret the data since the reflected beam from the open hot cells can lead to a somewhat higher reading. Accurate calibration depends on the knowledge of the emissivity of the wafer, which itself could change depending on the temperature and on the thickness and composition of the deposited fihns. A method for absolute calibration of the substrate temperature uses the eutectic temperature of Al-S1 system. [W Another method for compound semiconductors is the observation of changes in RHEED pattern as a function of temperature to establish the congruent sublimation temperature, which is accurately known for compound semiconductors such as GaAs and InP. Pyrometric Interferometry. The pyrometers used in MBE operate in a narrow wavelength where the substrate is opaque at the substrate temperature range of interest (e.g., 940 nm f 30 run for GaAs) and supposedly only receive the grey body radiation from the outermost surface of the epilayer. However, the grey body radiation from the substrate itself is not completely absorbed in the epilayers as the absorption length for GaAs at 600°C is about 1 pm, and is larger for AlGaAs. This radiation can then undergo multiple reflection and interference within the epilayers themselves, if suitable boundaries are present in the growing epilayers. For example, a layer of AlGaAs on GaAs provides two such boundaries: the buried AlGaAs/ GaAs interface and the exposed AlGaAs/vacuum interface. This interference results in apparent oscillations in the temperature as the growth proceeds, the oscillations being due to intensity oscillations as a result of growing optical path length These observed oscillations in a one-color pyrometer can be directly related to layer thicknesses provided the indices of refraction for different layers are known. This technique has been exploited for growth rate and compositional monitoring.t1671-[16gl This technique can be applied to large, rotating substrates. A more versatile alternative is to use two-color pyrometry, i.e., detect two different wavelengths in narrow bands to obtain some of the optical parameters directly.t1701 In our view, using a
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
141
spectrometer in conjunction with a multichannel diode array instead of a one-color or two-color pyrometer can provide high speed spectroscopic data over an entire range of wavelengths, thus, providing the ultimate flexibility and maximal information for monitoring and control of complicated multilayer structures. An alternative approach is to use an external diode laser which can penetrate the layers while growing, and monitor the reflected beam having suffered multiple reflection and interference in the multilayers as they are being grown (dynamic optical reflectivity). 8.2
Transmission Spectroscopy
Direct radiation heating of substrates in MBE allows the infrared light which heats the substrate to also serve as a light source for transmission spectroscopy. tl’ll This has two important applications: temperature measurement and growth rate measurement. In the first application, the position of the absorption edge can be measured to better than 5 meV. In the temperature range of interest to MBE growth, the bandgap of GaAs shifts to the lower energy by about 500 meV per 100°C temperature increase, giving an accuracy of 1O°C with a reproducibility off 2°C for substrate temperatures measured down to 450°C.tr7rj The second is similar to the above interferometric pyrometry but radiation from the heaters behind the substrate is used as the probe, and the wavelength range, therefore, must be in the transparency range of the substrate. This method is more suited for the growth of InGaAs on InP where the substrate has a wider bandgap than the epilayer. 8.3
Photoluminescence:
Low Substrate Temperature Measurement
For low temperature measurement, an elegant method uses photoluminescence through viewports by employing an external laser and detector system with chopper and lock-in amplifier.t1721 This has the advantage of being more sensitive at the temperatures employed for the growth of low temperature GaAs (LT-GaAs) and related compounds (<3OO”C). The thermocouple measurements, although very reproducible, are difficult to calibrate absolutely. Pyrometers fail to be effective and accurate in this application since grey body radiation is very weak with a large wavelength at low temperatures. Similarly the heater radiation in the back of the substrate is too weak and is peaked at large wavelengths and is not suitable for pyrometric interferometry.
142
Compound Semiconductors
8.4
Reflectance Difference Spectrometry (RD)
In this method, a visible/deep UV light is passed through a focusing gr&ng monochromator, is polarized along the [ 1lo] direction or along the [ 1lo] direction and is incident upon the (001) oriented wafer at normal incidence. The reflected light is monitored for the two different polarizations and the difference in reflectivity of the two different polarizations (reflectance difference, RD, signal) is recorded as a function of time.t1731 The above polarizations correspond to Ga-Ga and As-As surface dimer bond directions, respectively. Because the reflectance contributions from randomly oriented (unreacted) surface species and the bulk are nominally isotropic, only the contribution from the directed bonds and/or oriented microscopic features at the surface survive the signal subtraction.t1731 RD signal can then provide either chemical or structural information depending on the wavelength. This complements the structural information available from RHEED and may be taken simultaneously. RD signals are observed to exhibits oscillations of the same period as in RHEED. As in RHBED, RD cannot be used during substrate rotation. For structural determinations, RD dyta is more detailed than RHEED due to an extremely short surface correlation length. 8.5
Laser Light Scattering (LLS)
In this technique, a visible laser beam is incident on the substrate and the scattered light from the substrate is collected and detected. In this manner, the topography of the growing surface can be monitored over a submicron scale. The use of this technique in MBE has been demonstrated for both Si[174land Ga.A~t~~~l-1~~~1 LLS can be used to monitor oxide desorption, MBE growth, and post-growth anneal. It is sensitive to a wavy surface morphology developed during the growth, as manifested by increased scattered light intensity. This increase is geometry and wavelength dependent, and is related to the correlation length of the surface features. LLS may also be used to detect the onset of dislocation formation. Celii, et al have utilized LLS for the in-situ detection of strained epilayer relaxation in the growth of InGaAs/GaAs strained layer superlattices.[1771 8.6
Spectroscopic
Ellipsometry
Spectroscopic ellipsometry is another powerful optical method of measuring surface characteristics, and is especially suited to multilayers.
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
143
The principles and advantages of this technique are reviewed in Ref. 10. This technique has been successfully applied to real-time monitoring and control in MBE and CBE.11781-11801 Closed loop control using this technique has been successfully demonstrated in the growth of a 200 A wide Al,Ga,_.@ well parabolic (x = 0 to 0.3).117gl
9.0
GROWTH OF III-V COMPOUNDS
The III-V compounds and their heterostructures grown on GaAs and Inp substrates are the most important semiconductors for high speed integrated electronic circuits, optoelectronic devices, and optoelectronic integrated circuits (OEIC). Figure 27 shows bandgap energy vs. lattice constant for important III-V and II-VI compounds as well as Si and Ge. Extensive studies on the materials properties of these semiconductors has been reported.[1811-11841 Th e group III elements used are Ga, Al, and In and the group V elements used are typically As and P. Typical dopants are Si for n-type and Be for p-type. These materials have high electron mobility and saturation velocity, and are very efficient light emitters with direct energy bandgaps over a wide range. The AlGaAslGaAs system is nearly lattice-matched and is widely used for high speed electron devices and optoelectronic devices in the 0.65-0.86 urn region. The In,,Ga&,P,, system is lattice-matched to Inp provided 0.1896 y x = 0.4176 -0.0125 y or x E 0.47 y. This material system is extremely important for lasers and detectors operating in the 1.3 pm and 1.55 pm region. The fundamental gap in the materials lattice-matched to InP ranges from 1.35 eV for Inp to about 0.74 eV for InGaAs. An alternative to this system is Inl_x_YG~,,As latticematched to InP which spans a larger bandgap range.11851-11881 The InGaAs/ GaAs and InA1As/GaAs are lattice-mismatched. As discussed in Sec. 11.3, the mismatch can be accommodated by elastic strains by making thin superlattice layers of the ternary and binary alloys. This provides flexibility in the bandgap and lattice matching requirement, but also changes in the valence band properties occur which are beneficial to laser and optical modulator applications. The most important application is 0.9 urn lasers for pumping erbium-doped optical fiber amplifiers to produce laser
144
Compound Semiconductors
radiation in the 1.55 pm region. When Sb is used, smaller bandgaps are achieved for use in long wavelength (5-10 pm) detectors. Finally, the InGaP, InAlP and InGaAlP system can be grown lattice-matched to GaAs to achieve materials in the visible range. Four Quaternary Alloy Systems
2s 3 o.pM 5 m l-
InSb w
0
I I 1 I II I' 6.0 5.6 5.8 5.4 cuta comely 01 A ENahxy Bellcore Lattice Parameter (A) I
I 6.2
I
I 6.4
Figure 27. Energy gap vs. lattice constant of III-V and II-VI compounds.
9.1
-5
I 6.6
(Courtesy EPZ.)
Substrate Preparation Prior to Transfer to MBE
The surface of the substrate plays perhaps the most important role in the monolayer by monolayer epitaxial growth process. Study of proper surface preparation and conditions for optimal epitaxy has always been and continues to be a most important activity in the successful development and evolution of MBE. For successful MBE growth, one has to start with a substrate free of contaminants and defects. Certain contaminants absorbed on the surface during the wafer handling prior to loading are so stubborn that they cannot be removed without damaging the surface. With such contaminants present, the morphology, optical, and transport properties of the layers would be adversely affected. In some cases, epitaxy may not be possible.
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
145
To prevent these problems, the substrates must go through a rigorous preparation regimen before loading. Some wafer suppliers make available wafers already prepared and ready for loading (epi-ready), in which case no preparation is necessary before loading. In the other extreme, one may start with saw-cut wafers which require extra preparation steps. Normally, wafers are supplied with one or both sides polished after etching but require preparation before loading. The substrate preparation steps are: degreasing, chemomechanical and/or chemical treatment, protective thin oxide formation, drying, mounting on wafer carrier, and finally loading in the load-lock chamber. The solvents and chemicals used should be high purity, filtered semiconductor grade to avoid chemical and particulate contaminants. These procedures are carried out in laminar flow exhaust hoods to minimize airborne particulates and protect the operator from chemical vapors. Many of the steps involve rinsing in deionized (DI) water (about 18 lWA resistivity). Care must be taken that the deionized water is constantly recycled and filtered with submicron filters. An additional 0.2 urn filter at the point of use nnnimizs the particulates. The DI water system must be sanitized periodically to avoid the build up of bacteria. The bacteria remnants are stubborn contaminan ts that can adversely affect the MBE growth. During any wet process, care must be taken that the surface is not exposed to air at any time. Chemomechanical and chemical etching is done in dishes and on surfaces that are chemically inert, such as Teflon’s’. The drying is done using filtered, high purity dry nitrogen dispensed from a gun, or subjecting the wafer to high spin drying. In the following, we first describe degreasing procedures which are common to GaAs, InP, and Si wafers. The chemical etching and oxide formation steps depend on the substrate material and will be given accordingly. Degreasing: The degreasing usually involves boiling for 3 min in trichloroethylene or trichloroethane, followed by rinsing and a 3 min boiling in acetone, followed by rinsing and another 3 min boiling in methanol or 2propanol (isopropyl alcohol). Some workers do additional cleaning in Alconox, or sulfuric acid to eliminate other possible organic contaminants. GuAs Substrates: For saw-cut wafers, the mechanical damage is removed on both sides by chemomechanical polishing using 0.3-l% mixture of Br in methanol on an inert soft pad on a firm surface, followed by a free Br-methanol rinse, a methanol rinse, and a DI water rinse and soak. This step is usually not necessary for substrates supplied as polished wafers. After degreasing and a DI rinse, the shelf oxide is first removed by dipping
146 Compound Semiconductors in HCl followed by a DI rinse. This is followed by a free etch in H,SO,:H,O,:H,O with typical ratios varying from 3-lO:l:l, with 5:l:l being normal. The hydrogen peroxide is 30% strength. This mixture is exothermic and the etching rate is higher for higher temperatures. The etching is usually performed several minutes after the mixture has been made (at about 50-60 “C). The hydrogen peroxide can be added after the acid-water mixture has cooled and before the substrate etch. A few minutes soak results in successive formation and dissociation of oxide, resulting in the removal of about 10-25 urn of GaAs, and leaving a smooth surface. This is followed by a thorough rinse in DI water. An additional HCl etch may be followed to remove any remaining thick oxide from the previous etch. The final wet step is the DI rinse which results in the formation of a thin native oxide which remains stable when kept in stagnant water. The wafer is finally dried either using a nitrogen gun or by spin drying, as pointed out above. The substrate is then mounted on a MO block with molten In, which results in heating the substrate to 150°C for about one minute. This heating, when performed in air, results in an additional oxide layer which is more stable. Alternatively, the dried substrate is directly mounted on a MO ring supported gently on the edge either by Ta wires or a loosely fitted collar ring. This leaves the back of the substrate exposed for direct radiation heating. It is reported that heating the substrate in controlled dry N2 and 0, mixture to 300°C for 3-5 minutes results in a more reproducible oxide and helps reduce surface-related oval defects to 300 cm-* or less.t18gl In any case, the thin oxide layer is a crucial protection as it prevents bonding of the contaminants in air such as CO and CO, to the GaAs surface. (The oxide is removed in the growth chamber revealing atomically clean GaAs surface prior to the growth.) The wafers are then quickly loaded in the MBE load lock chamber. InP Substrates: In many respect InP preparation is similar to GaAs. Extra care must be exercised during polishing and handling of InP since it is much “softer” than GaAs. The Br-methanol polishing is sometimes applied even if they are already received in a polished form. To remove the shelf oxide, a free dip in dilute (0.3%) Br-methanol is used. The substrate is then rinsed in methanol and DI water, followed by an etch in H,SO,:H,O,:H,O. Some authors use a 7: 1: 1 for 30 set, followed by DI water rinse and drying.llgol Others use 10 min etch in cooled 4: 1:1 mixture followed by DI water rinse, 3 min. etch in Br-methanol and final DI water rinse and drying.171
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 147 9.2
Substrate Preparation in the MBE System
After the substrates are loaded in the load lock chamber and a reasonably high vacuum is achieved (about loss torr), the substrates and the MO blocks are outgassed to about 200°C in the load lock to desorb most of the water vapor and other gases which are loosely bonded to the protective oxide. This and subsequent steps are presented in Fig. 28. The substrates are then transferred to the buffer or preparation/analysis chamber for additional outgassing at about 300°C from 10 min to 2 hrs to f&her remove water vapor and other gases. The substrate is then transferred to the growth chamber. The GaAs substrate is heated to 580-620°C for several minutes in the presence of As beam (0.5 to 1 x 10m5torr at the substrate) to remove the thin protective oxide and reveal the atomically clean GaAs. This process is monitored with RHEED. The presence of the group V beam is to prevent the GaAs surface from thermally decomposing (thermal etching, pitting or the formation of Ga or In droplets due to preferential desorption of group V elements). As shown by in situ Auger studies,[881-[901 the oxide film consists mainly of As,O, and G+O, which decompose and desorb at around 350°C and 550-58O”C, respectively. In the case of InP, the oxide removal is achieved at a lower temperature of about 5 10°C under a higher flux of As, (>3 x IO” torr or 10” As/cm* set) or P, flux. The P20s and As,O, decompose and desorb at around 36O’C and 460°C respectively. InP substrate surface cleans up at about 500°C and its surface starts to decompose at about 550°C.[901 Initially the RHEED pattern of the oxide has a diffuse pattern characteristic of an amorphous film. As the oxide starts to desorb, a spotty pattern will appear which will gradually give way to elongated streaks characteristic of atomically clean and smooth surface. Although the degreasing and DI water rinsing steps may seem trivial, the success of the following steps and the growth depends critically on them. Before the onset of growth, the substrate has to be atomically clean, free of oxides and other contaminants, free of defects, heated to the right temperature range, and possess the proper surface reconstruction. Some residual contaminants due to previous substrate handling and packaging may prove to be too stubborn. Even in the highest resistivity DI water, there may be bacteria, their remnants, or other particulates. All of these can adversely affect the final substrate surface and render the substrate useless. If stubborn oxides or carbon contamination is present, the transition to atomically clean surface will not be complete and faceting may occur, as evidenced by a crows’ feet
148
Compound Semiconductors
pattern. For properly prepared substrates, a streaky pattern will emerge, and at this stage growth can commence. As the growth progresses, the surface becomes smoother and the streaks get longer. As discussed in Sec. 5, a great deal can be learned from RHEED and RHEED intensity oscillations about surface reconstruction and growth mechanism.
1
GROWTH CHAMBER
OSCILLATION
1
-I
GROWTH RATE AND COUPOSmON CALIBRATION
I
4
I SELECTCELL TEYPERTATURES
I HEAT SUBSTRATE TO3OOC
I OPEN & SHUTTER MONITOR 1 WITH PYROMETER
RAISE SUBSTRATE TEMPERANRE
I
CHECK/ADJUST
BEGIN GROWTH
Figure 28. compounds.
Schematic diagram of steps involved in preparation of MBE
growth of I&V
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 9.3
149
MBE Growth
After oxide removal, the substrate temperature is adjusted to the proper value and group III and the dopant shutters are opened. Computer control can be used to program desired composition and doping profiles. Real-time monitoring equipment can be used to ensure proper growth, as discussed in Sec. 8. In the initial stages of the growth, it is sometimes advantageous to grow smoothing layers, such as superlattices or MEE layers, or use growth interruptions. These layers lead to sharper RHEED patterns. Growth and composition calibrations can be done prior to the growth using RHEED intensity oscillations. After the initial stages of growth, the surface must be maintained at proper conditions for the growth to proceed as smooth monolayer-by-monolayer epitaxy. The surface reconstruction depends on the substrate material, substrate orientation, substrate temperature, and material fluxes. As different layers are grown, the group V and substrate temperature must be adjusted to optimize the growth. Realtime monitoring such as desorption mass spectrometry or optical methods can be’used to fine-tune the growth.
10.0 POST-GROWTH
CHARACTERIZATION
There are many techniques for post-growth characterization of the MBE layers. These techniques give valuable information on the various properties of the epilayers and interfaces which can then be correlated with the growth conditions. The various techniques can roughly be divided into structural, electrical, and optical. In some cases, different techniques can be used to obtain the same information. For example, the thickness of GaAs quantum wells (less than a few hundred A thick) surrounded by AlGaAs layers can be measured directly using cross-sectional TEM. This technique is cumbersome and time-consuming but gives direct and absolute values. A second method is low temperature photoluminescence which is simpler and quicker. In this method, the quantum-confined energy shift from bulk GaAs is measured and the thickness of the quantum well thickness is inferred from a model (which must include the excitons), or from direct calibration curves previously obtained from correlating this shift with the thicknesses obtained from cross-sectional TEM on a calibration set of samples. The interface roughness (between GaAs and AlGaAs) may be studied using cross-sectional TEM, chemical lattice imaging,l1g1l or high resolution
150 Compound Semiconductors photoluminescence mapping of exciton energy, linewidth, and splitting.l13gl Finally, carrier concentration can be determined either by resistivity and Hall measurement, or by studying the photoluminescence linewidth and peak shift. The most important of the post-growth characterization techniques are as follows. Excellent reviews of many of these techniques are presented by Herman and Sitter,li”I and by various experts collected in a book edited by Stradling and Klipstein.11g21 10.1 Structural/Compositional Structural information such as morphology, layer thickness, composition, crystallinity, and interface and defect structure can be obtained using phase contrast optical microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, transmission electron microscopy (both planar and cross-sectional), lattice imaging, scanning tunneling microscopy (both planar and cross-sectional), secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS), x-ray diffraction (single crystal, double crystal, rocking curve), Auger electron spectroscopy, x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), Rutherford backscattering, low energy electron diffraction (LEED), and positron annihilation spectroscopy (PAS).[ig31 Perhaps the most often used technique in this category is x-ray diffraction (XRD). With XRD rocking curves, one can determine the lattice mismatch of the epilayer and the substrate (from the peak shifts) and hence the composition. From the peak width, one can get a measure of the degree of crystalhnity. For (100) wafers, the [5 1 l] di&tction geometry penetrates more and is useful for thicker layers. The [422] diffraction geometry is more at a glancing angle and is more sensitive to the crystalline quality of the upper layers. In case of small lattice mismatch, double crystal XRD is preferred. High resolution XRD, which involves double or triple crystal diffraction, is an extremely sensitive technique for measurement of multiple quantum wells and superlattices.11g4l 10.2
Electrical and Magneto-Transport
Resistivity and Hall mobility (both gated and ungated) is used extensively for the determination of carrier type, concentration, mobility, and compensation. Other magneto-transport measurements, such as Shubnikovde Haas oscillations are used to determine carrier concentration and dimensionality of carrier confinement. Capacitance-voltage (CV) measurements are used for determination of doping concentration and bandgap
Molecular Beam l?pita.xy 151 misalignments in heterostructures. llg51 A more elaborate version, namely deep level transient spectroscopy (DLTS) is used for the determination of trap energies, concentrations, and lifetimes. Photoconductivity is used for the determination of carrier transport properties. 10.3 Optical and Infrared Spectroscopy Optical and infrared spectroscopy provides a large variety of extremely powerful techniques for the characterization of thin films. These techniques include absorption, photohuninescence (PL), photoluminescence excitation (PLE), electroreflectance (ER), photoreflectance, time-resolved photoluminescence, Raman, spectroscopic ellipsometry, magnetoabsorption, magnetoreflection, magnetophotoluminescence, and photothermal deflection. These techniques provide a wide range of valuable quantitative and qualitative information about the epilayers. These include band structure (energy gaps, effective masses, band curvatures, energy vs crystal momentum dispersions in different directions, densities of state), composition, thickness, impurity identification and concentration, interface roughness, exciton binding energy, quantum confined energies, strain optical transition energies and matrix elements, optical constants, and surface and interface electric fields. Studies of excitons by high resolution spectroscopy is particularly useful for the study of quantum well interfaces.11g61~11ggl Photoreflectance and differential photoreflectance are useful tools to characterize the doping in epilayers, characterize surface electric fields or characterize buried quantum we11s.~2001-12021 Fourier transform infrared spectrometry can be used to characterize inter-subband transition energies in quantum wells for band offset measurements or characterization of photovoltaic detectors.12031-t2051It can also be used to determine minisubband transition energies and dispersions in superlattices.1206112071 Photothermal deflection spectroscopy is a sensitive method for determining quantum well energies before or after layer disordering.l2o8l Room temperature infrared absorption or photocurrent spectroscopy can be used to characterize excitonic transitions in multiple quantum well p-i-n electroabsorption modulators.l*Ogl-l*lil 10.4
Structural Defects in III-V Compound Epilayers
An important issue in epitaxial growth is the minimization or elimination of structural defects. Defects can appear in homomorphic epitaxy
152 Compound Semiconductors (lattice-matched epilayers of the same family), pseudomorphic epitaxy (lattice-mismatched compounds of the same family such as III-V/III-V, IIVI/II-VI, SiGe/Si, etc.) or heteroepitaxy (layers of different families such as III-V on Si and II-VI on III-V). No attempt is made here to give a comprehensive or quantitative account, only to list some of the important defects and their features in a qualitative manner. A comprehensive treatment of this topic appears in a recent volume of Semiconductors and Semimetals. f2121Of special interest is Ch. 9 by Liliental-Weber. Certain defects can be caused by nonuniform heating or mechanical stresses on the substrate due to improper mounting. With proper hardware design, these could easily be minimized or eliminated. The most common defects encountered in the growth of GaAs on GaAs are oval defects, which are typically 1-15 pm long along [ liO] and their density is in the range lo2 to lo5 per cm2. There are generally two groups of oval defects, one with and one without a core. The latter is believed to be due to particulates landing on the substrate during substrate preparation, loading, transferring or growth. The former group generally has a polycrystalline core. Most investigators believe that these are Ga related and are caused by Ga spitting and/or Ga oxides, and are somewhat controlled by growth conditions. Therefore, the oval defects can be minimized by proper substrate handling, by elimination of leaks and other sources of oxygen, by using Ga and In furnaces with higher temperature lips to eliminate Ga and In droplets, and by elimination of As spitting by using crackers and moderate growth rates. It appears that the Ga-related oval defect are absent in MOMBE since Ga droplets and oxides are absent. Another kind of defect is encountered in the growth of GaAs, AlGaAs, or InGaAs at low temperature (<300°C) due to excess As uniformly incorporated to form a non-stoichiometric epitaxial layer.12131-[2161 When these epilayers are annealed the excess As coalesces into metallic arsenic clusters imbedded in a III-V crystalline matrix. The tendency of the cluster formation seems to depend on doping and whether the layers contain Al or not. The nature of defects in materials grown by low temperature MBE seem to present certain advantages: they are high resistivity layers which can be grown epitaxially; under certain conditions these materials can be photoconductive with extremely short (sub-picosecond) carrier lifetimes; and depending on the heterostructure composition and doping, clusters can be engineered to appear preferentially in certain layers.
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 153 In growing heterostructures, several kinds of defects can be encountered, due to differences in lattice constants, differences in thermal expansion coefficients, and defects present on the substrate. In the growth of strained-layer III-V on III-V compounds or for Si/Ge, if the alternate layers are kept below a certain critical thickness, the strains may be elastically accommodated leading to defect-free structures with certain advantages discussed in Sec. 11.3. The most dramatic advantage is in Si/Ge superlattices where a direct bandgap structure can result from indirect bandgap material. Combining the advantages of III-V optoelectronic structures with Si electronics has motivated the growth of III-V compounds on Si substrate, which has the added advantage of higher thermal conductivity and better material strength as substrate. This is, however, complicated by the large lattice mismatch (4%), different thermal expansion coefficients, and polar on nonpolar epitaxy with the associated twinning due to anti-phase domains. Clever schemes have been implemented in overcoming some of these problems, and recent progress in this important technology is reported elsewhere.12i71 11.0 BUILDING BLOCKS OF MODERN DEVICES: BANDGAP ENGINEERING IN III-V STRUCTURES As discussed in the beginning, bandgap engineering is a powerful technique for the design of new semiconductor structures and devices. Early suggestions for using heterojunctions to improve semiconductor devices appear in the transistor patent by Shockley.12181The concept of a compositionally-graded semiconductor was proposed by Kroemer a few years later.121gl It was suggested that by spatially varying the composition, the bandgap can be varied spatially, resulting in an internal quasi-electric field. This is the simplest and earliest example of bandgap engineering. After the demonstration of the homojunction semiconductor laser in the early 1960’s, Kroemer suggested that electron and hole confinement in a narrower bandgap region clad by wider bandgap heterojunction barriers would result in population inversion and laser action at much lower current densities.l220l The advent of MBE has led to inception and implementation of many other ideas for manipulating the band structure and interface properties and thereby, transport and optical properties of semiconductors by various researchers. A number of these ideas have been described and implemented
154
Compound Semiconductors
by Capasso and coworkers. [~1[~W[2211[2221 gap engineering are listed below.
The e
ingredients
for band-
11.1 Doping The most basic is uniform p-n or p-i-n junctions in otherwise uniform semiconductors. The other is modulation doping or selective doping in conjunction with heterostructures in which case the wider bandgap material is doped and the narrower one undoped, leading to formation of a triangularshaped quantum well confining the charge carriers to move along the interface (similar to inversion layers in Si-SiO,). This results in a quantized 2-D electron (or hole) gas with much improved mobility, leading to high electron (or hole) mobility transistors. Other possibilities are n-i-p-i doping superlattices in either uniform composition or heterostructures resulting in novel optical and transport properties, such as optically tunable bandgap and long band-to-band recombination lifetime.[2231[2241Planar or delta doping,t225jas well as graded doping provide additional degrees of flexibility in bandgap engineering. An interesting concept in bandgap engineering is the elimination of conduction or valance band discontinuity by combining bandgap grading in conjunction with modulation doping.t2261 A recent account of fundamental issues and the state of the art regarding doping and its applications in bandgap engineering is presented in a pedagogical manner in a recent book by Schubert.[2271 11.2 Quantum Wells and Superlattices A semiconductor single quantum well (SQW) is formed when a thin (less than a few hundred A thick) layer of semiconductor W (well) is grown between two layers of semiconductor B (barriers) which has a larger bandgap (resulting in conduction and valance band misalignment or offset). The semiconductors W and B could be binary, ternary, quaternary or pentanary alloys. When there is a repeating sequence of W and B layers, we have a multiple quantum well (MQW). When W and B are sufficiently thin, the wavefunctions of the charge carriers (electrons and holes) in adjacent wells can penetrate the barrier layers and couple to one another forming a superlattice (SL) with new properties not available in the bulk semiconductors of W or B. Heterointerfaces, quantum wells and superlattices are generally formed by choosing W and B with the same crystal structure but different band parameters, and consequently different optical and electrical
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
155
properties. Heterointerfkces can be classified in four types leading to four different types of MQWs and SLs.l 2281For Type I, the conduction band edge of W is lower than that of B, while the opposite is true for the valance band edges. This results in the forbidden gap of W being located entirely in the forbidden gap of B, and both the electrons and the holes are confined on the W side of the W/B interface. Therefore, in Type I MQWs, both the electron and hole wavefunctions are in the W region and have a large overlap, leading to a large optical transition matrix element both for the interband and intersuband transitions. Furthermore, the index of refraction of the W layer is usually higher than that of the B layer (since B has a wider bandgap), also leading to the tendency of photons to be confined in the W layer. This dual confinement has important practical consequences for optoelectronic devices. Type I interfaces and MQWs are widely used for two-dimensional electron or two-dimensional hole gas structures, and a wide variety of optoelectronic devices such as lasers, modulators, and detectors. Type I materials systems include the important GaAs(W)/ Al,Ga,_$.s(B) (x < 0.45) and InGaAs(W)/InAlAs(B) systems. For Type II heterointerfaces, both the conduction and the valence band edges of W are lower than the values for the B semiconductor. Type I alignments result in confinement of both electrons and holes in the W side of a W/B interface, whereas in Type II, holes are confined on the B side and electrons on the W side. In Type II-staggered (e.g., GaAs/AlAs), the forbidden gaps of W and B overlap partially, whereas in Type II-misaligned (e.g., InAs/GaSb), the forbidden gaps do not overlap. In both cases, one can obtain two-dimensional electron and hole confinement at the interface simultaneously; the electrons are in the W side and the holes in the B side of the interface. In Type II-staggered at the interface, the electrons are a higher energy than the holes, whereas in Type II-misaligned the opposite is true. This results in unusual transport behavior. Type III is exemplified by HgTe-CdTe where the conduction and valance band edge of the former overlap (zero bandgap) and are in the forbidden gap of the latter. Optical properties of G&s-AlAs Type II-staggered superlattices are presented in Refs. 229 and 230. 11.3 Strained-Layer
Superlattices and Quantum Wells
Normally, W and B are chosen to have nearly identical lattice parameters (lattice-matched) to achieve perfect crystallinity. However, in recent years it has been shown that as long as the layers are sufficiently thin (less than a critical thickness), one can still maintain perfect crystallinity
156
Compound Semiconductors
without misfit dislocations even when W and B have different bulk lattice parameters. This results from coherent (elastic) in-plane biaxial strains which develop in the heterostructure to accommodate the lattice mismatch. Elastic biaxial strain (compressional or tensile) which is present in SSLs can dramatically affect the band structure (especially the valence band) in terms of energy, effective mass (and hence mobility), density of states, light hole and heavy hole splitting, interband transition matrix elements, inter-valence band transitions, and anisotropy. Optoelectronic devices such as MQW electroabsorption modulators and lasers can benefit from these effects and enhanced absorption coefficients, alteration of hole density of states, and polarization dependence in quantum wells under biaxial strain.~“~~-~u5~~21~~30~ 11.4 Bandgap Grading and Chirped Superlattices Bandgap grading offers many advantages in device performance especially for bipolar junction transistors, avalanche photodetectors,[2211[1881 and semiconductor lasers.[z61 This is achieved by changing the furnace temperatures in a precise manner to affect a desired flux and hence composition profile. This puts stringent requirements on thermal response of the furnaces and becomes impractical for large grading over small thicknesses. An alternative is to use chirped superlattices. These are short period superlattices where the period is kept constant but the thickness of GaAs is reduced while that of AlAs is increased from one period to the next (or vice versa). This was pioneered by Gossard and coworkers in the growth of a structure simulating a parabo1a.r2371 Recently we have implemented this idea to incorporate linear grading in the wells of a multiple quantum well PIN electroabsorption modulator and have observed effects associated with prepolarization of excitons, leading to higher sensitivity of the quantum confined Stark shift to external bias field.t211j
12.0 EPILOGUE
Molecular beam epitaxy is an exciting and fruitful scientific and technological activity which has drawn upon a tremendous pool of talent and vision for its longevity. Year after year exciting developments have been introduced and brought to fruition. The future looks prosperous with good prospect for development of multiwafer growth, valved crackers for precision control of group V elements, improvements in precursors for gas
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
157
source MBE, and more robust and reliable in situ monitoring techniques for closed loop control of the growth, such as desorption mass spectrometry and optical techniques. Combining the best of III-V compounds and Si using heteroepitaxy is another area of potential growth. Sophisticated interface characterization techniques, such as scanning tunneling microscopy and high resolution x-ray techniques for chemical analysis are paving the way for better understanding and control of interfaces. As mentioned earlier, the continued success of MBE depends on the same principles that started it: fundamental surface and interface science, combined with practical device development.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I am deeply indebted to A. Y. Cho for his guidance and advice, generously sharing of his insight and enthusiastic support over the years. I would like to thank P. Holloway for many useful suggestions. I would like to thank my family for their patience and support. Partial support of Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board Advanced Research and Advanced Technology Program, NSF, ARO, and DOE is gratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES 1. Cho, A. Y., and Arthur, J. R, Progress in Solid State Chemistry, (G. Somorjai and J. McCaldin, eds.), 10(3):157-191, Pergamon Press, New York (1975) 2. Chang, L. L., and Ludeke, R., Epitaxial Growth, (J. W. Mathews, ed.), Part A, Ch. 2.2, pp. 37-72, Academic Press, New York (1975) 3. Cho, A. Y., J. Vat. Sci. Technol., 16:275-284
(1979)
4. Weed, C. E. C., Physics ofThin Films, (W. R. Hunter and G. Haas, eds.),
11:35-103, Academic Press, New York (1980) 5. Foxon, C. T., and Joyce, B. A., Current Topics in Materials Science, (FL Kaldis, ed.), 7: l-68, New York (1981) 6. Ploog, K., Crystal Growth, Properties, andApplications, ed.), 3:73-162, Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1980) 7. Cho, A. Y., Thin Solid Films, 100:291-317 8. Chang, L. L. Heterostructures,
(H. C. Freyhardt,
(1983)
and Ploog, K. (eds.), Molecular
Beam
Epitaxy
and
NATO AS1 Ser. E., No 87, M. Nijhoff, Boston (1985)
158 Compound Semiconductors 9. Parker, E. H. C. (ed.), The Technology and Physics of Molecular Beam Epitaxy, Plenum Press, New York (1985) 10. Herman, M. A., and Sitter, H., Molecular Beam Epitaxy: Fundamentals and Current Status, Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1989) 11. Sakaki, H., III-V Semiconductor Materials and Devices, (R. J. Malik, cd.), North-Holland, New York (1989) 12. Foxon, C. T., and Joyce, B. A., Growth and Characterization of Semiconductors, (R. A. Stradling and P. C. Klipstein, eds.), Ch. 3, pp. 3% 64, Adam Hilger, New York (1990) 13. Cho, A. Y.,MolecularBeamEpitaxy,
Am. Inst. Physics, New York (1994)
14. Semiconductor Quantum Wells and Superlattices: Physics and Applications, J. Quantum Electron., special issue, QE22, no. 9, IEEE (1986) 15. Dingle, R., (ed.), Semiconductors and Semimetals, (R. K. Willardson and R. Beer, Treatise editors), Academic Press, New York (1987) 16. Mendez, E. E., and von Klitzing, K., (eds.), Physics andApplications of Quantum Wells and Superlattices, NATO AS1 Ser. B: Physics vol. 170, Plenum Press, New York (1987) 17. Capasso, F., (ed.), Physics of Quantum Electron Devices, Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1990) 18. Weisbuch, C., and Vinter, B., Quantum Semiconductor Academic Press, San Diego (199 1)
Structures,
19. Rosencher, E., Vinter, B., and Levine, B., (eds.), Inters&band Transitions in Quantum Wells, NATO AS1 Ser. B: Physics, vol. 288, Plenum Press, New York (1992) 20. Weisbuch, C., Proc. Seventh Int. Conf Molecular Beam Epitmy, Ploog and G. Weimann, ed.), pp. 742-751, North-Holland (1993)
(K.
2 1. Pearsall, T. P., (ed.) Semiconductors and Semimetals, 32, (R. K. Willardson and R. Beer, Treatise editors), Academic Press, New York (1990); Pearsall, T. P., (ed.), Semiconductors and Semimetals, 33, (R. K. Willardson and R. Beer, Treatise editors), Academic Press, New York (1991) 22. Charge Transport Nonlinearities, Optical and Quantum Electronics, special issue, vol. 22, (A. M. Glass and E. F. Schubert, eds.), Chapman and Hall, London (1990) 23. Capasso, F., J. Vat. Sci. Technol. BI, pp. 457-461 (1983); Capasso, F., Science, 235:172 (1987) 24. Sakaki, H., Proc. Int. Symp. Foundation of Quantum Mechanics, Tokyo (1983)
p. 94,
25. Abram, R. A. and Jaros, M., BandStructure Engineering in Semiconductor Structures, NATO AS1 Ser. B: Physics, vol. 189, Plenum Press, New York (1989) 26. Gossard, A. C., Treat. Mater. Sci. Technol., 24113-66 (1982)
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
159
27. Joyce, B. A., Rep. Prog. Phys., 48:1637 (1985) 28. Ikoma, T., (ed.) Semiconductors and Semimetals, 29 and 30, (R. K. Willardson and R Beer, Treatise editors), Academic Press, Boston (1990) 29. Morkoc, H., Unlu, H., and Ji, G., Principles and Technology of&fODFETs, ~01s. 1 and 2, Wiley & Sons, New York (1991) 30.
Zory, P. S., Jr., (ed.) Quantum Well Lasers, Academic Press, Boston (1993)
31. Smart Pixels, IEEE J. Quantum Electron., (1993)
special issue, QE 29, no. 2
32. Arthur, J. R, J. Appl. Phys., 39:4032 (1968) 33. Cho, A. Y., Surf: Sci., 17:494 (1969) 34. Cho, A. Y.,J. Appl. Phys., 41:782 (1970) 35. Cho, A. Y.,J. Appl. Phys., 41:2780 (1970) 36. Cho, A. Y.,J. Appl. Phys., 42:2074 (1971) 37. Cho, A. Y., J. Vat Sci. Technol., 8: S31-S38
(1971)
38. Cho, A. Y. and Hayashi, I., Solid State Electronics,
14: 125 (1971)
39. Cho, A. Y. and Hayashi, I.,J. Appl. Phys., 42:4422 (1971) 40. Cho, A. Y. Parrish,M. B., and Hayashi, I., Proc. S’p. GaAs and Related Compounds, Aachen, Germany, 1970, p. 18, Institute of Physics, London (1971) 41. Cho, A. Y. and Panish, M. B., J. Appl. Phys., 435118 (1972) 42. Cho, A. Y. and S. E. Stokowski, SolidState
Commun., 9:565 (1971)
43. Cho, A. Y., Appl. Phys. Lett., 19:467 (1971) 44. Cho, A. Y. and Casey, H. C., Jr., Appl. Phys. Lett., 25:224 (1974) 45.
Cho, A. Y. and Reinhart, F. K., J. Appl. Phys., 45:1812 (1974)
46. Cho, A. Y., DUM, C. N., Kuvas R. L., and Schroder, W. E., Appl. Phys. Lett., 25:288 (1974) 47. Chang, L. L., Esaki, L., Howard, W. E., and Ludeke, R, J. Vat. Sci. Technol., 1O:ll (1973) 48. Ludeke, R., Chang, L. L., Esaki, L., Appl. Phys. Lett., 23:201 (1973) 49. Chang, L. L., E&i,
L., and Tsu, R., Appl. Phys. Lett., 24:593 (1974)
50. Esaki, L. and Chang, L. L., Phys. Rev. Lett., 33:495 (1974) 51. Dingle, R., Wiegmann, W., andHenry, C., Phys. Rev. Lett., 33:827 (1973) 52. Arthur, J. R, Surf: Sci., 43:449 (1974) 53. Foxon, C. T., Harvey, J. A., Joyce, B. A., J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 3411693 (1973) 54. Foxon, C. T., Boudry, M. R, and Joyce, B. A., Surf: Sci., 44:69 (1974)
160
Compound Semiconductors
55. Foxon, C. T. and Joyce, B. A., Surf: Sci., 50:434 (1975) 56. Ploog, K., The Technology and Physics ofMolecular Beam Epitaxy, (E. H. C. Parker, ed.), pp. 647-679, Plenum Press, New York (1985) 57. Ploog, K. and Graf, K., Molecular Beam Epitaxy of III-V Compounds, A Comprehensive Bibliography 1958-1983, Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1984) 58. Kasper, E. and Bean J. C., SiliconMolecular CRC Press, Boca Raton, Florida (1988)
Beam Epitaxy, ~01s. I and II,
59. Tsao, J. Y., Materials Fundamentals ofMolecular Beam Epitmy, Academic Press, Boston (1993) 60. For recent developments in molecular beam epitaxy, see Proc. Int. Conf Molecular Beam Epitaxy, published by J. Crystal Growth (7th Conf. Schwab&h Gmtind, 1992; 6th Conf. San Diego, 1990; 5th Conf. Sapporo, 1988; 4th York, 1986). Also see Proc. of the North American Conf on Molecular Beam Epitaxy, (12th and 13th) and 11th Molecular Beam Epitaxy Workshop. These are published by American Vacuum Society in J. Vat. Sci. Technol. B, as are the earlier US workshop proceedings. 6 1. Salemink, H. W., and Pashley, M. D., (eds.), Semiconductor Interfaces at the Sub-Nanometer Scale, NATO AS1 Ser. E, vol. 243, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston (1993) 62. Larsen, P. K. and Dobson, P. J., Reflection High Energy Electron DtJraction and Reflection Electron Imaging of Surfaces, NATO AS1 Ser. B, vol. 188, Plenum, New York (1988) 63. Dhez, P. and Weisbuch C., (eds.) Physics, Fabrication andApplication of Multilayered Structures, NATO AS1 Ser. B, vol. 182, Plenum, New York (1988) 64. Parrish, M. and Ten&in, H., Gus Source Molecular Beam Epitaxy, SpringerVerlag, New York (1994) 65. Chand, N., Sergent, A. M., van der Ziel, J. P., and Lang D. V., J. Vat. Sci. Technol., B7:399 (1989) 66. PIiffer, L., West, K. W., Stormer, H. L., and Baldwin, K. W., Appl. Phys. Lett., 55:1888-1890 (1989)
67. Foxon, C. T. and Joyce, B. A., Surf Sci., 64:293 (1977) 68. SpringThorpe, A. J. andMandeville, P., J. Vat. Sci. Technol., B6:754-757
(1988) 69. Bremian, T. M., Tsao, J. Y., Hammons, B. E., Klem, J. F., and Jones, E. D., J. Vat. Sci. Technol., B7:277-291 (1989)
70. Evans, K. R., Stutz, C. E., Yu, P. W., and Wei, C. R., J. Vat. Sci. Technol., B8:271-275
(1990)
71. Evans, K. R., Kaspi, R, Jones, C. R, Sherriff, R E., Jogai, V., and Reynolds, D. C., J. Crystal Growth, 127:523-527 (1993) 72. Cho, A. Y., J. Appl. Phys., 47:2841 (1976)
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
161
73. Neave, J. H. and Joyce, B. A., J. Cryst. Growth, 44:387 (1978) 74. Larsen, P. K., Neave, J. H., van der Veen, J. F., Dobson, P. J., and Joyce, B. A., Phys. Rev. B, 27:4966 (1983) 75. Ludeke, R, King, R M., and Parker, E. H. C., The Technology and Physics of Molecular Beam Epitaxy, (I% H. C. Parker, ed.), Ch 16, pp. 555-628, Plenum Press, New York (1985)
76. Harris, J. J., Joyce, B. A., and Dobson, P. J., Surf: Sci., 103:L90 (1981); Harris, J. J., Joyce, B. A., and Dobson, P. J., Surf: Sci., 108L444-446 (1981) 77. Wood, C. E. C., Surf: Sci., 108L441-443 (1981) 78. Neave, J. H., Joyce, B. A., Dobson, P. J., and Norton, N., Appf. Phys., A31:l (1983) 79. Van Hove, J. M., Lent, C. S., Pukite, P. R., and Cohen P. I., J. Vuc. Sci. Technol., B1:741 (1983) 80. Lewis, B. F., Grunthaner, F. J., Madhukar, A., Lee, T. C., and Fernandez, R., J. Vuc. Sci. Technol., B3:1317-1322 (1985) 81. VanHove, J. M. and Cohen, P. I., Appl. Phys. Lett., 47:726 (1985) 82. Sakamoto, T., Kawamura, T., Hashiguchi, G., Appl. Phys. Lett., 48:1612 (1986) 83. Gunshore, R. L., Kolodzeijski, L. A., Melloch, M. R., Vaziri, M., Choi, C., and Otsuka, N., Appl. Phys. Left., 50:200-202 (1987)
84. Tsang, W. T., Chiu, T. H., Cunningham, J. E., and Robertson, A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 50:1376 (1987) 85. Mokler, S. M., Liu, W. K., Ohtani, N., and
Joyce, B. A., J. Vuc. Sci.
Technol., A10:1846-1855 (1992) 86. Madhukar, A., Physics of Quantum Electron Devices, (F. Capasso, ed.), 2: 13-90, Springer-Verlag, Berlin (1990) 87. McGuire G. E. and Holloway, P., Electron Spectroscopy: Theory, Techniques and Applications, 4: 1, (C. R Brundle and A. D. Baker, eds.), Academic Press, London (198 1) 88. Cho, A. Y. and Tracy, J. C., Jr., U. S. Patent 3969164 89. Cho, A. Y.,J. Appl. Phys., 47:2841 (1974) 90. Cheng, K. Y., Cho, A. Y., Wagner, W. R, and Bonner, W. A., J. Appl. Phys., 52:1015 (1981) 91. Pashley, M. D., Haberern, K. W., Friday, W., Woodal, J. M., and Kirchner, P. D., Phys. Rev. Lett., 60:2176-2179 (1988) 92. Pashley, M. D. and Haberern, K. W., SemiconductorInterfaces at the SubNanometer Scale, @I. W. Salemink and M. D. Pa&y, eds.), pp. 63-73,
NATO AS1 Ser. E, vol. 243, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston (1993)
162 Compound Semiconductors 93. Feenstra, R M., Strocio, J. A., Tersoff, J., andFein, A. P., Phys. Rev. Lett., 58:1192 (1987) 94. Biegelsen, D. K., Bringans, R D., Northrup, J. E., and Phys. Rev., B41:5701 (1990)
Swartz, L. E.,
95. Snyder, C. W., Bartlett, D., Orr, B. G., Battacharya, P. K., and Singh, J., J. Vuc. Sci. Technol., B9(4):2189-2193 (1991) 96. Vvdensky, Theory of Atomic Scale Processes During Epitaxial Growth: Current Status, Semiconductor Interfaces at the Sub-Nanometer Scale, (H. W. Salemink and M. D. Pashley, eds.), pp. 45-55, NATO AS1 Ser. E, vol. 243, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston (1993) 97. Madhukar, A. and Ghaisas, S. V., CRC Crit. Rev. Sol. State undkiuter. Sci., 14:l (1988) 98. Vvdensky, D. D., Clarke, S., Hugill, K. J., Myers-Beaghton, A. K., and Wilby, M. R., Kinetics of Ordering and Growth at Surfaces, (M. G.
Lagally, ed.), pp. 297-3 11, Plenum, New York (1990) 99. Dodson, B. W., CRC Crit. Rev. Sol. State andMater.
Sci., 16:115 (1988)
100. Hoover, W. G., DeGroot, A. J., and Hoover, C. G., Computers in Physics, 6:155 (1992)
101. Heckingbottom, R., The Application of Thermodynamics to Molecular Beam Epitaxy, in Molecular Beam Epitq and Heterostructures, (L. L. Chang and K. Ploog, eds.), pp. 71-104, NATO AS1 Ser. E., No 87, M. Nijhoff, Boston (1985) 102. Morris, F. J. and Fukui, H., J. Vat. Sci. Technol. 11:506-510 (1974) 103. Panish, M. B., J. Electrochem. 104
Sot. 127:2729 (1980)
Calawa, A. R., Appl. Phys. Lett. 38:701 (1981)
105. Panish, M. B., J. Crystal Growth, 81:249-260
(1987)
106. Liu, D. C., Lee, C. P., Tsai, K. L., Tsang, J. S., and Chen, H. R., Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 33:763 (1994)
107. Wicks, G. W., Koch, M. W., Varriano, J. A., Johnson, F. G., Wie, C. R, Kim, H. M., and Colombo, P., Appl. Phys. Lett., 59:342-344 (1991) 108. Variano, J. A., Koch, M. W., Johnson, F. G., and Wicks, G. W., J. ElectronMater., 21:195 (1992) 109. Johnson, F. G., Wicks, G. W., Vitarro, R E., and LaForce, R, J. Vat. Sci. Technol., Bl1:823-825 (1993)
110. Johnson, F. G., Wicks, G. W., Vitarro, R E., and LaForce, R, Proc. 1992 MRS Fall Meeting-Symposium D, pp. 49-54 (1993) 111. David, J. P. R, Hopkinson, M., Hill, G., Stavrinou, P., and Haywood, S. K., “Growth and characterization of InAsP/InP SQW and MQW PIN diode structures,” presented at the Fifth International Conference on InP and Related Compounds (April 1993)
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
163
112. Malik, J., J. Vat. Sci. Technol., B5:722 (1987) 113. Malik, J., Nottenberg, R N., Schubert, E. F., Walker, J. F., and Ryan, R W., Appl. Phys. Left., 53:2661 (1988) 114. Hoke, W. E., Lemonis, P. J., Lyman, P. S., Hendriks, H. T., Weir, D., and Colombo, P., J. Crystaf Growth, 111:269 (1991) 115. Ito, H. and Isbibasbi, T., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 3O:L944 (1991) 116. Malik, R. J., Nagle, J., Micovic, M., Harris, T. D., Ryan, R W., and Hopkins L. C., J. Vat. Sci. Technol., B10:85&852 (1992) 117. Hoke, W. E., Lemonis, P. J., Weir, D. G., Brierley, S. K., Hendricks, H. T., Alderstein, M. G., and Zaitlin, M. P., J. Vat. Sci. Technol., B10:856-858 (1992) 118. Ito, H., Nakajima, O., and Isbibasbi, T., Appl. Phys. Left., 62:2099 (1993) 119. Micovic, M., Evaldsson, P., Geva, M., Taylor, G. W., Vang, T., and Malik, R J., Appl. Phys. Left., 64:411-413 (1994) 120. Park, R. M., Troffer, M. B., Rouleau, M., DePuydt, J. M., and Haase, M. A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 57:2127-2129 (1990) 121. Veuboff, E., Pletschen, W., Balk, P., Ltitb, H., J. Crystal Growth, 55:3034 (1981) 122. Vojdani, N., Lemarcband, A., Paradan, H., Jounal de Physique, C5:339349 (1982) 123. Tsang, W. T., Appl. Phys. Lett., 45:1234-1236 (1984)
124. Tsang, W. T., Beam Processing Technologies, (N. G. Einspruch, S. S. Cohen, and R. N. Singh, eds.), Academic Press, New York (1989) 125. Boer, K. W., Survey ofSemiconductor Physics, (2 vols.), vol. 1, p. 15, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York (1992) 126. Wood, E. A., J. Appl. Phys., 35:1306-1312 (1964) 127. Cbadi, D. J., J. Vat. Sci. Technol., A5:834 (1987) 128. Biegelsen, D. K., Swartz, L.-E., Bringans, R D., J. Vat. Sci. Technol., A, 8:280 (1990) 129. Month, W., Semiconductor
Surfaces
and Interfaces,
Springer-Verlag,
Berlin (1993) 130. Farrell, H. H. andPalmstrom, C. J., J. Vat. Sci. Technol., A, 8:903 (1990) 131. Daweritz , L. and Hey, R., Surface Science, 236:15-22 (1990)
132. Joyce, B. A., Dobson, P. J., Neave, J. H., Woodbridge, K., Zbang, J., Larsen, P. K., and Boelger, B., Surf: Sci., 168:423 (1986) 133. Dobson, P. J., Joyce, B. A., Neave, J. H., and Zbang, J., J. Crys Growth, 81:1-8 (1987) 134. Fischer, R, Klem, J., Drummond, T. J., Tbome, R. E., Kopp, W., Morkoc, H., and Cho, A. Y., J. Appl. Phys., 54:2508-2510 (1983)
164
Compound Semiconductors
135. Foxon, C. T., Semiconductor Interfaces at the Sub-Nanometer Scale, NATO AS1 Ser. E, 243:57-61, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston (1993) 136. Sakaki, H., Tanaka, M., and Yoshino, J., Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 24:L417-420 (1985) 137. Tanaka M. and Shin&i, H., J. Cays. Growth, 81:153-158
(1987)
138. Tu, C. W., Miller, R C., Wilson, B. A., Petroff, P. M., Harris, T. D., Kopf, R F., Sputz, S. K., and Lament, M. G., J. 0y.s. Growth, 81:159-1163 (1987) 139. Bimberg, D., Christen, J., Fukunaga, T., Nakashima, H., Mars, D. E., and Miller, J. N., J. Vat. Sci. Technol., B4:1014 (1986) 140. Madhukar, A., Lee, T. C., Yen, M. Y., and Ghaisas, S. V., Appl. Phys. Lett., 46:1148 (1985) 141. Sakaki, H., Noda, T., Tanaka, M., Motohisa, J., Kadoya, Y., and Ikarashi, N., Semiconductor Interfaces at the Sub-Nanometer Scale, NATO AS1 Ser. E, 243:217-230 , Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston (1993)
142. Sakamoto, T., Funabashi, H., Ohta, K., Nakagawa, T., Kawai, N. J., Kojima, T., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 23:L657 (1984) 143. Sakamoto, T., Funabashi, H., Ohta, K., Nakagawa, T., Kawai, N. J., Kojima, T., and Bando, Y., Superlattice andMicrostructure, 1:347 (1985)
144. Sakamoto, T., Physics, Fabrication, and Applications of Multilayered Structures, NATO AS1 Ser. B, vol. 182,93-l 10, Plenum Press, New York (1987) 145. Horikoshi, Y. Y., Kawashima, M., and Yamaguchi, H., Jpn. J Appl. Phys., 25:L868 (1986) 146. Horikoshi, Y. Y., Kawashima, M., Yamaguchi, H., and Sato, M., Semiconductor Interfaces at the Sub-Nanometer Scale, NATO AS1 Ser. E,
243: l-10 Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston (1993) 147. Neave, J. H., Dobson, P. J., Joyce, B. A., and Zhang, J., Appl. Phys. Lett., 47:lOO (1985) 148. Sakaki, H., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 19:L735 (1980) 149. Sakaki, H., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 28:L314 (1989) 150. Sakaki, H., in Proc. Int. 1988 Symp. on GaAs and Related
Compounds
(Atlanta), p. 1 (1989) 151. Arakawa, Y. and Sakaki, H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 40:893 (1982) 152. Asada, M., Miyamoto, Y., and Suematsu, Y., IEEEJ. Quantum Electron.
QE-22:1915 (1986) 153. Yariv, A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 53:1033 (1988) 154. Miyamoto, Y., Miyake, Y., Asada, M., and Suematsu, Y., IEEEJ Quantum Electron., QE-25:2001 (1989)
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 165 155. Arakawa, Y., Vahala, K., and Yariv, A., Appl. Phys. Lett., 45:950 (1984) 156. Petroff, P. M., Gossard, A. C., and Wiegmann, W., Appl. Phys. Lett.,
45:620 (1984) 157. Gaines, J. M., Petroff, P. M., Kroemer, H., Simes, R. I., Geels, R S., and English, J. H., J. Vuc. Sci. Technol., B6:1378 (1988) 158. Petroff, P. M., Gaines, J., Tsuchia, M., Simes, R., Coldren, L., Kroemer, H., English, J., and Gossard, A. C., J. Cryst. Growth, 95:269 (1989) 159. Tanaka, M., and Sakaki, H., Appl. Phys. Lett. (1989) 160. Scott, E. G., Andrews, D. A., and Davis, G. J., J. Vuc. Sci. Technol., B4:534-535
(1986)
161. EPI Application Note, “On the use of dimeric arsenic in solid source
MBE,” August/September 1993, and references Hammond Road, Saint Paul, MN 55 110, USA.
therein, EPI, 1290
162. Gibson, E. M., Foxon, C. T., Zhang, J., and Joyce, B. A., J. Cryst. Growth, 105:81 (1990) 163. Foxon, C. T., Gibson, E. M., Zhang, J., Joyce, B. A., andLacklison, D. E., J. Cryst. Growth, 111:539 (1991) 164. Lacklison, D. E., Foxon, C. T., Zhang, J., Joyce, B. A., and Gibson, E. M., J. Cryst. Growth, 120:50 (1992) 165. Wright, S. L., Marks, R. F., and Goldberg, A. E., J. Vuc. Sci. Technol., B6:842 (1988) 166. Mizutani, T., J. Vuc. Sci. Technol., B6(6):1671-1677
(1988)
167. SpringThorp, A. J., Humphreys, T. P., Majeed, A., and Moore, W. T., Appl. Phys, Lett., 55:2138 (1989) 168. SpringThorpe, A, J. and Majeed, A. J. Vuc. Sci. Technol., B8:266-270 (1990) 169. Wright, S. L., Jackson, T. N., and Marks, R. F., J. Vuc. Sci. Technol., B8:288-292 (1990) 170. Grothe, H. and Boebel, F. G., J. Cryst. Growth, 127:1010-1013 (1993)
171. Hellman, E. S. andHarris, J. S.,J. Cryst. Growth, 81:3842
(1987)
172. Star&off, C. J., Turco-Sandroff, F. S., Florez, L. T., and Harbison, J. P., Appl. Phys. Lett., 59:1215 (1991) 173. Harbison, J. P., Aspnes, D .E., Studna, A. A., and Florez, L. T. J. Vuc. Sci. Technol., B6(2):740-742 (1988) 174. Robinson, D. J., Pidduck, A. J., Cullis, A. G., Chew, N. G., Hardeman, R.
W., Gasson, D. B., Pickering, C., Daw, A. C., Johnson, M., and Jones, R., J. Cryst. Growth, 81:421-427 (1987) 175. Briones, F., Golmayo, D., Gonzales, l., deMigue1, J. L., Jpn. J. Appl. Phys., 24:L478 (1985)
166
Compound Semiconductors
176. Smith, G. W., Pidduck, A. J., Whitehouse, C. R, Glasper, J. L., and Spowart, J.,J. Cryst. Growth 127:966-971 (1993) 177. Celii, F. G., Beam, E. A., III, Files-Sesler, L. A., Liu, H.-Y., and Kao, Y. C., Appl. Phys. Lett., 62:2705-2707 (1993) 178. Aspnes, D. E., Quiz
W. E., Tamargo, M. C., Pudensi, M. A. A., Schwarz, S. A., Brasil, M. J. S. P., Nahory, R E., and Gregory, S., Appl. Phys. Lett., 60:1244 (1992)
179. Maracas, G., Edwards, J. L., Shiralagi, K., Choi, K. Y., Droopad, R, Johs, B., and Woolam, J. A., J. Vuc. Sci, Technol., AlO: 1840-1832-1839 (1992) 180. Aspnes, D. E., Quinn, W. E., Tamargo, M. C., Gregory, S., Schwarz, S. A., Pudensi, M. A. A., Brasil, M. J. S. P., and Nahory, R. E., J. Vat. Sci. Technol., A10:1840-1841 (1992) 181. Ada&i, S., J. Appl. Phys., 58:Rl-R29
(1985)
182. Alavi, K., Aggarwal, R. L., Groves, S. H., J. Mugn. and Mugn. Muter., (Netherlund$, 11:136-138 (1979)
183. Alavi, K., Aggarwal, R. L., Groves, S. H., Phys. Rev. B, 22:1311-1315 (1980) 184. Ada&i, S., “Physical Properties of III-V Compounds: InP, InAs, GuP, InGuAs, and InGuAsP, ” J. Wiley and Sons, New York (1992) 185. Alavi, K., Ten&in, H., Wagner, W. R., Cho, A. Y., Appl. Phys. Lett., 42:254-256
(1983)
186. Alavi, K., Pearsall, T. P., Forrest, S. R., Cho, A. Y., Electron. 19:227-229 (1983)
Lett.,
187. Ten&in, H., Alavi, K., Wagner, R., Pearsall, T. P., Cho, A. Y., Appl. Phys. Lett., 42:845-847 (1983) 188. Alavi, K., Cho, A. Y., Capasso, F., and Allam, J., J. Vuc., Sci. Technol., B5: 802-807 (1987) 189. Fronius, H., Fisher, A., and Ploog, K., J. Cryst. Growth, 81:169 (1987) 190. Hekingbottom, G. J. R., Ohno, H., Wood, C. E. C., and Calawa, A. R., Appl. Phys. Lett., 37:290 (1980) 191. Gurmazd, A., in Semiconductor
Interfaces
at the Sub-Nanometer
Scale,
NATO AS1 Ser. E, 243:139-149, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston (1993) 192. Stradling, R. A., and Klipstein, P. C., (eds.) Growth and Churucteizution of Semiconductors, Adam Hilger, Bristol (1990) 193. Hozhabri, N., Hyer, R. C., Sharma, S. C., Ma, J. Y., Pathak, R. N., and Alavi, K., J. Vacuum Sci. Technol., B10:788-792 (1992) 194. McWhan, D. B., in Physics, Fabrication and Application of Multilayered Structures, NATO AS1 Ser. B, 182:67-92, Plenum, New York (1988)
Molecular Beam Epitaxy
167
195. People, R, Wecht, K. W., Alavi, K., and Cho A. Y., Appl. Phys. Lett.,
43:118-120 (1983) 196. Reynolds, D. C., Bajaj, K. K., Leak, C., Peters, G., Theis, W., Yu, P., Alavi, K., Colvard, C., and Shidlovsky, I., Phys. Rev. B, 37(6):3117-3119 (1988) 197. Reynolds, D. C., Bajaj, K. K., Peters, G., Look, D., Theis, W. M., Yu, P. W., Morkoc, H., Alavi, K., Colvard, C., and Shidlovsky, I., Superlattices undMicrostructures, 4(6):723-728 (1988) 198. Theis, W. M., Sanders, G. D., Leak, C. E., Reynolds, D. C., Chang, Y.-C. Alavi, K., Colvard, C., and Shidlovsky, I., Phys. Rev., B39(2):1442-1445 (1989) 199. Colvard, C., Bimberg, D., Alavi, K., Maierhofer, C., and Nouri, N., Phys. Rev., B, 39(5):3419-3422 (1989) 200.
Badakhshan, A. Glosser, R, Lambert, S., Anthony, M., Sillmon, R. S., Thompson, P. E., and Alavi, K., Appf. Phys. Lett., 59(10):1218-1220 (1991)
20 1. Badakhshan, A., Durbin, C., Glosser, R, Alavi, K., and Pathak, R, J. Vuc. Sci. Technol., Bl l(2): 169-174 (March/April 1993) 202. Sydor, M., Badakhshan, A., Dale, D. A., Alavi, K., and Pathak, R, Appl. Phys. Lett., 63(4):527-529
(1993)
203.
Goossen, K. W., Lyon, S. A., and Alavi, K., Phys. Rev., B, 36(17):93709373 (1987)
204.
Goossen, K. W., Lyon, S. A., and Alavi, K., Appl. Phys. Lett., 52(20): 17011703 (1988)
205.
Goossen, K. W., Lyon, S. A., and Alavi, K., Appl. Phys. Lett., 53(12): 10271029 (1988)
206.
Helm, M., Hilber, W., Fromherz, T., Peeters, F. M., Alavi, K., and Pathak, R. N., Phys. Rev., B, 48(3):1601-1605 (1993)
207. Helm, M., Hilber, W., Fromherz, T., Peeters, F. M., Alavi, K., and Pathak, R. N., Solid State Electronics, 37: 1277-1280 (1994) 208.
Shieh, C., Mantz, J., Colvard, C., Alavi, K., Engelmann, R., Smith, Z., and Wagner, S., Superlattices andMcrostructures, 4(4/5):5977-602 (1988)
209.
Jelley, K. W., Alavi, K., and Engelmann, 24(25):1555-1557
R. W., Electron. Lett.,
(1988)
210. Jelley, K., Engelmann, R., Alavi, K., Lee, H., Appl. Phys. Lett., 55:70-72 (1989) 211. Pathak, R. N., Wang, L. T., and Alavi, K., presented at Conference on Lasers andElectro-Optics, (CLEO ‘93), pp. 374-375, Baltimore, MD (27 May 1993)
168
Compound Semiconductors
212. Weber, E. R. (ed.), Imperfections in III/V Materials, Semiconductors and Semimetals, ~0138, @ K. Willardson and R Beer, Treatise eds.), Academic Press, New York (1993) 213. Smith, F. W., Calawa, A. R, Chen, C-L., Manfra, M. J., and Mahoney, L. J., IEEE Electron Device Lett., EDL9:77 (1988) 214. Kaminska, M., Liliental-Weber, Z., Weber, E. R., George, T., Kortright, J. B., Smith, F. W., Tsaur, B-Y., and Calawa, A. R, Appl. Phys. Lett., 54:1881 (1989) 2 15. Melloch, M. R., Gtsuka, N., Woodall, J. M., Warren, A. C., and Freeouf, J. L., Appl. Phys. Lett., 57: 153 1-1533 (1990)
216. Gupta, S., Bhattacharya, P. K., Pamulapati, J., and Mourou, G., Appf. Phys. Lett., 57: 1543-1545 (1990) 217. Nissim, E., and Rosencher E., (eds.), Heterostructures on Silicon: One Step Further with Silicon, NATO AS1 Ser., Ser. E, vol. 160, Kluwer Academic Publishers, London, 1989) 218. Shockley, W., U. S. Patent 2 569 347 (1951) 219. Kroemer, H., RCA Review, 18:332-342
(1957)
Kroemer, H., Proc. IEEE, 51:1782 (1963) 221. Capasso, F.,“Graded-gap and superlattice devices by bandgap engineering, ” in Semiconductors and Semimetals, (R. K. Willardson and R. Beer, Treatise editors), (6):319-395, Academic Press, New York (1987) 220.
222. Capasso F.,and Cho, A. Y., Surface Science, 229-230:878-891 223.
(1994)
Diihler, G. H., Doping Superlattices (“n-i-p-i Crystals”), pp. 1682-1695 in IEEE J. Quantum Electron., special issue, QE22, no. 9 (1986)
224. Dohler, G. H., Opt. and Quantum Electron. 22:S121-S140 (1990) 225. Schubert, E. F., Opt. and Quantum Electron. 22:S141 (1990) 226. Schubert, E. F., Tu, L. W., Zydzik, G. J., Kopf, R. F., Benvenuti, A., and Pinto, M. R., Appl. Phys. Lett., 60:466468 (1992) 227.
Schubert, E. F., Doping in III-V Semiconductors, Press, (1993)
Cambridge University
228. Esaki, L., in Molecular Beam Epitq and Heterostructures, NATO AS1 Ser. E., No 87, Boston (1985)
(l):l-36,
229. Cingolani, R., Ploog, K., Scamarcio, G., andTapfer, L., Opt. andQuantum Electron., 22:S201-S230(1990) 230. Dawson, P., Opt. and Quantum Electron., 22:S231-S241(1990) 231. Osboum, G. C., in J. Quantum Electron., pp. 1671-1681, special issue, QE22, no. 9, IEEE (1986) 232. Voisin, P., Proc. SPIE, 861:88-95 (1988)
Molecular Beam Epitaxy 233.
169
Kothiyal, G. P., Hong, S-C., Singh, J., and Bhattachaqa, P., Proc. SPIE, 861:102-108 (1988)
234. Adams, A. R, Heasman, K., and O’Reilly, E. P., in Band Structure Engineering in Semiconductor Microstructures, (R. A. Abrams and M. Jaros, eds.), NATO AS1 Ser. B, vol. 189, pp. 279-301, Plenum Press, New York (1989) 235. Tamargo, M. C., Hall, R, Green, L. H., Hayes, J. R., and Cho. A. Y., Appl. Phys. Lett., 46569-571 236.
(1985)
Tsang, W. T., in Semiconductors and Semimetals, (R. K. Willardson and R Beer, Treatise eds.), pp. 397-458, Academic Press, New York (1987)
237. Miller, R C., Gossard, A. C., Kleinmann, D. A., and Monteanu, O., Phys. Rev. B, 3215443-5446 (1984)
Physical and Chemical Deposition of Metals as Ohmic Contacts to InP and Related Materials Avlshay Katz
1.0
INTRODUCTION
Practically all semiconductor electronic and photonic devices receive and transmit power and signals through metallic contacts, which connect them to the external circuitry. Furthermore, an ohmic contact performs as an electrical communication link between the active region of the semiconductor device and the external circuit, which allows for a low-energy carrier transport mechanism through the contact volume and ensures a negligible voltage drop across it. Practically, ohmic contacts are to be considered and evaluated as narrow-barrier-width metal-semiconductor Schottky barriers, through which the majority of the carriers are tunnel-injected, enhanced by high dopant concentration in the interface region. Typically, these contacts are characterized by low Schottky barrier heights (up to about 0.4 eV) and present an almost linear relationship between the measured current and the voltage applied across the contact.11112j The processing parameters and performance of the metal-semiconductor structures, such as ohmic contacts, have been thoroughly studied due to their essential role in the performance of electronic and photonic devices. 170
Deposition of Metals as Ohmic Contacts to InP
171
These tremendous efforts resulted in significant improvement, both in the processing of high-precision nanostructure, highquality contacts, and in yielding an improved physical, electronic, and mechanical properties of the metal-semiconductor joint. This progress allowed to develop and manufacture high performance and high reliable ohmic contacts, which are essential for the operation of InP-based various electronic devices, such as field effect transistor (FET),131141junction field effect transistors (JFET),t41t51 high electron mobility transistor (HEMT), and heterojunction bipolar transistor (HBT),171181as well as for photonic devices such as long-wavelength laser diodes,lgll10l light-emitting diodes (LED),llil-[I31 and solar cells.I14l Yet, in spite of the achievements in processing high-quality ohmic contacts and controlling the mechanical, metallurgical, thermodynamic, kinetics, and electrical properties of the metal-semiconductor reacted interface, a relatively slim theoretical and practical understanding has been demonstrated in actually explaining and engineering the design of the Schottky barrier height and its formation mechanism.115ll16l The lack of knowledge, and in particular, the somewhat controversial experimental results which have not provided a clear correlation between the routinely measured metal-semiconductor contact properties such as the barrier height and the metal work functions, were interpreted in some theoretical models. One of these is a well structured model suggesting the Fermi-level pining formed as a result of inter-facial electronic states induced by mechanical defects1171-11gl and metal induced gap states (MIGS),1201-122jto be the origin for the above discrepancy. 1231124jThis mechanism suggests only a weak, second-order dependence of the Schottky barrier height in the metal-semiconductor system on the interfacial atomic structure, and thus, on the overall interfacial metallurgical reactions. Recent experimental results and, in particular, the excellent studies on epitaxial metal-semiconductor interfaces opposed the above theoretical mechanism, and actually demonstrated the importance of the interface structure on the nature of the