GOD SEEN BY SCIENCE: ANTHROPIC EVOLUTION OF THE UNIVERSE
A CONTRIBUTION OF SOPHIA-IBERIA TO THE METANEXUS CONFERENCE ...
19 downloads
748 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
GOD SEEN BY SCIENCE: ANTHROPIC EVOLUTION OF THE UNIVERSE
A CONTRIBUTION OF SOPHIA-IBERIA TO THE METANEXUS CONFERENCE 2008
GOD SEEN BY SCIENCE: ANTHROPIC EVOLUTION OF THE UNIVERSE CHRISTINE HELLER DEL RIEGO (EDITOR) Manuel G. Doncel Javier Monserrat Ignacio Núñez de Castro Agustín Udías
CÁTEDRA DE CIENCIA, TECNOLOGÍA Y RELIGIÓN
This book has been published by the Cátedra of Science, Technology and Religion in collaboration with the Program of Science, Technology and Social Ethics of the Engineering School ICAI of the Universidad Pontificia Comillas during the preparation of the centenary of its creation (1909-2009). The Program of Science, Tecnology and Social Ethics is supported by:
Printed by the Universidad Pontificia Comillas Alberto Aguilera, 23 28015 Madrid, Spain ISBN 978-84-8468-235-6
CONTENTS PROLOGUE BY CHRISTINE HELLER DEL RIEGO Why the anthropic principle? / 1 PART I: INTRODUCTION BY AGUSTÍN UDÍAS Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion / 5 PART II: TEILHARD DE CHARDIN BY AGUSTÍN UDÍAS Teilhard de Chardin and the Current Dialogue between Science and Religion / 45 BY IGNACIO NÚÑEZ DE CASTRO The Bio-Philosophy of Teilhard de Chardin / 61 BY MANUEL G. DONCEL Creation in Evolution: Philosophical and Theological Perspective / 79 PART III: BARBOUR, PEACOCKE AND POLKINGHORNE BY J AVIER MONSERRAT Science and Religion in Ian G. Barbour / 93 Science, Biochemistry and Panentheism in Arthur Peacocke / 115 John Polkinghorne, Science and Religion from theoretical physics / 131 PART IV: CONCLUSION BY MANUEL G. DONCEL The Kenosis of the Creator / 157 PART V: SOPHIA-IBERIA IN EUROPE / 173 MATTER /177 UNIVERSE / 185 LIFE / 191 MAN AND NEUROLOGY / 199 FORMAL SCIENCES: / 207 PHILOSOPHY AND THEOLOGY / 215
Why the anthropic principle?
PROLOGUE Why the anthropic principle? CHRISTINE HELLER DEL RIEGO UNIVERSIDAD PONTIFICIA COMILLAS, MADRID
The history of life on Earth is estimated in 50 billion species, of which only around 50 million are still alive today. Why consider the anthropic principle? If man has been evolutionarily possible, we must postulate, within a general evolutionary paradigm, that the ontology of primordial matter already had certain anthropic properties which made the organization of an anthropic universe possible. But how long will Homo Sapiens survive? Species either die outright, like dinosaurs, or they evolve into something different (“transformed out of existence”). As Denis Edwards puts it: “the loss of biodiversity is a theological issue”, especially when the extinction of other species is caused by human beings. Will man be able to control the environment and stop his own extinction or will we continue to evolve and eventually become something else? The Sophia Iberia Project is searching for the anthropic roots of human evolution. The reflection on the anthropic properties, which make the emergence of the human being from matter possible, is essential in order to correctly understand human nature, including the nature and the functional use of reason. However, we consider that the grand metaphysical questions of humanity and the questions on the final meaning of life remain open, in the new scientific image of the world. Therefore, Sophia-Iberia would like to go beyond the purely scientific by addressing the ideological, philosophical and theological problems from the point of view of science. The content of this book is an introduction to the general themes of the science-religion dialogue from the perspective of the Sophia-Iberia Project. The essays can be grouped as follows into four parts: I - A systematic historical introduction to the science-religion dialogue, written by Prof. Agustín Udías. II – Three essays on the teilhardian interpretation of the evolutionary process, written by Professors Agustín Udías, Ignacio Núñez de Castro and Manuel G. Doncel. III - Three essays that present and discuss the work of three great masters of the science and religion debate: Ian Barbour, Arthur Peacocke and John Polkinghorne, written by Prof. Javier Monserrat. IV - A conclusion by Prof. Manuel G. Doncel reflecting on the notion of the kenosis of a God Creator in nature. In order to present the description and the open questions of the Sophia-Iberia Project, six framework documents (Matter; Universe; Life; Man and Neurology; Formal Sciences; Philosophy and Theology) were written to help instigate the reflection on human evolution, that through science – which presents a universe in constant evolution that produced the human being – leads to the big questions that connect to metaphysics and theology. These documents were introduced during our Academic Conference, “Human Evolution: in search of our anthropic roots”, that took place in September 2007 in Madrid and are included here in Part V of this volume to stimulate interest and better understand the endeavour of the SophiaIberia Project.
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
1
Why the anthropic principle?
The introducción of A. Udías is not merely a history of the science-religion dialogue, but also a systematic analysis of its nature. Udías tells us that “Science, a term which we use here in its restricted sense as natural science, and religion are, undoubtedly, the two grand visions of the world. Although there are other visions, such as the artistic, these two have an extension and force which places them as the two most important ways of looking at the world. Science attempts to understand the nature of the material world which surrounds us, how it came about, how we know it and the laws which govern it. Religion seeks the meaning of life and the world, it transcends the material and puts man in contact with what lies beyond, the numinous, the mysterious, in short, with the mystery of God”. “Therefore, it is of much interest to study the relationships between these two grand visions of the world. The interaction between them goes back to the very origins of science in the first great civilisations and especially to the beginning of modern science in the XVI century. However, the explicit issue of the relationship between both originated in the XIX century. As we will see in detail, at that time people began to reflect on the relationship between science and religion and began to propose opinions on these. Opposing postures which were apologetic in both senses were frequent at the end of the XIX and the beginning of the XX century”. An exceptional protagonist and pioneer of the science-religion discussion in the Catholic Church was, without any doubt, Pierre Teilhard de Chardin. The development of his thoughts begins in the 1930’s and represent values that connect to the center of interest of SophiaIberia: the study of mankind in the dynamic evolutionary process of the cosmos and the first grand attempt to construct a “theology of science”; that is, an attempt to reformulate Christian theology from the new anthropology of modern science. For many jesuit scientists Teilhard has been over the last years a role model, although that does not imply that they ignore that Teilhard died in 1955 and that many of his intuitions probably need a critical reformulation. The article of A. Udías studies Teilhard from a point of view of his influence in the sciencereligion debate. In the next essay, I. Núñez de Castro offers a systematic exposition of the biophilosophy of Teilhard, followed by the essay of M. García Doncel who explains how the evolutionary ideas of Teilhard were extended by other relevant authors of the Catholic community. Karl Rahner reformulated his theology under the influence of teilhardian thought; but it was Karl Schmitz-Moormann who conceived a new developmental synthesis of Teilhard from the idea of a “cosmos created for freedom”. Finally, in the synthesis offered by Doncel, the interpretation of evolution in Christian theology would have encountered continuity in the vision of the “evolutionary cosmos” that has been recently proposed by Denis Edwards. The three articles of this set present the fertility of the evolutionary thought of Teilhard and some of its ramifications in the current Christian theology. The three essays of J. Monserrat also present a unified ensemble and complement the classical teilhardian perspective. Apart from Teilhard, in the last 30 years of the XX century, a series of important authors have been recognized as modern “maestros” in the reflection of science projected on Christian theology. Amongst others, three scholars of renowned prestige are: Ian Barbour, Arthur Peacocke and John Polkinghorne. Monserrat presents and discusses the work of these three grand authors, offering a synthesis of their thoughts that can be useful as a systematic introduction of them. These three articles, apart from their expositionary content, an indepth discussion from a precise point of view: the theology offer of kenosis. Science reveals a world where it is realistic to talk about God as creator. But it also reveals an enigmatic universe where God is not required and it is possible to construct an interpretation without God. A God that does not impose His presence in the world is a God that creates the cosmos as a scenario for human freedom.
2
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Why the anthropic principle?
The logic of the essays collected in this volume can very well lead us to conclude that the “theology of kenosis” is the “theology of science” that permits a description of the scientifictheological reflections at the beginning of the XXI century. That is why this book concludes with a text written by M. G. Doncel about the kenosis of the Creator. Doncel tells us that “Beyond these time-space elements of the kenosis of the Creator, the anthropic elements are related to human beings –or in general to free and responsible creatures. Without a doubt, the most radical of this kenosis is the acceptation that such creatures do not correspond to his loving plan, but that they reject Him as God, in other words, the permission of sin. Such permission appears a necessary condition in order that a true created freedom can exist”. The aim of this book was to offer the participants of the Metanexus Conference 2008 a series of essays and documents prepared by members of Sophia-Iberia. It was conceived as a collection of introductory lectures on the field of transcendent reflections: the image of the numinous, of God, of the theological, of the diverse religious traditions, of the Christian theology … that can be constructed from an anthropology based on the results of modern science. The basic reading material that is compiled here can be completed with the essays presented in the first two volumes of the series “Ciencia, Filosofía y Religión” of the Journal PENSAMIENTO. Many questions remain unanswered along with challenging fields of research that should continue to be developped to create a new culture in which reflection on science allows us to know what we can freely expect in the future of the enigmatic metaphysical dimension of the universe.
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
3
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
PART I: INTRODUCTION Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion AGUSTÍN UDÍAS UNIVERSIDAD COMPLUTENSE, MADRID 1. Two visions of the world Science, a term which we use here in its restricted sense as natural science, and religion are, undoubtedly, the two grand visions of the world. Although there are other visions, such as the artistic, these two have an extension and force which places them as the two most important ways of looking at the world. Science attempts to understand the nature of the material world which surrounds us, how it came about, how we know it and the laws which govern it. Religion seeks the meaning of life and the world, it transcends the material and puts man in contact with what lies beyond, the numinous, the mysterious, in short, with the mystery of God. No one can doubt the importance of science and its practical consequences for the lives of men. The lives of modern men are progressively more influenced by science and its applied side, technology, and is the vision which most impresses. It is difficult for man today to conceive of the world without the progress which technology puts within his reach, which provide him with possibilities unknown before and which penetrate all aspects of his life. To mention only a few, there is transport and communications which have transformed the Earth into a global village. The speed and facility of transport have meant that intercontinental travel is today a normal experience. The rapid extension of the mobile telephone, even in underdeveloped countries, the PC and access to the Internet are essential instruments in today’s world. In addition, there is the enormous progress made by medicine which has extended life expectancy to levels never achieved before. Behind technology is science which contains the basis which makes the functioning of all this progress possible. Science, especially, provides man with an image of the universe, knowledge of the structure of matter, of the mechanisms of life, of what man himself is, in short, of the reality that surrounds us. Terms which were unknown until a few years ago, such as nuclear power, quarks, the big-bang, DNA and the genome, have become familiar to us, although most persons have only a confused idea of what they mean. Today we cannot doubt the primacy of science and technology in the lives of men. We live in a culture which has a profound dependence on technology for its functioning and well-being and on science for its understanding of reality. Religion whose roots go back to the first vestiges we have of primitive man and which plays a determining role in the first cultures, today continues to be an important factor in the lives of men. Structured in the different religious traditions and forming communities united by shared beliefs and rites, religions continue to offer man another vision of the world, which is not limited to the scope of the purely natural, but rather opens up to transcendent realities, man can enter into contact with. On the horizon, recognised by different names depending on the traditions, is the reality of God, recognised as the source of religious experience. Despite the secularising tendencies, which we will speak of below, in the more developed countries and those which are God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
5
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
most influenced by the technical scientific phenomenon, religion continues to be a living force which cannot be ignored. Faced with these two visions of the world, it should not surprise us that, in 1925, the North American philosopher Alfred N. Whitehead mentioned that, “when one considers what religion represents for humanity and what science is, it is not an exaggeration to say that the future course of history depends on the decision this generation takes regarding the relation between these. Here we have the two general, strongest forces which influence man and which seem to place themselves against each other, the force of our religious intuitions and the force of our impulse to make precise observations and logical deductions”1. After more than 80 years have passed since Whitehead wrote those words, the problem continues to be alive and the relationship between the two grand visions of the world continue to be a preoccupation. Edward O. Wilson, biologist and creator of socio-biology, stated in a recent interview that, “science and religion are the two most powerful forces in the world. I beg the religious persons…to leave aside their differences with materialist lay persons and scientists like me, and join us to save the planet”2. Wilson recognises the force of science and religion and the need for them to unite to save nature threatened by man himself. Therefore, it is of much interest to study the relationships between these two grand visions of the world. The interaction between them goes back to the very origins of science in the first great civilisations and especially to the beginning of modern science in the 16th century. However, the explicit issue of the relationship between both originated in the 19th century. As we will see in detail, at that time people began to reflect on the relationship between science and religion and began to propose opinions on these. Opposing postures which were apologetic in both senses were frequent at the end of the 19th and the beginning of the 20th century. After the Second World War, new more conciliatory attitudes began to extend, at the same time as this matter became an academic discipline with specific courses in many universities, especially in the AngloAmerican environment. The Templeton Foundation, whose centre is in Philadelphia, has awarded 1000 of these courses each year since 1995. This Foundation was established by the financier John Templeton in 1987 and dedicates all its endeavours to encouraging activities related to the dialogue between science and religion. Since 1972, Templeton has granted a special award to the most outstanding personalities who have distinguished themselves in the progress of research or discovery concerning spiritual realities and the dialogue between science and religion. The monetary allocation of this award is greater than that of the Nobel Prize. One of the most active centres in the study of the relationship between science and religion is the “Center for Theology and the Natural Sciences” (CTNS), founded in 1981 in the multi-confessional school of Theology “Graduate Theological Union” in Berkeley, California. The CTNS organises courses and seminars every year in several parts of the world on subjects related to the dialogue between science and religion and has been publishing the Theology and Science journal since 2003. The oldest journal dealing with this subject and the most prestigious is, Zygon, published in Chicago, by several organisations, especially the “Institute on Religion in an Age of Science” (IRAS) founded in 1954. Among more than 50 organisations throughout the world dedicated to this subject due to its proximity and importance is the “European Society for the Study of Science and Theology” (ESSSAT), which holds biannual meetings from 1986. 2. Three focuses 1
Alfred N. Whitehead, 1925. Science and the Modern World. New York: The Free Press, 181-182.
2
Interview made to Edward O. Wilson. El País, Sunday June 11, 2006.
6
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
The relationship between science and religion can be focused from several points of view. The most important among these can be grouped into three, the historical, the epistemological and the sociological. Religion and science are cultural phenomenons which have been present throughout history. Sometimes there is the danger of supposing that science begins with modern science of the Renaissance, and we forget the previous developments. This is a serious error as the birth of modern science cannot be understood without the previous scientific developments. Going back to the dawn of science in ancient times we can find interactions with religion. Of special interest is the relationship between Christianity and science, as modern science begins precisely in Western Christianity. This relationship begins with the first Christian authors of the third century and continues to our days. Sometimes erroneous conclusions on this relationship are simplified and presented when its passage through time is not taken into account. The historical focus is, therefore, essential if we are to achieve a correct vision of the problem. Religion and science constitute forms to approach reality, that is to say, forms of knowledge with their distinct peculiarities. Therefore, it is important to study the different natures of each of these and the relationship which can be established between scientific and religious knowledge. This reflection belongs to the field of philosophy. Philosophical reflection and specifically epistemological reflection are essential for understanding the relationship between science and religion as forms of knowledge. Faith and religious experience form the foundation of religious knowledge which is formalised in theology, while scientific knowledge is formed by the formal framework of laws and theories, related to an empirical base of experiments and observations. To clearly establish the nature and the limits of these types of knowledge is fundamental if we are to correctly establish the relationship between both. Religion and science are also social phenomena. Their sociological aspects are, therefore, very important for knowing the relationship between them. This aspect is less well known and is rarely taken into account. Science and religion form two complex social systems which group individual and collective experiences and which have their norms and standards of conduct which give rise to the formation of communities with their own types of knowledge and languages. Both communities interconnect with society in general through codes of acceptance, prestige, etc and, therefore, contact each other. The assertion of positions of social influences has led, at times, to confrontations between them. The regulatory incidence of religion on the conduct which leads to ethical proposals interacts with the practice of science, which cannot ignore the ethical problems which might arise regarding science. The growing preoccupation of society concerning ethical problems related to science today opens up new field for relationships with religious thought. 3. Presupposition for interaction Before briefly analysing what is understood by science and religion, we must take some previous considerations into account. In the first place, let us consider what we understand by experience. This is a very general concept which groups together diverse types of interaction of the person with reality and the other persons surrounding him. Experiences occur at different levels. There is a level which we can call daily experience, which constitutes the least developed and reflective level of our daily contacts with the reality in which we live. This experience is often taken for granted, and is full of automatic reactions so that it remains at the non-reflective level. At this level, we accept the reality of our environment with no critical reactions. If we turn this God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
7
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
daily experience into a reflective experience our lives would become a martyrdom. The experience of our relationship with other persons has a special character within this first level. In this regard, when we leave the first level, a special personal relationship in which we recognise the other is established with the person we know with a knowledge which is different from daily realities in which persons might be present, but we do not communicate with them personally. These types of experiences imply the recognition of a communication in which we are known and know and in which mutual emotional relationships are established. Beyond these two types of experiences there are a variety of more reflective experiences which include different types of activities, for example, the artistic, in the fields of literature, music, painting or sculpture. Listening to good music or looking at a beautiful painting are special types of experiences. Again the same can be said of the study of any subject. With regard to the subject in question, we must speak of the religious experience and the scientific experience. These are two types of very different experiences which must be borne in mind. The religious experience has many different forms, depending on the levels and the religious traditions the person participates in. In general, one can speak of faith as an essential component of this experience, as we shall see below. Recognising this experiential level of religion is very important if we want to establish its relationship with science correctly. On the other hand, scientific experience is related to the practice of science, in the empirical aspect of observations and experiments or in the more formal aspect of theoretical developments involved in its desire to understand natural phenomena. A new discovery is an unrepeatable experience of the understanding of an aspect of nature for the scientist. The human group which participates in the same type of experience forms a community. From this point of view, we can speak of the religious community and the scientific community. Here the sociological aspects we spoke of before come into play. Belonging to a community entails the acceptance of a number of presuppositions which are normative and standards of conduct. The communities are subdivided into smaller, specific communities, as, for example, in the case of religion, are the different religious traditions and the different churches within the Christian community. Within the scientific community are the different sciences, such as physics, chemistry, biology, etc and within each of these, other communities with more restricted specialities. In religion and in science, the communities are subdivided into smaller groups with more specific aims such as theoretical physics or Benedictine monks. We will see later how, in these social aspects, there are more similarities among the scientific and religious communities than is generally thought. One person can belong to several communities and sub-communities and, specifically, can participate in both the scientific and the religious community. The form of communication of the experiences within a community determines the language of each one of these. Each community develops its own language adapted to the type of experience it wants to communicate. Specialization in a type of specific experiences leads to the development of languages which are progressively less understandable outside the community. This creates a difficulty in communication between different communities. It is well known that there is a difficulty to establish points of view which are truly interdisciplinary and even the less demanding multidisciplinary. In our case, the peculiarities and idiosyncrasies of religious and scientific languages and the difficulty which might exist as regards establishing a dialogue between them. We must be aware of the linguistic barriers which must be overcome in order to establish a true relationship between science and religion. 8
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
4. Science and technology It is advisable to establish some basic ideas on what constitutes science and what constitutes religion. It is not easy to define science. In 1998 the American Physical Society proposed achieving a definition of science which most scientists would agree to. After several formulations the project was abandoned due to the lack of agreement. The definition which was most acceptable defined science as , “a disciplined search in order to understand nature in all its aspects ... requiring an open and complete exchange of ideas and data ... and an attitude of scepticism regarding its own results”. Stress was laid on the fact that the results must be capable of being reproduced, modified or falsified by independent observers and, finally, that the scientists value other complementary points of view and methods to understand nature, but if the alternatives can be called scientific, they must comply with the principles proposed3. The proposal was due to the preoccupation of the scientists concerning the attention given to many proposals by the public, such as astrology and paranormal phenomena, which should be termed pseudoscience. According to John Ziman, a physicist and philosopher of science, science can be defined as a human activity directed at the organised knowledge of nature, based on observation and experiment and expressed in laws and theories, through an unequivocal public language (ideally mathematical), guaranteed by the controls of the scientific community4. In this definition, stress is laid on the dynamic character of science and its two most important components which are the empirical basis of observations and experiments and the formal framework of laws and theories. Science is characterised as public knowledge and it endeavours to achieve an unequivocal formal language, unbound by cultural contexts and whose ultimate ideal is mathematical language. Similar to this definition is the one given recently by V. V. Raman which defines it as: a collective intellectual effort of the human mind in order to understand the aspects of the world as a perceived reality in terms of conceptual categories with the aid of mathematical analysis and a crafted instrumentation5. These two definitions are only a sample of the many which have been proposed, and their presentation at this point is aimed only at making a first approach to its difference with religion. From the point of view of the practice of science, the distinction proposed by Ziman between “academic science” and “industrial science” can help6. The former refers to the science practised in universities and research centres and corresponds to what is sometimes called “pure science” or “fundamental science”, with characteristics focused on the search for knowledge of the world around us. The latter is science directed or sponsored by industry with more specific objectives which are more related to technology and is sometimes called “applied science”. The practice of science which we know today is a relatively recent phenomenon, which has been developed since the end of the 18th and the beginning of the 19th century, especially with the reformation of the European universities and the industrial revolution. Previous to this time, science was practised by individuals, with only some institutions, such as the Royal Society of London, created in 1642 or the Académie de Sciences of Paris in 1666. Ziman insists that, until the 1950s, these two types of science were clearly differentiated, but today, science has new
3 4 5 6
C. Macilwain, 1998. Physicists seek a definition of science. Nature 392, 849. J. Ziman, 1978. La credibilidad de la science. Madrid: Alianza, especially 13-25. V.V. Raman, 2004. Science and Religion: some demarcation criteria. Zygon 36, 541-556. J. Ziman, 2000. Real Science. What it is and what it means. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
9
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
characteristics where this difference is being deleted and he calls the new science “postacademic”. Related to science is technology which can be defined as the application of scientific knowledge to the resolution of practical problems, related to the needs of individuals and society in several areas (healthcare, transport, communications, production of energy, weapons, etc.). Behind technology, there is always scientific knowledge which it is based on. The separation of these components is becoming more and more difficult today. The scientific projects which are today termed big science, for example, the space programme or the large particle accelerators, involve a large number of scientists and engineers where the scientific and the technological part are closely united. The growing combination of the two leads us to consider them to be a single phenomenon called “technoscience”. This combination of science and technology corresponds in a way to what Ziman has called the post-academic era of science. 5. Characteristics of science With the sole objective of clarifying the relationship between science and religion it is important to propose some of the characteristics of science. In the first place, we find experimentation, that is to say, the reference to experiments and observations. Without this reference it is not possible to speak of a proposition as scientific. The logical positivists, involved in establishing the criteria which separate scientific knowledge from what is not scientific, proposed the verifiability in experience as criteria. Although it was later seen that this criteria cannot be made in the strict form, the empirical basis of science is an essential component. Scientific knowledge must always be related to observations and experiments, although this relationship is not always easy to establish. The second component is formalization, that is to say, the inclusion of observational components within a formal framework of laws and theories. This formal framework constitutes the nucleus of science. When we speak of scientific knowledge, we refer to the laws and theories which explain or describe the conduct of nature. This formal framework must be expressed with unequivocal language, unbound by cultural or social limitations. The ideal language is mathematical due to the level of formalisation and its independence from other conditioners. A mathematical equation means the same for any person of any culture. The process of mathematisation of science, however, limits the aspects of nature to be considered in science to those which are somehow susceptible to measurement. This limitation must be taken into account. A third important component of science is publicity. Observations, experiments and scientific languages must be public, recognisable and repeatable by all. The repeatability of the experiments is a necessary condition if they are to be considered as scientific. The results of an experiment or an observation which cannot be repeated and verified by other researchers cannot be considered to be part of science. This component is very related to what is called “scientific objectivity”. This is a complex problem, as we will see below, however, we must say that we cannot naively consider “objectivity” as an absolute correspondence with reality. Objectivity in science must be understood to be the property of inter-subjective or co-participated knowledge which is guaranteed by the scientific community. This is how the concepts of validity or truth must also be understood (the latter must be employed with extreme care) as these are finally based on the acceptance of the scientific community under controls in reference always to empirical data7. Although it is a little surprising, the scientific community is really the 7
10
The critique of Ziman is very enlightening in this matter which he calls scientific objectivity (Ziman, God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
ultimate guarantor of the reliability of science. However, we can “trust” in the results of science for the security offered by the controls which are imposed by the scientific community. A final component which must be considered is the relationship between scientific knowledge and reality. This is a complicated, difficult problem involving a range of positions which go from naïve realism to pure instrumentalism. The former sustains that the propositions of science directly correspond to reality and the latter that these are mere instruments which make it possible to describe phenomena. Throughout history, the analysis of scientific knowledge has led to many intermediary critical attitudes. This problem is also very important as regards establishing the relationships between science and religion. In a way, both refer and relate though in different ways to the real world in which we live. 6. Classification of the sciences In accordance with the fundamental nature of the subjects dealt with, the sciences can be classified as follows: physics – chemistry – biology – psychology – sociology. The first three form the natural sciences and the last two the human sciences, as the subject of study of these is man and the relationships between men. Geology and geography and other sciences related to these, such as geophysics, meteorology and oceanography are applications of physics, chemistry and biology to the phenomena of the earth. Astronomy and astrophysics can be considered as applications of physics to cosmological phenomena and the nature of stars. Medicine can be considered to be an application of biology to human pathology and is astride science and technology. The sciences directly related to technology constitute the branches of engineering. Mathematics constitutes the ideal formal language of all the sciences. Physics is the most mathematised science and its theories must always be presented in mathematical form; therefore, it only deals with quantifiable components of nature. Other sciences have not yet achieved this level of mathematisation and they involve many qualitative and descriptive components. That all sciences must finally reach a total level of mathematisation, as in physics, is a debatable problem. Also under discussion is whether all the phenomena of nature, including those regarding man and human affairs can be treated mathematically. The separation between the different sciences is somewhat artificial and today there are intermediate sciences between two, such as biochemistry and chemistry-physics. In the classification we have given, the content of the phenomena dealt with in each science is more complex than the content of the preceding one. Therefore, each science is based on the preceding one although it is not quite reduced to this. For example, although biology is based on chemistry, its study of living beings is not totally reduced to the principles of chemistry, nor to those of physics. Physics deals with the most elementary particles of the constitution of matter and the forces operating between them, thus, it is at the base of all other sciences. However, it cannot be said that the other sciences only apply physical principles to progressively more complex phenomena. Each science has its own principles, and, although there is a language common to all the sciences, each one has also its own language. Thus, the sciences which deal with man, such as psychology and sociologic are based on their own
2000). God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
11
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
principles. The proposal that the principles of each science are based totally on those of the preceding science is known as “reductionism”. 7. Religion and theology Just as we have found it difficult to propose a definition of science, the same problem exists with the definition of religion. Given the extreme complexity and variety of the religious phenomenon, it is not easy to find a definition which takes in all its common components. Sometimes, in order to apply it to movements which somehow participate in the characteristics of religion, but are not considered as such totally, the term “religiosity” is used. In this regard, as we shall see below, today we speak of “natural religiosity”. Both religion and religiosity, generally, can be considered to be systems of beliefs generating a meaning of life and values which guide personal and social conduct, which are generally expressed in rites and which may found communities. We have included in this description, rather than a definition, several components which appear in the majority of religions or religiosities. In the first place, we include faith or belief which supposes the acceptance of a reality which is not strictly demonstrated rationally, although it may be rational. We mean that the basics of religion cannot be strictly demonstrated although there are signs which move us to accepting it. The objective of religion is not to explain the functioning of the world and its material structure, but to discover the meaning of existence of the world and of man. The provision of principles to guide human conduct is also proper to religion and religiosity. For the person who adheres to a religion this implies a conduct in life. This is another aspect which differentiates religion from science, which in itself does not imply any type of principles as regards the conduct of scientists. In the area of religion we can distinguish religion, properly speaking, as what maintains the acceptance of a reality (God), above the material, transcendent or immanent, who man can relate to and is structured in religious traditions which create communities of life. More diffusely, we can consider as religious those attitudes which affect the vision of the universe and the relationships between men and which, in some cases, suppose a certain acceptance of the presence of the numinous or mysterious. Today we also speak of a natural or naturalist religiosity, which does not imply the presence of mystery and includes only the purely natural. Related to religion and religiosity is the use today of the term spirituality, whose meaning is not very precise and is sometimes contradictory, and commences from the interior and mystical dimension of the person and human experience. In general, spirituality is related to religions, thus we speak of Christian or Buddhist spirituality, but spirituality can also be referred to attitudes based on the acceptance of cosmic forces or a universal mind, which transcend the limits of a strictly materialist interpretation. However, it is also possible to speak of a naturalist spirituality, which does not entail the presence of the numinous, but accepts a spiritual dimension of reality which can be contained in the purely natural. Theology constitutes the structured formulation of religious thought. Although the term itself, according to its Greek roots, means science or discourse (logos) concerning God (Theos), more generally it can be applied to any formalisation of religion or religiosity, even though this does not involve a clear idea of divinity. In the 11th century, St. Anselm of Canterbury defined Christian theology as the faith which seeks to understand (fides quaerens intellectum). This concise definition, often cited today, connects the two parts of the theological task, faith which is the basis of the religious attitude and understanding which represents the search for a reason to clarify this. 12
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
Although theology, in the strict sense, is traditionally referred to Christian thought, the term can also be applied to other religious traditions and one can speak of an Islamic and Hindu theologies. The similarity of the theological task and the scientific task has led some authors to consider the relationship of science and theology rather than the relationship with religion. 8. Levels of religiosity The phenomena of religion and religiosity are very complex, and this can be appreciated in the high number of different religions and the divisions among each of these. Besides the religions, which are clearly definable as such, there are personal attitudes which are not linked to any religious communities and which we can group under the term of religiosities. All of these are difficult to classify. Simply, and possibly in a simplistic manner, it is possible to establish a gradation in religiosity in accord with a greater presence of acceptance of the idea of God and His action in the world in the following five degrees: Naturalist: There is no reality beyond the natural which can be materialist or spiritualist. Of mystery: Accept the existence of an unachievable mystery which manifests itself in nature with no personal character. Pantheist: God is identified with all reality. There is no separation of God and the world. Deist: The existence of a transcendent God, creator and designer, but he does not intervene in the world. Theist: God is creator and provident with a personal character and intervenes in the world and relates with man. Besides these positions, the negative positions of atheism and agnosticism which explicitly deny the idea of divinity or the possibility to know divinity must be taken into consideration. 8.1. Naturalist religiosity Naturalist religiosity is a relatively recent current whose major presence is in North America and is acquiring a growing importance. This involves the attempt to generate attitudes, traditionally linked to religion, such as the search for meaning, a reverential sentiment regarding life, contact with the totality of reality, recognition of human confraternity, respect for nature, etc., from the sole acceptance of the reality of the sensitive world. This religiosity may have a materialist character if only the existence of matter is admitted, or spiritualist if spiritual realities are accepted, but with no connection with anything supernatural. It involves the search for the meaning of reality from pure naturalness, with the acceptance of the finiteness of all that is natural (the death of the individual, of humanity, of the universe) and the proposal of a purely natural ethic. In some tendencies, stress is laid on a sense of reverence for nature, as expressed by the astrophysicist Carl Sagan. This attitude is present in some ecologist movements. Sometimes laicism also has naturalist religiosity characteristics and people speak of a “sacred laicism” (sacré laicité). Although there are many tendencies in this religiosity, the following principles can be proposed as being basic to them. The first is that only the world of nature is real, that is to say, all reality is reduced to the purely natural, and it is not possible to speak of any kind of transcendence. The second, nature is necessary in itself, that is to say, it does not God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
13
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
require any reason beyond itself to explain its origin, its existence, or ontological foundation. From these two principles it follows that nature, as a whole, can be totally understood without having to propose any other reality on which it depends, nor any other finality beyond itself. Therefore, in nature, as regards each event which takes place in it there are only natural reasons. Naturalism implies a materialist or physical vision of reality although some versions accept spiritual realities, only accepted as aspects of nature. 8.2. Religion of mystery Under this heading we understand the attitudes of some scientists who see the presence of a sense of the mysterious in the rationality of the universe, inexplicable by science. This type of religiosity is differentiated from the previous one as it accepts the presence of something mysterious, not understandable by science and beyond the purely natural, which is sensed and revealed in the order of the universe. This type of religiosity is described by Albert Einstein when he says, “The most beautiful and most profound experience which a man can have is the sense of the mysterious. This is the founding principle of religion, as it is of all scientific and artistic undertakings”; he later stated, “Feeling that, behind each thing we can experiment, there is something our minds cannot understand and whose beauty and sublimity only reaches us indirectly like a weak reflection, this is religiosity. In this sense, I am religious” and also, “Below all the relationships discernible, there is something subtle, intangible, inexplicable. The veneration of this force beyond all we can understand is my religion.”8 These words of Einstein show us this type of religiosity, which is also found in other scientists and is founded in the acknowledgement of a mystery which can be discovered in the Universe, beyond our understanding, which is not identified with the world itself, but does not have the characteristics of a personal, creator God. 8.3. Pantheism, deism and theism These three types of religious positions have in common the fact that they accept an idea of God, as a being understood in some way as the root of the world. The two basic ideas which must be taken into account are the immanence and transcendence of God, which appear to a greater or lesser extent in each religious tradition. Immanence describes the presence of God in the world and transcendence his being beyond it. In pantheism, which has many versions, stress is laid on immanence to achieve identification of God with the world and the world with God. The relationship between the world and God is, therefore, that of identification. The grand religious traditions of the East such as Hinduism, Buddhism and Taoism are strongly pantheist. At the opposite end is the idea of a totally transcendent God, separated from the world that has been created by Him. Both deism and theism affirm the existence of a transcendent, creator God, the difference between them is that, for the former, once God created the world, he no longer intervenes in it. The world functions like a machine, to which God has given its laws and which he leaves to function by itself. This mentality was in vogue during the 18th and 19th centuries among the authors of the Enlightenment and is often related to a deterministic mentality derived in part from Newtonian physics. Theism sustains a creator, provident God, who acts in the world and is both transcendent and immanent. The problem this poses as regards science is how the action of God in the 8
14
A. Einstein, Ciencia y Religion, in K. Wilber, 1987. Cuestiones cuánticas. Barcelona: Kairós, 161170. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
world must be understood without violating the laws of its functioning. The three traditions of Judaism, Christianity and Islam are theist religions. The emphasis on the immanent or transcendent character of God has also consequences regarding the relationships between science and religion. 8.4. Atheism and agnosticism The two negative attitudes to the religious vision are formed by atheism and agnosticism. The former implies the explicit negation of God and any recourse to any type of supernatural reality9. Atheism is present in what we have called naturalist religiosity, but is more frequent in the absence of all religiosity. A distinction is normally made between theoretical and practical atheism. The latter is confused with the attitude of indifference as regards all religious values in practical life. The former which implies a positive position against any idea of God, sometimes involves also aggressive attitudes against all religious thought. It is also possible to distinguish several currents in theoretical atheism. Among these is what we can call scientific atheism, which can also be called scientific materialism, which extends the non consideration of God in the scientific explanation of nature, to the negation of God in all other areas of reality. Another type of atheism, sometimes called moral, is based on the existence of evil as incompatible with the existence of God. The scandal of evil becomes the decisive argument against the existence of a God, who must be both goodness and power. The apparent contradiction between the existence of God and the freedom of man is the basis of humanist atheism. If God exists, it argues, freedom of man can only be illusory. In practice this atheism leads to the proposal that it is necessary to destroy religion so that man can be capable of thinking and acting with no mirages. In this view Marx denounced religion as the opium of the people. In the same line of thought, Freud denounced religion as a sedative in a world in which man is subject to too much suffering and deceptions. Agnosticism, a word invented by Thomas Huxley, the propagator of the evolutionist doctrine of Darwin, sustains that it is impossible that man can know the existence or nature of any transcendent reality. Agnisticism does not establish an explicit negation of God, it remains in the attitude which defends that nothing can be known about God, not even His existence. For the agnostic the existence or nonexistence of God can never be established and the most reasonable attitude is not to opt for one or other in this question. This position, which withdraws from both the acceptance of God’s existence and the explicit negation of God, is frequently found in scientific environments. 8.5. The grand religious traditions In the first place, we should recognize the generality and majority character of religion in the world and the richness and variety of its expressions. In fact, according to the Encyclopaedia Britannica (2000), in the world 85% of people acknowledge that they are religious, while only 15% are non-religious or atheists. At global level the main religious traditions group together the following figures, in millions and in percentages of the total religious population, Christianity 1974 millions, 33%; Islam 1155 millions, 20%, Hinduism 799 millions, 13%, Buddhism 356 millions, 6%, Taoism 382 millions, 6%. In Europe considering the total number of inhabitants, Christianity accounts for 559 million, 77%, Islam 31 million, 4% and the number of those who declare that they are not religious amount to 130 million, 18%. These figures respond to statistics which 9
H. Küng, 1979. ¿Existe Dios? Madrid: Cristiandad, 269-463. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
15
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
count religious persons as those who declare themselves as such, regardless of how they practice their religions. This should be taken into account when judging certain statistics on the religions which often reflect the positions taken up by those who implement these and interpret them. Here it is sufficient to say that, despite the secularised tendencies of the modern world, religion continues to be a majority phenomena. Among the plurality of religious forms there follows a brief description of what we consider to be the most important religious traditions10. What is today called Hinduism is the sum of a number of traditional religious beliefs in India formed throughout a long tradition and related with each other11. More than a religion properly speaking it is a range or gro of religions. The essential line in all of these is the belief in the presence of the divinity in all beings. The most ancient tradition is the pre-Vedic religions about the 20th century B.C. With the migrations to India from the northwest of the Aryan peoples, new religions were introduced which were written down in the books called Rig Vedas. The Vedic religion has a background of culture to nature personified in many gods in a certain hierarchy, with the god Varuna at the summit as a universal presence. The second elaboration of Hinduism religious thought is contained in the Upanishad, written about the 7th century B.C. The central idea of the vision of the Upanishad is the concept of Brahma. This idea was already present in the Vedas as a mysterious force and is now converted into the supreme, infinite, impersonal reality present in the entire universe and which constitutes the reality and identity of all of these. Religious thought gyrates around a monist conception. Brahma, and only he, is the ultimate reality, thus, ultimately everything is one. The sensitive world is appearance and deceit. The road to purification consists of shedding deceit and appearances and reaching the contemplation of the only being Brahma, as only Brahma is and nothing else is. The ego, consciousness or the individual soul, ends up also being identified with Brahma, the universal consciousness. Brahma, therefore, is the ultimate principle which is discovered in the depth of reality and the individual consciousness what reveals a person in his known depth and both are identified. Regarding the problem in question, it is important to remember the pantheism and radical monism of Hinduism in which all reality is identified with Brahma. The universal and the particular are identified, just as unity and multiplicity, the micro-cosmos and the macro-cosmos. There is only one ineffable reality, which cannot be known or expressed, in which the difference between being and non-being disappears. All is one and all is divine and eternal, and time is an illusion. From this there arises a cyclical conception of time with unlimited duration. Hinduism has not extended beyond India and it is a religion which is strongly linked to the culture and history of this country. Contrary to Hinduism, where it arose in the 6th century B.C., Buddhism is a historical religion with a founder, The Indian Prince Siddartha Gautama or Sakyamuni, who began to preach in the Ganges basin around 525 B.C.12 Gautama reacted against the excessive formalism of Hinduism, and was especially preoccupied by the problem of suffering and pain. He was illuminated and became Buddha (the illuminated one) and 10
11
12
16
T. P. Burke, 2004. The Major Religions. London: Blackwell. P. Poupard (ed.), 1987. Diccionario de las religiones. Barcelona: Herder. J. Delumeau (ed.), 1995. El hecho religioso. Enciclopedia de las grandes religiones. Madrid: Alianza. M. Eliade, 1978-1980, Historia de las creencias y de las ideas religiosas. 4 Vols. Madrid: Cristiandad. L. Renou (ed.). 1962. Hinduism. New York: George Braziller, R. A. Gard (ed.), 1961. Buddhism. New York: George Braziller, God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
dedicated himself to extending his message as a way to overcome suffering. The original veneration of Buddha as the master became latern object of cult. While Hinduism was limited to the peoples of India, the new message of Buddha soon crossed the frontiers of India and extended throughout the East, while it practically disappeared in India itself. Buddhism has a universalistic vocation and has become known and extended in the West since the 19th century. The central idea of Buddhism is that, faced with the universality of suffering, it is necessary to seek to overcome it through interior illumination. Therefore, it is a primarily experiential religion or philosophy which has to do with existence itself. The root of suffering lies in desire which arises from the ego and has a chain of causes, therefore, in order to extinguish suffering, it is necessary to extinguish all desire. The extinction of all desire, through knowledge and interior liberation, leads to Nirvana, a state of complete passivity, and through this, man becomes a Buddha or illuminated. In Buddhism there is no divinity, nor ultimate reality, but only a way to interior illumination which leads to an identification with nothingness in the perfection of Nirvana. Therefore, it separates from Vedic pantheism and denies all essential reality of things of the exterior world. Within the complexity of the traditions of Buddhism, there are two main streams or ways, Theravada or Hinayana (small way) and Mahayana (grand way). The first spread through Sri Lanka, Thailand and Indochina and the second through China, Japan and Korea. The traditional Chinese religions go back to the 15th century B.C. during the Shang dynasty and later up to the V century B.C. with the Chou dynasty. Their characteristics are very different from the religions of the Semitic or Indian environments. They have a strong civic character and are a mixture of philosophy and religion based on the structure of the family and the state. One of their characteristics is the importance given to the forefathers who become protecting spirits after they die. The origin of the religious tradition known as Taoism is linked to the legendary figure of the master Laotse (Lao tzu) around the VI century B.C. Its doctrine is framed in the philosophicalreligious tradition and there is no clear idea of the divinity. The fundamental idea is constituted by the Tao, the way or supreme principle, the origin of all, which is in itself the indescribable, a mixture of being and non-being. Unlike other traditions such as Buddhism, Taoism has a strong cosmological component. In its vision of the world, everything is developed from the Tao, through the action of contraries (ying and yang: night and day, masculine and feminine, etc) which represent cosmic energies. Everything finally returns to its starting point, in an eternal return in which time is cyclical. The Tao represents the authentic real, existing by itself, animated by autonomous movement it is a route which moves. As a norm for living, the Tao entails abandonment to the impulse which the natural movement exercises over us, simply living the mystery which surrounds us. The Tao is in itself the indefinable. It proposes solidarity between man, society, nature, the universe. The rhythm of life must be adapted to nature, thus, the importance of the calendar and astronomy with the influence of the stars. In religious practice it proposes the cult of Heaven, forefathers and family and social piety. While Taoism stresses nature and its rhythms, the doctrine contained in the writings of Confucius (Kung fu tsu) (551-479) B.C. form an ethic or a philosophy of individual and social conduct. Confucius had the noble ambition to give the country order and peace. His doctrine, therefore, is focused on human relationships, individual-familysociety, bases of ethics and politics. The development of the person is at the root of family order and social order. One recurring concept is that of humanity or goodness, the basis of perfect virtue which implies overcoming oneself and exercising goodness God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
17
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
towards others, beginning with those closest to us, the family, then the people and the State in broader and broader circles. He insists on reverence for parents and the elderly and teaches that family ethics is the basis of social and political ethics. Confucius teaches that being human is, in itself, a social task. The ultimate finality of his doctrine is to achieve political stability and universal peace. The doctrine of Confucius and his interpreters became the classical doctrine the Chinese civil servants had to know by heart and today it has a strong influence in the countries of the Far East. The last three religions we will deal with are theist religions with the transcendent figure of a single God (strict monotheism), with a personal character, separated from the world, which has been created by him, and in which he acts, establishing a special relationship with men which constitutes their salvation. This conception of the creator God makes its relationship with science similar, as the three religions acknowledge that the world was created. The three also have sacred books (the Jewish Bible, the Christian Bible and the Koran) which contain the revelation of God and whose texts, interpreted literally as regards natural phenomena, have led to some confrontations with science. The three, Judaism, Christianity and Islamism have a common stem, from where they have differentiated. This common stem is formed by Judaism, whose most ancient origins go back to the tribal religions from which, little by little, a religious unity was created in the people of Israel13. The formation of the people of Israel places the bases of Holy Scripture, the Bible, made up of the Pentateuch, the first five books of the Bible, or the Law (Torah), which contains the covenant of God with the people of Israel and the laws which the people must obey. After a slow process, the faith of Israel evolved into an absolute monotheism (only Yahweh is God) with the rejection of idolatry (images of God cannot be made). One key component is that of the alliance between God and Israel, conditioned by compliance with the Law. The Scriptures (Bible) were composed throughout centuries from the first traditions, around the 9th century B. C. up to the last books in the first century B.C. and they are made up of the books which contain the Law, the teachings of the prophets, the Psalms, the books relating the history of Israel and the books of wisdom. One characteristic note of Judaism is its conception of the history of the people of Israel as history of salvation. God is not only the creator of heaven and earth, but is also the God who freed the people from slavery in Egypt and guides it throughout time. Its conception of a personal, transcendent God who creates the real world and is separate from it and its conception of time as linear, Judaism separates from the pantheist conceptions and the cyclical times of the eastern religious traditions. Christianity arose within the Jewish tradition in the I century and is centred on the figure of Jesus of Nazareth14. The centre of his preaching is the coming of the kingdom of God, the conception of God as the Father and the love of fellow men, as the commandment equal to the love of God. Compliance with the Law and the precepts of an external piety are considered insufficient as regards a religion which must be founded on love. After only three years of preaching, rejected by the religious authorities, Jesus was handed over to the Roman authorities who crucified Him. After His death, the disciples experienced his resurrection and proclaimed Him Lord and Messiah (Christ), the Son of God. The experience of the recognition of Jesus as the Son 13
14
18
A. Hertzberg (ed.), 1962. Judaism. New York: George Braziller. H. Küng, 1991. El Judaísmo. Pasado, presente y futuro. Madrid: Trotta F. Gogarten, 1977. ¿Qué es el Christianity? Barcelona: Herder; J. Feiner y L. Vischer (eds.), 1977. Nuevo libro de la fe cristiana. Barcelona: Herder God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
of God, led to a transformation of the very conception of the God of the Jewish tradition as now the mystery of the Trinity is recognised, that is to say, the existence of three persons, the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit in a single God. Although Jesus’ first disciples were Jews, Christianity soon opened up to the Gentiles and became universal. Soon Christian communities spread throughout the Roman Empire. The life of Jesus is told in the four gospels, written between the years 60 and 100 to which were added the Acts of the Apostles and the letters of some of these and, especially, Saint Paul. These writings were added to the Jewish Bible (Old Testament) and are called the New Testament. The spread of Christianity was not easy and soon found opposition in the Roman Empire until the year 320, when it was recognised by Constantine, and in 392 became the official religion of the Empire by an edict of Theodosius. During almost four centuries, Christianity interacted with the Greek and Roman cultures, especially, with Greek philosophy and science. This would give a special characteristic to its relationship with science. After the fall of the Roman Empire in 476, Christianity was the religion adopted by the western kingdoms which arose after the invasions of the barbarians. During all the Middle Ages, the Church had a strong social and cultural influence. The unity of Christianity was broken first with the definitive separation of the Orthodox Church in the East in 1054. In the West the main division occurred with the Protestant Reformation of Luther in 1517 (Evangelical Church), the reformation of Calvin in 1536 (Reformed Church) and in England with Henry VIII in 1534 (Anglican Church) which separated from communion with the Catholic Church. Other protestant denominations and sects were created during the 17th and 19th centuries (Presbyterian, Pentecostal, Quaker, Mormons, etc). From the beginning, missionary work was considered to be a necessity and Christianity spread throughout Asia, Africa, America and Oceania. Currently Christianity is divided into several churches or denominations in which, although they all recognise as their foundation the faith in Jesus Christ, the Lord, the doctrine regarding many points has become diversified. However, the desire to find the unity lost remains. The religion of Islam arose in Arabia and is based on the preaching of Mahomet (570-632). Mahomet began to have religious experiences which marked him deeply and made him see himself as the receiver of a new, definitive revelation of God15. In these experiences Mahomet received a new religious message which constituted him as the prophet entrusted with spreading these experiences. The preaching of Mahomet is included in the Koran, considered to have been revealed by God through the archangel Gabriel to Mahomet, and its text was established about 640. Its contents include elements of the traditional Arab religions and of the traditions of Judaism and Christianity. Islam can be considered to be a project of religion and civilisation in which religious and social norms are established. From the religious point of view, Islamism is based on trusting submission (Islam) of man before God, quite a simple credo with an absolute monotheism in the style of Abraham, which Mahomet separated from its subsequent Jewish and Christian developments. The proclamation of faith is synthesised in: there is only one God (Allah) and Mahomet is his prophet. Above all, the Muslim is a person submitted to God who follows the example of the great prophets. With regard to the relationship between God and the world, Islamism receives the Jewish-Christian tradition of a transcendent, creator God. Besides its religious character, Islam entails a social and political organisation, with a code of conduct and laws. Islam spread rapidly, 15
J. A. Williams (ed.), 1962. Islam. New York: George Braziller, God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
19
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
sometimes through trade and sometimes through the force of arms, throughout the Middle East, Anatolia, North Africa and Spain and later Iran, Afghanistan and India (Pakistan and Bangladesh), East Africa and South-East Asia (Indonesia). At the present time, Islam extends along a strip which goes from the west coast of North Africa to Indonesia. 9. Magic Magic is a word of Persian origin which means science or wisdom, it is an ancestral practice related to religion and science. Despite the progress of the rational explanation of the world by science and the purification of religious experience, magic is a phenomenon which subsists and is present in all cultures. It can be said that it is based on the conviction that there is a “force” in nature which can be captured through shrewdness and skill for the benefit or to the detriment of men16. Magic is an ancestral phenomenon which is present in all the ancient cultures. Today we find it in the practices of primitive peoples and also in modern man in which it may represent a never lost component of a pre-rational mentality related to a mythical consciousness which has never been quite eliminated by intellectual consciousness. This strange inhabitant of the human depths is related to the irrational functions of sensation and intuition. It is related to the possibility of acquiring powers through certain occult practices only known by certain initiated persons. This is a very universal phenomenon since, as Hegel said, magic appears in all peoples and in all the eras. The relationship between magic and religion is complex, although magic must not be considered as a previous, more primitive stage of religion. In fact, all religions coexist with magic tendencies17. One important component of magic, which is also present in religion, is the symbol. Magic exploits the ambivalence of the symbols and absolutises them, by transferring the reality of the meaning to the symbol. The image becomes a reality and acquires characteristics of the marvellous. This perversion of the meaning of the symbol which provides it with magical components must be purified by the true religious feeling. Judaism, as is seen in the Old Testament (Deut. 18, 9-14; Lev 19, 26; 20, 6), strongly opposed magic, as did Christianity from its beginnings (Acts 8, 9-25). From St. Justin to St. Augustine, the first Christian authors despise magic as a manifestation of the evil spirit which deceives and is deceived. Despite all, certain tendencies towards magic have always persisted at popular level. Magic also has a relationship with science and technology. From ancient times in Egypt and Mesopotamia, the practice of astronomy was mixed with religious and magic components. The ancient Chaldeans magicians, who flourished in the first century B.C. spread the practice of astrology throughout the Roman Empire. At popular level this practice still exists. It should be remembered that Kepler supplemented his scant salary as Imperial Mathematician with the practice of horoscopy. Science which has presented a purely rational image of the world has not managed to exorcise all the magical components. In popular environments technology, whose scientific bases are not understood, has a certain magical aspect. The relationship which we have seen between magic and the acquisition of powers gives a certain magical component to technology. In a way, technology has become the magician of our times. 10. Preliminary considerations 16 17
20
P. Saintyves, 1914. La force magique. París. Ver en Poupard (1987) Magia. M. Eliade, 1983. Imágenes y símbolos. Madrid: Taurus. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
Up to now, we have attempted to present a brief view of the complex phenomena of science and religion, before dealing with the problem of the relationships which can be established between them. When we speak of science and of religion, it should be borne in mind that, in both cases, the realities they take in are very broad and include a great variety of meanings. This necessarily affects the relationship between the two. Although, as we have seen, there are, of course, common components, their complexity must not be forgotten. Considering the personal attitudes which we have called religiosities and the religious traditions which we have mentioned, in general, its relationship with science will be conditioned by their understanding of the relationship between divinity and the world. In the case of naturalist religiosity, its rejection of all supernatural reality restricts its conception to the purely natural, and, therefore, it assumes that the world is the only reality. Regarding the purely materialist currents, it is not necessary to search beyond the material world and, therefore, not beyond the image of it provided by science. This attitude assumes science as the only source of knowledge of the world. The difficulty of this attitude is how to base attitudes regarding the search for meaning or reverence for nature itself. Spiritualist naturalism adds the difficulty of explaining what is understood by the spiritual dimension and how to integrate this into the world known by science which cannot include this dimension. What we have called the religiosity of the mystery, starts precisely from the world known by science, in which something beyond what science can explain is discovered. This inexplicable factor present in reality is, as Einstein said, the base of this type of religiosity. In the thought of some scientists, such as the great physicists Heisenberg and Schrödinger, there are certain attitudes of this type. In these cases, science provides the way to this type of religiosity, when beyond science something is glimpsed which belongs to the realm of mystery. As concerns religions properly speaking, the relationship between the divinity and the world can be described with the two concepts of immanence and transcendence. The former refers to the presence of God in the world and the latter to His separation from it. The religions which stress the immanence of God can lead to a true pantheism or monism, in which all reality is one thing, as we have seen in the case of the eastern traditions of Hinduism, Buddhism and Taoism. The theist tradition, which begins in ancient Judaism and was assumed by Christianity and Islamism, holds that there is a personal, transcendent God who created the world which is thus separate from Him, although his presence in the world is not denied. The immanence type religious currents, such as the Hindu, Buddhist and Taoist traditions which we have stressed, at first sight appear to have little relationship with science, as they identify all reality with the divinity. The world which appears to the senses is only the appearance of an underlying reality which cannot be understood (Brahma or Tao). Moreover, the cyclical concept of time, in which nothing really new can happen and which engenders certain pessimism regarding the meaning of any human enterprise, adds a negative component to the possibility of the progress of science. Stanley Jaki who examines the classical cultures of India and China holds this opinion as regard their relationship with science18. However, Fritjof Capra finds a parallelism between the principles of Hinduism and Taoism and modern quantumrelativist physics19. According to him, the theories and models of modern physics lead 18
19
S. L. Jaki, 1986. Science and Creation, From Eternal Cycles to an Oscillating Universe. Edinburgh: Scottish Academy Press. F. Capra, 1987. El Tao de la física. Una exploración de los paralelos entre la física moderna y el misticismo Oriental, 2ª edición. Madrid: Luís Carcamo. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
21
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
to a vision of the world which is internally consistent and is in perfect harmony with the visions of oriental mysticism. The physicist and the mystic reach the same intuition of the essential unity of all things, one starts from the external world and the other from the internal. To do so, some properties of the physics of subatomic phenomena are taken such as non-locality and intertwining, which are interpreted as an approximation to the concept of unity of the oriental mystique. The tradition of a creator God separate from the world commences with the narration of Genesis in the Jewish tradition which is accepted by Christianity and Islamism. Its opening sentence, “In the beginning, God created heaven and earth”, indicates the transcendence of God who is not identified with the world which He freely creates. This statement leads to a process of secularisation of the world, which, therefore, can be observed and studied in itself, leaving aside the confusion between world and divinity. This confusion was also present in the western tradition in the cosmogonic myths. This demythologisation of the world is a necessary step for it to be studied rationally. This process is achieved by another way in ancient Greece. From the 6th century B.C. the Greek philosophers of nature addressed the question of how to explain what the world is from pure reason and thus laid the foundations of the scientific explanation20. The union of these two currents of secularisation of the world occurs in Christianity, where the Christian authors of the 3rd to 5th centuries used science and Greek philosophy to explain the story of creation. Later, in the Middle Ages this current led to the separation of theology based on revelation and philosophy based on reason. The recognition in medieval Christian thought of natural philosophy (today called science) as an autonomous field of knowledge regarding nature, contributed to the development of science in the West. In conclusion, the religious and scientific visions of the world, although different, they have points of contact and have historically interacted throughout time. This could not be otherwise as they are visions of the same man and the same world. When science speaks of the origin of the universe, of life and of man, these are questions about which religion also has its answers to. Are the two visions incompatible? Which do we pay attention to? Do they invalidate each other? Can the explanations of science finally make the intuitions of religion unnecessary? Sometimes there is an impression that scientific progress is conceived as a threat to religion. As if each step forward by science constitutes a regression of religion. We will now try to shed light on these questions, by considering the relationship between science and religion from different points of view. 11. Science and ideology We have seen how science and religion make up two ways of approaching reality and they have a strong presence in society. As they coexist in the same society and often in the same person, we must now address the type of relationship we can establish between them. One previous question to be considered is the role played by ideologies as regards this problem. The very term ideology can have several meanings and is sometimes used with negative connotations. In general, ideologies can be considered to be systems of beliefs and values which a group of individuals hold, sometimes for very diverse reasons, and that they can sometimes be related to structures of power. Here we will take a more neutral meaning, considering ideologies, in general, as conceptual systems 20
22
C. F. von Weizsäcker, 1968. La Importancia de la science. Barcelona: Labor. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
which provide a totalising vision of reality, which serve to give meaning to life, create a global framework of references and justify personal and social conduct21. A very generalised propensity of ideologies is to make values and social schemes absolute when these are normally considered to be relative and contingent. In these cases, a partial vision becomes a horizon which takes in the totality of reality, and this vision is made absolute so that all others are excluded or considered to be false. This creates intransigent attitudes and the acceptance of its basic assertions without discussion, as truths which cannot be appealed against. Thus, in some points ideologies approximate to the characteristics of religion, except for the absence of any reference to a supernatural reality. In this regard, ideologies can, on occasions substitute the functions of religion. Examples of this are the ideologies imposed in totalitarian countries, where there is also a link between ideology and structure of power, as is the case of communism and Nazism. On the other hand, a religion unbound from its basis of the experience of religious faith can become an ideology. Seen from the outside, without accepting this link, religions are sometimes erroneously considered to be ideologies. We can now analyse whether science can be considered to be an ideology or whether ideologies can be created from science. In the first place, it must be made clear that science, neither as knowledge nor as an activity is in itself an ideology and is, moreover, independent of any ideology. In fact, science as knowledge does not attempt to give a totalising vision of reality, but, as we have seen, it limits its field of knowledge to aspects of reality which can be subject to its methodology. This always entails that its assertions must be backed up by observations and experiments reproducible by all, and must be directed at providing rational knowledge of nature and its functioning. This can be said of any one of the sciences and all of them together. More restrictively science is limited to the measurable and quantifiable aspects of nature, preferably those which can be processed through mathematical language. These limitations are basically the root of its efficacy. On the other hand, science does not in any way seek to give meaning to life. That is not its role, which is to discover the functioning of material nature. The question of meaning is not a part of its approach. Neither does science attempt to create values which serve as guides to conduct. Even more, for its survival the very practice of science requires the acceptance of certain standards of conduct which science cannot give to itself. Neither physics nor biology, in themselves, can serve to give values or provide norms of conduct. Just as science is not an ideology, it does not require a specific ideology to function. Scientists with different ideologies can equally be good scientists. Science is, then, not an ideology, nor can it be presented as the basis of an ideology which necessarily is deduced from it. There are ideologies which pretend to have a scientific character and are presented as based on science and sometimes want to be confused with science. These ideologies are known by the generic name of “scientism”. Often, especially, when an attempt is made to oppose science and religion, in fact, an ideology is being talked about, not science itself. Thus, one should begin by clearly distinguishing them from science itself. For example, when Richard Dawkins states, “I want to persuade the reader not only that the Darwinist world-view is true, but is the only known theory which can, in principle, resolve the mysteries of our existence”, he
21
This is the sense in of Evandro Agazzi, 1996, El bien, el mal y la science. Las dimensiones éticas de la empresa científico-tecnológica. Madrid: Tecnos, Chapter V, La ideología científico-tecnológica. 106128. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
23
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
is in fact referring to an ideology not to science22. On speaking of a “world-view” and pretending to “resolve the mysteries of our existence”, the Darwinism he is speaking of stops being a scientific theory and becomes an ideology. Here, as in so many other cases, a clear distinction should be made between what belongs to the field of science and what belongs to the field of ideologies. The acceptance of the scientific theory of biological evolution does not entail the need to have to accept any ideology which may quite often be constructed on the theory. One characteristic of these types of ideologies is to pretend to extend the scope of the scientific explanation to all of reality, without accepting any other type of knowledge. In many cases, an unjustified step is taken here with the assertion, “this takes place”, which belongs to the field of science, to “only this takes place”, which is an unjustified generalisation of the scientific explanation to all areas of reality. That is to say, as in the case of the materialist ideology, it is postulated that there is only the reality which is known by science. 12. Relationships between science and religion The existence of the two visions of the world, that of science and that of religion, leads to the consideration of what type of relationship can be established between them. A classification, which has become classical, is the proposal made by Ian Barbour, which groups the possible relationships into four categories: conflict, independence, dialogue and integration23. A fifth category can be added: complementariness, which would be located between dialogue and integration. This category was recently proposed by the theologian Hans Küng24. Although other classifications can be established we will follow this one which makes it possible to follow the relationship between science and religion from the most negative form, conflict, to the most positive, some type of integration of both. On dealing with this subject, it is important to remember that all the aspects of science and religion must be taken into account, not only the cognitive aspects. Outstanding among these is the historical aspect as, throughout time, the relationship may have varied from one type to another. It must be acknowledged that the relationship is complex and some aspects of the categories may be present with greater or lesser intensity in some epochs than in others. Neither are the categories pure and there may be relationships where aspects of several of these are mixed together. Also these categories must not necessarily be considered as excluding each other but each represents a way of relationship present. In this first approximation, the importance is to delimit the possible ways in which science and religion have interacted with each other and the proposals put forward to support one or other type of relationship. 13. Conflict The sometimes generalised opinion that the relationship between science and religion is and has always been one of inevitable conflict is not infrequent nowadays. Science and religion are considered to be two opposing visions of the world, which can only crash against each other. Not only this, each of them denies the validity of the other. Furthermore, today it is held that only the vision of science can be true, therefore, the 22 23
24
24
Richard Dawkins, 1989, The Blind Watchmaker. New York: Norton. Preface, I. Barbour presented this classification in: Ways of Relating Science and Theology, in R. J. Russell, W. R. Stoeger, G. V. Coyne (eds.), 1988, Physics, Philosophy and Theology. A Common Quest for Understanding. Vatican City: Vatican Observatory, 21-48. This is further developed in Barbour, 2004. Religion y ciencia. Madrid: Trotta, 133-181. Hans Küng, 2005, Der Anfang aller Dinge. Naturwissenschaft und Religion Munich: Piper. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
vision of religion must little by little disappear. From this point of view, the progress of science always entails a regression of religion. In order to support this position, a biased interpretation of history is often made always with the same cases of Galileo and Darwin. Although this position is taken back to the origins of modern science indicating that from its very beginning science itself can only be in conflict with religion, in fact, it began in the 19th century, though it does have some roots in the 18th century. One example of the first attitudes of this type is that of Ernest Renan, the author of the famous life of Jesus which caused much stir, who said in 1848 that the real world which science reveals to us is much more superior to the fanatical world of religion created by the imagination, and finished by saying that the modern task will not be completely carried out until the belief in the supernatural, in any form, is destroyed. For him, the break between religion and science seemed to be definitive25. Two books published at the end of the 19th century contributed, in a special way, to spreading this attitude. The first was published in 1874 by John W. Draper (1811-1882), born in England and Professor of Chemistry at New York University26. in his work Draper dedicates his most furious attacks against the Catholic Church of which he says, that the antagonism between religion and science of which we are witnesses is the continuation of the struggle which began when Christianity began to achieve political power and concludes that, Catholic Christianity and science are absolutely incompatible, as recognised by their respective supporters, they cannot exist together, one should cede to the other and humanity must choose, both cannot be conserved27. The work of Andrew D. White (1832-1918), Professor of History and the first President of Cornell University in the United States, published in 1896, was also widely diffused28. It does not ferociously attack religion like the work of Draper, but, although it was not the author’s intention, it also served to propagate the idea that human progress requires the victory of science over religion. In the introduction, White says that in all of modern history the interference with science in a supposed interest of religion, however careful this interference has been, has had the most terrible bad result for both religion and science. Despite the good intentions of the author, his book together with that of Draper’s represents the posture which maintains the inevitable conflict between science and religion. The defence against these attacks were sometimes equally belligerent, such as that of the French polemist Denis Frayssinous who in 1825 criticised the scientists of his time as manufacturers of worlds which fix and unfix the universe capriciously and it seems to have been they who presided over creation29. During this time, in 1891, Leo XIII, on the occasion of the establishment of the Vatican Observatory, mentioned these opinions and called attention to those who calumniate the Church as a friend of obscurantism, generator of ignorance and enemy of science and progress and stated that the inauguration of the Observatory clearly shows that the Church and its pastors are not opposed to the true, sound science, but embraces, encourages and promotes it with the utmost dedication30. In 1976, Paul VI recognised that this misunderstanding between 25
26 27 28
29 30
G. Minois, 1991. L’Église et la science. Histoire d’un malentendu.”. 2. De Galilée à Jean Paul II. Paris: Fayard, 205. J. W. Draper, 1874. History of the Conflict between Religion and Science. New York: Appleton. Draper (1987), LXIV and 305. Andrew D. White, 1896. A History of the Warfare of Science with Theology in Christendom. London: Appleton. Denis Frayssinous, 1821. Défense du christianisme. Paris. Leo XIII, 1891, Motu propio, Ut mysticam. Reproduced in Sabino Maffeo, 2001, La Specola God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
25
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
scientific thought and Christian religious thought shakes our mental security and is the big problem of our time. He assured everyone that the religious mentality has nothing against scientific progress, rather it favours this and integrates it objectively and subjectively with its cult of the total truth31. After the Second World War, there was a change in these positions. On the one hand, scientific euphoria, which had favoured the idea of conflict and war between science and religion as inevitable, began to wane. Robert Oppenheimer, who had directed the construction of the atom bomb, stated that with this bomb science had lost its innocence. Preoccupation also began regarding the deterioration of the environment due to technological applications and the dangers in the applications of genetic engineering. The unlimited admiration of science has been changed into a certain suspicion due to the dangers of some of its consequences. On the other hand, the new historical studies have shown that many of the arguments used by Draper and White do not have a serious historical basis. As shown by John H. Brooke, the relationships between science and religion throughout history have been complex and cannot be reduced to those of continual conflict32. A number of historical studies in recent years have dealt with delicate subjects such as the epochs of Galileo and Darwin and have quite clearly shown that neither conflict, nor harmony alone reflect the complex relationships between science and religion. The idea of conflict, then, as the only type of relationship must be abandoned as, throughout history, the interactions have been both positive and negative33. Despite everything, the perception of the conflict between science and religion continues and we can see it repeated, even today, especially at popular level. We do not deny that there have been negative interactions, but these must be seen in their historical contexts which involve numerous factors, and must not be considered in a simplistic fashion as examples of a supposed inevitable conflict which arises from the very essence of both. As an example, we can see three cases of positive interaction between religion and science, which in themselves serve to show that it is not possible to speak of conflict and war as the only forms of relationship. In order not to restrict ourselves to Christianity, we can begin by the promotion of science by Islam, especially, from the 8th to 13th centuries. In the 8th century, at the dawn of Islam, astronomy and mathematics, especially, but also medicine and the natural sciences, flourished in Arab culture, boosted by the translation of the Greek scientific texts to Arabic. These sciences were considered to be useful, for example, in order to establish the dates and times of the rituals and as an expression of praise of God the creator and service to man (medicine). It was not only using Greek science, there was also a true development of new ideas, such as algebra and the decimal system, not developed in Greece, where the Arab authors incorporated ideas from the Indian mathematicians and added the progress made in astronomic observations. The Middle Ages is used as an example of the opposition of Christianity to science, and attributing to Christianity the abandonment of Greek science. The situation was in fact very different. The Western part of the Roman Empire scarcely knew Greek and Greek science in this epoch was not translated into Latin. In the High Middle Ages there was only available the scarce scientific knowledge 31 32
33
26
Vaticana. Nove Papi, una missione. Vatican City: Specola Vaticana. 297-301. Pablo VI, General Audience on June 2, 1976. John H. Brooke, 1991, Science and Religion. Some Historical Perspectives. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. A clear presentation of the subject in the case of Christianity can be found in David C. Lindberg and Ronald L. Numbers (eds.), 1986. God and Nature. Historical Essays on the Encounter between Christianity and Science. Berkeley: University of California Press. Introduction 1-18. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
transmitted by Latin authors. The Church began and promoted the foundation of the universities in which natural philosophy was an important discipline and in the 12th to 14th centuries, it encouraged the translations of the Greek scientific texts to Latin, making their subsequent use by the creators of modern science possible34. A third example is the development of experimental science in England in the 17th and 18th centuries which was encouraged by the Protestant movement which saw in science a way to give glory to God and to contribute to the welfare of man. The influence of Protestant piety is present in many of the English scientists of this epoch, such as Robert Boyle, Robert Hooke and Isaac Newton. 13.1. Attitudes generating conflict Although the relationship of conflict cannot be generalised as the only one possible between science and religion, one can find attitudes in both which may lead to and have, in fact, led to conflicts35. Within the area of religion we find the fundamentalist attitude which can take on different forms. One of these is biblical literalism in Christianity which literally interprets the texts of the Bible as regards natural phenomena, giving these a scientific character. One example is the literal interpretation of the texts on creation in Genesis. This mentality was at the basis of the conflicts with Galileo and Darwin, with the opposition between the literal sense of some texts of the Bible and modern cosmology and the theory of evolution. In modern times, this mentality in the United States has led to presenting a scientific theory called “creationism” through conservative Protestant currents, this sustains the independent creation of each species of animals and plants, as related in the first chapter of Genesis, and considers that the age of the world is approximately 6000 years, which go against the current results regarding biological evolution and the age of the cosmos. The discussion has reached the area of education in some American States in which it was proposed that this doctrine be explained in classes of biology instead of or together with the theory of evolution. Finally, Courts have rejected this pretension. These attitudes confuse the religious message of the Bible with its historical and literary expression, which depends on the cultural components at the time of the composition of each of its books. This attitude leads to an undue intromission of religion in the field of science. Just as there is a religious fundamentalism, although it is less spoken of, there is what we can call a scientific fundamentalism which turns science into a totalising ideology with a materialist vision, beyond which there are no other perspectives, nor another truth. Therefore, it is not a question of science itself, but rather an ideological vision which pretend to be based on science, as the only interpretation possible. For this type of fundamentalism only science is the source of true knowledge of the world and the only one which establishes its meaning. In consequence, the attitudes and values which govern human conduct must also be based on science. In the name of science, this attitude pretends to deny religion any relevance as there would be no place for it. In some cases there are even attempts to explicitly supplant religion with an ideology and even a religiosity based on science. Attitudes of this type are not infrequent in scientific environments, where the ideological aspects become blurred and are concealed and presented as if they were science itself. In fact, this is also an undue intromission, where science is used to attack and supplant religion. 34
35
Edward Grant, 1996. The Foundations of Modern Science in the Middle Ages, their Religious, Institutional and Intellectual Contexts. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Barbour (2004) 135-145, refers to scientific materialism and biblical liberalism. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
27
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
Another source of conflict lies in the social consequences of science and religion. These conflicts arise from the struggle for influence and social power in which some groups use the support of progress in science in order to supplant the position traditionally occupied by religion. In Europe the birth of modern science in the 16th and 17th centuries took place in a society in which the ecclesiastical establishment enjoyed enormous social influence inherited from the medieval tradition. Groups contrary to this situation took advantage of the scientific establishment and its rapid ascent in prestige and popularity in order to use its support to confront the influence of religion. Opposed to the social attitudes of the religious establishment, which at times were excessively conservative, were those which proposed radical social reforms and sought support for it in the prestige of science. As the social prestige of scientists grew, these replaced the ecclesiastics in popular influence and politics. Although the scientists were not the creators of this movement, they were often, consciously or unconsciously dragged into this undeclared conflict. The modern secularising tendencies in society are also supported by the influence of science in order to minimise or even eliminate the social influence of religion. Sometimes science is presented as substitute for religion where the scientists appear as the new priests, the possessors and dispensers of the only true knowledge. The situation today has changed as the enormous prestige of science has socially overcome that of the religious instances. With this situation this type of conflict has diminished, as religion is no longer considered to be an important enemy to defeat. Reminiscences of the past conflicts arise in the suspicions and sensitivities of scientists regarding the criticisms presented from religious sectors of the possible negative consequences of their work in the field of ethics. It is not strange that science today is presented as the only sector which does not admit criticism and against which there are no possible appeals. In some cases, it can be said that a certain scientific dogmatism has substituted religious dogmatism. These attitudes, which in fact defend the areas of influence of science, become sources of conflict which are rationalised by defending the incompatibility between science and religion. In spite of all, these types of conflicts can have a positive side. Through them religion is obliged to recognise that it has too often adopted roles which have approximated it to political power. These roles have been justified by the weight of tradition, with no critical analysis of the damage which they have sometimes caused. Unfortunately, these situations of influence and power are difficult to abandon on one’s own initiative, nor are their negative consequences easily recognised. Only when religion has shed these, does it recognise that they were a serious obstacle to its true mission rather than a help. In fact, if religion wants to conserve its critical force as regards all the abuses of power, which sometimes use apparently scientific arguments as justifications, it must first shed itself all power. Religion must not exercise its influence from a position of power but from the appeal to the conscience of man and the recourse to an ultimate transcendent instance. 14. Independence As we have seen, if the conflicts between science and religion arise from the undue incursion of one into the field of the other, the solution to the problem can be sought in manifesting the independence of both. It must be accepted that religion and science are two types of knowledge and languages regarding reality, independent of each other, each one is valid within its own environment. There should be no conflict between them as these arise when the independence is not recognised. Science must not meddle with the environment of the religious, nor must religion meddle with the scientific 28
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
environment. In addition, history teaches us that both intromissions have led to bad consequences and have been sources of conflict. There are many arguments in favour of this attitude of mutual independence. In the first place, there is the need to recognise the autonomy of the sciences in their terrain and that of religion and theology in theirs. This separation is due not only to the desire to avoid unnecessary conflict, but to the desire to be loyal to the distinctive characters of each one and their validity in each terrain. The recognition of independence between science and religion already existed in the medieval formulation of the two books: the Book of Nature and the Book of Revelation. These were recognized as two different books, but having the same author, God, could not contradict each other. Among the formulations of this principle, we can cite that of Francis Bacon who said that the Book of the Word of God and the Book of the Works of God represent two types of knowledge that must not be mixed or confused. Galileo insisted on the same in his letter to the Grand Duchess of Loraine, saying that “in discussions on natural problems, one should not begin with the authority of the written texts, but with sensitive experiences...the natural effects which sensitive experience places before our eyes...cannot be condemned by quotations from Scripture”36. The recognition of the mutual autonomy of science and religion is included in the document on “The Church in the modern world” of the Vatican Council II37. This document states that “many of our contemporaries seem to fear that, due to an excessive link between human activity and religion, the autonomy of man, society and science is hindered”. After stating that this demand for autonomy is absolutely legitimate, it concludes that “if methodical research in all the fields of knowledge is carried out in an authentically scientific fashion and in accordance with the moral standards, it will never, in fact, be contrary to faith, because the secular realities and those of the faith originate in the same God”. However, it remembers the conflicts this lack of recognition has led to, specifically, as regards the case of Galileo, and states that, “as concerns this, certain attitudes should be deplored as they do not understand well the sense of the legitimate autonomy of science, Among Christians themselves there have sometimes been attitudes followed by bitter polemics, which led many to establish an opposition between science and faith”38. According to the Council, the recognition of mutual autonomy and independence is, therefore, the first step to establishing correct relationships between science and faith. John Paul II, in a document on science and religion in 1988, supported this position stating, “Science and religion must preserve their autonomy and peculiarity. Each has its own principles and ways of acting”39. The Board of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States reached a similar conclusion in 1981 concerning the debate on creationism and stated that religion and science are separate, excluding fields of human thought, and their joint presentation in the same context gives rise to the fact that both scientific theories and religious beliefs are mistakenly understood40. 36 37
38 39
40
Galileo Galilei, 1987. Carta a Cristina de Lorena. Madrid: Alianza, 70. Concilio Vaticano II, Constituciones. Decretos. Declaraciones. Madrid: Biblioteca de Autores Cristianos, 1965. Constitución pastoral sobre la Iglesia en el mundo actual (Gaudium et Spes), 209365. Gaudium et Spes, No. 36 (256-257). “Message of His Holiness Pope John Paul II” in R. J. Russell, W. R. Stoeger, G. V. Coyne (eds.), 1988, Physics, Philosophy and Theology. A Common Quest for Understanding. Vatican City: Vatican Observatory. The message and a number of comments on this in: R. J. Russell, W. R. Stoeger y G. V. Coyne, John Paul II on Science and Religion. Reflections on the New View from Rome. Vatican City: Vatican Observatory Publications, 1990. Frank Press, 1984. Science and Creationism: A view from the National Academy of Sciences. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
29
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
Barbour goes over the arguments, deduced from the Protestant, theological movements of neo-orthodox faithism, religious existentialism and linguistic analysis, in favour of considering science and religion as independent and autonomous forms of life and thought, with no relationship between them41. To sum up, according to the Protestant neo-orthodox movement and its main proponent the German theologian Karl Barth, religion is based on faith as a relation of man to God who is revealed in history, not in nature. For Christianity, God can only be known insofar as He is revealed in Christ and is confessed in faith. Therefore, the contrast between science and religion becomes stronger, as the former is based on observation and on human reason, while the second is based on divine revelation. Another current which also defends the separation between the two is existentialism. According to Barbour, this involves the contrast between the realms of personal conscience and that of non-personal objects. For the religious existentialists God is found in immediacy and personal participation, which characterises the subject relationships of the I-you type and not the object making, I-It analysis, proper to scientific knowledge. The third current of linguistic analysis considers science and religion to be two distinct languages which are independent from each other. Barbour concludes his analysis of these three currents stating that they understand science and religion to be forms of life and thought which are autonomous and independent. Recently, the palaeontologist, Stephen Jay Gould formulated the postulate of the total independence of science and religion with the term “non-overlapping magisterial” and the acronym NOMA42. For Gould science involves documenting the factual character of the natural world, what the world is made of and developing theories which coordinate and explain these facts and how they function, while religion moves in the field of human objectives, the human sense of reality and ethical values, subjects which the factual domain of science can enlighten but never resolve. From this point of view, Gould does not see how the two can be unified or synthesised in an explicatory scheme or common analysis and understands that they must not undergo any conflict43. Therefore, in his words, they are teachings which do not overlap. There must be a respectful concordat between them. Although he proposes mutual independence as the only relationship possible and desirable, he accepts that both must be open to dialogue which rejects irenism, which syncretism and the posture of the politically correct, which avoids any discussion, may lead to. This posture approaches the one held by the physicist Max Planck, the father of quantum mechanics, who said, “Science and religion are two parallel ways which only join in the infinite”. As Barbour acknowledges, if science and religion were totally independent, all risk of conflict would be avoided, however, this should not exclude the possibility of a constructive dialogue and mutual enrichment44. In addition, he wishes to maintain science and religion totally separated, with no interaction between them, is completely impossible, as shown by history. Throughout history, both religion and science are components of a broader process which we can designate as culture, which also includes art in all its manifestations, personal relationships and other manifestations. Among these there can only be continual interaction. Although the very autonomy of each of
41 42
43 44
30
Washington: National Academy Press, 6. Barbour (1988) 27-33 y Barbour (2004) 146-154. Steven J. Gould, 1999, Rocks of Ages. Science and Religion in the Fullness of Life. New York: Ballentine Publ. Gould (1999), 4-5. Barbour (2004), 154. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
these cultural manifestations must be respected, their interaction and mutual dialogue must also be accepted. 15. Dialogue As we have seen, respecting each other’s autonomy, absolute independence is neither realistic nor sufficient, and, throughout history, science and religion have interacted in many ways. Basically, both are visions of the same reality and cannot ignore each other. In many cases, one person participates in both and cannot maintain a schizophrenic attitude, dividing his mind into two watertight compartments. If the relationship of a continual and inevitable conflict does not represent the real situation, absolute independence is not recommendable either. Therefore, it is necessary to propose a relationship of dialogue45. Dialogue involves communication, an exchange of information between the two. Religious reflection (theology) must take into account the vision of the world offered by science as, in all religions, there is always a consideration of the relationship between the world and the divinity. Part of the essence of all religions is the expression of the relationship between the world and God, and between man and nature, through its rituals and symbols, and this puts man in contact with the problems of the origin of the universe and of life. In the three monotheist religions, Judaism, Islamism and Christianity, God is the creator of the world, which depends totally on Him. In them the contemplation of the world, as emerging from the hands of God, and which includes the manifestation of His presence, is an important component. On speaking about creation, the questions about what this world which God has created is like, and which we know through science, undoubtedly, are also important for theology. In the 13th century Saint Thomas Aquinas stated that the error regarding the nature of creatures leads to a false idea of God and this can separate the minds of men from God46. Therefore, theology cannot be totally indifferent to the images of the world which sciences create. In fact, throughout history, mutual influence has always existed. For example, the religious vision of the world has assumed the cosmological conceptions in force in each epoch. The narration of creation in Genesis reflects the cosmological image of the world present in the culture of the Middle East, at the time of its composition, and, later the Fathers of the Church assumed the geocentric model of the Greek astronomy. If it can be said that a certain dialogue has always existed, this must become more explicit and intense today. Barbour proposes that the field of this dialogue be the limit or frontier questions put forward by scientist, but whose answers elude their methodology. Examples of these are the origin and destiny of the universe and man, the future of humanity and the ethical questions about scientific practice. For him, the methodological differences between science and religion must be attenuated by what he calls methodological parallelisms. From these the supposed objectivity of science and the subjectivity of religion must be refined, and it must be recognised that even from the methodological point of view there are points of contact between them. For Barbour, other fields in which it is possible to have and there must be dialogue between science and religion are the emergence of a spirituality focused on nature, or the aspects of an ethical and religious nature arising from scientific work. This dialogue is also referred to 45 46
Barbour (2004), 154-170. St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa contra gentiles 2, 3, 6: “Nam error circa creaturas redundant in falsam de Deo sententiam et hominum mentes a Deo abducit in quem fides diriget nititur, dum ipsas quibusdam aliis causis supponit.” God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
31
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
by John Paul II, in the document mentioned above, when he states that, “simple neutrality is no longer acceptable. Today we have an unprecedented opportunity for a common interactive relationship in which each discipline maintains its integrity and, however, is radically open to the discoveries and intuitions of the other”... ”The problem is urgent” he adds and compares the situation regarding the contributions of current science with the incorporation of Aristotelian philosophy to theology by Saint Thomas Aquinas commenting that, “Can we not expect that contemporary sciences and the forms of human knowledge, give vigour and form to those areas of theology which have to do with the relationship of nature, humanity and God? ”; he finishes by saying, “Science can purify religion of error and superstition, religion can purify science of idolatry and false absolutes”47. In order to understand this dialogue well, it should be understood that it is not quite symmetrical. While scientific knowledge of nature is important by itself in theological work, science as knowledge of nature does not depend on religious intuitions, although some scientists may be moved by these. In a sense, it can be said that science, in each epoch of its development, gives an image of the world, which is as complete as possible, within its own methodology, and it is not the job of religion to fill in these gaps which remain and which will be filled by science in the future. In this sense, religion does not contribute anything to science as knowledge within its own methodology. As rightly stated by John Paul II, what religion contributes to science is to free this from being an absolute, that is to say, from the danger of becoming an ideology, which pretends to have all the answers to the questions which man has regarding his relationship with the world, himself and his destiny. While the knowledge of the sciences concerning nature and man himself must be taken into account in theological reflection. In fact, the image of the world offered by the sciences has always been present in theological thought. Clinging to an image which was already being rejected by science was a source of conflict, such as the resistance to the acceptance of the heliocentric nature of the solar system and the theory of evolution. It was the lack of dialogue which led to the religious authorities to take decisions which were later regretted. This “intense dialogue with contemporary science” which is so necessary is missed by John Paul II in those engaged in the theological teaching and research. Science in itself can ignore theology, but theology cannot ignore science. The dialogue must be opened by both parties, but it does not have the same characteristics in both directions. Despite the fact that it is quite clear that there is a need for dialogue between science and religion, reality reveals that, in practice, this is not easy to carry out. In the 19th century and up to the middle of the 20th century, the absence of a true dialogue from the religious side was manifested in the apologetic postures. In many cases, these were a justified defence from the attacks of philosophical positions which used science as an argument against religion. These attitudes on both sides did little to encourage dialogue. As from the middle of the 20th century, the situation changed due to new focuses on the nature of scientific knowledge and the task of theology. As acknowledged by John Polkinghorne, who had been a theoretical physicist for 25 years and was then ordained as a priest of the Anglican Church, in this dialogue there have been an abundance of scientists, among whom were himself and the aforementioned Ian Barbour, a physicistchemist and Arthur Peacocke, a bio-chemist and Anglican priest, as compared with the theologians48. These three authors are considered to be the great pioneers in this 47
Juan Pablo II, (1988) Message, 24, 25.
48
John Polkinghorne, 1998. Belief in God in an Age of Science. New Haven: Yale University Press.
32
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
dialogue. Among the theologians whose absence he regrets, Polkinghorne cites the Protestants Thomas Torrance and Wolfhart Pannenberg. In the catholic area, uniting the scientific and the theological perspective, we can cite Michel Heller, physicist and professor of the Theological Institute of Cracow, William Stoeger, astronomer of the Vatican Observatory, Mariano Artigas, professor of the University of Navarre and Dennis Edwards, Australian theologian. Polkinghorne proposes a number of lines of dialogue with a greater participation of theologians and members of other religious traditions, besides Christianity, a serious discussion on ethical problems, the recognition in philosophy of forms of thinking from experience similar to that of science, the acceptance of holistic and relational points of view, which can be correlated with those of theology, and attitudes of critical realism as regards scientific and theological knowledge. Polkinghorne concludes by saying that, science and theology participate in the same finality which attracts the attention of those who have the intellectual integrity and the desire to understand. Within their forms and domains, these are involved in the search for truth and this is sufficient to guarantee that a fruitful dialogue will continue between them49. 16. Complementariness Another way of looking at the relationship between science and religion which entails something more than dialogue, or which makes the consequences of dialogue more explicit, is what we can define as “complementariness”. This relationship was recently proposed by the theologian Hans Küng, although it can be found in other authors50. This idea was already proposed in 1925 by the Danish physicist Niels Bohr, the pioneer of the application of quantum mechanics to atomic models, who considered that it was possible to understand religion and science as two complementary descriptions of reality. Bohr defended that, in physics there are complementary descriptions of one phenomenon, such as those of wave and particle, and he added that atomic physics teaches us that we must think more subtly about reality than up to now51. Under the term complementariness we understand that the two visions of reality which are offered by religion and science are not only not mutually exclusive, but complement each other. Conflict should not be established between them nor should they be kept totally apart from each other. Küng also defends that the integration of the two must not be sought, where the theologians adapt dogmas to the results of science, nor should scientists use religion for their theses. Küng defends a model of complementariness of criticalconstructive interaction where the sphere of each of these is conserved, illegitimate coparticipations are avoided and all attempts at absolutisation are abandoned by both. Thus, complementariness affirms that the two, together with other human visions, such as the artistic and ethical, are necessary to capture reality in all its richness. The difference between the relationship of dialogue and complementariness consists in the fact that the former only affirms that there must be a relationship between the two in which they communicate, while complementariness also affirms that neither of these is a complete vision of all reality and that each of them is complemented with the other. Therefore, complementariness entails that the visions of reality will not be complete if
49 50 51
Cap. 4. The continuing dialogue between science and religion. 77-100 Polkinghorne (1998) 99-100. Küng (2005) Instead of confrontation or integration he proposes a complementary model, 57-58. Werner Heisenberg, Erste Gespräche über das Verhältnis von Naturwissenschaft und Religion. In Hans-Peter Dürr (ed.) (1988) Physik und Traszendenzs. Die grosssen Physiker unseres Jahrhunderts über ihre Begegnung mit dem Wunderbare. Bern: Scherz, 305-306. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
33
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
the others are not included. The ways in which they can complete each other are of a different natures. This relationship can be illustrated with the famous words of Einstein: “Science without religion is lame and religion without science is blind”52. This can be interpreted that religion should be enlightened by knowledge of the world provided by the sciences, and that scientific work must be boosted by religious feeling. In one case, results presented by science must be taken into account in the theological formulations, and in the other the practice of science must take into account the ethical and moral intuitions proceeding from religious thought. However, these are only some of the many ways in which science and religion are complemented in order to create a more complete vision of reality. The vision of science, which is often reductionist, can be completed with the perspectives of totality and opening up to the transcendence provided by the religious intuitions, in turn, religious thought can be enriched by the progress made in our knowledge of natural phenomena. However, science and religion are not the only perspectives which man has of reality, there are others, such as the artistic or the ethical, and all of these contribute to an understanding of reality, without opposing each other and with a mutual enrichment. One example of mutual enrichment lies in the relationship between the religious and the artistic vision. Religion serves as an inspiration for many works of the plastic art, poetry and music, and artistic productions and these are often the vehicle for religious inspiration. The poetry of the mystical authors and the feelings reflected in the oriental icons are only two examples of this relationship of complementariness between religion and art. In another area an analogous relationship of religion and science can be proposed. 17. Integration The last type of relationship between science and religion proposed by Barbour is what he terms integration, although this term might not always be the most suitable one53. This category includes the proposals which defend a more direct relationship between the two, and which propose that it is possible to achieve a certain integration or continuity between the content of religion or theology and science. Therefore, this goes beyond dialogue and complementariness which we have explained above. In this model it is more precise to speak specifically of the relationship between theology and science as this is a question of proposals which start from one of the two and are integrated into the other. In the previous relationships, the positions were quite uniform, in this relationship there is a wide variety of positions. Here it is important also to consider the role played by philosophy which must be distinguished from that of science. In some cases, a philosophical reflection on reality takes on components of scientific knowledge and interacts with theology. Although it is difficult to classify the different approaches, Barbour, distinguishes three types of integration: natural theology natural, the theology of nature and systematic synthesis. Given the diversity of proposals with different characteristics, we now consider two large categories, the first goes from the scientific or philosophical knowledge of nature to a consideration of God and the second starts from a religious posture and integrates the contributions of science. This division may seem a little artificial and some proposals are difficult to classify in one group or another. Among the many proposals 52
Albert Einstein, Science y religion. En K. Wiber (ed.), 1984. Cuestiones cuánticas. Escritos místicos de los físicos más famosos del mundo. Barcelona: Kairós, 161-170.
53
Barbour (2004), 170-181.
34
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
which can be found in recent literature, we have chosen some, and have no pretensions to include them all. In the limited space available it is not possible to present even the most important lines of thought. We only give examples which illustrate the types of integration proposed. 17.1. From the knowledge of the nature to God The oldest proposal concerning the rational knowledge of God, which starts from the knowledge of the natural world, is that of natural theology in its classical meaning. Natural theology is generally understood to be a rational knowledge, independent of that contributed by religious faith, which approaches the existence of God and His relationship with the world and maintains that it can say something about Him. In it there is a way from philosophy which leads to the knowledge of God. This way is already found in the Greek philosophers, especially Plato and Aristotle. As we shall see in Christian tradition the possibility of this rational way to God has been proposed since the writing of the Fathers of the Church. Among the most famous formulations are the ontological argument of St. Anselm of Canterbury and the five ways to rationally approach God of St. Thomas Aquinas, which have sometimes been interpreted as true proofs of His existence. It is important to emphasise that this is not scientific knowledge in the modern sense, but rather philosophical and more specifically metaphysical. It is necessary to begin with the validity of the knowledge of being and it is the interpretation of the meaning of being that decides whether God can be known, in what aspects and how, taking into account that the image of God in natural theology is not yet the God of faith54. The possibility of this type of natural theology has been maintained until our days with some variants among authors in Catholic tradition. John Paul II insisted on its current relevance when he stated, “There is a way which man, if he wishes, can take and this with the capacity of reason to go beyond the contingent towards the infinite”55. This natural theology today can include also components of the natural sciences. Natural theology acquired another aspect in the authors of the Anglo-Saxon tradition beginning in the 17th century, who defended that, from the scientific knowledge of nature, it is possible to find signs of the existence of a creator God. The starting point is now the world known by science, from where the way to the existence and action of God in it is discovered. This type of argumentation was fashionable among the Protestant English authors of the 18th century and the beginning of the 19th century. Among these we can cite the work of William Paley, Natural Theology (1804), in which he insists on the unity, design and finality, found in nature, which are a proof of the existence and action of God in the world and that of Thomas Paine, Age of Reason (1807), which insists that nature known by science teaches us the divine laws present in nature and reveals the goodness of the Creator. Some of these authors even say that of the two ways to reach God, revelation and nature, the latter is clearer and more secure. The main argument used is that of the design, which these authors say can be found in the natural world known through science, that is to say, the admirable adaptation of the organs for their functioning, which indicate a creator God who has made them with this finality. This type of reasoning based on finality was deeply shaken and had problems in recovering from the Darwinian proposal of evolution, which denies 54 55
Klaus Riesenhuber, 1976. Teología natural en Sacramentum Mundi, vol. 6, 599-610. Juan Pablo II, 1998. Fe y razón. Carta encíclica “Fides et ratio”. Madrid: Biblioteca de Autores Cristianos, 44. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
35
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
any finality in nature, and where there is only a mechanism of chance and adaptation. We may conclude that science, alone, cannot find a design in nature and, in itself, is not a way to find God. A modern proposal which we can include within this last current is what is known as the “intelligent design”. The defenders of this proposal, present especially, in the united States, propose that the biological evolution, which we know has taken place on earth, cannot be explained only by the mechanisms of chance and the adaptation of Darwinist theories and, therefore, it is necessary to accept that this reveals the presence of an intelligent designer who has directed the process. In order not to appear too religious, the proposal does not speak explicitly of God, but of an “intelligent designer”. The defenders of this doctrine attempt to demonstrate with specific details of biological evolution that current science does not seem to adequately explain the need to accept a finality in the evolutionary process. In other words, the detailed study of the process of biological evolution indicates directionality and intelligent programming. The difficulty of this proposal is that it is presented erroneously as an alternative scientific theory to that of evolution and its proponents pretend that it should be explained in public schools together with the theory of evolution. The proposal starts from scientific knowledge of nature and, pretending not to leave it, try to show that purely scientific evidences require the recognition of finality and a designer. The way followed, however, is not valid as God cannot be reached through the deficiencies of the scientific explanation, within itself. This would be the often refuted “God of the gaps”, which science itself in time always renders unnecessary. Recognising a finality and design in nature belongs to another level of knowledge, not to scientific knowledge, that is to say to philosophical or theological knowledge. One proposal which we can include here, in part, is the thought of the French Jesuit palaeontologist, Pierre Teilhard de Chardin. He begins by calling attention to the role of science in human evolution as the true motor of progress, and from the scientific vision of the world, which presents us with its evolutionary nature, he reaches the conclusion that evolution must be convergent and find its culmination in what he calls the Omega Point56. According to him, this conclusion is reached logically led by the integral application to man of the experimental laws of evolution. He starts from the need to accept that the total study of the human phenomenon involves determined requirements and methods which go beyond those commonly employed by science. As he himself admits, his approach is not that of science in the strict sense, but that of a phenomenology, or generalised physics or “hyper-physics”, in which all aspects of reality must be taken into account. Therefore, not only the external face of the world, the subject of natural sciences, must be taken into account, but also what he calls its internal face. In this way, Teilhard thinks that the evolution of matter, always towards more complexity, in fact, entails evolution towards the consciousness which is linked to the interiority of things. For him, the biological process does not take place by pure chance, but it is necessary to recognise a direction in this, which marks the way of evolution of inert matter to life and consciousness. Projected towards the future by a process of human convergence, this culminates in the Omega Point, which, as it has the qualities of being personal and personalising is identified with God. Although in this way Teilhard does not invoke religion at all, he does recognise that he would not have dared to present this hypothesis without having lived it in his conscience as a believer. In the end, as he says, “religion and science are two conjugated faces or phases of the
56
36
Pierre Teilhard de Chardin, 1955. Le phénomèn humain. Paris: Seuil. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
same complete act of knowledge, the only one which can take in the past and the future of evolution in order to contemplate them, measure them and finish them”57. Philosophical reflection, in its search for the meaning and explanation of reality, can find support in the images contributed by science in order to go back to the consideration of a creator God. To do so, the nature of scientific knowledge and its limitations should be taken into account. For example, the enigma that man can rationally grasp the keys of the universe can lead to the discovery of an ultimate principle, which explains his rationality, or, otherwise, the combination of a world which is both contingent and intelligible can lead to the hypothesis of a necessary and rational God. The results of science thus become a starting point for the problem of God. The physicist Paul Davies dedicates a long discussion to this problem without reaching a clear conclusion, and only admits that by themselves, the ontological and cosmological arguments are only indicators of the existence of a necessary being. This being remains obscure and abstract. He asks that if a similar being exists, can we say anything about its nature supported by an examination of the physical universe?58 It is significant that, at the end of the book, he states that, the essence of his book has been to follow the retrospective footprints of scientific rationality, as much as possible, in order to seek the ultimate answers to the mystery of existence and he finishes with the question, if it is possible to hold that the ultimate objective of this search is more than a chimera.59 Thus, at the end of the way, Davies can only put forward questions for which science itself has no answers, and he does not find these answers in philosophy or theology either. Another perspective in which a more positive conclusion is reached is that taken by Frank Tipler, a theoretical physicist, in his direct route from science, and more specifically from physics, to God, which he calls the “Omega Point theory”. By this he means a theory which is scientifically verifiable and which proposes the existence of an omnipotent, omniscient and omnipresent God, who, in a far off future, will resurrect everyone so that we may live eternally”60. Curiously he holds a totally reductionist and materialist point of view and at no time appeals to faith. He confesses that the route of physics of necessity leads to finding God. Thus, he advocates the unification of science and religion and states that theology must be considered to be a branch of physics; not only this, but it must become a branch of physics if it is to survive. For him theology is only a physical cosmology, based on the suspicion that life, taken as whole, is immortal61. We cannot explain here how Tipler develops his thought and how he arrived at the need for the existence of a Point Omega in the universe. It is sufficient to present it as a system in which acontinuity is established in which the proposal of a God is reached through science. Naturally many of his proposals are very controversial, such as defining life as information conserved through natural selection and his model of God (Point Omega) which is evolving in its immanent character and is eternally incomplete in its transcendence and is, “from the quantum point of view, an omnipresent, invisible field which guides and gives rise to every being and which is finally Personalised”62. 57
Teilhard (1955), 316-317.
58
Paul Davies, 1993. La mente de Dios. La base científica para un mundo racional. Madrid: McGraw Hill, 184. Davies (1993), 217. Frank J. Tipler, 1994. La física de la inmortalidad. Cosmología contemporánea: Dios y la resurrección de los muertos. Madrid: Alianza, 33. Tipler (1994), 17, 43, 50. Tipler (1994) 178, 212, 245.
59 60
61 62
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
37
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
Along the same lines is the proposal of Diarmuid O’Murchu who calls it “quantum theology” and seeks to “dismantle the exclusivity of religious theology and open it up to everyone who is prepared to take part with the experience of the universe lived as a quantum reality”63. The starting point for O’Murchu is the mystery and the meaning inherent in quantum theory which goes beyond the purely scientific implications in order to affect the comprehension of life at each level of existence. According to this approach from the quantum vision of the universe, many of our concepts must be revised, such as, our image of God, who for quantum theology is described as “a creator energy, which includes and exceeds the attributes given by traditional theology and works through movement, rhythm and structures within the nature of life itself”. Another approach which we can include within this category is the one deriving from the philosophy of process. This philosophy was proposed by Whitehead under the joint influence of scientific and religious thought64. In it he develops a philosophical synthesis based on the idea of considering the essence of reality as a process, that is to say, as a sequence of changes. Reality is a dynamic network of interrelated events for which nature is both order and change, stability and novelty, a structure of processes in evolution. Reality is precisely the process itself. God is taken into consideration as the principle for the concretion of the processes. He is not concrete, but is the foundation of all concrete actuality. He is the source of all stability and novelty, of order and change and participates in both. God changes with the process itself and is both transcendent and immanent. Divine reality appears as the ontological basis of the cosmic process; it is not the process, but is the creator of the process. A synthesis between the philosophy of the process and Christian theology has led some authors such as Charles Hatshorne and John Cobb to what is known as the “theology of process”65. Certain aspects of the philosophy of process, especially as regards the relationship between God and the world are incorporated into the works of Barbour and with more nuances in the work of Peacocke66. As has been seen in the examples we have presented, the approaches are very varied and it is difficult to group them in one category. They have in common the fact that in them a start is made for scientific and/or philosophical knowledge in order to reach the idea of divinity and its relationship with the world. In all these there are a certain number of presuppositions of a philosophical nature, which are not always explicitly presented. In some cases, it is assumed that science and religion contribute jointly to making a coherent vision of the world possible, from an all embracing type of metaphysics. Philosophical reflection appears as a meeting point of science and religion. In some cases, some type of metaphysics is proposed as the guide to search for a set of general categories, with which it is possible to interpret different types of experiences, especially those deriving from science and religion. These proposals start from the acceptance of philosophical or metaphysical principles which are employed to make the synthesis of science and religion. Other proposals which start directly from the natural sciences are even more problematic as within these it is not allowed this type of 63 64
65
66
38
Diarmuid O’Murchu, 1997. Quantum Theology. New York: Crossroad, 49-51. Alfred N. Whitehead, 1925. Science and the Modern World. New York: MacMillan; 1929. Process and Reality. New York. John Cobb y Donald Griffin, 1976. Process Theology: An Introduction. Philadelphia: Westminster Press. Charles Hartshorne, 1948. Divine Relativity. New Haven: Yale University Press. A summary of these two authors can be found in Javier Montserrat , 2004. Ciencia y philosophy del proceso y Dios en Ian G. Barbour. Pensamiento, 60, 33-66; 2005. Ciencia, bioquímica y panenteísmo en Arthur Peacocke. Pensamiento, 61, 59-76. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
reflection. However, we must remember that the frontier between philosophy and science is somewhat blurred and we cannot prevent scientists entering the field of philosophical and even theological considerations, either to affirm or deny the existence of God. It is not always clear at what level the discussion is carried on and sometimes the frontier between the two is crossed without recognising it. Sometimes scientific arguments are provided in order to support postures which, in fact, are philosophical or even theological. One example can be found in the popular book of Stephen Hawking of which Carl Sagan states in its prologue that this is also a book about God ... or perhaps the absence of God. The word God fills these pages ... And this makes the conclusion of his efforts unexpected, at least up to now: a universe with no special edge, with no beginning and no end and with no place for a creator67. Just as the authors we have cited begin from the knowledge of the world through science to arrive somehow at God, here an attempt is made to arrive at the negation of God. Hawking seems not to realise that from the scientific image of the universe, regardless of what this may be, God cannot be affirmed or denied. The same can be said about the negation of God in the works of Richard Dawkins starting from the principles of biological evolution68. Another type of reasoning is required and this is lacking in these and other similar works. This same precaution must also be taken into account as regards some of the attempts which we have presented in which a consideration about God can be reached from the scientific knowledge of the world. 17.2. From religious faith to knowledge of nature and science Another approach to this problem is the one which begins from a religious position, assumed within a specific tradition, and from this a vision of nature and science is taken so that the sciences are allowed to influence the religious formulations. Barbour groups these postures with the term “theology of nature”69. A start is made from the verification that the vision which we have of nature, which is conditioned by our scientific knowledge, can condition our thought on the relationship of God with it. Today science presents nature to us as the result of a cosmic and biological evolution involving laws and chance. This image can influence our way of thinking, both about the relationship of nature with God and also that of man with nature. Within the theology of nature, Barbour presents several questions which are all related to the doctrine of creation. Some of them are the following: man’s stewardship of nature, which defines the attitude of man as regards to nature, as not that of a master, but that of an administrator; a sacramental vision of nature which recognises that the sacred becomes present in it; and the presence of the Holy Spirit in nature which serves as a link between the action of God as creator and redeemer. According to Barbour, these points of view on nature also offer an interesting basis for environmental ethics. For Arthur Peacocke the scientific knowledge of nature entails a substantial challenge to Christian theology, which takes the created world and its nature seriously. For him, the character of the natural world and man himself, known through science, have enormous theological importance. What nature is and what God is are intertwined questions which cannot be dealt with separately. Thus, it is necessary to reformulate the traditional religious beliefs from the interaction with current science70. For him the 67
68 69 70
Stephen Hawking, 1988. Historia del tiempo. Del big bang a los agujeros negros. Barcelona: Crítica, 14. Richard Dawkins, 2006. The God Delusion. New York: Bantam. Barbour (2004) 173-178. Arthur Peacocke, 1996. Theology for a Scientific Age. London: SCM Press. 1-23. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
39
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
relationship between science and theology must be considered from the perspective of the critical realism of both disciplines, and they should be seen as two interactive approaches to reality. The theology which starts from the experience of God must take the critical-realist perspective of the sciences regarding man and nature seriously as it holds that God Himself has given the world the type of being it has and that this reveals in certain aspects the nature and the objectives of God. Theology, for Peacocke, must be, at least, in “consonance” with the scientific perspectives of the natural world. This author insists that, on contemplating the action of God in the world, both his transcendent and immanent characters must be taken into account as both are important for understanding the role of theology and the relationship with science71. The thought of John Polkinghorne also belongs to this category as it starts from within the Christian tradition72. Although we saw part of his thought when we spoke of the dialogue between religion and science, in reality, this author goes beyond dialogue, as, for him, faith in God today offers a way to find meaning in the broader group of human experiences and to unify the many aspects of our encounter with reality. For him, only faith in God can provide a total meaning to the world and the best explanation of the wide variety of religious and human experiences. Polkinghorne takes an attitude of critical realism as regards both science and theology, that is to say, both contribute knowledge which has to do with reality, and therefore, there can be no contradiction between them. For example, in Christian tradition God acts in the world and in a way scientific knowledge of the world cannot absolutely exclude divine action. In the previous section we saw the thought of Teilhard as a way which went from knowledge of the evolutionary development of the universe, life and man to the recognition of its convergence in a divine Omega Point. Teilhard does not finish his thought here, but starting from the Christian faith he establishes a new interpretation in which the Christ of the faith appears as the Omega Point of evolution. This idea, which entails a reformulation of the role of Christ, taking into account the evolutionary vision of the universe presented by the sciences, is developed by Teilhard especially in his later writings73. In this proposal, the contribution of science to the evolutionary character of the universe leads to a new interpretation of the mystery of the Christ of faith and also the vision of the Christian faith also enlightens the image of the world contributed by science. Other proposals which can be included here are those recently put forward under the name of “theology of science”. I believe this term appears for the first time in the work of Michael Heller, who presents it in analogy with the well established philosophy of science. For him, the theology of science constitutes an authentic theological reflection on the sciences: their existence, their bases, their methods and results74. Heller recognises the difficulty of defining a science which still does not exist, but he situates it within the movement in Catholic theology initiated with the Vatican Council II on the theology of earthly values. As an approximation he proposes that the theology of science is an integral part of theology and would study the consequences of the fact that 71 72
73
74
40
Peacocke (1996) 19-23. Polkinghorne (1998), 1-24, 2000, Faith, Science and Understanding, New Haven: Yale University Press. 2005, Exploring Reality. The Intertwining of Science and Religion. New Haven: Yale University Press. A summary of his thought can be found in Javier Montserrat, 2005. John Polkinghorne, Science y religion desde la física teórica. Pensamiento, 231, 363-393. For example in Teilhard (1955) 324-332 and more developed in : Le Christ évoluteur (1942) and in: Le Coeur de la matiere (1950) (Oeuvres, 10, 163-176 and 13, 50-74. Paris: Éditions du Seuil). Michael Heller, 1996. The New Physics and a New Theology. Ciudad del Vaticano: Vatican Observatory Publications, 95-103. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
the natural sciences explore the world created by God. It has to do with the philosophy of science, but it goes beyond this, as it contemplates the world known by science as created by God, a point of view not accessible to science itself. According to Heller its purpose is, therefore, a reflection on the sciences in the light of the creation and is presented as a way of thinking science from a Christian perspective. The proposal of a theology of science has spread with a variety of meanings, for Richard Kirby it is based on the Christian doctrine of creation, redemption and sanctification from the mystery of the Trinity75, while for Donald Lococo it is based on the presupposition of the unity in science and in theology with the concept of the Logos, as the rational basis of being, necessary in both76. For José Antonio Jáuregui, the theology of science arises spontaneously from the inevitable question on God, which ends up also being asked from science, either to affirm or deny His existence. Commenting on the excursions of modern scientists, such as Hawking, into this matter Jáuregui comments, “These modern or fashionable scientists have given birth to a new academic creature, the Theology of Science. I applaud his daring”77. The meaning given by Jáuregui is different from that of the authors mentioned above. The very term is ambiguous and I believe that its content is not quite clear. If what is meant is a theological reflection on nature known through science, that is to say, on the content of science, it would be more pertinent to speak of a theology of nature, as above. A theological reflection on science itself, that is to say, its methodology and practice is more problematic. Just as a philosophy of science which investigates the type of knowledge which is scientific is pertinent, it is not clear in what aspect a theology of science can contribute, other than the theology of nature. 18. Conclusions From the ideas explained we see that several types of relationship can be established between science and religion. We must admit that they do not exclude one another and some can be present at some times with preference to other. The relationship of conflict cannot be made as the only one since it does not correspond to the nature of these two visions of the world, nor does it represent the complex, historical relationships which have existed between them. Although there have been times of conflict, these have not been constant throughout history and many factors alien to religion and science were involved. The relationship of mutual independence, although it is part of a correct consideration of the different realms and types of knowledge present in religion and science, it cannot be taken to the extreme of denying all other relationships between them. It is true that religion is not science and science is not religion, but, while respecting their mutual autonomy, there must be relationships which enrich both of them. In fact, historically, this has happened on many occasions. Dialogue and complementariness are the two models which are proposed in order to understand how they have in fact interacted at times in the past and especially how they must interact in the future, as the influence of science becomes stronger in culture and in society and in the conception which man has of the world and himself. Dialogue recognises the need for mutual enrichment which they can contribute to each other. As was mentioned above, complementariness adds to the dialogue the wareness of the incapacity of each 75 76 77
Richard Kirby, 1993. Toward a Theology of Science. Window Quarterly, 3. 1-20 Donald Lococo, 2002. Toward a Theology of Science. Toronto: Novales. José Antonio Jáuregui, 1992. Dios, hoy, en la ciencia, en la cultura, en la sociedad y en la vida del Hombre. Oviedo: Nobel, 25-81 God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
41
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
one alone to achieve a complete vision of the world and how both can help each other instead of being a hindrance. Other visions of the world, such as the artistic and ethical, must also cooperate in this task. The recognition of the need to complete our vision of the world, which is not provided by either in isolation, must open up ways of positive interaction between them. The two categories into which we have divided the possibility of more integration between religion and science offer more problematic proposals. In both ways, from science to religion and from religion to science, certain continuity between the two is proposed, which is not present in the relationships of dialogue and complementariness. As we have seen, the role of philosophy now appears as an intermediate field, as well as explicit theological reflection as a vehicle for the relationship with science. We have presented some examples of the many proposals made within each group. Within the first group, it is important to begin by rejecting all more or less concealed attempts to base the way to God from the gaps in the scientific explanation, that is to say the so called “God of the gaps”, which the progress of science will render unnecessary in the future. This does not mean that the scientific explanation is accepted as a complete explanation of reality. Also an important element to be taken into account at all times is from which epistemology of science we start off. Finally, the way of reason to God necessarily entails the acceptance of metaphysics, as without this the way would be closed. It should be borne in mind that from science alone, enclosed in its own methodology, only entities related to experience can arrive (through experiments and observations), therefore, it is no possible to open to the consideration of anything transcendent. The second group of proposals takes the opposite direction and starts from the religious faith lived in a specific tradition, from where the results of science are seen, and an attempt is made to integrate them. Its difference with dialogue lies in the fact that an endeavour is made to reformulate some aspects of faith, taking into account the new visions of the world provided by the sciences. Above all, this has to do with the relationships between God, man and the world. For example, how must creation be understood today considering the new cosmological theories, and how the presence and action of God in the world must be understood, without breaking the laws which He has imposed on it. Other examples are how the theological vision of man must be understood, taking into account his position in biological evolution, which affects the Christian doctrine of original sin and the Incarnation. In addition, this may involve reinterpreting nature known by science within a theological vision which discovers vestiges of God in nature, especially in the religions which accept a creator God. This line of thought leads to what we have called a theology of nature, which also has consequences for the relationship of man with nature. However, the formulation of theology of science does not seem to us to be right, science is an instrument for knowing nature which has its own rules, and theological reflection has little to say about these. It should be understood that, as regards these ways to integrate science and theology, which we have examined, their mutual autonomy must be respected at all times. Science must continue to be science and religion must continue to be religion, with no attempts to convert one into the other. This does not mean that elements of one cannot be integrated into the other, especially those involving the scientific vision of the world in theological thought, always taking into account, that science is always provisional and subject to continual revisions throughout time. What we have called theology of nature is part of theology not of science. It may also be useful to the 42
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
Introduction to the Relationship between Science and Religion
scientist and enlighten him in the practice of science that he may acquire a religious feeling of veneration of God in nature. The Psalmist exclaimed, “The heavens proclaim of the glory of God”. This feeling of discovery of the mark of God in nature has been present in many of the great scientists, such as the physicists Kepler, Newton, Lord Kelvin, Maxwell and Plank.
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Universe
43
Teilhard de Chardin
PART II: TEILHARD DE CHARDIN Teilhard de Chardin and the Current Dialogue between Science and Religion AGUSTÍN UDÍAS UNIVERSIDAD COMPLUTENSE, MADRID In the writings of Teilhard de Chardin we can find many points of interest for the dialogue between science and religion. In this work I have selected three of these: his conception of science, matter and human evolution. The first is focused on his great respect for science and its role in human history. Science for him represents the line along which evolution progresses at human level. Science surpasses its specific function and also prepares man to find the deepest, most hidden meanings of reality. This conception of science may serve as a starting point in the dialogue between science and religion as it recognises the potentialities of science to be interpreted in religious terms. The second is his conception of matter which surpasses all duality of matter and spirit. Matter for Teilhard has an internal dynamism which leads it towards the spirit through the process of cosmic evolution. The third is his conception of human evolution which situates it within cosmic evolution. In it human consciousness progresses in the line of a progressive increase in unity until it converges in the Omega Point, where it finds its definitive perfection. Introduction In 2005 we celebrated the fiftieth anniversary of the death of Teilhard de Chardin, an occasion to re-examine his thought. Pierre Teilhard de Chardin (1881-1955), a Jesuit priest, geologist and palaeontologist developed an original system of thought parallel to his scientific career which can be situated at the frontier of science, philosophy, theology and mysticism. During his life the ecclesiastical authorities prohibited the publication of the majority of his non-scientific works, although some essays were published in journals and other in private copies circulated among friends and admirers. Despite the efforts of the author to achieve the authorisation of the two extensive works Le phénomène humain (The Human Phenomenon) and Le Milieu divin (The Divine Milieu), these were not published during his lifetime. After his death in 1955, when the writings of Teilhard began to be published, they caused an enormous impact and were translated into many languages. The publication of all his works was a slow process. In the original French version, the first volume of the works of Teilhard were published in 1955 and the last in 1976. Other writings, letters and personal notes were published from that time on1.In this article the references to his writings are given according to the 1
The complete works in French are published in 13 volumes by Éditions de Seuil, Paris: I. Le phénomène humain (1955); II. L’Apparition de l’Homme (1956); III, La Vision de passé (1957); IV. Le Milieu divin (1957); V. L’Avenir de l’Homme (1959); VI. L’Énergie humain (1962); VII. L’Activation de la énergie (1963); VIII. La Place de l’homme dans la nature (1963); IX. Science et Christ (1965); X. Comment je crois (1969); XI. Les Directions de l’avenir (1973); XII. Écrits du temps de la guerre (1916-1919) (1976); XIII. Le Coeur de la matière (1976). His letter have been published by several publishers in 10 volumes, some of the more interesting are: Lettres d’Égypte (Aubier-Montagne, 1963); Lettres de Hasting et de Paris (1908-1914) (Aubier-Montagne, 1965); Genèse de un pensée, Lettres (1914-1919) (Grasset, 1961); Lettres intimes à Auguste Valensin, Bruno God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
45
Teilhard de Chardin
French edition of his complete works, the title of the essay and its translation, the volume of the work and the pages. As Teilhard assigned a special significance to some terms and created many neologisms, some of these are also given in their original French. The profound interest aroused everywhere by the ideas of Teilhard can be measured by the number of publications about these ideas, between 1956 and 1980 more than 3,000 books and articles were published in several countries2. Teilhard’s thought has been and continues to be the subject of many studies, which analyse it in its scientific, philosophical and theological aspects3. More recently, growing interest has been aroused as regards the mystical aspects of his work so that he is beginning to be considered to be one of the most important mystics of the twentieth century4. During the years they were being composed, from 1916 to 1955, the writings of Teilhard were considered with suspicion in ecclesiastical environments, especially due to his incorporation of evolution into Christian thought and his ideas on the origin of man, original sin and the role of Christ in an evolving world, even after their publication, they were prohibited in seminaries. Teilhard himself was aware of the novelty of his thought and his confrontation with some aspects of traditional Catholic doctrine. However, despite all the difficulties, he was always loyal to the Church and to the Society of Jesus, and was convinced of his own orthodoxy5. With the changes provoked by the Vatican Council II, this attitude began to change and in some documents of the Council there are signs of the thought of Teilhard although these are not cited explicitly6. As from 1980, the interest in Teilhard seems to have lapsed, although there has recently been a certain awakening. In the new dialogue between science and religion, which originated around the 1970s, the work of Teilhard is scarcely cited. One explanation
2
3
4
5
6
46
de Solages, Henri de Lubac (Aubier-Montagne, 1974); Lettres de voyage (1923-1955) (Grasset, 1961); Lettres inédits à l’abbé Gaudefroy et à l’abbé Breuil (Rocher, 1988). In addition, part of his diary has been published, Journal, tome 1 (1915-1919) (Fayard, 1975), the notes from his retreats, Notes de retraites (1919-1954) (Seuil, 2003) and other short texts such as Hymne de l’Univers (Seuil, 1961). Volumes I to VII y XII were published in Spanish between 1957 and 1966 (Taurus, Madrid) and in 2001 volume XIII (Sal Terrae, Santander). Taurus has also published four volumes of letters: Cartas de viaje (1957); Nuevas cartas de viaje (1960); Génesis de un pensamiento (1963) and Cartas de Egipto (1967) and Desclée de Brouwer (Bilbao) Cartas íntimas de Teilhard de Chardin (1974). Recently El Medio Divino (Alianza, Madrid, 1989) and El Himno del Universe (Trotta, Madrid, 1996) were published again. A more extensive bibliography of books and articles on Teilhard can be found in Polgar, L., 1990. Bibliographie sur l’histoire de la Compagnie de Jésus (1901-1980), Vol. I-IV. Archivum Historicum Societatis Jesu, Rome.(volume III, 359-563). Among these are the following: Crespy, P. 1961. La pensée théologique de Teilhard de Chardin, Éditions Universitaires, Paris ; De Lubac, H. 1962. La pensée religieuse du Père Pierre Teilhard de Chardin. Aubier, Paris; Rideau, E. 1965. La pensée du Père Teilhard de Chardin, Éditions du Seuil, Paris ; Chauchard, P. 1965. La pensée scientifique de Teilhard, Éditions Universitaires, Paris. Some works which deal with the mysticism of Teilhard are: the first classic, C. F. Mooney, 1968. Teilhard de Chardin and the Mystery of Christ. Doubleday-Image, Garden City, N.Y. and the more recent by T. M. King, 1988. The Way of the Christian Mystics: Teilhard de Chardin. Michael Glazier, Wilmington and E. de la Héronnière, 2003. Teilhard de Chardin, une mystique de la traversée. Albin Michel, Paris. During a retreat in 1951, he presented the basis of his orthodoxy in the form, “Man as an arrow, the resurrected historical Christ at the head, Catholicism as the axis of panconvergence; in this triple sign, Why can’t it be recognised that my course is orthodox or “orthodrome”?” (Notes de retraites, 322). “Orthodrome” is a neologism created by Teilhard to refer to his course or straight trajectory. In particular, these are found in the document on the Church in the World, Gaudium et Spes. This values human effort in the world, the role of science and technology in human progress and the work of men. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
Teilhard de Chardin
may be the preponderance of authors from the Anglo-American tradition in this dialogue7 in which the ideas of Teilhard have not penetrated so much. However, many points of undoubted interest for this dialogue can be found in his writings. In this work some of these ideas are grouped around his conceptions on science, matter and human evolution. Before entering into the theme proposed, it will help to briefly present the main stages of the life and thought of Teilhard. A written autobiographical testimony in 1950 tells us how his thought went back to intuitions he had had since his childhood and which matured during his lifetime8. His interest for the natural sciences and especially for geology was soon awakened from the time of his secondary schooling. After he entered the Society of Jesus, he maintained this interest and between 1905 and 1908 he was professor of science at the Jesuit College in Cairo, where he began to carry out work in geology. This was also his first contact with the East which always had a special attraction for him, together with a certain persistent pantheistic temptation coming from oriental thought. After he had studied theology and then geology, Teilhard was called up in 1914 and went through the experience of war as a stretcher bearer at the front. This was one of the strongest experiences in his life which he interpreted as a “baptism of the real”. In one of his first writings in 1916 appear the germs of many of the themes which would be repeated throughout his lifetime and his vital attitude reflected in the first lines of the introduction to this essay: “I write these lines due to the exuberance of life and the necessity to live, in order to express a passionate vision of the Earth and to seek a solution to the doubts of my action; because I love the Universe, its energies, its secrets, its hopes and because I am also dedicated to God, the sole Origin, the sole Exit, the sole End”. This passionate love for God and the Earth will be constant up to the time of his death. In this same introduction there is a call to the Christian to recognise this “cosmic awakening” and “to discover the divine Ideal in the marrow of the most material and terrestrial objects and to penetrate the beatifying value and the eternal hope of holy Evolution”9. The acceptance of the evolutionary character of the universe, of life and of its integration in his religious and Christian vision will always be at the centre of his thought. The 20 essays written during wartime (1916-1919) already contain most of the basic intuitions of his thought, on which he would work during the rest of his life. Once he finished his degree in natural sciences in Paris in 1919, he began teaching geology at the Institut Catholique, but he soon had to interrupt this. In 1923 Teilhard made his first trip to China, where he worked in geology in the north of China and in Mongolia. From the time of this first trip, his life remained linked to geological and palaeontological work in China. As from 1939, acknowledged in scientific circles, he travelled to France and the United States and carried out field work in China, Kashmir, Java, Burma and South Africa, progressively linking his work to studies on the origin of man. At the same time, he continually produced philosophical and religious thought which culminated in the drafting of two fundamental texts: The Human Phenomenon between 1938 and 1940 and The Divine Milieu between 1926 and 1927 revised in 1932. The first includes his thought, which we can call philosophical, although he considered 7
8 9
Three of the most representative authors in the modern dialogue between science and religion are Ian Barbour, John Polkinghorne and Arthur Peacocke. Their more representative works are: I. G. Babour, 1990. Religion in an Age of Science. SCM Press, London; J. Polkinghorne, 2000. Faith, Science and Understanding. Yale University Press, London. A. Peacocke, 1993. Theology for a Scientific Age. SCM Press, London. Le Coeur de la Matière (The Heart of the Matter), XIII, 19-92. La vie cosmique (The Cosmic Life), XII, 5. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
47
Teilhard de Chardin
it to be scientific reflection, on physics and “hyperphysics” in the manner of the Ancient Greek philosophers, not physics in the modern sense of the word. Thus, he develped a global vision (Weltanschaung) of all the evolution of the universe, including the evolution of man, taking the data provided by the sciences as the starting point. At the end of the work, he added considerations on the Christian phenomenon, and how it must be interpreted from new perspectives. The second is a book of a purely religious nature, in which he presents a new focus on ascetic and Christian mystical themes, coherent with his evolutionary vision of the world. Throughout his life, which involved enormous activity giving lectures and talks, the total number of essays he left on different subjects, beyond those of strictly scientific character, and content in the 13 volumes of his complete works amount to 243, the last written in March 1955, only one month before his death10. The religious meaning of science The first consideration we find in the work of Teilhard, which today can help in the dialogue between science and religion, is found in his great esteem for science and the role he assigns to it in the evolution of humanity. In fact, for him science is more than a body of knowledge on nature, in his own words, it deals with Le gran affaire du Monde (The grand business of the world), and he refers to it as “a vital, human function, as vital as nutrition and reproduction”. This might seem exaggerated to us, but later we will see how he justifies this. Teilhard goes even further and adds that we must “believe” in scientific research, which, if followed by faith, constitutes the source of a unique, human-Christian mysticism which can contribute to creating a true, human unanimity11. This integration of scientific research with the religious feeling, which Teilhard considered to be necessary, for him is a consequence of a unitary vision in which the universe is “crossed” (traversée) by the presence of God. In a short essay written shortly before his death Teilhard leaves us his last opinion on what the sciences meant for him12. In this essay he insists, firstly, on the confirmation of the fact that scientific research has become quantitatively and qualitatively the main form of human activity. If this was true at the time Teilhard was writing, it is much truer today when we live in a culture which is strongly influenced by science and technology. Not only is the life of man today profoundly influenced at all levels by the progress of technology, but the conception of the universe and of man is based on the knowledge contributed by science. In some way, as sensed by Teilhard, it can be said that science has become the basis of human life. Writing on the problems which young Jesuit students dedicated to the sciences might find, Teilhard refers explicitly to the conflict between science and religion and states that a solution to this problem requires another approach to the Christian message in the light of science, especially by incorporating the ideas of cosmic evolution. He concludes the essay by pointing out how scientific researchers at the present time can be considered to be the leading patrols of a society which progresses towards new forms of adoration. This consideration of scientific research as a form of adoration is often repeated in several of his essays and can only be understood through a consideration of scientific activity within the evolutionary scheme, as we shall see below, in which God appears as the engine and finality of evolution and of his 10
11 12
48
The complete list of his essays contained in the 13 volumes of his complete works are in XIII (Index bibliographique général) 225- 236. This also contains a chronological list of his essays from 1913 to 1955 (Chronologie général des oeuvres), XIII, 237-246. Sur le valeur religieuse de la recherche (On the Religious Value of Research) IX, 258-263. Recherche, travail et adoration (Investigation, Work and Adoration), IX, 281-289. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
Teilhard de Chardin
conception of the presence of God in the world. Thus, we may think that Teilhard considered science with optimism, as the true engine of human progress. Even more, science constitutes, for him, not only the source of knowledge and understanding regarding the universe, but also it opens up to deeper forms of understanding reality, so that it can be said that it has in itself a really religious character. From his point of view, this can only be understood by the fact that science has a broader character than it is normally considered to have. For him, science is not limited to the knowledge of the structure and functioning of the material world, but extends beyond what we normally consider to be its limits, in order to extend to all aspects of reality in which the spiritual dimension and transcendence enter. In order to understand Teilhard’s position regarding science, we must consider this in the context of his vision of human evolution and this as part of total cosmic evolution. Although this will be explained more at length in the next section, it is now sufficient to advance that for Teilhard the universe is in a state of cosmic evolution and human evolution is an integral part of this. For him, a central part of human evolution is made up precisely by scientific work. Thus, science for him represents the line whereby evolution progresses at human level. As the main characteristic of the evolutionary vision of Teilhard is that of its convergence towards its ultimate perfection through the spirit in what he calls the Omega Point, which he identifies with God, as will be seen below in more detail, all movement in the direction of convergence of the universe acquires in itself a religious character sense due to its relationship with the axis of convergence of the universe, in fact, acquires a mystical character13. In other words, in a universe in which all is finally directed to convergence through the spirit towards God, we must acknowledge a profound meaning of “sanctity” and “communion” in science itself14. With these words: sanctity and communion, Teilhard expresses the same idea as he refers to the religious and mystical character of science, that is to say, related to the evolutionary, convergent process towards God. In a real sense, for Teilhard scientific work, which consisted of developing ours consciousness of the world through knowledge, is also converted into something which can be called a priestly operation as it consists of a contribution to the progress of the world which is ultimately oriented towards God15. For him this is the ultimate reason for religious and mystical meaning of science. Scientific effort leads to progress through the action of men in a universe in which God Himself comes to meet us and in Him is our ultimate end. For Teilhard, therefore, the opposition between science and religion no longer makes sense. Teilhard took another step in the search for the understanding of the meaning of science and its relationship with religion, and introduced the role of Christ in a convergent world from Christian faith16. It must be remembered that, when Teilhard considers what he calls the “Christian phenomenon”, he identifies Jesus Christ as the Omega Point of evolution which is already present in the world. Thus, he discovers that, through the Incarnation of Christ, the very Pole of the convergence of the universe became present in the true heart of matter in order to attract all the movement of evolution and lead it towards its consummation For him, consequently, Christ is not an alien in the world, but the true centre of its convergence. Towards and through Christ, the Light and the Life of the world, through human work and effort carries out the 13 14 15 16
La mystique de la science (The Mystique of Science), VI, 202. La mystique de la science, VI, 222. La mystique de la science, VI, 202. This is developed in the epilogue with the title “Le phénomène chrétien” in Le Phénomène humain (The human Phenomenon), I, 324-332. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
49
Teilhard de Chardin
universal convergence through the spirit17. Through his cosmic vision of the role played by Christ in evolution and which we will deal with in the next two sections, Teilhard justifies his religious vision of science. He conceived his life’s work as an effort to bring Christ to the centre of the universe and lead the universe towards Christ (“universalise” Christ and “Christify” the universe)18. Teilhard’s understanding of the role of science and the role assigned by Christian faith to Christ, and which he interprets in the context of the process of evolution, is fundamental to understanding his position concerning the religious character of science. In this regard, science not only doesn’t opposes religion, but is in a way a preparation for it. In fact, science prepares man to find the deep, hidden meaning of reality, which for Teilhard is founded on the convergence of all evolution finally towards God. Once we accept that our universe is a universe in convergence towards its union with God, through the continual increase of consciousness, scientific work itself acquires a religious meaning. At a lecture on the relationship between science and religion, Teilhard distinguished between the method of science and the method of religion which he classified respectively as that of analysis and that of synthesis. With these two terms, analysis and synthesis, he expressed the distinction between scientific and religious knowledge. Therefore, for him there is no confusion between the two. Taking his mage of the universe into account, we can understand that for him, these two forms of knowledge do not exclude nor do they oppose each other. Thus, he states that, “Science with its analysis must not worry us in our faith. On the contrary, it must help us to understand and appreciate God”19. On speaking about the conflicts between science and religion, Teilhard concluded that these are not opposed, but, in away, they complement each other. Science in its desire to reach the ultimate truth of the universe finally meets with religious thought. “After two centuries of passionate struggle, neither science nor faith have been able to discredit each other. On the contrary, it has become evident that neither of the two can develop normally without the other …. Neither as regards impulse nor results, can science reach its true limits unless it becomes tinged with mysticism and becomes loaded with faith …. Religion and science are two features or phases of the same complete act of knowing”20. “A science loaded with faith” is precisely the title of the chapter dedicated to Teilhard by Henderson21. In this chapter Henderson develops Teilhard’s proposal to unite science and theology in a passionate search for God, whose presence must be acknowledged in both. On introducing the Christian mystery of the Incarnation of God through Christ in the universe, Teilhard went even further and concluded that, “Consequently, opposing science to Christ, or separating them as two domains which are strange to each other, are vain and unjust. Science by itself cannot discover Christ, but Christ complies with the desires which arise in our hearts in the school of science”22. In one of his first essays, in 1916, Teilhard had spoken of the “sacred fire of research” and had stated that, “it can never be said of religion that its influence has made men lazier, shyer, less human … that its dogmas risk withering the interest in the world, limiting the progress of the horizon of
17 18 19 20 21
22
50
Science et Christ ou analyse et synthèse (Science and Christ or Analysis and Synthesis), IX, 61. Notes de retraites, 202. Science et Christ ou analyse et synthèse, IX, 61. Le phénomène humain, I, 316-317. Henderson, C.P. 1986. God and Science. The Death and Rebirth of Theism. John Knox Press, New York. Science et Christ ou analyse et synthèse, IX, 62. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
Teilhard de Chardin
research and the sphere of energies”23. Teilhard was fully convinced that science and religion must walk together. Accustomed as we are to the well known solution of keeping science and religion separate with no interaction between them, we may think that Teilhard’s proposal is both unreal and absurd. Isn’t science in itself atheistic, that is to say doesn’t it dispense with all transcendent aspects of reality? How can it, then, become a way to God? In fact the solution which considers science and religion as two independent and autonomous domains has served as a good solution to prevent the conflicts of the past24. However, even accepting this mutual separation and autonomy, it is also recognised that it cannot be permitted that they totally ignore each other; a fruitful dialogue between them is obviously necessary. Even a proponent of the complete independence of science and religion like Stephen Gould, a scathing critic of Teilhard, agrees with the need for a certain dialogue between them25. Today there is a strong conviction that theology cannot progress in isolation from the increase in the knowledge of the natural world provided by science. This is not new, medieval theologians were already aware of the need for a correct knowledge of the world for theology26. However, science cannot be totally isolated from the source of inspiration and the ethical demands which arise in religion. Although the necessary autonomy of science and religion must never be forgotten, mutual interaction will always benefit both and is very necessary27. As regards his integrating proposals of continuity between science and religion, it may seem to us that perhaps Teilhard has gone too far, but we can only accept that his ideas open up ways along which we must dare to walk. The spiritual dimension of matter The ideological position called “scientific materialism” is recognised as the most serious source of confrontations between science and religion28. Scientific materialism is founded on two principles: the first, matter (including energy) is the fundamental reality of the universe and the second, science, which studies matter, is the only valid knowledge. The former is an assertion of a metaphysical nature and the latter is of an epistemological nature based on the former. If all that exists is matter, the only possible knowledge of reality is that of science, which studies precisely the nature and processes of matter. Consequently, for scientific materialism, the only reality is matter known through science. Materialism always implies a certain reductionism, that is to say, the affirmation that all knowledge of any system, however complex this may be, can be reduced to its simplest components. Thus, at least, in principle, everything could be explained in terms of the simplest components of matter, that is to say, the elementary 23
24
25
26
27
28
La maitrise du Monde et le Règne de Dieu (The Domination of the World and the Kingdom of God), XII, 83. On the relationships between science and religion and, specifically, mutual separation, see I. G. Barbour, 1990. Religion in an Age of Science. SCM Press, London. Steven Gould proposes a mutual independence of science and religion under the formulation of nonoverlapping magisteria. For him, science deals with the world and its functioning and religion deals with meaning and morality. However, at the end of his work, he accepts the possibility of dialogue between them. Gould, S. T., 1999. Rocks of Ages. Science and Religion in the Fullness of Life. Ballentine, New York, 221-222. Thomas Aquinas stated that a false idea of the world leads to a false idea of God and may separate men from Him, Summa contra Gentiles lib.2, cap.3, 6. This mutual need for dialogue between science and religion is affirmed by the majority of the authors who deal with these subjects and can be found in the works of Barbour, Peacocke and Polkinghorne cited. Barbour, 1990, 7-9. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
51
Teilhard de Chardin
particles and their interactions. Following this line, the sciences can be classified, from the minor to the major complexity of their subject matter, into: physics, chemistry, biology, psychology and sociology. Physics which deals with the most elementary particles of matter, their interactions and the forces of nature, could, in principle, explain all phenomena. We have said, in principle, as in practice it does not happen this way and each science starts from its own principles in order to explain the conduct of the systems which are progressively more complex. However, materialism does not exclude the idea that, in a complex system, might appear (“emerge”) some qualities not contained in its isolated components, but which continue to be at the strict material level. Consequently, for scientific materialism there is no reality apart from matter and, therefore, the consideration of any other reality, such as in spiritualism or animism, must be rejected as having no grounds. These ideas are very extended nowadays, as Barbour says, “The fact that scientific materialism has its origin in certain scientific ideas confers considerable influence on it in an age which respects science so much”. In the dialogue with this mentality, the ideas of Teilhard on matter can help very much. Teilhard began by rejecting all matter-spirit dualism and presents a concept of matter which includes in itself a spiritual dimension. Let us briefly examine his argumentation. Teilhard tried to understand the nature of matter, not from the starting point of its most elementary particles, but from the evidence of consciousness in man. That is to say, instead of trying to understand human consciousness from the constituents of nature, that is to say, from its biology or chemistry, as many neurobiologists attempt to do today, he tried to understand matter from the fact of the presence of consciousness in the material being which is man. In fact, if man is a self-conscious, material being, this quality of consciousness, clearly and explicitly present in man, for Teilhard has, in some way, to be present in all matter. A quality, such as self-consciousness, cannot appear as something totally new in man, without in a certain, even primitive way, already being present in the other beings. This led him to propose that there is an “interior” (dedans) of matter, besides its “exterior” (dehors), whose nature and functioning is the subject of the experimental sciences29. The interior of matter is linked to complexity (complexité), in such a away that, when complexity is increased, the degree of interiority is also increased. In turn, complexity is related to another characteristic of matter which he calls “centricity” (centréité), and both are related to consciousness. Centricity constitutes the capacity of integration of the components of a system in a unity, which could be called, “centred”, of a progressively greater order as more components are grouped together. On speaking of complexity, he observes the grouping of many components in each new unit, and on doing so with centricity, emphasis is placed on the fact that each new unit is centred on itself, grouping all the components which form it. The more components which make up a unit, the greater the centricity. For Teilhard, therefore, complexity centricity, interiority and consciousness are joined together so that an increase of the first also involves an increase in the last. That is to say, the degree of consciousness increases as the degree of complexity and centricity increases. This linking of interiority, complexity, centricity and consciousness is fundamental in Teilhard’s thought and is founded on the fact that consciousness clearly appears in man, whose brain is the most complex. Two types of energy also correspond to this dual character of matter (interior y exterior): a “tangencial” (tangentielle) energy, which corresponds to the physical energy with which things interact at their own level and another “radial” (radiale) energy, which is responsible for the convergence of the evolution of matter along the line of 29
Le phénomène humain, I, 49-64.
52
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
Teilhard de Chardin
greater complexity and greater consciousness. These two types of energy are, in reality, the two components of a sole, fundamental energy. Teilhard also calls radial energy spiritual energy as, for him, consciousness and spirituality are identified. Therefore, in Teilhard we have the identification of interiority, complexity, centricity, consciousness and spirituality in matter as dimensions, which increase throughout the evolutionary process due to the action of radial energy. These concepts of matter and energy are deduced for Teilhard from his vision of cosmic evolution which continuously proceeds from the elementary particles of the primitive universe up to the appearance of conscious, free man on Earth. In conclusion, for Teilhard matter, therefore, has an internal dynamism, which includes the spiritual dimension. It is a fact of observation that evolution proceeds along a line of greater complexity, with the appearance of progressively more complex systems. The most primitive universe was formed only of the most elementary particles (quarks and leptons) and later the simplest atoms of hydrogen and helium were formed. From these, in the interior of the stars, the other atoms were synthesised and then molecules were formed, from the simples to the most complex organic compounds. When the complexity of these compounds reached a certain degree, life appeared in the simplest form of unicellular bacteria. With the appearance of life on Earth the formation of a layer with new characteristics was formed, which Teilhard calls the “biosphere” (Biosphère). He also uses the word “emergence” in order to describe the appearance of this new condition of matter30. Once life had appeared, it developed towards progressively more complex forms, from unicellular animals to mammals and within these the primates, in which the brain acquired greater development as regards complexity. As we said above, this increase in complexity has a corresponding increase in consciousness and consequently a greater degree of spirituality. When beings evolve from inert matter to life and later towards greater degrees of consciousness, their spiritual dimension grows as they grow along a line of greater complexity. A new step is taken with the appearance of man in which consciousness is clearly developed. Just as the appearance of life created the biosphere, the appearance of consciousness developed in man created a new wrapping for the Earth, which Teilhard calls the “noosphere” (Noosphère)31. Thus, inn order to ensure the continuity of evolution, consciousness, which is present completely in man, must also in a certain primitive way be present in all material beings. With this continuity of evolution, Teilhard does not deny the existence of a discontinuity between life and inert matter and between man and the other animals, which he refers to as “discontinuity with continuity”. The appearance of the biosphere and the noosphere are two cases of the process of emergence, which form a discontinuity in continuity, with the appearance of life in the former and consciousness in the latter32. In one of his studies on the forms of matter, Teilhard drew up a type of hierarchy of forms in matter in which he distinguishes seven degree or levels, in accordance with their position in the ascending movement towards spirit33. Teilhard speaks of a formal or specific matter, at the lowest level, and a total or elative universal matter, at a higher level ad finally liberated or resurrected matter at the highest level of all. This last form of matter is linked to the situation of matter after the convergence of the universe takes 30 31
32 33
Le phénomène humain, I, 77-92 (The Appearance of Life). Noosfera (Noosphere) “This word designates the thinking layer formed by the establishment of the human zoological group, above (and in discontinuity) with the Biosphere"”. La structure phylétique du groupe humain (ThePhyletic Structure of the Human Group), II, 191. Le phénomène humain, I, 187-188. Le noms de la matière (The Names of Matter), XII, 449-464. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
53
Teilhard de Chardin
place in the Omega Point. These levels can be considered to be steps in the process of the spiritualization of matter or in another way, of the growth of the spiritual dimension within matter itself. At the lowest level is the most primitive matter and at the highest the matter with the highest degree of spiritualization. However, he recognises that, in reality, there are two basic movements or processes in the evolution of matter, that is to say, one downwards in the direction of the most primitive matter and another upwards in the direction of the spirit, that is to say, materialisation and spiritualization (matérialisation et spiritualisation) which are strongly linked with the two features or dimensions (material and spiritual) of the same material reality. The former leads to disgregation and towards the multiple, an increase in the “material” dimension of matter. In this process the complex systems disintegrate into their elementary parts, losing complexity and centricity, and, therefore, level of consciousness. The latter tends towards unification and towards oneness growing in complexity and centricity. The systems integrate a growing number of components in a unit and these bring with them a greater level of consciousness and constitute an increase in the spiritual dimension. Behind this conception is what Teilhard calls “the spiritual power of matter”, which permits matter itself to become the matrix of the spirit34. In this way, he asserts that matter is the matrix of the spirit and the spirit is, in turn, a superior state of matter35. It can be said that, for Teilhard matter itself has an interior dynamism which makes it evolve towards progressively higher levels of its spiritual dimension, up to the explicit appearance of consciousness and spirit in man. This evolutionary movement of matter towards the spirit does not end in man as, through the human spirit, the evolution of matter continues until its final realisation in convergence, as was seen already, at a common convergent point, the Omega Point. The convergence of the evolutionary cosmic movement is an essential component in the thought of Teilhard. For him an evolution which does not converge does not make sense36. In the convergence in the Omega Point the final perfection of all evolution is realised. This convergence is realised through the noosphere (human evolution), as we will see later. Matter itself which initiates its evolutionary movement in the origin of the universe does not achieve its completion until its convergence in Point Omega, through the evolution of its spiritual dimension in man. We will speak more extensively of this in the following section. For the Greek philosophers, especially those of the platonic school, matter and spirit were two totally distinct realities. In man the spirit (nous) is enclosed in his body (soma) and, therefore, matter was considered to be an obstacle to overcome in the development of the spirit. This type of thought is the source of matterspirit dualism (body-soul, and in modern times brain-mind) present in several forms in a large part of Western thought. In this type of thought, the big difficulty lies in explaining the interaction between the two components, spirit and matter. On giving matter the power to progress towards the spirit, Teilhard proposes to overcome this dualism. He finishes his considerations on matter with a poetical and mystical “Hymn to Matter”, in which matter is greeted at the beginning as “sterile land, hard rock which only cedes to violence … Dangerous matter, violent sea, untameable passion which devours and enchains”, however, he later addresses it as “the powerful Matter, irresistible evolution, reality always being born … which obliges us to always chase something farther the Truth”, and finally as “Divine environment full of creative power,
34 35 36
54
La puissance spirituelle de la matière (The Spiritual Power of Matter), XII, 467-478. Le coeur de la matière, XIII, 45. Le phénomène spirituel (The Spiritual Phenomenon), VI, 117-139. Le phénomène humain, I, 286-293 (The convergence of the personal and the Point Omega). God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
Teilhard de Chardin
ocean shaken by the Spirit, clay worked and animated by the Word Incarnate”37. We see here three states of matter: the first is full of the potentialities of inert matter which are still undefined, the second is developing the evolutionary movement of life towards the spirit and the last, inspired by Christian faith, as a vehicle for the creator power of God (which is identified with then the Omega Point) and is related to the mystery of the Incarnation of Christ (the Word). Thus, the proposal of scientific materialism in which matter is the only reality, which constitutes the seed of atheism, may be overcome, by showing the internal dynamism towards the spirit of matter itself, in the general scheme of a convergent evolution in which the ultimate final is God Himself. From Teilhard’s point of view, the nature of matter known by science is incomplete in itself as it cannot explain its evolution towards greater complexity and consciousness, which encounters its complete expression in man. The reductionist scheme of science, which begins with the simplest components in order to explain the nature of the more complex systems exclusively in their terms, does not quite explain the emergence of life and consciousness. Today, from several points of view, more “holistic” approaches (a word derived from the Greek holos: whole) are proposed, in which the consideration of the nature of a system as a whole influences the understanding of its more simple parts and it is recognised that the whole is more than just the simple sum of its parts. Teilhard follows this type of approach, when he considers that life and consciousness illuminate the very nature of matter. Thus, he does not introduce a dualist principle in order to explain consciousness (spirit), but, on the contrary, he places the capacity to evolve towards the spirit in matter itself. Consciousness is for him, in fact, a dimension of matter which is linked to its complexity. When matter becomes more and more complex and, therefore, also more centred (units which integrate more components), progressively greater levels of consciousness appear. At the same time, consciousness constitutes what we can call the spiritual dimension which in some way is already present, in accordance with its level of complexity, in all material beings. In conclusion, for Teilhard, matter and spirit are not two opposing or distinct realities, but two dimensions of the same reality. This conception of the matter-spirit reality cannot be understood outside the idea of the existence of evolution towards a greater consciousness or spiritual dimension, and finally towards a common point of convergence, attracted by the super-conscious and super-spiritual Point Omega towards which it tends. This final point is the most problematic one, but it is essential for the understanding of the complete structure of Teilhard’s thought. All the potentialities of matter finally depend on the total dynamic structure of reality, which can only reach its perfection through its union in the Omega Point. The existence of this Point Omega, which is both attractor and centre of convergence, is what gives consistency to all the evolutionary process in the direction of a greater spiritual dimension. Current science confirms that in evolution there is a process in time towards systems which are more and more complex, but it does not acknowledge any directionality in this. It is only a fact that the simple can only evolve towards the complex and complexity, as this provides an advantage against the environment and ensures survival. In this Darwinian scheme, life and consciousness have no special significance; they are simply states in a continual process, governed only by chance and the laws of nature. The scientific analysis begins with the consideration of the simplest components and from these an attempt is made to explain the more complex systems which appear, without acknowledging that anything new might emerge in the process. This analysis comes up against man’s experience of his own consciousness and 37
Le coeur de la matière, XIII, 75-91. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
55
Teilhard de Chardin
freedom, which cannot be explained satisfactorily within the reductionist scheme. Teilhard takes precisely the contrary route, that is to say, starting from the existence of consciousness or the spiritual dimension in man, he investigates the nature of matter in whose evolution this arose. The sciences provide him with the basic data on the evolutionary cosmic process, which has taken place in time from the most elementary particles up to man. Teilhard seeks a meaning in this process, recognising in it a directionality and, finally, the need for convergence. Only thus is he assured of the meaning of all the evolution of the universe. The other possible alternative would be to renounce finding any meaning in this38. Human convergence The third aspect of Teilhard’s thought which can help in the dialogue between science and religion is his conception of human evolution. As we have seen, Teilhard considers cosmic evolution as a consequence of an intrinsic dynamism of nature, which is developed from the simplest material particles, through the living beings (biosphere), to the conscious dimension of man (noosphere), throughout the increase in complexity and interiority or spirituality. For Teilhard evolution does not stop with human consciousness, but must go on, through human evolution. At this level, there are two possibilities. In the first each conscious component (men) could seek his perfecting in his own individuality or in a group. This would constitute a movement of disgregación which would finally lead to the disappearance of the human group. In the second all the conscious components (men) collaborate in a grand unification, as the only way possible to overcome the individual and collective forces of dispersion. In his own word, this involves carrying out “a gigantic psycho-biological operation, a type of mega-synthesis or super-structuring” in which all the thinking components of the Earth intervene. This mega-synthesis is carried out moved by radial energy, following the line of the main axis of evolution, in order to construct an interior totalisation of the world in the unanimous construction of the “Spirit of the Earth” (Esprit de la Terre). This last is a term dear to the heart of Teilhard in order to express the interior urgency which moves men towards the achievement of the longed for human unification. Another important characteristic of this unification process is the “personalisation” carried out through an internal deepening of consciousness regarding itself. The point of convergence in which the unification of the noosphere is realised and where it finds its culmination and, as we have seen, Teilhard calls the Omega Point, must be “hyper-personal”39. This personal and transcendent Point Omega is not only a passive focus towards which all evolution tends, but is an active pole which attracts everything to unification with it, and Teilhard identifies it with God40. The final convergence of the universe, which, as was mentioned above, constitutes an essential point in Teilhard’s thought, therefore, it is realised at noosphere level, that is to say, through human evolution, by a unifying movement, attracted by the personal and transcendent Omega Point. This final stage of cosmic evolution in the noosphere takes place through what Teilhard calls the “human collecting” (la collectivation humaine) or “socialisation”. What he understood by these terms is the subject of many of his essays, some of which are included in volume V of his works, under the title L’avenir de l’homme (The Future 38
39 40
56
One posture of this type is that of the theoretical physicist and Nobel Prize Winner Steven Weinberg who stated that, “The more the Universe seems understandable, the less sense it seems to make”. Los tres primeros minutos del universo, Alianza, Madrid, 2000, 132. Le phénomène humain, I, 286-293. Le phénomène humain, I, 326-328. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
Teilhard de Chardin
of Man). In these essays he recognises that his idea of the noosphere and of spiritual evolution are often difficult to understand. For him, at human level, evolution is linked to his idea of progress, conceived as the form in which human evolution is realised. The future of humanity, in fact, may finally tend towards a convergent unity or towards a divergent plurality. That is to say, humanity progresses either towards a certain unity or disgregate into a multiplicity. This double direction corresponds, at human level, to the double direction already found in the evolution of the spiritualisation and materialisation of matter. The former always means progress and the latter regression. In the way forward of human evolution, a previous state is the creation of a unified science and final objectives accepted by all. As was seen above, science for Teilhard corresponds to the human effort in the line of its convergent evolution, therefore, in order to achieve true progress, unity of method and objectives must be found in it. However, in order to avoid falling into divergent plurality, which always threatens the process of evolution at human level, and to ensure the convergent movement, these two components are not sufficient. There must be an attraction by "Someone", a “Centre of attraction” which carries out the final unification of all consciousness by a certain attractive force41. This is a difficult point and Teilhard was aware of this as man is free and, therefore, progress at human level is not an automatic and necessary movement. There are many ways possible for humanity to take in its evolution and not all of these lead to the expected end. Teilhard reduces these fundamentally to two: “evolution of plurality” and “evolution of the unit”. The former leads to divergence and disgregación, in which the constituent components tend to oppose each other, moved by what he calls a “mystique of separation”. This movement leads to individualism, both of individuals and of groups. Signs of this tendency can be found today in the growth of particularisms and nationalisms, which seek their satisfaction in the progress of the interests of individuals or groups in opposition to the interests of others. This introduces a component of disgregation and finally death into the evolution at the conscious human level. The only alternative for this is to achieve a true unification through what he calls “a universal socialisation”. This is what he calls the “grand option”42. Here humanity decides that the only route to follow is to work in the line which potentiates the convergent unity of all, as an aspiration which is universally accepted and participated in. On calling it “option”, Teilhard stresses that it is not something which happens of necessity, but implies a free decision by men. This is a process which, of necessity, will be slow and which we still can only glimpse. However, certain movements in which there are some characteristics, which tend towards a global unification above the forces which disgregate and separate, may indicate that humanity is beginning to move in this direction. For Teilhard the convergence of the noosphere is an irresistible process, although it implies human freedom, both at planetary and at cosmic level. The general process of evolution has two phases for him: one necessary or automatic which acts on inert matter and on life through biological evolution, and a second which is free at human level43. The force behind this second phase of the process of evolution, which must be carried out by man in freedom and which Teilhard calls “planetisation”, for him, can only be that of “love”. On first sight, this may seem strange and requires a clarification. In order to understand it, we must begin by understanding the general meaning which 41
Réflexion sur le progrès (Reflection on Progress), V, 85-106. La grande option (The Grand Choice), V, 57-80. 43 Un grand événement qui se dessine: la planétisation Humain (A Grand Event Specified: Human Planetisation), V, 159-175. 42
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
57
Teilhard de Chardin
Teilhard gives to the term “love” as “mutual internal affinity” (affinité mutuelle interne). In other words, according to Teilhard, “love is, by definition, the word we use to designate the attractions of a personal nature”. In this sense, “love” corresponds, at human level, to the continuation of what he has called the “radial energy”, that is to say, the energy which has always been the pulling power in all process of evolution from the first synthesis of inanimate matter and is responsible for evolution towards systems with greater complexity, integrating more complex components into progressively more complex units. At human level, that is to say, on dealing with persons, radial energy takes the form of what we call love as love is a uniting process and the only force which can carry out a personal union, without denying the individuality of the persons who make this up44. In his own words, “Only a union which is carried out by love and in love has the physical property not only to differentiate but also to personalise the components it organises”. His conception of human evolution is, therefore, dynamic and can be described as a tendency towards unity, moved by the impetus of love, in which the personality of those who are united is not lost. For Teilhard this conception is reinforced by the evidence provided by the natural and the social sciences. The former show a convergent movement in the evolution of the universe and living beings which results in man and the latter a movement of progress in humanity always tending towards some type of unity. In this context Teilhard introduces the role of religion and specifically the role of Christian faith, as a force which works in the same direction as human convergence. In fact, for him Christianity must become the “religion of the future” (la religion del’avenir) revealing what he calls the “human meaning” (Sens Humain), which Teilhard recognises is really implicit in it. As he conceives it “human meaning” is the motor force which gives impulse to all men towards their ultimate realisation in unity. For the Christian this realisation in unity takes place in the union of all men in Christ, forming a single body. Therefore, the aspiration towards the unity of men of Christianity coincides with what human progress proposes. This convergence between the Christian and the human meaning leads Teilhard to state that, “The light of Christ is not eclipsed by the brilliance of the ideas of the future, research and progress, rather His light occupies the centre which maintains his fire”. Following this line of thought, he concludes by saying that Christ is the only one who can save the human aspirations of our time45. In an epilogue to The Human Phenomenon, entitled “The Christian Phenomenon” (Le phénomène chrétien), Teilhard presents a Christian interpretation of all the evolution in which the Omega Point, towards which all evolution converges, is identified with the figure of Christ46. Thus, the universe in its movement of convergence at human level tends towards an ultimate unity which Christian faith recognises can only be implemented in the union of men with Christ. Christ Himself is, therefore, the presence of the Point Omega in human history, and helps its consummation to be carried out in definitive unity with Him. In this interpretation, the cosmogenesis of evolution becomes what Teilhard calls a “Christgenesis”, on identifying the pole of convergence of all evolution with Christ Incarnate. The unity of men and the unity of all the universe in Christ through men constitutes what he calls the “Total Christ” or “Cosmic Christ”. The process whereby the universe is developed is identified with that whereby the Total Christ is formed. These ideas are expressed more completely in one 44 45 46
58
L’énergie humain (La energía humana), VI, 180-192. Le sense humain (El sentido humano), XI, 21-44. Le phénomène humain, I, 324-332 (The Christian Phenomenon). God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
Teilhard de Chardin
of his last essays, written in March 1955, only one month before his death and which can be considered to be his spiritual testament47. However, this idea is already present in his first essay written in 1916, In which, for the first time, he uses the term “Cosmic Christ” and asserts that Christ has a cosmic body extended throughout the universe48. This cosmic body of Christ is the Christian version of unity towards which evolution tends. Teilhard’s insistence on the requirement of the presence of Christ in a universe in convergence may lead to some misunderstandings. For Teilhard this requirement must unite the total freedom of the Incarnation with a quasi-necessity as the universe cannot achieve its convergence and the unity towards which it tends without the mediation of the Man-God. This consideration of the convenience of the incarnation of Christ, even in the absence of sin, that is to say, coherent with the infinite love of God for man and with the aspiration of man towards God, is not new in Catholic theology49. God giving Himself to the created spirit, in Christ through the Incarnation, is the freest act of the transcendent love of god and also the culmination of the evolutionary ascension of the spirit in the world. For Teilhard the role of Christ is really central to all the movement of cosmic evolution50. The modern phenomenon of globalisation, which tends to erased the differences between peoples although still imperfect and incipient and be seen as something which participates in this convergent movement of the noosphere and can be interpreted as a sign, however weak this might be, of the human convergence postulated by Teilhard. Similar signs can be discovered in many phenomena which begin to gain strength in our times and which are the bases for globalisation, such as the increase in the world of communications at global level, the speed of transport which shortens the distances between peoples, the generalised preoccupation with international problems and the desire for international organisms such as the United Nations to play a progressively greater role. Television, for example, brings us the images of any event from all over the world, and projects the proximity of countries. These signs have led to the designation of our current world as the “global village”51. However, we should not ignore the fact that modern times are also witness to numerous, divergent movements, such as the imbalances between rich and poor countries, extremist nationalism, religious fundamentalism, violence, wars and terrorism. In the light of these negative signs, one might wonder if there really are reasonable grounds for the optimism of Teilhard. We would have to weigh up the present positive and negative signs, in order to evaluate which are the strongest, although it should be acknowledged that we are still very far from appreciating clear signs of human convergence. This distance should not lead us to lose hope that the processes of convergence will finally be imposed. We must not forget that Teilhard developed his vision during the period of the two world wars, and 47
Le Christique (The Christical), XIII, 93-117. La vie cosmique (The Cosmic Life), XII, 67. 49 Among the theologians who defended this opinion were Albertus Magnus, Duns Scotus, Francisco Suárez and Francisco de Sales. Fray Luis de León also gives this opinion: “All this universe, so big and so beautiful, was made by God in order t make His Son a man, and to bring to light this unique and divined fruit, Christ.” Fray Luis de León, De los nombres de Christ, Apostolado de la Prensa, Madrid, 1941, 63. 50 Le Christique, 3. L’Univers Christifié (The Christified Universe), XIII, 105-111. The central place of Christ in Teilhard’ thought is treated in: G. Martelet, 2005. Teilhard de Chardin, prophète d’un Christ toujours plus grand, Lessius, Brussels. 51 The term global village was first used by Marshal McLuhan in 1964. “Today after more than a century of electrical technology, we have extended our central nervous system in a global embrace, abolishing time and space as concerns our planet … time has stopped, space has vanished, we now live in a global village”.(Understanding media, Mentor, New York). 48
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
59
Teilhard de Chardin
the subsequent tragic division of the cold war period. Despite all, these negative signs did not cool his optimism and he was able to see the coming of future unity with hope. Today we need some of his optimism in order to be able to see, through the many dark signs, the light at the end of the tunnel which shines as hope for the future of humanity. Conclusion Accustomed as we are to the usual solution of keeping science and religion separate with no interaction between them, the proposals of Teilhard may seem hardly realistic. However, there is a growing conviction that science and religion cannot continue to ignore each other, or there will be negative effects for both and fruitful dialogue between them is necessary. Religion, or rather theology cannot progress in isolation from the continual growth of knowledge on the natural world which science continues to produce and science cannot be cut off from the source of inspiration provided by religion. In the present dialogue between science and religion, the thought of Teilhard de Chardin can provide us with many intuitions which can be of much assistance. We have very briefly examined three aspects: the importance he gives to the sciences as the main component of human effort which in themselves acquires a religious character, his open concept of matter which includes the spiritual dimension and the convergence of the process of evolution through the unity of humanity. Although Teilhard directed his proposal at all men of good will and starts from what science reveals to us today on our universe in evolution, in his work he makes a synthesis with religious thought. In fact, God is at present on the horizon of both science and religion, and indicates with this that a convergence between the two is possible. Thus, he insists on the need for religious thought to accept the image of the universe in evolution presented by modern science. This may imply serious changes in some formulations of religious thought, but these are necessary in order to keep the dialogue between science and religion open. We have seen two of the proposals of Teilhard which could have repercussions on religious thought such as his new concept of matter which includes the spiritual dimension and convergence in God of evolution at human level through a process of unification. This last point especially opens up dialogue with Christian faith on the role of Christ in an evolutionary world.
60
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
Teilhard de Chardin
The Bio-Philosophy of Teilhard de Chardin IGNACIO NÚÑEZ DE CASTRO UNIVERSIDAD DE MÁLAGA The scientist Teilhard de Chardin was a philosopher, malgré lui. However, his BioPhilosophy has not been studied to any length. Three days before his death, Teilhard summed up his credo: Cosmos = Cosmo Genesis = Biogenesis = Anthropogenesis = Christ-genesis. These are his grand intuitions which he endeavoured to clarify in his writings. Life on Earth is a property of organised matter and entails a pre-biological chemical evolution. The elementary grain of life is the cell, and the atom is the elementary grain of matter. The first simple organisms (prokaryotes) tended to join together forming more complex cells (eukaryotes) by symbiosis. These cells form aggregates of growing complexity due to internal tension or elementary movements of life: reproduction, multiplication, renovation, conjugation association and directed activity. As there is an attraction of masses, there is a gravity of complexity, which defines an ascending line from bacteria to man called: deep orthogenesis. In all reality there is an interior or conscience, growing in complexity, consequently biogenesis leads to anthropogenesis. On April 10, 1955 Pierre Teilhard de Chardin died in New York. A few persons were present at the burial in the Cemetery of the Jesuit Fathers. His tombstone among those of his companions reads, Pierre Teilhard de Chardin S. J.; Natus 1 Maii 1881; Ingressus 19 Martii 1899; Obiit 10 Aprilis 1955. On the 13th of March, 1955, at a dinner in the French Consulate in New York Pierre Teilhard de Chardin said: “I would like to die on Easter Sunday”, and the remark was recorded by one of his nephews who was there at the time1. Teilhard de Chardin, who acknowledged that he was a son of the Earth, and had travelled the long road of the Human Phenomenon and the Divine Environment like a son of Heaven2, who ended up saying, “The Earth can seize me with its gigantic arms. (…) I am no longer perturbed by the charms of the Earth since, for me, it was made beyond itself, the body of He who is and He who will come”3. Death for Teilhard was the culminating moment of life. His words can lead us to how he lived the moment of his death, “Death is responsible for carrying out the opening required as far as the very depths of ourselves. It will make us experiment the expected disassociation. It will place us in the organic state required for the divine Fire to penetrate us. Thus its awful power to decompose and dissolve is placed at the service of the most sublime operation of Life”4. In the work of Teilhard, Life hypostatised and always written with a capital letter. Teilhard de Chardin was not an experimental biologist, he was a palaeontologist, as is stressed by Leandro Sequeiros in the same Journal on Thought. However, as he himself wrote in his short treatise on maturity, which he finished in Paris in January 1950, the 1
2
3
4
The phrase was noted down by one of his nephews. It is mentioned in Pierre Teilhard de Chardin. Imágenes y Palabras. Translation by JESÚS AGUIRRE (Taurus Ediciones, Madrid, 1966) 214. TEILHARD DE CHARDIN, P., Hymne de l’Univers (Éditions du Seuil, Paris, 1961) 24. He was very fond of this expression and we also find it in his work Como yo creo (Taurus, Madrid, 1970) 105: “By education and intellectual training, I belong to the sons of Heaven. However, by temperament and professional studies, I am a son of the Earth”. TEILHARD DE CHARDIN, P., El medio Divino (2ª Edición, Taurus, Madrid, 1962) 185. From now on this work will be cited as MD. MD, 89. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
61
Teilhard de Chardin
human zoological group, “Man is a part of Life, and (this is the thesis sustained throughout the thesis) is even the most characteristic part, the most polar, the most alive of Life”5. For Teilhard it was impossible to investigate the past in order to open ourselves up to the future without studying “the place Life occupies in the universe”6. Thus, Teilhard, who was not a biologist by profession, did not wish to become involved in Metabiology, much less in Metaphysics, but he did endeavour to make a Hyperphysics, and, despite himself, he constructed a Natural Philosophy of Life7. On the fiftieth anniversary of his death, when the biotechnological revolution, which Teilhard did not live to see, has occurred,8 these pages attempt to develop the essential points of the Biophilosophy of Teilhard. The grand intuitions of Teilhard de Chardin: Cosmos = Cosmogenesis Fifty years after his death, we still have his grand intuitions. On April 7, 1955, three days before he died, he left a hand written notebook on the desk in his office, the last page of his diary. It contains a poly-equation which has the force of a last testament which has the title, “What I believe”. Cosmos = Cosmogenesis = Biogenesis = Anthropogenesis = Christogenesis9 The grand hypothesis of Teilhard was, “if possible to extend bridge or at least a plan of a bridge between Biology and Physics”,10 this was conceived in the trenches of the First World War and finished in his manuscript of the Human Phenomenon written in Peking between June 1938 and June 194011. It is interesting to observe how Teilhard’s thought progressed and matured, although not in a progressive linear sense, but in depth as the grand intuitions are already outlined in his youth. The autobiography of the thought of Teilhard de Chardin is written honestly and sincerely in his work The Heart of the Matter. In 1917 Teilhard wrote, “The history of my interior life is the history of this search oriented towards realities which are progressively more universal and perfect. Basically, my deep natural tendency has remained firm since I have known myself”12 We said above that Teilhard was a Philosopher of Biology, but a philosopher malgré lui, several times he confessed, “I am neither a philosopher nor a theologian, but 5
TEILHARD DE CHARDIN, P., El grupo zoológico humano (5ª Edición, Taurus, Madrid, 1967) 21. From now on it will be cited as GZH. 6 GZH, Ibidem 7 The Philosophy of Life has been considered to be a part of Natural Philosophy. Michael Ruse very clearly defines what we understand by Philosophy of Life, “In conclusion, there are many things which the Philosophy of Life should be. A philosophy must discover, explain and possibly resolve problems in theoretical biology and its methodology. It must be able to communicate its results to other philosophers, scientists and especially biologists. It must show the consequences biological phenomena and theories have for other sciences and for philosophy or the consequences other sciences have for biology and even for philosophy”. RUSE, M., David Hull through two Decades in What the Philosophy of Biology is”. RUSE, M., David Hull through two decades en What the Philosophy of Biology is, RUSE, M., Ed. (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 1989) 1. 8 NÚÑEZ DE CASTRO, I., Respeto a la vida humana y su integridad personal: V Congreso Nacional de Reales Academias de Medicina (Sucesores de Nogués, Murcia, 1989) 85-93. 9 “Last page in the diary”, TEILHARD DE CHARDIN, PIERRE, El corazón de la materia (Sal Térrea, Santander, 2002) 108-109. COLOMER, E., Teilhard de Chardin: Evolución y cristianismo. En CRUSAFONT, M., MELÉNDEZ, B. y AGUIRRE, E., La Evolución (Biblioteca de Autores Cristianos, Madrid, 1966) 889. 10 GZH, 21. 11 FH, 361. 12 TEILHARD DE CHARDIN, P. El corazón de la materia, p. 18. 62
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
Teilhard de Chardin
a student of the phenomenon, a Physicist in the old sense of the Greeks”13. The first thing that stands out in his testament is the repetition of the suffix genesis14, as if he wanted to state the essence of his thought in one word, everything is a process, a becoming in continual evolution and projected forward, focused on man (noogenesis), but in the last instance attracted by Omega, the God who is forward15. Projected has a double meaning: designed and thrown, thrown forward to the future and designed from the past. In his book “Does God Exist? Hans Küng has shown the similarity of the thought of Alfred N. Whitehead and Teilhard de Chardin, “like Teilhard in Theology, in Philosophy Whitehead endeavours to maintain a close connection with the thought of the modern natural sciences. He also understands all nature as a gigantic process in which an infinite number minimum units (…) enters into an active relationship with others, and all of these are developed together in small processes which are equally infinite in number”16. In his book “Does God Exist? Hans Küng has shown the similarity of the thought of Alfred N. Whitehead and Teilhard de Chardin, “like Teilhard in Theology, in Philosophy Whitehead endeavours to maintain a close connection with the thought of the modern natural sciences. He also understands all nature as a gigantic process in which an infinite number minimum units (…) enters into an active relationship with others, and all of these are developed together in small processes which are equally infinite in number”17. The hypothesis of Teilhard matured and was revealed almost simultaneously with the hypothesis of two other great scientists John B. S. Haldane18 and Alexander I. Oparin19 in cultural and social areas which were very distant from the world of Teilhard. In 1929 Haldane proposed that the appearance of life on Earth had occurred at the same time as the formation of the planets. Haldane was one of the first scientists to put forward the hypothesis that the presence of a reduction atmosphere was 13
14
15
16
17
18
19
Cited by COLOMER, E., op. cit., 863. see also: CUÉNOT, C., Teilhard de Chardin, (Éditions de Seuil, Paris, 1963) 117. In Teilhard the term genesis means the oriented process of general converging nature, “In the discussions, I believe that is sometimes a confusion between ‘evolution’ (in the generic sense) and ‘genesis’. Evolution may be indefinite or periodic or quolibet (abstractly speaking) … Genesis is an evolution directed towards a point of consummation; in this, ‘fixedness’ is synthesised with movement”. (Letter from Teilhard to T. V. Fleming, S. J. New York, May 18, 1954, in The Heythrop Journal, January 1965, p. 42) in CUÉNOT, C., Nuevo léxico de Teilhard de Chardin (Taurus, Madrid, 1970) 140. TEILHARD DE CHARDIN, P., El Dios de la Evolución, en Como yo creo (Taurus, Madrid, 1970) 263-270. KÜNG, H., ¿Existe Dios? Respuesta al Problema de Dios en nuestro tiempo (Ediciones Cristiandad, Madrid, 1979) 249-250. The underlining is ours. FH, 73. Pre-life is defined by CUÉNOT as, “The evolutionary phase which precedes and prepares the emergence of life, in which matter, insofar as vital and spiritual power is concerned, is still not actualised. A notion which emphasises the continual transitions between the structures of inorganic matter and those of organised matter, while not negating the discontinuous threshold of the emergence of life” CUÉNOT, C., Nuevo léxico de Teilhard de Chardin, p. 244. John Burdon Sanderson Haldane a British Biologist born in Oxford, he held the Chair of Biochemistry and Biometrics at University College London, in 1930 he joined the Communist Party. His writings are tinged with Marxism which he considered to be the most scientific philosophical system. Due to the attacks on Lysenko he abandoned the party and its ideology. Enciclopedia Universal Ilustrada Europeo Americana, Suplemento Anual 1963-1964 (Espasa-Calpe, Madrid-Barcelona, 1968) 271. Alexander I. Oparin was one of the fathers of Biology in the Soviet Union. Oparinism was considered almost up to our days as the sole paradigm to explain the origin of life on planet Earth. Today there are alternative paradigms. Enciclopedia Universal Ilustrada Europeo Americana, Suplemento Anual 1977-1978 (Espasa-Calpe, Madrid-Barcelona, 1968) 162. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
63
Teilhard de Chardin
necessary for the evolution of life from non-living organic matter until, according to Haldane “the primitive oceans acquired the consistency of a hot diluted broth”20. Haldane’s ideas appeared in 1929 in the Rationalist Annual, but there was no reaction. Haldane belonged to the circle of pro-Marxist British intellectuals and, at this time, Teilhard de Chardin was in China21. The question whether Teilhard knew of Haldane’ thought when he wrote the Human Phenomenon is answered by Pierre in a clarifying note, “These pages were written a long time ago, and I was surprised to discover the same substance in a few masterly lines, recently written by J. B. S. Haldane, “In what we call Matter we find no evident trace of thought or life,” stated the grand English Biochemist, “(…) If the modern perspectives of science are correct, we can expect to find these throughout all the universe at least in a rudimentary forma”22. Some years previously the Soviet biochemist Oparin had published a short paper in Russian (1924) with his hypothesis regarding the caldo de cultivo or primeval soup. The work was not published in English and French until 193623. The first Spanish edition of The Origin and Evolution of Life was translated from the French edition in 196724. Was there crossed information as regards the hypotheses of the three scientists, Teilhard, Haldane and Oparin? It is on record that Teilhard knew of the work of Haldane as we mentioned above. In an interview made to Oparin by the ABC newspaper at the Congress of the Federation of European Biochemical Societies in Madrid on April 1969, he stated that he did not know the work of Teilhard de Chardin. There is no record of Teilhard knowing the contributions of Oparin. Teilhard cites few authors in his philosophical and theological essays. However, we can say that the three researchers independently and almost simultaneously reached the same hypothesis that pre-life is a stage of life and, therefore, the appearance of the components of living organisms supposes a pre-biological chemical evolution. From the beginning of The Human Phenomenon, Teilhard de Chardin gave a clear explanation of what his methodology would be. Teilhard did not deviate from the purest phenomenological method; the philosopher, despite himself, accepted the correct phenomenological attitude involving only seeing25. “These pages represent an effort to see and make persons see what man is and demands if he is placed entirely and up to the end, within the area of appearances”26. However, for man to discover himself completely he needs a number of meanings and the history of the Spirit is the discovery of these meanings: the meaning of the immensity of space, the meaning of depth, the meaning of numbers, the meaning of proportion, the meaning of quality or innovation, 20
21
22 23 24
DIKERSON, R. E., La evolución química y el origen de la vida, Investigación y Ciencia, Sientific American (Noviembre, 1978) 75. “Chronology established by MARIE-LOUISE AUBOUX” in Pierre Teilhard de Chardin. Imágenes y Palabras, op. cit., pages 216-222. FH, 73-74. OPARIN, A. I., The Origin of Life (Dover, New York, 1936). OPARIN, A., El Origen y la evolución de la vida (Editorial Curie, Buenos Aires, 1968). See
also: ORÓ, J., Origen y evolución de la vida en Nuestros orígenes: el Universo, la Vida, el Hombre, Editor FERNÁNDEZ-RAÑADA, A. (Fundación Ramón Areces, Madrid, 1991) 169-199. 25
26
64
“The phenomenological method is a special procedure of knowledge. Essentially it consists of an intellectual vision based on an intuition. This intuition refers to what is given; the principal rule of phenomenology states, ‘towards things themselves, understanding ‘things’ to be ‘the given’. Above all, this requires a triple elimination or ‘reduction’, called epoché”. BOCHENSKI, I. M., Los métodos del pensamiento (14ª Edición, Ediciones Rialp, Madrid, 1981) 40. FAESSLER, M., Genèse et structure de la phenomenologie teilhardienne, Études Teilhardiennes, 4/5 (1971-1972) 19-89. FH, 43. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
Teilhard de Chardin
which can arrive without breaking the physical unity of the world, the meaning of movement capable of perceiving the irresistible developments concealed in the greatest slowness, the meaning of the organic which discloses the structural interrelationships and unity.27 This new sensitivity which Teilhard demands in order to be able to see all the phenomena has been the one which certain detractors of his work and methodology have failed to grasp. The cosmos, in the process of Cosmogenesis, is seen by Teilhard as a system, a totum and a quantum28. The concept of system involves interrelationships within a set which is closed within itself, with capacity for self- regulation and autonomy. The system constitutes a structurally terminated group, different from a star or a crystal, in which the set is accidentally delimited, where there is “no trace of a limited unit related to itself”29, a trical repetition of units, however varied and numerous are the axes of their layout. Thus, Teilhard de Chardin considers all the cosmos as a block, “looking around us as far as we can see, the universe is sustained by the fact that it is a set”30. This universe is a totality (totum) weaved as “a single piece, following a single, same procedure, but it is never repeated from end to end”31. For this totality to be constituted and maintained there must be a continual interaction between all the components. “This is because of the Totality, as it exists, must be expressed in a global capacity for action, whose resulting partial element we find in each one of us. Thus, we are led to seek and conceive a dynamic measurement of the world”32. This dynamic nature is what Teilhard calls the Quantum.“Quantum which does not fully acquire meaning until we try to define it in relation to a specific natural movement, that is to say, in Duration”33. Thus, for Teilhard de Chardin “each component of the Cosmos is positively interwoven with the rest thanks to the mysterious phenomenon of ‘composition’ (…) It is impossible to break up this network, impossible to isolate a single piece without if becoming frayed a and it comes apart at the ends”34. The frame of the universe is the universe itself. A farme which is much more than the simple superimposition of articulated relationships. For Teilhard, life, that thin film which constitutes the Biosphere35 of one of the planets of the solar system, (“so ridiculously located, in the space of an instant, on a sideral particle!”36) is a quality which is inherent to matter and not an epiphenomenon. “life is not a curious anomaly, flourishing sporadically on Matter, Life is a privileged
27 28 29 30 31 32 33
34 35
36
FH, 45-46. FH, 58. GZH, 24. FH, 58. FH, 59. FH, 60. FH, 61. Further on Teilhard explained what he understood by organic duration or time, “What constitutes and classifies a man as ‘modern’ is the fact that he has been able to be sensitive to perception of space, time and also of duration, in other words of biological space-time and, consequently, it also involves being incapable of perceiving anything different in any way, nothing, beginning with himself”. FH, 266. FH, 58. GZH, 46. The Biosphere is defined by C. Cuénot as, ”the area of non-reflective life which is located between the spheres of the inorganic (lithosphere, hydrosphere …) and the psychic sphere (noosphere). This zone is the seat of perfectly determined physical properties and which constitute a common power for organic development (not to be confused with the sense of Suess and Vernadsky, which designates a purely local area, with no combined structure and no specific properties” CUÉNOT, C., Nuevo léxico de Teilhard de Chardin, p. 68. GZH, 22. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
65
Teilhard de Chardin
exaggeration of a universal cosmic property; Life is not an epiphenomenon but the very essence of the phenomenon”37. Life the material effect of complexity For Teilhard de Chardin life “for scientific experience, is none other than a specific effect (the specific effect of Matter which has become complex: a coextensive property in itself of the entire cosmic Matter, but only apprehensible by our vision wherever (…) the complexity surpasses a certain critical value”38. Life for Teilhard is not an inexplicable anomaly, it is the rationally expected creation of cosmic involution or rolling up. Many scientists contemporaries of or subsequent to Teilhard de Chardin, believers and agnostics, have chosen to conceive life in cosmic terms as a grand exception39. Perhaps one of the most severe critics of Teilhard was his compatriot Jacques Monod, a Molecular Biologist and Nobel Prize-winner in his work Chance and Necessity. For Monod the principle of objectivity, that is to say, not being able to conceive anything in nature in terms of a project, forces him to state that, ”man finally knows that he is alone in the indifferent immensity of the Universe where he has emerged by chance. Neither his destiny nor his duty are written anywhere. He must choose between the Kingdom and darkness”40. In his book Monod accuses tacha Teilhard de Chardin as an animist and states that, “the biological philosophy of Teilhard de Chardin would not deserve a passing look if it were not for the success he has had among thousands of scientists”41. Monod’s position is also counter to that of the winner of the Nobel Prize for Medicine Christian de Duve for whom the essential components for the formation of the first living beings on the Earth could have come from space and he postulated the existence of planetary systems similar to that of the earth where life could have emerged42. In the Anglo-Saxon environment we also find strong reactions to Teilhard’s thought on life. At the time, the disproportionate, unjust and harsh recensión to the English edition of The Human Phenomenon of the English Nobel Prize-winner Peter Medawar was much commented on43. The criticism of Medawar contrasts with the position regarding the work of Teilhard of the grand geneticist Theodosius Dobzhansky, an enthusiastic reader of Teilhard’s works as can be seen in his correspondence with John Greene. For Dobzhansky, Teilhard de Chardin did not want to construct his cosmo37 38 39
40
41
Ibidem GZH, 27-28. In this respect, the quotation of JEANS, J. is interesting, “What can life be reduced to? An evident accidental decadence in a world which, in no case, was made for it. (…) The universe is indifferent (even hostile) to any type of life”. Quoted by KENNEY, W. H. El Fenómeno humano de Teilhard de Chardin. Guía para el lector (Sal Térrea, Santander, 1973) 77. MONOD, J., Le hasard et la nécessité. Essai sur la philosophie naturelle de la biologie moderne (Éditions du Seuil, Paris, 1970) 225. MONOD, J., op. cit. 49.
42
DE DUVE, C., Construire une cellule: essai sur la nature et l'origine de la vie (Inter-Editions, De BoeckWesmael, Paris-Bruxelles, 1990)
43
“I will show that most of the book has no meaning. It is adorned with a variety of metaphysical concepts and the author’s dishonesty can be excused by the fact that by deceiving others he has undergone great suffering on deceiving himself”. Medawar himself in an autobiographical conversation on his life in science, confessed that he was indignant with poor Teilhard de Chardin. MEDAWAR, P., La amenaza y la gloria. Reflexiones sobre la ciencia y los científicos, Compilation by PYKE, D. (Gedisa Editorial, Barcelona, 1993) 26. The complete recensión of Medawar can be found at: http://cscs.umich.edu/~crshalizi/Medawar/phenomenon-of-man.html
66
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
Teilhard de Chardin
vision based solely on science. Dobzhansky stated that the work of Teilhard is science, metaphysics and theology, and, although Medawar does not mention this, poetry44. We mentioned above that for Teilhard life is born from complexity, “I will constantly repeat throughout these pages that Life is offered experimentally to science as a material effect of complexity”45 and elsewhere he points out that, “a more complete observation of the movements of the world would oblige us (…) to discover that if things are sustained this is only due to the force of complexity”46. We can ask ourselves what Teilhard understands by complexity or, as he mentions on other occasions “axis of complexities”? In the first place, complexity is not a simple aggregation of ordered components, nor is it the simple geometrical undefined repetition of units, as is a crystal for example. For Teilhard the world is not specially constructed on two infinites (remembering the infinites of Pascal: the infinitely big and the infinitely small), but on three infinites. To the minute and the immense should be added the immensely complicated47. “Biology is only the Physics of the biggest complex”48. Teilhard de Chardin stated that complexity is the result of the combination or “as I understand it here, the complexity of an organised heterogeneity and, therefore, centred”49. Heterogeneity is one of the fundamental characteristics of the cosmos: “woven in a single piece and following the same single procedure, but which is never repeated from one point to another, the Frame of the Universe corresponds to a single model: it structurally constitutes a whole”50. Unity-diversity is one of the antinomies of life51, as apparently unity and diversity can be predicated of life. Life in its origin (monophylism) is one because all living organisms have the same biochemical components: the four bases of the nucleic acids, the twenty same protein genetic amino acids and the same genetic code, as well as the metabolic chains which are essentially the same. However, life is also marvellously different in all its manifestations of the great variety of living beings, which at times is so surprising. Teilhard proposes a grand solution to this antinomy: life constitutes a single Biota52: “Testing profusion, constructive ingeniousness, indifference as regards all that is not future and totality. Life, due to its elementary mechanisms rises thanks to these three vectors and thanks also to a fourth which covers all: global unity, (…) since “considered as a totality living substance extended over the Earth and, from the first studies of evolution, drew the lines of a single gigantic organism”53. This unique gigantic organism, which Teilhard’s 44
45 46 47 48 49 50 51
52
53
NÚÑEZ DE CASTRO, I., Evolución y sentido en la correspondencia de Theodosius Dobzhansky, en La Nueva Alianza de las Ciencias y la Filosofía, BLANCH, A. Ed., (Universidad Pontificia Comillas, Madrid, 2001) 109-114. The correspondence was published by GREENE, J., and RUSE, M., On the Nature of the Evolutionary Process: The Correspondence between Theodosius Dobzhansky and John C. Greene, Biology and Philosophy, 11 (1996) 445-491. GZH, 23. FH, 57 GZH, 27 GZH, 28. CUÉNOT, C., Nuevo léxico de Teilhard de Chardin, p. 77. FH, 59. NÚÑEZ DE CASTRO, I., Categorías del discurso biológico en Evolucionismo y cultura, DOU, A., Ed., (Mensajero, Bilbao, 1983) 17-55. Biota: defined by Teilhard himself, “I understand this to be a vertical grouping whose components are related by birth and are sustained and completed mutually in their efforts to subsist and propagate”. FH, 151. FH, 137. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
67
Teilhard de Chardin
disciple Crusafont Pairó has called the phyletic continuum54, materialises in time in the innumerable manifestations of the vegetable and animal kingdoms. The cell: the unit of life Teilhard de Chardin stated that there is only one structural model, a model which is never repeated in its external materialisation due to diversity. What is this model at physical and structural levels? The model at physical level is the cell55. Life properly speaking began when the first cell began to exist. “For a century, the more Science concentrates its efforts on this chemically and structurally complex unit, the more evident it becomes that behind it is concealed the secret a knowledge of which would establish the link of union, sensed, but still not verified, between the two worlds of Physics and Biology. The cell, the natural grain of life, just as the atom is the natural grain of unorganised Matter”56. Teilhard accused the cytologists and histologists of having frozen the cell for study57. “We have worked very much on its differences, that is to say, everything which makes up Descriptive Biology: Microbiology, Zoology, Botany, it is advisable that our research converge towards the origins, that is to say, to the roots set in the unorganised, if we want to point out the true essence of its innovation. (…) Let us try to see what it becomes if we observe it and treat it as we must, as something prepared a long time ago and profusely, that is to say, as something born”58. For Teilhard the cell is where the frame of the universe appears with all its features: system, totum and quantum. Undoubtedly, the cell supposes an ulterior step of complexity and, consequently, a superior grain of interiority, that is to say, consciousness59. Teilhard himself formulated this procedure which at structural level is never repeated and is the law of complexity-consciousness of Teilhard60. This law was formulated by Teilhard de Chardin as a phenomenological guide for the better understanding of the vital phenomenon. The term consciousness is used by Teilhard 54
55
56 57
58 59
60
68
“However, above this defense of the independence of systems, there is such proteicity of these in the phyletic continuum that the machine becomes blurred in its individualisation to become a complex in continual transformation” CRUSAFONT PAIRÓ, M., El fenómeno vital (Editorial Labor, Barcelona, 1972) 81-82. The cellular theory proposed by T. Schwann in his treatise in 1839 on microscopic research into the coincidence in the structure of animals and plants continues to be valid and has been confirmed in all living organisms. See: RADL, E. M., Historia de las ideas biológicas. Desde Lamarck y Cuvier, Tomo 2, (Alianza Editorial, Madrid, 1988) 66-70. Consult: ALBARRACÍN TEULÓN, A., La teoría celular. Historia de un paradigma (Alianza Editorial, Madrid, 1983). FH, 99. Modern Cellular Biology fused with Molecular Biology and Bio-Computing, disciplines which Teilhard did not know of, would have kindled his innate enthusiasm. FH, 101. It should be pointed out that for Teilhard de Chardin the frame of the universe is a dual frame: “the specific being in which the cosmos is constituted and which is not confused with matter as an ‘interior’ (consciousness) represents the same as an ‘exterior’ (matter). The spirit-matter is what constitutes the evolutionary frame of the universe, whose unity is not broken up by molecularisation or thresholds”. CUÉNOT, C., Nuevo léxico de Teilhard de Chardin, p. 288. this is the formulation of the law of complexity-consciousness, which is universal for Teilhard. In other words, “coextensive with its exterior there is an interior to things”. FH, 73. “In the following I must constantly refer (…) to the cosmic axis of physical ordering and psychic interiorisation, manifested by this deep derivation or orthogenisis (…). I will call this the complexityconsciousness axis”. CUÉNOT, C., Nuevo léxico de Teilhard de Chardin, p. 78. Below we will refer to Teilhard’s concept of “deep orthogenisis”. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
Teilhard de Chardin
without taking its etymology into account and designates any form of psychism from the most elementary to the most elevated form, reflective consciousness. “Consciousness, that is to say, what is inside and can be experimentally obtained or (by infinitesimal) is unobtainable from pre-living and living corpuscles”61. For Teilhard de Chardin it is possible to measure the degree of psychism or consciousness. Every being in the universe has its centre of convergence. Thus, “Life is apparently none other than the privileged exaggeration of a fundamental cosmic derivation (…) which can be called ‘law of complexity-consciousness’ and can be expressed as follows: abandoned to itself for a long period of time, under the prolonged universal game of probabilities, Matter shows that it has the property of entering into groups which are progressively more complex and, at the same time, consciousness increases so that this dual combined movement of psychic roll up and psychic interiorisation (or focusing) continues, accelerates and is thrust forward as far as possible once initiated”62. It is “in the cell, which has such oneness, uniformity and complicatedness, where the Frame of the Universe appears with its features, although the cell is now in an ulterior step of complexity and, consequently, simultaneously (if the hypothesis that guides us throughout these pages is true) to a higher level of interiority, that is to say, consciousness”63. We should remember that the features of the Frame of the Universe are system, totum and quantum. The appearance of the first cell supposes a decisive step in the process of consciousness on the Earth64. For Teilhard de Chardin the appearance of life in cellular form did not suppose an absolute commencement, but rather, as he put it a metamorphosis. How did this come about? For Teilhard the answer is once again in the external structural organisation of the cellular components and in the internal appearance of a new type of activity65. Asked whether life appeared once or in points throughout the planet at the same time, Teilhard replied that we do not know but “this matters little” since “taking as a whole, the Biosphere would only represent a simple branch within and above other less progressive or less fortunate proliferations of pre-life”66. The process of evolution: orthogenesis Teilhard de Chardin believed that, in the process of evolution of life, there are two critical points: la biogenesis (the origin of life properly speaking, the point of vitalisation or, as he liked to say, phyletisation67) and anthropogenesis, or point of hominization or the appearance of reflection68. Between these two critical points lies all the evolutionary process. The process which Teilhard believed could be explained by “a 61
GZH, 37. CUÉNOT, C., Nuevo léxico de Teilhard de Chardin, p. 165. 63 FH, 109 64 Ibidem 65 “The external realisation of an essentially new corpuscular grouping which enables a more flexible and better focused organisation of an unlimited number of substances considered as particular in all the levels of magnitudes; and, simultaneously, the internal appearance of a new type of activity and conscious determination; through this dual and radical metamorphosis, as regards what is specifically original, we can now reasonably define the critical transition of the molecule to the cell, the step of Life”. FH, 111-112. 66 FH, 118. 67 Filetización in the lexicon of Teilhard means the process for the formation of the phylum. “The phylum is a “living ray. The line of lines. (…) Above all the phylum is a collective reality. (…) The phylum is also somewhat polymorphic and elastic”. FH, 140. 68 GZH, 29. 62
God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
69
Teilhard de Chardin
constant perennial current of interiorising complexification”69. “Independently of all scientific interpretations (and even less finalist) for us, the Universe is as if it were ‘weighed down’ with Complexity, it falls on progressively more perfected forms of disposition”70. In a clarification note, Teilhard de Chardin, who was not prone to provide notes and citations, wrote in his original and peculiar style, full of metaphors, that, “There is perhaps a secret relationship between the Newtonian gravity of condensation (which engendered the stars) and the ‘gravity of complexification’ (which engendered Life)” and he adds “in any case, both only function jointly”71, , and he repeats the idea of the commensurability of the evolution of matter and the appearance of life (Cosmogenesis = Biogenesis). For Teilhard complexity was the engine of evolution, and this was in a way similar to the élan vital of Bergson72. “Complexity cannot be developed in the interior of each corpuscle without correlatively entailing in rapid succession an interlinking of relationships, a delicate perpetually mobile balance between neighbouring corpuscles”73. We should note here that the current theory of the appearance of eukaryotic organisms (unicellular or multi-cellular organisms whose cells have a well defined nucleus), in a way, confirms the hypothesis of Teilhard that a symbiosis of prokaryotic organisms (unicellular with no defined nucleus) is the origin of eukaryotic organisms. This is the hypothesis put forward by Teilhard de Chardin in 1950: “however granular and discontinuous the layer of vitalised Matter might have appeared in its beginnings, since this elementary phase, a network of deep affinities and attraction (destined to progressively affirm themselves) united and tended to progressively bring this innumerable multitude of particles with their load of germinal power closer, in a broad symbiosis”74. The Biologist Lynn Margulis recently stressed the explanation of the appearance of eukaryotic organisms through a symbiosis among prokaryotes. The biological transition between bacteria and cells with nuclei is one of the more critical steps in all the history of evolution and it is so sudden that it cannot be explained by gradual changes through time. “The division between bacteria and the new cells is really the most spectacular in all of biology. Vegetables, animals, fungi and protists are based on the nuclear design of the cell, a distinction which reflects the common inheritance of these organisms”75. Lynn Margulis describes these new cells thus, “they appear to have been bacterial confederations. They cooperated with each other and centralised the functions forming a new type of cellular government. The newcomers had a progressively more centralised organisation and their cellular organelles became joined in a new biological unit”76.
69 70 71 72
73 74 75
76
70
GZH, 36. Ibidem GZH, 37. According to H. BERGSON, “evolutionism is not explained by mechanical factors as the Darwinians or Neo-Darwinians pretend. It is necessary to resort to a cause in the psychological order, as proposed by Neo-Lamarckians. It starts with an original impulse (the original élan of life)”. Entry of the élan vital in FERRATER MORA, J., Diccionario de Filosofía (Editorial Ariel, Barcelona, 1994) 984. For a study on Bergson and finality, consult GILSON, E., De Aristóteles a Darwin (y vuelta) EUNSA, Pamplona, 1976) 207-236. GZH, 46. GZH, 47. MARGULIS L. and SAGAN D., Microcosmos. Cuatro mil años de evolución desde nuestros ancestros microbianos (2ª Edición, Tusquets Editores, Barcelona, 2001) 131-132. Ibidem, 133. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
Teilhard de Chardin
This symbiosis of the units of life, firstly among bacteria and then among differentiated cells, seen synchronically (taxonomic classification) or diachronically (history of the appearance in the past, the point which most interested Teilhard de Chardin, as palaeontologist), will explain the Tree of Life. It is curious to observe how Teilhard was not concerned about the explanation of the mechanisms which can explain the evolutionary fact. Interested in seeing the phenomenon of life and al the phenomenon, the fundamental preoccupation of Teilhard was to see in the evolutionary process “whether, behind its apparent disorder, there is a concealed a principal axis of growth and management, as well as a general polarisation towards progressively more complexity and consciousness”77, the fundamental law of the thought of Teilhard. Further on, he asks. “Does the Tree of Life, even when it is studied before the appearance of Man, enable us to see a true ‘guide’ in its destiny, or is it only divided towards its summit in a branching of rival forms?”78 In the extensive work of Teilhard de Chardin we will find the answer in orthogenesis79. The term orthogenesis was proposed by Gustav Heinrich T. Eimer in 1888 in order to designate the evolution which takes place in a determined sense80. Claude Cuénot distinguishes two senses of the term orthogenesis in the work of Teilhard de Chardin. Firstly, in the biological sense, “Series of small anatomical and psychic mutations oriented in the same direction and which are added to, thus constituting a phenomenon of continual growth in the same direction”. Secondly, in the phenomenological sense, “fundamental derivation, following which the Frame of the Universe behaves before our eyes as being displaced towards progressively more complex corpuscular states as regards their material ordering and, psychically, more and more interiorised; a derivation which is manifested in the superior human beings through cephalisation, and in man through the appearance of reflection”81. Teilhard de Chardin accepted the term and used it throughout his writings, although, according to him, “the word is excellent and must be conserved, however, it has been misused, like evolution and socialism”82. In the Human Phenomenon he defends the use of the term, “without orthogenesis there would only be extensibility: with orthogenesis there is an invincible ascension of Life”83. In the same context “on the contrary, my firmest conviction is that the word be essential and irreplaceable as regards marking and affirming the manifest property which living Matter possesses”84. Property, in the terms of Teilhard is only the constant growth of centre-complexity. This ascent of centrecomplexity which is anatomically manifested in cerebration was called deep 77 78 79
80
81 82
83 84
GZH, 47. The underlining is ours. GZH, 52. “Starting from Life, on the contrary, (and perhaps due to the astounding ascending complexity of the buildings to be assembled), the construction efforts are divided and extended both in space and time. On the one hand, thanks to the surprising ‘trick’ of reproduction, the corpuscle is transformed into population, multiplying the effects of attempts and opportunities. On the other hand, this is simultaneously stretched in chains, in accordance with which the possible growth can be tested, brought and assimilated, one by one, with a continually renewed flexibility. The complexification, which was individual in pre-life became linear; this simple change started up all the branching complications of the genesis of the species”.TEILHARD DE CHARDIN, P., La aparición del Hombre (Taurus, Madrid, 1958) 301. From now on this will be cited as AH. BERGSON, H., Memoria y Vida. Textos escogidos por Pilles Deleuze (Alianza Editorial, Madrid, 1977) 97. CUÉNOT, C., Nuevo léxico de Teilhard de Chardin, p. 205. TEILHARD DE CHARDIN, Letter of March 16, 1952, cited by CUÉNOT, C., Nuevo léxico de Teilhard de Chardin, p. 206. FH, 133. Ibidem God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
71
Teilhard de Chardin
orthogenesis by Teilhard de Chardin85, and this forces any Matter toward the most complicated and the most complex86. Teilhard is aware that the term orthogenesis has been much discussed by biologists. The correspondence between T. Dobzhansky and J. Greene cited above is an example of this. Teilhard distinguished between passive orthogenesis or ortho-selection and active orthogenesis or ortho-election. Once the evolution of man arrives, “from man and in man, simple evolution gradually tends to become self-evolution”87. In the thought of Teilhard, therefore, pure chance has no meaning. Chance, the fortuitous encounter of elementary determinisms which imitates the act intended. The solution for Teilhard lay in the testing. “The fundamental technique of Testing, the specific invincible weapon of all multitudes in expansion”88. Testing in which the law of large numbers and the finality towards an intended goal are combined; this is what Teilhard de Chardin originally called directed Chance, “fill all in order to test all. Test all in order to fill it all”.89 Regarding the diversity of living beings We saw above that, according to Teilhard de Chardin, the symbiosis between the elementary grains of life would explain the exuberant branching of the Tree of Life as can be appreciated in a synchronic cross section at the present time, or as Palaeontology shows us through the fossil registry which has come down to us. According to Teilhard: “it is impossible to order this enormous complex phenomenon without first analysing the procedures imagined by Life in order to make progress in each of its components considered in isolation”90. Once more Teilhard personified life and did so subject to the invention of the elementary movements which lead to the explosion of forms of living organisms, which are sometimes fascinating. Teilhard was aware of this hypostatization and exclaimed, “Life, more real than lives”91. The elementary movements or procedures used by life to achieve this immense variety would be, according to Teilhard: a) Reproduction b) Multiplication c) Renovation d) Conjugation e) Association f) Directed additivity. 85
86
87
88 89 90 91
72
CUÉNOT: it is defined as “derives from complexity-consciousness which is manifested at the level of life by systems which are progressively more complex, towards a maximum cerebration” Nuevo léxico de Teilhard de Chardin, p. 207. “We insisted before on the general orthogenesis of corpusculisation, on the ‘deep orthogenesis’ which we said led all Matter towards the more complicated and more conscious. In the case of living substances, a second derivation (a sub-derivation) which is already outlined: the orthogenesis of the species, oriented in accordance with a number of incredible diverse directions, towards the most highly differentiated, under all its forms”. AH, 304. TEILHARD DE CHARDIN, P., Nota sobre la realidad actual y el significado evolutivo de una ortogénesis humana en La visión del pasado (Taurus, Madrid, 1958) 327-336. From now on this will be cited as VP. FH, 135. Ibidem. FH, 127. FH, 136. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
Teilhard de Chardin
a) Reproduction is the procedure for ensuring the permanence of the unstable in the case of the vast molecular buildings which living beings are composed of. “In itself, cellular division seems to be provoked by the simple need the living particle has to find a remedy to its molecular fragility and to the difficulties related too the continuity of its growths”92. When reproduction becomes sexual, a new source of heterogeneity appears: “what at the beginning is only chance, or a means of survival, is immediately transformed and used as an instrument of progress and re-conquest”93. b) Undefined self-duplication of the living particles (of the DNA and RNA nucleic acids, in today’s language) Teilhard de Chardin stated that it seemed to know no other limits “than the amount of Matter offered for its functioning” (…) Life has a force for expansion as invincible as that of a body which is dilated or evaporated”94. Nothing can detain this expansive force. There is nothing big enough to extinguish this constructive and devouring fire. The acceptance of this multiplying power led the English biologist Richard Dawkins to state that life has no other meaning than that the chains of DNA continually and impulsively duplicate themselves. Organisms are only the machines of this gene factory. The very title of his well known work The Selfish Gene, a title which was well chosen by Dawkins for his purpose, is the negation of any type of finality in the happenings of life. “Its preservation, the preservation of the gene, is the ultimate reason for its existence”95. It is interesting to note how the same biological fact, multiplication, can lead to such opposing ultimate conclusions as those of Teilhard de Chardin and Dawkins, which tells us that the final part of the reasoning, starting from the same data, depends, to a large extent, on previous presuppositions which are sometimes fundamental options for positioning as regards human existence. c) In the opinion of Teilhard renovation leads to ‘pluralisation’ bot as regards form and number. Genetic mutation is the mechanism whereby this ‘irisación’ is produced in an undefined range of tonalities. We must bear in mind that, at the end of the thirties in the XX century, Teilhard de Chardin could only speak of his accurate intuitions. Teilhard died two years after J. Watson and F. Crick96 published the structure of the double helix of DNA. The biological discoveries which followed on at a vertiginous rate from the fifties to the seventies, occurred after the death of Teilhard de Chardin, and these included: the confirmation of the semi-conservative duplication of DNA by Meselson and Stahl (1958), the isolation of the polinucleótido fosforilasa (S. Ochoa, 1955), the deciphering of the genetic code (Ochoa, Nirenberg and Khorana, 1961-1965), the hypothesis of
92 93 94 95 96
FH, 128. Ibidem FH, 129. DAWKINS, R., El gen egoísta (Editorial Labor, Barcelona, 1979) 42. GIRALDO, R., 50 años del descubrimiento de la doble hélice del DNA, Razón y Fe, 248 (2003) 185195. Three articles in the journal Nature can be said to be the starting point of the new revolution: WATSON, J. D. and CRICK, F. H. C., A structure for deoxyribonucleic acid, Nature 171, (1953) 737-738; WILKINS, M. H. F. et al., Molecular structure of deoxypentose nucleic acids, Nature 171 (1953) 738-740; y FRANKLIN, R. E. and GOSLING, R. G. Molecular configuration in sodium thymonucleate, Nature 171 (1953) 740-741. Facsimile copies of the three articles can be found in Nature 421 (2003) 397-401. God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
73
Teilhard de Chardin
the messenger RNA (Jacob and Monod, 1961) and the mechanisms for the synthesis of proteins97, etc., obviously could not be known by Teilhard. d) Teilhard de Chardin also sensed the significance that sexual reproduction (conjugation) had for the variability of living beings and consequently for evolution as an exchange of information. “Instead of irradiating from each centre in the process of division, since then, the radios of Life began to anastomosate exchanging and varying their respective riches”98. e) We referred above to the intuition Teilhard had concerning the role of symbiosis (one of the many forms of association): from the colony soldered in bacteria, passing through the cell of cells (eukaryotic cell), the associations of hypercomplex units, up to the human societies. “We restrict ourselves here to pointing out that Association, considered in all its levels, is not, among the animate beings, a sporadic or accidental phenomenon. On the contrary, it represents one of the most universal most constant mechanisms and, therefore, one of the most significant used by Life for its expansion”99. f) Finally, according to Teilhard de Chardin, Life has achieved the grand recourse involved in being able to ascend to progressively more complex levels through the factor of additivity. “In a more general and deeper manner, the enabling renovations by each reproduction do more than just replace; they unite their additions to each other which is growing in a determined sense. Dispositions which are increased or organs which are adjusted or superimposed. Diversification here, growing specialisation there of the terms which constitute the same genealogical line”100. The new rationality sensed by Teilhard de Chardin We pointed out above that the force of his discourse made Teilhard de Chardin to hypostatise life, which has led some critics to accuse him of being panpsychist or animist. Teilhard conferred subjectivity and, we could say, almost personality on a quality which is life as we appreciate life in living organisms, which are those which really exist. Thus, Teilhard de Chardin speaks of profusion, ingeniousness and indifference attributed to life, to finish up stating “Life more real than lives”101. This phrase understood in its rawness and taken out of context, in a purely biologicist reading, could be the basis for a social totalitarianism which is as far as possible alien to the thought of Teilhard. It should also be noted that, in order to understand the thought of Teilhard de Chardin, we must overcome the barrier of his language102. What Teilhard de Chardin 97
98 99 100 101 102
74
NÚÑEZ DE CASTRO, I., El Proyecto Genoma humano. Discurso bioquímico y discurso antropológico en La Fe interpelada. Jornadas de estudio y diálogo entre Profesores Universitarios (Universidad Pontifica Comillas, Universidad Pontificia de Salamanca, Colegio Español San José de Roma, Departamento de Publicaciones, Universidad Pontificia Comillas, Madrid, 1993) 29-48. FH, 131. FH, 132. FH, 133. FH, 134-137. Despite the fact that Teilhard knew when he had to use a purely scientific discourse, when he used poetry in his endeavour ‘to see the interior’ of things, he sometimes used a language which disconcerted some. In this respect, Henri de Lubac stated, “Father Teilhard has taken care not to confuse the literary genres and the disciplines of knowledge, however, like all the spirits who have something new to say, he had his own way to distinguish and unite these. Particularly in the Human Phenomenon, as he was perfectly aware of the mirages which the reader of these types of writings God Seen by Science: Anthropic Evolution of the Uuniverse
Teilhard de Chardin
means is that his fundamental intuition that we must understand the cosmos as a system, as a totum, as unit, which is always becoming. It is not easy to arrive at the basis of the thought of Teilhard starting from what Henryk Skolimowsky called “positivist rationality”103, nor from scholastic rationality104, which explains why he often did not satisfy scientists (we nave remarked on the harsh criticisms made by Medawar and Monod) and some philosophers and theologians. It is curious to note that Teilhard himself was aware of this change of