GLOBAL PLANT GENETIC RESOURCES FOR INSECT-RESISTANT CROPS
Edited by
Stephen L. Clement and Sharron S. Quisenberry
C...
219 downloads
895 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
GLOBAL PLANT GENETIC RESOURCES FOR INSECT-RESISTANT CROPS
Edited by
Stephen L. Clement and Sharron S. Quisenberry
CRC Press Boca Raton New York
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Acquiring Editor: Developmental Editor: Project Editor: Marketing Manager: Direct Marketing Manager: Page design: Cover design: PrePress: Manufacturing:
Norm Stanton (Optional) Susan Fox Susie Carlisle Becky McEldowney (Optional, only if new interior design) Denise Craig Kevin Luong Sheri Schwartz
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data McLachlan, Alan Molecular biology of the hepatitis B virus / Alan McLachlan p. cm.
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN 0-8493-2695-8
1. Hepatitis B virus. 2. Biology—molecular. I. McLachlan, Alan. II. Title. [DNLM: 1. Hepatitis B virus. QW 710 G289h]
QR749.H64G78 1999
616′.0149—dc20
DNLM/DLC
for Library of Congress
9?-????? CIP This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. A wide variety of references are listed. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and the publisher cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials or for the consequences of their use. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without prior permission in writing from the publisher. All rights reserved. Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use, or the personal or internal use of specific clients, may be granted by CRC Press LLC, provided that $.50 per page photocopied is paid directly to Copyright Clearance Center, 27 Congress Street, Salem, MA 01970 USA. The fee code for users of the Transactional Reporting Service is ISBN 0-8493-2695-8/99/$0.00+$.50. The fee is subject to change without notice. For organizations that have been granted a photocopy license by the CCC, a separate system of payment has been arranged. The consent of CRC Press LLC does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained in writing from CRC Press LLC for such copying. Direct all inquiries to CRC Press LLC, 2000 Corporate Blvd., N.W., Boca Raton, Florida 33431. © 1999 by CRC Press LLC No claim to original U.S. Government works International Standard Book Number 0-8493-2695-8 Library of Congress Card Number 9?-????? Printed in the United States of America 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 Printed on acid-free paper
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Foreword
Masa Iwanaga In spite of the successes of the “Green Revolution”, food security is assuming an importance of ever-increasing dimensions. Most projections estimate a growth in world population over the next quarter century to 8.5 billion, signifying an additional 3 billion people to feed. At the same time, an overall decline is being registered in the per capita surface area available for food production. It is imperative to find sustainable, cost-effective means of augmenting food supplies, primarily through reliable improvement of crop yields, to meet the inevi table increased demand for resources. At present, despite all of this century’s improvements in production technology, 800 million people are estimated to be undernourished. The majority of these people reside in developing countries, where almost four-fifths of the world’s population live and where, by the year 2025, it is thought that 97% of the global population will compete for food supplies, with social, environmental, economic, and political repercussions worldwide. Therefore, it is essential that the problem of food security be recognized as a challenge facing all of humanity, and that concerted global efforts in agricultural research be intensified. Both national governments and international bodies must collaborate in increasing productivity on all available agricultural land while employ ing environmental safeguards to protect natural resources (i.e., soil, water, plant genetic resources) for the future. Of these natural resources, genetic resources offer us the greatest benefits in terms of return on scientific, technological, and economic inputs and, therefore, require the most focused attention of researchers. The safe conservation and sustainable use of plant genetic resources are the keys to ensuring food security and, by extension, poverty alleviation and the promotion of peaceful development. The prevention of genetic erosion of these resources and, even more importantly, the conservation of genetic diversity in the world’s plant crops, are essential to future food security. Food production can be increased by the extension of arable land. Advances in this direction, however, appear to have reached the limits of our present scientific and technological capabilities. Further expansion of agricultural areas can only be made at unacceptable environmental costs. A second means of increasing food production would be to intensify cultivation and increase yields from lands which are presently agriculturally viable. This was the objective of agricultural policies and research programs in the last few decades, when the development and spread of high-yielding cultivars of major crops resulted in large increases in production. These gains, however, came only at the expense of reduced sustainability. Improved or high-yielding cultivars alleviated some problems but it soon became apparent that they also introduced constraints that created new
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
problems. The evolution of plants and insects are closely intertwined, with local adaptation of landraces incorporating, through a lengthy selection process, a natural resistance to impediments to their growth in the local environment. This balance between pest organisms and host plants was disturbed by the spread of monoculture of improved cultivars and the resulting reliance on a series of chemical pesticides. Monoculture of single high-yielding cultivars made crops more vulnerable, in the long run, to the resilience of endemic pests and diseases, which adapted to the expanded and homogenized host environment. This led to the increasing dependence of farmers on the use of chemical means to counter these sources of crop losses. But, over time, pest organisms — with their short reproductive cycles — are able to evolve resistance to pesticides. This leads to an increase in pest infestations, increased use of pesticides in an escalating “treadmill” of action and reaction, and higher production costs and damage to the environment and human health. The problem is often compounded by pesticides inadvertently killing the natural enemies of the target pests. Reduction of food supplies through damage by pathogens, animal pests, and weeds — apart from abiotic factors such as weather fluctuations — is serious, accounting by some estimates to anywhere from 30 to 70% of total production losses, depending on the crop and region. In value terms, total crop losses may approach $490 billion (U.S.). Insects are the major culprits, especially in developing countries where tropical conditions often foster large populations and where, unfortunately, crop losses are most damaging and difficult to compensate. In relative terms, insects are responsible for greater crop damage worldwide than disease pathogens or weeds. Insect pests have been estimated to cause $90.5 billion in damages to eight principal food and cash crops (rice, wheat, barley, maize, potato, soybean, cotton, and coffee) versus $76.9 billion in damage by disease pathogens and $76.3 billion by weeds.1 Apart from direct damage to plants by insects through consumption of plant parts, insects also serve as vectors for viruses which cause a number of plant diseases. Damage occurs not only in the field, but also under post-harvest storage conditions and during use. In addition to expansion of agricultural production areas and intensification of production, a third means of increasing food production tackles the problem of reducing these crop losses. It involves the protection of food yields through means which break or circumvent the “pesticide treadmill” pattern and which seek to restore a sustainable balance. This is accomplished by integrated pest management (IPM), which aims to protect crop yields by containing losses from pest attacks and at the same time lowering economic and environmental risks. It has been suggested that by adopting IPM approaches, global crop yields could be doubled. Approaches include: • introducing the natural enemies (parasites, predators, and diseases) of the pest species; • improved monitoring and predictions of pest populations and movements; • judicious and reduced use of pesticides; • intercropping to avoid monoculture;
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
• introduction of pest-resistant cultivars; • insect control through the employment of pheromones, repellents, intro duction of sterility, etc.; and • culturally acceptable, cost-effective, and non-toxic methods for protecting stores of harvested crops from damage. Host plant resistance is a basic component of IPM. Plant breeding for pest resistance has been estimated to be responsible for a full third of recent yield increases. Resistant cultivars can be developed through breeding programs and resistance qualities can be conferred in vitro on plants that are subject to damage by insects either in the field or in post-harvest storage. This is the key area where plant genetic resources researchers are equipped to provide a foundation for food security. The number of genebanks housing accessions of plant genetic resources germ plasm has increased in the last 20 years from 10 to the more than 1,300 collections that are registered in FAO’s WIEWS (World Information and Early Warning System) database. Approximately 6.1 million accessions are stored worldwide in ex situ germplasm collections, including 527,000 in field genebanks. Data are not available on how many accessions maintained by genebanks have been used in breeding programs or have contributed to improved cultivars. However, there is a consensus that the conserved germplasm has not been fully used and that there is a need in most countries to ensure better use of plant genetic resources (including underutilized species) through plant breeding for more pest-resistant cultivars. Highly promising areas in which genetic resources research is successfully focusing, such as molecular techniques for identifying genes which determine desirable characteristics and in vitro methods for rapid propagation and selection, merit increased emphasis in future IPM programs. In addition, the deployment of productive diversity in crop plants is a cornerstone of the holistic IPM approach, requiring interactive expertise in several fields to bring about increased plant resistance. Agrobiodiversity contributes to reduced crop losses through: • bolstering intraspecific diversity to put in place a broader range of traits to which insect pests must adapt, thus making more difficult the cyclical interplay between effect and response in continuing pest-host adjustments; • introduction and maintenance of interspecific diversity to effect a complex ecosystem where competition between species will reduce rapid develop ment of simple single-plant host/single-insect pest relationships through a portfolio of crop species subject to a range of pests; • intercropping to provide barriers to movement and spread of pests; and • use of “time” controls, i.e., different cultivars of a crop can be planted in alternating years to slow down the process of pest adaptation, and plant breeding can result in crop cultivars with traits that allow them to be planted or harvested earlier or later to break synchronization with the pest’s reproductive cycle.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Numerous obstacles limit the effective use of plant genetic resources. They include lack of characterization and evaluation data, lack of documentation and information, poor coordination of policies at the national level, poor linkages between the genebank and the users of the germplasm, and lack of plant breeding programs. This situation is improving, however, and exciting successful examples of effec tive use of genetic diversity for the development of insect-resistant crops abound. This book provides many such examples, from which we can learn valuable lessons for the effective use of conserved germplasm. The widely applicable lesson is that close, effective, and long-term collaboration is required among different players, including germplasm curators, plant breeders, molecular biologists, entomologists, ecologists, and social scientists. As plant yields are increased, however, there is a corresponding rise in their vulnerability to pests and pathogens, making vigilance and collaboration by plant genetic resources scientists and entomologists vital to minimize crop losses. Linkage of efforts at national, regional, and international levels is also critical to deal with globally important pest problems, and thus to increase the world’s food security by maximizing existing resources and production potential.
REFERENCE 1. Oerke, E.C., H.W. Dehne, F. Schonbeck, and A. Weber, Crop Production and Crop Protection: Estimated Losses in Major Food and Cash Crops, Elsevier Science B.V., Amsterdam, 1994.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Preface
Social and natural scientists, the general public, and policymakers affiliated with government and non-governmental organizations have become more aware of the importance of plant genetic resources to world agriculture and food security over the last four decades of the 20th century. Erosion of biodiversity in agriculture resulting from widespread cropping of high-yielding, genetically uniform cultivars, coupled with the continuous and permanent loss of natural plant biodiversity, brought about by habitat destruction and environmental degradation, has resulted in this heightened interest in germplasm conservation. In light of these developments, the question becomes: Can we sustain human society, albeit one that owes its origins to the emergence of land plants, without the vast genetic diversity that has enabled plants to surmount insect pests, diseases, and droughts over the ages? An ample supply of genetically diverse germplasm is vital to sustain future agricultural pro ductivity worldwide. What makes this book unique among a considerable body of literature on the importance and use of genetic resources to world agriculture is the entomological focus of the assembled chapters. The chapters are grouped into six topic groups: foreword, cereal crops, legume crops, vegetable crops, root and tuber crops, and basic research and biotechnology. An important concept that is addressed in several places in the book is the dependency of modern agriculture on chemical pest control. Modern crop cultivars without the pest-resistant genes or alleles that occur in the wild types and related species of crops are often highly susceptible to insect attack and damage, a point emphasized in the Foreword to this volume. These resistance genes frequently have been lost under intense selection for traits such as high yield and improved human nutritional value. If we hold to the widely believed importance of developing agricultural production systems less dependent on chemical pesticides, researchers will have to look to the world’s plant germplasm conservation sites as a major source of pest-resistant genes for crop improvement programs. The message conveyed by each of the crop-based chapters in this book is that germplasm stocks have been indispensable to entomologists, plant breeders, and other agricultural scientists for insect resistance evaluations for crop improvement. Sometimes, fewer than 10 accessions have been screened for insect resistance; however, many evaluations have included hundreds if not thousands of accessions of a particular collection. Insect- and mite-resistant material has been identified (Chapters 1 through 11), although a higher frequency of usable resistance has been found in the germplasm stocks of some crops (see chapters on rice, wheat, barley, sorghum, common bean, soybean, and alfalfa) than in other crops (see the chapters on grain legumes, vegetable crops, potato, and sweetpotato). As pointed out by some authors in this book, the breeding of advanced lines with resistance genes from unadapted germplasm has been constrained by biological, technological, and social
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
factors. Overcoming these constraints is contingent on interdisciplinary research teams in national and international programs, i.e., plant breeders, molecular biolo gists, entomologists, plant pathologists, and social scientists, working together to apply modern plant breeding and new biotechnological innovations to develop insectresistant cultivars. This book is also about the use and potential of germplasm stocks for basic research in insect-plant interactions, which the penultimate chapter covers, and the applications of biotechnology to the use of natural plant genes for insect-resistant crops, which the final chapter covers. Progress in developing insect-resistant crops relies on indepth knowledge of the myriad biotic factors that mediate insect-plant interactions, and conserved germplasm has much to offer the entomologist and ecologist with an interest in this field of study. Finally, the resource that plant and microbial germplasm bring to plant biotechnology for insect resistance is incalcu lable when one considers that scientists have barely scratched the “biodiversity surface” for resistance genes and products. This book is the product of the efforts, cooperation, and understanding of world leaders in the conservation and use of global plant genetic resources for sustainable agricultural production. We are grateful to the authors for their contributions. We also express our indebtedness to colleagues who provided critical reviews of each chapter. Pioneer Hi-Bred International and Zeneca Ag Products provided partial funding for a symposium at the XX International Congress of Entomology, August 1997, on which this book was based. Finally, we owe a special debt of gratitude to Leslie Elberson and Marilyn Weidner for their professional and tireless efforts in assisting with the preparation of this book for publication. Stephen L. Clement Pullman, Washington Sharron S. Quisenberry Lincoln, Nebraska
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Editors
Stephen L. Clement is the research entomologist, Plant Germplasm Introduction and Testing Research Unit, U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), Agricultural Research Service (ARS), Washington State University, Pullman, WA, and affiliate professor of entomology, Department of Plant, Soil and Entomological Sciences, University of Idaho, Moscow, and scientist, Department of Entomology, Washington State University, Pullman. He obtained his Ph.D. in entomology in 1976 from the University of California, Davis, and was assistant professor of entomology, Ohio Agri cultural Research and Development Center, The Ohio State University (1976-1980), and research entomologist in USDA-ARS laboratories in Albany, California (1980) and Rome, Italy (1981-1986), before assuming his present position in 1986. Over the past 25 years Dr. Clement has written broadly on insect biology and behavior, insect pest management, plant resistance to insects, and biological weed control. His research projects have concentrated on rice, corn, rangeland weeds, artichoke, alfalfa, grain legumes, cool-season perennial grasses, fungal endophytes of grasses, and wheat. He is the author or coauthor of more than 115 professional papers, abstracts, and book chapters. Clement has presented or copresented more than 85 research papers before national and international audiences. Dr. Clement is a member of the Entomological Society of America, Crop Science Society of America, Kansas Entomological Society, International Organization of Biological Control, Pisum Genetics Association, and the honorary society Sigma Xi. He has been the recipient of research grants from Sigma Xi, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, and USDA agencies (Cooperative State Research, Education, and Extension Service; Foreign Agricultural Service, Scientific Cooperation Program). Sharron S. Quisenberry is professor and head of the Department of Entomology, University of Nebraska, Lincoln, (1994-present) and courtesy professor in the Departments of Agronomy, Curriculum and Instruction, and Center for Biotechnol ogy, University of Nebraska-Lincoln. She obtained her Ph.D. in entomology (1980) from the University of Missouri, Columbia, and was assistant professor of entomol ogy at Iowa State University (1980-1982), assistant to professor of entomology at Louisiana State University (1982-1991), and professor and division chair of ento mology at the University of Idaho (1991-1994). Dr. Quisenberry has published in the areas of plant resistance to insects, insect/plant interactions, insect biology, insect pest management, and livestock insects related to insect/animal interactions and insecticide resistance. Her research projects have concentrated on insects related to wheat, rice, bermudagrass, tall fescue, alfalfa, and livestock. Dr. Quisenberry is the author or coauthor of more than 165 professional papers, and presented or copresented more than 90 papers at international, national, and regional professional meetings. She has received research
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
grants from National Science Foundation, USDA (e.g., Cooperative State Research; National Research Initiative; Integrated Pest Management; Special Grants), Murdock Trust, and Ford Foundation. Dr. Quisenberry holds a U.S. Patent and germplasm registration with colleagues. Dr. Quisenberry is a member of the Entomological Society of America (ESA) and was the recipient of the ESA Southeastern Branch J. E. Bussart Memorial Award for Research (1991). She is a Board Certified Entomologist and member of Gamma Sigma Delta and Sigma Xi honor societies. Other professional societies include the American Agronomy Society, American Association for the Advancement of Sci ence, American Association of University Professors, Crop Science Society of America, and the Council for Agriculture Science and Technology.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Contributors
Silvia Arnone Research Agronomist ENEA, Dipartimento Innovazione Settore Biotecnologie e Agricoltura CRE Casaccia Rome, Italy
Susan E. Cowgill, Ph.D. Doctor Centre for Plant Biochemistry and Biotechnology University of Leeds Leeds, United Kingdom
James D. Barbour, Ph.D. Assistant Professor Parma Research and Extension Center University of Idaho Parma, Idaho
Massimo Cristofaro Research Entomologist ENEA, Dipartimento Innovazione Settore Biotecnologic e Agricoltura CRE Casaccia Rome, Italy
David J. Boethel, Ph.D. Professor Department of Entomology Louisiana State University Baton Rouge, Louisiana Cesar Cardona, Ph.D. Entomologist Centro Internacional de Agricultura Tropical (CIAT) Cali, Colombia Edward E. Carey, Ph.D. Sweetpotato Breeder International Potato Center (CIP) Nairobi, Kenya Stephen L. Clement, Ph.D. Research Entomologist USDA/ARS Western Regional Plant Introduction Station Washington State University Pullman, Washington Wanda Collins, Ph.D. Deputy Director General — Research International Potato Center (CIP) Lima, Peru
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Francois du Toit, Ph.D. Research Station Manager Pannar (PTY) LTD Bainsvlei South Africa Sanford D. Eigenbrode, Ph.D. Assistant Professor Department of Plant, Soil and Entomological Sciences University of Idaho Moscow, Idaho Kathy L. Flanders, Ph.D. Assistant Professor and Extension Entomologist Department of Entomology Auburn University Auburn, Alabama Angharad M. R. Gatehouse, Ph.D. Doctor Department of Biological Sciences Science Laboritories University of Durham Durham, United Kingdom
Elvis A. Heinrichs, Ph.D. Adjunct Professor Department of Entomology University of Nebraska Lincoln, Nebraska Masa Iwanaga, Ph.D. Deputy Director General (Programme) International Plant Genetic Resources Institute (IPGRI) Rome, Italy Julia Kornegay, Ph.D. Director of Research Fairchild Tropical Garden Miami, Florida George R. Manglitz, Ph.D. Professor Emeritus Department of Entomology University of Nebraska Lincoln, Nebraska Il-Gin Mok, Ph.D. Plant Breeder
International Potato Center (CIP)
Bogor, Indonesia
Dolores W. Mornhinweg, Ph.D. Geneticist USDA/ARS Plant Science and Water Conservation Research Laboratory Stillwater, Oklahoma
Gary C. Peterson, Ph.D. Professor Agriculture Research and Extension Center Texas A&M University Lubbock, Texas David R. Porter, Ph.D. Research Geneticist USDA/ARS Plant Science and Water Conservation Research Laboratory Stillwater, Oklahoma Sharron S. Quisenberry, Ph.D. Professor and Head Department of Entomology University of Nebraska Lincoln, Nebraska Edward B. Radcliffe, Ph.D. Professor Department of Entomology University of Minnesota St. Paul, Minnesota C. Michael Smith, Ph.D. Professor Department of Entomology Kansas State University Manhattan, Kansas
Kanayo F. Nwanze, Ph.D. Director General West Africa Rice Development Association (WARDA) Bouaké, Côte d’Ivoire
Edgar L. Sorensen, Ph.D. Research Geneticist (Retired) USDA/ARS Department of Plant Pathology Kansas State University Manhattan, Kansas
Bonnie B. Pendleton, Ph.D. Postdoctoral Research Associate Department of Entomology Texas A&M University College Station, Texas
George L. Teetes, Ph.D. Professor Department of Entomology Texas A&M University College Station, Texas
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Paul Thompson, Ph.D. Professor Department of Plant Sciences Mississippi State University Pontotoc, Mississippi
Susanne Weigand Legume Entomologist (Retired) International Center for Agricultural Research in the Dry Areas (ICARDA) Aleppo, Syria
James A. Webster, Ph.D. Laboratory Director and Research Entomologist USDA/ARS Plant Science and Water Conservation Research Laboratory Stillwater, Oklahoma
Zhang Da Peng, Ph.D. Sweetpotato Breeder International Potato Center (CIP) Lima, Peru
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Table of Contents
FOREWORD Masa Iwanaga SECTION I: CEREAL CROPS Chapter 1 Germplasm Evaluation and Utilization for Insect Resistance in Rice Elvis A. Heinrichs and Sharron S. Quisenberry Chapter 2 The Value of Conserved Wheat Germplasm Evaluated for Arthropod Resistance C. Michael Smith, Sharron S. Quisenberry, and Francois du Toit Chapter 3 Insect Resistance in Barley Germplasm David R. Porter, Dolores W. Mornhinweg, and James A. Webster Chapter 4 Genetic Diversity of Sorghum: A Source of Insect-Resistant Germplasm George L. Teetes, Gary C. Peterson, Kanayo F. Nwanze, and Bonnie B. Pendleton SECTION II: LEGUME CROPS Chapter 5 Bean Germplasm Resources for Insect Resistance Cesar Cardona and Julia Kornegay Chapter 6 Assessment of Soybean Germplasm for Multiple Insect Resistance David J. Boethel Chapter 7 Germplasm Resources, Insect Resistance, and Grain Legume Improvement Stephen L. Clement, Massimo Cristofaro, Susan E. Cowgill, and Susanne Weigand
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Chapter 8 Alfalfa Germplasm Resources and Insect Resistance George R. Manglitz and Edgar L. Sorensen SECTION III: VEGETABLE CROPS Chapter 9 Vegetable Crops: Search for Arthropod Resistance in Genetic Resources James D. Barbour SECTION IV: ROOT AND TUBER CROPS Chapter 10 Utilization of Sweetpotato Genetic Resources to Develop Insect Resistance Wanda W. Collins, Edward E. Carey, Il-Gin Mok, Paul Thompson, and Zhang Da Peng Chapter 11 The Potato: Genetic Resources and Insect Resistance Kathy L. Flanders, Silvia Arnone, and Edward B. Radcliffe SECTION V: BASIC RESEARCH AND BIOTECHNOLOGY Chapter 12 Plant Genetic Resources for the Study of Insect-Plant Interactions Sanford D. Eigenbrode and Stephen L. Clement Chapter 13 Biotechnological Applications of Plant Genes in the Production of InsectResistant Crops Angharad M. R. Gatehouse
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Section I Cereal Crops
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
1
Germplasm Evaluation and Utilization for Insect Resistance in Rice E. A. Heinrichs and Sharron S. Quisenberry
CONTENTS I. Introduction II. Germplasm Conservation III. Germplasm Evaluation and Utilization A. West Africa B. Asia C. Latin America D. North America IV. Biotechnology as a Tool to Enhance Resistance A. Tissue and Anther Culture B. Wide Crosses C. Transgenic Plants D. DNA Markers E. DNA Fingerprinting of Insects V. Integration of Resistant Cultivars A. Plant Resistance and Biological Control B. Plant Resistance and Cultural Control C. Plant Resistance and Chemical Control VI. Resistant Cultivars in IPM Systems VII. Conclusions References
I.
INTRODUCTION
The diversity and complexity of the constraints limiting food crop production call for a well-focused and strategic approach to agricultural development. Changing pest populations caused by the immigration of new pests, introduction of new crops, and cropping intensification attest to the need for dynamic crop breeding programs.22 Crop cultivars developed in such breeding programs that have resistance to the various abiotic and biotic stresses such as drought, salinity, soil toxicity, weeds,
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
insects, and diseases are major components in integrated pest management (IPM) programs.43 The foundation of IPM programs should be laid with crop cultivars that are not only well adapted to the various abiotic constraints, but also have some level of resistance to one or more insect pests and diseases. The cultivar should be the best from an economic perspective, as conditioned by resistance to key pests and positive or negative interactions with other components of the production system. Development of rice, Orysa sativa L., cultivars having genetic resistance to insects requires an effective program of germplasm screening to identify genotypes that can be used as parents in rice breeding programs. These breeding programs must increase productivity per unit of agricultural land, and this must be accomplished in a way that conserves natural resources and the environment and meets the food requirements of people who are undernourished. The breeding of rice cultivars with multiple resistance to pests and tolerance to abiotic stresses is essential if we are going to experience another “Green Revolution,” which some have termed the “Super Green Revolution.”13 Breeding programs of the first “Green Revolution” involved close collaboration among plant breeders, agronomists, pathologists, and entomologists. The “Super Green Revolution” breeding programs should involve additional disciplines encompassing both the natural and social sciences. The availability of germplasm with a wide range of genetic diversity is essential to the success of these breeding programs.
II.
GERMPLASM CONSERVATION
There is a high level of genetic diversity in rice, Oryza sp., that exceeds that of most other crops. Throughout the long history of rice cultivation, rice strains adapted to the many different agroclimatic regions of the world have been selected by farmers. It has been estimated that there are more than 100,000 strains of rice in the world. Utilization of the genetic diversity which exists in rice has been economically profitable. For example, the contribution of rice landraces from genebanks in South Asia is estimated at $150 to $200 million (U.S.) per year.17 Included in the diversity that exists in the world collection of rice is genetic resistance to numerous rice insect pests. Rice germplasm collections, varying in size from a few hundred to several thousand accessions, are maintained in various countries by national research programs and by International Agricultural Research Centers (IARCs) of the Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research (CGIAR). The global collection consists of approximately 420,000 accessions, including duplicates (Table 1). The largest holdings and the global base collection are at the International Rice Research Institute (IRRI) in the Philippines (19% of the global total). Other large holdings are located in national programs in China (5%), India (5%), the U.S. (National Small Grains Collection, Aberdeen, Idaho, 5%), and at the West Africa Rice Development Association (WARDA) in Côte d’Ivoire (4%).17 The IRRI collection consists of about 77,000 accessions of O. sativa, 2,000 strains of O. glaberrima Steud., and 1,000 wild rices under long-term storage. About 11,000 duplicate or back-up accessions are maintained under long-term storage conditions at the National Seed Storage Laboratory (NSSL), Fort Collins, Colorado. Of the 10 largest rice germplasm collections, 7 are stored under long- or medium-term conditions.17 © 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 1 Status of Rice (Oryza) Germplasm Collections Genebank Institutea IRRI ICR-SAAS CRRI NSGC WARDA ICGR-CAAS RD NBPGR IITA NIAR NSSL CNPAF Univ. of Kyushu CIRAD IRCT-CIRAD ICRR-JAAS CRIA MARDI CENARGEN BRRI Others Total
Country/ organization CGIAR China India USA CGIAR China Thailand India CGIAR Japan USA Brazil Japan France France China Indonesia Malaysia Brazil Bangladesh
Accessions
Storage facilities (%)
Number
%
LTb
MTc
STd
Others
80634 20000 20000 19646 17440 16885 15350 12872 12315 11559 10833 8998 8000 7306 7131 6900 5917 5333 4734 4265 124223 420341
19 5 5 5 4 4 4 3 3 3 3 2 2 2 2 2 1 1 1 1 30 100
100 0 0 0 0 100 0 100 50 100 100 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 0 100 100 0 0 0 0 50 0 0 100 0 0 0 0 100 100 100 87
0 100 0 0 100 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 100 0 0 0 13
0 0 0 0 0 0 100 0 0 0 0 0 100 100 100 0 0 0 0 0
34
22
13
31
a
IRRI = International Rice Research Institute; ICR-SAAS = Institute of Crop Research-Sichuan Academy of Agricultural Sciences; CRRI = Central Rice Research Institute; NSGC = U.S. National Small Grains Collection; WARDA = West Africa Rice Development Association; ICGR-CAAS = International Center for Crop Germplasm Resources — Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences; RD = Rice Division; NBPGR = National Board for Plant Genetic Resources; IITA = International Institute for Tropical Agriculture; NIAR = National Institute of Agrobiological Resources; NSSL = U.S. National Seed Storage Laboratory; CNPAF = Centro Nacional de Pesquisa de Arroz e Feijão; CIRAD = Centre de Coopération Internationale en Recherche Agronomique pour le Developpement; IRCT-CIRAD = Institute de Rechenchers du Coton et des Textiles Exotiques — Centre de Coopération Internationale en Recherche Agronomique pour le Developpement; ICRR-JAAS = Institute of Crop Resources Research-Jiangsu Academy of Agricultural Sciences; CRIA = Central Research Institute for Agriculture; MARDI = Malaysian Agricultural Research and Development Institute; CENARGEN = Centro Nacional de Recursos Geneticos e Biotecnologia; BRRI = Bangladesh Rice Research Institute. b Long-term. c Medium-term. d Short-term. Data from FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations), The State of the World’s Plant Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture, Rome, 1996. (Ref. 17)
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Estimates are that 95% of landraces and 10% of the wild species have been collected.17 On a global basis, accessions consist of 1% wild relatives, 25% landraces, 9% advanced cultivars/breeding lines, and 65% mixed categories or unknown material. For safety, 77% of O. sativa, 54% of O. glaberrima, and 65% of wild relatives have been duplicated at IRRI. The various rice germplasm collection and conservation programs have been successful on a global basis and have provided a large number of accessions for use in insect resistance screening and breeding programs.
III.
GERMPLASM EVALUATION AND UTILIZATION
Rice research programs in several regions of the world have active projects for the development of insect resistant rice cultivars (Table 2). Resistance to more than 30 insect species has been identified through the screening of germplasm collections and numerous insect-resistant cultivars are being used as components in pest management systems worldwide.21
A. WEST AFRICA West Africa dominates the sub-Saharan rice sector with 60% of the rice area and 56% of the production.42 Driven by urbanization and changing food preferences, rice consumption in sub-Saharan Africa has increased at more than 5% per annum since 1970 and rice is emerging as a commodity of strategic significance.71 Rice yields in West Africa average only 40% of the world imports, are rising at an annual rate of 6.8% since 1970, and are projected by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) to increase to 4 mt by the year 2000 costing more than $1 billion (U.S.) in scarce foreign exchange. Rice availability and rice prices are major factors in the welfare of the poorest West African consumers who are the least food secure. Weeds, insects, and diseases are major constraints to rice production in West Africa. The most important insects are root feeders such as termites, several species of stem borers, the African rice gall midge, Orseolia oryzivora Harris and Gagne, foliage feeders including the rice caseworm, Nymphula depunctalis Guenée, and chrysomelid beetles which transmit rice yellow mottle virus (RYMV).23 Because of their importance in all West African rice ecosystems, stem borers have received the greatest emphasis in the development of resistant rice cultivars. Through the screening of rice germplasm by the International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA), Institut de Recherche Agronomique Tropicale (IRAT), WARDA, and the National Cereals Research Institute (NCRI) in Nigeria, cultivars with resistance to the stem borers Diopsis longicornis Macqart, Chilo zacconius Blezynski, Maliarpha separatella Ragonot, and Sesamia calamistis (Hampson) have been identified.42 Screening of rice cultivars for resistance to D. longicornis has been conducted at IITA in Nigeria,3-5,65 at Bouaké, Côte d’Ivoire,57 and in Senegal.69 Cultivars with moderate levels of resistance were from Asia, Africa, and South America. In addition, nine tropical O. glaberrima (Tog) cultivars from Liberia were selected. In his report on screening at IITA, Akinsola2 lists 35 cultivars as moderately resistant to D. longicornis (Table 3). A review of the literature indicates 54 O. sativa and 10 tropical O. glaberrima cultivars as moderately resistant to D. longicornis.23
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 2 Status of Screening and Breeding for Varietal Resistance to Rice Insect Pests
Common name White stem borer Pink borer Stalk-eyed fly African rice gall midge Asian rice gall midge Brown planthopper Whitebacked planthopper Green leafhopper Zigzag leafhopper White leafhopper Blue leafhopper Striped stem borer Yellow stem borer Whorl maggot Seedling fly Armyworm Thrips Rice bug Black bug Caseworm Leaffolder
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Scientific name Maliarpha separatella Sesamia calamistis Diopsis longicornis Orseolia oryzivora Orseolia oryzae Nilaparvata lugens Sogatella furcifera Nephotettix virescens Recilia dorsalis Cofana spectra Empoascanara maculifrons Chilo suppressalis Scirpophaga incertulas Hydrellia philippina Atherigona exigua Mythimna separata Stenchaetothrips biformis Leptocorisa oratorius Scotinophara latiuscula Nymphula depunctalis Cnaphalocrocis medinalis
Region West West West West Asia Asia Asia Asia Asia Asia Asia Asia Asia Asia Asia Asia Asia Asia Asia Asia Asia
Africa Africa Africa Africa
Screening methods developed
Resistance sources identified
Resistant cultivar released
Genes for resistance identified
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + – + + + + +
– + – – + + + + + – – + + + – – + – + – –
– – – – + + + + + – – – – – – – – – – – –
TABLE 2 (continued) Status of Screening and Breeding for Varietal Resistance to Rice Insect Pests
Common name Leaffolder Hispa Bloodworm Rice delphacid Sugarcane borer Lesser cornstalk borer Whorl maggot Fall armyworm Rice water weevil Rice weevil Maize weevil Lesser grain borer Angoumois grain moth
Scientific name Marasmia patnalis Dicladispa armigera Chironomus tepperi Tagosodes orizicolus Diatraea saccharalis Elasmopalpus lignosellus Hydrellia griseola Spodoptera frujiperda Lissorhoptrus oryzophilus Sitophilus oryzae Sitophilus zeamais Rhyzopertha dominica Sitotroga cerealella
Region
Screening methods developed
Resistance sources identified
Resistant cultivar released
Genes for resistance identified
Asia Asia Australia Latin America Latin America Latin America Latin America North America North America Worldwide Worldwide Worldwide Worldwide
+ + + + + + + + + + + + +
+ + + + + + + + + + + + +
– – – + + – + – – – – – –
– – – – – – – – – – – – –
Modified from Heinrichs, E.A., Rice insects: the role of host plant resistance in integrated pest management systems, Korean J. Appl. Entomol., 31:256-275, 1992. (Ref. 21)
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 3 Rice Cultivars Tested and Identified with Moderate Resistance to Stem Borers at the International Institute of Tropical Agriculture, Ibadan, Nigeria Stem borer Diopsis longicornis Chilo zacconius Maliarpha separatella Sesamia calamistis
Accessions tested (no.)
Moderately resistant accessions (no.)
Type of test
2,036 600 2,000 800
35 10 5 6
Field and screenhouse Field and screenhouse Field Field and screenhouse
Data from Akinsola, E.A., The Biology and Ecology of Rice Stem Borers in Nigeria, Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Ibadan, Ibadan, 1979. (Ref. 1)
Screening studies for C. zacconius resistance were started at IITA in 1973 when three Asian cultivars, “H8,” “Malagkit Sung Song,” and “Ratna,” were selected out of 400 cultivars screened.34 In 1975, 200 cultivars were screened in the field and then retested in the screenhouse at IITA where “TOs 2513” and “Taitung 16” were selected.65 Ukwungwu67 evaluated 60 cultivars previously identified as having resistance to certain insects and found “Lac 23” (white) from Liberia and “IR 4625-123-1-2” as having moderate resistance. Akinsola2 reported 10 moderately resistant accessions out of 600 tested at IITA (Table 3). The literature lists 22 cultivars from 9 countries (mostly Asian) as having moderate resistance.23 Field screening for M. separatella resistance at Badeggi, Nigeria,1 at IITA in Ibadan, Nigeria,65 and in Man, Côte d’Ivoire,57 identified 14 accessions as having moderate resistance. A total of 26 accessions has been reported as having moderate resistance.23 Resistant donors have been used as parents in the WARDA breeding program and, in 1991, 10 lines with resistance under high insect pressure were reported by WARDA breeders located at IITA.23 Only 10 cultivars have been selected for resistance to S. calamistis.23 Of these, “Sikasso” from Nigeria and “Taitung 16” from Taiwan have been used as parents in the breeding program.2 The African rice gall midge has only recently become a pest in West Africa, especially in Burkina Faso and Nigeria.68 No resistant sources have been identified although extensive screening of Asian germplasm resistant to the Asian rice gall midge, O. oryzae (Wood-Mason), has been conducted. In 1993, the WARDA/Commonwealth Agricultural Bureaux (CABI) Gall Midge Project began operation to identify, among other objectives, gall midge-resistant germplasm for use in the breeding program. Although cultivars with resistance to C. zacconius and S. calamistis have been released (Table 2), resistant cultivars still occupy a small percentage of the rice area in West Africa. Commercial cultivars with moderate resistance to D. longicornis are “BG 90-2,” “IR 8,” “Faro 188A,” “Iguape Cateto,” and “I Kong Pao.”23 “BG 90-2” is widely grown in West Africa, especially in the irrigated Sahel area of Mali. The widely adopted traditional upland cultivar “Lac 23” has moderate resistance to C. zacconius.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
The cultivars with resistance to M. separatella and S. calamistis can be used as donor parents in the breeding of new stem borer resistant cultivars, although resistance levels are only moderate. Identification of germplasm with higher levels of resistance to the various stem borer species and other major insect pests is needed. Once identified, resistant germplasm can be used in the development of high yielding, multiple pest-resistant rice cultivars that are also tolerant to the abiotic constraints in West Africa.
B. ASIA Sources of resistance to more than 30 insect species have been identified in the world rice collections (Table 2).21 There are numerous rice breeding programs in Asia that include resistance to insects as a breeding objective, including the national programs and the IRRI program. These programs have made significant progress in the development and release of pest-resistant cultivars. The All India Coordinated Rice Improvement Project (AICRIP) through the screening of rice germplasm at 20 sites has identified germplasm resistant to seven rice insect pests.59 More than 40 cultivars with multiple resistance to as many as four insect species have been commercially released.59 The first hybrid rice developed by Chinese scientists was released in 1976 and by 1991 the area under hybrid rice cultivation reached 17.6 million ha (55% of China’s total rice area) and contributed to 66% of the country’s rice production.76 Chinese hybrids have been adapted for the tropics and national programs in India, Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines, and Vietnam. They have 15% yield advantage compared with open pollinated cultivars, possess good grain quality, and have multiple disease and insect resistance.6 The Korean national rice breeding program has emphasized resistance to planthoppers and leafhoppers in the development of multiple pest-resistant cultivars. One cultivar, “Namyeongbyeo,” is resistant to five diseases, namely bacterial leaf blight Xanthomonas pv. oryzae (Ishyama) Dye, black-streaked dwarf virus (fijivirus), blast Pyricularia oryzae Cavara, dwarf virus (reovirus), and stripe virus (tenuivirus); three hopper species, namely brown planthopper Nilaparvata lugens (Stål), green leafhopper Nephotettix cincticeps (Uhler), and smaller brown planthopper Laodelphax striatella (Fallen); and a nematode Aphelencoides besseyi Christie. “Namyeongbyeo” yields in multi-location trials were 5.69 t/ha, 10% higher than the highest yielding check.64 The IRRI rice improvement program emphasizes the development of germplasm with multiple resistance to key diseases and insects.29,39 Screening procedures for numerous rice insect species have been developed.28 Emphasis in screening and breeding activities has been on the major insect pests including the Asian gall midge, brown planthopper, green leafhopper, yellow stem borer Scirpophaga incertulas (Walker), and the striped stem borer Chilo suppressalis (Walker) (Table 2). Cultivars with multiple resistance to these pests and the diseases blast, bacterial leaf blight, sheath blight Rhizoctonia solani Kuhn, tungro virus (spherical form = ribotungrovirus; bacilliform = badnavirus), and grassy stunt virus (tenuivirus), have been developed.24 The widespread adoption of these cultivars has helped stabilize rice production in Asia.39
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
In Asia, where rice is mostly grown under irrigated conditions, modern cultivars have rapidly spread. Ninety-four percent of the rice hectarage is planted to modern cultivars in the Philippines. Furthermore, modern cultivars occupy 100% of the rice area in China and Japan.40 Most of the cultivars planted have resistance to at least one insect. Cultivars developed at IRRI have had a significant economic and social impact in Asia.40 Cultivar “IR36,” with multiple resistance to insects and diseases, was once grown on about 16 million ha in Asia, but has been replaced by newer cultivars which have multiple resistance to at least seven key diseases and insects. The availability of rice cultivars with multiple resistance to insects and diseases has minimized the need for pesticides and has promoted the adoption of IPM practices. Indonesia’s national IPM policy resulted in the banning of 57 rice insecticides.24
C. LATIN AMERICA Rice is a major food crop in Latin America where pest control expenses contribute to increasing costs and decreasing profitability of rice production.73 Crop protection costs in Colombia account for 22% of total production costs and insecticides represent 35% of the total pest control costs in Latin America (Rice Program Database, Centro Internacional de Agricultura Tropical [CIAT], Cali, Colombia). Cost of rice insecticides in Latin America is $170 million (U.S.) per year. CIAT scientists predict that with improved management, including host plant resistance, insect control costs can be cut to 0.2% of total production costs which is equal to the value of 8 kg/ha of paddy rice. Insect-resistant cultivars are one component in an overall strategy for developing commercially acceptable rice cultivars in Latin America. Screening has identified cultivars with resistance to the “sogata” planthopper Tagosodes orizicolus (Muir), sugarcane borer Diatraea saccharalis (F.), whorl maggot Hydrellia griseola (Fallen),73 and the lesser cornstalk borer Elasmopalpus lignosellus (Zeller).28 Major emphasis in pest resistance breeding in Latin America is on the “sogata” planthopper and the rice hoja blanca virus (RHBV) (tenuivirus) that this insect vectors. The uncertainty of RHBV epidemics in the Andean, Central American, and Caribbean countries causes farmers to apply “insurance sprays” even when the problem is not apparent. It is estimated that about half of the lowland farmers in these areas apply one insecticide spray for planthopper-RHBV each cropping season, costing approximately $15 million (U.S.) annually.74 Numerous sources of resistance against the planthopper have been identified in CIAT screening. Planthopper-resistant cultivars were released in 1970 (“CICA 4”) and the level of resistance was increased in “CICA 8” by 1978, based on the “Tetep” cultivar source.74 Most of the rice cultivars, including “CICA 4” and “CICA 8,” grown in Latin America are tolerant to the planthopper and outbreaks on these cultivars have been rare. These cultivars tolerate natural pest fluctuations and allow beneficial arthropods to maintain planthopper populations at sub-economic levels. Surveys of commercial fields throughout Colombia indicated that no insecticide applications were necessary when tolerant cultivars were planted even though the maximum planthopper densities exceeded the action threshold. Because of cultivar
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
tolerance, direct damage by the planthopper was insignificant and biological agents were allowed to regulate population densities below the action threshold.73 More than 70% of the major commercial cultivars in Latin America have resistance to the planthopper, 50% have resistance to the whorl maggot, and 80% have resistance to the sugarcane borer. Some cultivars have occupied large areas, such as “J 104” (110,000 ha in Cuba) and “Oryzica 1” (260,000 ha in Colombia).73 Economic analyses indicate that the breeding and utilization of planthopperRHBV resistant cultivars is highly profitable. An impact assessment of CIAT research projects in the years 1997 to 2010 for breeding planthopper-RHBV resistant rice cultivars indicated a net present value of $616 million (U.S.).56 In a subsequent impact assessment, this resistance was predicted to provide a high internal rate of return of 63%.33
D. NORTH AMERICA Rice is an important crop in the economies of Arkansas, California, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, and Texas in the U.S. Although the U.S. only grows 1% of the world’s rice production, yields are high (6.2 t/ha) and the U.S. is a major rice exporter.36 The rice water weevil, Lissorhoptrus oryzophilus Kuschel, is the major rice pest in North America causing significant damage to rice root systems.60 It ranges from Central America to Canada and has recently been introduced into Japan from the U.S.,66 and has since spread to Korea41 and Taiwan.58 Screening of germplasm in the U.S. has emphasized this pest but some germplasm screening for the fall armyworm, Spodoptera frugiperda (J.E. Smith),53 and studies on the effect of cultivar height on the least skipper, Ancyloxypha numitor (F.),63 also have been conducted. Because all cultivars currently grown in the U.S. are susceptible to larvae of the rice water weevil, research has attempted to identify sources of resistance in rice lines and cultivars.62 Based on the field screening technique of Bowling,10 more than 8,000 USDA Rice World Collection lines have been screened for larval resistance. Two lines designated WC1711 and CI11048 were identified in California20 and three lines (WC1403, WC1349, WC1815) were identified in Louisiana as having moderate tolerance to the rice water weevil.19 These lines have been used as parents in the breeding program in Louisiana. Further screening in Louisiana has identified several promising breeding lines. Field screening in 1990 identified AL6029, LA2218, TX22041, URN199, and URN200 as having tolerance, and TX12685 and TX13079 as having low levels of antixenosis.47 Greenhouse evaluations in 1991 and 1992 identified the breeding lines 8723518, 8725417, and 8725454 as having resistance based on larval numbers on the roots.50 In a 1991-1992 field evaluation of 40 breeding lines, lines 8720906 and 8721937 exhibited moderate levels of tolerance and lines 872239 and 8721317 had low levels of tolerance.51 These lines supported high larval populations, but yields did not decline or were higher when compared with treated controls. This germplasm also recovered from root pruning damage caused by larval feeding. Pantoja et al. screened about 5,000 rice accessions to the fall armyworm in the greenhouse in Louisiana.53 Moderate resistance to larval defoliation was detected in
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
plant introductions (PI) 160842, 346830, 346833, 346840, and 346853 from the U.S. National Small Grains Collection. Moderate levels of resistance were also detected in U.S. cultivars “Honduras,” “Newrex,” and “Chinese,” and in O. glaberrima Steud accessions 101800, 102554, and 369453 from the IRRI collection. However, no commercial cultivars with resistance to this pest have been released (Table 2). The need for cultivars with higher levels of resistance continues in spite of the extensive screening of germplasm for rice water weevil and fall armyworm resistance. This need has increased with the banning of effective insecticides for water weevil control in the U.S.51 On an international basis, the need has become increasingly acute with the spread of the rice water weevil to Japan, Korea, and Taiwan where this pest causes serious economic damage. Biotechnology techniques have been used to enhance levels of resistance to the rice water weevil.14
IV.
BIOTECHNOLOGY AS A TOOL TO ENHANCE RESISTANCE
Several biotechnological approaches are employed in the development of insectresistant rice cultivars. Tissue and anther culture techniques are utilized to increase the level of resistance, and wide hybridization and transformation contribute to the generation of novel genetic variation by increasing the gene pool available to breeders. DNA markers of rice and DNA fingerprinting help to make selection, phenotypic analysis, and biotype studies more efficient and powerful.9,46
A. TISSUE
AND
ANTHER CULTURE
Tissue culture and anther culture techniques have been used in Louisiana in attempts to develop germplasm with higher levels of rice water weevil resistance than has been found in conventionally bred lines. In a field evaluation of 66 tissue culture lines in 1990, lines 244 and 2232 showed antixenotic resistance and line 112 tolerance to the rice water weevil.48 Both were regenerated from tissue culture of the susceptible cultivar “Tebonnet.” The anther culture lines 952836 and 953527 exhibited moderate levels of resistance to the rice water weevil in field evaluations of 43 anther culture lines in 1990 and 1991.49
B. WIDE CROSSES Wild species have provided resistance sources where screening of the O. sativa germplasm collection has failed to identify adequate levels of resistance to certain rice insects.32,44,75 Although wild species are often incompatible with O. sativa in conventional breeding, they can be used as donor parents using wide hybridization and embryo rescue techniques.11 Rescue of hybrid embryos through tissue culture and backcrossing to O. sativa allows recovery of new lines which contain segments of the wild genome introgressed into the O. sativa background.8 In studies at IRRI, genes from seven wild rice species have been transferred to O. sativa for resistance to the brown planthopper, whitebacked planthopper Sogatella furcifera (Horvath), and yellow stem borer (Table 4). IRRI breeding lines possessing a gene for brown planthopper resistance from O. officinalis were tested in the Mekong Delta, Vietnam,
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 4 Status of the Transfer of Genes for Insect Resistance from Wild Rice Species to Oryza sativa by Wide Hybridization and Embryo Rescue Resistance to: Brown planthopper
Whitebacked planthopper Yellow stem borer
Donor species (Genome) O. O. O. O. O. O. O. O.
officinalis (CC) minuta (BBCC) latifolia (CCDD) australiensis (EE) granulata (unknown) officinalis (CC) brachyantha (FF) ridleyi (unknown)
Status Completed Completed Completed Completed Material under test Completed Material under test Material under test
From Brar, D.S. and G.S. Khush, Wide hybridization for enhancing resistance to biotic and abiotic stresses in rainfed lowland rice, In: Proc. Int. Rice Res. Conf., International Rice Research Institute, Los Baños, 1995. (Ref. 11)
where they were more resistant than test cultivars with known resistance genes.54 Current work at IRRI concentrates on the transfer of yellow stem borer resistance from O. brachyantha to O. sativa because only moderate levels of resistance to the stem borer have been identified in O. sativa germplasm.8
C. TRANSGENIC PLANTS The transgenic approach to enhancing resistance to rice insects is attractive because it provides access to non-rice genes, allows purified rice genes to be returned to rice after modifications that give enhanced performance not attainable through mutation and recombination in vivo, and allows the addition of specific characters into rice without the linkage drag and the requirement for backcrossing that accompany sexual hybridization.8 Scientists at IRRI and at other locations linked by the Rockefeller Foundation Biotechnology Network are incorporating novel genes for resistance into rice through transformation. The genes include the Bacillus thuringiensis Berliner (Bt) genes cryIA(b) and cryIA(c) under the control of various promoters and several proteinase inhibitor genes. The rice insects controlled by these genes include the yellow stem borer, striped stem borer,8 and the leaffolder Cnaphalocrocis medinalis (Guenée).18 Genetic engineering of rice with toxin genes from Bt has the potential to provide effective and environmentally safe control of several rice insect pests. Of major concern, however, is its potential lack of stability.9 Numerous strategies have been proposed to delay the evolution of rice pest resistance to Bt toxins in transgenic rice plants.9,12 One strategy is the use of spatial refuges in association with the combination of multiple Bt toxins that bind to different receptors. Proposed spatial refuges consist of tissue specific expression, within field mixtures of Bt and non-Bt rice plants, and field-to-field mixtures of Bt and non-Bt rice. Cohen et al.12 reported that the genetic engineering of rice is progressing rapidly and Bt genes may soon be in agronomic © 1999 by CRC Press LLC
backgrounds suitable for use by farmers. They caution that genetic engineering is proceeding at a faster pace than the development of resistance management strategies.
D. DNA MARKERS Genetic (DNA) markers are being used to accelerate breeding for resistance to the brown planthopper and the Asian gall midge, both major pests of rice in Asia. These markers are being used to cope with the problem of breeding rice cultivars with resistance to insect biotypes. The use of DNA markers enables the breeding program to progress during seasons when there is inadequate insect pressure for field screening, permits breeding to be conducted in countries where the insect does not occur, and allows the pyramiding of genes for more stable resistance. DNA marker-aided selection is being used in breeding for gall midge resistance in China and India as part of a collaborative program coordinated by IRRI. The objective in China is to transfer the gall midge-resistant gene Gm6(t) to the parental lines used in hybrid rice production, while in India the objective is to transfer the resistant gene Gm2 to new germplasm developed for the rainfed lowlands.8
E. DNA FINGERPRINTING
OF INSECTS
Biotypes are a major constraint to the breeding for gall midge resistance in Asia.30 DNA fingerprinting, using restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP), random amplified polymorphism DNA (RAPD), and amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) markers, is being used as a tool to study the genetic diversity of this insect in Cambodia, India, Indonesia, Laos, Myanmar, Nepal, Sri Lanka, and Thailand.8,16 The AFLP technique gives the highest degree of reproducible variation between different gall midge isolates and is sufficiently sensitive to be applied to individual insects in a population.70
V.
INTEGRATION OF RESISTANT CULTIVARS
Rice IPM programs employ cultural controls, pesticides, natural enemy conservation, and pest-resistant cultivars as tactics in the management of rice insect pests. The extent to which each component is integrated into the system is dependent on the nature of the pest complex and the socioeconomic conditions existing in the country.61 Where insect-resistant cultivars are available, they are often used as a basic component in the management of rice pests.22 An advantage of using host plant resistance is that, in general, it is compatible with other control tactics.
A. PLANT RESISTANCE
AND
BIOLOGICAL CONTROL
Complexes of biological control agents have been identified for most major rice insect pests and studies indicate that they have the potential to regulate rice insect populations.52,55 In addition to the joint pest controlling roles of host-plant resistance and biological controls, there exists the longer-term significance of their interaction in delaying or preventing the development of biotypes capable of overcoming previously resistant rice cultivars.72 Insect-resistant cultivars may have an adverse effect on © 1999 by CRC Press LLC
natural enemies by reducing prey density, but generally have a positive effect on natural enemies, especially parasites and predators, by minimizing the need for the application of toxic insecticides. Research on the interactions between plant resistance and biological control has increased in recent years and has shown the positive effects of combining the two tactics.61 The combination of the two control tactics may be additive, or even synergistic, in their effect on decreasing pest populations. Because the use of this combination requires minimal training, it is especially attractive in countries where extension services are not able to train farmers in IPM principles and practices. Examples of how these two tactics can be effectively integrated follow. The green leafhopper is an important rice pest in Asia because it is a vector of the pathogen causing rice tungro virus (RTV). Combinations of green leafhopperresistant cultivars and predation by the mirid bug, Cyrtorhinus lividipennis Reuter, have a cumulative effect on green leafhopper populations. In greenhouse studies at IRRI, the number of green leafhoppers only reached six on the leafhopper resistant rice cultivar “IR29” with the predator, and 31 without the predator, while there were 91 and 220 leafhoppers, respectively, on susceptible “IR22” with and without the predator.45 The cumulative effect was evident in the green leafhopper mortality rates. Predatory activity by the mirid bug increased leafhopper mortality on all cultivars by approximately 30%; from 66 to 92% on highly resistant “IR29,” 34 to 56% on moderately resistant “IR8,” and 7 to 40% on susceptible “IR22.” The cumulative effect of antibiosis and predation resulted in 52% greater leafhopper mortality in the highly resistant “IR29” as compared with susceptible “IR22.”45 Insect-resistant rice cultivars can enhance the activity of predators resulting in a synergistic effect of the two control tactics. Cyrtorhinus lividipennis predation rate increased when the prey, brown planthopper nymphs, fed on the resistant rice cultivar “IR36.”37 This may be caused by increased movement of planthopper nymphs on resistant plants, facilitating detection of prey.
B. PLANT RESISTANCE
AND
CULTURAL CONTROL
The integration of insect-resistant cultivars with cultural management can be a powerful tool in managing pests.43 Early maturing cultivars and planting date are cultural practices employed to evade rice insect attack. In field studies in the Philippines, brown planthopper populations and planthopper:predator ratios on early maturing rice cultivars were significantly lower than those on later maturing cultivars because the insect was not able to complete as many generations on the early maturing cultivars as compared with long duration cultivars.25 A shift of planting dates minimized damage to several stem borer species in India, Indonesia, and Malaysia.38 This strategy could be integrated with plant resistance. However, caution should be taken before using pest evasion tactics because they may have negative attributes, such as yield loss caused by planting at a sub-optimal date. Nitrogen fertilizer is a major component for producing high yields of modern rice cultivars. High plant nitrogen generally favors insect pest populations and is manifested in greater pest survival, increased feeding rate, increased fecundity, and faster growth.15 In a greenhouse study, nitrogen fertilizer was shown to favor population growth of brown planthoppers on rice, even on a resistant cultivar.27 However, brown
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
planthopper population growth was least at the higher levels of cultivar resistance. Thus, when high nitrogen levels are needed to maximize rice production, planting of resistant cultivars will minimize brown planthoppers populations.
C. PLANT RESISTANCE
AND
CHEMICAL CONTROL
Control of rice insects with insecticides has been shown to be more effective when the host plant is an insect-resistant cultivar as compared with a susceptible cultivar. Depending on the insect pest complex, the level of insect pressure, and the degree of plant resistance, insecticides in combination with an insect-resistant cultivar can increase grain yields above that of a resistant cultivar alone.31 A cumulative effect was observed when plant resistance and insecticides were integrated in the control of the green leafhopper (vector of RTV) in field studies in the Philippines.31 The cumulative effect was based on the percentage of RTV-infected plants in the various cultivars tested and was dependent on the level of green leafhopper resistance in the cultivar and insecticide rate. Cultivar “IR28,” with a high level of green leafhopper resistance, had a low pest population and a low incidence of RTV at all insecticide rates including the untreated control. Conversely, the cultivar with high susceptibility to green leafhopper (“IR22”) had a high level of RTV regardless of the rate of insecticide applied. However, the moderately resistant cultivar “IR36” showed a cumulative effect. Resistance of “IR36” to the green leafhopper alone reduced RTV incidence 50% below that of the susceptible cultivar “IR 22.”31 When used in combination with insecticide, there was a rate effect with RTV incidence decreasing from 42% at the 0.0 kg/ha rate to 30% and 11% at the 0.25 and 0.5 kg/ha insecticide rate, respectively. Grain yields were related to percent RTV incidence. This study indicated the need for high levels of resistance to the vector insect in controlling RTV and the cumulative combination effect of moderate resistance and insecticides to the control of the virus vector.31 Results of a greenhouse study indicated that insecticides cause higher mortality to planthoppers feeding on resistant rice rather than on susceptible rice.26 Both the whitebacked planthopper and the brown planthopper were killed at low insecticide rates when feeding on resistant rice cultivars. Mortality rates of biotype 2 brown planthoppers, reared on the moderately resistant “ASD7,” were 2 to 12 times higher than those reared on susceptible “IR26” when treated with spray applications of various insecticides.26 In the same study, LD50 rates of the whitebacked planthopper were three times as high on susceptible “TN1” than hoppers feeding on moderately resistant “N22.”26 Plant resistance is important in minimizing the extent of insecticide-induced brown planthopper resurgence. In field studies at IRRI, brown planthopper populations on rice plants treated with a resurgence-inducing insecticide only reached 10 insects per hill on a resistant rice cultivar, whereas populations on a susceptible cultivar reached 1,100 per hill.7 Thus, when insecticide is needed to control a defoliator, the level of insecticide-induced brown planthopper resurgence can be reduced, or even eliminated, by the planting of a hopper-resistant cultivar.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
VI.
RESISTANT CULTIVARS IN IPM SYSTEMS
A major portion of the world collection has been evaluated for resistance to rice insects. Many resistant accessions have been identified and some have been used as donor parents to produce high yielding rice cultivars with multiple resistance to pests and tolerance to abiotic stresses. The increased pest problems accompanying the “Green Revolution” have sparked a movement toward an integrated approach to the management of rice insect pests, especially in Asia and Latin America. Pest-resistant cultivars have served as key components in IPM programs and in the development of sustainable rice production systems. Insect-resistant rice cultivars have been successfully used in IPM programs throughout Asia and other regions of the world. The Korean rice IPM program uses insect resistance as a major component.41 The cultivar “Namyeongbyeo,” with high yield potential, is resistant to five diseases, three insects, and a nematode.64 The Sri Lankan cultivar “BG367-3” is resistant to blast, brown spot Cochliobolus miyabeanus Ito and Kuribayashi, tungro virus, leaffolder, Asian gall midge, green leafhopper, leaf miner Dicladispa armigera (Oliver), and stem borer Sesamia inferens (Walker). The AICRIP has identified germplasm resistant to seven insect species.59 Use of these sources as gene donors in the Indian rice improvement program has produced more than 40 commercial cultivars with multiple insect resistance, some with resistance to as many as four pest species. Insect-resistant cultivars have minimized the need for pesticides and promoted the adoption of IPM practices and thus stabilized yields at higher levels than previously achieved. Because of insect resistance, early sprays of insecticides are seldom necessary and pests are maintained at sub-economic levels by biological control agents. Indonesia established a national IPM policy based on the integration of plant resistance, biological control, and cultural practices. The policy has led to an upward trend in rice yields and reduced insecticide use resulting in improved health of the growers and improved environmental quality.40
VII.
CONCLUSIONS
In spite of remarkable progress in increasing rice production through genetic improvement and expansion of crop area, the global pursuit for food self-sufficiency continues as the world population rapidly increases. Population growth in rice growing countries results in 80 to 100 million additional people to feed each year.35 Rice production must approximately double by the year 2020 to feed the world population, which will approach 8 billion. Unless technology rapidly advances, lack of suitable land will cause farmers to till highly erodible and marginal land to meet food demands. Insect-resistant rice cultivars integrated with other pest management tactics contribute to crop pest management strategies that are environmentally and economically acceptable. These tactics are a vital component in technology packages that will increase the productivity of existing land resources. Although significant progress has been achieved in the development and commercial use of insect-resistant rice cultivars, plant resistance has the potential to play an even greater role in rice production systems in the future. Because of various
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
constraints in the breeding of insect-resistant cultivars, there are still numerous insect species for which resistant cultivars have not been developed and for which plant resistance as a management tactic has not been used. Biotechnology tools, including wide hybridization, transformation, DNA markers, and DNA fingerprinting, are being used to overcome constraints of breeding rice cultivars with resistance to insects and diseases. These approaches will contribute to the breeding of resistant cultivars for improved crop protection, biodiversity conservation, and profitability.
REFERENCES 1. Akinsola, E. A., The Biology and Ecology of Rice Stem Borers in Nigeria, Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Ibadan, Ibadan, 1979. 2. Akinsola, E. A., Varietal resistance to stem borer pests of rice management in West Africa: a review, Insect Sci. Applic., 8:771-776, 1987. 3. Alam, M. S. and Y. Efron, Resistance of rice to the stalk-eyed fly Diopsis macrophthalma, Int. Rice Comm. Newsl., 35:40-45, 1986. 4. Alghali, A. M., Relative susceptibility of some rice cultivars to the stalk-eyed fly, Diopsis thoracica West., Insect Sci. Applic., 4:135-140, 1983. 5. Alghali, A. M. and E. O. Osisanta, The effects of some rice cultivars on the biology of the stalk-eyed fly Diopsis thoracica West. (Diptera: Diopsidae), Insect Sci. Applic., 3:163-166, 1982. 6. Anonymous, Hybrid seed controversy in India, In: Biotechnology and Development Monitor, No. 19, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, 1994, 9. 7. Aquino, G. B. and E. A. Heinrichs, Brown planthopper populations on resistant cultivars treated with a resurgence-causing insecticide, Int. Rice Res. Newsl., 45:12, 1979. 8. Bennett, J., M. B. Cohen, S. K. Katiyar, B. Ghareyazie, and G. S. Khush, Enhancing insect resistance in rice through biotechnology, In: N. Carozzi and M. Koziel, Eds., Advances in Insect Control: The Role of Transgenic Plants, Taylor Francis, London, 1997, 75. 9. Bottrell, D. G., R. M. Aguda, F. L. Gould, W. Theunis, C. G. Demayo, and V. F. Magalit, Potential strategies for prolonging the usefulness of Bacillus thuringiensis in engineered rice, Korean J. Appl. Entomol., 31:247-255, 1992. 10. Bowling, C. C., Tests to determine varietal reaction to rice water weevil, J. Econ. Entomol., 56:893-894, 1963. 11. Brar, D. S. and G. S. Khush, Wide hybridization for enhancing resistance to biotic and abiotic stresses in rainfed lowland rice, In: Proc. Int. Rice Res. Conf., International Rice Research Institute, Los Baños, 1995. 12. Cohen, M. B., R. M. Aguda, A. M. Romena, G. K. Roderick, and F. L. Gould, Resistance management strategies for Bt rice: what have we learned so far? In: G. S. Khush, Ed., Rice Genetics III: Proc. 3rd Int. Rice Genetics Symp., International Rice Research Institute, Los Baños, 1996, 749. 13. Conway, G., U. Lele, J. Peacock, and J. Pineiro, Sustainable Agriculture for a Food Secure World, a Vision for the Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research, Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research, Washington D.C., 1994. 14. Croughan, T. P. and J. F. Robinson, Application of tissue culture techniques to the development of insect resistant rice, In: E. A. Heinrichs and T. A. Miller, Eds., Rice Insects: Management Strategies, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1991, 275.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
15. Dale, D., Plant mediated effects of soil mineral stresses on insects, In: E. A. Heinrichs, Ed., Plant Stress-Insect Interactions, Wiley, New York, 1988, 35. 16. Ehtesham, N. Z., J. S. Bentur, and J. Bennett, Characterization of a DNA sequence that detects repetitive DNA elements in the Asian rice gall midge (Orseolia oryzae) genome: potential use in DNA fingerprinting of biotypes, Gene 153:179-183, 1995. 17. FAO (Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations), The State of the World’s Plant Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture, Rome, 1996. 18. Fujimoto, H., K. Itoh, M. Yamamoto, J. Kyozuka, and K. Shimamoto, Insect resistance generated by introduction of a modified α-endotoxin gene of Bacillus thuringiensis, Biotechnology 11:1151-1155, 1993. 19. Gifford, J. R. and G. B. Trahan, Rice water weevil and rice stalk borer resistance, In: 67th Ann. Progress Rep., Rice Exp. Stn., Louisiana Agricultural Experiment Station, Baton Rouge, 1975, 125. 20. Grigarick, A. A., M. O. Way, and S. L. Clement, Results of rice cultivar tolerance tests to the rice water weevil in California, In: Proc. 16th Rice Tech. Working Group, Lake Charles, 1976, 63. 21. Heinrichs, E. A., Rice insects: the role of host plant resistance in integrated pest management systems, Korean J. Appl. Entomol., 31:256-275, 1992. 22. Heinrichs, E. A., Development of multiple pest resistant crop cultivars, J. Agric. Entomol. 11:225-253, 1994. 23. Heinrichs, E. A., Rice Insects of West Africa: A Review of the Literature, West Africa Rice Development Association, BP 2551, Bouaké, 1996. 24. Heinrichs, E. A. and A. A. Adesina, The contribution of multiple pest resistance to tropical crop production, In: B. R. Wiseman and J. A. Webster, Eds., Proc. 1994 Nelson Memorial Symp. on Host Plant Resistance, Thomas Say Pubs., Entomological Society of America, Lanham, in press. 25. Heinrichs, E. A., G. B. Aquino, S. L. Valencia, S. DeSagun and M. B. Arceo, Management of the brown planthopper, Nilaparvata lugens (Homoptera: Delphacidae), with early maturing rice cultivars, Environ. Entomol., 15:93-95, 1986. 26. Heinrichs, E. A., L. T. Fabellar, R. P. Basilio, Tu-Cheng Wen, and F. Medrano, Susceptibility of rice planthoppers Nilaparvata lugens and Sogatella furcifera (Homoptera: Delphacidae) to insecticides as influenced by level of resistance in the host plant, Environ. Entomol., 13:455-458, 1984. 27. Heinrichs, E. A. and F. G. Medrano, Influence of nitrogen fertilizer on the population development of brown planthopper, Int. Rice Res. Newsl., 10:20-21, 1985. 28. Heinrichs, E. A., F. G. Medrano, and H. R. Rapusas, Genetic Evaluation for Insect Resistance in Rice, International Rice Research Institute, Los Baños, 1985. 29. Heinrichs, E. A., F. G. Medrano, L. Sunio, H. Rapusas, A. Romena, C. Vega, V. Viajante, D. Centina, and I. Domingo, Resistance of IR cultivars to insect pests, Int. Rice Res. Newsl., 7:9-10, 1982. 30. Heinrichs, E. A. and P. K. Pathak, Resistance to the gall midge, Orseolia oryzae (Wood-Mason) in rice, Insect Sci. Applic., 1:121-132, 1981. 31. Heinrichs, E. A., H. R. Rapusas, G. B. Aquino, and F. Palis, Integration of host plant resistance and insecticides in the control of Nephotettix virescens (Homoptera: Cicadellidae), a vector of rice tungro virus, J. Econ. Entomol., 79:437-443, 1986. 32. Heinrichs, E. A., V. D. Viajante, and A. M. Romena, Resistance of wild rices, Oryza spp. to the whorl maggot Hydrellia philippina Ferino, Environ. Entomol., 14:404-407, 1985. 33. Hertford, R., Strengthening ecoregional research for agricultural development in the American lowland tropics: a framework and discussion paper, CIAT, Cali, 1994.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
34. IITA (International Institute of Tropical Agriculture), Cereal Improvement Program Rep. 1973, Ibadan, 1974. 35. IRRI (International Rice Research Institute), Facts About IRRI, Los Baños, 1990. 36. IRRI (International Rice Research Institute), IRRI Rice Facts, Los Baños, 1995. 37. Kartohardjono, A. and E. A. Heinrichs, Populations of the brown planthopper, Nilaparvata lugens (StDl) (Homoptera: Delphacidae), and its predators on rice cultivars with different levels of resistance, Environ. Entomol., 13:359-365, 1984. 38. Khan, M. Q., Control of paddy stem borer by cultural practices, In: The Major Insect Pests of the Rice Plant, Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore, 1967, 369. 39. Khush, G. S., Multiple disease and insect resistance for increased yield stability in rice, In: L. R. Pollard, Ed., Progress in Irrigated Rice Research, IRRI, Manila, 1989, 79. 40. Khush, G. S., Modern cultivars--their real contribution to food supply and equity, Geojourn., 35:275-284, 1995. 41. Lee, S. C., Toward integrated pest management of rice in Korea, Korean J. Appl. Entomol., 31:205-240, 1992. 42. Matlon, P., M. Becker, M. Dingkuhn, E. Heinrichs, M. Jones, K. Miezan, K. Sahrawat, and A. Sy, Achievements in African rice research, Paper IRC:94/81(b), In: Eighteenth Session Int. Rice Commission, FAO, Rome, 1994. 43. Maxwell, F. G., Use of insect resistant plants in integrated pest management programmes, FAO Plant Prot. Bull., 39:139-146, 1991. 44. Medina, E. B., A. M. Romena, and E. A. Heinrichs, Screening wild rices for resistance to Marasmia patnalis Bradley, Int. Rice Res. Newsl., 11:12, 1986. 45. Myint, M. M., H. R. Rapusas, and E. A. Heinrichs, Integration of varietal resistance and predation for the management of Nephotettix virescens (Homoptera: Cicadellidae) populations on rice, Crop Prot., 5:259-265, 1986. 46. Nair, S., J. S. Bentur, U. P. Rao, and M. Mohan, DNA markers tightly linked to a gall midge resistance gene (Gm2) are potentially useful for marker-aided selection in rice breeding, Theor. Appl. Genetics, 91:68-73, 1995. 47. N’Guessan, F. K. and S. S. Quisenberry, Screening selected lines for resistance to the rice water weevil (Coleoptera: Curculionidae), Environ. Entomol., 23:665-675, 1994. 48. N’Guessan, F. K., S. S. Quisenberry, and T. P. Croughan, Evaluation of rice tissue culture lines for resistance to the rice water weevil (Coleoptera: Curculionidae), J. Econ. Entomol., 87:504-513, 1994. 49. N’Guessan, F. K., S. S. Quisenberry, and T. P. Croughan, Evaluation of rice anther culture lines for tolerance to the rice water weevil (Coleoptera: Curculionidae), Environ. Entomol., 23:331-336, 1994. 50. N’Guessan, F. K., S. S. Quisenberry, and S. D. Linscombe, Investigation of antixenosis and antibiosis as mechanisms of resistance in rice to the rice water weevil (Coleoptera: Curculionidae), J. Entomol. Sci., 29:259-263, 1994. 51. N’Guessan, F. K., S. S. Quisenberry, R. A. Thompson, and S. D. Linscombe, Assessment of Louisiana rice breeding lines for tolerance to the rice water weevil (Coleoptera: Curculiondae), J. Econ. Entomol., 87:476-481, 1994. 52. Ooi, P. A. C. and B. M. Shepard, Predators and parasitoids of rice insect pests, In: E. A. Heinrichs, Ed., Biology and Management of Rice Insects, Wiley Eastern, New Delhi, 1994, 585. 53. Pantoja, A., C. M. Smith, and J. F. Robinson, Evaluation of rice germ plasm for resistance to the fall armyworm (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae), J. Econ. Entomol., 79:1319-1323, 1986.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
54. Phuong, L. T., L. M. Chau, and M. B. Cohen, Resistance of cultivars derived from a wide cross with Oryza officinalis to the brown planthopper in the Mekong Delta, Vietnam, Int. Rice Res. Newsl., in press. 55. Rombach, M. C., D. W. Roberts, and R. M. Aguda, Pathogens of rice insects, In: E. A. Heinrichs, Ed., Biology and Management of Rice Insects, Wiley Eastern, New Delhi, 1994, 613. 56. Sanint, L. R., Summary of technology surpluses (1994-2010) associated with new rice technologies at CIAT, Rice Program Rep., CIAT, Cali, 1993. 57. Sauphanor, B., Résistance Variétale du riz aux Insectes. Rapport d’activités: 2ème Semestre 1981 et 1er Semestre 1982, Mimeo, IRAT, Bouaké, 1982. 58. Shih, H. P., The newly found rice water weevil (Lissorhoptrus oryzophilus Kuschel) on rice plant in Taiwan, Bull. Taoyuan Dist. Agric. Improve. Stn., 7:61-67, 1991. 59. Singh, J., G. S. Dhaliwal, and G. S. Sidhu, Advances in insect resistance in rice, In: G. S. Dhaliwal and V. K. Dilawari, Eds., Advances in Host Plant Resistance to Insects, Kalyani Publishers, New Delhi, 1993, 31. 60. Smith, C. M., The rice water weevil, Lissorhoptrus oryzophilus Kuschel, In: K. G. Singh, Ed., Exotic Plant Quarantine Pests and Procedures for Introduction of Plant Materials, ASEAN (PLANTI), Selangor, 1983. 61. Smith, C. M., Integration of rice insect control strategies and tactics, In: E. A. Heinrichs, Ed., Biology and Management of Rice Insects, Wiley Eastern, New Delhi, 1994, 681. 62. Smith, C. M. and J. F. Robinson, Evaluations of rice cultivars grown in North America for resistance to the rice water weevil, Environ. Entomol., 11:334-336, 1982. 63. Smith, C. M. and J. F. Robinson, Effect of rice cultivar height on infestation by the least skipper, Ancyloxypha numitor (F.) (Lepidoptera: Hesperiidae), Environ. Entomol., 12:967-969, 1983. 64. Sohn, J. K., S. K. Lee, J. C. Koh, H. Y. Kim, S. J. Yang, H. G. Hwang, D. Y. Hwang, and G. S. Chung, A new rice cultivar with multiple resistance to diseases and insect pests “Namyeongbyeo,” Res. Rep. Rural Development Administration (Crops), 29:18-28, 1987 (in Korean with English abstract). 65. Soto, P. E. and Z. Siddiqi, Screening for resistance to African rice insects, Paper presented at the WARDA varietal improvement seminar, West Africa Rice Development Association, Bouaké, 1976, 13. 66. Tsuzuki, H. and K. Isogawa, The initial occurrence of a new rice insect pest, the rice water weevil, in Aichi Prefecture in Japan, Shokubutsu-Boeki Plant Protection, 30:341, 1976, (in Japanese). 67. Ukwungwu, M. N., Susceptibility of Rice Cultivars to the Stem Borer, Chilo zacconius Bleszynski (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae), Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Ibadan, Ibadan, 1983. 68. Ukwungwu, M. N., M. D. Winslow, and V. T. John, Severe outbreak of rice gall midge (GM) in the Savannah zone, Nigeria, Intl. Rice Res. Newsl., 14:36-37, 1989. 69. Vercambre, B., Diopsis thoracica West (Dipt. Diopsidae), Importants ravageurs du riz en Afrique de l’Ouest. Données bio-ècologiques et application à la lutte intégrée, Agronomie Trop., 37:89-98, 1982. 70. Vos, P., R. Hoges, M. Bleeka, M. Reijans, T. van de Lee, M. Homes, A. Freijters, J. Pot, T. Peleman, M. Kaiper, and M. Zabeau, AFLP: a new concept for DNA fingerprinting, Nucleic Acids Res., 23:4407-4414, 1995. 71. WARDA (West Africa Rice Development Association), Rice Trends in Sub-Saharan Africa, WARDA, BP 2551, Bouaké, 1993.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
72. Way, M. J. and K. L. Heong, The role of biodiversity in the dynamics and management of insect pests of tropical irrigated rice — a review, Bull. Entomol. Res., 84:567587, 1994. 73. Weber, G. and O. Parada, Development of integrated pest management systems for rice in Latin America, In: E. A. Heinrichs, Ed., Biology and Management of Rice Insects, Wiley Eastern, New Delhi, 1994, 733. 74. Winslow, M. D., New breakthroughs and present accomplishments in rice research in Latin America and the Caribbean, Paper IRC:94/8-1(C), In: Eighteenth Session Int. Rice Commission, FAO, Rome, 1994. 75. Wu, Jung-Tsung, E. A. Heinrichs, and F. G. Medrano, Resistance of wild rices, Oryza spp. to the brown planthopper, Nilaparvata lugens (Homoptera: Delphacidae), Environ. Entomol., 15:648-653, 1986. 76. Xizhi, L. and C. X. Mao, Hybrid Rice in China — a Success Story, Asia-Pacific Association of Agricultural Research Institutions, FAO Regional Office, Bangkok, 1994.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
2
The Value of Conserved Wheat Germplasm Evaluated for Arthropod Resistance C. Michael Smith, Sharron S. Quisenberry, and Francois du Toit
CONTENTS I. Introduction A. Origin and Domestication of Wheat B. Importance as a Food Crop C. World Production II. Development of Arthropod-Resistant Wheat Germplasm A. Germplasm Resources B. Genetic Recombination and Selection C. Identification of Cereal Resistance Genes III. The Value of Wheat Resistance to Arthropods A. Economic Value B. Ecological and Humanitarian Values IV. Future Directions for Arthropod Resistance Research V. Conclusions Acknowledgments References
I. A. ORIGIN
AND
INTRODUCTION
DOMESTICATION
OF
WHEAT
The origin of Triticum spp. wheat traces back to antiquity in several different languages. The Chinese mai, the Sanskrit sumara and godhuma, the Hebrew chittah, and the Egyptian br are all synonymous of the word wheat.26 Prehistoric wheat has been unearthed in Aggtelek, Hungary, where it is believed to have been grown and consumed during the Stone Age.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Archeological records indicate that T. monococcum L. and T. turgidum L., both ancestral species of modern bread wheat (see below), were domesticated in the Near East 9,000 years ago.126 Triticum turgidum dicoccum Schrank, another ancestral wheat species, was grown in the Near East as long as 9,500 years ago.164 Approximately 6,000 years ago, some tetraploid and diploid wheats hybridized to form currently grown hexaploid wheats (see below). This occurrence greatly broadened the growing range of wheat.164 The Chinese cultivated wheat approximately 5,000 years ago, viewing it as a gift from heaven. The historian Berosus is quoted as saying that wheat grew wild in the valleys between the Tigrus and Euphrates Rivers, the cradle of modern civilization.26 Cultivated wheats now exist in an allopolyploid series, ranging from diploid to hexaploid, in the A, B, and D genomes (sets of seven chromosomes). The analyses of these genomes pioneered by Kihara73 have been used extensively to develop a knowledge of the evolution and phylogenetic relationships among members and relatives of the tribe Triticeae. Diploid wheat, T. monococcum L. var. urartu (2N=2X=14, AA), is the probable origin of the A genome in polyploid wheats.84 The source of the B genome, although not completely defined, is thought to be T. speltoides (Tausch) Gren. Ex Richter (2N=2X=14, BB).84 The source of the D genome in polyploid wheat is T. tauschii (Coss.) Schmal. (2N=2X=14, DD).64 The development of modern bread wheat occurred as a result of at least two major evolutionary events. The first was the creation of the tetraploid wheat Triticum turgidum L. var. durum (2N=4X=28, AABB), which resulted from a cross between T. monococcum and an unknown B genome donor. Subsequently, a cross between T. turgidum (2N=4X=28, AABB) and T. tauschii (2N=2X=14, DD) created what is now common bread wheat, Triticum aestivum L. (2N=6X=42, AABBDD). The majority of wild and cultivated wheats are genetically either AA, AABB, or AABBDD, and can be classified as T. monococcum (AA), T. turgidum (AABB), or T. aestivum (AABBDD). The chromosomes of hexaploid wheat exist in seven homeologous groups. Each group has three pairs of chromosomes, one each from the A, B, and D genomes.
B. IMPORTANCE AS
A
FOOD CROP
Triticum aestivum is a cool-season cereal crop, but it is grown across the widest range of environments of any cereal crop in the world.10 Wheat is the most important cereal crop in the world as it provides more nourishment for the world’s population than any other source of nutrition.61 By the mid-1990s, wheat had become the food source of choice by the majority of the world’s population. Wheat- and grain-based diets are continually shown to be higher in fiber and lower in fats than meat-based diets. Wheat has been a major food crop in many countries for several hundred years, and it is now a competitor with rice and maize as the dominant food crop of the developing world. From 1961 to 1992, wheat experienced a 4.6% increase in use as a food crop among developing countries, compared with a 4.3% increase for maize and a 3.0% increase for rice. Per capita consumption of wheat in developing countries
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
rose from 71 kg per year from 1987 to 1989 to 75 kg per year from 1990 to 1992. Wheat use in all countries increased by 3.4% from 1993 to 1994, compared with 3.0% for maize and 2.8% for rice during the same period.29 Wheat is also used as an animal food. About one-fourth of the post-milling grain weight of wheat, which includes the bran and germ, is utilized as human and livestock food supplements. In the vegetative stage, wheat foliage can be directly grazed by livestock. Some low-grade wheat is fermented for alcohol production. Wheat gluten, a component that determines the quality of the flour obtained from the milling of wheat grains, is used to increase the total protein of baked goods, food products, and low-protein flours. Wheat starch is used for laundering, adhesives, wallpaper, and textiles.10
C. WORLD PRODUCTION More land is devoted worldwide to the production of wheat than any other commercial crop. A wheat crop is harvested somewhere in the world in every month of the year, but most harvests occur from April to September in the temperate regions of the world.9 Until the dissolution of the former Soviet Union and the formation of the European Economic Union, the USSR was the world’s leading wheat producer, with the U.S. and the People’s Republic of China ranking second and third, respectively. The People’s Republic of China is the current leading wheat producer, with a 1994/1995 harvest of 106.4 mmt.4 The European Economic Union (82.1 mmt) and the U.S. (63.2 mmt) rank second and third, respectively, in world production. The two other major world wheat producing countries are the former Soviet Union (60.1 mmt) and India (56.8 mmt).4 Because of these production rates, the continent of Asia leads world wheat production at 281.2 mmt, followed by Europe (119.9 mmt), North America (90.3 mmt), Oceania (18.1 mmt), South America (15.9 mmt), and Africa (13.1 mmt). The major world wheat exporting countries are the U.S., which exported 52% (33.1 mmt) of its 1994 wheat crop and the European Economic Union, which exported 20.1 mmt of its 1994 crop (24% of its production). Canadian producers exported 81% (18.7 mmt) and Australia producers 71% (12.8 mmt) of their 1994 wheat production.4 The principal world wheat importer is the former Soviet Union, which purchased 13.5 mmt of wheat and wheat flour in 1994.4 Other significant wheat importing countries include Japan (6.1 mmt), Egypt and Korea (5.9 mmt each), Brazil (5.8 mmt), and the People’s Republic of China (4.3 mmt). The amount of wheat and wheat flour imported by Brazil, Egypt, Japan, and Korea remained relatively constant from 1991 to 1994, while importation dropped significantly in the People’s Republic of China (73%) and the former Soviet Union (43%). Annual increases in world wheat production have fluctuated between 1.5 and 3.0% during the past 40 years, as a result of changes in human and livestock food consumption patterns, increases in the standard of living in developing countries, and the effects of abiotic and biotic stresses.115 One of the major biotic stresses affecting cultivated wheat is the feeding damage from several arthropod pests in
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
different production zones throughout the world. In this chapter, we review and discuss the germplasm resources available to improve wheat for arthropod resistance, the resistance genes that have been identified and used, the value of resistance genes, and the future directions for research to improve wheat with arthropod resistance.
II.
DEVELOPMENT OF ARTHROPOD-RESISTANT WHEAT GERMPLASM
A. GERMPLASM RESOURCES Ayad et al.6 compiled information on the 25 major collections of Triticeae germplasm throughout the world. These collections are maintained by state, national, and international institutions. Other major collections of wheat germplasm are maintained in Australia, Germany, Israel, Italy, and Japan. The largest Triticum collections are stored and maintained at the International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center (CIMMYT), El Battan, Mexico (approximately 98,905 accessions),127 the Vavilov All-Union Institute of Plant Industry, Leningrad, Russia, (approximately 70,000 accessions),6 and the U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service (USDA-ARS), National Small Grains Collection, Aberdeen, Idaho (45,997 accessions).38 The International Plant Genetic Resources Institute, Rome, Italy (formerly International Board of Plant Genetic Resources), in conjunction with the International Center for Agricultural Research in Dry Areas, initiated a database of the number, location, and condition of all existing wild Triticeae accessions.56 Over 22,000 unique accessions are maintained in 33 different countries and in an additional 25 smaller collections. A special collection is the Kansas State University Wheat Genetic Resource Center Collection of approximately 5,000 accessions of Triticeae. The species identity and country of origin are known for nearly all accessions in these collections but, in many cases, precise data on altitude of collection site and ecogeographic characteristics are not known. Only a fraction of these accessions have been evaluated for more than one arthropod pest.
B. GENETIC RECOMBINATION
AND
SELECTION
Knowledge of the genetics of arthropod resistance in wheat is facilitated by exploiting the aneuploid condition in Triticum species. Aneuploidy is an increase or decrease in the plant chromosome number from the normal 2N euploid chromosome number. The change in chromosome number may involve a single chromosome arm (telosome) change or a change in more than one chromosome. Hexaploid wheat exists in several different types of aneuploid configurations, including nullisomic (2N=40), monosomic (2N=41), disomic (2N=42), trisomic (2N=43), tetrasomic (2N=44), and a range of monosomic through tetrasomic combinations with varying numbers of chromosome arms.62 Although the generation of trisomic and tetrasomic stocks of wheat is possible, di-telosomic stocks and nullisomics with compensating tetrasomics (nuilli-tetra) stocks are used more commonly than tri- or tetrasomic stocks because of their greater vigor than nullisomics and improved specificity over monosomic stocks. Nevertheless, monosomic spring wheat
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
cultivars susceptible to the Hessian fly, Mayetiola destructor (Say), have been crossed to a disomic line to determine the chromosome(s) responsible for fly resistance.32 Monosomics produced with the “Chinese Spring” wheat cultivar have also been used to determine the chromosome location of genes for resistance to the greenbug Schizaphis graminum (Rondani), and to the Russian wheat aphid Diuraphis noxia (Mordvilko).58,122 The seven homologous sets of hexaploid wheat chromosomes have similar gene contents and can either replace or compensate for each other in combinations ranging from nullisomic to tetrasomic. Translocations involving the homologous wheat chromosome with foreign chromosomes, chromosome arms, or chromosome segments can be useful breeding events in wheat improvement. Success in moving genes from related foreign species into common wheat depends on the evolutionary distance between the two species involved.30 Species in the primary gene pool of common wheat (T. turgidum, T. monococcum, T. tauschii) share homologous chromosomes. The secondary gene pool includes polyploid Aegilops/Triticum species with at least one genome (a set of 7 chromosomes) homologous to T. aestivum or T. durum. This group includes T. timphophevii Zhuk. and species belonging to the Aegilops section Sitopsis.30 The tertiary pool consists of relatives with only a distant association whose chromosomes are not homologous to those of wheat. Meiosis centric-breakage-fusion techniques, ionizing radiation, and induced homologous recombination have been used to move chromosome arms or chromatin from tertiary gene pool donors into wheat.30 Arthropod resistance genes have been transferred from species in the primary and secondary gene pools following crossing and homologous recombination with chromosomes of agronomically superior common wheat cultivars. Backcross breeding is commonly used to select for progeny with both resistance and improved agronomic traits. Backcross breeding involves crossing the resistant progeny from each previous generation back to the same agronomically desirable parent wheat cultivar. Selection is made after each generation for arthropod resistant progeny with superior agronomic performance. Backcross breeding has been used to incorporate arthropod and disease resistance into agronomically superior wheats that were susceptible to these pests.
C. IDENTIFICATION
OF
CEREAL RESISTANCE GENES
The development and use of arthropod-resistant cultivars has long been recognized as a sound approach to wheat protection. One of the earliest uses of arthropod resistance in the U.S. was when resistant wheat cultivars were grown to protect crops in New York from infestations of the Hessian fly in 1788. Today, arthropod-resistant wheat cultivars are grown in Africa, Asia, Europe, and the U.S. Sitobion avenae — Metopolophium dirhodum — Rhopalosiphum padi Complex Resistance. Numerous sources of resistance to one or more of the aphids in the S. avenae (F.)-M. dirhodum (Walker)-R. padi (L.) complex have been identified by European researchers. Research in England identified resistance to S. avenae in the T. aestivum cultivars “Kador” and “Amigo,” and resistance to both S. avenae and M. dirhodum in the T. dicoccum cultivar “Emmer,” and in the T. monococcum cultivar
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 1 Wheat Genes Governing Resistance to Biotypes of Schizaphis graminum (Rondani) in North America Reaction to aphid biotype Source “Dickinson” “Amigo” “Largo” CI17959 CI17882 GRS 1201
Origin
Gene
B
C
E
F
G
H
I
Triticum turgidium durum Secale cereale T. tauschii T. tauschii T. speltoides S. cereale
gb1 Gb2 Gb3 Gb4 Gb5 Gb6
s r s s s r
s r r r r r
s s r r r r
r s s s s s
s s s s s r
s s r s s s
— — r r — r
r = resistant; s = susceptible.
“Einkorn.”74,136 In the Czech Republic, resistance to all three aphids was identified in “Mironovskaya 808.”52-54 In Poland, “Asta,” “Grava,” and “Sago” are resistant to S. avenae.72 In France, resistance to S. avenae was confirmed in “Mirela,” “Vala,” “Downy,” and “Kornay,” and in T. monococcum.12,19 In Hungary, several cultivars and the U.S. cultivar “Downy” are resistant to R. padi.98 Canadian research on R. padi as a vector of barley yellow dwarf mosaic virus led to the identification of a T. aestivum x Agropyron repens L. Beauv. hybrid with resistance to R. padi.146 Schizaphis graminum Resistance. Six genes have been identified with resistance to biotypes of S. graminum (Table 1). There is one recessive gene, gb1,18 and five dominant genes, designated Gb 2-6.105,148 The first S. graminum biotype, B, was named because of its ability to overcome the resistance of “Dickinson 28A,” a durum wheat that possesses gb1 and resistance to biotype A.163 Biotype B also has the ability to tolerate higher temperatures than biotype A.128 In the late 1960s, S. graminum populations became severely damaging in sorghum, Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench, producing areas of the southwestern U.S. and the sorghum biotype C developed.40 “Amigo” wheat, which possess the Gb2 gene from rye, Secale cereale L., is resistant to biotypes B and C.123 Increased insecticide usage on sorghum in Texas and Oklahoma caused the development of biotype D which is resistant to the insecticide disulfoton.102,143 During the past 20 years, several additional biotypes of S. graminum have developed. Biotype E, capable of feeding on biotype C resistant “Amigo” wheat, developed in the U.S. high plains of Texas during the 1970s. Resistance to biotypes C and E was documented in the amphiploids T. turgidum/T. tauschii “Largo” (Gb3) and T. durum/T. tauschii CI17959 (Gb4) which also possess resistance to wheat streak mosaic virus.106,149 Specific resistance to biotype E (Gb5) was identified in CI17882, whose lineage involves T. speltoides, the presumed source of resistance.148 Biotype E greenbugs exhibit normal feeding behavior and fecundity on wheat cultivars resistant to biotype B.87 Because biotype E greenbugs have comparatively higher digestive enzyme activity, they are physiologically superior to biotype C.13 Biotype F differs from biotype E in its ability to kill Canada bluegrass, Poa compressa
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 2 Development of Diuraphis noxia-Resistant Wheat in North America and South Africa, 1986–1996 Source PI137739 PI262660 SQ24 PI372129 PI294994 29 Pls PI149898 PI243781 a
Origin Iran Russia Triticum tauschii Russia Bulgaria Afghanistan, Iran, Russia Russia —
Genes Dn1 Dn2 dn3 Dn4 Dn5 ? —a Dn6
Ref. 20-22, 129 20-22, 129 89 89, 119 76 103 8 119
Resistance controlled by at least two undesignated genes.
L., and it lacks a dorsal stripe. Biotype F is also susceptible to the gb1 gene in “Dickinson 28A” wheat.65 Biotypes G and H differ in their reactions to small grain hosts.107 Biotype G survives on all known sources of resistant wheat, but is avirulent to a recently discovered source of resistance (GRS 1201), a T. aestivum /S. cereale hybrid with the Gb6 gene.104 Biotype H has the same effect on wheat cultivars as biotype E, but is avirulent to the Gb3 gene of “Largo” wheat. Biotypes I and K, new biotypes virulent to S. graminum-resistant sorghums, were detected in Kansas,41,46 and are avirulent on sources of Gb3, Gb4, and Gb6.105 Chapter 4 of this volume is a source of information on S. graminum biotypes in relation to the development of S. graminum-resistant sorghum. Diuraphis noxia Resistance. Six genes have been identified in different wheats for resistance to D. noxia (Table 2). The dominant genes Dn1 and Dn2 were identified in the hexaploid wheat plant introduction (PI) lines 137739 (Iran) and 262660 (Russia) in South Africa,20-22 and confirmed in the U.S.130 The recessive gene dn3 originates from the T. tauschii accession SQ24, a parent in the amphiploid wheat derived from crosses between T. tauschii and T. turgidum.89 Two additional dominant D. noxia resistance genes, Dn4 and Dn6, originate from a Russian T. aestivum (PI372129) and an Iranian T. aestivum (PI243781).90,119 The resistance of a Bulgarian T. aestivum (PI294994) to D. noxia is controlled by the dominant gene Dn5.20,23,78 Twenty-nine PI lines from Afghanistan, Iran, and Russia exhibited moderate to high levels of D. noxia resistance during an evaluation of more than 12,000 wheat accessions from the USDA-ARS National Small Grains Collection.103 One of the lines (PI14898) has been crossed with the susceptible hard red spring wheat “Bobwhite” to produce the germplasms “STARS-9302W” and “STARS-9303W,” which are both moderately resistant to D. noxia.8 Resistance in these germplasm releases appears to be controlled by two genes. Wheat cultivars with D. noxia resistance were grown for the first time in 1996 in the U.S. in Colorado and in the South African Free State province. The South African wheats possess the Dn1 and Dn2 genes and the Colorado cultivar “Halt” © 1999 by CRC Press LLC
contains the Dn4 gene. Additional U.S. cultivars are being bred from germplasm developed in Idaho, which also contain the Dn1 gene from PI137739 and the Dn2 gene from PI262660.137,138 Mayetiola destructor Resistance. The development of M. destructor biotypes has closely paralleled the development of Hessian fly resistant-wheat cultivars, which began in New York in the early 1900s. Hessian fly biotypes were first recognized in 1930.95 Since then, 27 different genes for M. destructor resistance have been identified in common wheat, durum wheat, T. turgidum L. var. durum, goatgrass, T. tauschii, and in S. cereale (Table 3). Genes H1-H5, the H7H8 combination, and H12 are from T. aestivum,33,93,101 while genes H6, H9-H11, H14-H20, and H27 are from T. turgidum.1,15,76,77,91,92,94,99,111,112,125,139-141 Genes H13, H22-24, and H26 are from T. tauschii,17,48,49 and genes H21 and H25 are from S. cereale.50,114 This information has been summarized by Ratcliffe and Hatchett.110 Sixteen M. destructor biotypes have been identified in field populations, and are differentiated by how various combinations of genes for virulence (the ability to overcome cereal resistance) interact with genes for resistance to M. destructor in different resistance sources.113 Virulence in an M. destructor biotype depends on the existence of the homozygous recessive condition in the virulence gene of the fly at a locus corresponding to a specific dominance gene for resistance.31 Thus, in each instance of cultivar resistance (fly avirulence), the particular fly biotype in question lacks the homozygous recessive condition at the virulence gene locus. High temperature diminishes the expression of resistance genes to some M. destructor biotypes, causing them to appear only moderately resistant.76,77,91,109,133,135,140,141,147 An alternative system of biotype nomenclature, based on fly reaction to sets of different resistance genes has been proposed,100 but this system has yet to be put into practice. The U.S. Great Plains biotype, isolated in western Kansas, carries the homozygous recessive condition for virulence only in association with “Turkey,” and lacks this condition when attempting to survive on cultivars with the H3, H5, H6, H7H8 gene combination, and H9-H19.112 Biotype A (Table 3) is similar to the Great Plains biotype, but is homozygous recessive for virulence on “Seneca” (H7H8 gene combination). Biotype B possesses an additional virulence gene capable of breaking the resistance of the H3 gene in “Monon.” Biotype C is now found infrequently in the north central U.S., but has the opposite reaction of biotype B to the H3 and H6 genes in “Monon” and “Knox 62” wheat, respectively. Biotype D, found commonly in the mid-Atlantic and northeastern U.S., is similar to biotype B, but is also virulent to the H6 gene of “Knox 62.”110,112,113 Biotype E in Georgia47 is similar to biotype C, and is nonvirulent to the H7H8 gene combination. Biotypes F and G are present in the south and southeastern U.S. and are also nonvirulent to the H7H8 gene combination.110,112,113 Biotypes J and L developed in response to the resistance from the H5 gene in “Arthur 71” are found in field populations in Indiana.110,112,113,132,134 Biotype L is now widely distributed in the midwest, mid-south, mid-Atlantic, and southeastern regions of the U.S. The H6 gene is resistant to biotype J. Numerous biotype L resistance genes have been identified in the H9, H10, and H12-27 genes.112 Current major U.S. wheat breeding efforts for M. destructor resistance are located at the University of Florida, University of Georgia, Kansas State University, and
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 3 Interaction of Cereal Genes for Resistance to M. destructor with Virulence Genes in M. destructor Biotypes Resistance gene(s), source, and cultivar, PI, or CI name None, Triticum aestivum, “Turkey” H1&H2, T. aestivum, “Dawson,” CI3342 H3, T. aestivum, Ill. #1, W-38 sel.7, CI12061 H4, T. aestivum, “Java,” CI10051 H5, T. aestivum, “Ribeiro,” PI56206-8 H6, Triticum turgidum, PI94587 H7H8 combination, T. aestivum, “Seneca” & CI12529 H9, T. turgidum, CI17714 H10, T. turgidum, CI17714 H11, T. turgidum, PI94587 H12, T. aestivum, “Lusco” H13, Triticum tauschii, HU2076 H14 & H15, T. turgidum, CI1764 H16, T. turgidum, PI94587 H17, T. turgidum, PI428435 H18, T. turgidum, CI6887 H19, T. turgidum, PI422297 H20, T. turgidum, “Jori” H21, Secale cereale, “Chaupon” H22, T. tauschii, TA1644 H23, T. tauschii, TA1642 H24, T. tauschii, TA2452 H25, S. cereale, “Chaupon” H26, T. tauschii, TA2473 H27, T. turgidum, PI422297 a
Biotype GP
A
B
C
D
E
J
L
Sa R R ? R R R
S S R ? R R S
S S S ? R R S
S S R ? R S S
S S MR ? R S S
S S S ? S R S
S R S ? S S R
S S S ? S S S
R R R R — — — — R R — — — — — — — —
R R R R — — — — R R — — — — — — — —
R R R R R R R — R R — — — — — — — —
R MR R MR R R R — R R R — — — — — — —
R R R R R R R R R R — — R R R — R —
R — R — — R R — R — — — — — — — — —
— — S — — S — — — — ? — — — — — — —
R R S MR R R R R R R — R R R R R R R
R = resistant; MR = moderately resistant; S = susceptible.
Modified from Patterson, F.L. et al., Proposed system of nomenclature for biotypes of Hessian fly (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae) in North America, J. Econ. Entomol., 85:307-311, 1992; and Ratcliffe, R.H. and J.H. Hatchett, Biology and genetics of the Hessian fly and resistance in wheat, In: New Developments in Entomology, K. Bobdari, Ed., Research Signpost, Scientific Information Guild, Trivandrum, 1997, 47. (Refs. 100 and 110)
Purdue University in conjunction with USDA-ARS scientists. The primary focus of these efforts is resistance to biotypes E and L.112 Cephus cinctus Resistance. Since 1946, 11 spring wheat cultivars with resistance to C. cinctus have been developed by North American scientists.158 Many of the first cultivars had useful levels of sawfly resistance but lacked adequate yield levels and baking qualities. Currently grown spring wheats with sawfly resistance have medium to high levels of yield, good baking quality, and disease resistance. © 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Winter wheats have recently been identified with useful levels of C. cinctus resistance.14,85 In Syria, several bread and durum wheat cultivars express resistance to C. pygmeus and Trachelus spp.83 Reduced light intensity decreases the expression of the solid stem character in resistant cultivars.116 Under field growing conditions, reduced natural light intensity, resulting from prolonged periods of cloud cover, can inhibit the full expression of the stem solidness character in some resistant cultivars. This occurrence has slowed the acceptance of some resistant cultivars by producers. Oulema melanoplus Resistance. Numerous sources of resistance to O. melanoplus have been identified in wheat. The original two sources of resistance from Russia, CI8515 and CI9321,153,157 were used as parents to develop “Downy”155 which is resistant to O. melanoplus in Hungary.97 Several additional sources of resistance to O. melanoplus also have been identified in Hungary.66,67,97 Some wheat cultivars with dense growth of long, erect trichomes deter oviposition by O. melanoplus, much more than cultivars with sparse growth of short trichomes.59,150 Eggs deposited on the trichome “field” rising above the leaf surface suffer mortality due to desiccation and puncture by trichomes.160 Larvae also die from punctures of the alimentary canal sustained after ingestion of trichome fragments.159 Some pubescent wheats also exhibit antixenosis to adults and larvae of M. destructor and R. padi.117,118 Aceria tosichilla Resistance. Resistance to A. tosichilla in cereals was first demonstrated in Triticum x Agropyron hybrids.2 The gene from Agropyron is expressed as a dominant trait and was later designated as Cmc2.162 Mite resistance from a single gene (Cmc1) from T. tauschii, also inherited as a dominant trait, was incorporated into wheat.144 Several wheats with translocations from S. cereale also effectively reduce the incidence of wheat streak mosaic virus and cultivars with this resistance are commercially available.80,81 Research in Kansas45 (Table 4) determined that sources of resistance with the Cmc1 and Cmc2 genes are resistant to A. tosichilla populations from South Dakota or Alberta, Canada, but susceptible to A. tosichilla from Kansas and Texas. Wheats with resistance originating from S. cereale are resistant to A. tosichilla from all locations, but are susceptible to A. tosichilla from Kansas adapted to and reared on the normally resistant “TAM-107”. A common wheat with D. noxia resistance (PI222655) is resistant to all A. tosichilla populations except the one from Alberta, Canada (Table 4). Resistance to A. tosichilla has also been detected in the D. noxia-resistant wheats CI9355, PI221699, PI222651, PI222661, PI222679, PI222680, and PI222682,43 and in a chromosome addition hybrid (Add 6V-1) and a chromosome substitution hybrid (Sub 6V-1) arising from wheat and the annual grass Haynaldia villosa (L.) Schur.16 In contrast to the effects of pubescence on O. melanoplus and R. padi, pubescent wheats are susceptible to infestation by A. tosichilla.42
III.
THE VALUE OF WHEAT RESISTANCE TO ARTHROPODS
A. ECONOMIC VALUE The economic benefits resulting from the production of arthropod-resistant wheat cultivars are quite significant in production agriculture. Wheat resistance research
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 4 Interactions Between Genes in North American Wheat Germplasm and Virulence Genes in Aceria tosichilla Mite colony collection site Plant source Aegilops squarrosa Agropyron elongatum Secale cereale (PI475772) S. cereale (TAM-107) Triticum aestivum (PI222655)c T. aestivum (“Tomahawk”) a b c
Kansas
Kansasa
Texas
South Dakota
Alberta, Canada
Sb S R R R S
S S S S R S
S S R R R S
R R R R R S
R R R R S S
Kansas mite colony reared on TAM-107 extensively before bioassay. Susceptibility and resistance based on numbers of mites per plant. Resistant to D. noxia.
From Harvey, T.L. et al., Survival of five wheat curl mite, Aceria tosichilla Keifer (Acari: Erophyidae), Strains on mite resistant wheat, Exp. Appl. Acarol., 19:459-463, 1995. With permission.
provides a substantially greater return for each dollar invested in development, compared with research to develop chemical insecticides or miticides. In the late 1960s, several U.S. wheat cultivars developed with resistance to M. destructor returned approximately $600 on each U.S. dollar invested in cultivar research, compared with a $5 return on each dollar spent on the development of insecticides during the same period, a 120-fold greater return on investment.96 The following section documents the economic benefit of varietal resistance in wheat to several arthropod pests. S. avenae-M. dirhodum-R. padi Complex. The aphids R. padi, S. avenae, and M. dirhodum cause significant wheat yield reductions as they inject salivary enzymes into plants and remove nutrients during feeding. Sitobion avenae is considered the major aphid pest of small cereal grains in central and western Europe,12,55,121 whereas R. padi is considered the cereal aphid of greatest economic significance in Canada, southeastern Europe, and Scandinavia.69,98,146 In the U.S., wheat seedlings infested with R. padi and S. avenae suffer 57 and 13% reductions in kernel weight, respectively.63 Resistance to these aphids is yet to be incorporated into European wheat production on a large scale, and economic data on the value of the resistance identified is unavailable. Schizaphis graminum. Greenbug damage to wheat is well documented in Brazil, Chile, Pakistan, and the U.S.39,51,108,145 Numerous severe S. graminum outbreaks have occurred on wheat, barley Hordeum vulgare L., oats Avena sativa L., and sorghum in several U.S. production areas since 1949. The value of yield losses in U.S. wheat production related to S. graminum infestation and feeding from 1951 to 1960 was estimated at 1.4% of the total crop.70 Based on a 1993 wheat crop value of $7.6 billion © 1999 by CRC Press LLC
(U.S.),4 this loss would exceed $106 million. The incorporation of the multibiotype S. graminum-resistant germplasm GRS1201 into locally adapted cultivars should be worth over $20 million annually in the states of Kansas, Texas, and Oklahoma alone.154 Diuraphis noxia. Russian wheat aphid reduces wheat yield by direct feeding damage, but is an inconsequential vector of wheat diseases. Damaged wheat plants react to injection of D. noxia saliva by rolling the leaves longitudinally around the main leaf vein to form a tubular refuge for feeding aphids. In addition to removal of plant sap that weakens plants and lowers grain yield, prolonged infestations cause emerging panicles to be partially trapped in the leaf sheath, resulting in a “goose neck”-shaped panicle and substantially reduced grain yields.151 Diuraphis noxia is a primary pest of wheat in Mexico, South Africa, and Lesotho, and in the northwestern Great Plains of the U.S.35,86,151 With its rapid spread into several previously uninfested areas of the world, D. noxia has caused significant economic losses to wheat production. The cumulative losses to all U.S. small grain production for D. noxia control, yield losses, and lost community economic activity from 1986 to 1993 was valued at $850 million.71 Insecticide applications were reduced by approximately 50% when “Halt,” the first U.S. D. noxia-resistant wheat cultivar, was produced in Colorado during 1996 on approximately 1.13 million ha. This resulted in a savings to wheat producers of approximately $14 million.165 In the Free State province of South Africa, D. noxia-related yield losses of approximately 5% of the annual crop area (525,000 ha) are approximately $6.8 million (U.S.), and insecticidal control of the aphid ($13.30 per ha) costs producers an additional $7 million, for a total of $13.8 million for annual D. noxia control. In 1996, approximately 9.6% of the total crop was planted to resistant cultivars. Thus, the estimated value of D. noxia resistance in 1996 was 9.6% of the total $13.8 million control costs, or $1.33 million. Six resistant cultivars have been released for production thus far, but five of these have been marketed for only 1 to 2 years. The area planted to D. noxia-resistant cultivars is expected to increase dramatically during the next 5 years, and should exceed 50% of the total wheat area by the year 2000. Use of resistant cultivars should increase the annual value of D. noxia resistance to nearly $7 million.166 Mayetiola destructor. Hessian fly is distributed throughout North America, Europe, North Africa, and Russia.27,28 The economic importance of this insect is related to larval feeding damage between the plant leaf sheath and plant stem, which stunts wheat seedling growth and causes plant death or reduces the grain yield in surviving plants. Larval feeding affects approximately 50% of the U.S. crop every year, causing about $100 million in damage.70,113 Damage from M. destructor feeding on wheat in various states in the U.S. varies between years and geographic locations. In Georgia in 1989, damage was estimated to be $28 million,60 while yield losses in Texas in 1984 were estimated at over $5 million.57 As mentioned previously, extensive research in the U.S. on the gene for gene interaction between M. destructor and fly-resistant cereal germplasm has led to the development and release of many fly-resistant wheats since the mid 1960s. These cultivars were developed because of the pervasive distribution of M. destructor on wheat in the soft wheat region of the eastern U.S. Hessian fly damage claimed 1.5% © 1999 by CRC Press LLC
of the annual U.S. wheat crop from 1951 to 1960, a loss of approximately $114 million, based on the 1993 wheat crop value.4 The current value of M. destructor resistance in wheat compensates for much of the loss estimate, because of the positive effects that resistant cultivars have had during the past 25 years. Between 1950 and 1983, 60 different M. destructor-resistant cultivars were released.51 By 1984, over 10 million ha of fly-resistant wheats were planted in 30 different states in the U.S.124 The value of M. destructor resistance in the southeastern U.S. is beginning to be recognized. Survey and loss data developed by the Georgia Agricultural Experiment Station documented that the use of M. destructor-resistant cultivars from 1990 to 1994 decreased fly damage 69% compared with losses incurred from 1985 to 1989. Conversely, wheat yields increased by 24% from 1985 to 1994 as the percentage of resistant cultivars increased from 5 to 90%. The approximate value of M. destructor resistance in Georgia, caused by reduced yield losses and insecticide applications, is approximately $7 million.11 In South Carolina, annual M. destructor management costs have declined from $12 million to $200,000 since the establishment of an M. destructor management program which uses resistant cultivars.154 Of the cultivars grown in the north central and southeastern U.S. during the past decade, 60 to 80% have possessed some level of resistance to M. destructor. Had these resistance genes been highly durable, their value would have been worth more than $50 million annually. However, biotype L now dominates that area of U.S. wheat production, and is virulent to all of the M. destructor resistance genes in commercial wheats grown there. Until cultivars with biotype L resistance are grown on a large scale in north central and southeastern U.S., yield losses due to M. destructor feeding may reoccur, especially when fly populations reach economically damaging levels. Mayetiola destructor severely reduced wheat production in Morocco during the late 1980s.27 Since then, a 14-year Morocco–U.S. cooperative research effort has led to the development and release of 32 lines of bread wheat with M. destructor resistance. Of these, 27 are Moroccan bread wheats. The benefit to cost ratio of this research has been estimated at 9:1.7 Thus, every Moroccan dirham invested in this research yielded an average return of 9 dirhams for society. Cephus cinctus. Wheat stem sawfly occurs in the northern Great Plains, damaging wheat in the U.S. states of North Dakota and Montana and the Canadian provinces of Alberta, Manitoba, and Saskatchewan.158 Grain yield is reduced from the effects of larvae feeding inside the plant stem during development, which restricts nutrient flow to grain heads. Larval feeding also weakens the stems and causes them to lodge, which further reduces grain yield. Estimated C. cinctus-related yield losses to wheat in North Dakota and Montana exceed $10 million in some years.70 In 1989, a severe infestation in central Montana caused estimated wheat yield losses of 80%. Similar losses have been reported in the Canadian provinces affected by C. cinctus. The European wheat stem sawfly, C. pygmeus (L.), and two related sawflies Trachelus judaicus (Kônow) and T. libanensis (André), frequently damage cereal grains in North Africa and western Asia.82 Although no current estimates are available, the annual value of C. cinctus resistance in Montana in 1948 was estimated at $3.8 million.3 If conservative (3.5%) annual inflationary estimates are used to amplify this figure,
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
the current annual value of C. cinctus resistance is greater than $15 million in Montana. Oulema melanoplus. Cereal leaf beetle damages wheat and other small grains by skeletoning leaves, which reduces the grain yield of infested plants.161 The range of this insect extends throughout Europe, into the Caucasian area of Russia and into western North Africa and the Middle East.152 This insect was first noted in the U.S. in Michigan wheat plantings in 1959, and has since extended its range into wheatproducing states of the eastern and central U.S. An O. melanoplus population has recently been detected much farther west, in Idaho.167 Populations of O. melanoplus in the U.S. are currently below economic damage levels and widespread population outbreaks have not occurred in several years.154 However, wheat grain losses resulting from past O. melanoplus infestations have approached 55% in spring wheat156 and 23% in winter wheat.34 In field studies comparing resistant and susceptible cultivars under O. melanoplus infestation, yield losses of susceptible cultivars ranged from 17 to 25%, while the yield of resistant cultivars was not reduced.155 Several parasitic insects have played a major role in reducing O. melanoplus populations since the resistant cultivars were released,68 and there have been no major efforts to demonstrate the economic value of O. melanoplus resistance. Aceria tosichilla. Aceria toschilla is a native pest of North American grasslands and causes major annual losses in wheat yields. Mites feed and lay eggs on the upper leaf surfaces of wheat plants. As the mite infestation increases, damaged leaves curl toward the midvein, often preventing new leaves or grain heads from emerging and elongating. This mite is important because it is the primary vector for wheat streak mosaic virus (WSMV),129 an important disease of wheat in Europe, North America, and Asia, which periodically causes severe yield losses.131 Estimates of yield losses from WSMV infection during severe virus outbreaks range from 37% in Canada to 13% in Kansas.5,44,79 The average estimated yield loss attributed to WSMV in Kansas from 1976 to 1996 was 2%.168 The development of genetic resistance to A. tosichilla in Canada and the U.S. has provided substantial monetary savings to agricultural producers in the form of increased wheat yields and decreased production costs for miticides. Mite resistance in commercial cultivars reduces the incidence of WSMV, preventing approximately three-fourths of the virus losses incurred in A. tosichilla-susceptible cultivars. Using 1993 crop values and production figures,4 this amounts to a current annual value of more than $150 million (U.S.) for A. tosichilla resistance in North American wheats. Combined Value of Arthropod Resistance in Wheat. The economic value of genetic resistance in wheat for all of the arthropod pests discussed above amounts to just over $250 million (U.S.) each year (Table 5). This includes $20 million for S. graminum resistance, $12.9 million for D. noxia resistance, $50 million for M. destructor resistance, $15.7 million for C. cinctus resistance, and $151.8 million for A. tosichilla resistance. All of these values are gross values, without the addition of any economic multiplier effects. Frequently, the use of multiplier effects will double or triple the value of a cost or a savings in the economics of agricultural productivity.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 5 Global Economic Value of Arthropod-Resistant Wheat Arthropod pest
Approximate value ($U.S. million)
Schizaphis graminum Diuraphis noxia Mayetiola destructor Cephus cinctus Aceria tosichilla Total value
B. ECOLOGICAL
AND
20.0 12.9 50.0 15.7 151.8 250.4
HUMANITARIAN VALUES
In addition to the significant economic advantages mentioned previously, ecological and environmental benefits arise from the use of arthropod-resistant wheat cultivars. Populations of beneficial insects and microorganisms increase in the agroecosystem when pesticide use is reduced, as does species diversity. With reduced pesticide applications, wheat in the vegetative growth stage is safer for livestock grazing and for use as habitat by game birds. The environmental benefits of producing wheat using arthropod resistance instead of pesticides include cleaner soils and ground water supplies. A significant reduction in insecticide use on U.S. wheat is envisaged with greater use of resistant cultivars, as was estimated to have occurred with the use of arthropod-resistant cultivars of barley, corn, and sorghum.120 In at least one instance, the value of arthropod resistance in wheat has humanitarian value. In South Africa, D. noxia-resistant wheat cultivars have been given to farmers in Lesotho, where wheat production had been severely disrupted by D. noxia damage and civil strife. Farmers renamed the cultivar “Puseletso,” meaning “that which has been returned to us,” and wheat production in Lesotho has been reestablished.166
IV.
FUTURE DIRECTIONS FOR ARTHROPOD RESISTANCE RESEARCH
Molecular marker techniques are being used more frequently in the development of pest-resistant wheat. One technique, restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis, is based on inherent variations in the sites where restriction endonucleases cut DNA. RFLP analysis makes use of genetic markers derived from cloned DNA fragments to analyze different fragment lengths as alleles of particular genes. Once arthropod resistance genes are shown to be associated (linked) with an RFLP marker, selection for these genes can be based on the genotype of the RFLP marker, rather than the plant phenotype. The marker can then be used to assess plant populations segregating for resistance before the phenotypic trait for resistance is expressed. This process can greatly accelerate the rate of breeding for arthropod-
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
resistant plants.142 There is a substantial need for improved techniques to access linked traits associated with resistance to arthropods and other pests. Current research is limited in the use of the tertiary germplasm pool, where genetic recombination is restricted for the non-homologous chromosomes transferred in T. aestivum.30 Using RFLP analysis, high-density genetic maps are being constructed by entomologists, geneticists, and plant breeders to locate genes of economic value, including arthropod and disease resistance genes, that flank DNA markers. An extensive library of DNA markers has been developed for wheat and related cereal crops in the Kansas State University Wheat Generic Resource Center.37 Several of these markers have already been used to map the RFLP linkage locations of genes for resistance to A. tosichilla, D. noxia, and M. destructor.16,24,25,36,75,88
V.
CONCLUSIONS
Pronounced economic and environmental accomplishments have resulted from the cooperative efforts of entomologists, geneticists, and plant breeders who have used the genetic diversity of wild Triticum and closely related species to develop arthropodresistant wheats during the past 40 years. From a strictly economic perspective, the current value of this resistance is more than $250 million (U.S.) each year. The ecological value of this resistance has not been rigorously assessed, but the cultivation of arthropod-resistant cultivars has greatly decreased pesticide usage in the U.S. This decline in pesticide use has contributed to a healthier environment for humans, livestock, and wildlife. Wheat producers have benefitted from arthropod-resistant cultivars in the form of reduced production costs, and consumers have benefitted because their food has been produced more economically and safely. Although many arthropod-resistant cultivars have been developed, research and development must continue to maintain the benefits of this resistance in global food production. Researchers and extension educators must continue to monitor the development of virulence genes in newly developing biotypes of wheat arthropod pests. Where possible, accurate, efficient, and economical techniques based on molecular genetic markers must be developed and implemented to monitor biotypes. The pools of resistance genes available to researchers to breed into wheat cultivars that succumb to these new biotypes must be increased. This will require sustained or enhanced funding for collection, curation, and evaluation of germplasm to identify these genes. Additional efforts should be made to identify resistance where it is lacking, or where it has been identified, to breed it into an existing cultivar. Acceptance and use of the resistance identified to R. padi and S. avenae should be undertaken by producers in areas, especially Europe, where these pests cause significant losses to wheat production. Significant levels of resistance to M. dirhodum are yet to be identified. This and other voids should challenge researchers and their supporting government or donor constituents to cooperatively develop this resistance and place it into production. Whether they are developing new resistant cultivars or improving existing ones, researchers must continue to identify wheat germplasm with arthropod resistance, from both conventional and transgenic sources. A large amount of germplasm
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
remains to be evaluated. Only a modest percentage of the more than 300 species of Triticeae have been evaluated for arthropod resistance. Those evaluated include A. elongatum, S. cereale, T. speltoides, T. tauschii, and T. turgidium, some very rich sources of resistance. However, many opportunities await the interdisciplinary research efforts of entomologists, geneticists, molecular biologists, and plant breeders to identify additional resistance genes. Wheat is a food that is critical to the survival of the world population. With the human population predicted to double to over 10 billion people by 2040, it is essential that global wheat production be increased to meet this need. Arthropod-resistant wheat cultivars should be integral components of that production system because of their proven economic and environmental benefits. A continual development of arthropod-resistant cultivars depends heavily on the availability of diverse, wellmaintained collections of Triticeae adequately supported by local, regional, national, and international funding.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors thank Roger Ratcliffe and Edward Souza for their reviews and suggestions to improve the chapter.
REFERENCES 1. Amri, A., T. S. Cox, B. S. Gill, and J. H. Hatchett, Chromosomal location of the Hessian fly resistance gene H20 in 'Jori' durum wheat, J. Hered., 81:71-72, 1990. 2. Andrews, J. E. and J. T. Slykhuis, Reaction of winter wheat cultivars and Triticum X Agropyron hybrids when inoculated with streak mosaic virus by the mite vector Aceria tulipae, Plant Dis. Rep., 40:513-516, 1956. 3. Anonymous, The wheat stem sawfly in Montana, Mimeo. Rep. Mont. Agric. Exper. Stn. Extn. Serv., Bozeman, 1946. 4. Anonymous, Agricultural Statistics 1995-96, Wheat, National Agricultural Statistics Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Washington, D. C., 1996. 5. Atkinson, T. G. and M. N. Grant, An evaluation of streak mosaic losses in winter wheat, Phytopathol., 57:188-192, 1967. 6. Ayad, G., J. Toll, and J. T. Williams, Directory of Germplasm Collections, III. Cereals 1. Wheat, International Board for Plant Genetic Resources, Rome, 1980. 7. Azzam, A., S. Azzam, S. Lhaloui, A. Amri, M. El Bouhssini, and M. Moussaoui, Economic returns to research in Hessian fly (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae) resistant breadwheat varieties in Morocco, J. Econ. Entomol., 90:1-5, 1997. 8. Baker, C. A., D. R. Porter, and J. A. Webster, Registration of STARS-9302W and STARS-9303W, Russian wheat aphid resistant germplasms, Crop Sci., 34:1135-1136, 1994. 9. Briggle, L. W., Origin and botany of wheat, In: E. Hafliger, Ed., Wheat, Documenta Ciba-Gigey, Basel, 1980, 6. 10. Briggle, L. W. and B. C. Curtis, Wheat worldwide, In G. E. Heyne, Ed., Wheat and Wheat Improvement, Agron. Monograph 13, ASA, CSSA, & SSSA, Madison, 1987, 1.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
11. Buntin, G. D. and R. D. Hudson, Small grain insects, In: G. K. Douce and R. M. McPherson, Eds., Summary of Losses from Insect Damage and Costs of Control in Georgia, 1984-94, Georgia Agricultural Experiment Station Special Publication, Athens, 1995, 1. 12. Caillaud, C. M., C. A. Dedryver, and J. C. Simon, Development and reproductive potential of the cereal aphid Sitobion avenae on resistant wheat (Triticum monococcum), Ann. Appl. Biol., 125:219-232, 1994. 13. Campbell, B. C. and D. L. Dreyer, Host-plant resistance of sorghum: differential hydrolysis of sorghum pectic substance by polysaccharases of greenbug biotypes (Schizaphis graminum, Homoptera: Aphididae), Arch. Biochem. & Physiol., 2:203-215, 1985. 14. Carlson, G. R., P. L. Bruckner, J. E. Berg, G. D. Kushnak, D. M. Wichman, J. L. Eckhoff, K. A. Tilley, G. F. Stallknecht, R. N. Stougaard, H. H. Bowman, W. C. Morrill, G. A. Taylor, and E. A. Hockett, Registration of “Vanguard” wheat, Crop Sci., 37:291, 1997. 15. Carlson, S. K., F. L. Patterson, and R. L Gallun, Inheritance to Hessian fly derived from Triticum turgidum L., Crop Sci., 18:1011-1014, 1978. 16. Chen, Q., R. L. Conner, and A. Laroche, Molecular characterization of Haynaldia villosa chromatin in wheat lines carrying resistance to wheat curl mite colonization, Theor. Appl. Genet., 93:679-684, 1996. 17. Cox, T. S. and J. H. Hatchett, Hessian fly-resistance gene H26 transferred from Triticum tauschii to common wheat, Crop Sci., 34:958-960, 1994. 18. Curtis, B. C., A. M. Schlehuber, and E. A. Wood, Jr., Genetics of greenbug (Toxoptera graminum (Rond.)) resistance in two strains of common wheat, Agron. J., 52:599-602, 1960. 19. DiPetro, J. P. and C. A. Dedryver, Relations entre les pucerons des céréales et leurs plantes-hôtes. 1. Mise au point d'une methodologie de recherche de resistance à Sitobion avenae F. chez differents cultivars de blé d'hiver, Agronomie, 6:469-479, 1986. 20. du Toit, F., Resistance in wheat (Triticum aestivum) to Diuraphis noxia (Hemiptera: Aphididae), Cereal Res. Comm., 15:175-179, 1987. 21. du Toit, F., Another source of Russian wheat aphid (Diuraphis noxia) resistance in Triticum aestivum, Cereal Res. Comm., 16:105-106, 1988. 22. du Toit, F., Inheritance of resistance in two Triticum aestivum lines to Russian wheat aphid (Homoptera: Aphididae), J. Econ. Entomol., 82:1251-12153, 1989. 23. du Toit, F., W. G. Wessels, and G. F. Marais, The chromosome arm location of the Russian wheat aphid resistance gene, Dn5, Cereal Res. Comm., 23:15-17, 1995. 24. Dweikat, I., H. Ohm, S. MacKenzie, F. Patterson, S. Cambron, and R. Ratcliffe, Association of a DNA marker with Hessian fly resistance gene H9 in wheat, Theor. Appl. Genet., 89:964-968, 1994. 25. Dweikat, I., H. Ohm, F. Patterson, and S. Cambron, Identification of RAPD markers for 11 Hessian fly resistance genes in wheat, Theor. Appl. Genet., 94:491-423, 1997. 26. Edgar, W. C., The Story of a Grain of Wheat, D. Appleton & Co., New York, 1903, 195. 27. El Bouhssini, M., M. A. Amri, and J. H. Hatchett, Wheat genes conditioning resistance to the Hessian fly (Diptera: Cecidoymiidae) in Morocco, J. Econ. Entomol., 81:709-712, 1988.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
28. Everson, E. H. and R. L. Gallun, Breeding approaches in wheat, In: F. G. Maxwell and P. R. Jennings, Eds., Breeding Plants Resistant to Insects, Wiley, New York, 1980, 513. 29. FAO Agrostat/PC Production, Trade, and Utilization Statistics, Diskettes, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome, 1995. 30. Friebe, B., J. Jiang, W. J. Raupp, R. A. McIntosh, and B. S. Gill, Characterization of wheat-alien translocations conferring resistance to diseases and pests: current status, Euphytica, 91:59-87, 1996. 31. Gallun, R. L., The genetic basis of Hessian fly epidemics, Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci., 278:223-229, 1977. 32. Gallun, R. L. and F. L. Patterson, Monosomic analysis of wheat for resistance to Hessian fly, J. Hered., 68:223-226, 1977. 33. Gallun, R. L. and L. P. Reitz, Wheat cultivars resistant to races of Hessian fly, Production Research Report No.134, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, Washington, D. C., 1971, 1. 34. Gallun, R. L., R. T. Everly, and W. T. Yamazaki, Yield and milling quality of Monon wheat damaged by feeding of the cereal leaf beetle, J. Econ. Entomol., 60:365-369, 1967. 35. Gilchrist, L. I., R. Rodriguez, and P. A. Burnett, The extent of Freestate streak and Diuraphis noxia in Mexico, Proc. Barley Yellow Dwarf Workshop, CIMMYT, El Battan, 1984, 157. 36. Gill, B. S., J. H. Hatchett, and W. J. Raupp, Chromosomal mapping of Hessian fly-resistance gene H13 in the D genome of wheat, J. Hered., 78:97-100, 1987. 37. Gill, G. S., E. L. Lubbers, W. J. Raupp, and T. S. Cox, A genetic linkage map of Triticum tauschii (DD) and its relationship to the D genome of bread wheat, Genome, 34:362-374, 1991. 38. GRIN (Genetic Resources Information Network), United States Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, on the World Wide Web (http://www.arsgrin.gov/ars/PacWest/Aberdeen/nsgc.html), 1997. 39. Hamid, S., Natural balance of graminocolous aphids on Pakistan: survey of populations, Agronomie, 3:665-673, 1983. 40. Harvey, T. L. and H. L. Hackerott, Recognition of a greenbug biotype injurious to sorghum, J. Econ. Entomol.,62:776-779, 1969. 41. Harvey, T. L., K. D. Kofoid, T. J. Martin, and P. E. Sloderbeck, A new greenbug biotype virulent to E-biotype resistant sorghum, Crop Sci., 31:1689-1691, 1991. 42. Harvey, T. L. and T. J. Martin, Effects of wheat pubescence on infestations of wheat curl mite and incidence of wheat streak mosaic, J. Econ. Entomol.,73:225-227, 1980. 43. Harvey, T. L. and T. J. Martin, Resistance to the wheat curl mite (Acari, Eriophyidae) in common wheat, Cereal Res. Comm., 20, 63-66, 1992. 44. Harvey, T. L., T. J. Martin, and D. L. Seifers, Importance of plant resistance to insect and mite vectors in controlling virus diseases of plants: resistance to the wheat curl mite (Acari: Eriophyidae), J. Agr. Entomol.,11:271-277, 1994. 45. Harvey, T. L., T. J. Martin, and D. L. Seifers, Survival of five wheat curl mite, Aceria tosichilla Keifer (Acari: Erophyidae), strains on mite resistant wheat, Exp. Appl. Acarol., 19:459-463, 1995. 46. Harvey, T. L., G. E. Wilde, and K. D. Kofoid, Designation of a new greenbug biotype, biotype K, injurious to resistant sorghum, Crop Sci., 37:989-991, 1997. 47. Hatchett, J. H., Race E, sixth race of the Hessian fly, Mayetiola destructor, discovered in Georgia wheat fields, Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am., 62:677-678, 1969.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
48. Hatchett, J. H. and B. S. Gill, Expression and genetics of resistance to Hessian fly in Triticum tauschii (Coss) Schmal, In: S. Sakamoto, Ed., Proc. 6th Int. Wheat Genetics Symp., Kyoto, 1983, 807. 49. Hatchett, J. H., T. J. Martin, and R. W. Livers, Expression and inheritance of resistance to Hessian fly in synthetic hexaploid wheats derived from Triticum tauschii (Coss) Schmal., Crop Sci., 21:731-734, 1981. 50. Hatchett, J. H., R. G. Sears, and T. S. Cox, Inheritance of resistance to Hessian fly in rye and in wheat rye translocation lines, Crop Sci., 33:730-734, 1993. 51. Hatchett, J. H., K. J. Starks, and J. A. Webster, Insect and mite pests of wheat, In G. E. Heyne, Ed., Wheat and Wheat Improvement, Agron. Monograph 13, ASA, CSSA, & SSSA, Madison, 1987, 625. 52. Havlickova, H., Reproduction of cereal aphids on two cultivars of winter wheat, Sbor. UVTIZ-Ochr. Rostl., 22:223-229, 1986. 53. Havlickova, H., Behavior and reproduction of cereal aphids in relation to changes in the content of water and free amino acids in wheat during the growing season, J. Appl. Ent., 103:142-147, 1987. 54. Havlickova, H., Unvernalized seedlings in screening of cereal aphid preferences for winter wheat cultivars, J. Appl. Ent., 106:432-436, 1988. 55. Havlickova, H., Level and nature of the resistance to the cereal aphid, Sitobion avenae (F.), in thirteen winter wheat cultivars, J. Agron. Crop. Sci., 171:133-137, 1993. 56. Hodgkin, T., Y. J. Adham, and K. S. Powell, A preliminary survey of wild Triticum and Aegilops species in the world's genebanks, Hereditas, 116:155-162, 1992. 57. Hoelscher, C. E., H. A. Turney, and M. C. Kidell, Hessian fly in Texas wheat, Texas Agri. Ext. Ser., Bull. 518, Texas A&M University, College Station, 1987. 58. Hollenhorst, M. M. and L. R. Joppa, Chromosomal location of genes for resistance to greenbug in 'Largo' and 'Amigo' wheats, Crop Sci., 23:91-93, 1983. 59. Hoxie, R. P., S. G. Wellso, and J. A. Webster, Cereal leaf beetle response to wheat trichome length and density, Environ. Entomol., 4:365-370, 1975. 60. Hudson, R. D., G. D. Buntin, and D. J. Isenhour, Small grain insects, In: G. K. Douce and R. M. McPherson, Eds., Summary of Losses from Insect Damage and Costs of Control in Georgia, 1989, Georgia Agricultural Experiment Station Special Publication 70, Athens, 1991. 61. Johnson, V. A., L. W. Briggle, J. D. Axtell, L. F. Bouman, E. R. Leng, and T. H. Johnson, Grain crops, In: M. Milner, Ed., Protein Resources and Technology, AVI Publ. Co., Westport, 1978, 239. 62. Joppa, L. R., Aneuploid analysis in tetraploid wheat, In: G. E. Heyne, Ed., Wheat and Wheat Improvement, Agron. Monograph 13, ASA, CSSA, & SSSA, Madison, 1987, 255. 63. Kieckhefer, R. W. and B. H. Kantack, Losses in yield in South Dakota caused by cereal aphids, J. Econ. Entomol.,73:582-585, 1980. 64. Kimber, G. and E. R. Sears, Evolution in the genus Triticum and the origin of cultivated wheat, In: G. E. Heyne, Ed., Wheat and Wheat Improvement, Agron. Monograph 13, ASA, CSSA, & SSSA, Madison, 1987, 154. 65. Kindler, S. D. and S. M. Spomer, Biotypic status of six greenbug (Homoptera: Aphididae) isolates, Environ. Entomol., 15:567-572, 1986. 66. Kolarov, J., Resistance of different wheats to the cereal leaf beetle, Cereal Res. Com., 16:19-23, 1988. 67. Kolarov, J. and D. Boyadjieva, Inheritance of trichome density and length in T. aestivum L. hybrids, Proc. Intl. Symp. on Wheat Breeding Prospects and Approaches, Albena, 1990, 184.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
68. Lampert, E. P., D. L. Haynes, A. J. Saywer, D. P. Jokinen, S. G. Wellso, R. L. Gallun, and J. J. Roberts, Effects of regional releases of resistant wheats on the population dynamics of the cereal leaf beetle (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae), Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am., 76:972-980, 1983. 69. Leather, S. R., K. F. A. Walters, and A. F. G. Dixon, Factors determining the pest status of the bird cherry-oat aphid, Rhopalosiphum padi (L.) (Hemiptera: Aphididae), in Europe: a study and review, Bull. Ent. Res., 79:345-360, 1989. 70. LeClerg, E. L., H. T. Cook, C. D. Van Hauweling, R. J. Anderson, A. M. Vance, K. Dorwood, and H. R. Thomas, Injurious Crop Insects, Losses in Agriculture, Agriculture Handbook No. 291, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, Washington, D.C., 1965, 43. 71. Legg, D. and S. Amosson, Economic impact of the Russian wheat aphid in the western United States:1991-1992, Great Plains Agr. Council Publication 147, Colorado State University Cooperative Extension, Fort Collins, 1993. 72. Leszczynski, B., Winter wheat resistance to the grain aphid Sitobion avenae (Fabr.) (Homoptera, Aphididae), Insect Sci. Applic., 8:251-254, 1987. 73. Lilenfield, F. A. and H. Kihara, Genome-analysis in Triticum and Aegilops. Concluding Review, Cytologia, 16:101-123, 1951. 74. Lowe, H. J. B., Resistance and susceptibility to colour forms of the aphid Sitobion Avenae in spring and winter wheats (Triticum aestivum), Ann. Appl. Biol., 99:87-98, 1981. 75. Ma, Z.-Q., B. S. Gill, M. E. Sorrells, and S. D. Tanksley, RFLP markers linked to Hessian fly-resistance genes in wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) from Triticum tauschii (Coss.) Schmal., Theor. Appl. Genet., 85:750-754, 1993. 76. Maas, F. B. III, F. L. Patterson, J. E. Foster, and J. H. Hatchett, Expression and inheritance of resistance of 'Marquillo' wheat to Hessian fly biotype D, Crop Sci., 27:49-52, 1987. 77. Maas, F. B. III, L. Patterson, J. E. Foster, and H. W. Ohm, Expression and inheritance of resistance of ELS 6404-160 durum wheat to Hessian fly, Crop Sci., 29:23-28, 1989. 78. Marais, G. F. and F. du Toit, A monosomic analysis of Russian wheat aphid resistance in the common wheat PI294994, Plant Breed., 111:246-248, 1993. 79. Martin, T. J., T. L. Harvey, G. G. Bender, and D. L. Seifers, Control of wheat streak mosaic virus with vector resistance in wheat, Phytopathol., 74:963-964, 1984. 80. Martin, T. J., T. L. Harvey, G. C. Bender, D. L. Seifers, and J. H. Hatchett, Wheat curl mite resistant wheat germplasm, Crop Sci., 23:809, 1983. 81. Martin, T. J., T. L. Harvey, and R. W. Livers, Resistance to wheat streak mosaic virus and its vector, Aceria tulipae, Phytopathology, 66:346-349, 1976. 82. Miller, R. H., Insect pests of wheat and barley in West Asia and North Africa, ICARDA Tech. Manual No. 9, Rev.1, ICARDA, Aleppo, 1987. 83. Miller, R. H., S. El Masri, and K. Al Jundi, Plant density and wheat stem sawfly (Hymenoptera: Cephidae) resistance in Syrian wheats, Bull. Ent. Res., 83:95-102, 1993. 84. Monte, J. V., C. L. McIntyre, and J. P. Gustafson, Analysis of phytogenetic relationship in the Triticeae using RFLP’s, Theor. Appl. Genet. 86:649-655, 1993. 85. Morrill, W. L., J. W. Gabor, E. A. Hockett, and G. D. Kushnak, Wheat stem sawfly (Hymenoptera: Cephidae) resistance in winter wheat, J. Econ. Entomol., 85:2008-2011, 1992. 86. Morrison, P., Current distribution and economic impact, In: F. B. Peairs and S. D. Pilcher, Eds., Proc. 2nd Russian Wheat Aphid Workshop, Denver, 1988, 5.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
87. Niassy, A., J. D. Ryan, and D. C. Peters, Variations in feeding behavior, fecundity, and damage of biotypes B and E of Schizaphis graminum (Homoptera:Aphididae) on three wheat genotypes, Environ. Entomol., 16:1163-1168, 1987. 88. Nieto-Lopez, R. M. and T. K. Blake, Russian wheat aphid resistance in barley: inheritance and linked molecular markers, Crop Sci., 34:655-659, 1994. 89. Nkongolo, K. K., J. S. Quick, A. E. Limin, and D. B. Fowler, Sources and inheritance of resistance to Russian wheat aphid in Triticum species and Triticum tauschii, Can. J. Plant Sci.,71:703-708, 1991. 90. Nkongolo, K. K., J. S. Quick, W. L. Meyers, and F. B. Peairs, Russian wheat aphid resistance of wheat, rye, and triticale in greenhouse tests, Cereal Res. Comm., 17:227-232, 1989. 91. Obanni, M., H. W. Ohm, J. E. Foster, and F. L. Patterson, Genetics of resistance of PI 422297 durum wheat to the Hessian fly, Crop Sci., 29:249-252, 1989. 92. Obanni, M., F. L. Patterson, J. E. Foster, and H. W. Ohm, Genetic analyses of resistance of durum wheat PI 428435 to the Hessian fly, Crop Sci., 28:223-226, 1988. 93. Oellerman, C. M., F. L. Patterson, and R. L. Gallun, Inheritance of resistance in ‘Lusco’ wheat to Hessian fly, Crop Sci., 23:222-224, 1983. 94. Ohm, H. W., R. H. Ratcliffe, F. L. Patterson, and S. E. Cambron, Resistance to Hessian fly conditioned by genes H19 and proposed gene H27 of durum wheat line PI422297, Crop Sci., 37:113-115, 1997. 95. Painter, R. H., Biological strains of Hessian fly, J. Econ. Entomol., 23:322-326, 1930. 96. Painter, R. H., Crops that resist insects provide a way to increase world food supply, Kansas State Agric. Exp. Stn. Bull. 520, Kansas State University, Manhattan, 1968. 97. Papp, M., Resistance of winter wheat cultivars to the cereal leaf beetle (Oulema melanoplus L.) and bird cherry oat aphid (Rhopalosiphum padi L.), Novenytermeles, 39:11-22, 1990. 98. Papp, M. and A. Mesterhazy, Resistance to bird cherry-oat aphid (Rhopalosiphum padi L.) in winter wheat varieties, Euphytica, 67:49-57, 1993. 99. Patterson, F. L., J. E. Foster, and H. W. Ohm, Gene H16 in wheat for resistance to Hessian fly, Crop. Sci., 28:652-654, 1988. 100. Patterson, F. L., J. E. Foster, H. W. Ohm, J. E. Hatchett, and P. L. Taylor, Proposed system of nomenclature for biotypes of Hessian fly (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae) in North America, J. Econ. Entomol., 85:307-311, 1992. 101. Patterson, F. L. and R. L. Gallun, Inheritance of resistance of Seneca wheat to race E of Hessian fly, In: E. R. Sears and L. M. Sears, Eds., Proc., 4th Int. Wheat Genetics Symp., Missouri Agricultural Experiment Station, Columbia, 1973, 445. 102. Peters, D. C., E. A. Wood, Jr., and K. J. Starks, Insecticide resistance in selections of the greenbug, J. Econ. Entomol., 75:339-340, 1975. 103. Porter, D. R., J. A. Webster, and C. A. Baker, Detection of resistance to Russian wheat aphid in hexaploid wheat, Plant Breed., 110:157-160, 1993. 104. Porter, D. R., J. A. Webster, R. L. Burton, G. L. Puterka, and E. L. Smith, New sources of resistance to greenbug in wheat, Crop Sci., 31:1502-1504, 1991. 105. Porter, D. R., J. A. Webster, and B. Friebe, Inheritance of greenbug biotype G resistance in wheat, Crop Sci., 34:625-628, 1994. 106. Porter, K. B., G. L. Peterson, and O. Vise, A new greenbug biotype, Crop Sci., 22:847-850, 1982. 107. Puterka, G. J., D. C. Peters, D. L. Kerns, J. E. Slosser, L. Bush, D. W. Worrall, and R. W. McNew, Designation of two new greenbug (Homoptera: Aphididae) biotypes G and H, J. Econ. Entomol., 81:1754-1759, 1988.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
108. Ramirez, I. A., A review of barley yellow dwarf in the Southern cone countries of South America, In: P. A. Burnett, Ed., World Perspectives on Barley Yellow Dwarf, CIMMYT, El Battan, 1990, 362. 109. Ratanatham, S. and R. L. Gallun, Resistance to Hessian fly (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae) in wheat as affected by temperature and larval density, Environ. Entomol.,15:305-310, 1986. 110. Ratcliffe, R. H. and J. H. Hatchett, Biology and genetics of the Hessian fly and resistance in wheat, In: K. Bobdari, Ed., New Developments in Entomology, Research Signpost, Scientific Information Guild, Trivandrum, 1997, 47. 111. Ratcliffe, R. H., H. W. Ohm, F. L. Patterson, and S. E. Cambron, Biotype composition of Hessian fly (Diptera: Cecidomiidae) populations from Arkansas, Georgia, Illinois, North Carolina and Virginia, J. Entomol. Sci., 32:154-164, 1997. 112. Ratcliffe, R. H., H. W. Ohm, F. L. Patterson, S. E. Cambron, and G. G. Safranski, Response of resistance genes H9 -H19 in wheat to Hessian fly (Diptera: Cecidomiidae) laboratory biotypes and field populations from the eastern United States, J. Econ. Entomol., 89:1309-1317, 1996. 113. Ratcliffe, R. H., G. C. Safranski, F. L. Patterson, H. W. Ohm, and P. L. Taylor, Biotype status of Hessian fly (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae) populations from the eastern United States and their responses to 14 Hessian fly resistance genes, J. Econ Entomol., 87:1113-1121, 1994. 114. Raupp, W. J., A. Amri, J. H. Hatchett, B. S. Gill, D. L. Wilson, and T. S. Cox, Chromosomal location of Hessian fly-resistance genes H22, H23, and H24 derived from Triticum tauschii in the D-genome of wheat, J. Hered.,84:142-145, 1993. 115. Rejesus, R. M., The world wheat situation, CIMMYT World Wheat Facts and Trends Supplement, 1995, Ongoing Research at CIMMYT: Understanding Wheat Genetic Diversity and International Flows of Genetic Resources, CIMMYT, El Battan, 1995. 116. Roberts, D. W. A. and C. Tyrrell, Sawfly resistance in wheat. IV. Some effects of light intensity on resistance, Can. J. Plant Sci., 41:457-465, 1961. 117. Roberts, J. J. and J. E. Foster, Effect of leaf pubescence in wheat on the bird cherry oat aphid (Homoptera: Aphidae), J. Econ. Entomol., 76:1320-1322, 1983. 118. Roberts, J. J., R. L. Gallun, F. L. Patterson, and J. E. Foster, Effects of wheat leaf pubescence on the Hessian fly, J. Econ. Entomol., 72:211-214, 1979. 119. Saidi, A. and J. S. Quick, Inheritance and allelic relationships among Russian wheat aphid resistance genes in winter wheat, Crop Sci., 36:256-258, 1996. 120. Schalk, J. M. and R. H. Ratcliffe, Evaluation of ARS program on alternative methods of insect control: host plant resistance to insects, Bull. Entomol. Soc. Am., 22:1-7, 1976. 121. Schepers, A., Chemical control, In: A. K. Minks and P. Harrewijn, Eds., Aphids, Their Biology, Natural Enemies and Control, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989, 89. 122. Schroeder-Teeter, S., R. S. Zemetra, D. J. Schotzko, C. M. Smith, and M. Rafi, Monosomic analysis of Russian wheat aphid (Diuraphis noxia) resistance in Triticum aestivum line PI137739, Euphytica, 74:117-120, 1994. 123. Sebesta, E. E. and E. A. Wood, Jr., Transfer of greenbug resistance from rye to wheat with x-rays, Agron. Absts., 61-62, 1978. 124. Seigenthaler, V. L., J. E. Stepanich, and L. W. Briggle, Distribution of the Varieties and Classes of Wheat in the United States, 1984, Crops Branch, Estimates Division, Statistical Reporting Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture Statistics Bull. 739, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., 1986. 125. Shands, R. G. and W. B. Cartwright, A fifth gene conditioning Hessian fly response in common wheat, Agron. J., 45:302-307, 1953.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
126. Simmons, S. R., Growth, development and physiology, In G. E. Heyne, Ed., Wheat and Wheat Improvement, Agron. Monograph 13, ASA, CSSA, & SSSA, Madison, 1987, 77. 127. SINGER (System-wide Information Network on Genetic Resources), Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research, on the World Wide Web (http://nocl.cgiar.org/cgintrus.htm), 1996. 128. Singh, S. R. and E. A. Wood, Jr., Effect of temperature on fecundity of two strains of the greenbug, J. Econ. Entomol., 56:l09-110, 1963. 129. Slykhuis, J. T., Aceria tulipae Keifer (Acarina: Eriophyidae) in relation to the spread of wheat streak mosaic, Phytopathology, 45:116-128, 1955. 130. Smith, C. M., D. J. Schotzko, R. S. Zemetra, E. J. Souza, and S. SchroederTeeter, Identification of Russian wheat aphid (Homoptera: Aphididae) resistance in wheat, J. Econ. Entomol., 84:328-332, 1991. 131. Smith, K. M., A Textbook of Plant Virus Diseases, Academic Press, New York, 1972. 132. Sosa, O., Jr., Biotype L, ninth biotype of the Hessian fly, J. Econ. Entomol., 71:458-460, 1978. 133. Sosa, O., Jr., Hessian fly: resistance of wheat as affected by temperature and duration of exposure, Environ. Entomol., 8:280-281, 1979. 134. Sosa, O., Jr., Biotypes J and L of the Hessian fly discovered in an Indiana wheat field, J. Econ. Entomol., 74:180-182, 1981. 135. Sosa, O., Jr. and J. E. Foster, Temperature and the expression of resistance in wheat to the Hessian fly, Environ. Entomol., 5:333-336, 1976. 136. Sotherton, N. W. and H. F. van Emden, Laboratory assessments of resistance to the aphids Sitobion avenae and Metopolophium dirhodum in three Triticum species and two modern wheat cultivars, Ann. Appl. Biol., 101:99-107, 1982. 137. Souza, E., J. M. Windes, S. S. Quisenberry, D. J. Schotzko, P. F. Lamb, S. Halbert, R. S. Zemetra, and C. M. Smith, Registration of Idaho 471A and Idaho 471B wheat germplasms, Crop Sci., 37:1031, 1997. 138. Souza, E., J. M. Windes, S. S. Quisenberry, D. J. Schotzko, P. F. Lamb, S. Halbert, R. S. Zemetra, and C. M. Smith, Registration of Idaho 472 wheat germplasm, Crop Sci., 37:1032, 1997. 139. Stebbins, N. B., F. L. Patterson, and R. L. Gallun, Interrelationships among wheat genes for resistance to Hessian fly, Crop Sci., 2:177-180, 1980. 140. Stebbins, N. B., F. L. Patterson, and R. L. Gallun, Interrelationships among wheat genes H3, H6, H9, and H10 for Hessian fly resistance, Crop Sci., 22:1029-1032, 1982. 141. Stebbins, N. B., F. L. Patterson, and R. L. Gallun, Inheritance of resistance of PI 94587 wheat to biotypes B and D of Hessian fly, Crop Sci., 23:251-253, 1983. 142. Tanksley, S. D., N. D. Young, A. H. Paterson, and M. W. Bonierbale, RFLP mapping in plant breeding: new tools for an old science, Biotechnol., 7:257-263, 1989. 143. Teetes, G. L., C. A. Schaefer, J. R. Gipson, R. C. McIntyre, and E. E. Latham, Greenbug resistance to organophosphorous insecticides on the Texas high plains, J. Econ. Entomol., 68:214-216, 1975. 144. Thomas, J. B. and R. L. Conner, Resistance to colonization by the wheat curl mite in Aegilops squarrosa and its inheritance after transfer to common wheat, Crop Sci., 26:527-530, 1986. 145. Tonet, G. L. and R. F. P. Dasilva, Antibiosis of wheat genotypes to C-biotypes of Schizaphis graminum (Rondani, 1852) (Homoptera, Aphididae), Pesquisa Agr. Brasil, 29:1181-1186, 1994. 146. Tremblay, C., C. Cloutier, and A. Comeau, Resistance to the bird cherry-oat aphid, Rhopalosiphum padi L. (Homoptera: Aphididae) in perennial gramineae and wheat x perennial gramineae hybrids, Environ. Entomol.,18:921-932, 1989.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
147. Tyler, J. M. and J. H. Hatchett, Temperature influence on expression of resistance to Hessian fly (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae) in wheat derived from Triticum tauschii, J. Econ. Entomol.,76:323-326, 1983. 148. Tyler, J. M., J. A. Webster, and O. G. Merkle, Designations for genes in wheat germplasm conferring greenbug resistance, Crop Sci., 27:526-527, 1987. 149. Tyler, J. M., J. A. Webster, and E. L. Smith, Biotype E greenbug resistance in wheat streak mosaic virus-resistant wheat germplasm lines, Crop Sci., 25:686-688, 1985. 150. Wallace, L. E., F. H. McNeal, and M. A. B. Berg, Resistance to both Oulema melanoplus and Cephus cinctus in pubescent-leaved and solid stemmed wheat selections, J. Econ. Entomol., 67:105-110, 1974. 151. Walters, M. C., F. Penn, F. du Toit, T. C. Botha, K. Aalbersberg, P. H. Hewitt, and S. W. Broodryk, The Russian wheat aphid, farming in South Africa, Leaflet Series, Wheat C3, Government Printer, Pretoria, 6, 1980. 152. Webster, J. A., The cereal leaf beetle in North America: breeding for resistance in small grains, Ann. N. Y. Acad. Sci., 287:230-237, 1977. 153. Webster, J. A., S. H. Gage, and D. H. Smith, Jr., Suppression of the cereal leaf beetle with resistant wheat, Environ. Entomol., 2:1089-1091, 1973. 154. Webster, J. A. and P. Kenkel, Benefits of managing small grain pests with plant resistance, In: J. A. Webster and B. R. Wiseman, Eds., Economic, Environmental, and Social Benefits of Insect Resistance in Field Crops, Thomas Say Publications, Entomological Society of America, Lanham, in press. 155. Webster, J. A., D. H. Smith, Jr., and R. P. Hoxie, Effect of cereal leaf beetle on the yields of resistant and susceptible winter wheat, Crop Sci., 22:836-840, 1982. 156. Webster, J. A., D. H. Smith, Jr., and C. Lee, Reduction in yield of spring wheat caused by cereal leaf beetles, J. Econ. Entomol., 65:832-835, 1972. 157. Webster, J. A., D. H. Smith, Jr., E. Rathke, and C. E. Cress, Resistance to cereal leaf beetle in wheat: density and length of leaf-surface pubescence in four wheat lines, Crop Sci., 15:199-202, 1975. 158. Weiss, M. J. and W. L. Morrill, Wheat stem sawfly (Hymenoptera: Cephidae) revisited, Amer. Entomol., 38:241-245, 1992. 159. Wellso, S. G., Cereal leaf beetle: larval feeding, orientation, development, and survival on four small-grain cultivars in the laboratory, Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am., 66:1201-1208, 1973. 160. Wellso, S. G., Cereal leaf beetle: interaction with and ovipositional adaptation to a resistant wheat, Environ. Entomol.,8:454-457, 1979. 161. Wellso, S. G., Cereal leaf beetle (Coleoptera: Chrysomelidae) and winter wheat: host plant resistance relationships, Great Lakes Entomol., 19:193-197, 1986. 162. Whelan, E. D. and G. E. Hart, A spontaneous translocation that transfers wheat curl mite resistance from decaploid Agropyron elongatum to common wheat, Genome, 30:289-292, 1988. 163. Wood, E. A., Jr., Biological studies of a new greenbug biotype, J. Econ. Entomol., 54:1171-1173, 1961. 164. Zohary, D. and M. Hopf, Domestication of Plants in the Old World, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1993. 165. Peairs, F.B., Personal communication, 1996. 166. du Toit, F., unpublished data. 167. Sandvol, L.E., Personal communication, 1997. 168. Bowden, R.L., Personal communication, 1997.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
3
Insect Resistance in Barley Germplasm David R. Porter, Dolores W. Mornhinweg, and James A. Webster
CONTENTS I. Introduction II. The Barley Crop A. History B. Importance C. Germplasm Resources III. Pests of Barley A. Pest Status B. Sources of Resistance 1. Diuraphis noxia 2. Schizaphis graminum 3. Rhopalosiphum padi 4. Oulema melanopus 5. Other Pests IV. Conclusions References
I.
INTRODUCTION
Barley, Hordeum vulgare L., germplasm collections have long played a crucial role in providing valuable genes for breeding pest-resistant, high-performance cultivars. Continuous improvement in yield and quality of barley cultivars is dependent on the availability and judicious use of the diverse genetic resources found in our national and international germplasm collections. Increasing genetic diversity within commercial cultivars could promote the expansion of production potential through enhanced adaptation and tolerance to biotic and abiotic stresses. However, by its very nature, the process of developing new barley cultivars has resulted in a narrowing of the genetic base that is now available to producers. The number of alleles of commonly studied loci encountered in samples of H. vulgare ssp. spontaneum K. Koch, the progenitor of cultivated barley, decreased dramatically in the progression from primitive materials to the most advanced modern cultivars.1 Repeated
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
cycles of selection for specific quality traits under limited environments, within existing adapted germplasm, have produced narrow pools of elite barley genotypes.49 The challenges and potential dangers of limited genetic variability in cultivated crops is not a new concern. The northern corn leaf blight (caused by Helminthosporium turcicum Pass) that reduced U.S. corn production in the 1970s is a classic example of the consequences of over-reliance on a very narrow gene base. Lack of genetic diversity for pest resistance in commercial barley cultivars limits the potential for expansion of current production areas into regions where insect pests are problematic. In addition, present production areas are being threatened by new pests (e.g., Russian wheat aphid, Diuraphis noxia [Mordvilko]). Currently, almost half of the total U.S. malting barley production is limited to three midwestern states, namely Minnesota, North Dakota, and South Dakota.50 Two cultivars, “Stander” and “Robust,” account for approximately 75% of the acreage planted to malting barley in these states.2 This spatially and genetically concentrated production of malting barley could be vulnerable to new pests. It might be possible to expand barley’s production area beyond the regions where it is now grown if the crop were more pest-resistant. For example, D. noxia has severely impacted feed barley production in eastern Colorado. All commercially available barleys are susceptible to D. noxia, and the low profit margin of feed barley production restricts the use of insecticides. Because damaging populations of D. noxia are now common in eastern Colorado, feed barley production acreage has declined 90% in this area.59 The development and use of D. noxia-resistant barleys would reclaim this lost production area. This chapter will focus on the use of germplasm collections for the enhancement of pest resistance in barley. Specifically, we review barley history and importance, germplasm resources, pests of barley, and successes in identifying and developing pest-resistant germplasm lines and cultivars.
II.
THE BARLEY CROP
A. HISTORY The origin of barley, one of the oldest domesticated crops, is thought to be in the Fertile Crescent area of the Near East.20 Early Egyptians believed the goddess Isis gave them barley, and thus it was the first grain used for food.21 Based on the oldest evidence available, it was not until about 8000 B.P. that barley was used for brewing alcoholic beverages.19 Beer made from fermented barley figured prominently in the commerce of ancient Egypt, where it was sold for local consumption and even exported. Many ancient civilizations viewed fermented beverages as sources of supernatural powers, and drunkenness was considered a religious experience.19 The importance of barley as food continues to take a lesser role and today it is more often used in malt production and livestock feed.41 Barley under domestication is divided into two types: two-rowed forms (primitive condition) in which only the central spikelet at each node of the inflorescence rachis is fertile and six-rowed forms in which all three spikelets are fertile.43,58 Mature barley spikes can be erect or nodding; dense or lax; awnleted, awnless, or hooded;
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
and hulled or hull-less (naked).43 Primitive hulled barleys were probably cultivated by 9000 B.P. in the Near East.58 Today, hulled two-rowed and hulled six-rowed barleys are widely grown.
B. IMPORTANCE Barley is the world’s fourth most important cereal after wheat Triticum aestivum L., maize Zea mays L., and rice Oryza sativa L.40 However, barley’s economic impact is much greater if its value to the brewing industry is considered. In 1995, Canada was the largest single producing country with 11.7 mmt.41 Europe and the former Soviet Union account for 68% of the total world production of 161 mmt. In the U.S., the 1995 value of barley production ($1.0 billion) made it the fifth most important cereal behind maize ($23.1 billion), wheat ($9.7 billion), rice ($1.5 billion), and sorghum, Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench, ($1.4 billion). The 1994 U.S. per capita consumption of malt-equivalent barley food products was 772 g compared with 65 kg of wheat flour. Of the total U.S. supply of barley in 1994 (12.6 mmt), approximately 48% was used for animal feed; 38% for food, alcohol, and seed; and 14% for export.41
C. GERMPLASM RESOURCES Major Hordeum seed collections are maintained by the U.S. Department of Agriculture-Agricultural Research Service (USDA-ARS), National Small Grains Collection (NSGC), Aberdeen, Idaho; the International Center for Agricultural Research in the Dry Areas (ICARDA), Aleppo, Syria; and the International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center (CIMMYT), El Battan, Mexico. The U.S. collection has grown steadily from the initial introduction of four accessions in 189436 to the USDA collection at Aberdeen, Idaho, with over 30,000 plant introduction (PI) accessions from 20 Hordeum species (see Chapter 12 in this volume). This collection contains cultivars, advanced germplasm lines, landraces, and genetic stocks, with some dating back to 1900. Extensive collections from other countries are obtained through plant explorations and through exchanges with national and international germplasm repositories. The U.S. barley collection at Aberdeen, Idaho, is an active collection, compared with the long-term storage collection at the USDA-ARS National Seed Storage Laboratory, Fort Collins, Colorado. Other countries (e.g., England, Russia, Germany, Brazil, The Netherlands, Bulgaria, and Czech Republic) also store and maintain large collections of barley germplasm. ICARDA maintains a collection of over 22,000 accessions and CIMMYT has a collection of over 9,000 barleys.45
III.
PESTS OF BARLEY
A. PEST STATUS Over 100 species of insects attack barley,48 most of which are occasional pests that cause economic damage during outbreaks. For example, the army cutworm, Euxoa auxiliaris (Grote), is an occasional pest in the U.S., but it can devastate barley fields © 1999 by CRC Press LLC
in outbreak years.48 In contrast, the primary pest D. noxia causes serious economic losses every year throughout much of the barley-producing areas of the western U.S. The bird cherry-oat aphid, Rhopalosiphum padi L., is not a primary pest in the U.S., but is one of the most severe pests in spring barley in northern Europe.57 Aphids are the most important pests of barley. These insects puncture the leaves and feed in the phloem. The Russian wheat aphid, greenbug Schizaphis graminum (Rondani), and bird cherry-oat aphid are considered the most serious aphid pests in North America. In some European countries the corn leaf aphid, Rhopalosiphum maidis (Fitch), is considered the most serious pest, causing up to 35% annual yield loss.51 The greenbug was the most serious insect pest of barley in North America until the Russian wheat aphid appeared in the 1980s.48 Diuraphis noxia has caused over $1 billion (U.S.) in losses in the western U.S. since it was detected in Texas in 1986.39 Economic losses caused by S. graminum are not well documented, but this aphid and R. padi are more damaging on spring barley than are R. maidis and the English grain aphid, Sitobion avenae F.26 In addition to removing essential plant nutrients, some aphids are vectors of plant viruses. Rhopalosiphum padi is often considered to be problematic only through its ability to vector barley yellow dwarf virus (BYDV), but its feeding damage can cause up to 50% yield loss in the absence of BYDV.26
B. SOURCES
OF
RESISTANCE
Diuraphis noxia, S. graminum, and R. padi have received the most attention with regard to identifying sources of plant resistance and developing resistant germplasm. Each of these aphids will be discussed individually, along with research on cereal leaf beetle Oulema melanopus L., Hessian fly Mayetiola destructor Say, R. maidis, and grasshoppers Melanoplus spp. 1. Diuraphis noxia The USDA collection has been a valuable source of germplasm in the search for pest-resistant material, most recently for D. noxia.52 All U.S. barley cultivars in production were highly susceptible to D. noxia when this aphid was detected in the southern Great Plains in 1986. Early attempts to find resistance among greenbugresistant barleys were unsuccessful.55 Efforts to find resistant barley germplasm commenced when 524 USDA accessions, originating from regions where barley and D. noxia coexist, were evaluated in greenhouse tests.52 From this research and further analysis of the categories of resistance (antibiosis, antixenosis, and tolerance) of resistant plants, five resistant accessions from Afghanistan (PIs 366444, 366447, 366449, 366450, and 366453) and one from Iran (CI1412) were identified (Table 1).52 Progeny of resistant plants selected from screening tests were used as parents in a resistance breeding program. From this work, one highly resistant accession (PI366450, collected by J. D. Gray in 1965) was selected and used in an accelerated germplasm enhancement program. It was necessary to select for homogeneity of resistance within PI366450 because this accession was heterogeneous for
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 1 Evaluation of Barley Genetic Resources for Insect Resistance No. of entries Insect Diuraphis noxia Russian wheat aphid Schizaphis graminum Greenbug Rhopalosiphum padi Bird cherry-oat aphid Oulema melanopus Cereal leaf beetle Mayetiola destructor Hessian fly Rhopalosiphum maidis Corn leaf aphid Melanoplus spp. Grasshoppers
Screened
Resistant
Ref.
524 111 23,070 577 1,230 1,005 474 500 172 8,634 5,114
6 15 109 194 160 15 41 29 6 17 33
52 5 33 12 9 54 24,25 57 16 15 22
121
7
23
32
8
29
D. noxia resistance. This selection resulted in the release of STARS-9301B, the first D. noxia-resistant barley germplasm.31 Genetic analysis of the resistance in STARS9301B indicated control by two genes, Dnb1 and Dnb2.32 Specifically, D. noxia resistance is expressed through recessive epistasis of the dominant gene Dnb2 on the incompletely dominant gene Dnb1. Multiple gene control also has been reported for STARS-9577B, a D. noxia-resistant germplasm line selected from CIho 4165 (USDA accession from Afghanistan).33 Analysis of D. noxia resistance in PI366444 and PI366453 indicated that at least two resistance genes are shared or tightly linked in both lines.37 Molecular marker analysis located one of the genes in the short arm of chromosome 5.37 Barley germplasm accessions have been evaluated under field conditions. Out of 111 spring barleys artificially infested with D. noxia, 15 entries were classified as resistant (Table 1).5 Two of these resistant lines, ASE/2CM//B76BB and “Gloria/Come,” underwent further analysis to determine the genetic control of resistance.44 Although studies indicated that the same dominant gene controls resistance in ASE/2CM//B76BB and “Gloria/Come,”44 it is not known if this gene is the same as Dnb1 or Dnb2 in STARS-9301B or a different gene.34 Cultivars developed using these resistance genes are at potential risk from new introductions of D. noxia or genetic recombinations within existing U.S. populations that produce plant resistance-breaking biotypes. Thus, when Puterka et al.42 discovered that PI366450 was susceptible to a D. noxia population from Iachmen, Kyrgyzstan, a
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
search for additional sources of resistance was started. After screening the entire USDA collection of available H. vulgare ssp. vulgare accessions (23,070), 109 accessions were rated resistant to moderately resistant to D. noxia (Table 1).33 In addition, evaluations of accessions of wild Hordeum species revealed substantial inter- and intraspecific variability for resistance to D. noxia.10,27 Further research showed that the presence of clavicipitaceous endophytic fungi (Neotyphodium) in some of these wild Hordeum accessions was responsible for high levels of resistance to D. noxia.11 Transfers of D. noxia resistance from slender wheatgrass, Elymus trachycaulus Link, into H. vulgare produced resistant hybrids that may be useful in backcrossing.4 Thus, genetic diversity for D. noxia resistance exists in conserved germplasm. 2. Schizaphis graminum In the U.S., a greenbug outbreak in 1942 caused significant yield losses to small grains (estimated at $38 million) and precipitated interest in the development of resistant cultivars.3 By chance, S. graminum colonized two barley nurseries in Denton, Texas, and Lawton, Oklahoma, and differential S. graminum damage among nursery cultivars from China and Korea indicated the potential for host plant resistance. Subsequently, screenings of 577 germplasm lines identified S. graminum resistance in 194 accessions, including the Korean landrace “Omugi” (PI87181) (Table 1).12 Genetic analysis indicated that a single dominant gene controls resistance in PI87181.17 The S. graminum-resistant barleys “Kerr” and “Will” were developed using two different sources of S. graminum resistance, one from PI87181 and one from “Kearney,” respectively.30 The cultivar “Kerr” was developed in 1952 by crossing PI87181 with “Rogers.”14 Greenbug resistance in “Will” is likely from “Kearney,” a Nebraska S. graminum-resistant winter barley selected from Composite Cross III (CCIII) in 1941 and released in 1951. The source of the S. graminum resistance gene in CCIII is unknown; this population was developed by intercrossing 13 winter and spring cultivars in all combinations and was released in 1931.35 Genetic analysis of PI87181, “Kearney,” and two other S. graminum-resistant barleys (“Dobaku” and CIho 5087) indicated that the same dominant gene controls resistance in all four lines.47 It is quite possible that the resistance gene (Rsg1a)30 in PI87181 was common among many of the landraces of southeast Asia, specifically east-central China and Korea, collected during 1929 to 1930. The presence of the same gene in “Kearney” resulted because the 13 cultivars (e.g., “Everest,” “Esaw,” “Nakano Wase,” and “Smooth Awn 86”) used in the development of CCIII were collected from Asia or had Asian cultivars in their pedigree.3 The resistance gene Rsg1a was made available in sets of S. graminum-resistant and -susceptible nearisolines in 1988.6 Today, these near-isolines are being used for molecular genetic analysis of the S. graminum resistance.60 The chain of events highlighted above demonstrates the value of conserved germplasm and its use in pest resistance efforts. A landrace of winter barley collected in Korea over 67 years ago provided a gene that has saved U.S. producers countless dollars in pesticide applications, and now is the focus of experiments to better
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
understand the nature of plant resistance to insects. The entire collection of winter barleys, totaling 1,230 accessions, was screened in 1961 and 160 accessions with S. graminum resistance were identified, some more resistant than PI87181 (Table 1).9 The occurrence of new S. graminum biotypes, which can damage previously resistant germplasm, has prompted searches for new sources of resistance. For example, the advent of greenbug biotype E in the U.S. prompted a 1981 search of the USDA collection which identified 15 accessions with varying levels of resistance (Table 1).54 A different gene (Rsg2b) is responsible for the resistance in one line (PI426756).30 Also, resistance to S. graminum has been detected in H. chilense,8 and wheat/H. chilense disomic addition lines have been analyzed to locate the resistance genes on chromosomes.7 These lines may be useful in providing sources of S. graminum resistance for cultivated barley in the future. Efforts to produce S. graminum-resistant cultivars, such as “Tambar 402,”18 “Tambar 500,”28 and “Post,”13 have used PI87181 (“Omugi”) and “Will” as the sources of the aphid resistance. 3. Rhopalosiphum padi Barley resistance to R. padi protects plants from direct feeding damage and may reduce the incidence of BYDV by reducing feeding of viruliferous aphids. Screening of 474 barley cultivars from the Canadian Genetic Stock of Barley showed 41 selections with tolerance and antibiosis resistance to R. padi (Table 1).24,25 In addition, two of the aphid-resistant selections (“Rojo” and CI3906-1) exhibited BYDV resistance.24 However, none of the 474 cultivars in the collection showed very high levels of aphid resistance, and only 43 selections (9%) were considered sources of resistance for breeding purposes.25 Use of these resistant selections to develop R. padi-resistant barley cultivars has not been reported. Hordeum species other than cultivated barley (H. vulgare ssp. vulgare) have been evaluated as potential sources of resistance to R. padi. Testing of a Swedish collection of 27 accessions of Hordeum species and interspecific hybrids (crosses between H. vulgare ssp. vulgare and related Hordeum species) showed significant differences in the ability of aphids to reproduce when feeding on the different species.56 A diploid species, H. bogdani Wilenski, had very high levels of resistance, but genetic incompatibilities between this species and H. vulgare make it difficult to transfer the resistance to cultivated barley. In addition, a collection of 500 accessions of H. vulgare ssp. spontaneum K. Koch from Israel was evaluated under natural infestations of R. padi in Sweden, and 29 resistant selections were reevaluated in greenhouse tests (Table 1).57 Two of the resistant selections were crossed with cultivated barley and some of the progeny were more resistant than the resistant parents. Efforts to produce R. padi-resistant barley cultivars using these resistance sources are ongoing.57 4. Oulema melanopus The search for cereal leaf beetle resistance began in 1963 when 172 cultivars of barley were field screened for resistance to adult and larval feeding (Table 1).16 Over
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
94% of the entries were moderately or severely damaged. In a subsequent screening of 8,634 accessions from the USDA collection, less than 1% were resistant to larval feeding damage.15 In contrast to yield losses of up to 38% for susceptible cultivars, two resistant accessions (CI6671 and CI6469) produced high yields in beetle-infested plots.53 These two resistant accessions were used as parents in a breeding program to produce two improved O. melanopus-resistant spring barley germplasms, CI15820 and CI15821.46 However, Oulema melanopus-resistant cultivars have not been made available to producers. 5. Other Pests Extensive screening of the USDA barley collection has identified resistance to other insect pests, such as M. destructor, R. maidis, and Melanoplus spp. The bulk of the USDA collection (5,114 accessions) was evaluated for M. destructor resistance from 1945 to 1950.22 Of the total accessions tested, 7 accessions were highly resistant and 26 moderately resistant to M. destructor (Table 1).22 Genetic analysis of three highly resistant cultivars, “Delta,” “Nile,” and “Abusir,” indicated that two dominant genes (Hf and Hf2) control resistance to M. destructor.38 Cultivars with resistance to M. destructor have not been released to the barley industry. A screening of 121 winter barley cultivars for R. maidis resistance detected high levels of resistance in seven entries (Table 1).23 Unfortunately, two of the resistant entries (“Davie” and “Rogers”) from this study are susceptible to S. graminum. Another line in this study (PI87181) was susceptible to corn leaf aphid, but is resistant to greenbug. These differential plant responses indicate that different genes control resistance to the two aphid species.23 Rhopalosiphum maidis-resistant barley cultivars are not available. Melanoplus spp.-resistant cultivars were discovered under natural infestations in Canadian field tests from 1944 to 1947 (Table 1).29 We are unaware of any followup research on barley resistance to Melanoplus spp.
IV.
CONCLUSIONS
Germplasm repositories have a rich history of providing new sources of barley resistance to insect pests. Seed from the unpretentious barley plant, gathered by intrepid collectors from isolated areas, is often a treasure-trove of genetic resources. All that is required to uncover these assets is a reliable bioassay for screening tests, a focused approach to systematically evaluating a large number of accessions, and perseverance from dedicated entomologists and plant breeders. History shows that resistance has been found in H. vulgare ssp. vulgare L. accessions for every pest studied to date. However, if levels of resistance identified in cultivated barley types are not high enough to be useful in a resistance breeding program, then searches of other Hordeum species should proceed. This chapter shows that the world’s Hordeum germplasm stocks are a source of strong resistance to barley pests.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
REFERENCES 1. Allard, R. W., Methods for germplasm identification, In: H.T. Stalker and J.P. Murphy, Eds., Plant Breeding in the 1990s, C.A.B. International, Wallingford, 1991, 122. 2. Anonymous, Barley Variety Survey, American Malting Barley Association, Inc., Milwaukee, 1996. 3. Atkins, I. M. and R. G. Dahms, Reaction of small-grain varieties to greenbug attack, USDA Tech. Bull. 901, 1945. 4. Aung, T., Intergeneric hybrids between Hordeum vulgare and Elymus trachycaulus resistant to Russian wheat aphid, Genome, 34:954-960, 1991. 5. Calhoun, D. S., P. A. Burnett, J. Robinson, and H. E. Vivar, Field resistance to Russian wheat aphid in barley: I. symptom expression, Crop Sci., 31:1464-1467, 1991. 6. Carver, B. F., G. H. Morgan, L. H. Edwards, and J. A. Webster, Registration of four pairs of greenbug-resistant vs. susceptible near-isolines of winter barley germplasms, Crop Sci., 28:1034-1035, 1988. 7. Castro, A. M., A. Martin, and L. M. Martin, Location of genes controlling resistance to greenbug (Schizaphis graminum Rond.) in Hordeum chilense, Plant Breed., 115:335-338, 1996. 8. Castro, A. M., L. M. Martin, A. Martin, H. O. Arriaga, N. Tobes, and L. B. Almaraz, Screening for greenbug resistance in Hordeum chilense Roem et Schult., Plant Breed., 112:151-159, 1994. 9. Chada, H. L., I. M. Atkins, J. H. Gardenhire, and D. E. Weibel, Greenbugresistance studies with small grains, Texas Agric. Exp. Stn. Bull. B-982, Texas A&M University, College Station, 1961. 10. Clement, S. L. and D. G. Lester, Screening wild Hordeum species for resistance to Russian wheat aphid, Cereal Res. Commun., 18:173-177, 1990. 11. Clement, S. L., A. D. Wilson, D. G. Lester, and C. M. Davitt, Fungal endophytes of wild barley and their effects on Diuraphis noxia population development, Entomol. Exp. Appl., 82:275-281, 1997. 12. Dahms, R. G., T. H. Johnston, A. M. Schlehuber, and E. A. Wood, Jr., Reaction of small-grain varieties and hybrids to greenbug attack, Okla. Agric. Exp. Stn. Tech. Bull. T-55, Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, 1955. 13. Edwards, L. H., E. L. Smith, H. Pass, and G. H. Morgan, Registration of Post barley, Crop Sci., 25:363, 1985. 14. Edwards, L. H., E. L. Smith, H. Pass, and E. A. Wood, Jr., Registration of Kerr barley, Crop Sci., 10:725, 1970. 15. Gallun, R. L., E. H. Everson, R. F. Ruppel, and J. C. Craddock, Cereal leaf beetle resistance studies (1963-1964), USDA Special Rep. W-200, 1964. 16. Gallun, R. L., R. Ruppel, and E. H. Everson, Resistance of small grains to the cereal leaf beetle, J. Econ. Entomol., 59:827-829, 1966. 17. Gardenhire, J. H. and H. L. Chada, Inheritance of greenbug resistance in barley, Crop Sci., 1:349-352, 1961. 18. Gardenhire, J. H., M. E. McDaniel, and N. A. Tuleen, Registration of Tambar 402 barley, Crop Sci., 22:1259, 1982. 19. Hardwick, W. A., History and antecedents of brewing, In: W. A. Hardwick, Ed., Handbook of Brewing, Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York, 1995, 37. 20. Harlan, J. R., On the origin of barley, In: Barley: Origin, Botany, Culture, WinterHardiness, Genetics, Utilization, Pests, USDA Agric. Handbook No. 338, U.S. Department of Agriculture-Agriculture Research Service, Washington, D.C., 1968, 9.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
21. Hedrick, U. P., Sturtevant’s Notes on Edible Plants, N.Y. Dept. of Agriculture, Vol. 2, Part 2, 1919. 22. Hill, C. C., W. B. Cartwright, and G. A. Wiebe, Barley varieties resistant to the Hessian fly, Agron. J., 44:4-5, 1952. 23. Hormchong, T. and E. A. Wood, Jr., Evaluation of barley varieties for resistance to the corn leaf aphid, J. Econ. Entomol., 56:113-114, 1963. 24. Hsu, S. J. and A. G. Robinson, Resistance of barley varieties to the aphid Rhopalosiphum padi (L.), Can. J. Plant Sci., 42:247-251, 1961. 25. Hsu, S. J. and A. G. Robinson, Further studies on resistance of barley varieties to the aphid Rhopalosiphum padi (L.), Can. J. Plant Sci., 43:343-348, 1962. 26. Kieckhefer, R. W. and B. H. Kantack, Yield loss in spring barley caused by cereal aphids (Homoptera: Aphididae) in South Dakota, J. Econ. Entomol., 79:749-752, 1986. 27. Kindler, S. D. and T. L. Springer, Resistance to Russian wheat aphid in wild Hordeum species, Crop Sci., 31:94-97, 1991. 28. Marshall, D. S., J. H. Gardenhire, B. A. Shafer, K. B. Porter, M. D. Lazar, M. E. McDaniel, L. R. Nelson, and W. D. Worrall, Registration of ‘Tambar 500’ barley, Crop Sci., 33:1104, 1993. 29. McBean, D. S. and A. W. Platt, Differential damage to barley varieties by grasshoppers, Sci. Agric., 31:162-175, 1951. 30. Merkle, O. G., J. A. Webster, and G. H. Morgan, Inheritance of a second source of greenbug resistance in barley, Crop Sci., 27:241-243, 1987. 31. Mornhinweg, D. W., D. R. Porter, and J. A. Webster, Registration of STARS9301B barley germplasm resistant to the Russian wheat aphid, Crop Sci., 35:602, 1995. 32. Mornhinweg, D. W., D. R. Porter, and J. A. Webster, Inheritance of Russian wheat aphid resistance in spring barley, Crop Sci., 35:1368-1371, 1995. 33. Mornhinweg, D. W., D. R. Porter, and J. A. Webster, Germplasm enhancement for RWA resistance, Barley Newsl., 39:92-94, 1995. 34. Mornhinweg, D. W., D. R. Porter, and J. A. Webster, Inheritance of Russian wheat aphid resistance in spring barley germplasm line STARS-9577B, Barley Genetics Newsl., 25:34-35, 1995. 35. Moseman, J. G., Use of introduced germplasm in the USDA-ARS national barley collection in barley cultivars, In: H. L. Shands and L. E. Wiesner, Eds., Use of Plant Introductions in Cultivar Development, Part 1, CSSA Special Publication no. 17, Crop Science Society of America, Madison, 1991, 49. 36. Moseman, J. G. and D. H. Smith, Jr., Germplasm resources, In: D. C. Rasmusson, Ed., Barley, ASA, CSSA, & SSSA, Madison, 1985, 57. 37. Nieto-Lopez, R. M. and T. K. Blake, Russian wheat aphid resistance in barley: inheritance and linked molecular markers, Crop Sci., 34:655-659, 1994. 38. Olembo, J. R., F. L. Patterson, and R. L. Gallun, Genetic analysis of the resistance to Mayetiola destructor (Say) in Hordeum vulgare L., Crop Sci., 6:563-566, 1966. 39. Patrick, C. D. and S. Amosson, Economic impact of the Russian wheat aphid in the United States: 1993-1994, Texas A&M Univ., College Station, in press. 40. Poehlman, J. M., Adaptation and distribution, In: D. C. Rasmusson, Ed., Barley, ASA, CSSA, & SSA, Madison, 1985, 1. 41. Pratt, B., Statistics of grain and feed, In: Agricultural Statistics, USDA, National Agricultural Statistics Service, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., 1996, 1.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
42. Puterka, G. J., J. D. Burd, and R. L. Burton, Biotypic variation in a worldwide collection of Russian wheat aphid (Homoptera: Aphididae), J. Econ. Entomol., 85:1497-1506, 1992. 43. Reid, D. A., Morphology and anatomy of the barley plant, In: D. C. Rasmusson, Ed., Barley, ASA, CSSA, & SSSA, Madison, 1985, 73. 44. Robinson, J., F. Delgado, H. E. Vivar, and P. A. Burnett, Inheritance of resistance to Russian wheat aphid in barley, Euphytica, 62:213-27, 1992. 45. SINGER (System-wide Information Network on Genetic Resources), Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research, on the World Wide Web (http://noc1.cgiar.org/cgintrus.htm), 1997. 46. Smith, Jr., D. H., J. A. Webster, and J. E. Grafius, Registration of two cereal leaf beetle resistant barley germplasms, Crop Sci., 24:828, 1984. 47. Smith, O. D., A. M. Schlehuber, and B. C. Curtis, Inheritance studies of greenbug (Toxoptera graminum Rond.) resistance in four varieties of winter barley, Crop Sci, 2:489-491, 1962. 48. Starks, K. J. and J. A. Webster, Insects and related pests, In: D. C. Rasmusson, Ed., Barley, ASA, CSSA, & SSSA, Madison, 1985, 335. 49. Ullrich, S. E., Barley Germplasm Status in the USA, Barley Crop Germplasm Committee Report, Pullman, 1996. 50. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Prospective Plantings Report, National Agricultural Statistics Service, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., 1996. 51. Verma, G. P., D. N. Mahto, and M. H. Haque, The loss in grain yield due to aphids and other pests on certain varieties of barley grown in North Bihap, Sci. Cult., 45:370-371, 1979. 52. Webster, J. A., C. A. Baker, and D. R. Porter, Detection and mechanisms of Russian wheat aphid (Homoptera: Aphididae) resistance in barley, J. Econ. Entomol., 84:669-673, 1991. 53. Webster, J. A. and D. H. Smith, Jr., Yield losses and host selection of cereal leaf beetles in resistant and susceptible barley, Crop Sci., 19:901-904, 1979. 54. Webster, J. A. and K. J. Starks, Sources of resistance in barley to two biotypes of the greenbug Schizaphis graminum (Rondani) (Homoptera: Aphididae) Prot. Ecol., 6:51-55, 1984. 55. Webster, J. A., K. J. Starks, and R. L. Burton, Plant resistance studies with Diuraphis noxia (Homoptera: Aphididae), a new United States wheat pest, J. Econ. Entomol., 80:944-949, 1987. 56. Weibell, J., Screening for resistance against Rhopalosiphum padi (L.). 2. Hordeum species and interspecific hybrids, Euphytica, 36:571-576, 1987. 57. Weibell, J., Resistance to Rhopalosiphum padi (Homoptera: Aphididae) in Hordeum vulgare subsp. spontaneum and in hybrids with H. vulgare subsp. vulgare, Euphytica, 78:97-101, 1994. 58. Zohary, D. and M. Hopf, Domestication of Plants in the Old World, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1993. 59. Peairs, F.B., Personal communication, 1997. 60. Hays, D.B., Personal communication, 1997.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
4
Genetic Diversity of Sorghum: A Source of Insect-Resistant Germplasm George L. Teetes, Gary C. Peterson, Kanayo F. Nwanze, and Bonnie B. Pendleton
CONTENTS I. II. III. IV. V.
Introduction Importance and Use Basic Plant Characteristics Origin and Domestication Germplasm Resources A. Germplasm Collections B. Sorghum Conversion Program VI. Modern Genetic Selection in Sorghum VII. Resistance to Insects VIII. Role of Insects in Diversifying the Genetics of Sorghum IX. Co-evolutionary Relationship of Insects and Sorghum X. Case Studies XI. Economic Benefit of Insect-Resistant Sorghum XII. Molecular Genetic Techniques for Development of Insect-Resistant Sorghum XIII. Conclusions Acknowledgments References
I.
INTRODUCTION
Modern sorghum, Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench, is a product of human ingenuity.3 This marvelous plant has been domesticated, selected, and changed to meet human needs. Sorghum yields well in areas too hot and too dry to produce other crops such as maize, Zea mays L., and thus has prevented starvation of millions of people who live in the environmentally harshest and most austere regions of the world.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
The crop grows well in small, subsistence plots under primitive cultivation methods or as vast monocultures utilizing the most modern production practices and equipment. Sorghum is known for its production reliability. But, sorghum is not without an array of about 75 species of insects that infest the crop, and several of these insects threaten yield certainty and food security. Early domestication of sorghum and subsequent movement to many regions of the world, especially semi-arid tropical areas, resulted in the evolution of a genetically diverse crop species. This genetic diversity has been exploited in crop improvement programs to increase yield and yield stability by incorporating beneficial genes for many traits including adaptation to a wide variety of habitats and uses, higher yield, and more desirable grain. More recently, a major effort has been made to increase genetic resistance for defense against abiotic and biotic stresses, including insect pests. In each sorghum agroecosystem one or two key insect pests such as sorghum midge Stenodiplosis sorghicola (Coquillett), greenbug Schizaphis graminum (Rondani), or shoot fly Atherigona soccata (Rondani), dominate control practices. Several species, such as Banks grass mite Oligonychus partensis (Banks) and corn earworm Helicoverpa zea (Boddie), are secondary or induced pests injurious as a result of changes in cultural practices or cultivars, or because of injudicious use of insecticides applied for a key pest. Most insects that infest sorghum are occasional pests that cause economic damage only in localized areas or sporadically in time. Occasional insect pests include species of wireworms, white grubs, cutworms, aphids, leaf- and panicle-feeding caterpillars, and leaf- and panicle-feeding bugs. The challenge for crop protectionists is to use the genetic diversity of sorghum to combat a complex of insect pests. Development and use of sorghums resistant to key insect pests provide the greatest immediate benefit to an integrated pest management approach. However, there is opportunity to identify, incorporate, and deploy sorghums resistant to most insect pests of the crop. Toward this goal, much has been accomplished but much remains to be done.
II.
IMPORTANCE AND USE
Sorghum usually is considered fifth in importance among the world’s cereal crops. Worldwide, about 50 million ha of sorghum are grown annually, with the greatest hectarage located in Africa and Asia (Table 1).24
TABLE 1 World Production of Sorghum in 1995 Region
Hectares
Africa Asia North America Central and South America Other Total
22,000,000 15,000,000 4,000,000 2,000,000 3,000,000 46,000,000
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Sorghum grain is used for human food and as feed for animals. Through the ages, sorghum has been a vital food source for billions of people, especially in the semiarid tropics of Africa and Asia. Sorghum grain as human food is prepared in many traditional ways. Unleavened bread prepared with flour ground from grain is a common food made from sorghum. Sometimes the dough is fermented before baking. Sorghum grain also is boiled into a porridge or gruel. Beer commonly is made from the grain. Sorghum stems and foliage are used for green chop, hay, silage, and pasture, and after grain harvest stalks may be used for fuel or construction. Sorghum as a feed grain for livestock and poultry is first coarsely ground, broken, or soaked by various procedures. These treatments expose a larger portion of the kernel to an animal’s digestive enzymes, and less passes undigested through the animal. Generally, sorghum grain has the nutritional qualities of maize, but the kernel size is smaller.
III.
BASIC PLANT CHARACTERISTICS
Sorghum is a large-stemmed tropical grass having the ability to grow to great heights. Sorghum is a perennial, grown as an annual, is a self-pollinating species, but is handled in advanced agricultural situations as a cross-pollinating crop. The rate of outcrossing of sorghum generally is considered to be about 5%. The diverse types in the species are all diploids with a 2N = 20 chromosome number, and they will intercross.62 Related grassy species are 2N = 40. Cytoplasmic-genetic male sterility is extremely important in hybridization of sorghum. Sorghum is classified into four groups: (1) grain sorghum, (2) forage or saccharine sorghum, (3) broomcorn, and (4) grass sorghum.3 Grain sorghum is known by a variety of names: guinea corn in West Africa, kafir corn in South Africa, durra in the Sudan, mtama in eastern Africa, jowar in northern India, kaoliang in China, and milo in America. Types with sweet and juicy stems from which syrup can be extracted are known as sorgos, while those with long stiff panicle branches from which whisk brooms are made are broomcorns. Sorghum is adapted to many environments, requiring 90 to 140 days to mature. Yields usually are higher from later rather than earlier maturing cultivars. Yields have exceeded 11,000 kg/ha, with above-average yields ranging from 7,000 to 9,000 kg/ha where moisture is not a limiting factor.3 In areas where sorghum commonly is grown, yields of 3,000 to 4,000 kg/ha are obtained under better conditions, dropping to 300 to 1,000 kg/ha as moisture becomes limiting. Sorghum hybrids are grown in developed countries where commercial seed industries exist. Typically these hybrids are short statured and machine harvested. In most developing countries, landrace varieties instead of hybrids are grown, and farmers select and save seed from their crops for planting. In subsistence agriculture, sorghum is harvested by hand and usually stored unthreshed until needed for food preparation, then threshed and decorticated.
IV.
ORIGIN AND DOMESTICATION
While there is general consensus of opinion that sorghum originated in the northeastern quadrant of Africa, there is less agreement on the region of Africa where it © 1999 by CRC Press LLC
was first domesticated.10,16,17,30,45,52 Harlan30 proposed that sorghum was a “noncentric crop,” that is, a crop whose current distribution of genetic variability revealed no evident center of origin or diversity. Based on comparative morphological studies and numerical taxonomy, three independent centers of sorghum domestication have been proposed — the Ethiopian area of eastern Africa, tropical western Africa, and southeastern Africa.10 After considering the distribution of races of sorghum in Africa, Harlan30 concluded that initial domestication of sorghum occurred in a long belt across central Africa. Doggett16 concluded that sorghum was first cultivated by the Cushites in the Ethiopian highlands of eastern Africa. Domestication of sorghum was believed to have begun about 5,000 B.P.45 Afterwards, various tribes in different parts of Africa domesticated different races of sorghum as knowledge of crop cultivation spread. The durra race was domesticated in the Ethiopian-Sudan region, and the guinea race was developed in western Africa, at least in part by Mande tribesmen. The Bantu people adopted sorghum as a staple food as they began to populate the dry savannas east of the forest belt. From Tanzania southward the kafir race of sorghum came to be associated with the Bantu, just as the caudatum race became associated with the Nilotic and Nil-Hamitic people of Uganda and western Kenya. The fact that sorghum is an extremely diverse species with much morphological variability resulted in various tribes using sorghum in different ways, from building materials for huts, furniture, and mats, to beer, sugar, and cereal production.10 Cultivation of the durra race of sorghum spread from Ethiopia and Sudan into the Near East and to India soon after 4,000 B.P. Sorghum probably was not cultivated in ancient Egypt. It is absent from the extensive archaeological excavations of early farming sites in the Near East. In the first century (60 to 70 A.D.), Pliny48 mentioned the introduction of sorghum into Italy by caravans from India. The spread of sorghum cultivation into southeastern Asia and China also occurred around 3,000 B.P., but there are no authentic records of sorghum in China before the 13th century.15,48 At approximately this time period, sorghum was in Southeast Asia where the crop first came in contact with wild sorghum diploids such as S. propinquum (Kunth) Hitchc. Genetic exchange between wild and cultivated forms may have given rise to the characteristic koaliang types of China, Manchuria, and Japan.16 Sorghum, called “guinea corn,” “indian millet,” and “coffee corn,” probably was introduced from western Africa into the Western Hemisphere.16,47,48,58 Sorghum probably first entered the U.S. along with slaves. Benjamin Franklin is credited with introducing broomcorn.48 Sorghum is believed to have been under cultivation in the U.S. before the end of the 18th century.47 There are records of the early presence of sorghum (“broomcorn,” “indian millet,” and “coffeecorn”) in the U.S. in the 1800s.20,58
V.
GERMPLASM RESOURCES
A. GERMPLASM COLLECTIONS Organized collecting of Sorghum began in the mid-1950s at the time of the hybrid production era.19 Collections exceeding 30,000 accessions have been assembled at
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
the International Crops Research Institute for the Semi-Arid Tropics (ICRISAT) Asia Center, India and at the Plant Genetic Resources Conservation Laboratory, Griffin, Georgia. The National Seed Storage Laboratory, Fort Collins, Colorado, is a security backup to the active collection at Griffin, Georgia. About 80% of the total world sorghum collection was introduced from developing countries of the semiarid tropics. Only 1.2% of the world sorghum collection is composed of wild and weedy relatives. Accessions in these world seed collections were obtained from tropical and temperate zones, from low and high elevations, and from sorghum grown during different seasons of the year. Sorghums from these varied environments ensured germplasm diversity. If resistance to any sorghum insect pest exists in the world, it probably can be found in these collections, although much of the existing germplasm has not yet been collected or evaluated for resistance to insects.
B. SORGHUM CONVERSION PROGRAM Many sorghums in the world collection are from Africa and Asia. Most of these tropical varieties, because they are photoperiod-sensitive and require long nights to induce flowering, cannot be evaluated in temperate zones of the world. As a result, only a small fraction of the total genetic diversity within the species could be evaluated in its original form and used to produce improved lines and hybrids in temperate areas. Sorghum improvement specialists have long recognized the restricted germplasm base of sorghum adapted for temperate areas. Early research that culminated in development of hybrid grain sorghum used some of the few temperately adapted sorghum cultivars that were naturally short and early maturing.59 Discovery and utilization of cytoplasmic-genetic male sterility to produce hybrid sorghum revolutionized sorghum production around the world. However, there was little germplasm available for temperate areas to make additional significant improvements in grain yield, adaptation, and resistance to abiotic and biotic stresses. Initiated in 1963, the cooperative Texas Agricultural Experiment Station, Texas A&M University, U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), Agricultural Research Service (ARS), Sorghum Conversion Program70 has made available a portion of the genetic diversity within the genus Sorghum. This program uses the genetics of sorghum height and maturity, and crossing and selection to convert tall, photoperiodsensitive sorghums into short, early types suitable for use in temperate areas. Other than the discovery of the sterility system that allowed for commercial production of hybrid sorghum, the sorghum conversion program has been the largest contributor to the improvement of sorghum in the developed world. Sorghum is a short-day species, but strains exhibit differential sensitivity to photoperiod. Four genes influence the photoperiod reaction that governs the time of floral initiation (duration of growth). Lateness of maturity and tallness are dominant characteristics, and each is controlled by genes at four independently inherited loci.58 In the sorghum conversion program, crossing and backcrossing are done during the winter at the USDA Experiment Station, Mayaguez, Puerto Rico. Short, early genotypes are selected from segregating populations during the long days of summer
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
in Texas. Tropical sorghums are used as male parents in the crosses and backcrosses except the last cross, when the tropical line is used as the female to restore the converted line to its original cytoplasm. The original female (nonrecurrent parent) is an early, four-dwarf, B-line (male fertile) in normal cytoplasm. Each backcross is made to an F3 progeny grown from a short, early maturing F2 plant selected in Texas. Four cycles of backcrossing and selection are required for conversion; however, partially converted lines (lines with less than four backcrosses) sometimes are released as breeding stocks.
VI.
MODERN GENETIC SELECTION IN SORGHUM
It is readily apparent that much of the genetic diversity within sorghum is a result of its early domestication, movement to many regions of the world, and selection for many different habitats and uses. Plant genetic improvement efforts today generally attempt to maximize yield, which result in a recombination of some genetic components and, inadvertently, in the loss of others.34 Newly developed crop cultivars are grown over large areas and used for as many years as possible. Crop cultivars or hybrids generally are genetically homogeneous from one plant to another within a field. Thus, common dogma is that modern cultivated plants such as sorghum have a narrower genetic base than those of even a few decades ago. This genetic and phenotypic uniformity tends to increase the vulnerability of crop plants to insect pest attack, and the practice of monoculture further exacerbates the problem.34 However, the genetic base of any given crop can be broadened to include insectresistant characteristics that intrinsically protect plants from insect pests. Incorporating resistance to insects is one way to broaden a crop’s genetic base, obtain general benefits from increased genetic diversity, and gain specific benefits from resistance. Deliberate attempts to use plant resistance in any crop span primarily the last 100 years, with the greatest emphasis on resistance made during the last five decades. Even less time has been devoted to developing insect-resistant sorghums. Considering that the history of plant domestication is several thousand years old, the longneglected task of deliberately incorporating insect resistance into plants, including sorghum, has just begun. Hopefully, greater knowledge of the subject and better techniques will allow fast, effective progress.
VII.
RESISTANCE TO INSECTS
Resistance has been reported for many of the common insect and mite species infesting sorghum (Table 2). This table indicates the insects for which sorghum germplasm has been evaluated and provides estimates of the germplasm lines evaluated and the number of resistance sources identified. Thousands of sorghum germplasm lines, most from the world collection, have been evaluated for resistance to several aphid species, especially greenbug, shoot fly, stem borers, sorghum midge, and panicle-infesting bugs. These efforts are evidence of the commitment of sorghum improvement specialists to identify resistance, incorporate resistance into improved plant types, and deploy insect-resistant sorghum. Although the success rate in identifying resistant sources has been relatively low, resistance has been identified for © 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 2 Sorghum Germplasm Evaluated for Resistance to Insects Insect Schizaphis graminuma Melanaphis sacchari Rhopalosiphum maidis Sipha flava Atherigona soccata Spodoptera frugiperda Busseola fusca Chilo partellus Diatraea saccharalis Peregrinus maidisa Blissus leucopterus leucopterus Oligonychus pratensis Stenodiplosis sorghicola Calocoris angustatus Eurystylus oldi (marginatus)a
No. of germplasm lines evaluated
No. of resistant lines identified
Ref.
29,000 13,337 650 8,809 31,000 8,990 16,000 30,000 200 104 1,000 553 18,491 18,000 400
28 108 73 3 134 34 18 182 4 3 53 2 70 58 9
— 4, 5, 28, 46, 51, 55 38, 42, 49 9, 68, 77 53, 63, 65 12-14, 27, 78 26 53, 63, 65 27 — 8, 19, 50, 69 25 1, 41, 53, 63, 65, 79 53, 63-65 —
a
Information provided by H. C. Sharma, especially stem borers and panicle-feeding bugs, and Y. O. Doumbia for Eurystylus oldi.
almost all of the important insect pests. However, far fewer insect-resistant sorghums actually have become a component of integrated pest management in agricultural production. Most success has been with resistance to greenbug in the U.S., resistance to sorghum midge in Australia and India, and resistance to stem borers and shoot fly in Africa and India. Because most insects infesting sorghum, especially those insects originating in the Western Hemisphere, do not have a long history of association with sorghum, it is surprising that resistance would occur in sorghum to so many of the insects that infest the crop. This is a testament to sorghum genetic diversity.
VIII.
ROLE OF INSECTS IN DIVERSIFYING THE GENETICS OF SORGHUM
Evolutionary biologists have been preoccupied for almost a century with assessing the role of different abiotic and biotic stresses, including insects, in generating plant genetic diversity. Although caution is important when applying theories of evolutionary biology to agricultural systems, evolutionary biology is of interest to crop protectionists whose goal is to locate and incorporate into plants genes for defense against insect pests. A common, but not fully agreed upon, hypothesis is that much of the genetic diversity of plants has arisen as a product of co-evolution between plants and their natural enemies (i.e., insect pests).22 For this reason, centers of origin of domesticated plants are believed to be important sources of insect-resistant genes
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
for incorporation into improved varieties. Two important issues are related to this hypothesis: (1) “selection imposed by natural enemies causes plant populations to diverge in defensive characteristics” and (2) “selection imposed by plant defensive characteristics causes the plant’s natural enemy populations to diverge in characteristics associated with exploitation of the host plant.” Issue 1 implies that plants within a population that are weakened or unable to survive the attack of insects are replaced through natural selection by better-adapted plants. Plants that survive will have genes for defense against the insect. The controversy regarding this issue is that selection by natural enemies of plants is normally too weak to account for evolution of defense traits such as secondary compounds, morphological characteristics, and other features.40 Also, resistance to an insect commonly is found in plants that have had no long-term association with the insect pest. The consequence of the second issue is sometimes an unfortunate, real-world catastrophe, formation of virulent biotypes, after deployment of resistant genotypes into an agroecosystem. This issue further illustrates the importance of plant genetic diversity, but also stresses the importance of considering the genetic diversity of the insect.
IX.
CO-EVOLUTIONARY RELATIONSHIP OF INSECTS AND SORGHUM
The co-evolutionary relationships between insect pests and sorghum have not been thoroughly assessed. Cursory examination reveals that most insects infesting sorghum are widely distributed species, generalist feeders, that did not co-evolve with sorghum, but resistance has been identified for many of these insects (Table 3). The insects infesting and having the longest and most host-specific association with sorghum are sorghum midge and sorghum shoot fly. Most insects infesting sorghum have many hosts and because of their proposed geographic origins could not have evolved with sorghum. Greenbug is a good example of a key insect pest of sorghum that did not evolve with sorghum, but resistance has been identified and used in agriculture. Resistance genes were selected for in the absence of the insects. Characters that cause resistance to these insects have physiological or ecological functions other than or in addition to protection of the sorghum plant. Seemingly, resistance traits developed in a plant population free of an insect pest are fortuitously derived from pleiotropic effects of genes maintained by natural selection pressures unrelated to the insect. Harris34 referred to this kind of resistance as allopatric resistance, which he defined as “heritable qualities possessed by a plant that influence the ultimate degree of damage done by an insect having no prior continuous co-evolutionary history with that insect.” In contrast, he defined sympatric resistance as “resistance that comes from insects having a prior, long-term history with a plant species.”
X.
CASE STUDIES
Two key insect pests that represent sympatric and allopatric relationships with sorghum are sorghum midge and greenbug, respectively. Sorghum midge is a dipterous, multivoltine species with a short life-cycle (16 days). Only species of the genus
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 3 Geographical and Ecological Relationships of Sorghum with Insects Infesting Sorghum Insect
Pest status
Schizaphis graminum Melanaphis sacchari
Key Occ
Rhopalosiphum maidis Sipha flava Atherigona soccata Mythimna separata Spodoptera exempta Spodoptera frugiperda Busseola fusca Chilo partellus Eldana saccharina Sesamia calamistis Sesamia inferens
Possible origin
Current distribution
Hosts
Co-evolved w/sorghum
Resistance reported
E & W Hemisph. E & W Hemisph.
Grasses Grasses
No No
Yes Yes
Occ Occ Key Occ Occ Occ Occ Key Occ Occ Occ
Mediterranean Asia, Africa, Tropical America Americas Americas Africa, Asia Asia Africa Americas S Africa India Africa Africa Asia
E & W Hemisph. W Hemisph. E Hemisph. Asia, Pacific E & W Africa W Hemisph. Africa India, E Africa, Far East Africa Africa Asia, Pacific
No No Yes No No No No No No No No
Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes No No No
Diatraea saccharalis
Occ
C America
C & S America
No
Yes
Peregrinus maidis
Occ
C America
No
No
Poophilus costalis Locris rubens Blissus leucopterus leucopterus Oligonychus indicus Oligonychus pratensis
Occ Occ Occ
Africa W Africa Americas
Worldwide but more tropical, especially S Africa & C America Asia & Africa W Africa W Hemisph.
Grasses, Solanaceae Grasses Sorghum Grasses, many dicots Grasses, many dicots Grasses, many dicots Sorghum, maize, millet, grasses Sorghum, maize, sugarcane, grasses Sorghum, sugarcane, maize Grasses Sorghum, sugarcane, maize, rice, wheat, millet Sorghum, sugarcane, maize, aquatic grassy weeds Sorghum, maize, sugarcane
Sorghum, grasses Sorghum, grasses Grasses
No No No
No No Yes
Sec Sec
India Americas
E Hemisph. W Hemisph.
Sorghum, sugarcane, grasses Grasses
No No
No Yes
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 3 (continued) Geographical and Ecological Relationships of Sorghum with Insects Infesting Sorghum Insect
Pest status
Possible origin
Current distribution
Hosts
Co-evolved w/sorghum
Resistance reported
Tetranychus urticae Stenodiplosis sorghicola Cryptoblades adoceta Dichocrocis punctiferalis Heliothis armigera
Sec Key
Americas NE Africa
W Hemisph. E & W Hemisph.
Grasses Sorghum spp.
No Yes
No Yes
Occ Occ
Asia Asia
Oceania, Asia Asia, Oceania
Sorghum, maize, grasses Sorghum, grasses, fruit
No No
No No
Occ
E Hemisph.
Yes
Occ Sec
Asia W Hemisph.
No No
No Yes
Nola sorghiella Calocoris angustatus Dysdercus superstitiosus Eurystylus oldi (marginatus) Nysius raphanus Chlorochroa ligata Leptoglossus phyllopus
Occ Key Occ
Americas Asia Africa
S USA, C America E Hemisph. Africa
Sorghum, maize, cotton, tomato, many others Sorghum, grasses Sorghum, maize, cotton, tomato, legumes, many others Sorghum spp. Sorghum, grasses Sorghum, millet, grasses
No
Stenachroia elongella Helicoverpa zea
S Europe, Africa, SE Asia, Australia, New Zealand Asia Americas
No No No
No Yes No
Key
Africa
Africa
Grasses
No
Yes
Occ Occ Occ
Africa Americas Americas
Africa W Hemisph. W Hemisph.
No No No
No No No
Nezara viridula
Occ
Americas
Worldwide in warm areas
No
No
Oebalus pugnax
Occ
Americas
W Hemisph.
Sorghum, many others Sorghum, legumes Sorghum, legumes, cucurbits, pecan, persimmon 100+ hosts include sorghum, vegetables, legumes Grasses
No
No
Occ = occasional, Sec = secondary, Key = key pest.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Sorghum are hosts of the insect. Adult females lay about 50 eggs (usually one per spikelet) between the glumes when sorghum spikelets are flowering. Larvae feeding cryptically on developing ovaries prevent normal kernel formation and cause direct grain loss. In contrast, greenbug is a holocyclic aphid that feeds on at least 60 grasses, including cultivated wheat Triticum aestivum L., oats Avena sativa L., barley Hordeum vulgare L., and rye Secale cereale L., during winter months, and sorghum during the summer. Parthenogenic females are mostly wingless. A greenbug produces about 80 young during a 3-week period. Ten to twelve generations can develop during the growing period of sorghum in the U.S. southern Great Plains, but usually after five or six generations greenbug abundance greatly declines because of parasitism. Greenbugs, feeding in colonies, extract copious amounts of sap from plant leaves and stems and inject a toxin as they feed that causes necrosis of leaf tissue. The aphid excretes honeydew and transmits important diseases such as maize dwarf mosaic virus. Biotypes of the species have been designated. While there are few prehistoric and historic facts about the origin of sorghum midge, there is certainly strong evidence to suggest that sorghum midge originated with sorghum in northeastern Africa.2,31-33,71 However, literature review of the dates of first discovery of sorghum midge in various sorghum-growing countries appears to suggest that after its discovery in Australia in 189472 and in the U.S. in 1895,7 it spread to Hawaii, the West Indies, Indonesia, and Sudan, and from Sudan gradually spread throughout Africa. Support for the contention that sorghum midge originated in Africa is as follows: 1. Examination in the Kew Herbarium and the herbarium of the British Museum of Natural History of botanical material of the genus Sorghum from Sudan revealed the presence of sorghum midge larvae and pupae in 45 samples which proved that sorghum midge was present in Sudan in 1869, 25 years before discovery in Australia or the U.S. 2. Only grasses of the genus Sorghum are hosts of the sorghum midge, and sorghums are indigenous to Africa. 3. Species diversity of the genus Stenodiplosis (formerly Contarinia) and perhaps associated parasitoids are apparently greater in Africa than in Australia or the U.S. 4. Many of the sources of plants resistant to sorghum midge are “zera zera” sorghums from Ethiopia and Sudan. 5. Sorghum midge is a much more severe pest in Australia and the U.S. than in northeastern Africa. There seems little doubt the sorghum midge is indigenous to Africa and an alien Australian, American, and Texan. The origin of the greenbug, like that of many insects that have become cosmopolitan in distribution, is unknown.67 General consensus is the insect is of Mediterranean (e.g., western or southwestern Eurasian) origin. The earliest available record of the insect is 1847 in Italy, where 5 years later the species was described.60 Soon after, in 1863, Passerini in Italy noted that sorghum was infested by greenbug.76 By © 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 4 History of Greenbug Biotypes and Some Ecological Characteristics Biotype
Ecological characteristics
A
Original population avirulent to “Dickinson Selection 28A” wheat; designated in 1961; cool season insect; rarely infested sorghum; currently, rarely naturally occurring Virulent to “Dickinson Selection 28A” wheat; designated in 1961; predominant biotype until late 1960s; cool season insect; “Piper” sudan grass was resistant; rarely infested sorghum; more common on grasses; currently, rarely naturally occurring Sorghum became important host; designated in 1968; predominant biotype until 1980s; became a warm and cool season insect; “Piper” sudan grass susceptible; resistant wheat and sorghum developed; naturally occurring Insecticide resistant, especially to organophosphates; designated in 1975; because this biotype is not based on virulence to plants, it often is omitted from a list of greenbug biotypes Virulent to most biotype C-resistant sorghum and wheat; designated in 1980; currently predominant biotype; resistant sorghum developed; still commonly occurring Damages Canada bluegrass; designated in 1986; somewhat similar to biotype A; not considered important to sorghum or wheat; naturally occurring Virulent to all resistant wheats; avirulent to sorghum; designated in 1988; not proven agriculturally important; naturally occurring Same host plant relationships as biotype E on wheat; avirulent to sorghum resistant to other biotypes; designated in 1988; virulent to “Post” barley; not proven agriculturally important Virulent to most biotype E-resistant sorghum in 1990, but not E-resistant wheat; designated in 1991; replacing biotype E; resistance identified in sorghum Avirulent to sorghum and some wheat and barley resistant to other biotypes; designated in 1994 from Idaho; damages “Post” barley; natural occurrence unknown Virulent to some sorghum sources resistant to biotype I; designated in 1996; some sources resistant to I retained resistance to K but at lower levels; ability to replace E and I unknown
B
C
D E F G H I J K
1907, the insect had been reported to occur in Europe, Asia, Africa, and North America.75 Greenbug now has spread into South America, but is not in Australia. In the U.S., the insect has infested small grains since about 1882.76 Infestations of johnsongrass, S. halepense (L.) Pers., in the U.S. were reported as early as 1909.76 Serious damage to sorghum occurred in Kansas in 1916.37 Sorghum became a primary cultivated summer host of greenbug in 1968 when outbreaks in sorghum occurred throughout most of the Great Plains region.36 The insect has remained a key insect pest of sorghum since 1968. Ten greenbug biotypes have been designated for their ability to damage resistant sorghum or wheat cultivars, seven of which have been identified within the last 16 years (Table 4).56 In contrast to the long evolutionary history shared by sorghum midge and sorghum, greenbug and sorghum have a relatively short history. Despite these different relationship histories, resistance in sorghum has been identified to both insects. Deployment of resistant sorghums has been more successful for greenbug than for sorghum midge. One reason is that genes for resistance to greenbug commonly have been simply inherited and mostly dominant, while genes for resistance to sorghum midge have been quantitatively inherited, mostly recessive, and complexly inherited.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
It is difficult to compare resistance mechanisms of sorghum midge and greenbug because of the differences in damage these insects cause to sorghum. Also, numerous greenbug biotypes complicate generalizations about resistance inheritance and mechanisms. The resistance to sorghum midge appears to be a non-preference response probably because of glume structure, time of day glumes close after flowering, and the tightness with which the glumes close.11,29,61,73,74 Greenbug resistance in sorghum probably is more related to the ability of the plant to tolerate enzymes such as pectinase secreted by the aphids as they suck juices from the plant.18 Resistance to these two insects is inherited differently and the mechanisms of resistance differ. However, it is difficult to relate these differences to evolutionary relationships of sorghum with sorghum midge or greenbug. One theory proposes that an insect with a long-term association with a host plant species has the genetic plasticity to overcome defense strategies of the host plant.35 That is, resistance in plants that evolved with an insect could be susceptible to being overcome by genetic changes in the insect pest. The theory that selection by insects causes plant populations to acquire resistance traits, and that selection imposed by these resistance traits provides the insect the ability to exploit these plants applies to one sorghum insect in these case studies. Sorghum midge is believed to have evolved with sorghum while greenbug did not. Popular theory would indicate that sorghum midge would constantly be changing to overcome resistance. However, no biotypes of sorghum midge have been reported, but many greenbug biotypes have been designated. Sorghum resistance to greenbug did not come from sources obtained through genetic feedback, but greenbug has the genetic plasticity to overcome resistance. Sorghum resistance to greenbug is qualitative, controlled by only one or a few genes that are mostly dominant. Commonly, resistant sorghums express all three resistance mechanisms, but tolerance resistance is the major mechanism and would have limited effect on greenbug biology. Resistance to sorghum midge that co-evolved with sorghum is believed to be quantitative, controlled by many genes that are mostly recessive and confer resistance to evasion by spikelets flowering when sorghum midges are not present, physical obstruction to sorghum midge oviposition in the spikelets, or antixenosis.11 Many other factors are associated with the ability of an insect to overcome plant resistance. Most effort to increase the durability of resistance has been on attempting to understand the genetics of the resistant plant. However, the genetics of the resistant plant is but one side of the issue. The genetics of the insect is the missing piece of the puzzle regarding the relationship of an insect with a resistant plant.
XI.
ECONOMIC BENEFIT OF INSECT-RESISTANT SORGHUM
The use of insect-resistant sorghum hybrids as a tactic in an integrated pest management approach functions to reduce insect pest abundance through antibiosis and antixenosis, and increases the ability of plants to withstand damage through tolerance. Intrinsic plant defense mechanisms have economical and ecological benefits. Often, only slight decreases in susceptibility of a crop cultivar to an insect pest enhance the effectiveness of other cultural control tactics such as crop rotation, host
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
FIGURE 1
Effect of greenbug-resistant sorghum hybrids on insecticide usage in Texas.
destruction, and planting date adjustment; biological control, especially conservation of natural enemies; and insecticide control. Assessing the ecological benefits of insect pest-resistant cultivars by synergizing a multi-tactic management approach is difficult, and few such assessments have been made. Even determining the yield advantage from use of insect-resistant cultivars is difficult. The most commonly measured benefit to the use of insect-resistant crop cultivars is reduction in insecticide use. Although important, this benefit falls far short of the real economical and environmental benefits to the use of insect-resistant cultivars. Environmental benefits, such as cleaner water and safer food resulting from reduced insecticide use, must be tremendous, but largely are not measurable. Even the more direct benefits, such as reduced incidence of secondary pest outbreaks, are difficult to measure. Economic benefits have been assessed for sorghum resistant to some insect pests. In the U.S., economic assessments have been directed toward greenbug- and sorghum midge-resistant sorghum hybrids. Again, these evaluations are largely based on reduction in insecticide use because of use of insect-resistant sorghum hybrids. The effect of greenbug-resistant sorghum hybrids on insecticide use in Texas sorghum indicates how little insecticide was used before 1968 when greenbug became a serious pest of sorghum (Figure 1). In the mid-1960s, less than 10% of sorghum hectarage was treated with insecticide, but by the mid-1970s nearly 60% of the hectarage was treated. That trend in insecticide use continued until about 1977 when the first greenbug-resistant sorghum hybrids became commercially available. By 1980, hectarage of treated sorghum dropped from about 60 to 30% and has remained at about that level since. More than $9 million (U.S.) would be saved each year if 4 million acres in Texas were planted with resistant sorghum and insecticides costing $7.50 per acre were not needed to control greenbug. Eddleman et al.21 using a multicommodity agricultural sector model quantified the economic impart of greenbug-resistant sorghum hybrids. They reported development of greenbug-resistant sorghum hybrids resulted in $116 million in net gain © 1999 by CRC Press LLC
to U.S. consumer-taxpayers and a $273 million increase in benefit to producers for a total of $389 million net welfare to the U.S. under the existing farm program provisions. The annual rate of return on the research investment ($8.54 million) was 48.2%. Without farm commodity programs, the net social benefit to the U.S. would be $113 million, yielding an annual rate of return of 33.4% on the research investment. A similar, but less detailed cost/benefit analysis was conducted for sorghum midge-resistant sorghum hybrids.24 Ervin et al.23 calculated that for each dollar invested in research, the value of benefits to increased crop yields ranged from $24.20 to $2.70 depending on the discount rate. The average value of benefits was $9.90 for each dollar spent to develop the technology. This assessment would set the economic value of sorghum midge-resistant sorghum hybrids at $27 million.
XII.
MOLECULAR GENETIC TECHNIQUES FOR DEVELOPMENT OF INSECT-RESISTANT SORGHUM
Evolving molecular genetic techniques are providing exciting opportunities to better understand the genetic relationship between an insect and a resistant plant. This kind of information is needed especially for insects such as greenbug that have overcome several resistance genes in sorghum. DNA marker technology currently is used to map and identify gene structure conferring resistance traits in plants. Understanding the genetics of the resistance in plants will provide the knowledge to improve resistance deployment strategies. However, it is becoming clear that, with regard to plant resistance to insects, the genetics of the insect attacking the plant is equally, if not more, important to understand. Molecular genetic techniques are beginning to provide the opportunity to better understand the relationship of plant genetics to insect genetics. A detailed genetic map of the sorghum genome has been assembled.6 This map has been the basis to assess the magnitude of gene conservation among grass species54 and to study sorghum genetics of height and maturity,44 resistance to greenbug,43 and other important traits. Molecular genetic techniques also have been used to study the genetic structure of insect populations. Use of these techniques provides important clues to geographical variation, evolution of mating systems, heterozygosity, relatedness of individuals, and other factors that determine how insect populations respond to environmental conditions or human-imposed stresses, and set the framework for how insects evolve. Hoy39 reviewed selected examples of questions in insect population biology and ecology evaluated by the use of molecular techniques such as randomly amplified polymorphic DNA-polymerase chain reaction (RAPD-PCR), restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) (ribosomal DNA, mitochondrial DNA, nuclear DNA), DNA fingerprinting, DNA sequencing, and dot blot hybridization. Powers et al.57 compared mtDNA restriction patterns to assess relationships among greenbug biotypes B, C, E, and F, and estimated a long period of time since these biotypes shared a common ancestral mitochondrial genome. Shufran et al.66 used DNA fingerprinting and found that almost every individual greenbug collected in any particular field on any one date had a different intergenic spacer (IGS) length; 13 major IGS size classes
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
were present. Their data suggested that field populations of greenbug were comprised of many unique clones rather than a proliferation of one or a few. Better understanding the molecular bases of interactions of sorghum insect pests with resistant sorghum genotypes hopefully will point to gene deployment strategies to reduce the selective advantage favoring evolution of resistance-breaking biotypes. Many evolutionary concepts are based on the theory that substantial genetic variability exists in virulence of insect populations, i.e., greenbug, to resistant plants. The growing amount of evidence that grass species are genetically similar supports the possibility that genes for resistance to an insect pest could be conserved during the evolutionary divergence of host species. This issue has important implications to insect resistance in sorghum and raises the possibility that resistance genes to greenbug in sorghum may have been conserved from wheat, other small grains, or their progenitors. Traditional methods of assessing the genetics of insects, plants, and their interactions have not been adequate to explain evolutionary relationships, especially formation of biotypes virulent to resistant plant genotypes. Phylogenic analysis of data from comparative DNA sequence studies offers a methodology to reconstruct evolutionary history and relationships at all taxonomic levels. Molecular methods are providing reliable markers to distinguish between biotypes, races, and cryptic species of economically important insects39 — problems long resistant to solution, but central to the management of insect pests of sorghum.
XIII.
CONCLUSIONS
The genetic diversity of sorghum provides a wonderful opportunity to improve many agricultural properties of the cultivated crop, especially resistance to insects. The success in identifying sources of resistance to many of the insects infesting sorghum is a tribute to the genetic diversity of sorghum and to the efforts made by sorghum improvement specialists. However, identification of resistance sources is but the beginning of a long and difficult venture to deploy insect-resistant genotypes into agricultural production systems. The almost unimaginable ability of insects to overcome human-imposed defenses such as resistance will require a much better understanding of the genetic relationships between insects and resistant plants. Traditional entomological and plant breeding methods will continue to be important in this process, but molecular genetics techniques will greatly enhance traditional methods. Sorghum is genetically diverse, but so are the insects that infest the crop.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors are grateful to H. C. Sharma for information on sorghum germplasm evaluated for resistance to insect pests, especially stem borers and panicle-feeding bugs, and to Y. O. Doumbia for information on sorghum lines evaluated for resistance to Eurystylus oldi (marginatus). The U.S. Agency for International Development (Grant LAG-1254-G-00-6009-00), Pioneer Hi-bred International, and the National Grain Sorghum Producers Association are acknowledged for research support.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
REFERENCES 1. Ali, A. E. B., Identification of Sorghum Midge (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae) Resistant Lines Among Converted Exotic Sorghum, M.S. Thesis, Texas A&M University, College Station, 1986. 2. Barnes, H. F., Gall midges injurious to the sorghums, In: H. R. Barnes, Ed., Gall Midges of Economic Importance, Volume 7, Crosby Lockwood, London, 1956, 151. 3. Bennett, W. F., B. R. Tucker, and A. B. Maunder, Modern Grain Sorghum Production, Iowa State University Press, Ames, 1990. 4. Chang, C-P. and M-N. Fang, Studies on the resistance of sorghum variety to sorghum aphid, Melanaphis sacchari (Zehntner), Chinese J. Entomol., 4:97-105, 1984. 5. Chang, S-C., Sources of resistance in sorghum to sugarcane aphid Melanaphis sacchari (Zehntner), Rep. Corn Res. Center, Tainan DAIS, 15:11-14, 1981. 6. Chittenden, L. M., K. F. Schertz, Y-R. Lin, R. A. Wing, and A. H. Paterson, A detailed RFLP map of Sorghum bicolor x S. propinquum, suitable for high-density mapping, suggests ancestral duplication of sorghum chromosomes or chromosomal segments, Theor. Appl. Genet., 87:925-933, 1994. 7. Coquillett, D. W., A cecidomyiid injurious to seeds of sorghum, USDA Div. Entomol. Bull., 18:81-82, 1898. 8. Dahms, R. G. and J. B. Sieglinger, Reaction of sorghum varieties to the chinch bug, J. Econ. Entomol., 47:536-537, 1954. 9. Davis, F. H., G. L. Teetes, and J. W. Johnson, Yellow sugarcane aphid in sorghum, Sorghum Newsl., 21:112-113, 1978. 10. de Wet, J. M. and J. P. Huckabay, The origin of Sorghum bicolor, II, distribution and domestication, Evolution, 21:787-802, 1967. 11. Diarisso, N. Y., Spikelet Flowering Time and Morphology as Causes of Sorghum Resistance to Sorghum Midge, Ph.D. Dissertation, Texas A&M University, College Station, 1997. 12. Diawara, M. M., B. R. Wiseman, and D. J. Isenhour, Spodoptera frugiperda (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) resistance in converted sorghum accessions: a research summary, Sorghum Newsl., 32:46-49, 1991. 13. Diawara, M. M., B. R. Wiseman, and D. J. Isenhour, Sorghum resistance to whorl feeding by larvae of the fall armyworm (Lep.: Noct.), J. Agric. Entomol., 9:41-53, 1992. 14. Diawara, M. M., B. R. Wiseman, D. J. Isenhour, and G. R. Lovell, Resistance to fall armyworm in converted sorghums, Fla. Entomol., 73:111-117, 1990. 15. Doggett, H., Sorghum, Longmans, Green and Co. Ltd., London, 1970. 16. Doggett, H., Sorghum, In: N. W. Simmonds, Ed., Evolution of Crop Plants, Longman, New York, 1976, 112. 17. Doggett, H., Sorghum, Longman Scientific and Technical, Harlow, Essex, 1988. 18. Dreyer, D. L. and B. C. Campbell, Association of the degree of methylation of intercellular pectin with plant resistance to aphids and with induction of aphid biotypes, Experimentia, 40:224-226, 1984. 19. Duncan, R. R., J. Dahlberg, and M. Spinks, International activities in sorghum germplasm acquisition during the past thirty-five years, In: International Germplasm Transfer: Past and Present, Special Publication 23, Crop Science Society of America, Madison, 1995, 117. 20. Eaton, A., Manual of Botany for the Northern and Middle States of America, Containing Generic and Specific Descriptions of Indigenous Plants and Common Cultivated Exotics, Growing North of Virginia, Websters and Skinners, Albany, 1922.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
21. Eddleman, B. R., C. C. Chang, and B. A. McCarl, Economic Benefits from INTSORMIL Grain Sorghum Variety Improvements in the United States, Tex. Agric. Exp. Stn. Report TAMRF 9045, Texas A&M University, College Station, 1991. 22. Ehrlich, P. R. and P. H. Raven, Butterflies and plants, Evolution, 18:586-608, 1964. 23. Ervin, R. T., T. M. Khalema, G. C. Peterson, and G. L. Teetes, Cost/benefit analysis of a sorghum hybrid resistant to sorghum midge (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae), Southwest. Entomol., 21:105-115, 1996. 24. FAO, FAO Production Yearbook, FAO Statistics Series, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome, 1995. 25. Foster, D. G., Sorghums Resistant to the Banks Grass Mite, Oligonychus pratensis (Banks), M.S. Thesis, Texas A&M University, College Station, 1976. 26. Gebrekidan, B., Breeding sorghum for resistance to insects in Eastern Africa, Insect Sci. Appl., 6:351-357, 1985. 27. Guiragossian, V. and J. A. Mihm, Improving host-plant resistance to fall armyworm and sugarcane borer in sorghum, In: Proc. Int. Sorghum Entomology Workshop, 15-21 July 1984, Texas A&M University, College Station, ICRISAT, 1985, 201. 28. Hagio, T., M. Umehara, and S. Ono, Varietal reaction of sorghum to sugarcane aphid (Melanaphis sacchari Zehntner) in the seedling stage, Sorghum Newsl., 28:51-52, 1985. 29. Hallman, G. J., G. L. Teetes, and J. W. Johnson, Relationship of sorghum midge (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae) density to damage to resistant and susceptible sorghum hybrids, J. Econ. Entomol., 77:83-87, 1984. 30. Harlan, J. R., Crops and Man, American Society of Agronomy, Madison, 1975. 31. Harris, K. M., The sorghum midge, Contarinia sorghicola (Coq.), in Nigeria, Bull. Entomol. Res., 52:129-146, 1961. 32. Harris, K. M., The sorghum midge complex (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae): taxonomy, biology and assessments of field populations, Bull. Entomol. Res., 63:305-325, 1963. 33. Harris, K. M., The sorghum midge: a review of published information, 1895-1983, Proc. Int. Sorghum Entomology Workshop, 15-21 July 1984, Texas A&M University, College Station, ICRISAT, 1985, 229. 34. Harris, M. K., Allopatric resistance: searching for sources of insect resistance for use in agriculture, Environ. Entomol., 4:661-669, 1975. 35. Harris, M. K., Arthropod-plant interactions related to agriculture, emphasizing host plant resistance, In: M. K. Harris, Ed., Biology and Breeding for Resistance to Arthropods and Pathogens in Agricultural Plants, Tex. Agric. Exp. Stn., MP-1451, Texas A&M University, College Station, 1980, 23. 36. Harvey, T. L. and H. L. Hackerott, Recognition of a greenbug biotype injurious to sorghum, J. Econ. Entomol., 62:776-779, 1969. 37. Hayes, W. P., Observations on insects attacking sorghums, J. Econ. Entomol., 15:349-356, 1922. 38. Howitt, A. J. and R. H. Painter, Field and Greenhouse Studies Regarding the Sources and Nature of Resistance of Sorghums, Sorghum vulgare Pers., to the Corn Leaf Aphid, Rhopalosiphum maidis (Fitch), Agric. Exp. Stn., Tech. Bull. 82, Kansas State College of Agriculture and Applied Science, Manhattan, 1956. 39. Hoy, M. A., Insect Molecular Genetics: An Introduction to Principles and Applications, Academic Press, San Diego, 1994. 40. Jermy, T., Evolution of insect/host plant relationships, Am. Nat., 124:609-630, 1984. 41. Johnson, J. W., D. T. Rosenow, and G. L. Teetes, Resistance to the sorghum midge in converted exotic sorghum cultivars, Crop Sci., 13:754-755, 1973.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
42. Johnson, J. W., G. L. Teetes, and D. T. Rosenow, Evaluation of sorghum hybrids for resistance to the corn leaf aphid, Sorghum Newsl., 18:91, 1975. 43. Katsar, C. S., A. H. Paterson, G. C. Peterson, and G. L. Teetes, Use of molecular genetics to improve greenbug resistance in sorghum, In: Proc. 20th Biennial Grain Sorghum Res. and Utilization Conf., New Orleans, 1997, 71. 44. Lin, Y-R., K. F. Schertz, and A. H. Paterson, Comparative analysis of QTLs affecting plant height and maturity across the Poaceae, in reference to an interspecific sorghum population, Genetics, 141:391-411, 1995. 45. Mann, J. A., C. T. Kimber, and F. R. Miller, The Origin and Early Cultivation of Sorghums in Africa, Tex. Agric. Exp. Stn. Bull., Texas A&M University, College Station, 1454, 1983. 46. Manthe, C. S., Sorghum Resistance to the Sugarcane Aphid (Homoptera: Aphididae), Ph.D. Dissertation, Texas A&M University, College Station, 1992. 47. Martin, J. H., Sorghum Improvement, USDA Agricultural Yearbook, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C., 1936. 48. Martin, J. H., History and classification of sorghum, Sorghum bicolor (Linn.) Moench, In: J. S. Wall and W. M. Ross, Eds., Sorghum Production and Utilization, Avi Publishing, Westport, 1970, 1. 49. McColloch, J. W., The corn leaf aphid (Aphis maidis Fitch) in Kansas, J. Econ. Entomol., 14:89-94, 1921. 50. Mize, T. W. and G. Wilde, New resistant germplasm to the chinch bug (Heteroptera: Lygaeidae) in grain sorghum: contribution of tolerance and antixenosis as resistance mechanisms, J. Econ. Entomol., 79:42-45, 1986. 51. Mote, U. N., M. D. Shinde, and D. R. Bapat, Screening of sorghum collections for resistance to aphids and oily malady of winter sorghum, Sorghum Newsl., 28:13, 1985. 52. Murdock, G. P., Africa: Its People and Their Culture History, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1959. 53. Nwanze, K. F., N. Seetharama, H. C. Sharma, and J. W. Stenhouse, Biotechnology in pest management: improving resistance in sorghum to insect pests, African Crop Sci. J., 3:209-215, 1995. 54. Paterson, A. H., Y-R. Lin, Z. Li, K. F. Schertz, J. F. Doebley, S. R. M. Pinson, S-C. Liu, J. W. Stansel, and J. E. Irvine, Convergent domestication of cereal crops by independent mutations at corresponding genetic loci, Science, 269:1714-1718, 1995. 55. Pi, C-P. and J-S. Hsieh, Preliminary studies on aphid resistance in sorghum, Natl. Sci. Counc. Monthly, 10:153-160, 1982. 56. Porter, D. R., J. D. Burd, K. A. Shufran, J. A. Webster, and G. L. Teetes, Greenbug (Homoptera: Aphididae) biotypes: selected by resistant cultivars or preadapted opportunists?, J. Econ. Entomol., 90:1055-1065, 1997. 57. Powers, T. O., S. G. Jensen, S. D. Kindler, C. J. Stryker, and L. J. Sandall, Mitochondrial DNA divergence among greenbug (Homoptera: Aphididae) biotypes, Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am., 82:298-302, 1989. 58. Quinby, J. R., Sorghum Improvement and the Genetics of Growth, Texas A&M University Press, College Station, 1974. 59. Quinby, J. R., N. W. Kramer, J. C. Stephens, K. A. Lahr, and R. E. Karper, Grain Sorghum Production in Texas, Tex. Agric. Exp. Stn. B-912, Texas A&M University, College Station, 1958. 60. Rondani, C., Aphis graminum n. sp., Nuov. Ann. Sci. Nat. Bologna, 6:9-11, 1852.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
61. Rossetto, C. J., Tipos de Resistencia de Sorgo, Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench, a Contarinia sorghicola (Coquillett, 1898), Tese de Livre Docente, Universidade Estadual Paulista “Julio de Mesquita Filho,” Jaboticabal, 1977. 62. Schertz, K. F., Biology of sorghum, In: M. K. Harris, Ed., Biology and Breeding for Resistance to Arthropods and Pathogens in Agricultural Plants, Tex. Agric. Exp. Stn. MP-1451, Texas A&M University, College Station, 1980, 124. 63. Sharma, H. C., Host plant resistance to insects in sorghum and its role in integrated pest management, Crop Prot., 12:11-34, 1993. 64. Sharma, H. C. and V. F. Lopez, Genotypic resistance in sorghum to head bug, Calocoris angustatus Lethiery, Euphytica, 58:193-200, 1992. 65. Sharma, H. C., S. L. Taneja, K. Leuschner, and K. F. Nwanze, Techniques to Screen Sorghum for Resistance to Insect Pests, ICRISAT Information Bull. 32, Andhra Pradesh, 1992. 66. Shufran, K. A., W. C. Black IV, and D. C. Margolies, DNA fingerprinting to study spatial and temporal distributions of an aphid, Schizaphis graminum (Homoptera: Aphididae), Bull. Entomol. Res., 81:303-313, 1991. 67. Starks, K. J. and Z. B. Mayo, Jr., Biology and control of the greenbug attacking sorghum, In: Proc. Int. Sorghum Entomology Workshop, 15-21 July 1984, Texas A&M University, College Station, ICRISAT, Andhra Pradesh, 1985, 149. 68. Starks, K. J. and K. A. Mirkes, Yellow sugarcane aphid: plant resistance in cereal crops, J. Econ. Entomol., 72:486-488, 1979. 69. Starks, K. J. and D. E. Weibel, Sorghum cultivars rated for resistance to chinch bug, Sorghum Newsl., 25:82-83, 1982. 70. Stephens, J. C., F. R. Miller, and D. T. Rosenow, Conversion of alien sorghums to early combine genotypes, Crop Sci., 7:396, 1967. 71. Teetes, G. L., Entomology of johnsongrass/sorghum/sorghum midge and agriculture, In: M. K. Harris and C. E. Rogers, Eds., The Entomology of Indigenous and Naturalized Systems in Agriculture, Westview Press, Boulder, 1988, 125. 72. Tryon, H., The insect enemies of cereals belonging to the genus Cecidomyia, Trans. Nat. Hist. Soc. Queensland, 1:80-83, 1895. 73. Waquil, J. M., G. L. Teetes, and G. C. Peterson, Adult sorghum midge (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae) nonpreference for resistant hybrid sorghum, J. Econ. Entomol., 79:455-458, 1986. 74. Waquil, J. M., G. L. Teetes, and G. C. Peterson, Sorghum midge (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae) adult ovipositional behavior on resistant and susceptible sorghum hybrids, J. Econ. Entomol., 79:530-532, 1986. 75. Webster, F. M., Investigations of Toxoptera graminum and its parasites, Ann. Entomol. Soc. Am., 2:67-87, 1909. 76. Webster, F. M. and W. J. Phillips, The spring grain-aphis or 'green bug', USDA Bur. Entomol. Bull., 110:1-153, 1912. 77. Webster, J. A., Yellow sugarcane aphid (Homoptera: Aphididae): detection and mechanisms of resistance among Ethiopian sorghum lines, J. Econ. Entomol., 83:1053-1057, 1990. 78. Wiseman, B. R. and G. R. Lovell, Resistance to the fall armyworm in sorghum seedlings from Ethiopia and Yemen, J. Agric. Entomol., 5:17-20, 1988. 79. Wuensche, A. L., An Assessment of Plant Resistance to the Sorghum Midge, Contarinia sorghicola, in Selected Lines of Sorghum bicolor, Ph.D. Dissertation, Texas A&M University, College Station, 1980.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Section II Legume Crops
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
5
Bean Germplasm Resources for Insect Resistance Cesar Cardona and Julia Kornegay
CONTENTS I. Introduction II. Genetic Resources III. Host Plant Resistance for Major Pests A. Leafhoppers B. Bean Stem Maggot C. Bean Pod Weevil D. Mexican Bean Weevil and Bean Weevil E. Mexican Bean Beetle F. Other Arthropods IV. Conclusions References
I. INTRODUCTION The common bean, Phaseolus vulgaris L., is the world’s most important edible foodlegume (Table 1). Approximately 18 mmt of dry beans and 3 mmt of snap beans are produced annually. Nearly 80% of dry bean production occurs in developing countries on small-scale farms. Latin America, the center of Phaseolus domestication, produces nearly half of the world’s supply of dry beans. The principle producing countries or regions are Brazil, Mexico, and Central America. Africa, with nearly 4 million ha of annual bean production, is a secondary center for bean genetic diversity. The major producers are Kenya, Zaire, Tanzania, Uganda, Burundi, Rwanda, and Ethiopia. A significant amount of dry beans are also grown in Eastern Europe and North America. More than 50,000 ha of snap beans are grown annually in China.60 Beans play an increasingly important role in human nutrition in Africa where they are the second most important source of dietary protein and the third most important source of calories.60 Beans are ranked fourth as a protein source in Latin America.
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 1 The Global Importance of Common Beans as Compared to Other Edible Food Legumes Food legume
Production (mt)
Percent (%)
Common bean Chickpea Faba bean Lentil Cowpea Total
17,973,300 8,036,670 3,773,040 2,772,860 2,532,270 35,088,140
51.2 22.9 10.8 7.9 7.2 100.0
From FAOSTAT (Food Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Production Statistics), on the World Wide Web (http://apps.fao.org), 1997. (Ref. 25)
TABLE 2 Status of the Phaseolus Bean Collection Available at CIAT Species Domesticated P. vulgaris P. lunatus P. coccineus P. polyanthus P. acutifolius Other wild speciesa Total a
Wild
Cultivated
Total accessions
856 149 69 2 145
24,532 1,527 529 290 127
25,388 1,676 598 292 272 167 28,393
Includes 21 species.
From CIAT (Centro Internacional de Agricultura Tropical), Bean Program Ann. Rep., Cali, 1996. (Ref. 21)
II.
GENETIC RESOURCES
The largest Phaseolus germplasm collection is housed at the Centro Internacional de Agricultura Tropical (CIAT), Cali, Colombia. Out of 28,000 available accessions, approximately 25,000 are cultivated and wild P. vulgaris; the remaining 3,000 accessions are domesticated and wild species of Phaseolus (Table 2). More than 60 countries have donated Phaseolus germplasm to the CIAT collection since its formation in 1969, with the most important collections coming from Mexico, Honduras, Costa Rica, U.S., Colombia, Peru, Ecuador, and England.34 Another major Phaseolus collection (13,467 accessions) is maintained by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service, Western Regional Plant Introduction © 1999 by CRC Press LLC
Station (WRPIS), Pullman, Washington.82 Other repositories at the N. I. Vavilov Institute, Russia, the Instituto Nacional de Investigaciones Agrícolas (INIA), Mexico, and the University of Cambridge, U.K., store and maintain sizeable collections.34
III.
HOST PLANT RESISTANCE FOR MAJOR PESTS
More than 100 insects and other invertebrate pests have been recorded on beans. Of these, about 14 are major pests of the crop.13 Whiteflies Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius) and Trialeurodes vaporariorum (Westwood), leafhopper Empoasca kraemeri Ross & Moore, chrysomelids Diabrotica balteata LeConte and Cerotoma facialis Erickson, Mexican bean weevil Zabrotes subfasciatus (Boheman), and bean weevil Acanthoscelides obtectus (Say) are widely distributed and important in Latin America. Bean pod weevil Apion godmani Wagner, Mexican bean beetle Epilachna varivestis Mulsant, and slug Vaginulus plebeius (Fisher) are important in parts of Mexico and Central America. In the U.S., Mexican bean beetle, seedcorn maggot Delia platura Meigen, and mites Tetranychus spp. are the main pests of beans.67 Bean stem maggot or bean fly, Ophiomyia spp., is the key pest in Africa, followed by chrysomelid Ootheca bennigsenni Weise, pod borer Maruca testulalis (Geyer), aphids Aphis craccivora Koch and A. fabae Scopoli, and bruchids.1 The economic importance of the invertebrate species affecting beans varies widely between and within regions. In spite of their impact on yield and crop quality, this crop has been neglected and only in recent times has there been a concerted effort to breed for resistance to insects. Knowledge on mechanisms of resistance, inheritance, and biochemical basis of resistance is limited to a few major pests and breeding efforts are limited to five species. It is unfortunate that no useful sources of resistance have been reported for several economically important polyphagous pests such as whiteflies, chrysomelids, leafminers, thrips, and pod borers (Table 3). Bean cropping systems and insect control tactics vary widely, from total reliance on natural control in most of Africa to excessive use of insecticides in the hillsides of the Andes.1,20 For most bean farmers who cannot afford costly pesticides, or do not know how to use them, host plant resistance is the best method of insect control. Plant resistance in beans and other smallholder crops should receive more attention. Pesticide use in the developing world is increasing and there is growing awareness of human health hazards and environmental degradation.5,78 It was initially thought that increases in Latin America were mainly caused by the growth of plantation crops, an important source of export revenue.5 However, the developing world’s share of the world agrochemical usage, currently valued at $10.6 billion (U.S.) is forecast to rise from 19% to an estimated 35% by the year 2000.78 Much of this growth stems from a wider and more intensive use of chemical protection by smallholder farmers. Extensive use of pesticides by many bean farmers in Central and South America began after the mid-1970s.70 Recent surveys by CIAT and national agricultural research organizations in this region show that many bean growers have adopted the risky and environmentally degrading practice of conducting weekly, and often unnecessary, insecticidal sprays with up to 22 applications in 90 days.19 Given this situation, and because biological control and cultural practices have limited scope in © 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 3 Major Arthropod Pests of Beans and their Present Status in Terms of Development of Host Plant Resistance Resistance Insecta Bean pod weevil Bean stem maggot Bean weevil Chrysomelids Helicoverpa Leafhopper Leafminers Lygus bug Mexican bean beetle Mexican bean weevil Red mite Seed corn maggot Thrips Whiteflies a b
Sources
Mechanism
Inheritance
Breeding methodsb
Yes Yes Yes No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes?
Antibiosis, antixenosis Tolerance, antixenosis Antibiosis — — Tolerance, antixenosis — Antibiosis, antixenosis Tolerance, antixenosis Antibiosis Tolerance Unknown — —
Two genes Polygenic (?) Two genes — — Polygenic — Unknown Unknown Monogenic Unknown Unknown — —
P P BC — — RS — None None BC None None — —
Scientific names in text. BC, backcross; P, pedigree; RS, recurrent selection.
beans,70 the need for a more sustained effort in developing insect-resistant cultivars is evident. In this chapter, we summarize and discuss present knowledge on host plant resistance to major insect pests of beans.
A. LEAFHOPPERS The leafhopper E. kraemeri is the most important insect pest of common beans in Latin America and southern Florida.70,73 In North America, E. fabae Harris is the principal species attacking beans.63,69 Under early infestations, yield losses to E. kraemeri feeding can be as high as 95%.70 Thousands of bean germplasm accessions from the CIAT, WRPIS, and other repositories have been screened for resistance to leafhoppers. Low levels of resistance to E. fabae were detected after screening over a thousand bean varieties, breeding lines, and WRPIS accessions in the late 1950s and early 1960s in the U.S.80 Additional screening for E. fabae resistance was conducted in North America.46,69 When several thousand accessions from the CIAT Phaseolus collection were evaluated for resistance to E. kraemeri, only 4% of 18,000 accessions were resistant.43 High levels of resistance to E. kraemeri also have been identified in P. acutifolius A. Gary20,21 and P. lunatus L.49 accessions. Tolerance to feeding damage is the most common mechanism of resistance to leafhoppers in common beans.42,80 Electronic feeding studies showed that leafhopper probing and feeding behavior on a tolerant cultivar (EMP 84) was less damaging to
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
the plant than that exhibited on a susceptible cultivar.8 This tolerance may be related to a unique behavior adjustment of the leafhopper, which leads to less feedinginduced damage. In addition, free and no-choice feeding and ovipositional experiments identified low to moderate levels of nonpreference (antixenosis) to leafhopper oviposition in some cultivars.42,43,79 Although Pillemer and Tingey63 found that hooked trichomes reduced E. fabae nymphal populations on two bean cultivars, this resistance mechanism does not affect E. kraemeri. Resistance to E. kraemeri is quantitatively inherited.27,44 Additive and dominance gene effects were significant for plant yield in three resistant lines under leafhopper attack, but the magnitude of the dominance gene effects was greater than the additive effect.44 For nymphs per leaf, only additive gene effects were significant in two lines, EMP 89 and EMP 94, having moderate levels of antixenosis to leafhopper oviposition. Transgressive segregation for higher yield under leafhopper attack was found in F2 populations combining antixenosis and tolerance resistance mechanisms. More than 300 E. kraemeri-resistant breeding lines have been developed as a result of breeding for bean resistance to this pest at CIAT. Based on the results of the inheritance and combining ability studies, a modified recurrent selection program was developed to increase bean yields under leafhopper attack.39 The advantage of this breeding strategy is that it increases the frequencies of genes with additive effects which may be at a low level initially in the population. Selection can be delayed within populations until later generations when the genotypes are relatively fixed. Genotype by environment interactions are also minimized by the repeated evaluation and yield testing of breeding populations over time. The modified recurrent selection breeding program has been successful in increasing overall tolerance to leafhopper feeding damage and in incorporating resistance into a wide variety of bean market types (Table 4).17 By the sixteenth cycle of recurrent selection, there was significant progress in increasing resistance within small, red-seeded lines, a group that had been difficult to improve in earlier cycles. Breeding lines that were developed using a pedigree breeding strategy had non-protected yields 10 to 16% below that of “ICA Pijao,” the standard commercial check cultivar, while lines developed using the modified recurrent selection breeding strategy had yields ranging 9 to 17% above “ICA Pijao.”39 The most resistant lines have leafhopper action threshold levels equivalent to seven nymphs per leaf compared with the susceptible check cultivar with three nymphs per leaf.11,18 Some of E. kraemeri-resistant lines developed at CIAT also show high levels of tolerance to E. fabae in Canada.69 Of these, several small, white-seeded EMP lines show the greatest promise as they combine resistance to leafhoppers, high yields, and good canning qualities required by farmers and consumers.
B. BEAN STEM MAGGOT The bean stem maggot or bean fly is one of the most important pests of common bean in Africa, Asia, and Australia, causing complete loss of bean seedlings and more mature plants in certain areas.22,31,47,55,77 It has not been reported in the Americas. Three species of bean stem maggot attack beans (1) O. phaseoli (Tryon), (2) O. spencerella Greathead, and (3) O. centrosematis de Meijere. In Africa,
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
TABLE 4 Best Carioca, Cream, and Red-Seeded Bean Lines from the XVII Cycle of Recurrent Selection for Leafhopper Resistance Yield (kg/ha) Line Carioca EMP 413 EMP 412 EMP 407 EMP 332b Cream EMP 392 EMP 400 EMP 394 EMP 267c “ICA Pijao” d BAT 41 e Red EMP 385 EMP 375 EMP 378 EMP 335f “ICA Pijao” d BAT 41e
Protected
Unprotected
Susceptibility index
% Gain in tolerance a
2750 2388 2171 2099
1924 1750 1597 1459
0.77 0.79 0.84 0.88
33.6 31.9 27.6 24.1
2487 2180 2398 1985 2315 1849
1865 1708 1631 1261 867 276
0.67 0.69 0.76 0.89 1.15 1.51
41.2 39.4 33.3 21.9 — —
2890 2196 2342 2380 2326 1993
2442 2014 2024 1543 1077 269
0.67 0.70 0.73 1.01 1.33 1.92
49.6 47.3 45.1 24.2 — —
Adapted from CIAT (Centro Internacional de Agricultura Tropical), Bean Program Ann. Rep., Cali, 1992. (Ref. 17) a With respect to the tolerant check (“ICA Pijao”). b Improved Carioca check. c Improved Cream check. d Tolerant check. e Susceptible check. f Improved Red check.
O. phaseoli is the most important species. However, O. phaseoli and O. spencerella were reported as equally important pests at two sites in Kenya, but their prevalence depended on environmental conditions.55 The major damage to a bean plant is caused by third instar larvae, which destroy the medullar tissue of the stem at ground level. The concentration of puparia in the stems causes swelling, splitting, and rotting of the base of affected plants. Infested bean seedlings suffer premature leaf fall and are either killed or severely stunted.1 Evaluations of bean cultivars for resistance to bean stem maggot have been done in Ethiopia, Malawi, Tanzania, Uganda, and Taiwan.16,21,31,37 Msangi and Karel54 reported that cultivars with high numbers of leaf trichomes had lower oviposition punctures in Tanzania. Low O. phaseoli larval and pupal counts were also correlated with narrow stem diameters. Nevertheless, few of the reportedly resistant cultivars
© 1999 by CRC Press LLC
have been consistently resistant to bean stem maggot. In addition, the CIAT core collection of P. vulgaris was field evaluated in Tanzania to identify new sources of resistance to this insect.21 Several germplasm accessions from Africa, Mexico, Guatemala, and Peru exhibited high levels of resistance in the initial screenings. Evaluation of the core collection is continuing in Tanzania and Ethiopia. Tolerance to stem damage caused by pupating larvae is reported as a mechanism of resistance to O. phaseoli. Low egg counts were associated with high leaf pubescence, thin stems, and long internodes.37,65 Other studies indicate that nonpreference for oviposition, differential larval survival and development, and tolerance may be involved in resistance to bean stem maggot.21 Because of difficulties in identifying good sources of resistance to bean stem maggot, only limited breeding work has been undertaken for this pest. When crosses were made between “Ikinimba” and “ZPV 292” and local Tanzanian susceptible lines, the progeny from “Ikinimba” as a parent had generally less plant mortality in both generations than progeny from “ZPV 298.”