FUNCTIONALLY GRADED MATERIALS 1996
Organized and sponsored by THE FCM FORUM THE SOCIETY OF NON-TRADITIONAL TECHNOLOGY...
35 downloads
2922 Views
45MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
FUNCTIONALLY GRADED MATERIALS 1996
Organized and sponsored by THE FCM FORUM THE SOCIETY OF NON-TRADITIONAL TECHNOLOGY Supported by SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY AGENCY, JAPAN
FUNCTIONALLY GRADED MATERIALS 1996 Proceedings of the 4th international symposium on Functionally Graded Materials, AIST Tsukuba Research center, Tsukuba, Japan, October 21-24,1996
Edited by
ICHIRO SHIOTA Department of Environmental Chemical Engineering, Kogakuin university, 2665-1, Nakanocho, Hachioji, Tokyo 192, Japan
YOSHINARI MIYAMOTO The Research center for Cyclic Loop Systems for Processing and iviaintenance. Joining and welding Research institute, Osaka university, ibaraki, Osaka 567, Japan
ELSEVIER Amsterdam - Lausanne • New York - Oxford - Shannon - Singapore - Tokyo 1997
ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. Sara Burgerhartstraat 25 P.O. Box 211,1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
ISBN 0 444 82548 7 © 1997, ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elsevier Science B.V., copyright & Permissions Department, P.O. BOX 521,1000 AM Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Special regulations for readers in the u.S.A.-This publication has been registered with the copyright Clearance Center inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923. information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the U.S.A. All other copyright questions, including photocopying outside of the U.S.A., should be referred to the copyright owner, Elsevier Science B.V., unless otherwise specified. No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. This book is printed on acid-free paper Printed in The Netherlands
PREFACE
A formulated concept of functionally graded materials(FGMs) was proposed in 1984 by material scientists in Sendai area, Japan, as a means of preparing thermal barrier materials, and a coordinated research was developed in that country since 1986. The idea, that continuously changes in the composition, microstructure, porosity, etc., of these materials resulting in gradients in such properties as mechanical strength and thermal conductivity, has spreaded world-wide during the past ten years through the research. Aiming at opening channels among researchers working in state-of-the-art FGM topics and at discussing further developments in the FGM field, the first FGM symposium was held in Sendai, the birthplace of FGMs, in 1990 followed by the 2nd in San Francisco, 1992, and then the 3rd in Lausanne, 1994. Through these activities, the idea of graded structures and functions has attracted the attention of many scientists and researchers for its boundless scope in materials science and engineering. In this symposium, nearly three hundreds participants joined in order to exchange information which covers all aspects of functionally graded materials including their design, process and evaluation of structure, function, and integration, as well as applications. In particular, it should be noted that fifty five of these participants were from many countries in the worid. As a chairman of this symposium, I expect that this proceedings will be useful for FGM scientists and engineers, and will contribute to promote the research and development of FGMs in future.
V*^' Mitsue Koizumi Chairman
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
LIST OF ORGANIZING COMMITTEE
Chairman: Vice-Chairman:
Prof. M. Koizumi (President of the FGM Forum, Ryukoku University) Prof T. Hirai (Tohoku University)
Advisory Committee Dr. L. I. Anatychuk Prof F. Erdogan Dr. R. Ford Prof A. Glaeser Mr. T. Hirano Prof N. Ichinose Prof B. Ilschner Mr. R. Imoto Dr. M. Kamimoto Prof W. Kaysser Mr. T. Kurino Dr. A. Mazurenko Prof A. Merzhanov Prof Z. Munir Dr. Y. Nikolaev Dr. B. Rabin Prof S. Suresh Prof R. Watanabe Prof R. Yuan
Institute of Thermoelectricity, Ukraine Lehigh University, Pennsylvania, USA Materials Technology, New York, USA University of California, Berkeley, USA Daikin Industries, Ltd., Kusatsu, Japan Waseda University, Tokyo, Japan Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Lausanne, Switzerland Science and Technology Agency, Tokyo, Japan Electrochemical Laboratory, Tsukuba, Japan German Aerospace Research Establishment, Koln, Germany The Society of Non-Traditional Technology, Tokyo, Japan Institute of General & Inorganic Chemistry, Kiev, Ukraine Institute of Structural Macrokinetics, Chemogolovka, Russia University of California, Davis, USA Research Institute of SIA LUCH, Moscow, Russia Idaho National Engineering Laboratory, Idaho Falls, USA Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, USA Tohoku University, Sendai, Japan Wuhan University, Wuhan, China
Executive Committee Prof Y. Tada (Chairman) Nihon University, Chiba Dr. K. Eguchi National Aerospace Laboratory, Tokyo Dr. R. Fukuda Electrotechnical Laboratory, Tsukuba Prof Y. Miyamoto Osaka University, Osaka Dr. M. Niino National Aerospace Laboratory, Kakuda Dr. I. A. Nishida National Research Institute for Metals, Tsukuba Prof I. Shiota Kogakuin University, Tokyo Ms. S. Tsuda The Society of Non-Traditional Technology, Tokyo Dr. S. Yatsuyanagi National Aerospace Laboratory, Kakuda
Program Committee Prof. I. Shiota (Chairman) Dr. N.Cherradi Prof. M. Gasik Prof T. Kawasaki Dr. A. Kumakawa Prof Y. Miyamoto Prof J. Yoshino
Kogakuin University, Tokyo, Japan Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Lausanne, Switzerland Helsinki University of Technology, Helsinki, Finland Tohoku University, Sendai, Japan National Aerospace Laboratory, Kakuda, Japan Osaka University, Osaka, Japan Tokyo Institute of Technology, Tokyo, Japan
Tsukuba Regional Committee Dr.R.Fukuda (Chairman) Dr.T.Fujii Mr.Y.Imai Mr.Y.Kasuga Dr.K.Kato Dr.I.Kojima Ms.M.Maeda Mr.A.Negishi Dr.I.A.Nishida Mr.Y.Nishio Mr.T.Ohta Dr.Y.Shinohara Mr.J.Teraki Mr.A.Yamamoto
ElectrotechnicalLaboratory,Tsukuba National Research Institute for Metals,Tsukuba National Research Institute for Metals,Tsukuba ElectrotechnicalLaboratory,Tsukuba National Institute of Materials&Chemical Research,Tsukuba National Institute of Materials&Chemical Research,Tsukuba The Society of Non-Traditional Technology,Tokyo Electrotechnical Laboratory,Tsukuba National Research Institute for Metals,Tsukuba Daikin Industries, Ltd.,Tsukuba Electrotechnical Laboratory,Tsukuba National Research Institute for Metals,Tsukuba Daikin Industries, Ltd.,Tsukuba Electrotechnical Laboratory,Tsukuba
CONTENTS
GENERAL TOPICS
FGM research programs in Japan -from structural to functional uses Mipmoto, Njino and Koizumi ............................................................................
1
Research program on gradient materials in Germany R&je/ and A. Neubrand.. ..............................................................................................
9
Lessons learnt in 7 years of FGM research at Lausanne
6.//schner .............................................................................................................................. PART I
15
STRUCTURAL MATERIALS
Design and Modeling
Local fields in functionally graded materials Y.D. Bi/otsky and M.M. Gasik ............................................................................................
21
Computer-aided process design for forming of pore-gradient membranes
c.w.
.............................................................................................................................
29
Mathematical model for axial-symmetrical FGM and C.C. ..................................................................................... X.D.
35
Stress analysis in a two materials joint with a functionally graded material y- Yang and D.Munz .........................................................................................................
41
Optimum design and fabrication of TiC/Ni,Al-Ni functionally graded materials Q- Shen, X.F. Tang, R. T", L.M. Zhang and R.Z. Yuan ..................................................
47
A mathematical model for particle distribution in functionally graded material produced by centrifugal cast B. Zhang, J. Zhu, Zhang, Z. Ying, H. Cheng and G.An ............................................
53
Modeling and measurement of stress evolution in FGMcoatings during fabrication by thermal spray S.Kuroda, y. Tashiro and Fukushima .........................................................................
59
Artificial neural network used for TiB,-Cu FGMdesign cao and C.C. .................................................................... Z C. Mu,Z.X.
65
Deformation analysis of graded powder compacts during sintering Shinagawa .......................................................................................................................
69
Simulation of the elasto-plastic deformations in compositionaily graded metalceramic structures: Mean-field and unit cell approaches H.E. Pettermann, E. Weissenbek and S. Suresh
75
Large deflections of heated functionally graded clamped rectangular plates with varying rigidity in thickness direction F. Mizuguchi and H. Ohnabe
81
Model investigation of ceramic-metal FGMs under dynamic thermal loading: Residual stress effect, thermal-mechanical coupling effect and materials hardening model effect O.J. Zhang, P.C. Zhai and R.Z. Yuan
87
Fractal geometry and it's implications to surface technology D.P. Bhatt, O.P. Bahl, R. Schumacher and H. Meyer
93
Database system for project of the functionally graded materials K. Kisara, A. Moro, Y.S. Kang and M. Niino 1-2
99
Fracture Analysis
Fracture mechanics of graded materials F. Erdogan Microstructural effects in functionally graded thermal barrier coatings M.J. Pindera, J. Aboudi and S.M. Arnold
105 113
Micromechanical failure criterion for FGM architecture studied via disk-bend testing of Zr02/Ni composites T. Ishizuka, Y. Ohta and K. Wakashima Thermomechanical response characteristics of ZrOg/Ni functionally graded materials: An experimental study to check model predictions T. Ishizuka, C.S. Kang and K. Wakashima Micromechanical approach to the thermomechanical analysis of FGMs S. Nomura and D.M. Sheahen Effect of gradient microstructure on thermal shock crack extension in metal/ceramic functionally graded materials A. Kawasaki and R Watanabe Thermal fracture mechanisms in functionally graded coatings K. Koklnl, Y.R. TakeuchI and B.D. Choules 1-3
123
131 137
143 149
Powder Metallurgical Process
Fabrication of AIN/W functionally graded materials K. Sogabe, M. Tanaka, T. Mlura and M. Tobloka Graded casting for producing smoothly varying gradients in materials B.R. Marple and S. Tuffe
155 159
XI
Gradient components with a high melting point difference M. Joensson, U. Birth and B. Kieback
167
Fabrication of pore-gradient membranes via centrifugal casting aw. Hong, F.Muller and P. Greil
173
Mechanical properties and microstructure of insituTiCp reinforced aluminum base FGM by centrifugal cast a Zhang, J. Zhu, Y. Zhang, Z Ying, H. Cheng and G. An
179
Dispersion and fabrication of ZrOj/SUSSIG functionally graded material by tape casting process J.G. Yeo, Y.G. Jung and S.C. Choi
185
Fabrication of ZrOj/Ni and ZrOj/AljOg functionally graded materials by explosive powder consolidation technique A Chiba, M. Nishida, K. Imamura, H. Oguraand Y. Morizono
191
Development of metal/intermetallic compound functionally graded material produced by eutectic bonding method S. Kihhara, T. Tsujimoto and Y. Tomota
197
Mechanical performance of Zr02-Ni functionally graded material by powder metallurgy J.C. Zhu, S.Y. Lee, ZD. Yin andZH. Lai
203
Fabrication of PSZ-SUS 304 functionally graded materials H. Kobayashi
209
Preliminary characterization of interlayer for Be/Cu functionally gradient materials - thermophysical properties of Be/Gu sintered compacts S. Saito, N. Sakamoto, K. Nishida and H. Kawamura 1-4
215
Deposition and Spray Process
Electrophoretic forming of functionally-graded barium/strontium titanate ceramics P. Sarker, S. Sakaguchi, E. Yonehara, J. Hamagami, K. Yamashita and T. Umegaki Processing and properties of electrodeposited functionally graded composite coatings of Ni-AI-AljOg K. Barmak, S.W. Banovic, H. M.Chan, L.E. Friedersdorf, M.P. Harmer, A.R. Marder, CM. Petronis, D.G. Puerta and D.F. Susan Functionally graded materials by electrochemical modification of porous preforms A Neubrand, R. Jedamzik and J. Rode! Thermal management of carbon-carbon composites by functionally graded fiber arrangement technique Y. Kude and Y. Sohda
221
227
233
239
Xll
Formation and properties of TiC/Mo FGM coatings T. Fukushima, S. Kuroda, S. Kitahara, K. Ishida and M. Sano Formation of a Ti-AlgOa functionally graded surface layer on a Ti substrate with the use of ultraflne particles A Otsuka, H. Tanizaki, M. Niiyama and K. Iwasaki
245
251
Oxidation-resistant SiC coating system of C/C composites N. Sato, I. Shiota, H. Hatta, T. Aoki and H. Fukuda
257
AljOg-ZrOj graded thermal barrier coatings by EB-PVD-concept, microstructure and phase stability U. Leushake, U. Schuiz, T. Krell, M. Peters and WA. Kaysser
263
Microstructure characteristic of plasma sprayed ZrOj/NiCoCrAlY graded coating Z Yin, X. Xiang, J. Zhu and Z Lai 1-5
269
Reaction Forming Process
Formation of functionally-graded materials through centrifugally-assisted combustion synthesis W. Lai, ZA. Munir, BJ. McCoy and S.H. Risbud
275
SHS - a new technological approach for creation of novel multilayered diamondcontaining materials with graded structure E.A. Levashov, LP. Borovinskaya, A.V. Yatsenko, M. Ohyanagi, S. Hosomi and M. Koizumi 283 Graded dispersion of diamond in TiB2-based cermet by SHS/dynamic pseudo isostatic compaction(DPIC) M Ohyanagi, T. Tsujikami, M. Koizumi, S. Hosomi, E.A. Levashov and l.P. Borovinskaya
289
Annealing of ceramic/metal graded materials fabricated by SHS/QP method A.N. Pityulin, Z.Y. Fu, M.J. Jin, R.Z. Yuan and AG. Merzhanov
295
Thermodynamic calculation and processing of TiBg-Cu FGM C.C. Ge, Z.X. Wang and W.B. Cao
301
Fabrication of Al-Cu system with functionally graded density profiles R. Tu, O. Shen, J.S. Hua, L.M. Zhang and R.Z. Yuan
307
AlgOgto Ni-superalloy diffusion bonded FG-joints for high temperature applications L IHeikinheimo, M. Siren and M.M. Gasik 1-6
313
Novel Process
Advances in the fabrication of functionally graded materials using extrusion freeform fabrication G.E. Hilmas, J.L. Lombardi and R.A. IHoffman
319
Novel routes to functionally graded ceramics via atmosphere-induced dopant valence gradients M Kitayama, J.D. Powers and AM Glaeser
325
The growth of functionally graded crystals by verneuil's technique M Ueltzen, J.F. Fournie, C. Seega and H. Altenburg
331
Excimer laser processing of functionally graded materials Y. Uchida, J. Yamada, Y.P. Kathuria, N. Hayashi, S. Watanabe, S. Higa, H. Furuhashi and Y. Uchida
337
Development of stainless steel/PSZ functionally graded materials by means of an expression operation K. Taka, Y. Murakami, T. Ishikura, N. Hayashi, S. Watanabe, Y. Uchida, S.Higa, T.lmura and D. Dykes 343 Microwave sintering of metal-ceramic FGM M A Willert-Porada and R. Borchert
349
Residual stress control of functionally graded materials via pulse-electric discharge consolidation with temperature gradient control H. Kimura and T. Satoh
355
Study on the composition graded cemented carbide/steel by spark plasma sintering A Ikegaya, K. Uchino, T. Miyagawa and H. Kaneta
361
Phase composition profile character of a functionally-graded AljTiOg/ZrOj-AljOa composite S. Pratapa, B.H. O'Connor and IM Low
367
The use of a functionally graded material in the manufacture of a graded permittivity element S. Watanabe, T. Ishikura, A. Tokumura, Y.Kim, N. Hayashi, Y. Uchida, S. Higa, D. Dykes and G. Touchard 373 1-7
Material Evaluation
Evaluation and modelling of the residual stresses generated on functionally graded materials - Two examples N. Cherradi, D. Delfosse and P. l\/loeckli Residual strains and stresses in an AljOg-Ni joint bonded with a composite interlayer: FEM predictions and experimental measurements B.H. Rabin, R L Williamson, H.A. Bruck, X.L. Wang, T.R. Watkins and D.R.Clarke Residual thermal stresses in functionally graded Ti-TiCx materials N. Frage, M.P. Dariel, U. Admon and A. Raveh
379
387 397
The effect of constituent and microstructure of composites on the residual thermal stress in TiC-NigAI FGMs J.H. Wang and LM Zhang 403 New application of FGMto identification of unknown multicomponent precipitates /. Itoh, H. Yamada, Y. Kojima, Y. Otoguro, H. Nakata and M. Matubara Evaluation of graded thermal barrier coating for gas turbine engine M Kawamura,Y. Matsuzaki, H. Hino and S. Okazaki Mechanical and electrical properties of multilayer composites of silicon carbide J. Hojo, F.Hongo, K. Kishi and S. Umebayashi
409 413 419
The effect of thermal shock on the thermal conductivity of a functionally graded material A J. Slifka, A Kumakawa, B.J. Filla, J.M. Phelps and N. Shimoda
425
Non-destructive evaluation of carbon fibre-reinforced structures using high frequency eddy current methods G. Mook, O. Koserand R. Lange
433
Thermal diffusivity measurement forSiC/C compositionally graded graphite materials J. Nakano, K. Fuji! and R. Yamada High-temperature ductility of TiC as evaluated by small punch testing and the effect of CrgCg additive L M Zhang, J.F. Li, R. Watanabe and T. Hirai Mechanical and thermal properties of PSZ/Ni-base superalloy composite S. Akama Processing-working stress unified analysis model and optimum design of ceramic-metal functionally graded materials P.C. Zhai, Q.J. Zhang and R.Z. Yuan
439
445 451
457
Evaluation test of C/C composites coated with SiC/C FGM, under simulated condition for aerospace application Y. Wakamatsu, T. Saito, F Ono, K. Ishida, T. Matsuzaki, O. Hamamura, Y.Sohda andYKude 463 Durability and high altitude performance tests of regeneratively cooled thrust engine made of ZrOg/Ni functionally graded materials Y. Kuroda, M. Tadano, A Moro, Y. Kawamata and N. Shimoda
469
XV
PART II 11-1
ENERGY CONVERSION, MATERIALS
ELECTRONIC AND ORGANIC
Thermoelectric Materials
Research on enhancement of thermoelectric figure of merit through functionally graded material processing technology in Japan T, Kajikawa
475
A design procedure of functionally graded thermoelectric materials J. Teraki and T. Hirano
483
Transport properties in multi-barrier systems Y. Nishio and T. Hirano
489
Theoretical estimation of thermoelectric figure of merit in sintered materials and proposal of grain-size-graded structures J. Yoshino
495
Computer design of thermoelectric functionally graded materials LI. Anatychuk and LA/. Vikhor
501
Anisotropic carrier scattering in n-type BijTejgsSeo 15 single crystal doped with HgBr^ I.J. Ohsugi, T. Kojima, H.T. Kaibe, M. Sakata and LA. Nishida
509
Percolation design of graded composite of powder metallurgically prepared SiGe and PbTe R. Watanabe, M. Miyajima, A. Kawasaki and H. Okamura
515
Design of multi-functionally graded structure of cylindrical Rl heat source for thermoelectric conversion system S. Amada, J. Terauchi and T. Senda
521
Fabrication of N-type polycrystalline Bi-Sb and their thermoelectric properties M Miyajima, G.G. Lee, A. Kawasaki and R. Watanabe
527
Development of functionally graded thermoelectric materials by PIES method A Yamamoto and T. Ohta
533
MIcrostructure and thermoelectric properties of p-type BiogSbigTea fabricated by hot pressing D.M. Lee, J.H. Seo, K. Park, I. Shiota and C.H. Lee
539
Microstructural and thermoelectric properties of hot-extruded p-type BiosSbigTeg J.H. Seo, D.M. Lee, K Park, J.H. Kim, I.A. Nishida and C.H. Lee •'• • Effect of dopants on thermoelectric properties and anisotropies for unidirectionally solidified n-BigTeg N. Abe, H. Kohri, I. Shiota and LA. Nishida Thermoelectric properties of arc-melted silicon borides L.D. Chen, T. Goto and T. Hirai
545
551 557
XVI
Graded thermoelectric materials by plasma spray forming J. Schilz, £ Muller, W.A. Kaysser, G. Langer, E. Lugscheider, G. Schiller and R.Henne • 563 Preparation of PbTe-FGM by joining melt-grown materials M Orihashi, Y, Noda, LD. Chen, Y.S. Kang, A. Moro and T. Hirai
569
Improvement and thermal stability of thermoelectric properties for n-type segmented PbTe S. Yoneda, H.T. Kaibe, T. Okumura, Y. Shinohara, Y Imai, LA. Nishida, T.Mochimaru, K. Takahashi, T. Noguchi and I. Shiota
575
Preparation and thermoelectric properties of IrSbg M Koshigoe, I. Shiota, Y. Shinohara, Y. Imai and LA. Nishida
581
p-n joining of melt-grown and sintered PbTe by plasma activated sintering Y.S. Kang, Y. Noda, LD. Chen, K. Kisara and M. Niino
587
Trial manufacture of functionally graded Si-Ge thermoelectric material T. Noguchi, K. Takahashi and T. Masuda
593
Microstructure and property of (Si-MoSigVSiGe thermoelectric converter unit J.S. Lin, K. Tanihata, Y. Miyamoto and H. Kido
599
Temperature dependence of the porosity controlled SiG/B4G+PSS thermoelectric properties K. Kato, A. Aruga, Y. Okamoto, J. Morimoto and T. Miyakawa Preparation of B4G-B system composites adding PSS and their thermoelectric properties A Aruga, K. Tsuneyoshi, Y. Okamoto and J. Morimoto
605
611
Joint of n-type PbTe with different carrier concentration and its thermoelectric properties Y. Imai, Y. Shinohara, LA. Nishida, M. Okamoto, Y. Isoda, T. Ohkoshi, T. Fujii, L Shiota and H.T. Kaibe 617 Effects of plasma treatment on thermoelectric properties of SigoGejo sintered alloys K. Kishimoto, Y. Nagamoto, T. Koyanagi and K. Matsubara Gontrol of temperature dependence of thermoelectric properties of manganese silicide by FGM approach T. Kajikawa, S. Suzuki, K. Shida and S. Sugihara Heat sensing device with thermoelectric film laid on insulated metal sheet T. Amano, N. Kamiya and S. Tokita 11-2
623
627 633
Thermionic IVIaterials
Recent developments in oxygenated thermionic converters J. L. Desplat
639
Development of refractory metal oxide collector materials and their thermionic converter performance R Fukuda, Y. Kasuga and K. Katoh
647
Thermionic properties and thermal stability of emitter with a (0001) oriented rhenium layer and graded structure M Katoh, R. Fukuda and T. Igarashi
655
Development of efficient thermionic energy converter T. Kato, K. Morimoto, K. Isogai, M. Kato, T. Fukushima and R. Fukuda
661
Radiation dose reduction by graded structures in the heat source of a ®°Sr radioisotope battery A Ohashi, K. Ueki and T. Senda
667
Output increase of thermionic energy converter due to the illumination of xenon short arc lamp Y. Shibahara and M. Kando
673
Hybrid mode concept of a thermionic converter with a FGM structured collector M Iwase and Y. Hirai
681
11-3
Electronic Materials
Thermoelectrically modulated/nanoscale multilayered gradient materials for application in the electromagnetic gun systems M A Otooni, J.F. Atkinson and LG. Brown Synthesis of In-Sb alloys by directional solidification in microgravity and normal gravity condition H. Minagawa, Y. Suzuki, K. Shimokawa, Y. Ueda, J. Nagao and J. Kawabata Full-colored zinc gallate phosphor with graded composition T. Endo, K. Uheda and H. Takizawa Synthesis and characterization of a model CuO/SnOg oxygen sensor P.J. Mailer, Z.S. Li, Q.L Guo
687
695 701 707
Fabrication of magnetic functionally graded material by martensitic transformation technique Y. Watanabe, Y. Nakamura and Y. Fukui
713
Characterization of single-crystalline Cu/Nb multilayer films by ion beam analysis S. Yamamoto, H. Naramoto, B. Tsuchiya and Y. Aoki
719
Enrichment of ^^Si by infrared laser irradiation T. Tanaka, I. Shiota, H. Suzuki and T. Noda
725
11-4
Natural, Organic and Intelligent Materials
Adaptive and functionally graded structure of bamboo S. Amada and N. Shimizu
731
XVlll
Learning about design of FGMsfrom intelligent modeling system in natural composites F.Nogata Development of the fire door with functionally graded wood H. Getto and S. Ishihara Elemental mapping of functionally graded dental implant in biocompatibility test F. Watari, A Yokoyama, F. Saso, M Uo, S. Ohkawa and T. Kawasaki Characteristics of epoxy-modified zirconium phosphate materials produced by an infiltration process AM Low, S. Yamaguchi, A. Nakahira and K. Niihara Preparation and properties of PVC/polymethacrylate graded blends by a dissolution - Diffusion method Y. Agari, M. Shimada, A. Ueda, T. Anan, R Nomura and Y. Kawasaki Preparation and properties of polyimide/Cu functionally graded material M Omori, A. Okubo, G.H. Kang and T. Hirai Smart functionally graded material without bending deformation J. Qiu, J. Tani and T. Soga
737 743 749
755
761 767 773
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
FGM research programs in Japan —from structural to functional uses Y.Miyamoto^ M.Niino^ and M.Koizumi'' ^ The Institute of Scientific and Industrial Research, Osaka University, Japan ^ National Aerospace Laboratories, Kakuda, Japan "^ Faculty of Science and Technology, Ryukoku University, Japan The FGM concept can be applied to various material fields for structural and functional uses. In Japan, several five-year programs have been conducted over the past ten years in order to develop the architecture of FGMs, and also to develop these materials for high temperature applications (e.g., components for the hypersonic space plane) and for functional applications (e.g., thermoelectric and thermionic converters). These programs are discussed with respect to the construction of FGM architecture and the future of FGMs. 1. APPLICATION OF THE FGM CONCEPT A functionally graded material (FGM) is a material in which the composition and structure gradually change resulting in a corresponding change in the properties of the material. This FGM concept can be applied to various materials for structural and functional uses. In order to create FGMs, the architecture of design, processing, and evaluation needs to be developed because no comprehensive study of such nonuniform materials has been carried out previously. The concept of integrating incompatible functions such as the refractoriness of ceramics and the toughness of metals with the relaxation of thermal stress, lead to a research project for the development of FGM architecture in 1987 [1]. In fact, it is possible to integrate a variety of dissimilar materials and properties if the thermal expansion mismatch or lattice mismatch can be relaxed and chemical compatibility can be maintained. Many applications exist that require high temperature resistance or thermal shock resistance, where the FGM concept can be applied. 2. THE DEVELOPMENT OF FGM ARCHITECTURE 2.1. For structural uses~the integration of refractoriness and toughness A five-year research program entitled "Fundamental Study on the Relaxation of Thermal Stress for High Temperature Materials by the Tailoring of Graded Structures" was established in 1987 with a total budget of 1,215 million yen under the auspice of the Science and Technology Agency. The goal was to develop the architecture of FGMs for structural uses and for high temperature components for the future hypersonic space plane. About 30 research organizations from national institutes, universities, and companies participated in the
Major Results of The FGM Program for 1987 -1991 CAD System: Inverse design model Selection of composition & microstructure Optimization of gradation Fuzzy function ,
Micromechanical Modeling: Correlation of graded microstructures & properties
Small Punch Test for Fracture energy
(3 Evaluation of Heat Shock: Xenon lamp irradiation. Burner Heating
immmm
r Stress Analysis by FEM J
Fractal & Percolation Theories: Quantitative analysis of gradation
Process Developments: CVD, PVD, PM, Plasma Spray, SHS, GalvanoForming, CVD/CVI, PM/CVD, SHS/HIP PS/GF
FGM Samples: Disk: SiC/C, PSZ/SUS, PSZ/Ni, AlN/SiC,TiC/Ni, Cr3C2/Ni, TiB2/Ni Nose cone: SiC/CC Rod: PSZ/Ni
Figure 1. Major results of the 1987-1991 FGM research program on the "Fundamental Study on the Relaxation of Thermal Stress for High Temperature Materials by the Tailoring of Graded Structures."
program as a member of one of three major groups: design, processing, or evaluation. Each investigation was coordinated for the purpose of developing the fundamental architecture of FGMs and their applications. Figure 1 illustrates the major results of the research program [2, 3]. For example, with respect to design and modeling, a CAD system using an inverse design model was developed that can produce an overall design architecture including selecting compositions and microstructures and optimizing the graded arrangement. Thermophysical parameters measured or calculated to minimize thermal stress both under process and service conditions were used for this optimization. A fuzzy function was used to combine different microstructures and properties smoothly, and a micromechanical approach to correlate graded microstructures and properties was established. Fractal and percolation theories were introduced for the quantitative analysis of the spatial change in graded microstructures, and FEM was used to model the distribution of internal stress. A number of processes were developed that use CVD, PVD, plasma spray, powder metallurgy, SHS, and galvanoforming. Several combined processes were also developed including CVD/CVI, PM/CVD, SHS/HIP, and plasma spray/galvanoforming. Various FGM samples were fabricated such as disks of SiC/C, AlN/SiC, PSZ/stainless steel, PSZ/Ni, TiC/Ni, Cr3C2/Ni, TiB2/Cu; nose cones of SiC/CC; and rods of PSZ/Ni. A small punch test was devised to evaluate the fracture energy of a thin FGM disk. Two methods were developed for the evaluation of thermal shock resistance up to 2000 K: irradiation by a strong xenon lamp and heating using an oxygen/hydrogen mixed-gas flame burner. Small combustion chambers for rocket engines made of SiC/CC by CVD/CVI and of Zr02/Ni by plasma spray/galvanoforming are undergoing combustion tests at the National Aerospace Laboratory. Although this program did not extend beyond fundamental research, it established the future direction for continuing FGM research worldwide. The FGM concept has been applied by several industries to a variety of products. To date, high performance cutting tools of TiCN/WC/Co, Ni FGM [4] and shaving blades of Al-Fe intermetallics/stainless steel FGM [5] have been commercialized. However, other commercial applications are still limited. 2.2 For functional uses ~ the direct conversion of thermal energy to electric energy Because the FGM concept was expected to be applicable to materials for functional uses as well as for structural applications, a new five-year project was initiated in 1993 with the aim of applying the FGM concept to the development of highly efficient thermionic and thermoelectric energy conversion materials. Both a themionic converter (TIC) and a thermoelectric converter (TEC) can produce electric power directly from thermal energy by the electron flow generated in space or in a solid under a high temperature differential. Figure 2 illustrates this ongoing program. In this Hybrid Direct Energy Conversion System, a TIC and a TEC are combined, and solar energy is used as the heat source to create a large temperature differential from ~2000K to ~300K. The design and optimization of the graded fields with respect both to the electronic and the elastic potential should lead to higher conversion efficiency with the relaxation of thermal stress. Thus the development of FGM architecture that would combine structural and functional properties is another goal of this program.
• C/C heat reservoir Mo radiation shield cyhnder TIC emitter Re graded coating TIC collector
SiGePbTeBi2Te3-
2.2.1. The design and processing of graded components for TICs and TECs In order to develop efficient and long lasting TICs and TECs, or combinations of these devices, an optimized system with lower heat loss and less degradation must be assembled using high performance TIC and TEC materials and devices. This will require solving various interface problems with respect to heat and carrier transportation, materials joining, thermal stress, electric contact, and insulation under extreme thermal conditions.
1) Graded C/C heat reservoir In order to achieve efficient heat accumulation and transfer from solar rays, Figure 2. A schematic illustrating the Hybrid Direct a composite FGM consisting of a 3-D Energy Conversion System. graded alignment of carbon fibers and pitch infiltration has been developed at Nippon Oil Company Ltd. [6]. Carbon fibers are highly anisotropic with respect to thermal conductivity along and across their length. Therefore, the graded alignment of fibers is designed to have a higher fiber density along the heat flux at the inner layer. A woven carbon fiber cup with a graded texture was infiltrated with pitch and hot isostatically pressed (HIP) to graphitize the pitch and densify the structure. Figure 3(a) shows the graded alignment of carbon fibers, and Figure 3(b) is a photo of the dense, graded C/C heat reservoir after HIPing. Solar rays are concentrated in this graded C/C heat reservoir by a large parabolic mirror, and the bottom and lateral sides are uniformly heated to 1680°C and 1380°C, respectively. The heat reservoir is covered with a radiat ion shield made of a highly polished Solar Rays
1380 x:
o ^^\\\\\\\
J680
(a) (b) Figure 3. A schematic of the graded ahgnment of carbon fibers in a heat reservoir (a), and a graded C/C heat reservoir (b).
cylinder of single crystal Mo (see Figure 1). A high heat flux of 1450°C can be transported from the bottom of the reservoir to the back surface of the TIC emitter electrode by heat radiation. 2) The graded TiC/MoAV/Re TIC emitter Titanium carbide is a promising material for the heat receiver of the TIC emitter because of its high melting point (3000''C) and its high emissivity (-0.9), which allows the efficient absorption of heat from a wide range of the solar spectrum at a high temperature. A graded coating of TiC/Mo with low thermal stress has been developed by using a double-gun plasma spray technique developed at the National Research Institute for Metals [7]. No cracks were observed in this graded coating after heating to 1800°C. The coating was formed on the back of the MoAV/Re emitter electrode [8]. W and Re were deposited on a Mo substrate by CVD. The compositionally graded layer formed through inter-diffusion of these elements at 2300°C by heat treatment. The W can act as a diffusion barrier for Re thereby creating a stable compositional gradation up to 2000°C. Figure 4 shows the graded cross section of this FGM emitter developed by Tokyo Tungsten Co. Ltd. The linear change of the thermal expansion coefficient for Re-W and the small change for W-Mo effectively relaxes the thermal stress.
Figure 4. Microstructural changes in the graded TiC/MoAV/Re emitter. The collector electrode was made at the Electrotechnical Laboratory by sputtering niobium oxide with a low work function of 1.38 eV on a Mo electrode [9]. A TIC device with a maximum output power of 8 W/cm^ obtained at an emitter-collector temperature differential of 1600°C-760°C and a Cs reservoir temperature of 330°C was assembled at Mitui Engineering & Ship Building Co.Ltd. [10]. 3) Graded PbTe thermoelectric material For TEC devices such as Bi3Te2 [11], PbTe [12], and SiGe [13], the theoretical calculation suggests that it is possible to improve the conversion efficiency by several percent by the gradation of dopants or compositions. Figure 5 compares the maximum output power of a graded PbTe having three different carrier concentrations (a-layer 3.51xlO^Vm^', b-layer 2.6xlO^Vm^ c-layer 2.26xlO^Vm^), fabricated at the National Research Institute of Metals, with that of homogeneous compositions of each layer. The PbTe with a Pbl2 dopant gradation was prepared by laminating powders with three different compositions of the dopant, followed by hot pressing. The output power was measured by holding the low temperature electrode at room temperature. It was shown that the FGM sample has a maximum power of 253 W/m for AT=486 K, which is 11% higher than the highest power of the non-graded sample with a layered composition.
0
100
200 300 400 500 Temperature difference A T/K
Figure 5. Effective maximum power as a function of the temperature difference for a three-layered FGM.
Figure 6. Photo of the graded symmetric MoSi2/ Al203/Ni/Al203/MoSi2 electrodes fabricated at Osaka University for a SiGe device.
4) A symmetrically graded MoSi2/Al203/Ni/Al203/MoSi2 electrode for a SiGe TEC In the case of the TEC device, MoSi2 is promising as a high temperature electrode for thermoelectric materials such as SiGe because it has a high melting point (2030°C), suitable resistivity (-LTxlO""^ Q-cm at 1000 °C), and excellent oxidation resistance. However, its mechanical toughness (3-4 MPa m^^^) is low. To make toughened electrodes, a symmetrically graded electrode of MoSi2/Al203/Ni/Al203/MoSi2 (shown in Figure 6) was fabricated at Osaka University by a combination of self propagating high temperature synthesis and HIP (SHS/HIP). This symmetrically graded structure produces a compressive residual stress of 100 MPa at the outer MoSi2 layer due to the thermal expansion mismatch between the outer and inner layers, resulting in reinforcement of the MoSi2 up to 5.8 MPa m^^^. The AI2O3 acts as a diffusion barrier against Ni at around 800 °C. A survey of experiments with Ni diffusion in an FGM structure at high temperatures suggests that at 800°C there will be little formation of a reaction layer for at least 10 years. This symmetric FGM electrode was joined to SiGe at Mitsubishi Heavy Industries Ltd. using interlayers of Ge powder and W and Zr -Ni foils at 1000°C [14]. 5) Graded AINAV radiative material For use of the TIC and TEC or their combined device in space, cooling by radiation is required. At Sumitomo Electric Industries, Ltd., a unique radiative material made of an AIN ceramic matrix composite containing a graded dispersion of fine W particles was fabricated by sintering at 1800°C. Dense AIN has a high thermal conductivity (-200 W/mK) and is transparent to wavelengths from the visible to the infrared. On the other hand, W has high emissivity (0.9) for the infrared region. Part of the heat flow conducted from the TEC to the AIN can be radiated by the W particles, as illustrated in Figure 7. A high emissivity of 0.97 was calculated and measured when a high concentration of W particles were dispersed near the interface with TEC, and the concentration was gradually decreased toward the opposite end.
As shown in Figure 8, the graded structure of AIN/W, which can satisfy both high thermal conductivity and high emissivity, has different characteristics compared with conventional materials [15]. In this program, further investigation will be carried out mainly on the following topics. 1) Modeling and evaluation of graded thermoelectric materials. 2) Synthesis of graded p and n type Bi3Te2, PbTe, and SiGe with higher conversion efficiency. 3) Fabrication of TEC segments and cascades with tough and low energy loss interfaces. 4) Fabrication of TICs with graded electrodes that have a conversion efficiency above 15%. 5) Stability of graded structures and properties at high temperatures.
Functionally Graded —T- Materials w
1.0 Dispersed particles: W Matrix: AIN Heat flow
-i
L_
^--4::::::::-::::::i»::::::::
0.8
t
0.6
a
Zr02 0 Y203 0
•
/
AI203 O ZrCO
00
Heat radiation
Si02 O
0.4
pq Al«
0.2
-Conduction-
MgOO Cu"
0.0
1 10 100 1000 Thermal conductivity , W • m"^ • K"^ Figure 7. Schematic of a highly radiative material Figure 8. The relation of thermal conductivity composed of an AIN matrix containing a graded and emissivity. dispersion of fine W particles. 3. THE FUTURE OF FGMs Although systematic research on the design, processing, and evaluation of FGMs has been carried out in Japan for the past ten years, it is only a first step for constructing the architecture for FGMs. Natural materials found in living organisms are composed of graded or nonuniform structures and textures. The organic combination of graded structures and properties can produce higher order functions than uniform structures. FGM architecture is expected to be a useful tool not only for integrating dissimilar materials and functions but also for creating synergistic effects in graded structures and properties like biomimetic and intelligent materials. Presently, FGM research is being actively conducted worldwide. New research programs were initiated in 1995 in Germany and in 1996 in Japan. In the German program 41 topics are being investigated in universities and national institutes with respect to processing and
modeling for developing FGM applications for the 21st century [16]. A new Japanese program is being promoted among universities on 67 topics relating to the chemistry and physics of FGMs. However, continuity and communication of individual and group research is of importance for developing FGM architecture. A new science and technology of non-homogeneous graded materials could result in the development of practical applications during the 21st century. To establish FGM architecture, the following research is needed: 1) Establishment of mathematical definitions and theories for graded structures and properties. 2) Development of a computer aided design and modelling system. 3) Development of cost effective processes. 4) Evaluation of graded properties. 5) Establishment of a data base for FGM architecture.
REFERENCES [I] T.Hirano, T.Yamada, J.Teraki, M.Niino and A.Kumakawa, Proc. 16th Int. Symp. on Space Tech. and Science, (1988) 375. [2] T.Hirai, Chapter 20,"Functional Gradient Materials", Mater. Sci. and Tech. vol.l7B, R.W.Chan, P.Hassen and E.J.Kramer(eds.), VCH, Weinheim, Germany( 1996)293. [3] Report on "Fundamental Study on Relaxation of Thermal Stress for High Temperature Materials by Tailoring the Graded Structure (Phase II, 1990-1991)", published by R&D Department of Science and Technology Agency (1992). [4] Pat. Japan, Application number: Hei7-179978 (1995). [5] NIKKEI Mechanical, No.469, December 11, (1995) 94. [6] Y. Kude and Y. Sohda, This symposium proceedings. [7] T. Fukushima, S. Kuroda and S. Kitahara, This symposium proceedings. [8] M. Katoh, R. Fukuda and T. Igarashi, This symposium proceedings. [9] R. Fukuda, Y. Kasuga and K. Katoh, This symposium proceedings. [10] T. Kato, K. Morimoto, K. Isogai, M. Kato, T. Fukushima and R. Fukuda, This symposium proceedings. [II] N. Abe, H. Kohri, I. Shiota and I. A. Nishida, This symposium proceedings. [12] Y.lmai, Y. Shinohara, I. A. Nishida, M. Okamoto, Y. Isoda, T. Ohkoshi and T. Fuji, This symposium proceedings. [13] T. Noguchi, K. Takahashi and T. Masuda, This symposium proceedings. [14] Y. Miyamoto, J. Lin and K. Tanihata, Y. Kang and M. Niino, S. Hirai and T. Umakoshi, Proc. Int. Symp. on FGMs, Ceramic Transactions, to be printed. [15] K. Sogabe, M. Tanaka, T. Miura and M. Tobioka, This symposium proceedings. [16] T. Rodel, This symposium proceedings.
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Research program on gradient materials in Germany J. Rodel and A. Neubrand Fachbereich Materialwissenschafl, Technische Hochschule Darmstadt, PetersenstraBe 23, 64287 Darmstadt, Germany The concept of the program on gradient materials, which was started in the fall of 1995, will be outlined. The program is structured in four subgroups, co-ordinating work in powder metallurgy, melt processing, coatings and functional materials. Since it is scheduled to run for 6 years, the early emphasis will be on processing, with some support in modelling and characterisation. There is no constraint on any group or combination of materials, but metal/ceramic combinations feature most prominent in the current arrangement. The prime constraint on accepting research into the core program results from the requirement that the gradient needs to determine the relevant properties of the gradient material and needs to extend over most of the active part of the component.
1. MOTIVATION Whereas in Japan, the research on functionally graded materials had gained a remarkable level already in the early 90's, activities in Germany were very restricted. German companies were holding a limited number of patents on manufacturing processes for FGM's and a few researchers at the German Aerospace Laboratory were developing FGM thermal barrier coatings. Although these efforts have to be acknowledged, their impact was limited and the knowledge and acceptance of gradient materials amongst German researchers and engineers was small. At the same time, a report of the Fraunhofer Society entitled „Technology at the beginning of the 21'* century" and the Delphi-Report of the German ministry for education and research both stated the potential of gradient materials in energy and transport technology, development of resources, medicine, food science and environmental protection. On the other hand, the reports asserted that the human capital and industry involvement in FGM technology required improvement in Germany. In this situation, a group of German scientists recognised the need for a national program as the complexity of a gradient material necessitates scientific collaboration of specialists from different fields such as metals, ceramics, characterisation and modelling. The broad horizontal integration across materials classes and disciplines in such a research program would also make it ideal for the education of young scientists. A program committee was formed, and a proposal was submitted to the German research society (DFG). Finally, in 1994 the senate of DFG decided to establish a research program on gradient materials to enhance and bundle research activities on FGM's in Germany.
10 2. STRUCTURE OF THE PROGRAM The German FGM program has a duration of 6 years. It intends to gather materials scientists, mechanical engineers, physicists and chemists from universities and research institutes. Its open structure allows to incorporate new research projects every year - which seems appropriate in a field where new ideas and potential applications are still emerging at a high rate. The program is not restricted to a certain class of materials or applications. Its intention is not to improve already existing technologies where gradients play a role such as case-hardened steels. Instead, the program supports development of new materials, in which the property gradient is essential for the function of the material. The gradient may serve to join two materials that would normally fail during production or service because of large differences in coefficients of thermal expansion and/or elastic modulus and/or poor adhesion. Alternatively, it may introduce a well-defined profile of a functional property that allows an optimum response of the component to an external field. The aim of the program is to improve the basic knowledge on the processing, properties and theory of gradient materials. Processing techniques allowing to produce continuous and multidimensional gradients for a variety of material combinations have preference within the program. Apart from already established production methods for FGM's relying on the addition of a gradation step to a conventional process (e.g. plasma-spraying), the development of special methods for the production of FGM's (e.g. using potential fields) is encouraged. The determination of the property profiles of gradient materials requires methods that have a sufficiently high spatial resolution - new methods offering such possibilities should be included in the program just as well as already existing techniques in order to be able to characterise the manufactured materials and to provide theoreticians with the information required for the prediction of FGM behaviour. Theoretical groups in the program have two tasks : First, they support the processing groups in improving their processing steps, e.g. drying or sintering. Second, they predict the FGM behaviour under load and calculate optimised property profiles for the FGM's produced by the program participants. Collaboration in the program is planned between participants with related topics and along the lines processing-properties-modelling. 3. STATE OF THE PROGRAM The German program on gradient materials started in November 1995. Already in the first year of the program there were 59 applications out of which 32 with a total funding of 4.1 Mio. DM were accepted. In the second year the program will have 41 participants and a budget of 4.5 Mio. DM. 26 projects cover the processing of gradient materials, out of which nine are powder techniques and seven coating techniques. 8 projects deal with theoretical aspects of gradient materials and seven projects are devoted to the characterisation and properties of gradient materials. In order to integrate such a large number of projects into the program and create links between the different participants, four discussion groups have been formed, which meet at regular intervals. The main topics of the groups are melt processing, sintering technology, coatings and thermomechanical aspects, and functional applications of gradient materials (Table 1). The melt processing group applies conventional casting techniques to the production of FGM's - the gradient is introduced by partial mixing or directed solidification of melts, sedimentation in melts or by the Vemeuil process. Graded fibre composites are produced by melt infiltration. The sintering technology group is dealing
11 with the problems of grading and densifying bodies using powder metallurgy. This includes the production of FGM's with various technologies including slip casting, centrifuging or hot extrusion. Sedimentation and sintering processes are treated theoretically and experimentally. The interest in the third group is focused on graded thermal barrier coatings and wear resistant coatings. Processing routes include PVD and spraying techniques. Experimental investigations of the behaviour of FGM's under static and cyclic thermal and mechanical loading is of major importance in this group. It is expected that modelling of the fracture mechanics, residual and applied stresses will help to improve the performance of the FGM's produced within the group. The last group gathers a number of participants which produce FGM's for specific functional applications. Emphasis hes on the production of materials for energy conversion and medicine. In contrast to Group I and II the goal of these projects is not the development of production technologies applicable to a large number of materials, but to achieve an optimum material for a specific application by improving production technology. Table 1 The German FGM program Group I Melt Processing
Group n Sintering Technology
Graded Single Crystals Directional Solidification Casting Technology Gas Pressure Infiltration
Modelling of Sintering Graded Porosity Slip Casting Sedimentation Powder Metallurgy
Group n i Coatings and Thermomechanical Modelling
Group rv Functional Materials
EB-PVD Thermal Barrier Coatings Chemical Vapour Condensation Method Wear Resistant Coatings Measurement of Residual Stresses Laser Thermal Shock Test Cyclic Loading of Gradient Materials Fracture Mechanical Modelling
Thermoelectric materials Solid Oxygen Fuel Cells Graded BaTiOs Biocompatible Composites Medical Implants Acoustic Characterisation
12
Figure 1
Important topics and links in the gradient materials program
13 At present 60 links between participants exist - a significant number of which has been established during the group meetings. Additional stimulation of collaboration between members of different groups is expected from yearly meetings of the participants, where the progress of the projects is presented. It is already obvious in the early state of the program that a number of projects in the characterisation, theoretical and testing field has gained an important support character for all participants of the program. Of particular importance in this context are the theoretical and experimental determination of stresses in FGM's, and the measurement of elastic and thermal property profiles. Any effort to describe the interaction between the participants must remain rudimentary - nevertheless Fig.l shows an attempt to sketch the most important links within the program.
4. OUTLOOK At the end of the first year of the program, the task of structuring the program is almost accomplished. Whereasfijndinga wide scope of methods and appUcations in the early phase of the program should awake academic interest in gradient materials, the second phase will bring a reduction of the number of projects. Nevertheless, a number of projects of high scientific quality and relevance as well as a few highly innovative works will be funded beyond the year 2000. However, the expected reduction in public funding should not lead to a general reduction in FGM research - it will only be transferred partly to industrial laboratories (Fig.2). A central task for the co-ordinators and participants of the program is therefore to stimulate industrial interest in FGM's. At present, industrial interest is only moderate as commercial applications of FGM's are still rare - the obstacles towards introduction of FGM's into components being manifold : Most production processes for FGM's are batch processes and difficult to scale up for mass production at a reasonable cost. With many processes, the production of components with complicated geometry and/or multidimensional gradation is impossible. The consolidation process of FGM's is frequently very sophisticated and considerable efforts are necessary to adapt it to new material combinations or shapes. Further, FGM's are presently not widely accepted by engineers because the effect of a gradation on the performance of a component is not known a priori. The above statements lead to a number of challenges for the participants in the German FGM program : 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Elaborate processes suitable for mass production Ensure that the cost of the FGM does not interfere with the application in mind Prefer methods capable of near-net shaping Develop methods applicable to different material combinations without major changes Promote simple rules where a gradient will always be advantageous Determine a number of favourable gradation profiles for some important applications
Non-scientific efforts to awaken industrial interest are also made - a brochure in German language has been composed and distributed to companies manufacturing products where incorporation of FGM's may be of interest. Industrial participation in the yearly meetings is encouraged and a number of company representatives took part already in the first meeting. If a number of FGM's with application potential evolves from the program, it is expected that
14 the industrial interest will further increase within the next years opening possibilities for collaborations between participants and companies.
Industrial Interest Funding level by DFG awakening academic interest
increasing Industrial promise
1995
1998
2001
Figure 2 Expected development of the gradient materials program 5 CONCLUSION The research program on gradient materials in Germany had a good start. At present a broad spectrum of processes and applications is funded, and many groups report first interesting results a part of which is presented in these proceedings. The future will bring a reinforcement of industrial participation and a selection of processing methods and applications of technical relevance. It is believed that the basic work on gradient materials carried out in the framework of the program will result in an enhanced interest for FGM in research divisions of companies thus promoting the application of FGM's. If the program is successful, it is expected that German companies will produce components containing FGM's in the first decade of the next century.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The authors would like to thank the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) for establishing the program on gradient materials and for personalfinancialsupport.
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 1997 Elsevier Science B.V.
15
Lessons learnt in 7 years of FGM research at Lausanne B. Ilschner Dept. of Materials, Swiss Fed. Inst, of Technology Lausanne
General experience gained during the research period 1988 - 1955 underlay the difficulties to make FGM economically visible ("marketplace"). The conclusion is the suggestion to focus future research on graded materials on 1) fundamental aspects ("Functions of Gradients in Materials") and 2) an effort to develop fast, low-cost, highly reliable fabrication routes for technically relevant components. Introduction In this paper, a number of reflections and conclusions are formulated which result from research work on functionally graded materials as performed by a small group at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology at Lausanne, mainly in the period 1988 to 1995. It is hoped that these observations, after critical review by the "FGM community", may contribute to the planning and accomplishment of future research activities within this field. In order to explain these ideas, it is proposed to start with a retrospect. "Thermally graded materials" The origin of the author's preoccupation with graded materials was simple scientific curiosity, without an immediate application in mind: after 15 years of work in the field of high-temperature creep, performed with a group of young collaborators at the university of Eriangen-Nurnberg (Germany) between 1965 and 1980, discussion of the behavior of gas-cooled turbine blades led to the idea of investigating into the creep of axially symmetric, tubular model specimens [1]. The outer part of this type of specimen was externally heated to high temperature (up to 0.7 T J , while the central part was cooled by pressurized air, generating a radially symmetric temperature field T(r). These specimens were then subjected to a constant axial tensile stress, a, and the elongation e between markers on the specimen surface was measured optically. The corresponding constitutive law for steady state contains elements named after Arrhenius (T-dependence) and Norton (a-dependence), both of them being strong functions of their parameters: de/dt = C a" exp(-Qc/RT). Even a small temperature difference would therefore produce an appreciable difference in the creep rate for a given applied stress, if the specimen was to be considered as a set of independent coaxial shells. This is equivalent to the
16 Statement that the inner shells are "harder" than the outer ones, since TQ > Tj. As a matter of fact, the setup of the experiment imposes a constraint inasmuch as all coaxial shells have to have identical elongation at any moment, independent of their respective temperature T(r). One part of this elongation is due to the thermal expansion, the other part to the creep strain. We consider the material to be in a visco-elastic state. A transient stress distribution will therefore occur after each change of the applied stress and/or temperature profile. Only very small local deformations and, thus, short times are necessary to adjust local stresses to the general continuity condition. After the transition, the whole specimen will creep in tension under the action of a radial distribution of axial stresses a(r) which assures, respecting the creep rate equation, an equal creep rate for the whole specimen. From the viewpoint of continuum mechanics, a chemically homogeneous specimen with a radial temperature gradient is indeed a "graded material" inasmuch as each coaxial shell offers a different resistance to the applied stress and has a different time constant for relaxation. We may speak of a "thermally graded material". This work led to the idea of adapting the alloy composition to the temperature profile; this must be an iterative process, because the radial composition profile implies an inhomogeneity of thermal conductivity and is thus influencing the primary temperature profile. As a next step, it was felt that the mechanical behavior of a compositionally graded material at homogeneous temperature should be studied. Consequently, after taking up a new academic position in Lausanne, the author filed a research proposal with the Swiss National Funds [2]. This project was, incidentally, not approved in the first time, but later granted thanks to an initiative taken by Prof. V. Franzen, who at that time was the director of the National Research Program on "Materials for the Demands of Tomorrow". This was the first project in Lausanne on what later became known as FGM. The funding was modest and permitted to hire just one PhD. student, who was to be D. Delfosse, joining the lab on July 1,1985. Insights: The Japanese Model The fact that the above-mentioned Ph.D. project was part of a program on materials "for the demands of tomorrow" obliged us to go beyond the original guideline of obtaining valid scientific results and to seriously consider the potential for technical applications. Our primary concern was, however, to develop an experimental method for making fully dense continuously graded specimens in a sufficiently large number to allow for subsequent study of composition profiles, microstructures, and mechanical behavior. Although a number of alternatives were briefly studied, the process of "centrifugal powder metallurgy" as originally proposed in [2] emerged as the most efficient and reliable one. It was first published in [3,4]. At this stage, Prof. W. Bunk, at that time director of the materials division of the German Aeronautical Research establishment near Cologne (now DLR) established close contracts with the pioneering FGM research activities in Japan. These were centered at the National Aerospace Research Center (with Dr. Niino) and patronized by the Japanese Society for Non-Traditional
17 Technology. In the framework of these early contacts, a group of scientists from Japan under the direction of Prof. Koizumi visited Germany in 1988 and came subsequently also to the author's laboratory at EPFL Lausanne. This encounter proved to be of great importance for the future work of this group, The first insight gained from this visit was that the Japanese colleagues had a real national program, had a goal (at that time: thermal barrier coatings for future commercial space shuttles); they had generous funding, industrial resonance, an efficient organization - and all of this was practically nonexistent in Europe (and the rest of the world). One might illustrate this situation by depicting the Japanese FGM-program as a strong tree, and the other research activities in graded and layered structures as individual flowers distributed all over the world. By and large, this picture is still valid today. One exception - also going back to an initiative of W. Bunk - may be seen in the priority program on graded materials which has been launched in Germany in 1995 [5]. The Impact due to the discussion with the Japanese colleagues during their visit to Lausanne was reinforced by the insights which the present author gained during his participation in the first international conference on FGM in Sendai, 1990. It became clear that in order to achieve a visible result it was necessary to go beyond the limits of the traditional European university research style ("one topic - one thesis - one student"), which had, by the way, already been abandoned In other fields like nuclear physics or semiconductor research. Thus, in spite of serious difficulties to obtain funding, a small group of highly motivated young researchers [6] could be formed, which was since 1991 coordinated by N. Cherradi [7,8], who also made a very important contribution to the visibility of the FGM concept in his capacity as secretary general of the 3rd International. Symposium at Lausanne, 1994 [9]. On the other hand, the attempt to bring together a FGM Working Group on a national scale in Switzerland was not met by success. In retrospective, it appears that 2 necessary conditions for such a plan could not be established: a) to find a key person ("locomotive") of high reputation and sufficient political influence in the national community, being able to devote a major part of his energy and time to overcome the "activation barriers" during the incubation phase, and b) a fair amount of "seed money" which would enable the pioneer research group to produce preliminary results on which to base further funding applications. Again, both of these conditions were fulfilled in Japan! Functionally Graded Materials on the Marketplace During the 7-year period of FGM research in Lausanne, several other lessons had to be learnt. Among these is one which could already be sensed while working on the "thermally graded materials" project: The necessity of linking the experimental and microstructural aspects of graded (or layered) materials to the methods and results of continuum mechanics. Clearly, each inhomogeneous material is subjected to complex multi-axial stresses originating from the local differences in basic properties, in particular Young's modulus, the limit of elasticity, and the coefficient of thermal expansion. In this
18 field, it is therefore particularly important to coordinate expertise from both communities, such as demonstrated in a workshop in Davos organized in 1995 [10]. Probably the most important lesson which had to be learnt came in recent years only, and it came from outside of our community. As researchers and academic teachers in the field of materials we have to face an embarrassing fact: Materials and manufacturing actually are not in a dynamic growth phase comparable to the period 1960 to 1980. The so-called New Materials, in spite of the fascination originating in their often astonishing mechanical or electromagnetic behavior, do not find It easy to present themselves as an attractive value on the "marketplace". Too many of this kind, with sometimes exotic structures and compositions, have been announced with much ado, without finally living up to (exaggerated) expectations. The actual situation on the marketplace of our industrial society appears to be such that improved property values are no more considered to be a natural justification for Increased prices; this holds except for the field of telecommunication and for some "niche" applications which are not characteristic for the general status of materials science and engineering. Quite generally. Industrial leaders adhere more and more to a philosophy which states that the shareholder value - being their primary responsibility - is not essentially increased by research into new materials and technologies, but rather by skillful use of existing technology in combination with computerized design strategies and "lean assembly". The decisive battles, they say, are won or lost by commercial or financial moves. In parallel, governments (or parliaments ) are less and less Inclined to spend public money in scientific research as a "culture". This tendency is not likely to change in the next 10 years. As all sectors of our society, materials science and engineering must continuously discuss, redefine and justify its aims and ways. This general analysis may lead us to the following insight: If functionally graded materials, or FGM, are advertised as a wonderful new class of materials for the 21st century, they risk to be marginalized (as others before), except if they yield really spectacular results within the next few years. This is not impossible, but it Is not very likely either that this will happen. It has to be admitted that at the present stage of knowledge, graded materials with designed functions are too difficult and too expensive to make so that they cannot be produced in large quantities for industrial use; moreover, the means to ascertain their quality, reproducibility, reliability and lifetime by accepted standards with corresponding testing procedures are insufficient. There are no accepted design rules, and the community of design engineers (conservative as it is obliged to be) has little or no knowledge at all of the advantages, problems and limits of gradients in solid materials. The conclusion which we derived from this lesson at Lausanne is that the aforementioned limiting conditions reflect the reality and that a twofold strategy appears to be appropriate: I) To encourage basic studies of the physical, chemical and mechanical behavior of graded materials in general, of their cross
19 links with microstructure, and of the mechanisms likely to control possible fabrication routes. II) To consider the above-mentioned shortcomings as a challenge to resolve the associated technical problems by intelligent engineering, taking advantage of all the impressive knowledge on FGM which has been accumulated worldwide. In the following two sections, these two parallel strategies will be more closely described and discussed. Beyond FGM: The Function of Gradients in l\^ateriais There is no doubt that it can be of great advantage to design technical components using different materials for load-bearing, surface-protecting, electromagnetic and decorative functions. Fiber reinforcement and the whole surface treatment as well as joining technologies are excellent examples. Likewise, many scientific and manufacturing arguments can be brought fon/vard in favor of graded transitions inside such multi-material components, instead of abrupt property changes. The FGM concept has provided a new quality of understanding of these phenomena. In particular, it has demonstrated that compositional or microstructural gradients can not only serve to avoid undesirable effects (such as tensile stress concentrations) but can also serve to generate unique positive functions: focusing light in fibers, channeling heat in computer chips, implant-tissue transitions in biomedical engineering. Many others can be conceived. In a general way, the FGM concept has taught how to optimize concentration profiles. "Opening the lens" towards a broad view on "The Function of Gradients in Materials" may thus lead beyond the current scope of FGM as a special class of materials. The topic of gradients (and also multilayers) in solid materials presents itself as a promising perspective, very timely after a century of practical exercises and after 10 years of intensive work on FGM. The whole field Is urgently needing a coherent scientific infrastructure In all its chemical, electronic, mechanical aspects. Obviously, such a methodical approach envisages and enables applications in many traditional and non-traditional fields. Where a scientific background is in demand, there is no reason to shy away from topics such as welding and brazing, segregations after casting of liquid alloys, diffusion controlled hardening of steel surfaces and glasses; the analysis needs extension into polymer systems and natural materials such as wood, bone, teeth and shells. The Engineering Chaiienge: Fast, Cheap, Reiiabie - Conclusion The present shortcomings of graded materials from an engineering point of view have been listed above. Real progress can be achieved only if the following tasks are being fulfilled: Define applications which appear adapted for gradient solutions and establish a complete list of properties needed for their satisfactory function.
20 Specify candidate systems of graded materials/structures to comply with as many as possible (If not all) of the properties in demand. Evaluate feasible fabrication routes which yield either a semifinished product (strip, wire, etc.) or even near-net shaped components. Assess the materials systems and fabrication routes envisaged with respect to quality, reproducibility, available equipment and cost per piece. Define quantitative criteria for reliability (or admissible scatter) and durability (in terms of total service time or cycle number to failure). Find or design testing methods (preferably non-destructive, and as close as possible to currently standardized methods) which appear suitable to control the validity of the above-mentioned criteria. Evaluate possible environmental hazards as well as problems related to recycling. This package of tasks contains a considerable number of problems which belong to the modern field of manufacturing science. On the other hand, manufacturing science has not yet dealt at all with graded materials. So there is an "open sky" before us, and a rich and realistic source of motivation for young scientists and engineers to join the field which has been opened by the introduction of the FGM concept. Acknowledgment The author gratefully acknowledges financial support from the Swiss National Funds and the Priority Program on Materials Research (financed by BSFIT). Moreover, he thanks his collaborators for their successful work and many colleagues In the international FGM community for enlightening discussions. References [1] U.Engel, Z. Werkstofftech. 10 (1979) 243-248, see also U.Engel, B. Ilschner, Z. Werkstofftech. 17 (1986) 299-307 [2] B. Ilschner, Projet No. 4.834-(1985) du Fonds National Suisse [3] B. Ilschner, in: M. Yamanouchi, M. Koizumi, T. Hirai, I. Shiota (Eds.), Proc. 1st Internatl. Symposium on FGM, Tokyo 1990, pp. 101-106 [4] B. Ilschner, D. Delfosse, H.U. Kuenzi, Acta metall.mater. 40 (1992) 2219-2224 [5] J. Roedel, D. Neubrandt, Proc. 4th Internatl. Symposium on FGM, Tsukuba 1996 [6] The group consisted (in alphabetical order) of K. Barthel, M. Blumm, D. Delfosse, N. Desmonts, P. Li, X. Ding, K. Dollmeier, M. Probst-Hein, W. Thiele; important advice in theoretical and experimental questions is due to M. Cans, H.U. Kuenzi, and N. Merk. Most of their work hasa been published in the Proc. 3rd Internatl. Symposium FGM, Lausanne 1994. [7] N. Cherradi , A.Kawasaki, M.Gasik, Composite Engineering. Current Trends in Composites Research, Vol.4 (1994) 883-894 [8] N. Cherradi, D.Delfosse, B.Ilschner, A. Kawasaki, Rev. de MetallurgieCIT (1996) 185-196 [9] S. Suresh, F. Needleman (Eds.): Mechanics and Physics of Layered and Graded Materials (Proc. Of an Engineering Foundation Conference Davos 1995, Special Issue of J. of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
21
Local fields in functionally graded materials Yevgen D. Bilotsky^ and Michael M. Gasik^^ ^Institute of Physics, 252650 Kyiv, Ukraine ^Helsinki University of Technology, 02150 Espoo, Finland
The structure and basic properties of the FGMs of different systems have been studied theoretically. There is a need for theoretical basis, which would allow to describe the structure and properties of materials from first principles, while remaining simple and easy to use. In this work, such theoretical principles are suggested and their applications to heat flow and respective stress fields in FGMs are considered as example. These principles can be spread out for other materials.
1. INTRODUCTION The functionally graded materials (FGMs) are characterised by a non-linear 3D-distribution of phases and corresponding properties [1,2]. They are distinguished from isotropic materials by gradients of composition, phase distribution, porosity, texture, and related properties (hardness, density, resistance, thermal conductivity. Young's modulus, etc.) [3-5]. The FGM is characterised not only by the presence and appearance of compositional or other gradients but also by the sophisticated behaviour of FGM component in comparison with conventional (macroscopically uniform) materials. In the simplest case, the structure of a material is represented or replaced by the model-like system of a matrix with embedded particles or grains. For such composites the microstructural fields are assumed to be homogeneous, whereas for FGMs they are heterogeneous. Due to the gradients in FGMs, the "normal" approximations and models, used for traditional composites, are not directly applicable to FGM. The situation becomes even more complicated, when an FGM has gradients on several levels, i.e. macro-, micro- and nano-scale, where defects such as vacancies and dislocations start to play an important role in the transfer processes and mechanical behaviour of the specimen. The main method actually used is based on the finite element approach (FEM) and its variations. Most numerical schemes are bases on discrete distribution models, not all of them taking into account possible non-isotropic phase distribution. When this distribution is not isotropic but complies with a certain law, the same observation of measurement process yields This work was partially supported by Technology Development Centre of Finland (TEKES) and the Commission of European Communities (COST-503 project)
22
different results depending on the way the sample is placed. It is obvious that the resources necessary to define, conduct, and interpret such an analysis, are prohibitive for complex structures [4]. Another opportunity would be in a modelling of the FGM structure and in a deducing of "structure-property" relationships, e.g. as micromechanical model. This, however, is limited to simplified structures with quite a lot of assumptions. The explicit description of any material (not only FGM) from the first principles can be obtained from its consideration over an arbitrary domain, where every inclusion, defect, anisotropy, etc., is precisely taken into account [6,7,15]. This task could be solved theoretically, but its application would be certainly useless in practice, since it will involve a vast number of calculations and measurements. In this connection, there is a need for theoretical basis, which would allow to describe the structure and properties of materials from first principles, while remaining simple and easy to use. In this work, such theoretical principles are suggested and their applications to FGM heat flow and respective mechanical stresses are considered as example. These principles, however, can be spread out for other materials.
2. THEORETICAL BASIS FOR FGMS A comparative analysis of such structures, involving the evaluation of their "effective" properties, e.g. with a "pointwise" homogenisation, with some micromechanical models [4], as well as numerical methods (combined models, FEM calculations, etc.) was reported elsewhere [4,6,7]. In this respect, the following issues might be formulated for an "ideal" theory that is able to describe and to solve these problems: (i) it should be a first-principle theory, involving as less as possible or none fitting assumptions or parameters, e.g. do not require an artificial representative volume element or grid introduction; (ii) this theory should be easily applicable for any material with the structure of any complexity; (iii) the solution procedure should be rather fast and reliable, and be asymptotically free (i.e. all asymptotic cases have to have finite solutions without singularities); the calculations themselves should be "error-resistant" (e.g., a small error should be compensated on the next iteration) [6,12]. This kind of a theoretical approach could be based on the local field analysis [6,7,10,15]. The external and local fields in materials can alter in a significant way such processes as the dislocations motion, solid-state reactions kinetics, sublimation, oxidation, etc. In many of the reported findings, the attempts were made to provide basic explanations for the experimental observations, but in general they were failed to give a consistent picture of the role of the fields in the various processes [9]. For instance, one of the main problem for polycrystalline specimens is in high non-linearity and inhomogeneity of the fields between the grains and near the defects. Resulting singularities usually do not allow the differential equations to be solved numerically. 2.1. Local stress and strain fields in FGMs Let's consider first a defect-free grain of one phase in a two-phase composite. The state of this crystal can be described by the equation of motion of elastic media [11]:
23
where vector f describes the density of the volume forces, applied to crystal, p is the crystal density, ui are components of the distortion (shift) vector
= l(^i^k-^^k^i) \^Xk
(2)
^^ij
and tensor Oj^i is bound with strains e^-^ by Hooke's lawCJ-j^ — A-^^^ £^^ . Let's consider now a crystal with a dislocation. In this crystal a single-valued vector of elastic shift u can be always introduced, where function u(r) will have a leap b on the surface SQ, laying on the dislocation loop or interface D:
5u = u^ - u ~ = b
(3)
where superscripts "+" and "-" refer to values of u(r) on upper and lower side of Sj) respectively. It is important that the same form of this equation is valid for a leap of u(r) on the grain boundaries and well as interfaces in the solid. In the latter case (3) does not specify a general appearance of the leap over S, whereas strain 8^-^ keeps its continuity and remains differentiable. Thus (3) transforms to
<5u = u^-u" = b + [Qr],
(4)
where b - translation vector, Q - rotation vector, and r - radius-vector of a point on surface S. When Q = 0, translation vector coincides with the Burgers vector. In a scalar elastic field, the distortion tensor can be substituted by vector h and stress tensor can be replaced by vector a : \i-grad
u ; diva
= -/
; a
= Gh .
(5)
These equations along with the Hooke's law constitute full system of equilibrium relationships for an elastic media with dislocations and interfaces. Let's suppose now that the piece of a two-phase material (grains of A within matrix of B) is assembled from these isotropic domains, where domain boundaries are some arbitrary distributed interfaces. For domains outside the A-phase grain and with conditions (3-5), it follows div u = 0. Thus, substituting distortion vector by u = UQ + grad cp , the respective Laplace equation for the distortion potential cp will be A(p(r) = 0. Consider now a jrain of phase A, which has several border interfaces with other A grains as well as with B-matrix; and the internal volume of this grain will be a positive direction (Fig.l). The picture on Fig.l is taken from the real structure of W-Cu infiltrated composite with a graded distribution of diamonds [4]. The equilibrium requirements stipulate that distortion potential on positive (inside) and negative (outside) sides of the interfaces must be coupled as follows, so far the material is not a subject of an application of external forces:
24
(p,(r)l = (p_ir)l /':s.^\ 3(p
l^nJ-
=
(6)
E(^ y^^JA
(7)
for every A grain in the composite, where n is outside normal vector to surface S, and ^ is a couphng coefficient.
Figure 1. Model of A-B FGM structure (see definitions in the text). Points schematically represent potential for positive and negative sides of interface SD. Here ^ is assumed to be the same for each interface of A grain, although its two principal values (for A-A and A-B interfaces) could be taken into consideration already in this simple approach. Solution of the Laplace equation A(p(r) = 0 in this case will have form:
^(r)dS, cpfrj = -u.r4- X 11 , I .
(8)
„„•' r-r -a
where analogue to charge surface density x(r) should satisfy the following integral equation:
1-^ f;?/^M V
^frj + j ; ^ J T f r ' j X
cos((r-r'-Si)'n,)dS, 27lj r - r - a
_
1 1-^
2711+^ u n.
(9)
Here n^ is outside normal vector in the point r, and the graded structure inhomogeneity is introduced by vector a. In general, a represents a distance between the centres of two A grains (Fig.l), where sum is taken over all existing grains (a(r) G [-©O; CO]). Thus, FGM structure parameters as well as grains topology and possible gradient of particle size distribution, are
25
taking into account. For homogeneous (non-FGM) materials the value of a could be simply taken equal to mean distance between A grains. The most essential feature of this approach is in exclusion of the singularities of the derivatives from consideration, since there are no singularities in the local domain by definition, and the integration removes singularities between the domains. These equations, however, cannot be apply for materials with very small grain sizes (20-50 nm and less), because these elasticity relationships (3-5) are not valid on atomic distances. 2.2. Dynamics of local Helds in FGMs Now let there be within a material a scalar field T(XQ), where XQ are space coordinates (|i =1..3). It could be temperature, electrostatic potential, concentration, etc. [6,8,11]. This field leads to the some form of transfer (heat, mass, charge, etc.) depending of its nature. In its turn, this transfer (flow) is one of the forms of motion, which must satisfy the principle of "least action" (61= 0): I = ^LdQ.
; dQ. = dh
(10)
where L(T,VjnT) is the Lagrangian density, and integration is taken over the body domain Q. The Lagrangian density L and the functional / must be invariant under any symmetry transformation (translational invariance in time and in space, and rotational invariance) in order to preserve the conservation laws (Noether theorem): T-> T + 5 T
,
8 T = Qe ,
(11)
where 8 is an infinitesimal parameter, and Q is a constant. The Lagrangian density itself should be also invariant (8L = 0):
^ST^4^ST^0.
(12)
After substitution of equations, the following form of (12) can be obtained [13]: dL dL d dT dx^ v^^.y
^^6r
dT^
0.
(13)
This equation is a form of the equation of motion and it virtually describes any variations and interactions. The Lagrangian L, which is generally expressed as difference between potential and kinetic energy [8,11], should be substituted by a respective expression, depending on the kind of problem considered (mechanical deformation, heat flow, diffiision, electrical conduction, etc.) These equations are valid over any domain of material, which does not contain inhomogeneties (inclusions, defects, dislocations, grain boundaries, etc.). Let's suppose now that a piece of material is assembled from isotropic domains, where domain boundaries are
26 arbitrarily oriented, but gradually distributed. The equations above are still valid in any domain, but they cannot be directly applied to the material due to singularities of derivatives on interfaces. In this case, the infinitesimal parameters e will no longer be constants but functions e(x), and the transformation (11) will be T ^ T+8T
,
8T=Q8fx^j
,
(14)
and the in variance of L will not hold anymore:
For retaining of the invariance of (12), a new field A(x) has to be introduced to cancel the right-hand side of (13). New Lagrangian L'(T, V„T, A) and the new considered transformation 5T(x) =E(x)Q,
5A = UAe(x)-tC^^
(16)
where U is a constant, will ensure that the functional will be invariant under transformation (8). Here A^ = C~^ A and the elements of the matrix C and its inverse C"^ here, and in the transformation (8), are [14]: C'C;' = 8 , C;' C" = 5; . In the case of a non-homogeneous, non-isotropic FGM, the gauges A(x) are considered to be uniquely determined by the structure of the material. Proceeding from the single domain to the bulk component, the non-steady field T could be evaluated from the invariance of L'(T, V QT, A) over the entire component by integration of the particular local field equations, taking into account coupling equations deduced above (6-7). This transformation gives new system of equations for any field distribution in a FGM of any complex structure from the single phenomenological point of view [6,15], where fields in domains and between them are considered within the same equations. Any external field, applied to the material with a certain temperature distribution, will not change the form of equations, since they will be t^en into account within the Lagrangian.
3. APPLICATION OF LOCAL FIELDS THEORY TO FGM With the theoretical principles above, it is possible to formulate their applications to the problems solution in FGMs. The sequence of the constructing of the systems of equations could be presented as a combination of the following stages: (i) obtaining structural information and construction of the "internal" fields Q, (ii) introduction of gauge fields A and description of the Lagrangian(s) L', (iii) introduction of "external" field(s) and analysis of the gauge and L', (iv) integration of the equadons and solution for unknown variables or fields. It is theoretically possible to determine the local stresses on every grain of one phase, depending on its distribution, structure, interfaces, etc. The exact description of the solution method is possible to formulate for particular cases, depending on the conditions applied
27 [6,15]. The following practical applications could be solved with this approach: (i) determination of the mechanical fields in FGMs and components under specific conditions (temperature, force and deformation); (ii) solution of the heat transfer problem in FGMs with an arbitrary defects distribution; (iii) prediction of the properties of materials and their behaviour in different fields (gravitation, electrostatic, electromagnetic, etc.). Although the equations shown do not often contain temperature explicitly, it may be introduced with the equation of motion, based on that thermal loading of a FGM component will be accompanied by propagation of elastic compression waves. This shows that interaction of mechanical and thermal factors in FGMs is one of the key issues of designing of reliable FGM components [6,12,15].
4. CONCLUSIONS The results of this work reveal that the general problems, such as "structure-properties" relationships, materials behaviour in different fields, etc. in FGMs, could be in principle solved through the construction and proper solution of integral equations in a scalar form for particular cases. Local fields of stress and strain, temperature, etc. as well as non-steady problems were considered. The approach suggested could be extended on fields of any nature, such as mechanical, concentrational, etc., whereas the form of equations and the method of their solution remain invariant to the kind of problem.
REFERENCES 1. M.Koizumi, Ceram. Trans.: Functionally Gradient Materials, Ed. B.Holt e.a., ACerS., Ohio, 34(1993)3-10. 2. M.Gasik and K.Lilius, Comp. Mater. Sci., 3 (1994) 41-49. 3. N.Cherradi, A.Kawasaki, and M.Gasik, Compos. Eng. 4 (1994) No. 5, 883-894. 4. M.Gasik, Acta Polytech. Scand., Ch 226 (1995) 73 p. 5. M.Sasaki and T.Hirai, J. Ceram. Soc. Jap. 99 (1991) 970-980. 6. Y.Bilotsky and M.Gasik, Compos. Eng., in special issue "Use of Composites in MultiPhased and Functionally Graded Materials", (1996). 7. Y.Bilotsky, B.Lev and P.Tomchuk, Proc. 2nd Int. Works. Non-linear Turbul. Proces. Phys., 1983, Kiev, Ukraine, Ed. R.Z.Sagdeev, Gordon & Berch Publ. Co., NY, 7 (1984) 701-704. 8. L.D.Landau and L.M.Lifschitz, Theory of elasticity. Compr. Cours. Phys., 7 (1986) 187 p. 9. Z.Munir and H.Schmalzried, J. Mater. Synth. Process. 1 (1993) 1,3-16. 10. E.Bilotsky and P.Tomchuk, Proc. 3rd Int. Works. EPMS-91, Berlin, Germany (1991) 410. 11. A.M.Kosevich, Physical mechanics of real crystals. Naukova Dumka, Kyiv (1981) 328 p. 12. M.Gasik, FGM News. J. FGM Forum Jap. 31 (1996), 6-9. 13. R.Utiyama, Phys. Rev. 101 (1956) 5, 1597-1607. 14. C.N.Yang and R.L.Mills, Phys. Rev. 96 (1954) 1, 191-195. 15. M.Gasik, Y.Bilotsky, N.Cherradi and A.Kawasaki, Proc. Europ. Powd. Metal. Conf EPMA'96, Stockholm (1996) 7.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V, All rights reserved.
29
Computer-Aided Process Design for Forming of Pore-Gradient Membranes C.-W. Hong Universitat Erlangen-Niirnberg, Institut fiir Werkstoffwissenschaften (3), Martensstrasse 5, D-91058 Erlangen, Germany
Abstract The DEM simulation method has been used to study the mechanics for the pore-gradient formation via centrifugal casting. A model system based on the dynamic similarity has been applied for the simulation. The simulation results show that pore-gradient membranes can be formed by using stabilized AI2O3 suspensions with a suspension height of 70 mm and a density of < 10% under a centrifugal acceleration of greater than 40 g. These design parameters have been applied and verified experimentally. 1. I N T R O D U C T I O N The Discrete Element Method (DEM) has been used to model the particle packing dynamics during forming processes of colloidal ceramic powder systems [1-4]. Hereby the response of each particle to mechanical and electrostatic impact from its surroundings has been described by the summation of all interactions, e.g. particle-particle, particle-medium, particle-boundary, and particle-external force field interaction. Long-range potential interactions, short-range repulsive hydration, steric stabilization through surface-adsorbed polymer as well as adhesion during solid state contact were taken into account. Using this DEM simulation method, the time-dependent particle packing processes and the resulting pore structure in the greenbody compact can be analysed. In addition to high temperature stability, ceramic membranes exhibit backflush capability, they are chemically and microbiologically resistant and have an excellent mechanical stability. Most of ceramic membranes are used in micro- and ultrafiltration applications (0.1 to 1.0 fiin and 1 to lOOnm., respectively) [5,6]. The extremely ultrafine pore size (< 0.1 iim) of the filtration (or inner) layer is produced by using the sol-gel method [5-9]. Typically, this filtration layer is formed on a support (or outer) layer which has larger pore size (1 to 6 f-irn) and is manufactured by slip casting [6,8]. Between the support layer and filtration layer, a discontinuous transition of material properties exists. Which, however, can be avoided by a gradient structure. It is well-known that large particles form the large pores, while small particles form the small pores. Multimodal suspensions will form greenbodies with pore gradient if the size segregation can be ensured during the forming processes. The developed DEM simulation program has been used to study the mechanics for the pore-gradient formation via centrifugal casting under diff"erent colloidal and process conditions. The necessary process parameters were designed and optimized by this DEM simulation tool. Hereby the fabrication of AI2O3 flat membranes was considered as a case study and will be shown in this paper.
30
increasing pore-channel diameter (a) asymmetric membrane
(b) pore-gradient membrane
Figure 1: Analogy between asymmetric and pore-gradient membrane. 2 PARTICLE PACKING A N D PORE-GRADIENT FORMATION Ceramic powders have usually a continuous size distribution. For well-stabilized and lessconcentrated suspensions, a size separation can be achieved through the optimized centrifugal casting processes. Once the size separation can be ensured, a continuous pore-gradient structure can be fabricated. The resulted pore structures will look like the random packing structures of nearly monosized spheres. Hereby the large particles form the large pores on the bottom of the sediment, while small particles form the small pores on the top layer of the sediment. This pore-gradient structure is analogous to an asymmetric membrane (see Fig. 1) which is prefered in the filtration applications. The resistance of an asymmetric membrane to mass transfer is determined largely or completely by the thin top layer. There are several factors which may influence the size separation and packing structure during the centrifugal casting. These factors include Zeta potential, ionic and solid concentration, centrifugal acceleration, viscosity of medium, size distribution and suspension height, etc.. The particle packing dynamics under simultaneous influences of these factors will be studied in the following sections by using the DEM simulation method. 3 D E M A N D D Y N A M I C SIMILARITY FOR PROCESS SIMULATION 3.1 D i s c r e t e element m e t h o d ( D E M ) The discrete element method regards each particle as an individual element, and where the motion of each particle is calculated according to the Newton's second law. At time t, the total response forces EF,- and moments EM,- of each element to its surroundings produce linear (a) and angular {to) accelerations: EMi = JCJ .
EF,
For the numerical computations, if the time step At is chosen small enough, then the accelerations (a.ij) could be assumed to be constant. At constant linear and angular accelerations, the linear v and angular uj velocities can be obtained by t-\-At
- /
idt ^ a At
and
UJ
I
t-{-At
Lodt ^ LO At
Using the trapezoidal rule, the Hnear and angular displacements have been calculated. At time t-|-At, these displacements are used to compute the new displacements at the end of the current time increment. This process is repeated until the response forces and moments become zero or when the process is stopped.
31 3.2 D y n a m i c similarity in centrifugal casting The DEM method can't simulate the system in full-scale because of computing limits, e.g. number of particles, computing time, etc.. Like many problems in the fluid dynamic, a smaller model system has to be developed and tested for the design purpose. Test results obtained from experiments with the smaller model system can then be transfered to the full-scale system. In centrifugal casting process, the centrifugal force (or accelerated gravity) is the only driving force for the size separation and mass transport, and only inertia and centrifugal forces play an important role. For such flow phenomena, the Froude number Fr = v/ s/gl should be the criterion of similarity [10]. The characteristic length / may be the suspension height, if the centrifugal acceleration g and the velocity of particle v are involved. For dynamic similarity between the model and full-scale system, the relationship can be expressed as (Fr)„, = (Fr)j
or
—^^^
= —L=
W hn 9'fn
.
(1)
\lfQj
If the velocities of particles at the corresponding points of both systems are assumed to be identical, i.e. ^;„^ = v/, then the conditions for the dynamic similarity reduce to
^m gm = yjhgs
or Im gm = hgf
•
(2)
For the case of free sedimentation, a sphere with diameter dp and density differing from that of the medium by A p moves at the Stokes settling velocity, Vo = ~ j ^ ^ g 18?/
,
(3)
where g is the centrifugal acceleration (or gravity) and rj the medium viscosity. Introducing the process times tm — lm/^\n and tj — Ij/vj and the model ratio l^ = Im/h ^^^ using the relationships in Eq. 2 and 3, the process time ratio can be expressed as
^ = k . i l ^ / , . . i ^ = /;2 . if
If
v,^-^
(4)
g.fy^
4 PROCESS SIMULATION A N D DESIGN 4.1 M o d e l s y s t e m For a full-scale system w^ith a suspension height of If — lOrmii^ a model suspension height with Im — 70 pm has been introduced. This corresponds to a model ratio of Ir = 10^. In the case of an applied centrifugal acceleration of gf — iO g (g ^ lOm/5^), the centrifugal acceleration for the model system gm. must be calculated according to Eq. 2, so that the dynamic similarity can be fulfilled. This results to g^ = 40 000 g. For the simulation, multimodal AI2O3 powders (p = 3.98 (//c??2"^) with the following discrete size distribution, 5 % with c/i = Ipni, 20% with do = O.Spm, 40% with c/3 = 0.6 pm, 2 5 % with (^4 = OApm and 10%) wdth c/5 = 0.2pm, will be used. The DLVO (Deryaguin-Landau-Verwey-Overbeek) potential interactions and medium influences described in [4] have been taken into account. A Zeta potential of ( == 40/7/1'', the Hamaker constant of AH = 4.76 x 10~^^J between AI2O3 particles in aqueous solution and a Debye-Hiickel parameter of AC = 10~^m~^ for the suspensions were assumed. In the following presentations, the process times for the full-scale system according to Eq. 4 have been used.
32 S 0.8|
(b)
pA = 5 % , t = 42.32mm
S
\(b) (a) initial state 0.61 \ (b) stabilized (C=40mV)| \ (c)flocculated(C=OmV)| 0.4
o
0.2
a ^
(c)-\
Bo PA = 5 % , t = 42.32 min
, 2 3 ^^^
(a)
^ 0.01 0-2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 Normalized distance from left end •#•40 g
Figure 3: Particle packing dynamics and structures of a stabilized and a flocculated AI2O3 suspension and the corresponding size distributions of smallest particles. The initial state (a) is identical with the initial state in Fig. 2(a), and is therefore omitted here. of a stabilized and a flocculated suspension with PA — 5 %. In Fig. 3, the initial state is identical with the initial state in Fig. 2. The flocculated suspension shows obviously a worse size separation as the stabilized one. The agglomerates A (two particles with d^ = 0.2/utm and one particle with c/4 = OA/jm.) and B (three particles with d^ = 0.2 fim) in Fig. 3(c) will settle much faster than a single stabilized particle with d^ = 0.2 jim. This prevents the formation of a good pore-gradient. 4.4 Influences of solid concentration Using different concentrated suspensions, different thicknesses of sediments can be obtained. It is therefore desirable to know that can a higher concentrated suspension ensure also a good size separation for a good pore-gradient formation? In order to answer this question, suspensions with area density of pA = 7.5% and 10% have been simulated. There is no difference in the size separation effect to be observed in the simulation results in Fig. 4. The only difference is the thicknesses of each sediments. 5 CONCLUSIONS The DEM simulation results show that the pore-gradient membranes can be formed by using the stabilized AI2O3 suspensions with a suspension height of 70 mm and a density of < 10 % under a centrifugal acceleration of AOg. A process time of t > 6 hours is enough for a complete sedimentation of the finest particles with d^ = 0.2 pm. Using flocculated suspensions, the quality of pore-gradient will be negatively influenced. But using a higher centrifugal acceleration, a shorter process time, a better size separation and better pore-gradient can be expected. These simulation results have been used as process design parameters and verified experimentally [11]. AI2O3 flat membranes via centrifugal casting with a graded pore-size distribution from 40 to 250 nm across a membrane thickness of about 5 mm have been shown in [11]. A c k n o w l e d g m e n t : The author would Hke to thank the German Science Foundation (Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft, DFG) for the financial support.
33
(a) initial state (b) t = 25.27 min (c) t = 48.64 min
•P2J»? •».
(a) l.Oj
PA =
5% C=40mV
0.8
Kb);
0.6
:ic)
0.4
•N^
J^L-
0.2
(bj-—,P25
1(c)'
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Normalized distance from left end
^40 g Figure 2: Pore-gradient forming dynamics of a stabilized AI2O3 suspension during centrifugal casting with an acceleration of 40 g and the corresponding size distribution of smallest particles. 4.2 Pore-gradient forming dynamics of stabilized suspensions It is believed that excellent pore-gradient structures can be obtained from well-stabilized and less-concentrated suspensions. Thus, a stabilized suspension with 250 particles and the above-mentioned discrete size distribution have been generated in a square box of 70jum X 20.53 ^ m without contacts for the simulations (see Fig. 2(a)). This corresponds to an area density of pA — 5%. Hereby periodic boundaries in the horizontal direction and walls in the centrifuging direction have been assumed. Fig. 2 shows the time-dependent pore-gradient forming dynamics during casting and the corresponding size distribution ratios of smallest particles with c^5 = 0.2 fim. Hereby the distribution ratio was calculated in the way that the counted smallest particles in every distance partition, in which 1/5 of all particles (in this case: 50) exist, was divided by the total number of smallest particles (in this case: 25). This size distribution ratio of smallest particles is taken as reference quantity for the size distribution and for the gradient formation. The initial state shows a relatively homogeneous size distribution. The size separation increases with the processing times. After t = 48.64 min, more than 80% of the smallest particles remain in the suspension. The smallest particle P25 needs at least 7 times of the past processing time, i.e. t — 1 x 48.64 min ^ 6 hours, to reach the sediment. Therefore, it can be expected that after 6 hours a thin top layer made of smallest particles can be formed and a pore-gradient can be obtained. There are only less than 20 % of the smallest particles are packed in interior of the sediment, because their free sedimentation ways are too short for a good segregation. 4.3 Influences of Zeta potential For the flocculated suspensions with C = OinV, the size segregation effect will be disturbed by the dominating attractive interaction between particles. This disturbance can be observed even in the less-concentrated suspensions. Fig. 3 shows the packing structures after a process time of t = 42.32 mi??- and their corresponding distributions of smallest particles
34
(b)
^
0.8
^
0.6
0.4
c= 40mV,t = 25.27 min (a)/>A== (b)pA ==
5% 7.5 % (c) PA=:10%
\^ vs. "^^
(b)
0.2
•^^^N
(c)
(c) C = 40 mV,t = 25.27 min
0.0 0.2
0.4
(a) ^ ^" - '^^' 0.6
0.8
1.0
Normalized distance from left end
^40 g
Figure 4: Particle packing dynamics and structures of stabilized AI2O3 suspensions with different solid fractions and the corresponding size distributions of smallest particles. The initial state (a) is identical with the initial state in Fig. 2(a), and is therefore omitted here. REFERENCES [I] C.-W. Hong and P. Greil, Discrete Element Modelling of Colloidal Powder Processing, Ceramic Transactions, Vol. 54: Science, Technology, and Applications of Colloidal Suspension, American Ceramic Society, (1995) pp. 235-249. [2] C.-W. Hong and P. Greil, DEM Simulation of Particle Packing Dynamics during Colloidal Forming Processes, Ceramic Transactions, Vol. 51: Ceramic Processing and Technology, American Ceramic Society, (1995) pp. 349-353. [3] C.-W. Hong, Computer-Aided Process Modelling of Colloidal Powder Forming{m German), Fortschrittsbericht der DKG 10 (1995) [4], pp. 225-241. [4] C.-W. Hong, Discrete Element Modelling of Colloidal Packing Dynamics During Centrifugal Casting, J. of the Ceramic Society of Japan, 104[9] 793-795 (1996). [5] A. Larbot, J.-P. Fab re, C. Guizard, L. Cot, New Inorganic Ultrafiltration Membranes: Titania and Zirconia Membranes, J. Am. Ceram. Soc, 72[2] 257-61 (1989). [6] K. K. Chan and A. M. Brownstein, Ceramic Membranes - Growth Prospects and Opportunities, Am. Ceram. Soc. Bull., 70[4] 703-7 (1991). [7] C. Guizard, A. Julbe, A. Larbot, L. Cot, Nanostructures in Sol-Gel Derived Materials. Application to the Elaboration of Nano filtration Membranes, Key Engineering Materials Vols. 61 & 62 (1991) pp. 47-56, Trans Tech PubHcations, Switzerland. [8] R. Kohl, G. Tomandl, A. Larbot, L. Cot and J. Gillot, Herstellung und Charakterisierung von keramischen Membranen aus Titanoxid zur Cross-Flow-Ultrafiltration nach dem Sol-Gel-Verfahren, Kurzreferatepp. 64-66, DKG-Jahrestagung, Bayreuth, 4.-7. Oktober 1992. [9] Q. Xu and M. A. Anderson, Sol-Gel Route to Synthesis of Microporous Ceramic Membranes: Thermal Stability of Ti02-Zr02 Mixed Oxides, J. Am. Ceram. S o c , 76[8], 209397 (1993). [10] D. N. Roy, Applied Fluid Mechanics, Ellis Horwood Ltd., Chichester, 1988. [II] C.-W. Hong, F. Miiller and P. Greil, Fabrication of Pore-Gradient Membranes via Centrifugal Casting, paper presented at the 4th International Symposium on Functionally Graded Materials (FGM), Tsukuba/Japan, October 20 - 24, 1996.
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
35
Mathematical Model for Axial-Symmetrical FGM X.D.Zhang^ T.Q.Lm% C.C.Ge^ "Mathematics-Mechanics Faculty, ^Laboratory of Special Ceramics & P / M University of Science and Technology Beijing
Abstract Analytical procedure for empty cyUnder of Functionally Graded Material(FGM) with axicJ symmetry has been investigated. Based on thermcil elasticity theory and computational mathematical method, temperature distribution has been obtained and thermal stress of FGM in ring section has been calcidated.
1
INTRODUCTION
Ceramic-metal FGM is a new kind of heterogeneous composite material that consists of a gradient compositional variation from ceramic to metal from one surface to the other. These continuous changes result in property gradients. Because ceramic has good heat-resistance and metal has high strength. Ceramic-metal FGM can work at super high-temperature or under high-temperature difference field. Because of its good property , ceramic-metal FGM is expected to be used in hghtweight structure such as 2iircraft and spacecraft structures. It is the key problem to reduce thermal stress made from different effective materia properties for intermediate compositions of the FGM and prevent destruction by thermcil stress. This paper discusses temperature distribution 2ind thermal stress distribution in empty cylinder. This topic wiU be of great interest for fabrication of ceramic-metal FGM.
2
ANALYTICAL MODEL
Considering an empty cylinder with axial symmetry whose iimer radius is a, outer radius is b. The cylinder in ring section is made of n layers through the radius, which could represent a gradient of material distribution. CyUndrical coordinates are used and the z-axis is taken as symmetrical axis as shown in Fig.l. Such an ideaHzation requires uniform mixture of ceramic and met Ell phase and isotropic in each layer. It is assumed that the FGM is placed in a steady state temperature field. The temperature of inner and outer surface of FGM are Ti and T2 respectively, and two ends of model are insulation.
36
••
^
Figure 1. Analytical model. Figure 2. Mechanical model
3
DISTRIBUTION FUNCTIONS OF FGM CYLINDER
Assuming that the constituents of FGM comprise phase A(metal), phase B(ceramic). The volumes for contituents are express as VAandVB respectively. Let J^
-
VA+VB
' J^
-
VA-\-VB
here fAifs axe the volume functions for the metal and ceramic of FGM respectively, which satisfy the following equation /4 + / B = 1 Supposing r-coordinate of each layer is expressed as a = ro < 7*1 < • • • < Tn = 6 f\ denotes volume function of metcJ phase of FGM in i-th layer. According to hypothesis of analytical model, we have f\ = Ci{cost), Ti-x
fAir) = J2f/'l\{r),a
^^ ^
\ 0,
(1) * )^) is base function, the definition of which is as follows
< r < ri ri
(2)
37
l'A{r)=<
i^^^r, I 0,
1 0,
ri
ro
r„_i n-l
(3)
(4)
' U J^ ' ^ '
p is a form factor.
4
CALCULATION OF EFFECTIVE PROPERTIES
In Older to calculate the temperature distribution and the thermal stress distribution in the FGM cylinder, effective material properties such as heat expansion coefficient a(r), heat conduct on coefficient k(r), the volume modidus K{r)^ the shear elasticity G(r) and Young's modi V. E(r) for intermediate composition of the FGM are required. This paper assumes that ' ckch layer of FGM is simple macroscopically isotropic two-phase system with spherical particles.We utilize formula proposed by K.Wakashimat^Ho calculate effective properties in each layer.
5
TEMPERATURE DISTRIBUTION OF FGM
Because the empty cylinder of FGM is placed in steady state temperature field, two ends are heat insulation, the temperature distribution T is no relation with z, 9 and time t. One dimensional equation of heat conduction in r direction is given as: A_LZ^ =0
(5)
It satisfies boundary conditions T(a) = Ti,Tib) = T2 It is very easy to solve this equation by virtue of the assumption of FGM being homogeneous in each layer. Let us denote ki as the heat conduction coefficient at i-th layer. The temperature distribution can be expressed as follows by using local radius variables Vi : T(r) - Ti + C{T2 - Ti)( E MiiAiz^ + C =^l/{f2 H^»A'-0)
^-i^irJiA) (6)
Ts
6
THERMAL STRESS CALCULATION
According to hypothesis of analysis model, we can know variations of temperature AT(r) is symm-etrical with the z axis, and have nothing to do with the z coordinate. And thus displacement W along the z axis can be zero. Suppose taking the i-layer of the empty cylinder as an obj'ct of study as shown in Fig.2 , there are only three stresses (Tr{r), <7"^(r), ^^^(r). Owing to
38 symmetry of the center axis and equalization along the axis, three shearing stresses and shearing strains can be zero. crr(r) and (TQ(r) fit balance equation:
^
+ ^^ir)^
=0
(a)
Because of W = 0,6^ = 0 . So crz(r) = McTrir) + M^)) -
aiEiAT{r) (b)
Stress-strain relation is £, - (1 + Ui)aiAT{r)
== i ^
[
j^^Mr)]
£ « - ( ! + ./i)aiAT(r)
= i ^ K ( r ) - j^
Using u as redial displacment 2ind geometrical equation is
^r = t ; ee = ^
(d)
Prom (c) (Trj(T0 can be solved, and then return to balance equation (a) with (d), u as a residt can be solved.
u =i ± ^ ^
r AT{r)rdr + AiVi + —
\ — Ui Vi J a
(7)
Tj
SO
'^^^'^^ - 1 - ^i r? y„ ^^^'^^'^^ + (1 + .0(1 - 2^0 ^ (1 + "O'-l
(1 - "0
(9)
from (b) ,we have
'^^('•) - i r : 7 ; o ~ ^ (1+"0(1-2.0
^'°^
here Ai^Bi are certain integral constants, which can be defined by the boundary corditions and continuity condition. Two equations can be obtained by the boundary condition: (Tr{a) = 0,(7^(6) = 0.
39
On the basis of the continuity condition for the boundztries in every layer, u or a{r) along r direction is continuous, so
{(Tr)i = {(Tr)i-\.l t =
l,2,..-,(n-l)
According to hypothesis of analysis model, the empty cylinder has n layers . So there are 2(n-l) continuity conditions. Getting them together with two boundary condition, we have 2n equations. Thus 2n integral constants Ai^Bi can be solved by 2n equations. These equations are expressed as follows:
iP^ai
- l±i^ai+i)i r
I -fi
1 - I'i+l
aiEi at+iEi+il r^lEL_?^i±l^i±l)L
AT{r)r
ri Ja
p r
(13)
Ti
.^, . , ATMrdr
, +
, f
EjAj ^^
r ? l ( l + «/,)
Et+iAi+i ^ +i)(l-2i/i+i)^ ( l + «/Hi)^
^ '
For simphcity, let
Ci = -{-
ai -
Dj = —^(Bi
-
«i+i)-2 /
AT(r)r(fr
Bi^i)
i=l,2,...,(n-l) The equation (13) can be simpHfied as: Ai - Ai+i = Ci + Di
(15)
Similarly, let Fi = -{-
aiEi
ai^iEi^i
) /
r*
AT{r)rdr
Hi = z—-—^Gi l-2i/i ' l + i/i z = l,2,-..,(n-l) The equation (14) can be simpHfied as: GiBi - Gi^iBi^i
= Fi^ r^{GiHiAi
- Gi^iHi^iAi^i)
(16)
Thus Ai,Bi{i = 1,2,- -,71) can be solved by equation (11) (12) (15) (16). Finally, getting Ai^Bi{i = 1,2,- -,71) to (8) (9) (10), the expression of thermal stress in every layer can be obtained.
40
7
CONCLUDING REMARKS
ON the basis of the hypothesis analysis model, this paper gives temperature distribution and thermal stress distribution of FGM. By using above formulas to calcidate thermal stress in every layer, the optimum combination and distribution profile will be expected to obtain.
8
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
this project is supported by China National Natural Science Foundation, Doctorial Programe Foundation of State Education Commission and China National Committee of High Technology New Matericils.
References [1] K.Wakashima & H.Tsukamoto,Proc First Int . Symposium, FGM , Sendai JAPAN:1990 [2] Tohru H,Junichi T,Tomohiko Y,Proc First Int Symposium, FGM Sendai JAPAN:1990.
I. Shiota and M.Y, Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
41
Stress analysis in a two materials joint with a functionally graded material Y.Y.Yang and D.Munz Institute for Reliability and Failure Analysis, Karlsruhe University P.O.Box 3640,D-76021 Karlsruhe, Germany
Abstract In this paper the stresses in a joint with a functionally graded material (FGM) are analyzed. In the middle of a joint with FGM the stresses have been calculated analytically by using the plate theory. The effect of the thickness of the FGM layer and the effect of the transition function form on the stresses in the joint is discussed. Near the free edges of the interface in a joint with FGM, the stresses are described analytically by using the Mellin transform method. Some examples are presented to show the good agreement of the stresses calculated from FEM and with the analytical description in a joint with graded material.
1
Introduction
After a homogeneous change of temperature very high stresses exist near the free edges of the interface of a two dissimilar homogeneous materials joint due to the difference in elastic constants and in thermal expansion coefficients. For most material combinations with elastic material behaviour stress singularity occurs, i.e. the stresses are infinite at the intersection of the free edges and the interface. By introducing a FGM interlayer these stresses can be reduced significantly and the stress singularity at the free edge of the interface vanishes [1]. The functionally graded material is often used for reducing the thermal stress or residual stress in a dissimilar materials joint, also for another aims. The material properties in FGM depend on the coordinates. Therefore, it is very difficult to calculate the stresses analytically in such a joint, even for very simple geometry and simple loading. The Finite Element Method (FEM) is generally used to calculate the stress distribution in a joint with FGM. However, in the middle of a thin joint the stresses can be calculated analytically by using the plate theory. In the present paper the Mellin transform method is used to describe analytically the stresses in the edge range of a joint with graded material.
42
i
y A
y 1
,
Material 2
i
1
'
Material 2
I
FGM
h. ' f i
hi
1
yf
FGM
— • Xj
Material 1
hi
X
'
_.,.,
^x
(b)
(a) Fig.l The geometry of a joint with FGM.
2
Stresses in t h e middle of a joint with F G M
Using the plate theory, the stresses in the middle of the joints in Fig.l can be calculated from (1)
"•«' = T ^ ( ' ' - S - ^ ^ " ' « >
where the quantities e^ and R can be determined from the equilibrium conditions of the force and moment, i=l,2,...,N is the number of layers in the joint, E is Young's modulus, u is Poisson's ratio and a is thermal expansion coefficient. Fkt. 3
Fkt. 2
-^ ^^
Fkt. 4
4—e-^^ ^r;/y ^ = 0) qi^y = 0)
0 OQ 0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
I 0.2
-O a^y = h,) 1 1.0
I 0.4
i 0.6
0.8
1.0
f
f
Fig.2 (left) Stresses versus f for hi/H=O.Ol {Ei = 200 GPa, u^ =: u^ = 0.3, c^i = 5 * 10-yK, E2 = 100 GPa, 0^2 = 10 * IQ-yK), Fig.3 (right) Stresses versus f for hi/H=0.05. In Fig.la, we assume that in FGM the transition function of E and a is the same, i.e., E{y) = g{EuE2, y),
a{y) = g{au 0^2, y)
(2)
where Ei, ai is the value of the material at y=0 and ui = iy2- We define a quantity
f = ^j\ifuf2,y)dy
(3)
43 with / i = 1 and /2 = 0. The quantity f is the average value of material 1 in the FGM. f = fi = 1 means that FGM is the homogeneous material 1, f = /2 = 0 means that FGM is the homogeneous material 2 and a linear transition function corresponds to f=0.5. The different value of f means that in FGM the transition function form is different. For hi/H =0.01 (H=/ii + /12), the stresses at different positions are plotted versus f in Fig.2 and for hi/H =0.05 in Fig.3. It can be seen that for a very thin FGM layer (thickness of FGM = 1% H) the transition function form in FGM has a negligible effect on the stresses, whereas for a thickness of FGM = 5%H the transition function form in FGM has a significant effect on the stresses. Generally, it is impossible to reduce the stresses at any position of the joint for thermal loading. Therefore, the optimization of the stress in a joint with FGM is not unique. There is no general rule for the optimization of the stress in a joint with FGM. The optimization of the stress in a joint with FGM may be: (a) reduce the maximum stress in the joint; (b) move the location of the maximum stress from the interface; (c) reduce the stress at a special location, e.g., at the upper surface, at the lower surface, at the interfaces, etc. Some studies on (a) and (b) have been given in [2]. As an example for the case (c), we use the transition function (coordinates see Fig.lb) E{y) = g{Ei, ^ 2 , y) = E2 - (^2 - ^1)
hi +
h2-y
(4)
where n can be varied to reach a optimization of the stress. Our aim regarding the optimization of the stress is that, for example, at the lower surface (y=0) or at the interface (y=^i) the stress in the middle of the joint equals zero. We can vary n and the geometry ^ 1 , ^2, hs. For a given geometry hi, /i2, /13, the corresponding values of n have been found and they are plotted in Fig.4 for cTxiv = 0) = 0 and in Fig.5 for cr^iy = hi) = 0, where U—hi + /12 + ^3- From these figures we can see that for some geometries it is impossible to reach the optimization, if this transition function form is used.
n 0.125
0.25
0.375
0.5 h,/H
0.625
1
r
0.75
0.875
1.0
0.375
Fig.4 (left) The possible n for a^{y = 0) = 0 {h2 = H - hi - /13). Fig.5 (right) The possible n for a^iy — hi) — 0.
0.5 h,/H
0.625
0.75
0.875
1.0
44
3
Stresses near t h e free edges of a joint with F G M
For thermal loading, the stress function $ in a homogeneous material must satisfy V^^ + V2(gT) = 0
(5)
aE for plane stress aE ^ ^I 7(1-^) ^ ^ for plane strain ' where q is independent of the coordinates and T is the temperature change. Now, in a graded material (i.e. q is not a constant, but q=q(x,y) =q(f, ^)), we can imagine that qT is the effective temperature change and the material is homogeneous. Under this assumption, we obtain the same equation as Eq,(5) for the stress function in a graded material. To get the solution for $, the Mellin transform method is used. The Mellin transform of a function (f, 6) is defined as _{
—\
roo
^s,e)=
/
^{r,e)f^'-^^df
(6)
Jo
where s is the Mellin transform parameter and f = r/L, L is a characteristic length of the joint. The basic equation Eq.(5) in the Mellin domain is [«' + ^ ] [ ( ^ + 2)' + ^]Ms,
with
0) + [is + 2f + ^]f{s
f{s + 2,6>) = / q(f, e)Tr^'-^^^df = To J
+ 2,9) =0
(7)
q{f, e)f^'^^Uf,
(8)
0
where the temperature change is T=To for f < RQ and T=0 for f > RQ. Its solution is
^,{s,e) = ¥,{s,o) + ^'(s,e) with
4^(5,9) = Aks''^ + AkC-''^ + Bke'^'"^^^^ + 5^6-^(^+2)^
4^^(s, 0) = — Lin{se) jfk{s
(9) ^^^O)
+ 2, e)cos{sO)de - cos{se) ffk{s -h 2,0)sin{se)de\ (11)
where the coefficients Ak and Bk can be determined from the boundary conditions (k=l, 2 for material 1 and 2). For the case of a polymonial as the transition function, i.e. E{f, e) = A-\- Bfsm{0) + Cr^ sin2(6>) + Df^ sm\0) + Er^ sin^(l9) + ... the stresses in the Mellin domain are obtained [3] as
(12)
45 where Sn is the solution of A*A2 = 0 and dijk{sn, 0) / 0, The stresses in a polar, coordinate system can be calculated from
Sn<7
-
V
^-
lim '^
Us - s ) ' ^
'^'^'^^'^^
r-'^+^H
(14)
For each s^ there is ^zjn(r, 0) = 7 ^ - [ ^ n ( ^ , i^n) + 9^Jn{0)ln{f)
+ /l.,n(^)],
(15)
where Un = —{sn + 2), the functions fijn{^^Kn),gijn{^)^ hijn{0) can be calculated analytically, but the factors K^ should be determined from one numerical method, e.g., FEM. Finally, the stresses in the edge range of a joint can be calculated by
^iiir,0) = J2 {{r/Lr-[fij„i0,K„) For the geometry 6i
+ gij„{e)lnir/L) + V W l } -
(16)
-0^ = 90° there is A2 = —sin{{s -h l)7r).
(17)
Its solutions are Sn = 0, ± 1 , ± 2 , ± 3 , ..,, ±n,,.. s = - l corresponds to the rigid body displacement and for 5 > —1, the displacements at r = 0 are infinite. Therefore, Sn — —2, —3, —4,... , -n, ... are the interested poles of dij{s,6). This means that there is uj^ — 0 , 1 , 2 , 3 , . . . . For A* we have A*-/(^,i/,50.
(18)
The solution of A* = 0 depends on the values of B and v. If ^ = 0, the solutions of A* = 0 and A2 = 0 are the same. If J? 7^ 0, s^^ can be arbitrary value, but 5^ < —2. EXAMPLES
(coordinates see the following Fig.)
The materials data for example 1 are Ex = 100 GPa, z^i = 0.25 = 1^2, o^i = 2.5 * l O ' V K , £;2 = 100 + 50f25m2(6>) ,GPa 0^2 = [2.5 -h 5f'^si'n?{e)] * 1 0 - 7 ^ ^ . The materials data for example 2 are El = 100 GPa, 1^1 = 1 = 1^2,^1 = 2.5 * I O ' V K ,
E2 = 100 + 50f5m(i9),GPa 0.2 = [2.5 + bf^sin^iO)] * 1 0 - V K .
For example 1 we have ^ = 0, therefore, the poles of aij{s, 6) are independent of u. They are s = -2, -3, -4, -5, -6, ..,, where s=-2, - 3 , -5 are the first-order poles of Gij{s,9) and
46 s=:-4, -6 are the second-order poles of dij{s,6). The stresses calculated from Eq.(16) and by FEM are compared and given in Fig,6. For example 2 we have B ^ 0, therefore, the poles of dij{s,6) depend on the values of v and B, They are s== -2, -3, -4, -4.1529, -5, ..., where s=-2, -4.1529 and -5 are the first-order poles, and s=-3 and -4 are the second-order poles of cFij{s, 9). The stresses calculated from Eq.(16) and by FEM are compared and given in Fig.7. From Figs.6 and 7 we can see that in the range of r/L < 0.1 Eq.(16) can describe the stresses very well. 0.030-
O.OlbO-i
0.020-
0.0100-
—™««niaBBB»»n»™«»»»R'^
0.00500.010H \
0.0000-
CO
o.oooH -0.0050-0.010-
...,.^V \
-0.0100o—
-0.020- TTT 1 lE-04
1 I II 1 lE-03
1 I I I 1 1 I Ir 1E-02 1E-01 1E+00 r / L along the line 8 = 0
p -0.01501E-04
"' "^'^1
1—TTT
1E-03
BBiuiiuuumMiii!™::::;^^
^
r-
m — 1 — 1 -I 11—^^t—1 1 11 1E-02 1E-01 1E+00 r / L along the line 8 = - 4 5
Fig.6 Stress distribution along ^ = 0 and 9 =-45 for example 1. U.UJUUt WHiHHHtHtfWHHBIfflgmffl^iqw^ge
0.0200-|
0.0250-
0.0150-
^
^
\
™ ^ 6
/
0.0100-
0.0200-
0.00500.01500.0000-
\
0.0100-
5^ a
-0.00500.0050-
-0.0100o
-0.0150- J
0.0000-^ -0.0050- W T
. 1E-03 2
t-r-n 1 r—r-n \ 1^• i - n 4 lE-02 2 4 1E-01 2 4 1E+00 r / L olong the line 8 = 0
C «•>,
lE--03 2
•W 1\ ^ 4
1E-02 2 4 lE-01 2 4 1E+00 2 r / L along the line 8 = - 4 5
Fig.7 Stress distribution along ^ = 0 and 9 = - 4 5 for example 2. Acknowledgement:The financial support of the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft is gratefully acknowledged. The authors would like thank Mr. Schaller for some calculations.
References 1. D.Munz, Y.Y.Yang, Proc. of 3rd Int. Symposium on Structural and Functional Gradient Materials, 1994, pp.465-471. 2. Y.Y.Yang, D.Munz, Fracture Mechanics: Vol.26, ASTM STP 1256 (1995) pp.572-586. 3. Y.Y.Yang, Stress analysis in a two materials joint with a functionally graded material under thermal loading by using the Mellin transform, submitted to J. Solids & Structures.
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
47
Optimum Design and Fabrication of TiC/NijAl-Ni Functionally Graded Materials Q. Shen , X.-F. Tang , R. Tu , L.-M. Zhang and R.-Z. Yuan State Key Lab. of Materials Synthesis and Processing, Wuhan University of Technology, Hubei, 430070 P.R. China
TiC/Ni3Al-Ni system was chosen for the potential use as the first wall materials of thermonuclear experimental reactors. The residual thermal stresses during fabrication were calculated by finite element inethod. Based on the consideration of minimum stress, minimum ratio of stress to fracture strength and proper distribution of thermal stress in pure TiC side, the optimum design with the distribution exponent P=1.6 was reached. According to the design result, TiC/Ni3Al-Ni FGM samples were then successfully fabricated.
L IISTRODUCTION In recent years functionally graded materials(FGMs) have received considerable attention. Ceramic/metal type FGMs are believed to be hold promise in applications for advanced technology, especially in aerospace and nuclear engineering, where the materials encounter high heat loads[l-2]. On the basis of the traditional cermet TiC-Ni, we chose TiC/NiaAl-Ni FGM system, which was composed of Ni as the metal phase, TiC as the ceramic phase and TiC-Ni3 Al composites with various Ni3Al ( has a lower thermal expansion coefficient and a better wettability with TiC[3] ) volume fraction as the graded interlayers.
2. EXPERIMENTS AND CALCULATION Pure metal Ni and TiC-Ni3Al composites with Ni3Al volume fraction of 0, 20%, 40%, 60%, 80%, 100% were sintered by HP method for 2h at ISOO^C and 30MPa under Ar gas protection( the same as the conditions for sintering TiC/'Ni3Al-Ni FGMs). The samples were then cut and ground into 36x4x3mm strips, the mechanical properties including Young's modulus, Poisson ratio and the fracture strength, were measured by a four-point bending test method. The thermal expansion coefficient was tested by a non-loaded thermal dilatometer. The tested v ^ e s are indicated in Table 1.
48 Table 1 Properties of Ni and TiC-Ni3Al composites with various Ni3Al volume fraction Ni3Al volume fraction (%)
0
Young's modulus (GPa) Poisson ratio Fracture strength (MPa) Thermal expansion coefficient (xl0"%-l)
20
40
60
320
318
340
267
0.195
0.195
317
587
0.225 1351 9.15
0.253 1261 9.46
7.40
7.55
80
100
100(Ni)
266
199
206
0.270 0.295 0.30 1468 1346 1322 11.46 11.90 13.30
The residual thermal stresses were calculated by a finite element computer programme Super-Sap. The model is 10mm in diameter, 6mm in thickness and has 11 graded layers. Due to the axisymmetric problem, an axisymmetric finite element modle is used and 1/4 part of the material is considered. The FE model includes 1200 elements and 1275 nodal points. The thermal load is raised from the sintering temperature 1300 ^C to room temperature. Moreover, an insulated heat condition is considered at the flank boundary. The compositional distribution of the metal and ceramic in the graded layers was assumed to take the form C=(x/d)P[4], where C is the volume fraction of Ni3Al, d is the distance to the graded layers, x is the layer location coordinate, and P is the distribution exponent. In the calculation, the material properties at the graded layers were obtained by using the tested values.
3. THERMAL STRESS ANALYSIS AND OPTIMIZATION 3.1. Thermal stress analysis of TIC-Ni two layers material It can be seen from Table 2 that the stresses at the metal-ceramic interface are extremely high. For the radial stress GJ^ and the circumferential stress 099, the metal side is in compressive state and the ceramic side in tensile state, which due to the difference thermal expansion coefficient. The stress state of the axial stress a^z in Z-axis direction is quite the contrary. Such large stresses at the interface can easily lead to rupture failure of the two layers material. Also, the experimental results prove to be the same. Table 2 Calculated results of the thermal stress for TiC-Ni t(vo layers material an- (MPa) Metal side Ceramic side
-1930 1550
099 (MPa) -1930 1550
GZ^
(MPa)
1870 -837
49 3.2. Thermal stress analysis and optimization of TiC/NijAl-Ni FGMs The thermal stresses of TiC/Ni3 Ai-Ni FGMs were calculated for different exponent values ranging from 0.6 to 2.2. Fig.l presents the tensile stress a^r and Cjri with respect to the distribution exponent P. From Fig. 1, it is seen that within the exponent values tfie thermal stress in any of the FGMs is relaxed compared with that in the two layers material. In particular, when P=1.8, the stress a^- is a minimum (280MPa), and the stress relaxation is a maximimi, up to 75%, whereas the stress Cjz reaches the minimum value (290MPa) at P=1.6, the stress 1000
1.2 1.6 diBtributtonttxponontP
2
24
Fig. 1 Relationship between tensile stress and the distribution exponent P
1.2
1.6
2.4
oiscnxjDon oixporioni r
Fig. 2 Relationship between the ratio of stress to fracture strength and the distribution exponent P
50 relaxation in FGM is nearly 80%. According to the minimum stress rule, P=1.6~1.8 can be the optimum points for the FGM compositional design. It k noticed that the FGM interlayers have differentfracturestrength. If the thermal stress occurs at any interlayer was not optimized, the FGM could be damaged. By examining the ratio of the stress to the corresponding layer fracture strength, an optimum P can be obtained. From Fig. 2, the ratio for c^ is found to reach its minimum value (0.27) at P=1.8, but for Oj^ it is at P=1.4. Therefore, the optimum result for the FGM compositional design is P=1.4~1.8. To verify the reasonableness of the FGM compositional optimum design, one must also check the stress state at the pure ceramic side since it is usually damaged first. Fig. 3 provides the relationship between the stress at the TiC side and the exponent P. From Fig. 3, it is observed that the residual stress at the pure TiC side decreases with increasing of P, and it experiences a transition at P=1.6 from tensile to compressive, where the stress is zero. This is favourable for FGM fabrication. Therefore, P=1.6 is indeed an optimum design for TiC/Ni3Al-Ni FGMs. 800
•soo
dtatributlonflxponontP
Fig. 3 Relationship beween the stress in pure TiC side and the distribution exponent P 4 FABRICATION Table 3 Constituent (vol%) and density (g/cm^) of FGM layers layer Ni3Al TiC Density
1 100(Ni) 0 8.90
2
3
97.5 92.4 2.5 7.6 7.47 7.23
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
85,4 76.9 67.0 55.8 43.5 30,0 15.5 14.6 23.1 33.0 44.2 56.5 70.0 84.5 7.13 6.94 6.67 6.52 6.21 5.85 5.47
0 100 5.03
51 According to the optimum design result P=1.6, the constituent and density of each layer is determined, as shown in Table 3. The mixtures were prepared by mixing a 5pm average sized Tie powder, 5S3puxk sized Ni3Al and Ni powder, fhen sintered under the same conditicms stated previously.
(a) Layers near the metal side (b) Layers near the ceramic side (c) the 4th and 5th layers
Fig. 4 SEM micrographs of the FGM Fig.4 gives the SEM micrographs of the FGM specimen. From Fig.4a,4b, the layered projSle is clear. The SEM micrograph of the FGM interface between the 4th and the 5th layer is shown in Fig. 4c, the transition crossing the layer interface is smooth, no cracks and pores are observed. It is indicated that the expected design has been achieved during the fabrication process.
5. CONCLUSIONS (1) Within the exponent values ranging from 0.6 to 2.2, the theimal stress in any of the FGMs is relaxed compared with that in TiC-Ni two layers material.
52 (2) By analysing the thennal stress and its distribution, an optimum design with the exponent P=1.6 was reached. (3) TiC/Ni3Al-Ni FGM samples were successfully fabricated via a HP method.
REFERENCES [1] M.Niino, T.Hirai, and R. Watanabe, J. Jpn. Soc. Compos. Mater., 13(1987),257 [2] Edited by B.Dschner and N.Cherradi, Proc. 3rd Int. Sym. on SFGM, Presses Pofytechniques et Universitaires Romandes,1995. [3] L.M.Zhang, R.Tu and R.Z.Yuan, Acta Materiae Compositae Sinica, 12(1995),22 [4] A.Kawasaki and R.Watanabe, J. Jpn. Soc. Powder Metall., 37(1990),253
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
53
A Mathematical Model for Particle Distribution in Functionally Graded Material Produced by Centrifugal Cast Zhang Baosheng Zhu Jingchuan Zhang Yongjun Ying Zhongda Cheng Hongsheng An Geying School of Material Science and Engineering, Harbin Institute of Technology, Compus Box 434, Harbin 150001,P.R.China 1. Introduction Functionally Graded Materials (FGMs), with gradiently distributed reinforcement particles, can be produced conveniently by centrifugal cast due to the segregation phenomena which is caused by the different specific gravities of reinforcement particles and alloy liquids J ^'^'^^ To produce FGMs with accurately distributed particles, the sedimentation procedure of reinforcement particles in centrifugal fields should be theoretically grasped. For this purpose, the paper applies the continuous theory and builds up the mathematical and physical model for reinforcement particle distribution by considering the influence of alloy viscosity and solidification on particle sedimentation as well as the interrelation of particles.^"^^ Then the author solves this model numerically and simulates the sedimentation procedure with aids of numerical analysis and computer graphics. At last, a SiCp/A356 FGM is prepared to rectify the results of theoretical analysis. 2. Mathematical Model Figure 1 shows the microelements filled with melt of reinforcement particles and alloy liquid in the cenrifugal force field. The initial concentration of this microelement is C and the densities of particles and alloy are Pp and pi, respectively. The gravity is omitted because it is * far smaller than the centrifugal force. Thus, the ^^^' ^ J^^^^ eiawfit reinforcement particles can only move in radius " ^^^ ^^ "*® ^ direction. If the particle concentration distribution is axisymmetrical, it can be considered as the function of radius r and time t. At any time t, in a microelement Ar, the volume concentration of particles is C, and the sedimentary velocity is Uc. The unit volume flux J of reinforcement particles in unit time is
J=CUc
(1 )
According to continuous theory, in time At, the change of concentration in the microelement is
[{J + dl/a-) - j]dt = -{dCla)drdt. Adjusting Equation (2), one can write * School of Material Science and Technology, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin , China, 150001
(2 )
54
[{J + dJ/a-) - J]dt = -{dCla)drdt.
(3 )
From Robison^^', the sedimentary velocity of particles with concentration C in centrifugal force field is
Uc=U^x{\-CY
(4)
with Kd^iPp - Or)
^
M where k is the shape coefficient of particles, d is the average diameter of particles, ^ is the viscosity, ps and PL are the specific gravities of particles and liquid, respectively, co is the rotation angular velocity, and r is the centrifugal radius. The change of melt viscosity caused by the increment in volume portion of reinforcement particles (Vp) is /^^P=A(I + | ^ ' . + 7 . 6 F / ] where |ii is the viscosity of alloy liquid. ^^^ Using equation (4) and (5), we may write equation (1) in the form aC o[Ar(l-CyC] —- + ——^^ —^ = 0
ar with
(6)
(7)
aA=
^^-—^-^co\
which is the mathematical model for particle sedimentation. Equation (7) is a nonlinear partial differential equation. According to conditions of convergence and stability, applying against wind differential scheme, it may be discretized as Ari C."-^' ^ ^ « | [ ^ r ( l - C ) ] . -\Ar{\-Cyc\ \ (0
( 10 )
55 which can be discretized as
C;''=C"o +
Ar{l-C,yC,\.
( 11 )
As to the outer element AtN, after the same derivation, we may get ( 12 ) 3.4 Mathematical Model of Solidification Let us still consider the microelement in fig.l, which filled with melt consisting of reinforcement particles and alloy liquid.
The temperature of melt and mold are To and T^, respectively. In order to
produce FGM with particles gradiently distributed in the direction of centrifugal force, the transfer of heat must be in the same direction. Hence, the heat conduction equation can be simplified as
^ ^T
d
( 13 )
dKK' ^%)^^'' dK) • "
dT
where p is the density of alloy, \ is the conductivity coefficient, L is the specific heat of solidification, and gs is the fraction of solid phase. A temperature picking up method is utilized to deal with the solidified specific heat
.
The
second class and third class boundary conditions are prescribed to describe the heat transfer in the inner surface and the outer surface, respectively.
The inner surface is perfectly insulted and the heat transfer of
outer surface can be described as Newton's law of heat transfer. is no interface heat resistance.
Between the casting and the mold, there
To solve equation (13), we can apply direct difference method.
4. Numerical Calculation of Mathematical Model The difference schemes for particles sedimentation in centrifugal force field are shown in equation (8), (11), (12), and the direct difference
format of equation (13). At a certain interval of time, the
particlesconcentration and temperature and the solid fraction of every element are calculated, and then the condition under which the particles stop sedimenting is judged. The sedimentation of particles terminates when (a) the fraction of solid reach to 100% due to the solidification procedure, and (b) the volume fraction of reinforcement particles reach beyond a critical value 0.74 or 74%. 5. Result of Numerical Simulation Fig.2 shows the changes of particle concentration distribution with time. normalized.
All the results are
The reinforcement particles is SiC with the density of S.2g/cm\ and the base alloy is Al alloy.
The viscosity of liquid is 1.19 X 10'^g/(mm.sec), and the centrifugal accelerate is 500g.
The average
concentration Co of reinforcement particles is 20%, and the initial concentration is uniform. Other parameters are selected from reference^^l
( a)
t=30 s
( b ) t=60 s
56
( c ) t=120 s
( d ) t=240 s
Fig. 2 Distribution of reinforcement particle concentration with centrifugal time
From Fig.2., in the case of uniform initial concentration, with the increment of centrifugal time, the concentration distribution of particles is obviously divided into four zones: particles enriched outer zone, uniformly distributed middle zone, gradiently distributed inner transition zone and the non-particle base zone. During process of centrifugal cast, the outer zone expands and its concentration increases, while the middle zone becoming thiimer gradually. The iimer zone moves outside and the base zone expands gradually. At last, after the meh has solidified, three zones - the particles enriched outer zone, the unformly distributed middle zone and the non-particle base zone ~ are formed, which ar^ shown as Fig.2(d). Generally, in the whole process of centrifugal cast, the distribution of reinforcement particle changes distinctively. The concentration curve varies from notching curve to straight line, and fmalUy becomes a convex curve, which is in accordance with and exponential function.
( a ) t=30 s
( b ) t=60 s
( c ) t=120 s
( d ) t=180 s
Fig. 3 Distribution of reinforcement particle concentration with centrifugal time
57 In fig.3, the initial distribution is not uniform while the result is the same as fig. 2. What different are that (a) the uniformly distributed middle zone is not even, and that (b) the changing process speeds up because of the uneven initial concentration. At last, it also develops to three zones~the particles enriched outer zone, the gradiently distributed middle zone and the non-particle base zone. 5.2 Influence of process parameter on distribution Fig.4 illustrates the influences of initial concentration and centrifugal accelerate on particle distribution. The centrifugal time is 180 seconds. When the initial concentration increases, the outer zone become thicker and the concentration distribution become of easier curve. When increasing the centrifugal accelerate G, the speed of sedimention increases and the time to stable state is shortened. The outer zone becomes thinner while its concentration increases.
( a ) 10 % SiC
C a ) G = 300
( b ) 20% SiC
( b ) G = 500
( c ) 30 % SiC
( c ) G^
Fig. 4 Influence of centrifugal process Parameter on particle graidet distribution
6. Fabrication of SiCp/A356 FGM 6.1 Experimental Method To verify the results of numerical simulation, the author designed a set of experiments to research the SiC particle distribution with different centrifugal time. A horizontally rotating centrifuger is applied, shown as fig. 5. The SiC particles, with concentration of 15%, were added through vacuum stirring method. The base alloy was A356. The temperature was 750 °C, and the centrifugal accelerate was 500g. The mold was iron crucible with insulted coating. After the experiment, the sample was cut through radically and axially. The volume fraction and distribution of SiCp particle distribution were determined by optical quantative analyzing technique.
58 6.2 Result of Experiments
±
O«=0(s) ^ « = 120(S) - t = 180(s)
B J^ 20 15(B—o 10 •
(b—<3)—^yg>—^-e—^—e—y
'
NormalizecJ distance
( a ) SiC/A356FGMmacrophotographst=240s
( b ) curve of SiC particle
Fig. 6 changes of distribution SiC particle
distribution
with different time
Fig.6 (a) shows the macrostructures of FGMs produced with different centrifugal time, and fig.6(b) shows the experimental concentration distribution of SiCp particles Which is in accordance with the simulated result perfectly. 7. Conclusion 1. In centrifugal force field, the mathematical model of reinforcement particle distribution is dC_
dr^ J-j,
^Ar{\-CfC\
a= ^/a
J-J^=^/a.
r^Kdjp-p).
)
( l
(i=i) (i=N)
2. The sedimentation process of particles in centrifugal field is dynamic. The static distribution of particles is in accordance with an exponential funtion. Therefore, the particle distribution can be controlled by selecting different process parameters. 3. Under the synphosized boundary conditions, the mathematical model for particle distribution is decretized and solved numerically to obtain the information of influences of different process parameter on concentration distribution. Thus, it is possible to control the particle distribution quantitatively and quaUtatively.
References 1. YJukui eto.Transactions ofthe Japan Society ofMechanical Engineas (C) 56 (1990) 67 2. Fukui, Y, JSME Int, J, Ser. 34-1 ( 1991 ) 144 3. Y.Fukui,Y.Watanabe,Transactions of the Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers ( A ) 58 ( 1992 ) 2472 4. Zhang Baosheng, Foundry vol 218. 3(1995) 6 (in Chinese) 5. T.M. Coulson, Chemical Engineering Volume Two Unit Operation Pergramon Press, 1978 6. Schowalter, W.R, Mechanics of Non-New-tonian Fluids p299 pergamon press 1978 7. Ohnaka , Computer Aided Solidification and Heat Transfer Analysis, 1988.3 8. Qian Miaogen, Metallogy, Shanghai Sceice and Technology Press, 1980 9. Mamoru Mizuno, Toru Matsuoka and Tatsuo Inoue, J.Soc. Mat. Sci, Japan, Vol. 42, No.480, pp. 1046-1051, Sep. 1993
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
59
Modeling and measurement of stress evolution in FGM coatings during fabrication by thermal spray S.Kuroda^> Y.Tashiro^ and T.Fukushima^ ^National Research Institute for Metals, Advanced Materials Processing Division, 1-2-1, Sengen, Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305, Japan ^Department of Materials Science and Technology, The Science University of Tokyo, 2641, Yamazaki, Noda, Chiba 278, Japan 1. INTRODUCTION In thermal spray, molten powder particles are sprayed onto a substrate to form relatively thick coatings of a wide range of materials[l] and the technique has been used to form functionally gradient coatings (FGM) for various applications[2-4]. Residual stresses in thus formed FGM is an important factor which can affect the durability of the FGM under service conditions. We have developed an instrument to continuously measure the curvature of a thin substrate in-situ during spraying to understand the mechanism of stress generation in sprayed coatings. With the understanding acquired through the experiments, a niunerical model has been developed to predict the residual stress distributions in thermal sprayed FGM. 2. EXPERIMENTS AND NUMERICAL MODELING 2.1 Spraying method and conditions NiCrAlY and 8%Y203-Zr02 (YPSZ) powders were plasma sprayed in air under the conditions listed in Table 1. As shown in Fig.l, two torches were operated simultaneously and the powder feed rates to each of the torches were varied as functions of time in order to form FGM coatings, whose typical cross section is shown in Fig. 2. 2.2 Curvature measurement Fig.l also shows the schematic diagram of the instrument to measure the curvature of a substrate during thermal spray[5]. A strip-shaped substrate is fixed onto a pair of knife edges by a pair of springs and the displacement at the center of the rear surface is measured by a displacement sensor. A thermocouple is spot welded to record the thermal history.
60 Table 1 List of spray conditions. Powder material 1 Spray parameters Arc current 1 Plasma gas 1 Flow rate 1 Voltage 1 Powder feed rate x 1 Feed gas flow rate 1 Substrate 1 Spray distance 1 Substrate temp.
NiCrAlY 10 - 44 tim 800A
YPSZ 10 - 44 ^lm 1200A Ar 451/min 30V 0 < X < 10 g/min | 0 < x < 12.5 g/min 2.5 1/min mild steel, 2 x 15 x 100 mm 100mm 470-670K spring
metal
tCU
\
3
B
substrate knife edge
ceramic'
1/R
displ. sensor!
twin plasma torch
Figure 1. Twin plasma torches to spray FGM coatings and the instrument to measure the curvature of a substrate during deposition. 2.3 Modeling The ntmierical model we used was originally developed by Gill and Clyne [6] and has been modified to handle multi-layered deposits. It is a 1-dimensional model and consists of two parts: thermal profile calculation and stress calculation. By regarding the torch motion as a fluctuation in the heat and mass flux onto a reference point on the substrate and assuming biaxial stress state, the program calculates both the through-thickness thermal profile and stress distribution during thermal spray as fimctions of time.
61
Table 2 Thermal and mechanical properties used for modeling. E: elastic modulus, kithermal conductivity, a:thermal expansivity, Gqi quenching stress. NiCrAlY
YPSZ (bulk)
YPSZ (deposit)
190 18
192 4 10 20
19 0.8 8.3 20
E(GPa) k(W/m/K) a(10-6/K) CTq(MPa)
12.2
250
Figure 2. Cross section of FGM coating. *—• 10|im ^
preheat
cool down
spray
^ o.3r — ^ -0.2
;=o.i 2
3 Timelmin]
400r _300 •^200 2
3 Time[min]
Figure 3. Measured curvature and temperature of a substrate during spra3dng of a NiCrAlY coating.
62 3. RESULTS 3.1 Experimental results Fig.3 shows the curvature and temperature records when NiCrAlY was sprayed onto a mild steel substrate. The high-frequency oscillations in the curvature and temperature traces are due to the heating and cooling by the plasma and cooling air jets. From the slope of the gradual curvature change with respect to time, i.e. the coating thickness, quenching stress in sprayed deposits can be evaluated[7]. Quenching stress arises because the thermal contraction of individual splats is constrained by the underljdng solid and is therefore always tensile. The value of quenching stress is independent of substrate material but depends on the substrate temperature. In the case of a substrate temperature around 600K, aq=250MPa for NiCrAlY and 20MPa for YPSZ were obtained. The values of aq as well as the elastic modulus of the deposits with several mixing ratios were also measured too. For the modulus determination, 3-point bending test was performed for deposits detached from substrates. Fig.4 shows the curvature and temperature data when a graded coating was sprayed onto a mild steel substrate by gradually changing the volume ratio of YPSZ from 0 to 1. It is evident that the slope, i.e. the quenching stress, decreases as more YPSZ is mixed. 3.2 Thermal and mechanical properties of sprayed deposits Table 2 lists the thermal and mechanical property data used for the model calculation. The thermal conductivity and elastic modulus of sprayed YPSZ are often an order of magnitude smaller than the bulk values. This is due to extensive microcracks and unbonded gaps between lamellae. 3.3 Model calculation Fig.5 shows the calculated curvature and temperature evolution for an FGM deposit with thickness of about 180|jm, which is consistent with the experimental results shown in Fig.4 except for the transient oscillations. Fig.6 (a) shows the calculated stress distributions in 2-layer and FGM deposits. The gradual stress variation in the FGM can be observed. In Fig.6 (b) effects of model parameters such as the substrate temperature and elastic modulus of YPSZ on the stress distribution in 2-layer deposits are demonstrated. As the substrate temperature is raised from 600 to 825K, the tensile stress in the NiCrAlY layer is significantly reduced. If a value of elastic modulus of 190GPa of a dense bulk material was used, the compressive residual stress in the YPSZ is excessively overestimated. This example clearly demonstrates the importance of using realistic values for modeling thermal and mechanical behavior of sprayed deposits. 4. CONCLUSION To predict the residual stress distributions in sprayed FGM, in-situ curvature measurement is necessary because the values of quenching stress are difficult to
63 preheat
YPSZ vol ratio 0 p400
cool doown
spray
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
6
7
8
9
0.8
0.9
1
|ii|iiMM^^^^
3*200'
0 1
2
3
4
5
10
11
12
Time[nnin]
Figure 4. Measured curvature and temperature of a substrate during spraying of a NiCrAlY/YPSZ FGM coating.
Time (min) ^uu
:
—
I
-
—
\
—
'
—
i
^
—
•
—
*
—
1
—
•
—
-
'
'^~
T
•
^
'
_ _^^^^^^^^ ^
._ _
300
'
1 1 t
U
j j 1
•
200
V
100 n
j
*-. ^
*
•
•
•
*»
1 -
1
1
1
1
1 — 1 — 1 .
8 Time (min)
•
J
1
•
n
•
•
1
12
Figure 5. Predicted curvature and temperature of a substrate during spraying of a NiCrAlY/YPSZ FGM coating.
64
200
l<-
Substrate Deposit
S
2-layer deposit FGM (91ayers)
100
li
CT)
2.0
1.0 Position (mm)
(a) 200
T
1
•
I
-r-
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
•
Ts=600K,Ed= 19GPa Ts=825K, Ed= 19GPa — ^ Ts=825K, Ed=192GPa
100
i
>-^
-^""""""lA^^
^ -100 -200 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
Position (mm) (b) Figure 6. Calculated residual stress distributions in deposits, (a) 2-layer deposit and 9-layer FGM, (b) effects of the substrate temperature and elastic modulus of the YSPZ deposit.
obtain theoretically. Proper evaluation of thermal and mechanical properties of sprayed deposits is also important for modeling because these can be remarkably differed from the values of bulk materials. Using numerical models, the influence of the property data on the stress distributions can be studied easily. REFERENCES 1. L.Pawlowski, The Science and Engineering of Thermal Spray Coatings, Wiley, Chichester, 1995. 2. T.Fukushima, S.Kuroda and S.Kitahara, Proc. 1st Int. Symp. FGM, Sendai, Oct., 1990, p. 145. 3. N.Shimodaet al., i6irf, p.l51. 4. H.StefFens, M.Dvorak, and M.Wewel, ibid, p. 139. 5. S.Kuroda, T.Fukushima and S.Kitahara, Thin SoHd Films, 164(1988)157. 6. S.C.Gill and T.W.Clyne, Thin Solid Films, 250(1994)172. 7. S.Kuroda and T.W.Clyne, Thin Sohd Films, 200(1991)49-66.
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
65
Artificial neural network used for TiB2-Cu FGM design Z.C.Mu', Z.XWang', W.B.Cao', C.C.Ge' ^School of Automation and Information Engineering, University of Science and Technology Beijing, Beijing, 100083, P.R.China ^Laboratory of Special Ceramics and Power Metallurgy, University of Science and Technology Beijing, Beijing, 100083, P.R.China As FGM is a kind of complex heterogeneous composites, the underlying relationship among various factors (composition, constitution, processing parameters etc.) affecting its properties such as density, hardness, strength, fracture toughness, hot shock resistance, elastic modulus and grain size etc. of the bulk or certain layer of FGM are subtle, complicated and very difficult to describe as formulas or rules. Artificial neural network (ANN) does not require any explicit knowledge rules to construct, and can learn by itself to form "mapping" from inputs to outputs. In this work, ANN is first applied for density estimation of the FGM. 1. INTRODUCTION Knowing the effective material properties is essential for the FGM design especially in its earlier stages. Traditionally these properties are obtained mainly by using some classical rules of mixture. More recently some papers have presented the methods that use Expert System and/or Fuzzy Logic as alternatives for the property estimation. However, the FGM is a kind of complex heterogeneous composite, its properties are affected by various factors such as composition, constitution, and processing parameters etc. The underlying relationship among these factors are subtle, complicated, and very difficult to find and describe as formulas or rules. To solve these problems which lack existing solutions, we have applied the Artificial Neural Network (ANN) technology into property estimation of the FGM design. The result from this trial looks quite promising. 2. BACKGROUND OF THE ANN The ANN is mathematical model that simulates many characteristics of actual neurons in the brain. Generally, an ANN is a structurally multi-layered network which links a large number of nodes (the neuron-like computational elements) and operates dynamically. Although mathematical neurons were conceived as early as 1943, only recently have largescale real-world applications become practical. Unlike rule-based Expert System and Fuzzy Logic, the ANN can find relationships among the inputs and outputs of the network without the need for training by an expert. It does not require any explicit knowledge rules to construct. It applies a weight-adaption algorithm to a representative sample of training data to correlate inputs with desired outputs, i.e. it can learn by itself to form "mapping" from inputs to outputs. Another advantage of the ANN over Expert System is that it has the ability to generalize — to produce a reasonable response to data for which the system has not been explicitly trained. In a rule-based Expert System, if a situation occurs for which there is no applicable knowledge rule, it may be unable to give any response.
66 In short, the motive that we have applied the ANN into the FGM design was inspired by the ANN'S distinct characteristics-its noniinearity, ability of self-learning, and ability of generalization. 3. APPLICATION TO THE FGM DESIGN According to our application purpose, the development of the ANN can be described as follows: If defme x^eK" (i=l,2,...,n) as the network inputs which represent the factors that have significant influence on the properties of the FGM and yjGR"" (j=l,2,...,m) as the network outputs which represent the estimated properties, the goals of the work are to choose the network architecture, train the network with data from real experimental process, and make the network act mathematically as an underlying function Y=F(X) which maps network inputs to network outputs. density
hardness
gram size output layer hidden layer
Ti
input layer pressure
B particle size Fig. 1 The Architecture of ANN Network
Development of the ANN for the FGM design consists of two phases. In the first phase, or the training session, an ANN network is trained for the property estimation after its network architecture is determined. The architecture of the network is shown in Fig. 1 . It is a layered, feed-forward network. A supervised learning algorithm — Back-Propagation Algorithm (BPA) is used for the training. The algorithm compares the calculated outputs of the network to the expected outputs, and readjust the weights in the network so that the next time that same input is presented to the network, the network's output will be closer to the expected output value. The training error is defined as: 1
(1)
^^ k=\ f=i
where m is the number of output nodes; n is the number of training data sets; T^^, is the expected output value of the network which is measured from experimental process; and Oi,, is the calculated output value of the network. The network is trained step by step according to the equation : AW(t) = -y\VE{t) + a A ^ ( / -1)
(2)
where the arguments t and t-1 are used to indicate the current and the most recent training step
67 respectively, W represents the weights which interconnect the network nodes, r| is the learning constant, and a is an user-selected positive momentum. During the training session, the equation (2) is applied iteratively until convergence of the calculated and expected outputs. In general, the specific architecture of the network and the optimum value of y\ and a depend on the problem being solved, and there is no single solution suitable for different applications. Therefore, the number of hidden layers, the number of hidden nodes, learning constant r\ and momentum a must be chosen experimentally for the application during the training session. Experimental results have shown that the effectiveness and convergence of the BPA depend significantly on these factors. In the second phase of the development, the ability of property estimation of the network is examined with the data samples which are measured from the experimental process but never used in the training session. Based on the experimental data which were available for the trial, we trained and tested the ANN network to predict densities of FGM. Table 1 shows the comparison of measured and the network estimated densities of as-synthesized TiB2-Cu FGM using the Self-propagating High-temperature Synthesis (SHS) technique. The result indicates that the ANN network can give quite good estimations to the FGM properties. Apart from density, other properties of FGM such as hardness, strength, fracture toughness, hot shock resistance, elastic modulus and grain size etc. of the bulk or certain layer of FGM can be predicted and designed.
Table 1 The Comparison of Measured and BPA Estimated Densities estimated values Samples measured values 1 79.00 80.20 70.83 2 71.33 63.95 3 64.40 80.93 4 79.10 63.74 5 63.70 In order to further improve the ability of generalization of the network, a more complex ANN network was developed. This network combined two companion networks using the Double Back-Propagation (DBP) algorithm which improves the network performance by forcing the output to be insensitive to incremental changes in the input. The improvement is quite significant. The mean estimation error of the network decreases by 30% compared with the network using the BPA[3]. 4. CONCLUSIONS The ANN is an artificial intelligent technique that has several distinct advantages over rulebased Expert System and Fuzzy Logic. The technique has been shown to be a feasible technique that estimates the material properties for the FGM design. The estimation accuracy is satisfactory.
68 5. ACKNOWLEDGMENT This work is supported by China National Natural Science Foundation, The Doctorial Program Fundation of State Education Commission, and National Committee of High Technology New Materials. REFERENCES 1. T.Hirano et al. Proceedings, The First International Symposium, FGM, Sendai, (1990) 5. 2. T.Hirano et al. International Workshop on Artificial Intelligence for Industrial Application, (1988)245. 3. Z.C.Mu et al. Pattern Recognition and Artificial Intelligence, Vol. 8, No. 1 (1995) 51. 4. H.Drucker and Y.L.Cun, IEEE Trans. Neural Networks, Vol. 3, No. 6 (1992) 991.
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
69
Deformation analysis of graded powder compacts during sintering K. Shinagawa Department of Mechanical Engineering, Anan College of Technology Minobayashi, Anan, Tokushima 774, Japan
A method for simulating the deformation behavior of graded powder compacts during sintering is proposed. A constitutive model for sintering of metal and ceramic powder mixtures is presented. The constitutive equation is applied to the viscoplastic finite element method. The shape change in graded powder plates during sintering is predicted. The effects of sintering properties of the powders and their combinations on warpage in the sintered plates are examined.
1. INTRODUCTION Powder metallurgy is one of the methods to produce functionally graded materials (FGM) with metals and ceramics. In general, shrinkage behavior of ceramics during sintering is different from that of metals. Difference in shrinkage rate often induces distortion or cracks in sintered bodies. Sintering process should be controlled to avoid such defects. Powders may be coordinated by selecting particle size or adding elements to get almost homogeneous shrinkage rate all over the layers in FGM powder compacts [1,2]. In another way, graded heating may be imposed to the powder compacts to adjust the sintering balance of the layers [3]. Conditions of the process, however, seem to be determined by trial and error. Thermal stress in FGM has been studied because it is important to avoid the fracture due to thermal shock. However, the defects in the powder compacts during sintering is caused by sintering stress, which arises from surface tension. Therefore, the structure of FGM made by sintering should be designed with both thermal stress and sintering stress taken into consideration. Analysis of the sintering process of FGM powder compacts has not been conducted. The author has proposed a constitutive equation for sintering of a single powder and applied it to the prediction of deformation behavior of powder compacts during sintering using the viscoplastic finite element method [4-6]. In this paper, a constitutive model for sintering of metal/ceramic mixed powder compacts is developed. The shrinkage behavior of metal and ceramic powder mixtures is expressed on the basis of the sintering behavior of each component powder and the mixing ratio. The constitutive equation is applied to the finite element method and the deformation behavior of cylindrical graded powder plates during sintering is simulated. The effects of the balance of sintering properties of two component powders and the size of powder compacts on the warpage in the graded powder plates are examined.
70 2. CONSTITUTIVE MODEL FOR GRADED POWDER COMPACTS 2.1. Constitutive equation for sintering Sintering can be described as the deformation process of viscous porous bodies under the action of the sintering stress, which is an apparent hydrostatic stress [4-6], Based this theory, the constitutive equation for sintering is given by = _1_ en = 2rj (1) hj=x,y,z 9/^ «=2.5, f=l/2.5fi7p, where rj is the viscosity, p the relative density, ^ , rr' are the strain rate and deviatoric stress, respectively, 6 is the Kronecker symbol, Om is the hydrostatic stress, as is the sintering stress. The sintering stress is evaluated from surface tension and pore geometry as follows;
^irl^'^^^^V^'^'^^H
as=p^-y, 1P(1-PO)I
(2)
'
N=6, A:=0.5, po=0.52,
where y is the surface tension,} is the effective pore radius, R is the radius of a powder particle, po is the initial relative density. If the mechanism of material transport in sintering is grain boundary diffusion, the viscosity can be expressed as a function of the temperature and the grain size. From a model for boundary diffusion controlled creep M2 1 proposed by Coble [7] and the temperature 70 C2 dependence of diffusion coefficients, we obtain 4U}
rj=ciT'exp(f\d\
where T is the temperature, d is the grain size and ci, C2 are constants. The grain growth during sintering is assumed to be given by d^=do^^C3t'exp(^],
I
/Ml 10 /
C/3
5
(4)
do=2R, where do is the initial grain size (= the diameter of powder particles ), t is the time (sec) and cs, CA are constants.
^Cl
15
(3)
n
j
/
j
-
C/ 1 i 600 800 1000 1200 1400 0.5 1.0 Temperature /°C Holding time /h Figure 1. Shrinkage curves.
2.2. Sintering behavior of metals and ceramics powder compacts Figure 1 shows shrinkage curves of metals Ml(Mo), M2(Mo with 0.1mass%Ni) and ceramics Cl(Zr02), C2(PSZ) calculated by Eqs. (1)'^(4), which are employed as components of FGM. The rate of heating up is 100°C/min. After the temperature reaches 1400 °C, the sintering is carried on at the same temperature for one hour. The material parameters used in Eqs. (1) ^^(4) are shown in Table 1. These component materials were referred to the research on molyb-
71 Table 1 Material constants. Metals
Ml
?;[Pa-s]
1.5628 x l O '
16415 d[m]
1.2794x10"'"
Ceramics
M2
7.3919x10'' 15426
CI
C2
5.4445x10'' 1.4454x10'' 47921
40043
1.2569x10"" 4.6148x10"' 2.5493x10"'
R[m]
-34804 1.0x10"^
-29041 1.0x10"^
-72213 0.025x10"^
-65313 0.025x10"^
)4mN/m]
1000
1000
1000
1000
denum / zirconia system by Watanabe et al. [1,2] and the parameters ci'-C4 were determined from their experimental data by the method of least squares. 2.3. Constitutive model for metal and ceramic powder mixtures Let us express the shrinkage behavior of powder mixtures MCI composed of Ml and CI, and MC2 composed of M2 and C2 by the shrinkage curve of each component shown in Figure 1. It is assumed that there is no reaction between the metals and the ceramics. The powder mixtures are described as two porous bodies mechanically engaging with each other. Using this assumption, the sintering stress of the mixtures may be given by Osmc=VmOsm-^VcOsc^
(5)
where Vmy Vc are the volume fractions of metal and ceramic, respectively (Km +Fc =1), Osmy Osc are the sintering stresses of metal and ceramic, respectively. When two kinds of particles with different diameters fill up a container, the bulk density may change with the ratio of mixture. Variation of the initial relative density with the volume fraction of ceramic is set as shown in Figure 2. The relative densities of metallic and ceramic parts of powder compacts are assumed to be given by p,=((1-a)Fc+a>-p , a=0.8, (6) where a is a parameter to express the reduction in relative density due to mixture. The viscosity of the mixtures is assumed to be evaluated by m=^mrjm-^Vcric, m
rjm rjc'
20 40 60 80 100 Volume fraction of ceramic /% Figure 2. Variation of initial relative density with ratio of mixture of metal and ceramic.
72
25 20 ^15
1400°C^
u
x^oo°c 1
I 10 c/5
5
1200°C
k
r O ^ — /\• _ 1 0
1
1
iioo°c[ &—-
0 -^ lOOO^C 1
1
1
20 40 60 80 100 20 40 60 80 100 Volume fraction of ceramic /% Volume fraction of ceramic /% (b) MC2 (a) MCI Figure 3. Variation of sintering behavior with ratio of mixture of metal and ceramic.
MCI: ^=1, MC2: y5=.0.0625+0.863 V^ The actual shrinkage behavior of the mixtures was also referred to the research of Watanabe et al. [1,2] and the initial relative densities in Figure 2 and the parameters a, fi were determined from their experimental data. Figure 3 shows shrinkage behavior of powder mixtures calculated by Eqs. (1)'^(7) with the heating rate of 100°C/min. The sintering balance of MC2 is better than that of MCI. The shrinkage does not follow the law of mixture, that is, the minimum shrinkage is obtained at the low volume fraction of ceramic [1,2]. This is considered to be because of the increase in the average radius of pores due to mixture. This phenomenon was expressed as the reduction in relative density in Eq. (6) in the present work. 3. FINITE ELEMENT ANALYSIS OF SINTERING PROCESS 3.1. Theory The finite element method with the sintering stress taken into account has been formulated [4,6]. In this case, the equilibrium equation is given by dXi
dXi
'
hj=x,y,z
(8)
where Sij is the sintering stress. From the principle of virtual work, the nodal forces for each element are given by
{P)=\[BY{o)dV^\
[B7{S)dV
(9)
73
Figure 4. Model of graded cylindrical powder compacts.
{a} = {ajc Oy Oz x^y Tyz T^Y where [B] is the matrix correlating the strain-rate components with the nodal velocity components. The stresses are given by (10) {a) = [D]{e) = [D][B]{u) s] = { ex
£y £z Yxy Yyz Yzx]
[D] = 3r/mao2''-l 0 0 0 0
0 0 0 c 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 c 0 0c
2c = i 9' 3 where {u} is the nodal velocity. Substituting Eq. (10) into Eq. (9) gives
a=f^^,b=f-
•.j[BnD][B]dV[u]^j[ {P]=\[BnD][B]dV{u]^\[BY{S)dV
(11)
Adding together the nodal forces of the surrounding elements at each nodal point gives simultaneous linear equations. The nodal velocities are obtained as solutions of these equations. 3.2. Sintering simulation Deformation of two types of graded cylindrical powder compacts having different diameters as shown in Figure 4 were analyzed in the same sintering conditions as Figure 1 (section 2.2). Figure 5 shows calculated distorted grid patterns of the sintered cylinders with the small diameter. The shape of MCI is not strait because the shrinkage of metal Ml is much smaller than that of ceramic CI. The middle of cylinder MC2 with the small diameter is slightly swelled because the initial density of this part is high and the shrinkage is small. However, a sound shape may be obtained in MC2 due to the good sintering balance of the component layers.
74 Figure 6 shows calculated shapes of the sintered cylinders with the large diameter. MCI, having an inferior sintering balance, is considerably warped because a difference in shrinkage exerts more significant influence on a large size. Even MC2 suffers from some warpage. During the process of MCI heating up, the cylindrical plate MC2 is warped once and deformed again in the opposite direction. This may produce a defect within the sintered body. These results suggest that the MC2 size effect should be taken into consideration for suitable design of FGM. 900X
1200X
ISOO'C
1400*C
4. CONCLUSIONS A constitutive equation to simulate the deformation of the graded powder compacts during sintering was proposed. The sintering stress of each layer in the powder compacts was evaluated from powder properties. The constitutive equation with the sintering stress was applied to the prediction of the deformation behavior of graded powder plates. Warpage in the plate during sintering was predicted by the viscoplastic finite element method.
UOOV (Ih)
Figure 5. Distorted grid pattern in cross section of cylindrical FGM with small diameter.
izoo'C 1300X:
MCI
MC2
Figure 6. Warpage in cylindrical FGM with large diameter.
REFERENCES 1. R. Watanabe, A. Kawasaki and N. Murahashi, J. Asso. Mater. Eng. Resour., (in Japanese), 1 (1988) 36. 2. R. Watanabe, Micromeritics, (in Japanese), 33 (1989) 76. 3. M. Yuki, M. Toshikazu, I. Toshio, A. Kawasaki, R. Wtanabe, J. Jpn. Soc. Powder Metall., (in Japanese), 37-7 (1990) 929. 4. K. Shinagawa, Trans. Jpn. Soc. Mech. Eng., A, (in Japanese), 62-539 (1996) 240, 246. 5. K. Shinagawa, JSME Int. J., A, 39-4 (1996) 565. 6. K. Shinagawa, Proc. 3rd Asia-Pacific Symp., AEPA'96, (1996) 439. 7. R. L. Coble, J. Appl. Phys., 34-6 (1963) 1679.
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
75
Simulation of the Elasto-Plastic Deformations in Compositionally Graded Metal-Ceramic Structures: Mean-Field and Unit Cell Approaches* H.E. Pettermann^, E. Weissenbek"^ and S. Suresh^ ^Institute of Light Weight Structures and Aerospace Engineering, Vienna University of Technology, Austria, Gusshausstr. 27-29/E317, A-1040 Vienna, Austria ^Department of Materials Science and Engineering, MIT, 77 Massachusetts Avenue, Cambridge, MA USA 02139-4307 1. I N T R O D U C T I O N The elasto-plastic behavior of a compositionally graded metal-ceramic structure is investigated. The deformation under uniaxial loading is predicted using both an incremental Mori-Tanaka method and periodic as well as random microstructure extended unit cell approaches. The latter are able to give an accurate description of the local microfields within the phases. Furthermore, the random microstructure unit cell model can represent the interwoven structure at volume fractions close to 50%. Due to the high computational costs, such unit cell analyses are restricted to two-dimensional considerations. Computationally less demanding mean-field methods provide a tool to account for the out-of-plane constraints, but have the disadvantage of using phase averaged stress and stain fields. In the present work, an incremental Mori-Tanaka approach is employed, which is implemented as a constitutive material law in a finite element code. Both twodimensional and three-dimensional investigations are performed and the results are compared to the predictions of the extended unit cell approaches. 2. M O D E L I N G OF T H E F G M - S T R U C T U R E The investigated structure (cf. fig. 1) consists of a pure nickel top layer (1.2mm thick), an FGM zone with a linear variation of the volume fraction (2.2mm thick), and a pure alumina bottom layer (0.45mm thick). Material data of the constituents are given in table 1, where Eh denotes the strain hardening modulus. The boundary conditions force all cross sections perpendicular to the monolithic/FGM interfaces to remain plane, i.e. the lefthand and the righthand side (as well as the viewing plane for three-dimensional considerations). The uniaxial load (which causes extension and bending for the present *This work was supported by the Grant DE-FG02-93ER45506to MIT from the US Department of Energy. The post-doctoral study of EW at MIT was supported by an Erwin Schrodinger Fellowship from the AUSTRIAN NATIONAL SCIENCE FOUNDATION. HP'S visit to MIT was supported by a scholarship for
Overseas Scientific Study from the AUSTRIAN FEDERAL MINISTRY OF SCIENCE, TRANSPORT AND ART. ^present address: BMW Entwicklungszentrum Steyr, Hinterbergerstr. 2, A-4400 Steyr, Austria
76 Table 1 Material data for alumina '* and nickel ^ [GPa] 380 0.25
[GPa] [MPa] 214 0.31 148
[MPa] 668
case) is applied centered at and perpendicular to the left- and righthand side, respectively. All calculations are performed with the finite element code ABAQUS [1]. 2.1. Extended Unit Cell Models Periodic Packing In the field of metal matrix composites a number of models are used to characterize both, macroscopic behavior as well as local microfields. The present section deals with plane models, the three packing cases shown in [2] are used as the basis to extend the unit cell method for graded structures with hexagonal packing, square edge packing^ and square diagonal packing [3]. Nine subcells with different volume fractions (corresponding to linear grading) are combined to represent the graded part (fig. 1, left and middle). Due to the fact that these models can only represent a pure matrix/inclusion structure, a switch from nickel-matrix to alumina-matrix is necessary. To investigate the particular influence of the eflfective matrix phase for the center sublayer two diflFerent cases are considered, viz. the 50% layer shows a nickel-matrix (marked as Ni) or an alumina-matrix (marked as A1203). Random Micro structures Usually the microstructure of an FGM does not show a matrix/inclusion type topology throughout the thickness. Typically, in the range between 30 and 70 % volume fraction an interwoven type microstructure exists. To account for this, a further two-dimensional plane stress approach is used where the grading within the FGM layer is divided into 11 sublayers each having a fixed volume fraction. In each row the proper number of hexagonal "grains" are assigned to the nickel and alumina phases, according to the volume fraction. The locations with the pertinent row are chosen randomly (fig. 1, right). The bottom and top layers, consisting of pure nickel and alumina, respectively, show the same finite element mesh topology, viz. each grain comprises six triangular elements. Eight diflFerent randomly generated microstructures are studied. 2.2. Incremental Mori-Tanaka Method (IMT) As a complementary approach a mean-field method is used in combination with the finite element method to investigate the FGM. To compare the predictions with the periodic unit cell simulations, the FGM part is divided into nine sublayers. Each of them consists of two bi-quadratic 8-node plane elements over the thickness, and only one element is used in the horizontal direction. The parts of pure alumina and pure nickel are modeled by three and 12 elements, respectively. In each sublayer the volume fractions of the phases are constant. In addition, the center sublayer can be split into a metalmatrix and a ceramic-matrix half sublayer. The properties of the particular material on the meso-structural level within the finite element calculation are described via a con-
77
Figure 1. Extended unit cell finite element models; hexagonal arrangement and detail of center subcell (left); square edge arrangement and detail of center subcell (middle); random arrangement (right)
stitutive material law. This is an incremental Mori-Tanaka approach [4] (representing an matrix/inclusion topology) which is based on Eshelby's equivalent inclusion method. Herein, the Eshelby tensor is a function of the inclusion aspect ratio and the (instantaneous) material properties of the matrix phase. For a general behavior of the matrix material (i.e. elasto-plasticity or anisotropic elasticity) the Eshelby tensor is calculated numerically, based on an implementation developed by Gavazzi/Lagoudas [5]. The IMT method is implemented as a "user supplied material routine" [4] for the finite element package ABAQUS [1]. The mesoscopic, instantaneous material data of the microscopically heterogeneous materials are calculated individually for each integration point at each increment within the finite element analysis. In contrast to the extended unit cell models, the IMT-method does not provide detailed information about the micro-fields. The computational requirements, however, are much lower. Furthermore, this method can be employed to predict the complete deformation of a three-dimensional graded layer and to perform structural analyses for components made from composite materials. Within the present method a pure matrix/inclusion type micro-topology is assumed (no interwoven structure can be represented). Hence, a sudden change of the properties occurs, when the matrix material changes from alumina to nickel. The IMT-method as implemented performs a fully three-dimensional analysis on the micro level independently of the global finite element analysis option.
78
IQ
0)
U
CQ
•H
H
IMT reduced constr. (Ni) IMT reduced constr. (A1203) Square-diagonal (Ni) Square-diagonal (A1203) Square-edge (Ni) Square-edge (A1203) Hexagonal (Ni) Hexagonal (A1203) 2.0
Axial Strain (%)
Figure 2. Predicted axial strain response for the extended unit cell models and the corresponding incremental Mori-Tanaka approach (IMT); the matrix of the center sublayer being nickel (Ni) or alumina (A1203)
3. RESULTS The deformation is given in terms of axial strain and bending strain which are the mean value of the strains in loading direction and in proportion to the curvature of the layered structure, respectively. The global behavior of the periodic packing models with respect to the axial strain is displayed in fig 2, considering both an alumina and a nickel center sublayer. (The responses with respect to the bending strains are equivalent.) The square diagonal packing and the hexagonal packing show similar response, but the square edge packing model is stiffer. The results coincide with the findings in [2,6,7] for equivalent periodic packing arrangements. The overall stress vs. axial and bending strain prediction of the random microstructure models are displayed in fig 3. A slight variation for different randomly generated models can be observed; the global behavior, however, does not deviate markedly. Compared to the periodic unit cell approach the random microstructure models show a more compliant behavior. Mainly responsible for the overall stiffness of the FGM is the portion of interconnected alumina matrix. The periodic unit cell results are directly comparable to the IMT predictions, because both approaches represent the same matrix/inclusion type microstructure. However, such comparisons have to be done carefully since some assumptions regarding the finite element calculations are not equivalent for the extended unit cell approaches and the present mean-field method. The plane stress analysis of the unit cell models does not take into account the constraints in the out-of-plane direction. In contrast, within the present IMT formulation the inclusions are enclosed three-dimensionally by the matrix material. In contrast to the plane stress unit cell models, the constraint in the out-of-plane direction is accounted for. Accordingly, these predictions are denoted as full internal constraint. To overcome this internal constraint in order to "simulate" the plane stress model assump-
79 J
1
1
1
1
_i
1
1
L
(0
0) 0)
4.)
a^
"^St^^
•H
X
(d •d 0)
•H
n
0.0
^
1
4.0
,
1
8.0
^
Arrangement Arrangement Arrangement Arrangement Arrangement Arrangement Arrangement Arrangement 1 ' 12.0
8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 r
16.0
Axial/Bending strain (%)
Figure 3. Predicted axial (stiffer) and bending (more compliant) strain response for eight different random microstructure models tions, the inclusions are introduced as infinite fibers in out-of-plane direction and the elastic material parameters of the ceramic phase in out-of-plane direction are reduced by several orders of magnitude. Such models are denoted as internally reduced constraint. A center layer with alumina matrix and nickel matrix, respectively, is modeled. It is well known that incremental mean-field methods show a tendency to over-predict the hardening behavior, but the general features are captured in a qualitative as well as quantitative way (cf. fig. 2). Additional calculations are performed where the center sublayer is subdivided. These results and the stress-strain behavior of a global plane stress and full internal constraint analysis (considering spherical inclusions and unmodified material data throughout) are displayed in fig. 4. A marked stiffening as the result of the full constraining on the micro level can be observed. Furthermore, the predictions of a generalized plane strain analysis are shown. This way, mesoscopic interaction between the sublayers is accounted for and a second set of strains can be calculated, describing the axial strain in the out-of-plane direction and the out-of-plane rotation (see fig. 4). These results show that a plate under the assumed loading is deforming to a saddle shape. 4. CONCLUSIONS The deformation behavior of a compositionally graded metal-ceramic structure has been investigated by numerical and (semi)analytical simulations. Random microstructure models are able to predict the response of an FGM-structure in a more accurate way than the other approaches. The interwoven structure in the "middle" of the FGM can be accounted for using this modeling strategy. For the extended periodic unit cell models the predicted stress strain response depends strongly on the micro-arrangement of the inclusions. Detailed information on the microfields of the stresses and strains can only be obtained by the extended unit cell models. The incremental Mori-Tanaka method
80 1
,
I
i
.
I
.
I
0)
u
GPE GPE GPE GPE PST PST PST PST
'
Id 0) •H H
& 1
'
1 -0.5
1 0.5
b e n d i n g / o u t of p l a n e a x i a l / o u t of p l a n e bending/in plane axial/in plane full c o n s t r . red.constr. r e d . c o n s t r . (Ni) r e d . c o n s t r . (A1203)
|
'
1
1 1.5
•
Axial/Bending strain (%)
Figure 4. Predicted axial strain response for plane stress (PST) calculations with internally full and reduced constraint and predicted axial and bending strain response for interally fully constraint generalized plane strain (GPE) calculations by the incremental Mori-Tanaka approach
shows a tendency to over-predict the hardening behavior, but, it is numerically less intensive. In addition, the three-dimensional interaction between matrix and inclusions can be considered, and it can be employed to predict the complete deformation of an FGM-structure. Acknowledgments The authors thank Drs. H. J. Bohm, M. Finot, A.E. Giannakopoulos, A. Needleman and F. G. Rammerstorfer for many helpful discussions during the course of this work. REFERENCES ABAQUS User's Manual; HKS Inc., Pawtucket, RI (1994). T. Nakamura, S. Suresh.: Acta metall.mater. 41, 1665 (1993). E. Weissenbek, H.E. Pettermann, S. Suresh: submitted to Acta.mater. H.E. Pettermann, H.J. Bohm, F.G. Rammerstorfer: In "Proceedings of the General Workshop in Materials Science and Engineering", 1996, Ed: M. Rappaz, European Commission, in press. A.C. Gavazzi, D.C. Lagoudas: Comput.Mech. 7, 13 (1990). E. Weissenbek., H.J. Bohm, F.G. Rammerstorfer: Comp.Mat.Sci. 3, 263 (1994). E. Weissenbek: VDI Fortschrittsberichte (Reihe 18, Nr. 164), VDI Verlag, Diisseldorf, Germany (1994).
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
81
Large Deflections of Heated Functionally Graded Clamped Rectangular Plates with Varying Rigidity in Thickness Direction F. Mizuguchi^^ and H. Ohnabe**^ ^Dept. of Mechanical Engineering, Japan Maritime Safety Academy, 5-1, Wakaba-cho, Kureshi, Hiroshima-ken,737 Japan. ^CompositeNfeterials Center, AeiD-Engine & SpaceOperations, Jshikawajima-Haiirna Heavy Inciustries Co., lid, 3-5-1, Mukodai-cho, Tanashi-shi, Tokyo, 188 Japan. The governing equations for the large deflection of heated functionally graded elastic, rectangular^plates with varying Young's modulus in thickness direction are derived by Berger and K i m ^ approach. We assume that the functionally graded Young's modulus varies symmetrically with respect to the middle plane according to the nth power of the nondimensional thickness. For a clamped rectangular plate affected by an arbitrary symmetrical temperature and load distribution about midpoint of the plate and prevented from inplane motions on the boundary, the governing equations are solved by means of the Galerkin method. As a numerical example, the cases as seen in aerodynamic heating are analyzed. The influence of functionally graded Young's modulus and temperature change on the large deflection are shown in the graphs. 1. INTRODUCTION Recently, the functionally graded materials (FGM) of the thermal relaxation type, adaptable to a super-high-temperature environment like a super and hyper sonic transportation and a space plane, have received considerable attention. An approximate method for investigating the large deflections of isotropic plates has been proposed by Berger [1] in 1955. Since then much research has been conducted on large deflections by Nowinski [2] in 1962 and on thermal buckling by Kamiya [3] inl976. Nowinski and Ohnabe [4] in 1972 pointed out that the relative exactness of the Berger method is closely associated with the restriction imposed on the in-plane displacement of the boundary conditions. The mathematical justification for this statement has been given by Schmidt [5] in 1974 using a proper perturbation method. Recently Horibe [6] in 1990 proposed a new iterative solution of the Berger equation. The solution is derived by utilizing both the idea of the Kantrovich method and the boundary integral equation method. Following Berger, Ohnabe and Mizuguchi [7,8] derived the governing equations for the large deflection and the non-linear vibration of heated non-homogeneous circular plates with radially varying rigidity. They were solved for the clamped boundary condition by using the Galerkin method. The governing equations for large deflections of heated functionally graded elastic, rectangular clamped plates with varying Young's modulus in thickness direction were also derived by Berger and Karman approaches. Assuming the functionally graded Young's modulus in thickness direction symmetrical with respect to the middle plane, for a rectangular simply supported plate due to a temperature distribution as seen in aerodynamic heating, they are solved by employing the Poincarc method [9]. In the present study, appling the same procedure, for a case of a rectangular clamped plates, they are solved by employing the Galerkin method. The influence of functionally graded Young's modulus and temperature change on the large deflection are shown in the graphs. The solutions for Berger and Karman approaches are compared.
82
2. GOVERNING EQUATIONS We consider a functionally graded, elastic, heated rectangular plate, with a lateral load q. Let the deformation be axisymmetric with respect to the center .We assume that the functionally graded Young' s modulus varies symmetrically with respect to the middle plane according to the nth power of and is given by According to Berger, eliminating the second strain invariant and applying the Euler-Lagrange variational principle for minimum potential energy, the Euler-Lagrange differential equations become the following governing equations for large deflection of heated functionally graded elastic, rectangular plates with varying Young's modulus in thickness direction [9] B V^ (V^w) + a( 1 + V ) i | (V^nu, + pV^m ') - K^v\ h^
- -5L ^0
(2) (3)
where fh/2 thil B = l + - ^ ^T-, , n u ,- - |I Tzdz,PT,= Tdz nu, Tzdz , PT = I| n.-3 ^ |_^2 T j_^^
1+-^, n+1 h/2 tV2
rh/2 tY\l2
1
h/2 equations with large ^^W.h/2 The von Karman-type deflection can also be12(1derived from the equations of equilibrium and compatibility referring to[9]
^ V ^ ^ ^ r ^ (^^"h-+P^^"^T')=^^'p) ^ ^ V"^ + aEQ ( v \ + PV^P^') = - 1 AEQh^w, w)
(4)
(5) ^^^
where the operator L applied to the functions w, F is 3x2 3y2 "^ ay2 9x2 ' ax9y dxdy
^^^
3. EXAMPLES OF SOLUTION OF GOVERNING EQUATIONS The approximate expression for w is selected directly from the linear theory of plates with small deflections, and is given by w(x, y) - f sin^ axsin^ Py /gx where f is the maximum deflection and ^
a,
*^ b
Boundary conditions for a plate clamped on all edges are, at X - 0, a
at y - 0, b
(9)
83
w
3w
^ 0
w
3w
^ 0
ax ay (10) The temperature distribution over the plate is assumed to be symmetrical with respect to the center of the plate and is given as oo oo
I
Px = h i: E Tij COS iax cos jpy ijieven Pj = h S E Tij cos iax cos jPy ijreven and the load is also given as
oo oo
I
m j - h^ | S Z Tpq sin pax sin qPy + Tg (p,q:odd ) m j ' = h^ ! S S Tpq sin pax sin qPy .+.T^ ;! \p,q:odd (11)
q = X S qij sin iax sin jPy ijiodd Substituting Eqs. (8) and (11) into Eq. (3) and integrating with respect to x and y, K^ is obtained _
(12)
Obtaining a general and a particular solution of Eq. (2) and using the boundary conditions of Eq. (10), we then determine the integral constants. Wefinallyobtain the following expression for maximum deflection
_2_ 128
T^C ^?K^!^I*^(^* J ^ t ^ C *^)Kf^lT(».*Poo)|;p,q:odd
p2 + >.V .= 64 £ % X2pq(p2 - 4)(q2 - 4) ^^-^j^J''^ ' "^^^ ' "^^ (14) ^=^
where
h, (15) We consider the case where the temperature distribution on the xy-plane of the plate takes a parabolic form and the temperature distribution through the thickness is linear and the temperature on the lower face is one-half on the upper face , that is, the temperature distribution is expressed as follows: T(x,y,z|)= T „ + T , (0 1L
•(vfi'-i^*" ^ a ' J L V b / JiM'^si ' 3h'
(16)
Then if a lateral load is uniform, q(x,y) - QQ , the above equation (14) becomes
128l-v2l »15
j,2| '^ j i2(i.v2)(^4\2'^'| 4 ( l - v ) P 5 ^ 2 H T , ^ 9 l U " ' • | ' '
-E_ Hfn2.4¥n2-4rh' '"'^'"^.;;idd^'(p^)^(p^-4X'^^-4)
_SQ_ - l (y)^i2-4)(j2-4) 7l4 . l l.i ij:odd
(17)
84 where Qo* - qob''/(Eoh'') stands for non-dimensional loading. In case of Karman, Eq. (14) becomes the following
^dJ 9 i + 2vx.^ + x'^ I 1 / n i + x"^, 4 , 1 I 1 (Ir^i ^128(l-v2) ^4 3 2 | 8 ^4 (^^^2)2 (^^^^^2)2 (4,;,2)2|J^
• { 4(T02 + PT'02) - (TO4 + pTo4)| + HTIO + PT'20) -(T40 + pT'4o)ll + ^ ^ / ^ ^0?^ " J 2(1+X2)
IX'
i |(T24+PT'24) ^ (T42 + PT'42)|
^-(ftlh)"^ 6
(Tpq-PTpq)
p,q:odd = 64 Ji2 U
i,j:odd
p2 + x V 5^ pq(p2-4Kq2-4)
'lij ij(i2-4)(j2-4)
(18) In case of /?= 0, this equation becomes the same equation as Eq. 26 of [10] and for aerodynamic heating with a uniform load, q(x,y) = qo, it becomes as follows 128(l-v2)
,4
12(l-v2)l;^4
^2
& JtMl+x2 = 21^ Z ^^I'l
i,j:odd
32|8
,4
(^^^2)2
(^^^^2)2
(^^^2)2|
U s 2 (l+J^)(Io^.l| + ^ | l + X U [4{l-v)(
5^2)17,
(t)25-TAr2ll^ L_._i 1 + 4)L2 4 + X^,
9l 4;t2| ^2J Z
P2.M2
(h)2^T,
* (iJ)^i2-4)(j2-4)
where qo* = qobVCEgh^) stands for non-dimensional loading.
(19)
4. NUMERICAL CALCULATIONS AND DISCUSSION OF RESULTS First we present the comparison with the solutions of the Berger and Karman equations for large deflections due to the temperature distribution through the thickness by means of the same Galerkin method in Fig. 1. The results by the Berger equation are thick lines and the solutions by the Karman equation are shown as thin lines. The solid lines are for the homogeneous elastic plate (/9 - 0) and the dashed lines are for the functionally graded plate (/9 - 1, n-2). It shows the relation between the maximum deflection(f ) and the temperature difference ((b/hfaT^) with TQ/TJ as the parameter and without a lateral load for a rectangular
85 clamped plate. The deflection due to heating according to the Berger method is lower than the Karman method. Nevertheless the two methods do show the good agreement over a wide range of temperature difference. When a temperature distribution as seen in aerodynamic heating which causes the deformation , f =0.7, at a plate with uniform elastic modulus (/? -0), is applied to the graded plate ( ^ = 1 , n=2), the amount of deformation can be reduced by 26% at To/Ti=0, 36% at 0.5, 40% at 1.0 and 49% at 2.0 in case of Berger approach. Figure 2 represents the maximum deformation due to uniform external loading QQ* using Berger and Karman. It may be seen that the deformation of the plate with the graded ekstic modulus in thickness direction is smaller by 20 % at (b/h)'aT^ = 0 and 15 % at (b/h)^aTi = 2.0 for QQ* =200 than the ones with a constant elastic modulus in case of Berger. It is observed from these figures that the graded elastic modulus can decrease the deformation of the plate.
5. CONCLUSION Assuming the Young's modulus and the temperature distribution through the thickness, the governing equations by Berger and Karman with the boundary condition of the edges clamped were solved by employing the Galerkin method. ^ A comparison with ^ e numerical results by the Karman -type non-linear governing equations showed sufficient agreement to verify the much simpler Berger approach. The graded elastic modulus can control the deformation of the plate. ACKNOWLEDGMENT The authors are deeply indebted to Dr. J. L. Nowinski, H. Fletcher Brown Distinguished Professor Emeritus, Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Delaware for his helpful suggestions.
REFERENCES 1. H. M. Berger,. "A new approach to the analysis of large deflections of plates," J. Appl. Mech. 22 (1965) 465. 2. J. L. Nowinski, "Note on an Analysis of Large deflections of Rectagular Plates," Appl. Sci. Res., Sec. A, Vol. 11(1962)85. 3. N. Kamiya, "Large Thermal Bending and Thermal Buckling," ACTA TECHNICA CSAV, 1(1982)33. 4. J. L. Nowinski, and H. Ohnabe, "On certain inconsistencies in Berger equations for large deflections of elastic plates," Int. J. Mech. Sci. 14 (1972) 165-170. 5. Schmidt, R. 1974. "On Berger's method in the nonlinear theory of plates," J. Appl. Mech. 14:521. 6. T. Horibe, "Boundary Strip Method for Large Deflection Analysis of Elastic Rectangular Plates," Transaction of the Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers, 56(532) (1990) 140 (Japanese). 7. H. Ohnabe and F. Mizuguchi, "Large deflections of heated non- homogeneous circular plates with radicaUy varying rigidity," Int. J. Non-Linear Mechanics, 28, (4) (1993) 365. 8. H. Ohnabe and F. Mizuguchi, "Non-Linear Vibrations of Heated Non-Homogeneous Elastic Circular Plates with Radially Varying Rigidity," Proc. American Soc. Composites, 9th Technical Conference, (1994) 1147.
86 9. F. Mizuguchi and H. Ohnabe, "Large Deflections of Heated Functionally Graded Simply Supported Rectagular Plates with Varying Rigidity in Thickness Direction/* Proc. American Soc. Composites, 11th Technical Conference (1996) 957. 10. M. Sunakawa, ^Thermal Deformation of Clamped Rectangular Plate Subjected to Aerodynamic Heating," Transaaion of the Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers, Vol, 9, No. 85, (1961) 37 (Japanese).
A = 0, »/»0.3.qQ*-0 I
.
I
I
.
.
L
1 Fig. 1 Relation between maximum deflection( f ) and temperature difference ((b/h)^aTj) with TQ/TI ' '
\j,
Berger ^«0 - —-^/?-l,n-2 Karman /?.l.n-2
A=1,
y=0.3,
T/T=1 0
i—•—I—I—I—I—I
100
200
I
1
L
300
400
500
Fig.2 Maximum deformation due to uniform external loading QQ*
600
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
87
Model investigation of ceramic-metal FGMs under dynamic thermal loading: Residual stress effect, thermal-mechanical coupling effect and materials hardening model effect Qing-Jie Zhang, Peng-Cheng Zhai and Run-Zhang Yuan State Key Laboratory of Materials Synthesis and Processing Wuhan University of Technology, Wuhan 430070, P.R.China
ABSTRACT The analysis model for the response of ceramic-metal FGMs under dynamic thermal loading is investigated. Emphasis is put on the effects of the residual stress, thermalmechanical coupling and hardening model for the materials. It is shown that the three effects are significant when the materials' response is inelastic and should carefully be considered in constructing the analysis model.
l.THE STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM The key issue in developing ceramic/metal FGMs is to identify an optimum compositional gradation or micro structure according to the response to service loads or environments. Since different responses may lead to different conceptions of the optimum design, it is important to establish a correct model for the response analysis. There have been some studies on the service stress and optimum design of FGMs under some service environments, but a detailed investigation of the analysis model is lacking. The present paper focuses on the model investigation of the service stress of the materials under dynamic thermal loading. The loading history considered is indicated in figure 1 which simulates a wide range of service environments. In figure 1, the thermal loading history consists of two phases: phase I corresponds to the cooling phase after sintering and this phase is steady one; phase II corresponds to the service phase and this phase is dynamic one, either thermal shock process or thermal fatigue process. Phase II is illustrated in more detail in figure 2. The model investigation involves three important effects: • the residual stress effect. The residual stress is produced in phase I and may exert a significant effect on the service stress in phase II. This should be considered in a correct way. • the thermal-mechanical coupling effect. The thermal-mechanical coupling results from phase II and is an important phenomenon for the dynamic thermal loading process. This effect depends on the thermal loading rate and the plastic deformation of the material.
88 • the material hardening model effect. For ceramic-metal FGM, there are two hardening models which can be used to describe the plastic deformation: one is the kinematic hardening model and the other is the isotropic hardening model. Under dynamic loading circumstances, the effect of the two hardening models becomes important since they may predict very different responses of the materials. 2.MODEL DESCRIPTION FOR THE THREE EFFECTS 2.1.The residual stress effect There are two methods that can be used to treat the residual stress effect: one is so-called separate analysis model and the other is an unified analysis model. The two methods can be explained in a simple way as follows: separate analysis model: the resultant stress = the residual stress in phase I only + the service stress in phase II only; unified analysis model: the resultant stress = the stress obtained through an unified analysis for phase I and phase II (namely the two phases are treated as one unified loading process). 2.2. The thermal-mechanical coupling effect The thermal-mechanical coupling model for suddenly-heated ceramic-metal FGMs has been developed by the present authors in Ref [1]. To consider the plastic deformation effect on the heat conduction in the materials, the coupled heated conduction equation in Ref [1] is now modified as: ^
^
JT
JT
d
- (A(z) —) - Q (z) - - -f 3/:, (z)a(z)r[3a(z) — + -
G (TTTTT)]
d
" ^:^
G
G
(TT
- -)
The signals in the above equation have been defined in Ref [1]. If the coupling terms(the second and third terms on the right hand side) in the above equation are abandoned, the coupled heat conduction equation is reduced to the common uncoupled heat conduction equation. The motion equation of the model remain the same as those in Ref [1]. 2.3.The materials hardening model effect The stress-strain relationship for FGMs is assumed to be a bilinear form and can be described by the isotropic hardening model and kinematic hardening model as: \G\- G + Hs for the isotropic hardening model J{G- HS^ ) - cr^, = 0 for the kinematic hardening model where H = EE^/(E - E^)\ errand s^ are the yield stress and effective plastic strain of the materials, respectively; E and E^ are the elastic modulus and the elastic-plastic modulus.
89 3.RESULTS AND DISCUSSION A TiC/Ni FGM is used as an example. The graded layers in the FGM are treated as homogeneous with effective properties. The properties, geometrical sizes and the compositional distribution function in the graded layers were given in Ref.[l]. The dynamic thermal load in the service phase is taken as q = 4 MW/m^ and t^ = Is for the residual stress effect analysis and the hardening model effect analysis, and as q = 6 MWlm^ and t^ = 0.5s for the thermal-mechanical coupling effect analysis, where q is the magnitude of the heat flux and IQ is the duration of one thermal cycle. The sintering temperature in phase I is taken as 1300A^. The compositional distribution exponent is taken SLS P = 1.6. The residual stress effect is considered by the separate analysis model and unified analysis model, and the results are shown in figures 3(a) and (b). Figure 3(a) corresponds to the elastic analysis and it is seen that the separate analysis model and unified analysis model give the same resultant stress; Figure 3(b) corresponds to the elastic-plastic analysis and it is seen that the resultant stresses found from the two models are different. This is because in the elastic analysis the two responses in phase I and phase II are both linear and the resultant response can be obtained from a direct superposition of the two separate ones. In the elastic-plastic analysis, however, the two separate responses are both nonlinear and the separate analysis model based on the direct superposition of the two separate responses is no longer suitable. The thermal-mechanical coupling effect is shown in figure 4. The difference between the coupling model and uncoupling model for the presented thermal loading is about 7%. Different thermal loadings have also been examined and the results indicate that the difference between the two models increases when the loading rate and plastic deformation increase. The material hardening model effect is demonstrated in figure 5. From figure 5, the kinematic hardening model and isotropic hardening model produce the same material response in first thermal cycle and different ones in the subsequent cycles. The first difference between the two responses after the first cycle is the compressive history at the ceramic surface: the compressive history predicted by the isotropic hardening model is longer than that predicted by the kinematic one. The second difference between the two responses is the maximum tensile stress at the ceramic surface: it is nearly the same in every thermal cycles for the isotropic hardening model, and it changes and increases in the subsequent cycles for the kinematic hardening model. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This work was supported by the National Science Foundation of China REFERENCES 1. Q.J.Zhang, G.H.Zhang and R.Z.Zhang, Proc. 3rd Int. Symp. on FGMs, 1994, 235-240
90 T(K)
time phase I
phase n
Figure 1: Thermal loading history of ceramic-metal FGMs phase I: cooling phase after sintering phase II: service phase
heat flux ,
1
X
ceramic graded layers
1
metal liquid cooling
tmie
Figure 2: Dynamic thermal loading simulating the service phase in figure 1
91 o
time (s)
^
o o (N
O
S o
-K3- unified analysis model —i^ separate analysis model
o o
a: elastic case o o
o o cd
T3
o a o (N B
I
o B o
• unified analysis model • separate analysis model
o o
b: elastic-plastic case Figure 3: processing-service stress obtained from the unified analysis model and separate analysis model
92
_ 1
a
uncoupled theory coupled theory
O rsi in
PLH
s rn C/1 d)
o 0^
^ ^
h
0
0.5
1
1.5
time t(s) Figure 4 : Effect of the thermal-mechanical coupling model
o o o
- isotropic hardening model • kinematic hardening model
o o o
Figure 5 : Effect of the materials hardening model
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
93
Fractal geometry and it's implications to surface technology D.P.Bhatf, O.P. Bahl^ R. Schumacher^ and H. Meyer^ ^Carbon Technology Unit, National Physical Laboratory, New Delhi 110 012, India ^Atotech Deutschland GmbH, Erasmusstrasse 20-24, 10553 Berlin, Germany The basic know-how is presented to simulate impedance diagrams of complex equivalent circuits by viewing the electrode surface through fractal patterns. The implications of this model for electrochemical surface technology are also reported in this paper. 1. INTRODUCTION In the recent years fractal geometry has made considerable advances in the surface problems of many scientific disciplines^'^. Fractals (a word coined by Mandelbrot in the seventies) which mean basically for either irregularity orfragmentation,are more than the topographical dimensions, or these are the geometrical objects of non-integer dimensions which always exhibit the rule of self-appearance characteristics in contrary to the conventional elements of Euclidean-geometry. One of the first steps of the development of systematic fractal geometry, including its computer graphic aspects have blossomed tremendously on the basis of a simple system of Z = x^+C in order to subsequently demonstrate how one could calculate Mandelbrot set^'"^ in a particular plane of Cp,q. Assemblance of ZiZ2,Z3 Zn, under varying conditions of the square of the hypotenuse of the p,q plane while put together in the plane by applying the simulation principles, could generate two categories of points viz. White and black, leading to the formation of the strange figure, nick-named as apple tree owing to its appearance (Fig.l). Any fiirther modelling of Cp,q points in different shorter ranges from the Fig. 1 could give rise to ensemble offinerdiagrams^
A
B
n^T;r-A>Q.
. ^ ^
3^
^-^
Brtjcr^tZt^
(a) Figure!.
(b) "^'^Ure
2.
94 Traditional electrochemical concepts of the interface usually proceed by assuming an ideal smooth electrode surface ( e.g. Mercury). In other words, the ideal homogeneous electrode surface plane is often the worst assumption on the part of the electrochemist to prepare their interfacial experiments. Decisive factors associated with irregular heterogeneous surfaces are governed in various processes for e.g. the growth of crystalline and amorphous materials, heterogeneous catalysis, galvanic processes, corrosion, general decomposition processes, surface rich adsorbance, surface enhanced Raman spectroscopy, etc. Distinct features of the fractal surfaces in comparision to those of the non-fractal ones have been exemplified in Fig. 2A-E^:SituationA: Here is a case where atoms or molecules (o-o) go alongwith the surface only. In case (a) having the smooth surface, the distance between the molecules or species is shorter within the same length of the electrode and hence could be considered as the better situation as compared to the situation with fractal surface (b) Situation B: In this situation atoms or molecules go to the surfaces by diffusion controlled mechanism. Fractal electrode (b) is better than the smooth electrode (a) because the ionic species have got relatively more paths in the former situation and could thereby possess more ionic mobility to get themselves transported to the electrode surface. Situation C: Edges, cracks, etc. (b) could place at disposal energy richer reaction centres than the surfaces with the normal number of free valencies (a). Therefore, the active centres can be distributed more in case of fractal surface (b) than the non-fractal surface (a). This is a prominent case applicable to electrocatalysed systems likefiielcells. Situation D: When the surface has many neighbouring atoms or species, one may then expect two neighbouring atoms or species to interact. In (b) situation, one has choice for the atoms to make more neighbours and hence the system possesses more neighbouring atoms. Because of the multiple choice, the interaction could,therefore, result more in the fractal electrode than in the case of smooth surface (a). Situation E: Both (a) and (b) planes here belong to the real surfaces (fractal). However, the dimension of the molecular species would be the detrimental parameter of the reactions in the real surfaces, i.e. having the same surface, either more or less number of molecules can be absorbed. The size of the molecules is apparantly smaller in the former one and hence more number of molecules can be accommodated in the structure (a) than (b). Fractal dimension, D is considered as an effective number that characterises the irregular electrode surface. The term has been related to physical quantities such as mass distribution, density of vibrational stages, conductivity and elasticity. If we consider a 2-D fractal picture in its self-similar multi-steps, one can draw various spheres of known radii at various points of its structure and may thus count the number of particles, N inside the sphere by microscope, following relation will then hold good : N(r) - r^ (1) where D = Fractal dimension and N = Number of lattice points inside a sphere of radius, r The plot of r vs. N could give rise to a straight line, the slope of which equals the value of fractal dimension. Equation (1) is, however, not valid for the 3-D geometry of the structure. A general simulation programme for the calculation of Nyquist plots with
95 respect to the 3-dimensional fractal electrode-electrolyte interface is included in the next section. ^4
/
0 STAGE 6=30.13 D = 2.50 1st STAGE — I \—I
^
>—^ ^^—11nd STAGE
Sc
.^JLAJ Figure 3.
^ A j X A - m r d STAGE Figure 4.
2. STRUCTURAL MODELLING OF THE NYQUIST CURVES FOR FRACTAL ELECTRODE/ELECTROLYTE INTERFACE The simplest model to describe the impedance behaviour of the metal/solution interface can be the Koch curve. Fig.3 illustrates the view of the irregular surface in terms of fractal geometry. Each interface consists of long parallel V-shaped grooves filled with electrolyte (black shaded region). Working electrode is depicted by the white portion. The metal/electrolyte interfacial boundary forms a generalised Koch-curve, the fractal-dimension of which can be measured by various methods described elsewhere^'^. Roughness of the surface is the measure of the fiinction of 0 (angle of the grooves). In this example, we consider a four-stage Koch-curve wherein 4 peaks of different sizes are present (Fig.4). Dilatational symmetry is one of the feature of the Koch-curve. Each peak could thus possess different impedance characteristic, which are named as Z4, Z3, Z2 and Zi according to the falUng sizes. Besides these peaks, there are 16 flat regions which show pure capacitive behaviour (Zo). As the impedances are all connected in parallel, the whole impedance, Zt is composed of the reciprocal values of the individual impedances. If the different regions of these peaks are taken into account, Zt may be written as : 1/Zt =16/Zo+8/Zi +4/Z2 + 2/Z3 +I/Z4 (2) 2.1. Calculation of the impedance of a flat region (Zo) If we permit charge penetration to the interface, the simplest equivalent circuit diagram is then a parallel circuit composed of R^ and Cai in series with Rbuik- Its impedance is calculated as : 1/Z = (jcoCdi + 1/Rct) (3) or Z = Rct/GcoCdiRct+1) = RcAo'Cdi 'Rct'+ 1) - j [(o)CdiRct')/(«'Cdi'Rct'+ 1) (4) Taking into consideration Rbuik gives :Z = Ret/(co'Cdi 'Rct'+ 1) - j [(cDCdiRct')/(«'Cdi'Rct'+ 1) + Rbuik
(5)
96 2.2.
Calculation of the impedance of smallest peak (Zi) Conical shape as divided into K number of slices is the drawing of the smallest peak [Fig. 5(a)]. Equivalent circuit of these different slices is an ensemble of branched resistance/capacitance ladders [Fig.5(b)]. The parameters like ro,ri,r2, r/; ro',ri',r2', n' and Co,Ci,C2, Ci are the K different values of bulk resistances, charge-transfer resistances and the capacitances, respectively. Wang^ did not consider these additional charge-transfer resistances. Considering the circled last parallel connection (Fig. 6), the impedance of the last but one slice could be calculated. This rule can be further followed to other equivalent circuit diagrams in a similar manner till one gets Zo which would be the total impedance of the peak. Following the analogy of the apple tree, in this situation too, one could do with a recursive calculation in order to formulate the following derivation to calculate the impedance of all the sHces : 1/Zi.i = l/{(ai +ri) + bj)} + l/r/.i + JCOCM (6) where i is the index for K and varies from K to 1. Substitution of uj = ai + n in equation (6) followed with suitable mathematical changes gives :1/Zi.i = Ui/(ui' + bi') - j [(bi/(ui' + bi')] + l/r'i.]jcoCi.i (7) Separating into real and imaginary parts gives :1/Zi.i = Ui/(ui' + bi') + l/r-.i + j[coCi.i - {bi/(ui' + bi')}] Substitution of Ci = Ui/(ui ^+ bi^) + l/r'i-i as real part and di = coCi. imaginary part gives :l/Zi.i = Ci+diJ or Zi.i = l/(ci + dij) = Ci/(Ci' + di') - j[di/(Ci' + di')]
Thus, we obtain > New real part: New imaginary part
ai-i = Ci/(ci^ + diO bi.i-di/(Ci' + di')
bi/(Ui' + bi')
(8) as
(9) (10)
(11) (12)
4=h^I3TCI]TCIh (b)
-^^Y^'fg"f(]
^^-o-
Figure 5. Figure 6. Now ri, r'i and Ci are to be calculated. The length and the depth of the electrode has been originally assumed as 1 cm. Capacitance of the interface may be calculated by multiplying the standard capacitance and the length of the Koch-curve. Both sides of the groove structure are considered here in constrast to the flat smooth surface. Using the geometrical principles, further steps with respect to the calculations of length of the fractal electrode, number of peaks, bulk resistance, etc. have been followed in the numerical
97 model. With this knowledge, it could be then possible to calculate the impedance of the cone (Zi) in any multiple number of the structure. 2.3.
Modelling of a rough electrode with equivalent electrical circuits Z2 is the impedance of the second smallest network as shown in Fig. 7(a). Parallel placements of three branches each having the Zi impedance could give rise to the resultant impedance of Zi/3 at the intersection. The latter, in turn, becomes the terminating impedance at the end of the network for the calculation of Z2 [Fig. 7(b)]. The branched resistance/capacitance network can be solved by using the same equation as employed previously for the calculation of Zi. The impedances of the next higher grooves such as Z3, Z4, Z5,.... Zn, can also be calculated in similar manner depending upon the branching configuration. In this work, a general programme has been thus developed using Turbopascal 5.0 language in order to simulate the impedance of the many peak irregular surface with n number of stages. The details of this software are to be published.
(a)
(b) 0
^00 200 REAL PART(ohm)
Figure 7. 3. PRESENTATION OF THE MODEL CALCULATIONS
Figure 8.
The assessment of the reported model for experimental passivation systems of say magnesium/magnesium perchlorate^^'^^ and titanium/or titanium dioxide/sulphuric acid has been made from the view-point of fractality of the electrode surface and a good agreement between the model calculated complex plane impedance (Fig. 8 being a typical simulated plot) and the measured Nyquist-plots is obtained. The charge transfer resistance (Ret) values in respect of magnesium AZ31 alloy in 2 M Mg(C104)2 have been measured as 4154 , 338, 238 and 150 ohm for the applied potentials of 0,10,30 and 50 mV, respectively^^. Increase of the passivation potential from 0 to 50 mV has brought about the gradual decrease of the radii of the semi-circle - an anomalous observation because in any normal circumstance, the Ret of the electrode surface should have increased with the rise in the passivation (a case of oxide film formation). In order to rationalise this unusual polarisation behaviour, one could imagine the interpretation based on the concept of anion adsorption in the surface oxide layer wherein afieldassisted transport of ions through the passive layer is introduced to account for the ion current density increase upon raising the oxidation potential. These interpretations are, however, not valid for systems containing no chloride in the base electrolyte. High corrosion rate accounts the reason of the non-employment of MgCb
98 electrolyte in the cells developed by us in India ^'*•^^ Different parameters such as the groove angle, number of slices, number of different peaks, capacitance, series/and parallel resistors and the thickness of charge transfer resistor have been varied during the simulation by the programme so as to obtain the series of semicircled impedance diagrams. The important findings are such that decrease of the groove angle brings about the decrease in the Ret which has been found valid for 10 < 9 < 75 and 5 < N (number of different peaks) < 20. It is thus envisaged qualitatively that during passivation, morphological changes in the electrode take place and this change becomes effective for the charge flux to diffuse which thereby explain the cause of anomalous behaviour. This model, however, requires much more refinement as the small lateral branches remain still unconsidered and the number of slices (K) must be selected so large that the impedance is constant i.e. Z ^ f (K). Also the simulation of the diffusion controlled interfacial processes has not been possible through the present model. These are some of the open areas wherein modelling research could be further pursued . Acknowledgements. Correspondence and discussions with M. Wicker is highly acknowledged. DPB is obliged to DST , Govt, of India and Klaus Hagen, Atotech, Tokyo 141 for providing partial financial aid in attending FGM96 symposium. Grateful thanks are accorded to the Director, NPL, New Delhi for giving permission to publish this paper. REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
L. Pietronero and E. Tosatti (eds.). Fractals in Physics, Elsevier Science Publishers B.V.,Netherland, 1986. M. Gardner, Scientific American, 238 (1978) 16. B.B. Mandelbrot, The fractal geometry of nature. Freeman W.H. and Co., New York, 1982. H.-O.Peitgen and P.H. Richter (eds.). The beauty of fractals - Images of complex dynamical systems. Springer Verlag, New York Inc., 1986. H.-O. Peitgen and D. Saupe (eds.). The Science of fractal images. Springer Verlag, New York Inc., 1988. P. Pfeifer, Chimia, 39 (1985) 120. D. Avnir and P. Pfeifer, J. Chem. Phys., 79 (1983) 3566. R.F. Voss, Physica Scripta, T13 (1986) 27. J.C. Wang, Electrochim. Acta, 33 (1988) 707. R. Udhayan and D.P. Bhatt, In International Conf on Magnesium alloys and their applications, Germisch-Partenkirchen, Germany (1992) 59. R. Udhayan, Ph.D. thesis, M.K. University, Madurai, India, 1991. M. Wicker, Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Kiel, Kiel, Germany, 1991. D.M. Drazic, S.K. Zecevic, R.T. Atanasoki and A.F. Despic, Electrochim. Acta, 28(1983)751. D.P. Bhatt and R. Udhayan, Indian Pat. 749/DEL/l 991. R. Udhayan and DP. Bhatt, J. Power Sources, 39 (1992) 323 ; J. Appl. Electrochem., 23 (1993) 393.
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
99
Database System for Project of the Functionally Graded Materials K. Kisara, A. Moro, Y. S. Kang, M. Niino National Aerospace Laboratory, Kakuda Research Center, Japan. ABSTRACT This report will introduce the concept and status of a database system for a national project entitled: "A Study in the Development of Energy Conversion Materials through the Formation of Gradient Structures" , which project is being promoted by some thirtyodd industrial, academic and governmental organizations. While the database system will be, organizationally speaking, somewhat loose-knit, it is ejected that the project's initial goal will be realized within a fixed period of time. In order to provide a convenient means of comunication for researchers working in various organizations to exchange information, complete their work assignment in a short space of time and maintain a common perspective, the establishment of some method of information-sharing is essential. At the same time the report will describe measures of the need for maintenance of the database and a network to make use of it in real time so as to promote support for the project and, additionally, show that the use of the Internet is a viable method of operating the system at this present time.
1. INTRODUCTION The Fimctionally Graded Materials Database System was established to manage the entire body of data arising out of the Science and Technology Agency funded project: "A Study in the Development of Energy Conversion Materials throu^ the Formation of Gradient Structures" (Phase I: 1993-1995; Phase II: 1996-1997, hereafter referred to collectively as the FGM Part 2 Project), and to maintain such so as to facilitate effective access to said data. The project aims at dividing materials into thermal areas and developing the most efficient energy conversion elements for each individual area, all the while keeping to the fore the concept of a compound system that would convert thermal into electrical energy at a high level of efficiency. Some thirty-odd industrial, academic and governmental orgEinizations are participating in the project, the activities of which are carried out by subcommittees. As the fimction of these subcommittees is to make use of e)q)erimental data found in the published reports and minutes of seminars held in various fields of study, an information centre to collect
100 and maintain this data assumes an important role in enabling the project's participant organizations to share and effectively access such information resources. Additionally, the centre play s a vital role in preventing the loss of project assets. Also,fromthe very early stages of the project, maintaining and actually operating such a centre as a base for accessing information is vital to the project's receiving adequate support.
2. FGM PROJECT AND DATABASE The following is an outline of the role of the database within the project as a whole. The research being conducted under the project has as its principle aim the development of fundamental technological skills essential to the creation of new materials, these skills being developed by sharing results of research among the various specialist subcommittees dealing with planning, synthesis (creation of new materials) and evaluation into which the thirty-odd participating organizations are divided. By means of this co-operation, participating bodies become part of a loose-knit organization working together to achieve common goals and thus it can be seen that the adoption into the system of a groupware concept whereby these bodies engaged in research can mutually access each other's published data would be effective. The relative position of the database as seen against the background information outlined here is illustrated in Figure 1. As described above, within theframeworkof a looseknit organization where participant bodies work together to achieve common goals, the database needs to provide an operating system for the groupware, desiga the system platform that serves as its base and, at the same time, fulfill the primary function of the database, namely to prevent the loss of the fruits of project research so that individual researchers may mutually access this information. The different duties involved in this information distribution are classified variously as: data gathering and maintenance, standardization, access environment maintenance and educational.
^ ,
plaiming(designing)
.•^
estimate of characteristic estimate of performam design of FGM ^ 3 ^ 3 ^ ^ ^ Ithennoelectru material
Thermal andl Mechanical evalution total evaluation laracteristic of FGM iterial
S Ithermionic database material |(FGM emittei a te collector] radiator o insulator electrode heat collecter
, ^
synthesisofinaterials
'^.
Fig.l The relative position of the database
In order to accomplish all this, the FGM Database manages the entire body of project data and maintains a network for effectively accessing this data. The relationship between the database and the project is shown in Figure 2. Basically speaking, the database is made up of three groups of data shown in Figure 2.: data from written sources, that from electronic conferences and measurement datafromexperiments.
101 characteristic of FGM material Icharacter of thermal and | mechanical evalution FGM database (three groups) f Database server ^ database *«ct data management system store data
electronic filing report data (Optical memory disc) logging data of BBS (first class) communication
JI
provide data multi platform -interface—! subcommittees mtemet planning or modem [Network systeiji WWW e-mail ftp —news—
thermoelectric material thermionic generator synthesis of materials evaluation
-support system for planning-
knowledge base of FGM (example based)
theory, experence simulation technique of use of database] technique of designing
expert system
Fig.2 The relationship between the database and the project
3. OPERATION AND THE NETWORK 3.1. Design of the System Platform In the early stages of the project, a database system centering on personal computer communication was constructed to enable infonnation to be shared and accessed. At the present moment a different approach is possible with group ware making use of the Internet, and machine interface is possible by means of hypertext browsers such as the World Wide Web. As the database is constructed to gather and maintain information, questions such as the following are pertinent: What information is gathered in the database? How is it compiled? Who uses it? How do they use it? What is needed is a database that will make the optimum use of limited resources, in other words, one that will increase the efficiency of the brainwork of its users.
102 In the area of what information is gathered, the following data has been collated: information and actual experimental data on the physical properties, methods of making and measuring the performance of new materials being developed; graphs, tables and photographs published in seminar journals and subcommittee reports together with data in written form from monographs and the published minutes of subcommittee conferences. As to how it is compiled, keywords are assigned to assembled data from e^qjeriment measurement values, images, written works such as monographs and this data is maintained in electronic files as a means of managing project information. Also, the results of information exchanges using electronic bulletin boards are stored and accumulated as further resources of information. As to the envisaged users of the system, for the duration of the project, the idea is to provide timely information to researchers belonging to organizations involved in the project and, upon the project's completion, make this information available to public users in an open database. On the matter of method of access, direct access via the Internet has been chosen. At the inception of the project, a network was deployed using modems connected to the public telephone lines but, in response to changes in the network environment cause by the growing availability of the Internet, a switch was made to direct access via the net. In summary, the database was assigned the following three information management roles: To serve as a database in the narrow sense of the term - simply gathering, organizing and recording data. To provide a system for dissemination timely information - enabling participants to share groupware data. To maintain an environment for access and a users' service (support for researches on how to make use of the system). These three roles are dealt with morefrillybelow. 3.2. Maintaining an Environment for Information Access In order to keep the project moving forward it is vital that participant organizations not only share the same goal but also share information and maintain a common perspective. The project maintains a closed networksystem, excluding access to all but participant org3nizations, as a base for information sharing whilst protecting portions thereof that may need to be kept secret. Operation of the original service begun at the Japan National Aerospace Laboratory's Quaked Research Centre with the construction of a personal computer communication host computer (BBB) using four public telephone lines. Subsequently, with the availability of the Internet, a BBB using Window and Macintosh to support TCP/IP protocol was put into operation. At the present moment, a switchover is taking place in the mode of operating the database access environment from the old C/S (client server) system to a method employing the concept of a distributed database such as the World Wide Web using the Internet. A distributed database is being constructed hat uses data and monographs in the
103 possessionof the various individual participating organizations to create home pages, and then serves as a database centre, consolidating these pages into a single home page for convenient access. 3.3. The Functionally Graded Material Database in the Narrow Sense of the Term Gathering, organizing and recording data contributes to the accumulation of the project's immaterial assets. Data is principally assembled from the published monogr^hs of researchers and from subcommittee reports. These are recorded on electronic files. Data is organized at the time of recording according to information or keywords necessary to reference it. Additionally, in order to manage this information, a search application is provided to facilitate researchers' access to the data from their own personal computers. Also, as measurement data from e^eriments is used in designing new materials or inferring their physical properties, it is vital that such measurement data be kept up to date in a systematic fashion so that the database may fulfill its role in the narrow or restricted meaning of the term "database*' and the maintenance of such a body of experimental data increases the value of the database's support operations. 4JTJTURE PROSPECTS In these days when the dual concepts of the Intemet and group ware are being brou^t more and more to the fore, a base whereby project researchers can make optimum use of needed information is being put in place. Formerly, a WWW browser would read and display a specified file but, from the spring of 1995, the Hot JAVA browser developed by the Sun Microsystem Company has deployed a form of programming called "Applet" . By means of CGI (Common Gateway Interface) procedures org3nically linking h i ^ processing level database servers such as SQL together with the WWW server, the construction of a distributed database able to conduct sophisticated dialogue has become possible. Always adjusting to progress in the network environment, the Functionally Graded Materials Database will continue to gather data and support the project. It will also continue to frmction as an attractive centre for information pertaining to frmctionally graded materials by translating the tables and the abstracts of principal monographs into En^sh, thereby fiilfilling its role as an internationally valuable information source and contributing to the standardization of research data and, additionally, it is intended that it will serve as a news centre educating the public regarding the concept of fimctionally graded materials.
104
NAL KRC LAN Macintosh TCP/IP H
Macintosh
GatorBox Filing system
UNIX
Windows
LocalTalk
llU EtherNET
AppleTalk TCP/IP DataBase BBS;First Class
^ ^ ^ '
IBM/AT DOS/V Modem (4 ports)
Macintosh
TEL NTT
IBM/AT Windows
PC98/DOS
WWW databese homepage http://fgin.kakuda-splab.go.jp/
Fig.3 Network System for FGM Database
References 1) R. Watanabe ,Fimctionally gradient material(Japanese),The society of non-traditional technology
I. Shiota and M.Y. Miyamoto (Editors) Functionally Graded Materials 1996 ® 1997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
105
Fracture Mechanics of Graded Materials F. Erdogan Department of Mechanical Engineering and Mechanics Lehigh University, Bethlehem PA, 18015, USA In this article after a brief review of elementary principles of fracture mechanics, certain issues concerning the applications to graded materials are identified and some examples are given. 1. INTRODUCTION In recent past there has been a great deal of interest in the concept of material property grading as a tool for new material design. This is usually accomplished by suitably varying composition and/or microstructure of the medium. Thus far most of the work in the field has been on metal/ceramic composites, various intermetallics and electronic materials with current and potential applications as interfacial zones and coatings. From a mechanics view point the main advantages of material property grading appear to be improved bonding strength, toughness and wear and corrosion resistance, and reduced residual and thermal stresses. Some typical applications include thermal barrier coatings of high temperature components in gas turbines, surface hardening for tribological protection and graded interlayers used in multilayered microelectronic and optoelectronic components [1-3]. An important aspect that needs to be addressed in various engineering applications of FGMs is the question of reliability and durability in general and fracture related failures in particular. This article is concerned primarily with fracture mechanics as applied to structures involving FGMs. After a brief description of some basic notions of fracture mechanics, certain critical issues relating to FGMs are discussed and some examples are given. 2. FRACTURE MECHANICS The quantitative theories of fracture which are currently in use are based on a fundamental principle of continuum thermodynamics, namely the first law or the energy balance which states that dU_ _ dV^ dJ^ dD_ dt dt dt dt where t is the time U the external work, V the recoverable (elastic) energy, T the kinetic energy and D the sum of all irreversible energies associated with the creation of new fracture surfaces such as surface tension, plastic work and viscous dissipation. If the solid contains a
106 dominant flaw which may be represented by a planar crack having a surface area A(t) and if the fracture process is taking place in a quasi-static manner and A(t) can be characterized by a single length parameter a{t), then dT/dt = 0 and defining dD/da = Qc, (1) may be expressed as ±(U-V)=
Gc,
(2)
where the left hand side is the rate of energy available for fracture (also known as Q, the crack driving force or the strain energy release rate) and Qc represents the energy required for unit crack extension. If the fracture can be characterized as a low energy or brittle phenomenon, then it can be assumed that the size of the inelastic region around the crack tip (also known as the fracture process zone) where all the dissipative processes take place is small compared to the crack size a, Qc is independent of a and the energy flowing into the crack tip region comes from the elastic bulk of the medium and is insensitive to the details of the stress and deformation states in the fracture process zone. The significance of this last observation lies in the fact that a purely elastic solution may be used to calculate the crack driving force. For example, by observing that under normal opening or mode I loading the asymptotic values of the cleavage stress and crack opening displacement at the crack tip x = a, y = 0 are given by [4] ^^^^^'^^ ~ ~J2(i^'
^y ~ ^y = ^^y(^'^) = " ^
hy/2{a-x),
(3)
by using the concept of crack closure energy, the energy available for fracture can be expressed as 1 pa+da
d{U-V)
= -
J
ayy{x,0)I^Uy{x - da,0)dx,
Z Ja
ki = ^mJ2{x
—{U -V) aa
- a)ayy{x,0),
1 4- /c
= Qi = - ^ n k l Qfi
(4)
where ki is known as the mode I stress intensity factor, /x is the shear modulus and « = 3 - 4z/ for plane strain and « = (3 - i/)/(l +1/) for plane stress, i/ being the Poisson's ratio. Similarly under mode II, the in-plane shear and mode III, the anti-plane shear loading conditions, the stress intensity factors, the corresponding energy release rates and the total strain energy release rate for co-planar crack growth are given by /C2 = MiJ2{x
-a)(7a;y(x,0),
^// = ^ 7 r A : | ,
Giii = ^7rkl
ks = ]im^y2{x - a) ayz{x,0), Q = Qi+Qii + Qiii.
(5)
Referring to the general expression (2), in brittle fracture the critical value of Qc corresponding to the co-planar crack growth is known as Qic, the fracture toughness, with G = Qic being the fracture criterion. In practice, very often Kj = ^J^k\, Kjj = ^Jl^hi, Km = v^/cs and Kj = Kic are used as the stress intensity factors and the fracture criterion. In addition to their successfiil applications to fracture stability problems, the stress intensity factors have been widely used as correlation parameters in analyzing the subcritical crack growth rates da/dn (in fatigue) and da/dt (in corrosion), n and t referring to the number of
107 load cycles and time, respectively. In the presence of large scale inelastic deformations the general energy balance criterion described by (2) is still valid. However, in this case since Qc is no longer independent of the crack size, the fracture propagation can not be described by a single parameter criterion. In high energy fracture, the fracture process zone, and consequently Gc usually grows with the growing crack size. Hence, for fracture stability problems it becomes necessary to use a criterion based on variable Qc such as a crack extension resistance curve or a R-curve approach. Unlike the linear elastic fracture mechanics dealing with brittle fracture and subcritical crack growth, the tools of the so-called elastic-plastic or nonlinear fracture mechanics dealing with high energy or ductile fracture are not well-developed and universally accepted. In some cases the J-integral is used with some success to compute the crack driving force, Q = d{U — V)lda. In all cases the application of the criterion G = Gc requires extensive numerical and experimental work. 3. MAJOR ISSUES IN FGMS The principles of fracture mechanics described in the previous section are applicable to inhomogeneous as well as homogeneous materials. In FGMs the difficulties arise in the solution of elastic or elastic-plastic crack problems to evaluate G or ki, ki, k^ and in characterizing the material to determine Kjc, Gic or Gc where the fracture toughness Gic is no longer a material constant [5]. The definitions of stress intensity factors and expressions of the strain energy release rates given by (4) and (5) are still valid provided the elastic parameters /i and K are evaluated at the crack tip. Following are some of the major issues concerning the fracture mechanics of FGMs. (a) Elastic singularities. As long as the elastic parameters ^ and K are continuous ftinctions of the space variables with piecewise continuous derivatives, the stress state around the crack tips has the standard square-root singularity. For example, in plane isotropic elasticity problems for r -• 0 the leading terms of the stresses are given by [6-8] -
-'^^'"'^^[fci/iyW + fc2/2i,W], {ij) = ir,e)
(6)
where (r, 9) are the polar coordinates at the crack tip, ki and k2 are the modes I and II stress intensity factors, (f>{r,6) is a smooth function with )(0,6) = 1 and the ftinctions fuj and f2ij are identical to that found for crack problems in isotropic homogeneous materials. If the crack tip terminates at a kink or slope discontinuity of /i(x), there would be no change in the dominant terms shown in (6) [8]. However, for small values of r the next significant term would be different, which, for the cleavage stress at the crack tip is given by [9]
k^f
^-A^
aeeir, 0) c^ - ^ ( 1 -h ^^,, ^\.^ /3r\nr] + c^/^, y^V 87r(l-i.)
(7)
where c is a constant, /i(x) = fxocxip{/3x) for x < 0, /i = fiQ for x > 0 and the crack is located along 0 < x < a, y = 0. (b) Analytical methods/benchmark solutions. Even though there are no known closed form solutions for crack problems in FGMs, for simple property variations the formulations leading
108 to singular integral equations are straightforward and accurate solutions can be obtained [7]. (c) Computational methods. Finite element method is the major computational tool. However, to improve efficiency and accuracy the development of enriched crack tip and transition elements and ordinary inhomogeneous elements will be needed [10]. (d) Material orthotropy. In many cases the material orthotropy seems to be the consequence of processing technique. For example, FGMs processed by using a plasma spray technique tend to have a lamellar structure. Flattened splats and relatively weak splat boundaries result in an oriented material with higher stiffness and weaker cleavage planes parallel to the boundary [11]. On the other hand graded materials processed by an electron beam physical vapor deposition technique have usually a columnar structure giving higher stiffness and weak fracture planes in thickness direction [12]. These oriented materials can generally be approximated by an inhomogeneous orthotropic medium. (e) Inelastic behavior. Because of the length scales involved in FGM coatings and interfaces, in addition to conventional plasticity, one may have to use a microplasticity approach which accounts for the effect of strain gradients on strain hardening coefficients. The resulting nonlinear elastic-plastic crack problems require a numerical approach with special inhomogeneous elements. (f) Rheological effects. Invariably FGMs are used in high temperature environments. As a result the time-temperature effects may not be negligible and the material may have to be modeled as an inhomogeneous viscoelastic or viscoplastic medium. (g) Dynamic effects. Generally, high velocities in propagating cracks and high rates of loading (e.g., impact) in stationary cracks would necessitate the consideration of inertia effects in solving the fracture problem. However, even for the uncracked linear elastic inhomogeneous bounded medium, the stress wave phenomenon is not fully understood. The existing solutions are restricted mostly to one dimensional problems in materials with certain simple property gradings. (h) Material characterization. This is still the most important issue in studying the fracture mechanics FGMs. The knowledge of thermomechanical and fracture mechanics parameters of the material is essential for any realistic predictive reliability study of FGM components. 4. EXAMPLES In this section we will briefly discuss three groups of examples. The first two are concerned with FGM coatings on homogeneous substrates in which for simplicity it is assumed that the bond coat has the same thermomechanical properties as the substrate. The third group deals with the effect of material orthotropy on the stress intensity factors. 4.1. Surface Cracking In FGM as well as homogenous (ceramic) coatings the fracture related failures may take place in various ways. One way would be under cyclic mechanical and/or thermal loading the initiation of a fatigue crack at a surface defect, the subcritical growth of the crack in thickness direction, fracture of bond coat and opening an oxygen path to the substrate. This may happen if there are no weaker fracture planes in the coating and the coating/bond coat interface is
109 sufficiently strong. Such crack initiation and growth in thickness direction have been observed in FGM coatings by several investigators (e.g., [13,14]). A variation of this mode of failure would be multiple (or eventually, periodic) surface cracking. Multiple cracking is clearly in evidence in the work reported in [14]. In practice, because of the long hold times under high temperature, the crack growth process would be heavily enhanced by the environmental effects. Even in the simplest case of low temperature and relatively high cycle fatigue for which a simple two-parameter crack propagation model such as ^=C{AK)\ C = C{a), b = b{a) (8) an may be applicable, in FGMs the parameters C and b would be dependent on the material composition and the microstructure. This would mean that in surface crack problems C and b would be functions of the crack length a. For modeling and any quantitative analysis, these functions must be determined from the fatigue data on homogenous cupons with various composition. The surface crack problem is one of mode I and the determination of the stress intensity factor ki is sufficient for fracture stability and fatigue analysis. For a FGM coating on a homogenous substrate some sample results are given in Figures 1-3 [15] where hi and /12 are the thicknesses of coating and the substrate, respectively, c is the crack length, K is constant and the shear modulus of FGM is given by /i(x) = /ioexp(/3a:), ^0 being the modulus of the substrate. Figure 1 shows the effect of material inhomogeneity on /ci in a medium loaded by fixed grips or constant strain EQ. The normalizing stress is given by CTQ = 8/ii£o/(l + /^), /ii := /ioexp(-/5/ii). Figures 2 and 3 show ki for PSZ/Rene 41 FGM coating (/5/ii = 0.375) on Rene 41 substrate loaded by constant strain £0 or constant temperature change AT, respectively. Figure 2 shows the influence of the thickness ratio h2/hi on ki. The effect of the uniform temperature change AT is shown in Figure 3 where To corresponds to the stress-free state and T] and To are the surface temperatures. This is a special case of a general problem in which Ti 7^ To and the medium is under steady-state heat conduction.
. 7.0 6.0 ,
kl
i ; i !
y
h2/h,=0.5 h/h,=1.0 h/h,=2.0 h^h,=10.0
/-
5.0
y/
ic
\
^Oy 2.0 1.0
U—\
,^^^^^^:
-
-'-"'IT-
c/Zii
Figure 1. Mode I stress intensity factor for a surface crack in FGM coating, h\ —h^.
Figure 2. Mode I stress intensity factor for a surface crack in FGM coating, phi = 0.375.
4.2 Spallation Another mode of failure would be the transformation of the surface crack to a T-shaped crack at a relatively weak fracture plane parallel to the surface. This may be microcracks forming along the oxidized splat boundaries or the interface between the thermally grown
no oxide and the coating. There seems to be some evidence of such branching in the results given in [14]. For the T-shaped crack the stress state at the crack tip is one of mixed-mode. Therefore, in the fatigue model, for example, one would have to use A^ rather than Ai^ as the correlation parameter.
Tj=T,=5To Tj=T,=10To T,=T.=20T„
~».^
y
"^^
•r.^
^pL
N
0.025 o 0.020
TT
O^ 0.015
\
arxA"^ "*"-«.»
\
0.010
t\-
0.005
-^^ ^^ *^
1
0.003
^ ^
0.002
1
r_ f
'
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
Figure 4 Strain energy release rate for a T-shaped crack under uniform temperature change.
1
\CR2
f
1
LN
r
1
MR1
/^ '
1
0.2
CR1
f
0.001
•
\\.
0.0
- p=:CO
b/l
c/hi Figure 3. Normalized stress intensity factor under uniform temperature rise, ar = 8/ioQ:oTb/(l + K,)
0.004
0.000
p=0.2 p=0.5 p=1 p=3 p=5 p=8
MR2 .
1
1
.HM 1
1
1
"^
Figure 5 Normalized strain energy release rate due to uniform temperature change, ijhi = 5, ^0 = (1 - i^Dids^TfEs-Khi.
Figure 6 Mode I stress intensity factor in an orthotropic FGM subjected to uniform crack surface pressure o-ii(0, X2) = -po, z^ = 0.3
In [14] it was reported that spallation cracks develop in the graded region due to the change in residual stresses caused by the oxidation of the metallic lamellae. Similar observations were made in [16] where a candidate design for an abradable seal was tested 242 hours at 1000°C The seal consisted of a 0.13mm NiCoCrAlY layer, 2.54mm NiCoCrAlY/YSZ FGM region and a 1.27mm low density YSZ. The substrate was a MM247 superaUoy. The spallation occurred in FGM 0.5mm from the initial substrate surface. It was observed that most of the metallic phase in the spalled region was oxidized whereas the part of the seal remaining on the substrate was not. This appears to be due to connectivity of the oxidized region. The continuous oxide layer seems to create a weak fracture plane as well as preventing further oxygen diffusion. Figures 4 and 5 show the strain energy release rate for a T-shaped crack and symmetric edge cracks, respectively. In these examples the substrate is Rene 41 (E5 = 219.7 Gpa,
Ill 1/3 = 0.3, as = 1.67 IQ-^K ) the coating is FGM ( Rene 41 / YSZ, ^Jc = 151 Gpa, Uc = 0.3, Qc = 10"^/°K), h2/hi = 0.16, £/hi = 5,the loading is uniform temperature change AT and the normalizing strain energy release rate is QQ = {1 - u^)(asAT)^Es7vhi. For the FGM coating the modulus variation is given by E{y)
-{
Es, E, -h {Es - Ec)il + ihi/h2) - (y//l2))^
0
/12.
(9)
In Figure 5 a is the length of the edge crack and the results given correspond to homogeneous ceramic coating (IL, p = 00), ceramic-rich (CRl, p = 8 and CR2, p = 2.5), linear (LN, p = 1) and metal-rich (MRl, p = 0.5 and MR2, p = 0.2) FGM coatings, and homogenous metal (HM, p = 0). Note that in both examples Q increases with increasing ceramic content in the coating.
2.0 Figure 7 Variation of the normalized strain energy release rate with aa and 6 in a graded orthotropic medium under uniform tension /to = 1, i^ = 0.3, a22(a;i, ±oo) = po,Qo = np^a/Eo.
Figure 8 Variation of the normalized strain energy release rate with «o and ota in a graded orthotropic medium under uniform tension 0-22(3:1, ± 00) = po, 6 = 1,1/ = 0.3, Qo = Trpga/Eo.
4.3 Effect of Material Orthotropy As mentioned in section 3, because of the processing techniques used, the graded materials are seldom isotropic. Thus, in studying the mechanics of many of the FGMs the medium may be approximated by an inhomogeneous orthotropic continuum. In these materials there are basically two groups of crack problems. In the first the weak firacture plane, and consequently the plane of the crack is parallel to the direction of the material property variation and the related crack problem is one of mode I. The second is a mixed-mode problem in which the crack is perpendicular to the direction of property variation. The plane elasticity problem is solved by introducing the following four parameters for the plane stress problem to replace the engineering elastic constants En, E22, G12 and 1/12 : E = yjEnE22.
P = y/^^ni^x.
6^=En/E22,
KQ = {E/2Gi2) -1^-
(10)
Similar parameters may be defined for plane strain problems. The previous results have shown that the solution of crack problems in FGMs is not very sensitive to the Poisson's ratio. Thus, 1/ is assumed to be constant throughout the medium. In this study it is further assumed that in the graded materials the variations in Eu, E22 and G12 are proportional. Referring to
112 (10), these assumptions imply that «o, v and d are independent of the space variables xi, X2 and the inhomogeneity of the medium may be represented by the function ^(0:1,0:2). The results given in Figures 6-8 are obtained by assuming that xi and X2 are the principal axes of orthotropy and E = Eoexp{ax2). In the mode I problem a crack of length 2a is located along xi =0, -a < X2 < a, and figure 6 shows the influence of the shear parameter KQ and the inhomogeneity parameter a on the stress intensity factor fci. In this case ki turns out to be independent of 6 or the stiffness ratio. More generally, from the formulation of the problem it can be shown that (711(0,0:2) is invariant with respect to a 90-degree material rotation. In the figure «o = 1 corresponds to the isotropic material [17]. Figures 7 and 8 respectively show the effect of a and 6 and a and KQ on the normalized strain energy release rate in an orthotropic FGM with a crack of length 2a located along the xi axis. The problem is one of mixed-mode, the external load is a uniform tension po perpendicular to the crack plane and Go is the strain energy release rate for the corresponding homogeneous isotropic medium for which a = 0, KQ = 1, 6 = 1, ^' = 0.3[18].
REFERENCES 1. M. Yamanouchi, M. Koizumi, T. Hirai and I. Shiota (eds.), 1990, FGM-90, Proc. FGM90, FGM Forum, Tokyo, Japan (1990). 2. J.B.Holt, M. Koizumi, T. Hirai, and Z.A. Munir (eds.), Proc. FGM'92, Ceramic Transactions, Vol. 34, American Ceramic Society (1992). 3. B. Ilschner, and N. Cherradi (eds.), Proc. FGM'94, Presses Polytechniques et Universitaires Romands, Lausanne, Switzerland (1995). 4. H. Liebowitz (ed.). Fracture, Vol. 2, Academic Press (1968). 5. M. Saito and H. Takahashi, Proc. FGM'90 (1990), p. 297. 6. F. Delale and F. Erdogan, Int. J. Engng, ScL, 26 (1988) 559. 7. F. Erdogan, Tr. J. Engineering and Environmental Sci., 18 (1994) 185 8. F. Erdogan, A.C. Kaya and P.F.Joseph, ASME J. Appl. Mech., 58 (1991) 410. 9. P.A. Martin, J. Engineering Mathematics, 26 (1992) 467. 10. Y.D