This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
1: 2.2.4. Theorem. Suppose Q is a circular region in C , 0 e Q, and some biholomorphic F maps B onto Q. Then there is a linear transformation of C" that maps B onto Q. Proof. Let a = F~^(0). Then F o cp^ is a biholomorphic map of B onto Q that fixes 0. By Theorem 2.1.3, F o (p^is linear. Corollary. When n > 1, there is no biholomorphic map ofB onto the polydisc U\ Proof. Invertible linear transformations map balls onto ellipsoids. 0; every (peLip a is thus a Dini function. (The terminology comes from Dini's test for the convergence of the conjugate Fourier series; see Zygmund [3], vol. I., p. 52.) If (^ is a Dini function on S, let us extend cpto a continuous function on B (with the same sup-norm), in such a way that (p(z) = (p(z/\z\) for ^ < |z| < 1, and let us define (6)
28
2. The Automorphisms of B
Note that Theorem 2.2.4 holds (with the same proof) if B is replaced by any bounded circular region that contains 0 and that has a transitive group of automorphisms. We shall encounter further variations on this theme in the context of proper holomorphic maps. The automorphisms of B that we have met so far are the maps cp^ and the unitary transformations. The next theorem shows that all automorphisms are obtained from these: 2.2.5. Theorem. Ifil/e Aut(B) and a = il/~^(0) then there is a unique U e^ such that (1)
(A = U<Pa^
The identity (2)
1 -
holds for all z e B, w e B. Proof. The map ij/ ocp^is an automorphism of B that fixes 0, hence is linear, by Theorem 2.1.3. Since the unitary transformations are the only linear ones on C" that preserve B, there is a U e^ such that xjj o (p^= JJ, hence xj/ = Ucpa- The uniqueness of U is trivial. The rest follows from Theorem 2.2.2(iii), since (Ucp^zX UcpM} = <(pa(zl (paM}> 2.2.6. Theorem. (i)Ifil/e ^ at zs Bis
Aut(^) and a = i/^"^(0), then the real Jacobian of
(ii) Ifx is the measure defined on B by dT(z) = ( l - | z p ) - " - i r f v ( z )
(2) then
(3) for every feL^(z)
f/dT= Ufoil,)dx
JB
'JB
and every ij/ e Aut(B).
This T is thus invariant under Aut(B).
2.2. The Automorphisms
29
Proof. Put il/(z) = w. Then cp^oij/ o cp^is an automorphism of B that fixes 0, hence it is unitary, by another appUcation of Theorem 2.1.3, as in the preceding proof. Thus ij/ = (p^ Ucpz for some U e^. Hence
(4)
nz) = cp'^(o)ucp'Xzy
By Theorem 2.2.2(ii), the Unear operator (p'y^iO) has a 1-dimensional eigenspace with eigenvalue —s^ (where s^ = 1 — |w|^)andan(n — l)-dimensional eigenspace with eigenvalue — s, so that its determinant is ( — l)"s"'^ ^ Hence (see §1.3.6) (5)
(JRCPJ(0)
= Idet cpl(0)\' = (1 -
\w\y^K
Similarly, (JR(PZ)(Z) = (1 — | z p ) ~ " ~ \ and now (4) implies that
The identity 2.2.5 (with w = z) shows that (6) is the same as (1). Next, (fdt= JB
f/(w)(l-|wp)-"-irfv(w) JB
= f/(.A(z))(i -JB
\Hz)\'r"-\AiPK^)dv(z).
By (6), the last integral is f/(^(Z))(l -
|zp)-"-'dv(z) =
JB
f
(/o^)dT.
JB
2.2.7. We now describe the sets onto which cp^ maps balls centered at 0. Fix a G J5, fix £, 0 < e < 1, and define (1)
E(a, 8) = cp^isB).
Since cpa is an involution, z e E(a, s) if and only if | cp^z) | < e. If one squares this and uses the definition 2.2.1(2) of (pa(z), a little manipulation shows that E(a, s) consists of all z that satisfy
30
2. The Automorphisms of B
where P = P „ e = 6 , , and ,,,
(1 - ^')a
1 - \a\'
Thus E(a, e) is an eUipsoid with center at c; this is close to a when s is small. The intersection of E(a, e) with [a] is a disc of radius sp, which is roughly ss^ when s is small; its intersection with the real (2n — 2)-dimensional space perpendicular to [a] at c is a ball of the much larger radius Note that this agrees with Theorem 2.2.2(ii), i.e., with
As 8 -^ 0, the quotient converges to (JRcpJiO). By (3), it follows that (5)
(JR(Pa)(0) =
(l-\a\'r^K
This is another derivation of 2.2.6(5). 2.2.8. Extensions of Automorphisms. Suppose \ < n < N. Corresponding to the orthogonal direct sum decomposition C^ = C" © C^"", each z e C^ decomposes into z — z' + z\ where z' e C , z" G C^~". Let B„ and B^^ be the corresponding unit balls. Every ij/ e Aut(B„) extends then to a^^ e Aut(B^). It is enough to prove this for iJ/ = (p^iae B„X since the extension of unitary operators presents no problem. Given cp^, put 5 = (1 — \a\^y^^, and define ^a(z) = (Pa(zl -
l-
Since
2.3. The Cayley Transform
31
2.3. The Cayley Transform 2.3.1. One often transfers problems from the unit disc to the upper halfplane by means of the correspondence w = i(l -\- z)/(l — z). A similar device is available in C". The appropriate "upper half-plane" in C is the region Q consisting of all w = (wi, w') such that (1)
Im Wi > |w'|^
where w' = (w2,..., w„), |w'p = |w2p + ••• + |w„p. The Cayley transform is the map O that sends zeC" (z^ ^ 1) to w G C", by (2)
w = i1 -zi
where, as usual, e^ = (1, 0'). Simple computations show that (2) implies (3)
Imw,-|w-p=/"'^''
and (4)
2w z =— ^
I + Wi
- e,.
Hence O is a biholomorphic map ofB onto Q. Let Q = Q u ^Q be the closure of Q in C"; clearly, w G dQ if and only if (5)
Im Wi = |w'p.
Let Q u {oo} be the one-point compactification of Q, and let 0(ei) = oo. Then O is a homeomorphism of 5 ontoQ u {oo}, and it is clear that O induces an isomorphism between Aut(J5) and Aut(Q). 2.3.2. Aut(Q) has a subgroup that is isomorphic to the multiplicative group of the positive real numbers and that consists of the so-called "non-isotropic" dilations 6^, defined by (1)
dt(w) = (t^Wi, tw')
(0
< 00).
When t ^ I, St fixes only 0 and oo. Hence 0~ ^ o ^^ o O is an automorphism of B whose only fixed points on B are Ci and —e^.
32
2. The Automorphisms of B
2.3.3. Another subgroup of Aut(Q) consists of the "translations" h^ (one for each a e 3Q) that are defined by (1)
Kiy^) = (^1 + «i + 2f<w', a'y, W + a').
To see this, put hj(w) = C = (Ci, D- Using the fact that Im a^ = \a'\^, it is easy to verify that (2)
ImCi-|C'P = Imwi-|w'p.
Every ha thus maps Q into Q, ^Q into dCl. Moreover, if a, bedO. and c = ha(bX then ha^'hi, = h^. If b = ( —fli, —a') then /i^Cfo) = 0, hence h^ = h~^, since /IQ is the identity map. Thus {ha'.aedQ} is indeed a subgroup of Aut(Q). It induces a binary operation # on ^Q, defined by (3)
a#b
= (Koh,)(0)
(a,bedni
or simply hy a # b = ha(b). This makes 5Q into a group that has been called the Heisenberg group and that has been the setting for a great deal of recent research in harmonic analysis and partial differential equations. See, for instance Greiner and Stein [1], Rothschild and Stein [1]. Note that h^fixesno point of Q when a ¥" 0. Hence 0~^ o /^^ o O is an automorphism of B whose only fixed point on B is e^.
2.4. Fixed Points and Affine Sets 2.4.1. Affine Sets. In place of C", let us for the moment consider arbitrary vector spaces X and Y over a field F. A nonempty SQt E c: X is said to be affine if the following is true: whenever jci, . . . , x^ G £", Cj, . . . , c^ e i^, and Zq = 1, then ZcfXf e E. One sees easily that E is affine if and only if E == XQ -\- p for some pe X and some vector space XQ CZ X. Now fix beY, peF, let L : X -^ 7 and K.X^F be linear, let D = {xeX'.Kx 7^ j8}, and define a "Moebius transformation" ij/.D -^ 7 b y
<"
*« = F ^ -
If Xf G D, Ci G F, Zci = 1, and ScjXf = x G D, it follows that (2)
Hx) =
^yMxi)
where y^ = c,(iS — Axf)/(jS — Ax). The linearity of A shows that Zy,- = 1.
2.4. Fixed Points and Affine Sets
33
Somewhat imprecisely (because of the possible vanishing of denominators), this says that ij/ maps the affine set generated by X j , . . . , x^ into the affine set generated by , we see that ij/ has the form (1), and that
HE). One sees in the same way that affine sets are preserved by the Cayley transform. 2.4.3. Definition. If/is a map of a set X into X, thQ fixed-point set of/is the set of all X G A" for which/(x) = x. As we shall now see, the automorphisms of J5 have very simple fixed-point sets. 2.4.4. Theorem. Ifij/^ Aut(B) fixes a point of B, then the fixed-point set of ij/ is affine. Conversely, every affine subset of B is the fixed-point set of some xj/ G Aut(B). Proof. Suppose \l/{a) = a for some asB. Then (Pa°^ ° (pafixes0, hence is unitary, hence its fixed point set E (in C") is either {0} or it is a subspace Y of C" corresponding to the eigenvalue 1. The fixed-point set of ij/ is (Pa(E n B). The first assertion follows now from 2.4.2. For the converse, let E be an affine subset of JB. If a G £, Proposition 2.4.2 implies that C" has a subspace Y such that (Pa(E) = B nY. Choose UE^ so that Y is the eigenspace of U with eigenvalue 1. If i/^ = (p^Ucpa, then ij/ has E as its fixed-point set. 2.4.5. As a consequence of the Brouwer fixed point theorem, every \j/ G Aut(B) fixes at least one point of B. In Section 2.3 we saw examples of automorphisms that fix no point of B and whose fixed-point set on S consists of exactly one or two points. This is as far as one can go: 2.4.6. Theorem (Hayden-Suffridge [1]). If ij/ e Aut(B) and if \j/ fixes three distinct points ofS, then ij/fixes a point of B. Consequently (by Theorem 2.4.4) the fixed-point set of ^ is then affine. The following proof is due to David Ullrich.
34
2. The Automorphisms of B
Proof. Let Zj, Z2, z^ be distinct fixed points of ij/ on 5. The identity 2.2.5(2) becomes now ,
. ^^^'^'^^
(l-
where a = ij/' ^0). If f 7^fethen
-. (1 -
With /c = 3 and f = 1 or 2, this impHes that (1)
=
Put z = i(zi + Z2). Then zeB. Since (1) holds, the definition of (p^ impHes (2)
(Pa(z) = l(pa(Zl)
+ i()^a(22)-
Since ij/ = Ucpa for some U e^,we conclude that iA(z) = iiA(2i) + # ( ^ 2 ) = i(^i + ^2) = ^. The following theorem characterizes the automorphisms (p^ as precisely those involutions thatfixonly one point of B: 2.4.7. Theorem, (i) Each cp^fixesexactly one point of B, and no point ofS. (ii) IfbeB and a = 2b/(l + |bp), then cpa is the only involution in Aut(jB) that has b as its only fixed point. Proof. Suppose zeB and (Pa(z) = z. Then Q(Pa(z) = Qz, where Q = Qa, and 2.2.1(2) implies (1)
-sQz = (l-
This forces Qz = 0, since Re(l —
is the only fixed point of (p^ in B. This proves (i).
2.4. Fixed Points and Affine Sets
35
If beB and a = 2b/(l + |6p), then (2) holds, as is easily verified. Thus (Pa(b) = b. Assume now that i/^GAut(B) is an involution with b as its only fixed point. Then cpj, o ij/ o cp^ {$ an involution with 0 as its only fixed point. But if a unitary transformation is an involution, then 1 and — 1 are its only possible eigenvalues, and if it fixes only 0, then 1 is excluded from the eigenvalues. Hence (pi,o\j/ o(p^ = (p^. This establishes the uniqueness of ij/ and shows, incidentally, that (3) ifa = 2b/(l + |bp).
(Pa = (pb°(Po° (Pb
Chapter 3
Integral Representations
3.1. The Bergman Integral in B 3.1.1. The Spaces (L^ n H)(B). As usual, n is a fixed positive integer, n > 1, B = B^is the open unit ball of C", and v is the normalized Lebesgue measure on C defined in §1.4.1. For 1 < p < 00, {U r\H){B) is the space of all holomorphic f:B -^ C that belong to L^(v). With respect to the usual norm
(1)
mp-Uifi'dvY",
L^ n H turns out to be a closed subspace of L^. This follows quickly from the mean value formula (2)
f(z) = r-'-
f
fdv
(r < 1 -
\z\),
valid for every / G H(5), since Holder's inequality leads from (2) to
(3)
1/(^)1 <(l-UI)-'""'ll/llp
(zeB).
[Formula (2) can be proved by the argument that was apphed to subharmonic functions in §1.5.3.] If now {fj} is a Cauchy sequence in L^ n H, (3) implies that {fj} converges uniformly on every compact subset of B. Hence L^ n His closed in L^. 3.1.2. The Bergman Kernel. This is the function A^ defined on B x B (or, if preferred, on all of C" x C except where
X(z,w) = ( l - < z , w » - ' ' - ^
Note that K(z, w) is holomorphic in z, conjugate holomorphic in w, and that (2) 36
K{w,z) = K(z,w),
3.1. The Bergman Integral in JB
37
This kernel associates to every fsL^{v) by the integral (3)
Kin{z)=
a function X [ / ] , defined in B
\ K{z,w)f{y^)dv{w),
This is well-defined, since K(z, w) is a bounded function of w, for each zeB. It is clear that X [ / ] is always holomorphic. The most important property of K is that it reproduces holomorphic functions: 3.1.3. Theorem, (a) / = K [ / ] for every fe(L^n H)(B). (b) On L^(v), h -^ Klh] is the orthogonal projection whose range is (L'nHXB). A more explicit statement of (a) is that e v e r y / e ( L ' n H)(B) satisfies
for every ZEB. Proof. Fix / G (L^ n H)(B), fix a 6 B, and define (2)
g(z) = ^r^,f(z) K{z, a)
(zeB),
Since 1/K(z, a) is bounded, ge(L^ n H)(BX and the same is true of g o cp^. The mean value formula (3)
ig^(Pa)(0)=
f g((Pa(u))dv(u)
JB
holds therefore. (See §3.1.1.) Since f{a) = g{a\ the change of variables u = (pj[w) turns (3) into (4)
f(a)=
\ g(w)(Jj,q>J(w)dv(w). JB
By Theorem 2.2.6 and the definition of K(z, w), ,,,
(5)
.r
v^
[
1-|«P
Y^'
(J,
If we insert (2) and (5) into (4) we obtain (1).
=
K(a,w)K(w,a)
^fa,)
•
38
3. Integral Representations
To prove (b), it is now enough to show that X[/z] = 0 for every h e L^(v) that is orthogonal to (L^ n H)(B). Fix aeB, define K«(w) = K(w, a). Then K^ 6 (L^ n H)(BX and therefore { hK^ dv = 0.
K M ( a ) = \ K{a,w)hiw)dv(w)= JB
JB
3.1.4. Remark. There is a Bergman kernel associated to every region Q c= C", as follows: For every z e Q, the evaluation functional /—> f(z) is continuous on (L^ n //)(Q), essentially by 3.1.1(3). Hence there corresponds to every z 6 Q a function K,eL^ nH such that /(z) = [/, K J for all feL^nH, where [ , ] is the inner product in L^. If {MJ is an orthonormal basis for L^ n H, then i
i
By Parseval's theorem, J] \Ui(z)\^ = WKJj < ^» and /(^) = Z [/» WJWi(2) = i
Jci
/(W) Z Wi(^)Wi(w)^v(w) i
for every / G L^ n H,z€Q. The sum ^ Wi(z)Mf(w) is the Bergman kernel iC(z, w) of Q. The associated integral transform projects L\Q) orthogonally onto (L^nH)(Q). The uniqueness of this projection implies that K(z, w) is independent of the choice of {wj; any orthonormal basis of (L^ n H)(Q:) will do. (Bergman [1].) In the ball, the normalized holomorphic monomials form such a basis (see Proposition 1.4.9), and the kernel 3.1.2(1) can be obtained by summing the resulting series.
3.2. The Cauchy Integral in B 3.2.1. Definition. The Cauchy kernel for B is the function C defined by
(1)
c(z,o = (i-
for all (z, C) e C X C" that satisfy
C [ / ] (z) = J C{z, Of(Od(T(0
(z e B)
3.2. The Cauchy Integral in B
39
and (3)
C M ( z ) = fc(z,CV/i(0
{zeB\
We call C [ / ] and Cljii] the Cauchy integrals of/ and /i, respectively. It is clear that these are holomorphic functions in B. The operator that takes / to C [ / ] , or ji to C[ju], is called the Cauchy transform. 3.2.2. Lemma. 7%^ Cauchy transform commutes with the action of the unitary group ^. Proof. The conclusion is, more explicitly, that (1)
C [ / o t/] = ( C [ / ] ) o U
{feL\a),
Ue
n
Since C(z, U^^C) = C(Uz, 0 and a is ^^-invariant, (1) follows from fc(z, o / ( i / O M O = fc(z, c / - i o / ( O r f T ( 0 = fc(c/z,o/(Otiff(0. Js -^s Js 3.2.3. Definition. The /?«// algebra A(B) is the class of all / : B -• C that are continuous on the closed ball B and that are holomorphic in its interior B. Equipped with the supremum norm ||/||oo, A(B) is a Banach algebra. When n = 1, it is the well-known disc algebra. 3.2.4. The Cauchy Formula in B. Iffe
A(B) and z e B, then
This will later be extended to larger classes of holomorphic functions. We begin with A(B) since here there is no problem concerning the existence of boundary values. When n = 1 there is of course no need to prove this. When n > 1, the following proof shows that the Cauchy formula in B„ is a consequence of the Bergman formula in B„_ j . Proof. Fix / e A(BX zeB = B„. Write points w G C" in the form w = (w', w„), where w' = ( w i , . . . , w„_ i). By Lemma 3.2.2 we may assume, without loss of generality, that z„ = 0, i.e., that z = (z\ 0). Define (2)
g(w) = Ciz,w)f(w)
(WGB).
40
3. Integral Representations
Since z„ = 0, C(z, w) = K(z\ w'), the Bergman kernel for B„_i. Next, g(C\ w„) is a holomorphic function of w„, for every CeS,in the disc I w„ I < I C„ I, and is continuous on the closure of this disc. Hence
(3)
3(C',0) = 1J%(C',A„¥9.
We now integrate (3) over 5„_i. On the right, Proposition 1.4.7(2) shows that we obtain (4) Since g(C, 0) = K(z\ Of(C\ 0), Theorem 3.1.3 shows that the integral of the left side of (4) is f(z\ 0) = /(z). This proves (1). It is curious that this simple formula (1) is not older than it appears to be. It occurs in Hua's 1958 book [1; p. 93], for more general symmetric domains, and was rediscovered in 1964 by Bungart [1], who computed the kernel C{z, 0 from the normalized holomorphic monomials in L^((TX following Bergman's method (see §3.1.4). As in one variable, there is a Cauchy formula in B that expresses / in terms of its real part on S: 3.2.5. Theorem. Iffe A(B), w = R e / , andf(0) is real, then, for z e B, (1)
f(z)=
f[2C(z, 0 - 1 ) ^ ( 0 ^ ^ ( 0 .
Proof. Assume /(O) = 0, without loss of generality. Then \ fdcr = 0, hence ^uda = 0, and the right side of (1) is C [ / ] + C [ / ] . Put (2)
g(w) = C(w, z)f(w)
(we5).
Then g e A(B), g(0) = 0, hence ^ g da = 0. Since C [ / ] is the complex conjugate of f g da, the right side of (1) is C [ / ] (z).
3.3. The Invariant Poisson Integral in B 3.3.1. Definition. The kernel (1)
(1 - IzP)" P(z,0=,; /;,-'„„ |l-
izeB,CeS)
3.3. The Invariant Poisson Integral in B
41
is called the invariant Poisson kernel in B = B„. Theorem 3.3.8 justifies this terminology. We shall usually omit the adjective "invariant" when there is no danger of confusing P with the ordinary Poisson kernel that will be briefly discussed in §3.3.10. The definition (1) shows that the Poisson kernel is related to the Cauchy kernel by the formula C(z, z) The (invariant) Poisson integral P [ / ] of a function feL^ip) for z 6 B, by
(3)
pin{z)= fp(z, o/(OMO. ^s
Similarly,
(4)
PM(z)= fp(z,O^MO
is the Poisson integral of the measure ^i on 5. 3.3.2. Theorem. Iffe
A(B) thenf{z) = Pin{z)for
zeB.
Proof, Fix zeB, put (1)
^(w) = ^ ^ / ( w ) C(z, z)
(we 5).
Then g e A{B\ and /(z) = g{z). Hence /(z) = ^C{z, OgmaiO
= ^P{z,
OmdaiQ.
The last equality used (1) and 3.3.1(2). 3.3.3. Proposition. IfO < r < I, l^e S,r] e S, then (1)
P(rr;,0 = P(rC,»/).
Also (2)
f Pirn, QdcriO = 1 = f Pirr\, CWiri).
Js
'JS
is defined,
42
3. Integral Representations
Proof. (1) is clear from 3.3.1(1). The first equality in (2) is the special case / = 1 of Theorem 3.3.2; the second follows from (1). 3.3.4. Theorem, (a) Iffe C(S) and F is defined on B so that F = fon S and F = Pin in B, then F e C(B) and ||F |L "= || / ||^. (b)
Ifl
00, / e L V ) , u = P [ / ] , and uXO = u(rO
(0
then \\Ur\\p < 11/lip. If also p < co then
l i m | k - / | | p = 0. (c) Iffi is a complex Borel measure on 5, with total variation ||/z||, and u = P M , then \\Ur\\i < \\ix\\,for 0 < r < 1, and lim Ur da = d^i in the weak*-topology of the dual space ofC(S). (d) IfPlfi] (z) = 0 for all zeB, then JJ, = 0. The proofs are so similar to the classical case of the Poisson integral in the disc that a brief sketch will suffice. By 3.3.1(1), P(z, 0 > 0 and P(rri, Q -^ 0 uniformly, as r -^ 1, if ^ e 5 Hes outside any prescribed neighborhood of C- Part (a) follows now exactly as in the disc, because of 3.3.3(2). Part (b) follows from Holder's inequality, and the fact that C(S) is dense in L^(a) when p < oo. The first assertion of (c) is obvious. With the aid of 3.3.3(1), Fubini's theorem gives
Js
Js
if u = Plfi] and fe C(5). By (a), P [ / ] , ^ / uniformly. Thus f ujda -^ ^fdfi, as r -> 1. Finally, (d) is a corollary of the second assertion in (c). The following theorem shows how the Poisson kernel is related to the automorphisms of B. 3.3.5. Theorem. Ifil/e Aut{B), z e B, and ( e 5", then
(1)
P(Hzl 0 = P(z, r HO)W(O), 0.
3.3. The Invariant Poisson Integral in B
43
Proof. Put a = \l/~^(0). The identity 2.2.5(2) is equivalent to
(2)
c(Hz)M) = ^^f'fJf'% C{z, a)C{a, C)
and 3.3.1(2) converts this to
(3)
pmzi HO) = 5 ^ P(a, 0
In particular, P(il/(0), ^Q) = l/P(fl, Q, since P(0, Q = 1. Thus (4) P(^(zX »A(0) = P(^, OP(«A(0), iA(0). If we replace ^ by ^~^(0 in (4), we obtain (1). 3.3.6. Definition. A function / e C(B) is said to have the invariant mean value property if
(1)
/('/'(0))= =
jfiHr \fmrO)d
for every ij/ e Aut(B), 0 < r < 1. If we set \l/(0) = a, then ^ = (p^U for some 1/ e ^ , and the ^-in variance of G shows that (2)
f{a)=
\f{
if (1) holds. The integral in (2) is an average of / over the boundary of the ellipsoid E(a, r); see §2.2.7. A class X of functions with domain B or 5 or S is said to be Moebiusinvariant, or simply Jf-invariant, if / o i/^ G X for every f e X and for every ij/ G Aut(B). As an example of this terminology, observe that the class of all f with the invariant mean value property is ^-invariant For if/satisfies (1), ij/i e Aut(5), and g = f^if/u then g satisfies (1), simply because g^^^j/ = / ° (^Ai ° ^\ ^nd iAioj/^GAut(B). 3.3.7. Theorem. If p. is a complex Borel measure on S, then P[_p] has the invariant mean value property.
44
3. Integral Representations
Proof. Put u = Plfi]. If z is replaced by rrj in Theorem 3.3.5 (with rj e S), and if we integrate the resuh with respect to dG(r]\ we obtain, for any ll/ G Aut(B), (1)
(p(4f(rrj),Od(7{ri)==PmOXO
by Proposition 3.3.3. Multiply (1) by d/i(C) and use Fubini's theorem to get the desired conclusion (2)
humrtl))d(7(r,) = umO)).
3.3.8. Theorem. Iffe L\o) then (1)
P[/°^] = P[/]°^
for every xj/ e Aut(B). In other words, the Poisson transform commutes with the action of Aut(J5). The theorem also implies that the class of all Poisson integrals of L^-functions is ^-invariant. Proof. Since C{S) is dense in L^{(J\ it is enough to prove the theorem for fe C(S). By Theorem 3.3.7, with dfi = fda, (2)
P[/](^A(0))= f
PUimrri))da(rj).
When r -> 1, the integrand converges uniformly to f(il/(rj)X by 3.3.4(a). Hence (3)
n / ] ( ^ ( 0 ) ) = P[/oiA](0),
which establishes (1) at the origin. For any zeB, two applications of (3) give
ThusP[/](./.(z)) = P [ / o ^ ] ( 2 ) . Remark. Since P(0, 0 = 1, (3) is tiie same as (4)
(p(HO),OnC)d<7(0= Js
\mM)d
3.3. The Invariant Poisson Integral in B
45
Replace / by / o i/^~ \ then replace i/^ by i/^" ^ and (4) turns into a change-ofvariables formula
(5)
jPirKO), OfiUCMaiO = J fda
in which the Poisson kernel plays the role of a Jacobian. 3.3.9. Example. Lemma 3.2.2 showed that the Cauchy transform commutes with ^ . But it does not have the stronger in variance property of Theorem 3.3.8, for any n> I. For instance, let / ( Q = Ci- Then Clf'](z) = 0 for every ZEB, but if a = r^i, 0 < r < 1, then
if^cpam = ^ ~ so that
C[/o(pJ(0)=
UfocpJda^r^O.
ThusC[/o(^J^C[/]o(^,. 3.3.10. Remark. The kernel P{z, C) is intimately related to the Cauchy kernel of B and to the automorphisms of B. The functions that it produces (i.e., the Poisson integrals) are annihilated by a differential operator, the so-called invariant Laplacian, which will be the topic of Chapter 4. But these Poisson integrals need not be harmonic functions in the ordinary sense; i.e., their ordinary Laplacian need not be 0, except when n = I. Let us note, very briefly, that there is a Poisson kernel Q(x, y) associated to the unit ball of any euclidean space R^:
Qix,y) = ]~_^''l 1^
yi
(|x|
Straightforward (but tedious) differentiations show that g is a harmonic function of x, for every y with \y\ = L Also
J
Q(x, y)da(y) = 1
46
3. Integral Representations
because this integral is a radial harmonic function in the ball, hence is constant (by Gauss' mean value theorem), hence can be evaluated by putting X = 0. Thus Q solves the Dirichlet problem for harmonic functions. When N = 2n, and R^" is identified with C , then
<2feO=,,\C-z\'_1 Thus Q(z, 0 = P(z, 0 only when n = 1.
(zeB^C^S).
Chapter 4
The Invariant Laplacian
4.1. The Operator A 4.1.1. Definition. Suppose Q is an open subset of B,fe We define (1)
C^(Q), and aeO..
(S/)(a) = A(/o
where cpa is the involution defined in §2.2.1, and A is the ordinary Laplacian given by (2)
Ag =
4tDAg i=l
as in §1.3.4. This operator A is called the invariant Laplacian because it commutes with the automorphisms of 5 : 4.1.2. Theorem. Iffe
C^(Q) and xj/ e Aut(B), then A(/otA) = ( S / ) o ^
in^-\a). Proof. Pick z6i/<"^(Q), put w = \l/{z). Then (/)w°^°<^z fixes 0, hence is unitary, so that
48
4. The Invariant Laplacian
The next theorem Hsts some other expressions for A/ that will be used later. It is curious that they totally hide the invariance that was just proved. 4.1.3. Theorem. Iffe
C\a) and aeQ, then
(i) in terms of integral averages, (AfXa) = l i m ^ UficPairO) r^O ^
(ii)
fia)}daiO;
JS
in terms of partial derivatives, (A/)(a) = 4(1 - lap) t
i^ik -
a,a,)iD,D,fKa),
i,k=l
(iii)
where dij^ = 0 when i ¥" K ^u = 1; in terms of the slice function fa defined byfa(X) = f{^a\ (AfKa) = (1 - |fl|^)[(A/)(a) - (A/J(l)].
Proof. Ifh = f'^cPa then the formula 4n C (A/z)(0) = lim-2 {h(rO - /i(0)}MO r-^O ^
*JS
is an easy consequence of the Taylor expansion of h about 0, since heC^. By 4.1.1(1), this proves (i). The discussion in §1.3.4 shows that (iii) is just another way of writing (ii). We turn to the proof of (ii). Put h = f o cp^, as above. Denote the components of (Pahy (pi, .,.,(p„. Since these are holomorphic, the chain rule gives (Ah)iO) = 4 1 : {D,DJ){a) ^ (D„
m
Let us compute {D^(p^{0). The definition of(Pa (§2.2.1) shows that (Pa{z) = {1 +
1 + 5
Pz - s{z - Pz)}
/
The missing terms have z-degree 2 or more. Hence
14-5
4.2. Eigenfunctions of A
49
Insert this into the expression for (Aft)(0). After some computation, the inner sum (over m) simpHfies to
Since 5^ = 1 — |a|^ (this was of course used in the preceding computation), and since (S/)(a) = (A/z)(0), the proof is complete. 4.1.4. Remark. When n = 1, formula 4.1.3(ii) simplifies to (A/)(a) = ( l - | a m A / ) ( « ) Thus, although A and A are not the same, they do annihilate the same functions. This fails to be true if w > 1. 4.1.5. Remark. It is an immediate consequence of Theorem 4.1.3(i) that Af = 0 for e v e r y / G C^(5) that has the invariant mean value property. Since P[ju] has this property (Theorem 3.3.7) for every complex Borel measure fi on 5, it follows that AjP[/i] = 0. Taking for /i a point mass at a fixed C e 5, and putting u(z) = P(z, Q, we see, in particular, that Aw = 0. 4.2. Eigenfunctions of A 4.2.1. Definition. For every A e C, we define X;^ to be the space of a l l / e C^(B) that satisfy the equation (1)
A/ = A/.
Theorem 4.1.2 shows that every X^ is ^-invariant. The case A = 0 will be the most interesting; the members of XQ will be called ^-harmonic functions. Recall that a function / with domain B is said to be radial iff o L/ = / for every U e%. We associate to e a c h / e C(B) its socalled "radialization"/* by the formula (2)
/*(z)= \f(Uz)dU
(zeB).
The ^-invariance oidU shows that / ' ^ is indeed a radial function. Each Xx is an eigenspace of A, since none of them reduce to 0. This is part of the content of the following theorem. 4.2.2. Theorem. Ifa and X are related by (1)
A = -4n^a(l - a)
50
4. The Invariant Laplacian
then X;^ contains every fof the form (2)
/ ( z ) = fnz.CMMO Js
(zeB),
where fi is a complex Borel measure on S. In particular, X^ contains the radial function g^ defined by (3)
gj,z)=
fnz,Od^(0 Js
(2 6B).
Note that P > 0, so that the complex powers P"" are defined, as usual, by (4)
P«(^,0 = exp{alogP(z,0},
where the logarithm is real. Proof. Fix t,eS, and write (as temporary notation) P{z) in place of P{z, C). Then AP = 0 (Remark 4.1.5), hence (AP)(0) = 0. Since P(0) = 1, it follows that (5)
(AP«)(0) = 4a(a - 1) £ (2),P)(0)(5,.P)(0).
But (5^P)(0) = «Cr Thus (5) becomes (6)
(AP")(0) = -An^a{\ - a) = 1
Now apply Theorem 3.3.5 with cp^ in place of i/^: (7)
P\cp^{z\ 0 = P\z, c p J O n w , C).
Take the Laplacian, with respect to z, at z = G; by (6), the result is (8)
(AP'')(w) = XP\w),
Hence A/ = Xf for every / of the form (2). Since P((7z, t/C) = P{z, Q for every U e%, the ^-invariance of a shows that g^ is radial. In the remainder of this section, a and X will always be related by (1). 4.2.3. Theorem. Iffe
X^ andf is radial, thenf = f(0)g^.
4.2. Eigenfunctions of A
51
Corollary. ^i_« = g^. Proof. Every radial / e C^{B) has the form/(z) = u{\zW and a little computation converts A/ = Af to (1)
Lu = hi
where Lw = aw" H- bw', with a(0 = 4r(l - 0 ^
(2)
KO = 4(1 - t){n - t).
The equation LM = 0 has a solution (3)
wo(0 = f s-"(l - 5)"-^
rfs
(0 < t < 1)
which is unbounded as t ^ 0. If Ux is a solution of (1), with Ux{G) = 1, if i; satisfies ulv' — U'Q (for small t > 0, where Uxit) ^ 0) and if w = u^v, one finds that Lw = kw and that w(0 is unbounded as t -^ 0. Since the solution space of (1) is 2-dimensional, the solutions of (1) that stay bounded as t -> 0 form a space of dimension 1. This proves the uniqueness asserted by the theorem. The corollary follows, since 4.2.2(1) is unchanged if a is replaced by 1 — a. 4.2.4. Theorem. Every f eX^ satisfies (1)
{fmrQ)da{Q Js
=
gj,rn)mm
for every xj/ e Aut(J5), 0 < r < l,rjeS, Equivalently (2)
f f((p, Uw)dU = gMf(z)
(z, w G B).
Conversely, iffe C(B) and f satisfies (1), thenfeC'^(B)
andfeXx-
Proof. I f / G X;t, so is its radialization
(3)
/ * = Uf^WdU.
By Theorem 4.2.3,/'*' = /(O)^^. This is (l)with/in place of/o i/^. The general case of (1) follows from the ^-invariance of X^If we take il/ = (p^in (1) and put r = | w|. Proposition 1.4.7(3) gives (2).
52
4. The Invariant Laplacian
For the converse, pick a radial function h e C°°(5), with compact support in B, such that f^ hg^^ dx = 1, where T is the ^-invariant measure of Theorem 2.2.6. Multiply (2) by h(w)dT(w% integrate, invert the order of integration, and use the ^-invariance of T to obtain
(4)
f(z) = f dU \f{ w)/z(i/-Vz(w)yT(w).
Since h is radial, the inner integral is independent of U, and (4) simplifies to (5)
/ ( z ) = \ fiw)h(cpM)dT{w). JB
This makes it evident that / e C^iB). We can now differentiate (2) with respect to w, and find that (6)
^ficpXO)) = A/(z),
i.e., that A/ = Xf.
ThusfeX;,.
Corollary 1. Every X^ is a closed subspace ofC(B), in the topology of uniform convergence on compact sets. Proof. (1) is preserved if fj -^ / uniformly on compact sets. Cot^oUary 2. Every ^-harmonic function in B has the invariant mean value property, and every feC(B) with the invariant mean value property is Ji-harmonic. Proof. This is the case A = 0 of the theorem. Note that go = Qi = ^' Corollary 3. For every A 6 C, X;i c C°°(B). Actually, more is true: 4.2.5. Theorem. Every fe Xj^ is real-analytic in B. The term real-analytic refers of course to analyticity relative to R^" rather than C". A real-analytic function is thus one that is locally the sum of a convergent power series in the 2n real variables Xi, y i , . . . , x„, y„. Proof. We will see that S meets the requirements of the following theorem about partial differential equations (Hormander [1], Theorem 7.5.1): If L is an elliptic differential operator with real-analytic coefficients, then every solution M of Lw = 0 is real-analytic.
4.2. Eigenfunctions of A
53
Theorem 4.1.3(ii) allows us to represent S in the form (AM)(Z) = p{z, D)u
where (replacing d/dxj by Uj, d/dy^ by v^, Wj = Uj + iv^ P(Z, W) = (1 -
| z p ) < X WfWf -
^ Z,.Z;tW^.Wfc>
= (l-UP)(|wp-|
1^1-1. 4.2.7. Theorem, (i) Z^ n Co(B) ^ {0} if and only if (1)
4n^Re:i + (lmXy
< 0.
(ii) X;^ contains a bounded function (not identically 0) if and only if (2)
4n^ Re A + (Im A)^ < 0.
Proof. Let X — — 4w^a(l — a), as before. Then (1) and (2) are equivalent to 0 < Rea < 1 and 0 < Rea < 1, respectively. Suppose /eX;^. If / e CQ{B\ or / is bounded, the same is true oi f* = f(0)g^ (Theorem 4.2.3). The following three assertions about g^ therefore prove the theorem. (Recall that6fi-a = ^a-)
(a) If 0 < Re a < i then g^ e Co(B). (b) If Re a = 0 then I ^a I < 1 but ^« ^ Co{B). (c) If Re a < 0 then g^ is unbounded in B. To prove (a), write formula 4.2.2(3) more explicitly:
Proposition 1.4.10 shows that the integral in (3) is bounded if Re a < ^ and that it is 0( —log(l — |z|)) if Re a = i. In either case, (a) follows from (3), as does part of (b), namely that \go,(z)\ < 1 if a is pure imaginary.
54
4. The Invariant Laplacian
Put j8 = —n(x. Then (c) and the second part of (b) will be proved once we show that the integral
(4)
^ l l - <\\l-
Js
has a non-zero limit, as |z| -> 1, if Re j8 > 0. Since (4) is a radial function of z, and since the absolute value of the integrand is bounded by a constant that depends only on j8, it suffices to show that (5)
f|l-CiP^MO^0
(ReiS>0).
The details of the computation that establishes (5) are not very enlightening, and we only sketch the proof. Formula 1.4.5(2) converts (5) to an integral over U. Replace Xe U by (z — l)/(z +1), z = x -\- iy, x > 0, to get an integral over the right half-plane, which, after replacing y by (1 + x)r, becomes a product of two integrals, one involving only x, the other only t. Each of these turns out to be a beta-function. This proves that the integral in (5) is not 0. Actually, the result can be further simplified, by means of Legendre's duplication formula for the gamma function, to (fs\ (6)
f u r \2P rin(r\ - n^)^^^ + ^P) ^ J J l ~ C i r ^ t T ( 0 - ^2^^^^^
valid for Re j8 > — w/2, by analytic continuation. 4.2.8. A Digression. Every function / with domain B "lifts" to a function / * on the group Aut(5), by setting
(1)
f%^) = mm
(^6Aut(B)).
Clearly, f\\j/U) = /*(iA), for every Ue^Affis invariance property (2)
/*(l/i't/2) = / * W
radial, then / * has the bi-
(t/i, U2 e * ) ;
conversely, it is easy to see that every bi-invariant function on Aut{B) arises in this way, from a radial function on B. Formula 4.2.4(2) holds with gf^ in place of/, and gives
(3)
gK(Pz)gi((pJ =
gKcp.Ucpjdu.
4.3. ^-Harmonic Functions
55
If i/^i, i/^2^Aut(5), then (/^i = Uicpz, \j/2 = (Pw^i-, for some z, w6 5, Ui, U2^'^, and the bi-invariance of ^* converts (3) to (4)
gt{^,)gt{^2)
= f 9:(4^iUil/2)dU,
This says that g^ satisfies the functional equation that characterizes the so-called "spherical functions" on the group Aut(5). We refer to Helgason [1], [2] and Lang [1] for more information on this subject.
4.3. ^-Harmonic Functions 4.3.1. Corollary 2 of Theorem 4.2.4 shows that the ^-harmonic functions are precisely those continuous function on B that have the invariant mean value property. Since Poisson integrals satisfy this (§4.1.5), every Poisson integral is ^-harmonic. The main purpose of the present section is to prove the converse (Theorem 4.3.3), subject, of course, to the obviously necessary growth restrictions. But first we state a maximum principle: 4.3.2. Theorem. Suppose Q is an open subset of B, ue C(Q), AM = 0 in Q, and u < 0 on 5Q. Then u < 0 in Q. (Boundary and closure of Q are understood to be taken with respect to C", not just B.) Proof, Put h(z) = u(z) + eziZi, for some g > 0. Then h < eon dQ, and (Ah)(z) =
4sil-\z\')(l-z,z,)>0
for all zeQAfh had a local maximum at some z e Q, then ho (p^ would have a local maximum at 0, which is impossible since A(/io(^J(0) = (A/2)(z)>0. Thus h < sinQ. Since u < h, the proof is completed by letting e tend to 0. 4.3.3. Theorem. Suppose F. B ^ C is an Ji-harmonic function that satisfies the growth condition (1) for some p, 1 < p < oo.
sup ||F,||^ = M , < o)
0
56
4. The Invariant Laplacian
/ / (1) holds for some p > 1, then there is an feU'{o) such that F = P [ / ] . / / (1) holds for p = 1, then there is a measure pionS such that F = P[/x]. Note that this is a converse of parts (b) and (c) of Theorem 3.3.4; part (d) of the same theorem estabUshes the uniqueness of the / and ja that occur in the present conclusion. The norm in (1) is of course (2)
l|F,||, = ^ | \F(rO\'daiO} ' {!'"<'
when 1 < p < 00. When p = oo, (1) simply says that F is bounded in B. For ^-harmonic functions F that have continuous extensions to 5, the theorem is trivial: Let u = P[F] be the Poisson integral of the restriction of F to S. Then u — Fiscontinuous on fi, ^-harmonicin B,0on 5, hence0in B. (We have used Theorems 3.3.4(a) and 4.3.2.) When deahng with harmonic functions in the disc (or in the unit ball of R^), one can deduce the L^-result by applying the preceding paragraph to the dilates F^ of F. This device is not available in the present context, since dilates of ^-harmonic functions need not be e/#-harmonic. (See Theorem 4.4.10.) For bounded F, Theorem 4.3.3 is contained in a much more general result proved by Fiirstenberg [1] that depends on a fairly heavy dose of Lie group machinery. The L^ statements were added by Koranyi [2]. The elementary proof that follows is due to David Ullrich. Its main ingredient is a simple equicontinuity argument. Proof Let /z: ^ ^ [0, oo) be a continuous function that satisfies (3)
f h(U)dU = 1,
where dU is the Haar measure of ^ . Define (4)
G(z)=
\ F(Uz)h(U)dU
(zeB).
For any C e 5, 0 < r < 1, (5)
{ \F(UrO\'dU=
J%
{\FA^dcj.
Js
(See Proposition L4.7.) Hence Holder's inequality, applied to (4), gives (6)
\G(z)\<M,\\hl
(zeBX
4.3. ^-Harmonic Functions
57
where q is the exponent conjugate to p, and (7)
IIGJ, <M,
(0 < r < 1).
We claim that {G^: 0 < r < 1} is an equicontinuous family of functions on S: Pick £ > 0. There is a neighborhood N of the identity in ^ , such that (8)
\h(U) - h(UUo')\ <s
(Ue%UoeN)
and there is a 5 > 0 with the following property: If C e 5, w e S, | C — w | < d, then w = UQC for some UQ e N. The in variance of the Haar measure dU leads from (4) to (9)
GiUoz)=
\
F(Uz)h(UUo')dU,
If we combine (4) and (9), and use (8), we obtain the desired equicontinuity: (10)
\GXO - Gr(w)| <M,8
(0 < r < 1),
whenever |C — >v| < 5; note that Mi < Mp. Since {GJ is equicontinuous and uniformly bounded (see (6)), there is a sequence ri -^ 1 such that {G^..} converges uniformly to a function g e C(S). Let (11)
8, = s u p | G ( r , 0 - P M ( r , 0 | .
Since \G(riO - g(0\ and \g(0 - P[gUriO\ tend to 0 uniformly, as / -^ oo, we see that Si -^ 0. We now use the fact that AF = 0. By (4), Ao = 0. Thus G - P[^] is ^-harmonic, and the maximum principle (Theorem 4.4.2), combined with (11), shows, for every i, that (12)
|G(z)-PM(z)|<8,
(|z|
Hence G(z) = P[^] (z) for all zeB. Note also that Hfi'llp < Mp, by (7) and Fatou's lemma. To finish, we do the preceding for a sequence {hj} in place offt,in which the supports of hj shrink to the identity element of %. The corresponding functions Gj, defined by (4) with hj in place of h, converge then pointwise to F(z). They are Poisson integrals of functions gjEL^ia), with \\gj\\p < Mp. If p > 1, some subsequence of {gj} converges, in the weak*-topology of L^((7), to some / e L^ia), In particular, P[^,.] (z) -^ P [ / ] (z). Thus F = P [ / ] .
58
4. The Invariant Laplacian
When p = 1, the weak*-convergence takes place in the dual of C(5), and results in a measure /i that satisfies F = P M . Corollary. Iff is a positive J^-harmonic function in B then there is a positive measure jion S such that F = P[/i]. Proof, By the mean-value property (Corollary 2 to Theorem 4.2.4) ||FJ|i = F(0) for all r, 0 < r < 1. Thus, by the theorem, F = Plpi] for some /x, and ft is positive because fi is the weak*-limit of the positive functions f ^. (See Theorem 3.3.4.) We shall now show, for continuous functions on the closed ball, that a much weaker mean value property implies ./#-harmonicity: 4.3.4. The One-Radius Theorem. Suppose u e C(B), and suppose that there corresponds to every z e Bjust one radius r(z)(0 < r{z) < 1) such that
(1)
M(z)= \u{
Then u is M-harmonic in B. If C(B) is replaced by C(B), the theorem becomes false, as we shall see in §4.3.5. It is not known whether the theorem is true for bounded continuous functions in B (or, for that matter, for bounded real-analytic functions in B), even in the case n = 1. See Zalcman [1] and Berenstein-Zalcman [1] for further information about such mean-value problems. Proof. Let u be real, without loss of generality. Let v be the Poisson integral of the restriction of u to S, put f = u — v. We have to prove that / = 0. Note that fe C(B), / = 0 on 5, and (1) holds with / in place of w, since Poisson integrals have the invariant mean value property. Assume / > 0 at some point of B, let E be the set of all z G B at which / attains its maximum. Then £ is a compact subset of B, and E therefore contains a point z which is nearest to S. The integral (1) (with / in place of u) is an average of/ over the boundary of an ellipsoid around z; this boundary cannot lie in E; the integral is therefore smaller than /(z). This contradiction proves the theorem. 4.3.5. Theorem. To every r (0 < r < 1) correspond infinitely many 2 e C such that
u(2)= L((pM))d
4.4. Pluriharmonic Functions
59
Proof. Fix w E B with | w | = r. By Theorem 4.2.4, it is enough to show that 9(tM = 1 for infinitely many a G C. Put F(a) = gfa(w) — 1. The definition of g^ (Theorem 4.2.2) shows that JF is an entire function of order 1. Since ^i-a = ^a, we have F(a) = F(l — a). If G(X) = F(i -h A), it follows that G is even, and therefore G(X) = i/(>l^), where if is an entire function of order j . Since F(a) grows exponentially as a ^ 00 through positive values, H is not a polynomial, and Hadamard's factorization theorem (Titchmarsh [1], Theorem 8.24) shows that H has infinitely many zeros in C. The same is then true of F.
4.4. Pluriharmonic Functions 4.4.1. Definitions. Let Q be open in C . A function u e C^(Q) is said to be pluriharmonic if it satisfies the n^ differential equations (1)
DjD,u = Q
a,fc=l,...,n).
The class of all real parts of holomorphic functions in Q will be denoted by JRP(Q). 4.4.2. Remarks, (a) If / 6 H(n) then D^ / = 0 and Djf = 0. Hence / and / are pluriharmonic. So i s / -h /. Every u e RP is thus pluriharmonic. (b) By Theorem 4.1.3(ii), every pluriharmonic w in B satisfies AM = 0. The pluriharmonic functions in B are thus M-harmonic as well as {trivially) harmonic. (c) If M e C\n\ aeQ,beC\ put ^a,bW = «(« + ^b) for all A 6 C for which a + /Ife G Q. As we saw in §1.3.4, u is then pluriharmonic in Q if and only if every Ua^^ is harmonic. Theorem 4.4.9 will show that (a) and (b) have converses. But first we present a recent result of Forelli which is related to (c) but uses far fewer complex lines. 4.4.3. Definitions. A complex function M, defined in a neighborhood of the origin in C", is said to be of class C°^({0}) if there corresponds to every positive integer k a neighborhood of 0 in which u is of class CK A set £ c: C" is said to be balanced ii XzeE whenever z 6 £, >l e C, and iA|
60
4. The Invariant Laplacian
4.4.4. Theorem (Forelli [7]). Let Q be a balanced region in C . Suppose u:Q-^R has the following properties: (a) (b)
M6C-({0}). For every zeQ the slice function u^ is harmonic in the disc {AG C: AZGQ}.
Then u e RP(Q). Note that the continuity of M in Q is not part of the hypothesis, nor is it even assumed that u is bounded on compact subsets of Q. Proof. By (b), every u^ is harmonic in a neighborhood of the closed unit disc U in C. Hence there corresponds to every z G Q a sequence of coefficients Fk(z) such that (1)
u{re''z)=
f; Fj.izy^^e''^' k=-ao
for Q < r < 1, 0 < 0 < 271. The series converges absolutely. In particular, (2)
f;|F,(2)|<« - 00
(zeQ).
f(z) = tUz)
(ZGQ).
Define (3)
k=i
Then (4)
(ZGQ)
u(z) = u(0)+f(z)+W)
and (1) implies, for XeU, fie U, that f F,(Xz)fi' = fiXfiz) = f n(z)AV. Jk=l
k=l
Consequently, for z e Q, | /I | < 1, /c = 1, 2, 3 , . . . , (5)
F,(Xz) = X'F,(z). Another consequence of (1) is
(6)
F,iz) = ~j'' F^iz) ~ \ uie">z)e «(e'«z)e-'*V0.
4.4. Pluriharmonic Functions
61
Now consider a fixed positive integer k. By (a), there is a ball, centered at 0, in which u e C^. By (6), Fj, e C^ in this ball. In particular, Fj, is bounded there, and hence (5) implies that Fj^z) = 0( | z |^) as z ^ 0. The Taylor expansion of Ffe thus has the simple form (7)
F,(z)=
X P,Xz) + r+s=k
\zh(z)
where Prs(z) has total degree r in the variables Z j , . . . , z„, total degree s in Z i , . . . , z„, and y(z) ^ 0 as z -^ 0. If we combine (5) and (7), we see that (8)
Z A'AT„(z) + |Az|*y(Az) r+s=k
is equal to (9)
Z X'P,,(z)-^
2.'\zMz),
r+s=k
When A > 0, the two sums are equal, so that y(Xz) = y(z). Letting /I -^ 0, we see that 7 = 0. The two sums in (8) and (9) are thus equal for all XeU. Hence Prs(z) = 0 except when r = k, s = 0. Returning to (7), we have now proved that Fj, is a homogeneous (holomorphic) polynomial of degree k. By (2) and (3), Theorem 1.5.6 tells us now that f€H(Q). By (4), this completes the proof. 4.4.5. Theorem. Let Q be a balanced region in C , and suppose f:Q. -^ C satisfies (a) /GC-({0}),aMrf (b) all slice functions fz are holomorphic. ThenfeHiQ). Proof, Forelli's theorem applies to w = Re / , and shows that there exists F e H(Q) such that w = Re F. For each zeQ, F^ — f^ is holomorphic, pure imaginary, hence equal to a constant c(z). But c(z) = F , ( 0 ) - / , ( 0 ) = P ( 0 ) - / ( 0 ) , independent of z. Thus f = c + F. This characterization of H(Q) leads to a very simple formulation and proof of a theorem concerning removable singularities (Theorem 4.4.7).
62
4. The Invariant Laplacian
4.4.6. Definition. Let Q be a region in C". A (relatively) closed subset EofQ is said to be H"^-removable in Q if every bounded/e H(Q\E) has an extension FeH{Q). For example, when n = 1, then every discrete set £ <= Q is H°°-removable. The same is true if the 1-dimensional Hausdorff measure of £ is 0. (AhlforsBeurling [1].) Let us say that E is Udimensionally H"^-removable in Q if (informally) L n £ is //*-removable in L n Q, for every complex Une L that contains a point of Q\E, More precisely: If a e Q \ £ , b e C , V= {XGC:a + XbeQ}, and VQ is the component of V that contains 0, then {keVo:a-\-
XbeE}
is to be if°°-removable in VQ. 4.4.7. Theorem. IfE is a relatively closed subset of a region Q cz C", and if E is \-dimensionally H"^-removable in Q, then E is H"^-removable in Q. Proof, Let fsH'^^^XE), Pick w e £. Since E has empty interior, w lies in a ball p -h rB c: Q, with p4 E. Let p = 0, without loss of generality. Our hypothesis on E says then that every slice function /^ (with z G rS) extends to a holomorphic function in U, This extends / to a function in rB which, by Theorem 4.4.5, is holomorphic in rB. A neighborhood of w has thus been removed from the set of singularities of / . Continuing in this way, all of E can be wiped out. The following special case is a standard result that is frequently encountered: Corollary. / / Q is a region in C , g e H(Q),'g ^ 0, and E = {zeQ:giz)
= 0}
then E is H"^-removable in Q. Proof. If a G Q, g{a) ^0,be
C , and Fand VQ are as in Definition 4.4.6, then {XeVo:g(a + ?ib) = 0}
is a discrete subset of VQ. Hence E is 1-dimensionally ff°°-removable in Q, and the corollary follows from the theorem.
4.4. Pluriharmonic Functions
63
4.4.8. Let Q again be a balanced region in C", and suppose/ e C^(Q). Forelli's theorem asserts then that if/ satisfies the smoothness condition (1)
/eC-({0})
as well as the differential equation (2)
t
ZjUDjD,f)(z)
=0
(ZEQI
then / is pluriharmonic in Q. Thus, in the presence of (1), the single equation (2) implies that the n^ equations DjDj^f = 0 hold. Similarly, Theorem 4.4.5 asserts that feH(Q) provided that / satisfies (1) and (3)
tuDuf)(z)
=0
(zeQ).
k=l
It is a very curious fact that these results fail completely if the assumption (1) is replaced by the existence of any finite number of derivatives in a neighborhood of 0, even if/is assumed to be real-analytic in the complement of the origin. To see a simple example of this phenomenon, fix n > 1, let p > 2 be an integer, and define / on C" by (4)
/(z)=|zr^zf^%
(z#0),
and /(O) = 0. Then fe C^(C"), / is real-analytic except at 0, and all sUce functions/^ are entire; in fact (5)
LW = /(Az) = f(z)XP^'
(z 6 C", A e C).
Thus / satisfies equations (2) and (3). Nevertheless, / is not even a harmonic function of Z2 (for fixed z^ ¥" 0), since / ^ 0 as Z2 -* oo. Multiplication of (4) by suitable functions that are constant on each slice (except at 0) leads to solutions of (2) and (3) that are in ^ ( C " ) but are not real-analytic anywhere. 4.4.9. Theorem. If a function u\ B -^ R has one of the following five properties, then it has the other four. (a) (b) (c) (d) (e)
ueRP(B), u is pluriharmonic in B. Aw = 0 and AM = 0 in B. u G C*({0}) and u^ is harmonic in U,for every C G 5. uoij/ is harmonic in B,for every ij/ e Aut(B).
64
4. The Invariant Laplacian
Proof. The implications (a) -^ (b) -^ (c) were noted in §4.4.2. That (c) -> (d) follows from Theorem 4.1.3(iii), and Theorem 4.4.4 shows that (d) -> (a). It is trivial that (a) -> (e). If (e) holds, then (Au)(a) = A(uocpJ(0) = 0 for all aeB, since uocp^ is harmonic. Thus (e) -^ (c), and the proof is complete. The implications (e) -»(a) and (c) -> (a) occur in Nagel-Rudin [1], p. 865, and in Rudin [10], respectively. As is clear from the above proof, ForelH's theorem is now the only nontrivial step in these equivalences. If B is replaced by any region Q ci C", the implication (b) -> (a) holds in every ball in Q, hence it holds globally whenever Q is simply connected. We conclude this section by clarifying a remark made prior to the proof of Theorem 4.3.3, to the effect that dilates of ^-harmonic functions need not be ^-harmonic: 4.4.10. Theorem. Iff is Ji-harmonic in B and if there is one r, 0 < r < 1, such thatf is also M-harmonic in B, then f is pluriharmonic in B. Proof. Put g{z) = /(rz), for zeB. Since A/ = 0 and A^ = 0, both / and g are solutions of the equation (Aw)(z) = (AwJ(l), by 4.1.3(iii). Since gX^) = frzW, it follows that 0 = iAg)(z) - (Ag,)(l) = r^(A/)(rz) - ( A / J ( l ) = - ( 1 - r^)(A/)(rz). Thus A/ = 0 in rB. Being ^-harmonic, / is real-analytic in B (Theorem 4.2.5), hence so is A/, and it follows that A/ = 0 in all ofB. Thus/has property (c) of Theorem 4.4.9.
Chapter 5
Boundary Behavior of Poisson Integrals
The principal result of the present chapter is Koranyi's Theorem 5.4.5—the fact that certain maximal functions associated to invariant Poisson integrals are of weak type (1, 1). The existence of what we call "K-Hmits" at almost all points of S follows easily from this. The chapter begins with the definition of a certain '^-invariant metric and the associated maximal function Mjn of a measure /a on S. The corresponding maximal theorem 5.2.4 is true for many other choices of metrics. As the proof will show, the finiteness of the constant A^ in Lemma 5.2.3 is basically all- that is needed. The reason for the particular choice made is that Mjx dominates Plfi] in a way that Theorem 5.4.5 makes precise. The chapter contains some appUcations to holomorphic functions that do not depend on the more dehcate theorems concerning the boundary behavior of Cauchy integrals. The latter will be studied in Chapter 6.
5.1. A Nonisotropic Metric on S 5.1.1. Definitions. For
aeB,beB,
(1)
d(a,b)=\l-(a,b}\'^\ For C e 5, 5 > 0,
(2)
Q(i:,d) =
{rieS:d(i:,rj)
Note the ^-invariance: for every U e^, (3)
d(Ua, Ub) = d(a, b\
UQ(C, S) = Q(UC, S).
The letter Q will always denote a "ball" Q(C, S). Occasionally, when the "center" C is of no particular importance, we shall write Q^ in place of g(C, <5). If Q and Q' are balls with the same center C but with "radii" d and 65
66
5. Boundary Behavior of Poisson Integrals
td, we shall sometimes write Q' = tQ. Mathematically, this notation makes little sense, but it is quite convenient. Note that Qs = S when 6 > ^/l. Throughout this chapter, the letter A will denote a positive finite constant that depends only on the dimension n. Any dependence on other parameters will be explicitly indicated. 5.1.2. Proposition, (i) The triangle inequality d(a, c) < d(a, b) + d(b, c) holds for all a,b,ce B. (ii) On S, d is a metric; the sets Q{C, ^) cire the corresponding balls. Proof. Since d is ^-invariant, one may take b = rei(0 < r < l\ and one then has to prove that (1)
|i_|<{|l-ra,|i/^ +11-rcji'^^ Put a = a — a^Ci, c = c — c^e^. The left side of (1) is then |1 - aiCi - | < |1 - a^Cil + \a'\\c'\.
Since 11 - aiCi I = 11 - rfli + ai(r - Ci)\ < \1 - ra^\-\-\1 - rc^l and k T < 1 - kil'< 1 - | r a i P < 2 | l -rail, with a similar estimate for |c'P, (1) holds. This proves (i), and (ii) is an immediate consequence, since (on 5), diC, f/) = 0 if and only if C = rj. (This fails in 5 : if |a| < 1 then d(a, a) > 0.) Note: When n = 1, our metric d is the square root of the eucHdean metric of the unit circle as a subset of the plane. 5.1.3. Let Qg = Q(^i, 3), for small 5. Then Qs is close to being a (2n — 1)dimensional ellipsoid (hence the term "nonisotropic" for our metric): Recall that C^Qs provided that |1 - Cil < ^^. In the yj-direction (i.e., if C = Ci^iJ ICil = 1) the "thickness" (in the euclidean metric) of Q^ is thus about S\ But if Ci = 1 - S\ then
5.2. The Maximal Function of a Measure on S
67
SO that C' ranges over a (2n — 2)-dimensional ball of radius about l^^^S, which is much larger than 3^. This indicates that (7(Qs) is roughly proportional to 3^. 3^""^ = ^^", where 3 is small. We shall now prove this conclusion by an accurate computation, instead of relying on the imprecise argument which led to it. 5.1.4. Proposition. When n > I, the ratio (j{Q^I3^'' increases from 2~" to a finite limit A^as 3 decreases from ^Jl to 0. When n = 1, this ratio decreases from \ to IIn. Proof. The case n = 1 is elementary. When n > 1, apply formula 1.4.5(2) to the characteristic function of 2(^i, 3\ to get
^(&) = ^ ^ ^ f (l-|Ap)"-2^m2(A) where E{3) = {A:|A| < 1 and |1 — /l| < 3^}. The change of variables 1 — A = (5^/z turns this into
^
= !Lzi r 0
n
(2x-3^y-^\z\-^^dxdy
JE'{3)
where E'(3) = {z = x -{- iy:2x > 3^ and |z| > 1}. As ^ decreases, both the integrand and the domain of integration increase. The monotone convergence theorem shows therefore that the hmit O{(T(Q^)/3^", as ^ ^ 0, exists and equals 1)2""^
Ao = -
n
/'OO
Ji
J
^
/.71/2
J-K/2
This proves the proposition. Computation of these integrals gives the more explicit result jrjn + 1) ^ o = f;27
n(n/2 + 1)
5.2. The Maximal Function of a Measure on S 5.2.1. Terminology and Notation. If/< is a complex measure on 5 ("measure " will always mean "Borel measure") then, as usual, (i) (ii)
I ju I is the total variation measure of fi, M = \ti\iS),
68
5. Boundary Behavior of Poisson Integrals
(iii) jii < (T means that fi is absolutely continuous with respect to cr, i.e., that fi(E) = 0 for every Borel set £ c S with (T(E) = 0, and (iv) ju J_ (T means that jii is singular with respect to a, i.e., that there is a Borel set £ cz 5 with (j(E) = 0, |/x|(E) = ||/x||. We recall the theorem of Lebesgue and Radon-Nikodym: dfi = f da + d^s^ uniquely, with / e L^(cr), /x^ 1 cr. 5.2.2. Definition. The maximal function of a complex measure // on 5 is the function M/i: S ^ [0, oo] defined by (Miu)(0 = sup
-——.
Note that M/i = M|/i|. For each fixed 5 > 0, the above quotient is easily seen to be a lower semicontinuous function of C- Hence M/x is lower semicontinuous. The proof of Theorem 5.2.4 will use the following simple covering lemma, that involves the constant
.
^(36)
^3 = s u p - — - . Proposition 5.1.4 implies that ^3 < oc. 5.2.3. Lemma. IfE is the union of a finite collection O of halls Q <^ S, then ^ has a disjoint subcollection F such that
(1)
£ c U 36 r
and
(2)
<E)
Proof Order the members Qi = Q(Ci, 3i) of 0) so that di > ^, + 1. Put i^ = 1. Suppose /c > 1 and ij, is chosen. If Qi^ intersects Qi for every / > f^, stop. If not, let ifc+i be the first index such that Q^^^^ is disjoint from g^^. Since O is finite, this process stops, say at /c = m. Put F = {Q^^,..., Q,-^}. To every Qi-eO corresponds some /c such that i^ < i < ik+i (except when i > fc^, since there is no im+i)- Since Si < Sf^ and Q,- intersects g;^, we have gj c: 3Qi^. This proves (1), and (2) follows from (1) and the definition of^3.
5.2. The Maximal Function of a Measure on S
5.2.4. Theorem. Iffiisa (1)
69
complex measure on 5, then (T{M//>r}< ^3^"'11/^11
for every t > 0, The left side of (1) replaces the more cumbersome (2)
<7({Ce5:(M/i)(0>t}).
We shall often simplify notation in this way. Proof. Fix fi and t. Let K he 2i compact subset of the open set {M/i > t}. Each C e X is the center of a ball Q such that | /x(Q) | > to-(Q). Some finite collection O of these g's covers K. If F is as in Lemma 5.2.3, then
A.t-'M,
The disjointness of F was used in the last inequality. Now (1) follows by taking the supremum over all compact K c: {Mja > t}. 5.2.5. Weak L\ Iffe L\a) and t > 0, then the inequality (1)
<^{\f\>t}
is obvious (and holds equally well for any positive measure in place of a). Any measurable function / such that (2)
t(j{\f\>t}
is a bounded function of t on (0, oo) is said to belong to weak L^((T). Every / G L^(G) can be identified with the absolutely continuous measure fdcF. Its maximal function Mf is thus, in accordance with Definition 5.2.2, given by (3)
(M/)(0 = s u p - i - f
\f\d<7.
Theorem 5.2.4 (restricted to L^) can now be restated by saying that the "maximal operator" M sends L^{(T) to weak L^((T), with constant A^, i.e., that M is "of weak type (1, 1)" in the customary terminology. Since M is subadditive (M(f + g) < Mf + Mg) and since the inequaHty ||M/||oo < II / II ^ is trivial, the following L^ result is a consequence of the Marcinkiewicz interpolation theorem (Section 5.7):
70
5. Boundary Behavior of Poisson Integrals
5.2.6. Theorem. For I < p < GO there are constants A(p) < oo such that ( \Mf\^ da < A(p) {\f\'dG Js Js for every f € LF{o). 5.2.1. Theorem. If fi^ is the singular part of fi and if E = {Mfi < oo}, then IfisKE) = 0. In other words, fi^ is concentrated on the set {M/x = oo}. Proof. If Et = {Mfi < t} then £ = U£(, and it is enough to prove that I fis I (Ef) = 0 for every positive integer t. This, in turn, follows once we show that fi(K) = 0 for every compact K a E^ with a{K) = 0. Fix such a K. Choose £ > 0. There is an open set Q ZD K, having (T(Q) < e. There is a finite collection O of balls Q cz Q, with centers in K, whose union covers K. Choose F as in Lemma 5.2.3. If g e F, then 3Q is a ball with center in X cz £^, so that | A* 1(3(2) < tcr(3g). Lemma 5.2.3 implies therefore that \f^\(K) < X \fi\(3Q) < t X (J(3Q) < ^3? Z ^(Q) < A,tG(n) < A,ts r r r by the disjointness of F. Thus \fi\(K) = 0.
5.3. Diflferentiation of Measures on S Theorem 5.2.4 gives easy access to differentiation theorems. We shall deal separately with the absolutely continuous case and with the singular case. 5.3.1. Theorem. IffeL\o) (1)
then
li^^T^f
l/-/(OM^ = 0
for almost every C^S. Hence (2)
/(0=lim-i-f
fda
(a.e.)
Note: The points C for which (1) holds are called the Lebesgue points of / . If £ c: S is measurable and / is the characteristic function of E, then every point of E that is a Lebesgue point of / is called a point of density of E. The theorem implies that almost all points of E are points of density of E.
5.3. Differentiation of Measures on S
71
Proof. Define T / Q to be the left side of (1), but with Um sup in place of lim. Choose t > 0and e > 0. Chooseg e C(S) with \\f - g\\i < £• Put h = f - g. Then (i) (ii) (iii)
7} < T, + r „ Tg = 0 since g is continuous, and T, < |/i| -f M/i.
Thus Tf <\h\ -\- Mh, so that {Tf > t} is a subset of
By Theorem 5.2.4, and 5.2.5(1), (T(E,)
<
Arh.
Since a was arbitrary, {77'> r} is a subset of Borel sets of arbitrarily small measure. Thus o{Tf> ?} = 0 for every t > 0. This implies that (Tf)(0 = 0 (a.e.). Corollary. IffeL^{G)
then | / ( 0 | < (Mf)(C) at every Lebesgue point off.
This follows directly from (2). 5.3.2. Theorem. If ^ is a complex measure on S and ft A- a, then (1)
lim^(e(C,(5)) = 0
(a.e.M).
Proof. Assume |i > 0, with loss of generality. Pick r > 0, £ > 0. There is a decomposition/I = /^i + )U2, where/i^ is the restriction of/i to some compact K with G{K) = 0, and II/X2II < e. Write (^/i)(0 for the Hmit in (1), and {S)iJi)(X) for the corresponding lim sup. Off K, Q)fx^ = 0, hence ^jU = ^/i2- Thus X u {^/z > t) = KKJ {9ii2 > t} cz Ku {Mfi2 > t}, and (J of this last set is at most A^t-'\\fi2\\
by Theorem 5.2.4. Letting e -^ 0, it follows that a{^fi > t} =0 for every r > 0. Letting t -^ 0, we see that ^JJ. = 0 a.e. [cr].
72
5. Boundary Behavior of Poisson Integrals
5.3.3. The two preceding theorems can be combined: If fi is any complex Borel measure on S, then its derivative (^/i)(0 = lim^((2(C,(5)) exists a.e. [ a ] ; ifdfi = fdo + d^^ is the Lebesgue decomposition offi, then
i^fiXO = m
(a.e. M).
5.4. X-Limits of Poisson Integrals 5.4.1. Approach Regions. For a > 1 and C e S, we let DJiJi) be the set of all zeV such that
(1)
|i-aC>l<|(l-UP).
It is clear that D^CQ <= B. When a < 1, (1) defines the empty set. As a -> oo, the regions DJ^QfillB, for every fixed (,sS. Note that every Ue^ permutes the D^'s: the relation (2)
V{DM)) = D^(UO
follows obviously from (1). [The notational similarity between the regions D^O and the differential operators D" should cause no confusion.] In one variable, the classical theorem of Fatou states that Poisson integrals of measures on the unit circle have nontangential limits almost everywhere. The theorem extends, with the same proof, to harmonic functions in balls in R^, where "nontangential" means approach within a cone. However, Koranyi [2] proved that the invariant Poisson integrals in B have Hmits at almost all C G S, as z approaches C within any DJ^CX although—and this is the remarkable point—approach to C within D^{Q is not restricted to be nontangential when n > 1. To examine the shape of DJ^O more closely, let us take C = ^i [by (2), this involves no loss of generahty] and write /)« in place of D^Cei). Thus zeD^if and only if
(3)
\i-z,\<^(i-\zn
5.4. ^-Limits of Poisson Integrals
73
The intersection of D^ with the complex line through 0 and ei is the famihar angular region (4)
|l-zi|<|(l-|zj^)
in the unit disc. However, the intersection of D^ with the copy of i?^""^ obtained by setting y^ = 0 in (3) is the ball
(5)
(^-^y + l^'l^<0-^y'
where z' = ( z 2 , . . . , z„). This ball is tangent to S 3.t e^. Although they are not really needed for the boundary theorems that are our present concern, this is a natural place to introduce the so-called complex tangents. They will play an important role later on. 5.4.2. Complex Tangent Spaces. Any point z = (z^, . . . , z„) e C" is also a point of R^", and can thus be written in the form (1)
z =
(xuyw'-^^n.yn)
where Zj, = Xk + iyj,. Note that then (2)
iz= ( - ) ; i , x i , . . . ,
-y„,x„).
If w = ( w i , . . . , w„), Wfe = Mfc + iVk, then, in addition to the Hilbert space inner product
(3)
Z'W = Y^i^k^k + yk^k)
on i^^". The two are related by (4)
Z'W = Re
Thus (5)
z • (iw) = — (iz)' w.
In particular, w • (iw) = 0. Let Y now be an K-subspace of C" = R^", of real codimension 1, Pick w 6 C", \w\ = 1, perpendicular to Y, i.e., w • z = 0 for all z e 7. Let YQ be the set of all z E Y that are perpendicular to both w and iw. It follows from (5) that YQ is a C-subspace of C", of complex codimension L
74
5. Boundary Behavior of Poisson Integrals
This maximal C-subspace YQ of Y could also have been defined by YQ =
Yn(iY).
Now let C^S. The tangent space T^ = TJCS') to iS at C consists then of all vectors w e C" that are perpendicular to the radius of B which ends at CThus w G T^ if and only if w • C = 0. The complex tangent space Tf is defined to be T^ n (iT^), ^^^ consists of all w that satisfy <w, C> = 0. The preceding discussion shows that the vector iC lies in T^ but that iC is perpendicular to Tf. To return to our regions D^(C), they are tangential to S in the direction of Tf. In formula 5.4.1(1), the left side is the euclidean distance from z to the affine set C + Tf; the easiest way to see this is to refer to 5.4.1(3). The right side is essentially proportional to 1 — | z |, the euclidean distance from z to S. This interpretation of 5.4.1(1) suggests generalizations which led E. M. Stein [2] to extend Koranyi's theorem to a much wider class of regions. When n = 1, this discussion is vacuous, since {0} is then the only complex subspace of codimension 1. 5.4.3. Lemma. Ifrj G S, C ^ S, z e DJ£), |z| = r, then (1)
|l-
and (2)
P(z,^)<
[32a^(l - r)Y 1-
Proof. 11 -
^)d(z,
<J~^d{z,rj).
rj).
This gives (1), since a > 1. The estimate (2) follows from (1) and the definition of the Poisson kernel. 5.4.4. Definition. If F G C(B) and a > 1, the maximal function M^F: S -^ [0, oo] is defined by (1)
(M,T)(0 = sup{|F(z)|:zGD,(0}.
Note that {M^F < t} is closed in S, for every real t, since F is continuous. Thus M„F is lower semicontinuous.
5.4. A^-Limits of Poisson Integrals
75
5.4.5. Theorem (Koranyi [2]). To every a > 1 corresponds a constant A(oc) < 00 such that the inequality (1)
M , P M < Aia)Mfi
holds for every complex measure fi on S. In conjunction with Therem 5.2.4 this says that the map fi -^ carries measures into weak L^
M^P[^]LL]
Proof. Since Mfi = M\in\ and \P[JLL]\ < P[liU|], it is enough to prove (1) for positive JLL. We shall work at the point Ci, and assume (M/i)(^i) = 1. By 5.1.4 there is a constant ^o < ^ such that (T(QS) < AQS^" for all ^ > 0. (When n = 1, replace AQ by ^.) We shall prove that (2)
PM(z)<2^o(16a)"
for every z e DJ^Ci). This estabhshes (1), with the right side of (2) for ^(a). Fix z G D^Ci), put r = |z|, put t = 8a(l — r), define (3)
Vo = {ajeS:\l
(4)
F, = {o)eS\2^-h<
- co,\ < t}, |1 - c o j < 2^t},
for /c = 1, 2 , . . . , until 2^ > 2. Since (M/i)(^i) = 1, (5)
M H ) < ^0(2^^0"
(/c = 0,1,2,...).
Decompose P[ju] (z) into a sum
(6)
fp(z,a))rfM«)= f + 1 f .
•^S
•/Fo
fc>l
^Fk
For any coeS, P(z, co) < 2^(1 - r)~". Thus (5), with k = 0, shows that (7)
j ^ ^ ^ X o ( ^ ) " = ^o(16a)". When A: > 1 and coeV^, Lemma 5.4.3 gives
76
5. Boundary Behavior of Poisson Integrals
by (4). Hence (5) implies that (9)
f
(/c = 1, 2, 3,...).
The inequalities (9), added to (7), give (2). 5.4.6. /^-Limits. Suppose C e S, Q is open in B, and to every a > 1 corresponds an r < 1 such that (1)
{|z|>r}nD,(Oc:Q.
(Q = Bis the simplest and most important example.) We say that a function F : Q ^ C has X-limit X at C, and write (2)
(K-\imF)(0
=^
if the following is true: For every a > 1 and for every sequence {Zi} in Da(C) ^ ^ that converges to C, F{zj) -^ /I as i ^ oo. The case X= cois not excluded. But usually we will of course be interested in finite iC-limits. Koranyi [2] used the terms "admissible limit" and "admissible convergence" in this context. The next three theorems are consequences of the maximal theorems 5.4.5 and 5.2.4. 5.4.7. Theorem. If ii is a positive measure on S and if(^fi)(0 C eS, then (1)
= Ofor some
(X-limPM)(O = 0.
Proof. Pick £ > 0. Choose Qo = 6(C, ^o) so that (2)
MG(C, d)) < 8(7(e(C, d))
(0<S<
So).
Let /^o be the restriction of/i to QQ , put //J = JH - IJ,Q. Then P[/ii] has X-limit 0 at C, simply because C is not in the support of //j, and (MjUoXC) ^ £» by (2). Theorem 5.4.5 implies therefore that (3)
Hm sup Plfi] (Zi) < A((x)e
if Zf -• C within DJ^C). This proves (1).
5.4. A^-Limits of Poisson Integrals
5.4.8. Theorem. Iffs
77
L\G) then
(K.limP[/])(0=/(0 at every Lebesgue point C off. Proof. Fix such a C and apply Theorem 5.4.7 to the measure fi defined for all Borel sets E a Shy
KE)= f
\f-f(0\dc7.
5.4.9. Theorem. Ifjuisa complex measure on S, then ( / : - l i m P M ) ( 0 = (^/i)(0
a.e.[(T].
Proof. Let dji = fdo + d^^ be the Lebesgue decomposition of//. By Theorems 5.4.8 and 5.3.3, it is enough to show that P[iuJ has iC-limit 0 a.e. [o]. Since IjuJ i. (7, this follows from 5.3.2 and 5.4.7. 5.4.10. Theorem. 7/^1 < p < oo andfe U{a), then \\M^PU^\'
da < A{oi,p) ^\f\^
da.
Proof. Combine Theorems 5.4.5 and 5.2.6. (The measurability of M^F was estabhshed in §5.4.4, for any F e C(B).) 5.4.11. The Radial Maximal Function. For any F: ^ -^ C, define (1)
(MradF)(0=sup|F(rO|. 0
Since rC e DJ^O for 0 < r < 1 if a > 2, Theorem 5.4.5 implies that (2)
MradPM < AMfi.
For positive measures, the opposite inequahty holds too: 5.4.12. Theorem. Iffi is a positive measure on S, then (1)
Mfi < 9''MradPM.
Consequently, if // > 0 and one of Mja, Mrad^M, M ^ P M is finite at some C G iS, so are the others.
78
5. Boundary Behavior of Poisson Integrals
Proof. For 0 < d < yjl, let r = 1 — \b^. To cover the point —e^, we work with the closed balls g(^i, b\ If C e g(^i, b\ then 11 - Ci I < 2(1 - r\ hence 11 — rCi | < 3(1 — r), so that
by Proposition 5.1.4. It follows that ( - ) ( e ( e i , S)) < 9"PM(rci) < 9"M„<,PM(ei). This proves (1) at the point ^ j . The same estimate holds at every other point of 5. 5.4.13. Examples. When « = 1, it is a classical fact that P[/i](r^'®) -^ (^fi)(e'^) at every point of T where the symmetric derivative ^fi exists. Theorem 5.4.9 shows, for arbitrary n, that this Umit relation still holds for almost all C e S. But, as we shall now see, the result can fail at individual points. In the first two examples that follow we shall take n = 2, The first example gives a positive measure fi on S with (^fi)(ei) = 2 but lim,^iP[ju](rei) = 4. We define fx by requiring that
jfdfi=j^f(e'^0)\smQ\d6 for e v e r y / e C(S). If 0 < x < 1, CG C, \c\ < 1, then (1 - I c 1^)^(1 - x " ) ^ | s i n ^ | |1 -xe'^l^ = 4 ( l - | c p2\2 ) With c = 0 this gives 4 for the radial limit. We see also that P^jx] has no K-limit at e^. Next, Me(ei,<5))~
Isinei^e-^^
whereas (T{Q(ei, 3)) ^ ^3"^. (When n = 2, the computation used in the proof of Proposition 5.1.4 can be replaced by a direct estimate of the first integral that occurs in that proof.) Thus (^fi)(ei) = 2.
5.5. Theorems of Calderon, Privalov, Plessner
79
Our second example gives a real measure fi on S, with (^fi)(ei) = 0 but Urn sup P M ( r e i ) = oo. Choose mfc > 0, 0 < ffc < 1, for /c = 1, 2, 3 , . . . , so that ^ m^t < oo but mj(l — tkY -^ 00. Choose 0^ so that 11 — e'^^\ = 1 — r^. Let ja be the sum of the point masses nik at
(e'\OX
-m^
at
fe,^!
- ti).
Then fi{Q{ei, 3)) = 0 for every 5 > 0, hence (^fj)(ei) = 0. Next,
For 0 < r < 1, each term in this sum is positive. When r = t^, thefethterm is (2tt + tl)m^
(1 - tlf which tends to oo as /c -> oo. The proof of Theorem 5.4.5 shows that the constant ^(a) is at most AoiP. Our third example shows that this is the correct order of magnitude^ as far as its dependence on OL is concerned. Let /z be the unit point mass at e^. Then P M ( z ) = P{z, Ci). Pick (,eS, with 0
> A-^a"(M/i)(0.
5.5. Theorems of Calderon, Privalov, Plessner This section extends two classical theorems of Privalov [1] and Plessner [1], concerning the nontangential behavior of harmonic and holomorphic functions' in the unit disc, to analogous theorems about ^-harmonic and holomorphic functions in the approach regions DJ^Q. (Theorems 5.5.7 and 5.5.8.) Their first extension to several variables was made by Calderon [1]—to harmonic and holomorphic functions in half spaces and their behavior on cones with vertices on the boundary. The material of the present section is directly based on Calderon's ideas, although many details are different.
80
5. Boundary Behavior of Poisson Integrals
5.5.1. Definition. If E cz S and a > 1, then Q(£,a) = U ^ a ( 0 . For any set E, XE denotes its characteristic function: XEM = 1 if X G £, 0 if x^E. 5.5.2. Lemma. If E a S, a{E) = m < 1, and a > 1, there is a constant c = c(a, m) > 0 such that P{IS\E'\{Z)>C
for every z outside Q(E, a). Proof. Put V = S\E, f=Xv' Pick ZEB,Z^ Q(E, a). Without loss of generality, z = rci, 0 < r < 1. If r < 1/a, a trivial lower bound for the Poisson kernel shows that
(1)
pum > (|^,)"'^(^) ^ (^)"(i - '")•
So assume 1/a < r < 1. Let (^^ e Aut(B) be as in §2.2. L Then / o (^^ is the characteristic function of (pjy), and the ^-invariance of Poisson integrals (Theorem 3.3.8) implies that (2)
P [ / ] (z) = P [ / o (pJ(0) = f ( / o (^JrftT = G{cp,{V)). Js Put G„ = {^ 6 5:1 + 1/a < 11 - f^i I < 2}. Pick rjeGo,, put C = ^PzC'?)- Since r > 1/a, |1 -rf],\>
2 |1 - ^ / i l - ( 1 - r ) > - . a
The definition of (p^C^) implies therefore that
Thus z = r^i G D^(C). Since z ^ Q(£, a), C e K We have shown that (pXGJ ^ V. Hence G« c (^^(F), (7((p^(F)) > (T(GJ > 0, so that (2) yields
(3)
n/](z)>a(Gj
('-^)-
5.5. Theorems of Calderon, Privalov, Plessner
81
The lemma follows from (1) and (3). 5.5.3. Lemma. Suppose E a S is measurable, C is a point of density of E, a > 1, jS > 1. Then there exists r = r(E, C, a, jS) < 1 such that {\z\>r}nDf,(O^Q(E,oc). (The interesting case is jS > a.) Proof. Without loss of generality, a(E) < 1. By Theorem 5.4.8, the Poisson integral in Lemma 5.5.2 has X-limit 0 at C- Since this integral is > c outside Q(£, a), it follows that every sequence {zj that converges to C within Dp(C) must eventually be in Q(£, a). 5.5.4. Lemma. Fix r, 0 < r < 1. Every g e C{rS) extends then to a function G e C(rB) that satisfies AG = 0 in rB. Every uniformly bounded collection of these G's is equicontinuous on every compact subset ofrB. (The first part of the lemma asserts the solvability of a certain Dirichlet problem.) Proof Let ju be a complex measure on S that satisfies
(1)
[PUWOdKO = 0
for every / G C(S). By Fubini's theorem, (2)
jpifi](rcD)f(co)dc7(co) = 0
for every / . Thus P[//] = 0 on rS, hence in rB (by the maximum principle for ^-harmonic functions), hence in B by real-analyticity. Thus ju = 0, by Theorem 3.3.4(d). It follows now from the Hahn-Banach theorem that there is a sequence {y;.} c C(S) whose Poisson integrals converge to g, uniformly on rS. By the maximum principle, {P^fi]} converges uniformly on rB to GeC(rE). If z e rB and t > 0 is so small that (pJitB) cz rB, then G inherits the mean value property (3)
Giz)=
{Giq>M))d(^i.Q Js
from Plfi]. To finish the proof, confine z to a compact set K c: rB, let T be the invariant measure of Theorem 2.2.6, and pick h e C°^(B) whose support
82
5. Boundary Behavior of Poisson Integrals
is a very small neighborhood of 0, such that j^hdr (4)
= 1. Then (3) implies
G(z) = {(Go (p^)hdx = f (/io (p^)G dx. JB
JB
The last integral shows that GeC'^(K); by Theorem 4.1.3(i), (3) implies now that (AG)(z) = 0. The equicontinuity assertion follows from the representation of G by the last integral in (4). 5.5.5. Theorem. Suppose E cz S is measurable, a > 1, and u is a bounded function in Q(£, a) such that Au = 0. Then u has K-limits at almost every point ofE. [Although it is not obvious that Q(£, a) satisfies the geometric condition that is needed before it makes sense to talk about X-limits at points of E, Lemma 5.5.3 shows that the condition does in fact hold at every point of density of £.] Proof. Suppose 0 < w < 1, without loss of generahty. If we replace a by a sUghtly smaller value, and write Q for Q(£, a), then u is continuous onQn B, hence u extends to a continuous function on B, with 0 < w < 1. Let rj/" 1, rj < r^+i- By Lemma 5.5.4 there are functions QJG C{r^B\ such that Qj = uon rjS, A^j = 0 in rjB, 0 < gj < L By equicontinuity, some subsequence, again denoted by {QJ}, converges uniformly on compact subsets of B, to an ^-harmonic function g in B. Let V be the Poisson integral in Lemma 5.5.2. (We may of course assume, without loss of generahty, that (T(E) < L ) Then v>c>0 on Bn 5Q, and |w — ^jl < 1 in rjB. Also, u — gj = 0 on rjS. Thus (1)
\u~gj\
on ^(Q n rjB). By the maximum principle, (1) holds at every point of Q n rjB. Letting7 ^ 00, it follows that (2)
\u-g\
in
Q.
By Theorems 4.3.3 and 5.4.8, the iC-limit of g exists at almost all points of S. If C is a point of density of E, Theorem 5.4.8 and the definition of v show that V has K-limit 0 at C- Hence (2) implies that u and g have the same iC-limits at almost all points of E. 5.5.6. Definition. A function F: B ^ C is said to be (weakly) ^-bounded at a point C^ S if there exist a > 1, M < 00, such that \F(z)\ < M for every ^eZ),(0. The word "weakly" is to draw attention to the fact that boundedness of F on DJ^O is required only for a single a > 1, whereas every a > 1 is involved in the definition of K-limits.
5.6. The Spaces N(B) and 7/^(5)
83
5.5.7. Theorem. If u is J^-harmonic in B, E is a measurable subset of S, and u is weakly K-bounded at every C ^ E, then (K-\im w)(C) exists for almost all C e £. Proof For i = 1, 2, 3 , , . . , let £, be the set of all C^S such that |M| < i in ^ i + i/i(0- Since u is continuous in B, each Ei is closed. By Theorem 5.5.5, u has K-limits at almost every point of each Ei. Since E <= (J. £., the theorem is proved. 5.5.8. Theorem. Every fe H(B) decomposes S into three measurable sets EK, Ec, Ej^, such that (i)
cT(Ej,) = 0,
(ii) / has finite K-limit at every C^E^, (iii) f(DXO) is dense in C, for every a > 1 and for every C^ Ei^. Proof. Let {Vj} be a countable base of C, consisting of open discs with centers Cj, radii r^. Let E^ be the set of allC^S such that / ( D j + i/i(0) does not intersect Vj. Each Eij is closed, and their union is the complement of EQ. (Thus Ec is a set of type G^.) Now fix (ij) and let Q = Q(£,.y, 1 + 1/0, as in Definition 5.5.L The function^ = l/(f — c^)isholomorphicinQ,and |^| < 1/r^-in Q. By Theorem 5.5.5, g has»iC-hmits ^*(0 at almost all C^Eij. As we shall see presently, 6f*(C) # 0 for almost every C e E^^.. Thus / has finite iC-hmits a.e. in each Eij, hence at almost all points of the complement of EQ . This is what the theorem asserts. If ^*(C) were 0 on a set of positive measure, some slice function ^^ = V(/c ~ ^j) would be a meromorphic function in the unit disc U with nontangential limit 0 on a subset of the unit circle that has positive measure. This forces ^^(A) = 0 for all /I e [/ (Zygmund [3], vol. II, p. 203); but g has no zero in B, by its very definition. For later reference, here is a formal statement of a uniqueness theorem that the preceding argument proves: 5.5.9. Theorem. If g e H{B) and if g has K-limit ^ on a set E a S with (7(E) > 0, then g = 0.
5.6. The Spaces N(B) and H'(B) 5.6.L Definitions. I f / i s any function with domain B, and 0 < r < 1, then f denotes the dilated function defined for |z| < 1/r by fXz) = f(rz). A function fe H(B) is in the Nevanlinna class N(B) provided that (1)
sup \og'^\f\d(7 0
< CO,
84
5. Boundary Behavior of Poisson Integrals
and is in the Hardy space H^{B) (0 < p < oo) provided that (2)
sup sup
Ifrl^da f|/,|^
< 00
^S
In the latter case, we write \\f\\p for the pih root of the left side of (2). This is evidently a norm when p > 1, and \\f — g\\p defines a metric when 0 < p < 1. More generally, let (p: [—oo, oo) ^ [0, oo) be a nondecreasing convex function, not identically 0, and let H^(B) be the class of all fe H(B) whose growth is restricted by the requirement (3)
sup 0
\(p(log\f,\)d(T < 00.
Js
lfq)(x) = x^ = max(0, x), then H^(B) = N(B), lf(p(x) = ^^^ then H^iB) = H\B). Clearly, H^' a H^^ cz N if pi > P2Suppose g is real-valued function in B. If there is an ^-harmonic u'mB such that g < u, "WQ call u an J^-harmonic majorant of g. If, furthermore, every other ^-harmonic majorant M^ of ^ satisfies the inequality u(z) < Ui(z) at every zeB, then w is said to be the least ^-harmonic majorant ofg in B. 5.6.2. Theorem. Let fe H(B), let cp be as above, put v = (p(\og | / | ) , and define (1)
/ , = sup 0
i^S
\\vUaX'\ J
(a) If 11 < 00, then v has a least Jf-harmonic majorant u in B. There is a positive measure ft on S such that u = P M , and \\JLI\\ = I^. (b) If 1 < p < CO and Ip < oo, then the least ^-harmonic majorant u ofv has the form u = P[/i] for some h e L\o) with \\h\\p = I p. Proof Pick zeBsLndij/e Aut(B) so that 1^(0) = z. If 0 < r < 1 then/,o «A is in the ball algebra, hence v^^ij/ is subharmonic, so that v(rz) = (v, o il/)(0) < \(v^o il/)d(7 = Plv, o i/^](0). Js By Theorem 3.3.8, this is the same as (2)
v(rz) < Plv,-](z).
5.6. The Spaces NiB) and H^iB)
85
If/i < 00, there is a sequence r^- y 1 such that {i;^.} converges to a positive measure jn, in the weak*-topology of the dual of C(S). Clearly, ||/i|| < I^ and f < P\_fi]. This last inequality implies I^ < \\ju\\. Thus ||/z|| = / i . To show that u = P[ju] is the least c/#-harmonic majorant of v, suppose u> V and u is ^-harmonic in B. Then u = Plfi] for some positive measure /Ion 5. Since w^ > i;^ for 0 < r < 1 and since u^ -^ fi and tv -^ /^> in the weak*topology, it follows that \gdiu> Js
\gdfi Js
for every g e C(S). In particular, if z e J5, then u(z) = P[Ml(z) > Plfiliz) = u(z). This proves (a). To deduce (b), one proceeds as above, using weak convergence in L^(o-). 5.6.3 Theorem. A function f e H(B) is in H^(B) if and only if (p(\og \f\) has an Ji-harmonic majorant. Proof. If feH^(BX then I^ < oo, and Theorem 5.6.2 furnishes the desired majorant. The converse is trivial. Corollary. Every H^{B) is an Ji-invariant function space. Note: The spaces HjiJB) are also characterized by the existence of harmonic (rather than e^-harmonic) majorants of epilog \f\). This is not difficult to prove, but does not lead to their ^-invariance. The existence of a pluriharmonic majorant is a much more restrictive requirement, as we shall see in Chapter 7. 5.6.4. Theorem. Iffe
N{B)J ^ 0, then
(a) / has finite K-limits / * a.e. on S, (b) log|/*|GLH^), (c) the least Ji-harmonic majorant u of log \f\ satisfies w* = log | / * | a.e. on S, and (d) there is a singular measure T on S such that u=
P[\og\f*\d(7-\-dTl
(Part (a) was proved by Koranyi [3] and Stein [2].) Proof. Theorem 5.6.2, with (p(x) = x'^ and p = 1, shows that log"^]/! < P[/l] for some measure X. The maximal theorems 5.2.4 and 5.4.5 show that
86
5. Boundary Behavior of Poisson Integrals
P[/l] is K-bounded at almost every C e 5. The same is then true of log"^ | / | , hence also of | / | itself. This proves (a), by Theorem 5.5.7. To prove (b), put Ar= j log|/,M(7,
B,= j log^lfAdd,
C,= j
\\og\fA\dG,
for 0 < r < 1. Since l o g | / | and log"^ | / | are subharmonic, A^. and B^ do not decrease as r increases; B^ is bounded, by hypothesis; Q = IB^. — A/, and log|/(0)|<^, l o g | / * | allows us to apply Fatou's lemma and to conclude that f(w* - \og\ f*\)da Js
< liminf f (w, - log\f,\)d(7. r-*l
Js
Since both u^ and log|/J tend to fi in the weak*-topology, the integral of the nonnegative function w* — l o g | / * | is 0. This proves (c). Since u* = ^fi a.e. on S (Theorem 5.4.9), (d) follows from (c) and §5.3.3. 5.6.5. Theorem. To every a > 1 corresponds a constant A((x) < oo such that
b
\MJ\^d(7
for every feH\B\ 0 < p < oo. (The case n = 1, with M^^d in place of M^^, is the original maximal theorem of Hardy and Littlewood [1].) Proof. Fix p, 0
Put v = \f\^'^. Then
5.6. The Spaces N(B) and H'iB)
87
Theorem 5.6.2, with (p(x) = e''^'^, shows therefore that v < P[/j] for some /i6LV),with||/»||2 = ||/||P'^Hence
and we conclude from Theorem 5.4.10 (applied to h, with exponent 2) that (\MJ\''dcj
h'd,J Js
= A(o{)\\fr,.
5.6.6. Theorem. Suppose 0 < p < oo, / e H'iB), and put (1)
/ * ( 0 = (X-lim/)(0
(a.e.onS).
Then (2)
Um f | / * - / , | ' ' d < T = 0. Note that / * ( 0 exists a.e., by Theorem 5.6.4.
Proof. Put F = M.^^f. Then F < M ^ / if a > 2, and Theorem 5.6.5 shows that F e L\(J). The inequalities
^ ^y>
-\^P
+ yP
1),
(0
valid for X > 0, j ; > 0, show that (3)
* ....[2^^^ \r-fr\'< [2F^
(P^l) (0
1).
Since X ^ / * a.e. as r / * 1, (2) follows from (3) and the dominated convergence theorem. 5.6.7. Definition. We let A(S) denote the class of all fe C(S) that are restrictions to S of members of the ball algebra A(B). [Note that ^4(5) is a closed subalgebra ofC(S), relative to the sup-norm, by the maximum modulus theorem.] For 0 < p < 00, we let H^iS) be the L^-closure of ^(5). 5.6.8. Theorem, (a) Iffe IF(B) thenf* e IP{S) and |[/'*||p = \\f\\p. (b) Ifp >\andge H\S\ then P[^] = C[^] e H\B\ and g = C|^]* a.e.
88
5. Boundary Behavior of Poisson Integrals
Proof. Part (a) is a corollary of Theorem 5.6.6, since f e A(S) for 0 < r < 1, and since the subharmonicity of | / | ^ impHes that
lim||/,||,= sup II/,||p= 11/11,. r-^l
0
Next, Pig'] = Clg] when g e A(SX by Theorem 3.3.2. Hence Pig] = Clg] for every g e H^iS). Since Clg] is holomorphic, the rest of (b) follows from Theorems 3.3.4(b) and 5.4.8. Corollary. The map f-^ f* is a linear isometry ofH\B)
onto H\S).
5.6.9. Theorem. The map f -^ C [ / ] * is the orthogonal projection of V-{o) onto H^(S), and (1)
[\M^Clf]\'dG
[m^da Js
for every f e L^{a). Proof. Every feV'{a) has an orthogonal decomposition f = g -\- h, where g eH\S) and h 1 H^S). Fix zeB and define t/,(0 = C(z,0. Then u^ e A(S\ and therefore
=1
Clh'](z)=
hu,d(7 = 0.
Js
Thus C [ / ] = Clg], and C [ / ] * = ^ by Theorem 5.6.8. This proves the first assertion. Next, (1) holds with g in place of/, by the Hardy-Littlewood theorem (5.6.5). Since C [ / ] = C[^] and Wgh < 11/II2, (1) holds f o r / a s well.
5.7. Appendix: Marcinkiew^icz Interpolation This appendix contains the special cases of the Marcinkiewicz interpolation theorem that occur in the present book. The theorem is usually stated for a wider variety of function spaces (see, for instance, Zygmund [2], [3; Chap. XII] or Stein and Weiss [1; Chap. 5], and the proofs are correspondingly more complicated. We consider two positive measures a and fi on sets 5 and X, respectively, and we let Tbe an operator that associates to every/GL^((T) a measurable function Tf.X ^ [0, 00], and that is sub-additive: r ( / + g) < Tf + Tg.
5.7. Appendix: Marcinkiewicz Interpolation
89
The various maximal functions that occur in Chapters 5 and 6 are examples of such operators. We let c^ and c^o be the smallest constants such that the inequahties li{Tf > t] < c^r' \ l/r^d, \\Tf\\^
{iff Js
da.
(b) / / r > 1, then f (Tf)dfi < KXM, Jx
Ml c) + K'Xci, c,) f \f\log^\f\dc7. Js
The constants Kp, K\ K" are finite whenever the indicated parameters are finite (and are + oo otherwise). Proof. The formula (1)
[pPdii^p Jx
f ii{F>t}tP-^ Jo
dt
holds for every measurable F : X - > [0, oo] and for every pe(0, oo). To prove (1), define (p on X x [0, oo) by (p(x, t) = pt^'^ if 0 < r < F(x\ 0 otherwise, and apply Fubini's theorem to the integral of cp over X x [0, oo) with respect to the product measure dju x dt. Fix feL^((j). For every te(0, oo) split / into f = gt + K, where gji£) = / ( O if 1/(01 > t, g,(0 = 0 if 1/(01 < t. Put
(2)
G(t) = Jrg, > | | ,
Hit) = JTK > ^ j ,
and (3)
GM = ^
f \f\dG, t J\f\>t
H,(t) = ^ t
f l / r da. J|yl<(
90
5. Boundary Behavior of Poisson Integrals
The definitions of Ci and c^ (for r < oo) show that (4)
G(t)<2c,t-'
(5)
H(t) < I'Crt-'
j\gM(^=G,(tl f \K\' da = H,(t). Js
Integration of (3) yields (6)
pG,it)dt
(7)
p rG,(tr-'dt Jo
(8)
p rH.ity-' Jo
=
2c,j\f\\og^\f\dG
= ^ ^ f l/l^ da P - ^ Js
(l
dt = ^ ^ \\f\'da r - p Js
^X
(0
Since Tf < Tg^ + Th,, (4) and (5) give (9)
ii{Tf >t}<
G{t) + H{t) < G,{t) + H,{t\
Hence (1) impHes: \x{Tfy dji < (7) + (8) if 1 < p < r. This proves (a) in the case r < oo. If r = 00 in (a), assume c^ <^, without loss of generality. (Replace T by Tjlc^ if necessary.) Since ||/iJloo ^ U we have ||T/i(||^ < t/2, hence //(O = 0, and (9) becomes ^{Tf > t) < G^(t). Now (a) follows from (1) and (7). Since fi{Tf > t} < \\iii\\,(9) yields /•oo
/t{r/ > t}cit < 11/^11 +
Jo
/•oo Ji
GiCOrft +
/•oo Jo
so that jx C^TMiU < lliull + (6) + (8) (with p = 1). Since \\f\da<e\\a\\+ Js (b) follows.
Js
Uf\\og^\f\da,
i/i(Orff,
Chapter 6
Boundary Behavior of Cauchy Integrals
One major difference between the Poisson kernel and the Cauchy kernel is. that the former is positive and the latter is not. The positivity of P(z, Q made it possible to be rather unsubtle in the proof of the basic maximal theorem 5.4.5: jj, was replaced by |/i|, and it was then just a matter of making size estimates without giving too much away. No cancellation effects came into play. No such approach can succeed with the Cauchy integral, for the simple reason that
b\C(z,0\dc7(0^oo as z approaches any boundary point of B. (This is the case c = 0 of 1.4.10.) Nevertheless, Cauchy integrals of measures do have finite X-Hmits at almost all points of S (Theorem 6.2.3), and a weak-type (1, 1) maximal theorem (6.2.2) does exist, even though M^Cljii] is not pointwise dominated by MJJ,. The proofs of these facts proceed along a route that has by now become standard when deahng with singular integrals, but they are quite selfcontained and rely on no previous acquaintance with singular integrals. (These methods were originated by Calderon and Zygmund [1]; there are now many good expositions, for instance by Riviere [1], Coifman-Weiss [1], Stein [1].) There is one feature that should perhaps be emphasized. Usually, singular integrals involve a kernel K(x, y) in which both x and y live on the same set; the singularity occurs when x = y, and one deals with it by truncating K. In the Cauchy kernel C(z, CX C hves on 5, z Hves in B, and no truncations will be made. In this respect, the present treatment differs from the one used by Koranyi-Vagi [1; Theorem 7.1]. They introduce kernels C^z, 0 (the notation is different) in which both z and C mc on 5, by
^ '
[0
otherwise, 91
92
6. Boundary Behavior of Cauchy Integrals
and show, for feUip), Sby
1 < p < oo, that the functions G C / ] defined on
Q[/](z)= fcXz, 0/(QMO converge in the norm topology of L^(o-), as s \ 0, thus obtaining a generahzation of the Marcel Riesz projection theorem. This will be obtained more easily in Theorem 6.3.1 below. Among the other topics taken up in this chapter, let us just mention that the complex tangent spaces play an essential role in Section 6.4.
6.1. An Inequality 6.1.1. Lemma. Suppose C, rj, coe S, d(co, rj) < S, d(co, Q > 2^» ^^d zeDJ^Q. Then \C(z,ri) - C(z,(o)\ < (16ay^'5\l
-
(Asin§5.1.1,rf(a),^) = | l - < a ; , ^ > r / 2 . ) Proof. The proof will be based on the identity (1)
C(z, n) - C(z, (o) = 2^ By 5.4.3(1),
(2)
|l-
and (3)
|1 - {z,ri>\-' < 4a|l - < C , ^ > r ' < 16a|l -
the last inequality amounts to d(C, (o) < 2 d(C, rj), which is a consequence of the triangle inequality and the hypotheses of the lemma. We claim that (4)
I
In the proof of (4), take co = e^, without loss of generality, and let z', t]' be the components of z, rj orthogonal to e^. The left side of (4) is then \
6.1. An Inequality
93
Since 11 - ^i | < ^ ^ < :^| 1 - Ci | < a| 1 - z^ |, by (2) and the hypotheses, one obtains
Kz,r,} - iz,co}\ < 5(2 + u'")\l -
z,\'l\
which proves (4), since a > 1. Returning to (1), we first apply (4), then (2) and (3), and conclude that I C(z, ff) — C(z, (D) I is at most n-l
The lemma follows. 6.1.2. Definition. For C, (o e S,(x > 1,5 > 0, we define a maximal difference, (1)
A(C, CO, oi, S) = sup I C(z, rj) - C(z, co) \,
the supremum being taken over all rj e Q(co, 3) and over all z e D^OThus Lemma 6.1.1 says that (2)
A(C,co,a,^)<(16a)" + M|l -
ifd(C, CO) > 23, i.e., if C ^ Q(co, 23). If we integrate (2), we obtain an inequality that will be needed in the proof of Theorem 6.2.2: 6.1.3. Theorem. Ifco e S,a > 1,3 > 0, then (1)
A(C, CO, a, 3)d(j(0 < A(oc),
where R(co, 3) = S\Q(co, 23).
Here, as in the rest of this chapter, ^(a) denotes a finite constant, that may also depend on the dimension n, and that is not necessarily the same at each occurrence. The integral in (1) is clearly independent of co. The significant assertion of the theorem is that there is a bound that is independent of 3. Proof. By 6.1.2(2), it is enough to show that
(2)
f
|l-
94
6. Boundary Behavior of Cauchy Integrals
When n > 1, formula 1.4.5(2) shows that this integral equals
where £(<5) = {A: |A| < 1, |1 - A| > 43^}. Replace 1 - |Ap by 2|1 - A|, then put 1 — A = re'*, to see that (3) is less than 2 ' ' - 2 ( n - 1)
fr-^'Ur
2"-\n - 1)
This proves (2). If n = 1, (2) still holds, since the integral is then
6.2. Cauchy Integrals of Measures We need a covering lemma that is more elaborate than 5.2.3, one that is specifically adjusted to the maximal function of a given measure. In place of the constant A^ that occurred in 5.2.3, we now use A^ = sup
^(46)
By Proposition 5.1.4, ^4 < oo. 6.2.1. Lemma. Let ja be a complex measure on S. If t > ||/i||, then there are balls Qi and pairwise disjoint Borel sets Vi c= Q^ such that (i)
(M/i > 0 c= U, Q, = (J, ^^,
(ii) <^(Qi) t}. Assume n>0, without loss of generahty. To each C e £, corresponds then a largest 5 such that the ball q = Q(C, d) satisfies (1)
Kq) > t(T(q).
6.2. Cauchy Integrals of Measures
95
Since t > ||iu||, we have q ¥" S; hence (2)
fi(4q) < tC7(4q).
Et is thus covered by a collection T^ of balls q that satisfy (1) and (2). Let ri be the supremum of the radii of the members of F j , and choose qieT^ with radius >3ri/4. Discard all members of r^ that intersect q^. Call the remaining collection r 2 , let r2 be the supremum of the radii of the members of r 2 , and choose q2^'^2 with radius > 3^2/4. Discard all members of r2 that intersect ^2 > let T^ be the remaining collection, etc. (The process stops if some F^ is empty, otherwise it continues through the natural numbers.) We thus get disjoint balls qi. Put Qi = 4^^. It is then easy to find disjoint Borel sets P^ such that q^ cz Vi cz Q. for each i, and [jiVi= [jiQi, If some qeT^ was discarded at the ith stage, then q intersects qi, and r(q) < 4r(^i)/3, where r{q) is the radius of q. Since 1 + f + f < 4, we have q c 4qi = Qi. Thus E^ cz | J . Q^., and (i) is proved. Next, (3)
(y(Qi) < AMqd
< A^r
'Kqtl
by (1). This proves (ii). If we add the inequahties (3), the disjointness of {qi} proves (iii). Finally, fi(Qi) < tcr(gf), by (2), so that (iv) follows from KVd < KQi) < t(T{Qd < A^taiqd. 6.2.2. Theorem. To every a > 1 corresponds a constant A((x) < 00 such that (1)
for all complex measures fion S and for all t > 0. Let us recall that M , C M ( 0 = sup{|CM(z): zeZ)«(0}, in accordance with Definition 5.4.4. Proof. Fix IX and t. If t < \\p\\, then (1) holds provided that .4(a) > 1. So assume t > ||//||, put E^ = {Mfi > r}, and choose {QJ, {T^} in accordance with Lemma 6.2. L Let (2)
dn= fd(T -\- dii,
be the Lebesgue decomposition of ^. We construct another decomposition (3)
dfi = g d(T -\- dp
96
6. Boundary Behavior of Cauchy Integrals
in which ^ is a "good" function (one that is not too large) and P = Zj5j is the "bad" part of the measure fi, by defining (4)
c , = (^)(P.)
^^
^^^^ 1/(0
(6)
p,(E) =
if C^S\[j,V, (n-c,c7)mnE).
Since n^ is concentrated in £, <= (J,, t^., it is not hard to verify that (3) holds, i.e., that (7)
KE)= \gdc7 + p(E) -L'
for every Borel set £ ci 5, by considering separately the cases £ <= T^ and En\JVi = 0.(ln the latter case, //,(£) = 0.) We shall first deal with g. Since Mf < Mfi, the corollary to Theorem 5.3.1 implies that | / ( 0 | < t a.e. outside E^, hence \g\^ < f | / | , so that
f
\g\'da
\\f\da
Part (iv) of Lemma 6.2.1 shows that \Ci\ < At (where A = A^, and part (iii) imphes therefore that
i
JVi
i
i
Thus (8)
j\g\'da<(l+A')ML
Setting G = M^C^g^, Theorem 5.6.9 (the Hardy-Littlewood maximal theorem) gives {G^ da < Aioc)\\fi\\t. Js
6.2. Cauchy Integrals of Measures
97
Since a{G > t} < t~^ j G^rfcr,we conclude that (9)
(^{Mo,CW\>-\< 2J -
t
Our next objective is the analogous estimate
(10)
<x<(M.Cm>^j<'^^"^' 2J -
t
This will complete the proof, because M , C M < M,C|>] + M,C[fi], so that (1) follows from (9) and (10). By (4), cMVb = MK). Hence i|^;|| < 2\ii\{V^, by (6), and thus (11)
Z m\ < 2ii/'ii. i
Let Q be the set that occurs in (10). Put W = |J,- {IQ^. Then
i
By part (iii) of Lemma 6.2.1, (12)
a(W) < Z(7(2Q,) < AI^cTiQd < ^ ^ .
Note that pi is concentrated on P^ cz Q., and that Pi(Qi) = 0. This is a crucial feature of the proof, for it enables us to write the Cauchy integral of Pi in the form (13)
ClP^-Jiz) = r {C(z, ri) - C(z, cod}dPiifi),
where cOf is the center of Qi = Q(cOiy di). Using the notation introduced in §6.1.2, it follows that (14)
|C[iS,](z)|
for all z G DjiO' This inequality persists if its left side is replaced by its supremum as z ranges over DJ^CX i.e., by M^ClPJiO- If we then integrate,
98
6. Boundary Behavior of Cauchy Integrals
and appeal to Theorem 6.1.3, we see that (15)
f
M^Cmdd
< A(a)||AI|.
Js\2Qi
In (15), we can replace S\2Qi by its subset Q\l^, and then add, to obtain (16)
f
Jn\w
M^CmdG
< A(oi) X Ili?,|| < i
2A(a)M,
by (11). The integrand in (16) exceeds t/2 at every point of Q. Hence (16) shows that
(17)
a(«\P^)<'^^"^ll'^ll t
This completes the proof, since (12) and (17) imply (10). 6.2.3. Theorem. If fi is a complex Borel measure on S, then C[//] e IP{B) for all p < 1. CoroJlary. C[/i] has finite K-limits C\_iiY^ at almost all points ofS, Proof. Fix a > 2, put F = M^C\_ix\. Theorem 6.2.2 shows that G{F > t) < xjt, where x = A(a) ||ju||. Hence, for 0 < p < 1, [fPd(T = p r a{F > t}tP-^ dt Js Jo
Since |C[/x](rO| < F(0, the theorem is proved. The corollary follows from Theorem 5.6.4. 6.2.4. Remark. There exist bounded function w on 5* whose Cauchy integrals tend to 00 along some radius of B. For example, let u be the real part of i log(l — Zj). This shows that the precise analogue of Theorem 5.4.5 fails for Cauchy integrals, since (M/i)(0 may be finite at a point where M^C\ji], or even MradCM is infinite. The conclusion of Theorem 6.2.3 cannot be strengthened to C[//] e H^(B). Theorem 6.3.5 shows this.
6.3. Cauchy Integrals of L^-Functions
99
6.3. Cauchy Integrals of L^-Functions 6.3.1. Theorem (Koranyi-Vagi [1]). If \ < p < co and a > 1, there exists A(a, p) < GO such that (1)
f\M,Clfl\''da
Js for every f e L\G).
Corollary. / / 1 < p < oo and feL\G\ then C\_f^eH\B). f -^ C [ / ] * is a bounded linear projection ofL\G) onto H^(S).
The map
Proof. The case p = lis Theorem 5.6.9. Since
f^M,cu:i is subadditive, the Marcinkiewicz interpolation theorem, combined with Theorem 6.2.2, proves (1) if 1 < p < 2. A standard duality argument completes the proof: Fix p, 2 < p < oc, let q be the conjugate exponent, pick / G L^(o-), h e L\a). For 0 < r < 1, [KQCU^{rQd(T{Q= •Is
Js
Since 1 < ^ < 2, ||C[/j],L < Aiq)\\hl,
IIh-CU\da s
\c\K]{rr])W)dcj{n\
so that
This holds for every h e L^((J). Hence
IIC[/li|,<^(^) 11/11, forallrG(0, 1). This says that C [ / ] e ff^(B) and that ||C[/]||p < A{q)\\f\\p. Now (1) follows from the Hardy-Littlewood maximal theorem. For the corollary, see Theorem 5.6.8. 6.3.2. Definition. The class of all measurable functions/on S for which
Jl/|l0g^|/|d(7<^ is called L log L.
100
6. Boundary Behavior of Cauchy Integrals
6.3.3. Theorem. IffeL
log L then C [ / ] e H\B).
Proof, By Marcinkiewicz interpolation, this follows from Theorems 6.2.2 and 6.3.1. L log L is actually the largest class in which this conclusion holds. Theorem 6.3.5 will show this. But first we show that there is a close connection between the maximal function Mfi and the class L log L. 6.3.4. Theorem. If pi is a complex measure on S for which Mfi e L^ia), then there is anfeLlogL such that dfx = fda. Stein [4] proved this for functions rather than measures, but the proof is essentially the same. Proof. Since M/J, — M\fi\ we may assume that jU > 0, and that \\fi\\ = 1. Our first objective is the inequahty (1)
fi{Mfi > t} < At(p(t)
(t > 1)
where (p(t) = G{A^M^ > t}, and A is the constant A^ in Lemma 6.2.1. Choose Qi.Vi'm accordance with that lemma, and put E^ = {Mfi > t}. Pick some g, = g(C, S), If co e Q,-, it follows that Qi cz Q(a), 23). Hence ( M M ) M > ^ (6(0), 2^)) > ^ ^ ^ > - 2 , by6.2.1(ii). Hence (Jf ^ ^ {^/^ > t/A"^}. By 6.2.1(iv),
KEt) < I KVd
f (p(t)dt = A^ UMfi)da < 00, Jo Js by formula 5.7(1). It follows that t(p(t) ^ 0 as t -> oo. Hence //(£,) -• 0 as t -^ 00, by (1). Since fi^ is concentrated on nE^ (Theorem 5.2.7), we conclude that fi^ = 0, hence dfi = fda for some / e L^(cr), and Mf = Mfi. At every Lebesgue point of/, / ( O < (Mf)(Q. Thus / < t a.e. outside £,, or {/ > r} <= £f. Hence (1) shows that (3)
f
Jf>t
fdc7
(r>l)
6.4. Cauchy Integrals of Lipschitz Functions
101
SO that finally (by Fubini's theorem)
A r(p(t)dt>
f f
f fda=
\f\og^fda,
which proves the theorem, because of (2). 6.3.5. Theorem. Iff e H\B) and M = R e / > 0, then u* e L log L. Proof. By the Hardy-Littlewood maximal theorem, M^feL^{c\ hence M^ueL^{G) (for any a > 1). There is a measure ju > 0 such that u = P M Since M^ueL^(cTX it follows from Theorem 5.4.12 that MiieL^{G\ and Theorem 6.3.4 gives the desired conclusion. 6.3.6. When n = 1, Theorems 6.2.3, 6.3.1, 6.3.3, and 6.3.4 are due to Kolmogorov, M. Riesz, Zygmund, and M. Riesz, respectively. See Zygmund [3], Chap. VII, §2, and p. 381, for detailed references.
6.4. Cauchy Integrals of Lipschitz Functions 6.4.1. Definitions. If 0 < a < 1, and if/is a complex function with domain S, or B, or S, we say that / satisfies a Lipschitz condition of order a (briefly: / e Lip a) provided that (1)
|/(z)-/(w)|
for some c = Cj < oo and all z, w in the domain of/. Note that this definition of Lip a is based on the euclidean metric, even when the domain of/is S, rather than on the nonisotropic metric introduced in §5.1.1. A holomorphic Lipschitz function is one that Hes in A(B) n Lip a. A complex-tangential curve is a C^-map y:I ^ S, where / is some interval on the real fine, whose derivative yXt) lies in the complex tangent space to S at y(tX for all tel. (See §5.4.2.) Analytically, the requirement is that (2)
(teiy
Stein [3] showed that holomorphic Lipschitz functions of order a are, roughly speaking, twice as smooth on complex-tangential curves. The same conclusion holds if the Lipschitz condition is only imposed on the slices of a holomorphic function (Rudin [12]). Ahern and Schneider [5] went even further, and showed that it holds for Cauchy integrals of arbitrary L^functions (not necessarily boundary values of holomorphic functions) whose slices are in Lip a. Theorems 6.4.9 and 6.4.10 summarize these results.
102
6. Boundary Behavior of Cauchy Integrals
But first it seems advisable to describe some geometric features of the curves that are involved. 6.4.2. Complex-Tangential Curves. Let y: I ^ S be a C^-curve. Then (y, y> = 1, and if we differentiate this, we obtain Re
Im,7> = 0. Associate to each C e 5 the curve T^ defined by
(2)
r^(Q) = e'^C
i-n
Note that F^ traces a circle, namely the intersection of S with the complex line through 0 and C, and that r^(0) = I'C. If y is a C^-curve in S, and if C = y(tX it follows that (3)
yXt) • r^(0) = ,Re<7tO, iy(0> = lm
the dot-product is as in §5.4.2. Comparison of (1) and (3) leads to the following characterization: A C^-curve y in S is complex-tangential if and only if y is perpendicular to every circle F^ that it intersects. For any n > 1 there is a large supply of such curves. To illustrate this, consider the case n = 2. Let r = r(0, ^ =- 0(0 be of class C^ on /, so that y^ = re'^ defines a C^curve 7o i^i the complex plane. Choose real functions w, t; on / such that (4)
t;' = j - ^ T ^ ,
u=
v-e,
and define
(5)
re" y='
Then 7 is a curve on S. Consider the map of S onto the Riemann sphere (more appropriately, in the present context, onto the complex projective space of dimension 1) that sends (2, w) to w/z. Its fibers are the circles F^. It carries y onto our prescribed curve yo, since t; — w = 6, by (4).
6.4. Cauchy Integrals of Lipschitz Functions
103
Differentiation of (5) leads to (6)
,7> =
i(u' + r^v') 1 + r2
which is 0, by (4). Hence y is complex-tangential This construction can be used to connect any point (a, b)eS to any (z, w) G 5 by a complex-tangential curve: Perform a unitary change of variables, if needed, so that none of a,fc,z, w are 0. Let / = [0,1]. Find a positive function r e C\I) with r(0) = \b/a\, r(l) = |w/z|, then find 0 e C\I) so that e(0) = arg('^j,
0(1)
= a,gQ
and
j\l+r'r'Q'dt
= SiTg(^\.
Put t!(0) = arg b, define u and v by (4), and y by (5). Then y(0) = (a, b), y(l) = (z,w). 6.4.3. A theorem of Hardy and Littlewood (see, for example, Duren [1], p. 74) characterizes the holomorphic function in U that belong to Lip a (0 < a < 1) by the growth condition
i/'(z)i = o((i - izir-i). We shall reprove this in the n-variable context, but mention it here because it furnishes much of the motivation for the work in this section. 6.4.4. The Radial Derivative ^ / . L e t / e H{B) have the homogeneous expans i o n / = ZJF^. We define (1)
(^/)(z) = f/cF,(z)
(zeB).
k= 0
^f is related to the derivative of the slice functions /^ by
(2)
m)W) = ¥lW
(CeSAeUy
The advantage of ^f over f[ is that the former is a holomorphic function in 5.
104
6. Boundary Behavior of Cauchy Integrals
If / is a Cauchy integral, say / = C[JK] for some measure fj, on S, one can use (2) to derive a Cauchy formula for ^ / , namely
(3)
^""^^^'^-U-tor^''^^^-
6.4.5. Lemma. Iffe
H{B) and P is a multi-index, then
(1)
D^^f-diDPf=\p\D''f
and, for 0 < r < l,CeS, P ^ 0,
(2)
r^^Wf)(,rO= fV^/)(tOf"""'rft.
Proof. By linearity, it suffices to prove (1) and (2) for / = F^, a homogeneous polynomial of degree k. Then D^F^ has degree k — \p\ (negative degree indicates the zero-function), so that - ^D^JF, = [feD" - (/c - \P\)D':\F, =
\p\D'F„
which gives (1). Next,
so that the integral in (2) is r\D^F,)(0
=
r\^WF,)(rO.
6.4.6. Lemma. Ifg e H(B), c > 0, and (1)
|^(z)|<(l-|z|)-
(zeB)
thenjor /c = 1, 2, 3 , . . . , 0 < r < 1, (2)
mg)(re,)\
< AU^ -
rr^-'^\
Recall that D2 = d/dz2. The derivative on the left of (2) is thus the feth derivative in the direction of ^2, which is orthogonal to ei. The pair ei, 62 could be replaced in the lemma by any pair of orthogonal unit vectors inC".
6.4. Cauchy Integrals of Lipschitz Functions
105
The point of the lemma is the appearance of /c/2 in the exponent. The growth of (D\g)(re^) can be much more rapid. For example, if g(z) = (1 - z^y then iD\g)(re,) = a,,,(l - r ) — \ where a^ ,. = c(c + 1 ) . . . (c + /c — 1). Proof. Fix r and define (3)
KX) = g(re, + Ae^)
for a l U 6 C with | Ap < 1 - r^ Then, by (1), (4)
\h(l)\ < 2%l - r ' -
\X\Y\
since 2(1 - |z|) > 1 - |zp. Let F be the circle on which |Ap = ^(1 - r^). The Cauchy formula (5)
;,W(0) = ^ 2ni
(x-'-'h(X)dX JY
gives the estimate (6)
\h\0)\
Since (D^^Xrei) = /I'^'CO), (2) follows from (6). 6.4.7. Lemma. Suppose fe H(B), 0 < a < 1, and (1)
l(^/)(z)l<(l-Uir-'
(zeB).
Then, for 2 <j < n and 0 < r < 1, (2) (3)
mDjf)ire,)\
< ^(1 -
rf-"\
l(Z>?/)(rei)|<^„(l-rr-i,
and (4)
l(D,/)(r.,)| < ,^^
^.^^^^^_
106
6. Boundary Behavior of Cauchy Integrals
Here, and later, A^ denotes a finite constant, not necessarily the same at each occurrence. Proof. Lemma 6.4.6, with ^f in place of g, shows that (5)
\(Dj^f)(re,)\
(6)
< A,(l -
rT-''\
\(DJ^f)(re,)\
6.4.8. Lemma. If the gradient of a function u: B -^ C satisfies (1)
|(gradM)(z)|<(l-|z|r'
(zeB)
for some a G (0, 1), then u e Lip a. (It follows, trivially, that u has a Lip a extension to B.) Proof Choose aeB, beB, with 0 < |a| < \b\ < 1. Put \b - a\ = S, and define a = -—— a, \ci\
b = —-— b. \b\
Three cases occur: (i) When^ < 1 - |b|then Igradi/I < ( 1 - \b\f-'
<^"-^
on the line from a to b. Hence | u(a) — u(b) \ < (5". (ii) Whenl - |fo| < ^ < 1 - | a | , t h e n | a - b'\ < \a-b\,Sind \u(a) - u(b)\ < \u(a) - u(b')\ + \u{b') - u(b)\. The first term on the right is estimated as in (i); the second is at most r\b\
(1
-xr-Ux
(iii) When 1 - |a| < (5, then \a' - b'\ < \a - ft|, and \u(a) - u(b)\ is at most \u(a) - u(a')\ + (w(a') - u(b')\ + \u(b') - u(b)\. The first and third term is estimated as in (ii), the second by (i).
6.4. Cauchy Integrals of Lipschitz Functions
107
6.4.9. Theorem. Assume 0 < a < 1 , / G L^(a), and
(1)
\f{^^)-f{e'X)\<W'-e'r
for all C^S and all real 6, t. The radial derivative of the Cauchy integral F = C [ / ] must then satisfy the growth condition (2)
\i^F)iz)\
Proof If we combine formulas 6.4.4(3) and 1.4.7(1), we see that (^F){z) is equal to
Fix z, C, for the moment, and denote the inner integral by J. Write
' • ^ I -271 - JJ__JJ11 -r^^-(^-9)|"+i -"'-e''-^'^^-
Note that 11 - A | < 2 | 1 - r A | i f | A | = 1. Hence (5)
l-^'-Sr
|l-
If we insert this into (3), and use 1.4.7(1) once more, we see that (6)
|(^F)(z)| < 2 n | | l - < z , O r " - ' ^ " M C ) .
Now (2) follows from (6) and Proposition 1.4.10. Remark. The hypothesis of Theorem 6.4.9 holds for every / e Lip a, and in particular for every feA(B) n Lip a, in which case F = f The converse of this remark is part of the following theorem. 6.4.10. Theorem. Suppose 0 < a < 1 , / G H(B), and (1)
|(^/)(z)|<(l-|z|)«-i
(ZG5).
Then f has a continuous extension to B (still called / ) that lies in A(B) n Lip a.
108
6. Boundary Behavior of Cauchy Integrals
/ / } ' : I -^ S is a complex-tangential C^-curve and ifg =fo y, then (a) g e Lip(2a) on I when 0 < a < j , (b) g is differentiable and g' e Lip(2a — 1) on I when ^ < a < 1. Proof, Since j ^ (1 - 0''"' dt = a ' ^ l - rf, we infer from (1) that / ( r Q converges, uniformly on S, to a limit that we call f(Q. This extends / , so that / e ^(B). Note also that (2)
\m-f(rO\
for all Ce 5,0 < r < 1. Lemma 6.4.7 shows that the gradient of / satisfies the hypothesis of 6.4.8. T h u s / e Lip a. Assume now, without loss of generahty, that our complex-tangential y has ly'l = L (This amounts to parametrizing y by arc length.) Define (3)
gXt) = firyit))
(t6/,0
For any t e /, there is a unitary change of coordinates in C" such that 7(0 = ^1 ^iid y'(t) = ^2- The chain rule shows then that (4)
grit) =
r(D2f)(re,)
and (5)
g:(t) = r\Dlf){re,)
+ ^
r{DJ){re,)y]{t).
7=1
Fix ti, ^2 e / so that t2 = t^ -^ h,0 < h < I. Put r = 1 - /i^. If 0 < a < ^, it follows from (2) that \g — gA < A^h^^", and it follows from (4) and Lemma 6.4.7 that \g',\ < A^h^"'\ so that (6)
\gr(t2) - gr(tl)\ < (t2 " 1^^"''
=
A,h^\
Hence \g{t2) — g{ti)\< A^h^^", and (a) is proved. Finally, assume ^ < a < 1. By (5) and Lemma 6.4.7, Ig^l < A^^yh^""'^, so that (7)
\g'Xt2)-9'Xh)\
Furthermore, it follows from 6.4.7(2) that (8)
Writ) - g'lt)\ < A^l - rf-'"
=
A^h'^-'
6.4. Cauchy Integrals of Lipschitz Functions
109
if r < 5 < 1. Hence {g's} converges, uniformly on /, as s -^ 1, so that g' exists and (8) holds with g' in place of g's. Combined with (7), this proves that (9)
\gXt2)-gXh)\
which is what (b) asserts. Remark. In the omitted case a = i, it is still true that Ig^l < Ayh~^. From this and (2) it is easy to deduce that (10)
\g(t + /i) + g(t -h)-
2g(t)\ < A,K
i.e., that g Hes in the space that is often called Aj. (Chapter V of Stein [1] describes the spaces A^ and their relation to Lip a.) But g need not be in Lipl. To see an example (with n = 2), take (11)
/(^) = f ^ l o g ^ — . Zi
1 -
Zi
Then (^/)(z) = Z2/(l - z j , and since |z2p < 1 - |zi P,
(12) Thus feA{B) but
mm)\ ^ {(T4^}'• n Lip^. If y(t) = (cos t, sin r), then y is complex-tangential,
/(7(0) = tanr-log
1 — cos t
is not in Lip 1 and is not differentiable at t = 0. The combination of Theorems 6.4.9 and 6.4.10 shows that the Cauchy integral tends to preserve smoothness on slices, while introducing additional smoothness in the complex-tangential directions. An extreme example of this phenomenon is furnished by any feL^ that is constant on each shce. The conclusion—probably surprising at first glance—is that C [ / ] is then constant in B. Actually, the proof follows immediately from the ^-invariance of the Cauchy transform: If Uz = e^^z, then f°U = fby assumption, hence C [ / ] o [/ = C [ / ] , which shows that the holomorphic function C [ / ] is constant on each shce. Hence it is constant in B, since all sHces intersect at the center of B.
110
6. Boundary Behavior of Cauchy Integrals
6.5. Toeplitz Operators 6.5.1. Introduction. To every cp e L°°((j) is associated a linear operator T^—the Toeplitz operator with symbol (^—that is defined for / G L ^ ( ( T ) by (1)
(T^f)(z) = acpn(z)
(zeB).
The holomorphic functions T^f have K-limits at almost all points of S (Theorem 6.2.3). This extends the domain of T^/is a natural way to the closed ball B, with the possible exception of a set of measure zero on 5. The domain of 7^ is often restricted to certain subclasses of L^((T). For example, every T^ is a bounded linear operator on the Hilbert space if ^(5), and the relations between the symbol cp and operator-theoretic properties of 7^ provide an interesting topic. This, however, will not be pursued here. (See Coburn [1], Boutet de Monvel [1], Janas [1], McDonald [2], [3].) Theorems 6.4.9 and 6.4.10 imply that T^ preserves Lip a (0 < a < 1) if (p e Lip a (since Lip a is an algebra). Theorem 6.3.1 shows that every T^ carries L^(cr) into H^B) if 1 < p < oc. This is false for p = 1, even when (p = 1: iff > 0 on iS, Theorem 6.3.5 shows that / must be in L log L in order for T^f = C [ / ] to be in H\B). It is also not true that every T^ carries H"^ to /f*: Let g be an unbounded holomorphic function in B whose real part is bounded, with ^(0) = 0. If (P = RQ ^*, then T^(2) -=g$H'^. (See Theorem 3.2.5.) There is a rather weak smoothness assumption which, when imposed on (p, avoids this last difficulty. Theorem 6.5.4 shows this in detail. We define the modulus of continuity co^ of a function (p:S^Chy (2)
(o^(t) = sup{\(p(0 - (p(ri)\: \C - r]\ < t}.
We say that (pis a. Dini function if
(3)
r^
. ^dt
o)^(t)—< Jo t
00.
For example, (3) holds if co
(4) iorzeB,C€S,z¥^C-
rM) = {kz)-(p(0}c(z,o
6.5. Toeplitz Operators
111
6.5.2. Lemma. Ifcp is a Dinifunction, then {T^: zeB) is uniformly integrable. More explicitly: To every £ > 0 corresponds a ^ > 0 such that j ^ \T^\dG < e for all z e S and for all £ c S with a(E) < 5. Proof. Iir^ll^ is bounded for |z| < i . It is thus sufficient to consider z of the form z = rrj, ^ < r < 1, rjeS. Since |1 - /i| < 2|1 — r/l| for \X\ < 1, we have (1)
|C(rf/,OI<21C(^,OI
and therefore (2)
Ir,(C)I < 2^co(I^ - CI)IC(rj, 01 = 2"F,(0,
say, where a> = a>^. Since {F^:^eS} is ^-invariant, in the sense that Fu^f = F^o (7~ \ the lemma will follow as soon as we know that (3)
(F,(OdcT(0 < 00. Js
When n = 1, (3) is elementary. When n > 1, we use formula 1.4.5(2). Since co is nondecreasing and \rj — l^\^ = 2Re(l —
^
£ ^^ ~ ' ^ ' ^ r ' « ( V 2 | r ^ y m 3 ( A ) .
Now use 1 — | / l p < 2 | l — / l | , replace U by the half-disc D with center atA = 1 and radius 2 that covers [/, write A = 1 - se'^(0 < s < 2,|9| < n/I), and then replace 25 by t^. It follows that (4) is less than (5)
(n-
1)2"-^ f co(t)-< 00. Jo ^
6.5.3. Lemma. If (p is a Dini function, then
(1)
z ^ r,
is a uniformly continuous map ofB into L^icr). Proof, The uniform integrability of {F^}, combined with Egorov's theorem, gives (2)
lim \\r,-rjd(7 = 0
z-*w Js
112
6. Boundary Behavior of Cauchy Integrals
for every weB. This shows that (1) is continuous; the compactness of B gives uniform continuity. 6.5.4. Theorem. Let cp be a Dini function. (a) / / V^ is defined by
VJ=cpf-TJ then V^p carries the closed unit ball of H"^ into a bounded equicontinuous subset of C(B). (b) T ; carries H"^ into H"^, and A(S) into A(B). (c) T^ carries H^ into HK Note. Since bounded equicontinuous subsets of C(B) have compact closure (Ascoh's theorem), (a) asserts that V^ is a compact operator from if °° into C(B). Proof. For z e B.feH^,
(1)
the Cauchy formula shows that
(VJKz) = [{(piz) -
i.e., that
(2)
(vjKz)=
{fr^dc. Js
I f / G / / ^ it follows that
(3)
\(vj)(z) - (vj)(w)\ < 11/11, fir, - rjdcT Js
for zeB, we B. By Lemma 6.5.3, (3) imphes that V^fis uniformly continuous in B, hence has a continuous extension to B. The equicontinuity asserted in (a) is then also a consequence of (3). Since T^f = (pf — V^f, (a) shows that the holomorphic function T^/ is bounded i f / e if °°, which proves (b), and (c) will follow from (4)
sup
0
\\{VJ){rn)\d<j{n) {\{VJ){r ^S
<'X,
6.5. Toeplitz Operators
113
By (2) and Fubini's theorem, the estimate (5)
sup
0 < r < l JSS
\r^iO\d<Jiri) < CO rti\
implies (4). The computation used in the proof of Lemma 6.5.2 estabhshes (5). Theorem 6.5.4 will be used in the solution of Gleason's problem (Section 6.6) and in the proof of Henkin's theorem (Chapter 9). Our first application, however, is to the space f/°° + C, the set of all sums g -\- h *with g e C(SX /IE if ^(5): 6.5.5. Theorem (Rudin [7]). H'^iS) -h C(S) is a closed sub-algebra ofL'^ia). Proof. I f / G H ° ° ( S ) and cp is a Dini function. Theorem 6.5.4 shows, after restricting to S, that the product
(pf=T4+VJ hes in H'^{S) + C(5). Since the Dini functions are dense in C (we omit S in the rest of this proof) it remains to be shown that if °° + C is closed with respect to convergence in the essential supremum norm. The following observation is the key: / / / sH"^ + C, then f = g + hfor some geQhe if*, that satisfy ll^lloo<2||/|L, 11/^11 00 < 3 | | / | L . Indeed, / = G + if, for some GeCHeH"^. The case ||/||^ = 0 being trivial, assume ||/||oo > 0. Then there exists r < 1 such that the Poisson integral P[G] satisfies
I|G-P[G1L<||/IL. Define g = G-
P[G], + P [ / ] „
h = H - PIH^,. ThQngeC,hGH-,f=g + K ||^|U < 2||/iU, and \\h\\^ = \\f - g\\^ < 3II/II00. Finally, if / is in the closure of H"^ + C, there exist /• G if °^ 4- C, f = 1,2,3,...^ such that il/ilL < 2"^ for i > 2, and f = f^f f. Consequently, f = gi + hi (i > 1), where giEC, hiEH"^, and (for / > 2)\\gi\\^ < 2'-\ m^ < 2'-\ Then g = YA 9i is in C, /i = ^T h^ is in H'^, and hence / = ^ + ft is in if °° + C.
114
6. Boundary Behavior of Cauchy Integrals
6.5.6. Remarks. The case n= 1 of Theorem 6.5.5 was proved by Sarason [1]. When n = 1, then //°° + C is the smallest closed subalgebra of L°° that contains //°^ and is larger than i/°°. (See Sarason [2].) This is false when n > 1. For example, let E be an arbitrary circular subset of 5 with 0 < (7(E) < 1; then £ is a union of circles F^ introduced in §6.4.2. Let XE be the subalgebra of H°°(S) + C(S) consisting of all / whose restriction to almost every F^ c= £ belongs to i/°°(T). It is clear that XE is closed, that H'^iS) ^ XE ^ H'^iS) + C(5), and that both inclusions are strict. Aytuna and Chollet [1] have extended Theorem 6.5.5 to strictly pseudoconvex domains. If B and S are, however, replaced by a polydisc W (n > 1) and its distinguished boundary T", the situation is different: H'^{T'') + CiT"") is still a closed subspace of L°°(T"), but it fails to be an algebra (Rudin [7]).
6.6. Gleason's Problem 6.6.1. Let X be some class of holomorphic functions in a region Q cz C". Gleason's problem for X is the following: IfaeQ and fe X, do there exist functions g^,.. .,g„eX such that (1)
/(^) - m
= E (z, - a,)g,(z) k=l
forallzeQl Gleason [1] originally asked this for Q = B, a = 0, and X = A(BX the ball algebra. (In other words, do the coordinates functions generate the maximal ideal consisting of 3\\fEA(B) with /(O) = 0?) The difficulty of the problem depends on Q. For instance, if B is replaced by a polydisc, Gleason's question becomes trivial: take n = 2, for simpHcity, and decompose a n y / e H(U^) that is continuous on U^ into a sum (2)
/(z, w) = /(O, 0) + zg,(z, w) + wg2(z, w)
where ,,, (3)
, , /(z,0)-/(Q,Q) ^i(z, w) = , z
^ ^ /(z,w)-/(z,0) g2(z, w) = . w
The point is that z # 0 and w 7^ 0 on the torus T^, so that the functions (3) belong to the prescribed class. Put in different terms, i f / G //°°(L/^) and ^2 is as in (3), then ^2 e H'^iU^). This is not true in B:w^/(1 — z) is bounded in B2, but w/(l — z) is not; to see the latter, take (z, w) = (cos t, sin t).
6.6. Gleason's Problem
115
Gleason's original question was solved by Leibenson (see Henkin [4]), who observed that (4)
/(z) - /(O) = C ^f(tz)dt JQ
at
= t z, f^=i
C(DJ)(tz)dt JQ
and then proved that the functions (5)
g,(z) = f (DJ)(tz)dt Jo
(l
lie in A(B) if feA(B). (This proof is similar to some of the work in Section 6.4; details may be found on pp. 151-153 of Stout [1].) Kerzman and Nagel [1] used sheaf-theoretic methods to solve Gleason's problem in smoothly bounded strictly pseudoconvex regions, for functions subject to Lipschitz conditions that could vary from point to point. The simplest and most far-reaching solution is probably the one found by Ahern and Schneider [4]. They worked in strictly pseudo-convex domains. Here is the special case of the ball: 6.6.2. The Ahern-Schneider Solution. If / e H\B) and a e B, the Cauchy formula gives (1)
/(z) - / ( a ) = f lC(z, 0 - C(a, OmOd^iO Js
(z 6 B)
where /(C) denotes the K-limit of / at C e 5. This suggests consideration of the functions
Js
iz - a, C>
since they clearly satisfy n
(3)
f{z) - f(a) = X (^fc - «/c)^fe(«» z)' The identity
= c(z, 0 L shows that every gffc(a, z) is (for fixed aeB) a finite sum of products, each product being a holomorphic monomial z^" (of degree |a| < n — 1) times a
116
6. Boundary Behavior of Cauchy Integrals
Toeplitz transform of/whose symbol is in C°°(5); in fact, the symbols are conjugate-holomorphic functions in a neighborhood of B. The results of Section 6.5 prove therefore cases (i), (ii), and (iii) (for 0 < a < 1) of the following conclusion: The formulas (2) and (3) solve Gleason's problem in any of the following spaces X: (i) X = A(B). (ii)
X = H\B\
1 < /? < 00.
(iii) X = A{B) n Lip a, 0 < a < 1. (iv) X = H^(BX the space of all feH'^(B) extensions to B u E, where E c: S. (v) X = A(B, EAoc}).
that have continuous
The spaces (v) are defined as follows: let £ c: 5 be arbitrary, associate to each C G £ a number a(C), 0 < a(0 < j , and let X consist of all fe A(B) for which
zeB
1^ ~ U
(These spaces occur in Kerzman-Nagel [1], with a(Q < 1/2.) Note, furthermore, that the g^s given by (2) depend linearly on f when a is fixed, and that they depend holomorphically on a when f is fixed. The proofs of the remaining cases (iv), (v), and Lip 1 depend on a more detailed look at the operators K^ of Theorem 6.5.4, where cp is any of the conjugate-holomorphic symbols that play a role in the definition of gf^, and that are defined on a neighborhood of B. Recall that (5)
VJ=cpf-TJ
and that (6)
iyj){z)
= f {cp{z) - 9(0}C(z, 0 / ( O M C ) . Js
IffeH"^ then V^fe C(B) (Theorem 6.5.4); by (5), this proves case (iv). Similarly, case (v) will follow from (7)
|(gradF^/)(z)|
since V^f is then in Lip ^, by Lemma 4.6.8, and the case a = 1 of (iii) will follow if we show that the above gradient is bounded in B, since then V^fe Lipl.
6.6. Gleason's Problem
117
The gradient of V^f is obtained by differentiating (6). Since it suffices to consider (8)
f {cp(z) - cpiO} Y,
/Vxxn^i
(peC^(B\
mdo{Q
for 1 < 7 < n. Since \(p(z) - (p(0\ < c|z - CI < 2c|l -
(9)
cii/Lii-
and now (7) follows, for / G //°°, by Proposition 1.4.10. Finally, suppose feA(B) n Lip 1, and extend / to a bounded Lip 1 — function on C", for instance by setting f{z) = f(z/\z\) when |z| > 1. Put z = reiin (8), without loss of generahty, and put (10)
.^(0 = •A,,;© = nCjMre,) -
Writing C = (Ci, C')> (8) is then the sum of (11)
f ,,
' ^ y , „ ^ i [/(Ci, O - fir, O]rf
and (by 1.4.7(2)) (12)
£
f(r,ndv„.,(n^f
HW, CO ^e.
(1 - r C i ^ - T
Since | / ( C ^ , 0 - / ( r , O I < c|Ci - r| <^c|l - rC,\ and |iA(C)l < k^i - CI < c| 1 — rCi r^^, (11) is bounded. Since cp is holomorphic, the inner integral in (12) is (/^(O, C'X so that the absolute value of (12) is at most 2n||/||oo II<)^HocThis completes the proof. 6.6.3. A Multiplier Theorem. We shall now consider the Ahern-Schneider solution in the special case a = 0. Differentiate the Cauchy formula 6.6.2(1) with respect to z^, then replace z by tz, and integrate over 0 < t < 1. Comparison with 6.6.2(2) shows that (1)
f{DJ)(tz)dt
= g,iO,z).
The Ahern-Schneider solution thus turns out to be identical with Leibenson's, when a = 0.
118
6. Boundary Behavior of Cauchy Integrals
If f(z) = ^ c(a)z'* (the summation extends over all multi-indices a), one computes easily that (2)
z, f W ) ( f z ) d t = Z
^c(a)z°'
where |a| = aj + • • • -h a„, as usual. In view of the properties of the functions ^^ that were estabhshed in §6.6.2, the following multiplier theorem emei:ges: For k = 1,..., n, the transformation (3)
Xc(a)z"-^E ^ c ( a ) z "
maps X into X, where X is any of the spaces A(B), H\B) A{B) n Lip a (0 < a < 1), H^{B\ or A(B, £, {a}). The same is true if the right side of (3) is divided by Zj,.
(1 < p < oo),
6.6.4. Homomorphisms of H'^(B). The fact that Gleason's problem can be solved in H°°(JB) has impHcations concerning the possible homomorphisms of the algebra H°^(B) (relative to pointwise multiplication) into any algebra of holomorphic functions. This is Theorem 6.6.5 below. Its proof also depends on the following two easy propositions: (a)
To each homomorphism A ofA(B) onto C corresponds a point weB such that A/ = f(w)for every feA(B). (b) / / Q is a region in C", F:Q^ C" is a holomorphic map with range in B, and F(wo) e S for some WQ e Q, then F is constant. Proof of (di). Let TC^ denote the ith coordinate function: ni(z) = Zf, 1 < i < n. Put Wf = ATCf, w = ( w i , . . . , w„). Thus ATC^ = TC^W). Since A is Hnear and multipHcative, it follows that A/ = f(w) for all polynomials / . Since A is a complex homomorphism of a Banach algebra, ||A|| = 1, and the fact that the polynomials are dense in A(B) implies now that A/ = /(w) for all / e A(B). Proof of (b). Put g(w) =
6.6. Gleason's Problem
119
Proof. The multiplicativity of T implies that Tl = 1. If z G Q, it follows that / - > (Tf)(z) is a homomorphisms of A(B) onto C. Hence there is a point il/(z) e B such that (Tf)(z) = /(Hz)) for ei\lfeA(B). In particular, n^oxj/ = Tn^.l < i < n. Thus i/^ is a holomorphic map, and since Tf ^ const, for some / e ^(B), i/^ cannot be constant. Hence i/^(Q) cz B. Now let feH'^{B), pick Z G Q , and apply the solution of Gleason's problem to / at the point a = ^{z)\ there are functions QI E H'^{B) such that
/-/(•/'(z))=
ti^i-UzM.
Apply T to this equation and evaluate at z: (TfXz) - m{z))
= t liTT^diz) i=l
U^mTgdiz).
Since Tui = j/^^, the right side is 0, and thus Tf = fo\j/. This proof is quite similar to one used by Ahern and Schneider [1]. Corollary. / / T is an automorphism of the algebra H'^(B), then Tf = foil/ for some ij/ G Aut(B). This follows if the theorem (with Q = B)is applied to both 7and T~^. The assumption that Tf is nonconstant for at least one / e A(B) is needed for the validity of the theorem. In fact, there exist homomorphisms of ff °°(C/) onto H'^iU) that send every member of the disc algebra to a constant. For a proof of this (which depends on the existence of analytic embeddings of U in "fibers" of the maximal ideal space of H'^(U)), we refer to pp. 166-169 Hoffman's book [1].
Chapter 7
Some L^-Topics
7.1. Projections of Bergman Type 7.1.1. A Class of Reproducing Kernels. Fix n > 1, write B„ for B, temporarily, let s be a nonnegative integer, and let P be the orthogonal projection of C""^^ onto C" (regarding C" as the subspace of C""^* defined by z„+ ^ = • • • = z^+s = 0). I f / e (L' n H){B„), the Bergman formula can be applied to fo PmB„+s'.
If zeBn then Pz = z,
r (1 - iwpy /(z) = c(n, 5) J^ ( ^ _ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ y . . . i /(wMv.(w).
The constants c(n, s) can be computed by taking / = l , z = Oin(l): (3)
l=c(n,s)
f
(l-\w\'ydv(w).
JBn
Reverting to our usual notation {B and v in place of 5„ and v„) we obtain the following analogues of the Bergman formula: (4)
''''-[«
\ ^KXz, w)/(w)iiv(w) w)/(H
(z G B)
where (5)
t ' (- uA _ ^sVZ, W) —
for s = 0, 1, 2,.... 120
(1 - iwpy - < z , w » " + ^+^
(z e J5, w e 5)
7.1. Projections of Bergman Type
121
Both (5) and the right side of (4) make perfectly good sense for arbitrary complex s = a -\- it (provided (T > — 1, for obvious integrability reasons), if the complex powers are understood to be the usual principal branches: both numerator and denominator in (5) are 1 when w = 0. The binomial coefficient in (4) is then r(n + s + 1) r ( n + l)r(s + 1)* This suggests the introduction of operators 7^ defined by (6)
(TJ)(z)=l
(°r)//=<^ j
jJCXz,w)f(w)dv(w)
for z e B , for Re s = (7 > —1, and for any fGL^(v) {not necessarily holomorphic) for which the integrands are in L^(v). One can now use a complex interpolation argument to prove that all of these operators have the reproducing property (4): 7.1.2. Proposition. IffeH'^(B)
and a > -1, then TJ = f and Tj = /(O).
(The restriction to /f * will be removed in Theorem 7.1.4.) Proof. The computation that yielded the value of c(n, s) in §7.1.1 was valid for all s with a > —1. Hence 7]1 = 1. To prove that T^f = f amounts therefore to showing that fU
r flHHf_?
/(W)-/(Z)
JB [1 - <2, vv>j (1 - <^z,wyy^^
,
for z e B, (J > —1. Regard z and / as fixed, and denote the integral (1) by H{s). Then H is holomorphic in the half-plane a > -1, and H(s) = 0 when s is a nonnegative integer, because of the reproducing formula 71.1(4). Since ^ "'""'' < 2 |l-
and
|arg(l -
there is a constant y = y(f, z) < oo such that (2)
\H(s)\ < yl'^e''^'^'^ Now define
(s = a + it, a > 0).
122
7. Some L^-Topics
Since 21 sin(7rs/2)| > | e^^'^ — e~'^^'^ |, G is a bounded holomorphic function in the half-plane c > 0. Since H vanishes at every positive integer, G vanishes at every odd positive integer. This zero-set of G violates the Blaschke condition for bounded holomorphic functions in a half-plane. Hence G is identically 0, and so is H. Thus (1) holds, and T^f = f. To evaluate 7^/, it is enough to consider the case /(O) = 0. Insert / into 7.1.1(6), use the explicit formula for K^z, w), and integrate in polar coordinates (§1.4.3). It is then easy to see that the integrals over S are 0, by the mean-value property of conjugate-holomorphic functions. 7.1.3. The Case s = n -\- 1. This case is particularly simple, because
(1)
\K„^,{z, w)\ = {j^^
l_|w|2
T T ^ ^
>+i
=
(JR
(see Theorem 2.2.6), so that (2)
\\K„^,(z,w)\dv(z)=l. JB
Consequently,
(3)
lj'--^i'"^C"r)Jyi*
for every feL^(v). Thus 7;,+ i is a bounded linear operator on L^(v), with range in (L^ n H)(B), Since /f °^(5) is dense in (L^ n H)(B), the conclusions of Proposition 7.1.2 hold i f / G (L^ n H){B). Hence T„+^ is a bounded linear projection ofL^{v) onto (L^ n H)(B). This is a special case of the next theorem, which says precisely on which L^ a given 7^ is bounded, or, equivalently, which 7^ are bounded on a given L^. Since KQ is the Bergman kernel, the theorem shows that the Bergman transform is not bounded on L^(v), but that it is bounded on L^(v) for 1 < P < 00.
7.1.4. Theorem (ForeUi-Rudin [1]) (a) For 1 < p < oo, Tg is a bounded linear operator on L^(v) if and only if (1)
Re(l + 5) > - . P
7.1. Projections of Bergman Type
(b)
123
/ / (1) holds then T, projects L^(v) onto {U n H){B): in fact
(2)
TJ = f and Tj = W)
for every
fe{UnH){B).
Proof. By Proposition 7.1.2, part (b) is an immediate consequence of (a), since H°°(B) is dense in {U n H)(B). The estimate (3)
e-^''l/2|X,(z, w)| < |K,(z, w)| < ^^'^'/^|X,(z, w)|
(where s = a + it, as before) will be used in the proof of (a); it holds because 1 —
sup
|X,(z, w)\dv(z) < 00.
By (3), we can replace s by a in (4), and now Proposition 1.4.10 implies that (4) fails when a = 0 but that (4) holds when a > 0. This proves (a) in the case p = I. If 1 < p < 00 and 1 + a < 1/p, then aq < —1, where 1/p + 1/q = 1. Hence (5)
\\KXz,w)\Uv(w)
= 00
for every zeB, and 7]/fails to exist for some / e L^(v). There remains the case l
hiz) = (1 - \z\'r^
1/p. Put c = 1/pq, and (zeB).
Since a — gc = tr — 1/p > — 1, Proposition 1.4.10 implies that (7)
r
r (1 - ivvp)""'"^
JjK„(z, w)|;,(w)*^v(w) = J ^ | i _ ^ ; J ) | . ^ i . . ^ H w ) < [«A(z)]«
124
7. Some L^-Topics
for some a = a(n, a, q) < oo. Also, pc = 1/q < 1 and a + pc = a + 1/q > 0, so that
(8)
jjKXz,w)\Kzydviz) = (1 - |w|Y
l^i^l^,]'Syr\..Mz)
< [bh(w)y for some b = b(n, a, q) < oo, by another application of 1.4.10. Now fix some / e L''(v), and put (9)
Fiz)=
f|K,(z,w)||/(w)|dv(w)
(zeB).
JB
By Holder's inequality and (7), Fiz)=
(10)
{\K„\''->h-\KJ'"'
dv
JB
p
"ji/p
(w)dv(M')
If we raise (10) to the pth power and apply (8), we obtain (11)
{F''dv
{\{\(w)dv(w) «
JB
<(' aby
{\K,(z,w)\h(zydv(z) JB
fi/rdv.
JB
If we combine (3), (9), and (11), we see that 7] is bounded on L^(v) if 1 < p < 00 and 1 -h o" > 1/p. This completes the proof. One consequence of the theorem just proved is that the L^(v)-norm of any holomorphic function in B is controlled by the corresponding norm of its real part: 7.1.5. Theorem. To every p, 1 < p < oo, corresponds a constant Mp = M^ „ < 00 with the following property: IffeH(B)J(0) = 0, M = R e / , then (1)
{\f\'dv<Mp
JB
JB
{\ufdv.
Proof. Fix p and choose s so that 1 + cr > 1/p. Then there exists >1 < oo such that IIT,^ lip < AII ^11 p for every g e L^(v). Apply this tog =f and g = f^
7.1. Projections of Bergman Type
125
(where /^z) = f(rz), 0 < r < 1, as usual). By Theorem 7.1.4, X = TXfr) = Ufr + /.) = ITXUrX SO that { IfA-dv = 2" \ \ Uu.Wdv
JB
JB
< {lAf
f luj" dv
JB
or (2)
f \f\Pdv < (2Ay f \u\P dv JrB JrB
(0 < r < 1).
Now (1) follows as r / * 1 in (2). 7.1.6. The real part of the function /(z) = f l o g ( l - z O is bounded in B, but its imaginary part is not. Theorem 7.1.5 can therefore not be extended to the case /? = oo. As in the proof of 7.1.5 shows, Theorem 7.1.4 also fails for p = oo, no matter what s we choose. 7.1.7. The Koranyi-Vagi theorem shows that Theorem 7.1.5 has an analogue in which integration over B is replaced by integration over S: There are constants Mp^„ < co, for l < p < o o , n = l , 2, 3 , . . . such that
(1)
{\f\''da<M,^J\u\''da
Js
Js
for every f = u -\- iv in H^{S) with v(0) = 0. In contrast to Theorem 7.1.5 this fails when p = 1 and n = 1; the functions (2)
/Xz) = y ^ T ^
(0 < r < 1)
show this. However, it is not known whether there exist constants M^ „ < oo for n = 2, 3, 4 , . . . , such that (1) holds. In other words, if 5 is (for example) the unit sphere in C^, it is not known whether (3)
sup|4q^
126
7. Some L^-Topics
where the supremum is taken over all holomorphic polynomials / # 0, with/(0) real, and w = Re / It seems quite likely that (3) is true when n > 1. This conjecture is closely related to the inner function problem which will be discussed in Chapter 19.
7.2. Relations between H^ and L^ r\H I.IA, Plurisubharmonic Functions. Let Q be a region in C". An upper semicontinuous function M:Q -• [—oo, oo) is said to be plurisubharmonic if to each a G Q and b G C" corresponds a neighborhood F of 0 in C such that (1)
2 -> M(a + lb)
is subharmonic in V. Less precisely, the restrictions of u to all complex Hues should be subharmonic. The most obvious examples of plurisubharmonic functions are l o g | / | and l / r ( c > 0), for any / e //(Q). The slice-integration formula shows that every plurisubharmonic function M in Q is subharmonic in Q (see the proof of Proposition 1.5.4) and that therefore AM > 0, provided, of course, that u e C^. When Q. = B, the class of plurisubharmonic functions is Moebius invariant. It follows that every plurisubharmonic u e C^(B) satisfies (2)
AM
> 0 and
AM
> 0.
Contrary to what one might expect by analogy with Theorem 4.4.9, (the equivalence of (b) and (c)), this last statement does not have a converse (at least not when n > 2): The function (3)
M(Z) = ZjZi + Z2Z2 -
Z3Z3
has AM = 4 and Au = 4(1 - |z|^)(l - M) > 0 in B, but M(0, 0, W) = - 1 wl^ is not subharmonic. Plurisubharmonic functions will play an important role in Chapter 17. They are also closely related to the characterization of domains of holomorphy (see, for instance, §2.6 in Hormander [2]). At present, we only need the following inequality. Its statement uses the familiar notation z = (z', z„) for zeB„, where z' = (z^,..., Z „ _ I ) E B „ _ I . 7.2.2. Proposition. Ifu is plurisubharmonic in JB„ (n > 1) and M > 0, then (1)
f ^Bn-i
M(Z^OMV„_I(Z')<
sup 0 < r < l 'JS
\u(rOda(0
7.2. Relations between H^ and U r\ H
111
where S is the boundary ofB„. If , furthermore, u(z\ z„) is a harmonic function ofz„,for every z' eB„_i, then equality holds in (1). Notes, (i) The assumption w > 0 can be removed. It is made because its presence assures the existence of all integrals that occur in the proof and it allows us to apply Fubini's theorem without any argument. (ii) The integrals on the right of (1) are nondecreasing functions of r, since u is subharmonic. The supremum is therefore equal to the limit, as Proof. To each z'sB^-i 0 < r < 1, (2)
corresponds a
Z „ G C SO
that {z\z^eS.
For
u{rz\ 0) < ^ J " u{rz\ rz^e'^Q,
since u is plurisubharmonic. By formula 1.4.7(2), it follows that (3)
f
u(rz\ 0)dv„_ i(zO < f u(rOdcT(0.
JSn-i
JS
Setting rz' = w\ the left side of (3) is seen to be I
JrBn- 1
u(w\, <0)dv(w').
Hence (1) follows from (3) as r y 1. If M(Z', Z„) is harmonic in z„, then equality holds in (2), hence also in (3) and (1). 7.2.3. Restrictions and Extensions. With B„ and B„_i as above, let / and g be functions with domains B„ and B„_ i, respectively, and define a restriction operator p and an extension operator E by (1)
(p/)(z') = / ( z ' , 0)
(2)
(Eg)(z\z„) = g(z')
(Z'G5„_,), (zeB„).
Since {pEg){z') = (Eg)(z\ 0) = g(z'\ pE is the identity operator. 7.2.4. Theorem. Assume n > l , 0 < p < o o . (a) (b)
The extension E is a linear isometry of(L^ n H)(B„_ j) into H^(B„). The restriction p is a linear norm-decreasing map of H^(B„) onto (UnH)(B,.,).
Proof Apply Proposition 7.2.2 to the plurisubharmonic function u = | / | ^ where / 6 //(B). This gives (a) and most of (b). The fact that p(H%B„)) is all of (U n H)(B„-1) follows from (a) and the identity pEg = g.
128
7. Some L^-Topics
Note: An analogue of this result holds in polydiscs, for restrictions to the diagonal, but it is not quite so easy. See Rudin [1], pp. 53, 69, DurenShields [1], Horowitz-Oberlin [1], J. H. Shapiro [1], Moulin-Rosay [1], and Detraz [1]. 7.2.5. Theorem. Suppose n > 1, 0 < p < oo. (a)
lffeH\B,)then
(1)
1/(^)1 <2''/^ll/IWl-1^1)-"/^
and (2)
lim(l-|z|r/^|/(z)HO
{ZEB;).
|z|-l
(b) Iffe(L^
n H)(B„) then (1) and (2) hold with n replaced by n -\- 1.
Proof. Assume fEH^(B„). Theorems 5.6.2 and 5.6.3 show that | / | ^ has an ^-harmonic majorant u = P\_dfi], where /x is a positive measure on 5 whose total mass is ||/||^. The estimate n^
P^ n
(1 - \z\'T
^ [1 + \z\
therefore yields (1). If we apply (1) to / — X ^^ place o f / and recall that | | / — /r||p ^ 0 as r / 1 (Theorem 5.5.6), we obtain (2). Next, '\ife(U n //)(5„), (a) can be applied to the function EfeHP(B„+ J ; see Theorem 7.2.4. This gives (b). Notes: (i) When p > 1, Theorem 7.2.5 can be proved more directly by applying Holder's inequality to the Cauchy formula and the Bergman formula, respectively. (ii) If c < n/p and / ( z ) = (1 - z^y then feH\B„\ by Proposition 1.4.10. The exponents that occur in (1) and (2) can therefore not be replaced by smaller ones. 7.2.6. In several complex variables it is much harder to construct functions that exhibit interesting phenomena than it is in one. The required techniques are not sufficiently developed. We shall now present two rather modest examples (7.2.9 and 7.2.10) that illustrate the possible boundary behavior of functions in H^(B„) and in (L^ n H)(B„X for n = 2 and n = 3. Similar examples undoubtedly exist when n >3, but different constructions would be required for them.
7.2. Relations between H^ and L^ n H
129
The following "scrambling lemma" works, however, for all n. It is basically due to Calderon (see Zygmund [3], Vol. II, p. 165) and to Stein [5; p. 146]. 7.2.7. Lemma. Suppose {/J is a sequence of Borel functions on S,0 < f < 1, and t
(1)
\ftdcr=cx>.
1 = 1 Js
Then there exist unitary Ui such that O O Y.fi(UiO = oo a.e. on S.
(2)
i=l
Proof. Let ^ = ^(n) be the unitary group on C", and let ^°° be the cartesian product of countably many copies of ^ , with the Tychonoff topology, so that ^"^ is a compact group whose Haar measure is the usual product of the Haar measures of the copies of %. Consider the function (3)
giC,{Ui})=f[U-MU^o^ i=l
on S X %'^. The definition of the product measure dU on ^"^ shows, for any CeS, that (4)
f g(L {U,})du =f[
f [1 -
f^u.oidUi.
By Proposition 1.4.7(3), (4) is the same as
(5)
f 0(c, {t/,})dc/= n [ i - f/i^4 i=i L
Jm^
^s
J
By (1), this infinite product is 0. Since gf > 0, Fubini's theorem implies now that (6)
[gii. {^J)d^(0 = 0
Js
for almost all {[/J G^°^. For any such choice of {(7J, ^(C, {t/J) = 0 for almost all ^eS, and therefore (2) holds. 7.2.8. Proposition. For z = ( z j , . . . , z„) G C", define F,(z) = n''"(zi-.-2„)^''
(/c = l , 2 , 3 , . . . ) .
130
7. Some L'-Topics
Then (i) \F^(z)\
This gives (i). By 1.4.9, the integral in (ii) is n^%n- 1)1 (kiy (n - 1 + nk)\ Hence (ii) follows from Stirling's formula, and (iii) is just (ii) with 2k in place of k. Since F^ is homogeneous of degree Ink, an integration in polar coordinates shows that
b'^^'''=Thkb'^^''^Thus (iii) impHes (iv). 7.2.9. Example. There is an feH^(B) (when n = 2, 3) such that almost no slice function /^ has a Taylor series that converges absolutely on the closed unit disc: Whenn = 2 or 3, Proposition 7.2.8 shows that there exists {Cfc},0 < c^ < 1, such that 00 /• (1)
X
\CkFk\d(j = 00
but
(2)
£ { \c,F,\'da < c^. k=i
Js
(Take c^ = k' ^'^ if n = 2, c^ = l/log(/c + 2) if n = 3.)
7.2. Relations between H^ and L^ n H
131
Since Ic^Ffcl < 1, it follows from Lemma 7.2.7 that there exist JJ^e'^ such that (3)
I kfeF,([/,OI = cx) a.e. on 5. fc=i
If/(z) = YJ ^k^ki^k^X the orthogonahty of the functions F^ ° U^ in shows that feH^(BX by (2). Finally, note that (4)
L^((T)
f,W=t^kFk(U,0^'"\
If C satisfies (3) then the series (4) does not converge absolutely on the unit circle. 7.2.10. Example. There is an feiL^n
H){B) (when n = 2,3) such that
sup |/(rOI = 00
0
for almost all C^S: When w = 2 or 3, Proposition 7.2.8 shows that 00 /• (1)
X
i n i ' ^v < a,
whereas (2)
X
UF,\'da=<x.
Since [F^l < 1, it follows from Lemma 7.2.7 that there exist such that (3)
U^e^
I i n ( ^ . O I ' = cx) a.e. on 5. fe=i
Now let {(pk(t)} be the Rademacher functions (independent random variables that take the values + 1 with probabihty ^) and define (4)
gt(z)=Y.
(0
Since the functions Fj, o JJ^ are mutually orthogonal in L^(v), (1) shows that every gt belongs to (L^ n H)(B).
132
7. Some L^-Topics
If Ce5 satisfies (3), it follows from a well-known theorem about Rademacher series that (5)
sup|^,(rC) = sup I
Fk(UuOr''''(p,it) — 00
for almost all t e [0, 1]. (See Zygmund [3], vol. II, pp. 212, 205.) By Fubini's theorem, it is therefore true for almost every t that the supremum in (5) is oo for almost all C e S. Putting f = Qt for such a value of t gives our example. 7.2.11. Example, li feH^(B2\ function of/ satisfies (1)
Theorem 7.2.4(b) implies that every slice
fl/c(A)P^v(A)< 11/11
the norm on the right being the //^-norm of/ In particular, the left side of (1) is a bounded function of C on S. One may ask whether there is a converse to this, i.e., whether H^ can be characterized by the slice functions forming a bounded set in the Bergman space. The answer is negative: Put F^{z) = (2zlZ2)^ for /c = 1, 2, 3, As in Proposition 7.2.8, (2)
Js
whereas another simple computation gives (3)
f |F,(AOP^v(A) =
Ju
\F,{0\' ^ 1 < 2/c + 1 " 2/c + 1
for every C e S. If c^ G C is chosen so that
and if / = J^c^F^, then (2) shows that / is not in H^(B2\ although (5) for every C^S.
r |/,(A)p dv(X) < 1 Ju
7.3. Zero-Varieties
133
7.3. Zero-Varieties 7.3.1. Introduction. If Q is a region in C" and / G / / ( Q ) , we write Z ( / ) for the set of all z e Q at which /(z) = 0. We call a set E cz Q a zero-variety in Q if £ = Z ( / ) for some feH(QX / # 0. If X is a subspace of /f(Q) and E = Z(f) for some / G X, / # 0, then £ is said to be a zero-variety for X. At the other extreme, E is said to be a determining set for X if the assumptions feX,Ecz Z(f) force / = 0. The local structure of zero-varieties is described by the Weierstrass preparation theorem (Chapter 14). The present section is devoted to quantitative global properties of zero varieties of certain subspaces of H{BX with special emphasis on the differences that exist between the case n = 1 and the cases n > 1. When n = 1, the zero-varieties in U are precisely the discrete subsets of U. Such a set £ is a zero-variety for H'^(U) (hence also for all H^{U) and for the Nevanhnna class N{U)) ii E = {a J satisfies the Blaschke condition Y,{\-
la,.I) < 00.
Conversely, £ is a determining set for iV(t/) (hence also for all H\U\ including H'^(U)) if £ violates the Blaschke condition. (Duren [1], Hoffman [1], Rudin [3], etc.) We turn ton > LA recent very impressive theorem, proved independently by Henkin and by Skoda, characterizes the zero-varieties of N(B) by an analogue of the Blaschke condition. This forms the subject of Chapter 17. One result of the present section (Theorem 7.3.8) is that to distinct values of p correspond distinct classes of zero-varieties. But no characterizations of any of these classes are obtained. In view of some examples, it seems quite unlikely that any reasonably simple characterizations can exist. Theorem 7.3.3 gives a simple necessary condition, which is however very far from being sufficient. In one variable, zeros of holomorphic functions can occur with multipHcities greater than 1. The Blaschke condition is usually stated so as to take these multiphcities into account. When n > 1, one can also assign multiplicities (positive integers) to the irreducible branches (we shall not define this) of a zero-variety. This leads to the concept of a divisor. The introduction of divisors can be avoided by the following simple device which will accompHsh the same thing for us: Two functions fge H(B) are said to have the same zeros if both f/g and g/f are holomorphic in B, i.e., if / = gh^ and g = //I2, with /i^, h2eH(B). Having the same zeros is clearly an equivalence relation, and many properties involving zeros (such as the consequences of Jensen's formula discussed in §7.3.2) depend only on the equivalence class to which a function belongs. Some of our results will be stated for the spaces H^(B) defined in §5.6.1.
134
7. Some L^-Topics
7.3.2. Counting Functions. \{ feH{U\ the customary notation for the number of zeros of/(counted with multipUcities) in the disc rC/is ny(0-If/(O) "^ 0> there is also the integrated counting function f
dt n/0Jo '
Nf(r)=
(1)
(0
Jensen's formula (see Titchmarsh [1], p. 126) expresses Nf(r) directly in terms of/: (2)
Nfir) = - J
l o g i / ( r O M e - log|/(0)|.
Assume now that feH{B\ and /(O) = 1 for simplicity. For each (,eS, let nj(C, 0 and A/^/C? 0 be associated to the shce function /^ in the above manner. Thus (3)
N/C, '•) = ^ f
log|/(/-e'''0|de
(0 < r < 1).
Note that both sides of (3) are unchanged iff is replaced by some g e H(B) which has the same zeros as f {provided that g(0) = 1 ) . If (p is any nonnegative increasing convex function on (— oo, oo), Jensen's inequality leads from (3) to (4)
(piNfiC, r)) < ^ J '
cp(\og\f(re''0\)dQ
and if (4) is integrated over S one obtains (5)
f cpiNfiC, r))dc7iO < f cpQog I / 1 )dG, Js Js
by 1.4.7. Since N/(C» r) increases as r increases, the monotone convergence theorem leads from (5) to the inequality (6)
[(^(AT/C, 1)^^7(0 < sup
0 < r < l Js
Js
L(\og\f\)da.
This provides a necessary condition which the zeros of certain holomorphic functions must satisfy (Weyland [1]): 7.3.3. Theorem. Suppose f e H(B\ f(0) = 1. The inequality
(1)
{cp(N^c,m
7.3. Zero-Varieties
135
holds then iff e H^(B), In particular,
(2)
jN/C,l)MO
iff is in the Nevanlinna class N{B), and (3) iffeH\E)for
Jexp{piV/C, l)}dG(0 < O) some p,0 < p < GO.
Part (1) was proved above. The case (p(x) = x'^ gives (2), and (p(x) = e^"^ gives (3). The Henkin-Skoda theorem that was mentioned in §7.3.1 gives a converse of (2): / / f satisfies (2), then f has the same zeros as some g e N(B). (Chapter 17.) On the other hand, (3) does not ensure that / has the same zeros as some geH\B). We shall see this in §7.3.5, after the following theorem, which (for n = \) occurs in Shapiro-Shields [1]. Points of B will be written in the form Z = ( Z i , Z'),
Z' =
(Z2,...,Z„).
7.3.4. Theorem. Suppose S(l — x^) = oo, where 0 < x,- < 1 for all i, and let E he the set of all ZEB that have z^ e {x,}. / / / G H{B) satisfies the growth condition (1)
|/(z)|<exp|^—^|,, =3 E, then / = 0.
for some c < oo and some oc < j , and ifZ(f)
Note that £ is a countable union of balls of complex dimension n — 1, and that E is the zero-variety of some holomorphic function in B that depends only on z^. The theorem asserts that £ is a determining set for the class of functions described by (1). Proof Let Q be the set of all w G 5 with (2)
|2wi-l|
and
|w'|<|l-Wi|.
Fix w G Q. Since Q is a nonempty open set, it is enough to prove that /(w) = 0. Define (3)
h(X)
/I + A
1-A
\
^. ^^^
136
7. Some ^''-Topics
Put 5 = 1 — | w ' p | l - Wi|"^.ThenO < ^ < LA simple computation shows that (4)
4(1 - \h(re'%\^) = 2(1 - r^) + 3(1 - 2r cos Q + r^) > d sin^ 0
for 0 < r < 1,161 < n:. It follows that h maps U into B, so that one can define (5)
g(X) = fiHX))
(XeU).
By (1) and (4), (6)
^og\g(re«>)\ < ^ "^ ,>eM2 1 - \h(re'^)\ <1^f=^^l^'"®l
for 0 < r < 1, |0| < TT. Since a < | , (6) implies that g e N{U). Next, note that (7)
9(2.
^"'•-^^=^(^"r^^') = «
for all U since Z(f) => E. The sequence {2xj — 1} violates the Blaschke condition. Since g e N(U\ it follows that g(X) = 0 for all A G C/. In particular, 2wi — 1 G (7, so that (8)
/(w) = f(w,, wO = g(2w, - 1) = 0.
7.3.5. Example. If n > 1, there is a function g G H(B) such that
(a)
J^exp{pN,(C,l)}MO < 00
for every p < oo, although (b) no product of the form f = gh (with h e H(B)) satisfies a growth condition of the form 7.3.4(1), unless h = 0. In particular, no feH^{B) has the same zeros as g. To construct g, put Xi,= \ — {k log k)'^ for fc = 3,4, 5 , . . . , let G be any holomorphic function in U with simple zeros at precisely the points x^, and put g{z) = g(z^, z') = G(z^). Since 1(1 - x^) = oo, Theorem 7.3.4 shows that g has property (b). To prove (a) we need an upper estimate for iV^(C, !)• For C^S, rigiC, t) is the number of A's in tU such that ACi G {XJ,}. This is the number of /c's such thatXj, < t\Ci\, i.e., such that /clog fc <
i-fKil
7.3. Zero-Varieties
137
If /clog /c = A, then A < k^, hence A log kr
k = z
<
2A log A
Taking ^ = (1 - t|Ci | ) " \ it follows that 2 "«(^'^)<(l_(|^J)10g{l/(l-f|(J)}Since Jo
^
it follows that NJC, 1) < c log log
1-ICil
for some c < oo and all |Ci I sufficiently close to 1. Hence exp{pJV,(C, 1)} < ^log This implies (a). 7.3.6. Example. Suppose V^ and V2 are zero-varieties in B, V^ a V2, and V2 is a zero-variety for some class X c H(B). In some sense this imposes a restriction on the size of V2, and one might expect that V^ should therefore also be a zero-variety for X. But it need not be: Take n = 2, write (z, w) in place of (z^, Z2). Fix p > 0, let m be an integer, m > 4/p. Put Z) = { ( z , 0 ) : | z | < l } , r, = l - 2 - ^
E, = E=
/c= 1,2,3,...,
{iz,w)eB:zeT^}, Ij E,.
138
7. Some L^-Topics
Each Efc is the union of m2^ discs "in the w-direction" and D is a disc orthogonal to those that make up E. This example has the following properties: (a) £ is a zero-variety, (b) EVJD = Z(h) for some h e A(B\ but (c) no ^ G HP(B) has Z(g) = E.
The proof of (a) and (b) uses the product
Since (rfc)^" > | , we have 00
CO
(2) \P{z)\ < n of{1I's+ in4'"|zr2'} - 1expansion + ^4'"^<^>|zr where c{t) is the number the binary of t. Thus c{t) < log t + 1/log 2, so that
(3)
^
c
ip(z)i> 1 + I (r + i)''"izr <(1-lzl)^--^^
Since P{z) = 0 if and only if z G T^ for some k, the function g(z, w) = P(z) estabUshes (a). Since |wp < 1 - |z|^ in B, the function (4)
/i(z, w) = w^'^+^PCz)
estabhshes (b), because of (3). To prove (c), suppose g e H{B\ Z(g) ZD £, but ^(0) = 1. (Note that 0 ^ E.) Putting /(z) = g(z, 0), Theorem 7.2.4(b) shows that it suffices to prove that (5)
(\ffdv=^. Ju As in §7.3.2,
(6)
f f dt 1 r J nf(t)dt < J n / 0 j = 2^ J log|/(re^'«)Me.
7.3. Zero-Varieties
139
Multiply (6) by p, exponentiate, apply the geometric vs. arithmetic mean inequahty on the right, multiply by r dr, and integrate: (7)
£ jexp j\nf(t)dt\r
dr < ^ jjf\^r
dr dQ.
If 7 < t < 1, then Tfc < t < rfc+1 for some k. Since / has m2^ zeros in 7^, it follows that (8)
prifit) > pm2' >
4 > 1 — r^
2 -. 1— r
The left side of (7) is thus oo, and (5) is proved. Note. Each of the m2^ discs in Ej, has radius (1 -riy/2
^2-^'-'^^^
so that the area of E^ is about 2nm, for every k. Thus (b) shows that E u D is a zero-variety for A(B\ of infinite area. No such example seems to be known when n > 2 (where "area" must of course be replaced by (2n — 2)-dimensional volume), even with H'^{B) in place of A{B). The following lemma will be used in the proof of Theorem 7.3.8. 7.3.7. Lemma. Suppose (a) n is a finite positive measure on a set Q; (b) V is a real measurable function on Q, with 0 < y < 1 a.e., whose essential supremum is 1; (c) 0 is a continuous nondecreasing real function on [0, oo), 0(0) = 0, 0(x) -^ CO as X -^ ao\ (d) 0 < ^ < 00, 0 < t < 00. Then there exist constants c^ e (0, oo\for k = 1, 2, 3 , . . . , such that (1)
{ ^(c,v')dfi = S.
//I a I < 1 and i/1^ = 1^(0 is the set of all coeQat which Ckv\aj) > t, then (2) lim Ck(x^ = 0 k->^oo and (3)
hm f ^(CkV^)dfi = S.
140
7. Some L^-Topics
Proof. The monotone convergence theorem shows that (4)
c-^
\^(cv^)dfi
is, for each k, a continuous mapping of [0, oo) onto [0, oo) which carries 0 to 0. Hence (1) holds for some c^ e (0, oo). Assume |a| < j5 < 1, and let E be the set of all co e Q at which v(co) > fi. Since the essential supremum of r is 1, ix{E) > 0. Also, (5)
This shows that {cj,fi^}is a bounded sequence, and (2) holds because \OL\ < p. To prove (3), define 0 GkioS) - ^ _ , Ckv\o))
(6)
if if
ojsY^ co^Yj,.
Then 0 < g^ < t. Since 0 < r < 1 a.e., (2) implies that gk(co) -^ 0 a.e. on Q. Thus (7)
f
^(c,v')dfi=
{Q>(g,)dfi^O
as /c ^ 00, by the dominated convergence theorem. Now (3) follows from (l)and(7). 7.3.8. Theorem. Fix n > 1. Assume that (p and ij/ are nonconstant, nonnegative, nondecreasing convex functions defined on (—oo, oo), and that \l/(t) -^-^+00 (p(t)
(1)
as
r^+oo.
Suitably chosen points Ci^-S', positive integers /Cf, and positive numbers a^ produce then a function (2)
/(z)= n(l-a.
such that (i) feH^iBXbut (ii) ifb e H-(B), g e H(B), 3 # 0, and (3)
h = if + b)g
then some constant multiple of h fails to be in H^(B).
7.3. Zero-Varieties
141
The classes H^(B) were defined in §5.6.1. Some comments on the theorem will follow its proof, which, for convenience, is spUt into four steps. Step 1. We claim that there exist nonempty circular sets K and X^ (i = 1, 2, 3,...) on S such that (a) K is compact, a(K) > 0, (b) the sets X^ are pairwise disjoint open subsets of S\K, and (c) every circular open subset of S that intersects K contains infinitely many X,.. The standard projection TT of S onto the complex projective space P of dimension n — 1 provides an easy way to see this. By definition, n(0 = n(rj) if and only if rj = e'^C for some real 9; a set £ c P is open if and only if TT" ^(E) is open in 5; and a(n~^(E)) defines a Borel measure on P. Now let K' be a compact subset of P, of positive measure, with empty interior, let {pj be a sequence of distinct points in P\K' whose set of subsequential Umits is exactly K\ pick pairwise disjoint neighborhoods X- of p,- that do not intersect K\ and define
Step 2. We now construct / . It will be convenient to assume that (4)
(p(t) = 0 if
t
To see that this involves no loss of generaHty, put (Pi(t) = (p(t) — (p(l) if t > 1, and put (p^(t) = 0 if t < 1. Then cp - cp^ is bounded, hence H^ = H^^, and (pi satisfies (4). For t > 0, define (5)
0 ( 0 = (pil + log(l + 0),
^ ( 0 = ^(1 + log(l + 0).
By (1), there are numbers ti > i (i = 1, 2, 3,,..) such that (6)
^ ( 0 > m(t)
if
t>ti.
Let the sets Xj be as in Step 1. For each f, pick d^^iWe now apply Lemma 7.3.7, with (5, a) in place of (Q, //), with v(z) = I
Ft(z) = a,{z,Ciy'
(zeC")
142
7. Some L^-Topics
we have
(8) (9)
fo(|F,|y(7 = | ,
Js \Fi(z)\<2-'
^
if zeS\Xi
(10)
and if
|z| < 1 - ^, I
r 0(|f,|>i(r > 4,
where 7^ = {CeS: |Fi(OI > h}. We define (11)
f(z)=f[(l-F,{z))
(zeB).
This product has the form (2). Because of (9), the product converges uniformly on compact subsets of B (thus / e H{B)\ and it is 0 only where one of the factors is 0. Note also that Y^ <= Jf,-, by (9), and that (6) and (10) imply (12)
f 4^(1^,1)^.7 > / .
Step 3. To prove that / e i/^(B), put (13)
M^{z) = n ii - Fii^)i
^ ( ^ ) = n {1 + i^^(^)i}-
Note that Y\{\ + 2~') < e x p ( ^ 2 " 0 = e. Since the sets X, are disjoint, (9) imphes therefore that
By (4) and (5), it follows that (15)
[0 ^O°g^(0)^^^(l^^.|)
in S\UX.. .„ ^^
Hence (8) implies (16)
{ip{\ogM)dG<
f
|<4.
7.3. Zero-Varieties
143
Mjv is the absolute value of a holomorphic function. Hence log M^ is subharmonic, for each AT, and so is (p{\og M^vX since (p is convex and nondecreasing. For 0 < r < 1, it follows that (17)
f (p(\og MM))dc7(0
< f (p(log M^)dG < 4.
If we fix r and let N -> oo, M^{r(,) -> | / ( r O | uniformly on S. Hence (17) gives (18)
J'
\ cp{\og\fA)dG < A
(0
Thus/E//^(B). S^^p 4. We now prove part (ii). Suppose b e H°^iB), g e H{B\ h = (f -\- b)g, and ^ # 0. Then ^ = G^ + G^+i 4- • • •, where each G^ is a homogeneous polynomial of degree i, and G^ ^ 0. Referring to Step 1, a(K) > 0, hence G^(0 T*^ 0 for some C^K. Since |G^(^'®0| = |G^(OI for all real 9, |G^| is bounded from 0 on some circular open subset of S that intersects K. By Step 1, there is a ^ > 0 and there is an infinite set J of natural numbers, such that (19)
|GJOI>^
if CeX,
and
ieJ.
We shall see that ch is not in H^(B) if c = 16e/3, by factoring (20)
ch =
Se(f-\-b)-23-'g.
Since ti -> oo (see (6)) we may, after discarding at most finitely members of J, assume that (21)
t,>5
+ S\\b\\^
(ieJ),
We now fix7 G J and choose r = r(J) < 1 so that (22)
2r>l
and
(1 - r^O 11^^,11 oo < L
Fix C^Yj and put (23)
y(X) = 2S-n-"^g(X0
Then 7 e i / ( l / ) , |y(0)| = 2d-'\G^(0\ 25-'\g(re'%)\
(XeU)
> 2 > r"=
ny(re'%
144
7. Some L^-Topics
and the subharmonicity of log 171 implies therefore that (24)
^ j ^ log 12(5 - 'gire'%) \ dQ > log | r-y(O) | > 0.
Next we note that
(25)
n(i-2--)>i 1=1
If C e Y; and I A| = r, it follows from (9) and (11) that 4|/(A0I > \FjiXO\ - 1 = r*'|f/OI - 1 > \FjiO\ - 2, by (22). Since IF/OI > tj on Yj, (21) implies now that (26)
8|/(A0 + b(AOI > 2 | F / 0 I - 4 - 8||Z>|L > 1 + 1^/01
By (20), (24), and (26), (27)
^ J " log I ch(re'''01 ^6 > log{e(l + | F/QI )}•
Since ij/ is convex and nondecreasing, Jensen's inequality leads from (27) to (28)
^ I " ./.(log I cHre'^O I )rfe > W( \ F / 0 1 )•
This holds for every C^Yj. If we integrate (28) over Yj and recall the rotation-invariance of a, (12) shows that (29)
f il/(\og\cHrO\)d(T(0
>I
JYJ
This was done for fixed r = r(j). But (29) impHes obviously that (30)
sup
U(\og\cHrO\)d(T(0
>j
for every j e J. The left side of (30) is therefore infinite, and we have proved that chis not in H^. 7.3.9. Remarks, (a) The appearance of a "constant multiple" may be a bit puzzHng in the conclusion of Theorem 7.3.8. The phrase may be omitted
7.4. Pluriharmonic Majorants
145
when \l/ satisfies the growth condition Mt + 1) (1)
Hm s u p —77-T— < 00
since H^(B) is then closed under scalar multiplication. In that case, the conclusion is simply that h ^ H^(B), The case (p(t) = exp(eO, il/(t) = (p(t + 1), shows the need for the "constant multiple": For every / G i / ^ we have e'^feH^. Thus H^ and H^ have the same zero-varieties, although \j/{t)/q){t) ^ 00 as t -> 00. (b) Theorem 7.3.8 states that no "bounded perturbation" f -\- b oi f has the same zeros as any member of H^(B), Letting b range over the constants, this gives some information about the level sets of/, or, in other words, about the distribution of values of/. (c) Fixp,0 < p < 00, and define (2)
(p(t) = e'\
m
= (2 + p^t^K.
Then ij/ is convex and increasing, H^ = H^, and H^ c H^ for all q > p. Since ij/ satisfies (1), Theorem 73.S furnishes anfe H^(B) whose zero-variety is a determining set for every H\B) with q > p. (d) With a gap series in place of a product. Theorem 7.3.8 appears in Rudin [9]. An earlier result, for polydiscs, is due to Miles [1]; it strengthened Theorem 4.1.1 of Rudin [1]. Similar theorems have also been proved for Bergman spaces, by Horowitz [1] and J. H. Shapiro [2].
7.4. Pluriharmonic Majorants 7.4.1. Introduction. If Q is a region in C" and 0 < p < 00, Lumefs Hardy space (LHYiQ) is defined to consist of all feH(a) such that | / | ^ < w for some pluriharmonic u. (Lumer [1].) Whenn = 1, pluriharmonic is the same as harmonic, so that this definition coincides with the classical one that involves harmonic majorants. But when n > 1, then (Lif)^(Q) is a proper subclass of what is usually called H^(Q); see Stein [2], Stout [5], for instance. The use of pluriharmonic majorants leads to some appeahng function-theoretic properties of (LH)^(Q); from the standpoint of functional analysis, however, (LHy(B) has some unexpectedly pathological properties, as we shall see presently; for example, {LHy{B) is not even a Hilbert space. One appealing property is what may be called holomorphic invariance: IfQ>: Qi ^ Q2 is holomorphic and f e (LHy(Q2) then / o O 6 (LHf (Qj). This is trivial, for if u is pluriharmonic, so is w o O, simply because u is locally the real part of a holomorphic function (Theorem 4.4.9).
146
7. Some L^-Topics
As regards zeros, (LHy(Q) behaves much better than H%B) does: / / Q is simply connected, then every fe(LHy(Q) has the same zeros as some heH'^iO). This is a corollary of the following result: 7.4.2. Proposition. Suppose Q is a simply connected region in C" and f e H(Q). Then f has the same zeros as some h G H * ( Q ) if and only if there is age H(Q) such that (1)
log|/|
Proof If (1) holds, put h = f-Qxp(—g). Then |/z| < 1 and h has the same zeros as /.Conversely, if he//°°(Q) has the same zeros as / , then f/h is a zero-free holomorphic function which has a holomorphic logarithm g, since Q is simply connected. 7.4.3. For most of the remainder of this section we confine ourselves to the case Q = B, n > 1. In addition to the difference in zero-varieties that we just saw, there are at least two other ways of seeing that {LHy{B) is a rather small subclass of H\B). The first of these involves rates of growth. If w is a positive pluriharmonic function in J5, then each slice function u^ is a positive harmonic function in U, hence u^{X) < 2w(0)/(l - \X\). lffe(LHy(B), it follows that (1)
\f(z)\
(zeB)
for some c = c(f) < oo. This is much more restrictive than the corresponding H^ bound (Theorem 7.2.5). For instance, if 1/p < t < n/p, and g(z) = (1 - z j then g e H\B) but g i (LHy{B). The second difference involves the norm
(2)
\\\f\\\, = Mu(Oy"',
the infimum being taken over all pluriharmonic majorants of | / | ^ in B. As pointed out by Lumer [1], it is easy to prove that this norm turns {LHy(B) into a Banach space if p > 1. If WfWp and ll/Jp denote the norms of / and /^ in H^iB) and if^((7), respectively, it follows that (3)
11/11
|jjl/cll?M0j'
7.4. Pluriharmonic Majorants
147
by slice-integration of | / | ^ whereas (4)
lll/lllp>sup||/,||,
since u^ is a harmonic majorant of | / J ^ for every u that competes in (2). There is a variant of (4) in which equality holds, and in which the right side is replaced by an expression that involves all representing measures of the origin (not just those that come from slices). This will be taken up in Section 9.7. EquaHty need not hold in (4). In fact, the left side may be oo although the right side is finite: 7.4.4. Example. When n = 2, there is a n / e H^(B) which extends continuously to B except for one boundary point, such that
(1)
l/(rA)prfe
^f
for allC e 5, 0 < r < 1, although / is not in (LHyiB): Writing (z, w) in place of (z^, Z2), define (2) let c^>0 (3)
g^(z,w) =
(l-zr--'w'-^\
satisfy fc^-l
but
m=1
fm^/^4=oo, m=1
and put (4)
f{z.y^)=Y.cJ
m=l
\ ^ J
^.fevv).
To see an example of (3), put c^ = 0 unless m is a power of 16. If m = 16'', put c , = 2-'^ (/c = 1,2,3,...). The proof that (4) defines a function with the desired properties is as follows. First, we claim, for 0 < (5 < 1, that (5)
l^.fevv)|<(^)''\2-^)\ /
for all (z, W)eB that satisfy 11 — z| > ^. Indeed, since | wp < 1 — |z|^ in 5, (6)
\gJ,z,w)\<\\-z\--\\-\z\'r^'l\
148
7. Some L^-Topics
On the set defined by |z| < 1, 11 — z| > 5, the right side of (6) attains its maximum at the point z = 1 — 3. This gives (5). By Stirhng's formula, (7)
0
Hence (5) shows that the mth term in (4) is dominated by a constant times
if 11 — z I > <5. Thus / is continuous on B, except at the point (1, 0). Next, we claim that
for C e 5, 0 < r < 1. It is of course enough to do this when r = 1. Insert the binomial expansion (10)
(1 - z)-
into (2), and apply Parseval's theorem; if C = (z, H ) e S and r = 1, the left side of (9) equals
(11)
iwr^^f l^^"^] 2 izr. 2k
It is easily verified that (12)
/k + m