FORTIFY Essential resources for training and HR professionals
McClay EDITOR
Praise for Fortify Your Sales Force “This is an excellent no-nonsense resource for the novice or seasoned sales leader, salesperson, or sales training professional. Jam-packed with valuable information from a variety of industry experts, this book is a must have for anyone responsible for enhancing the performance of their sales organization.”
MARY A. ELLIOTT BASSETT worldwide director, sales and customer training, Eastman Kodak Company
Photo by Janna Giacoppo
“Renie McClay has compiled a great body of material for sales leaders in all industries to reference as they’re looking for expertise, seasoned experience and fresh ideas to help them inspire top performance from their teams. Leaders looking for ways to continue to grow in their skills and profession will benefit from the great reference, Fortify Your Sales Force, for a long time.”
KEVIN MOORE region sales manager, Kraft Foods
T HE EDITOR
Renie McClay has managed sales training for three Fortune 500 Companies, including Kraft, Novartis, and Pactiv (makers of Hefty). She spent 20 years in sales, account management, sales management, and sales training roles with Kraft. She has hired and managed sales teams and sales trainers. Her company, Inspired Learning, helps companies to design and deliver programs and curriculum for new and veteran sales people and sales management globally. Renie is a past president of SMT: Center for Sales Excellence and the author of Sales Training Solutions, 10 Steps to Successful Teams, and The Essential Guide to Training Global Audiences.
“To truly be successful as a leader, especially in a rapidly changing world such as sales, you must continuously stay on top of the latest insights and thoughts in the field. What’s needed is a resource that collects the best ideas and brings them together in one place. Renie McClay, in her latest book, Fortify Your Sales Force: Leading and Training Exceptional Teams, has done just that. She has reached out to several thought leaders in the sales and sales training field, asked them to address a particular sales/sales training topic and put their thoughts together in one accessible resource. This is a must own, especially for all sales training leaders.”
DARYL THOMAS senior manager, sales development and education, FedEx Office
Join Us at Pfeiffer.com
www.pfeiffer.com
FORTIFY SALES FORCE
focus for your sales force. For sales managers, there are tips for onboarding new sales people into the organization, leading virtual sales teams, reinforcing training to make it stick, and planning effective sales meetings. For sales people, there are a self-assessment and ideas on how to use emerging technology to sell. In addition, the book offers critical information on how to determine the impact of training, and what it takes to survive in a down economy.
YOUR
“With its emphasis on measurement and implementation, this book covers areas that are too often neglected and makes a useful and practical contribution.”—PROFESSOR NEIL RACKHAM, author, SPIN Selling
FORTIFY
Sa l es Force YOUR
LEADING AND TRAINING EXCEPTIONAL
TRAINING AND DEVELOPEMENT
TEAMS Register at www.pfeiffer.com/email for more information on our publications, authors, and to receive special offers.
Renie McClay EDITOR
YOUR
Sa l es Force When an organization wants to gain and maintain a competitive advantage, it is essential that they provide the right sales training to the right sales people at the right time. Fortify Your Sales Force is a hands-on resource for any organization that wants to increase profitability and thrive in today’s highly competitive marketplace. The book is filled with the real-life experiences from more than a dozen seasoned sales training professionals who have worked with a range of Fortune 500 companies that represent a wide variety of industries. These experts clearly define successful methods for leading and training an effective sales force in this era of limited resources and cut budgets. They offer the proven tools for any company that wants to increase the effectiveness of their sales force. The book gives a behind-the-scenes look at training experiences from leading companies such as Motorola, Proctor & Gamble, Kraft, Ricoh, United Airlines, and RR Donnelly. Based on their real-life experiences, the contributors reveal how to get internal support and funding of training initiatives, how to choose the right solution, the role leadership plays in successful training, and offer information on how to assess the competencies and needs of the sales force. Fortify Your Sales Force shows what it takes to make certain the customer is the primary
McClay fend.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
More Praise for Fortify Your Sales Force
‘‘This book offers a broad array of practical and valuable ideas along with tangible tools that can be readily applied to build high performance sales teams. From matching the right training solution to measuring the impact of the training, this collection of articles can be a ready resource for sales managers and training professionals alike.’’ —Kathy Leck, executive VP, Lake Forest Graduate School of Management. ‘‘This is a must read ‘hands-on thought book’ for all sales training and development professionals who want to define what blocks they need in their foundation of competencies. Regardless of your experience level, each chapter guides you in building the right foundation or provides the perfect ‘check points’ for assessing what cracks you have, what new blocks to add, and what mortar you need to strengthen yourself to stay relevant in responding to tomorrow’s development challenges.’’ —Joe Slezak, manager of sales team development, Miller Electric Manufacturing Company. ‘‘Fortify Your Sales Force offers proven and actionable strategies for keeping your sales force ‘frosty’ in a tough economy. Sales leaders and trainers from any organization struggling to maintain a competitive advantage in today’s economy need to read this book!’’ —Jesse Teverbaugh, manager, Technology Solutions, CDW.
12:55 A.M.
Page i
McClay fend.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
12:55 A.M. Page ii
‘‘Fortify Your Sales Force is a corporate treasure map that leads your organization down the path to consensus and into the house of higher profits. From the board room to the training room, this book provides clarity in a world of information overload. If you’re passionate about improving corporate performance, then this book is a MUST read!’’ —Todd Zaugg, CEO of Matrix Achievement Group, LLC and author of Warrior Sales Monk. ‘‘In Fortify Your Sales Force, McClay has assembled a world class team of contributors across 14 topics of interest to sales leaders and sales trainers around the globe. You’ll get a variety of perspectives—from the experts who have been in the arena. It is definitely worth reading!’’ —Stephen J. Bistritz, Ed.D., Sell XL; past president of SMT: Center for Sales and Excellence and co-author of Selling to the C-Suite. ‘‘Fortify Your Sales Force’s sage contributors serve up the perfect mix of proven and pragmatic advice to those who have among the toughest of tough jobs—sales leaders. Read it now. Next quarter is way too late.’’ —Dave Stein, CEO, ES Research Group, Inc. ‘‘Because we live in a world of diversity, we need to understand the many different angles of the sales process! That’s the reason this book is so important. Get the best from the different authors and your sales people will hear the word ‘yes’ many times!’’ —Alfredo Castro, president of MOT, chairman of the ASTD 2010 Advisory Committee, author and international consultant. ‘‘Leave it to Renie McClay to compile the best thinkers in the industry to inform, challenge and inspire us.’’ —Polly Rowland, former director, Sales Strategy at Kraft Foods.
McClay f01.tex
V1 - 12/09/2009
12:57 A.M. Page iii
Fortify Your Sales Force Leading and Training Exceptional Teams Edited by Renie McClay
McClay
f01.tex
V1 - 12/09/2009
12:57 A.M.
Copyright © 2010 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Published by Pfeiffer An Imprint of Wiley 989 Market Street, San Francisco, CA 94103-1741 www.pfeiffer.com No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning, or otherwise, except as permitted under Section 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400, fax 978-646-8600, or on the web at www.copyright.com. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, 201-748-6011, fax 201-748-6008, or online at http://www.wiley.com/go/permissions. Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and author have used their best efforts in preparing this book, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents of this book and specifically disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. No warranty may be created or extended by sales representatives or written sales materials. The advice and strategies contained herein may not be suitable for your situation. You should consult with a professional where appropriate. Neither the publisher nor author shall be liable for any loss of profit or any other commercial damages, including but not limited to special, incidental, consequential, or other damages. Readers should be aware that Internet websites offered as citations and/or sources for further information may have changed or disappeared between the time this was written and when it is read. For additional copies/bulk purchases of this book in the U.S. please contact 800-274-4434. Pfeiffer books and products are available through most bookstores. To contact Pfeiffer directly call our Customer Care Department within the U.S. at 800-274-4434, outside the U.S. at 317-572-3985, fax 317-572-4002, or visit www.pfeiffer.com. Pfeiffer also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic books. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Fortify your sales force : leading and training exceptional teams / edited by Renie McClay. p. cm. Includes index. ISBN 978-0-470-48866-9 (cloth) 1. Selling. 2. Sales personnel—Training of. 3. Sales management. I. McClay, Renie. HF5438.25.F674 2010 658.8’1—dc22 2009037351
Acquiring Editor: Matthew Davis Marketing Manager: Brian Grimm Production Editor: Michael Kay Printed in the United States of America Printing 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Editor: Rebecca Taff Editorial Assistant: Lindsay Morton Manufacturing Supervisor: Becky Morgan
Page iv
McClay
f00.tex
V1 - 12/09/2009
1:00 P.M.
Page v
McClay
ftoc.tex V3 - 12/09/2009
Join Us at Pfeiffer.com Register at www.pfeiffer.com/email for more information on our publications, authors, and to receive special offers.
1:02 P.M.
Page vi
McClay
ftoc.tex V3 - 12/09/2009
CONTENTS
Introduction
ix
1. Invest in Your Salespeople Now
1
Bob Rickert 2. Winning Leadership Support for Sales Initiatives
23
Jim Graham 3. The Perfect Salesperson: A Guide to Building Your Dream Team 45 Teresa Hiatt 4. Develop Sales Reps Using Structured Feedback 67 Kenneth R. Phillips 5. So Many Choices: Determining the Right Solution
93
Michael Rockelmann vii
1:02 P.M. Page vii
McClay ftoc.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:02 P.M.
Contents
viii
6. Capabilities: The Engine That Drives Success
111
Maria Edelson 7. Making Training Stick: Get Them to Use It
123
Susan Onaitis 8. Measuring the Impact: Did They Use It?
141
Gary Summy 9. Collaborative Partnership to Maximize L&D Investment 161 Susanne Conrad 10. Sales Managers: The Heavy Lifters in Training Salespeople 181 Rick Wills 11. Productive New Hires, Faster: You Don’t Get a Second Chance to Make a First Impression 199 Renie McClay 12. ‘‘Raise the Roof’’ Sales Meetings
235
Lanie Jordan 13. Successfully Leading Virtual Sales Teams
261
Renie McClay 14. Media Mojo: Using Technology as a Survival Strategy 273 Trish Uhl About the Editor 305 About the Contributors Index 317
307
Page viii
McClay f03.tex
V1 - 12/09/2009
INTRODUCTION
R
EGARDLESS OF THE economic environment, companies NEED talented sales people. Sales revenues are the life blood
of most organizations. To keep the revenues flowing, sales leadership and sales representatives must continuously improve their skills to meet changing demands of a competitive global economy. Revenue fluctuations have a direct impact on the bottom line. An increase in the effectiveness of a sales force by just 5 percent translates to a significant increase in the bottom line. An increase in sales, particularly these days, isn’t easy to get. Sales management doesn’t always have the answer to new challenges or know how to make it happen. Their talents may lie in different areas. Sometimes it takes an objective resource to see things more clearly from a distance. Often the answer can be found in experience with other industries or a different approach to sales and learning strategies. Many organizations don’t have sales training departments or deep cross-functional experience. Where do they turn for guidance? This question is precisely the reason for this book. I have set out to gather experience from the best and the ix
1:03 P.M. Page ix
McClay
f03.tex
V1 - 12/09/2009
1:03 P.M.
Introduction
x
brightest in the sales industry to provide wisdom and best practices to help you fortify your sales organization.
Who Are the Contributors? My selection criteria for book contributors was that they need to be wildly talented, successful, and have deep experience with sales forces. Each contributor is a thought leader in his or her particular topic area, and I relied on them for providing the content. They share tried-and-true tips and ideas that they have personally used to succeed and improve their organizations. This book is a compilation of articles from thirteen contributing authors who have mountains of experience building and bettering sales forces. Combined, they have more than 75 years of selling, over 60 years of management experience, and greater than 120 years of improving the performance of sales teams. There is an astounding amount of wisdom between these covers for those willing to do some reading and pondering. Fortunately or unfortunately, this book is not ‘‘vanilla.’’ Some of the authors have a strong opinion about their topic and perhaps even an edge, or they take one side of an issue. Similarly, the contributors don’t necessarily have the same view or particularly agree with each other. This strong feeling comes with experience and wisdom, and that’s okay with me. I actually like this about the book because I believe there is more than one way to approach many of the topics presented here.
Who Will Benefit from This Book? If your sales force is perfect, the revenues are pouring in, and you’ve perfected the business case to get whatever funding you want for training or other events, this is not for you. This book is written for those who want to improve their sales teams and are open to new ideas to make that happen. There are topics for sales leaders, sales managers, and trainers who work to develop sales audiences. There are both strategic topics and more tactical topics.
Page x
McClay f03.tex
Introduction
V1 - 12/09/2009
xi
How to Get the Most from This Book The book does not have to be a cover-to-cover read. Using the table of contents as a guide, go to the topics that interest you. Better yet, determine who in the organization would benefit from the various topics and split up the reading. I wish you well in your journey to increase the talents and capabilities of your sales force and ignite your sales success. I invite you to put some of these ideas into practice and then let me know how they work for you at email me at
[email protected].
1:03 P.M. Page xi
McClay f03.tex
V1 - 12/09/2009
1:03 P.M.
Page xii
McClay
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1 Invest in Your Salespeople Now Bob Rickert
Y
OUR SALESPEOPLE ARE fighting a new kind of battle today.
Doing business has changed in recent years as economic cycles have become less predictable and erratic, creating greater competition and forcing every company to re-examine its go-to-market sales strategy. With every economic cycle, there is a chain reaction of good things or bad things that occur, depending on which way the economy is heading. In good times, demand is strong, prices are stable, and growing the company can be done while investing in the business. However, in a downturn, the impact can be swift and painful. In reaction, customers typically initiate deep cuts in spending in every area of their businesses, including technology, labor, operating expenses, inventories, and capital investments. As a result, decisions are delayed or simply not being made at all to conserve cash and to ensure that spending does not get ahead of 1
1:06 P.M.
Page 1
McClay
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:06 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
2
revenue or capital reserves. This type of reaction has a direct impact on virtually every industry and every company.
Facing a Strong Headwind What does this all mean for your salespeople? They are your first line of defense, as they are the first to experience shifts in your customers’ buying behavior. In the past, a slowing economy meant you had to consider being more aggressive with pricing and offer more services to slow the loss of revenue and margins. Customers still bought, it was reasonably predictable, and you simply had to manage your business more cautiously. That will not be the case in the future. For customers, in a tough economic environment it is all about conserving capital, making deep cuts in spending, and forcing greater competition among suppliers to get lower pricing to optimize their expenditures. Customers’ behavior will become even less predictable as they attempt to get their arms around their continued financial challenges. This means it is going to take strong leadership to keep the sales organization focused, effective, and successful in the face of stiff economic headwinds. There are only two ways companies and their sales leadership can respond to economic downturns and increased competition. First, you can batten down the hatches, ride out the storm, and hope you are competitively viable when the economy rebounds. Or you can press your advantages and exploit the opportunities the financial challenges have created by embracing new sales capabilities and go-to-market strategies. Now is the time to make a significant investment in your sales organization, even though the easy decision would be to wait, hunker down, and conserve resources. However, with the public and the press hammering corporations for how they spend money, it is essential that a business case be built to justify every significant investment a company makes. To accomplish this will require a new mind-set and learning to speak the language of financial return and improved profitability. In this chapter, we will explore the financial challenges that are impacting your organization and what it will take to build a strong business case for
Page 2
McClay
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
I n v e s t i n Yo u r S a l e s p e o p l e N o w
3
investing in your salespeople when they need it most. We will also review strategies for identifying measurements tied to the company’s key business drivers and objectives that you can use to make a persuasive business case for equipping your sales team for a new kind of competitive battle.
Why Invest in Your Salespeople Now Business cycles are constantly evolving. When the economy is growing, companies invest in their sales organization in a variety of ways, including sales meetings, training, promotional campaigns, incentives, client conferences, CRM technology, customer intelligence, market research, and more. But once the organization misses its revenue targets and forecasts grow soft, the budget shrinks and the pressure to produce revenue grows exponentially. In typical economic cycles, a defensive posture can be effective by focusing on retaining existing business and finding ways to win market share from weakened competitors. But a deeper economic downturn requires a different kind of response. An economic downturn is the time to go on the offensive by enabling your salespeople to pursue profitable selling strategies.
When economic downturns are relatively short, you can often avoid investing in your salespeople. Actions can be taken to remain competitive knowing a rebound is within sight. However, fighting for profitable revenue gets harder the longer and deeper a downturn goes. You run the risk that reactions to the downturn, such as discounting, more financially lenient terms, and providing additional no-cost or low-cost value-added services will be institutionalized and difficult to undo later when the economy recovers. This is why investing in the sales organization during a downturn becomes even more important than any other investment an organization can make. You need your salespeople equipped to handle the pressures from customers and increasingly desperate competitors to retain your competitive advantages.
1:06 P.M.
Page 3
McClay
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:06 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
4
Lessons of Past Recessions Taking a look at current economic conditions, it will serve you well to learn from history. McKinsey conducted a study of past recessions that companies could learn from as they make their decisions to invest in their businesses, focus on surviving, or sit on the sidelines waiting for the recovery. They found that some companies emerged from recessions stronger and more highly valued than they were before the economic downturn. By making strategic choices that sometimes defied conventional wisdom, they increased their market value relative to those of their former peers and thus gained more power to shape their industries. I believe this will be the case during this financial crisis and should be factored into your investment plans.
Consider a contrarian strategy during an economic downturn while your competitors adhere to more low-risk, low-reward approaches.
McKinsey studied one thousand industrial companies in the United States over the period from 1982 to 2000, which included the recession of 1990–1991. They identified companies that kept their leadership positions within their industries or became successful by challenging top-performing companies. They studied the characteristics of successful companies, during both the recession and the subsequent economic recovery. They found that successful companies took an aggressive position in everything from acquiring companies to investing in new products to improve competitive advantage. Of the various strategies deployed, perhaps the most unexpected action was that industry leaders actually increased their operating expenses. While most companies tightened their belts, the successful companies refocused rather than cut spending, giving up short-term profit for long-term growth. These leaders spent significantly more on selling, general, and administrative (SG&A) costs than did companies that lost their market leadership. Another interesting point was that, during expansionary periods, successful leaders actually spent less on SG&A than did their less
Page 4
McClay
I n v e s t i n Yo u r S a l e s p e o p l e N o w
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
5
successful peers as their improved efficiency was an outgrowth of their earlier investment. Finally, expenditures on R&D, marketing, and advertising followed a similar pattern. Despite selective spending increases during the 1990– 1991 downturn, successful leaders were far more efficient, even with their increased spending, as they maintained an employee-to-sales ratio 27 percent lower than that of their industries. The financial markets rewarded those companies willing to pursue contrarian strategies during the downturn. By the end of 1990– 1991, successful challengers had a market-to-book ratio that was 25 percent higher than those of their unsuccessful challengers. In most economic downturns, conserving cash is a major concern. Still, when it comes to investing in the one area that ultimately impacts cash the most, your revenue engine, it goes to reason that now is the time to invest to stay ahead of the competitors that are most likely not investing.
What’s Impacting Your Business Too often I hear sales leadership complain that, given the importance that revenue generation plays in an organization, they are left fighting for budget dollars after ‘‘non-revenue-generating’’ investments are made. But at the top of every organization, executive management is challenged to prioritize and choose the investments that generate the greatest return. To position a strong business case for investing in your salespeople, you need to view the business the way your executive team does. Looking at your business from 20,000 feet, how are current economic challenges impacting your ability to grow profitable revenue? What should you look at to assess the challenges you might face when putting together a business case? Here are five key business factors that might be directly or indirectly impacting your company’s financial health and that could prevent senior management from making an investment in your salespeople at this time: 1. The Credit Squeeze.This isn’t usually a factor that sales leaders think about in normal times, but companies are now under extreme pressure to conserve their capital. Is your company putting an extra emphasis on managing cash flow? Lowering
1:06 P.M.
Page 5
McClay
6
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:06 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
costs, reducing inventory levels, and deferring capital expenditures make it an especially difficult climate to ask for funding. 2. A Shutdown in Capital Investments. Companies in many industries are stopping or slowing down capital expenditures. The uncertainty of future economic growth has stalled attempts to build infrastructure or improve plants or make other large-scale investments. A JP Morgan study on the healthcare sector, for example, found that 33 percent of hospitals are stopping capital investments, and only those that offer an attractive ROI are being funded. The lowest ROI projects are being cut first. 3. Major Cost Reductions. If you are in an industry that is experiencing huge fluctuation in the cost and availability of raw materials such as chemicals, electricity, oil and gas, food ingredients, steel, and more, it is probably causing your cost of goods or services to go up faster than you can pass through price increases to your customers to maintain your margins. This will force your organization to take a hit in profitability to maintain your current levels of revenue. This puts tremendous pressure on margins and causes a pullback on the expenditures you are pursuing. 4. Consumer Spending. Are you in an industry that is directly impacted by consumer spending? When consumer spending trends downward, inventories build up, purchasing slows down, and price pressures surface as a key strategy for selling products in inventory, further pressuring the company’s financial health. 5. Executive Turnover. Are high-level executives leaving your organization? This will make it more difficult to make a case for investing in your salespeople. Typically, when there are leadership changes, everyone in the company becomes obsessed with keeping their jobs. For sure there will be a lack of clarity during the transition. Until the priorities of the new leadership team are communicated, senior leaders are hesitant to commit to future investments in people-related expenses.
Page 6
McClay
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
I n v e s t i n Yo u r S a l e s p e o p l e N o w
7
Anticipating market trends has never been more challenging than it is today.
There is growing pressure on executives to deliver immediate results, especially in the current environment. It is also difficult given the public scrutiny on company performance and the challenges of living and dying by quarterly earnings reports. This is causing turnover among CEOs to reach all-time highs. The pressure CEOs face will always involve the financial performance of their companies. Compliance to new rules such as Sarbanes-Oxley creates even greater pressure. And now with the government’s involvement in the excesses of Wall Street leading up to the financial crisis, it will not be unusual to see a CEO forced out due to questionable business decisions or overall performance of the company, especially during these times. It is important to assess your company’s environment and how internal and external changes or challenges are impacting senior management’s view of investments, especially as it relates to developing and supporting the sales team. Understanding these pressures will help you prepare a business case that addresses the immediate financial and organizational concerns of senior management.
What You Need to Know About Your Business There is no question that managing sales puts you in a position of strength in terms of leveraging resources to help you deliver profitable revenue growth. But there are also inherent risks as well. To make an informed and impassioned plea for funding and support, you will certainly be asked how your proposed investment will impact the business. With the new economic realities we face comes a new level of responsibility for the sales leader. Business and economic cycles in the past were reasonably predictable, generally slow to occur, and easier to manage around. In today’s environment, having a stronger knowledge of the business will prepare you to respond quickly to new emerging challenges.
1:06 P.M.
Page 7
McClay
8
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:06 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
I have spent nine years with Aarthun Performance Group working with Fortune 500 companies to improve financial performance through improved sales financial literacy and value selling. Most of the company leaders I have interviewed admit that the sales organization is viewed as not having a deep enough understanding of the key financial drivers they directly impact, nor do they understand the customers’ business, leaving them vulnerable to competition. It’s a big gap in corporate America, and the consequences are greater today than they were even a year ago. So why do you need to understand your company’s financials? Understanding the key trends in your business and understanding the key financial indicators that are driving executive decisions will assist you in positioning your business case for investing in your salespeople in a way that addresses executives’ most important goals. Most people understand whether their company is making money or not. You can review your quarterly releases and 10K to keep up with your company’s latest financial performance. Pick up The Wall Street Journal and you can learn about what is going on in the market, in your industry, and with your key competitors. Most people understand it when the company announces that revenues are up, profits are strong, and shareholders are receiving a dividend. However, I have found that, although these performance numbers are useful, they don’t really tell the whole story. Mostly, they won’t tell you about the challenges the company had to overcome to be successful. Only when you can interpret the meaning of the numbers ‘‘operationally’’ does it begin to help you understand your business at a higher level. If you work for a private company, many are open about their financial situations. Some may not be, especially during tough economic times. But understanding more than just the top-line numbers that are revealed can help you get a picture of the company’s key challenges and priorities. There are three things you can look at to enhance your discussions with executive leadership and your development of an effective business case—revenue growth, expense management, and the use of capital.
Page 8
McClay
I n v e s t i n Yo u r S a l e s p e o p l e N o w
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
9
The Financials Financial reporting is fairly standardized and easy to interpret. When it comes to top-line growth and what goes into the company’s revenue generation, no one knows that area better than the sales department. You know all too well that the key numbers being looked at, in addition to revenues are cost of goods sold, gross profit, gross profit margin, operating expenses, and operating profit. But what is behind the numbers? If the company is under unusually stiff competitive pressure, winning the business at a lower margin may have been a Herculean task. Did you exploit a market opportunity to defeat a stronger competitor to win new business? This needs to factor in to your business case as you defend how you achieved the numbers and why enabling and equipping the sales organization with new capabilities and tools will directly improve those numbers. I suggest that you compare the numbers going back three years. Looking at three years’ data will provide the view that analysts take to evaluate your company’s key performance drivers. You should also pick one or two of your competitors and compare the numbers. Here are a few questions you should pursue in your analysis: • Are you growing at a faster rate than last year? How does that growth rate compare to your key competitors? • Are you growing faster than your overall market is growing? • Are you achieving your growth goals in your target markets? • Are you penetrating new accounts and taking market share away from your key competitors? The answers to these questions can be very revealing in terms of what the market and shareholders look at in terms of future performance expectations for your company and whether you are a good investment versus your competitors.
The Trends As a sales leader, you need to compare two key trends that most directly impact your organization. Gross profit and gross profit margin are your
1:06 P.M.
Page 9
McClay
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:06 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
10
first lines of defense. These suggest that a company is viable, has a strong plan, and is executing well. Gross profit margin is especially critical today because there is extraordinary pressure from customers to cut prices, which has painful consequences. For every dollar of revenue you bring in, the gross profit margin tells management just how much money it has left over, after paying the cost of goods or service, to run the business. Seems simple enough, but it is the trend that management reacts to first and foremost. Every dollar of gross margin lost drops directly to operating income. Here are the questions they want answered: • • • •
Are the gross margins going down a trend we need to plan for? Why is it happening, and what can we do about it? Is it an increase in raw materials that couldn’t be passed through? Is it a competitive pricing issue that to retain the same level of business you had to spend more through discounting?
Whatever the answers to these questions are, the pressure will be on to improve your overall go-to-market sales strategy. The next important trend looked at are operating costs. Senior management will assess the trend in operating expense as a percent of sales ratio. This tells them what it is costing to generate a dollar of revenue. It is an indication of how efficient the company is. Are operating expenses (also expressed as SG&A) going up at a faster or slower rate than revenue? That does not land on the sales department solely, but since that is where your investment dollars will come from, understanding it and how sales can impact it is a powerful tool in persuading management to invest. Increases in raw materials or pricing challenges alert management to margin pressures down the road. That is why cuts in salaries, training, and travel budgets more often are done quickly because management knows that the pressure to adjust costs to produce promised profits will increase, and operating expenses are the easiest target. There are other implications for trends. These trends may also be leading indicators of the need for training. If the company is growing, new hiring and speed to performance will be keys to sustaining the growth
Page 10
McClay
I n v e s t i n Yo u r S a l e s p e o p l e N o w
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
11
or turning around a decline. You can anticipate learning needs based on the key financial trends of the company. Most of all, demonstrating a working knowledge of these trends will elevate you as a sales leader in the eyes of senior management.
What Executives Are Saying You can learn a lot about your company’s current and past performance and future strategies by what your executives are saying publicly. The numbers tell a story about what is happening in the business. I have talked to many sales managers who routinely listen to their companies’ quarterly and annual earnings calls to understand their financial results. The executive team will explain external factors like the economy, trend in raw material costs, internal changes, and initiatives designed to improve performance, projections they are making for market growth, competitive factors, and more. As a leader, it is important to hear what your executives are saying about your business so that you can position strategies with your salespeople that reflect corporate direction. Perhaps the most revealing part of the call, however, is the questionand-answer session. Executives and their investor relations teams put together substantial information to prepare for questions from analysts. The questions reflect how analysts keep score in your industry or sector and expose the concerns analysts have as they attempt to report on the business and advise their firms whether to invest, and on whom. What management is saying publicly also provides you insight into how they intend to address the business to deliver value for the shareholders. It is an opportunity for you to key in on strategies and/or challenges that you can align your business case with. This will help address the most pressing business challenges the company faces, especially those you can address in your effort to build the capabilities of your organization.
1:06 P.M.
Page 11
McClay
12
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:06 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
How to Analyze Your Sales Team’s Needs Once you understand your company’s key financial priorities, be prepared to get in front of your leadership with a business case that reflects those priorities and is based on an assessment of how your sales team can deliver on them. You are skilled at managing sales and applying strategies to win business. But to get to the next level as a strong leader, you need to leverage your understanding of the business drivers discussed above by conducting an analysis of your sales team’s strategies and needs tied directly to the company’s priorities. As you conduct your needs assessment, be prepared with well-thought-out answers to the following business questions.
1. What Challenges Do You See in Growing Revenue? What leadership wants to know: Leadership needs to understand the challenges you are facing in growing the business. For example, one challenge you might be facing is the continued uncertainty about customers’ pullback in purchasing. With the slowdown in customer spending, salespeople may be at a loss to determine ‘‘what buttons to push’’ to move their customers off the dime. Is it cash flow that is causing the customer to pull back? As a result, are customers throwing up new kinds of obstacles around extending terms, requesting vendor-managed inventory or value-added services at no cost? You will need to defend in business terms what and why things are happening and what you intend to do about it.
2. Will Your Salespeople Be Able to Protect Price and Defend Margins? What leadership wants to know: Be prepared for this one! In times like these, customers who have been less price driven in the past may now be under immense pressure to drive all suppliers’ pricing down as they feel urgency to protect cash and squeak out a profit (at your expense). Pricing is a profit-improvement strategy. Salespeople always feel the heat on protecting margin, but margin is lost not only in price but also in
Page 12
McClay
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
I n v e s t i n Yo u r S a l e s p e o p l e N o w
13
services that are provided without compensation. There is a cost for the resources the sales team relies on, and if the focus is too much on the revenue and not on the profitability of that increased sales volume, senior management will balk. McKinsey found in a study on pricing that for every 1 percent in price increase a company can achieve, it will result in an 8 to 10 percent increase in operating profit. Conversely, they found that on average a 5 percent discount, all things being equal, will require 18.7 percent greater sales volume to make up the loss in profitability. This is why your team and your plan for investment must be tied to improving and defending margin.
3. What Are Your Competitors’ Strategies for Winning Against You? What leadership wants to know: Sun Tzu said in his book The Art of War that the key to success is not in defeating the enemy, but in defeating the enemy’s strategy. Do you know what your competitors’ strategies are for beating you in the market? What are you up against in this challenging economic environment? What intelligence do you have regarding what your competitors will do to defend their positions? Leadership does not like surprises, and when it comes to competitors, anticipating what your competitors will do is key to winning.
4. Are Your Salespeople Equipped to Win? What leadership wants to know: Are your salespeople ready for the new challenges that face them? Are you clear on the three to five things that you must do to get your salespeople ready for the market challenges? These might include training, data, marketing support, market or industry intelligence, or competitive information. Sales managers know the strengths and weaknesses of their sales teams, but articulating the specific needs translated into business improvement is what management will want to know, especially with regard to your proposed solution. More than that, you will need to be able to link the financial consequences or impact to a specific competency gap you propose to close.
1:06 P.M.
Page 13
McClay
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:06 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
14
5. What Are Your Critical Success Factors? What leadership wants to know: Be clear on the one or two critical success factors for your success. For example, in the current environment, selling to higher-level decision makers may be the single most important thing your salespeople can do to achieve their revenue numbers. Getting to the customers’ executive-level decision makers and presenting a strong value proposition based on improving their profitability will result in a higher win ratio (because you pre-empted competition by being there first); larger deals (because the total value and impact are sought and better understood at that level); and deals close sooner because the case is compelling to invest now. This is what your executive team wants to hear: that you are clear and that you have a strategy. This is all the more reason to build a business case that aligns to corporate goals. Your salespeople need more than moral support during tough economic times.
In a tough economic market, growing the business usually requires that you take business away from your competitors. You must win without giving away margin in the form of discounts, terms, or no-cost services. To accomplish this, salespeople must sell on value and not price, call higher where the economic decisions are made, and differentiate not only what they sell but also how they sell it. Salespeople are in the best position to protect your margin, and your business case should always address the skills and performance drivers that help you manage these critical success factors. The worksheet that follows is a guide that will help you think through those areas that you know executives will challenge you to answer.
Sales Team Analysis Worksheet 1. What are the trends in your industry? Example: Are the key industries you serve immune from the current economic downturn and represent opportunities to expand your
Page 14
McClay
I n v e s t i n Yo u r S a l e s p e o p l e N o w
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
15
business and protect your position, or are the industries you serve being adversely affected by the downturn and require innovative ideas to remain profitable? 2. What will it take to grow your business? Example: Retaining the 20 percent most profitable customers; selling existing products and services to new prospects; selling new products and services to existing customers; going after new target markets or industries. 3. What are your competitors’ key strategies? Example: Competitors are bundling their solutions and positioning their offerings as a cost savings package; competitors are discounting to buy market share and pressure higher value companies like yours to price to win or withdraw. 4. What support will be required to equip your sales team to compete and win? Example: Training on how to analyze customers’ financial and business needs with the skills to sell higher may be the single most important support you can provide; it might be customer intelligence or market intelligence; it might require new marketing tools to combat competitors’ low price strategy. 5. What role can executives play in helping you win in the marketplace? Example: In tough economic times, taking your executive team to the customer can be a very important sales growth strategy. Should you arrange peer-to-peer C-suite meetings and dialogue to position your company for success?
The Business Case for Investing in Your Team In good economic times, executives make decisions regarding investments the same way, based on return on investment. That includes return on the capital that is required, but it also includes the human capital required.
1:06 P.M.
Page 15
McClay
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:06 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
16
The CEO cuts a big check every day in the form of operating expenses (people, processes, etc.) to execute the business plan. What he or she always wants to know is: Are we getting our money’s worth? Regardless of what level you are presenting your business case to, the approach needs to be the same; it is always about how any business improvement idea can impact the company’s operational, financial, and business processes.
Components of an Effective Business Case Based on the key trends driving your business, you must start with the challenges executives are facing. You need to establish the financial and business need before you can effectively formulate a recommendation. Next you need to identify the measurements you will use to track success—acquiring new accounts, revenue growth, being paid for valueadded services, customer retention, and so on. Start with the end in mind: What financial outcomes are needed? From there identify your key strategies that will address the desired outcomes. This might include targeting only a certain market segment or selling higher, which can drive results more quickly. Here are the components of the business planning approach.
Think Like Your CEO As you approach your solution and prepare your business case, put yourself in the shoes of your CEO, regardless of whom you are targeting for the presentation. This will help you anticipate the issues, concerns, and questions that will likely be asked of you. Use the information you gathered in analyzing the company’s business. It has been my experience that executives view sales leaders as experts in selling and not enough as financial stewards of the business from a total profitability position. That is not to say sales leadership or any level of sales management lacks the requisite financial and business knowledge; it is just that too often the perception is that it is really about revenue and not addressing the direct and indirect ways the sales department impacts profitability. Speaking the
Page 16
McClay
I n v e s t i n Yo u r S a l e s p e o p l e N o w
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
17
language of the financial and profitability will cause executives to view you as someone who understands their world and, more importantly, their challenges. To prepare a strong business case, focus on what keeps executives up at night. Revenue growth is certainly at the top of the list, but it will be more than that. Other questions covered in part earlier include: • Are sales growing faster than your key competitor’s? Analysts and shareholders are looking at this and it may be a critical area to study. • Is the sales organization protecting price and defending your margins? Pricing has a significant impact on overall profitability, which often is the single biggest metric executives look at. • Are your operating expenses in line with your growth rate? Some of this is outside of your control; however, within the sales organization, cost management is important. • Are you retaining your high-profit customers? In some industries or companies, losing one or two key customers can have a dramatic impact on the business. • Are you retaining your best people? And what are you doing to ensure they are operating at a high motivational level?
Delivering Your Business Case Executives are open to new profit improvement ideas if they address one or more key financial or business priorities. The first thing they want to know about your recommendation will be what is required of them. What is the investment being requested, and what will they see in return? They will also press you on when the company will see the return. There is no shortage of requests of executive management to invest in the business. They have too many choices; their job is to deploy limited capital on those projects that bring the greatest return to the corporation and shareholders. Job one is sorting out how best to manage the resources of the company and the capital that has been bestowed upon them. They will also gauge your level of confidence in your recommendation, which
1:06 P.M.
Page 17
McClay
18
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:06 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
will be a key determining factor when considering your recommendation. They will want to know how confident you are that the outcomes can be achieved, how you will measure results, and how much time is required on your part to implement the solution.
What every executive wants to know is: Why should I invest and why now?
Here are a few things to keep in mind when approaching executives with your business case: • Demonstrate your understanding of the business. Summarize your understanding of the company’s key performance metrics and executive strategies, and position your solution in a way that addresses the critical short-term and longer-term business drivers. If the company is suffering revenue and margin declines, speak in terms of ratios and why you are addressing them with a solution designed to impact their key business goals. • Sell results up-front. To capture the executive’s attention, demonstrate the kind of financial and business impact your recommendation will have on the organization. Nothing speaks louder than numbers, especially when the organization is under performance pressure. You should quantify the impact of your solution in terms of sales growth, margin improvement, new customers, and so forth, and be prepared to defend your numbers. • Align your recommended solution to other important corporate initiatives. If possible, link your recommended solution to other key initiatives to demonstrate that you are aligned with the key strategies of the executive team. • Set realistic time frames. Be clear and realistic regarding the time and effort required to implement your project as well as the amount of time and effort you will have to devote to ensuring success. Executives want to know whether it will take away from other revenue-producing activities if the sales management team
Page 18
McClay
I n v e s t i n Yo u r S a l e s p e o p l e N o w
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
19
is focused on this. You need to set clear expectations and follow through on your promises. If it takes six months to see the impact, be specific about the milestones that can be anticipated on the way to results, what steps it will take, what will be observable, and how results will be measured and tracked. • Close for a decision or a clear next step. Fortunately, your executive team got to be where they are by being decisive and making informed decisions quickly. They will welcome a leader in their company pursuing a timely decision so that attention can be given to the appropriate next steps. Close for a decision and/or a clear next step demonstrating your interest in getting things done.
Business Case Worksheet 1. What are the key corporate financial and business goals and the CEO’s key strategies? Example: The company is focused on acquisitions to achieve growth; the focus is on lowering costs to improve margins, cost-reduction measures are being put in place; strategies for lowering raw materials are a key focus; there will be investments in R&D and new product rollouts. 2. What are your key strategies? Example: How do your strategies for your sales team address the key goals of the corporation? Because CEOs address their most pressing business and financial concerns every quarter, identify those areas you can reference in your recommended solution to strengthen your business case. 3. What is your proposed solution and how will it impact the business? Example: What are you going to propose that will address the needs of your team to deliver on the most pressing corporate objectives? The sales team is always the first line of defense when it comes to growing the business. Based on the big issues, there will be connections to how the sales organization needs to focus their attention and what is required to be successful.
1:06 P.M.
Page 19
McClay
20
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:06 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
4. What are the key measurements you will use to track success? Example: Revenue growth; margin improvement; retaining customers; selling bundled solutions; selling value; selling higher. 5. What are the key sales and sales management activities required to implement the solution? Example: What will be required of you and your sales managers to implement your recommended solution in terms of time commitment and resources, and how will it happen while you are performing your other responsibilities? 6. What are your recommended timeline and next steps? Example: Have a clearly defined timeline and next steps. Include next steps for your executive team and other areas that are needed to support your solution.
Building a strong business case for investing in your salespeople is important during any market condition. You can offset some of the impact of unpredictable economic swings by asking your best people what they are hearing from your most valued customers. Your best salespeople are the ones who typically spot early warning signals because they are having higher-level business conversations with senior levels who are monitoring their business activity. These conversations with executives offer important insights into the trends that predict future behavior (that is, requests for a review of supply chain efficiencies; alternatives to building inventories too high; slowdown in orders; end user behaviors being tracked, etc.). Another strategy is to invest in the top 10 to 15 percent of your salespeople. Too often, spending stops altogether. It is expensive to invest in the entire sales organization, even in the expansionary periods. But when you are early into a recession, persuade senior management that one way to mitigate the revenue decline is to enable the top performers
Page 20
McClay
I n v e s t i n Yo u r S a l e s p e o p l e N o w
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
21
with new tools, alternative pricing/bundling, and terms—as they are in a position to make an immediate difference. This will also help you make a broader business case to invest in the whole team as the recession deepens. Finally, talk to your customers more often. Many companies have formalized a ‘‘voice of the customer’’ to stay in touch with trends. It is even more important at the onset of a recession to have a defined swat team that gets out ahead of the economic changes by looking into the source of your revenue, your customers, and better understanding their business (which is your business).
Summary We are living through challenging times and the rules have changed. For most companies, holding their positions and conserving resources seem like prudent approaches. But as history has shown us, for those companies that aggressively pursue a strategy of investing in their salespeople, the rewards can be great. To advocate for investment during a difficult economic environment when senior management is attempting to ward off disaster is not easy. But, like every other financial decision senior management is making, a business case built on a strong return on investment is essential. Many sales managers fail to pursue funding for their people because the head winds are simply too strong. But for innovative sales leaders who know how to leverage the resources for improved performance, it will serve you well. Knowing your company’s financial situation and offering solutions that address the company’s highest priorities will earn you credibility at a time when you need it most. This will require analyzing your business and your team’s needs and proposing a development plan that achieves results. Building a business case for success is the only way in the current economic environment to win your share of available budget.
1:06 P.M.
Page 21
McClay
c01.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:06 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
22
Bibliography Richard F. Dobbs, Tomas Karakolev, and Francis Malige. ‘‘Learning to Love Recessions.’’ McKinsey Quarterly, June 2002. Michael V. Marn, Eric V. Roegner, and Craig C. Zawada. ‘‘The Power of Pricing.’’ McKinsey Quarterly, 2003. JP Morgan Medical Supplies and Equipment Report, North America Equity Research, December 17, 2008.
Page 22
McClay
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
2 Winning Leadership Support for Sales Initiatives Jim Graham In today’s economy, more than ever before, you as a sales leader must understand and successfully execute the internal sale.
T
HERE IS NO silver bullet for persuading senior leadership to support your initiatives! It’s a tough, uphill battle, where you
are competing for time, tight budget dollars, potential outsourcing, reductions, restructuring, cost controls, and many more worthy projects. Other constituents are just as enthusiastic and eager as you are to get the same support. So here are a few best practices and some success stories for gaining that support for your projects. But let’s be clear: there is no panacea, no one right way, no way that works every time, and no formula that I know of for always getting what you want. We will explore some options and give you ideas, along with a few actual cases, that could work in your organization. 23
1:09 P.M.
Page 23
McClay
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:09 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
24
Credibility Let’s start with credibility. As the old saying goes, sometimes you’ve got it, and sometimes you don’t. In gaining support from senior management, you must have it! This is not negotiable; you cannot gain support for your project without having credibility. How do you get it? First, you earn it through years of service to the company. You rise through the ranks, become successful in sales or sales management, earn a reputation for effectiveness, take on challenging initiatives, and succeed. Basically, your reputation precedes you. It’s great if you have it, but it’s tough if you don’t. In today’s world, with mergers, acquisitions, downsizing, and rightsizing, many of us don’t have years of experience to support our positions. Perhaps the VP of sales who supported you has now left the company and your champion is gone. (I have a story about a project like this later in the chapter.) As a result, credibility can be hard to come by. What is credibility? Credibility is doing what you say you will do when you say you will do it. It is your track record of performance. How quickly and professionally have you responded to each request? How successful have your projects been? How visible? Who knows about your past performance successes? Can you or someone who has credibility summarize your successes to impress a decision maker? As you did with your customers, one way to gain this credibility is to obtain the support of others who have it. You can’t gain it alone; you must get help and support. You gain credibility for your project by the associations you have with those who are seen as credible. The people who coach and support you must be credible, even if you are still earning your stripes. They can actively support you via email recommendations or in hallway conversations (yes, those conversations with the right people do influence decisions), or by attending a presentation and supporting you with their presence. They also may coach you behind the scenes (the invisible coach). What they do and how you use their credibility is very important. The higher this person is in your organization, the better!
Page 24
McClay
Winning Leadership Support for Sales Initiatives
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
25
The general has more clout than the lieutenants, captains, or even the colonels. Here is an example from my company: One of my first experiences selling—yes, selling—a major project to senior management was a large, interactive computer-based learning simulation project designed to train salespeople more effectively and efficiently. I started by building a very elaborate presentation with well over one hundred slides in more detail than a congressional report. Then I requested two hours with our president. His approval would lead me to the CEO. I started with someone with whom I already had credibility, who had credibility with the ultimate decision maker, and someone I thought could influence the decision. I told him I had prepared the presentation for the CEO and wanted him to critique it. After the first ten slides or so, he stopped me and asked what I was doing. He described the attention span of the CEO as that of a gnat, and suggested an executive summary of a few slides, without the agonizing detail I had prepared.
I learned a valuable lesson about being brief and precise. I took the advice, built the executive summary with plenty of detail to back it up, and a few weeks later presented to the CEO. The CEO asked, ‘‘Who else have you talked to?’’ I told him the president (hoping that would seal the deal). He asked more questions. Because the project was for sales, he wanted to know whether I had the approval of senior sales leaders across the business units? No. I had not talked with all of them, but I certainly would. I went off to meet with each, get his or her sign-off and support, and returned to both the president and CEO with support signatures and obtained the finances I needed.
Consider the Audience Sometimes all the support you need from the most senior level, the CEO or president, is a signature on an appropriation releasing the funds. At other times, their support is in the form of a message to the organization.
1:09 P.M.
Page 25
McClay
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:09 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
26
It’s amazing how much support you get when the CEO or president is behind your initiative. Unfortunately, politically minded people often check the organization chart before making a decision. We all know that there are followers and leaders in every organization. Your job is to gain support high enough to bring the followers along, just as you did in selling a customer; you need to determine roles and relative clout. Here is an example of how this might work. A well-known mid-western furniture manufacturer wanted to create a ‘‘learning organization,’’ an environment of ongoing learning, growth, and development for all employees. With this in mind, a well-seasoned training leader with remarkable credibility set out to create a state-of-theart facility to provide such an environment. But in order for this project to be successful, it had to have senior leadership support and, in fact, board funding approval. This person’s credibility made support from the highest levels possible, and the project proceeded, becoming a best-inclass facility not only in the industry and state, but unquestionably one of the top five in the nation. Most facilitators for the center were internal and well credentialed in their own right. The CEO who supported the project with the board also was an instructor. Can you guess how many other members of the senior management team also were involved in leading sessions in the new facility? Yes, my friend, you are correct—all members of the senior team became involved in one way or another in developing talent at the new learning center. As you can see, sometimes you need a signature and funds, and sometimes you need the direct support and presence of senior managers. As you plan your strategy, think about how to maintain support at this level for much more than just approving the funding.
Defining the Return When faced with a lack of your own earned credibility, as well as a lack of high-level support, you must consider another tactic. One tactic is showing the potential impact this initiative will have on the company’s bottom line. (I’m sure you needed that advantage when you were selling.)
Page 26
McClay
Winning Leadership Support for Sales Initiatives
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
27
Can you prove that changing the behaviors of certain individuals with training will have a return on investment for the company? If you have compelling evidence of such an outcome, then you are home free! Not so fast: we need to think this one through a bit. Why? Because people refute irrefutable evidence all the time! Most of us at one time or another have completed an exhaustive needs analysis to understand gaps in performance and have developed plans to close those gaps. It’s a good starting point, but the message is sometimes lost in the project minutiae. Have we considered business outcomes? Do we know the key business drivers of the internal organization? Is an earnings per share target such a driver? How about growing revenue? Reducing costs? Competing in new markets? Launching new products? Retaining talent? These questions, and their answers, are as important as your credibility in selling your initiative. Using business terms shows that you are thinking of the business—and management’s definitions of success. If you make management look good by helping to achieve their goals, you will become a business partner. Let’s dig a little deeper. A few years ago, Rob Brinkerhoff introduced a high-impact learning process called success case methodology,which is tied to measurement and evaluation of training outcomes. He should be credited with changing the way that many training people and businesspeople alike think about training outcomes. His process can help you gain that elusive credibility we all seek. And if you already have the credibility, it can cement your ability to gain support from senior management. Quite simply, it involves understanding the business-related questions above. Which business outcomes must be produced for the enterprise this year? Every company has a quarterly scorecard (at least the public ones do), and they are evaluated against their industry peers, forecasts, previous quarters, and more. We, as professionals, must understand those outcomes if we are to win. Here is a story that shows this point. Sales training at a large medical products company was historically classroom-based for new sales representatives joining the company.
1:09 P.M.
Page 27
McClay
28
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:09 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
Often reps were from outside the industry, so they had to learn about the industry as well as products. Experts were committed. A solid training process was in place. The sales training leader, working with an external consultant, determined it was time to move to an e-learning platform for product training and to institute a ‘‘masters’’ program for senior reps, as well as define a curriculum for overall sales development. The price tag would be more than $1 million for three years and included: analysis, selecting an e-learning vendor, design, development, 360-degree feedback instruments, and, of course, heavy use of the external facilitator. How would you sell this expensive idea to a conservative senior management staff? First, by understanding the company sales culture—what sales needed, sales usually received. Second, by using some ideas from Rob Brinkerhoff about measurement and proving outcomes. Finally, with a well-orchestrated plan expertly presented to upper levels, showing speed of learning and 24/7 access to e-learning modules (many of which were also used by experienced reps for their own quick reference). The outcome? Complete support from senior management! The metrics offered proof of success and encouraged continued funding. In the business climate today, we must be business professionals as well as sales leaders. Rob Brinkerhoff provides ample direction for how we get there. Understand the key business drivers of your organization first, and design your outcomes to meet those initiatives. Deceptively simple, and not impossible to execute! While having discussions with key senior leaders and trying to gain their support for your initiatives, you should be asking what the success drivers are for this year and/or this quarter. When you meet with business unit leaders, you should ask the same questions about those business units. Ask for the behavioral outcomes they need to see from your sales teams, sales managers, and senior sales leaders. The answers will tell you what your special initiative needs to accomplish. When you understand the business drivers, both for the company and the business unit in particular, you can create ‘‘line of sight’’ plans and ideas to accomplish those business objectives. (And you will have some very
Page 28
McClay
Winning Leadership Support for Sales Initiatives
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
29
interesting business discussions with those you engage.) Your project, your initiative, and your plan must be linked to business outcomes if you are to have a chance of winning support, with or without credibility. You really must understand your audience just as you did in your external sales role. We spend a lot of time training sales representatives on how to sell to senior executives with programs like ‘‘Selling to Senior Executives,’’ ‘‘Selling to Vito,’’ and ‘‘Selling to the C Level.’’ The message always is that, if you are going to sell to senior management, you must understand how they buy! It seems simple, and in some ways it is, but not always. I mentioned earlier that your priorities compete against other priorities. Executives have more on their plates than just your project. Someone (the president of our company in my story earlier in this chapter) must help you identify the ‘‘hot buttons’’ for his or her buying decisions. You need to understand the budget. Are there budget dollars available? Who is going to pay for your program? Will it be billed back to business units? Will the budget house the costs? There are always budget dollars available for the right idea. You may have to search to find them, but the dollars are there—somewhere. You also have to work with accounting to determine whether your project can be included in the ‘‘capital’’ budget. If a project includes hardware, building improvements, upgrades, or furniture, you may be able to capitalize the costs instead of expensing them. The expense budget is usually much more sensitive than the capital one. Maybe you can amortize the costs over several years, and this will help to reduce the single-year impact. You must shape the content of the message as well. Executive summaries are an excellent place to start. Become familiar with the detail that supports your summary, and find a way to make it short, sweet, and to the point. Realize too that the people you are presenting to are quick studies. They would not be where they are if they weren’t. Don’t oversell your proposal; get the signature and get out! Wow, does that sound like an old sales adage . . . once the customer signs the contract, shut up and leave quickly! The content is important, but so is the delivery. Many a great message, proposal, or project with an important payoff for the
1:09 P.M.
Page 29
McClay
30
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:09 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
company has been denied because the delivery was flawed. Just as a good facilitator can make an average training program come alive and a poor facilitator can destroy a good program, so too with a proposal. Here is an example. In a large manufacturing company, a proposed system would cost thousands of dollars and expert time from the systems group. It was clear to those pushing that this system would be beneficial to all managers worldwide, but the challenge was to convince the budget approvers in purchasing and finance that this was a good deal and a critical need for the company that could save millions. Gaining agreement for a meeting to discuss the project was a challenge, accomplished primarily through friends of influence. At this meeting, the decision makers were coached on using the system and provided with impressive marketing materials to engage their interest. They really enjoyed using the system and found the materials to be impressive. So they responded well to the internal sales pitch/public relations approach and approved the project. This took a long time (eighteen months), so patience and persistence were important to the success of this effort. Your executive summary is like the executive summary often built into a sales proposal, or a request for proposal response. Think about your customer—the senior executive—and build the summary around ‘‘what’s in it for them.’’ What are the business drivers? Will the project deliver results? and Why do they need it now? Why should they spend the company’s dollars on this instead of any one of several important initiatives? (Sound familiar?) Timing is critical! Timing is everything! If your proposal falls in Q1 and the budget was finalized three months before, you will have little chance of gaining approval. Unless, and this is a big one, someone very high up wants to support the project. As I said, there are always budget dollars available for the right idea. If your company is completing a good year, timing may be right for your proposal. If, on the other hand, it’s been a tough year or quarter, or the next year looks dismal, all bets are off on the proposal being accepted. And here is another point on timing that you cannot control: a change
Page 30
McClay
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
Winning Leadership Support for Sales Initiatives
31
in personnel. Leadership changes occur without your knowledge (at least before it happens), and you may find you’ve been working with the wrong people. Sales training company Miller Heiman, in its program Strategic Selling, would call this a red flag—a loss of executive sponsorship. Here’s something that happened in my company: My team and I worked for several months convincing a group president and an executive VP of sales how important it was to conduct a fundamental leadership program for the sales leadership team. Our proposal was strong, needs were identified, and curriculum was developed and tied to business outcomes. We had done everything. Our last meeting included four hours with the executive VP of sales defining launch strategies, attendees, and location—detail after detail. Three days later, an organization announcement was made: the company had reorganized business units and these two individuals were not retained. The outcome for my team: no sponsors and new decision makers—we had to start over.
Defining Outcomes Your next question is, or should be: How are you going to measure the success or outcomes of your project? Put yourself in the chair of the senior executive. Would you ask: What will be the outcome of my investment in your project? Have you measured the ROI? Will the investment make a difference? How will I know? Who else is supporting this (another way of asking whose neck, other than yours, is on the line)? Companies always measure the ROI of a capital project (new equipment, a plant, a system upgrade, or an acquisition), and you can measure the ROI on your project if it’s a capital expenditure. A N E X A M P L E FR O M O F TRAI NI NG
T H E
W O R L D
In a large equipment products company, a system was purchased to provide data on the success of sales promotions. The senior management decided that it was worth the investment to purchase and implement this
1:09 P.M.
Page 31
McClay
32
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:09 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
system. It was considered critical to the success of the organization and important to achieve organizational goals. The training group compared the costs of having the external company that designed the system conduct the training to the cost of having internal resources conduct the training. Management was sold on supporting the internal training effort. While the training was a success, the system was not, so management considered the training unsuccessful as well. The lesson we learned was to spend our training efforts on projects that are more likely to succeed rather than on risky ones, because management often cannot separate the failure of a project from the successful training that was conducted. It was a hard lesson and not one you can always avoid. With limited resources, it is important to prioritize the projects that you can be most successful in supporting, and that will show positive results for the organization.
Often the results of an initiative are intangible, much like buying insurance: I know I need it, I’m just not sure how much, which type, and for how long. Most would agree it’s better to have a trained workforce than an untrained one. Some might argue that if we train them, they might leave. Others might argue that if we don’t train them, and they stay, what do we have? (Which is worse?) Few senior leaders would disagree, but why then are training dollars the first cut from the budget? Many of us have experienced this over the years. We know the organization needs XYZ, and many times so do the executives, but decisions must be made. If you don’t have a direct link to business outcomes, you won’t obtain the funding! Sometimes even when you do, the funding is just not there. We were conducting a leadership development program through a large mid-western university for thirty-plus attendees. The program had budget approval and had been conducted before. In fact, the relationship we had with the university went back several years and several sessions. We had complete approval and support from the business units the participants worked in, and we were four weeks from launch. The university faculty had developed their sessions, correspondence had been
Page 32
McClay
Winning Leadership Support for Sales Initiatives
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
33
distributed to all, and university accommodations were booked. Then I received the dreaded phone call from the CEO’s office and was asked to immediately cancel the program. No discussion, no negotiations—just cancel it. I, of course, being of stout heart, scheduled a meeting with the CEO to explain why this was not a good idea for our company reputation and for the message it would send to participants, and that it was just too darn late to do such a thing. I received a quick lesson in economics, which I have never forgotten—what it means when a public company is close to missing quarterly results. The CEO not only wanted to save the cost of the program, travel, and missed work opportunities (there were a lot of sales leaders in the program), but he wanted to send a very clear message to the organization: your number 1 job is to make the numbers to which we committed. (I was not in sales, but was leading a major initiative during a quarter.) We postponed instead of canceling, and rescheduled six months later. The university, to their credit and our relationship, did not charge the normal cancellation fee, although it would have been impossible to schedule another company in the slot. I made sure the CEO knew what a good partner the university had been. We ran this program and several others there.
Budget Process and Timing Timing, as we’ve seen, can be so critical. The project was right—the purpose, process, funding, support, and agreements at all levels— and it was critical for leadership development. Sometimes the chief financial officer (CFO), not the CEO, is ‘‘to blame’’ for a project rejection: ‘‘Obviously, it’s the accountants who don’t understand the importance of our project and who reject it only because they have veto power! They don’t understand the complete merits of our very important endeavor!’’ In my CEO example, that CEO was an attorney by background, although he did understand the numbers quite well (as any CEO must!).
1:09 P.M.
Page 33
McClay
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:09 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
34
There are times though when the CFO or the accounting team can be your ally, rather than your adversary. Here’s another example from my experience: We were in the midst of an internal consulting project with our large account managers. We were trying to measure the outcome of our very extensive efforts by using additional volume and/or profits from their accounts. The account managers were held to rigorous details and analysis of their accounts. They dug deeper than they ever had into understanding their customers’ businesses. We looked at everything from marketing to operations to sales and distribution. Update meetings were held every three weeks, and each participant presented what he or she had learned and accomplished since our last meeting. There were three follow-up meetings after an initial training session to understand a process for building a deliverable and working with an external coach. A lot of time, effort, and sweat went into the program. We were collecting solid growth numbers, but needed more support to continue our efforts. To gain that support, we developed a presentation, which we delivered to our CFO. We were conservative in the results we were claiming; we didn’t want to get caught up in numbers we couldn’t support. He looked at our analysis, asked several good questions, as you would expect, and in the end told us our numbers were better than we thought they were! We were surprised, even though we had been knowingly conservative. He further pointed out results we could take credit for that we had not considered.
The point is that the accounting team, especially the CFO, can be helpful in selling your projects to senior management. If you have the numbers that the CFO supports, you can’t get a better recommendation! Before you present to the CFO, make sure you have worked with someone in accounting to help you understand which metrics make the biggest impression on those who approve the numbers. Is it return on assets (ROA), internal rate of return (IRR), or another measure? How are other projects judged? Do you need to prove a return on investment
Page 34
McClay
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
Winning Leadership Support for Sales Initiatives
35
in three years or five? The better you understand the internal accounting mechanism, the better you will be able to present your story.
Sell It How do you really develop that winning presentation, and what does it contain? As I mentioned earlier in the chapter, there is no one right way, but there are some elements that must be considered. The list below may help if you have not done this before. Even if you have, it might be worth a quick review of the fundamentals: 1. As you do in sales, know your audience and how they like to receive information. (If you don’t know, ask one of their assistants or get coaching as I did from the president.) Provide an executive summary, which should include answers to: Why are we doing this now? What impact will this have on the growth and development of participants? What is the change outcome that will make a difference? What are the costs? Don’t try to hide this at the end as most people do with proposals; present it up-front, but then explain why. What time will this save? Almost any project worth its salt will speed up a process or provide greater efficiencies. Which costs will the project reduce? For example, reduce travel, less time from the field, and more trainer time? Who, other than yourself, is sponsoring it? How long is the development time? Give yourself some flexibility here, no matter what your developers or external suppliers are telling you. When will it be implemented? 2. Always under-promise and over-deliver.
1:09 P.M.
Page 35
McClay
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:09 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
36
3. Keep it short. Brevity is one of the keys to success. 4. Bring the back-up data. Don’t be surprised with a question you can’t answer. (Just as you would prepare for a sales call, anticipate what your audience will want to know and questions they may ask.) 5. Practice, practice, practice. Don’t get fooled by what might seem to be an informal meeting. Even if you are not presenting via PowerPoint, be thoroughly prepared. In many cases, you have only one time to make a good impression. Even if you know your audience, don’t be too casual. 6. PowerPoint slides can be a great way to present, if done right. Make the presentation clear and concise. Avoid putting 80 percent of what you say on the slide! Put 20 percent of the information on the slide in bullet points, and talk to the rest. 7. Schedule enough time for the meeting, and avoid circumstances when they are preparing for board meetings or budgets and/or during the busy times in your organization. (Again, an executive assistant can give you insight here.) 8. Be enthusiastic but rational. They probably will be less excited about your project than you are, but your job is to get them excited. 9. Remember that your objective is to gain the commitment—once you do, leave. Don’t become caught up in trying to explain more just because you think they should know. Once you get the signature, grab it and run.
Progress Updates As part of your project proposal, you should plan to provide feedback on progress and demonstrate, within a reasonable period of time, that the dollars invested were invested wisely. The story earlier from the medical products company included very detailed end-of-the-quarter and annual
Page 36
McClay
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
Winning Leadership Support for Sales Initiatives
37
ROI analyses. It was a three-year project, so interim accounting of costs and results was critical in gaining additional funding. In order to obtain funding from senior management for your next project, you must provide progress reports. These should be at least annually or, even better, quarterly to apprise the leadership team of your success and accomplishments. Again, consider your audience. They don’t need length or depth; they need a brief synopsis of accomplishments and measures. For example: 1. The results we are seeing are as follows . . . . 2. Our cost savings have been . . . . 3. Our improvements in process are as follows . . . . 4. Our time savings have resulted in X . . . . They will tell you if they want more information, so you should be prepared. Tips for Success 1. Start with company or organization priorities and goals. 2. Identify what training is required to achieve those goals. 3. List all stakeholders (see example below). Create a plan to engage each stakeholder (person who stands to benefit from the successful implementation) and explain how it will support his or her success. 4. Find out the definition of success. 5. Design the training to achieve this definition of success and the learning objectives that would ensure that organization results can be achieved. 6. Don’t waste time and money on projects that are not viewed as essential by key leadership. 7. Start a year ahead to obtain budget funds for key projects. 8. Put together a solid business case
1:09 P.M.
Page 37
McClay
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:09 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
38
9. Don’t be disappointed if you don’t get the funding. They are often choosing among many other important initiatives. 10. Keep informed of the state of the business, choose your timing (when they have money to spend), and word requests very carefully. 11. Always keep open communications regarding status of projects, needs of management, and success celebrations with management and stakeholders. The results of gaining leadership support for initiatives might include the following: 1. Priorities are always agreed on by the end of the year for the next year. 2. There is a large budget and there is support for training. 3. Suppliers are engaged as partners for success. 4. Purchasing helps with RFP and approval process. 5. Finance always says yes. 6. Senior management introduces concepts and ideas and demonstrates their leadership. Credit for results is often shared with training. 7. Sales representatives and sales managers ask for more training on a continuous basis and often fund it. 8. Training expenditures are approved quickly. 9. Training often is highlighted in the company newsletter. 10. Senior managers often attend and stop in on training sessions. 11. Many managers conduct training sessions, as requested. 12. Subject-matter experts make it a priority to be available for design, review, and delivery of training programs. 13. Managers and the best salespeople make themselves available to coach those who request their support. 14. Training results are reviewed on a monthly or quarterly basis.
Page 38
McClay
c02.tex
Winning Leadership Support for Sales Initiatives
V3 - 12/09/2009
39
15. Awards and recognition are given to training staff and sales representatives for outstanding performance. A
S ALE S
TRA INING
EX A MPL E
We were developing a low-cost (webcast) approach to training sales representatives on new products and we engaged the VP of sales in the design and implementation to save money on travel and training costs and time. The VP agreed to invite participants with our prewritten memo and his signature. He then followed up the memo with a phone message to all sales representatives telling them that he expected their full participation and would be checking to see who attended and who did not. Then he asked for attendance rosters and gave them to his directors to follow up to see why someone had not attended the session. He congratulated those who completed the training and encouraged them to use the techniques they learned in the next few months so he could track the increase in sales on the product. This really motivated or coerced everyone to attend and apply the new learning because they knew the expectations and follow-up would be conducted by their managers. They would be responsible for applying the new learning and showing results from the training. Sales on the product on which they were trained were closely tracked to ensure the reps were using the knowledge and skills that had been learned.
In short, what you want to do is 1. Develop a plan to obtain leadership support. 2. Find out what the ‘‘hot buttons’’ are for key leaders. 3. Use their terms and examples to prepare to discuss what they would like training to do for them. 4. Deliver excellence on a continuous basis. 5. Make them the leaders of the training effort, but do all the work for them.
1:09 P.M.
Page 39
McClay
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:09 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
40
A N O T H E R
EX A M P L E
We were asked by the president of the division to create a university in which senior executives would learn to use and teach their employees about new products. Our dialogue helped us learn what he was looking for, and we agreed to provide drafts for his approval. We quickly worked as a team to design a proposal and some examples for his review. We made him the ‘‘dean’’ of the university, created a curriculum, and brought him sample tools and certificates for the completion of the training. After some revisions based on his input, the program was introduced at the annual executive meeting by the president, who expressed his expectation of completion by every executive. He would receive monthly reports regarding who had completed the training and who had conducted the training for his or her sales representatives, and he would personally sign and present the certificate of completion to each executive. Ongoing communications from the president (which we created and he signed) were sent to all executives throughout the year. Lists of those who had completed each phase of the university sessions were sent out to all executives on a monthly basis so that those who had completed were recognized and those who had not completed were motivated to finish quickly.
Your Plan for Leadership Support Answer the following questions in order to get leadership support for a specific initiative. If you find that categories cannot be completed, it is time to do more homework to determine the answers to these critical success factors. This list is just a beginning; you should add other factors that will be important to the success of the project. 1. What critical needs have to be identified? 2. What is required to achieve organization goals and targets? 3. Who are the key stakeholders?
Page 40
McClay
c02.tex
Winning Leadership Support for Sales Initiatives
V3 - 12/09/2009
41
4. What are the costs? 5. What results need to be achieved? 6. What are the objectives? 7. What is the timing? 8. What is the plan? 9. What is the schedule for engaging stakeholders? 10. What are the roles and responsibilities? 11. What are the measures of success? 12. What is the communication plan? 13. Is there a design document? 14. What is the implementation plan? Persuasion is an art and a science, and it is important in gaining other people’s support. ‘‘Change management’’ to engage support of leadership often depends on relationships that have been built over time (trust) and the numbers to prove success. Senior managers are people too. Find out what they like—and especially what they don’t like. Just like your customers, administrative assistants are your best friends (or they can be your worst enemies, that is, gatekeepers). Always make the senior leaders and your manager look good. Find ways to talk to managers on a more casual basis, such as after presentations or at charity, community, or network events that you attend to show your support of their interests. Always tie your initiatives to the corporate goals they are committed to achieving. Show that you value their time by making their involvement brief and preparing everything for them to ensure that things proceed smoothly.
Summary There are a lot of right ways to gain acceptance on the projects you bring to senior management seeking their support, and there are a few things you can do to shoot yourself in the foot, so to speak.
1:09 P.M.
Page 41
McClay
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:09 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
42
I hope this chapter has spurred your thinking about your approach to gaining support. But let me capture what I think is most salient: selling to senior executives is not completely different from selling to senior levels of a customer or prospect. You must 1. Have credibility (If you don’t have it, you need to find a way to get it!); 2. Consider the audience and the message content, length, depth, time, structure, level and position of buyers, and more; 3. Make sure your project provides a return on investment for the corporation because you are competing against other projects that will; 4. Define project outcomes very clearly, with ROI, time savings, improved efficiencies, and more; 5. Understand the budget process timing; 6. Be prepared to answer questions; 7. Practice, practice, practice; 8. Get the order and get out; 9. Plan progress reports and gain senior management agreement on when they want to see them; and 10. Remember that selling internally is not that different from selling externally. So, let’s get going! There are lots of people to persuade! Questions for Reflection • Challenge yourself . . . . Do you really have credibility within your organization? Why? Are you sure? Can you prove it? • Are you willing to put that credibility on the line, risk it to get support for your next project? • How well do you know your audience? Are there new players? Do they all think alike? Do they all buy what you are selling?
Page 42
McClay
Winning Leadership Support for Sales Initiatives
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
43
• How good are your investment numbers? Will they pass muster with your CFO? Have you asked the CFO or someone else in finance to test your logic? • As you wrote your proposal, did you clearly define the outcomes? Can the real value be found? Have you differentiated your project from others under consideration? • What about your timing? Are you in line with the budgeting process? • Who else do you need for support? If you have an advisory can you get submarined at the last minute?
Recommended Resources Robert O. Brinkerhoff. Success Case: Find Out Quickly What’s Working and What’s Not. San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler, 2003. Robert O. Brinkerhoff and Anne M. Apking. High Impact Learning Process: Strategies for Leveraging Business Results from Training. New York: Perseus Publishing, 2001. Robert B. Miller and Stephen E. Heiman, with Tad Tuleja. Strategic Selling: The Unique Sales System Proven Successful by America’s Best Companies. Reno, NV: Miller Heiman.
1:09 P.M.
Page 43
McClay
c02.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:09 P.M.
Page 44
McClay
c03.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
3 The Perfect Salesperson A Guide to Building Your Dream Team Teresa Hiatt
T
HE NEED FOR sales training is very easy to document. Anyone who has ever done a survey and asked a sales team what they need to
be more successful can attest to the fact that the salespeople always want more training. Any analysis of poor sales results, lower profits margins, sales productivity declines, or any other problem that might involve a sales team will almost always have ‘‘more training needed’’ somewhere in the top few causes of the problem. Also, to be fair, when research is done to showcase positive areas of sales success, ‘‘good training’’ or a ‘‘well-trained sales force’’ is often highlighted as a key ingredient to the success. Jerry Marterella, of the Lincoln Consulting Group, states in his article for the Chally Group, titled ‘‘The Eight Critical Success Factors of a High Performance Sales and Marketing Organization,’’ that ongoing skills training is the key component of the second critical success factor. 45
1:11 P.M.
Page 45
McClay
46
c03.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:11 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
Research, expert opinion, and even common sense agree that an ongoing program of sales training is a key component to sales success. What we cannot find is similar agreement from all the research and opinions about exactly what kind of sales training we should be doing. Whether it is the sales manager conducting informal training at the weekly sales meetings or formal training conducted by professional sales trainers, there are wildly diverse methods, content, and focus for sales training across the industry. Let’s stop and ask a question. ‘‘Why are there so many different styles, types, and content for sales training?’’ Answer. ‘‘Because none of them works for every situation.’’ Because we have clearly established a need for sales training, our goal is to take that one step further and help define what kind of sales training should be delivered to a given sales team. One of the most effective ways to approach the creation of training programs is to start with a competency model.
What Are Competency Models? Competency models define the key characteristics and job tasks that are performed by top performers of the job. They are a way of associating success at the job with predictable, repeatable, objective activities that show up with statistical frequency in observed performance of the job. Rather than think of training as a way to introduce newly hired people to the company, give information about the job, or provide communication about resources, think of training as delivering the necessary skill sets to fill any gaps between what the student consistently does in her or his job and what a top performer would do in the same job. Tactical Planning: A manager may also use the competency model to determine weekly or daily activities and expectations for an employee. This can help with time management, performance goal planning, and other management tasks.
Page 46
McClay
c03.tex
T h e Pe r f e c t S a l e s p e r s o n
V3 - 12/09/2009
47
Strategic Planning: By using the competency model to define the critical job tasks, management can also make strategic planning decisions on technology, resources, and manpower allocation. Once it is clear what job tasks are required for top performers, more emphasis can be placed on enabling those specific tasks.
Creating a Competency Model for Sales The fundamentals of developing a competency model are easy: basically, just watch several people who are very good at doing a job for a while and record what common things they all do and how those tasks help make them successful. Sounds really easy, but there are some tricks to creating a repeatable, predictable model. First, a group of top-performing salespeople has to be defined. This may seem simple on the surface, but many teams have isolated a group based solely on highest sales for the year and found little or no commonality and have given up on the competency model process. Let’s define top-performing salespeople and avoid a common mistake in this area. Typically the very top (5 percent or so) of an active sales force are rogue outliers. These are salespeople who succeed on the sheer force of their powerful charisma and personality. They have a unique inborn set of personal communications skills and work habits that cannot be predicted, reproduced, or measured. Start by eliminating these outliers from the initial assessment, as only frustration and failure will result if you leave them in. Imagine creating a training plan for developing basketball talent that had a requirement of being born eight feet tall. This would hardly be the kind of repeatable behavior that can be the focus of training. Once the outliers have been removed from the stack ranking, the top-performing group is defined as the next 10 percent of the sales force. A process of interviews, observation, and manager input can be used to create a list of the most important facets of the job, such as sales activity, technical knowledge, business acumen, etc. It can be as simple as asking the group to identify specific job tasks they use to make successful sales, or it can be a comprehensive analysis completed by one of the many
1:11 P.M.
Page 47
McClay
c03.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:11 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
48
vendors that provide this service. The key is to find common items across the group in predictable, repeatable patterns. The key to developing a good sales competency model is to find common items across the group in predictable, repeatable patterns.
Each job task that seems to be common across the group of top performers is then given a reality check and labeled according to business impact. For example, we could find that our top performers all wash their hands before making sales calls, but a reality check would identify that task as having minimal business impact and it would be excluded from the list.
Sample Competency Models Below is an example of a simple sales competency model using ten job tasks found to be common across a group of top-performing salespeople in the technology solutions industry. Each job task is further defined by how that task might be applied on the job (this is called evidence). Sales Competency Model for Salespeople in Technology Solutions Evidence Characteristic 1 Sales Activity Employs a systematic, consistent process for sales cycle Maintains high levels of activity in contacting new and existing customers Keeps a full pipeline of customers in various stages of the sales cycle Reports regularly and accurately on sales forecasts 2 Technical and Product Knowledge Demonstrates knowledge of full product line and features Exhibits awareness of competitive solutions in the marketplace
Page 48
McClay
c03.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
T h e Pe r f e c t S a l e s p e r s o n
49
Evidence Characteristic Pursues sales-appropriate technical skills, achieves relevant technical certifications Displays comprehension of relevant industry technical terminology 3 Solution Selling Expertise Approaches customers to offer solutions, not just sell product Effectively conducts comprehensive needs assessments with customers Able to confidently propose appropriate solutions that meet customer objectives 4 Competitive Excellence Understands performance expectations and requirements Takes active steps to address performance gaps quickly Works to enhance skills through role plays and working with mentors Provides performance activity metrics to manager 5 Business Operation and Financial Acumen Articulates business strategy and company goals Displays knowledge of customer’s business fundamentals Uses business terminology correctly to describe solutions benefits Actively pursues research about customer vertical markets 6 Tactical Planning Actively uses planning tools such as Salesforce, calendars, tickler files Effectively plans and strategizes for customer calls Knows how and when to ‘‘close the deal’’ with the customer Accurately forecasts sales achievements (Continued)
1:11 P.M.
Page 49
McClay
c03.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:11 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
50
Sales Competency Model for Salespeople in Technology Solutions (Continued) Evidence Characteristic 7 Time Management and Prioritization Plans effective use of own time to accomplish tasks Starts each day with a clear plan Spends limited time ‘‘fighting fires’’ or crisis management Adjusts schedule based on priority situations as they arise 8 Professional Development Consistently displays a professional demeanor to both co-workers and customers Maintains industry expertise through reading of trade journals, publications, and Internet research Follows an individual continuous education program for professional growth 9 Builds Effective Relationships Within the team, asks questions, expresses concerns, and makes suggestions for process improvements Shares customer challenges with manager in a timely manner Takes active steps to build long-term customer relationships Shares credit for successes 10 Communicates with Impact Uses appropriate grammar and syntax Selects appropriate communications style (face to face, telephone, email) Collaborates with peers to develop ideas and course of action Communicates customer or staff needs and suggestions to relevant others
Page 50
McClay
c03.tex
T h e Pe r f e c t S a l e s p e r s o n
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:11 P.M.
51
Here’s an example of one for a sales management role in the same industry: Sales Manager Competency Model Competency
Evidence Characteristic
1 Strives for Success Employs a systematic method for reviewing and evaluating sales rep performance, sales reports, ride-alongs, customer feedback Sets clear expectations of sales reps’ activities and performance standards Involves sales reps in establishing long-term goals Allocates ample time for sales reps to be trained on key skills 2 Coaching Addresses performance gaps quickly Understands and practices coaching Helps sales reps enhance their skills through role plays, targeted assignments, and working with mentors Provides individually targeted recognition and rewards 3 Business Operation and Financial Acumen Articulates business strategy and scorecard goals Displays knowledge of business fundamentals Uses business terminology correctly Correctly identifies revenue and profit sources 4 Sales Rep Recruitment and Selection Takes active steps to attract top sales talent Utilizes behavior-based interviewing skills 5 Leverage of Technical and Product Knowledge Demonstrates knowledge of full solution offerings Aware of competitive solutions in the marketplace (Continued)
Page 51
McClay
c03.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:11 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
52
Sales Manager Competency Model (Continued) Competency
6
7
8
9
Evidence Characteristic
Encourages technical excellence in sales reps, promotes technical certifications Displays comprehension of industry technical terminology Tactical Planning and Project Management Actively uses planning tools such as calendars, tickler files, etc. Clearly advertises team objectives and regularly reviews progress, milestone achievements Accurately forecasts sales, budgeting, and personnel needs Time Management and Prioritization Plans effective use of own time to accomplish tasks Starts each day with a clear plan Spends limited time ‘‘fighting fires’’ or crisis management Adjusts schedule based on priority situations as they arise Leadership and Development Makes timely, effective decisions after gathering adequate information Consistently displays a professional demeanor to both co-workers and customers Maintains industry expertise through reading of trade journals, publications, and Internet research Follows an individual continuous education program for professional growth Builds Effective Relationships Offers opportunities for team members to ask questions, express concerns, and make suggestions Shares information about organizational changes or problems in a timely manner
Page 52
McClay
c03.tex
T h e Pe r f e c t S a l e s p e r s o n
Competency
V3 - 12/09/2009
53
Evidence Characteristic
Supports corporate or group decisions, even if not in total agreement Shares credit for successes 10 Communicates with Impact Uses appropriate grammar and syntax Selects appropriate communications style (face to face, telephone, email) Collaborates with peers to develop ideas and courses of action Communicates customer or staff needs and suggestions to relevant others 11 Solution Selling Expertise Conducts effective in-depth account reviews with sales reps Encourages reps to conduct comprehensive customer needs assessments Advocates a culture change from ‘‘box’’ selling to ‘‘solution’’ selling mentality Instead of devising your competency model from scratch, it may be efficient to begin with a sample model such as these and work with a team to customize the model for a specific business environment. Sample models can be purchased from companies that develop models or are sometimes found through professional associations, HR groups, or training organizations.
Using Competency Models to Develop Hiring Profiles In addition to providing the basis for developing training, competency models can be used to develop a hiring profile that will help select qualified candidates. The specific job tasks can be used to develop
1:11 P.M.
Page 53
McClay
c03.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:11 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
54
behavior-based questions for applicants. By asking questions about how these tasks may have been done by the applicant in the past, an interviewer can be listening for evidence of the required skill sets. For example, if a competency model is developed and it states that a high level of sales call activity is common to successful people performing this job, an interview question might be framed in a manner to discover whether a potential candidate can produce high sales call activity. The question could be: ‘‘Have you ever had the experience of having to increase sales call activity? If so, how did you go about it, and what were the results?’’ By using the competency model to help develop a hiring profile, new applicants can be examined against a standard that has been proven to be effective in the real-world sales environment. Applicants can gain a better understanding of the job expectations when shown a list of evidence characteristics.
Testing Against the Model Once a solid model has been developed, it can then be used to help identify the problem areas training can affect. Simply put, now that the specific job tasks a top producer performs are identified, how well does our current sales force match up against that ideal? Training professionals who skip this narrowing step often find themselves with far too many objectives for a meaningful program. There is also a high risk of training the sales force on tasks they already do well and diluting the value of the training program. It is important to measure the sales force against the ideal and clearly identify areas of weakness that can be addressed by a targeted training program. There are several methods to test the sales force.
Objective vs. Subjective The most time-consuming method for measuring an existing sales force against the model is to build an objective exam based on the identified competencies. Each question must be written so that it reveals whether or not the examinee is proficient in particular tasks. This can be difficult
Page 54
McClay
c03.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
T h e Pe r f e c t S a l e s p e r s o n
55
when some of the job tasks include items such as ‘‘addresses performance gaps quickly,’’ but questions can be used to draw out expected responses if the skill is being practiced. Below are some questions that have been used to test against the standard for sales managers. Note how the underlying competency being tested can be seen in the flavor of the question. 1. What are the best ways to monitor sales rep performance? (Select all that apply.) a. Sales reports b. Ride-alongs c. Customer feedback d. Feedback from other employees e. Ask the sales rep during quarterly interviews 2. Which of the following is an example of a clear expectation that a sales manager might set for a sales rep? a. Make a minimum of three appointments with clients each week. b. Dress in proper attire for meeting with clients. c. Check messages on a timely basis. d. Submit expense reports on time. e. Provide updates to the sales manager on a regular basis. 3. The process of analyzing the needs of the business and selecting the assets that will maximize its value is known as: a. Capital budgeting b. Financial management c. Comprehensive budgeting d. Fixed budgeting 4. Where in your office is your business plan posted? (Select one.) a. In my immediate work area b. In a central common area c. In a binder on my desk
1:11 P.M.
Page 55
McClay
c03.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:11 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
56
d. On my computer or shared network drive e. I do not post the business plan 5. Which of the following approaches are effective in developing new sales reps? (Select all that apply.) a. Let the sales rep create the person’s own development plan. b. On-the-job training with top performers. c. Encourage the sales rep to work with a sales development manager for coaching as needed. d. Practice product demonstrations in the showroom with someone who can give the sales rep feedback on the demonstration. e. Set a low sales quota to start. 6. Which of the following are valid time management techniques for handling daily work-related tasks such as emails and correspondence? a. Check email frequently throughout the day, as time permits, to be sure to keep current. b. Limit email reading and responding to correspondence to scheduled times each day to prevent interruptions to higherpriority tasks. c. Only respond to urgent, customer-related email; read and respond to other email when business is slow. d. Keep the daily schedule fluid to allow for rapid response to emergencies as they arise during the day. 7. Which of the following are important time management practices that should be part of the normal business day? (Select all that apply.) a. Dedicate time each day to set tasks for the day that are labeled high, medium, and low priority so that important tasks are done first.
Page 56
McClay
T h e Pe r f e c t S a l e s p e r s o n
c03.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
57
b. Keep planning to a minimum to be able to respond quickly to situations that arise during the day. c. Post a copy of the team’s monthly activity goals in a visible place, so they can be kept in mind during daily tasks. d. Be sure to get enough sleep every night. 8. In a year’s time, how much time should be set aside for sales reps to attend training on skills related to their job? a. One or two days b. Three to four days c. Five to ten days d. It is the sales reps’ responsibility to schedule training on their own time. e. There is no need for formal training; training on key skills can best be handled ‘‘on the job.’’ 9. From the list below, what would be the most appropriate response from you as a manager if your team were faced with a directive from management that is not very popular? a. Sympathize with your team about the unpopular directive and help brainstorm ways that it can be accomplished despite its unpopular points. b. Allow team members to offer feedback and express concerns, but fully support the corporate decision, even if you are not in full agreement. c. Help the team work up viable objections to the directive and present those to your immediate management as additional information. d. Enforce the directive as instructed by senior management. 10. You just reviewed a copy of a letter to a customer from a sales rep and found three mistakes in grammar. Because you are familiar with the account, you are reasonably certain that the customer
1:11 P.M.
Page 57
McClay
c03.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:11 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
58
will never notice the mistakes. What course of action would you take? a. Discuss the problem with the rep via email. b. Take no action until you review additional correspondence sent by the sales rep. c. Discuss the problem with the rep in a face-to-face meeting. d. Discuss the problem with the rep over the phone. Another way to test against the model is to ask both the employee and the employee’s manager to rate performance in the specific areas. Although this is a subjective method, it often yields good results if the competencies and evidence characteristics are clearly defined. On the next page is an example of a subjective competency analysis showing where an employee and manager would rate the proficiency level of the various competencies based on the descriptive activities provided. Tip: When time is short or budget tight, it is advantageous to make the initial process simple by listing only the competencies identified and customizing a proficiency rating scale for the particular business environment for which the training program is being designed.
Analyzing the Results Once the exams have been administered and graded or the subjective assessments have been recorded, the comparison can now be made against the ideal. Rank the test scores or proficiency ratings of the various competencies as compiled from the objective or subjective assessments from lowest to highest. Thus revealed is the priority list of the training strategy needed to bring this sales force up a level in performance. The areas in which the sales force scored the lowest highlight the competency gap between the role model and the actual proficiency. Depending on how serious the gaps between the ideal and the actual are, these lists will probably give the top two or three course goals and learning objectives to be covered in a training program. If there is a very significant gap in an area, it may be important to address that one area before any lowerpriority items are addressed.
Page 58
2. Productivity
1. Communications
Competency
delivers needed information Keeps communications clear and straightforward; explains technical terms appropriately and succinctly
exhibits a presence that commands attention and respect across organizational levels
applications; knows where and how to locate and utilize Ricoh resources efficiently
standard productivity applications, when needed; can access and competently use advanced productivity
Proficient in the use of
Exhibits a confident, open communication style that encourages dialogue and effectively
Effectively delivers presentations to groups; uses clear, concise written skills;
accomplish goals; coordinates with internal and external partners
Takes advantage of available resources (individuals, processes, departments, and tools) to complete work efficiently and
Displays intermediate level use of advanced applications such as Visio, MS Project, or other applications
Displays expert use of common applications such as Word, Excel, and PowerPoint
Activities
Skill Expert
Skilled
Unskilled
(Continued)
Proficiency Rating Working Knowledge Unfamiliar
McClay c03.tex V3 - 12/09/2009
T h e Pe r f e c t S a l e s p e r s o n 59
1:11 P.M. Page 59
3. Organizational Skills
Competency
and yearly planning
allocating times and resources to accomplish job tasks; employs time management principles in daily, monthly,
Schedules times appropriately; demonstrates solid project management fundamentals in
Skill Expert
Skilled
Proficiency Rating Working Knowledge Unfamiliar Unskilled
60
other systems to coordinate and prioritize tasks, schedule meetings, and/or allow others to schedule time with him/her
materials and people needed Uses workable formal planning tools such as Day-Timers, calendars, tickler files, PDAs, or
individuals, processes, departments, and tools) by breaking them down into tasks and appropriately scheduling
milestones; rarely misses deadlines Determines resource requirements needed to accomplish goals (i.e.,
Allocates appropriate amounts of time for completing own and others’ work; avoids scheduling conflicts; develops timelines and
Activities
McClay c03.tex V3 - 12/09/2009 1:11 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
Page 60
4. Customer Focus
customers; takes action to meet customer needs; gathers and implements customer feedback
Seeks to understand both internal and external
when indicated; refers customer feedback to other departments when appropriate
complaints or issues with a sense of urgency and understanding that customers have other options in the market Employs a formal, consistent process for tracking customer feedback; takes corrective action
customer organization and needs and to develop appropriate solutions Efficiently deals with customer
Seeks information to understand
McClay
T h e Pe r f e c t S a l e s p e r s o n c03.tex V3 - 12/09/2009
61
1:11 P.M. Page 61
McClay
c03.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:11 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
62
Is Training the Answer? One caveat to explore at this point is the trap of ‘‘process gaps’’ as opposed to ‘‘knowledge gaps.’’ A sales manager competency model was developed for a business-to-business sales company, and it revealed that the top sales managers all shared a common attribute in that they heavily recruited top talent to their teams. An assessment of the sales manager population as a whole revealed that most sales managers did not use best practices in recruiting top talent, so a training program was developed to teach the sales managers how to recruit in the same fashion used by the top sales managers. The program was launched with much fanfare, but few details until the actual week of the training. As soon as the sales managers realized the focus of the content, they became discontent. As it turned out, they knew the best way to recruit; however, their individual regions had made the decision to outsource recruiting and so the sales managers had no opportunity to use the skills they already possessed. The problem was a process gap, not a knowledge gap. In this case, training was not the solution. To avoid this trap, do some questioning to validate the results of the gap analysis.
Business Impact This is a good time to look at the least performing competency areas and gauge which one or two will have the most immediate business impact if addressed quickly. Assessments provide accurate information that is used to rapidly address problems with an effective, visible, positive change and add credibility to the process. Future training programs benefit from the credibility built on the success of the previous program. It then becomes possible to address longer-term goals and objectives with support from the target audience. Using the competency model method to develop a training strategy is less likely to lead to the creation of training programs that are not in alignment with the needs of the audience, as data is collected directly from the student audience. To make sure this does not happen, be sure
Page 62
McClay
T h e Pe r f e c t S a l e s p e r s o n
c03.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
63
to verify the competencies against consistent, repeatable, predictable top performers. Once this point in the cycle of the competency model method is reached and at least one problem competency area is identified, the instructional designer should ask the question: ‘‘If we fix this problem competency area, will it generate a business impact to the organization?’’ If the answer is yes, the model has been used successfully. If the answer is no, there is an error in the model and the process reverts back to development of the model.
Creating the Instructional Strategy Since this method involves laying good foundational work at the beginning of the process, it makes the rest of the training development process easier. The designer already has a good learner profile defined in the competency model. This profile can be used to target the best delivery method, determine the length of the training program, and define any constraints of the program. When the specific competency area targeted for improvement is highlighted by the gap analysis, the course goals and learning objectives can be easily defined. Test questions that a successful student of the program should be able to answer are easy to write, since an objective assessment of the competency model would have been reviewed earlier. Finally, the actual course content can be gleaned from the initial group of top performers who helped define the competency model. C A S E
S T U DY
A leading manufacturer of wireless technology started an evolution of their sales strategy. They decided to move their sales force from a traditional hardware reseller model to a solution provider model that would offer their customers not only hardware devices, but configuration and security services. The new model more fully met the needs of their customers and
1:11 P.M.
Page 63
McClay
c03.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:11 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
64
greatly improved the profit margin of the average sale (hardware prices had become more compressed). Although a comprehensive training program was delivered to all salespeople at the initial launch of the evolution, it became apparent that only about 20 percent of the sales force was successful making the transition. The other 80 percent continued to rely on hardware-only sales. After ensuring the sales management team was on board with the transition process, a competency model was developed from the 20 percent of successful salespeople. (Note: A handful of salespeople who seemed to excel using unpredictable methods were removed from this model group.) With ten solid competencies defined, the company conducted a sales-force-wide assessment against those competencies. Two areas scored very low, which quickly highlighted the target areas for a remedial training program. The first area, Technical Expertise, was no surprise and would have been the first one picked for a training program based on anecdotal knowledge that many salespeople did not understand the services customers needed. The second area, Time Management, was a big surprise, since it was considered more of a basic business skill, rather than a specific sales skill. What the competency model had shown was that with the longer sales cycle, salespeople who could prioritize tasks, manage their database, and organize their sales calls could take the extra time needed to understand customer needs before offering a proposal. The training group gathered a list of time-saving best practices from the role model group and created an effective time-management module to accompany the technical expertise workshop. The training program delivered as a result of the competency model method had a quick business impact; there was an 18 percent increase in services proposals in the four months following the program launch. In addition, the next two competency areas became the focus of a longer-term project delivered throughout the following year. The bottom line: If relying solely on field research, the Technical Expertise aspect would have been the only topic addressed by the initial training program. Time
Page 64
McClay
c03.tex
T h e Pe r f e c t S a l e s p e r s o n
V3 - 12/09/2009
65
management would never have been addressed, and the organization would have missed out on the increase in service proposals. In a reverse case study, another sales company engaged the services of a training provider to develop a training program for newly hired salespeople. The training provider conducted interviews with sales managers, asking for input on what the training program needed to include. Because newly hired salespeople require additional attention from their manager to answer questions about their benefits, work expectations, and development plans, the sales managers all recommended these elements be covered in training. As requested, the training provided now focused on the sales managers’ concerns and delivered the program on time, on budget. Students graduating from the program no longer bothered their sales managers with questions, but they also failed at making sales, since that was not the focus of their training. Also, because they had no need to develop relationships with their managers, they also did not feel comfortable bringing problems to their attention, and thus turnover increased. By delivering what the sales manager WANTED instead of what the students NEEDED to be successful, the training program had the overall effect of decreasing sales, destroying the effectiveness of sales teams, and increasing turnover. Lesson learned: A good training developer never asks a customer what he or she wants in a training program. He or she asks: ‘‘What business measures do you want to impact with this training program?’’
Summary For many sales companies, it is of vital importance that valuable sales staff time be used on training programs that have a direct bearing on unique needs of the business. Building a competency model and testing the sales force against that model is a reliable way to align business needs with training programs. The competency model method also gives valuable information for hiring profiles and long-term training strategies.
1:11 P.M.
Page 65
McClay
c03.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:11 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
66
Questions for Reflection • Have you ever attended a training program that seemed disconnected from the realities of your actual job? How might the training program have been made more relevant using the competency model method? • What job tasks of the sales professional have changed over the last twenty years? What job tasks have remained the same? • How would the job tasks of a salesperson targeting small to midsize businesses be different from those of a salesperson targeting large businesses? • Have you ever interviewed or been interviewed with competencymodel-based behavior questions, as opposed to traditional resume questions? What additional information is gathered from competency-model-based questions that help make a hiring decision?
Page 66
McClay
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
4 Develop Sales Reps Using Structured Feedback Kenneth R. Phillips
L
EADERSHIP AND MANAGEMENT guru Ken Blanchard, borrowing from a well-known breakfast cereal, describes feedback
as the ‘‘Breakfast of Champions.’’ What’s more, he’s right. When used effectively, feedback can reinforce something a sales rep has done well in order to get the rep to do more of the same, point out an area in which a sales rep’s performance is below expectations in hopes the rep will adjust his or her future performance in order to meet expectations, and let a sales rep know where he or she stands. However, the extent to which feedback is able to fulfill these functions depends on two elements: (1) how accurately a sales rep perceives the feedback he or she receives and (2) the extent to which the rep accepts the feedback and believes that it is an accurate portrayal of his or her past job behavior or performance (Ilgen, Fischer, & Taylor, 1979). 67
1:14 P.M.
Page 67
McClay
68
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:14 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
Unfortunately, due to the nature of the job, most sales reps don’t get much effective feedback. There are, of course, the occasional joint sales calls with a sales manager, but often the feedback received focuses on the content of the call (what company products and services the rep discussed with the customer) and not on the process (how well the rep engaged in relationship building, identifying customer needs, exploring possible solutions, etc.). And while feedback on call content is important, it’s no more important than process feedback. Some people might also suggest that sales reps receive feedback each time they make or fail to make a sale. While no doubt this is a form of feedback, it is analogous to someone telling you that you either did a good job or a poor job performing some job task. While hearing that you did a good job makes you feel better than hearing you did a poor job, neither offers much useful feedback. The question in both cases remains: ‘‘What specifically did I do well or poorly so that either I can do more of the same or take corrective action and get back on track?’’ The Sales Skills Assessment–Self and Other that appear later in this chapter are tools to help sales reps obtain specific actionable feedback regarding their strengths and development needs in working with customers. The value of this feedback is that it creates awareness and gives sales reps the ability to see where changes are needed—to identify and break bad habits and become more effective. The assessment consists of forty-two statements divided into seven scales or dimensions. The scales are taken from the Harvard University Competency Dictionary and were chosen by a group of sales managers who saw them as critical to working effectively with customers. A brief description of each scale follows: Building Trust—Interacting with customers and others in a way that gives them confidence in your intentions and those of your organization. Communication— Clearly conveying information and ideas to individuals or groups in a manner that engages them and helps them understand and retain the message.
Page 68
McClay
D e v e l o p S a l e s Re p s U s i n g S t r u c t u r e d Fe e d b a c k
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
69
Customer Focus— Making customers and their needs a primary focus of your actions; developing and sustaining productive customer relationships. Gaining Commitment— Using appropriate interpersonal styles and techniques to gain acceptance of your ideas or plans, and modifying your own behavior to accommodate the tasks, situations, and individuals involved. Negotiation— Effectively exploring alternatives and positions to reach outcomes that gain the support and acceptance of all parties. Sales Ability/Persuasiveness— Using appropriate interpersonal styles and communication methods to gain acceptance of a product, service, or idea from prospects and customers. Building Strategic Working Relationships— Developing and using collaborative relationships to facilitate the accomplishment of sales goals. Six items describing various skills and behaviors associated with each of these scales were then developed and reviewed by the sales managers. The Sales Skills Assessment–Self and Other that follow are the result. The Sales Skills Assessment–Self may be used by itself or in combination with the Sales Skills Assessment–Other. In either case, it’s important that the results from the assessment be used for development purposes only. Using the assessments for evaluative purposes is likely to compromise the validity of the results, as respondents may be less likely to provide honest feedback. Specific instructions for completing the Self version of the assessment are located with the inventory along with a scoring form, scoring interpretation information, and an action planning exercise. The Sales Skills Assessment–Other is intended for use by sales managers, other sales reps who have first-hand knowledge of a particular sales rep’s approach to working with customers, and a sales rep’s customers. Two critical components in gaining the cooperation of
1:14 P.M.
Page 69
McClay
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:14 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
70
respondents to complete the Sales Skills Assessment–Other are (1) to ensure their anonymity and (2) to make sure that they understand the results are going to be used for developmental purposes only. Two techniques for ensuring respondent anonymity are to be sure to collect Other assessments from at least three respondents and to average the scale scores instead of providing the individual respondent scores. A useful technique for ensuring that respondents understand that the assessment results are going to be used for developmental purposes only is to have the target sales rep contact the people being asked to complete the Other version of the assessment and explain to them how the results will be used and what insights the rep hopes to gain from their feedback. Generally, if people know that their individual responses will remain confidential and that the results are being used for developmental purposes only, gaining their cooperation to complete the Sales Skills Assessment–Other and provide honest feedback is not difficult. This is just as true for customers as it is for others within your own organization who possess first-hand knowledge of a particular sales rep’s approach to working with customers. To increase the likelihood that the feedback results are accepted by a sales rep, it is recommended that each rep be given the opportunity to select those people from whom to solicit feedback. Your sales reps themselves are in the best position to identify respondents who know them well enough to provide accurate feedback regarding their approach to working with customers. Allowing the sales rep to make the selections also increases the perceived validity of the feedback results. However, if you are concerned that a sales rep may try to ‘‘stack the deck’’ toward respondents who will only provide favorable feedback, you can have the rep either: (1) select half the respondents and you select the other half or (2) submit a list of names from which you will select a smaller group to receive the Sales Skills Assessment–Other.
Tips for Use It is not recommended that the assessments be used with inexperienced sales reps. Greatest insights occur after a sales rep has developed his or
Page 70
McClay
D e v e l o p S a l e s Re p s U s i n g S t r u c t u r e d Fe e d b a c k
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
71
her own approach to working with customers (a minimum of six months of calling on accounts by him- or herself). The assessments also are best used on some type of ongoing basis (every twelve to eighteen months) as a way to help sales reps identify any ‘‘bad habits’’ they may have fallen into and to help them create specific development plans for improving their approach to working with customers. The benefit to sales managers for using the assessments is that it takes their feedback out of the realm of ‘‘personal opinion’’ and objectifies it, especially if sales reps are given a hand in selecting the respondents to provide feedback, as described earlier. Moreover, increasing the perceived objectivity of the feedback is also likely to increase its acceptance as an accurate portrayal of a sales rep’s past job behavior or performance.
References Harvard University Competency Dictionary, http://www.hks.harvard .edu/HR/staff/Harvard%20Competency%20Dictionary%20Final %20PDF.pdf Ilgen, D. R., Fischer, C. D., & Taylor, M. S. (1979). Consequences of Individual Feedback on Behavior in Organizations. Journal of Applied Psychology, 90, 349– 371.
1:14 P.M.
Page 71
McClay
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:14 P.M.
A Sales Skills Assessment–Self
Note
Developed by Kenneth R. Phillips, Please keep in mind that the results from Founder and President, Phillips this inventory will be helpful to you only Associates, Grayslake, Illinois to the extent that they are an accurate reflection of your actual approach to working with customers. Therefore, it is to your benefit to respond as candidly as possible. Instructions • The inventory consists of forty-two statements which describe a sales rep’s approach to working with his or her customers.
Page 72
McClay
D e v e l o p S a l e s Re p s U s i n g S t r u c t u r e d Fe e d b a c k
• Carefully read the first statement. Keeping in mind your own approach to working with customers, indicate how often you engage in the behavior along a continuum from Never to Always. • Place an X in the circle that corresponds to your choice for each statement. Place an X in only one circle per statement. You must make a choice for all forty-two statements in order for the assessment to be scored accurately. • Make your choices based on how you actually behave, not on how you think you should behave.
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
73
1:14 P.M.
Page 73
McClay
74
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:14 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
Never 1. I keep my promises and commitments, and respond promptly and willingly to customer requests. 2. During sales calls, I listen carefully and periodically repeat back to the customer what he or she has said to test for and confirm my understanding. 3. During sales calls, I actively seek information to gain an understanding of the customer’s stated and unstated business needs, problems, and expectations. 4. When bringing up discussion topics during sales calls, I position them from the customer’s point of view to show that there is value in discussing them. 5. During sales calls, when needed, I negotiate schedules and deliverables with customers. 6. When presenting product or service solutions to a customer, I do so in a manner that clearly shows how the solution would meet a need or solve a problem. 7. I proactively build effective work relationships with my customers by identifying their needs and expectations, clarifying how and when they want to be contacted, and who should be included in our communication. 8. I willingly and appropriately share my thoughts, feelings, and rationale with customers so that they understand my position.
Always
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
Page 74
McClay
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
D e v e l o p S a l e s Re p s U s i n g S t r u c t u r e d Fe e d b a c k
75
Never 9. During sales calls, I pause during the conversation to encourage and allow the customer to speak. 10. When working with a customer to solve a problem or meet a need, I follow up to make sure the customer’s needs and expectations are met. 11. During sales meetings, I establish good interpersonal relationships by helping everyone feel valued, appreciated, and included in the discussion. 12. When negotiating with customers during sales calls, I seek a win-win solution that recognizes both the customer’s and my needs. 13. When presenting product or service solutions to a customer, I use an approach that positions the product or service as a viable solution and prevents or minimizes customer resistance. 14. When working on customer projects, I place a higher priority on the project goals than on my own personal goals. 15. During sales calls, I use the customer’s name periodically during the course of our discussion. 16. During sales calls, I periodically summarize what the customer and I are talking about in order to consolidate what has been discussed and move the conversation forward.
Always
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1:14 P.M.
Page 75
McClay
76
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:14 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
Never 17. My sales approach is characterized as one of being more interested in fully understanding the customer’s needs and problems than in presenting information about my company’s products and services. 18. During sales meetings, I explain how I arrived at conclusions I’ve reached so that others understand the decision and support it. 19. When negotiating with customers during sales calls, I engage in mutual problem solving by exploring alternative positions or approaches and evaluating them openly. 20. During sales calls, I get a complete picture of who all the buying influencers are in the customer’s organization and their personal buying motives (economic, technical, user, etc.). 21. When working on customer projects, I try to build a network of strategic relationships within the customer’s organization. 22. In addition to helping customers solve a particular problem, I am also sensitive to their personal situations and try to understand their needs and concerns. 23. When meeting with customers, I use appropriate non-verbal communication (eye contact, gestures, posture, voice tone, etc.) throughout the discussion.
Always
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
Page 76
McClay
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
D e v e l o p S a l e s Re p s U s i n g S t r u c t u r e d Fe e d b a c k
77
Never 24. When engaging customers in a discussion of their needs and problems, I encourage them to do most of the talking by asking questions that are concise and to the point. 25. As customers move toward making a buying decision, I help them think through the criteria and priorities they consider to be the most important. 26. When negotiating with customers during sales calls, I identify the customer’s and my initial position, build common ground by highlighting areas of agreement, and then concentrate on resolving areas of disagreement. 27. During sales calls, I use compelling arguments and techniques to move customers to action or to an agreement. 28. When working on customer projects, I support and encourage a good working relationship between me, the customer, and my company. 29. When discussing solutions to meet a customer need or solve a problem, I accurately and appropriately communicate the strengths and limitations of each solution. 30. When discussing complex ideas or solutions during sales calls, I explain them at a level appropriate to the audience and use terminology to ensure understanding.
Always
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1:14 P.M.
Page 77
McClay
78
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:14 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
Never 31. When critical decisions need to be made on a customer project, I try to get all the key decision makers together from the customer’s organization to provide input and gain their buy-in. 32. When recommending a product or service solution to address a customer need or problem, I also provide the customer with evidence of the product or service’s effectiveness. 33. When negotiating with customers during sales calls, I also pay attention to the interpersonal process by keeping the discussion focused on the task and constructively addressing emotions and conflict. 34. During sales calls, I adapt my sales approach to match the personal and stylistic preferences of the customer. 35. When discussing project issues during customer meetings, I look for opportunities to expand on previously discussed ideas and seek new ideas from the customer. 36. During sales calls, I actively listen to what the customer is saying and objectively consider his or her ideas and opinions, even when they conflict with my own. 37. During sales calls, I keep the customer engaged and involved through the use of techniques such as analogies, illustrations, stories, humor, and an appealing style.
Always
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
Page 78
McClay
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
D e v e l o p S a l e s Re p s U s i n g S t r u c t u r e d Fe e d b a c k
79
Never 38. When working with customers, I look for opportunities to educate them by sharing information and building their understanding of the issues and my company’s capabilities. 39. If a customer is resistant to an approach or solution I’ve recommended, I first try to understand the resistance from the customer’s perspective and then, with customer input, try to find a way to overcome it. 40. During negotiations with customers, I try to build value for preferred alternatives by relating them to the customer’s needs and pointing out problems with undesirable alternatives. 41. When presenting product or service solutions to a customer, I look for opportunities to present multiple options for the customer to consider. 42. When working on customer projects, I regularly assess the strength of the partnership that exists between me and the customer and our ability to attain mutual goals.
Always
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1:14 P.M.
Page 79
McClay
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:14 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
80
Your Skill Scores Instructions marked a ‘‘3.’’ In this case, you • Listed below are the seven dimensions identified as critical would enter a 3 in the box to working effectively with labeled ‘‘1’’ below. customers. Numbers to the • Total the numerical values on right represent statements from each dimension to obtain your the assessment. Refer back to skill effectiveness scores. statement number one and in • After finding your skill the box labeled ‘‘1’’ below, effectiveness scores on each enter the numerical value of the dimension, total your scores to response you chose for that determine your Overall statement. For example, let’s say Effectiveness. that for statement one you Dimensions
1
8
+
Building Trust 2
9
3
5
12
6
13
+
Sales Ability/Persuasiveness
19
7
20
+ 14
+
21
+
=_________ 40
+ 34
+ 28
+
39
33
27
=_________
+
+
+
38
32
26
=_________
+
+
+
37
31
25
=_________
+
+
+
+
30
24
18
36
+
+
+
+
+
23
17
11
29
+
+
+
+
Negotiation
16
10
4 Gaining Commitment
22
+
+
+
Customer Focus
15
+
+
Communication
Building Strategic Working Relationships
Skill Effectiveness
Statements
=_________ 41
+ 35
+
Add the skill effectiveness scores for each dimension to get your Overall Effectiveness score.
=_________ 42
+
=_________ _________
Page 80
McClay
D e v e l o p S a l e s Re p s U s i n g S t r u c t u r e d Fe e d b a c k
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
81
What Your Scores Mean The Sales Skills Assessment–Self is designed to assess your use of the skills and behaviors that are essential to working effectively with customers. Your overall effectiveness score will give you a general picture of how well you use these skills and behaviors. This score will range between 210 (most effective) and 42 (least effective). Your skill effectiveness scores will indicate how well you use the specific skills and behaviors associated with each of the seven dimensions. Each of these scores will range between 30 (most effective) and 6 (least effective). The Effectiveness Score Ranges chart below will help you interpret more accurately your overall and skill effectiveness scores. The chart categorizes all effectiveness scores into the ranges of ‘‘Strength,’’ ‘‘Competent,’’ and ‘‘Development Need.’’ Locate your scores on the chart and circle the range of numbers within which each of your
scores fall. The Overall Effectiveness column of the chart will help you better interpret your overall effectiveness scores. The Skill Effectiveness columns of the chart are designed to help you gain a more accurate picture of your strengths and development needs on each of the seven dimensions critical to working effectively with customers. Take a moment to notice whether your scores fall above or below competent. If you have scores that fall into the ‘‘Strength’’ category either overall or on any of the seven dimensions, congratulations! These scores show that you use the skills and behaviors in these areas significantly more effectively than average. On the other hand, if you have scores in either the ‘‘Competent’’ or ‘‘Development Need’’ categories, these identify areas where there is room for improvement, with scores in the ‘‘Development Need’’ category having the highest priority.
1:14 P.M.
Page 81
Need
6–16
17–24
Competent
Development
25–30
Strength
Trust
Building
6–16
17–24
25–30
6–16
17–24
25–30
Sales Ability/
6–16
17–24
25–30
6–16
17–24
25–30
6–16
17–24
25–30
6–16
17–24
25–30
42–108
109–175
176–210
Effectiveness
Strategic Working Overall
Building Commitment Negotiation Persuasiveness Relationships
Customer Gaining Communication Focus
Effectiveness Score Ranges
McClay
82 c04.tex V3 - 12/09/2009 1:14 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
Page 82
McClay
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:14 P.M.
B Sales Skills Assessment–Other
Instructions
Developed by Kenneth R. Phillips, • The inventory consists of forty-two Founder and President, Phillips Associates, Grayslake, Illinois statements which describe a sales rep’s approach to working with his or her customers. • Carefully read the first statement. Consider the approach to working with customers used by the sales rep you’re providing feedback for, and indicate how often this person engages in the behavior along a continuum from Never to Always.
Page 83
McClay
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:14 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
84
• Place an X in the circle that corresponds to your choice for each statement. Place an X in only one circle per statement. You must make a choice for all forty-two statements in order for the assessment to be scored accurately. • Make your choices based on how this sales rep actually behaves, not on how you think he or she should behave.
Page 84
McClay
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
D e v e l o p S a l e s Re p s U s i n g S t r u c t u r e d Fe e d b a c k
85
Never 1. This sales rep keeps promises and commitments, and responds promptly and willingly to customer requests. 2. During sales calls, this sales rep listens carefully and periodically repeats back to the customer what he or she has said to test for and confirm his or her understanding. 3. During sales calls, this sales rep actively seeks information to gain an understanding of the customer’s stated and unstated business needs, problems, and expectations. 4. When bringing up discussion topics during sales calls, this sales rep positions them from the customer’s point of view to show that there is value in discussing them. 5. During sales calls, when needed, this sales rep negotiates schedules and deliverables with customers. 6. When presenting product or service solutions to a customer, this sales rep does so in a manner that clearly shows how the solution would meet a need or solve a problem. 7. This sales rep proactively builds effective work relationships with his or her customers by identifying their needs and expectations, clarifying how and when they want to be contacted, and who should be included in their communication.
Always
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1:14 P.M.
Page 85
McClay
86
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:14 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
Never 8. This sales rep willingly and appropriately shares thoughts, feelings, and rationale with customers so that they understand his or her position. 9. During sales calls, this sales rep pauses during the conversation to encourage and allow the customer to speak. 10. When working with a customer to solve a problem or meet a need, this sales rep follows up to make sure the customer’s needs and expectations are met. 11. During sales meetings, this sales rep establishes good interpersonal relationships by helping everyone feel valued, appreciated, and included in the discussion. 12. When negotiating with customers during sales calls, this sales rep seeks a winwin solution that recognizes both the customer’s and his or her needs. 13. When presenting product or service solutions to a customer, this sales rep uses an approach that positions the product or service as a viable solution and prevents or minimizes customer resistance. 14. When working on customer projects, this sales rep places a higher priority on the project goals than on his or her own personal goals. 15. During sales calls, this sales rep uses the customer’s name periodically during the course of the discussion.
Always
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
Page 86
McClay
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
D e v e l o p S a l e s Re p s U s i n g S t r u c t u r e d Fe e d b a c k
87
Never 16. During sales calls, this sales rep periodically summarizes what the customer and he or she are talking about in order to consolidate what has been discussed and move the conversation forward. 17. This sales rep’s sales approach is characterized as one of being more interested in fully understanding the customer’s needs and problems than in presenting his or her company’s products and services. 18. During sales meetings, this sales rep explains how he or she arrived at conclusions they’ve reached so that others understand the decision and support it. 19. When negotiating with customers during sales calls, this sales rep engages in mutual problem solving by exploring alternative positions or approaches and evaluating them openly. 20. During sales calls, this sales rep gets a complete picture of who all the buying influencers are in the customer’s organization and their personal buying motives (economic, technical, user, etc.). 21. When working on customer projects, this sales rep tries to build a network of strategic relationships within the customer’s organization. 22. In addition to helping customers solve a particular problem, this sales rep is also sensitive to their personal situations and tries to understand their needs and concerns.
Always
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1:14 P.M.
Page 87
McClay
88
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:14 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
Never 23. When meeting with customers, this sales rep uses appropriate non-verbal communication (eye contact, gestures, posture, voice tone, etc.) throughout the discussion. 24. When engaging customers in a discussion of their needs and problems, this sales rep encourages them to do most of the talking by asking questions that are concise and to the point. 25. As customers move toward making a buying decision, this sales rep helps them think through the criteria and priorities they consider to be the most important. 26. When negotiating with customers during sales calls, this sales rep identifies the customer’s and his or her initial position, builds common ground by highlighting areas of agreement, and then concentrates on resolving areas of disagreement. 27. During sales calls, this sales rep uses compelling arguments and techniques to move customers to action or to an agreement. 28. When working on customer projects, this sales rep supports and encourages a good working relationship between him- or herself, the customer, and his or her company. 29. When discussing solutions to meet a customer need or solve a problem, this sales rep accurately and appropriately communicates the strengths and limitations of each solution.
Always
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
Page 88
McClay
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
D e v e l o p S a l e s Re p s U s i n g S t r u c t u r e d Fe e d b a c k
89
Never 30. When discussing complex ideas or solutions during sales calls, this sales rep explains them at a level appropriate to the audience and uses terminology to ensure understanding. 31. When critical decisions need to be made on a customer project, this sales rep tries to get all the key decision makers together from the customer’s organization to provide input and gain their buy-in. 32. When recommending a product or service solution to address a customer need or problem, this sales rep also provides the customer with evidence of the product or service’s effectiveness. 33. When negotiating with customers during sales calls, this sales rep also pays attention to the interpersonal process by keeping the discussion focused on the task and constructively addressing emotions and conflict. 34. During sales calls, this sales rep adapts his or her sales approach to match the personal and stylistic preferences of the customer. 35. When discussing project issues during customer meetings, this sales rep looks for opportunities to expand on previously discussed ideas and seek new ideas from the customer. 36. During sales calls, this sales rep actively listens to what the customer is saying and
Always
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1:14 P.M.
Page 89
McClay
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:14 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
90
Never
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.
objectively considers the customer’s ideas and opinions, even when they conflict with his or her own. During sales calls, this sales rep keeps the customer engaged and involved through the use of techniques such as analogies, illustrations, stories, humor, and an appealing style. When working with customers, this sales rep looks for opportunities to educate them by sharing information and building their understanding of the issues and his or her company’s capabilities. If a customer is resistant to an approach or solution this sales rep recommended, this sales rep first tries to understand the resistance from the customer’s perspective and then, with customer input, tries to find a way to overcome it. During negotiations with customers, this sales rep tries to build value for preferred alternatives by relating them to the customer’s needs and pointing out problems with undesirable alternatives. When presenting product or service solutions to a customer, this sales rep looks for opportunities to present multiple options for the customer to consider. When working on customer projects, this sales rep regularly assesses the strength of the partnership that exists between himor herself and the customer and their ability to attain mutual goals.
Always
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
1
2
3
4
5
Page 90
McClay
c04.tex
D e v e l o p S a l e s Re p s U s i n g S t r u c t u r e d Fe e d b a c k
V3 - 12/09/2009
91
Your Skill Scores Instructions marked a ‘‘3.’’ In this case, you • Listed below are the seven dimensions identified as critical would enter a 3 in the box to working effectively with labeled ‘‘1’’ below. customers. Numbers to the • Total the numerical values on right represent statements from each dimension to obtain the the assessment. Refer back to skill effectiveness scores. statement number one and in • After finding the skill the box labeled ‘‘1’’ below, effectiveness scores on each enter the numerical value of the dimension, total the scores to response you chose for that determine your Overall statement. For example, let’s say Effectiveness. that for statement one you Dimensions
1
8
+
Building Trust 2
9
3
5
+
6
13
+
Sales Ability/Persuasiveness 7
20
+ 14
+
=_________ 39
+
+
=_________ 40
+ 34
+ 28
+
38
33
27
21
+
+
+
=_________
+ 32
26
+
37
31
25
=_________
+
+
+
+
30
24
19
36
+
+
+ 18
12
+
Negotiation
23
17
11
29
+
+
+
+
Gaining Commitment
16
10
4
22
+
+
+
Customer Focus
15
+
+
Communication
Building Strategic Working Relationships
Skill Effectiveness
Statements
=_________ 41
+ 35
+
Add the skill effectiveness scores for each dimension to get your Overall Effectiveness score.
=_________ 42
+
=_________ _________
1:14 P.M.
Page 91
McClay
c04.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:14 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
92
Instructions
Action Planning
• Refer back to your Sales 1. What are your overall reactions to your Skills Assessment–Self scores? Effectiveness Score Ranges chart. • Note your highest and lowest scores. • Think about your role as 2. Which results please you most? a sales rep in working with customers and answer the following questions. 3. How would you like to see your scores improved?
4. What steps can you take to improve your scores?
5. What obstacles might keep you from taking the steps listed above and how can you overcome them?
Page 92
McClay
c05.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
5 So Many Choices Determining the Right Solution Michael Rockelmann
A
T SOME POINT we all have performance issues and need to determine the appropriate solutions. You may be running short
of your quarterly or annual sales targets; you may have a new CRM or other software or a new product or product enhancements; you have a perceived skill gap, a new sales model you want to introduce; or your people are just not performing to your expectations. Too many times, team leaders rush to implement a training solution based on a gut feeling, only to miss the results they were hoping to gain. Training is the easy answer and you check the box that you did something. But was it the right thing? Or did you just throw money at the problem? No matter what your level in the organization—supervisor, manager, director, or vice president—implementing the wrong solution can cost you time and money, and harm your reputation. Too many times, the 93
1:19 P.M.
Page 93
McClay
c05.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:19 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
94
solution implemented is training, when in reality the problem cannot be solved with training, or a long training session is built when a simple, short solution was required. No matter what the issue you are facing, following a tried-and-true approach to analyzing the problem will always put you in a better position to determine the correct solution. This chapter will provide you with a basic process to help analyze your problem and determine the appropriate solution, training or otherwise. I cannot guarantee that you will always arrive at the best solution, but by following the process and answering a set of questions, you are more likely to have success. Be aware that, once you have determined the problem and decided on the best solution, the process does not stop there. If you want to truly be successful and set yourself apart from other sales leaders, you need to stay involved, conduct further analysis, and make additional decisions to ensure you implement the solution correctly. If you determine that training is the right solution, there are a series of questions that will help you successfully create and implement the appropriate training. Part of this process is determining whether you have the internal capability to create the best training solution or whether you should outsource to a vendor. Whatever you choose, following this process will also ensure that what is built meets your criteria and positively impacts your business goals.
Model Overview We will use a basic set of questions to help you determine the real issue and define the right solution to implement. The basic questions fall into three categories, which will be defined in more detail in this chapter. • The Needs Analysis • Outsourcing Decision • Implementing the Best Solution This model is a framework to help you make decisions and ensure alignment to your original business goals. The first set of questions
Page 94
McClay
c05.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
So Many Choices
95
helps you determine your needs and isolate the real issue; the second set helps you ensure the right resources are working on the solution; and the last set ensures that you are implementing the best solution. By answering the questions in this order, you should have alignment and a successful solution.
The Needs Analysis What Is the Business Impact or Goal I Am Looking For? There are three main questions you can answer here. Two are not optional, and one is necessary if you need to request funds for the project. 1. What Business Results or Outcomes Do You Need or Expect? This is
the most important question to answer. Every project should lead to a business result—an increase in sales, a rise in customer satisfaction, and so on. Face it, if you were not expecting good results, you would not be taking on this initiative. If you can’t define the business results you expect, then you should ask yourself why you are putting the time and resources into this. Although improved product knowledge or increased sales skills can lead to business results, they are not themselves business results. Be sure to identify why you are undertaking this initiative. Typically, these are some results you might expect: ‘‘To meet our sales goals or $XXX in revenue,’’ ‘‘To increase sales X percent,’’ ‘‘To reach X percent market share.’’ In the case of a new CRM, it may simply be not to negatively impact your sales. Say, for instance, that your sales are slipping and you are 10 percent behind forecast. You need a 15 percent increase on expected sales for the remainder of the year to reach your goal. 2. (If Necessary) What Is Your Expected Return on Investment? What
monetary return are you expecting from the business result? If you are expecting a 10 percent increase in sales, what is the increase in revenue? If you are expecting to rise a point in customer satisfaction ratings, what monetary value will this lead to? This question is difficult and not often
1:19 P.M.
Page 95
McClay
96
c05.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:19 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
answered. It is hard to isolate the training as the factor for sales increases. Use this type of information cautiously and only present if it is expected or required to receive the funds. For the example above, you are looking for a 15 percent increase in sales over the remainder of the year. This will give you an exact number to reach. As it is hard to say that one solution alone will solve the problem, be realistic and say this program is expected to help the end result by X percent. 3. What Do Your People Need to Do Differently on the Job to Realize the Business Goal? This is the first step to isolate the real issue. Once you
have identified your expected business results, you can identify what your salespeople need to do to achieve those results. If you know that you want to increase sales, but don’t know how, you may have to conduct a survey of salespeople or look for an outside vendor to help. To answer this question, you review current performance against desired performance. This is where an internal assessment of what salespeople are currently doing that is not leading to your expected results comes in. Are they not closing deals? Not positioning products well? Unable to use the systems correctly? At this point you may need to ask customers for input. You can check on salespeople through surveys, interviews, or focus groups; with the use of job observation; or from formal assessments. Once the required skills and knowledge have been identified, you can perform an analysis against what you expect to determine what training should be provided. Information on the desired state of performance can come from many different sources. It may be based on a competency model, or it may be derived from your salespeople. Even in a project as simple as creating job aids, there should be defined business results and an expected performance. From the results of your research you can identify the skills or knowledge needed to achieve the results you want.
Page 96
McClay
So Many Choices
c05.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
97
Can You Do This Alone? You must honestly ask yourself whether you can define the performance gap alone. Many leaders feel they ‘‘know’’ their people and what they need. At times this is true, but more often this is where things tend to go off track. Be aware of your limitations and, if possible, involve others at this point. Even pulling together a few people to discuss the problem can have a positive impact. I was once approached by a senior sales director of one of our most profitable regions. He was known within the company as one of the best leaders and was always on top of the needs of his people. He insisted on delivering a one-day team-building and motivation training program for his salespeople. He insisted that their sales numbers were falling because they weren’t motivated to sell anymore and needed to be reenergized. He knew they could sell and had great skills, but did not understand why their numbers were falling. After some discussion, I received his permission to hold a focus group with a few of his people. In that meeting, I discovered that motivation was not the issue. They still wanted to remain a topselling unit, but they were having problems understanding some of the new products and features and how to position them to customers. While they could sell the old products and knew all of the benefits, they felt that if they knew more about the new products, specifically how to position their benefits, they could sell more. We ended up delivering a one-day course with specific job aids that helped the salespeople understand the new products and features and how to correctly position the benefits. In no time the region was back on top.
Sometimes even a senior manager who typically understands the needs of his people can be mistaken. Involving salespeople in the project can lead to the right solution and can have other positive effects. Having the target audience provide input up-front and contribute to the design
1:19 P.M.
Page 97
McClay
c05.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:19 P.M.
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
98
of a training program can also mean greater buy-in. The audience can also give advice to avoid pitfalls and offer real-life scenarios for the program. Having salespeople on the project team means that you will have ‘‘champions’’ who can deliver your message and build internal commitment to the training program. For our example, we will use the scenario I presented above. Through a series of interviews and focus groups with sales managers and salespeople, you determine that they are getting in front of customers and submitting bids, but they are not closing deals. You expect 50 percent of all bids to lead to closed deals, but you are currently experiencing 40 percent. You have identified your performance gap as the inability of the salespeople to bring a bid to a successful sale. 4. What Is Causing the Gap Between What They Need to Do and What They Are Doing? What Is the Right Solution? At this point you have
identified the business outcome you expect and compared it with what they are doing now. This gives us a performance gap. The next question you need to ask is ‘‘Why are they not performing as we want them to?’’ This is where you make your decision about whether training is the best solution. It is easy to jump into a training solution, but this may not be the right answer. For example, if you say, ‘‘I’ll give you $100 right now if you can do this’’—and they CAN do it—it isn’t a training problem. Have you ever thought, ‘‘We have a problem, so we need a workshop’’? Or read an article or book and said, ‘‘I want that for my people’’? It is easy to fall into offering ‘‘flavor of the month’’ training programs. You must not take the easy way out, but continue to search for the right answer. According to Tom Gilbert’s Behavior Engineering Model (BEM), performance issues can be categorized into the following six groups: • • • •
Consequences, incentives, or rewards Data, information, and feedback Environmental support, resources, and tools Individual capacity
Page 98
McClay
So Many Choices
c05.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
99
• Motives and expectations • Skills and knowledge Of the six categories, the only one that can be resolved by training is lack of skills and knowledge. The others may require different changes. If your salespeople have the skills and knowledge to perform as expected, then something else is the problem. If you want to be successful, take the time to find out what is really causing the performance gap. Consequences, Incentives, or Rewards. Do your salespeople have the correct
incentives or rewards to achieve the performance you want? Are there consequences to them not performing? Often sales incentives are based on volume and not on profit; if your goal is to increase profit, or your performance gap identified salespeople not closing profitable deals, then you may want to change your incentives. Do not overlook consequences. Human behavior drives all of us to complete work in ways that result in the least negative consequences. Make sure the incentives to perform are greater than the consequences of not performing. It is very typical to raise goals or give extra work to high performers; this can be seen by them as a negative consequence of success. Problems in this area can typically be solved by changing incentives or pay structure. If you do not have the right incentives, work with your HR or compensation expert to determine what is needed to drive the results you want. Data, Information, and Feedback. Often people have the skills and knowledge
to perform, but they do not have the data, information, or feedback they need. Ensure your salespeople have the customer and product data they require to complete their jobs successfully. Have they been given feedback that they are not meeting expectations? Salespeople need to receive feedback on their performance. People want to be successful, and may not even realize they are not meeting expectations. Problems in this area can typically be solved by providing the essential data salespeople need to perform their jobs and the correct
1:19 P.M.
Page 99
McClay c05.tex
100
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:19 P.M. Page 100
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
data and feedback on their performance. Job aids, manager feedback, and coaching can resolve issues. If manager feedback is required, ensure the managers understand exactly what performance is required and are coaching to the right skills. Environmental Support, Resources, and Tools. Do salespeople have the
support, resources, and tools to be successful? Has a cut in the sales support function hurt their ability to complete their tasks? Is the territory or customer base too large for one person? Do they have a CRM to help them? Do they have tools that provide essential product information to make a sale? Answers to these types of questions will help you determine whether you have issues in this area. Often people have the skills and knowledge, but their environment does not support them to be successful. Frequently, providing support systems, job aids, and sales tools, or even an organizational or job realignment, can resolve issues in these areas. Individual Capacity. Is each person capable of successfully completing his or
her job? This is typically one of the hardest questions to answer, as some issues of individual capacity cannot be solved with training. We have all known someone who just cannot perform the expected job. No matter how much training the person receives, the job is not the correct fit for his or her abilities. At times we need to make the tough decision that a hiring mistake was made or a job promotion has put someone in a position in which he or she cannot be successful. If one or two people are struggling, then it could be individual capacity. However, if your entire sales organization is not performing as expected, it is probably an organizational issue. It is important to work with your human resources representative if you feel you have an issue with individual capacity. Motives and Expectations. Do your salespeople understand what is expected
of them, and are they motivated to complete the work? These are tough questions that require a hard look at how the team is being led. Leadership is key in solving any performance issues in this area.
McClay c05.tex
So Many Choices
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:19 P.M. Page 101
101
Many leaders feel that, if they communicate sales goals and have a good incentive program, people will perform. Human behavior does not just peak in the presence of incentives. People need to feel part of an organization and they want to follow a strong leader. Employees want to have a good understanding of organizational goals and how they fit into the bigger picture. Much research on what motivates people is available. We must motivate people and communicate their value to them. We must also communicate expectations. We must be clear, not only about sales goals, but about how we expect people to meet those goals. Performance issues in this area can be solved only by focusing on leadership and communication. Are you unwittingly part of the problem? Take a realistic look at yourself and the other leaders of the sales force. We all want to feel we are good leaders and have communicated well, but have you really communicated your expectations? Saying ‘‘I expect you to reach $X’’ is not enough. You must also communicate ‘‘This is what I am looking for because . . . .’’ Knowing ‘‘why’’ can have a greater impact. Look at your entire leadership team. Do the managers know what they are looking for? Have they clearly communicated that to the team? Have you communicated it to them? Skills and Knowledge. Do people have the correct skills and knowledge to
perform their jobs? Can they follow the sales process? Do they understand the product, its features, and benefits so that they can properly position it to meet customers’ needs? Do they know how to use the tools required to complete their jobs? Problems in this area, if present, can be solved with training. The bottom line: If the problem is with skills and knowledge, some type of training intervention is required, but it is not quite that easy. You still must determine the correct solution. Often performance issues do not fit neatly into one category. You will need to address each issue in order to be successful. Adjusting incentives, providing tools and resources, and setting clear expectations may also be required.
McClay c05.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:19 P.M. Page 102
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
102
The rest of this chapter will focus on moving forward with a training program once you have determined that lack of skills or knowledge is the issue. You should not forget about the other performance categories, however. Going back to our example, let’s say that you have determined that the reason people are not moving bids to closed deals is a lack of knowledge of the benefits of new enhancements to the product. Your salespeople can sell and everything else is in place, but they need to better position the product.
Outsourcing Decisions 5. Do You Have the Internal Resources to Build a Program, or Should You Outsource? After completing your needs analysis, the next step is to
conduct an internal assessment of resources to determine whether you should look inside or outside for trainers or use a combination of both. This decision is usually based on factors, including, but not limited to, time, resources, money, expertise, and audience acceptance. If you decide to buy outside, more questions must be answered: • • • •
What do we need to outsource? What supplier should we use? Should we use off-the-shelf or customized training? Should we use internal or external trainers?
Even if you decide to build a program internally, there are still many questions to answer: • • • •
Who are the content experts? Do I have a selling model? How will I design the course? Who is the best internal trainer for the job?
You can outsource any or all of the four basic areas of a training program—needs analysis, identification of the content, course design, or delivery. If you could not answer the first four questions in the process outlined in the sections above to determine what the real need is, you
McClay c05.tex
So Many Choices
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:19 P.M. Page 103
103
should consider outsourcing the needs analysis, but if you made it this far and feel confident in your assessment, then you can look at potentially outsourcing the course design and delivery. When you consider the content of the course, think about who the experts are. If product information is required, your internal resources may be able to provide the training. If the course comes from a vendor, then why re-create something that exists? If you need to use a packaged program, then consider what outside vendors offer and compare that to how you expect salespeople to use the system. (Straight-out-of-the-box training may differ from what you need, which could result in more performance issues.) If you have the internal expertise, the next decision is to determine who should build the training. Not everyone can put together effective training. You may have an internal training department that can help with the design of a course, but you may want to consider outsourcing the design of this particular course. Many vendors can provide design expertise and work with your internal experts. You have put a lot of time into defining your need; do not throw out that work by implementing an ineffective solution.
Implementing the Best Solution Most people stop at this point and hand off the course to the training department or a vendor. In my experience with leaders in Sales and across organizations, the leaders who stay involved end up with more successful solutions. This is especially true with outsourcing. People believe consultants have all the answers, but leaders who are involved can ensure that a vendor delivers a great product. You do not have to answer the remaining questions yourself, but your involvement in the process will add to the success of the solution and to your personal success. Your support can be integral for the acceptance of the program by your team. As I said before, people want to follow a great leader; being the visible ‘‘owner’’ of a project can help with its implementation and adoption.
McClay c05.tex
104
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:19 P.M. Page 104
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
6. What Knowledge or Skills Do People Need to Perform Differently? After
you have completed your analysis of the performance issue and decided who can build and implement the solution, the next step is to define what your people need to learn. Define the objectives of the course, and identify the knowledge or skills participants should leave the course with. You have determined what people are doing now, what you want them to be doing in the future, and what they need to accomplish this. Alignment to the business goal is key: • In order to reach our sales goal, our salespeople need to better position products. • In order to better position products, our salespeople must know the key features and benefits of the products and how to position these to our customers. Once you have identified your objectives, you need to decide how to deliver the information. This is another decision point for you. You may determine that a formal training program is not needed. It may be as simple as a communication, a presentation by a manager in a meeting, or some type of job aid if information is needed. For our example above, in order to fully understand the key features and benefits of a product and to position them for customers, we need a short class to ensure understanding, and we need a job aid for them to use in sales meetings to ensure this is done well. 7. What Are the Needs of the Audience, and How Will Those Be Met?
Defining the needs of the participants and how they prefer to learn is often overlooked. Finding answers to these questions helps you decide what you want the training experience to be like for participants. You may have decided that the knowledge can be transferred by a manager in a sales meeting. Or you could have decided that a class is needed. Either way, you must know the atmosphere that would be most effective for the training. For example, an eight-hour lecture would not be appropriate for a sales group that is used to communicating and being active.
McClay c05.tex
So Many Choices
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:19 P.M. Page 105
105
Here you assess the audience, which helps define what you want people to feel when they leave training. The information you gain will also help you to design the course or aid you in finding an appropriate vendor. Many people skip this step or do not give it enough thought. The content, material, and experience of the training are all critical. We have all been to training programs in which the content is important and will help us on the job, but the delivery is less than exciting. We sit and listen to the best of our ability, but just cannot seem to be engaged. We may also have been to training programs in which it was an exciting and motivational experience, but in the end we are not sure what we should have taken away and applied on the job. A basic requirement for all training is that it be interactive and fun. Salespeople, even more than other learners, do not like to sit and listen for extended periods. They like to try what they are learning and apply it immediately. They are often competitive, so working in some games or activities that include competition can engage them as learners. 8. How Will the Skills and Knowledge Be Taught to Ensure That Participants Learn? In the last section you decided what the feel of the course would
be; now you are looking at how the content will be taught to ensure learning and to meet the needs of the audience. You don’t have to be a training expert to realize what is needed to ensure learning. Think back to classes you have taken. For an effective course, why was it effective? What did you do that helped you learn? For an ineffective course, why was it ineffective? Why didn’t you learn? There are a few basic elements of effective training. As a leader, you can ensure the course will be effective. You can positively influence the outcome. Here are some simple rules to follow: • Keep people engaged. Start by letting them know why it is important and continue engaging them with interesting activities and reallife applications. • Tie back to their jobs. Always relate the training to how they will apply it on the job.
McClay c05.tex
106
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:19 P.M. Page 106
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
• Make time to apply the knowledge and skills and receive feedback. This will help ensure participants learn and remember the correct skills. • Training should be fun, interactive, and with varied activities. Don’t simply do the same things over and over. 9. What Assistance Will Be Provided Back on the Job to Help People Perform Differently? This may be the most important question to ask.
Learning does not end in the classroom, but all too often, it does not continue to the workplace. Even the best training program can lead to no results. To make any program successful, ensure that people have what is needed to transfer the skills back to the job. By building these into your program, you can better ensure transfer to the job and see the change in performance you are expecting. Thinking back to Gilbert’s Behavioral Engineering Model, some of these elements can impact transfer back to the job. Be sure to look at each of them when implementing your solution. • Consequences, incentives, or rewards. If I have taught new skills, are people rewarded for using those new skills? Don’t overlook the negative consequences. Will changing their behavior actually cause their jobs to be more difficult? • Data, information, and feedback. Ensure that your salespeople will have the data, information, and feedback to know whether they are now performing as you expect. This may involve teaching your managers the new process or expectations and how to provide the necessary feedback. • Environmental support, resources, and tools. Does the environment support the use of the new skills and knowledge? Do employees have the resources and tools to perform differently? You can provide them with job aids during the training to help application on the job. • Individual capacity. At times you have to face the reality that some people will not be able to make the change. Be honest
McClay c05.tex
So Many Choices
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:19 P.M. Page 107
107
with yourself and your team and look at the possibility that some people do not have the capacity to perform as you expect. • Motives and expectations. Ensure your salespeople know what performance you expect from them and why they attended training. Show them the big picture and be honest about why a change is needed. Again, most people want to have outstanding performance, so let them know how you define it.
Summary This chapter contains a lot of information, and the process may appear to be overwhelming. The basic point is to remember to complete your due diligence in defining performance issues before deciding on a solution. It is also important to answer the questions to ensure you have implemented a solution that is aligned with your business goals. The process we outlined contained three areas and eight or nine questions to answer. Here it is in outline form. The Needs Analysis 1. What Business Results or Outcomes Do You Need or Expect? 2. What Is Your Expected Return on Investment (If Necessary)? 3. What Do Your People Need to Do Differently on the Job to Realize the Business Goal? 4. What Is Causing the Gap Between What They Need to Do and What They Are Doing? What Is the Right Solution? Outsourcing Decision 5. Do You Have the Internal Resources to Build a Program, or Should You Outsource? Implementing the Best Solution 6. What Knowledge or Skills Do People Need to Perform Differently?
McClay c05.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:19 P.M. Page 108
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
108
7. What Are the Needs of the Audience, and How Will Those Be Met? 8. How Will the Skills and Knowledge Be Taught to Ensure That Participants Learn? 9. What Assistance Will Be Provided Back on the Job to Help People Perform Differently to Reach Your Goal? The most important takeaways from this chapter are • Have a good understanding of the process, including the types of answers you require for each question. • Put time and energy into a needs analysis to ensure you understand the problem. Be honest with yourself about what you do and do not know about the problem. Do not try to make all the decisions yourself. Include others if possible. • Make sure you have the right internal or external resources working on the project. Don’t be afraid to outsource if necessary. • Do not stop the process at implementation. If you want to be successful and set yourself apart as a leader, stay involved, ensure you implement the best solution, and be the champion of the program. • Don’t fall into the trap of believing that consultants have all the answers. Be involved in defining what skills and knowledge must be taught, how the needs of the audience will be met, and how the training will teach the content. • Most important, define what is needed to ensure people perform as you expect back on the job. By following this process and staying engaged to answer all of these questions, you can ensure the increased performance of your team. Questions for Reflection • Have you implemented a training solution in the past that did not achieve the expected results? What might have helped you achieve the results you were looking for?
McClay c05.tex
So Many Choices
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:19 P.M. Page 109
109
• Are you currently facing a performance problem? What will be your next steps in finding a solution?
Bibliography Gilbert, T. F. (1996). Human Competence: Engineering Worthy Performance. Amherst, MA: HRD Press/ISPI.
McClay c05.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:19 P.M. Page 110
McClay c06.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:20 P.M. Page 111
6 Capabilities The Engine That Drives Success Maria Edelson
I
NDIVIDUALS AND LEADERS invest countless hours on devel-
oping a vision and a mission, setting goals, making choices, determining business tactics, and devising financial measures to support business plans. But how much time is spent determining whether your organization is able to actually do what you are planning to do? In other words, does your organization have the knowledge, skills, and overall capability to deliver the business results? Successful organizations understand the critical link between the strategic business plan and the capability development program for the organization. In today’s economic environment, everyone needs to understand and obtain the skills needed to deliver business results.
111
McClay c06.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:20 P.M. Page 112
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
112
WHAT IS A C APABILITY D E V E LOP M E N T P R O G R A M ? Simply stated, it is a program designed to ensure that an organization has the skills and knowledge to deliver what is promised in the business plan.
A well-thought-out capability development program integrated into the fabric of the enterprise’s business plan enables strategic choices as the engine that drives an organization to surpass expectations. It is an investment in the business that pays dividends over and over again. This chapter outlines a practical process for building a capability development program for your organization. Developing models for the competencies your organization needs and assessments to help figure out where skill gaps exist are covered elsewhere in this book. The author of this chapter assumes that you either have a competency model and have done an assessment, or that you have a plan to accomplish this. So with that information in hand, you need to decide what the goals and objectives of your capability development program should be. What does the organization need to know and to be able to do today and in the next three to five years? Where do you want to be as an organization? In other words, you need a destination.
What’s Your Destination? Determining the Goals and Objectives of Your Capability Development Plan Where do you begin to devise the goals and objectives for your capability development plan? There are many ways to find answers to this question. You could: 1. Do a gap analysis. Using the assessment data, identify the lowest scoring skills. These represent the biggest gaps and obviously should be given a priority, right?
McClay c06.tex
Capabilities
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:20 P.M. Page 113
113
2. Survey senior managers to determine what they think the development goals or skills for the organization should be. 3. Identify industry trends or ‘‘hot topics’’ and focus on one of these as a goal—hoping that you identify the right trend at the right time. While each of these approaches may provide some good information, how can you be sure that these will address the needs of your business? I submit to you that every successful capability development program’s goal and objective should be exactly the same, regardless of the industry or business. The goal and objective should be to ensure that the organization has the knowledge and skills to deliver the business goals. The operative words in that sentence are NOT knowledge and skills. The operative words in that sentence are deliver the business goals. Capability development plans must START by asking the question, ‘‘What are the enterprise’s goals and what strategies are they employing to deliver the goals?’’ After starting with the business goals, work backward to identify what skills and knowledge the organization must have. You may quickly find out that a skill gap doesn’t matter because perhaps that skill isn’t critical to deliver the business goal. Maybe it is more important to take a skill that the organization is quite good at, a strength, and drive it to excellence to achieve business goals. The key is to be able to identify which skills and what knowledge are critical to deliver the desired success. This is no easy task, in part because you need to plan both for today and for tomorrow. You need a process to deconstruct the goal and thereby determine leadership’s strategic choices. Remember, strategies are nothing more than resource allocation choices. So what choices has leadership made for resource allocation? A thorough analysis of the strategic choices will uncover what company leadership thinks is important and directionally where they are headed. Once you have a sense of the strategies and resource allocation, your job is to make sure the organization has the skills and knowledge to do the work that leadership deems important in both the short and longer term. This can be real ‘‘heavy lifting’’ because you need to assess which
McClay c06.tex
114
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:20 P.M. Page 114
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
skills are crucial to successfully deploy the strategies that will deliver the goal in the short term while still planning for longer-term goals. Are the needed skills well developed, or are they skills that the organization has never developed because they haven’t been crucial in the past? Let me give you a sales example. In the CPG industry in the late 1980s and early 1990s, most sales organizations were asked by the enterprise to deliver top-line volume as measured by cases sold. The environment was simple: high frequency, transactional sales calls. The skills required were simple (by today’s standards): to create a presentation focused on benefits, not features, and to be able to overcome objections and close the sale. Suddenly, team selling became a phenomenon. In addition to traditional salespeople, other people in the organization started to ‘‘sell’’ the customer—like finance or logistics managers. The plethora of data available and the need to transform the data into information and knowledge also changed the game for traditional salespeople. And finally, the shift in the balance of power from manufacturer to retailer created the need for salespeople to invest the effort to better understand customer needs. Internally, companies were now expecting more from their salespeople than just cases sold. Company goals for their sales organizations expanded to be profitable cases, and they wanted to be able to measure the return on their investment. Since sales goals changed, so did sales strategies (resource allocations). There was a new focus on ‘‘category management’’ and creating deeper customer understanding. Resources were being allocated to market research and category management analysis. There were also new measures and tracking systems installed to measure profit and ROI. Bottom line, CPG salespeople needed a whole lot of new skills. Really progressive CPG companies recognized that these new goals and strategies required new skills. Many companies revised their competency models to add skills like ‘‘financial acumen,’’ ‘‘data analysis,’’ and ‘‘understanding customer needs’’ to their competency models.
McClay c06.tex
Capabilities
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:20 P.M. Page 115
115
Business and technology have been evolving quickly ever since. Most successful sales learning and development programs now start with the enterprise’s goal and strategies for the sales organization and then identify the skills needed to deliver on these goals and strategies. Following this process of beginning with enterprise goals and working backward will inevitably lead you to three to five skills from your competency model that should be the focus of your capability development program. These are the skills that will ensure the organization can deliver the short- and long-term goals of the enterprise.
Developing the Capability Development Plan So now you have the process for identifying the capability development plan goal and the key skills and knowledge your organization needs to deliver its business goals. The next step is to develop a comprehensive plan—a roadmap—to take your organization from where you are today to where you need to be tomorrow and three to five years from now. The best capability development plans I’ve experienced include the following three key components: • Transparency: This means that everyone across the organization is familiar with the plan and knows how it works. Ideally, everyone is also crystal clear on his or her role in the deployment of the plan. • Holistic Approach: The plan is a continuing, ongoing effort with follow-up steps built in. It includes adequate preparation and pre-work, ‘‘in-person’’ sessions, and then on-the-job follow-up. • Line Leader Involvement: Line leaders and management are actively engaged in the deployment of the plan. When the line leaders are involved in training their organization, they are typically more personally invested in the outcome. Employees see this dedication and are more likely to buy in as well. Now let’s take a closer look at each of these three elements, including examples.
McClay c06.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:20 P.M. Page 116
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
116
Transparency It is critical that everyone in the organization knows the plan and understands what it means to him or her personally. When employees understand how the plan can benefit them, by making them more effective or building their capacity to improve their work/life balance, they will be willing and active partners with you to bring the plan to life. Tips 1. Make sure that a good communication or marketing plan is not the final stage in building a development plan. It might be the final step to be executed, but it certainly shouldn’t be the last step to be thought about. It must be included throughout the process so that it is comprehensive. 2. Specifically document your capability plan choices and ‘‘brand’’ them. One example is to refer to the choices in your plan as a ‘‘go to market’’ strategy and broadly communicate it. 3. The best marketing plans are multi-faceted and include the opportunity to deliver the message several times. This is especially the case with a new plan. The average recipient needs to hear a message seven times before he or she begins to adopt it. 4. It’s also powerful to use different delivery methods. For example, use email for a quick first introduction. Follow up with a hard-copy mailing. When possible, use videoconferencing or inperson meetings to communicate the importance of this new capability plan. Of course, the most powerful delivery is direct messaging from the line leader. Use this approach whenever possible.
Holistic Approach When developing your plan, be sure to leverage adult learning principles. Figure 6-1 is a model that depicts a simple but effective three-pronged approach to building competency.
McClay c06.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
Capabilities
1:20 P.M. Page 117
117
Figure 6-1. Three-Pronged Approach to Building Competency
Go to Market Strategy Three-Pronged Approach to Building Competency 1 Transfer Knowledge eLearning Informative Engaging Interactive Interesting
2 In-Person Practice
3 On-the-Job Application Expectations Demonstration Feedback Critiques Practice
Transfer Knowledge. First things first, there is usually a knowledge transfer
requirement before we can engage in skills training. One of the most effective and efficient ways to transfer knowledge is online training. Technology has become a tremendous enabler of training—when used properly and appropriately. However, if web-based training is not feasible, there are always hard copy or preparation exercises to enable knowledge transfer. In-Person Practice. Second is the acknowledgement that skill training is really
all about PRACTICE. If someone has read about how to swing a golf club or, better yet, watched a video on how to swing a golf club, do you think he can successfully play golf? Probably not. The person needs to practice his swing, take a few lessons with a golf pro, and go to the driving range before he can expect to have a successful game. Similarly, after acquiring the knowledge, we need in-person training time to practice with someone who can give coaching and constructive feedback. A common mistake many training programs make is to use inperson sessions to transfer knowledge instead of practicing skills. The
McClay c06.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:20 P.M. Page 118
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
118
participants spend their valuable ‘‘together time’’ sitting in a semi-dark room listening to the presenter drone on, reading one PowerPoint slide after another. Once the learners have the necessary knowledge, they can come to the in-person session ready to practice what they learned. The most effective in-person sessions use adult learning principles—highly interactive and therefore very engaging sessions in which individuals learn by doing and benefit from experienced coaching and balanced feedback. Examples of using these principles go from using simple role plays all the way to building custom simulations. There are a lot of possibilities in between, including learning maps, games, table exercises, ‘‘off-the-shelf’’ simulations, and interactive scenario competitions. All of these techniques give learners the opportunity to practice their skills and receive valuable and balanced feedback from a coach or trainer. On-the-Job Application. If the new knowledge and skills are not applied
on the job—the sooner the better—the previous work is for nothing. Follow-up is critical! There are many ways to check on the job application of skills; for example, contact by the immediate manager in the field, weekly follow-up conference calls with peers or trainers, webinar followups, or on-the-job follow-ups with trainers. The most effective follow-up is in the field, where someone can observe the skill in use and provide in-the-moment coaching, suggestions, and direction. However, if this isn’t possible another alternative that reinforces the training is a benefit.
Line Leader Involvement How do you build in line leader involvement? Often this is a sticking point in an organization. Training is delegated to trainers or to HR. I’ve often heard the excuse that line leaders are too busy or have more important work to do. But the fact remains that line leaders often have the most impact and get the best results because they have the experience to share as they build the capability of their organizations. No one is better positioned to teach salespeople how to be more effective than their immediate managers who usually have more experience
McClay c06.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
Capabilities
1:20 P.M. Page 119
119
calling on bigger and tougher customers using the skills at a much higher level of proficiency and sophistication. The ideal scenario is to have line leader involvement as frequently as possible throughout the capability development process. There is a role for the line leader throughout the process. Figure 6-2 captures the possibilities for line leader involvement.
Figure 6-2. A Market Strategy for Line Leader Involvement
Go to Market Strategy Line Leader Involvement Pre-Program Preparation Expectation Review Interact Engage Involve
Trainer/Moderator
Post-Program Follow-Up Expectations Demonstration Feedback Critiques Practice
So far we’ve discussed the linkage between business goals and success through the development of a capability development model and the resulting components of the plan to impart the skills needed to deliver the business results desired. We’ve also covered the importance of directly involving the line leaders in this process. From my experience, it’s imperative to keep leaders engaged at each step of the way. Pre-Program Preparation. Ideally, the line leader sets expectations for the
training. Is this part of the individual’s personal capability plan, or will this training build proficiency to deliver a specific strategy? Is this building a strength or shoring up a weakness? The line leader needs to be sure the individual knows WHY he or she is attending training, WHAT he or she must get out of the training, and HOW it can be applied to the daily work. Best-in-class programs send out line leader and participant prework about three weeks before the training. This information clearly
McClay c06.tex
120
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:20 P.M. Page 120
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
communicates the role the leader should take and what the participants should expect to discuss about the event with their line leaders prior to the event. Trainer/Moderator. The very best in-person training events are led by line
leaders, not professional trainers. They serve as the moderators, deliver the keynotes, run the workshops, are the buyers in the simulations and role plays, and provide the balanced feedback and coaching. The bottom line: they are the role models the participants look up to and want to emulate. Tip: There are many arguments to make a case for using professional trainers: consistent delivery, no prep time or out-of-office time for line leaders, and so on. Often, however, the professional trainers haven’t done the job of the participants or don’t have experience in the business. Line leaders are generally much more experienced, have sophisticated skills, and are usually more successful than the participants. Plus, when the line leader speaks, everyone listens, so there is a higher adoption rate coming from the line leader. An example: Having account executives run a university session for account managers is powerful. The account execs have done the work of account managers and can often share stories that relate how-to techniques based on real-life job experiences. This is what participants remember when they return to their jobs! Post-Program Follow-Up. In the perfect world, the line leaders own the
follow-up from in-person training sessions. They are responsible for checking in with the participants to determine whether the training met the participants’ expectations. They should discuss how the participants will put their new knowledge and skills to use on the job and how they will change their behavior as a result of this training. Best-in-class programs send out follow-up reminders to line leaders about three weeks after the session. These remind them to contact their direct reports to (1) see whether the session met their original expectations, (2) discuss immediate on-the-job application, and (3) set
McClay c06.tex
Capabilities
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:20 P.M. Page 121
121
up a session for the line leader to observe the new behaviors/skills and provide coaching. This should come as no surprise to the participants, as this is coordinated with their follow-up. Ideally, the follow-up should continue as long as the relationship between the line leader and participants exists. Ongoing On-the-job training is a cornerstone of classic sales training. Tip: On-the-job sessions are critical. If line leaders can’t find the time to moderate a training program, work to build a culture in which line leaders train with their direct reports on the job. The rewards are more than worth the effort and the time.
Summary I am absolutely confident that any organization, large or small, can build and execute a capability development program. And more importantly, I have seen the results. Organizations with well-designed and wellexecuted capability development programs can win in both the short term and long term by meeting and often exceeding their enterprises’ business goals. Building a successful capability development program begins with understanding the business goals, objectives, and strategies for an organization. Once these are understood, it’s time to work on developing a goal (destination) for your capability development program. Once the goal is determined, create a capability develop plan (roadmap) with ways for your organization to build the capabilities needed to deliver the organizational goals. Successful capability development plans have three key elements: transparency, a holistic approach, and engaged line leaders. This process works regardless of whether you are at a Fortune 100 company or a small-cap company. To ensure your success, I recommend that you do three things: 1. Align a key, influential business leader. Identify the one or two influential leaders in the organization who are innovative and
McClay c06.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:20 P.M. Page 122
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
122
agile. Share the vision and ‘‘what could be.’’ Directly ask for their support for a pilot or test. 2. Enroll others in your vision. Don’t just depend on an influential leader; start a ground swell of support. Engage and excite your peers and those in the organization who would benefit from this and encourage them to volunteer to be part of a test. 3. Pilot and test. Be sure to quantify the potential benefits as you set up a pilot or test so the results are achievable and measurable. Questions for Reflection • Does your organization have a capability development model or plan? If so, is it linked to the business goals? • Does your sales force have the skills and knowledge necessary to achieve the business plan? Do they have the skills they will need five years from now? • What has sales management identified as the top training needs of the organization? • What is the cost to train on these topics? • What is the cost to NOT train on these topics?
McClay c07.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 123
7 Making Training Stick Get Them to Use It Susan Onaitis
T
HE MANTRA OF every professional sales trainer I know is
‘‘Training is not a one-time event.’’ Training is a process that requires accurate assessment, careful instructional design, effective implementation, and continuous follow-up. Even the earliest pioneers in the field of education knew that repetition and reinforcement were required for long-term retention. Most learners don’t get it the first time they hear new information or learn new skills. Reinforcement, follow-up, and coaching are required for training to have the impact you want. This is true for both formal and informal training. In this chapter we will examine ways to make sure your training sticks and that your learners put what they learn into action. It’s not just about what you do in the classroom, on the job, or during the online course, but also what happens before and after the training. 123
McClay c07.tex
124
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 124
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
Of course, sales managers play a pivotal role in the effectiveness of an organization’s training process. In Chapter 10, Rick Wills takes an in-depth look at how managers impact the application of learning on the job. In this chapter we will focus on steps that can be taken before, during, and after training to reinforce the learning. We will also share some ideas for ways you can integrate learning into your organization’s culture at any time. But let’s start by looking at why reinforcement is so crucial to the success of training.
Why Is Reinforcement Necessary? Remember the old joke that poses the question: ‘‘How do you get to Carnegie Hall?’’ The answer is practice, practice, practice. We’ve all heard it a hundred times. Practice makes perfect. Yet many executives continue to operate under the misconception that if their people have been trained, they should know it and use it. Unfortunately, that’s not how the real world works. And it is not how the human mind works. Today scientists have studied the human brain like no other generation before did. They have linked the chemical and genetic makeup of the human body to memory, both long- and short-term. Memory plays an important role in our ability to retain and recall information. It is the ability to retain and recall learning that allows the salesperson to access the skills or information he or she needs to deal with particular client situations in a more effective way. In order for a salesperson to retain what he or she has learned in a classroom or online, he or she must see a purpose for that information. The training must be relevant to participants. We’ll talk more about that when we get to the things you can do during training to make sure it sticks. Salespeople also need to be able to interpret and apply the information. And in order to successfully apply what they are learning, they must be able to practice a number of times during the learning experience. Repetition leads to retention.
McClay c07.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
M a k i n g Tr a i n i n g S t i c k
1:21 P.M. Page 125
125
How Much Repetition Is Required to Learn? There is no easy answer to that question, according to Dr. Will Thalheimer, president of Work-Learning Research, Inc., a Massachusettsbased company that studies ways to make learning more effective in the workplace. ‘‘What we do know is that more repetitions are better and that spacing the repetitions over time will result in better retention over the long term,’’ he said in a recent interview. How much time? ‘‘In a ninetyminute e-learning module, repetition of learning points is good every ten minutes or so. Managers are overly optimistic about their people’s ability to remember. Spacing the repetitions helps minimize forgetting,’’ according to Thalheimer, who recommends teaching a bit about topic A, then some about topic B, then a little about topic C, then going back to topic A. The spacing effect was first identified by German psychologist Hermann Ebbinghaus in his 1885 book on the study of memory. His basic finding was that spacing learning over time produces substantial benefits, especially long-term retention of learning (Ebbinghaus, 1885). Dr. Thalheimer recommends that organizations change the definition of a learning event to include the idea that learning takes place over time. It doesn’t just happen in one classroom event or during one online course or one coaching session by the manager. ‘‘All the research indicates that repetition and reinforcement over a period of time are vital to long-term retention of knowledge and skills,’’ says Dr. Thalheimer.
Carrot or Stick: Which Reinforcement Works Best? If you have ever trained a pet using treats or raised a toddler using smiles and kisses, you know the value of positive reinforcement. And if you have ever had to ‘‘ground’’ a teenager or take away cell phone rights for a week, you have undoubtedly seen the effects of negative reinforcement. It’s that old carrot or stick approach that motivates animals and humans
McClay c07.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 126
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
126
toward the results you want. So when it comes to reinforcing learning, which one works best with your salespeople? Aubrey Daniels, behavior analyst and author of Bringing Out the Best in People, says ‘‘Positive reinforcement maximizes performance, while negative reinforcement gets a level of performance that is just enough to get by—just enough to escape or avoid some unpleasant consequence’’ (Daniels, 2000). What does that mean for you before, during, and after a training program if you want to see meaningful results? It means that the learner needs positive recognition when he tries a new behavior and that he needs to know someone is noticing. By the way, simply paying attention can have an impact on your salespeople’s behavior. It is called ‘‘the Hawthorne effect.’’ Back in 1927, professor Elton Mayo studied the relationship between productivity and work conditions at Western Electric Hawthorne Works in Cicero, Illinois. What he discovered is that employees’ behavior may be altered in a positive way just because they know they are being studied. Translated into the workplace it means that noticing someone’s new way of doing a job task may be enough to motivate him or her to improve performance (Mayo, 1933). The message is clear for managers and sales leaders: pay attention to your salespeople and how they put training to work in their jobs. Reinforce them positively by commenting on their use of new skills or knowledge. Your attention and feedback can help maximize their performance. Now let’s look at what can be done before a salesperson takes part in a formal training experience.
Before the Training At the beginning of the chapter, I mentioned that there are many things that you can do to reinforce training, even before a participant steps into the classroom or tunes into an e-learning program. As a sales training professional for more than twenty-five years, I know from my own experience that there is something called ‘‘the teaching moment.’’ It is that time when a learner is completely open to taking in a
McClay c07.tex
M a k i n g Tr a i n i n g S t i c k
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 127
127
new idea, approach, knowledge, insight, tactic, or methodology for what he or she is doing. If a salesperson truly desires to get the most out of a training opportunity, he or she needs to prepare psychologically before setting foot in the classroom or tuning into an e-learning program. They and you can create ‘‘the teaching moment.’’
Program Review One of the first things salespeople can do is review the course description and agenda to decide whether this particular course addresses their needs. The next thing is for them to jot down the specific objectives they would like to accomplish and to be prepared to discuss them in the class. That might mean having a conversation with the trainer to gain more insight into the course curriculum. It might also mean having a conversation with their manager to determine whether he or she is in agreement with their assessment and goals. For example, at the Eastman Kodak Company all managers of trainees are briefed on their roles in the transfer of learning, according to Mary Elliott Bassett, Worldwide Director of Sales and Customer Training. ‘‘We provide the managers with a checklist of the activities the manager needs to complete throughout the process so the trainee has a much higher chance of using the new skills and information on the job,’’ says Bassett. This indicates that managers are always put through a condensed version of the program before their salespeople participate in it.
Value of Pre-Work Another thing salespeople should do to prepare themselves for the teaching moment is to complete any required pre-work such as readings, case studies, interviews with experts, computer research, tests, or prerequisite courses. By doing the pre-work, salespeople are creating a framework for the learning that will take place in the course. They are also becoming familiar with concepts, terms, and skills that might be new to them. In the process of doing pre-work, they can also write down any questions they
McClay c07.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 128
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
128
want answered during the course. Pre-work helps set up ‘‘the teaching moment.’’
During the Training Management Presence One way for management to show commitment to learning and support for the salespeople is for a senior manager to welcome the participants, set expectations, and positively reinforce trainees for their dedication to growing. The welcome speech doesn’t have to be long, but it does have to demonstrate that management is paying attention to the development of salespeople. The sheer presence of a senior manager communicates much more than the words he or she says in the introduction. The senior manager can also allay concerns or anxieties that participants may have about being part of a training class. He or she can emphasize the benefits of the course and create a comfortable, safe environment for learning. It means the ‘‘welcomer’’ has to be familiar with the course concepts and objectives so that he or she lays a foundation for participants to feel excited and committed to the experience of learning.
Eliminate Distractions While BlackBerries and cell phones can be tremendous time-savers, they can also be a huge distraction for salespeople. Turn off all PDA devices and phones before the training begins if you want to get the most learning. While many of us rely on multi-tasking to get our jobs done, it has an upside and a downside. Even though you may think you can focus on more than one task at a time, the truth is that when you are trying to learn new concepts or knowledge and integrate them into your behavior, you need to concentrate fully on learning.
Learning Contracts In the same way, managers who are constantly interrupting trainees or pulling them out of the class ‘‘for just one moment’’ are breaking the learners’ concentration. This behavior communicates that training is
McClay c07.tex
M a k i n g Tr a i n i n g S t i c k
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 129
129
unimportant—not necessarily the best message if you want salespeople to learn and improve their performance. If training is going to stick, participants need to be allowed to give it their full attention and not be sidetracked by other things. Some companies ask managers and salespeople to sign a learning contract before the training that delineates each person’s specific responsibilities and commitments during the training class, such as managers will not interrupt the trainee or pull that person out of the training for any reason. If your budget allows for offsite training, it is easier to alleviate work distractions. But, of course, that isn’t always possible. Learning contracts are typically an effective way of making sure both parties— the manager and the salesperson—make a commitment to the training.
Design of the Training Even if you are not the person responsible for the design of a learning program, you should review the course materials to make sure they include certain elements. When I design a program, I incorporate a variety of action learning activities, skill application practices, case studies, games, and trainee presentations so the participants can practice new skills and knowledge in a variety of fun, interactive, and challenging ways. The activities reflect the trainees’ real-world job situations and are designed to give them many opportunities to repeatedly practice what they are learning in the safety of the classroom. Doing this gives salespeople a comfort level with new skills, and they are more likely to apply the learning immediately. The course should include some kind of materials or workbook in which participants take notes, work on exercises, and compile information that can then become a reference and review tool after they leave the training. Allowing participants to take notes in their own handwriting also encourages retention of the information. Three things that I design into the course workbook are (1) a followup page for any pre-work, (2) a ‘‘light bulbs’’ page, and (3) an action learning plan.
McClay c07.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 130
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
130
Follow-Up on Pre-Work The follow-up page is typically positioned right after the agenda and objectives in the trainee workbook. It may be designed as a pre-test or as a case study requiring small group discussion based on assigned pre-work. The rationale is to help trainees start from a similar level of knowledge and to demonstrate their responsibilities as participants. Learning is not just a matter of showing up and listening. Salespeople need to actively engage and participate from the beginning. Completion of pre-work is part of their commitment to their own learning and should be communicated that way. By the way, every training program should include objectives that are communicated or listed in the course workbook. Check to see that the objectives match what you and your trainees hope to achieve through the training.
Light Bulbs Going On The light bulbs page is typically at the end of the workbook and is devoted to whatever the salesperson wants to jot down and remember—new ways of doing something, things to stop doing, things to incorporate into his or her repertoire. Whatever they want to capture on the page is totally up to them. Periodically during the training, I stop to let them jot down ‘‘any light bulbs that came on for them during the session.’’ As a way to review at the end of the day, I ask each person to share aloud one thing he or she has written on the light bulbs page. Allowing the learners to personally select ideas they feel will be most valuable to them not only reinforces the learning, but also strengthens the salespeople’s commitment to applying what they are learning to the job.
Action Plan The action learning plan is just that—a three-step plan that trainees complete at the end of the training. They choose three things they learned during the program that they commit to applying immediately when they are back on their jobs. They also commit to sharing their
McClay c07.tex
M a k i n g Tr a i n i n g S t i c k
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 131
131
plans with their managers so the managers can coach around those skills. To give the action learning plan even more clout, the management development manager at a multimillion-dollar North American luxury company follows up with each training participant a month after the session to see how the learner’s plan is progressing and what role the manager is playing. It is one more way to strengthen skills and to reinforce the commitment to a learning culture.
A Different Kind of ‘‘Smile Sheet’’ Most trainers utilize an evaluation form at the end of the training course to determine whether participants enjoyed the program and found it valuable. Often the forms are referred to as ‘‘smile sheets’’ because they are more focused on how the participants liked the trainer and not what they found to be of value. Smile sheets are not always a measure of how effective the training was and whether participants will actually use what they learned on the job. However, Dr. Thalheimer has come up with a new take on the old smile sheet. According to him, ‘‘Smile sheets don’t seem to correlate with learning and behavior, are often biased by being provided to learners immediately after learning, and are sometimes analyzed in a manner that over-values the data as more meaningful than it really is.’’ His new design for a smile sheet asks learners to respond to specific learning points covered in the class. This not only enables the learners to better calibrate their responses, but also gives them a spaced repetition of the course concepts—improving later memory retrieval on key learning points. ‘‘The new smile sheet enables me to capture data about the value of the individual key concepts so that changes can be made in future sessions if needed,’’ says Dr. Thalheimer, who encourages trainers to use his format as a template. It is available on his website at www.work-learning.com and also as Exhibit 7.1. He also encourages training professionals to send out a slightly reworded survey two weeks after the course to offer yet another spaced repetition of the key learning concepts.
McClay c07.tex
132
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 132
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
Exhibit 7-1. Your Immediate Impressions of the Learning Experience
McClay c07.tex
M a k i n g Tr a i n i n g S t i c k
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 133
133
Used by permission of Work-Learning Research, Inc.
After the Training With all the cost-effective multimedia options available today, reinforcement of training can take the form of audio products, video, print, and web-based tools.
Audio Reinforcement Tools A very popular and portable audio product is the podcast, a reinforcement segment that can be downloaded onto a CD, computer, Smartphone, or iPod. Doug Fox, corporate sales and product training manager at Ryerson Steel in Chicago, worked with a local supplier, The MarComm Store, to create a radio talk show format to reinforce concepts taught in his telephone selling course. The radio DJ interviewed Fox as if it were a real radio show. This gave Fox the opportunity to highlight the key ideas he wanted the salespeople to remember in an engaging and lively format.
McClay c07.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 134
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
134
Every sales representative who attends the training program receives a CD that can be downloaded onto a computer and then duplicated for other handheld devices so reps can access the information whenever they want to review key concepts. ‘‘One of my reps told me that for about three weeks in a row she would listen to the CD while driving to work on Monday morning to inspire her and get her in the right frame of mind for selling,’’ said Fox. ‘‘She told me she saw a 10 percent increase in her close rate as a result.’’ He also heard from a manager who used the podcast as a coaching and training tool during a lunch presentation. ‘‘It generated a lively discussion on how we need to be more on top of things.’’ MarComm Store will also create a customized weekly or monthly radio show for your salespeople that can include interviews, testimonials, success stories, and announcements that reinforce training concepts.
Peer Mentoring Most of us have heard of traditional mentoring, whereby a seasoned salesperson takes a novice under his or her wing to show him or her the ropes. Peer mentoring is where people of mostly equal experience, but perhaps of different levels of understanding or success, join forces to help them both be more successful. For example, a major technology company recently introduced a new product. It was clear from the training that some of the salespeople ‘‘got it’’ immediately and others were left a bit confused. In their wisdom, management matched up those who got it with those who were struggling and allowed them to work together. The results were so positive that the company set up a formal peer mentoring program for all employees based on objectives defined by each individual. Clearly there is value in pairing salespeople with different skills and setting specific goals so they learn from each other. It is also a creative way to reinforce training.
Contests and Incentives In my last corporate job, one of my first goals as vice president of sales training was to train the sales force in four different and complex product
McClay c07.tex
M a k i n g Tr a i n i n g S t i c k
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 135
135
lines. Once everyone had completed the five-day classroom program, we invited the sales force to participate in a product knowledge competition. I worked with a New York–based company called Professional Motivational Technologies (PMT) to design a series of four monthly quizzes based on the product training. Each quiz had a tiebreaker essay question. Participants were encouraged to go back into their training workbooks to find the answers, reinforcing their product knowledge. Based on answers to the essay questions and the overall numerical scores, we whittled down the number of finalists to ten salespeople. At the national sales meeting, we conducted a Jeopardy-type game show to determine the overall winner, who received $1,000 in cash and a trip for two to Hawaii. Not only was it a fun and engaging incentive, but it also applied the principle of ‘‘spaced learning,’’ which I discussed earlier in the chapter. And salespeople really knew their product information! Today all of PMT’s knowledge reinforcement is done online, making it easy to involve a large sales force that is spread around the globe. Henry Berzinn, PMT president, outlined some of the benefits of this type of knowledge reinforcement. ‘‘Our competitions stimulate mastery and motivation because not only does our customized testing help salespeople grow and learn, but also we loop management right into the process with regular email updates on who is participating and how they are doing.’’ PMT also offers sales data tracking so managers can see how the training is impacting achievement of sales goals. ‘‘If your company depends on third-party sellers, such as dealers or distributors, it is also a great way to get them focused on your brand and motivated to sell it,’’ says Berzinn, who knows first-hand from one of his biggest clients, a major truck manufacturer. ‘‘This well-known company has been using knowledge competitions for years not only to track individual and dealership sales, but also to reward those who do the best job. The incentive combined with constant repetition is what they feel is the formula for their success.’’ The questions for the knowledge challenge come directly from the classroom and e-learning courses provided by the company. Each question is a learning/reinforcement event using real-life situations. When a sales
McClay c07.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 136
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
136
rep takes the challenge, if he or she answers a question incorrectly it is flagged and the person is given the correct answer before he or she can move on to the next question. So sales reps continue learning through the knowledge challenges. John Connors, president of the Center for Corporate and Human Development in Albany, New York, uses the product knowledge challenges as a component of the training he provides to banks. According to Connors, one of the most valuable parts of the process is linking managers/coaches into the results so they know exactly where they need to spend their coaching time with each salesperson and they can customize it to that person’s needs. ‘‘We got 80 to 90 percent compliance from managers on the coaching piece because they felt they had specific areas where they could help their people,’’ says Connors.
Follow-Up Sessions Many trainers include brief follow-up sessions in which salespeople can practice using real-life challenges they have faced since the training course. I offer a three-hour ‘‘skill byte’’ following sales presentation skills courses so that participants can practice a real upcoming customer presentation if they didn’t have one they were working on in the class. I also include a three-hour session for managers on how to coach their people on the skills learned in a class. John Connors makes follow-up a part of each of his courses. ‘‘I will come back a certain number of times every thirty days to coach onsite,’’ says Connors. ‘‘Participants receive an email homework assignment to complete in preparation for the onsite coaching session. The spaced repetition is what helps people retain and use the information they are learning.’’ Another trainer I know offers telephone coaching during which she has the sales team call in to a conference number for a sixty-minute session discussing how to apply the training in specific customer situations that have arisen since the onsite training.
McClay c07.tex
M a k i n g Tr a i n i n g S t i c k
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 137
137
Any Time Reinforcement Sharing Success Stories Another excellent way to reinforce training’s value to the sales force is to share success stories. PMT has incorporated this idea into their work by including an essay question in each knowledge competition. The essay question, which serves as a tiebreaker, revolves around a real success a salesperson has had using the skills and knowledge acquired in training. ‘‘At our truck manufacturer, if your submission is selected to be included in the customized online newsletter we provide to them, you get $50. And the success story is published with your name—a great way to encourage salespeople to use the things they learn in training on the job,’’ says Berzinn, who has worked with companies in a variety of industries. Success stories can also be shared on a company intranet or in any kind of newsletter that goes to the sales force. Demonstrating that the skills learned in training work in the real world is another way to make training stick.
Annual Product Knowledge Qualification Tests Many companies are requiring their salespeople to pass an annual product knowledge qualification test in order to receive a ‘‘meets requirements’’ score on their performance appraisal. Some companies even tie scores into their incentive plans.
Annual Performance Review Many companies have an annual performance appraisal process that includes creating a development plan for the employee. But in order for it to work, companies must put teeth into that plan. At ColgatePalmolive, the development plan often includes a list of courses or learning experiences that an employee must complete during the year as a qualifier for next-level responsibilities. The expectation is set by each manager that an employee’s development is the responsibility of both
McClay c07.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 138
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
138
the manager and the employee. Learning experiences are documented and reflect on decisions for promotion.
Mentoring Programs Formal mentoring programs, spawned by the influx of women and minorities into the workforce during the 1970s, abound in companies around the globe. Pairing more experienced individuals with newer people to help them successfully navigate unfamiliar waters has proven to be important in grooming and retaining rising stars. The major difference between formal and informal programs is that the former set clear expectations, provide mentors with specific guidelines, promote creative learning experiences, and initiate supportive networks within companies that encourage success. Mentors and mentees are taught how to give and receive the most out of the mentoring relationship. Among the expectations is that mentors will reinforce concepts from training courses, giving mentees repetition and application opportunities to cement the learning. Mentors also provide a sounding board when mentees want to try out new concepts in the real world without the risks associated with making a mistake in front of the boss or a customer.
Peer Training An old expression among educators states that ‘‘nobody learns more than the teacher.’’ When you know that you are going to have to teach someone else a concept, you learn it in a very different way than if you simply have to know it for yourself. For this reason, many companies require managers and salespeople to learn how to be trainers, then have them co-train courses with a professional trainer. Knoll, an international office furniture company, has been using peer training for the past four years. According to David Bright, vice president of communications, ‘‘Having our best salespeople do the training not only improves the effectiveness of the whole sales force, but also creates a respect for training at all levels.’’
McClay c07.tex
M a k i n g Tr a i n i n g S t i c k
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 139
139
Chapter Summary Companies invest millions of dollars each year in learning and development. Yet not as many invest in making the training stick, thereby losing much of the value that these efforts could provide. In this chapter, I have provided a myriad of ideas on how to obtain a better return on investment for training through spaced repetition, reinforcement, and engagement of both managers and salespeople in the process of learning. As you can see from this chapter, effective learning and development is a process that begins before a training experience, continues through that experience, and goes on after the program. If you want to make training stick, you will throw out the vision that it is an event and commit to the whole process to get the return on investment you deserve. Questions for Reflection • What are we currently doing before and after the training session to reinforce key learning points? • What are some things we could be doing? • What else should we be looking for in the learning and development programs we use? • What should we be expecting from managers in the development process? • What responsibilities do salespeople have in terms of learning? • What are some ways we can demonstrate our commitment to developing people? • What are some resources we have, but might not be using effectively, to reinforce our training? • How can we get managers more focused on helping their people grow and learn?
References Daniels, Aubrey. (2000). Bringing Out the Best in People. New York: McGraw-Hill.
McClay c07.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:21 P.M. Page 140
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
140
¨ Ebbinghaus, Hermann. (1885). Uber das Ged¨achtnis (‘‘On Memory,’’ later translated to English as Memory: A Contribution to Experimental Psychology in 1913). Mayo, Elton. (1933). Western Electric Company Hawthorne Studies Collection. Cambridge, MA: Baker Library, Harvard Business School. Thalheimer, Will. www.work-learning.com and his blog: www .willatworklearning.com or 617-666-9637. ‘‘New Design for My Smile Sheet’’ (July 9, 2008).
Additional Resources Center for Corporate and Human Development at www.cchdtraining .com or at 518-399-5872. MarComm Store offers customized training and reinforcement tools including audio, video, print, and web-based solutions such as podcasts, CDs, and DVDs at www.MarCommStore.com. Professional Motivational Technologies (PMT) offers customized knowledge reinforcement programs online at www.pmttest.com or 800-382-8685. www.SalesRepRadio.com provides a weekly webcast with the latest sales experts speaking on hot topics of interest to salespeople and sales managers.
McClay c08.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 141
8 Measuring the Impact Did They Use It? Gary Summy
T
RAINING PROFESSIONALS ARE always in search of a
way to identify, measure, report, and receive credit for the ROI of the initiatives we champion. From the first time Donald Kirkpatrick introduced his four levels of training measurement in his book Evaluating Training Programs (1975), through Jack Phillips’ work in Measuring Return on Investment (1994), which took the discussion to five levels with an attempt to clearly define ROI (return on investment), we have been like Arthur’s knights in search of this Holy Grail that will return our Camelot to glory. One of the things we long to change is the perception of training from a cost line item to an organizational investment.
141
McClay c08.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 142
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
142
ROI—The Quest While the quest is admirable, is it attainable? ROI is an extremely useful metric when applied to capital purchases, investment options, and other expenditures. But is it really appropriate for sales training? Can it or should it be applied to learning? I often hear from my colleagues focused on other training-related disciplines that I have it easy because sales training is simple to measure: Did salespeople sell more after training? It would seem to be an easy metric to capture and prove our results. Or is it? Looking at the overall topic of measuring training departments, including sales training, there are two areas that every department leader must address: (1) operational excellence and (2) business impact. Operational excellence refers to our efficiency and the effectiveness of the transactional aspect of training. Historic training metrics apply to the operational aspect of training departments, such as: • Cost per student • Training days or hours delivered • Pre-test and post-test results Business impact is all about our ability to create a positive effect on the metrics that matter to our clients. In other words, did the training actually make a difference to the business? My intent is to focus on evaluating sales training programs in terms of business impact. Business impact is all about our ability to create a positive effect on the metrics that matter to our clients. In other words, did the training actually make a difference to the business?
If we are unable to identify and quantify positive business impact, all of our efforts have a negative impact. The inability to identify, define, and quantify true business impact will always keep sales training (in fact, all training) simply another element of the expense line, and thereby subject to the sword wielded by the cost-cutters. Training without positive impact is seen as a cost to the business. Training with positive business impact can be positioned as an investment.
McClay c08.tex
Measuring the Impact
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 143
143
Many things affect the measurement of training impact, not the least of which is deciding which metrics are most appropriate to use. We know that simply looking at increased revenue (gross sales) is not always the best measurement. For example, gross revenue may increase, but how about net revenue? Selling more at lower margins with a higher cost of sales is probably not the long-term goal of most businesses, and if we measure only that aspect, what have we proven? However, if the corporate objective is market share, it could be a more reasonable measurement to consider. Is the business goal top-line growth only? This implies the business has selected top-line revenue as the market share metric instead of the myriad of other metrics (such as units shipped, units in the pipeline, number of active customers, and a host of others).
Make sure you measure what the business has defined as the critical metric, not simply what is easy to capture.
Before embarking on our quest, there are several things to keep in mind.
Measure the Right Thing We want to be sure that whatever we attempt to measure (and hopefully the focus of our training content) is appropriate to the corporate objectives. Negotiations training with a focus on improving margins, in the middle of a campaign for market share improvement, may not be a good choice of engagements. It is like serving salty peanuts to a person dying of thirst. Under the right conditions peanuts are desirable, but what you are providing not only fails to meet the most urgent needs, it may actually have a negative impact on the current objectives.
Who or What Has an Impact? For the sake of argument, let’s assume we are in alignment and the expected outcome of our offering is designed to address the needs and objectives of the business. We deliver our training, the smile sheets are all
McClay c08.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 144
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
144
top box (they loved the doughnuts), and three months later the business metrics we have targeted show positive improvement. Life is good and we have proven our value. Then marketing steps in and makes the case that it was the amazing new promotion or literature—not the training—that made a difference. In the meantime, finance tells us that the market growth during the measurement period would account for most of the financial gains, and the strategy gurus claim it was their insight on the markets and customers to target. And just when we think everyone has joined the ‘‘grab the credit’’ melee, in comes the competitive intelligence group to confirm two of our major competitors suffered significant shortages of materials in their supply chains and were unable to meet some delivery commitments, so no one can claim credit.
Sort Out the Variables We work in a dynamic and changing marketplace. Competitors, suppliers, market forces, natural disasters, and other phenomena all have some impact on results. Given this, how can training take credit for specific ROI gains? With so many things potentially (and actually) having an effect on the performance of a sales organization’s financially related metrics, it is difficult to claim, much less validate, a true ROI for sales training. I realize there are organizations that claim to measure true ROI for training, and I applaud their effort, but in my experience it is difficult to accurately assign responsibility for the returns. I remember a measurement project some years ago when we indicated we would be providing an ROI number to sales management. They all smiled, applauded our efforts, and wished us luck. Then as we were leaving, they told us they would be interested to see our results, but that no matter what number or ROI we would claim, they would not accept it because there were just too many variables. While we may be dealing with some obvious organizational metrics in sales numbers, we have little, if any, control over all the variables. So how do we sort out the variables and show that it was the training
McClay c08.tex
Measuring the Impact
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 145
145
that made the difference? At this stage in the process, work to determine which variables will affect the metrics. Try to identify how much impact each will have on the metrics and outcome.
Practice What We Preach I am sure that occasionally we each have our difficulties communicating with others. Often the difficulty is more acute when our interaction involves someone on our team, in our company, or with our clients. When that happens to me I am frequently reminded by people close to me: ‘‘You teach this stuff, so why don’t you use it?’’ Too often I have taken shortcuts and not used the active listening skills, feedback tools, and the genuine interest in the other person I know I should employ. I know better, but still I persist. As sales trainers, we also do not always pay attention to the content of what we deliver and fail to practice what we preach.
Obey Cardinal Rules One of the cardinal rules of consultative, solutions, customer-centric selling is to find out the business drivers and key issues of the client. If we are unable to demonstrate how our ‘‘solution’’ will have a positive impact on the priorities of our client, we are at risk that funding will go somewhere else. Should we not do the same when we begin to justify our value to our clients? One of the fundamental problems of ‘‘solutions’’ selling is that, by definition, a solution requires a problem that must be fixed. If we are about impact, our focus should be on improving the business. While solving a problem with a solution should certainly help to improve the business, our first goal should be improving and accelerating the required business results as defined by our client’s strategy and associated metrics.
Identify Metrics Time to use the skills we teach and become a consultant to your internal clients’ business. Identifying metrics internally is the same process we teach our students to use when they engage their clients. Find out
McClay c08.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 146
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
146
what is important to the client, using your knowledge of the company’s goals, objectives, and priorities as your initial roadmap in the search for meaningful metrics. 1. Step 1 in measuring the impact of sales training is to engage the clients and find out what metrics matter to them. • Ask probing questions to determine how they are measuring these key factors now. You might learn they want you to show improvement in an area for which no viable current metrics exist. Frequently, I have found a client wants to show improvement in areas such as call-to-close ratio or cycle time, only to find out they have no current metrics, but they know that whatever it is now, it should be better. How do we show improvement if we don’t know where we are now? • Tip: When no baseline exists, it is impossible to validate positive or negative movement. Never promise impact or attempt to show improvement if there is no starting position. You may move the needle, but how will you know, conclusively, the amount or even the direction of movement? The degree of impact of where you finish depends on where you started. • Do your homework. Without question, we must begin with the client and the client’s priorities. The caveat is that, as with a call on a senior executive, this is not purely a ‘‘discovery’’ call. We should have a good idea of what these critical metrics might include. Here are some examples of potential metrics of value to our clients and where a baseline may exist: • Funnel speed or sales cycle time • Level of relationships (top to bottom) • Breadth of relationships (horizontal across business units and departments) • Call-to-close ratios • Number of ‘‘units’’ shipped or in the pipeline
McClay c08.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
Measuring the Impact
1:24 P.M. Page 147
147
• Mix of ‘‘units’’ shipped or in the pipeline • Product-to-service mix • Revenue generated • Revenue mix across product/service lines • Margin/profit generated • Margin/profit mix across product/service lines • Sales (fiscal or numeric) of targeted product/service lines • Sales mix (fiscal or numeric) of targeted product/service lines • Sales (fiscal or numeric) in targeted markets • Sales mix (fiscal or numeric) in targeted markets • Repeat customers (same mix) • Repeat customers (new products) • New customers • Number of new opportunities added in the pipeline • Size of transactions • Breadth of transactions across products/services/markets • Time to first order or revenue (new representatives) • Time to ‘‘break even’’ (new representatives) • Customer satisfaction (surveys and comments) Remember that the metrics you use in your business case are the same ones you will need to report on after the fact. Be sure you are able to capture the specific information necessary to express results in terms of the business case metrics. Think about how you will impact the organization and use those metrics to sell the idea as well as to report back on the results. 2. Narrow the list of metrics. The list above, along with metrics appropriate to your business environment, should form the
McClay c08.tex
148
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 148
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
foundation of your discussions with your sales leadership. Don’t use the whole list, but pick the top three or four. • They may already be defined in your company’s business plan and objectives. If not, use your general knowledge of your company and its goals to identify those metrics that reflect the priorities of your sales leaders. • Tip: Your list must focus on business and sales metrics, not training metrics. Be sure to focus on what is critical to your client, not to you. • Note: Traditional training metrics (operational) are things like cost per student day/hour, number of people trained, positive smile sheets, or improvement in pre-test/post-test scores (which only measure potential capability, not performance). Certainly some of the cost and efficiency metrics are important to the business and must be managed. However, an outstanding cost per student day or hour with lots of people trained on something that does not create value for the business is no value at all. Your operational excellence may actually deliver negative business impact at a cost that is expendable. 3. You are now in a position to validate whether your understanding of key metrics is the same as if they would set priorities. • If they push back, you have opened a dialogue. You can use your basic ‘‘handling objections’’ skills to understand the disconnects and obtain their list of priorities. Experience tells me that most people will be glad to edit your list (if it truly represents insight) but are less likely to create the list for you.
• Tip: If you start your dialogue by asking what the top three performance issues are that they need to address, this demonstrates a lack of understanding of the priorities of your client
McClay c08.tex
Measuring the Impact
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 149
149
and could significantly affect your level of credibility. Worst case, you may not be invited back and you become a commodity. Best case is for you to engage your client on his or her terms, bring insight and value unique to your perspective of the issues, and begin moving your status to one of a partner. 4. Once we know the key metrics our clients view as critical, we can begin to explore how to measure them and how to link our efforts to positive changes in the metrics. Remember that, while our clients may identify key metrics, they may not have any data on a metric at the moment. If you don’t know where point A is, how will you know whether point B is better or worse (or the same as)? It is worth repeating, be careful not to get caught up in proving positive impact on something not currently defined.
Establish the Link Let’s assume we have clearly defined metrics identified and that sufficient baseline information exists for us to move forward. We need to begin to look at the direct links between: • The content we will deliver; • The skills and behaviors that will be developed; • The results expected (when those skills and behaviors are effectively implemented); and • The value potential of those results. The most effective model I have found to identify that linkage was developed by Robert O. Brinkerhoff, currently professor emeritus at Western Michigan University and a principal consultant for Advantage Performance Group. The model is the Impact Map. Dr. Brinkerhoff has written several books on the subject of the impact of training and how to measure results. I recommend you find the information and application directly from his books or specific training that is available
McClay c08.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 150
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
150
from Advantage Performance Group (www.advantageperformance.com). Several books are listed in the reading list at the end of this chapter. An Impact Map uses a matrix to develop direct line of sight between training content and business goals and objectives. As noted in the example in Table 8-1, we create a direct link between the knowledge and skill content of the training effort and corporate goals. Left to right, we see that the skill is for participants to develop a plan and strategy for the inevitable concessions that are part of any negotiation. One of the critical actions in the process is to know what options are available for you to concede or trade. When the knowledge is applied or the skill performed appropriately, the result is to ensure you receive value in return for giving value. The impact is an improvement in profitability for the negotiation. Finally, if profits go up, so should net revenue.
Table 8-1. Example of an Impact Map Knowledge and/or Skill
Critical Actions
Key Results
Business Corporate Unit Goals Goals
Develop a concession plan and strategy
Develop a list of negotiable options and desired returns for trading
Grow Meet Never give profitability revenue anything targets without receiving value in return
We can validate this by using a right-to-left analysis. We need to grow revenue. One way to do that is to improve our profitability on the deals we close. In order to improve profitability we must ensure we don’t give away value without some commensurate value being realized. In order to get something in return for what I give, I need to understand both what I have to offer and what I want in return. The basis for being able to engage in that action step is the skill of developing a plan and strategy for concessions.
McClay c08.tex
Measuring the Impact
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 151
151
Using the Impact Map model with managers helps them see the direct link between the training initiative and the on-the-job impact they can expect. This is also an excellent tool for managers to use with their direct reports who will participate in the training, ensuring everyone knows what will happen and what is expected.
With the Impact Map model, we create (and validate) the direct link between what we deliver and the metrics we are measuring. If there is no link, are we delivering appropriate training? Without a direct link between the capability (knowledge and/or skill) and performance (actions and results) we are trying to influence, how can we expect to demonstrate what impact we are trying to achieve? A problem in this scenario results from the other variables beyond our control. Negotiation skills and net revenue or value per deal/transaction may improve and sales teams may meet the profitability targets on a deal-by-deal basis; however, if we are engaged in fewer deals or deals of a smaller magnitude, total revenue may not be impacted in the desired direction. We have proven ability to impact individual transactions, but total revenue, even net revenue, may still not achieve overall corporate goals. The issue is not our negotiating ability, but perhaps our selection of opportunities to pursue or the ability to feed the sales funnel to ensure we are expanding the potential revenue opportunities. We do better at what we chase, but we may not be chasing enough to meet the total revenue targets. Therefore, it is essential to obtain agreement and commitment on exactly what you are measuring and attempting to impact up-front and an understanding of what may be out of scope (opportunity selection or funnel management in this example). If this agreement on the targets and metrics is not established in the beginning, we may find we have delivered and measured skill improvement in the areas we targeted, but our value is not seen as significant. However, we may identify skill gaps not previously recognized as an issue, demonstrating the need to analyze the total environment versus isolated perceived deficiencies.
McClay c08.tex
152
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 152
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
On the plus side in this scenario, if we have truly engaged in a total performance improvement discussion with our clients, we are in a position to demonstrate that impacting sales effectiveness is not the result of a single class or intervention but of a total analysis of the sales environment in which our teams must operate. With this type of total sales environment analysis and approach, we can move the discussion away from the classic ‘‘Just send them to training so they can be fixed’’ to looking at performance development and sustainability. Earlier I mentioned the issue of receiving credit for our impact, given all the variables involved in measuring sales performance. Using Impact Maps and the corresponding analysis of success scenarios helps us to clearly identify the factors that influence the results. This is the next step in the process developed by Dr. Brinkerhoff, called the Success Case Method.
Making the Case for Subjective Analysis Which is a more valuable metric, objective data or subjective analysis? Most people believe that ‘‘hard’’ or objective data is the more valuable. While I would not disagree that this type of information can make a compelling story, is it possible that this type of data might be misleading at best? It might even create a false or inaccurate analysis of the true situation. Many things go into ensuring that so-called objective data and metrics actually measure what is intended or that the results truly depict the veracity of the circumstances. When approaching this potential issue related to objective data, I recently did a web search using the phrase ‘‘how to lie with statistics’’ and Google identified over 100,000 results. It is possible to maneuver the statistical response based on what you measure, when you capture the data, how you capture the data, and a variety of other techniques. Take, for example, an end-of-course questionnaire that captures the participants’ evaluation of the value or impact of the course to their on-the-job requirements. These are often used in an attempt to produce ‘‘objective’’ data that shows the course has on-the-job impact. This is not
McClay c08.tex
Measuring the Impact
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 153
153
‘‘objective’’ data, but is a numerical value that is easy to compare and gives the impression of objectivity. I have also seen this type of question used as part of the validation of the elusive ROI calculation, using the results to point to direct links between training program and job impact. However, a program potentially could receive excellent responses immediately after the session, with participants responding that they see a direct link to their ability to perform on the job. Based on the questionnaire, the case is made that the participants recognized the value and potential for impact. Often these surveys are done immediately after the session or within forty-eight hours using web ‘‘push’’ technologies. However, the same survey taken three months later may have a totally different set of results. In this case, the ‘‘objective’’ data may appear to support the fact that the intervention had (or in reality appears to have the potential to have) impact on job performance. Let’s look at it from a personal perspective. Assume you have an opportunity to attend some training that will impact your career skills and opportunities. You do some research and identify a program that, based on the participant surveys using a 5-point scale with 5 being ‘‘most definitely,’’ the average score on the question about whether the program will have a significant impact on your job performance and expanded career opportunities is 4.7. Would you consider attending? Would you spend your own money? The data certainly looks good, and the participants have clearly identified the value of the program. In further research, you discover the questionnaire was administered onsite at the end of the program and was available online for forty-eight hours after the session ended (on a Friday). You learn that one of your most trusted friends from another company attended the session and you call that person to discuss the program. You mention the survey results and would like this trusted friend’s personal opinion. She tells you she rated the program a 5 when she completed the survey. Sounds good so far; you’re probably ready to send the check. But then she tells you that after getting back to her real job she realized that, while there was a lot of good information, the training really didn’t develop actionable
McClay c08.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 154
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
154
skills that transferred to the job, and the training provided no tools to implement the learning or ways to reinforce the content. In retrospect, it was nice stuff to know, but nothing that could be put into practice. Her advice? ‘‘Don’t waste your time or money.’’ What information is more credible and personally valuable to you, the ‘‘objective’’ and numerically expressed survey results, or the opinion of your trusted friend?
While ‘‘objective’’ data is valuable and compelling, it can often be trumped by subjective data based on the source and how it is presented.
Although clients tell you they want objective validation of a program’s value, do they ever use subjective information to make decisions? As you think about the value or weight of subjective versus objective metrics, have you ever been asked to deliver a program based on any of the following reasons from your sales managers? • • • •
Read the consultant’s book; Talked to another colleague that ‘‘swears’’ by the content; Hired a new ‘‘hot shot’’ who ‘‘swears’’ by the program; Listened to a sixty-minute webinar/commercial and it sounded good; • Met with a salesperson from a training company who bypassed you and ‘‘made a compelling case’’; or • Actually believed the information in the brochure or email they received? Subjective information may have more of a role in our decisions or evaluations than we would like to admit. How often do we discuss with sales professionals that customers make decisions based on personal reasons and use objective analysis to validate the subjective choice of suppliers? The same is true for the evaluation of the impact of the solutions we deliver. So how can we bring them together to make a compelling presentation of our value?
McClay c08.tex
Measuring the Impact
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 155
155
Combining Objective and Subjective Analysis Used in conjunction with Impact Maps, a methodology for evaluation I have found useful is the Success Case Method developed by Dr. Brinkerhoff. It uses both an objective survey process and an in-depth interview format to uncover the more subjective analysis of the impact. I will review the basic process and approach, but recommend that you investigate it further. The basic process builds on the Impact Map process, whereby we establish a direct link between the program content and the business objectives and metrics. It’s imperative that the Impact Maps: • Represent the same view your clients have; • Include specific metrics that are of value; and • Acknowledge the other variables in play. This up-front analysis and agreement ensures our measurement process is of value to the client and represents their expectations. It also helps to take the other variables either out of the equation or at least has them on the table where all sides recognize the multitude of factors affecting the outcome. With Impact Maps in place, we build a brief post-session questionnaire designed to identify those participants who have been successful in applying what they learned and those who were not successful (but not necessarily failures). The questionnaire should: • Identify situations of both success and nonsuccess from our post-session survey data; • Be limited to five questions or fewer (other than demographics you may want to capture); • Be phrased to capture specific examples directly related to the critical actions and results defined in the Impact Map; • Include questions related to uncovering who has applied the skills of the program and the level of success related to the desired results as well as places where success has not been achieved and what circumstances existed in both situations; and
McClay c08.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 156
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
156
• Have an open-narrative opportunity to explain or provide an example to determine where the most robust stories exist in both the success and nonsuccess populations.
Identify Each Survey Participant You should say up-front that, because you will be contacting some individuals for further information, it is necessary to capture each participant’s identity. You should be very clear on this. Also confirm that this information will be used only by the evaluation team or department and that no information will be shared with those outside the team. If you find it could be of value to identify a specific respondent, you should do so only with his or her knowledge and consent. Survey participants must feel confident in their ability to provide honest responses without fear of repercussions, especially for the nonsuccess situations. Your own policies and procedures around disclosure should be reviewed and discussed with your appropriate human resources or legal departments before proceeding with the data collection.
Identify Representative Samples Using the results of the survey, the next step is to identify a representative sample group for both success and nonsuccess. These do not need to be large, but enough to obtain good stories. It is vital that you select only individuals who fall at the extreme ends of the distribution—both the highly successful individuals and those indicating no success in the application. Generally, select about twice as many success stories as nonsuccess. As part of the Success Case Method you learn an interviewing process and use that approach to discuss and capture the stories of both success and nonsuccess cases. The idea is to capture robust information that very specifically identifies the elements of the training that were responsible for success and minimize the effect of other variables. Properly prepared and validated Impact Maps are a significant advantage when coming up with questions. Through this process you separate the
McClay c08.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
Measuring the Impact
1:24 P.M. Page 157
157
variables and focus on the impact of the application of the skills on the outcome.
What Was the Impact? What Made the Difference? You are able to report, from credible sources, exactly what impact was realized and, more importantly, what elements of the training program were directly responsible. Show that the application of these elements was the difference between the top performers and both the nonsuccess and mid-range populations. The nonsuccess group should provide a clear understanding and awareness of factors that inhibit success. Use real stories about real accounts and opportunities from credible sources within your own environment. It is a compelling message with built-in credibility. (Check the resources at the end of the chapter to learn more about this process.) Whatever process you use to capture the results from program participants, always ask yourself: ‘‘Have I really measured the impact of our training? Does a training program really create impact?’’ Let me raise the question of what training professionals can truly influence . As Brinkerhoff explained in High Impact Learning and expands on in his new book, Telling Training’s Story, our domain is capability. Performance (that has impact) happens on the job. The best training in the world, not performed on the job, realizes zero impact. In fact, the best training in the world, not performed on the job, actually has a negative impact. Without on-the-job performance, all you have done is spend money and taken people out of the field. You are a cost burden. On-the-job performance and impact are the domain of the manager, coach, or perhaps a mentor, and they happen in the real world, not a classroom, a virtual environment (virtual environments reap virtual results), a role play, or a case study analysis.
Measurement Is a Shared Responsibility In my opinion, training, in isolation, at best has no impact, and without some means of evaluation and transfer of skills to the workplace, it will be perceived as a negative cost impact by many. Training on any
McClay c08.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 158
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
158
topic or via any delivery mode, when done properly and with good instructional design, will ideally develop skills and improve capability. If we have analyzed the current as is and desired to be situations and addressed the appropriate skill gaps to move us to the desired state (assuming our analysis and definition of the to be are valid), training should be the major catalyst in developing the appropriate skill capability in the target population. However, just because they ‘‘can’’ do it does not ensure they ‘‘will’’ do it. Impact is realized through performance, not through capability. As a result, we must become partners with our clients. No matter how good our training might be, without field managers, coaching, reinforcement, and actual application to customer situations, there will be no business impact.
The days of sending salespeople to class to be ‘‘fixed’’ are over, if they ever existed at all. When I work with sales management clients, the discussions focus on the skill gaps and how we will help in developing capabilities to overcome those gaps and on the reinforcement and coaching necessary to realize change on the job. The good news has always been that it is not a particularly difficult sale—managers know this. It is a lot easier to point to the fact that the training didn’t fix the problem. Reality says training alone never will. We have the responsibility to ensure we address the right skills and develop the capability of the target populations to overcome their skill gaps. Managers have the responsibility to turn that capability into performance on the job, where impact really happens. If you work with the sponsoring managers, identify their critical metrics and how they are captured and gain commitment about the roles and responsibilities related to capability and performance, as they become part of the measurement process. Impact and results are validated by management, not just by the training department. With shared responsibility, there is also shared value, shared success, and shared impact.
McClay c08.tex
Measuring the Impact
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 159
159
Resource Robert O. Brinkerhoff, Ed.D. Western Michigan University Advantage Performance Group www.advantageperformance.com
Additional Resources Robert O. Brinkerhoff. Success Case: Find Out Quickly What’s Working and What’s Not. San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler, 2003. Robert O. Brinkerhoff. Telling Training’s Story: Evaluation Made Simple, Credible, and Effective. San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler, 2006. Robert O. Brinkerhoff and Anne M. Apking. High Impact Learning Process: Strategies for Leveraging Business Results from Training. New York: Perseus Publishing, 2001. Donald Kirkpatrick. Evaluating Training Programs: The Four Levels. San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler, 1975. Jack J. Phillips. In Action: Measuring Return on Investment. Alexandria, VA: ASTD, 1994.
McClay c08.tex
V3 - 12/09/2009
1:24 P.M. Page 160
McClay c09.tex
V3 - 11/10/2009
5:18 A.M. Page 161
9 Collaborative Partnership to Maximize L&D Investment Susanne Conrad
Q
UESTION: WHY IS the Sales Learning and Development
(L&D) budget usually near the top of the hit list when budgets are trimmed? Simple answer: Because Sales slashes expenses deemed to have the least impact on the primary objective of making the sales target (and, therefore, earning bonuses) first. At the risk of sounding like a heretic to sales trainers, if L&D cannot provide sufficient value in terms of readying the sales force to deliver against objectives, then its budget should be cut. An equal burden, however, rests on sales management to collaborate with Sales L&D in a manner that actually allows L&D to be effective in contributing to the achievement of Sales’ objectives. In the end, the failure of L&D to provide the value sought by sales management is a shared failure between the two. 161
McClay c09.tex
V3 - 11/10/2009
5:18 A.M. Page 162
F o r t i f y Yo u r S a l e s F o r c e
162
This chapter addresses a collaborative approach that maximizes the learning and development investment to build a sales force that not only delivers on objectives and goals, but can outperform the competition—in other words, a profitable win-win situation!
The Need for Collaboration The purpose of L&D, in the end, is to build the skills and competencies the sales force needs to execute sales strategies effectively and efficiently. And keep in mind that the sales force’s performance success is difficult to tie directly to L&D effectiveness—there are other significant forces in the marketplace that influence sales success. A perfectly trained and developed, effective and efficient sales rep may still lose ground with a