Forest entomology
To: A. H. MacAndrews Who introduced me to the world of forest insects
Forest entomology A global p...
278 downloads
4663 Views
17MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Forest entomology
To: A. H. MacAndrews Who introduced me to the world of forest insects
Forest entomology A global perspective
By William M. Ciesla
This edition first published 2011 Ó 2011 by William M. Ciesla Blackwell Publishing was acquired by John Wiley & Sons in February 2007. Blackwell’s publishing program has been merged with Wiley’s global Scientific, Technical and Medical business to form Wiley-Blackwell. Registered office: John Wiley & Sons Ltd, The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex, PO19 8SQ, UK Editorial offices: 9600 Garsington Road, Oxford, OX4 2DQ, UK The Atrium, Southern Gate, Chichester, West Sussex, PO19 8SQ, UK 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030-5774, USA For details of our global editorial offices, for customer services and for information about how to apply for permission to reuse the copyright material in this book please see our website at www.wiley.com/wiley-blackwell. The right of the author to be identified as the author of this work has been asserted in accordance with the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, except as permitted by the UK Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, without the prior permission of the publisher. Designations used by companies to distinguish their products are often claimed as trademarks. All brand names and product names used in this book are trade names, service marks, trademarks or registered trademarks of their respective owners. The publisher is not associated with any product or vendor mentioned in this book. This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information in regard to the subject matter covered. It is sold on the understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering professional services. If professional advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional should be sought. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Ciesla, William M. Forest entomology : a global perspective / by William M. Ciesla. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-4443-3314-5 (cloth) 1. Forest insects. I. Title. SB761.C537 2011 634.9'67—dc22 2010048037 A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. This book is published in the following electronic formats: ePDF 9781444397871; Wiley Online Library 9781444397895; ePub 9781444397888 Set in 9/11 PhotinaMT by Thomson Digital, Noida, India 1 2011
Contents
Acknowledgements, vii
9. BARK AND AMBROSIA BEETLES, 173
The author, ix
10. LARGE CAMBIUM AND WOOD BORING INSECTS, 203
Preface, xi
11. SUCKING INSECTS, 233
1. THE WORLD’S FORESTS AND THEIR DYNAMICS, 1
12. GALL INSECTS, 253
2. FOREST INSECT DYNAMICS, 15
13. TIP, SHOOT AND REGENERATION INSECTS, 273
3. FOREST INSECT AND HUMAN INTERACTIONS, 31 4. MONITORING FOREST INSECTS, THEIR DAMAGE AND DAMAGE POTENTIAL, 49 5. FOREST INSECT MANAGEMENT, 73
14. INSECTS OF TREE REPRODUCTIVE STRUCTURES, 295 15. INSECTS OF WOOD IN USE, 313 References, 329
6. FOREST INSECT ORDERS AND FAMILIES, 97
Subject and Taxonomic Index, 355 Host index, 371
7. FOLIAGE FEEDING INSECTS – LEPIDOPTERA, 113
Colour plate sections appear between pp. 100–101, 132–133, 180–181, 228–229 and 276–277
8. OTHER FOLIAGE FEEDING INSECTS, 149
COMPANION WEBSITE This book has a companion website: www.wiley.com/go/ciesla/forest with Figures and Tables from the book for downloading
Acknowledgements A half-century of work as a forester, forest entomologist, remote sensing specialist and forest health program manager is reflected in the pages of this text. My chosen profession has provided me with opportunities to work and travel across much of the USA and also Mexico, portions of Central and South America, Europe, Asia and Africa. I have also had the good fortune to meet many outstanding people along the way who became my mentors, colleagues and friends. Aubrey H. MacAndrews, Professor of Forest Entomology at the State University of New York, College of Environmental Science and Forestry at Syracuse University introduced me to the world of forest insects when I was an undergraduate forestry student. As a young forest entomologist, I had the good fortune to work with people like Gene Amman, A.T. Drooz and Hoover Lambert, USDA Forest Service. Robert C. Heller, USDA Forest Service and later, University of Idaho, first introduced me to color aerial photos as a tool to map and assess forest insect damage. Russell K. Smith, USDA Forest Service, provided me the opportunity, guidance and confidence to manage forest health programs in several Forest Service regions and at the national level. In partnership with contemporaries, including J. W. Barry, W. H. Klein, W. B. White, F. P. Weber, J. D. Ward and many others, we evaluated and integrated remote sensing, geographic information systems and the technology of pesticide application into forest health protection programs. Jorge Macias (Mexico), Attilio Disperati, Edson Tadeu Iede, Yeda Oliviera and Augusta Rosot (Brazil), Aida Baldini Urrutia, Osvaldo Ramierez and Patrico Ojeda (Chile), Joseph Mwangi (Kenya), Muhammad Yousuf Khan and Hafeez Buzdar (Pakistan), Zhou Jian Sheng and Wang Gaoping (China), Cernal Akesen and Musa Erkanat (Cyprus), Heinrich Schmutzenhofer and Edwin Donaubauer (Austria), Mihai Barca (Romania) and many other international colleagues introduced me to the cultures and forests of their respective countries.
Rainier P€ ohlmann, Director of Public Affairs, Bavarian National Park, Germany, shared his insights on bark beetles, forest dynamics and people and how they affect management policy of a national park. Many friends and colleagues provided photos of subjects not available from my own archives. These included Ronald F. Billings, Texas Forest Service, S. Sky Stephens, Colorado State Forest Service, E. Richard Hoebecke, Cornell University, Paula Klasmer, Instituto Nacional de Tecnologia Agropecuaria, Argentina, David Cappaert, Michigan, R. Scott Cameron, International Paper Company, Larry Barber, Sheryl Costello, Jerald E. Dewey, Jose Negrón and Brian Howell, USDA Forest Service. Several of the images in this text were accessed via the www.forestryimages.org website of the University of Georgia, which is the work of Extension Entomologist, G. Keith Douce. William Jacobi, Department of Bioagricultural Sciences and Pest Management, Colorado State University, made available samples of damage caused by ambrosia beetles, carpenter ants, termites and wood borers, photos of which are included in this text. The team at Wiley-Blackwell took the title of this work “A Global Perspective” seriously. They arranged for constructive and supportive peer review of the manuscript by Robert G. Foottit, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. Ward Cooper, Senior Commissioning Editor and Delia Sandford, Managing Editor of Wiley-Blackwell, Oxford, UK provided overall leadership to the production and Kelvin Matthews, Production Manager, also in Oxford, arranged for peer review and design of the cover. Maggie Beveridge, currently residing in Lusaka, Zambia, served as copy editor and was instrumental in transforming a still unfinished draft into a polished document, ready for printing. Jessminder Kaur, Production Editor, Wiley-Blackwell, Singapore, supervised the layout and printing. Prakash Naorem, Thomson Digital, Noida, India provided leadership to
viii
Acknowledgements
the typesetting and layout. Therefore, this project was indeed one of “global” proportions, with people representing six countries and four continents working together to make it a reality. Finally, special thanks go to my wife and life partner, Pat Ciesla, who spent many long days with me during field assignments in Brazil, China, Chile,
Cyprus, Kenya, Indonesia, the USA and many other places and provided encouragement and support as I researched and wrote this text. Several of her photos are also included. William M. Ciesla Fort Collins, Colorado, USA
The author William M. Ciesla earned a Bachelor of Science Degree in Forestry from the State University of New York, College of Environmental Science and Forestry at Syracuse University in 1960. He later specialized in forest entomology at the same institution and earned a Master of Science Degree in 1963. He began his professional carrier in Asheville, North Carolina with USDA Forest Service and subsequently held assignments as a forest entomologist and forest health program manager in several locations throughout the USA. From 1990 to 1995 he served as Forest Protection
Officer for the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations in Rome, Italy and in 1995, chartered Forest Health Management International, an international forest health consulting service based in Fort Collins, Colorado. He has worked with forest insects in over 30 countries and is author or co-author of over 160 publications. He is also author of Stranieri: An Italian Odyssey, a light hearted account of life and travels in Italy. In 2005 he received the Western Forest Insect Work Conference - Founder’s Award for outstanding contributions to forest entomology in the West.
Preface Insects are by far the most dominant group of animals on the Earth’s surface. Over a million species have been described and new species are continuously being discovered. They are an integral part of the biodiversity of our planet and presently comprise about 80–85% of the total number of animal species known to science. Some experts estimate that the total number ultimately recognized may eventually approach 30 million species. More than 1000 species can occur in a relatively simple ecosystem such as a back yard and can number many millions per hectare of land surface. In addition to being abundant, insects are extremely diverse and adaptable organisms. They are found in virtually every ecosystem. Insects are classified into about 30 orders. Each order is further subdivided and classified into families, genera and species. In North America alone, some 698 families, with an estimated 95,553 species are recognized (Erwin 1982, Chapman 2006, Triplehorn & Johnson 2005). Insects are an integral part of all of the world’s forest ecosystems. Many species serve beneficial and even critical functions in forests. Some visit flowers and pollinate plants. Others function as agents in the breakdown of dead vegetation. Insects, such honeybees or the lac insect, provide products beneficial to humans. Others kill old, mature trees and make way for the establishment of young, more vigorous forests. When insects become excessively abundant, they can damage trees and forests and thus compete with humans for the goods and services that forests provide. Some groups of insects, such as foliage feeders and bark beetles, are
considered major forest pests and their prevention and control is an integral part of forest management. Worldwide, approximately 68 million ha of forests suffer some type of insect damage each year. This is more than twice the area burned by wildfires (FAO 2005). This text examines forest insects in a global context and addresses the species of major concern in the world’s forest ecosystems. It is divided into two parts: Chapters 1–5 examine the role of insects in forests, their dynamics and their effects on natural forests, plantations, agroforestry systems, urban forests, wood and non-wood products. Approaches to forest insect monitoring are reviewed and alternatives for management of damaging forest insects within the framework of integrated pest management (IPM) are presented. The basis for classification of forest insects into orders and families is reviewed in Chapter 6. Chapters 7–15 address the main thrust of this text and provide descriptions of important forest insects, their distribution, hosts, life histories and economic, social and ecological impacts. These chapters are organized according to the damage the insects cause, rather than by taxonomic groups. This text is written for foresters, forest entomologists and forest health specialists engaged in management and protection of forests, worldwide. It is intended to call attention to the importance of insects in the world’s forest ecosystems, the need to consider management of insect pests as an integral part of sustainable forest management and to serve as a guide to the identification of the world’s major pest species.
Chapter 1
The World’s Forests and their Dynamics
INTRODUCTION Forests cover 3.952 billion ha or 30.3% of the Earth’s surface. Other wooded lands cover another 1.3 billion ha.1 They provide habitat for many living organisms. Moreover, they provide a wealth of goods and services for humans. Forests are a source of both wood and nonwood products, including lumber, pulpwood, fuel wood, resin and food items such as nuts, fruits, mushrooms, edible plants and game. In addition, they provide protective cover for watersheds, range for domestic animals and are an important source of recreation and spiritual refreshment. A more recently appreciated value of forests is their ability to remove excess carbon from the Earth’s atmosphere, much of which is produced by humans through burning of fossil fuels or clearing of forests, and store it in woody biomass. The 1
Forests are defined as land spanning 0.5 ha with trees higher than 5 m and a canopy of more than 10%. Other wooded land is defined as land spanning more than 0.5 ha with trees higher than 5 m and a canopy cover of between 5% and 10% (FAO 2005, 2009a).
world’s forests presently store an estimated 240 gigatonnes (Gt) of carbon in woody biomass and a total of 683 Gt of carbon in forest ecosystems as a whole (FAO 2005, 2009a). The world’s forests have been subject to human pressure since the beginning of civilization. Large areas have been deforested to make room for agriculture, communities, industrial sites, roads and highways. Additional areas have been degraded as trees of the most desirable species and quality were harvested, forests were overgrazed by domestic livestock or burned for land clearing or to drive game. Presently, the rate of forest loss due to land use change is estimated at 13 million ha/year, resulting in a net reduction of forest area of about 7.3 million ha/year. Only 36% of the world’s forests are regarded as “primary forests.” These are defined as forests of native species in which there is no clearly visible indication of human activity and ecological processes are not significantly disturbed (FAO 2005, 2009a). Forests have the capacity to regenerate and produce goods and services for humans on a continuing basis, provided they are managed in a sustainable manner.
Forest Entomology: A Global Perspective, First Edition. William M. Ciesla. Ó 2011 William M. Ciesla. Published 2011 by Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
1
2
Forest entomology: a global perspective
The concept of sustainability evolved as a result of the United Nations Brundtland Commission (United Nations 1987), which defined sustainable development as “development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.” Sustainable development focuses attention on finding strategies to promote economic and social development in ways that avoid environmental degradation, overexploitation or pollution. Forests managed under the concept of sustainable development, therefore, should provide needed goods and services for present as well as future generations. The world’s forests are dynamic. They are in a continuous state of flux and, in addition to human activities, are subject to disturbance by wind, water, fire, insects and disease. This chapter provides an overview of the world’s forests and the factors that characterize their dynamics.
FOREST ECOSYSTEMS The world’s forests are highly varied and complex and many classification systems have been used to categorize them. A system proposed by Olson et al. (2001) subdivides the Earth’s vegetation into eight biogeographic regions (Fig. 1.1) and 14 biomes. The biomes are further subdivided into 867 ecoregions. Eight of the
14 biomes proposed by Olson et al. (2001) are forest biomes and include: .
Tropical and subtropical forests: tropical and subtropical moist broadleaf forests; * tropical and subtropical dry broadleaf forests; * tropical and subtropical coniferous forests; * mangroves. Temperate forests: * temperate broadleaf and mixed forests; * temperate conifer forests; * Mediterranean forests, woodlands and scrub. Boreal forests/taiga. *
.
.
Tropical and Subtropical Forests The portion of the Earth that lies roughly between 23.5 north and south latitude, or between the Tropics of Cancer and Capricorn, is regarded as the tropics. The tropics are characterized by having consistently warm temperatures and are frost free. Annual and monthly mean temperatures are above 18–20 C and there is a difference of no more than 5 C between the warmest and coolest month of the year. These temperatures allow for biological activity to take place throughout the year, except in areas with seasonal droughts. The subtropics, on the other hand, are two bands around the earth adjacent to the tropics, from about 10 north and south latitude to 23.5 north and south
Fig. 1.1 Biogeographic regions of the world (redrawn from Olson et al. 2001).
The world’s forests and their dynamics
3
Fig. 1.2 Moist tropical forests are richest in species diversity (Parque Nacional Foz do Igua¸cu, Brazil).
latitude. While the climate is generally warm, subtropical regions are subject to occasional frosts and plant communities are more tolerant of cold temperatures than those found in the tropics. Species composition in tropical forests varies according to moisture, soil types and geological history. The richest species diversity is in Latin America, followed by Southeast Asia and Africa (Fig. 1.2). There is little similarity in species between these regions, although they do share some common plant families and genera. The tropical forests of Southeast Asia are dominated by members of the plant family Dipterocarpaceae. These are broadleaf trees that include many valuable timber species (Nair 2007). Tropical and Subtropical Moist Broadleaf Forests Most tropical and subtropical moist broadleaf forests have no discernable dry season. They are composed of broadleaf evergreen trees and are rich in terms of both plant and animal diversity. The largest area of moist tropical forest occurs in South America, in the Amazon Basin. Other areas of moist tropical forest occur in portions of Africa and Southeast Asia. Tropical and subtropical moist broadleaf forests are characterized by having dense, luxuriant, multistoried plant growth. Woody lianas or vines are common. Monocots, such as bamboos or canes, are also common in some areas.
Tree branches often provide habitat for luxuriant growth of ferns, orchids, bromeliads, mosses and lichens. Many of the world’s moist tropical forests occur at elevations of <1000 m in elevation. Moist tropical forests also occur in mountainous regions, especially in portions of Central and South America, at elevations ranging from 1000 to 3000 m. These forests are sometimes referred to as “cloud” forests because they receive much of their moisture from clouds that envelop the summits of mountain peaks for much of the year. Moist deciduous tropical forests occur in areas of distinct, alternating wet and dry seasons and are known as “seasonal or monsoonal tropics.” These are occupied by broadleaf trees that lose their foliage and become dormant during dry seasons and are lush and green during rainy seasons. They are found in portions of Asia from Sri Lanka east to southern China, across portions of western and eastern Africa, northern Australia, Brazil, Mexico and Central America. Tropical and Subtropical Dry Broadleaf Forests Dry tropical and subtropical forests are characterized by a strong seasonality of rainfall distribution and have several months of severe, even absolute, drought (Mooney et al. 1995). Portions of eastern Africa, for example, have two alternating wet and dry seasons.
4
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Fig. 1.3 Dry tropical woodland, dominated by species of Acacia (Amboseli National Park, Kenya).
The long dry season occurs from about December to March and is followed by a long wet season from late March through August. A short dry period occurs from September to October, followed by a short rainy season in November and December. During the dry periods there is little or no precipitation. The Caatinga, a region of dry broadleaf forests in northeastern Brazil, has an average of 300–1000 mm of precipitation/year, which is concentrated over a 3–5 month period. Droughts are common and severe droughts of 3–4 years’ duration can occur at intervals of every three or four decades. These forests are characterized by low deciduous trees, often armed with thorns. They transition into open woodlands and savannas in areas where soils are less fertile or where moisture regimes are too dry to support forest cover (Fig. 1.3). Tropical and Subtropical Conifer Forests Conifer forests are found in tropical and subtropical regions of Mexico, Central America, east Africa and southeastern Asia. In Mexico, Central America and southeastern Asia, these forests are dominated by pines. The pine flora of Mexico and Central America is the most diverse in the world and consists of about 72 species and subspecies (Perry 1991). In Central America, pine forests extend south into northern Nicaragua (Fig. 1.4). Pine forests of southeastern Asia are less diverse but cover significant areas of Cambodia,
southern China, Myanmar, Thailand and Vietnam. One species, Pinus merkusii, is found just south of the equator on the Indonesian island of Sumatra (Critchfield & Little 1966). In portions of Ethiopia, Kenya and Saudi Arabia, high-elevation forests are dominated by the east African pencil cedar, Juniperus procera, which is the only juniper that extends its range south of the equator (FAO 1986). Mangroves Mangroves occur in silt-rich, saline, brackish water habitats, generally along large river deltas, estuaries and coastal areas. They are characterized by having relatively low tree diversity, with a low broken canopy. Mangrove species are broadleaf evergreen trees and shrubs adapted to salty and swampy habitats by having breathing roots, or pneumatophores, which are exposed to the air and absorb oxygen (Fig. 1.5). They are important ecosystems because they provide spawning grounds and nurseries for many marine and freshwater species. They also help prevent and reduce coastal erosion and storm damage. Mangroves are threatened because of their proximity to the ocean and are often targets for development. Moreover, local people make heavy use of mangrove trees as an easy source of wood. These forests occupy roughly 15.2 million ha and about 47% of the world’s mangrove forests are found in Australia, Brazil, Indonesia,
The world’s forests and their dynamics
5
Fig. 1.4 A tropical conifer forest dominated by Pinus oocarpa (northern Nicaragua).
Mexico and Nigeria. The world’s largest mangrove forest is the Sundarbans, which occurs along the coastal regions of Bangladesh and India. The Sundarbans supports the world’s largest remaining population of Bengal tigers.
Temperate Forests Temperate forests have well-defined warm and cold seasons. They are found north and south of the tropical/subtropical forests or at high elevations in tropical/
Fig. 1.5 A blue heron rests on pneumatophores of red mangrove, Rhyzophora mangle (Bonaire, Netherlands Antilles).
6
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Fig. 1.6 A temperate mixed deciduous broadleaf–conifer forest dominated by Fagus sylvatica and Picea abies (Alpensee near Füssen, Bavaria, Germany).
subtropical latitudes where temperatures are cooler. The cold or winter season usually has sufficiently low temperatures to force plants into dormancy. Growing seasons vary from 140 to 200 days and from 4 to 6 frost-free months. These forests may be composed of conifers and both broadleaf evergreen and deciduous trees. Temperate Broadleaf and Mixed Forests Temperate broadleaf and mixed broadleaf–conifer forests are the dominant forest biome over most of Europe, portions of Asia and eastern North America. They are restricted to the northern hemisphere, except for a small area at the southern tip of South America (Argentina and Chile), and occur where average temperatures are below 0 C for the coldest month of the year and above 10 C for the warmest month (Dansereau 1957). Most of the broadleaf species in these forests are deciduous and are characterized by leaf fall in autumn, which is an adaptation to a cold season when liquid water is either restricted or unavailable to plants. Leaf fall is preceded by an often spectacular coloration of autumn foliage. Annual precipitation ranges between 70 and 150 cm and is more or less evenly distributed. Evergreen broadleaf species tend to be intolerant of winter drought or prolonged cold and are generally absent from these forests.
Central Europe’s temperate broadleaf forests have been severely fragmented due to agriculture, grazing and other human activities. These forests have less species diversity than other temperate deciduous forests because many species were lost during the Pleistocene ice ages. Pure forests of beech, Fagus sylvatica, dominate the higher elevations (Fig. 1.6) and oaks, Quercus spp., linden, Tilia spp., and ash, Fraxinus spp., are dominant components of low-elevation forests. In Asia, North America and the Near East, there are many more species of trees including representatives of the genera Acer, Aesculus, Carya, Juglans, Liquidambar, Liriodendron and Magnolia, as well as outliers of some tropical families (e.g. Diospyros) (Hora 1981). For example, the temperate deciduous forests of the southern Appalachian Mountains of southeastern USA have approximately 140 different species of trees (Westveld 1949). Warm temperate forests may consist of both deciduous and evergreen broadleaf species and conifers and tend to occur along the eastern coastal regions of continents that are exposed to monsoons or trade winds. They often transition into subtropical forests. Rainfall is abundant and evenly distributed throughout the year. In southeastern Asia, eastern Australia and southern Brazil, there is a continuous gradation with increasing latitude from wet tropical to subtropical to warm temperate conditions. This makes it difficult to distinguish vegetation zones. These forests are typically
The world’s forests and their dynamics dense and penetration is difficult due to abundance of vegetation. They tend to be rich in tree species, including some conifers, epiphytes and climbers, although less so than tropical forests. Some of the broadleaf trees found in these forests are deciduous. In Australia, warm temperate forests, dominated by Nothofagus, are found in Tasmania and Victoria. In Africa, only the Drakensburg Mountains of South Africa have suitably moist conditions to support warm temperate forests. The boundaries of the warm temperate forests of eastern North America are poorly defined because cold air masses move south as far as the Gulf of Mexico. They are generally found along coastal regions of the Atlantic Ocean and Gulf of Mexico from North Carolina south to Florida and west to Texas, USA. The tree flora of North American warm temperate forests is rich and includes both evergreen and deciduous species of oaks, Quercus spp., Liquidambar stryaciflua, and conifers including several pines, Pinus spp., and bald cypress, Taxodium distichum. Warm temperate forests also occur in New Zealand and include several species of Nothofagus and kauri pine, Agathis australis, which often occur in mixture with subtropical broadleaf species (Hora 1981). Islands of warm temperate forests occur at high elevations in the tropics. For example, high-elevation temperate cloud forests are found in Central America and extend as far as the northern tip of South America. These contain species of oaks, Quercus spp., and other broadleaf trees (Author’s observation, Ramierez Correa 1988).
7
Fig. 1.7 Stratification of coniferous forest types by elevation and moisture in the central Rocky Mountain region of northern Colorado, USA.
appears at lower elevations than on south-facing slopes, which are warmer and drier. In northern Colorado, ponderosa pine–Douglas-fir forests are usually replaced by pure, even-aged forests of lodgepole pine, Pinus contorta, at around 2400 m and at elevations of around 3000 m, subalpine fir, Abies lasiocarpa, and Engelmann spruce, Picea engelmannii, are the dominant trees. As elevation continues to increase, the proportion of Engelmann spruce increases until at approximately 3500 m, the upper limit of tree growth, nearly pure stands of this species exist (Figs 1.7 & 1.8). Similar stratifications of species by elevation and moisture can be found in conifer forests of the Atlas Mountains of northern Africa and the Himalaya Mountains of Asia.
Temperate Conifer Forests Large areas over portions of western North America are dominated by conifers of the family Pinaceae. Many of these forests occur in mountainous regions with semiarid climates and species occurrence tends to be stratified by elevation and moisture. In Colorado, USA, for example, piñon pine, Pinus edulis, and juniper, Juniperus spp., woodlands dominate the lowest elevations and begin at about 2000 m. As elevations increase, pure forests of ponderosa pine, Pinus ponderosa, become the dominant species. As elevation and available moisture increase, Douglas-fir, Pseudotsuga menziesii, and in southern Colorado and northern New Mexico, white fir, Abies concolor, occur in mixture with the ponderosa pine. On north-facing slopes, which receive less direct sunlight and have a cooler, moister climate, Douglas-fir
Fig. 1.8 Stratification of coniferous forest types by elevation and moisture in the central Rocky Mountain region of northern New Mexico and southern Colorado, USA.
8
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Along the Pacific Coast of North America, where there are higher levels of precipitation, forests are dominated by giant conifers including redwood, Sequoia sempervirens, Douglas-fir, western hemlock, Tsuga heterophylla, and western red cedar, Thuja plicata. Mediterranean Forests Mediterranean climates are characterized by mild wet winters and hot dry summers. Areas with Mediterranean climate are found along the western coastal regions of the world’s continents and include portions of southern Europe, North Africa and the Near East; southern California, USA, central Chile and Western Australia. Average annual precipitation ranges from 500 to 1000 mm, with prolonged periods of low humidity. The vegetation of Mediterranean forests tends to be relatively rich in species diversity. In Mediterranean Europe and California, they are dominated by pine, oak and other broadleaf trees. In the western part of Australia, eucalypts, Eucalyptus spp., are the dominant trees and in central Chile, species of Nothofagus dominate. Many plants that occupy Mediterranean forests have hard leather-like or sclerophylus leaves, which are an adaptation to prolonged dry summers. Mediterranean forests are subject to frequent wildfires, often of human origin, and are easily degraded by
grazing of domestic animals. Moreover, heavy cutting results in domination of formerly forested sites with low dense, evergreen woody shrub vegetation, known by several colloquial names: maquis in Mediterranean Europe, chaparral in California, USA, mattaral in Chile, malee scrub in Australia and fynbosch or karroo in South Africa (Hora 1981).
Boreal Forests/Taiga The boreal forests or taiga encircle the northern hemisphere and cover a vast area of North America and Eurasia between 50 and 60 north latitude. Despite their large area, boreal forests occur in relatively few countries: Canada, northern China, Finland, northern Mongolia, Norway, Russia, Sweden and the USA (Alaska) (Fig. 1.9). Climate is characterized by long, cold and dry winters and short, moist summers. Growing season is short, about 130 days, and soils are thin, nutrient poor and acidic. Boreal forests are dominated by conifers of the genera Abies, Larix, Picea and Pinus (Fig. 1.10). Broadleaf trees are poorly represented, although the few species that do occur can cover large areas. Families and genera of broadleaf trees found in the boreal forests include members of the Salicaceae (Salix, Populus), Betulaceae (Alnus, Betula) and Rosaceae
Fig. 1.9 Global distribution of boreal forests or taiga across the northern hemisphere (redrawn from Olson et al. 2001).
The world’s forests and their dynamics
9
Fig. 1.10 Aerial view of a boreal forest dominated by white spruce, Picea glauca (Kenai Peninsula, Alaska, USA).
(Sorbus). In the northern limits of the boreal forest, trees are typically reduced to low, shrubby trees, known as krumholz, due to short growing seasons and severe weather. Island forests composed of typically boreal species extend south into the higher elevations of the Alps, Carpathian and Pyrenees Ranges of Europe and the Appalachian, Rocky and Cascade mountain ranges of North America (Hora 1981, Vasilevich 1996).
intolerant, pioneer species are adapted to canopy disturbance and require gaps in which to become established. Some late-successional species may tolerate shade as juveniles, but most also require disturbance of the forest canopy to reach reproductive maturity. As gap size increases, conditions become more favorable for the establishment of shade-intolerant pioneer species, which may eventually succeed to more shadetolerant species.
FOREST DYNAMICS
Tropical Forests
Forests are dynamic and their structure and composition are continuously subject to change. Disturbances set the stage for replacement of mature, senescent trees and stands with young vigorous trees. The magnitude of disturbances ranges from the death an individual or group of trees that leaves a small opening or gap in the forest canopy to a wildfire that can encompass thousands of hectares. At first glance, forest canopies may appear uniform. In reality, they are a mosaic of conditions. Canopy gaps are an integral part of virtually every mature forest. They can be caused by death of individual or small groups of trees, strong winds, landslides, wildfires and pest outbreaks. Strong winds and landslides with resultant uprooting of trees may disturb the soil and expose the mineral horizon. Many fast-growing, shade-
In moist tropical forests, natural disturbances tend to be relatively small and help give the impression of a stable forest ecosystem. However, disturbances can be of relatively high frequency and caused by a number of factors (Nair 2007). In the Amazon Basin, a key biotic disturbance agent is invasion by lianas following death of small groups of trees or disturbances, often caused by indigenous people. These are eventually occupied by pioneer trees. A climbing bamboo, Guarda macrocarpa, is also capable of invading more open forests in transition between tropical rain forests and the seasonally dry cerrado vegetation that lies to the south of the Amazon Basin. Abiotic disturbance factors in Amazon rain forests include blowdown events caused by convective downburst winds or, less frequently, tornadoes, and flooding or
10
Forest entomology: a global perspective
accelerated tree mortality due to below normal precipitation (Nelson 2006). Wildfires are an important factor in the dynamics of tropical forests. Most wildfires in tropical forests are of human origin, largely due to escaped agricultural fires (FAO 2005). Low-intensity ground fires, for example, are a disturbance factor that influences the dynamics of tropical rain forests in the Amazon Basin, especially in areas disturbed by timber harvesting (Nelson 2006). Some moist tropical forests are subject to periodic prolonged droughts, such as those caused by the El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO), which increase their susceptibility to stand replacement fires. An ENSO event in 1982–3 set the stage for catastrophic wildfires that occurred in East Kalimantan, Indonesia and burned over 3.5 million ha of primary and secondary tropical rain forest. Severe, ENSO-related wildfires also occurred in Indonesia during 1991–2, 1993–4 and 1997–8. Wildfires during the 1997–8 ENSO event burned over 5.2 million ha or about 25% of the forest area of East Kalimantan (Hoffman et al. 1999). Fuel accumulations caused by windthrow due to tropical storms can also increase risk of wildfire. In 1988, Hurricane Gilbert swept across tropical forests of the Yucatan Peninsula of Mexico and damaged over 1 million ha of forests. During the following year, over 120,000 ha of Mexico’s largest area of tropical forest burned. Dry tropical forests are subject to regular wildfire episodes that can cover large areas. For example, during the 1990s and early part of the 21st century, wildfires burned over large areas of Chad, located in the SudoSahelian region of Central Africa. These fires burned over 50–70% of the vegetation and 20–23% of the Sahelian vegetation each year. Today, humans are undoubtedly the key factor that influences the dynamics of tropical forests. Tropical deforestation, due to land clearing for agriculture, is occurring at high rates. As mentioned earlier in this chapter, the annual rate of deforestation for the period 2000–5 averaged 13 million ha/year. This resulted in a net loss of 7.3 million ha/year, an area equivalent to the land area of Panama or Sierra Leone (FAO 2005).
Temperate and Boreal Forests Temperate and boreal forests are subject to frequent and widespread disturbance events, including wildfire, severe winds and insect outbreaks. Landscape level disturbance events are relatively common. As is the
case in tropical forest ecosystems, disturbance events set the stage for replacement of mature, senescent forests with young, vigorous stands, often of the same species that occupied the site prior to the disturbance. In most cases, disturbance events are due to interactions of several factors, including the condition of the forest, climatic events, human activities, insects and disease. Catastrophic outbreaks of insects, especially bark beetles and defoliators, are a major cause of disturbance in many temperate and boreal forests. The following sections describe scenarios of how insects interact with other factors, including human activities, to create major forest disturbances.
Windstorms and Bark Beetles Severe storms, resulting in extensive windthrow of mature forests, can set the stage for bark beetle outbreaks (Fig. 1.11). Several species of conifer-infesting bark beetles invade fresh windthrow and build to epidemic levels. Beetles that emerge from the windthrow subsequently invade standing trees at the edge of the windthrow and cause additional tree mortality. Examples of bark beetles that build to epidemic proportions in fresh windthrow and cause landscape level tree mortality are the spruce bark beetle, Ips typographus, in Eurasia and the spruce beetle, Dendroctonus rufipennis, and Douglas-fir beetle, D. pseudotsugae, in North America. In central Europe, forests have been managed intensively for over 200 years. Management of spruce, Picea abies, takes into consideration the risk of development of outbreaks of the spruce beetle, Ips typographus, and includes rapid removal of windthrown trees, debarking of trees that have been harvested and use of pheromone traps to reduce numbers of beetles. In 1970, the Bavarian National Park was established in southeastern Germany along the border with the Czech Republic. The park was to be managed on the principle of “let nature take its course.” During the 1990s and early part of the 21st century, several windstorms occurred in mature spruce forests in the park. The windthrown trees were subsequently invaded by I. typographus. Beetles emerging from the windthrow attacked adjacent standing trees. As of late 2009, 5000 ha or about 20% of the 24,500-ha park had been killed by spruce beetle outbreaks, mostly in highelevation forests of pure spruce. Public reaction to the
The world’s forests and their dynamics
11
Fig. 1.11 Windthrow events provide a large volume of host material for buildup of several conifer infesting bark beetles (Bavarian National Park, Germany).
outbreak and safety considerations has forced park officials to modify the “let nature take its course” policy. Pest management actions included removal of infested trees to reduce hazard of falling dead trees along hiking trails and to minimize spread of the outbreak into surrounding privately owned forests. In addition, the park has conducted a program of educating the public on the dynamics of spruce forests, including forest disturbances such as wind storms and bark beetle outbreaks, and set the stage for replacement of old spruce forests with young, vigorous stands.2 Fire, Humans and Insects Interactions between fire, humans and insect outbreaks in temperate and boreal forests cause disturbance events, including insect outbreaks. Many forest ecosystems throughout the world are subject to disturbances by naturally occurring fire and have developed adaptations that allow them to co-exist with naturally occurring fire. Virtually all of the world’s pine forests, for example, are subject to wildfire and fire regimes in pine forests can vary from low, moderate or high severity 2
Information in this paragraph is based on an interview with Rainier P€ ohlmann, Director of Public Affairs, Bavarian National Park, 12 October 2009.
depending on the species and local climatic conditions (Agee 1998).
Pinus ponderosa In western North America, pure forests of ponderosa pine, Pinus ponderosa, dominate low-elevation forests. This species is long lived (300–600 years) and subject to frequent, low-intensity fires. Prior to arrival of European settlers, the fire return interval in these forests averaged from 3 to 36 years. Older, larger ponderosa pines are thick barked, which allows them to survive low-intensity fires. This resulted in a landscape of open, park-like pine forests with a grass understory (Fig. 1.12, Oliver & Ryker 1990, Agee 1998). European settlement on the fringes of ponderosa pine forests resulted in a need for wildfire suppression. This lengthened the fire interval and gradually changed the character of the open forests to more dense forests. These have become susceptible to outbreaks of mountain pine beetle, Dendroctonus ponderosae. In addition, when fire now occurs in these stands, they tend to be high-intensity stand replacement fires. In other areas, a combination of selective harvesting of ponderosa pine and wildfire suppression has allowed species such as Abies concolor and Pseudotsuga menziesii to invade sites formerly dominated by ponderosa pine. These trees are subject to outbreaks of defoliating insects including
12
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Fig. 1.12 Open park-like forests of ponderosa pine, Pinus ponderosa, are the result of relatively frequent, low-intensity fires (Rio Grande National Forest, Colorado, USA).
western spruce budworm, Choristoneura occidentalis, and Douglas-fir tussock moth, Orgyia pseudotsugata.
Pinus contorta Lodgepole pine, Pinus contorta, is another species that occupies large areas of forest in western North America. This species occurs as a mosaic of pure, even-aged stands of varying age classes over the landscape. Unlike ponderosa pine, this tree has a relatively short life span and most stands are considered mature at about age 60–100 years. Lodgepole pine forests have a moderate severity fire regime with a fire return interval that ranges from 60 to over 100 years. Because the bark of lodgepole pine is thin and unable to protect trees, fires in lodgepole pine are typically stand replacement fires. Lodgepole pine has adapted to fire by producing serotinous cones, which open only when exposed to high temperatures (Fig. 1.13). When a wildfire burns through lodgepole pine, the high temperatures cause these cones to open and release abundant seeds to start a new forest (Fig 1.14, Agee 1998). Lodgepole pine forests are also subject to devastating outbreaks of mountain pine beetle, Dendroctonus ponderosae. These can cover millions of hectares and kill most or all of the trees in excess of 13 cm in diameter. Beginning in the late 1990s, massive outbreaks of this
insect developed over portions of British Columbia, Canada, and Colorado and Wyoming, USA. They are believed to be the result of a combination of large areas of mature lodgepole pine, susceptible to beetle attack, fire exclusion and a decade of mild winters that allowed a higher portion of overwintering beetles to survive. The outbreak in British Columbia, Canada has affected over 7 million ha of lodgepole pine forests and is regarded as the most severe insect outbreak ever to occur in that country (Aukema et al. 2006). A question on many people’s minds is: do bark beetle outbreaks increase the probability of a catastrophic wildfire? These outbreaks have left thousands of dead trees in their wake and changed the character of the forest fuels. Dead standing trees, with red needles and fine dead branches, can carry high-intensity wildfires. However, after a few years, the needles and fine branches drop from the trees. Over time, many of the beetle-killed trees fall and new trees develop in their wake. This creates ladder fuels and conditions favorable for fires capable of burning over large areas. The wildfires on lodgepole pine forests in the Greater Yellowstone Basin, which covers portions of Idaho, Montana and Wyoming, USA in 1988, provided some insights into the interaction between mountain pine beetle outbreaks and wildfire. These fires burned
The world’s forests and their dynamics
13
Fig. 1.13 Serotinous cones of lodgepole pine, Pinus contorta, open only when exposed to high temperatures associated with wildfires (Beaverhead National Forest, Montana, USA).
Fig. 1.14 Regeneration of lodgepole pine, Pinus contorta, after a wildfire (Yellowstone National Park, Wyoming, USA).
approximately 36% of Yellowstone National Park’s forest area following the driest period in its recorded history. Prior to 1988, Yellowstone National Park and surrounding areas endured two mountain pine beetle outbreaks; one from 1972 to 1975 and another from 1980 to 1983. An analysis of the relationship between fire and previous outbreaks showed that areas affected
by mountain pine beetle 13–16 years before the fire increased the probability of an area burning by about 11%. However, the occurrence of the more recent outbreak was not correlated with the probability of an area burning. Scientists who conducted this study believe that one of the reasons older outbreak areas have a higher probability of intense wildfires was that
14
Forest entomology: a global perspective
enough time had passed to allow understory vegetation to release, providing “ladder fuels.” These consist of a combination of low-growing tree branches, shrubs and small trees (Lynch et al. 2006).
Foliage Feeding Insects Many insects feed on foliage of trees and other woody plants and some species are capable of causing landscape-level outbreaks. These insects also have a role in forest dynamics, which, in strictly ecological terms, are beneficial. Mattson and Addy (1975) argue that the
ecological role of foliage feeding insects is nutrient recycling. Feeding by insect larvae and, in a few cases, adults, on foliage and dropping of fecal pellets on to the forest floor results in a transfer of nutrients from the foliage to the soil. In addition, these insects are instrumental in plant succession. Crown thinning due to insect feeding allows more sunlight to reach the forest floor and encourages growth of understory vegetation. Stand openings created by pockets of tree mortality due to insect feeding favors the growth of successive generations of trees. Defoliator outbreaks may also contribute to greater species diversity and, therefore, greater ecosystem stability.
Chapter 2
Forest Insect Dynamics
INTRODUCTION In Chapter 1, it was pointed out that forests are dynamic entities. Insects are also dynamic, significantly more so than forests. Their abundance is a function of many factors in the environment they occupy. This chapter addresses the dynamics of forest insect populations, the factors that set the stage for outbreaks and the nature of insect outbreaks.
POPULATION DYNAMICS Population dynamics is the study of animal populations and addresses their abundance and density and how they change over time as functions of rates of birth, mortality, immigration and emigration. The study of the dynamics of animal populations, especially of insects, is a complex and fascinating science. The dynamics of some insect populations have been simulated by complex mathematical models that describe their behavior in nature.
Several definitions are in order. A population is defined as a group of individuals of the same species that occupy a given geographic area. Population abundance is the absolute number of individuals that make up this population and population density is the number of individuals of the population that occupy a given unit of area (number of larvae per branch of a given length, insects/m2 of foliage, insects/tree, etc.) (Berryman 1986). Population abundance and density are rarely constant. They are influenced by many factors, including the environment occupied by the population, interactions within species, between species and the behavior and physiology of the species in question. A basic understanding of these mechanisms and how they influence numbers of potentially damaging forest insects is one of the foundations of forest entomology. Understanding the population dynamics of forest insects allows specialists to examine the underlying causes of outbreaks, predict population trends and establish a better basis for forest pest management activities.
Forest Entomology: A Global Perspective, First Edition. William M. Ciesla. Ó 2011 William M. Ciesla. Published 2011 by Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
15
16
Forest entomology: a global perspective
POPULATION PROCESSES Four basic processes define the dynamics of all living organisms: birth (B), death (D), emigration (E) and immigration (I) (Berryman 1986). The rates of these processes are defined by the quality of the physical and biological environment that the organisms occupy. When conditions are favorable, rates of birth and immigration will exceed the rates of death and emigration and populations increase. Therefore: BþI>DþE If conditions are unfavorable, death and emigration rates exceed the rates of birth and immigration and populations decline: BþI
Birth and Death Rates Rates of birth and death in insect populations are a function of their reproductive capacity and environment. For those insects that rely on sexual reproduction, mating success is dependent upon finding a mate. If the population density is low, odds of finding a mate are also low. Some insects have lost their capacity to reproduce sexually and all adults in the population are females. Other species have alternating sexual and asexual generations. While asexual reproduction may be an efficient means of reproduction, the level of genetic variability is low and, concurrently, the ability to adapt to changes in the environment is also low. Quality of food is also a determinant factor in the ability of an insect to reproduce. Repeated defoliation by foliage feeding insects, for example, can change the level of nutrients in the foliage. This, in turn, causes reduced reproductive capacity or fecundity. Competition, both within and between species, reduces the amount of food available on a per insect basis and has a negative effect on fecundity.
Death rates in insect populations are influenced by the availability and quality of food sources, the level of competition for available resources and activity by natural enemies.
Migration Ability to migrate or disperse helps insects locate suitable hosts for breeding, feeding and shelter (e.g. pupation sites). Migration may take one of two forms. Emigration is the movement of insects out of the area in which they developed. Immigration, on the other hand, is the movement into a site that offers suitable host material and/or breeding sites. Emigration causes insect populations to spread over the landscape, whereas immigration concentrates their numbers in specific locations. The latter is critical for insects that must invade hosts in large numbers, such as tree killing bark beetles, to overcome host resistance. Dispersal is a key function of adult insects with functional wings. Adults of many insects, such as beetles, wasps, flies, moths and butterflies, are strong fliers and can at least cover distances of several kilometers. However, many insects either do not have functional wings, have lost their capacity to fly or the females are so heavily laden with eggs they are incapable of flight, at least until they have deposited a portion of their eggs. These insects are dependent on other mechanisms of dispersal. Larvae of some insects can migrate short distances to new feeding sites. The larvae of the processionary caterpillars, Thaumetopoea spp., which defoliate pines and broadleaf trees in the Mediterranean region, move in head to tail processions to new feeding sites within trees (Fig. 2.1) and later to seek pupation sites in the soil. Larvae of the tent caterpillars, Malacosoma spp., also migrate, often crossing roads, to seek new food sources after they have completely defoliated trees. Wind is a key agent of dispersal for many insects, even for those capable of flight. Insects are known to be carried on air currents for long distances. Large numbers of adult spruce budworms, Choristoneura fumiferana, including females still laden with eggs, have been observed dispersing over distances of up to 600 km during outbreaks in eastern Canada. This massive dispersal apparently is due to a combination of adult flight and prevailing winds (Blais 1985). Adult females of several important forest defoliators
Forest insect dynamics
17
Fig. 2.1 A colony of instar III larvae of the processionary caterpillar, Thaumetopoea wilkinsonii, migrates to a new feeding site on Pinus brutia (northern Cyprus).
of the family Noctuidae, subfamily Lymantriinae, are unable to fly because their wings are either nonfunctional, as is the case of the European gypsy moth, Lymantria dispar, or because they have atrophied, as in the case of species of Orgyia. The larval stages of these insects are covered with fine hairs and when exposed to winds are subject to dispersal. Even larvae of the related nun moth, Lymantria monacha, an insect with functional wings, are subject to wind dispersal during their early instars (Fig. 2.2). Larvae of insects of the family Tortricidae, which includes the spruce budworm and western spruce budworm, spin out of host trees on silken threads when disturbed and are subsequently dispersed via air currents. Other insects that rely on air currents for dispersal are aphids and the early instar nymphs (crawlers) of species of adelgids and scales. Some insects have developed symbiotic relationships with other insects that ensure their dispersal to new feeding sites. Some aphids, for example, have developed symbiotic relationships with ants. The ants feed on honeydew produced by aphid colonies. To maintain a reliable food source, ants move aphid nymphs and adults to new feeding sites. In addition, some ants protect aphid colonies on which they rely for food from predation. Humans are an important agent of long distance insect dispersal via international trade and travel.
Human involvement in introduction and establishment of forest insects is reviewed in Chapter 3. Chemical Ecology of Insects Insects are among many organisms that rely on chemical messengers to accomplish functions essential for survival and reproduction. These may be produced by the insects themselves, related species or by their host plants. The study of these messengers is known as chemical ecology. Chemicals that transmit information between organisms, either of the same species or different species, are known as semiochemicals. Several classes of semiochemicals are recognized depending on their function: pheromones, allomones, kairomones and synomones. In some cases the same chemical may serve two or more functions. Pheromones Pheromones are produced by an organism and influence the behavior of individuals of the same species. Sex attractants or sex pheromones are produced by female insects to lure males for mating. Aggregating pheromones attract large numbers of both males and females. They are used by bark beetles to attract large numbers of attacking adults to a suitable tree or group of trees
18
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Fig. 2.2 Larvae of nun moth, Lymantria monacha, are one of several forest defoliators subject to wind dispersal shortly after egg hatch (Lithuania).
(Fig. 2.3). Some species of ladybird beetles also produce aggregating pheromones to establish large colonies for overwintering. Primer pheromones trigger hormonal changes in insects. Queen termites, for example, release a pheromone that inhibits maturation in worker castes. Alarm pheromones are used by social insects, such as honeybees and wasps, to take defensive action to protect their colonies from natural enemies. Trail pheromones are used by ants to establish routes between their nests and food sources. Some species of colony feeding caterpillars, such as the processionary caterpillars, Thaumetopoea spp., use trail pheromones to migrate from one feeding site to another (see Fig. 2.1). Other pheromones function as agents of dispersal or anti-attractants. These are produced by several bark beetles that send a message to other attacking beetles that a given tree is fully occupied by attacking beetles and/or that they have mated successfully.
Fig. 2.3 Pitch tubes on the bark surface of a lodgepole pine, Pinus contorta, indicates mass attack by mountain pine beetle, Dendroctonus ponderosae. Mass attacks, driven by aggregating pheromones overcome resistance of relatively vigorous trees (Roosevelt National Forest, Colorado, USA).
Allelochemicals A group of chemicals known as allelochemicals convey information between two or more different species. Several classes of allelochemicals are known. Allomones send signals to other species that benefit the species sending the chemical message but may or may not benefit the species that receives the message. Many plants produce allomones that either repel or discourage invasion by foliage feeding insects. Allomones can also discourage competing species from entering the territory of the species that send the message. Kairomones, on the other hand, send messages to other species that benefit the receiver but not necessarily the sender. For example, some aggregating
Forest insect dynamics pheromones produced by attacking bark beetles are also attractive to predaceous beetles of the family Cleridae. The pheromone complex of the southern pine beetle, Dendroctonus frontalis, for example, is also attractive to its clerid predator, Thanasimus dubius (Vite & Williamson 1970). In this example, the same chemical that acts as an attractant pheromone also functions as a kairomone. Similarly, many bark beetles of the genus Ips respond to the same aggregating pheromones. When these chemicals attract members of the same species, they function as pheromones and when they attract competing species or predators they function as kairomones (Wood 1982). Some caterpillars also produce kairomones in their frass, which attracts natural enemies. Chemicals produced by trees can serve as host attractants and send a chemical signal to potential invading insects that they are stressed or weakened and suitable for attack. These chemicals are used by bark beetles to locate suitable trees such as lightning strikes, during periods of low population density. Synomones are chemical messengers that benefit both the sender and the receiver. Some plants release chemicals when invaded by foliage feeding insects. These are attractive to natural enemies, parasites and predators of the foliage feeding insect. The plant benefits because the population density of the feeding insects is reduced and the natural enemies benefit because they are able to locate prey. Studies in Europe indicate that odors from twigs of Scotch pine, Pinus sylvestris, that contain needles infested with eggs of the pine sawfly, Diprion pini, release volatile chemicals that attract an egg parasitoid, Chrysonotomyia ruforum. Twigs that did not contain egg infested needles, on the other hand, were not attractive to the parasitoid (Hilker et al. 2002). A study in Canada suggests that the chemicals ipsenol and verbenone, which are attractant pheromones of the engraver beetle, Ips latidens, and mountain pine beetle, Dendroctonus ponderosae, respectively, repel a related species, the pine engraver beetle, Ips pini. In this case I. latidens and mountain pine beetle each produce a chemical that benefits the other but serves as a deterrent or allomone for I. pini (Borden et al. 1991). Identification and Synthesis of Semiochemicals Many semiochemicals that function as attractants or anti-attractants for forest insects have been identified and synthesized and their role in the dynamics of these insects has been studied. This is especially true for the tree killing bark beetles (Table 2.1, Wood 1982).
19
The use of aggregation and anti-aggregation pheromones and host attractants for host selection and invasion is exemplified by the southern pine beetle, Dendroctonus frontalis. Females initiate attacks. When a suitable host tree is located, they release aggregation pheromones, primarily frontalin. Frontalin, in combination with odors produced by host trees, attracts a male for mating plus additional males and females. Arriving males also release pheromones, including endo-brevicomin, which increase aggregation. If sufficient numbers of beetles are attracted, host resistance is overcome and the tree is successfully colonized. Males then release another pheromone, verbenone, which inhibits landing and causes invading beetles to switch to neighboring trees for attack (Clarke & Nowak 2009). Semiochemicals are used with varying degrees of effectiveness to either monitor insect populations (see Chapter 4) or as pest management tools (see Chapter 5).
ENVIRONMENTAL INFLUENCES ON INSECT POPULATIONS The environment occupied by an insect is critical to its survival and abundance. Environmental factors that affect population numbers and densities can be classified into three broad categories: biotic, physical and disturbances. Biotic factors include host abundance and quality, and the levels of competition and natural enemies. Physical factors include climate, soil and landscape features such as elevation, slope and aspect. Disturbances include wildfire, severe storms and human activities that can have a profound effect on quality and quantity of food and breeding sites. A favorable environment provides the following: . . .
abundant food of good quality; a low risk of mortality from natural enemies; ahighprobabilityofsuccessfulmatingand reproduction.
These influences can be further subdivided into two broad categories: density dependent and density independent. Density dependent factors are those that influence population processes in relation to the number and density of animals in the population. Density independent factors are those that influence population processes independent of population density (Berryman 1986).
20
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Table 2.1 Semiochemicals important in the ecology of several destructive species of bark beetles and ambrosia beetles (Coleoptera: Curclioidae: Scolytinae). Species
Semiochemical
Source
Function
Dendroctonus brevicomis
þ exo-brevicomin (-)-frontalin Myrcene trans-verbenol Verbenone
Female Male Host Female Male, female
Male attractant Aggregation Host attraction Aggregation Anti-aggregation
Dendroctonus frontalis
(-)-frontalin a-Pinene trans-verbenol Verbenone endo-brevicomin Myrtenol
Female Host Female Males Males Males and females
Aggregation Host attractant Synergist Anti-aggregation Aggregation Synergist
Dendroctonus ponderosae
þ exo-brevicomin trans-verbenol Myrcene Verbenone
Female Male Host Both sexes
Male attractant Aggregation Host attraction Anti-aggregation
Dendroctonus rufipennis
Frontalin a-Pinene Methylcyclohexanone (MCH)
Female Host Both sexes
Aggregation Host attractant Anti-aggregation
Dendroctonus pseudotsugae
Frontalin Seudenol Methylcyclohexanone (MCH) Camphene a-Pinene
Female
Aggregation Aggregation Anti-aggregation Host attractant Host attractant
Ipsdienol Lanierone Ipsenol Verbenone
Male Male Ips latidens (competitor) Dendroctonus ponderosae (competitor)
Ips typographus
Ipsenol Ipsdienol cis-verbenol trans-verbenol a-Pinene 2-Methyl-3-buten-2-ol
Male Male Male Male Host Male
Aggregation Aggregation Aggregation Aggregation Host attraction Aggregation
Ips acuminatus
Ipsenol Ipsdienol
Male Male
Aggregation Aggregation
Ips calligraphus
Ipsdienol cis-verbenol trans-verbenol
Male Male Male
Aggregation Aggregation Aggregation
Scolytus multistriatus
(-)-a -Multistriatin 4-Methyl-3_heptanol (threo isomer a-Cubenene
Female Female
Aggregation Aggregation
Host
Host attraction
Ips pini
Both sexes Host Host
Repellent Repellent
Forest insect dynamics
21
Table 2.1 (Continued ) Species
Semiochemical
Source
Function
Scolytus scolytus
(-)-a -Multistriatin 4-Methyl-3_heptanol (threo isomer) 4-Methyl-3_heptanol (erythto isomer) a-Cubenene
Female Male
Aggregation Aggregation
Male
Aggregation
Host
Host attraction
Tomicus piniperda
a-pinene
Host
Host attraction
Trypodendron lineatun
( þ )-4,6,6-lineatin
Female
Aggregation
Sources: Gru¨ne 1979, Thatcher et al. 1980, Byers 1987, Borden et al. 1992, Payne et al. 1992, Negro´n et al. 2006, Wood D.L. 1982).
Density Dependent Factors Biotic factors influence populations in direct relation to their density and include: (i) food quantity and quality; (ii) competition, both within and between species; and (iii) the abundance of natural enemies. They can have either negative or positive effects on population numbers and density. Negative Effects The suitability of an insect’s environment is directly affected by numbers of insects present in the environment. As population number and density increase, there is less food available on a per insect basis. Extremely high population densities can consume all of the available food resource before development is completed. This may lead to starvation of some individuals and/or reduced fecundity in others. Higher population densities are also favorable for natural enemies, which have an easier time locating their host. Therefore their numbers will increase. Disease organisms, such as insect viruses, are also favored by high population densities of their hosts, which allow for easy spread of the disease from individual to individual. High population levels and reduced food supplies may also force some of the population to migrate to other locations. These effects on populations are referred to as negative feedbacks. Mechanisms of negative feedback can either be rapid, causing increases in mortality rates of the current generation (rapid negative feedback) or they can adversely affect future generations (delayed negative feedback) (Berryman 1986).
Rapid Negative Feedback Extremely high numbers of defoliating larvae can eliminate available food supply before they finish feeding. Unless larvae can seek new feeding sites, mass starvation and high death rates will result. In addition, populations stressed due to food shortages are more susceptible to disease. These factors can, either alone or collectively, bring about the collapse of an insect population within the current generation. An example is the Douglas-fir tussock moth, Orgyia pseudotsugata, of western North America. This insect can reach population densities of outbreak proportions rapidly and cause complete defoliation of its host trees within a single generation. Outbreaks last from 1 to 3 years, after which a combination of starvation and epizootics of a nucleopolyhedrosis virus (NPV) cause a population collapse.
Delayed Negative Feedback High population densities of some insects may consume most or all of the available food supply but most individuals will complete their life cycle, mate and reproduce. If the population was stressed by insufficient food, it will be reflected in fecundity rates of females and fewer offspring are produced. Moreover, when host trees put out new foliage the following spring, they may contain fewer nutrients, be more fibrous and an overall less desirable food source. Consequently, mortality rates will increase in the following generations and some individuals may migrate to new sites. Moreover, rates of increase of natural enemies, especially during insect outbreaks, are not significant until two to three generations have passed. Host depletion is a significant factor in the collapse of insect populations that kill their hosts, such as
22
Forest entomology: a global perspective
bark beetles. When all of the suitable host material is consumed in an area, the population collapses in the depleted stands but may continue in adjacent stands until the host material is also depleted in those stands.
Positive Feedback High population densities can also have a positive feedback. Higher population densities increase the probability of mating success. Higher rates of mating success result in increased population numbers and densities of future generations. This can result in a continued or sustained high population density until one or more of the negative feedback mechanisms exert an influence on the population. Higher population levels also allow insects to overcome host tree resistance. This is true of the aggressive bark beetles. When populations are low, they are forced to confine their attacks to severely weakened trees, fresh logging residues or windthrow. When populations increase, large numbers of attacking beetles, attracted to host trees by a combination of host attractants and insect produced pheromones, can overcome the resin flow produced by host trees that resist attacks. Therefore, the supply of suitable host material increases as population levels increase.
Density Independent Factors Factors that influence populations independent of their density include quantity and quality of host material, and climatic factors that either favor or adversely affect the ability of insects to survive (Berryman 1986).
Host Quality and Quantity Quality and quantity of available host material can act as either a density dependent or density independent factor in the dynamics of forest insect populations. Many temperate and boreal forests, especially conifer forests in the northern hemisphere, consist of large areas occupied by relatively few tree species. These forests provide a virtually unlimited supply of host material for insects and are subject to relatively frequent outbreaks of bark beetles, wood borers and/ or foliage feeders. For example, large areas of mid- to high-elevation forests in the Rocky Mountains of western Canada and the USA are covered with a mosaic of
even-aged stands of a single species, lodgepole pine, Pinus contorta. Mature lodgepole pine forests, generally stands older than 60–80 years, with a high proportion of large diameter ( > 13 cm) trees with thick bark, provide a virtually unlimited food supply for the development of mountain pine beetle, Dendroctonus ponderosae, outbreaks. Other factors that can alter host quality include stocking levels (number of trees/ha), available soil nutrients, soil moisture or presence of mechanical injury. These are independent of population numbers or density. Changes in the quality of suitable host material or host depletion by insect outbreaks, on the other hand, are a function of population numbers and densities and are, therefore, density dependent factors.
Climate Climate is an important factor that regulates insect numbers and can have both favorable and detrimental effects. Periods of warm, dry weather can be favorable for development and survival of many foliage feeding insects. As temperatures cool or moisture levels increase, insects may cease feeding or become more susceptible to infection by fungi or virus (Fig. 2.4). Late spring frosts can kill large numbers of early instar larvae that have just hatched or emerged from overwintering sites. Moreover, frosts can damage food sources such as foliage. Cold winter temperatures can kill overwintering stages of insects and keep their numbers at low levels. Low winter temperatures, for example, cause extensive mortality of broods of mountain pine beetle, Dendroctonus ponderosae, overwintering under the bark of infested trees. Early autumn or mid-spring temperatures of about 18 C and winter temperatures below 37 C can cause sufficiently high levels of overwintering mortality to influence the course of outbreaks. In areas where low temperatures occur more or less regularly, such as near the northern limits of its natural range or at high elevations, the probability of outbreaks has been low (Amman et al. 1990).
Climate–Host Interactions Climatic events such as droughts, excess precipitation or severe storms can have a profound effect on trees. Drought stresses trees and lowers their resistance to bark beetle and wood borer attacks. Bark beetle outbreaks, for example, often follow extended droughts. When levels of precipitation increase, host resistance
Forest insect dynamics
23
Fig. 2.4 Adult of the bark beetle, Ips typographus, killed by the fungus Beauvaria bassiana. High moisture levels favor fungi and increase their ability to attack and kill insects (southern Bavaria, Germany, photo by Patricia M. Ciesla).
24
Forest entomology: a global perspective
increases and populations of some species of bark beetles decline. Lightning strikes in trees due to summer storms create focal points for bark beetle attacks that could spread to neighboring trees. Severe storms that cause extensive windthrow also create suitable host material for several bark beetle species. They can build up to high population densities in the windthrow and subsequent generations invade surrounding standing trees. Interactions between Insects and other Biotic Agents The activities of one insect population may have a strong influence on host quality for an unrelated insect population. In forest entomology, the classic example is outbreaks of foliage feeding insects that weaken their hosts and increase their susceptibility to attacks by bark beetles and/or wood borers. Defoliator outbreaks in mixed oak forests, by Lymantria dispar and other species, weakens trees and increases their susceptibility to attacks by flat headed wood borers of the genus Agrilus, i.e. A. bilineatus in North America and A. pannonicus in Europe. Outbreaks of conifer defoliators, such as western spruce budworm, Choristoneura occidentalis, and Douglas-fir tussock moth, Orgyia pseudotsugata, in western North America and Siberian silk moth, Dendrolimus sibirica, in Asia are also known to set the stage for increased activity by bark beetles and wood borers. Infection by pathogenic fungi, especially root pathogens, such as Armillaria spp. and Heterobasidium annosum, also reduces host resistance and increases susceptibility to attack by bark beetles and wood borers. Interactions between insects, pathogens, climate and host condition are the cause of a group of complex diseases known as diebacks and declines, which are discussed in greater detail later in this chapter. FOREST INSECT OUTBREAKS Most forest inhabiting insects consistently remain at low levels and are of little or no concern. However, others can go through periods of extremely high numbers and alternating low periods where they are difficult to detect. Insects that undergo periods of high population levels and become damaging are those of greatest concern, especially in natural forests. Several classes of outbreak cycles have been described (Berryman 1986). The mechanisms that favor development of insect
outbreaks are often complex and involve interactions of several density dependent and density independent factors. These relationships are often difficult to identify and there is often considerable disagreement among investigators as to their causes.
Sustained Gradient Outbreaks Some environments have conditions that are consistently favorable for development of high numbers of insects. While population densities may vary somewhat from year to year, these insects are almost always present and, in some cases, damaging year in and year out. An example of a sustained gradient outbreak is that of the larch gall midge, Dasineura rozhkovi (¼ D. laricis) in southern Siberia. This insect infests buds of various species of larch, Larix spp., where it produces an artichoke-shaped gall. The infested buds are killed and affected trees do not produce flowers, cones or seeds during the following year. Infestation levels capable of damaging up to 90% of the buds have been reported. Affected trees are not killed and damaged branches produce new shoots the following year. These provide an ample food source for the next generation of gall midges. This insect has become an important pest in larch seed orchards in the region. Infestation levels are consistently high from year to year and chemical control is required in larch seed orchards to ensure flower production (Isaev et al. 1988). Another insect capable of sustained gradient outbreaks is the western balsam bark beetle, Dryocoetes confusus, found in high elevation forests of subalpine fir, Abies lasiocarpa, in western North America. Some level of activity by this insect can be detected almost every year. A high incidence of root disease, caused by several fungi, stresses these trees and provides a continuous supply of suitable host material for invasion by the beetles. Many insects that are pests of forest plantations tend to remain at high levels because of the virtually unlimited host material provided by large areas of single species, even-aged stands characteristic of most plantations. Examples include white pine weevil, Pissodes strobi, in North America, several species of shoot and tips moths, Rhyacionia spp., in conifer plantations and the mahogany shoot borers, Hysipyla grandella and H. robusta, in mahogany plantations in tropical regions of Africa, the Americas and southeastern Asia.
Forest insect dynamics Cyclic Outbreaks Periodic and, occasionally, predictable oscillations in the abundance of animals, known as population cycles, are one of the most fascinating characteristic of population dynamics. These cycles are not present in all species but occur in a number of forest insects. During peaks, populations may reach extremely high numbers and during low periods the same species may be difficult to locate. In high-elevation forests of European larch, Larix decidua, in the Alps, the larch bud moth, Zeiraphera diniana, has exhibited a high degree of variation in numbers on a more or less regular cycle. Population densities are known to vary from 1 to > 30,000 larvae/ tree. During years of high population density, larvae may cause complete defoliation. Historical records of defoliation indicate that outbreaks have occurred in high-elevation larch forests with a high degree of regularity every 8–9 years. These cycles do not occur in lower elevation mixed species forests where larch is a component. Analysis of the tree ring history of larch forests in the Alps indicates that outbreaks have occurred on an average of once every 9.3 years over the past 1173 years but have not occurred since 1981 (Baltensweiler & Fischlin 1988, Esper et al. 2007). Numbers of the North American Douglas-fir tussock moth, Orgyia pseudotsugata, can fluctuate greatly between generations. A study by Watt (1968) indicates that this species had the most extreme population fluctuations of any of several hundred species of Canadian forest Lepidoptera. There is some evidence that tussock moth populations may possess characteristics of both cyclic and eruptive outbreaks (see following section). Historical records in the Blue Mountains of eastern Oregon, USA indicate that outbreaks occurred at about 9-year intervals (1928–9, 1937–9, 1946–8, 1963–5, 1972–4, 1992–3 and 2000–1) (Brookes et al. 1978, Powell 2008).
Eruptive Outbreaks Some forest insect populations remain at low population levels for many years, then suddenly explode to extremely high levels, often with little or no warning, over large areas of forest and cause extensive damage. These are referred to as population eruptions or eruptive outbreaks. Many examples of eruptive outbreaks of bark beetles and defoliating insects have
25
been documented from the forests of Asia, Europe and North America. The southern pine beetle, Dendroctonus frontalis, undergoes eruptive and highly destructive outbreaks throughout its natural range. While this insect is usually present at epidemic levels somewhere within its range, there are periods at any given location where its levels are extremely low. In Central America, devastating outbreaks occurred in Honduras during the mid1960s and again during the early 1980s. A regional outbreak, which encompassed many pine forests in Central America, occurred from 2000 to 2003. During years between outbreaks, the insect was difficult to detect (Billings et al. 2004). The pine forests of east Texas, USA also have a history of devastating outbreaks of D. frontalis. However, the insect has not been found in east Texas since the early 1990s. A startling and fascinating aspect of eruptive outbreaks is the synchronous buildup of insect populations over large areas within a relatively short time. One scenario or hypothesis is that populations build to high levels in localized areas known as epicenters, where there is an abundance of suitable feeding and breeding sites. Subsequent generations disperse to surrounding areas where they too become damaging. A second scenario is the synchronous buildup of populations over large areas. This was first observed in populations of the Canadian lynx by Australian statistician P.A.P. Moran (Moran 1953). Moran’s hypothesis was that if two or more populations of the same species are influenced by the same density dependent factors, then correlated density independent factors, usually weather induced, would bring the population’s fluctuations into synchrony. This phenomenon is known as the “Moran Effect” (Hudson 1999, Ripa 2000). Spruce budworm, Choristoneura fumiferana, a major defoliator of boreal forests across North America, may remain at low levels for long periods ranging from 30 to 100 years. When outbreaks develop, they typically cover large areas, sometimes millions of hectares. The outbreaks of the 1910s, 1940s and 1970s covered 10, 25 and 55 million ha, respectively. Outbreaks are often associated with heavy crops of male flowers in stands of mature balsam fir, Abies balsamea, the insect’s favorite host. During outbreaks, adults disperse and invade regions as distant as 600 km from their points of origin. Tree ring analysis in eastern Canada, where this insect has been a historical pest, suggests occurrence of outbreaks over the past 200–300 years and indicates that outbreaks occurred more frequently
26
Forest entomology: a global perspective
during the 20th century than previously. Reasons for the increase in frequency, extent and severity may be the result of human activities, including timber harvesting, fire protection and budworm spraying, that favor development of spruce–fir forests over other species in the region and make the forest more prone to budworm attack (Blais 1985). Buildup of spruce budworm populations, initially in relatively small areas, coupled with the mass migrations of adults, suggests that dispersal of large numbers of insects into uninfested areas is a key factor in the dynamics of this insect. However, an analysis of the dynamics of spruce budworm populations in New Brunswick, Canada disputes this. This analysis indicates that local populations tend to oscillate in unison. Local population processes are composed of two parts, a basic oscillation and secondary fluctuations about the basic oscillation. The basic oscillation is the result of several density dependent mortality factors that affect larval instars III–VI and cause increases in budworm numbers. Secondary oscillations are the result of local population buildups supplemented by an influx of female moths dispersing from other areas. These are highly correlated with local meteorological conditions. This study concluded that moth invasions can only accelerate an increase in local populations to an outbreak level when the local population is already in an upswing phase. Therefore, localized increases in spruce budworm numbers brought about by density dependent factors are brought into synchrony by density independent factors such as weather, the so called Moran Effect (Royama 1984). Other analyses of both cyclic and eruptive forest insect outbreaks confirm the role of the Moran Effect in their dynamics. For example, analyses of outbreak patterns associated with six damaging forest insects indigenous to Europe and North America: spruce budworm, Choristoneura fumiferana, forest tent caterpillar, Malacosoma disstria, larch bud moth, Zeiraphera diniana, mountain pine beetle, Dendroctonus ponderosae, and gypsy moth, Lymantria dispar, indicate a spatial synchrony consistent with the Moran Effect (Peltonen et al. 2002).
Declines and Diebacks Declines and diebacks of trees and forests are complex conditions caused by interaction of several biotic and abiotic agents, including insects. While these may not
be considered as outbreaks in the classic sense, many declines are episodic and insects often play a significant role in their occurrence. Causes of declines are difficult to diagnose. In many cases, a scenario or “working hypothesis” is the only realistic diagnosis that can be made. Symptoms associated with these conditions are often similar, regardless of the cause(s) and include growth loss, thin crowns, yellow (chlorotic) foliage, dieback and tree death. Forest decline episodes have been reported worldwide (Ciesla & Donaubauer 1994). The interaction of several biotic and abiotic agents as causes of decline is described by Manion (1991) as an array of predisposing, inciting and contributing factors. Predisposing factors are present in a forest for long periods, cause stress but at a level too low to produce visible symptoms. These include occurrence of large areas of mature forests, which have reduced growth rates and increased susceptibility to diseases such as root pathogens, or exposure to low levels of air pollutants. Inciting factors are short-term events that weaken the already stressed trees and cause growth loss, crown thinning and/or dieback. Examples include defoliator outbreaks, late spring frosts, prolonged drought or excess precipitation. Contributing factors are those that cause death of declining trees and are usually secondary bark beetles and/or wood boring insects that are unable to attack healthy, vigorous trees. Outbreaks of forest defoliators have been implicated as inciting factors in a number of forest decline events. In parts of Europe and eastern North America, for example, a condition known as oak decline has caused extensive forest damage. Outbreaks of several defoliating insects, including Lymantria dispar, Malacosoma disstria and Tortrix viridana, have functioned as inciting factors. Moreover, two species of wood borers, Agrilus bilineatus in North America and A. pannonicus in Europe, have been implicated as contributing factors to oak decline. Several scenarios that involve an interaction of predisposing, inciting and contributing factors have been formulated to explain oak decline on both sides of the Atlantic Ocean (Table 2.2). While Manion’s (1991) scenario considers declines as a disease, Mueller-Dumbois (1983, 1986, 1982) considers them an integral part of forest dynamics and succession. He developed this hypothesis while working with a decline of ohia, Metrosideros polymorpha, in the Hawaiian Islands, USA. While he concurs that declines are a complex of interacting factors, he argues that the primary predisposing cause of decline is the occurrence of even-aged forests (cohorts) growing on marginal soils
Forest insect dynamics
27
Table 2.2 Predisposing, inciting and contributing factors to oak decline in Europe and North America. Factor
Europe
North America (Appalachian Mountains, USA)
North America (Ozark Mountains, USA)
Predisposing factors
Root pathogens, Armillaria spp.
Root pathogens, Armillaria spp.
Fire exclusion
Inciting factors
Extreme cold Drought Insect defoliation
Drought Insect defoliation
Drought
Contributing factors
Wood borer (Agrilus pannonicus) Fungi
Wood borer (Agrilus bilineatus)
Wood borers (Enaphalodes rufulus)
Sources: Haack & Acciavatti 1992, Hartman and Blank, 1992, Gibbs & Grieg 1997, Spencer & Sutton 2001.
that have reached a stage of senescence, a condition he refers to as synchronous cohort senescence. When exposed to an inciting factor, such as drought, excess rainfall or defoliation, they decline. While some trees may recover, others die as a result of attack by secondary insects. A decline of quaking aspen, Populus tremuloides, in western North America seems to fit the scenario proposed by Mueller-Dumbois. This condition, referred to as “sudden aspen decline” (SAD), involved rapid death of aspen climax stands growing at the lower elevation limits of tree growth. These are pure, even-aged clonal stands regenerated from sprouts and therefore have limited genetic diversity. P. tremuloides reaches maturity at about 60 years and many stands in the affected area were in excess of 100 years. During the late 1990s and into the first years of the 21st century, the region was subject to a prolonged drought, which may have incited decline. Several species of secondary wood borers and bark beetles were associated with dying aspens. Most affected stands had a dense ground cover of aspen regeneration, which released as older trees died. Aspen climax stands that lack understory regeneration often have been overgrazed by either wild or domestic ungulates (Author’s observations, Worrall et al. 2008). A common error when diagnosing causes of forest declines and diebacks is that the contributing factor, which is often an insect, is the agent to which the cause is attributed. This is because evidence of secondary insects, such as bark beetles and/or woodborers, is most obvious and is often present for long periods. A classic example is the case of a decline of Acacia nilotica, an important riparian species in the Blue Nile River Basin
of the Sudan. This species grows in pure, even-aged stands in old oxbow lake beds along the Blue Nile and is often regenerated by direct seeding. Initially, decline and mortality of A. nilotica was attributed to a stem infesting wood borer, Sphenoptera chalcicroa, which was present on affected trees in moderate numbers. A later evaluation suggested that other stem boring insects also occurred in the affected trees and were most likely contributing factors of a complex condition. It was hypothesized that the decline may have been due to senescence of even-age forests coupled with almost annual inundations of water and silt in the oxbow lakes from annual flooding of the Blue Nile, which, over time, fill the lakes with silt and render them too dry to support tree growth (Ciesla 1993). Insect outbreaks are the result of many of the same factors that cause decline. A forest may be predisposed to a bark beetle outbreak because of its age and structure. Occurrence of drought, which adds an additional stress to the forest, or mild winter temperatures that increase survival if overwintering insects may serve as the inciting factors. The key difference is that the insect outbreak may be able to infest and kill large numbers of trees even after climatic conditions become more favorable for growth and survival of the host trees simply because of the massive numbers of insects present.
CLIMATE CHANGE AND FOREST INSECT DYNAMICS Global climate change, due to increased levels of carbon dioxide (CO2) and other greenhouse gases in
28
Forest entomology: a global perspective
the Earth’s atmosphere, has emerged as the primary environmental issue of the 21st century. CO2 accounts for less than 1% of the Earth’s atmosphere, yet its presence is critical because it causes thermal radiation from the sun to be reflected back to the Earth’s surface, thus increasing the Earth’s temperature. As the level of CO2 and other greenhouse gases (e.g. methane, carbon monoxide, nitrous oxides) increases, there is more reflection of thermal radiation and temperatures increase. Conversely, if levels of these gases decrease, the Earth’s temperature cools. Without the presence of greenhouse gases, the Earth’s temperature would be about 33 C cooler than it is today and too cold to support life as we know it. Levels of atmospheric CO2 and other greenhouse gases have been increasing gradually since the mid19th century. Many scientists have attributed this to increasing human activities such as burning of fossil fuels (coal, natural gas, oil) for energy, industry and transportation, and release of carbon sequestered in trees due to deforestation and land use change. Concurrently, global surface temperatures have increased by about 0.74 C over the past century. Eleven of the 12 years from 1995 to 2006 ranked among the 12 hottest years on record since 1850, when worldwide temperature measurements began. Consistent with rising global temperatures, episodes of cold temperatures and frosts have declined over the past 50 years. Mountain glaciers have shrunk in size, changes in precipitation patterns have been recorded and there is evidence of intensified tropical cyclone activity since about 1970 (IPCC 2007). Forests as well as insects and other organisms that inhabit forests can respond to a changing climate. Natural ranges of trees and forest ecosystems could shift to higher latitudes or higher elevations as temperatures rise. Insects, with their short life cycles and ability to disperse, could react to a changing climate much more rapidly than their host plants. In an earlier part of this chapter, the effect of short-term climatic fluctuations such as drought, excess precipitation or severe storms on insect population dynamics has already been discussed. The following sections address how insects might be affected by long-term climate change and provide some examples of insects that may have already responded to a changing climate. A comprehensive review of potential impacts of climate change on forest health is provided by Moore and Allard (2008).
Shifts in Natural Ranges and New Host Associations Long-term warming of the Earth’s temperature could cause insects to shift ranges north in the northern hemisphere, south in the southern hemisphere or upwards in elevation. As ranges expand, insects could come in contact with new hosts. Several examples of changes in natural ranges of forest insects, some with new host associations have been reported. In Europe, two species of processionary caterpillars, oak processionary, Thaumetopoea processionea, and pine processionary, Thaumetopoea pityocampa, have been found north of their known ranges. The “traditional” range of the oak processionary is central and southern Europe and Israel. Populations have been detected further north and this insect is now known to occur in Belgium, northern France, the Netherlands, Sweden and the UK (Evans 2007, FAO 2009b). Pine processionary caterpillar occurs in pine forests of the Mediterranean Basin where larvae feed during winter. Studies in France indicate that they can survive in areas that receive 1800 hours of sun/year with an average minimum January temperature of above 4 C (Huchon & Demolin, 1971). There are indications of a northward and upward altitudinal expansion in the range of this species, both in France and Italy (Battisti et al. 2005). During the summer of 2003, the warmest summer in Europe during the past 500 years, this insect was able to expand its range into high-elevation pine forests in the Italian Alps (Battisti et al. 2006). Some bark and ambrosia beetles and their associated fungi are also expanding their ranges. In western North America, walnut twig beetle, Pityophthorus juglandis Blackman, has been indigenous to portions of Arizona, California and New Mexico, USA, and northern Mexico, where it infests stems of several species of walnuts, Juglans spp., and causes occasional twig dieback. Beginning in 2002, infestations were discovered further north, in portions of Colorado, Idaho, Oregon, Washington and Utah, USA, in a new host, black walnut, Juglans nigra. This bark beetle has developed an association with a fungus, Geosmithia sp., which is highly pathogenic to black walnut and causes “thousand cankers” disease. This fungus, vectored by P. juglandis, has killed hundreds of black walnut trees and a potential exists for the beetle and the fungus to spread east into the natural range of black walnut
Forest insect dynamics where its lumber is highly prized for furniture, gunstocks and other wood products (Wood 1982, NAPPO 2008, Tisserat et al. 2009). The ambrosia beetle, Platypus quercivorus, occurs in temperate, subtropical and tropical forest ecosystems across Asia. During the early 1980s, mortality of Quercus mongolica forests was reported from western Japan. This condition was attributed to a fungus, Raffaelea quercivora, which is the fungal symbiont of P. quercivorus. Oaks resistant or tolerant to R. quercivora may have co-evolved under a stable relationship between the tree, fungus and beetle during a long evolutionary process. Q. mongolica may not have been part of this coevolution. The present epidemic may be the result of a warming trend that began in the late 1980s, which allowed the insect to extend its range to more northerly latitudes and higher elevations where Q. mongolica occurs (Kamata et al. 2002, Kubono & Ito 2002). Factors other than climate change that can cause insects to expand their natural ranges include accidental introductions via human trade and travel or climatic anomalies such as high winds that can carry insects over long distances. Provided they find suitable hosts the insects can become established in their new locations.
Additional Generations Ability of insects to undergo additional generations and, therefore, become more damaging, is another potential consequence of a warming climate. This could be especially true for species that already undergo several generations/year. Depending on latitude and elevation, southern pine beetle, Dendroctonus frontalis, may undergo from three to seven generations/year (Thatcher et al. 1980). A warmer climate could cause this species to undergo additional generations, especially in the more northerly portions of its range. The North American spruce beetle, D. rufipennis (Kirby), typically requires 2 years to complete a generation but at lower, warmer elevations it can complete a generation in a year (Holsten et al. 1999). Warmer climates could, therefore, favor a 1-year life cycle, thus increasing the destructive potential of an already damaging species. Some forest defoliators also have the potential to have additional generations in warmer climates. For example, an Asian pine caterpillar, Dendrolimus punctatus Walker, currently has two and a partial third
29
generation/year in east central China and four generations/year in Vietnam (Dao Xuan Truong 1990). Warmer temperatures could potentially increase the number of generations in a given location.
Outbreaks in New Locations Low winter temperatures are known to kill overwintering populations of insects and reduce the probability of outbreaks. This was the case with mountain pine beetle, Dendroctonus ponderosae, near the northern limits of its range or at high elevations. Moreover, in northerly latitudes and high elevations, this insect requires 2 years to complete a generation as opposed to one generation/ year across most of its range (Amman et al. 1990). In 1994, an outbreak of mountain pine beetle developed in the central-interior region of British Columbia, Canada. The outbreak expanded dramatically and by 2007, covered over 10 million ha. In addition, since 2006, this insect extended its range into the Peace River area of northern Alberta. Several factors are believed to be responsible for this outbreak. The predominant forest cover is even-age stands of Pinus contorta, a favorite host of mountain pine beetle. Many of these stands are older than 60–80 years and contain large-diameter, thick-barked trees. In 1910, an estimated 2.5 million ha of British Columbia’s 14.9 million ha of lodgepole pine forests were classified as mature. By 1990, an estimated 8 million ha were classified as mature, a threefold increase. Climate change may have also contributed to the unprecedented extent and severity of this outbreak. A combination of hot dry summers and mild winters caused reduced overwintering brood mortality and increased the potential for a higher portion of insects to complete a generation in 1 year. This increased the insect’s damage potential and allowed it to reach epidemic levels at higher elevations and more northerly latitudes. Climatic data indicate that average minimum temperatures in the affected areas have increased by 2.2–2.6oC over the past 100 years. There is increasing concern in Canada that this insect could spread into areas where the ranges of Pinus contorta and P. banksiana, a component of Canada’s transcontinental boreal forest, overlap. This could provide mountain pine beetle an opportunity to attack a new host and expand its range east across Canada (Logan & Powell 2001, British Columbia Ministry of Forests, Lands and Mines 2003).
30
Forest entomology: a global perspective
In portions of Colorado and Wyoming, USA, another mountain pine beetle outbreak of unprecedented proportions began during the late 1990s. In Colorado, most lodgepole pine forests occur at elevations at or above 2500 m. Milder temperatures at these elevations, coupled with a high proportion of mature forests susceptible to beetle attack, are believed to have incited this outbreak. A mountain pine beetle phenology model predicts the observed northward and upward elevation shift of populations that could undergo one generation/year. This model also indicates that even under a conservative climate change scenario, the area where mountain pine beetle could complete one generation/year will shift considerably north, to the point where it may be maladapted over much of its traditional range. However, a cold tolerance model suggests that winter survival of mountain pine beetle will continue to remain low throughout Canada’s boreal forests and thus limit its eastward spread (Logan & Powell 2001, Regniere and Bentz, 2009).
Outbreaks of Insects Previously Considered Non-Damaging A changing climate could create conditions favorable for occurrence of outbreaks of little known or previously considered innocuous insects. The geometrid, Nepytia janetae, was first described in 1967 and considered a curiosity (Rindge 1967). From 1996 to 1999, an outbreak of this defoliator erupted on 4000 ha of high-elevation ( > 3000 m) forests of Engelmann spruce, Picea engelmannii, and corkbark fir, Abies lasiocarpa var. arizonica, in the White and Pinaleño Mountains of Arizona, USA. Defoliation, in combination with secondary attacks of several species of bark beetles, resulted in extensive tree mortality, especially in the Pinaleño Mountains. This insect has an unusual life cycle for a high-elevation species. Adults appear in late June and July and deposit eggs, which hatch in late September. Larvae feed throughout the winter and following spring. Milder winter temperatures could favor this insect by increasing larval survival rates. Another outbreak occurred in portions of the Sacramento Mountains in New Mexico between 2006 and 1
Personal communication, Ann M. Lynch, USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Tucson, Arizona, USA.
2008 (Fairweather et al. 2006, USDA Forest Service 2007, 2009).1 In the Southern Alps, an outbreak of a web spinning sawfly, Cephalica arvensis, between 1985 and 1992 is believed to be the result of warming temperatures. Sawflies of the genus Cephalica generally have a low fecundity and undergo an extended diapause of several years stimulated by low temperatures at the time of pupation. The outbreak corresponded to a period of high temperatures, low precipitation and severe water stress resulting in reduced mortality, faster development and higher rates of feeding (Marchisio et al. 1994, Battisti 2004). Changes in Population Cycles There is evidence that climate change can alter the cyclic nature of some forest insects. The cyclic nature of larch bud moth, Zeiraphera diniana, outbreaks in the Alps was described earlier in this chapter. These cycles apparently continued despite climatic changes such as the Medieval Optimum, a period of warm temperatures, and the Little Ice Age, a period of cooler temperatures, across Europe. Beginning in 1981, these cycles ended. Absence of outbreaks of this insect, beginning during the late 20th century, corresponds to a period of regional warming that is unprecedented over the past 1000 years (Esper et al. 2007). Forest Insect Outbreaks as Carbon Sources Outbreaks that cause extensive tree mortality reduce carbon uptake by forests and increase CO2 emissions caused by decay of dead trees, a positive feedback for climate change. According to a study by Kurz et al. (2008), between 2002 and 2020, trees killed by mountain pine beetle outbreak in British Columbia, Canada, will release some 270 megatonnes (Mt) of carbon over 374,000 km2 of forest. During the worst year, impacts of this outbreak, in terms of carbon release, will be equivalent to 75% of the average annual direct forest fire emissions from all of Canada during 1959–99. They conclude that massive insect outbreaks can undermine the ability of boreal forests to take up and store atmospheric carbon.
Chapter 3
Forest Insect and Human Interactions
INTRODUCTION
FOREST INSECTS AS PESTS
Trees and other forest vegetation provide food and breeding sites for many insect species. Virtually every part of a tree: foliage, stems, branches, bark, cambium layer, woody tissue, roots, flowers, seeds or cones, is utilized by insects. In doing so, they can compete with humans for food and fiber either because they feed on trees and cause growth loss, loss of seed crops or tree death, or because they serve as vectors of fungi, viruses or other agents that cause plant disease. How we relate to the insects that occupy forests depends on our system of values and needs for the goods and services that forests provide. Humans may view a forest insect as beneficial, damaging or simply innocuous, depending on how that insect affects the forest and, in turn, how that affects the resources we receive from the forest.
When is an insect a pest? The answer lies in the age-old question “If a tree falls in the forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?” A similar question can be asked about insects. “If trees are attacked and killed by insects and there are no humans around to make use of them, are those insect pests?” The answer is no. In the absence of humans, an insect outbreak is simply an ecological event, part of the dynamics of the forest. If, however, the trees under attack are a source of lumber, fiber, food, fuel or other product of human value, the insects in question are, at least by some members of society, considered pests. If the damage they cause is significant, steps may have to be taken to reduce those losses so that humans dependent on these resources may continue to exist in comfort.
Forest Entomology: A Global Perspective, First Edition. William M. Ciesla. Ó 2011 William M. Ciesla. Published 2011 by Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
31
32
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Fortunately, only a small proportion of the insect species found in the world’s forests competes with humans for forest resources. However, that relatively small number can have a wide range of ecological, social or economic impacts. Their damage can be significant, sometimes accounting for millions of US$ in resource losses and pest management costs.
Tree Damage Caused by Insect Feeding or Breeding Many insects feed on foliage of trees and other woody plants. During outbreaks, they can consume most or all of the foliage, sometimes over millions of hectares. Defoliation, especially if it occurs over several successive years, causes reduced seed yields, growth loss, branch dieback and, in extreme cases, tree death. Insects that breed in the inner bark and cambium of living trees cause tree mortality and, during outbreaks, kill trees over large areas. Wood boring insects reduce structural integrity of trees they infest, thus increasing their susceptibility to windthrow. Insects that feed in wood in use can cause structural damage to poles, fences and wooden buildings. Sucking insects, such as aphids and scales, feed on plant juices and heavy infestations can kill stems and foliage. In addition, species that establish colonies and feed on the bark of trees cause drying and cracking of the bark. This creates sites where fungi can invade and cause further damage. Gall making insects can kill branches, reduce cone and seed production and make trees in urban settings unsightly. Shoot and stem infesting insects kill growing portions of trees and cause growth reduction and tree deformity. Repeated infestations of shoot and stem insects can reduce young fast-growing trees to bushy shrubs. Insects that use flowers, cones, nuts and seeds of trees as a source of food or breeding sites can reduce seed yields. Moreover, some forest trees provide edible fruits and nuts, which humans have relied on as a staple food source.
Insects as Vectors of Tree Disease Some forest inhabiting insects have developed a symbiotic relationship with fungi, viruses, nematodes or other agents that cause tree disease. Insects carry spores or
other life stages of disease agents on their bodies, which are transferred to trees during feeding. In some cases, the disease weakens or kills the tree and makes it a suitable site for breeding or feeding by the insect vector. Bark beetles and ambrosia beetles are vectors of wood staining fungi. They carry the spores of these fungi in structures on the thorax of adults known as mycangia and introduce the fungi into the tree during breeding attacks. Many species of non-aggressive bark beetles breed in recently killed trees. This is true of the elm bark beetles, Scolytus multistriatus and S. scolytus. Both species can carry spores of the fungi, Ophiostoma ulmi and O. novo ulmi, which cause Dutch elm disease. When the new generation of adults emerges they feed in branch crotches of elms before seeking breeding sites. If the beetles are carrying spores of the Dutch elm disease fungi on their bodies, they inoculate the feeding sites. After infected trees die, they serve as breeding sites for the same beetles. Ambrosia beetles breed in woody tissue of host trees and have developed a symbiotic relationship with fungi known as ambrosia fungi. Female adults construct a network of galleries and cradles in the woody tissue. During gallery construction, they inoculate the wood with fungus spores. These fungi provide food for developing larvae. They also discolor or stain wood and can reduce lumber quality. In some cases, these fungi are pathogenic, especially if the insect vector should expand its range and attack new hosts. Other wood boring insects also serve as vectors of either fungi or nematodes. Larvae of most wood boring species cannot digest cellulose, which is their major source of nutrition. They live in a symbiotic relationship with wood decay fungi that can break down cellulose. The woodwasp, Sirex noctilio, is associated with a wood decay fungus, Amylostereum areolatum, which is injected into trees by females during egg deposition. This fungus, along with mucus produced by the insect, is pathogenic to species of North American pines that have been planted in the southern hemisphere and has caused widespread tree mortality. Longhorn beetles of the genus Monochamus are found throughout conifer forests of the northern hemisphere where they breed and bore in the inner bark, cambium and wood of host trees. These beetles are vectors of nematodes of the genus Bursaphelenchus. Most species of Bursaphelenchus cause no damage to conifers with which they have co-evolved. However, if they are introduced into a new location, they have the potential of becoming important forest pests. The pinewood
Forest insect and human interactions
33
nematode, B. xylophilus, is native to North America and the cause of a pine wilt disease. It has been introduced into China, Japan, Korea, and, more recently, Portugal, where it has caused extensive tree mortality of indigenous pines. Monochamus larvae become infested with nematodes while feeding in nematode infested trees. The nematodes are spread by adults when they feed on twigs and branches of pines. The nematode “dauerlarvae” emerge from the spiracles of adult beetles during feeding and invade trees via the feeding wound produced by the beetles. When the trees die from the nematode infection, they become suitable breeding sites for Monochamus (Kobayashi et al. 1984, Sousa et al. 2001). Pitch canker, caused by the fungus Fusarium subglutinans f. spp. pini is a pest of pines in southeastern USA, several Caribbean islands and has been introduced into New Zealand and South Africa. This disease was discovered in California, USA in 1986 in native forests of Monterrey pine, Pinus radiata, other pines and Douglas-fir, Pseudotsuga menziesii. Studies in California indicate that several insects are vectors of this fungus including twig beetles of the genus Pityophthorus, the cone beetle, Conopthorus radiatae, a dry twig and cone beetle, Ernobius punctulatus, and three engraver beetles of the genera Ips and Pseudips (Fig. 3.1, Storer et al. 1994). Indigenous vs Introduced Insects Forest insect pests may be either indigenous or exotic. Indigenous insects are an integral part of the ecosystems they occupy and have co-evolved with their hosts and environment. While some indigenous species reach epidemic levels and have a significant effect on forest dynamics, they are subject to checks and balances imposed by natural enemies including parasitoids, predators and disease, host condition and climatic factors. On the other hand, non-native or exotic species, which are introduced from other locations and become established in a new habitat, have the potential to be exceptionally damaging. Their new hosts may lack effective defense mechanisms against these insects and/or the new habitat has few or no natural enemies to help regulate populations. Indigenous Insects Most forests insects that are considered pests are indigenous. In temperate and boreal forests, insect outbreaks are a more or less regular occurrence in natural forests.
Fig. 3.1 Pitch canker, a damaging disease of pines caused by the fungus Fusarium subglutinatus f. spp. pini, is spread from tree to tree by several insects associated with pines (Point Lobos State Reserve, California, USA).
These forests have less species diversity than do tropical and subtropical forests and, under certain conditions, can provide an unlimited supply of suitable host material. Natural forests in both Eurasia and North America are subject to widespread outbreaks of indigenous defoliating caterpillars. Defoliators such as Dendrolimus sibirica, D. spectabilis, Euproctis kargalika and Lymantria dispar asiatica have a history of outbreaks across portions of Asia. In central and northern Europe, indigenous defoliators including Dendrolimus pini, Lymantria dispar, L. monacha and Tortrix viridana cause extensive defoliation. In the Mediterranean forests of southern Europe, the Near East and northern Africa, repeated outbreaks of the processionary caterpillars, Thaumetopoea pityocampa and Th. wilkinsonii, have defoliated pine
34
Forest entomology: a global perspective
forests. Conifer forests across Canada and portions of the USA are subject to periodic outbreaks of the budworms, Choristoneura fumiferana and C. occidentalis. Other significant North American forest defoliators include forest tent caterpillar, Malacosoma disstria, in mixed broadleaf forests and Douglas-fir tussock moth, Orgyia pseudotsugata, in forests of Abies and Pseudotsuga menziesii. These outbreaks have, on occasion, been the subject of massive, and often controversial, campaigns to reduce population levels and subsequent damage via aerial and ground applications of insecticides. Outbreaks of indigenous bark beetles kill trees over large areas. These insects are especially damaging across portions of North and Central America and also Eurasia. In North America, the most damaging species are members of the genus Dendroctonus. Of the 19 recognized species in this genus, 17 are indigenous to the western hemisphere (Wood, S.L. 1982). D. frontalis, for example, is a pest of pine forests from eastern and southern USA, west to Arizona and New Mexico and south through Mexico to northern Nicaragua. Outbreaks of D. ponderosae cause extensive tree mortality in pine forests across portions of western North America. D. rufipennis causes extensive tree mortality in mature spruce forests across all of North America and D. pseudotsugae is an important pest of mature forests of its host Pseudotsuga menziesii. Several bark beetles of the genus Ips are also important forest pests and, during outbreaks, cause extensive tree mortality. Examples include I. acuminatus and I. typographus in Eurasia and I. avulsus, I. confusus, I. pini and others in North America. Other damaging bark beetles include Orthotomicus erosus and Tomicus destruens in the Mediterranean region of Europe, North Africa and the Near East and Scolytus ventralis in western North America. Introduced Insects Insects are opportunistic organisms and will use any method available to disperse and seek new hosts. Humans are effective vectors for long-distance spread of insects, either intentionally or inadvertently, and have been responsible for introduction of many species that have had severe ecological, social and economic consequences when established in new locations. In the USA alone, estimated environmental and economic costs associated with all alien invasive forest species, including insects, is estimated at US$ 2.1 billion annually (Pimentel et al. 2005).
Globally, humans provide opportunities for introduction and establishment of damaging forest insects in two ways. First, international trade and travel or within-country movement of plant products provides pathways for the movement of insects. Second, establishment of plantations of trees exotic to an area provides additional hosts that increase their chances of survival once they arrive at a new location. Some key pathways for movement of forest and tree pests include: .
live plant materials: nursery stock house plants scion material for grafting bonsai; unprocessed logs (Fig. 3.2); lumber, especially lumber containing bark strips; dunnage – wood used to stabilize containers in transit; fuel wood (Fig 3.3).
. . . .
Increased human travel and international trade is causing an alarming increase in rates of insect introduction and establishment worldwide. Wood borers and bark beetles feature prominently among invasive forest insects because they are easily transported inside wood products, wood crating and dunnage where they are concealed and protected. According to records available from the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Animal Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) between 1985 and 2000, bark and ambrosia beetles were intercepted at ports of entry in the USA 6825 times from 117 countries. Overall, 73% of these interceptions were from wooden packing materials (Haack 2003). During the same period, 25 species of wood borers, bark and ambrosia beetles became established and several have caused severe damage. A similar study in New Zealand indicates that between 1950 and 2000, 1500 interceptions of bark and ambrosia beetles, representing 103 species were made (Brockerhoff et al. 2006). A summary of key forest insect introductions, which have affected natural forests worldwide, is given in Table 3.1.
Insect Pests of Forests of Human Origin Forest Plantations Forest plantations occupy about 187 million ha worldwide, or about 5% of the world’s total forest area.
Forest insect and human interactions
35
Fig. 3.2 A variety of wood products, including unprocessed logs, a potential pathway for spread of bark beetles and wood boring insects, await shipment to foreign destinations (Concepción, Chile).
Forests and trees are planted for many purposes. Industrial forest plantations, established for wood and fiber production, account for 48% of the total plantation area. Protective forest plantations, established for conservation of soil and water, account for 26% and the
objectives of the remaining world’s forest plantation area are unspecified. Significant areas of forest plantations are found on all of the world’s continents, except Antarctica. Asia has the largest area of forest plantations, about 116 million ha (FAO 2001).
Fig. 3.3 Transport of fuel wood over long distances poses a hazard of spread of a variety of wood infesting insects (Fort Collins, Colorado, USA).
36
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Table 3.1 Examples of introduction and establishment of damaging forest insects into natural forests, worldwide. Type of damage
Species
Native range
Introduced range
Mode of introduction
Foliar damage
Lymantria dispar Gypsy moth
Eurasia
North America
Hyphantrea cunea Fall webworm Gilpinia hercyniae European spruce sawfly
North America Europe
China, eastern Europe, Japan, Korea, Russia North America
Purposely introduced as a potential source of silk Unknown
Bark and ambrosia beetles
Dendroctonus valens Red turpentine beetle Tomicus piniperda
North America
China
Eurasia
North America
Wood products, crating
Wood borers
Agrilus planipennis Emerald ash borer Anopolphora glabripennis Asian longhorn beetle Tetropium fuscum
Asia
North America
China, Japan
North America, Europe
Wood products and crating Wood products and crating
Europe
Eastern Canada
Wood products and crating
Adelges piceae Balsam woolly adlegid Adelges tsugae Hemlock woolly adlegid Pineus boerneri Pine woolly aphid
Europe
North America
Nursery stock
Asia
North America
Eurasia?
Cryptococcus fagisuga
Europe
Africa, Australia, New Zealand, North America, South America Eastern North America
Unknown, probably live plant materials Nursery stock
Coptotermes formosana Formosan termite
China, Japan, Taiwan
Sucking insects
Wood products insects
Many of the world’s forest plantations are composed of fast-growing exotic trees. Extensive plantations of eucalypts, pines, poplars, teak and other exotic trees have been established in tropical, subtropical and temperate regions of the southern hemisphere (Fig. 3.4). Even in Europe and North America, where native species are preferred, there are some plantations of exotic species. For example in the British Isles, plantations of the North America conifers Picea sitchensis and Pinus contorta ssp. contorta have been established. In the Galicia region of Spain, plantations of the North American Pinus radiata have been established and in Portugal there are extensive plantations of Eucalyptus. Moreover, these plantations are often established with genetically improved seedlings, bred specifically for certain
North America, South Africa, Southeast Asia
Nursery stock? Unprocessed logs
Unknown Wood products and crating
desirable characteristics such as rapid growth, good form or disease resistance. Trees of the genera Eucalyptus and Pinus are the most extensively planted trees and account for 20% and 10%, respectively, of the world’s total forest plantation area (FAO 2001). Forest plantations typically, although not always, consist of extensive, even-aged stands of a single species. These can provide an unlimited food supply for insects. Insects that damage forest plantations can be classified into four categories: . . . .
indigenous insects in plantations of native trees; indigenous insects that have adapted to exotic trees; introduced insects in plantations of native trees; introduced insects in plantations of exotic trees.
Forest insect and human interactions
37
Fig. 3.4 Extensive plantations of exotic trees, such as Pinus taeda, which is widely planted in southern Brazil, can provide a favorable habitat for establishment of damaging exotic insects (Santa Catarina State, Brazil).
Indigenous Insects in Plantations of Native Trees Over much of Asia, Europe and North America, forest plantations tend to be established with indigenous species. These include Cunninghamia lanceolata, Pinus massoniana and Populus spp. in China, Picea abies, Pinus sylvestris and Populus spp. in Europe, Pinus taeda and Pinus elliotii in southeastern USA and Pseudotsuga menziesii in western Canada and the USA. Plantations of trees indigenous to a region are susceptible to their own complex of indigenous insect pests. Moreover, since the plantations provide a large amount of suitable host material, they can favor buildup of insects that would be less damaging in surrounding natural forests composed of several tree species. In China and Vietnam, the defoliating caterpillar Dendrolimus punctatus is an important pest of indigenous pine plantations. In eastern and central China Pinus massoniana plantations are defoliated. In Vietnam outbreaks have occurred in plantations of P. merkusii, often established on steep deforested slopes where they are an important source of lumber, pulpwood, fuel wood and resin (Dao Xuan Truong 1990). A sawfly, Nesodiprion biremis, is one of several species of concern in pine nurseries and plantations in northern Thailand. Nun moth, Lymantria monacha, is a defoliating caterpillar of both Picea abies and Pinus sylvestris in central
Europe. This insect was originally a pest of natural P. abies forests but readily adapted to pine plantations established in this region. In Poland, P. sylvestris plantations are established on low nutrient, sandy soils or abandoned marginal agricultural lands. Widespread outbreaks of this insect occurred in these plantations between 1978 and 1983, and again during the early to mid-1990s. Other defoliating insects of P. sylvestris plantations in Europe include Bupalis piniarius, Dendrolimus pini, Panolis flammea and sawflies, Gilpinia spp. (Speight & Wainhouse 1989, Ciesla 1994). In North America, several pine sawflies and tip and shoot borers such as the Nantucket pine tip moth, Rhyacionia frustrana, and the white pine weevil, Pissodes strobi, are pests of indigenous conifer plantations. Reproduction weevils, such as Hylobius pales, are damaging to pine seedlings in plantations (Drooz 1985). Poplars, Populus spp., are important plantation species in many parts of Asia, Europe and North America because of their rapid growth and excellent wood quality and are subject to damage by a number of insects. In central China, for example, the Asian longhorn beetle, Anopolphora glabripennis, damages older poplar plantations (Schmutzenhoffer et al. 1996, Lingafelter & Hoebeke 2002). Mahogany shoot borers, Hysipyla grandella and H. robusta, are pests of young mahogany, Cedrela, Khaya,
38
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Swietenia, etc., throughout the tropics wherever these trees are grown in plantations and can cause significant growth loss and tree deformity (Browne 1968, Horak 2001, Wagner et al. 2008).
Indigenous Insects That have Adapted to Exotic Trees Many indigenous species have adapted to the presence of a new host in their environment due to establishment of forest plantations with fastgrowing exotics. In Colombia, where extensive plantations of exotic species of Cupressus, Eucalyptus and Pinus have been established, several indigenous insects have found the plantations to be suitable host material. According to one report, 29 indigenous foliage feeding insects are associated with plantations of exotic conifers, including caterpillars of the family Geometridae, walkingsticks and leaf cutting ants. Several geometrid caterpillars, Cargolia arena, Chrysomima semilutearia, Glena bisulcata and Oxydia trychiata, have caused at least moderate levels of defoliation (Rodas P. 1998). In Chile, larvae of Ormiscodes cinnamomea, which normally feed on foliage of broadleaf trees of the genus Nothofagus, have adapted to plantations of Pinus radiata and can defoliate young pines. Ohmart and Edwards (1991) provide a worldwide review of indigenous insects that have found species of Eucalyptus to be suitable host material. This includes 223 species in Brazil, 96 in China, 94 in India, 31 in New Zealand, 105 in Papua New Guinea and 62 on the island of Sumatra, Indonesia. Termites and leaf cutting ants are among the more damaging insect pests. In northern Scotland, the pine beauty moth, Panolis flammea, a defoliator of Scotch pine, Pinus sylvestris, has adapted to plantations of the Pacific Coast subspecies of the North American lodgepole pine, Pinus contorta ssp. contorta, and has defoliated 10–19-year-old plantations (Speight & Wainhouse 1989). A tussock moth, Orgyia mixta, which normally feeds on Acacia and other broadleaf trees in eastern Africa, was discovered feeding on the foliage of Pinus radiata in plantations established in Kenya during the 1950s and has caused localized defoliation in plantations of this species in both Kenya and Zambia (Schabel 2006).
Exotic Insects in Plantations of Native Trees Several cases are known of exotic insects becoming
pests of plantations of indigenous trees. In North America, two species of sawflies indigenous to Eurasia, the European pine sawfly, Neodiprion sertifer, and the European spruce sawfly, Gilpinia hercyniae, have damaged plantations. The European pine shoot moth, Rhyacionia buoliana, is a pest of plantations of indigenous pine plantations in parts of North America (Drooz 1985).
Exotic Insects in Exotic Tree Plantations Exotic, invasive insects introduced and established in plantations of exotic forest trees have the potential to cause extensive and widespread damage. A classic example of an exotic insect in exotic forest plantations is the wood wasp, Sirex noctilio, in the southern hemisphere. Monterrey or radiata pine, Pinus radiata, was first planted in the late 19th century in southern Australia, Chile, New Zealand and South Africa. The excellent growth and form of this tree encouraged widespread planting. These provided raw material for thriving lumber and paper industries, especially in Chile and New Zealand, which each presently have in excess of 1.5 million ha of P. radiata plantations. S. noctilio first appeared in New Zealand during the early 1900s where it was probably introduced via unprocessed pine logs imported from Europe. Plantations established in New Zealand during 1920–30 stagnated because there was no market for small logs from thinning operations. This made the plantations susceptible to S. noctilio and its associated fungus, Amylostereum areolatum. By 1947, extensive tree mortality occurred, primarily in unthinned plantations. S. noctilio subsequently appeared in P. radiata plantations on the Australian island of Tasmania and on the Australian mainland in 1952. In 1980, infestations were detected in South America where this insect damaged plantations of P. elliotii and P. taeda in Argentina, southern Brazil and Uruguay. In 1994, infestations were discovered in P. radiata plantations in the Cape Peninsula of South Africa and in Chile in 2001, again on P. radiata (Ciesla 2003a). Several other insects have been introduced into exotic pine plantations throughout the tropics and in the temperate regions of southern hemisphere (Table 3.2). Eucalypts, which comprise about 20% of the world’s forest plantations, have been victims of introduction and establishment of many insects from Australia. These include several defoliators, sucking insects and wood borers (Table 3.3, Ohmart & Edwards 1991).
Forest insect and human interactions
39
Table 3.2 Examples of introduction and establishment of damaging forest insects into exotic plantations of Pinus worldwide. Mode of introduction
Type of damage
Species
Native range
Introduced range
Bark and ambrosia beetles
Hylurgus lignipera Red haired pine beetle Ips grandicollis
Europe
Chile, New Zealand
North America
Australia
Buprestis novomaculata Sirex noctilio Sirex wood wasp
Europe
Chile
Eurasia
Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, South America
Cinara maritima
Mediterranean Europe, Near East Eurasia?
Argentina, Brazil, Chile Africa, Australia, New Zealand, North America, South America China, Korea, northeastern USA China
Unknown
North America: Canada, USA South America: Argentina, Chile
Unknown
Wood borers
Sucking Insects
Pineus boerneri
Shoot borers
Matsucoccus matsumurae Oracella acuta Loblolly pine scale
Japan
Rhyacionia buoliana European pine shoot moth
Europe
North America
Plantations of Cupressus lusitanica were established in eastern and southern Africa where it was favored because of its rapid growth and excellent form. In 1986, a giant conifer aphid, initially identified as Cinara cupressi, was discovered in Malawi. Infestations spread into neighboring countries and caused extensive tree mortality. In Kenya, where 46% of the forest plantations were composed of C. lusitanica, damage was especially severe. This insect was ultimately redescribed as a new species, C. cupressivora, which is believed to be indigenous to the eastern Mediterranean region of Europe and the Near East. The severe impact of this insect on cypress plantations in Africa has forced foresters to shift to other plantation species, especially eucalypts (Ciesla 1991, Ciesla et al. 1995, Watson et al. 1999). The sawfly, Neomatus oligospilus, has a circumpolar distribution in the northern hemisphere. This species has been introduced into southern Africa, Argentina, Australia and New Zealand, where it has become a pest
Probably wood containing bark strips Unprocessed logs, wood products Unprocessed logs, wood products Unprocessed logs, wood products
Nursery stock
Ornamental pines Infested scion material
of both poplar and willow plantations (Dapoto & Giganti 1994, Ede 2006). Agroforestry Agroforestry, the practice of integrating trees with agricultural crops, has been used in some areas of the world for thousands of years. Examples include interplanting of leguminous trees that have nitrogen fixing bacteria on their roots, growing crops under the shade of trees (understory intercropping) and establishment of plantations of trees to protect crops from wind damage. While some crops may be grown under shade of a natural forest, most agroforestry involves planted trees (Wilkinson & Elevitch 2000). One of the most widely used trees in agroforestry in the tropics is the leucaena, Leucaena leucocephala. This tree is native to Central America, southern Mexico and northern South America. It has an exceptionally rapid growth rate and a wide range of uses. Leucaena psyllid,
40
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Table 3.3 Examples of introduction and establishment of damaging forest insects into exotic plantations of Eucalyptus worldwide Type of damage
Species
Native range
Introduced range
Mode of introduction
Foliar damage
Gonipterus scutellatus Eucalyptus weevil
Australia
Africa, Asia, Europe, North America (California), South America
Unknown
Wood borers
Phoracantha semipunctata, Eucalyptus longhorn borer
Australia
Wood products
P. recurva Eucalyptus longhorn borer
Australia
Africa, Europe, Near East, New Zealand, North America (California), South America Africa, Europe, New Zealand, North America (California), South America
Glycaspsis brimblecombei Red gum lerp psyllid
Australia
Ctenarytaina eucalypti Blue gum psyllid
Australia
Leptocycbe invasa Blue gum chalcid Ophelimus eucalypti Eucalyptus gall wasp
Australia?
Sucking insects
Gall insects
Australia?
Heteropsylla cubana, feeds on new shoots of leucaena and occurs throughout the native range of this tree. In 1983, leucaena psyllid was detected in Florida, USA and a year later, in the Hawaiian Islands. Between 1984 and 1993, the spread of this insect across the Pacific Islands into Asia, Australia and, ultimately, Africa, was of spectacular proportions. Newly established infestations caused extensive drying and dieback of new shoots, growth loss and some tree mortality. The future of this tree in agroforestry was threatened until pest management methods, which emphasized introduction of the pysllid’s natural enemies, were developed (Banpot Napompeth 1994). Urban Forests Trees contribute significantly to the quality of life of people who live in cities and urban areas. They add beauty and harmony to what would otherwise be a
Chile, Mauritius, Mexico, Portugal, Spain, USA (California) South America Ireland, Mexico, Sri Lanka, USA (California) Africa, Asia, Europe, North America Africa, Mediterranean Europe, Near East, New Zealand
Wood products
Infested planting stock?
Infested planting stock?
Unknown Unknown
harsh, cold landscape. They provide shade (Fig. 3.5), filter noise and break up “heat islands” created when the sun’s radiation is absorbed by tall buildings. Even in rural areas, planted ornamental trees along roadsides can add a special character to the landscape (Fig. 3.6). Urban forests are special ecosystems because they are composed almost entirely of planted trees, many of which are exotic. In some parts of the world, especially areas with semi-arid or arid climates, these trees are planted in areas that were previously steppe or desert vegetation. Since many of the trees established in urban forests are exotic, many of the insects that damage these trees are also exotic and have spread to new locations with their hosts. Moreover, in developed countries, where people are able to spend leisure time working in their gardens, they are more aware of insects whose damage may be largely cosmetic (e.g. species of gall insects). Damage by these insects would be largely unnoticed in forests.
Forest insect and human interactions
41
Fig. 3.5 Neem trees, Azadirachta indica, provide welcome shade from the hot African sun (Dogondoutche, Niger).
Several introduced insects have caused significant damage to urban forest landscapes. The smaller European elm bark beetle, Scolytus multistriatus, introduced into North America is a vector of Dutch elm disease, a pathogen with origins in Asia that has killed millions of elm shade trees. In many communities in northeastern and north central USA and adjoining Canada, American elm, Ulmus americana, was the dominant
shade tree. When the disease and its insect vectors arrived, large numbers of elms were killed and many communities lost all or most of their shade trees. Gypsy moth, Lymantria dispar, an introduced defoliator of broadleaf trees, has caused extensive defoliation in urban forests in many areas of eastern USA. Moreover, large numbers of larvae associated with outbreaks are a nuisance in gardens, parks and green belts.
Fig. 3.6 Columnar cultivars of the Mediterranean cypress, Cupressus sempervirens, planted along a rural road add a special character to the landscape of Tuscany, Italy.
42
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Emerald ash borer, Agrilus planipennis, native to Asia, was discovered in 2002 in Michigan, USA. Since its arrival, it has spread into several states and adjoining portions of Canada. This insect is an aggressive tree killer of ash, Fraxinus spp. Since its establishment, millions of ash trees have been killed. This beetle threatens trees in both natural and urban forests, where several species of ash are important shade trees. In Europe, horse chestnut, Aesculus hippocastanum, a tree with a dense crown, dark green foliage and cultivars that produce clusters of flowers in several colors, is a popular shade tree. In 1985, a leaf mining insect, Cameraria ohridella, was observed for the first time on this tree by Lake Ohrid in Macedonia. Heavy infestations produce brown blotches of discoloration on the leaves and are unsightly (Plate 1). In 1989, infestations were detected in Austria and within a few years the insect spread throughout most of Europe. The origin of this leaf miner is still unknown (Deshka & Dimic 1986, Busko 2006, Ivinskis & Rimðait€e 2006). Neem, Azadirachta indica, a tree native to the Indian subcontinent, has been widely planted to provide shade in cities and villages in the SudoSahelian region of Africa. It is one of a few trees that can thrive in the hot, semi-arid climate of western Africa and still produce a crown of dense foliage. This tree provides welcome shade under which local residents work and set up outdoor markets. Oriental scale, Aonidiella orientalis, an insect that feeds on the foliage, petioles and stems of host trees, became established across northern and central Nigeria, where neem is widely planted as a shade tree. Infestations cause a browning of the foliage and thinning of the crown. A long-term strategy to minimize impacts of damaging pests of urban trees and shrubs is to plant as great a variety of species as local conditions will allow. Most biotic pests (insects, mites, fungi, etc.) are relatively host specific. Therefore, should a new pest appear, only a portion of trees would be affected. This was a lesson learned, somewhat painfully, following introduction of the insect-vectored Dutch elm disease into both Europe and North America.
BENEFICIAL FOREST INSECTS
keep the so called “damaging” insects in check. Still others contribute to the breakdown of dead vegetative and animal matter. In addition, a number of insects that feed on forest trees produce direct benefits to humans because they are sources of food or other products of value or have been subjects of curiosity because of their striking appearance or unique habits. Products of Value to Humans Honey Before they were domesticated, honey bees, e.g. Apis mellifera, were forest dwellers. They produce honey, the oldest sweetener known to humans. Honey is produced from the nectar of flowering plants, was originally stored in wax combs in trees hollowed out by decay fungi, and used as a food to feed larvae throughout the year and adult bees during winter. Primitive human societies hunted for trees where bees stored honey to obtain the precious sweetener. Eventually beekeeping, or apiculture, the science and art of raising bees in artificial hives, where honey can easily be harvested, became a major agricultural enterprise. Today, domestic honey bees have become more important as pollinators of agricultural crops than for production of honey. Food Larvae of several forest insects are locally important food sources. Pandora moth, Coloradia pandora, larvae feed on several species of pine in western USA. They are a traditional food source for the Paiute, an indigenous tribe from Nevada and southern California. During outbreaks, larvae are collected as they drop from host trees to the ground to pupate and are roasted and dried on site (Blake & Wagner 1987). In southern Africa, larvae of the mopane worm, Imbrasia belina, feed on the foliage of the mopane tree, Colophospermum mopane, and are an important local food source. Roughly 65% of rural people in southern Africa collect the larvae for subsistence use and 35% sell the dried larvae at rural markets. Some are traded locally and internationally as snacks and canned products (Browne 1968, Ditlhogo et al. 1996, Makhado & Potgeiter 2009). Silk
A vast number of forest dwelling insects have beneficial functions in the forest ecosystem. Many species pollinate plants. Others, such as parasitoids and predators, help
Larvae of the silkworm, Bombyx mori (Lepidoptera: Bombycidae), feed on foliage of mulberry, Morus spp.
Forest insect and human interactions The larvae spin cocoons of silk in which they pupate. Silk is the most luxurious of fibers, with an unsurpassed beauty, luster and softness. It takes dyes well and, although soft, is one of the strongest, most durable fibers known. Silk has been produced commercially in China and India for centuries. The method of silk production was a carefully kept secret and silk became a major item of trade with Europe and the Near East. The “Silk Road” was a major trade route that began in China, passed through central Asia and ended in the eastern Mediterranean region. Silkworm larvae have been domesticated for so long and reared in flat baskets containing mulberry leaves that they have lost their ability to grasp leaves and branches of host trees and could no longer survive in the wild (Fig. 3.7).
43
Several other forest caterpillars are sources of “wild” silk. Wild silk is coarser than cultivated silk, which makes it more durable and practical for clothing. Most wild silk producing species feed on the foliage of broadleaf trees and some have been at least semicultivated. In China, a wild silk known as tussah silk is produced by the tussar moth, Antheraea pernyi. Larvae feed on foliage of oaks, Quercus spp., and are reared on pruned oak shrubs 1.5–2 m high. A related species, A. yamamai, has been cultivated in Japan for over 1000 years (Ciesla 2002a). Dyes and Inks In Mediterranean Europe, a scale insect, Kermococcus vermilis, which infests the stems of several oaks, was highly prized because female adults were a source of red dye used for dyeing wool and silk before other dye sources were available. The Aleppo gall, Cynips gallae tinctoria, produces a gall on oaks in Mediterranean Europe and the Near East. These galls have a high tannic and gallic acid content and have been of commercial importance since the time of ancient Greece for manufacture of inks that did not fade (Ciesla 2002a). Lac In India and neighboring countries, the lac insect, Kerria (¼Laccifer) lacca, which feeds on the stems of broadleaf trees, is known for secretion of a substance known as lac. Lac is scarlet in color and used to dye wool and silk. It is also used as a cosmetic, a medicinal drug, as shellac to coat candies and give fresh fruits and vegetables a glossy finish. The lac insect is cultured in India and to a lesser extent, Myanmar and Thailand where it is considered one of the most valuable of all plant parasitic insects. Biological Control
Fig. 3.7 Silkworms, Bombyx mori, are reared in large baskets for production of silk (Hanoi, Vietnam).
Occasionally, an insect pest in one part of the world may serve as a biological control agent for a noxious plant in another. In western China, Central Asia and Russia, salt cedars, Tamarix spp., are indigenous and planted for shelterbelts and sand dune stabilization. When introduced into southwestern USA, these trees became invasive in riparian areas and displaced native vegetation. Larvae and adults of five species of diorhabda beetles, Diorhabda spp., feed on foliage of salt cedar and
44
Forest entomology: a global perspective
damage plantations established within the natural range of these trees. Diorhabda beetles have been introduced into the USA as a biological control agent for these invasive trees (DeLoach et al. 2003, Hudgeons et al. 2007, Tracy & Robbins 2009).
Curiosities Some forest insects are colorful, eye catching or have habits that arouse human curiosity. Some have even become subjects of various art forms. In North America, the monarch butterfly, Danaus plexippus, the larvae of which feed on milkweeds, Asclepias spp., is a migratory species. In autumn, the large, colorful orange and black butterflies travel thousands of miles to spend the winter in groves of trees along the coast of California or in dense forests of sacred fir (oyamel), Abies religiosa, in central Mexico. The migratory habits of this insect have intrigued amateur and professional entomologists alike and many people have tracked migration patterns to help locate overwintering sites. Overwintering sites in central Mexico were not discovered until 1975 and are now threatened by illegal logging (Plate 2, Brower 1977, Slayback et al. 2007). On the Greek island of Rhodes, the forest of the Petaloides Valley (petaloides is Greek for butterfly) is the site of an annual migration of the moth, Panaxia quadripunctaria. Moths mate in this valley and then depart to lay eggs in other locations in autumn. The valley, with its migrating butterflies, is an important tourist attraction (Petanidou et al. 1991). Other forest insects are favorites among collectors because of their brilliant coloring. Species of morpho butterflies, Morpho spp., of tropical forests in Mexico, Central and South America, with their bright metallic blue or violet wings, are a classic example. In addition, adults of wood boring beetles of the families Buprestidae (metallic wood borers or jewel beetles) and Cerambycidae (long horned beetles) are favorites among insect collectors. Striking colors and patterns on a few forest insects have made them subjects of various art forms. In China, longhorn beetles of the genus Anopolphora, several of which are damaging wood borers, have been the subject of ivory and wood carvings (Lingafelter & Hoebeke 2002). On Roatan Island, Honduras, females of a sawfly, Sericoceros mexicanus, that feed on the foliage of sea grape, Coccoloba uvifera, are the subject of weavings made by backstrap weavers (Fig. 3.8, Ciesla 2002b).
Fig. 3.8 A weaving by traditional backstrap weavers depicts female adults of the sawfly, Sericoceros mexicanus (Roatan Island, Honduras).
FOREST ENTOMOLOGY AS A CAREER Forest entomology can be an exiting and rewarding career and several paths are open to individuals interested in working with forest insects. The following sections outline educational requirements and alternative career paths for people who chose to work in forest entomology or its sister field, forest pathology, the study of forest diseases.
Educational Requirements Many of today’s professional forest entomologists begin their formal education in an undergraduate forestry program, develop an interest in forest insects (or diseases) and decide to specialize. Others take
Forest insect and human interactions undergraduate training in general biology, agricultural science or entomology. Regardless of their undergraduate training, graduate level training in forest entomology leading at least to a Master of Science (MSc) degree is essential. A high proportion of prospective forest entomologists now undertake a program of study leading toward a Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) degree with some continuing on with postdoctoral studies.
Additional Skills In addition to formal training in forest entomology and related courses, other skills are essential. Certainly, a working knowledge of forest entomology’s sister field, forest pathology, is important, especially for those who are frequently asked to diagnose tree pest problems that could be caused by insects, pathogens or other agents. The ability to write is a critical skill. Forest entomologists should document their observations and findings either as reports or formal publications in scientific journals for the benefit of resource managers, professional colleagues or in the popular media to inform the public on the status and management of damaging forest pests. The ability to draw is a desirable skill, especially for those who wish to specialize in insect taxonomy. An interest and skill in photography is essential to document insect damage, the insects themselves and activities undertaken to manage insect pests. Since many of the duties of a forest entomologist involve design of experiments or sampling insect populations, a basic knowledge of statistics is essential. While forest entomologists are not expected to be expert statisticians, they should possess a basic understanding of the science to allow them to work effectively with a statistician to design experiments and develop appropriate protocols for insect sampling. Perhaps most important is the ability to communicate and work effectively with people of other professions and the general public. As specialists, forest entomologists work with forest managers or forest landowners to communicate why an insect may have become a pest and recommend appropriate actions to address forest insect issues. They must also be able to work effectively with the public, including those who may be opposed to taking action against a pest, especially on public lands.
45
Research Research on the biology, ecology and management of damaging forest insects is a critical activity needed to develop appropriate forest insect management strategies and tactics to effectively reduce losses. New approaches for management of forest insects are continuously needed to meet changing needs of forest managers or to develop environmentally friendly pest management tools. Moreover, new pests are continuously appearing and provide additional challenges for forest managers. Therefore, there is a need for a strong cadre of research scientists dedicated to gaining an improved knowledge of damaging forest insects, their interactions with local climate, their hosts and natural enemies and to develop new approaches to forest insect management that can be readily implemented in the field. Universities Most entomology or forestry faculties at universities will employ one or more forest entomologists. Usually the duties of these individuals involve a combination of teaching undergraduate and graduate level courses in forest entomology and related topics, providing guidance to graduate students and conducting research, often funded by external grants. If forest entomologists are employed at a public university, their duties may also involve extension; the process of putting new knowledge obtained through research into practice. Forest Research Institutes Most countries with a significant forest resource base have national forest research institutes. These may be part of the national forest service or function as a separate entity. In large countries with a diverse forest base, such as Canada, China and the USA, the research capacity may be decentralized into a network of regional forest research centers. In other countries (e.g. Austria, Brazil, Kenya, Romania and Tanzania) most or all of the forest research capacity is centralized in a single laboratory. Forest research institutes employ scientists to conduct research on the ecology, management and protection of forests. Forest entomologists and forest pathologists are an integral part of the research team. Research forest
46
Forest entomology: a global perspective
entomologists conduct studies on the biology, ecology and management of forest insects of concern to forest managers and may also provide technical assistance in their management. In addition, forest research entomologists may become part of interdisciplinary teams to address broader, more complex issues such as the overall management of a forest ecosystem. A continuing challenge for forest research is to obtain sufficient funding and support to adequately address the needs of a country’s forest sector. Even in developed countries, support for forest research is often inadequate. Therefore, scientists are unable to travel to the field to conduct studies and the research capacity becomes ineffective and disrespected by the people who desperately need the knowledge generated by these institutes.
Applied Forest Entomology Applied forest entomologists conduct surveys to detect insect pests, delineate areas affected by outbreaks and to obtain clues as to their underlying causes. They provide continuing education to foresters and forest workers in recognizing insect pests and their damage and provide technical assistance to forest managers and forest landowners in forest insect management. They may be called on to provide leadership to suppression projects designed to reduce insect populations and commensurate damage. One of the more challenging tasks required of applied forest entomologists is to put into practice new knowledge or technologies obtained through research. This may involve design and conduct of pilot studies, usually in collaboration with research counterparts, to determine how the new knowledge or technologies will perform under operational conditions.
Government Agencies National, state or provincial forestry departments often employ forest entomologists to conduct forest insect surveys, provide technical assistance and related duties. In the USA, the Forest Service of the USDA has a forest health protection organization staffed with specialists at the national and regional level. In most Forest Service regions, a network of zone or field offices that serve several National Forests, as well as other federally
administered lands (e.g. National Parks, Indian Reservations, Bureau of Land Management, Military Reservations) are staffed with forest entomologists and forest pathologists who work as a team to address forest pest issues. Most state forest services also employ one or more forest entomologists who perform the same duties on state and private forest lands. Since most forested areas in the USA are a mosaic of Federal, state and private lands, it is critical that technical specialists from the USDA Forest Service and state forest services work as partners to address pest issues on lands of mixed ownership. In Canada, applied duties related to forest entomology and pathology rest with the provincial forest services whereas the research function is the responsibility of the Canadian Forest Service. In many countries, the applied aspects of forest entomology and pathology are assigned to foresters who have a special interest and, in some cases, some specialized training in these areas. In Chile, each regional office of Corporacion Nacional Forestal (CONAF), the Chilean national forest service, has a forester specifically assigned to matters relating to forest health. At the national headquarters in Santiago, several staff specialists have graduate level training in forest entomology or forest pathology. Private Industry The two primary private sector employers of forest entomologists are companies that manufacture products to support forest insect and disease management and the forest industry. Companies who manufacture products to support forest pest management (e.g. chemical or biological insecticides, pheromones, insect traps, etc.) may employ forest entomologists as technical representatives whose primary duties are to promote and seek applications and markets for their products and to work with forest managers or public sector forest entomologists to evaluate product efficacy. Forest companies have a need for technical expertise in forest insect management on forest lands they own, which provide raw material for their mills. In many countries, forest companies assign forest insect and disease management responsibilities to an area or district forester as all or part of their duties and rely on expertise available in public resource management agencies such as national, state or provincial forest services, forest research institutes or universities for technical support. However, there are exceptions. In
Forest insect and human interactions Chile, Forestal Arauco, a large forest company, has its own research department, which includes expertise in forest entomology. Moreover, a Chilean consortium of forest companies has chartered Controladora Contra Plagas, a laboratory that mass rears parasitoids for classic biological control of European pine shoot moth, Rhyacionia buoliana, and is staffed by a team of specialists with training in forest entomology and techniques for mass rearing of insects under laboratory conditions (Controladora de Plagas Forestales 1997).
International Opportunities Opportunities also exist for international work in forest entomology. The ability to work effectively in other countries requires an additional skill, the ability to read, converse and write in more than one language. An ideal combination of language skills is English, French and Spanish, with a fluency in at least one and a working knowledge of the other two. The Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) provides technical assistance in all aspects of forestry to its member countries and has a full-time forest health specialist on the staff of the Forestry Department at its international headquarters in Rome, Italy. This post could be filled by either a forest entomologist or forest pathologist. In addition, FAO may employ consultants on a short-term basis to provide technical assistance on matters dealing with forest insects. Other United Nations Agencies such as the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), the United Nations Office of Project Services (UNOPS) or the World Bank (WB) fund international development projects via grants or lowinterest loans. These include forest sector development projects, which may include an element of protection from damaging forest insects and require the services of a forest entomologist, at least on a short-term basis. Many developed countries have organizations that provide bilateral financial and technical assistance to
47
developing countries. Examples include the Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA), The Danish International Development Agency (DANIDA), Gesselschaft für Technische Zussamenarbeit (GTZ) (Germany) and the US Agency for International Development (USAID). The European Union (EU) also funds international development assistance projects. If forest sector development projects are funded by these agencies, they could require technical expertise in forest entomology. National forest research institutes and universities may provide opportunities for short-time technical exchange visits between scientists from different countries for teaching and/or research. The Consultative Group in International Agricultural Research (CGIAR) has a number of international research institutes worldwide including two that address forestry issues: the International Center for Research in Agroforestry (ICRAF) based in Nairobi, Kenya and the Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR) based in Bogor, Indonesia. ICRAF conducts research and disseminates information on appropriate agroforestry technologies and CIFOR is a center for research and global knowledge on forest conservation and improvement of the livelihoods of people in the tropics. Both institutes have dealt with forest health concerns and have need for forest entomologists and forest pathologists, at least on a short-term basis. Finally, there are volunteer organizations, such as the US Peace Corps, which provides opportunities for recent graduates in forest entomology, among many other disciplines, to gain international experience. Beginning in 1967, a team of Peace Corps volunteers worked for several years in Chile and established the groundwork for a viable and sustained program in forest entomology. They designed and taught courses in forest entomology at several universities, conducted surveys in both natural forests and forest plantations and identified a number of insect pests (Billings et al. 1973).
Chapter 4
Monitoring Forest Insects, their Damage and Damage Potential
INTRODUCTION
Is the Insect Present?
Conducting surveys to monitor forest insects and their damage is one of the most critical activities carried out by applied forest entomologists. Data acquired from these surveys keep forest managers and other stakeholders updated on the status of key pest species on a local, regional or country-wide basis. These data also provide, in part, the basis for decisions for or against pest management and the most appropriate strategies and tactics to be taken to reduce losses (see Chapter 5). While the decision to take action against a forest pest lies with the forest manager or landowner, it is the responsibility of forest health specialists, both entomologists and pathologists, to provide the best data possible on which to base these decisions.
This question is directed towards either established or potentially invasive insects. Approaches designed to ensure early detection of exotics include inspections of plant and wood products at ports of entry and/or warehouses and deployment of traps to monitor for presence or absence of the insect(s) in question.
OBJECTIVES Forest insect monitoring is designed to address the following questions.
How Abundant is the Insect? Estimation of insect abundance, or population density, addresses concerns such as: . .
Are populations increasing or decreasing? Is an outbreak imminent?
Insect numbers are typically expressed as the number of life stages (eggs, larvae, nymphs or adults) on a per unit basis such as per branch of a given length, unit of foliage area, bark surface or numbers of insects collected per trap.
Forest Entomology: A Global Perspective, First Edition. William M. Ciesla. Ó 2011 William M. Ciesla. Published 2011 by Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
49
50
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Where are the Insects and their Damage? Occurrence of insects and their damage must be described in a spatial context, either with regard to political units affected (states, provinces, counties), land ownership (government, industrial private, non-industrial private) or landscape features (drainage basins, mountain ranges, vegetation types, elevations). What is the Severity of Damage? Severity of damage caused by insects can be expressed in a number of ways. Tree mortality caused by bark beetles is expressed as number of trees per spot or per hectare in a drainage basin or land ownership class. Foliar injury is usually classified by predetermined intensity classes (e.g. light, moderate, heavy) or area of aerially visible defoliation. Why is the Insect Abundant? Occurrence of an insect outbreak is usually a symptom of a deeper forest health issue. Therefore, it is important to explore site and stand conditions, past forest management practices, climatic anomalies or other factors that may be favoring increases in insect numbers. What is the Potential for Damage by Future Generations of the Insect? This is a critical question if actions are being considered to suppressaninsectoutbreak.Willtheoutbreakcontinueor will populations decline due to natural factors? Sampling methods and prediction models have been developed for many forest insects, usually based on systematic counts of an overwintering stage, such as egg masses, to predict damage during the next growing season. These surveys may be supplemented by observations on levels of disease or parasitism in the population. This information is used to help decide for, or against, direct control and which areas should be treated.
What is the Probability that an Outbreak will Occur? Forest conditions such as stocking levels, age, species diversity, soil conditions or other factors can
predispose forests to forest insect damage. Tree and stand hazard/risk rating systems are designed to assess the probability that an outbreak will occur in the future and the magnitude of loss that can be expected. This information helps forest land managers set priorities for cultural treatments well in advance of an impending outbreak.
When is the Best Time to Apply a Pest Management Tactic? If direct control is undertaken, a pest management tactic must be applied at the time the target insect is most vulnerable. This is especially true of insects that are cryptic and spend much of their life cycle inside a bud, shoot, fruit or cone. Monitoring techniques are available or can be developed to establish when the most vulnerable life stage is present to ensure that pest management tactics are applied at the time of optimum efficacy.
How Effective were the Pest Management Tactics? If one or more pest management tactics are applied to reduce an insect population and its damage, their effectiveness should be evaluated to determine if the objectives of the treatment(s) were achieved. These should consider both immediate effects, such as population reduction, and long-term effects such as reduced levels of defoliation and re-invasion of treated areas from surrounding untreated forests.
SURVEILLANCE AND REPORTING Surveillance and reporting, or field surveillance, is an informal but highly effective process for early detection of potentially damaging insects and other damaging agents in forests. Field surveillance is carried out by local foresters, forest workers or forest landowners who have some familiarity with the agents that could damage their forests. It is done in conjunction with other field work such as layout of timber harvesting operations, fire prevention, trail and road maintenance, wildlife habitat improvement, etc. Should field personnel encounter a pest or notably high levels
Monitoring forest insects, their damage and damage potential of damage, they report the condition to officials with the authority to assess and manage the pest. In the case of a forest company, that responsibility may lie with a district or area forester. On public or nonindustrial private forest lands, the authority may rest with officials in a state, provincial or national forest service or agriculture ministry. Field surveillance is especially effective in areas where local foresters and forest workers cover a relatively small area of forest, where forests are easily accessible or are intensively managed. In order for field surveillance to be effective, forest landowners and workers must recognize pests and early stages of damage. Therefore, periodic training in recognition of signs and symptoms of pests and mechanisms for reporting damage, provided by forest entomologists and pathologists, is an essential part of field surveillance. Leaflets or brochures that describe key pest species are also helpful to raise levels of awareness of forest pests and provide a handy reference to aid in the recognition of pest species and their damage. These materials are typically produced by forest services and/or extension services. The availability of the Internet increases the accessibility of this information and allows for its easy updating as new information becomes available. Timely reporting of pest occurrence to appropriate authorities is critical for field surveillance to be effective. In Canada and the USA, standardized forms are available for reporting of occurrence of damaging pests (Fig. 4.1). Many developing countries lack the capacity to conduct even the most informal of surveillance activities and, even more important, do not have a capacity to identify pest species should they be detected. In 2001, the Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research (ACIAR) initiated a project to increase capacity in forest health surveillance for several South Pacific island nations including Fiji, Samoa, Tonga and Vanuatu. This project uses the term “surveillance” in a broader context than what is described in the above sections. Activities include formal ground surveys in forest plantations and near ports of entry, use of pheromone traps to detect potential insect pests, development of a standardized reporting system, establishment of a capacity for timely identification of potential pest species, and a network to share information (ACIAR 2001, Sanjana Lai 2008).
51
ESTIMATING INSECT NUMBERS Monitoring often involves estimating numbers of insects present to: . . .
predict potential for damage by the following generation; time application of pest management tactics; evaluate the efficacy of pest management tactics.
Obviously, it is physically impossible to count all of the insects on a hectare of forest land or even on an individual tree. Therefore sampling schemes are developed to provide reliable estimates of insect numbers that meet objectives of the monitoring. Development of effective methods of insect population sampling requires knowledge of the insect, its biology and ecology as well as some basic knowledge of statistics and sampling design. Considerations Once the objectives of the monitoring have been identified, the following considerations are addressed in development of protocols for sampling an insect population: . . . . .
sample unit (e.g. tree, branch, bole or trap); sample size; where to sample; when to sample; how often to sample.
Sample Unit The sample unit is the place from which the sample is drawn, such as: . . . .
. .
branches of a given length on which numbers of eggs, egg masses or larvae are counted; sections of bark of known area on which counts of bark beetle life stages are made; leaves on which counts of aphids or scales are made; branches containing cones or fruits to estimate levels of infestation by insects that attack reproductive structures; entire trees (seedlings or saplings); an area of soil or litter surface to estimate numbers of cocoons or pupae.
Selection of the sample unit for a given insect is defined by a combination of the biology and habits of
52
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Fig. 4.1 USDA Forest Service, forest pest detection report form used by field personnel to report insect and disease occurrence.
Monitoring forest insects, their damage and damage potential the insect and where it is practical to draw the sample. Branch samples are often used for estimating population densities of defoliators. They are also effective sample units if the insect deposits its eggs on branches. Sections of bark of known size are logical sample units for estimating population densities of bark beetles or for insects that deposit their eggs or egg masses on the bark surface of host trees. Use of whole trees as a sample unit is limited to small trees, usually less than 3 m tall and where insect densities are relatively low or are concentrated in colonies. Insect numbers are expressed relative to the sample unit. Population densities of defoliators, for example, are expressed as numbers of eggs, egg masses or larvae per branch of given length or per unit area of foliage surface. Numbers of bark beetles are expressed as insects per square meter of bark surface. Densities of aphids or scales can be expressed as insects or insect colonies per leaf or per branch of known size. In cases where whole trees can serve as the sample unit, insect densities are expressed as numbers of egg masses, larvae or colonies of larvae per tree. Sample Size
Optimum sample size can be determined as follows (Freese 1967): n¼
t2 s E2
Where: n ¼ optimum sample size (e.g. number of trees to sample) t ¼ value of t at n 1 degrees of freedom s ¼ standard deviation of the mean E ¼ level of precision desired (e.g. x egg masses/tree). Use of this formula is illustrated using field data on numbers of egg masses of pine processionary caterpillar, Thaumetopoea wilkinsonii, on young trees less than 3 m in height in Pinus brutia plantations in northern Cyprus (Ciesla 2003b). The objective of this work was to develop a method to predict defoliation by this insect using egg-mass counts to serve as a basis for decisions for, or against, control. Egg-mass counts were made on each of 30 randomly selected trees from each of two plantations. The following statistics were computed for each plantation and for the two plantations combined (Table 4.1): .
Sample size is a key consideration when designing survey methods to estimate population numbers. Obviously, taking too large a sample is inefficient and involves unnecessary work while under-sampling presents a risk of an inaccurate population estimate. Sample size is a function of the variability of the population, expressed as the standard deviation of the mean, and the desired precision of the estimate.
53
. . . .
average number of egg masses/tree; range of egg masses/tree; standard deviation; standard error; 95% and 99% confidence limits.
Optimum number of sample trees needed was determined for each plantation and the two plantations combined for the following levels of precision:
Table 4.1 Thaumetopoea wilkinsonii egg-mass densities and sampling errors for trees <3 m in height from two Pinus brutia plantations on the Diorios/Tepebasi Forest, northern Cyprus, December 2000. Statistical parameter Sample size (number of trees) Mean (egg masses/tree) Range (egg masses/tree) Standard deviation Standard error 95% confidence limits (egg masses/tree) 99% confidence limits (egg masses/tree) Source: Ciesla 2003b.
Plantation 1
Plantation 2
Combined
30 5.97 0–24 5.77 1.05
30 6.87 0–45 8.53 1.56
60 6.42 0–45 7.24 0.93
2.15
3.18
1.91
2.59
3.83
2.30
54 2 1 2 1
Forest entomology: a global perspective egg egg egg egg
When to Sample
masses 95 out of 100 times; mass 95 out of 100 times; masses 99 out of 100 times; mass 99 out of 100 times.
Samples must be taken at the time the life stage of interest is present in the field. If the objective of sampling is to predict population levels and subsequent damage, then the life stage of interest will, most likely, be the overwintering stage. In the case of forest defoliators, this may be eggs, egg masses, diapausing larvae or pupae. Therefore, sampling is done during autumn or winter. If, on the other hand, the objective of the sampling is to properly time an insecticide application, then sampling should coincide with adult flight, egg hatch or emergence of larvae from overwintering sites. In Poland, monitoring of population levels of the nun moth, Lymantria monacha, during an outbreak that occurred in 1990s involved two stages of sampling at different times of the year. Initial surveys to predict potential damage were conducted during the adult flight period. Daily counts of female adults landing on permanent sample trees in pine stands were made by district foresters. Stands were classified into four levels of damage for initial planning of suppression projects. The final decision for or against spraying was based on counts of larvae made on felled sample trees (one tree/ 50 ha) or on trees banded with an adhesive material. These counts were made after egg hatch and immediately prior to treatment (Ciesla 1994).
The number of sample trees is based on average eggmass densities, their variability and practicality. In the above example, the best alternative was to attempt to achieve a precision of 2 egg masses 95 out of 100 times. This resulted in a required sample size of 33 trees in plantation 1 and 72 trees in plantation 2. The larger optimum number of sample trees in plantation 2 is attributed to the wider range of egg-mass numbers per tree (0–45) The combined data show an optimum sample size of 52 trees per plantation (Table 4.2). Sample Location The decision as to where to sample is usually a compromise between where the insect’s life stage of interest is located and the physical limitations of obtaining the sample. Trees are tall and insects are often located in the upper crowns, which are difficult to reach. Options may include cutting trees (destructive sampling) to reach the insects or removal of branches using pole pruners. If insects are concentrated in the upper crown, as is the case with many defoliators, use of pole pruners may limit sample acquisition to mid- or lower crown, which, hopefully, will be representative of the population. Specialized equipment, such as such as Swedish ladders, designed to climb into the crowns of tall trees, or hydraulic lift vehicles may be required to reach tree crowns and collect samples to estimate infestation levels of insects affecting seeds and cones.
Sample Frequency Another important consideration is how often to sample. If the objective of sampling is to predict damage, a single sample to estimate numbers of flying adults, egg masses
Table 4.2 Optimum sample sizes for estimating numbers of pine processionary caterpillar egg masses per tree in northern Cyprus on trees < 3 m in height based on data collected from two plantations in the Diorios/Tebebasi Forest, northern Cyprus, December 2000. Plantation
Mean egg masses/tree
Standard deviation
Number of trees to sample 2 egg masses
1 2 Combined Source: Ciesla 2003b.
5.97 6.87 6.42
5.77 8.53 7.24
1 egg mass
95% confidence limits
99% confidence limits
95% confidence limits
99% confidence limits
33 72 52
56 121 87
133 290 209
222 485 349
Monitoring forest insects, their damage and damage potential or diapausing larvae may be sufficient. However, if the objective is to estimate the efficacy of a treatment, a series of samples may be required. For example, if a new insecticide is tested against a defoliator, a pre-application (pre-spray) sample is normally taken to estimate the baseline population level. This is followed by one or more post-treatment samples. Interval of the post-treatment samples depends on the nature of the material being evaluated. If the material is a relatively fast-acting, contact insecticide, a post-treatment sample interval of 7 and 14 days may be appropriate. If, on the other hand, the material is a slower acting biological agent, such as the bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis, which must be ingested by the larva to be effective, then a longer post-treatment sampling protocol, such as 14 and 21 days, may be more appropriate. Sampling to determine if a parasitoid or predator released as a biological control agent has become established and is having an impact on the target insect may require periodic sampling at, or near, release sites over a period of several years. If the objective of the sampling is to estimate infestation levels and damage over the course of a growing season, then a sample may have to be taken several times during the season. For example, in a study to estimate infestation levels and resultant losses of Chinese chestnut in orchards in XinXian County, Henan Province, China, 30 sample trees were randomly selected in each of four orchards. Sample trees were examined three times during the growing season: early July, mid-August and early September, coinciding with the chestnut harvest. During the initial July sample period, chestnut burrs occurring on each sample branch were marked with colored cloth and during the July and August sample periods, damaged burrs were recorded, and, to the extent possible, classified as to causal factor, but were not removed from the trees. In early September, coinciding with harvest, all chestnuts were removed from sample trees. Counts of the number of chestnuts per burr were made and the condition of each chestnut was recorded. These data were summarized in a life table (Wang Gaoping et al. 2001).
Prediction of Population Levels and Damage Sampling plans designed to predict either numbers of insects, their damage or to use as a basis for pest management decisions may take one of two forms: . .
Sampling plans have been developed for many forest insects to meet a variety of objectives. Several are summarized in the following sections.
prediction methods based on a fixed sample size; sequential sampling.
Fixed Sample Size Sampling plans based on a fixed sample size are appropriate if samples taken in the field must be counted in the laboratory. An example is a plan developed to predict defoliation by larch casebearer, Coleophora laricella, a needle mining species native to Europe and introduced into North America, where it has damaged native tamarack, Larix laricina and western larch, Larix occidentalis. This insect overwinters as an instar III larva enclosed in a larch needle attached to spur shoots on branches. Number of overwintering larvae on spur shoots is a logical sample unit if areaor region-wide forecasts of defoliation for the following growing season are desired (Fig. 4.2). A sampling plan based on counts of overwintering larvae per 100 spur shoots was developed for forecasting defoliation by this insect in portions of western Montana, northern Idaho and northeastern Washington, USA. Preliminary studies indicated that 38 branch samples of 100 spur shoots each per sample station would provide estimates of the number of overwintering larvae with a sample error of 20% of the mean 9 out of 10 times, based on an average population density of 41 overwintering larvae per 100 spur shoots. Therefore, four branch samples, each with a minimum of 100 spur shoots, were removed from each of 10 trees per sample point. The number of overwintering larvae on each branch sample was counted in the laboratory. Defoliation was rated on trees the following spring using a matrix that weighted defoliation estimated for each of three crown levels: 1, upper crown; 3, midcrown; and 5, lower crown. Numerical ratings were also assigned to each of five classes of damage: . . .
Applications
55
. .
0 2 4 6 8
negligible – no visible discoloration; light – up to 25% of the foliage discolored; moderate – 26–50% of the foliage discolored; heavy – 51–75% of the foliage discolored; severe – >75% of the foliage discolored.
Numerical defoliation ratings for each crown level were obtained by multiplying the damage rating by the crown level. Tree defoliation rating was the sum of the
56
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Fig. 4.2 Overwintering larvae of larch casebearer, Coleophora laricella, attached to spur shoots of western larch, Larix occidentalis, are a sample unit that can be used to predict defoliation by this insect.
three crown level ratings and ranged from a low of 0 to a high of 72 (Table 4.3). Sample point defoliation rating was the mean of the 10 sample trees. Regression analysis was used to define the relationship between overwintering larvae and defoliation rating. This analysis indicated that the quadratic equation: y ¼ a þ bx þ cx2 Where: y ¼ defoliation index x ¼ number of overwintering larvae per 100 spur shoots provided the best fit for the data. A regression model: y ¼ 4.015 þ 0.4419x – 0.00104x2 was computed with
a coefficient of determination (r2) of 0.763 for 2 years of data (Table 4.4) (Ciesla & Bousfield 1974). Sequential Sampling Sequential sampling is a technique in which the sample size is flexible and counts of the attribute of interest are accumulated. As a sample is drawn and counted, a decision is made to either classify the population or continue sampling (Figs 4.3 & 4.4). This approach is best suited for sampling of insect populations and their damage when counts of the attribute of interest can be made in the field. It minimizes sampling time and effort where population densities are clearly high or low. In places where densities are moderate, or highly variable, more samples are required before a population is classified (Waters 1955).
Table 4.3 Matrix used to compute a larch casebearer damage index for three crown levels and five defoliation classes Crown level
Upper Mid Lower
Damage class Weighting factor
Negligible (0)
Light (2)
Moderate (4)
Heavy (6)
Severe (8)
1 3 5
0 0 0
2 6 10
4 12 20
6 18 30
8 24 40
Source: Ciesla & Bousfield 1974.
Monitoring forest insects, their damage and damage potential
57
Table 4.4 Overwintering larch casebearer population density and predicted defoliation based on the quadratic equation y ¼ 4.015 þ 0.4419x – 0.00104x2. Number of overwintering larvae/100 spur shoots (x)
Defoliation index (y)
Predicted defoliation
0–8.9 9.0–26.9 27.0–44.9 > 45.0
Negligible Light Moderate Heavy
0–11.5 11.6–60.4 60.5–136.5 136.6–236.75* *Highest observed population density. Source: Ciesla & Bousfield 1974.
potential damage as either light ( 3.3 egg clusters/ tree), moderate (8.3–14 egg clusters/tree) or severe ( 26 egg clusters/tree). Dominant or co-dominant jack pines, Pinus banksiana, are selected at a sample point, felled and all egg clusters occurring on the needles are counted in the field. A maximum of 10 trees per site are felled and egg clusters counted. Counts are compared with the sequential table (Table 4.5) to decide if the area can be classified or to continue sampling. If no decision can be made after 10 trees, then trees with a cumulative egg cluster count of less than 51 are considered as light, 51–188 as moderate and more than 188 as severe (Tostowaryk and McLeod, 1972). Sequential sampling has also been used for purposes other than damage prediction. In Brazil, a binomial (infested/not infested) sequential sampling plan has been developed to estimate infestation levels and tree mortality in pine plantations caused by the wood wasp, Sirex noctilio. Three sample lines are established in a
Cumulative number of insect life stages
A challenge associated with development of sequential sampling plans is that the spatial distribution of the population of interest (e.g. binomial, negative binomial or Poisson) must be determined. Most epidemic insect populations have a contagious or negative binomial distribution, where the occurrence of one individual of the insect of interest increases the probability that other individuals will be found. Negative binomial distributions are defined by a parameter “K,” which is difficult to compute. Despite these challenges, a number of sequential sampling plans have been developed for forest insects to predict damage and establish a basis for decisions for or against control and several are summarized by Fettig et al. (2001). Procedures for development of sequential sampling plans for forest insects are detailed by Waters (1955). A sequential sampling plan was developed in Canada to predict damage by the Swaine’s jack pine sawfly, Neodiprion swainei, a defoliator of pine forests in both Canada and the north central USA. This classifies
Fig. 4.3 General model for a two-class sequential sampling plan.
Heavy
g
in
pl
m
ue tin
on
sa
Moderate
C
ling
amp
es tinu Con
Light
Number of samples (n)
Fig. 4.4 General model for a three-class sequential sampling plan.
58
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Table 4.5 Sequential sampling decision table for Swaine’s jack pine sawfly in Canada based on the number of egg clusters per tree Number of trees
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Cumulative number of egg clusters
Light
– – 2 7 12 17 22 27 33 36
– – – – – 44 49 54 59 64
– – – – – 49 68 86 105 124
83 102 120 139 158 177 196 214 233 252
Continue sampling
Moderate
Continue sampling
Severe
Source: Tostowaryk & McLeod 1972.
plantation and 40 trees are examined in each line. Each tree is tallied as infested or uninfested. The minimum sample size is 48–57 trees, depending on the desired sample error. Maximum number sample size is 200–250 trees. A sequential sampling plan has also been developed in Brazil to estimate the level of parasitism achieved by the nematode, Deladenus siricidicola, on Sirex noctilio (Penteado et al. 1993, 2008).
.
for contact insecticides and 14 and 21 days for materials that must be ingested (e.g. the bacterial insecticide Bacillus thuringiensis). Count all live larvae and buds on each branch sample in the laboratory. Larval densities were initially expressed as larvae per 100 buds and later as numbers of larvae per branch. Both larval density and percent population reduction for each post-spray sample period was computed (Flavell et al. 1978, 1979).
Evaluation of Treatment Effects TRAPS AND SEMIOCHEMICALS Sampling plans have been developed to evaluate efficacy of chemical and biological insecticides against forest insects. In 1975, a team of forest entomologists and statisticians developed a set of protocols for testing aerial applications of insecticides under semi-operational conditions (pilot control projects) against western spruce budworm, Choristoneura occidentalis, in western USA. These tests usually consist of one or two materials or dosage rates. The protocols consist of the following: . . .
.
.
Knowledge of the chemical ecology of insects (see Chapter 2) has provided a number of tools to monitor for occurrence of damaging forest insects and their abundance. Traps baited with semiochemicals (either pheromones, host attractants or a combination of the two) are used to monitor for: . .
Establish three blocks/treatment and three untreated checks. Size of each block is 1200 ha. Select 25 clusters of three trees each. Trees should be relatively open grown, 11–18 m in height and full crowned. For each sample period, remove one branch about 45 cm long from each of the four cardinal directions (north, east, south and west) from each tree using pole pruners. Sample periods are: pre-spray – 24 h prior to application and post-spray – 7 and 14 days after treatment
. .
presence of invasive insects detection of increases in numbers of insects timing of treatments effectiveness of treatment tactics.
Trapping systems have several advantages for insect monitoring. They are relatively easy to deploy, maintain and collect. Moreover, cost is low.
Presence or Absence of Invasive Insects Several trapping systems using either semiochemicals or trap trees have been developed for early detection of
Monitoring forest insects, their damage and damage potential
59
potentially invasive insects, including defoliators, bark beetles and wood borers. Gypsy Moth Disparlure, a synthetic version of the sex attractant of both the European and Asian forms of gypsy moth, Lymantria dispar, is a powerful attractant for male moths. Traps baited with disparlure are widely used throughout areas not known to be infested by this insect in Canada and the USA. Disparlure baits are deployed in delta traps coated with a sticky substance during the adult flight period, collected at the end of the flight period and examined for presence of male moths. Traps are usually deployed in urban areas, initially at a low trap density of one trap/mile2 (one trap/2.59 km2). If male moths are trapped, trap density is increased the following year to 32–64 traps/2.59 km2. This level of trap density is known as delimitation trapping and is designed to define areas in need of eradication. Following treatment, trap densities are maintained at 32–64 traps/2.59 km2 for 1 year. If no male moths are trapped, density is reduced to 16 traps/2.59 km2 the following year. If results continue to be negative, trap density is reduced back to one trap/2.59 km2 the third year following treatment (British Columbia Ministry of Forests and Range n.d.). Trapping for early detection of gypsy moth is also conducted in other countries. For example, disparlurebaited traps are used to monitor for possible introduction of Asian gypsy moth in the Pacific Island of Fiji (Sanjana Lai 2008).
Bark Beetles and Wood Borers Traps baited with a combination of pheromones and host attractants have been used with varying degrees of success for detection of exotic bark beetles. The most widely used trap for bark beetle monitoring is the Lindgren funnel trap. These consist of a column of funnels that collect beetles as they fly into the attractant source located at the bottom of the trap. They are available in 4, 8, 12 and 16 funnel sizes (Fig. 4.5, Lindgren 1983). In the USA, the USDA Animal Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) has worked with several state departments of agriculture to survey for exotic bark beetles as part of the Cooperative Agricultural Pest Survey. In most cases, Lindgren funnel traps, baited
Fig. 4.5 Lindgren funnel trap baited with bark beetle aggregation pheromones is a valuable tool for detection, assessment and mass trapping of several bark beetles (photo by Jose Negrón, USDA Forest Service).
with various combinations of ethanol, turpentine and commercially available bark beetle lures, such as IpslureÒ or ChalcopraxÒ, have been used. Traps are deployed near ports of entry, warehouses that receive goods from foreign countries packed in wooden crating and disposal sites for wooden crating and dunnage from international sources. A joint USDA Forest Service/APHIS Rapid Detection and Response Pilot Project for Exotic Bark Beetles was initiated in 2001 using Lindgren funnel traps baited with several combinations of semiochemicals, including a-pinene and ethanol and ethanol and a threecomponent aggregation pheromone for the Eurasian bark beetle, Ips typographus. This project resulted in the initial detection of banded elm bark beetle, Scolytus schevyrewi, in the USA in 2003 (Negrón et al. 2005). In New Zealand, a semiochemical-based early warning system was initiated in 2002 for detection of exotic bark beetles and wood boring insects. Approximately
60
Forest entomology: a global perspective
580 funnel traps baited with a-pinene and ethanol, b-pinene and ethanol or frontalin and ethanol or ipsdienol were placed around the country at high-risk sites, including major seaports, international airports and forests near high-risk sites. Additional traps were used to compare these lures with unbaited control traps to assess their effectiveness in catching established exotic bark beetles and wood borers, and to assess the effects of placing traps at varying distances from host trees. Over 27,000 beetles were captured between 2002 and 2004, but no new insect establishments were detected (Brockerhoff et al. 2006). In Anhui Province, China, a system was developed as part of an FAO/UNDP forestry development project to monitor the spread of pinewood nematode, Bursaphelenchus xylophilus, by trapping its vector, the sawyer beetle, Monochamus alternatus. The trapping system used a-pinene/ethanol baits placed in flight traps. The objective was to collect beetles ahead of the known area of nematode infestation to determine if local populations of sawyer beetles carried the nematode. Traps were established near log decks, sawmill sites and forested areas where high numbers of M. alternatus would be expected to occur (Fig. 4.6, Author’s observation). Trap trees stressed by injection of a weak herbicide are used to monitor the occurrence and spread of infestations of the wood wasp, Sirex noctilio, in pine plantations wherever this insect has become established outside of its natural range. This insect is attracted to stressed trees for egg deposition and, if populations are present in an area, they will readily attack the herbicide-treated pines.
Population Monitoring Defoliating Insects Traps baited with sex attractant pheromones are used to monitor population numbers of forest defoliators including: the spruce budworms, Choristoneura fumiferana and C. occidentalis, in North America; the processionary caterpillars, Thaumetopoea pityocampa and Th. wilkinsonii, in the Mediterranean Basin, and Dendrolimus punctatus in Asia (Fig. 4.7). One of the most widely used and successful semiochemical-based defoliator population monitoring schemes is the Douglas-fir tussock moth Early Warning System (DFTM–EWS). This defoliator has a cyclic
Fig. 4.6 A flight trap baited with a-pinene and ethanol is used to collect specimens of the sawyer beetle, Monochamus alternatus, to determine if they are infected by pine wood nematode, Bursaphelenchus xylophilus (Anhui Province, China).
pattern of outbreaks, which tend to occur in any one location at 7–10 year intervals (see Chapter 2). DFTM–EWS is used throughout much of insect’s range in western North America. The objective of the DFTM–EWS is to detect population increases indicative of impending outbreaks and identify areas where more intensive larval or egg-mass sampling is needed to delineate areas to be considered for direct control. Each EWS plot consists of five traps placed along a line at 23-m intervals and at least 23 m away from roads in stands dominated by Douglas-fir. Traps are placed near the ends of branches about 2.75 m above ground on relatively open-grown host trees. Traps are modified 2.25-litre milk cartons cut to a delta shape
Monitoring forest insects, their damage and damage potential
61
conducted to predict defoliation and to identify areas that should be treated (Ravlin et al. 1991).
Bark Beetles
Fig. 4.7 An entomologist inspects a trap baited with the female sex attractant of the pine caterpillar, Dendrolimus punctatus, to monitor population levels of this defoliator (Anhui Province, China).
with interiors lined with adhesive and, within the trap, a small pellet containing the synthetic pheromone is suspended above the adhesive by a long pin. Traps are deployed between late July to mid-August and collected the following mid-October to early November. Plots are evenly distributed over the host type at a density of at least one plot for every 2115 ha of susceptible host type. Capture of a minimum of 25 male moths per trap serves an “early warning” of an impending outbreak. During over 20 years of monitoring, this system provided advance warnings of 1–3 years for seven of nine outbreaks (Daterman et al. 2004). In eastern USA, numbers of male gypsy moths, Lymantria dispar, caught in pheromone traps are used to identify areas where egg-mass surveys should be
A practical and reliable system to monitor population trends of the southern pine beetle, Dendroctonus frontalis, using pheromone traps has been implemented throughout the range of this bark beetle in southeastern USA. The South-wide SPB Prediction System was developed by the Texas Forest Service and involves monitoring numbers of southern pine beetle and its major predator, the clerid beetle, Thanasimus dubius. Three Lindgren funnel traps baited with the southern pine beetle aggregation pheromone, frontalin, and a rapid-release container of turpentine are established in each county or National Forest to be surveyed. The traps are monitored for 4 consecutive weeks during spring, at peak bloom of flowering dogwood, Cornus florida, which coincides with southern pine beetle long-range dispersal flights. Insects are collected weekly. Average number of southern pine beetles/trap/day and the ratio of southern pine beetle to T. dubius is used to predict population trends for the remainder of the year. This system has proven to be practical and reliable for forecasting general trends (increasing, declining or static) and expected infestation levels (low, moderate, high or outbreak) throughout the region. It serves as an early-warning system that predicts pending outbreaks and/or collapses of southern pine beetle populations (Billings & Upton 2008).
Regeneration Weevils Weevils that breed in roots of freshly cut conifers and feed as adults on seedlings (e.g. Hylobius spp., Pachylobius picivorus) are strongly attracted to resin odors of host trees. Several traps have been developed to estimate population levels of these largely nocturnal insects. Radial discs, ranging in size from 12 to 18 cm in diameter and about 5 cm thick cut from green pines and placed overnight in areas where population level estimates are needed are an effective survey tool in southeastern USA. An average of eight adults per trap have been collected in areas such as recently burned or harvested areas where weevils would be expected to congregate and as many as 42 adults have been collected in a single trap (Ciesla & Franklin 1965). Other trapping techniques include use of pine billets treated with insecticide or polyvinyl chloride (PVC) pitfall traps
62
Forest entomology: a global perspective
baited with a 5 : 1 ethanol : turpentine mixture (Rieske & Raffa 1993, Fettig & Salom 1998). Timing of Treatments Pheromone traps are an effective means of timing applications of chemical or biological pesticides. In forestry, this approach is used primarily in intensively managed sites such as nurseries, seed orchards or in urban forests. Pheromones have been used to determine need for and timing of pesticide application for several coneworms of the genus Dioryctria in seed orchards (Turgeon et al. 1994, Meeker 2004). In addition, sex pheromones of several wood boring species of clearwing moths, including lilac ash borer, Podesesia syringae, have been identified and synthesized. Traps baited with the pheromone are deployed 2 weeks prior to adult flight. Insecticides are applied 10–14 days after the first males are captured in traps. Weekly monitoring of insects in traps during the flight period may indicate need for a second treatment if the flight period is extended (Nielsen 1978). REMOTE SENSING Remote sensing, defined as “collection and interpretation of data based on measurement of electromagnetic energy reflected or emitted from objects of interest,” has broad applications in natural resource assessment. Damage caused by many forest insects, especially those that cause tree mortality, defoliation or foliar discoloration, is visible from long distances (Plates 3–6). This lends itself to assessment using various remote sensing technologies ranging from aerial observation (sketchmapping), aerial photos, airborne video and satellite imagery (Ciesla 2000). Remote sensing provides the best set of tools to record the location and intensity of forest insect damage in a spatial context.
application. For example, maps showing the location of outbreaks can be obtained simply by flying over an infested area in a small aircraft and mapping damage. If more detailed data are required, such as estimates of numbers of infested trees and/or timber volume affected, then aerial photos or high-resolution satellite imagery, in combination with a small ground sample, may be needed. Biology of the Target Insect Knowledge of the target pest, its damage and when damage is most visible is critical to ensure that reliable data are acquired. Moreover, individuals responsible for data interpretation must be familiar with the target insect, its damage and vegetation types affected to recognize and accurately classify the damage. Acquisition of Ground Data Use of remote sensing for assessment of forest damage does not eliminate need for some level of field or ground data. Data obtained by remote sensing should be supplemented by ground data to verify that the information obtained via remote sensing is in fact true. Depending on the technique used and the data requirements, acquisition of ground data may range from informal ground checks to establishment of a subsample of ground plots linked to the remote sensing imagery using multi-stage sampling.
Design Remote sensing often involves sampling of large areas of forest with aerial imagery in combination with a small ground sample. Several multi-stage sampling techniques have been developed for natural resource management applications that can be applied to assessment of damage by forest insects and other agents. These are reviewed by Ciesla (2000).
Considerations Effective use of remote sensing for assessment of forest insect damage requires careful consideration of several factors. Data Requirements Data needed to meet the objective of the survey should define the remote sensing tools used for a specific
Aerial Forest Health Surveys Aerial forest health surveys or aerial sketchmapping is a widely used technique for assessment of forest damage caused by insects and other agents. It consists of one or two trained aerial observers flying in a high-wing aircraft who record the location of areas affected by forest damage on topographic maps, usually of a scale of
Monitoring forest insects, their damage and damage potential
63
Fig. 4.8 An aerial observer briefs a pilot on a mission to map damage caused by cypress aphid, Cinara cupressivora (Nairobi, Kenya).
1 : 100,000 or, more recently, using touch-screen computers (Fig. 4.8). This technique has been used to map damage caused by forest insects and other agents as early as the 1920s in Canada and the USA. In the USA, systematic annual aerial forest health surveys were begun in 1947 with the passage of the Federal Forest Pest Control Act and are a cooperative effort between USDA Forest Service and state forest services. In the USA, approximately two thirds of the forest area is flown annually and between 2002 and 2006, an average of 1.8 million km2 of forest was surveyed each year (Klein et al. 1983, Ciesla 2000, McConnell et al. 2000, Johnson & Wittwer 2008). In Canada, aerial forest health surveys are conducted by provincial forest services. In New South Wales, Australia, aerial surveys are conducted over Pinus radiata plantations by Forest New South Wales, primarily for assessment of tree mortality caused by two introduced insects: the wood wasp, Sirex noctilio, and the bark beetle, Ips grandicollis (Carnegie et al. 2005, 2008). During the 1990s, aerial surveys were used in Kenya to map tree mortality in Cupressus lusitanica plantations caused by cypress aphid, Cinara cupressivora (Ciesla et al. 1995). Aerial sketchmap surveys have also been conducted in southern Brazil, initially for
detection and assessment of tree mortality in pine plantations caused by the woodwasp, Sirex noctilio, but also for other applications (Malheiros de Oliviera et al. 2006). In central Mexico, aerial sketchmap techniques have been used to locate overwintering colonies of the monarch butterfly, Danaus plexippus, in Abies religiousa forests (Slayback et al. 2007). Advantages of aerial sketchmapping are that large areas of remote forest, an average of 80,000–85,000 ha/ day can be surveyed in a relatively short time and at a low cost (less than US$ 0.025/ha). In addition, resultant data are available to forest managers and other stakeholders within 1–2 days. A disadvantage is that data are subjective and their accuracy depends on the experience and skill of individual aerial observers, weather and light conditions and other factors. Uses of Aerial Forest Health Survey Data The primary purpose of aerial forest health surveys is to provide data on location and intensity of forest damage in a timely fashion so that forest managers can plan and conduct appropriate management activities. These data can be used to plan and conduct timber salvage operations or conduct additional surveys to predict next
64
Forest entomology: a global perspective
season’s damage and begin planning for appropriate pest management actions, including drafting of environmental impact analyses. Another use of aerial forest health survey data is to report regional and/or country-wide pest conditions and for development of historical databases on occurrence of outbreaks of major forest pests. These data are a source of information on trends and cyclic patterns of outbreaks and may be helpful for prediction of future outbreaks. Aerial forest health survey data, stored in a geographic information system (GIS), have been used to evaluate long-term effects of insecticide treatments against at least one forest defoliator; western spruce budworm, Choristoneura occidentalis. An evaluation of the effects of insecticide treatment directed against this insect from 1982 to 1992 on subsequent defoliation was conducted in Oregon and Washington, USA. For each treatment, the extent and severity of defoliation was calculated for the treated area and a set of four nested rings surrounding the treated area for up to 8 years (3 years prior to treatment, the year of treatment, and 4 years following treatment). Insecticide treatments coincided with reduced percentages of defoliation during the year following treatment. However, the percentage of defoliation usually returned to pre-treatment levels by the second year, and severity of defoliation in treated and adjacent untreated areas was nearly identical (Sheehan 1996). Operational Parameters Aerial surveys are flown at an average altitude of 300–450 m above the terrain at an average airspeed of 160–190 km/hour. Flights are generally made between the hours of 08:00 and 14:00. A variety of small aircraft are used for aerial surveys. The Cessna 182, 185, 205, 206 and 210 high-wing aircraft are most widely used. Other aircraft that have been used include the twin engine Partnavia P-68, the Aero Commander 500 and the DeHaviland Beaver. Helicopters have also been used effectively but are considerably more expensive to operate than fixed-wing aircraft. Timing of aerial surveys is critical to their success. Aerial surveys must be conducted when damage is at its peak. In addition, phenomena that could mask damage signatures, such as fall coloring of broadleaf trees, and some conifers (Larix, Metasequoia, Taxodium), in temperate zone forests, should be at a minimum. Over most of western North America, aerial forest health surveys are
conducted during July and August. This time frame effectively captures damage caused by most bark beetles and foliage feeding insects. Aerial observers must be able to: . . .
read maps and know their precise location at all times; recognize aerial signatures of vegetation types and forest damage; have normal color vision and little or no susceptibility to motion sickness.
Roughly 100 hours of flight experience are needed before an aerial observer becomes proficient. Two mapping techniques are used. In mountainous terrain, contour surveys are conducted where the flight path conforms to drainages and ridges in the survey area. In level or gentle terrain, grid surveys of straight flight lines, either east–west or north–south and spaced at about 5-km intervals are flown (Fig. 4.9). Damage types most frequently mapped include defoliation, foliage discoloration, tree mortality or mechanical injury, such as windthrow caused by severe storms. Integration of New Technologies Technologies that have been integrated into aerial forest health surveys over the past 20 years include GIS, global positioning systems (GPS), use of touchscreen computers for data recording and automated flight following (AFF). These have improved observer safety, made data recording more efficient and provide for improved analysis and storage of the data.
Geographic Information Systems (GIS) The ability of GIS to store, analyze and retrieve spatial data on the status of forest insect and disease outbreaks was first evaluated in the USA by the USDA Forest Service during the late 1970s and early 1980s. This technology became operational during the late 1980s and today is used country-wide to store information on the status of major forest pests. GIS is used to develop historical records of pest outbreaks and record changes in their status from year to year. In addition, GIS allows for integration of data on location of pest outbreaks with other resource information such as vegetation type, elevation, slopes, aspect, etc. GIS maps, showing the location of insect and disease damage by year, are now available on the Internet for anyone to study (e.g. www. fs.fed.us/r2/resources/fhm/aerialsurvey/).
Monitoring forest insects, their damage and damage potential
65
Fig. 4.9 Aerial forest health survey flight patterns. A: contour flight over mountainous terrain. B: grid flight over level or rolling terrain with east-west flight lines.
66
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Global Positioning Systems (GPS) The network of orbiting satellites known as GPS, which can be used to triangulate the position of a person, a vehicle, ship or aircraft, anywhere on the Earth’s surface, has revolutionized navigation. This technology has proven to be a valuable tool in the conduct of aerial forest health surveys. GPS receivers, installed in survey aircraft, can be used to locate the starting and ending points of a day’s aerial survey. During grid surveys, the starting and ending points of each flight line can be entered in the GPS receiver and used to help the aerial survey pilot keep the aircraft on the flight line. Touch-Screen Computers Touch-screen computers, linked to GPS receivers, have replaced paper maps for recording location and intensity of forest damage (digital aerial sketchmapping). Products such as the Motion Tablet or Hammerhead, loaded with mapping software (geoLink) and linked to a GPS receiver via the Bluetooth wireless technology, are widely used. An advantage of these systems is that recorded data can be converted into shape files, which are entered directly into a GIS without additional scanning or digitizing. In addition, the system display shows the survey aircraft’s locations. This eliminates the need for aerial observers to continuously locate themselves relative to terrain features (Schrader-Patton 2002).
Automated Flight Following In western USA, where a high proportion of forest land is administered by federal agencies such as the Forest Service (Department of Agriculture) or the Bureau of Land Management (Department of Interior), a protocol has been in place for the survey pilot to advise a local fire dispatch center via radio of the aircraft’s location at 15-minute intervals. AFF triangulates the aircraft’s location using a GPS receiver and transmits these data to a communications satellite, which, in turn, transmits the aircraft’s location to the local dispatch center every 2 minutes. If a signal is not received, a warning message is transmitted. AFF significantly reduces response time in case the survey aircraft develops a problem and must make an emergency landing in a remote area. Aerial Observer Training As mentioned previously, aerial observers require about 100 hours of in-flight training before they become
proficient. Guides for recognition of aerial signatures of forest damage are available that cover most forest ecosystems in the USA (Ciesla 2006, Ciesla et al. 2008). In addition, in the USA, aerial observers are required to attend aviation safety training every 3 years. Training consists of on-line courses and a 1-week classroom session that qualify an observer to manage a fixed-wing aviation program. In-flight training of new aerial observers has become more formalized. Initially, an aerial observer trainee flies with an experienced aerial observer. Later, the trainee receives “front seat” training and has the opportunity to work with the pilot to direct the survey. Hours of aerial observer experience are logged in a manner similar to how a pilot’s flight hours are logged. Aerial Photography Of all of the remote sensing tools currently available, aerial photographs, acquired either by film or digital cameras, provide the highest resolution imagery. Aerial photos have been used for assessment of forest damage where more detailed information is needed than can be acquired from aerial forest health surveys (Ciesla 2000). Photographic Parameters Image Types Forest damage caused by insects or other agents usually first appears as a change in color of tree crowns. This is difficult, if not impossible, to resolve on panchromatic (black and white) film. Therefore, either color or color infra-red (CIR) aerial films or digital images are used for assessment of forest damage. True color aerial images record information in colors as seen by the human eye and, for this reason, are relatively easy to interpret. CIR film is a false color film, sensitive to visible light and the near infrared region (to 0.9 m) of the electromagnetic spectrum. This film has been of value in forestry and other natural resource applications because, in combination with a medium yellow (minus-blue) filter, it can easily penetrate atmospheric haze and there is a greater contrast between certain vegetation types, such as conifer vs deciduous broadleaf forests than can be seen by the human eye or on a true color image. Deciduous broadleaf forests often appear as a bright red color and conifers appear dark red brown or magenta (Plate 7). Color films are available that can be processed to either negatives for
Monitoring forest insects, their damage and damage potential production of photo prints or to positive transparencies. For forest health applications, color transparencies have been preferred because they have higher resolution than prints. Digital camera systems have largely replaced film cameras for virtually all photographic applications. Digital aerial mapping cameras, both small and large format, are now available and widely used. Some digital aerial mapping cameras will record data in both the visible and near infrared regions of the electromagnetic spectrum from whichbothnaturalcolorandCIRimages.Therefore,aerial films have become obsolete. As of December 2009, Eastman Kodak, the sole producer of CIR aerial film, ceased production of this product. Formats A variety of image formats have been used for aerial photographic assessments of forest damage. These include: . . .
small format – 35 or 70 mm aerial photos; mapping format – 230 mm; panoramic format – 115 965 mm.
The most widely used film for forest damage assessment has been the standard 230 mm mapping format.
Scales A range of photo scales have been used with varying degrees of success. These range from 1 : 500 to 1 : 2000 for small format photography, from 1 : 4000 to 1 : 8000 for mapping format photography and from 1 : 30,000 for high-resolution, panoramic format photos. A photo scale of 1 : 8000 is generally considered optimum for forest damage assessments where individual tree crowns must be resolved.
Applications Aerial images have been used with varying degrees of success for a number of diverse applications relating to detection and assessment of damage caused by forest insects.
Inventory of Bark Beetle Damage Multi-stage sampling techniques, using a combination of aerial photos and a small ground sample, have been developed to inventory losses incurred by bark beetle outbreaks (Ciesla 2000). These techniques provide data on:
. . .
67
location and area affected; number of trees infested; timber volume affected.
One approach is three-stage sampling where the area affected is stratified by aerial sketchmapping. This area is then sampled with aerial photo stereo pairs or triplets, of a scale of 1 : 4000, 1 : 6000 or 1 : 8000, on which the number of dying or “fading” trees is counted. A small subsample of the aerial photo plots is examined on the ground to correct the aerial photo sample and obtain data for volume loss estimates. Another approach involves a two-stage sample where aerial photo sampling is done over a forested area, the aerial images are interpreted and a small ground sample is taken and used to correct the aerial estimate using statistical procedures such as double sampling with regression. In Germany, complete aerial photo coverage with CIR film has been acquired over the Bavarian National Park, an area of about 24,500 ha, to map areas of windthrow and subsequent damage to adjacent stands caused by the bark beetle, Ips typographus.1 Mapping Forest Defoliation CIR aerial photos, taken from a flying height of approximately 18,300 m, have been used effectively to map defoliation of broadleaf forests by gypsy moth, Lymantria dispar, in eastern USA. This work was done during the mid1980s when defoliation occurred over several eastern states to an extent that was too large an area to be mapped by conventional aerial forest health surveys. The aircraft used to acquire the images was a National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) ER-2 reconnaissance aircraft. The aerial photos were acquired over a 2–3-day period over a multi-state area when defoliation was at its peak, interpreted monoscopically and the location of defoliated areas was transferred to topographic maps (Acciavatti 1990).
Assessment of Forest Pest Management Tactics Both color and CIR aerial photos have been used to assess effectiveness of pest management tactics directed against forest insects. CIR film has been used to assess the degree of foliage protection achieved by aerial application of both biological and chemical insecticides 1
Information in this paragraph is based on an interview with Rainier P€ohlmann, Director of Public Affairs, Bavarian National Park, 12 October 2009.
68
Forest entomology: a global perspective
directed against forest defoliators (Plate 8). Color aerial photos have been used to demonstrate effectiveness of thinning pine forests to prevent attacks by the mountain pine beetle, Dendroctonus ponderosae (Ciesla 2000).
confusing. One set of generic definitions, provided by the General Accounting Office (GAO) of the USA, is used in at least one set of guidelines for risk/hazard assessment and is presented below (Schmitt & Powell 2005). Risk Assessment
Other Remote Sensing Tools Other remote sensing tools, such as airborne video, radar, lidarand dataacquired fromairborne satellites, areusedin natural resource management and have been used to some extent for assessment of forest insect damage. To date, their applicability for assessment of forest insect damage is limited by their resolution. Imagery from airborne satellites such as Landsat TM or SPOT can resolve cumulative damage caused by several years of bark beetle activity butcannot separate current mortalityfrom that of previous years. Use of these approaches has, to data, been largely experimental. Moreover, the probability of a satellite occurring over an area of forest damage when the damage signature is at its peak and skies are sufficiently cloud free to capture the damage is low.
Risk assessment is the process of evaluating natural hazards, such as disturbance agents, including insect outbreaks, the probability of a hazardous event occurring and the resulting consequences or losses if the event occurs. Hazard Hazard is defined as a potential event, such as fire, insect or disease outbreak, and the conditions causing it. Hazard-rating systems are used to determine infestation or infection potential and where the heaviest damage is expected based on certain biotic and abiotic conditions. The terms hazard and susceptibility are often used interchangeably.
RISK/HAZARD RATING
Risk
In the previous chapter the point was made that outbreaks are a function of host condition, climate and the dynamics of the insect. Risk/hazard rating examines underlying causes of outbreaks, especially host condition, and attempts to predict the probability of an outbreak occurring in the near future. Some of the variables considered in rating susceptibility to insect outbreaks include:
Risk is the likelihood or probability that an event will occur. In the context of insect risk assessment, for example, risk depends on both stand hazard and insect population densities. The terms risk and vulnerability are used interchangeably.
. . . .
species composition; age; stocking levels; elevation/latitude.
Risk/hazard rating schemes provide forest managers with an opportunity to set priorities and undertake management actions, such as thinning and timely harvesting, to create conditions less hospitable for development of outbreaks well in advance of their occurrence.
Susceptibility Susceptibility is the probability of an infestation occurring, based on stand characteristics (species composition, tree density, etc.). Vulnerability Vulnerability is the probability that a tree or stand will suffer damage. Note that susceptibility reflects the influence of forest or stand conditions on hazard, whereas vulnerability refers to the probability that damage will occur.
Definitions Much of the terminology associated with risk/hazard rating of forests for their susceptibility to pest damage has been used interchangeably and may be somewhat
Values Values are the losses that might be incurred should the damaging event occur. In a human context, social or
economic values might be lost or compromised during an outbreak. In an environmental or ecological context, wildlife habitat and other values could be either damaged or improved as a result of an outbreak. Risk/Hazard Rating Systems In North America, risk/hazard rating systems have been developed for both forest insects and diseases. These range from relatively simple approaches used to rate individual stands without the aid of a computer to regional, even country-wide, systems that integrate capabilities of mathematical models, geographic information systems and forest inventory databases. In the USA, many of these systems have been compiled in a database known as the Forest Insect and Pathogen Hazard Rating Systems Database by the USDA Forest Service, Forest Health Technology Enterprise Team and can be downloaded from the Internet (www.fs.fed.us/ foresthealth/technology/haz_rating_database.shtml). Mountain Pine Beetle in Lodgepole Pine, USA Amman et al. (1977) describe a simple procedure for estimating susceptibility of lodgepole pine forests in the Rocky Mountains of western USA to mountain pine beetle, Dendroctonus ponderosae. This is based on the following assumptions: .
.
.
Stands occurring at low elevations and lower latitudes will have a climate more suitable for overwintering brood survival and, therefore, are subject to greater losses during outbreaks. Trees of large diameters (> 20 cm) have a thicker phloem and will produce more brood than smaller diameter trees. Stands age 60 years and older tend to have a higher proportion of large-diameter trees.
This system uses tree diameter, stand age and location to predict risk or susceptibility to mountain pine beetle damage. Numerical ranks are assigned to each variable. Rankings for each variable are added to provide a stand rating from 3 (low) to 27 (high) (Fig. 4.10, Table 4.6). It rates stand hazard or susceptibility but does not consider the presence or absence of a mountain pine beetle population in or near the stands being evaluated. Therefore, it does not consider risk or vulnerability in the context of the presence or absence of the insect in question.
Elevation (thousand feet)
Monitoring forest insects, their damage and damage potential
12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3
69
Lo Mo w (1) de <2 5% Hig rate (2) mo h( r 25 3) -50 tality >5 % 0% mo mor ta r ta lity lity
40
42 44 46 48 Latitude (degrees)
50
Fig. 4.10 Interaction of elevation and latitude on stand susceptibility to mountain pine beetle, Dendroctonus ponderosae (redrawn from Amman et al. 1977).
Mountain Pine Beetle in Lodgepole Pine, Canada A two-step mountain pine beetle risk index has been developed in Canada that considers both stand characteristics and beetle pressure. The first step involves computation of a susceptibility index, which considers several stand variables: (i) proportion of susceptible pine basal area; (ii) age; and (iii) location (latitude and elevation). Beetle pressure index is a function of the size and proximity of a mountain pine beetle population that may affect the stand being rated. The final risk index combines the susceptibility and beetle pressure indices and provides a continuous scale index for any lodgepole pine stand. Since the mountain pine beetle is dynamic, the authors caution that the beetle pressure index should be recalculated at regular intervals (Shore & Safranyik 1992). Multiple Pest Agents, Eastern Oregon, USA Schmitt & Powell (2005) describe a procedure that provides stand-level hazard ratings for six individual insect and disease pests and three pest groups in the Blue Mountains of eastern Oregon, USA. This system makes use of stand-attribute data that can be obtained from interpretation of aerial photographs and use of stand-level databases. Seven stand attributes are used in various combinations to rate susceptibility of stands to each of these pests or pest groups. The ratings are done on a form, without a computer (Fig. 4.11, Tables 4.7 & 4.8).
70
Forest entomology: a global perspective Table 4.6 Stand hazard or susceptibility rating system for mountain pine beetle in lodgepole pine stands in the Rocky Mountains, USA (see also Fig. 4.10) Elevation/latitude
Age (years)
Average diameter breast height (dbh) (cm)
< 60 (1) 60–80 (2) > 80 (3)
< 18 (1) 18–20 (2) > 20 (3)
High (1) Medium (2) Low (3) Source: Amman et al. 1977.
Southern Pine Beetle Hazard Regional Rating System, Southeastern USA
Plain, Piedmont and Mountains. Each model was constructed at a 30-m resolution within a GIS environment using a set of forest parameter layers that include basal area, diameter, stand density index and a multicriteria modeling framework (USDA Forest Service 2006a).
A regional map of hazard of southern pine beetle, Dendroctonus frontalis, has been developed by USDA Forest Service for southeastern USA. This map is a compilation of eight mathematical models run across 15 ecological zones. Southern pine beetle hazard is defined as “degree of vulnerability of a stand to southern pine beetle, based on stand and physiographic attributes.” In several of the models, southern pine beetle presence was considered a precursor to hazard and separate susceptibility and vulnerability models were constructed. Models were developed from variations of existing southern pine beetle hazard rating systems developed for three major physiographic regions of southeastern USA: the Coastal
Pine Needle Gall Midge Hazard Rating System, South Korea A tree damage risk assessment system has been developed for pines damaged by the pine needle gall midge, Thecodiplosis japnensis, in South Korea. This system is based on the use of artificial neural networks. These are non-linear data modeling tools used to model complex
STAND SUSCEPTIBILITY RATING FORM (worksheet for one stand) Stand No._____________________________ T. _________ R. _________ Sec.__________ Observers ____________________________
Location _______________________________ Aerial Photos ___________________________ Date __________________________________
SCORES FOR RATING FACTORS INSECT OR DISEASE AGENT Defoliators Douglas-fir beetle Fir engraver Spruce beetle Bark beetles in ponderosa pine Mountain pine beetle in lodgepole pine Douglas-fir dwarf mistletoe Western larch dwarf mistletoe Root diseases
A _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____
B _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____
C _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____
D _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____
SUSCEPTIBILITY RATING* E
F
_____ _____ _____ _____ ____ _____ ____
TOTAL _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ _____ ______
LOW
≥5 ≤6 ≤7 ≥9 ≤6 ≤ 10 ≤5 ≤3 ≤4
MODERATE
HIGH
6-8 7-10 8-10 8-10 10-12 11-13 6-7 4-6 5-6
≥9 ≥ 11 ≥ 11 ≥ 11 ≥ 13 ≥ 14 ≥8 ≥7 ≥7
* This section shows how the total score (Total column) can be used to assign a categorical rating (low, moderate, high). Fig. 4.11 Worksheet used for stand-level hazard rating for multiple pest agents in the Pacific northwest region of the USA (Schmitt & Powell 2005).
Monitoring forest insects, their damage and damage potential
71
Table 4.7 Stand attributes and their corresponding database fields used to rate stand susceptibility to insect and disease pests in the Blue Mountains of eastern Oregon, USA Stand attribute
Database field
Existing tree species composition Tree species composition by layer Overstory tree size class Intra-stand variability Tree (stand) density Number of tree canopy layers Physiography/slope position
Forest cover type Canopy class composition Layer A size classes Clumpiness Tree canopy cover Canopy layering Slope curvature
Source: Schmitt & Powell, 2005.
relationships between inputs and outputs or to find patterns in data sets. They are adaptive systems that change their structure based on external or internal information that flows through the network during a “learning phase.” Variables used to predict probability of tree mortality or survival include: (i) diameter at breast height (dbh); (ii) tree height; and (iii) length, ratio, width, volume and density of tree crowns. Two approaches were developed. The first approach used an unsupervised neural network known as a self organizing map (SOM), which classifies trees according to their characteristics. The second approach used a multi-layer perceptron (MLP) to predict the probability of survival of affected trees following gall midge damage. The trained MLP model showed a 96% level of correct predictability (Park & Chung 2005).
National Pest Risk Map for the USA A National Insect and Disease Risk Map (NIDRM) was first developed for the USA in 2006. The threshold of mapping risk is the expectation that, without pest management, 25% or more of the standing live basal area of trees > 2.54 cm in diameter will die over the next 15 years due to insects and/or disease. The map represents the integration of 188 risk models that predict how certain tree species react to various mortality agents. The models, in turn, are the interactions of predicted agent behavior with known forest parameters. The most widely used forest parameters for the NIDRM are stand basal area (BA), stand density index (SDI), and tree diameter or its surrogate, quadratic mean diameter (QMD). Plot data were interpolated to create uniform “surfaces” that capture natural variations in forest parameters.
Table 4.8 Database fields used to rate susceptibility for each of six forest insects and diseases and three pest groups using aerial photographs in the Blue Mountains of eastern Oregon, USA Pest agent(s)
Database field Forest Canopy Layer A Clumpiness Tree Canopy Slope cover species size canopy layering curvature type composition classes cover
Defoliators Douglas-fir beetle Fir engraver Spruce beetle Bark beetles in ponderosa pine Mountain pine beetle (lodgepole pine) Douglas-fir dwarf mistletoe Western larch dwarf mistletoe Root diseases Source: Schmitt & Powell 2005.
A A A A A A A A A
B B B B B B B B B
– C C C C C C C C
– D D – D D – – –
C E E D E E – – –
D – – – F F D – –
– – – E – – – – –
72
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Each of the 188 models, which predict the reaction of 42 mortality agents, including 13 recently introduced species, acting on 57 tree species, were documented using a spreadsheet template. The model results for each agent/host interaction are represented by a pair of maps showing: . .
likelihood (on a scale of 0–10) of an agent/host interaction resulting in mortality; percent contribution to total basal area loss attributed to that model.
The 2006 NIDRM displays projected risk of morality on a national scale at a 1-km spatial resolution and can be updated as new models and data become available. In its present form, NIDRM estimates that 23.5 million ha of the 303 million ha of forest land in the USA, including Alaska, are at risk from insect and disease (USDA Forest Service 2006b, Krist et al. 2007). An improved version of NIDRM is scheduled to be available by 2012. This map is expected to display areas at risk at a resolution of 240 m at the country-wide level and 30 m at a regional level.
Chapter 5
Forest insect management
Protection of forests from damaging insects and other pests is a complex and often costly process. Moreover, many activities related to forest pest management are controversial, especially when tactics such as aerial application of chemical insecticides or harvesting infested or dead trees are undertaken on public lands. This chapter provides a framework for activities designed to protect forests from damaging insects with minimal adverse impacts on other resources. This framework considers maintenance of forest health and vitality as the objective of forest pest management and integrated pest management (IPM) as a set of tools to achieve this objective.
HEALTHY FORESTS – THE OBJECTIVE The objective of managing forest pests is to help keep forests in a healthy, productive condition. The concept of a healthy forest evolved during the mid- to late 1980s. In economic terms, a “healthy” forest can be defined as “a forest in which pests and diseases remain at low levels and do not interfere with
management objectives.” In ecological terms, a healthy forest is considered “a fully functional ecosystem; one in which all of its parts can interact in a mutually beneficial way.” Healthy forests, therefore, are those that can meet economic, social and ecological functions now and in the future. The healthy forest concept directs forest managers to focus on the forest rather than its pests and takes into account the natural role of insects, fungi, fire and other so called “damaging agents” and their interactions in the dynamics of forest ecosystems. Pest outbreaks are viewed as a symptom of an unhealthy forest rather than as the problem. This directs forest managers and forest protection specialists to focus on underlying causes of insect or disease occurrence, such as overstocking, overmaturity, poor site/species matching, excessive fuels or presence of single species, even-aged forests with little diversity. Striving for healthy forests also involves anticipation of pest outbreaks based on historical records of their occurrence and knowledge of forest, climatic, soil and other factors that favor their occurrence. Ideally, this should allow time to implement management practices that will help make forests
Forest Entomology: A Global Perspective, First Edition. William M. Ciesla. Ó 2011 William M. Ciesla. Published 2011 by Blackwell Publishing Ltd.
73
74
Forest entomology: a global perspective
inhospitable for buildup of damaging pests before outbreaks occur (Ciesla 1998). The notion of maintaining healthy forests may, initially, sound like an idyllic approach. This is especially true in cases where an introduced insect is causing damage in single species plantations in the absence of its natural enemies. Yet even some of the most damaging of exotic pests are known to respond to stand and site conditions or local climatic variations and there is some evidence that many exotic species focus their activities on unhealthy or stressed forests. An example is the wood wasp, Sirex noctilio, in exotic pine plantations in the southern hemisphere. In New Zealand, it was noted that stressed trees in unthinned plantations were the first to be attacked. Therefore, by its action, the insect was thinning overstocked pine plantations, albeit not to the same standards that a forester would use (McLean 1998). Similarly, when cypress aphid, Cinara cupressivora, appeared in eastern and southern Africa, the most severe damage occurred in plantations that were either overmature or had been established on lownutrient soils (Claude & Fanstin 1991, Obiri 1994, Ciesla et al. 1995).
INTEGRATED PEST MANAGEMENT The concept or philosophy of IPM as a “rational” approach to pest control was formalized during the 1960s as agricultural crop protection specialists became aware of adverse side effects of chemical pesticides including insect resistance to pesticides, occurrence of secondary pests, environmental damage and human health hazards. This led to a realization that alternative approaches, including cultural, biological and genetic tactics, used either alone or in combination, were also needed to provide long-term, effective protection against pests. IPM has many definitions. Between 1959 and 2000, some 67 definitions of either “integrated control” or IPM appeared in the worldwide literature (Bajwa & Kogan 2002). Smith et al. (1976) refer to IPM as “a process based on ecological principles and integrates multi-disciplinary methodologies in developing agroecosystem management strategies that are practical and effective and protect both public health and the environment.” FAO defines IPM as “the careful consideration of all available pest control techniques and subsequent integration of appropriate measures that discourage the development of pest populations and
keep pesticides and other interventions to levels that are economically justified and reduce or minimize risks to human health and the environment. IPM emphasizes the growth of a healthy crop with the least possible disruption to agro-ecosystems and encourages natural pest control mechanisms” (FAO n.d. (a)). Pimentel (1986) describes IPM as a “pest control method that includes judicious use of pesticide and non-chemical technologies – all of which are based on sound ecological principles.” IPM consists of two basic elements: a decision process and an action process. The decision process establishes the basis for pest management actions to be undertaken, including no action. The action process may consist of one or more ecologically, economically and socially acceptable tactics designed to reduce pest populations to non-damaging levels (Ciesla 1982).
THE DECISION PROCESS The forest owner or manager is the person who must ultimately decide for or against pest management and which, if any, pest management tactics to use. Selection of the most appropriate pest management approach is often the most time consuming and complex aspect of IPM. It requires careful consideration of the pest, its hosts, resource management objectives and ecological, economic and social consequences of the pest and of the available pest management tactics. Data on forest insect populations and their potential to cause damage in the immediate future are a critical input to the IPM decision process (see Chapter 4). The value of anticipated resource losses is estimated, as is the cost of treatment and its anticipated benefits. If treatment costs exceed losses, a rational decision may be to not treat and accept the loss. Other questions that should be addressed include: . .
Will natural controls take over within a short enough time so that artificial controls will be unnecessary? Will the ecological impacts of proposed treatments be so adverse that they outweigh the benefits of treatment?
The depth of analyses needed to support pest management decisions varies depending on the nature of the pest and its damage, the pest management tools being considered and the country and local laws and regulations regarding pest management. In some cases, surveys to determine if the insect has reached
Management of forest insect pests population levels that exceed a predefined economic threshold may be sufficient. In others, the decision process may be significantly more complex. The cost of proposed treatment is compared with the projected benefits in a cost–benefit analysis. Consideration is given to potential adverse impacts of treatments on non-target organisms with special consideration to impacts on rare or threatened species. In many countries, if a pest management action is considered on public lands, such as national or state forests, a formal environmental impact analysis with public review and comment may be required before any action is taken.
THE ACTION PROCESS Pest management actions consist of strategies and tactics. Strategies are the overall approaches to pest management and tactics are the tools. In IPM, there are three basic strategies: . . .
no action; prevention; direct control or suppression.
Depending on conditions, elements of one or more of these strategies may be part of an IPM project or system.
No Action The decision processes described in the preceding section may lead forest owners or resource managers to take no action either on all, or a portion of, the area affected by a forest pest and simply accept the losses. Selection of this option may be driven by one or more ecological, policy, economic or social considerations. Ecological Considerations Ecological factors that may drive a “no action” pest management decision include: .
.
Insect population monitoring may indicate that population levels of the target insect are declining and/or natural factors such as parasites and predators will exert enough pressure on the next generation that damage is expected to be minimal. An outbreak has become so massive that attempts at pest management are futile.
.
.
75
Limited access, steep terrain or poor weather conditions constrain implementation of available pest management tactics. Implementation of pest management might adversely affect non-target species that may occur in all, or a portion of, the affected area.
Policy Considerations Land management objectives and policies may constrain use of certain, or all, pest management tactics. National parks and reserves or other lands with special classifications (e.g. designated wilderness in the USA) are usually managed on a “let nature take its course” or “no intervention” policy. A disturbance, such as an insect outbreak would, therefore, be considered part of the dynamics of the ecosystem and viewed as a means of replacement of old, mature forests with young, vigorous forests. Economic Considerations One of the key elements of the pest management decision process is to weigh the costs of treatment vs anticipated benefits (benefit/cost analyses). Benefits of pest management in terms of reduced rates of tree mortality, avoidance of growth loss or loss of wood quality are relatively easy to quantify on lands where timber production is one of the resource management objectives. Benefits of pest management on scenic and recreational values, improved wildlife habitat or water yields from forested watersheds, on the other hand, are more difficult to quantify. If benefit/cost analysis indicates a marginal or negative benefit of a proposed pest management action, the decision to not treat a pest problem is valid, at least in economic terms. Social Considerations Many pest management tactics are controversial. Use of chemical pesticides, with their potential adverse effects, is almost always a subject of controversy. Even proposed use of relatively host specific direct control measures, such as the bacterial insecticide, Bacillus thuringiensis, against a forest defoliator can be controversial because non-target Lepidoptera are also affected. In some countries, there is a strong public sentiment against timber harvesting and road construction on public forest lands. Therefore, proposals to salvage trees
76
Forest entomology: a global perspective
killed by insects may be met with strong opposition. Public opposition to use of some, or all, available pest management tactics against a forest pest may cause public land forest resource managers to decide to take no action against a forest pest.
pest populations. The broad classes of IPM tactics include: . . . .
Risks Associated with No Action There are certain risks associated with a decision to take no action against a forest pest on public lands. National parks and reserves, for example, receive large numbers of visitors. Presence of dead trees caused by insect outbreaks, especially in heavily used areas such as campgrounds, picnic areas, vistas or hiking trails, are a safety hazard, especially as stems decay and become subject to windthrow. Another risk is liability associated with spread or conceived spread of insects and resultant damage into neighboring forest lands where management objectives may be quite different. Presence of damaging populations of indigenous insects in a national park or reserve may be looked upon as a “natural” event and, therefore, not treated. However, introduction and establishment of exotic species may require special consideration. These could have devastating impacts on the very values under protection by the land use classification. An example is the introduction of the hemlock woolly adelgid, Adelges tsugae, into the Great Smoky Mountains National Park in the southern Appalachian Mountains of the USA. This insect is causing extensive mortality of eastern hemlock, Tsuga canadensis, a key component of riparian forest ecosystems, and has adversely affected the park’s biodiversity. As a result, officials are using a combination of chemical and biological control tactics in an attempt to reduce losses (USDI National Park Service n.d.).
. . .
regulatory; cultural; genetic; mechanical; biological control; semiochemicals; chemical insecticides.
Several of these can be used either to prevent or suppress damage. For example, cultural tactics, such as thinning, may create conditions inhospitable for development of pest populations. Salvage logging, on the other hand, is oriented towards the removal of trees that are infested or have been killed by insects to reduce insect populations and/or recover some of the losses incurred (Fig. 5.1). Similarly, semiochemicals can be deployed to prevent attacks through use of antiaggregating pheromones or to reduce insect populations by mass trapping or mating disruption. Details of tactics available in forest insect management are described in the following sections.
PEST MANAGEMENT TACTICS Regulatory Tactics The objective of regulatory tactics is to prevent introduction of exotic pests and to prevent or reduce their spread in areas where they have become established. Three areas of activity fall under the general heading of regulatory tactics: . . .
inspections of imported goods; conduct of pest risk analyses; establishment of quarantine zones.
Prevention and Suppression Pest management actions, designed to reduce losses incurred by forest insects, involve two strategies: prevention or suppression. Prevention is designed to reduce the probability of occurrence of damaging insects by creating environmental conditions inhospitable for their buildup. Suppression or direct control consists of actions directed against the insect to reduce population levels and subsequent losses to the resource. Tactics are the tools used to either prevent damage or reduce populations and subsequent losses from existing
Inspections of Imported Goods Inspections of agricultural commodities and forest products at ports of entry are designed to intercept and destroy exotic species that may be associated with these products. Considering the high risk of introduction of wood infesting insects, it has become necessary to not only inspect the commodity itself but also wooden containers that contain the product, dunnage and pallets, especially wood containing bark strips, for presence of potentially damaging wood borers and bark beetles.
Management of forest insect pests
77
Fig. 5.1 Salvage logging of trees killed by southern pine beetle, Dendroctonus frontalis (Honduras, photo by R.F. Billings, Texas Forest Service).
Pest Risk Analyses
International and Regional Standards
Pest risk analyses are undertaken when new agreements are negotiated between international trading partners. These analyses identify key species with a potential for becoming pests should they be accidentally introduced, their potential pathways of entry and how to recognize the insect and infested material. During the late 1990s, teams of USDA APHIS and Forest Service experts conducted several pest risk analyses for importation of unprocessed logs and chips from Siberia and the Russian Far East, Mexico, New Zealand and South America (USDA Forest Service 1991, 1993, 1998, 2001).
Prevention of introductions of exotic pests involves a high level of international cooperation. At the global level, the International Plant Protection Convention (IPPC) is an international treaty that establishes standards designed to prevent introduction, establishment and spread of plant and plant product pests and to promote appropriate measures for their control. The IPPC Secretariat coordinates the activities of the Convention and is housed at the headquarters of FAO, Rome, Italy (www.ippc.int). IPPC activities are oriented largely toward agricultural crop pests but forest pests are also addressed. For example, International Standards for Phytosanitary Measures No. 15 (ISPM 15) establishes standards for wood packing materials used in international trade to prevent movement of cambium and wood boring insects. This standard applies to wood materials of a thickness greater than 6 mm, used to ship products between countries. It affects all wood packaging material (pallets, crates and dunnage) and requires that they be treated with heat or fumigated with methyl bromide and
Quarantines Quarantines are designed to prevent spread of an introduced pest once it has become established. In the case of forest insects, quarantine procedures focus on restricting movement of potentially infested fuel wood, other wood or non-wood products and nursery stock from infested to uninfested areas.
78
Forest entomology: a global perspective
branded with a seal of compliance. Products exempt from ISPM-15 are made from alternative materials such as paper, plastic or wood panels. A 2009 revision of ISPM-15 requires that wood used to manufacture ISPM-15 compliant wood packaging must be made from debarked wood not to be confused with “bark free wood.” This was done to incorporate bark restriction regulations proposed by the EU. Several regional plant protection organizations operate under the umbrella of the IPPC. The European Plant Protection Organization (EPPO) is a regional intergovernmental organization responsible for cooperation in plant protection in the European and Mediterranean regions. Founded in 1951, it has grown from 15 to 50 member countries and now includes nearly every country in these regions (http://www.eppo.org/ ABOUT_EPPO/about_eppo.htm). EPPO’s objectives are to: .
.
. .
develop an international strategy against introduction and spread of pests that damage cultivated and wild plants, in natural and agricultural ecosystems (including invasive alien plants); encourage harmonization of phytosanitary regulations and all other areas of official plant protection action; promote use of modern, safe and effective pest control methods; provide a documentation service on plant protection.
Cultural Tactics Cultural tactics designed to reduce the probability of pest buildup include matching tree species selected for planting to suitable growing sites, controlling stocking through intermediate harvests (thinning) to maintain tree vigor and timely harvesting of forests when they reach maturity. Thinning and Timely Harvesting In western North America, mountain pine beetle, Dendroctonus ponderosae, outbreaks in ponderosa pine, Pinus ponderosae, forests are favored by high stand densities. Stands can be protected through regular thinning to basal areas below 23 m2/ha (Sartwell & Dolph 1976). Lodgepole pine forests, P. contorta, which also suffer devastating outbreaks of this insect, are most susceptible when they exceed age 60 years and a high proportion of trees have a diameter at breast height
(dbh) of > 20 cm. Since lodgepole pine forests typically occur as pure, even-age stands over large areas and readily regenerate following clearcuts, a practice of creating a mosaic of age classes over the landscape, with a high proportion of young stands, less than age 60 years, can reduce the overall impact of an outbreak (Amman et al. 1977, 1990). Factors that may limit this practice include lack of access, limited markets for lodgepole pine products and opposition to timber harvesting and road construction on public lands by environmental groups. In countries such as Australia, Brazil and New Zealand, where the woodwasp, Sirex noctilio, has been introduced and become established, thinning of pine plantations to increase vigor of residual trees will reduce infestation levels and subsequent losses (Haugen et al. 1990, Iede & Ciesla 1993, Iede et al. 1998).
Species Selection and Biodiversity One of the important silvicultural tactics to reduce impact of damaging insects is to maintain as high a level of biodiversity as possible. Unfortunately, forest plantation programs in many countries rely on relatively few tree species, often exotics, which happen to be well adapted to local climatic and soil conditions, are fast growing and produce a variety of useful wood products. In Brazil, for example, there are 6 million ha of forest plantations: 4 million ha of eucalypts and 2 million ha of pines. In the country’s three southernmost states there are 1.2 million ha of pine plantations, of which roughly 80% are Pinus taeda. In Chile, as of 2005, there were 2.078 million ha of forest plantations, of which 68% were of Pinus radiata. An additional 24% of the country’s forest plantation estate is composed of eucalypts, primarily Eucalyptus globulus (INFOR 2005). In Kenya during the 1990s, 46% of forest plantations were composed of Cupressus lusitanica. Reliance on one or two forest plantation species puts them at high risk should either a native species adapt to the large area of monoculture or should a damaging invasive pest become introduced and established. Introduction of cypress aphid, Cinara cupressivora, into Kenya and other countries of eastern and southern Africa caused extensive tree mortality in Cupressus lusitanica plantations. This forced forest departments to seek alternative species for their plantation programs. Maintenance of a mix of species or a mosaic of age classes where the natural forest is composed of just a
Management of forest insect pests few species, as is the case over much of the Rocky Mountain region of North America, helps increase biodiversity and reduces the overall volume of suitable host material available for development of outbreaks.
Mechanical Tactics Mechanical tactics include removal and destruction of all, or a portion of, infested trees to destroy the pest. Low-level populations of tent making defoliating caterpillars, such as Malacosoma spp. throughout the northern hemisphere and the pine processionary caterpillars, Thaumetopoea pityocampa and Th. wilkinsonii of Mediterranean Europe and northern Africa, can be effectively controlled by pruning and destroying branches containing tents and larval colonies. Hand pruning is also a viable tactic for control of gall insects on small ornamental trees and shrubs. A technique known as “cut and leave” is an effective treatment for southern pine beetle, Dendroctonus frontalis, in areas where opportunities to salvage log infested trees are limited. This consists of cutting all trees with fresh attacks or containing beetle broods and leaving them on site. Beetle survival in cut trees is reduced and, by disrupting pheromone production, spot size growth is prevented. This has been used effectively in outbreak areas in southeastern USA and Central America (Fig. 5.2, Billings et al. 2004). Solar radiation is a technique used to increase brood mortality of bark beetles. Trees containing brood are cut
Fig. 5.2 Strip of pines cut as part of a “cut and leave” technique to limit spot growth of southern pine beetle, Dendroctonus frontalis (Honduras, photo by R.F. Billings, Texas Forest Service).
79
and bucked into workable lengths, placed in an open area with direct exposure to sunlight and wrapped in plastic sheeting. This produces temperatures high enough to cause brood mortality and has been used successfully to reduce mountain pine beetle broods in the Rocky Mountain region of the USA (Negrón et al. 2001). When pine woolly aphid, Pineus boerneri, was first discovered in Kenya, the initial response was to cut and destroy infested trees. However, this insect is easily carried on air currents and it was soon realized that infestation had spread far beyond the designated areas where trees were being destroyed (Owour 1991).
Genetic Tactics Genetic tactics make use of varieties of host plants that are either more tolerant to damage or less palatable to the pest. Identification and testing of varieties of Leucaena leucocephala, a fast-growing tree widely planted in the tropics as an agroforestry species, for resistance or tolerance to the introduced leucaena psyllid, Heteropsylla cubana, was a major line of investigation following this insect’s introduction into the Asia-Pacific region (Banpot Napompeth 1994).
Biological Control Biological control involves use of natural enemies (parasitoids, predators or diseases) of an insect to help
80
Forest entomology: a global perspective
keep its numbers in check. Several approaches to biological control have been used: . . .
classic biological control; augmentative biological control; microbial insecticides.
Classic Biological Control Importation of natural enemies to help control a damaging pest, usually an introduced species, is known as classic biological control (Fig. 5.3). This tactic has been widely used against a wide range of forest insects and there are many examples of its successful application. Release of a parasitic wasp, Pauesia bicolor, resulted in control of a giant conifer aphid, Cinara cronartii, which
Fig. 5.3 A screen cage is placed over a branch of a cypress, Cupressus lusitanica, for release of parasitoids as part of a classic biological control program for cypress aphid, Cinara cupressivora (western Kenya).
is native to North American and accidentally introduced into pine plantations in South Africa (Kfir et al. 1985, Mills 1990). In Chile, state-of-the-art mass rearing facilities have been established by forest industry for production of Orgilis obscurator, a parasitoid of the European pine shoot moth, Rhyacionia buoliana, which has become an important pest of that country’s Pinus radiata plantations. One such laboratory, Controladora de Plagas Forestales, was established in 1992. In 1996, this facility produced 1.2 million parasitized larvae and 22,558 adult female parasitoids for field release (Controladora de Plagas Forestales 1997). Attempts at classic biological control of forest pests in Europe, where, to date, there have been relatively few introductions of exotic species, have involved the movement of indigenous natural enemies from one area to another. In the UK, the natural enemy complex of many forest insects is considerably less diverse than in continental Europe. This suggests that there are opportunities to move natural enemies from the central portions of their distributions to outlying areas. When natural enemies are absent in certain areas, it is important to determine if this due to an unsuitable environment or simply separation of the pest and its enemy in certain parts of their natural ranges. In southern Sweden, infestations of adelgids occurred on plantations of Abies alba, a tree exotic to northern Europe. Transfer of a predaceous ladybird beetle, Scymnus impexus, from Germany led to its establishment in Sweden (Speight & Wainhouse 1989). Classic biological control is not necessarily restricted to exotic pests. In Colombia, for example, indigenous foliage feeding Geometridae that adapted to exotic plantations were successfully controlled via the introduction and release of a North American egg parasitoid, Telenomus alsophilae (Bustliio & Drooz 1977). Several factors should be considered before using classic biological control as a pest management tactic. One is the possibility that the introduced natural enemy might also attack innocuous or beneficial insects in the ecosystem. It is, therefore, necessary to thoroughly evaluate candidate species prior to their release to determine their host specificity. Another concern is the hazard of accidentally introducing hyperparasites, natural enemies of the biological control agents, which might eventually affect the agent’s efficacy. For example, colonies of the leucaena psyllid predator, Olla v-nigrum, released on the Indian Ocean island of Reunion, were subsequently discovered infested by three species of hyperparasites (Quilici et al. 1995).
Management of forest insect pests Augmentative Biological Control Tactics to increase abundance and efficiency of natural enemies already in place are known as augmentative biological control and involves two approaches: . .
mass rearing and inundative releases of parasitoids and predators; altering site conditions to create a more favorable habitat for natural enemies.
In China, mass rearing and release of an indigenous egg parasitoid, Trichogramma dendrolimi, for control of the defoliating caterpillar, Dendrolimus punctatus, has been used with reasonable success (Yan & Liu 1992). Birds are known predators of damaging forest insects, although their effectiveness is not well understood. In Europe, augmentation of insectivorous birds in forests through establishment of nesting boxes has been practiced for about 80 years. This tactic is based on the assumption that nesting site availability is limited. While this may be true for cavity nesting birds in areas where dead trees are removed, there is no certainty that an increase in bird density increases mortality of important pest species. When food supply is a limiting factor in bird population dynamics, an attempt to increase bird density by installation of nesting boxes during times when populations of damaging insects are at low levels may not be effective (Speight & Wainhouse 1989). In China and Vietnam, it is believed that elimination of livestock grazing in pine plantations will encourage growth of flowering plants, which serve as a source of nectar for parasitic wasps of the pine caterpillar, Dendrolimus punctatus, thus increasing parasitoid numbers. While there is some logic to this hypothesis, no data are available to substantiate it (Author’s observation). Microbials Use of agents that cause disease in insects (e.g. fungi, viruses, bacteria and nematodes) as a control agent is known as microbial control. One bacterial insecticide is available commercially for insect control and several viruses have been registered by government agencies responsible for pesticide regulation against forest insects.
Bacteria Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) is a naturally occurring soil bacterium that causes disease in insects. Bt is considered ideal for pest management because of
81
its relative host specificity and its lack of toxicity to humans or the natural enemies of many insect pests. There are several subspecies of Bt, each with a specific toxicity to a particular group of insects. B.t. israelensis (Bti) is effective against mosquitoes, blackflies and some fungus gnats. B.t. kurstaki (Btk) controls lepidopterous insects, including forest defoliators such as tent caterpillars and spruce budworms. B.t. san diego/tenebrionis, is effective against certain species of beetles (Martin 1994, Cranshaw 2009). Bt produces proteins in the form of a toxic crystal, known as the delta-endotoxin, which reacts with the cells of the gut lining of susceptible insects. They paralyze the digestive system, and infected insects stop feeding, usually within hours. Bt affected insects generally die from starvation, which can take several days. B.t. kurstaki is currently the most widely used microbial insecticide in the world and has been applied over thousands of hectares of forested lands in Asia, Europe and North America for control of forest defoliators (Speight & Wainhouse 1989, Reardon et al. 1994, Cranshaw 2009, Fig. 5.4, Table 5.1).
Viruses Epizootics caused by viruses are often seen in insect populations. Several groups of viruses infect and kill insects. Baculoviruses replicate in the nuclei of insect cells. Nucleopolyhedrosis viruses (NPVs) are by far the most common type of baculovirus and have a characteristic structure. Individual virus particles, known as virons, are contained within a protein matrix known as a polyhedron. Granulosis viruses (GVs) are less common and found only in the larval stages of moths and butterflies. With GVs, virons are individually encapsulated and not grouped together in polyhedra. Cytoplasmic viruses (CPVs) are similar to NPVs except in their site of action and that they belong to a different group of viruses, the Retroviridae. This group also contains viruses capable of infecting vertebrates and plants. To cause disease, virus particles must be ingested by larvae. After ingestion, the virus multiplies and death occurs quickly (Speight & Wainhouse 1989). Larvae of some forest caterpillars and sawflies are highly susceptible to baculovirus diseases (Fig. 5.5, Table 5.2). They are considered promising organisms for insect control because they can spread through a population quickly and persist in the environment for long periods. Viruses also have the advantage of being host specific. Therefore their use in the forest should not affect other organisms. Host specificity also works
82
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Fig. 5.4 A spray aircraft applies the microbial insecticide, Bacillus thuringiensis, over a forested area infested by western spruce budworm, Choristoneura occidentalis (Mt Hood National Forest, Oregon, USA).
against these materials because private industry is reluctant to invest in their development and registration because they only offer limited markets. Several insect viruses have been produced and registered for use against forest defoliators, either by ground
or aerial application. Insect viruses must be mass produced by rearing large numbers of host insects in the laboratory, infecting them with virus and recovering virus particles from the cadavers. In the USA, the first two NPVs registered by the US Environmental
Table 5.1 Examples of forest defoliators treated with Bacillus thuringiensis kurstaki in Asia, Europe and North America. Scientific name
Common name
Where treated
Choristoneura fumiferana Choristoneura occidentalis Dendrolimus punctatus Dendrolimus sibiricus Lymantria dispar Lymantria monacha Malacosoma disstria Orgyia pseudotsugata Thaumetopoea pityocampa
Spruce budworm Western spruce budworm Pine caterpillar Siberian silk moth Gypsy moth Nun moth Forest tent caterpillar Douglas-fir tussock moth Pine processionary caterpillar
Thaumetopoea wilkinsonii
Eastern pine processionary caterpillar
Canada, USA Canada, USA China, Vietnam Mongolia, Russia Asia, Europe, North America Lithuania, Poland USA Canada, USA Mediterranean regions of Europe, North Africa and the Near East Cyprus
Sources: Speight & Wainhouse, 1989 and the Author’s experience.
Management of forest insect pests
83
Enough refined virus was produced at this facility to treat 203,305 ha of forest at the recommended dosage of 2.681 108 activity units (AU)/ha. In 2000, some 12,145 ha of forests in Oregon and Washington were treated with this material. An additional 4048 ha were treated the following year. The virus production facility was closed in late 1992. However, detailed plans are available to produce additional virus if needed (Scott 2001).
Fig. 5.5 Larva of gypsy moth, Lymantria dispar, killed by a virus (South Mountain, Pennsylvania, USA).
Protection Agency (EPA) were the Douglas-fir tussock moth virus in 1976 (TM Biocontrol-1) and the gypsy moth virus in 1978 (Gypchek). Because of their host specificity and relative infrequency of use, especially the Douglas-fir tussock moth NPV, registration of these products was done by two USDA agencies: Forest Service and Agricultural Research Service (ARS) instead of a private company. As of October 2002, the US EPA registered five NPVs and GVs as pesticides and 10 pesticide products containing these active ingredients. Between 1980 and 1992, the Douglas-fir tussock moth NPV was produced in laboratory facilities in Corvalis, Oregon, USA by the USDA Forest Service.
Fungi All major groups of fungi contain species lethal to insects and most insect orders are susceptible. Fungi infect insects through the digestive tract and the integument. Larvae, pupae and adults are subject to attack. Weather plays an important role in determining effectiveness of fungi as biocontrol agents. Fungi need moisture and high humidity to germinate. Frequent rainfall during May and June, for example, can create conditions favorable for development of fungi that attack defoliating caterpillars. Fungi also thrive in warm temperatures. One of the most commonly occurring insect fungi is Beauvaria bassiana, sometimes referred to as the white muscadine fungus. This fungus is often seen as a mass of white mycelium covering the body of a dead insect (see Fig. 2.4). B. bassiana has been propagated in the laboratory for control of pine caterpillar, Dendrolimus punctatus, in China and Vietnam (Fig. 5.6) and applied in a unique manner. Fungus spores are inserted into large firecrackers from which a portion of the gunpowder has been removed. The firecracker is lit, tossed into the crowns of infested pines and the spores are released as the firecracker explodes. Unfortunately, data on the effectiveness of this method are lacking (Author’s observation). The fungus Entomophaga maimaiga causes a disease of gypsy moth, Lymantria dispar, in Japan. This fungus was first released in the USA near Boston, Massachusetts in 1910, as part of a program to introduce natural enemies of gypsy moth in areas where this insect was introduced. Scientists could find no evidence that the fungus had become established and the project was abandoned several years later. The fungus appeared unexpectedly in several northeastern states in 1989 and caused high mortality of many gypsy moth populations. Although scientists have several theories, the strange reappearance of this fungus is still a mystery. E. maimaiga passes the winter as a tough, thick-walled “resting spore” in the soil and on tree bark. In May or
84
Forest entomology: a global perspective
Table 5.2 Examples of baculoviruses known to affect forest defoliators. Insect species
Common name
Virus type
Host trees affected
Country(s)
Bupalis piniarius Gilpinia hercyniae Lymantria dispar
Pine looper Spruce sawfly Gypsy moth
NPV NPV NPV
Netherlands North America Europe, North America
Lymantria monacha Neodiprion sertifer Orgyia pseudotsugata
Nun moth European pine sawfly Douglas-fir tussock moth
NPV, CPV NPV NPV NPV
Pines Spruce Oaks and other broadleaf species Fir
Thaumetopoea pityocampa Zeiraphera diniana
Pine processionary caterpillar Larch bud moth
Lymantria fumida
CPV
Pine, spruce Pine Douglas-fir, true fir Pines
GV
Larch, pines
Japan Northern Europe Canada, Europe, USA Western North America Mediterranean regions of Europe, North Africa and the Near East Switzerland
CPV, cytoplasmic virus; GV, granulosis virus; NPV, nucleopolyhedrosis virus. Source: Bird 1953, Podgewaite et al. 1984, Speight & Wainhouse 1989 and the Author’s experience.
June, resting spores germinate and produce