Springer Finance
Editorial Board M. Avellaneda G. Barone-Adesi M. Broadie M.H.A. Davis E. Derman C. Klüppelberg E. Kopp W. Schachermayer
Springer Finance Springer Finance is a programme of books aimed at students, academics and practitioners working on increasingly technical approaches to the analysis of financial markets. It aims to cover a variety of topics, not only mathematical finance but foreign exchanges, term structure, risk management, portfolio theory, equity derivatives, and financial economics. Ammann M., Credit Risk Valuation: Methods, Models, and Application (2001) Back K., A Course in Derivative Securities: Introduction to Theory and Computation (2005) Barucci E., Financial Markets Theory. Equilibrium, Efficiency and Information (2003) Bielecki T.R. and Rutkowski M., Credit Risk: Modeling, Valuation and Hedging (2002) Bingham N.H. and Kiesel R., Risk-Neutral Valuation: Pricing and Hedging of Financial Derivatives (1998, 2nd ed. 2004) Brigo D. and Mercurio F., Interest Rate Models: Theory and Practice (2001, 2nd ed. 2006) Buff R., Uncertain Volatility Models-Theory and Application (2002) Carmona R.A. and Tehranchi M.R., Interest Rate Models: an Infinite Dimensional Stochastic Analysis Perspective (2006) Dana R.A. and Jeanblanc M., Financial Markets in Continuous Time (2002) Deboeck G. and Kohonen T. (Editors), Visual Explorations in Finance with Self-Organizing Maps (1998) Delbaen F. and Schachermayer W., The Mathematics of Arbitrage (2005) Elliott R.J. and Kopp P.E., Mathematics of Financial Markets (1999, 2nd ed. 2005) Fengler M.R., Semiparametric Modeling of Implied Volatility (2005) Geman H., Madan D., Pliska S.R. and Vorst T. (Editors), Mathematical Finance–Bachelier Congress 2000 (2001) Gundlach M., Lehrbass F. (Editors), CreditRisk+ in the Banking Industry (2004) Kellerhals B.P., Asset Pricing (2004) Külpmann M., Irrational Exuberance Reconsidered (2004) Kwok Y.-K., Mathematical Models of Financial Derivatives (1998) Malliavin P. and Thalmaier A., Stochastic Calculus of Variations in Mathematical Finance (2005) Meucci A., Risk and Asset Allocation (2005) Pelsser A., Efficient Methods for Valuing Interest Rate Derivatives (2000) Prigent J.-L., Weak Convergence of Financial Markets (2003) Schmid B., Credit Risk Pricing Models (2004) Shreve S.E., Stochastic Calculus for Finance I (2004) Shreve S.E., Stochastic Calculus for Finance II (2004) Yor M., Exponential Functionals of Brownian Motion and Related Processes (2001) Zagst R., Interest-Rate Management (2002) Zhu Y.-L., Wu X., Chern I.-L., Derivative Securities and Difference Methods (2004) Ziegler A., Incomplete Information and Heterogeneous Beliefs in Continuous-time Finance (2003) Ziegler A., A Game Theory Analysis of Options (2004)
Eric Jondeau, Ser-Huang Poon and Michael Rockinger
Financial Modeling Under Non-Gaussian Distributions
Eric Jondeau University of Lausanne and Swiss Finance Institute HEC-Department of Finance and Insurance CH-1015 Lausanne-Dorigny Switzerland
Ser-Huang Poon Manchester Business School University of Manchester Oxford Road Manchester M13 9PL UK
Michael Rockinger University of Lausanne and Swiss Finance Institute HEC-Department of Finance and Insurance CH-1015 Lausanne-Dorigny Switzerland
Mathematics Subject Classification (2000): 91B28, 91B84 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Control Number: 2006923899 Springer Finance Series ISSN 1616-0533 ISBN-10 1-84628-419-8 ISBN-13 978-1-84628-419-9
Printed on acid-free paper
© 2007 Springer-Verlag London Limited MATLAB® is a trademark of The MathWorks, Inc. and is used with permission. The MathWorks does not warrant the accuracy of the text or exercises in this book. This book’s use or discussion of MATLAB® software or related products does not constitute endorsement or sponsorship by The MathWorks of a particular pedagogical approach or particular use of the MATLAB® software. Apart from any fair dealing for the purposes of research or private study, or criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, this publication may only be reproduced, stored or transmitted, in any form or by any means, with the prior permission in writing of the publishers, or in the case of reprographic reproduction in accordance with the terms of licences issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside those terms should be sent to the publishers. The use of registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. The publisher makes no representation, express or implied, with regard to the accuracy of the information contained in this book and cannot accept any legal responsibility or liability for any errors or omissions that may be made. Printed in the United States of America 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Springer Science+Business Media, LLC springer.com
(MVY)
(< :F 3.:69F @LIG !LC= &IH>?;O
; 9
(< .B?. @LIG )C=B;?F .I=ECHA?L
";./*,.
,L;=NCNCIH?LM ;H> ;=;>?GC= L?M?;L=B?LM QBI B;P? B;H>F?> WH;H=C;F G;LE?N >;N; EHIQ NB;N ;MM?N L?NOLH >CMNLC
I HIN B;P? NB? QCNB NB? #;OMMC;H IL HILG;F >CMNLC?FM ;L? MNCFF <;M?> IH NB? ;MMOGJNCIH I@ HILG;FCNS CM ?F JL?M?HNM ;H> J?LB;JM NB? ?LMN;H>CHA I@ NB? GI>?FCHA ?MNCG;NCIH ;H> B;H>FCHA I@ HIH #;OMMC;H >CMNLC?FM QB?H NB? ;MM?N L?NOLH >CMNLC;HA?LIOM MO=B ; JL;=NC=? =IOF> F?;> NI ; QLIHA =BIC=? I@ JILN@IFCI NB? OH>?L?MNCG;NCIH I@ ?RNL?G? FIMM?M
;H> BOA?FS GCMJLC=?> >?LCP;NCP? JLI>O=NM *IH #;OMMC;H >CMNLC>L?MM?M NB? =;OM?M ;H> NB? =IHM?KO?H=?M I@ HIH HILG;FCNS I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM +NB?L CH=FO>? ;GJ );=ECHF;S
;H> !G )CEIM=B %H L?F;N?> W?F>M IH? G;S ;FMI =CN? #IOLCf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
2%%%
,L?@;=?
"CH;H=C;F ?LCP;NCP?M %N CM OM?@OF @IL G;NB?G;NC=C;HM QBI Q;HN NI EHIQ GIL? ; CH WH;H=? ;H> @IL NBIM? QBI DOMN Q;HN NI EHIQ GIL? ; WH;H=C;F G;LE?NM 3? JLIPC>? CH ,;LN 2 MIG? G;NB?G;NC=;F ;JJ?H>C=?M NB;N Q? @??F ;L? MO^=C?HN @IL =IJCHA QCNB NB? G;NB?G;NC=;F =IHN?HNM I@ NB? G;CH J;LNM /IG? <;MC= EHIQF?>A? CH MN;NCMNC=M =;F=OFOM ;H> JLI<;?N?LGCH;NCIH MBIOF> M?? NB? L?;>?LM NBLIOAB NB? =IL? G;N?LC;FM )IMN I@ NB? G;N?LC;F JL?M?HN?> CH NBCM @LIG IOL J;J?LM ;H> G;N?LC;F OM?> NI N?;=B JL;=NCNCIH?LM ;H> A?H?L;NCIHM I@ ) /= ;H> ,B MNO>?HNM ;N 1HCP?LMCNS I@ (;OM;HH? ;H> );H=B?MN?L OMCH?MM /=BIIF
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
;CFS >;N; OM?> CH NBCM CHNL;>;CFS >;N; =IG?M @LIG NB? !OLIH?RN ,;LCM >;N;M?N = CM ; L?ACMN?L?> NL;>?G;LE I@ 0B? );NB3ILEM %H= "IL ) 0 ) 0( ( JLI>O=N CH@ILG;NCIH JF?;M? =IHN;=N 0B? );NB3ILEM %H= JJF? $CFF LCP? *;NC=E ) 1/ ! G;CF CH@I G;NBQILEM =IG 3?< QQQ G;NBQILEM =IG
,L?@;=?
%4
/B? Q;HNM NI NB;HE ;FMI B?L MNO>?HNM @IL G;HS MNCGOF;NCHA >CM=OMMCIHM ;H> ALCFFCHA L?;>CHA =F;MM?M FF NBL?? ;ONBILM ?RJL?MM NB?CL AL;NCNO>? NI (;OL; .I=ECHA?L @IL L?;>CHA NB? ?HNCL? G;HOM=LCJN ;H> =ILL?=NCHA G;HS GCMN;E?M 3? ?RJL?MM IOL NB;HEM NI G;HS INB?L J?IJF? =IFF?;AO?M @LC?H>M ;H> @;GCFS
NI QBIG Q? ;L? GIMN AL;N?@OF @IL NB?CL MOJJILN 0B?S ;L? NII G;HS NI H;G? B?L?
!LC= &IH>?;O /?L $O;HA ,IIH ;H> )C=B;?F .I=ECHA?L OAOMN
98>/8>=
#+<> 38+8-3+6
+<5/>= +8. 38+8-3+6 '37/ &/<3/=
8><9.?->398 "CH;H=C;F G;LE?NM ;H> WH;H=C;F NCG? M?LC?M !=IHIG?NLC= GI>?FCHA I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM JJFC=;NCIHM I@ HIH #;OMMC;H ?=IHIG?NLC=M +JNCIH JLC=CHA QCNB HIH #;OMMC;H >CMNLC
&>+>3=>3-+6 #<9:/<>3/= 90 38+8-3+6 +<5/> +>+ ?WHCNCIHM I@ L?NOLHM /CGJF? L?NOLHM (IA L?NOLHM /NSFCT?> @;=NM CMNLCIG P;LC;?J?H>?H=S /?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIH CH L?NOLHM /?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIH CH PIF;NCFCNS 2IF;NCFCNS ;MSGG?NLS 0CG? P;LSCHA BCAB?L GIG?HNM (CH?;L >?J?H>?H=? ;=LIMM L?NOLHM ,?;LMIHZM =ILL?F;NCIH =I?^=C?HN 0?MN @IL ?KO;FCNS I@ NQI =ILL?F;NCIH =I?^=C?HNM 0?MN @IL ?KO;FCNS I@ NQI =ILL?F;NCIH G;NLC=?M )OFNCP;LC;N? BCAB?L GIG?HNM )OFNCP;LC;N? =I ME?QH?MM ;H> =I EOLNIMCM IGJONCHA GIG?HNM I@ JILN@IFCI L?NOLHM
4%%
IHN?HNM
?8->398381 90 38+8-3+6 +<5/>= +8. '2/93-+6 9./6= 09< %/>?<8= "OH=NCIHCHA I@ WH;H=C;F G;LE?NM +LA;HCT;NCIH I@ WH;H=C;F G;LE?NM !R;GJF?M I@ IL>?LM IGJIH?HNM I@ NB? ;ME MJL?;> );H>?F NB? MN;CMNLCCMNLCCH;NCIH GI>?F 0B? C>?; I@ NB? GI>?F 0B? >?HMCNS I@ L?NOLHM OH>?L MOCH;NCIH CMNLC?F @IL L?NOLH ;H> PIFOG? GC=LIMNLO=NOL? GI>?F @IL CH@ILG;NCIH ;LLCP;FM %GJFC=;NCIHM I@ NB? GCRNOL? I@ >CMNLCCMNLC?F I@ JLC=?M ;H> KOIN?M CH ; KOIN? >LCP?H G;LE?N GI>?F <;M?> IH NB? NL;>? XIQ !MNCG;NCHA NB? J;L;G?N?LM 0B? KOIN? JLI=?MM !RN?HMCIH NI NB? FCKOC>;NCIH I@ ; F;LA? JILN@IFCI
#+<> -9897/><3
9./6381 90 ==/> %/>?<8=
9./6381 )96+>363>C 2IF;NCFCNS ;N FIQ?L @L?KO?H=C?M . $ GI>?F "IL?=;MNCHA 'OLNIMCM I@ ;H . $ GI>?F 0?MNCHA @IL . $ ?_?=NM . $ CH G?;H GI>?F %FFOMNL;NCIH # . $ GI>?F "IL?=;MNCHA %HN?AL;N?> # . $ GI>?F !MNCG;NCIH 0?MNCHA @IL # . $ ?_?=NM /I@NQ;L? NI ?MNCG;N? . $ ;H> # . $ GI>?FM %FFOMNL;NCIH MSGG?NLC= # . $ GI>?FM !# . $ GI>?F 0# . $ GI>?F
IHN?HNM
4%%%
#&. GI>?F IR IR NL;HM@ILG *?QM CGJ;=N =OLP? ,;LNC;FFS HIH J;L;G?NLC= ?MNCG;NCIH 0?MNCHA @IL ;MSGG?NLC= ?_?=NM %FFOMNL;NCIH # . $ GI>?F QCNB DOGJM GI>?F QCNB NCG? P;LSCHA DOGJ CHN?HMCNS H ?GJCLC=;F CFFOMNL;NCIH AAL?A;NCIH I@ # . $ JLI=?MM?M 0?GJIL;F ;AAL?A;NCIH LIMM M?=NCIH;F ;AAL?A;NCIH !MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? Q?;E # . $ JLI=?MM /NI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS "LIG # . $ GI>?FM NI MNI=B;MNC= PIF;NCFCNS GI>?FM !MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? >CM=L?N? NCG? /2 GI>?F .?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS 0B? >C^=OFNS NI >CM?HN;HAF? DOGJM -O;>L;NC= P;LC;NCIH ,IQ?L P;LC;NCIH CJIQ?L P;LC;NCIH !MNCG;NCIH IP?L WHCN? NCG? CHN?LP;FM .?;FCT?> =IP;LC;H=? "OLNB?L L?F;N?> L?MOFNM
9./6381 312/< 97/8>= 0B? A?H?L;F JLI !MNCG;NCIH 0B? ?RCMN?H=? I@ >CMNLCCMNLC /NO>?HN [ >CMNLCCMNLCCMNLCCMNLC CH@?L?H=? )IG?HN MJ?=CW=;NCIH N?MNM >?KO;=S N?MNM <;M?> IH >?HMCNS @IL?=;MNM >?KO;=S N?MNM <;M?> IH CHN?LP;F @IL?=;MNM %FFOMNL;NCIH )I>?FCHA =IH>CNCIH;F BCAB?L GIG?HNM 0?MNM @IL ;ONIL?AL?MMCP? =IH>CNCIH;F BCAB?L GIG?HNM )I>?FCHA BCAB?L GIG?HNM >CL?=NFS
4%2
IHN?HNM
)I>?FCHA NB? J;L;G?N?LM I@ NB? >CMNLC
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
B>CMNLC?J?H>?HN >;N; !MNCG;NCIH I@ BCAB KO;HNCF?M )OFNCP;LC;N? >?J?H>?H=? B;L;=N?LCTCHA N;CF >?J?H>?H=S !MNCG;NCIH ;H> MN;NCMNC=;F CH@?L?H=? IH ;H> )I>?FCHA >?J?H>?H=S H CFFOMNL;NCIH "OLNB?L CHP?MNCA;NCIHM
IHN?HNM
42
#+<> ::63-+>398= 90 !98+?==3+8 -9897/><3-=
%3=5 +8+1/7/8> +8. )+% ?WHCNCIHM ;H> G?;MOL?M ?WHCNCIHM )I>?FM @IL JILN@IFCI L?NOLHM $CMNILC=;F MCGOF;NCIH /?GC J;L;G?NLC= ;JJLI;=B?M !RNL?G? 2;FO? 0B?ILS !20 -O;HNCF? L?AL?MMCIH N?=BHCKO? ,;L;G?NLC= ;JJLI;=B?M .CME)?NLC=M ] & , )ILA;H 0B? JILN@IFCI F?P?F ;JJLI;=B 0B? ;MM?N F?P?F ;JJLI;=B *IH FCH?;L GI>?FM 0B? [>?FN; IHFS\ G?NBI> 0B? [>?FN; A;GG;\ G?NBI> IGJ;LCMIH I@ 2;. GI>?FM !P;FO;NCIH I@ 2;. GI>?FM IGJ;LCMIH I@ G?NBI>M >;S 2;. ;H> M=;FCHA %FFOMNL;NCIH
#9<>09639 669-+>398 ,ILN@IFCI ;FFI=;NCIH OH>?L HIH HILG;FCNS CL?=N G;RCGCT;NCIH I@ ?RJ?=N?> ONCFCNS H ;JJLIRCG;N? MIFONCIH <;M?> IH GIG?HNM ,ILN@IFCI ;FFI=;NCIH OH>?L >IQHMC>? LCME ?WHCNCIH IQHMC>? LCME ;M ;H ;>>CNCIH;F =IHMNL;CHN IQHMC>? LCME ;M ;H IJNCGCT;NCIH =LCN?LCIH
#+<> ) ":>398 #<3-381 A3>2 !98+?==3+8 %/>?<8= ?8.+7/8>+6= 90 ":>398 #<3-381 *IN;NCIHM 0B? HI ;L;G?HN;F J;LNC;F >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIH /IFPCHA NB? @OH>;G?HN;F , ! 0B? F;=E /=BIF?M )?LNIH @ILGOF; );LNCHA;F? G?;MOL? ;H> /) @ILGOF; /?F@ WH;H=CHA MNL;N?AC?M ;H> JILN@IFCI =IHMNLO=NCIH
42%
IHN?HNM
B;HA? I@ HOG?L;CL? B;HA? I@ LIQHC;H GINCIH !PIFONCIH I@ ?N OH>?L = 0B? ?RJ?=N?> J;S I_ ;M ; G;LNCHA;F? 0B? NL;>CHA MNL;N?AC?M !KOCP;F?HN G;LNCHA;F? G?;MOL?
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fPS IJNCIH JLC=CHA
IHN?HNM
42%%
IGGIHFS OM?> (fPS JLI=?MM?M BIC=? I@ NB? NCG? =B;HACHA JLI=?MM +JNCIH JLC=CHA ,LC=CHA IJNCIHM QCNB LCME H?ONL;F =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH !GJCLC=;F L?MOFNM
#+<> ) ::/8.3-/= 98 ":>398 #<3-381
+>2/7+>3-=
<9A83+8 9>398 +8. &>9-2+=>3- +6-?6?= (;Q I@ F;LA? HOG NB? =?HNL;F FCGCN NB?IL?G .;H>IG Q;FEM IHMNLO=NCIH I@ NB? LIQHC;H GINCIH ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ NB? LIQHC;H GINCIH /NI=B;MNC= CHN?AL;NCIH /NI=B;MNC= >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIHM %NIZM F?GG; )OFNCP;LC;N? ?RN?HMCIH I@ %NIZM F?GG; 0L;HMCNCIH JLI<; J;LNC;F >C_?L?HNC;F ?KO;NCIHM 'IFGIAILIP <;=EQ;L> ;H> @ILQ;L> ?KO;NCIHM , ! ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB >C_OMCIHM "?SHG;H ';= @ILGOF;
+<>381+6/ +8. 2+81381 /+=?CMNLCIH *CEI>SG >?LCP;NCP? #CLM;HIPZM NB?IL?G );LNCHA;F? L?JL?M?HN;NCIH NB?IL?G
2+<+->/<3=>3- ?8->398= +8. 9?<3/< '<+8=09<7= B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIHM ;MC= JLIJ?LNC?M )IG?HNM ;H> NB? =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH IHPIFONCIH NB?IL?G 1HCKO?H?MM %HP?LMCIH NB?IL?G "IOLC?L NL;HM@ILG ;H> =B;L;=N?LCMNC= @OH=NCIH ?7: #<9-/==/= IOHNCHA ;H> G;LE?> JICHN JLI=?MM 0B? ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM IHMNLO=NCIH I@ NB? ,ICMMIH >CMNLCCMNLC
42%%% IHN?HNM
IGJIOH> ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM 0B? ?RJIH?HNC;F >CMNLC JLIJ?LNC?M )IG?HNM I@ NB? ?RJIH?HNC;F P;LC; ;H> MOLPCPIL @OH=NCIHM OL;NCIH ,ICMMIH JLI=?MM?M M@C #<9-/==/= IHMNLO=NCIH I@ NB? (fPS JLI=?MM ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ (fPS JLI=?MM?M %/0/
7=;8->,=287
0BCM ?FCHA I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM QB?H NB? HILG;FCNS ;MMOGJ NCIH >I?M HIN ;JJFS %N JLIPC>?M ;H OJ NI >;N? ;H> MN?J <S MN?J >?M=LCJNCIH I@ NB? NIIFM NB;N ;L? OM?@OF @IL NB? GI>?FCHA I@ HIH #;OMMC;H ;MM?N L?NOLH >CMNLC @IL IJNCIH JLC=CHA CH NB? HIH #;OMMC;H =IHN?RN
27*7,2*5 6*;4.=< *7- D7*7,2*5 =26. <.;2.< "IL GIL? NB;H @IOL >?=;>?M >CMNLC?F ";G; 0B? ;MMOGJNCIH I@ HILG;FCNS CM MN;=E?> ;A;CHMN NQI B;L> @;=NM "CLMN NB? ?GJCLC=;F >CMNLCCMNLC ;JJ?;L NI 0BCM G?;HM GIL? ?RNL?G? H?A;NCP? P;FO?M QBC=B B;M ; P?LS M?LCIOM CGJFC=;NCIH @IL LCME G;H;A?G?HN ;H> JILN@IFCI M?F?=NCIH /?=IH> L?NOLHM ;L? NCG? >?J?H>?HN /KO;L?> L?NOLHM
;<MIFON? L?NOLHM ;H> ;FF G?;MOL?M ;H> JLIRC?M I@ PIF;NCFCNS ?RBCCNCIH;F B?N?LIME?>;MNC=CNS !HAF? "CH;H=C;F GI>?FCHA CM ;FF ; ?RJFICNCHA J;NN?LHM CH NB? >;N; CH=FO>CHA NB? NQI JB?HIG?H; G?HNCIH?> ;CM=OMM?M NB? OHCKO? MN;NCMNC=;F JLIJ?LNC?M I@ WH;H=C;F G;LE?N >;N; ;H> M?P?L;F MI =;FF?> MNSFCT?> @;=NM 0B?M? MNSFCT?> @;=NM QCFF ?M=LC NB? GC=LIMNLO=NOL? I@ W H;H=C;F G;LE?NM $?L? Q? JL?M?HN MIG? NB?IL?NC=;F GI>?FM NB;N G;S B?FJ ?RJF;CHCHA QBS ;MM?N L?NOLHM ;L? HIH HILG;F ;H> NCG? >?J?H>?HN 0B? @IOH>; NCIH CM PIF;NCFCNS =FOMN?LCHA =IOF> O? NI CHN?LGCNN?HN CH@ILG;NCIH ;LLCP;FM
%HNLI>O=NCIH
,8786.=;2, 68-.5270 8/ *<<.= ;.=>;7< ,;LN %% CM =IH=?LH?> QCNB NB? NCG? M?LC?M ;MJ?=NM I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM B;JN?LM ;H> =IP?L GI>?FM @IL NB? M?=IH> NBCL> ;H> @IOLNB GIG?HNM ;H> NB? N;CFM I@ L?NOLH >CMNLC N;CF G?;MOL?M ;L? NB? B;FFG;LEM I@ HIH #;OMMC;H >CMNLC?;FM QCNB NB? >?J?H>?H=? MNLO=NOL? QB?H NB? BCAB?L GIG?HNM >CMJF;S MCAHCW=;HN >?J;LNOL? @LIG HILG;F CNS ;H> L?NOLHM ;JJ?;L NI ?J?H>?HN 0B? >?J?H>?H=? ;GIHA NB? N;CF I<M?LP;NCIHM >?M=LC CH B;JN?L CM P?LS >C_?L?HN @LIG NB? >?J?H>?H=?
>?M=LC CH B;JN?L I@ NB? =?HNL;F ;H> G;CH J;LN I@ NB? >CMNLC
C_?L?H=?M CH NB? OH>?LJCHHCHA MN;NCMNC=;F NB?ILC?M ;H> NB? CG JILN;HN @;=N NB;N WH;H=C;F G;LE?NM >I C_?L?HNFS =LCMCM J?LCI>M /J?=CW=;FFS B;JN?L =IP?LM GI>?FM @IL PIF;NCFCNS NB;N CH=FO>? NB? ONIL?AL?MMCP? ;H> IH>CNCIH;F $?N?LIME?>;M NC=CNS =F;MM I@ GI>?FM ;H> MIG? H?Q ?RN?HMCIHM MO=B ;M # . $ GI>?FM QCNB DOGJM ;H> L?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS GI>?FM 3CNB BCAB @L?KO?H=S >;N; ;SM L?;FCT?> PIF;NCFCNS CM ?RJ?=N?> NI L?G;CH ;H ;L?; I@ ;=NCP? L?M?;L=B 0BCM =B;JN?L ;FMI >?M=LCCM =OMM?> CMMO?M IH # . $ ;AAL?A;NCIH ;H> NB? L?F;NCIHMBCJ ?F CH =IHNCHOIOM NCG? ;H> NB? >CM=L?N? NCG? # . $ GI>?F FNBIOAB NCG? P;LSCHA PIF;NCFCNS ;H> PIF;NCFCNS ;MSGG?NLS G;S JLI>O=? NBC=E N;CF ;H> ;MSGG?NLC= >CMNLCCMNLC
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
+JNCIH JLC=CHA QCNB HIH #;OMMC;H >CMNLC
I@ ?RNL?G? ?P?HNM %H J;LNC=OF;L Q? ?RJF;CH BIQ NI GI>?F NB? >CMNLC NB? >CMNLC;H=?M ; %H ; GOFNCP;LC;N? =IHN?RN Q? ;FMI BCABFCABN NB? CGJILN;HN >C_?L?H=? ?J?H>?H=? ;H> ;MSGJNINC= CH>?J?H>?H=? ;H> >?M=LC
9952,*=287< 8/ 787*><<2*7 .,8786.=;2,< ,;LN %%% JL?M?HNM MIG? ?R;GJF?M I@ ;JJFC=;NCIHM I@ NB? GI>?FM >?M=LC CH ,;LN %% FF NB?M? ;JJFC=;NCIHM ;L? CGJILN;HN ;H> I@ LIONCH? OM? CH NB? W H;H=? CH>OMNLS .?;>?LM MBIOF> ;@N?L L?;>CHA NBCM J;LN NB;N NB? HIH #;OMMC;H GI>?FM ;L? HIN IHFS CH>CMJ?HM;?FCHA
CHA /J?=CW=;FFS B;JN?L >?;FM QCNB LCME G;H;A?G?HN ;H> NB? 2;FO? ;N .CME 2;. G?;MOL? CHNLI>O=?> <S NB? ;M?F ==IL>M 0B? CH>OMNLS ?F CM <;M?> IH HILG;F >CMNLC?M=LCCMNLC QCNB JILN@IFCI =IHMNLO=NCIH ;H> ;MM?N ;FFI=;NCIH );LEIQCNTZM G?;H P;LC;H=? ;H;FSMCM CM ;JJLIJLC;N? @IL #;OMMC;H >CMNLCL;NC= ONCFCNS @OH=NCIH IHFS %H NB? =IHN?RN I@ HIH HILG;F L?NOLHM NBCM ;JJLI;=B G;S HIN BIF> ;HSGIL? 0B? G;CH C>?; CM NB;N NB? CHP?MNILZM ?RJ?=N?> ONCFCNS G;S ;M ; @OH=NCIH I@ G?;H P;LC;H=? BCAB EOLNIMCM ;H> CH @;PIL I@ JIMCNCP? ME?QH?MM 3? QCFF ;FMI MBIQ CH NBCM =B;JN?L BIQ >IQHMC>? LCME =IHMNL;CHN ;_?=NM ;MM?N ;FFI=;NCIH >?=CMCIHM
!9=287 9;2,270 @2=1 787*><<2*7 -2<=;2+>=287< ,;LN %2 >?;FM QCNB >?LCP;NCP? ;MM?NM ;H> =IHMC>?LM IJNCIH JLC=CHA QB?H NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N L?NOLH B;M ; HIH #;OMMC;H >CMNLC /=BIF?M ;H> )?LNIH F;C> NB? @IOH>;NCIH I@ JLC=CHA <S HI ;L F;N?L JLC=CHA <S ?KOCP;F?HN G;LNCHA;F? G?;MOL? 0BCM GI>?F QBC=B ?MM?HNC;FFS ;MMOG?M HILG;FCNS ;H> NCG? CH>?J?H>?H=? I@ JLC=? =B;HA?M B;M O=? MIG? Q?FF EHIQH MNSFCT?> @;=NM MO=B ;M NB? PIF;NCFCNS MGCF? IL NB? N?LG MNLO=NOL? I@ PIF;NCFCNC?M M @IL NB? GI>?FCHA I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM IJNCIH JLC=CHA GI>?FM B;P? NI CH=ILJIL;N? NB? PIF;NCFCNS =FOMN?LCHA ;H> NB? HIH HILG;FCNS I@ NB? =IH>C NCIH;F >CMNLC?FM NB? GIMN Q?FF EHIQH CM NB? MNI=B;M NC= PIF;NCFCNS GI>?F ;H> NB? GI>?FM QCNB DOGJM O? NI NB? G;NB?G;NC=;F
+HFS NB? G?;H ;H> P;LC;H=? N?LGM ;L? L?F?P;HN QB?H ;MM?N JLC=CHA CM <;M?> IH ; KO;>L;NC= ONCFCNS @OH=NCIH
%HNLI>O=NCIH
=IHN?HN I@ NB?M? IJNCIH JLC=CHA GI>?FM Q? B;P? JLIPC>?> WP? MOJJILN =B;J N?LM CH NB? ;JJ?H>C=?M CH ,;LN 2 MI NB;N ,;LN %2 CM HIN IP?LFS =FONN?L?> <S G;NB?G;NC=;F ;<MNL;=NCIH 3? B;P? G;>? ?P?LS ?_ILN CH ?HMOLCHA NB;N NB?M? NQI J;LNM ;L? ;==?MMC?LM %H B;JN?L Q? AI NBLIOAB NB? @OH>;G?HN;F CHA ?F ;H> OM? CN ;M ;H ?R;GJF? NI CHNLI>O=? NB? E?S G;NB?G;NC=;F =IH=?JNM MO=B ;M LIQHC;H GINCIH ;H> MNI=B;MNC= =;F =OFOM B;JN?L ;H> G;LNCHA;F? ;H> =B;HACHA G?;MOL? B;JN?L 0B? /) GI>?F CM <;M?> IH NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N L?NOLH B;PCHA ; HILG;F >CMNLC ?F Q;M L?=IAHCT?> NB? CGJFC?> PIF;NCFCNS MGCF? Q;M L?JILN?> CH>C=;NCHA NB;N NB? HILG;FCNS ;MMOGJ NCIH CM CH=IHMCMN?HN QCNB IJNCIH JLC=? >;N; *?P?LNB?F?MM ;H> >?MJCN? NB? /) JLC=CHA CLL?AOF;LCNC?M NB? JIJOF;LCNS I@ NB? /) GI>?F MOLPCP?M ?P?H NI>;S "LIG NB? /) GI>?F CN ?G?LA?M NB;N IJNCIHM =;H OMCHA LCME H?O NL;F >?HMCNC?M .* L??>?H ;H> (CNT?H @LIG NB? IJNCIH JLC=?M *IN IHFS NB;N .* =;H @IL JLC=CHA INB?L NSJC=;FFS NB? F?MM FCKOC> ;H> GIL? ?RINC= >?LCP ;NCP?M QLCNN?H IH NB? M;G? OH>?LFSCHA .* NI GIL? L?MJIHMCP? NI H?QM NB;H NB? ;=NO;F >?HMCNC?M I @LIG NB? JLC=?M I@ NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N ON NB? GIMN CGJILN;HN @;=N CM NB;N NB?M? ?GJCLC=;FFS I .* M ;L? ;FGIMN ?R=FOMCP?FS HIH #;OMMC;H B;JN?L =IP?LM ; QBIF? L;HA? I@ J;L;G?NLC= ;H> HIH J;L;G?NLC= G?NB I>M @IL ?RNL;=NCHA .* M 0B?M? N?=BHCKO?M >I HIN ;MMOG? ; MJ?=CW= GI>?F @IL NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N 0BCM CM NB? L?;MIH QBS Q? =;FF?> NBCM =B;JN?L NB? [HIH MNLO=NOL;F\ ;JJLI;=B NI IJNCIH JLC=CHA %H NB? F;MN =B;JN?L B;JN?L Q? JON ?RN?HMCIHM I@ NB? /) GI>?F CHNI QB;N Q? =;FF [MNLO=NOL;F\ IJNCIH JLC=CHA GI>?FM MNLO=NOL;F CH NB? M?HM? NB;N Q? HIQ B;P? ; MJ?=CW= >SH;GC= @IL NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N JLC=? ;H> MIG?NCG?M ; MJ?=CW= >SH;GC= @IL NB? PIF;NCFCNS ;FMI 0BCM =B;JN?L CM NB? GIMN G;NB?G;NC =;FFS >?G;H>CHA ;H> QIOF> L?KOCL? NB? MOJJILN I@ B;JN?LM ;H> @IL NB? G;NB?G;NC=;FFS F?MM CH=FCH?> L?;>?LM ON NBCM =B;JN?L ;FMI NLOFS L?X?=NM NB? HIH #;OMMC;H H;NOL? I@ NB? OH>?LFSCHA ;MM?N >CMNLC MCT?M\ ;L? J?LGCNN?> ;N PIF;NCFCNS F?P?FM N NB? NCG? I@ QLCNCHA NBCM CM NB? =ONNCHA ?>A? I@ IJNCIH JLC=CHA ;M Q? EHIQ CN
%=*=2<=2,*5 ";89.;=2.< 8/ 27*7,2*5 *;4.= *=*
%H NBCM =B;JN?L Q? >?M=LC? MIG? >?WHCNCIHM NB;N ;L? OM?@OF @IL NB? L?MN I@ NB? ;L? Q?FF EHIQH ?GJB;MCM CM JF;=?> IH =LCNC=;F CMMO?M =IH=?LHCHA NB? ?MNCG;NCIH ;H> NB? ;JJFC=;NCIHM I@ NB?M? MN;NCMNC=;F G?;MOL?M 0B?H Q? =IHMC>?L NB? P;LCIOM ;MJ?=NM I@ NB? L?NOLH >CMNLC;L> ;MMOGJNCIH I@ HILG;FCNS CM L?D?=N?> @IL MNI=E G;LE?N L?NOLHM G;CHFS N;CF NBC=EH?MM I@ NB? L?NOLH >CMNLCCM=OMM NCG? >?J?H>?H=? ;H> >?GIHMNL;N? NB? MNLIHA PIF;NCFCNS =FOMN?LCHA CH WH;H=C;F G;LE?NM /?=NCIH >CM=OMM?M =ILL? F;NCIH ;=LIMM ;MM?N L?NOLHM CNM NCG? P;LSCHA H;NOL? ;H> NB? CGJFC=;NCIH I@ =B;HACHA >?J?H>?H=? IH ;MM?N ;FFI=;NCIH $IQ?P?L =ILL?F;NCIH CM HIN ; P;FC> G?;MOL? @IL >?J?H>?H=? QB?H L?NOLHM ;L? HIH HILG;F +NB?L G?;MOL?M @IL >?J?H>?H=? ;L? JLIPC>?> CH B;JN?L "CH;FFS QB?H NB? >CMNLC L?F?P;HN NI =IHMC>?L GOFNCP;LC;N? GIG?HNM MO=B ;M =I ME?QH?MM ;H> =I EOLNIMCM 0BCM CM =IP?L?> CH /?=NCIH "CH;H=C;F GI>?FCHA >?;FM QCNB =;JNOLCHA NB? G;CH =B;L;=N?LCMNC=M I@ L?NOLH >CMNLC;N; C>?HNCW?> CH NBCM =B;JN?L QCFF M?LP? ;M NB? <;=E
B;JN?L >?M=LC?FM ?RJF;CHCHA MIG? I@ NB? I<M?LP?> MN;NCMNC=;F JLIJ?LNC?M ;H> B;JN?LM ;H> QCFF >?P?FIJ NB? NIIFM H?=?MM;LS @IL GI>?FCHA NCG? >?J?H>?H=S ;H> HIH HILG;FCNS CH JL;=NC=?
.D72=287< 8/ ;.=>;7< FNBIOAB JLC=?M ;L? QB;N Q? I<M?LP? CH WH;H=C;F G;LE?NM GIMN ?GJCLC=;F MNO> C?M @I=OM IH L?NOLHM 0B? L?;MIH CM NB;N CH A?H?L;F JLC=?M ;L? HIH MN;NCIH;LS QB?L?;M L?NOLHM ;L? MN;NCIH;LS 0B?L? ;L? M?P?L;F L?NOLH >?WHCNCIHM ?;=B I@ QBC=B JLI>O=?M ; >C_?L?HN M?N I@ JLIJ?LNC?M @IL L?NOLHM 3? GIL? MJ?=CW=;FFS @I=OM IH MCGJF? L?NOLHM ;H> FIA L?NOLHM
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N
;N;
%2695. ;.=>;7< 0B? IH? J?LCI> MCGJF? L?NOLH @IL BIF>CHA ;H ;MM?N CM >N
IL
N (
QB?L? CHA >CPC>?H>M I@ NB? ;MM?N ;N NCG? [ ;H> >N CM NB? IH? J?LCI> MCGJF? L?NOLH @LIG NCG? [ NI [ %@ Q? BIF> NB? ;MM?N @IL R J?LCI>M @LIG [ R NI [ Q? B;P? NB? R J?LCI> MCGJF? L?NOLH N R ( N R NF >N ( QB?L? >N R CM NB? R J?LCI> MCGJF? L?NOLH @LIG [R NI [ 0B?L?@IL? NB? L?F;NCIH L?NOLH ;H> R J?LCI> L?NOLH CM HIH FCH?;L
>N R
F -
>NE '
E
%H MIG? =;M?M C@ L?NOLHM ;L? MG;FF Q? G;S OM? NB? ;JJLIRCG;NCIH >N R
F ,
>NE (
E
? CH G;HS ;JJFC=;NCIHM +H NB? INB?L B;H> NB? MCGJF? L?NOLH I@ ;H : ;MM?N JILN@IFCI CM MCGJFS NB? Q?CABN?> ;P?L;A? I@ NB? CH>CPC>O;F MCGJF? L?NOLHM I@ NB? : ;MM?NM >?HIN?> >D N ( @IL P ( ( : (?N W >?HIN? NB? JILN@IFCI QCNB CHP?MNG?HN Q?CABN " D ). IH ;MM?N P ;H> D " D 0B?H NB? JILN@IFCI L?NOLH CM >J N
. ,
" D >D N '
D
80;.=>;7< H
%@ ; <;HE J;SM ;H ;HHO;F CHN?L?MN I@ >N T NCG?M ; S?;L NB? CHN?L?MN L;N? H @IL ?;=B OHCN I@ CHP?MNG?HN CM <S >?WHCNCIH >N *T ;H> ;@N?L IH? S?;L NB? H
H
%H NB? FCGCNCHA =;M? QB?L? NB? >N NIN;F P;FO? I@ NB? >?JIMCN CM H CHN?L?MN CM =OGOF;N?> =IHNCHOIOMFS T Q? B;P?
H
H &%' >N LL* ' H T
?WHCNCIHM I@ L?NOLHM
3? >?>O=? NB;N YN NB? =IHNCHOIOMFS =IGJIOH>?> L?NOLH IL FIA L?NOLH CM YN &)# P;HN;A? I@ NB? FIA L?NOLH CM NB;N NB? GOFNCJF? J?LCI> L?NOLH CM MCGJFS NB? MOG I@ IH? J?LCI> L?NOLHM MI NB;N YN R &)# >N R
F )
&)# >NE
E
F ,
YNE '
E
*IQ NB? FIA L?NOLH I@ ; JILN@IFCI >I?M HIN B;P? NB? M;G? =IHP?HC?HN JLIJ?LNS ;M NB? =;M? QCNB MCGJF? L?NOLH %H>??> NB? JILN@IFCI FIA L?NOLH YJ N CM YJ N &)#
. , D
" D LL *
. ,
" D YD N '
D
ON NBCM JLI?L?> ;M GCHIL CH ?GJCLC=;F ;JJFC=;NCIHM
%=B52C.- /*,=< N WLMN MCABN NB?L? CM HI L?;MIH QBS =IGGI>CNS JLC=? MNI=E JLC=? IL ?R=B;HA? L;N? MBIOF> C?M B;P? C>?HNCW?> ; M?N I@ =IGGIH @?;NOL?M ;GIHA WH;H=C;F >;N; NB;N ;L? EHIQH ;M @AF96G21 3.0A@ IHN CH J;LNC=OF;L JLIPC>?M ; =IGJL?B?HMCP? MOLP?S I@ NB?M? MNSFCT?> @;=NM QBC=B CH=FO>? .A A.69@ 0B? OH=IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLC @LIG ; HILG;F >CMNLCCMNLC?F WH;H=C;F L?NOLHM Q? QCFF OH>?L?MNCG;N? NB? HOG G;AHCNO>? I@ =L;MB?M ;H> CNCIH;F >CMNLC MOAA?MN CHA NB;N ?RNL?G? H?A;NCP? L?NOLHM ;L? GIL? @L?KO?HN NB;H ?RNL?G? JIMCNCP? L?NOLHM 0B? ;MSGG?NLS ;H> @;N N;CF JB?HIG?H; J?LMCMN ?P?H ;@N?L ;>DOMN CHA @IL =IH>CNCIH;F B?N?LIME?>;MNC=CNS IL =B;HACHA PIF;NCFCNS G?;HCHA NB;N NB? =IH>CNCIH;F >CMNLCCMNLCCMNLCI HIN >CMJF;S MCAHCW=;HN M?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIH ?R=?JN ;N BCAB @L?KO?H=S
/?? @IL ?R;GJF? IFF?LMF?P BIO ;H> 'LIH?L ,;A;H /B?JB;L> ;GJ );='CHF;S IHN ;H> #IOLCfLIOR ;H> &;MC;E ;
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N
;N;
*<9.A696AF 09B@A2?6;4 2IF;NCFCNS I@ L?NOLHM CM M?LC;FFS =ILL?F;N?> MOAA?MNCHA NB;N ; F;LA? JIMCNCP? IL H?A;NCP? L?NOLH N?H>M NI <S ;HINB?L F;LA? JIMCNCP? IL H?A;NCP? L?NOLH GIHA NB? JLIRC?M @IL PIF;NCFCNS ;< MIFON? L?NOLHM ;JJ?;L NI (6:2C.?F6;4 0?<@@0M NI CH=L?;M? >OLCHA BCAB PIF;NCFCNS J?LCI>M CH J;LNC=OF;L >OLCHA =L;MB?M %H NB? @IFFIQCHA M?=NCIHM Q? QCFF OM? WH;H=C;F G;LE?N >;N; NI CFFOMNL;N? NB?M? MNSFCT?> @;=NM ;H> NI M?? BIQ ;AAL?A;NCIH IL F?HANB?HCHA I@ >;N; @L? KO?H=S ;_?=NM NB?M? MNSFCT?> @;=NM 0B? >;N; =IHMCMNM I@ FIA L?NOLHM IH @IOL MNI=E G;LE?N CH>C=?M H;G?FS NB? /N;H>;L> ;H> ,IILZM /, @LIG NB? 1/ NB? 4 @LIG #?LG;HS NB? "0/! FF /B;L?M @LIG NB? 1' ;H> NB? *CEE?C @LIG &;J;H 0B? M;GJF? J?LCI> =IP?LM &;HO;LS NI OAOMN
2<=;2+>=287 8/ ;.=>;7< "CAOL? >CMJF;SM NB? FIA L?NOLHM IH @IOL MNI=E G;LE?N CH>C=?M !RNL?G? H?A;NCP? L?NOLHM ;JJ?;L NI NB;H ?RNL?G? JIMCNCP? L?NOLHM "CAOL? >CMJF;SM NB? BCMNIAL;G I@ NB? FIA L?NOLHM QBC=B MBIQ NB? ?GJCLC=;F >CMNLC B;P? N;CFM NB;N >I HIN P;HCMB ;M @;MN ;M NBIM? I@ NB? HILG;F >CMNLC <S NB? GCHCGOG ;H> G;RCGOG L?NOLHM L?JILN?> CH 0;
&*+5. !6:6:B: .;1 :.E6:B: <3 1.69F 9<4?2AB?;@ /, 4 "0 /! *CEE?C )CHCGOG
);RCGOG
86.7=< 8/ * ;*7-86 ?*;2*+5. %H NBCM CMNLC <S GIG?HNM NB;N ;L? BCAB?L NB;H NB? M?=IH> IL>?L IHMC>?L ; =IHNCHOIOM L;H>IG P;LC;
%H NBCM M .B@@6.; ;H> ;CMNLCC?> ;M ?;LFS ;M <S >? )ICPL? (;N?L IH (;JF;=? ;H> #;OMM OM?> CN NI GI>?F F?;MN MKO;L? ?LLILM $?H=? NB? #;OMMC;H >CMNLC NI ;M NB? #;OMM (;JF;=? >CMNLC
CMNLC
SP500
DAX
10
10 5
0
0
-10 -5
-20
-10
-30 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
-15 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
FT-SE
Nikkei
10
20 10
0
0 -10
-10
-20 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
-20 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
20 C<9BA6<; <3 1.69F 9<4?2AB?;@
SP500
DAX
2500
1500
2000 1000
1500
1000
500
500 0 -30
-20
-10
0
10
0 -20
-10
FT-SE
0
10
Nikkei
2000
3000
1500
2000
1000 1000
500 0 -20
-10
0
10
0 -20
-10
0
20 6@A<4?.: <3 1.69F 9<4?2AB?;@
10
20
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N
28 _ + D _
.
;N;
R
M8 \ K\(
QB?L? M8 CM NB? =? GIG?HNM I@ D ;L? >?WH?> ;M . TF 1 D F _F M8 _ K_( @IL R ( ( '
0B? WLMN HIH =?HNL;F GIG?HN T 1 D CM NB? G?;H I@ D #CP?H NB? G?;H T NB? =?HN?L?> GIG?HNM I@ D ;L? >?WH?> ;M 5 . 4 F F F 1 D T _ T M8 _ K_( @IL R ( ( '
S =IHMNLO=NCIH 0B? M?=IH> =?HN?L?> GIG?HN CM NB? P;LC;H=? I@ D B D T T 0B? NBCL> ;H> @IOLNB =?HN?L?> GIG?HNM ;H> ;L? L?MJ?=NCP?FS NB? HIH MN;H>;L>CT?> ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM 0B? MN;H >;L>CT?> ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM IL MCGJFS ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM ;L? >?WH?> ;M D Z ?R D 1
( D ' 7\ D 1 '82D;2@@ ?R D >?JC=NM NB? ;MSGG?NLS I@ NB? >CMNLCCM NLC NB;H ?RJ?=N?> @LIG ; HILG;F >CMNLC CFFOMNL;N? BIQ CHNLI>O=CHA ;MSGG?NLS IL @;N N;CFM QIOF> ;_?=N NB? MB;J? I@ ; >CMNLCCMNLCCMNLC <S ; AL?;N?L JLI<;CMNLC BCAB?L J?;E CH NB? =?HN?L QB?H =IGJ;L?> QCNB NB? HILG;F >CMNLC
%H "CAOL? NB? ;MSGG?NLC= >CMNLC @LIG NB? MI =;FF?> ME?Q?> /NO>?HN I >CMNLC?AL??M I@ @L??>IG ;H> ME?QH?MM J;L;G?N?LM ;H> L?MJ?=NCP?FS @IL NB? FIHA >;MB FCH? ;H> NB? MIFC> FCH? M?? /?=NCIH %H "CAOL? NB? @;N N;CF?> >CMNLC?HN I >CMNLC >?AL??M I@ @L??>IG L?MJ?=NCP?FS @IL NB? FIHA >;MB FCH? ;H> NB? MIFC> FCH?
CMNLC
0.6 Norm al Neg. s kewnes s Pos . s kewnes s
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0 -8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
20 E.:=92@ <3 .@F::2A?60 16@A?6/BA6<;@
0.4 Norm al t(5) t(2)
0.35
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0 -8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
20 E.:=92@ <3 16@A?6/BA6<;@ D6A5 3.A A.69@
8
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N
;N;
0B? HILG;F >CMNLC EOLNIMCM ;FQ;SM ?KO;F NI FF @OLNB?L GIG?HNM ;L? ?CNB?L I>> GIG?HNM IL @OH=NCIHM I@ ;H> ?P?H GIG?HNM $?H=? ; HILG;F >CMNLC?HNCW?> <S CNM G?;H ;H> P;LC;H=? FMI ;M >CMNLC QCNB NB? HILG;F >CMNLC CHMN?;> I@ NB? EOLNIMCM CNM?F@ )IMN WH;H=C;F ;MM?N L?NOLHM B;P? EOLNIMCM P;FO?M AL?;N?L NB;H ;H> MNI=E G;LE?N L?NOLH CH J;LNC=OF;L CM MNLIHAFS @?;NOL?> <S ; H?A;NCP? ME?QH?MM +NB?L WH;H=C;F M?LC?M MO=B ;M CHN?L?MN L;N?M L?NOLHM IH =IGGI>CNC?M IL IH B?>A? @OH>M G;S B;P? JIMCNCP? ME?QH?MM "CH;FFS @IL?CAH ?R=B;HA? L;N?M G;S B;P? JIMCNCP? ;M Q?FF ;M H?A;NCP? ME?QH?MM >?J?H>CHA IH NB? Q;S NB?S ;L? =IGJON?>
692;2,*5 686.7=< .*<>;.< 8/ 58,*=287 4
*IQ =IHMC>?L ; NCG? M?LC?M I@ L?;FCT?> L?NOLHM 'YN (N 0B? GIMN =IGGIHFS OM?> G?;MOL?M I@ FI=;NCIH ;L? @.:=92 :2.; Y ;H> :216.; T 0B? M;GJF? G?;H CM =;F=OF;N?> ;M 4
, Y YN ' @ N 4
%@ 'YN (N B;M ; MSGG?NLC= >CMNLCC;H CM >?WH?> ;M NB? NB J?L=?HNCF? I@ NB? M;GJF? %H INB?L QIL>M I@ NB? M;GJF? B;M ; P;FO? FIQ?L NB;H T TLK Y C ?
+ YN T + YN T
'
)?;H ;M ; G?;MOL? @IL FI=;NCIH CM M?HMCNCP? NI IONFC?LM +H? ?LLIH?IOMFS L?=IL>?> P;FO? =IOF> JIN?HNC;FFS GIP? NB? G?;H ;Q;S @LIG NB? =?HNL;F J;LN I@ NB? >CMNLCC;H CM GIL? LI
I?M HIN L?FS IH NB? JL?=CM? P;FO? I@ NB? L?;FCT;NCIHM INB?L NB;H NB? G?>C;H CNM?F@ .*<>;.< 8/ -2<9.;<287 2;LC;H=? CM ; JIJOF;L G?;MOL? I@ >CMJ?LMCIH ;H> CN CM NB? IJNCG;F G?;MOL? @IL >CMJ?LMCIH C@ L?NOLHM B;P? ; HILG;F >CMNLC @.:=92 C.?6.;02 =;H @LIG ; M?N I@ L?NOLHM ;M
%H NBCM ?HIN? ?MNCG;N?M QCNB ; B;N 9 *IN? NB;N CM HIN NB? );RCGOG (CE?FCBII> )( ?MNCG;NIL I@ NB? P;LC;H=? OH>?L HILG;FCNS "IL ; HILG;F >CMNLC
CMNLC
4
, YN Y ' @ N
%H WH;H=? NB? MN;H>;L> >?PC;NCIH NB? MKO;L? LIIN I@ P;LC;H=? CM I@N?H OM?> NI G?;H PIF;NCFCNS /CH=? NB? MN;NCMNC=;F JLIJ?LNC?M I@ M;GJF? G?;H G;E? CN ; P?LS CH;==OL;N? ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? NLO? G?;H ?MJ?=C;FFS @IL MG;FF M;GJF?M N;E CHA >?PC;NCIHM ;LIOH> T?LI CHMN?;> I@ NB? M;GJF? G?;H ;M CH NSJC=;FFS CH=L?;M?M PIF;NCFCNS @IL?=;MN ;==OL;=S 0B?L? ;L? G?NBI>M @IL ?MNCG;NCHA PIF;NCF CNS NB;N ;L? >?MCAH?> NI ?RJFICN IL L?>O=? NB? CHXO?H=? I@ ?RNL?G?M M?? ;FF ;H> 0ILIOM ,;LECHMIH IL #;LG;H ;H> 'F;MM ON NB?M? G?NBI>M A?H?L;FFS L?FS IH NB? ;MMOGJNCIH I@ HILG;FCNS I@ L?NOLHM QBC=B CM HIN FCE?FS CH NB? =;M? I@ WH;H=C;F G;LE?N M?LC?M HINB?L CHN?L?MNCHA G?;MOL? I@ >CMJ?LMCIH CM NB? :2.; ./@<9BA2 12C6.A6<; 9 -0 %N CM =IGJON?> ;M 9 -0
4
, )YN Y) ' @ N
0B? 9 -0 CM GIL? LIB.?A692 ?.;42 5=> CM NB? >C_?L?H=? NB J?L=?HNCF?M I@ NB? >;N; /CH=? IHFS NB? GC>>F? I@ NB? >;N; ;_?=NM NBCM G?;MOL? CN CM LI;L>CT?> ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM ;L? =IGJON?> L?MJ?=NCP?FS
;M
4
, YN Y Z ( @ N ;H>
4
, YN Y ' @ N
1H>?L NB? ;MMOGJNCIH I@ HILG;FCNS Q? B;P? NB? @IFFIQCHA ;MSGJNINC= >CMNLC ;FF ;H> /NO;LN + + ( ( @ ( @ +
@ Z
(
+
@
( (
3BCF? CH ?KO;NCIH CM ;H OH ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? MKO;L? LIIN I@ CM ; ?MNCG;N? I@ >O? NI &?HM?H CH?KO;FCNS IR ;H> .O ;MMOGCHA ; HILG;F >CMNLC
CH GIMN =;M?M NB? CGJ;=N I@ NBCM ;>DOMNG?HN CM MG;FF
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N
;N;
QB?L? [\ >?HIN?M ;MSGJNINC= =IHP?LA?H=? O? NI NB? F;LA? P;FO? I@ NB?CL ;MSGJNINC= P;LC;H=?M M;GJF? ME?QH?MM ;H> M;GJF? EOLNIMCM ;L? CH@ILG;NCP? IHFS @IL F;LA? M;GJF?M 0B?M? ;MSGJNINC= >CMNLC NI J?L@ILG MN;NCMNC=;F N?MNM IH NB? >CMNLC?M=LC CH NB? H?RN MO<M?=NCIH FF NB? MN;NCMNC=M >?M=LC ; ;M MOGG;LS MN;NCMNC=M 0; ;N >C_?L?HN >;N; @L?KO?H=C?M %@ Q? L;HE NB? L?NOLHM <;M?> IH NB? MOGG;LS MN;NCMNC=M Q? HIN? NB;N NB? L;HEM JLI>O=?> <S NB? G?;H ;L? MCGCF;L NI NBIM? JLI>O=?> <S NB? G?>C;H /CGCF;LFS OMCHA MN;H>;L> >?PC;NCIH IL 9 -0 NI L;HE L?NOLHM >I?M HIN JLI>O=? P;MNFS >C_?L?HN L?MOFNM M ?RJ?=N?> G?>C;H ;H> 9 -0 ;L? F?MM >CMJ?LM?> P;LC;H=? >?LCP?> @LIG >;CFS Q??EFS ;H> GIHNBFS >;N; CM MCGCF;L NI NB? P;LC;H=? I@ ;HHO;F >;N; FNBIOAB NB? M;G? CM HIN NLO? @IL ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM NB?L? CM HI MSMN?G;NC= J;NN?LH ;CFS ;H> ;HHO;F L?NOLHM "IL CHMN;H=? NB? >;CFS ME?QH?MM I@ /, CM F;LA?L NB;H NB? ;HHO;F ME?QH?MM
&.<=270 /8; 78;6*52=B %N B;M @IL ; FIHA NCG? NB;N GIMN WH;H=C;F ;MM?N L?NOLHM ;L? HIH HILG;F );H>?F ";G; 0BCM HIH HILG;FCNS CM MNLIHAFS @?;NOL?> CH NQI MN;NCMNC=;F JB?HIG?H; C !RNL?G? ?P?HNM I==OL GIL? I@N?H NB;H JL?>C=N?> <S ; HILG;F >CMNLC?F #IH?>?M 'IH ;H> CC =L;MB?M I==OL GIL? I@N?H NB;H CNNC /CGEIQCNT ;H> ??>F?M /CHAF?NIH ;H> 3CHA?H>?L ,B?HIG?HIH C =ILL?MJIH>M NI ?R=?MM EOLNIMCM IL 3.A A.69@ QB?L?;M JB?HIG?HIH CC CM ;MMI=C;N?> QCNB H?A;NCP? ME?QH?MM IL .@F: :2A?F "IFFIQCHA );H>?F CMMO?M B;P? >L?MM?> CH NB? WH;H=? FCN?L;NOL? >I?M NB? HILG;FCNS ;MMOGJNCIH BIF> @IL ;MM?N L?NOLHM %@ HIN NI QB;N ?RN?HN ;L? L?NOLHM HIH HILG;F %H NBCM =B;JN?L Q? @I=OM IH OH=IH>CNCIH;F HILG;FCNS 0B;N CM @IL NB? GIG?HN Q? ;MMOG? NB;N L?NOLHM >CMNLCI?M HIN =B;HA? NBLIOAB NCG? %H B;JN?L Q? QCFF L?F;R NBCM ;MMOGJNCIH ;H> ;FFIQ >CMNLCCNCIH;FFS NI MIG? >CMNLC?P?FIJ?> <;M?> IH NB? GI G?HNM IL IH NB? >?HMCNS @OH=NCIH I@ NB? >CMNLC M?LC?M 3? QCFF >?M=LC IH JLIJ?LNC?M I@ NB? ILCACH;F >CMNLC?FS OM?> N?MN CH NBCM =;N?AILS CM >O? NI &;LKO? ;H> ?L; ;H> ?L; ;H> &;LKO? QBI L?FS IH NB? @;=N NB;N ME?QH?MM ;H> ?R=?MM EOLNIMCM ;L? CMNLC ?L;
CMNLC
&*+5. 'B::.?F @A.A6@A60@ <3 9<4?2AB?;@
)?;H )?>C;H /N> >?PC;NCIH ) %-. HH G?;H HH MN> >?P /E?QH?MM 'OLNIMCM )?;H )?>C;H /N> >?PC;NCIH ) %-. HH G?;H HH MN> >?P /E?QH?MM 'OLNIMCM )?;H )?>C;H /N> >?PC;NCIH ) %-. HH G?;H HH MN> >?P /E?QH?MM 'OLNIMCM )?;H )?>C;H /N> >?PC;NCIH ) %-. /E?QH?MM 'OLNIMCM
/, 4 "0 /! *CEE?C ;CFS @L?KO?H=S I<M?LP;NCIHM
3??EFS @L?KO?H=S I<M?LP;NCIHM
)IHNBFS @L?KO?H=S I<M?LP;NCIHM
HHO;F @L?KO?H=S I<M?LP;NCIHM
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N
;N;
MBIQ @IL 661 ;H> HILG;FFS >CMNLC L;H>IG P;LC;;L>CT?> ME?QH?MM ;H> ?R=?MM EOLNIMCM ;L? ;MSGJNINC=;FFS CH>?J?H>?HN ;H> B;P? NB? @IFFIQCHA ;MSGJNINC= >CMNLC
(
;H>
8 *@ (
( '
?L; ;H> &;LKO?ZM C>?; @IL N?MNCHA HILG;FCNS CM NI OM? NB? 6. N?MN MN;NCMNC= >?WH?> ;M Z
6. @ ( QBC=B CM ;MSGJNINC=;FFS >CMNLC ;M 0B? GIMN M?P?L? FCGCN;NCIH I@ NB? 6. N?MN CM NB;N NB? ;MSGJNINC= >CMNLCM IHFS @IL P?LS F;LA? M;GJF?M 0I N;E? CHNI ;==IOHN NB? WHCN? M;GJF? $;HM?H JLIJIM? ;H [IGHCO=? ;JJLIRCG;NCIHM @IL NB? WHCN? M;GJF? >CMNLC EOLNIMCM OH>?L NB? ;MMOGJNCIH I@ HILG;FCNS ;H> QCNB NB? ;>>CNCIH;F ;MMOGJNCIHM NB;N NB? EOLNIMCM B;M ; #;GG; >CMNLC NB;N + Z 1MCHA a ;H> a NI >?HIN? NB? WHCN? M;GJF? ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM IILHCE ;H> $;HM?H MBIQ QCNB NB? HILG;FCNS ;MMOGJNCIH NB;N 0 a a C
( 8 &)# N N (
<JJ
a 8
a
&)# "
+ (
QB?L? >?HIN?M ;JJLIRCG;N? >CMNLC <JJ
;
" @ @
( @
8 " I ( Z ( I N Z
I I Z (
;H> QCNB NB? @IFFIQCHA =ILL?=NCIH @;=NILM @IL WHCN? M;GJF?
H ;JJLIRCG;NCIH I@ WHCN? M;GJF? >CMNLC CH Z AIMNCHI
I I I I
CMNLC
@ @ @ @
( @ @ @ @
@ @ @ @
@ (
@ @ @ @ @ ( @ @ @ @ @ ( @ @ @ @
M?=IH> >L;Q<;=E I@ NB? 6. N?MN CM NB;N NB? ?GJCLC=;F ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM ;L? =IGJON?> @IL ACP?H P;FO?M I@ G?;H ;H> P;LC;H=? MIH ;H> /GCNB ;H> $;LP?S CH>?J?H>?HNFS JLIJIM? DICHN ?MNCG;NCIH I@ NB? GIG?HNM <;M?> IH NB? #)) #?H?L;FCT?> )?NBI> I@ )IG?HNM ILNBIAIH;FCNS =IH>CNCIHM L N YN Y(
L N YN Y (
L N YN Y * Z(
L N YN Y * ' /IFPCHA NB? ILNBIAIH;FCNS =IH>CNCIHM <S NB? G?NBI> I@ GIG?HNM SC?F>M ; DICHN ?MNCG;N? I@ NB? WLMN @IOL GIG?HNM ( ( Z( ;H> ;H ;MMI=C;N?> =I P;LC;H=? G;NLCR 4 QBC=B B?FJM NI L?GIP? NB? >?J?H>?H=? IH NB? ;MSGJNINC= >CMNLC?L NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM I@ HILG;FCNS Q? B;P? Z 0B? N?MN CM J?L@ILG?> <S ; 3;F> N?MN OMCHA NB? MN;NCMNC=
C @ 3 34 3 3 ( QB?L?
3
'
1H>?L NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM I@ HILG;FCNS C CM >CMNLC ;M ; ' "IL NB? =;M? I@ Q?;EFS >?J?H>?HN >;N; ;C ;H> *A JLIPC>? NB? M;GJFCHA >CMNLC EOLNIMCM ?MNCG;NILM ;H> JLIJIM? ; DICHN N?MN @IL HILG;FCNS NB;N N;E?M NBCM M;GJFCHA >CMNLC
.C=B;L>MIH ;H> /GCNB ?MNCG;N? ;FF @IOL GIG?HNM ;H> N?MN QB?NB?L ME?Q H?MM ;H> ?R=?MM EOLNIMCM ;L? DICHNFS T?LI +H NB? INB?L B;H> $;LP?S J?L @ILGM NB? ?MNCG;NCIH OH>?L NB? HOFF ;H> OM?M NB? F;MN NQI ILNBIAIH;FCNS =IH>CNCIHM ;M IP?L C>?HNC@SCHA =IH>CNCIHM
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N
;N;
&.<=< +*<.- 87 -.7<2=2.< 0B? E?S N?MN B?L? CM NB? 'IFGIAILIP /GCLHIP '/ N?MN NB;N =IGJ;L?M NB? ?GJCLC=;F 013 2L ' I@ NB? L?NOLHM QCNB NB? 013 I@ NB? HILG;F >CMNLC >CMNLCCMNLC <S NB? ?GJCLC=;F 013 3 '
>?WH?> ;M 4
, 3 _
L* R ' @ N
0B? HOFF BSJINB?MCM CM 4 3 ' 2 _ @IL ;FF _ P?LMOM NB? ;FN?LH;NCP? BSJINB?MCM 4< 3 ' 2 _ @IL ;N F?;MN IH? _ 0B? '/ N?MN ;MMOG?M NB;N CM EHIQH %@ CM OHEHIQH NB? (CFFC?@ILM N?MN ?RJF;CH?> F;N?L IH MBIOF> +H? I@ NB? MCGJF?MN G?;MOL?M CM NB? F;LA?MN >CMN;H=? 2 _ 0BCM CM EHIQH ;M NB? 7? N?MN ;M MOAA?MN?> CHCNC;FFS <S 'IFGIAILIP 0B? N?MN MN;NCMNC= CM >?WH?> ;M 7? ,.* R
)2 _ 3 _ ) '
%H JL;=NC=? NBCM N?MN CM P?LS ?;MS NI CGJF?G?HN /ILN NB? M;GJF? >;N; <S CH=L?;MCHA IL>?L ;H> >?HIN? NB? H?Q M;GJF? 4 '0 YN (N QCNB Y0 Y04 0B?H <S =IHMNLO=NCIH NB? ?GJCLC=;F 013 CM ACP?H <S 3 0 YN [*@ 4 !P;FO;N? NB? ;MMOG?> 013 2 0 YN @IL ;FF P;FO?M '0 YN (N %H NB? =;M? I@ NB? HILG;F >CMNLC NB;N NB? G?;H ;H> NB? P;LC;H=? ;L? EHIQH IGJON? NB? 7? N?MN MN;NCMNC= [ 7? ,.* 2 0 YN ' @ N 0B? =LCNC=;F P;FO?M I@ NBCM MN;NCMNC= B;P?
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
0CG? >?J?H>?H=S
cdf of standardized SP500 return 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 -25
-20
-15
-10
-5
5
0
10
Empirical cdf against Theoretical cdf 1 Emp. vs Theor. Emp. vs Emp.
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
20 <:=.?6@<; <3 A52 2:=6?60.9 16@A?6/BA6<; <3 A52 '$
D6A5 A52 ;
+ 7?, ' #CP?H NB;N NB? =LCNC=;F P;FO? CM ' * ' NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM I@ HILG;FCNS CM MNLIHAFS L?D?=N?> 0;?M=LC ;C;AHIMCM IH HILG;FCNS I@ L?NOLHM CM KOCN? =F?;L =ON "LIG >;CFS NI GIHNBFS @L?KO?H=C?M NB? >C_?L?HN N?MNM MSMN?G;NC=;FFS L?D?=N NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM I@ HIL G;FCNS 0B? L?D?=NCIH CM >O? NI N;CF NBC=EH?MM I@ NB? >CM NLC ON CH NBCM CHMN;H=? CN CM JIMMC ;L? MCGJFS OHL?FC;
&26. -.9.7-.7,B 0CG? >?J?H>?H=S CH ;MM?N L?NOLHM =;H I==OL ;N M?P?L;F F?P?FM 3? QCFF >CM=OMM >?J?H>?H=S CH L?NOLHM PIF;NCFCNS ;H> BCAB?L GIG?HNM CH NOLHM CH NB? @IFFIQ CHA MO<M?=NCIHM 0CG? >?J?H>?H=S CM ; =LO=C;F CMMO? @IL M?P?L;F L?;MIHM "CLMN
C@ L?NOLH >CMNLC?J?H>?HN NB?H MN;NCMNC=;F N?MNM OMCHA OH=IH>C NCIH;F MN;NCMNC=M ;H> CH@?L?H=?M >?LCP?> NB?L?I@ =IOF> CHA /?=IH>
C@ NB? NCG? >?J?H>?H=S =;H CN QCFF B?FJ NI JLI>O=? BCAB?L GIG?HNM I@ L?NOLHM /O=B ;H CGJLIP?
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N
;N;
&*+5. "
/E?QH?MM IH 'OLNIMCM I +$ J P;FO? ,1 LCNC=;F P;FO? /E?QH?MM IH 'OLNIMCM I +$ J P;FO? ,1 LCNC=;F P;FO? /E?QH?MM IH 'OLNIMCM I +$ J P;FO? ,1 LCNC=;F P;FO? /E?QH?MM IH 'OLNIMCM I +$ J P;FO? ,1 LCNC=;F P;FO?
/, 4 "0 /! *CEE?C ;CFS @L?KO?H=S I<M?LP;NCIHM
3??EFS @L?KO?H=S I<M?LP;NCIHM
)IHNBFS @L?KO?H=S I<M?LP;NCIHM
HHO;F @L?KO?H=S I<M?LP;NCIHM
G?HN CM I ;MM?N ;FFI=;NCIH
%.;2*5 ,8;;.5*=287 27 ;.=>;7< $?L? NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM CM NB;N NB? WLMN W M?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIHM I@ L?NOLHM ;L? ?KO;F NI 4 J QB?L? NB? =ILL?F;NCIH I@ IL>?L Q CM ?MNCG;N?> <S
0CG? >?J?H>?H=S
E
,4
YN Y YNE Y
,4 YN Y
NE
@IL
Q ) @ '
N
MCGJF? N?MN I@ 4 =IOF> IH NB? (DOHA IR - MN;NCMNC= =J @ @
J , E
' @ Q E
1H>?L NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM I@ HI M?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIH NB? =J MN;NCMNC= CM ;MSGJ NINC=;FFS >CMNLC ;M W =IGGIH JL;=NC=? CM NI N?MN 4 L?J?;N?>FS OMCHA M?P?L;F =BIC=?M I@ W
%.;2*5 ,8;;.5*=287 27 ?85*=252=B 0I N?MN @IL NCG? >?J?H>?H=S CH PIF;NCFCNS Q? H??> ; NCG? P;LSCHA G?;MOL? I@ PIF;NCFCNS 0B?L? ;L? ;N F?;MN NQI JIMMCDOMN?> MKO;L?> L?NOLHM ;H> M?=IH>FS OMCHA ;<MIFON? L?NOLHM MMOG? NB;N L?NOLHM B;P? NB? @IFFIQCHA >SH;GC=M Y N #N (
QCNB
# N N aN (
QB?L? CM NB? =IHMN;HN G?;H #N NB? G?;H ;>DOMN?> L?NOLHM N NB? NCG? P;LSCHA PIF;NCFCNS ;H> aN CM ;H ( CHHIP;NCIH 0B?H QCNB CH@ILG;NCIH M?N N ;N NCG? [
1 # N ) N N 1 aN ) N N
CMNLC ;M 0B?L?@IL? # N =;H ;M ; JLIRS @IL NB? PIF;NCFCNS ;N NCG? [ FN?LH;NCP?FS IGCNNCHA @IL NB? GIG?HN Q? B;P? YN ( N ;H> 8 1 )YN ) N *' 8 IHM?KO?HNFS )YN ) * * CM ; JLIRS @IL N %N MBIOF> BIQ?P?L NB;N NB?M? NQI G?;MOL?M ;L? HICMS ?MNCG;N?M I@ =IH>CNCIH;F PIF;NCFCNS /?? B;JN?L @IL GIL? >?N;CF ;H> GIL? MIJBCMNC=;N?> G?;MOL?M I@ =IH>CNCIH;F PIF;NCFCNS #CP?H NB?M? =LO>? G?;MOL?M I@ PIF;NCFCNS NB? N?MN @IL M?LC;F >?J?H>?H=? CH PIF;NCFCNS =;H CH NB? M;G? G;HH?L ;M NB? N?MN @IL L?NOLHM CH NB? JL?PCIOM MO<M?=NCIH OMCHA (DOHA IR - MN;NCMNC= *IH T?LI M?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIH CH MKO;L?> IL ;<MIFON? L?NOLHM CM ?PC>?H=? I@ PIF;NCFCNS NCG? >?J?H>?H=? 0; L?NOLHM ;H> ;<MIFON? L?NOLHM @IL W ;H> W CH NB? =;M? I@ ;HHO;F >;N; 0B? =ILL?MJIH>CHA =LCNC=;F P;FO?M ;L? ' @IL W ;H>
' @IL W 0B? L?MOFNM CH>C=;N? NB;N L?NOLHM ;L? M?LC;FFS =ILL?F;N?> QB?H NB?S ;L? M;GJF?> ;N NB? >;CFS @L?KO?H=S ;H> ;<MIFON? L?NOLHM ;L? GIL? MNLIHAFS =ILL?F;N?> ;N F?;MN ;N NB? >;CFS ;H> Q??EFS @L?KO?H=C?M
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N
&*+5. ?2AB?;@
;N;
7B;4<E A2@A @A.A6@A60@ <3 9<4?2AB?;@ @>B.?21 ?2AB?;@ .;1 ./@<9BA2 "L?KO?H=S /, ;CFS 3??EFS )IHNBFS HHO;F
;CFS 3??EFS )IHNBFS HHO;F
;CFS 3??EFS )IHNBFS HHO;F
4 "0 /! .?NOLHM
/KO;L?> L?NOLHM
<MIFON? L?NOLHM
*CEE?C
3B?H M;GJF?> ;N GIHNBFS @L?KO?H=S MKO;L?> ;H> ;<MIFON? L?NOLHM I@ 4 ;H> *CEE?C ;L? MNCFF M?LC;FFS =ILL?F;N?> L?X?=NCHA NB? MNLIHA NCG? >?J?H>?H=? I@ PIF;NCFCNS %H>??> NB? MNLIHA NCG? >?J?H>?H=? CH PIF;NCFCNS CM ;H CGJILN;HN @?;NOL? CH WH;H=C;F G;LE?N GI>?FCHA ;H> ACP?M LCM? NI NB? CNCIH;F B?N?LIME?>;MNC=CNS GI>?FM M?? B;JN?L %H @;=N NB? ;ONI=IL L?F;NCIH =I?^=C?HN I@ PIF;NCFCNS JLIRC?M CM MCAHCW=;HNFS AL?;N?L NB;H T?LI ?P?H @IL P?LS FIHA BILCTIHM 0I CFFOMNL;N? NBCM JICHN Q? JFIN CH "CAOL? NB? ;O NI=ILL?FIAL;G I@ MKO;L?> L?NOLHM @IL OJ NI F;AM 0B? WAOL? MBIQM NB;N NB? M?LC;F =ILL?F;NCIH I@ 4 MKO;L?> L?NOLHM CM MCAHCW=;HN OJ NI F;A 0BCM JB?HIG?HIH CM HIQ L?@?LL?> NI ;M NB? FIHA G?GILS I@ PIF;NCFCNS 0B?L? B;M ;FMI ?<;N? ;M NI QB?NB?L PIF;NCFCNS B;M ; OHCN LIIN ,?LLS ;H> ,;A;H ;H> /=BQ?LN 0B;N CM C@ N & N #N ( NB? CMMO? =IH=?LHM QB?NB?L IL HIN & CM CH>CMNCHAOCMB;CM=OMMCIHM NIIE JF;=? PIF;NCFCNS >?P?FIJ?> %@ Q? ;JJFS OHCN LIIN N?MN NI NB? PIF;NCFCNS M?LC?M =IGJON?> OMCHA CHNL;>;S >;N; Q? =;N?AILC=;FFS L?D?=N NB? HOFF BSJINB?MCM I@ ; OHCN LIIN ?P?H ;N NB? F?P?F M?? /?=NCIH
0B? =IHW>?H=? CHN?LP;F L?JILN?> CH NB? WAOL? CM =IGJON?> ;MMOGCHA NB;N NB? ?MNCG;NIL CM ;MSGJNINC=;FFS HILG;F / 4 QCNB 4 ?MNCG;N?> <S 4
0CG? >?J?H>?H=S SP500
DAX
0.2
0.3
0.15
0.2
0.1 0.1 0.05 0
0 -0.05
0
50
100
-0.1
0
FT-SE 0.3
0.4
0.2
0.2
0.1
0
0
0
50
100
Nikkei
0.6
-0.2
50
100
-0.1
0
50
100
20 BA<0B.?21 ?2AB?;@
(85*=252=B * <S H?A;NCP? L?NOLHM NB;H <S JIMCNCP? L?NOLHM 0I CFFOMNL;N? NB? JICHN
Q? J?L@ILG NB? @IFFIQCHA L?AL?MMCIHM # N " # N # N * (
)#N ) " )#N ) )#N ) * (
IL QB?L? G?;MOL?M NB? >CL?=N ?_?=N I@ J;MN L?NOLHM ;H> =;JNOL?M NB? ;> >CNCIH;F CGJ;=N I@ H?A;NCP? L?NOLH MBI=EM 0;;L> ?LLILM L?JILN?> CH J;L?HNB?M?M "CLMN HIN? NB;N
;H> ?MNCG;N?M ;L? I@ MCGCF;L G;AHCNO>? @IL NB? =;M? I@ ;<MIFON? L?NOLHM L?NOLHM "IL ;<MIFON? L?NOLHM L;HA?M ' QB?L?;M B;M ; L;HA? I@ MCGCF;L G;AHCNO>?
;H> ' 0BCM G?;HM NB;N IH ;P?L;A? ; H?A;NCP? L?NOLH MBI=E B;M NQC=? ;M GO=B CGJ;=N IH PIF;NCFCNS ;M ; JIMCNCP? L?NOLH MBI=E F;=E ;H> BLCMNC? =;FF NBCM F?P?L;A? ?_?=N L?F;NCHA NI NB? @;=N NB;N QB?H ?KOCNS P;FO? >?=L?;M?M F?P?L;A? ;H> B?H=? LCME ;H> PIF;NCFCNS CH=L?;M? ;GJ $?HNM=B?F CHN?LJL?N NB? >C_?L?HN L?MJIHM?M ;M ; MNLIHA?L CGJ;=N I@ <;> H?QM NB;H AII> H?QM 0BCM ;MSGG?NLC= IL F?P?L;A? ?_?=N CH PIF;NCFCNS QCFF @OLNB?L CH B;JN?L
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N
;N;
&*+5. $.?.:2A2? 2@A6:.A2@ <3 C<9.A9696AF .@F::2A?F ?24?2@@6<;@ .;1 /,
4 "0 /! /KO;L?> L?NOLHM
<MIFON? L?NOLHM
*CEE?C
&26.?*;B270 1201.; 686.7=< +H? I@ NB? G;CH @?;NOL?M I@ ;MM?N L?NOLHM CM NB? PIF;NCFCNS =FOMN?LCHA MOAA?MNCHA NB;N NB? PIF;NCFCNS I@ L?NOLHM G;S P;LS IP?L NCG? >?J?H>CHA IH NB? ;LLCP;F I@ H?Q CH@ILG;NCIH 3? G;S NB?H ;ME C@ INB?L GIG?HNM I@ NB? >CMNLC;CFS /, L?NOLH =IGJON?> OMCHA ; LIFFCHA QCH>IQ I@ QILECHA >;SM QBC=B CM ;;N; 0B? WAOL? CH>C=;N?M NB;N NB? +=NI NL?H> CH NB? ?PIFONCIH I@ NB? PIF;NCFCNS G?;MOL?> ;M NB? MN;H>;L> >?PC;NCIH I@ NB? M?LC?M /E?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM ;L? =F?;LFS ;_?=N?> <S F;LA? DOGJM 0B? G?>C;H P;FO? @IL NB? ME?QH?MM CM '
( ;H> NB? G?>C;H P;FO? @IL NB? EOLNIMCM CM ' 0B?M? P;FO?M MOAA?MN NB;N IP?L MBILN?L M;GJF? J?LCI>M NB? HILG;FCNS ;MMOGJNCIH G;S BIF> ON IP?L ; FIHA?L M;GJF? J?LCI> L?NOLH CM JLIH? NI F;LA? H?A;NCP? MBI=EM NB;N B;P? ; M?P?L? CGJ;=N IH NB? ME?QH?MM ;H> EOLNIMCM ?MNCG;N?M
27.*; -.9.7-.7,. *,;8<< ;.=>;7< %H NBCM M?=NCIH Q? NOLH NI MIG? MNSFCT?> @;=NM =IH=?LHCHA NB? DICHN >CMNLC <S M?J;L;NCHA NB? G;LACH;F >CMNLC NB? >?J?H>?H=? MNLO=NOL? 0B? G;LACH;F >CMNLCCM NLCCPC>O;F M?LC?M 0B? >?J?H>?H=? MNLO=NOL?
IH NB? INB?L B;H> >?M=LCCPC>O;F M?LC?M ;L? L?F;N?> NI ?;=B INB?L OMO;FFS QCNBION NB? CHXO?H=? I@ NB? OHCP;LC;N? >CMNLC?J?H>?H=? MNLO=NOL?
(CH?;L >?J?H>?H=? ;=LIMM L?NOLHM T im e - va r yi n g m e a n 0 .4
T im e - va r yi n g vo la til ity 3
0 .2 2
0 1
- 0 .2
- 0 .4 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
0 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
T im e - va r yi n g s k e w n e s s 5
T im e - va r yi n g k u r to s is 80
60
0 40
-5 20
-1 0 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
0 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
20 (6:2C.?F6;4 :<:2;A@ 3
?2AB?; 0<:=BA21
".*;<87F< ,8;;.5*=287 ,8.J,2.7= 0B? GIMN @L?KO?HNFS OM?> G?;MOL? I@ >?J?H>?H=? CM NB? 96;2.? 0
QB?L? /V] D( E CM NB? =IP;LC;H=? E 0B? ,?;LMIHZM =IL L?F;NCIH M;NCMW?M NB? =IHMNL;CHN D( E ;H> B;M ;M MJ?=C;F =;M?M D( D ;H> D( E E( D ' /CH=? D ( E ZPNU D( E =ILL?F;NCIH CM CHP;LC;HN OH>?L MNLC=NFS CH=L?;MCHA FCH?;L NL;HM@ILG;NCIHM 3B?H ) D( E ) Q? B;P? J?L@?=N =ILL?F;NCIH IL J?L@?=N FCH?;L >?J?H>?H=? %N CM QILNB ?GJB;MCTCHA NB;N [HI =ILL?F;NCIH\ >I?M HIN H?=?MM;LCFS G?;H [CH>?J?H>?H=?\ ILL?F;NCIH CM ; AII> G?;MOL? @IL >?J?H>?H=? C@ L?NOLHM B;P? ?FFCJNC=;F >CMNLC? HILG;F ;H> /NO>?HN [ >CMNLC?J?H>?H=? @IL HIH ?FFCJNC=;F >CMNLC '`N (N CM
!FFCJNC=;F >CMNLC?WH?> ;H> ;H;FST?> CH /?=NCIH
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N
;N;
)4 _N _ `N `
9 ) N ( 4 )4
N _N _ N `N `
QB?L? _ ;H> ` ;L? NB? M;GJF? G?;H I@ _ ;H> ` L?MJ?=NCP?FS 0B? ;MSGJNINC= >CMNLCC=?M G?;MOL?> ;N P;LCIOM @L?KO?H=C?M FF =ILL?F;NCIH =I?^=C?HNM L?JILN?> CH NB? N;;N; @L?KO?H=S NB? BCAB?L NB? =ILL?F;NCIH =I?^=C?HN ?MNCG;N? "CAOL? JL?M?HNM NB? ?PIFONCIH I@ NB? =ILL?F;NCIH =I?^=C?HNM =IGJON?> OMCHA ; LIFFCHA J?LCI> I@ GIHNBM !R=?JN @IL NB? J;CL /, PM *CEE?C ;FF =ILL?F;NCIH =I?^=C?HNM ?RBC NL?H>
&.<= /8; .:>*52=B 8/ =@8 ,8;;.5*=287 ,8.J,2.7=< 0B?L? B;P? CM=OMMCIHM CH NB? FCN?L;NOL? IH BIQ NB? =ILL?F;NCIH =B;HA?M QB?H NB? WH;H=C;F G;LE?NM ;L? [;ACN;N?>\ 0BCM CM ;H CGJILN;HN CMMO? CH JILN@IFCI >CP?LMCW=;NCIH %@ =ILL?F;NCIH CH=L?;M?M >OLCHA NOLM ;H> MNI=E G;LE?N =L;MB?M NB?H NB? CP?LMCW=;NCIH >CM;JJ?;L QB?H NB?S ;L? GIMN H??>?> ,L?PCIOM MNO>C?M IH =B;HACHA =ILL?F;NCIH ?MNCG;N?> CN &*+5.
/, 4 "0 /! *CEE?C
/, 4 "0 /! *CEE?C
/, 4 "0 /! *CEE?C
4 "0 /! ;CFS @L?KO?H=S
3??EFS @L?KO?H=S
)IHNBFS @L?KO?H=S
HHO;F @L?KO?H=S
*CEE?C
(CH?;L >?J?H>?H=? ;=LIMM L?NOLHM SP500 - DAX
SP500 - FT-SE
1
1
0.5
0.5
0
0
-0.5 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
-0.5 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
SP500 - Nikkei
DAX - FT-SE
1
1
0.5
0.5
0
0
-0.5 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
-0.5 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005
20 (6:2C.?F6;4 0
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
/N;NCMNC=;F ,LIJ?LNC?M I@ "CH;H=C;F );LE?N
;N;
NB?M? CMMO?M CH ; AL?;N?L >?N;CF CH B;JN?L $?L? Q? JL?M?HN NB? MCGJF?MN =;M? QB?H NB?L? CM HI MNLO=NOL;F =B;HACHA >CMNLC JL;=NC=? NI WLMN WFN?L ION NB? NCG? >?J?H>?H=? I@ NB? CH>CPC>O;F M?LC?M %H MIG? =;M?M NB? L?GIP;F I@ =IGGIH @;=NIL >?J?H>?H=? CM B?FJ@OF CH C>?HNC@SCHA NB? NLO? >?J?H>?H=? MNLO=NOL? 0B? N?MN I@ NB? ?KO;FCNS I@ NB? =ILL?F;NCIH =I?^=C?HNM I@ NQI HIH IP?LF;JJCHA J?LCI>M @ ;H> @ L?FC?M IH NB? ;MSGJNINC= >CMNLCCMNLC