De Gruyter Studies in Mathematics 34 Editors Carsten Carstensen, Berlin, Germany Nicola Fusco, Napoli, Italy Fritz Gesz...
35 downloads
1482 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
De Gruyter Studies in Mathematics 34 Editors Carsten Carstensen, Berlin, Germany Nicola Fusco, Napoli, Italy Fritz Gesztesy, Columbia, USA Niels Jacob, Swansea, United Kingdom Karl-Hermann Neeb, Erlangen, Germany
Jo´zsef Lo˝rinczi Fumio Hiroshima Volker Betz
Feynman-Kac-Type Theorems and Gibbs Measures on Path Space With Applications to Rigorous Quantum Field Theory
De Gruyter
Mathematics Subject Classification 2010: 81Q10, 81S40, 47D08, 60J60, 82B05, 35Q40, 46N50, 81V10.
ISBN 978-3-11-020148-2 e-ISBN 978-3-11-020373-8 ISSN 0179-0986 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Lo˝rinczi, Jo´zsef. Feynman-Kac-type theorems and Gibbs measures on path space : with applications to rigorous quantum field theory / by Jo´zsef Lo˝rinczi, Fumio Hiroshima, Volker Betz. p. cm. ⫺ (De Gruyter studies in mathematics ; 34) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-3-11-020148-2 1. Integration, Functional. 2. Stochastic analysis. 3. Quantum field theory ⫺ Mathematics. I. Hiroshima, Fumio. II. Betz, Volker. III. Title. QC20.7.F85L67 2011 5151.724⫺dc22 2011005708
Bibliographic information published by the Deutsche Nationalbibliothek The Deutsche Nationalbibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliografie; detailed bibliographic data are available in the Internet at http://dnb.d-nb.de. ” 2011 Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG, Berlin/Boston Typesetting: Da-TeX Gerd Blumenstein, Leipzig, www.da-tex.de Printing and binding: Hubert & Co. GmbH & Co. KG, Göttingen ⬁ Printed on acid-free paper Printed in Germany www.degruyter.com
Preface
For a long time disciplines such as astronomy, celestial mechanics, the theory of heat and the theory of electromagnetism counted among the most important sources in the development of mathematics, continually providing new problems and challenges. The main mathematical facts resulting from these fields typically crystallized in linear ordinary or partial differential equations. In the early 20th century Heisenberg’s discovery of a rule showing that the measurement of the position and momentum of a quantum particle gives different answers dependent on the order of their measurement led to the concept of commutation relations, and it made matrix theory find an unexpected application in the natural sciences. This resulted in an explosion of interest in linear structures developed by what we call today linear algebra and linear analysis, among them functional analysis, operator theory, C -algebras, and distribution theory. Similarly, quantum mechanics inspired much of group theory, lattice theory and quantum logic. Following this initial boom Wigner’s beautiful phrase talking of the “unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics” marks a point of reflection on the fact that it is by no means obvious why this kind of abstract and sophisticated mathematics can be expected at all to make faithful descriptions and reliable predictions of natural phenomena. If indeed this can be appreciated as a miracle, as he said, it is perhaps at least a remarkable fact the degree of flexibility that mathematics allows in its uses. Feynman has pointed to the different cultures of using mathematics when he remarked that “if all of mathematics disappeared, physics would be set back by exactly one week.” While mathematics cannot compete with physics in discovering new phenomena and offering explanations of them, physics continues to depend on the terminology, arsenal and discipline of mathematics. Mathematical physics, which is part of mathematics and therefore operates by its rules and standards, has set the goal to understand the models of physics in a rigorous way. Mathematical physicists thus find themselves at the borderline, listening to physics and speaking mathematics, at best able to use these functionalities interchangeably. If one of the imports of early quantum mechanics has been the realization that the basic laws on the atomic scale can be formulated by linear superposition rules, another was a probabilistic interpretation of the wave function. This connection with chance, amplified and strongly advocated by the Copenhagen school, was no less revolutionary than the commutation relations. Richard Feynman has discovered a second connection with probability when he offered a representation of the state of a particle in terms of averages over all of its possible histories from one point in spacetime to another. While this was an instance seriously questioning his dictum quoted
vi
Preface
above and his use of mathematics was in this case very problematic, the potential lying in the description advanced in his work turned out to be far reaching. It took the efforts of the mathematician Mark Kac to be the first to show that this method could be made sense of and was eminently viable. Our project to write the present monograph has grown out of the thematic programme At the Interface of PDE, Self-Adjoint Operators and Stochastics: Models with Exclusion organized by the first named author at the Wolfgang Pauli Institute, Vienna, in 2006. The initial concept was a smaller scale but up-to-date account of Feynman–Kac-type formulae and their uses in quantum field theory, which we wanted to dedicate to the person all three of us have much to thank both scientifically and personally, Herbert Spohn. At that time we secretly meant this as a present for his 60th birthday, and we are glad that we are now able to make this hopefully more mature tribute on the occasion of his 65th birthday! Apart from the inspiring and pleasant environment at Zentrum Mathematik, Munich University of Technology, where our collaboration has started, and Wolfgang Pauli Institut, University of Vienna, hosting the thematic programme, we are indebted to a number of other individuals and institutions. We are thankful for the joint work and friendship of our closest collaborators in this direction, Asao Arai, Massimiliano Gubinelli, Masao Hirokawa, and Robert Adol’fovich Minlos. We also thank Cristian Gérard, Takashi Ichinose, Kamil Kaleta, Jacek Małecki, Annalisa Panati, Akito Suzuki for ongoing related joint work. It is furthermore a pleasure to thank Norbert Mauser, Director of the Wolfgang Pauli Institute, for supporting the programme, and Sergio Albeverio, Rodrigo Bañuelos, Krzysztof Bogdan, Carlo Boldrighini, Thierry Coulhon, Laure Coutin, Cécile DeWitt-Morette, Aernout van Enter, Bill Faris, Gero Friesecke, Jürg Fröhlich, Mohammud Foondun, Hans-Otto Georgii, Alexander Grigor’yan, Martin Hairer, Takeru Hidaka, Wataru Ichinose, Keiichi Itô, Niels Jacob, Hiroshi Kawabi, Tadeusz Kulczycki, Kazuhiro Kuwae, Terry Lyons, Tadahiro Miyao, Hirofumi Osada, Habib Ouerdiane, Sylvie Roelly, Itaru Sasaki, Tomoyuki Shirai, Toshimitsu Takaesu, Setsuo Taniguchi, Josef Teichmann, Daniel Ueltschi, Jakob Yngvason for many useful discussions over the years. We thank especially Erwin Schrödinger Institut, Vienna, Institut des Hautes Études Scientifiques, Buressur-Yvette, and Università La Sapienza, Rome, for repeatedly providing excellent environments to further the project and where parts of the manuscript have been written. Also, we thank the hospitality of Kyushu University, Loughborough University and Warwick University, for accommodating mutual visits and extended stays. We are particularly pleased to thank the professionalism, assistance and endless patience of Robert Plato, Simon Albroscheit and Friederike Dittberner of Walter de Gruyter. Also, we are grateful to Max Lein for technical support in the initial phase of this project. József L˝orinczi, Fumio Hiroshima, Volker Betz
February 2011
Contents
Preface
v
I Feynman–Kac-type theorems and Gibbs measures
1
1
Heuristics and history 1.1 Feynman path integrals and Feynman–Kac formulae . . . . . . . . . 1.2 Plan and scope . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3 3 7
2
Probabilistic preliminaries 2.1 An invitation to Brownian motion . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2 Martingale and Markov properties . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2.1 Martingale property . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2.2 Markov property . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2.3 Feller transition kernels and generators . . . . . 2.2.4 Conditional Wiener measure . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3 Basics of stochastic calculus . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.1 The classical integral and its extensions . . . . . 2.3.2 Stochastic integrals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.3 Itô formula . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.3.4 Stochastic differential equations and diffusions . 2.3.5 Girsanov theorem and Cameron–Martin formula 2.4 Lévy processes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.1 Lévy process and Lévy–Khintchine formula . . . 2.4.2 Markov property of Lévy processes . . . . . . . 2.4.3 Random measures and Lévy–Itô decomposition . 2.4.4 Itô formula for semimartingales . . . . . . . . . 2.4.5 Subordinators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.4.6 Bernstein functions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
3
Feynman–Kac formulae 3.1 Schrödinger semigroups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1.1 Schrödinger equation and path integral solutions 3.1.2 Linear operators and their spectra . . . . . . . . 3.1.3 Spectral resolution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1.4 Compact operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
11 11 21 21 25 29 32 33 33 34 42 46 50 53 53 57 61 64 67 69
. . . . .
71 71 71 72 78 80
viii
Contents
3.1.5 Schrödinger operators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1.6 Schrödinger operators by quadratic forms . . . . . . . . . . . 3.1.7 Confining potential and decaying potential . . . . . . . . . . 3.1.8 Strongly continuous operator semigroups . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2 Feynman–Kac formula for external potentials . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.1 Bounded smooth external potentials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.2.2 Derivation through the Trotter product formula . . . . . . . . 3.3 Feynman–Kac formula for Kato-class potentials . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.1 Kato-class potentials . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.3.2 Feynman–Kac formula for Kato-decomposable potentials . . 3.4 Properties of Schrödinger operators and semigroups . . . . . . . . . . 3.4.1 Kernel of the Schrödinger semigroup . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.4.2 Number of eigenfunctions with negative eigenvalues . . . . . 3.4.3 Positivity improving and uniqueness of ground state . . . . . 3.4.4 Degenerate ground state and Klauder phenomenon . . . . . . 3.4.5 Exponential decay of the eigenfunctions . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5 Feynman–Kac–Itô formula for magnetic field . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5.1 Feynman–Kac–Itô formula . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.5.2 Alternate proof of the Feynman–Kac–Itô formula . . . . . . . 3.5.3 Extension to singular external potentials and vector potentials 3.5.4 Kato-class potentials and Lp –Lq boundedness . . . . . . . . 3.6 Feynman–Kac formula for relativistic Schrödinger operators . . . . . 3.6.1 Relativistic Schrödinger operator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.6.2 Relativistic Kato-class potentials and Lp –Lq boundedness . . 3.7 Feynman–Kac formula for Schrödinger operator with spin . . . . . . 3.7.1 Schrödinger operator with spin . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.7.2 A jump process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.7.3 Feynman–Kac formula for the jump process . . . . . . . . . . 3.7.4 Extension to singular potentials and vector potentials . . . . . 3.8 Feynman–Kac formula for relativistic Schrödinger operator with spin 3.9 Feynman–Kac formula for unbounded semigroups and Stark effect . . 3.10 Ground state transform and related diffusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.10.1 Ground state transform and the intrinsic semigroup . . . . . . 3.10.2 Feynman–Kac formula for P ./1 -processes . . . . . . . . . . 3.10.3 Dirichlet principle . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.10.4 Mehler’s formula . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
81 85 87 89 93 93 95 97 97 108 112 112 113 120 124 126 131 131 135 138 142 143 143 149 150 150 152 154 157 162 166 170 170 174 181 184
Gibbs measures associated with Feynman–Kac semigroups 190 4.1 Gibbs measures on path space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 190 4.1.1 From Feynman–Kac formulae to Gibbs measures . . . . . . . 190 4.1.2 Definitions and basic facts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 194
ix
Contents
4.2
4.3
4.4
Existence and uniqueness by direct methods . . . . . . . . . 4.2.1 External potentials: existence . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.2 Uniqueness . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.2.3 Gibbs measure for pair interaction potentials . . . . Existence and properties by cluster expansion . . . . . . . . 4.3.1 Cluster representation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.3.2 Basic estimates and convergence of cluster expansion 4.3.3 Further properties of the Gibbs measure . . . . . . . Gibbs measures with no external potential . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.1 Gibbs measure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.4.2 Diffusive behaviour . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
II Rigorous quantum field theory 5
6
Free Euclidean quantum field and Ornstein–Uhlenbeck processes 5.1 Background . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2 Boson Fock space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.1 Second quantization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.2 Segal fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.3 Wick product . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3 Q-spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3.1 Gaussian random processes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3.2 Wiener–Itô–Segal isomorphism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.3.3 Lorentz covariant quantum fields . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4 Existence of Q-spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4.1 Countable product spaces . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.4.2 Bochner theorem and Minlos theorem . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5 Functional integration representation of Euclidean quantum fields 5.5.1 Basic results in Euclidean quantum field theory . . . . . . 5.5.2 Markov property of projections . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.5.3 Feynman–Kac–Nelson formula . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.6 Infinite dimensional Ornstein–Uhlenbeck process . . . . . . . . . 5.6.1 Abstract theory of measures on Hilbert spaces . . . . . . . 5.6.2 Fock space as a function space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.6.3 Infinite dimensional Ornstein–Uhlenbeck-process . . . . . 5.6.4 Markov property . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.6.5 Regular conditional Gaussian probability measures . . . . 5.6.6 Feynman–Kac–Nelson formula by path measures . . . . .
201 201 204 208 217 217 223 224 226 226 238
245 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
247 247 249 249 255 257 258 258 260 262 263 263 264 268 268 271 274 276 276 279 282 288 290 292
The Nelson model by path measures 293 6.1 Preliminaries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 293
x
Contents
6.2
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
294 294 296 298 298 303 309 309 315 316 322 324 328 333 333 335 339 344
The Pauli–Fierz model by path measures 7.1 Preliminaries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.2 Lagrangian QED . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.3 Classical variant of non-relativistic QED . . . . . . . . . 7.2 The Pauli–Fierz model in non-relativistic QED . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.1 The Pauli–Fierz model in Fock space . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.2 The Pauli–Fierz model in function space . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.3 Markov property . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.3 Functional integral representation for the Pauli–Fierz Hamiltonian 7.3.1 Hilbert space-valued stochastic integrals . . . . . . . . . . 7.3.2 Functional integral representation . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.3.3 Extension to general external potential . . . . . . . . . . . 7.4 Applications of functional integral representations . . . . . . . . . 7.4.1 Self-adjointness of the Pauli–Fierz Hamiltonian . . . . . . 7.4.2 Positivity improving and uniqueness of the ground state . 7.4.3 Spatial decay of the ground state . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.5 The Pauli–Fierz model with Kato class potential . . . . . . . . . . 7.6 Translation invariant Pauli–Fierz model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.7 Path measure associated with the ground state . . . . . . . . . . . 7.7.1 Path measures with double stochastic integrals . . . . . . 7.7.2 Expression in terms of iterated stochastic integrals . . . . 7.7.3 Weak convergence of path measures . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
351 351 351 352 356 359 359 363 369 372 372 375 381 382 382 392 398 399 401 408 408 412 415
6.3 6.4 6.5
6.6 6.7 6.8
7
The Nelson model in Fock space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2.1 Definition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2.2 Infrared and ultraviolet divergences . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2.3 Embedded eigenvalues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Nelson model in function space . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Existence and uniqueness of the ground state . . . . . . . . . . Ground state expectations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.1 General theorems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.2 Spatial decay of the ground state . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.5.3 Ground state expectation for second quantized operators 6.5.4 Ground state expectation for field operators . . . . . . . The translation invariant Nelson model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Infrared divergence . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ultraviolet divergence . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.8.1 Energy renormalization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.8.2 Regularized interaction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.8.3 Removal of the ultraviolet cutoff . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.8.4 Weak coupling limit and removal of ultraviolet cutoff .
xi
Contents
7.8
7.9
8
Relativistic Pauli–Fierz model . . . . . . 7.8.1 Definition . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.8.2 Functional integral representation 7.8.3 Translation invariant case . . . . . The Pauli–Fierz model with spin . . . . . 7.9.1 Definition . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.9.2 Symmetry and polarization . . . . 7.9.3 Functional integral representation 7.9.4 Spin-boson model . . . . . . . . 7.9.5 Translation invariant case . . . . .
Notes and References
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
418 418 420 423 424 424 427 434 447 448 455
Bibliography
473
Index
499
Part I
Feynman–Kac-type theorems and Gibbs measures
Chapter 1
Heuristics and history
1.1
Feynman path integrals and Feynman–Kac formulae
In Feynman’s work concepts such as paths and actions, just discarded by the new-born quantum mechanics, witnessed a comeback in the description of the time-evolution of quantum particles, proposing an alternative to Heisenberg’s matrix mechanics and Schrödinger’s wave mechanics. It is worthwhile briefly to review how this turned out to be a viable project and led to a mathematically meaningful approach to quantum mechanics and quantum field theory. A basic tool in the hands of the quantum physicist is the Schrödinger equation i„
@ @t
„2 .t; x/ C V .x/ .t; x/; 2m .0; x/ D .x/; .t; x/ 2 R R3 .t; x/ D
(1.1.1)
with Hamilton operator H D
„2 C V; 2m
(1.1.2)
and a complex valued wave function describing a quantum particle of mass m at position x in space at time t . Here „ is Planck’s constant, V is a potential in whose force field the particle is moving, and describes the initial state of the quantum particle. The Schrödinger equation can be solved only under exceptional choices of V . However, formally the solution of the equation can be written as .t; x/ D .e .it=„/H /.x/ for any V . The difficulty is that for a general choice of V we do not know how to calculate the right-hand side of the equality. The action of the complex exponential operator on can be evaluated by using an integral kernel G allowing to write the wave function of the particle at position y at time t based on its knowledge in x at s < t , i.e., Z .t; y/ D G.x; yI s; t / .s; x/dx: R3
This representation can then in principle be iterated from one interval Œs; t to another, and thus our knowledge of the wave function “propagates” from the initial time to any
4
Chapter 1 Heuristics and history
time point in the future. This observation suggests that at least a qualitative analysis of the solution might be possible for a wider choice of V by using this integral kernel, and the key to this approach is the information content of the kernel. Feynman proposed a method of constructing this integral kernel in the following way. Consider first a classical Hamiltonian function 1 2 p C V .q/; .p; q/ 2 R3 R3 ; (1.1.3) 2m describing a particle at position q moving with momentum p under the same potential V as above. The corresponding Lagrangian is obtained through Legendre transform, m L .q; q/ P D qp P H .p; q/ D qP 2 V .q/; 2 where @H p qP D D : @p m Classical mechanics says that the particle is equivalently described by the action functional Z H .p; q/ D
t
A .q; qI P 0; t / D
0
L .q.s/; q.s//ds; P
where q.s/ is the path of the particle as a function of the time s. In particular, the equation of motion can be derived by the principle of least action by using variational calculus, and it is found that the particle follows a route from a fixed initial to a fixed endpoint which minimizes the action. In the late 1920s Dirac worked on a Lagrangian formulation of quantum mechanics and arrived at the conclusion that the ideas of the classical Lagrangian theory can be taken over, though not its equations. Specifically, he arrived at a rule he called “transformation theory” allowing to connect the positions at s and t of the quantum P particle through the phase factors e .i=„/A .q;qIs;t/ . By dividing up the interval Œs; t into small pieces, Dirac noticed [128, 129, 130] that due to the fact that „ is of the order of 1034 in standard units, this is so small that the integrands in the exponent are rapidly oscillating functions around zero. Therefore, as a result of the many cancellations the only significant contribution into the integral is given by those q whose large variations over the subintervals involve small differences in the Lagrangian. Feynman, while a Princeton research assistant during 1940–41, turned Dirac’s somewhat vague observations into a more definite formulation. He argued that the propagators G.x; yI s; t /, which were Dirac’s “contact transformations,” can be obtained as limits over products of propagators at intermediary time points. This means that with a partition of Œs; t to subintervals Œtj ; tj C1 with tj D s C jb, j D 0; : : : ; n 1, b D .t s/=n, the expression n1 n1 YZ Y G.x; yI s; t / D lim G.xj ; xj C1 I tj ; tj C1 / dxj n!1
3 j D0 R
j D1
5
Section 1.1 Feynman path integrals and Feynman–Kac formulae
holds, where r G.xj ; xj C1 I tj ; tj C1 / D
m ib xj C1 xj exp L xj C1 ; : 2b i „ „ b
From here it was possible to conclude that
.e
.it=„/H
Y i A .q; qI P 0; t / /.x; y/ D G.x; yI 0; t / D const exp dq.s/ „ xy Z
0st
(1.1.4) giving a formal expression of the integral kernel of the operator e .it=„/H for all t . Here dq.s/ is Lebesgue measure, and xy is the set of continuous paths q.s/ such that q.0/ D x and q.t / D y. The right-hand side of the expression is Feynman’s integral. These results have been obtained first in his 1942 thesis, which remained unpublished; the paper [161] published in 1948, however, reproduces the crucial statements (see also [164]). Feynman was able to apply his approach also to quantum field theory [162, 163]. For all its intuitive appeal and potential, Feynman’s method did not win immediate acclaims, not even in the ranks of theoretical physicists. Mathematically viewed, the object Feynman proposed was by no means easy to define. Mathematicians hitherto have not found a satisfactory meaning of Feynman integrals covering a sufficiently wide class of choices of V . For instance, there is no countably additive measure on xy allocating equal weight to every path, and A .q; qI P 0; t / fails to be defined on much of xy since it involves q.s/. P Various ways of trying to cope with these difficulties have been explored. Several authors considered purely imaginary potentials V and masses m leading to a complex measure to define Feynman’s integral, but these attempts had to face the problem of infinite total variation [79, 102, 372]. Another suggestion was to define the Feynman integral in terms of Fresnel distributions [126, 3, 127, 80, 85, 474]. Other attempts constructing solutions of Schrödinger’s equation from Feynman’s integral through piecewise classical paths or broken lines or polygonal paths [177, 279, 283, 273, 476, 292]. In Feynman’s days integration theory on the space of continuous functions has already been in existence due to Wiener’s work on Brownian motion initiated in 1923. It was Kac in 1949 who first realized that this was a suitable framework, however, not for the path integral (1.1.4) directly, see also [294, 295]. In contrast to Feynman’s expression, the Feynman–Kac formula offers an integral representation on path space for the semigroup e .1=„/tH instead of e .i=„/tH , obtained on replacing t by i t . Why should this actually improve on the situation can be seen by the following argument. Analytic continuation s ! i s, ds ! ids and the replacement q.s/ P 2 ! q.s/ P 2
6
Chapter 1 Heuristics and history
in (1.1.4) leads to the kernel Z tH .e /.x; y/ D const
e .1=„/
Rt 0
V .q.s//ds .m=2„/
e
Rt 0
xy
Y
q.s/ P 2 ds
dq.s/:
0st
(1.1.5) Since defining the latter factor as a measure remains to be a problem as Z Y dq.s/ D 1
(1.1.6)
xy 0st
for every t , one might boldly hope that its support Cxy is a set on which the exponential weights typically vanish. If qP were almost surely plus or minus infinite on this set, then the situation Z 1 tm 2 exp q.s/ P ds D0 (1.1.7) „ 0 2 Cxy would occur. Cxy would thus be required to consist of continuous but nowhere differentiable paths. Once this can be allowed, zero in (1.1.7) can possibly cancel infinity in (1.1.6), and it would in principle be possible that Y Z 1 tm 2 q.s/ P ds dq.s/ D 0 1 exp „ 0 2 0st
is a well-defined measure. As we will explain below, the miracle happens: The paths of a random process .B t / t0 called Brownian motion just have the required properties and the Feynman–Kac formula Z Rt x;y tH .e /.x; y/ D e 0 V .Bs .!//ds d WŒ0;t .!/; 8t 0; x; y 2 R3 C.R;R3 /
(1.1.8) rigorously holds provided some technical but highly satisfying conditions hold on V . In particular, there is a measure supported on the space Cxy identified with the space C.R; R3 / of continuous functions R ! R3 , and it can be identified as Wiener measure W conditional on paths leaving from x at time 0 and ending in y at time t . In other words, the kernel of the semigroup at the left-hand side (the object corresponding to G.x; yI 0; t / above) can be studied by running a Brownian motion driven by the potential V . Kac has actually proved [293] that the heat equation with dissipation @f 1 D f Vf; @t 2
.x; 0/ D .x/;
(1.1.9)
7
Section 1.2 Plan and scope
is solved by the function Z f .x; t / D
e
Rt 0
V .Bs .!// ds
C.R;R3 /
.B t .!// d W x .!/:
(1.1.10)
This equation is actually the same as the Schrödinger equation (1.1.1) when analytic continuation t 7! i t is made, a fact that has been noticed by Ehrenfest as early as 1927. In particular, on setting V D 0 and formally replacing with a ı-distribution, the fundamental solution ….x; t / of the standard heat equation is obtained. The relation of this so called heat kernel 1 jxj2 ….x; t / D exp ; t > 0; (1.1.11) 2t .2 t /3=2 is once again strong with random processes as it gives the transition probabilities of Brownian motion. The Feynman–Kac formula makes thus a link between an operator semigroup, the heat equation, and Brownian motion. This observation has opened up a whole new conceptual and technical framework pointing to and exploring the rich interplay between self-adjoint operators, probability and partial differential equations.
1.2
Plan and scope
The Feynman–Kac formula for the operator H D 12 C V derived from the heat equation with dissipation can be written in any dimension d as Z Rt tH .e f /.x/ D e 0 V .Bs .!// ds f .B t .!// d W x .!/ C.R;Rd /
where .B t / t0 is accordingly an Rd -valued Brownian motion. Due to the connections outlined above, the operator H is called a Schrödinger operator with potential V . If the potential is such that H admits an eigenfunction at eigenvalue E, then e tH D e E t and thus this eigenfunction can be represented in terms of an average over the paths of Brownian motion given by the right-hand side. This makes possible to obtain information on the spectral properties of H by probabilistic means. In particular, the Feynman–Kac formula can be used to study the ground states (i.e., eigenfunctions at the bottom of the spectrum) of Schrödinger operators. It is natural to ask the question whether it is possible to derive representations similar to the Feynman–Kac formula for any other operator. In the pages below we will show that also other operators, derived from quantum field theory, allow to derive Feynman–Kac-type formulae with appropriately modified random processes at the right-hand side. On the one hand, this relation will allow us to ask and answer questions relevant to quantum field theory in a rigorous way. On the other hand, we will face situations in which new concepts and methods need to be developed, which thus generates new mathematics.
8
Chapter 1 Heuristics and history
We split the material of this monograph in two parts of comparable size, each focussing on one aspect explained above. In Part I we discuss the mathematical framework and in Part II we present the applications in rigorous quantum field theory. Part I is called Feynman–Kac-type theorems and Gibbs measures and it consists of four chapters. In Chapter 1 we outline the origins of the idea of a path integral applied in quantum mechanics and quantum field theory, due to the physicist Richard P Feynman, and formulated in a mathematically rigorous way by the mathematician Mark Kac. In Chapter 2 we offer background material from stochastic analysis starting from a review of Brownian motion, Markov processes and martingales. We devote a section to basic concepts of Itô integration theory including some examples, and we conclude by a review of Lévy processes and subordinate Brownian motion. In Chapter 3 we start by a review of background material of the theory of selfadjoint operators and their semigroups, with a special view on Schrödinger operators. As in the previous chapter we present established material in the light of our goals. The remainder of the chapter deals with a systematic presentation of versions of the Feynman–Kac formula. We cover cases of increasing complexity starting from an external potential V , through including vector potentials describing interactions with magnetic fields, spin, and relativistic effects. Purely mathematically this amounts to saying that we proceed from operators consisting of the sum of the negative Laplacian and a multiplication operator of varying regularity, through including gradient operator terms, and pseudo-differential operators such as the square root of the Laplacian and related operators. From the perspective of random processes involved, we proceed from Brownian motion to diffusions (P ./1 -processes and Itô diffusions), and subordinate Brownian motion (relativistic stable processes). Apart from establishing the variants of the Feynman–Kac formula for these choices of operators and processes, we also address their applications in the study of analytic and spectral properties of these operators (properties of integral kernels, positivity improving properties, Lp -smoothing properties, intrinsic utracontractivity, uniqueness and multiplicity of eigenfunctions, decay of eigenfunctions, number of eigenfunctions with negative eigenvalues, diamagnetic inequalities, spectral comparison inequalities etc). From the perspective of quantum mechanics, these results translate into the ground state properties of non-relativistic or relativistic quantum particles with or without spin. In Chapter 4 we focus on the “right-hand side” of the Feynman–Kac formula and its variants. In all cases that we consider the kernel of the operator semigroup can be expressed in terms of an expectation over the paths of a random process with respect to a measure weighted by exponential densities dependent on functionals additive in the time intervals. This structure suggests to view this as a new probability measure which can be interpreted as a Gibbs measure on path space for the potential(s) appearing directly in or derived from the generator of the process. Gibbs measures are well understood in discrete stochastic models, and originate from statistical mechan-
Section 1.2 Plan and scope
9
ics where they have been used to model thermodynamic equilibrium states. In our context this interpretation is not relevant, however, the so obtained Gibbs measures provide a tool for studying analytic and spectral properties of the operators standing at the left-hand side of the Feynman–Kac formula. In this chapter we define and prove the existence and properties of Gibbs measures on path space. First we present this for the case of external potentials and define the framework of P ./1 -processes. Then we establish existence and other results (uniqueness, almost sure path behaviour, mixing properties etc) for the case when the densities of the Gibbs measure also contain a pair interaction potential. Finally, we present the special case when the external potential is zero, and discuss Gibbs measures on the Brownian increment process, showing an emerging diffusive behaviour under proper scaling. Part II of the monograph is called Rigorous quantum field theory and consists of three chapters. In Chapter 5 we discuss the representations of the free boson field Hamilton operator. First we discuss it in Fock space, which is the natural setting for the description of quantum Hamiltonians in terms of self-adjoint operators. Then we introduce suitable function spaces in which the operator semigroups will be mapped by using the Wiener–Itô–Segal isomorphism, and discuss the basic theorems of Bochner and of Minlos on the existence of an infinite Gaussian measure on these spaces. Then we establish the functional integral representation of the free field Hamiltonian on this space. Also, we establish the Feynman–Kac–Nelson formula, which is a representation of the free quantum field in terms of the path measure of an infinite dimensional Ornstein–Uhlenbeck process, and we discuss the Markov property which is crucial in this context. In Chapter 6 we make a detailed study in terms of path measures of Nelson’s model of an electrically charged spinless quantum particle coupled to a scalar boson field. First we formulate the Nelson model in Fock space and discuss the infrared and ultraviolet cutoffs which we need to impose to define the model rigorously. Then we formulate the Nelson model in function space by using the same Wiener–Itô–Segal isomorphism as for the free quantum field previously. We present a proof of existence and uniqueness of a ground state. Next we establish a path measure representation of the Nelson Hamiltonian and identify a Gibbs measure on path space which can be associated to it. This Gibbs measure is defined for a given external potential, and a pair interaction potential arising as an effective potential obtained after integrating over the quantum field. Using the Gibbs measure we derive and prove detailed properties of the ground state, in particular, we discuss ground state expectations for the field operators, establish exponential spatial localization of the particle etc. We furthermore discuss the case of the translation invariant Nelson model obtained when the external potential is zero. We conclude the chapter by discussing infrared divergence manifested in the absence of a ground state, and ultraviolet divergence appearing in the point charge limit.
10
Chapter 1 Heuristics and history
In Chapter 7 we carry out a similar study in terms of path measures of the Pauli– Fierz model. This model is obtained from the quantization of the Maxwell (vector) field. As before, we start by a formulation of the model in terms of Fock space operators. Next we derive and prove a functional integral representation of the operator semigroup generated by the Pauli–Fierz Hamiltonian. As in the Nelson model, also in this case we obtain a pair interaction potential through the functional integral, however, the double Riemann integrals seen previously are replaced by a double stochastic integral. We define this integral and will be able to extend the functional integral representation to a large class of external potentials. As applications of functional integration first of all we establish self-adjointness of the Pauli–Fierz operator. Also, we prove uniqueness of its ground state by exploring the positivity properties that the integral yields, and discuss its spatial decay. We will use the functional integral formula in order to define the Pauli–Fierz operator for Kato-decomposable potentials as a self-adjoint operator. Next we discuss the translation invariant case when the external potential is zero. In a next step by using the appropriate function spaces we establish a path integral representation of the Pauli–Fierz operator, in which the pair interaction potential becomes a twice iterated stochastic integral. Then we turn to the case of the relativistic Pauli–Fierz model, whose functional integral representation involves subordinate Brownian motion. Finally we discuss the Pauli–Fierz model with spin, and the spin-boson model as an application. In a concluding section we offer a commented guide to the selected bibliography. Undoubtedly, our list of references can be further increased, however, in lack of space we need to defer this to the reader.
Chapter 2
Probabilistic preliminaries
2.1
An invitation to Brownian motion
A random process is a mathematical model of a phenomenon evolving in time in a way which cannot be predicted with certainty. Brownian motion is a basic random process playing a central role throughout below. We offer here a brief summary of the mathematical theory of Brownian motion as background material for a reasonably self-contained presentation of what follows. Let .; F / be a measurable space, where is a set and F a -field. When is equipped with a topology, its Borel -field will be denoted by B./ and then .; B.// is called a Borel measurable space. A measurable space .; F / is separable if and only if F is generated by a countable collection of subsets in . In particular, if is a locally compact space with a countable basis, then .; B.// is separable. Throughout we will assume that Borel measurable spaces are separable. With measurable spaces .; F / and .S; S / we write f 2 F =S to indicate that the function f W ! S is measurable with respect to F and S , i.e., f 1 .E/ 2 F for all E 2 S . When f 2 F =B.Rd /, f is called a Borel measurable function. A measurable space equipped with a measure is a measure space denoted by .; F ; /. One can define the Rintegral of a Borel measurable function f on .; F ; / which will be denoted by f d. A probability space is a measurable space .; F ; P / in which is called sample space, F is called algebra of events and P is a probability measure on .; F /. In this case the integral with respect to P of a Borel measurable function f is called expectation of f and will be denoted by any of the symbols Z Z f .!/dP .!/ D f dP D EP Œf :
The probability of event ¹! 2 j conditionsº is simply denoted by P .conditions/: A measurable function X from a probability space .; F ; P / to a measurable space .S; S / is called an S-valued random variable. The inverse map identifies the sample points in on which the observation of event A depends. Let X be an Svalued random variable. The measure PX on .S; S / defined by PX .A/ D P .X 1 .A//;
A 2 S;
12
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
is called the image measure or the distribution of P under X . By the definition of the distribution of X W ! S we have Z EP Œf .X / D f .x/dPX .x/ (2.1.1) S
for a bounded Borel measurable function f W S ! Rd . The covariance of two Rd -valued random variables X and Y on the same probability space is defined by cov.X; Y / D EP Œ.X mX /.Y mY /;
(2.1.2)
where mX D EP ŒX and mY D EP ŒY are the expectations of X and Y , respectively. For two S-valued random variables X and Y , not necessarily defined on the d same probability space, we use the notation X D Y whenever they are identically distributed, i.e., PX D PY . A random variable X W ! R with distribution 2 1 .xm/ dPX .x/ D p e 2 2 dx 2 2
d
is called a Gaussian random variable and the notation X D N.m; 2 / is used. An N.0; 1/-distributed random variable is a standard Gaussian random variable. A random vector X D .X1 ; : : : ; Xd / W ! Rd is a multivariate Gaussian random variable if its distribution is given by dPX .x/ D
1 .2/d=2 .detC /1=2
1
e 2 .xm/C
1 .xm/
dx;
where x D .x1 ; : : : ; xd / 2 Rd , C D .Cij / is a d d symmetric, strictly positive definite matrix and m D .m1 ; : : : ; md / 2 Rd is a vector. The matrix element Cij gives the covariance cov.Xi ; Xj / of the multivariate Gaussian random variable, and mj D EP ŒXj . We summarize the notions of convergence of random variables next. Definition 2.1 (Convergence of random variables). Let .Xn /n2N be a sequence of real-valued random variables and X another real-valued random variable, all on a given probability space .; F ; P /. a:s:
.1/ Xn ! X , i.e., Xn is convergent almost surely to X if P . lim Xn .!/ D X.!// D 1: n!1
Lp
.2/ Xn ! X , i.e., Xn is convergent in Lp -sense to X for 1 p < 1 if lim EP ŒjXn X jp D 0:
n!1
13
Section 2.1 An invitation to Brownian motion P
.3/ Xn ! X , i.e., Xn is convergent in probability to X if for every " > 0, lim P .jXn .!/ X.!/j "/ D 0:
n!1 d
.4/ Xn ! X , i.e., Xn is convergent in distribution or weakly to X if lim EP Œf .Xn / D EP Œf .X /
n!1
for any bounded continuous function f . The relationships of the various types of convergence are given by Theorem 2.1. Let .Xn /n2N be a sequence of real-valued random variables and X another real-valued random variable, all on .; F ; P /. a:s:
Lp
P
.1/ If Xn ! X or Xn ! X for some p 1, then Xn ! X as n ! 1. P
d
.2/ If Xn ! X , then Xn ! X as n ! 1. P
a:s:
.3/ If Xn ! X , then there exists a subsequence Xnk ; k 1; such that Xnk ! X as k ! 1. P
.4/ .Dominated convergence theorem/ Let Xn ! X as n ! 1 and suppose there is a random variable Y such that jXn j Y , n D 1; 2; : : : , and EŒY < 1. L1
Then X 2 L1 .; dP / and Xn ! X . a:s:
.5/ .Monotone convergence theorem/ Let Xn ! X as n ! 1. Suppose the sequence .Xn /n1 is monotone and there exists M > 0 such that EP ŒXn < M , for all n. Then X 2 L1 .; dP / and EP ŒXn ! EP ŒX as n ! 1. Next we review the convergence properties of probability measures. Definition 2.2. Let S be a metric space and P a probability measure on .S; B.S //. .1/ A sequence of probability measures .Pn /n2N on .S; B.S // is weakly convergent to P whenever lim EPn Œf D EP Œf
n!1
(2.1.3)
for every bounded and continuous real-valued function f on S . .2/ A family P of probability measures on .S; B.S // is relatively compact whenever every sequence of elements of P contains a weakly convergent subsequence.
14
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
.3/ A family P of probability measures on .S; B.S // is tight whenever for every " > 0 there exists a compact set K" S such that P .K" / > 1 ", for every P 2 P. Note that for any given sequence .Xn /n2N of random variables on .; F ; P / with d
values in a metric space .S; B.S //, the convergence Xn ! X is equivalent to weak convergence of P ı Xn1 to P ı X 1 . We will be mainly interested in the cases S D C.Œ0; 1// and S D C.R/. Since both are Polish (i.e., complete separable metric) spaces, a family of probability measures .S; B.S // has a weakly convergent sequence if it is tight. Take S D C.R/. Recall that for T; ı > 0 the modulus of continuity of ! 2 S is defined by mT .!; ı/ D
max
jst jı T s;t T
j!.s/ !.t /j:
(2.1.4)
For S D C.Œ0; 1// the modulus of continuity only modifies by T being replaced by 0. Theorem 2.2. Let S be a Polish space. .1/ Prokhorov’s theorem: A family P of probability measures on .S; B.S // is relatively compact if and only if it is tight. .2/ A sequence .Pn /n2N of probability measures on .C.R/; B.C.R/// is tight if and only if lim sup Pn .!.0/ > / D 0;
(2.1.5)
"1 n1
lim sup Pn .mT .!; ı/ > "/ D 0;
ı#0 n1
8T > 0; 8" > 0:
(2.1.6)
Two events A; B 2 F are independent if and only if P .A \ B/ D P .A/P .B/. Two sub--fields F1 ; F2 of F are independent if every A 2 F1 and B 2 F2 are pairwise independent. Let X be a random variable on .; F ; P /. .X / denotes the minimal -field such that X is measurable, i.e., .X / D ¹X 1 .U /jU 2 S º:
(2.1.7)
Let Y be also a random variable on .; F ; P /. If the sub--fields .X / and .Y / are independent, then X; Y are said to be independent. If X; Y are independent, then cov.f .X /; g.Y // D 0 for all bounded Borel measurable functions f; g. For two Gaussian random variables the converse is also true, i.e., if their covariance is zero, then they are independent. Let .; F ; P / be a probability space and J be a given set. A family of S-valued random variables .X t / t2J is called a random process with index set J . When S D
15
Section 2.1 An invitation to Brownian motion
Rd we refer to it as a real-valued random process no matter the dimension. If J is uncountable, then .X t / t0 is called a continuous time random process. For any fixed t 2 J the map ! 7! X t .!/ is an S-valued random variable on , while for any fixed ! 2 the map t 7! X t .!/ is a function called path. This distinction justifies for any random process to address distributional properties on the one hand, and sample path properties on the other. Definition 2.3 (Brownian motion). A real-valued random process .B t / t0 on a probability space .; F ; P / is called Brownian motion or Wiener process starting at x 2 Rd , whenever the following conditions are satisfied: .1/ P .B0 D x/ D 1 .2/ the increments .B ti Bti1 /1in are independent Gaussian random variables d
for any 0 D t0 < t1 < < tn , n 2 N, with B ti Bti1 D N.0; ti ti1 / .3/ the function t 7! B t .!/ is continuous for almost every ! 2 . In particular .B t / t0 is called standard Brownian motion when x D 0. A d -component vector of independent Brownian motions .B t1 ; : : : ; B td / t0 is called d -dimensional Brownian motion. Brownian motion is thus a real-valued continuous time random process with index set RC D Œ0; 1/. Consider X D C.RC I Rd /;
(2.1.8)
the space of Rd -valued continuous functions on RC , equipped with the metric X 1 sup jf .x/ g.x/j ^ 1: dist.f; g/ D k 2 0jxjk k0
This metric induces the locally uniform topology in which fn ! f if and only if fn ! f uniformly on every compact set in RC . The so obtained topology gives rise to the Borel -field B.X /. Proposition 2.3. The Borel -field B.X / coincides with the -field generated by the cylinder sets of the form 1 ;:::;En AE t1 ;:::;tn D ¹! 2 X j.!.t1 /; : : : ; !.tn // 2 E1 En º
with E1 ; : : : ; En 2 B.Rd /, 0 t1 < t2 < < tn and n 2 N. Next we consider the canonical representation of Brownian motion on the measure space .X ; B.X /; W x /, where W x is the Wiener measure defined below. In this representation a realization of the process .B t / t0 is given by B t .!/ D !.t / 2 Rd ;
!2X
(2.1.9)
16
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
called coordinate process. For each fixed ! 2 X we think of RC 3 t 7! B t 2 Rd as a Brownian path. Write 1 jxj2 … t .x/ D exp (2.1.10) ; t > 0; x 2 Rd 2t .2 t /d=2 called d -dimensional heat kernel. Definition 2.4 (Wiener measure). Let 0 D t0 < t1 < < tn , Ej 2 B.Rd /, j D 1; : : : ; n, n 2 N, and 1E be the indicator function of E 2 B.Rd /. The unique measure W x on .X ; B.X // whose finite dimensional distributions are given by W x .B0 D x/ D 1
(2.1.11)
and W x .B t1 2 E1 ; : : : ; B tn 2 En / Z n n n Y Y Y D 1Ej .xj / … tj tj 1 .xj 1 xj / dxj Rd n
j D1
j D1
(2.1.12)
j D1
is called Wiener measure starting at x. For expectation with respect to Wiener measure we will use the notations Ex ŒF D EW x ŒF ;
EŒF D E0 ŒF :
(2.1.13)
By the definition of Wiener measure we have Ex
n hY j D1
i Z fj .B tj / D
Rnd
n Y
n n Y Y fj .xj / … tj tj 1 .xj 1 xj / dxj
j D1
j D1
j D1
(2.1.14) for all bounded Borel measurable functions f1 ; : : : ; fn with x0 D x. In particular, Z x f .y/… t .x y/dy: (2.1.15) E Œf .B t / D Rd
Recall that the real-valued random processes .X t / t2J and .Y t / t2J on a probability space .; F ; P / are versions of each other if for each t 0 there is a null set N t such that X t .!/ D Y t .!/ for all ! … N t . When t 7! Y t .!/ is continuous in t for almost every ! 2 , .Y t / t2J is called a continuous version of .X t / t2J . Theorem 2.4. The Wiener measure W x exists on .X ; B.X // and the coordinate process B t .!/ D !.t /, t 0, on .X ; B.X /; W x / is Brownian motion starting at x 2 Rd .
Section 2.1 An invitation to Brownian motion
17
Proof. The first part of the argument is to prove that there is a unique measure on .RŒ0;1/ ; G / satisfying (2.1.11) and (2.1.12), where G is the -field generated by the cylinder sets in RŒ0;1/ . This can be done by using the Kolmogorov extension theorem quoted in Proposition 2.5 below. The second part is to prove that there exists a continuous version .BQ t / t0 of the coordinate process .B t / t0 on RŒ0;1/ by using ˇ the simple criterion given by the Kolmogorov–Centsov theorem, see Proposition 2.6 below. Note that .BQ t / t0 is not the coordinate process, and while BQ t .!/ 6D !.t / for every ! 2 RŒ0;1/ , it is true that BQ t .!/ D !.t /, for ! … N t , with a null set N t depending on t . With the so constructed Brownian motion .BQ t / t0 on .RŒ0;1/ ; G ; /, BQ 0 D 0, let X W .RŒ0;1/ ; G ; / ! .X ; B.X // be defined by X t .!/ D BQ t .!/. Since BQ t .!/ is continuous in t , it can be checked that X 1 .E/ 2 B.RŒ0;1/ / for any cylinder set E. Thus X 2 G =B.X /, since B.X / coincides with the -field generated by the cylinder sets. The image measure X of under X on .X ; B.X // is denoted by W 0 . It is seen that W 0 is Wiener measure with x D 0, and the coordinate process B t W ! 2 X 7! !.t / is Brownian motion on .X ; B.X /; W 0 / starting at 0. Define Y W .X ; B.X /; W 0 / ! .X ; B.X // by Y t .!/ D B t .!/ C x. It can be seen that Y 2 B.X /=B.X /. Then the image measure of W 0 under Y on .X ; B.X // is denoted by W x . This is Wiener measure starting at x, and the coordinate process B t .!/ D !.t /, t 0, under W x is Brownian motion starting at x. Let be a Polish space and J be an index set, ƒ J , jƒj < 1, with j j denoting the cardinality of a finite set. Consider the family of probability spaces jƒj .ƒ ; B.ƒ /; ƒ / indexed by the finite subsets of J , where ƒ D kD1 . An element ! 2 ƒ is regarded as a map ƒ ! . Take now ƒ1 ƒ2 ƒ3 J and let ƒ1 ƒ2 W ƒ2 ! ƒ1 denote the projection defined by ƒ1 ƒ2 .!/ D !dƒ1 . The relation 1 ƒ1 .E/ D ƒ2 .ƒ .E// 1 ƒ2
(2.1.16)
for E 2 B.ƒ1 / and ƒ1 ƒ2 with jƒ1 j; jƒ2 j < 1, is called Kolmogorov consistency relation. Proposition 2.5 (Kolmogorov extension theorem). Let .ƒ ; B.ƒ /; ƒ /, ƒ J with jƒj < 1, be a family of probability spaces with underlying Polish space . Suppose that ƒ satisfies the consistency relation (2.1.16), and define 1 A D ¹ƒJ .E/ 2 J jƒ J; jƒj < 1; E 2 B.jƒj /º;
18
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
1 where ƒJ .E/ D ¹! 2 J j!dƒ 2 Eº. Then there exists a unique probability mea1 .E//, for E 2 B.ƒ / with ƒ J sure Q on .J ; .A// such that ƒ .E/ D . Q ƒ and jƒj < 1, where .A/ denotes the minimal -field containing A.
To address the second part of the existence theorem first we need the following concept. Definition 2.5 (Hölder continuity). A function f W RC ! R is called locally Hölder continuous at t 0 if there exist "; > 0 and Cs;t > 0 such that jf .t / f .s/j Cs;t jt sj ; for every s 0 such that jt sj < ". The number is called Hölder exponent and Cs;t is the Hölder constant. ˇ Proposition 2.6 (Kolmogorov–Centsov theorem). Let .; F ; P / be a probability space and .X t / t0 a real-valued random process on it. Suppose there exist ˛ 1, ˇ; C > 0 such that EP ŒjX t Xs j˛ C jt sjˇ C1 :
(2.1.17)
Then there exists a version .Y t /0tT of .X t /0tT for every T 0 with -Hölder continuous paths, with 0 ˇ=˛. Using a version copes with the fact that for a continuous time process path continuity is not a measurable event since, intuitively, to know about a path that it is continuous would need uncountably many observations and the countably generated field of cylinder sets cannot accommodate them. By the definition of Brownian motion it is straightforward to see that standard Brownian motion is a multivariate Gaussian process with EŒB t D 0; EŒBs B t D s ^ t; and an easy computation gives EŒ.B t Bs /2n D
.2n/Š jt sjn ; nŠ2n
n 2 N;
(2.1.18)
while all odd order moments of the increments of Brownian motion vanish. When applying Proposition 2.6 to Brownian motion one can make use of (2.1.18) and take ˛ D 2k, ˇ D k 1, k D 1; 2; : : : , to construct a -Hölder continuous version for every 0 < < .k 1/=.2k/. Optimizing over k implies Hölder continuity for any
D .0; 1=2/. In the following we briefly review some basic properties of Brownian motion starting with the distributional properties.
19
Section 2.1 An invitation to Brownian motion
Proposition 2.7 (Symmetry properties). Let .B t / t0 be standard Brownian motion. The following symmetry properties hold: .1/ .spatial homogeneity/ if .B tx / t0 is Brownian motion starting at x 2 R, then d
B t C x D B tx d
.2/ .reflection symmetry/ B t D B t p d .3/ .self-similarity/ cB t=c D B t , for all c > 0 ² 0 if t D 0; d then Z t D B t .4/ .time inversion/ let Z t .!/ D tB1=t .!/ if t > 0; d
.5/ (time reversibility) B ts B t D Bs , for all 0 s t . Proof. These equalities easily follow from (2.1.14). The fact that Z0 D 0 a.s. is an application of the strong law of large numbers quoted below. Next we discuss sample path properties of Brownian motion without proof. Proposition 2.8 (Global path properties). Let .B t / t0 be standard Brownian motion. Then the following hold almost surely: .1/ lim inf t!1 B t D 1 and lim sup t!1 B t D 1 p p .2/ lim inf t!1 B t = t D 1 and lim sup t!1 B t = t D 1 a:s:
.3/ .strong law of large numbers/ B t =t ! 0 as t ! 1 .4/ .law of the iterated logarithm/ p lim sup B t = 2t log log t D 1 and t!1
p lim sup B t = 2t log log.1=t / D 1 and t#0
p lim inf B t = 2t log log t D 1; t!1
p lim inf B t = 2t log log.1=t / D 1: t#0
Proposition 2.9 (Local path properties). Let .B t / t0 be standard Brownian motion. Then the following hold: .1/ .Hölder continuity/ For every T > 0, 2 .0; 1=2/ and almost every ! 2 X there is .T; ; !/ > 0 such that jB t .!/ Bs .!/j .T; ; !/jt sj ;
0 s; t T:
.2/ .Nowhere differentiability/ t 7! B t is almost surely at no point Hölder continuous for any > 1=2, hence nowhere differentiable.
20
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
.3/ .p-variation/ Let p > 0 and n D ¹t0 < t1 < < tn º be a partition of a bounded interval I R such that t0 and tn coincide with the two endpoints of I , with mesh m.n / D maxkD0;:::;n1 jtkC1 tk j. Define p
VI;n .!/ D
n1 X
jB tkC1 .!/ B tk .!/jp :
kD0
Then for every bounded interval I and d -dimensional Brownian motion ² d jI j; p D 2; p in LP .X ; d W x /-sense (a) lim supm.n /!0 VI;n .!/ D 0; p > 2; p
(b) lim supm.n /!0 VI;n is almost surely bounded if p > 2, and almost surely unbounded if p 2. By a similar construction as above Brownian motion can be extended over the whole time-line R instead of defining it only on RC . This can be done on the measurable space .Y ; B.Y //, with Y D C.RI Rd /. Consider XQ D X X and x D W x W x . Let ! D .!1 ; !2 / 2 XQ and define ´ if t 0 !1 .t / BQ t .!/ D !2 .t / if t < 0: Since BQ t .!/ is continuous in t 2 R under x , X W .XQ ; B.XQ // ! .Y ; B.Y // can be defined by X t .!/ D BQ t .!/. It can be seen that X 2 B.XQ /=B.Y / by showing that X 1 .E/ 2 B.XQ /, for any cylinder set E 2 B.Y /. Thus X is a Y -valued random variable on XQ . Denote the image measure of x under X on .Y ; B.Y // by WQ x . The coordinate process denoted by the same symbol BQ t W ! 2 Y 7! !.t / 2 Rd
(2.1.19)
is Brownian motion over R on .Y ; B.Y /; WQ x / with BQ 0 D x almost surely. We will denote the path space of two sided Brownian motion by X D C.R; Rd /. The properties of Brownian motion on the whole real line can be summarized as follows. Proposition 2.10 (Brownian motion on R). .1/ W x .BQ 0 D x/ D 1 .2/ the increments .BQ ti BQ ti1 /1in are independent Gaussian random variables d for any 0 D t0 < t1 < < tn , n 2 N, with BQ t BQ s D N.0; t s/, for t > s .3/ the increments .BQ ti1 BQ ti /1in are independent Gaussian random varid ables for any 0 D t0 > t1 > > tn , n 2 N, with BQ t BQ s D N.0; s t /, for t > s .4/ the function R 3 t 7! BQ t .!/ 2 R is continuous for almost every !
.5/ B t and Bs for t > 0 and s < 0 are independent.
21
Section 2.2 Martingale and Markov properties
It can be checked directly through the finite dimensional distributions (2.1.14) that the joint distribution of BQ t0 ; : : : ; BQ tn , 1 < t0 < t1 < < tn < 1, with respect to dx ˝ d WQ x is invariant under time shift, i.e., Z Rd
dxEWQ x
n hY
i Z fi .BQ ti / D
iD0
Rd
dxEWQ x
n hY
i fi .BQ ti Cs /
(2.1.20)
iD0
for all s 2 R. Moreover, the left-hand side of (2.1.20) can be expressed in terms of Wiener measure on X as " n " n # Z # Z Y Y dxEWQ x fi .BQ ti / D dxEW x fi .B ti t0 / : (2.1.21) Rd
2.2
iD0
Rd
iD0
Martingale and Markov properties
2.2.1 Martingale property Let G F be a sub--field and X a random variable on .; F ; P /. Recall that the conditional expectation EP ŒX jG is defined as the unique G -measurable random variable such that EP Œ1A X D EP Œ1A EP ŒX jG ;
A 2 G:
(2.2.1)
The left-hand side of (2.2.1) defines a measure PQ .A/ D EP Œ1A X on G and EP ŒX jG is in fact the Radon–Nikodým derivative d PQ =dP . The next lemma is of key importance. Lemma 2.11. Let .; F ; P / be a probability space and .S; S / a measurable space. Let, moreover, X be an S-valued random variable on and Y a real-valued and .X /-measurable random variable on . Then there exists an S -measurable function f on S such that Y D f ı X a.e. Proof. It suffices to show the lemma for non-negative Y . Let L be the set of realvalued .X /-measurable random variables on satisfying the assumption of the lemma. If A 2 .X /, then 1A 2 L and all .X /-measurable step functions belong to L . Since Y is .X /-measurable, there exists a sequence of increasing step functions n such that n ! Y almost surely. Since n 2 L , there exists a sequence of S -measurable functions fn such that n D fn ı X . Define the function f on S by f .x/ D lim supn!1 fn .x/ for x 2 S. Then f is S -measurable and f .X.!// D lim supn!1 fn ı X.!/ D limn!1 fn ı X.!/ D Y .!/, and hence Y 2 L.
22
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Let .X t / t0 be a random process on .; F ; P /. Then EP Œf j.X t / is a .X t /measurable function and by Lemma 2.11 it can be expressed as EP Œf j.X t / D h.X t / with a Borel measurable function h. This function is usually denoted by h.x/ D EP Œf jX t D x:
(2.2.2)
Note that if h.X t / D f .X t / D EP Œf j.X t / a.s., then h.x/ D f .x/ for P ıX t1 -a.e. x 2 R, so the ambiguity in the expression (2.2.2) has measure zero under P ı X t1 . Since EP Œf .X0 /g.X t / D EP Œf .X0 /EP Œg.X t /j.X0 /, using the notation (2.2.2) we have Z 0 .dx/f .x/EP Œg.X t /jX0 D x; (2.2.3) EP Œf .X0 /g.X t / D Rd
where 0 .dx/ denotes the distribution of X0 on R. The conditional expectation EP Œ1A jG is in particular denoted by P .AjG /. It is not obvious that P .jG /.!/ defines a probability measure for almost every !, since P .AjG /./ is defined almost surely for each A. Let P .AjG /.!/ be defined on ! 2 nS NA with P .NA / D 0. Then P .jG /.!/ W F ! Œ0;S 1 is defined only for ! 2 n A2F NA . It is, however, in general not clear that P . A2F NA / D 0. This justifies the following definition. Definition 2.6 (Regular conditional probability measure). Let .; F ; P / be a probability space, and G a sub--field of F . A function Q W F ! Œ0; 1 is called a regular conditional probability measure for F given G if .1/ Q.!; / is a probability measure on .; F / for every ! 2 .2/ Q.; A/ is G -measurable for every A 2 F .3/ Q.!; A/ D P .AjG /.!/, P -a.s. ! 2 , for every A 2 F . We will be interested in the case when the sub--field is generated by a random variable X , which makes worthwhile to rephrase this definition. We use the notation EŒ1A jX D x D P .AjX D x/. Definition 2.7 (Regular conditional probability measure). Let .; F ; P / be a probability space and X be a random variable on it with values in a measure space .S; S /. A function Q W S F ! Œ0; 1 is called a regular conditional probability measure for F given X if .1/ Q.x; / is a probability measure on .; F / for every x 2 S .2/ Q.; A/ is S -measurable for every A 2 F .3/ Q.x; A/ D P .AjX D x/, P ı X 1 -a.s., for every A 2 F .
Section 2.2 Martingale and Markov properties
23
Theorem 2.12. Suppose that is a Polish space and F D B./. .1/ Let P be a probability measure on .; F / and G a sub--field of F . Then there exists a regular conditional probability measure for F given G , and it is unique. .2/ Let X be random variable on .; F / with values in a measurable space .S; S /. Then there exists a regular conditional probability measure for F given X . Moreover, if Q0 is another regular conditional probability measure, then there exists a set N 2 S with P ı X 1 .N / D 0, such that Q.x; A/ D Q0 .x; A/, for all A 2 F and every x 2 S n N . .3/ If S is a Polish space and S D B.S /, then the null set N 2 S above can be chosen such that Q.x; X 1 .B// D 1B .x/, for B 2 S , x 2 S n N . In particular, Q.x; X 1 .x// D 1, P ı X 1 -a.e. x 2 S , holds. In what follows the regular conditional probability measures Q.!; A/ and Q.x; A/ will be denoted by P .AjG / and P .AjX D x/, respectively, unless confusion may arise. Definition 2.8 (Filtration). Let .; F ; P / be a probability space and .F t / t0 a family of sub--fields of F . The collection .F t / t0 is called a filtration whenever Fs F t for s t . The given measurable space endowed with a filtration is called a filtered space. Intuitively, Ft contains the information known to an observer at time t . Let .Xs /s0 be an S -valued random process. A convenient choice of filtration is the natural filtration given by F tX D .Xs ; 0 s t /, containing the information accumulated by observing X up to time t . Definition 2.9 (Adapted process). Let .; F / be a filtered space, .F t / t0 a given filtration and .X t / t0 a random process. The process is called .F t / t0 -adapted whenever X t is F t -measurable for every t 0. If a process .X t / t0 is .F t / t0 -adapted it means that the process does not carry more information at time t than F t . Obviously, .X t / t0 is adapted to its natural filtration .F tX / t0 , or equivalently, the natural filtration .F tX / t0 is the smallest filtration making .X t / t0 adapted. Definition 2.10 (Martingale). Let .; F ; P / be a filtered space with a given filtration .F t / t0 . The random process .X t / t0 is an .F t / t0 -martingale whenever .1/ EP ŒjX t j < 1, for every t 0 .2/ .X t / t0 is .F t / t0 -adapted .3/ EP ŒX t jFs D Xs , for every s t .
24
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
We will make use of the next result on martingales which will be quoted here with no proof. Theorem 2.13 (Martingale inequality). Let .X t / t0 be an .F t / t0 -martingale on .; F ; P / and suppose that X t .!/ is continuous in t , for almost every ! 2 . Then for all p 1, T 0 and all > 0, P
1 sup jX t j p EP ŒjXT jp : 0tT
(2.2.4)
Proposition 2.14. Let .B t / t0 be Brownian motion on .; F ; P / and consider its natural filtration .F tB / t0 . Then both .B t / t0 and .B t2 t / t0 are .F tB / t0 -martingales. Proof. We have that EP ŒB t jFsB D EP ŒB t Bs jFsB C EP ŒBs jFsB D EP ŒB t Bs C Bs D Bs (2.2.5) by independence of B t Bs and Br for r s. By a similar calculation it is easy to show also the second claim. Remarkably, there is a strong converse of this proposition. Proposition 2.15 (Lévy martingale characterization theorem). Let .X t / t0 be a random process and .F tX / t0 be its natural filtration. Suppose that .1/ X0 D 0 almost surely, .2/ the paths t 7! X t are almost surely continuous, .3/ both .X t / t0 and .X t2 t / t0 are .F tX / t0 -martingales. Then .X t / t0 is a standard Brownian motion. There is a useful weakening of the martingale property which removes the condition of integrability in Definition 2.10. To introduce and apply it below, we first need a concept of random times. Definition 2.11 (Stopping time). Let .; F ; P / be a filtered space with filtration .F t / t0 . A random variable W ! Œ0; 1 such that ¹ t º 2 F t , for all t 0, is called a stopping time. Whenever the filtration is right-continuous, is a stopping time if and only if ¹ < t º 2 F t , for every t 0. An example of a stopping time is the first hitting time of Brownian motion .B t / t0 of an open (or a closed) set E, i.e., D inf¹t 0 W B t 2 Eº. If . n /n2N is a sequence of stopping times and n # ,
25
Section 2.2 Martingale and Markov properties
S then since ¹ < t º D n1 ¹ n < t º, we have that also is a stopping time. Similarly, if a sequence of stopping times . n /n2N is such that n " , then since ¹ t º D \n1 ¹ n < t º, again is a stopping time. Notice that t ^ is a stopping time whenever is. We make use of this in the following property. Definition 2.12 (Local martingale). A random process .X t / t0 on a filtered probability space .; F ; .F t / t0 ; P / is said to be a local martingale if there exists a sequence of stopping times . n /n2N such that .X t^n / t0 is a martingale with respect to the filtration .F t^n / t0 . Whenever .X t / t0 has a continuous version, one way of choosing the stopping times is n D inf¹t 0 j jXn j > nº.
2.2.2 Markov property In addition to the martingale property Brownian motion possesses the equally important Markov property. Intuitively, this means that the future values of the random process only depend on its present value and do not on its past history. Definition 2.13 (Markov process). Let .X t / t0 be an adapted process on a filtered space .; F ; P / with a filtration .F t / t0 . .X t / t0 is a Markov process with respect to .F t / t0 whenever EP Œf .X t /jFs D EP Œf .X t /j.Xs / ;
0 s t;
(2.2.6)
for all bounded Borel measurable functions f . Markov processes can be characterized by their probability transition kernels. Definition 2.14 (Probability transition kernel). A map p W RC RC Rd B.Rd / ! R, .s; t; x; A/ 7! p.s; t; x; A/, is called a probability transition kernel if .1/ p.s; t; x; / is a probability measure on B.Rd / .2/ p.s; t; ; A/ is Borel measurable .3/ for every 0 r s t , the Chapman–Kolmogorov identity Z p.s; t; y; A/p.r; s; x; dy/ D p.r; t; x; A/ Rd
(2.2.7)
holds. Let .X t / t0 be a Markov process. We define pX .s; t; x; A/ D EP Œ1A .X t /jXs D x for A 2 B.Rd /, 0 s t < 1 and x 2 Rd .
(2.2.8)
26
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Lemma 2.16. Let .X t / t0 be a Markov process with a filtration .F t / t0 . Then pX is a transition probability kernel. Proof. Properties (1) and R(2) of Definition 2.13 are straightforward to check, therefore we R only show (3). Since Rd 1A .y/pX .r; s; x; dy/ D EP Œ1A .Xs /jXr D x, we have Rd f .y/pX .r; s; x; dy/ D EP Œf .Xs /jXr D x, for bounded Borel functions f . Hence Z pX .s; t; y; A/pX .r; s; x; dy/ D EP ŒpX .s; t; Xs ; A/jXr D x: (2.2.9) Rd
Here pX .s; t; Xs ; A/ D pX .s; t; y; A/ evaluated at y D Xs . Thus the identity pX .s; t; Xs ; A/ D EP Œ1A .X t /j.Xs / follows, and furthermore pX .s; t; Xs ; A/ D EP Œ1A .X t /jFs by the Markov property. Inserting this into (2.2.9) we obtain Z pX .s; t; y; A/pX .r; s; x; dy/ D EP ŒEP Œ1A .X t /jFs jXr D x: (2.2.10) Rd
Since .Xr / Fs , we have that EP ŒEP Œ1A .X t /jFs j.Xr / D EP Œ1A .X t /j.Xr /, and therefore EP ŒEP Œ1A .X t /jFs jXr D x D pX .r; t; x; A/: R Combining this with (2.2.10), Rd pX .s; t; y; A/pX .r; s; x; dy/ D pX .r; t; x; A/ is obtained. The measure P 0 .A/ D P .X0 2 A/
(2.2.11)
is the initial distribution of the Markov process describing the random variable at t D 0. Then the finite dimensional distributions of .X t / t0 are determined by its probability transition kernel and initial distribution through the formula P .X t0 2 A0 ; : : : ; X tn 2 An / Z Y n n Y 1Ai .xi / p.ti1 ; ti ; xi1 ; dxi / 1A0 .x0 /P 0 .dx0 /; D Rd
iD1
(2.2.12)
iD1
for n D 1; 2; : : : , and where t0 D 0. Proposition 2.17. Let .X t / t0 be an Rd -valued random process on a probability space .; F ; P /, P 0 a probability measure on Rd and p.s; t; x; A/ a probability transition kernel. Suppose that the finite dimensional distributions of the process are
27
Section 2.2 Martingale and Markov properties
given by (2.2.12). Then .X t / t0 is a Markov process under the natural filtration with probability transition kernel p.s; t; x; A/. Proof. It suffices to show that n n i i h h Y Y EP 1A .X tCs / 1Aj .X tj / D EP EP Œ1A .X t /j.Xs / 1Aj .X tj / (2.2.13) j D0
j D0
for every 0 D t0 < t1 tn t r and every Aj 2 B.Rd /, j D 0; 1; : : : ; n. From the identity EP Œ1A .X t /EP Œf .Xr /j.X t / D EP Œ1A .X t /f .Xr /, it follows that Z Z 1A .y/EP Œf .Xr /jX t D yP t .dy/ D 1A .y/f .y 0 /p.t; r; y; dy 0 /P t .dy/; Rd
Rd
R where we denote P t .dy/ D Rd P 0 .dy0 /p.0; t; y0 ; dy/ and note that P t .dy/ is the distribution of X t on Rd . Thus it is seen that Z EP Œf .Xr /jX t D y D f .y 0 /p.t; r; y; dy 0 /: (2.2.14) Rd
By the definition of EP Œf .Xr /jX t D y we have Z EP Œf .Xr /j.X t / D
Rd
f .y/p.t; r; X t ; dy/
(2.2.15)
and thus EP Œ1A .Xr /j.X t / D p.t; r; X t ; A/:
(2.2.16)
Using (2.2.16) and the Chapman–Kolmogorov identity, (2.2.13) follows. Furthermore we have the following strong description of the converse situation. Proposition 2.18. Let p.s; t; x; A/ be a probability transition kernel and P 0 a probability distribution on Rd . Then there exists a filtered probability space .; F ; P / and a Markov process .X t / t0 on it such that EP Œ1A .X t /jXs D x D p.s; t; x; A/ and P ı X01 D P 0 . When the transition probability kernel p.s; t; X; A/ of a Markov process satisfies p.s; t; x; A/ D p.0; t s; x; A/, the process is said to be stationary Markov process. In this case by a minor abuse of notation we write p.t; x; A/ for p.0; t; x; A/, and the
28
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Chapman–Kolmogorov identity reduces to Z Rd
p.s; y; A/p.t; x; dy/ D p.s C t; x; A/:
(2.2.17)
Theorem 2.19. Let .B t / t0 be Brownian motion adapted to a filtration .F t / t0 . Then .B t / t0 is a stationary Markov process and Ex Œf .BsCt0 ; : : : ; BsCtn /jFs D EBs Œf .B t0 ; : : : ; B tn / ;
8x 2 Rd ;
(2.2.18)
holds for every bounded Borel function f . Moreover, its initial distribution P 0 D ıx is Dirac measure with mass at x, while its probability transition kernel is given by Z PBM .t; x; A/ D
Rd
1A .z/… t .x z/dz
(2.2.19)
or equivalently, PBM .t; x; dy/ D … t .x y/dy:
(2.2.20)
Proof. The Markov property with transition probability kernel (2.2.20) follows by the definition of the finite dimensionalRdistributions of Brownian motion and Proposition 2.17. Note that Q PBM .s; t; x; A/ D Rd 1A .z/… ts .x z/dz. We show (2.2.18). Let h.y/ D Ex Œ jnD1 f .BsCtj /jBs D y. By the identity n n h i h hY ii Y x x fj .BsCtj / D E 1A .Bs /E fj .BsCtj /j.Bs / E 1A .Bs / x
j D1
j D1
we have Z
n n n Y Y Y 1A .y/…s .y x/ fj .xj / …t1.x1 y/ … tj tj 1 .xj xj 1 / dy dxj
R.nC1/d
j D1
Z
D
Rd
j D2
j D1
1A .y/h.y/…s .y x/dy:
Comparing the two sides above Z h.y/ D
n Y Rnd
j D1
n n Y Y fj .xj / … t1 .x1 y/ … tj tj 1 .xj xj 1 / dxj j D2
j D1
29
Section 2.2 Martingale and Markov properties
Q is obtained, while the right-hand side equals Ey Œ jnD1 fj .B tj /. Hence E
x
n hY
n i i hY Bs f .BsCtj /j.Bs / D E fj .B tj /
j D1
j D1
and (2.2.18) follows. From the proof of Theorem 2.19 it follows that the Markov property (2.2.6) can be reformulated as Ex Œf .B t /jFs D EBs Œf .B ts /;
t s:
(2.2.21)
In what follows, the Markov property of a random process will be considered with respect to its natural filtration, unless otherwise stated. 1
Corollary 2.20. Let ˛ 2 R. Then the random process .e ˛B t 2 ˛ t / t0 is a martingale with respect to the natural filtration of Brownian motion. 2
Proof. By (2.2.21) we have 1
1
Ex Œe ˛B t 2 ˛ t jFsB D EBs Œe ˛B t s 2 ˛ t : 2
2
The right-hand side above can be computed as Z 1 2 1 2 1 2 EBs Œe ˛B t s 2 ˛ t D e 2 ˛ t e ˛y … ts .Bs y/dy D e ˛Bs 2 ˛ s Rd
and the corollary follows. Brownian motion has a yet stronger Markov property than (2.2.18) since the same equality holds even for random times. Given a stopping time , we define the -field F by saying that A 2 F if and only if A 2 F and A \ ¹ t º 2 F t , for all t 0. Intuitively, F contains the events occurring before or at the given stopping time. Theorem 2.21 (Strong Markov property). Let .B t / t0 be a Brownian motion and a bounded stopping time with respect to the filtration .F t / t0 . Then Ex ŒB tC jF D EB ŒB t ;
t 0; x 2 Rd :
(2.2.22)
The theorem is valid also for unbounded stopping times but we have stated it in this form for simplicity.
2.2.3 Feller transition kernels and generators Markov processes are intimately related to semigroups, which intuitively describe the time evolution of the probability distributions. Here we need to use operator semigroup theory; for essential background material see Section 3.1.8 below.
30
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Definition 2.15 (Feller transition kernel). A probability transition kernel p.t; x; A/ is said to be a Feller transition kernel whenever the following conditions hold: .1/ p.t; x; Rd / D 1 R .2/ Rd p.t; ; dy/f .y/ 2 C1 .Rd / for f 2 C1 .Rd / R .3/ lim t#0 Rd p.t; x; dy/f .y/ D f .x/, for every f 2 C1 .Rd / and x 2 Rd . Consider Z .P t f /.x/ D
p.t; x; dy/f .y/: Rd
(2.2.23)
When P t f 0 for f 0, for all t 0, the semigroup ¹P t ; t 0º is called nonnegative. The next proposition gives the relationship between Markov processes and C0 -semigroups. Proposition 2.22. Let p.t; x; A/ be a Feller transition kernel. Then ¹P t W t 0º is a non-negative C0 -semigroup on C1 .Rd /. Proof. It is easy to see that P0 D 1 and P t is non-negative. P t Ps D P tCs follows by the Chapman–Kolmogorov identity. Moreover, kP t f k1 kf k1 can also easily be seen. The difficult part is to show the strong continuity, i.e., lim P t f D f
t!0
(2.2.24)
R1 in the sup-norm. Let ˛ > 0 and define f˛ D 0 ˛e ˛t P t f .x/dt . Then f˛ 2 C1 .Rd /, since f 2 C1 .Rd /. Let M be the closed subspace ofR C1 .Rd / spanned by 1 f such that (2.2.24) holds. Take f 0 and define f˛;h .x/ D h ˛e ˛t P t f .x/dx; then f˛;h .x/ " f˛ .x/ as h # 0. This convergence is uniform as the sequence of continuous monotone functions .f˛;h /h converges to f˛ .x/ pointwise on the compact set Rd [ ¹1º. Since M is closed, f˛ 2 M follows for any non-negative f 2 C1 .Rd / and therefore for all f 2 C1 .Rd /. Let l 2 C1 .Rd / be a linear functional on C1 .Rd /. Since kf˛ k1 kf k1 and lim˛!1 f˛ .x/ D f .x/ pointwise, it follows that f˛ ! f weakly as ˛ ! 1 and hence l.f˛ / ! l.f / as ˛ ! 1. Suppose l.g/ D 0 for all g 2 M . Then for any f 2 C1 .Rd /, l.f / D lim˛!1 l.f˛ / D 0. Thus the Hahn–Banach theorem yields that C1 .Rd / D M . The converse statement of Proposition 2.22 is also true. Proposition 2.23. For any non-negative C0 -semigroup there exists a unique Feller transition kernel such that (2.2.23) holds.
31
Section 2.2 Martingale and Markov properties
Let .X t / t0 be a Markov process and consider its Feller transition kernel. P t in (2.2.23) is by Proposition 2.22 a C0 -semigroup and there exists a closed operator L on C1 .Rd / such that 1 lim .P t f f / D Lf: t!0 t L is called the generator of the Markov process and is formally written as P t D e tL . Proposition 2.24. The probability transition kernel P BM of Brownian motion is a Feller transition kernel and its generator is .1=2/ on C01 .Rd /. R Proof. We have already shown that p BM .t; x; A/ D Rd 1A .z/… t .xz/dz in (2.2.19). R 2 Thus p BM .t; x; Rd / D 1 holds. Since P tBM f .x/ D .2 t /d=2 Rd e jzj =2t f .x C z/dz for f 2 C1 .Rd /, by dominated convergence it is clear that P tBM f .x/ is continuous in x and limjxj!1 P tBM f .x/ D 0. Thus P tBM f 2 C1 .Rd /. Next we check that lim P tBM f .x/ D f .x/:
t!0
(2.2.25)
Notice that f is uniformly continuous on the compact set Rd [ ¹1º. Thus for any " > 0 there exists ı > 0 such that jf .x C y/ f .x/j " for all x 2 Rd and jyj < ı. Hence jP tBM f .x/ f .x/j Z Z jf .x C y/ f .x/j… t .y/dy C jyj<ı
Z
Z
"
jyj<ı
jyjı
… t .y/dy C M
jyjı
jf .x C y/ f .x/j… t .y/dy
… t .y/dy;
where M D supx jf .x/j. Thus lim t!0 jP tBM f .x/ f .x/j ", whence (2.2.25) follows. Let LBM denote the generator of Brownian motion and take f 2 C01 .Rd /. 2 The Fourier transform of P tBM f is equal to e tjkj =2 fO.k/. This gives 1 BM O/ 1 jkj2 fO D 0 . P f f lim (2.2.26) t t!0 t 2
2
and lim
t!0
1 1 BM .P t f f / D f t 2
(2.2.27)
in L2 .Rd /. By taking a subsequence t 0 , (2.2.27) stays valid for almost every x 2 Rd while the right-hand side (2.2.27) is equal to LBM f . Hence LBM f D .1=2/f for almost every x. We will see in Section 2.4.2 below that Feller transition kernels form a rich class and further examples of generators will be given.
32
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
2.2.4 Conditional Wiener measure We conclude this section by discussing pinned Brownian motion. Definition 2.16 (Brownian bridge measure). Given a division T1 t1 < < tn T2 and x; y 2 Rd , the probability measure on .X ; B.X // defined by x;y
WŒT1 ;T2 .B t1 2 A1 ; : : : ; B tn 2 An / (2.2.28) Z n n Y … t1 T1 .x x1 /… t2 t1 .x1 x2 / …T2 tn .xn y/ Y 1Ai .xi / dxi D …T2 T1 .x y/ Rnd iD1
iD1
is called Brownian bridge measure starting in x at t D T1 and ending in y at t D T2 . Furthermore, the measure x;y
…T2 T1 .x y/WŒT1 ;T2
(2.2.29)
is called conditional Wiener measure. Note that the Brownian bridge measure is a probability measure, while conditional Wiener measure is not. x;y x;y Write EŒT1 ;T2 for expectation with respect to WŒT1 ;T2 . From the definition it is x;y directly seen that W x and WŒT1 ;T2 are related through x
E
n hY
i Z fj .B tj / D
j D1
Rd
dy…T2 T1 .x
x;y y/EŒT1 ;T2
n hY
i fj .B tj / ;
(2.2.30)
j D1
with T1 t1 tn T2 and any bounded Borel function fj . In particular, x
E
h
n Y i fj .B tj / g.BT2 / f .BT1 /
Z D
Rd
(2.2.31)
j D1 x;y
dy…T2 T1 .x y/f .x/g.y/EŒT1 ;T2
n hY
i fj .B tj / :
j D1
Definition 2.17 (Full Wiener measure). We refer to the measure d W D d W x ˝ dx
on X Rd
(2.2.32)
as full Wiener measure, carrying infinite mass. d Although full Wiener R measure is not a probability measure on X R , we use the notation EW Œ for d W . The full Wiener measure d W is expressed in terms of the Brownian bridge measure as Z x;y dW D …T2 T1 .x y/d WŒT1 ;T2 dy dx; Rd
33
Section 2.3 Basics of stochastic calculus
or in other words, Z Z n Y fi .B ti /d W D X Rd iD1
x;y
Rd Rd
dxdy…T2 T1 .x y/EŒT1 ;T2
n hY
i fi .B ti / :
iD1
(2.2.33) For T1 t1 tn T2 define EW Œ jBT2 D x; BT1 D y by EW
n hY j D1
n ˇ i i hY ˇ x;y fj .B tj /ˇBT2 D x; BT1 D y D …T2 T1 .x y/EŒT1 ;T2 fj .B tj / : j D1
(2.2.34) Thus for T1 t1 tn T2 we have n Y i h EW f .BT1 / fj .B tj / g.BT2 / j D1
Z D
2.3
Rd Rd
f .x/g.y/EW
n hY
ˇ i ˇ fj .B tj /ˇBT1 D x; BT2 D y dxdy:
j D1
Basics of stochastic calculus
2.3.1 The classical integral and its extensions Classical analysis provides a working notion of integral called after Riemann. In this concept a real-valued function f on an interval I D Œa; b is considered, I is divided into subintervals n D ¹a D x0 < < xn D bº and limits of sums of the type n1 X
f . j /.xj C1 xj /;
j 2 Œxj ; xj C1 /
j D0
are considered when limn!1 m.n / D 0, where m.n / is the mesh of the partition. When such a limit exists independent of the choice of the partition and the values j , Rb we call it the Riemann integral a f .x/dx of f . A sufficient condition for the Riemann integral of f to exist is that f is continuous. If for some purposes one is interested in integrating a function against the increments of another, it is possible to extend the concept of Riemann integral to cover this Rb case. This extension is achieved by the Stieltjes integral a f .x/dg.x/, obtained as the limit of sums of the type n1 X j D0
f . j /.g.xj C1 / g.xj //;
j 2 Œxj ; xj C1 /:
34
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Riemann integral then follows when the integrator is the identity function, g.x/ D x. Two sufficient conditions for the Stieltjes integral of f with respect to g to exist are (1) f and g have no discontinuities at the same point x, (2) f is continuous and g is of bounded variation. However, (2) is not a necessary condition. Surprisingly, there are few results on weaker conditions on the existence of Riemann–Stieltjes integral. Young has shown as early as in 1936 that if f is -Hölder Rb continuous and g is -Hölder continuous such that C > 1, then a f .x/dg.x/ exists. A nearly optimal (sufficient and “very nearly” also necessary) condition is that .1/ f and g are not both discontinuous at the same point x, .2/ f has bounded p-variation and g has bounded q-variation for some p; q > 0 such that 1=p C 1=q D 1. Rb Our interest is to define integrals of the type a X t dB t where we would use Brownian motion as integrator and a random process X t as integrand. Clearly, due to nowhere differentiability of Brownian motion, the usual Riemann–Stieltjes integral will not work. However, since Brownian motion is of bounded p-variation for p > 2, see Proposition 2.9, provided the integrand is of bounded q-variation with suitable q < 2, Young’s criteria can be applied. This is possible, in particular, when .X t / t0 has bounded variation, i.e., q D 1. A sufficient condition for this is that t 7! X t is differentiable and has bounded derivative. However, the approach offered by Young or the conditions above quickly show their limitations as they would fail to cover Rb the simple integral a B t dB t . In order to include this and more interesting cases a genuinely new type of integral is needed.
2.3.2 Stochastic integrals Recall the basic theorem of calculus: If f 2 C 1 .Rd I R/ and g 2 C 1 .RI Rd /, then Z f .g.t // f .g.0// D
t 0
rf .g.s// .dg.s/=ds/ ds:
Since Brownian paths are nowhere differentiable, we cannot substitute Bs for g.s/ in the formula above. In spite of that, a similar formula still exists with an extra term appearing as a correction. Indeed, we will see that almost surely we have Z f .B t / f .B0 / D
0
t
1 rf .Bs / dBs C 2
Z
t
f .Bs / ds; 0
with an expression formally written as dBs “D” .dBs =ds/ds which will be explained below. The first term on the right-hand side above leads to a new concept of integral. Following the conventional concept of Riemann–Stieltjes integrals, in order to construct the integral with respect to Brownian motion we divide the interval into n subin-
35
Section 2.3 Basics of stochastic calculus
tervals and look at approximating sums Sn D
n X
f .Bsj /.B tj C1 B tj /;
sj 2 Œtj ; tj C1 /:
j D1
The pathwise (that is, in X pointwise) limit of the random variable Sn does not exist due to the unbounded variation of Brownian paths, thus it cannot be defined as a Stieltjes integral. However, as it will be seen below, when Sn is regarded as an element of L2 .X ; d W /, it does have a limit. But even in this situation we face the peculiar feature that, unlike in the case of Riemann–Stieltjes integral, the limit depends on how the point sj is chosen and a different object is obtained when sj D tj or when sj D tj C1 . First we consider one dimensional standard Brownian motion. Example 2.1. Take a division of the interval Œ0; T into P subintervals of equal length, i.e., choose tj D j T =n. Then in L2 -sense limn!1 jn1 D0 B tj .B tj C1 B tj / D Pn1 1 1 2 2 j D0 B tj C1 .B tj C1 B tj / D 2 .BT C T /. Indeed, a rear2 .BT T / and limn!1 rangement of the terms gives for the first sum n1 X j D0
n1 1 1X B tj .B tj C1 B tj / D BT2 .B tj C1 B tj /2 : 2 2 j D0
By Proposition 2.9 the latter sum converges in L2 sense to the quadratic variation VT2 D T , thus the first claim follows. The other limit can be computed similarly. To remove the problem of dependence on the intermediary point, we restrict here to the choice sj D tj , i.e., choose the integrand to be adapted to the natural filtration .F tB / t0 of standard Brownian motion. We call ..t // t0 a random step process if there is a sequence 0 D t0 < < tn and random variables f0 ; : : : ; fn 2 L2 .X ; d W / such that fj are F tjB -adapted and .t; !/ D
n1 X
fj .!/1Œtj ;tj C1 / .t /:
(2.3.1)
j D0 2 will be used for the space of random step processes. The notation Mstep
Definition 2.18. We denote by M 2 .S; T / the class of functions f W RC X ! R such that .1/ f 2 B.RC / B.X /=B.R/ .2/ f .t; !/ is F tB -adapted RT .3/ EŒ S jf .t; !/j2 dt < 1.
36
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Let .t; !/ be (2.3.1) with S D t0 < t1 < < tn D T . Define Z
T
S
.t; !/dB t D
n X
fj .!/ .Btj C1 .!/ Btj .!//:
(2.3.2)
j D0
Lemma 2.25. Let .t; !/ be as in (2.3.2). Then
ˇ Z ˇ Ex ˇˇ
T S
ˇ2
Z ˇ .t; !/dB t ˇˇ D Ex
T S
j.t; !/j2 dt :
(2.3.3)
RT Proof. Denote for a shorthand I./ D S .t; !/dB t , Bj D B tj C1 B tj and tj D tj C1 tj . Then clearly Ex ŒBj D 0, Ex Œ.Bj /2 D tj . We have n1 X
jI./j2 D
fj2 .Bj /2 C 2
j D0
X
fj fk Bj Bk :
j
By independence, if j < k, then Ex Œfj fk Bj Bk D 0. On the other hand, for j D k, Ex Œfj2 .Bj /2 D Ex Œfj2 tj . Hence Ex ŒjI./j2 D
n1 X
Ex Œfj2 tj :
(2.3.4)
j D0
Moreover, j.t /j2 D
Pn1
2 j D0 fj 1Œtj ;tj C1 / .t /,
i.e.,
ˇ# n1 "ˇZ ˇ ˇ T X ˇ ˇ Ex ˇ j.t /j2 dt ˇ D Ex Œfj2 tj ˇ ˇ S
(2.3.5)
j D0
follows. A comparison of the right-hand sides of (2.3.4) and (2.3.5) above completes the proof. Equality (2.3.3) is called Itô isometry. Using Itô isometry we can extend the defiRT nition of the stochastic integral S f .t; !/dB t to f 2 M 2 .S; T /. We first construct 2 convergent to a in the lemma below a sequence of random step functions n 2 Mstep 2 given f 2 M .S; T /, that is, # "Z Ex
T
S
jf .t; !/ n .t; !/j2 dt ! 0 as n ! 1.
(2.3.6)
2 satisfying Lemma 2.26. Let f 2 M 2 .S; T /. Then there exits a sequence n 2 Mstep (2.3.6).
37
Section 2.3 Basics of stochastic calculus
Proof. We divide the proof into four steps. Step 1: Let g 2 M 2 .S; T / be bounded and g.; !/ be continuous for every ! 2 X . 2 such that Then there exists a sequence of random step functions n 2 Mstep Z
T S
jg.t; !/ n .t; !/j2 dt ! 0
as n ! 1. In fact, we can take n D
(2.3.7)
Pn1
j D0 g.tj ; !/1Œtj ;tj C1 / .t /.
Step 2: Let h 2 M 2 .S; T / be bounded. Then there exists a bounded sequence gn 2 M 2 .S; T / of functions gn .; !/ continuous for every !, with Z T jh.t; !/ gn .t; !/j2 dt ! 0 (2.3.8) S
Rt as n ! 1. We can take gn .t; !/ D 0 n .s t /h.s; !/ds, whereR negative and continuous function, (2) supp n Œ1=n; 0, and (3) R
n
is (1) a nonD 1.
n .x/dx
Step 3: Let f 2 M 2 .S; T /. Then there exists a sequence hn 2 M 2 .S; T / of bounded functions and Z T jf .t; !/ hn .t; !/j2 dt ! 0 (2.3.9) S
as n ! 1. Here we can take
8 ˆ <n; hn .t; !/ D f .t; !/; ˆ : n;
f .t; !/ < n n f .t; !/ n f .t; !/ > n:
Step 4: If f 2 M 2 .S; T /, by (2.3.7)–(2.3.9) we can choose a sequence of random R 2 such that Ex Œ T jf .t; !/ .t; !/j2 dt ! 0 as n ! 1. step functions n 2 Mstep n S RT Hence by Lemma 2.3.6 and the Itô isometry . S n dB t /n2N is a Cauchy sequence RT in L2 .X ; d W x /. Thus S n dB t converges to a random variable as n ! 1 in L2 .X ; d W x /. Now we are in the position to define the Itô integral. Definition 2.19 (Itô integral/stochastic integral). Let f 2 M 2 .S; T / and .n /n2N R 2 such that Ex Œ T jf .t; !/ .t; !/j2 dt ! 0 as n ! 1. We define the Itô Mstep n S integral of f by Z T Z T f .t; !/dB t D lim n .t; !/dB t : (2.3.10) S
n!1 S
38
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Note that the definition of step functions n .
RT S
f .t; !/dBs is independent of the choice of random
Rt Example 2.2. We compute 0 Bs dBs as follows. Take the division 0 D s0 < < P sn D t of the interval, with sj D jt =n. Write n .t / D jn1 D0 Bsj 1Œsj ;sj C1 / . Then Rt Rt 2 and we see by Example 2.1 that .s; !/dB approximates B dB in L s s 0 n 0 s Z
Z
t 0
t
Bs dBs D lim
n .t /dBs D lim
n!1 0
n!1
n1 X j D0
1 t Bsj .Bsj C1 Bsj / D B t2 : 2 2
Here are some basic properties of the Itô integral. Theorem 2.27 (Itô isometry). Let f 2 M 2 .S; T /. Then the expectation of any Itô integral is "Z # T x E f .s; !/dBs D 0; S
and its covariance is given by
ˇ Z ˇ E ˇˇ
T
x
S
ˇ2
Z ˇ x ˇ f .s; !/dBs ˇ D E
T
2
jf .s; !/j ds :
S
The latter relationship is called Itô isometry for this class of functions. Proof. This follows from the definition of
RT S
f .t; !/dB t and (2.3.3).
2 Theorem 2.28 (Martingale R t property). Let f 2 M .0; t / for all t 0. The random process .I t / t0 , I t D 0 f .s; !/dBs , is a martingale with respect to the natural filtration of Brownian motion, .F tB / t0 , i.e.,
.1/ I t is F tB -measurable, .2/ Ex ŒjI t j < 1, .3/ Ex ŒIs jF tB D I t , for s t . Rt Proof. (1) and (2) are immediate; we show (3). Let I t .n/ D 0 n .s; !/dBs , where P .n/ n D jn1 D0 fj .!/1Œt .n/ t .n/ / .t /. I t .n/ is an approximating sequence of I t . We j C1
have
j
Z x
E
ŒIs .n/jF tB
D
Z
t 0
n .s; !/dBs C E
s
x t
n .r; !/dBr jF tB
:
39
Section 2.3 Basics of stochastic calculus
The claim follows by showing that the second term on the right-hand side above vanishes. We have ˇ ˇ
Z s
X ˇ B ˇ B .n/ x x ˇ ˇ E n .r; !/dBr ˇ F t D E fj .B t .n/ B t .n/ /ˇ F t : j C1 j t
.n/
fj
.n/
ttj
.n/
tj C1 s
.n/
.B t .n/ B t .n/ / is independent of F tB and thus Ex Œfj j C1
.n/
Ex Œfj
j
.B t .n/ B t .n/ /jF tB D j C1
j
.B t .n/ B t .n/ / D 0. Therefore j C1
j
Z
s
x
E
t
ˇ ˇ B ˇ n .r; !/dBr ˇ F t D 0:
Theorem 2.29 (Continuous version). Let f 2 M 2 .0; T /. Then the random process Rt .I t /0tT , I t D 0 f .s; !/dBs , has a continuous version .IQt /0tT , i.e., IQt .!/ is continuous in t for almost every ! 2 X and W x .IQt D I t / D 1, for all 0 t T . 2 be such that Proof. Without restricting generality we set x D 0. Let n .t / 2 Mstep Rt Rt 2 EŒ 0 jf .s; !/ n .s; !/j ds ! 0 as n ! 1. Write I t .n/ D 0 n .s; !/dBs . Note that I t .n/ is continuous in t for all n and is an F tB -martingale. This implies that I t .n/ I t .m/ is also F tB -martingale, thus by the martingale inequality (see Theorem 2.13) we have
W
1 sup jI t .n/ I t .m/j > " 2 EŒjIT .n/ IT .m/j2 " 0tT "Z # T 1 2 D 2E jn .s/ m .s/j ds ! 0 " 0
as m; n ! 1. Hence we can choose a subsequence nk ! 1 such that W .Ak / 2k , where Ak D ¹! 2 X j sup jI t .nkC1 ; !/ I t .nk ; !/j > 2k º: 0tT
P1
1 Since kD1 W .Ak / < 1, we get W .\1 N D1 [kDN Ak / D 0 by the Borel–Cantelli lemma. Thus for almost every ! 2 X it follows that
sup jI t .nkC1 ; !/ I t .nk ; !/j 2k 0tT
for all k > N.!/, with some N.!/. Therefore .I t .nk ; !//k2N is a Cauchy sequence and so it converges uniformly in t 2 Œ0; T as k ! 1 for almost every ! 2 X , which is denoted by IQt .!/. IQt .!/ is continuous in t for almost every ! 2 X since the convergence is uniform in t . Since I t .nk / ! I t in L2 .X /, we conclude that IQt D I t almost surely.
40
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
From now on we will consider the continuous version of the Itô integral of a random process without explicitly stating it. Next we consider d -dimensional Brownian motion .B t / t0 and f D .f1 ; : : : ; fd / such that f 2 M 2 .0; t /, D 1; : : : ; d . We define the Itô integral Z 0
t
f .s; !/ dBs D
d Z X D1 0
t
f .s; !/dBs :
(2.3.11)
Rt It is easy to see that the basic properties Ex Œ 0 f .s; !/ dBs D 0 and
Z Ex
t
0
Z f .s; !/dBs
t 0
Z t f .s; !/dBs D ı Ex f .s; !/f .s; !/ds 0
similarly hold. Let Cbn .Rd / denote the set of bounded and n times continuously differentiable functions on Rd . Consider the following specific cases. Corollary 2.30. Let B t be d -dimensional Brownian motion. Write tj D tj=2m and Bj D Btj Btj 1 , 1 j 2m . .1/ Let f 2 Cb1 .Rd /. Then Z
n
lim
n!1
2 X j D1
f .Btj 1 /Bj
D
0
t
f .Bs /dBs :
(2.3.12)
.2/ Let f 2 Cb2 .Rd /. Then Z t Z 2 X 1 t 1 lim .f .Btj 1 / C f .Btj //Bj D f .Bs /dBs C @ f .Bs /ds: n!1 2 2 0 0 n
j D1
(2.3.13) The limits in both expressions above are understood in L2 .X ; d W x / sense. Proof. (1) is directly obtained from the definition of Itô integral. For (2) we write 2n ˇ ˇ X X 1X ˇ ˇ @ f .B tj 1 /Bj @ @ f .B tj 1 /Bj Bj ˇ ˇf .B tj / f .B tj 1 / 2 ;
j D1
n
C
2 X j D1
n!1
jB tj B tj 1 j3 ! 0
41
Section 2.3 Basics of stochastic calculus
in L2 .X ; d W x /, where C is a constant independent of !. By writing f .Btj 1 / C f .Btj / D 2f .Btj 1 / C .f .Btj / f .Btj 1 // and making a Taylor expansion we have l:h:s: (2.3.13) n
D lim
n!1
D
t 0
2n
f .Btj 1 /Bj
j D1
1 lim 2 3Š n!1
C Z
2 X
XX 1 lim C @ f .Btj 1 /Bj Bj 2 n!1 d
j D1 D1
2n X
d X
@ @ f .Btj 1 /Bj Bj Bj
j D1 ;D1
f .Bs /dBs
1 C 2
Z
t
@ f .Bs /ds: 0
yielding (2.3.13). Definition 2.20 (Stratonovich integral). The right-hand side of (2.3.13) defines the Stratonovich integral, i.e., for f D .f1 ; : : : ; fd / 2 .Cb2 .Rd //d , Z 0
Z
t
f .Bs / ı dBs D
t 0
1 f .Bs / dBs C 2
Z
t
r f .Bs /ds:
0
(2.3.14)
Using random processes given by Itô integrals we have the following important class. Definition 2.21 (Itô process). A random process .X t / t0 on .X ; B.X /; W / is called Itô process if .1/ t 7! X t .!/ is continuous for almost every ! 2 X Rt .2/ there exist a random process .b t / t0 with 0 jbs jds < 1, and an Rd -valued random process . t / t0 2 M 2 .0; t /, for all t 0, such that Z X t D X0 C
Z
t 0
bs ds C
t
0
s dBs :
(2.3.15)
In concise differential notation the above integral equality is written as dX t D b t dt C t dB t :
(2.3.16)
The process .b t / t0 is called drift term and . t / t0 diffusion term. It should be stressed that the stochastic differentials dX t resp. dB t have no meaning other than the shorthand explained above. Finally, we define a more general stochastic integral for a wider class of integrands by weakening the conditions of M 2 .0; T /.
42
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Definition 2.22. Let M2 .S; T / be the class of f W RC X ! R such that .1/ f 2 B.RC / B.X /=B.R/ .2/ f .t; !/ is .F tB / t0 -adapted Rt .3/ W x . 0 jf .s; !/j2 ds < 1/ D 1. Rt For this class it is not necessarily true that Ex Œ 0 jf .s; !/j2 ds < 1. However, for f 2 M2 .0; t / there exists a sequence .fn /n2N M 2 .0; t / such that Z t jfn .s; !/ f .s; !/j2 ds ! 0 (2.3.17) 0
Rt as n ! 1, for almost every ! 2 X . The sequence 0 fn .s; !/dBs converges to a random variable for almost every ! 2 X , and the limit only depends on f while it does not on fn . Definition 2.23. Let f 2 M2 .0; t / and .fn /n2N M 2 .0; t / be an approximating sequence as in (2.23). Define the stochastic integral Z t Z t f .s; !/dBs D lim fn .s; !/dBs in probability: (2.3.18) 0
n!1 0
Note that the so defined integral is not an F tB -martingale and the Itô isometry is also not automatically satisfied. Example 2.3. Let f 2 L2loc .R/. It is not necessarily true that f .Bs / 2 M 2 .0; t /, Rt however, it is true that f .Bs / 2 M2 .0; t /. Therefore 0 f .Bs /dBs is well defined by (2.3.18).
2.3.3 Itô formula Another landmark result of stochastic analysis is the Itô formula which is the counterpart of the fundamental change of variable rule in classical analysis. In particular, this provides a tool for computing Itô integrals without directly having to use the definition. Recall that C 1;2 .RC R/ denotes the space of functions on RC R which are C 1 with respect to the first variable and C 2 with respect to the second. Theorem 2.31 (Itô formula for Brownian motion). Let h 2 C 1;2 .RC R/ and define X t D h.t; B t /. Then .X t / t0 is an Itô process and we have Z t Z t P Bs / C 1 @2 h.s; Bs / ds C X t X0 D @x h.s; Bs /dBs ; (2.3.19) h.s; 2 x 0 0 or in equivalent differential notation (and with hP D @s h.s; x/) P B t / C 1 @2 h.t; B t / dt C @x h.t; B t /dB t : dX t D h.t; 2 x
(2.3.20)
43
Section 2.3 Basics of stochastic calculus
Remark 2.1 (Rules of Itô differential calculus). For practical purposes the following formal rules of Itô differential calculus are useful: dt dt D 0;
dt dB t D 0;
dB t dt D 0;
dB t dB t D ı dt
(2.3.21)
for all ; D 1; : : : ; d . The last property intuitively corresponds to the fact that the quadratic variation of Brownian motion p grows linearly in time, that is, B t has large fluctuations on small scale, dB t D O. dt/. By using the rules of formal Itô differential calculus the following more general formula is readily obtained. Theorem 2.32 (Itô formula for Itô process). Let .X ti / t0;1in be the Rd -valued Itô process dX ti D b ti dt C ti dB t ;
i D 1; : : : ; n;
(2.3.22)
on .X ; B.X /; W x /, where b ti .!/ 2 L1loc .RC ; dt /; ti .!/ D
i . t .!//1d
8! 2 X ; [ M2 .0; T /: T 0
Let h D .h1 ; : : : ; hm / 2 C 1;2 .RC Rn I Rm /. Then also Y t D h.t; X t / is an Itô process with d Y tk D hP k dt C
n X iD1
hki dX ti C
n 1 X k j hij dX ti dX t ; 2
1 k m:
(2.3.23)
i;j D1
Here hP D @ t h, hki D @xi hk and hkij D @xi @xj hk , evaluated at .t; X t /. In differential notation, n n n X X 1 X k hki b ti C hij . t tT /ij dt C hki ti dB t : d Y tk D hP k C 2 iD1
i;j D1
(2.3.24)
iD1
An application of the Itô formula gives the following useful result. Corollary 2.33 (Product formula). Let .X t / t0 and .Y t / t0 be two Itô processes as in (2.3.22). Then the product formula d.X t Y t / D dX t Y t C X t d Y t C dX t d Y t holds.
(2.3.25)
44
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Proof. Choose g.x; y/ D x y, x D X t and y D Y t . Then the formula follows directly from the Itô formula. Example 2.4. When the integrand f .s/ is continuous and of bounded variation but non-random, i.e., independent of !, an application of the Itô formula gives Z t Z t f .s/dBs D f .t /B t Bs df .s/: 0
0
Example 2.5. Let Z t D g.t; X t / with g.t; x/ 2 C 1;2 .RC R/, where dX t D V .B t /dt C a.B t / dB t and a D .a1 ; : : : ; ad /. Then 1 dZ t D gP C .a a/x g C V @x g dt C .@x g/a dB t : 2
(2.3.26)
This formula shows the relationship between Stratonovich and Itô integrals. In the particular case g.t; x/ D g.x/ and X t D B t Z t g.B t / D g.B0 / C .@x g/.Bs / ı dBs : (2.3.27) 0
We conclude this section by two further applications of the Itô formula (2.3.23). 1
2
Example 2.6 (Wick exponential). Put h.t; x/ D e ˛x 2 ˛ t ; notice that it satisfies .1=2/h C hP D 0. The Itô formula yields dh.t; B t / D ˛hdB t . Hence Z t 1 h.s; Bs /dBs D .h.t; B t / 1/: (2.3.28) ˛ 0 Define the Wick exponential of e ˛B t by
1 2 Wexp.˛B t /W D exp ˛B t ˛ t ; 2
(2.3.29)
giving Z t Z t
Z t 1 x 2 Wexp f .s; Bs /dBs W D exp f .s; Bs /dBs E jf .s; Bs /j ds : 2 0 0 0 This definition is useful for stating the Cameron–Martin formula (2.3.57) below. The Wick product of B tn can then be written as n d h WB tn W D .t; B t /d˛D0 ; d˛ n and as a result we obtain by (2.3.28) Z t WBsn WdBs D 0
1 WB nC1 W: nC1 t
45
Section 2.3 Basics of stochastic calculus
The following inequality offers useful bounds on the moments of the martingale RT 0 f .s; Bs / dBs . Proposition 2.34 (Burkholder–Davis–Gundy (BDG) inequality). Suppose that for RT m 2 N we have EŒ 0 jf .t; B t /j2m dt < 1. Then
ˇ Z ˇ E ˇˇ
T 0
ˇ2m
Z ˇ m m1 ˇ f .t; B t / dB t ˇ E .m.2m 1// T
T 0
jf .t; B t /j
2m
dt : (2.3.30)
Proof. To see this, apply the Itô formula to jX t j2m , where dX t D f .t; B t / dB t . We obtain d jX t j2m D m.2m 1/jX t j2m2 jf .t; B t /j2 dt C 2mjX t j2m1 f .t; B t / dB t : Hence Z EŒjX t j
2m
m.2m 1/
0
T
EŒjXs j2m2 jf .s; Bs /j2 ds:
(2.3.31)
By the Jensen inequality we have EŒjX t j2m jFs jXs j2m for t s. Thus EŒjXs j2m EŒjXT j2m : By (2.3.31) and the Hölder inequality it follows that EŒjXT j
2m
m.2m 1/.EŒjXT j
.2m2/p 1=p
/
Z E
q 1=q
T 0
2
jf .s; Bs /j ds
for 1=p C 1=q D 1. Putting p D m=.m 1/ and q D m we obtain .EŒjXT j
2m 1=m
/
Z m.2m 1/E
m 1=m
T
0
2
jf .s; Bs /j ds
:
Taking the mth power of both sides, by Schwarz inequality
Z EŒjXT j
2m
m
Œm.2m 1/ T
m1
E
0
T
jf .s; Bs /j
2m
ds :
Rt Since . 0 f .s; Bs /dBs / t0 is a continuous martingale provided that f 2 M 2 .0; t / for all t 0, combining the BDG inequality and the martingale inequality (2.2.6) further useful inequalities can be derived.
46
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
2.3.4 Stochastic differential equations and diffusions In this section we consider a class of stochastic differential equations (SDE) and their solutions. An SDE can be thought of arising from an ordinary differential equation XP t D a t X t in which a t is replaced by a factor consisting of a non-random and a noise term. The solution of such an equation is a random process. The theory of SDE makes possible to implement the noise term mathematically and allows to show that under sufficient regularity a solution exists, it is continuous in t and has the Markov property. Consider the SDE Z t Z t i i Xt D bs .Xs /ds C si .Xs / dBs (2.3.32) 0
0
or in differential form dX ti D b ti .X t /dt C ti .X t / dB t :
(2.3.33)
Theorem 2.35 (Solution of SDE). Suppose that for t 2 Œ0; T jb t .x/j C j t .x/j C.1 C jxj/; jb t .x/ b t .y/j C j t .x/ t .y/j Djx yj;
(2.3.34) (2.3.35)
with some constants C; D independent of x; y 2 P Rd and t 2 Œ0; T , where we set Pn ij 2 1=2 j t .x/j D . i;j D1 j t .x/j / and jb t .x/j D . niD1 jb ti .x/j2 /. Then there exists a unique solution X x D .X tx / t2Œ0;T on .X ; B.X /; W 0 / of dX ti D b ti .X t /dt C ti .X t / dB t ;
X0i D x i 2 R;
i D 1; : : : ; n;
(2.3.36)
such that .1/ .X tx / t0 is adapted to the natural filtration of Brownian motion .F tBM / t0 RT .2/ EŒ 0 jX tx j2 dt < 1 .3/ X tx is almost surely continuous in t 2 Œ0; T . An important class of solutions of SDE is the following. Definition 2.24 (Diffusion process). A random process .X t / t0 on a filtered space .X ; B.X /; W 0 / with filtration .F t / t0 is a diffusion process whenever .1/ .X t / t0 is a Markov process, .2/ X t .!/ is continuous in t for every ! 2 X . Now consider (2.3.36) with b ti and ti replaced by a time-independent b i and i , respectively.
47
Section 2.3 Basics of stochastic calculus
Theorem 2.36 (Itô diffusion). Suppose that jb.x/ b.y/j C j.x/ .y/j Djx yj; with some constant D independent of x; y 2 Rd . Then the unique solution .X tx / t2Œ0;T of dX ti D b i .X t /dt C i .X t / dB t ;
X0i D x i 2 R;
i D 1; : : : ; n;
(2.3.37)
satisfies the Markov property Xsx
x EŒf .XsCt /jFsBM D EŒf .X t
/ Xx
y
for every Borel measurable bounded function f , where EŒf .X t s / D EŒf .X t / x x evaluated at y D Xsx . In particular, EŒf .XsCt /jFsBM D EŒf .XsCt /j.Xsx / holds. The diffusion process in Theorem 2.36 is called Itô diffusion. Next we compute the transition probability kernel of the Itô diffusion .X tx / t0 . The Markov propXsx / implies the equality EŒ1A .X tx /jXsx D y D erty EŒ1A .X tx /j.Xsx / D EŒ1A .X ts y EŒ1A .X ts /. Thus the probability transition kernel of .X tx / t0 satisfies y
p.s; t; y; A/ D EŒ1A .X ts /:
(2.3.38)
Moreover, by (2.3.38) the Itô diffusion .X tx / t0 is stationary. Let .X tx / t0 be an Itô diffusion and U t W L1 .Rd / ! L1 .Rd / be given by U t f .x/ D EŒf .X tx /:
(2.3.39)
Then by the definition of U t , Xsx
Us U t f .x/ D EŒU t f .Xsx / D EŒEŒf .X t
/;
and by the Markov property we furthermore have x x /jFsBM D EŒf .X tCs / D U tCs f .x/: D EŒEŒf .X tCs
Thus ¹U t W t 0º defines a semigroup on L1 .Rd /. Definition 2.25 (Generator of Itô diffusion). The generator HX of an Itô diffusion .X tx / t0 is defined by 1 HX f .x/ D lim .U t f .x/ f .x//: t#0 t
(2.3.40)
48
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Theorem 2.37 (Generator of Itô diffusion). Let .X tx / t0 be an Itô diffusion obtained as the solution of (2.3.37). Its generator is given by the second order partial differential operator n n X 1 X T HX D . /ij .x/@i @j C b i .x/@i 2 i;j D1
(2.3.41)
iD1
acting on C02 .Rd /. Proof. Let .Y ti / t0 be the Itô process d Y ti D ui dt C v i dB t with Y0i D x i . The Itô formula (2.3.24) yields f .Y t / f .Y0 / D
Z t X n n X 1 .vv T /ij @i @j f .Ys / C ui @i f .Ys / ds 2 0 i;j D1 iD1 Z tX n C .@i f .Ys //v i dBs : 0 iD1
Taking expectation, the martingale part left with
Z t EŒf .Y t / D f .x/ C E
0
R t Pn 0
iD1 .@i f
/v i dBs vanishes and we are
n n X 1 X .vv T /ij @i @j f .Ys / C ui @i f .Ys / ds : 2 i;j D1
iD1
Hence U f .x/ f .x/
Z t X n n X 1 DE . T /ij .Xsx /@i @j f .Xsx / C b i .Xsx /@i f .Xsx / ds : 2 0 i;j D1
iD1
(2.3.42) Since Xsx is continuous in s, the lemma now follows directly. The last equality is in fact a simple version of Dynkin’s formula. Example 2.7 (Linear SDE). Assume that the n n, n 1 and n d matrices A t , a t and t , respectively, are non-random and locally bounded. Let ˆ t be the n n P t D A t ˆ t . Then the solution of matrix function solving the non-random equation ˆ the linear stochastic differential equation dX t D .A t X t C a t / dt C t dB t
(2.3.43)
49
Section 2.3 Basics of stochastic calculus
is given by Z t Z t 1 1 ˆs as ds C ˆs s dBs ; X t D ˆ t X0 C 0
(2.3.44)
0
where ˆ1 t is the inverse matrix of ˆ t . This is easily checked by an application of the Itô formula. Example 2.8 (Langevin equation). Let d D 1 and a; > 0. Consider the stochastic differential equation dX t D aX t dt C dB t ;
X0 D x 2 R:
By (2.3.44) the solution of (2.3.45) is given by Z t x at ea.ts/ dBs : Xt D e x C
(2.3.45)
(2.3.46)
0
The random process .X tx / t0 is called Ornstein–Uhlenbeck process. We have by (2.3.46) EŒX tx D eat x;
covŒX tx Xsx D
2 .1 e2a.s^t/ /eajtsj : 2a
(2.3.47)
Moreover, the generator of X tx is given by 2 ax r: 2
(2.3.48)
Definition 2.26 (Brownian bridge). A Brownian bridge over the interval ŒT1 ; T2 starting in a 2 Rd and ending in b 2 Rd is a multivariate Gaussian random process .X t /T1 tT2 on .; F ; P / such that .1/ XT1 D a a.s.
t t Cb .2/ EP ŒX t D a 1 T 2 T1 T 2 T1 st .3/ cov.Xs ; X t / D s ^ t : T 2 T1 From this it follows that EP ŒXT2 D b, cov.Xs ; XT2 / D 0, thus actually XT2 D b almost surely since EP ŒjXT2 bj2 D 0, justifying the name of the process. For t 2 ŒT1 ; T2 the distributional relation t t d Xt D 1 .b BT2 / C B t (2.3.49) aC T 2 T1 T 2 T1 holds.
50
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Example 2.9 (SDE for Brownian bridge). The Brownian bridge starting in a at t D 0 and ending in b at t D T solves the stochastic differential equation b Xt dt C dB t ; 0 t < T; X0 D a: T t As a linear SDE, it can be solved exactly through (2.3.44) giving Z t 1 t t Xt D a 1 dBs ; 0 t < T: C b C .T t / T T 0 T s dX t D
Let
Z ˛ t D .T t /
0
t
1 dBr ; T r
0 t < T:
(2.3.50)
(2.3.51)
(2.3.52)
Then ˛ t is a Gaussian random variable with EŒ˛ t D 0 and Z t^s 1 st EŒ˛s ˛ t D .T t /.T s/ dr D s ^ t : 2 .T r/ T 0 Thus
t t Cb ; EŒX t D a 1 T T
cov.X t ; Xs / D s ^ t
st : T
It is easily seen that X t ! b as t ! T in L2 .X ; d W /. Furthermore, it can also be shown that X t .!/ ! b for almost every ! 2 X .
2.3.5 Girsanov theorem and Cameron–Martin formula In this section we add a pathwise shift to Brownian paths and show that this results in a Brownian motion on a suitable probability space. Fix T > 0 and suppose that a t D a t .!/ D .a1t ; : : : ; adt / is such that Z T sup ja t .!/j2 dt < 1: !2X
0
Define the random process .Z t /0tT by 1 dZ t D a t dB t a2t dt: 2
(2.3.53)
Next, define the measure POT on .X ; FT /, with FT D FTB D .Bs ; 0 s T /, and the d -dimensional random process .BO t /0tT by putting POT .A/ D EŒe ZT 1A ; A 2 FT ; Z t O B t .!/ D B t .!/ as .!/ds; t 2 Œ0; T : 0
Note that POT .X / D 1.
51
Section 2.3 Basics of stochastic calculus
Proposition 2.38 (Girsanov theorem). The random process .e Zt /0tT is an .F t /0tT -martingale and .BO t /0tT is a d -dimensional Brownian motion on the space .X ; FT ; POT /. Proof. Since de Zt D Z t a t dB t , e Zt is an .F t /0tT -martingale (already seen in Corollary 2.20). For 2 C 2 .Rd / a combination of the Itô formula and the product formula (2.3.25) gives 1 d.e Zt .BO t // D e Zt .r .BO t / C a t / dB t C e Zt .BO t /dt: 2 From this and by the martingale property of e Zt it follows that for A 2 Fs , s t ,
Z s Zr O O O EPOT Œ.B t /1A D E .B0 / C e .r .Br / C ar / dBr 1A C
1 2
Z
0
t
0
EŒ1A e Zr .BO r /dr
Z 1 t O D EŒ1A e .Bs / C EŒ1A e Zr .BO r /dr 2 s
Z 1 t D EPOT .BO r /dr 1A : .BO s / C 2 s Zs
Rt Hence it can be seen that Y t D .BO t / .BO 0 / 12 0 .BO s /ds is an .F t /0tT martingale on .X ; FT ; POT /. Set .x/ D e i x , 2 Rd , and substitute this into Y t . Then the random process e
i BO t
j j2 C 2
Z
t 0
O
e i Bs ds;
0 t T;
d is an .F t /0tT -martingale on .X ; FT ; POT /. Since dt EPOT ŒY t jFs D we have d j j2 O O EPOT Œe i B t jFs D EPOT Œe i B t jFs : dt 2
d Y dt s
D 0,
Solving this equation yields O
O
EPOT Œe i .B t Bs / jFs D e j j
2 .ts/=2
:
(2.3.54)
Thus .BO t2 t /0tT is an .F t /0tT -martingale, therefore by Proposition 2.15 .BO t /0tT is a Brownian motion on .X ; FT ; POT /, as claimed. We conclude by two applications of Girsanov’s theorem.
52
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Example 2.10 (Drift transformation). Consider the process .X t / t0 given by the solution of dX t D dB t C a t .X t /dt: (2.3.55) Rt By the Girsanov theorem BQ t D B t 0 as .Bs /ds, t 2 Œ0; T , is a Brownian motion on .X ; FT ; e ZT W /, where ZT is given by (2.3.53). From the definition of BQ t we have dB t D d BQ t C a t .B t /dt:
(2.3.56)
Put
1 d ZQ t D a t .B t / dB t a t .B t /2 dt: 2 We regard B t as a solution of the stochastic differential equation (2.3.56) on .X ; FT ; Q e ZT W /. Its generator is 12 C a r, which coincides with that of X t of the solution of (2.3.55) on .X ; B.X /; W /. Therefore Q
EŒf .X t / D EŒf .B t /e ZT : Let Q be the distribution of W under the random variable X 3 ! 7! X .!/ 2 X . Then ! Z T Z 1 T dQ D exp as .Bs / dBs as .Bs /2 ds : dW 2 0 0 Example 2.11 (Cameron–Martin formula). Here we consider the effect of pathwise shifts applied to Brownian motion. Let d Y t D dB t C a t dt; 1 d ZN t D a t dB t a2t dt: 2 Note that a t is independent of the path ! 2 X and Z t Z t Y t .!/ D B t .!/ C as ds D !.t / C as ds 0
R
0
Rt
is a shift of ! by the path 0 as ds. Since BN t D B t 0 as ds is a Brownian motion N on .X ; FT ; e ZT W / by the Girsanov theorem, we have that
Z t N N EŒf .Y t / D E f BN t C as ds e ZT D EŒf .B t /e ZT : (2.3.57) 0
Here we used that
Rt 0
as ds is independent of path !.
53
Section 2.4 Lévy processes
Let Q be the distribution of W under the random variable X 2 ! ! Y .!/ 2 X on .X ; B.X //. By (2.3.57) Z t Z dQ 1 t 2 D exp as dBs a ds (2.3.58) dW 2 0 s 0 follows, known as the Cameron–Martin formula.
2.4
Lévy processes
2.4.1 Lévy process and Lévy–Khintchine formula Brownian motion is a specific case of a wider class of random processes which itself is of interest for our purposes. It is a simple fact of elementary probability that the distributions of sums of independent, identically distributed random variables are obtained as convolutions of their distributions. A natural question is then whether one can break up a given random process into sums of others, simpler or canonical ones. This leads to considering the following concept. Definition 2.27 (Infinite divisibility). An Rd -valued random variable X on a probability space .; F ; P / is infinitely divisible if for every n 2 N there exist indepen.n/ .n/ dent, identically distributed random variables X1 ; : : : ; Xn such that d
.n/
X D X1
C C Xn.n/ :
(2.4.1)
Equivalently, the probability distribution on Rd of X is infinitely divisible if there .n/ exists a probability distribution n common to all Xj such that D n n : „ ƒ‚ … n-fold
(2.4.2)
Recall that the convolution of distributions 1 and 2 on Rd is defined by the formula Z .1 2 /.A/ D 1A .x C y/1 .dx/2 .dy/ Rd Rd
for A 2
B.Rd /.
In terms of the characteristic function O of , i.e., Z iuX D e iux .dx/; u 2 Rd ; .u/ O D EP Œe Rd
we can alternatively say that a random variable is infinitely divisible if and only if for every n 2 N there is a characteristic function O n satisfying .u/ O D .O n .u//n :
(2.4.3)
54
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Let be a probability measure on Rd . Then the characteristic function of has the properties (1) .0/ O D 1 and j.u/j O 1; (2) O is uniformly continuous; (3) O is non-negative definite, i.e., n X
.u O k ul /zk zN l 0
(2.4.4)
k;lD1
for uj 2 Rd , zi 2 C, i; j D 1; : : : ; n, n 1. A remarkable fact is that the converse of this statement is also true: If a function ' W Rd ! C satisfies properties (1)-(3) above, then there exists a probability measure on Rd such that the characteristic function of is O D '. This is Bochner’s theorem, discussed in Theorem 5.10 below. Example 2.12. Examples of infinitely divisible processes include: d
.1/ Gaussian distribution: Take a Gaussian random variable X D N.m; 2 / over R with Gaussian distribution .x m/2 .dx/ D .2 2 /1=2 exp dx: 2 2 Since by direct computation .u/ O De
ium.1=2/u2 2
!!n m 1 2 2 D exp i u u p ; n 2 n
p D N m=n; .= n/2 .
.n/ d
.n/
we have X1 ; : : : ; Xn
d
.2/ Poisson distribution: Since for a Poisson random variable X D Poi . / over R with the distribution .¹kº/ D e
k ; kŠ
k 2 N [ ¹0º;
we have n iu .u/ O D exp .e iu 1/ D exp .e 1 ; n .n/
.n/ d
we can identify X1 ; : : : ; Xn
D Poi . =n/.
d
.3/ Cauchy distribution: Let X D C.˛; ˇ/, ˛ > 0, ˇ 2 Rd , be a random variable with the Cauchy distribution on Rd .dx/ D
˛ ..d C 1/=2/ dx: .d C1/=2 2 .jx ˇj C ˛ 2 /.d C1/=2
55
Section 2.4 Lévy processes
Then
n ˛ ˇ .u/ O D exp .˛juj C iˇ u/ D exp juj C i u : n n .n/
.n/ d
Thus we can identify X1 ; : : : ; Xn
D C.˛=n; ˇ=n/.
Two important counterexamples are the uniform and binomial distributions. Next we will see that there is a general formula describing the characteristic function of any infinitely divisible random variable. Definition 2.28 (Lévy measure). A -finite Borel measure on B.Rd n ¹0º/ satisfying Z .jyj2 ^ 1/.dy/ < 1 (2.4.5) Rd n¹0º
is called Lévy measure. Theorem 2.39 (Lévy–Khintchine formula). If a probability distribution on Rd is infinitely divisible, then there exist a vector b 2 Rd , a non-negative definite symmetric d d matrix A and a Lévy measure such that .u/ O D e .u/ , for all u 2 Rd , where Z 1 .e iuy 1 i u y 1¹jyj<1º / .dy/: (2.4.6) .u/ D i b u u Au C 2 Rd n¹0º The triplet .b; A; / is uniquely given. Conversely, given a triplet .b; A; / with the above properties there exists an infinitely divisible probability distribution on Rd whose characteristic function is O D e .u/ . Remark 2.2. The integrand in (2.4.6) satisfies ´ 1 juj2 jyj2 C O.jyj3 /; iuy 1 i u y 1¹jyj<1º j 2 je 2;
jyj < 1; ; jyj 1
R ensuring that the integral is well defined. Furthermore, if jyj1¹jyj<1º .dy/ is bounded, then (2.4.6) becomes Z 1 0 .u/ D i b u u Au C .e iuy 1/.dy/ 2 Rd n¹0º R with b 0 D b ¹jyj<1º y.dy/. Now we consider the following large class of random processes.
56
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Definition 2.29 (Lévy process). A random process .X t / t0 on a probability space .; F ; P / is called a Lévy process if .1/ X0 .!/ D 0 for almost every ! 2 .2/ the increments .X ti X ti1 /1in are independent random variables for any 0 D t0 < t1 < < tn d
.3/ X t Xs D X ts X0 for 0 s t .4/ X t is stochastically continuous, i.e., for all t 0 and " > 0 lim P .jXs X t j > "/ D 0:
s!t
Remark 2.3 (Càdlàg paths). It can be shown that every Lévy process has a version with paths t 7! X t which are right continuous and have left limits; functions, and thereby random processes, of this type are called càdlàg retaining the original French terminology “continue à droite, limitée à gauche.” The space of Rd -valued càdlàg functions on an interval I R is denoted by D.I I Rd /; it is a linear space with respect to pointwise addition and multiplication by real numbers. There is a close relationship between infinitely divisible distributions and Lévy processes. Theorem 2.40. .1/ Let .X t / t0 be a Lévy process. Then for every t the distribution t of X t is infinitely divisible. .2/ Conversely, for every infinitely divisible distribution on Rd with a triplet .b; A; /, where b 2 Rd , A is a d d non-negative definite symmetric matrix and a Lévy measure, there is a Lévy process .X t / t0 on .; F ; P / such that the distribution of X1 is and the characteristic triplet of X t is .t b; tA; t /, i.e., EP Œe iuX t D e t .u/ ;
(2.4.7)
where is given by (2.4.6). The vector b is called drift term, the matrix A diffusion matrix and the triplet .b; A; / the characteristics of the Lévy process .X t / t0 , while given by (2.4.6) is called Lévy symbol. Example 2.13. By Theorem 2.40 the processes in Example 2.12 are Lévy processes. The Lévy triplet of Brownian motion with drift (Itô process) is .b; A; 0/ and its Lévy symbol is .u/ D i b u 12 u Au. For a Poisson process with intensity > 0 the Lévy triplet is .0; 0; ı1 /, where ı1 is one dimensional Dirac measure, and the Lévy symbol is .u/ D .e iu 1/. The Cauchy process is a specific case of the class in the next example.
57
Section 2.4 Lévy processes
Example 2.14 (Stable processes). A Lévy process .X t / t0 is called a stable process d
if for any a > 0 there exist b > 0 and c 2 R such that Xat D bX t C ct , and a strictly stable process if c D 0. This definition originates from an extension of the scaling property of Brownian motion, see Proposition 2.7 (3). From the definition it can be seen that for a stable process there exist 0 < ˛ 2 and b t 2 Rd such that d X t D t 1=˛ X1 C b t ; for a strictly stable process one can take b t D 0. ˛ is called the index of the stable process. For a stable process either ˛ D 2 and its Lévy triplet is .b; A; 0/, i.e., it is a Gaussian process with mean b and covariance matrix A, or 0 < ˛ < 2 and its Lévy triplet is .b; 0; / with Lévy measure Z Z 1 dr .E/ D .d / 1E .r / 1C˛ ; (2.4.8) r S d 1 0 where S d 1 is the d 1-dimensional unit sphere centered in the origin. The above integral can be computed; for d D 1 the calculation gives c1 c2 .dy/ D 1.0;1/ C 1.1;0/ dy; c1 ; c2 0: (2.4.9) y 1C˛ .y/1C˛ d
A stable process with index 0 < ˛ 2 is rotation invariant if RX t D X t , for all R 2 O.Rd /, the orthogonal group. In this case the Lévy symbol of the process becomes .u/ D cjuj˛ , with some c > 0, and for 0 < ˛ < 2 the Lévy measure has uniform distribution on Sd 1 . In particular, the rotation invariant 1-stable process is the Cauchy process.
2.4.2 Markov property of Lévy processes In this section we show that Lévy processes are Markov processes possessing Feller transition kernels, and derive their generators. Let .X t / t0 be a Lévy process on .; F ; P /. Let t be the infinitely divisible distribution of X t and define p.s; t; x; A/ by p.s; t; x; A/ D ts .A x/
(2.4.10)
for t s 0, x 2 Rd and A 2 B.Rd /, where A x D ¹y xjy 2 Aº. Note that t .A x/ D P .X t C x 2 A/. By the definition of a Lévy process we have p.s; t; x; A/ D P .X t Xs 2 A x/ and p.s; t; x; A/ is a probability transition kernel. The Chapman–Kolmogorov identity results from the semigroup property ts ut D us ;
s < t < u:
(2.4.11)
Set p.s; t; x; A/ D p.t s; x; A/:
(2.4.12)
58
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Proposition 2.41. A Lévy process .X t / t0 is a stationary Markov process and its probability transition kernel is given by p.t; x; A/ under (2.4.12). Proof. By the independent increment property of the process its finite dimensional distributions can be written as P .X0 2 A0 ; : : : ; Xn 2 An / Z n n Y Y D 1Ai .xi / p.ti ti1 ; xi1 ; dxi /P 0 .dx0 /; R.nC1/d iD0
(2.4.13)
iD1
where P 0 .dx/ D ı.x/ is Dirac measure with mass at x D 0. Thus by Proposition 2.17, .X t / t0 is a Markov process with probability transition kernel p.t; x; A/. Theorem 2.42 (C0 -semigroup on C1 .Rd /). The probability transition kernel p.t; In particular, P t f .x/ D R x; A/ of a Lévy process is a Feller transition kernel. d Rd p.t; x; dy/f .y/ defines a C0 -semigroup on C1 .R /. Proof. The fact p.t; x; A/ 1 is trivial. We show that P t f 2 C1 .Rd / for f 2 C1 .Rd /. Let xn ! x as n ! 1. By the dominated convergence theorem we have Z lim p.t; 0; dy/f .xn C y/ D P t f .x/ lim P t f .xn / D n!1
Rd n!1
Z
and lim P t f .x/ D
jxj!1
lim p.t; 0; dy/f .x C y/ D 0:
Rd jxj!1
Thus P t f 2 C1 .Rd /. To conclude, we show that lim t!0 P t f D f for f 2 C1 .Rd / in the sup-norm. Since f is uniformly continuous, for any " > 0 there exists an r > 0 such that supx2Rd jf .x C y/R f .x/j < " for all jyj < r. Moreover, by stochastic continuity of the Lévy process jyj>r p.t; 0; dy/ D P .jX t j > r/ ! 0 R as t ! 0. Thus there exists t0 such that jyj>r p.t; 0; dy/ < " for 0 < t < t0 . Hence ˇ ˇZ ˇ ˇ .f .x C y/ f .x//p.t; 0; dy/ˇˇ sup jP t f .x/ f .x/j D sup ˇˇ Rd x2Rd x2Rd ˇ ˇZ Z ˇ ˇ D sup ˇˇ .f .x C y/ f .x//p.t; 0; dy/ C .f .x C y/ f .x//p.t; 0; dy/ˇˇ x2Rd
Z
"
jyj
jyjr
jyj>r
p.t; 0; dy/ C "kf k1
for 0 < t < t0 . Thereby lim t!0 P t f D f follows.
59
Section 2.4 Lévy processes
This amply illustrates the fact that the class of Feller transition kernels is far from empty. When the infinitely divisible distribution t of .X t / t0 satisfies t .A/ D t .A/;
(2.4.14)
P t can be extended to a C0 -semigroup on L2 .Rd /. Theorem 2.43 (C0 -semigroup on L2 .Rd /). Suppose that (2.4.14) holds. Then P t can be extended to a symmetric C0 -semigroup on L2 .Rd /. R Proof. Suppose that f; g 0 and Rd g.x/.P t f /.x/dx < 1. Since Z Z Z dxg.x/.P t f /.x/ D dxg.x/ f .x C y/p.t; 0; dy/ Rd Rd Rd Z Z dxg.x y/ f .x/p.t; 0; dy/; D Rd
Rd
(2.4.14) implies that Z Z Z dxg.x/.P t f /.x/ D dxg.x C y/ f .x/p.t; 0; dy/ Rd Rd Rd Z D dx.P t g/.x/f .x/: Rd
(2.4.15)
Let f 2 L2 .Rd / \ C1 .Rd /. Thus by Schwarz inequality and the symmetry of equality (2.4.15) we have Z Z Z j.P t f /.x/j2 dx P t .jf j2 /.x/dx D 1 P t .jf j2 /.x/dx d d d R R R Z D P t 1 jf j2 .x/dx: Rd
P t 1 D 1 implies that kP t f k kf k. Since L2 .Rd / \ C1 .Rd / is dense, the inequality kP t f k kf k can be extended to f 2 L2 .Rd /, and the theorem follows. By the Hille–Yoshida theorem (see Proposition 3.25) the semigroup ¹P t W t 0º associated with a Lévy process is of the form P t D e tL with a generator L on C1 .Rd /. The operator L is closed on C1 .Rd / endowed with the sup-norm. The semigroup ¹P t W t 0º can be also viewed as a pseudo-differential operator with symbol e t .k/ (see below). Denote by S .Rd / Schwartz space over Rd , i.e., the space of infinitely differentiable rapidly decreasing functions on Rd . Proposition 2.44 (Generator of a Lévy process). Let .X t / t0 be a Lévy process with characteristics .b; A; / and symbol . Let ¹P t W t 0º be the associated C0 semigroup on C1 .Rd / and L its generator, i.e., P t D e tL . Then the following hold:
60
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
.1/ For t 0, f 2 S .Rd / and x 2 Rd , Z .P t f /.x/ D .2/d=2
e ikx e t .k/ fO.k/d k:
Rd
.2/ For f 2 S .Rd / and x 2 Rd , Lf .x/ D .2/
d=2
(2.4.16)
Z e ikx .k/fO.k/: Rd
(2.4.17)
In particular 1 L D r Ar C b r C L ; 2 where
(2.4.18)
Z
L f .x/ D
Rd n¹0º
.f .x C y/ f .x/ y rf .x/1¹jyj<1º /.dy/:
Proof. (1) By the definition of P t we have
Z d=2 .P t f /.x/ D .2/ EP
e
ik.xCX t /
O f .k/d k :
Rd
Since EP Œe ikX t D e t .k/ , we have (1). To prove (2) consider the generator L given by ! Z t .k/ 1 e .Lf /.x/ D lim .2/d=2 e ikx fO.k/ d k: t!0 t Rd Since je ikx fO.k/. e t 1 /j .1 C jkj2 /fO 2 L2 .Rd /, the result follows by the dominated convergence theorem. t .k/
Example 2.15. The generators of some specific Lévy process are as follows: .1/ Brownian motion with drift: 1 L D r Ar C b r: 2
(2.4.19)
.2/ Poisson process with intensity : Lf .x/ D .f .x C 1/ f .x//:
(2.4.20)
L D ./˛=2 :
(2.4.21)
.3/ ˛-stable process:
61
Section 2.4 Lévy processes
2.4.3 Random measures and Lévy–Itô decomposition Lévy processes make a class large enough to contain random processes with jumps. One would like to know if there is a canonical way of separating the continuous part from the part with discontinuous paths. As we will see now, any Lévy process can be decomposed into a sum of four independent random processes accounting for these components. Before discussing the decomposition of Lévy processes we briefly review random measures. Let .S; S / be a measurable space and .; F ; P / a probability space. Furthermore, let M D .M.A//A2S be a collection of random variables M.A/./ W ! R indexed by A 2 S . Definition 2.30 (Random measure). M D .M.A//A2S is a random measure whenever .1/ M.;/ D 0 .2/ M.[n An / D
P1
nD1 M.An /
a.s., provided that An \ Am D ; for n 6D m
.3/ M.A/ and M.B/ are independent whenever A \ B D ;. Definition 2.31 (Poisson random measure). If in addition to (1)–(3) of Definition 2.30 each M.A/ has a Poisson distribution with intensity .A/, i.e., P .M.A/ D n/ D e .A/
.A/n ; nŠ
(2.4.22)
then M is called a Poisson random measure. From (2.4.22) it follows that .A/ D EP ŒM.A/ and it is a measure on S since M is a random measure. Conversely, given a -finite measure on S , there exists a probability space .; G ; P / and a Poisson random measure M such that .A/ D EP ŒM.A/ for A 2 S . Next we define the counting measure associated with a Lévy process .X t / t0 on .; F ; P /. Every càdlàg function is bounded on compact intervals and attains its extrema there, moreover, every such function is Borel measurable. Denote X t D lims"t Xs and define the jump at t by X t D X t X t :
(2.4.23)
A càdlàg path can only have jump discontinuities, and the set J D ¹t 2 RC jX t ¤ 0º
(2.4.24)
of time points where a jump occurs, is at most countable but does not have accumulation points for each path. Lévy processes can be classified by their sample path properties:
62
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
.1/ type I: A D 0 and .Rd n ¹0º/ < 1;
R .2/ type II: A D 0, .Rd n ¹0º/ D 1 and 0<jyj1 jyj.dy/ < 1; R .3/ type III: A ¤ 0 or 0<jyj1 jyj.dy/ D 1. A process of type III has a finite number of jumps in every bounded interval. If a process is of type I or II, then the paths are of bounded variation on every bounded interval, while if it is of type III, then paths are of unbounded variation on any interval. The counting measure N.t; / W B.Rd n ¹0º/ ! N [¹0º adds up the jumps of specific size, i.e., for 0 t and A 2 B.Rd n ¹0º/, N.t; A/ D j¹0 s t jXs 2 Aºj:
(2.4.25)
It is seen that N.t; /.!/ is a measure on B.Rd n ¹0º/ and EP ŒN.t; / is a Borel measure on B.Rd n ¹0º/, while ./ D EP ŒN.1; /
(2.4.26)
is called intensity measure. In Theorem 2.47 below we will see that coincides with the Lévy measure of a Lévy process. When the expectation of the number of small jumps at t D 1 of a Lévy process is zero, the Lévy symbol is simply Z 1 .u/ D i b u u Au C .e iuy 1/.dy/: 2 jyj1 Proposition 2.45. We have the following properties: N Then .N.t; A// t0 is a Poisson process with .1/ Let A 2 B.Rd n ¹0º/ and 0 … A. intensity .A/. .2/ N.t; A1 /; : : : ; N.t; An / for pairwise disjoint A1 ; : : : ; An 2 B.Rd n ¹0º/ are independent. To see the relationship between the Lévy measure associated with a Lévy process given by (2.4.26) we note that for f D Pn .X t / t0 and the intensity measures d n ¹0º/, A A and A \ A D ; for i 6D j , c 1 with A ; A 2 B.R j j i j j D1 j Aj EP Œe iu
R A
f .x/N.t;dx/
D
n Y
EP Œe iucj N.t;Aj /
j D1 P t jnD1 .e iucj 1/.Aj /
De
D et
R
A .e
iuf .x/ 1/.dx/
:
The following result is obtained by an approximation procedure. Lemma 2.46. Let A 2 B.Rd n ¹0º/ and f 2 L1 .A; /. Then EP Œe i
R A
f .x/N.t;dx/
D et
R
A .e
if .x/ 1/.dx/
:
(2.4.27)
63
Section 2.4 Lévy processes
By replacing f by sf Rwith s 2 R in (2.4.27) and R differentiating both sides above at sR D 0, we obtain EŒ A Rf .x/N.t; dx/ D t A f .x/.dx/, and the covariance EŒj A f .x/N.t; dx/j2 D t A jf .x/j2 .dx/. Thus for a general f 2 L1 .A; d/ the random process Z f .x/N.t; dx/ (2.4.28) A
t0
is well defined. In order to obtain the decomposition of a Lévy process .X t / t0 , we define the total sum of jumps over path X t . For A B.Rd n ¹0º/, Z tZ Z X zN.dsdz/ D zN.t; dz/ D Xu 1A .Xu / 0
A
A
0ut
is the sum of all the jumps taking values in set A up to time t . Since the paths of .X t / t0 are càdlàg, this is a finite sum R R of random variables. Note that the random processes . A zN.t; dz// t0 and . B zN.t; dz// t0 are independent as soon as A \ B D ;. The difference between the counting measure N.t; / and the intensity measure NQ .t; A/ D N.t; A/ t.A/
(2.4.29)
defines a compensated Poisson random measure. It can be checked that NQ .t; A/ is martingale. By Lemma 2.46 we can compute the characteristic functions of Z Z .1/ .2/ Zt D zN.t; dz/ and Z t D z NQ .t; dz/ jzj1
.1/
as EP Œe iuZt D e t
0<jzj<1
.2/
.1/ .u/
.2/ .u/
and EP Œe iuZt D e t Z .1/ .u/ D .e iuy 1/.dy/;
, respectively, where (2.4.30)
jj1
Z .2/ .u/ D
0<jj<1
.e iuy 1 u y1¹jj<1º /.dy/:
Then the characteristic function of the process p .1/ .2/ X t D bt C A B t C Z t C Z t ;
t 0;
(2.4.31)
(2.4.32)
p p T with b 2 Rd , a d d non-negative matrix A such that A D A A , is given by EP Œe iuX t D e t .u/ , where Z 1 .e iu 1 u 1¹jj<1º /.d /: (2.4.33) .u/ D i u b u Au C 2 Rd n¹0º
64
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Finally we can state the Lévy–Itô decomposition theorem saying that every Lévy process can be represented as the sum of four independent components of which a part has almost surely continuous paths and the other part can be expressed as a compensated sum of jumps. Theorem 2.47 (Lévy–Itô decomposition). Let .X t / t0 be a Lévy process with characteristics .b; A; / and N the counting measure on B.RC / B.Rd n ¹0º/ in (2.4.25). Write NQ .dsdz/ D N.dsdz/ ds.dz/:
(2.4.34)
Then .1/ N is a Poisson random measure with intensity measure ds.dz/. .2/ X t can be written as the sum of four independent Lévy processes, i.e., .1/
Xt D Xt
.2/
C Xt
.3/
C Xt
.4/
C Xt ;
(2.4.35)
where .1/
Xt
.3/
Xt
D bt; Z tZ D 0
jzj1
.2/
D
.4/
D
Xt zN.dsdz/; X t
p
A Bt ; Z tZ z NQ .dsdz/: 0
0<jzj<1
.1/
.2/
is a constant drift with Lévy symbol 1 .u/ D i u b, X t a Brownian motion p p T .3/ with 2 .u/ D .1=2/uAu, where A D A A , X t a compound Poisson process R .4/ with 3 .u/ D jyj1 .e iuy 1/.dy/, and X t a square integrable martingale with R 4 .u/ D 0<jyj<1 .e iuy 1 i u y/.dy/. Xt
2.4.4 Itô formula for semimartingales In view of the Lévy–Itô decomposition a Lévy process can be split into four integrals with respect to ds, dBs , N.dsdz/ and NQ .dsdz/. This justifies to consider a general stochastic integral of the form Z t Z t X t D X0 C a.s; !/ds C b.s; !/ dBs (2.4.36) 0
Z tZ C
0
Rd n¹0º
0
c.s; z; !/N.dsdz/ C
Z tZ d.s; z; !/NQ .dsdz/; 0
Rd n¹0º
where the integrands satisfy suitable conditions for the integrals to exist. Furthermore, we want to consider the process Y t D F .X t / for a function F and are interested whether Y t is again of the form as (2.4.36).
65
Section 2.4 Lévy processes
Let .; F ; P / be a probability space with filtration .F t / t0 . Fix a Brownian motion .B t / t0 and a Lévy process .X t / t0 on .; F ; P / assuming them to be independent. N.t; A/ is the Poisson random measure associated with the Lévy process, and NQ .dt dz/ is given by (2.4.34) with being its Lévy measure. Let P be the smallest -field on RC Rd such that all g having the properties below are measurable: .1/ for every t 0, the mapping .z; !/ 7! g.t; z; !/ is B.Rd n ¹0º/ G t =B.R/; .2/ for every .z; !/ 2 Rd , the mapping t 7! g.t; z; !/ is left continuous. P is called a predictable -field, while a P-measurable mapping h W RC Rd ! R is called .F t / t0 -predictable. Note that if g is .F t / t0 -predictable, then the process .g.t; x; / t / t0 is .F t / t0 -adapted for each x. Definition 2.32. Define P and P2 by the following conditions: R tC R .1/ f 2 P if f is P-predictable and 0 Rd n¹0º jf .s; z; !/jN.dsdz/ < 1 a.s., t > 0, Rt R .2/ f 2 P2 if f is P-predictable and EP Œ 0 Rd n¹0º jf .s; z; !/j2 ds.dz/ < 1, t > 0. Next we define semimartingales which are extensions of the Itô processes seen before. Definition 2.33 (Semimartingale). Let .; F ; P / be a probability space with a filtration .F t / t0 . Assume that for each i D 1; : : : ; n and D 1; : : : ; d , .1/ fi 2 M2 .0; t / for all t 0, i.e., .fi .t; !// t0 is .F t / t0 -adapted and we Rt have P . 0 jfi .s; !/j2 ds < 1/ D 1, for all t 0; .2/ .g i .t; !// t0 is .F t / t0 -adapted and g i .t; !/ 2 L1loc .RI dt / .3/ hi1 2 P and hi2 2 P2 . The random process .X ti / t0 , i D 1; : : : ; n, on .; F ; P / defined by Z X ti D X0i C Z C
0
t
0 tC Z
Z f i .s; !/ dBs C
Rd n¹0º
t
g i .s; !/ds
0
hi1 .s; z; !/N.dsdz/
Z C
(2.4.37) tC Z
0
Rd n¹0º
hi2 .s; z; !/NQ .dsdz/
is called a semimartingale. Proposition 2.48 (Itô formula for semimartingales). Let F 2 C 2 .Rd / and .X t / t0 D j .X ti / t0;1in be a semimartingale given by (2.4.37). Suppose hi1 h2 0, i; j D
66
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
1; : : : ; n: Then .F .X t // t0 is also a semimartingale and the following formula holds: n Z X
F .X t / D F .X0 / C
C
iD1 0
Z t X n 0
Z C Z C
Fi .Xs /f i dBs
Fi .Xs /g i C
n Z 1 X t Fij .Xs /f i f j ds 2 0 i;j D1
iD1
tC Z 0
Rd n¹0º
.F .Xs C h1 / F .Xs //N.dsdz/
tC Z
Rd n¹0º
0
Z tZ C
t
Rd n¹0º
0
.F .Xs C h2 / F .Xs //NQ .dsdz/
n X hi2 Fi .Xs / ds.dz/; F .Xs C h2 / F .Xs / iD1
where Fi D @xi F and Fij D @xi @xj F . Example 2.16. An application of the Itô formula above is the variation formula of a Lévy process .X t / t0 such as F .X t / F .X0 /. Consider the Lévy process .X t / t0 given by the Lévy–Itô decomposition Z tZ X t D bt C A B t C
0
jzj1
Z tZ zN.dsdz/ C
z NQ .dsdz/: 0
jzj<1
Since 1¹jzj1º 1¹0<jzj<1º D 0, for F 2 C 2 .Rn /, Y t D F .X t / is also a semimartingale of the form Y t D Y0 C
C
0
0
Z C
D1 iD1 0
Z t X n Z
C
d X n Z X
0
iD1
0
Fi .Xs /Ai dBs
n Z 1 X bi Fi .Xs / C Fij .Xs /.AAT /ij ds 2 i;j D1
tC Z
Rd n¹0º
.F .Xs C z1¹jzj1º / F .Xs //N.dsdz/
tC Z
Z tZ C
t
Rd n¹0º
Rd n¹0º
.F .Xs C z1¹jzj<1º / F .Xs //NQ .dsdz/
n X zi 1¹jzj<1º Fi .Xs / ds.dz/: F .Xs C z1¹jzj<1º / F .Xs / iD1
67
Section 2.4 Lévy processes
Finally, we show the product formula for semimartingales. Write (2.4.37) as Z Z hi1 dN t C hi2 d NQ t dX ti D g i .t /dt C f i .t / dB t C Rd n¹0º
Rd n¹0º
in differential notation. Take d D 1 and let .Z t / t0 and .Y t / t0 be semimartingales given by Z Z .1/ .1/ .1/ .1/ dZ t D u t dt C v t dB t C f t dN t C g t d NQ t ; .2/
Z
.2/
d Y t D u t dt C v t
dB t C
Rd n¹0º
Rd n¹0º
.2/
Rd n¹0º
ft
Z dN t C
.2/
Rd n¹0º
g t d NQ t :
Then by Proposition 2.48 we have the following product formula. .1/ .1/ gt
Corollary 2.49 (Product formula). Let f t .2/ .1/ and f t g t D 0. Then Z .2/ .2/ d.Z t Y t / D Z t u t dt C Z t v t dB t C
Rd n¹0º
.1/ C Y t u t dt .1/
C vt
.1/ C Yt vt
.2/
v t dt C
.2/ Z t f t dN t
Z dB t C
Z
.1/
.f t
Rd n¹0º
Rd n¹0º .2/
ft
.1/ .2/ gt
D 0, f t
.1/ Y t f t dN t
.2/ .2/ gt
D 0, f t
Z C
Rd n¹0º
.2/ Z t g t d NQ t
Z C
D0
Rd n¹0º
.1/ Y t g t d NQ t
.1/ .2/
C g t g t /dN t :
This formula is written as d.Z t Y t / D dZ t Y t C Z t d Y t C dZ t d Y t in concise notation.
2.4.5 Subordinators We conclude this section by discussing a special class of Lévy processes. Definition 2.34 (Subordinator). A one-dimensional Lévy process .T t / t0 is called a subordinator whenever s t implies Ts T t almost surely. d
Since T tCs Ts D T t , for all s; t 0, the definition readily implies that T t 0 almost surely, for every t > 0. A subordinator can be regarded as a random time since it is non-decreasing and non-negative. Theorem 2.50 (Characterization of subordinators). The Lévy symbol of a subordinator is Z 1 .u/ D i bu C .e iuy 1/.dy/; (2.4.38) 0
68
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
where b 0 and the Lévy measure satisfies that Z ..1; 0// D 0 and .y ^ 1/.dy/ < 1: Conversely, for every .u/ given by (2.4.38), there exists a subordinator .T t / t0 whose Lévy symbol is of the form .u/. By Theorem 2.50 it is seen that the map u 7! EP Œe iuT t D e t .u/ can be analytically continued into the region ¹i u 2 C j u > 0º. This implies that the Laplace transform of T t is well-defined and given by EP Œe uT t D e t where
Z .u/ D bu C
1 0
.u/
;
.1 e uy /.dy/
(2.4.39)
(2.4.40)
for every u > 0. Example 2.17 (˛=2-stable subordinator). Let b D 0, 0 < ˛ < 2 and using (2.4.9) take .dx/ D
1.0;1/ .x/ ˛ dx; 2.1 ˛=2/ x 1C˛=2
(2.4.41)
where denotes the Gamma function. This is called ˛=2-stable subordinator and EP Œe uT t D e tu
˛=2
holds. Example 2.18 (Inverse Gaussian subordinator). Let .; F ; P / be a probability space, m 0, ı > 0 be given constants, and define the first hitting time of onedimensional standard Brownian motion by T t .m; ı/ D inf¹s > 0jBs C ms D ıt º:
(2.4.42)
.T t .m; ı// t0 is called inverse Gaussian subordinator for m > 0. We have p EP Œe uT t .m;ı/ D exp.t ı. 2u C m2 m//: (2.4.43) Moreover, the distribution of T t .m; ı/ is given by ıt ımt 1 1 2 21 2 .s/ D p e exp : t ı Cm s 2 s s 3=2 2
69
Section 2.4 Lévy processes 1
To see this, recall that by Corollary 2.20, the random process .e ˛B t 2 ˛ t / t0 is a 1 2 martingale. In addition, .e ˛BT t ^n 2 ˛ T t ^n / t0 is also a martingale. Thus 1
EP Œe ˛BT t ^n 2 ˛
2T
t ^n
2
D EP Œe ˛B0 D 1:
Let An D ¹T t nº and 1
EP Œe ˛BT t ^n 2 ˛
2T
t ^n
1
D EP Œe ˛BT t ^n 2 ˛
2T
t ^n
1
1An C EP Œe ˛BT t ^n 2 ˛
2T
t ^n
1Acn :
It is easy to see that 1
EP Œe ˛BT t ^n 2 ˛
2T
t ^n
1
1Acn e 2 ˛ n EP Œ1Acn e ˛Bn 2
1
and since Bn < ıt mn on Acn , it follows that limn!1 EP Œe ˛BT t ^n 2 ˛ 0. Furthermore, 1
lim EP Œe ˛BT t ^n 2 ˛
n!1
2T
t ^n
1
1An D EP Œe ˛.ıtmT t / e 2 ˛ 1
This implies that 1 D EP Œe ˛.ıtmT t / e 2 ˛
2T
t
2T
t
2T
t ^n
1Acn D
:
, and hence
1
e ˛ıt D EP Œe 2 ˛.˛C2m/T t follows. Setting ˛ D
p 2u C m2 m proves the claim.
2.4.6 Bernstein functions Subordinators and Bernstein functions have a deep connection with each other. We will make use of this in the path integral representations below. Definition 2.35 (Bernstein function). Let f 2 C 1 ..0; 1// with f 0. The funcn tion f is called a Bernstein function whenever .1/n ddxfn .x/ 0, for all n 2 N. We denote the set of Bernstein functions by B. It follows from the definition that Bernstein functions are positive, increasing and concave. Define a subset of B by B0 D ¹‰ 2 Bj lim ‰.u/ D 0º: u!0C
(2.4.44)
Examples of functions in B0 include ‰.u/ D cu˛=2 with c > 0 and 0 < ˛ 2, and 0. ‰.u/ D 1 e au with a P It can be seen that sums j .1 e aj u / of Bernstein functions are also Bernstein R1 functions, and u˛ can be expressed as u˛ D 0 .1e yu /.dy/ by using the measure in (2.4.41). The right-hand side is derived from the analytic continuation of the Lévy symbol of subordinator (2.4.38). We will see next that B0 can be characterized by subordinators. We define the following subset of Lévy measures.
70
Chapter 2 Probabilistic preliminaries
Definition 2.36 (Lévy measures for Bernstein functions). R 1 Let L be the set of Borel measures on R n ¹0º such that ..1; 0// D 0 and 0 .y ^ 1/ .dy/ < 1. R1 Note that 2 L satisfies 0 .y 2 ^ 1/ .dy/ < 1. The important fact connecting L and B0 is given by the next proposition. Proposition 2.51 (Characterization of Bernstein functions). For every ‰ 2 B0 there exists .b; / 2 RC L such that Z ‰.u/ D bu C .1 e uy / .dy/: (2.4.45) .0;1/
Conversely, the right-hand side of (2.4.45) is in B0 for every .b; / 2 RC L . For a given ‰ 2 B0 the constant b is uniquely determined by b D lim ‰.u/=u: u!1
Note that f D d ‰=du is a completely monotone function. For a completely monotone functionR g it is well known that there exists a unique measure on Œ0; 1/ such 1 that g.u/ D 0 e us d.s/, for u > 0. Since Z 1 d ‰=du D b C e uy .dy/; 0
the measure 2 L for the Bernstein function ‰ is also uniquely determined. Proposition 2.52. The map B0 ! .RC ; L /, ‰ 7! .b; /, is a bijection. Denote by S the set of subordinators. From the one-to-one correspondence between B0 and .RC ; L / we have also the one-to-one correspondence between S and B0 . Proposition 2.53. Let ‰ 2 B0 . Then there exists a unique .T t / t0 2 S such that EP Œe uT t D e t‰.u/ :
(2.4.46)
Conversely, let .T t / t0 2 S . Then there exists ‰ 2 B0 such that (2.4.46) holds. Proof. Let ‰ 2 B0 be given. Then there exists .b; / 2 RC L such that (2.4.45) holds. This means that there exists a subordinator .T t / t0 with characteristic .b; 0; /. Moreover, (2.4.46) by analytic continuation of EP Œe iuT t D e t .u/ with R 1 follows .u/ D i bu C 0 .e iuy 1/ .dy/. Conversely, let .T t / t0 2 S be given. By .b; / 2 RC L associated with .T t / t0 we define the Bernstein function by (2.4.45), and the proposition follows.
Chapter 3
Feynman–Kac formulae
3.1
Schrödinger semigroups
3.1.1 Schrödinger equation and path integral solutions As we have explained in Chapter 1 a basic motivation of the interest in Feynman–Kac formulae is that of analyzing the solutions of the Schrödinger equation 1 i @ t ' D ' C V ' 2
(3.1.1)
or its imaginary-time counterpart, heat equation with spatially non-homogeneous dissipation 1 @ t ' D ' C V ': 2
(3.1.2)
In fact, the scope of Feynman–Kac formulae in the context of partial differential equations goes far beyond these two cases, however, in this book we have no space to discuss the PDE aspect separately. Let f W R Rd ! R be a solution of the heat equation, i.e. 1 @ t f .t; x/ D f .t; x/; 2
f .0; x/ D g.x/:
Recall the formula known from the theory of partial differential equations: Z f .t; x/ D … t .x y/g.y/ dy: Rd
(3.1.3)
(3.1.4)
A comparison with Z x
E Œg.B t / D
Rd
… t .x y/g.y/ dy;
(3.1.5)
shows that, as we have said above, the solution of (3.1.3) can be obtained by running a Brownian motion, and f .t; x/ D Ex Œg.B t /
(3.1.6)
72
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
is obtained. Using operator semigroup notation (3.1.3) implies f D e .t=2/ g. In what follows we ask whether a similar representation is possible when 12 is replaced by 12 C V , with suitable V . Let now f W R Rd ! R be a solution of 1 @ t f .t; x/ D x f .t; x/ V .x/f .t; x/: 2
(3.1.7) 1
In semigroup notation, this problem translates then to studying f D e t. 2 CV / g. In what follows, instead of equations in our considerations the basic input will be linear operators and one-parameter semigroups generated by them as above, although we will remember the deep relations with partial differential equations.
3.1.2 Linear operators and their spectra In what follows we will be interested in various spectral properties of sums of selfadjoint operators. In the present section we only consider Schrödinger operators 1 CV 2
(3.1.8)
defined on a suitable space as the operator sum of the Laplacian and the multiplication operator V viewed in a specific sense as a perturbation of the Laplacian. As we progress to take magnetic fields and spin into account, further operator terms will appear, and when we discuss relativistic quantum mechanics, the Laplacian will be replaced by its square root. In Part II of the book we then turn to quantum field theory where moreover different types of operators will be added to Schrödinger operators. We start by briefly reviewing key concepts and facts of general linear operator theory used throughout in this book, and next focus on first Laplacians and then on their perturbations. Let K be a Hilbert space over the complex field C with inner product .; / and norm k k. When inner products or norms of several distinct Hilbert spaces are compared, we indicate the specific space in the subscript whenever necessary; for Lp spaces we use the standard notation k kp . Let H be also a Hilbert space. The domain of a linear operator A W K ! H will be denoted by D.A/, its range by Ran.A/ and its kernel by Ker.A/. Recall that for two linear operators A and B we have A D B if and only if D.A/ D D.B/ and A' D B' for all ' 2 D.A/, and A B if and only if D.A/ D.B/ and A' D B' for all ' 2 D.A/; in the latter case B is said to be an extension of A, or from the opposite point of view, A is the restriction of B to D.A/. An operator A on K is densely defined if D.A/ is a dense subset of K. Definition 3.1 (Bounded/unbounded operators). Let A W K ! H be a linear operator. Whenever there exists c 0 such that kA'kH ck'kK for all ' 2 D.A/, the operator A is called bounded, otherwise it is called unbounded.
73
Section 3.1 Schrödinger semigroups
A linear operator A is called strongly continuous at ' 2 D.A/ when there is a sequence .'n /n2N D.A/ such that 'n ! ' in strong convergence sense implies A'n ! A' also in strong convergence sense. If A is continuous for all ' 2 D.A/, A is called strongly continuous. A linear operator is bounded if and only if it is strongly continuous. The norm of a bounded operator A is defined as kAk D kAkK;H D
kA'kH : '2D.A/;'6D0 k'kK sup
(3.1.9)
A bounded operator is a contraction if kAk 1. When K is finite dimensional, any linear operator on it is bounded. Next we give the notions of bounded operator topology we will use in what follows. Definition 3.2 (Topologies of bounded operators). Let .An /n2N W K ! H be a sequence of bounded operators such that D.An / D D, n 2 N, and A another bounded operator. Then .An /n2N is (1) weakly convergent to A, denoted A D w limn!1 An , if D.A/ D D and limn!1 . ; An ' A'/ D 0, for all ' 2 D and for all 2 H (2) strongly convergent to A, denoted A D s-limn!1 An , if D.A/ D D and limn!1 kAn ' A'kH D 0, for all ' 2 D (3) uniformly convergent to A if D.A/ D D and limn!1 kAn Ak D 0. If A is a densely defined bounded operator with kA'kH ck'kK , then it can be uniquely extended to an operator B such that A B, D.B/ D K and kB'kH ck'kK hold. In what follows we assume that the domain of a bounded operator is the whole space. Recall that the graph of a linear operator A W K ! H is the subset G.A/ D ¹.'; A'/j ' 2 D.A/º K ˚ H :
(3.1.10)
Definition 3.3 (Closed/closable operator). Let A W K ! H be a linear operator. (1) A is a closed operator if G.A/ is closed in K ˚ H , in other words, if the sequence .'n /n2N satisfies that A'n ! and 'n ! ' as n ! 1, then ' 2 D.A/ and moreover D A' holds. (2) A is a closable operator if there exists a closed operator B W K ! H such that A B. N is the smallest closed extension of A, i.e., AN is (3) The closure of A, denoted by A, a closed extension of A and if B is another closed extension, then AN B. (4) A subspace D K is a core of A if AdD D A, in other words, if for every ' 2 D.A/ there is a sequence .'/n2N D such that ' ! ' and A'n ! A' strongly as n ! 1.
74
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
The bounded operators are closed. The next proposition ensures the existence of the closure of closable operators. N Proposition 3.1. Let A be closable. Then the closure of A exists and G.A/ D G.A/ holds. A linear operator A is injective if and only if A' D 0 implies ' D 0. In this case the inverse A1 of A is defined by D.A1 / D Ran.A/;
A1 ' D
(3.1.11)
for A D '. From this definition it follows that for ' 2 Ran.A/ and 2 D.A/, AA1 ' D ';
A1 A D :
(3.1.12)
Definition 3.4 (Invertibility). A linear operator A is called invertible if it is injective and has a bounded inverse on Ran A. Note that invertibility of an operator and the existence of an inverse are properties that do not necessarily coincide. Definition 3.5 (Addition and multiplication of operators). The sum A C B of two linear operators A and B is defined by D.A C B/ D D.A/ \ D.B/;
.A C B/' D A' C B':
(3.1.13)
The product AB is defined by D.AB/ D ¹' 2 D.B/jB' 2 D.A/º;
.AB/' D A.B'/:
(3.1.14)
Note that in general it may happen that D.A/ \ D.B/ is not a dense subset in D.A/ or D.B/. Let B.K; H / denote the set of bounded operators from K to H with the whole space K as their domain. For A; B 2 B.K; H /, A C B 2 B.K; H / and kA C Bk kAk C kBk hold, and for B 2 B.K; H / and A 2 B.H ; L/, AB 2 B.K; L/ and kABk kAkkBk hold. In the following a central issue will be the spectral properties of some linear operators. Definition 3.6 (Resolvent and spectrum). Let A W K ! H be closed. The resolvent set of A is .A/ D ¹ 2 Cj Ran. A/ D H ; A is injective and . A/1 is boundedº (3.1.15) and its spectrum is defined as Spec A D C n .A/:
(3.1.16)
For 2 .A/ the bounded operator RA . / D . A/1 is the resolvent of A.
75
Section 3.1 Schrödinger semigroups
In the definition of the resolvent A must be assumed to be closed. The reason is as follows. If 2 .A/, then RA . / D . A/1 is bounded and hence closed. Let j W K ˚ H ! H ˚ K be defined by j.'; / D .; '/. This is an isomorphism between K ˚ H and H ˚ K, and G.B 1 / D jG.B/ follows. Let B be closed. Then G.B/ is a closed set and hence G.B 1 / is also closed. We conclude that B 1 is closed. Thus we proved that in general if B is closed and injective, then B 1 is also closed. In particular A is closed since so is . A/1 , from which follows that A must be closed. Furthermore, it can be also seen that if A is closable and injective, then . A/1 is also closable and . A/1 D . A/1 follows. For a closable operator A W K ! H its resolvent set is defined by .A/ D ¹ 2 C j Ran. A/ is dense; A is injective; . A/1 is boundedº: For a closed operator A the conditions .1/ Ran. A/ is dense, .2/ A is injective and .3/ . A/1 is bounded automatically imply that Ran. A/ D H . The spectrum of A can be decomposed into three parts: (1) The point spectrum Specp .A/ of A consists of the elements 2 Spec.A/ such that A is not injective; the elements of the point spectrum are called eigenvalues, i.e., for every such there exists ' 2 D.A/ n ¹0º, such that A' D ' , and ' is an eigenvector (or eigenfunction when the vector space is a set of functions), while the number dim Ker. A/ is the multiplicity of eigenvalue . (2) The continuous spectrum Specc .A/ of A consists of all 2 Spec A for which A has an inverse with a dense domain but it is not a bounded operator. (3) The residual spectrum Specr .A/ of A is given by 2 Spec.A/ such that A has an inverse, i.e., injective, but its domain is not dense. Thus the complex field C is decomposed into the disjoint sets C D .A/ [ Specp .A/ [ Specc .A/ [ Specr .A/:
(3.1.17)
The resolvent set of a bounded operator A contains ¹z 2 Cjjzj > kAkº since . A/1 D
1 1 X n n A nD0
holds in the uniform topology and the right-hand side of the equality is bounded for > kAk. Thus the spectrum of bounded operators is a closed non-empty subset of ¹z 2 Cjjzj kAkº, however, in the case of unbounded operators both the spectrum and the resolvent set may be empty. The operators we will consider below are self-adjoint, therefore we do not need to address spectral theory in its full generality.
76
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Definition 3.7 (Adjoint operator). Let A W K ! H be a densely defined linear operator. The adjoint operator A of A is a linear operator from H to K defined by D.A / D ¹' 2 H j 9 and A ' D
2 H such that .'; A/ D . ; /; 8 2 D.A/º
.
Since A is densely defined, A is well defined. The adjoint operator A is always closed, and whenever A is closed, then moreover A D .A / . If A is closable, then AN D .A / holds. It can be also checked that if D.A / is dense, then A is closable. If A; B 2 B.K; K/, then A ; B 2 B.K; K/ and the properties kA k D kAk, N , and .AB/ D B A hold. .A / D A, .aA C bB/ D aA N C bB Definition 3.8 (Symmetric operator and self-adjoint operator). Let A W K ! K be a densely defined linear operator. A is said to be a symmetric operator if A A , a self-adjoint operator if A D A, and an essentially self-adjoint operator if A is self-adjoint. Whenever D.A / is dense, A is closable, moreover, .A / D AN for a closable operator. If A is symmetric, D.A / is dense by the definition. Hence A is closable and AN is a closed symmetric operator. In general, infinitely many self-adjoint extensions of a given symmetric operator exist. Note that if A B, then B A . Let A be symmetric and B a self-adjoint extension of A. Then A B D B A , thus B D A dD with some domain D. Next let A be essentially self-adjoint and B a self-adjoint extension of A. Since A B, it follows that .A / B. Thus B D B ..A / / D .A / and N We summarize this in the proposition below. therefore B D .A / D A. Proposition 3.2 (Self-adjoint extensions). .1/ Let A be symmetric and B a selfadjoint extension of A. Then B is a restriction of A . .2/ Let A be essentially self-adjoint. Then AN is the only self-adjoint extension of A, i.e. if B is self-adjoint and A B, then AN D B. .3/ Let A be a symmetric operator and suppose it has only one self-adjoint extension. Then A is essentially self-adjoint. A bounded operator A is symmetric if and only if it is self-adjoint. However, for an unbounded operator these two properties are in general different, indeed, a symmetric operator need not be closed and a closed symmetric operator need not be self-adjoint. Equivalent conditions to self-adjointness and essential self-adjointness of a symmetric operator are as follows. Proposition 3.3 (Equivalent conditions to self-adjointness). Let A be a symmetric operator in K. Then properties .1/–.4/ below are equivalent.
Section 3.1 Schrödinger semigroups
.1/ .2/ .3/ .4/
77
A is self-adjoint. A is closed and Ker.A ˙ i / D ¹0º. Ran.A ˙ i / D K. A is closed and Ran.A ˙ i / D K.
Proposition 3.4 (Equivalent conditions to essential self-adjointness). Let A be a symmetric operator in K. Then properties .1/–.3/ below are equivalent. .1/ A is essentially self-adjoint. .2/ Ker.A ˙ i / D ¹0º. .3/ Ran.A ˙ i / D K. Self-adjointness removes some of the complications of the structure of the spectrum. The following facts are fundamental on the spectrum and resolvent of selfadjoint operators. Proposition 3.5 (Spectral properties of self-adjoint operators). Let A be a self-adjoint operator. Then .1/ Spec.A/ R. .2/ The residual spectrum Specr .A/ is empty. .3/ The eigenvectors for distinct eigenvalues are orthogonal. .4/ For 2 Spec.A/ there exists .'n /n2N D.A/ such that k'n k D 1 and limn!1 k. A/'n k D 0. .5/ If there exists c > 0 such that k. A/'k ck'k for all ' 2 D.A/, then 2 .A/ and ¹z 2 Cj jz j < cº .A/. .6/ kRA . /k 1=j= j holds. A self-adjoint operator A with the property that .'; A'/ 0, for all ' 2 D.A/, is called a positive operator and denoted by A 0. Positivity of A is equivalent with Spec.A/ Œ0; 1/. Definition 3.9 (Unitary operator). A bounded operator U W K ! H is called a unitary operator if it is an isometry, i.e., kU'kH D k'kK for all ' 2 K, and Ran.U / D H . The isometry condition can be equivalently formulated as U U D 1. Unitary operators can be used to define a conjugate operator to any given operator by keeping its spectrum unchanged. More precisely, if A is a closed operator and U is a unitary operator, then UAU 1 is well defined on UD.A/ and closed, moreover, Spec.UAU 1 / D Spec.A/. For instance, Fourier transform is a unitary operator on L2 .Rd / and this equality can be used to compute the spectrum of the Laplacian, see Example 3.2 below. Furthermore, if A is self-adjoint, then UAU 1 also is self-adjoint on UD.A/.
78
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Definition 3.10. Let .An /n2N be a sequence of unbounded operators. convergence if .1/ An ! A is said to converge in the sense of strong resolvent T RAn . / strongly converges to RA . /, for all 2 .A/ \ n .An /. .2/ An ! A is said to converge in the sense of uniform resolvent T convergence if RAn . / uniformly converges to RA . /, for all 2 .A/ \ n .An /. Convergence in strong and uniform resolvent sense are the proper generalizations to unbounded operators of strong and uniform convergence of bounded operators, respectively.
3.1.3 Spectral resolution The spectral theorem establishes a fundamental relationship between a linear operator and a measure on its spectrum. Let K be a Hilbert space and the set of projections on K be denoted by P .K /. Consider the map B.R/ 3 B 7! E.B/ 2 P .K / with the properties .1/ E.;/ D 0 and E.R/ D 1 S .2/ if B D n2N Bn with Bm \ Bn D ;, m ¤ n, then E.B/ D s-lim
n!1
n X
E.Bk /
kD1
.3/ E.B1 \ B2 / D E.B1 /E.B2 /. A family of projections indexed by B.R/ satisfying properties .1/–.3/ above is called a projection-valued measure. For ' 2 K the Borel measure .'; E.B/'/ on R can be defined, and by the polarization identity it gives rise to the complex measure .'; E.B/ /, '; 2 K through .'; E.B/ / D
4 1X n i ..' C i n /; E.B/.' C i n //: 4
(3.1.18)
nD1
The spectral theorem says that there is a one-to-one correspondence between selfadjoint operators and projection-valued measures. For a self-adjoint operator A and the corresponding EA . / we define f .A/ for a Borel measurable function f by Z .'; f .A/ /K D f . /d.EA . /'; /; (3.1.19) R
with domain
ˇZ ³ ˇ 2 2 ˇ D.f .A// D ' 2 K ˇ jf . /j d kEA . /'k < 1 : ²
R
79
Section 3.1 Schrödinger semigroups
Note that the support of the measure EA coincides with Spec.A/. Equality (3.1.19) is R formally written as f .A/ D R f . /dEA . / and is called the spectral resolution of f .A/. The following algebraic relations hold. Proposition 3.6. Let A be a self-adjoint operator. Then for Borel measurable functions f and g, .1/ D.f .A/ C g.A// D D..f C g/.A// \ D.g.A// D D..f C g/.A// \ D.f .A// and f .A/ C g.A/ .f C g/.A/ .2/ D.f .A/g.A// D D..fg/.A// \ D.g.A// and f .A/g.A/ .fg/.A/. We will use the terminology of also another classification of the spectrum. Definition 3.11 (Discrete spectrum and essential spectrum). Let A be self-adjoint. If 2 Spec.A/ is such that there is " > 0 for which dim Ran EA . "; C"/ < 1, then is said to be an element of the discrete spectrum, denoted Specd .A/. If 2 Spec.A/ is such that dim Ran EA . "; C "/ D 1 for all " > 0, then is in the essential spectrum, denoted Specess .A/. Note that the discrete and the essential spectra form a partition of the spectrum. Moreover, Specess .A/ is a closed set, while Specd .A/ need not be so. Furthermore, the following facts hold. Proposition 3.7. 2 Specd .A/ if and only if both of the following properties hold: .1/ is an isolated point of Spec.A/, i.e., there exists " > 0 such that Spec.A/ \ . "; C "/ D ¹ º .2/ is an eigenvalue of finite multiplicity, i.e., dim¹' 2 KjA' D 'º < 1. An eigenvalue of arbitrary multiplicity which is not an isolated point in the spectrum is called an embedded eigenvalue. Example 3.1 (Multiplication operator). Let V be a Lebesgue measurable real function and define a multiplication operator by .V '/.x/ D V .x/'.x/ and domain D.V / D ¹' 2 L2 .Rd /j Vf 2 L2 .Rd /º. Note that it is densely defined. Since V is real-valued, it is symmetric, and in fact it is a self-adjoint operator. Example 3.2 (Laplace operator). Recall that the weak partial derivative @j ' of ' 2 L1loc .Rd / is a function h 2 L1loc .Rd / such that Z
Z Rd
h.x/f .x/dx D
Rd
'.x/@j f .x/dx;
f 2 C01 .Rd /;
80
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
and is the j th component of the gradient operator in weak sense. This notion reduces to the partial derivative (gradient) known from elementary calculus whenever ' 2 C 1 .Rd /. The Laplacian in L2 .Rd / is the symmetric operator defined by W ' 7!
d X
@j2 '
(3.1.20)
j D1
for ' 2 C01 .Rd /. It is seen that T D dC 1 .Rd / is essentially self-adjoint. We 0
denote the closure of T by the same symbol, i.e., D T . The domain of is the Sobolev space D..1=2// D H 2 .Rd / D ¹f 2 L2 .Rd /jjkj2 fO 2 L2 .Rd /º; where fO and fL denote the Fourier transform and inverse Fourier transform of f , respectively. Moreover, f .k/ D jkj2 fO.k/ holds for every f 2 H 2 .Rd /. Since the range of the multiplication operator jkj2 is the positive semi-axis, we have that has continuous spectrum and Spec./ D Specess ./ D Œ0; 1/, in particular, is a positive operator.
1
Example 3.3 (Fractional Laplacian). The operator with domain H ˛ .Rd / D ¹f 2 ˇ L2 .Rd /ˇjkj˛ fO 2 L2 .Rd /º, 0 < ˛ < 2, defined by ./˛=2 f .k/ D jkj˛ fO.k/, is called fractional Laplacian with exponent ˛=2. It is essentially self-adjoint on C01 .Rd /, and its spectrum is Spec../˛=2 / D Specess ../˛=2 / D Œ0; 1/. This is a case of a pseudo-differential operator. A related operator is the relativistic fractional Laplacian . C m2=˛ /˛=2 m, with m > 0.
4
3.1.4 Compact operators Finally we discuss compact operators. Definition 3.12 (Compact operator). A bounded operator A W K ! H is a compact operator whenever A takes bounded sets in K into pre-compact sets in H . Equivalently, A is compact if and only if for every bounded sequence .'n /n2N , .A'n /n2N has a subsequence convergent in H . R Example 3.4. Let k 2 L2 .Rd Rd /. Then A W f 7! Rd k.x; y/f .y/dy is a compact operator on L2 .Rd /. 1=2 .y/ for d 3 with 0 V 2 Example 3.5. Let k.x; y/ D V 1=2 .x/jx yj2d RV d=2 d L .R /. Then the integral operator A W f 7! k.x; y/f .y/dy is compact. In the case of d D 3 this is proven by the Hardy–Littlewood–Sobolev inequality ˇZ Z ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ C kf kp kgkq f .x/jx yj g.y/dxdy (3.1.21) ˇ ˇ Rd
Rd
Section 3.1 Schrödinger semigroups
for < d and
1 p
C
d
C
1 q
81
D 2, with some constant C . See Lemma 3.47.
Some important properties of compact operators are summarized below. Proposition 3.8. Let A be a compact operator. .1/ Spec.A/ n ¹0º Specd .A/. .2/ Spec.A/ is a finite set or a countable set without accumulation points. .3/ Let C.K/ be the set of compact operators from K to itself. Then C.K/ is an ideal of B.K; K/, i.e., AB; BA 2 C.K/ for A 2 C.K/ and B 2 B.K; K/. Furthermore, K.K/ D B.K; K/=C.K/ is simple, i.e., K.K/ has no nontrivial ideal. .4/ C.K/ is closed in the uniform operator topology. The space K.K/ is called Calkin algebra. It is useful to have criteria guaranteeing that the spectrum of a self-adjoint operator is purely discrete. Proposition 3.9. Let A be a self-adjoint operator and bounded from below. Then properties .1/–.4/ below are equivalent: .1/ . A/1 is a compact operator for some 2 .A/. .2/ . A/1 is a compact operator for all 2 .A/. .3/ The set ¹' 2 D.A/jk'k < 1; kA'k bº is compact for all b. .4/ The set ¹' 2 D.jAj1=2 /jk'k < 1; kjAj1=2 'k bº is compact for all b. We will consider perturbations of given operators, and address the question of invariance of the essential spectrum of a self-adjoint operator under perturbations. Definition 3.13 (Relative compactness). Let A be self-adjoint. An operator B such that D.A/ D.B/ is called relatively compact with respect to A if and only if C.i C A/1 is compact. Proposition 3.10. Let A be self-adjoint and B be relatively compact with respect to A. Then A C B with domain D.A/ is closed and Specess .A C B/ D Specess .A/.
3.1.5 Schrödinger operators Definition 3.14 (Schrödinger operator). Let V be a real-valued multiplication operator in L2 .Rd /. The linear operator 1 H D CV 2
(3.1.22)
D.H / D D..1=2// \ D.V /
(3.1.23)
with the dense domain
is called a Schrödinger operator.
82
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
By the definition of it is readily seen that every ' 2 D..1=2// is a bounded continuous function whenever d 3. Indeed, by the estimate k'k O 1 D k.1 C jkj2 /1 .1 C jkj2 /'k O 1 k.1 C jkj2 /1 k2 k.1 C jkj2 /'k O 2 < 1; the Fourier transform of ' lies in L1 .Rd /. Thus ' is a continuous bounded function by the Riemann-Lebesgue lemma. Moreover, by the scaling 'Or .k/ D r d '.rk/ O we d 4 have k'k O 1 cr 2 kjkj2 'k O 2 C cr d=2 k'k O 2 , with a constant c independent of r. Since d 3, for arbitrary a > 0 there exists b such that k'k1 k'k O 1 ak'k2 C bk'k2 :
(3.1.24)
This bound is useful in estimating the relative bound of a given potential V with respect to the Laplacian. We are interested in defining Schrödinger operators as self-adjoint operators. One reason is that then the spectrum is guaranteed to be real, in match with the uses of quantum mechanics. Secondly, since the solution of the Schrödinger equation (3.1.1) is given by e itH '0 for '.x; 0/ D '0 .x/, to make sure that e itH is a unitary map the question has to be addressed whether the symmetric operator H is self-adjoint or essentially self-adjoint. From the point of view of quantum mechanics, distinct self-adjoint extensions lead to different time-evolutions, however, since several selfadjoint extensions of H may exist, a particular one must be chosen to describe the evolution of the system. Since for any self-adjoint extension K of H it is true that K H , an important step is to find a core of H as then T D H dD is the unique self-adjoint extension of H dD . In general it is difficult to show self-adjointness or essential self-adjointness of a Schrödinger operator. Here we review some basic criteria, however, as we are interested in defining and studying the properties of perturbations of the Laplacian, first we give a notion of perturbation. Definition 3.15 (Relative boundedness). Given an operator A, the operator B is called A-bounded whenever D.A/ D.B/ and kBf k akAf k C bkf k
(3.1.25)
with some numbers a; b 0, for all f 2 D.A/. In this case a is called a relative bound. Moreover, if the relative bound a can be chosen arbitrarily small, B is said to be infinitesimally small with respect to A. A classic result of self-adjoint perturbations of a given self-adjoint operator is offered by the following theorem. Theorem 3.11 (Kato–Rellich). Suppose that K0 is a self-adjoint operator, and KI is a symmetric K0 -bounded operator with relative bound strictly less than 1. Then K D K0 C KI is self-adjoint on D.K0 / and bounded from below. Moreover, K is essentially self-adjoint on any core of K0 .
83
Section 3.1 Schrödinger semigroups
Applied to Schrödinger operators, the natural class of V for the Kato–Rellich theorem is Lp .Rd / C L1 .Rd /. Example 3.6. Let d D 3 and V D V1 C V2 2 L2 .R3 / C L1 .R3 /. Since kV 'k2 kV1 k2 k'k1 C kV2 k1 k'k2 and k'k1 ak'k2 C bk'k2 for arbitrary a > 0 and some b > 0 by (3.1.24), we have kV 'k2 akV1 k2 k'k2 C .b C kV2 k1 /k'k2 : Thus by Theorem 3.11 the Schrödinger operator .1=2/ C V is self-adjoint on D..1=2// and bounded from below. Moreover, it is essentially self-adjoint on any core of . In particular, .1=2/jxj1 is self-adjoint on D..1=2// for d D 3. Example 3.7. The previous example can be extended to arbitrary d -dimension. Let ´ p D 2; d 3 V 2 Lp .Rd / C L1 .Rd / (3.1.26) p > d=2; d 4: In the case d 4 consider V 2 Lp .Rd /. Set q D 2p=.p 2/ and r D 2p=.p C2/. By the Hölder and the Hausdorff–Young inequalities it follows that kVf k2 kV kp kf kq C kV kp kfOkr : Thus kfOkr D k.1 C "jkj2 /1 .1 C "jkj2 /fOkr k.1 C "jkj2 /1 kp k.1 C "jkj2 /fOk2 C 0 "d=.2p/ ."kf k2 C kf k2 /: For a given ı > 0 by taking a sufficiently small " we see that kVf k2 ık.1=2/f k C Cı kf k2 : Thus V is infinitesimally small with respect to . In particular, H is self-adjoint on D..1=2// and essentially self-adjoint on any core of . From the discussion in Example 3.7 we conclude the following result. Proposition 3.12. Let V 2 Lp .Rd /, with p D 2 for d 3, and p > d=2 for d 4. Then there exists a constant C such that kVf k2 C kV kp k..1=2/ C 1/f k for f 2 D..1=2//.
(3.1.27)
84
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
The Kato–Rellich theorem fails to be useful in investigating the self-adjointness of Schrödinger operators with a polynomial potential such at V .x/ D jxj2 . In this case the following can be applied. Theorem 3.13 (Kato’s inequality). Let u 2 L1loc .Rd / and suppose the distributional Laplacian u 2 L1loc .Rd /. Then the inequality juj <Œ.sgn u/u
(3.1.28)
holds in distributional sense. Above we have the sign function sgn u D u.x/=ju.x/j whenever u.x/ 6D 0, and sgn u D 0 for u.x/ D 0, defined as usually. The natural class for Kato’s inequality is L2loc .Rd /. Corollary 3.14. Let V 2 L2loc .Rd / be bounded from below. Then H is essentially self-adjoint on C01 .Rd /. Proof. By (3) of Proposition 3.3 it suffices to show that Ran.H dC 1 .Rd / C1/ D 0
L2 .Rd /, or equivalently, .u; . C V C 1/f / D 0 for 8f 2 C01 .Rd / implies that u D 0. Suppose that . C V C 1/u D 0 in distribution sense. Then u D V u C u follows. By Kato’s inequality juj <.Œsgn uu/ D .V C 1/juj 0. In particular, juj 0. Let vı .x/ D v.x=ı/ı d , where v 0, v 2 C01 .Rd / and R ı Rd v.x/dx D 1. Consider wı D juj vı . Then wı 2 D..1=2//, w D juj vı D juj vı 0 and .wı ; wı / 0 is trivial, thus wı D 0. Since wı ! juj as ı ! 0 in L2 .Rd /, we have juj D 0. Hence the statement follows. Corollary 3.14 can be extended to more general cases. Corollary 3.15. Let V D V1 C V2 be such that V1 0, V1 2 L2loc .Rd / and V2 is .1=2/-bounded with a relative bound less than 1. Then H is essentially selfadjoint on C01 .Rd /. Example 3.8. By Corollary 3.14 the operator .1=2/ C P .x/ with a polynomial P .x/ bounded from below is essentially self-adjoint on C01 .Rd / and bounded from below. Example 3.9. By combining the Kato–Rellich theorem with Kato’s inequality it is seen that H with potential V D V1 C V2 such that V1 2 L2loc .Rd /, V1 0 and ..1=2//1=2 -bounded V2 is self-adjoint on D..1=2/CV1 //, and essentially selfadjoint on C01 .Rd /. To see this first note that .1=2/CV1 is essentially self-adjoint by Kato’s inequality. Secondly, V2 is .1=2/ C V1 -bounded with infinitesimally small relative bound. Hence H is self-adjoint on D..1=2/ C V1 / by the Kato– Rellich theorem.
85
Section 3.1 Schrödinger semigroups
3.1.6 Schrödinger operators by quadratic forms When the potential is too singular and D./ \ D.V / is too small (in the extreme case, it may reduce to ¹0º), then a Schrödinger operator cannot be defined as an operator sum, however, it still can be defined in terms of a form sum. Recall that a quadratic form q on a Hilbert space K is a map q W Q.q/ Q.q/ ! C such that q.f; g/ is linear in g and antilinear in f for f; g 2 Q.q/, where Q.q/ denotes the form domain of q. The form is symmetric if q.f; g/ D q.g; f /. If q.f; f / M kf k2 for some M , then q is said to be semibounded. Notice that a semibounded quadratic form is automatically symmetric if K is defined over the complex field C. A semibounded quadratic form q is closed if Q.q/ is complete in the norm kf kC1 D .q.f; f / C .M C 1/kf k2 /1=2 with M as above. Moreover, if q is closed and D Q.q/ is dense in Q.q/ in the norm k kC1 , then D is called a form core for q. By Riesz’s theorem there is a one-to-one correspondence between semibounded quadratic forms and self-adjoint operators bounded from below. Let A be a selfadjoint operator bounded from below. Then it is clear that A defines the semibounded quadratic form Z qA .f; g/ D
R
d.EA . /f; g/
with form domain Q.qA / D D.jAj1=2 /. Proposition 3.16. If q is a closed semibounded quadratic form, then there exists a unique self-adjoint operator A such that q D qA . Using this fact we can define the Schrödinger operator with a singular potential such as V .x/ D ı.x/. Let A and B be self-adjoint operators bounded from below, and suppose that Q.qA / \ Q.qB / is dense. Then the quadratic form q.f; g/ D qA .f; g/ C qB .f; g/ with Q.q/ D Q.qA / \ Q.qB / defines a closed semibounded quadratic form. Its assoP B. For a non-positive self-adjoint ciated self-adjoint operator is denoted by C D A C P operator B, A C .B/ is written as A P B. Here is next a form analogue of the Kato–Rellich theorem. Theorem 3.17 (KLMN theorem). Let A be a positive self-adjoint operator and suppose that ˇ is a symmetric quadratic form on Q.qA / such that jˇ.f; f /j aqA .f; f / C b.f; f / with some a < 1 and b 0. Then there exists a unique self-adjoint operator C such that Q.qC / D Q.qA / and qC .f; g/ D qA .f; g/ C ˇ.f; g/ for f; g 2 Q.qC /. Also the concept of relative boundedness of operators can be extended to forms.
86
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Definition 3.16 (Relative form boundedness). Let A be a positive self-adjoint operator and B a self-adjoint operator such that .1/ Q.qB / Q.qA / and .2/ jqB .f; f /j aqA .f; f / C b.f; f /, for some a > 0 and b 0. Then B is said to be relatively form-bounded with respect to A. If B is A-bounded, then B is relatively form-bounded with respect to A with the same relative bound as the A-bound. Example 3.10. Let V .x/ D jxj˛ , 0 ˛ < 2 and d D 3. In quantum mechanics the relation kjxj1 f k 4kf k is known as the uncertainty principle. It can be seen that V is infinitesimally small form bounded with respect to , i.e., for any " there exists b" > 0 such that kV 1=2 f k "k./1=2 f k C b" kf k for f 2 Q./. Therefore there exists a self-adjoint operator K such that .f; Kg/ D .f; . C V /g/ for f; g 2 C01 .R3 /. R Example 3.11. Let q.f; g/ D .rf; rg/ C Rd V .x/fN.x/g.x/dx. The natural class of V such that inf¹q.f; f /j kf k2 D 1; f 2 H 1 .Rd /º > 1 is 8 d=2 d 1 d ˆ d 3 0; d D 2 ˆ : 1 1 1 1 L .R / C L .R /; d D 1: Note that in theR case of (3.1.29) the fact that f 2 H 1 .Rd / implies by the Sobolev inequality that Rd jV .x/jf .x/j2 dx kV kd=2 kf k22d=.d 2/ C kV kd=2 krf k22 < 1. Since q is semibounded on the form domain H 1 .Rd /, there exists a self-adjoint operator associated with q.
The relationship between the convergence of sequences of quadratic forms and associated self-adjoint operators is the following. Let q1 and q2 be symmetric quadratic forms bounded from below. q1 q2 means that Q.q1 / Q.q2 / and q1 .f; f / q2 .f; f /, for all f 2 Q.q1 /. A sequence .qn /n2N of symmetric quadratic forms bounded from below is non-increasing (resp. non-decreasing) if qn qnC1 (resp. qn qnC1 ), for all n. Theorem 3.18 (Monotone convergence theorem for forms). .1/ Case of non-increasing sequence: Let .qn /n2N be a non-increasing sequence of densely defined, closed symmetric quadratic forms uniformly bounded from below; qn
with some constant , and let Hn be the self-adjoint operator associated with qn . Let q1 be the symmetric quadratic form defined by [ q1 .f; f / D lim qn .f; f /; Q.q1 / D Q.qn /: (3.1.30) n!1
n
Let H be the self-adjoint operator associated with qN 1 , the closure of q1 . Then it follows that s-limn!1 .Hn /1 D .H /1 , for < < .
87
Section 3.1 Schrödinger semigroups
.2/ Case of non-decreasing sequence: Let .qn /n2N be a non-decreasing sequence of densely defined, closed symmetric quadratic forms, and Hn be the self-adjoint operator associated with qn . Let q1 be the symmetric quadratic form defined by q1 .f; f / D lim qn .f; f /; n!1
Q.q1 / D ¹f j lim qn .f; f / < 1º: (3.1.31) n!1
Then q1 is a closed symmetric quadratic form. Suppose furthermore that Q.q1 / is dense. Let H be the self-adjoint operator associated with q1 . Then it follows that s-limn!1 .Hn /1 D .H /1 , for Im ¤ 0.
3.1.7 Confining potential and decaying potential A natural question is how the spectrum of the Laplacian changes under a perturbation V . It is not our scope to discuss spectral theory in this book, however, we make a few remarks by means of examples which are relevant in our considerations below. Theorem 3.19 (Rellich’s criterion). Let F and G be functions on Rd such that limjxj!1 F .x/ D 1 and limjxj!1 G.x/ D 1. Then the set ˇZ ° ˇ jf .x/j2 dx 1; f 2 L2 .Rd /ˇ d R ³ Z Z 2 2 O F .x/jf .x/j dx 1; G.p/jf .p/j dp 1 Rd
Rd
is compact. Using this criterion the following interesting result is obtained. Theorem 3.20 (Confining potentials). Let V 2 L1loc .Rd / be bounded from below P V has compact resolvent. such that V .x/ ! 1 as jxj ! 1. Then H D .1=2/ C In particular, it has a purely discrete spectrum, i.e., Spec.H / D Specd .H /. Proof. By Proposition 3.9 it suffices to show that S D ¹f 2 D.jH j1=2 /jkf k 1; kjH j1=2 f k2 bº is compact for all b. Since S is closed, we need only prove that S is contained in a compact set. Indeed, ˇZ ° 2 d ˇ jf .x/j2 dx 1; S f 2 L .R /ˇ Rd ³ Z Z 1 2 O p jf .p/j2 dp b V .x/jf .x/j2 dx b; Rd Rd 2 and the right-hand side is compact by Rellich’s criterion.
88
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
From this theorem we see that Schrödinger operators with confining potentials have a purely discrete spectrum. Next we consider Schrödinger operators with decaying potentials. The spectral properties of this class are markedly different from those with confining potentials. Let L1;0 .Rd / D ¹f 2 L1 .Rd /jf .x/ ! 0 as jxj ! 1º R Define the operator P .i r/ by P .i r/f D .2/d=2 P .k/e ikx fO.k/d k: Proposition 3.21 (Compactness). Let P; Q 2 L1;0 .Rd /. Then Q.x/P .i r/ is compact. Proof. Let 1ƒ 2 C01 .Rd / be given by ´ 1; jxj < ƒ; 1ƒ .x/ D 0; jxj > ƒ C 1: Then the product 1ƒ .x/1ƒ .i r/ is an integral operator with kernel k.x; y/ D .2/d=2 1ƒ .x/1O ƒ .y x/ 2 L2 .Rd Rd /. Thus 1ƒ .x/1ƒ .i r/ is compact by Example 3.4. Since Q.x/1ƒ .x/ ! Q.x/ and 1ƒ .i r/P .i r/ ! P .i r/ as ƒ ! 1 uniformly, it is seen that Q.x/P .i r/ D lim Q.x/1ƒ .x/1ƒ .i r/P .i r/: ƒ!1
Since Q.x/P .i r/ is a uniform limit of a sequence of compact operators, it is compact by Proposition 3.8. Theorem 3.22 (Decaying potentials). Let V be such that ´ p D 2; V 2 Lp .Rd / C L1;0 .Rd / p > d=2;
d 3; d 4:
Then H D .1=2/ C V is essentially self-adjoint on C01 .Rd / and Specess .H / D Specess ./ D Œ0; 1/. Proof. Set H0 D .1=2/. Essential self-adjointness follows by the Kato–Rellich theorem. By Proposition 3.21, V .H0 C 1/1 is compact for V 2 L1;0 .Rd /. Thus it suffices to show that V 2 Lp .Rd / is relatively compact with respect to H0 . Let V 2 Lp .Rd /. For each " > 0 we decompose V D V" C W" , where kV" kp < " and W" 2 L1;0 .Rd /. Indeed let 8 ´ ˆ jgj < N ƒ : N; g N:
89
Section 3.1 Schrödinger semigroups
Then V is decomposed as V D .V 1ƒ /.N / C V .V 1ƒ /.N / : „ ƒ‚ … „ ƒ‚ … N DVƒ
(3.1.32)
N DWƒ
Thus VƒN 2 L1;0 .Rd /, WƒN 2 Lp .Rd / and kWƒN kp < " for sufficiently large ƒ and N . Furthermore, VƒN ! V in Lp as ƒ; N ! 1. We have by (3.1.27) k.V .1 C H0 /1 VƒN .1 C H0 /1 /f k C kV VƒN kp kf k2 : Thus VƒN .1 C H0 /1 ! V .1 C H0 /1 in the uniform topology and VƒN .1 C H0 /1 is compact since VƒN 2 L1;0 .Rd /. Hence V .1 C H0 /1 is compact, and the proof is complete. Example 3.12. Two notable examples of spectra of Schrödinger operators are: .1/ Harmonic oscillator: Choose, for simplicity, d D 1, and let ! > 0. The 2 Schrödinger operator H with V .x/ D !2 x 2 !2 describes the harmonic oscillator. In this case the spectrum is purely discrete Spec.H / D Specd .H / D ¹!njn 2 N [ ¹0ºº. .2/ Hydrogen atom: Choose d D 3, and let > 0. The Schrödinger operator H with V .x/ D jxj describes the hydrogen atom. In this case Specess .H / D 2
Œ0; 1/, and Specp .H / D Specd .H / D ¹ 2n 2 j n 2 Nº.
3.1.8 Strongly continuous operator semigroups We conclude this section by a summary of basic facts on operator semigroups. Definition 3.17 (C0 -semigroup). The one-parameter family of bounded operators ¹S t W t 0º on a Banach space B is said to be a strongly continuous one-parameter semigroup or C0 -semigroup whenever .1/ S0 D 1 .2/ Ss S t D SsCt .3/ S t is strongly continuous in t , i.e., s-lim t!0 S t D S0 D 1. Every C0 -semigroup is generated by a uniquely associated operator. Definition 3.18 (Generator). Let ¹S t W t 0º be a C0 -semigroup on a Banach space B. Its generator is defined by 1 Tf D s-lim .S t f f / t!0 t ˇ ® ¯ with domain D.T / D f 2 B ˇs-lim t!0 1t .S t f f / exists .
90
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Note that T is densely defined, closed, and determines S t uniquely. Proposition 3.23. Let ¹S t W t 0º be a C0 -semigroup with generator T . The following properties hold for all t 0: .1/ S t D.T / D.T / and
d S ' dt t
D T St '
.2/ there exist M 1 and a > 0 such that kS t k M e at Rt .3/ 0 Sr 'dr 2 D.T / for all ' 2 B Rt Rt .4/ S t ' ' D T 0 Sr 'dr, moreover S t ' ' D 0 Sr T 'dr if ' 2 D.T / .5/ if T is a bounded operator, then D.T / D B and S t is uniformly continuous. With a given self-adjoint operator A, the semigroups e itA and e tA can be defined through the spectral resolution (3.1.19). In particular, ¹e itA W t 2 Rº is a strongly continuous one-parameter unitary group, and ¹e tA W t 0º is a strongly continuous one-parameter semigroup whenever A is bounded from below. Example 3.13 (Heat kernels). Some specific choices of interest of generators giving rise to strongly continuous semigroups are as follows: .1/ T D 12 gives e .1=2/t .x; y/ D .2 t /d=2 exp.jx yj2 =2t /: .2/ T D ./˛=2 , 0 < ˛ < 2, has the integral kernel Z 1 ˛=2 ˛ e t./ .x; y/ D e tjkj Cik.xy/ d k; d .2/ Rd moreover for ˛ D 1 the explicit formula d C1 t 1 t./1=2 e .x; y/ D .d C1/=2 2 2 .t C jx yj2 /.d C1/=2 holds. .3/ T D . C m2 /1=2 m, m > 0, has the integral kernel e t..Cm
2 /1=2 m/
.x; y/
1 t D p d 2 .2/ t C jx yj2
Z
p 2 2 2 2 e mt .t Cjxyj /.jkj Cm / d k:
Rd
The cases above are examples of Feller semigroups associated with Brownian motion, ˛-stable processes and relativistic stable processes, respectively. Conversely, given a semigroup here are some basic results on their generators, of which we will often make use.
91
Section 3.1 Schrödinger semigroups
Proposition 3.24 (Stone’s Theorem). Let ¹U t W t 2 Rº be a strongly continuous oneparameter unitary group on a Hilbert space. Then there exists a unique self-adjoint operator A such that U t D e itA , t 2 R. Proposition 3.25 (Hille–Yoshida theorem). A linear operator T is the generator of a C0 -semigroup ¹S t W t 0º on a Banach space if and only if .1/ T is a densely defined closed operator, .2/ there exists a 2 R such that .a; 1/ .T / and k.a T /m k
M ; . a/m
> a;
m D 1; 2; : : : ;
where .T / denotes the resolvent set of T . Proposition 3.26 (Semigroup version of Stone’s theorem). Let S t be a symmetric C0 semigroup on a Hilbert space. Then there exists a self-adjoint operator A bounded from below such that S t D e tA , t 0. Proof. Define the operator A by 1 Af D s-lim .S t 1/f; t!0 t
² ˇ ³ ˇ 1 D.A/ D f ˇˇ s-lim .S t 1/f exists : t!0 t
By the Hille–Yoshida theorem and the fact that S t is symmetric, A is a closed symmetric operator and for some a 2 R the resolvent .A/ contains .1; a/. It is a standard fact that the spectrum of a closed symmetric operator is one of the following cases: (a) the closed upper half-plane, (b) the closed lower-half plane, (c) the entire plane, (d) a subset of R. Hence A must be (d), which implies that A is self-adjoint and bounded from below. Since a given generator gives rise to a unique C0 -semigroup, we have that S t D e tA . In case when S t is not a semigroup yet s-lim t!0 t 1 .S t 1/ does exist, one can use the following result. Proposition 3.27. Let A be a positive self-adjoint operator and %.t / a family of selfadjoint operators with 0 %.t / 1. Suppose that S t D t 1 .1 %.t // converges to A as t # 0 in strong resolvent sense. Then s-lim %.t =n/n D e tA :
n!1
Proof. s-limn!1 exp tS t=n D e tA follows by strong resolvent convergence of S t=n to A. Then it suffices to show that s-lim .exp.tS t=n / %.t =n/n / D s-lim Gn .tS t=n / D 0;
n!1
n!1
92
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
where ´ e x .1 x=n/n ; 0 x n; Gn .x/ D x x n: e ; It is easily seen that limn!1 kGn k1 D 0 and the proposition follows. We now define semigroups generated by Schrödinger operators. Definition 3.19 (Schrödinger semigroup). The one-parameter operator semigroup ¹e tH W t 0º defined by a Schrödinger operator H is a Schrödinger semigroup. Due to the additive structure of Schrödinger operators the following result will also be useful. Proposition 3.28 (Trotter product formula). Let A and B be positive self-adjoint operators such that A C B is essentially self-adjoint on D.A/ \ D.B/. Then s-lim .e .t=n/A e .t=n/B /n D e t.ACB/ ;
n!1
(3.1.33)
where A C B denotes the closure of .A C B/dD.A/\D.B/ . Proof. Let %.t / D e .t=2/A e tB e .t=2/A . Then .e .t=n/A e .t=n/B /n D e .t=2n/A %.t =n/n1 e .t=2n/A e .t=n/B holds. Since e tA and e tB are uniformly bounded in t 0 and strongly converge to identity as t ! 0, it suffices to show that s limn!1 %.t =n/n1 D e tC , where C D A C B. We have that t 1 .1 %.t // is a bounded self-adjoint operator and t 1 .1 %.t // D e .t=2/A e tB t 1 .1 e .t=2/A / C e .t=2/A t 1 .1 e tB / C t 1 .1 e .t=2/A / ! C as t ! 1, for 2 D.A/ \ D.B/, which implies that t 1 .1 %.t // ! C in strong resolvent sense. Thus s-limn!1 %.t =n/n D e tC follows by Proposition 3.27. Furthermore, s-lim .%.t =n/n1 e tC /
n!1
D s-lim %.t =n/n1 .1 %.t =n// C s-lim .%.t =n/n e tC / D 0: n!1
Hence the proposition follows.
n!1
93
Section 3.2 Feynman–Kac formula for external potentials
The Trotter product formula can be extended to more general cases. Proposition 3.29. Let A and B be positive self-adjoint operators in a Hilbert space H with form domains Q.qA / and Q.qB /. Denote by PAB the projection to Q.qA / \ Q.qB /. Then P
s-lim .e .t=n/A e .t=n/B /n D e t.A C B/ PAB ;
n!1
(3.1.34)
P B is the quadratic form sum of A and B, i.e., the self-adjoint operator in where A C PAB H associated with the densely defined closed quadratic form f 7! kA1=2 f k2 C kB 1=2 f k2 .
3.2
Feynman–Kac formula for external potentials
3.2.1 Bounded smooth external potentials We begin discussing Feynman–Kac formulae by assuming that V 2 C01 .Rd /, which is the simplest case. For such a choice of potential the Schödinger operator H is self-adjoint on D.H / D H 2 .Rd / and bounded from below by the Kato–Rellich theorem. Therefore the semigroup e tH can be defined by the spectral resolution and the solution of (3.1.7) with initial condition g is given by f .x; t / D .e tH g/.x/. We will denote Brownian motion throughout by .B t / t0 and its natural filtration .F t / t0 as discussed in Chapter 2. Theorem 3.30 (Feynman–Kac formula for Schrödinger operator with smooth external potentials). Let V 2 C01 .Rd /. Then for f; g 2 L2 .Rd /, Z Rt Ex Œf .B0 /e 0 V .Bs / ds g.B t /dx: (3.2.1) .f; e tH g/ D Rd
In particular, .e tH g/.x/ D Ex Œe
Rt 0
V .Bs / ds
g.B t /:
(3.2.2)
Proof. Define the map K t on L2 .Rd / by .K t f /.x/ D Ex Œe
Rt 0
V .Bs / ds
f .B t /:
(3.2.3)
K t is bounded on L2 .Rd / for each t as kK t f k2 e 2 inf V kf k2 . First we show that ¹K t W t 0º is a symmetric C0 -semigroup on L2 .Rd /. Define BQ s D B ts B t , d s < t , for a fixed t > 0. By Proposition 2.7 we have BQ s D Bs . Thus Z Rt .f; K t g/ D EŒf .x/e 0 V .Bs Cx/ds g.B t C x/dx Rd
Z Rt Q DE f .x/e 0 V .Bs Cx/ds g.BQ t C x/dx : Rd
94
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Changing the variable x to y D BQ t C x, we obtain
Z Rt Q Q f .y BQ t /e 0 V .Bs B t Cy/ds g.y/dy .f; K t g/ D E Rd Z Rt D EŒf .y C B t /e 0 V .B t s Cy/ds g.y/dy Rd
D .K t f; g/;
(3.2.4) Rt
i.e., K t is symmetric. Write now Z t D e 0 V .Bs /ds . The semigroup property follows directly from the Markov property of Brownian motion: .Ks K t f /.x/ D Ex ŒZs EBs .Z t f .B t // D Ex ŒEx ŒZs e
Rt 0
V .BsCu /du
f .BsCt /jFs
D Ex ŒZsCt f .BsCt / D KsCt f .x/: Strong continuity is implied by kK t f f k E0 Œke
Rt 0
V .CBs /ds
f . C B t / f k ! 0
as t ! 0, by using the dominated convergence theorem. We now know that on both sides of (3.2.1) there is a C0 -semigroup. What remains to show is that their generators are equal, i.e., 1t .K t 1/ converges to H strongly in L2 on D.H /. We will use Itô calculus for this. Put Y t D f .B t /; then the Itô formula gives dZ t D V Z t dt and d Y t D rf dB t C .1=2/f dt . By the product rule (2.3.25), 1 d.Z t Y t / D Z t Vf .B t / C f .B t / dt C Z t rf .B t / dB t 2 D Z t .Hf /.B t /dt C Z t rf .B t / dB t :
(3.2.5)
Taking expectation with respect to R tWiener measure on both sides of the integrated form of (3.2.5) and using that Ex Œ 0 Zs rf dBs D 0, we obtain Z t Z t Ex ŒZs .Hf /.Bs /ds D f .x/ Ks Hf .x/ds: (3.2.6) .K t f /.x/ D f .x/ 0
0
For f 2 D.H / and " > 0 there exists s0 > 0 with kKs Hf Hf k ", for all s < s0 . Thus by (3.2.6), with t < s0 Z t 1 .K t f f / C Hf 1 k Ks Hf C Hf kds " t t 0 is obtained. This shows strong convergence of 1t .K t 1/f to Hf for f 2 D.H / as t ! 0, completing the proof.
95
Section 3.2 Feynman–Kac formula for external potentials
Definition 3.20 (Feynman–Kac semigroup). The symmetric C0 -semigroup ¹K t W t 0º defined by (3.2.3) is called Feynman–Kac semigroup for the given V . It is seen that the solution of (3.1.7), like the solution of the heat equation, can be obtained by running a Brownian motion with an additional exponential weight applied. This gives a probabilistic representation of the solution or, equivalently, of the kernel of the semigroup e tH . Using this picture we see that Brownian paths spending a long time in a region where V is large are exponentially penalized and thus their contribution to the expected value will be accordingly small. The dominant contribution will therefore come from paths that spend most of their time near the lowest values of V . This is a property which will be explored in more detail in Part II of the book.
3.2.2 Derivation through the Trotter product formula By using the Trotter product formula we can give another proof of Theorem 3.30. Alternate proof of Feynman–Kac formula for Schrödinger operator with smooth potentials. Write H0 D .1=2/, let f1 ; : : : ; fn1 2 L1 .Rd / and f0 ; fn 2 L2 .Rd /. By the finite dimensional distributions of Brownian motion, for 0 D t0 t1 tn we have n i hY e .tj tj 1 /H0 fj .x/ D Ex fj .B tj /
n Y j D1
(3.2.7)
j D1
and n Z Y .tj tj 1 /H0 N f0 ; e fj D j D1
Rd
E
x
n hY
i fj .B tj / dx:
j D0
The Trotter product formula combined with (3.2.8) gives .f; e tH g/ D lim .f; .e .t=n/H0 e .t=n/V /n g/ n!1 Z Pn D lim Ex Œf .B0 /g.B t /e .t=n/ j D1 V .B tj=n / dx: n!1 Rd
Since V is continuous and Bs is almost surely continuous in s, Z t n t X V .B tj=n / ! V .Bs /ds n 0 j D1
almost surely as n ! 1. Thus we have Z Rt .f; e tH g/ D Ex Œf .B0 /g.B t /e 0 V .Bs /ds dx: Rd
(3.2.8)
96
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Having the Feynman–Kac formula for smooth bounded potentials at hand, we are now interested in extending it to wider classes of V . We present here one immediate extension covering potentials as singular as V .x/ D 1=jxj3 (see Section 3.4.4). Theorem 3.31 (Feynman–Kac formula for Schrödinger operator with singular external potentials). Assume that for V D VC V we have VC 2 L1loc .Rd n S /, where S is a closed set of measure zero, and V is relatively form bounded with respect to P VC .1=2/ with a relative bound strictly less than 1. Define H D .1=2/ C P V . Then (3.2.1) holds. Proof. Suppose that V 2 L1 and Vn D .x=n/.V jn /, where jn D nd .x n/ R 1 d with 2 C0 .R / such that 0 1, Rd .x/dx D 1 and .0/ D 1. Then Vn .x/ ! V .x/ almost everywhere. Thus there is a set N Rd of Lebesgue measure zero such that Vn .x/ ! V .x/ for x … N , and Z Ex Œ1¹Bs 2N º D
Rd
1N .y/… t .y x/dy D 0
for every x 2 N . Then for every x 2 N , Z 0D
Z
t 0
x
dsE Œ1¹Bs 2N º D E
t
x 0
ds1¹Bs 2N º
by Fubini’s theorem. Thus for every x 2 RN , the measure Rof ¹t 2 RC jB t .!/ 2 N º t t is zero, for almost every ! 2 X . Hence 0 Vn .Bs /ds ! 0 V .Bs /ds almost surely x under W , for x … N . Therefore by the dominated convergence theorem, Z x
Rd
dxE Œf .B0 /g.B t /e
Rt 0
Z Vn .Bs /ds
!
Rd
dxEx Œf .B0 /g.B t /e
Rt 0
V .Bs /ds
:
On the other hand, e t..1=2/CVn / ! e t..1=2/CV / strongly, since .1=2/CVn converges to .1=2/ C V on a common core. Thus (3.2.1) holds for V 2 L1 .Rd /. Now assume that VC 2 L1loc .Rd n S/ and V is relatively form bounded with respect to .1=2/. Let ´
VC .x/; VC .x/ < n; VCn .x/ D n; VC .x/ n;
´ Vm .x/ D
V .x/; V .x/ < m; m; V .x/ m:
Then .f; e t..1=2/CVn;m / g/ D
Z Rd
dxEx Œf .B0 /e
Rt 0
Vn;m .Bs / ds
g.B t /:
(3.2.9)
97
Section 3.3 Feynman–Kac formula for Kato-class potentials
Set h D .1=2/. Define the closed quadratic forms 1=2
1=2
1=2
1=2
1=2
1=2
1=2 1=2 qn;m .f; f / D .h1=2 f; h1=2 f / C .VCn f; VCn f / .Vm f; Vm f /;
qn;1 .f; f / D .h1=2 f; h1=2 f / C .VCn f; VCn f / .V1=2 f; V1=2 f /; q1;1 .f; f / D .h1=2 f; h1=2 f / C .VC f; VC f / .V1=2 f; V1=2 f /; whose form domains are respectively Q.qn;m / D Q.h/, Q.qn;1 / D Q.h/ and Q.q1;1 / D Q.h/ \ Q.VC /. Clearly, qn;m qn;mC1 qn;mC2 qn;1 and qn;m ! qn;1 in the sense of quadratic forms on [m Q.qn;m / D Q.h/. Since qn;1 is closed on Q.h/, by Theorem 3.18 the associated positive self-adjoint operators satisfy hCVCn Vm ! hCVCn P V in strong resolvent sense, which implies that for all t 0, exp .t .h C VCn Vm // ! exp .t .h C VCn P V //
(3.2.10)
strongly as m ! 1. Similarly, we have qn;1 qnC1;1 qnC2;1 q1 and qn;1 ! q1;1 in form sense on ¹f 2 \n Q.qn;1 / j supn qn;1 .f; f / < 1º D Q.h/ \ Q.VC /. Hence by Theorem 3.18 again we obtain P VC P VCn P V // ! exp.t .h C P V //; t 0; exp.t .h C
(3.2.11)
in strong sense as n ! 1. By taking first n ! 1 and then m ! 1 it can be proven that both sides of (3.2.9) converge; the left-hand side of (3.2.9) converges by monotone convergence for forms, (3.2.10) and (3.2.11), and the right-hand side by monotone convergence for integrals.
3.3
Feynman–Kac formula for Kato-class potentials
3.3.1 Kato-class potentials The Feynman–Kac formula we have derived so far covers only a limited range of interesting models of mathematical physics. First, the potential was not allowed to grow at infinity. This excludes cases when the particle is trapped in some region of Rd , like under the harmonic potential V .x/ D jxj2 . Secondly, it is desirable to allow for local singularities, especially the case of the Coulomb potential V .x/ D 1=jxj in dimension 3. To include these and further cases of interest, we introduce here a large class of potentials and use it as a space of reference as far as we can. This space is Kato-class which on several counts is a natural function space as it will be made clear below. However, occasionally we will have to leave this space in order to draw stronger conclusions or because the conditions of Kato-class are too strong themselves for a particular statement we want to prove.
98
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Our objective in this section is to introduce Kato-class and discuss its basic properties, then define Schrödinger operators with Kato-class potentials as self-adjoint operators, and finally derive a corresponding Feynman–Kac formula. .1/ V W Rd ! R is called a Kato-class potential
Definition 3.21 (Kato-class). whenever
Z lim sup
r!0 x2Rd
Br .x/
jg.x y/V .y/j dy D 0
(3.3.1)
holds, where Br .x/ is the closed ball of radius r centered at x, and 8 ˆ d D 1; <jxj; g.x/ D log jxj; d D 2; ˆ : 2d jxj ; d 3:
(3.3.2)
We denote this linear space by K.Rd /. .2/ V is Kato-decomposable whenever V D VC V with VC 2 L1loc .Rd / and V 2 K.Rd /. In the case of d D 1 we have an equivalent definition of Kato-class which we will use below. V is of Kato-class if and only if Z sup jV .y/jdy < 1: (3.3.3) x2R B1 .x/
R R Suppose (3.3.3) holds. Then supx Br .x/ jx yjjV .y/jdy r supx B1 .x/ jV .y/jdy, for 0 < r < 1, thus V is of Kato-class. Next R suppose that V is of Kato-class. For any " > 0 there exists r > 0 such that supx Br .x/ jx yjjV .y/jdy < ". Then it follows that Z Z r sup jV .y/jdy sup jx yjjV .y/jdy " 2 x r=2jxyjr x r=2jxyjr Z
and therefore sup x
r=2jxyjr
jV .y/jdy
2" : r
Since B1 .0/ can be covered by a finite number of annuli, sayR N , we have that Aj D ¹yjr=2 jxj yj rº with some point xj . Then supx B1 .x/ jV .y/jdy R PN 2N " j supx Aj Cx jV .y/jdy r < 1 holds. Before deriving a Feynman–Kac formula for such potentials it is useful to discuss some basic features of Kato-class. We begin by explaining the definition. Let … t
Section 3.3 Feynman–Kac formula for Kato-class potentials
99
be the transition kernel of Brownian motion given by (2.1.10), and f a non-negative function. By Fubini’s theorem we have
Z 1 Z Ex f .B t /dt D H.x; y/f .y/dy; (3.3.4) 0
R1
Rd
with integral kernel H.x; y/ D 0 … t .x; y/dt . In the limit t ! 1, … t .x/ behaves like .2 t /d=2 , thus H diverges for d D 1 and 2. For d 3, on making the change of variable jx yj2 =.2t / 7! t , H.x; y/ D
1 .d=2 1/ d=2 2 jx yjd 2
(3.3.5)
is obtained, where is the Gamma-function. For lower dimensions we proceed by R1 compensation with a suitable additive term. Let HQ .x; y/ D 0 .… t .x; y/ h.t // dt . For d D 1 we choose h.t / D … t .0; 0/ D .2 t /1=2 yielding Z 1 jxyj2 =.2t/ 1 e 1 Q dt D jx yj H .x; y/ D p p t 2 0 by making the same change of variable as above. For d D 2 write h.t / D … t .0; v/, with unit vector v D 10 . Then Z 1 jxyj2 =.2t/ 1 1 e e 1=.2t/ Q H .x; y/ D dt D log jx yj: 2 0 t This shows that g in Definition 3.21 is basically given by the potential kernels of the Laplacian. The conditions in (3.3.2) limit the growth at infinity (K.Rd /) and the severity of local singularities (L1loc .Rd /). These are illustrated by the following examples. Example 3.14. Let d D 3. Kato-class allows singularities of the type jxj.2"/ with any " > 0, including in particular Coulomb potential V .x/ D 1=jxj, as well as infinitely many isolated singularities of the same type are allowed. In contrast, the function V .x/ D jxj is not contained in K.R3 /. Example 3.15. An application of the Hölder inequality gives an idea about the growth at infinity allowed. Let d D 3; then ˇ Z ˇZ 1=p Z 1=q ˇ ˇ 1 1 q ˇ ˇ jV .y/j dy ˇ dy jV .y/j dy ; ˇ p Br .x/ jx yj Br .x/ jx yj Br .x/ with 1=p C 1=q D 1. The first factor is independent of x and when p < 3, it goes to R zero as r ! 0. Thus V 2 K.R3 / if supx Br .x/ jV .y/jq dy < 1 for some r > 0 and some q > 3=2. A direct calculation shows, for instance, that V .x; y; z/ D jxj˛ e jxj
ˇ .jyj2 Cjzj2 /
100
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
is in K.R3 / if ˇ > 3˛=2. This shows that Kato-class is essentially an integrability condition; pointwise divergence is allowed as long as the given integrals can be controlled. Example 3.16. Let V 2 Lp .Rd / C L1 .Rd / with p D 1 for d D 1, and p > d=2 for d 2. Then V 2 K.Rd /. If V is Kato-decomposable, the positive part of V is in L1loc .Rd /. We have the following property. Rt Lemma 3.32. Suppose that 0 V 2 L1loc .Rd /. Then W x . 0 V .Bs /ds D 1/ D 0 for almost every x 2 Rd . In particular, Ex Œe x 2 Rd .
Rt 0
V .Bs /ds
> 0, for almost every
Proof. Let N 2 N and ´ 1N .x/ D
1; jxj < N; 0; jxj N:
Since 1N V 2 L1 .Rd /, we have
Z t Z x dxE 1N V .Bs /ds t k1N V kL1 : R3
0
Rt Hence for almost every fixed x 2 Rd , W x . 0 1N V .Bs /ds < 1/ D 1, and then there Rt exits NN , dependent on x, such that W x .NN / D 0 and 0 1N V .Bs .!//ds < 1, for R t every ! 2 X n NN . Let N D [N NN . Note that N depends on x. Thus 0 1N V .Bs .!//ds < 1, for every N 2 N and ! 2 X n N . Since Bs .!/ is continuous in s almost surely, for every ! 2 X nN there exists N D N.!/ 2 N such that V .Bs .!// D 1N V .Bs .!//, for all 0 s t . Thus V .Bs .!// D 1N V .Bs .!// and hence Z t Z t V .Bs .!//ds D 1N V .Bs .!//ds < 1; ! 2 X n N : 0
0
Next we present a first equivalent characterization of Kato-class. Proposition 3.33. A non-negative function V is in K.Rd / if and only if
Z t x lim sup E V .Bs / ds D 0: t#0 x2Rd
0
(3.3.6)
Section 3.3 Feynman–Kac formula for Kato-class potentials
101
Proof. As in (3.3.4), write for t 2 R
Z E
t
x 0
Z
V .Bs / ds D
Z
t
ds Rd
0
dy …s .x y/V .y/:
By the same change of variable as above, Z 0
t
…s .x y/ds D
1 1 d=2 .2/ jx yjd 2
Z
1
jxyj2 =.2t/
e u ud=22 du D H.x; yI t /
readily follows. The key observation now is that H.x; yI t / behaves like g.x y/ in Definition 3.21 whenever jx yj2 =2t is small, and vanishes rapidly when jx yj2 =2t goes to infinity. This is obvious in the cases d 3 and is seen through integration by parts in d D 1 and 2. We give the details only in the simplest case d D 4; the others go by the same arguments, though require further estimates. The convenient feature of the case d D 4 is that then we have an explicit formula for H.x; yI t / and
Z sup Ex x2R4
t 0
Z V .Bs / ds D sup x2R4
R4
jxyj2 1 e 2t V .y/dy 2 .2jx yj/
(3.3.7)
follows. We split up the domain of integration on the right-hand side above into Aq D ¹y j jx yj < t 1=q º and Bq D R4 n Aq for q > 0. Notice that Aq shrinks to ¹xº when t ! 0. If (3.3.6) holds, then the integral over A2 on the right-hand side of (3.3.7) vanishes with t ! 0, uniformly in x. On A2 , exp.jx yj2 =2t / is bounded away from zero, hence V 2 K.R4 / follows. Conversely, assume V 2 K.R4 /. Then by definition and the fact that the negative exponential is bounded from above, we 2 R 1 jxyj 2t obtain lim t#0 supx2R4 A3 .2 jxyj/ V .y/dy D 0: On the other hand, on 2e B3 we have exp.jx yj2 =2t / exp.jx yj=t 1=6 /, thus the right-hand side of (3.3.7) goes to zero on this set by dominated convergence. We present a second equivalent characterization of Kato-class recalling the asymptotic properties of the resolvent of the Laplacian. The kernel of the resolvent operator . C /1 is explicitly given by . C /1 .x; y/ D C .x y/;
(3.3.8)
where d=2
C .x/ D .2/
p !.d 1/=2 p K.d 2/=2 . jxj/; jxj
(3.3.9)
102
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
with Kd .z/ being the modified Bessel function of the third kind. As jx yj ! 0, 8 2d ; ˆ d 3; <jx yj C .x y/ log jx yj; d D 2; ˆ : C; d D 1; moreover for any ı > 0, lim
sup e jxyj C .x y/ D 0:
!1 jxyj>ı
R Then we readily have supx Rd CE .x y/jV .y/jdy ! 0 as E ! 1 if and only if V 2 K.Rd /, and by comparison with R Definition 3.21 the proposition below follows. We see that . C E/1 jV j.x/ D Rd CE .x y/jV .y/jdy, and we use that ˇ ˇ k. C E/1 jV jk1 D sup ˇ. C E/1 jV j.x/ˇ :
(3.3.10)
x2Rd
Proposition 3.34. V 2 K.Rd / if and only if lim k. C E/1 jV jk1 D 0:
E !1
(3.3.11)
For the sake of completeness, we present a proof of equivalence between (3.3.11) and (3.3.6). Proof. Take in a suitable neighbourhood of 0 and denote H0 D .1=2/. Clearly, Ex ŒjV .Bs /j D .e sH0 jV j/.x/. Then by Laplace transform, 1
..H0 C E/
jV j/.x/ D
XZ
.nC1/T
n0 nT
e sE .e sH0 jV j/.x/ds:
By a change of variable we furthermore have ..H0 C E/1 jV j/.x/ D
X n0
e nTE
Z
T 0
e sE .e .sCnT /H0 jV j/.x/ds:
By the semigroup property and using the integral kernel e tH0 .x; y/ we derive that ..H0 C E/1 jV j/.x/ Z Z T X nTE nTH0 e dy.e /.x; y/ e sE .e sH0 jV j/.y/ds: D n0
Rd
0
103
Section 3.3 Feynman–Kac formula for Kato-class potentials
Take the supremum with respect y. Then ..H0 C E/1 jV j/.x/ X Z T Z sup e sE .e sH0 jV j/.y/ds e nTE 0
y2Rd
Since
R
Rd .e
n0
nTH0 /.x; y/dy
Z .e
nTH0
Rd
.e nTH0 /.x; y/dy: Rd
D 1, we have
1 /.x; y/dy sup 1 e TE y2Rd
Z
T 0
e sE .e sH0 jV j/.y/ds
1 k.H0 C E/1 jV jk1 : 1 e TE
Taking the supremum, this yields .1 e TE /k.H0 C E/1 jV jk1 Z T sup e sE .e sH0 jV j/.y/ds k.H0 C E/1 jV jk1 : y2Rd
0
Furthermore, trivially we have e
TE
Z
T
.e
sH0
0
Then supy2Rd T 0, hence
Z jV j/.y/ds
RT 0
T
e
sE
0
.e
sH0
Z jV j/.y/ds
T 0
.e sH0 jV j/.y/ds:
.e sH0 jV j/.y/ds is bounded by e TE k.H0 C E/1 jV jk1 , for all Z
T
lim sup
T #0 x2Rd
0
.e sH0 jV j/.x/ds k.H0 C E/1 jV jk1 ;
for all E. Therefore, if limE !1 k.H0 C E/1 jV jk1 D 0, then the right-hand side decreases with E, and optimizing over E implies (3.3.6). Conversely, if we assume (3.3.6), then by the above 1 sup T #0 E !1 1 e TE x2Rd
lim k.H0 C E/1 jV jk1 lim lim
E !1
Z
T 0
.e sH0 jV j/.x/ds D 0;
i.e., (3.3.11) holds. The latter characterization is particularly interesting in view of the following property, which through the KLMN theorem implies that if V is Kato-class, then H is self-adjoint at least in form sense.
104
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Proposition 3.35. If there exist a; b > 0 and 0 < ı < 1 such that for all 0 < " < 1 p p .f; jV jf / "k f k2 C a exp.b ı /kf k2 ; 8f 2 D. /; (3.3.12) p then V 2 K.Rd /. Conversely, if V is Kato-class, then D. / D.V 1=2 / and V is -form bounded with infinitesimally small relative bound. Proof. Suppose (3.3.12). Since . C E/1 jV j.x/ D
Z
1
dt e tE
Z Rd
0
… t .x y/jV j.y/dy;
p we estimate … t .x y/jV .y/j for a fixed x. Let ./ D … t .x /. By the assumption p .; jV j/ "k k2 C a exp.b"ı /kk2 D .; / C a exp.b"ı / ct 2 C a exp.b"ı / with a constant c independent of x. Hence Z 1 Z 1 ˇ ˇ ˇ. C E/1 jV j.x/ˇ C e tE .ct 2 C a exp.b"ı //dt: 0
(3.3.13)
1
Taking " D .1Clog jt j/2=.1Cı/ , we have a exp.b"ı / t b ae b , thus (3.3.11) follows. Conversely, suppose that V is of Kato-class. By duality it is seen that k. C E/1 jV jk1;1 D kjV j. C E/1 k1;1 , where k kp;p denotes bounded operator norm on Lp . Notice that k. C E/1 jV jk1;1 D k. C E/1 jV jk1 . For the operator-valued function F .z/ D jV jz . C E/1 jV j1z on the strip ¹z 2 Cj
V is -form bounded with an infinitesimally small relative bound. Remark 3.1 (Stummel-class). Kato-class defined above can be regarded as the quadratic form analogue of Stummel-class. A potential V is in Stummel class whenever Z lim sup h.x y/jV .y/j2 dy D 0 (3.3.14) r!0 x2Rd
Br .x/
105
Section 3.3 Feynman–Kac formula for Kato-class potentials
holds, where 8 ˆ if d 3; <1; h.x/ D log jxj; if d D 4; ˆ : 4d jxj ; if d > 4:
(3.3.15)
The counterparts of Propositions 3.34 and 3.35 hold similarly. An equivalent condition to (3.1) is lim k. C E/2 jV j2 k1 D 0: E !1
Suppose that there are a; b > 0 and a ı with 0 < ı < 1 such that for all " < 1 and all f 2 D./, kVf k2 "k f k2 C a exp.b"ı /kf k2 : Then V 2 S.Rd /. Remark 3.2. From the perspective of self-adjointness Kato-class is not a natural space, certainly not the largest possible. A well-known example is V .x/ D jxj2 j log jxjj" which is -form bounded with relative bound 0 exactly when " D 0, while it is of Kato-class if and only if " > 1. Rt Proposition 3.33 says that given V 2 K.Rd / one can make Ex Œ 0 V .Bs /ds arbitrarily small by taking t small uniformly in x. R t We will now see that this implies exponential integrability of the random variable 0 V .Bs / ds. The proof of this fact is based on Khasminskii’s lemma which follows directly from the Markov property of Brownian motion but is so useful that we state it as a separate result. First we show a preliminary result. Lemma 3.36. Let f; g W X ! R be functions such that f is F tB -measurable, Ex Œjf j < 1 and supy Ey Œjgj < 1. Let t W X ! X be time shift given by . t !/./ D !.t C / and define t g.!/ D g ı t .!/ D g.!. C t //. Then ˇ x ˇ ˇE Œf gˇ Ex Œjf j sup Ey Œjgj: t y
Proof. Notice that jEx g.BCt /jF tB j D jEB t Œg.B /j supy Ey Œjgj. Since f is F tB -measurable, jEx Œf t gj D jEx Œf Ex Œ t gjF tB j Ex Œjf j sup Ey Œjgj D sup Ey ŒjgjEx Œjf j; y
where we used the Markov property of Brownian motion.
y
106
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Lemma 3.37 (Khasminskii’s lemma). Let V 0 be a measurable function on Rd with the property that for some t > 0 and some ˛ < 1
Z t x sup E V .Bs / ds D ˛: (3.3.16) 0
x2Rd
Then sup Ex Œe
Rt 0
V .Bs / ds
x2Rd
1 : 1˛
(3.3.17)
Proof. By expanding the exponential in (3.3.17), it suffices to show that n
Z t 1 ˛ n sup Ex V .Bs / ds nŠ 0 x
Z t Z t 1 D sup Ex ds1 dsn V .Bs1 / V .Bsn / : nŠ x 0 0 Since there are nŠ ways of ordering ¹s1 ; : : : ; sn º it suffices to prove
Z V .Bs1 / V .Bsn /ds1 dsn ; ˛ n sup Ex x
(3.3.18)
n
where n D ¹.s1 ; : : : ; sn / 2 Rn j0 < s1 < < sn º. For fixed s1 < < sn1 , Lemma 3.36 gives
Z t x E V .Bs1 / V .Bsn1 / V .Bsn / dsn sn1
x
Z
E ŒV .Bs1 / V .Bsn1 / sup E x
x
t
V .Bsn / dsn sn1
˛Ex ŒV .Bs1 / V .Bsn1 / : The result follows by induction and an application of Fubini’s theorem. Now we are in the position to prove exponential integrability of the integral over the potential. As it will be seen below this is essentially all we need to prove the Feynman–Kac formula for Kato-decomposable potentials. When V 2 K .Rd /, it Rt V .B /ds s can be seen that the exponent e 0 is integrable with respect to Wiener measure Rt x V .B /ds s is bounded for all x. so that E Œe 0 Lemma 3.38. Let 0 V 2 K.Rd /. Then there exist ˇ; > 0 such that sup Ex Œe x
Rt 0
V .Bs /
< e ˇ t :
(3.3.19)
107
Section 3.3 Feynman–Kac formula for Kato-class potentials
Furthermore, if V 2 Lp .Rd / with p D 1 for d D 1, and p > d=2 for d 2, then there exists C such that ˇ C kV kp :
(3.3.20)
Rt Proof. There exists t > 0 such that ˛ t D supx Ex Œ 0 V .Bs / < 1, for all t t , and ˛ t ! 0 as t ! 0. By Khasminskii’s lemma we have sup Ex Œe
Rt 0
V .Bs /
1 1 ˛t
<
x
(3.3.21)
for all t t . By means of Lemma 3.36 we obtain x
E Œe
R 2t 0
V .Bs /
x
D E Œe
R t 0
V .Bs /
E
Bt
R t
Œe
0
V .Bs /
1 1 ˛t
2 :
Repeating this procedure we see that x
sup E Œe
Rt 0
V .Bs /
x
1 1 ˛t
Œt=t C1 (3.3.22)
1 for all t > 0, where Œz D max¹w 2 Zjw zº. Set D . 1˛ / and ˇ D t
1 log. 1˛ /1=t . This proves (3.3.19). Next we prove (3.3.20). Suppose V 2 Lp .Rd /. t When d D 1 it follows directly that Z t Z t Ex ŒV .Bs / ds .2s/1=2 dskV k1 : (3.3.23) ˛t D 0
0
1 p
Next we let d 2 and q be such that Z
Z
t
E ŒV .Bs /ds D
0
Z
t
t
x
jyj"
0
C
1 q
D 1. Fix an arbitrary " > 0. We have
Ex ŒV .Bs /1¹jBs xj"º C 1¹jBs xj<"º ds Z
… t .y/V .x C y/dy C e t
1 0
Ex Œe s V .Bs /1¹jBs xj<"º :
It is easy to see that Z
d=2
jyj"
… t .y/V .x C y/dy .2/
Z e
qjyj2 =2
Rd
1=q dy
kV kp :
Let f be the integral kernel of ..1=2/ C 1/1 . Then Z 1 Z dsEx Œe s V .Bs /1¹jBs xj<"º f .x y/V .y/dy: 0
jxyj<"
(3.3.24)
108
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Since jf .z/j Cg.z/ for jzj 12 with some constant C and g given by Definition 3.21, we have Z 1 Z x s dsE Œe V .Bs /1¹jBs xj<"º C g.x y/V .y/dy jxyj<"
0
and then Z 1
x
dsE Œe 0
s
Z V .Bs /1¹jBs xj<"º C
1=q q
g.z/ dy jzj<"
kV kp
(3.3.25)
by the Hölder inequality. Hence from (3.3.23),(3.3.24) Rand (3.3.25) there exists C t ."/ such that ˛ t C t ."/kV kp and lim t!0 C t ."/ D C. jzj<" g.z/q dy/1=q . Thus for 1 sufficiently small T and " we have ˇ . 1CT ."/kV /1=T and then there exists DT kp such that ˇ DT kV kp . This proves (3.3.20).
3.3.2 Feynman–Kac formula for Kato-decomposable potentials When V is Kato-decomposable the operator H is not always an easy object to define. We have seen in the previous section that much functional analytic machinery is needed to decide whether it is essentially self-adjoint and on which domain. The strategy we will adopt here is to define the Feynman–Kac semigroup as given in Definition 3.20 for Kato-decomposable potentials, and identify Schrödinger operators for such potentials as generators of this semigroup. By Lemma 3.38 the map K t W L1 ! L1 is a bounded and linear whenever V is Kato-decomposable. In fact, a yet stronger property holds. Definition 3.22. Let .M; d m/ be a measurable space. T is said to be Lp Lq bounded if there exists D Lp .M / such that it is dense for all 1 p 1, and T dD W Lp .M / ! Lq .M / is bounded for all 1 p q 1. In other words, Tp D T dD
Lp
is bounded from Lp .M / to Lq .M / with domain Lp .M /.
Theorem 3.39 (Lp –Lq boundedness). Let V be Kato-decomposable. Then for every 1 p q 1, the semigroup ¹K t W t 0º as defined by (3.2.3) exists and maps bounded operators from Lp .Rd / to Lq .Rd /. In the proof we will rely on the Riesz–Thorin theorem quoted below. Lemma 3.40 (Riesz–Thorin theorem). Let T W Lpj .Rd / ! Lqj .Rd / be a bounded operator, j D 1; 2 and 1 p1 ; p2 ; q1 ; q2 1. Then T is bounded from Lr .Rd / to Ls .Rd / for every r; s such that ˇ ² ³ ˇ 1 1 1 1 .r; s/ ˇˇ ; D C ; C ;0< <1 : r s p1 p2 q1 q2
Section 3.3 Feynman–Kac formula for Kato-class potentials
109
Proof of Theorem 3.39. By making use of the Riesz–Thorin theorem it suffices to prove that K t is bounded from L1 .Rd / to L1 .Rd /, from L1 .Rd / to L1 .Rd /, and from L1 .Rd / to L1 .Rd /. Boundedness from L1 .Rd / to L1 .Rd / has already been shown in Lemma 3.38. We prove boundedness from L1 .Rd / to L1 .Rd / by using duality. For f 2 L1 .Rd / and g 2 L1 .Rd / we have Z Z Rt f .x/K t g.x/ dx D dxEx Œg.B0 /e 0 V .Bs / ds f .B t /: (3.3.26) Rd
Rd
This follows from (3.2.4) in the proof of Theorem 3.30. By taking g D 1 and reading (3.3.26) from right to left we find kK t f k1 kf k1 kK t 1k1 ; hence K t is bounded from L1 .Rd / to L1 .Rd /. Since K t is bounded from L1 .Rd / to L1 .Rd / and L1 .Rd / to L1 .Rd /, the Riesz–Thorin theorem implies that K t is bounded from Lp .Rd / to Lp .Rd / for all p 1, and by the Markov property of Brownian motion it is a semigroup on all of these spaces. It remains to show that K t is bounded from L1 .Rd / to L1 .Rd /. Consider the diagram Kt
Kt
L1 .Rd / ! L2 .Rd / ! L1 .Rd /:
(3.3.27)
Assume first that f 2 L2 .Rd /. Then by Schwarz inequality kK t f k21 sup.Ex Œe 2 x
Rt 0
V .Bs / ds
Ex Œf .B t /2 /:
The first factor above is bounded by the Khasminskii lemma, while the second is R 2 bounded due to Ex Œf .B t /2 D .2 t /d=2 Rd f .y/2 ejxyj =2t dy. Hence K t W L2 .Rd / ! L1 .Rd / and kK t f k1 C kf k2 . Now for 0 f 2 L1 .Rd / choose g 2 L2 .Rd /, and by a similar reasoning as in (3.3.26) we find Z Z .K t f / .x/g.x/ dx D f .x/ .K t g/ .x/ dx kK t gk1 kf k1 : Rd
Rd
This can be extended to any f 2 L2 .Rd / by separating f D .
Hence K t f 2 L2 .Rd / for f 2 L1 .Rd /, and for f 2 L1 .Rd / we have kK t f k1 D kK t=2 K t=2 f k1 C kK t=2 f k2 CQ kf k1 : Therefore K t maps L1 .Rd / to L1 .Rd / and the proof is complete.
110
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Theorem 3.41. Let V be Kato-decomposable and f 2 Lp .Rd / for 1 p 1. Then for every t > 0, K t f is a continuous function. Proof. First we make a preliminary observation. In the proof of Lemma 3.37 we have x
sup E Œj1 e
Rt 0
V .Bs / ds
x
k
Z t 1 X 1 x sup E j jV .Bs /j ds kŠ x 0 kD1 Rt supx Ex Œ 0 jV .Bs /jds t!0 ! 0 Rt 1 supx Ex Œ 0 jV .Bs /jds
(3.3.28)
by Proposition 3.33. Notice that the Khasminskii lemma implies that for small enough T, sup sup Ex Œe
Rt 0
jV .Bs /j ds
x 0tT
< 1:
(3.3.29)
We can now proceed to prove the theorem. Since K t f D K t=2 K t=2 f and K t=2 f 2 f 2 L1 .Rd /. L1 .Rd / whenever f 2 Lp .Rd /, 1 p 1, it suffices to consider Rt First assume V 2 K.Rd /. For every > 0, g .x/ D Ex Œe V .Bs / ds f .B t / is a continuous function with respect to x. In fact, since g.xn / g.x/ D E0 Œe and, since f and e
Rt 0
Rt
V .xn CBs / ds
V .CBs /ds
lim E0 Œe
Rt
f .xn C B t / E0 Œe
Rt
V .xCBs / ds
f .x C B t /;
are bounded it suffices to show that
V .xn CBs / ds
n!1
e
Rt
V .xCBs / ds
D 0;
(3.3.30)
and lim E0 Œf .xn C B t / f .x C B t / Z 2 d=2 D lim .2 t / e tjyj jf .xn C y/ f .x C y/jdy D 0:
n!1
n!1
Rd
(3.3.31)
Here (3.3.30) follows from the dominated convergence theorem and (3.3.31) can be easily proven. We have kg K t f k1 D sup Ex Œ.1 e
R 0
V .Bs / ds
/e
Rt
V .Bs / ds
x
kf k1 sup sup Ex Œe x rt
Rr 0
V .Bs / ds
sup Ex Œ1 e x
R 0
f .B t /
V .Bs / ds !0
! 0:
In the last line we have used Lemma 3.36 and (3.3.28)–(3.3.31). Thus we find that K t f is continuous as a uniform limit of continuous functions.
111
Section 3.3 Feynman–Kac formula for Kato-class potentials
Next, let V be Kato-decomposable, and consider for R > 0 the function VR with VR .x/ D V .x/ if jxj R and V .x/ D 0 otherwise. Then VR 2 K.Rd / and the above reasoning applies. Let M BR .0/R be compact, where R t BR .0/ denotes the ball t of radius R centered at the origin. Then 0 VR .Bs / ds D 0 V .Bs / ds for each path ! 2 X starting in M and not leaving the ball up to time t . Hence sup jEx Œe
Rt 0
x2M
sup Ex Œe
V .Bs / ds Rt 0
x2M
sup .Ex Œe 2 x2M
f .B t / Ex Œe
V .Bs / ds
Rt 0
Rt 0
VR .Bs / ds
f .B t /j
f .B t /1¹sup0st jBs jRº
V .Bs / ds
jf .B t /j2 /1=2 .Ex Œ1¹sup0st jBs jRº /1=2 :
The first factor above is bounded since V is Kato decomposable, the second goes to zero as R ! 1 by Lévy’s maximal inequality Ex Œ1¹sup0st jBs jRº 2Ex Œ1¹jB t j>Rº : Hence K t f is a locally uniform limit of continuous functions. The last part of the above argument is of some independent interest, so we single it out. Corollary 3.42. Let V be Kato-decomposable and f 2 Lp .Rd / with 1 p 1. Then e tH f is the local uniform limit of a sequence e tHn f with Hn D 12 C Vn and Vn with compact support. One possible choice for Vn in the corollary above is 1¹xWjxjnº V . In particular, each Vn is in K.Rd / as opposed to being only Kato-decomposable. We are now ready to define H with Kato-class potential as a self-adjoint operator and give the Feynman–Kac formula for e tH . Theorem 3.43 (Feynman–Kac formula with Kato-decomposable potentials). Assume that V is Kato-decomposable. Then ¹K t W t 0º as defined by (3.2.3) is a symmetric C0 -semigroup on L2 .Rd /. Moreover, there exists a unique self-adjoint operator K bounded from below such that K t D e tK , for every t 0. Proof. We already know that K t is a semigroup of bounded operators on L2 .Rd /, and .g; K t f / D .K t g; f / can be proven in the same as (3.2.4). To see strong continuity, by denseness it suffices to prove kK t f f k ! 0 as t ! 0 for all bounded L2 functions f with compact support. Let Q t D e t=2 . Then kQ t f f k ! 0 as t ! 0. We only need to show that x 7! K t f .x/ Q t f .x/ D Ex Œ.e
Rt 0
V .Bs / ds
1/f .B t /
112
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
converges to 0 in L2 .Rd / as t ! 0. Using the proof of Theorem 3.41 and Corollary 3.42 it follows that K t f Q t f ! 0 as t ! 0 pointwise in Rd . Moreover, .K t f .x/ Q t f .x//2 Ex Œ.e
Rt 0
V .Bs / ds
1/2 Ex Œf .B t /2 :
Here, the first factor is bounded uniformly in t and x by Lemma 3.38, while the t -supremum over the second one is bounded and exponentially decaying at infinity, thus integrable. Thus K t f Q t f ! 0 in L2 .Rd / by the dominated convergence theorem. Hence by the triangle inequality kK t f f k kK t f Q t f k C kQ t f f k the statement follows. Furthermore, by the Hille–Yoshida theorem there exists a unique self-adjoint operator K bounded from below such that K t D e tK , for every t 0. Definition 3.23 (Schrödinger operator for Kato-decomposable potentials). We call the self-adjoint operator K in Theorem 3.43 Schrödinger operator for Kato-decomposable potentials V . Remark 3.3 (Fractional Schrödinger operator). Using the fractional Laplacian (3.3) it is possible similarly to define fractional Schrödinger operators ./˛=2 C V . Similarly to Kato-class one can define also fractional Kato-class by using the potential kernels of the fractional Laplacian. A Feynman–Kac-type formula similarly holds for this class replacing Brownian motion with symmetric ˛-stable processes.
3.4
Properties of Schrödinger operators and semigroups
3.4.1 Kernel of the Schrödinger semigroup From the perspective of functional analysis and the theory of partial differential equations it is a crucial point that for every t > 0 the operator e tH has an integral kernel given by the Feynman–Kac formula. This is addressed in the next theorem. Theorem 3.44. Let V be a Kato-decomposable potential. Then e tK is an integral operator in Lp .Rd / for every 1 p 1. Moreover, the integral kernel Rd Rd 3 .x; y/ 7! K t .x; y/ is jointly continuous in x and y, and is given by Z Rt x;y (3.4.1) K t .x; y/ D … t .x y/ e 0 V .Bs / ds d WŒ0;t : x;y
Here WŒ0;t is Brownian bridge measure defined in (2.2.28). Rt
Proof. By Theorem 3.43 we have .e tK f /.x/ D Ex Œe 0 V .Bs / ds f .B t /, for every f 2 Lp .Rd /, and by Theorem 3.41 the above equality holds pointwise as the righthand side is a continuous function. Thus Z Z Rt x;y tK .e f /.x/ D … t .x y/f .y/dy e 0 V .Bs / ds d WŒ0;t ; Rd
113
Section 3.4 Properties of Schrödinger operators and semigroups
which shows that (3.4.1) holds for all x and almost all y. Next we show continuity. Let s D t =3. Then Z K t .x; y/ D Ks .x; v/Ks .v; w/Ks .w; y/ dw dv Rd Z D Ks .x; v/Ks .y; w/Ks .v; w/ dw dv: Rd
The product .x;v/;.y;w/
Ks .x; v/Ks .y; w/ D EŒ0;s
Œe
Rs
.1/ .2/ 0 .V .Br /CV .Br // dr
is the kernel of the Schrödinger operator with Kato-class potential 1 1 KQ D x y C V .x/ C V .y/; 2 2 and .x; y/ 7! V .x/ C V .y/ is Kato-decomposable in R2d since V is in Rd , where .i/ B t , i D 1; 2, denote two independent d -dimensional Brownian motions. On the other hand, the function .v; w/ 7! Ks .v; w/ is bounded. One way to see this is to recall that e sK is bounded from L1 .Rd / to L1 .Rd / and that supv;w jKs .v; w/j D supf 2L1 .Rd /;kf k1 D1 ke tK f k1 < 1. Hence Q
K t .x; y/ D .e t K Ks /.x; y/ with Ks 2 L1 .Rd Rd / and is thus jointly continuous in x and y by Theorem 3.41. The above proof has the virtue of simplicity; using more sophisticated arguments, it can be shown that K t .x; y/ is even jointly continuous in x; y and t for t > 0.
3.4.2 Number of eigenfunctions with negative eigenvalues In this section we will prove the Lieb–Thirring inequality giving an estimate on the number of eigenfunctions in the level sets of negative eigenvalues of a Schrödinger operator. From the point of view of quantum mechanics these eigenfunctions describe bound states. Let 1./ .T / be the spectral resolution of self-adjoint operator T , and for E 0 define NE .V / D dim 1.1;E .H / D #¹eigenvalues of .1=2/ C V below Eº: Theorem 3.45 (Lieb–Thirring inequality). Suppose d 3 and V 2 Ld=2 .Rd /. Then there exists a constant ad independent of V such that Z N0 .V / ad jV .x/jd=2 dx: Rd
114
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Before proving Theorem 3.45 we briefly discuss the Birman–Schwinger principle. Recall the kernel of C m2 introduced in (3.3.9). Let Cm .x; y/ denote the integral kernel of the operator C m2 , which is the Green function defined by . C m2 /Cm .x; y/ D ı.x y/: Alternatively, by Fourier transform Cm .x; y/ D Cm .x y/ D .2/d=2
Z Rd
e ip.xy/ dp: jpj2 C m2
As it was seen in (3.3.9) this can be computed explicitly: Cm .x/ D .2/
d=2
m jxj
.d 2/=2 K.d 2/=2 .mjxj/;
(3.4.2)
where K .x/ > 0 is the modified Bessel function of the third kind. The fact ´ Cm .x/ D
e mjxj 2m ; e mjxj ; 4 jxj
d D 1; d D3
is well known. Many properties of the covariance operator Cm .x; y/ can be deduced from (3.4.2) and the known properties of Bessel functions such as a singularity in the jx yj ! 0 limit and exponential decay as mjx yj ! 1. Here we summarize the properties of Cm .x; y/. Proposition 3.46. The covariance Cm .x; y/ D Cm .x y/ has the following properties: .1/ Cm .x; y/ > 0 mjxyj
e .2/ for mjx yj > 0, Cm .x; y/ const m.d 3/=2 jxyj .d 1/=2 , d 3 ² jx yjd C2 ; d 3; .3/ for mjx yj 0, Cm .x; y/ log.mjx yj/; d D 2
.4/ limm!0 Cm .x; y/ D
1 .d=21/ 1 , 4 d=2 jxyjd 2
d 3.
We now look at potentials V for which V 1=2 . C m2 /1 V 1=2 is a compact operator, i.e., when V is form compact with respect to . Lemma 3.47. Let 0 V 2 Lq .Rd / with q D d=2 for d 3, q > 1 for d D 2 and q D 1 for d D 1. Then K D V 1=2 . C m2 /1 V 1=2 is a compact operator with m 0 for d 3 and m > 0 for d D 1; 2.
Section 3.4 Properties of Schrödinger operators and semigroups
115
Proof. In the case of d D 1; 2 it is trivial to see that Z jV .x/jCm .x y/2 jV .y/jdxdy C kV kp2 : Rd Rd
Then K is a Hilbert–Schmidt operator. In case when d D 3 Cm .x y/ C0 .x y/ D Then we have
1 1 : 4 jx yj
Z R3 R3
jV .x/jCm .x y/2 jV .y/jdxdy C kV k23=2
by the Hardy–Littlewood–Sobolev inequality. In the case of d 4 we show an outline of the proof. It suffices to show compactp ness for m D 0. Let Lw .Rd / be the set of Lebesgue measurable functions u such that d supˇ >0 ˇj¹x 2 R jju.x/ > ˇºj1=p < 1, where jEj denotes Lebesgue measure of p E. Let g 2 Lp .Rd / and u 2 Lw .Rd / for 2 < p < 1. Define the operator Bu;g by Z d=2 e ikx u.k/g.x/h.x/dx: Bu;g h.k/ D .2/ Rd
It can be shown that Bu;g is a compact operator on L2 .Rd / and u.k/ D 2jkj1 2 Ldw .Rd / for d 3. Let F denote Fourier transform on L2 .Rd /, and suppose that V 2 Ld=2 .Rd /. Then Bu;jV j1=2 is compact and hence so is ./1=2 jV j1=2 D FBu;V 1=2 . Thus also jV j1=2 ./1 jV j1=2 is compact. We assume in what follows that V .x/ D W .x/ 0 and V is form compact with respect to . Let H. / D H0 W , where H0 D .1=2/. It can be seen that for
> 0 we have H. / D if and only if W 1=2 .H0 C /1 W 1=2 ' D .1= /', where ' D W 1=2 . Put K D W 1=2 .H0 C /1 W 1=2 :
(3.4.3)
This is the so called Birman–Schwinger kernel, for which 2 Spec.H. // ” 1= 2 Spec.K /
(3.4.4)
holds. Since W is .1=2/-form compact, Specess .H. // D RC . Let ej . / < 0 be the j th negative eigenvalue of H. /, and ei . / D 0 if NE . V / i 1. Then 7! ej . / is continuous and strictly decreasing in the region ¹ jej . / < 0º. Hence for E < 0, NE .V / D #¹i j ei .1/ Eº D #¹i j ei . / D E; 9 1º D dim 1Œ1;1/ .KE /: (3.4.5)
116
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Proposition 3.48 (Birman–Schwinger principle). Suppose that V 0 and it is relatively form compact. Then NE .V / D dim 1Œ1;1/ .KE /; E < 0; d 1; N0 .V / dim 1Œ1;1/ .K0 /;
(3.4.6)
E D 0; d 3:
Proof. For E < 0 relation (3.4.6) follows from (3.4.5). To obtain the result for E D 0 note that KE K0 and N0 .V / D limE #0 NE .V /. The Birman–Schwinger principle has the following immediate implication. Corollary 3.49. Let d 3. Suppose that V is .1=2/-form compact and the operator norm of KD0 is kK0 k < 1. Then .1=2/ C V has no ground state. Proof. By the Birman–Schwinger principle we have N0 .V / dim 1Œ1;1/ .K0 / D 0, and Specess ..1=2/ C V / D Œ0; 1/. Then the corollary follows. We will estimate NE .V / from above. It can be seen directly that W 1=2 .H0 C W C /1 W 1=2 D K .1 C K /1 :
(3.4.7)
On the other hand, the integral kernel of W
1=2
1
.H0 C W C /
Z W
1=2
DW
1
1=2
e t e t.H0 CW / W 1=2 dt
0
is given by using the conditional Wiener measure, (3.4.8) .W 1=2 .H0 C W C /1 W 1=2 /.x; y/ Z 1 Z Rt x;y e t dt d WŒ0;t e 0 W .Bs /ds … t .x y/: D W 1=2 .x/W 1=2 .y/ 0
Let g.y/ D e y and F .x/ D x.1 C x/1 , i.e., Z 1 F .x/ D x e y g.xy/dy:
(3.4.9)
0
Then together with (3.4.7), (3.4.8) can be reformulated as F .K /.x; y/ DW
1=2
.x/W
Z 1=2
1
.y/
e 0
t
Z dt
x;y d WŒ0;t g
Z
t 0
W .Bs /ds … t .x y/: (3.4.10)
117
Section 3.4 Properties of Schrödinger operators and semigroups
Moreover, when W is continuous, the right-hand side of (3.4.8) is continuous in x and y. Then by a general result Tr F .K / can be evaluated by setting x D y. Hence Z Tr F .K / D
1
e t dt
Z
Z dxW .x/ Rd
0
Z x;x d WŒ0;t g
t
W .Bs /ds … t .0/:
0
(3.4.11) Lemma 3.50. Suppose that W is .1=2/-form compact and continuous, and let f .y/ D yg.y/ D ye y . Then it follows that Z Tr F .K / D
1
0
Z
dt t e t
Z dx
Rd
Z x;x d WŒ0;t f
t
W .Bs /ds … t .0/: (3.4.12) 0
Proof. It suffices to show that 1 t
Z
Z dx Rd
Z x;x d W0;t
Z D
Z dxW .x/
Rd
t
W .Bs /ds e
0
Z
x;x d W0;t
t
Rt 0
W .Bs /ds
… t .0/
Rt W .Bs /ds e 0 W .Bs /ds … t .0/:
(3.4.13)
0
Let Ur D e rH./ W e .tr/H./ . Note that Ur is compact. Its integral kernel can be computed as .Ur f /.x/ D Ex Œe
Rr 0
W .Bs /ds
W .Br /EBr Œe
R t r 0
W .Bs /ds
f .B tr /
Rt
D Ex Œe 0 W .Bs /ds W .Br /f .B t / Z Z Rt x;y D dy… t .x y/ d W0;t e 0 W .Bs /ds W .Br /f .y/: Rd
Rt R x;y Hence Ur .x; y/ D … t .x y/ d W0;t e 0 W .Bs /ds W .Br / and thus
Z Tr Ur D
Z dx Rd
x;x d W0;t e
Rt 0
W .Bs /ds
W .Br /… t .0/:
(3.4.14)
From the identity Tr Ur D Tr U0 it follows that Z
t 0
1 Tr Ur dr D Tr U0 : t
Inserting (3.4.14) into (3.4.15) yields thus (3.4.13).
(3.4.15)
118
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Furthermore, a more general formula holds. Lemma 3.51. Let W 2 Lp .Rd / with p D d=2 for d 3, p > 1 for d D 2, and p D 1 for d D 1 with W > 0. Suppose > 0 for d D 1; 2, and 0 for d 3. Let f be a non-negative lower semicontinuous function on RC with f .0/ D 0 and let f; g; F be related by (3.4.9) and f .y/ D g.y/y. Then Z t Z 1 Z Z dt t x;x Tr F .K / D e dx d WŒ0;t f W .Bs /ds … t .0/ (3.4.16) t Rd 0 0 Z t Z 1 Z Z x;x t D dt e dxW .x/ d WŒ0;t g W .Bs /ds … t .0/: Rd
0
0
(3.4.17) P W is bounded from below. See Proof. Note that W 2 Lp .Rd / implies that 12 C Example 3.11. We divide the proof into six steps. In Steps 1–3 we suppose that > 0 and f is continuous with a compact support Œa; b with a > 0. In this proof we assume that d 3. In the case where d D 1; 2 the proof is similar. R1 Step 1: Suppose first that W 2 C01 .Rd /. Since F .x/ D 0 e z=x g.z/dz, F is linear with respect to g. The sum of functions of the form g.y/ D e y is dense in the space of continuous functions on Œ0; 1/ vanishing at infinity. By a limiting argument (3.4.10) follows for any continuous g with compact support. Since the right-hand side of (3.4.10) is jointly continuous in x and y, Tr.F .K // is given by (3.4.17) or (3.4.16) by Lemma 3.50. Step 2: Suppose W 2 L1 .Rd / with compact support. Then there exists a sequence Wn 2 C01 .Rd / and a bounded set S Rd such that Wn a1S with some a, Wn ! W in Ld=2 .Rd / and Wn ! W almost everywhere as n ! 1. Thus K .Wn / ! K .W / in the operator norm, so that F .K .Wn // ! F .K .W // also in the operator norm, which implies that Tr F .K .Wn // ! Tr F .K .W //. We next show the convergence of the right-hand side of (3.4.17). Let h be defined by g.x/ D x m h.x/. Note that suppg Œa; b and a > 0. Then khk1 < 1. Note also that Z t Z t e t Wn .x/g Wn .Bs /ds … t .0/ e t a1S .x/g a1S .Bs /ds … t .0/: 0
We have Z t Z t dt e 0
khk1
Z 0
Z Rd
t
0
dxa1S .x/
dt e t
Z Rd
khk1 amC1 .2/d=2
Z x;x d W0;t
t
m Z t a1S .Bs /ds h a1S .Bs /ds … t .0/
0
dxamC1 1S .x/t m … t .0/ Z
t 0
dt e t t m t d=2 < 1:
0
Section 3.4 Properties of Schrödinger operators and semigroups
119
R t Hence e t a1S .x/g 0 a1S .Bs /ds … t .0/ is L1 .RC Rd X /. Thus (3.4.17) follows by the dominated convergence theorem. By a similar limiting argument (3.4.16) also follows. Step 3: Suppose that W 2 Ld=2 .Rd /. Let Wn 2 L1 .Rd / with compact support such that Wn " W . Since F is a monotone function and the eigenvalues ej .n/, j D 1; 2; : : : , of K .Wn / are monotone with respect to n, we have Tr F .K .Wn // ! Tr F .K .W // by the monotone convergenceR theorem. Let h.x/ D x m k.x/ such that 1 h g and kkk1 < 1, and H.x/ D x 0 e y h.xy/dy. Hence (3.4.16) holds with g and F replaced by h and H , respectively. Note that Tr Km < 1 as long as R1 m > d=2. Since H.x/ x mC1 kkk1 0 e y y m dy, Z Tr H.K / kkk1
0
1
e y y m dy Tr Km < 1
follows. Then (3.4.17) follows by the dominated convergence theorem, and (3.4.16) follows in the same way as (3.4.17). Step 4: Suppose that W is as in Step 3 and f is continuous. Let fn D f 1Œn;n . By the monotone convergence theorem again it follows that limn Tr Fn .K / D Tr F .K / and Z t Z 1 Z Z dt t x;x lim e dx d WŒ0;t fn W .Bs /ds n t Rd 0 0 Z t Z 1 Z Z dt t x;x D e dx d WŒ0;t f W .Bs /ds : t Rd 0 0 Then (3.4.16) follows and (3.4.17) is similarly proven. Step 5: Suppose that W is as in Step 3 and f is a non-negative lower semicontinuous function on RC with f .0/ D 0, and f , g and F are related by (3.4.9). Since any lower semicontinuous function is a monotone limit continuous function, Fn D R 1 y R 1 of y f .xy/dy=y monotonously. e f .xy/dy=y also converges to F D e n 0 0 Hence limn Tr Fn .K / D Tr F .K / by the monotone convergence theorem, and also R Rt R1 R x;x t limn 0 dt Rd dx d WŒ0;t fn . 0 W .Bs /ds/ converges to the right-hand side t e of (3.4.16) by the monotone convergence theorem. (3.4.17) can be also proven in the same way as (3.4.16). Step 6: Make the same assumptions as in Step 5, moreover suppose that 0. It suffices to check the case of D 0, which is readily given by the monotone convergence theorem. This completes the proof. Proof of Theorem 3.45. Notice that F is monotone increasing, thus F .x/=F .1/ 1, for x 1. Let f .y/ D yg.y/ and F be related by (3.4.9), and f be convex. Then by
120
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Lemma 3.51 we have N0 .V / Tr F .K0 /=F .1/ Z t Z Z Z 1 ds dt x;x D F .1/1 … t .0/ dx d WŒ0;t f tW .Bs / t Rd t 0 0 Z Z t Z Z 1 dt ds x;x F .1/1 dx d WŒ0;t f .tW .Bs // … t .0/; d t t R 0 0 where we used Jensen’s inequality. By using the definition of Brownian bridge Z Z x;x d WŒ0;t h.Bs / D dyh.y/…s .x y/… ts .y x/=… t .0/ Rd
the right-hand side above can be computed as Z 1 Z Z t Z dt ds 1 dx dyf .tW .y//…s .x y/… ts .y x/ F .1/ t Rd Rd 0 0 t Z Z Z 1 dt t ds 1 D F .1/ dyf .tW .y//… t .0/ t 0 t Rd 0 Z 1 Z 1 d=2 1 d=2 D F .1/ .2/ t t dt dyf .tW .y//: Rd
0
Changing the variable t to s=W .y/, we furthermore have Z Z 1 Z F .1/1 .2/d=2 f .s/s 1 s d=2 ds W .y/d=2 dy D ad 0
where ad D F .1/1 .2/d=2
R1 0
Rd
W .y/d=2 dy; Rd
f .s/s 1 s d=2 ds.
Remark 3.4. In the case of d D 1 or 2 the operator H D .1=2/ C V with V 0 (not identically zero) has at least one negative eigenvalue. The operator norm of the compact operator K goes to infinity as " 0. This may be compared with the case of d 3 where by the Lieb–Thirring inequality there are no negative eigenvalues if kV kd=2 is sufficiently small.
3.4.3 Positivity improving and uniqueness of ground state We have seen in the preceding section how to use the Feynman–Kac formula to derive the properties of the semigroup e tH . Here we give some examples of another application. We explain below how to use it to study eigenfunctions of e tH which are obviously also eigenfunctions of H . This last fact makes them important for quantum physics through the Schrödinger eigenvalue equation H D E . A detailed study of ground states in models of quantum field theory through Feynman–Kac formulae will be further done in Part II of the book.
121
Section 3.4 Properties of Schrödinger operators and semigroups
Definition 3.24 (Ground state). Let E.H / D inf Spec.H /. An eigenfunction satisfying H ‰p D E.H /‰p is called a ground state of H , and the bottom of the spectrum E.H / is called ground state energy. The non-negative integer m.H / D dim Ker.H E.H //
(3.4.18)
is called the multiplicity of the ground state. If m.H / D 1, the ground state is said to be unique. The simplest but very useful fact is Rthat e tH .x; y/ is strictly positive. This is t readily implied by (3.4.1) whenever e 0 V .Bs /ds is strictly positive for almost every ! 2 X . In particular, e tH is positivity improving in the sense of the following definition. Definition 3.25 (Positivity preserving/improving operator). Let .M; / be a -finite measure space. .1/ A non-zero function f 2 L2 .M; d/ is called positive if f 0 -almost everywhere. Moreover, f is called strictly positive if f > 0 -almost everywhere. .2/ A bounded operator A on L2 .M; d/ is called a positivity preserving operator if .f; Ag/ 0, for all positive f; g 2 L2 .M; d/. A is called a positivity improving operator if .f; Ag/ > 0, for all positive f; g 2 L2 .M; d/. R Example 3.17. Since e t f .x/ D Rd … t .x/f .x/dx, the operator e t is positivity improving. Moreover, e ia.ir/ is a positivity preserving operator, as it produces the shift e ia.ir/ f .x/ D f .x a/. Positivity preserving operators of the form e tE.ir/ have a deep connection with Lévy processes. As it was seen in Example 2.15, the square root of the Laplacian generates a stable Lévy process. The Lévy–Khintchine formula (2.4.6) has the following important relationship with positivity preserving operators. Proposition 3.52. Let E W Rd ! C. .1/ Suppose that the real part of E is bounded from below. Then (a)–(d) below are equivalent: (a) e tE.ir/ is a positivity preserving semigroup. (b) e tE.u/ is a positive definite distribution, i.e., for all 2 C01 .Rd / we have R R tE.u/ .x u/.x/dudx 0. Rd Rd e (c) E.u/ D E.u/, and it is conditionally negative definite, i.e., n X
E.pi pj /Nzi zj 0;
i;j D1
for any n 2 N, z D .z1 ; : : : ; zn / 2 C n with
Pn
iD1 zi
D 0.
122
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
(d) There exists a triplet .b; A; /, where b 2 Rd , A is a positive definite symmetric matrix, and is a Lévy measure such that Z 1 E.u/ D a C i u b u Au C .e iuy 1 i u y1¹jyj1 º/.dy/ 2 Rd n¹0º (3.4.19) with some a 2 R. .2/ Suppose that E is a spherically symmetric and polynomially bounded continuous function with E.0/ D 0 and real part bounded from below. Suppose, moreover, that E in distributional sense is positive definite. Then E is conditionally negative definite. Write E.u/ D
p u2 C m2 m;
m 0I
then by a straightforward calculation u E.u/ D .d 1/.juj2 C m2 /1=2 C m2 .juj2 C m2 /3=2 : R1 2 2 2 Since .juj2 C m2 /ˇ D dˇ 0 t ˇ 1 e t.juj Cm / dt and e tjuj is positive definite, we conclude by Proposition 3.52 that E.u/ is conditionally negative definite, which implies that E.u/ can be represented as in (3.4.19). Since the left-hand side is real and E.u/=juj2 ! 0 as juj ! 0, its Lévy triplet is .b; A; / D .0; 0; /. Thus we have Z q 2 2 juj C m C m D .e iuy 1 i u y1¹jyj<1º /.dy/: (3.4.20) jyj>0
The following result gives the Feynman–Kac formula for e E.ir/ . Proposition 3.53. Let .X t / t0 be a Lévy process with characteristic triplet .0; 0; / in (3.4.20). Then Z tE.ir/ .g; e f / D E Œg.x/f .x C X t /dx: The Lévy measure in (3.4.20) can be determined exactly. The integral kernel of the operator e tE.ir/ is given by the Fourier transform F e tE.u/ F 1 and thus p m .d C1/=2 tK .m jx yj2 C t 2 / .d C1/=2 ; (3.4.21) e tE.ir/ .x; y/ D 2 2 .t 2 C jx yj2 /.d C1/=4 where Kd is the modified Bessel function of the third kind. Note that Kd .z/ 1 1 d as jzj # 0. Hence 2 .d /. 2 z/ 1 Œ.g; f / .g; e tE.ir/ f / t!0 t .d C1/=2Z Z q m .g.x/ g.y//.f .x/ f .y// 2 D K .d C1/=2 m jx yj dxdy .d C1/=2 2 jx yj Rd Rd
.g; E.i r/f / D lim
123
Section 3.4 Properties of Schrödinger operators and semigroups
In the case of m D 0, the integral form of .g; E.i r/f / is given by .g; E.i r/f / D
..d C 1/=2/ 2 .d C1/=2
Z Rd
Z Rd
.g.x/ g.y//.f .x/ f .y// dxdy: jx yjd C1
Hence it is seen that the Lévy measure associated with E.u/ for m D 0 is 1 1 d C1 1 .dy/ D .d C1/=2 dy 2 jyjd C1 and for m > 0 m 1 .dy/ D 2
m .d C1/=2 1 K.d C1/=2 .mjyj/dy: .d 2 jyj C1/=2
(3.4.22)
Remark 3.5. Let ˛ .dy/ D
1 2˛ . d C˛ 2 / dy; ˛ d=2 d C˛ j. /j 2 jyj
0 < ˛ < 2;
where .x/ D x1 .1 x/ for x > 0. Then the Lévy process .X t / t0 with triplet .0; 0; ˛ / is a stable process with index ˛ and its generator is ./˛=2 . A useful application of the operator positivity properties is to show uniqueness of the ground state of self-adjoint operators. Theorem 3.54 (Perron–Frobenius). Let .M; / be a -finite measure space and K be a self-adjoint operator bounded from below in L2 .M; d/. Suppose that inf Spec.K/ is an eigenvalue and e K is positivity improving. Then inf Spec.K/ is non-degenerate and the eigenfunction corresponding to the eigenvalue inf Spec.K/ is strictly positive. Proof. Put D inf Spec.K/. Then ke K k D e . Let f be an eigenvector corresponding to the eigenvalue . Since e K maps real-valued functions to real-valued functions, 0 and f > 0. Thus e kf k2 D .e K f; f / .e K jf j; jf j/ ke K kkf k2 D e kf k2 ; implying .e K f; f / D .e K jf j; jf j/. This further implies .e K f C ; f / D .e K f ; f C /:
(3.4.23)
124
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Since f C , f , e K f C and e K f are all nonnegative, both sides of (3.4.23) must vanish, and this can only happen if either f C or f vanish almost everywhere as e K improves positivity. Hence f has a definite sign and, for instance, f 0 can be assumed. However, since f D e K e C f , f is even strictly positive. The above reasoning applies to any eigenvector corresponding to the eigenvalue . This shows that there cannot be two linearly independent such eigenvectors since then they could be chosen orthogonal which is impossible as they both would have to be strictly positive. Hence f is unique. Theorem 3.55 (Uniqueness of ground state). Suppose that there exists t > 0 such that Z Rt W x .e 0 V .Bs /ds D 0/dx D 0: (3.4.24) Rd
Then the ground state of H is unique. In particular, for VC 2 L1loc .Rd /, H has the unique ground state whenever it exists. R Proof. Since e .t=2/ is positivity improving, Rd dxEx Œf .B0 /g.B t / > 0 for any positive f and g. Then the measure ofR M D ¹.x; !/ 2 Rd X j f .x/g.B t .!/ C t x/ > 0º is positive. By (3.4.24), e 0 V .Bs Cx/ds > 0 for almost every .x; !/ 2 Rd X . Then Z Rt tH .f; e g/ D dxEŒf .x/g.B t C x/e 0 V .Bs Cx/ds Rd Z Rt dxd W f .x/g.B t C x/e 0 V .Bs Cx/ds > 0; M
and the theorem follows from the Perron–Frobenius theorem, R R t Theorem 3.54. For VC 2 L1loc .Rd /, it is seen in Lemma 3.32 that Rd dxW x . 0 VC .Bs /ds D 1/ D 0, which implies (3.4.24).
3.4.4 Degenerate ground state and Klauder phenomenon Now we turn to presenting an example where e tH is not positivity improving. To break positivity down we construct a potential V such that Z Rt dxW x .e 0 V .Bs /ds D 0/ > 0: Rd
This requires of the potential V to be singular in a suitable form. Let M1 D ¹x D .x1 ; x2 ; x3 / 2 R3 jx3 > 0º; M2 D ¹x D .x1 ; x2 ; x3 / 2 R3 jx3 < 0º; M D M1 [ M 2 :
125
Section 3.4 Properties of Schrödinger operators and semigroups
Define 1 1 H./ D C jxj2 C : 2 2 jx @M j3
(3.4.25)
Here @M is the boundary of M and jx @M j denotes the distance between x and @M . Since the potential in (3.4.25) is singular, self-adjointness of H./, 6D 0, is unclear. To see this we use the following general result. Proposition 3.56. Let D be an open set in Rd and V 0 on D. Suppose that there is a P uniform Lipshitz continuous function h on every compact subset of D such that .1/ diD1 .@i h/2 e 2h on D, .2/ limx!@D h.x/ D 1 (if D is not bounded, 1 is regarded as a point of @D), .3/ there exists ı > 0 such that .f; . C V /f / .1 C ı/.f; e 2h f / for f 2 C01 .D/. Then C V is essentially self-adjoint on C01 .D/. Lemma 3.57. H is essentially self-adjoint on C01 .M /, for all 2 R. Proof. Let
´ V" .x/ D
=jx @M j3 C 12 jxj2 ; jx @M j < " otherwise: ="3 C 12 jxj2 ;
Since V D V" C T , where T is a bounded operator, it suffices to show that C 2V" 1=2 is essentially self-adjoint on C01 .M /. Define h D log V" . h can be directly shown to satisfy (2)P and (3) in Proposition 3.56. We shall check (1). (1) is equivalent to 3 0 4V" 3iD1 .@i V" /2 . For jx @M j ", it is immediate to see that 4V"3 P3 2 iD1 .@i V" / > 0 for sufficiently small ". We have for jx @M j < ", 3 X 9 2 1 2 3 1 3 2 2 4V" .@i V" / 4 C jxj C jxj : jx @M j3 2 2 jx @M j8 iD1
Take sufficiently small ". Then the right hand side is positive, and the lemma follows. Since H.0/ H./, we have n .H.0// n .H.//, where n .K/ D
sup
inf
1 ;:::;n1
2D.K/;k kD1 2Œ1 ;:::;n1 ?
. ; K /:
By the fact that n .H.0// D n C 12 it is seen that n .H.// ! 1 as n ! 1. In particular, by the min-max principle H./ has a purely discrete spectrum. Further by Theorem 3.31 we have .f; e tH. / g/ Z
Z D Ex f .x/g.B t / exp R3
t 0
C jBs j2 ds jBs @M j3
dx:
(3.4.26)
126
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Lemma 3.57 gives that H./ D HD ./, where HD ./ denotes H./ with Dirichlet boundary condition. We see that .f; e tHD . / g/ Z Z D f .x/g.B t / exp M1 [M2
t 0
2 C jB j ds d W x dx; s jBs @M j3
(3.4.27)
with Mj D ¹.x; !/ 2 R3 X jx C Bs 2 Mj ; s 2 Œ0; t º denoting the set of paths starting at x and confined to Mj . Comparing (3.4.26) with (3.4.27), we can see that Z 0
t
1 ds D 1 jBs .!/ @M j3
for ! 2 R3 X n .M1 [ M2 /. Thus such paths do not contribute to (3.4.26) at all. Hence .f; e tH. / g/ D 0 for f and g for which supp f M1 and supp g M2 . Thus e tH. / is not positivity improving. Moreover we have Z f .x/g.B t /d W x dx 6D .f; e tH.0/ g/: lim .f; e tH. / g/ D !0
M1 [M2
This vestigial effect of singular potentials is called Klauder phenomenon and shows that once a singular potential is turned on, its effect is felt after the potential is turned off. We have seen that for e tH. / positivity improving breaks down. This offers the possibility of constructing a two-fold degenerate ground state. Corollary 3.58. The ground state of H./ is two-fold degenerate. Proof. It can be seen that H./ can be reduced by L2 .Mj /. With Hj ./ D H./dL2 .Mj / we have that H./ D H1 ./ ˚ H2 ./. Let Ej D inf Spec.Hj .//; then E1 D E2 by symmetry. Thus the corollary follows. By replacing the potential jx @M j3 with jx @M j2" , " > 0, we can show the same results as in Lemma 3.57 and Corollary 3.58.
3.4.5 Exponential decay of the eigenfunctions A sufficient condition for the existence of a ground state of a Schrödinger operator is that lim infjxj!1 V .x/ D 1. However, ground states exist also for many other choices of V such as Coulomb potential in three dimensions. In many cases these ground states decay exponentially at infinity, while for potentials growing at infinity they decay even faster. An intuitive derivation of the order of decay jxjmC1 of the eigenvectors is obtained as follows.
127
Section 3.4 Properties of Schrödinger operators and semigroups
Suppose the potential is of the form V .x/ D jxj2m and the ground state of the form n .x/ D e jxj . By the eigenvalue equation 12 C jxj2m D E we roughly have 1 .n.n 1/jxjn2 C n2 jxj2n2 / C jxj2m D E : 2 Comparing the two sides in the leading order for large jxj we expect that n D m C 1. This can in fact be proved by using the Feynman–Kac formula. Suppose 2 L2 .Rd / with H D for some 2 R. By adding a constant to V we may assume D 0. Thus Rt .x/ D e tH .x/ D Ex Œe 0 V .Bs / ds .B t /: Therefore the value of .x/ is obtained by running a Brownian motion from x under a potential V . This suggests that starting in regions where V is large, the effect will be quite small as most of the Brownian paths take a long time to leave a finite region. Formally, j .x/j2 k k21 Ex Œe 2
Rt 0
VC .Bs / ds
Ex Œe 2
Rt 0
V .Bs / ds
by Schwarz inequality. By Khasminskii’s lemma the expectation involving V grows at most exponentially in t with a constant that can be estimated conveniently. We now present Carmona’s argument in detail. This will work for any eigenfunction of H and not just the ground state; therefore we assume ‰p 2 L2 .Rd / with H ‰p D Ep ‰p : For the present purposes we introduce two further classes of potentials V . Definition 3.26. V upper and V lower are defined as follows. (V upper ) V 2 V upper if and only if V D W U such that .1/ U 0 and U 2 Lp .Rd / for p D 1 if d D 1, and p > d=2 if d 2 .2/ W 2 L1loc .Rd / and W1 D infx2Rd W .x/ > 1. (V lower ) V 2 V lower if and only if V D W U such that .1/ U 0 and U 2 Lp .Rd / for p D 1 if d D 1, and p > d=2 if d 2 .2/ W 2 L1loc .Rd /. Let V D W U 2 V upper . Then W 2 L1loc .Rd / and 0 U 2 Lp .Rd / implies that U 2 K.Rd /. Thus V is Kato decomposable. Hence e tH W L2 .Rd / ! L1 .Rd / by Theorem 3.39, in particular, ‰p 2 L1 .Rd /. A fundamental estimate which we will make use of in showing the spatial exponential decay of eigenfunctions is given in the lemma below.
128
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Lemma 3.59 (Carmona’s estimate). Let V 2 V upper . Then for any t; a > 0 and every 0 < ˛ < 1=2, there exist constants D1 ; D2 ; D3 > 0 such that ˛ a2 t
j‰p .x/j D1 e D2 kU kp t e Ep t .D3 e 4
e tW1 C e tWa .x/ /k‰p k;
(3.4.28)
where Wa .x/ D inf¹W .y/jjx yj < aº. Proof. By Schwarz inequality j‰p .x/j e tEp .Ex Œe 4
Rt 0
W .Bs /ds
Note that
/1=4 .Ex Œe C4
Rt 0
U.Bs /ds
/1=4 EŒj‰p .x C B t /j2 1=2 : (3.4.29)
Z 2
EŒj‰p .x C B t /j D
Rd
Z D
… t .y/j‰p .x C y/j2 dy e jzj j‰p .x C 2
Rd
p
2 tz/j2 dz k‰p k2 :
Let A D ¹! 2 X j sup0st jBs .!/j > aº. Then it follows by Lévy’s maximal inequality that Z 1 2 r 2 =2 d 1 EŒ1A 2EŒ1¹jB t jaº D 2.2/d=2 Sd 1 r dx ˛ e ˛a =t p e a= t
with some ˛ , for every 0 < ˛ < 1=2, and where Sd 1 is the area of the d 1 dimensional unit sphere. The first factor in (3.4.29) is estimated as Ex Œe 4
Rt 0
W .Bs /ds
D E0 Œ1A e 4
Rt 0
W .Bs Cx/ds
C Ex Œ1Ac e 4
Rt 0
W .Bs /ds
e 4tW1 E0 Œ1A C e 4tWa .x/ ˛ e ˛a
2 =t
e 4tW1 C e 4tWa .x/ :
(3.4.30)
Next we estimate the second factor. Since U is in Kato-class, there exist constants D1 ; D2 > 0 such that Ex Œe 4
Rt 0
U.Bs /ds
D1 e D2 kU kp t
(3.4.31)
by Lemma 3.38. Setting D3 D ˛ 1=4 , we obtain the lemma by using the inequality .a C b/1=4 a1=4 C b 1=4 for a; b 0. Corollary 3.60 (Confining potential). Let V D W U 2 V upper . Suppose that W .x/ jxj2n outside a compact set K, for some n > 0 and > 0. Take 0 < ˛ < 1=2. Then there exists a constant C1 > 0 such that ˛c (3.4.32) j‰p .x/j C1 exp jxjnC1 k‰p k; 16 where c D infx2Rd nK Wjxj=2 .x/=jxj2n .
129
Section 3.4 Properties of Schrödinger operators and semigroups
Proof. Since supx j‰p .x/j < 1, it suffices to show all the statements for sufficiently large jxj. Note that Wjxj=2 .x/ cjxj2n for x 2 Rd n K. Then we have the following bounds for x 2 Rd n K: jxjWjxj=2 .x/1=2 cjxjnC1 ; jxjWjxj=2 .x/1=2 cjxj1n : Inserting t D t .x/ D jxjWjxj=2 .x/1=2 and a D a.x/ D j‰p .x/j e
˛ 16 cjxjnC1
D1 e .D2 kU kp CEp
1n jW j 1
.D3 e cjxj
jxj 2
in (3.4.28), we have
/cjxj1n ˛
C e .1 16 /cjxj
nC1
/k‰p k
for x 2 Rd n K. Hence (3.4.32) follows. For V D W U 2 V upper define † D lim infjxj!1 V .x/: Since U 2 Lp .Rd /, lim infjxj!1 .U.x// D 0 and hence † D lim infjxj!1 W .x/: Moreover † W1 holds. Corollary 3.61. Let V D W U 2 V upper . .1/ Decaying potential: Suppose Suppose that † > Ep , † > W1 , and Let 0 < ˇ < 1. Then there exists a constant C2 > 0 such that ˇ .† Ep / jxj k‰p k: (3.4.33) j‰p .x/j C2 exp p p 8 2 † W1 .2/ Confining potential: Suppose that limjxj!1 W .x/ D 1. Then there exist constants C; ı > 0 such that j‰p .x/j C exp .ıjxj/ k‰p k:
(3.4.34)
Proof. Since supx j‰p .x/j < 1, it is again sufficient to show the statements for large enough jxj. Decaying case: Rewrite formula (3.4.28) as ˛ a2 t
j‰p .x/j D1 e D2 kU kp t .D3 e 4
e t.W1 Ep / C e t.Wa .x/Ep / /k‰p k: (3.4.35)
Then on flipping signs, with † D lim infjxj!1 .W .x// and † > W1 it is possible to choose a decomposition V D W U 2 V upper such that kU kp .† Ep /=2 since lim infjxj!1 .U.x// D 0. Inserting t D t .x/ D "jxj and a D a.x/ D jxj 2 in (3.4.35), we have ˛
j‰p .x/j D1 e kU kp "jxj .D3 e 16" jxj e "jxj.W1 Ep / C e "jxj.Wjxj=2 .x/Ep / /k‰p k ˛
1
D1 .D3 e . 16" C".W1 Ep / 2 ".†Ep //jxj 1
C e "..Wjxj=2 .x/Ep / 2 .†Ep //jxj /k‰p k:
130
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Choosing " D
p p ˛=16= † W1 , the exponent in the first term above becomes ˛ 1 1 C ".W1 Ep / ".† Ep / D ".† Ep /: 16" 2 2
Moreover, we see that lim infjxj!1 Wjxj=2 .x/ D †, and obtain "
j‰p .x/j C2 e 2 .†Ep /jxj k‰p k for sufficiently large jxj. Thus (3.4.33) follows. Confining case: In this case for any c > 0 there exists N > 0 such that Wjxj=2 .x/ c, for all jxj > N . Inserting t D t .x/ D "jxj and a D a.x/ D jxj 2 in (3.4.28), we obtain that ˛
j‰p .x/j D1 e kU kp "jxj .D3 e 16" jxj e "jxj.W1 Ep / C e "jxj.Wjxj=2 .x/Ep / /k‰p k ˛
D1 .D3 e . 16" "kU kp C".W1 Ep //jxj C e "jxj.cEp kU kp / /k‰p k for jxj > N . Choosing sufficiently large c and sufficiently small " such that ˛ "kU kp C ".W1 Ep / > 0 and 16"
c Ep kU kp > 0;
0
we obtain j‰p .x/j C 0 e ı jxj for large enough jxj. Thus (3.4.34) follows. By using the Feynman–Kac formula we can also establish a lower bound on positive eigenfunctions. Recall that eigenfunctions corresponding to E.H / are strictly positive. Lemma 3.62. Let V D W U 2 V lower and suppose ‰p .x/ 0. Also, let x 2 Rd n ¹0º, and ˛1 ; : : : ; ˛d , a1 ; : : : ; an , b1 ; : : : ; bd and t > 0 satisfy for j D 1; : : : ; d , ˛j2 > t;
˛j < aj =2;
jŒaj ; aj \ Œxj bj ; xj C bj j > ˛j ;
(3.4.36)
where j j denotes Lebesgue measure. Then log ‰p .x/ Ep t log ".b/ C t WQ a .x/ p
C d log.2t 2 t /
d X j D1
log.˛j2 aj /
d 9 X 2 C aj ; 8t j D1
where WQ a .x/ D sup¹W .y/j jyj xj j < aj ; j D 1; : : : ; d º and ".b/ D inf¹‰p .y/j jyj j bj ; j D 1; : : : ; d º < 1:
(3.4.37)
131
Section 3.5 Feynman–Kac–Itô formula for magnetic field
Proof. Let ˇ j ® ¯ A D ! 2 X ˇ jB t .!/j bj ; sup jBsj .!/ xj j aj ; j D 1; : : : ; d : 0st
(3.4.36) yields that d Y p 2 Ex Œ1A .2t 2 t/d ˛j2 aj e 9jaj =.8t/ :
(3.4.38)
j D1
Hence ‰p .x/ D e tEp Ex Œ‰p .B t /e e tEp Ex Œ‰p .B t /e ".b/e tEp e
Q a .x/ t W
Rt 0
Rt 0
W .Bs /ds W .Bs /ds
Rt
e
0
U.Bs /ds
1A
Ex Œ1A :
Combining this with (3.4.38) we obtain (3.4.37). Corollary 3.63 (Lower bound of ground state). Let V D W U 2 V lower . Suppose that W .x/ jxj2m outside a compact set with > 0 and m > 1, and ‰p .x/ 0. mC1 Then there exist constants ı; D > 0 such that ‰p .x/ De ıjxj . Proof. Since k‰p k1 < 1 it suffices to prove the corollary for large enough jxj. Set t D jxj.m1/ , aj D 1 C jxj j, ˛j D 1=2 and bj D 1 for j D 1; : : : ; d . It can be directly checked that with these choices (3.4.36) is satisfied. Notice that WQ a .x/ 24m jxj2m . Upon insertion to (3.4.37) we obtain p log ‰p .x/ Ep jxj.m1/ log ".b/ C jxjmC1 24m C d log.2 2/ C d log.jxj.m1/3=2 / C 2d log 2 X 9 C jxjm1 .1 C 2jxj j C jxj j2 /; 8 d
d X
log.1 C jxj j/
j D1
j D1
from which 2
log ‰p .x/ log.2.2
p
9 4m 9 2 9 1 2/ =".b//C 2 C d C d jxj C d jxj jxjmC1 : 8 8 4 d
Then for sufficiently large jxj and ı > 24m C 9d=8 the result follows.
3.5
Feynman–Kac–Itô formula for magnetic field
3.5.1 Feynman–Kac–Itô formula The Schrödinger operator (3.1.22) gives the energy of a quantum particle in a force field rV . In some cases of electrodynamics there is an interaction with a magnetic
132
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
field that has to be taken into account. This is done by adding a vector potential a D .a1 ; : : : ; ad / to the Schrödinger operator. A formal definition of the Schrödinger operator with vector potentials is then given by 1 H.a/ D .i r a/2 C V: 2
(3.5.1)
Lemma 3.64. Suppose that a 2 .L2p .Rd / C L1 .Rd //d , V 2 Lp .Rd / C L1 .Rd / and .r a/ 2 Lp .Rd / C L1 .Rd /, where p D 2 for d 3 and p > d=2 for d 4. Then H.a/ is self-adjoint on D..1=2// and essentially self-adjoint on any core of .1=2/. Proof. Under the assumption H.a/ D .1=2/ C .1=2/.i r a/ C a .i r/ C .1=2/a a C V
(3.5.2)
follows. It is easy to see that a a, r a and V are infinitesimally small multiplication operators with respect to .1=2/. Furthermore, a r is also infinitesimally small. Indeed, we have ka @ f k ka k2p k@ f kq ka k2p ."kf k2 C b" kf k/ for any " > 0, where q D 2p=.p 1/. The second inequality follows from the Hausdorff–Young inequality as k@ f kq kk fOkq 0 k.1 C jkj/˛ k2p k.1 C jkj/˛ k fOk2 ; d ; 1/. Then by the Kato–Rellich theorem H.a/ is where q 0 D 2p=.p C 1/ and ˛ 2 . 2p self-adjoint on D..1=2//, and essentially self-adjoint on any core of .1=2/.
In this section our goal is to construct a Feynman–Kac formula of e tH.a/ . A drift transformation applied to Brownian motion gives Ex Œf .B t /e
Rt 0
a.Bs /dBs 12
Rt
On replacing a by i a, formally Ex Œf .B t /e i
Rt 0
a.Bs /dBs C 12
0
a.Bs /2 ds
Rt 0
D e t..1=2/ar/ f .x/:
a.Bs /2 ds
D e t..1=2/Ciar/ f .x/
is obtained. Let W D V C .1=2/a a C .1=2/.i r a/. By (3.5.2) the “imaginary” drift transformation yields Z t Z t
Z 1 t x a.Bs / dBs C r a.Bs /ds V .Bs /ds E f .B t / exp i 2 0 0 0
Z t Z Z t 1 t x 2 D E f .B t / exp i a.Bs / dBs C a.Bs / ds W .Bs /ds 2 0 0 0 D .e tH.a/ /f .x/: We turn this rigorous in the next theorem.
133
Section 3.5 Feynman–Kac–Itô formula for magnetic field
Theorem 3.65 (Feynman–Kac–Itô formula). Suppose a 2 .Cb2 .Rd //d and V 2 L1 .Rd /. Then for f; g 2 L2 .Rd /, Z Rt Rt .f; e tH.a/ g/ D dxEx Œf .B0 /e i 0 a.Bs /ıdBs e 0 V .Bs /ds g.B t /: (3.5.3) Rd
In particular, .e tH.a/ f /.x/ D Ex Œe i
Rt 0
a.Bs /ıdBs
e
Rt 0
V .Bs /ds
f .B t /:
(3.5.4)
Recall that the notation ı in the stochastic integral above stands for Stratonovich integral. Rt Rt Proof. Write Z t D e X t , X t D i 0 a.Bs / ı dBs 0 V .Bs /ds and Y t D f .B t /. Set .Q t f /.x/ D Ex ŒZ t f .B t /: Note that V .B t / and .ra/.B t / are L1loc .R; dt / almost surely, and aj .B t / 2 M 2 .0; t /. Thus, since i dX t D i a dB t .r a/dt Vdt; 2 we arrive at 1 1 i 2 dZ t D Z t dX t C Z t .dX t / D Z t .r a/ a a V dt C Z t .i a/ dB t 2 2 2 by the Itô formula. Then by d Y t D .1=2/f dt C rf dB t and the product formula 1 i d.Z t Y t / D Z t .r a/dt .a a/dt C .i a/ dB t Vdt Y t 2 2 1 f dt C rf dB t C Z t .i a/ rf dt C Zt 2 H.a/f Z t dt C Z t .rf C .i a/f / dB t is obtained. It gives Z .Q t f /.x/ f .x/ D
t
.Qs H.a/f /.x/ds: 0
Then in a similar manner as in Theorem 3.30 we see that 1 s-lim .Q t f f / D H.a/f: t!0 t
134
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Then it is enough to show that Q t is a symmetric C0 semigroup. We directly see that Qs Q t f .x/ D Ex Œe i D Ex Œe i
Rs 0
Rs 0
a.Br /ıdBr a.Br /ıdBr
EBs Œf .B t /e i
Rt
Ex Œf .BsCt /e i
0
a.Bs /ıdBs
R sCt s
a.Br /ıdBr
jFs
D QsCt f .x/: Recall that .F t / t0 is the natural filtration of Brownian motion. Hence the semigroup property follows. Let BQ s D B ts B t , 0 s t . We have Z Rt Rt Q Q Q .f; Q t g/ D dxf .x/Ex Œe i 0 a.Bs /ıd Bs e 0 V .Bs / g.BQ t / d R
Z Rt Rt 0 i 0 a.xCBQ s /ıd BQ s 0 V .xCBQ s / DE dxf .x/e e g.x C BQ t / : Rd
Let
1 Ij D .a.x C BQ tj=n / C a.x C BQ t.j 1/=n //.BQ tj=n BQ t.j 1/=n /: 2 Rt Pn es in L2 .X / as n ! 1. Thus a subsequence Then j D1 Ij ! 0 a.x C BQ s / ı d B Rt P n0 es almost surely. We reset n0 as n. Chang. j D1 Ij /n0 converges to 0 a.x C BQ s /ıd B ing the variable x to y BQ t , we have
Z Rt P 0 i jnD1 IQj 0 V .yBQ t BQ s / Q .f; Q t g/ D lim E dyf .y B t /e e g.y/ ; n!1
Rd
where 1 IQj D .a.y BQ t C BQjt=n / C a.y BQ t C BQ t.j 1/=n //.BQ tj=n BQ t.j 1/=n /: 2 Recall that a 2 .Cb2 .Rd //d . Then in L2 .X / sense it follows that lim
n!1
n X
Z IQj D
j D1
0
t
a.y C Bs / ı dBs :
This gives Z .f; Q t g/ D
Rd
dxEx Œf .B t /e i
Rt 0
a.Bs /ıdBs e
Rt 0
V .Bs /ds g.x/
D .Q t f; g/: (3.5.5)
Hence Q t is symmetric. The strong continuity of Q t with respect to t is derived in the same way as in the proof of Theorem 3.30.
135
Section 3.5 Feynman–Kac–Itô formula for magnetic field
3.5.2 Alternate proof of the Feynman–Kac–Itô formula As before, the Trotter product formula can once again be employed to prove the Feynman–Kac–Itô formula. Here we give this proof, which will be useful in constructing the functional integral representation of the Pauli–Fierz model in Chapter 7. Suppose a 2 .Cb2 .Rd //d and V D 0. Write Ks .x; y/ D …s .x y/e ih ;
(3.5.6)
where h D h.x; y/ D .1=2/.a.x/ C a.y// .x y/: Define the family of integral operators %s W L2 .Rd / ! L2 .Rd / by Z %s f .x/ D
Rd
Ks .x; y/f .y/dy;
s 0;
(3.5.7)
where %0 f .x/ D f .x/. Notice that %s is symmetric and k%s k 1. Let f; g 2 C01 .Rd /. It is directly seen that d .g; %s f / D ds
Z
Z g.x/dx Rd
Rd
1 ih y e f .y/ dy: …s .x y/ 2
Here we used that .d…s =ds/.x y/ D .1=2/y …s .x y/. Since @j e ih f D .i @j h f C @j f /e ih ; @j2 e ih f D ¹@j2 f C 2i @j h @j f C .i @j2 h C .i @j h/2 /f ºe ih ; 1 @j h D ¹@j a.y/ .x y/ .aj .x/ C aj .y//º; 2 ² ³ 1 @j2 h D @j2 a.y/ .x y/ @j aj .y/ ; 2 where @j D @yj , j D 1; : : : ; d , we have Z lim
s!0 Rd
…s .x y/.y e ihf .y//dy D .f 2a .i rf / .i ra a a/f / D 2H.a/f:
Thus lims!0 .d=ds/.g; %s f / D .g; H.a/f / and hence lim .g; t 1 .1 % t /f / D .g; H.a/f /:
t!0
(3.5.8)
136
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae n
We show next that %2t=2n converges to a symmetric semigroup. For f; g 2 L2 .Rd /, n .g; %2t=2n f
Z /D
g.x/e
i
P2 n
j D1
h.xj ;xj 1 /
Rd
j D1
with x0 D x. Therefore n lim .g; %2t=2n f n!1
2n n Y Y f .xn / … t=2n .xj xj 1 / dxj
Z
j D0
dxE g.B0 /f .B t / x
/ D lim
n!1 Rd
X 1 exp i .a.B tj=2n / C a.B t.j 1/=2n //.B tj=2n B t.j 1/=2n / 2 j D1 Z t
Z x D dxE g.B0 /f .B t / exp i a.Bs / ı dBs (3.5.9) 2n
Rd
0
by Corollary 2.30. Hence
n j limn!1 .g; %2t=2n f
/j kgk kf k. By the Riesz theon
rem there is a bounded operator S t such that limn!1 .g; %2t=2n f / D .g; S t f /. It is symmetric since %s is symmetric. (3.5.9) implies that S t f .x/ D Ex Œf .Bs /e i
Rt 0
a.Bs /ıdBs
:
Hence S0 D 1, s-lim t!0 S t D 1 and Ss S t D SsCt follow. Thus S t is a symmetric C0 -semigroup, so there exists a self-adjoint operator A such that e tA D S t by Proposition 3.26. It suffices to show that A D H.a/. This can be checked without using the Itô formula. We have 1 tA 1 2n .e .% t=2n 1/g; f 1/g; f D lim n!1 t t n 1 2X 1 2n 2n .j=2n / D lim .% t=2n 1/g; % t=2n f n!1 2n t j D0
Z D lim
n!1 0
1 n 2
t
Œ2n s
.% t=2n 1/g; % t=2n f
ds;
where the brackets denote integer part in this formula. Since for g 2 D..1=2//, 2n .% t=2n 1/g D H.a/g; n!1 t the norm k.2n =t /.% t=2n 1/gk is uniformly bounded in n. Moreover, we see that Œ2n s s-limn!1 % t=2n D e stA , s 2 Œ0; 1, by Corollary 3.67 below. Thus we conclude that Z 1 1 tA .e 1/g; f D .H.a/g; e tsA f /ds: (3.5.10) t 0 w lim
137
Section 3.5 Feynman–Kac–Itô formula for magnetic field
As t ! 0 on both sides above, we get .g; Af / D .H.a/g; f /, implying that Ag D H.a/g. Hence A D H.a/ and the proposition follows for V D 0. Let now V be continuous and bounded. Note that for f0 ; fn 2 L2 .Rd / and fj 2 1 L .Rd / for j D 1; : : : ; n 1, it follows that for 0 D t0 < t1 < < tn , n n h Y Z i R tn Y .tj tj 1 /H.a/ e fj D dx f0 .B0 / fj .B tj / e i 0 a.Bs /ıdBs : f0 ; Rd
j D1
j D1
(3.5.11) This can be proven by using the Markov property of Brownian motion as
n Y
f0 ; Z D
j D1
Rd
Z D
e .tj tj 1 /H.a/ fj
Rd
dxEx Œf0 .B0 /f1 .B t1 /e i EB t1 Œf1 .B t1 /e i dxEx Œf0 .B0 /f1 .B t1 /e i
R t1 0
a.Bs /ıdBs
R t2 t1 0
R t2 0
a.Bs /ıdBs
a.Bs /ıdBs
G2 .B t2 t1 /
f1 .B t1 /G2 .B t2 t1 /;
Q where Gj .x/ D fj .x/. niDj C1 e .ti ti1 /H.a/ fi /.x/. Repeating this procedure we arrive at (3.5.11). From this and the Trotter product formula we have .f; e tH.a/ g/ D lim .f; .e .t=n/H.a/ e .t=n/V /n g/ n!1 Z Rt Pn D lim dxEx Œf .B0 /e i 0 a.Bs /ıdBs e j D1 V .Bjt =n / n!1 Rd Z Rt Rt D dxEx Œf .B0 /e i 0 a.Bs /ıdBs e 0 V .Bs /ds : Rd
Finally, we can extend the result for smooth V in a similar way as done in Theorem 3.31. Now we prove the statements used in the proof above. Lemma 3.66. Let An be a positive and contracting self-adjoint operator such that s-limn!1 An D A. Then for all s 0, s-limn!1 Asn D As . Proof. Suppose that 0 < s 1=2. Since An is positive, we have Z sin.2s/ 1 2s1 f D .An C /1 An f d : A2s n 0 2s weakly as n ! 1, thus As ! As strongly. For From this follows that A2s n ! A n s=2 0 s 1, s-limn!1 Asn D s-limn!1 .An /2 D As , since An is a contraction. Repeating this procedure the result follows.
138
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae Œns
Corollary 3.67. s-limn!1 % t=n D e stA for s 0. Proof. Set An D %2n . Then An is a positive and a contracting self-adjoint operator t=n .nsC1/=n
such that s-limn!1 An D e 2tA . We have An
2Œns
% t=n Asn in form sense. 1=n
From this inequality, Lemma 3.66 and the fact that s-limn!1 An D 1, we obtain 2Œns Œns that .f; % t=n f / ! .f; e 2tsA f / as n ! 1. Hence s-limn!1 % t=n D e tsA follows.
3.5.3 Extension to singular external potentials and vector potentials The Feynman–Kac–Itô formula derived in the previous subsection can further be extended to singular vector potentials a D .a1 ; : : : ; ad /. By using form technique, we are able to define H.a/ as a self-adjoint operator. Let D D i @ a W L2 .Rd / ! D 0 .Rd /;
(3.5.12)
with Schwartz distribution space D 0 .Rd / over Rd . Define the quadratic form qa .f; g/ D
d X
.D f; D g/ C .V 1=2 f; V 1=2 g/
(3.5.13)
D1
with domain Q.qa / D
Td
D1 ¹f
2 L2 .Rd /jD f 2 L2 .Rd /º \ D.V 1=2 /.
Lemma 3.68. Suppose that a 2 .L2loc .Rd //d and V 2 L1loc .Rd / with V 0. Then qa is a closed symmetric form. Proof. Let .fn /n Q.qa / be a Cauchy sequence with respect to the norm k k0 D .qa .; /Ckk2 /1=2 ; then V 1=2 fn , D fn are Cauchy sequences in L2 .Rd /. Thus there exist g; f 2 L2 .Rd / such that D fn ! g and V 1=2 fn ! V 1=2 f as n ! 1 in L2 .Rd /. This gives .f; D / D .g; /, for all 2 C01 .Rd /. Therefore g D D f in D 0 .Rd / distribution sense, hence Q.qa / is complete with respect to k k0 . By Lemma 3.68 there exists a self-adjoint operator h such that .f; hg/ D qa .f; g/;
f 2 Q.qa /; g 2 D.h/:
(3.5.14)
Definition 3.27 (Schrödinger operator with a singular external potential and a vector field). Assume that a 2 .L2loc .Rd //d and V 2 L1loc .Rd /. We denote the self-adjoint operator h in (3.5.14) by H.a/ and call it Schrödinger operator with singular external potentials and vector potentials. A sufficient condition for C01 .Rd / to be a core of H.a/ is the proposition below.
139
Section 3.5 Feynman–Kac–Itô formula for magnetic field
Proposition 3.69. .1/ Let V 2 L1loc .Rd / with V 0. If a 2 .L2loc .Rd //d , then C01 .Rd / is a form core of H.a/. .2/ Let V 2 L2loc .Rd / with V 0. If a 2 .L4loc .Rd //d and r a 2 L2loc .Rd /, then C01 .Rd / is an operator core. We can also construct a Feynman–Kac–Itô formula for the form-defined H.a/. Lemma 3.70. Let 0 V and V 2 L1loc .Rd /. Suppose that a.n/ ; a 2 .L2loc .Rd //d .n/ and a ! a in L2loc .Rd / as n ! 1. Then H.a.n/ / converges to H.a/ in strong resolvent sense. .n/
.n/
Proof. Put Hn D H.a.n/ /, H D H.a/ and D D i @ a . Notice that C01 .Rd / is a form core of H.a/ by Proposition 3.69. Set un D .Hn C i /1 f for f 2 L2 .Rd /. Thus kun k kf k and d X
.n/ kD un k2 C kV 1=2 un k2 kf k2 :
D1 .n/
Since un , D un and V 1=2 un are bounded, there exist a subsequence un0 and some .n0 / vectors u, v, w 2 L2 .Rd / such that un0 ! u, V 1=2 un0 ! v and D un0 ! w .n0 / weakly. Since, furthermore, V 1=2 un0 ! V 1=2 u and D un0 ! D u in D 0 .Rd /, we have v D V 1=2 u and D u D w , and hence u 2 Q.qa /. For 2 C01 .Rd / qa .u; / D lim .un ; Hn / D .f i u; /: n!1
(3.5.15)
As C01 .Rd / is a form core of H , (3.5.15) implies that u 2 D.H / and f D .H Ci /u. Hence u D .H C i /1 f follows. Therefore, .Hn C i /1 ! .H C i /1 in weak sense, and similarly, .Hn i /1 ! .H i /1 weakly. Since k.Hn C i /1 f k2 D .i=2/.f; .Hn C i /1 f .Hn i /1 f / ! k.H C i /1 f k2 ; strong resolvent convergence of Hn follows. Lemma 3.71. Let V 0 be in L1loc .Rd /, a 2 .L2loc .Rd //d and r a 2 L1loc .Rd /. Then .f; e tH.a/ g/ has the same functional integral representation as in (3.5.3). S Proof. First suppose that V 2 L1 .Rd /. Notice that since a .Bs / 2 T >0 M2T by Rt the assumption that a 2 .L2loc .Rd //d we have W x .j 0 a.Bs / dBs j < 1/ D 1, R t moreover by Lemma 3.32, W x .j 0 r a.Bs /dsj < 1/ D 1 also holds. By using a mollifier we can choose a sequence a.n/ 2 C01 .Rd /, n D 1; 2; : : : , such that .n/ a ! a in L2loc .Rd / and r a.n/ ! r a in L1loc .Rd / as n ! 1. Let 1R D .x1 =R/ .xd =R/, R 2 N, where 2 C01 .R/ such that 0 1, .x/ D 1
140
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
for jxj < 1 and .x/ D 0 for jxj 2. Since 1R a.n/ ! a.n/ as R ! 1 in .L2loc .Rd //d and a.n/ ! a as n ! 1 in .L2loc .Rd //d , it follows from Lemma 3.70 .n/ that e tH.1R a / ! e tH.1R a/ , as n ! 1 and e tH.1R a/ ! e tH.a/ as R ! 1 in strong sense. Furthermore, (3.5.3) remains true for a replaced by 1R a.n/ 2 C01 .Rd /. Since 1R a.n/ 2 .C01 .Rd //d and 1R a.n/ ! 1R a in .L2loc .Rd //d as n ! 1, it follows that Z t Z t 1R .Bs /a.n/ .Bs / dBs ! 1R .Bs /a.Bs / dBs (3.5.16) 0
0
and since r .1R a.n/ / D .r1R / a.n/ C 1R .r a.n/ / ! .r1R / a C 1R .r a/ in L1 .Rd / it follows that Z
Z
t 0
r .1R .Bs /a
.n/
.Bs //ds !
0
t
¹.r1R .Bs // a.Bs / C 1R .Bs /.r a.Bs //º ds (3.5.17)
strongly in L1 .X ; d W x /. Thus there is a subsequence n0 such that (3.5.16) and (3.5.17) hold almost surely for n replaced by n0 , therefore (3.5.3) follows by a limiting argument for a replaced by 1R a. Let ® C .R/ D ! 2 X j ®
.R/ D ! 2 X j
max
¯ Bs .!/ R ;
min
Bs .!/ R
0st;1d 0st;1d
¯
ˇZ t ˇ Z t ˇ ˇ I.R/ D ˇˇ 1R .Bs /a.Bs / dBs a.Bs / dBs ˇˇ :
and
0
0
It is a well-known fact that x
x
W . .R// D W .C .R// D
d Y
W x .jB t j R/
D1
D
p
2 2 t
Z
!d
R
e
y 2 =.2t/
dy
0
Since I.R/ D 0 on C \ , we have W x .I.R/ "/ D W x I.R/ "; C .R/c [ .R/c d Z 1 2 2 e y =.2t/ dy : 2 p 2 t R
:
141
Section 3.5 Feynman–Kac–Itô formula for magnetic field
Hence limR!1 W x .I.R/ R "/ D 0. Thus there exists a subsequence R0 such that Rt t 0 0 0 1R .Bs /a.Bs / dBs ! 0 a.Bs / dBs as R ! 1, almostR surely. It can be seen t in a similar way that with a subsequence (3.5.17) converges to 0 r a.Bs /ds almost Rt Rt surely. Thus 0 1R00 .Bs /a.Bs / ı dBs ! 0 a.Bs / ı dBs , almost surely. Since jf .B0 /g.B t /e
Rt 0
V .Bs /ds i
Rt
e
0
1R00 .Bs /a.Bs /ıdBs
j D jf .B0 /g.B t /je
Rt 0
V .Bs /ds
and the right-hand side is integrable, (3.5.3) holds for a satisfying a 2 .L2loc .Rd //d and r a 2 L1loc .Rd / by the dominated convergence theorem. Finally, by a similar argument as in the proof of Theorem 3.31, we can extend (3.5.3) to V 2 L1loc .Rd /. Define H 0 .a/ by H.a/ with V D 0. Lemma 3.72. Let a 2 .L2loc .Rd //d , r a 2 L1loc .Rd / and V be a real multiplication operator. .1/ Suppose jV j is relatively form bounded with respect to .1=2/ with relative bound b. Then jV j is also relatively form bounded with respect to H 0 .a/ with a relative bound not larger than b. .2/ Suppose jV j is relatively bounded with respect to .1=2/ with relative bound b. Then jV j is also relatively bounded with respect to H 0 .a/ with a relative bound not larger than b. Proof. By virtue of Lemma 3.71 we have j.f; e tH Since .H 0 .a/ C E/1=2 D that
p1
0 .a/
R1 0
g/j .jf j; e t.1=2/ jgj/: t 1=2 e t.H
0 .a/CE /
(3.5.18)
dt , E > 0, (3.5.18) implies
j.H 0 .a/ C E/1=2 f j.x/ ..1=2/ C E/1=2 jf j.x/
(3.5.19)
for almost every x 2 Rd . Hence we have jV .x/j1=2 j.H 0 .a/ C E/1=2 f j.x/ jV .x/j1=2 ..1=2/ C E/1=2 jf j.x/ and k jV j1=2 .H 0 .a/ C E/1=2 f k k jV j1=2 ..1=2/ C E/1=2 jf jk : (3.5.20) kf k kf k R1 0 Similarly, by using .H 0 .a/ C E/1 D 0 e t.H .a/CE / dt , E > 0, we have k jV j.H 0 .a/ C E/1 f k k jV j..1=2/ C E/1 jf jk : kf k kf k
(3.5.21)
On taking the limit E ! 1, the right-hand sides of (3.5.20) and (3.5.21) converge to b. Hence .1/ follows by (3.5.20) and .2/ by (3.5.21).
142
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Let V be such that VC 2 L1loc .Rd / and V is relatively form bounded with respect to .1=2/ with a relative bound strictly smaller than one. Then the KLMN theorem P VC and Lemma 3.72 allow to define H 0 .a/ C P V as a self-adjoint operator. Definition 3.28 (Schrödinger operator with singular external potentials and vector potentials). Let a 2 .L2loc .Rd //d and r a 2 L1loc .Rd /. Let V be such that VC 2 L1loc .Rd / and V is relatively form bounded with respect to .1=2/ with a relative bound strictly smaller than one. Then the Schrödinger operator with V and a is defined by P VC H 0 .a/ C P V :
(3.5.22)
This is also denoted by H.a/. Theorem 3.73 (Feynman–Kac formula for Schrödinger operator with singular external potentials and vector potentials). Let a 2 .L2loc .Rd //d and r a 2 L1loc .Rd /. Suppose that VC 2 L1loc .Rd / and V is relatively form bounded with respect to .1=2/ with a relative bound strictly smaller than one. Then the Feynman–Kac formula of .f; e tH.a/ g/ is given by (3.5.3). Proof. The proof is similar to the limiting argument in Theorem 3.31. We used inequality (3.5.18) in the proof of Lemma 3.72. This can be extended to operators with singular external potentials. Corollary 3.74 (Diamagnetic inequality). Under the assumptions of Theorem 3.73 we have j.f; e tH.a/ g/j .jf j; e tH.0/ jgj/:
(3.5.23)
3.5.4 Kato-class potentials and Lp –Lq boundedness We can also add Kato-class potentials for Schrödinger operators with vector potentials a. Let V be Kato decomposable, a 2 .L2loc .Rd //d and r a 2 L1loc .Rd /. Define K t f .x/ D Ex Œe i
Rt 0
a.Bs /ıdBs
e
Rt 0
V .Bs /ds
f .B t /:
(3.5.24)
Since the absolute value of the first exponential is 1, K t is well defined as a bounded operator on L2 .Rd /. Theorem 3.75. Let V be Kato decomposable, and a 2 .L2loc .Rd //d , r a 2 L1loc .Rd /. Then ¹K t W t 0º is a symmetric C0 semigroup and there exists the unique selfadjoint operator K.a/ bounded from below such that K t D e tK.a/ , t 0.
143
Section 3.6 Feynman–Kac formula for relativistic Schrödinger operators
Proof. In a similar way to Theorem 3.65 it can be proven that ¹K t W t 0º is a symmetric C0 semigroup. Definition 3.29 (Schrödinger operator with vector potentials and Kato-decomposable potentials). Let a 2 .L2loc .Rd //d , r a 2 L1loc .Rd / and V be Kato decomposable. Then we call the self-adjoint operator K.a/ defined by Theorem 3.75 Schrödinger operator with vector potentials and Kato-decomposable potentials. Corollary 3.76 (Lp –Lq boundedness). Let V be Kato decomposable, a 2 .L2loc .Rd //d and r a 2 L1loc .Rd /. Then e tK.a/ is Lp –Lq bounded, for every t 0. Proof. By the diamagnetic inequality je tK.a/ f .x/j e tK.0/ jf j.x/:
(3.5.25)
In Theorem 3.39 we have shown that e tK.0/ is hypercontractive. By (3.5.25) it follows that e tK.a/ is bounded from L1 .Rd / to L1 .Rd /, from L1 .Rd / to L1 .Rd /, and from L1 .Rd / to L1 .Rd /.
3.6
Feynman–Kac formula for relativistic Schrödinger operators
3.6.1 Relativistic Schrödinger operator Relativity theory says that in the high energy regime the kinetic energy of a body in motion should be proportional to the absolute value of its momentum p rather than p its square. In fact, the classical energy of a relativistic particle of mass m is jpj2 C m2 c 2 , where c is the speed of light, and this justifies the definition of the relativistic Schrödinger operator p C m2 m (in units for which c D 1). The constant m is subtracted to set the bottom of its spectrum to zero. In this section we consider Feynman–Kac formulae for relativistic Schrödinger operators of a more general form. Definition 3.30 (Relativistic Schrödinger operator with vector potentials). Suppose that a 2 .L2loc .Rd //d and V 2 L1 .Rd /. The operator HR .a/ D .2H 0 .a/ C m2 /1=2 m C V;
(3.6.1)
is called relativistic Schrödinger operator, where H 0 .a/ is the self-adjoint operator given in Definition 3.27 with V D 0.
144
Chapter 3 Feynman–Kac formulae
Note that the square-root term is defined through the spectral projection of the selfadjoint operator H 0 .a/. Denote by HR0 .a/ the operator HR .a/ with V D 0. Proposition 3.77. .1/ Suppose that a 2 .L4loc .Rd //d and r a 2 L2loc .Rd /. Then C01 .Rd / is an operator core of HR0 .a/. .2/ Suppose that a 2 .L2loc .Rd //d . Then C01 .Rd / is a form core of HR0 .a/. Proof. For simplicity, in this proof we set HR0 .a/ D HR and H 0 .a/ D H . .1/ There exist non-negative constants c1 and c2 such that kHR f k c1 kHf k C c2 kf k
(3.6.2)
for all f 2 D.H /. Hence C01 .Rd / is contained in D.HR /. Since HR is a nonnegative self-adjoint operator, HR C1 has a bounded inverse, and we use that C01 .Rd / is a core of HR if and only if HR C01 .Rd / is dense in L2 .Rd /. Let g 2 L2 .Rd / and suppose that .g; .HR C 1/f / D 0, for all f 2 C01 .Rd /. Then C01 .Rd / 3 f 7! .g; HR f / D .g; f / defines a continuous functional which can be extended to L2 .Rd /. Thus g 2 D.HR / and 0 D ..HR C 1/g; f /. Since C01 .Rd / is dense, we have .HR C 1/g D 0, and hence g D 0 since HR C 1 is one-to-one, proving the assertion. 1=2 .2/ Note that kHR f k2 c1 kH 1=2 f k2 C c2 kf k2 for f 2 Q.h/ D D.H 1=2 /, 1=2 1=2 and C01 .Rd / is contained in Q.HR / D D.HR /. Since HR C 1 has also bounded 1=2 inverse, it is seen by the same argument as above that C01 .Rd / is a core of HR or a form core of HR . A key element in the construction of the Feynman–Kac formula is to use the Lévy subordinator studied in Example 2.18. In that notation we write ı D 1, D m so that we have the subordinator T t D T t .1; m/ on a suitable probability space .T ; BT ; / such that p E0 Œe uT t D exp.t . 2u C m2 m//: (3.6.3) For simplicity,