feminist Aesthetics in Music
Recent Titles in Contributions to the Study of Music and Dance Otto Laske: Navigating Ne...
374 downloads
2382 Views
12MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
feminist Aesthetics in Music
Recent Titles in Contributions to the Study of Music and Dance Otto Laske: Navigating New Musical Horizons Jerry Tabor, editor Perspectives on the Grateful Dead: Critical Writings Robert G. Weiner, editor The Cultivation of Body and Mind in Nineteenth-Century American Delsartism Nancy Lee Chalfa Ruyter Domenico Cimarosa: His Life and His Operas Nick Rossi and Talmage Fauntleroy The Writings and Letters of Konrad Wolff Ruth Gillen, editor Nomai Dance Drama: A Surviving Spirit of Medieval Japan Susan M. Asai The Wind and Wind-Chorus Music of Anton Bruckner Keith William Kinder Modern Myths and Wagnerian Deconstructions: Hermeneutic Approaches to Wagner's Music-Dramas Mary A. Cicora Virtue or Virtuosity? Explorations in the Ethics of Musical Performance Jane O'Dea Beethoven in Person: His Deafness, Illnesses, and Death Peter J. Davies The Character of a Genius: Beethoven in Perspective Peter J. Davies Sing Sorrow: Classics, History, and Heroines in Opera Marianne McDonald
Feminist Aesthetics in Music Sally Macarthur
Contributions to the Study of Music and Dance, Number 61
GREENWOOD PRESS Westport, Connecticut • London
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Macarthur, Sally. Feminist aesthetics in music / Sally Macarthur. p. cm.—(Contributions to the study of music and dance, ISSN 0193-9041 ; no. 61) Includes bibliographical references (p. ), discography (p. ), and index. ISBN 0-313-31320-2 (alk. paper) 1. Feminism and music. 2. Music—Philosophy and aesthetics. I. Title. II. Series. ML82.M22 2002 780'.82—dc2I 2001023329 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data is available. Copyright © 2002 by Sally Macarthur All rights reserved. No portion of this book may be reproduced, by any process or technique, without the express written consent of the publisher. Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 2001023329 ISBN: 0-313-31320-2 ISSN: 0193-9041 First published in 2002 Greenwood Press, 88 Post Road West, Westport, CT 06881 An imprint of Greenwood Publishing Group, Inc. www.greenwood.com Printed in the United States of America
The paper used in this book complies with the Permanent Paper Standard issued by the National Information Standards Organization (Z39.48-1984). 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3
Copyright Acknowledgments The author and publisher gratefully acknowledge permission for use of the following material: Excerpts from Ansturm by Richard Dehmel, translated by Margit Franklin-Spaeth and Jim Franklin, in Peter Platr "Love and Passion in Alma Mahler- Werfel's Ansturm!' Predictions and Inaccuracies: Collisions of Musical Histories and Futures Approaching the Millennium. Papers from the Sydney Music Research Symposium, University of Western Sydney, February 20,1999, Sydney Chapter of the Musicological Society ofAustralia. Translation by Richard Hobbs of Rimbaud's poem O Saisons, O Chateaux!, which appears on the sleeve notes of the CD entitled Red Leaves by Cala Records Ltd., 1996. Adaptation of Sally Macarthur's "Performance Rites: AMEB, or Not to Be?" in Sally Macarthur and Cate Poynton, eds., Musics and Feminisms. Sydney. Australian Music Centre, 1999. Figure 2.7, "Percentage of Australian Music Included in the AMEB Syllabuses for A. Mus. A. and L. Mus.A. in 1985,1990, and 1995" by Sarah-Grace Williams. Excerpts from Genefer Luff's unpublished interview with Moya Henderson, March 21,1989. Musical extracts from Moya Henderson's Sacred Site (1983) and Stubble (1975). Musical extracts from VierLiederNo. 3, Ansturm by Alma Mahler-Werfel. © Copyright 1915 by Universal Edition A. G. Wien. Reproduced by permission of Boosey & Hawkes on behalf of Alfred A. Kalmus Ltd. (London). Musical extracts from Trio for Violin, Violoncello and Pianoforte by Rebecca Clarke. © Copyright 1928 by Hawkes & Son (London) Ltd. Reprinted by permission of Boosey & Hawkes Music Publishers Ltd. Musical extracts from Cycle of Love by Anne Boyd. © Faber Music Limited. Reproduced by permission of Boosey & Hawkes Pty Ltd. on behalf of Faber Music Limited. Musical extracts from Tast-en by Elena Kats-Chernin. © Boosey & Hawkes New York. Reprinted by permission of Boosey & Hawkes Pty Ltd.
This page intentionally left blank
This book is dedicated with love and gratitude to my mother, Meryll Marion Macarthur, to my father, Robert James Macarthur, and to Rosemary Schaffler
The words the happy say Are paltry melody But those the silent feel Are beautiful. —Emily Dickinson (J.1750)
This page intentionally left blank
Contents
Illustrations Acknowledgments Introduction: For Women's Eyes Only?
xi xiii 1
1 Feminist Aesthetics in Music
11
2 Music in Context and Practice
31
3 The Power of Sound, the Power of Sex: Alma Schindler-Mahler's Ansturm
63
4 Sexing the Subject of Musical Analysis: Rebecca Clarke and Elisabeth Lutyens
81
5 Meditations on Feminist Aesthetics: Anne Boyd's Cycle of Love
107
6 Framing the Case for a Feminist Reading of Elena Kats-Chernin's Postmodern Tast-en
129
7 Sexual Signatures: Feminist Aesthetics in the Music of Moya Henderson after the Death of the Author
149
8 This Music Which Is Between Two
173
Bibliography
185
Discography
197
Index
199
This page intentionally left blank
Illustrations
FIGURES 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.7 5.1
Repertoire Findings for All Groups Surveyed, 1985-1995 Repertoire Findings for Music Reviewed in the Sydney Morning Herald, 1985-1995 Repertoire Findings for Music Performed by the SSO, 1985-1995 Percentage of Australian Music and Women's Music Performed by Contemporary Music Ensembles, 1985-1995 Percentage of Australian Music and Women's Music Performed by Mainstream Ensembles, 1985-1995 Percentage of Australian Women's Music against All Australian Music Performed by All Groups, 1985-1995 Percentage of Australian Music Included in the AMEB Syllabuses for A. Mus. A. and L. Mus. A. in 1985, 1990, and 1995 Arc Structure of Cycle of Love Showing Tonal Centers for Each Movement
37 38 39 40 41 41 49 118
TEXT EXAMPLES 3.1 4.1 5.1
Ansturm (Assault or Uprush) by Richard Dehmel Poem O Saisons, O Chateaux! by Rimbaud Textual Analysis of Cycle ofLove
72 99 120
MUSICAL EXAMPLES 3.1
Alma Schindler-Mahler, Vier Lieder No. 3, Ansturm (Bars 8-14)
73
xii
3.2 4.1 4.2 4.3 5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5
Illustrations Alma Schindler-Mahler, Vier Lieder No. 3, Ansturm (Bars 28-31) Rebecca Clarke, Music of First Three Bars of the Piano Trio Rebecca Clarke, Bugle Call in Bar 33 of the Piano Trio Series upon which O Saisons, O Chateaux! Is Based Quotation from the Dirge in Serenade for Tenor, Horn, and Strings (Bars 4-6, Second Song, Cycle of Love) Boyd's Transcription of a Korean Sijo, Opening Flute Melody of Cycle of Love (Bars 1-2) Opening Bars of Cycle of Love (Bars 1 -6, First Song) Modes Used in Cycle of Love Opening Five Frames of Tast-en Bar 6 of Tast-en Opening and Closing Bars of Tast-en Bars 63-74 of Tast-en Melodic Line in Stubble, First Bars Following Initial Humming Opening of Sacred Site (Bars 1-2) Cyclic, Swirling Ostinato in Sacred Site (Bars 2-3) Prokofiev Theme from Three Sections of Sacred Site (Bars 30-34, Bars 138-142, and Bars 149-152) Volley of Car Horns (Bars 153-155)
75 94 94 100 117 118 121 123 141 142 142 143 162 167 167 168 169
TABLES 4.1 4.2 4.3 6.1 7.1
Clarke, Piano Trio, First Movement Ternary Structure of O Saisons, O Chateaux! High Points in O Saisons, O Chateaux! Macrostructural Plan of Tast-en Henderson, Sacred Site
93 100 101 139 166
Acknowledgments
This book would not have been possible without the contribution of a great many people. Above all, I would like to thank Rosemary Schaffler. The task of writing was made all the easier because of her loving and generous support for me as a person and as a writer. Her guidance was invaluable, as were her detailed reading and editing of the manuscript and her perceptive comments regarding the content and overall organization. I would also like to thank Susan Erickson for her patient and careful editorial work in the final stages of the book. I am indebted to Susan for the musical expertise and specialist knowledge of the field that she brought to bear on the project. She gave her support with unbounded generosity. This was also the case with Gretchen Poiner, to whom I express sincere thanks for her reading and rereading of the entire manuscript at every stage of its writing. She offered thoughtful, practical, and conceptual criticism along with much encouragement. This book has been a long time in the making and bears indebtedness to many other people. There were those who supported and encouraged me in the early stages of the research. I would like to thank Anne Boyd and Terry Threadgold, both of whom were unstinting in their generosity of time, offering the greatest assistance and encouragement with infinite patience. I thank them both for their enthusiasm,and for guiding the direction of my thought with insights that have been inspirational. In many ways the book owes its existence to Susan McClary. Susan's courageous and pioneering work in the area of feminist music criticism has been visionary and is an exemplary model for this project. From the time of my first encounter with Susan McClary at the Gender and Music Conference in London in 1991 to the completion stages of the book, she has been extremely generous with her knowledge. I have benefited enormously from her comments, suggestions, and encouragement given during some of the written and oral presentations
XIV
Acknowledgments
of my work. I would also like to thank Marcia Citron and Nicola LeFanu, both of whom gave valuable feedback in the earlier stages of the research. To Moya Henderson I owe a great deal of gratitude. First, she provided me with unlimited access to her private letters, manuscripts, tapes, and unpublished writings and allowed me to use the scores and recordings of her works. Second, she was always willing to answer my questions in numerous interviews and personal communications. Third, she read parts of the book and made some extremely useful and practical suggestions. I am grateful to Moya Henderson for permission to include musical extracts from Sacred Site (which also appear in an anthology of Australian organ music by Currency Press) and Stubble. I also thank Elena Kats-Chernin, who kindly made time available to discuss her music with me. I have benefited from the help and guidance of my friends Idena Rex and Patsy Short, with whom I had many fruitful conversations and who read portions of the book in earlier drafts. I express gratitude to Caitlin Rowley for her support and assistance and to Alan Walker for his careful compiling of the index. To Eric Levy and his predecessor, Pamela St. Claire, editors at Greenwood Publishing Group, I owe special thanks for their patient assistance and help along the trajectory of the book's writing to its publication. To Deborah Whitford of Publishing Support Associates, I owe special thanks for her meticulous care of the manuscript. I wish to acknowledge my indebtedness to my colleague Julian Knowles for reading early drafts of the manuscript and for contributing very special insights with respect to contemporary performance practice in Australian music. Thanks are due to my colleagues David Hull, Michael Atherton, Diana Blom, Jim Franklin, Kim Poole, Ian Shanahan, Andree Greenwell, and Jean Callaghan for their moral support and encouragement of my work. My students at the University of Western Sydney have provided me with consistent feedback by helping me over many years to develop and refine my ideas. In particular, I would like to acknowledge the contributions of Adrian Renzo, Corrina Bonshek, and Lara Biernoff. I thank the School of Contemporary Arts, University of Western Sydney for providing me with time release and six months' study leave during 1999 and 2000.1 also thank the Research Project Unit of the School of Contemporary Arts for production support. My thanks are extended to the following music organizations in Australia whose staff so generously provided me with access to program information and other data used in the book: the Australia Council, ABC Concerts, Sydney Symphony Orchestra (now Sydney Symphony), Musica Viva Australia, the Australian Opera (now Opera Australia), Australian Chamber Orchestra, Australia Ensemble, the Song Company, Sydney Alpha Ensemble, Australysis, Synergy, the Seymour Group, Sydney Spring Festival of New Music, SBS Youth Orchestra, the Sydney Youth Orchestra, the Australian Youth Orchestra, and Camerata Australia. The development of the theoretical model in this book owes much to important feedback that I received from presenting portions of this research at international
Acknowledgments
xv
conferences (especially the Gender and Music Conference, Kings College, London University) and at national musicology and interdisciplinary conferences (especially Word-Voice-Sound: Interactions around Musics, Artspace, Woolloomooloo, Sydney 1996; and Resonances, the Australian Women's Music Festival Conference, University of Sydney, 1997, the latter of which provided me with an opportunity to discuss my work with the eminent scholar Suzanne Cusick). A special thanks to Trish Pearse, who listened patiently in the early stages of the research. Special thanks are also due to my dear friend Helene Trocme-Fabre, who nourished my thinking over a period of some 20 years; to Deborah Hayes for her very careful reading of the manuscript and helpful guidance; and to Therese Radic, Cate Poynton, Maree Macmillan, Peter McCallum, Linda Kouvaras, and Helen Rusak, who were always willing to share ideas with me. My thanks to John Phillips for uncovering some valuable material on Alma Schindler-Mahler and passing it on to me. I give thanks of a personal sort to myfriendsMarcia Perry Jones, Christopher von Keisenberg, Michael Farrell, Toni Kram, Ron Wilson, John Terry, Nigel Smith, Lyndsey Paget-Cooke, Rachael Hainsworth, Kylee Stevens, Lorna Lander, Bernadette Herzig, Sharon Goldenberg, Christine Kelley, and Amanda Zappia and to my brother John Macarthur. I wish to acknowledge the special role in my life during the book's gestation of Genefer Luff (now deceased) and my former high school music teacher, Marianne Helm (nee Rosenberg) (now deceased). Marianne's enthusiasm and encouragement triggered my desire to learn more about music, providing a starting point for what has since become a long, ever-changing journey through the kaleidoscopic realm of musical knowledge.
This page intentionally left blank
Introduction: For Women's Eyes Only?
There aren't many women in this book, and most of the ones I do include are teachers. ... Do I dislike women because I dislike ecriturefeminine—or bad ecriturefe inine? —Kevin Kopelson, Beethoven's Kiss Taking my cue from Kopelson,11 could begin by stating the obvious. There aren't many men in this book, and most of the ones I do include are theorists. Kopelson's book is an exploration of gender and sexuality (with an emphasis on homoerotic desire) in relation to pianism in the Romantic period. The women whom he includes are "maiden" piano teachers; a number of the men whom he includes are virtuosos. He asks why he does not write about female virtuosos—for example, "Martha Argerich, who's sexier than Horowitz and whose Tchaikovsky Concerto is the best on record"2—and concludes that it is because he (Kopelson) is "phallocentric." He says, "I prefer men—in bed. And yes, I'm phallogocentric. I prefer to argue—in print. But does that make me misogynistic?"3 On reading a book that boasts about being "a vivid (and startling) example of the 'new musicology,' "* I admit to being unnerved by Kopelson's up-front declaration about his preference for men, his apparent dismissal of women (with the implication that he is being misogynistic), and what seems like his loathing of Vecriture feminine (women's writing). My book wants to celebrate Vecriture feminine. It wants to celebrate women's music. Yet if I were to begin this book by adopting a tone similar to Kopelson's—declaring, for example, that I prefer women, that I am gynocentric (or "gynologocentric"), and that I dislike masculinist aesthetics (for want of a better complement to the term / 'ecriturefeminine)—it would be more than likely that I would alienate the vast majority of my readership, feminists included.
2
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
Feminist Aesthetics in Music is one of a number of recent books that focus exclusively on music by women composers. In dealing only with women composers, however, it runs the risk of being seen as a separatist publication (in some ways like Kopelson's) with something of a covert message that reads: "Open only if you are a feminist." But its intention is not to antagonize men, or women, for that matter, whether or not they wish to identify themselves as feminists. This book invites readers of all kinds to read what is written here, for I believe its message is important to all who enjoy music and to all who are concerned with the politics that divide women from men. In some ways, it is a book that adds to the remarkable array of information that has already been assembled concerning women composers of the past and present.5 Like its antecedents, it draws attention to the fact that women composers have always existed and continue to exist and that their music is deserving of attention. The problem with much of the work on women's music to date, as Susan McClary observes, is its failure to deal critically with actual music.6 In this respect, Feminist Aesthetics in Music fills an important void, for it deals in depth with a number of concrete musical examples. Careful analysis is undertaken of each piece of music chosen to demonstrate the theory being proposed. I want to show how understanding actual music provides insights into the social world that it inhabits. I contend that music is, in fact, profoundly implicated in the transmission of social knowledge. Almost by way of retort to Kopelson and others like him, I want to say that there are many women composers (professional composers) whose music is worthy of discussion. I want to assert that it is worth leaping into print and even arguing about this subject. That the music establishment has not taken women's music seriously (as Chapter 2 demonstrates) is a monumental mistake. There is no denying it, however, for women's music is not discussed in mainstream history of music texts as a matter of course, nor has it been analyzed to the same extent as men's music. In short, it has not been given the same kind of attention, including performances and broadcasts, that has been afforded men's music. The label "women's music" is a problematic one, for it immediately conjures up the idea that it exists in a domain separate from men's music. In fact, it could be argued that the category "women's music" has been brought about by the fact that men's music is simply music; women's music, to follow this line of thinking, is understood as something else. Perhaps women's music is not understood as music at all? But if it is music—as the vast amount of work by feminist musicologists since the 1970s has been at pains to illustrate—then the label "women's music" draws attention to the idea that there are divisions to be drawn not just between women's music and men's music but between men and women themselves. According to Elizabeth Grosz, Western culture is founded upon hierarchies that resolve into opposing terms. Inherent in these oppositions is the sanctioning of one term by defining the other through its negation.7 In this book I argue that men's music has always been highly valorized. Women's music has always been defined in relation to men's and has thus been devalued. This division between the two, with its negative connotations for
Introduction
3
women's music, underscores a fundamental problem that I encounter in this book. Put simply, it is this: How do I avoid reinforcing the distinction between men's and woman's music while at the same time drawing attention to the fact that women's music is deserving of serious attention? Dichotomies have the function of making distinctions mutually exclusive. Even worse, as Elizabeth Grosz states: "Dichotomies are inherently non-reversible, non-reciprocal hierarchies, and thus describe systems of domination."8 So if I were merely to reverse the dichotomy of women's music and men's music—to imagine women's music as the taken-for-granted norm and men's music as something else—I would be doing something quite counterproductive. Terry Threadgold points out that merely reversing the terms and leaving the dichotomy potentially intact do nothing to rescue women's music in terms of its specificity, its difference, or, indeed, its autonomy. Nor does this dichotomy allow for the fact that there may be more than two terms to be considered, that this binarism, as Threadgold puts it, "might be a quite arbitrary division into two of what is actually a continuum."9 In order to overcome this difficulty, which emerges wherever I find myself almost inevitably wanting to construct a dichotomy, I attempt to slip into the interstices that separate men's music from women's. I want to think about women's music as being part of a continuum encompassing men's music while at the same time, as contradictory as this idea may seem, separating it from men's music. On this last point, the surface ground suddenly becomes very slippery, for in order to come to grips with the idea that women's music may be different from men's music, it has become necessary to construct an arbitrary distinction between them. I want to make it clear, however, that these exclusive terms are not meant to represent the reality, but rather they are employed as the only useful way of thinking about the inherent differences. It is not useful, for example, to explain the differences that I have discovered in women's music with reference to what they are not (or what they are lacking) in relation to men's music. Nor is it useful to reverse the binary divisions so that women's music suddenly appears as a site of privilege over men's, the latter by implication thus viewed as inferior. For the reasons that I have outlined, it is not useful to set up mutually exclusive categories, the idea of the exclusivity of each category in this sense being ultimately unhelpful. In addition, the sample of women composers who are represented in this book is very small, making it impossible to generalize my findings. Furthermore, except in the instance of Alma Schindler-Mahler and Alexander Von Zemlinsky, I avoid making direct comparisons between women's music and men's. Based on the research presented in this book, I cannot make grand claims about women's music, regardless of its sociohistorical context, as being different from men's music. Rather, my aim is to demonstrate that women's music, which has a long history of being neglected, is deserving of the same kind of lavish attention that has been showered on men's. Throughout the book, however, I appear to be on something of a seesaw on the dichotomy issue. On the one hand, it may appear that I am, indeed, setting forth an
4
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
argument that women's music is different from men's. Moreover, it becomes obvious that I want to demonstrate its difference in order to celebrate its worth. On the other hand, it is apparent that I am painfully aware of the deficiencies involved in such an argument. The contradictory nature of these differing positions resurfaces over and over again in the book and is linked to the related issue of how to draw attention to women's music without becoming entangled in a web of dichotomous relationships. To complicate the problem further and in an effort to dispel the myth that women's music is inferior to men's, I draw connections between different kinds of music composed by women in different contexts. My purpose is to show that their music, linked as it is by some of these connections, has perhaps been denied because it has been misunderstood. When we speak about women's music, we invariably find ourselves using the problematic, but frequently bandied-about, term "woman composer." As readers of music histories know, the noun "man" is never used to describe men in composition. They are simply composers. This labeling "woman composer" is the other half of the dichotomy "(man) composer," yet the word "man" is always just implied. Women composers are thus defined in relation to a generic term grounded in masculinity with an implication based on a deep-seated belief in hierarchical difference. As Susan McClary puts it, " 'different from' implies 'inferior to.' " To avoid being tarnished by this difference and following suit more generally with the women's movement of the 1970s, women composers began to push for equality. This, however, was often misread as, and collapsed into, sameness. Thus, women composers preferred not to draw attention to their difference from men and stressed their sameness, that is, their ability to compose as well as men. As McClary continues: "Whatever differences existed were demonstrated to be relatively trivial, up against the ways in which the sexes shared the same capabilities. Because women had been excluded from composition longer than the other arts, many female composers have maintained this position of 'sameness' to legitimate their presence in what is still somewhat alien territory."10 There are many problems inherent in maintaining a position of sameness. As I have already suggested, the word "composer," for example, while seeming to be inclusive and neutral, registers as an exclusive term that is synonymous with men. The word "composer," used in abundance in history of music texts, corresponds to the idea that the history of music is actually a history of music by men. The majority of books dealing with music and composers thus discriminate against women composers on the grounds of their sex. In this view, the way the term "composer" is used in these books is neither innocent nor neutral. It goes without saying, of course, that the term "woman composer" is not innocent or neutral either. But it does not pretend to be, and this is the important difference. The problem is that use of the word "woman" tends to have a negative effect here, implying that music by women composers is of poor quality. For good reason, then, many composers who are women will often prefer not to draw attention to their gender, choosing to call themselves simply composers. This is where they find themselves in something of a catch-22, for being subsumed under the um-
Introduction
5
brella term "composer" means that women, in effect, are required to operate according to the rules of the category, to become like (or the same as) their male composer colleagues. Given that men have dominated the category "composer," it is not difficult to arrive at the conclusion that the norms and conventions that have been established in music are male. Having no alternative but to operate according to these norms, it is not surprising to discover that women's music has frequently been castigated because it does not measure up to these norms. It has certainly been shown to fall short in terms of the standards of excellence that have been seen to characterize men's music, at least that which has been canonized. As Susan McClary puts it: "The music that has been composed by women (despite all odds) has often been received in terms of essentialist gender stereotypes ascribed to women by masculine culture; it is repeatedly condemned as pretty yet trivial or—in the event that it does not conform to feminine propriety—as aggressive and unbefitting a woman."11 Women's music is frequently accused of lacking aesthetic taste, the implication being that it does not conform to particular ideas about taste. This is because the dominant aesthetic paradigm under which Western art music seems to be measured, even today in some quarters, has roots in 19th-century Romanticism. But how appropriate is this paradigm not only for judging music by composers more generally in the 21st century but also for assessing and determining the worth of women's music? It is widely acknowledged that 19th-century aestheticism is biased in favor of men's music. Yet, scholars such as Marcia Citron and Susan McClary are now showing that women's music has much to offer. Citron and McClary would argue that women's music is aesthetically pleasing, even when it apparently fails to conform to reigning paradigms.12 In this book I want to put a name to the different aesthetic criteria that inform women's music, calling it, perhaps somewhat problematically, "feminist aesthetics."13 In Chapter 1,1 dwell on the term "feminist aesthetics" in some detail, resuming my discussion of it throughout the book and in particular, showing that there are multiple ways to conceive of this term. The composers and musical examples chosen for in-depth discussion are used to demonstrate the idea that there is no single, universal, guiding principle that underscores the analytical strategy. The most important concept that I wish to convey is that there be a fluid relationship between the music and the analyst. I argue that this approach stands as a dramatic contrast to the majority of analytical methods used in music academies throughout the world. In Schenkerian Analysis and Forte Set Theory, for example, the opposite frequently tends to happen, and music is forced into the mold of the analytical system. In Chapter 2,1 explore the contexts in which women make music, suggesting that particular kinds of music become self-perpetuating because of prevailing ideologies. While the Australian context is used as a specific example (a convenience since I am located in that country), I am mindful of the fact that music practices in Australia are part of a much larger, global picture. The discriminatory practices identified are understood as being, in part, a consequence of the difficulties that
6
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
music organizations have when negotiating with a hegemonic European canon. If Australian composers as a group have difficulty in having music performed in the concert hall, then it is even worse for Australian women. The data reported in this chapter are read against a set of political and discursive practices that include vocabularies of excellence and nationalism in the domain of Australian art music. These, it is argued, function to reinforce and reproduce the music that has dominance. Discussion follows on institutionalized learning processes and practices, in particular, the Australian Music Examinations Board (AMEB). Drawing on Pierre Bourdieu's concepts of the habitus and the field, I argue that the structures that generate the music hegemony that I identify in the first part of the chapter are traced back to the concertgoing music lover's early childhood and adolescent musical training. I suggest that the habitus in the field of art music is collectively orchestrated to maintain and perpetuate this hegemony, leaving little or no room for women's music to make its presence felt. In Chapter 3,1 undertake a reading of the song Ansturm by the composer Alma Schindler-Mahler (1879-1964). In his book The Power of Sound,14 Edmund Gurney suggests that the presentation of music as motion corresponds to sexual (e)motion. It could be argued that the sexual metaphor invoked by Gurney draws on a conception of sexuality that is male in orientation. In addition, Gurney's sexual metaphor for music could be seen to have resonance with a number of analytical models that have been developed to study music, including Schenkerian Analysis and those that draw on the so-called divine ratio, or golden section. In this chapter, I suggest that these analytical models tend to have the function of revealing music to be great (and worthy of canonization) if it conforms to a notion of the so-called ideal structure, which, in turn, is based on a male/masculine sexual stereotype. I interrogate some of the assumptions behind analytical models that correspond to a male sexual metaphor (but which, nonetheless, invoke the notion of the ideal in music) and question their usefulness in relation to women's music. I argue that it is possible to identify difference in music based on a notion of a female/feminine sexual stereotype. I deliberately invoke these stereotypes because they have wide currency, but it is not my intention to leave them intact. Alma SchindlerMahler's music is used as a demonstration of the idea that women's music may operate according to aesthetic criteria that are different from those for men's music. In Chapter 4,1 continue this theme by examining the music of two English composers, Rebecca Clarke (1886-1970) and Elisabeth Lutyens (1906-1983). This chapter is in two parts. In Part 1,1 outline the debate concerning music and meaning, positioning myself somewhat problematically on the side of the argument that claims that music has meaning beyond its formal system. In Part 2, the first movement of Clarke's Piano Trio (1921) is discussed in relation to the theories that are concerned with the gendered nature of sonata form. I show how Clarke subverts the conventions inherent in sonata form, despite choosing to write in this so-called masculine genre. The aesthetic that underpins serialism could be argued to be the most alienating territory of all for a woman to enter. It is a system that has often been regarded as highly mathematical. Some have even thought it antimusical.15
Introduction
7
Susan McClary makes the point that serialism can produce sounds like the dissonant discourse of a madwoman. Yet, as she also reminds us, its major proponent, Arnold Schoenberg, was anxious to rid the music of its feminine associations. Drawing on Adorno, she says that having created his madwoman's discourse in his earlier expressionist works (McClary examines Erwartung [Expectation] in detail) he emerged [from a period of silence] with a systematic theory that permitted him to have it both ways: his technique of serialism succeeds in underwriting what sound like dissonant ravings with supreme control... . From this moment on, the rational frame guaranteeing social order comes to permeate the dissonant discourse of the madwoman, and the chromaticism of feminine sexual excess no longer poses a threat: henceforth it is appropriated—even generated—by the highest achievement of intellectual discipline.16 Thinking about the issues raised by McClary, I explore the ways in which Lutyens deals with the serialist aesthetic, focusing on her cantata O Saisons, O Chateaux (1943). I contend that this work can be read in terms of feminist aesthetics. In a similar vein to Clarke's Trio, this work is viewed as subversive in terms of its structure and its steady stream of gestural syntax. Chapter 5 begins by recalling issues raised in the first chapter, canvassing the philosophical positions that have been adopted by feminists as well as dealing with the problems raised by the concepts of equality and difference. Whereas the preceding chapters may have painted a gloom and doom picture for women in music, this chapter opens up possibilities for the theory proposed, drawing as it does on the work of McClary and feminists situated outside musicology. This is then put into practice by undertaking a close textual and score analysis of Australian composer Anne Boyd's work Cycle ofLove (1981). The theories discussed in the first part of the chapter are mapped onto the work itself. I view Anne Boyd's Cycle of Love as a process of semiosis in which I identify a fluid movement between the body and the score, the woman writing (from) the feminine (body). Rather than looking for the difference of who she is as a contrast to who she is not, I envisage her sounds to fall somewhere within the cracks, unable to be contained and constrained, occupying something of a different space. By proposing feminist aesthetics along these lines, I move into the realm of the elusive, positing the idea that woman, in contrast to man, defies definition. I am attracted to Alice Jardine's construct of woman as process which "is neither a person nor a thing . . . [but] is a reading effect, a woman-in-effect that is never stable and has no identity."171 argue that the stylistic properties of Boyd's work can be read as an exemplar of feminist aesthetics in these terms. A musical work such as Elena Kats-Chernin's (b. 1957) Tast-en for piano (1991) is frequently labeled postmodern, however that term is defined. It seems a useful label for works that are self-referential, use parodic techniques, and are liberally sprinkled with quotations of music by other composers and other sound worlds. Feminist and postmodernist theories, however, have frequently charted
8
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
similar, if not identical paths, undermining and deconstructing the principal tenets of modernism. In Chapter 6,1 make the point that deconstructive feminisms have much in common with deconstructive theories that have emerged out of postmodernist thought. Given that Kats-Chernin is a woman, it might be argued that a feminist, rather than a postmodernist, reading of Tast-en is more appropriate. But is a feminist reading legitimate if the composer is not a feminist? If a woman produces music, may it automatically be considered feminist? Kats-Chernin refuses identification with the feminist movement, so, on the face of it, the answer is perhaps self-evidently no. However, because postmodernist discourses tend to ignore feminist agendas, I argue that not only is it possible, but it is useful to read a postmodernist work using feminist theoretical tools. Thus, it is possible to lay claim to feminist, rather than postmodernist, aesthetics. Furthermore, postmodern theories of readership invite multiple reading positions. As in the previous chapter, the theoretical models outlined in the first part of the chapter are mapped onto Tast-en (in particular, Elizabeth Grosz's model of the Mobius strip for theorizing the mind-body relation). Chapter 7 follows with an analysis of composer Moya Henderson's (b. 1941) music in relation to its intertextualities. It explores the ways in which discourses of excellence, national identity, environmental issues, racism, and religion impact on the composer's life. These are then further scrutinized in her textual practices. It may seem that among the composers cited, more attention is given to Henderson. This is deliberate, for in the wake of the "death of the author,"18 this chapter posits the division between composer and analyst as a problematical one. In the second part of the chapter I undertake close readings of two very different works by the composer—Stubble (1975), an early music theater work created while she was a student with Mauricio Kagel—and Sacred Site for grand organ and tape (1983). I argue that it is possible to read her works using the theory proposed. I draw on philosopher Elizabeth Grosz's work to demonstrate the theory. As the countersignature to Henderson's own signature, I read her music, even if provisionally, against the dominant patriarchal paradigm of modernism. Both signatures, however, can never tie her texts to any fixed origin or provide them with a definite destination. It is never possible to fix and control meaning or to know in total the author's intentions. Nor is it possible to know the details of the reception of her works in all contexts of their performance. I illustrate in this chapter that feminist aesthetics become possible when we engage with the elusive qualities that exist both inside and outside the text (in this case, music) and with the themes that become enfolded from the context onto the text, and vice versa. This is the theoretical model, I believe, that gives birth to the notion of feminist aesthetics in music but one that is constantly changing, always fluid. The final chapter draws together the threads of the arguments of the book. It also draws attention to the fact that women composers have not, by and large, been viewed as being at the leading edge of stylistic development. Yet, as I indicate in this chapter, they have been at the forefront of genre development.19 In making this claim, I refer to the work of American performance artist Laurie Anderson and
Introduction
9
Australian composer Andree Greenwell who have been branching out to explore different concepts of genre (indeed, inventing new ones). Most genres operate according to male conventions and are thus governed by a male aesthetic. With the development of these new ways of creating music/art, I ask if we are now beginning to see the emergence of genres that exemplify feminist aesthetics. If this is true—and only time will tell—then it may be that, for the first time in the history of Western art music, women have come into their own, on their own terms. Perhaps they will be seen to be at the forefront of artistic creation. This is a startling thought that I hope will become the subject of some future investigation. The book as a whole ambulates from the general to the particular, from context to text, from the objective to the subjective, and from the impersonal to the personal, but the movement between these things is always fluid. Along similar lines to conceptions of music by Susan McClary and Lawrence Kramer, I regard the music itself as a site not where the context vanishes but where it appears. 20 In conclusion, I suggest a movement in the direction of both a feminist politics and a feminist aesthetics of music simultaneously. I uncover the ways in which politics and social practices operate in music to marginalize women composers, including the ways in which their textual practices are often misunderstood on the grounds of their difference. By using Judith Butler's notion that gender is performative, together with strategies of subversive repetition, I argue that entrenched attitudes will change. If alternative repertories are repeatedly presented, they will begin to assume the status of the norm. NOTES 1. Kevin Kopelson, Beethoven's Kiss: Pianism, Perversion, and the Mastery ofDesire (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1996). See, in particular, "Music Lessons," 117-136. 2. Ibid., 117. 3. Ibid. 4. Ibid., back cover. 5. An excellent review of the literature appears in Susan McClary, "Reshaping a Discipline: Musicology and Feminism in the 1990s," Feminist Studies 19.2 (Summer 1993): 399-423. This review updates that by Elizabeth Wood, "Review Essay: Women in Music," Signs 6 (Winter 1980): 283-297. 6. Susan McClary, "Different Drummers: Theorising Music by Women Composers," in Sally Macarthur and Cate Poynton, eds. Musics and Feminisms (Sydney: Australian Music Centre, 1999), 79. 7. See Elizabeth Grosz, Sexual Subversions: Three French Feminists (Sydney: Allen andUnwin, 1989), xvi. 8. Ibid., xvi. 9. Terry Threadgold, "Introduction," in Terry Threadgold and Anne Cranny-Francis, eds., Feminine/Masculine, and Representation (Sydney: Allen andUnwin, 1990), 1. 10. McClary, "Different Drummers," 79-80. 11. Susan McClary, Feminine Endings: Music, Gender, and Sexuality (Minnesota and Oxford: University of Minnesota Press, 1991), 18-19.
10
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
12. See McClary, Feminine Endings; Marcia Citron, Gender and the Musical Canon (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993). 13.1 use the plural "aesthetics" in this book deliberately for two reasons: first, to suggest the possibility of there being multiple ideas about "beauty" in music; second, in the spirit of postmodernist discourses, to avoid making universalist claims such as those that seem to issue from 19th-century aesthetic theory. 14. Edmund Gurney, The Power of Sound (London: 1880; reprinted by Basic Books, 1966). 15. Here is not the place to discuss the merits, musical or otherwise, of serialism. I touch on this issue in Chapter 4 in relation to my discussion of Elisabeth Lutyens' music. 16. McClary, Feminine Endings, 108-109. McClary refers to Theodor W. Adorno, "Arnold Schoenberg, 1874—1951," Prisms, trans. Samuel Weber and Shierry Weber (Cambridge: MIT Press, 1981), 147-172, making the point that Adorno does not construct his argument in terms of gender. 17. Alice A Jardine, Gynesis, 25. 18. See Roland Barthes, "The Death of the Author," in Image-Music-Text, trans. Stephen Heath (Glasgow: Fontana/Collins, 1979), 142-148. 19. This idea has some historical precedents. Susan Erickson points out that while Giulio Caccini in the 17th century is credited with the early development of the monody and with opera (Florentine opera), his daughter Francesca Caccini's monodies are highly regarded by scholars who have studied the genre. She was among the first to compose them. As Erickson reminds us, the 17th century was truly a revolutionary era with the advent of figured bass, monody, and opera, and Francesca was on the cutting edge of writing in these new genres. Elisabeth-Claude Jacquet de la Guerre was among the first to compose cantatas and sonatas in France. While these genres had existed for a while in Italy, they were new to France, and Jacquet de la Guerre was in the forefront of their composition there. Hildegarde of Bingen is a major composer of medieval monophonic composition. She did not invent it, but as recent scholarship has shown, she carried it to new heights. As Erickson remarks, however, despite the remarkable achievements of these composers, who made significant contributions to the development of new genres, they have not always been recognized for their efforts by mainstream musicology. My thanks to Susan Erickson for these observations (Personal communication, October 2000). 20. See, in particular, Susan McClary's reading of Bach's Brandenburg Concerto No. 5 and Cantata 140 Wachet auf'm an essay entitled "The Blasphemy of Talking Politics during Bach Year," in Richard Leppert and Susan McClary, eds. Music and Society: The Politics of Composition, Performance and Reception (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1987), 13-62. McClary provides a very clear demonstration of what I mean here, reading both these works as exemplars of the society in which they were produced. See also Lawrence Kramer, "The Musicology of the Future," Repercussions 1 (Spring 1992): 8.
1 Feminist Aesthetics in Music
[T]he question asked of woman "What does she want?"—is a question that woman asks herself, in fact, because she is asked it. It is precisely because there is so little room for her desire in society that, because of not knowing what to do with it, she ends up not knowing where to put it or even if she has it. This question conceals the most immediate and most urgent question: "How do I pleasure?" What is it—feminine jouissance—where does it happen, how does it inscribe itself—on the level of her body or of her unconscious? And then, how does it write itself? —Helene Cixous and Catherine Clement1 The codes marking gender difference in music are informed by the prevalent attitudes of their time. But they also themselves participate in social formation, inasmuch as individuals learn how to be gendered beings through their interactions with cultural discourses such as music. Moreover, music does not just passively reflect society; it also serves as a public forum within which various models of gender organization (along with many other aspects of social life) are asserted, adopted, contested, and negotiated. —Susan McClary2 The idea that artistic forms can accommodate a woman's perspective or that there is such a thing as a feminist aesthetic has a history that goes back to the second-wave feminist movement of the late 1960s and earlier. Referring to an example of this idea that predates the 1960s, Janet Wolff points out that "Virginia Woolf suggested that there is such a thing as a 'woman's sentence,'3 to be found in the work of women modernists like Dorothy Richardson."4 Since the 1960s, however, the most influential work to embrace the idea of feminist aesthetics—or, at least,
12
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
the idea that there is such a thing as a "woman's writing"—is found in contemporary French feminism, particularly that of Luce Irigaray and Helene Cixous. Taking the body as their reference point, they argue for the notion of Vecriture feminine, a French phrase that loosely translates to mean "writing (from) the feminine (body)."5 The concept of Vecriture feminine has also been extended to the visual arts. As Wolff reports, "Nancy Spero's work has recently been discussed as an example ofla peinture feminine."6 Wolff goes on to say: "That women can write, paint and produce culture which is no longer constrained within forms alien to their experience has proved an attractive and a liberating one for many artists and critics."7 She then discusses some of the problematic issues that are raised by the concept of a woman's art. Music has been slower to take up the idea that women's music adopts aesthetic strategies different from those in men's music. The major stumbling block, it would seem, has been the widespread belief that music—that is, "pure music"—is the most abstract of the arts. As a consequence, it is thought that meanings that reside in music itself can never be decoded in terms of the social and political contexts in which it is produced. In this view, music is seen as autonomous and disassociated from the social context. The idea that meanings are embedded in music itself, including meanings concerning the sex of a composer, was not really given serious attention until the decade of the 1990s. Speaking in the early 1990s about the possibility of feminist aesthetics in relation to music—that music may be marked by the gender of the composer—musicologist Julia Moore suggests that "men composers demonstrate their sociallyestablished ability to compel events, whereas women composers inject a more egalitarian perspective into patriarchal discourse."8 Moore's paper is furnished with examples of women Romantic composers, including Clara Schumann, who, she says, "made strategic moves to the submediant, while others favored continual modulation, thus avoiding any 'binary harmonic opposition.' "9 Several other music scholars have indicated the presence of feminist aesthetics in music. In an essay published in 1985, Eva Rieger alludes to this idea by pointing out that women have contributed in ways different from men in the various branches of music but that these have changed over time. The implication is that if their contributions have been different, then it stands to reason that their compositions, as part of that contribution, will also have been different. Rieger suggests that contemporary female composers may sense that there is a quality of flexibility in women's music from the past and absorb this.10 More recently, Rieger has argued that there are a number of similarities to be found in the music of 20thcentury women even while taking into account the specific social and historical contexts in which their music has been composed. She lists these as follows: 1. Many women composers have a special ability to create a maximum amount out of a minimum of material, a sort of "restricted aesthetics." 2. Many have a special preference for functional music. 3. Communication is of primary concern to them.
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
13
4. Women composers are more interested in constituent substance than in compulsive innovation. 5. They often strive to overcome binary contrasts. 6. The aspect of Ganzheitlichkeit means that they wish to combine not only various fields of art, but also the whole human being, body and soul, Mankind (or Womankind) and Nature. 7. They relate closely to their own bodies and the human voice.11 Rieger argues the merit of each point, providing numerous examples by way of illustration. For example, she says that although women have composed in all forms and genres, their social status in the 19th century meant that they were largely confined to writing parlor music. As Rieger says, they became skilled in writing music that could be easily performed—songs, and piano and chamber music predominate—and were less experienced in writing music for its own sake. Rieger suggests that this has meant that women have had a tradition in making the most out of limited circumstances. In turn, this gives rise to what she describes as a "restricted aesthetics" in the music itself. She goes on to suggest that a number of 20th-century composers—including Pauline Oliveros, Annea Lockwood, Anne Gillis, and Joan La Barbara—have perhaps subconsciously been drawn to write with a kind of restricted aesthetics by working with a minimum amount of material to create maximum effect. Rieger makes the point that in striving to overcome binary contrasts, women blur the past and present, creating music that is cyclical and thereby avoiding relationships in the music that are hierarchical. Lists of this kind, of course, are problematic because they entail drawing on stereotypes. But another problem with Rieger's list is that it is not beyond the realm of possibility that men will also exhibit the same kinds of characteristics in their music. I take up this issue during the course of the book. Nonetheless, Rieger claims that "gender is one of the most important determinants of human behavior."12 Since composing may also be viewed as a behavior, it logically follows that gender will influence the way in which men and women compose music. This, I believe, is a useful starting point for thinking about the question of feminist aesthetics in music. Another musicologist who takes up the possibility of feminist aesthetics in music is Marcia Citron. Her close reading of the first movement of Cecile Chaminade's Sonata for piano, op. 21 argues that the composer was possibly tampering with the norms of Germanic sonata form.13 Susan McClary also supports the idea of feminist aesthetics in music. In Feminine Endings1* she shows how the tonal system encodes the values of the dominant social class, which she identifies as patriarchal. Undertaking close readings of a wide range of music, covering most of the significant historical epochs in Western art music as well as dealing with some popular music representations, McClary shows how these values are inscribed in music that is taken to be absolute or value-free. Moreover, she suggests what a feminist intervention on behalf of a composer might be like.15 McClary's readings can be interpreted as offering the idea of feminine aesthetics that emerges
14
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
from, and is part of, a specifically feminine habitus, which also produces these performances of femininity. The notion of feminist aesthetics has been rejected by a number of scholars. Rita Felski, for example, suggests that it is ultimately unhelpful to insist on sexual difference as a means of projecting a positive identity for women.17 Felski claims that it is impossible to speak of a feminine or feminist nature of a text without investigating the social conditions of its production and reception. She argues that the value of the text can be determined only as an effect of the particular historical context in which it is created. She suggests that it is more useful to think in terms of a feminist politics of literary practice rather than a feminist aesthetics of literature. I agree with Felski that the politics of literary practice (and, for that matter, any practice) are crucial, for politics have an uncanny way of determining what finally becomes accepted. I do not concur, however, with her view that such discussion should exclude the text itself and its aesthetic properties. Felski's argument seems to be dependent on an assumption that there exists a set of rigid separations. She draws distinctions between the political context and the literary text and between politics and aesthetics, as if each of these excluded the other. These kinds of separations are arbitrary and as such are problematic when they are invoked for arguments of this kind. I view the text as having a fluid and dynamic relationship with the context. Indeed, the text cannot be separated from the context. The term "feminist aesthetics" is deliberately ambiguous. In feminist literature it seems to have defied rigid definitions. Luce Irigaray, for example, identifies the ways in which the production of discourse, texts, and representations are sexualized, and she seems to want to find "a space for women as women''' Thus, as Elizabeth Grosz puts it, Irigaray sets out to introduce "a genuine plurality into the monosexual [male] model."18 Discussing women and femininity leads Irigaray to affirm women's sexual identity as follows: "woman" is not one, is not an essence, but multiple, fragmented, polyvocal.19 This idea gives rise to a concept of feminist aesthetics that is highly elusive in nature. Yet, I want to suggest that the elusiveness of the term "feminist aesthetics"—that is, its deliberate resistance to concrete definition—is the very thing that makes it possible to imagine. Furthermore, I argue that it is possible to develop a theory of aesthetics that relates to women's textual (musical) processes and practices while at the same time it uncovers and reveals the patriarchal nature of the contexts in which they are produced. Indeed, it might be said that such theorizing is born of these revelations. This preliminary discussion begins to open up a theoretical minefield. On the one hand, it will lead to a deconstruction of the modernist conception of music, which situates it in the realm of the sublime and the transcendental. This conception of music, as I argue later, ignores the role of the body in the musical experience. On the other hand, I find myself embracing a feminist/postmodernist view that relegates music to the realm of Other and as a metaphor for the feminine. In this view, music is intimately connected to the body of its creator. Yet, as Linda Kouvaras points out, in both the modernist and feminist/postmodernist conceptions of music, notions of the ideal are questionable. Both imagine it to be beyond
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
15
signification: "Music is for both groups the ineffable, untouchable, sublime and, for the feminists' viewpoint, Utopian, being outside patriarchy."20 Aside from its resistance to definition, the term "feminist aesthetics" invokes at least two different kinds of meaning. First, it refers specifically to cultural artifacts created by women, including the ways in which these are created as a means of articulating a different voice within the fields of literature, art, and music. Second, in some ways linked to the first meaning, it refers to the feminine or to the female body itself. In other words, it is not simply a matter of the female body being different. It is also an issue of how female bodies function, how they are expected to function, and how they function socially. These issues underpin the work of the French feminists (particularly Irigaray and Cixous and Clement), who, as I have already pointed out, speak of Vecriture feminine. Influenced by psychoanalysis and semiotics, they contend that if a woman's body is different from a man's, then it follows that her textual practices will also be different. Although this is an essentialist formulation, it is nonetheless important to embrace it in this preliminary discussion. The distinction invoked here between men's and women's textual practices is an arbitrary one, yet necessary in that it is the only useful way to begin thinking about the differences implied. SOME MODERNIST CONCEPTIONS OF AESTHETICS There are several meanings for the word "aesthetics" given in The Oxford English Dictionary. It has come to be understood in the following ways: "Of or pertaining to the appreciation or criticism of the beautiful or of art.... Of a person, etc.: having an appreciation of the beautiful; refined. Of a thing: in accordance with the principles of good taste; beautiful. . . . Designating of, or pertaining to a 19th-cent. movement of artists and writers who advocated 'art for art's sake.' "21 This dictionary definition stems from the 19th-century view that works of art are autonomous and/or that the beautiful in art needs no bodily mediation for its understanding. This is an important point, for although the word "aestheticism" is a late 19th-century coin, aesthetic theory has roots in the foundational philosophy of the Greeks in which the body was seen as the enemy. As Anne Cranny-Francis points out, the notion of the body as enemy is demonstrated very clearly "in the Christian theology that was based on that earlier Greek philosophy."22 She continues: "In the writings of St. Augustine the body is presented unequivocally as the deadly enemy of the mind, will, spirituality and intellect. The body holds us back from spiritual apotheosis; it is torn by physical temptations which must be resisted if the pure self is to ascend to another, higher (than bodily) state."23 Drawing on Susan Bordo,24 Cranny-Francis notes that in this formulation the body is "the site of'slimy desires of the flesh' . . . that 'Plato, Augustine and, most explicitly, Descartes provide instructions, rules or models of how to gain control over the body, with the ultimate aim of learning to live without it.' "25 It is not surprising, then, to find that dictionary definitions of aesthetics tend to ignore the role of the body in the appreciation of art and that they thus assume that the artwork is
16
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
autonomous. Indeed, acting on the assumption that the artwork is autonomous, in the decade prior to the 19th century, Immanuel Kant developed a systematic theory of aesthetic judgment. As Lydia Goehr writes, Kant "intended to give to aesthetic judgement (contemplation and evaluation) an autonomy and uniqueness that would separate it from moral reasoning, i.e. from the rules both of theoretical and practical understanding."26 Goehr sketches the "four moments or desiderata" for what Kant described as the fundamental principles for "pure judgements of taste": 1. Such judgements should be held universally for all persons, such that all private points of view are suspended. 2. They should be derivedfroma disinterested attention, such that the viewer takes no interest either in the existence of the object or in the particular concept under which the object falls (what kind of object it is). 3. Aesthetic judgements should be purposive yet without specific purpose, for beauty is absolute and not instrumental. If an object looks as if it were designed for a moral, practical, or scientific end, and the viewer takes account of that end, then the viewer is not contemplating the object aesthetically. 4. Aesthetic judgements should depend upon a modality of satisfaction or sympathy, a reconciliation of all our mental faculties.27 The significance of Kant's work, as Goehr continues (and I paraphrase her), is that he was able to guarantee the autonomy of the fine arts by separating the work from its external utilities, giving rise to the notion that the true value of art lies in its transcendence. The experience of the transcendent in art is enabled only by pure contemplation.28 Kantian aesthetics became firmly entrenched in the 19th century, spawning a number of permutations. For example, the complex relation between art and nature, in turn, presupposed a range of other separations, including form from content, music from nature, and the distinction between the musical and the extramusical, thus legitimating the idea of music's autonomy from the natural world of mundane phenomena.29 All of these ideas were kept alive and well in the 20th century. Another leftover from 19th-century aesthetic theory is the assumption that it is not enough to separate moral and rational thinking from emotional experience with its bodily associations. In order to appreciate the work of art fully, the disinterested viewer (or reader or listener) must also be able to transcend the mind and enter the world of the sublime. As Eva Rieger writes: "The speculative philosophy of German Idealism attributed transcendence and the power of revelation to the musical work and preached the doctrine of eternal beauty. This ahistoric aesthetic . . . was similar to the cult of the genius. The composer was worshipped as a 'divine genius' . . . [and] the work of art was seen to be a timeless document of divine perfection."30 The rhetoric of pure contemplation, pure reason, impartiality, objectivity, and transcendence bound up with 19th-century aesthetic theory, then, ignores the im-
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
17
portance of the self, the body, and sexuality in the making and appreciating of art (and music). The experience of art is thus constructed such that it lacks a body for its mediation. FEMINIST AESTHETICS: EMBODIED OR DISEMBODIED? The notion of art without body in 19th-century aesthetics contrasts with a notion of art with body in a feminist conception of aesthetics. Feminists claim that the role of the body is crucial in the making and appreciation of art. In contrast to 19th-century (modernist) aesthetics, feminist aesthetics are seen to be profoundly embodied. Yet, it is useful to draw attention to a contradiction that emerges from French feminist theory on this point, for while proposing that feminine writing is an embodied writing, it also wants to imagine that the feminine itself functions beyond patriarchal inscription. To have it both ways would seem to be impossible in practice, for to function beyond patriarchal inscription is to function beyond social signification and thus beyond the material world and beyond the body. On this conception, French feminist aesthetics begins to resonate somewhat awkwardly with 19th-century aesthetic theory in which the body is viewed as inferior to the mind. What seems to emerge from this discussion of feminist aesthetics is a conundrum, for how can embodied practices be simultaneously disembodied? I return to this question in due course. Another problem that emerges in any discussion of feminist aesthetics viewed as embodied is that it is necessarily posited as an opposite to the disembodied aesthetics of 19th-century aesthetic theory. Such a separation between the two relies on a binary division that ultimately yields to what is, in effect, a flawed philosophy. As a consequence, it is ultimately unhelpful to insist on this division for projecting an alternative, positive view of art (and music) from a feminist perspective because binarisms are set up according to principles of hierarchies in which one of the opposing terms has dominance over the other. When stated within a system of binary logic, as Elizabeth Grosz argues, one of the terms has a positive, independent status from the other, which is defined as negative.31 In this formulation, "feminist aesthetics" would be defined as negative against the positive, independent status of the term (modernist) "aesthetics." To the extent that a substantial body of feminist literature argues that all textual practice is embodied practice, I argue that aesthetics (including modernist aesthetics) can never be seen as innocent or disinterested or, indeed, as sublime or transcendental.32 In other words, the feminist work to which I have been referring shows that all textual experiences operate on behalf of particular social interests—interests that are intimately connected to bodies—to sustain prevailing power relations. To return, then, to the conundrum that I posited earlier: How can embodied practices simultaneously be disembodied? I want to suggest that bodies as producers and consumers necessarily mediate all experiences of art, and, to that extent, art exists not in the transcendental realm outside signification but, rather, in the physical, material world.
18
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
In addition, it appears that embodied practices, frequently originating in childhood, though often forgotten as such, to invoke Pierre Bourdieu's notion of the habitus here, are molded over a long period of inculcation and become durable and reproducible in adulthood.33 Bourdieu maintains that aesthetic taste is not a static, immutable, ahistorical, disembodied concept but, rather, is acquired, taking form in adulthood after the long gestation period of childhood and adolescence. We form distinctions between things without realizing it and without recognizing that by the very act of classifying, we are also participating in the creation of unequal relations. Along the lines of feminist theorists who are critical of the ideal of impartial reason and while not specifically undertaking a gender analysis, Bourdieu demonstrates that it is futile to insist on the possession of a centered and autonomous human subject. EMBODIED AESTHETICS: MUSIC AND WRITING For the sake of this preliminary inquiry into notions of feminist aesthetics, however, it is useful to deal with the concept of a centered, autonomous human subject that is variously labeled "male" or "female" in order to ground what is being spoken about. This is a deliberate ploy and adopted for convenience, but as the book proceeds, it will become clear that identity can never be understood as a singular construct. It is always open to multiple and provisional readings, and wherever it is realized and/or enacted and/or performed, it is always and at all times different; it is never reducible to oneness and sameness. What, then, constitutes feminist aesthetics in music? I have already noted that feminist aesthetics is something elusive and ambiguous. Yet, when theorists first began to think about this idea, they did not always describe it as something intangible or indefinable. For example, a number of feminist scholars in the fine arts frequently discussed the work of female artists in terms of archetypal feminine symbols and forms.34 Cyclical patterns such as mandalas have, for example, become associated with the female or the feminine. Later in the book I explore some of the work in music analysis that draws on ideas about female or feminine archetypes. Two musicologists who are inclined to analyze music in these terms are Marcia Citron (with her reading of Cecile Chaminade's piano sonata in C minor, op. 21, referred to earlier)35 and Susan McClary (with readings of works by Laurie Anderson, Madonna, and Janika Vandervelde, as well as her brief discussion of Diamanda Galas).36 Both theorists arguably draw attention to feminine stereotypes.37 They do not shy away from the idea that the music evokes and invokes feminine metaphors that might be associated with the female body. They are, however, careful not to generalize their findings as if these would apply to all women composers. Perhaps, more importantly, they are careful not to claim that feminine metaphors belong exclusively in the domain of women. Both theorists would acknowledge that men and women alike have access to feminine images in much the same way as they have access to masculine images.
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
19
Citron and McClary toy with the idea that certain stylistic features of the music being analyzed may be available for reading in feminist terms. Yet, in the spirit of postmodernism, neither McClary nor Citron pins down in absolutist terms what characterizes the works that they choose to analyze. They recognize that identity, reflected here through the music "is not one', that it is a network of multiple positions, constructed in and through many chains of signification," to borrow Terry Threadgold's words.38 McClary and Citron also know that it is futile to suggest that women's music will sound like women's music as separate and distinct from the sound of men's music. Eva Rieger concurs with this idea, making this point: "When discussing the subject of women aesthetics, someone is bound to protest and say, 'Oh, but I know a male composer who composes exactly that way,' or T know a female composer who composes exactly the opposite.' "39 As Rieger continues: "This level of argument leads nowhere, as it is confined to personal experience."40 Nonetheless, Rieger, Citron, and McClary want to claim a space for their women subjects, to suggest that even while working with inherited paradigms and stylistic norms, women compose music differently than men do. Embracing this idea, McClary chooses to analyze music by contemporary women composers and performance artists who are concerned with their own representations as women in the music that they write and/or perform. It is important, however, to note that though all of McClary's subjects are women, each is uniquely different in her approach. She is the first to recognize that when considered as a whole, their music cannot be said to represent a unitary style. Rather, they represent a plurality of styles. In this view, then, the idea of an aesthetic broadly brushed across the range of these differences is impossible to sustain. In the 1990s, there was a shift away from some of these earlier essentialist formulations of feminist aesthetics. Scholars are now reluctant to define a text rigidly as feminine or feminist. This is because the characteristics that constitute a feminist or feminine text are unclear, not least because the subjectivities of these texts are viewed as multiple and fluid. Furthermore, it is apparent that a uniform set of distinguishing features will not apply to all feminist or feminine texts in all contexts. The complexity of the argument is beginning to be exposed. These ambiguities and contradictions have roots in the work of the French feminists (in particular, Irigaray, Cixous, and Clement, and, for different reasons, Kristeva) and, in different ways, in the work of the American theorists, including Alice Jardine and Teresa de Lauretis.41 Another anomaly that arises from theorizing feminist aesthetics is that women are compelled to work within the framework of inherited male styles. On the face of it, then, it would seem impossible to theorize women's music in terms of difference, for it might be said that women's styles are no different from men's. Yet, it is possible to detect an array of differences that exist between composers who are said to work in similar styles. It follows on this logic that while women's music may, perhaps, share features in common, it also displays many differences. Complicating this is the idea that women's music necessarily shares features in common with men's music. The critical point that needs to be considered here,
20
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
however, is whether there are more differences between men's and women's styles than there are within each of them. This point is important, for if it is the case that women work with male styles (a well-traversed terrain and one that French feminist theorizing, in particular, would corroborate42), then it would seem logical to conclude that it is impossible to distinguish the presence of a pure female or feminist style. Despite this, I argue that it does exist, however elusively, nonessentially, indefinably, intangibly, or ambiguously. For all the slipperiness entailed in the notion of a feminist style, it is also imperative to conceive of feminist aesthetics as being grounded and embodied. Thinking, then, that feminist texts exist in some transcendent or disembodied space is not helpful, for in its (negative) association with 19th-century aesthetics such a notion gives birth to the composer who can be only male. As Rieger says, the composer, "who was able to communicate the metaphysical through his music and who was venerated as one of creation's exceptions, as the human incarnation of the 'absolute,' could only be male."43 So, it would seem that the only possibility for the entry of women into composition is through the socially grounded material world. But then, as I have already pointed out, notions of transcendence, composer, feminists, women, feminine principle, and so on are all constructions of a real, material, social world. CONCEPTIONS OF DlFFEKENCE/DIFFtiRANCE AND MUSIC AS FEMININE Crucial to thinking about notions of feminist aesthetics is the idea that the body itself—the signifying practice of a real, situated body in the real, material world— is available for reading in aesthetic terms. This follows from the argument that bodies are themselves marked by gender, sexuality, race, class, and so on and that these same bodies make and produce texts, whether, to use Threadgold's words, "enacted and performed, read and written, heard and spoken, in verbal, visual, graphic, photographic, filmic, televisual and embodied forms, to name some."44 Part of Threadgold's own project is to trace the feminist concern with subjectivity and with identity and location and to examine the ways in which texts are discursively constructed in "complex dialogic and institutional contexts."45 Contrary to patriarchal views that insist on impartiality and objectivity, Threadgold attempts to demystify these in order to demonstrate that all textual practice is embodied practice. That is also a project for this book. Notions of identity, embodiment, and subjectivity inevitably give rise to notions of difference or, in Derrida's sense of the word, to differance, which simultaneously suggests both difference and deferral.46 Derrida's conception of differance is useful, for if the word suggests constantly and also simultaneously differing and deferring, then the implication is that it can never be static. As Sue Best writes on Derrida's view: "Meaning is an historical product that is subject to change. There is no final truth, no resting-place for meaning."47
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
21
While often accused of being essentialist, the French feminists (conveniently but inappropriately grouped together), particularly Irigaray and Cixous, open up spaces for women by proposing, though differently from each other, the idea of a female/feminine language. In the case of Irigaray, feminine writing is intrinsically related to women's bodies: "Women must allow their bodies to speak through those spaces"; women must write their bodies.48 I am a woman. I write with who I am. Why wouldn't that be valid, unless out of contempt the value of women or from a denial of a culture in which the sexual is a significant subjective and objective dimension? But how could I on the one hand be a woman, and on the other, a writer? Only those who are still in a state of verbal automatism or who mimic already existing meaning can maintain such a scission or split between she who is a woman and she who writes.. .. Not to contribute to making language and its writings sexed is to perpetuate the pseudo-neutrality of those laws and traditions that privilege masculine genealogies and their codes of logic.49 Cixous also locates the feminine in the body—/ 'ecriture feminine, the familiar slogan of all three French feminists—but conceives of it as something that is possible for both female and male experience. Yet, echoing Irigaray, and together with Catherine Clement, she writes: "A feminine text cannot be more than subversive: if it writes itself it is in volcanic heaving of the old 'real' property crust. In ceaseless displacement. She must write herself because, when the time comes for her liberation, it is the invention of a new, insurgent writing that will allow her to put the breaks and indispensable changes into effect in her history."50 According to Judith Still, the writing and speech of Cixous as they refer to woman raises "the twin spectres of ahistoricism and biologism."51 Certainly, it is true that this has been one of the major criticisms of French feminist theory. I would argue, however, that while popular in contemporary, critical feminisms, this is not the only interpretation that might be offered. It is possible that Cixous is taking a relativist stance on this issue, that she is proposing a new mode of writing for women while at the same time offering a recovery of their history from the standpoint of her own specific historical context and her own conception of what constitutes a female body. In this case, a tension is produced between a modernist versus a postmodernist interpretation in which a theorist adopts either an essentialist or a relativist position or, indeed, a position that lies somewhere between these two poles. It seems more useful to conceive of the spaces between polarities such as these than it is to buy into the notion that one mutually excludes the other. Furthermore, I would argue that those theorists who view Cixous' work as being ahistorical and essentialist are themselves seeking universalist answers to the problem. Julia Kristeva's notion of the feminine is interesting but perhaps the least helpful for the postulation of feminist aesthetics that relate specifically to women's bodies. Of the French theorists, Kristeva insists on attaching the feminine to the male body. Elizabeth Sayrs notes that both Kristeva and Irigaray seem to be seek-
22
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
ing a return to a female essence that is preoedipal, prediscursive, prelanguage. Irigaray's conception is of a return to a "pre-discursive, woman-identified womanhood." "For Kristeva, it is a return to a pre-repressed/preoedipal maternal essence."52 As Janet Wolff points out, however, Julia Kristeva's analysis "explored the possibility of subverting the patriarchal order in representation by writing from the 'semiotic chora'—the preoedipal (and therefore . . . the pre-Symbolic) moment."53 Wolff is not concerned with the fact that Kristeva attaches the "semiotic chora" to male poets, for what she claims is important is her examination of "the origins, in modernist literature, of a type of writing which escapes the confines of the predominating patriarchal culture."54 Wolff goes on to suggest that such writing is also available for a feminist cultural politics, a point with which I agree. My particular interest in Kristeva's work, however, lies in its analysis of language as music. She draws a connection between music and the musical, with the rhythms and sonorities of language, in turn, associated with the feminine. Kristeva views music as positioned as language's "other," indeed, as Leslie Dunn puts it, as "melos vs. logos," "sound vs. sense," "music vs. meaning."55 MUSIC AS FEMININE According to Kristeva, the feminine principle, the semiotic, is distinguished from the masculine principle, the symbolic order of representation, language, and social organization. As the negative Other to the symbolic, the semiotic functions, particularly in poetic language, as the transgressor of symbolic order: "Language tends to be drawn out of its symbolic function (sign-syntax) and is opened out within a semiotic articulation; with a material support such as the voice, this semiotic network gives 'music' to literature."56 In arguing for the distinction between the symbolic and the semiotic, Kristeva makes it clear that both modalities are inseparable within the signifying process: "Because the subject is always both semiotic and symbolic, no signifying system he produces can be either 'exclusively' semiotic or 'exclusively' symbolic, and is instead necessarily marked by an indebtedness to both."57 A number of writers have criticized Kristeva's model, because they seem to think that she insists on a rigid distinction between the semiotic and the symbolic. They argue that she is, in fact, reinforcing the binary separation between these modalities. For example, Linda Kouvaras remarks: "Such apparently innocent, usually celebratory metaphors of 'musical' language reveal how music, whether as discourse or in discourse, becomes implicated in the binarisms that organise patriarchal thinking, and thereby associated with the unconscious and the irrational as well as with the feminine."58 On this formulation, it could be that the distinctions between language and music arerigidlyopposed, even to the point of, as Kouvaras suggests, recalling Dunn, who, in turn, recalls Carol Flinn: "In blurring the distinction between music and musical metaphor, they essentialize music itself; it becomes the discursive Other
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
23
through an act of linguistic appropriation." Yet I would want to disagree with this interpretation and, notwithstanding the problems with Kristeva, return to what Kristeva herself says. The modalities are inseparable—Kristeva argues, indeed, for their inseparability—and it is thus never clear where the separation between the modalities begins and ends. Viewed from this angle, the binary division between the semiotic and the symbolic is more inclined to be dissolved. Like Wolff, then, I find Kristeva's model a useful one to theorize women's writing, art, and music, despite her resistance to the notion of feminist aesthetics or a woman's writing. As I pointed out earlier, Kristeva's conception of a feminine (rather than feminist) aesthetic, that is, the appropriation of the feminine principle, describes male literature.60 A number of music theorists have noted that music is intimately connected with the feminine, as Other to the masculine world of language and visual representation. For example, by showing how the body is linked to music (the body is positioned as feminine Other to the masculine mind), Richard Leppert reveals how music, in turn, is positioned as Other to the world of sight. Leppert's argument is interesting, for he shows that the body is both sight (and site) and sound.61 On a different tack, John Shepherd remarks, "The existence of music, like the existence of women, is potentially threatening to men." 62 Susan McClary amplifies this idea: Music has been coded throughout all Western history as a feminine medium that is in danger of escaping language, in danger of escaping our control. It is seductive, yet causes the body to move. It arouses emotions. It even arouses sexual passions and imitates them. We are reluctant to talk about it because it's scary stuff.... If s the fear of the presumably feminine qualities of music and our need to control these that keep it under patriarchal lock and key.63 Conceiving of music as an elusive medium, Jacques Attali argues that the whole of human society is constituted by the sounds of its makeup. "Because music is produced by," and here I quote directly from Elizabeth Wood's paraphrasing of Attali: and as a mirror reproduces or echoes, the complexity and circularity of the movements of history, it reflects a fluid reality. Music is prophetic . . . for it can provide us with a "rough sketch of society under construction" and can prefigure social change, which may be inscribed faster in sound than it transforms society. Music is political... for its appropriation and control is a reflection of power and the political hierarchy that is inscribed with precision into social systems of power. Listening to music, then, and thinking the social organization or composition that bears the marks of its time, we ought to be able to theorize, in a sense to "hear," the crisis of society in its sounds and noises and vibrations.64 Attali identifies a two-way fluidity between music (noise) and society; the sounds of society both constitute and are constituted by the particular societies that they inhabit and of which they are made. To extend this idea, it is useful to refer to the work of Deleuze and Guattari, who read music's narrativity as being in a con-
24
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
stant state of becoming. In this view, it is argued that music is both separated from, and contained within, the socius. As with Attali, Deleuze and Guattari recognize that there is a constant fluidity of movement between culture (noise/silence) and music, which, in a sense, is itself in a constant state of flux, in a constant state of varying the cultural theme while simultaneously appropriating from it. The sounds of culture become a musical variation, and vice versa. Every musical text is a variation of another musical text. Everything contained inside the framing contours of one musical composition is a variation of other musical compositions, themselves variations of others and of the sounds of culture. The territory of culture folds onto the musical text, which, in turn, folds back on its own musical territory when the theme embarks on its many variations. In the act of becoming deterritorialized, the theme sets up the possibility of becoming reterritorialized, and so on. It is never afinishedproduct. Constantly becoming, constantly shifting, unable to be pinned down, it ruptures the system. It has been important to lay out this theoretical groundwork, for it effectively informs the various readings of music undertaken in this book. Before concluding this chapter, however, it is useful to undertake a preliminary investigation into the problems that are potentially posed by postmodernist discourses to feminist theories. FEMINIST OR POSTMODERNIST, OR FEMINIST POSTMODERNISM? Feminism's challenge to patriarchal knowledge has been to destabilize and denaturalize categories of gender and sexuality, providing deconstructive readings of cultural contexts and texts to expose the assumptions and values that are held implicitly in themt. Postmodernism, too, uses the tools of deconstruction to undermine modernist, universalist values and to decenter the human subject, among many such things. As Linda Kouvaras writes: Postmodernism's challenge to modernism achieves two major reassessments in cultural perception. Firstly, it enables the realisation that "our culture is neither as homogenous or as monolithic as we once believed it to be,"66 and secondly, that Western representational systems (and music ... to be included in these) admit "only one vision—that of the constitutive male subject—or, rather, they posit the subject of representation as absolutely centred, unitary, masculine."67 The postmodernist work seeks "to upset the reassuring stability of that mastering position."68 It would appear that postmodernisms and feminisms are charting similar paths. The chief differences between these two approaches, both of which ostensibly deconstruct the principal tenets of modernism and its attendant ideologies, are, however, as follows. First, as a number of feminists have argued, feminism's modus operandi has been colonized by postmodernists.69 Second, in becoming principally the stamping ground of the male theorist, postmodernism has tended to ignore feminism. One of the few books to deal specifically with postmodernism and mu-
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
25
sic, a publication by Lawrence Kramer,70 would tend to support this idea. Aside from brief mention of the work of Susan McClary and Rose Subotnik, as well as Carolyn Abbate's discussion of the language/music division in which she brings techniques of narratology to bear on music,71 he glosses over, by virtually making invisible, the significant work that has been undertaken by feminist musicologists since McClary's Feminine Endings. This glossing over woman in postmodernist discourses is significant, for music "is so manifestly not a single universal language," to borrow Don Michael Randel's phrase.72 As Randel speculates, not only might listening as a woman expand the canon specifically to include music by women, as "the product of composing as a woman," but listening as a woman might offer something quite different from the existing, male-dominated canon and challenge "the canon of music theory."73 It is all too easy to gloss over woman and ignore the difference that might be thrown up by the female subject. The music analyst might be inclined to adopt the tools of postmodernism to elucidate music, especially if the subject claims that she is not a feminist. I believe, however, that a feminist postmodernist analysis of such music is warranted on the grounds that postmodernist theories of readership, for example, Derrida and Barthes,74 permit multiple reading positions. Once the text leaves the author's pen, it can be read in multiple ways in new contexts. Its very iterability produces the possibility of different readings from somewhere else. The author's intention has nothing to do with the reading position that I take up. I argue that attention is deflected from the author while elevating the status of the reader (performer, listener, analyst). Yet, it is important to draw attention to the question of reversing the authorship/readership dichotomy, for what we inevitably have when identifying a work from a composer's pen is only the trace of the composer. The composer's signature is countersigned by that of the analyst (performer, listener). The relationship between composer and analyst, like other dichotomies discussed in this book, is never rigid; the distinction between an authorial and readership position is inseparable, and it is never clear where the distinction begins and ends. An author can never be separated exclusively from a reader, and vice versa. NOTES 1. Helene Cixous and Catherine Clement, "Sorties: Out and Out: Attacks/Ways Out/Forays," in The Newly Born Woman, trans. Betsy Wing (Manchester: Manchester versity Press, 1986), 82. 2. Susan McClary, Feminine Endings: Music, Gender and Sexuality (Minnesota an ford: University of Minnesota Press, 1991), 7-8. 3. Virginia Woolf, "Women and Fiction," Collected Essays, vol. 1 (London: Hogar Press, 1966), cited in Janet Wolff, Feminine Sentences: Essays on Women and C (Cambridge: Polity Press in assoc. with Basil Blackwell, 1990), 67. 4. Virginia Woolf, "Dorothy Richardson," Collected Essays (see "Feminism and Mod ernism" in this collection), cited in Wolff, Feminine Sentences.
26
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
5. This term is defined differently from theorist to theorist. 6. Wolff, Feminine Sentences, 68. 7. Ibid. 8. Julia Moore, "The Social Construction of a Feminist Aesthetic," paper presented at the American Mus icological Society Conference, Pittsburgh, November 1992, cited in Peter J. Martin, Sounds and Society: Themes in the Sociology ofMusic (Manchester and N York: Manchester University Press, 1995), 153-154. 9. Ibid. 10. Eva Rieger," 'Dolce semplice?" On the Changing Role of Women in Music," in Gisela Ecker, ed., Feminist Aesthetics, trans. Harriet Anderson (London: Women's Press, 1985), 135-149. 11. Eva Rieger," T Recycle Sounds': Do Women Compose Differently?" Journal ofthe International League of Women Composers (March 1992): 22-23, reprinted in a shortened version in Leo Treitler, gen. ed., Source Readings in Music History: The 20th Century, Robert Morgan, vol. 7 (New York and London: W. W. Norton, 1998), 147-149. 12. Ibid., 25. 13. Marcia Citron, "Music as a gendered discourse," in Gender and the Musical Canon (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993), 132-135. 14. McClary, Feminine Endings, passim. 15. See, in particular, "Readings of Janika Vandervelde's Genesis II and Madonna's Live to Tell and Like a Prayer," in McClary, Feminine Endings. 16. See Chapter 2, where I discuss the notion of the habitus in relation to Pierre Bourdieu's concept of the term. 17. Rita Felski, Beyond Feminist Aesthetics: Feminist Literature and Social Chang (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1989). 18. Elizabeth Grosz, "Feminist Theory and the Politics of Art," in Catriona Moore, ed., Dissonance: Feminism and the Arts 1979-90 (Sydney: Allen and Unwin in assoc. wit Artspace, 1994), 151. 19. See, for example, Luce Irigaray, This Sex Which Is Not One, trans. Catherine Porter with Carolyn Burke (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1985). 20. Linda I Kouvaras, " 'Sweet Death': Strategies of the Feminine Grotesque in a Contemporary Australian Chamber Opera" (Doctoral dissertation, Faculty of Music, University of Melbourne, June 1996), xviii-xvix. 21. Lesley Brown, ed.The New Shorter Oxford English Dictionary on Historical Prin ples, vol. 1, A-M (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1993), 34. 22. Anne Cranny-Francis, The Body in the Text (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 1995), 4. 23. Ibid. 24. Susan Bordo, "Anorexia Nervosa: Psychopathology as the Crystallization of Nature," in Irene Diamond and Lee Quinby, eds., Feminism andFoucault: Reflections on R sistance (Boston: Northeastern University Press, 1988), 93. 25. Ibid., cited in Cranny-Francis, The Body in the Text, 4. 26. Lydia Goehr, The Imaginary Museum ofMusical Works: An Essay in the Philoso of Music (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1992), 168. 27. Ibid., 168-169, paraphrasing Immanuel Kant, Critique ofJudgement, trans, with analytical indexes by James Creed Meredith (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1952), 6-16. In The Imaginary Museum of Musical Works, Goehr notes that "Kant further divides aesthetic judgements into the beautiful and the sublime" and that he also "assigns music a low place in the classification of the arts." Apparently this is because "music is transitory rather than lasting" (N.36, 169).
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
27
28. Goehr, The Imaginary Museum of Musical Works, 169. 29. Ibid., 165. 30. Rieger, "Dolce semplice? " 138. 31. Two particularly clear accounts of this phenomenon are given by two Australian feminist philosophers as follows: Elizabeth Grosz, Sexual Subversions: Three French Feminists (Sydney: Allen and Unwin, 1989), xvi; and Moira Gatens, "A Critique of the Sex/Gender Distinction," in Imaginary Bodies: Ethics, Power and Corporeality (London and New York: Routledge, 1996), 3-20. 32. See, for example, Janet Wolff, "Reinstating Corporeality: Feminism and Body Politics," in Wolff, Feminine Sentences, 120-141; Helen Wilcox et al., eds. The Body and the Text: Helene Cixous, Reading and Teaching (New York: Harvester Wheatsheaf, 1990); Cranny-Francis, The Body in the Text. 33. See, for example, Pierre Bourdieu, The Logic ofPractice, trans. Richard Nice (Cambridge: Polity Press in assoc. with Basil Blackwell, 1990), 56-57. The word habitus is derived from Latin, meaning "bodily constitution;" it is associated with "condition, state, dress, get-up, expression, character." 34. An excellent book that analyzes the "feminine" stereotype imposed on women's art is Rozsika Parker and Griselda Pollock, Old Mistresses: Women, Art and Ideology (London and Henley: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1981). Griselda Pollock in Vision & Difference: Femininity, Feminism and the Histories of Art (London and New York: Routledge, 1988) explores the idea of a feminist intervention into art, taking the idea of a feminist aesthetic beyond the limitations that arise from simplistic sexual stereotyping. Also see Lucy Lippard, From the Center: Feminist Essays on Women's Art (New York: Dutton, 1985). 35. See Citron, Gender and the Musical Canon, 120-164. 36. See McClary, Feminine Endings, 132-147, 148-166, 112-131, 110-111. 37. For example, McClary reads Janika Vandervelde's sonic image of childbirth, which begins with a clockwork ostinato, as an example of "writing as a woman." See McClary, Feminine Endings, 112-131. "[A] woman's voice can at least be heard as a woman's voice1' (123). I discuss this more fully in Chapter 5. 38. Terry Threadgold, Feminist Poetics: Poesis, Performance, Histories (London and New York: Routledge, 1997), 5. 39. Rieger, "I Recycle Sounds," 22. 40. Ibid. 41. In Alice Jardine, Gynesis: Configurations of Woman and Modernity (Ithaca, NY, and London: Cornell University Press, 1985), for example, Jardine views woman as a process. Teresa de Lauretis also views woman as a process. She argues that for all social beings, subjectivity is constructed, and for each person "subjectivity is an ongoing construction, not a fixed point of departure or arrival from which one then interacts with the world. On the contrary, it is the effect of that interaction—which I call experience—and thus it is produced not by external ideas, values or material causes, but by one's personal, subjective, engagement in the practices, discourses and institutions that lend significance (value, meaning, and affect) to the events of the world." See Teresa de Lauretis, Alice Doesn 't: Feminism, Semiotics, Cinema (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1984), 159. 42. See, for example, Luce Irigaray, "Questions," in This Sex Which Is Not One, 119-169. 43. Eva Rieger, "Dolce semplice!" 138. 44. Terry Threadgold, Feminist Poetics, 5. 45. Ibid.
28
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
46. Jacques Derrida, "The Question of Style" in B. Allison, ed. The New Nietzsche: Contemporary Styles of Interpretation, trans. R. Berezdivin (London and Cambridge: MIT Press, 1985), 176. 47. Sue Best, "This Style Which Is Not One," in Catriona Moore, ed. Dissonance: Feminism and the Arts 1970-90 (Sydney: Allen and Unwin in assoc. with Artspace, 1994), 164-165. 48. See Jardine, Gynesis, 262. 49. Luce Irigaray, "Writing as a Woman," in je, tu, nous: Toward a Culture of Difference, trans. Alison Martin (New York and London: Routledge, 1993), 53. 50. Cixous and Clement, The Newly Born Woman, 97. 51. Judith Still, "A Feminine Economy: Some Preliminary Thoughts," in Wilcox et al., eds. The Body and the Text, 51. 52. Elizabeth Sayrs, "Deconstructing McClary: Narrative, Feminine Sexuality, and Feminism in Susan McClary's Feminine Endings," College Music Symposium: Journal the College Music Society 33.34 (1993-1994): 48. 53. Wolff, Feminine Sentences, 67. 54. Ibid., 67-68. 55. Leslie C. Dunn, "Ophelia's Songs in Hamlet," in Leslie C. Dunn and Nancy A. Jones, eds. Embodied Voices Representing Female Vocality in Western Culture (London: Ca bridge University Press, 1994), 54. 56. Toril Moi, ed., The Kristeva Reader (Oxford: Blackwell, 1986), 113. 57. Ibid., 93. 58. Kouvaras, "Sweet Death," xix. 59. Dunn and Jones, Embodied Voices, 55; Carol Flinn, "The 'Problem' of Femininity in Theories of Film Music," Screen 27.6 (1986): 58. Also see 56-72 for further discussion of the maternal voice and theories of nostalgic lack. 60. For example, Kristeva discusses the "semiotic" in relation to Mallarme, Joyce, Beckett, and Kafka, among others. 61. Richard Leppert, The Sight of Sound: Music Representation, and the History of t Body (Berkeley, Los Angeles, and London: University of California Press, 1993). See, in particular, "Introduction: Music, Representation, and the Scandal of the Body," xix-xxix. 62. John Shepherd, "Music and Male Hegemony," in Leppert and McClary, Music and Society, 158. 63. Susan McClary, Interview with Sally Macarthur, broadcast on The Score, ABC Radio National, 13 August 1991; cf. Sally Macarthur, "Celebrating Difference in Music at the 1991 Gender and Music Conference," Sounds Australian 33 (Autumn 1992): 9. 64. Jacques Attali, Noise: The Political Economy of Music, trans. Brian Massumi (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1985), 4-9, paraphrased by Elizabeth Wood, "Performing Rights: A Sonography of Women's Suffrage," The Musical Quarterly 19A (Winter 1995): 608. 65. See Gilles Deleuze and Felix Guattari, A Thousand Plateaus: Capitalism & Schizophrenia, trans. Brian Massumi (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1987), 299-309. 66. Kouvaras, "Sweet Death," xiv, cites Craig Owens, "The Discourse of Others: Feminists and Postmodernism" in Hal Foster, ed., The Anti-Aesthetic: Essays on Postmoder Culture, 5th ed. (Washington, DC: Bay, 1987 [1983]), 58. 67. Ibid. 68. Ibid. 69. See, for example, Patricia Waugh, "Modernism, Postmodernism, Feminism: Gender and Autonomy Theory," in Patricia Waugh, ed., Postmodernism: A Reader (London, New
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
29
York, Melbourne and Auckland: Edward Arnold, a Division of Hodder and Stoughton, 1992), 189-204. Also see Meaghan Morris, The Pirate's Fiancee: Feminism, Reading, Postmodernism (London and New York: Verso, 1988), particularly the "Introduction: Feminism, Reading, Postmodernism," 1-16. 70. Lawrence Kramer, Classical Music and Postmodern Knowledge (Berkeley, Los Angeles, and London: University of California Press, 1995). 71. Kramer references his discussion to Carolyn Abbate, Unsung Voices: Opera and Musical Narrative in the Nineteenth Century (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1991). Moreover, Kramer is concerned with applying his insights to music of the past; he ignores contemporary music. Another book, by Michael Chanon, Musica Practica: The Social Practice of Western Music from Gregorian Chant to Postmodernism (London: Verso, 1994) as Kouvaras in "Sweet Death" points out, "astoundingly, despite the title, does not mention feminism and only allots two sentences to two women composers (Fanny Mendlessohn, to whom he does not even grant the preferred nomenclature of Mendelssohn-Hensel, and Clara Schumann) in the book's 287 pages, covering seven centuries of Western music-making," xxxix. 72. Don Michael Randel, "The Canons in the Musicological Toolbox," in Katherine Bergeron and Philip V. Bohlman, eds., Disciplining Music: Musicology and Its Canons (Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press, 1992), 18. 73. Ibid. 74. See Jacques Derrida, "Signature Event Context," in Peggy Kamuf, ed., A Derrida Reader: Between the Blinds (New York: Harvester Wheatsheaf, 1991), 80-111, especially "Signature," 106-109; Barthes, "The Death of the Author," 142-148.
This page intentionally left blank
2
Music in Context and Practice
Music by women heard en masse confused me by jumping the barrier of scholarly detachment that I was expected to keep around me. It left me feeling awkward, both at home and not at home. This was music coming from the same general experience of life as mine. I began to realise that to grasp its meaning a whole new set of analytical tools and a new perspective on its context was possibly necessary. The tools to hand were plainly not fitted to the task. They were devised by men for men's music. The place women's music occupied within music and society seemed to be more subtext than context. —Therese Radic1 This chapter is in two parts. The first explores the conditions under which composition and performance operate, using the Australian context as a case in point— and for convenience, given that I am located in that country. Statistical data are included to support the claim that women's music occupies a vastly inferior position when compared to music by men. This finding is explained, in part, by the dominance of the hegemonic European canon on concert platforms. In Part 2 the data reported in Part 1 are read against a set of discursive practices that are ideological in nature. These include vocabularies of "excellence" and nationalist agendas that, I argue, function to reinforce and reproduce the music that has dominance. I examine institutionalized learning processes and practices, taking the Australian Music Examinations Board (AMEB) as a particular example. The central question framing this part of the chapter is: To what extent do the social, pedagogical, and political practices that constitute musical performance and composition become durable and self-perpetuating?
32
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
PARTI Feminist critiques of music point to the dominance of male traditions and practices.2 An emergent branch of musicology, feminist work has identified the almost total maleness of music's public image, from the occupation of senior positions in university music departments,3 to the overwhelming preoccupation by scholars and practitioners with music composed by men. Along the lines of feminist work in other disciplines, much of the feminist work in musicology begins with, but seeks to go beyond, concerns that tend to emphasize equity within the profession. Yet, as a way of establishing what it means to be men and women participants in the context of Australian composition, it seemed useful to begin with a basic survey of major music organizations that commission and perform Australian music. While I make use of quantitative information to give a rough indication of what is happening on Australian concert platforms, I more importantly allude to the ways in which participants locate themselves in contemporary music culture. Moreover, in Part 21 raise questions about the descriptive statistical information presented in Part 1 by situating the findings within a much broader, critical line of inquiry. I argue that the concertgoing music lover's early childhood training is profoundly implicated in perpetuating the kind of music that has dominance on Australian and, by inference, world concert platforms. In making this claim, I am not suggesting that mainstream concert music does not have value. On the contrary, it is music to which I was, and continue to be, deeply attached. I raise the point, however, for what I have found is that there is a virtual exclusion of women's music from the concert hall. As Australian feminists working in the social sciences have shown, women's participation in the workforce at large has improved since the late 1970s, but, as Gretchen Poiner points out, there is still a long way to go.4 Nonetheless, the small improvements that have been made can be attributed to a number of factors, including the implementation of legislation by the Australian government aimed at improving the position of women in the paid workforce.5 Consistent with these improvements, it would seem that women working as professional artists are a well-represented group. The Australia Council report But What Do You Do for a Living? highlights the fact that there has been a notable increase in the number of women working as professional artists, stating that in 1993 women constituted 50 percent of this group. The report also acknowledges that most of these women are visual artists, actors, and writers. Composers make up the smallest group: 3 percent of all artists surveyed, while musicians and singers account for the largest proportion, 29 percent.6 The report also demonstrates that professional artists in general are a valued sector within the workforce. Artists contribute around 3 percent of the gross domestic product and 5 percent of employment. Yet, as the National Agenda for Women states, "Women have been traditionally active in all the arts, but their contribution to Australia's artistic and cultural heritage has been largely unrecognised."7
Music in Context and Practice
33
Despite the steady increase in women's paid employment, the report also noted that women artists earn significantly less than male artists do.8 Because of this difference in income, it would seem that a large number of aspiring women artists take up positions as arts administrators in the hope of gaining access at a later time to a more sustainable arts practice. Other women juggle household and family needs with their work and find that they have significantly fewer hours in the day to create their art. It is almost impossible for women to gain entry in some fields of art. For example, there are very few women who are directors in subsidized theater companies, and very few succeed as conductors of professional orchestras. In addition, the sheer struggle for recognition by Australian women composers, who occupy a significantly inferior position to their male counterparts, signals that there are structural barriers within the world of the professional arts.9 The national data show that approximately 20 percent of Australia's composers are women.10 This percentage taken from the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS), loosely accords with the figure of approximately 17 percent released by the Australian Music Centre in July 1996 (an organization that introduced composer representation in 1988). The message from these statistics is that women composers are an underrepresented group, falling well short of the figure of 50 percent calculated for all artists working professionally in Australia. Since 1982 the Australia Council, the federal government's funding body for the arts, has spearheaded a number of studies on women in the arts.11 The conclusion to be drawn from these studies is that while some improvements are noted, especially in the area of the funding of women composers by the Australia Council itself, little has changed over the decade (1985-1995) to improve the circumstances for women composers in Australia. In fact, not one of these studies is particularly concerned with the plight of women composers. Moreover, it would seem that when women constitute the focus of some of these studies, it is as arts administrators rather than arts practitioners. In their pilot study Paths to Performance: Gender as a Theme in Professional Music Careers,n Mira Crouch and Jenny Loveric examine women's participation in two prominent Sydney orchestras, the Sydney Symphony Orchestra (SSO) and the Australian Chamber Orchestra (ACO). This is a study aimed at addressing issues of equity between the sexes, focusing on the conditions that affect their progression to professional status in music and including a brief analysis of the psychosocial variables involved. Many of the findings in this study correlate with those of similar studies of women's workplace conditions in fields other than music, showing prejudice based on sexual stereotyping and highlighting conflict between paid work and career and the demands of motherhood and child care. Moreover, the findings in this study can be correlated to statistical data for women in American orchestras. Conclusions from a survey conducted in 1995-1996 by the Women's Philharmonic of orchestras throughout the United States established that women conductors, composers, and performers are still significantly disadvantaged in America's concert halls.13 While the situation may seem dismal for women musicians in America and Australia, it is even worse for
34
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
women whose aspirations are to perform in some European orchestras. According to data obtained by Varda Ullman Novick, women's participation in Austrian and German orchestras is 16 percent. When this statistic is compared with women's participation in orchestras in the United States (36 percent) and the United Kingdom (30 percent), there would seem to be a significant difference, indicating a more equitable policy in those countries.14 Particularly resistant to the notion of including women among its ranks at the time when I conducted my own study of Australian music was the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra, which until very recently had a policy of categorically excluding female membership. The harpist of that orchestra, who was a full-time paid member, was the exception to this rule.15 It would seem that women are a marginalized group within the music profession as a whole. Their most conspicuous absences are in positions commanding power and prestige, particularly as principal players in orchestras and as conductors and composers. British composer Nicola LeFanu would seem to have supported this view, for while she claimed that in 1987 women composers in her country constituted 15 percent of the composing population (compared with approximately 13 percent in Australia at that time16), the Arts Council of Great Britain awarded only 4 percent of major bursaries, 5 percent of minor bursaries and 6 percent of composer commissions to women between 1983 and 1987.17 Commiserating with her British colleague, American-born Australian composer Mary Mageau notes in 1991 that during the 1988 Australian bicentennial celebrations no woman received a federal bicentenary commission, and she goes on to state: Not one of some 40 opportunities from the Bicentenary, the ABC-sponsored Musica Nova Festival of 1990 or the ABC Classic CD collection has been given to a woman during the past few years. The January 1991 Sounds Australian Update states that 41 Austral symphonic works will be performed by the six state orchestras during the current concert season. The 41 works are composed by 22 composers. All but one of these (Anne Boyd) men.18 Of 175 Australian composers working in 1991, 154 were men, and 21 (12 percent) were women.19 For the quantitative observations being made here, it would seem that women composers were discriminated against during the Australian bicentenary. Mageau's numbers thus flag a serious problem. To date, no proper study has been conducted to investigate the particular situation for women composers in Australia. Musicologists specializing in Australian music studies have been preoccupied with the music of male, elitist composers situated in "high culture."20 Australian music within musicology as a whole, as Bruce Johnson points out, is an underresearched area due to the importance attached to European Western art music by Australian academies. When it is studied, the preponderance of work produced is concerned with Australian male composers.21
Music in Context and Practice
35
As a consequence, I carried out my own investigation of women composers in the context of Australian performance practice in general. National music companies operating from Sydney in the decade 1985-1995 were selected. I hypothesized that Australia's art music companies are thoroughly unified in their programming in four respects, that is that the concertgoing public hears music that is: • predominantly composed before 1900 • predominantly composed before 195022 • weighted toward music by non-Australian composers (in particular, European composers) • gender-biased toward men's music Before presenting my findings, it is important to make clear that I view the descriptive statistics presented in this part of the chapter as neither a demonstration nor a proof of the problem. Rather, they are used to raise a problem, and I use them to add to the qualitative argument that I develop in Part 2. Second, I did not calculate the total number of works that exist for the concert hall, thus providing a general context in which to situate my findings. Such an undertaking would have been a monumental task in the present work. I did, however, provide a context for all the Australian music performed, including that by women. By and large, the majority of women's music performed was Australian. Approximately 6,575 works are available to concert programmers, as compiled from catalogs provided by the Australian Music Centre. Of this number, women's music amounts to 1,212 works, or about 18 percent of all Australian music written.23 This roughly accords with their representation as a group by the Australian Music Centre (in June 1996, women constituted approximately 17 percent of the composer population). Another important point to be made in the context of this study is that it might be argued that the pool of women's music from which music programmers select works in each of the canonical periods of music represented on Australian concert platforms is significantly lower than that of men's. This is, of course, the case. As Australian musicologist Therese Radic writes: "The encyclopedist. .. Aaron Cohen has calculated that there are or have been some 70,000 composers of European high-art music, not all living in Europe. 92 percent are male."24 Women's music, according to Cohen, then, constitutes only 8 percent of all high-art music. Yet, as Mary Mageau, writing in the same issue of 24 Hours as Radic, notes from Cohen's two-volume, second published edition of the International Encyclopedia of Women Composers?5 there are more than 6,200 entries of women composers from 72 countries (including 630 from behind the Iron Curtain), and more than 4,000 of the women composers listed were from the 20th century alone.26 While I have not counted the number of women composers listed in a more recent source, The New Grove Dictionary of Women Composers?1 which used Cohen's two-volume tome as a starting point, it can be safely assumed that the number of women composers recovered from history as well as those repre-
36
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
sented in the 20th century is more than the number listed by Cohen. I thus argue that women's music does exist as an alternative to the usual "malestream" music and could be programmed should companies wish to do so. Moreover, the alternatives are often very attractive when considered against the usual music selected by programmers. For example, should music companies consider performing high Renaissance and early Baroque music, they would be rewarded by including a selection of madrigals by Barbara Strozzi or some of the instrumental music of Francesca Caccini. Should they decide to program a selection of French baroque music (e.g., Couperin or Lully), they would find the highly innovative music of Elisabeth-Claude Jacquet de la Guerre an irresistible companion. While there is less, perhaps, from which to choose in the Haydn/Mozart era, the 19th century's offerings include high-quality music by Fanny Mendelssohn-Hensel, Clara Schumann, Louise Farrenc, Carlotta Ferrari, Louise Adolpha Le Beau, Cecile Chaminade, Josephine Lang, Ethel Smyth, Amy Beach, and many others. Moreover, the approach taken to music programming by key national music companies in Australia produces a cumulative effect. Those institutions that are primarily concerned with mainstream repertoire (music composed prior to 1900 and music composed in a post-Romantic idiom before 1950) are also less likely to perform Australian music and music by women composers. Those institutions that perform contemporary music are more likely to include more music by Australian composers and also tend to include a higher proportion of music composed by women than mainstream ensembles. Of the groups surveyed, 69 percent were mainstream ensembles; fewer contemporary performance companies were represented, owing to the financial constraints that result from the difficulties of attracting audiences to concerts.28 The findings of my study seem to support the suppositions of my hypothesis.29 A rough calculation of descriptive statistics for all music groups surveyed in the decade 1985-1895 revealed the following: • from a total number of 15,301 works performed, 8,688 (or approximately 57 percent) were composed before 1900 • from a total of 15,035 works performed, 10,840 (or approximately 72 percent) were composed before 1950, much of it in the post-romantic tradition • from a total of 14,995 works performed, 12,794 (or 85 percent) were composed by non-Australian composers • from a total of 15,216 works performed, 14,892 (or 98 percent) were composed by men I have deliberately documented the statistics on men's music because they compellingly highlight women's music as being virtually absent. This is the case for all the statistics presented in this chapter. Figure 2.1 presents a graph of the percentages for all groups surveyed. Similar findings to those above are reflected in the data for the Sydney Morning Herald (see Figure 2.2). The statistics for music reviewed in the Sydney Morning
Music in Context and Practice
37
Figure 2.1 Repertoire Findings for All Groups Surveyed, 1985-1995
Herald for the decade 1985-1995 do not seem to be significantly different from those presented in Figure 2.1: • from a total of 9,363 works reviewed, 5,549 (or approximately 59 percent) were composed before 1900 • from a total of 9,471 works reviewed, 6,882 (or approximately 74 percent), much of it in the post-romantic tradition, were composed before 1950 • from a total of 9,363 works reviewed, 8,036 (or approximately 86 percent) were composed by non-Australian composers • from a total of 9,363 works reviewed, 9164 (or approximately 98 percent) were composed by men The marginalization of more radical forms of music is not an uncommon phenomenon in the 20th century. For example, the Schoenberg school has never had wide acceptance from concertgoing audiences. Yet I would argue that an important reason for the dominance of conservative music on Australian concert platforms is that art music audiences prefer to hear familiar "museum" music. While most music organizations might suppose that they have autonomy over the selection of repertoire performed, I suggest that this is not the case. There is a circular dynamic between the market and music organizations in which organizations are reactive to, and reproductive of, the market, and vice versa. For example, from 1985 until 1992, the chamber music organization Musica Viva relied on the general manager (and on an artistic director from 1993) to select repertoire and create concert programs in conjunction with those groups, mostly from abroad, that it had selected to undertake Australian tours each year. By and large, Musica Viva's programs reflect the conservative tastes of its market, which tends to demand the inclusion of the obligatory Classical, Romantic, and early
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
38
Figure 2.2 Repertoire Findings for Music Reviewed in the Sydney Morning Herald, 1985-1995
20th-century work in a typical concert program. Safe, familiar music appeals to mass audiences for high art music. Despite its attempts to introduce 20th-century music to its audiences, the data presented for the SSO show overwhelmingly that the bulk of repertoire that it performs on the concert platform is as I have previously described. Figure 2.3 presents a graph of percentages of a total of 1,447 works performed: • • • •
841 (or approximately 58 percent) were composed before 1900 1,245 (or approximately 86 percent) were composed before 1950 1,335 (or approximately 92 percent) were composed by non-Australian composers 1,441 (or approximately 99.5 percent) were composed by men
Women's music, as clearly illustrated in all three figures, would seem to be a much less desirable commodity on concert platforms, for, as the descriptive statistics suggest, it is barely heard, a situation that is especially exemplified in the data obtained from the SSO concert brochures. To a certain extent, these findings are self-evident but are nonetheless worth spelling out. Concert hall music in late 20th-century Australia is dominated by male composers of European descent whose music was composed before 1950. No doubt concert managements would argue that this phenomenon is attributed to the fact that the largest proportion of repertoire available for programming belongs in the Western art music tradition and, by comparison, the pool of Australian works is relatively small. Given that 6,575 Australian works are available for performance on concert platforms, I would estimate that Australian music constitutes approximately 15 percent of all the available concert hall music. Yet it needs to be pointed out that many of the non-Australian works analyzed in this study (a total of 12,794 performed) probably received multiple performances over the decade. On the other hand, Australian works (2,201 works performed) probably received only one performance each over the 10-year period surveyed.30 This would significantly skew
Music in Context and Practice
39
Figure 2.3 Repertoire Findings for Music Performed by the SSO, 1985-1995
the findings for the representation of Australian music. On this observation, it is highly likely that Australian music is discriminated against on concert platforms. I have dwelled on this point for two reasons: first, with few exceptions, most of the Australian repertoire performed was composed after 1950 and is thus situated in the unpopular category of contemporary music; second, most of the women's music performed in the decade was by Australian women. I suggest that women are disadvantaged for two reasons: because their music is situated within the unpopular category of contemporary Australian music and because they are women. My findings also show that contemporary music performance in Sydney is subordinated to the performance of "museum" music. It is thus argued that within the network of musical power in Sydney, the larger ensembles, with their emphasis on music from the past, have a virtual monopoly over contemporary performance practice as a whole. This is a self-evident phenomenon. The contemporary music groups, all drawing small audiences to their concerts, struggle to survive financially. Performing music composed in the 20th century and regularly commissioning and premiering works from composers based in Australia and abroad, they operate precariously on the edges of the larger and more popular companies. Figure 2.4 illustrates the percentage of Australian music performed by contemporary music ensembles against that of women's music.31 The groups shown in Figure 2.4 are as follows: Song Company (SC), Sydney Alpha Ensemble (SAE), Sydney Spring Festival of New Music (SSFNM), Australysis (AUS), Synergy (SYN) and the Seymour Group (SEY). It might be expected that if an ensemble performs a large proportion of Australian music, it might also perform more music by women. This is not always the case, however. Sydney Alpha Ensemble is the exception to this rule, for while almost half its repertoire is by Australian composers, it also performs the greatest proportion of music by women. In contrast to this, well over half of the repertoire of the percussion ensemble Synergy is by Australian composers, and yet it in-
40
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
Figure 2.4 Percentage of Australian Music and Women's Music Performed by Contemporary Music Ensembles, 1985-1995
eludes significantly less music by women composers. This is not an unusual finding, however, for women are not as visible as men are in the area of percussion performance. The logical expectation, therefore, is that women will compose less music for a percussion ensemble than men will. The descriptive statistics for contemporary ensembles, while reflecting a commensurately smaller proportion of women's music performed in comparison to the total percentage of Australian music performed, starkly contrasts with the significantly lower percentages of Australian music performed by mainstream ensembles, where, in turn, women's music is virtually invisible. Figure 2.5 below shows that the percentage of Australian music performed by mainstream music ensembles is greater than that for women's music. The groups represented in Figure 2.5 are as follows: Sydney Symphony Orchestra (SSO), Australian Chamber Orchestra (ACO), Australian Youth Orchestra (AYO), Camerata Australia (CA), Sydney Youth Orchestra (SYO), SBS Youth Orchestra (SBS), Australia Ensemble (AE), Song Company (SC) and Australian Opera (AO).32 By and large, all groups surveyed in this study, both mainstream and contemporary, perform a greater percentage of music by non-Australian composers. The exceptions are two groups: Synergy, a contemporary percussion ensemble that includes Australian music in a little more than half its repertoire, and Australysis, which devotes half its repertoire to Australian composers. If the representation of Australian women's music is examined against Australian men's music, thus separating Australian music from all other music, a healthier picture begins to emerge. In Figure 2.6, Australian women's music is analyzed as a percentage of all Australian music performed by all groups. The organisations and music groups represented in Figure 2.5 are as follows: Sydney Morning Herald (SMH), Musica Viva (MV), Sydney Symphony Orchestra (SSO), Australian Chamber Orchestra (ACO), Camerata Australia (CA), Sydney Youth Orchestra (SYO), SBS Youth Orchestra (SBS), Australian Opera (AO), Australia Ensemble (AE), Song Company (SC), Sydney Alpha Ensemble (SAE), Sydney Spring Festi-
Music in Context and Practice
41
Figure 2.5 Percentage of Australian Music and Women's Music Performed by Mainstream Ensembles, 1985-1995
Figure 2.6 Percentage of Australian Women's Music against AH Australian Music Performed by AH Groups, 1985-1995
val of New Music (SSFNM), Australysis (AUS), Synergy (S YN), and the Seymour Group (SEY). Not surprisingly, when compared with all Australian music performed, Australian women's music constitutes a greater proportion of music in contemporary music ensembles than it does in mainstream ensembles.33 In this part of the chapter I note that a significant problem exists in the context of Australian music for the performance of women's music. Thus, a number of structural barriers need to be removed before female composers can enjoy the same exposure on Australian concert platforms as their male colleagues. Of course, this is not the sole responsibility of those music companies that have resisted including women's music in their concert programs, since they are obliged to perform music that satisfies the tastes of their paying consumers. In tandem with music companies, audiences play a significant role in determining repertoire. PART 2 Most of the mainstream national music companies based in Sydney appear to be heavily influenced by notions of music that are framed in dominant discourses associated with Western high cultural forms as well as in economic discourses of
42
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
what sells. Music is regarded with suspicion if it has not had the seal of approval from the dominant music organizations, which, in any case, are heavily influenced by market forces. Vocabularies of Excellence A notion of excellence is among many key terms that have come to guide much public (government) and private (corporate) activity in the arts, particularly, as Mary Kalantzis and Bill Cope note, "[w]hen it comes to what is funded and what is not funded."34 While it is an intangible concept, it is nonetheless assumed to be recognizable in its manifestation as art or, as Kalantzis and Cope put it, in its application as "excellence-in-action": the finished product of the musical performance, the published book, the art exhibition. The first objective advanced by the Australia Council is "to promote excellence in the arts."35 Yet a paradox emerges, for "excellence" as a quality and as value is never defined. It is simply assumed that it can be identified wherever and whenever it exists. As Kalantzis and Cope put it, whatever it is, it is never applied rigorously: "Deciding what excellence seems to be, much of the time, is a matter of social, political and moral contingency."36 A disturbing finding to emerge from Kalantzis and Cope's investigation is that excellence is very often used as a tool for discrimination against art produced by particular groups of artists. As Australian composer Moya Henderson puts it, "Excellence is used as a tool of oppression."37 In this book I argue that women's music suffers from discrimination by excellence in the negative sense; in other words, the taste system discriminates against women's music. Kalantzis and Cope identify three uses of the word "excellence" often used in arts policies. The first is a "discriminating excellence," which has strong connections with universalist values in high art, rooted in 19th-century aestheticism. The second is "excellence as discrimination," which is disassociated from the canon of high art and used to discriminate in the negative sense against artists and art. The third, a more desirable type, is a "discriminating excellence without discrimination."38 Arts policies in high art organizations generally tend to apply the first kind of excellence to the identification of worth in music. While it is not spelled out in these terms, it is nonetheless implicitly embedded in the rhetoric of music companies promoting their products to their prospective audiences. Most music companies seek Australia Council funding and, if already beneficiaries, are anxious to stay on the public payroll. As a consequence, they tend to mimic the discourses that filter down through the system from the council. Thus, if the council states that it promotes excellence in the arts, then those music organizations seeking funding will follow suit and state that they, too, promote excellence. This, of course, is an obvious statement yet an important one, because the musical product being sold to audiences in Sydney by most of the music companies is music composed predominantly before 1950 by male composers. Since this music, together with the ideologies that circulate in and through it, is rooted in 19th-
Music in Context and Practice
43
century aestheticism, we can therefore assume that excellence used as a criterion in this manner will be discriminatory. The Rhetoric of Diversity and Nation in Australian Music The commodification of art music and its programming alliance with marketability have meant that the Australian government has projected issues such as the promotion of an Australian identity and the promotion of equal access to the arts as cultural imperatives. Yet how diverse is the Australian art music culture with respect, for example, to sex and race? In other words, is the habitus associated with the field of art music as diverse with respect to the people who populate it as it purports to be? The annual report of 1992-1993 of the Australia Council states that the members of the council: "are selected to ensure relevant expertise in the arts and regional, gender, non-English speaking and Aboriginal community representation."39 Yet an analysis of the composition of the boards and music committees for the decade 1985-1995 reveals a male bias with a mean representation of 67 percent. Unraveling the way in which a particular notion of "Australian" is constructed by the council "to foster the expression of a national identity through the arts,"40 Bruce Johnson points to a number of contradictions between what the council says and what it does in practice. He inspects a passage under the heading "Arts for a Multicultural Australia" in the Australia Council Annual Report 1993-1994, which states: It is increasingly acknowledged that Australia derives enormous pleasure from its cultural diversity. Advantages include the rich, challenging and exciting contribution that difference makes to art making in all its guises, including developing new forms, expanding audiences, and increasing international cultural exchanges. The Council's Art for a Multicultural Australia policy recognises and encourages this.41
According to Johnson, the council "takes control of the meaning of Australia, ironically, in the very moment it proclaims democracies."42 Its meaning is constructed by a privileged minority group in the Australian community that does not reflect anything like an equal representation according to race, including nonEnglish-speaking communities, and I would add gender, with specific reference to musical composition.43 According to Johnson, however, the notion of cultural diversity is not reflected in practice. He continues: "Presumably the Council itself is not part of the 'diversity' which it recognises. Rather, it is moved powerfully but unconsciously by the conviction that it is the centre from which and by which diversity is constructed and defined."44 Johnson argues that the selection of people for the Australia Council boards should be a two-way process involving suggestions from the community as well as invitations from the council. As Johnson observes, at the time of the publication of the Australia Council Annual Report 1993-1994, the council consisted of nine
44
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
women and seven men who, with the exception of two members (an Indian-born academic and an Aboriginal performer), were all of white Anglo-Saxon background. Much the same composition existed for the council during the financial year 1994—1995 (six women and nine men, two of whom were of non-AngloSaxon background). Johnson's point is important, for it seems that the membership of the council is not diverse at all. In this view, there is something of a contradiction between practice and theory: the notion of cultural diversity promulgated in the annual reports is not reflected by the council in practice. Yet, these discourses are powerfully persuasive and lead people to believe that what is being proclaimed is true and is being adopted in practice. On the particular point of diversity, the council gives the impression that arts practice in Australia is diverse. Moreover, its reports project an image of art that proclaims it to be "Australian," "excellent," "cultural," and representative of all, all having equal access to the arts. As Bruce Johnson illustrates, however, this is not the case, not least because of the predominantly white, Anglo-Saxon membership of the upper tier of the council, which, in turn, constructs a notion of Australia that reflects the values of this minority white, Anglo-Saxon group. According to Johnson, the notion "Australian" thus becomes an ideologically biased construct with a very narrow focus in relation to the broader context of Australia. The notion of "diversity" is thus a "truth-effect." The agenda in the rhetoric surrounding diversity, it would seem, is to make people believe that diversity exists. The Social Engineering of Australian Music45 The music market in Sydney, able to be generalized on a global level, shows preferences for a particular repertoire that is rooted in the Western art tradition of the 19th century. This, in turn, impacts on discourses that permeate the policies of arts funding bodies, since funding bodies are conscious that the needs of the music market must be satisfied, driven essentially by economics as they are. What seems to be occurring is a mutually reinforcing dynamic of circular simplicity. Conscious that a particular mass art music market exists for a particular music, as described in Part 1, the federal government funding body for the arts (the Australia Council) has an important impact on music programming. In tandem with music organizations and the mass market to which it is catering, the Australia Council imposes particular imperatives on performance groups, shaping repertoire, taste, musical value, and performance standards. The funding body is profoundly implicated in this process, regulating, controlling, and determining which music is performed/ not performed, heard/not heard, and where and by whom it is performed and heard. As a consequence of this fluid relationship between the market for music and the body that funds it, a particular kind of performance practice becomes constituted, regulated, and maintained. In order to understand how the social engineering of music comes about, it is useful to refer to some of the theoretical work of French cultural theorist Pierre
Music in Context and Practice
45
Bourdieu. Bourdieu's work has been concerned with the relationships between social institutions, systems of thought, and the way in which power relations are embedded in social structures. Significant among his theories is that all practices are embodied practices.46 An important underlying argument is that the sexed body is a crucial factor, though not the only factor, in the production and reception of music. It is incontestable that men have dominated art music practices.47 It is important to understand how particular individuals come to occupy prestigious positions in music. How is it that long after the advent of the second wave of the women's movement of the late 1960s, women still constitute only about 18 percent of the composing population in Australia? Why do we continue to hear relatively more music from the 18th and 19th centuries and Romantic 20th century on Australian and, by inference, on world concert platforms? A number of factors contribute to these phenomena, not least of which are the ways in which political and discursive practices in music function to reinforce and reproduce music that has dominance. Marcia Citron discusses a number of factors that have hindered women's participation in music, including access through education and training, critical and audience reception, print and electronic publication of works, regularity of performances and broadcasts of works, and written critiques of music in both the popular and academic presses. She goes on to suggest that these mechanisms are the obvious ways in which compositions are brought to the public's attention. Moreover, she continues, the complex interaction of all these components creates the aura of the professional composer. This, in turn, opens doors for particular works to become canonized.48 Institutionalized learning practices such as those constituted by the AMEB are profoundly implicated in the canonization process. The AMEB adopts practices that I believe are exclusionary in nature, despite its attempts more recently to include popular forms of music. There appears to be a demonstrable correlation between concerthall repertoire and the repertoire of the AMEB. Drawing on Pierre Bourdieu's concepts of the habitus and thefield,it appears that the structures that generate the music hegemony (identified in the study undertaken of art music performance practices in Australia, some of the results of which are reported in Part 1) can be traced back to the concertgoing music lover's early childhood and adolescent musical training. The habitus in the field of art music is collectively orchestrated to maintain and perpetuate this hegemony, leaving little or no room for women's music to make its presence felt. In addition, I draw on Lydia Goehr's assertion that concert hall music has been modeled on the "work concept," in turn giving rise to hierarchies in which particular music is privileged.49 The work concept is bound up with the idea that musical works are coherent entities comprising a complex structure of sounds intimately connected to the composer, to the score, and to a given set of performances. Goehr maintains that each of these cannot be understood in isolation but must be understood in relationship to each other.50
46
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
It might seem obvious that present-day audiences attend concerts to hear musical "works." Goehr, however, points out that the phenomenon of the work concept is relatively new, dating from 1800 onward. Music that was composed for purely functional purposes, such as entertainment music and therefore "without the work concept," predominated during the 17th and 18th centuries. In contrast, music composed under the paradigm of the work concept from the beginning of the 19th century is often composed for its own sake (art for art's sake) and requires the performance of whole works, all movements intact, in one concert sitting. The paradigm shift to the work concept, argues Goehr, gives rise to the "genius" in music (and all the associated notions of individualism, including the notion of the "great" work of art).51 So entrenched is the Romantic aesthetic of the work concept in late 20th-century music practice that it regulates all music into the work paradigm, including music composed before 1800 and music/composers who supposedly broke with that tradition in the mid-20th century (e.g., John Cage).521 argue that the work concept, together with the perpetuation of AMEB repertoire in the Australian concert hall, is implicated in the exclusion of women's music. Bourdieu: The Habitus and the Field of Cultural Production In announcing, "In each one of us to varying degrees, is contained the person we were yesterday . . . that our pastpersonae predominate in us,"53 Pierre Bourdieu locates the body as being particular to its history. Yet because life's experiences are "internalized as second nature and so forgotten as history,"54 the habitus—"the active presence of the whole past of which it is a product"55—molded over a long period of inculcation and becoming formed and durable in adulthood, accounts for why we take the world for granted. In childhood and into early adulthood, we form distinctions between things, classifying according to our tastes. The dispositions that we form during this long period of conditioning, becoming part of a collective unconscious, are durable and will probably last for our entire lifetimes. The habitus, then, is unconsciously generative.56 What is ignored, however, as Bourdieu notes, is that "taste classifies, and classifies the classifier."57 This point is important, for Bourdieu claims that we are not conscious that we are making distinctions between things, nor are we, in making these distinctions, aware that we are participating in the creation of unequal relations in society. In all forms of cultural production and practice the principles of domination and subordination are in operation. While Bourdieu is not suggesting that the classifications themselves cause class divisions and inequalities, he is, nonetheless, contending that "art and cultural consumption are predisposed, consciously and deliberately or not, to fulfil a social function of legitimating social differences,"58 and this contributes to the process of social reproduction. According to Bourdieu, any social formation is structured into a hierarchically organized series of fields. These include, for example, the economic, educational, political, and cultural fields. To enter afield,one must possess a habitus that is particular to that field.59 The field of cultural production (which includes music pro-
Music in Context and Practice
47
duction) is independent and autonomous of other fields of production in that it has its own laws of functioning, yet it is homologous in structure with others. The field is determined at any given moment between the various positions that "cultural agents" (artists) occupy in the field. Agents (or artists) in the cultural field, as in any field, constantly engage in competition for dominance, which, as Bourdieu points out, is predicated on the amount of economic and/or symbolic wealth or capital that they can summon. This is important, for Bourdieu argues that symbolic capital, or wealth, is more desirable than economic wealth. Bourdieu explains the legitimization of high art forms on these grounds. Economic capital is associated with cultural production aimed at the mass market (e.g., popular music). In other words, while symbolic capital may imply the possession of economic capital, it is more importantly associated with prestige and celebrity or with public recognition for one's work. Cultural capital, then, is wealth that is acquired through education and training, which is particular to a given cultural field. Economic capital is associated with the dollars and cents obtained for services rendered (the amount of money that art attracts). Symbolic capital is the value that an individual accumulates in the social system in terms of both economic and cultural capital. According to Bourdieu, symbolic capital locates its agents as valued members of the society. Bourdieu's conception of symbolic power, then, while possibly connected to, and enmeshed in, economic and political power but not reducible to it, has the function of legitimating unequal power relations. Indeed, one of the central arguments in Bourdieu's work is that social structures produce unequal power relations, but because these are unrecognized as such, they are accepted as being legitimate.60 Bourdieu goes on to suggest that the field of cultural production is structured by an opposition between two subfields, the field of restricted production ("high" art), where the competition between agents is for symbolic capital (in which art production is invariably for art producers rather than for society at large), and the field of mass production, that is, popular culture, where economic capital is the dominant principle of hierarchization and involves economic wealth. Within the field of cultural production, art music tends to be located in the subfield of restricted production, for it does not cater to the mass music market.61 To enter the field of restricted musical production, agents must possess the appropriate habitus, undertaking training that leads to composing and performing high art music. Bourdieu's Model and the AMEB The rituals of art music performance practice in the 20th century, dependent upon the solid training ground of a good musical education, give rise to a particular literate, musical body, which, in turn, produces a particular musical habitus. The rite of passage, for example, through the AMEB,62 a system of private musical training, produces a particular musical subject. On entering the system (or what Bourdieu calls the "game," in this case, the AMEB game), the subject takes on all that is involved in playing this particular game, acquiring, as it were, a "feel for the
48
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
[AMEB] game." The earlier musicians enter the AMEB game, the less aware they are of all that is entailed in learning it, the greater their ignorance of all that is tacitly gained through their investment in this particular music and the greater their ignorance that they are, indeed, interested in its very existence and perpetuation. Not realizing what is involved in learning under this particular system of musical training and yet realizing that it did procure them a music education, the likelihood is that they will go on to reproduce the system, so that it becomes self-perpetuating. On this proposition, I argue that there is a direct link between systems of musical training., such as that provided by the AMEB, and the repertoire that constitutes the music performed in the concert hall. At this point it is useful to provide a concrete illustration of how the typical AMEB habitus comes to be formed. If we were to conceive of a typical music lesson, we would find that the teacher invariably asks the student to perform standard warm-up exercises and studies, all designed to produce technical agility on the chosen instrument. More importantly, however, these tasks also reinforce all that is involved in learning the greater portion of AMEB repertoire. As an analysis of this repertoire shows, the greater portion of works included in the various lists A, B, C, and D (especially in the higher grades) of the syllabuses, is tonal. This music thus relies on the major/minor system and its associated rules of Western, functional harmony, the foundation of typical practice exercises for music students. Music lessons aimed at preparing the student for the AMEB examination also include a series of value judgments made by the teacher about the music being studied. It is assumed, for example, that any choice of music from all the possible selections of works by Bach will be acceptable. Since he is generally viewed as a towering composer from the high baroque era who produced consistently great music, the assumption continues that there were no troughs and peaks in his output. Another tendency by the AMEB instructor is to avoid choosing works from the 20th century unless they are tonal. There also seems to be a bias against choosing works from the little Australian music that is listed, usually in list D of the syllabus. In the last 10 years, the amount of Australian music included in the associate (A. Mus. A.) and licentiate (L. Mus. A.) syllabuses of the AMEB might well be described as tokenistic. Over the decade 1985-1995, its representation has increased by very little. In 1985 there were only 18 Australian works of a total of 1,282 (or approximately 1.4 percent) included in these syllabuses. In 1990 this rose to 48 of a total of 1,557 works (approximately 3.1 percent), and in 1995 it climbed to 91 of a total of 1,992 works (4.6 percent).63 (See Figure 2.7.) It is worth noting, however, as Monique Geitenbeck does, that during the 1930s quite a different situation prevailed with respect to the inclusion in the syllabuses of Australian music and, in turn, women's music. As Geitenbeck points out, by 1938 of the 42 Australian instrumental and vocal compositions included in the syllabuses, 20 percent were by women, and by 1949 works by women represented 36 percent of the total of Australian works in the AMEB syllabuses.64 In contrast to these earlier trends, on the present-day training ground of the AMEB,65 the student learns to play without question a repertoire that is predomi-
Music in Context and Practice
49
Figure 2.7 Percentage of Australian Music Included in the AMEB Syllabuses for A. Mus. A. and L. Mus. A. in 1985,1990, and 1995
Source: Sarah-Grace Williams nantly drawn from the Western art music tradition of the 17th, 18th, and 19th centuries. It should be noted, too, that in its 79 years of operation, the repertoire and instruments examined have not altered significantly.66 The Foreword to the 1996 AMEB syllabus states: While one of the chief functions of the Board is to set examination standards of the highest order, more importantly it strives to offer all students access to some of the best repertoire for study purposes, whether they subsequently sit for examinations or not. .. . The Board has a commitment to including compositions by Australian and New Zealand composers in its publications and syllabuses.67 While it may be the case that the board includes some Australian- and New Zealand-composed music in its syllabuses, a search through the seventh-grade piano syllabus, for example, produces eyestrain in the attempt to locate the Australian content. New Zealand music, too, is conspicuous by its virtual absence: one piece by New Zealand composer Douglas Lilburn is included in list D of the eighthgrade 1996 syllabus. There is clearly a bias of the AMEB syllabuses toward the repertoire previously described, with women's music, 20th-century music, and Australian and New Zealand music being represented as a token. It would seem that the assumption upon which the AMEB operates is that "best music" equates with a particular kind of "old" music. This assumption produces another: "best music" produces "good," if not "best," musicians. The way in which students are trained through the AMEB produces subjects who go on to reproduce endlessly the very same kind of music in adult life. This method includes repeated performance of the exclusive repertory of Western tonal music, as well as adoption of attitudes and value judgments toward this music similar to those of their teachers. Having had it ingrained from an early age by their teachers that there exists predominantly only one kind of music, musical subjects trained in the AMEB system, without realizing it, tend to regard Australian music and even 20th-century music with a certain amount of suspicion. These attitudes
50
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
may be formed for life. Moreover, that there is an even smaller amount of music composed by women in the syllabuses of the AMEB means that it barely signifies, and, on this observation, it would seem that this is a crucial reason for their invisibility on Australian concert platforms. What emerges is that representation is an important issue, for the way in which Western, tonal music comes to assume priority over all other music that might be included in (but is, in fact, excluded from) the syllabuses of the AMEB bears a strong resemblance to what comes to be understood as musical knowledge in later life. The rigid definitions of "fine" music formed by unsuspecting AMEB candidates, gradually perfected through the long rehearsal period from early childhood to adolescence, are so powerful in their effect that versions of the same repertoire in the AMEB syllabuses flood the music of the concert hall, served up in highly refined performances to audiences who choose to attend concerts in their adult lives. I thus argue, along Bourdieurian lines, that the AMEB is a self-perpetuating system with far-reaching effects. During the extended process of training, the AMEB "civilizes" its musical subjects (providing them with a feel for what is deemed to be proper music by "playing the AMEB game"), and the AMEB student complies with, and, in turn, reproduces, the process, conditioned into thinking that the AMEB repertoire is superior to any other kind of music. Goehr's "Work Concept" In her book The Imaginary Museum of Musical Works, Lydia Goehr describes the "work concept," a notion that would support the idea that the history of music consists of great musical works. She argues that all concert hall music is modeled on the work concept and that all contemporary performance is regulated by this concept.68 Briefly, she invites her reader to explore, both historically and analytically, how the work concept came to be constructed, locating the moment for the paradigm shift that saw a transition from music created without the work concept to music composed with the work concept at around 1800. The work concept is therefore rooted in 19th-century ideologies and practices, and Goehr suggests that we see the world's music, even today, through romantic spectacles, packaging all of it in terms of "works." She says: "The phrase 'musical work/ like 'work of art,' is used with evaluative as well as classificatory sense. What we see under imperialistic influence is a conflation or contamination of the two senses."69 Goehr argues that all Western music (whether composed before 1800 or since 1900) is colonized by the work concept. According to Goehr, musicians do not speak of music in terms of "occurrences," as they might have prior to 1800. Instead, they conceive of music as a set of "works," using all the attendant terminology to describe these works. At every level, musicians engage in practices that are associated with the "work production." Taken for granted in such institutions as the AMEB, those engaged in music practice are ostensibly tamed and civilized, molded and regulated by the work concept. Music that does not fit the work para-
Music in Context and Practice
51
digm, for example, popular musics, improvised musics, non-Western musics, jazz, and women's musics, is relegated to the borderlines, where it is, by and large, ignored; it is as if these musics did not exist. In this view, it might even be the case that women's music is being treated as an entirely different genre rather than as a category offering different kinds of possibilities in terms of aesthetics. The sheer force of the work concept in contemporary performance practice spawns a series of related concepts, including that of the virtuoso performer, whose claim to fame is the exhibition of mastery over the music performed. Another is the "conductor syndrome," in which the conductor is seen as both master over, and servant of, the music (he must be faithful to the score) while at the same time exerting his individual authority and control over the collective body of the orchestra,70 which, in turn, is often viewed paradoxically as a single instrument. Goehr argues that the work concept is difficult to shift for two important reasons: "First, those who wish to challenge a concept's regulative force usually find themselves paradoxically situated in a practice that is regulated by the very concept they want to challenge; second, that a regulative concept's alteration or demise is no less complicated a process than its emergence."71 Taking John Cage as an example, Goehr points out: What he and other avant-gardists demand in theory [namely, to eliminate themselves from their work and simply let the work happen] has to be contradicted by practice, if that practice functions with ideals one opposes in theory, yet, for whatever reason and however reluctantly, one accepts in practice. It is difficult to challenge in practice in a radical way that [which] one at the same time participates in.72 Given Goehr's elucidation of the work concept and Bourdieu's notion of the habitus, it is not surprising to find that concert hall music in Australia is undifferentiated by repertoire. While I have not covered every possible reason for this phenomenon, I have argued that among the most potent is that the early musical training likely to have been received by these audiences in childhood and adolescent years, notably through the AMEB, is self-perpetuating. Audiences feel safe with the music that they know. Thus, the familiar in art music, correlated with mass audience appeal, means that even the bureaucrats in the administration of art music institutions, such as the Sydney Symphony Orchestra, are destined to program according to their audience's tastes for particular music. If they did not, they would not survive financially. Demographic Profile of Audiences Data made available to me by three music companies based in Sydney73 on audience demographics for mainstream art music support my argument that the AMEB is implicated in the perpetuation of music associated with 19th-century ideologies on Australian concert platforms. It is interesting to discover that there was not a significant difference between audiences who attended mainstream concerts and
52
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
audiences who attended new music concerts in terms of suburb, class, educational background, and age.74 Audiences for mainstream art music are predominantly from the affluent areas of Sydney's north shore, eastern suburbs, and inner west, are what might be loosely described as middle- to upper-class, are predominantly tertiary-educated and in full-time employment, and are aged 40 years and over. There are some similarities between this audience and that for new music in that the latter audience is also predominantly well educated and drawn from the wealthier suburbs. According to Allen, audiences for new music, however, are younger than audiences for old music, and many are themselves musicians.75 Based on this evidence, it would seem that in Bourdieurian terms, the economically/symbolically empowered music institutions dominating the music scene in Sydney derive audiences from a very exclusive group. The profile for art music audiences (mainstream and contemporary music concerts) is remarkably similar. It is important to remember that all the music institutions that I examined in an earlier study76 receive substantial subsidies from the Australian government through the Australia Council and are thus indirectly subsidized by all taxpaying Australians. On this basis we might perhaps question why such an exclusive group of the population, which already tends to be biased by social class and age, comes to be given preferential treatment. While there is no concrete evidence available to link the demographic profile of the AMEB candidature with audiences for concert hall music, I conjecture, nonetheless, that those who study under the AMEB in early life are among those—in all probability constituting a large proportion of those—who in later life attend mainstream concerts. Studying music privately is a costly exercise: there is considerable financial investment in learning music through the AMEB. While it is something of a myth that the wealthy classes in Sydney are confined to the north shore, eastern suburbs, and the inner west, I contend, nonetheless, on the basis of economic capital alone, that a direct link can be made between audiences for concert hall music and those who received training in the AMEB system. I would also say that those who invest financially in the AMEB acquire educational capital. The concert hall repertoire analyzed in my study and that of the AMEB syllabuses are remarkably similar. Indeed, further support is given to this supposition from the findings of the study "What Are Music Students Really Being Taught?—Music Education in Sydney," by Nicole Donald, who found in her survey of the SBS Youth Orchestra that its members were from predominantly middle-class families and undergoing private training through the AMEB.77 Moreover, to get an idea ofjust how pervasive the AMEB training ground is, I was overwhelmed by the numbers of candidates reported as having sat for examinations in New South Wales alone. In 1988 the New South Wales office for the AMEB reported that a total of 33,025 candidates sat for practical and written examinations; in 1990 this figure increased to 35, 963; and in 1995 it was 43,648.78 Given the empirical evidence in my own study,79 and the ways in which particular music becomes self-perpetuating, it is not surprising to find that women's mu-
Music in Context and Practice
53
sic has been positioned on the fringe of mainstream art music. The AMEB is profoundly implicated here, for students seldom come across the names of women composers in the list D of the syllabus, if at all. Even then a contradiction often arises, for what they are being taught about women's music (without being conscious that this is happening) is that music by women is romantic in style. Much of the music by Australian women included in the AMEB syllabus is written in a romantic idiom (e.g., Dulcie Holland, Miriam Hyde, and Marjorie Hesse). Names such as Anne Boyd, Moya Henderson, Elena Kats-Chernin, Mary Finsterer, and Liza Lim—five among Australia's contemporary composers, each of whom is in vogue, writing in individual, idiomatic musical styles (some hard-edged and modernist, others postmodernist)—tend to be omitted. Australian men's music that is in-vogue also tends to be omitted from the syllabuses, but the names of composers such as Peter Sculthorpe and Ross Edwards do appear occasionally. Lydia Goehr does not delve specifically into an analysis of the exclusive nature of the work concept in relation to women's music, making only brief mention of this fact.80 Marcia Citron,81 however, covers this point in exemplary detail. Illustrating that the musical canon is gender-biased toward men's music, Citron examines the practices and attitudes that have led to the exclusion of women's music from the received canon. Among the issues covered by Citron are the paradigm of "greatness" (associated with the male "genius"); the "test-of-time" syndrome— the idea that music is transcendent (beyond the body, to which women, but not men, are supposedly tied, into the mind, and into the realm of the spiritual, which can be accessed only by men); and the concept of "originality." In practice, argues Citron, "works of art perform 'cultural work' that makes them effective and successful in the context in which they existed."82 But it is through repeated practice—a necessity in musical training—that such ideas become ingrained. CONCLUSION Concert hall repertoire shapes and is shaped by the market, and by and large, this repertoire is undifferentiated. This means that a particular repertoire, namely, that from the Western art music canon, is privileged over a variety of musics that, if not omitted altogether, do not have a strong presence. Musical tastes formed at an early age (e.g., through "playing the AMEB game" and joining youth orchestras) are sustained and maintained into adult life, by which time the particular disposition for AMEB and youth orchestral music has become durable. It is not surprising to find that music in Sydney is biased toward the Western art music canon, results that can be generalized to include Australia as a whole and other countries where similar practices occur, for the assumption underpinning institutions such as the AMEB is that music by men is superior to all other music. The AMEB candidate, civilized and cultured through the lengthy rehearsal period of AMEB training, reinforces the choice of this music, adhering to early experience in exercising taste judgments in the Australian concert hall in adult life.
54
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
Moreover, it is common for the former AMEB candidate to ensure that her or his own progeny receive private music lessons through the AMEB. Practices of early training function to produce, reinforce, and perpetuate truths that have a normalizing and regulatory effect on the music culture as a whole. In effect, and I tend to agree with Lydia Goehr on this point, this is impossible to shift unless all practices, mainstream and marginal (for marginal practices, including those that marginalize women's music, are contained within the dominant field of mainstream practices), are overthrown and replaced with something different. Goehr makes a case for revisiting those practices that were in existence prior to the 19th century, composed under the without the work concept paradigm. I wonder, however, if a return to former practices would rescue women from their present low status in the music world and afford them the right to an equal hearing on their own terms. I suspect not, given the fact that no women from previous historical epochs have gained entry into the music canon, with the exception, perhaps, of Hildegarde of Bingen. The wealth of historical evidence that has surfaced in feminist musical research for a good three decades now supports the fact that the musical past for women in music, while better in some epochs than in others, has always peripheralized their activities, if not excluded them entirely. The AMEB is so well entrenched in Australian culture that it is certain to endure at least for the foreseeable future.83 It is also a paradox that the AMEB would not survive without the work of the many women who populate the AMEB system as teachers and examiners.84 That a system so well populated by women as teachers/performers is so lacking in support for, and representation of, women composers would seem an anomaly but, since the role models of musical composition are almost exclusively male, not surprising. While I may have seemed to paint a bleak picture for women's music, I believe, nonetheless, that when we know how structures operate to exclude particular people and particular music, then, and only then, can we do something about the matter. NOTES 1. Therese Radic, "Past Imperfect, Present Indicative, Future Tense: The Repercussions of the Australian Composing Women's Festivals," in Sally Macarthur and Cate Poynton, eds., Musics and Feminisms (Sydney: Australian Music Centre, 1999), 10. 2. See Elizabeth Wood, "Review Essay: Women in Music," Signs 6 (Winter 1980): 283-297, and Susan McClary, "Reshaping a Discipline: Musicology and Feminism in the 1990s," Feminist Studies 19.2 (Summer 1993): 399-423. The earliest contributions in fe nist musicology that also corroborate this claim were concerned with excavating a musical past for women composers, including Christine Ammer, Unsung: A History of Women American Music (Westport, CT, and London, England: Greenwood Press, 1980); Caro Neuls-Bates, ed., Women in Music: An Anthology ofSource Readingsfrom the Mid to the Present (New York: Harper and Row, 1982); and Jane Bowers and Judith Tick, e Women Making Music: The Western Art Tradition, 1150-1950 (Urbana and Chic versity of Illinois Press, 1986), among others. One of the first essays to examine music fro the perspective of a feminist criticism was Eva Rieger in Frau, Musik, un Mdnnerherrschaft (Frankfurt, Germany: Ullstein, 1981; reissued in Kassel, Germany: F
Music in Context and Practice
55
rore-Verlag, 1988). Excerpts from the book were published under the title "Dolce semplice?" in Gisela Ecker, ed., Feminist Aesthetics, trans. Harriet Anderson (London: Woman's Press, 1985), 135-149. Two outstanding books that systematically examine the way in which music has been dominated by male traditions and practices are Susan McClary, Feminine Endings: Music, Gender, and Sexuality (Minnesota and Oxford: University of Minnesota Press, 1991), and Marcia Citron, Gender and the Musical Canon (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993). 3. See, for example, Women's Studies/Women's Status (Boulder, CO: College Music Society/CMS Report Number 5, 1988). 4. Gretchen Poiner, "Old Time Dancing: Affirmative Action for Women," in Jan Larbalestier and Denise Roberts, eds., Women and the Law: Working for Women? Anti-Discrimination, Affirmative Action and Equal Opportunity (Sydney: Women's Studies Centre, University of Sydney, 1995), in particular, 70-72. Poiner's work shows that while proportionately more women are employed in Australia in the 1990s when compared with the 1970s, most are in part-time work, and few hold full-time managerial positions. 5. In Australia these include the Commonwealth Sex Discrimination Act 1984, the Public Service Reform Act 1984 (amending Public Service Act 1922), the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986, the Affirmative Action (Equal Employment Opportunity for Women) Act 1986, and the Equal Employment Opportunity (Commonwealth Authorities) Act 1987. 6. David Throsby and Beverley Thompson, But What Do You Do for a Living? A New Economic Study of Australian Artists (Sydney: Australia Council, 1994), 9. The occupations that the report identified as being arts-based were categorized as follows: writers, craftspeople, visual artists, actors, dancers/choreographers, musicians/singers, composers, and community artists. 7. Australia: Office of the Status of Women, Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet, Women Shaping and Sharing the Future: The New Agenda for Women, 1993-2000, 2nd ed. (Canberra: Australian Government Public Service, June 1993), 124-125. 8. Throsby and Thompson, But What Do You Do for a Living?, 27, 46. 9. According to a 1990 U.S. study by Eleanor Dickinson (comp) Gender Discrimination in theArtfield (Sonoma: California College of Arts and Crafts, Artists Equity Association, 1990), these structural barriers appear to be universal. In parallel with the Australian experience, U.S. male artists made over 68 percent of the total U.S. art income while representing slightly less than 50 percent of ail artists and received 73 percent of all arts grants and fellowships. 10. See Australian Census, Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS), August 1991. 11. These include Gil Appleton, ed., Women in the Arts: A Study by the Research Advisory Group of Women and the Arts Project (Sydney: Policy and Planning, Australia Council, December 1982); Women in the Arts: A Strategy for Action (Sydney: Policy and Planning, Australia Council, 1984); Women in the Arts: Submission to the Australia Council Arts Employment Inquiry (Canberra: Australian Government Public Service, 1985); Mira Crouch and Jenny Loveric, Paths to Performance: Gender as a Theme in Professional Music Careers: A Pilot Study of Two Orchestras (Sydney: Report to Australia Council, 1990); Victoria Rogers, Cora V. Baldcock, and Denise Mulligan, What Difference Does It Make? A Pilot Study of Women in the Performing and Visual Arts in Western Australia (Sydney: Australia Council, 1993). 12. Crouch and Loveric, Paths to Performance. 13. This information, cited in Women of Note (Fall 1996), published by the Women's Philharmonic, was posted to the International Alliance of Women in Music (IAWM) list on
56
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
15 November 1996. The statistics presented in this posting were as follows: women's compositions accounted for only 3 of a total 1,530 pieces (approximately 0.2 percent) programmed in concerts for 21 of the highest budgeted orchestras; these 21 orchestras had no women music directors or conductors appointed to permanent positions; of the 75 orchestras sampled, only 5 have principal music directors or conductors who are women; community orchestras whose budgets ranged from $175,000 to $275,000 reported the highest percentage of women composers programmed (2 percent of all works performed). In this same group, 50 percent of the conductors and soloists were women. 14. Varda Ullman Novick, "Protest and Empowerment," posting to gen-mus@ virginia.edu., 13 November 1996. 15. Yet according to an article posted to the IAWM list on 23 December 1996 from the Santa Barbara News-Press (the Voice of Santa Barbara County since 1855) on 6 April 1996 written by George Jahn under the title "Without Harping: Philharmonic Female Finally Gets Her Due," the harpist, who is the only female member of the orchestra (since winning an audition for the post in 1970), did not have her name appear on the program along with all other members of the orchestra until March 1996. The article states: For harpist Anna Lelkes, the Vienna Philharmonic's latest tour at Carnegie Hall brought a bouquet few outsiders can appreciate. Finally—after 25 years with the orchestra—her name appeared on the program. .. . The Vienna Philharmonic's main harpist has never been on the program because she isn't a formal member. The problem? She's a woman. In its 153 years, the Philharmonic never has admitted women as member musicians who vote on setting Philharmonic policy. The orchestra wasn't swayed when the rival Berlin Philharmonic shattered tradition in 1982 by hiring itsfirstwoman.... Publicly, Lelkes, 56, says her "non-person" status is a small price to pay for playing in the Vienna Philharmonic. I am aware that the policy of excluding women in the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra has since changed due to the concerted efforts of a number of protest groups, including the boycotting of the orchestra's concerts. 16. Of 155 Australian composers listed by the Australian Music Centre in 1988,20 were women. See Directory ofAustralian Composers Represented in the Collection of the Au tralian Music Centre (Sydney: Australian Music Centre, 1988). 17. Nicola LeFanu, "Master Musician: An Impregnable Taboo?," Contact: A Journal of Contemporary Music 31 (Autumn 1987): 6. 18. Mary Mageau, "Australian Women Composers' Network: Aiming for Its Own Demise," 24 Hours (December 1991): 51. 19. It is interesting to compare this statistic with that of June 1992, when the total number of Australian composers represented by the Australian Music Centre increased to 228. Of this total, 33 composers were women, and 195 were men (women constituted 14.5 percent of the composer population). 20. The Register of Theses in Australian Music (Parkville, Victoria: Centre for Studies in Australian Music, University of Melbourne, 1996) points to a preoccupation by postgraduate scholars with "art" music by male composers. In the section entitled "Composer Studies" (meaning Australian composers) it is revealed that 81 percent of theses are concerned with music by male art music composers, 16 percent with music by female composers, and 3 percent with the music of both sexes (see 43-54). In the section on "Analysis," 69 percent of theses are devoted to music by male "art" music composers, 4 percent (one master of music thesis, in fact, written in 1984 on Margaret Sutherland's Sonata for clarinet and piano of 1947) to music by female "art" music composers, and 27 percent of theses to the analysis of music by Aboriginal Australians (see 38-40). 21. Bruce Johnson made this point in a paper entitled "Musicology in the 90s—Which Century?" presented at the "Musicology in the 90s" National Conference of the Musicolog-
Music in Context and Practice
57
ical Society of Australia, School of Graduate Studies, University of Melbourne, 5 July, 1996. 22. I am making a distinction between music composed before 1900 and music composed before 1950 because Australian music really began to seriously signify on concert platforms only after 1950, especially in the 1960s. Moreover, much of the 20th-century music programmed for performance on Australian concert platforms was composed before 1950; the second half of the 20th century is underrepresented by comparison. 23. I used the Australian Music Centre catalogs for this purpose and included a broad range of genres such as vocal, chamber, solo chamber, piano, orchestral, and choral music. 24. Therese Radic, "Where Are the Women Composers?," 24 Hours (December 1991): 43. 25. Mageau is referring to Aaron Cohen's International Encyclopedia of Women Co posers, 2nd ed. (New York: Books and Music, 1987 [1981]). 26. Mary Mageau, "Australian Women Composer's Network," 50. 27. Julie Anne Sadie and Rhian Samuel, eds., The New Grove Dictionary of Women Composers (London: Macmillan, 1994). 28. By "mainstream" ensembles I mean groups that perform the bulk of their repertoire from music composed prior to 1900 (or 1950 in a post-Romantic idiom). It is conceded, however, that some contemporary groups, while attracting smaller audiences to their concerts, might also be viewed as being mainstream in that they are consistently funded by the Australia Council. 29. The full data (raw figures and percentages) from this study are available in Sally Macarthur, "Feminist Aesthetics in Music: Politics and Practices in Australia" (Doctoral dissertation, Department of Music, University of Sydney, May 1997). 30. This is a typical phenomenon, and while I did not specifically calculate the number of performances for each work (an enormous task for the present study), I noticed that while there were many repetitions of works by 19th-century composers of European descent there were very few for works by Australian composers. It is rare for Australian works to receive more than one performance (unless it happens to be an operatic work that might run for a short season) because audiences are not favorably disposed to hearing Australian repertoire. I did not absorb the repetition factor into my analysis, for given that the emphasis of my study is qualitative rather than quantitative, I felt that by becoming overly concerned with the statistical evidence, I would deflect from the interpretation that I offer in the latter part of this chapter and in subsequent chapters. 31. From a total of 488 works, the Song Company (SC) performed 71 Australian works (or approximately 14.5 percent) and from a total of 478, it performed 11 by women (or approximately 2 percent); from a total of 70 works, Sydney Alpha Ensemble (SAE) performed 57 Australian works (or approximately 48.5 percent), and from a total of 63 works, it performed 10 by women (or approximately 16 percent); from a total of 374 works, Sydney Spring Festival of New Music (SSFNM) performed 116 Australian works (or approximately 31 percent) and 24 by women (or approximately 6 percent); from a total of 151 works, Australysis (AUS) performed 91 Australian works (or approximately 14 percent) and 18 by women (or approximately 12 percent); from a total of 194 works, Synergy (SYN) performed 113 Australian works (or approximately 58 percent), and from a total of 194 works, it performed 10 by women (or approximately 5 percent); and from a total of 211 works, The Seymour Group (SEY) performed 119 Australian works (or approximately 56 percent), and from a total of 201 works, it performed 22 by women (or approximately 11 percent). The full data (raw figures and percentages) are available in Macarthur, "Feminist Aesthetics in Music."
58
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
32. From a total of 968 works, Musica Viva (MV) performed 56 Australian compositions (or approximately 6 percent), and from a total of 1,220 works it performed 11 by women (or approximately 1 percent); from a total of 1,447 works, the Sydney Symphony Orchestra (SSO) performed 112 Australian compositions (or approximately 7.5 percent) and 6 by women (approximately 0.5 percent); from a total of 651 works, the Australian Chamber Orchestra (ACO) performed 7 Australian compositions (or approximately 7.5 percent), and 4 by women (or approximately 0.5 percent);froma total of 41 works, the Australian Youth Orchestra performed 7 Australian compositions (or approximately 17 percent), and from a total of 40 works, it performed none by women (0 percent); from a total of 26 works, Camerata Australia performed 5 Australian compositions (or approximately 19 percent), and from a total of 27 works, it performed none by women (0 percent); from a total of 229 works, the Sydney Youth Orchestra performed 23 Australian compositions (or approximately 10 percent) and 2 by women (approximately 1 percent); from a total of 101 works, the SBS Youth Orchestra (SBS) performed 7 Australian compositions (or approximately 6.5 percent) and 1 by a woman (or approximately 1 percent); from a total of 458 works, the Australia Ensemble performed 57 Australian compositions (or approximately 12.5 percent), and from a total of 454 works, it performed 6 by women (or approximately 1.5 percent); of a total of 488 works, the Song Company performed 71 Australian compositions (or approximately 14.5 percent), and from a total of 478 works, it performed 11 by women (or approximately 2 percent); and from a total of 223 works, the Australian Opera (AO) performed 11 Australian operas (or approximately 5 percent) and none by women (0 percent). See Macarthur, "Feminist Aesthetics in Music," for raw data and percentages. 33. The breakdown of Australian women's music, when compared with all Australian music performed, is as follows: from a total of 50 Australian works, Musica Viva (MV) performed 6 by Australian women (or approximately 12 percent); from a total of 103 Australian works, the Sydney Symphony Orchestra (SSO) performed 6 by Australian women (or approximately 9 percent); from a total of 49 Australian works, the Australian Chamber Orchestra (ACO) performed 4 by Australian women (or approximately 10 percent); from a total of 7 Australian works, the Australian Youth Orchestra (AYO) performed none by women (0 percent); similarly, from a total of 5 Australian works, its affiliated orchestra Camerata Australia (CA) performed none by women (0 percent); from a total of 21 Australian works, the Sydney Youth Orchestra (SYO) performed 3 by women (or approximately 14 percent); from a total of 23 Australian works, SBS Youth Orchestra (SBS) performed 1 by a woman (or approximately 16.5 percent); from a total of 11 Australian works, the Australian Opera (AO) performed none by women (0 percent); from a total of 54 Australian works, the Australia Ensemble (AE) performed 2 by women (or approximately 3.5 percent); from a total of 75 Australian works, the Song Company (SC) performed 8 by women (or approximately 1.0.5 percent); from a total of 28 Australian works, Sydney Alpha Ensemble (SAE) performed 9 by women (or approximately 32 percent); from a total of 112 Australian works, Sydney Spring Festival of New Music (SSFNM) performed 25 by women (or approximately 22 percent); from a total of 151 Australian works, Australysis (AUS) performed 17 by women (or approximately 11 percent); from a total of 98 Australian works, Synergy (SYN) performed 8 by women (or approximately 8 percent); and from a total of 111 Australian works, the Seymour Group (SEY) performed 13 by women (or approximately 11.5 percent). See Macarthur, "Feminist Aesthetics in Music," for raw data and percentages. 34. Mary Kalantzis and Bill Cope, "Vocabularies of Excellence: Rewording Multicultural Arts Policy," in Sneja Gunew and Fazal Rizvi, eds., Culture, Difference and the Arts (Sydney: Allen and Unwin, 1994), 13. 35. Australia Council Annual Report 1993-94 (Sydney: Australia Council), 4.
Music in Context and Practice
59
36. Kalantzis and Cope, "Vocabularies of Excellence," 17. 37. Moya Henderson, personal communication with Sally Macarthur, 12 January 1995. 38. Kalantzis and Cope, "Vocabularies of Excellence," 17-21. 39. Australia Council Annual Report 1991-92, 8. 40. Section 5 of the Australia Council Act of 1975, published in the Australia Council Annual Report 1994-95, 4. 41. Australia Council Annual Report 1994-95, 25. 42. Johnson, uCreative Nation, Creating Nation: Issues in Cultural Policy and Popular Music," Paper presented at the IASPM Australia-New Zealand Conference, Melbourne, June 1995, 5. 43. On the statistical evidence reported in Part 1, it would be impossible to have an equal representation of composers on the basis of their gender. However, as Throsby and Thompson in But What Do You Do for a Living? point out, women constitute more than 50 percent of the overall artistic population; equal representation by gender should therefore be possible for representing women across all art forms on the boards of the council. 44. Johnson, "Creative Nation, Creating Nation," 5-6. 45. Part of what follows in this section of the chapter is an adaptation of a paper that I wrote entitled "Performance Rites: AMEB, or Not to Be?" which appeared in Sally Macarthur and Cate Poynton, eds. Musics and Feminisms (Sydney: Australian Music Centre, 1999), 19-34. It is reprinted here with kind permission of the Australian Music Centre. 46. For example, Bourdieu states: "The habitus—embodied history, internalized as second nature and so forgotten as history—is the active presence of the whole past of which it is a product." In Pierre Bourdieu, The Logic of Practice, trans. Richard Nice (Cambridge: Polity Press in assoc. with Basil Blackwell, 1990), 56. Refer to his whole discussion on the habitus, 52-65. 47. See, for example, Macarthur, "The Conservative Hegemony of Australian Art Music," in "Feminist Aesthetics in Music," 40-85. 48. Citron, Gender and the Musical Canon, 80. 49. Lydia Goehr, The Imaginary Museum ofMusical Works: An Essay in the Philosophy of Music (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1992). 50. Ibid., 20. 51. Ibid., 160-163. 52. Ibid., 245, 260. 53. Bourdieu, The Logic of Practice, 56. 54. Ibid. 55. Ibid. For a further discussion of the habitus see also Pierre Bourdieu, The Field of Cultural Production: Essays on Art and Literature, ed. and intro. Randal Johnson (Cambridge: Polity Press in assoc. with Basil Blackwell, 1993), 29-73. 56. Bourdieu, The Logic of Practice, 56. 57. Bourdieu , Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste, trans. Richard Nice (London and New York: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1984), 6. 58. Ibid., 7. 59. See, for example, Bourdieu, The Field of Cultural Production, 29-73; see, in particular, 64-72 for a discussion on the relationship of the field to the habitus. 60. See, for example, the editor's discussion in ibid., 1-25. 61. Ibid., 40-45. 62. According to archival material available at the Sydney office of the AMEB, music examinations in Australia date back to 1887 and were initially conducted through the Universities of Adelaide and Melbourne. The Foreword, Australian Music Examinations Board: 1996 Manual of Syllabuses (Sydney: Australian Music Examinations Board, Aus-
60
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
tralian Print Group, 1995) states that in 1918 the AMEB emerged "as a national body with the purpose of providing graded assessments of the achievements of music students." From the moment of its inception to the present day, the typical AMEB music lesson, geared toward the mid- or end-of-year examination, has concealed a number of important assumptions. 63. These data were taken from an undergraduate student paper written on the AMEB (unpaginated, 6) by Sarah-Grace Williams, University of Western Sydney, Nepean, November 1996, and used with permission. 64. Monique Geitenbeck, "The Role of Women in the Australian Music Examinations Board from 1930-1950," in Nicholas Brown et al., eds., One Hand on the Manuscript: Music in Australian Cultural History (Canberra: Humanities Research Centre, Australian National University, 1995), 195. 65. It is not my intention to investigate the reasons for differences that existed between the first half of the 20th century described earlier and those of the present time. However, one possible explanation, as Therese Radic points out, is that composers in Australia were invisible until Sculthorpe launched a national style in the 1960s. See Radic, "Where Are the Women Composers?," 44. 66. While in its early years the AMEB examined only piano, violin, organ, and singing, as the century progressed, it added the full complement of instruments that make up the symphony orchestra (including percussion) together with classical guitar, recorder, accordion, organ, and electronic organ. 67. Australian Music Examinations Board: 1996 Manual of Syllabuses, 3. 68. Goehr, The Imaginary Museum ofMusical Works. 69. Ibid., 249. 70. I have deliberately used the male pronoun here, for very rarely do women conduct orchestras. 71. Goehr, The Imaginary Museum ofMusical Works, 260. 72. Ibid., 261. 73. See market surveys carried out for Musica Viva, the Australian Chamber Orchestra, and the Sydney Symphony Orchestra as follows: 1994 Research Study ofMusica Viva Subscribers (Sydney: Marketing for Change, 1994); a survey conducted by the Sydney Symphony Orchestra in conjunction with Yann, Campbell, Hoare, Wheeler and Carter James Associates, October 1995, in which it was shown that the audience was skewed to the wealthier suburbs, women, the well educated, and the financially well-off, and 89 percent were aged 40 and over; and the Australian Chamber Orchestra subscriber survey conducted in association with Yann, Campbell, Hoare, Wheeler and Carter James Associates, 1995, in which it was revealed that the audience was skewed to the north shore, the eastern suburbs, and inner west (wealthier suburbs, in that order), 69 percent hold a university degree, 53 percent are in full-time employment, and 79 percent of the audience is in the 36- and-over age bracket. Also see the study of contemporary music audiences by Fiona Allen, "Contemporary Music Audiences in Sydney," Sounds Australian 34 (Winter 1992): 5-7. 74. Allen, "Contemporary Music Audiences." 75. Ibid., 6. 76. See Macarthur, "Feminist Aesthetics in Music," 40-85. 77. Donald, "What are Music Students Really Being Taught?" 18. Donald found that approximately 82 percent of the members of the SBS Youth Orchestra were studying music through the AMEB system. 78. These data were obtained from the AMEB office located on Elizabeth Street, Sydney, May 1996. 79. See Macarthur, "Feminist Aesthetics in Music," 40-85.
Music in Context and Practice
61
80. Goehr, The Museum of Musical Works, 260. 81. See Citron, Gender and the Musical Canon. 82. Ibid., 223. 83. Having made this point, it is important, however, to acknowledge some of the values of the AMEB, especially as it would be perceived by parents: first, the award of a graded certificate provides tangible evidence of a child's competence as she or he progresses to higher levels of accomplishment; second, the provision through the AMEB of structured goals in music learning provides some concrete means for parents to know the level of their child's achievement. 84. In her essay "The Role of Women in the Australian Music Examinations Board from 1930-1950," Geitenbeck laments that women were not accepted as examiners until 1942, long after the AMEB had been established, yet, as she points out, between 1917 and 1930, for example, approximately 85.5 percent of qualified teachers produced over 13 years (having successfully completed their licentiateships) were women. Similarly, she adds, approximately 92.5 percent of candidates who sat at the associate level (A. Mus. A.) were women (189). Geitenbeck argues that women were the invisible force behind the music education of the nation.
This page intentionally left blank
3
The Power of Sound, the Power of Sex: Alma Schindler-Mahler's Ansturm
[T]he archetype of all fiction is the sexual act.. . for what connects fiction—and music—with sex is the fundamental orgastic rhythm of tumescence and detumescence, of tension and resolution, of intensification to the point of climax and consummation. —R. Scholes1 In "Talking Like a Girl," Cate Poynton makes what would seem like an obvious point, that we have no difficulty accepting, even taking for granted, that "voice is profoundly gendered."2 It is an idea that seems to go without saying: women have high-pitched voices, and men have low-pitched voices. It is not obvious, by way of contrast, however, to suggest that music is profoundly gendered. Indeed, mainstream musicology has resisted this notion on the grounds that in its most abstract form music seems to be disconnected from the body and is thus unable to be read in terms of gender or, for that matter, in terms of any other kinds of social meaning. Of course, it would be problematic, not to say simplistic and foolish, to suggest, following suit with voice, that all high-pitched sounds in music are feminine and all low-pitched sounds are masculine. But if this idea seems nonsensical in relation to music, why does it seem to make sense in relation to voice? Indeed, how natural is the voice, really? Is it really true that all women have high-pitched voices and, conversely, that all men have low-pitched voices? In her paper, Poynton problematizes the essentialism that flows from thinking about the naturalness of the gendered voice—that "women and men speak differently because of different configurations of the vocal tract"—in turn, giving rise to the idea that "biology is destiny." As she puts it: "[T]he biological is the source of whatever differentiates women and men from one another—including, of course, the assumption that women are more different from all men than they are different from any of one another."3
64
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
Poynton's own project is to "complicate this 'natural' story of the gendered voice" by attempting "to write a space for voice across the biological and the cultural."4 Using examples of the radio voice from two very different countries, Japan and Australia, Poynton demonstrates that the voice is very much a cultural phenomenon, that the gendering assigned to it is always arbitrary. In this chapter, I question the biological versus cultural argument in relation to music. But I also question the long-running, familiar, and natural story of music, which almost exclusively celebrates music by male composers. This story fails to tell other stories equally deserving of attention. Throughout this book I highlight women's music as a case in point. In the decade of the 1990s music scholars situated in the poststructuralist, feminist camp began to question the singularity of the narrative told about music within modernist frameworks and demonstrated that music operates to sustain unequal relations between the sexes. These scholars showed that institutional power plays a significant role in constructing and maintaining, among other things, the male bias of the musical canon.5 In this chapter, I aim to recover a space for women, focusing on the music of Alma Schindler-Mahler (1879-1964). This is a difficult task, however, for in the act of celebrating her achievements, I find myself becoming embroiled in a number of debates. One of these is the postmodernist view that to undertake close readings of musical works is to continue the modernist cause. As Gary Tomlinson puts it, "[I]t is the act of close reading itself that carries with it the ideological charge of modernism."6 Yet, as Peter McCallum sensibly points out, approaches that avoid close readings amount to a "musicology without music,"7 and this, of course, is problematical. Nonetheless, carrying out close readings of music could be something of a pressing issue, for, as Suzanne Cusick comments, in wanting to distance themselves from modernist frameworks, large numbers of North American musicologists, in particular, feminist and queer theorists, have been systematically moving away from, if not abandoning altogether, the explicit study of composers in the high art music tradition and their works.8 It would seem that it has become increasingly fashionable to be thinking about musics and musicians in terms of their contexts and to be thinking about music as being in a state of dynamic flux, never to be pinned down to analysis. Many scholars have actively avoided dealing with the music itself and have been reluctant to engage with music situated in the Western canon. If they have been concerned with the canon, it is from the point of view of rereading it in order to show how it operates to serve particular interests. There has been a tendency to focus attention on popular musics and musics that cross disciplinary boundaries such as performance art and music theater. I argue that the shift away from the study of art music has had a negative effect on women's music located in the Western art music tradition. From these reflections this present chapter is born. It is a chapter that is bound to sit quite uneasily, if not nervously, on the seat of postmodernism within current music research. Another difficulty for this chapter is that in order to celebrate the musical achievements of this most remarkable composer, Alma Schindler-Mahler, I al-
The Power of Sound, the Power of Sex
65
most inevitably find myself wanting to recover an essential woman. Within the confines of the nature/nurture argument I might be tempted to use biology to explain her difference, for it is obvious that men and women have differences based on their biological makeups. But what this view does not take into account, of course, as my opening remarks make clear, is the significant impact of upbringing and social conditioning. So while it may be tempting to invoke the biological to explain this composer's difference, in the spirit of much of the feminist literature devoted to the body, I shall be required to tread the fine line between treating the body literally and biologically and treating it metaphorically and culturally. My argument in this chapter is situated against the backdrop of literature concerned with aesthetics in general and feminist aesthetics in particular. The central question asks: Does it matter if we fmd that women's music is different from men's music? If it does matter, why does it matter? To begin, then, I want to explore why it matters to view the sexes as separate categories. SEXUAL IDENTITY According to French feminist Luce Irigaray, the question of sexed identity is one of the most important of our time. She offers three reasons for this assertion. First, "Sexual difference is necessary for the continuation of our species, not only because it constitutes the locus of procreation, but also because it's here that life is regenerated. The sexes regenerate one another aside from any question of reproduction."9 Second, she suggests: "The status of sexual difference is obviously related to that of our culture and its languages. Our centuries-old sexual economy is so often cut off from all aesthetic, speculative and truly ethical elaboration that the idea of a sexed culture is astonishing to most people. Sex is said to be a matter separate from civilization."10 Third, she goes on to say that any inquiry would reveal that it is nothing of the sort, that "sexuality, though said to be private, cannot possibly escape from social norms," and she concludes that "what we need for our future civilization, for human maturity, is a sexed culture."11 Finally, she makes the point that the disappearance of a sexual culture gives rise to values that are supposedly universal but that, in fact, permit men to dominate women. I have traversed this ground in the Introduction and Chapter 1, ground that lends support to earlier work elaborated by Irigaray in "This Sex Which Is Not One" and "When Our Lips Speak Together."12 In these essays, Irigaray discusses the female sexual anatomy in quite explicit terms to advance the idea that women are different from men. In essence, she arrives at the conclusion that woman is multiple, yet denied. Irigaray's argument is firmly grounded in biology. But, I want to ask, is that such a bad thing? As an increasing number of feminist theorists are now recognizing, Irigaray's work breaks new ground, for it posits the view that identity and sexual difference are inextricably linked to the body. A number of theorists who have worked more recently in the spirit of postmodernism (and I situate my own work here) have tended to deny the existence of a stable, female self or subject. They argue that the polarization of
66
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
the categories of sex into male versus female is problematic, for these categories are always in a state of flux and can be constituted only provisionally. I have sympathy with this idea, but it might be equally argued that the more fluid the subject and the more fuzzy the boundaries around the categories of male and female, the more difficult it becomes to say what or who is actually being discussed. What I do not wish to do in this chapter is to abandon my subject on the grounds that she is unable to be constituted as a woman who composed music as a woman. BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH OF ALMA SCHINDLER-MAHLER (1879-1964) During the course of her long life Alma Schindler-Mahler had friendships and affairs with, and was married to, some of the most prominent artistic men in Europe. She was in love with Gustav Klimt and very close to Alexander Von Zemlinsky. Other friends included Max Burckhard, Hans Pfitzner, Franz Schreker, Paul Kammerer, Gerhart Hauptmann, Arthur Schnitzler, Arnold Schoenberg, and Alban Berg. Berg dedicated Wozzeck to her and his Violin Concerto to the memory of her daughter, Manon, with the line, "To the Memory of an Angel." She allowed Hans Pfitzner to court her quite openly in front of Mahler, and there was a short-lived, harmless romance with the pianist Ossip Gabrilowitsch, whom Mahler had brought to their house in New York in 1907. She married Gustav Mahler; Walter Gropius, with whom she also had an affair while married to Mahler; and Franz Werfel, with whom she had an affair while married to Gropius. Between her affair with Gropius in 1910 and marriage to Gropius in 1915, she was involved in a notorious love affair with the artist Oskar Kokoschka. Following Mahler's death, Dr. Fraenkel, the physician who had looked after Mahler in America when he was stricken with the disease that killed him, proposed twice to Alma. But she had just gained her independence, and the thought of mothering another, older man, did not appeal to her. Men were constantly around her throughout all three of her marriages. They included the Roman Catholic priest and theologian Johannes Hollensteiner, a much younger man and, as Franchise Giroud notes, it was highly unlikely that this was a platonic relationship.13 The purpose of this chapter is not to present the biographical details of Alma Schindler-Mahler's life. This has been covered more than adequately by others.14 The brief opening sketch, however, points to a personality that was remarkably passionate and to a person who seemed to be constantly consumed by the pursuit of love. It is not surprising, then, that she should engage love as a theme in her music. Indeed, the "love interest" for this chapter materializes as a song. In Ansturm, composed in 1911 and published as the third of four lieder in 1915, the composer provides to a text by Richard Dehmel a vivid and sexually explicit musical account of erotic love, subject matter that would have been regarded by many as taboo for women at the turn of the century in Vienna. There has been some speculation that the numerous love interests that seem to have dominated Alma Schindler-Mahler's life acted as substitutes for the music
The Power of Sound, the Power of Sex
67
that she yearned to compose. Edward Kravitt makes the point that to view Alma as no more than a woman who was sexually available to men is to ignore other important aspects of her personality. She was, for example, prone to depression. As he says, "Before her marriage [to Mahler], composition was her major interest. It served also as psychological support in periods of distress."15 Alma herself confided: "When I was on the verge of suicide I began to compose again, to seek some creative outlet for my grief."16 In this instance she was referring to her stepfather Carl Moll's interference in her relationship with Klimt when she was 18. Throughout her life, however, she was often seriously depressed, a condition that could have been exacerbated during her marriage to Mahler, since he forbade her to compose but, rather, told her to regard his music as hers. As he put it to her before they married, "From now on you have only one profession: to make me happyl"11 By the time she became engaged to Mahler, she had already produced more than 100 lieder, some instrumental music, and a sketch for an opera. All that remains of her entire output are 14 lieder.18 It may have been socially acceptable at the turn of that century to expect that a woman would obey her husband. It is difficult to fathom, however, given that she had already produced a substantial output and seemed intent on making composing her serious profession, why Mahler would have insisted on silencing her. During their marriage, Mahler became totally engrossed in his work and ignored and suppressed his wife's artistic aspirations. In the first five years of the marriage, she felt helpless and, writing in her diary, commented: "He lives his own life—and I must live it too!"19 He often admonished her, suggesting that his friends found her intelligent only because she was beautiful, and ridiculed her literary and philosophical tastes. With her artistic freedom severely restricted and becoming increasingly aware of her life's emptiness, she studied Greek and translated Plato to keep herself occupied. Not until the marriage came to a crisis point in 1910, causing Mahler to consult with Freud, did Mahler realize what he had done and encouraged her, out of fear of losing her, to resume her composition. He helped her to publish the first song cycle, Funf Lieder, in 1910. These were all chosen from her existing songs.20 Alma Schindler-Mahler's relationship with her father, Emile Schindler, who had died when she was 13 years old, is also worthy of comment. He was a landscape artist and had encouraged her creativity from a very early age and, as Kravitt remarks, "enkindled her love for the avant garde."21 Through him she was introduced to the important poets and philosophers of the day and, as a consequence, developed a deep love of literature, particularly poetry and philosophical writings. She loved her father, whom she described as "a knight in shining armour, unfettered by bourgeois convention."22 According to her biographers, the resemblance of Mahler to her father probably attracted her to him. As she said herself, "I really had always been looking for a short stocky man with the wisdom and intellectual superiority I had known in my father."23 There is no doubt that Alma Schindler-Mahler had an extraordinary musical talent. She was also seen as nonconformist. Indeed, to become a composer in a field dominated by men was already taking a step into territory that was officially taboo
68
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
for women. At that time, however, her style was arguably at the vanguard. In company with her then-colleague, Arnold Schoenberg, who had also been under the tutelage of Alexander von Zemlinsky, her music was viewed as highly experimental. Like Schoenberg's, her music was daringly chromatic, and, in some of her songs, there is a tendency to drift away from keys and tonal centers altogether. Her accompaniments were regarded by some, such as Kravitt and Filler,24 as having the most interest, being likened to those of Brahms, with thick textured chords, sometimes broken and sometimes solid. Her style is seen to have its foundations in Wagner, whom incidentally, she had greatly admired when she was an adolescent. She has been variously labeled egocentric and arrogant, a siren, a devouring maenad, a nymphomaniac, a femme fatale. But, then, what were the options for women at the turn of the century in Central Europe? There was only a handful of roles for a woman to play and to be seen to play and among the artistic community, flaunting convention and viewing Victorian values as prudish, the femme fatale was certainly one such role. The German expression that sums up the most acceptable role for women was Kinder, Kirche, Ktiche: children, church, cooking. A woman was to be an adornment to the life of her husband. There were also, of course, a couple of other alternatives, the godly and devilish deviants: nuns and whores. It could be argued that 19th-century Europe was inscribed with a deep, soulful masculinity. Human subjects were men. Men were seen to be at the center of the universe and at the center of all artistic creation. In late 19th-century Vienna, it was not possible for women to follow their own creative urges. They were expected instead to live according to a masculine prescription. As Francoise Giroud writes: Girls were brought up to regard their virginity as something sacrosanct, prudery was the rule, hysterical breakdowns werefrequent.Men, single or not, went to obtain from actress or working girls what the women of their own milieu longed to give them but could not, fo their honor stood in the way. A respectable woman in Vienna, as elsewhere, did not posse a body. If she discovered she did have one, then the devil must have got into the holy wat Once her sexuality was aroused, the irrepressible violence of her instincts, her natural propensity to lewdness, would be unleashed. Women had to be defended against themselves, by education and constraint.25 As Giroud continues, a woman was deemed to be "the natural enemy of morality, reason, and creativity."26 But there are always exceptions to every rule. From an early age, Alma Schindler-Mahler was surrounded by artists, art and music, and numerous books. On a diet of the literary classics, poetry, and philosophy and having access to the avant-garde, it was not surprising that she saw herself able to become an artist in her own right. But it was not to be when she married Gustav Mahler, older by more than half her age. I am not the first to remark that had things been different, the course of music history might have changed significantly.
The Power of Sound, the Power of Sex
69
Kravitt notes that for her songs she chose poets who were known as the radical intellectuals: Richard Dehmel (1863-1920), Rainer Maria Rilke (1875-1926), Otto Julius Bierbaum (1865-1910), Gustav Falke (1853-1915), and Franz Werfel (1890-1945). Through her father's stimulus, according to Kravitt, Alma Mahler had become fascinated with the mystic, the search for life's inner meaning. Her poets were similarly on that journey, expressing something of an inner or hidden reality beyond outer reality.27 Dehmel was a particular favorite of hers, possibly because he was viewed as a dangerous radical. As Wilhelm Kahle observes, this poet's struggles to express people's freedom brought him to a police court on charges of obscenity.28 Interestingly, 4 of the 14 songs that remain from Alma Schindler-Mahler's output are to Dehmel's poetry. In this chapter I posit the idea that it is possible to view Schindler-Mahler's music in terms of difference based on the particularities of her sex. In making this claim, I compare two contemporaneous settings of Ansturm: Alma Schindler- Mahler's setting composed in 1911 and that of her former teacher, Alexander von Zemlinsky, composed four years earlier in 1907. As a general rule, I do not regard comparisons of this kind as productive, forfrequentlythey serve the purpose of strengthening the negative associations made of women's music. Furthermore, it is difficult to find examples that make such comparisons meaningful. In this instance, however, I believe that a comparison is warranted. Both composers have chosen the identical genre for the expression of their chosen text, itself identical in both settings. In addition, Schindler-Mahler borrowed from the music of Zemlinsky's opening bars and radically transformed it into something else. Finally, the style of their music is similar, though it is arguably the case that Schindler-Mahler's style is far more adventurous in its use of atonality than that of Zemlinsky. NOTIONS OF THE SEXUAL IN MUSICAL ANALYSIS Marcia Citron suggests that Ansturm is possibly one of the earliest songs by a woman set to a text on sexual desire and release. In this respect it is extraordinarily daring and provocative. As Citron continues: Its brilliant musical contrasts would provide fodder enough for lively discussion of style. But arguably its frank expression of forbidden subject matter is much more important and opens the door to larger questions. What did it mean for women around 1900 to openly express sexual desire and release? How were women of her background and class conceptualized sexually?... What these queries suggest is that music as lived practice represents much more than style, formalism, and a succession of great names and works.29 Men and women alike, albeit in different ways from each other, have always known what it is to experience desire, love, passion, eroticism, sexual passion, climax and release. Moreover, although sex has tended to be a taboo subject—even today we are cautious about it—when it is discussed, it frequently draws on stereotypes.
70
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
Representations of male desire and release are regularly discussed in terms of erection-penetration-climax-closure.30 Contrasting the stereotypical male experience of sex is the idea that women's sexual experiences are multiple and "indefinite, cyclic, without set beginnings and endings."31 These essentialist formulations have wide currency. Furthermore, to invoke the cliche "if art imitates life," then it is not beyond the realm of possibility that music should imitate the sexual act. Indeed, there has been a history of writing on this subject, including that by Edmund Gurney, who, writing in 1880, argues that the presentation of music as motion corresponds to sexual (e)motion.32 Drawing on Charles Darwin's The Descent of Man, Gurney attempted to explain that the highly pleasurable characteristics of what he termed "impressive music" were, in Malcolm Budd's words, the "sublimated quintessence of primitive sexual passions."33 But to avoid these messy kinds of discussions and thus to avoid thinking about music's connectedness to the human body and to bodily behaviors, music theorists also have sought to explain music by using other kinds of analytical models. One such model is based on the notion that there exists a perfect or divine ratio.34 Studies using this model show that the great masterworks from the canon conform to the ideal proportion (or golden section). I would argue that such studies are used to justify and perpetuate the notion of the ideal in music. Analytical models such as these privilege a particular kind of music, disregarding musics of other cultures, popular musics,35 and, pertinently for this book, women's music.36 What is interesting, however, is that analytical models that explain music in terms of the divine ratio are not mutually exclusive to a model that uses the metaphor of analysis in which a stereotypical idea of male sexual desire and release is invoked. What we find with the divine ratio is that the climax tends to be positioned around two-thirds of the way through the music (or at the proportion 0.618). This corresponds to a stereotypical idea of male sexual experience in which erection and penetration leading to climax take longer than the aftermath leading to closure. In contrast to this, I would argue that models of analysis that invoke the divine ratio and models that explain music using a metaphor of female sexual desire and release are more than likely to be mutually exclusive. On a model of women's experience of sex, if we are to invoke the essentialist and stereotypical idea of this given earlier by Renee Cox,37 there are likely to be several climaxes instead of one major climax, and each climax, in all likelihood, will vary in intensity, perhaps avoiding closure altogether. If we accept this proposition, then, in all likelihood, the sexual metaphor for female sexual desire and release will not correlate with the "golden mean." I want to make it clear, at this point, however, that I recognize the fact that men and women alike have access to the feminine and the masculine. Thus, it is possible for men to appropriate the female metaphor for sex and imitate it, and, conversely, it is possible for women to appropriate the male metaphor and imitate it. Susan McClary, for example, provides an excellent account of Schoenberg's appropriation of the feminine. She suggests that his expressionist works sound like the dissonant ravings of a madwoman and infers that he has deliberately feminized his musical language.381 ex-
The Power of Sound, the Power of Sex
71
pand on this idea in the next chapter in relation to my discussion of Elisabeth Lutyens' serial music. Nonetheless, the stereotypes for sexual behavior that I have discussed have wide currency, and, in effect, I argue that such notions of sex and the sexual have been appropriated as frameworks, albeit subconsciously, for a number of analytical models that have been used in music. I am, of course, all too aware that these notions are problematic. Sexual experiences by men and women cannot be reduced to such rigid, formulaic explications, an idea that resonates with other binary constructions such as male and female, masculinity and femininity. The boundaries separating male from female and masculine from feminine can never be defined categorically. Indeed, it is possible for both women and men to exhibit varying degrees of masculine and feminine traits. If we accept, however, that bodies mediate music and that the sex of a body, together with other aspects of identity, is likely to influence the way in which the music is written, then it is possible to imagine that music composed by a woman will reflect differences that are, perhaps, attributable to her sex. The male dominance of the canon, coupled with the dominance of music theory by analysts who have sought to explain greatness in music according to what I call male models, including analytical methods such as that of Schenker, where the notion of the ideal is implied and seems to correspond to a male sexual metaphor, has led to what feminist musicologists have suggested is an unbalanced view of music. If we accept that the stereotypical idea of male sexual passion and release is a metaphor for particular kinds of musical methods of analysis, then we might wish to ask why this metaphor is privileged over the female experience, which I suggest is conceivably different. Indeed, it would seem that in mainstream culture female experiences of the sexual are virtually ignored. While I do not go so far as to suggest that sexual experiences can be reduced rigidly to differences based on biological sex, I am nonetheless seeking some kind of explanation for the differences that I have found in music by women composers. ANSTURM (SCHINDLER-MAHLER'S SETTING, 1911; PUBLISHED 1915; ZEMLINSKY'S SETTING, 1907) In turning to Alma Schindler-Mahler's music in order to revisit her setting of the Dehmel poem Ansturm, I include a brief comparison of her setting with that of Alexander Von Zemlinsky. Zemlinsky was her composition teacher before she met and married Gustav Mahler, and it would be fair to say that he had a significant influence on her compositional style. Zemlinsky composed his setting of Ansturm in 1907, four years before Alma Schindler-Mahler's version. This song is one of the products of her later work and not the work that predates her marriage to Mahler. The poem Ansturm by Richard Dehmel is already, before its mediation into music by Alma Schindler-Mahler, a passionate outpouring. See Text Example 3.1.
72
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
Text Example 3.1 Ansturm (Assault or Uprush39) by Richard Dehmel (Translation by Margit Franklin-Spaeth and Jim Franklin40) O zurne nicht,wenn mein Begehren dunkel aus seinen Grenzen bricht, soil es uns selber nicht verzehren, muG es heraus ans Licht! ans Licht! Fuhlst ja, wie all mein Innres brandet, und wenn herauf der Aufruhr bricht, jah tideinen Frieden strandet, dann bebst du aber du ziirnst mir nicht. Oh don't be wrathful When my passion darkly breaks its bounds, That it not consume us, It must come out Into the light! Into the light! [Mahler, significant musical climax; Zemlinsky, no climax] You feel, ah, how all my inner being surges And when the uproar breaks And strands itself abruptly on your peace, [Mahler, less-significant climax; Zemlinsky, significant climax] Then you tremble but without wrath towards me. [Mahler, final cadence open; Zemlinsky, final cadence closed] As the translators point out, this is a poem in which the lover (a man) is addressing his beloved (a woman). The opening line implies that there has been a sense of repression on behalf of the lover, that he has not been able to express his passion in the past. He asks his beloved not to be wrathful, for it is now time for his passion to break its bounds so that it does not consume both lover and beloved in flames. According to the translators, verzehren conjures up the notion not just of passion itself but of being burned by passion, consumed by it. It must come out into the light, and "light" here, as the translators point out, is a spiritual concept that has to do with liberation. In addition, light here also represents the idea of ecstasy. As Franklin-Spaeth and Franklin suggest, the key image in the first stanza is that of passion and fire. The second stanza, according to the translators, implies a release of the lover's passion through attainment of sexual climax. "When my passion darkly breaks its bounds" in the first stanza is resolved in the second: "and when the uproar breaks and strands itself abruptly on your peace." Here is a symbolic connotation or metaphor that "peace" is also the shore, the implication being that the shore is also a place of safety. The wrath—"O don't be wrathful"—in the first stanza is also re-
The Power of Sound, the Power of Sex
73
solved—"but without wrath towards me." Moreover, "and you tremble," suggests the shuddering of an earthquake, but, as Margit Franklin-Spaeth suggests, this is an earthquake of ecstasy, not of anger. The metaphor in the second stanza is ocean and waves—conjuring up the idea of turbulence—and the shoreline, solid ground, representing the safe haven.41 Alma Schindler-Mahler's treatment of this text is evocative, a passionate outpouring. As Sarah Click says: "The challenge to match its erotic mood through musical expression is met quite aggressively by the composer."42 The composer avoids establishing a key or key center for the song and uses nonfunctional harmony extensively, thus indicating a move in the direction of atonality. The bass line underpinning the first section returns in the last and creates a sense of musical coherence for the song as a whole. It could be argued that the music makes explicit what is implicit in the words. There is urgency in the music from the outset. The first stanza, constituting the whole of the first section, begins with a declamatory, recitative-like style, with the words of the singer punctuated by sustained block chords. The first three declamations are rounded off dramatically with an abrupt tritone leap in the bass, B flat to E, suggesting something ominous, perhaps, at bar 7. This leads, with much more activity in the accompaniment, to a major moment of tension—a climax—on the words "ans licht\"—"it must come out into the light." This is the major climax of the song. See Text Example 3.1 and Musical Example 3.1. Musical Example 3.1 Alma Schindler-Mahler, Vier Lieder No. 3, Ansturm (Bars 8-14)
74
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
The second stanza, the first line of which acts as a bridge between the first and second sections, is almost impressionistic in the Debussyian sense as its broken chords tumble out in descending patterns to evoke images of waves breaking. These descending arpeggios, it could be argued, contrast with the way in which arpeggios are employed conventionally in climactic passages. Typically, a musical climax is achieved by preceding it with a series of ascending arpeggios set against a rising bass line, a pattern that might also be understood to be ejaculatory. By way of contrast, descending arpeggios do not create the necessary tension for climax and may be understood, to continue with the sexual metaphor, as avoiding arousal. So while Alma Schindler-Mahler heads the music toward a second climax in this section (at bar 21), it is a climax that is not as intense or as dramatic as the first. Here, however, in contrast to the first climax, resolution can be attained only through release, suggested by the text (see Text Example 3.1). Yet I would argue that the music is less inclined to provide that release, even though, on the surface, it might seem that the descending, arpeggiated chords, which occasionally break into solid blocks, are suggestive of such release. In the final section, however, the music is quite unsettled. Whereas there is a sense of resolution, even finality in the final line of the poem—"but without wrath towards me"—this is not echoed in the music. Indeed, the whole song concludes on a dominant seventh chord over a root in the bass on A, thus avoiding closure altogether. I wonder, then, whether this woman composer was ambivalent about the closure implied by the poem? If it is agreed that the sexual stereotypes are different for women's and men's experiences, then it is possible to draw attention to the ways in which this song may be seen to be representing passionate love from a female perspective—even in its setting of the words spoken by a male. Indeed, I argue that the composer, whether consciously or unconsciously, has subverted the masculine stereotype. As I have already noted, the song resists closure. It is left hanging on a V7 chord, which is approached by a flat VI chord to heighten the tension of its nonresolution. By not ending on a tonic chord, she has violated both the requirement of the poem to attain closure and the musical framework within which she has chosen to work.43 See Musical Example 3.2. Moreover, the seventh (G) in the chord is doubled. It is set as the melodic note before leaping a tritone to rest on the third of the chord (C sharp). This creates a highly unstable feeling for the final chord. So, whereas the words of the text are arguably complete, conclusive, final, and resolved, the music, in stark contrast, lacks this sense of completeness and finality by blatantly resisting closure. Instead, the song hovers on a. dominant seventh chord, refusing to provide that sense of completion and fulfillment suggested by the text. The song is cast in a loose ternary shape. The first section takes up almost half the entire length of the song. The first 17 bars constitute section A; the next 6 bars make up section B; and the last 8 bars make up section A1. If we were to consider the musical balance of the setting of the first stanza to the second stanza, we would find that there is virtually an equal proportion of music allotted to both stanzas, yielding a ratio of approximately 1:1 (17 to 18 bars). The ratio of the three sections
The Power of Sound, the Power of Sex
75
Musical Example 3.2 Alma Schindler-Mahler, Vier Lieder No. 3, Ansturm (Bars 28-31)
to each other, however, presents an entirely different sense of balance for the song. Using a beat-counting analysis—perhaps a more accurate way of looking at the overall architecture of the song, for it takes into account the tempo changes—we find that the ratios are 3:1:1, revealing that the song is top-heavy.44 This is already interesting when I recall other works by women that are proportioned in a similar manner. Moya Henderson's Sacred Site for grand organ and tape, for example, is divided into four sections with a ratio of 5:1:1:2. Marcia Citron's analysis of the first movement of Cecile Chaminade's Piano Sonata shows that it is also top-heavy with a ratio of 5:1:2.45 In stark contrast, the ratio of the three sections (stanza 1 -interlude-stanza 2) in the Zemlinsky setting of this poem reveals that his song is bottom-heavy. Using a real-time analysis, the ratios are 5:1:10. The climaxes of the song are particularly interesting. The first climax in Ansturm, arguably the most intense and dramatic moment, occurs at bar 15 to the words "into the light" (see Text Example 3.1). On a beat-counting analysis, this climax yields a proportion that is, surprisingly, close in proximity to the shorter section of the golden mean of 0.382. The proportion yielded by the first climax in Ansturm is 0.39. It is not usual, as Clive Pascoe's work demonstrates,46 for the major climax of musical works by male composers (he does not examine music by women) to occur in the earlier part of a work. In this song by Alma SchindlerMahler, the major interest is in its opening bars. It might be argued that there is little, if any, foreplay (to draw again on the sexual metaphor), and what is created instead, perhaps, is something of a premature ejaculation. Where we expect a major musical climax according to the male norm, however, is around two-thirds of the way through the music or at the longer section of the golden mean which is 0.618. While we get a climax close to that proportion in this song, its impact is not as intense (it occurs midway through bar 21 on the word strandet). A beat-counting analysis reveals that the second and less intense climax for the song, then, occurs quite close to the golden mean at 0.68. What is interest-
76
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
ing for this analysis, however, is that the proportions have been placed in reverse order from what is arguably considered the norm in music. So, in this analysis, it would seem that the notion of the ideal, stemming from notions of male sexual passion (though often also discussed in terms of the transcendental or divine), is possibly subverted. Might it be that a woman would understand sexual love (even transcendental love) differently than a man would? Why has she given more emphasis to the first climax than to the second? Why does she not conclude the work, as would be expected from the poem—the words in the text imply that the woman understands this climactic difference between the sexes—with a tonic? Why does she end with the dominant seventh chord, leaving the last bar open and hovering, as if, in fact, all has not been resolved? In contrast to Schindler-Mahler's setting, Zemlinsky's (composed in 1907) is a complete understatement of the passion implied by the poem. The opening accompaniment figure in the piano part of the Zemlinsky setting is appropriated by Alma Schindler-Mahler for the voice part. Zemlinsky's setting, however, is much less adventurous harmonically than hers, and he adopts a more traditional approach to the structure of the song by inserting a short interlude between the two stanzas. Although the poetry calls for a climax on the words ans Lichtl, Zemlinsky does not provide a major climax at this point. Instead, he motions toward a climax, using a rising harmonic sequence in the second stanza, and while his positioning of the climax occurs at a greater distance from the golden section (0.618) at 0.828 on the word strandet, it nonetheless makes an attempt to model itself on the stereotypical male experience of sex. Zemlinsky also closes his song with the expected resolution of a tonic chord. The idea that Alma Schindler-Mahler's setting of Ansturm is a woman's piece, exhibiting aesthetic qualities that are particular to the sex of the composer, has been further reinforced by some observations made to me by a friend who happened to hear the song. Rosemary Schaffler remarked that Ansturm opens up a space that is between the male/female dichotomy for the following reasons. First, the text is the expression of a male persona, yet the woman sings. A further expression of the dichotomy is that the male poet writes, and the female composes. In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, especially, it is unusual to find erotic poetry written by a man and set to music by a woman. The convention is rather that the male poet writes and the male composer creates the music. In the contemporary recital hall women frequently sing poetic texts by men set to music by men that express love toward a woman from a male perspective (thus, perhaps, seen to be producing a cross-dressing effect). Schaffler's observation is therefore pertinent, for in this instance the convention is transgressed. Second, as Schaffler points out, the male poet's feminine component shows in his placing of climaxes. Alma Schindler-Mahler's climaxes correspond with Dehmel's, but Zemlinsky's do not. It might be surmised, then, that Zemlinsky is seeking to satisfy his masculine side, that with masculine intuition he feels the music would become top-heavy if he were to place a major climax so early in the song. Such a consideration, it would seem, did not enter into the thinking of Schindler-
The Power of Sound, the Power of Sex
77
Mahler. Finally, Schaffler observes that Zemlinsky's closure seems to be earthbound, while Schindler-Mahler's nonclosure or open-endedness has hovering, trembling effect. She suggests that where the male writes and the male composes, there is the potential for the doubling up of one-sidedness, leaving no space between the male/female dichotomy. Yet it seems that the poet here has provided an opportunity for the space because he is in touch with his own feminine side. As Schaffler concludes, Schindler-Mahler seized the opportunity to provide that space, while Zemlinsky missed it.47 Alma Schindler-Mahler would have been well aware of the accepted codes of behavior for both men and women in her day. In some respects, she was nonconformist. She did not adopt accepted behaviors for women, including, if we conceive of composing as a behavior, venturing onto the male territory of composing. But, as may be inferred from Judith Butler's work,48 she would also have rehearsed many behaviors that were deemed acceptable for women of her time. On the one hand, then, this particular composer may be viewed as one who, in her lived life, broke moral codes and other codes that were taboo for women, such as accessing the intellectual worlds of philosophy, art, and music normally reserved for men. But she would also have conformed in other ways, such as in bearing children (she gave birth to four) and in being a dutiful and obedient wife. It may also be useful to ask, as Suzanne Cusick before me has asked of a much earlier composer, Francesca Caccini,49 How did Alma Schindler-Mahler herself perform as a composer? Obviously, her role models in musical composition had been men. Indeed, as a child growing up, she was well acquainted with the works of Wagner and, as a highly competent pianist, performed the piano reductions of his operas, over and over again, until she knew them by heart. So Wagner's music, together with that of Brahms and her teacher, Zemlinsky, and others, would have been the repository from which she would have drawn for her own work. Yet (and here I borrow another idea from Cusick, whose work is based on that of Butler), She would have also rehearsed aspects of her gender into the music that she composed and performed.50 Thus, the body and the body as a mediator of music are strongly connected. Alma Schindler-Mahler accessed, rehearsed, and performed music, her own and that of others, becoming an accomplished composer and imitating the styles of her male role models. But also her sexed body, her female body, performed these acts of imitating, composing, and performing. It would seem, then, that Alma Schindler-Mahler was a composing woman—to invoke Irigaray again, ambiguous, and yet denied—whose music, while owing some allegiances to male models, is sprinkled with difference. What I seem to have discovered is that some of the normal conventions of musical behavior, in this instance, have been transgressed. NOTES 1. R. Scholes, Fabulation and Metafiction (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 19 26.
78
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
2. Cate Poynton, "Talking Like a Girl," in Sally Macarthur and Cate Poynton, eds., Musics and Feminisms (Sydney: Australian Music Centre, 1999), 119. 3. Ibid. 4. Ibid. 5. Susan McClary's Feminine Endings: Music, Gender, and Sexuality (Minnesota a Oxford: University of Minnesota Press, 1991), and Marcia Citron's Gender and the Musical Canon (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993) provide vivid accounts of this phenomenon. 6. Gary Tomlinson, "Musical Pasts and Postmodern Musicologies: A Response to Lawrence Kramer," Current Musicology 53 (1993): 22. 7. Peter McCallum, "The Analytical Significance of Beethoven's Sketches for the String Quartet in F Major, Opus 135: Vol. 1, Analysis" (Doctoral dissertation, Department of Music, University of Sydney, March 1994), 14. 8. Suzanne Cusick, "Performing/Composing/Woman: Francesca Caccini Meets Judith Butler," in Macarthur and Poynton, eds., Musics and Feminisms, 87-98. 9. Luce Irigaray ye, tu, nous: Toward a Culture of Difference, trans. Alison Martin (New York and London: Routledge, 1993), 15. 10. Ibid. 11. Ibid., 16. 12. These essays are published in Luce Irigaray, This Sex Which Is Not One, trans. Catherine Porter with Carolyn Burke (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1985), 23-33, 205-218. 13. Francois Giroud, Alma Mahler or the Art ofBeing Loved, trans. R. M. Stock (Oxfor and New York: Oxford University Press, 1991), 1. 14. See, for example, Susanne Keegan, The Bride of the Wind: The Life ofAlma Mahl (London: Seeker and Warburg, 1991); Walter Sorell, Three Women: Alma Mahler-Werf Gertrude Stein, Lou Andreas-Salome: Lives of Sex and Genius (London: Oswald Wolf 1975); Giroud, Alma Mahler or the Art of Being Loved. Alma Mahler herself contribute autobiographies as follows: And the Bridge Is Love (London: Hutchinson, 1959); Mein Leben (Frankfurt, 1960). She also provides interesting insights about her husband in Donald Mitchell, ed., Gustav Mahler: Memories and Letters (London: Faber and Faber, 1973). 15. Edward F. Kravitt, "The Lieder of Alma Maria Schindler-Mahler," The Music /Review 49 (1988): 190. 16. Ibid. 17. From Mahler's letter to Alma in December 1901 before their marriage, quoted in Giroud, Alma Mahler, 37. 18. Susan Filler provides the publication details of the 14 lieder in "A Composer's Wife as Composer: The Songs of Alma Mahler," Journal of Musicological Research, 3.3/4 (1983): 429. They are as follows: 5 Lieder, Wien: Universal Edition, 1910: "Die stille Stadt," "In meines Vaters garten," "Laue Sommernacht," "Bei dir ist es traut," and "Ich wandle unter Blumen"; 4 Lieder, Wien: Universal Edition, 1915: "Licht in der Nacht," "Waldseligkeit," "Ansturm," and "Erntelied"; and 5 Gesange, Leipzig: Josef Weinberger, 1924: "Hymne," "Ekstase," "Der Erkennende," "Lobgesang," and "Hymne an die Nacht." 19. Sorell, Three Women, 14. 20. Keegan, The Bride of the Wind, 60. 21. Kravitt, "The Lieder of Alma Maria Schindler-Mahler," 192. 22. Keegan, The Bride of the Wind, 2. 23. Giroud, Alma Mahler, 87. 24. See Kravitt, "The Lieder of Alma Maria Schindler-Mahler"; Susan M Filler, "A Composer's Wife as Composer," 427-442.
The Power of Sound, the Power of Sex
79
25. Giroud, Alma Mahler, 10. 26. Ibid., 11. 27. See Kravitt, "The Lieder of Alma Maria Schindler-Mahler." 28. Wilhelm Kahle, Geschichte der deutschen Dichtung (Munster, 1954), 338, cited in Kravitt, "The Lieder of Alma Maria Schindler-Mahler," 192. 29. Citron, Gender and the Musical Canon, 111. 30. Elizabeth Sayrs makes this explicit in her interpretation of Susan McClary's analysis of Janika Vandervelde's Jack and the Beanstalk in "Deconstructing McClary: Narrative, Feminine Sexuality, and Feminism in Susan McClary's Feminine Endings''' College Music Symposium: Journal of the College Music Society, 33/34 (1993-1994): 45. 31. Adapting the work of the French feminists, Renee Cox uses this phrase in "Recovering Jouissance: An Introduction to Feminist Musical Aesthetics," in Karin Pendle, ed., Woman and Music: A History (Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 1991), 334. 32. Edmund Gurney, The Power ofSound (London: Basic Books, 1966 [1880]). The idea that music has resonances with the sexual and aspects of the sexual, such as childbirth, has been taken up by a number of feminist theorists. See, for example, McClary's discussion of Janika Vandervelde's Genesis //in Feminine Endings, 112-131. Suzanne Cusick, while not describing the music itself in these terms, nonetheless ponders on what a lesbian relationship with music would be like. See Suzanne Cusick, "On a Lesbian Relationship with Music: A Serious Effort Not to Think Straight," in Philip Brett, Elizabeth Wood, and Gary C. Thomas, eds. Queering the Pitch: The New Gay and Lesbian Musicology (New York and London: Routledge, 1994), 67-83. 33. Malcolm Budd, Music and the Emotions: The Philosophical Theories (London and New York: Routledge, 1985), 57. 34. See, for example, Clive Pascoe, "Golden Proportion in Musical Design," (D.M.A. dissertation, University of Cincinnati, 1973). See also Erno Lendvai, Bela Bartok: An Analysis ofHis Music (London: Kahn and Averill, 1971); Roy Howat, Debussy in Proportion: A Musical Analysis (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983); Barry Kenny, "Charlie Parker and the Golden Section: An Examination of Structural Unity in the Released and Alternate Takes of An Oscar for Treadwell" paper presented at the Musicological Society Conference, Perth, July 1999. 35. Kenny's paper cited in ibid, is the first of which I am aware that attempts to map the golden proportion onto jazz. 36. See, in particular, Sally Macarthur, "Music Analysis as a Pedagogical Practice," in "Feminist Aesthetics in Music." 37. As stated earlier, Cox views women's sexual experiences as "indefinite, cyclic, without set beginnings and endings." See Cox, "Recovering Jouissance," 331-340. 38. McClary, Feminine Endings, 106-109. 39. The word also conjures up the idea of storm, blast, and onslaught. Margit Franklin-Speath says that the word Ansturm is not used very often in the German language in the late 20th century and that it is difficult to translate. What seems to be implied by the word in relation to the poem, however, is a sense of turbulence in relation to passion. 40.1 owe gratitude to Margit Franklin-Spaeth and to my colleague Jim Franklin for this translation and to Margit Franklin-Spaeth for her insider-knowledge and insights, as a native German speaker, of the way in which the German language works to produce layers of meaning. 41.1 draw attention to some of the keywords of the poem (highlighted by the translators) that validate the interpretation offered for the poem: • Brandet—the waves come, breaks at the shoreline.
80
Feminist Aesthetics in Music • Aufruhr bricht—a breaker, a big wave breaks. • Strandet—similar to brandet but implies arriving at the shore, in the meaning of being soothed (that is why there is the connection with Friede—peace). • Ziirnen—means being very angry. Here ziirnst (anger) is seen passively and is equated with the idea of someone who awakens emotions in response to someone who might be angry. • Friede—peace/the shore (Frieden). • Beben—shaking to the ground, an earthquake (very dramatic), but here it is a positive earthquake, as there is no wrath caused. It is more the earthquake of ecstasy.
42. Sarah Click, "Art Song by Turn-of-the-Century Female Composers: Lili Boulanger and Alma Mahler" (D.M.A. dissertation [partial fulfillment], University of North Texas, 1993), 60. 43. Alma Schindler-Mahler uses the strategy of nonclosure at the final cadence in two other songs, Laue Sommernacht (from FiinfLieder) and Licht in der Nacht (from Vier L der). 44. A, with the pauses added, comprises approximately 61 beats, B, with pauses added, comprises approximately 21 beats, and A1, with pauses added, comprises approximately 32 beats. My thanks to Ian Shanahan for his assistance with this aspect of the analysis. 45. See Citron, Gender and the Musical Canon, 149. 46. See Pascoe, Golden Proportion in Musical Design. 47. My thanks to Rosemary Schaffler for these observations. Personal communication, October 2000. 48. See Judith Butler, Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity (N York and London: Routledge, 1990). 49. See Cusick, "Performing/Composing/Woman," 87-98. 50. See ibid.
4
Sexing the Subject of Musical Analysis: Rebecca Clarke and Elisabeth Lutyens
[Music] is . .. pure form, liberated from any object or from matter. To this extent, music is the art that is least limited by physical considerations in that it represents pure motion as such, abstracted from any other object and borne on invisible, almost spiritual wings. —Friedrich von Schelling1 Far from setting the score aside and concentrating on extramusical issues, my work is always concerned with explaining how it is that certain images or responses are invoked by particular musical details. But as long as we approach questions of signification exclusivelyfroma formalist point of view, we will continue to conclude that it is impossible to get from chords, pitch-class sets, or structures to any other kind of human or social meaning. —Susan McClary2
This chapter is in two parts. In Part 1,1 outline the long-running debate over music's abstract nature: whether music has meanings only in and on its own terms or whether, like all other signifying systems, it is seen to reflect and be implicated in the social world that it inhabits, including that of ideology and politics. Set up on a binary model, the debate remains unresolved. In Part 2, I analyze music by two English women composers—the first movement of Rebecca Clarke's Piano Trio (1921) and the cantata O Saisons, O Chateaux! for soprano and strings, op. 13 (1946) by Elisabeth Lutyens—both of whose music would tend to be ignored in the disciplines of music analysis and music theory. Part of the reason for its absence in these disciplines is that these composers are women. But another part of the reason has to do with the fact that the conservative arm of music analysis and
82
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
music theory tends to align itself with the view that music is a self-contained, fully autonomous system, complete in and of itself, having no connection or reference to its social context. This debate is founded on two mutually exclusive, opposing positions. As a consequence, I am mindful that by unpacking it, I face the danger of reinforcing the contradiction thrown up by the terms discussed. Yet it is a necessary methodological tool that cannot be avoided. In order to ground my own work—located between the cracks and slippages of the dichotomies discussed—it is important to engage with the debate and to discover its own sets of contradictions as they emerge. I have deliberately considered these two English composers in the same chapter in order to demonstrate that, despite their different engagements with musical techniques, styles, and genres, links between them can be established on the grounds of their sex. PARTI Music as Absolute versus Referential During the 19th century, music was abstracted and rationalized by a school of philosophical thought that argued not only for the superiority of the syntactical construction of music over its cultural references, thereby failing to account for a connection between the two, but also for the idea that music is able to transcend the mind itself. I discuss this idea in Chapter 1, but it is useful to reiterate it here, for in the context of the present debate, it was thought that the ultimate experience of music was a transcendent one, something akin to an out-of-body or out-of-mind experience. Music as transcendence—that is, the notion that a listener is taken outside reality to a world beyond music and beyond its formal systems where, perhaps, it is imagined to refer only to "the soul or spirit, to the very essence of the divine or the human mind"3—is prevalent in the writings of a number of 19th-century humanist philosophers. For example, Arthur Schopenhauer tells us: "Music, unlike all the other arts, does not represent ideas or phases in the will's objectification, but rather represents the will itself with nothing intervening . . . it is pure form without matter, like a world of spirits without material."4 Drawing a comparison between music and language, Nietzsche remarks that language "can never adequately render the cosmic symbolism of music, because music stands in symbolic relation to the primordial contradiction and primordial pain in the heart of Primal Unity, and therefore symbolizes a sphere which is beyond and before all phenomena."5 Taking up a somewhat ambiguous position, Leonard Meyer, though he proclaims himself an absolutist, distinguishes between two kinds of meaning in music: absolute and referential.6 According to Meyer, "absolute meaning" in music is intramusical, solely concerning its grammar and the internal patterning of sounds and the effect that these relationships of sound patterns have on each other. "Referential meaning" refers to extramusical phenomena that inform the musical work.7 Recog-
Sexing the Subject of Musical Analysis
83
nizing that by necessity the intramusical to the extramusical is a codependent relationship—in other words, the full nature of music (the intramusical) can be understood only in relation to phenomena that exist beyond itself (the extramusical)—Meyer nonetheless tends to regard the intramusical as more important. Coexisting with the thinking that regards music as a system that is incapable of meaning beyond its own terms is an opposite view that "regards music as essentially a human, socially grounded, socially alterable construct."8 Siding with this view, Susan McClary comments that in the Republic, Plato's references to music are concerned with its ethical impact on people. In some instances music is seen to be socially beneficial, while in others harmful.9 This idea has resonance in the writings of the 19th-century philosopher Eduard Hanslick, who asserted that listening to music in a spontaneous manner is no better than taking drugs, for it "loosens the feet or the heart just as wine loosens the tongue,"10 thus degrading the listener; this kind of (dangerous) listening "may prevent the development of that strength of will and power of intellect which man is capable of."11 Hanslick's moralizing here, along similar lines to that of Plato, implies that music can have a corrupting influence. The general tenor of Hanslick's argument in The Beautiful in Music, however, is that the material object of music itself does not contain emotions. Rather, he suggests that emotions reside in those who listen to music and respond to it accordingly. Hanslick would thus tend to be aligned with the absolutists. Yet, as Malcolm Budd points out, Hanslick contradicts himself, for he attaches importance to the meaning of music, noting its capacity to have real effects—producing emotional responses or having degrading effects—on those who listen to it. Budd suggests that if music has these effects, then it would seem impossible for it not to have meaning. As Budd goes on to say, an acceptance of Hanslick's contention that music is "devoid of emotion" must, in the final analysis, render music meaningful, simply because of this contradiction.12 The idea that music has meaning beyond its formal system is taken up by a number of other 19th-century philosophers. In the previous chapter, I mention Edmund Gurney, who suggested that the presentation of music as motion corresponds to sexual (e)motion.13 The idea that music contains meaning continued to intrigue writers on aesthetics in the 20th century, including Deryck Cooke, whose view is that music is (in itself) an expression of the emotions,14 and Susanne Langer, who abandons the term "meaning" in favor of "symbolism."15 More recently, Stephen Davies insists that emotions are located within music itself and that the expressive power in music awakens emotions in listeners.16 Susan McClary's position is not dissimilar to some of these views. She states: Meaning is not inherent in music but neither is it in language: both are activities that are k afloat because communities of people invest in them, agree collectively that their signs serve as valid currency. Music is always dependent on the conferring of social meaning—as ethnomusicologists have long recognized, the study of signification in music cannot be undertaken in isolation from the human contexts that create, transmit, and respond to it.17
84
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
McClary's point that music cannot be understood in isolation from its context is important, for music can be seen to embody the changing social values in the wider social context in the emergence of new styles in musical composition. For example, some parallels might be drawn between scientific and musical progress, thus connecting music quite explicitly to the social context in which it is produced. Newton discovered gravity in the 17th century at around the time that music established a gravitational center around the tonic in the major/minor system. Einstein developed the theory of relativity in the early 20th century at much the same time as Schoenberg created the 12-tone system, which organizes music so that all tones are relative to each other. A particularly compelling interpretation that links music to its sociohistorical context is Susan McClary's reading of Bach, whose music she argues is indelibly marked by the social order of his period.18 McClary's analysis of the Brandenberg Concerto No. 5 reveals that the interactions between the two principal forces (the ripieno and the concertino) are metaphorically—even visually—parallel to the interactions between the emergent middle class and the ruling class. The continuo, on the other hand, enacts a service role, which is not unlike the role of servants who would have been in the employ of the aristocracy of the day.19 The significance of McClary's reading of this work is its revelation of Bach in subversive mode, in which she shows him to create a "revenge of the continuo player." Normally an instrument performing a service (servant) role, providing necessary harmony and filigree, the harpsichord becomes the genius of the first movement, hijacking it in an extensive, wild, and frenzied cadenza. This reading is a graphic demonstration of how the internal workings of the hierarchical structure of early 18th-century German society are depicted in the music of the time. It is also a brilliant illustration of how a composer—who would have been regarded as not much above the status of the so-called slave class—whose favorite instrument was arguably the harpsichord, subverts the normal conventions for this instrument. It also needs to be said that this kind of reading, although disarmingly simple, would leave the absolutists—that is, the Bach purists in this case—completely bewildered. To ground Bach's music in the banality of its social context in this manner—music that would normally be regarded by the purists to transcend the context, not least because its composer is regarded as a genius, godlike figure—would be seen to be sacrilegious. Despite the persistence and unresolved nature of the autonomy/heteronomy debate, it is still the case that the majority of analysts in mainstream musicology tend to privilege the side of the argument that insists on music's autonomy. As a consequence, they tend to employ reductive, pseudoscientific methods with which to study music, which, in turn, ensures that there is a separation of music from its context. Such analytical strategies focus on the internal coherence of music. Furthermore, if works are found to be internally coherent, absolutist analysts can make another kind of claim with apparent certainty: that there exists a body of great masterworks produced by genius composers. In other words, those works that fit the ideal in terms of internal coherence can also be slotted into the canon of great music.
Sexing the Subject of Musical Analysis
85
Music as Score versus Sound Running parallel in a kind of supportive role to the autonomy/heteronomy argument in which music's autonomy is regarded as sacrosanct is a view from hard-core music theory that the score, the visual document of music, is the site where real musical meanings are made. Such a belief supports the notion that music is a nonreferential, fully autonomous system. It also generates another kind of debate, again set up on a dichotomy: the primacy of the visual score versus that of the auditory sound of music. As I have suggested, in this debate the score is the site of privilege. The score is visual. It can be contained. Analysts can look at it, study the musical notation embodied in it, and make observations about music's pitch and rhythmic structure. The sound of music, on the other hand, cannot be contained. During the course of a performance, music produces the effect of being here one moment and gone the next. It is highly elusive. In its performative context, music is reliant on the memory of listeners for its recollection. When the memory of a piece of music fades in time, it becomes reduced to something of a trace. Given this, it is not surprising, then, that the score in Western art music theory is treated as the object of study. Richard Leppert's formulation of this idea is that music as sight takes precedence over music as sound in the production of meaning.20 According to popular music theorist Richard Middleton, the superiority of the visual over the auditory in music explains why notation-centric approaches to musical analysis have been developed. The fleeting moment, the impermanence of music in its temporality, makes it vulnerable to the visual world that encapsulates its meaning in the printed score. Moreover, according to Middleton, this gives rise to very particular listening practices, for in the absence of a score, the conservatory-trained listener tends to imagine a score in order to make sense of the music. Part of this institutional musical training also involves being able to do the opposite. The conservatory-trained listener who has endured a typical analysis class will be asked to imagine the sound of the music in the mind while reading a score in the absence of its sound. As Middleton says, the score in Western musicology is reified: "It is 'seen' as 'the music' . . . In one stroke, this downgrades the 'vulgarities' of performance, the productive significance of variants, and the influence of performance context; practice is frozen in symbol. . .. The feelings and physical responses induced by music are obliterated."21 The idea that the score is supreme in the musical experience spills over into the writings of a number of 20th-century philosophers. While implicit to his theory and not overtly stated as such, Roger Scruton gives credence to the musical experience as a visual experience.22 Scruton's argument is based on Eduard Hanslick's notion that musical content is not attributable to the sounding medium of music, that is, to the material object of music, but rather it is attributable to the intentional (external) object. Scruton implies that the intentional object of music is the score. The distinction invoked by Scruton between the intentional and material object of music has a parallel in Saussure's notion that language is a system of signs that
86
Feminist Aesthetics in Music
consists of a signifier (a sound image or a written shape) and a signified (a concept). As Catherine Belsey observes, the separation between the signifier and signified is possible only on an analytical level.23 Saussure himself puts the