Femininity in the Frame
Cinema and Society series general editor: jeffrey richards Best of British: Cinema and Societ...
156 downloads
1636 Views
5MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Femininity in the Frame
Cinema and Society series general editor: jeffrey richards Best of British: Cinema and Society from 1930 to the Present Anthony Aldgate & Jeffrey Richards Brigadoon, Braveheart and the Scots: Distortions of Scotland in Hollywood Cinema Colin McArthur The British at War: Cinema, State and Propaganda, 1939–1945 James Chapman British Cinema and the Cold War Tony Shaw Children, Cinema and Censorship: From Dracula to the Dead End Kids Sarah J. Smith The Crowded Prairie: American National Identity in the Hollywood Western Michael Coyne An Everyday Magic: Cinema and Cultural Memory Annette Kuhn Femininity in the Frame, Women and 1950s British Popular Cinema Melanie Bell Film and Community in Britain and France Margaret Butler Film Propaganda: Soviet Russia and Nazi Germany Richard Taylor From Moscow to Madrid: Postmodern Cities, European Cinema Ewa Mazierska & Laura Rascaroli Hollywood Genres and Post-War America Mike Chopra-Gant Hollywood’s History Films David Eldridge Licence to Thrill: A Cultural History of the James Bond Films James Chapman Past and Present: National Identity and the British Historical Film James Chapman Powell and Pressburger: A Cinema of Magic Spaces Andrew Moor Projecting Empire: Imperialism and Popular Cinema James Chapman & Nicholas J. Cull Propaganda and the German Cinema, 1933–1945 David Welch Shooting the Civil War: Cinema, History and American National Identity Jenny Barrett Spaghetti Westerns: Cowboys and Europeans from Karl May to Sergio Leone Christopher Frayling Spectacular Narratives: Hollywood in the Age of the Blockbuster Geoff King Typical Men: The Representation of Masculinity in Popular British Cinema Andrew Spicer The Unknown 1930s: An Alternative History of the British Cinema, 1929–1939 Edited by Jeffrey Richards
Femininity in the Frame Women and 1950s British Popular Cinema
Melanie Bell
Published in 2010 by I.B.Tauris & Co Ltd 6 Salem Road, London W2 4BU 175 Fifth Avenue, New York NY 10010 www.ibtauris.com Distributed in the United States and Canada Exclusively by Palgrave Macmillan 175 Fifth Avenue, New York NY 10010 Copyright © 2010 Melanie Bell The right of Melanie Bell to be identified as the author of this work has been asserted by her in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patent Act 1988. All rights reserved. Except for brief quotations in a review, this book, or any part thereof, may not be reproduced, stored in or introduced into a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher. ISBN: 9781848851597 A full CIP record for this book is available from the British Library A full CIP record is available from the Library of Congress Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: available Printed and bound in Great Britain by CPI Antony Rowe, Chippenham from camera-ready copy edited and supplied by the author
For my husband, Chris Curtis – ‘It had to be you’
contents
vii
Contents
List of Illustrations
ix
Acknowledgements
xi
General Editor’s Introduction
xiii
Introduction: Women and the 1950s 1. Man-Made Women
1 15
2. The British Femme Fatale
41
3. The Comedy-of-Marriage Film
67
4. The Female Group Film 5. The Figure of the Prostitute
97 123
6. Female Film Critics
149
Conclusion: Reconfiguring 1950s Femininity
173
Notes
175
Bibliography
201
Selective Filmography
211
Index
215
viii
femininity in the frame
illustrations
ix
Illustrations 1. Pamela Devis as Olga in The Perfect Woman (1949)
22
2. The Perfect Woman (1949) – inspecting ‘the perfect woman’
24
3. Ritter (Paul Henreid) transforms Lily (Lizabeth Scott) in Stolen Face (1952)
30
4. ‘Amazing – is it possible?’ – reproducing women in Four Sided Triangle (1953)
35
5. Greta Gynt as the ‘Shady Lady Spiv’ in Easy Money (1948)
50
6. Emmy entices David in Daughter of Darkness (1948)
61
7. Kenneth More in Raising a Riot (1955)
81
8. John Gregson consoles Peggy Cummins in To Dorothy a Son (1954)
84
9. The Female Group in A Town Like Alice (1956)
107
10. Glynis Johns and Diana Dors in The Weak and the Wicked 117 (1954) 11. Marissa’s room in The Flesh is Weak (1957)
141
12. Publicity Poster for Passport to Shame (1959)
144
x
femininity in the frame
acknowledgements
xi
Acknowledgements
I am grateful to the School of English Literature, Language and Linguistics at Newcastle University for providing me with a period of research leave which allowed me to complete the manuscript. I am also grateful for an award from the British Academy Small Grants scheme that allowed me to undertake research on the film critics. I owe a debt of gratitude to Sue Harper and Bruce Babington who have both read drafts and given generously of their time and expertise. I’d also like to thank Andrew Spicer who lent me copies of films, Steve Chibnall who invited me to raid the British Cinema and Television Research Group archive at De Montfort University, and Viv Chadder for introducing me to post-war British cinema. Thanks to Mark Glancy who allowed me to present material on the female film critics to the Film History seminar at the Institute for Historical Research, and to participants for their extremely stimulating and perceptive comments. Library staff have been helpful especially at the British Film Institute Library, the British Library Newspapers, Colindale, and the BBC Written Archives Centre at Caversham. Photo illustrations are courtesy of the British Film Institute Stills, Posters and Designs, and the Steve Chibnall Archive. Every effort has been made to obtain copyright clearance where copyright holders could be traced. If any proper acknowledgment has not been made, I invite copyright holders to inform me of the error. Thanks to family and friends especially Guinevere Narraway, Martin Shingler (for tea, conversation and permission to have ‘Bette’ days), my wonderful daughter Eris Williams Reed and my husband Chris Curtis who has supported me in countless ways. Chapter Two is an extended version of an earlier article that ap peared as ‘Fatal femininity in post-war British film: investigating the British femme’ in H. Hanson and C. O’Rawe (eds) The Femme Fatale: Images, Histories, Contexts (Basingstoke, Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan, 2009). Chapter Four is an extended version of an earlier article that appeared as ‘“A Prize Collection of Familiar Feminine Types”: the Female Group
xii
femininity in the frame
Film in 1950s British Cinema’ in M. Bell and M. Williams (eds) British Women’s Cinema (London: Routledge, 2009). Chapter Five is a re-working of an article that first appeared as ‘“Shop-soiled” women: female sexuality and the figure of the prostitute in 1950s British Cinema’, Journal of British Cinema and Television, 3. 2 (2006). I am grateful for the permission to reprint these here.
general editor ’s introduction
xi
General Editor’s Introduction In this refreshingly original and persuasively argued book, Melanie Bell challenges the oft-repeated view that 1950s British cinema was complacent, conservative and conformist in its depiction of women. She argues that the picture was much more complex and contradictory than has generally been admitted and she charts the ways in which popular cinema dealt with these complexities. She concedes that there was pressure on women to return to a normative pattern of marriage and family life, disrupted by World War Two. But she points out that at the same time there was an increase in the number of women going out to work and that there was an increasing focus on female sexual behaviour in the wake of the 1953 Kinsey Report. She draws not only on films but on a wide range of film magazines, press packs, Mass Observation reports and radio scripts to back up her analysis. Proceeding chronologically and thematically, and providing social and cinematic context at every stage, she examines a series of different depictions of women to support her claim of complexity and contradiction. She begins by looking at a group of science fiction films (The Perfect Woman, Stolen Face, Four Sided Triangle) which highlight male anxiety about post-war gender roles. She charts the emergence of a distinctively British femme fatale who is simultaneously demonized and celebrated in films such as Madeleine, Dear Murderer and Daughter of Darkness. She looks at the 1950s ‘comedy of marriage’ in which men are educated in their domestic responsibilities and learn to appreciate their wives’ contribution to the household: Raising a Riot, To Dorothy a Son and Young Wives’ Tale (all directed or written by women). She examines films about female friendship and same sex relationships (A Town Like Alice, The Weak and the Wicked) and about female prostitutes (The Flesh is Weak, Passport to Shame). She concludes with a consideration of the work of three female film critics (E. Arnot Robertson, Freda Bruce Lockhart and Catherine de la Roche), focusing on their consistent engagement with the cinematic depiction of women. The whole study adds a new, rich and revealing dimension to our understanding of the depiction of women in 1950s British cinema. Jeffrey Richards
xii
femininity in the frame
women and the 1950s
1
Introduction
Women and the 1950s The orchestration of consensus on the position of women in post-war Britain was the achievement of a deceptive harmony out of a variety of noisy voices … The orchestration was harmonious – in a peculiar way – in covering up what was really a silence; what was not said: the absence of women battered, of women raped, of women sexually attracted to women, of women in revolt, of women despised, of women despairing. (Elizabeth Wilson, Only Halfway to Paradise) You know what a woman has to be? A cross between a saint and a dray horse, a diplomat and an automatic washing machine, a psychiatrist and a bulldozer, a sanitary engineer and a mannequin. (Raising a Riot, d. Wendy Toye 1955)
This study takes as its focus some of the variety of ‘noisy voices’ as they appeared in British popular film of the 1950s. This decade is lodged in the popular consciousness as a period of gender conservatism, a time when women enthusiastically returned to their ‘natural’ roles as wives and mothers and readily gave up the employment opportunities and increased personal freedoms widely enjoyed during the Second World War. Tessa Perkins speaks for many when she describes the post-war period as one associated with feelings of ‘disappointment … for socialists and feminists alike … that something “went wrong”’ leading to the ‘conservatism and puritanism of the “consensual” 1950s’.1 The popular image of women in the 1950s is of the ‘happy housewife’, content with husband, children and a home full of labour-saving devices, an image satirized in the horror mode by The Stepford Wives (1974) and critiqued aggressively by Betty Friedan’s The Feminine Mystique (1963), a text which laid the groundwork for second wave feminism. This understanding of the period’s gender politics is one that continues to have cultural currency. Andrew Marr’s recent television series History of Modern Britain (2008) characterizes it as a time when ‘every woman was a housewife’, whilst recent film productions set in the 1950s, such as Mona Lisa Smile (2004), are critiqued by the liberal press for glamorizing ‘old-fashioned femininity’ and for failing to depict the
2
femininity in the frame
time as one of male backlash against women’s wartime gains; a position that similarly understands the decade as one of gender conformity and feminist failure.2 A stubborn image remains of the post-war years as a time of ‘tense domesticity and anxious conformity’.3 Domestic popular cinema of the time has fared no better and has likewise been dismissed as reflecting the decade’s wider conservatism. Commentators as illustrious as Lindsay Anderson famously wrote it off as ‘a period of dullness’ whilst for Charles Barr ‘the period 1952–58 was an extraordinarily dead one’.4 What emerged for British actresses during this period of dull film-making were, in Robert Murphy’s account, ‘pathetically trivial roles’ without emotional weight or intensity, with women characterized as either a Madonna or a whore.5 But, as Wilson’s quote reminds us, what is at stake here is the victory of image over reality and the successful mythologizing of the decade as a time when traditional sex roles predominated. The social and economic history of women in the 1950s is more complex and contradictory than the mythological image permits as it was shaped by, and fed into, wider concerns about post-war reconstruction and the emergence of a new social order. Whilst the popular consciousness may be dominated by the figure of the housewife, women’s experiences in the public realm were, throughout the decade, varied and diverse; shaped by age and generation, the availability of childcare, support given or withdrawn from husbands and family, and the types of work available to them.6 For example, women’s employment increased in the 1950s, particularly among married and older women who found work in the light and service industries and in the new welfare state. Whilst women might take up the role of full-time housewife and mother, that role had particular meanings that differ sharply from contemporary understandings. A housewife might exercise considerable agency in the creation of a home and consider herself at the vanguard of modernity.7 Likewise a mother, as imagined by the child psychologist John Bowlby, is afforded considerable status, elevated to a central role in the physical and psychological development of her child.8 Some women yearned for homes of their own and the chance to put down roots and experience a life that they understood as profoundly different to, and an advancement on, that experienced by their mothers. Other women mourned the loss of employment opportunities after the war and resented being shunted into ‘women’s work’, which was primarily low status and low paid relative to what for them had been a positive war-time employment experience.9
women and the 1950s
3
The diversity of women’s experiences has led historians to increasingly characterize the decade as ‘a period of instability rather than unthinking smug conventionality’,10 with gender relations shaped by ‘[r]evision and negotiation, rather than acceptance and acquiescence’.11 These diverse experiences suggest a schism between image and reality and Alison Light raises the question of how to engage with the ‘subtle gradations of change within the period which might speak to the contradictory relations between what women lived and experienced and the official descriptions of, or prescriptions for, their lives’.12 How did British popular cinema respond to the ‘contradictory relations’ permeating the social imaginary? For many critical commentators domestic cinema was not a hospitable place for depicting femininity, with film production skewed in favour of masculine desires readily expressed in the war films that dominated the box office, whilst the female-centred melodramas that had characterized the 1940s were sidelined. For Christine Geraghty, who offers one of the few sustained accounts of cinematic femininity as it appeared in domestic cinema at this time, British film struggled to successfully dramatize what she terms the ‘New Woman’, a mythical figure through whom film-makers attempted to incorporate the overlapping discourses of ‘motherhood, sexuality, paid work and consumption’.13 Whilst the star personas of Virginia McKenna and Kay Kendall were able to capture something of this mythical figure, Geraghty concludes that British popular genres such as comedy contented themselves with presenting women as ‘childish, silly and vindictive or valorised and saintly’, with domestic cinema more broadly ‘locked into systems of gender that were out of line with the contemporary views about mature femininity that found a ready outlet in other forms of popular culture such as women’s magazines and fiction’.14 Despite providing some interesting film readings to support her claims, Geraghty’s is not a book-length study of femininity, a factor which both prevents it undertaking a more detailed analysis of gender relations and limits its claims for typicality. Domestic cinema was not ‘out of line’ in a wholesale manner with contemporary views about femininity and gender relations, but was at times, and in particular places, working through the myriad concerns and contradictions which impacted on gender. To be commercially successful cinematic representation had to negotiate – for the pleasures of the cinema audience – the shifts that were taking place in women’s roles in the material world. How it did this becomes more evident when we expand the contours of the cultural map to include genres such as
4
femininity in the frame
science fiction and crime melodramas, and when we consider films where particular ‘agents’ sensitive to gender concerns had a role in the creative process. Nor were actresses confined to the ‘pathetically trivial roles’ that characterize Murphy’s understanding of the decade’s cinematic femininities. Actresses as diverse as Virginia McKenna, Glynis Johns, Diana Dors, Sylvia Syms, Yvonne Mitchell and Kay Kendall found rewarding cinematic roles as television presenters, secretaries, nurses, resistance fighters, prison guards and missionaries, as well as the obligatory portrayals of housewives and mothers (and these often more imaginative than widely credited). My motivation for revisiting the cinema of this decade arises from a clear sense that only a partial account has been offered concerning gender and femininity. There is another, more challenging side to British cinema and when we engage with that a different picture emerges. What I propose in this study is the first sustained examination of cinematic femininities in British popular film that is driven by an understanding of the period as one of instability and change rather than gender conservatism and the ready acceptance of normative femininity, and which keeps at the forefront of its consciousness Wilson’s observation of ‘a variety of noisy voices’ in relation to the position of women.15 By drawing across a range of genres (war, comedy, science fiction, crime, social problem) and focusing on key figurations (the prostitute, the femme fatale, the incarcerated woman) I will explore how British popular film (that is, mainstream narrative film made for a mass audience) engaged with the new ideas and contradictory understandings of femininity that were seeping into the cultural imaginary at this time. The first half of this Introduction covers social context and draws a road map of how women as a group were addressed, positioned and imagined within official discourses and in relation to the key areas of employment, marriage and motherhood. I then demonstrate how women’s lives disrupted the rhetoric of domesticity and maternity, for example through employment, and the debates about female sexuality which characterized the decade. Whilst this is not a comprehensive social history of the time, it provides a framework for understanding femininity and gender relations in this period that subsequent chapters are in dialogue with.16 It is within this framework that we can begin to position the figure of the woman in 1950s British popular cinema and the second half of the Introduction outlines the study’s methods and introduces the subject of the cinema audience, a key element to understanding popular film at this time.
women and the 1950s
5
Women in 1950s Britain – The Dependent Wife and Mother The widespread understanding of the 1950s as a decade of conservatism in gender relations stems in part from the fact that the equality that was loudly proclaimed at the time was an equality that was predicated on difference. Vera Brittain’s 1953 statement that ‘women have moved within thirty years from rivalry with men to a new recognition of their unique value as women’ is fairly characteristic of how women’s equal position was understood at this time.17 This ‘equal but different’ ideology, with women and men experts in their separate and complementary spheres, was certainly not unique to the 1950s, but it did take on particular characteristics in this decade, particularly in relation to motherhood and the home. Post-war reconstruction focused on rebuilding the family, assumed fractured by six years of war during which time women as well as men had been conscripted, many children evacuated, and the single-parent family headed by the mother had, for many, become the norm. Women were central to this process. As Alison Light has argued, ‘femininity becomes one of the central pivots of post-war reconstruction within social policy and welfarism’; a femininity that was constructed as heteronormative and focused on marriage and the home.18 Beveridge’s social welfare policies, for example, were predicated on the ‘traditional model’ of the family with a male breadwinner and female homemaker. A woman’s entitlement to welfare support enshrined in the 1946 National Insurance Act was dependent on her husband’s claim, and working married women who chose to contribute to the scheme received a lower rate of benefit than men. Single working women paid lower contributions than men, the rationale being that they didn’t have dependents to maintain.19 Women’s role as the mother was supported through the introduction of family allowances (paid direct to the mother) and through a maternity benefit which was intended to both support families and stimulate the birthrate.20 Marriage was enshrined in the welfare state by making significantly lower provision for divorced or separated wives and for single mothers. Heterosexual marriage was the privileged site through which the legitimate nuclear family would prosper; indeed the argument put forward by the Royal Commission on Marriage and Divorce (1951– 55) that ‘life-long marriage is the basis of a secure family life’ is representative of the entrenched beliefs about marriage and the family that shaped social policy.21 The increase in the number of marriages
6
femininity in the frame
taking place (from 59.7 per 1,000 in 1931 to 76.2 per 1,000 in 1951)22 needs to be set alongside a rise in the divorce-rate (from 1.6 per cent 1937 to 7.1 per cent in 1950). There was a strong sense within public policy that marriage was being undermined by the increasing ‘divorcemindedness’ of the population and that measures were required to strengthen its position as an institution and the corner-stone of family life.23 Marriage is a subject that I discuss in more detail in Chapter Three but it is worth mentioning briefly here that a feature of 1950s matrimony was the notion of ‘companionship’, with men and women having different and complementary roles and working together to create a marriage based on partnership, which in turn extended the discourse of ‘separate and equal’ to personal relations. That women were primarily imagined and addressed as mothers has become one of the most prevailing understandings of the decade. Whilst the centrality of motherhood to constructions of femininity was not new, what did change in this decade were the terms of reference. Physical care was to be supplemented with psychological care as theories about good mothering techniques and the effective socialization of children proliferated. From different psychoanalytical schools D. W. Winnicott, in a series of popular radio talks, addressed the ‘ordinary devoted mother’, whilst John Bowlby advocated that ‘mother-love … is as important for mental health as are vitamins and proteins for physical health’.24 It was this idea of seemingly continuous care, delivered solely by a devoted mother, that second wave feminists later critiqued as detrimental to the woman as it denied her any independent life beyond maternity. As the pre-war trend of smaller families continued unabated in the 1950s (the increase in the birth-rate in the immediate post-war years was temporary) the focus now shifted to giving the best possible care to children; a task for which women must be equipped.25 The belief in domesticity and motherhood as woman’s ‘natural’ outlet was enshrined in the educational policy of the period. John Newsom’s influential publication, The Education of Girls (1948), distinguished between a minority ‘elite’ of academic girls (considered comparable to intellectual males) and the majority of young women who should receive vocational training to equip them for their future roles as housewives and mothers. For Newsom ‘[t]he future of women’s education lies not in attempting to iron out their differences from men … but to teach girls how to grow into women and to relearn the graces which so many have forgotten in the last thirty years’.26 This view was echoed in the 1959 Crowther Report, which argued that ‘the prospect of … marriage should rightly influence the education of adolescent girls’,
women and the 1950s
7
and domestic science remained a central feature of their curriculum.27 Educational policy assumed that young girls had a natural capacity to become experts in the domestic field and that they must be supported to achieve this role.28 Educating women for their primary role of wife and mother had the added advantage of producing a pool of semiskilled labour which would meet the demands of industry as reserve workers. The Working Woman Despite the rhetoric of domesticity and maternity and the fact that increasing numbers of women married (and at an earlier age) the reality of women’s lives in the post-war period was that a growing number of them worked outside the home. The 1947 Economic Survey, when reporting on the shortage of ‘manpower’ skills, argued that women ‘now form the only large reserve of labour left’ and called for them to contribute actively to the economy, albeit on the understanding that women would not ‘do jobs usually done by men’ and their efforts would be temporary, part-time, and would not interfere with caring for their young children.29 Employment rates for married and older women increased in the 1950s as the British economy expanded in areas that either traditionally or increasingly employed women: clerical work, light and service industries, and the caring professions in the new welfare state.30 The increase in female workers gave rise to much discussion of what was termed women’s ‘dual role’, most famously encapsulated in the work of sociologists Alva Myrdal and Viola Klein and their 1956 publication Women’s Two Roles: Home and Work. In this they propounded the ‘life-span’ model (grounded in middleclass norms) where women’s careers took a back-seat when children were young, after which they would return to paid employment, and concluded that women no longer had to choose between paid work and home-making as career paths.31 Although women’s entry into the workforce was based on the assumption that family came first (or would do when they had children), the increasing numbers of women working outside the home did not sit easily with official prescriptions regarding contemporary womanhood.32
8
femininity in the frame
Female Sexuality In addition to women’s increased participation in the workforce and the significant changes which were shaping understandings of marriage and divorce, shifts were occurring in the personal and emotional realm that impacted on women. The publication in 1953 of Alfred Kinsey’s Sexual Behavior in the Human Female caused a stir by suggesting that same-sex relations and masturbation might be more sexually fulfilling for women than heterosexual penetrative intercourse. Whilst Wilson has persuasively demonstrated that the Kinsey findings on female sexual pleasure were quickly ‘domesticated’, channelled into discussions about heterosexual monogamous marriage with simultaneous orgasm responsible for cementing the emotional ties between the sexes and strengthening the bonds of marriage, the Kinsey report (and other key publications) did open up for discussion the recognition and reality of female sexual pleasure.33 Literature on the subject burgeoned during the decade and theories of sexual behaviour were popularized through innumerable Penguin publications such as Mary Macaulay’s The Art of Marriage (1952), pamphlets and leaflets from the Family Planning Association, and the problem pages of women’s magazines. Increasingly through the 1950s ‘sexual potency in men and sexual responsiveness in women began to be seen as explicitly desirable qualities’.34 On the one hand this placed a greater burden on marriage (as the condoned site for sexual pleasure) as it led to both higher expectations and the potential for increased dissatisfaction. Women now had a duty and responsibility to enjoy sex and the potential to feel a sense of failure if they did not. On the other hand it is evident that discussions about female sexuality had entered the mainstream and were increasingly shaping the cultural consciousness. Publications on the topic ranged from advocacy of the ‘full and natural “vaginal orgasm”’ in Macaulay’s book, which worked with a model of female sexuality predicated on male need, to the somewhat more radical approaches propounded by Helena Wright, working in the family planning movement, who emphasized the role of the clitoris in achieving female sexual pleasure.35 For Wright ‘orgasm failure … is unavoidable if the clitoris is not discovered and correctly stimulated’ and sexual dissatisfaction in women is due to a model of sexual intercourse ‘which turns out to be based on the male instead of the female pattern’.36 As I demonstrate further in Chapter Five, women had to tread a difficult path vis-à-vis female sexuality, negotiating double standards and different attitudes to pre- and extramarital sex, but it is clear from the debates concerning not only female
women and the 1950s
9
sexuality but employment, divorce and birth-rates, that women’s life experiences went beyond those described in official commentaries, and in a manner not widely recognized in the popular myths and narratives of the 1950s. What emerges from these accounts is a sense of the complex and contradictory social terrain that women occupied. Employment, marriage and birth-rates provide one account of the story of women’s lives, popular culture in the form of autobiography, fiction and film another. The novelist and critic Harriett Gilbert, for example, in reflecting on her 1950s middle-class girlhood commented on the innumerable ambiguous messages she received as a child. On the one hand ‘a great many “un-girlish” things were not only permitted but encouraged in the privacy of home … asking questions, putting my own point of view’ whilst conversely ‘[m]arriage and children were still, it was perfectly clear, the only safe goal’ for women.37 The film actress Sylvia Syms characterized herself as being ‘always in conflict’ in the 1950s, struggling to reconcile her ‘duty to be a gifted housewife’ with her aspirations as a ‘gifted actress’.38 Deborah Philips and Ian Haywood, in their study of 1950s popular fiction for women, demonstrate some of the literary devices for negotiating the contradictions and ambiguities that impacted on the female role. In relation to the subject of work and training, for example, Adult Education classes were increasingly popular with women in 1950s Britain, but they were conspicuously absent from romance novels of the same period which employed instead ‘a set of awkward narrative devices that allow her [the heroine] to experience the benefits of professional advice and training without searching them out’.39 Thus women’s increased expectations are recognized and their horizons expanded, but in a manner which does not advocate overt female agency. The popularity of these novels suggests that they succeeded in providing a space where women’s anxieties and uncertainties about gender roles and gendered subjectivities could be worked through and, as I will demonstrate, British popular cinema likewise engaged with femininity in some unusual and surprising ways. Whilst Light notes that ‘contradictory relations’ marked women’s lives at this time, contradiction more broadly was a feature of the decade, where a sense of duality shaped the wider consciousness of British society as it faced the upheaval of social reconstruction and absorbed into the social fabric the transformative events of the war. The experience of living in the ‘modern world’ – which was marked by rapid social and technological change – was both exhilarating and
10
femininity in the frame
unnerving.40 Becky Conekin et al. in their study of modernity in post-war Britain use the term a ‘return to the future’ to characterize a nation that was both shaped by the weight of tradition and heritage whilst seeking to construct a new, meritocratic and modern society.41 The tension between the old and the new was perfectly encapsulated in the Coronation of the new monarch in 1953, an event where the old notions of empire were transformed into the new concept of the Commonwealth, and which reached the people of Britain via the new medium of television. For Conekin et al. the Coronation is emblematic of the ‘balancing act between innovation and tradition’ that characterizes British modernity and which was present in many areas of British society and culture.42 It is for these reasons that Hall’s characterization of the decade as one of ‘instability’ is valid, with a sense that the ‘moral pronouncements’ of the decade (as they impacted on marriage, female sexuality and gender roles) were ‘defensive reactions to a sense, whether correct or not, that the old constraints were falling away’.43 As this brief outline has demonstrated, women’s lives were broader and more expansive than the official prescriptions of motherhood and housewifery permitted. Women might have been addressed primarily as wives and mothers but they also entered paid employment in growing numbers, had smaller families and higher expectations of marriage and home life, and were increasingly able to reflect on their own sexual pleasure, expressing sexual needs and desires that went beyond reproduction. In sum, transition, instability and negotiation were features of gender roles in this decade with women and the wider society poised between traditional modes of thinking and the emergent new social order. The contours of normative femininity were clearly under pressure, being transformed and rendered increasingly ambiguous by the greater economic, social and sexual freedoms that many women experienced. The British Cinema Audience It is well known that the shape and structure of the British cinema audience changed considerably through the 1950s with annual admissions dropping to 755 million in 1958 after an all-time high of 1635 million in 1946.44 A response to a 1950 Mass Observation survey entitled ‘Why do they go to the Pictures?’ shed light on the reasons why cinema attendance had dropped, with less money, lack of time and the
women and the 1950s
11
‘counter-attraction’ of radio, television and theatre as the most cited reasons.45 At a time when the attractions of home were pronounced, cinema struggled to compete, and the comments of one woman in the survey are fairly typical: ‘[t]o be quite frank with you I haven’t been since we had the television fixed … [m]y husband … comes home of an evening tired out … [w]e just switch on the television and relax, and often there’s a good play on.’46 There were important changes in the class, age and gender composition of the audience as the decade progressed. Through the 1950s, women’s cinema attendance dropped sharply with 50 per cent of Britain’s housewives reporting that, by 1957, they never went to the cinema.47 By the end of the decade the regular cinema-goer was increasingly young, male and working-class. The proportion of occasional cinema-goers (as a percentage of the total audience) rose steadily across the decade, from 14 per cent in 1950 to 40 per cent by 1960. This was a group where married couples in their late twenties and early thirties predominated.48 These occasional cinema-goers were characterized at the time by one social survey as ‘truly selective’; that is, motivated by the actual film being screened rather than a regular cinema-going ‘habit’.49 It is for this reason that, as Harper and Porter conclude, ‘the real path to commercial success lay in bringing the occasional cinema-goer back into the cinema’ and this was a group whose ‘ambitions and anxieties were more traditional and conventional’ than the majority who comprised the habitual audience.50 At a time when women’s habitual cinema attendance was in decline, the commercial success of particular films gives some indication of the tastes and preferences of lower middle-class and middle-class women. For a film to be commercially successful it had to appeal to both the habitual and the occasional audiences, with film producers gauging how to appeal to the more traditional and conventional preferences of one group whilst simultaneously addressing the appetite for more rapid social change held by other groups. The challenge to produce an open text is one that commercial film faces at all times. As Richard Maltby has demonstrated in a study of commercial Hollywood film and its ‘economies of pleasure’, films ‘presuppose multiple viewpoints, at multiple textual levels, for their consuming audience’.51 It is a film’s inclusion of ‘contradictions, gaps and blanks [that] allowed it to be consumed as at least two discrete, even opposing stories going on in the same text’.52 To maximize financial returns there always has to be the possibility of more than one reading, but this established requirement of commercial film was intensified in the 1950s where habitual attendance was no longer assured and ‘opposing stories’ were
12
femininity in the frame
in high demand. Vincent Porter has suggested that one of the key features of the most commercially successful 1950s films was their ability to ‘offer alternative meanings to different spectators’: something that they achieved through sharply marked ‘textual compromises and ambiguities’.53 In a decade where the social order was characterized by contradiction and instability, not least in relation to femininity and the reconfiguration of gender roles, popular cinema had to work hard to address the differing needs of both the habitual and the occasional cinema-goers. It is for this reason that I have paid attention to a film’s popularity (i.e. box office success) where this can be demonstrated, and where possible have extrapolated from its success to suggest what appeal it might have held for women.54 This study focuses primarily on close readings of key films from popular genres but also draws from a variety of extra-cinematic materials such as newspaper and journal reviews, popular and trade magazines such as Picturegoer and Kinematograph Weekly, film press books, letters and radio broadcast scripts, all of which broaden our understanding of the production and reception of films. These sources are supplemented with contemporary social documents such as Mass Observation surveys, government publications such as the Wolfenden Report, advice manuals and newspaper articles, to give a sense of the social, cultural and psychological landscape of the era. Whilst space restrictions preclude a detailed focus on the question of creative agency in relation to film production, I do signpost the contribution to the creative process of women who were either overtly feminist (the director Muriel Box, the film critic Catherine de la Roche) or who delighted in treating contemporary gender relations with irony and satire (the director Wendy Toye and the scriptwriter Anne Burnaby). In this respect the study is informed by a feminist methodology that seeks to recover the contribution made by women to the British film industry and film culture at this time, and the final chapter on female film critics does this most explicitly. It also brings a broadly feminist perspective to bear on the films and to how female characters are constructed through, for example, clothing, space and narrative positioning. Each chapter is organized around either a key female ‘figure’ (the prostitute or the femme fatale, for example) or a type of film where women and their concerns occupy the centre-stage. Detailed readings of approximately three films form the basis of each chapter: readings which are contextualized in relation to both pertinent social discourses and other comparable films. By focusing on an extended analysis of key films rather than a survey approach, I have been motivated by a desire to
women and the 1950s
13
engage with textuality and mise-en-scène – the visual style of a film that so often evades film historians.55 Rather than be overly constrained by the demands of decadology, this study utilizes the common perception of a ‘long 1950s’, which ran from 1945 into the early 1960s. The long 1950s can be divided into two distinct yet related periods starting with the immediate post-war years of austerity, from 1945 until the early 1950s, which were marked by the Labour government and the creation of the welfare state and which culminated in the 1953 Coronation. What followed were the years of the ‘New Elizabethans’ when, under a Conservative government, Britain witnessed a rise in consumerism, full employment, a restructuring of society along meritocratic lines and international decline on the world stage. This period ran until about 1963 when key events like the Profumo affair symbolized the emergence of a new more permissive society.56 It is across this time period that gradually ‘ideas of pleasure, enjoyment, and self-fulfilment replaced those of duty, responsibility, and loyalty to the group (be it family, class, or nation)’, a process which had profound implications for women.57 The six core chapters that comprise this book are organized in a roughly chronological order to give a sense of gradual change. Chapters One and Two cover the post-war period, the ‘age of austerity’ typically characterized in gender terms by an anxiety about ‘female selfishness’ and whether women would resume their ‘proper’ social roles.58 Chapter One explores the trope of the artificial or ‘man-made’ woman in science fiction and comedy of the period, arguing that cultural constructions of science intersected with the filmic representation of women to create a figure of male fantasy that speaks of an anxiety about men and post-war gender roles. The theme of male anxiety emerges strongly in Chapter Two which makes a case for a British femme fatale who, in contrast to her Hollywood counterpart, is located in the domestic realm and inhabits a sexuality that is at times repressed and virginal, and which is shown in some films to be as much a source of fascination for women as for men. Chapter Three shifts gear to the first half of the 1950s (1951–55) to focus on the popular ‘comedy-of-marriage’ film and the topical concerns of partnership and companionability between the heterosexual couple, arguing that in these films men are educated about gender roles and brought round to a respect for the feminine. In Chapter Four the focus centres on the middle years (1955–56) and the theme of female friendship and same-sex desire as it emerges in the female group film. These films bring particular challenges to bear on heterosexuality and the companionate marriage, whilst the portrayal
14
femininity in the frame
of female agency is balanced by certain narrative strategies which attempt, with varying degrees of success, to refeminize the women in accordance with gender norms. The closing years of the decade are featured in Chapter Five, which explores the figure of the prostitute in the light of the 1957 Wolfenden Report and argues that it was through this particular figure that debates about pre-marital sex and new forms of female sexuality received their most comprehensive analysis. In Chapter Six my attention moves from film to film critics and, in a case study of three women writers working in print and broadcast media, I explore the contributions they made to debates about ‘women and film’ across the period of the long 1950s. By revisiting the cinema of the decade and engaging, in a sustained manner, with some of its cinematic femininities, I hope that a new and more rounded understanding of femininity will emerge – one which stimulates discussion and debate.
man-made women
15
1
Man-Made Women In this chapter I discuss three films from the post-war period that explore the theme of the male scientist and his creation of ‘the perfect woman’. All three films dramatize the theme of male-controlled reproduction and the creation of females to satisfy the personal needs – either professional and/or emotional/sexual – of the male scientist. Each film uses a different reproductive strategy – creating a machine that resembles a human, surgical transformation of an existing human, creating an exact copy of a human – but difference in technique or reproductive strategy does not result in difference in outcome. In all cases the project fails because the man-made woman is not wholly biddable, the men have misread their own desires and at all times have failed to actualize them in a functional manner. In The Perfect Woman (d. Bernard Knowles 1949) an elderly professor creates a mechanized doll in the image of his niece. The niece subsequently substitutes herself for the doll, which leads to a series of chaotic misunderstandings before the doll self-destructs and harmony is restored. Stolen Face (d. Terence Fisher 1952) follows the misguided fortunes of a plastic surgeon who, unable to have the woman he loves, recreates her face on a disfigured female criminal, with tragic consequences. In Four Sided Triangle (d. Terence Fisher 1953) a young scientist suffering from unrequited love develops a replicating machine and uses his invention to produce an exact copy of his would-be love. The facsimile spurns him and both perish in an accidental fire. Although the primary focus of these films is men and the male project, they find a place in this study because they highlight dramatically the contradiction between male fantasies and idealizations of women and female reality. In this respect they illustrate Alison Light’s observation (discussed in the main Introduction) of the contradictory relations between the official prescriptions for women’s lives and women’s own experiences. That cultural constructions of science interacted with the representation of women in an era of rapid technological change, highlights something of the space occupied by the female fantasy figure in the male cultural imaginary of the 1950s.
16
femininity in the frame
Science Science and technology were important themes in the post-war years. Robert Jones suggests that ‘the prestige of science was very high in 1945’, not least because of its role in securing the war-time victory of the Allies.1 The military needs of the war (often referred to as ‘the physicists’ war’) led to the refinement of scientific advances in areas such as nuclear capabilities, radar and chemical development, which in turn had profound implications for exploitation in peacetime. As Arthur Marwick observes, ‘there was great enthusiasm for, and much talk about, the importance of science and technology to Britain’s social regeneration’, although it was less clear exactly how these scientific and technological developments should be harnessed.2 Science was, for example, central to the 1951 Festival of Britain where the Science Exhibition sought to educate the general public about scientific concepts such as atoms, whilst the Festival more broadly was driven by a desire to integrate science with the arts.3 Scientists themselves had significant status in post-war society and were looked to as experts whose knowledge was of fundamental importance in shaping the future. Writing in 1945, George Orwell captured this belief in his wry observation that: [a] scientist’s political opinions, it is assumed, his opinions on sociological questions, on morals, on philosophy, perhaps even on the arts, will be more valuable than those of a layman. The world, in other words, would be a better place if the scientists were in control of it … there are already millions of people who do believe this.4
Alongside prestige, however, was a certain amount of anxiety about the uses to which scientific inventions could be put. Ambivalent feelings about the creation of the atom bomb in 1945 were captured in the 1947 Mass Observation Report ‘Where is Science Taking Us?’ which described ‘widespread public anxiety about atomic bombs, a feeling that science was now out of control whereas it had formerly been a blessing’.5 Planning documents pertaining to the Festival of Britain likewise demonstrated an anxiety about the role of atomic weapons and a desire to use art to tame and balance the excesses of science.6 In an essay first published in the Tribune in 1945, Orwell again berated the intellectual community for failing to engage fully with the ramifications of atomic technology beyond the ‘reiteration of the useless statement that the bomb “ought to be put under international control”’.7
man-made women
17
The contradictory discourses that shaped understandings of science and technology were very much in evidence in the realm of reproductive science. Whilst eugenics had been discredited by Fascist practices there remained a concern about the long-term decline in the birth-rate and the phenomenon of ‘differential breeding’; that is, the lower classes reproducing faster than the middle classes.8 Socially acceptable measures to incentivize the ‘right’ people to reproduce came in the form of improved state services and childcare allowances (discussed in the main Introduction), which were deemed the ‘democratic route to improving the nation’s stock’ after the war.9 Medical expertise in this area was far-reaching, ranging from state-funded child welfare clinics to the widely disseminated teachings of the child psychologist D. W. Winnicott. Although radical advances in reproductive technology did not emerge in Britain until the 1970s, the strategies intended to shape the reproduction of the nation (or more accurately a particular privileged section of it) demonstrate the extent to which reproductive science had the capacity to infiltrate everyday life in the 1950s. It is this link between science and reproduction which is played out to extremes in the post-war science fiction films where men strive to do away with the real woman in favour of creating the ‘right’ kind of (fantasy) woman. British Science Fiction Cinema Given the status of science it is not surprising that science and scientists were a recurring feature in films throughout the period, in both the burgeoning science fiction genre and also more mainstream genres such as comedy, where Ealing’s The Man in the White Suit (1951) provided an acerbic comment on the consequences of science and invention. Relaxations in film censorship (which allowed film producers to experiment with more ‘adult’ themes) and a contemporary concern with cold war politics meant that British science fiction films broadly engaged with the themes of ‘social instability, the false promises of science and cold war threats, much like their American postwar counterparts’.10 Seven Days to Noon (1950) is an early example of the fear of nuclear development and the theme of the ‘mad scientist’, whilst The Quatermass Experiment (1955, first broadcast on television in 1953) is one of the best-known examples of the popular ‘invasion’ narrative. Alongside the scientist as ‘boffin’, typified by Michael Redgrave’s performance as Barnes Wallis in The Dam Busters (1954),
18
femininity in the frame
was the figure of the ‘comic scientist’. In films such as The Mouse that Roared (1959) the figure was an amalgam of common clichés (unable to explain his invention, forgetful about everyday matters, endearingly ‘batty’) and ultimately the narratives propose that the wildest excesses of science can be brought to heel, or rather, as Geraghty suggests, ‘modernity can be outflanked by the traditional’.11 In addition to the many cinematic depictions of cold war fears, British science fiction began to explore the threat that women were thought to represent to the post-war world. As Steve Chibnall illustrates, a number of British films from this period combine ‘female monstrosity and otherness with male erotic spectatorship … [suggesting] fear of female sexuality with excitement about its possibilities’.12 These ‘alien women’ (in Chibnall’s parlance) range from the male-produced doppelgänger in The Perfect Woman to the alien-invaders of Devil Girl from Mars (1954) who abduct earth-males to repopulate their matriarchal planet. Interestingly it is the lower-budget films where these types of representation are most readily found. By the early 1950s, pulp science fiction literature, as Chibnall demonstrates, was the ‘repository for male [sexual] imaginings’13 and a parallel can be drawn with domestic feature-film production. Films such as The Perfect Woman, Devil Girl from Mars, Stolen Face and Four Sided Triangle were all relatively minor features, modestly budgeted, and were certainly not intended or imagined at the time as prestige productions. Four Sided Triangle and Stolen Face were made by Hammer before their famous horror costume cycle got underway in 1957. Stolen Face is a HammerLippert co-production, made in British studios with British personnel but drawing in secondary American stars and scriptwriters to produce a sharper product that would capture both the domestic and American market.14 A number of these films replay themes from American film noir, thus the plastic surgery theme in Stolen Face is a rehash of George Cukor’s 1941 MGM star vehicle for Joan Crawford, A Woman’s Face, which was itself reworked by Anthony Mann’s later, and much lowerbudgeted, Strange Impersonation (1946). Co-productions like Stolen Face enjoyed reasonable commercial success, in part because of tight budgeting, casting, and audience familiarity with thematic content. Four Sided Triangle comes after the Hammer-Lippert co-production deal had ended and by this time Hammer was producing science fiction/horror films, before later moving into the costume horror they became famous for. Both films were directed by Terence Fisher and have attracted (limited) critical interest which has primarily focused on the films as early examples of the director honing his craft before his
man-made women
19
later success as the quintessential Hammer horror director.15 The Perfect Woman is comparable in terms of budgeting. Made by Two Cities under the administrative umbrella of Independent Producers Limited (which gave producers a degree of artistic licence), the film is known to have been commercially profitable, not least because it was inexpensive to make.16 There is no case to be made for these films as lost or underappreciated masterpieces; these are modest films with modest budgets that were moderately successful both commercially and artistically.17 But it is striking that the theme of the alien women – specifically the man-made woman – should emerge so sharply at this time and in films that occupied a similar position towards the sidelines of the cultural map. It is highly probable that it was this positioning which permitted a more imaginative and direct engagement with the extremes of male fantasies vis-à-vis desire for, and control of, women, than would have been readily permitted in films with larger production budgets and higher-profile directors and stars. Men, Science and Reproduction Whilst women as invaders from outer space is one example of what could be conjured up in the male imaginary, man-made doppelgängers more readily represent the threat from within. The focus of this chapter is the attempt by men to reproduce females through scientific means, and the films demonstrate a concern with how male scientists use science in the quest for the ideal woman and female perfection as defined by those men. Their quest points to the gendering of science and a recognition of the impact of male scientists in the arena of reproductive technology. Reproduction should here be understood in the broadest sense as creating a facsimile of life; a copy which is made by a man without recourse to either God or woman. This can occur in many different ways in the cultural imaginary; the revitalization of body parts, the transformation of an existing being, the cloning of a human, or the creation of an ‘artificial’ person; that is, a machine that resembles a human. In most cases an in-uterine birthing process or female womb is rendered redundant. All such strategies are fundamentally concerned with circumventing the ‘natural’ role of either the female or of God in the reproductive process, and are predicated on an implicit belief that science can improve on nature. Examples of ex-uterine reproduction are prolific in Western culture and include, within Christian mythology, the creation of Eve from Adam’s rib, and within Greek
20
femininity in the frame
mythology the creation of Athena, who was born from the head of Zeus. The literary tradition of the theme of revitalizing human body parts is evident in Mary Shelley’s novel Frankenstein (1818), which dramatizes the creation of the male figure, whilst E. T. A. Hoffman’s short story The Sandman (1816) deals with the creation of a female figure in the form of a mechanized doll.18 The Frankenstein story has become a metaphor in Western cultures for any work or creation that becomes uncontrollable to its creator, who then typically rejects it. The fascination with male control over the reproduction of life readily translated first into theatrical adaptations of Frankenstein in the 1820s, and then moved into film. Versions of the Frankenstein story appeared in Hollywood as early as 1910, with Universal Studios’ later 1930s Frankenstein cycle being the best remembered. It was a favourite theme of German Expressionist cinema which produced The Golem (1915 and 1920), Lubitsch’s The Doll (1919), The Cabinet of Dr Caligari (1920) and most famously Metropolis (1926), where Fritz Lang’s robot Maria clearly functions, as Lyn Phelan suggests, as a ‘deathly seductress’ to the men around her whom she provokes into causing industrial chaos.19 Typically within Western mythologies, the creation of the female by the male is perceived to be a lesser form of creation, and it differs in important ways from the male. Whilst Mary Shelley’s male creation is an intelligent and articulate being with considerable agency who becomes monstrous in Frankenstein’s eyes, Hoffman’s doll-figure Olympia is physically beautiful but practically mute and functions primarily as a passive agent in a feud between her two male creators. As Phelan argues, the stakes change when men produce women rather than other men; ‘the additional layer of difference more easily secures the distinction between male maker and female machine – autonomous subject and automated object.’20 This additional difference makes it possible for the man-made woman to function also as ‘the explicit focus of eroticized fantasy and often of a special kind of sexualized disturbance’,21 thereby gendering the nature of uncontrollability. There is certainly a tradition in science fiction of seeing sex work as an ‘activity that can be conveniently mechanized’, leading, in more recent films, to the creation of ‘[h]umanoid sex toys’ which range from the techno-women in Bryan Forbes’ The Stepford Wives (1974) to the robotic ‘comfort woman’ Pris in Ridley Scott’s Blade Runner (1982).22 Whatever the male scientists’ stated intention for (and motivation behind) the creation of the women, which varies across the case studies offered here, her function as an object of male sexual desire underpins her creation. Like all Frankensteinian inventions, however, the women
man-made women
21
prove difficult to control and ultimately their male creators come to recognize the limits both of their own agency and scientific possibility, and that their vision of female perfection was false. The Perfect Woman The Perfect Woman was adapted for the screen by George Black and Bernard Knowles from a play by Wallace Geoffrey and Basil Mitchell which had already proved commercially successful in the West End theatre. Professor Belmon (Miles Malleson), a comedic variant of the eccentric scientist, creates a mechanized doll, Olga (Pamela Devis), modelled on his niece Penelope (Patricia Roc). The Professor hires two men, man-about-town Cavendish (Nigel Patrick) and his batman Ramshead (Stanley Holloway), to take Olga into society to ensure she is convincing as a real woman before the Professor unveils his invention to the scientific community. Penelope, in an attempt to secure a rare evening of entertainment, substitutes herself for Olga and the three characters decamp to the bridal suite of the Hotel Splendide, where chaos and misunderstandings ensue. The robot woman eventually selfdestructs, whilst Penelope and Cavendish fall in love. The film combines elements of science fiction with comedy, more specifically romantic comedy, and the trope of the star couple. This type of film is not without precedent in post-war British cinema where romantic comedies with a ‘fantasy’ theme enjoyed some popularity; Miranda (1948) and Blithe Spirit (1945), for example, centred on the disruption caused to the social order by, respectively, mermaids and ghosts. The Perfect Woman departs from that tradition by attributing creative agency to the male scientist rather than nature or the supernatural, thus linking the creation and its ‘sexualized disturbance’ more readily with male desires and fears. As a mechanical device the doll Olga is presented as a ready-made, complete entity that requires only to be switched on. She is clad in a strange outfit comprising quilted material, leather and metal rivets. The quilted material of the torso gives the impression of a soft doll’s body, whilst the leather material inlaid with metal rivets symbolizes the constructed nature of Olga, who is a combination of malleable and hard; natural and artificial. Through the means of the outfit the mechanized female body is simultaneously presented to us in a sexualized manner, with leather and rivets used to emphasize the shape and curve of the breasts. The presentation of the woman foregrounds her status as a
22
femininity in the frame
1. Pamela Devis as Olga in The Perfect Woman (1949)
man-made object, the display of her ‘constructed-ness’ allows us to admire the skill of her creator and ensures that the audience is in no doubt that the figure is artificial. The purpose imagined for the mechanized doll is left vague and deliberately ambiguous, although a sexual function is hinted at. Much of the film’s humour derives from misunderstandings, most obviously between robotic and real women, but also at the level of language. The dialogue is peppered with double entendres, ambiguity and extended wordplay. Cavendish calls Ramshead ‘Buba’ because, as he explains to a confused Professor, ‘rams, lamb, sheep, baa, baa, see?’ Comedic misunderstandings occur between the Italian manager and the Swiss waiter of the Hotel Splendide; ‘You serve the food in the suite, you know where the suite is?’ ‘Si, rice pudding semolina.’ This constant slippage between what is said and what is understood extends to the doll when the Professor explains to Cavendish and Ramshead that he has ‘made a woman’ but doesn’t say she is a robot. His instruction to the men – ‘I want her tried out’ – is therefore ambiguous. For the men it has one possible meaning whilst for the audience, conversant with
man-made women
23
the Professor’s invention, it has another. As Mark Bould has suggested, the scene is inflected through a lens of ‘impropriety, of everything [the Professor] says in innocence being taken by the others to mean something else’.23 The Professor, who describes his creation as ‘the perfect woman’ (‘she does exactly what she is told, she can’t talk, she can’t eat, and you can leave her switched off under a dust sheet for weeks’), instructs the men to ‘try her out’ because the invention is useless if he has created ‘a woman who won’t work’. The men do not yet know that Olga is artificial and, believing her to be a real woman, respond with, ‘a woman must work, if she’s a working woman, scrubbing and all that’. Within the film’s established framework of linguistic confusion the suggestion of both domestic labour and sexual function has been made. As Bould had indicated, ‘the meaning of “working woman” shifts from “functioning robot” to “woman engaged in work” to “prostitute”’ in this scene.24 Through the masquerade of domestic appliance, the male fantasy of sex toy can be smuggled into the home. The Professor’s statement that Olga is ‘strictly speaking … of no sex’ is therefore not credible, and Cavendish’s later comment that ‘there won’t be a single home without one’ marries the domestic and sexual function into one object; perhaps the perfect wife? Having suggested Olga’s role as sex toy, the way is paved for this male fantasy to be played out to its fullest when, unbeknown to Cavendish and Ramshead, the real woman Penelope (on whom Olga has been modelled) substitutes herself for the robot-doll and is installed by the men in the hotel bridal suite. The substitution opens up a number of possibilities, one of which is the play between restraint and exposure of the ‘real’ female body. When the men first arrive at the laboratory to escort what they think is the mechanized doll they subject Penelope to a rigorous inspection; brushing her cheek, scrutinizing her nose and ears and lifting up her dress to fondle her lower limbs, whilst proclaiming the skill of her creator. The objectification and exposure of the female to the scrutiny of the male gaze is the method by which femininity is confirmed, and indeed an uncomplaining Penelope has to acquiesce to this scrutiny if she is to convince in the role of robot. Exposure here is two-fold: Penelope’s act of substitution (her fraud) and the sexual dimension of exposure. There is a question throughout the scene about how far exposure could go, most especially in relation to Ramshead. The batman removes the dustsheet covering Penelope’s lower body commenting ‘I wonder if …?’ and then pauses, leaving an unspoken desire hanging in the air. His actions, significantly, are halted by Cavendish, which introduces a class dimension to the dynamic,
24
femininity in the frame
2. The Perfect Woman (1949) – inspecting ‘the perfect woman’
attributing lust and sexual danger to the lower-class male and restraint to the middle-class man. The threat/promise of sexual exposure is returned to later on in the hotel bridal suite. The men, intending to put the robot to bed for the night, remove her dress and reveal Penelope’s body (Patricia Roc) clad in lacy black underwear – a shot which was one of the key publicity images for the film. Alongside this male fantasy of the real woman as sex toy is the fantasy of material excess. In an earlier scene Penelope and the Professor’s housekeeper go shopping for clothes for what the Professor describes as Olga’s ‘trousseau’, another hint about her function as the perfect wife. Ensconced in a Bond Street department store they take their pick from the numerous items paraded for their inspection through three scenes which are all accompanied by dreamy romantic music. First we see expensive lacy underwear comprising a basque and French knickers, all available in a wide range of colours (‘pearl, platinum, silver, icyblue and petunia’). Secondly, an assortment of day dresses where the fitted jacket and expansive swirling material of the skirt evokes Dior’s
man-made women
25
‘New Look’, fashionable and desired by many British women at the time. Finally, luxurious evening dresses where Penelope picks out the salesman’s recommendation of ‘a model of stiff-ribbed silk in star sapphire’. Scenes of excess continue in the hotel bridal suite where Ramshead orders copious amounts of food (‘fish, chicken … two dozen bottles of beer’) which we later witness Penelope ravenously eating. At a time when there was considerable resentment that the government continued to dictate post-war consumption patterns it is not difficult to explain the appeal that such scenes of material excess would have had for austerity audiences. Food items at this time were still rationed and despite the very recent end of clothes rationing many women remained unable to access such luxurious new garments produced with extravagant amounts of material. The shopping sequences indulge a feminine fantasy of consumption and allow spectators to be immersed in a world of plenty. Whilst audience pleasure is addressed through scenes of material excess, it is also derived from a positioning as ‘knowing spectators’ vis-à-vis the artificial woman. In contrast with the two male players (Ramshead and Cavendish), the audience is fully conversant from the outset with Penelope’s act of substitution, and the presentation of Penelope as the robot plays on the audience’s knowledge that she is not a robot. The two women are distinguished by clothing (Penelope’s lacy black underwear differs markedly from Olga’s more fetishistic body armour), by casting (Pamela Devis in the role of Olga is made up to look like Patricia Roc’s character Penelope) and through the frequent moments where Penelope shifts out of the role of artificial woman and back into the role of real woman. In the bridal suite she eats and drinks (a function the robot cannot perform), leaving the men, who have been temporarily distracted, with inexplicably empty dinner plates. Close-ups of her face depict her licking her lips at the promise of an exotic dessert (glace à la maison) and nervously biting her lip when her dress is removed. There is never any attempt to fool the audience or confuse them about which woman is real and which is artificial. In this respect there are parallels with cross-dressing narratives within the comedy genre. As Annette Kuhn has demonstrated, these narratives, typified in films such as Some Like It Hot (1959), play on a known disjunction between clothes and body, drawing attention to sexual difference as socially constructed and gender identity as performative.25 In many mainstream films this dynamic is often conservative, allowing audiences to enjoy a flirtation with transgressions of gender and sexuality whilst remaining conversant with the ‘fundamentalism of the body … as final arbiter of a basic
26
femininity in the frame
truth’.26 Penelope’s performance of robotic femininity allows norms of social decorum to be transgressed (exactly how many layers of clothing will the men remove?) whilst the fundamentalism of her ‘real’ human body means both that she has something to reveal (unlike the robot, which is made up merely of ‘gimbals’), and that she can stop the male inspection should it go ‘too far’. Spectatorial pleasure for a knowing audience is derived from this titillation and from the safe play between artificial and real womanhood. Both women are involved in performative acts of femininity and are subjected to male control, but in different ways both women refuse to comply with male expectations. Olga needs constant instruction to function (‘sit’, ‘stand’ ‘step up’; she is the automated object of Phelan’s description), a situation that requires Cavendish and Ramshead to adapt their discussions to insert the required verbs into the conversation. Her instruction manual is too complex to readily understand and she requires of her operators a significant investment of labour and effort to function. Cavendish and Ramshead are forced to interact with her in ways that are impossible to sustain and which ultimately impoverish their quality of life to the extent that, paradoxically, they are robotized through their attempts to control her. This theme of Man’s dehumanization by the demands of machinery is long present in cultural representation, Metropolis and Chaplin’s Modern Times (1936) for example. Such concerns had contemporary relevance in post-war British society where the development of new technologies and the drive to increase industrial efficiency and productivity raised many fears and anxieties, with commentators such as George Orwell expressing concern about the ‘excessive mechanization of life’ and its impoverishment of the human spirit.27 The robotization of Cavendish and Ramshead certainly suggests, albeit in a humorous manner, how these anxieties were permeating British films.28 Olga eventually self-destructs in spectacular fashion: running out of the hotel room with a plume of smoke behind her. The man-made machine-woman is destroyed in preference for the real woman, who is presented as the epitome of feminine perfection. Olga explodes when the word ‘Love’ is spoken; something which the Professor had warned about but given no explanation for. ‘Love’ is presented as the emotional variable that science cannot rationalize or predict and it stands as a comment on the male scientist’s failure to integrate science successfully into the social realm. Penelope may attain the status of ‘the perfect woman’ and be rewarded with the promise of marriage at the film’s close, but she is not altogether compliant with male demands
man-made women
27
or male norms of femininity. Playing the role of robot allows her to transgress the role of obedient niece who is expected to comply with her uncle’s orders that she remain at home. There is a clear sense of masquerade as Penelope performs the roles of artificial woman and real woman, crossing effortlessly between the two. The shift between the roles, unwitnessed by the male characters but for the pleasure of the audience, creates a space which she occupies as an unruly woman. In Kathleen Rowe’s assessment, the unruly woman of comedy is marked by ‘excess and outrageousness’ and motivated by a desire to satisfy her needs.29 Whilst Penelope, played by British cinema’s sexy, bouncy girl-next-door Patricia Roc, might initially seem to sit awkwardly in a spectrum of unruly femininity that encompasses, in Rowe’s schema, Mae West and Miss Piggy, the comparison is illuminating. Penelope causes considerable chaos in the bridal suite when she steals food from the men’s plates. Not only does this lead to much head-scratching and arguing amongst the men but it provides the occasion for close-ups of Penelope engaged in ‘transgressive’ behaviour; drinking soup directly from the bowl, gobbling chicken and cramming more food into her already full mouth, allowing morsels to drop onto her dress. Penelope gratifies her needs when and where she can and engages in behaviour that clearly fails to comply with normative femininity. Her performance as the mechanized doll points to the ideal of perfect womanhood – biddable, silent and without needs – as a fallacy that exists only as a male fantasy figure. The film’s popularity can be accounted for by its adept handling of the perennial themes of pretty girls, titillation and mistaken identities, with more contemporary concerns regarding new technologies, assertive women and a lack of male control, all treated in a manner that provides pleasure and reassurance for audiences. The film’s ‘A’ certificate suggests a broad appeal and the very positive review in trade paper Kinematograph Weekly (played with ‘zest’ and ‘accurate timing’, with exhibitors advised to ‘Grab it; its formula has never failed’), positioned the film for popular success.30 The positive response it received in the pages of Picturegoer suggests it found its audience. Picturegoer reviewed the film as ‘simple stuff packed with a lot of laughs, some of them good ones’, and noted that although the film had been kept from show houses ‘Pat’s fans’ had followed her to the suburban cinemas to watch her latest film.31 Reader Derek Lowe of Essex won second prize of 10 shillings and sixpence for his letter to Picturegoer advising ‘Dismal Jimmies’ pronouncing the death of British screen comedy to watch this ‘rollicking new comedy’ which is being ‘lapped up’ by audiences.32 The
28
femininity in the frame
film addresses the needs of audiences that can be broadly categorized along gender lines. Olga is at one point referred to by the Professor as a ‘Dummy … indistinguishable from a female of the human species’. Comedy allows for the expression and then subversion of such thinly veiled misogynist statements. Scenes of Penelope in lacy underwear (heavily used to promote the film) are set alongside scenes showcasing desirable feminine items of clothing. Men are shown to be absurd in their desires and romantic love disrupts the male project. Both of these themes also emerge in Stolen Face. Stolen Face – the Plastic Surgeon as Pygmalion Figure In Stolen Face (1952), Philip Ritter (Paul Henreid) is a dedicated and successful plastic surgeon with a thriving private practice. He also undertakes charity work in the form of reconstructive surgery at Holloway women’s prison, as he believes that facial disfigurement plays a part in female criminality. He falls in love with Alice Brent (Lizabeth Scott), a concert pianist who returns his love but is engaged to another man and decides to honour that commitment. Distraught, Ritter resolves to recreate Alice’s face on an inmate of the prison, Lily (Mary Mackenzie before surgery, played by Scott post-surgery), who was disfigured in the Blitz and has been a hardened criminal ever since. Ritter marries Lily in the belief that he can rehabilitate her, but her criminal tendencies remain and, to make matters worse, Alice returns and is now free to marry Ritter. Lily discovers that she bears Alice’s face and in a drunken fury she challenges Ritter, accidentally falling to her death in front of the reconciled Ritter and Alice. The narrative is structured around a portrayal of male desire, the fantasies held about ‘woman’ in the male cultural imaginary, and the contradictions that real women and their experiences bring to bear on that fantasy. Male desire is here interwoven with scientific pursuit. Ritter’s role as a plastic surgeon has much in common with the scientist as individual genius figure as it draws together the qualities of ‘the pioneer, the scientist, the idealist, the creator and the aesthete’ to create a very particular professional identity (indeed one that would as accurately describe Dr Frankenstein).33 Plastic surgery and particularly cosmetic plastic surgery is ‘one of the most “gendered” of all medical specialties’ with predominantly male surgeons operating on female bodies.34 Ritter, significantly, only extends his charitable services to the women’s prison. This indicates a belief that facial disfigurement is more
man-made women
29
socially disabling for women than men as they are more bound by norms of physical beauty, but Ritter’s work also allows him to pursue his search for female perfection; the archetypal Pygmalion trope. Ritter recreates the face of his ideal woman on the prison inmate Lily but then, in a manner similar to Dr Frankenstein, rejects his creation. In this way Ritter is able to avoid the reality of real women whilst idealizing femininity, a state which is a motivating factor for all men but one which plastic surgeons are uniquely placed to realize. Ritter’s preference for fantasy over reality is evidenced both by his choice of Alice, who is an unobtainable woman, and the manner in which he approaches Lily as a project for the expression and actualization of his desires. Lily’s disfigurement in the Blitz presents her as a worthy subject for cosmetic surgery (unlike the rich, vain women that Ritter turns away from his private practice) whilst her status as a working-class woman and repeat offender positions her as the ideal figure to prove Ritter’s theories about the nature of female criminality. In an intertextual nod to the criminal brain inserted into Frankenstein’s creature, Lily’s criminality places her beyond society and allows Ritter to manipulate her as he pleases. Ritter initially wields complete power over Lily, who he subjects to rigorous scrutiny as he prepares to construct her new face. First he photographs her in close-up, with additional lighting, and then he inspects the blown-up photographs at length in his laboratory, with the assistance of a magnifying glass. During this protracted process he shuns social life, preferring to spend time in his clinic with the photographs and a pre-operative clay bust he has modelled for Lily’s reconstructive surgery. If she is to gain her new face Lily must acquiesce by obeying Ritter’s instructions to keep quiet and sit still whilst he examines her. The photographs are preferable to the reality of an inquisitive Lily. Within a psychoanalytic model, Freud argues for a ‘substitutive relation between the eye and the male member … [and a] connection between fears about the eye and castration’.35 Ritter clearly gains scopophilic satisfaction from these activities; subjecting Lily as an objectified other to a controlling gaze that allows him to counter anxiety about a loss of male power and control. As with The Perfect Woman, the male gaze is the method by which idealized femininity is confirmed. Lily is never consulted about her new image but is, not surprisingly, curious and asks, ‘what am I going to look like?’ Ritter replies with vague comments (‘I don’t know yet’), eventually concluding that she will look like ‘everything you’ve ever wanted to look like’. What transpires, of course, is that Lily looks like everything Ritter wants in a woman; that is, Alice.
30
femininity in the frame
3. Ritter (Paul Henreid) transforms Lily (Lizabeth Scott) in Stolen Face (1952)
Plastic surgery is only one aspect of Lily’s reconfiguration as Ritter’s fantasy of female perfection. In order to completely transform Lily in the image of Alice, Lily must acquire Alice’s clothes, jewellery, hairstyle, manners and decorum; in essence her middle-class femininity. In a makeover motif reminiscent of Hitchcock’s Vertigo (1958) and Scottie’s transformation of Judy into Madeleine, Ritter has very clear ideas about what he wants. Following the ‘unveiling’ of Lily’s new face in the surgery Ritter escorts her to an upmarket boutique where he proceeds to select the ‘correct’ shoes, evening gowns and dresses, vetoing unsuitable suggestions made by Lily, who repeatedly picks out the ‘wrong’ items. The process of acculturation into bourgeois norms is then completed by an evening at the opera. Whilst the transformation of the woman takes place here as much through learning and acculturation as through surgical means, Ritter, as a Pygmalion figure and agent of change, is well qualified to undertake both tasks and ensure that the acquisition of preferred femininity results in upward social mobility for Lily.
man-made women
31
Ritter’s attempt to take his creation from the scientific domain into the social realm is ultimately doomed and he quickly rejects the creation, which has failed to live up to his fantasy. Lily continues to prefer jazz bars to high culture, gaudy rather than ‘tasteful’ jewellery, and over-runs Ritter’s house with an assortment of low-life friends and lovers, acting as the ‘sexualized disturbance’ of Phelan’s description. She changes from her initial acquiescence to Ritter’s requests to become a form of monstrous-feminine; loud, uncontrollable, tasteless. Ritter cannot understand Lily’s behaviour, proclaiming her to have ‘everything any woman could want’ and he recommends her for psychiatric treatment. His attempts to make her responsible for her failure in his eyes are cut short, first by the medical director of the prison who concludes ‘maybe you left love out of your calculations’, and later by Lily. Her explanation about why she stole an expensive brooch – ‘didn’t you ever see something you wanted so badly you just had to have it?’ – points to Ritter’s guilt and culpability. Whilst Lily exhibits an insatiable appetite for furs, jewellery and drinking and fails to conform to Ritter’s expectations, Ritter is no more able than her to occupy the moral high ground. In his theft of Alice’s face and his marriage to Lily to satisfy his own desires, he has proven himself equally guilty of a failure to exercise restraint. Ritter’s preference for an ideal of femininity is recognized by Lily, who catches him gazing at the reconstructive bust of what she now recognizes to be Alice. Lily dashes the likeness to the ground and her statement, ‘you wanted this face, you’re gonna live with it’, highlights the poverty of this male vision and the misreading of his desires. The film has much to say about the male desire for female compliance and female usurpation of those desires: themes likely to have a broad gendered address for audiences. Narrative space is created for the articulation of male desires whilst those desires are ultimately shown to be fantastical and unsustainable in the real world. There are other elements in the film that suggest a more direct address to a female audience. For example, the casting of Austrian actor Paul Henreid in the role of Ritter builds on his high-profile roles in Casablanca and Now Voyager (both 1942) which had established him as a credible romantic male player in Hollywood. Interestingly, in both these films he has romantic credentials (tall, handsome, exotic ‘otherness’) but is something of a secondary character when placed alongside a stronger woman (Bette Davis in Now Voyager) or a more robust male (Humphrey Bogart in Casablanca). This hints at a weakness underlying his romantic masculinity. These aspects are well suited to his characterization in Stolen
32
femininity in the frame
Face, where Ritter is convincing as a romantic hero who goes to great lengths to pay homage to his love for Alice, but is conversely shown to be vulnerable, acting in an ill-considered manner and coming to regret those actions. Henreid’s star persona aptly signifies both Ritter’s weakness and his romantic intent, suggesting that whilst his actions were monstrous his romantic inclinations were not without value. In addition to casting, female audiences were courted via the numerous lavish costumes worn throughout the film by Lizabeth Scott. The outfits were designed by one of Hollywood’s leading costume designers, Edith Head, whose work was garnering Academy Awards at this time.36 Scott parades a number of outfits ranging from Alice’s smart tailored day suits and black wool dress accessorized with patent leather belt, to Lily’s more risqué party gowns and sumptuous full-length furs. Scott, as Lily, accompanies Ritter to the opera wearing a floor-length cream jacquard bustier-style evening gown with full skirt. Later, as her confidence grows, she appears in another full-length bustier-style evening dress, this time in clinging black satin which displays her curvaceous body, and in this way signals how Ritter’s hold over her has loosened. Alice’s profession as concert pianist likewise demands show-stopping gowns, with the display of décolletage set against the full skirt as befits her middle-class status and her embodiment of a more restrained femininity than Lily. Alice’s profession also legitimizes the lush ‘romantic’ score (primarily strings and piano) that accompanies the film. Written by Malcolm Arnold, a prolific and highly respected composer who wrote scores both for British genre films and more prestigious productions such as David Lean’s The Bridge on the River Kwai (1957, for which he won an Academy Award), a recurring motif is the tune played by Alice when Ritter first declares his love for her, a love she cannot return as she is engaged to another. This musical motif returns to haunt Ritter in key scenes; as he works on reconstructing Lily’s face in the manner of Alice, and later when Alice, now released from her engagement, returns to Ritter, only to discover he has married Lily. The motif gives voice both to the desire between the romantic leads and the thwarting and repression of that desire by social convention and by Ritter’s flawed vision. Music of this nature was a frequent feature of romantic melodrama at the time and suggests that the film’s producers were eager to capture a female audience. Likewise the ‘makeover’ scene where Ritter takes Lily shopping is a recurring motif in female-centred drama. As Rachel Moseley has demonstrated, this ‘narrative of transformation is a staple of women’s culture’ a ‘basic cultural trope … [that] feeds into feminine culture in
man-made women
33
endless ways’.37 It typically includes ‘before and after’ scenes where the physical appearance of a young woman is transformed through dressfittings or clothes-shopping sequences, and ‘coming out’ moments such as balls, dances and other occasions of increased visibility where the new woman showcases her acquisition of preferred femininity in exchange for public approval.38 As I have demonstrated, Lily’s makeover is not only surgical; the boutique sequence (comparable to that in The Perfect Woman) allows for the prolonged display of desirable feminine objects – evening gowns, high-heeled shoes – and is clearly addressed at female audiences who would be well versed in this motif of feminine fantasy. Critical reviews of the film recognized its feminine address with Kinematograph Weekly classifying it as a ‘romantic melodrama with a deep clinical fringe’ and Today’s Cinema as ‘fair popular entertainment, mainly appealing to women’, whilst exhibitors were advised by the film’s production company to promote the film’s romance angle through ‘catch lines’ such as ‘To capture love he cheated nature’.39 The film capitalizes on a number of gendered assumptions about the audience. It articulates a male project concerned with fear and fascination with the feminine and male anxiety about a perceived lack of control vis-à-vis women that it attempts to redress through an active male gaze. A male anxiety about female agency and women’s choices resonates with an understanding of a post-war consciousness where it was not automatically accepted that traditional gender roles would be resumed. The quest for female perfection is actualized through science but also through dress and costume and, in this respect, a range of feminine reading competences are courted. In addition to visual and aural stimulus there is a certain amount of female spectatorial pleasure to be gained from witnessing male fantasies about women as fantasies, and the disruption that real women can bring to bear on the male project. Male idealizations of women and the obsessive and disturbing extremes implemented by one man to actualize his desires are themes evident in Four Sided Triangle, although there the focus of that obsession is as much another male as it is the unattainable woman. Four Sided Triangle In Four Sided Triangle, Bill (Stephen Murray), Robin (John Van Eyssen) and Lena (Barbara Payton) are childhood friends. Robin comes from a wealthy family whilst Bill is an orphaned boy who is befriended and tutored by the local medic, Dr ‘Doc’ Harvey (James Hayter), who
34
femininity in the frame
also acts as the film’s narrator. After studying science at university, Bill and Robin return to their small village and set up a laboratory where they succeed in their goal of creating a replicating machine which can duplicate matter, thus bringing to an end human want. Robin and Lena fall in love and Bill, who has always loved Lena, persuades her to allow him to produce a copy of her for himself. Unfortunately the copy, Helen, has Lena’s mind and therefore she too loves Robin. Confused and unhappy, Helen tries to kill herself. In an attempt to resolve the situation Bill suggests that he erase Lena’s memories from Helen’s mind, but during the procedure a fire breaks out in the laboratory killing both Bill and Helen, whilst Lena survives to be successfully reunited with Robin. In the film’s opening sequence Doc observes that ‘There is often less danger in the things we fear than in the things we desire’, setting up the film’s central theme of male desire and the destructiveness of that desire. Bill is a driven individual and, in a manner similar to Ritter, his desire is interwoven with scientific pursuit. He pursues science for its own sake and is largely uninterested in the implication and wider application of the replicator, commenting, ‘what’s there to think out, we’ve done it, that’s all that matters’. Conversely Robin tempers this view with, ‘not quite Bill, we’ve a responsibility to ourselves and the world’. Robin’s ethical code, shared by his father Sir Walter, who has funded the research, allows for a direct confrontation with post-war concerns about science and a fear about how its advances will be used. Sir Walter recognizes the replicator’s potential as a ‘secret weapon’, able to reproduce not only the good things in life such as medicines but also ‘atom bombs and poison gas’, and insists the men work in conjunction with ‘the proper authorities’. Sir Walter acknowledges that Bill, not Robin, is motivated by what he calls ‘the spirit of detached scientific curiosity’, and for this reason proper restraint must be exercised. Unfortunately Bill proves unable to restrain himself and the film’s two moderating males, Dr Harvey and Sir Walter, may act as the voice of ethical responsibility by questioning the scientist’s actions, but ultimately have little real power and are impotent in the face of Bill’s overwhelming desire to realize his creative vision. In part Bill is motivated to create a new Lena because he desires to have what Robin has and seeks to actualize his desires for the unobtainable woman, but also because the project gives him the potential to extend the scope of the reproducer beyond its initial capacity to duplicate inert matter. The woman that he reproduces and names Helen is intended as his lover and playmate. Whilst Lily fails to please Ritter because she
man-made women
35
4. ‘Amazing – is it possible?’ – reproducing women in Four Sided Triangle (1953)
is too different from Alice, Helen cannot please Bill because she is too similar to Lena. Helen possesses Lena’s memories and emotions; thus the woman amounts to more than the malleable body or empty vessel envisaged by the male scientist who has, again, forgotten to account for the whole woman. Helen’s presence creates anxiety for all the men. She causes social embarrassment to Doc, who is initially confused by her possession of Lena’s memories. Bill’s attempt to integrate his scientific experiment, Helen, into the social realm via a seaside holiday is doomed to failure. Helen, tormented by Lena’s memories and love for Robin, attempts suicide and later sits impassively in front of her bedroom mirror, mechanically brushing her hair in a parody of learnt female behaviour. Sue Harper has suggested that Helen is one of a number of female protagonists in low-budget British science fiction films at this time who are ‘directed … to use none of the normal resources of gaze, expression and response’, the lack of which speaks of an anxiety about ‘female behaviour which cannot be coded according to predictable
36
femininity in the frame
rules’.40 In contrast to Lena’s more mobile features, Helen’s impassivity and blankness is a challenge for Bill. He has no idea how to read her and declares himself ‘frightened for the first time in my life’. According to Bill’s (flawed) logic Helen should respond to him, but she fails to react in the ways that were expected of her, or rather, she does act in a predictable way (in her love for Robin) but the consequences of her behaviour hadn’t been fully thought through. The failure to know and clearly read the woman is shown in this film to be the fault of the male scientist and his science. Whilst Helen is less overtly disruptive than either Lily in Stolen Face or even Penelope/Olga in The Perfect Woman, she is not entirely passive in the face of male control, and in her determination to kill herself she exercises sufficient agency to disrupt the male project. The similarity between Helen and Lena makes it (almost) impossible to distinguish between the two women. The laboratory fire results in the death of one of the women whilst the survivor loses her memory. Robin and Dr Harvey are wracked with uncertainty; has Lena or Helen survived? In a discussion of Frankenstein and Metropolis Ludmilla Jordonova argues that the ‘alien presence’ in the former is ‘alien because hideous’ whilst in the second, the robot Maria, is alien because she is ‘undetectable’; that is, indistinguishable from a ‘real’ woman.41 The inability here of Robin and Doc to distinguish the real woman from the artificial female created by Bill is presented as profoundly unsettling for the men and suggests the fear harboured in the male cultural imaginary towards all women. In this respect, Triangle is certainly darker than The Perfect Woman which relentlessly parades the real woman in a manner that leaves no room for ambiguity. Ultimately the film settles the matter by having the artificial woman marked by a small scar at the base of her neck. Doc has delayed examining the surviving woman because, as he suggests to Robin, ‘I thought perhaps it was your right’. The scar stands as a symbol of man’s right to assert ownership of the female body and mind, with Lena having no rights to claim her identity for herself. Whilst the film in many respects places the woman at the centre of the narrative, an equally important relationship is the one between Robin and Bill, with critics commenting on the closeness between the two men. Peter Hutchings argues that the ‘dichotomy set up by the film, with the normal Robin/Lena relationship on one side and the deviant Bill/Helen relationship on the other, is undermined by the way in which the film stresses the similarity between the men – men who are lifelong friends, both inventors, in certain respects almost interchangeable’.42 In a similar vein, Landy suggests that ‘[t]he focal point of
man-made women
37
the narrative is Bill’s desire to fuse with Robin. Lena is the battleground in Bill’s attempts to become like his friend, to possess what he has.’43 The literal doubling of the women Lena and Helen is extended to the two men who mirror each other in everything from their scientific interests to their rangy physiques. Whilst Hutchings argues that this ‘splitting of masculinity … registers an attempt … to deal with some anxiety relating to male identity’ he stops short of working through the full implications of this.44 The closeness between the two male friends suggests the possibility of same-sex desire and that the ‘deviancy’ that characterizes Bill and Helen’s relationship also exists between Robin and Bill, but in their case it cannot be openly expressed. Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick’s work on male homosociality – that is, the social bonds that exist between men – is pertinent here and she extends her definition to incorporate ‘male homosocial desire – the spectrum of male bonds that includes, but is not limited to the homosexual’.45 Whilst male homoeroticism is never as explicit in Four Sided Triangle as Phelan finds with, for example, Bride of Frankenstein (1935), it nevertheless shapes the relationship between Robin and Bill. The melodramatic plotting sets up a number of complex and interlocking (romantic) triangles: Bill loves Lena who loves Robin, Helen loves Robin who loves Lena, Doc admires Bill who loves Lena, to which we might add Bill loves Robin who loves Lena. In the first half of the film the relationship between the two men is prioritized through framing and physical placing. A recurring motif is a framing shot of Bill/Lena/Robin in a triangular structure, with Lena positioned between the two men to suggest how both love her and that she will ultimately come between them. But the fact that their relative positioning within this structure is neither equal nor balanced suggests a different meaning can emerge. Lena is positioned in the background whilst the men take up the foreground prioritizing, through physical placing, the strong connection between Bill and Robin – who occupy a different cinematic space to the one allocated to Lena. Bill, furthermore, shows remarkably little interest in Helen as an erotic object of desire. The seaside trip devised so that Helen can, in the words of Doc, ‘get used to him’ is accompanied by a montage of romantic imagery – picnics by the sea, lingering strolls in the sun – but the romance between the couple is decidedly lacklustre. Bill is more animated by the contents of his picnic sandwich than the woman in front of him, asking Helen ‘why have sandwiches no imagination in this country?’. Helen’s reply, ‘perhaps there’s a general lack of [imagination]’, shrewdly points to the failure of the male scientific project. Significantly
38
femininity in the frame
the duplicated Helen wears the same wedding ring as Lena, given to her by Robin on their wedding day. Bill’s insistence, commented on by Helen as ‘strange’, that she continue to wear the ring, suggests his own desire for Robin’s love token, something that he cannot legitimately wear but can only access via Helen. Lena is more than the ‘battleground’ of Landy’s argument; she is the focal point for the expression of male homoeroticism and Bill’s desire to possess not only what Robin has, but also the man himself. The ‘normal’ and ‘deviant’ couples make up a four-sided triangle, a perversion and an offence against nature, and must be destroyed to allow for normal heterosexual coupling. With the deaths of Bill and Helen all forms of ‘perversion’ are removed: out-ofcontrol science, alien women and deviant men. This film, perhaps more sharply than the others, demonstrates an uncertainty and anxiety about women and what they require from men (hence Bill’s inability to ‘read’ Helen) and a concomitant preference for male relations, played out through the theme of scientific pursuit. This male anxiety is more directly evident as the film is more overtly ‘masculinist’ in its address. It lacks the ‘balancing’ tropes of a romantic male lead, costume and music found in the other films, and its modest visual attractions are confined to the laboratory sequences and the display of male-coded technology. That the artificial woman is indistinguishable from the real is another source of unease. It is not known how the film fared at the box office although it received an unfavourable review from Picturegoer, which struggled to identify anything commercially viable in a film whose plot ‘dabbles in alchemy and romantic melodrama with equal clumsiness’.46 Certainly the casting of the American Barbara Payton as the female lead would have generated publicity. Payton had a reputation in Hollywood for sexual promiscuity, drinking and drug taking, and came to Britain in 1953 to escape negative publicity following a high-profile divorce.47 A front-page story about her (‘Payton, the Problem Girl’) appeared in Picturegoer in the September 1952 edition, foregrounding to a British public her infamous reputation. This makes her status in Triangle as an object of male desire credible, whilst it simultaneously and conversely renders ironic the idea of her as pliable and biddable love object and sheds light on male idealizations and fantasies of women as profoundly illusory and ill considered.
man-made women
39
Conclusion The films discussed show the attempt to realize male desire for an idealized ‘perfect’ woman through technology, but this technological achievement is then exposed as false. In all three films the artificial ‘perfect’ woman fails; a failure that seems to reinforce male impotence in terms of actualizing their desires. Indeed, as scientists they might more accurately be defined as ‘panic-stricken rather than authoritative’; a statement which suggests that anxiety concerning gender roles is a driving force for these men.48 Whilst this has become something of a gender cliché in writing about the post-war period (masculinity in both Hollywood film noir and the British war film is understood in terms of ‘anxiety’), I find it has currency in a discussion about the male scientist and his project. Do men fail to create what they really want, does technology fail them, or do they create what they think they want only to realize that they have failed to read their own desires accurately? The failure of male-made technology to function in the social world suggests that the ‘real’ woman is preferable, and in the films discussed the human woman is shown to be more than a ‘doll’. Thematically this is consistent with many other British films of this period that engage with science and demonstrate its failure or a ‘reining in’ of its wildest excesses.49 What distinguishes the treatment of science and the male scientists’ project in the alien women films is that moderation is achieved through the forces of romance and love. Emotion is the confounding variable that all science tries to exclude but it is shown in these films to be resistant to manipulation. Men, and science, disregard it at their peril and must account at all times for love. That romantic love can disrupt the male project would have been an appealing theme for a female audience and there are many elements in the films that were directly addressed to women. The slippage between male fantasy and female reality resonates with the theme, popular in Hollywood’s female gothic films of the 1940s, of women being haunted by the former wives and lovers of their husbands (Rebecca, 1940; Dragonwyck, 1946; The Two Mrs Carrolls, 1947 for example). Among other things these films demand that men give up their fantasies and pay attention to the real woman. Female audiences, well versed in these elements of women’s culture, would have found much to enjoy in the British alien women films. This is not to claim that the British films are in any way protofeminist texts (although reading against the grain may facilitate that meaning), or that they were marketed exclusively at women, rather that in their subject matter they point to an anxiety about, and uncertainty
40
femininity in the frame
regarding, the post-war roles of men and women. This is treated in a broadly sympathetic manner with male scientists shown to be anxious and misguided, unthinking rather than malevolent. These films were not alone in vocalizing the theme of male control and impotence visà-vis women – the St Trinian’s cycle (1950+) most famously tackled it in the comic mode – but it is striking that it receives its most thorough working in these minor SF/comic films, often made with modest budgets and relatively modest artistic aspirations. That they enjoyed some commercial success suggests an audience appetite for cinematic depictions of male concerns and female non-compliance.
the british femme fatale
41
2
The British Femme Fatale In Chapter One I discussed how the figure of the ‘man-made woman’ linked the theme of male control and impotence in relation to women with the fears about science and technology that were shaping the social consciousness. The ‘man-made woman’ was not the only fantasy figure in circulation at this time, with British cinema producing a number of films that showcased the female villain: the sexually active criminal woman, often motivated by murderous intent. These criminal women are an archetypal form of narrative trouble and permit a simultaneous celebration and demonization of the figure of the strong, active woman who refuses normative femininity and her ‘proper’ social role; themes that were replete in the British social imaginary at this time. In the Introduction I illustrated how the official prescriptions for women’s lives were contradictory; where Beveridge’s 1946 National Insurance Act positioned them as dependent housewives the 1947 Economic Survey called for them to be pulled into the workforce. Innumerable films from the post-war period framed these concerns about the conflicting position of women and their readjustment to traditional gender roles in civilian life, through the narrative trope of ‘female choice’ and a dramatic tension between desire and duty. This was as common to films within a realist mode such as It Always Rains on Sunday (1947) and Dance Hall (1950) – where the heroines have love affairs which jeopardize their marriages – as it was to costume melodramas like Madonna of the Seven Moons (1944) – which literalize the theme of choice through the heroine’s split personality. Underpinning the notion of ‘choice’ was a deep-seated uncertainty about how men and women might understand and relate to one another in the new post-war world. Whilst the choice between desire and duty in both the realist and the costume melodrama modes has been well documented, what has not been addressed in critical writing is the role relative to these debates of the British femme fatale.1 This chapter will reposition the femme fatale to her proper place in British film history by arguing that a study of the murderous/duplicitous woman can shed equal light on how domestic cinema engaged with the possibilities and anxieties readily associated with female agency.
42
femininity in the frame
The Absent Femme Fatale in British Cinema The commonly received wisdom is that British cinema of the 1940s failed to produce any femmes fatales. In his discussion of post-war British film Robert Murphy argues that ‘there was no equivalent to the glittering femme fatales who haunted Hollywood cinema’.2 He supports his statement with reference to Wolfenstein and Leites’ muchquoted post-war film survey that concluded ‘British films do not, on the whole, take the destructive potentialities of women seriously’.3 Likewise Sue Aspinall, who concludes her post-war survey with the claim that ‘there were few memorable images of strong women in British films’.4 Andrew Spicer, who has done much to open up the field of British noir for study by identifying its own ‘energies and distinctiveness’, is largely silent on the subject of the femme fatale, despite claims that British noir was preoccupied with ‘a critique of male prowess, potency, sexuality and criminality’; concerns where we might reasonably expect to find a female influence.5 How do we explain this curious critical absence, given that the British crime film in all its various manifestations proliferated in the post-war period? Sue Harper’s ground-breaking work on Gainsborough costume drama has convincingly demonstrated the centrality of ‘wicked ladies’ in British cinema, and she argues that the post-war period ‘is notable for the amount of screen time given to female villainy, and the care taken to discriminate between its different types and degrees … [as] female deviants quickly spread from costume to modern melodrama and to other generic forms.’6 From this statement we might reasonably conclude that the dangerous female was present across a range of genres including – but not limited to – crime. This chapter will draw together the two strands of the crime film and the female villain into a discussion of the femme fatale as she emerges, contrary to previous opinion, within a specifically post-war British film context. As Britain struggled with war-time rationing and a burgeoning blackmarket economy a new type of crime film emerged in British cinema which Peter Wollen and others have categorized as the ‘Spiv cycle’.7 Films such as Waterloo Road (1945), They Made Me a Fugitive (1947) and Brighton Rock (1948) focused on a criminal underworld populated by razor gangs, delinquents and ‘wide-boys’, dealing in black-market goods within the urban milieu of the palais de dance, the boxing ring and the dog track. Within these worlds men dominate and women are secondary, being either loyal but duped wives and girlfriends or
the british femme fatale
43
dance hostesses and nightclub performers who function primarily as objects of male exchange. In either role their narrative importance is minimal and their concerns and desires marginal. These films, popular with audiences, attracted a mixed critical response. While some responded positively to the perceived energy, vitality and realism of the films, others condemned them for their ‘sordidness’ and glamorization of crime. The Sight and Sound critic Arthur Vesselo coined the term ‘morbid burrowings’ in 1947 to describe contemporary British filmmaking which had an ‘unpleasant undertone, a parade of frustrated violence, an inversion and disordering of moral values, a groping into the grimier recesses of the mind.’8 Vesselo’s term, although originally applied to They Made Me A Fugitive, has been taken up by critics such as Robert Murphy to describe the wider cycle of film-making in post-war Britain that dramatized themes of paranoia, male anxiety, murder, psychological disturbance, sex and violence.9 The parallels with American film noir are obvious, and from 1943–49 Britain produced its own cycle of ‘morbid films’ concerned with maladjusted or brain-damaged veterans (The October Man, 1947; The Small Back Room, 1948), hommes fatales (Blanche Fury, 1947) and tragic male murderers (Daybreak, 1946; Dear Murderer, 1947; Obsession, 1949). What Murphy rightly identifies about this loose cycle of film-making is its diffuseness with male paranoia and criminality appearing across a broad spectrum of films which, in Spicer’s topography, ranges from topical crime thrillers to gothic-inspired Victorian films noirs.10 Indeed it is this very diffuseness that has mitigated against a serious engagement with the British femme fatale. Dangerous women are central to some contemporary crime dramas (Dear Murderer) but more marginal to others (Obsession). They are afforded little narrative space in the ‘Spiv cycle’ but assume greater prominence in gothic noir (for example So Evil My Love, 1948; Daughter of Darkness, 1948; Madeleine, 1949).11 This diffuseness is only part of the explanation. British film criticism has demonstrated a remarkable uncomfortableness with home-grown female villainy and has struggled to find a way to engage with it in any meaningful manner. The most popular British star of the 1940s, Margaret Lockwood, was the quintessential ‘wicked lady’ of British cinema (see her murderous roles in costume dramas such as The Man in Grey, 1943 and The Wicked Lady, 1945), but critics of the day roundly dismissed her performances. Leonard Mosley in the Daily Express declared ‘I just cannot believe in Miss Margaret Lockwood as a femme fatale’, and the Guardian likened her to ‘cold suet pudding’, whilst for
44
femininity in the frame
Time and Tide she was competent to ‘launch a hair style [rather] than a thousand ships’.12 As I discuss in Chapter Six, Lockwood’s wicked lady roles were poorly served by the film review pages of Woman magazine, with the critic Freda Bruce Lockhart commenting that Lockwood ‘doesn’t even look naughty’.13 Gavin Lambert later sneeringly dismissed her performances as ‘suburban’ and indeed she has fared no better with more recent commentators.14 For Murphy, Lockwood’s costume roles are examples of ‘boisterous, good-natured villainesses, bold but unthreatening’, whilst her role as a ‘real femme fatale’ in Bedelia (d. Lance Comfort 1946, adapted for the screen by Vera Caspary, from her novel of the same name) sees her performing as a ‘spoilt child rather than a psychopath’ with the film compared unfavourably to Caspary/ Preminger’s Laura (1944).15 The sense that Lockwood cannot be taken seriously as a femme fatale even now suggests that the benchmark for dangerous women remains predicated on a Hollywood model perhaps best embodied by Barbara Stanwyck, whose femininity was resolutely modern, edgy and urban. The Angel-in-the-House This, however, elides any engagement with how a specifically British variant of the femme fatale may have emerged, and there are two key concerns that need to be addressed: domesticity and sexuality. As Babington has demonstrated, part of Lockwood’s appeal was her ordinariness coupled with elements of the exotic which he terms the ‘Karachi-Norwood interface’.16 Her star persona embodied a type of fatal femininity which was inflected through a domestic lens, seemingly at odds with commonplace understandings of the ‘Hollywood femme fatale’ but rooted in a specifically British context and threatening because of its very domesticity. The ordinary/exotic dualism of Lockwood’s star persona is actualized in Bedelia where her titular heroine is a serial killer who marries then poisons her husbands to inherit the insurance money. A prestige production and star vehicle for Lockwood, this glossy melodrama was clearly addressed at female audiences with publicity materials focusing on Lockwood’s hairstyles, jewellery and wardrobe, which had been designed by Elizabeth Haffenden.17 Beautifully dressed and with a penchant for exotic items such as Siamese cats (hardly indigenous to the film’s Yorkshire setting) Bedelia is also presented as the ‘perfect wife’: charming, biddable, and skilled at housekeeping. On the one hand Bedelia functions as an
the british femme fatale
45
inverted angel-in-the-house figure with her characterization indicating, as Marcia Landy has suggested, that the ‘overtly domestic female is the disrupter of family and tradition’ and with the film warning of ‘the dangers of excessive femininity’.18 However, Bedelia’s characterization is rather more complex than this reading allows. Under interrogation by her husband and an insurance investigator, Bedelia responds with a violent outburst: ‘I hate men, they’re rotten beasts, I wish all the men in the world were dead.’ This statement is a moment of emotional truth from the normally evasive Bedelia and hints at an unexplained trauma in her life. Her actions seem motivated less by financial greed (she rarely spends her money) than to visit vengeance on men for a great wrong done to her. In this film the femme fatale is embodied in the character of the ‘ordinary’ women being simultaneously a figure of vengeance and the perfect wife, whilst her central position in the domestic sphere indicates a certain anxiety about what this role might require of women. This focus on the domestic extends beyond Lockwood, as the spectre of the poisoning wife proliferated in post-war British cinema not only in gothic noir (Pink String and Sealing Wax, 1945; So Evil My Love, 1948; Madeleine, 1949) but also in contemporary thrillers such as Dear Murderer. Poisoning has long occupied a central place in the popular consciousness as a quintessentially female method of murder and the gendered weapon of choice for women who enjoy unregulated access to the vulnerable stomachs of the family.19 The spectre of the ‘poisoning wife’ is one that emerges historically and alongside studies of female criminality which, as Jones has argued, have proliferated at times of ‘profound unease about women’s place in society’.20 It is therefore perhaps not surprising that the poisoning wife emerges in the post-war period, but as a more domestic variant of the femme fatale, this figure has been relatively overlooked in studies of British cinema. Whilst the idea of domestic space as threatening is a long-standing feature of the female gothic film, in the Hollywood variant men threaten women in this sphere (The Spiral Staircase, 1946; Secret Beyond the Door, 1947). Conversely, in the British films mentioned above it is the women who prove deadly to the men, and the dominant setting for crime, and by association ‘transgressive’ femininity, is the domestic realm rather than a criminal underworld, with murder carried out through the use of domestic weapons such as poison and sleeping tablets rather than guns.
46
femininity in the frame
Peculiarly British Sexuality As Rebecca Stott and others have argued, sexuality is the defining feature of the femme fatale; a sexuality that is ‘perceived to be rapacious, or fatal to her male partners’.21 It is this component more than any other which is seen as lacking in British actresses and which might account for Murphy’s comment that Lockwood is ‘unthreatening’ in the role of villain. Sue Aspinall’s claim that female characters were rarely involved in ‘the exercise of female power through sexuality’ is fairly representative of British critical commentary on this subject.22 Certainly British cinema had always used ‘exotic outsiders’ to import sexual sophistication into the narrative.23 During the war and immediate post-war period, casting ‘exotics’ was neither possible nor desirable and home-grown actresses were called upon to perform divergent femininity with varying degrees of critical success. Actresses as diverse as Googie Withers (Pink String and Sealing Wax; Night and the City, 1950), Margaret Lockwood (Bedelia), Jean Kent (Good Time Girl, 1948), Ann Todd (Daybreak; So Evil My Love; Madeleine), Greta Gynt (Dear Murderer; Easy Money, 1948), Patricia Roc (The Brothers, 1947) and Siobhan McKenna (Daughter of Darkness) featured as villains in period and contemporary melodramas and crime thrillers, made by a range of British production companies including Ealing, Gainsborough and Cineguild. An actress’s star persona inflected the female villain character in particular ways. Ann Todd’s impassive glacial iciness differed markedly from Googie Withers’ sensual and grounded persona, producing a broad spectrum of fatal femininity where sexuality was not necessarily rapacious in the way that Stott deploys the term. For example, Ann Todd was, as Harper suggests, adept at ‘inspir[ing] passion in others … [whilst herself remaining] frigid’.24 The idea of a frigid femme fatale is perhaps a peculiarly British phenomenon. There is no doubt that Todd’s characters are fatal to men: in Madeleine she poisons a besotted and blackmailing former lover whilst in Daybreak the rivalry between her two suitors causes murder and suicide. Similarly Withers (another duplicitous poisoner), whose sexuality was shot through with a degree of pragmatism that enabled her to approach her male victims with steely determination.25 Frigidity and pragmatism may seem the antithesis of the femme fatale but they point to a particularly British inflection of female sexuality and indicate some of the methodological limitations in deploying wholesale, to any national cinema, a framework drawn from critical discussions of the Hollywood femme fatale. Within the space available
the british femme fatale
47
in this chapter I want to offer a case study of three types of British femme fatale appearing in films ranging from contemporary thrillers to gothic and Victorian melodramas: the mature overtly sexual woman who self-consciously performs female villainy (Greta Gynt in Dear Murderer and Easy Money), the seemingly repressed femme fatale (Ann Todd in Madeleine and Daybreak) and the more domestic yet no less deadly ingénue type located within a rural setting (Siobhan McKenna in Daughter of Darkness). The three types illustrate some of the diverse ways in which British cinema imagined femininity and female sexuality in the post-war years. At times I’ve drawn from existing scholarship on the femme fatale (particularly Doane, Gledhill, Dyer),26 and these ideas have helped illuminate readings, but I have borne in mind the Britishness of these femmes, and suggested points where they depart from these critical frameworks. Performing Fatal Femininity for the British Screen – Greta Gynt Greta Gynt enthusiastically embraced stardom within British cinema at a time when many British actresses eschewed such glamour in favour of a more modest star identity.27 Norwegian-born, she trained as an actor and dancer and came to England in 1935, aged 19. Instructed by her agent to model herself on Madeleine Carroll, she dyed her hair blonde and after an apprenticeship in supporting roles she secured a seven-year contract with Rank, enjoying a brief but intense period of success from 1943–48. She provided fuel for the gossip columns with numerous marriages and love affairs and was a shameless self-promoter who always courted press attention. She famously appeared at a 1947 Royal Command performance in a silver lamé dress, matching silver fox coat and silver hair adorned with silver osprey feathers in a calculated attempt to steal publicity from Hollywood star Loretta Young, whose film The Bishop’s Wife was premiering at the event.28 She later commented that she looked ‘like a fairy on the Christmas tree gone wrong – but of course it made all the papers next day’.29 Described in 1948 by society magazine The Leader as ‘the only Rank star who behaves like a film star’, she has subsequently passed into the annuals of British film history as a vamp – one obituary describing her as ‘the slinkiest Delilah of them all’.30 Equally at home in comedy or straight drama, it was her roles in Dear Murderer and Easy Money that consolidated her female villain status. Upon her retirement from film
48
femininity in the frame
production at the end of the 1950s she declared herself ‘utterly bored with this femme fatale business’.31 Gynt’s Nordic heritage gave her an outsider status which meant she could signify as the ‘exotic other’ to the British cultural consciousness and perform certain roles in British cinema, whilst Norway’s position as occupied ally during the war ensured she continued to readily find work in the British film industry. It was of course her exotic outsider status coupled with her ‘Hollywood-esque’ attributes that allowed her to be read as a convincing femme fatale, both at the time and subsequently. Reviewing Dear Murderer for Sight and Sound in 1947, Arthur Vesselo argued that the film’s ‘chief redeeming feature’ was Gynt as a ‘highly unscrupulous siren’.32 She is afforded a brief mention in Murphy and Spicer’s studies of British noir; Murphy approvingly describing her as ‘glitteringly evil’ in Dear Murderer whilst for Spicer she succeeds as ‘the most ruthless femme fatale in British cinema’.33 For these two commentators there remains a sense that Gynt is best understood as an anomaly within British cinema, but what is missing from this account is an understanding of Gynt that locates her more precisely within a spectrum of British fatal femininity. Whilst aspects of Gynt’s star persona clearly did enable her to function effectively as a femme fatale, conversely those same elements could work against the character-type. Within British cinema culture where, as Babington rightly suggests, an ‘anti-star inflection of stardom’ predominated, Gynt occupied the terrain of self-conscious performer.34 Her own reference to the business of performing as a femme fatale suggests a self-awareness of her image, its construction and presentation. She was regularly cast in roles that showcased performances: a nightclub singer and dancer in The Common Touch (1941) and Easy Money, an opera singer in Take My Life (1947), and a cabaret artiste in Crooks’ Tour (1941). This, coupled with her training as a dancer, meant that her star persona included a generic ‘song and dance’ or ‘performative’ element. Christine Gledhill notes that the placing of noir women in ‘image-producing roles – nightclub singers, hostesses, models etc. … [has meant that] their performance of the roles accorded them in this form of male story-telling foregrounds the fact of their image as an artifice’.35 With Gynt, the idea of artifice is heightened, and her star persona worked in interesting ways with the film material. She is simultaneously convincing as the dangerous woman, whilst pointing to the creation of that image and its construction as a fantasy figure.
the british femme fatale
49
Easy Money This tension is evident in Easy Money (d. Bernard Knowles 1948), a portmanteau film which warns against the dangers of gambling and, by association, loose women. Gynt is cast as nightclub singer Pat Parsons, who persuades her pools-clerk boyfriend Joe to make a false claim on the pools for a payout of £20,000. Interrogated by the company’s claims investigator, Pat tries to double-cross Joe and the sequence ends with their arrest. Made with a modest budget by producer Sydney Box for Gainsborough, and co-scripted by Muriel Box, Easy Money was one of Box’s ‘topicals’ which were films loosely intended as a commentary on various aspects of contemporary life, in this case gambling.36 Opening in typical noir fashion, with flashback and moralizing voiceover, Gynt’s character is introduced performing her regular nightclub routine. Dressed in a black satin split-skirt dress and gloves she performs the song ‘Shady Lady Spiv’ to an upmarket nightclub audience seated at tables through which she moves and dances whilst singing.37 The scene is a remake of Rita Hayworth’s strip-tease performance of ‘Put the Blame on Mame’ in Gilda (1946). Gynt’s dress, described by a commentator at the time as the ‘new look and look again’ gown,38 is virtually a direct copy of Hayworth’s outfit. Wearing 24-button gloves to above the elbow, and with her shoulder-length hair blonde and waved, Gynt copies the hair-tossing mannerisms of Hayworth in Gilda in a manner that leaves no room for ambiguity in recognizing the source of the scene. Certainly performing a British variant of Gilda, an instantly recognizable femme fatale, is a role that no British actress other than Gynt could realistically and convincingly have attempted at this time, and the scene is intended to showcase Gynt’s character as a sex object for male heterosexual pleasure and the cause of their downfall, whilst it simultaneously celebrates her glamorous femininity. However, the notion of image-production cannot be escaped; artifice is foregrounded from the outset and runs throughout the film. In part this is achieved because of the double performance taking place as the star ‘Greta Gynt’ performs ‘Rita Hayworth’s Gilda’, which results in the audience being positioned to read between the two scenes. As Andrew Horton has illustrated in his work on remakes (an elastic term which can encompass allusion, parody or the recreation of key scenes), these ‘invite and at times demand that the viewer participate in both looking at and reading between multiple texts’.39 Richard Dyer has demonstrated convincingly that Gilda is a problematic femme fatale, not least because Hayworth’s
50
femininity in the frame
5. Greta Gynt as the ‘Shady Lady Spiv’ in Easy Money (1948)
star persona (her ‘charisma’) resists some of the negative connotations of the deadly female.40 Given the striking and extended parallelism between the two films, traces of this resistance spill over into Easy Money. Gynt’s song ‘Shady Lady Spiv’ suggests female culpability in the post-war black-market economy (singing, ‘ladies cash-in looks aren’t done on coupon ration books’), and that women sell sexual favours to the highest bidder (‘she’ll be your lady, but you’ve got to give-givegive’). But drawing together the myriad intertextual and contextual circuits of allusion and parallelism, it’s evident that performance and resistance are at play here and bring challenges to bear on this version of sexual politics. The film’s moralizing discourse is consistent with the idea of the film as a ‘social commentary’ and is not over-turned (it authoritatively proclaims Pat at the point of her arrest ‘a wicked and foolish girl’) but it is certainly disrupted and its validity rendered ambiguous; a characteristic that is not atypical of the femme fatale figure and her narrative positioning. Through Gynt and her performance of Gilda the film becomes a multi-layered text, positioned to readily address a post-war audience’s appetite for alternative meanings.
the british femme fatale
51
Dear Murderer A similar pattern obtains in Dear Murderer (d. Arthur Crabtree 1947) which, even more than Easy Money, points to the femme as a male fantasy figure. In this film Gynt’s character, Vivien Warren, is a society woman who drives her husband Lee (Eric Portman) to distraction with her constant infidelities. Lee returns from a business trip in America to murder one of her lovers, Richard, and then frames a second paramour, Jimmy, for Richard’s murder. A police investigation ensues and Lee is wracked with guilt at the incarceration of the innocent Jimmy. The film concludes with Vivien murdering Lee with an overdose of sleeping tablets (administered via a hot milk drink, under the guise of the ‘caring wife’) and being arrested by the police. A psychological crime thriller with an upper middle-class contemporary setting, the film thematically and stylistically deploys characteristics we now typically associate with film noir. Adapted from a play, the film is studio-bound, with the drama located in interior domestic settings and much of the action taking place at night. Chiaroscuro lighting is used to enhance this moody and claustrophobic setting. The iconography of Janey Place’s ‘spider woman’ is in evidence for Gynt’s character.41 Her long hair frames her face, she smokes constantly, and wears a number of glamorous outfits that signal her sexual availability. She frequently gazes at herself in the mirror at times of narrative importance (reflecting on her infidelity or planning her husband’s murder) suggesting the ‘selfabsorbed narcissism’ of the femme and the desire for autonomy.42 She is introduced through her husband’s flashback, and Lee’s voice-over draws attention to her appearance: ‘I remember how she looked, she was wearing her new black dress’. The simultaneous introduction of Vivien through physical appearance and Lee’s voice-over description of her denies her the opportunity to represent herself. She readily uses her sexuality to exercise power over men, using sex and emotional blackmail to achieve her goals. For example, after convincing Lee that she really loves him she later persuades him to write an ambiguously worded note that she uses to fake his murder as a suicide. Her presentation as confident, aggressive and sexually promiscuous suggests that on one level she unambiguously occupies the space of the dangerous woman in the narrative and her arrest is to be understood as justifiable punishment for her hubris. This, however, is not the only role attributed to her. The film is usually approached critically as one of a number of post-war psychological thrillers where the travails of ‘sensitive and tormented’ middle-class
52
femininity in the frame
men are foregrounded.43 The film’s press book, however, places great emphasis on Gynt as ‘a perfect model’, with film studios being well positioned to take advantage of the actress’s ‘enviable ability as a fashion model’.44 A full-page spread details aspects of Gynt’s ‘£2,000 wardrobe’ for the film: the ‘white strapless evening dress with draped crepe bodice and a skirt of cascades of white tulle’, the ‘exquisite hand beaten bronze and pearl studded flower jewellery’, the ‘sable-trimmed hat and muff’ and the ‘£3,000 luxurious mink coat’ on loan from a ‘distinguished London fashion house’. With accompanying film stills of Gynt in a variety of outfits, suggestions are then put forward as to how female viewers (the ‘average woman’) can adapt these ideas, which ‘can be copied quite easily and cheaply’, for their own wardrobes. The film’s publicity material then suggests the central importance of ‘performing’ and the film is a vehicle for Gynt to showcase a number of outfits that celebrate a glamorous femininity. These range from smart, stylish daywear to glamorous evening gowns, paraded against a backdrop of elegant dining and sophisticated ‘contemporary’ living. The film’s wardrobe was designed by Yvonne Caffin, who had worked as Elizabeth Haffenden’s assistant at Gainsborough during the war. Haffenden, who worked in a non-realist mode, was skilled at creating a ‘costume narrative’ that gave subconscious ‘cues’ about characters.45 Although Caffin worked in a realist mode and was therefore more conventional than her mentor, she was nevertheless adept at enhancing or signalling a character through nuance and detail in the costume. During one scene, for example, when Lee confronts Vivien about her adultery Gynt’s outfit, with pleated draped sleeves and adorned at the shoulder with decorative curlicues, not only signals her overt femininity but gives it a decidedly reptilian hue. The film’s visual pleasure, both now and certainly for a post-war austerity audience, derives as much from Gynt’s numerous costume changes as it does from her performance as ‘glitteringly evil’ or from Reginald’s Wyer’s ‘accomplished noir cinematography’.46 It is the frequent costume changes (which take place from scene to scene) coupled with Gynt’s star persona that provide the film with its sense of ‘dressing-up’ and playing multiple roles; both the stylish society wife and the fatal woman. The notion of image production in relation to the fatal/duplicitous woman is also evident in other, perhaps less immediately obvious, ways. The film opens with an extended scene depicting the husband, Lee, entering a stylish apartment and rifling through bedroom wardrobes and drawers. His attention is arrested by flowers in the waste-paper bin which are accompanied by a card reading, ‘Love Always, Richard’.
the british femme fatale
53
Spurred on by this ‘clue’, Lee continues searching for more evidence of his wife’s infidelity, and quickly finds numerous cards in the dressingtable drawer, all bearing the same message and intended to indicate the woman’s unbounded capacity for sexual duplicity. Vivien as an embodied character is entirely absent in the opening sequence and is only introduced twenty minutes into the film. What is present and so motivates the action is the idea of the duplicitous woman. Lee’s image of the ‘unfaithful wife’, a resident wartime folk-devil, is here pressed into service as a structuring absence. In this respect the idea of the femme fatale that is deployed in this scene recalls Angela Martin’s observation that this is an image that expresses ‘a masculine view of female sexuality’ and one which Martin argues, drawing on Mary Ann Doane, functions ‘as a kind of signpost’.47 For Martin, this signpost can point to male neurosis: that is, ‘women in films noirs are … subjected to male definition … not because they are a threat but because the male characters … project a neurotic sense of threat on everyone and everything around them’.48 Martin’s observation bears on Dear Murderer where the opening sequence illustrating the wife’s infidelity equally points to the obsessive nature of Richard’s ‘love’ (a man who clearly exhibits no restraint) and the husband’s capacity for paranoia and mental instability. That the husband might be the subject of query and investigation is hinted at in the film’s publicity material. The husband Lee is a typical example of the neurotic and damaged characters that the actor Eric Portman specialized in playing in the postwar years. A key item in the film’s press book is an article entitled ‘Do you really know Eric Portman?’ which, after giving brief biographical details, invites audiences to consider the actor in roles different to his usual ‘suave, sinister style’. As a typical piece of promotion and star study the article is not unusual, but it does succeed in foregrounding the man rather than the woman as the troubling enigma that the film might then work to resolve. There has been a critical tendency to approach Greta Gynt as the archetypal ‘siren’ or ‘ruthless femme’ and to read her as imagistic shorthand for fatal femininity on the British screen. This approach fails to engage fully with her position within British cinema and how aspects of her particular star persona (performativity, image-construction) pull against the femme fatale type in various, complex ways that suggest different readings. In Dear Murderer she is simultaneously the dangerous woman and a figure of male fantasy, and the perfect fashion model addressed at a female audience. Actresses more readily positioned within a domestic framework performed different versions
54
femininity in the frame
of fatal femininity although, in common with Gynt, these were not without contradictions. It is to these different versions of ‘female fatalness’ that I will now turn. The ‘Repressed’ Femme Fatale in Daybreak and Madeleine In marked contrast to Greta Gynt’s status as exotic outsider (albeit one comfortably positioned within British cinema) the actress Ann Todd was very much an insider figure. British born and trained, she entered film-making in the 1930s and, after a protracted apprenticeship in supporting film (and stage) roles, her breakthrough came in the internationally successful The Seventh Veil (1945). Her 1949 marriage to the film director David Lean consolidated her insider status and the couple made three films together before separating in 1954 (The Passionate Friends, Madeleine and The Sound Barrier). Her later comments on the status of the star – describing it as ‘a label I can’t stand’ – position her within the ‘anti-star inflection of stardom’ that has so dominated British cinema.49 With her trademark white-blonde hair, sharply defined cheekbones and ‘restrained’ performance style, she was typically described (both at the time and subsequently) as icy, ethereal, witch-like, inscrutable and enigmatic.50 It is Todd’s emotional coldness that Harper reads as ‘frigid’, although at its most effective her style hinted at the repression of deep emotions residing beneath the surface. McFarlane’s observation that Todd was able to deploy ‘conflicting suggestions of propriety and sensuality’ most accurately characterizes her as a performer.51 It is a style which seems ill-suited to the role of the femme fatale, where sexuality is more readily portrayed as overtly aggressive and sultry, but in fact it is particularly well suited to a dominant type of British cinema predicated on a tension between restraint and excess.52 Daybreak In Daybreak (d. Compton Bennett 1946) Todd plays Frankie, a nightclub dancer whose experiences with men have left her embittered and cynical. Uprooted and drifting, she meets middle-aged Eddie Tribe (Eric Portman) who has recently inherited a small fleet of barges at Gravesend. The couple strike up a seemingly unlikely alliance and appear content for a while, but Eddie’s secret life as a public hangman,
the british femme fatale
55
which he keeps hidden from Frankie, eventually threatens their happiness. Eddie gives work to the handsome Olaf (Maxwell Reed) and against her better judgement Frankie is increasingly drawn to the man. The couple become lovers and their eventual discovery by Eddie causes the ménage à trois to implode. Frankie commits suicide, Eddie exacts revenge on Olaf by wrongly imprisoning him for murder, and Eddie, grief-stricken at Frankie’s death, eventually hangs himself.53 A sense of fatalism infects the film. Eddie inherits more than just the barge business from his father. The man was an adulterous husband to Eddie’s mother, a beautiful and sensitive woman whose life was ruined by her husband’s cruelty. Eddie likewise suffered brutality and bullying at his father’s hands. The legacy is thus one of psychological and emotional suffering. Indeed in Frankie’s early comment to Eddie – ‘You don’t know much about women do you?’ – is a recognition of Eddie’s failure to develop emotionally. Eddie’s lack of experience with women contrasts sharply with Frankie’s extensive experience with men, which has left her bitter and cynical (‘most men aren’t kind’, she proclaims). The couple’s shared liking of animals is indicative of how both have almost given up on people. Despite their tentative attempts at happiness, outside events always threaten to overtake them. Whilst Olaf ’s predatory sexuality casts an obvious shadow over them, Eddie’s job as public hangman ensures that death hangs (literally) over their lives. Scenes of Frankie and Eddie’s domestic life are interspersed with scenes of Eddie noting execution dates in his secret diary and then travelling across the country to perform them. Eddie’s hidden double life is thus a constant threat to the present. The setting is likewise used to effectively enhance the sense that the life the couple create for themselves is not sustainable. By choosing to turn one of the barges into a houseboat (filmed in a studio setting and surrounded by atmospheric fog) the couple are positioned in a liminal space, cut loose from social connections.54 They have no telephone and connection for Frankie with the outside world is primarily via Bill, an elderly and drunken sailor who periodically rows her to the shore for shopping. Whilst initially this space offers both characters the chance of positive renewal, it is ultimately experienced negatively. When Olaf boards the boat in Eddie’s absence Frankie cannot escape and her earlier statement to Eddie that ‘You can’t live on a barge!’ is proven correct by the unfolding of tragic events. Frankie’s status as a femme fatale is complex and at times contradictory. She clearly exhibits a sexuality that attracts men to her and they die because of it. Whilst never a sexual aggressor, she is evidently
56
femininity in the frame
sexually experienced and immediately recognizes the danger that Olaf presents. She tries to persuade Eddie to dismiss Olaf in an attempt to preserve their domestic happiness, but the attraction that Olaf and Frankie hold for each other is made clear. She disparagingly refers to Olaf as ‘like an American film star’, but their shared love of dancing is her weakness. She lies to Eddie, absent on one of his ‘business’ trips, and goes dancing with Olaf at the palais de dance; a place where sexual desire can readily be given expression. Frankie oscillates throughout between desire and repression of that desire, and Todd convincingly portrays the sense of struggle between the two. In one scene Olaf leaves a dance record on the barge to be discovered by Frankie. She plays the tune and dances whilst, unbeknown to her, he watches. She’s momentarily startled when she discovers his presence but his quick flattery of her dancing pleases her. His comment of ‘we should dance … you, you have it’ elicits an emotional outburst of ‘I did once!’ and she stands very close to him, her face (captured in close-up) looking up, smiling, then breathing heavily. Almost immediately she recognizes that she has let herself go too far and turns abruptly away, reining in her sexual desire and emotional excess. Re-appropriating the persona of the ‘responsible wife’ and feigning sexual disinterest she reproaches Olaf with a curt ‘have you fixed the window?’ in an attempt to return their interaction to legitimate domestic matters. A similar tension is evident in a later scene where Frankie continues to fluctuate between attraction and disapproval of Olaf. Frankie is neither a passive victim of sexual manipulation nor a sexual aggressor and she is reminiscent of what James Maxfield terms the ‘fatal woman’ who is fatal to the hero but in herself neither evil nor a ‘deliberate agent of the hero’s destruction’.55 Whilst Ann Todd’s Frankie does not exhibit the aggressive sexuality characteristic of Greta Gynt’s performance of fatal femininity, neither is she devoid of sexual expression. As a type of femme fatale the characterization of Frankie is noteworthy because Todd captures in her performance something of the struggle between moral responsibility and personal desire. Madeleine The tension between convention and freedom also characterizes Todd’s later film, Madeleine. In this female-centred drama set in nineteenthcentury Glasgow, Todd plays the titular heroine Madeleine, the eldest daughter of an upper-class family who, like all heroines, must negotiate
the british femme fatale
57
the problems that arise from being a woman.56 Madeleine is conducting an affair with a lower-class man, Emile – a dandified French clerk in her father’s business whom she knows her father will never accept as a legitimate suitor. Under increasing pressure from her father to accept Mr Minnoch, his choice of husband for her, Madeleine breaks with Emile who resorts to blackmail by threatening to reveal her love letters to her father. Emile then dies suddenly and in suspicious circumstances, and Madeleine is accused of poisoning. She stands trial and a verdict of ‘not proven’ (only available in Scottish law) is returned. The film closes on Madeleine’s enigmatic smile and the question of her guilt, or innocence, is never resolved.57 Deliberate ambiguity is at the heart of the narrative, and the films’ opening voice-over (an anonymous male narrator) introduces Madeleine’s ‘strange romantic story’ and positions this ‘unusual’ young women as the object to be held up for scrutiny and examination. Madeleine thus operates within the model of the femme fatale proposed by Doane whereby ‘the threat of the woman [is transformed] into a secret, something which must be aggressively revealed, unmasked, discovered’.58 From the outset the domestic setting of the bourgeois Victorian home is presented as oppressive. Madeleine, her two younger sisters and her mother are bullied mercilessly by a cruel father, a tyrannical patriarch who presides over the family home. The family moves into a new house and Madeleine is irresistibly drawn to the basement room which she intends to occupy as a bedroom declaring, ‘I like this room very much’. The room provides her with a degree of freedom as its basement location and proximity to the servant’s entrance allows her to conduct secret trysts with her lover Emile. The setting is replete with sexual imagery; Madeleine takes a hidden key from the drawer and passes it to Emile through the bars of the window; Emile later thrusts a phallic cane through the same window when Madeleine refuses him entry. The spatial arrangement within the house points to desire and its repression which lies, hidden, beneath the respectable façade of the Victorian drawing room. The Victorian setting also harmonizes with the ambiguity that is characteristic of Todd; the ready display of an ‘icy’ façade and emotional coldness, coupled with the suggestion of sensuality and emotional depth. These two polarities are readily played out as Todd’s character expresses both sexual desire and sexual reticence, although in the case of the latter there is an acute awareness of coyness as an accepted sexual stereotype for women. Whilst never a sexual aggressor, it is clear that Madeleine is sexually desiring and finds a ready outlet for that desire in the form of Emile. The
58
femininity in the frame
archetypal ‘rake’ Emile is in many respects the imaginative manifestation of her repressed desires; a Byronic hero conjured up from the pages of popular literature, who appears at night to the accompaniment of thunder storms and whose ‘foreignness’ ensures his status as a social transgressor. Their basement trysts culminate in a secret rendezvous at the family’s holiday home where they meet on a hilltop overlooking a moonlit sea, accompanied by the musical strains of a working-class wedding party taking place in the valley below. Madeleine commands Emile to dance with her and as the music intensifies (augmented by some rapid cross-cutting) she grasps Emile’s cane and discards it before the couple fall to the floor in a passionate embrace. Her appropriation of the phallus and her sensuality, signified here by her diaphanous swirling white gown and loose, flowing hair, clearly suggests an active sexuality that dares to transgress socio-sexual norms. Furthermore, Madeleine, in contradiction with Sue Aspinall’s statement, does exercise female power through the deployment of her sexuality. Madeleine breaks with Emile when she realizes that his greatest desire is for social mobility and his response to this is blackmail; he will send her love letters to her father. Madeleine must now convince Emile that she does want to marry him on his terms, and in a manner similar to Gynt’s character in Dear Murderer her strategy is to feign sexual [re] interest in him. Crucially the love scene differs from that on the hillside where Madeleine was the instigator. Madeleine reluctantly receives Emile into the basement kitchen of the family home and terminates his confrontation of her by falling to the ground weeping. At Emile’s touch her face reveals a blank, inscrutable expression and, without resistance, she allows him to gather up her limp body in a passionate embrace. By allowing Emile to dominate her at this crucial point (and indeed knowing that an arrogant Emile will be inclined to read her neutral expression as passive acquiescence) Madeleine gives him the illusion of power and in doing so wins a reprieve from confronting her father. Through the disguise of the ‘acquiescent female’ she manipulates norms of femininity and is able to exercise agency within the limits in which she is forced to operate. This theme is made further evident in her dealings with Mr Minnoch, her father’s preferred suitor for her. When Minnoch presses her for an answer to his marriage proposal, Madeleine exploits the accepted sexual stereotype of demure feminine reserve in response and succeeds in delaying a final decision about the marriage. Her acute awareness of femininity as masquerade – the expectation that she will perform
the british femme fatale
59
a femininity deemed ‘natural’ for a woman of her social standing – is evidenced in a later scene where her father questions her about the failure of Mr Minnoch to propose: Madeleine: I can hardly propose to him myself Papa. Papa: No, but I cannot help feeling that some sign, some indication from you would … Madeleine: Bring him to the boil Papa?
Madeleine’s quip is insightful and incurs her father’s wrath because she dares to both vocalize his thoughts and the reality of socially sanctioned female role-playing. Throughout she is proven to be a skilled manipulator of sexual stereotypes and it is through her performance of the dutiful hostess, biddable and attentive to Emile’s needs, that the spectre of the poisoning wife is ushered into the family home and she serves Emile cocoa (possibly) laced with poison. Likewise the pharmacist, confronted with what he reads as a beautiful and vain young woman, readily accepts Madeleine’s excuse that she needs arsenic as a beauty preparation. Whilst not cast in an image-producing role, the characterization of the heroine nevertheless foregrounds the notions of artifice, masquerade and disguise in relation to femininity, and also how women struggle for agency within feminine roles which readily serve the interests of patriarchal society. Todd’s characters in both films exhibit a type of fatal femininity where active sexuality can surface alongside sexual repression, and in this respect the tension between social convention and female agency is laid bare. Madeleine’s period setting and status as a gothic noir gives it greater licence to explore sexual and social transgressions and issues of class and social propriety. Similar themes are evident in Daughter of Darkness (1948, adapted from a 1938 play), although here the tension is between the exotic and the domestic, embodied in the figure of the young lowerclass woman. The ‘Domestic-Exotic’ – Daughter of Darkness Daughter of Darkness (d. Lance Comfort) is a full-blooded melodrama in gothic mode with the central protagonist, a young Irish servant girl, Emmy Baudine (played by Irish actress Siobhan McKenna), using her sexuality to lure young men to their deaths.59 Banished from her village in Ireland, she is dispatched to a Yorkshire farm headed by
60
femininity in the frame
Bess Stanforth (Anne Crawford) and her husband. Young unmarried men from the local community begin to mysteriously disappear (their mutilated bodies later discovered) and Bess, increasingly suspicious of Emmy, confronts her, eventually expelling Emmy from the community to meet her death. The narrative is thus structured by the investigation of a mystery, although in common with many films noirs the focus of the investigation is displaced onto the woman and what follows is an investigation of female sexuality and its disruptive effects. Of particular interest is how nationality and landscape are used to construct fatal femininity, the nature of Emmy’s sexual power and the role of the woman Bess in investigating and regulating female sexuality. In contrast with the urban milieu most typically associated with noir, Daughter deploys a specifically rural landscape as the backdrop for its investigation of female sexuality. In the original play Emmy’s origins were Cornish, but in the film her roots are in rural Ireland; a shift that is significant. As Ruth Barton has argued, Irish neutrality during the war severely fractured British–Irish relations, with post-war British cinema responding with a ‘darker view … of national treachery’, the Irish countryside ‘represented as a dark, malevolent space whose depiction drew closely on the Gothic rather than the pastoral tradition of representation’.60 Part of Emmy’s fatal femininity is derived from her Irishness and firmly established in the opening scenes when she’s shown bringing chaos to her home village in Ireland. She is positioned in the English cultural consciousness as an outsider figure, an alieninvader to the English landscape. This gives her licence to perform fatal femininity, whilst the femme figure here assumes a wider political significance. The film does retain its Cornish elements through the medium of landscape, which is also put to use in constructing the femme. Despite the ostensible Yorkshire setting for the scenes where Emmy is banished to England, the film was shot on location in Cornwall with some of the more dramatic sequences being filmed at recognizable Cornish locations such as Hellsmouth near Perranporth. Studio press releases frequently stressed the film’s Cornish setting. The Cornish landscape is, as Rachel Moseley has argued, simultaneously ‘familiar and strange’, occupying a place within the British imaginary as ‘the domestic exotic’, and within post-war British film history this landscape was often used to represent the ‘desirable, dangerous woman’.61 In Daughter of Darkness, Emmy is linked with this landscape in ways which suggest dangerous femininity. In a key scene, after murdering one of her male victims,
the british femme fatale
61
6. Emmy entices David in Daughter of Darkness (1948)
Emmy is dramatically shot from a cliff-top at high angle, running along the beach. The camera then cuts to a close-up of her scrambling barefoot amongst the rocks and pools and then standing staring out at the pounding sea. She encounters a young fisherman, David (whom she later murders), who advises her not to ‘bide there too long … it ’ain’t healthy’. Emmy’s response that this is her ‘favourite spot’ signals her as a regular visitor to the deserted cove and establishes her connection with the dramatic Cornish landscape. Indeed, a very clear distinction is drawn between the English pastoral landscape where the farm is situated – gently rolling fields stocked with sheep and cows – and the dramatic Cornish coastline. Emmy is an outsider-figure to the farm whilst the seascape provides her with a more natural habitat. Conversely Bess and the other women are never shown to venture beyond the farm. Emmy is thus positioned as doubly divergent, through both her Irishness and her connection with the Cornish landscape. This divergence extends to sexuality, which is signalled through the parallels Emmy draws between herself and the sea:
62
femininity in the frame
It’s just like me that sea, nothing holds it back. You’d never think it had such strength. And then its hands come out and crash on the rocks and tear at them, and all the thunder is in your ears.
As a commentary on female sexuality, it is here given the force of nature and signalled as destructive and unbridled. Emmy’s sexual power is presented as something that she struggles and fails to control. She admits, ‘something terrible rises up in me and I can’t breathe’. In this respect she functions as an embodiment of Doane’s model of the femme fatale whereby ‘[h]er power is of a peculiar sort insofar as it is usually not subject to her conscious will’.62 This suggests a lack of agency and indeed Doane goes on to argue that the femme ‘has power despite herself ’. Emmy herself seems to abdicate responsibility, claiming ‘Can I help it if wherever I go the men’s eyes follow me … it’s no fault of mine’. Within this framework, power in the form of sexual power takes possession of the femme fatale, and the notion of ‘possession’ was a recurring feature of promotional material for the film. Suggested advertising angles for exhibitors included ‘what was the strange power of Emmy?’, ‘possessed by the devil’ and ‘terrified by her power over men’.63 The female body, possessed by an external force (a theme common to gothic horror), suggests the femme to be, in Doane’s words, ‘not the subject of power but its carrier’, with the attendant ‘connotations of disease’ that accompany this observation.64 This resonates with Bess’s later claim that Emmy is ‘rotten’, and thus the threat of contagion to the English pastoral idyll is linked to the Irish outsider figure. Doane’s observation that the femme lacks agency is not entirely borne out by Emmy’s characterization which, as I shall demonstrate later, does brings some particular challenges to bear on this model of fatal femininity. Whilst Emmy is signalled as exotic, possessed of a strange power and therefore threatening (David, bewildered, can only weakly observe ‘you’re not like a servant girl at all’), like the Cornish landscape she is simultaneously ‘domestic’ and familiar. She is complimented on her actual domestic skills on more than one occasion (Bess comments ‘she does her work well’ and she enjoys polishing the silver) and in this respect she performs the role of biddable and obedient servant girl. She is typically dressed in modest clothing: blouses with ‘peter pan’ collars, pretty embroidered dresses, flat shoes and a cross on a chain around her neck. Indeed the challenge for the film’s dress stylist (Dorothy Sinclair) was how to design a wardrobe that would ‘attract the admiration of men’ whilst remaining sufficiently ‘demure’.65 Reviews of the film
the british femme fatale
63
likewise focused on the duality of Emmy’s character, her ‘wistfulness and innocence, shot through with a suggestion of evil’.66 Her seduction technique consists of nothing more than a downward glance and seemingly shy half-smile when sexual power appears to overtake her. That she proves irresistible to men despite never actively seeking them out indicates that her power is ‘not subject to her conscious will’. One farmhand declares ‘I can’t hold myself back’ whilst another comments ‘there’s something about you Emmy, I don’t know what it is but … you’ve got something alright’. It is the combination of deadliness and innocence, the domestic and the exotic that characterizes this particular femme. Emmy is in many respects the ‘ideal servant’ – hard-working, quiet and demure – and this masquerade of biddable femininity permits her to infiltrate the English pastoral idyll and the family setting. There are clear parallels here with Ann Todd’s characters where a masquerade of frigidity is used to disguise or detract from her sexual desire, and Lockwood’s ‘Karachi-Norwood interface’, pressed into service in Bedelia as she performs as the perfect wife and scheming murderess. All cases point to the importance of recognizing the role played by the domestic and the ordinary in an understanding of the British femme fatale. In common with many films noir, the central concern of Daughter of Darkness is an investigation of the femme fatale and her sexuality. What is particularly noteworthy about this film is that the investigation is undertaken by a woman – a situation which gives considerable narrative space to the dynamics between two women: the fatal femme, Emmy (young and unmarried), and Bess (slightly older and married, but without children). Through casting, the two women are positioned as opposites – the fair ‘English Rose’ versus the ‘dark Celtic beauty’,67 – but Bess is simultaneously disgusted by Emmy (‘she repels me, I don’t know why’) and fascinated with her. As Gledhill has demonstrated, noir investigation uses confession as a narrative mode and Bess is positioned as a confessor figure in this narrative, confronting Emmy and forcing her to confess to violating the codes of female sexuality.68 In two key scenes Bess challenges Emmy: ‘What made you leave your village in Ireland? I want to know why, tell me! They didn’t like you, did they? Why, Why?!’ and later, ‘You’re going to tell me what’s behind this filthy thing, I’ll shake it out of you … Answer me!’. Bess is a redundant investigator because the audience already know what happened in Ireland and her interrogation brings no new evidence to bear on the killings. What actually motivates Bess is a desire to hear, in detail, Emmy’s sexual transgressions. Stott, in her discussion of the femme
64
femininity in the frame
fatale, draws on a Foucauldian framework to argue that ‘confession produces sexual discourse whilst appearing to repress sexuality’,69 and these ideas structure the narrative of Daughter of Darkness. Bess produces Emmy as the embodiment of transgressive female sexual desire (‘You’re a bit of a flirt, aren’t you’, ‘I believe you’re rotten’), inciting her to talk (‘Where have you been?’ ‘What have you been up to?’ ‘Did you know him’), whilst she simultaneously works to regulate her (‘You don’t bring those habits onto this farm’, ‘You’ll pack your things … and get out of this house’). Bess’s actions are ostensibly motivated by protecting the community but call female sexuality into being, allowing it to be displayed before being legitimately destroyed. In this case female sexuality is not subjected to ‘the voice of male judgement’, as Gledhill finds in many American noirs,70 but rather, in this British context, female judgement and regulation: in the end it is Bess who casts Emmy out of the community to almost certain death. The older married woman is positioned as the gatekeeper for the community’s sexual mores and bears the responsibility for reconstructing the domestic realm (ideas which would have had currency in the post-war period), but this is achieved through a process that allows her to confront, head-on, female sexual desire which is shown to be fascinating to her. Nor does Bess’s interrogation go unchallenged. At various points when Emmy is confronted she responds with ‘I have my rights’, ‘Perhaps you’d better not threaten me’ and ‘You shouldn’t speak to me like that’. Emmy’s comments suggest a degree of independence and agency; the young woman is given a voice and attempts at regulation are negotiated and, at times, thwarted. Emmy’s motivation for murder is not financial gain and in a manner similar to Lockwood’s Bedelia she desires vengeance. She is a sympathetic figure in contrast to the inhabitants of her original Irish village who despise and hound her and the Yorkshire farm owners whose middle-class world is oppressive and smug. She visits vengeance on the men who desire her (‘All of them whispering, staring, grinning’) and the communities that exclude her (‘The women, so dreadful to me’). Whilst most killings are presented as the result of a murderous sexual power that has risen up, seemingly involuntarily, inside her, on one occasion she actively takes control of her sexual power. She seeks out and murders Larry, Bess’s younger brother, as punishment for Bess’s hubris and the intolerance of the wider community of which Bess is a figurehead. The young lowerclass female is shown to actively seek reparations for her outsider status and she has somewhat more agency than Doane’s model permits. Furthermore, if many representations of transgressive female sexuality
the british femme fatale
65
come to, as Doane argues, ‘take on a life of [their] own’71 then what is particularly memorable in Daughter of Darkness is the fascination female sexuality is shown to have for women, as much as men. Conclusion As I have shown in this chapter, post-war British cinema did produce home-grown femmes fatales, and in a manner more diffuse and complex that has been widely recognized. Looking to female-centred melodramas, gothic and period features rather than the ‘Spiv cycle’ allows a different picture to emerge where fatal femininity is evident across a broad canvas. Aspinall’s statement that ‘there were few memorable images of strong women in British films’ is incorrect. Similarly, Wolfenstein and Leites’ claim that British films failed to ‘take the destructive potentialities of women seriously’. British articulations of fatal femininity (like their Hollywood counterparts) pointed to female agency and transgressive sexuality, which, as I have demonstrated, were portrayed in particular and nuanced ways. Whilst ‘resident outsiders’ such as Gynt had greater licence to perform a type of fatale femininity more readily associated with Hollywood femmes, the performative aspects of her star persona – and her place within the British consciousness – pulled against character type and foregrounded sharply the femme as a figure of male fantasy predicated on anxiety and neurosis. In addition to the role of the fatal women, Gynt was simultaneously constructed as the stylish society women with an enviable wardrobe addressed through publicity to a desiring female audience. Ann Todd’s characters illustrate a very different type of sexuality; one where sexual desire is typically restrained and only periodically disrupts a seemingly implacable façade. Whilst never overtly aggressive, her characters are highly attuned to the masquerade of femininity and the workings of female sexual stereotypes which women can appropriate to disguise or detract from their intent. Daughter of Darkness makes imaginative use of a particular rural landscape to construct a femme fatale who is simultaneously exotic and ordinary and presents unregulated female sexuality as a source of fascination for other women. More generally, understandings of the British femme fatale from this period need to recognize the importance of the domestic and the ordinary in codifying dangerous femininity. The placing of these female murderers within a domestic setting and the portrayal of seemingly ordinary women in extremis should not be understood as a lack or a
66
femininity in the frame
failure to perform convincingly as femmes fatales, but is in fact integral to characterizing British fatal femininity. Typically, aspects of normative femininity (domestic, biddable, sexually demure or disinterested) are set alongside more transgressive or exotic elements in a manner which points to masquerade and the performativity of female/feminine stereotypes. What emerges from these films is a sense of the importance of role-play at this time, of ‘trying on’ different female personas, each of which makes different demands on the wearer and elicits different responses and rewards. The women choose between suitable and unsuitable husbands and lovers, between being biddable and the desire for ‘something more’, whilst the men are shown as profoundly untrustworthy; predatory, manipulative or neurotic. These films share a connection which needs to be more widely recognized with other postwar films such as It Always Rains on Sunday and Madonna of the Seven Moons; the better-known examples of how British cinema dramatized the theme of female choice against a backdrop of wider uncertainties about gender roles that were shaping the social consciousness at this time. This cycle of film-making was a feature of the immediate postwar years and the output of female-centred melodrama and period features waned in the 1950s, replaced by the popular comedy and war genres, and the social-problem film. The crime genre likewise experienced a downturn and the criminal underworld and the more psychologically complex ‘morbid’ films were increasingly relegated to secondary features.72 Debates about female agency and transgressive female sexuality did not disappear but shifted gear, emerging most strongly in the social-problem genre which linked female sexuality to criminality. For example, in the ‘prostitute’ films of the late 1950s (the focus of Chapter Five) an interest in the social problem of the prostitute is combined with a popular fear of – and fascination with – organized crime. In the next chapter I will discuss the quintessential 1950s figure of the housewife positioned within the companionate marriage, seemingly the embodiment of normative femininity but, as I shall demonstrate, no less a complex and transgressive figure than the femme fatale.
the comedy-of-marriage film
67
3
The Comedy-of-Marriage Film In many respects marriage, housework and the domestic realm is the quintessential subject of the 1950s; a decade widely understood as the ‘golden age of marriage’ where the image of the ‘wife and mother’ (the post-war icon of femininity) embedded itself in the popular consciousness.1 The work by revisionist historians such as Claire Langhamer and Lesley Hall (discussed in the main Introduction) has done much to challenge this formation, but in mass cultural forms such as popular film there is scope for a broader consideration of how the gender roles within heterosexual marriage were configured. Whilst the subject of the housewife and mother was manifest in the genre of social-realism (Mandy, 1952, and Woman in a Dressing Gown, 1957, are the two best-known examples, thoughtfully discussed by Annette Kuhn and John Hill, respectively)2, popular comedy as a genre is particularly fruitful for analysis as it readily allows for dissent, chaos and unordered worlds, where forms of normality are inverted and social tensions can find a freer expression than in other modes. Divided into three parts, this chapter opens with a discussion of social context and how ideas about ‘companionship’ and ‘equal and different roles’ increasingly shaped marriage and gender relations in the period. An overview of British film comedy and the emergent cycle of the ‘comedy-of-marriage’ film sketches a map of how domestic cinema responded to these new forms of marriage and domestic life, at times drawing on genre conventions from screwball comedy and the trope of gender role reversal. Detailed critical analysis of three films, Raising a Riot (d. Wendy Toye 1955), To Dorothy a Son (d. Muriel Box 1954) and Young Wives’ Tale (d. Henry Cass 1951), explores the manner in which the domestic realm and relations between the heterosexual couple are imagined and the extent to which they can be interrogated, concluding that the women who shaped the creative direction of these films (Wendy Toye, Muriel Box and the scriptwriter Anne Burnaby) found comedy a genre conducive to an expression of sexual politics.
68
femininity in the frame
The Companionate Marriage and the Home Marriage, the family and motherhood were high on the social agenda in the post-war period after six years of conflict during which the phenomena of evacuation, working mothers and absent fathers were thought to have exacted a heavy toll on the fabric of society. Reconstructing ‘the family’ assumed national importance and it was in relation to the concept of ‘the family’ and ‘the home’ that debates crystallized concerning women and employment, the birth-rate and the role of the woman as housewife and mother. Numerous government commissions reported on issues that directly concerned the family: the 1942 Beveridge Report on the welfare state, the 1946 Curtis Committee on child welfare, the Royal Commission on Population (1945–49) and the Royal Commission on Marriage and Divorce (1951–55). In all of these, heterosexual marriage was the assumed, privileged mechanism through which the ‘legitimate’ nuclear family would prosper, and the ‘family home’ the appropriate location within which ‘family life could be re-established and safeguarded’.3 As commented on by a female Mass Observation panellist in 1942, ‘a happy home and family life is the bulwark of a Nation’, a view that encapsulated the template for post-war reconstruction.4 But the manner in which marriage was understood, certainly within sociological discourse, changed in the 1950s.5 The notion of ‘companionship’ in marriage, with equal and complementary roles taken by women and men, was an increasing and noticeable feature of gender relations in Britain. The Royal Commission on Population commented on ‘the wife’s role as companion to her husband as well as a producer of children’.6 Likewise the Beveridge Report, which was predicated on the idea that the ‘breadwinner-husband’ and ‘house-wife’ worked together as a team towards a common goal of raising children. Notions of men and women as companions or partners engaged in ‘team-work’ shaped ideas about marriage which, Elizabeth Wilson argues, ‘aspired to a democratic ideal’ in the post-war years and beyond.7 These ideas were not only confined to official prescriptions but also emerged in mass media publications including advice literature, magazines and popular fiction. Janet Winship demonstrates how the discourse of the companionate marriage was evident in women’s magazines of the 1950s with the ‘Tackle it together’ column on home improvements a regular and popular feature in Woman magazine, the contemporary woman’s trade paper.8 The notion of marriage as a partnership was central to popular romantic fiction where a ‘respect [for] one another’s
the comedy-of-marriage film
69
gifts and talents … [shaped] the idealized marriage of the hero and heroine’.9 Innumerable ‘how-to’ manuals were produced in the 1950s which instructed men and women in the practicalities of modern marriage and childcare. Mary Macaulay’s popular The Art of Marriage (1952, reprinted 1957) advocated ‘harmony of body, mind and spirit’ in the achievement of the ‘modern democratic marriage’.10 Dr John Gibbens’ popular childcare manual The Care of Young Babies advocated that the couple ‘think of the child as a joint project’, whilst marriage manuals discussed sexual pleasure within marriage and how men might sexually educate their wives,11 assuming, as did most commentators, that men and women’s sexual needs were different and divided along an active/passive axis. Such matters concerned the National Marriage Guidance Council, which in the 1950s (relative to its inception in 1938) experienced a particularly rapid growth in the number of its trained counsellors. The Council’s remit was to assist couples towards achieving a happy marriage where both partners were fulfilled sexually and emotionally.12 Despite a rise in the number of divorce cases in the immediate post-war years as couples sought to dissolve imprudent wartime marriages, marriage remained popular in Britain, with an increase in the number of people getting married and a reduction in age at first marriage.13 Irrespective of the reality that men and women in Britain through their actions broadly supported the institution of marriage, the amount of critical commentary the subject attracted suggests how certain anxieties and uncertainties about gender relations and roles were shaping the social fabric. Within the companionate marriage, men and women had separate and clearly defined roles. Gender relations at this time had settled into a framework of equal but different. As Summerfield indicates, the companionate marriage was widely thought to be based on equality, but an equality that was shaped by the ‘language of difference’.14 For Wilson the characteristic that defined the late 1940s onwards was recognition of ‘the sexual division of labour and the value of women’s “equal but different” role’.15 Men and women thus presided over separate spheres and possessed separate yet complementary skills and qualities. Each was considered an expert in their own field and for women this field was childcare and housework. It was widely acknowledged, of course, that many women did work outside the home, but paid employment for most women was imagined as secondary to the role of housewife and mother. It was commonplace at this time to think of ‘homemaking as a career’ for all women irrespective of their class background, but one of the biggest obstacles to the woman’s successful undertaking of
70
femininity in the frame
the housewife’s role was ‘drudgery’.16 Beveridge commented in 1948 that the job faced by the housewife with a large family was ‘frankly impossible’,17 and a number of state interventions were proposed. Policy-makers and social commentators believed the housewife would be supported through the new National Health Service and family allowances, whilst domestic drudgery would be removed by the extension of modern working practices into the home, and through direct home improvements in the shape of modern kitchens replete with new ‘labour-saving’ devices such as washing-machines and vacuum cleaners – items which were enviably present in Hollywood films at this time. The difficulty facing the modern housewife was widely and sympathetically recognized because the burden borne by the middleclass wife had increased sharply by this time. Numbers in residential domestic service declined rapidly in the post-war period, from two million in 1931 to 750,000 in 195118 and the middle-class housewife was faced with running the home with no residential help, or at best occasional support from ‘a daily’.19 The removal of drudgery (however achieved) was therefore a necessity in the dignifying of housewifery as a ‘career’ which could be deemed suitable for all women, but most particularly the middle classes, and which would permit them to enjoy ‘the more stimulating and rewarding aspects of childcare and the beautification of the home’.20 The distinction drawn between ‘creative homemaking’ and ‘the rough of household maintenance’ was one of the strategies through which the middle-class housewife attempted to maintain a hierarchical class division.21 Household appliances in particular were held up as the housewives’ saviour because of the commonly held belief that they required little effort to operate, perpetuating, as Wilson argues, ‘the myth … that housework hardly was housework anymore’.22 Winship illustrates how magazine advertising for domestic appliances at this time reiterated the common motif that ‘commodities … work by themselves’. This was an advertising fallacy that effectively concealed all traces of ‘the real labour … [still] performed by women’ in their utilization of those commodities.23 In addition to the removal of drudgery through household appliances, the extension of management practices from industry into the home assumed that housework could be made less onerous through better organization and planning, which would allow it to be managed in a ‘scientific’ manner. New products and household goods such as washing-up bowls and bed mattresses appeared made of new man-made materials like plastics and latex foam that allowed the
the comedy-of-marriage film
71
home to be run in new and efficient ways.24 In the ‘modern’ home, dustcollecting door panels were to be covered with hardboard, picture rails removed and sliding frameless windows installed, all with the intention of creating a continuous, smooth surface and an open space devoid of clutter.25 These ideas were enthusiastically taken up by advertisers and promoted in women’s magazines and the burgeoning ‘Do-It-Yourself ’ manuals. Features in Picture Post (March 1950), for example, focused on the mechanization of the domestic environment where the ‘modern streamlined and highly-equipped home’ ushered in the ‘coming of ease and efficiency to the kitchen’, with ‘work processes’ organized in such a way that household management could be undertaken by the housewife with maximum efficiency, and the home would be ‘liberated from drudgery’.26 Despite such utopian promises, more immediate and pressing concerns had to be addressed before women and men could take up their roles within the companionate marriage. During the war, a halt of the country’s slum clearance and building programme was compounded by the Blitz which left Britain desperately short of suitable accommodation. The immediate post-war rise in the birthrate and the increase in the numbers of young married couples with children placed additional pressures on a system already stretched to breaking point, which in turn led to what Langhamer terms ‘an intensified romance with home life’27 which the country was clearly struggling to meet. The large number of young couples who through necessity started married life living with their parents was at odds with the increasing value placed on ‘domestic privacy’ – a trend which had begun before the war and intensified in the post-war period.28 Ernest Bevin’s rash promise of ‘Five million homes in quick time’ proved to be a popular vote winner and helped sweep the Labour Party to victory in 1945.29 It’s clear that housing, home-making, marriage, the family and women’s roles were shaped by complex – and at times contradictory – inter-locking discourses that found expression in particular ways in both official publications and the mass media. British Film Comedy How did popular cinema respond to the rebuilding of family life and to changes in how heterosexual marriage was imagined at this time? Certainly the issue of ‘parenting’ assumed prominence in the cinema of the decade, with the adult–child relationship returned to repeatedly
72
femininity in the frame
by film-makers operating in a broadly realist vein. This ranged from troublesome adolescents and the newly emerging teenager in films at both ends of the decade – I Believe in You (1952) and Beat Girl (1959) – to relations between preadolescent children in search of strong male ‘father-figures’ – Tiger Bay (1959), The Yellow Balloon (1952), Jacqueline (1956), Mandy (1952), The Spanish Gardener (1956). The nuclear family was likewise well represented in the popular ‘Hugget’ series, starting with Holiday Camp (1947), which dramatized the everyday exploits of a ‘respectable’ working-class family featuring Jack Warner as the benign patriarch. Some of the most interesting manifestations of the trials and tribulations of the heterosexual couple were to be found in the genre of comedy which, as Haywood has argued, functions as an ‘arena where repressed tensions can be released in a safe manner’.30 Comedy occupies a central place in debates about 1950s British cinema culture. Alongside the war genre it was consistently popular at the box office, with British viewers preferring the domestic product to the Hollywood variant.31 Within this wide-ranging genre, numerous sub-categories and popular ‘series’ emerged. The Boulting brothers’ forte was the satirical comedy which attacked British bureaucracy and institutional structures such as the army (Private’s Progress, 1956), education (Lucky Jim, 1957) and the legal profession (Brothers-in-Law, 1957), offering an increasingly cynical view of human nature and motivation.32 Ealing continued to mine its comic vein with The Lavender Hill Mob (1951) and The Ladykillers (1955), whilst Launder and Gilliat’s ‘St Trinian’s’ series (inaugurated by the success of The Happiest Days of Your Life, 1950) focused on the battle of the sexes. Service comedies in particular were popular during the decade, offering what Spicer aptly terms a ‘worm’s eye view’ of the war.33 Films such as Carry On Sergeant (1958, which inaugurated the popular ‘Carry On’ series) and Operation Bullshine (1959) inverted and mocked the ‘noble’ struggle and sacrifice of the officer middle class portrayed in war dramas such as The Dam Busters (1955), offering instead a carnivalesque view of the war from a typically working-class perspective.34 Consistently successful at the box office was the ‘Doctor’ series (1954 onwards) which followed the fortunes of four student doctors and combined topical themes (meritocracy, politics of consensus) with a handsome, youthful cast headed by Dirk Bogarde. Mainstays of British comedy in the 1950s were films that focused on ‘the couple’ and the experience of marriage, and which engaged, directly and selectively, with the new forms of marriage and domestic
the comedy-of-marriage film
73
life that were emerging in British society. The type of comedy film produced in the 1950s where ‘the couple’ provided the central narra tive drive differed markedly from earlier post-war romantic comedies such as Blithe Spirit (1945) and Miranda (1948), which combined a ‘fantasy’ theme (ghosts and mermaids respectively) with an upper middle class setting. In the 1950s this upper-class fantasy setting was replaced by a concern for ‘real’ everyday life and the ‘here and now’ of contemporary living, as experienced by a broader and more inclusive middle class. Pace Raymond Durgnant, who argued that ‘[m]arriage fatigue … is rarely a principal theme’,35 British cinema did respond to the subject of marriage and not always in ways that were blithely celebratory. The films in this loose cycle range from more traditional romantic comedies and the genre convention of ‘boy meets girl’ (Value for Money, 1955; An Alligator Named Daisy, 1955), to films that focus on the newly-wed couple and readjustment during the first year of married life (For Better, For Worse, 1954), to those such as Simon and Laura (1955) where the verbal sparring between a well-established married couple is reminiscent of classic Hollywood screwball comedy. Comedies that are centrally concerned with the couple have particular genre conventions and it is useful to sketch out some of those that relate most closely to the British films under discussion. Screwball comedy (of which Bringing Up Baby (1938) is the paradigmatic example) focuses on ‘a principal couple from differing backgrounds whose initial antagonism gradually turns into romantic love’ – a process typically achieved through the characters learning to change and modify their view.36 Their antagonism, and attraction, is typically expressed through witty dialogue, accidents and misadventures. As accidents often have a dual meaning – Freud argued that ‘falling, stumbling and slipping need not always be interpreted as purely accidental miscarriages of motor action’37 – they function in the comedy genre more broadly as symptoms of an unconscious desire for change, and in the couplecentred comedy specifically as symptomatic of ‘gender trouble’. In romantic comedy more generally, romance and marriage are shown as conflicting goals and for this reason the action culminates in a wedding rather than married life.38 Despite the dominant trope of heterosexual courtship, there is a significant sub-genre of ‘marriage comedies’ that focus on the estranged married couple who have become romantically ‘out-of-sync’, and whose marital relations need to be realigned. In what Stanley Cavell terms the comedy of remarriage, ‘the drive of the plot is not to get the central pair together, but to get them back together, together again’.39 Thus in films such as The Awful Truth (1937) and
74
femininity in the frame
Adam’s Rib (1949) the couple gradually reconnect with what originally attracted them to their spouse, and matrimonial harmony is restored. The ability of couples to change and understand their partner’s position can at times be achieved through adopting a form of role reversal; a standard narrative device for eliciting humour and entertainment. Often delivered through forms of incongruity and exaggeration, role reversal throws into sharp relief something considered everyday and ordinary, exploring it from a different perspective that allows new understandings to emerge. As a narrative device it is well suited to couple-centred comedies, and forms of role reversal are found, for example, in the ‘male transvestism’ that is central to key examples of the genre such as Bringing Up Baby40 and Some Like It Hot (1959). British Marriage Comedies Whilst these brief examples have been drawn from classical Hollywood cinema, the points raised about the conventions of genre (across screwball, romantic comedy and comedies of remarriage) have a strong bearing on the British comedy-of-marriage films which draw on – and at times modify – those conventions to meet the needs of a domestic cinema operating in a particular national context. It is noteworthy that these British comedies work outside the conventions of Hollywood romantic comedy by introducing children into the plot. In the Holly wood variant children are rare – the baby in Bringing Up Baby is a leopard, for example – whilst the British comedies, in affording children narrative space, are part of the decade’s broader concern with families and the adult–child relationship. The film most widely discussed in the context of the marriage comedy is the Rank production Genevieve (1953), whose significant commercial and critical success inaugurated the cycle. The film deals with two couples, one married, one not, where the men’s enthusiasm for the London to Brighton vintage car rally marginalizes the women who find the race, and their men, increasingly childish and boring. The work of the narrative is to realign these couples into a harmonious companionate relationship. Christine Geraghty, in her reading of Kay Kendall and the companionate marriage in British film comedy, argues that in Genevieve and Kendall’s later film The Constant Husband (1955) there is less equality and balance between the heterosexual couple than Schatz’s model, derived from Hollywood romantic comedy, permits. For Geraghty narrative resolution in Genevieve is achieved at the expense
the comedy-of-marriage film
75
of the women who have to make ‘the move into a more sympathetic position with their men’.41 Furthermore, the women suffer a range of humiliations during the car race (dishevelled hair, wet clothes) that are designed to puncture their ‘aloofness’42 and undermine further their position. For Geraghty, Genevieve is evidence of the wider tendency in British popular genres such as comedy to portray women as ‘childish, silly and vindictive or valorised and saintly’,43 a tendency which, as I discussed in the main Introduction, sheds light on the failure of domestic cinema to imagine in any positive way the new, ‘modern’ woman of the 1950s. Whilst there is much about Geraghty’s reading of Genevieve that is persuasive (although I question whether the mechanisms for narrative closure are sufficient to completely eradicate the style, independence and spirit of the women – especially Kendall’s character), what is less convincing is the extrapolation from this film to wider comments about film comedy and its portrayal of women. Taking other films into consideration and broadening the field of enquiry allows a more balanced picture to emerge. Spicer’s work on the middle-class boy-next-door (as a 1950s variant on the cultural type of ‘The Everyman’) suggests that other romantic and marriage comedies from the period (An Alligator Named Daisy; Twice Round the Daffodils, 1962, for example) ‘open[ed] up a space, albeit a highly controlled one, in which women were allowed to be sharply critical of male behaviour … [and] could also be the educator of the male’.44 In this chapter I will explore in some detail three comedies-ofmarriage that help to broaden our understanding of how British popular cinema engaged with, and responded to, the subject of marriage, gender relations and roles within marriage. Raising a Riot (1955) is a role reversal film where a husband takes over his wife’s role as housewife and mother to their three children. To Dorothy a Son (1954) is another form of role reversal where a husband assumes the domestic burden under the supervision of his heavily pregnant wife (a figure rarely found in British cinema at this time).45 The focus of Young Wives’ Tale (1951) is the disharmony and friction between two married couples, both with young children, who share a house due to the housing shortage. In all cases the couples have been married for some time and are therefore beyond the courtship and honeymoon phase of their relationships. As established married couples, comedy is derived from their evident failures to achieve marital harmony and a mocking of the conventions of heterosexual relations and normative gender roles. Each film places different emphasis on aspects of the companionate marriage: Riot focuses on the woman’s role within the
76
femininity in the frame
family whilst Dorothy raises questions about remarriage and divorce. Young Wives’ Tale is the most complex of the three in tackling a number of themes (remarriage, romance, gender roles, equality, the working mother) and for this reason I have allocated it considerable space in my discussion. Housework is important in these three films in a way that isn’t shown in Simon and Laura or Genevieve. In this respect the films speak to an earlier understanding of the domestic burden borne by the housewife, and the later recognition (through role reversal) that the burden still hasn’t been addressed and it remains an impossible one. All of the films are broadly concerned with the education of the male, and it is noteworthy that these are films where women had a direct impact in the production process. Raising a Riot was directed by Wendy Toye for British Lion and, as Harper and Porter have demonstrated, she took total artistic control of the film46 and endowed it with a wry treatment of the male figure which was the mark of her particular brand of feminism. To Dorothy a Son was directed by Muriel Box, whose more overt feminist sensibility is evident in this work, whilst Young Wives’ Tale, although directed by a man, Henry Cass, bears traces of its scriptwriter Anne Burnaby and her ironic stance on gender politics. Although this chapter doesn’t focus in detail on the question of authorship it seems likely that the marriage comedy genre proved a relatively hospitable space for female creative agency in popular cinema, not least because its focus on marriage and the domestic could more readily align with what could be thought of as women’s ‘natural’ instincts and interests. Certainly in classic Hollywood cinema Babington and Evans find that the genre of romantic comedy was strongly ‘female-influenced’ through women’s work as scriptwriters, novelists whose work was adapted, and scenarists, leading them to conclude that the ‘innate demands’ of the couple-centred comedy ‘are the projections of a desire to enforce a respect for the feminine’.47 British cinema’s female-influenced marriage comedies likewise demonstrate a strong desire that the feminine be recognized and respected. Raising a Riot In Raising a Riot (1955) middle-aged, middle-class Tony (Kenneth More) returns from the navy to civilian life where he assumes full domestic responsibility for the couple’s three children whilst his wife travels abroad to look after her sick mother. He decamps with the children (and assorted animals) to his father’s home, a dilapidated
the comedy-of-marriage film
77
windmill in the countryside, where he attempts to recreate family life. The demands of everyday domestic routine such as cleaning and cooking and the entertaining, schooling and disciplining of the children quickly dominate his life. He is soon forced to abandon his aspirations as a writer as the role of mother and housewife consumes all of his time, and he gratefully welcomes the return of his wife, having come to understand and appreciate the role that woman are required to undertake. The film is topical in both placing the young family within the home of the older generation, which entails a loss of domestic privacy, and in dealing with a returning serviceman who clearly knows little about his children and has to rebuild relationships and regain their trust and a place in their affections. In this respect it is consistent with many other British films from the period that dramatize the reconstruction of the post-war family through the theme of parenting and the male father-figure. What marks it as different is the male’s complete appropriation of the female role. The central concern of the film in terms of gender politics is neither romance nor companionship between the heterosexual couple, but coming to an understanding of the woman’s role within the family. Although the wife is absent for most of the film she is omnipresent through the narrative’s focus on the domestic realm. Through this inversion of gender roles, comedy is derived from the seemingly incongruous image of the man struggling to fulfil the ‘natural’ female role. Landy argues that ‘[b]y means of the role reversal, the film defamiliarizes and lends a certain drama to the everyday tasks associated with women’s work in the home’.48 The familiar, everyday and therefore invisible work of the housewife is thrown into sharp relief when the male experiences this environment as alien and fraught with difficulty. As Lloyd and Johnson demonstrate in their study of the post-war housewife in Hollywood films, it is precisely because domestic labour is ‘invisible to the economy and culture’ that it is only documented on film when it is ‘aberrant, unusual or strange’.49 This process of defamiliarization is complemented by the casting of Kenneth More in the lead role. Coming after his recent successes in Genevieve and Doctor in the House (1954), More’s persona was associated with a confident middle-class masculinity described by Films and Filming in 1955 as ‘a symbol of everything we like to think of as English’50 and by Picturegoer in 1956 as ‘a contemporary actor who reflects the mood of today’.51 More is seen as representative of the nation by embodying normative rather than deviant masculinity and the humour derives, in part, from such a masculine persona taking up
78
femininity in the frame
an ‘aberrant’ feminine role. Part of the challenge faced by Toye’s film is to soften this persona and to inculcate in it a respect for the feminine.52 That the film received positive notices in the press and enjoyed popular success at the box office suggests that it succeeded in creating an address that was palatable to audiences.53 For Monthly Film Bulletin it was an ‘unpretentious film [which] contains a good deal of simple charm and affectionate humour’, whilst Kinematograph Weekly’s classification of it as a ‘woman’s film, as well as a certain rib-tickler’ suggests an appeal to both sexes.54 The setting plays an important part in Tony’s acquisition of the feminine domestic role. The windmill is dilapidated and only partly converted into a barely habitable living space. The living-room is dominated by a range, despairingly described by Tony as ‘a classic example of early Victorian domestic engineering’, whilst the kitchen is basic in the extreme, comprising a sink, table and stove. There is no hot water as the boiler has yet to be fitted, the loo is outside and the bathroom, as the father acerbically comments, is ‘well, a room with a bath in it’. The living space is as far removed as possible from the ‘modern efficient home’ replete with modern appliances that had been heralded as the housewife’s saviour by everyone from Beveridge to the appliance advertisers. As for most middle-class families in the 1950s, the task Tony faces of bringing up the children is compounded by the absence of servants. Tony is horrified to learn that not even ‘comers-in’ will venture to the windmill and his blithe comment that he can cook ‘in an emergency’ is punctured by his father’s blunt statement that ‘it’s all an emergency if you’re stopping here’. His time is thus occupied with domestic drudgery rather than being freed up to concentrate on the more stimulating and rewarding aspects of childcare and home beautification which I argued in the introduction were deemed a necessary component to dignifying housewifery as a career for the middle classes. Tony’s situation is that of the ‘ordinary’ housewife faced with childcare, housework and homemaking with little or no support. The father provides no help with the day-to-day running of the home and the children, instead occupying himself with house renovations such as tiling; activities consistent with ‘gendered discourses of appropriateness’ that shaped male work in the home during this period.55 In his constant badgering of Tony to prepare meals and meet his idiosyncratic demands for ‘three slices of toast … crisp!’ he assumes the role of the demanding husband, expecting his needs for food to be met without a thought to how meals are arrived at. Tony quickly
the comedy-of-marriage film
79
learns that the dishes remain unwashed and the potato peelings stay in the sink until he removes them. In the face of these unremitting demands on his time his attempts at writing are constantly thwarted, and throughout the film creative work is shown to be incompatible with domesticity. The narrative is organized around a number of episodes that detail the different and mundane aspects of childcare and housekeeping. Tony shops, cooks a meal, washes clothes, supervises teeth and hair-brushing at bedtime and entertains, disciplines and consoles the children. His initial approach is to blithely proclaim that housekeeping is ‘only a matter of organization’; an approach which resonates with post-war discourses that extended management practices into the home. Any sort of implicit criticism that the woman is incompetent in her approach to household management is rapidly dismissed as Tony struggles to succeed. His initial optimism is soon tempered by a more pragmatic approach which realizes the advantage of tinned food and quickly learns to dispense with the unnecessary tedium of washing each individual spinach leaf before cooking. His utopian vision of four cooked meals a day (and snacks in between) is modified (at the suggestion of a neighbour’s daughter, Sue) in favour of sandwiches and a fishing trip, consistent with the idea that children are more than work and should be enjoyed. Despite such necessary corner-cutting he soon becomes demoralized (‘I’m sick to death of grazed knees … and elevenses’) and he finds himself unable to approach any one task in a linear ordered manner. The fishing trip ends in disaster when the youngest child falls in the water, whilst a child tipping paint over herself interrupts his cooking, which results in a burnt meal. His response to the ruined food mirrors that commonly associated with the woman; he resorts to ‘feminine’ sulks, bad-temper and exasperation, much to the amusement of his father and eldest son. Whilst humour is clearly derived from the sight of the male acquiring feminine characteristics, the point is made that these are not natural, innate characteristics but are arrived at through circumstance, social practices and conditioning. Tony’s response to the burgeoning domestic chaos is an attempt to control it through imposing ‘naval discipline’; a masculinist project predicated on rationalist order. The children are frog-marched back to the home, given specific tasks to complete and then turned out for parade inspection, but this ‘marvellous system of inducing discipline’ (in the words of his neighbour’s daughter Sue) is completely undermined by the children’s riotous commando raid on a neighbour’s house. The depiction of his struggles is not an attempt to show that
80
femininity in the frame
men are unequal to the task of domesticity, and indeed at one point his daughter confides to him that ‘Mummy used to have catastrophes’. The point is not to demonstrate that the man is better or worse than the woman but that the job is a hard one and competence in it is only acquired through exposure and trial and error. Part of Tony’s appreciation of the female role is acquired not only through the performance of domestic tasks but via his own feminization through clothing. His initial appearance in the off-duty naval officer’s ‘uniform’ of shirt, tie and double-breasted jacket is quickly replaced by a variety of colourful open-necked shirts and loose slacks, more in keeping with the less rigid environment of the windmill. Upon his arrival at the windmill he quickly dons an apron, visual shorthand for domesticity and feminization, but at this stage the garment worn is plain white and secured at waist level, and therefore still has some resonance with ‘the masculine’ (the professional garb of the chef or the grocer perhaps). But the process of feminization through clothing gathers pace as Tony becomes more embroiled in the domestic role. Hanging out washing he wears his apron whilst pegging out a child’s sprigged calico pinny. The tight framing and shot composition gives the appearance of him wearing a dress and to his chagrin he’s confronted by Sue (young and sexually available), his appearance eliciting her comment ‘the maid was in the garden hanging out the clothes’; a statement which both feminizes and infantilizes Tony through its association with nursery rhyme. It is after his failed attempt to run the house along strict naval lines that his feminization is completed. The white apron has been discarded in favour of a full-length pinny in lavender blue, with detail on the bust and matching frill trim, worn over a pink-checked shirt. It is at this point he admits the defeat of his masculinist project and demobilizes the (children’s) navy. Babington and Evans have suggested that male transvestism is part of the ‘educative process of feminization … [and the] absorption of aspects of [female] identity’,56 and clothing is clearly being used here in the transformation of character. Tony’s gradual metamorphosis from jacket to pinny-wearing is not only a device for humour but part of the process by which he comes to respect the feminine. This is encapsulated in the film’s final scene where he openly acknowledges to his wife the complex and contradictory demands of the woman’s role: ‘You know what a woman has to be? A cross between a saint and a drayhorse, a diplomat and an automatic washing machine, a psychiatrist and a bulldozer, a sanitary engineer and a mannequin.’ The film is, in the end, a liberal text that calls for greater understanding by
the comedy-of-marriage film
81
7. Kenneth More in Raising a Riot (1955)
men of the difficulty of the female/domestic role. It does not advocate for radical change to the gendered status quo through a more equitable distribution of domestic roles and responsibility, but contents itself with a demonstration of the domestic role within marriage as complex and demanding. The film ends with the wife’s resumption of the household reins whilst the husband returns to naval work; thus a sexual division of labour is accepted. Although consistent with a discourse of equal but different that was shaping normative understandings of gender relations, implicit in the comedy is a modifying of the male views and a clear sense of bringing them into line with the female perspective. To Dorothy a Son To Dorothy a Son (1954) offers a different take on the role reversal comedy. Directed by Muriel Box, the film was independently financed by Muriel’s husband Sidney, but unfortunately its status as an ‘independent’ led to it being denied a West End premiere by
82
femininity in the frame
distributors57 which in turn hampered its chances of commercial success. Muriel was one of the few female film directors in British cinema at this time and her feminist sensibility, constantly a thorn in the side of mainstream, male-dominated domestic film production, is evident in this film. The narrative centres on the claustrophobic and chaotic domestic scene experienced by young married couple Tony (John Gregson) and Dorothy (Peggy Cummins), who is heavily pregnant. Confined to her bed, Dorothy makes innumerable domestic demands on her increasingly frustrated husband, a composer who works from home and is desperately trying to meet a deadline and earn sufficient money to pay the bailiffs. Tony’s flamboyant American ex-wife Myrtle (Shelley Winters) reappears, bearing news that she will inherit her Uncle’s $2 million fortune if, by a given date and time, her former husband has not yet produced a son. Myrtle’s appearance intensifies the domestic chaos as she tries to seduce Tony, whilst Tony’s (erroneous) realization that they were never properly divorced pushes to breaking point his already difficult marriage to Dorothy. Ultimately a form of harmony is restored when Dorothy gives birth to twins, a girl and then a boy, and the three adults agree to share the inheritance. With its central focus on a couple who are out-of-sync and whose marital relations need to be realigned, the film borrows conventions typically associated with romantic comedy through the couple’s progression from what Schatz terms ‘romantic antagonism to eventual embrace’.58 The focus on the dynamic of the already married couple ensures that the narrative drive is, in Cavell’s terms, to get the central pair ‘back together, together again’ through their remembering and recapturing of what it is that they originally loved about their spouse; a quality that has been temporarily lost. In Dorothy the central couple squabble but at times are reminded of their mutual love. In one scene Dorothy dissolves into tears and proclaims, ‘I don’t want the baby, I hate babies’. Tony makes her laugh and the scene ends with them working together to revise one of his musical scores, suggesting that their marriage is grounded in a companionship which, although threatened, has the potential to be recovered. Although the film doesn’t engage in a sophisticated debate about the nature of marriage, as in classics of the genre such as Adam’s Rib,59 it does engage with debates about marriage and specifically divorce that were topical to 1950s Britain. Comic tension is added to the film by confusion over which woman Tony is actually married to, and therefore uncertainty about which one he should realign himself with. It transpires that an error with paperwork has invalidated his divorce from Myrtle, which
the comedy-of-marriage film
83
was undertaken in Bolivia. This positions him in a bigamist marriage with Dorothy and raises the spectre that the couple’s child will be illegitimate. Tony is unable to divorce Myrtle because, in accordance with English law, ‘there aren’t any grounds’ and his only hope is to persuade Myrtle to divorce him for the sake of the child. At this time, divorce by mutual consent on the basis of an irretrievable breakdown of marriage was not possible in England although supporters of divorce reform advocated on behalf of couples in committed relationships who couldn’t remarry because one of them was still locked into a ‘dead marriage’.60 A figure that dominated the social landscape of the 1950s therefore was the ‘illegal wife’, the woman who changed her name by deed poll to cohabit with a man in a respectable manner,61 and Dorothy finds herself inadvertently in this situation. The film thus dramatizes in a comedic manner various law-breaking activities such as bigamy and sex and pregnancy outside marriage, which were topical subjects in the 1950s and would have resonated with audiences. The situation is ultimately resolved by Tony’s marriage to Myrtle in Tonga (‘one of the friendly islands … it sure was friendly’) eventually being proven as invalid, but for Dorothy and Tony the prospect of losing the other – Tony to Myrtle, and Dorothy to her huffily reclaimed single status (‘you may call me Miss Hetherington!’) – is both the cause of marital strife and the means by which the couple’s mutual love and affection is re-ignited. Tony, like his namesake in Raising a Riot, assumes the role of the woman within the family setting by acting as parent (mother) to his bed-ridden wife whilst undertaking all aspects of domestic work and home-making. The film’s opening shot depicts a country cottage complete with white picket fence and ducks waddling serenely down the lane, but this rural idyll is quickly shown to be a myth and the opening functions as an ironic comment on contemporary married life. Inside the cottage the domestic space is shown to be a mess with washing hanging from an indoor line and the room littered with a random assortment of papers and piles of books. The advertisers dream of the modern, efficient and streamlined home is again replaced by a ‘realistic’ chaotic living space and the drudgery of routine tasks. The action is primarily confined to the domestic setting, principally the living-room and bedroom where Dorothy lies marooned in bed. The setting is, in common with other comedies of remarriage, ‘emphatically at home at home’62 and provides a prolonged look at intimate and usually private domestic settings such as the bedroom.
84
femininity in the frame
8. John Gregson consoles Peggy Cummins in To Dorothy a Son (1954)
Tony’s experience of this space is deeply problematic; he bumps his head on the low beams, trips over his wife’s suitcases and searches hopelessly for a ringing telephone lost in a pile of newspapers. His repeated stumbling and falling about the domestic terrain is symptomatic of the impending gender trouble. Once again the man takes the role of the ‘ordinary housewife’ running the family home without any form of domestic help, but there is no attempt to impose a rationalist project of order and discipline on proceedings or even particularly to show him failing or succeeding at domestic tasks. A beleaguered Tony merely survives, responding to dramas as they arise. His wife’s demands for tea, toast, her novel and an explanation as to why he divorced his first wife, as well as visits by the district nurse must be accommodated, whilst the demands of the bank manager are held at bay with fanciful explanations of an imminent salary deposit. He is shown to have readily absorbed aspects of female identity. Dorothy’s bed-bound status positions Tony as a mother caring for a sick child, whilst the arrival on the scene of Myrtle brings tears and tantrums from Dorothy which requires Tony to soothe her like a difficult child. In a manner similar to Raising a Riot and the comedy of role reversal, the male undertaking of mundane domestic activity ‘defamiliarizes’ that
the comedy-of-marriage film
85
activity and makes the invisible work of the housewife visible. In one extended scene Tony attempts to iron socks, pushes the vacuum-cleaner around the living-room in a desultory manner and flicks a feather duster at the ornaments. Domestic activity is augmented once again by the use of clothing in the process of feminizing the male character. The obligatory frilly pinny is worn whilst ironing and vacuuming, and absent-mindedly holding the feather duster close to his face whilst talking on the telephone softens Tony’s masculine features. Removing an array of his wife’s frilly, feminine nighties from the internal washingline provides a further opportunity for male transvestism. One nightie gets caught on his head, its lace framing his face whilst Myrtle, holding up another in front of him, creates the overall impression of Tony as a bride, decked out in full wedding gown regalia. It is less the case here that through clothing the male character is transformed and educated about the feminine (as in Riot where the male is shown to have something to learn); rather it is deployed here as a standard humorous device intended to portray Tony as an already feminized male and the quintessential ‘hen-pecked’ husband (the scenes occur in the first half of the film).63 Even when the character assumes a more typically ‘masculine’ role – the expectant father-to-be, the object of Myrtle’s romantic affections – his masculinity is marked by nervousness and anxiety. Myrtle’s voluptuousness frightens him whilst Dorothy’s (false) labour sends him into a blind panic. Casting is important here, with Gregson’s solid and dependable persona marking him out as an ‘Everyman’ type: ordinary, stoical, capable.64 On the one hand Gregson’s unassuming persona engenders a degree of malleability that makes him receptive to feminine qualities, whilst his Everyman status can be used to suggest a degree of dissatisfaction with the mainstream male. This sense of frustration with contemporary gender roles is compounded when we consider how the women are portrayed. Dorothy and Myrtle represent opposite ends of a spectrum of femininity; the seemingly doting wife tied to domesticity, and the sex object who earns her living as a show-girl. Dorothy is, in her husband’s words, ‘warm, clinging, cuddlesome and sweet’, her alignment with woman’s maternal and domestic role represented by her confinement both physically and psychologically to the family home and the bedroom. She is played by Peggy Cummins, whose ingénue characteristics were often enlivened by a degree of insolence and sensuality, and which are put to good effect in this film where her sweetness is balanced by a short temper, biting tongue and demanding nature. She is thus convincing both as the ‘virtuous … homemaker’
86
femininity in the frame
of Harper’s description65 and as an equal combatant to her American competitor. In contrast Myrtle is loud, brassy and pneumatic. Introduced performing at an audition where she lustily sings, ‘Give me a man, any kind of a man’, the character is the embodiment of narrative trouble. Strongly Americanized (within a British context) she signifies overt sexuality, consumption and material excess. Whilst Dorothy’s pregnant figure is hidden under bedclothes, Myrtle’s is displayed via a number of tight-fitting outfits which emphasize her voluptuous hourglass figure. UK passport control categorize her visit to the country as one of ‘pleasure’, and upon learning of her inheritance she immediately purchases two mink coats (‘I’ll have one of each … the light one and the dark one’) which come to parallel Dorothy’s two babies. Each woman embodies an extreme of femininity – sex object/wife and mother – cultural types which, in the hands of Muriel Box, are deployed in an ironic and knowing manner. The failure to reconcile these two aspects of womanhood (positioned here as contradictory) into one figure suggests, as Geraghty has argued,66 the difficulty in holding together in any prolonged or coherent manner the different discourses that made up the ‘New Woman’ of the 1950s. But these extremes can also be read as Muriel Box’s feminist commentary on the poverty of contemporary gender relations and their cultural constructions within the mainstream popular media, where female identity was too readily imagined within a Madonna/whore dichotomy and normative hetero-femininity assumed priority. Muriel Box’s diaries record her frustration that the misogynist aspects of Peter Roger’s script for Dorothy (‘men were made to wear the pants and pants were made to carry the dough’) were widely endorsed by male laughter at screening previews.67 Dorothy’s description of the jacket cover of her missing crime novel – ‘it has a woman lying across a bed with a dagger sticking in her bosom’ – encapsulates the film’s dual image of womanhood, the bed-bound Dorothy and the pneumatic Myrtle, and suggests that within this film-maker’s mind at least was the desire to kill off both kinds of woman. The narrative culminates in the safe delivery of Dorothy’s babies and the equitable distribution of the inheritance, bringing to an end the inversion of gender roles. The reconciliation of the estranged couple and the banishment of narrative trouble in the form of Myrtle ensures Dorothy can assume her proper role as wife and mother, whilst the money means that Tony need no longer work from home. The tribulations of law-breaking (vis-à-vis personal relationships), feminized males and the acerbic critique of roles for women suggests that, in Box’s film at least, there is not so much a respect for the feminine
the comedy-of-marriage film
87
but a frustration with contemporary gender roles. In Young Wives’ Tale the consequence and difficulty of living in accordance with dominant cultural norms of femininity is further exposed and interrogated. Young Wives’ Tale Young Wives’ Tale (1951) is adapted from a successful West End play and is, of the three films discussed in this chapter, the most thorough and complex in its interrogation of marriage and gender roles. The film’s producer, Victor Skutezky, produced a number of films in the 1950s that incorporated a degree of gender radicalism relative to the mainstream (The Weak and the Wicked is one other example, discussed in Chapter Four), and he frequently employed the scriptwriter Anne Burnaby, whose approach to gender relations harmonized with Skutezky’s outlook. Burnaby had a reputation as an excellent writer and was remembered by the director J. Lee Thompson as sexually ambiguous,68 with the capacity to take an outsider’s view of mainstream culture. Whilst it is tempting to attribute the film’s protofeminist stance to its female scriptwriter, caution must be exercised as Burnaby’s adaptation is very close to the original screenplay, written by the playwright Ronald Jeans. However, it may be the case that Burnaby, who had a reputation for defending her professional opinion, negotiated sufficient creative space to retain in her script those elements of the play that were most challenging in relation to gender (the wry radio voiceover that closes the film, the extended exchanges between the husbands and wives where gender roles within marriage are debated). Certainly the production company, Associated British Picture Corporation (ABPC), was renowned for prioritizing screenplay over all other aspects of production,69 and the relative lack of visual style in relation to camera-work both betrays the theatrical origins of Young Wives’ Tale and affords the script a dominant discursive position. This provides some suggestive evidence for attributing an element of creative agency to Anne Burnaby. Young Wives’ Tale centres on two middle-class couples, each with a small child, who share a house due to the post-war housing shortage: Rodney and Sabina Pennant (Nigel Patrick and Joan Greenwood) and Mary and Bruce Banning (Helen Cherry and Derek Farr). Mary and Sabina represent differing versions of femininity. Mary is an organized and efficient career woman whilst Sabina is a chaotic, hopeless housewife. Both husbands are frustrated with the personalities of their
88
femininity in the frame
respective wives and wish the wives would change. Bruce thinks of Mary as a ‘cold-blooded fish’ who should stay at home with their child, whilst Rodney wishes Sabina would concentrate harder to improve her domestic skills. Their homes, and by extension their marriages, are chaotic and difficult: the children cry, cooking is piecemeal, the couples argue and domestic help is troublesome. Disruption occurs when the couples’ bickering results in the nanny giving notice and the couples briefly swap partners – a narrative device intended to arouse sexual jealousy and competition. Equilibrium is tentatively restored when the couples are reconciled, but the film ends with a return to domestic chaos as the children flood the house and the neighbour’s dog steals the Sunday roast. The couples’ status as well-established partners with young children indicates that the honeymoon stages of their relationships are over and the film focuses on their struggle with the mundane demands of domesticity and spousal familiarity. In a manner comparable with To Dorothy a Son, the couples are ‘out of step’ and need to get ‘back together, together again’, making the required move from antagonism to embrace and in the process accepting change. These conventions of genre are shaped by two topical social concerns: the post-war housing shortage which placed affordable housing at a premium, and the lack of servants. Rodney and Sabina are dependent on the generosity of their friends and are struggling to ‘make do’ with only one room to call their own whilst they share the remaining domestic space with the Banning family, the live-in nanny and a third lodger, Eve (played by Audrey Hepburn in an early film role). Rodney’s statement of ‘you call this living, it’s impossible’ would have resonated with audiences experiencing post-war austerity and similar cramped living conditions.70 In addition to the housing problem, the two couples struggle to run the home with erratic domestic support and in this respect dramatize what was the common experience of middle-class families in the 1950s. Tangential to my main argument about the married couples but interesting nevertheless, the nanny employed to look after Mary’s child71 occupies an ambivalent position in the household. On the one hand she is portrayed as holding a position of supreme power over her employers, who are forced to treat her solicitously for fear of losing her. The wives in particular are deferential as they (especially Mary) have the most to lose, with the burden of childcare defaulting to them if she leaves. Conversely the couples also resent the dependency and loss of freedom that accompanies live-in, paid help. Arguments, disagreements and misunderstandings over the behaviour of both the
the comedy-of-marriage film
89
children and the adults culminate in one nanny being harangued as a ‘shapeless, snooping, sanctimonious old bag’ whilst another is criticized for having ‘a very peculiar face’. Whilst the comic mode provides a legitimate space for trading insults there is an underlying viciousness to these expressions that suggests middle-class anxiety and simmering resentment about their ‘dependency’ on paid help where the balance of power has – to their mind – finally shifted in favour of the supplier. Dramatic interest is predicated on doubling between the two female characters whose representation is based on a dualism between the emotional artist and the rational scientist. Sabina was an actress who gave up her career to take up the role of housewife and mother. Her scatty and melodramatic personality is represented by a performance style based on exaggerated and expressive gestures, a ‘flamboyance’ which is mirrored in her erratic approach to housekeeping. Overly demonstrative and romantic, she enjoys male attention, stimulates her husband’s jealousy and picks fights with him to inject some ‘high drama’ into their mundane (i.e. ordinary) married life. Typically dressed in the outfit of the ‘harassed housewife’, that is, a random assortment of prosaic blouses and cardigans, supplemented by a teatowel draped casually over one shoulder, she appears on occasion in glamorous evening gowns which establish her overtly feminine nature. The characterization is enhanced by the casting of Joan Greenwood, whose seductive persona in comic roles was established by her ‘Sibella’ in Kind Hearts and Coronets (1949). Her husband Rodney frequently and loudly expresses his dissatisfaction with his wife’s home-management skills which he characterizes as inefficient and disorganized and which he attributes to his wife’s ‘fluffy mind.’ In contrast, Mary works outside the home holding a senior position in a chemical laboratory; a post she prefers to that of fulltime mother. She is both literally and figuratively a scientist. Played by Helen Cherry, an actress commonly described as ‘serene’,72 this quality of stillness consolidates Mary’s characterization. The epitome of the 1950s modern woman combining the ‘dual roles’ of career and motherhood, her efficient and controlled nature is signalled by her neat-fitting tailored suits, her refusal to be emotionally demonstrative and the lack of variety in her bodily movements, which are always purposeful and direct. She displays no interest in arguing with her husband, preferring instead rational discussion, and she is both amused and frustrated by Sabina’s tears and tantrums. Mary’s appropriation of attributes commonly associated with masculinity – emotional restraint, non-maternal nature, rationality – is highly challenging both
90
femininity in the frame
to her husband and to ideals of ‘feminine’ femininity. An infuriated Bruce disparagingly describes her as ‘the perfect machine at work’ and instead desires a ‘hearty buxom wife’, a stay-at-home mother to his six children ‘who’d adore me and the children’; an image Mary describes as ‘revolting’. For this reason he admires Sabina, whom he describes as a ‘thoroughly feminine wife’ and considers ‘courageous for taking on a job she hated’ – that of ‘real wife’ and mother. Bruce clearly wishes that Mary possessed Sabina’s emotional and demonstrative characteristics, whilst Rodney’s wishes Sabina had Mary’s organizational skills. Both couples are out of alignment and part of the work of the narrative is to effect a change. This is achieved by Sabina seducing Bruce, which provokes jealousy in their respective partners. Rodney learns to be more sympathetic towards Sabina and tolerate her domestic inadequacies, Sabina’s desire for high drama and romantic reconciliation is sated, and Bruce’s expectations of emotional femininity are satisfied by Mary’s tearful confession of feminine possessiveness towards her husband. In the process of moving towards this seemingly neat resolution necessary for narrative closure, marriage is debated and male hubris in relation to housework and the home is held up for ridicule. The women express opposing beliefs about the concept of marriage: Mary is pragmatic while Sabina is romantic, and both struggle to find equality within their marriages. Following a row with Rodney the women discuss their domestic situation. Sabina considers it ‘terribly important to keep the romantic side alive’ and gloomily questions whether ‘the romance in marriage can survive the sort of life we lead?’ Mary’s responses are typically pragmatic: ‘Personally I never deluded myself you could take romance into marriage. Wings are to fly with – not to walk with’, and suggests to Sabina that she should learn that ‘you can’t live forever on a diet of wedding cake’. The women’s views, although opposing, both express a similar concern over the difficulty of finding space within marriage for romance. Sabina creates it artificially through seduction and jealous intrigue, whilst Mary, for whatever reason, has no expectations of it. Notwithstanding these abstract ruminations about romance and marriage, the women are faced with more immediate and pressing concerns regarding housework and childcare. Rodney and Sabina’s marriage is predicated on the paradigm of different but equal; Rodney earns money as a writer, Sabina looks after the home and children. Rodney, who works from home, defends himself from Sabina’s accusations of his occasional shiftlessness, indignantly proclaiming, ‘I work every day’. Sabina challenges his belief that his role is equivalent to hers, exclaiming ‘Not like I do,
the comedy-of-marriage film
91
if you don’t feel like writing you don’t write, how would you feel if I said to you “there’s no dinner, I didn’t feel like cooking?”’ For Sabina at least, their roles in marriage are certainly different and are intended to be complementary, but they fall short in terms of equality. The housewife’s life of drudgery remains shaped by the demands of routine and mundane tasks – elements that Judy Giles terms ‘the rough of household maintenance’ – and the promise of the ‘attractive career’ of creative homemaking has yet to be delivered.73 In marriage Sabina feels she has drawn the short straw relative to her husband. Mary and Bruce’s marriage directly challenges the paradigm of different but equal through Mary’s ‘masculine’ character and her work outside the home. Narrative space is given over to Bruce’s open criticisms of Mary: ‘you might prefer looking after your own child to working in a chemical laboratory’. He chastises her for not immediately checking on their child after work, complaining that ‘she might be dead for all you know’. But space is equally provided for Mary to respond to his criticisms, and she reminds him of their pre-marriage agreement that he wouldn’t interfere with her career. Bruce’s implicit criticism of her as a negligent mother evokes the flippant response of ‘don’t be silly, nanny would have told me’. Whilst this confirms Bruce’s opinion of Mary as ‘unnatural’ the joke is not at her expense but his, used to highlight his ‘fussy’ and overly anxious nature. The film is not so radical as to suggest that the husband has an obligation for full-time childcare. It is accepted by all, including Mary, that responsibility for their child ultimately lies with Mary – who at one point agrees to give up her career if a suitable nanny cannot be found. But within this accepted framework the point is also made that the gendered division of labour favours men. Bruce’s judgement of his wife and some of his other expectations are shown to be unreasonable. Their conversation takes place in the living-room where Bruce is seated with the evening paper whilst Mary moves about the room, tidying away the detritus of children’s toys, lays the table for dinner and pours him a sherry. Her activities illustrate how women automatically assume their ‘natural’ role of wife and mother upon their return from paid work and demonstrate the gendered meanings of home: for men a space for leisure, for women a site of labour. The scene also points to the impossible and contradictory demands made of women by men; should she check on the child, pour her husband sherry or make preparations for dinner? Bruce’s position, comfortably ensconced in his favourite armchair whilst Mary works around him, undermines his argument and indicates his shortcomings within the marriage.
92
femininity in the frame
Similarly, Rodney’s assessment of his wife Sabina demonstrates a very particular and masculinist understanding of housework. Rodney sits typing at a table whilst Sabina is occupied with multiple tasks: bringing in washing from the garden, going upstairs to attend to their child and working at an ironing-board in the living-room. Sabina’s constant movement through the domestic space ‘interrupts’ Rodney’s creative work, leading him to explode ‘I can’t concentrate with you flitting in and out all the time!’ For Rodney, Sabina’s ‘flitting’ is evidence of a specifically female incompetence. He treats her with a mixture of exasperation and paternal indulgence, commenting to Bruce, ‘Dear Sabina, so delightfully incompetent, a really womanly woman. She can do it when she concentrates but she can’t, she’s always wishing she was doing something else, she has a fluffy mind.’ The concept of the ‘fluffy mind’ evokes what T. E. Perkins terms the ‘flighty woman’ stereotype; that is, a woman characterized by her ‘inability to concentrate … [and her] mental flightiness, scattiness’.74 For Rodney, Sabina’s bodily flitting and mental fluffiness are grounded in biology and her ‘womanly womanness’. Rodney advocates that she adopt a more linear approach to housework, concentrating on one task at a time and following it through to its logical conclusion to bring routine and order to the household; a distinctly ‘modern’ and 1950s approach to running the ‘efficient’ home. Mary articulates similar ‘masculinist’ views, commenting on Sabina’s ‘wasted energy’ in respect of housework and implicitly linking this to her excessively emotional nature. On the one hand Rodney wants Sabina to be more organized and efficient whilst on the other hand her (feminine) incompetence is to be both expected and welcomed as it affords him a position of superiority. Sabina’s mental flightiness is consistent with what Perkins describes as ‘a mode of thinking which is essential to the housewife’s job … [where] the capacity to keep shifting attention back and forth, and changing skills, is characteristic’.75 It is not the case that Sabina ‘flits’ (to use Rodney’s pejorative label) and fails to concentrate as defined within a rationalist discourse, but rather she responds (as Tony learns to do in Riot) to household tasks as they arise. The ironing is necessarily abandoned when the baby cries because children’s needs, not Woman’s, are irrational and unpredictable. Rodney’s misreading of Sabina’s actions as ‘flightiness’ and his position of smug paternal sufferance is challenged by the considerable amount of time given over to undermining the men and deriving humour at their expense. There are marked gender differences in how women and men negotiate the domestic space. All the rooms are chaotic and disorganized, strewn
the comedy-of-marriage film
93
with ironing-boards, children’s toys, piles of washing and precariously balanced drying-racks. The men experience the domestic space as extremely problematic and constantly bump into or trip over domestic artefacts. A fall over a discarded toy causes Rodney to scatter his pile of manuscripts, the children smear Bruce’s bowler hat with jam and he tumbles down the stairs at the end of the film. As I’ve suggested earlier, accidents in the comedy genre function, as Babington and Evans argue, at a dual level as ‘[o]nce attached to the realms of the mind … the basic pratfall is modified … by the creative potential of symbolism and symptomology’.76 On one level the accidents and falls experienced by the men are intended to humiliate them and make them look silly, and to illustrate the price to be paid for male hubris. Their pompous and imperious declarations of female incompetence and scattiness, their belief that their wives are either ‘fluffy’ or ‘unfeeling’, are punctured by their inability to adequately negotiate domestic space. Bruce’s outmoded and reactionary masculinity and Rodney’s imperious affectation of weary paternal indulgence are in need of correction in relation to revised, contemporary notions of gender and marriage. There is a sense that their pratfalls are also readable at the level of symptomology, suggestive of their own desire to embrace change and move beyond socially restrictive norms of masculinity. If, as Babington and Evans have argued in their discussion of screwball comedies, ‘accidents are the signs of an unconscious demanding liberation’77 then in Young Wives’ Tale the men’s falls not only humiliate them and undermine their assessment of the domestic situation, but suggest their own unconscious desire to break free from gender roles where normative masculinity is predicated on a desire for a buxom wife and six children. That the men are at fault is indicated by the women’s negotiation of the domestic space which is, in contrast to the men, skilful. Mary moves seamlessly through the domestic space, in one scene calmly tidying toys and pouring sherry, in another rolling pastry whilst simultaneously smoking a cigarette. Discarded toys present no hazard to her because, unlike the men, she notices them. Sabina’s movements are different but are no less skilful; leaping, but never falling, around and over objects in the room, ducking under a standard lamp and vaulting over a chaise longue to rescue a burning meal or attend a crying child. Neither of the women are subjected to the mishaps that befall the men. In this respect the film departs from the conventions of screwball comedy where typically both male and female protagonists are portrayed as accident-prone; women’s falls, like those of men, have literal and symbolic meaning.78 Indeed, it is the very absence of visual
94
femininity in the frame
gags at the expense of women that marks this film as strikingly different from other better-known examples of the comedy-of-marriage genre, particularly Genevieve which is often held as the paradigmatic case. As I have previously noted, Geraghty finds in this film that the women have to sacrifice more to bring their views in line with the men and ‘pay for their aloofness by being made to look childish and immature’,79 a punishment for their hubris. Such tribulations are not visited on either Sabina or Mary who, in being spared the humiliations that are directed instead towards the men, are afforded a considerable degree of dignity. Utilizing Schatz’s framework, where reconciliation is achieved through character change, it is Rodney and Mary in Young Wives’ Tale who have to modify their stance. Rodney admits ‘I don’t want a housekeeper and nothing else’, and he and Sabina companionably peel potatoes together, Rodney presumably having learned to love her as she is. Mary and Bruce’s reconciliation is similarly perfunctory, even though Mary’s characterization as independent and emotionally controlled is potentially more threatening to Bruce and his ideals of femininity. Bruce’s flirtation with Sabina finally results in Mary’s tears, which are welcomed by Bruce as evidence of an emotional femininity, consequently soothing his anxieties and allaying his fears of masculine usurpation. On the one hand it is clear that Mary has finally been won round to Bruce’s preference for a ‘thoroughly feminine wife’, her emotional control which had earned her the pejorative label of ‘the perfect machine’ finally softened and ‘feminized’. Her expectation that there is no place for romance in marriage has finally proven to be misguided. But the scene is ambiguous. Her emotional breakdown is extremely short-lived, comprising only a brief scene in the film’s final minutes. The scene is preceded by one where the latest nanny leaves, suggesting that Mary’s tears are as much attributable to the frustration and difficulty of retaining help essential to her career as they are to a more socially acceptable display of feminine sexual jealousy. In addition, the softening of her character through tears and emotional breakdown provides an appropriate ‘performance’ of normative femininity that satisfies her husband whilst allowing her to continue in her career. Significantly, the film does not end with the brief scene of reconciliation but rudely disrupts it by the neighbour’s dog stealing the roast and the children flooding the bathroom, whilst a radio voiceover solemnly declares ‘the country can never repay the debt it owes to the British housewife’. In film, attempts at narrative closure frequently meet with resistance or remain (as they do in this film) unconvincing,
the comedy-of-marriage film
95
as the resolutions that are offered are unequal to containing the conflicts that have been unleashed through the comic form. In sum, Bruce’s prolonged punishment for his reactionary masculinity is more memorable than Mary’s tears. Whilst it would be stretching the point to consider the film an overtly radical text in its gender politics, one doesn’t have to read too hard against the grain to see a considerable proto-feminist sub-text at work. It seems there wasn’t an enthusiastic audience for the film’s protofeminist declarations. It received a positive review in Picture Show, which classified it as a ‘thoroughly amusing domestic farce’ and singled out for special notice the performances of Nigel Patrick and Joan Greenwood, both extremely popular actors at this time.80 For Monthly Film Bulletin it was ‘an agreeable comedy in the tradition of adapted plays of the “Quiet Weekend” variety’.81 Despite being seemingly positioned to enjoy reasonable commercial success the film didn’t fare well at the British box office.82 One might speculate that whilst the script is well written and the dialogue sharp, its gender politics were out of step with contemporary consciousness, perhaps expressing too early, in 1951, the failure of housewifery to deliver on the promise of a creative career for women. Furthermore its theatrical setting appears dated and somewhat staid compared with the more effervescent Genevieve, which enjoyed such success two years later. Conclusion All three films share a common concern with contemporary roles for women and gender relations within marriage. Across the board there is a tendency to point out how difficult the role of housewife and mother is, but the films stop short of suggesting that men should take an equal and on-going share of the burden, pointing instead to more socially acceptable ‘corner-cutting’ solutions such as tinned food or learning to accept a degree of domestic chaos. Toye’s film, and her work more generally, is marked by a good-humoured tolerance of existing sexual politics and gender difference which contrasts sharply with Muriel Box’s approach, which is predicated on a more overtly feminist stance towards ‘positive representations’ of women. Box’s outlook in this respect has much in common with the film critics Catherine de la Roche and E. Arnot Robertson, the subjects of Chapter Six. The doting wife/sex object dualism found in To Dorothy a Son suggests something of Box’s frustration with what she saw as mainstream cinema’s inability to think
96
femininity in the frame
beyond those roles and the barriers she encountered to her attempts to portray a more rounded and complex womanhood. She found later success with Simon and Laura (1955), which continued the theme of the estranged warring couple, although here the sexual politics were more even and balanced: a factor achieved, in part, through the judicious casting of Kay Kendall and Peter Finch who were well matched as leads.83 Anne Burnaby continued to work in a comic vein and her script for Operation Bullshine (1959), one of the popular ‘service comedies’ of the decade, evidences her preference for irony as a political weapon by satirizing the notion of the female army recruit as the biddable helpmeet of the male. The female recruits are hedonistic and disobedient, drive their male commander to distraction, confound expectations that they will ‘naturally’ submit to discipline (an assumption predicated on a reading of female nature as biddable and submissive) and refuse to undertake domestic tasks like peeling potatoes because, as one female recruit complains, ‘I joined the army to get away from that kind of thing’. In the three films discussed at length in this chapter a (male) figure is constantly thwarted in his attempts at undertaking creative work within a domestic environment and the point is made loudly and clearly that domesticity is the death-knell of a particular type of artistic creativity.84 This figure can be read as a surrogate for these female artists (Box, Toye, Burnaby) who had to keep the domestic realm at arm’s length if they were to succeed professionally within the realm of film production.85 That all three worked successfully in comedy and at times marriage comedy establishes that the genre’s approach to sexual politics (a space where ‘gender trouble’ could be given rein) was sufficiently broad to accommodate their own different outlooks on the subject. The comedies-of-marriage discussed in this chapter provided a space where the male could be educated and brought round to a respect for the feminine, and where the conventions of heterosexual relations could at times, and within given limits, be interrogated, tested and exposed as predicated on an unequal division of labour. The genre’s capacity for a freer expression of tensions vis-à-vis gender roles is greater than has been widely realized and films such as Raising a Riot, To Dorothy a Son and Young Wives’ Tale need to be set alongside better-known examples to present a more rounded picture of how British comedy approached the subject of women, men and marriage.
the female group film
97
4
The Female Group Film In 1989 the actress Virginia McKenna recalled her experience of working on the 1956 British film A Town Like Alice as one of the most positive experiences of her career, delighting in a film which offered ‘a cast full of marvellous actresses’ substantial female roles at a time when they were in short supply in mainstream cinema.1 This film is unusual because the narrative centres on a small group of women of different ages and with different life