Fathers and Godfathers Spiritual Kinship in Early-Modern Italy
Guido Alfani
Fathers and Godfathers
This page has be...
102 downloads
706 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Fathers and Godfathers Spiritual Kinship in Early-Modern Italy
Guido Alfani
Fathers and Godfathers
This page has been left blank intentionally
Fathers and Godfathers Spiritual Kinship in Early-Modern Italy
Guido Alfani Bocconi University, Italy
© Guido Alfani 2009 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior permission of the publisher. Guido Alfani name has asserted his moral right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, to be identified as the author of this work. This volume has been translated from Italian by Christine Calvert. Original title: Padri, padrini, patroni. La parentela spirituale nella storia, Marsilio, Venice 2007 Published by Ashgate Publishing Limited Ashgate Publishing Company Wey Court East Suite 420 Union Road 101 Cherry Street Farnham Burlington Surrey, GU9 7PT VT 05401-4405 England USA www.ashgate.com British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Alfani, Guido, 1976– Fathers and Godfathers: Spiritual Kinship in Early-Modern Italy. – (Catholic Christendom, 1300–1700) 1. Catholic Church – Doctrines – History. 2. Kinship – Religious aspects – Catholic Church – History. 3. Baptism – Catholic Church – History of doctrines. 4. Sponsors – Italy – History. 5. Italy – Church history – 15th century. 6. Italy – Church history – 16th century. 7. Italy – Church history – 17th century. I. Title II. Series 234.1’61’0945’0903–dc22 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Alfani, Guido, 1976 Fathers and Godfathers: Spiritual Kinship in Early-Modern Italy / Guido Alfani. p. cm. – (Catholic Christendom, 1300–1700) Includes bibliographical references. 1. Sponsors – Italy – History. 2. Kinship – Religious aspects – Christianity. 3. Kinship – Italy – History. 4. Italy – Social conditions. I. Title. BV1478.A44 2009 306.83–dc22 2008055067 ISBN 978-0-7546-6737-7 (hbk)
ISBN 978-0-7546-9899-9 (ebk.V)
Contents Series Editor’s Preface Acknowledgements List of Tables List of Figures Introduction 1 2 3 4 5 6
vii ix xi xiii 1
Godparenthood and Spiritual Kinship: the Origins of a Distinctive Social Institution
13
Godparents and Compari between the Fifteenth and Sixteenth Centuries: a Wide Variety of Local Customs
27
Godparenthood, Literature and Family Records; from Perception to Interpretation
53
Godparenthood in the Sixteenth Century: from the Reformation to the Council of Trent
67
The Application of the Decrees of the Council; Resistance and Compromise: Three Lines of Enquiry
91
The Social Impact of the Reform
115
7 Newborn Babies and Spiritual Kinship: Equal Opportunities or Discrimination?
133
8
Godfathers and Godmothers: The Case of Ivrea
155
9
Godparenthood as an Instrument of Social Alliance
193
10
Godparenthood from the Seventeenth Century to the Present Day: A History of Decline?
209
Appendix Bibliography Index
233 245 263
This page has been left blank intentionally
Series Editor’s Preface The still-usual emphasis on medieval (or Catholic) and reformation (or Protestant) religious history has meant neglect of the middle ground, both chronological and ideological. As a result, continuities between the middle ages and early modern Europe have been overlooked in favor of emphasis on radical discontinuities. Further, especially in the later period, the identification of ‘reformation’ with various kinds of Protestantism means that the vitality and creativity of the established church, whether in its Roman or local manifestations, has been left out of account. In the last few years, an upsurge of interest in the history of traditional (or catholic) religion makes these inadequacies in received scholarship even more glaring and in need of systematic correction. The series will attempt this by covering all varieties of religious behavior, broadly interpreted, not just (or even especially) traditional institutional and doctrinal church history. It will to the maximum degree possible be interdisciplinary, comparative and global, as well as non-confessional. The goal is to understand religion, primarily of the ‘Catholic’ variety, as a broadly human phenomenon, rather than as a privileged mode of access to superhuman realms, even implicitly. The period covered, 1300–1700, embraces the moment which saw an almost complete transformation of the place of religion in the life of Europeans, whether considered as a system of beliefs, as an institution, or as a set of social and cultural practices. In 1300, vast numbers of Europeans, from the pope down, fully expected Jesus’s return and the beginning of His reign on earth. By 1700, very few Europeans, of whatever level of education, would have subscribed to such chiliastic beliefs. Pierre Bayle’s notorious sarcasms about signs and portents are not idiosyncratic. Likewise, in 1300 the vast majority of Europeans probably regarded the pope as their spiritual head; the institution he headed was probably the most tightly integrated and effective bureaucracy in Europe. Most Europeans were at least nominally Christian, and the pope had at least nominal knowledge of that fact. The papacy, as an institution, played a central role in high politics, and the clergy in general formed an integral part of most governments, whether central or local. By 1700, Europe was divided into a myriad of different religious allegiances, and even those areas officially subordinate to the pope were both more nominally Catholic in belief (despite colossal efforts at imposing uniformity) and also in allegiance than they had been four hundred years earlier. The pope had become only one political factor, and not one of the first rank. The clergy, for its part,
viii
SERIES EDITOR’S PREFACE
had virtually disappeared from secular governments as well as losing much of its local authority. The stage was set for the Enlightenment. Thomas F. Mayer, Augustana College
Acknowledgements This book, fruit of almost ten years’ labour, originated from my PhD thesis, supplemented by further research. I wish, therefore, firstly to thank my PhD tutors: Marco Cattini, Lorenzo Del Panta, Raul Merzario and Giovanni Vigo. My thoughts turn especially to Raul, whose premature death regrettably prevented me from presenting him with a copy of the book. I also wish to thank all those who patiently discussed with me various parts of this work: Maurice Aymard, Massimo Amato, Simona Cerutti, Gérard Delille, Joseph Goy, Maurizio Gribaudi, Anita Guerreau-Jalabert, Guido Guerzoni, Christiane Klapisch, Gérard Labrot, Paola Lanaro, Giovanni Levi, Omar Mazzotti, Fabrizio Pagani, Adriano Prosperi, Nicole Reinhardt, Massimo Riva, Mario Rosa, Angelo Torre, Marcello Verga. I am particularly grateful to Cristina Munno and Vincent Gourdon for reading and commenting on the first draft. Without their expertise and their interest in godparenthood, this book would not have been the same. Likewise, I wish to thank the anonymous referees who gave to the first Italian edition of this book their approval for their gratifying opinions and for their invaluable suggestions. I also wish to thank all the staff of the Diocesan and the City Archive of Ivrea, the State Archive of Turin, the Diocesan Archive of Vicenza, the Diocesan Archive of Cesena, as well as the parish priests and those responsible for the archives of S. Ulderico of Ivrea, S. Agostino of Turin, S. Maria Maggiore of Mirandola, S. Lorenzo of Voghera, S.S. Giorgio, Nazaro and Celso of Bellano, of the Cathedral of Ravenna, the Abbey of Nonantola and the Abbey of Finalpia, without whose collaboration my research would not have been possible. I would like to thank the Institute for Economic History of Bocconi University for the support they have always given me. This book would perhaps never have seen the light of day without the help and attention of two recent Directors, Franco Amatori and Marzio A. Romani. Franco Amatori shouldered the responsibility of closely following the complex path of the publication of the first Italian edition: I am extremely grateful. The book was finally completed in 2006 during a period of study spent at Glasgow University. I would like to thank that University and all the friends at the History Department and at the Institute for Medieval History for having provided an ideal working environment. My thanks also go to the Royal Society of Edinburgh, which awarded me the Research Fellowship that made my stay in Scotland possible. Special thanks go to
Fathers and Godfathers
Sam Cohn with whom I share an interest in an entirely different subject, plague. For the English edition of the book my thanks go to my translator, Christine Calvert, who during many months of work tolerated my ‘hairsplitting’ and my fondness for the quirks of the Italian language. Thanks go to her also for the working lunches at Pramollo, which I will remember as an English enclave in the Val Chisone. I am also grateful to Thomas Mayer for including this book in the Catholic Christendom, 1300–1700 series. Tom Gray, Kirsten Weissenberg and Kevin Doherty at Ashgate deserve thanks for their kindness and competence, as well as for all the attention they have given to this project. Finally my special thanks go to Elisa, not only for having been my first and harshest critic, but for all the love, affection and support that she gives me daily. I can never adequately repay her. Nor must I forget my parents and all the friends who in these years have supported me. This book is dedicated to my grandmother, Emma.
List of Tables 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4
Average number of godfathers in northern Italy (up to 1562) Average number of godmothers in northern Italy (up to 1562) Typology of godparenthood models Models of godparenthood by community and region
4.1 Opinions against a sole godparent 6.1
A comparison of the ranks of fathers and godfathers
7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7
Average number of godfathers and godmothers for baptized males and females before the Council of Trent Ranks of godparents for baptized males and females before the Council of Trent Average number of godfathers and godmothers for firstborn males and females before the Council of Trent. Ranks of godfathers for firstborn males and females (up until 1562) Ranks of godfathers for firstborn males and females after 1587 Ranks of fathers and number of godfathers and godmothers per baptism Ranks of fathers compared with ranks of godfathers
8.1 Occasional godfathers and habitual godfathers in Ivrea 8.2 Occasional godfathers and habitual godfathers in Azeglio 8.3 Social position of the habitual godfathers of Ivrea 8.4 Social position of the habitual godfathers of Azeglio 8.5 Duration and frequency of the careers of godfatherhood in Ivrea 8.6 Duration and frequency of the careers of godfatherhood in Azeglio. 8.7 Duration and frequency of the careers of godmotherhood in Ivrea 8.8 Repeated godfatherhoods in Ivrea 8.9 Godfatherhood and ‘systems of reciprocity’ in Ivrea
31 32 42 47 84 122 136 138 141 142 145 149 150 160 162 165 165 170 170 175 182 182
xii 9.1
Fathers and Godfathers
Composition of the extended groups of spiritual kin in Ivrea (1480–1487 and 1542–1549) 201
List of Figures 2.1
The distribution of models of godparenthood prior to the Council of Trent
44
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6
Ivrea (parish of S. Ulderico) Gambellara (parish of S. Pietro Apostolo) Turin (parish of S. Agostino) Voghera (parish of S. Lorenzo) Bellano (parish of SS. Giorgio, Nazaro and Celso) Mirandola (parish of S. Maria Maggiore)
94 95 96 97 98 99
6.1 6.2 6.3
Distribution by rank of the godfathers of the children of the untitled (Voghera, 1534–1604) Distribution by rank of the godfathers of the children of the seigneurs (Voghera, 1534–1604) Distribution by rank of the godfathers of the children of the untitled (Bellano, 1533–1609)
8.1
The godfatherhoods and godmotherhoods of the Albertis
179
9.1
Strategies and environment: a diagram of interactions
207
128 128 129
This page has been left blank intentionally
Introduction What is a godfather? This term, while no longer in common currency, is well known to us. We use it to indicate very different figures, which we do not know how to define otherwise: godfather in baptism, godfather in confirmation, the mafia godfather, the godfather in a duel. And godmother? Undoubtedly the meanings of ‘godmother’ and ‘godfather’ overlap, especially when they relate to baptism and confirmation. However, other meanings apply solely to the woman, or they seem to be more appropriate for her: for example, ‘godmother of a ship’ or ‘godmother of an orphanage’ or some other charitable institution – even a fairy godmother. In Italy, godfathers and godmothers are sometimes referred to as ‘compare’ and ‘comare’, with an infinite variety of expressions in dialect. These terms, more common in some areas than in others, evoke different kinds of relationships: friendship, deference, neighbourliness – meanings that are not all easily reconcilable. All the different meanings of godfather and godmother are in some way modelled on godfatherhood and godmotherhood in baptism. These have strong symbolic power that today, while still present, has partly faded. It is this symbolic power that has allowed the same word to be used for other types of relationships. For example, the godmother of a ship is the person who ‘christens’ it and gives it its name. The semantic primacy applied to godparenthood in baptism is also a historical primacy: the godfather in baptism, in fact, is the first to appear in our culture. Going back to our opening question, we must make it clear that here we are only interested in godparenthood in baptism, and if need be, in those factors that foster a semantic deviation in the use of the term. The Catholic The ‘compare’ is the godfather viewed in relation to the father of the baptised child, and vice versa. The word is used reciprocally (father and godfather of the child call each other compare), and has a feminine equivalent: ‘comare’. To indicate the social institution corresponding to the relationship between compari, the word ‘comparatico’ is used. All these words come from the Latin and have close equivalents in Romance languages: comparatico, for example, translates to ‘compérage’ in French and ‘compadrazgo’ in Spanish. Unfortunately, while the word ‘godparenthood’ can be used as a general term for all ties of spiritual kinship, the more specific words compare, comare and comparatico have no equivalent in modern English; we have thus left them untranslated. In ancient times a close English equivalent of compare existed: ‘godsib’, which meant more or less ‘spiritual brother/sister’. The word is the etymological antecedent of the modern word ‘gossip’, but has long disappeared from the English language. See Coster 2002, 93–97.
Fathers and Godfathers
Church, following current regulations, holds that for each newborn child baptized (except in the case of ceremonies conducted in an emergency), at least one godfather or one godmother must be present; at the most two (one of each sex) are permitted, unless a special licence is obtained, but this is very unusual. The fact that in Italy, and in other Catholic areas of Europe, there is almost always a godfather and a godmother, instead of one or the other, is by itself an interesting historical development, which is neither required by law nor justified theologically. This topic, which is more complex and fascinating than might at first appear, is the subject of this book. The role still ‘officially’ attributed to godparents is primarily to watch over the correct Christian upbringing of their godchild, and secondarily to be a witness to the baptism itself. It goes without saying that few godparents are fully aware of their duties, and even fewer make an effort to fulfil them; today, as in the past, godfathers and godmothers seem to take other aspects more seriously, ones not expressly envisaged by the Church, e.g. making gifts at baptism, perhaps also during their godchild’s infancy and on special occasions such as marriage or other ‘rites of passage’. Generally speaking, they somehow feel a tie with their godchildren, so much so that in exceptional circumstances, such as the premature death of the parents, they might provide parental care or intervene in support of the godchildren in a variety of ways. I will illustrate with examples from history in the course of this book. And compari? Today this term is somewhat problematic, as in most of Italy (in the north rather than the south), it is outdated, like another term, comparatico, which describes the type of relationship that exists between two compari. As well as being outdated, the term is sometimes used inappropriately; or rather, there are local customs in which people call each other compare, even when according to the original meaning
The 1983 Code of Canon Law, which is currently in force, states: ‘whenever possible, the baptised should be given a godparent…’ (Can. 872) and ‘only one godfather or only one godmother, or a godfather and a godmother are allowed’ (Can. 873). Codice di Diritto Canonico, Rome, Libreria editrice Vaticana (1983), p. 559. ‘Secondarily’ only insofar as it does not require any particular commitment on the part of godparents: in fact, both spiritual tutorship and being a witness are essential functions of godparents and, as such, cannot be put on a subordinate pastoral or juridical plane. I will return to the role attributed by the Church to godfathers, but see also Rubellin 1997, Torquebiau 1937, Van Molle 1964. The concept of ‘rites of passage’ applied both to baptism and to marriage was introduced by Van Gennep 1909, 1943. For an analysis of contemporary forms of comparatico and for the way this term and others connected to it are used, see the monographic number of the review L’Uomo edited by Italo Signorini: ‘Forme di comparatico italiano’ (1947).
Introduction
they are not in such a relationship. The word is derived from the Latin copater, the father of the baptized being compare to the godfather and vice versa: comparatico is, in fact, a symmetrical relationship. If it relates to a woman (the godmother or mother of the child), the corresponding comare (comater) is used. Between the compari there is a tie of proximity and solidarity, whose exact significance (concrete and symbolic) varies in time and place. Both in the relationships between godparents and godchildren and in those between compari, a tie can be perceived. The awareness of proximity is typical of the relationships created by godparenthood right from their appearance in the first centuries of the Christian era when godfathers were first introduced. Western culture has gradually lost its awareness of the fact that godparenthood and comparatico implied a form of kinship, a ‘spiritual kinship’ (cognatio spiritualis), the dimension of which changed in the course of time, first experiencing a phase of expansion from its beginnings up to the Council of Trent (1545–1563), and then a contraction. It was the Second Vatican Council in the twentieth century that cancelled the last traces, but this is recent history. It is significant that long before finally disappearing, spiritual kinship had almost completely been forgotten. A new question arises then: what exactly is a ‘spiritual’ kinship? In most Christian traditions baptism is a rite by which the baptized are cleansed of their original sin, with which they are stained from birth. With this sacrament, divine grace descends on the baptized and allows rebirth to a spiritual life, and at the same time opens the path to eternal salvation. Natural birth, then, is contrasted with spiritual birth; the flesh is contrasted with the spirit. Godparents, who began to attend baptismal ceremonies from the fifth and sixth centuries, represented the Church in the sense of the gathered community of Christians who present an incomplete and imperfect being at the rite, and through grace receive in exchange a new member of the community. This new member is then given a name and at the same time finds a place within the kinship group and within society as a whole. Baptism, in fact, realizes not only the spiritual birth of the new Christian but also his social birth. In the light of this spiritual birth, in the course of time the existence of spiritual kinship gradually came to be recognized, with its related marriage bans, between those who had taken part in the rite of baptism (including the parents of the baptized), and later including their families. Medieval theological tradition actually developed the concept of a real ‘spiritual family’ similar but superior to the ‘natural family’, as the spirit is always superior to the flesh (Guerreau-Jalabert 1995, 2004). I will later analyse in detail the long process that led to the development of a system of spiritual kinship so extended that towards the mid-sixteenth century restrictions upon it became necessary.
Fathers and Godfathers
Baptism, therefore, in generating kinship relationships, automatically also formed a network of relations similar to, but not exactly overlapping, the network based on natural kinship. However, it is not only a matter of recognizing that baptism sanctioned full entry into the community (i.e. into the network of all Christians) but, above all, of seeing the spiritual family in a more limited context, as a particular spiritual family comprising the baptized, their parents, godmothers and godfathers. The role played by relationships of natural kinship and of affinity, that is, the kinship created by marriage between members of different family groups, in the social and economic life of a community, has been at the centre of historical investigation but has also been studied by sociologists, anthropologists and also, more cautiously, by economists. We know far less, though, of the role played by godparenthood and by comparatico, certainly relationships not as close as those mentioned above, yet not devoid of a certain effectiveness. Sociological research has shown that, to reach certain goals, exploring ‘weak’ ties can prove to be more effective than resorting to ‘strong’ ones (Granovetter 1974). Fortunately, we can be in no doubt about the relevance of godparenthood and comparatico relationships, as there is no lack of historical sources evidencing their importance. It is necessary, however, to point out that the current availability of data limits our ability to explore the past: typical of almost all forms of unstructured, barely perceptible relationships is that they leave traces only in exceptional circumstances. From this standpoint, scholars from other disciplines are luckier, as they can still pose questions directly related to their objects of study. It is not by chance that scientific interest in godparenthood, and particularly in comparatico, first developed among anthropologists. Their interest originated from the surprise, first of travellers, and then of scholars coming from non-Catholic countries, especially North America and England, when they came into contact with the lively godparenthood practices that are still to be found today in Central and Southern America. From the 1930s at least, it became customary for anthropologists working in Latin America to make some mention in their publications of the system of compadrazgo in the societies they studied. Compadrazgo is the Spanish equivalent of comparatico, and relationships between compari were far more interesting than those between godfathers and godchildren, as they involved inescapable obligations of honest dealing, respect and reciprocal help, and they seemed to be part of all kinds of activities. Edward B. Tylor, one of the first ethnologists to describe the system of compadrazgo (his journey to Mexico was as long ago as 1856) writes: ‘I mentioned the word ‘compadrazgo’ a little way back. The thing itself is curious, and quite novel to an Englishman of the present day. The godfathers and godmothers of a child become, by their participation in the ceremony,
Introduction
In the years following the Second World War, research into godparenthood diversified and the field of research was extended to areas other than contemporary Latin America. A small number of scholars looked back, trying to make a brief reconstruction of the history of godparenthood in past centuries. Others studied different areas, in the first place Spain, where they searched for customs similar to those found among the populations in Latin America, and secondly, the Balkans and Greece, where forms of godparenthood still very much alive were investigated. The interest shown by historians in godparenthood certainly derived from the enthusiasm of anthropologists for compadrazgo, as seen by their attempts to discover its European antecedents. This influence could clearly be seen from the 1970s, 50 years from the beginning of the anthropological tradition. In this initial phase, however, historians were very much influenced by the approach anthropologists applied to their pioneering research, accepting a ‘vulgate’ or received view of the history of godparenthood from its origins to the Contemporary Era, which had been formulated by non-specialist scholars. An article of 1950 by Sidney W. Mintz and Eric R. Wolf was the key text in the construction of this received view. This article focused on a comparison of five studies dealing with godparenthood practices in Latin America, but the authors began their work with a nine-page reconstruction of the historical antecedents of what they defined as ‘ritual co-parenthood’, thus outlining what, in the following decades, would become ‘the’ history of godparenthood from its origins to contemporary society. Mintz and Wolf’s work helped to fill a serious gap, as anthropologists interested at that time in models of Latin American godparenthood had at their disposal extremely fragmentary historical references. Mintz and Wolf’s survey, however, clearly needed confirmation and further investigation, as it was based on a limited number of sources, which were sometimes of doubtful quality. The article contained a number of inaccuracies that
relations to one another and to the priest who baptises the child, and call one another ever afterwards compadre and comadre … In Mexico this connexion obliges the compadres and comadres to hospitality and honesty and all sorts of good offices towards one another; and it is wonderful how conscientiously this obligation is kept even by people who have no conscience at all for the rest of the world. A man who will cheat his own father or his own son will keep faith with his compadre. To such an extent does this influence become mixed up with all sorts of affairs, and so important it is, that it is necessary to count it among the things that tend to alter the course of justice in the country’ (Tylor 1861, p. 250, quoted in Lynch 1986, p. 58).
For a by no means complete bibliography for Latin America, see Christinat 1989, Nutini and Bell 1980–1984, Signorini 1981; for Spain, Pitt-Rivers 1976a; for the Balkans and Greece, Hammel 1968, Pitt-Rivers 1976b, Vellioti 1987.
Fathers and Godfathers
contributed to building up a body of erroneous beliefs that took a long time to lose acceptance. Some of the hypotheses put forward by Mintz and Wolf played a particularly important part in conditioning future historical research. First of all, querying the social function of godparenthood in a medieval period with vague historical boundaries, they concluded that it was very similar to the practice in Latin American societies. Secondly, they maintained, without producing any evidence, that after the Middle Ages, almost throughout the whole of Europe, comparatico gradually lost its social importance at the same time as feudal society disappeared. Mintz and Wolf’s synthesis perhaps proved to serve its purpose too well. It is a fact that for a long time anthropologists saw no need whatsoever to examine any further the history of godparenthood, except to criticize Mintz and Wolf on specific questions; this is the case with George M. Foster’s attempt to identify the Spanish antecedents of compadrazgo. As well as providing a historical reference that can still clearly be seen in many works on godparenthood, Mintz and Wolf’s article was in turn the instrument that guaranteed the lasting influence of Jules Corblet and Benjamin D. Paul. In 1881 Abbot Corblet published Histoire du Sacrement de Baptême, which has been used as a source of data and information up to the present day. However, because of its limited availability, few seem to have been able to consult it directly; Corblet’s data have been handed down through a chain of quotations with the result that, at each step, something seems to have been lost. I will come back to this aspect in due course.10
Mintz and Wolf (1950, pp. 351–352) claimed that the causes were ‘… the development of industrial capitalism, the rise of a strong middle class, and the disappearance of feudal and neo-feudal tenures. Within these areas compadrazgo has lost its function most completely within the classes in which the family no longer forms the primary unit of production’. Foster was the first to begin an anthropological line of research that, shifting the field of investigation from Latin America to Spain, looked in this area for analogies with the compadrazgo practices that for decades had aroused curiosity in scholars. The basic assumption was that at the time of the conquest, a ‘Spanish’ model of godparenthood was transplanted in America. In an article in 1953 (‘Cofradía and Compadrazgo in Spain and Spanish America’) Foster linked the institution of comparatico to the confraternities, claiming that both fulfilled a specific function: to create cohesion and social integration, creating a network of relationships which in a situation of crisis could come into play and make it easier to face difficulties. According to Foster, in Spanish society in the Late Middle Ages the two institutions existed side by side, and were both equally recognized. Later in Spain it was the confraternities that gained in importance, while in Latin America it was the compadrazgo, which prevailed on account of its similarity to practices typical of pre-Columbian religions. 10 For example, Corblet is the origin of a blind faith in the presumed predominance in Europe until the Council of Trent of the ‘French’ model of godparenthood, according to which two godfathers and one godmother were given to boys, and vice versa to girls.
Introduction
With regard to Paul, Mintz and Wolf consulted his unpublished 1942 doctoral thesis. Paul outlined a conceptual framework that was the basis for further godparenthood studies for some decades; he both provided an interpretation of godparenthood as one of the main forms of ‘ritual’ kinship, quite distinct from ‘blood’ kinship and kinship due to ‘affinity’ derived from a matrimonial tie,11 and was the first to pose some key questions. In particular, he observed that in Latin America, depending on the locality, godparenthood was used either to enter into a relationship with people with whom there had been no previous ties, or to strengthen an already existing relationship. Paul established an analytical category to be found at the centre of many later studies, summed up in the dichotomy ‘extension/intensification’ of natural kinship. In a clear and surprising way, the work of Mintz and Wolf, and indirectly that of Corblet and Paul, influenced and continue to influence anthropological research on godparenthood. Even more surprising, however, is the lasting influence they were able to exercise on historical studies. I have already mentioned that well into the 1970s studies on godparenthood were conducted amid general lack of interest on the part of historians. When they finally began to be aware that it was an interesting field of study, and, moreover, one that was practically unexplored from a historical standpoint, they were guided by suggestions that clearly came from research carried out by anthropologists. Not infrequently two disciplines exchange research aims and objectives, especially if, like history and anthropology, they share a close relationship, albeit not without differences of opinions (Viazzo 2000). What was unusual in the way these historians dealt with questions posed by godparenthood was the fact that together with subjects of research from the anthropological field they also imported a general historical frame of reference in which to incorporate their own specific investigations, and a global interpretation of the phenomena observed. Arriving late on the scene, historians essentially renounced their own specific remit and went back, albeit with some further modifications, to Mintz and Wolf’s interpretation. Actually, there is no lack of excellent studies produced by historians on specific aspects of godparenthood and its history, e.g. research carried out by Christiane Klapisch-Zuber and Louis Haas on late medieval Tuscany.12 11
For Paul ritual kinship included ‘... all those instances of artificial relationship growing out of a ritual compact and obligating the contracting parties to behave as kinsmen to each other and to the members of each other’s families’. The quotation is taken from Lynch 1986, pp. 60–61. 12 Christiane Klapisch-Zuber has studied godparenthood from a broad standpoint, analysing in a long series of articles comparatico (also as a form of social patronage), the
Fathers and Godfathers
However, it should be pointed out that until now no synthesis has been able to modify theories that, in the light of data available today, can no longer be accepted. Concentrating on the Early Medieval Period, Joseph H. Lynch’s attempt in 1986 proved insufficient, as the author failed to deal with crucial issues concerning later periods. If it were merely a question of a fresh synthesis to take account of recent findings, the task would not appear so daunting, nor, perhaps, so necessary. However, there exists a set of accepted beliefs on godparenthood, well established but unfortunately based on little data and on a small group of outdated secondary sources. Consequently, it is necessary to distance ourselves, using empirical evidence to demonstrate just how groundless are certain beliefs in the received wisdom. This state of affairs has gone on for so long because historians’ interest has been focused on two extremes: the Middle Ages13 and the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries.14 This is partly on account of factors not strictly connected to godparenthood studies, such as the general lessening of interest among historians in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. However, if, as Mintz and Wolf claim, godparenthood as an institution was already in a critical state in the Late Middle Ages, there was no particular need to carry out studies aimed at the first centuries of the Modern Age. The fact that historical studies on godparenthood increased with the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries can be explained by the availability of better documentary material and the fact that scholars from specialist areas within disciplines such as historical anthropology and historical demography have shown an interest in this period. In my opinion, the Early Modern Age, and in particular the sixteenth century, was a period of crucial importance in the history of godparenthood relationship between godparents and godchildren, the specific role of godmothers and so on (Klapisch-Zuber 1976, 1980, 1985, 1992; the author included many of her essays in the volume, La maison et le nom. Stratégies et rituels dans l’Italie de la Renaissance, 1990). In her article, ‘Parrains et filleuls: Une approche comparée de la France, l’Angleterre et l’Italie médiévales’ (1985b), she made the first important attempt to compare the different practices in Europe, although it was limited to the very specific aspect of the link between godparenthood and the giving of a name to the child, and done on the basis of the limited amount of data available at that period. With regard to Louis Haas, see Haas 1989, 1995–1996, 1998. 13 As well as the work of Lynch, Klapisch-Zuber and Haas, already mentioned, see Guerreau-Jalabert 1995; Jussen 1991, 1992; Cramer 1993. 14 The eighteenth and nineteenth centuries have attracted one of the lines of research that are producing the most interesting results in the study of godparenthood, namely historical anthropology. I refer especially to the work of David W. Sabean (1990, 1998). Another line of research links an interest in godparenthood with tools and methodologies borrowed from historical demography. See, for example, Cristina Munno 2005 and research still being carried out by Vincent Gourdon (2005). For Italy, see Bigi, Ronchi and Zambruno 1981.
Introduction
on account of the transformations brought about by the Council of Trent,15 for at least three reasons: first, because on the eve of the Council, godparenthood was not yet in a state of crisis, as Mintz and Wolf maintained; second, because as a social institution the characteristics of godparenthood do not correspond to the interpretation of many anthropologists; finally, because during the sixteenth century godparenthood went through a phase of rapid change, which has never been analysed, and it is not clear which paths it followed in later centuries. These assertions will be discussed in this work with the support of a large amount of data, the result of several years of research obtained from a heterogeneous set of sources, most of them unpublished. The fact that I became interested by chance in godparenthood is indicative of the state of current knowledge of these topics. It was the discovery of a phenomenon that seemed difficult to explain, following the chance discovery of a rare fifteenth-century baptismal register in the parish of S. Ulderico in Ivrea that triggered my curiosity. My degree dissertation and my doctoral thesis originated from this interest, followed by articles and papers given at conferences, and now this book, based on my doctoral thesis, ‘Nascite naturali e rinascite spirituali’(‘Natural births and spiritual rebirths’), supplemented by further research and reflection. What exactly was this discovery? Examining the baptismal registers of S. Ulderico with the intention of collecting demographic data, I realized that in Ivrea it was normal to have numerous godfathers and godmothers. Between the end of the fifteenth and the first half of the sixteenth century, not infrequently three, four or more were given; the most surprising case that I found was the baptism of Maria, daughter of Bernardo Salti of Chiaverano and granddaughter of Pietro Salti, who on 20 March 1502 was baptized in the presence of 17 godfathers and 10 godmothers. It was easy to ascertain that these kinds of godparenthood practices, while rarely documented, were not unknown to historiography. What proved to be a question that had never been investigated were the circumstances surrounding their disappearance. The baptismal registers indicated a reduction over a period in the number of godparents present at each baptism. This happened between the second half of the sixteenth and the beginning of the seventeenth century, when almost all children received only one godfather and one godmother. This transformation 15
Among the few works that have shown an interest, although marginally, in Catholic godparenthood in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, see Delille 1988; Reinhardt 2000; Vincent 1988. Church historians, and in particular John Bossy (1979, 1985, 1998a), have paid considerable attention to the Tridentine reform of godparenthood. Some of Bossy’s research has been continued in more depth by Adriano Prosperi (1997). With regard to Protestant areas, interest has recently been shown in godparenthood in the Early Modern Age. See Coster 2002 and Spierling 2005.
10
Fathers and Godfathers
coincided with the new rules on godparenthood issued by the Council of Trent, which limited godparents to two at the most (one godfather and one godmother). Once translated into numbers and transposed onto a graph, the impression of a gradual reduction in the average number of godfathers and godmothers per baptism was confirmed, and at the same time posed an important problem: the way the rule was applied. As the Tridentine canon allowed very limited room for manoeuvre, how was it possible that it was applied in such a gradual fashion? It was immediately clear that some form of negotiation must have taken place, but outside the limits imposed by the canon. This fact alone was interesting and worth further research, as well as suggesting that the inhabitants of Ivrea were much attached to their outlawed customs. Moreover, baptismal registrations made it possible to analyse the way in which godparenthood, and especially comparatico, put members of different social classes in relation with one another. Before the Council of Trent, when godparents were numerous, the baptism of a child was an opportunity to establish ties at every level of the social ladder. However, after the Council a gradual ‘verticalization’ of the relationship took place, which meant that as the permitted number of godparents diminished, there was a tendency to keep only those from a higher rank. The relationship between fathers and godfathers (the compari), which up to a short time before had often been a relationship between equals, increasingly became an asymmetrical relationship between patrons and clients. It was a social transformation never previously recognized and in many ways surprising, because it was imposed from on high on a stubborn population, because it happened in such a short space of time, and because it happened at a time when other forces of social closure were at work. Furthermore, its connection with these forces was unclear. Much of the subject matter of this book can already be seen in the example of Ivrea. However, the task became much more complicated than it had originally seemed when the field of research was widened to cover many communities throughout Italy, when the scanty information available for Europe was gathered and the survey extended to cover a longer period. It emerged that the model of godparenthood in Ivrea was not the only one practised in the whole of Italy, not even in northern Italy, nor even in the immediate surroundings of Ivrea. It was only one of many models, often with very different characteristics, scattered throughout the country and distributed in a way that poses challenges in the field of the geography of customs. Studying these numerous models, I discovered the many ways in which they had adapted to the rules laid down by the Council of Trent, each one able to throw light on new aspects of the meaning given to spiritual kinship relationships. Even though the starting point and the path followed differed from place to place, the direction that path took and the
Introduction
11
point of arrival were the same: the verticalization of the godparenthood relationship found in Ivrea was only one example of a widespread process, never before studied, and whose implications still had to be clarified. These few initial remarks should be enough to explain why the reform desired by the Council of Trent is at the centre of this book. The frame of reference, however, covers a long period, actually extremely long (from the origins of godparenthood to the present day), as only in such a long perspective is it possible to understand the implications that the Council’s decisions had on the two-thousand-year history of this social institution. Recognition of the importance of the Tridentine reform immediately changes our view of the history of godparenthood, making it imperative both to rewrite the crucial stages of its development and to reassess godparenthood and comparatico within the kind of timescale that enables us to look at the historical manifestations of godparenthood without being influenced by descriptions of its more recent forms. If historically the Council of Trent is at the centre of this book, then geographically the central role belongs to northern Italy, where the communities I have personally studied are to be found. However, whenever the data available allow me to do so, I will extend my view to the rest of Italy, Europe and the New World. Within these wider references in time and space, I will analyse the relationship between godparenthood practices and prescriptive rules intended to monitor the institution. Over the long period are to be found both conservative tendencies, primarily the specific tendency of godparenthood practices to evade regulation, and decisive moments of change. I have already said that the Council of Trent is a key moment in the history of godparenthood, not only because the Church completely changed the direction of regulatory processes that had begun centuries earlier (especially concerning the extension of spiritual kinship), but also because the new Tridentine rules were applied with coercive measures previously unknown. The increased strength of rule enforcement as regards godparenthood practices caused tensions, fractures and changes in society which, until now, have never been analysed. The Council of Trent, however, is itself the result of another fundamental turning point in the history of godparenthood: the Protestant Reformation. As well as causing Europe to fragment, from the point of view both of rules and of practices, the Reformation presented an opportunity for an in-depth reflection on the sacrament of baptism and on the concept of spiritual kinship, which the Council somehow had to face, if only to reject it. In this book attention will be paid mostly to the Catholic position, but I will consider the different forms of Protestant godparenthood where appropriate. Similarly I will mention godparenthood in the Orthodox Church, which was very
12
Fathers and Godfathers
similar to the Catholic form until the Council of Trent introduced different elements. Before proceeding further it is necessary to clarify a lexical problem. In Italian there is no term that includes both types of social relationships discussed in this book: godfatherhood (or godmotherhood), i.e. the relationship between godfather (or godmother) and godchild; and comparatico, i.e. the relationship between compari. However, from an analytical point of view, it is useful to be able to indicate both together, without having to make tiresome repetitions. For this reason, in the Italian edition of this book the word padrinato was used with the meaning of both ‘godfatherhood’ and ‘godparenthood’, making it clear in the text when it meant solely the relationship between godparents and godchildren and when it included also the relationship between compari. While such an expedient is not necessary in this English-language edition, a problem arises with translation of the Italian words comparatico and compare (or comare), given that in modern English such words have no equivalent. Thus, when it is necessary to designate this specific relationship between people who came to be tied by spiritual kinship because they were respectively parent and godparent of a baptized child, the Italian words are used.
CHAPTER 1
Godparenthood and Spiritual Kinship: the Origins of a Distinctive Social Institution In the Introduction I recalled that in European societies in the past, baptism, far from being a simple certification – albeit a solemn and public one of the ‘natural’ birth of a child – was rather a second birth, a ‘spiritual’ one, within a group of relatives who usually differed from the blood relations: a spiritual family, made up of godfathers and godmothers. For the Church, between the members of the spiritual family on the one hand and the child and his parents on the other, a real tie of kinship was created with the relative matrimonial interdictions. However, this description, which closely corresponds to the situation found between the end of the Middle Ages and the beginning of the Modern Era, cannot be indiscriminately extended to previous centuries; nor, for that matter, to later ones (among Catholics, at least, spiritual kinship no longer exists). In other words, the characteristics of the social institution of godparenthood are historically determined. In fact, godparenthood was not derived from Christ’s preaching. As was pointed out by Luther, neither in the gospels nor in other parts of the Bible are there clear references either to godparents or to spiritual kinship, at least not without stretching the interpretation of texts. It is therefore necessary to date and give a reason for the appearance of godparenthood. In addition, godparenthood and the relationships connected to it (the comparatico above all) show an unusual tendency to modify in time and space, adapting to different circumstances. The most significant and drastic transformation that godparenthood underwent in its long history is certainly among Catholics the one imposed de iure by the Council of Trent, and among Protestants by the Reformation, despite the fact that it went through a series of
Luther 1520, ‘Le prélude de Martin Luther sur la captivité babylonienne de l’Église’, in Lutero (1966) Oeuvres, p. 238. As is well known, the Reformation and the Council of Trent are closely linked historical events, which I will discuss fully in Chapter 4. Here it is sufficient to mention that for the whole of Europe, except the Orthodox countries, the first part of the sixteenth century marked the moment when godparenthood was debated, reviewed and reformulated, and these new forms were then imposed on populations. Luther ‘nailed’ his theses on the cathedral door of Wittenberg in 1517; the Council of Trent concluded its work in 1563.
Fathers and Godfathers
14
‘autonomous’ transformations that pose interesting problems and require a considerable effort of interpretation. All the issues mentioned above will be dealt with in due course in order to build a well-grounded and coherent picture of little-known historical facts. For the moment, I propose to explain how and why godfathers and godmothers appeared on the scene among Christians and how, from a very different situation, the concept of ‘spiritual kinship’, on which late medieval godparenthood was based, came into being. As well as for baptism, the need for the presence of godparents and the capacity to create spiritual kinship was recognized for another rite, confirmation. The history of godparenthood at confirmation closely follows that of godparenthood at baptism, to which in some way it is subordinated. Consequently, I will concentrate on the latter. I have already mentioned that there are no clear references in the Scriptures either to godparenthood or spiritual kinship; it is not by chance that there is no evidence of them in the very first centuries of the Christian Era. Their appearance is to be seen in relation to an important change that took place in Christendom: the widespread use of infant baptism. In the Primitive Church it was adult baptism that was mainly practised. Between the second and the fourth centuries the main Christian communities developed a series of practices, called together ‘catechumenate’, designed to test and instruct aspiring Christians. To be admitted to this course of instruction, it was necessary to be accompanied and presented by two guarantors (fideiussores, sponsores) who vouched for the dignity and suitability of the candidate. After a period of waiting, which could last some years, the candidate was baptized and the ceremony sanctioned his entry into the Christian community. In practice, the sponsores’ role was also to protect the community and to keep control, first of all because Christians, who were frequently an object of persecution, had every reason to fear attempts by false converts to infiltrate, and secondly because they wished to avoid the risk of receiving ‘heretics’ belonging to other Christian sects or being influenced by them. The fact was that at that time the Church was torn by profound differences. The sponsores, therefore, came into being when Christianity was nothing more than a sect, struggling to survive in a world in which paganism prevailed.
In certain periods, it was thought that confession/penitence and the catechumenate also gave rise to spiritual kinship and consequently to marriage impediments, even though they were far less common than those linked to baptism and confirmation. The spiritual kinship which derived from catechumens’ preparation was totally and finally suppressed by the Council of Trent; the spiritual kinship which derived from confession had disappeared centuries before, perhaps at the hand of Boniface VIII (Iung 1937). On sponsores and their role in the Early Church, see Lynch 1986; Signorini 1981; Leclerq 1938; Torquebiau 1937.
Godparenthood and Spiritual Kinship
15
Infant baptism spread in deeply different conditions, at a time when Christianity was consolidating as the dominant religion. In Italy from the fifth century, baptizing newborn babies became customary, at least in cities (Cattaneo 1975). On the one hand, this development is closely linked to the fact that Christianity became less and less a religion of conversion, as now most children were born to parents who were already Christians and, on the other, to the consolidation of new theological trends that led to the belief that in order to obtain salvation, baptism was absolutely essential, with no exceptions. St. Augustine, at the beginning of the fifth century, also maintained that children who were not baptized could not go to heaven. In order not to put the souls of the children at risk, it was necessary to baptize them as soon as possible. An important ritual and theological problem was soon to arise: the rite of baptism demanded an active participation and required at least the use of speech. The problem was solved by godparents, direct descendants of the ancient sponsores, replying to the priest’s questions in place of the child. This, at least, is the ‘traditional’ interpretation of the advent of godparenthood. However, it is only a partial and insufficient explanation, insofar as even in previous centuries there were cases of the baptism of infants, who were taken to the font by their own parents. The presence of adults at the ceremony was obviously necessary, but that did not mean that they had to be godparents. Thus, from the beginning, the spread of the institution of godparenthood required a degree of theological elaboration (the distinction between the ‘carnal generation’ and the ‘spiritual generation’), which led to the exclusion of parents as sponsores of their own children. As we shall see, the Council of Mainz of 813 expressly forbade parents to act as godparents to their own children, but for some time this practice had already fallen into disuse. Godparenthood and spiritual kinship, therefore, somehow came into being together, even though, particularly as far as the latter is concerned, it would take several centuries before a complete theological and legal formulation was devised. The Church recognized in these new figures, the godparents, a role as tutors in the Christian education of the child, which they shared
Augustine, De anima et eius origine, cit. in Le Goff 1982, pp. 84 ff. We know that at the time of St. Augustine (354–430), it was normal that parents acted as godparents at their child’s baptism. It was such common practice that Bishop Boniface expressed the opinion that only parents could fulfil this role. St. Augustine contradicted him in a letter with a wealth of examples, citing the children of slaves baptized by their owners, and children who were orphans or foundlings (Kearney 1925, pp. 30–31).
This view was originally put forward by Anita Guerreau-Jalabert (1995, pp. 161– 162).
16
Fathers and Godfathers
with the parents of the child baptized. The function of the sponsores was completely reviewed, but it was as educators that the enduring link with their original role as guarantors of the moral quality of their pupils is to be found. Once the need for the presence at baptism of godfathers and godmothers had been recognized, with its aim of clearly separating the natural generation and the spiritual generation, it was by no means a foregone conclusion that godparents were considered in the same light as ‘relations’. In the long term this could be considered a semi-automatic evolution, consequence of the parallelism between natural birth and spiritual birth (or better, rebirth), which was already in progress when godparents first appeared. In other words, if natural kinship is a corollary of natural birth, then spiritual kinship is a corollary of spiritual birth, deemed by theologians to be even more important. This kind of reasoning, however, reflects a certain teleological flaw, that is, a tendency to rationalize a historical process from knowledge of its result rather than its cause. It is more correct from a methodological point of view, and more interesting at a level of historical analysis, to reconstruct the way in which the idea of spiritual kinship increasingly comes to mirror the natural one, acquires a similar extension and becomes governed by analogous marriage interdictions. It was the taboo of incest, so strongly rooted in western societies, and the deeply disturbing suspicion that the relationship between people related by godparenthood could create barriers not to be crossed, that led civil and religious authorities to lay down rules that established matrimonial bans for the spiritual generation. Where there is incest there is certainly kinship; the safest foundation of spiritual kinship (far more than any theological reflection) was, right from the outset, the restriction on sexual relations. A difficulty clearly emerges that can be put as follows: which comes first, kinship or incest? To a certain extent they come together like two sides of the same coin but, if by kinship we intend that which is officially recognized and sanctioned by matrimonial interdiction, it must be recognized that in the case in question, incest comes first. In fact, the initial drive to regulate relationships between those related by baptism came from the scandal that came to light in cases judged as incestuous by members of Christian For Jews and Christians, incest is first prohibited in the Old Testament in Leviticus 18: 5–18. The rules governing it were taken up again, developed and reiterated in a long series of councils. Canonical tradition recognized four ‘forms’ of kinship (cognatio) which prohibited marriage and sexual relations: natural kinship or blood relations, kinship due to alliances or affinity (ensuing from marriage), legal kinship or adoption, and spiritual kinship (Cimetier 1932).
Godparenthood and Spiritual Kinship
17
communities. It is possible that at the root of this perception was preaching by leaders of the clergy based on precise theological reasonings, but due to a dearth of sources this cannot be verified. It is necessary, however, to point out that even the notion of impediment or ban on marriage presents a margin of ambiguity, as it would be a mistake to claim that the effective extension of matrimonial impediments corresponds exactly to that contemplated in canon law. Proof is the fact that, even in recent times, there have been cases of societies where interdictions perceived and applied by the population have gone far beyond those envisaged by the Church.10 I think these issues deserve to be carefully researched in the light of the history of mentalities, linked to more general considerations.11 This, however, goes beyond my competence and my mandate. I will, therefore, limit myself to describing how the growth of the spiritual kinship in force on the eve of the Council of Trent progressed. Essentially this will be based on the few sources available for ancient times, which are usually legal. This will also enable us to get an impression of the way this relationship was perceived. One aspect that deserves underlining is that, in general, the regulations concerning spiritual kinship seem to have been engendered as a reaction: as already noted, it is the perception of a scandal caused by cases which actually happened that led to the intervention of the legislators. On the other hand, their intervention was not effective everywhere. There continued to be cases of ‘spiritual incest’, both where the population was unaware of any impediment, and, to a lesser degree, where they were conscious of it. At the time of the Council of Trent, the scandals caused by the violation of the rules governing spiritual kinship to a large extent still determined the way baptism was reformed. As far as we know, the first document to contain a ban on marriage on account of spiritual kinship is a letter by the Emperor Justinian, addressed to the prefect of the praetorium, Julian, in October 530. The letter was in reply to questions posed on the legality of certain marriages;
10
In the latter part of the last century, Pitt-Rivers (1976a) discovered that the taboo of incest continued among the compadres of the Spanish Sierra, even though it was officially abolished by the Code of Canon Law in 1917. Numerous other cases of taboo, mainly concerning areas in South America, are indicated by Salvatore D’Onofrio (1995). As well as the above-mentioned taboo between godparents and parents of the baptized, there is also that between ‘spiritual brothers’ (the godchildren and children of a particular godparent), abolished by the Council of Trent in 1563, or that between godchildren of the same godparent, never officially recognized by the Catholic Church, and attested also in Greece among the Orthodox. I will come back to these vetoes in this and later chapters. 11
See, for example, Pierre Legendre’s thoughts on the problem of incest (1988).
Fathers and Godfathers
18
it was included in the famous Code of Civil Law.12 The ban envisaged by Justinian concerns marriages between a godfather and a goddaughter and is justified by the fact that the very relationship of godparenthood, more than anything else, can generate paternal affection; it is for this reason that this kind of union is ‘incestuous’.13 The second step in the extension of spiritual kinship was the Trullan Synod, convened in 692 at Constantinople by the Emperor Justinian II. In canon 53, Justinian’s ban is reiterated, with an addition: marriage is also banned between a godfather and the mother of the godson, when she is a widow. The canon justifies the rule by pointing out that a spiritual relationship is more important than a physical one, and must, therefore, have precedence; also, in this case the Council fathers were aware of actual cases and their aim was to prevent analogous instances in the future (Lynch 1986, p. 230). This extension of the limits of spiritual incest is important because with it comes the emergence of the concept of compaternitas, which is at the origin of the ‘comparatico’. The way these doctrinal formulations of the Eastern Church were received in the West was conditioned by the difficult relationship between Emperor and Pope. It was the wish of Justinian II that the conclusions of the Trullan Synod were accepted also in the West, but he had to overcome the resistance of the Pope, who did not completely concur with them. It was only in 711 that a compromise was reached. Pope Constantine I accepted most of the canons of the Trullan Synod (including 53), but excluding those that Rome did not find acceptable. His successor, Gregory II, had the substance of canon 53 accepted also by the Council of Rome of 721 12
Justinian Code, book V, title IV, law XXVI. At a time when baptism of adults was still frequent, it often happened that there was little difference in age between the godparent and his godchildren, and scandals and incestuous relations would come to light shortly after the ceremony. An interesting case is reported by the Byzantine historian Procopius. Belisarius, Justinian’s famous general, had in service a young man named Teodosius, born to a couple who were not Christians. Before embarking on a journey to Libya, Belisarius personally baptized the young man. Consequently, narrates Procopius, Belisarius’s wife, Antonina, became fond of Teodosius, as was appropriate, since the young man had become her son on account of the baptismal ceremony. However, during their journey to Libya, her love turned into an insatiable passion and she began to meet Teodosius secretly. According to Procopius the situation degenerated even further, and, once it became known, caused an extremely grave scandal. The story shows how at the time of Justinian, relations between godparents and godchildren roused indignation and not, it would seem, because of a violation of recent imperial precepts, but on account of a feeling of decorum that was common in various Christian communities. What is more, the scandal arose not from the relationship between godfather and goddaughter, but from that between the wife of the godfather (Antonina) and the godson of her husband (Teodosius). The perceived limits of incest are thus more extensive than those laid down by law. Procopius of Caesarea, Secret History, 1.1. 13
Godparenthood and Spiritual Kinship
19
(canon 4), which was widely publicized and had an enormous influence. It was an important step, as for the first time a ban on marriage on account of spiritual kinship was recognized by the West. Gregory II probably also encouraged its inclusion in the edict of 72314 of the Longobard king, Liutprand, which, moreover, envisaged a ban on marriage between a godson and the daughter of the godparent, as they also were to be considered spiritual kin. This is the principle of the fraternitas spiritualis (‘spiritual brotherhood’); when fully established, it resulted in a ban on marriages between all the children of a given godfather or godmother and all their godsons and goddaughters. It is necessary to refer to the Eastern Church also for the formulation of the principle of the fraternitas spiritualis. It is significant that its date is close to Liutprand’s edict. Recognizing the fact that after two centuries the Justinian Code was not only obsolete but had been written in a language (Latin) that in the Byzantine Empire was now little known, the Emperor Leo III and his son Constantine V put forward an ambitious project to prepare a new code, known as Ecloga (‘Selection’), which was published in 726 or 741. Its provisions on marriage seem to be influenced far more by Christian regulations than by the Justinian Code. Regarding the interdictions on marriage for spiritual kinship, as well as those already in existence, another two were now recognized: between the children of the godfather and his godchildren, linked by fraternitas spiritualis, and between the sons of the godfather and his compadri, that is, those who were connected to him by compaternitas spiritualis, in other words the parents of his godchildren. Furthermore, the existence of spiritual kinship was recognized along with the relative ban on marriage also between the person baptizing and the person baptized.15 According to Joseph H. Lynch, the Ecloga reveals a tendency to extend the same impediment to marriage for spiritual kinship as for natural kinship (Lynch 1986, pp. 230–234). He also surmises that, as in the case of the Justinian Code of 530, customs already adopted by the population were simply being officially recognized; there is, however, no proof of this. The West’s complete acceptance of the precepts of the Ecloga concerning spiritual brotherhood was not long in coming. Pope Zacharias (741–752), replying in a letter to a question posed by the Bishop of Pavia, Theodore, on 14
On the troubled history of the reception in the West of the Trullan Synod, Lynch 1986 pp. 234–240. 15 Although, at the time, anyone could celebrate baptism in cases of emergency, normally it was the responsibility of the clergy. In the Byzantine Church, priests could only marry before their ordination, that is, before they were able to celebrate baptism. The marriage restriction that had the most practical importance, therefore, was that which took place between the children whom a priest had had before ordination and the children whom he baptized, who were related by fraternitas spiritualis.
20
Fathers and Godfathers
whether it was opportune to allow a man to marry the goddaughter of his father, declares that it is so horrible that it should not even be mentioned; and taking up an issue already discussed at the Trullan Synod, he implies that spiritual incest is even worse than that between blood relations (Lynch 1982, pp. 240–242). Zacharias also played a key role in the diffusion of the regulations governing spiritual kinship between the Franks and the Anglo-Saxons, populations who seemingly knew virtually nothing of the impediments to marriage for spiritual kinship until the eighth century (Lynch 1986, p. 247). The innovation met considerable resistance on the part of local clergy, but in the end papal authority managed to prevail, above all thanks to the growing political détente between the papacy and the Franks. In 813 the Council of Châlons-sur-Marne examined an interesting abuse. It seems that some women acted as godmothers to their own children in order to obtain a separation from their spouses; the condition of compaternitas had been created between them and this was considered to be a valid reason for the annulment of marriage. Perhaps to avoid this kind of situation, in the same year the Council of Mainz forbade parents to act as godparents to their own children (Fine 1994, p. 22). In fact, the custom of resorting to a spiritual kinship to obtain divorce, which otherwise would have been illegitimate, was a real cliché in canon law, to be found throughout the whole of the Middle Ages.16 Following the ban on being godparents to their own children, the custom was to ‘realize’ that there was a spiritual connection pre-existing the marriage, which up to that moment had been ‘forgotten’. Given the considerable extent of marriage impediments due to baptism and the large number of godfathers and godmothers for each ceremony, this could not have been a difficult path to follow. Obviously there were scandals which, in different circumstances, led the Council of Trent to take drastic action. From the tenth century, the Eastern Church continued to extend the interdictions on marriage due to baptism to include all the blood relations of the godson and all the blood relations of the godparent to the same degree already recognized for consanguinity (Fine 1994, pp. 25–26). For the time being, I will leave the circumstances of the Eastern Church, concentrating instead on the territories that were under papal authority. Besides, the Schism of the East (1054) abruptly reduced the capacity of the two sides of Christianity to influence each other. In 1140, some of the ancient texts were included in the canonical collection of Gratian, which would be widely circulated and largely used also in the following centuries. In it we find a clear description of the 16 On the other hand, similar occurrences are to be found in the case of ‘natural’ kinship: see Duby 1981.
Godparenthood and Spiritual Kinship
21
three components of the ‘system’ of spiritual kinship in use at the time, which are worth recapitulating: the paternitas, or the direct link between godfathers, godmothers, the person who administered baptism and the godchild; the compaternitas that linked godfathers, godmothers and the minister of baptism to the parents of their godchild; the fraternitas that established spiritual kinship between the natural children of the godfathers, the godmothers and the minister of baptism and their godchild.17 If we supplement the picture provided by the Decretum Gratiani with commentaries dedicated to it, for example that of Etienne de Tournay,18 an even more complex picture emerges. As well as the relationships quoted above, considered ‘direct’, there are others that are ‘indirect’: between the godchild and the spouses of the godfathers, of the godmothers and of the minister of baptism; and between the parents of the child and the spouses of their godfathers, godmothers and the minister of baptism.19 All these people are connected by spiritual kinship, and consequently separated by the barrier of incest. This extension of spiritual kinship corresponds to the one generally recognized by the Catholic world on the eve of the Council of Trent. In the years following Gratian’s decree, however, there were attempts to further extend the boundaries of spiritual incest. In 1355, the Council of Prague counted 21 cases of legally recognized impediments to marriage, including a ban on unions between godparents and the children and grandchildren of their godchildren and between the children of godparents and brothers and sisters of the baptized (Fine 1994, p. 22). The comments made up to now on the relationship between the way incest was perceived and the positive law that ‘officially’ recognized its existence must not lead us to believe that, always and everywhere, it implied a juridical acceptance of a common sentiment. In fact, if it is certain that at the origins of the oldest positive laws on spiritual incest there was what was considered scandalous conduct, these norms were applied over very large areas characterized by different customs and traditions. I have already hinted at the difficulties the papal authority encountered when trying to 17
Decretum Gratiani, in J. P. Migne, PL, CLXXXVII. Cited in Guerreau-Jalabert 1995, pp. 172–174. 19 This is the compaternitas indirecta, that was constituted on the basis of the principle of unitas carnis between husband and wife. For a correct distinction between the various forms of spiritual kinship according to canon law, see Iung 1937. It is to be noted that the indirect forms of spiritual kinship were already expressly mentioned in texts collected in Decretum Gratiani: the purpose of commentaries was to systematically order and clarify the distinction between direct and indirect forms. Note also that the Church has never recognized the existence of spiritual kinship between godfathers and godmothers, despite the fact that sometimes in works on godparenthood, (mistaken) affirmations to the contrary are to be found. 18
Fathers and Godfathers
22
get the notion of spiritual incest recognized in the land of the Franks. An extremely interesting case was debated at the synod of Florence in 1517. It dealt with the issue of cases of spiritual incest between godparents and godchildren, which were frequent when the two were of the opposite sex and more or less the same age. Its statutes affirm that when they occurred it was because of a popular belief that between the parties a state had been created of familiare consortium (‘familial closeness’), where marriage was the natural consequence.20 The local population, then, had a very different conception of spiritual incest from the ecclesiastical authorities. The passage is interesting for other reasons. First, it gives us a clue to the real significance of spiritual kinship, or to the way in which it conditioned and shaped the relationship between those who were connected by it.21 Second, it is an important witness of how, on the very eve of the Council of Trent, the Church still encountered enormous difficulties in imposing its point of view on populations that tended to develop autonomously their own ideas of godparenthood. Due to the canon laws in force at the beginning of the sixteenth century, which potentially were complicated by local customs of which we know very little, numerous bonds of spiritual kinship were created for each godparent, given also that the relations of the godparent and those of his godchildren were involved. The abundance of ties of spiritual kinship is remarkable insofar as in vast areas of Europe extremely large numbers of godfathers and godmothers accompanied each baptism. Up to now scant attention has been paid to this fact. Instead, it is crucial to our full understanding of the importance of the Tridentine reform of godparenthood and the social transformation that it generated. We can say that if recognized as one of the key events in the history of godparenthood, it gives us a new perspective on godparenthood as a social institution. Like spiritual kinship, it would also seem that the number of godparents present at each baptism increased as time went by. However, unlike in the case of spiritual kinship, the Church neither supported nor approved this trend; the history of the norms governing the number of spiritual kinsmen is basically the history of repeated attempts to suppress customs that were spreading autonomously in various parts of Europe.
20
In this case, popular beliefs seem to go in the opposite direction to the tendency to extend the limits of spiritual incest beyond those laid down by canon law, which has been indicated by different sources for preceding periods. However, it is to be noted that what has been observed for the Florentine diocese can in no way be generalized or extended to other areas of Christendom; the fact that the customs connected to godparenthood differed considerably from one area to another commends extreme caution. 21 The statutes of the Synod of Florence have been interpreted and discussed from this point of view by John Bossy (1979, p. 443).
Godparenthood and Spiritual Kinship
23
Originally, each child baptized had only one godfather or godmother, normally of the same sex as the child. It is difficult to establish exactly when this situation began to change. Lynch, for example, connects this transformation with the collapse of traditional rules that took place during the ninth century.22 Actually, we do not know whether, perhaps only in certain areas, it had been customary for some time to appoint numerous godfathers and godmothers. The only thing that seems certain, on the basis of the few sources available, is that from the ninth century the Church began to fight against the spread of practices that increased the number of godparents, something it had perhaps simply chosen to ignore up to then. It is difficult to judge how effective these actions were, but everything leads us to believe that they were unsuccessful: first of all, because they were repeated in the course of time, and secondly, because during the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, when the first records of baptisms appeared, enabling us to check what really happened, we discover customs that radically deviated from the norms. Already at the end of the ninth century, the Council of Metz (893) attempted to impose a return to the old tradition of the single godparent. Canon 6 states: ‘Not two or more [persons] receive the child at the baptismal font, but only one, as a move in this direction would offer an opening to the devil and would belittle the reverence due to such a great ministry. In fact, one [is] God, one baptism, one, who receives him at the font, must [therefore] be the [spiritual] father or mother of the child’.23 It is a firm and strongly worded condemnation of the practice of multiple godparents. Efforts by the Church to contain the so-called ‘proliferation’ of godparents24 continued in the following centuries. In the thirteenth century, Pope Boniface VIII’s desire to reinstate the tradition of the single godparent was frustrated (Bossy 1979, p. 443; Signorini 1981, p. 32). During the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, it seems that many councils tried to reach a sort of compromise, proposing a model that contemplated two godfathers and one godmother for boys and vice versa for girls.25 Producing various examples, Abbot Corblet commented that, 22
Lynch observes that from this moment there is no way of satisfactorily estimating the average number of godparents present at the ceremonies (Lynch 1986, pp. 205–206). 23 ‘... et infantem nequaquam duo vel plures, sed unus a fonte baptismatis suscipiat, quia in hujuscemodi secta diabolo datur locus, et tanti ministerii reverentia vilescit. Nam unus Deus, unum baptismum, unus, qui a fonte suscipit, debet esse Pater vel Mater infantis’ (Council of Metz, Canon 6, taking the quotation from Lynch 1986, p. 209). 24 That is, their tendency to become ever more numerous. Here I am using an expression originally coined by Lynch 1986. 25 Among others, the Councils of Salisbury (1217), Trèves (1227), Compiègne (1229), Worcester (1240), Cologne (1281), Exeter (1287). Corblet 1881–1882, p. 204.
Fathers and Godfathers
24
despite the Council’s instructions, the ternary number was exceeded with no great difficulty. Besides, many synodal statutes were expressly more tolerant.26 The ‘ternary model’, preferred by the councils of the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, corresponds to a practice already in use in many areas for some time, as Hugh of St. Victor (c.1096–1141) witnesses; his own recommendation is that there should be a limit of one godfather or godmother.27 Sometimes the regulations aimed at limiting the number of spiritual kin were spectacularly infringed. Corblet reported that in the late Middle Ages, in certain parts of France and Switzerland, there were those who had as godparent a body made up of numerous people (for example an entire city, a village or a guild; Corblet 1881–1882, p. 205). This has to some extent been confirmed by Christiane Klapisch-Zuber’s research on Florence. In the fifteenth century, a significant number of children who were baptized had, as ‘collective godparents’, a college, a magistracy, a guild or a monastery.28 At the Council of Basel in 1432 the impression we get is that the Church seems to be losing control over the institution of godparenthood: one of those convened makes the comment that ‘in some provinces men run in droves from all over the place to receive an infant at the sacred font’.29 At the time of the Council of Basel, the considerable confusion in the customs actually practised corresponded to a confusion in local norms (whether or not they were respected), despite the already mentioned approval of the ternary model, which, however, was far less commonly adopted than is generally believed. If we take France as an example, we can see from the synodal statutes of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries that only one spiritual parent was allowed at Dax and Cahors, one or two
26
The Synod of Cambrai, before the fourteenth century, permitted two godfathers and two godmothers, to whom could be added two secular priests and two nuns; the Synod of Tournay of 1481 consented to go beyond the three godparents provided they shared the same office (e.g. members of a certain magistracy) or if they were members of the clergy (Corblet 1881–1882, p. 205), and the Synod of Chartres permitted three or four spiritual kin (Adam 1964, pp. 267–269). The Council of Canerich, held in Germany in 1300, permitted up to eight sponsores of baptism, of whom four were lay people and four from the clergy (Kearney 1925, p. 44). In Spain, an edict of the Order of Santiago de la Espada of 1440 cautioned priests not to allow more than two godfathers and two godmothers (Foster 1953, p. 4). 27 Hugh of St. Victor, De Sacramentis Christianae Fidei, in J. P. Migne, PL, CLXXVI, col. 458. 28 Klapisch-Zuber has calculated that 5 per cent of the children mentioned in the books of Ricordanze which she consulted had a collective godparent (Klapisch-Zuber 1990, pp. 126–127). 29 ‘… passim currunt in nonnullis provinciis homines catervatim ad levandum puerum de sacro fonte’ (taken from a quotation from Bossy 1979, p. 443).
Godparenthood and Spiritual Kinship
25
at Bourges, two at Châlons, three at Bayeux, Nantes and Arras, three or four at Chartres, and four at Cambrai.30 In time the canon law governing the number of spiritual parents, originally regulated by ecumenical norms, had become fragmentary, alongside the growing confusion in local customs. It was only with the Council of Trent that a return to a common legislation throughout the Catholic Church was possible, although it now had to face a new kind of juridical fragmentation on a territorial basis, due to the loss of vast territories caused by the Reformation gaining ground. Something even more remarkable is that the Council of Trent, as well as making uniform the legislative situation, managed to standardize the practices actually in use, and, at least apparently, succeeded in transforming them into its own model of godparenthood. For the moment, the point that needs to be underlined is that in the long term the Church encountered considerable difficulties in controlling the practices connected to the institution of godparenthood. This is clearly apparent if we look at the number of godparents allowed, and if we take into consideration the fact that the repeated attempts to limit them were regularly ignored, except perhaps in specific areas and at the cost of compromise. As for the extension of spiritual kinship and the relative matrimonial bans, the situation is different because the endeavour to impose norms did not contrast so strongly with the customs in use among the population. Rather, the imposing of norms seems to have followed and ratified a development of the Christian communities that was to some extent autonomous, even though the sources available are insufficient to enable us to reach irrefutable conclusions. The picture is further complicated by the fact that these communities did not share the same idea of spiritual kinship and their ability to influence the formulation of rules differed. The question is a complex one and deserves specific research. Here I will limit myself to stressing what is essential. It is undeniable that, in the two cases mentioned (the number of godparents permitted and the extension of spiritual kinship), the relationship between the Church and the population is qualitatively different: total opposition on the issue of the number of godparents,31 and substantial acquiescence, while not an active and ‘creative’ contribution, on the question of spiritual incest. 30
Adam 1964, pp. 267–269, except for Arras, whose synodal statues of 1350–1354 were examined by Delmaire (1983), and for Cambrai, whose source is Corblet (1881–1882, p. 205). 31 Actually, the position of the Church as a whole needs to be distinguished from that of its individual members. In fact, in various places the clergy were included among the most highly regarded godparents. On the other hand, they had a stronger than normal personal interest in establishing spiritual kinship ties, as they were excluded from marriage alliances. As parish priests they not infrequently served in communities that were diffident, if not hostile,
26
Fathers and Godfathers
The Church, therefore, which had ‘invented’ godparenthood and spiritual kinship, saw it rapidly getting out of control. In a certain sense, the population valued this social institution too highly, and this is clearly apparent in the uncontrolled proliferation of godparents. It would, however, be a mistake to maintain that the disobedience of the population in respect of ecclesiastical precepts was the same everywhere. It was rather that the problem was largely due to the wide variety of local models of godparenthood, which complicated not a little the task of regulating the various customs. In fact, each community claimed the right to keep its own customs, which distinguished it from others, and this was the main argument of those who at the Council of Trent opposed a reduction in the number of godparents. What exactly did this ‘fragmentation of customs’ comprise? What were its characteristics and what was its extent? Finally, what was its significance: why did the parents of the infants to be baptized have an interest in wanting more or fewer godfathers and godmothers? And why was the Church alarmed by the presence of a large number of godparents at a baptism? It is imperative to answer these questions if we are to understand the reasons which, in the middle of the sixteenth century, led ecclesiastical authorities drastically to reform godparenthood.
towards them. They could therefore reap considerable benefits from an institution such as godparenthood, which, like marriage, could generate formal relationships or friendship. Therefore it can be said that the hope of being asked to be a godparent tended to make them favourable to the practice of attributing numerous spiritual kin. See Alfani 2004b.
CHAPTER 2
Godparents and Compari between the Fifteenth and Sixteenth Centuries: a Wide Variety of Local Customs Between the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, the synods and councils which examined the problems associated with godparenthood give the impression that there was considerable discrepancy among local customs. As a consequence, children were often given more godfathers and godmothers than seemed appropriate. If, on the one hand, these sources enable us to state that the proliferation of godparents was quite common, they do not allow us to obtain a detailed analysis of the practices concerning this phenomenon. To do this, it is necessary to rely on documents that can provide more information: for example memorials (libri di ricordanze) or family records (libri di famiglia). These documents, however, usually have the defect of providing information that is restricted to social groups and well-defined milieux, and do not permit an analysis that covers the whole population. It may seem strange, but the source that best enables us to obtain information about parents and godparents of baptized infants, namely the parish registers of baptisms, has very rarely been used to study more remote times, and especially those before the Council of Trent. In these registers the parish priest or his assistant noted the date when the baptism was celebrated, the name given to the infant, the personal details of the father, the name of the mother (with or without her maiden name) and the personal details of the godparents, including any title they might have had, where they came from and, sometimes, their profession. While the information contained in the registers could vary from place to place and from one parish priest to another, by and large they are quite well-endowed sources, which enable us to reconstruct a network of relationships whose contents and effects can then be examined using different documents.
These sources have been used especially by Christiane Klapisch-Zuber (1990). I will analyse her results in detail later.
Fathers and Godfathers
28
All infants baptized had to be registered regardless of fortune and rank, including illegitimate offspring and foundlings. It is quite possible that the reasons why parish registers have been underused in the study of pre-Tridentine godparenthood were, on the one hand, a mistaken conviction that none was old enough, except for rare cases, and, on the other, the fact that their importance was not recognized because, according to Mintz and Wolf (1950), at the end of the Middle Ages godparenthood was already on the decline. I discussed the second point in the Introduction. As for the first, it is true that it was only the Council of Trent, which drew to its close in 1563, that established that parish priests were required to record the celebration of baptisms and weddings in special registers. However, in issuing the regulations governing the registration of baptisms, the Council was merely accepting that the practices widespread in many areas, including northern Italy, should be made universal (Alfani 2003b). Thanks to parish registers that go back to the second half of the fifteenth century or the first part of the sixteenth, I have been able accurately to reconstruct, for numerous communities in northern Italy, the customs in force before the Council concerning the number of godfathers and godmothers ascribed to each infant baptized. For eight of these communities I have collected a wide sample of baptisms (all the baptisms celebrated from the time when registers began to be kept to well into the seventeenth century). I have thus dispelled any doubts about the statistical relevance of the results. The area covered, from west to east, comprises Turin, Ivrea, Azeglio in Piedmont, Finale in Liguria, Bellano and Voghera in Lombardy, Mirandola in Emilia-Romagna and Gambellara in Veneto. These communities are situated in areas that are quite different one from the other, and in the sixteenth century were under different governments. Each of them differed in size, social organization, prevailing economic activity and so
For an evaluation of the baptismal registers as sources for historical demography, see Corsini 1974. Ivrea, Turin and Azeglio were part of the Duchy of Savoy. Turin became its capital in 1560. Bellano and Voghera were part of the Duchy of Milan and regularly shared its fate. The Counts Dal Verme were the lords of Voghera, even though towards the end of the sixteenth century they lost their feudal domain. Finale Ligure was an imperial fiefdom under the lordship of the Del Carretto. In that period it was divided into three burgs, Finalborgo, Finale Marina and Finale Pia. For a long time Finale was a thorn in the flesh of the Republic of Genoa, which finally acquired it in 1713. Mirandola was the ‘capital’ of the county of the same name, with the investiture of the Pico family, who were given a dukedom in 1617. Gambellara, a rural community in the countryside of Vicenza, belonged to the Republic of Venice.
Godparents and Compari
29
on: all factors that probably influenced the choice of godfathers and godmothers both in terms of numbers and the composition of the group from which each parent could choose the spiritual kin, and in terms of the considerations which led them to prefer one person rather than another. For reasons of space, I am not able here to give detailed information for each locality, so I will limit myself to highlighting, where necessary, some key points. In Table 2.1 I have recorded the percentage of baptisms where one, two, three or more godfathers were present for each locality studied; Table 2.2 shows the same data for godmothers. I have put together the baptisms of boys and girls, as the sex of the child made little difference to the number of godfathers and godmothers for each infant. The data span the period between the date of the beginning of records and 1562 (the year before the conclusion of the Council of Trent), except for any gap in the sources. The interval differs from place to place: in Ivrea, which has the oldest registers, the first records go back to 1473,
I will limit myself to giving some demographic data, which will help to give an idea of the existence of a town rather than a rural community, as well as a more or less developed and varied society. Turin, which had 14,244 inhabitants in 1517, by 1612 had increased to 24,410. The tumultuous demographic and urban growth that this city experienced in those years was due to the move in 1563 of the Court of Savoy from Chambéry. Over those same years Ivrea’s population grew from 3,031 to 4,467, still a long way from the 5,300 inhabitants that Beloch estimated in 1377 (in the same year, the number of inhabitants estimated for Turin was only 3,500). All in all, the sixteenth century was a period of demographic and economic stagnation for cities because of the suffering and consequences caused on various occasions by the Wars of Italy. For Finale, I have an estimate of the population only for Final Borgo which probably counted about 2,000 inhabitants around 1500 (Beloch 1994). The figure that Beloch suggests for Voghera for 1576 (1,600 inhabitants) is unacceptable as in no way does it correspond to the number of baptisms celebrated in the city around that date. If we take the birth rate as 38 per 1,000, we can conjecture that for that same year the population was 7,000 inhabitants (there were in fact 254 baptisms). I have estimated about 3,800 inhabitants for the mid century by taking the average number of baptisms celebrated in the period 1545– 1555 and assuming a birth rate of 38 per 1,000. Authors other than Beloch make estimates that are substantially in line with my calculations. For example, Manfredi (1908) affirms that in 1586 the city had more than 8,000 inhabitants. As for Azeglio, Bellano, Gambellara and Mirandola, as I do not have other estimates, I have made my own calculations using the same procedure as for Voghera. The result is that towards the mid century Azeglio had about 850 inhabitants, Bellano 660, Gambellara 680 and Mirandola 3,200. Here it is not my intention to make estimates that are absolutely correct from a statistical point of view, but to give a rough idea of the size of each community. On this subject, it would obviously be important to know which families made up the local elite, the relationship between them, if there were disagreements within the community, and so on. Among the centres I have studied, Mirandola had for a long time been the seat of a court, and in mid-sixteenth century Turin welcomed the court of Savoy. The Pico family in Mirandola and certain members of the Savoy Court in Turin (I only have at my disposal data for the parish of S. Agostino) were particularly popular as godparents. I will come back to this in Chapter 7.
30
Fathers and Godfathers
while in Turin, the ‘latest’ to record baptisms, the records only go back as far as 1551. I felt it was preferable to emphasize the extent of the samples of baptisms rather than their perfect chronological coherence; and in any case, in the period in question godparenthood models had from time immemorial been consolidated and were stable. First of all, let us consider the godfathers. The most important distinction between local models is between where there were ‘many’ and where there were just a ‘few’. On the one hand, we find Bellano, Ivrea, Turin, Azeglio and Voghera, where on average there were more than two godfathers for each baptism and where it is relatively rare to find only one or none (in 16.6 per cent of the cases in Bellano, in 28 per cent in Ivrea, in 26.9 per cent in Turin, in 19.4 per cent in Azeglio and only 10 per cent in Voghera). On the other hand, in Finale, Gambellara and Mirandola, on average the godfathers are decidedly less than two for each baptism. However, the case of Finale is in turn different from that of Mirandola: in Finale there are two godfathers in the absolute majority of baptisms (51 per cent) and in certain cases their number reaches three or four, while in Mirandola the norm is for one godfather, sometimes two, rarely three and almost never four or more. If we keep in mind the social customs and possible strategies for the selection of spiritual kin, this difference is not something to be underestimated. Gambellara represents a case which is about halfway between Finale and Mirandola.
For Ivrea, I have used four registers of the baptisms in the parish of S. Ulderico, concerning the periods 1473–1505, 1524–1585, 1586–1610 and 1587–1800 (parish archive of the Cathedral of Ivrea). The last register contains the original registrations regarding 1611–1800, as well as a copy of those of 1586–1610. No entries are available for the years 1506–1523. For Azeglio, I have used the oldest parish register, covering the years 1543– 1599, after which there is a long gap in entries (parish archive of Azeglio). For Turin, I have used the register of the parish of S. Agostino in Turin spanning 1551–1617 (parish archive of S. Agostino of Turin). For Bellano, I used a register of the parish of the SS. Giorgio, Nazaro and Celso, for 1533–1639 (parish archive of Bellano) For Voghera, I used four registers of the parish of S. Lorenzo (the Cathedral) for the periods 1534–1566, 1534–1570, 1567–1591 and 1592–1621 (archive of the Cathedral of Voghera). For Finale Ligure, I have resorted to the two registers of the parish of S. Maria, part of the Abbey of Finalpia, for the periods 1481–1592 and 1593–1644 (archive of the Abbey of Finalpia). For Gambellara, I used six registers of the parish of S. Pietro Apostolo, for the years 1541–1554, 1555–1564, 1564–1579, 1592–1609, 1609–1617 and 1617–1699 (archive of the Diocese of Vicenza). For Mirandola, I worked on seven registers of S. Maria Maggiore (Cathedral) for the years 1484–1521, 1521–1556, 1556–1568, 1568–1575, 1575–1586, 1587–1599 and 1600–1613 (archive of the Cathedral of Mirandola). This is confirmed by the figures in Chapter 5.
Table 2.1
Average number of godfathers in northern Italy (up to 1562)
Godfathers per baptism (%)
Bellano
Ivrea
Turin
Azeglio
Voghera
Finale
Gambellara
Mirandola
0
1.74
0.93
6.48
0.51
0.37
1.74
1.23
0.46
1
14.81
27.09
20.37
18.87
10.16
43.44
63.32
85.36
2
31.18
34.52
30.56
32.08
62.99
51.02
30.51
13.16
3
27.87
18.51
17.59
46.83
24.33
3.48
4.41
0.90
4
11.67
8.29
16.67
1.20
1.98
0.31
0.53
0.11
5
6.45
5.07
6.49
0.17
0.17
0
0
0.04
>5
6.27
5.57
1.85
0.17
0
0
0
0.02
Average number of godfathers
2.86
2.55
2.44
2.34
2.18
1.57
1.4
1.15
Number of baptisms
574
1,399
108
583
4,085
976
567
8,449
First year of records
1533
1473
1551
1543
1534
1481
1541
1484
Table 2.2
Average number of godmothers in northern Italy (up to 1562) Mirandola
Godmothers per baptism (%)
Bellano
Ivrea
Turin
Azeglio
Voghera
Finale
Gambellara
0
3.31
27.49
81.48
2.40
99.83
3.89
1.59
1.04
1
35.37
37.69
7.41
52.83
0.17
46.21
64.73
79.85
2
21.78
22.66
5.56
31.90
0
45.9
28.40
17.96
3
18.99
7.72
0
12.35
0
3.89
5.31
1.12
4
10.63
2.79
3.70
0.51
0
0.10
0.18
0.06
5
5.92
1.14
1.85
0
0
0
0
0.01
>5
4.01
0.57
0
0
0
0
0
0
Average number of godmothers
2.35
1.27
0.43
1.60
0
1.50
1.38
Number of baptisms
574
1,399
108
583
4,085
976
567
8,449
First year of records
1533
1473
1551
1543
1534
1481
1541
1484
1.19
Godparents and Compari
33
The differences within the first group (the one with numerous godfathers) are fewer. The Piedmontese localities and Bellano are rather similar, while Voghera differs in two ways. First, there is a fairly restricted upper limit to the number of godfathers allowed, as I have not found baptisms with more than five godfathers. Second, in Voghera the idea of giving only one godfather to children seems to have been much less acceptable than in Turin or in Ivrea, which brings it closer to Bellano. Apart from these limited differences, looking only at the godfathers, it seems sufficient to distinguish between places where there are ‘many’ and places where there are ‘few’. The situation changes, however, if godmothers are taken into consideration. In their case, the most important distinction is not between where there are ‘many’ and where there are ‘few’, but between where ‘they are present’ and where ‘they are absent’. In Ivrea, Azeglio, Bellano, Finale, Gambellara and Mirandola they are almost always present (respectively in 72.5 per cent, 97.6 per cent, 96.7 per cent, 96.1 per cent, 98.4 per cent and 99 per cent of the cases), while in Turin and Voghera they are almost never present (in 18.5 per cent and in 0.2 per cent of the cases). Where godmothers are present, their number corresponds to that of the godfathers: they are numerous where the godfathers are numerous and only a few where there are just a few godfathers, bearing in mind that on average there tend to be fewer female spiritual kin than male. Where godmothers are absent, we come across appreciable differences from one case to another. In Turin the godmother, present at one in about five baptisms, is quite rare, although it was a known and an accepted practice to ask for one. In Voghera, godmothers were an unknown figure: out of 4,085 baptisms celebrated over a 27-year period, I found them in only seven ceremonies. If we take the eight communities into consideration as a whole, it is clear that there was no general rule that correlated the number of godfathers and godmothers, as is shown by the examples of Turin and Voghera. Moreover, when there were godmothers present, going from the aggregate figures to single baptisms I discovered there were no norms, either positive or customary, that required the infants to be given the same number of godfathers and godmothers; usually the godfathers were the same number or more numerous than the godmothers, but sometimes it was the second group that was predominant. Summing up, the eight localities that have been taken into consideration appear to have adopted at least four different models of godparenthood:
34
Fathers and Godfathers
1. Ivrea, Azeglio and Bellano: many godfathers and many godmothers, with no established limits that obliged the parents not to exceed a certain number of spiritual kin; 2. Turin: many godfathers with no established limits, but only a few godmothers, who were present at about one baptism in five; 3. Voghera: many godfathers, though never more than five, but practically no godmothers; 4. Finale, Gambellara and Mirandola: relatively few godfathers, one or two as a rule, and never more than four (in Mirandola, in extremely rare cases six are reached). Godmothers are always present and on average in the same numbers as the godfathers. If closely examined, the differences between these models, constructed empirically, can be attributed to three variables: the more or less copious supply of godfathers; whether or not godmothers were present; the existence of a clear limit to the maximum number of godfathers allowed. As we will see, these variables can be used to propose a typology of godparenthood models, which is essential to highlight more effectively how different customs were distributed within a region. The notion of ‘limit’ to the number of godfathers ‘allowed’ must be clarified. Generally speaking, what is intended is a ‘social admissibility’ rather than a legal one, in the sense that in each community it was or was not socially correct to choose a certain number of godfathers. It is obviously possible that, in some places, positive norms helped to contain the number of godparents, while on the other hand, the Church’s attempts to regulate godparenthood go back to long before the Council of Trent, and were undertaken both at a general and at a local level. However, we know that the precepts urbi et orbi which determined the number of godfathers were largely ignored, and I discovered no traces of norms issued by local ecclesiastical authorities in the communities studied. I will return to this later. The eight communities already mentioned themselves suggest that there was considerable variation in customs, and that the territorial fragmentation of the practices connected with the choice of godparents was surprisingly high. This impression is confirmed by the information that we can deduce from some studies, unfortunately limited to three areas of Italy: the Republic of Venice, Tuscany and the Kingdom of Naples. In the Republic of Venice, it would seem that in the capital the heirs to the nobility had at least 20 godparents and sometimes up to 100. This information, reported by the Abbot Corblet, has been declared credible
Godparents and Compari
35
by recent writers, in my view rather uncritically and it should at least be checked. It is anyway almost certain that in Venice godfathers were extremely numerous, in line with the situation on the Venetian mainland. We know that in the sixteenth century, the heirs to the families belonging to the elite of Verona and Vicenza usually had two spiritual kinsmen, and in some cases more (three, rarely four, at the most five). Often the spiritual kin were all males; also for girls godmothers appear in less than a third of the baptisms (Grubb 1996). For Treviso, studies carried out on a considerable number of baptisms, celebrated at the beginning of the fifteenth century and not confined merely to the elite, have revealed a similar situation.10 The case of Gambellara, previously examined, is comparable to that of Verona and Vicenza, as far as the number of godfathers is concerned, but is radically different if godmothers are taken into account (there is at least one in 98.1 per cent of the baptisms). Gambellara is in the countryside near Vicenza; for the same area the study of a sample of 117 baptisms celebrated at Santorso in the years 1538–154011 has revealed the presence of numerous godfathers (an average of 2.33 per baptism), godmothers being almost always in attendance (in 79.5 per cent of the ceremonies) and quite numerous (an average of 1.44 per baptism), with no precise limit for the maximum number of godfathers and godmothers allowed. It should be underlined that, within the Republic of Venice, the customs of godparenthood change according to the place but, as will be seen, they do not seem to be conditioned by political boundaries. The cases of Verona, Vicenza and Treviso were very much like those described for Turin (numerous godfathers, few godmothers, who, however, were by no means unknown), except for the fact that no baptisms with more than five godfathers are recorded. If we give credence to Corblet, the case of Venice is different insofar as it seems there was no limit to the proliferation of godfathers. It would be interesting, though, to know whether it was customary among the whole population, and whether or not there were godmothers. Santorso’s customs of godparenthood were very similar to those found in Ivrea and Bellano (lots of godfathers and godmothers, with no clear limit). Finally, Gambellara is a case on its own (similar to Finale Ligure): unlike Santorso or Venice, there was a fairly cogent limit to the number of spiritual kin allowed (never more than four). Corblet 1881–1882. For Venice Corblet does not base his convictions on his own research, but reports information given by the March 1725 number of the Mercure de France. 10 Based on data yet to be published, the result of the patient research of Matthieu Scherman, who very kindly put his findings at my disposal. 11 Diocesan archive of Vicenza, register of the baptisms of Santorso, 1536–1565.
Fathers and Godfathers
36
For Tuscany, Louis Haas and Christiane Klapisch-Zuber have studied Florentine godparenthood thoroughly (Haas 1998, Klapisch-Zuber 1990); the latter, especially, supplies quantitative data on the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. Godfathers were numerous also in Florence, given that at half the baptisms, at least, three spiritual kin were present, but often many more: in 2.5 per cent of the cases, more than 10, up to a maximum of 25. Normally (73 per cent of the cases), godmothers were absent, and, anyway, they were fewer in number than the godfathers, as they amounted to only 13 per cent of all the spiritual kin. Apparently, this model of godparenthood exactly matched the one in Turin. Completely different models of godparenthood to those described up to now are attested by Gérard Delille (1988) in the Kingdom of Naples. He concentrates in particular on two models, which, as they were already in force before the Council of Trent, are relevant here: one in Manduria in Apulia, where there were two godfathers and no godmothers, one in the villages in the hills round Salerno, where there was a godmother and only rarely, more or less according to the possibility of social betterment, a godfather. Among the models already mentioned, the only other case where godmothers never appeared is Voghera, where, however, unlike Manduria there were numerous godfathers, and anyway their numbers varied. I was unable to find traces, in northern Italy or anywhere else, of customs like the ones in force in the Salerno area. It is possible to go beyond this broad view of the diffusion of practices governing godparenthood, gathering available information for the rest of Europe, which unfortunately, is less systematic than that available for Italy. As for England and France, it is widely believed that from the Middle Ages a model was enforced (or, rather, it was enforced by a long list of synodal statutes) that decreed two godfathers and a godmother for boys, two godmothers and a godfather for girls. The famous sculptor, Benvenuto Cellini, finding himself in Paris in the year 1544, and having to have his daughter Costanza baptized, asks the king’s physician, Guido Guidi, to be present, and comments, ‘he was the only godfather, because in France the custom is for one godfather and two godmothers’.12 Actually, apart from Cellini’s comment and the probable prevalence of the ternary model, also in France it was anything but rare to find different customs in different places. In Cambrai, in 1550, popular pressure was such as to induce the diocesan synod to allow officially two godfathers and godmothers per baptism (Chaunu 1975). In Porrentruy (situated on 12
Cellini, Vita, book II, chapter 37 (‘fu lui solo compare, perchè in Francia così è il costume d’un solo compare e dua comare’). Some other examples of this ‘Parisian’ ternary model are contained in Angelo 2005, p. 367.
Godparents and Compari
37
the border between the Canton of Jura in Switzerland and France), even before the Council, the model of two godparents, that is, a godfather and a godmother, prevailed (Pegeot 1982). Further information can be deduced from family records. We know that in Arras the heirs to the Le Borgne family had, between the fourteenth and the fifteenth centuries, in 78.6 per cent of the cases, altogether three spiritual kin (according to the classical ‘French’ custom), in 10.7 per cent two godfathers and two godmothers, in 7.9 per cent one of each, in 3.6 per cent three and three (Delmaire 1983). At Brive, in the first half of the sixteenth century, only one godfather and one godmother took part in the baptism of the infants of the Malliard family (Cassan 1996). Even though France, in comparison with Italy, seems to be characterized by more moderation in the number of spiritual kin, there is no lack of evidence for the custom of multiple godparents. Joan of Arc is said to have had four godfathers and five godmothers, if we are to believe those who, 20 years after her execution, were questioned about her infancy. She herself, however, at the time of her trial recalled only two godfathers and three godmothers. The two groups do not exactly match: the list of possible spiritual kin involves altogether four men and eight women (Jussen 1992). As far as England is concerned, I am not aware of any specific cases which are an exception to the prevailing ternary models, but I would not be surprised if the situation was very much like the one in France, as, even today, ‘multi-godparenthood’ is to be found among Anglicans, a sign of the survival of ancient practices. Prince Charles, for example, has eight godparents.13 As regards Holland, we know that at least some of the local gentry in the first part of the sixteenth century accepted the ternary model (Marshall 1987). As for Denmark, the only available evidence comes from the Manuale Curatorum of the Church of Roskilde, that used precisely the same model as above: two godfathers and a godmother for boys and vice versa for girls.14 In other parts of Europe, the extremely sparse information to be found in historiography gives the impression of a situation similar to the multi-
13
His children William and Harry have three godfathers and three godmothers each. As far as we know at the moment, it cannot be excluded that the custom of giving numerous godfathers and godmothers does not depend on the survival of pre-Tridentine practices, but rather developed after the Reformation and the birth of the Anglican Church, at a time and along geographical routes unknown today. We cannot, moreover, exclude that these multigodparent practices were reserved to the nobility. 14 The note is taken from Societas Goerresiana, Concilium Tridentinum diariorum, actorum, epistularum tractatuum, Herder & Co., Freiburg 1901–1985, vol. VI, p. 491.
Fathers and Godfathers
38
godparent pattern in the centre and north of Italy, rather than the French and northern ternary model. As regards Spain, Foster recalls an edict of the Order of Santiago de la Espada, dated 1440, which exhorted priests not to accept more than two godfathers and two godmothers at baptisms, and the custom of the time was expressly criticized, as some infants were accompanied to the font by more than 20 godparents. The arguments used by the Order to justify the edict are interesting: as there is one father for carnal birth, there must be one for spiritual rebirth or a maximum of two, to honour the child and his parents (Foster 1953). However, in the village of San Nicolás of Granada, Bernard Vincent (1988) discovered a completely different picture. In fact, from a sample of 305 baptisms celebrated between 1549 and 1562 there were just 627 godparents (little more than two for each baptism). The case of San Nicolás, however, is special as it was a village that was mainly Moorish (90 per cent), recently ‘reconquered’ and converted; the end of Arab rule in Granada is dated 1492. The existence of legal clauses restricted the freedom of action of the moriscos, limiting the list of potential godparents only to ‘old Christians’ and probably preventing a more widespread use of comparatico, which, anyway, was new to them.15 For Switzerland, Simon Teuscher (1998) reports some cases of godparenthood in the city of Berne around the year 1500, from which it can be deduced that the number of godfathers at baptism was high (between two and four per ceremony). At Vallorbe, in the Vaud, Lucienne Hubler (1992) discovered an analogous trend for the second half of the sixteenth century; even though the Reformation had already been introduced, there is no reason to believe that the number of godparents was any different from that in preceding years. For Germany, I am not aware of studies which could be useful to reconstruct models of godparenthood in existence on the eve of the Reformation, but, as will be seen, Luther’s preaching and practices still
15
With a law of 20 June 1511, the Kingdom of Castile decreed that godfathers and godmothers of moriscos had to be ‘Old Christians’ (that is they belonged to families who were Christians before the Reconquest, and not converted Muslims); probably these norms were extended in 1525 to the Kingdom of Aragon. The moriscos protested against this law, not only because it was discriminatory, but also because it was difficult to apply in an area with no old Christians, so much so that often baptisms had to be delayed for several months. The lawmaker, when he became aware of these difficulties, on 27 June 1513 ordered old Christians to hold themselves responsible for the duties of godparenthood, and authorized them to ask the moriscos for payment for taking part in baptisms (thus reversing the onus of godparenthood). It is obvious that with a similar limitation to the ‘spiritual market’, it was ill advised to choose numerous godparents.
Godparents and Compari
39
to be found today lead us to believe that giving numerous godparents to children was a widespread custom.16 This unfortunately rather sketchy information concerning Europe can be usefully supplemented with other information inferred from the Acts of the Council of Trent. In fact, within the Council there was a split between those who were in favour of reducing the number of godparents and those who were against it, as they preferred to safeguard the age-old customs of the Church. If we take into account the origin of those who defended the numerous godparents, we have some indirect indications about the practices that were common in the areas not yet taken into consideration. We discover, therefore, that the Bishop of Uppsala, Olaus Magnus, was one of the most fervent opponents of the reduction in the number of spiritual kin, and thus we can conjecture that in his home country it was traditional to have more than one godfather at baptisms, as some research on the centuries immediately following the Council of Trent would seem to confirm.17 In the same way, there are pointers that suggest there was an abundance of godfathers in Scotland and Ireland (the Scot Robert Vauchop, Bishop of Armagh in Northern Ireland), for Flanders (Peter van der Vorst, Bishop of Acqui in Piedmont) and for Greece (Sebastiano Lecavela, Bishop of Naxos, and Gregorio Castagnola, Bishop of Melos, of French origin). Equally interesting indications concern better known areas: Worcester in England (Richard Pate) and Mirepoix in France (Claude de la Guische). In the party opposed to the reduction of godparents there was naturally no lack of bishops from many Italian cities (Arezzo, Bologna, Cingoli, Genoa, Naples, Rome, Siena). Despite the scarcity of information available for Europe as a whole, a factor worthy of reflection emerges. It is, in fact, possible to discern a split on the continent into two main areas:
16
The oldest example I know of is that of the Lutheran merchant Matheus Miller of Augsburg, who, around the mid-seventeenth century, gave his children three or four godfathers and godmothers altogether (Safley 2000, pp. 112–113). 17 At the beginning of the eighteenth century, in some areas of Sweden, the average number of spiritual kin per baptism was about six, with a maximum found up to now of 18. For example, at Helsimborg, between 1688 and 1709, the children normally had between five and eight spiritual kin, and up to a maximum of 12; 56 per cent of the total number were godmothers (Fagerlund 2000). A couple of centuries later, the situation had not changed: in the city of Umeå, the children baptized in the years 1850–1855 had an average of 4.9 godfathers each; I do not , however, have any data on the godmothers (Ericsson 2000). Solveig Fagerlund has suggested (on the basis of sources not stated in the material I consulted) that prior to the Reformation in Scandinavia, the spiritual kin were usually two or three altogether, and it was only later that the number increased, even though the local Reformed Church did not prescribe it (Fagerlund 2000, p. 348).
Fathers and Godfathers
40
• Northern Europe (England, Holland, Denmark, perhaps Sweden and the north of Germany) and France, where the ternary model prevailed; • Central and southern Europe (Italy, probably Spain and central southern Germany), characterized by a greater propensity to multiple godparenthood and, probably, by a greater fragmentation in the practices themselves. Obviously this is a provisional conclusion that merits verification. If confirmed, it would suggest that very early on in the Modern Era there was a serious fracture within European societies, as the chance to choose from a longer or shorter list of spiritual kin was of considerable social importance. Actually, up to now, the number of godfathers and godmothers present at baptism was thought to be an important element of a godparenthood model – indeed, sufficiently important to make it possible to distinguish different models. It raises the question, though, why the number of spiritual kinsmen should be considered so important, and anyway, whether it is possible to differentiate between models of godparenthood merely on the basis of numbers of godfathers and godmothers. If we think about the importance that relationships of spiritual kinship had and have in traditional societies, we must accept that the number of godparents allowed at a baptism is one of the foremost features of any model of godparenthood. Spiritual kinship was a fundamental means of consolidating networks of social alliances for reasons and in ways I will gradually specify. Therefore, the more godfathers and godmothers it was possible to choose at each baptism, the wider, denser and more solid these networks would be. Not only this, but the chance to choose a more or less extensive number of godfathers and godmothers conditioned the kind of selection strategies that could be put into practice. As will be seen, if we look at the reaction to the Tridentine regulations relating to the peoples who adopted the multi-godparent model, we have indirect confirmation of the importance attributed to a tight network of spiritual kinship relationships. If we accept that the number of spiritual kin was important, is it possible to affirm that in two different localities, where it was customary to have the same number of godparents, the model of godparenthood was the same? Certainly not: suffice it to say that observation of the varieties of godparenthood practised in Catholic communities scattered around the world today leads one to realize that while all accept the ‘couple model’ (almost the only one18 allowed by canon law at the present time), there are 18
It is quite possible to give children only one godfather or one godmother.
Godparents and Compari
41
many different situations, as anthropological research has shown beyond a shadow of doubt. The analysis of the ‘numerical profile’ of the practices of godparenthood, therefore, certainly makes it possible to affirm that some places adopt clearly different models, but not that localities adopt totally analogous models. To say that two models are the same, a thorough examination of each locality and their models of godparenthood would be required, a difficult task owing to the lack of suitable pre-Tridentine sources. So, when I speak of ‘models’ of godparenthood, I mean ‘groups’ of models, characterized by practices in common as far as numbers of godfathers and godmothers are concerned, but within the group there could be further ramifications. Mapping these groups makes it possible to highlight an essential feature: the enormous variety of godparent practices spread throughout Europe, and the considerable degree of fragmentation it leads to in the region. I have already mentioned the need to introduce some form of classification of models of godparenthood in order to be able to study the distribution of the most important practices. In other words, it is necessary to develop a typology of models that is neither so comprehensive that significant differences are overlooked, nor so refined that it prevents the desired simplification. The empirical study of the eight cases described at the beginning of this chapter has made it possible to identify three variables of particular interest: • Is there only one godfather at a baptism or are there more than one? • With more than one godfather, is there a limit to the number of godfathers allowed? • Are there only godfathers or only godmothers, or both? A combination of these three variables enables us to work out the most useful typology. The second and the third variable, however, require further clarification. For the second, what must be the cogency of a limit to the number of godfathers in order to discover a qualitative difference between the models? On the basis of the known cases it seems sensible to choose four godfathers for each baptism. Therefore, the definition ‘limited’ will be used for a model in which in the greatest majority of baptisms (say 99 per cent so that we can allow for the occasional exception) there are at most four godfathers.
Fathers and Godfathers
42
As far as the third variable is concerned, it is preferable to distinguish not between cases where there are never godmothers or godfathers (that is, where spiritual kin attending a baptism are only of one sex), but between cases where they are rare (asymmetric models) and cases in which they are almost always present (symmetric models). To make a distinction, it would be best to set a limit to the presence of godfathers and godmothers in less than one-third of the baptisms.19 With these clarifications in mind, I have worked out a typology that is the result of the combination of three dichotomies: single godfather/multigodfathers;20 limited/unlimited; and symmetric/asymmetric. As the singlegodfather models are by definition limited, we are faced with six types of different models. Actually, it would be possible to reduce the typology from six to four, if we consider the single godfatherhood a subset of the ‘limited’ models. However, I think it preferable to keep the others separate from the rare cases where a single godfather and a single godmother (or one of the two) is present, because they anticipate the ‘couple model’ that was to dominate after the Council of Trent. Besides, all the models where it was customary to attribute more than one godfather, or more than one godmother, for each infant were banned by the Council. Table 2.3
Unlimited
Limited
Typology of godparenthood models Multi-godfather Symmetric Asymmetric Asymmetric Pure multimultigodfather godfather (type 1) (type 2) Limited Limited multiasymmetric godfather multi(type 3) godfather (type 4)
Single godfather Symmetric Asymmetric
Pure single godfather (couple model) (type 5)
Asymmetric single godfather (type 6)
19 Therefore cases like that of Turin, where in only 18.5 per cent (less than one-third) of the baptisms there is at least one godmother, are to be considered ‘asymmetric’, the same as the cases assimilable to Voghera, where godmothers are almost never present (0.2 per cent of baptisms). 20 For models to be defined as ‘single godfather’, in almost all the baptisms there must be at most one godfather and one godmother; for the purpose of this analysis I have adopted a threshold of 99 per cent. Obviously, certain cases will result as ‘doubtful’, because they are very close to the threshold; the problem usually concerns the identification of ‘limited’ models. At the moment there is no way of getting round this difficulty. So, while we are waiting for further data to become available that would enable us to calculate accurately the typology, we can only appeal to historiographic common sense.
Godparents and Compari
43
Table 2.3 makes it clear how each type of model derives from a combination of three variables. The types are as follows: • Type 1 (pure multi-godfather): the emblematic case of the custom of giving
•
•
•
•
•
children many spiritual kin, male or female, with no significant limit to the maximum number of spiritual kin allowed. In Italy it was very common; it is to be found, for example, in Ivrea, Bellano and Santorso. There is evidence that it was also to be found elsewhere, in France and, probably, in Spain and Germany. Type 2 (asymmetric multi-godfather): like type 1 it foresees the presence of numerous godfathers with no clear limit in number, but where godmothers were frequently absent, as in Turin and Florence. In type 2 another case could be included, for the moment merely theoretical as it has never been certified, of a model characterized by many godmothers but no godfathers. Type 3 (limited multi-godfather): similar to type 1, but with a limit to the maximum number of godfathers and godmothers allowed. Like type 1 it was very common in Italy; it is to be found in Azeglio, Finale Ligure, Gambellara and Mirandola. Probably it is the model that prevailed in vast areas of France and Northern Europe, as one of its special cases is the ‘ternary’ model (two godfathers and one godmother or vice versa depending on whether the infant baptized was male or female). Type 4 (limited asymmetric multi-godfather) is similar to type 2, but there is a limit to the maximum number of godfathers or godmothers allowed. It is documented at Voghera, Verona, Vicenza, Treviso and Manduria. As for type 2, I am not aware of any case where there are no godfathers rather than no godmothers. Type 5 (pure single godfather): this is the type I have called the ‘couple model’. Prior to the Council of Trent it was rare, both in Italy and in Europe. It is traceable in Porrentruy (in the Jura, between France and Switzerland) and, perhaps, at Brive (in France); in Italy, as will be seen, I found it only in some communities in the area around Modena. However, after the Council of Trent, the couple model was to become the godparenthood model in Catholic Europe, despite the fact that the Council’s orders clearly were in favour of type 2 model. I will return to this later. Type 6 (asymmetric single godfather): includes models that envisage the presence of only one godfather or only one godmother per baptism. It has been certified only in the hills around Salerno, where it was customary for there to be no godfathers. Contrary to what we might expect, the multigodfather asymmetric models (types 2 and 4) do not become, after the Council, type 6, but rather the couple model (type 5), thus losing their asymmetrical character.
44
Fig. 2.1
Fathers and Godfathers
The distribution of models of godparenthood prior to the Council of Trent
In the case of Italy, and in particular in the north of the peninsula, sufficient data are available for me to give an idea of the way customs were scattered throughout the area. As well as information about the eight communities I have already mentioned and what can be deduced from historiography, I can make use of the initial results of an enquiry, still being carried out, on samples of baptisms celebrated in the three years 1555–1557 or in
Godparents and Compari
45
the years immediately before or after them, in parishes with very early registers of baptism. There are altogether 27 additional cases.21 The distribution of the six models is shown in Figure 2.1. For central southern Italy, the set of the places where it is possible to identify the godparenthood model still has too many gaps for any views to be expressed. As far as the north of Italy is concerned, there are sufficient cases which, while they do not perhaps allow us to come to any definite conclusions, at least allow some general observations and enable us to formulate some hypotheses that further research will be able to verify. An elucidation is essential. The perspective that I have adopted is the ‘geography of practices’, directly influenced by Jean Yver’s pioneering work Essai de geographie coutumière (1966), which was continued by Emanuel Le Roy Ladurie, Joseph Goy and their associates (Le Roy Ladurie 1972; Goy 1988, 1997). It is a line of research that up to the present has not had much following in Italy, even though it is close to ethnography. In France, beginning with Yver, research into the geography of customs concentrated on the systems of succession prior to the introduction of the Civil Code. The results obtained contain useful lessons for the geography of practices in general, whatever their subject matter may be. Faced with an initial impression of having identified areas linked by the same customs, whose existence could be explained by ethno-cultural factors and legal traditions with roots going back to the great migration of peoples in the years following the fall of the Western Empire,22 later research has evidenced a multiplicity of legal situations with a wide variety
21
My research would not have been possible without the generous help of parish priests and their helpers who responded to my requests to copy and send me the data which I required. The parishes that so far have co-operated are S. Giacomo of Baresi, SS. Gervasio and Protasio of Spirano, S. Zenone of Osio di Sopra, S. Martino of Adrara, S. Grata of Borgo Canale di Bergamo, the parish of the Natività di Maria of Bondeno, SS. Giacomo and Filippo of Finale Emilia, the parish of the Beata Virgine di Casinalbo, S. Orsola of Campogalliano, S. Giovanni Battista of Compiano, SS. Giacomo and Filippo of Finale Emilia, the parish of the Natività di Maria of Rivalta, S. Donnino of Massenzatico, S. Giuseppe of Grosio, S. Pietro of Savigliano. Data from six other localities in Romagna can be added to the above parishes (in Ravenna, Cesena, Cesenantico, Bulgaria, Montereale, San Vittore), which I personally collected, such as those of the communities of Santorso in Veneto, of Romano, Strambino and Chivasso in Piedmont and of Nonantola in Emilia. As regards Gemona del Friuli, I have had to use much older data (referring to the years 1380–1382) contained in one of the first registers of baptisms to be preserved (unfortunately it was interrupted in 1404), published by De Vitt (2000). 22 Yver claimed that he identified three different hereditary systems, with geographical boundaries (the western, southern and Orleans-Parisian models), respectively characterized by egalitarian succession, inegalitarian succession and a mixed system with essentially an egalitarian tendency, but with the possibility that some potential heirs were to be excluded, usually daughters.
46
Fathers and Godfathers
of practices, which make it extremely difficult, if not impossible, to draw up a ‘map’.23 It is sufficient to look at Figure 2.1 to realize that similar risks are innate also in the ‘geography of godparenthood’. The godparenthood models, in fact, are not distributed on the ground in such a way as to be able to draw homogenous areas; neither is it possible to come to simple conclusions, not even taking into consideration different groups of practices (the colours of the figures on the map indicate the number of godfathers and godmothers; the shape of the figure shows whether or not godmothers were present). It seems that complexity is a constant feature of the distribution of customs. All the ‘easy’ or simplistic hypotheses have to be rejected. In Table 2.4 I have recorded the typology of models, case by case, grouping communities by region and by diocese. To simplify it, I have used the present administrative regions, in order to give an idea of the presence of different models in the same circumscribed areas. Examining the distribution of the models in the four regions with the highest number of cases (Piedmont, Lombardy, Emilia Romagna, Veneto), it is easy to realize that such a large area contained a very considerable variety of practices. Even in Emilia Romagna, the region where there was most uniformity in godparenthood practices, there is evidence of the extreme cases of type 1 models (pure multi-godfather) and type 5 (the couple model), although Compiano, the only case of type 1, is situated in the Apennines, while all those that adopted the couple model are to be found on the plain. This is an important factor to which I will refer later. It would be reasonable to claim that the present administrative regions are not the most suitable for studying a historical phenomenon. Even more pertinent is the fact that not even the state boundaries of the time, nor those of the dioceses, delimited areas with homogenous customs. Take, for example, the Duchy of Savoy. Within its boundaries we can find two models of type 1 (Ivrea and Chivasso), one of type 2 (Turin), four of type 3 (Romano and Strambino, neighbouring communities which are indicated by one point in Figure 2.1, Azeglio and Savigliano). The two other large states in northern Italy, the Duchy of Milan and the Republic of Venice, also cover a wide variety of practices.
23 Attempts to draw up maps can be seen in Goy (1988). Research has demonstrated that, if we go into detail, very few localities really correspond to the ideal types described by Yver. Besides, Goy and his assistants have discovered that the Civil Code did not have a real standardizing effect either. Apart from the principles that inspired it (clearly favourable to equalitarian succession), for the whole of the nineteenth century, on account of the norms it contained, the latitude permitted meant that practices endured which, by their nature and their distribution on the territory, exactly match those recorded before 1789 (Lamaison 1988).
Table 2.4
Models of godparenthood by community and region
Locality Hills of Salernitano Compiano Mirandola Massenzatico Campogalliano Cesenatico Bulgaria Montereale S. Vittore Cesena Ravenna Nonantola Bondeno Casinalbo Rivalta
Region/diocese Campania/Salerno Emilia Romagna/ Piacenza Emilia Romagna/Carpi Emilia Romagna/Reggio Emilia Emilia Romagna/ Modena Emilia Romagna/Cesena Emilia Romagna/Cesena Emilia Romagna/Cesena Emilia Romagna/Cesena Emilia Romagna/Cesena Emilia Romagna/ Ravenna Emilia Romagna/ Modena Emilia Romagna/Ferrara Emilia Romagna/ Modena Emilia Romagna/Reggio Emilia
Model 6
Locality Ivrea Chivasso
Region/diocese Piedmont/Ivrea Piedmont/Ivrea
Model 1 1
1
Turin
Piedmont/Turin
2
3
Azeglio
Piedmont/Ivrea
3
3
Romano
Piedmont/Ivrea
3
3
Strambino
Piedmont/Ivrea
3
3 3 3 3 3
Savigliano
Piedmont/Turin
3
Manduria
Puglia/Oria
4
Florence
Tuscany/Florence
2
Rovereto
Trentino-AltoAdige/Trent
3
5
Santorso
Veneto/Vicenza
1
5
Gambellara
Veneto/Vicenza
3
3 3 5
Locality
Region/diocese Emilia Romagna/ Modena
Model
Locality
Region/diocese
Model
5
Verona
Veneto/Verona
4
Gemona
Friuli/Udine¹
3
Vicenza Treviso
Veneto/Vicenza Veneto/Treviso
4 4
Finale Ligure
Ligury/Savona
3
Bellano Grosio Borgo Canale di Bergamo Baresi Voghera Spirano Osio di Sopra Adrara S. Martino
Lombardy/Milan Lombardy/Como
1 1
Lombardy/Bergamo
2
Lombardy/Bergamo Lombardy/Tortona Lombardy/Bergamo Lombardy/Bergamo Lombardy/Bergamo
3 4 4 4 4
Finale Emilia
¹ Gemona belonged to the patriarchate of Aquileia up to its dissolution in 1420; it then became part of the diocese of Udine.
Godparents and Compari
49
If we take a closer look, rather than at the state boundaries, which in time were subject to change, clearly it was the diocesan boundaries that over a long period might have influenced customs. In fact, not only were these boundaries more stable, but in the field of godparenthood the church authorities had every right to intervene, or at least try to do so. The bishops could, in time, have perhaps helped to define a local model of godparenthood, or could, anyway, have discouraged the fragmentation and variety of practices. This is a role they could have played in the context of interaction between local customs, based on history and culture, and diocesan regulations, which themselves acted as intermediaries of the Roman rules. It is, however, easy to see that not even the dioceses can automatically be considered as an area with homogenous customs, but rather the opposite. There is the case of Ivrea. Out of the five communities whose model of godparenthood I am familiar with, two correspond to type 1 (Ivrea and Chivasso) and three to type 3 (Azeglio, Romano and Strambino). In the diocese of Bergamo, on the other hand, out of the five communities taken into consideration, one belonged to type 2 (Borgo Canale di Bergamo), one to type 3 (Baresi), and three to type 4 (Spirano, Osio di sopra, Adrara S. Martino). In the case of a third diocese, that of Modena, a far more uniform situation is to be found, as the only models we have evidence of are types 3 and 5 (limited multi-godfather and the couple model). Moreover, this is the only area where there is a real problem with ‘borderline’ in attributing a type to each local model. In other words, the differences are extremely limited between these particular type 3 and 5 models, while generally they are sufficiently clear not to create difficulties (this is true also for the five cases of type 3 traced to Romagna). Can intervention on the part of local diocesan authorities account for the uniformity of customs in the Modena area? As there is no documentary evidence providing confirmation, the answer must be no, not only because a similar intervention might never have taken place, but also on account of the long list of the Church’s failures; its attempts to regulate godparenthood show that the norms designed to modify these particular customs were rarely applied. The ability of the pre-Tridentine bishops to intervene in the communities of their dioceses, especially the most remote, should not be overestimated; when pastoral visitations became compulsory, obliging them to pay a visit to these communities, they made unexpected discoveries, also, as we will see, on the question of the local practices of godparenthood. We could presume that in the area of Modena and the nearby dioceses of Emilia local church authorities intervened because we can see that the practices of godparenthood are more moderate than elsewhere. However,
50
Fathers and Godfathers
this kind of logic is marred by a kind of ‘evolutionist prejudice’ that leads us to believe that the Tridentine reform might, or indeed must, have had some precedents, in this case some early ‘couple models’, imposed by local bishops. If we take into consideration the opinions expressed on the question in Trent, a ‘reformer’ might have had a completely different opinion, as Luther certainly did. The couple model (type 5) did not correspond to the one desired by the Council, which was type 6 (only one godfather or one godmother). It is preferable, then, just to take as fact the comparative uniformity of the godparent models of Central Emilia. The presence of these ‘examples of moderation’ in such an important area of northern Italy, at the heart of a network of vital routes of communication (most of all, the Via Emilia), leads us to put forward some interesting hypotheses on the spread of these practices, where I feel we should proceed one step at a time. It is clear that the political and administrative boundaries, including those of the dioceses, do not seem to have played a major role in influencing the way the customs of godparenthood were distributed. However, on the basis of Figure 2.1, northern Italy seems to have been divided into two zones that easily cross the boundaries mentioned. The first is an Alpine and pre-Alpine belt that extended into the Apennines, where all the type 1 models identified so far were located. This surrounds the area of the Po Valley, where there was a limit to the numbers of spiritual kin allowed at baptism. Within this central area, then, the rules of moderation seem to have been stricter as they get closer and closer to the centre, which I will hypothetically place round the city of Modena, as I do not know the practices adopted by nearby important cities and especially those of the extremely important town of Bologna. The theory that the ‘moderate’ customs of godparenthood came to light in this area and then spread to others nearby is attractive, especially if we consider that when the Council of Trent was holding lengthy discussions on godparenthood in the year 1547, the Council was not meeting at Trent, but, and maybe not by chance, at Bologna. The surroundings, and the large numbers of spokesmen from the local clergy, could perhaps have contributed to generating a climate in favour of the adoption of restrictive measures. The idea of the ‘diffusion’ of customs has to be assumed with great caution. It is certainly true that among local practices there is a kind of ‘contagion’ over the years. However, the complexity of the map shown in Figure 2.1 clearly shows that if there was a diffusion of customs, it was not linear, and not only because practices travel with people and tend to prefer the winding routes of communication. It is probable, therefore, that there were more centres from which different customs spread out, as there were
Godparents and Compari
51
communities or areas more or less willing to be influenced; this spread was not even, but left behind it little pockets where different customs came into contact and mixed with practices from other hubs and, in the end, generated an irregular, complex and apparently fragmented picture. Finally, we need to remember that the very existence of different local customs implies that someone, at an unknown time, made innovations to the practices in force at that moment. On this score, I should point out that, in general, while retracing the birth of godparenthood models is certainly interesting, it goes beyond my immediate objectives.24 It is worth underlining, once again, that the tendency of the customs of godparenthood to spread is no more than a theory. Besides, even if the customs spread, at the present state of our knowledge we do not have the means to distinguish between who was influenced and who were the influencers. I have already hinted at the theory that practices similar to those enforced by events, if not desired by the Council of Trent, had begun to spread, starting from Central Emilia, even by the beginning of the sixteenth century. It is possible and perhaps equally probable that the opposite is true, that the ‘multi-godfather’ practices of the Alpine and pre-Alpine communities moved towards the plain; that is, naturally, if the situation was dynamic and not static. In other words, it is feasible that each community had always (and certainly from a time that precedes our chance to study it) adhered to its own godparenthood model, perhaps viewing it as a distinctive feature when compared to other models (it is worth remembering that, at that time, ‘foreigners’ might be those who only lived at a distance of a few kilometres). Up to now I have concentrated on the practices that led either to a limitation or to an increase in the number of godfathers, leaving aside those that allowed or did not allow the choice of godmothers. If we look at the spread of types 2 and 4 models, it would seem that the custom of excluding women from ‘active’ spiritual kinship was distributed in a different way from the rules of moderation. Except for the case of Florence, these models were to be found in a zone that, starting from Turin 24
Following the establishment in time of a local model of godparenthood, starting from a common hypothetical situation (only one godparent of the same sex as the child, the model which appears to have predominated up until the eighth century), it would certainly be extremely useful to understand why on the eve of the Tridentine regulations different localities followed such different practices. Following this path, it would be possible to identify the existence of a link between the adoption of a given model and the characteristics of each locality, making it possible to work out an interpretation of the ‘map of the customs of godparenthood’ which could better explain its complexity. I must say, however, that having made an attempt at reconstructing an evolutionary path, I realize just how complicated this is, partly on account of a dearth of necessary sources, and partly due to the lack of information they can supply.
52
Fathers and Godfathers
and continuing across Lombardy, passed through Veneto, at least as far as Treviso. To the north and to the south of this belt custom established both godfathers and godmothers. In this case, more than for the rules of moderation, it would be necessary to have more information available in order to discover if we really are dealing with practices confined to the area indicated, or if this is merely a false impression. To conclude, we have to admit that for the moment the geography of godparenthood customs remains a complicated and fascinating puzzle that makes future research advisable. The information I have collected, however, is sufficient to give an overall picture of the situation the Council of Trent had to deal with: a wide variety of local practices that gave rise to various difficulties on ethical, pastoral, administrative and diplomatic levels. However, before looking in more detail at the debate and decisions of the Council, we must try to find an answer to the question of what was a spiritual kinship relationship. What was it used for, what kind of behaviour did it entail, who could have used it and how?
CHAPTER 3
Godparenthood, Literature and Family Records; from Perception to Interpretation Research on godparenthood carried out in the past 50 years in the field of anthropology has highlighted its importance in the social and economic life of numerous communities scattered throughout the world. Studies have also shown the variety of ‘functions’ that it can or could accomplish. Eugene A. Hammel (1968) for example, while studying the case of populations in the Balkans in the 1960s and in preceding decades, noted that depending on time and place, they resorted to godparenthood to establish and strengthen relations of solidarity between peers, to show respect towards a godfather of a higher rank than their own (and sometimes to become his ‘clients’), to integrate and finalize marriage alliances, to overcome disputes and bring an end to blood feuds, and so on. This variety of uses was in spite of the fact that formally the social institution involved was always the same. When we look at past centuries our ability to observe is limited by the impossibility of directly questioning the protagonists, as anthropologists do. Finding coeval witnesses of godparenthood is by no means an easy matter. In fact, while the historical analysis of sources such as baptismal registers and notary deeds enables us to build up a picture, however incomplete, of the way in which spiritual kinship conditioned the social and economic life of a community, these sources do not, however, say much about the perception that the protagonists had of these links. Actually, it is the very perception of the existence of a link that enabled it to be exploited in a particular way (perhaps within the limits of what was ‘socially acceptable’, the dimensions of which will be specified later). In the centuries immediately before the Council of Trent, what kind of link was it? How did the ‘compari’ regard each other? Fortunately, books on baptisms and legal documents are not the only sources to contain information on godparenthood. There are others, which in an indirect and sometimes a distorted way let the compari speak about themselves, namely family records and literary texts. Their usefulness is not limited to the ‘perception’ of godparenthood but, as will be seen, they enable us to investigate other aspects. More specifically, these sources refer to local models of godparenthood that are potentially quite different but will be used here in an attempt to generalize; this, therefore, presents
54
Fathers and Godfathers
difficulties of a logical nature. It is possible, however, to object that the gaps in our knowledge force us to follow this route and that what we are looking for, the way ‘comparatico’ was perceived and its possible uses (not necessarily substantiated always and everywhere), is tendentiously at a higher level than local models indicate. In other words, very different models of godparenthood, for example with regard to the number of godfathers and godmothers allowed, can have in common a very similar perception of comparatico. The family records, or memorials, contain a record of events that concerned a particular family, usually noted down by the head of the family and often continued by the heirs. In this way, the family records are one of the tools used to reinforce the identity of the family and to transmit it to future generations. They are complex sources with a wealth of subtleties, and for many years they have been at the centre of the attention of historians. Usually they promptly report the celebration of the baptism of newborn infants, as well as the godfathers and godmothers present. Normally the information about godparenthood that we can deduce is limited to this list, useful, as has been seen, to formulate theories on the model prevailing in the area, but not enough to give a clear idea of the essence of the comparatico relationship that was established. Fortunately, however, in some cases more information is available. From the family records of fourteenth-to-sixteenth-century Florentine families it emerges that the spiritual kin tended to be chosen from outside the ‘natural’ kinship. To understand how important this is we need to make a brief digression. In the literature on godparenthood, and not merely in works of anthropology, a ‘dichotomous approach’ has been extremely influential; its origin is to be found in a work of Paul (1942). It is an extremely simple and certainly an effective way of cataloguing the customs in use in different communities, making use of a conceptual scheme constructed on a number of variables compared two by two: extension/intensification of natural kinship, vertical/horizontal character of comparatico relations, and so on. Once compared with historical data, as will be seen, this conceptual scheme proves to be too simplistic and unable to explain adequately a complex situation, at least if it is to be intended as a means of organizing and comparing systems of practices. It is, though, undeniable that this ‘dichotomous tradition’ has focused attention on significant variables. With regard to the ‘extension/intensification’ dichotomy, it is necessary to distinguish between communities where spiritual kinship was used to consolidate and intensify the natural kinship, and communities where, See the volumes in the series I libri di famiglia in Italia, edited by Angelo Cicchetti and Raul Mordenti (1985, 1997).
Godparenthood, Literature and Family records
55
instead, it was extended. In this case, the tendency was to avoid choosing relatives as children’s godfathers and godmothers, preferring to establish new relationships with people with whom there had been no previous connection. In Florence, then, they inclined towards the ‘extension’ of kinship, excluding their own family from godparenthood. According to Christiane Klapisch-Zuber, at the time this situation was common also in large parts of France, England and Germany. A significant exception was the Strozzi family, which in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries chose most of its godparents from among its relatives. According to Klapisch-Zuber this behaviour is to be accounted for by their need to re-establish links with relatives from whom they had long been separated; the Strozzis, in fact, had been exiled and only in 1466 had returned to Florence. This abnormal case only strengthens the conclusions that can be drawn from ‘normal’ cases; comparatico was not so much part of the ‘great game’ of kinship, as part of other forms of sociability such as friendship. As far as friendship is concerned, it is to be noted that the term ‘compare’ is often used in the sense of ‘close friend’, even if there is no spiritual relationship. Benvenuto Cellini, for example wrote ‘[my friend Bachiacca] called me sotto voce compare (which we called each other in fun), and he asked me …’. The comparatico of baptism is certainly, however, the model that allows for the figurative use of the term. Secondly, comparatico fulfils a twofold role in the establishment of friendship. In certain cases the friendship is pre-existent and a decision to become compari is based on a desire to turn what was above all an informal relationship into an ‘official’ one. In others, it is the comparatico itself that creates a relationship where there was none, and fosters a friendship through the close acquaintance that it entails. Another unusual case throws light on this first aspect. It can be reconstructed from the letters of Ser Lapo Mazzei to his close friend Francesco di Marco Datini, the famous merchant of Prato. Although he was aware that it was the custom to look for rich and powerful godfathers for one’s own children (Mazzei’s resources and rank were relatively modest, while Datini was one of the wealthiest men of his time), as well as to seal friendship with the comparatico, nonetheless Lapo for a long while resisted Francesco’s wish to become godfather to one of his children. In fact, Lapo
Klapisch-Zuber 1985b. Here Klapisch-Zuber is my source for the data concerning the Florentine family records. Although gradually disappearing, this meaning of the word compare is still found in some parts of Italy. Cellini, Vita, 1,33.
56
Fathers and Godfathers
thought that people who were of humble origin and lacking in wealth should be chosen as godfathers, adopting the principle of Christian charity that, in a different era, would induce Montaigne’s and Montesquieu’s parents to give their sons a poor man as godfather. It was only several years later, succumbing to Francesco’s continual pressure, that Lapo finally agreed. However, he felt obliged to point out that in a sincere friendship it was not necessary for him to add the relationship of comparatico (Origo 1979, pp. 177–178) and he made a condition: Francesco should abstain from making baptismal gifts and should attend the ceremony ‘as a poor pilgrim’. Many centuries later the lack of a plan in the selection of godparents still seemed eccentric, at least in Tuscany. So, in Pisa in 1792 Lussorio Bracci Cambini wrote in his book that as godfather to his son Giovanni he had chosen the first person to turn up at the scene, ‘not wanting to have a noble compare to escape duty and etiquette’ (Bizzocchi 2001, p. 120), although he was well aware that he was infringing precise social norms. The second aspect (the use of godparenthood to create a friendship ex novo) is often found in the literature of the late Middle Ages and the Early Modern Era. This is also because the acquaintanceship that was established between the compari was used by many writers as a means of introducing the indelicate subject of spiritual incest between a compare and his comare (usually the wife of the other compare). I will come back to this shortly. The family records also contain some indications on the difficult subject of the relationship between godfathers and godchildren. Generally, it seems that the ties of godfatherhood were not really deeply felt; far more important was the relationship of comparatico. However, there are cases where these sources testify to the intervention of a godfather in crucial moments in the life of his godson. Klapisch-Zuber (1985b, p. 60) gives the example of a notary who in 1444 supported the admission to a profession of his godson, actually the son of one of his colleagues. In the Brive in France, in November 1562, Rigal Malliard asked the court chancellor, Pierre Fontanel, to be godfather to his son. A few months later, Fontanel agreed to take as an apprentice another of Malliard’s sons, a boy of 13, with whom he had no spiritual relationship. We do not know, though, if the apprenticeship was agreed to before Fontanel and Malliard became spiritual kin (Cassan 1996, p. XXXIV). This example, in particular, indicates that what sometimes might seem an interest shown by the godfather in his godson is often nothing more than an episode in the periodical exchange of favours and courtesy between compari. The godfathers of Montaigne and Montesquieu are recurrent examples in the literature on godparenthood. See, among others, Pitt-Rivers 1995.
Godparenthood, Literature and Family records
57
A more tangible sign of a godfather’s interest in the fortunes of his godson could be the custom of small legacies left to the latter. While similar customs have been found in some areas of Europe (Rubellin 1997), they were not common everywhere, not in Florence, nor in Ivrea, where I have been able to examine some wills personally. In Barcelona, at the beginning of the seventeenth century, spiritual kinship played an important part in connection with wills, as the compari were often witnesses and executors of a will. If we look at the way godparenthood is depicted in Italian literary sources, we must begin with that celebrated writer of novellas, Boccaccio. In the Decameron a whole story is built round the relationship of comparatico, or rather around its abuse. Rinaldo, a handsome young man from a good family, falls in love with his neighbour Agnesa, unfortunately already married. Rinaldo, ‘… thinking that if he could contrive to speak with the lady without exciting suspicion, he would obtain what he desired, and finding no other opportunity, and the lady being with child, he resolved to become her compare’. So he agrees with the husband of his beloved to stand godfather for the infant, well aware that as there was a relationship of comparatico, he would be free to associate with the comare. Agnesa, however, hearing the declaration of Rinaldo, whom she likes, resists. Disappointed, the young man becomes a friar and for a certain time puts other frivolities and his love for the comare to one side, later going back to his old habits. Once again he takes to visiting his neighbour and insistently tries to convince her to give in to his advances. Agnesa objects that, as they are compari, ‘it would be a terrible sin’. Rinaldo, however, manages to convince her, adducing some bizarre logic. Having broken down her initial resistance ‘they began, under cover of the comparatico,
Amelang 1998, pp. 88 ff. Similar behaviour is recorded also in northern Italy in the fifteenth century (Klapisch-Zuber 1985b, p. 60). Decamerone, III, 7. The novella is told on the seventh day by Ellissa; on the same day, and referring explicitly to Ellissa, Dionèo also tells a story (X,7) in which there is a case of comparatico being infringed.
Decamerone, III, 7, 4. ‘The lady, laughing on one side of her mouth, and looking demure on the other, said, “How can I do such a thing? You are my compare, and therefore it would be a terrible sin, otherwise I am sure I would be willing to oblige you.” “You would be a goose if you do not oblige me because of this,” said the friar. “I do not deny that it is a sort of sin, but God pardons greater ones on repentance. Tell me, pray, which of the two is more nearly related to your son, I who held him at the font, or your husband who begot him?” –“My husband, of course.” “Very well,” says the friar, “and does not your husband lie with you?” “Yes, indeed,” answered the woman. “Then by consequence you may lie with me who am not so nearly related to your son as he.”’ Decamerone, III 7, 16.21.
Fathers and Godfathers
58
because they were under less suspicion, and they had many opportunities to be together’.10 The novella shows clearly how the comparatico could create intimacy where there was none. In particular, the ‘cover of the comparatico’ permitted relationships that otherwise would have been suspect, such as that between a man and a woman. In the above passage, the farce arises from an unscrupulous violation of an established social norm. The use of the comparatico to facilitate an approach to married women was, at least up until the Early Modern Era, a real literary commonplace. In Nicolò Machiavelli’s famous comedy, La Mandragola, it is Lucrezia, the married woman seduced by Callimaco, who suggests to her naive husband, Messer Nicia, ‘would that (Callimaco) be our compare’,11 so that she can meet her lover at her ease in her own home.12 In one of the novellas of the fifteenth-century storywriter Bandello, the problem is caused not by adultery but by the jealous husband’s suspicions, faced with the ‘normal’ intimacy that he discovers between his wife and her compare, whose son the woman had held at the baptismal font before she married. ‘On account of this, the man from Bergamo became extremely jealous and did not want Zanina any longer to call him compare, nor speak to him and thus desired that the holy comparatico should be sundered’.13 The behaviour of the husband causes a breach in a social norm, and indirectly provides a kind of list of the two ‘public’ aspects of the comparatico relationship: ‘calling each other compare’ and ‘speaking to each other’. Anthropologists have often observed the existence of social norms that make it necessary to emphasize the existence of spiritual kin by addressing the compari with particular formulas, thus increasing the public perception of the relationship between them. This has been observed in areas and in periods close to our own.14 Going back to spiritual incest, traces are to be found in several of Pietro Aretino’s works. On the third day of the Dialogo, it is ‘the comare’ who holds forth, and remarks explicitly: ‘Good work is that of the procuress who, making everybody her compare and comare, everybody her godson
10
Decamerone, III 7,22. Machiavelli, La Mandragola, VI. 12 In La Mandragola it is not entirely clear if what is intended is a real proposal of godfatherhood (as I believe) or if the term ‘compare’ is used in the sense of a ‘close friend’. 13 Bandello, Novelle, 1, 34. 14 See for example the customs described by Julian Pitt-Rivers for Andalusia (1976a, pp. 112–114) or by Berardino Palumbo for the village of San Marco dei Cavoti (1991, pp. 122–125). 11
Godparenthood, Literature and Family records
59
and godfather, pokes herself into every opening.’15 In Il Marescalco, Ambrogio observes: ‘Will I then be wiser than many masters [that] make their lovers brothers and compari?’16 It is perhaps possible to interpret the recurrent cases of spiritual incest in literature as a sign that they were really quite frequent in Europe, at least up to the early sixteenth century. In the Decameron, Tingoccio, on his return from the next world to tell his friend Meuccio how sins are punished after death, is questioned on the effects of an infringement of the rules of the comparatico so passionate as to be the cause of his death. He relates then that, overwhelmed by desperation, he confided in a more expert soul that ‘the sin was such, that I lay with my comare and lay so long that I was flayed’. His interlocutor, making fun of his fears, replies, ‘Come off it, imbecile, have no doubt, on this side we pay no attention to comari!’ leaving Tingoccio to surmise that it was common practice.17 Furthermore, it is certain that the dimension of the problem caused considerable concern within the Council of Trent. The climate had changed and the Council wished to avert scandals caused by the discovery of prohibited relations, in order to avoid supplying ammunition to Protestant preachers. Leaving spiritual incest to one side, the comparatico relationship implies an obligation to respect and not to harm one another. Whoever violates this duty of respect and of friendship is a ‘false’ compare. Thus, in a fourteenth-century novella by Franco Sacchetti, a poor mother rails against her compare, Friar Stefano, who taking advantage of her trust abused her adolescent daughter: ‘“Be off with you, false compare, that for the passion of God we will no longer have anything to do with you,” and he never again entered her house.’18 Once the comparatico has been violated, the breach cannot be healed: how can one who has trampled the holiest of bonds still be trusted? In Aretino’s La Cortigiana, Aloigia makes a list of the sins committed by her ‘teacher’ (who on the morrow is to be burnt at the stake as a witch), among which is the following: ‘She bewitched her compare, to please a friend.’19 While in the works of Aretino, the relationship of comparatico is often an object of derision, the author’s tone changes completely when he himself 15
Aretino, Dialogo nel quale la Nanna inesgna a la Pippa …, III. Aretino, Il Marescalco, V. 17 Decamerone, X, 7. Two centuries after Boccaccio, Bandello returned to the same subject, making an explicit reference to his predecessor’s novella: ‘In that day, Vittore had a son by his wife and for comare chose [his lover] Filippa, never desisting, whenever he could, from lying with her, believing perhaps that it was true what Tingoccio said to Meuccio when he appeared to him in a dream.’ Bandello, Novelle, III, 20. 18 Sacchetti, Il Trecentonovelle, CXI. 19 Aretino, La Cortigiana, II, 6. 16
Fathers and Godfathers
60
is involved. In a letter he writes: ‘You make [a request] that I baptize your daughter … I accept the comparatico so that it is between us an enduring sign of good will.’20 I remarked at the beginning of this chapter that godparenthood also offered the opportunity of healing social estrangements. Cellini’s behaviour can be interpreted in this light. Having quarrelled with his teacher, Firenzuola, he later held his son at the font; the comparatico restored peace between the two of them.21 The examples mentioned up to now emphasize the ‘horizontal’ dimension of godparenthood, that is, the relationship between peers (between ‘friends’), compared to the ‘vertical’ one, between people of very different social rank, where often the relationship is one of patronage. According to many anthropologists, whether one or the other prevails depends on the place in which it is observed.22 As will be seen, my research suggests that in sixteenth-century Italy a more complex situation was common; despite this, the ‘vertical dimension’ is certainly one of the directions that godparenthood can take.23 For example, patronage can be surmised for the baptism of John, son of the Byzantine historian Georgios Sphrantzes, baptized on 1 May 1439 by the protector of his father, Constantine Paleologus (from 1449 to 1453 as Constantine XI, the last Emperor of the East) who had already presided at Sphrantzes’s wedding, and who, two years later, was godfather to his daughter, Tamara.24 To cite an Italian case, it suffices to recall the baptism of Alfonso, the eldest son of Filippo Strozzi, whose godfather was Alfonso of Aragon, Duke of Calabria and son of King Ferdinand, who, being unable personally to take part in the ceremony, was represented by Lorenzo de Medici. As a sign of homage to his godfather, his godson was given his name, even though this blatantly contravened the onomastic rules in force in Florence (Klapisch-Zuber 1985b, pp. 57–58). Generally speaking, literary sources clearly stress the significance of the comparatico relationship over that of godfatherhood. Giovanni Fiorentino is an exception. He was probably a fifteenth-century writer; his collection of stories, Il Pecorone, was, though, printed for the first time in 1558. In a novella that inspired Shakespeare’s Merchant of Venice, the 20
Aretino, Lettere, V, I 293. Cellini, Vita, I, 14. 22 Mintz and Wolf (1950) were the first to introduce the horizontal/vertical dichotomy into anthropological analysis. 23 Pierre Chaunu (1975) interpreted godparenthood uniquely as a relationship of social patronage, completely leaving its horizontal dimension. I feel that this interpretation is definitely to be rejected. See on this issue John Bossy’s observations (1979). 24 Sphrantzes, Memorie. 21
Godparenthood, Literature and Family records
61
young Florentine, Giannetto, when orphaned, is taken into the house of his godfather, the Venetian merchant, Ansaldo. The godfather has such a high regard for his godson that he equips a splendid ship for him, which ventures on the high seas. Giannetto, however, naively loses his ship in the port of Belmonte, surrendering to the flattery of a wicked widow. Ansaldo entrusts him with a second ship, with the same result, and in order to supply him with a third asks for a loan from a money lender, who as a guarantee demands the right, if the money is not paid back, to take a pound of his flesh.25 In the story Ansaldo, as godfather, makes up for the loss of Giannetto’s parents with affection of an intensity that was rare at a time when godparents seemed to take little interest in their godchildren. It is clear from the examples given here that godparenthood was an extremely complex social relationship and any attempt to simplify it or to give it too clear cut an interpretation obscures far more than it manages to clarify. Godparenthood is a flexible institution that, according to the place and the time, can change its ‘function’, but even more, under the same circumstances of time and place, when necessary it can serve unusual purposes; so any effort at micro-investigation is faced with a bewildering range of different kinds of behaviour. However, an overall interpretation of godparenthood as a social institution is possible, but it would be premature to make any suggestions before analysing the transformations brought about by the Council of Trent, which provide elements of key importance. It is, though, opportune to clarify at once some further aspects. What has been observed up to now should adequately show the significance of godparenthood relations in the social life of many, if not all, European communities in the Early Modern Age. However, it remains to be seen if it is right to put forward the theory that the importance of godparenthood extended beyond the social environment and also played a part in organizing economic activity – thus questioning whether the ‘social’ and ‘economic’ sphere are really separable. In fact, with regards to the relationship between the economy and society during the ancien régime, Karl Polanyi’s (1944) is still one of the most influential theoretical models. It is sufficient to recall it with the famous formula: within the populations of the old regime, the economy is immersed, ‘embedded’ in society. The economic processes of production, distribution and allocation, which constitute essential activities of any society, take place from time to time in different institutional frameworks, with different laws, regulations, motivations, meanings etc. It is reasonable to expect that a social institution as important as godparenthood should count in transactions and ‘economic’ relations in 25
Giovanni Fiorentino, Il Pecorone, IV, 1.
Fathers and Godfathers
62
general. Obviously, the problem cannot be dealt with merely on the basis of baptismal registers; it is necessary to cross-check the data with other information obtained from sources that take into account the economic dimension of the life of the community (property tax registers, notary deeds etc.). Later I will use this procedure to examine the case of Ivrea. For the moment I will limit myself to giving an idea of the way in which godparenthood relations might influence, and be influenced by, economic activity, taking two examples from anthropological studies: Neckarhausen (Germany) and Karpathos (Greece). Even though these examples might lack geographical and chronological coherence with my research and with sources used previously, I wish only to give an idea of the potentiality of a social custom, and not, or at least not yet, to describe the way in which they appeared in sixteenth-century Italy.26 The extensive study carried out by David Sabean (1984, 1990, 1998) on the village of Neckarhausen in Württemberg between the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries is one of the most successful attempts at investigating a godparenthood model operating in a community of the ancien régime. Sabean is aware of the difficulty of observing what, concretely, a godparenthood relationship implied: what did the godparents do for their godchildren; how did they behave towards the compari? Consequently he looks for traces of the importance of the relationship at a fundamental moment of economic life: the transfer of real estate. A premise is absolutely necessary. The Neckarhausen model of godparenthood has a unique characteristic, one that distinguishes it from the cases considered up to now. There was a particularly close bond between the family of the baptized infant and the godfather. Rather than extending the spiritual kinship network as much as possible, the inhabitants of the village used to choose one person who acted as godfather to all their children.27 This resulted in a relationship that was continually being renewed and was certainly much felt. It is surprising how frequently Sabean discovered a link between the parties through a relationship of spiritual kinship. Rather than being ‘direct’, however, this link passed through a third person who acted as a go-between. Two kinds of relations recur: the members of a nuclear family
26
For the same reasons, readers should not be surprised if I resort to cases concerning denominations other than the Roman Catholic Church (Protestant for Neckarhausen, Orthodox for Karpathos). During this study I will have the opportunity to come back on various occasions to the differentiation between the forms of godparenthood in different denominations, mostly originating in the Reformation and in the later Council of Trent. 27 This was a tradition found elsewhere, for example in certain areas of the Balkans (Hammel 1968), or, to remain in Protestant Germany, in the city of Oettingen (Rajkay and Reinhard 1989).
Godparenthood, Literature and Family records
63
were spiritual kin both of the buyer and the seller; the parents of the buyer or the seller were spiritual kin of their counterpart. If we restrict our analysis to cases where there were no lasting or established relations between the parties, nor a close blood or affinity relationship – that is, to the cases in which buyer and seller were not connected by relationships other than that of spiritual kinship, but perhaps contracted through a go-between – the frequency of the sale and exchange of real estate apparently mediated by godparenthood is surprisingly high: 56.3 per cent of the sales and 76.9 per cent of the exchanges in 1700–1708; 79.2 per cent and 72.7 per cent respectively in 1740–1749, and 52 per cent and 60.5 per cent in 1780–1789. Sabean is not able to specify how the godfathers’ and comparis’ role as ‘mediators’ manifested itself. Some features are, though, recognizable; principally where spiritual kin did not directly profit from the transaction, in the sense that they did not use their position to obtain access to the land. According to Sabean, they acted rather as ‘estate agents’ and perhaps, as they enjoyed the trust of both parties, what they did as intermediaries was crucial in a situation where fixing a price and the guarantee of payment could present a problem (here the point is not exchange on the market). It is likely that mediation of this kind did not exhaust all the ‘functions’ of seventeenth-century godparenthood in Neckarhausen. Although Sabean resorted to the most sophisticated means at the disposal of historical anthropology, he ran into difficulty when trying to identify what exactly was the role of godparenthood in economic activity. The second case that I propose will be useful to clarify the problems of observation encountered by those who have to employ historical sources. During the second half of the twentieth century, Bertrand Vernier was able to examine closely the model of godparenthood operative on the Greek island of Karpathos.28 At least until the mid twentieth century, the population of the island was split by a radical social division, that between farmers and shepherds. The two groups had contrasting interests because one possessed almost all the land (concentrated in the hands of the class of landed peasants, the canacares), while the other required open spaces for grazing its flocks. Disputes were frequently caused by the damage done by sheep and goats. Generally, no marriages took place between the peasants, in particular those of middling rank and the canacares, and the shepherds. However, the peasants systematically acted as godfathers to the shepherds’ children and vice versa. On the island it was customary for the aspiring godfather to offer himself for the role, as it was considered inappropriate for the parent 28 Vernier has progressively expanded his research on Karpathos, giving an account in books and articles (Vernier 1984, 1991, 1999).
64
Fathers and Godfathers
to make the request: it was as if they were admitting that nobody wanted the honour. Besides, those who did not dare to refuse such a proposal would find themselves bound to a system of periodical gifts. As well as the baptismal gift, among the families there was an obligation to give presents at the time of religious festivals, which culminated at Easter. A woman from the farmer’s family would take a large loaf decorated with an egg to the shepherd’s family. The following day, the gift was returned in the form of one or more sheep, cheeses, cream, milk. The circle was closed for the time being with a new offer, by the peasant’s family, of the food that they had at their disposal, such as vegetables from the garden, flour, baked food and honey. This complicated system exclusively concerned spiritual kinship between the two groups. In cases of comparatico between peasants, or between shepherds, gifts were restricted to items of little value, in a far less formal context. This system, in fact, was a form of economic exchange in kind that satisfied an important part of the need of each of the two groups to procure goods almost exclusively produced by the other. The complementarity of the peasants’ and the shepherds’ products was such that some form of barter was necessary and inevitable. It fails to explain, however, why these exchanges took place under the cover of spiritual kinship, in the form of gifts and counter-gifts. According to Vernier, ‘the advantage of a system of kinship over that of pure barter was that it created a link between peasants and shepherds greater than that created by the complementarity of their products, and thus was a better guarantor of their economic interests’ (Vernier 1984, p. 63). Over and above the need to procure certain goods, the shepherds hoped to obtain permission from their peasant compari to graze their flocks on the peasants’ fields once crops had been harvested, as well as help when quarrels broke out with other peasants on account of damage caused by their flocks, something usually severely punished. Similarly, the peasants hoped that the compari would keep their flocks at a distance from the fields when crops were ripening, as well as keeping control over the flocks of the other shepherds and providing support when disputes arose with the latter. If we look purely at the economic value of the goods exchanged in the gift system between compari, it would seem that the peasants gained much more than they gave. However, together with the goods there was also the circulation of symbolic capital, given the social distance that separated the two groups. This factor clearly emerged on certain occasions, for example at dances and meetings where the godfather was expected to sing some mandinades (a kind of serenade) to his goddaughter; if he was of a sufficiently high rank (a canacares, for example) the girl’s chances of making a good match increased. The circulation of symbolic capital alongside
Godparenthood, Literature and Family records
65
goods meant that, even though the exchange might seem unbalanced from an economic point of view, it appeared fair. If we take into consideration the godparenthood model in use on Karpathos, the potential usefulness of spiritual kinship in finding ongoing solutions to problems of an economic nature is evident, above all when ‘normal’ commerce is made difficult by the existence of contrasting interests, social differences and so on. However, godparenthood on the island makes it possible also to highlight a crucial difficulty that is encountered when attempting to investigate the ‘effective’ significance of a relationship of spiritual kinship in the Early Modern Age, for the following reason: it is questionable how much of the system of circulation of goods and symbolic capital encountered on the island required the services of a notary – probably almost none. Since in the Modern Era, notary documents are the principal source at the historian’s disposal to reconstruct economic activity, we are faced with a serious problem. So the available sources say almost nothing; but luckily, however little they say, something is transmitted. Though rare, there are references to the relationship of spiritual kinship, and it is necessary to work on them. This could be the tip of the iceberg, and the most substantial part of the economic function of godparenthood could lie in virtually imperceptible aspects of social life. Despite little interest in the problem up to now, it is hoped that things will improve in the future and that the accumulation of knowledge, for the moment extremely limited, will make it possible to overcome the analytic limits with which we are faced today.
This page has been left blank intentionally
CHAPTER 4
Godparenthood in the Sixteenth Century: from the Reformation to the Council of Trent The day on which Martin Luther nailed his 95 theses on the door of All Saints’ Church in Wittenberg, 31 October 1517, is the conventional date for the beginning of the Protestant Reformation, which in a short space of time led to the clash between the Church of Rome and the newly established Reformed Churches. Actually, for some time Western Christendom had been in turmoil: personalities of the calibre of Erasmus of Rotterdam had tenaciously been trying to reform the Church from within, both its doctrines and the practices of the time; and it was not only a question of contesting vices and corruption in the Roman Curia, but also protesting against popular customs (the sale of indulgences would not have caused so much scandal if there had not been so many buyers). At the beginning of the sixteenth century, in the case of godparenthood and spiritual kinship, the confusion that reigned in the rules as well as in the practices jarred the sensibility of many. Generally speaking, there was almost unanimous agreement among both Catholics and Protestants that godparenthood no longer corresponded to its religious and pedagogical functions. Besides, the extension of marriage bans and the large number of godparents taking part in baptisms give the impression that, at least in small communities, spiritual incest was quite a common occurrence, and the scandals that occasionally broke out probably only reflected a small number of cases. In Luther’s doctrine, baptism, considered to be the only ‘true’ sacrament besides the Eucharist, is of vital importance. It is hardly surprising, therefore, that he intervened also on the question of godparenthood and spiritual kinship, making his views abundantly clear with his usual forthright dynamism (the italics are the author’s): That nonsense about conpaternities, conmaternities, confraternities, consororities and confilieties must therefore be altogether abolished, when a marriage has been contracted. What was it but the superstition of men that invented those spiritual relationships? If one may not marry the person one has baptized or stood sponsor for, what right has any Christian to marry any other
Fathers and Godfathers
68
Christian? Is the relationship that grows out of the external rite, or the sign, or the sacraments more intimate than that which grows out of the blessing of the sacrament itself? Is not a Christian man brother to a Christian woman, and is not she his sister? Is not a baptized man the spiritual brother of a baptized woman? How foolish we are! If a man instruct his wife in the Gospel and in faith in Christ, and thus become truly her father in Christ, would it not be right for her to remain his wife? Would not Paul have had the right to marry a maiden out of the Corinthian congregation, of whom he boasts that he has begotten them all in Christ? See, thus has Christian liberty been suppressed through the blindness of human superstition.
What mainly concerned Luther was the excessive number of matrimonial bans; he declared they were one of the ways the church used (by the sale of dispensations) to scrape money together. Even if we put to one side the question of bans attributable to blood kinship and affinity, in any case judged to be used too extensively, the reformer’s hostility towards spiritual kinship is evident. Because he finds no reference to it in the Scriptures, unless spiritual brotherhood is conceived so broadly as altogether to impede marriage between Christians, the solution proposed is radical: abolish it completely, because it is absurd and the fruit of human superstition. However, it was never Luther’s intention to eliminate the presence of godparents at baptism. He believed that it was their duty to fulfil an important role in the religious education of their godchildren, especially in cases where the children’s parents had died, or were incapable of imparting the necessary religious instruction. Even though the existence
From ‘Prelude by Martin Luther on the Babylonian Captivity of the Church’, translated by Albert T. W. Steinhaeuser; English text edited and modernized by Robert E. Smith. The elimination of spiritual kinship by the Reformation can be seen also in the light of a radical transformation of the significance of the ceremony, analysed by Edward Muir. Most of the reformers, Calvin and Zwingli for example, held that the sacraments were solely a sign of the promise made by God to Man, and therefore had no material effect; in Muir’s words, the divine was no longer present in the sacraments, but was represented (Muir 2000, pp. 204 ff). During the Eucharist the consecrated host was not actually transferred into the body of Christ, or there was no transubstantiation; it is possible to maintain that, in the same way, during baptism nothing happened to establish new relations of kinship. However, not all the reformers agreed with this interpretation. Luther, for example, while rejecting the doctrine of transubstantiation, proposed that of consubstantiation, whereby the host is not transformed into the body of Christ but bread and body coexist in the consecrated host, as Man and God coexisted in Jesus. I think then that the reason for the choice of abolishing spiritual kinship is to be sought above all in the absence of scriptural grounds, already noted by Luther. This does not mean that the transformation of the significance of the ritual did not perhaps contribute to creating, in the whole context of the Reformation, an environment that particularly favoured such a step. The Lutheran position is clearly expressed in the Ordinances of the Church of Brandenburg/Nuremberg, mostly attributable to Andreas Osiander, an early follower of Luther (reported in Fisher 1970, pp. 26–27). Luther’s views on the question of godparenthood
Godparenthood in Sixteenth Century
69
of godparents at the baptismal font had no scriptural or apostolic grounds, godparenthood was considered to be pious and useful, and was therefore to be maintained. Seeing a need to reform godparenthood, Luther chose to concentrate on the aspect of spiritual kinship, but he was not concerned about the number of godparents. In fact, once spiritual kinship was eliminated, they were considered to be mere witnesses, at most with the addition of the moral duty to watch over the education of their godchildren (but there is no reason to believe that Protestant godparents were more zealous in their task than their Catholic counterparts). As the concept of spiritual incest had disappeared, the number of godparents was no longer a major problem. Despite Luther’s inflexible position, Reformed churches, at least at the outset, were divided on the question of marriage impediments for spiritual kinship. For example, the Protestant community of Strasbourg in its ordinances of 1560 maintained them, while they were totally rejected by French Protestants (Fine 1994, pp. 23–24). On the whole, though, it is clear that Reformed churches were inclined to abolish them. The Church of England followed the Lutheran stance, keeping godparenthood in its traditional form but eliminating spiritual kinship and the matrimonial bans it entailed. The 1661 Book of Common Prayer tried to contain the number of godparents allowed, in accordance with the ternary model, but later it became customary to attenuate this rule according to circumstances (Bailey 1951, pp. 101–106; Coster 2002, pp. 86–91). Calvin, though, on this, as on other issues, proved to be more radical. He was of the opinion that it should be the parents who presented their children at baptism, as at the baptism of children in the Early Church, a view which was held also by some English puritans. Even though Calvin, unlike Luther, did not attribute much importance to godparenthood, baptismal rites in Calvinist churches kept their godparents. Their role, however, was re-dimensioned, as now they shared the task of presenting children at the baptismal font with the natural parents and the congregation. In the literature on godparenthood, it is commonly held that in the end Calvin’s preaching emptied it of all meaning, as the role of parenthood carried out by the godparents was assimilated by the natural parents. The
were also summarized and systematized at the beginning of the seventeenth century by the theologian Johannes Gerhard (1582–1637). See Lynch 1986, pp. 22–23. On the position of various Protestant churches on the question of baptism, see Hillebrandt 1996 and Amann et al. 1932. Two godfathers and a godmother for boys, vice versa for girls.
Fathers and Godfathers
70
sponsores survived only because Calvin was in favour of infant rather than adult baptism. Recent research, however, has shown that Calvinist communities often adopted customs of godparenthood very different from those that we might expect on the basis of their theological beliefs. It seems that their godparenthood and comparatico relationships maintained an important social role, evidently still connected to the ‘traditional’ role they had had prior to the Reformation. I will come back to this later. In the complex world of the Reformation, only the Anabaptists and the sects that rejected infant baptism totally abolished godparenthood. The real ‘victim’ of the Reformation was, therefore, spiritual kinship and only that, as in many Protestant areas it is still customary to give children numerous godparents. Godparenthood, then, is one of the issues that created a real split between the Council of Trent (1545–1563) and the Protestant world. The Council was a fundamental turning point in the long history of godparenthood. In fact, the post-Tridentine Church not only found itself in a position where it could at last aspire to imposing its own view of godparenthood on populations that had, up to then, put up an effective resistance, but it also changed its attitude towards some crucial ‘theological-social’ issues. These two adjectives conceal one of the most interesting aspects of the reform of godparenthood: contributions that were theologically motivated, and were, above all, an answer to controversy from the Protestant world had consequences to which the Council seems to have given little thought. In turn, these consequences had a pastoral and ritual outcome which went in a completely different direction to the one desired. Proposals for reforming godparenthood appear for the first time during the discussion on a more general reform of the sacraments, aimed at preventing the large number of abuses that occurred in their administration.
See, for example, Lynch 1986, p. 23. In Geneva, at the time when Calvin was minister, the community of believers stubbornly defended their ‘right’ to godparenthood, so much so that he had to agree to keep a ‘Catholic’ tradition (with no scriptural basis), trying however to mould it to the aims of the Reformation (Spierling 2005). The importance of the relations of godfatherhood has been shown also for French Huguenots (Conner 2002) and Scottish puritans (Todd 2002).
In the centuries following Luther’s preaching, ecclesiastical or civil authorities in Germany made attempts to impose, with sumptuary laws, restrictions on the number of godfathers, on the number of guests attending the baptismal festivities and on the value of the baptismal gifts given by the godparents. According to contemporary witnesses, however, these laws were loosely applied, and exceptions were very common (Lynch 1986, p. 26). For the nature of the Tridentine reform of the sacraments, see Prosperi 1997, pp. 251–266.
Godparenthood in Sixteenth Century
71
The problems concerning godparenthood were systematically dealt with in 1547, during the so-called ‘Bologna period’. In his famous history of the Council, Hubert Jedin remarked that ‘a disproportionate amount of time was dedicated to the discussion on godparents of baptism and confirmation’ (Jedin 1973–1981, vol. III, p. 176). From my point of view, the attention the conciliar fathers paid to ‘details’ like godparenthood is a stroke of luck, as the minutes of the sessions in which the proposals for reforms were debated and compared enable us to obtain precious evidence on how the Church viewed extremely common practices. This attention to detail also provides crucial evidence of the importance given to the question of the number of godparents by the members of the Council themselves. The Council was inaugurated on 13 December 1545. The venue, Trent, was juridically part of the Empire and, as it was on the boundary, was to facilitate the access of participants of all nationalities. For years, the requests, first made by Luther and his followers and then by the Emperor, that a Council should be summoned had met the firm opposition of the Pope, motivated by the fear that Rome’s authority would be weakened by an assembly that might be difficult to govern. It was only Charles V’s military victory against France and the peace treaty signed at Crépy (1544) which made it possible to overcome the intransigence of Pope Paul III. However, the Council did not have an easy time: dissolved on more than one occasion and transferred elsewhere, it finally ended in December 1563, 18 years after it was inaugurated. After the first period at Trent (13 December 1545 to 11 March 1547), the assembly transferred to Bologna, where it remained until it was temporarily suspended.10 Despite what appeared to be a favourable setting, the mood of the Council during the Bologna period was anything but serene. The assembly had clearly become a pawn, and one of the most important, in a diplomatic game of renewed rivalry between the Pope and the Emperor (Jedin 1973– 1981, vol. III pp. 13–48). It was Paul III who called the shots in the move. He was afraid that the Council would weaken papal authority and the interests of the Roman Curia, and so the aim was completely to subordinate the assembly to the Pope, thus preventing further strengthening of Charles V, who had recently won the war against the League of Schmalkalda.11 The Emperor’s protests 10
The Council met once more in Trent from 1 May 1551, but news of renewed hostilities between the Empire and France once again caused it to be suspended (18 April 1552). The work of the Council began again only a decade later when the conciliar fathers were convened for the third time at Trent (18 January 1562 to 4 December 1563). 11 The League of Schmalkalda was an alliance in self-defence, founded in February 1531, which united the princes and cities of that part of Germany which had adhered to the
72
Fathers and Godfathers
against the move to Bologna ‘only meant that … it remained provisional and ineffective, almost a parenthesis. However, the change then imposed on the work of the assembly was decisive in the sense that it shut the door on any real reconciliation between confessional groups in disagreement’ (Prosperi 2001, p. 43). The significance of the Bologna period of the Council has often been underestimated. It was an important time for developing new perspectives of reform that would be resumed later. The debates not only produced material that would be reused, but during the long recesses they also oriented the views of those who had taken part or who had had the chance to follow the debates.12 On 6 June 1547 the Deputation for Reform was established, made up of eight members and presided over by the Archbishop of Matera, Giovanni Michele Saraceno. Its task was to gather material to submit to the Council in the plenary session (plenum), to ensure that the work began promptly. Among the topics that the Deputation dealt with was that concerning abuses of the sacraments of baptism, confirmation and the Eucharist. On 26 July the Deputation was able to present the results of its work.13 The abuses discovered by the Deputation in the administration of the sacraments of baptism and confirmation were listed under 10 headings. Those significant here are the fourth14 – which concerns the custom of choosing unworthy characters as godparents in baptism and confirmation,
Reformation. Its aim was to oppose Charles V’s order of 1530 to return to Catholicism. 12 This is the conviction of Jedin, who dedicated to the Bologna period the whole of Book IV of his monumental history of the Council (Jedin 1973–1981). 13 On the constitution of the Deputation for Reform, see Jedin 1973–1981, vol. III, pp. 170 ff. Unlike the other commissions instituted by the Council, the Deputation did not compile a protocol of its sittings, so the available information on its activity is restricted to its results and to occasional mention of it, for example in the diary of Angelo Massarello, the Council’s secretary and apostolic protonotario. Societas Goerresiana, Concilium Tridentinum diariorum, actorum, epistularum tractatuum (CTT, vol. I, pp. 660 ff). 14 The first abuse, ‘qui communis est ad omnia sacramenta’, consisted in the fact that some priests demanded payment for celebrating baptism. The second concerned baptism celebrated outside a church building (except for two special cases: baptism when life was at risk and the baptism of kings and princes). The third concerned baptism celebrated in churches where there was no font (CTT, vol. VI, p. 302). Note that the CTT is the primary source for the treatment of discussions within the Council. It is in fact the only critical and complete edition of the acts of the Tridentine available today, to which other relevant documents have been added: diaries and letters written by the participants to the Council. The task of publishing this monumental collection was begun in 1901 by a society of German Catholics called ‘Görres Gesellschaft’ and was completed only in 1985. For a brief discussion on the sources and the ancient historiography of the Council, see Prosperi 2001.
Godparenthood in Sixteenth Century
73
such as prostitutes or people who had been excommunicated15 – and above all the fifth. Within this heading the members of the Deputation for Reform held that ‘today many make use of the sacraments of baptism and of confirmation to obtain advantages, while the purpose of the sacraments is to attain divine grace’.16 Two other abuses, the sixth and the seventh respectively, derived from this: • the search for rich and powerful compadri ‘ut inde possit maiorem lucrum facere’, rather than someone suitable who would respect their duty towards the child being baptized or confirmed;17 • the presence of numerous godparents at baptism as well as at confirmation.18 The picture of the inauspicious consequences of the fifth abuse was completed by a series of very common beliefs, such as that of the power of the baptismal waters to bestow spiritual kinship between the child and his parents with people who were not present at the ceremony, a belief that would prove particularly difficult to eradicate, and was probably at the origin of a series of more or less fraudulent practices aimed at ‘compulsorily’ becoming related to the family of the baptized infant.19 Furthermore, the merry behaviour of those invited to the baptism, with the din they made, drowned out the words of the priest. The godparents themselves often took part in this commotion, using mostly verba iocosa 15
‘Quartus, quod in baptismo et confirmatione admittantur compatres etiam notorie infames et meretrices et similes, vel excommunicati seu a divinis interdicti, vel si sint impuberes vel religiosi, i.e. regulares aut monachi, seu non confirmati’ (CTT, vol. VI, p. 302). 16 ‘Quintus, quod hodie plerique utuntur sacramento baptismi et confirmationis ad questum, cum sacramenta ordinata sint ad consequendam divinam gratiam’ (CTT, vol. VI, p. 302). 17 ‘Primus, quia quilibet querit habere compatrem et divitem et potentem, ut inde possit maiorem lucrum facere, et non talem, qui idoneus sit ad servanda ea, quae promittuntur in ipso baptismo et confirmatione’ (CTT, vol. VI, pp. 302–303). 18 ‘Secundus, quod in uno et eodem baptismo quaerantur et recipiantur plures compatres; sic in confirmatione’ (CTT, vol. VI, p. 303). 19 This practice included, as well as the direct contact with baptismal waters, that of touching the bonnet of the baptized, which was impregnated with the water, touching the ears of the baptized, or the washing of their nappies. From the fifteenth century onwards these activities were criticized by a large number of diocesan synods, who tried to repress them (See Corrain and Zampini 1970, pp. 121–122, 166, 168, 182–183, 352). It seems that these efforts were not always successful; some of these practices (such as that of touching the bonnet, thus becoming ‘cummere di coppula’) were still being reported in the twentieth century.
Fathers and Godfathers
74
et inhonesta and anyway not paying attention to the ceremony in which they were meant to be witnesses.20 In fact, the Deputation’s report describes a situation that substantially coincided with what has already been observed: godparenthood, instituted for precise ritual requirements, was being used by the population for completely different purposes. Besides, the ceremonies that instituted baptism, but also confirmation, tended to have an irreverent aspect: the Deputation made reference to the general rowdiness and merriment that characterized the ceremony, and the conciliar fathers in their plenary debate also condemned the festivities that followed.21 It is particularly revealing that the members of the Deputation claimed that most of the abuses arose from the desire of maiorem lucrem facere. Clearly, the godparents were chosen on account of the benefits that could be obtained. If many were chosen, it was preferable that they were rich (the Deputation suggested that baptismal gifts should be prohibited) and powerful. This is why the custom of sending the baptismal water to an aspiring godparent who did not attend the ceremony was so common. It was believed that to establish spiritual kinship it was enough to wet the hands with the baptismal water. Powerful people, especially if they resided at a distance, might not have been willing to take part in the baptismal ceremony or in the festivities that followed, but were ready to send a gift and accept this form of participation at a distance. As we will see, the Council also dealt with the problem of legates,22 who were another means of participating without actually being present. 20
‘Fit etiam abusus in baptismo et confirmatione, quia, dum baptismus fit vel confirmatio, plerumque fit tantus strepitus, ut vix verba sacerdotis baptizantis vel episcopi confirmantis intelligi possint. Praeterea plerunque proferuntur ab ipsis compatribus verba iocosa et inhonesta, dum attenti esse deberent ad ea, quae recitantur et pro quibis ipsimet sponsores sunt’ (CTT, vol. VI, p. 303). 21 There were also scandals that had a vast echo, like the one in 1460 involving Rodrigo Borgia, the future Pope Alexander VI. He attended a baptismal party with Cardinal d’Estouteville in a garden in Siena; both were godfathers. In the letter of rebuke that Pope Pius II sent to Rodrigo we read: ‘Three days or more ago several women of Siena assembled in the gardens of Giovanni Bichi … you … with little regard for your dignity were with one of them from one to six in the afternoon, having the company of a cardinal, who, if not out of decorum befitting the apostolic seat, at least from his age should have remembered his duties. We have been told that the dancing was unseemly, no amusement of love was lacking, and you behaved like a young layman. Decency forbids us to describe what took place, things of which merely the name is unseemly to your dignity: husbands, fathers and brothers who accompanied the young women were forbidden to enter, so that you could be freer to amuse yourselves’ (Bellonci 1983 (1st edn 1939), pp. 28–29). 22 The problem arose because it was not clear, either from the practice itself, or from a theological point of view (see the observation of Filippo Archinto, Bishop of Saluzzo, expressed during the meetings of the Canonists’ Commission of 6 September; CTT, vol. I, p. 436), whether the legates, as well as the legatee, formed a bond of spiritual kinship with the
Godparenthood in Sixteenth Century
75
The Deputation for Reform did not restrict itself to presenting a list of abuses, but also submitted a second list containing possible solutions (provisiones) to the problems encountered. The first measure proposed deserves mention, because it proved to be of exceptional importance for historical studies. It recommended that each priest when celebrating baptism should record in an appropriate register the names and surnames of the child baptized, of his parents and his godfathers and godmothers.23 As has been noted previously, it was a recognition of customs already widely practised in Italy. How, though, was this instruction an initial response to the abuses listed by the Deputation? The parish registers prior to the Council of Trent, when they were not established to satisfy the requests of the civic authorities, were introduced to keep control over the ties of kinship created by baptism, and in consequence to prevent cases of spiritual incest occurring. Strangely, the Deputation made no mention of this abuse, which was the source of numerous scandals and was to play a very important part in plenary discussions. This leads us to opt for the following interpretation: the register of baptisms was viewed by the Deputation not as a means of assisting the priest’s memory but rather as a means of controlling his conduct. It is not by chance that the question that frequently recurs in the first pastoral visits following the Tridentine council is: ‘Do you keep a record of baptisms?’ What is interesting here is that thanks to the register, it was possible to establish in the first place how many godparents were admitted to the baptism, as well as, though with some difficulty, whether the godparents chosen were unsuitable, being heretics, or those who had not been to confession and so on. The baptismal registers, therefore, were a kind of prerequisite for the effective application of many of the other measures proposed by the Deputation. These included: a prohibition to make gifts at baptism or confirmation; an obligation for godparents to pay attention when attending the ceremony; a warning to priests to rebuke anyone who disturbed the ceremony by gossiping about mundane affairs; an interdiction against rebaptizing those who had already been baptized because their life
godchild and his parents. It was the Deputation for Reform that demanded at the end of the list of provisiones, which I will deal with shortly, that once and for all an vera compaternitas contrahatur per procuratorem be clarified (CTT, vol. VI, p. 305). On the ‘political’ use that was made of the legates at Bologna, see Reinhardt 2000. 23 ‘… habeat penes se librum, in quo describat nomina e cognomina eorum, qui baptizantur, et parentum, et similiter eorum, qui levant baptizatos ex fonte, id est compatres’ (CTT, vol. VI, p. 303).
Fathers and Godfathers
76
had been in danger. Towards the end of the list is the most important item: ‘lay people are warned to refrain from seeking out numerous compari’.24 The materials proposed by the Deputation for Reform and the measures suggested provide an interesting picture of what was happening to baptismal practices in the first half of the sixteenth century, whether despite the Church’s position or with its tacit or absent-minded approval. In addition, they already in essence contain all the problems over which the plenary sessions would be exercised. Once the Deputation for Reform had presented the results of its work, there was no immediate discussion. The material collected by the Deputation was submitted to a second commission (the Canonists’ Commission), presided over by Cardinal Giovanni Maria de Monte,25 whose duty was to examine it and elaborate canons to submit to the plenary sessions of the Council. After the plenary session had discussed the canons, the Canonists’ Commission had to formulate decrees incorporating the reforms. The Commission first dealt with the abuses concerning baptism and confirmation on 30 August, continuing the next day. It is interesting to compare the minutes of the discussion with those of the plenum, which I will examine shortly. Adopting the spirit of the Deputation for Reform, the Commission dealt with the question of the choice of godparents with a view to the benefits that could be obtained, together with the issue of numerous godparents.26 Only three fathers, of the seven present, intervened.27 All recognized that in effect it was abuses that they were dealing with. The only one to express a reasoned opinion was Egidio Falcetta, Bishop of Caorle, who pointed out that it was not a question of preventing princes and magnates from being chosen as godparents, but of forbidding baptismal gifts. Besides, as far as multiple godparents were concerned, he suggested that the constitution of Leo I should be renewed. This established that each newly born infant should have only one godfather or godmother.28 Falcetta’s opinion is interesting for two reasons. First, because the stipulation regarding powerful 24
‘Admoneantur etiam laici, ut abstineant a pluritate compatrum’ (CTT, vol. VI, p.
305). 25
For the relation between the Deputation for Reform and the Canonists’ Commission, see Jedin 1973–1981, vol. III, pp. 174 ff. 26 ‘Quintus, quod compatres fiant propter lucrum, et quod plures recipiantur in compatres, quam deceat’ (CTT, vol. VI, p. 415). 27 In this order: bishops Giovanni Pietro Ferretto, Egidio Falcetta and Alvaro de la Quadra. 28 ‘Non plures ad suscipiendum de baptismo infantem accedant, quam unus, sive vir sive mulier. In confirmatione quoque id ipsum fiat.’ The prescription was included in the collection Decretum Gratiani (dist. IV de consecratione) and therefore easily available to the conciliar fathers; however, for centuries it had not been enforced (Leo I was Pope from
Godparenthood in Sixteenth Century
77
personages, who could not be as such excluded from godparenthood, is the first and a very early expression of uncertainty by those who wished to confront the problem of godparents chosen per lucrum, although, as will clearly emerge later on, Falcettta did not really have very clear ideas on the subject. Second, it is the first time, at least in the discussions as they have been handed down to us, that a reference is made to Leo I’s constitution, which was, from a legal point of view, the main point of reference of the ‘single godparent party’. At the end of the second meeting (on 31 August), a draft of five canons was ready. The fourth states:29 ‘To baptism and confirmation no more than one person is admitted as godparent, and whoever is admitted must not have a bad reputation, not be excommunicated, not be suspended a divinis, not be a child nor a monk.30 They should be confirmed, not be a prostitute, nor for any other reasons unsuited to maintaining the promises made at baptism.’31 No mention whatsoever is made in the text of the custom of preferring to give children rich and powerful godparents, which the Deputation for Reform considered closely linked to the problem of multiple godparents. Evidently, the objections made by Falcetta during the discussion had seemed convincing. The reduction in the number of godparents, then, was considered the best means, or the only one possible, of dealing with the selection per lucrum of spiritual kin. As I will show shortly, even the caution regarding baptismal gifts would not have an easy passage. The canon already outlined the model of godparenthood proposed by the Council: one godparent, who was not ‘unworthy’ but well suited to carrying out his role as tutor in the good Christian education of the child. 440–461). The Decretum Gratiani is published in Friedberg, Corpus Iuris Canonici, Vol. I, Officina Bernhardi Tauchnitz, Leipzig, 1923. The decree of Leo I is on p. 1394. 29 The others deal with: the obligation to administer sacraments gratis; the prohibition on celebrating baptism outside a church (apart from the exceptions already mentioned); the obligation to celebrate baptism only in churches with a baptismal font; the obligation to attend to the baptismal water and the font, so that abuses are avoided. 30 The exclusion of monks and nuns from spiritual kinship, a rule often infringed, is very old and can be explained by the fear that it would create personal links between monks and lay people that might compromise their withdrawal from the world (see Lynch 1986, pp. 149–155 and 169). The Council debated at length whether or not to allow other categories of clerics to form bonds of spiritual kinship. Previously there had been attempts to restrict them, which were regularly ignored (Guerreau-Jalabert 1995, p. 143). On access to godparenthood by members of the clergy before and after the Council, see Alfani 2004b. 31 ‘In baptismo et confirmatione non plures quam unus ad suscipiendum aliquem in filium admittantur, et qui admittitur, non sit notorie infamis vel excommunicatus vel a divinis interdictus vel impubes vel monachus vel non confirmatus vel mulier publice prostituta vel alias minus idoneus ad praestandum ea, quae in baptismo promittuntur’ (CTT, vol. VI, p. 418).
78
Fathers and Godfathers
In the discussions that followed, however, the proposal was not as easily accepted as the apparent agreement of intent on the part of the members of the Deputation for Reform and the Canonists’ Commission would lead us to believe. The Canonists’ Commission met again on 2 September to discuss eventual modifications to make to the text of the canons. It was on this occasion that a split emerged on the question of the number of godparents allowed. Peter van der Vorst, in fact, observed that it was necessary to reword the canon in order to admit the custom of giving to the baptized two godfathers and a godmother, or vice versa. This was the ternary model, which, as we saw in the Chapter 2, was very common in Europe and above all in France. Perhaps the Flemish van der Vorst, Bishop of Acqui, feared that it would prove impossible to impose a different regulation in the lands under his jurisdiction, or perhaps he himself was particularly attached to these customs; the acts of the Council do not allow us to go deeper into his motivations, nor (usually) into those of other ‘dissidents’. I will restrict myself, therefore, to pointing out how, in this first attempt at resistance, the legal basis for the defence of multiple godparents was already clear: it was established practice. It is equally clear what was the main weakness of this line of defence: the variety of practices, which led van der Vorst to demand the preservation of one practice (his own? that of his bishopric?), and not to make it an issue of principle as others, more shrewdly, tried to do.32 Four days later, on 6 September, the Canonists’ Commission met for the third time and discussed the directives (admonitiones) that the Deputation for Reform had attached to the material they had collected. Without going into detail, the debate centred on whether it was right to forbid baptismal gifts and the festivities following the ceremony, without, however, reaching an agreement. The question of baptismal gifts was left in abeyance and entrusted to the plenary session; as for festivities, a compromise was suggested, which consisted of replacing the profane elements with others of a sacred nature.33 The directive concerning the reduction in the number 32 In the course of the session of 2 September, the problem of practice was reiterated also by a second canonist, although for completely different reasons. Giovanni Pietro Ferretto, Bishop of Mileto, pointed out that the custom totius ecclesiae was against one godparent, so he said he was in favour of punishing those who infringed the new rule (CTT, vol. VI, p. 422). 33 The directive, as presented in the plenary session, states: ‘Ut occasione baptismi non fiant solemnia convivia cum tripudiis et choreis, sed cum benedictionibus et gratiarum actione et laude atque gloria Dei ac Domini redemptoris nostri, qui ex sua ineffabili bonitate sacramenta largitus est hominibus in remedium humanae fragilitatis.’ It is evident that the Commission had gone up a blind alley, as the festivities following the sacrament were intrinsically an element that was profane, and it would anyway have been useless to expect
Godparenthood in Sixteenth Century
79
of godparents was maintained, even though to many it seemed useless as the problem had already been mentioned in one of the canons.34 Despite discussion, four out of five of the canons that were proposed on 31 August came before the assembly virtually unchanged.35 The fathers had all received the entire list, dated 23 September, so that they could examine it before the plenary session, which occupied no less than seven days (26, 27, 28 and 30 September, 1, 3 and 5 October). During this time, each of the 56 fathers present expressed his own opinion on the canons. Consequently, we have the same number of votes either for or against, or for proposals with a compromise.36 At the opening of the session on 26 September, Giovanni Michele Saraceno, Archbishop of Matera and president of the Deputation for Reform, was asked to summarize the points under discussion. In his presentation the reduction to one in the number of spiritual kin was expressly justified with reference to the constitution of Leo I, the juridical foundation of the ‘single godparent party’. The first to speak was Antoine Le Filleul, Archbishop of Aix, who approved the fourth canon, suggesting, however, that it should be possible to ask one’s bishop for a dispensation in order to have a larger number of godparents. This is interesting because this condition was in fact accepted by the Council.37 The first voice of dissent was soon raised. Archbishop Sebastiano Lecavela, Bishop of Nasso and third to speak, observed that what was proposed concerning the number of godparents was ‘contra consuetudinem totius ecclesiae’, and this custom was ‘laudabilis’ as well as ‘neque a doctoribus damnatur’. The defence of multiple godparenthood was lively
solemn behaviour on the part of guests who had been difficult to restrain even during the baptismal service itself. On this point, the Deputation for Reform seems to have had clearer ideas. From the outset any attempt at compromise was destined to fail. 34 With regard to this canon, the directive linked the obligation to abstain from numerous godparents with the importance to attribute to the relationship of spiritual kinship (‘Ut layci admoniti, quanti momenti sit spiritualis cognatio, a pluralitate compatrum abstineant’) (CTT, vol. VI, p. 439). 35 From the text the only reference to be eliminated, as those unworthy to be godfathers or godmothers, was that to the non-confirmed and prostitutes. 36 A certain number of fathers limited themselves to expressing overall agreement with the canons proposed, without going into details (‘placent canones’, ‘probat canones’ etc). They are numbered among the supporters of one godparent. 37 Even though it is not widely known, the possibility of asking for a dispensation to have an additional godfather or godmother still exists today. However, once people became accustomed to giving up multiple godparents, requests for dispensation were extremely rare.
Fathers and Godfathers
80
and based from a legal point of view on established practice.38 Besides, Lecavela disclosed that the ‘doctores’ had never condemned these customs, which were widespread throughout Christendom.39 Faced with this kind of statement the impression is that the party in favour of multiple godparents took the proposals for reform as an insult, lacking solid theological grounds: the constitution of Leo I, the text of a law probably never enforced, must have seemed to them of little consequence in comparison with a widespread and established practice. Actually, why was the number of godparents such a crucial issue? In fact, during the preparation of the canons, most of the questions presented by the Deputation for Reform were dropped, and never reached discussion in plenary, for example the proposal directly to control selection of godparents and thus avoid choices based on the advantages that could be obtained. As I said in the Chapter 2, the area of Emilia distinguished itself on account of a godparenthood that definitely restricted the number of godfathers and godmothers present at baptism. It is possible that the ‘immersion’ of the Council in such local customs contributed to the creation of a climate unfavourable to multiple godparenthood, or, rather, favourable to an extension to the whole Church of a practice like the one in force in the land that hosted these discussions. However attractive, this explanation is certainly partial and insufficient. Another aspect to take into consideration is that a reduction in the number of godparents must have seemed a relatively easy option, so much so that it quickly became the only proposal to deal with the abuses highlighted by the Deputation. Once more, however, this does not seem enough. The discussion of the fourth canon during the plenary sessions is, in some ways, amazing: from a theological point of view, the triteness of the debate is disconcerting and, as I have just noted, the only ones from this point of view who could put forward solid arguments were those who defended multiple godparents, although, in the end they were thwarted. Generally speaking, the exchange of views had an extremely ‘practical’ flavour, as clearly emerges from the compromises that were proposed.
38
Speaking straight after Lecavela and taking sides with those who supported multiple godfathers, Olaus Magnus, Archbishop of Uppsala, to show the illegitimacy of the proposal for one godparent refers to a ‘pontifical book’, which allowed two godparents. Identification of this source is, however, uncertain (CTT, vol. VI, p. 491). 39 Ibid. The approval expressed by the doctores for multiple godparents was usually based on a twofold reasoning. In the first place, in a case in which there is doubt whether the person is baptized or not, the more godfathers there are, the easier it is to confirm it. Secondly, the more godparents, the greater the number of people involved in the education of the children. The first argument is found, for example, in J. Beleth (see, Guerreau-Jalabert 1995, pp. 167–168).
Godparenthood in Sixteenth Century
81
From a theological point of view these had strange or sometimes absurd implications. It was a practical debate for a practical purpose, and certainly not a fight against the ‘bad habit’ of trying to obtain an advantage from the baptism of one’s children. What drove most of the council fathers to support the proposal to restrict the number of godparents was the need to reduce the scandals which took place around the ‘incestus spiritualis’, in other words in the marriages between people connected by spiritual kinship. The problem of the scandals emerged on more than one occasion during the plenary discussion,40 and, as we will see, gave rise to the proposal to eliminate all interdiction on marriage for spiritual kinship. The prevention of spiritual incest in this light had to be effective, and it was the Council’s intention to remove any pretext for criticism on the part of Protestants. This is what set the tone of the discussion. Like the first defence of multiple godparents, a solution that proposed a compromise also appeared early on in the debate. The Archbishop of Armagh, Robert Vauchop, the fifth person to speak, proposed that multiple godparents should be admitted to baptism, but specified that with only one should there be a relationship of spiritual kinship.41 From a theological point of view, it is impossible to justify such a position, which, among other things, gave rise to considerable confusion.42 However, the proposal seems to have matched perfectly the very practical mood that characterized the discussion from the outset. It is definitely an unfortunate example of the use of compromise that was to surface on several occasions during the Council.43 In certain respects Vauchop’s idea recalls the decisions made by Luther completely to eliminate spiritual kinship with its related matrimonial impediments, maintaining the possibility of giving children numerous godparents, who, though, attend the baptism as mere witnesses. Vauchop proposed a curious hybrid solution that combined safeguarding the institution of spiritual kinship, as it had a history with a solid theological formulation, with transforming most of 40
For example in the speech of the Bishop of Porto, Baldassarre Lympo (CTT, vol. VI, p. 494). 41 ‘Quartus canon: placet, ut, cum sunt plures tenentes, unus tantum compaternitatem contrahat. Alii possint assistere, sed non contrahant’ (CTT, vol. VI, p. 491). 42 With which godparent would kinship be contracted? Would the father be able to decide? Would this ‘super godfather’ have a special role in the ceremony? And so on. With regards to the first question, a possible reply emerged on 5 November, during a meeting of the Canonists’ Commission. Giovanni Battista Cicada, Bishop of Albenga, suggested that spiritual kinship should be contracted only with the oldest godparent (CTT, vol. VI, p. 573). 43 The best-known and perhaps most investigated example is the one regarding whether or not so-called ‘clandestine marriage’ was legitimate. See Jedin 1973–1981, vol. III, pp. 199–226 and vol. IV, pp. 139–174.
82
Fathers and Godfathers
the godparents into witnesses.44 Despite its intrinsic doctrinal weakness, this proposal found defenders,45 which is a further confirmation of the fact that, in the debate, considerations of a merely theological nature carried limited weight. A fresh compromise was promised on the second day of discussion. Lelio Baruffo de Piis, Bishop of Sarsina, on the whole expressing his approval of the fourth canon, proposed, however, that two godparents46 should be allowed. The proposal, unlike Vauchop’s, did not cause theological misgivings but, although it actually provided an opportunity for the defenders of multiple godparents, its practical application involved problems that were almost as serious as those created by the transition to a sole godparent.47 Anyway, there were those who supported the proposal.48 Immediately after Baruffo, Peter van der Vorst took the floor. He reiterated the opinion he had already expressed as member of the Deputation for Reform: it was necessary to safeguard a particular practice, which was to give two godfathers and a godmother to boys and two godmothers and a godfather to girls. On the same day, 27 September, the most radical of the proposals for reform of godparenthood was put forward. Baldassarre Lympo, Bishop of Porto, not only said he was in favour of one godparent, but proposed also a drastic reduction in the extension of spiritual kinship: it was to be maintained only between the baptized and the person baptizing, and between the person confirmed and he who confirmed. Lympo explained 44 Note that the distinction between ‘godparents’ and ‘witnesses’ is only partially recognized by current canon law. While the presence of at least one Catholic godfather or godmother at baptism is compulsory, members of denominations other than Catholic are allowed to take part in the baptismal ceremony as simple witnesses (Code of Canon Law, canon 874). It is obvious that the purpose of this rule, which appeared for the first time in the 1983 Code of Canon Law (the result of Vatican Council II, which met in Rome from 1962 to 1965) is quite different from the one proposed by Vauchop. The 1983 Code reflects a desire to further relations between members of different denominations in an ecumenical spirit; Vauchop’s proposal was aimed at reforming godparenthood while somehow getting round the obstacle raised by local customs. 45 Namely Filippo Archinto, Bishop of Saluzzo, and Camillo Perusco, Bishop of Alatri. Perhaps to them can be added Francesco Romeo, General of the Order of Friars Preachers of St. Dominic, who having defended the legitimacy of multiple godparents, observed that it might be better to agree that among them there was one who was the principal godparent (CTT, vol. VI, p. 503). 46 CTT, vol. VI, p. 493. 47 Baruffo’s proposal is very close to what was to be the final decision of the Council, with the difference that no distinction was made between godfather and godmother, and so it would have been possible to choose two godfathers, two godmothers or one of each. 48 Bernardo Bongioanni, Bishop of Camerino.
Godparenthood in Sixteenth Century
83
clearly that he made this proposal in order to prevent scandal, and expressed the opinion that many other bans on marriage should also be eliminated.49 His proposal had a large following,50 which was moreover bipartisan if compared to the split over the question of one godparent. The Bishop of Saluzzo, Filippo Archinto, in particular, took it up again on 28 September to formulate, as an alternative to Vauchop’s proposal, a third type of compromise: multiple godparents, but with whom no relationship of spiritual kinship was established.51 The proposal is very near to a kind of ‘Lutheran’ solution, differing from it only insofar as it is not based on theological premises and because it maintained a vestige of spiritual kinship (between the person baptizing and the baptized). The proposals made during the plenary session were extremely varied. Complicating matters were the ‘hawks’; three of them were members of the Deputation for Reform (Olaus Magnus, Peter van der Vorst52 and Filippo Archinto), who had indicated as an abuse the large number of godparents, and a fourth was a member of the Canonists’ Commission (Egidio Falcetta), who had included this measure in the fourth canon. However, when they intervened in the plenary session, they sided in defence of multiple godparents.53 Table 4.1 lists the names, the office and the ‘country of origin’ of those who dissented with the proposal to reduce the number of godparents to one.
49
CTT, vol. VI, p. 494. Filippo Archinto (Bishop of Saluzzo), Cornelio Musso (Bishop of Bitonto), Alvaro de la Quadra (Bishop of Venosa), Francesco Gagliani (Bishop of Pistoia), Jacques Spitame (Bishop of Nevers), Roberto Senali (Bishop of Avranches). 51 CTT, vol. VI, p. 496. This proposal also had its supporters: Cornelio Musso (Bishop of Bitonto), Francesco Gagliani (Bishop of Pistoia) and as an alternative to maintaining multiple godparents, Egidio Falcetta (Bishop of Caorle). With regard to Musso, there remains an element of doubt because his speech was rather obscure (CTT, vol. VI, p. 497). 52 Van der Vorst had already espressed his opinion against only one godparent, but it was not reflected in the canon put forward to the plenum. 53 The Deputation for Reform did not record minutes of its meetings, so it is impossible to ascertain whether there was debate on the subject. With regard to Egidio Falcetta, I have already noted that he was the only one to split the unity of the Canonists’ Commission in the struggle against the choice of godfathers per lucrum. During those meetings, however, he did not make further objections to the reduction in the number of godfathers to one. 50
Table 4.1 Opinions against a sole godparent Against reduction in the number of godparents Name Office Claude de la Guische ep. Mirapicensis (Mirepoix) Gregorio Castagnola ep. Mylensis (Melos), ord. Praedicatorum Sebastiano Lecavela archiep. Naxiensis (Naxos), ord. Praedicatorum Richard Pate ep. Vigorniensis (Worcester) Francisco Romeo Generalis ord. Praedicatorum Gianbattista Campeggio ep. Maioricensis (Maiorca) Egidio Falcetta* ep. Caprulanus (Caorle) Giovanni Battista Cicada ep. Albinganensis (Albenga), auditor camerae apostolicae Giovanni Giacomo Barba ep. Aprutinus (Teramo), ord. Heremit. Bernardo Bongioanni* ep. Camerinensis (Camerino) Ambrogio Catarino ep. Minoriensis (Minori) Olaus Magnus archiep. Upsalensis (Uppsala)
Country France France Greece England Italy (Arezzo) Italy (Bologna) Italy (Cingoli) Italy (Genua) Italy (Naples) Italy (Rome) Italy (Siena) Sweden
Willing to reach a compromise Multiple godparents, but spiritual kinship established with only one of them Name Office Filippo Archinto* ep. Salutiarum (Saluzzo), vicarius S. mi D. N. in Urbe Camillo Perusco ep. Alatrinus (Alatri), rector studii romani Robert Vauchop archiep. Armarcanus (Armagh)
Country Italy (Milan) Italy (Rome) Scotland
Restriction in the number of godparents to two
Name Lelio Baruffo de Piis Bernardo Bongioanni*
Office ep. Sarsinatensis (Sarsina) ep. Camerinensis (Camerino)
Country Italy (Bertinoro) Italy (Rome)
Preservation of a specific custom: two godfathers and one godmother for boys, vice versa for girls Name Office Peter van der Vorst ep. Aquensis (Acqui)
Country Flanders
Multiple godparents, without matrimonial impediments Name Office Egidio Falcetta* ep. Caprulanus (Caorle) Francesco Gagliani ep. Pistoriensis (Pistoia) Filippo Archinto* ep. Salutiarum (Saluzzo), vicario S. mi D. N. in Urbe Cornelio Musso ep. Bituntinus (Bitonto), ord. Min. Convent.
Country Italy (Cingoli) Italy (Florence) Italy (Milan) Italy (Piacenza)
*Willing to accept different solutions; see in table.
86
Fathers and Godfathers
Of the 56 fathers taking part in the plenary sessions, 19 (34 per cent, i.e. about one in three) were completely against the adoption of a sole godparent. Of these, 12 wanted to leave things as they were, that is maintaining local customs; three proposed that spiritual kinship was established only with one of the many godparents present; two suggested restricting the number of godparents admitted to two; one asked to preserve exclusively the practice of two godfathers and one godmother (or vice versa); and four said they were willing to cancel matrimonial impediments almost completely, thus solving the problem of incestus spiritualis without reducing the number of godparents. The sum of the votes exceeds 19 because three of the fathers were ready to accept two different solutions. The origin of those who defended multiple godparents is very varied. Two-thirds were Italian, but at that time so were most of the participants in the Council. They came from all parts of the peninsula, a confirmation that the practice of giving children numerous godparents was widespread. As far as other countries are concerned, northern regions (an Englishman, a Swede, a Scot and a Fleming) and France (two) were better represented in comparison with Mediterranean Europe (only one from Greece). At the conclusion of the plenary sessions, it was once again up to the Canonists’ Commission to examine closely changes proposed to the original formulation of the canons. The fourth canon was examined on 5 November. Again there was no lack of defenders of multiple godparenthood, among whom was Cristoforo de’ Spiriti, Bishop of Cesena, who during the plenary session had not expressed any dissent; but, given the decided majority in favour of one godparent, the conclusion was reached that the canon should be kept unchanged, at least in this regard. At that time, though, the participants in the Council had other worries: the growing differences between the papacy and the Empire would shortly lead to a suspension of the meetings. The Bologna period ended without any decree on godparenthood being issued. The question was not even touched on in the next phase (1 May 1551 to 28 April 1552); it was only in the final period of the Council (18 January 1562 to 4 December 1563) that the subject of godparents was discussed once more, even though the space assigned to it was, in proportion, far less than in 1547. The documents compiled at Bologna were used again as preparatory material to further some aspects of reform. First, of interest here, was that of marriage. Trent, in fact, did not produce a real decree on the reform of the sacrament of baptism54 in the way the work planned in 1547 seemed to have promised. Instead, some of the proposals were accepted and 54 In the sense of a group of canons under the heading of reform of this sacrament, as happened, for example, in the cases of the Eucharist and marriage.
Godparenthood in Sixteenth Century
87
introduced into different contexts. This is what happened to the reform of godparenthood, which found a place in the canons on marriage. As is well known, the reform of the sacrament of marriage was one of the most delicate questions that the Council had to face in its final phase, in particular with regard to the complicated matter of the validity of clandestine marriages.55 It is not relevant to go into the question here other than to note that in the plenary session of 11 August 1563,56 12 articles of reform submitted to the conciliar fathers for the first time were appended to the famous Tametsi decree,57 the contents of which had already been the object of previous discussion and revision, but on which there was still no agreement. One of these articles dealt with the problem of marriages contracted in breach of the rules of the Church, which meant either a life lived in sin or a dissolution of the union once the parties recognized their error and, consequently, a grave scandal. This was attributed to the excessive number of prohibitions; to find an answer, the suggestion was made to annul the fourth degree of consanguinity and the state of brotherand sister-in-lawhood, as well as to reduce the number of godparents allowed in baptism and confirmation and to reduce the boundaries of spiritual kinship. Little remained, therefore, of all the proposals for the reform of godparenthood. No mention was made of the instructions concerning the qualifications that godparents should possess, nor of festivities or baptismal gifts; only a reduction in the number of godparents was proposed together with the elimination of many ‘degrees’ of spiritual kinship. These were merely calculated by the number of impediments to marriage that were abolished. The ‘reform of godparenthood’ was deprived of any doctrinal autonomy. I have searched in the discussions that followed for traces of the ‘multiple godparent party’ that had so opposed reform 16 years previously. I found none, and the only faint signs of opposition concerned the reduction of the extension of spiritual kinship. The reason for it seems clear: there were so many clashes regarding the Tametsi and other aspects of the reform of marriage58 that the reduction in the number of godparents was of secondary importance; indeed, it went practically unnoticed by the conciliar fathers. We can easily affirm, then, that the reform of marriage was the Trojan
55
On the Tridentine reform of marriage, see Zarri 1996; Lombardi 2001; Seidel Menchi and Quaglioni 2000, 2001, 2004. 56 CTT, vol. IX, pp. 685–697. 57 On Tametsi see Jedin 1973–1981, vol. IV, pp. 156 ff. 58 For an account of the conciliar discussion on Tametsi, see Lombardi 2001, pp. 109– 118; Jedin 1973–1981, vol. IV, pp. 138–200.
88
Fathers and Godfathers
horse that made it possible to overcome without a struggle the resistance to the reform of godparenthood.59 What exactly were the features of this ‘mutilated reform’ of godparenthood? Its final version reads: Experience teaches that it is often an excessive number of interdictions that out of ignorance leads to contract a marriage that is forbidden, and thus, either the couple continue in their marriage, committing a grave sin, or the marriage is dissolved, but not without a grave scandal. The Council, therefore, wishing to find a solution to this inconvenience, beginning with the impediments of spiritual kinship, decrees that only one, man or woman, according to the prescriptions of the sacred canons,60 or at the most one man and one woman can be godfather or godmother at baptism. They will contract spiritual kinship with the baptized and with his or her mother and father; so also a similar kinship will only be between the person baptizing and the baptized and the father and mother of the latter.61
In this final version the reduction in the number of godparents of baptism and confirmation62 and the restriction of the extension of spiritual kinship are the only means by which the objective of reducing marriage impediments was reached. The fourth degree of blood relationships, in fact, was maintained by the Council and would be abolished only by the 1917 Code of Canon Law. The reduction in the number of godparents, though very close to that proposed at Bologna by the ‘single godparent party’ was in a way a sort of compromise. Even though it is clearly stated that the ideal solution is to provide children with one godfather or godmother, only one godfather and one godmother at the most are allowed. As will be seen, this concession was to produce unexpected results. Going beyond the letter of the decree, in the light of the discussions that took place in 1547 and the decisions taken in 1563, it is possible 59 Other proposals concerning the project of reform of baptism were to form part of those on marriage, primarily the obligation to keep registers of baptisms and marriages. 60 The decree of Leo I. 61 ‘Docet experientia, propter multitudinem prohibitiorum multoties in casibus prohibitis ignoranter contrahi matrimonia, in quibus vel non sine magno peccato perseveratur, vel ea non sine magno scandalo dirimuntur. Volens itaque sancta synodus huic incommodo providere, et a cognationis spiritualis impedimento incipiens, statuit, ut unus tantum, sive vir sive mulier, iuxta sacrorum canonum instituta, vel ad summum unus et una baptizatum de baptismo suscipiant, inter quos ac baptizatum ipsum et illius patrem et matrem, nec non inter baptizantem et baptizatum baptizatique patrem ac matrem tantum spiritualis cognatio contrahatur’ (CTT, vol. IX, p. 969). 62 The passage on confirmation, which I have not transcribed here, is included in the same chapter as on baptism (CTT, vol. IX, p. 696).
Godparenthood in Sixteenth Century
89
to discern clearly the model of godparenthood that the majority of the conciliar fathers would have liked to impose. It was made up of three elements: 1. the godfather (or godmother) had to be one; 2. he/she had to be worthy; 3. he/she had to fulfil the commitment taken at baptism and to be actively responsible for the Christian education of their godchild. The application, or rather the attempted application, of this model will be the subject of the next chapters. However, a final observation is necessary. Many have underlined the role of the Council of Trent as the architect of a discipline of social relations that was subsequently to be entrusted to other institutions (Prodi 1994; Prosperi 2001, pp. XIII–XIV). The reform of marriage is certainly one of its better known components and for many reasons it comes close to the reform of godparenthood. The fact that the second is formally included in the first is a mere juridical expedient; much more important is the fact that both tried to combat common customs (for example in the case of marriage, abduction and concubinage,63 in the case of godparenthood, the multiplication of godparents64), to standardize practices and rituals,65 to emphasize the control of the Church over every aspect of the sacraments and of the attendant ceremonies. I will come back to this. More attention has been paid to the newly imposed discipline than to another equally important aspect, the project of reshaping society. I have emphasized that at the Council the tone of the debate was eminently practical; at least as far as the theme of godparenthood was concerned, theological concerns were of limited importance. The method adopted consisted in the comparison, in the juxtaposition and in the combination of proposals of a concrete nature. I do not think it is far-fetched in this sense to speak of a kind of ‘social engineering’, as the Council was in effect planning the society of the future. Even questions traditionally considered from a doctrinal point of view to be of comparatively ‘minor’ importance might lead to rules that definitely affected the lives and society of peoples in Europe; this is certainly true of the debate on the number of godparents.
63
Seidel Menchi and Quaglioni 2001, 2004. Other customs condemned during the discussion but then not mentioned in the final canons of reform were prohibited locally when the Tridentine rules were applied; I will come back to this in the next chapter. 65 For marriage, see Zarri 1996, p. 460. 64
90
Fathers and Godfathers
Recognition of this project of social reshaping leads us to wonder how far the conciliar fathers were aware that they were about to modify society. In response we must look at each case separately. For example, when the reform of marriage was discussed, every possible consequence of the proposed modifications was carefully analysed. However, when dealing with the reduction in the number of godparents, it seems that the conciliar fathers had a very limited awareness of what they were about to impose on Catholic populations. What emerges from the actions of the Council is only concern whether it would be possible to apply certain rules, and whether they would effectively achieve the pre-established objectives. The possible ‘collateral effects’ on society were not taken into account: nobody bothered to note that the denigrated practice of choosing rich and powerful godparents assisted certain strata of the population in establishing relationships on which they could rely in moments of crisis (to give an extremely restricted interpretation of the complex phenomenon of godparenthood). The analogy from the point of view of discipline between the reform of godparenthood and the reform of marriage does not hold from the point of view of a project to reshape society. Although these topics require further thought and specific investigation, as far as the reform of godparenthood is concerned, we can rightly speak of a ‘blind project’. Perhaps on account of the Council’s inability to look ahead, the model of godparenthood proposed by the Church, even though imposed more efficiently than those devised in the past, was never really accepted by the people. As will be seen, the resistance that it encountered was sufficient to change it radically, in substance if not in form.
CHAPTER 5
The Application of the Decrees of the Council; Resistance and Compromise: Three Lines of Enquiry On the eve of the Council of Trent, many different models of godparenthood were widely practised in both Italy and Europe. By imposing rigid restrictions on the number of godfathers and godmothers allowed, the Council rendered most of these models illegal. As illustrated in the Chapter 1, there had already been similar attempts universally to regulate godparenthood. What was new was the ability of the post-Tridentine Church to impose its laws on populations who were stubbornly attached to their own customs and traditions. In the decades following the conclusion of the Council, at least in Italy (where the Tridentine decrees were immediately accepted by the civil authorities, who consented to their adoption in the areas under their jurisdiction), there was a movement ‘from many to one’ that went hand in hand with the almost total disappearance of local godparenthood practices, which were usually replaced by the couple model. It is obviously feasible that, while respecting the limits imposed by the laws, godparenthood practices maintained different characteristics according to the locality, just as it is possible that, alongside ‘official’ godparenthood, informal practices whose validity was not recognized by the Church were developed or reinforced. I will come back to this later. However, this generalized movement to standardize customs, and consequently to standardize society, is clearly perceptible. Quite apart from its goal, the movement itself is interesting, as the course it took locally and the procedures used to impose the Tridentine laws allow us both to evaluate the reaction of the population to enforced social change and to get a better understanding of the nature of pre-Tridentine godparenthood and the importance attributed to it. For this reason, I will analyse the overall movement and the course it took locally from three different points of view: the gradual ‘normalization’ of the practices which can be deduced from baptismal registers; the process by which the population was disciplined to respect the new laws of godparenthood, enforced by the Archbishop of Milan, Carlo Borromeo, whose achievements
Fathers and Godfathers
92
were an example and were imitated throughout Europe; the application of the Council’s reforms and the struggle of Bishops Ferdinando and Cesare Ferrero against pockets of resistance in the diocese of Ivrea, reconstructed on the basis of the records of their pastoral visitatios. From the parish registers of baptism, it is possible to follow step by step the application of the reform of godparenthood. Once appropriately recorded on a graph, the data pertaining to the number of godfathers and godmothers present at baptism allow us to highlight important aspects about the way the new laws were received. Was it immediate or gradual? And, if it was gradual, how long did it take and what kind of resistance did it encounter? First of all, it is necessary to respond to a possible objection. We could surmise that any gradual process in the application of the norms was only in terms of appearance and exclusively depended on the alternation of different priests in a given parish. They might have ensured that certain prescriptions neglected by their predecessors were respected, or they might have taken less trouble in registering baptisms, perhaps merely indicating the ‘main’ godparents. Wherever possible, I have taken note of the rotation of parish priests and have accurately identified the different compilers of the registrations. It can be clearly seen that the handing over by one priest to another does not account for the phenomenon that can be observed in the graphs, nor is it feasible to suppose that there was any systematic negligence in keeping the registers in a period when extremely frequent pastoral visits required that their existence and the way they were kept be scrutinized and careless
For example, take the case of the parish of S. Ulderico of Ivrea, and focus on the period around the two years 1563 and 1586, which, as can be seen from Figure 5.1, can be considered to be crucial insofar as they represent the extremes of the period of adjustment to the norm. From parish sources it appears that in 1563 the registers were entrusted to Antonio Robesto, who had been responsible for them since 1558, and they remained in his care until April 1586. In the almost 20 years between the two dates, the average number of godfathers dropped from 3.19 in 1558 to 1.37 in 1587 (the last year when keeping the registers was Robesto’s exclusive responsibility). It is obvious, then, that unless we assume that negligence in the keeping of the registers increased with time (which is highly unlikely), the decline in the number of godparents mirrored a real change in practices. As far as the next period is concerned, after a very short interval when the registrations were entrusted to Michele Cherico of Lugnacco, at the end of April 1586 the task passed into the hands of Cristoforo Clerici. Actually, it is possible that, at least at that moment, handing over the job did have some effect on the registrations. This, however, cannot be attributed to a different system used by Clerici to register the data in comparison with his predecessors, but it is the final phase in the contrast between population and clergy over the number of godparents admitted. The new incumbent, faced with what was by now feeble resistance (Figure 5.1 shows this clearly) and without hopes for the future, succeeds in asserting his authority and getting the Tridentine regulations fully respected.
THe Application of the Decrees
93
priests chided. The data recorded on the graphs are to be considered basically reliable. They show that some places adjusted to the Tridentine laws over a long period of time, others extremely rapidly. Where the godparent model in force was not too far from that of the couple model (for example, in Finale Ligure and Mirandola), the change must have seemed less abrupt and probably caused fewer protests. Where many godparents took part in baptisms, the data suggest that the situation was one of bewilderment, of hostility towards the reform and of continual negotiation in order to mitigate its effects. I will begin with the cases that indicate a more dramatic response by the population, analysing the series of the average number of godfathers and godmothers per year. Ivrea (Figure 5.1) is a very good example of how often the application of the new Tridentine laws was not immediate, but took place gradually and caused confusion among people who were stubbornly attached to social practices consolidated over centuries. Between 1563 and 1586 a progressive decline in the average number of godfathers and godmothers can be seen, which for the former tends to be close to one, in the case of the latter going on average to well below that figure; in that period no godmothers are recorded in the registration of numerous baptisms. The movement of the curves allows us to assume that in Ivrea the new regulations were imposed by a kind of continual ‘negotiation’ between the clergy and the people, who found it difficult to understand the reasons for the changes and failed to accept them. Each time, the parish priest would probably reach an agreement with the parents on a limit to the total number of godfathers and godmothers. If they renounced the right to a godmother, it meant they could have a second godfather. After 1586, the date from which it is possible to presume that the population was disciplined, it seems that there was a kind of ‘rediscovery’ of godmothers, whose role acquired new significance as there was no longer the possibility of choosing a large number of godfathers.
Among the reforms introduced at Trent, that of godparenthood was certainly not unique in taking time to be fully adopted and for a long time subject to compromise. See, for example, the case of the reform of marriage (Ferrante 1994). Everything leads us to suppose that, before the Tridentine reforms, godmotherhood was less important than godfatherhood, later gaining prestige when the number of godfathers was limited to one. I will come back to this question in Chapter 7.
Fathers and Godfathers
94
$YHUDJH1XPEHURI*RGIDWKHUV
Fig. 5.1
$YHUDJH1XPEHURI*RGPRWKHUV
Ivrea (parish of S. Ulderico)
Azeglio, located in the countryside around Ivrea, shows that it took roughly the same time to adapt to the Tridentine laws as Ivrea, which is why I am not including its graph. The progressive reduction in the number of godfathers and godmothers seems to have come to an end towards 1583, slightly earlier than in the city. Besides, no system of exchange between godfathers and godmothers is to be found. Something similar to what happened in Ivrea is to be found in Gambellara (Figure 5.2). After temporarily accepting the Tridentine rule, from August 1564 and continuing throughout 1566, the population worked out a strategy of resistance: the average number of godfathers went back to above one, while the number of godmothers went below this. The phenomenon lasted for eight years, from 1567 to 1574. If we examine what happened in detail, we find that the total number of godparents present at baptism was never more than two; what happened is that the godmother was replaced by an additional godfather (29 cases in the period indicated, i.e. 14.4 per cent of the total number of baptisms) or, much more rarely, the opposite occurred (six cases). It is clear that, in order to behave in this way, the population of Gambellara must have had at its disposal a compliant priest or it must have possessed a means of obliging him to reach a compromise. The exchange of ‘a godmother for an extra godfather’ is so obvious here that there is little doubt that some form of negotiation actually took place concerning the way the new norm was to be applied, above all if we remember that the reaction was not immediate but was delayed for a sufficient length of time to lead people to hope that things had calmed down and that it would be possible, if not to return to the previous situation, at least to mitigate the undesired effects of the reform of godparenthood.
THe Application of the Decrees
95
The abuse, once discovered, must have been stopped, as between 1575 and 1629 I have not found any case in which there was more than one godfather.
$YHUDJH1XPEHURI*RGIDWKHUV $YHUDJH1XPEHURI*RGPRWKHUV Fig. 5.2
Gambellara (parish of S. Pietro Apostolo)
In Turin (Figure 5.3) there was also a phase of adjustment; however, it took place quite rapidly, and by 1572 the disciplinary measures were already concluded. The drastic reduction in the number of godfathers became an opportunity to ‘discover’ godmothers, who previously had appeared only at one baptism in five, but now were a constant feature. At Voghera (Figure 5.4) the immediate restriction in the number of godfathers to one is extremely abrupt: the new standard was already in force in 1565. Godmothers were a different matter. Godmothers were practically unknown in Voghera before the Council, and, as in Turin, the new legislation provided them with a role: in 1565 they already appear in almost all the registrations of baptisms. It is, though, surprising that after a trial period of only three years, godmothers disappear once more, to reappear only in 1573, after which they habitually attend baptisms. With any similar phenomenon, the immediate assumption to deal with is that the registrations were not absolutely accurate. However, the high quality of the baptismal registers of Voghera, which for many years were actually kept in two copies, leads us to reject this assumption.
Fathers and Godfathers
96
$YHUDJH1XPEHURI*RGIDWKHUV $YHUDJH1XPEHURI*RGPRWKHUV Fig. 5.3
Turin (parish of S. Agostino)
It is possible to suggest an alternative explanation. In the period 1565– 1567, most of the godmothers are midwives: names like Isabeta or Richeta are very common, often appearing with the word ‘coma’, an abbreviation meaning comare or midwife. In those years we find ever more frequently baptisms with two godmothers. In these cases, one of the two was always a midwife, and the registration could be something like this: compater (name of godfather) (name of godmother) coma (name of midwife). The registrars distinguished, therefore, between godfather and godmother on the one hand, and comare or midwife on the other, as if they failed to understand not so much the role of the midwife but that of the godmother. When, in 1573, godmothers reappear after an absence of five years, if they are midwives they are indicated as ‘comare’. However, their position is now clearer: they were registered only if they were godmothers, otherwise they were not mentioned. In fact, the registrations are along these lines: ‘comadre comare Isabeta’ if she was a midwife, or ‘comadre Lucia’ if not. The attendance of midwives at baptisms is not as common as before, and their number tends to diminish further in the following years.
For example, on 28 July 1567 we read ‘cpr. (copater) d. Bernardo Miliarde da Vuleza e dn.a Catrina Cavagna coma. Isabeta’. When the midwife administered baptism in a hurry because there was reason to fear for the child’s life (baptismus in casu necessitatis), she became spiritual kin as she was the person who performed the rite. In the baptisms under discussion at Voghera, however, usually they were not urgent cases.
THe Application of the Decrees
97
The story of godmothers in Voghera is interesting: first, as an aid in understanding the role, always rather ambiguous, attributed to midwives at baptism; and second, because it is an indication of the state of confusion reigning in Voghera after the Council. The rapid reduction in the number of godfathers abruptly destroyed an important system of relationships, and attempts to remedy the situation with the ‘invention’ of the godmother seem uncertain and unconvincing – so much so that at a certain moment they are abandoned. The impression is one of a society in search of a new order, but one that does not yet know which direction to follow.
$YHUDJH1XPEHURI*RGIDWKHUV $YHUDJH1XPEHURI*RGPRWKHUV Fig. 5.4
Voghera (parish of S. Lorenzo)
At Bellano (Figure 5.5), where it was customary to give children numerous godfathers and godmothers, restrictions took place at the same time and at the same pace on both sides of spiritual kinship, and in 1565 the new legislation was fully implemented. Given the difference between the model of godparenthood in Bellano (type I, pure multi-godfathers) and the couple model, such a sudden change might cause surprise, as it was implemented before the end of July 1564. As will be seen, this chronology coincides with that of the promulgation and application of the new legislation within the diocese of Milan, of which Bellano is part. It is evident that the parish priest, Giulio Stoppa, was not only willing to apply the new rules, but effectively managed to impose innovation on his parishioners. On the For the role of godmothers, see Marland 1993 and Wiesner 1986. On the question of the confusion between godmother and midwife, see Palumbo 1991, pp. 173–181.
Fathers and Godfathers
98
other hand, in the next chapter I will show how also at Bellano changes were not achieved without causing social tension.
$YHUDJH1XPEHURI*RGIDWKHUV $YHUDJH1XPEHURI*RGPRWKHUV Fig. 5.5
Bellano (parish of SS. Giorgio, Nazaro and Celso)
In places such as Finale Ligure and Mirandola where, even prior to the Council, customs were practised which were not far from the couple model, the restriction in the number of godfathers and godmothers took place together and swiftly. At Finale the last cases of multi-godfathers go back to December 1564 and at Mirandola to May of the same year. Figure 5.6 shows Mirandola as an example. Study of the graphs shows that even before the seventeenth century, in most of northern Italy, if not everywhere, one model had been firmly imposed: type 5, the ‘pure single godfather’, which I have also called ‘the couple model’. It became the norm to have one godfather and one godmother for each child baptized. The expectations of the conciliar fathers, who intended to propose a sole godparent for baptism, were thus ignored. As we will see, the reform of godparenthood formulated at Trent also had other unexpected results, and in fact was a failure. The graphs enable us to discover a fundamental factor brought about by the transformations imposed by the Council: the state of bewilderment and confusion in which populations found themselves. They were used to relying on a network of privileged relationships, based on specific as well as well-tried strategies. It can clearly be seen at Ivrea and Gambellara, with
THe Application of the Decrees
99
godfathers being substituted for godmothers, and at Voghera, following the story of the discovery, rejection and rediscovery of godmothers. The graphs, however, are too arid to convey on their own the impression of the social shock experienced by many communities in Italy. It is necessary to investigate in more detail, making use of other information. This will help us to evaluate the way godparenthood linked individual members of the community prior to the Council, how the situation changed once the couple model was introduced and what strategies were used to remedy the situation. I will deal with all these issues in the next chapter.
$YHUDJH1XPEHURI*RGIDWKHUV
Fig. 5.6
$YHUDJH1XPEHURI*RGPRWKHUV
Mirandola (parish of S. Maria Maggiore)
It is useful, though, to make some preliminary comments. The ‘violence’ of the impact which resulted from the Tridentine legislation was not the same everywhere. Mirandola, where a model close to that of the couple model was in force, certainly found it easier to adapt than Ivrea, where the transition took 20 years of adjustments and probably of difficult compromises between the population and the local clergy. In the graphs we see evidence of a confused situation in those places where the old customs were furthest from the new ones. So, alongside the process of standardization of godparenthood practices there was, at least at that time, a process of differentiation between various localities from the point of view of the social turmoil and tensions caused by the reform. The graphs demonstrate that the rules of the Council were applied rapidly even though, sometimes, the process required a difficult period of adjustment, while in historiography it is commonly held that for a long time European populations maintained their own customs of godparenthood, despite the decisions taken at Trent.
100
Fathers and Godfathers
John Bossy, for example, claimed that ‘… godparenthood was so obviously a good thing that people felt confident in flouting, well into the seventeenth century, attempts to restrict or control it’ (Bossy 1985, p. 16). At least as far as the north of Italy was concerned, this conviction is clearly mistaken, considering that even the most obstinate localities surrendered before the 1580s. On the other hand, the rapidity of the application of the reform of godparenthood can be explained by the alacrity with which the Italian states adhered to the decisions of the Council of Trent. The application of the decisions was delayed in certain areas of Europe, such as France, due to an alliance between suspicious clergy and the local secular authorities, who had the power to prohibit the publication of the Tridentine decrees in their territory. The Council of Trent terminated on 4 December 1563. Papal approval of the decrees and conciliar canons was quick to arrive: the bull Benedictus Deus et Pater is dated 26 January 1564 and, even though it was not published until 30 May, the conciliar decrees had already been printed and distributed. On 11 March, Carlo Borromeo sent a copy to Milan, followed on 25 March by 22 copies destined first of all for the bishops of his ecclesiastical province (Rimoldi 1994, p. 64). Generally speaking, the adherence of the Italian states took place before the end of 1564, but the representatives sent to Trent by the duchies of Savoy and Tuscany and by the Republic of Venice had already consigned their allegiance, in writing, on 6 December 1563 (Michel 1932). The Italian bishops quickly convened provincial and diocesan synods to promote the application of the decisions of the Council in their own lands. In Italy, therefore, no obstacle hindered the adoption of the new norms, apart from individual communities’ unwillingness to give up their own customs. It is well known, however, that the Church itself had to make a great effort to provide itself with the necessary means of effectively imposing the application of the conciliar decrees. A key role was played by Archbishop Carlo Borromeo, who made the diocese of Milan both an area for testing the new laws and an example for other dioceses. If we follow his achievements through the 11 diocesan synods and the six provincial councils, all occasions for verifying the necessarily gradual implementation of the reform, we are able to observe
For the opposition of the Gallic Church to the conciliar decrees, which lasted until 1615, see Michel 1932, pp. 1492 ff.
THe Application of the Decrees
101
in a different light the events described in the previous pages of this chapter. At Trent it was established that every year bishops had to celebrate diocesan synods, renewing an obligation ratified by the Lateran Council of 1215. During the first synod to be celebrated after the Council, everyone would be required to accept publicly what had been established at Trent, promise and profess obedience to the Pope and condemn all heresies (Rimoldi 1994, pp. 66–67). Carlo Borromeo would have liked to dedicate himself at once to the preparation of the synod, but Pius IV refused to give him permission to leave Rome, where the archbishop was in his service as cardinal nepote (‘nephew cardinal’). The task of presiding over the synod had to be entrusted to others: as his vicar general Borromeo designated a priest from Verona, Nicolò Ormaneto, who fixed the opening for 6 August 1564. From the point of view of the rules governing baptism, the First Provincial Council is the moment when their application actually commenced. The Council opened on 15 October of the following year and was personally presided over by Borromeo: ‘The Constitutions and the Decrees of this Council which embrace all aspects of Church life were the necessary reference for synodal legislation in all the dioceses of the Lombardy province.’10 Furthermore, 6,000 copies of the statutes of the Council were distributed throughout Europe, which was one of the main factors that contributed to making Carlo Borromeo’s achievement an example to be followed.11 I will deal with synods and councils in chronological order, to highlight how synods were often an opportunity to elaborate directives that a later council proposed should be implemented over a larger area. For many years it had been customary for each new pope to call to Rome friends, and above all, relations, to whom important posts would be assigned. It was a way of securing the help of trusty collaborators, and of benefiting their own family members. The numerous nephews of popes who were created cardinals by their uncles is a typical example of this kind of behaviour, from which the term ‘nepotism’ is derived. Often the right-hand man of the Pope was a cardinal nepote. For the post of Carlo Borromeo as cardinal nepote and for the events of his ‘conversion’ and his decision to dedicate himself completely to pastoral activity, see Majo 1995, pp. 316 ff. 10 Rimoldi 1994, p. 70. Even though the council terminated on 3 November 1565, the Holy See’s approval of the Constitutions and Decrees was ready only on 6 June of the following year, on account of attempts to raise obstacles by various bodies, and especially by the Senate of Milan (in the meantime Pius IV, who died on 9 December 1565, was succeeded by Pius V, and Carlo Borromeo finally left Rome and took up residence in his diocese). See Cattaneo 1964. 11 ‘Iniziazione cristiana, in AA.VV., Dizionario della Chiesa Ambrosiana, vol. III, Milan, NED, 1989, pp. 1594–1599.
102
Fathers and Godfathers
The institution of the provincial council had ancient roots, but it was centuries since one had been celebrated in Milan. The objective of the Council of Trent was that the custom should be relaunched, with the recommendation that it should take place every three years. The provincial council was to be attended by all the bishops of the relevant ‘ecclesiastical province’, that is, the territory made up of the dioceses that referred to one particular metropolitan Church, in this case Milan.12 In the Constitutions of the First Provincial Council, the regulations concerning baptism are listed under the heading Quae pertinent ad baptismi administrationem.13 Some of the principal themes of the Tridentine debates on the reform of baptism were discussed again, among them the prohibition on baptizing at home (unless the child’s life was in danger), the care to be given to baptismal fonts and the obligation to keep baptismal registers. Delays to the ceremony were also forbidden, with the ruling that it should take place within eight days of birth. As far as godparents were concerned, no reference was made to their number. Attention was paid to the criteria to adopt when they were chosen: it was preferable to select those who were able to offer spiritual advice rather than those who could give material assistance, and the parish priests were urged to be on the alert so that suitable people were selected for their faith and behaviour.14 Priests would, moreover, have to prevent the choice falling on godparents who failed to go to confession15 or who had been excommunicated. Lastly, they had to warn godparents to behave correctly during the ceremony, and to be certain that they well understood the commitments they were undertaking. In fact, if the natural parents failed in their duty, they themselves had to bring up the godchild in the Catholic faith and instil honest behaviour.16 The Council also condemned a practice that has a certain ethnological interest, and which did not emerge in Trent, perhaps because it was a local custom: children were placed on the altar, from where they were ransomed with gifts offered by their godparents. The condemnation of this abuse 12
Borromeo kept closely to the dates established by the Tridentine Council for Provincial Councils (one every three years). The same cannot be said of his successors: after the six councils that he convened, it was only his cousin Federico who convened the seventh, while the eighth and ninth took place only in the twentieth century (Vigotti 1981). 13 Acta Ecclesiae Mediolanensis (AEM), edited by A. Ratti, Milan 1890–1892, vol. II, coll. 43–45. 14
AEM, vol. II, coll. 43. Since the Lateran Council of 1215, the Church had imposed the obligation of a yearly secret confession, which was a necessary condition for being able to participate in Easter communion. For further information on confession, the changes it underwent at the time of the Council of Trent and the role played by Carlo Borromeo, see Bossy 1998a, pp. 59–85. 16 AEM, vol. III, coll. 43–44. 15
THe Application of the Decrees
103
provided an opportunity to expressly forbid godfathers and godmothers from making any gift whatsoever to their godchildren or to the child’s parents at baptism. From the outset, then, energy was spent in an effort to moralize godparenthood, initiating a course of reform in several stages. On 3 July 1568 the Second Diocesan Synod was convened, celebrated from 4 to 6 August. Here two decrees, XVI and XVII,17 are of interest. The first dealt with godparents who knew nothing of the principles of faith, so it was difficult to see how they could have instructed their godchildren in matters that they themselves did not understand. The parish priests were urged to reject them; as the decree contained a list of the minimum knowledge required of the godparents,18 the priest could by means of a brief interrogation directly ascertain their lack of suitability for the role of godparent. In XVII, clerks in holy orders were forbidden to act as godfathers for baptism and confirmation. In April 1569, the Second Provincial Council was held. Decree X repeated decree XVI of the 1568 synod, forbidding godparenthood to those who knew nothing of the principles of faith.19 The Third Diocesan Synod, convened for 1571, had to be postponed until April of the following year (Rimoldi 1994, p. 75). Decrees XI and XII regulated particular cases; the main one concerned foundlings. There was a risk that the priest might mistakenly baptize a child who had already been baptized by others, something to be categorically avoided.20 The escamotage they proposed was the introduction into the ceremony of special formulas expressing doubt.21 These orders were discussed once more and additions were made at the Third Provincial Council, held in 1573, when a further step was taken in an effort to moralize the conduct of godfathers, asking them to lay down any arms they might be carrying (swords, daggers …) before the ceremony, as they should take part in the ceremony in a spirit of humility and piety.22
17
AEM, vol. II, coll. 819–820. ‘… fidei symbolum, orationem Dominicam, et salutationem Angelicam …’ (AEM, vol. II, coll. 819). 19 AEM, vol. II, coll. 172. 20 Baptism, as spiritual generation, is a sacrament that can be received only once in a lifetime. From the point of view of the Church, the respect due to the sacrament made it necessary to take every precaution to prevent it being incorrectly administered. 18
21 An example is ‘si tu es baptizatus, ego te iterum non baptizo, et si nondum es baptizatus, ego te baptizo’ (AEM, vol. II, coll. 850). 22 AEM, vol. II, coll. 242–244.
104
Fathers and Godfathers
The Fourth Diocesan Synod began on 16 September 1574.23 Decree VII returned to the problem of godparents with no knowledge of the principles of the faith, an abuse that was proving particularly difficult to eradicate, proof of how little it mattered to the population whether godfathers and godmothers were able to carry out the task that the Church assigned to them; obviously, other qualifications were preferred. On this occasion an explicit obligation was made for parish priests to question the candidate for godparenthood if they doubted the latter’s knowledge of the principles of the Christian faith. This synod was the last of those convened by Carlo Borromeo to implement reforms to godparenthood; however, the work continued in the provincial councils. The Fourth Provincial Council (1576) paid considerable attention to baptism, concentrating on some cases that here are only marginally significant: the requirements for baptismal fonts (described meticulously) and the principles to be followed in their correct upkeep. As for the godparents, the parish priests were invited to check their knowledge of the basic principles of religion, something already stipulated in the Fourth Diocesan Synod.24 The Fifth Provincial Council (1579) is more interesting, as fresh directives appear concerning the choice of godparents. Only people who are confirmed will be accepted (the parish priest should ascertain whether they are in possession of this qualification) and then only if they are over 14 years of age. Up to this time, the participation of extremely young godparents was not uncommon. Last, the priests were requested to make sure that godparents did not dress in a gaudy manner and refrained from using ornaments or other showy decoration, which would contrast with the purely spiritual nature of the ceremony.25 In May 1582, the Sixth Provincial Council was held, the last to be presided over by Carlo Borromeo.26 Here there was a request to parish priests to write the names of godfathers and godmothers in the baptismal registers so as to avoid cases of spiritual incest (a regulation already existing in the Tridentine canon that established baptismal registers; evidently irregularities in registration had been discovered). There was also a request to celebrate baptisms without pomp and to avoid parties and festivities after the ceremony.27 23
AEM, vol. II, coll. 876. AEM, vol. II, coll. 344–348. 25 AEM, vol. II, coll. 543–545. 26 His death, on 3 November 1584, prevented him from celebrating the Seventh Council, which he had already convened for April of the following year. This council never took place, because the new Archbishop of Milan, Gasparre Visconti, had to face the unanimous opposition of all his suffragan bishops (Rimoldi 1994, p. 80). 27 AEM, vol. II, coll. 739–740. 24
THe Application of the Decrees
105
There are two other particularly relevant aspects in Carlo Borromeo’s measures to impose and adapt Tridentine legislation, or rather the spirit of the legislation, even going beyond the letter of the canons. In the first place, there is no mention of the number of godparents. This might seem a sign of a lack of interest in the issue; but were this so, it would be difficult to comprehend the reasons for such meticulous prescriptions on the quality of godfathers if there was a willingness to tolerate flagrant violations of provisions concerning quantity. The baptismal registers of Bellano, in the diocese of Milan, indicate that the prescriptions of the Council on the number of godfathers were never taken lightly, and the reduction in the number of godparents requested is sudden. It is the parish priest of Bellano who supplies evidence that settles the matter, noting in the register of baptisms: ‘Note that in the year 1564 on 29 July the Right Reverend Monsignor Nicolò Ormaneto, Vicar of Milan, ordered that from now onwards there is to be only one compare and one comare and thus I have commenced here below from 15 September 1564.’28 After the annotation, and thus from September 1564, he ensured that the restrictions to the number of godfathers and godmothers were respected. We discover then that Nicolò Ormaneto, Vicar of Carlo Borromeo until his return from Rome, had ordered on 29 July that at the most one godfather and one godmother should be allowed, and this was before the First Provincial Council (commenced on 6 August), over which he presided. Registers of other parishes in the diocese of Milan contain even earlier annotations, going back at least to the month of May. For example, in the register of the parish of Santa Grata of Borgo Canale in Bergamo dated 1 May is annotated: ‘Here baptism is now celebrated according to the order of the holy Tridentine Council.’29 A similar annotation is to be found in the register of S. Giacomo Maggiore of Baresi, and is certainly prior to 21 May.30 The diligence of Nicolò Ormaneto in applying the reform of godparenthood on the one hand confirms the importance attributed to the innovation, and on the other proves that the prescription of the 28
‘Nota che l’anno 1564 adi 29 luio el r.mo mons. [reverendissimo monsignor] Nicolò Ormaneto vic.o [vicario] de mi.lo [Milano] fece ordine che per inanzi non si possi eser al battesimo si non un solo co.pe [compare] et una sola comare et cosi ho comenzato qua sotto adi 15 7.re [settembre] 1564’ (parish archive of Bellano, register of baptism of the parish of SS. Giorgio, Nazaro and Celso, 1533–1639). 29 Parish archive of S. Grata di Borgo Canale in Bergamo, register of baptisms. 30 Unfortunately there is no exact date. According to the notes of the parish priest, 21 May is the date of the first registration of a baptism, while the previous registration is 6 February. The notes reproduce almost in full the conciliar decree, underlining, however, that the reduction of godparents is motivated by the aim to solve the ‘incommodus’ caused by spiritual kinship (parish archive of Baresi, register of baptisms).
106
Fathers and Godfathers
Council of Trent on the number of godparents was sufficiently clear as not to require further ‘interpretations’, nor any particular preparation of the clergy. This does not mean that a progressive adjustment to the rule was not necessary (it is enough to recall the case of Ivrea), but it was, in fact, an adjustment to the rule, and not of the rule. The most suitable place to verify its application was not the synod, but the pastoral visits, and it is well known just how important and, once more, how exemplary were Carlo Borromeo’s achievements in this field.31 I have looked for traces of any resistance on the part of the population of Bellano both in the baptismal registers and in the pastoral visits of 1573, 1579 and 1596.32 It would seem that the parish priest, Giulio Stoppa, with very rare exceptions,33 was quite capable of summarily imposing restrictions on the number of godparents. His actions could be indirectly monitored34 by inspecting baptismal registers, which in 1579 were still inspected by the delegated visitor, Luigi Sampietro, and found not to be perfectly ‘ad formam’. As already explained, the Council considered the registers a fundamental means of putting the reform of baptism into practice. Neither the registers of Baresi nor those of Borgo Canale contain appreciable signs of rebellion. The second aspect to be underlined is the gradual transposition of the ‘spirit’ of the Council’s rulings on the choice of suitable godparents into norms that could actually be applied. The gradual nature of the process is in itself a first significant feature: from a plea to prefer people who could supervise the Christian education of the child over those who could, instead, provide only material advantages, there is a move towards the need to verify their preparation in the subjects in which they should instruct their godchildren, concluding with rules on the age, and even on the dress for the ceremony (no jewellery, and absolutely no arms). I think it is possible to interpret this increasing development (the provisions of previous synods and councils remained in force, unless altered by subsequent ones) as a consequence of a difficult process of ‘training’ of stubborn populations, who for centuries had been used to following a logic in the selection of godparents which was completely different from that which the council had wished to impose on them. As will be seen, it is extremely doubtful that from the point of view of the ‘quality’ of the godparents the anticipated 31
See Turchini 1996. AEM, vol. III, Visitationes, coll. 1–16. 33 Between 1565 and 1600 at Bellano the conciliar rules on the number of godparents are infringed only in two cases, for which it is possible that a regular dispensation was asked (in both cases the admission of an additional godparent,, a godfather and godmother respectively). 34 In the sense that no explicit questions were put to him on the subject. 32
THe Application of the Decrees
107
results were achieved; perhaps the very persistence in the attempts at regulation was due to the growing awareness of failure. Even more interesting is the fact that an effort was made to realize fully a project of reform of godparenthood which corresponded not so much to what had been decreed by the Council of Trent, but to what I have defined as the ‘spirit’ of the reform of the sacrament, as emerges from the Council’s discussions. As will be remembered, this project has three main points: there must be one godparent; he must be worthy; he must fulfil his duty as tutor. It is only the first of these points that clearly emerges from the Tridentine decrees. Significantly, the diocesan synods and the provincial councils presided over by Carlo Borromeo concentrated on the second and the third. The Archbishop of Milan tried resolutely to persuade the population in his care to choose godparents who were capable of fulfilling their task, and in the same way he tried to persuade godparents to take an interest in the Christian education of their godchildren. On this question, however, an obstacle was soon to appear: godparents were often so ignorant of the principles of religion that it was highly unlikely that they could teach them to others. These problems repeatedly emerged in the synods and councils held between 1568 and 1576, and it is extremely improbable that, even after that date, they were solved. It must have been equally difficult to persuade godparents who had the necessary qualifications to take seriously the responsibilities they had undertaken at baptism. It is interesting to examine, with regard to this question, one of the texts prepared by Borromeo’s curia, which was widely distributed in Italy and abroad: Instructions to Confessors,35 published in 1574. These have been judged to be the fundamental part of a project aimed at ‘conquering souls’, reforming public conduct and, ultimately, transforming the whole social order (De Boer 2001). The role of the confessor is portrayed as that of a ‘spiritual father’; one could expect, therefore, that he be asked to supervise the activity of other ‘spiritual kin’ (the godfathers and godmothers of baptism) in the sense that from their confessions might emerge any shortcomings in the fulfilment of their duties. Alternatively, we could expect the question of the ‘spiritual tutorship’ of children not to be touched on at all. Neither hypothesis proves to be correct: instead, in the text the confessors are asked to counsel the children’s natural parents to supervise their correct Christian education, but no reference is made to the godparents, who were in principle the guarantors of this education. It seems to me that in this approach we can see the first signs of disillusionment with the prospect of putting a substantial reform of godparenthood into practice. As will be seen, at the time when the 35 Avvertenze di monsignore illuss. cardinale Borromeo, arcivescovo di Milano, ai confessori della città et diocese sua (AEM, vol. II, coll. 1870–1893).
108
Fathers and Godfathers
‘Instructions’ were published, the difficulty of imposing ‘good’ criteria in the selection of godparents was ever more evident. The reduction in the number of godparents had proved, if not easy, at least achievable. Parents could not hide the presence of extra godparents, and the obligation for priests to keep baptismal registers made it very risky for them to connive with stubborn communities.36 The next step, on the other hand, from control over how many were chosen to who was chosen required a much greater effort. Among other things, this fell completely to the parish priests, and it is well known that, after the Council, one of the most serious problems that the Church had to tackle was the inadequate training of priests. The foundation of diocesan seminaries was an attempt to provide this. In the post-Tridentine situation, the impossibility of being able to rely on godparents to ensure that the new generations were correctly instructed was a considerable setback in the project of reform and, above all, in the response the Church wanted to give to Protestants. It was necessary, therefore, to find a remedy; later on I will put forward some hypotheses on the kind of solution adopted.37 In the diocese of Milan, scene of the first and most resolute campaign to impose the conciliar decrees, pastoral visits witness with their silence only the immediate acknowledgement of the prescriptions concerning the number of godfathers and godmothers, confirmed by the annotations to be found in baptismal registers. The case was very different in other parts of Italy where, despite the reasonably timely intervention of bishops, parish registers as well as pastoral visits show signs of a struggle that lasted for decades. The role of the Council of Trent is well known in relaunching the custom of pastoral visits (a means adopted by the Church since the sixth century), underlining the obligation for bishops to carry them out regularly. Besides, right from the earliest years following the Council, the visits, 36 Actually, priests found themselves in a very difficult situation: they probably had to mediate between different concepts of the significance of the baptismal ceremony. On the one hand, there was the significance of the liturgy that envisaged that the ceremony in Latin (an unknown language to most of the faithful) was celebrated respecting certain rules and concluded with an official registration by the priest in the liber baptizatorum. On the other, it had a ‘popular’ significance that made the ceremony a crowded and animated socialcultural event in which all the relations, neighbours, patrons, clients etc. of the family of the infant took part. The reform of godparenthood and more generally of baptism produced a clear split between what was ‘actual’ and what was ‘legal’ (it was necessary to respect the prescriptions of canon law). This split was probably experienced by the population, unable to understand the motivation of the reform, as an imposition by the ecclesiastical powers and nothing more. 37 See Chapter 10.
THe Application of the Decrees
109
which up to then had been concerned mostly with the state of Church property and only superficially with the devotion of the people, showed a growing interest in the conduct of the laity: an unequivocal sign is the amount of space dedicated to this matter in the questionnaires (Burke 1979). This was due, on the one hand, to the need to verify empirically that the reforms introduced by the Council were really being put into practice on the ground, and on the other, to the desire to inculcate in the population morally acceptable behaviour, and to identify as soon as they arose possible breeding grounds of heresy. Pastoral visits, then, are the source par excellence with which to study the phases of the application of the new rules governing godparenthood. I will concentrate on the diocese of Ivrea, once again re-examining the case but from a fresh viewpoint. At the time, the diocese was governed by a real dynasty of bishops, the Ferreros. Various members of the family, which came from Biella, occupied the bishopric of Ivrea uninterruptedly from the year 1500 to 1610 (Benedetto 1942). Up to 1515, the diocese was suffragan to Milan, but in that year it became part of the recently constituted metropolitan of Turin.38 We can take it for granted that the bishops of Ivrea were well informed about Borromeo’s activities, which had reverberated throughout the whole of Catholic Europe. The climate in which they began to carry out the Council’s recommendations was similar to the one that emerges from the councils and synods of Borromeo. The bishop, Ferdinando Ferrero, visited various parts of the diocese of Ivrea in 1566 and in 1571–1572.39 His successor, Cesare Camillo Ferrero, continued the visits in 1581–1582, 1584, 1589, 1592–1595, 1598 and 1601.40 In his visit of 1566, Ferdinando Ferrero wanted, above all, to know if the parish priests had taken steps to inform their flock of the decrees of the Council of Trent, which had been published at Ivrea and of which they had been sent a copy. He also wanted to know if the registers of baptisms (from which the failure to respect the recently introduced restrictions on the number of godparents could evidently be assessed) were being kept properly; very often he asked if in administering the sacraments of baptism 38 Among the obligations of the suffragan bishop towards the metropolitan was (and still is) the participation in provincial councils.: For this reason it is important to clarify the position of Ivrea with regard to Milan, where often errors are to be found; it seems that following the Council of Trent, it was not clear even to Carlo Borromeo. The Bishop of Ivrea, Ferdinando Ferrero, was invited to attend the First Provincial Council of Milan to take place after Trent, but replied saying he was dependant on Turin, although he was willing to yield to more convincing reasons, if Borromeo were to suggest them. Nothing further happened and Ferrero did not attend the Council (Vigotti 1981). 39 Diocesan archive of Ivrea 1–2, G M 566/571/1. 40 Diocesan archive of Ivrea, 1–2, G M 581/1–2 and 1–2, G M 584/601/1.
110
Fathers and Godfathers
the decisions of the Council were being observed. There were no explicit questions on the number of godparents and, for the time being, he limited himself to verifying whether the Tridentine provisions were known, and asked for confirmation of their application ‘in general’ without going into detail. On the other hand, studying the registers of the baptisms of Ivrea and Azeglio, it is clear that the new rules were far from being applied literally, something the bishop was certainly aware of. As is clear from an appraisal of later visits, in imposing change a gradual approach was adopted, similar to what has been observed in the evolution of the synods and provincial councils in Milan. In the visit of 1571–1572, only in two parishes (Barbania and Mercenasco) did he concern himself with enquiring whether the books of baptism were kept properly. Actually, the visit of 1566 had already shown that they had usually been in existence since before the Council made them compulsory. At Barbania, in particular, the parish priest was questioned, ‘ … an teneat librum baptisatorum et an baptizet in tempore et quot compatres admittat’.41 So for the first time an explicit question on the number of godparents was being posed. The parish priest limited himself to replying that he observed the form established by the Tridentine reform, or at least this is what emerges from the record of the pastoral visit. As we saw in the graph of the average number of godfathers and godmothers in Ivrea (Figure 5.1), in 1571 the process of reduction in the number of godparents had already begun, but it was still far from being completed. Ferdinando Ferrero’s successor, Cesare, began his visits in 1581, venturing into some of the most remote and inaccessible areas of his diocese: the alpine valleys of Soana, Locana and Chiusella. As is natural to expect, in these areas he often came across some failings in the conduct of the parish priests. For example, the priest of Ceresole was admonished to be more diligent in the administration of the sacraments, and to keep books of baptisms and marriages, which were still missing. The priest of Locana anticipated the criticisms of the bishop, declaring that in administering baptisms he observed the form established by the Council, except when the harsh alpine climate made it dangerous to cover the distance that separated the church from habitations often placed miles away. At Sparone, Ribordone and Ronco, the bishop expressly asked how many godparents were allowed at baptism. If the parish priest of Sparone virtuously could declare that ‘… observat formam sacri tridentini concili’, the priest of Ribordone confessed that ‘admittit unum compatrem et aliquando unum secundum at plus …’42 and the priest of Ronco ‘observat formam sacri 41 ‘... if the book of baptism is kept and if the baptism is held within the (established) time and how many godparents are admitted’. 42 ‘… a sole godfather is allowed and sometimes at the most a second’.
THe Application of the Decrees
111
tridentini concili, et salvo q. aliquando et raro admittit compatrem et comatrem non solus’.43 In the other alpine parishes visited, either questions were not asked about the celebration of baptism (at Campiglia, Fondo, Pont, Salto) or the parish priest declared generically that he observed the form of the Council (at Vico and at Brosso). In any case, no more questions appeared that directly concerned the number of godparents. The gravity of these cases of ‘resistance’ by alpine communities should not be exaggerated. In those same years, even in the Bishop’s see (Ivrea) cases of multiple godparents were not infrequent, even though the custom was inexorably destined to disappear. However, it is significant that in various cases Ferrero specifically asked to be informed about the number of godparents allowed at baptism, which is further proof of the fact that the reduction in godparents was achieved only by the direct intervention of the episcopal authority, which was pressing and protracted. Between 1581 and 1582, Ferrero also visited 19 localities on the plain. In 16 cases the bishop asked if the form envisaged at Trent for the sacrament of baptism was respected or not, receiving 15 affirmative replies. Only the parish priest of Casalborgone admitted that sometimes he allowed two godfathers or two godmothers, promising that he would not do it any more. The case is interesting because the priest leads us to believe that it was the insistence on the part of the parents of the child that led him to infringe the rule: the population, then, tried to oppose a rule which was unpopular and incomprehensible.44 In the brief visits of 1584 and 1589, there are no questions whatsoever on the conduct of the laity. In 1592–1595, a period in which 33 parishes altogether were inspected. In 19 cases no question was put about the administration of baptism. In 10 cases the parish priest was merely asked generically whether the form established by the Tridentine reforms was observed and an affirmative reply was given. In two cases there were irregularities in the way registers of baptisms and marriage were kept; at Rueglio they were missing entirely. Finally, in two cases, Castellamonte and Quagliuzzo, from the reply given by the parish priest it is possible to deduce that a precise question had been put on the number of godparents allowed at baptism,45 even though the rather concise style in which the records of visits were compiled leaves no direct trace of such question. 43
‘… observes the form established by the holy Tridentine Council, except for occasionally allowing more than one godfather, and one godmother’. 44 Unfortunately I have not found any evidence of the way in which the reduction in the number of godparents was explained to the population. 45 For Castellamonte we read: ‘Interrogatus respondit … non admittit vel unum compatrem et ad sumum unam comatrem ex forma concili tridentini in baptizandis pueris.’ The formula used for Quagliuzzo is practically identical.
112
Fathers and Godfathers
No irregularities were mentioned, so it is not possible to know whether the bishop investigated there and not elsewhere, because he had reason to doubt the conduct of the resident parish priests or because he wanted to carry out a verification or he simply investigated in all the parishes; but his clerk did not find it appropriate always to make a note of it in the record of the visit, contenting himself, for example, with noting that the priest observat formam. If, on the other hand, at Castellamonte and at Quagliuzzo irregularities had been found, it would have been serious; the two localities were visited in 1595, when in Ivrea the custom of numerous godparents had been eliminated for good. In the visit of 1598, which was made only to Borgofranco, and during that of 1601, the last made by Cesare Ferrero, no irregularities were mentioned. Altogether, the pastoral visits of the diocese of Ivrea specifically indicate the way the new rules regarding godparents were applied. Initially, in the visits of 1566 and 1571, the issue is not tackled directly. These early visits were concerned with verifying that the priest was aware of the new rules and that he had informed his parishioners about them, that registers of baptisms were kept, and that ‘in general’ the form prescribed by the Council was observed. The bishop’s effort to control and to correct becomes more thorough and pressing in the visits of 1581–1582; in almost all the parishes visited (23 out of 28) precise information is demanded about the way the sacrament of baptism was administered and a specific question is often put on the number of godparents allowed. In these years a climax is reached, even though the full application of the rules cannot be said to be concluded. In 1595 there were still priests who were questioned on the number of godparents and godmothers admitted. If we compare the visits of 1592–1595 with those of 1581–1582, however, it is clear that the correct administration of baptism was no longer a central concern: the percentage of cases in which there was no question whatsoever on the matter is 58 per cent and 18 per cent respectively. It is not an indication of a decrease in interest in the question as much as of the fact that by now the population had been ‘trained’, at least as far as the number of godparents was concerned, something that could easily be checked by the bishop. On the other hand, the process that emerges from the pastoral visits exactly corresponds to the one that can be deduced from the baptismal registers. Both are of a gradual nature, which seems to have been a constant feature of the activity of the two Ferrero bishops. I have already noted that success in the reduction in the number of godfathers and godmothers does not necessarily correspond to the success of the reform of godparenthood. Decades of endeavours, synods and councils, pastoral visits, acts of persuasion and threats of tough measures only achieved that godparenthood assumed a ‘form’ considered
THe Application of the Decrees
113
acceptable. The ‘essence’ of the social institution, that is, the relationship between the parties (compari and comari, godparents and godchildren) proved to be impossible to regulate or control. This does not mean that the Council and the post-Tridentine Church did not influence the relationship of godparenthood and comparatico; on the contrary, the application of the conciliar decrees had evident social consequences. These were not, however, the results desired by the Church, but others that went in a completely opposite direction. This is the subject of the next chapter.
This page has been left blank intentionally
CHAPTER 6
The Social Impact of the Reform The attempts to put up a resistance to the reform, which can be deduced from baptismal registers and from pastoral visits, are proof of the fact that European populations were much attached to their own customs of godparenthood. Part of the clergy must have indicated that they too were perplexed by the idea of abandoning those customs, if the sizeable number of participants to the Council of Trent who tried to oppose the reduction in the number of godparents can be considered a symptom of a feeling that was common in the whole of the Catholic Church. In those same years Protestant reformers also had to take into consideration a population that wanted to keep their tradition and maintain godparents and compari. The Catholic Church, however, succeeded in making sure that the limits established for the number of godfathers and godmothers were not exceeded. The project of reform proposed at Trent and reaffirmed when the Council’s deliberations were applied, by Carlo Borromeo for instance, required that for the reform to be completed other aspects of the customs currently in use had to be modified. The faithful had to be dissuaded from choosing godparents on the basis of benefits that could accrue (protection, rich gifts at baptism, useful friendships). It was necessary to choose people who were not only capable of acting as tutors of their godchildren’s Christian education, but were also willing to do so. The interests of the parents were not to play any part in the choice of spiritual kin: what was paramount was the spiritual well-being of the baptized. It was obviously a question of imposing a transformation that was profoundly to modify forms of sociability, as spiritual kinship made for a considerable variety of behaviours and customs that changed from place to place and from case to case, and whose implications we are only now beginning to realize. When parents came to choose godfathers and godmothers for their children, they were also, and probably above all, motivated by their own interests and objectives. The Church managed to modify the social role of spiritual kinship, but the results were very different from those intended. Before analysing the developments that took place between the end of the sixteenth and the beginning of the seventeenth centuries, it is necessary to clarify the
For example, Calvin agreed to keep godparents only because of the resolute opposition of the inhabitants of Geneva to his proposal to do away with them (Spierling 2005). For further examples see Chapter 4.
116
Fathers and Godfathers
importance of the transformation brought about by the reduction in the number of godparents. In the light of what was said in the previous chapter, we can ascertain that as soon as the new Tridentine norms were enforced, many communities were greatly perturbed. Why? What disappeared with these reforms, and what did the communities feel deprived of? What difference did the number of godparents make? To understand the nature of the social change imposed by the conciliar fathers with the reform of godparenthood, it is useful to shift our attention from single individuals to the whole, or rather to the network that connected individuals one to another by way of spiritual kinship. This is not the place to examine in depth the theoretical premises of network analysis, especially as I will make only limited use of it. I will merely recall the well-known distinction proposed by Mark Granovetter between ‘strong’ and ‘weak’ social ties; in some situations weak ties are more effective in achieving desired objectives than strong ones (Granovetter 1973, 1974, 1983). It seems useful to me to interpret spiritual kinship as a weak tie, at least if compared with close natural kinship or affinity. The strength of weak ties lies not only in the ‘weakness’ meant as a limited reciprocal bond (for example, in comparison with marriage), one which leaves more freedom of action, but also in the abundance of these ties: in other words, in the density of the network that they are creating, in the superabundance of the ties between the various members and, as we will see shortly, between the various social ranks of the community. Useful references are to be found in the monograph number of the Rassegna italiana di sociologia dedicated to network analysis (no. 1, Jan–March 1996), supplemented a little later by the contribution of Michael Eve (1996), as well as by Gribaudi (1998) and Piselli (1995). For examples of its application in history, see no. 1/2005 of the Annales de Démographie Historique. For most of the period under consideration the paucity of important sources, for example those which could allow us to reconstruct kinship relationships between all the members of a particular community, would render it extremely difficult to resort to network analysis; such a partial view would cast doubt on the reliability of the results. Recently an attempt to apply mathematical statistical methods of network analysis to the study of godparenthood has been undertaken by Cristina Munno for the Venetian community of Follina; some of her early results are discussed in Munno 2005. Actually, Granovetter includes among the ‘strong’ ties both kinship and friendship, so if we wished to accept rigidly his distinction, spiritual kinship should be considered a strong tie. On the other hand, it is difficult to establish an exact hierarchy of the ‘strength’ of various types of ties, which can change in time on account of social change (Granovetter, in particular, refers to contemporary society), and really it is doubtful whether it is useful. What is important for me is to distinguish clearly between very strong relationships such as close natural kinship and affinity, and ties that in comparison with them are ‘weak’, such as friendship or spiritual kinship.
The SOcial Impact of the Reform
117
Prior to the Council of Trent, baptism was the occasion when a large number of relationships of spiritual kinship were created, not only on account of the frequent presence of multiple godparents, but also because canon law established a series of further ties. The child also became spiritual son of the godparents’ relations as well as spiritual brother to their offspring. It is reasonably certain that the ties that were most deeply felt were the ‘direct’ ones, i.e. between godfathers/godmothers and godchild and, above all, between compari. On the other hand, it cannot be said that other relationships were ignored, if for no reason other than the existence of precise matrimonial bans that had to be respected. If from a reproductive point of view incest created a barrier (godchild and spiritual siblings could easily belong to the same generation), from a social point of view it united. So ‘indirect’ relationships are rightly to be considered constitutive factors in the spiritual kinship networks. It is not difficult to appreciate that pre-Tridentine baptism created a decidedly larger number of spiritual kinship relationships than postCouncil baptism. Take as a hypothetical example a case of model 1 (pure multi-godfather), which envisaged the presence of three godfathers and two godmothers. If all the godfathers and godmothers were married and each of them had three living children on the day the baptism was celebrated, in one act the ceremony would establish 46 new spiritual kinship relations. After the Council, models of this kind would be transformed into the model of the couple (type 5), which featured one godfather and one godmother. Bearing in mind that spiritual brotherhood and indirect compaternitas would disappear simultaneously and bearing in mind the previous assumptions involving the godparents’ marital status along with the number of their children, it would follow that a baptism following this model would create just seven new spiritual kinship relations. The differences between the two examples are even clearer if we consider an extreme case of a multi-godfather model, with scores of godfathers and godmothers. It might be objected that perceptions do not neatly change to fall in line with changes in positive norms, and that the
Compaternitas indirecta and fraternitas spiritualis. See Chapter 1. Six of whom were paternitas spiritualis between godfathers/godmothers and the minister of baptism on the one hand and the baptized on the other, five paternitas spiritualis indirecta between the wives and husbands of the godfathers and godmothers and the baptized, 10 of compaternitas between godfathers/godmothers and the parents of the baptized, 10 of compaternitas indirecta between the wives and husbands of the godfathers/godmothers and the parents of the baptized, 15 of fraternitas spiritualis between the children of godfathers and godmothers and the baptized.
Three of paternitas spiritualis between godfather, godmother and minister of baptism on the one hand and the baptized on the other and four of compaternitas between godfather, godmother and parents of the baptized.
118
Fathers and Godfathers
abolition of spiritual brotherhood and indirect compaternitas might have involved only a ban on marriage, not the practices themselves. In fact, on the one hand, marriage impediments could still be kept, as no one was forced to enter a union held to be unseemly; on the other, a special tie might be recognized even in the absence of a matrimonial taboo. It is likely, though, that despite the fact that pockets of resistance remained, in most of Catholic Europe matrimonial customs gradually moved closer to the new norms, if for no other reason than because the extensive impediments typical of the centuries prior to the Council were frequently infringed even before they were abolished. Besides, the limitation on spiritual kinship played only a small part in the reduction in the number of ties; where the multi-godfather models were in use, the part played by the limitation in the number of godparents was considerably more significant. The calculation of the number of ties of spiritual kinship makes it possible to underline a factor that is not only of quantitative importance but indicates a qualitative difference between very diverse situations. Following the reform of godparenthood, an extremely dense network of relations was forced to reorganize and ‘collapse’ within the much narrower limits established by the new regulations. The passage from one network to another is of such importance that their morphology turns out to be practically incommensurable. The change is even more striking if the nature of the relations is considered. Take for example the complete disappearance of an instrument such as spiritual brotherhood, able to generate intragenerational solidarity. Anthropological investigation of compadrazgo has often highlighted the importance of godparenthood as a factor of social cohesion. It certainly carried out this function in the Early Modern Age. Probably the expected thinning of the network of spiritual kinship relationships compromised, at least for a time, the capacity of godparenthood to fulfil this role; at any rate the change must have been recognized in this way by populations accustomed to being able to count on numerous spiritual kin who saw an important aspect of their sociability unexpectedly mutilated. It is understandable, therefore, why these populations often tried to put up resistance, and baptismal registers preserve signs of what seems to be a reaction caused, if not by panic, then by a state of profound dismay. For example, in the Spanish Sierra the ban on marriage between compari was still operative, if not ‘officially’, at least until the 1950s, despite the fact that it had been abolished by the 1917 Code of Canon Law (Pitt-Rivers 1976a). If we assume that the relationship of compaternitas indirecta and fraternitas spiritualis was not eliminated, a type 5 model (a couple model) would include, keeping to the usual premises, 19 spiritual kinship relations against the 46 of a type 1 model with three godfathers and two godmothers.
The SOcial Impact of the Reform
119
This process can be introduced into a wider context. John Bossy, the historian most involved in the ‘social history of sacraments’, has interpreted pre-Tridentine godparenthood as a factor of social integration (in accordance with anthropological tradition) insofar as it is a key factor in the ‘social miracle’ of universal love. Universal love and Christian charity, the most perfect manifestation of which were the confraternities, were considered absolutely necessary to guarantee the survival of the community, as they alone made it possible to combat the state of continual feuding and to restore peace. Godparenthood, as generator of social relationships that brought with them the duty of reciprocal respect and friendship, was an important means of ‘pacification’. Anthropologists have supplied numerous examples where it was used to settle ongoing feuds (Hammel 1968). From this point of view, a multiplication in the number of godparents offered an opportunity to multiply relationships of friendship ritually guaranteed by the sacredness of baptism. According to Bossy, the forces of social change with their roots in the Council of Trent pointed in a specific direction, that is, ‘from the community to the individual’, discouraging collective rites or, at least, some of the forms of collective participation in rites, and promoting a more individual kind of devotion, unhampered by kindred (Bossy 1998a). The reduction in the number of spiritual kin can also be included among the forces of social change, both because it was part of the struggle against the great reunions of family and friends on occasions of baptism,10 and because it drastically reduced the dimension of the network of comparatico ties and thus tended to limit religious relationships in the broad sense of the term between members of the community;11 predictably, the post-Tridentine Church was also hostile towards confraternities. Furthermore, in the uncertain decades when the Reformation was taking hold, the Church seems to have developed a tendency to distance itself from the ‘moral tradition’ aimed at keeping the peace, re-established from time to time with specific juridical-ritual procedures (for example, the public exchange of a kiss of peace in front of certain altars, the stipulation of a contract of peace in the presence of a notary). The characteristic of these procedures was to follow the slow rhythms of reconciliation, something rejected by those who were the voice of a more intransigent and ‘authoritarian’ approach, which demanded immediate, or almost immediate, obedience; in this sense Carlo
10 On this score, the crucial contribution was the demand that baptism should take place very shortly after birth. Recall what was mentioned in Chapter 4 about the Council of Trent’s proposals to moderate, if not forbid, baptismal festivities. 11 According to Bossy, one of the priorities of the Counter-Reformation was to found the Church on the parish, to the detriment of alternative forms of religious participation.
120
Fathers and Godfathers
Borromeo had a forerunner in the Bishop of Verona, Gianmatteo Giberti.12 Godparenthood was not directly part of the peace mechanism, but served to sanction, as an alternative to marriage, a re-found stability. It is clear, however, that the period when spiritual kin were curtailed coincided with a reaction to the moral tradition. This cannot have been by chance. As well as a reaction to the dismantling of a network of social cohesion, the reaction of the populations of northern Italy to the reform of godparenthood can be explained by taking into account the effects of the weakening of an instrument used to develop a strategy of social relationships. Here it is necessary to pose an important question: how did spiritual kinship put the various strata of society into contact with each other? Was it a relationship between equals or between people at very different levels of the social hierarchy? In other words, using the language common to anthropological studies of compadrazgo, was it a horizontal or a vertical relationship? Lastly, what were the consequences, if any, of the collapse of the network of relations, just mentioned, on the choice of compari? In order to provide an answer to these questions it is necessary to evaluate the social level of the parents and godparents. As I do not have at my disposal other sources that enable me easily to establish the level in all the localities examined, I will make use of the only indicator present in the baptismal registers: the distinctive title of rank, for example, ‘messere’, ‘nobile’, ‘eccellente’, ‘reverendo’, ‘maestro’ (mister, nobleman, excellency, reverend, master).13 In the communities of the ancien régime, at least in the smaller ones, everyone had a clear idea of each inhabitant’s position in terms of superiority, equality or inferiority, in relation to others. Social hierarchy was something well defined, and above all ‘public’, insofar as an immaterial resource like honour, even though it could be measured ‘objectively’, exists only where it is reciprocally acknowledged by the recognition at each contact between different individuals of their respective positions. The distinctive title of rank somehow mirrors, albeit imperfectly, this living and changeable structure of relationships. The difficulty in defining a person’s place within the social hierarchy arises from the deficiencies in the means used to conduct the observation rather than some assumed lack of precision in the subject of the observation. Unfortunately in this light the distinctive title of rank proves to be an imperfect means, especially when one wishes to undertake an 12 Bossy develops his analysis of the crisis of moral tradition in Peace in the Post Reformation (1998c). For the procedures that fostered the re-establishment of peace, see Raggio 1990. 13 For an example of the use of distinctive titles of rank to study the evolution of the social structure of a community, see Cattini 1984.
The SOcial Impact of the Reform
121
inter-temporal analysis. The titles in use could change from place to place and in the course of time; they could be very varied and difficult to place in an absolute hierarchy of prestige; they could vary depending on individual careers and on the compilers of the registrations etc.14 (Alfani 2004a; Dolan 1998). It is preferable then to simplify matters, which is advantageous when analysing data and presenting results. I have therefore divided all the individuals present (either as parents or godparents) in the baptismal registers in the localities studied into four groups on the basis of their distinctive titles of rank. These groups correspond to the following subdivisions of the population: 1. The signori (seigneurs), or those indicated with a title that differed from that of magister (master), or from those reserved for the clergy such as reverendus or venerabilis (reverend, venerable). This is the group to which the social elite belonged. 2. The magistri (masters), those who possessed particular skills, a particular expertise in their craft, and who probably belonged to a guild. This social group not only appears to be quite distinct from that of the seigneurs, but is distinguished by a distinctive title of rank (magister, maistro, maestro, mastro), which is their own prerogative and cannot be replaced by any other as it has no equivalents, neither perfect nor imperfect (unlike titles such as dominus, messere, signore, which were often interchangeable). 3. The clergy, to whom special titles are reserved, such as reverendus and venerabilis. 4. The untitled, mainly belonging to the lower classes. Despite a degree of imprecision and imperfection that a classification of this kind inevitably presents, the large number of samples of baptisms examined guarantees that the results are reasonably reliable. On the other hand, these results will be interpreted ‘qualitatively’, that is paying attention to the levels, the reciprocal positions, rather than the values themselves.
14 Fortunately, in most cases each individual is also shown with the same titles and even when the title changes, there is one that is dominant.
Clerics (%)
Total godfathers
Untitled (%)
Masters (%)
Seigneurs (%)
Clerics (%)
Total godfathers
Untitled (%)
Masters (%)
Seigneurs (%)
Clerics (%)
Seigneurs
Seigneurs (%)
Masters Masters (%)
Ivrea 1540–1549 1600–1609 Turin¹ 1551–1560 1600–1609 Voghera² 1540–1549 1594–1603 Finale Ligure 1540–1549 1600–1609 Gambellara³ 1541–1549
Untitled Untitled (%)
Fathers Godfathers
A comparison of the ranks of fathers and godfathers
Total godfathers
Table 6.1
90 135
57.8 52.6
15.6 5.2
20.0 42.2
6.7 0
92 20
35.9 20.0
23.9 35.0
38.0 45.0
2.2 0
165 120
24.9 7.5
10.9 3.3
58.2 87.5
6.1 1.7
121 290
87.6 62.1
3.3 0.3
6.6 36.9
2.5 0.7
9 0
66.7 –
11.1 –
22.2 –
0 –
59 254
47.5 6.3
1.7 0
45.8 92.5
5.1 1.2
2082 1556
73.1 44.9
8.8 3.0
18.0 52.0
0.1 0.1
132 43
51.5 32.6
13.6 4.7
34.9 62.8
0 0
572 436
23.3 2.1
11.0 0
65.7 98.0
0 0
243 196
85.6 68.9
9.1 3.1
4.9 28.1
0.4 0
6 11
66.7 18.2
0 9.1
33.3 72.7
0 0
0 23
– 30.4
– 8.7
– 60.9
– 0
285
88.4
4.6
6.7
0.4
6
83.3
16.7
0
0
11
63.6
0
18.2
18.2
1600–1609 Mirandola 1540–1549 1600–1609 Bellano 1540–1549 1600–1609
340
85.6
2.4
11.2
0.9
4
100
0
0
0
29
31.0
0
69.0
0
798 557
29.7 9.2
4.9 1.6
64.5 88.7
0.9 0.5
164 97
11.4 3.1
10.3 1.0
77.7 95.9
0.5 0
240 806
5.0 0
2.7 0.9
88.0 97.2
4.4 1.9
340 216
32.9 52.8
2.7 0.9
56.5 45.8
7.9 0.5
16 0
6.3 –
0 –
50.0 –
43.8 –
204 46
4.9 4.4
0 0
73.0 89.1
22.1 6.5
¹ There is a difference of 11 years in comparison with the other localities in the first sample from Turin because the registers of the parish of S. Agostino began only in 1551. ² The second sample from Voghera relates to the period 1594–1603. on account of a long gap in the register from 1604. ³ The first sample from Gambellara began in 1541 instead of 1540. in line with the date of the first baptismal registers of that locality.
124
Fathers and Godfathers
Table 6.1 shows the way in which the parents’ titles related to those of the godfathers, locality by locality,15 before and after the Council of Trent. To facilitate the reading I have restricted my analysis to two decades that I consider apt:16 1540–1549 and 1600–1609. Data relating to godmothers have not been included in the table, as they lead to the same conclusions. I have listed the percentage of godfathers from each class present at the baptism of children of parents under ‘untitled’, ‘masters’, ‘seigneurs’ and ‘clerics’. I have separated the data of the baptisms of natural children and foundlings, which will be dealt with in the next chapter. Table 6.1 is interesting both on account of what it reveals about the composition of the groups of godfathers before the Council of Trent and for what it implies about later transformations. With regard to the first point, the data relative to the first sample of each locality clearly show that it is impossible to classify the models of godparenthood common in northern Italy up until the mid-sixteenth century as simply horizontal or vertical, as the situation is far more complex. First, let us examine the case of godfathers of children of untitled parents. Leaving aside the clergy for a moment, we can see that these godparents belong to all levels of the social categories, the untitled, the masters and the seigneurs. The relatively few godfathers who were masters can be explained by their limited number in the total population; it is appropriate, then, to concentrate on those without a title and on the seigneurs. The first are present in a percentage that varies between 29.7 per cent (at Mirandola) and 88.4 per cent (at Gambellara), the second go from 4.8 per cent of the total (at Finale) to 64.5 per cent (at Mirandola). These data do not entitle us to say that the pre-Tridentine models of godparenthood, and especially the multi-godfather ones, tended to be horizontal or, to put it more clearly, did not aspire to be vertical. In fact, it could be assumed that in the make-up of a large group of godparents the presence of some untitled individuals can be explained by the circumstance that if a father from a lower rank was unable to secure the desired number of high-ranking godparents, he would then choose some of his peers, but merely as ‘fillers’.
15 For Ivrea I have used only the data relating to the parish of S. Ulderico. I have excluded Azeglio from the table because its registers are full of gaps for the years subsequent to 1599. 16 The first decade had to be sufficiently distant from the end of the Council to be adequate to reflect pre-Tridentine godparenthood, but not so far back as to be unable to guarantee the availability of data for most of the localities. The second decade had to relate to a period when the couple model was a fixture.
The SOcial Impact of the Reform
125
That this assumption is unfounded can easily be demonstrated; it is sufficient to look at the baptism of children of seigneurs. In some respects it is surprising that untitled godfathers are to be found also at these ceremonies; the percentage ranges from 4.9 per cent at Bellano (whose elite are, at least apparently, absolutely closed from the point of view of spiritual kinship) to 63.6 per cent at Gambellara. The presence of seigneur godfathers, on the other hand, varies from 18.2 per cent at Gambellara to 88 per cent at Mirandola: the position of each locality tends to mirror that found for the untitled godfathers. This was predictable as the master and clergy godfathers made up only a small part of the total number. The seigneurs, therefore, usually chose a considerable number of spiritual kin from people of lower ranks than their own, a practice that appears even more marked if the presence of master godfathers is taken into account, as they too were on a lower rung of the social ladder. The clergy merit separate discussion. In some localities they are often to be found at baptisms (at Ivrea and Turin, but above all at Bellano), while in others they are completely absent. This is partly due to fundamental differences between the multi-godfather and single-godfather models, or multi-godfather models but with a very limited maximum number of godparents allowed. If it was possible to choose one godparent or at most two, it was unlikely that a member of the clergy would be admitted. This factor, however, does not explain the almost total absence of the clergy at baptisms celebrated in Voghera, one of the localities among those examined where godfathers were most numerous. Whether or not godfathers were chosen from the clergy, the ‘social legitimacy’ of this choice is then a further element that was regulated by local customs, in the absence of any definite norm on the matter. There is a fundamental difference between ‘non-limited’ multi-godfather models (types 1 and 2) and those that are extremely limited (types 5 and 6, to which some variations of types 3 and 4 can be added), which we could define as ‘oligo-godfather’. The multi-godfather models offered infinitely better strategic possibilities in comparison with the oligo-godfather models, insofar as they made it possible to form a group of spiritual kin pursuing simultaneously a multiplicity of objectives, which led to a choice of people with different characteristics: people from the same rank, from an inferior or a superior one, lay people or the clergy, and so on. If the possibility of choosing compari from an inferior rank to one’s own was a typical characteristic of spiritual kinship, to be found also in the oligo-godfather models, it was with the multi-godfather models that it was really evident. Examining data baptism by baptism reveals that large groups of spiritual kin usually included quite different components, with godparents belonging to all the different rungs of the social ladder,
126
Fathers and Godfathers
including perhaps a member of the clergy. I will come back to this later on.17 The data in Table 6.1 enable us to deal with the question of the changes following the Council. A comparison of the two samples leads in some way to an unexpected conclusion: far from producing a ‘moralization’ of godparenthood, thanks to which spiritual kin would at last have concerned themselves with the Christian education of their godchildren, the Tridentine reform had an entirely unwanted outcome, one that makes it doubtful whether the godparents carried out their duty any better than before; in fact, perhaps the opposite was true. The drastic reduction in the size of the groups of godparents made it impossible to pursue the traditional strategies of selection. The social consequences of this change are evident. If we consider the godparents of the children of the untitled, everywhere (except for Bellano) the percentage of godfathers belonging to their same class is reduced, often drastically: from 73 to 45 per cent at Voghera, from 30 to 9 per cent at Mirandola, from 86 to 69 per cent at Finale Ligure, from 88 to 62 per cent at Turin, from 58 to 53 per cent at Ivrea, from 88 to 86 per cent at Gambellara. Also, the percentage of godfathers who were masters or clerics is smaller. At the same time, the percentage of godparents chosen from the seigneurs increased (again except for Bellano): from 18 to 52 per cent at Voghera, from 64 to 89 per cent at Mirandola, from 5 to 28 per cent at Finale Ligure, from 7 to 37 per cent at Turin, from 20 to 42 per cent at Ivrea, from 7 to 11 per cent at Gambellara. If we look at the children of parents without a title, godparenthood as a social institution seems to have been subjected to a push towards verticalization. If we consider the children of the seigneurs, we discover an opposite trend; everywhere the percentage of godparents from their own class increases. The most remarkable cases are those of Turin (from 46 to 93 per cent), Gambellara (from 19 to 69 per cent), Ivrea (from 58 to 88 per cent) and Voghera (from 66 to 98 per cent). At the same time, the percentage of untitled godparents drops (from 47 to 6 per cent in Turin, from 64 to 31 per cent at Gambellara, from 25 to 8 per cent in Ivrea and from 23 to 2 per cent at Voghera). In localities such as Voghera, Turin, Bellano, Ivrea and Mirandola at the beginning of the seventeenth century the ‘spiritual endogamy’18 of the class of the seigneurs was practically absolute. In their case, then, the social 17
In Chapter 9. The description ‘spiritual endogamy’ is obviously meaningless from an etymological point of view, but it seems to me that it gives a good idea of what I wish to convey and, given the current use of the term ‘endogamy’, I think it is easily and immediately understandable and does not create confusion. For this usage, see Alfani (2005b). 18
The SOcial Impact of the Reform
127
impact produced by the Tridentine reform led to a horizontal selection of godparents among their peers. It was, above all, masters and clergy who paid for these changes; increasingly they were excluded from the baptism of the offspring of other classes. Clergy, especially, almost completely disappeared. It is not possible to explain this phenomenon with a change in legislation, as the only members of the clergy to be banned from godparenthood were monks, and by law they were already excluded prior to the Council.19 Rather, it was the sudden reduction in the size of the group of spiritual kin that penalized the clergy; as it was permissible to choose only one godfather, it was out of the question to choose a priest. In the divisive situation and confusion that were features of godparenthood in the years subsequent to the introduction of the new regulations, the ‘surviving’ godfather of these once-large groups is the ‘best’ that can be obtained, that is, from the highest possible rank. It would seem that the search for patronage in the past had been only one of the elements that contributed to determining the make-up of the group of spiritual kin, while now it prevailed over all others. The two trends, a vertical one for the lower classes and a horizontal one for the higher ranks, went in parallel with the progressive reduction in the average number of godparents during the phase when the new regulations were being applied and adapted. This can be clearly seen from the graphs in Figures 6.1 and 6.2, where the annual series of the percentage of godfathers from each social class are indicated respectively for the children of the untitled and the seigneurs of Voghera. The shape of the graphs for Voghera is very telling, and it confirms the link that existed between the reduction in the number of godparents and the transformation of the comparatico relationship. The verticalization of godparenthood of the children of the untitled, and the horizontal trend and ‘spiritual endogamy’ of the godparenthood of the children of the seigneurs reflect a gradual process that closely follows the stages of the application of the Tridentine norms limiting the number of spiritual kin. When this transitional phase terminated between the end of the sixteenth century and the beginning of the seventeenth century, an equilibrium was reached that probably lasted into the following decades. I will return to this hypothesis later.
19
In some areas, always before the Council, attempts were made to prohibit secular clergy from godfatherhood. A similar ban was present, for example, in the Constitutions of Fiesole of 1306, and was reaffirmed by the Provincial Council of Florence in 1517. In this case the reason put forward was not only to prevent members of the clergy from too close an association with lay friends, but also to prevent the latter, thanks to spiritual kinship, from putting pressure on the former and thus influencing their activities. It seems, however, that the Florentine elite were quite able to ignore this prohibition (Haas 1998, pp. 69–70).
Fathers and Godfathers
128
8QWLWOHG Fig, 6.1
0DVWHUV
6HLJQHXUV
&OHUJ\
Distribution by rank of the godfathers of the children of the untitled (Voghera, 1534–1604)
8QWLWOHG Fig. 6.2
0DVWHUV
6HLJQHXUV
&OHUJ\
Distribution by rank of the godfathers of the children of the seigneurs (Voghera, 1534–1604)
Recorded on a graph, the data from the other communities are seen to be quite analogous with that from Voghera, except for those from Bellano. As can be seen from Table 6.1, Bellano was the only locality, among those where the multi-godfather model was operative, that had characteristics which differed from the others. On the basis of the data recorded on the table, with regard to the percentage of the godfathers of the untitled, the impression is that Bellano went in the opposite direction to the current
The SOcial Impact of the Reform
129
trend, with a definite increase in untitled godparents and a reduction in all the others, including seigneurs. If, however, we examine the graph of the annual data, we discover that the situation is far more complex (Figure 6.3).
8QWLWOHG Fig. 6.3
0DVWHUV
6HLJQHXUV
&OHUJ\
Distribution by rank of the godfathers of the children of the untitled (Bellano, 1533–1609)
In the period after the conclusion of the Council, Bellano, far from experiencing a counter trend, experienced a rapid and very sudden reduction in the presence of untitled godparents at the baptisms of the children from families of their same class; such baptisms were, however, attended by an unusual number of seigneurs. This practice steadily grew, reaching a peak around 1577. It then declined until at the end of the century it returned to the values that roughly matched those prior to the imposition of the new regulations, except for the fact that the clergy had almost disappeared, to the advantage of untitled godfathers. What happened at Bellano is a further sign of the disarray and confusion caused in the short term by the Tridentine reform. As will be remembered, in this locality the reduction in the number of godfathers and godmothers was immediate: it took place before July 1564, without the population being able to put up any real resistance. The reaction is exactly the same as that found elsewhere: the only ‘surviving’ godfather was the highest in rank who could be persuaded to attend the ceremony. Unlike elsewhere, in time this ‘impulsive’ reaction weakened and there was a return to more moderate choices. The case of Bellano, then, prompts us to be cautious when suggesting that the equilibrium reached by communities like Voghera at the end of the
130
Fathers and Godfathers
sixteenth century was maintained in the following centuries; additionally, data are currently scarce for the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, when there might have been significant changes. It is true though that Bellano is anomalous, and elsewhere I have found no traces of any early ‘second thoughts’ that corrected the consequences experienced everywhere by godparenthood following the Council’s deliberations. Going back to the sixteenth century, how can we interpret this twofold thrust that godparenthood experienced, ‘vertical’ in the case of the lower rungs of the social ladder and ‘horizontal’ in the higher ones, which is to be found in many places in northern Italy? Undoubtedly, it appears that the Tridentine reform of godparenthood became a factor of social closure: the opportunity for having ‘official’ relationships with people from very different classes was drastically reduced. It is well known that in the second half of the sixteenth century central northern Italy experienced a marked economic recovery that remedied the damage caused in many areas by the conflict between France and Spain during the first part of the century. For many nouveaux riches it was a chance to try to climb the social ladder;20 in other words, society tended to open its doors. At the same time, however, there were forces at work moving in the opposite direction, tending towards social closure. An example was the new Tridentine regulations on marriage, which made so-called ‘clandestine marriages’ impossible and thus reinforced parental control of unions (Zarri 1996). The data shown indicate that the Council of Trent produced similar effects with the reform of godparenthood. If prior to 1563 parents were quite free to select godparents from all levels of the social hierarchy, in the last quarter of the century this possibility was drastically reduced. It was still permissible through compaternitas to become kin of people from a completely different rank from one’s own, and among the members of lower classes this practice became more common. However, the differences in rank were now so wide that there was no longer any doubt about the reciprocal position of the new relations. Exaggerating a little, it is possible to claim that, as any possibility of becoming ‘official’ friends with those from a higher class had disappeared, the only means of establishing a contact was to become their clients. These conclusions obviously need to be verified by extending investigation to other communities, and with the use of other sources, by making a thorough study at a local level of the transformation that took place in godparenthood. One thing, though, is certain: the Tridentine reform propelled godparenthood in a direction that was not desired by the Church; in fact, it went in the very opposite direction. 20 This, for example, has been demonstrated in a study conducted by Marco Cattini (1984) on San Felice and by Paola Subacchi’s research centred on Piacenza (1996).
The SOcial Impact of the Reform
131
It was the conciliar fathers’ intention that parents should be encouraged to choose for their children godparents who could really carry out their role as tutors in a correct Christian education. As the Council did not envisage any definite norm in the matter, in the following decades personalities of the calibre of Carlo Borromeo, in their efforts to try and apply the Tridentine decrees, grasped the opportunity to tackle these issues and prevent the choice of godparents being made for personal interest. The Church, then, wanted godparenthood to become above all a horizontal relationship, between peers, but it achieved the opposite result and never actually managed to impose its own views on reluctant populations. To solve the problem of Christian education it had to resign itself to adopting other means, such as catechism. I will deal with this in Chapter 10.
This page has been left blank intentionally
CHAPTER 7
Newborn Babies and Spiritual Kinship: Equal Opportunities or Discrimination? Up to now, in dealing with the godparenthood models that envisaged numerous spiritual kin, I have made no distinction between male and female newborn babies, merely noting that no great differences existed in their spiritual kin. In the literature on godparenthood, it is not uncommon to meet comments that seem to imply that there was discrimination based on sex in the choice of godparents. On the basis of my data, I think this is a misleading view, based on prejudice and similar to that which has led some to assume that only children of upper-class parents had numerous godparents. I have discussed the question of the relationship between social rank and the provision of spiritual kin in the previous chapter, showing how even infants from lower classes had numerous godparents, from all levels of the social hierarchy. In the same way, the offspring of the elite were also given godparents of humble origin; all in all, pre-Tridentine godparenthood was an opportunity to ratify the entrance of the child into the community as a whole, rather than into the restricted circle of his or her peers. The provision of very heterogeneous spiritual connections derives from this attitude, which was consistent with the Christian meaning of baptism and therefore attributable to cultural factors as well as to ‘strategic’ aims. My intention now is to add the gender factor to my analysis, showing how it combined with other elements to define a grading of privilege that was different from what might have been expected. As we will see, other factors had a far more decisive role than sex in affecting the number and quality of the godparents allotted to each infant. It was, in particular, a question of the legitimacy of the baby’s birth and of its order, in other words the position of each infant in relation to their siblings: were the firstborn especially privileged? The existence of discriminating factors linked to godparenthood is important when evaluating the opportunities available to children with different ascribed characteristics. Godparents could offer support at crucial times, for example, with the premature loss of parents or by taking a child on as an apprentice. Besides this, they constituted a store of social
134
Fathers and Godfathers
links on which it was possible to fall back in times of need. So, if to socially unfavourable factors, such as being illegitimate, was added an even more disadvantageous inclusion in the spiritual kinship network, an already unfortunate position was further worsened. On the other hand, provided there was no significant ‘spiritual’ discrimination, godparents could perhaps contribute to alleviating the consequences of an unpromising birth. It is obvious that infants had no chance of influencing their choice of godparents; they were ‘passive players’ at their own baptism. However, though passive, they possessed characteristics that affected the choice of the other players, though not all such characteristics were always known before the choice was made. If a baby’s order of birth and legitimacy would never usually be in doubt beforehand, the same cannot be said for its sex. As the baptismal ceremony took place very soon after birth, the baby’s sex remained unknown until a few hours before the ceremony. Probably it was the combination of these known and unknown factors that had consequences we would not fully anticipate. This is certainly the case in the absence of discrimination between the sexes. Given that in European societies of the ancien régime genders had clearly different roles, it might be expected that boys and girls would be treated differently at birth. The former might have had more numerous or more prestigious spiritual kin, more capable of offering them support when the boys entered the company of the active members of the community. For girls, second-rate connections might have been expected, or perhaps godmothers, given to them in greater numbers than to boys. Christiane Klapisch-Zuber, analysing the Florentine family records, noted that ‘Leur rédacteurs font moins d’efforts pour rapporter les noms des parents spirituels acquis aux baptêmes des filles que pour ceux des garçons. Ils semblent ainsi juger que l’alliance spirituelle contractée à travers les baptêmes des nouveaux-nées mâles est plus importante, plus digne d’etre mémorisée, que celle nouée par le baptême des filles’
The First Provincial Council of Milan (1565), presided over by Carlo Borromeo, established that baptism had to take place within eight days of birth (AEM, vol. II, coll. 43–45). On other occasions even more restrictive rules were issued in accordance with the Tridentine principle which decreed that baptism should be celebrated ‘as soon as possible’ (quam primum). The King of France, for example, in 1698 decreed that baptism should take place within 24 hours of birth (Gourdon 2003). However, at least in the first centuries of the Modern Age, norms of this kind were aimed at preventing deviant cases rather than opposing common practices. It was the conviction that baptism was a necessary condition to obtain salvation that encouraged parents to baptize their children very quickly (Le Goff 1982; Prosperi 2005). ‘Their compilers make less effort to record the names of spiritual kin acquired with girls’ baptism than with those of boys. Thus they seem to consider the spiritual alliance
NewBorn babies and Spiritual Kinship
135
(Klapisch-Zuber 1985b, pp. 56–57). Klapisch-Zuber discovered in Florence some discrimination based on sex, as girls were given on average fewer godparents: 59 per cent of them had one or two godparents, while 58 per cent of boys had at least three. However, the sex of the baptized did not determine that of the spiritual kin; boys actually had more godmothers than girls. As will be seen, my data confirm that newborn males were given a higher number of spiritual kin, though the difference is very limited. At this point, it is time to be more specific. It can be assumed that, generally, it was preferable to provide the newborn babies with as many kin as possible regardless of their sex. How, then, can the existence of discrimination be explained? And why was the socially accepted upper limit of spiritual kin not always reached, this limit in some communities being very high and not rigidly pre-established? In order to reply to these questions, it is helpful to consider godparents as a scarce resource. If a key person was asked to take part in the baptism of a child, perhaps expecting rich gifts as well as social support, it was unlikely that the same person would agree to carry out similar functions for later children. If parents wished to extend their network of alliances, it would be better to turn their attention elsewhere, rather than repeating a connection with a person where there was already a relationship of kinship. Usually the presence of a particular godparent at baptism was the result of definite agreements, which sometimes demanded lengthy negotiations to conclude, but I will come back to this shortly. Whatever the reasons, the empirical data clearly indicate that the list of possible candidates for godparenthood was limited in number, and those on the list could not, except in special circumstances, be ‘reused’. In this light it is important to evaluate whether the distribution, numerical and qualitative, of godparents was uniform among all children, or if some had preferential treatment. obtained by the baptism of newborn males more important and more worthy to be remembered than that of girls’. In literature there is no lack of cases where the prevailing custom was to attribute the same godparent to all the children of a couple (for example at Neckarhausen in Germany, or in various parts of the Balkans. For Neckarhausen, see Sabean 1998; for the Balkans, Hammel 1968). These are customs typical of godparenthood models that were very different from those I discovered in Italy, allowing godparenthood to be used to build and progressively renew a privileged relationship with just one godparent; often it was a public recognition of patronage. In the localities I have studied similar practices were neither appreciated nor common (I will come back to the exceptions), and in general the presence of a particular person at the baptism of one’s child was an event not to be repeated unless the child had died and the same godparents were given to a brother born later. In the next chapter I will look at cases in Ivrea, and especially at recurring godparents and crossed godparents.
Table 7.1
Average number of godfathers and godmothers for baptized males and females before the Council of Trent Years
Males
Females
Total baptisms
Average number of godfathers
Average number of godmothers
Total baptisms
Average number of godfathers
Average number of godmothers
Ivrea¹
1473–1562
731
2.65
1.24
656
2.47
1.31
Azeglio
1543–1562
275
2.45
1.56
307
2.23
1.55
Gambellara
1541–1562
298
1.38
1.42
269
1.41
1.31
Turin
1551–1562
59
2.54
0.68
50
2.38
0.6
Bellano
1533–1562
302
3.04
2.42
272
2.67
2.3
Finale
1481–1562
524
1.59
1.54
452
1.55
1.45
Voghera²
1534–1562
2,106
2.21
–
1,979
2.15
–
Mirandola
1484–1562
4,412
1.16
1.19
4,035
1.14
1.20
Ravenna
1555–1557
718
1.20
0.36
647
1.00
0.41
Cesena
1555–1557
363
1.34
1.23
380
1.18
1.21
Nonantola
1558–1562
141
0.97
0.92
136
1
0.96
¹ The data recorded in this and the following tables relates only to the parish of S. Ulderico. ² As will be recalled, the godparenthood model in Voghera did not envisage that infants be given godmothers.
NewBorn babies and Spiritual Kinship
137
Table 7.1 records the data for the average number of godfathers and godmothers of newborn males and females baptized before the Council of Trent in the communities already mentioned, to which I have added Nonantola, Ravenna and Cesena. The data suggest that boys tended to have a larger number of spiritual kin, both godfathers and godmothers, than girls. In all the localities except Gambellara and Nonantola, boys on average had more godfathers than girls, and in all the localities except Ivrea, Mirandola, Ravenna and Nonantola, more godmothers. The trend is clear, even though the extent of the discrimination is very limited. The case in which it is most marked is Bellano, both for godfathers and for godmothers (on average 3.04 against 2.67 and 2.42 against 2.3 respectively). This situation of moderate privilege does not change if we look at the ‘quality’ of spiritual kin. In Table 7.2, using the subdivision of the population into the four classes adopted in the previous chapter, I have recorded the percentage of godparents under ‘untitled’, ‘masters’, ‘seigneurs’ and ‘clerics’ for the baptisms of newborn males and females respectively. The data concerning godmothers (not recorded for the sake of brevity) confirm the conclusions that can be deduced from the data for godfathers. I have excluded from the count the baptism of natural children and of foundlings, which I will deal with separately. In all the localities except Ivrea, Finale Ligure and Ravenna, boys are given upper-class godparents, belonging to the seigneurial class, in a higher percentage than girls. At the same time, except in Ivrea and Finale Ligure, they have fewer godparents from the lower ranks, i.e. the untitled. As for the average number of godfathers and godmothers, the differences are negligible.
Nonantola is in Emilia, near Modena; Ravenna and Cesena are cities in Romagna. Although I only have for these communities samples of data that are chronologically limited, I include them in the analysis because they are invaluable for the study of the discrimination that foundlings experienced, which I will deal with shortly.
Table 7.2
Ranks of godparents for baptized males and females before the Council of Trent
Masters (%)
Seigneurs (%)
Clerics (%)
Total godfathers
Untitled (%)
Masters (%)
Seigneurs (%)
Clerics (%)
Females
Untitled (%)
Males Total godfathers
Years
Ivrea
1473–1562
1,930
52
13.9
27.3
6.8
1,615
50.4
14.5
27.3
7.8
Azeglio
1543–1562
672
79.8
6.6
6.7
7
687
84.1
5.5
3.4
7
Gambellara
1541–1562
412
82
7
10
1
380
87.6
3.7
7.9
0.8
Turin
1551–1562
142
75.4
0
20.4
4.2
117
76.9
5.1
13.7
4.3
Bellano
1533–1562
905
22.2
1.9
63
12.9
712
26
1.4
57.3
15.3
Finale
1481–1562
823
88.6
3.5
6.1
1.8
591
87.8
4.1
7.4
0.7
Voghera
1534–1562
4,590
62.2
8.7
29.1
0
4,187
66
8.1
25.9
0
Mirandola
1484–1562
4,911
37.7
10.1
47.6
4.6
4,407
39
9.6
46.7
4.7
Ravenna
1555–1557
852
36.9
0.8
55.8
6.6
643
37.8
1.4
56.1
4.7
Cesena
1555–1557
478
49
8.4
36
6.7
440
50.2
11.6
30.2
8
Nonantola
1558–1562
133
63.9
12
23.3
0.8
132
70.5
9.1
20.5
0
NewBorn babies and Spiritual Kinship
139
The sex of the baptized child, therefore, influenced far less than might have been supposed the way the choice of godparents. Why was the bias usually accorded to male descendants not carried into more numerous and prestigious godparents? One explanation may be that until just before the baptism there was uncertainty about the sex of the newborn baby. There is reason to suppose that at the moment of birth a decision had already been taken about most of the godparents, even though the exact day of labour was not known. As most baptisms were celebrated very shortly after a birth (if not immediately, in cases where there was doubt that the infant would survive), it was better to be prudent, so much so that in some cases the agreement to establish anew a relationship of comparatico was the result of lengthy negotiations. In one example, Claude Gauvard (1993) reports the case of two neighbours in Rouen in the fourteenth century, Perrin and Baillevache, who publicly take an oath to enter into a comparatico relationship, once Baillevache’s first child is born, and Perrin holds him at baptism. The author interprets this behaviour as part of a strategy designed to neutralize violence and criminality between neighbours, which was the cause of a considerable amount of urban crime; between compari security was (almost) completely guaranteed. In situations like this, it is clear that uncertainty about the gender of the baby made it necessary to plan blindly how the group of spiritual kin was to be composed; this, perhaps unwittingly, resulted in the protection of the female sex. This interpretation, though, seems to go against customs, common in most of Europe, that enforced a different treatment for newborn males and females: the ternary model, for example, which envisaged two godfathers and a godmother for males and vice versa for females. The problem, though, lies in our limited knowledge of the procedures necessary to guarantee that the desired godfathers and godmothers were present at baptism, procedures that probably changed according to place, time and customs. In the case of the relatively rigid ternary model it is possible that a particularly desirable godfather or godmother was ensured in advance and the list of spiritual kin would be completed later, once the sex of the infant was known. Compared with this, which is mere hypothesis, it is necessary to recognize that it was the most flexible models, and especially those that allowed the presence of numerous godfathers and godmothers,
Also in Ivrea, midwives, or some of them, probably used techniques to forecast the sex of the baby. Their reliability, however, was probably minimal, if not non-existent. It can be noted that a choice made on the basis of unfounded information corresponds, in the results, to a calculation made in a condition of uncertainty.
140
Fathers and Godfathers
that potentially posed far more difficult problems in the planning and strategic management of godparenthood. The question of the strategies in the selection of spiritual kin is complicated and will be examined later. For now the essential point to make is that discrimination on the grounds of sex proves to be a false problem, either because of the uncertainty of the sex of the infant or because current practices meant that there was not a big difference between the way males and females were treated, perhaps because what was really important were the comparatico relationships that the parents themselves wished to acquire. The planning procedures of the baptisms held in those communities that I have studied also protected newborn girls in another way. Those who were really privileged were the firstborn, whether they were males or females. Like gender, the order of birth is traditionally a discriminating factor. However, compared with gender, it is more difficult to analyse; it is necessary to resort to data that enable us to reconstruct the sequence of the births for each family nucleus. The only data of this kind at my disposal refer to the communities of Ivrea and Azeglio. I have restricted my analysis to those cases where it is possible to reconstruct the order of births with a certain confidence. I have not taken into account families in which I have found only one child, in the hope of being able to reduce as far as possible any distortions caused by migration or by the use of other baptismal fonts (see Alfani 2004a). Table 7.3 records the usual figures for the average number of godfathers and godmothers respectively for firstborn male and female children .
It is clearly impossible to follow the families in their transfer from one parish to another, and it is probable that for this and other reasons (Alfani 2004a) the resulting samples do not include all the firstborn in the period under consideration nor, on the other hand, is it possible to be certain that all its members were really firstborn. The differences between the measurements for the whole population and those of the subset of the firstborn are certainly underestimated. Even so, the data clearly indicate that the firstborn had more and better godparents.
Table 7.3
Average number of godfathers and godmothers for firstborn males and females before the Council of Trent Males
Females
Total baptisms
Average number of godfathers
Average number of godmothers
Total baptisms
Average number of godfathers
Average number of godmothers
Firstborn
115
2.8
1.27
120
2.68
1.42
All newborn
731
2.65
1.24
656
2.47
1.31
Firstborn
71
2.56
2.08
67
2.40
1.9
All newborn
275
2.45
1.56
307
2.23
1.55
Ivrea (1473–1562)
Azeglio (1543–1562)
Table 7.4
Ranks of godfathers for firstborn males and females (up until 1562)
Seigneurs (%)
Clerics (%)
Total godfathers
Untitled (%)
Masters (%)
Seigneurs (%)
Clerics (%)
319
44.2
16.9
31
7.8
322
44.1
14
31.7
10.3
1,930
52
13.9
27.3
6.8
1,615
50.4
14.5
27.3
7.8
Total godfathers
Masters (%)
Females
Untitled (%)
Males
Ivrea (1473–1562) Firstborn All newborn
Azeglio (1543–1562) Firstborn
179
79.9
7.8
7.8
4.5
160
88.1
6.3
3.1
2.5
All newborn
672
79.8
6.6
6.7
7
687
84.1
5.5
3.4
7
NewBorn babies and Spiritual Kinship
143
The order of birth was of considerable importance in establishing the size of the group of spiritual kin. The favour granted to the firstborn, whatever their sex, is clear. In Ivrea, the average number of godfathers for males increases from 2.65 to 2.8 and for females from 2.47 to 2.68, while at Azeglio it rises from 2.45 to 2.56 and from 2.23 to 2.4 respectively. The same applies to godmothers. The privileged position occupied by the firstborn within the spiritual kinship network becomes clear from the status of the godparents (Table 7.4). In Ivrea, in a comparison between the firstborn and all those being baptized, the percentage of godfathers of a lower rank (the untitled) is decidedly reduced: from 52 to 44.2 per cent for males and from 50.4 to 44.1 per cent for females. Correspondingly, the percentage of godfathers from a higher rank (seigneurs) increases from 27.3 to 31 per cent for males, and from 27.3 to 31.7 per cent for females. Strangely, no similar trend is to be found at Azeglio, given that the pattern of differences between the firstborn and the others is very small, and contrasts with that found in Ivrea. The reasons for this different attitude can probably be attributed to the context. Azeglio was a small village with little social diversity, which limited the potential significance of a comparatico strategy with higher ranks. As in Ivrea, the firstborn were privileged, but this appears in the average number of godparents rather than in the number of titled godparents. What is the reason for this privilege? It can probably, at least in part, be explained by cultural factors that led parents to consider the firstborn as more important than the others (with the possible exception of the firstborn male in comparison with his older sisters), which meant they were favoured, symbolically and materially, and were given more spiritual kin. As well as this factor, the young couple’s impatience to provide themselves with comparatico relationships must be taken into account. The baptism of the firstborn was an opportunity to begin to build up a network of comparatico relationships, which would be strengthened and perfected with the baptism of other children and by their own participation in other ceremonies as godfathers and godmothers. We can assume that
The case of the children of Stefano and Margherita de Aijmino, baptized at the font of S. Ulderico in Ivrea, is a good example. Their firstborn was a girl, Beatrice, baptized on 7 April 1526 in the presence of four godfathers and three godmothers. The second was a male, baptized on 21 June 1528. He still had a relatively large number of godfathers (three), but no godmother. Later children were also provided with fewer spiritual kin than the firstborn: Bartolomea had three godfathers and two godmothers (5 September 1531); Gaspare two godfathers and no godmother (22 December 1532); Marta three godfathers and no godmother (7 July 1539); Paola two godfathers and one godmother (24 May 1542); Antonio one godfather and one godmother (3 June 1548).
144
Fathers and Godfathers
all, or almost all, the long-awaited connections were set up at the first opportunity. I will come back to this. The question arises whether the privileged situation granted to the firstborn prior to the Council of Trent continued after the couple model had been introduced at Ivrea and Azeglio. Regarding the quantity of godfathers and godmothers, there was almost no room for manoeuvre, which meant that it is necessary to concentrate on their quality to evaluate the relative favour that children of a different pecking order enjoyed. Table 7.5 records the distribution by distinctive title of rank of the godparents of baptism for the ceremonies after 1587, which, as will be recalled, marked the end of the resistance to the couple model and its definite adoption. The data imply that towards the end of the sixteenth century the trend was to re-equate the position of the firstborn in comparison with the other baptized. Not only did they have the same number of godfathers and godmothers as their younger siblings (one godfather and one godmother), but also the social rank of the spiritual kin was approximately the same. It is dangerous to generalize these observations to apply to the following years, as it is possible that the situation of godparenthood as a social institution was not yet completely stabilized. It is reasonably safe to assume that in the aftermath of the changes imposed by the Tridentine reform, privileged categories such as the firstborn would have been swept away by a general trend towards the verticalization of the relationship of godparenthood, which led to giving all children godparents from the highest possible rank. Within circumstances like this, any favour accorded to the firstborn is difficult to identify. The most interesting aspect of the transformation of godparenthood from the point of view of privilege, however, concerns discrimination on the basis not of order of birth but of gender, and especially regarding godmothers. In Ivrea, before the Council of Trent, godmothers were absent at about one baptism in four. In other localities, like Turin and Voghera, the model of godparenthood in use envisaged the occasional attendance of a godmother (in Turin at one baptism in five), or a total absence (at Voghera). In all these localities the drastic reduction in the number of godparents permitted meant that, in adopting the couple model (type 5), a godmother was always present. The Tridentine reform, therefore, was an opportunity to enhance the godmother’s role and to increase the number of women acceding to spiritual kinship (see the next chapter).
Table 7.5
Ranks of godfathers for firstborn males and females after 1587
Seigneurs (%)
Clerics (%)
Total godfathers
Untitled (%)
Masters (%)
Seigneurs (%)
Clerics (%)
Firstborn
69
24.6
2.9
68.1
4.4
62
31.2
4.9
60.7
3.3
All newborn
374
27.5
5.4
64.2
2.9
362
26.8
6.1
63
4.1
Total godfathers
Masters (%)
Females
Untitled (%)
Males
Ivrea (1587–1616)
Azeglio (1587–1599) Firstborn
13
61.5
30.8
7.7
0
17
82.4
0
17.7
0
All newborn
192
77.6
10.4
12
0
169
81.1
4.7
14.2
0
146
Fathers and Godfathers
The last important factor in social discrimination is still to be evaluated: the legitimacy or illegitimacy of the infant. This factor goes with another, the abandonment of babies, which poses intriguing questions about the practices of godparenthood. During the Modern Era many illegitimate children were abandoned, left either ‘in the wheel’ in those villages and towns that had one (a mechanism in a church door in which an unwanted baby could be placed anonymously), or on the doorstep of a house or in some other place. Such was also the fate of some legitimate children whose parents either did not want or could not keep them.10 The illegitimate infants, baptized by one or both of their parents, were given godparents following a selection process similar to that for legitimate children. They were, though, obviously subject to discrimination. Before the Council of Trent they were given a reduced number of spiritual kin. For example, in Ivrea the illegitimate males had an average of 1.5 godfathers and 0.75 godmothers compared to the norm for all newborn babies of 2.65 and 1.24 respectively; illegitimate girls had 1.33 godfathers and 0.67 godmothers against 2. 47 and 1.31. At Voghera, illegitimate males had 1.75 godfathers against the usual 2.21 and illegitimate females 2.09 against 2.15 (as will be recalled, at Voghera prior to the Council, there were no godmothers).11 I found an equally marked discrimination regarding the social rank of godfathers and godmothers (the ‘best’ godparents were reserved for legitimate children).12 In the case of foundlings, the procedures for assigning godparents were quite different from the ‘normal’ ones, as there were neither parents or relations who could take it on themselves to look for suitable spiritual kin or who had an interest in creating comparatico connections. This makes
Although not on the same level as legitimate children, in the sixteenth century illegitimate offspring were still numerous and relatively well integrated. Their position, though, was to deteriorate rapidly with the consolidating of the Counter- Reformation. For the change in the perception of the illegitimate in the sixteenth century, see Prodi 1997. 10 The number of babies being abandoned increased from the sixteenth century, with a rapid acceleration in three periods: at the end of the sixteenth century with its devastating famines of 1590–1593, at the end of the eighteenth century and in the first half of the nineteenth. See Da Molin 1982; Palombarini 1993; Hunecke 1989. 11 The data for Ivrea and Voghera refer to the same chronological periods as those used previously: 1473–1562 and 1534–1562 respectively. 12 In Ivrea, illegitimate males had 66.7 per cent of untitled godfathers and none chosen from the seigneurs, compared with 52 per cent and 27.3 per cent respectively for legitimate males. Almost 100 per cent of the godparents of illegitimate females were untitled, compared with 50.4 per cent untitled and 27.3 per cent from seigneurs for the legitimate girls. At Voghera 76.2 per cent of the godfathers of the illegitimate males came from the untitled classes and merely 9.5 per cent from the seigneurs, with 62.2 per cent and 29.19 per cent respectively for the legitimate males; for the females there are no marked differences between the legitimate and illegitimate.
NewBorn babies and Spiritual Kinship
147
them a particularly interesting case,13 both for the customs that arose to remedy this problem and regarding the strategy for selecting godparents. For this reason, I shall now go into it in more detail. The spiritual kinship connections of foundlings were potentially even more important than for other infants. They did not have the usual natural parents, unless they were rediscovered after an unexpected recognition. Once they were adults, they might create links of affinity through marriage, but in their early years their only formal kinship relations were those with their godparents.14 It is important, therefore, to ascertain if and how the abandoned infants were really integrated into the complex network of spiritual ties that united members of each community or whether if, already deprived of their natural kinship, they also suffered from deprivation on a ‘spiritual’ level. It will be remembered that the Church held that the principal function of godparents was to supervise the correct Christian education of godchildren. This role, however, was rarely taken very seriously, and other ‘non-official’ duties of godparents were thought to be more important. In the case of abandoned children, it is particularly important to establish whether godfathers and godmothers may not only have taken on the responsibility of ensuring a Christian education but looked after the children as well in their parents’ place. Perhaps in certain cases we can suppose that a form of actual adoption originated from the relationship of spiritual kinship. It is clear that, in order to have a role in the life of the foundling, godparents had to be present, preferably in large numbers. In Table 7.6 I have recorded the average number of godfathers and godmothers ascribed 13 I have analysed in detail elsewhere the problem caused by ascribing a name and by the selection of foundlings’ godparents (Alfani 2007b). 14 Usually, foundlings were baptized using a special formula expressing doubt: there was a fear, in fact, that they had already been baptized, and the sacrament could not be repeated. For example, the Diocesan Synod of Milan of 1571, which I discussed in Chapter 5, made it necessary to use for foundlings the formula ‘si tu es baptizatus, ego te iterum non baptizo; et si nondum es baptizatus, ego te baptizo’; the norm was accepted by the Provincial Council of 1573 (AEM, vol. II, coll. 242–244 and 850). These conditional (sub condicione) baptisms, like the supplementary ceremonies or rites in which it sufficed to complete in Church a baptism celebrated in an imperfect way, usually an emergency, caused problems on account of the identification of the ‘true’ godparents. In cases where the formula expressing doubt was used, the baptism, if it had already taken place, was not repeated; it can be assumed that, given the absence of the sacrament, no spiritual kinship was instituted, but the opinion of the canonists on this question is not clear. Moreover , if the circumstances of the first baptism were unknown, the alleged godparents who had attended the second baptism certainly had to respect all the matrimonial bans connected to spiritual kinship. The presence of godmothers and godfathers at baptisms celebrated sub condicione was as necessary as at the ‘normal’ ones, as there was doubt whether children had been baptized. See for this Torquebiau 1937; on the supplementary ceremonies, see Gourdon 2003.
148
Fathers and Godfathers
to foundlings in the four communities for which I have sufficient data: Cesena, Mirandola, Ravenna and Voghera. In order to avoid excessively reducing the size of the samples of foundlings, already small, I have examined male and female infants together; in the case of foundlings, evidence of discrimination by sex is even more tenuous than for legitimate children. To facilitate my analysis I have compared the relative figures for foundlings with those referring to baptized infants as a whole, to the children of seigneurs and to children of untitled parents. The number of godfathers and godmothers progressively decreases as we descend the social ladder.15 Everywhere the children of seigneurs have more godparents than children from untitled parents, though the situation of godmothers is more confused. And everywhere foundlings have fewer spiritual kin (both godfathers and godmothers) than other classes, except for Voghera, where the total absence of godmothers puts children on a par irrespective of their origin. The norm seems to reflect a tendency for the number of godfathers and godmothers to decrease at the same rate as a decrease in social ranking; however, going from the untitled to foundlings, the process seems to accelerate sharply. In Ravenna, for example, it goes from 1.57 godfathers on average for the seigneurs to 1.01 for the untitled and just 0.13 for abandoned children; the trend, though less marked, is the same for godmothers. Ravenna stands out among the cases examined, because most of the foundlings baptized there have no spiritual kin: almost 82 per cent of the abandoned children have neither godfather or godmother. This situation appears problematic from a theological and pastoral point of view (will a child without a family of flesh and blood be reborn in Christ without a spiritual family?). It is probable that this persisted only because of the state of relative confusion and deregulation of customs of godparenthood that continued until the first part of the sixteenth century. When, after the Council of Trent, a limit was put on the number of godparents at baptism, in localities like Voghera, where godmothers were absent, very soon one was given to all the newborn infants to counteract the tendency to reduce spiritual kinship ties. It is significant that this change in customs also involved abandoned children, who, like all the others, were given a godmother. In Ravenna a survey on baptism celebrated in 1600 has shown that at the time foundlings always had at least one spiritual kin (usually only a godmother), in accordance with the Tridentine decrees.
15
Tom Ericsson (2000) reached similar conclusions for the Swedish town of Umeå in the years 1850–1855 (as will be recalled, in many Protestant areas multi-godparent customs still survive). The children of middle classes had on average 6.4 godparents per baptism, the shopkeepers 5.2, the craftsmen 4.8 and so on, down to the farmers who had 3. The author does not give data concerning godmothers, and cites no cases of abandoned children.
Table 7.6
Ranks of fathers and number of godfathers and godmothers per baptism All baptized
Children of seigneurs
Children of untitled
Foundlings
Average number of godfathers
1.26
1.36
1.25
0.31
Average number of godmothers
1.22
1.04
1.29
0.90
Number of baptisms
743
113
487
29
Average number of godfathers
1.11
1.57
1.01
0.13
Average number of godmothers
0.39
0.36
0.42
0.18
Number of baptisms
1,365
259
894
55
Average number of godfathers
2.18
2.45
2.13
1.90
Average number of godmothers
–
–
–
–
4,092
692
3,135
29
1.20
1.31
1.13
1.03
Cesena (1555–1557)
Ravenna (1555–1557)
Voghera (1534–1562)
Number of baptisms Mirandola (1482–1562) Average number of godfathers Average number of godmothers
1.21
1.21
1.20
1.05
Number of baptisms
8,389
1,041
6,267
320
Ranks of fathers compared with ranks of godfathers
609
58.8
10.3
24
6.9
9
66.7
0
22.2
11.1
9.4
0.3
81.7
8.6
900
53.3
0.7
41.9
4.1
7
57.1
28.6
14.3
0
6.4
4
83.1
6.5
7,084
46.6
10.6
38.5
4.3
330
66.4
16.4
11.5
5.8
0
0.9
97.2
1.9
555
9.2
1.6
88.7
0.5
40
25
7.50
67.5
0
21.4
8.7
69.9
0
6,682
75.6
7.7
16.7
0
55
78.2
10.9
10.9
0
2.3
0.3
97.1
0.3
2,064
43.7
3.1
53
0.3
86
58.1
3.5
38.4
0
Masters (%)
Clerics (%)
13.1
Untitled (%)
Seigneurs (%)
Total godfathers
64.7
Clerics (%)
3.3
Masters (%)
Seigneurs (%)
Masters (%)
19
Untitled (%)
Untitled (%)
Ravenna 1555– 405 1557 Mirandola 1484– 1,380 1562 1600– 798 1609 Voghera 1534– 1,695 1562 1590– 645 1604
Foundlings
Clerics (%)
Cesena 1555– 153 1557
Children of untitled Seigneurs (%)
Total godfathers
Children of seigneurs Years
Total godfathers
Table 7.7
NewBorn babies and Spiritual Kinship
151
If the changes following the Council made a difference to discrimination against foundlings, did they ever achieve equal or almost equal status with legitimate children? Clearly, to answer this question the social rank of the godparents must also be taken into account. In Table 7.7 I use the usual division into classes, comparing foundlings with the children of seigneurs and the untitled. I only have at my disposal data for Mirandola and Voghera, which can be used to compare the situation before and after the Council of Trent. Even if we take the rank of godparents into consideration, children of seigneurs are still in a privileged position compared with those of the untitled, and towards the lowest levels of society the latter have an advantage over foundlings. Before the Council foundlings always had the highest percentage of untitled godparents and the lowest number of seigneur godparents. If we look at the children of seigneurs, the ranking is reversed. As for clerics, there are no appreciable differences in their presence at baptisms of infants belonging to the various classes. Variations, though, are to be found between communities; it will be recalled that not everywhere were clerics allowed to be godfathers. Interestingly, records do not show a surplus of godfathers from the clergy among foundlings. Presumably, the problem of how to provide them with spiritual kin was solved before the Council of Trent (while it was still possible to choose many) by decreasing the number of godfathers reserved for them. After the Council clerics tended to be excluded from godfatherhood almost everywhere in northern Italy (Alfani 2004b). The Council of Trent, by compelling parents to reduce the number of godparents, encouraged a trend towards polarization and verticalization in the godparenthood relationship, at least if we look at the lower classes. On the basis of data available for Voghera and Mirandola it would seem that foundlings were part of this process; for them the percentage of titled godparents increased towards the beginning of the seventeenth century from 11.5 to 67.5 per cent at Mirandola and from 10.9 to 38.4 per cent at Voghera. However, a similar increase is also to be found for the other infants; while an apparent improvement in the situation of the foundlings hides the fact that discrimination continued to exist. I have already said that it is especially relevant to establish if the foundlings’ godparents played an important role in giving support and patronage. For this reason it is helpful to examine closely who the foundlings’ spiritual kin were. The case of Mirandola is interesting. A nominative reconstruction has made it possible to ascertain that the godmothers of foundlings were mostly figlie dell’ospedale (‘daughters of the hospital’), that is, its former inmates, or, perhaps, girls that still resided or worked there. In the years 1550–1562, out of a total of 111 godmothers of foundlings, 43 (39 per cent) were registered as daughters of the hospital,
152
Fathers and Godfathers
or can be safely identified as such in other registrations.16 In the three years 1611–1613, 15 out of 16 godmothers can actually be identified in this category (94 per cent). It is probable that the data concerning the first sample are considerably compromised by the impossibility of identifying with any degree of certainty some of the godmothers really as ‘daughters of the hospital’ (I have opted to be extremely cautious about them) and the situation may have been much nearer to that of 1611–1613. The fact that most of the godmothers of the foundlings of Mirandola probably had first-hand experience of being abandoned leads us to reflect on the role assigned to them by this particular local custom, which I failed to find in any other of the communities I studied. Was it a purely symbolic role that perhaps indicated a specific event or was it a good omen for the newborn infant? Here we can imagine the case of a godmother who had been a former foundling but was now married and well integrated into society. Or did it prefigure a kind of wardship (not only spiritual), a concrete commitment by someone who had made a success of life and could take responsibility for infants who found themselves in the same kind of difficulties she had experienced? The fact that many of these former foundlings reappear as godmothers in many baptismal records leads us to suppose that the attention given to each godchild must have been scant, even though the high mortality rate typical of these hospitals prevented an excessive increase in the number of ‘spiritual offspring’. It is also possible that it was simply the assigning of a godmother to a young inmate of the hospital or a former inmate who had remained there as part of the personnel. The choice of this type of godmother could have been dictated by convenience and might have had no symbolic meaning, nor might there have been any intention of becoming a ward. I did not find in any other communities practices similar to that of Mirandola. It would appear that the godmothers of the foundlings, while normally of humble origin, were not directly connected to the hospitals. The case of Cesena is partly an exception, where a significant number of the godmothers of abandoned children (about 24 per cent) are registered as balia (‘wet nurse’); in one case the registers are more explicit and refer to a dona balia del’ospedale (‘woman wet nurse of the hospital’). It is likely that these were wet nurses who had been entrusted with the newborn infant, and on becoming spiritual mothers received a kind of mandate that 16 At that time and in the communities studied, abandoned infants were given only a first name, with no surname. The foundlings who appear as godparents in the parish registers that I have consulted are identified usually as ‘(name) son of the hospital’ and sometimes with a nickname (which could take the place of or be added to the name). In the case of girls, if they were married, they are identified as ‘wives of’ or they directly acquire their husband’s surname.
NewBorn babies and Spiritual Kinship
153
went beyond the pay connected to their profession. Possibly it was hoped that in this way these women could be encouraged to keep their promise to look after the needy child. It is obviously possible, though unlikely, that practices similar to those found at Mirandola and Cesena were also to be found in the other communities examined, but this does not emerge because the registrations are incomplete. What was the attitude governing the choice of godfathers? At Mirandola, where godmothers were often ‘daughters of the hospital’, I did not find any similar trend regarding the males of the spiritual kin. Out of all the 108 godfathers of the foundlings baptized between 1550 and 1562, only two (el zopo de Sancta Maria, i.e. ‘the lame from St. Mary’ and messer Giuseppe de Sancta Maria) were in any way connected to the hospital; none of the 16 godfathers of the abandoned children baptized between 1611 and 1613 had any connection. It is evident, then, that the custom of choosing godmothers from among former foundlings had no equivalent among the godfathers. Among the godfathers the name of a priest (Don Albertino Guagnolino) recurred most (seven times). He was perhaps a mere ‘filler’ at the ceremony or he had a role in organizing the first phase of the infant’s ‘career’ as a foundling. Other people are listed who cannot be distinguished from the mass of godfathers who recur at all the baptisms celebrated at Mirandola, while the total absence of important personages is to be noted, including the members of the local seigneurial family, the Picos, and their principal employees. Altogether, the data available for the foundlings enable us to affirm that their connections with the overall network of spiritual kinship ties was not as advantageous as the other children’s. They had fewer opportunities for contact, as they had fewer godparents, and these were of a lower quality and had less influence; at Mirandola the custom of giving them a godmother chosen from among the inmates or ex-inmates of the hospital was perhaps a sign of social stigma. A less effective integration into the network of relationships based on spiritual kinship meant having less access to both non-material and material resources during their life. Without doubt, whatever the intention of those who took responsibility for the foundlings, as far as access to godparenthood was concerned they found themselves on the lowest rungs of the ladder of a hypothetical hierarchy of privilege. Disadvantaged at birth, abandoned infants and the illegitimate in general were also unfortunate at their ‘spiritual rebirth’ within the community. In proposing a hierarchy of privilege, it is useful to recapitulate what has emerged so far. Going from the most to the least privileged positions we find:
154 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Fathers and Godfathers
the firstborn male; the firstborn female; sons; daughters; illegitimate children; foundlings.
In part this hierarchy reflects well-known positions of privilege: in particular for the firstborn children in comparison with their siblings; legitimate children compared with illegitimate; infants in the care of parents and relations vis-à-vis foundlings.17 However, if we look closely at the measure of the privilege granted to each, it emerges that a traditionally privileged category, the male descendants, compared with their female counterparts, did not occupy a superior position. The partially counter-intuitive nature of the hierarchy of privilege proposed here derives from the presence of both certain and uncertain elements. When it was possible to know exactly the personal details of the infant, as with order of birth and legitimacy, the attribution of godparents followed the logic of the usual favours accorded in the society of the ancien régime. Where there was uncertainty (the sex of the infant, unknown up to shortly before the baptism), the details of the ‘strategies of godparenthood’ were made, perforce, blindly, and the limited differences found between the two sexes correspond to the limited room for manoeuvre enjoyed by the parents of the baptized to find in extremis an answer to what they had planned. The link between the characteristics ascribed to the infant and the trend in the provision of spiritual kin will be of help in the next and following chapters in analysing the strategies used in the selection of godparents before and after the Council of Trent.
17
Lucienne Hubler (1992) studied the case of Vallorbe, in the Vaud region in Switzerland, and has found that between the sixteenth and eighteenth centuries illegitimate children were not the only ones to be discriminated against. There was discrimination also in the case of those newborn children who, because of their weak state of health when they came into the world, were feared to be likely to die soon after baptism and on whom it was therefore useless to ‘waste’ prestigious godparents. My data do not allow me to investigate this form of discrimination.
CHAPTER 8
Godfathers and Godmothers: The Case of Ivrea So far I have analysed godparenthood from the point of view of fathers of newborn babies presented at baptism. I asked how many godfathers and godmothers the fathers chose, from what strata of society they selected them and how far the parents’ choices were affected by the change in legislation and the personal details of each child. In my analysis godparents have been treated as passive subjects, from time to time chosen either to take part in baptismal ceremonies or excluded from them. Only fleetingly have I mentioned that the children’s parents not only had to make a choice but also had to obtain the consent of those selected as godparents; this consent could be refused, or if the request was too insistent it could be judged inappropriate. Consequently, the different provision of spiritual kin for infants according to their sex, order of birth and different legal conditions can be explained as part of a wise long-term strategy designed not only to protect the infants themselves, but also and, above all, to maximize the benefits that could accrue from the comparatico relationship. The time has come to consider godparenthood from the point of view of the godparents themselves. Who were they? What were their obligations towards their godchildren and their compari? If they had obligations, why did they agree to undertake them? Did they themselves have an interest in establishing a comparatico relationship and if so, is it possible to identify strategies or ‘careers’ in godparenthood? To some of these questions I have already partly supplied answers. For example, it is clear that as comparatico was a symmetrical relationship, the godfather’s interests in forming the relationship partially overlapped those of the father of the baptized – ‘partially’ because ‘who chose whom’ is crucial. The change in perspective, however, will enable us to extend the discussion on issues already dealt with, and to tackle some completely new ones. In the next chapter, having examined the sensitive question of the specific characteristics of godparenthood as an instrument of social alliance, I will put together the two perspectives (the father’s and the godfather’s), showing how the combination of the motivations and aspirations of parties with quite different characteristics was realized and what the results were.
156
Fathers and Godfathers
The move from fathers to godfathers as the object of our study is not a mere change in perspective; we have to resort to different methods and techniques. It is no longer sufficient to limit ourselves to considering nonnominative data such as the number of godfathers and godmothers and their social rank. In order to follow a godfather in his ‘career’, in other words through the course of his life from the time when his willingness to take part in baptisms is confirmed, it is necessary to be able to use nominative data that allow us to establish links between different baptismal registrations. However, to have at our disposal suitable information to reconstruct the parties’ motivations, sources other than baptismal registers have to be taken into consideration. Nominative techniques of this kind require a considerable quantity of data and involve significant problems in both their transcription and their elaboration. For this reason, I will concentrate on one case, Ivrea, for which I have set up an ample prosopographic database, which I have called Eporedia (the Latin name for Ivrea). This has, at the moment, about 36,000 nominative registrations. I will not go into details here of the characteristics of the database, nor into the techniques of the nominative analysis used. I will merely note that I constructed Eporedia using disparate sources (baptismal and marriage registers, property tax registers (estimi), notary deeds, censuses), with the main intention of studying relationships of spiritual kinship and other weak relationships, such as between neighbours and between bridal couples and the witnesses to marriages. To obtain a comparison with Ivrea, I also constructed a prosopographic database for Azeglio, a small village in the countryside near Ivrea. This second database includes only baptismal registrations, and covers the years 1543–1599. The 1,681 baptisms of this period were attended by altogether 2,848 godfathers and 2,269 godmothers. The comparison between the city and the adjacent village makes it possible to enhance the investigation by highlighting eventual differences in the models of godparenthood (before the Council of Trent both communities adopted type 1 model, the pure multi-godfather). These differences can be attributed to differences in social, economic and environmental conditions. A thorough analysis also requires a better knowledge of the context. So, to begin, I will give some information about Ivrea, paying particular attention to the economic and social situation of the town in the sixteenth century, circumstances that were closely linked to the events in which it was an important player.
About the prosopographic approach, see Stone 1971, 1981. See Alfani 2004a.
Godfathers and Godmothers
157
Ivrea is situated in north-west Piedmont on the banks of the River Dora Baltea, where the Aosta Valley joins the plain. Its geographical position was a key feature in the birth and development of the city, which since Roman times had been an important junction of highways and commercial routes, and was the head of a network of roads that communicated with Rhaetia and Gaul. During the Middle Ages goods in transit from one side of the Alps to the other had to pass through Ivrea, and on these the local government could levy tolls. The city’s favoured position also boosted local productive activities (Tafel 1974). Ivrea passed into the hands of the Dukes of Savoy in 1313, which marked the beginning of a new period in the history of the city, and the end of the rule of the bishops. Among the Savoy possessions, Ivrea maintained its importance and around 1377 had an estimated population of 5,300. It was one of the largest towns in the Duchy (Beloch 1994, p. 578) and became a stronghold of great strategic importance in the context of the sixteenth-century struggles between Francis I and Charles V for domination over Italy, as in the wars of the next two centuries. The estimates quoted by Karl Julius Beloch (1994) suggest that the population in 1571 amounted to only 3,031 inhabitants, which by 1612 had increased to 4,467. The data obtained from the baptismal registers also confirm that in the sixteenth century population growth came to a halt (Alfani 2003b). The reason for this crisis, from which it seems Ivrea was unable to recover, can be traced to the so-called ‘Wars of Italy’, when the French and the Spanish fought for supremacy over the Italian peninsula. The first phase of the war, up until the Peace of Cambrai in 1529, did not touch Ivrea. The city was first occupied in 1535 when, with a renewed outbreak of hostilities, the city surrendered to the French, who were advancing to take possession of the Duchy of Milan. The Emperor, Charles V, reacted by taking the war directly into France, forcing the French to suspend their advance and to abandon some of their positions. Among others they withdrew from Ivrea, which was then occupied for many years by the Spanish, as allies of the Dukes of Savoy. In 1544, the French returned and stormed the city, which, nevertheless, valiantly defended itse