Fashion Statements
This page intentionally left blank
Fashion Statements On Style, Appearance, and Reality
Edited ...
149 downloads
2383 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Fashion Statements
This page intentionally left blank
Fashion Statements On Style, Appearance, and Reality
Edited by Ron Scapp and Brian Seitz
FASHION STATEMENTS
Copyright © Ron Scapp and Brian Seitz, 2010. All rights reserved. First published in 2010 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN® in the United States—a division of St. Martin’s Press LLC, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, NY 10010. Where this book is distributed in the UK, Europe and the rest of the world, this is by Palgrave Macmillan, a division of Macmillan Publishers Limited, registered in England, company number 785998, of Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS. Palgrave Macmillan is the global academic imprint of the above companies and has companies and representatives throughout the world. Palgrave® and Macmillan® are registered trademarks in the United States, the United Kingdom, Europe and other countries. ISBN: 978–0–230–10542–3 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Fashion statements : on style, appearance, and reality / edited by Ron Scapp and Brian Seitz. p. cm. ISBN 978–0–230–10542–3 (alk. paper) 1. Fashion design. 2. Fashion—Philosophy. I. Scapp, Ron, 1955– II. Seitz, Brian, 1954– TT507.F35457 2010 746.99201—dc22
2010018766
A catalogue record of the book is available from the British Library. Design by Newgen Imaging Systems (P) Ltd., Chennai, India. First edition: December 2010 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Printed in the United States of America.
CON T E N T S
Introduction: Just Looks Ron Scapp and Brian Seitz
1
Part 1 New Look One
Two
You Cannes Come In Here Dressed Like That: A True Story in Two Shoes Erin Norris
11
The Head Monkey at Paris: Henry David Thoreau on Fashion David Farrell Krell
17
Three
Fashion Statements: Communication and Culture Malcolm Barnard
Four
Tech Savvy: Technology as the New Fashion Statement Ava Chin
23
35
Five
Fleshing It Out: The Tyranny of the A-Line Skirt bell hooks
43
Six
Osh Kosh B’Gosh Mary O’Donoghue
47
Seven
The Fungi Dress—A Living Garment: Interview with Donna Franklin ( July 2005) Shannon Bell
49
Victimless Leather—A Prototype of Stitch-less Jacket grown in a Technoscientific “Body” Shannon Bell
57
Eight
vi
Contents
Nine
Is Clothing Art? Jeff Weinstein
69
Ten
Fashion Advice from the Anti-Christ Lydia Hartunian
73
Eleven
Puro High Life Maythee Rojas
81
Twelve
Irony Killed by the Ironic T-shirt and the True Religion of the American Jean Anne O’Neil
Thirteen
Jackie O., Or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love My Chanel Ellen Fridland and Andrew Porter
89
101
Fourteen
The Hat’s the Thing Johanna Wagner
Fifteen
’Pod Peeps: Why the iPod and Other Gadgets Are Fashion Staples in the ’Hood Lynne d Johnson
119
Dressed to Kill: Or, Women’s Right to Bare Arms Kelly Oliver
127
Sixteen
117
Seventeen The Naked Truth of Antifashion Philosophy Nickolas Pappas
143
Eighteen
Vivienne Westwood: Keeping Critique Alive Sinéad Murphy
159
Nineteen
Fashion at a Glance Edward S. Casey
171
Part 2 Retro Look Twenty
Plato’s Greater Hippias Translated by Albert A. Anderson
183
Contributor Biographies
213
Index
219
I N T RODUC T ION
Just Looks Ron Scap p and B rian S e itz
Sometimes the way things look is just the way things are. Sometimes looks don’t count for much, but sometimes the way a thing or a person looks accounts for just about everything. Sometimes looks are utterly unique, sometimes not—think here of the distinction between fashion and style, not to mention the complicated, if somewhat arbitrary, split between chic and hip? Sometimes, ironically, “tradition” itself is fashionable, that is, of the moment: on the streets of London and Paris, for example, one observes not only vogues for traditional bourgeoisie clothes but also second- and third-generation Anglo-Pakistani and Franco-Algerian youth who were raised in contemporary households but have adopted, with a certain self-conscious swagger, the garb of “traditional” Islam. * *
*
What is the difference or connection between fashion designed and fashion worn? What is fashion? Or more precisely, to ask an old question, what is “it” all about? Nothing relative in our opinion; no so-called social constructs at work here. Ontological by design, maybe fashion is simply one way that selfconsciousness addresses or manifests itself, particularly in the modern period.1 But in recent years self-consciousness has acquired a wildly accelerated and fetishistic profile, one draped, as it were, on the glossy armature that fashion displays: not just bodies but billboards, magazines,
2
Ron Scapp and Brian Seitz
reality TV, films, and others—an entire system, one might say, reinforced and shadowed by the ever increasing legitimacy of popular culture as a domain for serious theoretical investigation and philosophical consideration. Of obvious note, for example, are Gilles Lipovetsky’s The Empire of Fashion, Lars Svendsen’s Fashion: A Philosophy, Malcolm Barnard’s Fashion as Communication,2 and then the staggering array of books published by Valerie Steele alone!3 No longer, for instance, do men and women simply admire, buy, and wear suits, but theoreticians (both men and women) write books about suits,4 and analyses of those who bought them. Meanwhile, just as academia takes up fashion (“fashion studies”), its well-worn disciplines get transformed into brand names for fashion products: Philosophy, Theory, and Anthropologie. No longer do corporations simply market fashion products; they now generate high-profile controversies with their marketing designs rather than the designs of their product. Stated differently, “branding” circumnavigates and simultaneously bridges what was once the difference between marketing and the product, the difference, that is, between showing and wearing. Top female fashion models—supermodels—have been associated with certain looks and have held celebrity status for some time (Twiggy was the “original” waif ). But now there are entire magazines devoted to the models themselves, a celebration not just of what is being worn on the runways, but of the individuals who wear what is being worn. And who in some cases in fact get worn out: career casualties—wearing thin, here, is not just an expression but a state of being. For example, take Kate Moss, who’s had her episodes and recoveries, and yet who now fronts her own collection at Topshop. Here, where the individuality on display in magazines is supposed to really matter, it appears that at the height of fashion, individuality can paradoxically be produced and reproduced ad nauseum and, therefore, erased at the very moment of its appearance. This wildly ambiguous repetition and erasure occurs from the standpoint of the fashion follower as well as of the model whose body gets overexposed (a body that is by definition always apparently just so). There’s Top Model (published by Elle), but then there’s also America’s Next Top Model (hosted by the “fierce” Tyra Banks), and BBC3’s Missing Top Model, a show in which disabled women compete with ambitions of glamor. Neither of these is as interesting as Project Runway, where the focus is on the drama and melodrama of creation. Then, of course, there is the plethora of films about fashion, from The Devil Wears Prada to Valentino: The Last
Just Looks
3
Emperor and The September Issue, not to mention the now historically and stylistically trailblazing Unzipped. In the backdrop of this ubiquitous dynamic, one of the fundamental tensions of fashion is generated by the paradox encased in two contrary yet intimately related desires: the will to look special—unique—and the need to look special in a recognizably attractive way (i.e., affirmed as accepted). Or at least this is the case for anyone with fashion anxieties (which we understand, by definition, cannot be universal), and this is a universal fashion conf lict. While designers endeavor to churn out a “look” if not a brand, they themselves will seldom be caught dead (Alexander McQueen notwithstanding) wearing anything a civilian might be able to identify; they want to represent themselves as individuals, a dream ideal of singularity being Adele’s gold dress in Gustav Klimt’s “Portrait of Adele Bloch-Bauer” (1907). Fashion, of course, continues to ref lect and project a broad range of social values—it ref lects and signals, in our research-driven opinion, the sum total of the aesthetics of social and existential identity: that is, of power, of class, gender, racial and ethnic affiliation, not to mention sex per se. Put another way, fashion ref lects all of work and play, what for many amounts to acts of being dressed down or, preferably, of dressing up. It also seems increasingly more and more about itself, just itself. On one level, it is not “about” anything other than what it is. And yet, insofar as it clings to the surfaces of life, fashion is by necessity about everything else. In a word—and words are cover—fashion pretty much covers everything. In fact, for some, fashion might be everything, pure and simple. Whatever it is, fashion is not a metonym, but the thing itself. It is, after all, the way things look and get looked at, the way things appear. As the phenomenologist Edmund Husserl, bolstered by Maurice Merleau-Ponty might put it, we gaze at “the things themselves” precisely because there is nothing else (thanks to Jean-Paul Sartre). Long before phenomenology made its splash and became fashionable, the ridiculously mustachioed Nietzsche eviscerated the opposition between appearance and reality, and there we still are, mask to masks, garment to naked garments (and bodies). Our central philosophical axiom here is that the literal-mindedness of that time-honored opposition between reality and appearance—a product of a confused fantasy—is readily exposed by fashion, itself a product of the play of reality and appearance. To illustrate, consider the following: there was once a cocaine distributor who sometimes wore a fine Italian suit and tied his long hair
4
Ron Scapp and Brian Seitz
neatly back. When asked about this lifestyle choice, the smartly clad salesman replied, “Hey, I walk into a bank and I wear my Metallica t-shirt, I look like a drug dealer but if I wear a suit, I instantly become a citizen.” No one asked whether he was familiar with Machiavelli’s dictum that “. . . A prudent man must always follow in the footsteps of great men and imitate those who have been outstanding.”5 Appear “great,” and it seems that one will be perceived as great: appearances are sometimes the risky armature of effective reality, which runs just as slim as it runs deep. For many contemporary philosophers, “Is that really who you are?” becomes an irrelevant or imprecise metaphysical question—but in the domain of fashion, that same question becomes a profound assertion of one’s state of being: “That’s so you!” Thankfully, some philosophers still see this (and for the record, philosophers tend to dress better than they once did). From modest attempts at being presentable to extravagant endeavors of self-expression cast as style, fashion is thus perhaps the paradigmatic venue by and through which some thing becomes something noticeable or worth noticing, not to mention worth recognizing. And then because of its apparent value—if worn properly—if, in fact, properly signifying, it is how someone becomes noticed by others. But what about being noticed by one’s self? Isn’t that also enmeshed in the dynamics of just being noticed—of possibly, for example, being visually consumed by an other with one eye in the ubiquitous mirror that is life? (Suddenly, Lacan can be understood as part of some full-scale fashion manifesto, maybe the mirror is all that remains of his arcane theoretic acrobatics.) Think for a moment of the convolutions associated with the thought that women “dress” for other women, which, according to some, is to say for themselves—“this is what distinguishes me.” This is why it is always disconcerting or even humiliating to see the woman across the room wearing the same dress as me(!), especially when it is an occasion fueled by fashion, as most are—the surface serving as subtext (vanity of vanities, life does not run very deep). Here, understood within the context of the power of self-presentation, the double appears in the form of replication, and consequently I am simultaneously no longer glowing but merely reilluminated and thus stripped of the visage’s value, and ultimately devastated by this particular fashion disaster. This dynamic is fascinating not only from an anthropological perspective but also reveals much about the constitution of modern subjectivity. Neither the role of recognition in Hegel’s Master/Slave “dialectic” nor the objectification of the Sartrean gaze comes close to capturing the nuances of self-constitution
Just Looks
5
and deconstruction embodied in the example of—the still historically valid, however embarrassing, phrase—“women’s relation to other women,” and then to themselves through their looks. Even if devoid of almost all of its old meaning, the exclamation “I could just die” still remains part of the currently vexed lexicon of and about women (there is no symmetrical male analogue for this experience, yet). At the moment of the judgment of the dead depicted toward the end of his Gorgias, Plato’s thinking naked. What if, as Nick Pappas intimates in this volume, the antifashion of nudity is dedicated fashion taken to the extreme, the contours of bare skin being the most advanced, seamless garment, animated truth? *
*
*
Fashion Statements is an attempt to address some of the peculiarities that unfold within the fabric of the domain of appearance(s). At least that’s how it looks to us, as fashionistas and observers of things as yet unaddressed, underdressed, or simply undressed. Take the split that has come to define “west coast versus east coast,” otherwise understood as Hollywood and the rest of the world; but the interesting thing about, for instance, New York City, San Francisco, and Austin is that it really doesn’t matter how you look. Or, rather, it totally matters how you look—a distinction apparently lost on those from Century City (the site where Hollywood produces itself, often in unfortunate garments posing as athletic). As noted here by Erin Norris, ultraurban indulgence means you can look however you want—you can get by with anything—however, you risk the chance that maybe no one will look at you, or see you the way you long to be seen; maybe you might as well be dead. Pushing further, people who neglect their looks are dead people anyway (professionally, romantically, and existentially, or so we are to infer from the numerous style commentators who make such pronouncements in print and on the air waves—radio and TV, and online) everyone is looking now. After all, looks are life. What else could there be? This question might not always have made sense, but it does now, and so does its opposite. That’s because we also know that looks can kill, and these days having killer looks has grown from idiosyncratic obsessions into a zillion dollar enterprise (the price of jeans and the hegemony of detail!). Thanks to, for example, Argentina and plastic surgery,6 individuality has been fashioned and refashioned, reborn and killed off—picture a planet on which everyone has the same, perfect nose, and no one dares
6
Ron Scapp and Brian Seitz
to look otherwise, or picture a cyberpunk world in which anyone with the desire can look exactly like a favored celebrity, an image of particularity imploding. The question remains: what else could there be, a nation of unstylish people? It’s possible but no longer plausible—the cosmetic knife has already cut that deep. Thanks to television and the Internet, teenagers in Havre, Montana, could pass in Seattle since they wear pretty much the same sneakers, jeans, t-shirts, and hairstyles as teens do in Atlanta or DC (but what does pretty much the same mean?). However, this observation does not work when it comes to Bozeman, since women there—nuanced fusion fashion style—tend to dress with more specific f lare than they do in northern Montana (the same hot jeans as in any big city yet details frequently include western belt buckles, located just above where it all counts). Women in cities generally and elsewhere (actually just about anywhere according to the fashion industry) dress well and look desirable, an observation that typically does not translate for most men—the patriarchal gaze remains short sighted and distorted, misogynistic and homophobic, redundant and reductive. All due respects to GQ, the gender asymmetry in play is stunning. On the one hand, we know a man who broke up with a woman because he didn’t like her taste in shoes. To us, this seems like a very sensible reason, since sensible shoes are not always that enticing. But at the same time—part of the same story—when a women’s footware designer says without hesitation that it doesn’t really matter that much what shoes men wear as long as they’re nice, the world might as well go into a tailspin, particularly since this position is premised implicitly on the condition that men must nevertheless have some sense of style. Yet let’s observe that aside from shifting lapels, buttons, vents, a narrow range of fabrics and the minor yet decisive drama associated with these variations, the basic man’s suit has hardly changed in one hundred and fifty years; check out the pinstripes on Deadwood; again, it’s all in the details, like everything else all there is, details and surfaces. And then when a man wears a tuxedo, he’s a double of every other man there, which no inspired woman ever wants to get caught being. This is one peculiarity of fashion: some are inclined to suggest that fashion has not always been around, that it’s a “modern” phenomenon. Of course, we get the necessary sophistication of that fancy theoretical move, but Foucault—we’re picturing his ghost talking—might oddly enough disagree since this perspective might implode insofar as it is itself ref lective of the necessity of change at the heart of fashion and snags not on a discourse but on a word, “fashion,” everyone always
Just Looks
7
having worn something whether they’re pondering it much or not— who has time?—and then on another word, “modern,” which might have appeared many times throughout history. One day people are thinking nothing of wearing sandals made from the skin of stingrays or ostrich by Tony Lamas, the next day Isaac Mizrahi is bitching, “What do they want, a longer short skirt or something? Sorry, we did that last year.”7 If fashion has become a form of self-consciousness, it was always synonymous with specific forms of subjectivity, even before it existed. As soon as people were wearing something, and they have in fact been wearing something ever since, they (we) could choose colors, furs, fabrics, decorations, that is, could recognize seasons (like forever!). The Inuit traditionally had no choice but to wear furs, but they did choose how to decorate and wear them. Then, on the other hand, regarding the distinction between spring and summer lines, Nadia Tarr (Butter by Nadia) says, “same fabric, different silhouette,” and if that’s not nuance who knows what is? *
*
*
Long ago, Hippias showed up at the Olympics clothed, so this story goes, in garments all made by his lovely self: his fabrics woven by him, his chiton stitched by him, his sandals threaded together by him, probably his jewelry too. This is a utopian vision, a beauty clothed by himself—beauty clothes itself—clothed to be seen by all others. They— the others—must have appreciated him since otherwise we wouldn’t today be imagining what he was wearing, wouldn’t be imagining the profile he was cutting that day, that time—not the fashion—a rare revelation of the universal, the glory of the individual busting via style and beauty through the fashion system, neither Elle nor Vogue, that unique note between the expected and the usual dressed best. At that moment, Hippias must have been more beautiful than anything or anyone. Nowadays, the beauties are all just looking at each other, some might call it thieving. But in Tokyo, Milan, Paris, St. Petersburg, London, New York, we have come to expect nothing less of beauty (of beauties). It is not a case of stealing per se, instead it is a question of just looking and of taking images away, knowing full well that others are doing the same. Whether it is stealing a look from across a table or the length of a room, the act of taking is a necessary dynamic: the fashion exchange, the glance. We are guilty of nothing more, and nothing less, than a prurient trespassing, an ocular retrieval of the very make up and fabric of another’s way of being, crossing the threshold.
8
Ron Scapp and Brian Seitz
So, how do we look today? By 1979 Dick Hebdige had already documented, in his now classic semiology, Subculture: The Meaning of Style,8 the sense in which punk had become “just a look,” one that endures in the twenty-first century in the form of business executives and newscasters globally sporting spiky haircuts—and yet the question remains. For some the question is never really answered—cannot be answered— the result of the very dynamic of fashion itself. We are left with little else than fashion statements. Thus these Fashion Statements are just one more look at the play between the historical interaction of appearance and reality, in this case of the codes and conventions that state just how things look. We hope that the essays included in Fashion Statements provide the reader with yet another look at an intriguing philosophical question, one that refuses to be merely looked at or framed by the traditional oppositions that have adorned the history of philosophy so far. Notes 1. The forms of the self-consciousness of fashion may change, but it should be noted that consciousness of fashion predates modernity and “modernism” by centuries (cf. Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics). 2. Gilles Lipovetsky, The Empire of Fashion: Dressing Modern Democracy, trans. Catherine Porter (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2002); Lars Svendsen, Fashion: A Philosophy (London: Reaktion Books, 2006), and Malcolm Barnard, Fashion as Communication (London: Routledge, 2002). 3. In addition to editing the journal, Fashion Theory, Steele has authored and edited, among other books, The Black Dress (New York: HarperCollins, 2007), The Red Dress (New York: Rizzoli, 2001), The Corset (Yale University Press, 2004), The Fan: Fashion and Feminity (New York: Rizzoli, 2003), with Jennifer Park, Gothic: Dark Glamour (Yale, 2008), Shoes: A Lexicon of Style (New York: Rizzoli, 2009), and the three-volume Encyclopedia of Clothing and Fashion (New York: Scribners, 2004). 4. Anne Hollander, Sex and Suits: The Evolution of Modern Dress (Tokyo and New York: Kodansha Globe, 1995). 5. Niccolò Machiavelli, The Prince, trans. George Bull (New York: Penguin Books, 1982), 9. Cf. also, Nicholas Antongiavanni, The Suit: A Machiavellian Approach to Men’s Style (HarperBusiness, 2006). 6. Argentina has the highest per capita rate of cosmetic surgery. 7. Douglas Keeve, dir. Unzipped (1995). 8. Dick Hebdige, Subculture: The Meaning of Style (London: Routledge, 1981).
PA RT
1
New Look
This page intentionally left blank
CH A P T E R
ON E
You Cannes Come In Here Dressed Like That: A True Story in Two Shoes Erin Norris
I Am a Grown Woman, I Cannes Wear What I Want (Ass to crotch zippered leather pants, wife beater, gold shoes, usually.) New York Fucking City. A place where you can follow your own rules and dress like a fool if you so choose. You can wear last week’s threads with a maxi pad on your head and someone might even press a dollar in your palm for doing so. You can choose to pick from fashion magazines or wear whatever happens to be on top of the clean pile. I have never subscribed to the tribe mentality nor did it have anything to do with the nonchalance that comes with every bag of heroin—but it was exactly that attitude that got me a lead role in Amir Naderi’s film “A,B,C . . . Manhattan” and into the 1997 Cannes Film Festival where my lifelong indifference toward fashion was forever sewn up in one red carpet moment. Nice Customs (See-thru child size sleeveless thermal shirt and my most washed pair of jeans and rotten Converse.) I arrived at the Nice airport alone and was beginning to feel the effects of having snorted my last bag of dope in the taxi en route to JFK.
12
Erin Norris
Copious amounts of airplane booze and an attempt to nap seemed like the only way to forget I would be more than a casual observer in a living edition of Entertainment Tonight. Upon arriving in Nice, I was told I would be picked up upon arrival but was unaware that I was to be whisked away in the offical car of the 1997 Cannes Film Festival; a gold Mercedes Benz, festooned with f lags and a sharply dressed man servant. I, on the other hand, was in my junkie finest: an airplane ride approved threadbare number begging to be put out of its misery. A garish purple hickey and a halo of filth were my only accessories unwittingly jazzing up my Alphabet City Do-I-reallylook-like-I-give-a-fuck?-ness. I needed drugs. Pronto. Along with the f luke of having snagged a lead role in one of the f licks being shown, I was given a few dirty glances but full clearance to slip through customs without a pat down or check. Had I known of this courtesy extended to my decrepit thespian corpse, I certainly would have taken full advantage of being my own mule, ensuring the ensuing big tit comedy of the Cote d’Azur is painless and funny for the full ten days. It was anything but. Croissants and Blisters (One piece tea stained catsuit, most debilitating leopard print heels.) Flaky and painful are two choice words to describe the entire Festival du Cannes. The producers procured us a charming villa atop a hill just about a hair too far from the Croisette where all the action was to take place. We were a dirty dozen of East Village denizens thus taking cars like the A-listers was out of the question and, since you couldn’t get near the center with one, entirely impractical. So we walked. Down the hill, up the hill—dressed to the nines. For. Every. Function. Since the “secretary on the run” look was one I could never work, or work out, I wore heels (strappy ones) and boots (tall ones) and shoes (hurty ones). All crowd pleasers but foot squeezers and this sister got blisters. Agony was my passenger on a torturous ride to Crippledom via Hobbleville. It was bad enough I had to “look presentable” every waking minute but I wasn’t sure how much more I could take before my feet gave out. Hmmm. A little hitlet of dope, the pain would vanish. Scoring was just not going to happen as I was the only junkie in the bunch and I had to figure out how I was going to make it to our premiere a couple more painful days away.
A True Story in Two Shoes
13
A Leg and an Armani (Two piece midriff bearing brown number with 8 feet of straps to tie any which way and beige ankle boots.) I decided to check out the fashion emporiums dominating the High Street. Armed only with a barf bag, some credit cards and not much cash, I hobbled along in search of a shoe of some sort that would allow me to walk, not crawl le carpet rouge. I needed something that would strategically slip around the network of raw skin and pus bubbles. Since my once f lawless feet now resembled a topographical map of Good Fucking Luck, bejeweled strappy numbers would leave the crowd horrified, wanting more skin coverage, not less for once. I was beginning to think I was destined to crawl, or crawl under a rock with withdrawal symptoms and skip the whole premiere pomp and circumstance when a wedged angel in pale yellow silk beamed from a low plexi shelf in some nondescript shop. Like that moment out of Cinderella, one slip on and magic happened—except “happily ever after” was more like not “hobble for an hour” in my reality. The slope of this Armani wedge shoe felt gentle and stable, the front strap generous enough to cover bandages, yet soft enough to not chafe any more and apparently Courtney Love had a pair in black, I was told, BFD. Yes, this would work indeed not because of Ms. Love but solely because of the love they showed my grieving peds. Even if they cost 700 fucking dollars. This was an indie film, there was no money in it for me ever but thankfully my Publicist/ dominatrix careers back home allowed me not to care (too much) and plunk down the plastic, even going for the matching bag for an additional 400 fucking dollars. And I wore them out the store. Clothes Make the Man? I Beg to Differ, Mr. Twain, Unless You Are a Celebrity (“Floating” silver velvet dress with fishing line strap by Elisa Jiminez, Yellow silk Armani wedge sandals.) The day of our premiere, the villa was all atwitter with nerves; clothes being put on, clothes being discarded. Some had planned for days what they would be wearing, others panicked and got testy with each other. I couldn’t give a shit. There were only a couple of options left that I had not worn yet that did not reek of yesterday’s boulliabaisse and a night inhaling other peoples’ Galoises. Being a realist, I also knew that this fashion
14
Erin Norris
thing really didn’t matter—well, at least not to me. Nicole Kidmans we were not, so why kid ourselves like anyone really cares. No one was being hounded by the fashion houses, bribed to wear the latest Dolce or Prada. Not one stylist even knew we existed. Just put something on to cover up your frank and beans and back hair and let’s get a move on. I quietly slipped into my little number wishing this would all be over with already. The easy frock was made for me, on me, by a designer friend who hooked me up with everything nice I had for the week. She knew I preferred comfort over style but she excelled in both and happened to give me a great deal on her handiwork as well, so she won. We were allowed to ride in cars for this evening’s event. A good thing, since there would still be time for the shoes to begin to fail me if we were forced to walk to our gala affair. The crowds would part as our f lagged car came squeezing through to the theater. Onlookers banged on the cars quickly looking away heartbroken as we were most definitely not Catherine Deneuve, Ewan MacGregor, or some other actual person to them. I couldn’t resist giving the finger ever other block. I cackled in the absurdity if it all and I forgot for a moment how much I had been shivering from “the sickness.” Fuck tha (Fashion)Police (Same outfit as above.) We arrive at our corral in front of the theater and are told to wait. Apparently at this point in the carpet hoo-ha, even the Catherine Deneuves and the Ewan MacGregors of the world are told to wait as well. My we have a lot in common! I am getting antsy wondering what the big deal is all about but apparently there is something called “red carpet control,” where, like an enema, the intake f low is regulated, lest too many stars f low in at once. They need to savor their moments, smile for the camera, give the obligatory coy pose, the show of the freebie gown and perhaps a practiced wave before being ushered in by their “people.” This takes time. My feet were beginning to hurt from simply being told to wait on them for too long and I just wanted in so I could sit and shiver in peace. Finally I get closer to Mr. In Control, an overzealous soldier wannabe outfitted more like a crossing guard than a production assistant. As I approach the carpet’s edge, I am given a f lick of a white gloved hand. Now “Billie Jean” is not my lover nor booming out of the ether, and I understand this sign to be something more “Stop in the Name of I Have a Problem with the Likes of You” than
A True Story in Two Shoes
15
“Love.” The Carpet Keeper mutters something in French, which I do not understand. Our French-speaking assistant director at my side quietly leans over and informs me that this man, outfitted from a children’s book, has a problem with my shoes and would prefer if I enter around the side. She explains to him that I have a lead role in the film and we all go in together. If the side door were right there and saved me footsteps, I would gladly have done so even if it meant giving in to some warped Cannes version of “authority.” But it was further, much further and fuck it, I’ve come this far, I am pressing on. He gives me a tooth sucking “tsk” and a wag of his finger and points to my selection of footwear. Realizing what this crap town had been all about all week long, I reached down and f licked the shoe off my foot, thrusting it label up into his f lared nostrils, screaming, “They’re fucking armani, asshole!” Convinced that I was going to get beaten with a baguette and escorted to the Hospital for Fashion Faux Pas for my outburst, I was shocked when the reaction was, “Oh, Pardon, Pardon,” as the crossing guard bowed and gestured his gloved hand for me to go right ahead and enjoy my subtitled film. Hastily putting the shoe back on, ripping open earlier wounds, I held my head high (and wished I were) and only slightly hobbled up the red carpet toward our first viewing of our film. Back in the New York Groove (Ass to crotch zippered camouflage pants, wife beater, yellow Armani wedges.) Upon returning home, everyone expected stories of fabulousness, celebrity sightings and shaggings. I could only show them my battle scars on my feet and sum it up with my run in with the Fashion Police. That’s all it was. From time to time, I run into our director, Amir, and being a man in a hurry all of the time, he will rush past me miming a shoe being thrust my way and in his adorable broken English will scream “Fucking Armani!” as he darts off in his comfortable running sneakers looking for his next story. In Cannes, fashion was the law but I fought it with the help of two yellow shoes and continued to proudly wear my heroic foot soldiers here until they died a noble death.
This page intentionally left blank
CH A P T E R
T WO
The Head Monkey at Paris: Henry David Thoreau on Fashion Davi d Farre l l K re l l
Thoreau’s critique of fashion has always been one of my favorite parts of the Walden.1 Beware of all enterprises that require new clothes! he admonishes, and I have always responded fervently to his admonition—by looking like a slob. Correction: philosopher. Yet something has happened to me, or several things. For one, I fell in love with someone who cared about clothes and had exquisite style and taste. She determined to dress me up and take me out. Had I persisted in my slovenliness, she would have dressed me down. The terrible thing is that I myself began to notice what people were wearing, and now I am ashamed. Why? Puritanism. I was raised to feel contempt for fashion, and whereas other portions of the Puritan program did not take with me that one did. Puritanism and an undeniable sexism. I always felt that a man who paid attention to fashion wasn’t much of one. With a woman it was different, of course: a woman could have style—indeed, was expected to have style—along with brains. A woman could have and be everything; indeed, she was expected to be and have it all. She was both object and subject—the philosopher’s dream, if the philosopher was a guy. That has not changed much, in spite of feminism. Yet the number of men who have aesthetic intelligence is growing, an intelligence that shapes their sense of beauty and the beauty of their senses. I fear I will never be one of them. The Puritans will laugh over my grave and try to reclaim all of me, but I’ll see to it I’m laid out in FCUK and not in Land’s End, just to give them a hard time. Do clothes
18
David Farrell Krell
make the man? Let us not believe this cliché of the name-designers who profit by it. Yet it seems certain that the power of fashion runs more than skin deep. The suspicions that Henry and I raise against fashion are, therefore, themselves suspect. It is terrible for me nevertheless to have to live in the Epoch of Designer Clothing, in which people feel proud to be wearing a logo on their shirt, granting free advertising to companies that can afford to pay for it. The designer-dressed might as well be wearing sandwich boards. I realize, of course, that it is all about self-advertisement. Hi, I’m wearing a Ralph Lauren Polo Shirt, as you can plainly see by the snobby logo. That’s because I make a lot of money and could play polo if I wanted to and if I could stay on the horse. If you could see my horrid Hilfiger underwear you’d be even more impressed, if only by the logo and the near-miss Mondrian. The long and short of it is that I am entirely ambivalent about this thing called fashion. I am like Brian (not Brian Seitz, one of our two dashing editors, but the Brian who beans no surname, the unwitting founder or one of world’s great religions, Brianism) preaching about the lilies of the field and the birds of the air, suddenly undone by someone in the crowd. ’Ave the birds got jobs?! Leave ‘em alone! They’re pretty! What am I doing anyway, following an injunction of the gospel? It’s a serious breach of trust, an inconsistency. At all events I (finally!) reproduce the following Thoreauvian grump in full, savoring his manly contempt for fashion and wondering for my part whether my jeans are too baggy or not baggy enough, life is so perplexing: When I ask for a garment of a particular form, my tailoress tells me gravely, “They do not make them so now,” not emphasizing the “They” at all, as if she quoted an authority as impersonal as the Fates, and I find it difficult to get made what I want, simply because she cannot believe that I mean what I say, that I am so rash. When I hear this sentence, I am for a moment absorbed in thought, emphasizing to myself each word separately that I may come at the meaning of it, that I may find out by what degree of consanguinity They are related to me, and what authority they may have in an affair which affects me so nearly; and, finally, I
The Head Monkey at Paris
19
am inclined to answer her with equal mystery, and without any more emphasis of the “they,”—“It is true, they did not make them so recently, but they do now.” Of what use this measuring of me if she does not measure my character, but only the breadth of my shoulders, as it were a peg to hang the coat on? We worship not the Graces, nor the Parcae, but Fashion. She spins and weaves and cuts with full authority. The head monkey at Paris puts on a traveller’s cap, and all the monkeys in America do the same. (17) As a young man my sense of style was shaped by Heidegger’s indictment of the “They,” das Man, the neutral “one” in the expression “one dresses this way now.” In the room the women were coming and going, talking of Paloma Picasso, and it seemed to me essential to express my contempt for all of “Them.” We were all expressing contempt at that time; one simply did so, and that was all there was to it. They made me do it. I recently had occasion to look back into a book called Daimon Life: Heidegger and Life-Philosophy, which I wrote back in the early 1990s.2 To my astonishment, I found there the very passage from Thoreau that I have only now cited. I used it there to demonstrate two different paradoxes: the first, which is Heidegger’s own, is that even when we try to keep our distance from the “they-self ” we wind up being just like all the rest, inasmuch as each member of the “they-self ” is trying to achieve the identical independence; the second paradox, which is not Heidegger’s own but which recoils on him, is that whereas in the 1930s he was constantly bemoaning the vulgarity of pragmatic America, he seems in retrospect to have been closely allied with what one must recognize as puritanical America. Heidegger’s “hard and heavy” rhetoric sometimes seems as American as apple pie, if America is, as Freud famously called it, “God’s own country.” At all events, Daimon Life continues to quote Thoreau as follows: “I sometimes despair of getting any thing quite simple and honest done in this world by the help of men.” He is not being sexist in writing “men,” of course; the head monkey at Paris might readily be a female. Isn’t democracy grand? He continues: They would have to be passed through a powerful press first, to squeeze their old notions out of them, so that they would not soon get upon their legs again, and then there would be some one in the company with a maggot in his head, hatched from an egg deposited there nobody knows when, for not even fire kills these
20
David Farrell Krell
things, and you would have lost your labor. Nevertheless, we will not forget that some Egyptian wheat was handed down to us by a mummy. Thoreau’s turn at the end of this passage is surprising. It is as though the dormant yet fertile kernel of wheat cannot so readily be separated from the destructive maggot, or, rather, that the maggot cannot be extruded from the wheat. In other words, it is difficult to separate the wheat of fashion from the chaff of mere modishness. Heidegger has the same problem in his fundamental ontology of Dasein, even though Heideggerians are usually reluctant to talk about it. Everyone knows about the axis of “authenticity/inauthenticity” in Being and Time, perhaps better translated as “what is one’s own” versus “what is not one’s own.” The important thing about this distinction, however, is that Heidegger himself cannot sustain it: the “proper” and the “inappropriate” are always mixed together for human existence; Heidegger insists over and over again in Being and Time that his analysis of everydayness in the first division is essentially neutral, which is to say that the structures of everydayness are neither altogether appropriate nor entirely inappropriate. We can try as hard as we like to be “authentic,” but the fake will always be mixed in, and what is most our own will prove to be otherwise. This is bad news for ethicians and moralizers, but good news for the rest of us, at least when our Puritanism releases for an instant its stubborn hold. And yet I am assailed by doubts. For by now things with me have plunged to such a nadir that I find myself paying attention to fashion in shoes—the epitome of stupidity, inasmuch as all one needs is a pair of sturdy hiking boots with Vibram soles, boots that will not have been designed by Ralph, Oleg, Kenneth, or Coco. Yet the hard and heavy phrase epitome of stupidity and the catachresis with nadir stick in the throat of my designer pen: I’m growling “Vanity!” from the pulpit and secretly hoping that the head monkey at Paris will approve of my rags. And if I bristle at the thought of that secret hope, once again I hear a voice in the crowd. ’E’s ’avin’ a go at the flowers now! Leave ’em alone! They’re pretty! Notes 1. Henry David Thoreau, Walden, in Walden and Civil Disobedience: The Variorum Editions, ed. Walter Harding (New York: Washington Square Press, 1968), 1–252. Harding’s notes on the
The Head Monkey at Paris
21
text appear at 255–321. I cite Thoreau’s Walden by page numbers in parentheses in the body of my text. 2. D.F. Krell, Daimon Life: Heidegger and Life-Philosophy (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1992), 43–44, for this and the following, including the references to Heidegger’ Being and Time and his Marburg lecture courses.
This page intentionally left blank
CH A P T E R
T H R E E
Fashion Statements: Communication and Culture M alcol m Barnard
Introduction Modern, Western people are accustomed to the way in which the clothes they wear begin their lives as “trendy” or “stylish,” but then start to age, become “stale” and are no longer trendy or stylish. We are used to the idea that clothes come, or go, in and out of fashion and the English phrase “old hat” would appear to describe a well-understood drift from literal to metaphorical usage. Thus, fashion, the idea that what people wear may or may not be the current or latest style, is clearly understood in modern and Western cultures. Also, modern, Western people are familiar with the idea that the clothes they and others wear carry certain significance. Clothes are bought and worn according to the meaning we believe them to have, or the messages we believe them to send. A novelty tie or a strappy frock worn for an interview in the city, for example, “sends out all the wrong messages.” The English phrase again appears to give away an entire culture’s implicit understanding of fashion’s communicative function. Both fashion itself and the communicative function of fashion are perceived as being unproblematic and well-understood in modern Western cultures, as evidenced by the title of the current volume. However, while the conception of fashion as a temporal sequence of “looks” or styles that is taken for granted by certain cultures may
24
Malcolm Barnard
be relatively uncontroversial, the conceptions of meaning and communication that are presupposed in the notion that fashion or clothing are meaningful or communicative phenomena certainly are not. For example, presupposed in the apparently unproblematic and wellunderstood accounts of the sort of meaning that items of fashion and clothing possess is the idea that meaning is a message. Meaning here is conceived as the “sending out,” or expression, of a “message,” which is itself conceived as some form of inner mental content or statement. Similarly, presupposed in the above accounts of the sort of communication that fashion performs is the idea that communication is the conveying or transmission of that message from one place to another. This essay tries to define and explain the nature of fashion statements; it investigates the presuppositions of the conceptions of meaning and communication noted above, outlines what is problematic about them and attempts to suggest a more accurate and productive way of thinking about them. The essay is divided into four sections. The first section outlines a brief definition and explanation of fashion. In this section, fashion and clothing is defined and explained as meaningful and cultural phenomena. The second section considers the notion of meaning that is presupposed by many accounts of fashion and clothing. In this section, meaning is established as a profoundly cultural phenomenon. The third section explains the notion of communication. It argues that communication is not the sending/receiving of messages, but that it is the cultural construction of meaning and thereby identity. The fourth section takes two examples of fashion and clothing and shows how they may be explained in terms of meaning and communication. Fashion I am not proposing a particularly sophisticated, overly technical or calculatedly controversial definition of fashion in this section. However, even to follow Anne Hollander’s deceptively simple definition of fashion as what modern “Western” people wear1 is already to offer an allinclusive definition of fashion, which covers everything that people wear, not just that which is “up to the minute.” It is also to court challenges as to what is to count as “Western” and as “modern.” So, the definition of fashion offered here includes (but is not exhausted by), all instances of what people wear, from catwalk creations, through High Street and Outlet purchases, to police and military uniforms. And it
Fashion Statements
25
insists on both the modernity and “Westernity” of fashion. Indeed, the existence of fashion in a society may be a good test of whether that society is either modern or Western: a society in which there are not different classes, no social structure, and in which upward mobility in a class structure is neither possible nor desirable has no need of fashion and might reasonably be said to be neither modern nor Western. Though fashion may be about bodies, as Joanne Entwistle says,2 it is also, as Entwistle also says, about “fashioned” bodies. And by “fashioned” bodies, I understand produced, cultured bodies, because one of the meanings of fashion (as a verb) is “to make” or “to produce.” The fashioned body is, therefore, a made or produced body. To that extent, there can be no such thing as “the body”: the body is always already a constructed and meaningful body; it is a cultured or cultural body, because differently cultured bodies wear different fashions. Another way of putting this is to say that fashion is meaningful (as was said above), and, therefore, about communication. This is because saying that fashion is meaningful is to say that fashion is a cultural phenomenon. The reason for this, in turn, is that culture is about shared meanings and the communication and understanding of those meanings. Given this, and in the light of what Entwistle says about the fashioned body, we can say that differently cultured bodies communicate different things (meanings), by means of the different things (clothes, fashion) that they wear. Fashion has been established as being meaningful, communicative, and a profoundly cultural entity. Now this chapter explains; (1) what sort of meaning fashion communicates; (2) what sort of communication fashion is; and how fashion as meaningful communication constructs people as members, or nonmembers, of cultural groups because fashion is one of the ways in which people are constructed as members (and/or nonmembers) of cultural groups. The reference to culture is a significant part of the definition or explanation of what fashion is and that definition inevitably refers to culture. To move on to a light-hearted relief, the Roz Chast cartoon “The Girl with the Sensible Shoes” gives some idea of the sort of meanings that fashion does not communicate and illustrates one of the ways in which it does not communicate those meanings. Fashion statements are not like spoken statements, or the speech bubbles in cartoons, and they are not about such things as not forgetting to send your Aunt Hilda a thank-you note. Similarly, meanings are not “messages” in any simple sense and fashion does not communicate messages in terms of a “speaker/listener,” or “sender/receiver” model. These ideas are discussed in detail below.
26
Malcolm Barnard Meaning
What this section requires is a definition of meaning that will be of use in the explanation of fashion and communication. It also needs an account of meaning and communication that will perform the tasks demanded in the explanation and analysis of what has become known as visual culture. It must be said that the account of meaning to be proposed here cannot even pretend to be entirely uncontroversial. There are many people who would argue that it is not entirely convincing. However, I am trying to avoid an account of meaning where meaning is a function of either individual intention (what is going on in someone’s head) or of the item of clothing itself. In the first case meaning is something that is expressed and conveyed and in the second it is something like a natural or inherent property of the item of clothing itself (like color or texture) and neither can be supported. Basically, I have in mind Roland Barthes’ version of connotation, but without the sense that somewhere beneath connotation there is denotation. For Barthes, it will be recalled, denotation is the “literal” or “dictionary” definition of a word and connotation is the set of associations that accrue to it. Denotation can be correct or incorrect, precisely because it is thought of as being “literal” or “natural” in some way. Because it is “cultural” and dependent on an individual’s sociohistorical location, connotation does not admit of being correct or incorrect. This essay tries to make a case for meaning being like connotation because and insofar as Barthes’ version of connotation already refers to the work of culture. That is, meaning here is connotation “all the way down” and not “built” or “based” on anything that is not connotation. This conception of meaning is used because it already and explicitly depends upon culture: Barthes’ connotational meaning is explicitly the product of culture. Meaning on this account is a product of cultural beliefs and values, and different beliefs and values generate different meanings. In his famous account of the “Panzani” advertisement in “Rhetoric of the Image”3 Barthes identifies five connotational meanings, or “connotative signs” and he scrupulously explains each one in terms of the culturally specific knowledges (structures of ideas) needed to understand, or construct, those meanings. One, for example, is “Italianicity” and he says that, in order to be able to understand, or construct that meaning, one needs to be familiar with certain tourist stereotypes: members of a culture that has no tourist industry, or no stereotype of Italians, will not be able to understand that meaning. He also points out that Italians will also have a different take on the ad from non-Italians,
Fashion Statements
27
precisely because they are Italian: membership or nonmembership of the cultural group is here explicitly linked with the production of different meanings. On this account, then, meaning is a product of the interaction between the beliefs and values an individual holds as the member of a particular culture and some example of visual culture. In Barthes’ case, the example of visual culture is the “Panzani” ad and in our case it is fashion. Such an account of meaning is not inconsistent with other (cultural studies type) accounts of meaning in that meaning does not preexist the interaction between an individual member of a culture’s beliefs and values and the example of visual culture. Meaning is sometimes said to be a product either of the item in question or of individual intention: a tweedy jacket may be said to signify “rustic simplicity,” for example, or an individual may say they are wearing a shirt because it means something unique to them. But on this account, a piece of fashion or clothing is not meaningful in itself and a piece of fashion or clothing is not meaningful because of any individual intention. Of course, one may say that one is aware of, or indeed knows, the meaning an item of clothing has. But this formulation is surely a species of shorthand for saying that one knows the meaning an item of clothing has for, or within, a culture; it is, therefore, already to have interacted with that culture’s values and beliefs. So, shared meaning constructs one as member of cultural group. If one does not share the meaning, then one is not constructed as a member of that social group. If you do not share or understand the meaning, then you are not produced or reproduced as a member of the culture. Communication The model of communication that is adopted in this essay is essentially a semiological/cultural studies type one according to which communication is a negotiation of meaning through the interaction between items of visual culture and the values (beliefs and ideas) held by an individual as a member of a cultural group. It is also one with which those who believe that communication is expression, ref lection, or the sending and receiving of a message are likely to disagree. Fashion communication as expression is the idea that something going on inside someone’s head, individual intention, is somehow externalized and made present in a garment or an ensemble. It may also be the idea that entire cultures can express themselves in or through
28
Malcolm Barnard
what members wear. Joanne Entwistle, for example, says that clothes “can be expressive of identity.”4 She also says that clothing is “part of the expressive culture of a community.”5 Both individuals and cultural communities can use fashion to express or make externally visible what were “internal” and invisible ideas and beliefs. Fashion communication as ref lection is the idea that what people wear is a ref lection or mirroring of something else. That something else may be a society’s social or economic structure, or it may be a culture’s values, for example. On this model of communication, people may claim that Victorian women wear tight corsetry, voluminous bustles and tight-shouldered dresses because they are ref lecting their culture’s idea of women as weak and helpless. Other people may claim that upper-class Victorian women wear expensive dresses and their lower-class servants wear cheap dresses because they are ref lecting their society’s economic structure. However, the communication of gender in fashion is not the ref lection of something else. It is not, for example, the ref lection of a culture’s values, for example. The Victorian women are not ref lecting their culture’s view of them as weak, dependent, and immobile: they are weak, dependent, and immobile. Similarly, upper-class Victorian women are not ref lecting the economic structure: dress is one of the ways in which economic structure is produced and reproduced. On the sender/receiver model of communication, messages are encoded by a sender and sent, or transmitted through a channel to a decoder or receiver. Following this theory’s origins in telecommunications engineering, the paradigm case is that of telephony: the sender (encoder) is the speaking individual, the channel is the telephonic equipment and the receiver is the listener (decoder) on the end of the line. Should the message arrive at the receiver in a form other than that in which it was transmitted, communication theorists will speak of a communication problem or breakdown and appeal to concepts such as “noise” to explain the unexpected form. Insofar as most analysts seem to agree that fashion is not a language in any straightforward sense, they may be taken to agree that a simple version of the sender/receiver model cannot explain fashion. But it is not difficult to find people who are happy to assert that fashion and clothing are used to convey or “send messages.” Elizabeth Rouse, for example, uses this notion in her Understanding Fashion when she writes of fashion “conveying” an impression.6 And Eicher, Evenson, and Lutz suggest that “individuals often select items of dress because of the personal or public meaning that it conveys.” 7
Fashion Statements
29
There is another Roz Chast cartoon that explicitly mocks this conception of fashion communication, claiming to have “decoded” the “fashion statements of Rhonda Perlmutter III.” Fred Davis is more cautious and, while committed to the idea that fashion is some sort of communication, is wary of the idea that it is exactly like spoken or written language. Rather, he prefers to think of it in less “precise” terms, in terms of “aesthetics” or as being more like art or music.8 Such circumspection is to be distinguished from the approach of someone like Alison Lurie in The Language of Clothes, where she becomes so embroiled in a metaphor of clothing as a language that she takes the metaphor literally (if that is possible). I want to argue that if meaning is a cultural construction, in the manner of connotation, then it is not the sort of thing that can be ref lected, expressed, sent, received, conveyed, or transmitted, and communication cannot involve any of these things. So, I want to argue that communication through fashion is not ref lection, nor is it either individual or cultural expression. The points made above also suggest that we need to be a little careful with this notion of expression. This is because the notion of communication as expression involves the idea of simply moving something from “inside” someone’s head, or a cultural community’s “unconscious” (a meaning, intention, or value) to “outside.” Expression, that is, is a metaphor: it is a metaphor of conveying or transmitting something from one place to another. The problem here, of course, is that metaphor is itself a metaphor, and one that is dependent on the notion of “conveying” for any rhetorical power it possesses. The “meta” in “metaphor” means “beyond” or “over” and the “phor” means “to carry.” Communication as a conveying employs a transport metaphor, but metaphor is itself already a figurative use of the notion of transport; it is itself a transport metaphor. As a result, this essay suggests that there are problems involved in believing that meaning is expression and that communication is a transmitting or conveying of a meaning. The notion of meaning that is being followed in this essay suggests that meaning is constructed in the interaction between an individual’s values and beliefs (which they hold as a member of a culture) and the item of visual culture. If meaning works in this way, as an interaction, then it cannot simply be transported or conveyed in communication. Consequently, as the idea of expression uses a metaphor of transportation, neither cultures nor individuals can be said in any simple way to be “expressing” themselves through what is worn; it is more accurate to say that identity is being constructed and reproduced.
30
Malcolm Barnard
Finally, it is worth noting that there is one problem that is equally relevant to all the conceptions of communication discussed so far. It is that, according to the model of communication as conveying, something has to preexist the conveying or sending. As a passenger on a bus or train, for example, preexists their being conveyed by that train or bus, so meaning on this model preexists communication. Colin Campbell rightly and mercilessly takes issue with this model of communication in his essay “When te Meaning Is Not a Message: A Critique of the Consumption as Communication Thesis.”9 He is correct to critique the model of communication, but the notion of communication in or through fashion need not suppose that communication is the sending and receiving of a message. This essay is committed to arguing that communication through fashion is not a simple sending and receiving of messages. This is because meaning does not preexist the process of communication, the negotiation between an individual’s beliefs and ideas and the example of visual culture. And because meaning does not preexist the members of cultures who are communicating, communication cannot be the sending or receiving of a preexisting message. There is no meaning until the interaction between cultural values and items of fashion. This is why the argument is made here that fashion is not a vehicle for conveying messages. Indeed, in order for any of these phenomena (expression, conveying, or ref lection), to happen, it seems reasonable to suppose that there is something that exists prior to the expression, conveying, or ref lection of that thing. This is the origin of a major, if usually unacknowledged, difference between fashion theorists on these matters. There are those who believe either that something can meaningfully exist prior to representation or that something exists beyond representation and there are those who believe that there can be no such priority or beyond. For the former, such things as “the body,” or “individual intention” play the role of that which exists outside of, or prior to, representation. Taking this position, it is perfectly possible to say that something (a meaning), preexists the ref lection, conveying, or expression of that meaning. For the latter, such things as the body and individual intention literally make no sense unless they are represented. According to the latter position, it is impossible for meaning to preexist the process of communication. For what it is worth, I don’t think that there is a “beyond” to representation. I am with Derrida here: when he says that there is nothing outside the text,10 I take him to mean that, in order for anything to be meaningful, it must necessarily be represented. Similarly, I do not think that anything can preexist expression, or representation, even
Fashion Statements
31
in experience or spoken/thought language. This is a question raised, and some would say answered, by Wittgenstein, when he argues in his Philosophical Investigations11 that there are and can be no private languages. Communication, then, is either not-private (i.e., it is shareable) or it is not communication. Rather, on the account presented in this essay, communication is the negotiation of meaning: it is the result or product of the interaction between cultural values (ideas and beliefs) and the visual. Communication is also the process in which an individual is, or is not, constructed as a member of a cultural group. If I may argue by analogy in order to illustrate what I mean here, when I watch “Sex and the City” or the football on TV, the values and beliefs I hold as a result of my social and cultural positions as a white, middle-class European male generate the meanings of the programmes for me. Meaning is a product of the interaction between culture—cultural values, beliefs, and ideas—and the visual. The meanings that I construct are shared with other white, middle-class European males. We are likely to agree in our interpretation of the show, or the inestimable value of football on TV, for example. It is the sharing of the values (and thus the meanings) that makes us into an identifiable cultural group; it is this sharing, that is, that makes us into an “us.” Members of other cultural groups will construct the meanings differently. Non-European, Muslim, old, or working-class women, for example, will almost certainly construct entirely different meanings for “Sex and the City.” And this is because they will hold different beliefs and values. Those shared meanings are what construct and identify people as members of that group. Therefore, the meaning of items of fashion will be produced through the interaction between cultural values and ideas and the visual appearance of the items of fashion. Case Studies The first case study concerns what President Bush and Prime Minister Blair wore in a press photograph of the meeting of the Euro-Atlantic Partnership Council in June 2004 and the second concerns “hoodies,” short hooded jackets that have recently acquired demonic status in some parts of the British news media. In this photograph, Bush and Blair are wearing dark suits, light shirts, and red ties. Notwithstanding the fact that this picture has been chosen to support an argument, the case against either man being engaged in
32
Malcolm Barnard
any form of individualistic self-expression would appear already to be made. What is being claimed here is that neither man is sending a message, or using what they are wearing to convey a message. Both men know perfectly well some of the more dominant meanings that will be constructed by those viewing them and the photograph and they put together an outfit or a “look” accordingly. In the terms of the sender/ receiver model, this is effectively to suggest that the receiver is determining the message to some extent; it is an odd message that is constructed by the receiver, but that is what the proponents of the sender/ receiver model of communication are effectively suggesting. Both Bush and Blair already know that a dark suit, light shirt, and contrasting tie mean “middle class,” “serious,” “authoritative,” “businesslike,” and, for that matter, “masculine” to the people they will be dealing with at the meeting and that is why they have put together such similar outfits. This is not to say that both men know all the meanings of their suits and ties that might be constructed by all cultural groups; they do not necessarily know all of the possible structures of beliefs and values that suits and ties may be interpreted in terms of. For example, given their particular situations in 2004, it is unlikely that either man would wish to offend Christians or Muslims but some Islamic purists consider it haram, or prohibited, to wear ties made entirely of silk12 and the frog (as featured on what is reportedly Blair’s favourite tie), has long been a Christian symbol of uncleanliness. In this example, then, “alternative” or “new” interpretations of items of clothing may be explained as being constructed by people who either (1) know how the structure of cultural beliefs and values extends beyond the limits understood by the wearer or (2) are able to construct other parts of that structure. Someone else who is neither expressing his individuality nor sending a message in the sense assumed by the sender/receiver model is Osama bin Laden. He regularly appears in photographs wearing a combat jacket over white robes with white headgear. He knows very well that fellow Wahhabi Muslims will know that the white robes and headgear mean purity and he knows just as well that Western audiences will know that the combat jacket and AK47 mean a certain level and form of military/ technological threat and also a specific form of masculine identity.13 His outfit is constructed already knowing the different meanings that will in turn be constructed for it by different cultural groups and this, clearly, is not to convey a message in any simple sense. The second case study is that of the “hoodie.” A hoodie is a short hooded jacket, with or without a zipper on the front. Recently in the UK, hoodie has also become the name given to those wearing such
Fashion Statements
33
a jacket and it refers specifically to young people who are perceived by respectable, law-abiding middle-class observers and journalists as lower-class, drug-taking shop-lifters. The meaning communicated by these garments is now so powerful in the UK that hoodie wearers are being denied access to shopping malls because they are perceived as a shop-lifting threat. This constitutes a different kind of example in that here the structures of ideas and beliefs within which members of cultures construct meaning are being “extended”: new and different meanings are being made possible by “continuing” or extending existing patterns of beliefs in order to make new meanings. This may be seen by considering previously existing structures within which hooded garments have been constructed in the past. Hooded garments have a long history and there is nothing about hooded garments that is inherently or naturally lower class, or that inevitably indicates that the wearer is a delinquent and a threat to society. Academics, for example, have long worn hooded garments to communicate their status within the university. Certain religious orders are also in the habit of wearing hooded garments. And the humor in Neil Bennett’s cartoon in which a hoodied-up Christopher Robin suggests to Pooh and Tigger that they go and “hang about on the footbridge” is generated by the realization that when Christopher Robin, the goldenhaired goody-goody of A. A. Milne’s poem “Vespers,” pulls his hood right over his head so that nobody knows he’s there at all, nobody even thinks of him doing it to conceal his identity whilst engaged in a bit of casual vandalism. In these cases, among the meanings constructed by and for certain cultural groups are “learned,” “pious,” and “innocent childhood.” What is happening in the demonization of hoodie wearers is that the (British) print and television media are providing a new application of a set of values and ideas in terms of which certain cultural groups may construct the meaning of a particular garment. Those beliefs and ideas (shop-lifting, young people as threat, for example) are already present in the culture, but they have never been associated with this particular garment. Consequently, the structure of beliefs and ideas is being extended to include this new garment and thus to construct new meanings. And when a particular cultural group (middle-class, middle-aged aff luent consumers, for example) interprets hoodies as the latest evidence of moral decay, it is the result of the interaction between the values and ideas they hold and the garment they are looking at. Again, meaning here is not simply a message being sent to a receiver.
34
Malcolm Barnard Conclusion
This essay has attempted to define and explain the nature of fashion statements. In order to do this, it has had to investigate meaning and communication and explain what sort of meaning it might be that fashion has and what sort of communication it can be that fashion accomplishes. Meaning and communication have been explained in terms of culture: neither makes any sense without reference to culture. Culture has been understood as structures of beliefs, ideas, and values and as the communication of those beliefs, ideas and values in the construction (or not) of individuals as members (or not) of cultural groups. The construction of meaning by individuals, then, is one of the ways in which those individuals are themselves constructed as individuals. It is also one of the ways in which different, new, or alternative meanings are constructed. Fashion statements, then, are one of the ways in which cultural structures and individual agency relate and in which they are both constructed and reproduced. Notes 1. Anne Hollander, Sex and Suits (New York: Alfred A Knopf, 1994), 11. 2. Joanne Entwistle, The Fashioned Body (London: Polity, 2000), 1. 3. Roland Barthes, “Rhetoric of the Image,” in Image-Music-Text (Glasgow: Fontana/Collins, 1977), 43. 4. Entwistle, The Fashioned Body, 112. 5. Ibid., 66. 6. Elizabeth Rouse, Understanding Fashion (Oxford: Blackwell 1989), 24. 7. Joanne B. Eicher, Sandra Lee Evenson, and Hazel A. Lutz, The Visible Self (New York: Fairchild, 2000), 297. 8. Fred Davis, Fashion, Clothing and Identity (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1992), 11. 9. Colin Campbell, “When the Meaning Is Not a Message: A Critique of the Consumption as Communication Thesis,” in Mica Nava et al. (eds.), Buy This Book (London: Routledge, 1997). 10. Jacques Derrida, Of Grammatology, trans. Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak (Baltimore and London: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1974), 158. 11. Ludwig Wittgenstein, Philosophical Investigations (Oxford: Blackwell, 1953). 12. www.pakistanlink.com/religion/97/re05–23–97.html (accessed July 2005). 13. See Philip Mansell, Dressed to Rule (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2005). See “Postscript” for more on this.
CH A P T E R
FOU R
Tech Savvy: Technology as the New Fashion Statement Ava Ch in
On any given day in coffee houses, taxi cabs, SUVs, ferries, 18-wheeler trucks across the country, we can see evidence of a not-so-subtle revolution in the way that technology has impacted our fashionable lives. Where I live in New York, bike messengers sport the tell-tale white earphones of iPods, cabdrivers take phone calls on bluetooth devices, and businessmen and women broker deals on their iPhones and Blackberries while buying cappuccinos. Technology—what brand of portable computer, f lip-top, itty-bitty cell or smartphone, portable listening device, electronic reader you carry—makes a kind of fashion forward statement about the user that was once the province of combat boots, Fendi handbags, Rolex watches. Fashionistas are no longer afraid to reveal their geeky tech gear—now they flaunt it. At first, the marriage between technology and fashion might seem like an unlikely union. Technology is largely about providing function and ease—a speedier, more efficient way to aid our busy schedules. Fashion, on the other hand, is decidedly more self-conscious and selfreferential (read fashion for fashion’s sake). But with the advent of welldesigned technological products that are now appealing to women, and which have become ultimately wearable, technology has become as conspicuous a statement as fashion itself. Indeed, technology is the fashion. It’s no longer just purses that female consumers tote around—the latest accoutrement are the white iPod earphones, sporty bluetooth devices, all-in-one treos, e-Readers, and the ever-conspicuous Apple logo on
36
Ava Chin
laptops, listening devices, and touch-screened phones. Plus, there are the fancy cases to house the devices, which with Apple products, usually come with carefully designed cut-outs out so that the all-important logo is still visible. It crosses gender boundaries as well: these days, even the most masculinist men wear their electronic ear-devices like lady operators from the 1930s. The drive for ever better, faster technology, which certainly benefits the pockets of manufacturers and companies, means that updates and new models appear on the market as quickly as fashion is shown on the runways. But whereas even fashion has cycles—hemlines rising or falling, retro patterns paying homage to the past, dramatic makeup of the 1960s versus the “no makeup” look—the fashion of technology is to create product that moves ever forward: faster, sleeker, smaller, more portable. No one is trying to replicate the boxy desktops of the early PCs with their slow start-up booting time for a “feel good” retro appeal. Thorstein Veblen’s notion of “conspicuous consumption”1—where consumerism is largely fueled by the need to advertise class or social status—manifests here as not only a signifier of disposable income, but also of hip-ness, hypermobility and connection, technological savvy, and “forward” thinking. The newest of the personal listening devices and smartphones like iPhones, iPods, Blackberries, and other all-in-ones (with phone, music, Internet capability) nearly scream, “I work & play cool.” It’s no longer Prada shoes and Hermes handbags that signify what kind of fashion-conscious woman you are—these days it’s the kind of technology that you wear. Tech has become as all-important an item in your wardrobe as that little black dress. Technology Shapes Fashion We can see where technology has literally changed the “shape” of our fashion itself, particularly in the area of outerwear. Check the interiors of the newest coats designed for 21–34-year olds—for both men and women—and you will most likely discover several small pockets for cellphones and iPods built into the lining. I do not think it is a stretch to say that the primacy of this type of technology on fashion is unprecedented—as popular as the Sony Walkman of the 1980s was, for example, it never had its own pocket. Nowadays, designers and manufacturers are privileging cellphones and iPods with the equivalent of private parking in the garage of the garment.
Tech Savvy
37
Similarly, inside the latest lady’s purse you may find the addition of a technology pocket snuggled right next to the zipper compartment, usually reserved for money or makeup. The modern woman needs extra pockets for her technological accoutrement, which the bag’s designers seem to suggest, is now just as important as cash or beautification. And if the woman in question is lacking in that area, she might be prompted to purchase some digital accessory to fill that empty nest. Occasionally, these little pockets innocuously crop up on the exterior, changing the actual silhouette of the bag itself. In these instances, it is a testament to the tech savvy woman on the move, confident in her own identity as a card-carrying member of the digiterati. She needs all of her pockets in which to nestle her sleek and blinking peripherals. It’s not just ladies’ handbags that have morphed, but backpacks designed for both sexes from the likes of “traditionalist” companies that generally distain fast fashion, like L.L. Bean, that now accommodate technology as well. A recent online search yielded a crop of bags in traditional styles with one exception—many now come with a top pocket for storage of one’s listening device and a small hole in the fabric through which one’s headphones can connect and disappear. The only thing discrete about it is the fact that you can’t see the device, but the earphones give it all away. In each of these cases—coats, handbags, packpacks—it is possible to follow the tiny headphones of the iPod or iPhone dangling from the wearers’ ears like long white earrings, funneling into the recesses of the bag or garment. Wearers appear as if they are literally plugged into their clothing—as indeed they are, listening to music, holding not-so-private conversations in public, making a big show of sending messages out into the ether. In addition to outerwear and bags, technology has even impacted haute couture. In Hussein Chalayan, who hires MIT tech heads to augment his fashion, hemlines change, zippers uncurl, and models sometimes transform from fully clothed to naked by the time they reach the end of the runway. His luminous Airborne dress incorporates LED technology (often used for digital displays and traffic lights) with Swarovski crystals, while his Reading line is comprised of small red lasers embedding into the clothing that shine from Chalayan’s models like barcode scanners. iPod People In television advertisements and billboards across the country, silhouettes of young people of indeterminate but varied ethnicity dance
38
Ava Chin
across a solid-color background to British rock-n-roll. Their only distinguishable characteristics are youth, earphones, and the white rectangular object they carry. Clearly defined by their individuality and ability to “rock out” to the music, they are all listening presumably to the same song off the same kind of listening device—the Apple iPod. In the 1950s Cold War–era, plugged in “pod-people” were something to fear. They were a cautionary tale of soul-less conformists following a central alien “Pod” calling (see “Body Snatchers” and “Invasion of the Body Snatchers”). This trope of the ambiguous, amorphous collective was even reiterated in the 1990s version of “Star Trek” with the deeply disturbing hive-like Borg—similar-looking and sounding clones with nearly comical deadpan vocal delivery (resistance really was futile). Here too, connectivity suggested mindless following. You weren’t an individual so much as an appendage of a greater, collective mind. But Apple has rewritten the script—creating an entire culture industry that has made connectedness on par with individuality and mobility. Universal connectedness is cool. Through creative advertising and innovative, slimmed-down design that makes their products look as if they had been assembled by the hands of aliens and dropped from a space ship, Apple has made it easy to embrace the idea of connectedness while still maintaining a sense of individuality. Screenwriters! Musicians! Graphics designers! These were the early consumers the company marketed to and captured. You too can be a free-thinking individual, it promises. Perhaps since so many of us participate in the network of the World Wide Web, and since the Cold War is over, it is easier to relinquish some of the old pod-people fears. We are no longer worried about being transformed into mindless, communal creatures. Now, consuming and engaging in technology—being transported by the music in one’s iPod, having the ability to communicate and connect across vast distances of space from a café or a train—being “plugged in” denotes individuality and ultimate hipness. The iPod and Its Ever-Increasingly Cuter Permutations The revolution that is the iPod is the very calling card of modernity in design. Its clean lines and pure color palette—snow white, shiny black, and an assortment of seemingly airbrushed colors in between—are suggestive of airports, billboards, the future. That the iPod was fashioned with human beings in mind is clear—ergonomically designed to be
Tech Savvy
39
utilized in one hand, the other is free to hail a cab, drink a caffeinated beverage, or perhaps buy more product? The innovative, circular track pad is designed for the f lexibility of opposable thumbs, reinforcing the primacy of the primate (even King Kong could have scrolled through his playlist while carrying a struggling Fay Wray). Coinciding with forays into nanotechnology, and a movement in the culture where smaller is decidedly better, Apple spun off other even more minute generations. About the size of a stick of gum, the Nano has been marketed to display its glamorous slimness: its book-like packaging reveals in silhouette about a quarter inch thick, like a weight-loss model showing off her “after” figure. Even smaller than the Nano is its tiny cousin, the Shuff le. Barely larger than a postage stamp, and with the ability to clip onto a jeans pocket like the roach clips of the 1970s, it is suggestive of alternative coolness. As if the manufacturers are implying that you could smoke the last ends of your downloaded iTunes music with it. Mobile Connectedness In our technological milieu, a new kind of mobile connectedness has arisen. Through our mobile phones, computers and hand-held devices, we are connected to other tech savants beyond the limitations of space, beyond even the confines of our own office. On the streets and inside coffee houses, everyone it seems is engaged in this public/private technological connectedness. So-called private phone conversations, such as “I’ll be there in five minutes. Do you need anything?” has the importance of a Billboard rendering the speaker a character in their own personal reality television show. Even the dullest supermarket conversation is a moment of memoir: “What’s the difference between yellow and red onions?” We know everyone’s motivations and desires. Each of us within earshot, down the aisle or perusing produce, is willingly or not privy to the narrative. We are all spectators/audience members, and the only way to turn the station or close the book is to walk out of the theater of the phone call. It becomes easier and easier to lose touch with our surroundings— where we’re walking or driving, who is around us or who might be listening in. And as much as we’re talking to someone who could be thousands of miles away, here, on the busy, crowded streets of Manhattan, or as far away as Hong Kong or Tokyo, our new technology enables a strange, new form of solipsism. Like some sort of zen
40
Ava Chin
koan, technology extends our notion of being neither here nor there and the illusion of being simultaneously in two places at once. We can be internal—focusing on our work or music, connected via Internet or on the phone—while being in a public space. Physically here, but mentally elsewhere. And in public, this new sense of disengagement from our surroundings has created a new form or state of being around others. Only outdated thinkers believe that it’s rude to take a personal phone call while in the presence of a company of others. And if you do become offended, the logical conclusion is that you’re old. Enter the iPhone In recent years, since its unveiling in 2007, the must-have smartphone is Apple’s iPhone with its sans-keyboard, multitouch screen, and affordable applications accessible only through Apple’s App store. In addition to being a cellphone, the iPhone is an Internet-accessible personal listening device, with a calendar, camera, and global positioning system—and a host of other utilities that the consumer may wish to add for as little as 99¢ an app. Just as the iPod’s circular trackpad created a legacy of users showing off the facility of their opposable thumbs, the iPhone’s touch screen allows for certain gestures to be codified as “cool.” Enter the onefingered “swipe” to lock-unlock the phone, to scroll through different pages or advance text; the two-fingered gesture of fingers coming together or moving apart to “resize”; the tilting of the phone to rotate the screen for a larger, landscape view. This kind of facility, which extends to their computers as well (with the exception of the rotation orientation), is unprecedented in a phone—making it a highly portable, tactile object. And the technology is patented, so the gestures themselves signify not only “cool” but solely “Apple.” I first encountered the iPhone a few months after it was released at a monthly technology demo event I belong to, where I witnessed mostly male tech geeks who seemingly couldn’t wait to f lash their phones, showing off their latest apps as their fingers slid across their screens. Fast forward three years, and now it’s mothers whom I see touting iPhones, which aren’t just used for calling to set up playdates anymore—women give them to toddlers to occupy their attention.2 Clearly technology marketing has broken not only the gender barrier—companies are overjoyed they have accessed the female consumer—but with over 1,360 apps tagged for kids3 it’s also a family toy.
Tech Savvy
41
Changing Technological Fashion As I write this, the technological landscape is continuing to morph chameleon-like, with electronic Readers threatening to make the physical object of the book obsolete. Amazon’s Kindle, Barnes & Noble’s Nook, and now Apple’s iPad are set to revolutionize our lives—rehipsterizing the book and the act of reading. Students and professors no longer have to carry heavy published works on their shoulders—they can tout their single electronic device that can hold volumes of works, available at the click of a button. Indeed the iPad, with its rather unfortunate sounding name, promises to marry reading, surfing the Web, and listening to music into seamless acts with the drag of a finger. All this with the kind of intuitive design and solidly futuristic, forward-looking good looks that we expect from Apple products. Certainly new technology can improve our lives—keeping us interconnected and plugged into culture in ways unimaginable 30 years ago. Total disclosure: I myself am listening to iTunes on my MacBook as I write this, accepting calls on my iPhone. But as technology has become more wearable and more integrated in our daily lives—who can go a day without checking email?—I worry about our inability to focus on the present and our surroundings. Engaging in virtual or digital conversations takes us out of our physical space and into a mental space that is anywhere else but here. As fashion critic Guy Trebay wrote in the New York Times Sunday Magazine lamenting fashion’s future-forward sentimentalities, “We may be so caught up in the solipsism of consuming and in the virtual that we miss the now altogether.”4 I might venture it is also the here that we’re missing: we are so enamored of interfacing with our fashionable technology that one can easily miss what is physically happening right in front of us. A dangerous kind of solipsism and decreasing awareness accentuates and furthers the fracture between what’s going on at the moment and what we’re mentally consumed by. Rather like the equivalent of being engrossed in something while stepping into on-coming traffic, or texting while driving. One can only imagine that our dependence on technology will increase, and that as tech becomes even more visually well-designed that we will continue to wear it—and as evidenced by certain signature iPhone gestures, also act it. So while we’re taking our phone calls, plugged into our music nestled so snugly in our handbags or jackets, e-mailing colleagues continents away, or Googling the latest fads, consider this: will there be enough space inside our coats and jackets for all the new paraphernalia? Will technology take the place of clothing
42
Ava Chin
itself, just as microfibers have impacted the fabric industry? Indeed, will technology be the new clothing? And is it the case that we still wear and utilize our technology—or does our technology ultimately wear or utilize us? Notes 1. Thorstein Veblen, The Theory of the Leisure Class: An Economic Study of Institutions (New York: Macmillan, 1902). 2. Elizabeth Regalia, “25 iPhone Apps for Kids.” http://www.parenting.com/gear-gallery/ Gear/25-iPhone-Apps-for-Kids. 3. Warren Buckleitner, “The Best iPhone Apps for Kids,” Gadgetwise, New York Times Online, June 6, 2009. http://gadgetwise.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/06/10/the-best-iphone-apps-forkids/ 4. Guy Trebay, “Whatever Happened to Now?” New York Times, February 4, 2007. Section 6: col., 1, p. 73.
CH A P T E R
F I V E
Fleshing It Out: The Tyranny of the A-Line Skirt be l l h ooks
It’s hard to say when the schoolgirl look came on the fashion scene. Certainly, baby-doll dresses, T-shirts, and teeny-weeny tops that look like oversize clothes for tiny tots, as well as have-no-f lesh-on-yourbones Lycra cigarette pants, have all been part of the fashion mix that says to most women and a helluva lot of girls, “You, too, can starve yourself and look like this.” These fashion trends cannot be blamed on skinny Miss Kate Moss. I, for one, think she looks just fine the way she is. It becomes a problem when the way she looks, and those other folks with bodies just like hers, become “the” norm that everybody must strive for. Surely everyone must know someone, at least casually, who has a string-bean body but eats like a horse. Not everyone has to starve themselves to look like they’re doing just that. Some girls were just born skinny and are gonna stay that way, while the vast majority of females will find that the older we get, the more we put on pounds. It would be fun and life-affirming to live in a culture where that added f lesh could give us a thrill. When I was a girl, there was nothing more exciting to me than watching women get dressed. Even back in the day, when I saw mama pulling on that politically incorrect girdle to keep her soft marshmallow f lesh from spreading everywhere, there was no sense that it was “bad” to be full-figured. The girdle was just a necessary trick for particular outfits. It was not an everyday thing. Today’s grown woman has it drilled into her that any excess f lesh makes her less desirable. Gyms
44
bell hooks
are the new replacement for girdles and the like. Through constant exercise, we are told, we can make out bodies tighter, firmer and, or course, young-looking. Healthy exercise is one thing, but “manic if I don’t go to the gym everyday, I have sinned, must not eat and can’t possibly let anyone see me naked” is part of the antif lesh fixation. If only the demand were that we not have meat on our bones, but we are also being told to dress like girls—subjected to the tyranny of the A-line skirt. Undoubtedly, the fashion experts who decided that the schoolgirl look was the only way for women to go never really had to wear those school uniforms with the pleats and plaids. I’ve yet to meet a schoolgirl who thinks these skirts are the source of passion and pleasure. But all over this country, grown women are all too eager to enter the schoolgirl fantasy—and what better way than to wear tiny A-line miniskirts. After all, a friend says, you can’t have hips and thighs if you want to wear those skirts. And let’s not even talk about the way they are the kiss of death for those of us with soft, round bellies. Maybe it’s all about nostalgia. There’s all the new feminist writing reminding us that, for many females, premenstrual girlhood is the only time of passion and power some of us will ever know; the only time our bodies will be free to run with the wolves and unconsciously rough it. Because the moment those bodies start to bleed—starting on that arduous path to womanhood in patriarchal culture—shame about female f lesh threatens to overtake the psyche. And with this shame comes the overriding fear that our f lesh can betray us—make us less loving, less desirable, unable to face our images in the mirror. The more fashion has decided to that being a girl is more exciting than being a grown woman could ever be, the female f lesh is despised and ridiculed. At least filmmaker Atom Egoyan had the guts not only to mock the adult-male patriarchal, pornographic obsession with the “schoolgirl” in the film Exotica, he also let us know that masculine abuse and dysfunction are at the heart of the matter. He daringly shows the sexy beauty of a pregnant adult female body. While it’s not cool these days to act as though feminist politics put into place anything that was awesome and downright inspiring, let the truth be told: for a lot of women, it was the feminist movement that ushered in that rite of passage where we could move past the shame and glory in female f lesh. During the heyday of contemporary feminism, before the vicious backlash and the like, one thing I remember most (being 17 at the time) was the way in which female f lesh was celebrated in all its manifestations. Not only were we all rushing to the
Fleshing It Out
45
gynecologist to get that up-close and personal look at our clitorises, delighting in letting the hair on our bodies grow and grow, we were looking at the female body with new eyes. Whatever its shape or form, it was to be celebrated, cherished, and adored. I had come into my teens hating my body with a vengeance because it was just “too thin.” Protein drinks with raw eggs and vitamin supplements were not leading to that f leshly, womanly figure I wanted to have some day. I was living for the day when no one could ever say to me that I could pose for one of those posters of starving children. Feminism came along and I was swept away in a fierce circle of woman power where my body could be accepted and loved without the constant longing to change it, to make it something else. As the years have gone by, it’s been hard going to hold onto the rapture of that time. Yet there is no female alive who is not daily longing for a space where she can glory in the power and pleasure of her f lesh. May we seize that longing, garner it, and make a culture of belonging where we can celebrate female bodies, growing, moving from fierce, powerful girlhood to becoming more fully woman—in all her passion and glory.
This page intentionally left blank
CH A P T E R
SI X
Osh Kosh B’Gosh M ary O’ D onoghue
( for Áine and Trina) We’re all three of us let-outs, little big-shots, would you credit the cut of us, someone had better stop all the lights for us. Lawks, the state of us, kitted out in a gallimaufry of cast-offs from America, bits and bobs from Franciscan grand-aunts, scratchy Yonkers jumpers, nylon slacks from Tenaf ly. In the photograph two of us wear little capes for the opera, rabbit fur saddling our shoulders, trussed to our throats by pom-poms. Harnessed tight, one of us inside checkered dungarees, f lush with her belly and snug to the crotch, like a tiny hucksterish man.
48
Mary O’Donoghue The sun-spangled wall behind us in Annie Quinn’s yard is a wall that should itself be a frock, splotched with hand-sized lichen. Mary Quant would like it. These clothes on us might well bring on the bullies. But this morning we swagger our couture, and we’re cool as you please, and we don’t give a damn, for we are. The next. Big thing.
CH A P T E R
SE V E N
The Fungi Dress—A Living Garment: Interview with Donna Franklin (July 2005) S hannon B e l l
Donna Franklin is a designer who has been producing living textiles within the Faculty of Natural and Agricultural Laboratories, University of Western Australia, Perth, and constructing clothes that are the result of living processes that transform the cloth into an active site. Her work explores the merging of body and environment, fuses the organic and inorganic, and transforms the textile surface into a site of real biological activity. Franklin developed the fungi dress during her artist residency at SymbioticA: The Art and Science Collaborative Research Laboratory, Department of Anatomy and Human Biology, University of Western Australia, Perth. The fungi dress, titled Fibre Reactive, consists of a silk and pleated organza slip dress, on which is grown the orange bracket fungus, Pycnoporus conoccieus. Shannon Bell is a performance philosopher who lives and writes philosophy-in-action. Her books include Reading, Writing and Rewriting the Prostitute Body (Indiana University Press 1994), Whore Carnival (Semiotext 1995), Bad Attitude/s on Trial, coauthor (University of Toronto Press, 1997), New Socialisms, coeditor (Routledge 2004), and Fast Feminism (forthcoming). Bell is currently researching “extreme” science and art for FastBodies. This research is funded by Canada’s Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council (SSHRC). Bell is an
50
Shannon Bell
associate professor in the York University Political Science Department, Toronto, Canada. If the cloth or garment is alive, it becomes an entity on its own, it will change and grow, it will require care and nutrients like a pet, raising issues of how we interact with these living organisms. Franklin 2005, ii Donna Franklin: The body starts off as a biological base and the garment as a social construction. The fact that it is a biological garment merges the two. Shannon Bell: If identity is created self-consciously through fashion, or culture is inscribed on the body to some extent through fashion, how does the fungi dress change identity? Because you are using a medium that has never been used before, what does this mean in terms of identity? Donna: In terms of the garment being used as a site of social construction, the fact that it is a living garment the aim of doing this is to rupture the idea of garment as a source of identity. The fact that it is alive makes it become more intricate with the body; on a visceral level because it is biological and we are biological it creates a closer affinity with the body. The fact is that it is a dress and it is sealed within an acrylic case, a bit like traditional Snow White themes, and I wanted to create a tension with traditional stereotypes of femininity, as well. Shannon: What about when you are wearing the fungi dress? Donna: It is an unusual experience because I am aware of what it is made of; it feels like suede but it is quite firm in terms of its structure. It is quite fragile and delicate, but it is also like armor at the same time. Shannon: In a sense it is living body armor. Clothing is a way of wearing culture on our body, or acting in relation to culture, or undermining culture, or a way of countering culture. You do come out of a counterculture clothing movement. The fungi dress blows everything apart. It does this from a position of aesthetic beauty. The fungi dress is aesthetically gorgeous, but the material that it is made out is not what is considered beautiful; rather, it is considered grotesque. You have made beauty out of a material that is considered to be grotesque and diseased.
The Fungi Dress
51
Donna: I deliberately chose this beauty/grotesque juxtaposition. When people think of fungi they think of mold, skin diseases. I deliberately chose the surface of the garment to look slightly grotesque to bring up the stereotypes of Frankenstein, juxtaposing this with the idea of beauty. On the surface you have sections that are stitched together and raw and you have the softness of it as well. Shannon: Is it possible to look at the fungi dress and see it as grotesque? Donna: Possibly, in the film I have details of it being stitched. The pulling of the thread through the fungi and fiber looks very much like pulling thread through skin. Shannon: It does look like skin being stitched, producing a trace to body modification. Donna: There is the idea of decay. Because it is alive, it will eventually decay. Shan: It has been alive for quite a while now? How long has it been living? Donna: It’s a year old. Shannon: It looks almost the same? Donna: I can see the subtle differences. I can see sections of the dress that are sporing: the body is releasing its spores, its genetic material. Shannon: When you say “genetic material” what do you mean? Donna: Flowers have seeds, fungi has spores. Shannon: Are there new fungi growing on the dress? Donna: It seems to be self-regenerating itself. The dress is in a state of limbo and also in a state of f lux with life and death. Shan: The dress is both life and death, simultaneously. Donna: I can see that it has changed. At one stage there was some penicillin on the dress and that has disappeared. The fungi brought up its own immune system to protect itself and stopped the penicillin from growing; so this indicates that it is still alive. The dress has also had organisms eating it. This indicates that there is some sort of biological interaction going on inside the dress. Shan: What would you call what is going on inside the dress? Donna: A relationship. Shannon: Between the host which is the fungi and parasites that attach to it? What sort of parasites attach to it?
52
Shannon Bell
Donna: What I had in there were little brown museums bugs; these were eaten by the spiders. Shannon: How did the spiders get in the acrylic case? Donna: They must have crept in during construction. It is all part of the living dress system. Shan: I saw the fungi dress at Bio-Difference, BEAP (Biennale of Electronic Art Perth) (September 2004) and then again as part of HATCHED at PICA (Perth Institute of Contemporary Art) (May 2005). What was the white-greenish mold that was on the orange fungi when the dress showed at PICA? It looked to me like the fungi was acting as a host to a mold. Donna: That was the penicillin. Shannon: I think the fact that clothing can be made from living material that takes on a life of its own means something unique in the fashion industry. What would you say it means? Donna: I hope it challenges the fashion industry in terms of presenting a new way of using fabric. If you were to take it to the extreme and you had a wearable living garment, which is what I am working on in my new research, you would have to maintain that garment, you would have to look after the garment. You would have a responsibility to the garment, something like looking after a pet. The garment might change from season to season, in terms of color. Shannon: You would have a transmuting garment. Donna: Conceptually, it brings in the whole issue of the commodified body in fashion. Shannon: The fungi dress is both critique of the fashion industry and one of the most incredibly beautiful garments I’ve seen. I always thought critique could be beautiful. Donna: Me too. Because it is alive it makes people more aware of their body and what they are wearing, how they wear clothes, why they wear clothes as a cultural object, how we place certain ideologies onto clothing. With the commodified body it is more about the fact that I am using biological material to produce a garment, a dress, which is normally constantly recycled, constantly updated, the whole consumer thing of how fashion is always looking for something new. Shan: But this is as new as it gets, and it constantly rejuvenates itself as new, as well as critiquing new. This almost critiques both the hegemonic and counter cultural critiques of fashion.
The Fungi Dress
53
The fungi dress works as a metacritique because it is living and because it is made out of material that is officially considered grotesque but it looks really beautiful. So it sort of destabilizes all the invested identities inscribed in clothing. Was this your intent when you started off? Donna: Previous to this, my work was always about process and practice. I would be looking at the materials and looking at what they could communicate. In producing the fungi dress the intention was to rupture and challenge preconceived traditional notions of relationships between identity, the body and the garment, fungi and textile relationships, taking the latter to a new level. Historically, fungi have been used in textiles to dye; it is no longer living. How my research changes traditional techniques is by producing a living dye and keeping the fungi alive. Shannon: You didn’t dye the fungi? Donna: No, this is the fungi’s original color. It is an orange bracket fungus, Pycnoporus conoccieus. Shannon: How did you get the idea to produce a fungi dress? Donna: Previous to this I grew wheat into cloth and looked at patterns created; I was looking at the ideas of life, death, decay and energy. Then I transferred these patterns into hand embroidery, taking images from the wheat and making hand stitch. I met the bioartist Adam Zaretsky; he gave a talk about his residency at SymbioticA. I, then, did a residency at SymbioticA. I developed the fungi dress during a residency at SymbioticA. The natural progression after learning the techniques of mycology (the growth and study of fungi) and experimenting with different colors, different ways of growing fungi, was to make it into a garment because that is what I have always done. I have always worked with the body and clothing. Shannon: You come out of high femme Goth counterfashion. Donna: “Unconventional conventionists” to take the quote from Rocky Horror Picture Show. Shannon: How has Goth inf luenced your choice in terms of medium and in terms of style? Donna: Well, fungi, the whole issue of decay is a Goth thing; having it quite raw in terms of surface also reminds me of Gothic identities. Gothicism for me was very much about making a statement and challenging the norm; this has something to do with the inf luence of choosing biological material.
54
Shannon Bell
When I was working in the laboratory, I liked the idea of how I had this illusion of control. You have the entity contained, but you don’t have control over what it does entirely even though you choose where it goes and what it consumes food wise, as you are feeding it. The orange bracket fungus feeds on cellulose. There is still the unknown element that you don’t have control over which I find really exciting. Maybe this has something to do with Gothicism because at the time it was unknown to me. I saw Goths on the street and I thought this is intriguing: Why are they doing this? What is their purpose? What are they saying? Having the illusion of control and the unknown with the biological material is really exciting for me. Shannon: Do you foresee a living material fashion show? Donna: I am working on that right now for BEAP works. A fashion show exhibition. Shannon: Are you going to have people wearing them? Donna: Yes. Donna: Wow. Need any models? Donna: Yes. Shannon: Are you serious? When is the show? Donna: July 2006; are you going to be around? Shannon: I’d love to model. I could arrange to be around. Donna: Again, the work is combining the living and the nonliving, the organic and the synthesized. The fungi is grown in the laboratory and I’m combining this with stereotypical fashion ideologies, then challenging the stereotypes of science and art. When people think of biological art, they think Frankenstein and cloning; I want to play with this. Shannon: Yes, count me in. I’ll be back; are you doing any minis? How many garments do you foresee making? Donna: The number has to be significant, either seven or more than seven. Seven references the whole idea of God and Creation. Shannon: There is a spark of the divine in the material because it is a living thing. Donna: I had some problems in terms of how to make the fungi dress wearable so I am working on how to make the new living dresses wearable? Shannon: The fungi dress is so beautifully radical that it is both subtle and right up against the fashion industry, putting it under
The Fungi Dress
55
critique. And phenomenally beautiful to look at. You can do much more with beauty as critique and much more with art and installation than you can with words. You can do much more with presentational art—an installation that is presenting something new. Donna: Up until the last two years I have been producing representational work; I am still struggling with the fine line between representational and presentational work; and where I actually sit. I feel that I can’ t do works that are not aesthetically pleasing. Shannon: There is a difference between beauty that is a hegemonic beauty that falls into a status quo, that doesn’t put anything into question, and beauty that is outside of that and is a noncontainable beauty. To employ the philosopher Martin Heidegger’s thinking on art: this kind of beauty is unconcealing; it reveals a different medium and a different process to produce a standard everyday product: clothing. Note Franklin, Donna M., Fibre Reactive a Living Garment. A Synergy of Biological Technology and Art. Masters of Arts Dissertation, The School of Contemporary Arts, Faculty of Communication and Creative Industries, Edith Cowan University, 2004.
This page intentionally left blank
CH A P T E R
EIGH T
Victimless Leather—A Prototype of Stitch-less Jacket grown in a Technoscientific “Body” S hannon B e l l
Humans, the naked/nude apes, have been covering their fragile bodies/skins to protect themselves from the external environment. This humble act for survival has developed into a complex social ritual that transformed the concept of a “Garment” into an evocative object that cannot be taken on its face value. Garment became an expressive tool to project one’s identity, social class, political stand, and so on. Garments are humans’ fabrication and can be explored as a tangible example of humans’ treatment of the Other. By growing Victimless Leather, the Tissue Culture & Art (TC&A) Project is further problematizing the concept of garment by making it Semiliving. The Victimless Leather is grown out of immortalized cell lines that cultured and form a living layer of tissue supported by a biodegradable polymer matrix in a form of miniature stitch-less coat like shape. The Victimless Leather project concerns with growing living tissue into a leather like material. This artistically grown garment will confront people with the moral implications of wearing parts of dead animals for protective and aesthetic reasons and will further confront notions of relationships with living systems manipulated or otherwise. An actualized possibility of wearing “leather” without killing an animal is offered as a starting point for cultural discussion. Our intention is not to provide yet another consumer product but rather to raise questions about our exploitation of other living beings.
58
Shannon Bell
We see our role as artists as one in which we are providing tangible example of possible futures, and research the potential affects of these new forms on our cultural perceptions of life. It is not our role to provide people with goods for their daily use. We would like our work to be seen in this cultural context, and not in a commercial context. As part of the TC&A project we are artistically exploring and provoking notions relating to human conduct with other living systems, or to the Other. It deconstructs our cultural meaning of clothes as a second skin by materializing it and displaying it as an art object. It also presents an ambiguous and somewhat ironic take into the technological price our society will need to pay for achieving “a victimless utopia”. The research and development of “Victimless Leather” has been conducted in SymbioticA: The Art and Science Collaborative Research Laboratory, School of Anatomy and Human Biology at the University of Western Australia and in consultation with Professor Arunasalam Dharmarajan from the School of Anatomy and Human Biology as well as Verigen, a Perth-based company that specializes in tissue engineered cartilage for clinical applications. The State of Western Australia has made an investment in this project through ArtsWA in Association with the Lotteries Commission.1 Oron Catts is a Tissue Engineering Artist. He is cofounder and Artistic Director of SymbioticA, the Art & Science Collaborative Research Laboratory, School of Anatomy and Human Biology, University of Western Australia, Perth. Catts, with Ionat Zurr, is the cofounder of the Tissue Culture & Art Project/TC&A (1996). Catts was a research fellow at the Tissue Engineering and Organ Fabrication Laboratory, Harvard Medical School (2000–2001). Catts trained in product design and specialized in the future interaction of design and biological derived technologies. Ionat Zurr is a Wet Biology Art Practitioner. She is artist-inresidence/PhD candidate in SymbioticA. Zurr, with Oron Catts, is the cofounder of the TC&A Project. Zurr was a research fellow at the Tissue Engineering and Organ Fabrication Laboratory, Harvard Medical School (2000–2001). Zurr studied art history, photography, and media studies, specializing in biological and digital imaging as well as video production. Currently, Zurr is a PhD candidate researching the ethical and epistemological implications of wet biology art practices. Catts and Zurr, Tissue Culture and Art Project,2 have produced a number of semiliving tissue engineered wet biology art works: Pigs Wings Project, Semi-living Worry Dolls, Disembodied Cuisine, The Extra Ear 1/4 Scale, and Victimless Leather. Documentation of these works and
VICTIMLESS L EATHER
59
writings by Catts and Zurr can be viewed on the Tissue Culture and Art website (www.tca.edu.au). Shannon Bell is a performance philosopher who lives and writes philosophy in action. Bell did a three-month artist residency, in 2005, at SymbioticA where she studied the process and techniques of tissue engineering art objects with Catts and Zurr. The residency was part of Bell’s current research in “extreme” science and art for her book FastBodies. This research is funded by Canada’s Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council (SSHRC). Bell is an associate professor in the York University Political Science Department, Toronto, Canada. Interview with Oron Catts and Ionat Zurr July 2005 Shannon: How does Victimless Leather change how we see fashion, the industry of fashion, and the fetishization of fashion. How does victimless leather mark a shift in your body of tissue engineered 3 bioart work? I know that your new work is going to be with roadkill. Oron and Ionat: Perhaps we should put Victimless Leather not only in the context of the fashion, but also in the broader context of our work. Victimless Leather4 is part of an ongoing engagement with the notion of the semiliving.5 We decided to look at the notion the victimless utopia, which is mediated by technology. But, as with most of our work, it is somewhat ironic in perspective. We started with victimless meat, which was Disembodied Cuisine. In Disembodied Cuisine,6 we grew frog steak from living frog skeletal muscle cells that were taken as a biopsy. The healing frogs were displayed in the gallery alongside the growing steak. Obviously, it was tongue in cheek and, in fact, a pseudopositivist notion of where society is going with technology and food production. Victimless leather is the second in this series. With the exhibitions we have to find the right and appropriate context to present them. When we are invited to an exhibition it enables us to make the piece. For most of our pieces the first time they are produced is in the gallery. This means that the experimentation is done in
60
Shannon Bell
the gallery. The first time that all the components are coming together are in the gallery situation. Shannon: This is a high-risk exhibition situation. So the first time all the component of Victimless Leather came together was for the Space Between Exhibition at the John Curtain Gallery in Perth. Oron and Ionat: The whole system, yes. We, obviously, did quite a lot of testing. We grew bits of tissue in different layers in the laboratory; however, doing the jacket within the profusion pump was done for the first time in the gallery for this exhibition. It was the same with victimless meat, Disembodied Cuisine. We had done testing for victimless cuisine at Joseph Vacanti’s lab using totally different types of cells. We obviously never ate these because we were not allowed to do it.7 The gallery allows us space for experimentation, which is almost impossible in the laboratory. The gallery gives us the type of freedom to experiment and do things that are much harder to do in a gallery than in a laboratory. For us, showing our work is a continuation of the research rather than the outcome of the research When we reshow the work we show the relics rather than the actual piece. Because our art is so much process based to do the same thing over again is less exciting for us. We are invited to show the Victimless Leather project again in a gallery in Germany. They don’t have the funding or the ability to show any living specimens. The idea, then, is to show just the dead specimen. We put it in such a situation so that it will be similar to the way in which the living garment was grown and shown. We fixed the garment inside the environment in which it was growing before. The garment or specimen and the environment are inactive. The garment is fixed in formaldehyde. It preserves the specimen but it kills everything and breaks down all of the proteins. Formaldehyde fixes the cells to the surface, but they are not the cells anymore in this context. Rather, they are transformed by the formaldehyde; the cells retain their morphological structure but not their chemical structure. Shannon: What was Victimless Leather grown out of? Oron and Ionat: One of the things that came out of the work with victimless meat was that we were later approached to create the ultimate victimless meat by using human tissue. When you look at meat in the context of human tissue you start to touch
VICTIMLESS L EATHER
61
on cannibalism and all the taboos that are associated with it. From our perspective, this would really skew quite a lot of the discourse we are trying to generate. We raised it and discussed it in our writings and talks, but we were not interested in actually doing it because it would take us to places that might be interesting to some, but which for us and our ongoing discourse on the semiliving it might not be appropriate. We use generic terms to describe the tissue that we are working with rather than describe the species the tissue is coming from. This means we only describe the type of tissue: skin, bone, nerve cells. People tend to automatically attribute the tissue to humans. When we say skin, people assume that it is human skin, although this is not necessarily the case. When we talk about leather, in very few cases would the idea of it being human come up. In the context of leather we decided it might be interesting to grow human cells but fuse them with animal cells. When humans started to wear garments, according to all indications it was animal furs. In many cases it was not just protective covering which was the initial use which made humans such a f lexible organism that can survive quite a range of technological issues but also a very symbolic one: by wearing the animal you are the animal. You see by the descriptions of early cultures and the description of their relationship to animals, animal hides were used in a very ritualistic way. Shamans would use them and people would have special hides that they were wearing corresponding to their position in the culture. They became the animal. Then we removed ourselves from animal and most people now tend to forget that leather is an animal product. For them it is not a factor because it is so far removed. By creating the Victimless Leather project one of the intentions was to bring it back to the origin from which the animal hide came by removing it from the origin. By using the victimless technique of culturing leather rather than needing to kill animals. By also fusing it with human cells we were really turning it on its head. Particularly, he whole notion that you are the animal if you wear animal hides. Leather is a very fetishistic and a very symbolic garment more than plant derived garments. By bringing it back to the human and one of the things that came about was a discourse similar to the victimless meat where people were talking about growing human meat. Here we actually spoon-feed them and said we are using human tissue but we are fusing so we are creating this chimerical being which is both human and animal. Bringing people to think about using their own
62
Shannon Bell
skin as a second skin, as a garment, but also talking about the breakdown in barriers between the human and animal through the whole notion of the semiliving which is really breaking down notions of species. Actually wearing this hybrid human animal garment or a symbolic gesture towards wearing something like that. Interestingly, Victimless Leather was one of the most discussed projects that we have ever had. The subtitle of the project is a Stitch-less Jacket grown in a Technoscientific “Body.” I suppose this was the first time we are referring to the technoscientific body, the environment in which we were growing our sculptures as an artistic intention rather than as a necessary frame of technological context in which our sculpture is growing. The first one was in the Worry Dolls. At the time we called the worry dolls’ piece The Tissue Culture and Art(ificial) Wombs, which was quite strong and appropriate at the time, but now the Worry Dolls warrant enough attention by themselves so the project is now know as The Worry Dolls. Here we are referring to Stitch-less Jacket grown in a Technoscientific “Body.” This is also the first time that we were custom designing an environment to grow our sculptures. Before we were using ready-made bioreactors. This is a very experimental way of trying to grow three-dimensional tissue structures. It is experimental in one sense, but really goes back to the bases of drip cultures that were done when the first tissue culture experiments were taking place. Also, the actual piece itself uses a fairly archaic profusion pump which is based on the original profusion pump that Alexis Carrel did. There are a number of different layers and levels in which we are dealing with the work. We don’t expect everyone to engage with it on all of those levels. There are quite a lot of different narratives and discourses that are embedded within. People took us quite at face value when we were describing Disembodied Cuisine and Victimless Leather as totally victimless, as utopian projects, which wasn’t really our intention. It was always an ironic look, but obviously we didn’t articulate this enough, but perhaps that was also part of the notion of sucking people into this and describing the fact that it is not totally victimless. Nothing is victimless. By one life form surviving or existing it comes at the expense of something else. There is no limitless resources. Our survival is really dependent on the exploitation of other beings. Scientists got quite pissed off with us because they know that we use serum from cows and they know that some of the chemicals we are
VICTIMLESS L EATHER
63
using in the whole process of tissue culturing are animal derived. It is like going to the supermarket and buying meat rather than going and killing; it is removing the victim from the immediate context but it doesn’t take the victim away; it only removes it from attention. We took it to a very absurd conclusion: devictimizing living beings that are killed for our transportation system. Just for us to move from place to place we are generating quite a bit of death in terms of roadkill. The name of the project is ReLifeing RoadKill—taking bits of fresh roadkill, taking cells from these and growing these cells over miniatures of the animal from which it originated. Shannon: So you two will be looking on the road for roadkill? Oron: This is very much work in very early stages. Conceptually, at least, I think it is important to tie it up with Disembodied Cuisine and Victimless Leather. What it is going to do is create this notion of devictimization. If you take an animal that was killed just for a person to get from A to B, or for delivery of goods from one point to the other and you ReLife it, you create this notion of devictimization. It is obviously a symbolic ritualistic gesture toward the devictimization, although by the end of the exhibition people would rekill it because we have the killing ritual.8 If you can think about the victimless meat and the victimless leather as a fairly utilitarian and we actually were approached by companies that were talking about it as potential for commercial exploitation. The roadkill has no potential for exploitation, it has none what so ever; it doesn’t make sense. It is really confronting all of those capitalistic notions that things have to have a financial utilitarian value in order for them to be worthwhile. What we are doing by ref lecting back on the other two projects is saying that they are as futile as the ReLifeing of RoadKill. We really have to reassess our perception of life, find a totally new structure in which those kind of develops can take place; otherwise it is as useless as ReLifeing RoadKill. Shannon: The fashion industry is a multibillion dollar industry; Victimless Leather is a living send-up of this. Oron and Ionat: We need to describe Victimless Leather. It was in a totally dark room which had two intentions. One was to protect the nutrient solution which is light sensitive. Some people
64
Shannon Bell got really scared. In retrospect, I realize the gallery was a bit too dark. People were intimidated by this, which wasn’t our intention, but it kind of worked alright.
The whole profusion pump, which functioned as a kind of bioreactor, was inside the incubator. The incubator was hidden behind a false wall. What one saw was like a window into the incubator. You couldn’t see the incubator. You were only seeing the profusion pump and jacket. Bubbles came out of the profusion pump bioreactor and the pump made a repetitive mechanical noise. Because we made the profusion pump into the bioreactor we didn’t want the incubator to be shown. It had a diorama sense to it. The living garment appears as a threedimensional object with the profusion pump constantly pumping nutrients all inside an incubator hidden behind a black wall. This was one of the very first times that we didn’t have the laboratory in the gallery. Sometimes you want to expose the technology and sometimes the technology is too fantastic that people can’t seem to see beyond it. We had a light box with three Petri dishes that were backlite from underneath showing the layers of cell as proof of concept that you can actually grow thick layered tissue. The one on the left is human cartridge cells layered, the third dish shows the fusion of human and mouse cells. The Petri dishes, due to the lightening, were glowing. We cured or fixed the cells and dyed them in much the same way as hide tanning is done. The way of staining cells came from the tanning industry, which is bringing it back to its origin. Then we had the video framed in the same size as the window to the incubator. It was a small projection. It consisted of cells growing with subliminal messages that were images of Frankenstein, Alexis Carrel and his profusion pump, and Oron working in the lab. What we wanted, especially in the context of fashion, was that people would think about the monstrosity of it. It was a fairly Frankensteinian piece by itself; we reinforced it. It was shown in the context of a mainstream fashion textile show. Ionat: The thing about the garment in terms of fashion aesthetics is that it grows into shape, there is no stitching. Shannon: So you could grow yourself a minidress that would be growing while you were wearing it. Oron: Only if you are willing to live your life in sterile conditions to keep the garment alive.
VICTIMLESS L EATHER
65
Ionat: Unless, eventually you were able to grow an external layer of skin as a garment. Ionat: In the conclusion of the paper, “Anthropocentric Attitudes towards the Semi-living,” that I am working on for the Animal and Society Conference,9 I ask which is more disturbing: to wear other animals, or to wear yourself or other humans on yourself, or a hybrid of animals, yourself and other humans? Species differentiation is not a conceptual thing, it tends to be a moral thing. We classify species according to a particular type of morality. Which of the three would you find most disturbing? Shannon: I would find the hybrid mix most desirable. Ionat: Would you wear yourself on yourself? Shannon: Absolutely. I would wear myself, my friends, lovers, ex-lovers. Ionat: A combination of all and your pets, too? Shannon: One of the many great things about all your work is that often each piece raises a number of ethical issues without hitting the viewer over the head with these. When someone looks at a victimless garment, they will probably begin thinking about how we are always wearing leather. Oron: At the conference that accompanied the Space Between textile exhibition, which we gave the keynote at, people seems to be quite disturbed ethically with our work while they didn’t find any problems with the traditional ways of creating leather by killing animals. It seemed to be this idea that if it is new and it is confronting your perception of life, then it is unethical. The “yuck factor” is a way in which we can’t articulate our ethical problems with something but we feel it is wrong. There was a paper on this contending that you have to trust your yuck factor in terms of determining what is right and wrong ethically and morally. If it is in terms of species mixing, the yuck factor comes not because we are afraid of animals becoming us; it is more that we are afraid of us being reduced to animals, which is a humancentric position. Our work very much generates the yuck factor, and in many cases deliberately so. People rely on the yuck factor when they have no theory, no other tools to engage with. The reaction is quite visceral because you can’t articulate it in any coherent thought. What it represents, especially in the context of Victimless Leather, is that because this work is confronting people in terms of their relationships to living beings, they feel that it is wrong somehow, but they can’t articulate it.
66
Shannon Bell
On the other hand, they have no problems with the current production of leather because it is so common and it was done for so long that we are desensitized to it. So this is considered morally right. The fact that it has happened for a long time doesn’t make it right. And, the fact that it is new doesn’t make it wrong, in many cases. I think what we are trying to deal with in the new is with all the ways of perceiving the world. Our belief systems and our cultural tools are not adequate to new technologies. Ionat: Artists can play a role in exploring these issues and spawn “philosophy in action.” Using the very same tools and techniques offered by biotechnology for the sole purpose of generating cultural debate. There is a growing discrepancy between our cultural perceptions of life and what we know about life scientifically and what we can do with life technologically. The instrumentalization of living systems through different aspects of biotechnology is of great concern to us, in particular in the context of postcapitalistic forces. Our work deals with the tension between caring for living systems, on the one hand, and instrumentalizing life, on the other hand. We believe that art is best situated to confront such a paradox in ways that constructively raise philosophical and epistemological issues. Notes 1. Oron Catts and Ionat Zurr, Victimless Leather—A Prototype of Stitch-less Jacket Grown in a Technoscientific “Body” (www.tca.edu.au/vl/vl/html). 2. The Tissue Culture & Art Project (TC&A) was set to explore the use of tissue technologies as a medium for artistic expression. We are investigating our relationships with the different gradients of life through the construction/growth of a new class of object/being—that of the Semiliving. These are parts of complex organisms that are sustained alive outside of the body and coerced to grow in predetermined shapes. These evocative objects are a tangible example that brings into question deep rooted perceptions of life and identity, concept of self, and the position of the human in regard to other living beings and the environment. We are interested in the new discourses and new ethics/epistemologies that surround issues of partial life and the contestable future scenarios they are offering us. (Short Manifesto, TC&A, www. tca.edu.au). 3. The basic definition of tissue engineering is the combining of tissue cells with biodegradable scaffolding materials to generate functional tissue constructs. 4. Victimless Leather—A Prototype of Stitch-less Jacket grown in a Technoscientific “Body,” Space Between Exhibition, John Curtain Gallery, Perth, Western Australia, April–June 2004. 5. Semiliving and partial life are terms originated by Catts and Zurr, and until recently used interchangeably, to refer to “tissue culture and tissue engineered entities that can be sustained, grown, function and . . . ‘live’ outside [their] original body.” (Ionat Zurr and Oron Catts, “Are the Semi-living Semi-good or Semi-evil?” Technoetic Arts, Issue 1, 2003, www.tca.edu.ca/ atGlance/pubMainFrames.html/, 5.) The tissue construct is nurtured in a technosurrogate
VICTIMLESS L EATHER
6. 7.
8.
9.
67
body—a bioreactor, which functions as an artificial womb providing a sterile environment with a nutrient solution that sustain life. The bioreactor is necessarily inside an incubator that keeps the cell structure at 37.0 C, or body temperature. More recently, with the growing of the international performance robo-artist Stelarc’s Extra Ear 1/4 Scale, TC&A has made a distinction between semiliving and partial life entities: semilivings are shaped into forms that are not recognizable as part of any body in particular, whereas partial life can be recognized as parts of a whole of a living being, such as the Extra Ear 1/4 Scale. Disembodied Cuisine and The Tissue Culture and Art(ificial) Womb, part of the L’art Biotech group exhibition of biological art, Nantes, France, March 14–May 4, 2003. On the last day of the show the steak was cooked by a chef in a novelle cuisine dinner for six; the frogs, which had been rescued from a frog farm, were released to a pond in a local botanical garden. The semiliving is necessarily killed at the end of every installation because semilivings can’t be transported across borders and require sterile lab conditions to receive the appropriate care to continue life. The killing is “done by taking the semi-living sculpture out of its containment and letting the audience touch (and be touched) by the sculpture.” The fungi and bacteria that exist in the air and on hands contaminate the cells. Animal and Society Conference, Anthropology & Sociology, School of Social and Cultural Studies, University of Western Australia, Perth, July 2005.
This page intentionally left blank
CH A P T E R
N I N E
Is Clothing Art? Je f f We in ste in
More than two decades ago, avant-garde clothes designer Rei Kawakubo opened a groundbreaking retail space for her Comme des Garcons line in New York’s Soho, which was then a name still synonymous with the city’s thriving art world. The bright, minimal, polished-cement space signaled “gallery” instead of shop; the store’s design in fact predicted the industrial-luxury look of many galleries to come—galleries, of course, being shops that sell art. The first year Soho’s Comme des Garcons was in business, I saw a shopper take an indigo-black, cotton-and-wool, protean-shaped article off a hanger and walk to the dressing cubicle. A moment later, she called for a saleswoman: “I need help, I can’t see how to put this on.” And soon she and her helper emerged, looking for a waist, a belt, a front, a back, an inside or outside, anything to cue how this fascinating object marketed as clothing was supposed to relate to a woman’s body. Ultimately they did manage, the brave customer bought the item, and early Kawakubo clothing very like it now can be found in museum collections around the world. Some even call Kawakubo’s clothing art—whether she intends it to be or not—and the designer herself an artist. There is no question that since Marcel Duchamp and the maturation of modernism, displaying something in a gallery or museum urges us to consider the something, whatever else we may call it, as art. But clothing arrayed to be seen and not bought leads us to ask a preliminary, crucial question: Why can’t any clothing, made by artists or not, be art?
70
Jeff Weinstein
The usual answer is the same that has been invoked to keep so-called craft out of the serious Western art club, which is, the more something is meant to be used, the less “art” it can be. So clothing is not art if it’s taken off the wall and worn to a dinner party? A quick historical look at the “Is clothing art?” conundrum throws the utility response into deep doubt. Probably the earliest argument that clothing belongs to the same category as art was made by the late-Victorian English designer and theorist William Morris, who tried to convince his contemporaries that the distinction between the fine and applied arts was bogus because the same principles of creation apply—or should apply—to both. His ideal was an aesthetically unified world in which paintings, furniture, wallpaper, and fabric were produced as far from factories as possible, with paints, dyes, materials, and even patterns and themes derived from preindustrial nature and culture. The resulting Arts and Crafts Movement bungalows, paintings, chairs, books, and even suits or dresses became interconnected artistic equals in what has been called a “style universe.” At the same time, the wider Aesthetic Movement also in Europe and the United States included border-crossing inf luences from Japan, but its practitioners continued to erase boundaries between fine art and clothing, melding all the arts into a “beauty for beauty’s sake” fashion. Ironically, this anti-industry style became personified by a store, Liberty of London, that mass-produced a signature line of increasingly admired printed silk fabrics, to be sewn by those in the know into loose, f lowing, corset-free Aesthetic gowns. Clothing’s tentative invitation to the club of Western art was ratified at the beginning of the next century by a number of revolutionary modernist movements. The “art into life” impulse of Russian Constructivism was realized by the geometric clothing and textile designs of Lyubov Popova and Varvara Stepanova, two important artists—and women—of that politically fervent time. The Italian Futurists proposed a complete break with behavioral habits of the past, and manner of dress did not escape their scorn. Giacomo Balla’s Futurist Manifesto of Men’s Clothing (1913) passionately decried as passé suits that were “tight-fitting, colorless, funereal, decadent, boring and unhygienic” and called for the abolition of “wishy-washy, pretty-pretty, gloomy, and neutral colors, along with patterns composed of lines, checks and spots.” So what should his man of the future wear? “Hap-hap-hap-haphappy clothes, daring clothes with brilliant colors and dynamic lines.” Symmetry in tailoring was banished: “The cut must incorporate
Is Clothing Art?
71
dynamic and asymmetrical lines, with the left-hand sleeve and left side of a jacket in circles and the right in squares.” Balla wanted this sartorial adrenalin to zip in and out of style as fast as the latest locomotive, “in order to encourage industrial activity and to provide constant and novel enjoyment for our bodies.” Although the artist proudly wore examples of his own design (one photo shows colored triangular shapes sewn into a rather droopy jacket), Balla’s pronouncements were never brought into real production; his clothing ideas, the neckties made of wood and embedded with f lashing lights, were intended more to shock, to jump-start an aesthetic of change. The movement’s later art clothing backed away from the edge: vests by Fortunato Depero from the 1920s are surprisingly traditional shapes decorated with high-contrast but symmetrical appliqué. Only a jacket from the 1930s by Tullio Crali, with no lapels, pockets, or buttons, seems to stride Futurist innovation and commercial possibility. Still, the Futurists wore their art on their sleeves unequivocally. The Russian-born, Paris-based modernist who most clearly saw the connection between art and clothing, the “soft Cubist” painter Sonia Delaunay, also divided them, via her commercial fashion success; she was an originator of the concept of prêt-a-porter, or off-the-rack, clothing production and sales. Wearing her zigzag-bordered, early-Deco outfits—made from gem-hued scraps of tulle, f lannel, silk—all around town, Delaunay never doubted that clothing could be art. In 1925, her fashion designs were shown at the Exposition Internationale des Arts Décoratifs, and she gave a pioneering lecture at the Sorbonne about the inf luence of painting on clothing. The artist also collaborated with the less art-connected designer Coco Chanel; later, Delaunay goods were sold on both sides of the Atlantic, not in galleries, but (surprise!) department stores. As the twentieth century proceeded, it seemed that a piece of handmade clothing could be art either if it belonged to the prevailing artistic style universe, or if the hand that made it was attached to an artist. Does that mean factory-made, ready-to-wear duds can’t be art? Or that great, original couturiers, such as slinky bias-cut innovator Madeleine Vionnet or dramatic architect of fabric volume Charles James, created objects that cannot be considered art because the creators did not call themselves artists? I would like to propose that just as a clay bowl or puzzle cup by turn-of-the-last-century maverick George Ohr (who proclaimed himself “the world’s greatest potter”) can be displayed, priced, collected, and appreciated as art, so may articles of clothing, unique or even
72
Jeff Weinstein
mass-produced—“multiples,” in the vein of artist Joseph Beuys’ felt suits. To judge whether they are good or bad art remains the task of viewers, critics, and even those who dare to wear the art in question. How is clothing art? It’s a form of soft sculpture. It’s a vessel for the body; the body completes the artwork. It partakes of many mediums— any and all fabrics, leather, paper, rubber, string, chain links, paper clips, you name it. Like all art, clothing acknowledges history, yet at its most ambitious tries to supercede it. Like painting or traditional sculpture, clothing can be abstract or representational—or neither. (How would you fit a pair of Levis into these categories?) All clothing is interactive if worn, communicative if worn in public because it contains codes, which can refer to age, gender, race, income, taste, social aptness, or “suitability.” The clothing we remember often draws its artistic power by reminding us just how striking, how beautiful, created objects can be, and how in clothing’s case that beauty multiplies in motion. In case it isn’t clear, clothing is art mostly because it successfully challenges art-or-not categories. Although museums have collected clothing for years and displayed their homespun smocks and frayed velvet bustles as quaint anthropological artifacts, this began to change about the same time Kawakubo threw her complicated wares up for sale. The Brooklyn Museum displayed Charles James’ pearlescent taffeta gowns on sculptural pedestals; art critics, not fashion writers, were assigned to review them. Longtime art worlder Richard Martin took over the galleries of New York’s Fashion Institute of Technology and mounted blockbuster shows such as “Fashion and Surrealism,” which brought clothing designer Elsa Schiaparelli and artist Man Ray (who was a fashion photographer too) into the same aesthetic arena; Martin went on to replace Vogue magazine icon Diana Vreeland and run the popular fashion shows at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Even serious art destinations like the Guggenheim Museum attempted to cash in on crossover enthusiasm with a display of Giorgio Armani’s wares that many thought turned the Frank Lloyd Wright fixture into a just another Fifth Avenue boutique. This writer himself had the giddy-making experience of seeing his much-used black winter coat—I won’t bore you with details of who designed it and when—as the very final item, the only male item, in a clothing-as-art museum exhibition a few years back. When the show came down, the coat was returned, nicely cleaned and pressed, and it still sits in the closet, taunting its owner to take it off the hanger, put it on, and walk out into the rain.
CH A P T E R
T E N
Fashion Advice from the Anti-Christ Lydia Hartunian
“God is dead. God remains dead. And we have killed him. How shall we, the murders of all murders, console ourselves?”1 With a complete fashion makeover—an exfoliation of every religious pore, a bonfire for all festering threads! Remove the Christian paint from your nails, the spiritual tonic from your hair, steep yourself in an Dionysian bath to kill all semblances of indecency, and what will you have? The Beautiful Anti-Christ—the proper way to look and feel human. “I teach you the overman. Man is something that shall be overcome. What have you done to overcome him?”2 While you probably don’t don a ‘habit’ and the black clothes you adorn are probably not the grim frocks of the Amish chances are still good you are a fashion disaster sporting the latest in Christian Design. “One should not embellish or dress up Christianity—it has waged a war to the death against the higher type of man.”3 Take a look at your fashion pile—the heaps of sick clothing, decadent beauty products, cowardly footwear, and weary accessories all of which f latter you only in so far as they destroy you—and ask yourself the following: How many items in your pile were purchased with good will or worse yet, at Good Will? (“I simply won’t buy Nike products.”—“I give my old clothes to charity.”) “What is more harmful than any vice? Active sympathy for the ill-constituted and weak—(Christianity.)”. “Man is finished when he becomes altruistic.— Instead of saying simply ‘I am no longer worth anything’ the moral lie in the
74
Lydia Hartunian
mouth of the decadent says, ‘nothing is worth anything—life is not worth anything’. . . .”4 How many items do you wear with deception? (“I look good in this.”—“These pants makes me look slim.”) “[O]ne is deceived about many things in man because many a shell is shabby and sad and altogether too much shell. Much hidden graciousness and strength is never guessed; the most exquisite delicacies find no tasters. Women know this— the most exquisite do: a little fatter, a little slimmer—oh how many destinies lie in so little!”5 How many lies govern your fashion sensibilities? (“Clothes make the man.”—“These clothes are so me!”) “No one is accountable for existing at all, or for being constituted as he is . . . it is absurd to want to hand over [our] nature to some purpose or other.” . . .“I call a lie wanting not to see something one does see, wanting not to see something as one sees it . . . the most common lie is the lie to oneself.”6 How much weakness does your fashion sense succumb to? (“I wish I could wear that but fear it will be inappropriate.”—“I was so embarrassed by how I looked.”) “To him who has knowledge man himself is ‘the animal with the red cheeks.’ How did this come about? Is it not because man has been ashamed too often? ..[S]hame, shame, shame—that is the history of man.”7 Which items have you purchased without real money or without real purpose? ( “I buy this against money that is not mine and therefore deny myself with this purchase.”—“Botox.”) “A certain sense of cruelty toward oneself and others is Christian . . .”~ . . . “To cultivate out of humanitas a self-contradiction, an art of self-viloation, a will to falsehood at any price, an antipathy, a contempt for every good and honest instinct! These are the blessings of Christianity!”8 Just how subservient is your style? (“I’d love to see my wife in this!”— “This outfit would be great for work!”) “I pursued the living; I walked the widest and the narrowest paths that I might know its nature. With a hundredfold mirror I still caught its glance when its mouth was closed so that its eyes might speak to me. And its eyes spoke to me. But wherever I found the living, there I also heard the speech on obedience. Whatever lives, obeys.9 Are you so afraid you feel good in your clothes? (“I feel best in jeans and sneakers.”—“I hate when I have to dress up!”) “But why do I speak where nobody has my ears? And so let me shout it in to all the winds: You are becoming smaller and smaller, you small people! You are crumbling, you comfortable ones. You will perish of your many small virtues, of your many small abstentions, of your many small resignations. Too considerate,
Fashion Advice from the Anti-Christ
75
too yielding is your soil. But that a tree may become great, it must strike hard roots around hard rocks.”10 Do your fashion choices speak with “otherness” in mind? (“I hope people will notice me in this”—“I want to be accepted.”) “There are preachers of death; and the earth is full of those to whom one must preach renunciation of life. The earth is full of the superfluous; life is spoiled by the all-too-many. May they be lured from this life with the ‘eternal life’! Yellow the preachers of death wear, or black. But I want to show them to you in still other colors.”11 Now examine your fashion pile again and this time ask yourself how many items were purchased to make you strong—to make you human and unafraid to be human? To make you overcome and take you beyond all notions of good and evil? “Alas, that you would understand my word: ‘Do whatever you will but first be such as are able to will.’ ”12 What’s hot? “All that heightens the feeling of power, the will to power, power itself in man.”13 What’s not? “All that proceeds from weakness.”14 Look at yourself in the mirror—the full length mirror. How’s your posture? Do your shoulders roll down toward the ground you are afraid to walk on? “There he lay now, sick miserable, filled with ill-will towards himself; full of hatred for the impulses towards life, full of suspicion of all that was still strong and happy. In short, a ‘Christian.’ ”15 Do you dress to conceal? “I want to speak to the despisers of the body. I would not have them learn and teach differently, but merely say farewell to their own bodies and thus become silent. I want to speak to the despisers of the body. It is their respect that begets their contempt. . . . Even in your contempt, you despisers of the body, you serve yourself. I say unto to you, your self itself wants to die and turns away from life.”16 Women, how much makeup do you wear? “Comparing man and woman generally, one may say that woman would not have the genius for adornment, if she had not the instinct for the secondary role.”17 Men, do you even fit in to your primary role? “To be true—only a few are able! And those who are still lack the will. But the good have this ability least of all. Oh, these good men! Good men never speak the truth; for the spirit, to be good in this way is a disease. They give in, these good men; they give themselves up; their heart repeats and their ground obeys: but whoever heeds commands does not heed himself.”18 What color is your hair—are you afraid to “go blonde”?
76
Lydia Hartunian
“One may be perfectly justified in being always afraid of the blonde beast that lies at the core of all aristocratic races, and in being on one’s guard: But who would not a hundred times prefer to be afraid, when one at the same time admires, than to be immune from fear, at the cost of being perpetually obsessed with the loathsome spectacle of the distorted, the dwarfed, the stunted, the envenomed?”19 How sanguine are your shoes? “The fear of pain, even infinitely small in pain, cannot end otherwise than in a religion of love.”20 Are you gloveless too often? “[O]ne does well to put gloves on when reading the New Testament. The proximity of so much uncleanliness almost forces one to do so.”21 Do you blend with the crowd? “No Shephard and one herd! Everybody wants the same, everybody is the same: whoever feels different goes voluntarily into a madhouse.”22 How remembered will you be tomorrow for how you look today? “The great lie of personal immortality destroys all rationality, all naturalness of instinct—all that is salutary, all that is life-furthering, all that holds a guarantee of the future in the instincts henceforth excites mistrust. So to live that there is no longer any meaning in living: that now becomes the meaning of life . . .”23 Just how bacterin is your beauty? “What a monster of falsity modern man must be that he is none the less not ashamed to be called Christian!”24 do you even see yourself?!? “Faith has been at all times . . . only a cloak, a pretext, a screen, behind which the instincts played their game—a shrewd blindness to the dominance of certain instincts.”25 “I give a few examples of what these petty people have taken into their heads, what they have put in to the mouth of their Master: confessions of ‘beautiful souls’ one and all.”26 Are you able to look in the mirror and say, this is the hair I wish to have for all time—this is the ass I can take to my grave, these are the shirts, the shoes, the suits I will wear forever? “What if some day or night a demon were to steal after you into your loneliest loneliness and say to you: ‘This life as you now live it and have lived it, you will have to live once more and innumerable times more; and there will be nothing new in it, but every pain and every joy and every thought and sigh and everything immeasurably small or great in your life must return to you— all in the same succession and sequence—even this spider and this moonlight between the trees, and even this moment and I myself. The eternal hourglass of existence is turned over and over, and you with it, a grain of dust.’ Would you not throw yourself down and gnash your teeth and curse the demon who spoke thus?”27
Fashion Advice from the Anti-Christ
77
Cast off the nauseating spectacle of your style—make room for those who care of their manner! “My mind and my longing are directed toward the few, the long, the distant; what are your many small miseries to me? You do not yet suffer enough to suit me! For you suffer from yourselves, you have not yet suffered from man.”28 So who amongst us can pave the fashion way? Supermodel as Übermensch? “Obey must woman, and find a depth for her surface. Surface, is woman’s soul, a mobile stormy film on shallow water.”29 Madonna? Brittney? Paris? “Let me speak to [you] of what is most contemptible: but that is the last man . . . . Alas the time of the most despicable man is coming, he that is no longer able to despise himself. Behold I show you the last man. . . .‘We have invented happiness’ say the last men, and they blink.”30 Pamela Andersen? “When a woman has scholarly inclination there is generally something wrong with her sexual nature.”31 Sean John Diddy Daddy Puff P.? “You have made your way from worm to man, and much in you is still worm.”32 The Hollywood Red Carpet? “I walk among these people and I keep my eyes open: they have become smaller and they are becoming smaller and smaller; but this is due to their doctrine of happiness and virtue. For they are modest in virtue, too—because they want contentment. But only a modest virtue gets along with contentment. To be sure, even they learn in their way to stride and to stride forward. I call it their hobbling. Thus they become a stumbling block for everyone who is in a hurry. And many among them walk forward while looking backward with their stiff necks.~ Some of them are genuine, but most of them are all bad actors.”33 The Queer Eye? “For to-day have the petty people become master: they all preach submission and humility and policy and diligence and consideration and the long et cetera of petty virtues. Whatever is of the effeminate type, whatever originates from the servile type, and especially the populace-mishmash:—THAT wisheth now to be master of all human destiny—O disgust! Disgust! Disgust!”34 The Gap? “I mistrust all systematizers and avoid them. The will to a system is a lack of integrity.”35 The Catholic Church? “Yet the priests are, as is notorious, the worst enemies—why? Because they are the weakest. Their weakness causes their hate to expand into a monstrous
78
Lydia Hartunian
and sinister shape, a shape which is most crafty and most poisonous. The really great haters in the history of the world have always been priests, who are also the cleverest haters—in comparison with the cleverness of priestly revenge, every other piece of cleverness is practically negligible.”36 Marilyn Manson? “The noble type of man regards himself as a determiner of values; he does not require to be approved of; he passes the judgment: “What is injurious to me is injurious in itself”; he knows that it is he himself only who confers honor on things; he is a creator of values. He honors whatever he recognizes in himself: such morality is self-glorification. In the foreground there is the feeling of plentitude, of power, which seeks to overflow, the happiness of high tension, the consciousness of a wealth which would fain give bestow:—the noble man also helps the unfortunate, but not—or scarcely—out of pity, but rather from an impulse generated by the superabundance of power. The noble man honors in himself the powerful one, him also who has power over himself, who knows how to speak and how to keep silence, who takes pleasure in subjecting himself to severity and hardness, and has reverence for all that is sever and hard.”37 Where is your courage when you dress? How brave is your beauty? Just how long is the hour of your fashion contempt? “What is the greatest experience you can have? It is the hour of the great contempt. The hour in which your happiness, too, arouses your disgust, and even your reason and your virtue.”38 God is dead. God remains dead—and you have killed him. Time to start looking the part, oh marvelous murderer! And be sure to schedule plenty of time for your makeover—plan for at least another 6 million years for your style to evolve. But start now! “In the end one might reasonably ask oneself whether it was really not an aesthetic taste which blinded man for so long: it desired a picturesque effect from truth—it desired especially that the man of knowledge should produce a powerful impression on the senses. It was our modesty that offended their tastes the longest . . . Oh how well they divined that fact—those turkey-cocks of God!”39 That which does not kill you will definitely make you look and feel better.40 Notes 1. Friedrich Nietzsche, The Portable Nietzsche, trans. Walter Kaufmann (New York: Viking Press, 1968), 172. Cf. also Friedrich Nietzsche, The Gay Science, trans. Walter Kaufmann (New York: Vintage Books, 1974), 134. 2. Friedrich Nietzsche, The Twilight of the Idols and the Anti-Christ, trans. R.J. Hollingdale (New York: Penguin Books, 1977), 124.
Fashion Advice from the Anti-Christ 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
16. 17. 18. 19. 20.
21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37.
79
Ibid., 129. Ibid., 128 and 98–99. Nietzsche, The Portable Nietzsche, 306. Nietzsche, The Twilight of the Idols and The Anti-Christ, 65 and 186. Nietzsche, The Portable Nietzsche,200. Nietzsche, The Twilight of the Idols and the Anti-Christ, 143 and 198–99. Nietzsche, The Portable Nietzsche, 226. Ibid., 283. Ibid., 56–57. Ibid., 284. Ibid., 127. Ibid., 127. Ibid., 67. See also “Christianity is a revolt of everything that crawls along the ground directed against that which is elevated; the gospel of the lowly makes low . . .” Nietzsche, The Twilight of the Idols and the Anti-Christ, 169. Nietzsche, The Portable Nietzsche, 147. Friedrich Nietzsche, Beyond Good and Evil: Prelude to a Philosophy of the Future, trans. Walter Kaufmann (New York: Vintage Books, 1966), 145. Nietzsche, The Portable Nietzsche, 312. Friedrich Nietzsche, On the Genealogy of Morals and Ecce Homo, trans. Walter Kaufmann (New York: Vintage Books, 1969), 63. Nietzsche, The Twilight of the Idols and the Anti-Christ,154. See also “But I say unto you: your love of your neighbor is your bad love of yourselves. You flee to your neighbor from yourselves and would like to make a virtue out of that: but I see through your ‘selflessness,’ ” Nietzsche, The Portable Nietzsche, 172. Nietzsche, The Twilight of the Idols and The Anti-Christ, 173. Nietzsche, The Portable Nietzsche, 130. Nietzsche, The Twilight of the Idols and The Anti-Christ, 168. Ibid., 162. Ibid., 163. Ibid., 171. Friedrich Nietzsche, The Gay Science, trans. Walter Kaufmann (New York: Vintage Books, 1974), 134. Nietzsche, The Portable Nietzsche, 400–401. Ibid., 179. Ibid. 129. Nietzsche, Beyond Good and Evil,144. Nietzsche, The Portable Nietzsche, 124. Ibid., 281. Ibid., 399. Nietzsche, The Twilight of the Idols and the Anti-Christ,35. Friedrich Nietzsche, On the Genealogy of Morals and Ecce Homo, trans. Walter Kaufmann (New York: Vintage Books, 1969), 63. Nietzsche, Beyond Good and Evil,144. See also Marilyn Manson, Open Letter to Fans (http:// www.ncf.carleton.ca/~cd100/letter.htm): To whom it may conform: Hello from the gutters of Fort Lauderhell which are filled with piss, disease and broken toys. Hello from Marilyn Manson. We are your shit. You should be ashamed of what you have eaten. I am writing on behalf of my band, who has adopted my namesake as a mockery of your fixation with the grandiose “stars” that litter your television screens daily. I am the “All American” anti-Christ bathed in talk show—trash, here to help hysterical housewives wallow in their own
80
Lydia Hartunian
suffering. I have predicted the past. I am the accuser. Marilyn Manson is the harvest of thrown away kids, and America is now afraid to reap what it has sown. You have spoon fed us Saturday Morning mouthfuls of maggots and lies disguised in your sugary breakfast cereals. The plates you made us clean were filled with your fears. These things have hardened in our soft pink bellies. We have grown up watching your television, that you put in your homes. We are a symptom of your Christian America, the biggest Satan of all. It’s too late to take it all back. This is your world in which we grow and we will grow to hate you. Love and I am, Mr. Manson. 38. Nietzsche, The Portable Nietzsche, 125. 39. Nietzsche, The Twilight of the Idols and the Anti-Christ, 135. See also “Nothing is beautiful, only man: on this piece of naivety rests all aesthetics, it is the first truth of aesthetics. Let us immediately add its second: nothing is ugly but degenerate man—the domain of aesthetic judgment is therewith defined,” Nietzsche, The Twilight of the Idols and the Anti-Christ, 90. 40. “From the military school of life.—What does not kill me makes me stronger,” Nietzsche, The Twilight of the Idols and the Anti-Christ, 33.
CH A P T E R
E L E V E N
Puro High Life M aythe e Rojas
My earliest memory in life involves being baptized. I remember being passed back and forth between several hands and breaking into a fit of tears when a stream of water was poured over my face. The photographs from the event failed to capture my anxiety, however. Instead, they showcased a striking, young couple posed alongside a set of proud godparents and a blank-eyed priest. Although my parents’ expressions betrayed a certain inexperience, their stylish demeanor suggested sophistication beyond their years. Indeed, in each picture, their sharp outfits somehow overshadowed the parental role that they had dressed that day to assume. My mother, in particular, stands out with her white, almost translucent, skin cast against the brilliant shimmer of her tiny gold mini-dress and matching heels. Atop her head, she wears a round, cream-colored, silk hat with gossamer netting. Emboldened by rich green eye shadow, her golden-speckled eyes complete the auric look. The year was 1971 and my mother was the model image of the time’s fashion. She was, in her own words, a ref lection of “puro high life,” an expression she still uses today. Over time, however, my mother’s term has shifted meaning. Puro high life has gone from being code-switching proof of her successful affectation of the fashionable American elite to betraying the envy she feels as images of privilege and status pass her by. I have grown up understanding life and my mother through these same two dimensions: an ascension into an ultra femme, high fashion lifestyle that brings self-confidence, social acceptance, and an overall sense of pride; and the exclusion, doubt, and shame that follow poverty
82
Maythee Rojas
and personal downfall. My mother comes from two well-known, wellrespected families in Costa Rica. Both gifted her with an automatic pass into the social elite of her small, liberal-minded country. However, the two also left her a legacy of financial loss. Neither family managed its wealth well; instead, gambling, bad investments, and adultery left most of the heirs with only last names to pawn. My mother fared slightly better as her father’s small plots of land and reputation provided her with good social standing and a solid education. She entered adulthood proud and filled with knowledge about a world she was eager to explore. Her marriage to my working-class father who lived in the United States proved to be a test of both. The level of my mother’s social expectations as an immigrant is easily measured by the chic sense of style she employed when attending events with my father. Her hair, professionally styled into a round bouffant or classic chignon, and then later worn long and ironed straight, showed off soft pleated skirts with matching cardigans, empire lined baby dolls splashed in sequin, and f loor length f loral prints with frilled hems. These beautiful outfits were usually offset by intricate jewelry and small beaded clutches with room enough to hold only a silver cigarette case. Although the outings were often to house parties, or events sponsored by Club Latino, a local cultural organization made up of other Latin American immigrants in the area, my mother treated them all as if she were meeting with the heads of state. Not that she would have been the one to talk to them if she had. Although she knew how to dress the part, my mother was not the leader in the pair. It was my father who did the talking. My father was a charismatic man who also enjoyed looking good. As their only child for several years, I recall watching my parents preen and fuss for hours and then sharing in their pride when we were welcomed into people’s homes. Showered in compliments and approving looks, I knew my parents were an immediate hit whenever they walked in together and it was always a thrill to watch. Yet my parents’ stab at the puro high life in the United States lacked an essential ingredient: financial stability. When the 1980s ushered in a new set of rules for fashion, they brought economic demise to my family. Early into the decade, my father was laid off from his aircraft job and he was never able to regain a firm footing in the workplace. In addition, he discovered he was suffering from colon cancer. The disease took him quickly and his death left my mother, at age 36, a single parent of two young girls with few economic resources between them. I tend to divide my life between before my father’s death and after. However, another way to understand it is how my mother’s social
PURO High Life
83
mobility deteriorated as mine seemingly evolved. During what most see as the formative years of one’s life, I negotiated the typical wants of a teenage girl with the realities of our limited family income. My mother tried to erase the gap between the two wherever possible. She bought me designer jean knock-offs from the previous season. She made friends at the local bakery to ensure fulfilling birthdays. She scoured the discount stores months in advance to keep each year’s Christmas tree filled with gifts. Each of these things she managed to do by selling off her inherited Costa Rican properties, parcel by parcel. Eventually, the day came when the land was all gone; by then I had started working and was preparing to enroll in college. I was accepted to an elite, private school in southern California that prides itself on maintaining an Ivy League reputation, complete with all the east coast sensibilities. I knew going in that competing with students prepped for this education would prove a challenge, but I was unprepared for the social stratification that followed. Arriving on campus, I found two divergent fashion camps: the transplanted east coasters sporting khakis and striped polos, and the hippie set (some of them also from the East) donning cork-soled shoes and peasant style skirts. I had never seen a pair of Birkenstocks, but I knew polo shirts only extenuated my large breasts. I was also alarmed because despite a significant weight loss over the summer, as I looked around, I realized I was still heavier than most of my female peers. I reasoned that loose voile dresses would hide the differences between us better. Initially, I was also encouraged about fitting in after being told that my frizzy hair would make great dreads. Aptly, I had failed to inherit my mother’s pin-straight locks. That first week, I rushed out and bought a pair of baggy, purple cropped pants with gold trim and paired them with a billowing, long sleeve white top. I don’t think I had any clue how terrible I looked until a high school friend came to visit and I greeted her in this outfit. The look on her face is still mortifying to remember. While I sighed and pushed those clothes to the back of the closet, I continued to try my hand at the loose baggy wear that was worn by other groups I encountered. In particular, the feminists on campus seemed to revel in the long shapeless dresses they wore to the meetings we mutually attended. Oversized tees and ethnic print pants were equally popular. These fashion choices were not necessarily easier to adopt, but I was very drawn to this community. It was during my conversations with other likeminded women that I started to develop a political consciousness and language of my own. It was in feminist-centered classrooms that
84
Maythee Rojas
I learned of issues that felt profoundly meaningful. It was also through feminism that I gained a tangible framework for reading the literature to which I was so naturally attracted. I am still quite aware that it was within the pages of ethnic American women’s writing that I finally found myself. Unfortunately, however, our feminist community lacked the same mirror. Except for a few of us, the self-identified feminists on campus were white and often upper middle class. Their general approach to fashion ref lected these facts. Their decisions to reject designer labels, feminine dress, and personal grooming were choices they could make. In essence, their rebellion against patriarchal concepts of beauty still left their markers of ethnicity and class intact. At the time, however, I did not realize that the same did not hold true for me; so, like them, I cut curly hair short and dismissed the need for makeup, convinced we shared the same (body) politics. Fashion also found its way into my love life. Early one fall during college, I took a budding love interest shopping with me. Disguised as a search for a new season coat, the trip was mostly an excuse to spend time alone. A coolly styled, camel hair, mid-length jacket in turn played the intermediary. Slipping the garment on, I enjoyed the rub of the coat’s rich fabric against my skin. It felt expensive. At the same time, I noticed José watching and that made me nervous. I rushed over to a nearby mirror to avert his gaze. As I did, I spotted a man out of the corner of my eye also make a mad dash. As I quickly realized though, the plainclothes officer was less interested in the coat’s fit than where I was going with it. His reaction shook me. I was not a thief. Offended, but speechless, I hung up the coat on a nearby rack and walked out. José followed, both of us shaking our heads at the man’s stupidity, but neither of us comfortable enough to discuss why it happened. Later the event ate away at me. My thoughts remained focused on why we had been singled out. I knew our youth fit the average shoplifter profile but I worried that it had more to do with how he saw us. José was darker than me, his indigenous roots still prominent in his features, but we were both very visibly Latino. Neither of us wore anything that resembled a designer brand. In fact, the store itself was far different from the types of places we frequented prior to college. Did these factors add to the typical suspect qualities? Or were it these alone that made us suspects? The following week I was invited to a college party and I asked José to join me. I emphasized that he should dress nicely. That evening, he showed up at my door wearing a powder blue jacket with navy velvet lapels that I knew was straight out of a former quincañera ceremony.
PURO High Life
85
I was immediately embarrassed and tried to coax him out of wearing it. He shrugged off all of my suggestions, determined to keep it on. A friend who witnessed the exchange quietly advised me to let it go. I resigned myself to the situation and we left for the party. Once there, however, I took in the hip, white, wealthy guests and knew I could not be comfortable staying near him. His garish outfit screamed out the humiliation that was still lodged in my throat from days earlier. We talked very little that evening. Instead, I wandered in the party, trying to avoid looking like we were a couple, despite his insistence on trailing behind me. A week later, I found it equally difficult to return his calls. My experience in Spain while pursuing my higher studies brought with it a similar disconnect, even as I found a kind of liberation there. Although still thin, Spanish women dressed quite differently from the campus girls I knew. They wore skirts, scarves, silk camisoles, and even heels on a daily basis. They did not necessarily have extensive wardrobes; they just knew how to wear what they owned. They were also sexy. Short shorts with black tights, for example, were an evening must. While in some of them I saw features similar to my own and in others not, often while I was there I was reminded of my mother. In both dress and demeanor, Spanish women exemplified puro high life. In fact, away from home, I too felt a little high. Being in Spain meant getting the opportunity to travel, try new things, and dance early into the morning. In addition, it meant not having to worry about my family. Thousands of miles between us, we were forced to communicate only intermittently. Many things went unsaid and I used the silence to my advantage. I enjoyed my freedom and pushed back any thoughts that my family was being left out. I spent the money I had brought on train tickets, drinks with new Spanish friends, and an occasional sexy outfit of my own. I used the time away as an opportunity to be responsible only for myself. Only later did I learn from my sister that, while I was away, my family had found it difficult to make ends meet. Without my grocery store credit card to supplement their meals, they were often forced to make potatoes their main dish for weeks at a time. This information was kept from me for over a decade. And, when I returned home bearing souvenirs for everyone, my mother examined each piece, proudly, and sometimes a little shyly, noting how expensive everything seemed. Today I am a professor at a state university, which enrolls a diverse student population from largely working-class background. Its urban environment and proximity to Los Angeles make teaching there both
86
Maythee Rojas
alluring in terms of the rich cultural opportunities and difficult because of the high cost of living. My work experience is also rewarding but complicated because of my role as a Women’s Studies instructor. I have the pleasure of teaching self-selective students who meet with me regularly to discuss the intersections of race, class, gender, and sexuality. Our conversations are often personal and heartfelt. Our shared memories are surprisingly similar. Yet, sometimes, I envy their ability to find themselves so easily ref lected within their surroundings; then, I am reminded of how lucky I was to get the kind of education that allows me to extend that ref lection even further. Moreover, I am struck by the dissonance and similarity that run through our lives. While our ethnic backgrounds and gender draw us together, most of my female students and I now share a broad difference in terms of class. Eating ethnic cuisines other than their own is still foreign to many of them. Visiting distant family members is all the traveling most have done. Participating in the Los Angeles arts scene remains an unusual and distant experience to some. Nevertheless, I stand before them, like them, just not quite. With my doctorate in hand, I appear to have achieved puro high life. I know my mother thinks so. Most learn within minutes of meeting her that her daughter is a doctora. She also uses this fact to justify my purchases when she accompanies me shopping. Expensive leather boots? Well, with all the work I do—¡hay que disfrutar! A designer dress marked down? What a steal—¡no le de gusto al Diablo! Fine tailored pants? Don’t forget who you are—¡sos una profesional! Although several years of sustained financial stability have not erased her own hesitation to overspend, my mother believes it is a right I have earned along with my education. Perhaps she sees it as a recuperation of sorts. Lost to her, but returned to me. Yet, my financial stability is not that secure. How does being puro high life play out if I am forced to live in a cheap apartment, where I have to avoid leaving or walking to my car in high heels for fear of having to break into a run should someone chase me? A friend once reminded me that crossing the threshold into the thirties justifies indulging in expensive shoes and makeup, but doing so means I have to sacrifice something else. Although I make more money than my parents ever did, college loans and the price of living in an expensive city leave my education-achieved middle-class status lacking the financial backing to go along with it. Consequently, I often ask myself what my “fashion statement” is as a college professor. Indeed, what should a feminist wear? In graduate school, I learned that being seen as an authority figure required more than a thorough knowledge of my academic field. Living in Arizona
PURO High Life
87
without a car, I depended on my bicycle for transportation and a backpack big enough to carry a second set of clothes to look acceptable. Each day, inside the women’s bathroom, I exchanged sweaty tee shirts and jean shorts for dresses and nice shoes. I applied lipstick and perfume and ran gel through my curly hair to smooth back the frizz brought out by the bike ride, all in an attempt to earn a respectability that was effortlessly awarded to my male counterparts in the department. Students looked past their torn jeans, cargo shorts, and shaggy beards and saw authority in my colleagues’ demeanors. They looked at me and wondered how much they could get away with. Although now a professional, I still find myself maneuvering through these issues of visibility. Fashioning my identity as a professor requires me to continually negotiate the formality of my dress in order to maintain authority with how my (adorned) body is read through both its distance and nearness to my students. This is a difficult balance. While I may be able to provide a successful feminist model that does not require the rejection of traditional cultural ideas of femininity, I still run the risk of reinforcing other stereotypes. Similarly, while my education and fashion choices may suggest a perceived middle-class status, I remain distant from being able to fully enjoy its comforts. Instead, my life experiences leave me more aware of the contradictions implicit in reaching for the “high life.” So what do I, a relatively young woman of color professor who grew up poor, represent to students who walk into her classes? I am not sure if they recognize any discrepancies, immediately. Many are just beginning their journey across class lines and they may see me as the end post. Will their crossings echo those that my mother and I took? Will their experiences draw them closer to their families and community? Or, will their successes require them to move further apart? It is difficult to say. Ultimately, I am never sure of what my students think of me. I suspect not that all of my fashion choices appeal to them. I know some of them have never given it any thought. Nevertheless, every semester I receive positive feedback on my choice of footwear. Perhaps this anonymous nod to my fashion sense within the walls of academia by a group of individuals who would have once been my peers means, in fact, that I am finally puro high life. Maybe my mother was right. Note This essay is dedicated to Maria de los Angeles Rojas Volio.
This page intentionally left blank
CH A P T E R
T W E LV E
Irony Killed by the Ironic T-shirt and the True Religion of the American Jean A nne O ’ N e i l
Fashion, while often seen as nothing more than a competition to adorn our bodies in beautiful things, is both a form of expression of individuality and, at the same time, compounded, it is an expression of an entire culture. Person by person, fashion provides a unique form of expression, even as it becomes a subliminal barometer of the political and cultural climate of society. Most people would not deny that trends in art ref lect the intellectual trends of the times. Fashion is little different, and perhaps more immediate because each person’s decision of what to wear is newly made each day. Some people may write off fashion as a frivolous use of disposable income, but in itself, personal style is the most honest form of self-expression because it uses your corporal body and not an external medium to express yourself, and because your body is not only unique and specific to you, but also goes wherever you go with you. From The Parthenon to Piss Christ, Art historians see a direct correlation of art to the artists’ commentary on the current conditions of humanity. If we accept that each person as an individual is making an artistic choice, each day, when they get dressed, we can look at fashion trends as a barometer of a culture’s thinking. For close to a decade I worked as a trend scout in New York City. My job consisted primarily of wandering around New York City and observing what everyone was wearing. Then, depending on for what client (major brands of denim, casual clothing, online shopping, and liquor) I was doing research, I would find people within certain target
90
Anne O’Neil
markets whose taste stood out as exceptional. As a testament to the world we live in today, where Urban Outfitters sells a complete and unoriginal “hipster” kit and Banana Republic sells a complete and unoriginal “acceptable corporate attire” kit, sometimes standing out was as simple as not wearing a black coat. Once located, I interviewed these people in depth about their fashion inspirations, where and how they shopped, what magazines they read, the music they listened to, and what they predicted the upcoming trends would be. The job not only provided me with bounds of primary research into what individuals thought their clothes said about them, but what people thought the meaning and purpose of fashion was. I talked to everyone ranging from 14-year-old girls in prep school, to hip-hop teenagers in Harlem, to Soccer Moms with part-time jobs and to retired 65-year-old executives. Although the people were from all income levels, of different races, vastly varied in educational backgrounds and in a wide distance of ages, almost all people agreed that fashion was the one way they got to communicate who they were before they had an opportunity to say anything. It’s remarkable how similarly people express their individuality. Fashion does the same thing for all different kinds of people: it allows us to tell people who we are. The 45-year-old businessman used his sartorial skills to a different end than a 14-year-old art student, but both used their clothes to express their ambitions to the world without having to vocalize them. The businessman chose his clothes based on what would look both appropriate and successful without appearing too trendy or too garish. The teenager did the opposite: she wore things she’d either made herself or bought at a thrift store and altered to be even unique; with the intention of saying she was a singular person, not a reproduction of anything in a mall. She expressed her individuality while he expressed his achievements, but both told the world who they wanted the world to see when the world looked at them. Many people insist that clothes and fashion are meaningless, but denying the messages clothes send does not mean the messages are not there, even unintentional ones. Some men say, “I just wear what’s clean,” or “I don’t buy clothes,” or “I wear what my wife/girlfriend/ mother gets me,” but saying these things, and looking as if you’re wearing clothes your mother bought you, still says something about who you are. If you wear what your mother buys you, and don’t decide for yourself how you look, you are accepting your genetic fate and you don’t care enough about your appearance to have it ref lect yourself. Plus you are willing to still be the person your mom wants you to be.
Irony Killed by the Ironic T-shirt
91
Saying you don’t care about what you wear is like saying you don’t have any art in your soul. Simply wearing whatever you have can express a certain amount of poverty (or distain for consumerism) and sometimes slovenliness. This is why many poor people are the most fastidious about the cleanliness of their shoes and clothes and most likely to wear the neatest looking clothes. Very rich people, who have always had money and do not need validation by advertising their personal success, are the most likely to wear very reasonably priced clothes, while the arrivistes tend to overcompensate for poverty from which they came by wearing dollar signs, sometimes literally, on their body with ostentatious displays of wealth in boldly branded clothing and gold or gemstones jewelry. As long as garments have existed, they must have been used to identify class. Even within tribal communities the most superior have the finest garments. The obvious comparison of the famous self-portraits from the Renaissance of Albrecht Durer and Parmigianino show fashion’s clear class delineation five hundred years ago. In Durer’s 1498 Self-Portrait, he paints himself as a nobleman, complete with the garb of the nobility with the cloches and the gloves worn by the upper class, instead of as a craftsman and a painter. Parmagianino’s 1424 selfportrait shows the opposite: in a convex mirror he features his naked hands in the forefront, as large as his face, because they are the tools he uses to practice his craft of painting. Durer’s promotion of himself from one class to a higher one, through donning fine clothes, is common practice today. It can be seen particularly well in hip-hop culture. Many Rap artists come from poverty, and reinforce the images of their success by wearing expensive furs and diamonds and obviously displayed brand names all to say, “This cost money.” The kids I interviewed in Harlem were no different. Most of them lived in the projects, but they only wore the finest brands. Particularly trendy at the time were authentic basketball jerseys, which ranged in price from $75 to $250, but these were acceptable only with matching Nikes and the properly coordinated baseball cap. They also wore hip-hop brands like Sean Jean, Enyce, and Bathing Ape, which sell sweatshirts for hundreds of dollars. In this way, they showed themselves to be able to afford clothing above their social status. If fashion is normally used to make yourself look as—or more—important than you are, then, the use of fashion in an overtly political manner by looking less important than you are becomes more significant. I’m sure there were incidences before the French Revolution of people intentionally choosing to dress below their class,
92
Anne O’Neil
but the Sans-Culottes, particularly because they are named for their sartorial choice, stand out since they catalyzed the wearing of pants— which will later become essential to women’s liberation—but without the popularity of pants, jeans could never become the new God. The Sans-Culottes claimed to be people of the lower classes, men in France in the late eighteenth century who wore pants, not the culottes that were fashionable of the day, but many of them were middle class. If they had behaved as middle classes before them, they should have been using their clothes to rise higher socially, but instead thought that men should not be delineated by their attire. In fact, their wearing of pants was meant to unify all men as equals.1 This idea of dressing down as an act of rebellion—or as solidarity with the common man—continued into the twentieth century with the idealism behind the wearing of white t-shirts and denim. Laborers wear work clothes because the garments are comfortable, durable, and useful, but artists, socialists, and idealists began to wear jeans as homage to the open idea of possibility in the American West, as idealized by the mythology of the cowboy in Western novels, Western movies, and history. Cowboys wore jeans by Levi’s and Wrangler, and so should maverick individuals. This idea of the maverick individual, dressed in a white undershirt and jeans, was indelibly burned in the American Psyche with the images of James Dean in Rebel without a Cause, Marlon Brando in Streetcar Named Desire, The Wild One, and On the Waterfront. Paring jeans with a white t-shirt created the cool uniform; it indicated simplicity and independence. I once interviewed a participant at a focus group who pretended to be appalled that he had been chosen to participate in fashion research because he was wearing a white Hanes’ t-shirt and Levi’s. “But that’s a Calvin Klein t-shirt,” I said. I was right and he was shocked that his statement to the world, “I’m plain, look at my talent not at my clothes,” had been outed: wearing the plain uniform was an act of fashion in itself. It was not until printing on t-shirts became commonplace that t-shirts became useful for a more overt form of political statements. The t-shirt had been designed as to be worn underneath respectable clothing, and wearing it alone resonated with the simple honesty of wearing jeans. But all that white space provided real estate between the shoulders, and this was a perfect place to grow political statements. Although the first printed t-shirts were probably supplied by the U.S. Navy, designating the soldier’s division, and then Champion Athletic embossed t-shirts with names of universities, these were all intended to be undergarments.2 Printed T-shirts as outer garments were first used
Irony Killed by the Ironic T-shirt
93
for political statements, particularly Thomas Dewey’s 1948 presidential campaign “Dew It for Dewey” and Dwight Eisenhower’s “I like Ike” t-shirts for the 1952 presidential race.3 It’s not surprising then, considering that t-shirts’ first use was to advertise for universities and politicians, that today most printed t-shirts are imprinted with a brand name like Enyce, Calvin Klein, DKNY, or have a corporate logo like the Adidas three stripes, or say a corporate slogan, like “Just do it.” These t-shirts mean the person wearing them is not only expressing their individuality by showing their support of the brand name or their agreement with the slogan, but they mean that the wearer is now part of the advertising campaign. T-shirts with expressions contrary to the corporate logos became as common as those with them, and the 1960s popularity of Do It Yourself tie-dyes directly combats the walking advertising nature of most t-shirts. Exploring the exception to the rule becomes the most interesting part of the norm. The 1990s began with a def lated idea of possibility: f lower power of the 1960s had lead to nothing more than the disco excesses of the 1970s and the power suit, greed is good—a popular expression on t-shirts—1980s. The disillusioned idealists coming of age in the 1990s gave up trying to say something meaningful on a t-shirt and instead said exactly what we didn’t believe in by wearing used t-shirts with ironic images on them. My personal favorite, as an artist and someone who regularly got arrested for protesting the government, was a heather-red ringer shirt from the FBI Academy, which I found at a thrift store in 1993. The same idea was practiced by stoners in “dare to keep kids off drugs,” skinny unathletic men in t-shirts from sports teams they had never played on, and indie rockers wore concert t-shirts of artists they disliked, like Lionel Ritchie tour shirts from the 1980s. The act of wearing a t-shirt of something you were against, instead of supporting, was a small act of defiance to the corporatization, everything from the stadiums where sports were played down to your own body, and defied the masses who either didn’t notice or didn’t care that not only were they walking billboards, but they were paying to be so. It is Tom Sawyer, getting his friends to pay him to do his chores, come to life without any of the charming picaresque moments. Unfortunately, the ironic t-shirt became a trend and, therefore, it became commodifiable, and more than anything marked the death of irony as a powerful social tool. If I wear a t-shirt to be ironic, that style of t-shirt, or that exact t-shirt, is copied and mass produced by Urban Outfitters, the Gap and Target, then the t-shirt is no longer an ironic individual statement, but a buyable trend and a product that no
94
Anne O’Neil
longer has any individual meaning. Although few people before the past decade ever wore them as ironic, nothing is more ironic than the mass production by huge capitalist brands of t-shirts with the image of Che Guevara, the Cuban Communist revolutionary, which are now sold at endless capitalist establishments, from Nordstrom’s to Kmart. Soon “Kiss me I’m Irish” t-shirts worn by Irish-American girls are not ironic, just trendy, and a football player wearing a football t-shirt bought at Abercrombie and Fitch, instead of wearing his own football team’s shirt, doesn’t say anything political other than people will buy what they’re sold. These days, t-shirt corporations selling “ironic” t-shirts are as common as Clear Channel playing “alternative” music. If irony can be bought and sold it becomes useless for personal and political statements and sincerity has to be the new irony. When you put words on a t-shirt that has a statement, from “I like Ike,” through “Mountain Dew” or “I’m with stupid” or “slut,” you are consciously aware of what you say with your clothes because it is clearly printed. But what about all the subliminal things we say with clothes? Each of us individually decides, each day which clothes to put on so that we are dressed properly for the various tasks we have to complete that day, for how we want to feel—both physically and emotionally— and for how we want to be seen. If that’s true, and many people make similar clothing choices, what can we take as a whole from recent trends as a ref lection of culture and politics? We can look at long-term trends in history, about how upper-class clothes used to take hours to put on and needed a servant to do the dressing and how clothes have changed and most things can be put on without anyone’s help, and that there are clothes made for labor versus clothes made for leisure, and how over the centuries clothing has become more androgynous as the work of the sexes has become more similar, but these have been discussed enough by others and aren’t as interesting to me as the minutia of what seasonal trends in the past decade tell me about the emotional climate of society. I’ve already talked about this to some degree with the overt statements made on shirts, now I’m more interested in the hidden meanings in recent fashion trends. I started working as a trend scout in 2000, when the economy was booming due to growth in the technology businesses. The fashion then was lead by Prada and Alexander McQueen, and mass trends were of clothing that looked high tech and like in it, you could move fast. Fabrics were New Materials like Tef lon, nylon, spandex, and Modal. Shoes were rounded and a cross between athletic wear and loafers. Fashion mimicked the economy: new technology was to be trusted and was the
Irony Killed by the Ironic T-shirt
95
future. The 1980s fashion, including “greed is good” was exuberantly championed after the drab years of irony and grunge. Garish contrary colors and strong patterns that reminded me of Nagel paintings were all the rage.4 All the young Fashionistas I interviewed combed thrift stores for miniskirts and shoulder-padded blouses, still owning the irony by purchasing clothes that two years before they would have called hideous. Then in 2001, when the designers had planned out their next year’s lines with bright black and red palettes, September 11 happened. New York City was attacked by terrorists and suddenly, in the face of tragedy at home, clashing colors mocked the earnestness of those horrified by both the attack and the thought of war. Irony didn’t seem so funny in the face of real destruction. Before the designers could catch up, women clothed themselves head to toe in white, natural fabrics, and pastoral like f lowing skirts as if they were trying to look like an angel. Other cultures, glorified for their perceived spirituality, were looked to for fashion inspiration, particularly Tibetan clothes, resonating of the Zen of the Dali Lama, and Mexican peasant shirts, implying a closer understanding of nurturing the Earth. Even haircuts, which had trended toward short choppy and severe a-line cuts, returned to Pre-Raphaelite locks of long wavy natural hair. The Earth mother style didn’t last long. Once the shock of the attack passed, people slipped back into unawareness and went back to buying clothes without noticing what they were saying. By the time America declared war on Iraq, the major trend in women’s fashion was for military-inspired clothing. Joie came out with a line of cargo pants made out of silk, which imitated Army pants. The pants, while sympathizing with the armed forces, mocked them, because, for sure, the wearer of those pants was not going to have to fight for anything herself; not only was the fabric too delicate to withstand crawling on the ground or any physical labor but the pants were too sheer to carry anything, certainly not weapons, in the pockets. Anyway, anyone who could afford $200 for a pair of pants wasn’t going to be drafted or have to use the GI bill to go to college. You couldn’t kick a pigeon in New York City in 2002 or 2003 without hitting a fashionista in these pants, or similar pants by Ya-Ya or the hundreds of similar copy-cats that f lew off the shelves. Meanwhile Diesel outfitted Club Kids men with Army-inspired caps and commando style camo pants. The irony of war protesters wearing Army surplus pants was lost in a wave of prowar clothes. While these trends hit the trendy boutiques, the twee mascots arrived to comfort those lost without their ironic t-shirts. If irony was dead,
96
Anne O’Neil
something adorable had to replace it. In 2002 it was sparrows, probably instigated by the popularity of Sailor Jerry tattoos. In 2003 unicorns were everywhere, exacerbated by the popularity of the Canadian Indie rock band The Unicorns, celebrated by Vice magazine. By 2004 as a result of the growing aviary fad, Urban Outfitters commoditized birds as a whole and associated a specific bird with each of their American stores. The bird fad could be looked at as a result of the dove being a symbol of peace or perhaps the image of freedom associated with being able to f ly away. By 2005 woodland creatures popped up everywhere, populating clothes, music and art with deer, skunks, chipmunks and birds everywhere you looked. The pack of wolves that surfaced in music—Wolf Parade, Wolf Mother, We are Wolves and Sea Wolf— could have been an attack on the proliferation of fuzzy animals in art, fashion and music—The Dears, the Unicorns, and Panda Bear—but more likely it was just a more manly woodland creature to satisfy the twee needs of the more masculine. By 2006 charming whales were on everything from DYI art posters to JCrew shoes, and Owls peaked out of designer jacket linings. But by 2007 the cute mascots were returning to technology. Adorablized robots were the new sparrows. One of the most striking incidences of cultural reaction, unconsciously hidden within fashion, is in the current craze for designer denim. Religious integrity used to provide armor from the ferocities of American life: if a religious person could not always meet their fiscal needs, or was outdone socially by their neighbor, this person could be secure in her spiritual superiority and her guarantee of a better afterlife. But, as traditional religions wane in importance to metropolitan Americans, some follow fad religions propagated by celebrities—like Tom Cruise with Scientology or Madonna with Kabala—and some follow the religion of Designer Jeans. The divide between those who are religious and those who are not is probably closely correlative to those who would not spend $200 on a pair of jeans and those who would. Sundays that used to be spent in church are now spent buying denim made by True Religion, Blue Cult, and Seven Jeans for all Mankind, and Citizens of Humanity. Possibly the church of jeans is the only spiritual outlet for someone capable and willing to pay $285 for a pair of holy jeans that will be out of style within the year, but like most who join a cult, the consciousness of doing something foolish is overpowered by the appeal of belonging to a club. Calling a garment that costs $200 a garment “For all Mankind” is particularly spiteful, if you are aware that 42 percent of the population has an average income of less than $1000 a year.5 Therefore, that one pair of jeans would be one-fifth
Irony Killed by the Ironic T-shirt
97
of their income for the entire year on one garment. The brand name is somewhat disrespectful of who all of mankind is, unless perhaps the namer of the jeans thought that all of mankind is involved with these jeans in a trickle down way that includes consideration that some of the poorest people in the world work in sweatshops where the jeans are made, and some of the middle class people in the world are laborers who grow cotton and dyes used in producing the fabrics, or transport and handle the jeans and deliver them then to the elite population of the world who have disposable income to purchase the pants, and thus cover the breadth of all mankind. But mostly “for all Mankind” was a ref lection of the low-cut, snug fit of these jeans on women’s derrieres, thus providing enjoyment for all the men of mankind. The mania of American Fashionistas for designer denim can be traced back to the 1960s, when Levi’s and Lee began to make tailored jeans to specially fit and f latter women.6 The original ethos of jeans, as I mentioned earlier, was connected with the American spirit and the idea of individualism through Westerns and James Dean. The first designer jean revolution, lead by Calvin Klein and Gloria Vanderbilt toward the end of the 1970s, politically changed denim to mean the opposite of what it had meant before. Until then, jeans had been inexpensive and utilitarian; they were made by unions for the people to work. With the introduction of designer jeans, Calvin Klein’s in 1977 for $35 a piece,7 denim was no longer just the fabric of the people. Designer jeans priced themselves, like all high fashion, out of the range of the masses. When the first designer jean fad ebbed in the late 1980s with the decline of Guess jeans, it was replaced by an obsession for vintage denim in the early 1990s. Again, the origin of the infatuation in vintage denim, primary in collectors item Big E and Red Lines, but also with Wranglers, Lee, Landlubber and Smith’s, was rooted in thrift store culture and a nostalgia for both the innocence of the past, unsullied by brand name prices, and a quest for the original quality level of a pant made to withstand work and not just uphold the behind. Like many trends that began with intention, the quest for the integrity of vintage jeans was soon overtaken with the commoditization of them. A pair of Levi’s that was once worn to work, became valued for it’s esoteric elite fashion meaning. What would have been just another pair of dungarees to my father, in the 1990s, I searched for as a coveted pair of a 1950s Big Es, unique for not only the cut, the color of the fabric, the big E instead of little e on the label, the red line salvage cut seams, but for its rarity and, therefore, its price. A pair of Big Es sold at Aardvark’s Odd Ark on Melrose Blvd for $1000. Rumors said that they sold to the Japanese
98
Anne O’Neil
for even more than that. Levi’s jeans, which had used to be common in thrift stores, began to disappear, purchased by vintage buyers before they reached Salvation Army and St. Vincent De Paul f loors, and even when you found them there, their prices jumped, for even the usually unfashionable people running charity thrift stores saw the market for these previously owned work pants as a commodity. It was this craze that began the current passion for designer denim. In 1998 I bought my first pair of Earl Jeans. They were like the Levi’s and Wranglers I had altered myself, but had been done more professionally and provided a more attractive fit on a woman. Finally, someone was selling men’s jeans for women, so what if they cost $125? At least I didn’t have to do the work myself. The next few years saw waistbands going lower and lower and the prices going higher and higher. The first brands to the market kept the traditional ethos of denim, the rugged independence of cowboys, and used manly monikers like Earl and Joe’s, but as the trends exploded, and the market was viable for anyone with indigo and a good pocket logo, so denim brands proliferated the meaning of denim changed. Brands like Levi’s, Lee, and Earl no longer mattered, now jeans were mythologized themselves and didn’t need a cowboy to have their back. The new jeans brands expressed a spiritual ethos: Seven Jeans for All Mankind, Citizens of Humanity, True Region, Blue Cult, Earnest Sewn, People’s Liberation, and Rock and Republic. As if somehow spirituality was fulfilled in a good fit, a cool logo on a pocket and that somehow these dungarees, like the Tibetan shirts of 2002, brought the wearer to someplace more honest and meaningful. Clothing is one of the few unifying art forms. Each person is born with one body, which each day they get their own canvas into an art piece. As an individual you can express a mood, an ambition, a political statement, or even an act of love. In your daily life how you use that canvas is important only in relation to how those around you perceive you and understand you. But as a society, what you say as an individual, when combined with what all the other individuals around you are saying, says something about the cultural and political trends in the world. With all the options of attire, fashion is made not really by those doing something unique, but by the trends of people doing the same thing. Commando pants in a time of war say “go kill” and t-shirts that say “Slut” say “don’t respect me,” so looking for spiritually in jeans just seems to be taking the emptiness of today’s American society. With no intellectual icons and no spiritual guidance, perhaps the best thing we have to look forward to in America is a perfect fit.
Irony Killed by the Ironic T-shirt
99
Notes 1. Robert Schwartz, “Fact and Fiction of the Sans Culottes Movement,” http://www. mtholyoke.edu/courses/rschwart/hist255/la/sans-culottes.html” 2. Mark Dixon, A T-Shirt History: From Underwear to Outerwear, http://www.markedixon.com/ new_page_10.htm 3. Virginia Linn, “History of the T-shirt,” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, Pittsburgh, February 13, 2007. 4. Style.com, “Ready to Wear,” Fall 2001, http://www.style.com/fashionshows/powersearch/ results?&ca=search&site=style&event=show362&showCode=show362 5. “Two-Year-Average Median Household Income by State: 2003–2005.” U.S. Census Bureau. Page Last Modified: August 29, 2006. http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/income/ income05/statemhi2.html (last accessed May 14, 2007). 6. James Sullivan, Jeans: A Cultural History of an American Icon (New York: Gotham Books, 2006), 160. 7. Ibid., 159.
This page intentionally left blank
CH A P T E R
T H I RT E E N
Jackie O., Or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love My Chanel Elle n Fri dland and A ndrew Porte r
Introduction Fashion suffers from a bad reputation. Despite the fact that a culture’s norms and values are often revealed through its popular, occupational, recreational and religious dress, fashion is considered a petty distraction. One only need glance at modern public and academic culture to observe two boilerplate criticisms of fashion; while one objection deems fashion superficial, the other pronounces it wasteful. The first critic, the ascetic, claims that fashion unduly focuses attention on what is ultimately unimportant, namely, physical appearance. This position locates its origins in an ancient metaphysics that discounts the physical for the spiritual.1 The proper object of human attention, it is claimed, is what lies beyond the surface: the inner life or the life of the intellect. Whereas the ascetic critic judges fashion as trivial, the second critic, the egalitarian, condemns fashion as economically and socially irresponsible.2 According to her, fashion amounts to a squandering of resources. The egalitarian suggests that fashionable individuals ought to focus their attention and resources on improving social welfare rather than on improving their shoe collections.3 Considering the pertinacity of these two criticisms, fashion’s survival seems perplexing: if fashion is so detestable, then why does it survive so persistently and ubiquitously? If fashion is worthless, then
102
Ellen Fridland and Andrew Porter
why does it attract the attention of so many? These questions point to a tension between the propensity to expend mental and financial resources on appearance and the simultaneous proclivity to denounce its importance. Is fashion just aesthetic junk food? Is the tension resolvable only by cutting it out of our diet? Well, the tension reaches into the life of almost every member of a modern society. We are all told, in a pretty deep-seated way, that we must look good and also, that to spend time and money on looking good is a waste. We obey both imperatives: we all want to be attractive and we all want to be authentic. Fashion commands the attention (to a greater or lesser extent) of each and every person about to leave his home to enter a public space.4 The fact remains that it is much easier to stand before other people than it is to stand before a mirror and claim that appearance is unimportant.5 And still, the above criticisms have seeped so deeply into our culture that even unabashedly fashion-driven publications and TV programs self-censor. They reiterate clichés such as “what’s important is what’s on the inside” and “outer beauty is a ref lection of inner beauty,” thus creating not only tension, but also hypocrisy. This attempt to downplay fashion’s importance through both calculated and involuntary deception is evident through public, academic, and religious denouncements. So, what is one to do? In this essay, we resolve this tension by investigating an activity that is shrouded within fashion. Immune to charges of superficiality and excess, this activity is the genuine locus of fashion’s value; this activity, we claim, is personal style. This is fashion, the organic version—it’s good for everyone. In this essay, we demarcate the nature and significance of personal style as an intentionally ref lexive, visually aesthetic and creative activity. Having these features, we claim, makes style remarkably similar to art. By locating style as the locus of value within what has traditionally been understood as fashion, our project defeats the critics through a series of reductio arguments. Section 1: Defining Style (i.e., style seems curiously similar to art) 1.1
Style: Intentional and Reflexive
We begin investigating the phenomenon of style by turning to Jerry Fodor’s “Déjà vu All Over Again: How Danto’s Aesthetics Recapitulates
Jackie O.
103
Philosophy of Mind.” In this article, Fodor recruits H.P. Grice’s theory of meaning for use in explaining aesthetic discernment and engagement.6 Fodor argues that Gricean ref lexivity is a necessary condition not only for communication, but for art as well. That is, if an art object is to be properly so-called, it must satisfy the conditions of Gricean ref lexivity. Gricean ref lexivity stipulates that the speaker’s awareness of the audience as understanding him as intending to communicate to them is central to successful communication. Grice points out that, in communication, a speaker S utters a proposition p to an audience R, expecting that R come to believe p because R is aware of S as speaking p with the intention of getting R to come to believe p. In communication this is obvious: when I speak to you, I expect that you will come to believe certain things that I say because you interpret my speech as intended for your interpretation.7 In the realm of aesthetic presentation, colloquially, we might put the Gricean condition as follows: “look at me looking at you looking at me.” Fodor argues that for an object to reach the ontological status of “art object,” the artist must create that object with the intention for it to be presented, acknowledging that the audience will view it as intended to be viewed. Although such intentional ref lexivity is not a sufficient condition for art categorization, it is, quite plausibly, a necessary one. So, if we can show that style satisfies the conditions set forth in, from here on, “Fodricean ref lexivity,” then we will have, at the very least, brought style into closer proximity to the realm of art. So, naturally, the first question to ask is: does the styler intentionally present himself to others, expecting that others will recognize him as presenting himself to them? And second, does the audience usually interpret stylers as intending this sort of presentation?8 If we can answer these questions in the affirmative, then it will be clear that styling is, at the very least, communicative,9 and maybe, if it possesses additional features that we discuss below, a unique genre of art. We propose to answer each of the above questions with fairly anecdotal evidence, but we hope that such evidence will sufficiently support our claims. First then, we turn to the styler’s intentions. In order for an individual to meet the conditions of Fodricean ref lexivity, that individual must be aware that she is presenting herself to the public and that the public will react to her as though she is presenting herself to them. Unsurprisingly, this feature of intentional ref lexivity is rather intuitively part of our ordinary judgments about stylish persons.
104
Ellen Fridland and Andrew Porter
Ironically, it is the antistyler or the punk who provides us with the clearest example of this type of intentional ref lexivity. The rebel, whom, while wearing spiked bracelets and dawning a Mohawk, claims to “not care what other’s think” is acutely aware that others will think something. The rebel anticipates attention and denunciation; she knows that people will view her and judge her. She expects that people will understand, through her nontraditional presentation, that she is expressing the fact that she does not care. The antistyler is perfectly inside the style game because it is exactly to say “f*#!*-you” that she wears what she does. If she really didn’t care, she wouldn’t be so concerned to let others know that she didn’t care. This type of not caring is not only a statement but also a scream and, as such, it falls squarely into the satisfaction of Fodricean ref lexivity. This serves as a good example because it is extreme, it magnifies what ordinarily happens in fashion and style: dressing involves intending to present oneself to the world, knowing that the world will be looking and interpreting. Let us now turn to the second question: “Do audiences interpret persons, when they fashion, as presenting something for the audience to interpret?” For many political reasons, most of us will be hesitant to fully endorse the truth of this claim. After all, we’ve all been told a hundred times over never to judge a book by its cover. But often, making judgments of this sort just means being sensitive to the various mediums by which persons communicate. Here we use another extreme example in the hopes that more ordinary cases possess a similar character, but just to a lesser degree. Most persons living in contemporary America will be familiar with the alleged-rape-defense, “she was asking for it.” “She was asking for it” is usually followed by a description of a shockingly short skirt or revealing blouse. We have been taught that such defenses are bogus; and they are. Useful to support our case, however, is what this defense betrays. The “she was asking for it” defense presents us with a clear expression of the fact that we often interpret others as telling us something through their dress. “She was asking for it,” so naively and disturbingly uttered, indicates that it would defy commonsense not to take persons as presenting something for others to interpret by the way they dress.10 And if, by chance, you didn’t know that you told people stuff about yourself through your choice of apparel, fashion magazines will often take the opportunity to remind you: “wear a bright broach, it says “I’m fun.” Style, we have argued, satisfies Fodricean ref lexivity. But there is still much work to do. On Fodricean terms alone, both fashion and
Jackie O.
105
style qualify as equally communicative. For this reason, we now turn to the distinguishing characteristics of style. We hope to convince the reader that style and fashion are distinct and also that style is, if not art, something very much like it. 1.2
Style: Medium and Content
Now that the similarity between style and ordinary communication has been established, we would like to investigate the differences. We intend to do this by attending to two distinct features of style, the first obvious and the second, less so. First, then, while ordinary communication occurs through speech or writing, via a verbal medium, style communicates visually. That is, like painting, photography, sculpture, picture books, and traffic signs, style does not speak in words, but rather expresses itself through images. Second, not only the medium of style but also the content is visual. Style’s goal is not just to express a thought or a command through an image, like a stop sign would, but rather to communicate a visual sensitivity to the elements of beauty and composition; to express a visual aesthetic. The first point then, that style is visual and not verbal, should be obvious. Unless we count t-shirts with messages like, “I’m with stupid” or “I like to party,” as paradigmatically stylish, this point should be beyond contention. Style does its visual presentation through dress, shoes, hairstyle, accessories, jewelry, and body markings—through personal garb and decoration. Couched in this banal observation, however, is a more subtle claim: a visual image is not merely or necessarily a verbal proposition translated into pictures. That is, visually presented content is not necessarily conceptual or linguistic in nature (much to the disappointment of philosophers everywhere). A similar claim has been widely discussed in the attempts to construct the necessary and sufficient conditions for an art object. It seems to follow that, if all visual art were simply a translation of verbal thoughts into images, then conceptual art would be the paradigm example of visual art.11 However, not only has the centrality of conceptual art been challenged, but some have gone so far as to ban conceptual pieces from the realm of art, altogether. Simply put, it seems that the visual arts are not just “sending a message.” They are doing something different; their content is not conceptual but visual. And this seems right, for it seems quite reasonable to suppose that distinct mediums express distinct contents. We should no more expect that a linguistic statement is expressed through a visual
106
Ellen Fridland and Andrew Porter
art object than we should expect that a sensitivity to color schematics is expressed through this essay. This basic point then should apply to our discussion of style; style communicates but what it communicates is neither essentially words, nor necessarily through words.12 Style not only expresses through a visual medium, but what it expresses is visual as well. “But what is it that gets expressed visually?” one may reasonably ask, expecting a reply to be offered in nothing more than words. The problem is that since the content of a visual medium is not necessarily linguistic, it becomes very difficult to express linguistically.13 How can one answer the question: “what is expressed through painting?” besides replying, “which painting do you mean?” or hesitantly providing a cumbersome and incomplete list of intentional contents?14 We propose the alternative is to simply say the following: all visual or graphic arts share in the activities of choice, discrimination, attention and calculation applied to color, proportion, texture, hue, composition, and the like. That is, to reply by saying that what gets expressed in the visual arts is a visual-aesthetic sensibility. The styler, when he dresses, is clearly involved in this type of attention and discrimination. What makes an ensemble “work,” is the various qualities of the articles chosen along with their relationships to one another. Style then is an aesthetic process expressing a visual content though personal presentation. Like the arts, style is concerned not simply with content, but with the presentation of content. 1.3
Style, Imagination, and Creativity
A third constitutive element of style is creativity. This is a vital characteristic of style and ultimately, the one that distinguishes style from fashion. After all, it seems that fashion is just as intentionally ref lexive as style, maybe even more so. And in terms of aesthetic, visual attention, these two practices are arguably on a par. Where style and fashion differ is in individual creativity; that is, the direction of expression. What this means should become obvious in the following section. The basic claim is this: while the individual styler is engaged in a process of imagination and creativity, the individual fashioner is engaged in the activity of mimesis or copying.15 Creativity involves agency, engagement, and attention of a kind that copying lacks. Think of the difference between tracing paper and character development. Although copying may involve technical skill, it does not contribute to the pool of human and existential meaning. Reproduction may add
Jackie O.
107
to the quantity of beautiful things in the world, but ultimately, it will never produce an understanding of what it means to be a beautiful thing, or of what it means to live in a world where there is both beauty and misery. Copying adds nothing new to this most fundamental of human goals: meaning. The distinction between style and fashion as the distinction between creating and copying should resonate on a fairly intuitive level. After all, when we speak of fashions, we speak of many persons participating in them. We cannot call a thing fashionable unless it is popular; that is, unless lots of people do it. How odd it would be to say, “oh, that’s really in fashion this season” and then to add “but I haven’t seen anyone wearing it.” One would be justified in responding to this claim with confusion; we should suspect that the speaker is not familiar with the meaning of the word “fashion.” Importantly, it is not by shear chance that all in the crowds display the same look. There is no accident, no miraculous coincidence when all the girls in town are wearing their jeans tucked into their boots. They all exhibit the same fashion because they are all duplicating the same central models. They are all looking at the fashion magazines and TV shows and at each other and trying to get closer and closer to what they see. They see it, like it, and then do it themselves. They copy. It’s that simple. As opposed to fashion, the styler exerts a unique aesthetic sensibility; a look of one’s own. This is not, of course, to say that this sensibility is unrelated to the fashion world. If it were, there would be no reason to confuse the two for so long. Like fashion, style will be fixed and rooted in a particular time and culture of dress and decor. No one would expect that the requirement for being stylish is being ahistorical. However, the stylish individual does not want to wear what everyone else is wearing in the way everyone else is wearing it. The styler will, more often than not, stop displaying a look when too many people partake in it. The styler moves outward, expanding the porousness of a people and of a culture while the fashionista makes these boundaries collapse onto themselves. Whereas the fashionable person presents the trend of the moment, the stylish person creates it. The styler works the vector and momentum of an era’s garb while the fashionable follow suit. We can justifiably assert that style is what makes fashion tick. Style rescues fashion from redundancy. The difference between fashion and style can be understood through this comparison: whereas in pursuing the goal of fashion, one must
108
Ellen Fridland and Andrew Porter
move toward the center,16 making it ever more difficult to allow for variation and innovation, with style, the opposite is the case. Although there is a center, the outward movement of aesthetic sensibilities is toward the perimeters of what has become accepted and unchallenging. Style pushes the limits outward; it works the boundaries of time and location; of era and culture.17 1.4
Style is art or . . .
We conclude this section by reinstating that style is, if not art, something very much like it. That is, we do not claim to have discovered the necessary and sufficient conditions for art and then proven that style meets them. Instead, we have pointed to some central features of art and shown that style exhibits these features. So, the argument goes something like the following: if X meets the conditions of Fodricean ref lexivity and aesthetic expression and creativity, then X is something very much like art. We hope to have shown that style does indeed satisfy these conditions. What we have not done, nor do we seek to do, is enumerate and justify these conditions as the defining characteristics of art. Nor have we claimed that anything that satisfies these conditions is necessarily art. We have stuck to this weaker claim: style is something very much like art in virtue of sharing many features with it. We show in the next section that this commonality should make style subject to similar normative considerations. 2. The Significance and Location of Style 2.1
The Novel Trend in a Public Sphere
The first and most obvious characteristic that separates style from traditionally recognized art forms, such as painting and sculpture, is its presentational features; style is exhibited in personal dress, decoration, and adornment. The implications of this distinction should be fully appreciated: because of having this essentially “in-the-world” quality, style takes on a unique role in the aesthetic game. Style and fashion (fashion, as argued above, being the practice driven by style) live in the public sphere of social participation and expression. The aesthetic sensibility expressed in style is essentially historical, political, and social in attitude and orientation. This does not entail that such attitudes are articulated ideologies or political theories, but it does
Jackie O.
109
entail that they are necessarily connected to popular culture in virtue of the radically situated and public domain that style gets expressed. Style is not a disconnected universal aesthetic. Style is embedded and embodied; it draws on geographical, cultural, religious, economic, and class conditions. As such, style is a powerful expression of popular attitudes, transitions, and transformations. Just think of the difference between the miniskirt and the hijab. Moreover, in being an activity of imagination and creativity, the styler participates in driving these social practices and attitudes; the styler is not just along for the ride. He is sensitive to popular culture, music, movies, the new generation and its clash with the old, with the folk, the ignorant, the superstitious, the immoral, and the unjust. The stylist must be sensitive to the public dialogue in order to inf luence change and introduce reform. Because the stylist works the perimeters, it is likely that fringe groups and movements are brought into a legitimate public space. Note the rise of Japanese, Indian, Hip-Hop, and Punk designs in modern dress. This sort of familiarization leads to, if nothing more, the recognition that these groups exist. But it can do much more than this. It can also lead to a deepening interest into the history, culture, suffering, and thought of an otherwise unfamiliar people. 2.2
Significant: Yes; Art: No.
We hope that these soliloquies will be read as more than sentiment. We hope that the underlying value of the style practice will be appreciated. However, we anticipate that the reader may be willing to permit the import of style as a social practice while vetoing its invitation into the art world. We would like only to raise the possibility that such an inclination toward rejection may be the result of an overly institutionalized theory of art. Following the Dewian line,18 we would expect that there will be a resistance to judging style to be an artistic process due to the entrenched idea that art and life differ in location.19 Through the institutionalization of art we have come to think that the only things that can be properly called art object are the things displayed outside of life and in the lofty spaces of museums and galleries. However, it is because the process of styling is essentially in the middle of our world that it should be embraced as a unique opportunity to bring an aesthetic, expressive, and intentionally ref lexive activity into our otherwise, all-toopractical routine. It is a way to not only appreciate art, but also to, very
110
Ellen Fridland and Andrew Porter
literally, live artfully. It would not only be chauvinistic but also miserly and prudish to exclude style from the art world on these grounds. 3. Rescuing Style from the Critics 3.1
The Intellectual Criticism: Style Is Superficial
Without denying the Platonic distinction between the imperfect realm of particulars and the eternal perfection of reason, we can answer the ascetic critic. As we have argued, style is in the world, but can only be in the world through the application of reason and intellect. The criteria of style—aesthetic expression, intentional ref lexivity, and creativity—stem from inherently mental and intellectual capacities. So, style cannot be superficial or frivolous; it may find its expression in the physical world, but the practice is very much driven by attention and higher-order cognitive processes. The intelligence at work in aesthetic presentation is not often thought of as intelligence, per se. It may seem that this type of intelligence is intelligence only in the derivative sense of the word. But to believe this would be a mistake. It would be the prejudice of an overly linguistic person to believe that all nonlinguistic expressions, no matter how sophisticated or calculated, are always just second-rate versions of a meaningful proposition. This is simply not true. One should feel very hesitant to, by applying such standards more widely, declare that the works of Picasso, Monet, Degas, and Dali involve less intellectual sophistication than the works of Warhol. Upon ref lection, it should become ever so clear that to manipulate, discriminate, and attend to proportion, ratio, color, historical nuance, and the social psyche requires a high degree of cognitive engagement. As such, the ascetic critic cannot call style superficial or dumb. This activity, although centrally located in the world, is highly cognitive, intelligent, attentive and creative, and as such, a participant in the lofty and respectable world of reason. 3.2
The Egalitarian Criticism: Fashion is Wasteful
The egalitarian who claims that fashion is wasteful cannot declare, with one sweeping motion, that style is wasteful too. By distinguishing fashion from style, it becomes possible to recognize style as an activity living in very close proximity to art. As such, the activity of style possesses cultural, social, and personal value. However, if a critic was
Jackie O.
111
determined to prove that style is wasteful, then she could proceed in one of two ways: (1) she could attempt to prove that style is not related to art in the relevant way; and (2) she could argue that art is wasteful. We hope that this essay has adequately safeguarded against the first option and, as for the second option, well, it seems simply brutish to claim that art is wasteful. After all, it is widely recognized that the particular value of a human life exists in the distinct activities and capacities of a human being: self-consciousness, language, morality, and art. No other species creates objects that have no immediate or practical use. This should not lead us to say that humans should only create what has function, but instead, lead us to consider what this uniquely human expression is. We should value the meaning and significance-creation that we are capable of, and this means valuing art and ultimately style, too. 4.
Metaphysics, Not Epistemology; Failed Art and the Twins Problem
Just in case it wasn’t clear, the above discussion of style was concerned only with the metaphysics of style and not the epistemology of it.20 Although in aesthetics, most discussions concerning “expression” are concerned with the appropriateness and accuracy of applying mental predicates to art objects, this was not our objective here. Instead, we were looking to present the necessary and sufficient conditions governing the activity of style. We were not engaged in the attempt to determine which final products exhibit such characteristics. In particular, our investigation into the nature of style was concerned with demarcating which conscious, mental phenomena constitute the activity of styling; that is, we were concerned with ascertaining the “intentional etiology”21 of personal style in order to determine how it is distinct from other activities that individuals may participate in. The intentional background is absolutely essential for differentiating between style and fashion and between style, bad style, and no style. In the absence of an intentional background, “the twins problem”22 in aesthetics would become our problem with style. But it does not. Much ink has been spilt in the attempt to locate the substantial difference between Warhol’s Brillo Boxes and the cartons of Brillo displayed on supermarket shelves. After all, their presentational features are indistinguishable. It cannot be the color or the composition that makes one art and the other a household cleaner. Intuitively, it seems that the
112
Ellen Fridland and Andrew Porter
intentional processes involved in the creation of one but not the other are the natural contenders for distinguishing the two.23 Likewise is the case for style. A monkey with enough time in a walk-in closet may come out looking sharp, as sharp as James Brown. But since the monkey (unless it was a very sharp monkey, indeed) cannot satisfy the conditions of style due to her innate limitation for sophisticated intentional processing, the monkey, no matter how well dressed, will never be stylish. This monkey in silk clothes is, alas, only a monkey. 24 We hope that this example makes it clear that the intentional etiology of style is a legitimate area of inquiry and criteria demarcation. But the twins problem is not the only issue that makes it legitimate to look at the intentional etiology of an individual in order to determine whether or not the agent meets the conditions for style. Failed style, or bad style, also justifies the orientation of this endeavor. If we were only to look at the final products of style without considering the intentional processes involved in creating these final products, we would be left having to say that anything that did not qualify, under common consensus, as style, would not be style. Our categories would end up stylish or not stylish. We would find it impossible to differentiate between bad style and no style. But surely, just as how bad art is still art, we should want to be able to distinguish between something that is styled badly and something that is not styled at all. Not all attempts at style will succeed, but this does not seem like a good reason to negate the reasonable distinction in intentional processes between one who is trying to style and just lacking the proper skills to do so and one who is not even participating in the style game. Importantly, that an intentional story is central to this inquiry helps us to define style as an activity of an agent and not as an avolitional phenomenon. By focusing on the intentional process,25 but distinguishing it from the resultant product of the process, we are able to speak of the agent’s mental orientation without committing the intentional fallacy. While the intentional fallacy26 asserts that it is necessary to investigate the psychological orientation of the artist in order to accurately interpret an art work, we say that it is essential to ascertain the intentional characteristics of the style process in order to identify the nature of the activity. Not only should it seem straightforward to speak of an activity that is largely intentional in intentional terms, but it should also be obvious that this commitment to intentionality does not force us to state anything about the proper method for interpreting a style object. It should be clear that what an agent attempts to express through a medium and what sorts of statements are true of the medium and its
Jackie O.
113
creation are distinct questions. The concern for us is to describe the activity of an agent who exhibits personal style. 5. Conclusion We hope that this discussion of style has elucidated that part of fashion, which we take to be a vital expression of social and personal creativity. We hope that we have encouraged those of you who were