16531ffirs.qxd
3/19/07
3:12 PM
Page iii
Expert CAD Management The Complete Guide Robert Green
Wiley Publishing, In...
126 downloads
1910 Views
6MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
16531ffirs.qxd
3/19/07
3:12 PM
Page iii
Expert CAD Management The Complete Guide Robert Green
Wiley Publishing, Inc.
16531ffirs.qxd
3/19/07
3:12 PM
Page ii
16531ffirs.qxd
3/19/07
3:12 PM
Page i
Advance Praise Whether he’s demystifying electronic document-management solutions or offering sound advice for justifying training budgets, Robert Green writes as one who intimately knows the CAD manager’s world. When CAD industry veterans seek out CAD Management consultants, Robert Green is at the top of every list. —DOUG WIETBROCK, President, DC CADD The master of CAD Management, Robert continues to be an accurate knowledge base of information. Robert has a great combination of philosophy, real life experience, and raw data that can give you the insight and advantage over your competition. —YOSHI HONDA, President, Pacific CADD Services, Inc. Having traveled with Robert Green to multiple AUGI CadCamps and Autodesk Universities over the past few years, it has been amazing to watch the managers of many firms using Autodesk’s suite of applications, as well as other CADD systems, flock to his classes on CAD Management. His timely tools and ideas have consistently placed him as one of the highest rated instructors and consultants in the Autodesk Community, and NOW, we get a recap of those tools and ideas presented in a book. FINALLY!! Fantastic!! —DAN DOLAN, President, CADLearning by 4D Technologies Robert’s articles continue to provide practical guidance in the face of an everdeveloping CAD industry. The insights he shares have been invaluable in mapping a path for CAD growth in our company for years. —TIM THOMPSON, CAD Manager, PSC, Inc. As a proven leader in CAD management, Robert Green combines his many years as a CAD manager, writer, and trainer to communicate complex topics with ease and enthusiasm. Robert can relate to CAD managers in an understandable and entertaining way that only a fellow CAD manager can appreciate. —HEIDI HEWETT, AutoCAD Technical Manager, Autodesk, Inc. Robert has developed into the premier authority on matters relating to CAD management. His articles are widely read and shared by CAD managers everywhere. —TARA ROOPINDER, Editor, TenLinks.com
16531ffirs.qxd
3/19/07
3:12 PM
Page ii
Robert Green draws on many years of real-world experience as a CAD manager and consultant to deliver recommendations that work for any size and type of organization. He’s the top resource for CAD managers looking to increase performance and efficiency. —SARA FERRIS, technology writer and editor, former editor of Cadalyst I have been a longtime reader of many of Robert’s articles on the subject of CAD and business management and consider Robert to be a clear and focused expert on the topic. In order to be effective as a CAD manager you must stay current and knowledgeable, and Robert has the subject covered for you. —SHAAN HURLEY, Worldwide MyFeedback Programs Mgr., Autodesk, Inc. Surviving in today’s CAD industry means being able to adjust and adapt while managing and elevating a technical staff to greater productivity. With over 20 years of experience, Robert Green is the most accomplished expert I know who understands the issues and pressures revolving around CAD management and has developed a strategy that is clear, concise, and direct in solving those issues. —MATT MURPHY, Speaker/Trainer/Author, ACADventures
16531ffirs.qxd
3/19/07
3:12 PM
Page iii
Expert CAD Management The Complete Guide Robert Green
Wiley Publishing, Inc.
16531ffirs.qxd
3/19/07
3:12 PM
Page iv
Acquisitions Editor: WILLEM KNIBBE Development Editor: LISA BISHOP Technical Editor: NANCY SPURLING-JOHNSON Production Editor: MICHAEL GORDON Copy Editor: TIFFANY TAYLOR Production Manager: TIM TATE Vice President and Executive Group Publisher: RICHARD SWADLEY Vice President and Executive Publisher: JOSEPH B. WIKERT Vice President and Publisher: NEIL EDDE Media Project Supervisor: LAURA ATKINSON Media Development Specialist: KIT MALONE Media Quality Assurance: ANGIE DENNY Book Designer: FRANZ BAUMHACKl Compositor: CHRIS GILLESPIE, HAPPENSTANCE TYPE-O-RAMA Proofreaders: NANCY RIDDIOUGH, RACHEL GUNN Indexer: NANCY ANDERMAN GUENTHER Anniversary Logo Design: RICHARD PACIFICO Cover Designer: RYAN SNEED Cover Image: © DIETER SPANNKNEBEL, DIGITAL VISION, GETTYIMAGES Copyright © 2007 by Wiley Publishing, Inc., Indianapolis, Indiana Published by Wiley Publishing, Inc., Indianapolis, Indiana Published simultaneously in Canada ISBN-13: 978-0-4701-1653-1 No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning or otherwise, except as permitted under Sections 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, (978) 750-8400, fax (978) 646-8600. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Legal Department, Wiley Publishing, Inc., 10475 Crosspoint Blvd., Indianapolis, IN 46256, (317) 572-3447, fax (317) 572-4355, or online at http://www.wiley.com/go/permissions. Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: The publisher and the author make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents of this work and specifically disclaim all warranties, including without limitation warranties of fitness for a particular purpose. No warranty may be created or extended by sales or promotional materials. The advice and strategies contained herein may not be suitable for every situation. This work is sold with the understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering legal, accounting, or other professional services. If professional assistance is required, the services of a competent professional person should be sought. Neither the publisher nor the author shall be liable for damages arising herefrom. The fact that an organization or Website is referred to in this work as a citation and/or a potential source of further information does not mean that the author or the publisher endorses the information the organization or Website may provide or recommendations it may make. Further, readers should be aware that Internet Websites listed in this work may have changed or disappeared between when this work was written and when it is read. For general information on our other products and services or to obtain technical support, please contact our Customer Care Department within the U.S. at (800) 762-2974, outside the U.S. at (317) 572-3993 or fax (317) 572-4002. Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print may not be available in electronic books. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Green, Robert, 1961Expert CAD management : the complete guide / Robert Green. p. cm. ISBN 978-0-470-11653-1 (paper/cd-rom) 1. Engineering design—Data processing—Management. 2. Computer-aided design—Management. I. Title. TA174.G75 2007 620'.00420285—dc22 2007006213 TRADEMARKS: Wiley, the Wiley logo, and the Sybex logo are trademarks or registered trademarks of John Wiley & Sons, Inc. and/or its affiliates, in the United States and other countries, and may not be used without written permission. Autodesk is a registered trademark of Autodesk, Inc. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners. Wiley Publishing, Inc., is not associated with any product or vendor mentioned in this book. 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
16531ffirs.qxd
3/19/07
3:12 PM
Page v
This book is dedicated to all the engineers, architects, designers, and power users who keep their companies’ CAD installations humming. It has been my pleasure to work with so many of you over the last 16 years. —ROBERT GREEN
Acknowledgments Where does one start? This book is the culmination of my engineering and CAD career so far, and there are so many to thank for helping me get here: The Sybex team—for making this book a reality. Thanks go to Willem Knibbe for helping me navigate the publishing and contracts process, Nancy Spurling Johnson for technical editing, Lisa Bishop and Tiffany Taylor for production editing, and Michael Gordon for turning it all into the completed work you hold in your hands now. My mother—for pushing me toward higher education and teaching me to not be provincial, but rather to take a larger world view. My father—for pushing me to achieve practical results and to always be aware of the financial aspects of being in business. Walter Davis—the best teacher anyone could ever hope to have. His teachings developed my curiosity for physics and dynamic systems that led me to study mechanical engineering. Larry Stewart—a great boss, mentor, and friend who helped me to achieve far more in my early engineering career than I ever thought I could. Roopinder Tara and Arnie Williams—Roopinder took a chance on me in 1998 and gave me an opportunity to write the monthly “Manager’s VPOINT” column for CADENCE magazine, and Arnie helped me achieve my conversational writing style via mentoring and editing. Cadalyst magazine—for allowing me to continue my monthly CAD management newsletters and columns and serve as a contributing editor. Lorraine, Alex, and Austin—Ultimately, though, it all comes down to my family. My wife, Lorraine, and two sons, Alex and Austin, put up with the travel, extended writing sessions, late-night programming, customer calls, road-warrior stories, and ever-present Toshiba laptop (even at the boys’ hockey games) that define being a CAD management consultant. None of what I do would mean anything without my family; I love each of them very much.
16531ffirs.qxd
3/19/07
3:12 PM
Page vi
About the Author Robert Green earned his degree in mechanical engineering at the Georgia Institute of Technology (Georgia Tech) in 1983. Upon his graduation, he moved to the Santa Clara, California area to pursue design-engineering employment in the semiconductor capital equipment field. Over the next four years, Robert performed various engineering tasks including the design of wafer-handling robotics that functioned in intense heat and vacuum environments. The analytical modeling and analysis Robert performed led him to early usage of software tools such as SDRC’s IDEAS modeling and transient thermal-analysis modules, ALGOR stress-analysis modules, and combined-mode transient analysis using NASTRAN. Along the way Robert became familiar with a PC-based CAD program called AutoCAD, which he has used since 1985. In 1988, Robert relocated back to the Atlanta area, where he was a computer applications engineer specialist for Combustion Engineering specializing in CAD and analysis for power and petrochemical industries. By 1991, Robert decided to start his own company, and he has been providing training, programming, writing, and public speaking services throughout the U.S. and Canada ever since. In his free time, Robert can be found at various Atlanta area hockey rinks watching his two sons play; or at civic/political events with his wife, Lorraine, who serves as an elected County Commissioner. Robert also enjoys playing rock guitar, singing, and exploring digital recording technology, but he has no illusions about quitting his day job!
16531ffirs.qxd
3/19/07
3:12 PM
Page vii
Foreword Robert Green is an icon in the CAD Management world—plain and simple. He has learned his art by living the role day in and day out. Unlike many who profess to be experts in the field, he is the real deal. I receive countless e-mails each week from CAD users asking for advice relating to CAD management, and Robert (poor Robert) is always the one I send them to. I know they’ll get a great solution to their problem and have an improved customer experience. And let’s face it—working for a software company, that’s one of my biggest concerns. I’ve known Robert for over a decade, and I admit it—I’m a fan! His nonstop professionalism and willingness to help his fellow user has remained consistent over the years, even as he’s become more and more in demand. One of my roles at Autodesk consists of content management for Autodesk University, our largest user event. We have requested Robert’s guidance more than once to create the framework for our CAD Management track because we know he is well aware of the hot topics and issues confronting today’s CAD managers. He is consistently a high-rated speaker and clearly knows the pulse of the industry. I have even quoted Robert along with the results found in his popular CAD Management surveys in many of my own presentations. If you purchased this book, you’re probably looking to excel in your role of CAD Manager. You may have a dual role as CAD Manager and CAD user, or you may be fortunate enough to focus entirely on all things CAD Management. Regardless of your situation, you’re sure to find some helpful techniques within this book to make your role more effective and productive (and hopefully less stressful). Robert will guide you through the steps to take to walk down the road to CAD Management Mecca! I’ve seen him leave audiences in awe as they try to write down every single suggestion he has to offer. Lucky you, you get all those finely tuned tips and suggestions in this one book! So do yourself a favor, and set aside some time each night to read a little more of this book (we all know you’ll never get a chance to do this at work). Then, try the techniques you read about in the office where appropriate. How many times do we read great information, acknowledge it as great information, and then never use it? I know I’m guilty, and the techniques found in this book are just too good to let that happen!
16531ffirs.qxd
3/19/07
3:12 PM
Page viii
Robert Green travels all over, helping users solve their CAD Management issues; if he’s ever in your area, do yourself a favor and go hear him. And take your book— he’d love to sign it, but watch yourself! Everyone in the room will want to get their hands on it! Here’s to your bright future of CAD Management success! —LYNN ALLEN Autodesk Technical Evangelist, Cadalyst columnist
16531ftoc.qxd
3/19/07
1:35 PM
Page ix
Contents Introduction
Chapter 1
What’s Involved: Defining the Position
xv
1
Overview of Tasks. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 The Real Tasks More Examples Task List Conclusions
3 4 5
Understanding the Users’ Perspective . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Management’s Perspective . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 You’re Never Done, Though
8
Balancing Tasks and Perspectives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 Simplifying Your CAD Management Equation
9
The Business Angle: Money Talks! . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 A Quick Example Evaluating Tasks Based on Finances
12 13
Gaining the Power to Do Your Job . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 Making It Happen. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
Chapter 2
Taking Stock of Your Current Situation
17
User Skills Assessment. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18 Deploying a Test Interpreting Results Attitudinal and Management Issues Drawing Conclusions
19 19 21 21
Software Assessment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22 Summarizing Your Findings
22
Hardware Assessment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 Example Case Revisited Drawing Conclusions
24 24
IT Assessments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 Network Changes File Sharing/Security The Working Relationship Finding Red Flags in Your Assessment Conclusions Drawn
26 27 28 29 29
16531ftoc.qxd
3/19/07
1:35 PM
Page x
Budgetary Assessment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 Making the Assessment Find the Disconnects Drawing Conclusions
30 31 32
Standards/Process Assessments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32 A Formulaic Approach Getting Ideas No Shortcuts Drawing Conclusions
33 34 34 35
Prioritizing Based on Need . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35
Chapter 3
Managing Your Management
37
Manage: Not Manipulate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38 Debunking the Myths . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 39 Why Management Is out of the Technology Loop . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42 Meeting Company Needs—Not User Wants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42
CONTENTS ■
x
Explaining Standards to Management. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44 Managing Management’s Expectations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46 Reporting to Your Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46 Why Reporting Matters so Much
48
Avoiding the Technology vs. Management Trap via Clear Communication . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48
Chapter 4
It’s All About Balance
49
Managing Standards
51
Formulating and Writing Standards . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 52 Existing Standards: AIA, U.S. National CAD Standard, and Others . . . 54 Information Exchange. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56 Vendor Control via Standards . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 57 Auditing and Taking Control
59
Working to Client Standards . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60 Getting Started
61
Outsourcing Control . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 62 Standard Application Deployment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 64 Managing the Multi-CAD Office . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 65 Processes Will Change; React Accordingly Documenting What You’ve Found
66 68
Standards Enforcement via Management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68 Getting Help with Enforcement
69
Bringing It All Together. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 70
16531ftoc.qxd
3/19/07
1:35 PM
Chapter 5
Page xi
Training, Hiring, and Managing Users
73
Training Methodology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 74 Sorting Out the Methods
77
Building a Training Plan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 78 Identifying Training Needs Connecting Training and Standards Fixing Processes/Standards (If Required)
78 79 80
Delivering Your Own Training . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 80 Prepare with Good Materials Delivering Training Recycling Training for Maximum Effect
80 81 83
Hiring and Testing Staff . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 84 Avoiding Bad Hires Prioritizing the Candidates Selling the Value
85 87 88
Diagnosing Existing User Skills . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 88
Making the Most of Your Power Users. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 90 Creating Junior CAD Managers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 92 Handling Renegade Users . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 93 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 96
Chapter 6
Managing Software (and Change)
97
Changing Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 98 Understanding Software Licensing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 99 It’s Not Really Your Software It’s Really a Lease Licensing Limitations
99 100 101
Purchasing Software . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 102 Informing Management
105
Performing Upgrades. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 105 Understanding the True Cost Computing the Benefits Making the Decision Upgrade Barriers Training Notes Closing Thoughts
105 106 107 108 109 109
Easing the Transition. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 110 Juggling It All
111
Analyzing 3D Migration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111 Handling Objections Knowing What to Buy Setting Management’s Expectations
112 115 116
xi ■ CONTENTS
Encouraging Self Study . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 89
16531ftoc.qxd
3/19/07
1:35 PM
Page xii
Budgeting Notes Setting the Time Table Managing Complex File Relationships Putting It All Together
117 118 118 119
Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 120
Chapter 7
Understanding Financial Processes
121
Budgeting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 122 Managing Perception Gathering Data Changing Parameters Using a Disciplined Approach
122 123 123 125
The Faster/Cheaper Paradigm . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 127 Examining Old Projects Faster or Cheaper, or (We Hope) Both Faster/Cheaper Data Thinking Like Management Finding the Faster/Cheaper Planning for the Future (via the Past)
CONTENTS ■
xii
127 128 129 130 131 132
Faster/Cheaper Internet . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 132 The Possibilities
133
Using ROI Metrics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 134 Defining ROI Computing a Quick Example Drawing Conclusions Putting ROI to Use
134 135 137 138
Performing Bottleneck Analyses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 138
Chapter 8
Building Your Own Case Bottlenecking Conclusions
140 140
Building a Long-Term Plan
141
Capturing Good Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 143 Prioritizing Ideas on a Cost Basis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 145 Prioritizing Ideas on a Complexity Basis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 146 Prioritizing Ideas on a Cost-Savings Basis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 147 Documenting Your Processes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 148 Plan the Work, Work the Plan. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 150 Sequencing Your Approach . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 151 Writing an ROI-Focused Summary of Your Plan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 153 Selling Users . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 154 If You Can’t Sell It, Watch Out
155
Implementing Your Plan One Step at a Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 156 It All Comes Together
157
16531ftoc.qxd
3/19/07
1:35 PM
Chapter 9
Page xiii
Managing Networks, IT, and Hardware
159
How Much IT Do You Need to Know? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 160 Quantifying Networks: A Facilitating Tool or a Barrier to Productivity? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 161 Understanding the Environment Storing Data Running Software
162 163 165
Buying the Right Hardware . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 166 Justifying Fast Hardware Summing Up
168 169
Getting Involved with IT Planning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 170 Planning for Survival
171
Operating Systems. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 171
Chapter 10 Building Crucial Skills
173
Assessing Your Learning Style . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 174 Learning Methods and Resources Peer Activities
175 178
Learning What to Manage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 179 Building Your Management Style . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 183 Understanding Your Company
185
Selling Yourself . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 185 Writing Better Speaking Better Reporting Effectively Documenting ROI Learning Programming Visual Basic and AutoLISP AutoLISP Resources Visual Basic Resources
Chapter 11 Protecting Your Data
185 186 188 189 191 192 193 194
195
Identifying Intellectual Property . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 196 Locating Intellectual Property
197
Securing Files . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 197 Securing In-House Data Limiting What You Share via Formats Limiting What You Share via Tools Contractually Binding Agreements In Conclusion
198 199 200 202 202
Controlling Projects with Contracts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 202
■ CONTENTS
Learning Efficiently Is Essential. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 175
xiii
16531ftoc.qxd
3/19/07
1:35 PM
Page xiv
Bonus: Document-Management Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 204 Defining EDM/PDM/PLM Identifying System Types Identifying Scalability Identifying System Components Evaluating Costs Going Shopping Justifying Costs with Savings EDM Wrap Up
205 206 207 209 212 215 215 218
Summing Up . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 218
Appendix A: Optimizing Software Performance
219
Identifying Software Types . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 220 Networking Factors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 220 Understanding the Environment
221
Storing Data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 223 CONTENTS ■
xiv
Harmonizing Software with Networks
224
Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 226
Appendix B: Tips for AutoCAD Environments
227
Appendix C: Tips for Manufacturing Environments
231
Appendix D: Tips for AEC Environments
235
Appendix E Tips for Civil Engineering Environments
239
Appendix F: Tips for mixed Autodesk Environments (AutoCAD, Revit, Inventor, Civil 3D)
243
Appendix G: Tips for SolidWorks-Based Environments
247
An Open Letter to Senior Management
251
Index
255
16531flast.qxd
3/19/07
1:35 PM
Page xv
Introduction If anyone had told me 23 years ago that I’d be writing a book on CAD management, I would’ve been shocked. I likely would’ve replied, “Look, I’m an engineer, not a manager!” Sound familiar? I bet you’ve had similar experiences.
The CAD Manager’s Mission The CAD manager’s mission is multifaceted and comprises more tasks than seems humanly possible to track. Somewhere between planning, budgeting, training, software implementation, managerial oversight, programming, technical support, and staying on
xv ■ INTRODUCTION
You probably started out as a practicing architect, an electrical engineer, or an industrial designer and somehow found yourself in a CAD management position. You may be struggling with dual questions: “How did I get here?” and “What do I do now?” These are reasonable questions and not uncommon for those who find themselves in the CAD manager’s chair. Throughout the course of this book, I hope to offer solutions not just to the technical problems facing a CAD manager, but also to questions like “How did I get here?” and “What do I do now?” It’s my goal for this book to be the complete CAD management resource for a variety of issues both technical and managerial. All I ask is that you approach the task with an open mind and the willingness to question your methods and make changes to improve your job performance. Precisely because our backgrounds are so similar, I’m going to approach this book as a conversation between peers seeking to learn from each other. I’ll write this book just as if I were in the room leading you through one of my extended CAD management courses. I’ll strive to keep things conversational while steering clear of as much jargon as possible. I’m hoping that this straightforward dialogue will put a more human touch on an otherwise technical endeavor. So, as I’m fond of saying: Here goes!
16531flast.qxd
3/19/07
1:35 PM
Page xvi
the leading edge of technology innovation is a key mission with a relatively simple set of objectives: •
To keep CAD hardware and software running
•
To ensure that users can function without worrying about their CAD hardware and software
•
To make the company more profitable via efficient management of CAD resources
When the mission is viewed in terms of these objectives, it seems simple, doesn’t it? But like most technical endeavors, the devil is in the details, and things aren’t as easy as they seem at first. Throughout this book, we’ll compare and contrast this mission statement with what it takes to really get the job done.
Note:
Making a tough job look easy is the ultimate form of professionalism.To do so in CAD management requires a wide range of skills and keen planning. INTRODUCTION ■
xvi
CAD managers can feel like they’re carrying the entire office.
16531flast.qxd
3/19/07
1:35 PM
Page xvii
A Little History
•
We’ve literally gone from no computers, to not being able to work without one.
•
We’ve come from nobody knowing what a CAD system is to younger workers not knowing what a drafting board is.
•
E-mail has replaced the fax machine, which replaced FedEx.
Yet even with all this change in technology, I’ve been able to manage engineering processes and transition along the way without major problems. If so much has changed, why haven’t I been relegated to obsolescence like the drafting board or the fax machine? Why have I been able to jump to CAD management from drafting management? Pondering these questions inspired me to start writing about CAD management and to confront CAD management using history as a guide. Keep reading, and you’ll see what I mean.
xvii ■ INTRODUCTION
Where you’re going has a lot to do with where you’ve been. I admit to being a keen student of history and so would like to start our journey by examining how I became a CAD manager. Please indulge me for a couple of pages on this topic! I promise I’ll tie it all together shortly. I had prepared myself for a career in mechanical engineering design by taking lots of math, physics, and chemistry in high school and gaining acceptance to Purdue University (where I began my engineering studies) and then the Georgia Institute of Technology, from which I graduated in 1983. At the time, I had some concept of computer-aided design because I’d seen several of my aeronautical engineering comrades doing basic airframe analysis with crude, graphics-based Fortran programs. I was also aware that NASA was doing a substantial amount of computer-aided analysis on Space Shuttle payloads, because our campus computer shut down for several hours each night to run those solutions. But me using CAD to help design products? No way did I ever see that coming. My exposure to computer programming consisted of learning the Fortran and Pascal programming languages by creating punch cards and submitting them to a card-reader machine—and then waiting 45 minutes for the results of my computer run to pop out of a communal dot-matrix printer. In the fall of 1979, I was introduced to a blazingly fast 1200-baud computer terminal that made punch cards obsolete and cut submitting and compiling time down to a reasonable 20 minutes. If you’re under 40, you probably have no clue what I’m talking about. That’s the reason I’m telling you this anecdote. The amount of change that’s transpired in the last 20 years in the engineering workplace is staggering. Consider the following truisms, and the context of what has changed will become apparent:
16531flast.qxd
3/19/07
1:35 PM
Page xviii
New Tools, Same Challenge As CAD replaced the drafting board, which replaced parchment and pens, which replaced papyrus reeds, we’ve seen an evolution of design tools transform what we work with but not what we do. We run CAD systems to design and build things. Whether you use CAD, paper, or a stone tablet, the core mission is still to design new things and make them work. Thinking about your job from that perspective focuses you on supporting the design tasks at hand—and that is exactly the type of focus that the most successful CAD managers have. As I’ve given the tools-based approach to CAD management more thought, I’ve come to a few conclusions: •
Understanding the Tools As long as I understand the tools my company uses, I have a fighting chance to manage them effectively. It doesn’t matter what those tools are, as long as I understand them.
•
Strive for better results Understanding how to achieve better design results and greater user productivity by managing the tools at my disposal is the best way to approach the CAD management job.
•
Think more about strategy Most companies use similar tools. The strategies they use to manage those tools is what sets them apart.
•
Use your background to your advantage It has always been my engineering background much more than my computer background that has allowed me to understand the strategy of design.
INTRODUCTION ■
xviii
Think of CAD management like a chess game, and you’ll start to focus more on strategy and less on tools.
16531flast.qxd
3/19/07
1:35 PM
Page xix
The mental picture that emerges for me is that of a chess game where two players battle using the same pieces and rules, yet one player wins thanks to better moves and better strategy. If everyone has the same CAD systems, the same computers, the same networks, the same e-mail, the same access to the Web, and so on, we have to ask the question, “Why are some companies so successful, while others aren’t?” Do you think the CAD manager may have something to do with that?
No Barnstorming—Using This Book
1.
Skim over the table of contents, and think about what each topic means to you.
2.
Based on your first impressions, decide which areas you feel weakest in.
3.
Create a prioritized list of the areas you feel weakest in; order it from weakest to strongest. This list will serve as your priority checklist. You’ll use it to keep track of your progress later.
4.
Read Chapters 1 and 2. Keep in mind the areas you feel you’re weakest in. Even if you feel some of the topics in Chapters 1 and 2 are comfortable for you, don’t take any shortcuts: Be sure you read everything in detail. Everything else I cover in this book assumes you have a good understanding of Chapters 1 and 2, so no barnstorming!
5.
Revisit your list, and reprioritize the items if necessary. Your goal is to have a list of action items that you should improve on, with your weakest areas at the top of the list.
6.
Tackle the book chapter by chapter, emphasizing those areas that address your greatest weaknesses first.
Am I telling you to read the book out of sequence? Perhaps! If you’re going to spend your time reading this book, it’s my job to make sure you get the most from it.
xix ■ INTRODUCTION
In the early days of powered flight, it was not uncommon for someone to buy an airplane and start flying it without any instruction or experience. This practice was known as barnstorming, and it’s become a metaphor for carelessly undertaking any job without preparation, training, and knowledge. Using this book properly will help you plan your CAD management flight path rather than barnstorming. Of course, you could read this book from cover to cover in sequence and then take some time to reflect and digest the material, but my guess is that you won’t have time to do so. Given the time pressures you work under and the need to have a life outside of CAD and computers, it’s more likely that you’ll take a more incremental approach. Here’s a pragmatic way to get the quickest payback for your time from this book:
16531flast.qxd
3/19/07
1:35 PM
Page xx
If you follow my recommendations, you should already have achieved the following objectives: •
You know more about your own limitations.
•
You’ve been honest with yourself about your biggest weaknesses.
•
You’ve got a game plan for how to attack your weaknesses.
•
You’ve got the material that can help you in front of you.
•
You’ll be addressing your greatest weaknesses first to achieve maximum impact and get the best possible career results as fast as you can.
Let’s Go to Work
INTRODUCTION ■
xx
I’ve encouraged you to take stock of your strengths, weaknesses, history, and particular circumstances throughout this introduction. You may feel like I’ve talked a lot more about how to approach the job than how you do the job. If so, then I’ve succeeded in making you think about the entire process of CAD management. This process of self-analysis and prioritization of actions has worked for me throughout my career, and it’s used by most successful people I know of in CAD management (and other fields, for that matter). There’s no reason it can’t work for you. Now, all you have to do is get started.
16531c01.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 1
What’s Involved: Defining the Position What’s involved with being a CAD manager? That’s a reasonable question. In order to do any job well, you need to define the position and understand the tasks that you’re expected to accomplish. And make no mistake, if you don’t will define it for you. Being a CAD manager requires proactive management of your work environment. By this I mean that you should define what the tasks are and
1
how you hope to accomplish them. Without a firm idea of how to define your job, you’ll find yourself in reactive mode. There’s no way you can be a proactive, mission-accomplished CAD manager when you’re trying to live up to everyone else’s expectations.
1 ■ W H AT ’ S I N V O LV E D : D E F I N I N G T H E P O S I T I O N
define your CAD management job, other people
16531c01.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 2
The burden is on you to define how you’re going to do your job, given the realities of the mandatory job responsibilities you must tackle. Therefore, in this chapter I want to acknowledge the various tasks, pressures, and expectations that CAD managers must deal with in a constructive, analytical way. At the end of the chapter, you should have a clear idea of how you’ll define your job, how to approach it, and how to keep all parties in your company happy.
CHAPTER
1:
W H AT ’ S I N V O LV E D : D E F I N I N G T H E P O S I T I O N ■
2
Figure 1.1 Sometimes it seems like the CAD manager has to manage everything! The good news is you can manage the load with careful planning.
Overview of Tasks CAD managers must accomplish many tasks. Any list I write is likely to omit something that you’re responsible for already, but I’ll go ahead and throw out the more common CAD management tasks as a way to start our conversation. Here’s what I see CAD managers doing: •
Supporting CAD software
•
Supporting CAD hardware
•
Providing user support
•
Providing user training
•
Facilitating timely work completion
•
Reporting status to management
16531c01.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 3
•
Preparing budgets
•
Writing CAD standards
•
Performing staff development and review
•
Identifying promising new technology
If you have functioned as a CAD Manager for any length of time, you’re aware of these kinds of tasks. You’ve probably been confronted with many of them and have some degree of comfort in dealing with them. The reason that I like to define the tasks involved with a CAD management job is so you have a list down on paper and you have a tangible job description to go by.
Note:
Take some time to write down your task list while the concepts are fresh in your mind.You can use the TASKLIST.XLS spreadsheet file provided with the book to capture your task list electronically. 3
The Real Tasks For every task on your CAD management list, at least one and possibly many more real tasks lurk in the background, and only you can identify them. What do I mean by this? That’s a reasonable question—one best answered by example. I’ll use the topic of CAD standards to illustrate the point, because almost all CAD managers have this responsibility. The perceived task Let’s say that your management expects you to manage CAD standards, and so they’ve placed a task called “maintain CAD standards” in your job description. Simple enough—or at least, that’s what your management thinks. The real tasks As a CAD manager, you know that maintaining CAD standards includes at least the following real tasks: •
Define CAD standards.
•
Document CAD standards.
•
Train users to follow CAD standards.
•
Deal with those who don’t follow standards.
■ O V E RV I E W O F TA S K S
By documenting your tasks in list form, you can build a game plan for how you’ll handle those tasks. The more you think about defining your task list, the more likely you are to come up with good methodologies, standards, and processes to help you achieve those tasks. Conversely, if you don’t define your task list and think about the best way to approach it, you’ll inevitably be surprised by unexpected tasks. Being surprised puts you into reactive mode, where you lose control of your work environment.
16531c01.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 4
This example is useful because it illustrates the concept that you can’t accomplish a task without understanding it and proactively managing how that task will be accomplished. A little thought on the matter leads to the following conclusions: •
To document CAD standards, you have to define them first.
•
To define CAD standards, you have to know what users and customers need.
•
CAD standards are ineffective if users don’t understand them.
•
CAD standards are pointless if nobody follows them.
It becomes apparent that in order to accomplish the perceived task (maintaining CAD standards, in this case), you have to think about how that task will actually be done in your work environment. There’s no way, in this particular case, that I could tell you how to write a CAD standard. I could give you some guidelines, but the only way you’ll write a bulletproof CAD standard is to consider what you’ll control, how the standard will be used in your environment, how you’ll train your users, and how you’ll follow up to make sure the standards are enforced.
Note:
As with most things CAD management, I’ve found that user-centric tasks like training and standardizing work processes are the most complicated parts of the task.
More Examples I’ll give you two more examples of common CAD management tasks, common management perceptions of those tasks, and what the real tasks supporting those perceived tasks typically are. Along the way I’ll provide some insight. What Senior Management Sees
What the CAD Manager Sees
CHAPTER
1:
W H AT ’ S I N V O LV E D : D E F I N I N G T H E P O S I T I O N ■
4
Task 1 in Theory
Task 1 Sub-Tasks (Reality)
Task N in Theory
Task N Sub-Tasks (Reality)
Perception Disconnect
Figure 1.2 Here we see graphically how the actual tasks you manage are quite different from the perceived task(s) your management sees.
16531c01.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 5
The perceived task Provide ongoing user training. The real tasks •
Identify areas that require training.
•
Create custom training materials.
•
Coordinate external training resources and providers.
•
Deliver training seminars.
The topic of training illustrates how many skills you need to juggle to deliver on what seems like a single task. Your management thinks you need to be a good trainer to pull off this task, right? But in order to develop and deliver user training, you need a complete understanding of what your users already know, where the gaps in their skill sets lie, and where to spend your training time to get the maximum return. Here we have what sounds like a relatively simple task—providing ongoing user training—that is actually a series of dependent tasks, some of which have nothing to do with delivering training. The real tasks •
Answer user questions.
•
Catalog user questions and feedback to training processes.
•
Determine root causes for user-support needs.
It sounds simple to say, “Provide ongoing user support.” Although answering user questions is indeed part of support, the larger tasks of figuring out why you’re having to support users and how to minimize user-support questions are how the best CAD managers approach the task of user support.
Task List Conclusions I hope this section has raised your awareness that the hardest task you face is understanding your task list. Only by analyzing your job will you understand what you need to work on. I’ve talked to far too many CAD managers who are constantly blindsided by unexpected tasks because they never took the time to analyze their task lists! I recommend that you make a list of perceived job tasks and the real tasks you need to tackle to meet the perceived needs. Doing so will automatically force you to think more about what you’re trying to do—which will lead to better results. Go ahead and close the book now and write your list of perceived and real tasks. There’s probably nothing else you’ll do today that will pay you back as handsomely.
5 ■ O V E RV I E W O F TA S K S
The perceived task Provide ongoing user support.
16531c01.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 6
Understanding the Users’ Perspective
CHAPTER
1:
W H AT ’ S I N V O LV E D : D E F I N I N G T H E P O S I T I O N ■
6
Obviously, CAD managers have to support and serve CAD users. After all, if there were no CAD users, there would be no CAD managers. You have to be cognizant of what your users think and need and how you’ll meet their requirements. Simply stated, you must step outside yourself and consider the users’ perspective. This wouldn’t seem to be too much of a stretch because most of us got our start in this field as CAD users. If you can get yourself in the mental state of being a regular user and remember how you felt at the time, you should be in good shape, right? Most CAD managers, however, were not basic users, but power users. The power user is a more self-sufficient individual who takes pride in not needing to ask for help. Most of us became CAD managers precisely because we were the power users who could solve software or hardware problems independently. Consequently, most CAD managers possess a can-do, take-action, I’m-going-to-fix-this mind-set that can be intolerant of those who require lots of support. Be keenly aware of whether you have this perspective, because being dismissive of user problems inevitably leads to user dissatisfaction. Consider your users and how they think. Try to identify all your users in terms of their learning styles and the needed level of support. Over time, I’ve come to accept that users care about a narrower set of issues than the CAD manager does and that they judge their CAD manager based on how they feel about the following parameters: •
Does their hardware work?
•
Does their software work?
•
Can they get support when they need it?
•
Is CAD management a tool that helps them achieve work objectives or a barrier that makes their job harder?
To gauge how your users feel about their working environment, you need to put yourself in their shoes and ask the following questions as honestly as you can: •
How much of your support do your users really need?
•
Would your users say their CAD environment (hardware and software) is great, adequate, or poor?
•
Do your users feel well supported?
•
Do your users feel they need additional training to succeed?
•
Do your users feel that you (the CAD manager) are concerned with their productivity and ability to get work projects done efficiently?
16531c01.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 7
This exercise is tough because it forces you to think critically about how your users perceive you. When you think through these questions, consider things you’ve heard from users, and be prepared to confront some negatives. Remember that the point of the exercise is to identify the users’ perspective, whether positive or negative. Now the challenge is to take what you’ve learned from gauging the users’ perspective and figure out what, if anything, you need to change to achieve a positive perception from your user base. For instance, if the overwhelming user perspective is that more training is needed, you should either add training or find the root cause of why more training seems to be needed and eliminate the cause. Always remember that if you allow a negative user perspective to linger or fester, then you’ll have to deal with not only angry users but most likely angry management as well. Ignore the users’ perspective at your peril!
Management’s Perspective
Figure 1.3 Management views things from a strategy point of view, not unlike a chess game. So how well do you manage the resources you already have to play the CAD management chess game most effectively?
7 ■ MANAGEMENT’S PERSPECTIVE
Your senior management has its own perspective on the CAD manager’s position, and that perspective is curiously bipolar in nature. Because management understands that CAD work is done by CAD users, they have a vested interest in CAD users being well supported. This places management on the user-centric side of the ledger. On the other hand, management is also worried about longer-term factors like budgets, technology adoption, the cost of software training, and a host of other issues that users typically don’t deal with. CAD managers find themselves sandwiched between the seemingly conflicting user and management perspectives.
16531c01.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 8
There’s probably no one right answer to what upper management’s perspective on the CAD manager’s role should be, but I’ve noticed that the following views are widely held by corporate management:
CHAPTER
1:
W H AT ’ S I N V O LV E D : D E F I N I N G T H E P O S I T I O N ■
8
•
The CAD manager should enable CAD-related productivity.
•
The CAD manager should strive for user efficiency and more profitable operation of the company.
•
The CAD manager should remove complexity and make things simple, because making things simple usually makes things go better.
•
The CAD manager must keep CAD technology on budget and realize that there are no blank checks for software or hardware.
In my 17 years of CAD management experience, I’ve found that CAD managers who don’t subscribe to these views have rocky relationships with their management teams. Conversely, if you live these ideals on a daily basis, your management probably has a great opinion of you—and your users probably like you as well! When people work efficiently and you don’t spend too much money, everybody is happy.
You’re Never Done, Though One glaring difference between the perspectives of your users and your management is that management expects constantly improving efficiency—what I like to call the “good enough isn’t” mentality. If you do a great job facilitating productivity, making things simple, and staying on budget as you go, you’re just setting the bar that much higher for next year. So what types of questions does your management ask about improving efficiency? Here are some examples: •
How can we get the same work done in less time?
•
How can we get more jobs done with the same number of people?
•
What’s our CAD manager doing to make CAD processes work better six months from now? A year from now? Two years from now?
Although your users may achieve a state of satisfaction when their hardware and software systems are harmonized and productive, management feels no such satisfaction. Whenever you feel particularly good about the state of your CAD environment, pat yourself on the back and savor the feeling for a little while. But don’t pause for too long, because management expects more from you. In today’s hypercompetitive business environments, the effective CAD manager must embrace a longer-term view. How do you balance management’s longer-term view with your users’ shorter-term view? We’ll get into that in a moment.
16531c01.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 9
Balancing Tasks and Perspectives
Simplifying Your CAD Management Equation I’ve already recommended that you inventory all the perceived tasks you’re expected to perform and that you break these tasks down into the real tasks that lie behind them. If you haven’t built your task inventory do so now so that you can analyze it using the following steps: In this exercise you are encouraged to really think and capture all the information you need to describe your work tasks and analyze them. It may seem easy at first, but when you really start analyzing what you do you’ll be amazed at how complex it can all become. So get out a few sheets of paper and get ready to really analyze your job:
1.
Write down each task you do in list form and figure out which items are more in line with your users’ expectations and which ones are more focused on the needs of upper management.
2.
Rank all the tasks in terms of priority, with users’ priorities in one list and managerial priorities in another. You probably won’t get your priority order perfect, but with some careful thought, you should get close. Reshuffle as much as you need to before continuing, because this prioritization is the basis for the rest of the exercise.
3.
If at any point you feel that you need to expand or contract your task list, do so. After you’ve made your changes, go back to step 2 and reshuffle.
4.
Repeat steps 2 and 3 as many times as required.
9 ■ B A L A N C I N G TA S K S A N D P E R S P E C T I V E S
You’ve arrived at a point in defining your CAD management position where you realize that you have many tasks in front of you that your users and management probably don’t fully understand but expect you to accomplish. You have to somehow take into account the users’ perspective and upper management’s perspective and expectations as well. This is starting to look like a complicated job; and, to be honest, the CAD manager’s job can become as complicated as you let it. The good news is that there is a methodology you can use to approach these sometimes conflicting tasks and perspectives to make sense out of the CAD manager’s position. To me, CAD management is like solving an extremely complex equation. You can either flounder, trying to solve an equation with way too many variables, or you can simplify the equation by eliminating variables and making it easier to solve. Therefore, the balancing act of taking all the different tasks and perspectives into account is about thinking through CAD management for your particular company and breaking tasks into manageable chunks that reinforce each other. Let’s do the exercise in the following section to see how this works.
16531c01.qxd
CHAPTER
1:
W H AT ’ S I N V O LV E D : D E F I N I N G T H E P O S I T I O N ■
10
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 10
5.
Now the fun really begins! Sort through your lists of user-based and managementbased tasks, and look for any tasks that are similar. For example, a user-based task may be to “provide training,” whereas a management-based task of “make users more productive” may involve training. It always helps to look for win-win scenarios when combining tasks: for example, users may feel they’ve received great training, while at the same time management thinks they’ve received a more productive work force. If both users and management are happy then you’ve completed two tasks for the price of one.
6.
Unify your task lists to reflect any symbiotic relationships between tasks. You might, for instance, combine “provide user training” with “make users more productive” to make a single “raise user productivity through effective training” task on your simplified list.
7.
Repeat steps 5 and 6 as many times as required, and keep looking for tasks that have interdependencies.
8.
Finalize your new, simplified task list. Put it aside for a day or two, and then come back and review it to make sure you haven’t missed anything.
Exercise Conclusions—and Expansion You may have spent several hours on this exercise, but it was time spent in quality thought. You should have a single reduced or simplified list of tasks (the variables in your CAD management equation) and should now be able to manage the tasks more easily (because there are fewer variables to deal with). The only thing that remains to be done is to sort through your list of CAD tasks and decide where management-based tasks must take precedence over user-based tasks. Remember that management is more concerned about strategic use of the resources you have while users tend to focus on making this more optimal for themselves. Resolving the two, sometimes, competing areas of interest can be a tough balancing act. At the end of this (possibly laborious) process you’ll know the following things about your CAD management job equation: •
You’ll know which variables drive the equation: the ones with highest priority.
•
You’ll know which variables are interlinked, thus giving you the extra economy of solving multiple problems at once.
•
You’ll know which variables are less important than you may have thought— and which ones are more important than you thought.
•
You’ll have a thorough understanding of how to solve your CAD management job equation from both user and management perspectives—and how to achieve balance between the two.
Take whatever time you need to refine your list now, even if it means closing the book and coming back later. You may need to do this exercise away from the office
16531c01.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 11
late at night when it’s quiet and the phone’s not ringing, so you can focus. Few things are always true, but I’ve come to believe that CAD managers who plan, prioritize, sort, analyze, and optimize their task lists are the ones who achieve optimal success.
The Business Angle: Money Talks!
Figure 1.4 Management tends to measure things financially rather than technically. So remember that the same level of technical vigor you apply to CAD programs is exactly the way your management thinks about money!
11 ■ T H E B U S I N E S S A N G L E : M O N E Y TA L K S !
You’ve done your analysis of all the tasks and the user and management perspectives, and you’ve tried to get your CAD management position simplified into the most basic equation possible, but it still seems complex, doesn’t it? No matter how much you think about your position, and no matter how you try to simplify the tasks, you need to accomplish a lot. And no matter how thoroughly you think things through, you know a case will come up that involves competing priorities, right? It’s reasonable to ask, “How do I resolve these situations?” In the business world, the uniform answer to this question is that you have to make the decision that’s best for the company—and this is why I say, “Money talks.” A key to framing issues from the “money talks” perspective is to understand how competing priorities reach the attention of your management. If an issue causes enough discord, management will hear about it; and when they do, they’re going to wonder why you haven’t handled the problem. Remember, you’re the CAD manager, and you’re supposed to be facilitating optimal productivity—so why do you have unhappy users? At this point, management will ask you, “Why was this problem elevated up to us? Why haven’t you handled it?” And your immediate comeback must be, “Because I have different people with different perspectives. They have different things that they want and need or expect, and I can’t make everybody happy.”
16531c01.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 12
Management will now come back to you with another question along the lines of, “Well, what do you think we should do?” As soon as this question is asked, you have an opportunity to resolve the conflict using financial reasoning rather than technical reasoning. The key is to have your recommendation ready and to format it using business metrics, from the point of view of what’s best for the company’s business position.
A Quick Example
CHAPTER
1:
W H AT ’ S I N V O LV E D : D E F I N I N G T H E P O S I T I O N ■
12
Let’s say you have a user revolt on your hands because the users want the latest version of the software, but this software is expensive and the business isn’t doing well enough to afford the expenditure at present. This is the budget reality that the CAD manager understands but the CAD users don’t. The CAD users are complaining loudly, and the issue has come to upper management’s attention. The dialogue of this meeting might go something like this: Management: “There’s a lot of user discord, and they’re telling us that we need to go up to the new CAD System Revision 30, whereas we’re running on CAD System Revision 28 right now. What’s the problem?” CAD manager: “Our users feel that we should be using the most modern and available technology. They’re tired of using technology that’s two years old, and they feel that we should make the move.” Management: “Well, why don’t we make the switch, then?” CAD manager: “Going to CAD System Revision 30 would cost us $1,000 per seat, and with 20 users in our operating environment, that’s a $20,000 software cost that we didn’t budget. In addition, it would cost us close to $2,000 per user to get them trained and through the ramp-up and productivity curve that always occurs when we install new software. I’m looking at a total fee of about $60,000 to get this new software implemented. You and I both know that’s not in the cards budgetarily over the next six months. This is why I’ve said no to new software.” If your management team knows that $60,000 isn’t available to upgrade software, and if you present the argument just as I’ve articulated it here, they will respect your judgment and be impressed that you’ve taken the initiative to handle the financial aspect of the problem. Management’s opinion of you will only go up as they come to understand that you’re technical and financial and that you’ve combined those skills to look out for their business. Management also knows that you’d probably like to get your hands on the new software as much as your users, but you have enough discipline to say, “We can’t afford to do that now. It’s not in the best interests of the company. Even though the users want it, buying the software isn’t in the financial business interests of our company.” Now you should go back over your list of tasks and user and management expectations from a budgetary or “money talks” point of view. Think about tasks that
16531c01.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 13
may be placed on your list—either by your management or by your users—that don’t match up with the financial reality of your company. By ranking these tasks or expectations in terms of financial feasibility, you’ll automatically re-sort and reprioritize your CAD management responsibilities. And by understanding what you can afford to do in the long term, you’ve gained perspective on which jobs you can tackle first, second, last—or not at all. List Items
Sorting Method
Results
Item #1
Item #2
Sort Method Lowest Cost
Resulting Order 3, 2, 5, 1 then 4
Sort Method User Desire
Resulting Order 5, 1, 4, 2 then 3
Item #3
Item #5
Figure 1.5 Here we see how the prioritization of a list can change dramatically when the monetary filter is applied.
Evaluating Tasks Based on Finances The financial reality, the “money talks” perspective, becomes a useful reality check that you can apply to any task that’s placed on your CAD management agenda. I’ll give you an example: Management may come to you and say that they want you to implement a completely paperless, web-driven CAD environment. However, you know that the budget over the next 12 months will allow for only $5,000 worth of investment in software. It therefore becomes easy to determine that the task is not realistic, because the money isn’t available. Don’t assume that management understands the amount of money and time required to implement a proposed task—it’s up to you to make that determination and inform management of the task’s financial feasibility. By vetting each task—by looking at what it will cost to do something and prioritizing your task list based on that “money talks” viewpoint—you’ll be able to defend your choices and priorities based on financial arguments. And when everything is financially based, you’ll find that management will question you less and respect your decisions more and more as time goes by. Make no mistake: Management knows whether you understand the financial picture, because that is a core part of what they manage. It’s easier to gain respect from management by being financial than technical, as counterintuitive as that may seem.
■ T H E B U S I N E S S A N G L E : M O N E Y TA L K S !
Item #4
13
16531c01.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Note:
Page 14
If you want to get management’s attention, look at your job from the business angle.
Gaining the Power to Do Your Job At this point in defining the CAD management position, you’ve completed the following analytical steps:
CHAPTER
1:
W H AT ’ S I N V O LV E D : D E F I N I N G T H E P O S I T I O N ■
14
•
You’ve analyzed the tasks that you’re expected to accomplish.
•
You’ve looked at that task list from different perspectives—from your own perspective, from the users’ perspective, from management’s perspective, and from a money perspective.
•
You’ve painstakingly processed and prioritized lists, thinking about what is required to accomplish each task.
•
You’ve developed a simplified multivariable equation that describes your job.
Now that you’ve come this far, you probably know more about doing your job than 90 percent of the CAD managers I’ve ever talked to. You have a good understanding of what’s expected of you in your environment and who expects it, and you have a game plan to get there. But one important thing is missing from your CAD management plan: authority. Your authority. I see far too many CAD managers who are expected to do a lot but are given no power to do their jobs. Many of these CAD managers will say their management team doesn’t give them the power they need to do the job. But I would argue that it’s the CAD manager’s responsibility to gain the power required to do the job. Nobody is going to give you the power to go out and tell people how to work, until you earn it. Your senior management is the only group that can give you the power you need. To gain that power, you must earn your management’s respect. This is why I’ve taken so much time in this chapter to help you develop your task list and think things through. When management questions you, when they ultimately want you to make recommendations and tell them why things should be done a certain way, you’ll be well prepared. How do you take the task list and all the thought, variables, and equations you’ve developed and distill them down so you can gain the power you need to do your job? The process is somewhat detailed, so I’ll tackle it step by step: You must have clear documentation. It’s not enough to think about the tasks you need to accomplish. It’s not enough to think about what order they should be done in or how much they will cost: You have to write it down. In order for management to
16531c01.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 15
understand what you’re doing, you must have your prioritized list of tasks written in a brief, executive-summary format. CAD managers frequently try to write their task list in great technical detail, and they go to great lengths to talk about software versions, RAM requirements, and so forth, even though most senior management staff won’t understand that kind of information. Your summary should be brief and business focused and should use “money talks” logic wherever possible. After you’ve written it down, you have to be able to present it. If you get a chance to present your ideas to senior management staff, you’ll probably have to go into a board room to do so. It pays for you to have a clean, professional PowerPoint presentation ready for such occasions. You want to hit your high points, communicating what you’re trying to accomplish and why. Brevity is key: If you think you’ll have 15 minutes to present your agenda to the board, build a PowerPoint presentation that takes five minutes to run through, and assume that you’ll have 10 minutes for questions. I’ve found this three-to-one rule pretty effective over the years. If you create a 15-minute PowerPoint for a 15-minute meeting, you’re not leaving any time for interaction.
You must ask for authority. If everyone nods and says you have a good plan, that’s the time to strike! You must now ask, “Will you give me the authority to do this?” or “Will you give me the budget approval to accomplish these tasks?” If you’re at the point that management likes your planning and reasoning, they already know you need funding or authority to do the job. They’re waiting for you to close the deal. Don’t disappoint them—go ahead and ask! Ask respectfully. When you make a presentation to senior management, they judge you on many different levels. They try to see how effectively you present, how effectively you think, and how well you can answer questions. They’re also asking themselves these questions: “Can this person really make this work? Can this person do what they say they can do?” By asking nicely for the resources required, you show that you understand not only the issues, not only the variables, but also that it will take authority and budget to accomplish the job. The last benefit is that when you deal with management in a tactful, thoughtful way, they like you better as a person. There’s no reason not to have that advantage!
15 ■ GAINING THE POWER TO DO YOUR JOB
When you’re presenting, you must be conversant. I’ve encouraged you to diligently define your job so that you’ll have thought through everything, not once or twice, but many times from different perspectives. This thought and preparation will to pay off when you’re presenting your ideas to senior management staff. When they question you, you’ll have the answers handy and will seem on top of the material without being nervous or struggling. You’ll know exactly what to answer because you’ll have thought about the subject ad nauseum already.
16531c01.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 16
Making It Happen At this point, I hope you’ve gained some thorough preparation and a framework of understanding of all the variables, tasks, and perspectives that the CAD management job entails. Yes, it’s a complex job. Yes, you must consider many variables to do it. But the more you think, the more you prepare, and the better you can handle the giveand-take and the questions, the easier it’ll be. Probably more than other positions, the CAD manager has to balance technical and managerial factors. That’s why the preparation you’ve gone through in this chapter is so critical. Demonstrating the ability to judge, juggle, balance, and prioritize is exactly what gives you the basis to gain the power to do your job. As you plan how to attack your CAD management job, keep the following general truths in mind:
CHAPTER
1:
W H AT ’ S I N V O LV E D : D E F I N I N G T H E P O S I T I O N ■
16
•
If management thinks that all you do is serve the user perspective, they’ll form the opinion that you’re a great technical person but not management material.
•
If you serve only the managerial perspective, your users will feel under-supported, and their impression will ultimately get back to management.
•
Handling the tough decisions using financial, “money talks” logic trumps all other decision-making metrics because the company’s financial well-being is your ultimate concern.
•
Gaining the power to do your job is a matter of making management understand that you’ve mastered the concepts I’ve discussed.
What I hope we’ve accomplished in this chapter is to prod you into thinking about all the different aspects and facets of the CAD manager’s job. Before you read any further in the book make sure you’ve accomplished the following tasks since they’ll form the basis for everything you’ll do: •
Get all your tasks down in list form
•
Analyze the list based on the approaches outlined
•
Think, think and think some more
•
Rework your list any time you think of a new task you must manage
Obviously this is a difficult process, but nobody said this job would be easy, right? I’d rather you spend more time here in Chapter 1 really thinking about what you need to do and how you need to do it, than have you barnstorm forward. The time you spend here will pay you back tenfold in the future, believe me. In Chapter 2, we’ll talk about taking stock of your current situation and how to put the definition of your position into practice within your company.
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 17
Taking Stock of Your Current Situation In Chapter 1, you mapped out the tasks you need to manage; now it’s time to take charge of your CAD management situation. But before you begin taking random actions, you must assess your current situation so you can gauge what resources answer the following basic questions about your environment: •
What are your users’ strengths and weaknesses, and how will they affect your ability to do your job?
2
•
What hardware and software resources do you have, and how well matched are those resources to your users?
•
What type of network resources and processes are in place, and how will they help or hinder you?
17 ■ TAKING STOCK OF YOUR CURRENT SITUATION
are available to you. At minimum, you need to
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 18
•
What kinds of work processes are in place now, and how will you need to change them to achieve your goals?
•
What kind of planning can you do to take all of the above into account and be more effective?
•
What level of budget will you be allocated to achieve your CAD management mission?
Answering these questions is critical because the only way you can chart an intelligent CAD management course is to acknowledge the reality of your starting point. Although you may not consider your CAD management starting point ideal, at least you’ll know what you’re up against. In this chapter, I’ll take you through a step-by-step process you can use to inventory your current work situation. You’ll find that the time you spend here will greatly assist you in understanding what you can realistically achieve.
CHAPTER
2:
TAKING STOCK OF YOUR CURRENT SITUATION ■
18
User Skills Assessment Evaluating the skills of the users in your company is the most important assessment you’ll undertake and thus the one you should tackle first. The reason for assessing user skills so critically is because no other factor will limit you—or guarantee your success—more than user expertise. The more skilled your users, are the easier it will be for them to learn new efficiency-improving procedures. On the other hand, low user proficiency makes improvement much harder. When assessing user skills, consider measuring the following: •
Knowledge of software features
•
Comprehension of standard practices
By assessing these key areas, you can identify user strengths and weaknesses in every aspect of their software usage. And remember that users can understand their software environment well but cost you productivity if they don’t understand company standards. User(s) begin work on task
Task Assigned
CAD User(s)
Figure 2.1 The starting point of all work is the user, so assessing user knowledge establishes a baseline of what you can accomplish as CAD manager.
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 19
Deploying a Test If you have a large base of CAD users, skills assessment can be a time-consuming process unless you automate the process. Creating a good user-assessment test requires you to think about the questions you’ll ask and then make sure your test is clear and accurate before you unleash it. To achieve these goals, follow this process: Create a list of questions specific to your CAD software that measure user knowledge. Be sure to cover the common functions all users must use like geometry creation, editing, annotating, and plotting at bare minimum.
2.
Create another list of questions that measure knowledge of standards. You might want to question use of specific layers, fonts, symbology, etc., to make sure the user has actually read the applicable standards.
3.
For each question, craft a list of responses with only one right answer and several incorrect answers that can trip up someone without adequate knowledge. The key here is not to confuse, but to create several possible answers to allow multiple choice testing without users being able to guess the correct answer.
4.
Have your CAD power users review your questions and answers, and encourage them to add their own questions to the test.
5.
Create the actual test document as a paper handout or an HTML form, or use a software testing application (see sidebar) to deliver the test for you.
6.
Let users take the test, and grade the results.
7.
Draw conclusions on user strengths and weaknesses based on the results you observe.
I’ve developed a number of assessment tests and have found that the results are always surprising. You may find that some users have huge gaps in their CAD knowledge that they’ve been concealing for years. You may also find that some users genuinely don’t understand your standards—a problem that may have misdiagnosed as simply not reading standards in the past.
Interpreting Results Once you deploy your custom test, you’ll have results to interpret. You should draw conclusions about weak or strong areas of knowledge for each user. Specifically, you’re looking for patterns of user knowledge that allow you to draw conclusions regarding needed training and support. For example: •
If many users create geometry well, but they have weaknesses in plotting/scaling concepts, this indicates a systemic problem with your plotting processes that likely requires group training.
19 ■ USER SKILLS ASSESSMENT
1.
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 20
•
If only a few users have problems with filing standards, then this indicates an isolated problem that is best tackled via individual tutoring.
•
If a few users excel in all areas of testing you’ve found your power users.
By screening all your users for software and standards knowledge, you should be able to build a list of training topics based on actual need rather than speculation. And believe me when I say that the results of evaluating users’ skill sets can be surprising.
Using Testing Software The value of using software to deploy tests is that you don’t have to worry about grading, timing, or delivering a paper-based test. Although you still have to develop testing questions and load them into the testing software, you expend no more effort than authoring a paper test but reap the benefits of testing automation from that point on. The only software utility I’ve located to perform automated testing is called AutoTEST Pro (see Figure 2.2) by Academix Software (www.academix.com). AutoTEST Pro is inexpensive and runs in standalone or network environments, providing deployment, timing, and grading capabilities (all key to a good testing program).To load your custom questions into AutoTEST Pro, you need Microsoft Access; but if you’re handy with computer tools like Excel or Access, you’ll have no problems. At minimum, you should consider trying the free download trial to see what possibilities computer-based testing can bring to the table.You may think that dealing with another piece of software is too much to take on, but the economy of effort gained has been worth it for me.
CHAPTER
2:
TAKING STOCK OF YOUR CURRENT SITUATION ■
20
Figure 2.2 Automated software testing tools like AutoTEST Pro take the drudgery out of skills assessment.
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 21
Attitudinal and Management Issues When you conduct user assessments, you need to confront a couple of key attitude issues before anybody gets the wrong idea about why they’re being tested. Take a moment to think like your users, and consider that they may be asking the following questions: •
We’ve never had skills testing before, so why now?
•
What have I been doing wrong that is making them test me?
•
Are they considering layoffs and figuring out whom to let go?
•
Is upper management pushing this?
If you think about these questions from the users’ perspective, you have to admit that you can see why users would wonder. And always remember that a lot of people panic over being tested, no matter what the subject or reason. In order to mitigate these concerns, I recommend the following approaches:
Emphasize that there will be no firings Don’t ever let the idea take root that user-skills assessment is being used to punish people or as a reason to fire anyone. If you hear that sort of conversation going on, step in and stop it immediately. De-emphasize upper management with users If your users are curious about upper management’s involvement, tell them that upper management wants productivity, and you’re trying to improve it. Handling the question in this way keeps the emotions about testing between you and your users, where it should be. Highlight productivity with your management If anyone in upper management asks why you’re deploying tests or why you’re making people nervous, tell them that you’re trying to gain productivity. You can further explain that knowing where your department’s weak spots are will let you target and train to achieve your productivity goals.
Drawing Conclusions If you undertake all the steps I’ve outlined, you’ll be armed with a volume of data that helps you understand your user base and what areas you need to work on. I can’t stress enough that a user-skills assessment determines what you can do, how hard you can push, and what level of performance you can expect from your users over time by telling you what your users already know. And when you know what your users know it becomes a lot easier to figure out what you need to teach them. You may find that knowing your users’ strengths and weaknesses is the most valuable tool in your CAD management arsenal simply because it lets you plan your future course with full awareness of what your staff can and can’t do.
21 ■ USER SKILLS ASSESSMENT
Make it positive Tell your user base that a skills assessment helps you determine which areas you need to focus on for technical training. Tell them that you don’t want to speculate, so you need a baseline measurement to get started.
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 22
Software Assessment Most CAD managers are expected to keep track of their software licenses and make recommendations about new software acquisitions over time. To monitor your software environment, you need to track not just hard parameters like license numbers, renewal dates, upgrade fees, and so on, but also how well you’re using the software you manage. Let’s examine the larger view of software assessment by exploring an example where software resources are compared with a user-skills assessment like the one you completed in the prior section: Examining a software scenario A company has 10 copies of SolidWorks for mechanical 3D modeling and 10 copies of AutoCAD for all 2D CAD tasks. All software is found to be under a current subscription agreement that renews every year unless cancelled.
Creating a sample assessment By comparing the user-skills profiles against the number of software licenses owned, it seems fairly obvious that the company probably owns too many copies of SolidWorks and not enough copies of AutoCAD based on current usage patterns. This simple assessment should allow you to examine your company’s software needs from a position of user skills rather than a list of serial numbers and renewal dates. CAD filter applied here
CHAPTER
2:
TAKING STOCK OF YOUR CURRENT SITUATION ■
22
A user-skills assessment of 20 CAD users finds that only 4 users are very skilled with SolidWorks, and another 5 are somewhat skilled. On the AutoCAD side of assessment, 15 users are very skilled with AutoCAD, and the other 5 users are somewhat skilled.
Task Assigned
CAD User(s)
Knowledge Captured in Software
Figure 2.3 CAD software is the filter that converts human expertise into digital design files. Having the right mix of software tools to complement your user base allows the most efficient conversion.
Summarizing Your Findings The sample scenario brings up some interesting questions that I’ll summarize here: •
Why would a company buy more (or less) software than it needs?
•
Why would a company buy software that its users can’t operate?
•
Why hasn’t anyone noticed these questions before?
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 23
The answer to these questions is most likely that the company hasn’t had a strong CAD manager to deal with these questions. Pondering these questions over the years has led me to some conclusions that seem to be valid in most cases: Software should match user skills If the software tools you own don’t match the skills of your user base, then your company is probably wasting money. Think about this statement, and realize that it’s true for two reasons:
1.
If you own software that your users don’t comprehend, then that software isn’t being used, thus providing no value to the company.
2.
If you own too little of the software that users do comprehend, then chances are that users are waiting in line to use those tools, which costs money in the form of delays.
In either scenario, efficiency is sacrificed because software resources haven’t been harmonized with user skill levels. Sometimes a software assessment may point out invalid assumptions (such as, “all users will learn 3D in the next year”) that never came to fruition (thus causing poor utilization of the 3D software).
Software budgets should adjust to match user skills Now that you know what software your users can really use, and the reality of the software you own, perhaps it’s time to adjust your budgeting and purchasing to reflect your users’ skill sets. In the example case, it seems clear that you should at least examine converting some SolidWorks seats to AutoCAD. Because high-end 3D software like SolidWorks costs more per seat than AutoCAD, you can achieve costs savings as a bonus.
Hardware Assessment As with a software assessment, you need to know what hardware resources exist within your company and how effectively that hardware is running the software you use. It should be fairly simple for CAD managers in smaller firms to do a physical inventory of hardware resources; those in larger firms can work with their IT departments to gather the information. At minimum, you want to catalog the following hardware attributes: For computers/workstations/servers: •
Age of machine
•
Processor version and speed
•
Amount of memory
•
Video adapter resolution and memory
•
Hard-drive capacity
■ HARDWARE ASSESSMENT
Acknowledge your findings If your software assessment points out any of the aforementioned software/user imbalances, let your management know, and start the discussion about adjusting software resources. There’s no point in performing an assessment and not acting on the results.
23
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 24
For printers/plotters: •
Age of device
•
File format handling (HPGL, CALS, JPEG, and so on)
•
Amount of memory
•
Computer interface (network adapter, USB, and so on)
•
Driver availability for your software
Compile the information you gather in a brief list format, and sort the list in order of hardware age. As a result, you’ll have a great start on understanding how current or outdated your hardware is. These types of lists go a long way toward helping you get the attention of senior management when budgeting for new hardware.
Example Case Revisited
CHAPTER
2:
TAKING STOCK OF YOUR CURRENT SITUATION ■
24
Let’s go back to the example case illustrated in the “Software Assessment” section, where the company has 10 copies of AutoCAD for 2D work and 10 copies of SolidWorks for 3D work. We’ll continue the example by injecting some hardwareassessment criteria into the equation, and see what we can conclude: Hardware-assessment results The company owns 16 three-year-old Pentium-class machines with minimal memory, video, and disk resources. Four users’ machines are newer dual-core architecture with ample resources. Further investigation shows that the four high-power machines are being used by the four high-end 3D users, and the older machines are being used for AutoCAD.
Drawing Conclusions The good news in the example case is that the company’s hardware matches the needs and skill levels of the users. Although the presence of so much old hardware is cause for concern (because it will have to be replaced soon), everyone can be productive with what they have. The bigger concerns have to do with where the company is going and what the expectations will be with respect to 3D software usage and budget levels for hardware. I’ll draw some conclusions: Upgrade options are limited With so much older hardware (remember, most machines in the example are three years old), not much can be done to upgrade the machines. Even if a new video adapter or more memory is installed, the architecture of the machine limits its capabilities. These older machines will never be 3D workstations no matter what is done to tune them up. Does management understand this? Hardware should match 3D software To make a long story short, your hardware should be at least as new as the 3D software you propose to run on it, in order for that software to run optimally. If you propose to start using the latest version of a 3D building modeler or mechanical design software package, you should be using hardware that is essentially new to get the best results.
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 25
Task Assigned
CAD User(s) Task Assigned
Hardware must match software for optimum efficiency of output
Knowledge Captured in Software
Hardware Runs Software
Figure 2.4 Even the best users with all the right software will struggle if their hardware isn’t up to the task. Harmonizing your software and hardware gives you the best cost/performance ratio—and happy users, too.
Don’t assume that IT understands CAD hardware Your IT department may be more focused on general office applications or web browser–based applications and not understand the unique computing and data-bandwidth requirements of CAD. Most IT departments don’t worry about harmonizing hardware to software, so it’s your task to do so for your department and make all parties aware of its importance.
Budgeting Wake-Up Call How did your software tools line up with the hardware you have? If you find that your hardware is woefully outdated, then you need to budget for new hardware sooner rather than later. And if you have outdated hardware along with aggressive ambitions to move to more complex software, you may have a budgeting problem on your hands. If you’re in the position of having to budget for a lot of new hardware, you should inform management immediately.The keys to formatting the bad budgeting news for management are as follows: •
Write down the hardware inventory information in a brief format.
•
Write down the software you use and what machines it will run well on.
•
Write a brief explanation of each machine’s life expectancy, how soon you need to replace it, and why.
Now that all the information is in writing, have a budgeting conversation with management, and at least plant the seeds of your new budget requirements.Your management may not like the costs, but they need to know about them. And you need to be prepared for a longer timeframes than you hoped for, to get budget dollars. Having the conversation early makes things easier for you and management.
25 ■ HARDWARE ASSESSMENT
Manufacturer’s guidelines When in doubt about hardware guidelines, why not use the software developer’s recommendations as a starting point? It’s hard for anyone to argue with the correctness of the documented hardware configuration provided by a software company.
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 26
IT Assessments In addition to the other assessments performed, you must consider the available state of your network and IT resources. Users run software on computers and peripherals that are hooked together by networks, so understanding those networks becomes important to the CAD manager. And because networks utilize username and password– level encryption, network security is another area you must consider. CAD managers are expected to manage things like active files, archives, and backups, so network security is a concern that the CAD manager must be aware of. Unless you’re an IT expert, it will be to your advantage to form a working partnership with your firm’s IT department. The good news is that most companies have some sort of IT infrastructure, and that staff typically welcomes CAD manager involvement. In many cases, IT departments have little idea of how to deal with CAD applications, so an informed CAD manager is an asset they can take advantage of. If you find yourself in this win-win scenario, count yourself lucky.
Network Changes Although you probably won’t be responsible for the care and feeding of the corporate network, it helps to have an idea of the networking variables that can affect you. The key aspects to consider are how the network will change over time and how those changes influence you.
CAD Workstation
CAD Workstation
CHAPTER
2:
TAKING STOCK OF YOUR CURRENT SITUATION ■
26
Network Server
CAD Workstation
CAD Workstation
Figure 2.5 Networks connect computers (and therefore users) to each other in a digital community. Assessing your network’s state of health, now and into the future, lets you know how well your user community will function.
In order to assess the situation, I recommend asking your IT department the following questions: •
How much server space and capacity do we have today, and is it adequate?
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 27
•
How fast are the data connections between various offices in our company (assuming you have this issue)? Will these connections undergo change in the next year?
•
Will we outgrow our network in the next year? The year after?
•
Will we be revamping our telecommunications, Internet, or branch office networking strategies?
The answers to these questions allow you to draw powerful conclusions about the stability (or instability) of your network environment’s physical infrastructure. The more you hear about things changing, the more nervous you should be about possible work interruptions due to network outages or technical glitches. If you have any doubts about how network changes may affect your CAD users, ask your IT staff for guidance.
Note:
If your assessment determines that branch-office connections will be changing or that branch offices will be added, you should be concerned about how the changes can impact you. If you have work teams split among various branch offices, the problems associated with sharing files can become glaring, particularly when connection speeds are slow. Again, if you have doubts, press your IT department for guidance.
Note:
Fast data connections make users feel close to each other regardless of distance. Conversely, slow data connections can make users in the same building feel far apart.The savvy CAD manager takes the speed of data connections into account when planning work environments/teams.
File Sharing/Security Now that you have an idea of how your network is configured and how it will evolve in the near future, it’s time to assess how file sharing will be accomplished. To perform this assessment, you need to ask your IT department some additional questions: •
Will we share files via shared servers even between remote offices?
•
Will we utilize Internet-based file sharing like FTP sites or web storage tools?
•
Will customers/vendors be able to access our files? If so, what methods will they use?
•
What types of security mechanisms will be used to keep all the files safe?
27 ■ IT ASSESSMENTS
Networks behave a lot like software in that they’re most likely to experience problems while they’re being modified.
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 28
Again, you’re looking for a glimpse into the mind of the IT department and where they’re taking the network. My experience has shown that the only stupid IT question is the question you forget to ask—take the time to have the conversation. If you don’t understand the answer to any question, re-phrase/re-ask until you do.
The Working Relationship If you’re spending time working with your IT department to assess the situation, why not turn the experience into an excellent working relationship? I’ve frequently observed CAD managers not working closely with IT, which makes no sense considering the following metrics:
CHAPTER
2:
TAKING STOCK OF YOUR CURRENT SITUATION ■
28
•
IT determines how well your users can do their job, because IT controls all the machinery used to run CAD.
•
IT, if not managed properly, can slow user productivity via poor allocation of resources.
•
IT can make file sharing easy or hard, safe or perilous, depending on the types of technology and security they implement.
With all these parameters at stake, why wouldn’t you want to work well with IT? Here are a few things you can do to build the relationship while doing your IT assessment at the same time: Learn all you can about IT while doing your assessment The IT staff will appreciate your attentiveness and respect your growing base of knowledge in the future. Try to walk a mile in IT’s shoes By understanding the issues revolving around file and network security, servers, hardware, and Internet technology that IT manages, you’ll gain new respect for what they do. You’ll also find that you’ll be able to predict IT trends in the future using your new-found expertise. Teach IT about CAD when you can There’s no reason why the information exchange shouldn’t be bidirectional. And when you emphasize the complexity of what you do, IT will better accommodate you in the future and have more respect for the technology you manage. Stress file management Make it clear to the IT department that CAD files tend to be huge compared to other computer files and that CAD users therefore are much more critical of network speed and file-sharing methods. Driving home these points goes a long way toward making IT understand that CAD users aren’t cranky: They just work with really big file sets. I can’t stress highly enough that in order to be an effective CAD manager, you must have a positive, constructive working relationship with your IT staff. If your relationship with IT is adversarial, you’ll inadvertently miss network events that can affect you, and your users will suffer as a result. Go out of your way and do whatever it takes to forge that relationship using the network assessment as a conversation starter.
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 29
Finding Red Flags in Your Assessment As you interact with your IT department and assess the various aspects of your networks and security, it’s possible that you may not like what you hear. Being able to see the red-flag problems will help you identify any issues that may become big problems later. Here are the common problems I’ve encountered along with the danger signs that usually accompany them: Undercapitalized branch offices Poor connectivity may exist between branch offices, and/or there may be insufficient budgets to do anything about the problem. Management teams expect branch offices to communicate and are usually intolerant of networks being a barrier to that communication. If no funding is budgeted to make the situation work, you can be sure you’ll have problems.
Dismissive IT attitudes If, despite all your efforts, you can’t forge a working relationship with IT, then you should be worried. IT departments that pay no attention to CAD managers invariably make mistakes that could have been prevented. If you find yourself in this scenario, you should consider elevating the issue to management in hopes of rectifying the lack of communication.
Conclusions Drawn If you follow the recommendations laid out for the IT assessment, you should have a good idea of where you stand today and how the future looks. More important, you’ll know what, if anything, may be a problem, so you know what to avoid. React accordingly.
Budgetary Assessment If you followed along with me so far, you now have a pretty good understanding of where your users stand, where your software stands, what your hardware situation is like, and what sort of network and IT infrastructure ties it all together. Chances are, you’ve already started to formulate some ideas about things you might change. And constantly thinking about adapting your environment based on assessments is exactly what a CAD manager should be doing! Now it’s time for a severe reality check: your budget. You can request new software, new hardware, and new networks, but if you can’t get the dollars to purchase them, nothing will ever materialize. In a real sense, until you understand your budgetary limitations, both long and short term, you won’t be able to determine what to do with your department.
29 ■ BUDGETARY ASSESSMENT
Frequent user complaints If your users are complaining to you about the status of the network, then you have a problem, even if it’s only one of perception. When networks aren’t up to the current set of tasks, you know the situation will only get worse in the future.
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 30
Making the Assessment The first thing to realize is that understanding your budget means talking with the people who set your budget: your management. Now is the time to set up a meeting with your management team to talk over your budget options. Whether you’re experienced with budgets or not, having this meeting sets a professional tone and demonstrates your understanding of the process. When you attend your budget meeting, use the following points to keep the conversation moving along. Try to use the order I’ve suggested so you can draw conclusions as you go. I’ll present some conclusions after each question so you can understand what to concentrate on. I’ll also qualify why I’ve asked the questions in this order and what types of information I’m looking for from each. Be aware that you sometimes have to read between the lines to get the answer!
CHAPTER
2:
TAKING STOCK OF YOUR CURRENT SITUATION ■
30
1: How does the budget look over the next several years? By asking an open-ended question about budgets, you get management’s gut reaction. You may not like what you hear, but at least you’re getting the unvarnished version of what management believes to be true. If you want clarification about actual amounts of money, you can ask clarifying questions until you’re confident that you understand management’s starting position. 2 and 3: Will the company be growing, acquiring branch offices, buying other firms? Should I plan for more CAD users in the next few years, fewer, the same number? By asking questions that focus on company growth in terms of both users and office locations, you start to see management’s vision for the company’s growth. Watch out during this stage, because aggressive growth plans may not be reflected in the budget starting point outlined in question 1. As you understand the growth plans for the company, you’ll know what to plan for and whether management knows what they’re getting into. 4: Will we work more collaboratively with vendors/customers via the Internet? By asking about far-away collaboration, typically via the Internet, you can see if management has grand visions for remote work teams, home-based employees, customers tapping into drawing systems, and so on. Frequently, management underestimates the costs of these types of undertaking, thinking that they require only another CAD equipped machine rather than another machine plus Internet bandwidth, control software, additional security devices, and more. You get the point. 5: Will we be doing more 3D, less, none? By asking about 3D usage, you can see if management has visions of radically new work processes which will require large volumes of training, higher power computers, and new expertise on your part as CAD manager. Frequently, management focuses on the results they want and underestimates the steps and costs it will take to get those results. Plan accordingly.
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 31
6: Do you see any cost saving opportunities we could be pursuing that I haven’t thought of? By asking whether you can save money anywhere, you send a great message about your desire to help control costs. More important, you give management the green light to talk with you about things they’ve probably been thinking but didn’t know how to bring up.
31 ■ BUDGETARY ASSESSMENT
Figure 2.6 Budgets drive everything you need to do.Whether it’s user training, software, hardware, or networking you can’t change the current situation without funds to make it happen.
Find the Disconnects When you emerge from the budget meetings and reflect on the results, does anything bother you? Do you see any item that requires clarification or follow-up on your part? If so, then quick action is required to rectify the problems before everyone forgets about the issues. You can use the following example case as a template for communicating budget problems to management: Example scenario You emerge from a budget meeting where you learned that your company plans to acquire several more branch offices. Upon further review, it becomes clear that management expects these branches to work together in teams with personnel in other offices. When you pressed for clarification about budgeting for networks and telecommunications to connect the offices, you learned that management feels the existing IT budget will be sufficient.
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 32
The disconnects What jumps out about this scenario is the lack of understanding that branch offices need to be connected to other offices via fast data lines if teams are to collaborate over distances. It seems clear that management doesn’t understand that poor network connections will make wide area work teams very difficult to implement. Technically, yes, users will be connected—but they will hate working in such a slow network environment. Take action Now is the time to tactfully write up the scenario and request a follow-up meeting to discuss the issue. Consider bringing in staff from your IT department or users from other branch offices (via phone call) to support your points and lend you credibility. Remember that you’re teaching management about the problem, so don’t be confrontational, just tactfully informative.
Drawing Conclusions
CHAPTER
2:
TAKING STOCK OF YOUR CURRENT SITUATION ■
32
Don’t expect to come out of the budget-assessment phase with millions of dollars in your back pocket. But do expect to emerge with a much better working relationship with senior management, for the following reasons: •
They will understand that you’re a good steward of their money.
•
They will understand that you want to get good results.
•
They will see your diligence and respect your willingness to learn.
•
They will see that you understand the big picture and can tie it all together into a comprehensive budget.
•
They will see that you’re more than a CAD operator: You’re a real manager.
Throughout the budget-assessment process, keep a positive, learning attitude and engage your management team in the discussion. Above all, show that you respect the company’s money as if it were your own, and strive to get great results out of every dollar you budget. Believe me, senior management appreciates anybody who understands that there are only so many dollars to go around.
Standards/Process Assessments Most CAD managers are responsible for CAD standards, but did you know that makes you a process manager as well? I contend that having a standard is merely a way of standardizing a work process. The process is what’s important; the standard is simply the way to achieve the process. However, many CAD managers report having troubles with their standards and work processes, principally due to difficulty of enforcement. If you’ve had those frustrations, you aren’t alone: 85 to 90 percent of CAD managers in my annual CAD-management surveys have indicated having problems with CAD standards.
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 33
I encourage you to assess how your standards and processes are working. CAD managers are so busy fighting fires that it becomes easy to lose track of the big picture. Assessing the big-picture view lets you see how things work and how to improve them. And when you make things work better from the big-picture point of view, you’ll fight fewer fires. In this section, I’ll give you some techniques you can use to analyze your current situation and build ideas for improvement. The great news about assessing processes and standards is it doesn’t cost anything other than time and thought. These are the two resources that CAD managers have available at all times, and they should be used more.
A Formulaic Approach To make a standard or a process change, you must follow a few simple steps:
1.
Analyze the process.
2.
Document how it works.
3.
Suggest changes.
4.
Document the changes.
5.
Train users on following the new process.
6.
Implement the new process.
33
Task Assigned
Everything from start to finish is perceived as a single process
CAD User(s) Task Assigned
Task Completed
Knowledge Captured in Software
Hardware Runs Software
Figure 2.7 Processes are the one place you can change things with minimal funding. Because users typically facilitate process changes, you don’t have to worry too much about software, hardware, or networks during your process assessment.
■ STANDARDS/PROCESS ASSESSMENTS
That’s it. Use what you know about your work environment to make smart changes, and then systematically roll out the changes to the user community. Note that this process isn’t like buying a new computer; it doesn’t require $4,000 to go out and get a new process. Why not take a hard look at your CAD processes and standards? And why not do so on a repeated basis? Thinking is free, so you should think all you can and constantly analyze your processes and standards for improvement. The more you analyze and think, the more cost and labor savings you’ll find, which will make you a hero to management.
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 34
Getting Ideas If you want to find great ideas for improving processes while assessing existing processes, try using this methodology: The white-board method Go into a conference room with a large white board, some colored markers, and an open mind. Follow these steps:
1.
Go to the left side of the white board, and write Start Drawing.
2.
Go to the right side of the white board, and write Drawing Done.
3.
Fill in the gaps with all steps required to get from start to finish
You may be surprised that as you try to diagram the process, even you become confused. You’ll see where the inefficiencies and pinch points are. And here’s the beauty: You’ll understand how the process works, good or bad, when you’re done.
CHAPTER
2:
TAKING STOCK OF YOUR CURRENT SITUATION ■
34
Now you can pull in other managers, power users, and people from other departments and consult with them about how to improve the process. The old adage of a picture being worth a thousand words will demonstrate itself as people dive toward the white board and fix problems with the process. You’ll be amazed how easy it is to engage people in redesigning processes using this methodology.
No Shortcuts The process of assessing your standards and processes can be time consuming, but I know of no other way to tackle the problem. You have to understand the broken processes before you can improve them, and having the right people putting in quality thought is the only way. If this process takes a week, or two weeks, or a month, that’s fine. The point is the rewards you’ll bring to your company when you’re finished, which include: •
Understanding how your business works
•
Getting others to focus on process
•
Getting others to innovate and improve processes with you
•
Getting management to see how focused you are on improvement
The more you assess processes, the more management will become aware of your value. In my experience, process assessment is the best way to start a great relationship with your management. And remember, you can do all this for only the cost of your time and creative thought!
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 35
Drawing Conclusions Sometimes, CAD managers have a reputation of being too technical, too hands-on, and not focused enough on the business aspect of the job. But if you pay proper attention to processes and standards, those objections will quickly begin to go away. If you embrace the concept of evaluating how you work and viewing it as a process that can be improved, you’ll never see CAD the same way again. In a process-focused view of your company, you’ll evaluate software based on how it improves your productivity, hardware based on efficiency, and training as a way to change user behavior toward more efficient, smarter work processes. As CAD manager, you have the unique ability to use your technological strength to revise your company’s processes and standards. I promise that when you do so, management will notice.
Prioritizing Based on Need
Nothing works without smart users If your users’ skill base is lacking, then you should begin by enriching your users via training and the establishment of better processes. Smart users can be throttled by bad software or hardware If your software/hardware isn’t well matched, it can impede smart users’ ability to get work done. If you experience machine crashes or software limitations, then budgeting for these problems becomes your top priority. Users can’t work in remote teams or collaborate without good networks If your network systems are problematic, they will affect your users’ ability to work. Perhaps even worse, poor networks can hamper better processes in wide area environments because users can’t move data efficiently. If you experience network problems, then getting with the IT staff to explore solutions becomes your top priority. Bad processes waste time If everything else works well, then focus on processes, because there are always ways to improve how you work. Budgeting is always important Nothing gets done without money, so assessing your budget should be an ongoing high-priority task for all CAD managers.
35 ■ PRIORITIZING BASED ON NEED
Now that you have an idea of how to assess all the components of your operating environment, how do you know where to start? This is a great question that can only be answered by giving you a method to make your own decision. Consider the following recommendations in this order, and a clear idea of where to focus should emerge:
16531c02.qxd
3/19/07
1:36 PM
Page 36
These items are a lot to juggle, but it’s essential that you find a way to keep an eye on all of them. Focus on the area of assessment that is most problematic, and you’ll systematically get a better CAD environment as a result. To stay on top of the details, I encourage you to keep a running list of ideas that can deliver more productivity. Never stop thinking, never stop evaluating, and never stop trying to improve, and you’ll be a great CAD manager.
CHAPTER
2:
TAKING STOCK OF YOUR CURRENT SITUATION ■
36
16531c03.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 37
Managing Your Management One of the things I’ve tried to establish in the first two chapters is the importance of working with thing you do as a CAD manager is easier if management is on your side. So, from a strictly selfish standpoint, you should want to manage the relationship you have with your management.
37 ■ MANAGING YOUR MANAGEMENT
3
and informing your management. I believe every-
16531c03.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 38
Your Tasks Budgets
Training
Enabler Results
Procurement
Management Involvement - via Budget Approval - via Delegated Authority - via Political Support
Task Completed
Processes
Efficiency
CHAPTER
3:
MANAGING YOUR MANAGEMENT ■
38
Figure 3.1 No matter what you do, you can’t succeed without management. Management serves as the filter through which all resources you require must flow.
Here are some universal truths about senior management that CAD managers seem to miss given the day-to-day technical environment they operate in: •
Management controls the money, and money makes things happen.
•
Management sets priorities and pushes to get things done.
•
Management delegates authority, thus enabling you to do your job.
•
Management loves having their CAD manager work with them.
Therefore, it should be obvious that if you don’t have a positive working relationship with your management, it’s going to be much more difficult to do your job. In this chapter, I’ll pass along some techniques you can use to communicate more effectively with your management and thus manage the relationship to your advantage.
Manage: Not Manipulate By managing your management, I mean that you should know what you need to do, what results your management wants from you, and how to work that relationship in a positive manner. Communication is the key to managing your management staff and their expectations. In this chapter, I’ll introduce some methodologies you can use to identify what management expects from you and how to manage that relationship in the most constructive and cost-effective manner possible. Another advantage to you is that the more you manage your management staff, the less they have to manage you, and the more freedom you’ll have.
16531c03.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 39
Debunking the Myths I’ve spoken with many senior managers over the years, and I’ve discovered that many of them believe certain myths about CAD managers. Let me address those myths and give you some strategies for debunking them. First, it’s worth pointing out that when management has a perception of you, it’s immaterial whether you agree with that perception or not. If the perception is erroneous, you must confront it and demonstrate that it isn’t true. The easiest way to do that with senior management is to communicate frequently in a purposeful manner that debunks the myth that senior management has brought into the relationship. Many senior managers don’t know all the duties that the CAD management position entails (technical, managerial, process management, software and hardware administration). If management doesn’t realize the scope of your job responsibilities, they probably have some misconceptions about CAD managers. Let’s consider some of these common misconceptions and discuss strategies for getting rid of them:
Myth #2: CAD managers are expensive; they’re always asking for high-end software and hardware The first key to debunking this myth is to admit that it’s partially true. Your software is more expensive than general office tools, and your hardware is more expensive than the $399 loss-leader special from the large computer discounters. But the reason your hardware and software is more expensive isn’t because you have goldplated tastes: It’s because your software is more complex and requires more hardware to run. To debunk this myth, you have to educate management about the complex
39 ■ DEBUNKING THE MYTHS
Myth #1: CAD managers are technical people who don’t understand anything about management Many times, senior management sees you dealing with complex technical issues like installing software or debugging machines. Chances are, the only time they see you in action is when you’re working on a machine or leading a user through a complex technical problem. It’s easy to see how they get the idea that you’re exclusively focused on technical aspects of the work: That’s what they see you doing. To dispel this myth, it’s crucial that management sees you performing managerial tasks. They probably won’t see you working on a budget or talking to the IT staff about future hardware or software plans. Therefore, written communication via a reporting mechanism to senior management is crucial. Over the years, I’ve used a simple reporting format whereby I tell my management what I’ve done during the previous week and what I hope to accomplish during the next week. If your management reads this brief report, they will see the wide variety of tasks that you have to deal with, and they will gain a new perspective of and respect for the job you do. They’ll also see that not everything you do is technical. This will go a long way toward debunking that technical-only myth that I mentioned. For more information about this reporting format, see the section “Reporting to Your Management,” later in this chapter.
16531c03.qxd
CHAPTER
3:
MANAGING YOUR MANAGEMENT ■
40
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 40
nature of the technical tasks that your software performs and why it requires higherend hardware. This will help top management understand that you aren’t just asking for more money—you actually need higher-end resources than staff who just check their e-mail or occasionally run a spreadsheet. Every time you ask upper management for something, be it a new piece of software or hardware, make sure you justify the cost of that object with some sort of productivity offset. Don’t just ask for the new version of CAD software; say why you need it and what productivity gain you’ll be able to achieve with it. Back up your conclusions and justifications with numbers. By showing your management staff that it costs money to make money—or, more specifically, that it may cost money in the short term to derive long-term productivity gains—you won’t be seen as asking for expensive tools; you’ll be seen as providing new capabilities. Believe me, management understands how to look at long-term investments to get long-term gain. The key is that CAD managers need to stop being viewed as employees who always ask for new toys and to start being viewed instead as achievers who are taking a proactive approach toward driving productivity improvement. Myth #3: CAD managers can’t see the big picture In Chapter 2, I discussed in detail how and why you should address this issue by taking stock of your current situation. Specifically, in the “Process and Standards Analysis” section, I urged you to examine your company’s overall work processes and the methodologies and standards you’re using to achieve your work product. This automatically focuses you on examining how things are getting done rather than what is getting done. Many of us function in a dayto-day environment where we’re so engrossed in solving our department’s or CAD users’ technical problems that we only worry about what’s getting done on any given day. Rather than thinking about the overall process, we get bogged down in minutia, and this feeds into Myth #3. To combat this myth, I propose you do the following: •
Concentrate on the process(es) by which work gets done.
•
Draw other people into discussions of the process(es).
•
Include your analysis of work process(es) and the comments from others in your reporting to, and conversations with, senior management.
If you do these things, management will start to see beyond the myths and recognize the bigger picture of the CAD manager’s job. It’s difficult. I personally had trouble starting to delegate and looking at how other people worked. And yes, it was hard at first to get away from the technical details and see the bigger picture. But I was able to make the change relatively quickly once I made a conscious effort to do so. If you take the time to focus on the bigger picture and look at work processes and how things are getting done, management will notice.
16531c03.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 41
41 ■ DEBUNKING THE MYTHS
Figure 3.2 Management’s perception of you controls how they treat you.When management’s perception is based on myth versus reality, you’ll find it difficult to achieve anything.
No, you won’t debunk Myth #3 overnight. But it will happen over time if you continue to make these types of changes and look at the bigger picture. I’ve found that when they start paying attention to their companies’ bigger-picture issues, most CAD managers can make a radical change in management’s perception within six months to a year. No matter what you attempt to achieve in your job, you have to break through the common myths your management holds about CAD managers. Use the guidelines I’ve outlined to take inventory of the myths your management has about CAD managers and take the time to debunk them. Once you’ve shattered management’s improper perceptions, you’ll get more done and enjoy more respect from your management.
16531c03.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 42
Why Management Is out of the Technology Loop
CHAPTER
3:
MANAGING YOUR MANAGEMENT ■
42
I frequently speak to groups of CAD managers, and I ask them this question: “How many of you feel that your management has no idea what you do for a living?” This question is usually greeted with mild laughter and a show of hands typically representing 70–80 percent of the room. This tells me that CAD managers are generally frustrated that their senior management doesn’t understand the technology challenges they face day-in and day-out. Or, simply put, management doesn’t understand how hard your job is. Many times, CAD managers feel under-appreciated and not understood. I often respond to the audience by asking, “Do you think it’s good that your management doesn’t understand what you do?” Interestingly, most people say no. They expect management to have more understanding of what they’re doing as CAD managers. But here is where I tend to buck convention. I think it’s great that upper management doesn’t know what we’re doing technically: I think they’re out of the loop for a reason. They’re out of the technology loop because they hired us to handle that loop. Between CAD managers and IT management, upper management expects us to handle the technological challenges on a daily basis. They hired us to take care of it, so why should they have to understand it? When you think about it that way, it’s a good thing that management doesn’t understand everything you do.
Note:
Remember that management is comfortable delegating and has, accordingly, delegated the process of CAD management to you. If they don’t understand what you do, it’s because they don’t need to!
I believe management is the art of dealing with problems. Take a moment to think about that statement and appreciate how true it is. If your management staff doesn’t understand what you do, then they don’t need to. If you’re managing your tasks and responsibilities effectively, they don’t need to understand everything you do. I also believe the reverse is true: When your management does understand everything you do, that indicates there are problems. If management feels that you’re not managing effectively, they’ll begin micromanaging you or somebody within the management ranks will start keeping a close eye on you. So, if your management staff doesn’t seem to understand what you do, they’re most likely not concerned and are giving you the freedom to move forward and do your job—and that’s a blessing. You should celebrate rather than be upset.
Meeting Company Needs—Not User Wants One basic thing you need to understand about your management staff is that they have their eye on what’s useful for the entire company. They aren’t predisposed to thinking
16531c03.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 43
•
Looks at the big picture of overall company needs
•
Helps meet company objectives like sales targets and productivity quotas
•
Considers CAD users’ wants and needs into the mix
•
Focuses on technology solutions for the common good User Wants
Task Assigned
Perform Design
Document Design
Deliver to Client
Critical Path
Figure 3.3 Management’s perceptions of what the company needs represent the critical path of the CAD manager. User wants are represented as a block in parallel with company needs.You can work to accommodate user wants as much as possible, but never to the detriment of meeting critical path needs.
If you can find a common denominator by which facilitating CAD users’ wants and needs meets a management need or objective, then you’ve won on both counts. Communicate this with your management. Make this an ongoing dialogue, and discuss
43 ■ MEETING COMPANY NEEDS—NOT USER WANTS
about what the average CAD user in their company wants. They’re not thinking about the latest technology tool that may make your job easier or about the latest server that may make the network run faster. Instead, they’re thinking about global business objectives like how to sell more work, how to get more productivity per person, and other issues. They’re thinking on a higher business plane than we typically are as CAD managers. What’s important isn’t whether you agree or disagree with that concept but rather that you accept it, deal with it, and manage your relationship with management accordingly. You need to determine management’s expectations for you. In Chapter 1, I talked about management’s perspective. I outlined the idea of managerial principles overriding and sometimes being at odds with what CAD users want. If there are occasions when user needs and user wants come in direct conflict with management needs or wants, we all know that management has to win. The reason is simple: Management funds your budget requests, and they’re the only people who can enable you and empower you to do your job. Therefore, as CAD manager, you need to place an emphasis on understanding management’s needs and put those company needs above everything else. I would argue that a truly effective CAD manager does the following:
16531c03.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 44
it as frequently as you can. The key component is that through your reports and conversations with your management staff, you demonstrate to them continually that you understand your job, which is to facilitate the overall productivity and functionality of your company, and that this is the foremost goal in your mind. If you communicate that on a regular basis, you’ll establish a much better relationship with senior management and be seen as a more competent, task-oriented manager.
Explaining Standards to Management
CHAPTER
3:
MANAGING YOUR MANAGEMENT ■
44
The conversation starts innocently enough: Management asks you to explain why you need CAD standards. To explain a little about what CAD standards are, you launch into a discussion that includes any number of technical criteria for CAD standards such as layers, colors, fonts, dimensional standards, sheet set-ups, and so on. In reality, management wants to know not so much what CAD standards are but why they’re necessary. What good are CAD standards for the company? Why should you expend effort to manage CAD standards? Why should you worry about whether CAD users are utilizing CAD standards? These are all good questions from an upper-management standpoint. The problem typically is that CAD managers are stuck in the technical while upper management is thinking about process. This fundamental breakdown in communication generates problems for the CAD manager. To remedy this situation, I recommend explaining to management exactly why CAD standards make sense. Here are some tips for communicating the importance of standards to management: Having standards allows the company to stay consistent When work is consistent, outcomes become more predictable, less fraught with error, and easier to manage. When procedures are consistent, they can be automated And when procedures are automated via programming or customization, they become faster and smoother, the company gets more work done with the same number of people, error rates drop, and productivity generally goes up. This is the point in the discussion at which you should have your management’s full attention. This is where you get on their radar screen and keep going. Once procedures are automated, you can revisit the automation to fine-tune and improve CAD processes even more. Here’s an example: After automating the creation of correct layers, colors, linetypes, and fonts, you could expand your automation to set up drawing sheets or plotting assistance, because these functions depend on having correct layers and colors in the first place. Once you’ve automated standard processes and procedures, you’ll realize the full productivity benefit of getting more work done with the same number of people, thus achieving lower unit costs for every job you do. When you’ve made this point,
16531c03.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 45
management should fully understand what standards mean to the company: more productivity. They mean getting more done with the same number of people—and getting more done with no more staff will always be popular with management.
45
As I’ve tried to emphasize throughout this book, by approaching management from a more process-driven viewpoint, by talking less about technical details and more about productivity, you’ll get management’s attention. They, in turn, will give you the authority to make the changes in CAD standards that you need, because they understand the benefit of doing so. It’s also sometimes useful to have a discussion with management and explain some of the problems and inconsistencies that have popped up because you haven’t had CAD standards. These may include jobs that required excessive CAD hours because plotting wasn’t automated, or contract suppliers or vendors that provided CAD in a
■ EXPLAINING STANDARDS TO MANAGEMENT
Figure 3.4 Think of CAD standards as a transmission that allows the efficient flow of CAD energy. Like the gears pictured here, each portion of the CAD standards environment (consistency, automation, and better processes) links to those before it and after it to achieve optimal productivity.
16531c03.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 46
nonstandard format, and so on. I find it particularly useful to have a positive conversation with management about the benefits of standardization and then contrast that positive conversation with negative examples in which productivity or money was lost due to of lack of standards. This gives management a view of both sides of CAD standards and ensures that you’re on the same managerial page.
Managing Management’s Expectations
CHAPTER
3:
MANAGING YOUR MANAGEMENT ■
46
As I discussed in Chapter 1, management has a perception of what you do on a daily basis. Management’s expectations of you are largely colored by how difficult they perceive your job to be. If they believe you have a relatively small number of tasks on your plate, they’re going to think your job is easy, and they’re going to expect you to do more. On the other hand, if they understand the complexities of what you’re trying to accomplish—if, as I outlined in Chapter 1, you articulate the real tasks associated with each perceived task in your job—then management will come to understand what a multifaceted and complex job CAD management is and will have more realistic expectations. A big part of dealing with management is showing them what’s involved and what you have to do every day. By doing this, you manage their expectations. And by managing their expectations, you ensure that you’re both on the same page. You won’t feel overworked, and management won’t feel like you’re under-performing. This is why I continue to emphasize that you should develop a task list, as detailed in Chapter 1, and re-evaluate that task list on an ongoing basis. Don’t be afraid to adjust the real tasks associated with your job on a quarterly basis, or as often as needed. Be sure you go back and communicate the changes to your management staff. Telling them what you’re doing, what you’re up against, and what you have to deal with daily is the only way to ensure that management’s expectations of you are realistic. Remember to focus on tasks and goals rather than technical minutia so that you get your message across clearly. The burden of communication is on you, the CAD manager. By communicating effectively, you’ll set management’s expectations realistically. If you don’t tell them, they can’t know, can they?
Reporting to Your Management Communicating with your supervisor isn’t easy. Any number of barriers to good communication exist, including scheduling conflicts and travel or other obligations that take you out of the office, to name a few. But regular communication—ideally in person—is crucial, and a good CAD manager must establish a reporting process and stick with it. After all, senior managers won’t know what you’re doing unless you tell them.
16531c03.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 47
47
Here are some reporting techniques I’ve found very valuable over the years, many of which I still follow today: Create a weekly report This weekly report is a quick read, typically no more than one page in a word-processing document or e-mail message. This report allows you to accomplish two things. First, you delineate what you’ve done in the past week (this reporting interval) so that management knows what you’ve achieved. Second, you state what you hope to achieve in the following week (your next reporting interval) so that management has a look ahead at what you’ll be working on. The following week, you build on the first report to relay what you accomplished, and you project one more week into the future. As you get going, you prepare a nice checklist for yourself so you stay on task. By looking at what you hope to accomplish next week, you’ll automatically be more focused on working on the right tasks. That way, you can report in your next communication to management that you achieved most of your objectives. What’s important here is that you’re providing a quick status update, easy to read, in an executive summary format, so your boss can see what you’re doing within three to four minutes and tell whether you’re on track. This opens all sorts of communications. Of course, if you can have a personal conversation with your management to follow up this report, that’s optimal. But if you can’t, having the information in writing ensures that management gets the message.
■ REPORTING TO YOUR MANAGEMENT
Figure 3.5 Reporting your progress represents the final step of perception management because it’s the only formal communication in the process.Without efficient reporting, management doesn’t know what a great job you’re doing for them.
16531c03.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 48
Follow-up your weekly report with brief conversations These don’t have to be rigid scheduled or long-term meetings with management. They can be quick conversations at the coffee pot, on the way out to the car at lunch, or whenever you have a chance to spend three or four minutes with your manager. I find this method of communication to be more effective than formal meetings. By being conversational, you’ll tend to be more natural, you’ll focus on how you’re doing and what you’ve worked on, and you’ll be able to convey a sense of calm and accomplishment rather than feeling you’re on guard while being cross-examined in a formal meeting. Remember, the key is communication. At these quick meetings that follow your written report, management will have in mind the questions they want to ask you, and you’ll have ready answers. This means your communication will be effective and your management will appreciate how on-task, focused, and respectful of their time you’re being. I really believe this method of reporting and communicating with your management is more effective than any other approach.
CHAPTER
3:
MANAGING YOUR MANAGEMENT ■
48
Why Reporting Matters so Much To close this topic, I’ll point out that communication with management serves two primary functions. The first is to make sure that management understands what you’re doing and how you’re working to meet your job objectives. That’s great. But the second thing you’re doing is communicating the value of CAD management. By reporting, you show your senior managers that you’re on top of the details, that you understand how to apply technology to their specific work environment, and that you’re providing a unique value to the company. Remember, management doesn’t know how to manage CAD. That’s why they hired you. You’re the only one who can articulate what value you add to the organization. When you report to your management teams, you convey what you’ve accomplished, but you also sell yourself and your value. If you don’t toot your own horn a little, nobody will.
Avoiding the Technology vs. Management Trap via Clear Communication The worst scenario I see CAD managers getting into is fixating on technical details, not communicating with their management staff, and therefore not addressing management’s expectations. This is why I’ve gone out of my way in this chapter to explain to you how to manage your management staff’s expectations and how to report to them. When you talk to senior managers, remember that you understand far more of the technical details than they do, so the burden is on you to de-emphasize the technicality of your message. Use the following communication techniques to keep the conversation on track:
16531c03.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 49
Make it all easy to understand Format all your reporting and conversations with management in such a way that they understand what you’re trying to accomplish rather than how you’re doing so. Remember, it’s not important that management understand the technical details of everything you do. What is important is that they know what you’re trying to accomplish and why. Keep the communication channels open When you can talk to management, it’s a lot easier to resolve problems, because you can work through things conversationally. If you communicate clearly and often, management won’t be surprised by unexpected issues and can therefore work with you casually rather than in crisis mode. Don’t be afraid to ask for advice If you have an open dialogue with management, it’s easy to ask for advice if you’re ever puzzled by an issue. And because you’ve already communicated so much information to management, you never look stupid asking a defining question. My experience has been that no management staff expects you to know everything, and most management staffs want you to succeed. If you find yourself needing help to balance technical and managerial aspects of a challenge you face—ask!
When the CAD manager communicates with management in a goal-oriented, nontechno-babble manner, both sides benefit. When management and the CAD manager are in sync, there are fewer misconceptions on both sides. If you strive to achieve a balance between the technical and managerial aspects of your CAD management job, you’ll find that technology and management can coexist nicely. You may enjoy it once you get the hang of it.
■ AVOIDING THE TECHNOLOGY VS. MANAGEMENT TRAP VIA CLEAR COMMUNICATION
It’s All About Balance
49
16531c03.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 50
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 51
Managing Standards There’s an old story that says, when the second person in town bought a car, that’s when the town figured out that they needed a stoplight. There’s an analogous situation in CAD that has to do with CAD standards: You can’t allow all your users to sit down and draw however they’d like to, using whatever CAD system they’d like guides. If you let everyone proceed in the direction they wanted to, you’d have anarchy, and your information would never be in any sort of standard format. Of course, companies want to manage consistent information, and they want
4
to know that they can interchange or share data among different offices or with vendors or clients with some degree of certainty that the information can be shared efficiently. This is where CAD standards come in.
■ M A N A G I N G S TA N D A R D S
to, without any sort of operational standards or
51
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 52
Over the years, CAD standards have become more and more the domain of the CAD manager. It’s common now for the CAD manager to author CAD standards, document them in written or electronic form, educate users in the proper use of the standards, and, at the end of the process, verify that standards were followed. Sometimes CAD managers even have to resort to formal enforcement procedures to make sure CAD standards are being followed. Every CAD manager should expect to deal with CAD standards at some point in their career. Dealing with CAD standards effectively requires a multipronged approach. Think about how CAD standards will be formulated, how they’ll work within your environment, how to enforce them, and how to make them as easy as possible to use for all your users. If a standard is easy to follow, chances are people will follow it. In this chapter, we’ll examine various viewpoints on the CAD standards issue and see how you can deal with standards most effectively in a way that makes the most sense for users and for you.
Formulating and Writing Standards Many CAD managers find themselves in the position of being responsible for authoring and creating CAD standards, but they receive little guidance about how to do that. To tackle the job of writing CAD standards, focus on what good CAD standards are and how to communicate information most effectively, as opposed to following an equation.
CHAPTER
4:
M A N A G I N G S TA N D A R D S ■
52
Figure 4.1 To avoid user confusion and wasted effort, standards are required.Therefore, crafting a solid CAD standard document becomes a key CAD management task.
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 53
Here are some over-arching objectives to keep in mind while putting together a CAD standards document: Manage what needs to be managed As an example, if it’s important that your users draw on certain layers or use certain colors or text fonts or certain dimensional standards, those standards should be spelled out. On the other hand, if it doesn’t matter what sort of toolbars or graphical arrangement the operators use on their CAD desktop, then don’t control that. CAD standards should control only how the CAD file is formatted or stored. Don’t waste time trying to control parameters that can’t be standardized.
Brevity is the soul of wit Shakespeare said that, and he was right. The CAD standard that is best read, best comprehended, and best followed by users is the CAD standard that is the shortest. Again, by controlling only the parameters that need to be controlled, you’ll wind up with a succinct, easy-to-read CAD standard. That guarantees more people will read it and follow it. Even in cases where you use an existing CAD standard as your starting point, there’s no reason you can’t prune it to the minimum text needed. Write for the user CAD standards should be written at the appropriate level of technical expertise for the person using the standard. For example, if a CAD standard is targeted at someone using 2D AutoCAD, then you should restrict the standard to addressing commands that are familiar to that level of AutoCAD operator. By targeting the standard at the expertise level of the person who will use it, you’ll guarantee the best possible accepted comprehension of the standard and therefore the best possible chance that it will be followed. Use the three bears approach: Not too technical, not too simple; aim for the middle where it’s just right. Don’t tell them—show them Consider using CAD-specific tools to make standards utilization and enforcement easier. For example, don’t tell users what AutoCAD layers to draw on and how to set up their colors. And don’t tell MicroStation users what levels and line weights they should use. Set up the standards in template files or seed files that users can load automatically so layers, colors, levels, or line weights are correct in the first place. Remember: If it’s easier to be standard than to be nonstandard, people will follow the standard. Make easy-to-use CAD tools that are familiar to people a key component of your standards plan.
53 ■ F O R M U L AT I N G A N D W R I T I N G S TA N D A R D S
Use existing CAD standards as a starting point In a later section, I’ll discuss CAD standards offered by organizations such as the American Institute of Architects and the U.S. National CAD Standard. Although these major CAD standards may be overinvolved or exercise more control than you need in your specific environment, they can serve as a good starting point. The main point to recognize is that you don’t need to reinvent the wheel. Look for industry examples that you can piggyback on for CAD standards in your organization.
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 54
Tell users why standards matter Rather than making CAD standards a dictatorial process wherein users are commanded to follow a standard that they don’t understand, explain where the standard came from and why it matters. As an example, rather than saying, “Draw on this layer with this color,” spell out to the user that that standard makes it easier to transfer information into a customer’s business system to be compatible with their needs. Explain that a key reason why your company has obtained the contract to work on this project is because these standards will be followed. If you put users in a situation where they become part of the team and understand why standards matter for the execution of the job, they’re far more likely to follow the standards. It’s simple psychology: Tell me why I need to do something, and I’m much more likely to follow your instruction. Use this simple psychological technique, and watch as your standards implementation goes more smoothly and the amount of standards deviation you observe dwindles.
CHAPTER
4:
M A N A G I N G S TA N D A R D S ■
54
Make it official CAD standards must be documented in writing and approved by a managerial authority higher than you. Remember that for a standard to be a standard, it must be enforceable. Before it can be enforceable, it needs to be an official document signed by those in charge. Until the document is official, it’s only a suggestion. When you get it written down and signed, it becomes a standard—don’t skip this step.
Existing Standards: AIA, U.S. National CAD Standard, and Others As CAD software has become more prevalent in the past 20 years, the need for standards has been recognized throughout various segments of the industry. Whether it’s an architectural, a mechanical, or a civil engineering environment, there is a need for CAD standards. And as this need has been met, more and more standards have evolved. This evolution of standards has in turn brought about a need for a unified CAD standard that can address all needs. To address this need, some organizations have devised their own CAD standards. The American Institute of Architects (AIA), for example, has implemented its AIA CAD standard, with the idea that all architects involved in any number of subdisciplines in the architecture, engineering, and construction fields can use these CAD standards. If everybody in the field employed these CAD standards, they would save time and ensure consistency in the building trades. More recently, the U.S. National CAD Standard (NCS) has come into prominence as it attempts the same sort of overarching standardization that everyone could use to save time and money.
Note: Worth noting is the relative lack of mechanical CAD standards. As 3D-capable mechanical CAD has become more advanced, typically controlled parameters like layers, part numbers, and filenames are more often controlled by the software applications, leaving far less for the user to control and standardize.
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 55
The problem with this effort to standardize has been, and continues to be, that these super CAD standards are so large and complex in their reach and scope that small companies may have difficulty using them. Therefore, I recommend that you think of these CAD standards as a starting point: a place to begin the discussion. Or, if you’re having conversations with suppliers or customers and the topic of formulating a CAD standard comes up, you may find their industry standards useful in devising your own. The sidebar “Industry CAD Standards” provides web resources along with costs and document summary guidelines for the available national CAD standards. You may want to take some time to look these up, investigate them, or even download them to see what style of documentation they use. Even if you never use these CAD standards, you can learn a lot from how they’re written, targeted, and focused, and you can use their sample language as a mechanism to start your own CAD standards. On the other hand, if your projects are sufficiently large and complex, you may be able to utilize these standards out of the box. If so, that’s great.
U.S. National CAD Standard (www.nationalcadstandard.org).The NCS is the only comprehensive U.S. CAD standard for the design, construction, and facility management industries. The program’s goal is broad voluntary adoption of the NCS by the building design, construction, and operation sectors, thereby establishing a common language for the building design and documentation process. Use of NCS eliminates the overhead costs that organizations now incur to maintain proprietary office standards, train new staff, and coordinate implementation among design team members.The 2D standard plays a crucial role in easing the transition to new building information modeling (BIM) software systems and the 3D object–based standards represented by the Industry Foundation Classes (IFC), developed by the International Association for Interoperability (IAI). American Institute of Architects (www.aia.org).The AIA publishes a software package called Contract Documents, a Microsoft Word–based software platform that offers a great starting point for preparing contract documents. Because contracts are notoriously difficult to develop (and require legal oversight), using the Contract Documents can assist CAD managers in architecture, engineering, and construction (AEC) industries immensely.You can access a wealth of information on the AIA web site using the site’s search engine. For example, by searching on “CAD layering standards”, you can find several resources that explain sections of the NCS and how it can be applied in AEC environments.
■ E X I S T I N G S TA N D A R D S : A I A , U . S . N AT I O N A L C A D S TA N D A R D , A N D O T H E R S
Industry CAD Standards
55
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 56
Most CAD managers create a hybrid CAD standard by borrowing from existing CAD standards as a starting point, or template, and then adjusting them to cover only the topics that are necessary. There’s no perfect way to write a CAD standard, and there’s no such thing as the absolute standard CAD standard. However, by using industry norms, you’re more likely to craft a good standard, make few mistakes, and not overlook anything. Now that you have an idea of what CAD standards are available, it’s time to start writing standards to manage common tasks in your environment.
Information Exchange
Your Company (or one department)
Communication Barrier
2D CAD Work (AutoCAD 2007)
Other Company (or department)
2D CAD Work (MicroStation v8)
CHAPTER
4:
M A N A G I N G S TA N D A R D S ■
56
It’s worth pointing out that the entire reason to have a CAD standard is to allow information to flow better from one person to another or, in the case of companies, from one department to another, or from a customer to a vendor, and so on. The CAD standard facilitates proper communication in a particular digital format: CAD files. Just as you’d want all parties in a conversation to speak the same common language, the CAD standard facilitates a consistent CAD language.
DWG version 2005 based standard
Figure 4.2 Like a common second language connects those who would otherwise be noncommunicative, CAD standards facilitate communication between companies that use differing CAD packages or versions.
You can think of CAD standards as a way to allow information to move from point A to point B with the least possible chance for misinterpretation and the least possible need for having to rework or revisit those files. By making information flow smoothly and effortlessly, all sorts of efficiencies become possible. Those that come to mind immediately are as follows: Automation When processes are standardized, they become more consistent; therefore, you can apply programmatic type standards to them. For example, if you wanted to create an automated routine that would rename layers, it would be a lot easier to do that if all drawings were set up with properly named layers in the first place.
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 57
Economy of effort and lower unit cost per project When tasks become more standardized, and you can automate them to a greater extent or apply programmatic logic to them, then it stands to reason that the same number of people can get more work done than before, or the same project can be accomplished in fewer hours. Either way, the average cost per project is lower as standards are more uniformly enforced and automation is employed. As you start to think about CAD standards as a cost-lowering, efficiencyimproving, information exchange tool rather than a technical document to be maintained, you’ll begin to realize the true power of standardization. Focus on making your CAD standards facilitate seamless movement of data, and you’ll automatically start to reap the benefits of productive CAD standards.
Vendor Control via Standards
Formal contracts Your vendors are contractually bound to provide CAD services to you. Therefore, the burden is on them to meet your needs, but only to the extent that you specify in contract documents. Realize that the burden is on you completely to make sure the vendors have all the information they need to perform the work for you. Also realize that unless you spell out the CAD standards to be followed in written contract form, you have no legal recourse should the vendor not perform. Verification When you receive CAD work from a vendor, it’s your responsibility to make sure that work can be audited and that it complies with standards. Providing a vendor with your standard means nothing unless you can verify that work was completed to that standard. Remedy If a vendor provides you with work that is verifiably not to standard, the burden of communicating this fact to that vendor and indicating what needs to be fixed is also yours. As you can see, when you’re working with vendors, the standard must be specific about how the vendor must perform for you. There must be no questions or gaps. Remember that when you have a vendor working for you, it’s a legal or contracted process. Therefore, if your standard is insufficient or ambiguous in any way, you won’t be able to enforce that standard. The burden falls on you to be thorough and to create standards that control all behaviors.
57 ■ V E N D O R C O N T R O L V I A S TA N D A R D S
Many CAD managers work for companies that hire external vendors to provide services to them. In many cases, those vendors provide CAD files as a deliverable commodity in conjunction with the services they provide. Therefore, when dealing with vendor organizations, it’s sometimes necessary to subject the vendor to control via CAD standards. When you’re using CAD standards to control project deliverables from vendors, it pays to recognize what makes working with vendors different from working with your own in-house personnel. Here are some differences:
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 58
Your Company
File Submittal Process
CAD Work (any platform)
Vendor Company
CAD Work (any platform)
Your Specific CAD Standard
Figure 4.3 Managing vendors who submit CAD information to you using your standards removes all variables from the information-submission process and provides a controlled method to resolve problems using a feedback loop analogy.
What makes a vendor CAD standard different from a standard that’s used inside your company? Here are several important factors:
CHAPTER
4:
M A N A G I N G S TA N D A R D S ■
58
Formality/Tone Whereas an in-house CAD standard strives to convey proper work procedures, it’s typically more loosely written and assumes that everyone on the inhouse team is working for the good of the company. When you’re writing standards for external vendors, you can’t assume motivation or diligence, so everything must be specified much more tightly. As you construct vendor standards, keep this heightened degree of formality in mind, and always ask yourself, “Am I controlling the vendor tightly enough to guarantee a good working experience?” Versions and method of delivery must be specified It’s not enough to say what CAD package the vendor should use; you must also specify the format, software versions, and delivery media. Will work be submitted on CD or DVD? Will it be e-mailed? Will it be delivered in a compressed format? Will it be sent to an FTP site or a web site of your choosing? For AutoCAD, will DWG files be provided in a specific version format? For SolidWorks, will assemblies include all parts and drawing files in their native directory structure? Keep asking yourself these types of detailed questions, and realize that your in-house staff probably already knows the answers but your vendors don’t. It always seems to be the question you didn’t ask that causes problems later, so make sure to sweat the details!
Note:
Have a trusted power user review your vendor standards and note anything they find ambiguous; then, revise accordingly.
Hard copy Will the vendor have to provide hard-copy plots of data to you as well as electronic files? If so, make sure this detail appears in your standards. Alternate file formats Will the vendor also supply you with non-native CAD formats such as DWF, Adobe PDF, or others? If so, which version?
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 59
Conflict resolution If a vendor sees something in the CAD standard that they believe to be wrong or missing, or if they have a question, you need to have a mechanism set up within the CAD standard for resolving that issue. Be sure you include contact names, phone numbers, and e-mail addresses for anyone on the project management team who must make decisions about CAD standards. Allowable deviation In case the vendor encounters a situation in which the CAD standard can’t be met for some technical reason—usually because of an oversight on someone’s part—they need a mechanism to alert you about the problem. As an example, perhaps a vendor has a network security limitation that won’t allow them to submit files via File Transfer Protocol (FTP), thus making submittals on CDs a permissible deviation. Again, provide all the contact information necessary to bring the situation to your attention, and specify a process by which a written notification from the vendor can be sent.
At the end of a job, when the vendor submits CAD work to you, it’s your responsibility to audit the work to make sure it complies with standards. And should you find anything that’s not to standard, you must have a mechanism for informing the vendor. I suggest that you employ a spot-audit process where you randomly pull a number of CAD files and audit them for proper standards compliance. In the event you receive from a vendor CAD files that don’t comply with your standards, there should be a notification process in your standards document that explains to vendors how you’ll notify them. Typically, a formal letter of transmittal, whether it’s delivered by e-mail or hard copy, alerts a vendor that you’ve found difficulties with their file submissions. You should attach enough detail to this letter so the vendor knows which files and which specific problems you’ve encountered and can tell what to fix. You should also inform the vendor how long they have to address this problem and the mechanism by which they can resubmit the work. Also include your contact information so the CAD person working on the vendor side knows exactly whom to contact to technically resolve the standards problems. If you follow the advice I’ve laid out, you’ll be able to adapt your in-house CAD standard with additional information so that it becomes a great vendor-control CAD standard document. And by controlling your vendors’ work products, you’ll be able to accept information from them without translations or extra labor to fix data problems, because you can now enforce the standard! Keep in mind that the burden is on you to properly control the vendor by crafting a comprehensive standard that gives them the information they need to do their job correctly.
59 ■ V E N D O R C O N T R O L V I A S TA N D A R D S
Auditing and Taking Control
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 60
Working to Client Standards When working to client standards, you’re in the opposite position of controlling a vendor, because you’re the vendor to your client. That is, you’re providing work to someone else’s standards. This is a common scenario in AEC or engineering environments where you’re providing goods and services to someone else and documenting those services via CAD drawings. In this case, you should expect to work to a client standard. The risk in this situation is ambiguous or nonexistent standards—a client that doesn’t give you the information you need to do your job. I recommend that you go back to the preceding section, “Vendor Control via Standards,” and look at it from the opposite standpoint. Will you have all the information you need about CAD data, formats, delivery mechanisms, delivery locations, software versions, and so on, to provide the customer with everything they want in the exact format they need? Your Company
File Submittal Process
CAD Work (any platform)
Client Company
CAD Work (any platform)
Client Specific CAD Standard
CHAPTER
4:
M A N A G I N G S TA N D A R D S ■
60
Figure 4.4 Like vendor standards, client standards control the parameters of submitting information, but from the opposite perspective.
To evaluate the standard the vendor has sent you, you can employ the following checks and balances: Thoroughness Does the standard seem thorough? Do you have the information you need? Do any questions come to mind immediately? If so, list them so you can communicate those questions later. Contact persons Do you have all the contact information you need? Do you know whom to contact for technical issues, project standard issues, and so on? Problem resolution Do you have a mechanism for alleviating any problems? Are procedures in place for deviating from standards or resolving ambiguous standards? Do you know exactly whom to contact?
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 61
Getting Started If you have any concerns after running through the client CAD standard, you should inform the contact person in a written format immediately. The key is to try to eliminate any problems, questions, or ambiguities before any CAD work starts moving back and forth. If it seems that the standard you’re working to is complete and you don’t have any questions, take the following preventative actions to make sure things go well later when you submit CAD data: Benchmark Take the time to convert some CAD work to your client’s CAD standard and submit it for a pre-audit check. By taking this step, you perform a dress rehearsal for job closeout. I’ve found that sending CAD data to clients early in the process exposes any minor problems and makes the client feel comfortable that they’ll be in good hands later. The benchmarking phase is a great customer relationship management tool as well as a technical proving ground,
Document If you find and fix a technical glitch, make sure to document the discussion and copy your project staff. If the issue comes up later, you’ll have everything you need to back yourself up and avoid costly rework or litigation. Always remember that if you don’t write it down, it didn’t happen! Your Company (or one department)
Communication Barrier
2D CAD Work (AutoCAD 2007)
Other Company (or department)
2D CAD Work (MicroStation v8)
DWG version 2005 based standard
Benchmarking verifies that standards work and information flows
Figure 4.5 Benchmarking CAD standards provides assurance that the standards will work.Think of benchmarking as a dress rehearsal for a real project.
61 ■ W O R K I N G T O C L I E N T S TA N D A R D S
Fix If a technical glitch is exposed during benchmarking, move to fix the issue using the contact personnel spelled out in the client’s standard. As you move to fix the issue, remember that small technical issues typically aren’t anyone’s fault but are caused by oversights that are usually easy to fix. Working with the client constructively during this phase is key to managing the relationship and fixing the problem with minimal hassle and friction.
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 62
Take some time to be proactive. Make sure you can move data to and from your vendor and that both of you are happy with the vendor standard that’s controlling the project. If you do this, you should be able to move forward in a relatively painless manner with confidence that you’ll be able to meet their needs and avoid problems at the end of the job.
Outsourcing Control
CHAPTER
4:
M A N A G I N G S TA N D A R D S ■
62
With outsourcing, as with vendors, you receive CAD drawings from a completely external source. What makes outsourcing different from a traditional vendor relationship is that outsourcing implies you’re getting rid of a job and will exercise minimal, if any, control over how the work process is performed. If you don’t have a working relationship with the outsourcing vendor, and you’re not communicating on a regular basis, having a bullet-proof CAD standard becomes absolutely crucial. Also realize that, from a contracting standpoint, the outsourcing provider only has to supply you with what you’ve specified. Just as with a vendor control standard, the work you’ll receive can be only as good as the standard you provide. An additional wrinkle in the outsourcing picture is that outsourcing firms frequently aren’t located in your country. Common scenarios have countries in North America and westernized Europe outsourcing to far-eastern countries like India and China. In this case, outsourcing control becomes not just a CAD issue but a linguistic issue as well. It’s imperative that outsourcing control standards be written in standard language and be easy to read, and that you make sure the outsourcing party absolutely understands the standard that you’ve provided. Following are some other checkpoints you should consider when entering into an outsourcing arrangement: Will software versions be a problem? Many outsourcing firms work with older or outdated software. If you’re working with a recent version of AutoCAD or MicroStation, you can’t assume that the outsourcing firm has that same version. Your CAD standard should specify exactly what version the outsourcing provider must use and the version of any CAD deliverables that it provides to you. Is your data secure? In many cases, outsourcing providers, being far away, must deliver their work via the Internet. Be aware of this restriction when crafting your outsourcing CAD standard. Also understand that this can affect your drawing-security mechanism. If you want your outsourcing provider to upload drawings to your FTP site, for example, you may want to have a specific FTP folder for that outsourcing provider and that no other data will be accessible to them when they use that FTP site.
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 63
Lack of recourse If an outsourcing provider resides outside your country, you may have no legal mechanisms for remedy should they violate your contract—but they may be able to sue you in your local courts and win! Therefore, you need to make sure your outsourcing-control contract provides a way to audit the work you’re receiving on a periodic basis. The most effective way I’ve found to control this situation is to have progress milestones. You should spell out exactly what should be accomplished at 20 percent of the task, 40 percent of the task, 60 percent of the task, and so on. That way, you’ll have milestones along the way where the job can be stopped if any outsourcing-control problems are exposed. It’s crucial that you have this in your contract to avoid legal wrangling or arguments later. Be specific In all cases, make sure to specify your entire CAD-control process just as you would for any other vendor. Everything I’ve told you regarding outsourcing control is in addition to or beyond the normal vendor-control CAD standards that you should supply.
Your Company
File Submittal Process
CAD Work (any platform)
Vendor Company
CAD Work (any platform)
Your Specific CAD Standard
Your Legal Contract Docs
Figure 4.6 Outsourcing standards not only control the technical aspects of CAD information exchange but also form a legal foundation for the business relationship.
If you take these steps to control your outsourcing protocols, you should receive properly formatted CAD information that meets your timeline and information requirements. Controlling outsourcing can be tricky, so make sure that you’re thorough and that you check with all your project-management teams to be absolutely sure you haven’t missed anything.
63 ■ OUTSOURCING CONTROL
Make it legal Remember that an outsourcing agreement with another company, particularly one located outside your country, is a legal issue as much as a technical one. Have your legal staff and project-management staff go through the CAD standard control and outsourcing control documents that you propose to send to the outsourcing firm to see whether they will protect you if conflicts arise.
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 64
Standard Application Deployment Doesn’t it stand to reason that before you can achieve CAD standardization, you must have a standard CAD installation? This question seems to answer itself, but I’m constantly amazed at how many CAD managers allow users to install CAD tools however they want. By insisting on a standards-compliant installation, you’ll create order and prevent chaos while saving time on support—particularly on remotely located machines that you can’t access easily. To standardize your application deployments, always aim for a single point of control and consistency. Taking the following steps will help you get a handle on your applications:
CHAPTER
4:
M A N A G I N G S TA N D A R D S ■
64
Know your environment To standardize CAD machines from disparate locations, you must understand the network environment you’re operating in. At minimum, you must understand the connection speed and validation mechanisms by which your remote users log in to the network. Connection speeds can range from dedicated T1 lines to DSL to dial-up modems, whereas log-in validations are controlled by your network administrators. If you aren’t sure what the connection speeds are for your company, ask your network administrator. The connection-speed parameter will be important later in our discussion as we talk about remote loading of files. Generally, T1 or DSL connection speeds should be adequate for wide-area CAD management, but dial-up modems are typically too slow. Deploy a common CAD drive No matter what connection speed your company has, you should set up a standard CAD drive for all network users. This CAD drive will serve as a central location for all the standardized files from now on. Get your network administrator involved early in the creation of this drive, because it can sometimes take a while to get everything debugged. Once the drive is set up, create folders on the drive that contain support files for your various CAD applications. When all the files are in place, set (or ask your network administrator to set) the folders with READ level control for all CAD users and FULL CONTROL for you. This permission scheme gives you complete control over all files. Control your key files Now that your CAD users can connect to the standard CAD drive, you can place your standard files into folders for optimal organization. The key files you should control for any CAD application include custom programming files, device support drivers, plotting configurations, template files, CAD standards, and so on.
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 65
Put documentation on the network Assuming you have CAD standards documents or procedures, why not deploy them over the network as well? If you use universal digital formats like Adobe PDF, users can find files on their own while you keep files secure. This approach means you don’t have to worry about who’s working to what standards manual, because the official standard is always on the system. If users must use a printed copy, they can print it themselves. Now that your applications are installed in a consistent way and all your files are deployed from a consistent network location, you have a basis for driving standards via your software. For example, you can now update standard template files by updating a single network folder; documents can be updated in a single folder, and branch offices can be synchronized as easily as a computer on a desk next to you.
Standard Network Environment (Single Point of Control) CAD Workstation
CAD Workstation
CAD Workstation
CAD Workstation
Figure 4.7 Standardizing CAD applications forms the basis for consistent work practices and eases support hassles because all users can be supported from a single point of control.
Perhaps more important than achieving technical control is the fact that standard application deployment sets the tone for standards in general. Want to get users to start thinking more about standards and how to work to them? Standardize their software, and watch what happens.
Managing the Multi-CAD Office As more companies move toward 3D design software, yet still have to support common 2D CAD, the phenomenon of the “multi-CAD office” has become more common. My CAD-manager surveys over the last five years have shown these 2D/3D multi-CAD environments to now be the norm. It seems the question isn’t whether you’ll have to manage multiple CAD programs, but how best to do so. What role will standards play in this management paradigm, and how should you adapt your standards approach?
■ M A N A G I N G T H E M U LT I - C A D O F F I C E
Standards Invoked from Server
65
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 66
I’d first like to point out that you must accept some fundamental realities about the multi-CAD office: It’s about time Most companies don’t have time to migrate all staff to 3D CAD all at once. Lack of time is the number-one reason for the multi-CAD office, according to my CAD-manager surveys over the years. Switching users over to new CAD systems takes time for training, support, and ramp-up to full productivity. A switch doesn’t happen immediately, but over time. Again, the multi-CAD office just happens, due to natural factors. It’s economic Delaying the cost of a full 3D CAD implementation is the second most common factor responsible for the multi-CAD office. Accept the limitations It’s interesting to note that few companies chose the multi-CAD office, so you can be forgiven for not wanting to manage one. However, accept your fate, and realize that you’ll be managing a multi-CAD office. Accepting the multi-CAD reality means you’ll spend more time managing the scenario and less time fighting it.
CHAPTER
4:
M A N A G I N G S TA N D A R D S ■
66
Processes Will Change; React Accordingly Managing CAD tools is all about meeting business objectives and getting the job done. Therefore, mapping out the tasks you need to accomplish and considering which CAD tools will best help you to do so is the first step in organizing the multi-CAD office. Management wants you to get the job done and doesn’t care which tool accomplishes which task as long as it happens quickly, seamlessly, and profitably. However, users care about the CAD tools they use and how those tools impact their day-to-day lives. Balancing the users’ CAD needs with the company’s business needs is the trickiest part of dealing with the multi-CAD office. To accomplish this balancing act, you must analyze your existing needs and processes from both managerial and user perspectives. Only after mapping out needs and processes can you begin to know which tool is correct for each purpose and how to manage those tools effectively. Here are a few questions you should ask yourself to get a handle on what processes you perform daily and what software tool is best for each task: For what processes should you use 2D? You may use 2D to handle routine tasks like drafting or DWG-based collaboration. You may also find it more logical to keep 2D legacy projects in 2D to avoid the cost of re-creating models in 3D. The key is to determine where 2D should be used so you can concentrate your 3D resources in new areas/ projects where they can pay you back rather than re-creating models that already exist in 2D. For what processes should you use 3D? 3D design tools will assume a high-profile design role within your company, so make sure to use your 3D resources in the places they can give you the best possible payback. The question isn’t where you can use 3D but where you can best use 3D. Take into account parameters like user training time, software and hardware costs, and so on when making your decision.
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 67
Where does 3D leave off and 2D kick in? Once you’ve decided where 2D and 3D tools can be most optimally used, you must tackle the topic of interfacing them. Ask yourself questions like these: How can I get 2D output for my 3D system? How can my 3D systems accept 2D input? What will be the overhead in accomplishing these tasks? Depending on what you find out, you may want to alter your perceptions of where 2D and 3D tools fit best in your company. The 2D-versus-3D thought process is an iterative one that changes as projects, staff, and comfort with 3D systems change. It pays to rethink your 2D-versus-3D interface point often.
What about visualization tools? When 3D design packages take hold, it’s inevitable that advanced visualization will follow. Advanced visualization may comprise additional file types like animations, walk-throughs, flyovers, or even rendered still images. It logically follows that the CAD manager will assume control of these types of graphic software products because they work in conjunction with CAD tools. What will your game plan be for managing these additional software tools? 2D CAD Users
3D CAD Users
CAD Workstation
CAD Workstation
2D and 3D Standards Invoked from Server CAD Workstation
CAD Workstation
Figure 4.8 By standardizing which tasks will be performed on which CAD system in the multi-CAD office, you can minimize translation problems and achieve maximum advantage from all CAD applications.
67 ■ M A N A G I N G T H E M U LT I - C A D O F F I C E
What are your external interface points? Do you work in an environment where you have to provide computer files to external vendors, or do you work as a vendor for clients? If so, you have to understand where your points of CAD data exchange will be and define what computer formats will be needed to support them. You may find that some information is best exchanged in 2D, whereas other types are easy to transfer in 3D file formats based on the software your external vendors/customers use. Once you understand these data-exchange points, you may need to reconsider your internal 2D and 3D processes yet again. It makes no sense to use 2D/3D tools in a way that makes it difficult to do business with partners outside your company.
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 68
Documenting What You’ve Found As you outline your processes and make decisions about 2D and 3D tools, it’s critical that you write down what you learn and change your standards accordingly. I think you’ll find that your CAD standards will need to be rewritten—and as CAD manager, that responsibility will fall to you. I recommend that you combine your existing CAD standards with some of your new multi-CAD standards findings, like optimal usage of 2D or 3D for a given process, 2D/3D interface points, and visualization tool file types. As you do so, keep these ideas in mind: Standards should support needs Your new CAD standards should support the new 2D/3D processes and software tools you’ve discussed with your power-user panel. Now isn’t the time to create new standards or complexities; write the minimal standards required to support your needs.
CHAPTER
4:
M A N A G I N G S TA N D A R D S ■
68
Standard should address 2D and 3D tools Be specific about which tasks will utilize what software tools, and make this part of your standards. It’s pointless to decide what software tool is best suited for a process if you don’t standardize the procedures for doing so. Control 3D just as you would 2D Just because you have 3D software tools doesn’t mean your users should be able to run roughshod over you and model things however they like. Write your 3D CAD standards the same way you would for 2D. Make it simple Although a multi-CAD environment may seem complicated, your standards should make it seem simple. Period. Keep management in the loop Senior management probably doesn’t need to read every paragraph of your multi-CAD standard, but they should see an executive-level summary of what you’re doing and why you’re doing it.
Standards Enforcement via Management In Chapter 3’s section “Explaining Standards to Management,” I talked about how to introduce the idea of standards to your management team. If you haven’t read this section of the book, do so now, because getting management to help you enforce CAD standards assumes that you’ve already introduced the idea of standards. The key concepts that management needs to understand are as follows: •
Standards make processes consistent.
•
Consistency allows automation.
•
Automation saves time.
•
Time is money.
•
Therefore, standards save money.
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 69
When management understands that your attempt to control the CAD workplace with standards can save them money, they’ll become interested in the concept! If you don’t believe me on this point, go to management, explain the previous bullet items, and watch how the tone of your conversation changes. Now you should connect the lack of standards compliance in your office to a loss of money. In essence, you need to give management sample cases where poor standards led to lost money. Here are a few examples you can use as a starting point: Printing/plotting problems Bring up an example of how plotting various sets of drawings took hours rather than minutes because layering, border, and color standards weren’t in place during the creation of drawing sets. Then, take a conservative estimate of wasted man-hours and multiply by your average hourly labor cost to get a valid cost number.
Lack of automation possibilities Which manual processes in your company (like plotting) could you automate if your CAD standards made all your drawings perfectly consistent? This is a powerful argument with upper management because automating mundane processes would allow their employees to do higher quality work (and more of it). Inconsistent look and feel Most CAD managers can produce several different sets of drawings done by different vendors, engineers, and drafters that don’t look anything alike. If you throw three drawings on a conference table in front of project/engineering management and confront them with this reality, they’ll see that standardization would produce a more uniform look for the company’s drawing product. Placing a dollar value on the look and feel issue is tough, but the psychology is a powerful motivator.
Getting Help with Enforcement Now that management understands how CAD standards can enhance productivity and how much money they’re losing because of the lack of standards, you need to ask for their help in enforcing CAD standards. By asking for help, you send the message to management that you’re trying to save them money but that you need their political clout to do so. When management can save money, they’ll be willing to back you up.
69 ■ S TA N D A R D S E N F O R C E M E N T V I A M A N A G E M E N T
Temporary labor problems How long does it take you to get a new temporary CAD technician up to speed on your drawing practices? How much is that costing in lost productivity for your company? Wouldn’t a firm set of CAD standards cut through all this uncertainty? You can demonstrate costs in this area by taking the number of training hours it takes to orient a new employee times the labor rate times the number of new employees in a given year. If you use temporary labor, you may be able to justify CAD standardization on this cost savings alone.
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 70
Your Company (or one department)
Communication Barrier
CAD Work (any platform)
Other Company (or department)
CAD Work (any platform)
Internal/External CAD Standard
Management Enforcement (Financially Motivated)
Figure 4.9 By placing management in the standards-enforcement loop and making their motivation financial, the CAD manager can focus on crafting optimal CAD standards instead of enforcement.
CHAPTER
4:
M A N A G I N G S TA N D A R D S ■
70
Ask for help by making the following arguments to management: Users will listen to management Because the CAD manager isn’t the boss of most users, enforcement is lacking. When management speaks out on standards, everyone has to listen. All you need is management clout The CAD manager will formulate the standards, teach the standards, and enforce the standards. All upper management has to do is throw their support behind the CAD manager—no extra work is imposed on upper management. It’s the cheapest way to gain savings By helping the CAD manager enforce standards, the company can gain a great return on investment in terms of savings. You should leave the discussion with full management support to implement standards and the assurance that swift support for enforcement will be forthcoming if you experience any problems. Put out a memo to all users explaining management’s involvement in enforcement, or have a meeting with management present if need be. The point is that everyone should now know the vigor with which standards will be enforced. Take these steps, and watch how user adherence to standards changes for the better!
Bringing It All Together Now that you’ve demonstrated how well standards can solve problems and make your company more efficient, don’t lose momentum. Talk with management and make sure they know the success you’re having with your new emphasis on standards. Don’t be bashful in advertising what you’ve been able to achieve, and be sure to point out any cost savings you’ve gained.
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 71
I’ve covered a tremendous amount of material in this chapter, but that’s because the topic of standards is complex. As with most things in CAD management, you need to balance the needs of your company against the realities of the environment you work in and do the best you can. By using the topics I’ve covered, you should be able to figure out what type of standards (vendor, client, multi-CAD) you need and then utilize the existing standards available to you (AIA, NCS) to craft a great first cut at a company standard. Moving forward, you should constantly re-evaluate your company’s needs and environment and revise your standards accordingly. CAD standards are never complete because processes and procedures around the office are always changing. Even if you totally standardize your company’s processes, sooner or later the software you use will change enough to trigger CAD standards changes. Stay on top of things, and never stop striving to build a better standard.
71 ■ BRINGING IT ALL TOGETHER
16531c04.qxd
3/19/07
1:41 PM
Page 72
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 73
Training, Hiring, and Managing Users Probably nothing else you do determines your success more than the way you manage and train your CAD users. Even though the users you manage and train may not always be your direct staff, you’re responsible for achieving the highest level also find, from time to time, that you need to
5
manage their behavior even if they’re not under your direct charge. For example, enforcing standards is one case in which you, the CAD manager, must lead, but not everybody who needs to follow those standards reports to you.
73 ■ TRAINING, HIRING, AND MANAGING USERS
of productivity possible for those users. You’ll
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 74
When you have the responsibility for enforcing standards or processes but not the authority to do so, managing user behavior can be problematic. Absent enforcement authority to manage user behavior, training becomes the next best way to make users understand why they should follow CAD standards.
CHAPTER
5:
TRAINING, HIRING, AND MANAGING USERS ■
74
Figure 5.1 The wide variety of users you’ll hire and manage means you need to constantly adjust and revise your training methods.
Throughout this chapter, I’ll pass along tips about how I’ve used different training methods and skills diagnostics to get my people to perform at a top level and, therefore, to ease the burden of managing them over time.
Training Methodology Today, CAD managers have a wide variety of training methods at their disposal. No single method is better than any other except one: the school of hard knocks, which we’ll discuss later. I’ll address the various types of training methods in common use and explain each one’s strengths and weaknesses. You can draw your own conclusions about which methods make more sense for you based on your operating environment and your users: Method 1: Traditional classroom training In many cases, traditional classroom training is a process in which you send your CAD users to an external training provider such as a CAD reseller. This method offers you the advantage of not having to perform the training yourself, thus preserving your time for other tasks. But it comes at a relatively high price.
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 75
Remember that whenever you send people to an external training class, the price includes not only what it costs to send them to the training but also the work time they miss. Because lost productivity is the number-one cost associated with external or classroom training, upper management may be skeptical about approving this method of training. Even when management does support classroom training, they will take keen note of user non-productivity while the class is run. Method 2: Leading your own in-house training As with the first method, when you conduct your own internal training classes, you have the traditional instructor–student paradigm in which you lead CAD users through a training program that you’ve prepared. What changes is that your specific knowledge of your users’ strengths and weaknesses should allow you to produce training that is highly targeted and minimally invasive with respect to the users’ time.
Particular examples of in-house training methods are lunch-and-learns. In these one-hour sessions, information is delivered during a lunch break, thus converting employee spare time (lunch) into a training activity and keeping overhead low. Most management teams prefer this short-burst in-house training because of its minimal impact on employee time. It does take time for you to prepare materials for a lunchand-learn, but the time regained by training users during their lunch keeps the overall cost to the company minimal. Method 3: Computer-based training Increasingly, this type of training is delivered via CD, DVD, or the Internet with some sort of interactive instruction. Students work through lessons at their own pace. These courses are usually indexed and divided into small chunks of learning, not exceeding 5 to 10 minutes each. They’re a good way for motivated users who will study on their own to learn material at a pace and on a timeline that makes sense for them, without any involvement from you. Because users can take computer-based training materials home with them, use them on lunch break, or use otherwise idle periods of time to train, little lost productivity time is associated with computer-based training. Even in cases where a user trains during otherwise billable time, there is no instructor cost because the CAD manager doesn’t have to run the training. The only downside to computer-based training materials is that you, the CAD manager, can’t see how well the user is learning or what they’re having trouble with. But given the many benefits, computer-based training delivers great benefits; and you can always check in with a user to see how they’re doing after the fact.
75 ■ TRAINING METHODOLOGY
While leading your in-house training, you’re responsible for producing training materials and for the instruction time. Users will lose productivity time just as they would if they were at an external classroom. The real advantage is that when you lead your own internal training, you can focus tightly on the topics that are being covered and produce that training in incremental chunks of time—not necessarily entire instructional days, which helps users stay on schedule with regular work activities.
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 76
Instructor Training
Large Groups
Single Users
Size
Small Groups
More Book/DVD
Tutor/Book Hybrid
More Instruction Books/DVDs
Learning Style Self Learner
CHAPTER
5:
TRAINING, HIRING, AND MANAGING USERS ■
76
Classroom Learner
Figure 5.2 Different training methods work best in varying environments. Here’s a representation of which methods work best versus the structure required and sizes of groups being trained.
Method 4: Traditional books and handout materials In this learning paradigm, the user is expected to pick up a book or custom-prepared handout and learn from it. My experience has shown that most users today are more receptive to computer-based training that allows them to watch the lesson, but some users learn well from written materials. Whether a user prefers books, handouts, or computer-based training is largely a matter of personal preference that you’ll need to observe to get an accurate gauge. However, written materials, whether you purchase them or produce them yourself, are a great adjunct to traditional classroom training. For example, if you run a lunch-and-learn on a specific topic, you should probably supplement that class with some sort of written material to reinforce your instruction. The important aspect of traditional printed materials is that the user can take them away from the training to reference as needed later. Even in cases where you don’t train users directly from written materials, you should still use them to cross-reference or reinforce other training.
Note:
Publish your training handouts in a secure digital form like Adobe PDF, and place them in a network location available to all users.That way, you’ll build an electronic library of training materials for those who may have missed a session.
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 77
Method 5: Learning by the school of hard knocks Unfortunately, this method is still the most prevalent in the CAD world. Typically, this type of training puts a user in a situation in which they don’t know what they’re doing—you turn them loose to figure out what to do. Although users do learn in this scenario, it’s the least efficient training method because in order to learn, the user has to ask a co-worker or the CAD manager for help. This results in an interruption in productivity for both people. Doesn’t it make sense to train people by showing them the right way to do things rather than turning them loose and hoping they’ll figure it out? I mention this method because it’s so prevalent, yet few people stop to think about the wasted productivity it causes. No matter how many users you have, and no matter what their learning styles are, the school of hard knocks is the least effective way to teach anybody anything.
Sorting Out the Methods
Many users who aren’t self learners If you have a relatively high number of users who seem to need classroom instruction to understand what’s being taught, you should use the traditional classroom methodology. Doing so allows you to lead users through an aggressive training program on a fixed timeline, thus forcing users who don’t self-learn to absorb the material presented. Smaller groups of those who self learn fairly well If you have smaller groups of users who learn a bit more on their own but still need interaction and a classic training environment, consider leading your own shorter-format courses. I’ve found lunch-and-learn style training programs to be effective in these environments because you have an instructor-led training method presented in short segments. Highly motivated self learners or small offices If you have users who are self-directed, or if you have a small staff and therefore can’t realize the economies of training many users at once, look at more computer-based training or one-on-one tutelage. Now that you have some guidelines for what methods work in what environments, I encourage you to map out the best training methods for your users, decide who will present the training (you or a professional trainer), and get a preliminary training schedule in place. Taking these steps will help optimize the training process, deliver training to your users in the manner best for them, and minimize the time demands on you.
77 ■ TRAINING METHODOLOGY
If you put all these methods together, you’ll see a mixed palette of ways that you can deal with user training. I encourage you to think about your user base from a standpoint of how many users you have, how they seem to learn best, and how self-directed they are. Having put in some thought, you can draw conclusions about the best methodologies. Here are a few brief examples so you can get a feel for what I mean:
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 78
Building a Training Plan
Task Assigned
Everything from start to finish is perceived as a single process
Task Trained Task Assigned
Task Completed
Best Feature Usage
Best Standards Usage
Figure 5.3 Training based on job need is directly proportional to productivity gained.
CHAPTER
5:
TRAINING, HIRING, AND MANAGING USERS ■
78
What should you teach your users? This is an excellent question that merits some real thought. After all, if you don’t plan what you’ll teach your users, you can’t be sure of achieving the productivity-boosting results your users desire and your management team desperately wants. Some CAD managers perform major training tasks like product version upgrades, new features coverage, employee training, and so on. For these managers, it becomes imperative to deliver training efficiently so they aren’t bogged down to the point that the rest of their job suffers. Other CAD managers have to perform a patchwork quilt of training that embraces coverage of standards, common company procedures, lunch-and-learn topics, and so on. It’s imperative that you figure out what your training program will consist of and what type of trainer you need to be to meet the demands. Although figuring out what you’ll train is a task in and of itself, I’ve found that the delivery of training is essentially the same no matter what the content is. Therefore, I’ll pass along tips that are helpful for everyone and highlight specifics for varying types of training environments as I go.
Identifying Training Needs Once you’ve received support for a training program, you need to develop your list of training objectives and prioritize them. How do you know what topics to train users on, and how do you prioritize those topics? The first place to look for training topics is in your e-mail inbox. Search through your e-mails, and take the time to identify what sorts of questions you’re being asked. If the number-one user question you receive is how to use your company’s external reference file (XREF) standards, then a tutorial on the proper use of XREFs should be the first training class you run. If the next most popular question is how to access a particular plotting device, that tells you what your second training class should be. Analyzing
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 79
your training needs based on questions from users is a blessing in disguise because you’re taking the time to see what confuses your users, which in turn should give you keen insight into how to improve your procedures and standards as you train. You’ll most likely notice that the training topics you compile have a close correlation to how people work with CAD tools in your environment. The question won’t be, “What is an XREF?” but rather, “How do I use XREFs on a given project to meet our CAD standards?” Note the distinction between these two questions: Your training challenge becomes teaching people how to use CAD tools in your particular environment rather than a generic usage of a given set of commands.
Connecting Training and Standards Whenever you perform any sort of training, you can best emphasize concepts by relating examples in your training program to their use in your operating environment. One powerful way to do this is to demonstrate your use of standards in all training exercises. Here are a few examples you can use: If you’re showing users how to properly attach, scale, and XCLIP an external reference in AutoCAD, make note of your company standards and use an actual XREF that users see in their daily routine.
•
If you have custom programs in your CAD environment that staff can use to ease standards usage, demonstrate those programs in training exercises.
•
If you invoke standards via startup files or automated configurations, point them out at the beginning of your training exercises.
•
In all cases, take a few minutes to explain why standards are important, and solicit user questions on standards.
The end result should be that users learn the right way to do things (via standards), why it’s important to do things the right way, and how you’re helping them to do this. You may find that a conversation about standards will start to happen between you and your users, allowing you to tap into their expertise and debug your own standards. More on that in the next section.
Task Trained
Software Skills
Standards Emphasis
Excellent Results
Seen as one continuous process
Figure 5.4 The inclusion of standards in your software training program teaches good habits from the beginning and prevents nonstandard habits from taking root.
79 ■ BUILDING A TRAINING PLAN
•
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 80
Fixing Processes/Standards (If Required) If your list of training topics or classroom experience indicates that inability to comprehend standards is the number-one cause of confusion in your company, it may be time to examine your standards. Bottom line: If it’s hard for you to train people on how to use a feature, imagine how hard it will be for users to learn that feature. You may find that embarking on a training program will give you a great opportunity to update and tweak company standards and procedures. Because your training program is supposed to raise user productivity and cause minimal intrusion on work schedules, everyone involved should support your desire to simplify work processes via training.
Delivering Your Own Training
CHAPTER
5:
TRAINING, HIRING, AND MANAGING USERS ■
80
Many CAD managers I know are pressed into delivering their own training classes. Whether on a regular basis or periodically, doing your own training requires preparation and discipline but can reward you many times over in the form of smarter, savvier users. No two CAD managers run training the same way, but good self-delivered training programs have some elements in common that are worth covering.
Prepare with Good Materials Running a training class without training materials is, in my experience, a waste of time. Because most people don’t take good notes during a class, it becomes the instructor’s responsibility to provide a handout or workbook that chronicles the training. As soon as someone walks out of a training class, the only resources they have to fall back on are their memory and the handouts you provide. Because I’ve advocated targeted training that solves your company’s specific problems, it becomes obvious that you can’t go to Borders and buy a training workbook for your company. That means you must create your own training materials. Before you panic, I’d like to give you some suggestions for creating quality handout materials in an easy manner. You don’t need anything other than your CAD application and a good word-processing tool to build your own training materials: Get the software Purchase some software tools to help compile, record, and publish your training materials. My favorite tools are Camtasia Studio and SnagIt, both from Techsmith Software (www.techsmith.com). Camtasia Studio essentially functions as an audio/ video recorder for your computer, allowing you to create your own voice-annotated video segments to use in training environments. The companion SnagIt utility provides ultimate flexibility in capturing still graphics from your screen, such as dialog boxes or cascading menus that you can then easily paste into word-processing applications. Both these tools have a free downloadable test version that you can use to gauge how well they’ll work for you.
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 81
Create some basic examples Conceptualize what you’ll be teaching, and then come up with example files you can use to illustrate/demonstrate the concept. Don’t worry about anything polished at this point; just make sure you can convey the information to your students with the example files you created. Rehearse and record Turn on Camtasia Studio, put on your headset microphone, and record your presentation as you run through your lesson just as if you were conducting a training class. If you flub up, don’t worry—keep going as if you were in a real class. I recommend taking a laptop into a conference room or working at home so you won’t have to deal with phone interruptions while recording your lessons. When you’re done, save the file so you can find it later. Create written handouts Using your recorded presentation as a guide, open your wordprocessing program and then work through your lesson, transcribing your text and capturing graphics into the open document. Don’t forget to save often! Don’t worry about spelling or polished formatting; just get the content into your word-processing document.
Delivering Training Now that you know what topics you’ll be training on, and you have your materials, you have to deploy your training program using either formal instructor-led training sessions or informal meetings like lunch-and-learn sessions. I recommend the following steps to make your training sessions go smoothly: Training Method
Learning results
Written materials
Instructor-led training
Audio/Video reinforcement
User perception of preference
Measured Objectives (Reality)
Figure 5.5 Training requires a mix of written, verbal, and video presentation techniques to achieve maximum comprehension. Keeping these three components in balance is tough but essential.
■ DELIVERING YOUR OWN TRAINING
Polish and finalize Finish your handout by spell-checking, adjusting syntax, and formatting your document to make it look good. Do several printouts, and keep adjusting the handout until you’re happy with it. Congratulations—you’re finished. As you create training materials, always strive for concise wording, illustrative screen captures, and clean layout as the most important attributes. If your materials are easy to read and visually rich, people will look forward to attending your training.
81
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 82
Prepare yourself Do a private rehearsal of the key points of your training so you’ll be more on top of the details and less nervous. Even short periods of preparation time will give you a noticeably easier style of delivery when you enter the classroom. Also make sure to run through any training examples you’ll use to be sure they work. Nothing is more embarrassing than leading a training class with exercises that don’t work for the user. Make going through your training exercises part of your classroom preparation. Keep it brief Allocate the time you’ll need to train any given topic, and allow only a short period of time for questions. In cases like lunch-and-learns, you’ll be restricted to a known period of time; but in other cases, it’s key to avoid the “never-ending training session” where questions abound and you can’t escape the training room.
CHAPTER
5:
TRAINING, HIRING, AND MANAGING USERS ■
82
Use a good projector I’ve learned there’s no way to train without showing people what you’re doing. A picture is worth a thousand words, and a good data projector with good resolution and brightness is the only way to go. By showing the user the exact sequence of steps in the exact CAD software they’ll be using, they’ll see what they should be doing rather than interpreting those steps from a book. Don’t own a projector? Buy one! Look at the money you’re saving your company on training classes—that alone should foot the bill. Have your materials ready Don’t start training until you have the materials copied, bound, and ready, and the software you’ll be teaching users about installed. Give a handout to each user as they enter the room, and take the opportunity to welcome them to the training. Insist on timeliness Set a starting time, and stick to it. Late arrivers should be expected to make up for lost time on their own. Set the tone that training is valuable and so is your time as the instructor. Have their undivided attention Insist on cell phones off, IM clients off, no checking e-mail, and so on. If a student wants to surf eBay or IM their colleagues, why are they in class in the first place? Again, set the tone that training is time well spent before you start your lesson. Have a sign-in sheet This documents who was there and who wasn’t. It also makes it easy to spot those who say they want training but don’t show up for it. You’ll also be able to demonstrate to your management that people are coming to your training sessions. Have an evaluation sheet This way, you know how you did, how you can get better, and who stayed to the end of class! You can make your own evaluation sheet any way you like, but ask the following questions at minimum: What was most helpful to you? What topics could be covered better?
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 83
What topics could be added to make the class better? Were the learning materials helpful? If not, why? What can the instructor do to run the class better? By focusing on what can be done better, you’ll get valuable feedback that you can use to revise course materials, plan for the next class more thoroughly, and become a better instructor. Record what you do As long as you’re doing an instructor-led training session, why not record your training and make it available later to those who missed class, new employees, or those who want a refresher course? Using a utility like Camtasia Studio or connecting a video/audio line out from your computer to a DVD/hard disk recorder makes recording simple. The clear advantage of video capture is that it can be burned to DVD or placed on your network so users can replay it whenever they want. I’ve used Camtasia Studio with great success over the years to create audio/video files that can be played using Windows Media Player.
Recycling Training for Maximum Effect Now that you’ve completed your training session, be sure you get maximum value from your effort by utilizing some of the following ideas: Organize your recordings Take all the training recording sessions you made and burn a copy to several DVDs as well as placing electronic forms on your networks that can be replayed in the future. Making these resources available will cut down on follow-up questions and will be invaluable in training new employees at a future date. Archive materials to your training library Make copies of all handouts, course materials, electronic reference materials, and so on, and locate them in your office for checkout to any staff member who wants them. Providing materials for motivated self learners will gain you a better staff with almost zero further effort on your part. Pay attention to class evaluations Take time to read through the student evaluations now that you’ve had some time to reflect on the training you’ve performed. Sometimes, another quick read exposes ideas for improving your future training sessions. You never know: You can get great ideas from people if you take the time to think about what they tell you. I know full well that being responsible for training CAD users is no easy task. And when you add the extra burden of developing materials and delivering the training yourself, the task becomes even more complex. It’s my hope that by utilizing some of
83 ■ DELIVERING YOUR OWN TRAINING
Do a wrap-up write-up After your training is complete, summarize how it went, and forward a copy to your manager. This is a small bit of self promotion that you need to do so management knows what you’ve accomplished.
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 84
the techniques I’ve listed combined with your own custom handouts and video captures, you’ll be able to meet the challenge head-on and achieve professional results with minimum incremental effort. If you deliver your own training, perform your training based on delivering benefit to your company, and catalog your training work for maximum recycling and reuse, you’ll do a great job. And as an added bonus, if you follow these metrics, you should have a much easier time getting the respect and credit you deserve for undertaking a tough job.
Hiring and Testing Staff
CHAPTER
5:
TRAINING, HIRING, AND MANAGING USERS ■
84
I’m sure many of you have had to manage people you didn’t hire. I’m equally sure that most of you have had to manage somebody who wasn’t well qualified from a CAD standpoint. It’s obvious that you spend more time supporting, teaching, and coddling a bad hire than a good hire, right? And in the case where a bad hire has to be released or ultimately fired, everyone can see how much time, effort, and money that cost the company, right?
Figure 5.6 How do you know whether a prospective candidate actually knows what they say they know?
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 85
Your challenge is to take these obvious truths to your management team and craft an argument for your involvement in the interviewing and hiring process. I recommend using the following strategies to start the conversation: Emphasize bad-hire horror stories from the past Recall the people who were not productive, had to be let go, or misrepresented themselves during the interview process. Make the argument that if the interviewing process were more technically centered, such errors would be caught prior to the individual’s hiring. Equate bad hiring with needless support Illustrate how every hour you spend supporting a bad hire is a wasted hour for you plus a nonproductive hour for the bad hire. When your company starts to understand how much money they’re losing by supporting bad hires, they’ll see the value in preventing those bad hires. Offer to fix the problem Now that your management team understands the problem, offer to fix it by revamping the interviewing and hiring process. You can use a combination of your own ideas and those presented in this chapter to form a plan that prevents bad hires from happening.
The hiring process usually starts with an advertisement in a print publication or on a web site. Make sure any advertising you do emphasizes that all candidates will be screened for CAD competency via multiple-choice and practical testing (more on this shortly). By stating clearly that anyone who applies will be evaluated, you send a strong signal to those who would misrepresent their skill set, thus avoiding needless interviewing of bad candidates. The following sections describe the metrics you can use when testing candidates.
Note:
Be sure to get your ad approved by your human resources department. Policies for job-candidate evaluation and testing vary in different countries and municipalities.
Testing by Multiple Choice First, deploy a multiple-choice testing platform to quickly assess basic competency. The purpose of a multiple-choice test is to cull the pretenders from those with real knowledge and cut them out of the interview process immediately. You may even want to position the multiple-choice test as a qualifier for a more in-depth interview, thus saving you the time of interviewing those who do poorly.
Note:
For more information on multiple-choice testing, see the “Deploying a Test”section in Chapter 2.
■ H I R I N G A N D T E S T I N G S TA F F
Avoiding Bad Hires
85
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 86
Testing by practical example Candidates who survive the multiple-choice test may now be tested for drawing proficiency. Use a real-world problem the user would encounter in your work environment as the basis for your test. You can then use your typical task to craft a test that gives the candidate a short but challenging project to complete. Creating the practical drawing example will require time and thought but will be well worth your effort later, so take the time to do a good job. Be sure to include the following components at minimum: An itemized task list The candidate should know exactly what the task is. If objects need to be on certain layers, or certain text or object styles need to be used, make sure you list the specifics in a clear and concise manner. Prints of the completed task The candidate should be able to see what the result should look like. This is critically important because CAD users tend to be more visually oriented than text oriented.
CHAPTER
5:
TRAINING, HIRING, AND MANAGING USERS ■
86
Have a test machine with standard software ready to go This way, the candidate can work on the standard version of whatever your CAD software platform is without worrying about any tweaks or changes you may have made. If you have a highly customized CAD environment, take some time to orient the candidate so they aren’t confused before they start. Include scaling and geometry concepts in the task Make sure the candidate can perform scale-oriented tasks like attaching XREFs, combining files to common origin points, and so on. The point is to be sure the candidate understands what they’re doing. Test for plotting competency My experience shows that more time is wasted supporting users who don’t know how to plot than any other single task. Verify plotting competency by including a requirement to output a certain view or drawing on a set sheet size with a specific scale. If somebody can’t plot now, it’ll mean trouble later!
Grading the Practical Example Test When you give the practical drawing test to candidates, I recommend using a timing device so the user knows that they’re being evaluated for time to completion. I believe that timing candidates shows who functions well under pressure and, more important, who doesn’t. Some people say I’m cruel for introducing even more pressure into the job interview process, but I’ve found that time to completion is a important part of ranking candidates. I also recommend recording the test using a video-capture utility like Camtasia Studio so you can replay the user’s test session later.
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 87
To evaluate the results of your practical drawing test, use the following metrics: Check for accuracy Was everything done in accordance with the task list? Were objects drawn to scale and to dimensions? Was the plotting output correct? Assign an accuracy score based on how many parts of the task the user completed correctly. For AutoCAD, use Undo In AutoCAD environments, you can go backward through the drawing process using the Undo function to see how the candidate created the drawing. It’s amazing what you can learn about an AutoCAD user this way. Review the video capture of the exam By watching the candidate’s approach, you’ll learn a lot about how they work. For non-AutoCAD platforms, this is the only way I’ve found to evaluate how the user performed.
Note:
For all topics referenced in this section, it’s a good idea to talk with your human resources department to see if any local regulations govern the practices of employee testing or video recording. 87
Now that you’ve qualified, screened, and tested the applicants using multiple-choice and practical drawing techniques, it’s time to rank your candidates and present your recommendations to your management staff. Here’s the methodology I use:
Note:
By becoming actively involved in verifying crucial skills for new hires, you save yourself headaches and deliver value to your company as well.
Accuracy first Use the accuracy score you compiled to list candidates as the first filter. Speed second If two candidates have the same accuracy score, use their time of completion as a tie breaker, and reprioritize. The purpose is to hire someone who is “good and fast” before somebody who’s simply good. Approach third In cases where accuracy and speed are tied, go back to the video recording of the practical drawing test, and use the user’s approach to the task as your decision maker. Admittedly, you’ll need to use your best judgment to see which candidate performed best. Write up your list of candidates, scores, times, completed drawings, and your personal notes about each candidate, and submit the list to management. By including this level of information, you’ll show your management team that you’re enhancing the interview process tremendously. This should go a long way toward eliminating any doubts management had about including you in the hiring process.
■ H I R I N G A N D T E S T I N G S TA F F
Prioritizing the Candidates
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 88
Selling the Value You should now be able to use some of the strategies and tools presented in this chapter to make the interviewing and hiring process easier for you and more productive for your company by helping you skip over poor candidates and prioritize those who remain.
CHAPTER
5:
TRAINING, HIRING, AND MANAGING USERS ■
88
Figure 5.7 Building stronger staffs and making better hires is a key aspect of management. Do what it takes to be involved, and watch your company’s staff get stronger.
If you’re not involved in your company’s hiring processes, now’s the time to get involved. If you’re already involved in the process, why not use some of these ideas to maximize the value of your involvement? Either way, I guarantee that management will view you in a new way as you help your company hire better staff and prevent bad hires. And who knows—you may even enjoy your job more when you’re more involved with staffing decisions.
Diagnosing Existing User Skills Now that you’ve seen how to become more involved in the diagnostic aspect of hiring, why not use the same techniques to see how well existing users are doing? To transform your hiring process into a diagnostic tool for those you already employ, use the
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 89
techniques discussed in the “Hiring and Testing Staff” section earlier in this chapter, with the following slight modifications: •
Stress that the process is all about finding areas where employees need improvement so you can help them.
•
Stress the importance/duty of all CAD users to help formulate the most effective training plan possible.
If you don’t directly measure user skills, then you’re guessing at user needs. By measuring, you know exactly where your users’ skill sets are and what you can do, via your training program, to help them.
Encouraging Self Study
Establish a training library Make a library of written and computer-based materials available for checkout to anybody who wants to borrow them. Implement a sign-out sheet so that anybody can get copies of DVDs, CDs, or books and take them home for a night or weekend. Also make these materials available during lunch breaks. This makes it easy for people to study independently even in short blocks of time. It also allows them to utilize their own off-work time so that they’re not only studying independently; they’re doing so without losing work productivity. Make it public After you implement your training library, make sure everybody sees the sign-out list. By making the sign-out list public information and keeping it visible to everyone, your users will be able to see who else has been checking out the training materials. This is a subtle hint you can use to motivate users to keep up with their peers. The aspect of peer pressure in this method seems to work wonders, especially for your more competitive power users. Offer a reward Consider providing small incentives for users who complete self-study courses. For example, anyone who takes a computer-based training DVD, goes through the entire course, and demonstrates proficiency at the end of it might qualify for a $50
89 ■ ENCOURAGING SELF STUDY
In any operating environment, no matter what your training requirements or methods are, it’s always worth your while to get users to study on their own. I call this trait of highly motivated people the motivation to self-study, and it’s something you should try to foster throughout your user base. Any training you perform will get better results and will stick in users’ minds if they’re willing to put forth some effort on their own to study materials and be more proactive, productive students in your classroom. Therefore, it’s no accident that I tend to focus the entire self-study method on getting ready for instructor-led training and making more diligent use of computer-based and written training materials. To motivate your users to study independently as much as possible, take the following courses of action:
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 90
gift card from Best Buy or a similar store. You’d be surprised how relatively small payoffs sometimes motivate people to study independently far more than any other method you can use. Put a reward out there, and watch people strive to reach the goal.
CHAPTER
5:
TRAINING, HIRING, AND MANAGING USERS ■
90
Recognize self-study efforts Consider providing customized follow-up training, led by you, in small bursts for those who have self-studied. In essence, you’ll promote this type of training as “special advanced course studies for those who have already selfstudied.” By making this course publicly available and acknowledging everyone who has taken the time to study independently and get up to speed prior to training classes, you demonstrate to the entire office which people have strived, struggled, and learned the most on their own. Again, you can use this aspect of peer pressure to influence other users to study independently. They will want to be involved in the next advanced class and be praised for working the hardest. The main aspect of all these strategies for motivating users to study independently is that the cost to you is extremely low. All you have to do as CAD manager is make some training materials available. For the price of a few hundred dollars for computer-based training and/or printed books and some time to organize any custom materials you’ve created, you can establish a check-out training library that allows people to utilize their own time to study. You can even encourage users to learn about topics you haven’t trained them on by providing a wide selection of materials to choose from. And believe me when I say your management loves that. Once you’ve made the resources available, you motivate people by providing special acknowledgments or gifts to reward them for what they’ve achieved. Treating your self-study stars to a special training track or special treatment clearly shows others that independent study affords a real career benefit. They will see that hustle and learning on their own pays off much better than sitting by and waiting for someone else to train them, and you’ll see change in users’ behavior as a result.
Making the Most of Your Power Users When you think about training and managing your CAD users, there’s one group that you probably pay less attention to than any other. I call that group your power users. These are the people who are most likely to learn a new technology on their own and the most likely to study independently. They achieve a high level of proficiency with your CAD tools with almost no action on your part. Why should we talk about how to make use of these power users when it comes to training and managing other users? Because they have a wealth of knowledge, they’re well versed in the software your company uses, and they can serve as the greatest example to everyone else within your organization about how to achieve the best possible results with your CAD tools. Power users also can help you with the training and management of other users.
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 91
Here are a couple of characteristics of power users, which you can take advantage of in the training and management arenas: Power users learn a lot on their own They’re driven by competency and the ability to be productive, so they become independent quickly and serve as a model to other users. Power users diagnose problems They don’t just point out problems; they find problems and figure out work-arounds and ways to make the CAD work flow smoother throughout your entire company. Power users are always ahead of the information curve in terms of new knowledge, new software, and reading industry-provided information. Because power users can answer the odd question or casual inquiry from another CAD user, they function as your first line of support. You probably don’t even know how much your power users help you, because the questions they answer never reach your desktop. Traits that favor CAD management 91
Independence Skills Observed
Problem solving
Communication ability
User respect (credibility)
Figure 5.8 Power users exhibit several key skills that you can use to leverage yourself.
These attributes and characteristics of power users give you, the CAD manager, an opportunity to do your job more effectively. Consider the following possible uses of power user talent: Pick their brains If power users study independently and figure out new technology on their own, ask them how they do it. Ask them what resources they use. Ask them what sort of information they recommend placing in your training library so that other users can follow their example and self-study more efficiently. In fact, why not recruit your power users to run the training library and provide mentoring to other users who are interested in learning more and becoming more self-sufficient? The power user is the perfect role model to hold forward for self-study, so why not ask them?
■ MAKING THE MOST OF YOUR POWER USERS
Power Users
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 92
Tap into their skills In identifying problems or finding new and creative ways to deal with workplace CAD problems, power users have already worked out the solutions. Why not recruit them to help you formulate your training handouts and procedures documents? Frequently, you’ll find that solutions power users have come up with can form the basis for your short-format training courses. By tapping into this reservoir of user knowledge, you can accomplish your job more easily and know that the topics you’re training other users on have been battle-tested and proven by the power users you’ve recruited to help you perform the training. Let them teach others If power users are always out in front of the learning curve finding neat creative resources on the Internet or in CAD publications, ask them if they would consider running some training or orientation classes for other users. This will not only free up your time but also more fully realize the potential of your power users. To run an effective training program, you should use a variety of different trainers. Your users can probably benefit from gaining a power-user perspective.
CHAPTER
5:
TRAINING, HIRING, AND MANAGING USERS ■
92
Make them junior CAD managers More on this valuable technique in the next section. Tapping into your power users’ abilities is a win-win scenario for everyone. A lot of power users would love to be running training classes and doing some of the CAD management things that you typically do—becoming more involved in the training and management aspect of what’s going on in your company can be viewed as a promotion or at least a step up. This is tremendously motivational for your power users.
Creating Junior CAD Managers In the prior section, I talked about utilizing your power users more effectively. I recommend bringing your power users almost up to the level of a junior CAD manager. When you recruit power users to help you perform tasks like leading training classes, producing training handouts, or documenting creative new procedures they’ve found to generate better productivity around your workplace, you’re essentially growing a variety of junior CAD managers to assist you. I heartily encourage this approach. The main benefits I see for cultivating junior CAD managers are as follows: Smart people can help you more It’s never bad to have more intelligent people around you, helping you do your job. Power users can act as a diagnostic tool The more you educate your power users up to a CAD manager level, the more they’ll help you find mistakes and problems in your department. More important, they can help you solve the problems they find. In a real sense, two heads (or three or even four) are better than one. How else can you delegate? The only way you can achieve more time to do highervalue tasks for your company is to delegate lower-value tasks. By offloading repetitive tasks to a power user, you’re simultaneously cross-training an assistant, thus freeing up more of your time.
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 93
Now that you understand the benefits of building junior CAD managers, how do you do so? The approach to cultivating junior CAD managers is different for everyone, but I’ve found some basic, common steps that are effective in most cases:
1.
Identify tasks that are of lower value to you.
2.
Identify which of those tasks would be easiest to delegate.
3.
Select a task for delegation.
4.
Select a power user who would like to take over that task.
5.
Train the power user to assume the delegated task.
6.
Reinforce the training until the power user becomes independent and proficient at performing the task.
7.
Go back to step 3, and repeat the process as often as you can.
8.
Periodically repeat steps 1 and 2 to make sure you’re continually judging which tasks are lower value for you so you can adjust your delegation strategy.
Analyze Tasks
Select task to Delegate
Assign task to Power User
Verify Power User Competency
Train Power User
Repeat as often as possible
Figure 5.9 Create a task-delegation mechanism that identifies opportunities for others to learn more while removing low value tasks, and both parties win.
Handling Renegade Users One of the sad realities of training and managing people is that not everyone will behave as they should. It’s also certain that not everyone will be as motivated as you’d like them to be or follow standards as well as you might hope. Therefore, handling renegade users is an inevitable part of the training and user-management equation. Although I’ve never found a perfect method for dealing with these renegade users, I’ve discovered some general tricks and tips that work fairly well over time.
93 ■ HANDLING RENEGADE USERS
If you follow this procedure, over time you’ll find that you spend more time figuring out better ways to work while the lower-value tasks involved in keeping the place running are delegated to your new pool of junior CAD managers.
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 94
Before I list the methods to use, I’ll point out that I’m covering this topic last for a reason: Everything I’ve recommended regarding training has been presented in such a way as to minimize the renegade user component in the first place. If you’re skipping forward to this section in the book to find a magic answer for dealing with renegade users, you should go back and read the chapter from the beginning. The techniques I present here are for handling those who haven’t responded to any of the other techniques I’ve discussed.
CHAPTER
5:
TRAINING, HIRING, AND MANAGING USERS ■
94
Figure 5.10 Renegade users are testing your authority and lowering productivity as they create nonstandard work outcomes. When they’re allowed to deviate, your CAD-management plan falls victim.
Your renegade users probably fall into one of the following categories: The “You can’t tell me anything” user These operators won’t follow standards practices or procedures. They’re typically motivated by the concept that they have a better way to do it or that they can’t be bothered with the standards or procedures you’re requesting them to work with. The most effective way to deal with these users is to align them with a power user or mentor who forces the user to confront different work methods and ideas. Frequently, by aligning those users who won’t follow standards or procedures with a power user who is more knowledgeable than they are, they will come to realize that
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 95
they don’t know as much as they thought they did and that perhaps the standards and procedures you have in place are there for a reason. Renegade users who don’t respond to this tactic probably fall into the next category. The “I don’t want to; I don’t have to” user These obstinate users won’t follow instructions no matter what. The only effective way to deal with them is to make management, the power users around you, and other users aware of the users’ stubbornness and then use positive peer pressure to make these users conform. When users refuse to follow standards and procedures, they create work for everyone else. By shining the harsh light of day on this fact, you expose the renegade user as being the problem. Frequently, renegade users find every reason or excuse they can to justify why they’re not following instructions or procedures. When you reverse the dialogue by taking away the excuses and illustrating how much extra effort that person is causing everyone else, you’ll be able to utilize your entire CAD staff to focus the discussion on why the renegade is refusing to cooperate. This method will frequently bring the renegade user into alignment with little further effort.
Before you go to the user’s boss, or to anyone else in the authority chain, you must document and demonstrate the user’s noncompliance. You’ll have to have examples of cases in which they haven’t followed standards; some sample drawings may be illustrative. Demonstrate that you’ve tried to speak to this user or mentor this user and the behavior still hasn’t ceased. Also, tell the renegade user in no uncertain terms that you’re now willing to move the issue up to management and that the user has one last chance to get in compliance before you get the boss involved. Frequently, this low level of confrontation will convince the renegade user how serious you are and will remedy the situation. But if it doesn’t, you must take the problem to management. If you don’t follow through, you’ll have less credibility the next time. None of these profiles or solutions are all-inclusive. There are probably a million variations of renegade or nonstandard user behaviors that you may encounter, but the strategies I’ve offered should allow you to attack the most common problems and achieve solutions relatively quickly. Make no mistake: The way you handle problem users has as much to do with your success as how you handle your best users, and maybe more!
■ HANDLING RENEGADE USERS
The “You’re not my boss” user The third category of renegade user is someone who won’t do things the CAD manager tells them to, but will do something if another boss tells them to. In this case, the coping strategy that works is to realize what the problem is and not fight it. If this renegade user won’t follow your instructions or listen to other power users, then it’s time to admit it and get the management chain involved in order to bring the renegade into line.
95
16531c05.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 96
Summary The business of managing, training, and hiring people is the most variable task the CAD manager faces precisely because every one of your users is different. I hope you’ll be able to cull through the techniques presented in this chapter and tailor them to your specific environment and user base. There’s no shortcut for managing people. It requires a lot of thought and effort. And every time you get the process right, something like new projects, personnel turnover, or business changes will shake the process up again. Keep at it, keep thinking, keep adapting, and always remember that when your people are productive, so are you!
CHAPTER
5:
TRAINING, HIRING, AND MANAGING USERS ■
96
16531c06.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 97
Managing Software (and Change) Many CAD managers I’ve talked to don’t manage their software as a business or financial asset; rather, they view software as something they use. Although viewing software as a tool of the trade is understandable, the reality is that software is engineering, architecture, and product design gets done. Therefore software is a key financial asset that CAD managers should manage with vigor. Even if you don’t want to worry about software budgets or accounting lingo, you still have to make sure you’re planning for the software you’ll
6
need in the future. Software changes over time, so you need to manage the process of software change. In this chapter, I’ll present the tips, tricks, and methods I’ve used to manage software, and the change it brings, over the years.
97 ■ M A N A G I N G S O F T WA R E ( A N D C H A N G E )
an increasingly expensive and pivotal part of how
16531c06.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 98
Changing Methods First things first. When you budget for software, be it new software or upgraded software, the only reason you do so is that you expect better software in return for the money you spend. If you haven’t thought about software this way before, I can guarantee that your management does—so it behooves you to consider this perspective. When you get a new software package, whether on subscription or not, one of the following things must be true in order for you to undertake the time and expense of purchasing and installing it: Existing work tasks should get easier.
•
Old bugs should be fixed to allow better/faster operation.
•
New features should allow you to design better/faster.
•
New methods (like transitioning from 2D to 3D design) should create radically more efficient design processes.
The interesting point about all these factors is that they will change how your users work with their software. In essence, the new software you install will force people to learn new things and will jolt them out of their comfort zone. The conclusion I draw is that managing software is really about managing changes in how you design and use software. And managing that change is never easy.
CHAPTER
6:
M A N A G I N G S O F T WA R E ( A N D C H A N G E ) ■
98
•
Figure 6.1 Change people’s software, and you change how they work.They may not like the change. How will you manage the change process?
16531c06.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 99
Also note that this change has to happen quickly in order for it to make financial sense. You not only have to change how people work, but you must do so quickly and with an accountant looking over your shoulder. No wonder getting new software installed is so hard! Throughout this chapter, I’ll make references to how wrenching software change can be from the perspective of users (training), senior management (cost and return), and the CAD manager (juggling all the factors). I’ve presented this section on change first in hopes that you’ll keep it in mind as you read.
Note:
Installing software is easy. Changing how people use software is hard.
Understanding Software Licensing
It’s Not Really Your Software The perception that you purchase software and elect to upgrade it every so often was first brought to bear with early PC software titles like dBase, WordStar, and Lotus 1-2-3. In those days, we did purchase our software with perpetual rights, and upgrades were offered periodically by the software manufacturers. The software manufacturers sold us software and hoped that we’d upgrade as new features were created and released. In the early years, when new features abounded and bug fixes were fast and furious, upgrading was a no-brainer. Methods have changed, and now a software purchase isn’t a purchase at all but rather a complex leasing arrangement. Read through the licensing terms of almost any piece of software, and you’ll see that the software remains the property of the software company; you have merely acquired the right to use it under the software company’s list of conditions.
99 ■ U N D E R S TA N D I N G S O F T WA R E L I C E N S I N G
CAD software is expensive, and it plays a key role in how your company functions, so it makes good business sense to do your homework and squeeze every bit of cost performance you can from your software. But before we talk about how to stretch your software purchasing dollars, you need to understand how software licensing works. In this section, I’ll take you through a comprehensive explanation of software licensing and what it means to your business. I’ve found that CAD managers with years of experience often don’t understand how licensing works and thus don’t know how to explain it to their management teams. Take a while to read this section, and make sure you understand it before moving on.
16531c06.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 100
The first thing companies must be aware of is that because the software isn’t yours, it isn’t an asset that has value: It’s money spent that can’t be recovered in any way other than utility usage of the software product.
It’s Really a Lease Because acquiring a software license doesn’t give you ownership of any tangible asset, you’re leasing (a glorified word for renting) the software. To drive home the point of how software licensing is like a lease from a financial standpoint, let’s consider an example of leasing a car and compare it to a CAD software license. You may be surprised to learn that the software you thought you owned is really yours to use under a highly restrictive lease.
CHAPTER
6:
M A N A G I N G S O F T WA R E ( A N D C H A N G E ) ■
100
Figure 6.2 You can usually find the terms of your end user software agreement (EULA) under the Help > About menu of most CAD applications.The EULA spells out what you can and can’t do with your software.
A Leasing Analogy When you lease a car, the following lease components are almost always present: •
A lease inception fee (down payment) is collected that is usually equal to about one year of lease payments.
•
A payment schedule is agreed to (typically monthly) for a set duration of the lease term (usually several years at minimum).
•
A maximum usage rate is agreed to (a certain number of total miles on the car) over the life of the lease.
•
A buyout price is agreed to so that at the termination of the lease, you may elect to purchase the car for the buyout price if you choose.
Worth noting is that almost all car leases give you the power of ownership at the end of the lease so that you can choose to purchase the car, trade it as collateral for another car, or turn the car back in lieu of paying the buyout price. In all cases, the
16531c06.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 101
option of how to transfer ownership of the car at the end of the lease is up to you, the lessee. During the span of the lease, how you use the car is up to you as long as you meet the financial terms at the end of the lease. The car company won’t tell you how to drive the car, who you can drive in the car, or where you can take the car. In general, a car lease is a financial agreement that serves the interests of both parties and protects the rights of both parties. Now, let’s contrast a software license to the car lease example to see just how restrictive the software license is.
How Software Compares
Licensing Limitations As you examine the software license agreement for your CAD software, you’ll likely find a number of other usage restrictions. To make sure you don’t inadvertently violate your license agreement, I highly encourage you to read your EULA. I’ll highlight some items you should evaluate carefully: Geographic usage restrictions Think you can use your U.S./Canadian software in another country? You may not be able to. Because software companies don’t want their software taken to countries where it can be pirated without any chance of prosecution, their license agreements often preclude you from using their software in other countries. We have non-enforcement of patent and intellectual property rights in the Far East, specifically China, to thank for these sorts of restrictions.
101 ■ U N D E R S TA N D I N G S O F T WA R E L I C E N S I N G
A software license begins with a lump-sum fee like the car lease, although software inception fees are usually equal to about five years of lease payments (called subscription or support in the software business) rather than a single year of payments as is customary with a car. Whether you decide to pay for the subscription service is up to you in theory; but in reality, the pricing policy of most software vendors now makes it punitively expensive not to do so, because the software company can make your license non-upgradeable at any time they choose. For example, Autodesk’s present policy states that software older than three releases is considered old enough to be non-upgradeable unless you pay a renewal fee that is much higher than paying the software subscription in the first place. So, although software subscriptions in the CAD business are said to be optional, the financial reality is that they aren’t, unless you want to risk letting your software licenses lapse. Software licenses are said to be perpetual in that as long as you pay the subscription fee to keep your license current, you can retain the software forever. However, close examination of the software license agreement shows that the software company is under no requirement to keep the software in production or even to deliver timely updates in exchange for the subscription fees you pay. There is no “end of lease,” so there is no buyout option.
16531c06.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 102
Software audits Your license may grant the software company certain rights to audit your compliance with their usage terms by specifying the ability to search company property or by making you subject to the site visit and license auditing terms of the Business Software Alliance (BSA), which many CAD software developers are members of (along with Adobe, Intuit, and Microsoft). Transfer of license Think you’ll be able to move a software license to a sister company or subsidiary in case bankruptcy or corporate reorganization requires it? Your software license may preclude such transfers and almost always requires written permission from the software vendor.
CHAPTER
6:
M A N A G I N G S O F T WA R E ( A N D C H A N G E ) ■
102
Resale of license Think you can put an old copy of AutoCAD on eBay and sell it? Every EULA I’ve seen specifically precludes resale of your software license. Remember, you don’t own your software; you’re just leasing the right to use it. And because leasing terms are set by the software company, they can preclude you from selling your license. When you finish reading your software EULA terms and think about the stream of money your company pays to retain a software license, you have to conclude that software licenses are extremely restrictive rental agreements with few protections for you, the customer.
Purchasing Software What the lawyers take away from us in the form of restrictive software licensing documents, technology can partially restore via licensing technology. With reliable networks, Internet purchase validation, and remote activation technology, you can make a smaller number of software licenses serve more people and thus keep costs down. It’s important to note that each software vendor has their own preferred licensing schemas and enforcement mechanisms, so you’ll need to do your homework for each software vendor you purchase from. The key vocabulary words to examine in licensing schemas vary from manufacturer to manufacturer but can generally be described as follows: Standalone, activated license A standalone, activated license is a licensing schema for a single copy of software that is restricted to use on one computer. After installation, the software is activated, typically via the Internet, and the software’s serial number is associated to machine biometrics like the operating system serial number or even the hard drive’s formatted volume serial number, which is then tracked. The activated license schema, currently utilized by manufacturers like Adobe, Autodesk, Intuit, Microsoft, and Symantec, has made it impossible for the CAD manager to install a single copy of software on multiple machines, because the activation technology allows only a metered number of activations to be performed. There was substantial resistance to activated license schemas when Intuit and Microsoft started the trend, but activation technology is now standard throughout the industry.
16531c06.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 103
CAD Workstation
CAD Workstation
Network Server
CAD Workstation
CAD Workstation
Figure 6.3 Simple networks like the one shown here can use standalone, multi-seat, or even network licensing mechanisms with equal ease. Cost and ease of administration are the deciding factors.
Autodesk, the maker of AutoCAD, introduced this hybrid combination of a single serial number with multiple product activation keys, and the practice is now becoming more common for companies that use large numbers of CAD licenses. With a multiseat standalone license, the CAD manager can install the same software serial number via a network and activate it on any number of machines without messing with network license manager utilities.
Note:
For CAD managers with many full-time CAD users, this method gets you back to the good old days of easily installing a single software package over multiple machines.
Named user network This installation method uses network-based tracking components that require a copy of software to be purchased for every user on the network. Each user who ever logs in to the software is a billable seat of software.
Note:
Named user licensing isn’t as common in the PC CAD world but is common for Product Lifecycle Management (PLM) and Engineering Data Management (EDM) software tools.This is the least cost-effective way to deploy software because it has all the costs of standalone with all the hassles of network licensing utilities.
103 ■ P U R C H A S I N G S O F T WA R E
Multi-seat standalone A multi-seat standalone license is a licensing schema for a single serial number of software that can be used on multiple machines as dictated by the number of licenses purchased. After installation, the software is activated, typically via the Internet, and the software’s number of available licenses is lowered by one.
16531c06.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 104
Concurrent/floating local network This type of network-aware installation tracks the number of users simultaneously logged in to the system. The global number of users of the software is irrelevant; only the maximum number logged in at any given time is billable. This is the most cost-effective mode of licensing for most corporate users.
Note:
For CAD managers with many casual CAD users, the concurrent network licensing schema offers real cost benefits, because licenses can be shared. Although some network overhead is introduced, the cost benefits typically outweigh the hassle.
CHAPTER
6:
M A N A G I N G S O F T WA R E ( A N D C H A N G E ) ■
104
Concurrent/floating WAN network This approach is essentially the same as the local network option but is enabled to work across wide area networks (WANs) so that licenses can be shared by offices in different buildings, cities, or even countries in some cases. Most software products that support WAN network deployment require licensing software to be installed on multiple servers and, as such, are more IT intensive than other licensing options. If the economy of sharing licenses between multiple locations balances the IT overhead, this licensing option can be a great alternative.
Note:
Not all software products support this type of architecture, and several CAD products I’ve received specifically prohibit such license sharing.Read the fine print on the EULA of any software you plan to purchase.
License borrowing An increasingly common adjunct to concurrent network schemas, a license-borrowing utility allows you to take a shared license out of the concurrent pool and place it onto a single workstation or mobile computer for dedicated use. Autodesk network licenses, which use Flexible License Management (FLEXlm) technology from Macrovision, offer license borrowing.
Figure 6.4 WANs can take advantage of wide area network licensing and can enable laptop or relocating users via license-borrowing techniques.
16531c06.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 105
Informing Management Now that you have a working knowledge of how software licensing works and how to get the most for your licensing dollar, be sure to discuss these issues with your management team. It’s been my experience that senior management teams are unaware of how little control they have over corporate software licensing terms and costs. None of us, CAD managers included, can continue to be ignorant of software licensing issues. I believe CAD managers will have to become much more aware of software pricing policies and EULA terms in order to keep management aware of the true cost of software leasing and to ensure that usage terms aren’t violated. Be prepared to justify software purchases and upgrades not only on features and ease-of-use metrics but also in terms of restrictive licensing and financial conditions.
Performing Upgrades
Understanding the True Cost The root of any upgrade decision should be an analysis of the relative costs and benefits involved. As a CAD manager, I find it easy to get caught up in the coolness of a new release, but I’ve learned to force myself to be more business focused about the upgrade decision. I’ve also learned that what I think of as upgrade costs and what upper management thinks can be two very different things. For the sake of making sure you’re on the same page with management, I’d like to run through a listing of the costs associated with a typical upgrade and give you some brief background on each: Software cost This cost can be either an annualized subscription or a one-time upgrade fee. Either way, you need to account for the actual cost of procuring the upgraded software. CAD management and IT This is the amount of time you and your information technology (IT) department will spend investigating, implementing, and supporting the
105 ■ PERFORMING UPGRADES
In my early days as a CAD manager, I remember the Christmas-morning feel of getting the latest AutoCAD release and seeing how fast I could get it installed. Rapid upgrading was justified in the old days when CAD programs experienced massively upgraded feature sets on a 12- to 24-month basis. These days, the metrics of upgrading are more complex, and the enhancements to the software are much more subtle. Consequently, the most common question I’m asked when a major software package comes out is, “Should I upgrade to this version?” I can’t answer the upgrade question with a simple yes or no, but I can give you a benchmark by which you can make smart decisions on your own. What’s required is a methodology you can use to analyze the upgrade process to make a business decision about when to upgrade. Everything I’ll discuss is applicable for AutoCAD, MicroStation, SolidWorks, or any other software package you care to analyze.
16531c06.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 106
upgrade. Some companies consider this a normal part of your job; other companies don’t. Either way, I find it useful to estimate the time required. You can convert this expenditure of time to a dollar figure by using an hourly rate for the involved personnel. User training expenses Expenses here include books, tuition, in-house training sessions you have to create, and so on. This is an easy cost to miss, and it can really add up if you’re training a lot of people! Loss of user productivity This cost is something management cares a lot about. You need to be as honest as you can in tallying lost work time for each user as they train and ramp up to speed with the new software. Remember that users may not come to a halt while learning new software, but they will be less productive until they acclimate, and management will notice this lost productivity. Again, convert the loss of productive time to dollars by using the employees’ hourly rate.
CHAPTER
6:
M A N A G I N G S O F T WA R E ( A N D C H A N G E ) ■
106
Support expenses Will you need help from an external consultant or reseller? Will you have to spend a lot of otherwise billable time supporting users during the upgrade process? Will you need to spend time implementing new standards necessitated by the new software? If you answer yes to these questions, then you have to account for the expenditure. Be honest when tabulating these costs, and don’t scrimp: Few things doom an upgrade more than insufficient user support during rollout.
Computing the Benefits Once you’ve tabulated the costs associated with an upgrade, you can proceed to the identification of benefits and decide if the expenses of upgrading can be justified. Historically, these are the major areas of benefit offered by upgraded CAD systems: Increased productivity Does the upgraded software offer new benefits that your company/users can leverage to save time on a daily basis? Will you be able to get more work done with the same staff using the new software? If so, how many hours per month would you estimate that you can save or gain? Convert the time savings to a dollar basis by multiplying saved hours per year by the users’ hourly labor rate. Bug/error reduction Did any problems and/or bugs with the last software version cause your company heartburn? If so, have these problems been fixed in the latest version? Try to estimate the annual savings as outlined previously. Compatibility with collaborative partners If you work with outside vendors, customers, and so on, will the new software version help you do so? If so, try to estimate the savings you could achieve on an annual basis. You’ll have to use a gut-feel approach in this area, but it’s better to make an educated estimate than to have no idea when management asks about your assumptions.
Note:
For a detailed look at costs and ROI methodologies, see “Using ROI Metrics”in Chapter 7.
16531c06.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 107
Making the Decision You should now have a detailed list of costs and benefits that can be weighed against each other to justify (or not justify) upgrading your CAD software. By focusing on the metrics of cost and benefit, you avoid the “new software is cool” trap and focus on what management cares about—return on investment (ROI). For example, suppose your savings are computed for a full year, and the costs you’ll absorb to upgrade will also be realized in the first year. You’ll be able to compute an ROI value for the first year of the new software’s lifespan.
107 ■ PERFORMING UPGRADES
Figure 6.5 There’s no shortcut to pursuing upgrades.You need to spend time with the software, list your findings, and crunch the numbers to make a good decision.
The basic rule of determining ROI is to divide savings by cost and multiply by 100 to achieve an ROI percentage value. The ROI value for software upgrades typically has to come in at 66 percent so that the cost savings you generate cover the cost of the software upgrade in the first 18 months of use (which is, not coincidentally, generally the upgrade period observed in industry). ROI values lower than 66 percent are typically rejected, and you’ll need to wait until the next upgrade cycle to analyze the problem again. It isn’t easy to achieve a 66 percent ROI with a CAD upgrade, by the way, which explains why there are so many old CAD licenses floating around! You have to understand management’s mindset that a CAD program typically has only a 1- to 2-year lifespan and thus must be able to pay for itself quickly. It’s now your duty to present your ROI findings, good or bad, to senior management and obtain their approval before proceeding with your upgrade plans. By presenting an ROI analysis, you give full disclosure to management and insulate yourself from
16531c06.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 108
questions later, because you’ll have demonstrated your thoroughness. Your proposed CAD upgrade may or may not make it past the ROI phase, so don’t take it personally. By presenting the upgrade to management in a business-focused format, your management skills will be apparent.
Upgrade Barriers Assuming that you’ve achieved a substantial ROI, and management concurs that you should upgrade, what sorts of problems could you encounter that would derail the upgrade? This list isn’t comprehensive by any means, but it summarizes the barriers I’ve encountered most often:
CHAPTER
6:
M A N A G I N G S O F T WA R E ( A N D C H A N G E ) ■
108
Schedule crunches Is the biggest project of the year scheduled for completion during the week of your CAD upgrade? Have you scheduled your upgrade implementation without checking for major scheduling conflicts? If you answer yes to either of these questions, you’re inviting disaster. Be willing to postpone your upgrade to accommodate work schedules: I guarantee that will be your management’s priority. Staff willingness No matter how strong the case is for upgrading, you’re in for rough sledding if your CAD user base isn’t willing to come along. Make sure you communicate what will be updated, when, and what sort of training and support resources you’ll have available to ease the transition. Your goal is to make people confident that the upgrade will go smoothly and won’t negatively impact their personal workload. Lack of support resources Does management expect you to install some software and then walk away while everyone magically assimilates the new release? Does management expect you to be 100 percent billable the week after a major upgrade? If so, you’re heading for trouble. If you’ve followed my advice and budgeted for proper support, management should see what an important component of the upgrade process it is. If management persists in believing that you can upgrade without providing support, I suggest you postpone the upgrade until you can make them see otherwise. Lack of budget Does management want you to proceed with an upgrade without investing in the process? If so, you’re again heading for trouble. Software won’t install itself, and it’s important that you have the right resources so users can be productive. Stick to your guns, postpone the upgrade if you must, but don’t upgrade unless the budget/resources are there for you to be successful. Lack of training After buying software, ensuring support, and gaining management approval for upgrades, are you being pressured to cut out or cut short user training? If so, you need to go on red-alert status. Nothing will reduce user productivity more than turning untrained users loose on new software without training. Cutting training doesn’t save money: It costs money, because the errors and support problems stack up. If training becomes a cost-cutting issue in your upgrade process, take the time to make management understand what’s at stake, and don’t proceed until they do.
16531c06.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 109
Training Notes When you’re upgrading existing software, you may encounter the belief that training isn’t necessary because “we’re only talking about an upgrade.” I understand how nonCAD users who breeze though a Microsoft Word or Excel upgrade can think this, so I want to spend a moment clarifying my approach to training for upgraded CAD software versions. When I made the case for an upgrade, I said that there had to be enough enhancements, changes, and new features to make the software pay for itself in a short period of time. This statement points out three brutal truths: •
An upgrade that is worth doing will change how people work.
•
An upgrade that changes how people work will likely change standards.
•
An upgrade that is worth doing has to be done fast.
Note:
For much more information on training, see Chapter 5.
Closing Thoughts I’ve used the techniques presented in this section to guide me through upgrade scenarios since my first CAD management job in 1989, and they haven’t failed me yet. If you analyze a CAD upgrade based on what it can do for your company and keep the costs down enough to yield a good ROI value, you’ll be well served when you upgrade. If you do upgrade, take care to avoid the upgrade barriers I’ve outlined and focus on the economic benefits (via ROI methods), and your upgrade process should be both profitable and smooth. As you quantify the costs, benefits, and barriers of a CAD upgrade, you’ll find that you’ll adopt a managerial mindset that can advance your career more than you ever expected.
109 ■ PERFORMING UPGRADES
The only way I know to get people to change how they do their job in a short period of time is to provide intensely focused, fast-paced training. To not do so extends the period of time the users will flounder and enhances the possibility that users won’t use the time-saving new features you’ve found. In cases where standards need to be modified to reflect new work methods, you can effect the change more easily by including it in your training. Training = Productivity. Training = Standards Compliance. Period.
16531c06.qxd
3/19/07
1:42 PM
Page 110
Easing the Transition So far, everything I’ve covered talks about planning for software implementation; but when the time comes, you’ll need all the help you can get juggling technical issues and user questions. During implementation, it someti